id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06662v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06662v2 | EaSyGuide : ESG Issue Identification Framework leveraging Abilities of Generative Large Language Models | 2023-06-11T12:25:02 | 2023-06-13T13:47:15 | Hanwool Lee, Jonghyun Choi, Sohyeon Kwon, Sungbum Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents our participation in the FinNLP-2023 shared task on
multi-lingual environmental, social, and corporate governance issue
identification (ML-ESG). The task's objective is to classify news articles
based on the 35 ESG key issues defined by the MSCI ESG rating guidelines. Our
approach focuses on the English and French subtasks, employing the CerebrasGPT,
OPT, and Pythia models, along with the zero-shot and GPT3Mix Augmentation
techniques. We utilize various encoder models, such as RoBERTa, DeBERTa, and
FinBERT, subjecting them to knowledge distillation and additional training.
Our approach yielded exceptional results, securing the first position in the
English text subtask with F1-score 0.69 and the second position in the French
text subtask with F1-score 0.78. These outcomes underscore the effectiveness of
our methodology in identifying ESG issues in news articles across different
languages. Our findings contribute to the exploration of ESG topics and
highlight the potential of leveraging advanced language models for ESG issue
identification. | [
-0.4268604815,
-1.0154979229,
0.5656374693,
0.2512182593,
-0.2227375656,
0.2837972343,
-0.2731952369,
-0.7521820664,
0.2346012741,
0.4392148256,
-0.6572775841,
-0.6216735244,
-0.9072146416,
0.1276391596,
-0.4876271188,
1.2791601419,
0.0550374202,
0.1314114928,
-0.1080944687,
0.0466805175,
-0.0681566074,
-0.4757685065,
-0.9516904354,
0.0080393218,
0.6440894008,
0.2621561885,
0.0334139131,
0.2953067422,
0.467618674,
0.2410629094,
-0.6084489226,
0.2417305857,
-0.4394493699,
-0.1483222246,
0.0095945215,
-0.0456549115,
-0.1746903956,
-0.1193537489,
0.5723198652,
0.3621994257,
-0.278252095,
0.3947306871,
0.3358937204,
0.6156882644,
-0.4012601972,
0.3926289976,
-0.7249715924,
0.2372274697,
-0.1170749664,
-0.0526981801,
-0.3343676031,
0.1813700944,
-0.01804954,
-0.6240156293,
0.2755024731,
0.0630784929,
1.1526341438,
0.0621071532,
-0.7088600397,
-0.6026840806,
-0.2396066934,
0.7777962685,
-0.494276911,
0.4467027485,
0.0428927578,
-0.0433963276,
-0.1348628849,
-0.3901832402,
-0.2019373029,
0.1161923483,
-0.0552165061,
0.3410029709,
-0.2396303713,
0.0605140477,
0.1373056024,
0.2386972755,
-0.7684144974,
0.2346104383,
-0.7649191618,
-0.2565676868,
0.6558219194,
-0.1770971864,
0.302279681,
-0.2092774063,
-0.6298239827,
0.4956875145,
-0.9595939517,
-0.1549548209,
0.921271801,
0.4372437,
-0.1766273975,
0.6115294099,
-0.1142131016,
0.5195066929,
0.1528474838,
0.2565524876,
0.3389058709,
-0.366214335,
-0.038201686,
0.1811191142,
0.4691121876,
0.4650116563,
-0.0343106501,
0.1236760989,
-0.2720927894,
-0.4230776131,
0.2164855897,
-0.5340531468,
0.0901266932,
0.3288632929,
-0.5191087127,
-0.2726871073,
0.2994146049,
-0.9473968148,
-0.6732913852,
-0.4236543179,
0.3372521698,
0.3038489819,
-0.4462955594,
0.2331812978,
-0.2389405221,
0.5405406952,
0.2479225099,
-0.7766544223,
-0.0825527906,
0.8276853561,
0.5033611059,
-0.1644334793,
-0.0716485232,
-0.3896078765,
0.2377603799,
0.1352703273,
0.7623286843,
-0.4911787808,
-0.3982952833,
0.2260112166,
0.6789543033,
-0.288995564,
-0.2942242622,
0.5965670943,
-0.4028713107,
0.4106810093,
-0.4454323351,
-0.5388062596,
-0.161969766,
0.5108322501,
-0.7787792683,
1.0865761042,
-0.3643600047,
-0.8423271775,
0.3185088038,
-0.9916402698,
-0.070089519,
0.2148354203,
-0.3148971498,
-0.5429515243,
-0.0223127119,
0.3424838185,
0.5168920159,
-0.4807666242,
0.5344932079,
-0.0914852247,
0.0477195084,
-0.3519732356,
-0.5205614567,
0.8329073191,
0.3185856044,
-0.0479058214,
0.1436852068,
-0.7772077918,
-0.2044414431,
0.0650624856,
-0.3716678023,
-0.2248179018,
0.27096802,
0.6552788019,
0.0374062806,
0.6882041693,
-0.6192398667,
-0.0066640782,
0.1492457241,
0.3186873198,
0.7366697788,
0.5082516074,
0.2282254398,
-0.0125803724,
0.7335896492,
-0.080677703,
0.2955540717,
-0.3307065964,
-0.9610825181,
-0.6522849202,
-0.170450747,
0.2874828875,
0.7448447943,
-0.3468056321,
0.3327950835,
-0.0732783005,
-0.4410318136,
-0.3254042566,
-0.148774907,
0.2015610188,
0.14298518,
0.3262137771,
0.0869649947,
-0.4216037691,
-1.1245251894,
-0.5982034802,
-0.2820012569,
-0.2143452615,
0.2938832641,
0.5601474643,
-0.0287623443,
0.6269091964,
-0.3985331953,
-0.0526025333,
-0.1787528843,
0.6413822174,
0.1596019119,
0.3064157069,
0.4793246984,
-1.2361998558,
-0.3940010369,
0.3899443448,
-0.4898656011,
-0.3130801916,
-0.0874910057,
0.186711058,
0.1550002098,
0.8159074187,
-0.3769417107,
-0.1016819701,
0.6304587722,
-0.604408443,
0.3474956453,
-0.1421498358,
0.2897337377,
-1.2074613571,
-0.0548825413,
0.525513351,
0.0998014659,
-0.6550196409,
0.2108132094,
0.1796913594,
-0.5222811103,
-0.5905655622,
0.6019214988,
-0.5026720166,
0.0833980814,
0.1908869892,
-0.1519775838,
-0.0470528044,
0.3590382338,
0.22275877,
0.2701231837,
0.4900972247,
-0.454952538,
0.2125762701,
-0.1762463003,
-0.3727295995,
0.6162762642,
-0.7244253159,
0.1006495133,
-0.536111474,
-0.0748768449,
-0.8877139688,
-0.0384179205,
0.0537146218,
-0.3468020856,
0.2842287719,
-0.4175311029,
-0.3205143213,
-0.3930933475,
-0.0378735736,
-0.0413028002,
0.1605012417,
-0.4806362391,
0.9553579092,
0.6494383812,
-0.6834913492,
-0.8383104801,
-0.5067510009,
0.0396629386,
-0.7345175147,
-0.4189394116,
0.4098213613,
0.1374169886,
-0.0503644086,
0.1697898358,
-0.1662407815,
-0.2990931571,
0.1660801321,
-0.1307377219,
0.0301982667,
-0.180168882,
0.1667870432,
0.1585952044,
-0.1784097403,
0.0195507258,
-0.0035623012,
0.0734503418,
-0.2838247716,
-0.4825924039,
0.0316552557,
0.8990934491,
0.8495394588,
-0.5993131995,
0.6847165823,
1.0161751509,
-0.7281520367,
0.0372727923,
-0.5471208692,
0.0318993516,
-0.4538451433,
0.9173932076,
-0.2870977521,
-0.9849617481,
0.8527195454,
-0.1180841848,
0.1562289596,
0.6694072485,
0.4539895356,
-0.088585645,
1.0250552893,
0.9660610557,
-0.1962456256,
0.5349000692,
-0.1739979535,
0.4865116477,
-0.4886323214,
-0.5320069194,
-0.7512495518,
-0.0221766364,
-0.7765504718,
-0.1051394939,
0.3131642044,
0.0789435655,
-0.1159283146,
0.4460651577,
-0.2903190255,
0.6008375883,
0.1236325204,
-0.2635210454,
0.0948754996,
-0.0039799716,
-0.0638532341,
-0.0129239494,
-0.7801624537,
-0.6369786859,
0.6274603605,
0.6016306281,
0.6420620084,
0.1793113649,
0.6655694842,
0.5358391404,
0.4139840901,
-0.8034725189,
0.4257736504,
-0.2547323704,
-0.7484123707,
-0.3418865204,
-0.2462396175,
-0.7267050743,
0.4459122717,
-0.2350887954,
-0.8510691524,
0.2734313607,
-0.1128282398,
-0.3316016793,
0.2290281504,
-0.9091073871,
1.1184475422,
-0.2485987395,
-0.0628550574,
-0.1404575557,
-0.1928002089,
-0.0094833868,
-0.2786538601,
0.5589210391,
-0.3298821151,
-0.0574423298,
0.8222590685,
0.0258865375,
0.9832909703,
-0.3604333699,
-0.5083649755,
0.2593818009,
-0.8187425137,
0.7471399307,
0.1891756356,
0.0860979334,
0.2416276336,
-0.0020401757,
-0.3583959937,
-0.3493480384,
0.6301245689,
-0.6481310129,
-0.7076793909,
-0.3478840292,
-0.0977752432,
-0.163825497,
0.081928432,
0.2906934917,
0.2611182332,
-0.4060182869,
0.3531674743,
0.6467787623,
-0.4185005426,
0.4920504689,
0.9464774132,
-0.0226449426,
-0.1825304925,
0.8550252318,
0.2481271923,
-0.0873521194,
0.4488654733,
0.0630139634,
-0.4900906384,
-0.5085461736,
-0.3692397177,
0.0165038966,
-0.606589973,
-0.1744871587,
-0.7276613712,
-0.4867986441,
0.0456818677,
-0.1211941913,
-0.4935063422,
-0.058490485,
-0.386457175,
-0.4013492465,
0.3172799051,
0.7487772107,
0.1829544306,
0.0711920857,
-0.8950328231,
0.2346378714,
0.3046756089,
0.1055977792,
-0.5288076401,
-0.3896415532,
-0.3560523391,
-0.0861129984,
-0.2399206012,
-1.0172361135,
0.3933101892,
0.1856523156,
0.8711561561,
0.5296854973,
-0.0952784419,
0.5851993561,
-0.5774258971,
0.9900764227,
0.1759654731,
-0.8721767068,
0.4742448628,
-0.702704668,
0.0717573091,
0.4547244906,
0.7237778902,
-0.8087229729,
-0.4722044468,
-0.6093289852,
-1.3265959024,
0.2716751993,
-0.104309082,
0.3431093395,
-0.4124005139,
0.0837588906,
-0.1499750763,
0.1701256633,
-1.0182584524,
-0.0921426713,
0.4732102752,
-0.2450291961,
0.2023151815,
-0.4168220162,
-0.0666804537,
-0.0147136897,
0.8925218582,
-0.0485038869,
0.3008620739,
0.0215524714,
-0.0741280168,
-0.0708076209,
0.6852149367,
0.7368084788,
0.5135582089,
-0.0820545182,
-0.0541620515,
0.1686406732,
-0.4131942689,
0.0944033489,
0.3862418234,
-0.2113011777,
0.1183369383,
0.1380382925,
0.6680907011,
0.0902294442,
-0.5770341754,
0.5829944611,
-0.0003193318,
-0.4370249808,
-0.4939840734,
-0.471231252,
0.1402996182,
0.393037796,
0.7716746926,
-0.2264274359,
0.1368354857,
-0.4811186194,
0.1431422681,
0.3179264069,
-0.7236819267,
-0.1403777748,
0.5930431485,
0.5658095479,
-0.0718502775,
0.2780683935,
-0.4079372287,
-0.6201962233,
1.1657469273,
0.4258693457,
0.9360789061,
-0.3784579635,
0.3056108952,
0.5148168206,
0.6702376008,
-0.2763971388,
0.5258313417,
0.4476470947,
-0.9581078887,
-0.5252103209,
-0.5106434226,
-0.097004123,
0.739156425,
-1.002707839,
0.4136466086,
0.0196154434,
-0.1380220354,
0.0692661479,
0.0372327417,
-0.6686914563,
0.0027980795,
0.429256022,
0.7979927063,
-1.6458662748,
0.4620752335,
0.9015241265,
-0.1111915261,
-0.390622437,
0.0134718306,
0.3400354981,
-0.5245099664,
0.2916227579,
0.2738368511,
0.066245608,
0.0940680802,
-0.2589772344,
-0.7671821713,
1.0415483713,
0.2164085805,
-0.8674730062,
0.1218924969,
-0.1695577651,
0.428919971,
-0.4064225256,
-0.0390455052,
0.3148596287,
0.8172672987,
-0.2582321465,
-1.0134019852,
-0.3161585331,
-0.6141393185,
-0.0964664519,
0.3843120933,
-0.6956843138,
0.4682497978,
-0.0820718408,
-0.3549630344,
-0.1580985636,
0.4667465985,
0.2776621878,
0.3478145003,
0.4741697907,
0.5559479594,
0.9670062065,
-0.2588446736,
0.9348947406,
-0.4642558992,
0.7047781944,
0.8984659314,
-0.0791038573,
0.7135748267,
0.7581222057,
-0.2043461949,
0.0204598606,
1.0098365545,
-0.2337040901,
0.7635486126,
0.3697282374,
-0.3981058002,
0.0456224941,
-0.2527290881,
-0.3796660602,
0.4807466269,
0.7426648736,
-0.6807391644,
-0.3029244244,
0.2402040958,
-0.0018355239,
-0.1207925603,
-0.5377116799,
0.712708652,
-0.1506722569,
-0.2549495697,
-0.1613700241,
0.5275747776,
0.6997234225,
-0.6178100705,
-0.0579225607,
-0.0234571546,
-0.336550355,
-0.0969439745,
-0.5967201591,
0.4528576732,
0.2725738287,
-0.0966097713,
-0.5670042038,
0.6438670158,
-0.9230701327,
-0.7084867358,
0.2480469048,
0.6792298555,
0.085536018,
-0.1263561845,
-0.9695875049,
-0.0541266352,
0.0252434835,
-0.3278291821,
-0.0392667092,
0.4858455062,
-0.1332487166,
0.1753347069,
0.1733993143,
-0.1089680642,
0.0862342566,
0.4137875438,
0.534419477,
-0.449552983,
-0.5083544254,
-0.6356683373,
0.6584935784,
-0.2551102042,
-0.3571572602,
0.7276644111,
0.7353085279,
0.8378329873,
-0.3790698051,
0.9496076107,
-0.1923874319,
0.2346411496,
-0.6869603992,
0.876807332,
-0.4888588786,
0.3584418297,
-0.1925384402,
-0.8882790208,
-0.1347278208,
0.5586328506,
-0.3034627438,
0.0418442376,
0.596719861,
1.0416843891,
-0.07316342,
-0.0580992848,
0.1695926189,
-0.0384695418,
0.1174041554,
0.4414764345,
0.8649926782,
-0.3453352749,
0.355867058,
0.3532527387,
0.1393235475,
-0.0630193129,
-1.1754996777,
-0.6465001702,
-0.8392384052,
-0.8130850196,
0.0956582054,
0.1766367406,
0.8854974508,
0.6364958882,
-0.9461941123,
0.2032829374,
-0.3615863919,
0.192631036,
-0.2282074392,
-0.2755191028,
0.339104712,
-0.0074743074,
-0.8824619651,
0.2878395319,
0.4306141436,
0.0411839224,
-0.2790732682,
0.2268285006,
-0.2499290556,
0.0928833559,
0.6131501794,
0.3832553327,
-0.8834183812,
-0.5419964194,
-0.0669026896,
0.129316017,
-0.4128480554,
0.7862686515,
-0.1091791466,
0.271287173,
0.3240838051,
0.7205232978,
0.5603351593,
-0.1405461133,
0.5317792296,
-0.9721388817,
0.1464590281,
0.0315951742,
0.5972052813,
0.2197057456,
-0.5866261125,
0.5360072255,
0.1600146741,
-0.2804629505,
-0.5627490282,
0.3003551662,
-0.7798162699,
-0.090473257,
1.4629647732,
-0.2172787338,
-0.1066433638,
-0.3459124863,
-0.1550533473,
-0.171343118,
-0.2842197418,
0.6987105012,
1.1756124496,
0.1581829488,
-0.5196723938,
-0.7068344951,
0.3847667873,
0.1002843902,
-0.8683329821,
-0.1352583319,
0.3470330834,
0.1427284628,
0.1613559276,
0.5886487961,
-0.5064675808,
0.0309425537,
-0.1109753698,
0.111477755,
0.1225977093,
-0.6370706558,
-0.5181105137,
0.342938751,
-0.2567126453,
0.0330135152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06630v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06630v1 | Resolution for Constrained Pseudo-Propositional Logic | 2023-06-11T09:17:24 | 2023-06-11T09:17:24 | Ahmad-Saher Azizi-Sultan | math.LO | math.LO, cs.CL, 03B05 | This work, shows how propositional resolution can be generalized to obtain a
resolution proof system for constrained pseudo-propositional logic (CPPL),
which is an extension resulted from inserting the natural numbers with few
constraints symbols into the alphabet of propositional logic and adjusting the
underling language accordingly. Unlike the construction of CNF formulas which
are restricted to a finite set of clauses, the extended CPPL does not require
the corresponding set to be finite.
Although this restriction is made dispensable, this work presents a
constructive proof showing that the generalized resolution for CPPL is sound
and complete. As a marginal result, this implies that propositional resolution
is also sound and complete for formulas with even infinite set of clauses. | [
-0.2017296851,
-0.2856941521,
0.7444868684,
0.2082497329,
-0.6130498052,
0.2225085348,
-0.3917957544,
-0.5252634287,
0.2297198325,
0.5730744004,
-0.4912686646,
-0.2226078212,
-0.2579394579,
0.3907526433,
-0.2615069449,
0.6942772865,
0.0867967084,
0.019499572,
-0.2291360199,
-0.3614524007,
-0.2328271717,
-0.9807630181,
0.0975357294,
-0.0016726606,
-0.2309688479,
0.2098709643,
0.7645816207,
0.6868555546,
0.4943680167,
0.4207803905,
-0.1161415204,
0.5017896295,
-0.2134019881,
-0.2917152643,
-0.5257608891,
-0.4558387101,
-0.3595370948,
0.0142466174,
0.9372791052,
0.7718700767,
-0.0183298811,
-0.2088195831,
0.129905507,
0.7304258347,
-0.6849043369,
0.1878531575,
-0.4978790283,
0.1086093411,
0.0051111034,
-0.1400992572,
-0.6730659008,
-0.5042159557,
0.1488239616,
-1.0088717937,
0.3718549609,
0.0563968718,
0.8146582842,
0.4153530598,
-0.4615059197,
-0.3932975829,
-1.0240248442,
0.8918197155,
-0.4138068557,
0.1822606027,
0.3276567161,
0.3763929605,
-0.1992885917,
-0.8268710375,
-0.5793806911,
-0.3277378976,
-0.3132858574,
0.1404881179,
-0.1380297393,
0.5441738367,
0.6195818782,
0.7903333306,
-0.6591538191,
-0.4396641254,
-0.4491357505,
-0.5207549334,
0.4280606806,
0.0639688447,
0.1250555962,
-0.0067093712,
-0.0455380045,
0.2854738235,
-0.8482996821,
-0.0322662592,
0.0928939208,
0.3637787104,
0.0500113517,
0.6573923826,
-0.1167100593,
1.0662282705,
0.3045557737,
-0.2718889713,
0.084222883,
-0.5411094427,
-0.1022046581,
0.0676619411,
0.4245699048,
0.2545229495,
0.3044093847,
0.2046047002,
-0.1157586351,
0.212725535,
0.0065416959,
-0.5222100019,
-0.2995826304,
-0.055699762,
-0.5354450941,
0.355101347,
0.1433285177,
-0.2463514954,
-0.0221485365,
-0.5547050834,
0.2518531978,
-0.4662289619,
0.0010485713,
0.3401896954,
-0.0872815549,
0.1754444689,
0.2121037096,
-0.7578491569,
0.6486439109,
0.9288685322,
0.4339601696,
0.5753182769,
0.1966747344,
-0.7048841119,
0.091726087,
-0.6098818779,
0.7666309476,
-0.7449691296,
-0.6037688255,
0.2238864601,
-0.1059691384,
0.0646506622,
-0.7433546782,
1.0434211493,
-0.5322067738,
0.4260627627,
-0.6313060522,
-0.7943823338,
-0.1518597007,
0.3148167431,
-0.4132486284,
0.5552973747,
0.337660253,
-0.2206387371,
0.2757048011,
-0.3506355882,
-0.4076966345,
0.4394756258,
-0.412771374,
0.1020013168,
0.4832516611,
0.1673667431,
-0.3196604848,
-0.2372246236,
0.2022504061,
-0.1203125641,
-0.3042261899,
0.0854649693,
0.0282212291,
0.7398773432,
0.3026188612,
0.0783391148,
0.3157131672,
-0.8731614351,
0.5207953453,
-0.2494417727,
-0.4444312453,
-0.2380547822,
0.1192556843,
-0.5893158913,
0.2299456149,
0.4692548215,
-0.781489253,
0.5466175675,
-0.5907100439,
0.5586108565,
0.5445923805,
-0.061123915,
0.3254080415,
-0.2157772928,
0.2781676352,
-0.383148551,
0.3739356101,
0.1923346221,
-0.5761050582,
-0.8941623569,
-0.5123818517,
0.5484876633,
0.6094002724,
-0.8734536171,
0.7122200727,
-0.0642351955,
-0.0441528149,
-0.1936816424,
-0.1068221554,
0.537401557,
0.5011852384,
0.530744493,
0.1407909393,
-0.8747679591,
-0.8833230138,
0.0908733755,
-0.5597815514,
-0.3037615418,
0.3588012755,
0.3785397708,
0.2727516294,
0.9588299394,
-0.6069505811,
-0.4811700284,
-0.3666252196,
-0.0909094065,
0.8198890686,
0.494152844,
0.6874986291,
-0.7247947454,
-0.5837321281,
-0.2596166432,
-0.435112685,
-0.300625056,
-0.0149849942,
0.1233306304,
0.118123576,
0.2863617837,
-0.5700526834,
0.6269358993,
0.2446935773,
-0.4273376465,
0.9568200111,
-0.5263715982,
0.0528613441,
-0.4567056,
-0.1999276131,
-0.2066052854,
-0.4867566526,
-0.5131179094,
0.1203630045,
0.1910385936,
-0.1670482904,
-0.2104119509,
-0.0823913142,
-0.1501642019,
0.0983669758,
-0.5338739157,
-0.139561832,
0.1482420564,
0.2622267604,
0.5558844209,
0.4506083727,
0.4382151961,
-0.8009405732,
0.6376256943,
0.1413182169,
-0.0544570684,
0.7550085187,
-0.9089953303,
-0.1570958197,
0.1291652173,
0.4568101466,
-0.9081420898,
0.0337462276,
0.5842067599,
-0.1332874447,
-0.1325936168,
-0.1726856828,
-0.5569754243,
-0.5105044246,
-0.1358777583,
0.7374868989,
0.4728720486,
-0.8093549609,
0.4980981648,
-0.0846058503,
0.3128660023,
-0.2952151597,
-0.5351319313,
-0.1348865628,
0.0231128111,
-0.3242129982,
1.0994830132,
-0.3564533889,
-0.438796699,
0.2421018779,
-0.0860291347,
-0.1211899519,
-0.5682528615,
-0.0707138106,
0.3527913392,
-0.2711374462,
0.2209119052,
0.0446294807,
-0.2853635252,
0.1456622034,
-0.4842150211,
0.4351641238,
-0.5194200873,
-0.4484162927,
-0.3402108848,
0.6634178758,
0.2953259349,
-0.2186247259,
0.3207842112,
-0.2778666317,
-0.7360706925,
-0.2454153746,
-0.2866717875,
0.0008137887,
-0.5564852953,
-0.17944929,
-0.742744267,
-0.8603355885,
0.6490736604,
-0.2004598379,
-0.167420283,
0.7927572131,
0.2569571137,
0.332365036,
0.8418872356,
0.6777176857,
0.3613654375,
-0.0582826361,
-0.1100676507,
0.3858144879,
-0.731986165,
-0.221543178,
-0.8625356555,
-0.0246221982,
-0.5975954533,
-0.2856621146,
-0.0500401109,
0.4564220905,
-0.2203155011,
0.3912574947,
-0.9770931005,
0.9714882374,
0.5434209108,
0.1484138221,
0.4286566079,
-0.4977469146,
-0.6201919913,
-0.4650688469,
-0.4252088368,
-0.2083056569,
0.6309736967,
-0.0409188047,
0.0435943343,
0.6318579912,
0.5954385996,
0.444447577,
0.1362321079,
-0.8665856123,
0.6653031707,
-0.6356452703,
-0.8171271682,
0.0924100205,
-0.3904161155,
-0.2777010798,
0.0889552087,
0.0936712548,
-0.9742535949,
0.6874795556,
0.0846311748,
-0.6407393813,
0.1687235385,
-0.2311203778,
0.3289852142,
-0.1856664419,
-0.1519244313,
-0.3783445358,
-0.4518978894,
0.3682963848,
0.1544518769,
-0.2027746737,
-0.107526198,
-0.1670695692,
0.558613658,
-1.2724322081,
0.7208832502,
-0.0536715165,
-0.0149206901,
0.7563672662,
0.1044756994,
0.432436347,
0.2373309731,
-0.1391825825,
-0.4930315018,
0.1811015457,
-0.3581976593,
-0.7418906093,
0.7448313832,
-0.4916751981,
-0.7143560648,
-0.7700961828,
-0.3105595112,
-0.1267769039,
0.1859122664,
0.5953595638,
0.5489929914,
-0.0070115272,
-0.0799853802,
0.6131886244,
-0.1064574569,
0.3708324432,
0.6616607904,
-0.2787949145,
-0.7881560326,
0.8348788619,
0.4144202471,
-0.0568517484,
0.6262154579,
0.4052504301,
-0.8401479125,
-0.3792775273,
-0.1798162609,
0.226366356,
-0.8655627966,
-0.4187575877,
0.1660873145,
-0.4747714102,
-0.4275269508,
-0.2325160652,
-0.3838913441,
-0.9539347291,
-0.2724745572,
0.1329608858,
0.1088316366,
0.5986905694,
-0.7066280246,
-0.0505105853,
-0.6597816944,
0.717652142,
0.6543071866,
0.5096057653,
-0.3851233423,
-0.6621665359,
0.2269573361,
-0.147539109,
-0.3049439788,
-0.8289403915,
0.0999187604,
0.7610186338,
0.4514164031,
0.6352311373,
0.8649289012,
0.8207833767,
-0.4141584933,
0.7672131658,
0.2702439725,
-1.4897413254,
0.650816977,
-0.3186675906,
0.1759506464,
0.4860379994,
0.3565644026,
-0.2897413373,
-0.0703859627,
-0.6575064063,
-0.5419242382,
0.095362559,
0.127925083,
0.0654780939,
-0.2955371141,
0.6768068671,
-0.1210658625,
-0.0968511626,
-0.7839397192,
-0.2526784241,
-0.4647533894,
0.1782465428,
0.2899200022,
-0.6610360146,
-0.2510430515,
-0.6931510568,
0.6212716103,
-0.0614302307,
0.4013250768,
0.5292840004,
0.11506024,
0.098520793,
0.4054527581,
0.8885140419,
0.9126520753,
-0.4938784838,
0.3048847318,
-0.2040232718,
-0.0852598771,
0.3648448288,
0.3017662466,
0.1163164973,
0.0226986688,
0.5559004545,
-0.0018547793,
-0.2225014418,
-0.4116268158,
0.4343248308,
-0.0139297452,
-0.5315316319,
-0.2721259594,
-0.0584258065,
-0.2986670434,
0.1260669529,
0.6472678185,
0.0465380214,
0.2608285248,
-0.4394982755,
0.4260496199,
0.1290225387,
-0.3809562922,
-0.1707612872,
0.5968520641,
0.3386499584,
-0.2087835968,
1.1392072439,
-0.579143703,
-0.9429022074,
0.437864542,
1.0573569536,
0.4857470989,
0.1076230854,
0.3999071419,
0.566858232,
0.3092859983,
0.1135197207,
0.5126354098,
-0.3741939664,
-0.844568491,
-0.9798399806,
-0.3030581772,
-0.6843523383,
0.2081280798,
-0.6121166945,
-0.1036508158,
-1.1200326681,
-0.1119473279,
-0.0471644625,
0.0895453766,
-0.1271386147,
0.1337274015,
0.0258658659,
0.8150444031,
-0.5878605843,
0.9071435928,
0.7177761793,
-0.1933977753,
-0.6641862392,
-0.1505821198,
0.1697030813,
-0.3710832596,
0.6267806292,
0.1357436478,
-0.0366711915,
-0.4469692111,
-0.4385252893,
-0.5352530479,
0.1275735199,
0.673879981,
-0.4254692793,
0.4779115617,
0.6692082286,
0.8857337236,
-0.2513679862,
-0.296038121,
0.3724167943,
0.6299697161,
0.2921429574,
-1.0117952824,
0.3565433025,
-0.4678859711,
-0.2206202298,
0.3367129564,
-0.4260828197,
0.6234251857,
-0.2460813522,
-0.2790987492,
0.591884315,
0.9839400053,
0.3633451164,
0.0502926819,
0.4814067781,
0.8836555481,
0.707118988,
-0.6165843606,
0.9058428407,
-0.0723933131,
0.3347066939,
1.1890854836,
-0.2023961246,
0.5730439425,
0.2510882616,
-0.5549132228,
0.2808220088,
0.6099358201,
0.071919091,
0.7159817815,
0.7158356905,
-0.835380435,
-0.6835723519,
-0.7133253813,
-0.7587851882,
0.2051741332,
0.5777885914,
-0.3050690293,
-0.161760807,
-0.2748363614,
-0.4095974267,
0.5318161845,
-0.5688824654,
0.3943966329,
0.0999228358,
-0.734664619,
0.8357266188,
-0.1169831157,
0.268450886,
-0.4157938361,
-0.3245081306,
0.1102880687,
0.4051893055,
-0.4645886719,
-0.7860296369,
0.7367904186,
-0.2639307976,
-0.5067756176,
-0.1045397446,
0.6997542381,
-0.1379801333,
-0.6484900713,
0.1975482106,
0.1387075633,
-0.1610209793,
-0.1069135368,
-0.4848414361,
-0.0949700475,
0.1830892563,
0.2473534346,
-0.1282885224,
0.4159555733,
0.2115772069,
0.4891400635,
0.4036874175,
0.1250940561,
0.0254703537,
-0.0239372998,
0.8922013044,
-0.3879139423,
-0.3737630844,
-0.6102818847,
0.2574861944,
-0.0670981854,
-0.2946666777,
0.2078936398,
0.5226848722,
0.5738919377,
-0.1385745108,
0.6468362212,
-0.2289028019,
0.3705451488,
-0.3317467868,
-0.2659640908,
-0.2772939503,
0.4116181135,
-0.2065093517,
-0.9341205955,
-1.0049322844,
0.7299156785,
-0.5946641564,
-0.168518886,
0.7875277996,
0.2932657897,
-0.0854247808,
0.0284757987,
0.3853871226,
-0.1087961346,
0.3977641761,
0.7506736517,
1.0375496149,
-0.0539191812,
0.5390931964,
-0.7745022774,
-0.3352812529,
0.0869439617,
-1.020044446,
-0.3855010569,
-0.6335219145,
-0.5014094114,
-0.4741976261,
0.0392407738,
0.7037193775,
0.6724463105,
-0.9468214512,
0.0169785339,
-0.296417743,
0.3706717789,
-0.4746549428,
-0.248375684,
0.663479805,
-0.087993674,
-0.5746280551,
0.4436016977,
0.2187970132,
0.0646177754,
0.2305979133,
-0.2398575395,
-0.1447904706,
0.1984124184,
0.529156208,
0.9473124743,
-0.6861796975,
-0.680547893,
-0.4269347191,
0.2979499102,
0.1202260628,
0.9363976121,
-0.9266574979,
0.2715917826,
0.8236584067,
0.0993458405,
0.1721258909,
0.1748951823,
0.7545186281,
-0.9267756343,
0.4606288671,
0.3846314847,
0.6775990725,
-0.1478630751,
-0.1740243882,
0.5846797824,
0.3564194143,
-0.3854291439,
-0.5543213487,
0.5617298484,
-1.1586463451,
-0.3704229891,
0.5189736485,
-0.3205228746,
0.1736260802,
-0.2966667712,
-0.2269751579,
0.040678829,
-0.3506022692,
0.4729843736,
0.5647830367,
-0.6776168942,
-0.2066372037,
0.2601414025,
0.3807059526,
0.3329600096,
-0.4399962425,
-0.1358222812,
0.6567589045,
-0.2180131227,
0.7697286606,
0.4995401204,
-0.3588839173,
0.4507481158,
-0.1305337995,
-0.4498639107,
-0.008888578,
-0.349675864,
0.0015738949,
0.51421839,
0.2595072091,
-0.2128074616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06629v1 | GKD: A General Knowledge Distillation Framework for Large-scale Pre-trained Language Model | 2023-06-11T09:17:21 | 2023-06-11T09:17:21 | Shicheng Tan, Weng Lam Tam, Yuanchun Wang, Wenwen Gong, Yang Yang, Hongyin Tang, Keqing He, Jiahao Liu, Jingang Wang, Shu Zhao, Peng Zhang, Jie Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Currently, the reduction in the parameter scale of large-scale pre-trained
language models (PLMs) through knowledge distillation has greatly facilitated
their widespread deployment on various devices. However, the deployment of
knowledge distillation systems faces great challenges in real-world
industrial-strength applications, which require the use of complex distillation
methods on even larger-scale PLMs (over 10B), limited by memory on GPUs and the
switching of methods. To overcome these challenges, we propose GKD, a general
knowledge distillation framework that supports distillation on larger-scale
PLMs using various distillation methods. With GKD, developers can build larger
distillation models on memory-limited GPUs and easily switch and combine
different distillation methods within a single framework. Experimental results
show that GKD can support the distillation of at least 100B-scale PLMs and 25
mainstream methods on 8 NVIDIA A100 (40GB) GPUs. | [
-0.5105660558,
-0.7209391594,
0.9489657879,
0.2487266362,
-0.6417641044,
-0.0408515707,
-0.3450449705,
-0.0889727175,
-0.1319883764,
0.5517634749,
-0.1396669745,
-0.4720521569,
-0.7867575288,
-0.2086940557,
-0.3241412342,
1.1167424917,
-0.261400789,
-0.0261712894,
-0.3270848691,
0.1079102755,
-0.2349057645,
-0.6616002321,
-0.6564350724,
-0.3935688436,
0.3517975211,
0.1188247874,
0.5214836597,
0.4925965071,
0.3357996941,
0.2998481691,
-0.1015149876,
-0.1911166161,
-0.2839566469,
0.1994522959,
-0.2000211179,
-0.4660294056,
-0.2799903452,
0.086266391,
0.1603791267,
0.6666782498,
-0.441932261,
0.1815800071,
0.2645859122,
0.7111341953,
-0.7928750515,
0.2440245003,
-0.4612543881,
0.0752798021,
-0.1082016826,
0.3179793954,
-0.2473982275,
-0.4605087936,
0.3961953223,
-0.7649875283,
0.3465526104,
-0.1432785243,
0.5952421427,
0.3788849711,
-0.3536011577,
-0.3377064466,
-1.1561410427,
0.7108306289,
-0.764438808,
0.4702613354,
0.4332183003,
0.6981136203,
-0.0930649713,
-1.0046708584,
-0.657959938,
-0.1968972534,
0.1216032431,
-0.1538914591,
0.3399274647,
0.4412757456,
0.4152333736,
0.5718994141,
-0.3583539426,
-0.1241551265,
-0.1853830963,
0.089540042,
0.2231147438,
0.0771202669,
0.0905728117,
0.4840731323,
-0.2565546036,
-0.0377766266,
-0.5905253887,
-0.1934705526,
0.4221247733,
0.0380532704,
-0.0923732668,
0.1713205129,
-0.509417057,
0.8791921139,
0.0551613085,
-0.5020897985,
-0.0488712601,
-0.4115034044,
-0.5961244106,
-0.0371005498,
0.6573085785,
0.1925019175,
0.3480489254,
-0.2306826711,
0.0328506343,
0.1510264874,
0.1633500457,
-1.1523685455,
-0.7380162477,
0.1880782098,
-0.3750129044,
-0.2218145728,
-0.388550967,
-0.8028953075,
-0.5167487264,
-0.4941701293,
0.3381380141,
-0.2173273861,
-0.6001861691,
0.1929226816,
-0.535594821,
0.0877059028,
0.3569917977,
-1.2751787901,
0.2140007764,
0.5506551266,
0.9142186642,
-0.0116854375,
0.0422653854,
-0.0816686824,
0.5073950887,
-0.2370088249,
0.2939127386,
-0.5172271132,
-0.6688863039,
-0.4296132922,
-0.2297619134,
0.2512145936,
-0.9476943016,
0.4239920676,
-0.4990511239,
0.0279184394,
-0.2774198353,
-0.6007730961,
-0.1989186406,
0.0935148373,
-0.7064223886,
0.6596454382,
0.0869531706,
-0.8325035572,
0.7828657031,
-0.5377985239,
-0.4488669336,
0.105708003,
-0.1655111015,
-0.2529555261,
0.5224574208,
0.1373967826,
0.4251549244,
-0.5243309736,
0.5620645881,
-0.5460239649,
0.0438197069,
-0.4084581435,
-0.567498982,
0.6839455962,
0.4654707909,
-0.0628146306,
-0.1049766764,
-0.8684483171,
-0.1368949115,
-0.1606194973,
-0.6057651639,
-0.7981506586,
0.0232371278,
-0.0891144872,
0.3287751973,
0.3474117815,
-0.6530742645,
0.4708342552,
-0.0699764937,
0.6444337368,
0.5864679217,
-0.1135498807,
0.4737610817,
0.0968281925,
0.4902768731,
0.2918917835,
0.3316752613,
0.1362907141,
-0.6067250967,
-0.5190135837,
-0.439904511,
0.1553476006,
0.4840723276,
-0.9773213863,
0.3820734918,
-0.1248567104,
-0.5773766637,
-0.4205667675,
0.6231694818,
0.2208515406,
0.6298385262,
0.3873615563,
-0.0275415126,
-0.4857660532,
-0.8215041161,
0.1069470644,
-0.2159262449,
-0.5015387535,
0.116651319,
0.3573414683,
-0.1815352589,
1.3861829042,
-0.5849096775,
-0.3963540196,
-0.1647494882,
0.2399604917,
0.4025085568,
0.4249417782,
0.5533654094,
-0.7718911171,
-0.685505271,
0.4249713719,
-0.6985630393,
-0.0506890975,
0.1787198186,
0.2229774594,
0.1297686547,
0.6896549463,
-0.8209558725,
0.1212372854,
0.9038724899,
-0.2489372343,
0.9632537961,
-0.7813206315,
0.0909533352,
-1.1274574995,
0.1987225413,
-0.0917928815,
-0.0337095372,
-0.643668592,
-0.2332326472,
0.0357005857,
-0.100677222,
-0.3890969157,
0.506526649,
-0.3027529716,
0.0892076567,
-0.3012957871,
-0.2496645451,
0.113534376,
0.1573894769,
0.2220225036,
0.5525917411,
0.6273030043,
-0.8485906124,
0.9749798775,
-0.2291935235,
-0.6687948704,
0.6122965813,
-0.706718266,
-0.0521278977,
-0.1057107747,
0.1929727346,
-1.1364451647,
-0.0671518147,
-0.0617531873,
-0.1427010447,
0.3355493844,
-0.4337218404,
-0.3919670582,
-0.6374166012,
0.1437596381,
0.4130313098,
0.6250368357,
-0.7612442374,
1.0597678423,
0.1927255243,
-0.3953131735,
-0.422942549,
-0.6647734642,
-0.0889681578,
-0.6032654047,
-0.7178505659,
-0.0049680443,
-0.2620688975,
-0.2455498725,
0.0595722944,
-0.2937410772,
-0.4185205102,
0.1911342889,
0.2028201222,
0.2125322074,
-0.200893268,
-0.0278397538,
0.002683372,
-0.2104316652,
0.2213337421,
-0.6613045931,
0.5527479053,
0.3416312635,
-0.1929364502,
-0.3844583929,
0.0308660213,
0.8219035268,
0.119776614,
0.6374718547,
0.4450892508,
-0.2203771323,
-0.2538766861,
-0.6440348625,
0.0808153749,
-0.5850301981,
0.5400785804,
-0.4594564438,
-0.9665219188,
0.6964146495,
-0.4428395033,
0.009627766,
0.1580646038,
0.5917283893,
-0.0303007979,
1.0473835468,
0.7558595538,
-0.6307806373,
0.1595910043,
-0.1005321667,
0.4242241681,
-0.5274506211,
0.0541982129,
-0.592710793,
-0.5041717887,
0.0046598869,
-0.4851496816,
0.0641054064,
0.5827524662,
-0.1990151256,
-0.0710562393,
-0.3945096731,
0.7661145926,
0.5818251967,
-0.3780771494,
0.4629997909,
-0.1449978203,
-0.4186770022,
0.1911723614,
-0.3267923892,
-0.2617743015,
1.269895792,
0.2518917918,
1.0137866735,
-0.1482928395,
0.6282675266,
0.1671583354,
0.3203569055,
-0.4022052586,
0.3623374403,
-0.4676358998,
-0.9194052219,
-0.4060534239,
-0.4877080917,
-0.3053541481,
0.2060678899,
0.2003605962,
-0.4735457897,
-0.0669552684,
0.4661502242,
-0.5606952906,
0.5877385736,
-1.3504691124,
0.9805501699,
-0.2022571266,
0.0541968159,
-0.3778079748,
-0.2659017742,
0.7672926784,
-0.2606693804,
0.2730800211,
-0.0148619721,
0.1823082417,
0.5942991972,
-0.684908092,
0.593939662,
-0.8991927505,
-0.4713709652,
0.2526946664,
-0.1201067865,
0.4435905516,
0.2104732841,
0.4241960943,
-0.0141435284,
0.0288697816,
-0.034850847,
-0.6944006085,
0.8305431604,
-0.7658714652,
-0.644595921,
-0.0438901559,
-0.4671655297,
-0.3715350926,
0.1000458896,
0.2810890675,
0.0239718482,
-0.2917239368,
0.3037849367,
0.8954828978,
-0.3310986161,
0.5543326139,
0.3885277212,
-0.5616806149,
-0.3174177408,
0.9335373044,
0.2970494628,
0.5786390901,
0.1413901746,
0.1419510394,
-0.5196953416,
-0.7799666524,
-0.4986611307,
-0.2078808099,
-0.5020612478,
-0.0365253687,
-0.4913618267,
-0.1075035334,
-0.3881397545,
-0.1040569544,
-0.5957464576,
-0.2123222202,
-0.227038011,
-0.1574846506,
0.5331656337,
0.7080809474,
-0.0845964998,
0.5038788915,
-0.5262222886,
0.9284315109,
0.8732848167,
0.894018352,
0.0772736147,
-0.2351837903,
-0.2144329399,
0.187367335,
-0.0352118313,
-0.3470865488,
0.3154239357,
0.4812393188,
0.5808226466,
0.7910265923,
0.1047528014,
0.5415989757,
-0.4641661644,
0.7072988153,
0.4238068461,
-0.6663361192,
0.4552713037,
-0.2335110605,
0.5003401637,
0.5137966275,
0.6913808584,
-0.6110652089,
-0.4008449912,
-0.2720218301,
-0.9007783532,
0.4991476238,
-0.4128695726,
-0.0779660642,
0.2094570249,
0.1824124455,
0.2473545969,
0.0983873531,
-0.2865189612,
-0.2543261647,
-0.1141941473,
-0.2134875059,
-0.2318882197,
-0.3168785274,
-0.0754949749,
-0.443321228,
0.8156960011,
0.0116956681,
-0.1956445426,
-0.0825344175,
-0.1389176846,
0.3595941961,
0.2455680817,
0.4555429518,
0.5122015476,
-0.3473103642,
0.1329897046,
0.0273910034,
-1.1063371897,
0.4863925278,
0.0457525253,
-0.1815738529,
-0.2030594349,
-0.3587060571,
0.910710454,
-0.2493116558,
-0.4145121872,
0.1124962121,
-0.359084934,
-0.5712435842,
0.081723474,
0.2534861565,
0.7868384123,
0.2808632553,
0.5274404883,
-0.252900213,
-0.0761243403,
-0.2204146385,
0.0863630921,
0.3461228013,
-0.0046401648,
-0.2075992078,
0.8372775316,
0.293308109,
0.2396041453,
0.6717836261,
-0.3989390433,
-0.1268648356,
0.4588640034,
0.3091575801,
0.9544805884,
-0.4609328806,
0.2035513967,
0.2556455731,
0.022485679,
-0.440182656,
0.0925598145,
-0.2682030499,
-0.6854166389,
-0.7263249755,
-1.1956017017,
-0.3653238714,
0.4987870753,
-0.312825501,
0.1712578684,
-0.9894842505,
-0.3009001017,
-0.0342201777,
-0.0383553542,
-0.5604370832,
0.0531941466,
0.2571891844,
0.7803685069,
-0.9386950731,
1.4848130941,
0.4649793208,
-0.0250177868,
-0.665764153,
-0.6069591641,
-0.1628008783,
-0.4019832313,
0.8084441423,
-0.1323342919,
0.1869970709,
0.1488223076,
-0.4881396592,
-0.6373050213,
1.1785244942,
0.6773571968,
-0.9094823599,
-0.0798664093,
0.5027961135,
0.4411821067,
-0.1302719414,
0.0407879241,
0.9301133156,
0.5637037754,
0.3436846435,
-1.3295304775,
-0.2748642564,
-0.1625864953,
0.2000228465,
0.1709653437,
-0.1529974639,
0.9562442899,
-0.0301424656,
-0.1570787281,
-0.2006466091,
0.5943600535,
0.3135634363,
-0.0378954895,
0.4753388166,
1.2175428867,
0.6966750026,
-0.2897713482,
0.6611790061,
-0.2707747519,
0.2873412669,
1.2542200089,
-0.4308744669,
0.5166707635,
0.5694061518,
-0.4467714131,
0.2660211325,
0.1247942075,
0.2056293041,
0.8731690645,
0.3979101181,
-0.6997093558,
-0.1024750397,
0.2672201097,
-0.7019353509,
0.0519658588,
0.5122489333,
-0.2218949944,
-0.5994431973,
0.4127064943,
-0.0828726068,
-0.3175525069,
-0.4994564354,
0.7812359333,
0.0539272092,
-0.4263712466,
0.6329371333,
-0.1068791524,
1.1388123035,
-0.9596354365,
0.0596897081,
-0.2157803327,
0.6729598045,
0.021435583,
-0.6005682349,
0.3069374859,
-0.176015839,
-0.4706897438,
-0.3922697008,
0.8535254598,
-0.6870193481,
-0.3569606543,
0.3148641586,
0.0606235638,
-0.1752857715,
-0.458630383,
-0.0743084624,
0.0834957212,
-0.0482106209,
-0.2886757255,
0.7681609392,
0.7317435145,
0.1693665534,
0.7583571672,
0.6237018108,
0.2236746848,
0.4793276489,
-0.1082774103,
0.9018249512,
-0.3558883965,
-0.7796790004,
-0.8533188105,
0.2892581522,
0.1035014316,
-0.1113159731,
0.738006413,
0.5389831066,
0.945232451,
-0.4431882799,
1.2842814922,
-0.3041413426,
0.4170594215,
-0.4097262919,
1.112082243,
-0.0948374271,
-0.0609331317,
-0.0859710574,
-1.0841617584,
-0.0727651492,
0.5070643425,
-0.3140135109,
-0.0650508106,
0.277312398,
0.4077062309,
-0.0283915307,
0.231154412,
0.4226830304,
0.3227348626,
0.7075716257,
0.7414506078,
0.4535723627,
0.1671792269,
0.4501820207,
-0.2289121449,
-0.2007793337,
0.0496129729,
-1.0735970736,
-0.6923851967,
-0.6238433123,
-0.2071675211,
0.0561147183,
-0.0248408839,
0.4559000432,
0.670902133,
-0.8393104076,
-0.222005859,
-0.3007674217,
-0.1371171474,
0.0323895067,
-0.2130156755,
0.1461431235,
-0.4343495667,
-0.5917739272,
0.1321319342,
0.2072526217,
0.1909895241,
-0.527498126,
-0.2855150104,
-0.1660700738,
-0.3557889163,
0.5847894549,
0.5216374397,
-0.2832318246,
-0.3462043107,
-0.4564605653,
0.0691147596,
-0.3106958866,
0.8677743673,
-1.0112463236,
0.472309947,
0.6680682898,
0.7593992949,
0.5992633104,
-0.1420808136,
0.7464923859,
-0.9057073593,
0.4014379084,
-0.027175134,
0.0919092074,
-0.0247842744,
0.1039612293,
0.141501978,
0.438528955,
-0.5953855515,
-0.4935150146,
0.0679303482,
-0.7290521264,
-0.4158413112,
1.1025432348,
-0.3565324843,
-0.0900213793,
-0.5397313237,
-0.2097314745,
0.0564494245,
-0.1811847836,
0.7141327858,
1.1888790131,
0.2753858268,
0.0403606705,
-0.6432398558,
0.8909382224,
-0.1331643313,
-0.6462084055,
0.6165795922,
0.5625747442,
0.5112390518,
0.2027925402,
0.9171384573,
-0.0090918494,
-0.1158210188,
0.0090172021,
0.2702791095,
-0.2762771249,
-0.5523204803,
-0.0561959483,
0.3045864403,
0.1031628698,
-0.076500684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06625v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06625v1 | Are Intermediate Layers and Labels Really Necessary? A General Language Model Distillation Method | 2023-06-11T08:53:27 | 2023-06-11T08:53:27 | Shicheng Tan, Weng Lam Tam, Yuanchun Wang, Wenwen Gong, Shu Zhao, Peng Zhang, Jie Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The large scale of pre-trained language models poses a challenge for their
deployment on various devices, with a growing emphasis on methods to compress
these models, particularly knowledge distillation. However, current knowledge
distillation methods rely on the model's intermediate layer features and the
golden labels (also called hard labels), which usually require aligned model
architecture and enough labeled data respectively. Moreover, the parameters of
vocabulary are usually neglected in existing methods. To address these
problems, we propose a general language model distillation (GLMD) method that
performs two-stage word prediction distillation and vocabulary compression,
which is simple and surprisingly shows extremely strong performance.
Specifically, GLMD supports more general application scenarios by eliminating
the constraints of dimension and structure between models and the need for
labeled datasets through the absence of intermediate layers and golden labels.
Meanwhile, based on the long-tailed distribution of word frequencies in the
data, GLMD designs a strategy of vocabulary compression through decreasing
vocabulary size instead of dimensionality. Experimental results show that our
method outperforms 25 state-of-the-art methods on the SuperGLUE benchmark,
achieving an average score that surpasses the best method by 3%. | [
-0.5264645815,
-0.8233678937,
0.4683513045,
-0.0619455352,
-0.692255795,
0.0703349411,
-0.091036208,
-0.3610408902,
-0.1866301894,
0.3720922172,
-0.1779723465,
-0.5304445028,
-0.7776716352,
-0.4139412344,
-0.5128989816,
1.1585341692,
0.1464230269,
-0.183686167,
-0.1942046285,
0.0603681356,
-0.3392166495,
-0.792792201,
-0.6373178959,
-0.744792819,
0.3894067109,
0.0350768082,
0.8488271832,
0.685827136,
0.1975408196,
0.3058258295,
-0.4280696809,
0.321464777,
-0.2983804047,
-0.029354861,
-0.0829685479,
-0.2243980467,
-0.2950158715,
0.2591861784,
0.1488330513,
0.6738389134,
-0.4786741138,
0.3072603047,
0.4016396701,
1.0186012983,
-0.5181394815,
0.1885143369,
-0.7214446068,
-0.0177867673,
-0.248947829,
-0.0123626692,
-0.3101628125,
-0.2516853511,
0.2831388116,
-0.4157431424,
0.2317121774,
0.322805196,
1.0223989487,
0.2175343335,
-0.2282325029,
-0.3117511868,
-1.017822504,
0.6998895407,
-0.6961634755,
0.2034558505,
0.5070114732,
0.4716793001,
0.011436007,
-0.9483056068,
-0.6883336306,
-0.3211623132,
0.0336312801,
-0.1433510929,
-0.2715324461,
0.2592203617,
0.1366113275,
0.3372932076,
-0.4199899137,
0.1004317254,
-0.425280422,
-0.0693137273,
0.3052233458,
-0.1854634136,
0.2549418509,
0.1923722774,
-0.4383319914,
-0.2379490286,
-0.5821329951,
-0.249193117,
0.432600826,
0.3740332425,
0.1155503467,
0.3976115882,
-0.134613961,
0.8919889927,
-0.0675049722,
-0.3480288386,
0.264570117,
-0.2462007403,
-0.3920455277,
0.063343592,
0.6942782402,
0.3223255575,
0.3369862735,
-0.2711542547,
-0.2610941529,
0.0881541893,
0.0023257777,
-0.8215180635,
-0.6160074472,
0.3953983486,
-0.1393969953,
-0.2042858452,
-0.3632202446,
-0.3522854745,
-0.1313153356,
-0.5670529008,
0.5411019921,
-0.4435776174,
-0.2151046842,
0.2849961221,
-0.3805510998,
-0.2822287679,
0.1490798146,
-1.0357391834,
0.3561149538,
0.6277567744,
0.9186390042,
0.2105514109,
-0.0838551521,
-0.289129585,
0.3953518271,
-0.3205972016,
0.568167448,
-0.5421369672,
-0.3974170685,
-0.2196393907,
-0.3240648508,
0.2846040726,
-0.751000762,
0.6303714514,
-0.4927631915,
0.2232276201,
-0.0347028673,
-0.6808534265,
-0.4117130041,
0.1010368168,
-0.6668966413,
0.9817254543,
0.0409666449,
-0.8948218226,
0.2159951925,
-0.2696688771,
-0.2562259436,
0.1179159284,
0.0131957596,
-0.275341332,
0.456445545,
0.3636661172,
0.3993096054,
-0.5018765926,
0.521101594,
-0.0757601634,
-0.1357026696,
-0.1001341641,
-0.6528816223,
0.5153098702,
0.3386186361,
-0.1085357144,
-0.3582959175,
-0.8160539269,
0.2601152062,
-0.1108137295,
-0.5481497645,
-0.7254354358,
0.0779998451,
-0.1694520414,
0.341648519,
0.3248176575,
-0.3640924394,
0.3209194243,
-0.1778700799,
0.4028891623,
0.6011558771,
-0.1396707892,
0.3330749273,
-0.0553580634,
0.2409408391,
0.1926472932,
0.2215344161,
0.421156168,
-0.5529148579,
-0.6892406344,
-0.0984846428,
0.6575422883,
0.599039495,
-1.0907505751,
0.6736036539,
-0.193361342,
-0.7682255507,
-0.5168810487,
0.344229728,
0.7149416804,
0.6937555075,
0.6977087259,
0.0712062567,
-0.3420730829,
-0.99432832,
-0.0173732284,
-0.4816537797,
-0.2335150093,
-0.0350644402,
0.2199588269,
0.0209790394,
0.8826652169,
-0.7071994543,
-0.5175250173,
-0.2512857616,
0.4845421612,
0.4015851617,
0.3229982555,
0.4797178507,
-0.784234643,
-0.5129520893,
0.1058674604,
-0.5087612867,
-0.2874719799,
0.2988213301,
-0.0609030835,
0.0322260372,
0.5934278369,
-0.393850863,
0.0411165133,
1.106118679,
-0.035907235,
0.5849457979,
-0.7066159844,
-0.2223410308,
-0.881157577,
0.1094829366,
0.2094708383,
0.0167460479,
-1.12943995,
0.0333086625,
0.1146354526,
0.1182798445,
-0.6014689803,
0.3975484669,
-0.6436231732,
0.4953403473,
-0.4272380173,
0.0596664473,
0.2989458442,
0.2761282623,
0.0209174342,
0.5263339281,
0.4641308188,
-0.5988522768,
0.4642985463,
-0.248533383,
-0.7741870284,
0.1905671656,
-0.810974896,
0.3947149217,
-0.361626029,
0.2615662515,
-1.1861703396,
0.2768580019,
0.0883932784,
-0.0090012792,
0.525901854,
-0.2723036408,
-0.4988299012,
-0.6479791403,
-0.0061978293,
0.1663765162,
0.6929604411,
-0.3286022544,
0.5969680548,
0.4312237501,
-0.1088335514,
-0.5222556591,
-0.9644338489,
0.1588652134,
-0.5813704133,
-0.5188378692,
0.3951506317,
-0.1070422456,
-0.0497163124,
0.0596631095,
-0.1580504179,
-0.1358108819,
0.0688499138,
0.0234591477,
0.3736020923,
0.0711644292,
0.2537935376,
0.1202628538,
-0.2000017315,
-0.1845471114,
-0.5095055103,
0.6342933774,
0.1679041237,
-0.0154481903,
-0.2842671573,
0.1484388113,
0.3462802768,
0.0137485061,
0.7490178347,
0.5256197453,
-0.3272506297,
-0.2670956254,
-0.6719356775,
0.1941652447,
-0.5006691813,
0.4008823037,
-0.345634073,
-0.7878651023,
0.3449125886,
-0.1744557619,
0.0029122578,
0.25342834,
0.2131753862,
0.0136928614,
1.0710109472,
0.5821214318,
-0.4617396891,
0.1969771981,
-0.227248922,
0.3321223259,
-0.81308043,
-0.1241516173,
-0.8315688968,
-0.4386630654,
-0.0579099432,
-0.5288459659,
0.3872925639,
0.7805941105,
0.189420864,
0.0924696848,
-0.7010212541,
0.6480478644,
0.5602150559,
0.0382633917,
0.3286474049,
0.3315664828,
-0.292558372,
0.1117156595,
-0.46189484,
-0.4651370645,
0.8724783063,
0.3799772263,
0.7007209063,
0.0609077886,
0.847674489,
0.1492982507,
0.1979284137,
-0.5585839748,
0.5378701687,
-0.6883301139,
-0.6585354209,
-0.5803286433,
-0.3059669733,
-0.6404517889,
0.5404006839,
0.1484691203,
-0.7496166825,
0.050558608,
0.2900741696,
-0.5527456403,
0.0887595341,
-1.0388562679,
0.4239681959,
-0.1327867955,
0.0206700712,
0.0977920741,
-0.5652421713,
0.5088478327,
-0.3093417287,
0.5600454211,
-0.3463506699,
0.0282520503,
0.7876405716,
-0.887045145,
0.6464194655,
-0.62774086,
-0.3635194302,
0.45760566,
-0.0327047072,
0.7310832739,
-0.3934599161,
-0.0046745371,
0.1333546638,
-0.0920581967,
-0.0093230903,
-0.7716148496,
0.5324441791,
-0.6555323601,
-0.7851477861,
-0.0513943098,
-0.247281611,
-0.333489269,
0.0091799498,
0.2629876435,
0.5856047273,
0.0629464909,
0.1153732911,
0.5827355385,
0.0159079973,
0.4463902414,
0.2193565667,
-0.4569394886,
-0.3017130196,
1.034614563,
0.5891520381,
0.5255969167,
0.1562312543,
0.5451728106,
-0.612767756,
-0.8793532252,
-0.3893119991,
-0.0538538583,
-0.6587525606,
-0.1225601733,
-0.6300839186,
-0.443176657,
-0.2660212517,
0.2372782975,
-0.2803052962,
-0.3870463669,
-0.2285943329,
-0.0922204033,
0.1809849739,
0.5088406801,
-0.2356803417,
0.3474640846,
-0.8915413022,
0.6717507839,
0.5722231865,
-0.0363259912,
0.148666352,
-0.5798285007,
-0.3456701338,
0.2914459109,
-0.0156977847,
-0.4347991049,
0.4613421857,
0.7613065243,
0.4635424614,
0.3495007455,
0.1402796805,
0.8585478663,
-0.7817024589,
0.8541721106,
0.442879349,
-0.79014498,
0.5593140125,
0.1241605356,
0.4438146055,
0.5460900068,
0.6272874475,
-0.4788269997,
-0.3762294948,
-0.3655202091,
-1.213542223,
0.3800761402,
-0.0688786358,
0.2825495303,
-0.0399463214,
0.1034217775,
0.0703486726,
0.2757175565,
-0.2991443276,
-0.446265012,
0.1345315874,
0.0205947943,
-0.2998687029,
-0.4912571013,
-0.1222927719,
-0.282291621,
0.7649040222,
0.0932940692,
-0.3399864733,
0.0083797909,
-0.0081603955,
0.3848569691,
0.2802515328,
0.2120997906,
0.3597166538,
-0.3244561851,
0.3881337941,
-0.129332602,
-0.7355915904,
0.5883725882,
0.0340809114,
-0.1856542528,
0.1032042354,
0.016923001,
0.8736217022,
-0.0864232853,
-0.0499132946,
0.232557416,
-0.0292888563,
-0.4462850392,
0.2824780643,
0.1768726707,
0.4439409971,
0.2163586766,
0.5313720107,
-0.1479896307,
0.2820457816,
-0.5010331869,
0.0281679146,
0.1436666399,
-0.284519583,
-0.1750681698,
0.5573581457,
0.0574770048,
0.161292091,
0.6828475595,
-0.1476725787,
-0.2730745673,
0.2408176512,
0.4743166566,
0.9271859527,
-0.3759410679,
0.3436554968,
0.0637545213,
0.141760841,
-0.5624059439,
0.1229064167,
-0.0106555698,
-0.7666915059,
-0.5692086816,
-1.0813770294,
-0.1876704842,
0.3932081163,
-0.5459205508,
0.0977565795,
-0.3784134984,
-0.4454773068,
0.2517589629,
0.0491561666,
-0.5252903104,
0.3855797946,
0.4137377143,
0.9379454851,
-0.9300456047,
1.3205471039,
0.2893916965,
-0.0187721197,
-0.8716033697,
-0.2056581378,
0.0636463985,
-0.5343937278,
0.7934817076,
-0.0180127341,
-0.1964700222,
0.107016407,
-0.4215230346,
-0.7816488147,
0.8438180089,
0.50148803,
-0.9444710612,
-0.4117022753,
0.2076637447,
0.6964514256,
-0.1719174981,
0.0850594491,
0.6978840828,
0.5247815251,
0.5389316678,
-0.9057630897,
-0.1319804639,
-0.2755526304,
0.613048017,
-0.0491916388,
-0.3417838514,
0.8673852086,
0.0104528079,
-0.5252604485,
-0.1401796788,
0.7357962728,
0.3288069963,
-0.0969360173,
0.5561013222,
0.8081704974,
0.9123715758,
-0.2432251573,
0.7803441286,
-0.3299584687,
0.3985837698,
1.4549987316,
-0.306946367,
0.9044498801,
0.5193351507,
-0.3674346209,
0.3932539225,
0.382684648,
0.2613223493,
0.990258038,
0.6338831186,
-0.3106699288,
-0.0910204574,
-0.1315749586,
-0.7059130669,
0.217956692,
0.5076947212,
-0.1116656959,
-0.4332621992,
0.0919168368,
0.0702013969,
-0.1218387634,
-0.1761403829,
0.6182976961,
0.1063086987,
-0.5293088555,
0.9807193279,
-0.0751201659,
0.7982386351,
-0.7426233292,
0.1433016211,
-0.2095838487,
0.0354961939,
-0.0001368601,
-0.6572635174,
0.1007773876,
-0.2920333743,
-0.0921769813,
-0.1616462469,
0.6725361347,
-0.7933574915,
-0.5159031153,
0.4199662209,
0.4570483565,
0.2818078697,
-0.2688470781,
-0.5334067941,
0.1323509216,
-0.1344531476,
-0.4688144028,
0.382234782,
0.6640424728,
0.1849880368,
0.5313485265,
0.6852255464,
0.4335102141,
0.1057178378,
0.2772432864,
1.076477766,
-0.1934175938,
-0.4802658856,
-1.0648059845,
0.5724101067,
-0.1145537943,
-0.0528437197,
0.6096563935,
0.4311874509,
0.7335412502,
-0.0026891525,
0.9241836667,
0.0294509362,
0.3981901705,
-0.8479797244,
0.7001813054,
-0.4781233966,
0.258148551,
-0.2817709744,
-1.3141624928,
-0.3250071704,
0.1019913033,
-0.0889014974,
0.0407662652,
0.5896564126,
0.6361299753,
0.0959093794,
-0.1159060076,
0.5517590642,
0.1640099436,
0.5017373562,
0.4918487072,
0.6219638586,
-0.3375360072,
0.3947168291,
-0.4631543756,
-0.253403157,
-0.0373652913,
-1.0454460382,
-0.7247569561,
-0.6766527891,
-0.4373587072,
-0.3279369771,
0.2618546784,
0.47620067,
0.7099435925,
-0.5772374272,
-0.0578443594,
0.0307002291,
-0.2633650899,
-0.1529000401,
-0.1067671403,
0.4719656706,
-0.2949956357,
-0.878095448,
0.3493200839,
0.2900410295,
0.4354363978,
-0.3713932037,
0.0671428144,
-0.2058954686,
-0.0237312894,
0.5410709381,
0.0014317762,
-0.6739189029,
-0.4665823281,
-0.6679605842,
-0.1426222622,
-0.3292784691,
0.4387166202,
-0.8401533961,
0.4375964701,
0.6149042845,
0.1163765937,
0.3529075682,
0.175456807,
0.3981039226,
-1.0020127296,
0.3246563971,
-0.1683751494,
0.2574185133,
0.1500884593,
-0.1033974439,
0.4555053711,
-0.0165413376,
-0.4256931841,
-0.7873242497,
-0.077020362,
-0.5021256804,
-0.5369986892,
1.2050027847,
-0.3255841732,
-0.4266257584,
-0.2980416119,
-0.3320372701,
0.1650117636,
-0.239481613,
0.7411550283,
1.0459570885,
0.2433547974,
0.0850048587,
-0.5190646648,
0.5835834146,
-0.0244384371,
-0.4443331361,
0.3735378981,
0.3836918175,
0.0686031282,
0.358555913,
0.593688488,
-0.0532220192,
-0.4131117463,
0.0703158081,
0.0703010112,
-0.3327714801,
-0.6378326416,
-0.2055949867,
0.3847495615,
0.1155484319,
-0.2367566973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06624v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06624v2 | RestGPT: Connecting Large Language Models with Real-World RESTful APIs | 2023-06-11T08:53:12 | 2023-08-27T02:55:36 | Yifan Song, Weimin Xiong, Dawei Zhu, Wenhao Wu, Han Qian, Mingbo Song, Hailiang Huang, Cheng Li, Ke Wang, Rong Yao, Ye Tian, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Tool-augmented large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress
in tackling a broad range of tasks. However, existing methods are mainly
restricted to specifically designed tools and fail to fulfill complex
instructions, having great limitations when confronted with real-world
scenarios. In this paper, we explore a more realistic scenario by connecting
LLMs with RESTful APIs, which adhere to the widely adopted REST software
architectural style for web service development. To address the practical
challenges of tackling complex instructions, we propose RestGPT, which exploits
the power of LLMs and conducts a coarse-to-fine online planning mechanism to
enhance the abilities of task decomposition and API selection. RestGPT also
contains an API executor tailored for calling RESTful APIs, which can
meticulously formulate parameters and parse API responses. To fully evaluate
the performance of RestGPT, we propose RestBench, a high-quality benchmark
which consists of two real-world scenarios and human-annotated instructions
with gold solution paths. Experiments show that RestGPT is able to achieve
impressive results in complex tasks and has strong robustness, which paves a
new way towards AGI. RestGPT and RestBench is publicly available at
https://restgpt.github.io/. | [
-0.6894885898,
-0.7761396766,
0.6438679099,
0.3961580396,
-0.4565856159,
0.1077423468,
-0.4291186929,
-0.7904205322,
0.0677958503,
0.4098761678,
-0.9100969434,
-0.2660059333,
-0.4730729759,
0.1012988985,
-0.3982968628,
0.6847196817,
-0.2664583325,
0.0447490104,
0.1814992875,
0.2818374634,
-0.401370436,
-0.3285254538,
-0.8284384608,
-0.2184669077,
0.3542871475,
0.0507825539,
0.6445453167,
0.8544393182,
0.6406103969,
0.2633014321,
0.0269421488,
0.1517704427,
-0.4852300286,
0.3212673664,
-0.1154716387,
-0.4368377328,
-0.4273418486,
-0.1821008176,
0.1242173985,
0.609477818,
-0.2381642014,
0.3274894655,
-0.1445054114,
0.2610133886,
-0.3054430783,
0.1728447527,
-0.3765123487,
0.0868884847,
0.1247358695,
-0.166741997,
-0.0487149283,
-0.3762824237,
0.2916159928,
-0.2822499275,
-0.0621444657,
0.1199562028,
0.5796075463,
0.5217997432,
0.0838989392,
-0.2934266627,
-0.9853785634,
0.6109104156,
-0.8381061554,
0.5510960221,
0.2786864042,
0.5700885653,
-0.3473612964,
-0.8743845224,
-0.3884214461,
-0.299906671,
0.1981505305,
0.0826223344,
0.1002949923,
-0.0363057889,
0.2685701847,
0.2408615649,
-0.6493971348,
0.0662968159,
0.0509401895,
0.2319169343,
0.5072430968,
0.1322915852,
0.3751296997,
0.098517783,
-0.4308813512,
0.1350845695,
-0.7688897252,
0.0803843364,
0.3750389814,
0.6187129617,
-0.2990570068,
0.5274816155,
-0.1182147115,
0.7793456316,
-0.2867199481,
-0.0168213714,
-0.3841917813,
-0.1117221713,
-0.1073282138,
-0.0690967888,
0.5883241296,
0.1534303427,
0.3362517655,
-0.5722789764,
-0.3322075903,
-0.2213283181,
0.49746117,
-0.8014475703,
0.1468097568,
0.4027086198,
-0.379876405,
0.0965631008,
-0.1030490771,
-0.588572681,
-0.2178076357,
-0.5741881132,
0.143467024,
-0.3954083025,
-0.351184696,
0.0985694751,
-0.0603982769,
0.4277023673,
0.3370610774,
-0.7065500617,
0.4172296524,
1.1875059605,
0.9141702652,
-0.0089398203,
-0.4526331723,
-0.4409322739,
0.2781435847,
-0.081992358,
0.90613693,
-0.5785455108,
-0.4096537828,
0.0373488106,
-0.062847957,
0.4680964649,
-0.3436364233,
0.8312854171,
-0.526802063,
-0.1608469635,
-0.221650362,
-0.4467642307,
-0.1186040714,
0.6337985396,
-0.6319578886,
0.8683140874,
0.2887420654,
-0.4719531536,
0.0944785327,
-0.5580815077,
-0.6109235287,
0.0390061922,
-0.0125227403,
-0.1557161361,
-0.0488798209,
-0.205268383,
0.3712956607,
-0.5314042568,
0.1212841868,
-0.5288909078,
-0.5141072869,
0.1204868779,
-0.2718046606,
0.4671721756,
0.2046445608,
-0.5183122158,
0.2245387286,
-0.851121664,
0.277947247,
0.0717775524,
-0.5995116234,
-0.143217355,
-0.0388386734,
0.2270948142,
0.0648288205,
0.0916012898,
-0.5242339373,
0.4418183863,
-0.2488167435,
0.8663631678,
0.7446634173,
-0.2509087026,
0.1722494662,
-0.1277713627,
0.4335694313,
-0.8249650598,
0.3519396484,
0.0768978596,
-0.2768434286,
-0.507288754,
-0.3692798913,
0.3361471593,
0.6229727864,
-0.2737765908,
0.462595135,
-0.5851688385,
-0.7804771662,
-0.480035603,
-0.2482056916,
0.3154836297,
0.2250602841,
0.4026266932,
-0.2364351451,
-0.5476849079,
-0.6998020411,
-0.5801047683,
0.0427719541,
-0.2636389434,
0.2826021612,
0.2449236065,
-0.3934164941,
0.8685995936,
-0.3687941432,
-0.0139230285,
-0.2471404821,
0.1717794985,
0.0747265071,
0.4406088293,
0.2705037296,
-0.717238009,
-0.2469918728,
-0.111182563,
-0.3764275908,
-0.1711005121,
0.0704200119,
-0.1735392064,
-0.2585235834,
0.2292357385,
-0.7880246639,
0.085572049,
0.5152541995,
-0.1028914601,
0.7286730409,
-0.1270641983,
0.1198970377,
-1.07660079,
-0.0584851801,
-0.1254351288,
-0.427611351,
-0.5513017774,
0.3401348889,
-0.0904781744,
-0.506994009,
-0.4671317041,
0.5017880797,
-0.5153039098,
-0.4952282012,
-0.380523622,
-0.0834742188,
-0.2502643466,
0.4596978724,
0.0594533682,
0.7520168424,
0.4316222072,
-0.4285874665,
0.6512929201,
0.0618107356,
-0.1797375232,
0.2196758091,
-0.6506927013,
0.1238512918,
0.2444421947,
0.423535496,
-0.9269247055,
-0.4470118582,
0.1328902394,
-0.1575335115,
0.0580665283,
-0.5467318296,
-0.5564496517,
-0.0607752539,
-0.3524315953,
0.3327490985,
0.4264582992,
-0.4844893217,
1.1007306576,
0.1314471662,
-0.4553208053,
-0.2931753993,
-1.0389260054,
0.2966531813,
-0.0327811316,
-0.6505513787,
0.2645989954,
0.0896134451,
-0.1704093516,
0.2912139595,
0.0337943323,
-0.1842514127,
0.1287169456,
0.4734353125,
0.067983076,
-0.0575433634,
-0.326756835,
-0.1348795891,
-0.2389743626,
-0.0456909053,
-0.1728553623,
0.9741482735,
0.0546622984,
-0.9598956108,
-0.5846120715,
0.5148983002,
0.6663978696,
-0.45453462,
0.3535478711,
0.5134027004,
-0.308799535,
-0.2041013837,
-0.6076064706,
-0.0182563215,
-0.4245813191,
0.0832319111,
-0.5952503085,
-0.8853312731,
0.676726222,
-0.6217386723,
0.4656361341,
-0.2787450254,
0.3642116487,
0.2349963635,
0.8671822548,
0.3884319663,
0.0207156297,
0.5903656483,
-0.1982030571,
0.6337342858,
-0.872253716,
0.1062092334,
-0.4903974831,
-0.4459248483,
-0.5153046846,
-0.3427755237,
0.0657341331,
0.0842751041,
-0.3384770155,
0.321988374,
-0.4035938978,
0.3043031394,
0.6718297005,
-0.1307380348,
0.2806307077,
-0.1918037832,
0.3095766008,
0.3099282086,
-0.3751956224,
-0.5660501122,
0.6858679652,
0.085959211,
1.1070898771,
0.2347566783,
0.6341964006,
0.1820852757,
0.1376241297,
-0.7461740375,
0.6509355307,
0.177920565,
-0.2318771482,
-0.2952197492,
-0.3745492101,
-0.72404778,
0.2889160514,
-0.0012945344,
-0.3335259557,
-0.068493627,
-0.0843257606,
-0.5647682548,
0.3166725039,
-1.0843727589,
0.6588153839,
-0.5336177945,
-0.4536027908,
0.0085208714,
-0.5108084083,
0.1449188441,
0.2981111705,
0.3572767079,
-0.0134915663,
-0.2636367381,
0.1114781126,
-0.4575413465,
0.8188247681,
-0.0340665244,
-0.2956191599,
0.1817201078,
0.3595783114,
1.0580664873,
0.0851609707,
0.0369742103,
-0.0165220574,
-0.1342806816,
-0.3510600328,
-0.5353050828,
0.9574349523,
-0.6251414418,
-0.3661600649,
-0.1720536202,
-0.5329722166,
-0.3990675211,
0.2863994241,
-0.0897280574,
0.5413208008,
-0.1300942302,
-0.413733691,
0.3412632346,
-0.1172589436,
0.4684537351,
0.429353267,
-0.228443414,
-0.258685708,
0.7439109683,
0.2582150996,
0.2493317872,
0.1544652879,
-0.074834384,
-0.3893537819,
-0.6992946863,
-0.6929476857,
0.1404212862,
-0.4901477695,
-0.0612792373,
-0.3953606188,
0.0997230038,
-0.4628773034,
-0.3677428365,
-0.5225573182,
-0.2644436359,
0.1349886358,
-0.0938260853,
0.2744793892,
0.4463970959,
0.0919451565,
0.1147461236,
-0.8968756199,
0.2938875556,
0.382129848,
0.8423612118,
0.2772806585,
-0.0663068444,
0.0116362693,
0.0363463126,
0.2135952413,
-0.4261928797,
0.1615153104,
-0.0955865234,
0.3179164529,
0.3331148326,
0.0357115716,
1.0262446404,
-0.7391471267,
0.7584547997,
-0.1437039375,
-0.6244573593,
0.3225416243,
-0.384026736,
0.1984222531,
0.3401196003,
0.3089902401,
-0.7785257697,
-0.3894648552,
-0.4516082406,
-1.0748721361,
0.543751657,
-0.0323005468,
0.0896053463,
0.1676752716,
0.5175861716,
0.2900449634,
-0.0096675185,
-0.5189788342,
0.0589777566,
-0.0889041498,
-0.1409007162,
0.5189236403,
-0.1887796819,
-0.3502845764,
0.347506851,
0.591166079,
0.1312921345,
0.235595867,
0.1828688681,
-0.0620503947,
-0.1173666045,
0.5022059679,
0.4677121937,
0.9089557528,
-0.0458739772,
0.3010033667,
0.070503071,
-0.2519305646,
-0.0108033456,
0.4295114875,
-0.1408641934,
-0.3629678786,
0.7042863965,
0.7160760164,
0.3377515674,
-1.1292359829,
0.138904199,
-0.4607077539,
0.1731497496,
-0.4109660387,
0.1149344072,
0.394236058,
0.5849137902,
0.3429664969,
-0.1034267396,
0.143772468,
-0.6481613517,
-0.0616268255,
0.4223244786,
-0.4555075765,
-0.3538881838,
0.4309590161,
0.3973290324,
-0.6869239807,
0.1049590856,
-0.3365681767,
-0.5682049394,
0.1954357624,
0.5818514824,
0.7971790433,
-0.1060837209,
-0.2582283616,
0.0222420264,
0.1971446276,
-0.3183709979,
0.526172936,
0.0644406155,
-0.2317063808,
-0.9082329869,
-0.6742510796,
-0.5284734368,
0.1234186068,
-0.3232951164,
0.1065742821,
-0.5873823762,
0.0933439508,
-0.5311458111,
-0.2357601076,
-0.335752517,
0.0113776186,
0.0292067695,
0.9301723242,
-0.5013971329,
0.1891323924,
0.8975527883,
-0.2639828026,
-1.0302217007,
-0.0323328115,
-0.0960628316,
-0.7594336867,
0.2611933947,
-0.0308146905,
-0.3922012448,
0.2451896071,
-0.3864110708,
-0.7446662188,
0.9510225058,
0.4976306856,
-0.6239452362,
-0.007011543,
0.374019146,
0.3918995559,
-0.0362840407,
0.2302599102,
0.3989708722,
0.5571392179,
0.03706339,
-0.8909282684,
0.3117150962,
0.1087980792,
-0.0468747839,
0.3834509552,
-0.750007987,
0.7548414469,
-0.0183119923,
-0.2173368484,
-0.0371602364,
0.3098506033,
0.2062586993,
-0.2321104109,
0.51933074,
1.0513888597,
0.4185279608,
-0.1675940305,
1.2212139368,
-0.4368990958,
0.3698302805,
1.0113164186,
-0.3474149704,
0.8343827128,
0.4442104995,
-0.3486810327,
0.0414693356,
0.9340760112,
0.0502567962,
0.4807782173,
0.2820996642,
-0.4521180391,
-0.3130920827,
-0.262757659,
-0.4712968171,
0.2681774497,
-0.1283605397,
0.1163964048,
-0.5660694242,
0.0827436224,
0.0696817189,
-0.2058388591,
-0.307629317,
0.7819072008,
0.0667775795,
-0.6128439307,
0.4197466969,
-0.0492898859,
0.6397060156,
-0.7515719533,
-0.2324724346,
-0.1167688072,
0.154578954,
-0.1992458552,
-0.8379339576,
0.186695531,
0.3546892107,
0.0136243161,
-0.2668094933,
0.8031108975,
-0.3091625571,
-0.231251061,
0.5375253558,
0.562219739,
0.1076801494,
-0.2553995252,
-0.5529807806,
0.2654953003,
-0.2277245373,
-0.4587603807,
0.5545393825,
0.8886732459,
0.0688912868,
1.0076149702,
0.9090461135,
0.4536203146,
0.2285697311,
0.3370847106,
0.950735271,
-0.6145600677,
-0.6318161488,
-0.9803219438,
0.2037371546,
0.0985977799,
-0.0492463373,
0.4099884331,
0.7591933012,
0.9916453958,
-0.113740623,
1.0408984423,
-0.3252095282,
0.7534813881,
-0.2877630889,
0.4162945747,
-0.375660032,
0.1783925593,
-0.0093949009,
-0.9343908429,
-0.297480613,
0.2829593122,
-0.3184480369,
-0.2672090828,
0.2360539436,
0.5687382221,
-0.4312948883,
0.1224253103,
0.0052173585,
-0.0218145419,
0.7230206132,
0.215619728,
0.8949044943,
0.0361760631,
0.9232401252,
-0.1462157369,
-0.3065069914,
-0.2796083987,
-0.6950190663,
-0.63086766,
-0.1825089008,
0.2091658562,
0.0996522605,
0.0395991988,
1.2065386772,
0.5849089026,
-0.4750303924,
-0.1708972305,
-0.3039929271,
-0.0914528519,
-0.412079215,
-0.1655734777,
0.2744874656,
-0.389197886,
-0.7968680263,
0.2241756618,
0.4394192696,
0.1098281145,
-0.3618869483,
0.0132170459,
-0.1410809159,
-0.1903599948,
0.6956455112,
0.2455039173,
-0.7678704858,
-0.3949406147,
-0.1899448037,
0.0050200494,
-0.1219654083,
1.0148422718,
-0.3570317924,
0.0402813628,
0.4968892634,
1.237762928,
0.3644677699,
0.3433203995,
0.4810631871,
-0.4697095752,
0.027450446,
0.370241195,
0.3877322972,
0.3070528805,
-0.1365873516,
0.8334527612,
-0.0897914097,
-0.5805545449,
-0.9269880652,
0.5038858056,
-1.0630065203,
-0.3949564397,
1.0503140688,
-0.3338877857,
-0.3392215073,
-0.2616748512,
-0.4808503687,
0.4692409635,
-0.4179252088,
0.8822263479,
0.7454278469,
-0.6194257736,
-0.1991750151,
-0.7256003022,
0.32867378,
0.0325143114,
-0.9488843679,
0.5762138963,
0.3598408699,
0.2710244656,
0.2562934458,
0.3549100459,
0.1108561084,
-0.0298897251,
-0.1625662595,
0.2077952921,
-0.3219495416,
0.107522212,
0.1514722407,
0.2372258753,
0.3417455256,
0.0442856848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06615v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06615v2 | Empowering Molecule Discovery for Molecule-Caption Translation with Large Language Models: A ChatGPT Perspective | 2023-06-11T08:16:25 | 2024-04-22T17:41:43 | Jiatong Li, Yunqing Liu, Wenqi Fan, Xiao-Yong Wei, Hui Liu, Jiliang Tang, Qing Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Molecule discovery plays a crucial role in various scientific fields,
advancing the design of tailored materials and drugs. However, most of the
existing methods heavily rely on domain experts, require excessive
computational cost, or suffer from sub-optimal performance. On the other hand,
Large Language Models (LLMs), like ChatGPT, have shown remarkable performance
in various cross-modal tasks due to their powerful capabilities in natural
language understanding, generalization, and in-context learning (ICL), which
provides unprecedented opportunities to advance molecule discovery. Despite
several previous works trying to apply LLMs in this task, the lack of
domain-specific corpus and difficulties in training specialized LLMs still
remain challenges. In this work, we propose a novel LLM-based framework
(MolReGPT) for molecule-caption translation, where an In-Context Few-Shot
Molecule Learning paradigm is introduced to empower molecule discovery with
LLMs like ChatGPT to perform their in-context learning capability without
domain-specific pre-training and fine-tuning. MolReGPT leverages the principle
of molecular similarity to retrieve similar molecules and their text
descriptions from a local database to enable LLMs to learn the task knowledge
from context examples. We evaluate the effectiveness of MolReGPT on
molecule-caption translation, including molecule understanding and text-based
molecule generation. Experimental results show that compared to fine-tuned
models, MolReGPT outperforms MolT5-base and is comparable to MolT5-large
without additional training. To the best of our knowledge, MolReGPT is the
first work to leverage LLMs via in-context learning in molecule-caption
translation for advancing molecule discovery. Our work expands the scope of LLM
applications, as well as providing a new paradigm for molecule discovery and
design. | [
-0.2055117488,
-0.4827214777,
0.5762434006,
-0.2258539647,
-0.463229388,
0.3656664491,
-0.3488406837,
-0.2742811739,
0.0654664263,
0.4437180459,
-0.4657175541,
-0.6712314487,
-0.706798017,
0.2482808679,
-0.0906776562,
0.880518496,
-0.0313625969,
0.4091539681,
-0.5267794132,
-0.1317881942,
0.0556012094,
-0.5093066096,
-0.2450521588,
-0.3372725546,
0.4266228378,
0.4677291512,
0.0233389325,
0.4591931105,
0.9965321422,
0.1611634046,
-0.2734150887,
0.2642495036,
-0.5477962494,
-0.0014366612,
-0.2457862943,
-0.4324726164,
-0.5153208375,
-0.1064250469,
0.4542275965,
0.6382521391,
-0.1900431663,
-0.0619001985,
0.0166226141,
0.5100372434,
-0.3806318343,
0.4528301358,
-0.7932492495,
0.3268360496,
-0.2046532035,
-0.3573993146,
-0.2657666802,
0.2270214856,
0.4901124537,
-0.5551068783,
0.47870332,
0.3977312744,
0.7740456462,
-0.0038137916,
-0.7099161148,
-0.3852799833,
-0.2356978506,
0.7090919614,
-0.9277794361,
0.3025425076,
-0.1781404167,
0.4797998071,
-0.5348805189,
-0.6371561289,
-0.4073071182,
-0.5573120117,
-0.0127662644,
0.1334993392,
0.0100989221,
0.3580468595,
0.1690897942,
0.6456679106,
-0.7761368752,
-0.0954136699,
-0.3284168839,
-0.4015043676,
0.1222192422,
-0.0529638864,
0.2344440967,
-0.2344283462,
-0.7654654384,
-0.0490374714,
-1.1317586899,
-0.3131826222,
-0.0593571626,
0.587872684,
0.0374246463,
0.841014266,
-0.1340728253,
0.5432231426,
-0.1991962492,
-0.0169237331,
0.1324701309,
-0.2981190383,
-0.3410747647,
0.2159321606,
0.7540982962,
0.1665648222,
0.0785652176,
-0.0508703254,
-0.1208013147,
-0.3752195239,
-0.1861101687,
-1.3144117594,
-0.1643795222,
0.0466578081,
-0.3012304306,
-0.3052943945,
-0.0272648744,
-0.9918367267,
-0.553037405,
0.0229419209,
0.6536971927,
-0.5738456845,
0.0429768823,
0.0663689822,
-0.2193682194,
0.032387577,
0.2043934911,
-0.9275223017,
0.0275712181,
0.5718240738,
1.1361027956,
-0.5520766973,
-0.0794949681,
-0.7258512974,
0.4097201824,
-0.0443006493,
0.8580179214,
-0.6182225347,
-0.4305130541,
-0.0903736502,
-0.007777818,
-0.0000649847,
-0.6389127374,
0.1415901035,
-0.3452566564,
0.1503182799,
-0.135414511,
-0.9240459204,
-0.2462548912,
0.3577876091,
-0.5123157501,
0.2626360953,
0.0141584789,
-0.3624444008,
0.4112360179,
-0.9502505064,
-0.5065165758,
0.0906469002,
-0.3759130836,
-0.5014767647,
0.143219322,
0.4197572172,
0.6936198473,
-0.3149092495,
0.0982523859,
-0.1637400538,
-0.070595637,
0.4339610934,
-0.3122423589,
0.4432044625,
0.0750182346,
-0.2065984458,
0.0696980804,
-0.6155905724,
-0.2572381794,
-0.137090385,
-0.6407123208,
0.2041553557,
-0.1767858118,
0.0412108637,
0.1021756455,
0.1914051324,
-0.5459505916,
0.5038397908,
-0.4135162532,
0.7525789142,
0.5268899798,
0.1849776953,
0.6678948998,
-0.0079375952,
0.7149577737,
0.1499189734,
-0.3465631902,
-0.45976758,
-0.3593821824,
-0.518458128,
-0.517442584,
0.2935684323,
0.3123364747,
-0.5269114971,
0.065114595,
-0.6322469711,
-0.341809839,
-0.0469484329,
0.4442788363,
0.4402369857,
0.4420544207,
0.4653063118,
-0.3200879395,
-0.4038800597,
-0.9514374137,
-0.2757691145,
0.0869039372,
-0.1497570574,
0.6481589675,
0.6424061656,
-0.3087595999,
0.7242751122,
-0.4780188203,
-0.6711118817,
-0.6057279706,
-0.1453820318,
0.2292031795,
0.501588285,
0.2754639983,
-0.878336966,
-0.442360878,
0.3656153083,
-0.4413837194,
-0.0728721991,
0.1137488261,
-0.2452745885,
0.1263490915,
0.7423981428,
-0.7608968019,
0.0676246881,
0.5033430457,
-0.0307239462,
0.0900342464,
0.1921144724,
0.0003648972,
-1.3067626953,
0.2014726102,
-0.1446429938,
-0.3973241448,
-0.4966244698,
-0.01500112,
-0.0332877673,
-0.2702283859,
-0.7641560435,
0.6406574249,
-0.4839855134,
0.0518381707,
-0.2296940684,
0.142004624,
0.1057523713,
0.6918134689,
0.2090714425,
0.7532163262,
0.4151284099,
-0.3041119576,
0.1314511895,
0.2606954575,
-0.3387691379,
0.3322241008,
-0.4657443762,
-0.1306112409,
0.0606255382,
0.4254721403,
-0.9391484261,
-0.6833564639,
0.2695035934,
-0.4711405039,
0.4451206923,
-0.5913743973,
-0.3490694165,
0.0285055321,
0.0074669244,
0.360144496,
0.4366378486,
-0.6599825621,
0.8294808865,
0.3095825315,
-0.0396571271,
-0.3408636451,
-0.7583152652,
0.0828248188,
-0.3321955204,
-0.4193506539,
0.4891247451,
-0.0002832634,
0.1396898478,
-0.4058508277,
-0.4731821716,
-0.1605371386,
-0.2369257957,
0.273797065,
0.0576039627,
-0.2147999853,
0.3529117107,
-0.0966800228,
-0.0904802904,
-0.1768832207,
-0.5282129645,
0.6191452742,
-0.4072124064,
-0.1415213495,
0.0302697681,
0.2190222144,
0.7022869587,
-0.2936607003,
0.4721607268,
0.451156497,
-0.1299415082,
-0.2173817009,
-0.134567216,
-0.4698612988,
-0.4635941684,
0.5691287518,
-0.1457179785,
-1.1232901812,
0.3085884154,
-0.4233312607,
-0.194102183,
0.0782773197,
0.6970458031,
-0.1164124906,
0.5540758967,
0.5595839024,
0.0718537048,
0.5179205537,
-0.2932463884,
0.3984085619,
-0.7797521949,
-0.15540196,
-0.0349148884,
-0.2481816113,
-0.3572844565,
-0.6914369464,
0.6864354014,
0.0209905636,
-0.0502204001,
0.6247414947,
-0.2686474919,
0.674726367,
0.5479294062,
0.1880185306,
0.2879808247,
0.4287798405,
-0.3101536334,
0.1019926146,
-0.8757141829,
-0.3850761354,
1.2303144932,
0.0859147459,
0.5494508743,
0.3253325224,
0.6434651017,
0.0795601159,
0.0748288631,
-0.8404765725,
0.7505258918,
0.032050658,
-0.6929124594,
-0.2075594813,
-0.4550461769,
-0.838314414,
0.2630640864,
-0.213523984,
-0.5289849043,
0.0763059035,
0.4473312199,
-0.1796839535,
0.2954597175,
-0.6172732115,
0.9210684896,
-0.1507297605,
-0.3696239591,
-0.2174042016,
-0.7844794989,
0.2439414412,
0.0509211533,
0.0197207816,
-0.3351283967,
-0.1207519248,
0.4598820508,
-0.3731143475,
0.7245208025,
0.0471299253,
-0.1451226026,
0.2963837385,
0.2769165635,
0.3608249128,
0.0952090397,
0.2906795442,
0.1810348928,
-0.0977642983,
-0.4171647429,
-0.6206082106,
0.6646882892,
-0.0434395112,
-0.5675930977,
-0.3536789417,
-0.474134624,
-0.1034996286,
0.4109415412,
0.5024878383,
0.4126833975,
-0.0949768201,
0.428353548,
0.6551394463,
-0.2435591072,
0.276788801,
0.5928719044,
-0.3583678007,
-0.3852429688,
1.1415979862,
-0.2211437225,
0.5463016033,
1.0259366035,
0.1958066821,
-0.1271278262,
-0.6318832636,
-0.5275562406,
-0.0557718091,
-0.7094954848,
-0.5021051764,
-0.4770020247,
-0.0267386883,
-0.2813161612,
-0.1851662248,
-0.4326809645,
-0.5074844956,
-0.1063144058,
-0.2271579057,
0.4393194914,
0.11047104,
-0.0835023746,
0.1989428699,
-0.8161274195,
0.2855838835,
0.2145933509,
0.1694714725,
-0.3123261034,
-0.3857028186,
-0.3870998323,
0.0907129571,
-0.3253258169,
-0.5916807055,
0.4304443896,
0.4911825955,
0.4170436263,
0.4006143212,
-0.3299993873,
0.3734280169,
-0.5936665535,
0.7437079549,
0.0093507608,
-0.8716524243,
0.5609616637,
-0.5838432312,
0.2172954977,
0.369399488,
0.1997248828,
-0.3929184675,
-0.0844725743,
-0.4314464331,
-1.0217380524,
0.2512134612,
0.5118762255,
-0.0126049761,
0.0913055465,
0.1586416811,
0.1172469258,
0.5739096999,
-0.9581869841,
0.0477235578,
-0.0728457272,
-0.1900160909,
-0.0816766769,
0.0656465665,
-0.2038411796,
-0.0950290859,
0.6878157854,
-0.4142957032,
0.4792200029,
0.3385736048,
-0.3461584449,
0.2349020988,
0.4357632995,
0.6663396955,
0.2645612061,
-0.4031421542,
0.2443927228,
0.1442827284,
-0.5210775733,
0.0902805254,
0.1311763674,
0.115626432,
-0.1110720113,
0.6085698009,
0.5992158651,
0.2619818151,
-1.3116391897,
0.6877295971,
0.3621224165,
-0.082377851,
-0.100906983,
0.2378023118,
0.2143717259,
0.319868505,
0.3474332392,
0.158044368,
0.2410035282,
-0.5487623811,
0.1788904965,
0.525421083,
-0.3128179908,
-0.057388965,
0.5420241356,
0.1713408977,
-0.0263835844,
0.2745953798,
-0.0237811971,
-0.6390141249,
0.6565948725,
0.3256844878,
0.8377121687,
0.0051909941,
-0.005220803,
0.1749950349,
0.0136342002,
0.0878356099,
-0.0674586594,
-0.2764247656,
-0.6810088754,
0.0384564288,
-0.5484277606,
-0.4797570109,
-0.117911227,
-0.4008680582,
0.2563590705,
-0.2584143877,
0.2314303219,
0.0128345229,
-0.1349707991,
-0.5076465607,
-0.0540762134,
0.0772841573,
0.7775227427,
-0.4721524417,
0.7916282415,
0.5728514791,
-0.3255464733,
-0.213677004,
-0.034695629,
0.2002419978,
-0.6100145578,
0.6093638539,
0.4766995013,
-0.0364984162,
0.1411645859,
-0.7412666082,
-0.9411736131,
1.2881807089,
0.4243164062,
-0.9003711939,
0.1684032679,
0.3029211462,
0.6312826872,
-0.5874375701,
-0.1078829691,
0.400265336,
0.3119017482,
0.3263344467,
-0.6961185336,
-0.0483822674,
-0.1621708572,
-0.1534303427,
0.0420573354,
-0.5964590907,
0.636992991,
-0.3315781653,
-0.2714485228,
0.2013312727,
0.5279446244,
0.4792044759,
0.1744053811,
0.084687598,
0.267923981,
0.50653404,
0.0167584475,
0.9290699363,
-0.2117171586,
0.367431283,
1.1078090668,
-0.2244064808,
0.9504958987,
0.8565258384,
-0.1263165325,
0.183016479,
0.5050114393,
-0.3256333768,
0.6545732617,
0.4839669168,
-0.5126853585,
-0.286085844,
-0.088407144,
-0.1284554899,
0.3523930013,
0.573372066,
-0.5634450912,
-0.2560719848,
0.372117728,
-0.136598736,
-0.0939058587,
-0.1721257418,
0.5815816522,
0.2134836763,
-0.3560915589,
0.394492954,
-0.1231015176,
0.4955658019,
-0.5395761132,
-0.2948246598,
-0.3068369329,
0.1947102547,
0.0740334839,
-0.5333529115,
-0.2066985071,
-0.2155443132,
-0.1425875127,
-0.0189708192,
0.4513267577,
-0.7635199428,
-0.5745496154,
0.0661679283,
0.3731368184,
0.2275367826,
-0.2047388107,
-0.3285834193,
-0.206781134,
0.2629846632,
-0.3152277172,
0.326712817,
0.3444587886,
0.1635073721,
0.8892832398,
0.4809807837,
-0.224620387,
-0.0518310256,
-0.3005945385,
0.8547818661,
-0.6262965798,
-0.0409337021,
-0.9751788974,
0.2809117436,
0.0540339984,
-0.1657211632,
0.6376979947,
0.9878687859,
0.7715091705,
-0.4248855412,
0.8226305842,
-0.023694722,
0.4260289371,
-0.9352045059,
0.6278746128,
-0.5106320381,
0.4042696655,
-0.2078245878,
-0.8432043195,
-0.602641046,
0.653495729,
-0.0033034922,
-0.0646874607,
0.6416011453,
1.3224104643,
-0.3216224313,
-0.2499514967,
0.2364060134,
0.3771791756,
0.7571305633,
0.8584135175,
0.5442836285,
-0.3610044718,
0.8107233047,
-0.0822504833,
0.1762722433,
-0.4803124964,
-1.1005159616,
-1.3149769306,
-0.6396093965,
-0.1449933052,
-0.2387354225,
0.0523717813,
1.3106753826,
0.6425827146,
-0.9259589911,
-0.1550255269,
-0.6177181005,
-0.1121724248,
0.1246321946,
-0.2012937516,
0.5094687939,
-0.0125660254,
-0.8799009919,
0.7351415753,
0.5161263347,
0.5496852398,
-0.2627492547,
-0.002982138,
-0.0262261909,
-0.1457032263,
0.6425433755,
0.3591561913,
-0.7811483741,
0.1194704324,
-0.0261342004,
-0.0503763109,
0.3385885954,
0.9348651171,
-0.7474913597,
0.3736222386,
0.5334065557,
0.5365236998,
0.6806285977,
-0.1899604052,
0.9596999884,
-0.7685963511,
0.2596048117,
0.3397067487,
0.4542917609,
0.4144911766,
-0.3482781649,
0.6959971189,
0.2697335184,
-0.4656602442,
-0.8077305555,
0.3812742829,
-1.323312521,
-0.3455286622,
1.2597990036,
-0.0634639487,
-0.2064577341,
0.4012820423,
-0.4330974519,
-0.0147823486,
-0.6368113756,
0.688007772,
0.653736949,
-0.1458966434,
-0.223195523,
-0.4917458892,
0.7699360251,
0.3803115785,
-0.5483654737,
0.2592906356,
0.547026217,
0.2123519927,
0.0280104149,
0.0982854366,
-0.1292426139,
0.2068823129,
-0.1844997406,
0.0992894098,
-0.2732419372,
-0.302570194,
-0.1273695976,
0.1461115927,
-0.2786755264,
-0.0399957262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10042v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.10042v1 | A Pairing Enhancement Approach for Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2023-06-11T07:32:10 | 2023-06-11T07:32:10 | Fan Yang, Mian Zhang, Gongzhen Hu, Xiabing Zhou | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) aims to extract the triplet of an
aspect term, an opinion term, and their corresponding sentiment polarity from
the review texts. Due to the complexity of language and the existence of
multiple aspect terms and opinion terms in a single sentence, current models
often confuse the connections between an aspect term and the opinion term
describing it. To address this issue, we propose a pairing enhancement approach
for ASTE, which incorporates contrastive learning during the training stage to
inject aspect-opinion pairing knowledge into the triplet extraction model.
Experimental results demonstrate that our approach performs well on four ASTE
datasets (i.e., 14lap, 14res, 15res and 16res) compared to several related
classical and state-of-the-art triplet extraction methods. Moreover, ablation
studies conduct an analysis and verify the advantage of contrastive learning
over other pairing enhancement approaches. | [
-0.6483647227,
-0.5434420705,
0.3940624595,
0.365056783,
-0.5633969307,
0.4115628302,
-0.1255461574,
-0.696080029,
0.5965877771,
0.6358623505,
-0.4404440224,
-0.4160316586,
-0.4694724679,
0.0753180757,
-0.1617887169,
1.458625555,
-0.0669057369,
0.244068861,
0.0528594553,
-0.3202342391,
-0.2952262163,
-0.4362318218,
-0.812767446,
-0.5616877675,
0.2773385942,
0.5188163519,
0.4395090938,
0.0956845284,
0.6600918174,
0.2174627781,
-0.2641586661,
0.1403467208,
-0.0157603528,
0.1579161286,
-0.0965083316,
-0.2325206548,
-0.6210017204,
0.2937141657,
0.4771601558,
0.6987272501,
0.2415545881,
-0.2423454523,
0.3512045741,
1.1162474155,
-0.3962906897,
-0.025954891,
-0.3729682863,
-0.143514201,
0.05451997,
-0.2321671546,
-0.0041368171,
-0.4080345929,
0.374543339,
-0.269576937,
0.4993954003,
0.072940886,
0.8913229704,
-0.1790938228,
-0.3896710277,
-0.2183313668,
-0.5204228759,
0.5765196681,
-0.456433177,
0.2520693541,
0.1092537716,
-0.1754378825,
0.4926243424,
-0.1932948083,
-0.6539697647,
-0.0464799814,
-0.3133957684,
0.5322538018,
0.1265615672,
0.276805222,
0.0836603343,
1.1078292131,
-0.116053924,
-0.0946222991,
-0.3761003911,
-0.0120579563,
0.6469995975,
-0.1855416298,
0.2202649564,
-0.8028715253,
-0.6231644154,
0.0248158202,
-0.7463384867,
0.1804267913,
0.5522320867,
0.1932299286,
-0.2857092321,
0.4420011044,
-0.1870426983,
0.2778590024,
0.23421444,
0.5970076919,
0.5780081153,
-0.6273015141,
-0.1653013229,
-0.0644921064,
1.0650517941,
0.4427156746,
-0.600887537,
-0.1654501855,
-0.5220934749,
0.0882412717,
0.2288469523,
-0.5766210556,
-0.5381820798,
0.3887282014,
-0.3559535146,
-0.6995138526,
0.4371613562,
-1.1656702757,
-0.5356383324,
-0.1886041164,
0.6967385411,
-0.5781365037,
-0.6113232374,
0.1683525592,
-0.2876800001,
0.3576238155,
0.1819081455,
-0.9686474204,
0.3032674789,
0.9889261127,
0.7806650996,
-0.4372032583,
-0.2114825398,
-0.3765732646,
-0.1375595927,
-0.07409513,
1.0149966478,
-0.5845034122,
-0.6367881298,
-0.0927331373,
-0.3463383317,
0.2600682974,
-0.4416784644,
0.5313854218,
-0.706441462,
0.3840225041,
-0.3251417279,
-0.4007430375,
-0.5453411937,
0.331848532,
-0.7804191113,
1.0352545977,
-0.0209141839,
-0.941084981,
0.3861143887,
-1.156842351,
-0.5398852825,
-0.0177375507,
-0.2372304201,
-0.5097386837,
0.3080071211,
0.6916137338,
0.3834937513,
-0.2907474339,
-0.1863228083,
-0.1707072109,
0.1455578953,
0.1980104446,
0.0073609506,
0.8270040751,
-0.1628868431,
-0.4534900486,
0.2758072615,
-0.3986356258,
-0.2250806093,
-0.1627466828,
-0.1876809895,
-0.4193507135,
-0.3234881163,
-0.0038020147,
0.0235951226,
0.2257589549,
-0.8671373725,
0.1409988403,
-0.8420439363,
0.461047411,
0.6868137121,
0.4247407019,
0.586859107,
-0.3484429717,
0.4507952332,
0.3845421076,
-0.0149734057,
0.0362847857,
-0.2833812535,
-1.221452713,
-0.0785518661,
0.2477132082,
0.3740866184,
-1.3015409708,
0.5299170613,
-0.246196419,
-0.2123504877,
-0.8610243201,
0.3218018115,
0.8253803849,
0.3665391803,
0.6010442972,
-0.3330032825,
-0.5434832573,
-1.0974309444,
-0.3801876903,
-0.2038254142,
0.2222823948,
0.1832042336,
0.3503816426,
0.2253587395,
0.8121083379,
-0.5401424766,
-0.1460995376,
-0.4127005935,
0.442037344,
0.207168594,
0.613486886,
0.2398998737,
-1.1382638216,
-0.6401762962,
0.2449516058,
-0.6376137137,
0.1506258845,
0.2185582817,
-0.0620674789,
0.2942824364,
0.377558291,
-0.0890136287,
0.0356615931,
0.4831069112,
-0.2763889432,
0.2715686262,
0.1740256101,
0.6027901173,
-1.4175411463,
-0.1419626623,
0.2991628647,
-0.1469179094,
-0.6903094649,
0.2880925238,
0.1441038549,
0.0883807018,
-0.2102789581,
0.3133624792,
-0.5405811667,
-0.0949920937,
-0.1633384973,
0.1127092913,
0.4222756326,
0.3696790636,
0.3167616427,
0.6381867528,
0.4910425246,
-0.105593957,
0.4441430271,
0.2418815941,
-0.0204186048,
0.8172543049,
-0.3589627445,
0.5266209841,
0.0377124883,
-0.0122172171,
-0.825252831,
-0.016869029,
0.1738631278,
-0.5803737044,
0.3742640018,
-0.0225873161,
-0.25976035,
-0.3021084666,
-0.931398809,
0.3279254436,
0.2559749782,
-0.9595221877,
0.6262896657,
0.241980359,
-0.2611713409,
-0.5959589481,
-0.4435106516,
-0.147634387,
-0.4797872305,
-0.5002975464,
0.4538212419,
0.027691137,
-0.2359180748,
-0.0080652563,
-0.2016035169,
-0.0052026971,
-0.0409118608,
0.1161994711,
0.7240272164,
-0.3561241925,
0.0143274758,
0.013668566,
-0.2585213482,
0.0948700085,
0.074714683,
0.5515272617,
-0.6262953281,
0.0373488478,
-0.4445560873,
0.5830566287,
0.1711524874,
-0.2409230173,
0.3187977076,
0.6343394518,
-0.1992842704,
0.0313340351,
-1.0335839987,
-0.42355147,
-0.4707856774,
0.2467766404,
-0.5085342526,
-0.6671150327,
0.3401114345,
0.401353538,
0.0893945917,
0.643807888,
0.1314063668,
-0.3032069504,
0.8789250851,
0.596352458,
-0.2208721936,
0.6908738017,
-0.3346118629,
0.1924602687,
-1.4198828936,
-0.1356319189,
-0.3065333962,
-0.1718355566,
-0.4931239486,
0.0325899757,
0.5286084414,
0.3633736968,
0.0491455495,
0.1748319119,
-0.5314723253,
0.5897610188,
0.7015205026,
0.8320004344,
0.5520989299,
0.1110603213,
0.3372449279,
-0.1232428625,
-0.1027212292,
-0.2708761096,
1.1492162943,
0.1102369279,
-0.0147991609,
0.3344347775,
1.096280098,
-0.030712761,
0.2672407329,
-0.8709133863,
0.4562680125,
-0.4120175838,
-0.3575208783,
-0.0134152826,
-0.4203397632,
-0.5261621475,
0.1986325085,
-0.58413589,
-0.5954986811,
0.1210125387,
0.1145000234,
-0.7760975957,
0.2308553755,
-0.6229615808,
0.4757442772,
-0.0783745795,
-0.4996426404,
-0.5316881537,
-0.731336832,
0.4247156382,
-0.044740025,
0.1194231212,
0.2308650911,
-0.126196146,
1.0619212389,
-0.1675967276,
0.5419666767,
-0.100456126,
0.1776204258,
-0.0507319979,
0.0762211978,
0.237173453,
0.3024695218,
-0.2118565291,
0.269431293,
-0.3499798775,
-0.3424719274,
-0.6868134141,
0.8643516898,
-0.9677680731,
-0.7721194029,
-0.1879538596,
-0.3378496468,
-0.6228192449,
0.0403109379,
0.3829949796,
0.5845305324,
0.0855509788,
-0.0163355768,
0.4374769926,
0.0573258661,
0.5974912643,
0.3256450593,
-0.165012002,
-0.9911352396,
1.0864690542,
-0.3564905524,
0.4934179485,
0.3117468655,
0.4262925386,
-0.1458115876,
-0.7213127017,
-0.207652688,
0.3791828156,
-0.5939823985,
-0.2386489213,
-0.9048000574,
-0.4748526812,
-0.4569194019,
-0.464554131,
-0.3464553952,
-0.4479569793,
-0.0679870248,
-0.1506450772,
0.7174860239,
0.9662085772,
-0.1739494801,
0.4271388352,
-0.853699863,
0.3775384724,
0.4407891631,
0.2706685662,
-0.2779699266,
-0.3819169104,
0.0660948232,
-0.1746276617,
-0.5135298967,
-0.9843835831,
0.3882027268,
-0.0911090001,
0.2118423879,
0.4435374141,
-0.1826838553,
0.5454756618,
0.0891486108,
0.9793792963,
0.5536110401,
-1.1918296814,
0.8170075417,
-0.3987580836,
-0.1780404747,
0.8023517728,
0.3074138463,
-0.2308293581,
-0.212662816,
-1.1201303005,
-0.8538070917,
0.9342988133,
0.2277778536,
-0.1119072884,
0.2092002928,
0.5013484955,
0.3243681192,
0.3910938501,
-0.9806547165,
-0.2523424625,
-0.2722401917,
-0.1224587113,
-0.138892144,
-0.3887414932,
-0.1353304535,
-0.2642742097,
0.905929327,
0.1988539249,
0.0993239209,
0.135287568,
-0.016061943,
0.177948311,
0.2068318278,
0.1118007749,
-0.1183741614,
-0.4136979878,
0.2474308461,
0.0953481942,
-0.4476319849,
-0.2260417789,
0.1537142098,
0.0567604192,
-0.3149235249,
0.2801932693,
0.7820547223,
0.0952257439,
0.1679441035,
0.9067283869,
0.1421673596,
-0.0664596558,
-0.0932863578,
-0.2029369175,
-0.1222982779,
0.3592964113,
0.0528318398,
0.2399465889,
0.4726760983,
-0.5069480538,
0.0396842994,
0.6639764905,
-0.8075088263,
-0.499759227,
0.1632653624,
0.7689589262,
-0.300922364,
0.4234894812,
-0.3212400973,
-0.8400869966,
0.5089886785,
0.3646841347,
1.1418471336,
-0.283372432,
0.0641350299,
0.5460597277,
0.1098036841,
-0.0193570349,
0.307338804,
-0.1612892151,
-0.993283689,
-0.150796771,
-0.6136412621,
-0.3933705389,
0.1539334953,
-1.0006349087,
0.5890241265,
-0.3338292837,
0.2044159025,
0.3263047636,
0.2516547441,
-0.4775357544,
-0.0351966172,
0.0424570329,
0.2454144657,
-1.161403656,
0.6948865056,
1.0584454536,
-0.8877173066,
-0.6622515321,
0.1592419147,
0.0815050974,
-0.8698328137,
0.5032420754,
0.363335073,
-0.328970015,
0.0726642534,
-0.321216017,
-0.2394978106,
0.6913117766,
-0.2236996442,
-0.1737473011,
0.0674011037,
-0.3037777543,
0.3105469048,
-0.5131357312,
0.302071631,
0.7602761388,
0.1420558691,
0.16617091,
-0.7984511852,
0.0881413221,
-0.4525895715,
-0.1601059437,
0.4065111578,
-0.5735546947,
0.8354987502,
-0.0254442561,
-0.227539286,
-0.2968673408,
0.7952270508,
0.0034659263,
0.0429929271,
0.8920243382,
0.2036801428,
0.2795455158,
0.0953270122,
0.7869648933,
-0.4256741405,
0.4178789556,
1.0317648649,
-0.0673349947,
1.1275900602,
0.7008032203,
-0.1088916659,
0.6773461103,
0.5337007046,
0.1807769686,
0.3845126033,
-0.3600680232,
-0.6196730137,
-0.3528732955,
0.1183574051,
-0.2143262774,
0.2291680127,
0.5624339581,
-0.3663550019,
0.0292474236,
0.1245827824,
0.2360173464,
0.141998142,
-0.5141665339,
1.1538712978,
0.1051088944,
-0.8157489896,
0.1051389426,
-0.3702389002,
1.0319093466,
-0.0419810265,
-0.1092518941,
-0.3706319928,
-0.0397788249,
-0.6425871849,
-1.0820944309,
0.3295705616,
-0.2229712605,
-0.3508198857,
-0.1532994807,
0.3946639895,
-0.4470229447,
-0.5407192111,
0.3344242871,
0.4275377691,
-0.1563848108,
-0.1877808869,
-0.6409835815,
-0.1861793846,
0.3810822666,
-0.194427982,
0.0036357874,
0.1778217554,
0.2879343033,
0.0923444256,
0.5664243102,
0.4357099533,
-0.4944728613,
-0.0246321391,
1.038582325,
-0.7387831807,
-0.6037902236,
-1.0415679216,
0.5859506726,
-0.7273743749,
-0.2016655356,
0.6094648242,
0.5754608512,
0.33000651,
0.3232015967,
0.9237167239,
0.0064395373,
0.7802268267,
-0.8607194424,
0.5798630714,
-0.4933983088,
0.6837139726,
-0.4039731324,
-1.0233209133,
-0.3880588114,
0.6185780764,
-0.5849009752,
-0.0918517634,
1.2760156393,
0.8628927469,
-0.0322284922,
0.8271205425,
-0.1020641774,
0.2284166962,
0.2677953541,
0.4417020679,
0.8612467051,
-0.5124109387,
0.3031203747,
-0.6588405371,
-0.5850169659,
-0.0487722494,
-0.6727406979,
-0.9769035578,
-0.7372301817,
-0.5352490544,
-0.8021307588,
0.0480789542,
1.1192572117,
0.3343566358,
-0.7728291154,
-0.0843304098,
-0.1833304465,
0.0006445406,
-0.1112130135,
-0.2353330851,
0.6866310239,
-0.4792585075,
-0.687153101,
0.3271718323,
0.3618007302,
-0.0234267693,
-0.3046391606,
0.3229092658,
0.0421144404,
-0.1074058488,
0.4510056376,
0.0355517864,
-0.5525152087,
-0.6660364866,
-0.4317998886,
0.078111507,
0.5661620498,
0.9195090532,
-0.4541335702,
0.5853844285,
0.3889163733,
0.3921536505,
0.5695168972,
0.1143599823,
0.6981679797,
-0.702036798,
-0.0581970662,
0.3214484453,
0.350282371,
0.557336688,
-0.3345663548,
0.5020710826,
0.2488221079,
-0.4870470166,
-0.5281699896,
0.3782929778,
-1.2831807137,
0.113844052,
1.4475027323,
0.0591404215,
-0.036368534,
-0.2288180441,
-0.2594617903,
0.0252938792,
-0.5803000927,
0.9456704259,
0.5863267183,
-0.4452138841,
-0.0247622989,
-0.3372329772,
0.6514527798,
0.6124547124,
-0.9000640512,
-0.0738644674,
0.2901503146,
0.1318772286,
0.2728163898,
0.4829550982,
-0.2049353868,
0.2399305403,
-0.0381100476,
0.3946356177,
0.1204606369,
0.0315103121,
-0.8187571764,
0.2267865092,
0.1940184534,
-0.315420717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06605v1 | Towards Diverse and Effective Question-Answer Pair Generation from Children Storybooks | 2023-06-11T06:55:59 | 2023-06-11T06:55:59 | Sugyeong Eo, Hyeonseok Moon, Jinsung Kim, Yuna Hur, Jeongwook Kim, Songeun Lee, Changwoo Chun, Sungsoo Park, Heuiseok Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in QA pair generation (QAG) have raised interest in applying
this technique to the educational field. However, the diversity of QA types
remains a challenge despite its contributions to comprehensive learning and
assessment of children. In this paper, we propose a QAG framework that enhances
QA type diversity by producing different interrogative sentences and
implicit/explicit answers. Our framework comprises a QFS-based answer
generator, an iterative QA generator, and a relevancy-aware ranker. The two
generators aim to expand the number of candidates while covering various types.
The ranker trained on the in-context negative samples clarifies the top-N
outputs based on the ranking score. Extensive evaluations and detailed analyses
demonstrate that our approach outperforms previous state-of-the-art results by
significant margins, achieving improved diversity and quality. Our
task-oriented processes are consistent with real-world demand, which highlights
our system's high applicability. | [
-0.3129057288,
-0.451528728,
0.1029733866,
0.2862853706,
-0.2483202666,
0.7443631887,
0.4265502989,
-0.2929587662,
-0.0543086492,
-0.0369841903,
-0.5529265404,
-0.2627452612,
-0.5463116169,
0.0808377042,
-0.4999308288,
1.1312686205,
0.0094301477,
-0.234753564,
-0.5592766404,
-0.2985642254,
-0.4296368361,
-0.261612922,
-0.6013462543,
-0.0366691761,
0.5354790688,
0.8131780028,
0.6637169123,
0.3441156745,
0.1985697746,
0.2133190781,
-0.0603347868,
0.3413647413,
-0.5603228807,
0.6138747334,
-0.1969659477,
-0.3971537054,
-0.1345577836,
-0.2153361887,
0.6004092097,
0.6391791105,
-0.1803072244,
0.5208903551,
-0.014157719,
0.5394597054,
-0.5602859259,
-0.1603897512,
-0.4355187118,
0.2383839339,
0.2468191385,
-0.2404167652,
-0.1493050754,
-0.7404381037,
0.1059716716,
-0.5694019198,
0.3998819888,
0.0679752156,
0.7200134993,
-0.0939027816,
-0.8390139341,
-0.3258086443,
-0.3562632799,
0.6235682368,
-0.6518753171,
0.1694045365,
0.1853675693,
0.3264789581,
-0.1978843808,
-0.6388999224,
-0.5790912509,
0.1705914885,
-0.1677543968,
0.2292930782,
0.1062951311,
-0.2703833878,
0.1289552152,
0.561902523,
-0.7283877134,
-0.1531152874,
-0.2309626788,
0.3467074633,
0.7885507345,
0.2085846364,
0.3657639623,
-0.113248691,
-0.106870681,
-0.1856940538,
-0.6925692558,
0.6698093414,
0.6470642686,
0.1320834458,
-0.0271387678,
0.4151707888,
-0.530790329,
0.7436689734,
0.4105580747,
-0.531768322,
0.3255432844,
-0.5052907467,
0.2635681033,
-0.2842603326,
0.304564327,
0.4550565183,
-0.0924019217,
-0.352601409,
-0.1981358528,
-0.1807649434,
0.0297375172,
-1.0511552095,
-0.1090770066,
0.3164546788,
-0.2937797308,
-0.7401065826,
-0.0879351273,
-0.9266974926,
-0.2406549156,
0.1350454688,
0.5140641332,
-0.2382009774,
-0.3143038154,
0.0019555204,
-0.3946276903,
0.6101356149,
-0.0010528032,
-0.9718716741,
-0.0315308087,
0.2440466881,
0.1323511004,
-0.1395620257,
-0.0413346551,
-0.8997113109,
0.1726489812,
-0.2826803625,
0.7642059922,
-0.6684186459,
-0.6843469143,
0.06939888,
-0.4582493603,
0.0429029763,
-0.6086739302,
0.3390731514,
-0.5309084654,
0.8200419545,
-0.2511075139,
-0.429104805,
0.0326154716,
0.4428888261,
-0.3148058653,
1.1623034477,
0.48572281,
-0.6268520355,
0.7057668567,
-0.1152090654,
-0.6324709058,
0.3339053094,
-0.4108442068,
-0.5172284245,
-0.0909439623,
0.6436089873,
0.0027072686,
-0.3727273345,
0.5345841646,
0.0039243489,
-0.372575134,
0.1344831735,
-0.2094414681,
0.6196875572,
-0.029807223,
-0.3699136674,
0.0709403679,
-0.8627594709,
0.508363843,
0.173226878,
-0.5876665711,
-0.0783318803,
-0.0795075372,
-0.1238223165,
0.4686573148,
0.1966720074,
-0.5849553943,
0.1185667887,
-0.1634568721,
0.331129998,
0.4002662003,
0.3118556142,
0.1988409013,
-0.7793015838,
1.0348418951,
0.0570704266,
0.1826093644,
-0.2512548566,
-0.6310378909,
-0.6117643118,
-0.1838139743,
0.1604493111,
0.3574780226,
-1.1577875614,
0.5466552973,
-0.0850559324,
-0.5740967989,
-0.4995305836,
0.2503043115,
0.7270439863,
0.7312662005,
0.2203229517,
-0.1443870962,
-0.2860735953,
-0.7147023082,
-0.2501963377,
-0.5433623195,
0.1005676463,
0.5276639462,
-0.0887078866,
0.1796234846,
1.1328014135,
-0.3326434493,
0.3766227067,
-0.1463645548,
0.0274567287,
0.3245351017,
0.7104901671,
0.6222824454,
-1.2716007233,
-0.438459307,
-0.4391231239,
-0.7018188238,
-0.2441722006,
0.012455279,
-0.3532904387,
-0.1796376854,
0.0962379798,
-0.2534546256,
0.0848544464,
0.3905011415,
-0.8454944491,
0.3413444459,
0.2191934586,
0.3554742038,
-1.1319497824,
-0.0537458435,
-0.4491831362,
-0.1589319259,
-0.4553803802,
0.4996783733,
-0.0813845769,
-0.210857451,
-0.2859912515,
0.5543861985,
-0.0459169224,
-0.1016646624,
0.1854893118,
0.3277501762,
0.4005197883,
0.3541299999,
-0.3577971756,
0.9777610898,
0.2559194267,
-0.3022380471,
0.251665771,
0.5053709745,
0.1449567825,
0.6996747255,
-0.6808847189,
0.2009975761,
-0.3234425783,
0.2424875796,
-1.2141164541,
-0.0774232671,
0.194961071,
-0.6138777137,
0.2113522142,
0.0456634089,
-0.5353304744,
-0.481572777,
-0.4699522257,
0.750787437,
0.7248895764,
-0.9742436409,
0.4968207479,
0.184656933,
-0.4480399787,
-0.6603376269,
-0.2201448381,
-0.0239827763,
-0.1319136173,
-0.8688333035,
0.276509881,
-0.429505676,
-0.0601927042,
0.1835211515,
-0.4936552942,
-0.2154592425,
0.0697241351,
0.0511676818,
0.0625602305,
-0.5012664199,
0.4807284474,
0.7148380876,
0.2345312089,
-0.1822277009,
-0.1814600974,
0.3477658927,
-0.312930733,
-0.1863564104,
0.2669042945,
0.7375745177,
0.2253535986,
-0.6091681719,
0.4124821126,
0.4601682127,
-0.1529260278,
-0.5360836387,
-0.0889922529,
-0.0603364557,
-0.488799274,
0.2017434239,
-0.3551093638,
-1.2241677046,
0.2785598338,
0.2107655853,
0.4133046567,
0.0707510337,
0.2279367149,
-0.1976755112,
0.9368864298,
0.3852407634,
0.6649662256,
0.2355903387,
-0.0138905635,
0.2659430802,
-0.5058525801,
-0.226850152,
-0.2923724949,
-0.4096417725,
-0.5487400889,
-0.1876055747,
0.3807296455,
0.4810156524,
-0.0685539991,
-0.121994935,
-0.6399044394,
0.5325875878,
0.6881917119,
-0.0287599135,
0.516731441,
-0.1894416213,
0.1623675972,
0.1810143888,
-0.995307982,
-0.7055052519,
1.2506588697,
-0.0767747536,
0.1950594187,
0.4574131668,
1.3068550825,
0.30550614,
0.4983990788,
-0.4292019904,
0.5556223392,
-0.2144843936,
-0.8376327157,
-0.5118160248,
-0.1449262351,
-0.8065668344,
0.5819714665,
-0.3791773319,
-0.3468101919,
0.3585948944,
0.0525175333,
-0.5121132135,
-0.1660517454,
-0.6979305744,
0.6846212745,
-0.121806711,
-0.4325785935,
0.1801968813,
-0.6238675117,
0.5555992723,
-0.136744827,
-0.2749399543,
0.1000932232,
-0.0419257097,
0.7591706514,
-0.0689635724,
0.4838945568,
-0.1487241834,
-0.4746040404,
0.689358294,
-0.1378058195,
0.1757651716,
0.515817225,
-0.1302156746,
-0.5964857936,
0.0706314817,
-0.7465757132,
-0.6876246929,
0.6017623544,
-0.6972164512,
-0.8590056896,
-0.1968077421,
-0.8710604906,
-0.6784675717,
0.1926137209,
0.0911907852,
0.5425106883,
0.0109999841,
0.1873654574,
0.5899392366,
-0.3260325491,
0.456500411,
0.5552908182,
-0.3654679358,
-0.4698174894,
1.0223808289,
0.0465029031,
0.3161416948,
0.3648250103,
0.0343137905,
-0.2391840667,
-0.5278182626,
-0.5516837835,
0.063150771,
-0.7629767656,
-0.1301920563,
-0.5487675071,
-0.1601045877,
-0.4277426004,
-0.4287833869,
0.4087648988,
-0.7498109341,
-0.0885421932,
-0.4991356432,
0.2637122571,
0.4959940314,
0.2481895983,
0.2703776062,
-0.7972795367,
0.7810128927,
1.1029731035,
0.2888093591,
-0.1202204153,
-0.2251687646,
0.2239624411,
-0.2463081777,
-0.4239253104,
-0.8436033726,
0.030052172,
0.337633431,
0.6738917828,
0.1250812113,
0.2633469105,
0.4219192266,
-0.105271101,
0.9164417386,
0.0908467695,
-0.7919878364,
0.4051197171,
-0.4907303452,
0.1682397872,
0.7042520046,
-0.1406495869,
-0.2782175541,
-0.5759855509,
-0.7957509756,
-1.0223706961,
0.565737009,
0.2725095749,
0.1836641133,
-0.0350186117,
0.3093911707,
0.5459312797,
0.6044048071,
-0.4731568694,
-0.1862753332,
-0.6477835774,
-0.458402276,
0.0537256598,
-0.1307756007,
-0.1125354767,
-0.0425808318,
0.7246230245,
-0.359075278,
-0.2652202249,
0.1230188087,
0.022039298,
-0.2253255099,
0.4410476387,
0.1629635096,
0.6622613072,
-0.1001770794,
0.0676644892,
-0.1756714582,
-0.314943403,
0.643636167,
0.4024162889,
-0.6659074426,
-0.0563500337,
0.3738080263,
0.4736309648,
0.1079356,
-0.8940265179,
0.4624336362,
-0.1820304394,
-0.0742429867,
-0.0444770455,
0.4873435199,
0.2851039469,
0.4599333405,
0.5066182613,
-0.4698908627,
0.2013050914,
-0.2830782235,
0.4485795796,
0.2013327479,
0.0832023695,
0.0081731593,
0.46637097,
0.7388291359,
-0.5778871179,
0.38214764,
-0.5816069245,
-0.2331760973,
1.1121246815,
0.8267918229,
0.8761525154,
-0.0842922106,
0.7895024419,
0.326837182,
0.2693192363,
0.4687646329,
0.6668782234,
-0.4283944666,
-0.6933553815,
0.0671970397,
-0.3956625164,
-0.4986508489,
-0.0870137513,
-0.6896364689,
-0.1257507056,
-0.6196346283,
0.0619735904,
-0.4699620306,
-0.1250034273,
-0.5335016251,
0.5571243763,
0.0426070541,
0.4995433688,
-0.6729419827,
0.4027659297,
0.9179295897,
-0.6486190557,
-0.7455104589,
0.4076696038,
-0.6912109256,
-0.5913992524,
0.63476789,
0.2296575457,
-0.1207734942,
0.3175923228,
-0.4480108321,
-0.8984333873,
1.2973402739,
0.1201371327,
-0.3638121784,
-0.2918068767,
0.0427434966,
0.5657735467,
-0.5204938054,
0.0553780757,
0.2967135906,
0.2311683893,
-0.0283642616,
-0.3559394181,
0.1420548558,
-0.7572752237,
0.0749818236,
0.0591468811,
-0.7587287426,
0.7166497707,
-0.3780061305,
-0.2429576218,
0.1144913957,
0.7294352055,
0.9618317485,
0.4991819263,
0.5986276865,
0.2733040154,
0.5663180947,
0.2008564323,
0.7029437423,
-0.2591392994,
0.0498248152,
1.0888397694,
-0.1520198733,
0.5561996698,
0.6558433175,
-0.1651663333,
0.652166307,
0.578312099,
0.1442154795,
0.3544709384,
0.3241887689,
-0.4231997728,
-0.5511501431,
-0.2431878448,
-0.4074695706,
0.1976927817,
0.0258322507,
-0.2397026271,
-0.3923899829,
-0.2927601635,
-0.2220126092,
0.4544743001,
-0.0513531975,
0.4104736447,
-0.0112921838,
-0.9472610354,
0.50888592,
-0.1064258069,
0.594052732,
-0.4013627768,
-0.3039930165,
-0.5084056258,
-0.4775910974,
-0.195656091,
-0.8523703814,
-0.3985057175,
0.049486395,
-0.3787384033,
-0.1705940664,
0.5701473951,
-0.814961791,
-0.5517249107,
-0.0570223704,
0.8645958304,
-0.4368157983,
0.5708190799,
-0.3520325422,
-0.6349248886,
0.0543349162,
-0.2216574401,
0.2051045597,
0.3646720052,
-0.1759864837,
0.4609735906,
0.6180759072,
-0.376083076,
0.4294621646,
-0.0587971136,
0.8084668517,
-0.4160865247,
-0.7785093784,
0.0279561598,
0.7046917677,
-0.1278978735,
-0.8936335444,
0.5297840238,
0.3117149174,
0.5824504495,
0.0867485479,
0.8499049544,
-0.0914456844,
0.6347954273,
-0.0958468914,
0.4931491911,
-0.5382072926,
-0.0240818243,
-0.1680775881,
-0.8486506939,
-0.059397772,
0.270745188,
0.0686891079,
0.1359425634,
0.5432134867,
0.4107979834,
0.2571004331,
0.1929994076,
0.1362201571,
-0.3734619021,
0.6037551761,
0.8892793655,
1.0480388403,
-0.6535823345,
0.7519295812,
-0.1794796735,
-0.3660799265,
0.0539682247,
-0.6861301064,
-0.8260124922,
-0.384852767,
-0.4402695,
-0.1299947649,
0.2764241993,
0.6410147548,
0.3035358191,
-0.553889215,
0.0377236754,
-0.000048114,
0.3704323769,
-0.1357831359,
-0.2175936252,
0.2243658155,
-0.4808391035,
-0.634894073,
0.3019817173,
-0.0344453752,
-0.067746453,
-0.1431818306,
-0.0070442534,
-0.0898894444,
0.2263424695,
0.6117451787,
0.3359291255,
-0.3139736354,
-0.3835867643,
0.051861804,
-0.0870796219,
-0.091923967,
0.5478429794,
-1.0263551474,
0.4725137055,
0.6309632063,
0.9182114005,
0.1093270928,
0.2564932704,
0.5148459077,
-0.8457093239,
-0.1789880097,
0.5438548326,
0.1018734127,
0.3934704363,
-0.3629204631,
0.449492991,
0.3320730031,
-0.1745529771,
-0.84058851,
0.4110767841,
-0.6890776753,
-0.0637658536,
1.2717353106,
-0.0870192945,
0.1912829578,
-0.1402857602,
-0.2936321497,
0.2461379617,
-0.5672659278,
0.9443596601,
0.6021139026,
-0.1191339791,
-0.1378758103,
0.2718764544,
0.0864164457,
0.6952203512,
-1.1847628355,
-0.353497535,
0.3898322284,
0.1194464192,
0.1529444009,
0.4999103546,
-0.2543136477,
0.5907162428,
0.018413065,
0.0690344051,
-0.2134287655,
-0.0359928235,
-0.1882925928,
0.6579138041,
0.1866693944,
-0.337718755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06601v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06601v1 | Mimicking the Thinking Process for Emotion Recognition in Conversation with Prompts and Paraphrasing | 2023-06-11T06:36:19 | 2023-06-11T06:36:19 | Ting Zhang, Zhuang Chen, Ming Zhong, Tieyun Qian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion recognition in conversation, which aims to predict the emotion for
all utterances, has attracted considerable research attention in recent years.
It is a challenging task since the recognition of the emotion in one utterance
involves many complex factors, such as the conversational context, the
speaker's background, and the subtle difference between emotion labels. In this
paper, we propose a novel framework which mimics the thinking process when
modeling these factors. Specifically, we first comprehend the conversational
context with a history-oriented prompt to selectively gather information from
predecessors of the target utterance. We then model the speaker's background
with an experience-oriented prompt to retrieve the similar utterances from all
conversations. We finally differentiate the subtle label semantics with a
paraphrasing mechanism to elicit the intrinsic label related knowledge. We
conducted extensive experiments on three benchmarks. The empirical results
demonstrate the superiority of our proposed framework over the state-of-the-art
baselines. | [
-0.4773828983,
-0.8242482543,
0.8218955398,
0.0729799122,
-0.3692575395,
-0.1816686243,
-0.0680580437,
-0.3204034865,
0.5437188148,
0.3922728896,
-0.7981381416,
-0.3140463531,
-0.1950859576,
0.0415824465,
-0.1303033978,
0.861190021,
-0.1206522211,
-0.1345939487,
-0.1177043095,
-0.2564104199,
-0.1466077417,
-0.5050833821,
-0.5366000533,
-0.4105569124,
0.4355181456,
0.456178844,
0.2500313818,
0.1983279884,
0.0027230815,
0.2471402138,
-0.1138228029,
-0.1254964322,
-0.3382769227,
0.4923287928,
-0.2109782845,
-0.23465994,
-0.0123971719,
0.1382944286,
0.5615832806,
0.3940291703,
-0.158977896,
-0.15970397,
0.3035395443,
0.3137779534,
-0.6432924271,
0.1655990481,
-0.6600126624,
0.402169168,
0.1091919541,
-0.4969521761,
-0.399987936,
-0.3221793771,
0.5927579403,
-0.2428043336,
0.1741704643,
0.251368165,
0.5799542665,
-0.1480252594,
-0.2959158719,
-0.5496029854,
-0.610378623,
0.4811480939,
-0.6879748702,
0.1157129854,
0.2719115615,
0.3453145027,
0.4279714823,
-0.608533144,
-0.7542741299,
-0.259303093,
-0.1527177393,
0.272231698,
-0.3225263059,
0.0806576088,
0.4564289153,
0.3019201756,
-0.3993952572,
-0.4230908453,
0.0098851491,
-0.1367176175,
-0.0661669821,
0.351236105,
0.1643728465,
-0.1903885156,
-0.6676676869,
-0.0301849339,
-0.2698890567,
0.2251450866,
0.0689411983,
0.2442058623,
-0.0406625569,
0.0897914022,
-0.3964216113,
0.1845444441,
0.1428617239,
0.094951503,
0.41833359,
0.0427362323,
-0.3837766647,
0.1282210648,
0.7941017747,
0.5794231892,
0.1528936774,
0.0277440865,
0.1283861846,
0.1390161663,
0.3044043779,
-0.6160407066,
-0.3354363143,
0.1343400776,
-0.420969218,
-0.1107396409,
-0.1578236222,
-1.3786659241,
-0.5426872373,
-0.2301387936,
0.2600518167,
-0.4815382361,
-0.3277073503,
-0.2653135061,
-0.1067622155,
0.2581402957,
0.3348965943,
-0.6828228831,
0.4126299322,
0.5137582421,
0.7575428486,
-0.0659145936,
-0.1135779917,
-0.3991237283,
-0.0547299981,
-0.1524274647,
0.8063860536,
-1.1733907461,
-0.5867384672,
-0.0650268942,
-0.1778073311,
0.0565082915,
-0.3284065425,
0.7101738453,
-0.2098379731,
0.1257067174,
-0.4766519368,
-0.5636366606,
-0.2761642635,
0.5495021343,
-0.4492025971,
0.7814204097,
-0.0821864903,
-0.8285154104,
-0.0532650165,
-0.4306502342,
-0.1887155622,
0.2753703296,
-0.0788132399,
-0.3446721137,
0.2208869606,
0.0929225311,
0.5187250376,
-0.4035746753,
0.1534038484,
-0.391900152,
-0.2583501935,
0.4513007104,
-0.3249565661,
0.3176589012,
0.1776891649,
-0.5351853371,
0.1240513325,
-0.8008560538,
0.0617548078,
-0.2765567005,
0.1440285891,
-0.3989924788,
-0.1881204098,
-0.3972834647,
0.3842160702,
-0.143313095,
-0.5789983869,
-0.2211698741,
-0.2596043944,
0.2916482687,
0.6937949061,
0.4276426136,
0.6021191478,
-0.1563806832,
0.7807765603,
0.1660440117,
-0.1150194481,
-0.554029882,
-0.264334172,
-0.7242643237,
-0.0467973277,
-0.1514319181,
0.5084119439,
-0.7515832186,
0.0128973685,
0.0933540389,
-0.5673737526,
-0.5747925639,
-0.3012302816,
0.6532578468,
1.0348995924,
0.426412195,
0.0397414044,
-0.5051798224,
-0.8766095042,
-0.2568674088,
-0.3947550952,
-0.0458298437,
0.6980426311,
0.1012957543,
0.1034626514,
0.7082623839,
-0.547164619,
0.0656143203,
-0.1774023324,
0.8383796811,
-0.1320269406,
0.5680291057,
0.3908118904,
-0.7260400057,
-0.4192944169,
0.0938340873,
-0.6954824328,
-0.3587200642,
-0.3054354787,
-0.4374750555,
-0.1182662025,
0.435385555,
-0.5862419009,
0.3941919506,
0.0584916994,
-0.2437673211,
0.6733365059,
0.0948338658,
0.4356952608,
-0.923638165,
0.0232048072,
0.1440138519,
0.182879746,
-0.7051832676,
-0.2824266553,
0.1374269277,
-0.2246358842,
-0.6504486799,
0.5812631249,
-0.4341129661,
0.2242639959,
-0.2657601833,
-0.0141834943,
-0.0230703596,
0.9089280963,
0.309571445,
0.3691612482,
0.749678731,
-0.7870040536,
0.5315803289,
0.2255956084,
-0.4618839324,
1.250344038,
-0.4311506748,
0.3154803216,
-0.477463901,
0.3905385435,
-0.9558081031,
-0.0028268865,
0.7363659739,
-0.3496275842,
-0.0335629843,
0.0505051874,
-0.1435380429,
-0.2969002128,
-0.2007284164,
0.2768143713,
0.7837450504,
-0.3754058182,
1.354110837,
0.0774298981,
-0.6876068711,
-0.1904559135,
-0.3734102845,
0.1628945917,
-0.6420393586,
0.0095482469,
0.2390841395,
-0.2397133261,
-0.1708505005,
-0.3442683816,
-0.1416251808,
0.0677322969,
-0.0850944221,
0.4846195579,
0.1134625748,
0.1309736818,
0.2906103432,
0.0287654269,
-0.2037731111,
0.3932651281,
-0.0564619265,
0.3472330272,
-0.0960198343,
-0.0685445368,
-0.7325955033,
0.5056355,
0.4670945704,
-0.2355452329,
0.2044561356,
0.5396662951,
-0.3359335661,
-0.4390214086,
-0.5603408813,
-0.2368518114,
-0.4325336516,
0.2270966321,
-0.5710548162,
-0.5546640754,
0.6180793643,
-0.4342626035,
-0.2182538062,
-0.146097213,
0.5977061987,
-0.4112849832,
0.8937888741,
0.2776257396,
0.0506681986,
0.7447524071,
0.1904487759,
0.2734579444,
-1.0000447035,
-0.2212441117,
-0.637039423,
-0.6048231721,
-0.1202226207,
-0.328184098,
0.1401869059,
-0.1877271831,
-0.0367914625,
0.0872002542,
-0.2384166121,
0.4593624771,
0.6022410393,
0.3077488244,
-0.1031087041,
-0.2093841881,
-0.2422146648,
-0.2919416726,
-0.1409017593,
-0.726545155,
0.5220788717,
0.0816621631,
0.5980701447,
-0.345076412,
0.7921845317,
0.064520888,
0.431702584,
-0.6331617236,
0.9100761414,
0.6064801812,
-0.2884295583,
-0.0316139311,
-0.4551523328,
-0.6768886447,
0.2701665759,
-0.0282309763,
-1.2546104193,
0.1342344284,
0.2587533593,
-0.3415160477,
0.2660229206,
-0.4342517257,
0.7128225565,
0.13503097,
-0.1903809905,
-0.1451604962,
-0.898945272,
0.106585674,
0.092914708,
0.0825327486,
-0.2752277255,
0.3836080432,
0.7961755395,
-0.2632769942,
0.9362384677,
-0.3268808126,
0.0556017831,
0.6114538908,
0.3896436393,
0.5089475513,
-0.1334038675,
-0.1848839819,
-0.3450209498,
-0.2037558705,
-0.1233317778,
-1.0640470982,
0.4573239684,
-0.0693362653,
-0.679055512,
-0.1998851895,
-0.5210080147,
-0.4117058516,
-0.114288874,
0.1421809793,
0.2864654362,
-0.5143219233,
-0.0660686791,
0.7324731946,
-0.1177880988,
0.3636882305,
0.6587787867,
-0.0068405736,
-0.1723430753,
0.903676331,
-0.225529924,
0.1537128985,
0.5758937597,
0.3577049375,
-0.1146858856,
-0.0012487123,
-0.0300947241,
0.0406528153,
-0.8122010827,
-0.1188946068,
-1.0160131454,
0.3033037484,
-0.2208728641,
-0.102916114,
0.1023153216,
-0.1093337089,
-0.4090779722,
-0.5151550174,
0.2304462492,
0.3307923377,
0.1339788437,
0.2459516078,
-0.7632617354,
0.2244981527,
0.6851445436,
0.1518535763,
0.5416123867,
-0.4636743069,
0.1819098443,
0.2909814417,
-0.4855425954,
-1.1917327642,
0.5849873424,
0.207575947,
0.5330020189,
0.6743037105,
0.4719041288,
0.521371901,
-0.5099204183,
0.8410518169,
0.1748207211,
-1.3390043974,
0.7290378809,
0.0226196479,
0.1876011491,
0.5557312369,
0.5120440125,
-0.656674087,
-0.5164280534,
-0.8250169158,
-0.7752334476,
0.6264609694,
0.2870125771,
0.3719976246,
-0.1847229749,
0.051642973,
0.1691759527,
0.2511568964,
-0.6022130847,
-0.0264601558,
0.0141414609,
-0.4021982849,
0.1610079557,
-0.2992780507,
-0.1079766527,
-0.0973797441,
0.6203159094,
-0.1788199693,
0.534350574,
0.1757803261,
-0.1292810738,
-0.0450527035,
0.3679694831,
0.3352373838,
0.0444627441,
-0.2607773244,
0.3755504489,
0.3962453902,
0.0784656256,
0.1399497688,
-0.2199053019,
0.1011703461,
0.1561142057,
0.1646606773,
1.1684712172,
0.602439642,
-0.7757068276,
0.3684957027,
0.0402848311,
0.009149123,
0.1696410626,
-0.1467202008,
0.2302910239,
0.7553815246,
0.2520905733,
-0.0662926808,
0.5697966814,
-0.9081491232,
0.1696707457,
0.1758842617,
-0.6151931882,
-0.4538939595,
0.4959628582,
0.2218675017,
-0.3982678652,
0.4137800336,
-0.2635957897,
-0.9762803316,
0.6223126054,
0.5181570053,
1.0992741585,
-0.4756946564,
0.3703695536,
0.2336219102,
-0.5431535244,
-0.0199481584,
0.6032866836,
-0.8019337654,
-0.6568682194,
0.3466444016,
-0.4744352102,
-0.8775652051,
-0.4839610159,
-1.0597456694,
0.1252889633,
-0.4983533323,
-0.2101215124,
-0.0802011639,
-0.5072886348,
-0.6723092794,
0.3525667191,
0.4912855029,
0.7147532105,
-0.9567970634,
0.6432300806,
0.6529583931,
-0.1959177256,
-0.7368677855,
0.2088494748,
0.2174979895,
-0.6285690069,
0.4546139836,
0.3992174268,
-0.271473676,
0.0501766503,
-0.4299550056,
-0.4077778161,
0.8893185258,
-0.0032095592,
-0.5603608489,
-0.1187759787,
-0.3280921876,
0.6710500717,
-0.6095303297,
0.4140585661,
0.6898226738,
0.2722077668,
0.5371029377,
-0.5524753332,
0.1420948803,
-0.4709151089,
-0.0518186204,
0.0244699437,
-0.414064914,
0.7562720776,
-0.0418975987,
-0.4571533799,
-0.0370641574,
0.8055154681,
0.3981273174,
0.5650330186,
0.4518624544,
0.3561604917,
0.8725630641,
-0.1401112676,
0.7691280842,
-0.3433996141,
0.2687112093,
1.1584570408,
-0.5153399706,
0.8251007795,
0.3418276906,
-0.1355579942,
0.5870850086,
0.4106701314,
0.1720622033,
0.6134529114,
0.145521,
-0.3914338648,
-0.0618471168,
-0.3214057684,
-0.181507647,
0.0754873604,
0.4813864231,
-0.504386723,
-0.0825674832,
0.3676469028,
0.1002086252,
-0.0682121441,
-0.4055778384,
1.0554853678,
0.251647383,
-0.6816979647,
0.4485014081,
-0.5116537809,
0.6719613671,
-0.4940518737,
-0.0691885725,
-0.1723887324,
-0.2661276162,
0.0049087363,
-0.846934557,
0.0680809096,
0.0654124394,
-0.0327208713,
-0.4455772638,
0.3989368081,
-0.7794818282,
-0.2457702309,
0.2332747728,
0.1768612862,
0.302387327,
-0.3338135779,
-0.5123159885,
0.1626870036,
0.0423655026,
-0.3835711479,
0.0330907963,
0.8923273683,
0.2897162735,
0.6290344596,
0.1987321675,
-0.1293901503,
-0.2784205377,
0.1595882326,
0.6840353012,
-0.9612315893,
-1.0974807739,
-0.9890280962,
0.5282433033,
-0.1846577823,
-0.4251571298,
0.3335073888,
-0.0879722536,
0.3380289674,
0.0043212464,
0.6480727196,
0.1748939008,
0.6151369214,
-0.3035188913,
0.3176968694,
-0.237505123,
-0.0594972521,
-1.0182734728,
-0.957983911,
0.1136513054,
0.7581433058,
-0.2482056171,
-0.0802278668,
0.8086197972,
0.690869689,
0.2786453366,
0.7378908992,
0.2781410515,
0.3353812695,
0.2169663757,
0.8934076428,
0.9740448594,
0.0472098291,
0.4607538283,
-0.1347264946,
-0.2257830799,
-0.2463646084,
-0.9818416238,
-0.6772144437,
-0.8156948686,
-0.4672264159,
-0.3092927933,
-0.1012498736,
1.0791976452,
0.4468911886,
-0.6876163483,
0.1877882034,
-0.0575904548,
-0.0948190987,
-0.513378799,
-0.2744948268,
0.0200494975,
-0.0689468235,
-0.7846105099,
0.2386533767,
0.5079213977,
0.3514424264,
0.2724259496,
-0.1515524834,
-0.0181171522,
0.3807666898,
0.4053241909,
0.3089828491,
-0.7722265124,
-0.2626518905,
-0.5089151263,
-0.0678408295,
0.2341679782,
1.000109911,
-0.8878139257,
0.6266490221,
0.4382019639,
0.5584668517,
0.4913035035,
0.2811861038,
0.7336755395,
-0.6362961531,
-0.0444401577,
0.6430001855,
0.4354732931,
0.3791953921,
-0.3051376641,
0.1906768978,
0.1176558584,
-0.2378207594,
-0.7792184949,
0.5091791153,
-1.0424643755,
-0.135068953,
0.8645126224,
-0.5545423031,
-0.1143771932,
0.23811692,
-0.7159417272,
0.3568226397,
-0.58225137,
0.8474356532,
0.8788434863,
-0.2699047029,
-0.5371212959,
0.0247522481,
0.3073393703,
0.5968125463,
-0.791015327,
0.3746222556,
0.4001878202,
0.0228211936,
0.0674358532,
0.6460864544,
0.0363794789,
0.1869923174,
0.1235406622,
0.0109980404,
0.1925842166,
-0.285402745,
-0.2006498128,
0.4375893772,
-0.5344436765,
0.0165275857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06598v1 | RoBERTweet: A BERT Language Model for Romanian Tweets | 2023-06-11T06:11:56 | 2023-06-11T06:11:56 | Iulian-Marius Tăiatu, Andrei-Marius Avram, Dumitru-Clementin Cercel, Florin Pop | cs.CL | cs.CL | Developing natural language processing (NLP) systems for social media
analysis remains an important topic in artificial intelligence research. This
article introduces RoBERTweet, the first Transformer architecture trained on
Romanian tweets. Our RoBERTweet comes in two versions, following the base and
large architectures of BERT. The corpus used for pre-training the models
represents a novelty for the Romanian NLP community and consists of all tweets
collected from 2008 to 2022. Experiments show that RoBERTweet models outperform
the previous general-domain Romanian and multilingual language models on three
NLP tasks with tweet inputs: emotion detection, sexist language identification,
and named entity recognition. We make our models and the newly created corpus
of Romanian tweets freely available. | [
-0.3466040194,
-0.693005681,
0.3232925534,
0.542032361,
-0.2174704522,
0.4225987792,
-0.4000339508,
-0.500639081,
0.6118069291,
0.3843691647,
-0.8408992887,
-0.4722777307,
-0.8115599155,
-0.2113163322,
-0.9478607774,
0.9355425239,
0.0513618886,
0.2573264539,
0.6950551271,
-0.0706234276,
0.0570535064,
-0.3899761438,
-0.4899203777,
-0.2271627188,
0.5240431428,
0.1488210708,
0.7325573564,
-0.1107367128,
1.0692157745,
0.2265751213,
0.2073664963,
-0.3045219183,
-0.4753711522,
0.0598627403,
-0.2452730387,
-0.2653597593,
-0.2671065032,
-0.2124242932,
0.5738164186,
0.4196543992,
-0.0385595448,
0.3341777325,
-0.028954858,
0.7917577028,
-0.1166313812,
0.0571335629,
-0.9064074755,
-0.0972150862,
-0.1849054843,
-0.4460629821,
-0.590419054,
-0.6053876281,
0.3978568316,
0.0339156203,
0.5286849141,
-0.1745429933,
1.2388356924,
0.2854960561,
-0.0406334065,
-0.3684964478,
-1.2922885418,
0.8041525483,
-0.4156615436,
0.4072631598,
0.0318679512,
0.5523334742,
-0.0183659568,
-0.7665380239,
-0.3120261431,
-0.182236582,
-0.048665341,
-0.1057787463,
-0.8102941513,
-0.1070984304,
-0.3183329701,
0.0193402525,
-0.6974080205,
-0.0222520754,
-0.6841393709,
0.1996163279,
0.5133033395,
-0.3515835106,
0.2093617916,
-0.3737953901,
-0.4814005494,
-0.0055510872,
-0.4930252135,
-0.3098372519,
0.338468641,
0.4708098173,
0.0220884457,
0.6482347846,
0.3276997507,
0.4127777219,
-0.1291969717,
0.3523733318,
0.0460474081,
0.3039294779,
-0.3943870366,
-0.1388263553,
0.8477966189,
-0.0085589793,
0.544405818,
-0.459372282,
-0.1768199801,
0.2716115415,
0.654874146,
-0.5614536405,
-0.6170552373,
0.2389624566,
-0.5335065722,
-0.5298567414,
0.2574332952,
-0.3194491863,
-0.0826342851,
-0.0979945883,
0.2299818695,
-0.684360981,
-0.4738241732,
0.0669612885,
0.0383376926,
0.4808755517,
0.295542717,
-1.0722162724,
0.4339904487,
0.7345794439,
0.5667850375,
-0.164063707,
-0.1064542606,
-0.2245371342,
-0.1562354714,
-0.2703925669,
1.1577355862,
-0.3874459863,
0.2040068656,
0.1999527067,
-0.0390164182,
-0.0410540998,
-0.212049827,
0.6420546174,
-0.6964170933,
0.1428718567,
0.1030262262,
-0.4532855153,
-0.133593455,
0.0646474287,
-0.8026806712,
1.0084196329,
0.4577320814,
-1.0095475912,
0.2831355929,
-1.0812567472,
-0.5402516723,
0.6121220589,
-0.0261576772,
-0.1516487598,
0.0713718906,
0.1575409025,
0.9327365756,
-0.1532547027,
0.5595520139,
-0.1760356724,
-0.1638889611,
-0.054649137,
-0.1738311797,
1.2301052809,
-0.0285679251,
-0.2488150299,
0.0897933617,
-0.7271581888,
-0.0099356025,
0.2530485988,
-0.2597291172,
-0.0301459264,
0.2236244977,
0.6392402649,
0.0612907894,
0.0683794096,
-0.8695741296,
-0.0365048908,
-0.1514519751,
0.7737654448,
0.6468206048,
-0.2618225515,
0.5543215275,
-0.1904997826,
0.6864534616,
-0.5087194443,
0.1610440761,
0.1398288012,
-0.6223391891,
-0.771527648,
-0.1191110089,
0.4414190054,
0.940550983,
-0.8188347816,
0.545532167,
-0.2970365882,
-0.7219122052,
-0.8109430671,
0.0648971871,
-0.2483292967,
-0.1133204028,
0.3080976009,
0.223881498,
-1.0524861813,
-1.1834738255,
-0.1806976199,
-0.4957169294,
-0.2252485454,
-0.0673221126,
0.4890078306,
-0.2829709351,
0.9419592023,
-0.2474489659,
-0.2590607703,
-0.8895419836,
0.4359294176,
-0.0377447233,
0.2461637259,
0.9859060645,
-0.9018290639,
-0.4970250726,
-0.0910974219,
-0.5877833962,
0.0472861342,
-0.0387212411,
-0.1686587781,
0.4157207012,
0.247779429,
-0.4713279307,
0.2685085833,
1.0521789789,
0.1319163889,
0.3212254345,
0.213293314,
-0.1925136,
-1.3509451151,
-0.0701236948,
0.1829346567,
-0.3891967535,
-0.8513613939,
-0.0244537871,
0.0329638161,
0.0757247582,
-0.5470656157,
0.3272140324,
-0.1589933932,
-0.0375725143,
-0.1799018383,
0.1346176267,
-0.3658625185,
0.4268780053,
0.1137311831,
0.4827962816,
0.4220038652,
-0.270075202,
0.527798295,
0.2757956088,
-0.4110735655,
0.3278967738,
-0.7023867965,
0.1097657755,
-0.300745517,
0.149533987,
-1.031696558,
-0.235117659,
0.0889806449,
-0.831482172,
0.0870664418,
-0.3422346115,
-0.7177579999,
-0.6112901568,
-0.1260277778,
-0.3194451034,
0.62948668,
-0.5529257059,
0.9756678343,
0.391382128,
-0.1206493825,
-0.2382255942,
-0.91741997,
0.2919047475,
-0.0675672963,
-1.1338807344,
0.2504378557,
0.0697441623,
-0.2039644271,
0.2335490882,
0.2723524868,
-0.533174932,
0.0915076286,
-0.0220769141,
0.4186628163,
-0.5235921144,
0.2810998559,
-0.1578622758,
-0.1044793725,
0.0400011428,
-0.1401542574,
0.8481132984,
-0.4843143225,
0.099452123,
-0.463018328,
0.4250320494,
-0.0260883961,
-0.2060257345,
0.8678856492,
0.9931253195,
-0.3820478618,
-0.4188483953,
-0.6030025482,
-0.1035556868,
-0.4487413466,
0.2076754272,
-0.066619575,
-1.0948814154,
0.4064190984,
0.1048997492,
0.3908896148,
0.6189402342,
0.4810583591,
-0.4618858993,
0.4660699069,
1.1010433435,
-0.0310134105,
0.8363927007,
-0.467856884,
0.6907865405,
-0.3958243132,
0.3003641665,
-0.6246313453,
-0.3835308254,
-0.8609392643,
-0.2852655649,
-0.1427205205,
-0.2557603121,
0.0591968447,
0.995719254,
-0.5384523869,
0.4422028363,
0.5017899871,
0.0317809172,
-0.0303130038,
0.0433235019,
0.5554869175,
-0.1562701017,
-0.5629739165,
-0.9325690269,
0.8083672523,
0.4660308957,
0.87628299,
-0.0022695414,
0.9463905096,
0.367672652,
0.4295045733,
-0.6587863564,
0.5250644684,
-0.4590292275,
-0.8497123718,
-0.2355341166,
-0.1123300269,
-0.7890520692,
-0.1360703409,
-0.2157685161,
-0.8010963202,
-0.1303509623,
0.0250387639,
-0.3125580847,
0.617805779,
-0.8002299666,
0.6693066359,
-0.0026965337,
0.3247110844,
-0.0141410688,
-0.7501279712,
0.4583453238,
0.0643962175,
-0.0474096201,
-0.2758654654,
0.4439730346,
0.7778250575,
0.3452759683,
0.6770884991,
-0.0592248254,
0.1356001198,
0.2879530191,
0.3596478403,
0.2861618698,
-0.1064443886,
0.0020938679,
-0.0051156315,
-0.1449045539,
-0.5025734901,
-0.4655564129,
0.4303835928,
-0.6348805428,
-0.2035767436,
-0.2587261498,
-0.2256150693,
0.144070074,
0.0562384427,
0.2221613675,
0.1445834339,
-0.6527404785,
0.523712635,
0.6971897483,
-0.1136447713,
0.4308152199,
0.3809904456,
-0.1928247362,
0.1011331826,
0.678961575,
-0.0763388425,
0.2498967797,
0.5595932603,
-0.0619975291,
0.3798114359,
-0.4307549,
-0.3076091707,
0.0934120119,
-0.6341574192,
-0.0927292928,
-1.0016005039,
-0.7344657779,
-0.3774653673,
-0.4378200471,
-0.7005309463,
-0.6553163528,
-0.2548450828,
-0.3184752464,
0.3865367174,
1.1742457151,
-0.1007850394,
0.7343569994,
-0.759380877,
0.4722571969,
0.0561527573,
0.2921216786,
-0.2265099436,
-0.2779322863,
-0.2135691047,
-0.1430265009,
-0.3660490215,
-0.64826864,
0.5088986158,
0.0754483864,
0.2985333204,
0.2957811952,
-0.0125954142,
0.2009464353,
-0.6238457561,
0.7998400331,
-0.0361341499,
-0.6970281601,
0.6747671366,
-0.46011585,
-0.0352138802,
0.458960861,
0.3722541332,
-0.5430743098,
-0.6884965301,
-0.9946974516,
-0.8124514818,
0.7397887707,
0.5346693993,
0.4128234982,
-0.0793852806,
0.0184525866,
0.2063836157,
0.0913555622,
-0.8344001174,
-0.0575314239,
0.0561896488,
-0.2425522208,
0.1332113892,
-0.2540868223,
0.2369762212,
-0.3014537692,
0.7442828417,
0.2104054689,
0.7911741138,
-0.1182644069,
-0.4075056016,
-0.2475232184,
0.290245682,
0.6306329966,
0.7459657192,
-0.7137647271,
-0.0929168612,
-0.1551623046,
-0.3803233504,
-0.2347714156,
0.0620078035,
-0.1663568318,
0.5407447815,
0.5088871121,
0.8886705637,
0.2554889619,
-0.2337062508,
0.497137785,
-0.2771166563,
-0.302739948,
-0.8840014338,
-0.0857966989,
0.2927846909,
0.3206131756,
0.6103468537,
0.4372443557,
-0.0937929451,
-0.4768110216,
0.3629347682,
0.3828856647,
-0.4436467886,
-0.5882673264,
0.5937552452,
0.1763534695,
-0.7730497122,
0.5437378287,
-0.1103133708,
-0.9044627547,
0.2427929044,
0.214471221,
1.3482905626,
-0.3265380561,
0.7388510108,
0.2646567225,
0.7685193419,
0.0000619428,
0.3963392079,
0.1601094753,
-0.9733511806,
-0.3196659684,
-0.6780616641,
-0.3759754896,
-0.0550577082,
-0.7161408663,
0.5554684401,
-0.5600969195,
-0.1379560977,
0.482524544,
-0.0922692865,
-0.8299964666,
0.0057446775,
0.1891417652,
0.9922114015,
-1.0043329,
1.0969293118,
0.5219068527,
-0.1849977821,
-0.5391093493,
-0.0774187967,
-0.405564338,
-0.9957433939,
0.8024232388,
0.0023832447,
-0.1587409973,
0.0279106796,
-0.9447330236,
-0.7095947862,
0.7714010477,
0.5079968572,
-0.2469125986,
-0.416030854,
-0.0239576548,
0.7880913019,
-0.5937116146,
0.0277907196,
0.7089855671,
0.3635629714,
0.1829774231,
-0.7195458412,
-0.5804425478,
-0.2805320024,
0.0529521741,
0.5550367832,
-0.3131971657,
0.7715160251,
-0.1248411685,
-0.3207931817,
0.1291783452,
0.7513612509,
-0.2503011525,
-0.3458980024,
0.2738358676,
0.2353969812,
0.437307924,
-0.2833901048,
1.1301174164,
-0.2251421809,
0.4380629659,
1.0979030132,
-0.1172183976,
1.1779408455,
0.5027080774,
-0.1702849418,
0.6612991095,
0.3720196187,
-0.3401873708,
0.4050885439,
0.1211301982,
-0.0875059739,
-0.097466968,
0.0932573378,
0.0825742558,
0.3175131381,
0.2776362896,
-0.3718246222,
-0.4616714418,
0.1496951729,
0.0504038185,
0.0450626351,
0.2873154581,
0.6440284848,
-0.0333127417,
-0.2329823077,
0.3056236804,
0.123411037,
0.7419406176,
-0.740678072,
0.1524715275,
0.1675628424,
0.2840553522,
-0.2102447152,
-1.0984116793,
0.7129848599,
0.1202242747,
-0.0911391824,
-0.6422494054,
0.7780950069,
-0.2607982159,
-0.8919666409,
0.8298879862,
0.3006575704,
0.2377978265,
-0.2177007347,
-0.6933265328,
0.0622855276,
0.1137608439,
-0.4807416797,
-0.1576649398,
0.4132046103,
0.1318287998,
0.7081626058,
0.4048929513,
0.1202809289,
0.4006108642,
0.3021511436,
0.9825546741,
-0.6078513265,
-0.2464302629,
-0.8443524241,
0.514791131,
0.1120261699,
-0.2026612163,
0.3855841458,
0.2626413405,
0.7291342616,
-0.0133714825,
0.8819503188,
-0.545948863,
0.9681476951,
-0.1363919526,
0.6526827216,
-0.1805613935,
-0.0731488839,
-0.4185529649,
-1.0813055038,
-0.5355895758,
0.8958129883,
-0.2426390648,
-0.0796143636,
0.7504907846,
0.4027608335,
-0.0926493183,
0.4491923749,
0.2094690651,
0.2288186997,
0.5755945444,
0.3986816704,
0.5652647018,
-0.7721704245,
0.519313693,
-0.4242590666,
-0.1734755486,
-0.227100417,
-0.7354930639,
-1.2979358435,
-0.8083808422,
0.1348386109,
-0.2030435503,
0.0880342573,
1.2458899021,
0.4800155461,
-1.0685335398,
-0.2908655703,
-0.0205920041,
-0.0864317715,
0.1828259081,
-0.2468315214,
0.3448288739,
-0.3884301484,
-0.4729188681,
0.204799071,
0.304068327,
0.1314851344,
-0.5548728108,
0.2054151148,
-0.6869620085,
0.0459280647,
0.7295891047,
0.0669963658,
-0.6506923437,
-0.3464419842,
0.271266669,
-0.1174831465,
0.5123479962,
0.6735227704,
-0.6074014306,
-0.1030728742,
0.3945968449,
0.5811161995,
0.5545610785,
-0.0644711927,
0.7180503011,
-0.6394926906,
0.2443349063,
0.6819845438,
0.2111758441,
0.6145103574,
-0.205586642,
0.6261458993,
-0.1969466358,
-0.4850308597,
-0.7538384199,
0.1234091148,
-1.1854349375,
0.0490152352,
0.9607090354,
0.1356759965,
-0.4362181723,
0.0347051583,
-0.1435471773,
0.1049336642,
-0.5355911851,
0.8514111638,
0.9960555434,
0.2404700667,
-0.4822702706,
-1.1092073917,
0.3141354918,
-0.0322429016,
-0.6034142375,
-0.0667700395,
-0.2669853866,
0.1398364007,
0.2326060534,
0.5916880369,
0.1293876618,
0.1807309538,
-0.3801426589,
0.3962517381,
0.5749849081,
-0.6125003695,
-0.1183815673,
0.0236406252,
-0.1350554377,
-0.0984480307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07935v1 | Multi-modal Representation Learning for Social Post Location Inference | 2023-06-11T02:35:48 | 2023-06-11T02:35:48 | Ruiting Dai, Jiayi Luo, Xucheng Luo, Lisi Mo, Wanlun Ma, Fan Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Inferring geographic locations via social posts is essential for many
practical location-based applications such as product marketing,
point-of-interest recommendation, and infector tracking for COVID-19. Unlike
image-based location retrieval or social-post text embedding-based location
inference, the combined effect of multi-modal information (i.e., post images,
text, and hashtags) for social post positioning receives less attention. In
this work, we collect real datasets of social posts with images, texts, and
hashtags from Instagram and propose a novel Multi-modal Representation Learning
Framework (MRLF) capable of fusing different modalities of social posts for
location inference. MRLF integrates a multi-head attention mechanism to enhance
location-salient information extraction while significantly improving location
inference compared with single domain-based methods. To overcome the noisy
user-generated textual content, we introduce a novel attention-based
character-aware module that considers the relative dependencies between
characters of social post texts and hashtags for flexible multi-model
information fusion. The experimental results show that MRLF can make accurate
location predictions and open a new door to understanding the multi-modal data
of social posts for online inference tasks. | [
-0.3753004074,
-0.771242857,
0.6600902677,
0.1835110337,
-0.3114611506,
0.1051894128,
-0.2362149805,
-0.8472340703,
0.5729275346,
0.0003643822,
-0.6082507968,
-0.6702162623,
-0.4612702429,
-0.0856708512,
0.1462744325,
0.5740341544,
0.1530455947,
0.000796526,
-0.3633578122,
-0.2178330421,
-0.4054610729,
-0.7177215219,
-0.4222281575,
0.0125708524,
0.7325187325,
0.3075941205,
0.5366170406,
0.0594104007,
0.430737257,
0.1503937393,
0.3394107223,
0.6931497455,
-0.2894878983,
0.0003419775,
-0.2329688966,
-0.0047728671,
0.0833203122,
-0.2777634263,
0.8097127676,
0.3495560884,
0.0675085634,
0.1000134647,
-0.256806016,
0.1742907465,
-0.571606636,
0.1923492104,
-0.5155599713,
-0.1668462157,
-0.0555597022,
-0.2530141175,
-0.321654439,
-0.3685946763,
-0.003475667,
-0.4115628898,
0.2450903505,
0.3099460602,
0.952116251,
0.2206127942,
-0.6476973891,
0.1116687655,
-0.5227732062,
0.7238898277,
-0.4147570431,
0.851013422,
0.8638501763,
0.3515602052,
-0.0192269888,
-0.2347677052,
-0.2403542697,
-0.000898159,
-0.4952797294,
-0.142695725,
0.3507757783,
-0.143267706,
0.1794906855,
0.0276311692,
-0.4156859517,
-0.4221079051,
-0.0908462405,
-0.0328823142,
0.5979968309,
-0.2284453511,
0.1745059192,
-0.515412271,
-0.6579812765,
0.0679338723,
-0.526275754,
0.5120795369,
0.0055852779,
0.5909135342,
-0.4520100355,
0.3061500788,
0.041046299,
0.4740231335,
0.3541605473,
-0.1979280263,
0.2363315374,
-0.4998197258,
-0.147986263,
0.0905519277,
0.9605943561,
0.2889586091,
-0.2433675975,
-0.115965113,
-0.2394349575,
-0.3634372056,
0.1895091236,
-0.5536060333,
-0.0134311039,
0.1382727921,
-0.7477761507,
-0.1326964945,
0.5469380617,
-0.5998936892,
-0.4802239239,
-0.01047308,
0.2058078349,
-0.630538404,
-0.4155006707,
-0.0069900034,
-0.0929711387,
0.2837939858,
0.3461965322,
-1.1284199953,
-0.1255019754,
0.3576845527,
0.8365618587,
0.2090161741,
-0.3992237747,
-0.2434336096,
0.5142952204,
0.0436370708,
1.1043974161,
-0.8990731835,
-0.1554038376,
-0.0492814183,
0.155389294,
-0.2902431488,
-0.2906473279,
0.4184781909,
-0.7318768501,
-0.017113829,
-0.6859485507,
-0.1372643858,
-0.68891114,
0.2648755312,
-0.793397665,
1.2253966331,
0.1371190995,
-0.7002876997,
0.5432938933,
-0.5558030009,
-0.7654420137,
0.0178729203,
-0.1507112831,
-0.4769098461,
0.1397701651,
0.6353630424,
0.6220968962,
-0.0816472992,
0.2841294408,
-0.5061450005,
-0.4753665626,
0.2202662081,
-0.3094065487,
0.6462978721,
-0.0138345212,
-0.1771042496,
0.2079700828,
-0.5532903671,
-0.354229629,
0.132923916,
-0.187465474,
-0.5978651047,
0.1323568374,
0.1322212815,
0.1959594935,
0.3078897595,
-0.4109148979,
-0.0442506298,
0.0493427254,
0.239347443,
0.3630351424,
0.2999728024,
0.6662833095,
-0.2646261752,
0.4706141055,
0.0481852926,
0.1826960593,
-0.4447568357,
-0.4465910196,
0.1125611067,
-0.6626895666,
0.1730653495,
0.1226301119,
-0.7621340752,
0.3229449093,
-0.2693549097,
-0.3601144552,
-0.4008681476,
-0.231130451,
0.1943639219,
0.3902834952,
0.3388566077,
0.0552019924,
-0.4976751208,
-0.4202621281,
-0.1385152191,
-0.0463218763,
0.1562489271,
0.326471746,
0.2544082403,
-0.2633515596,
0.6491191983,
-0.3863336742,
-0.1451193839,
-0.1160749644,
0.006040154,
-0.126708135,
0.1924855709,
0.8535373211,
-1.0546348095,
-0.6027166247,
-0.1143831089,
-0.7423920035,
0.3095230162,
-0.2176283449,
-0.3492639065,
-0.0500863679,
0.2878517509,
-0.6706528068,
0.3320816159,
0.4031708837,
-0.5031123161,
0.3588352203,
-0.0689080507,
0.7240171432,
-1.2579265833,
-0.0338675827,
0.4119692743,
-0.6336767673,
-0.2511712015,
0.0210705996,
0.3556572199,
-0.1907240748,
-0.25159958,
0.4054064453,
-0.5648961663,
-0.1238688454,
0.1474086344,
-0.1532207429,
0.2040746957,
0.7036043406,
0.0392010435,
0.5761310458,
0.4675555229,
-0.2731413245,
0.110612601,
0.1443035901,
-0.4020061493,
0.5495452881,
-0.2559734285,
-0.058866404,
-0.3883091807,
0.3210699856,
-1.5247045755,
-0.6278567314,
0.4544684291,
-0.4968457222,
0.1675989479,
-0.2882955372,
-0.732673943,
-0.1928157657,
-0.2914515436,
0.7671355605,
-0.0491494201,
-0.6272835732,
0.7140623927,
0.352586329,
0.1857550293,
-0.4188328981,
-0.7366898656,
-0.1406382769,
-0.3004416525,
-0.4874430299,
0.4789745212,
0.101735577,
0.0741280764,
0.2587250173,
0.0283270665,
-0.2813966572,
-0.092396535,
0.3847006261,
0.0088171726,
0.0120314248,
0.5366933346,
0.005847726,
-0.0072244173,
-0.1312669665,
-0.033584889,
0.4906443357,
0.0949182138,
-0.5436472297,
-0.6864530444,
0.6085782647,
0.7481230497,
-0.6357739568,
0.7516824603,
0.6748093367,
-0.7811439633,
0.0548514836,
-0.4021100104,
-0.3988997042,
-0.4656232893,
0.0298709664,
-0.2732968032,
-0.5624386072,
0.4600275755,
0.0960342512,
-0.2190271467,
0.210835889,
0.1210306808,
-0.3873839676,
0.9125104547,
0.5740078092,
0.1091090143,
0.8296675086,
0.0260977577,
0.4365058839,
-0.474001199,
-0.3967878819,
-0.0637952238,
-0.4258809984,
-0.1943043321,
-0.6187066436,
0.2984578907,
-0.1272607297,
-0.0840606689,
0.408942163,
-0.3880629838,
0.4486450255,
0.6153841615,
0.6609646082,
0.1505749226,
0.5422288775,
-0.0444629416,
-0.2948357463,
-0.6792473793,
-0.1281558275,
0.6922258139,
0.1959606558,
0.8828734159,
0.1830641925,
0.4397882521,
0.3158563375,
0.0838885009,
-0.7332007289,
0.2337343544,
-0.0086338744,
-0.5449075699,
-0.0739122629,
-0.1904288679,
-0.5258601904,
0.2596858144,
-0.4693474472,
-0.4294137955,
0.2562576234,
0.0050461334,
-0.8946298957,
0.44509238,
-0.9047030807,
0.8686810732,
-0.3184675276,
-0.3828228712,
-0.1473301649,
-0.9477171302,
0.1519203186,
0.1312873662,
0.3685043752,
-0.2387710512,
0.2243398279,
0.315806061,
-0.1454490125,
1.0745296478,
-0.3203216493,
0.0128973499,
0.2993616462,
-0.1952288449,
0.3810375631,
0.2295646667,
-0.0532853007,
0.465844065,
-0.1716221124,
-0.2438657731,
-0.3844811618,
0.7398794889,
-0.5805799961,
0.0865498036,
-0.3852123618,
-0.7571592331,
-0.1436669827,
0.2513299882,
0.2010850757,
0.7503202558,
0.0668083578,
0.1717142463,
0.695052743,
0.0207180083,
0.6672475338,
-0.0263016634,
-0.0102285817,
-0.8018268943,
0.8300372362,
0.1533164233,
-0.278241545,
0.8177807331,
0.0414628647,
-0.7081865072,
-0.0401348993,
-0.1753097475,
0.5485181212,
-0.6706899405,
-0.2255790085,
-0.6339685321,
0.1661045551,
-0.5497616529,
-0.5797546506,
-0.2629505396,
-0.1057773605,
-0.3672194481,
-0.1675465554,
0.4329325259,
0.7943785191,
-0.1633148789,
0.5392891169,
-0.5946222544,
0.4531488419,
0.1203409955,
0.385753423,
0.0911835581,
-0.1606758386,
-0.6102899909,
0.1942066401,
-0.0234561879,
-0.8290595412,
0.149648577,
0.0577279776,
0.6195089221,
0.7152675986,
0.1589469314,
0.8831660748,
-0.256952107,
0.6095658541,
0.4017492235,
-0.426661998,
0.3888711333,
-0.5121042728,
0.5808171034,
0.5784184337,
0.4303541481,
-0.5459000468,
-0.0231947619,
-0.2654651403,
-0.6211528182,
0.5022817254,
-0.1548213512,
-0.0248471107,
-0.2222210318,
0.5215996504,
0.1438896954,
0.1965998411,
-1.007707119,
-0.1960167587,
-0.1832825691,
-0.3479840755,
0.1034836546,
-0.3854946792,
-0.0821856409,
-0.4023305774,
0.3368756473,
-0.1527183801,
0.4359011352,
0.2998701334,
-0.2619413137,
-0.2163435668,
-0.3705994785,
0.6682661772,
0.7700933814,
-0.2796733677,
0.4979713857,
0.0129163768,
-0.0154534252,
0.0372951888,
0.2918452024,
-0.1437292844,
0.0394446515,
0.3085483015,
0.5270515084,
0.6229545474,
-0.3884785473,
0.7168731093,
-0.1736987382,
0.1059126332,
-0.3158955872,
-0.4068638682,
0.1791243106,
0.6260899305,
0.5004446507,
0.4940497577,
-0.0084467204,
-0.465025425,
0.3339425027,
0.5991663933,
-0.8093649149,
-0.5664645433,
0.9341771007,
0.066610679,
-0.1926349252,
0.0501494631,
-0.2297263145,
-0.4058249891,
0.4114863575,
0.4889141023,
0.9355450273,
-0.5566967726,
0.4367576241,
0.6952789426,
0.2457382232,
0.0410587229,
0.4733010232,
-0.4116988778,
-0.4730353951,
-0.3258953094,
-0.3397381008,
0.0106803756,
-0.2815166712,
-0.302788049,
0.4589753449,
-0.5422708392,
-0.3659984171,
-0.3174241185,
-0.3717319667,
-0.5408273339,
0.0896652639,
0.2991199493,
0.4215877354,
-0.9063072801,
0.5038974285,
1.0088442564,
-0.3382742405,
-0.387896359,
0.4188329875,
-0.091272071,
-0.5281116962,
0.1955811381,
0.6591032743,
-0.4061874747,
-0.2436541468,
-0.8185665607,
-1.0885957479,
1.1549344063,
0.3761475086,
-0.1516086459,
-0.0631150529,
-0.0134362187,
0.1487187594,
-0.4841193259,
0.1475038081,
-0.3160164058,
0.2994996905,
0.0513442568,
-0.5487303734,
0.2466553301,
0.012333408,
0.0368502662,
0.0364788771,
-1.025796771,
0.6484520435,
-0.4777695835,
-0.3784244955,
-0.3720142841,
0.6431587338,
0.2933382988,
0.2871355414,
0.4371898174,
0.6002033353,
0.8091042042,
0.0054625086,
0.989330709,
-0.3121059239,
0.5361267924,
1.2256060839,
-0.0399605818,
0.6971702576,
0.4828608334,
0.2289774567,
0.6722214222,
1.0317384005,
0.117153354,
1.1454491615,
-0.4586999416,
-0.4713179469,
-0.5169035792,
-0.2060162872,
-0.3489700854,
0.3836134076,
0.428712517,
-0.6116559505,
-0.4411122799,
0.1508985758,
-0.1522972286,
-0.1442942917,
-0.079850845,
0.6098769903,
-0.1529248059,
-0.3353542984,
0.3740800917,
0.0829085037,
0.5635207295,
-0.7436539531,
-0.2069470882,
0.0914957747,
-0.0640475377,
-0.317809999,
-0.5525486469,
0.3410390317,
-0.7650619745,
-0.3866818547,
-0.4605030119,
1.0413730145,
-0.7374573946,
-0.5977458358,
0.3946435452,
0.0521958321,
-0.2080088258,
-0.4572796822,
-0.4680070877,
-0.0200972799,
-0.1711214781,
-0.137596786,
-0.0210372824,
0.5684253573,
0.0680128857,
0.3845510483,
0.7017894387,
-0.4906989336,
-0.0339423344,
-0.030494662,
0.6313497424,
-0.8141466975,
-0.7682315111,
-0.7846949697,
0.5465244055,
-0.0569032803,
-0.1001407802,
0.795809865,
0.3915764391,
0.6800731421,
0.0048676175,
1.0956605673,
-0.2190577239,
0.3552490473,
-0.1028149426,
0.6955951452,
-0.8052530885,
-0.1485860795,
-0.0665347651,
-0.6010164618,
-0.544298768,
0.6984309554,
-0.3019199967,
0.1162902489,
0.7980257273,
0.7226205468,
-0.3863517344,
-0.3540724516,
0.3869384825,
-0.2380608767,
0.1673508286,
0.4560463727,
0.7023265958,
-0.6559917331,
0.197535336,
-0.4164764881,
-0.0561821237,
-0.592502594,
-0.678550005,
-0.9449709058,
-0.7717230916,
-0.172373727,
-0.3361356258,
-0.2003494799,
1.2826639414,
1.0383529663,
-0.6872547269,
0.0449154712,
0.3493446112,
0.4072121382,
-0.5141554475,
-0.2483942658,
0.5141512156,
-0.0012649377,
-0.5224856734,
0.507666111,
0.4673235714,
0.101299651,
-0.0881338716,
0.1292531341,
-0.6749531627,
-0.1889325976,
0.8546725512,
0.1372785419,
-0.7090344429,
-0.6034540534,
0.1232144088,
-0.3373893797,
0.3952907026,
0.7282426357,
-0.47430861,
0.6264513135,
0.5877827406,
0.4583363235,
0.3297082484,
0.3943852782,
0.326652348,
-1.1032714844,
0.1911096126,
-0.1413931996,
0.6077657342,
0.6242611408,
-0.6195560694,
0.1361097246,
0.5661072731,
-0.3652425706,
-0.3250100613,
0.179708302,
-0.9416829348,
-0.2835208476,
1.4244514704,
0.1797627509,
-0.2930327058,
-0.2849542201,
-0.342297703,
0.2687568367,
-0.7063951492,
0.7973969579,
0.6017379761,
0.0430377834,
-0.552729845,
-0.4374781847,
0.3647548556,
0.0640959814,
-0.5330650806,
-0.0220849924,
0.6212710738,
0.2470433563,
0.06985946,
0.7786023021,
0.0288145486,
0.0791129321,
-0.1780079007,
0.1766315103,
-0.0268725641,
-0.4871109426,
-0.2261386663,
0.4802316129,
-0.2064164579,
-0.3682061732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06548v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06548v3 | Inductive reasoning in humans and large language models | 2023-06-11T00:23:25 | 2023-08-04T01:36:56 | Simon J. Han, Keith Ransom, Andrew Perfors, Charles Kemp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The impressive recent performance of large language models has led many to
wonder to what extent they can serve as models of general intelligence or are
similar to human cognition. We address this issue by applying GPT-3.5 and GPT-4
to a classic problem in human inductive reasoning known as property induction.
Over two experiments, we elicit human judgments on a range of property
induction tasks spanning multiple domains. Although GPT-3.5 struggles to
capture many aspects of human behaviour, GPT-4 is much more successful: for the
most part, its performance qualitatively matches that of humans, and the only
notable exception is its failure to capture the phenomenon of premise
non-monotonicity. Our work demonstrates that property induction allows for
interesting comparisons between human and machine intelligence and provides two
large datasets that can serve as benchmarks for future work in this vein. | [
-0.3896227777,
-0.608096242,
0.6705619693,
0.0538140424,
0.1362713426,
-0.0835679471,
-0.5690627098,
-0.6583932042,
-0.1215027794,
0.1751036644,
-0.2979412377,
-0.2228022218,
-0.333689332,
0.0543108582,
-0.3728859425,
0.815715313,
0.0963504612,
-0.0839847997,
-0.3207382858,
-0.2760261595,
-0.1655339748,
-0.7629513741,
-0.4421173632,
-0.9563757777,
0.4125002921,
0.1901605129,
1.0531882048,
0.535582602,
0.3675442636,
0.1685846895,
0.3387390673,
0.1051455811,
-0.1385208368,
0.1034742221,
-0.581317842,
-0.1192407981,
-0.3554974794,
0.3518013954,
0.4787164629,
0.8886086941,
-0.0335769989,
-0.1238767579,
0.0453502052,
0.5565620065,
-0.3479937017,
0.3300590217,
-0.6633429527,
-0.055498749,
-0.0431495905,
-0.133920759,
-0.4283919334,
-0.1502655894,
0.1476295739,
-0.7212049365,
0.8268055916,
0.0855393782,
0.861972332,
0.3258423805,
-0.224282369,
-0.374422878,
-0.8188757896,
0.6311869025,
-0.5486986041,
0.3766787946,
0.6680696607,
-0.0009603201,
-0.3601047993,
-0.6101127267,
-0.7944361567,
-0.8335103989,
-0.2521867454,
-0.146514833,
0.3313154578,
0.0785041898,
0.5683469176,
0.4263363779,
-0.691057682,
0.151665166,
-0.1814254969,
-0.0936413184,
0.7012360692,
0.0443844907,
0.1014203429,
0.0285265092,
-0.0199890509,
-0.0072407261,
-0.6393632889,
0.0355594642,
0.4567610323,
0.4553943872,
0.2372858971,
0.6624770164,
-0.4266980588,
0.4499512613,
-0.0489511341,
-0.0896761492,
0.2868326306,
-0.6125336885,
0.1895110458,
0.0438960046,
0.7049598694,
0.2276290804,
0.5699431896,
-0.4585902691,
-0.2079300135,
0.4373873472,
-0.0577848665,
-0.6776012778,
-0.5012119412,
0.0725599751,
-0.2098243088,
-0.0114627732,
0.1907033175,
-0.4278374612,
-0.5549516678,
-0.4248716831,
0.3082565069,
-0.3291662037,
-0.4226427972,
0.4363338947,
-0.2410937995,
0.7473317981,
0.2108895332,
-1.5122340918,
0.705789268,
0.836240232,
0.4757061005,
-0.0974548236,
-0.73833251,
-0.258924216,
-0.1052762643,
-0.2244063765,
0.756155014,
-0.6406984925,
-0.212416634,
-0.1944409162,
-0.1954203397,
0.0711602941,
-0.7312752604,
0.5385083556,
-0.2269123048,
0.2045729607,
-0.454999119,
-0.3932808638,
0.0220358241,
0.2189144343,
-0.7321984172,
0.9696769714,
0.5412703753,
-0.74507761,
0.651561439,
-1.1667830944,
-0.8385806084,
0.1305921078,
-0.2875480652,
-0.4118124545,
0.0017196126,
0.1755253524,
0.3110239208,
-0.5915007591,
0.2096094638,
-0.5150661469,
-0.3681379259,
0.2469076663,
-0.272415489,
0.7634267807,
0.0998419747,
-0.5272725224,
-0.0582752116,
-0.4510141313,
-0.0626674667,
0.3427323401,
-0.1804563999,
-0.0539540313,
0.0598260164,
-0.4097689688,
0.2967707813,
0.1779430956,
-0.5137921572,
0.6271808147,
-0.0478052236,
0.7701684833,
0.464553684,
-0.0664035082,
0.7136424184,
-0.3050258756,
0.0973069891,
-0.0665092096,
-0.1859791726,
0.273095876,
-0.8512634635,
-0.5583025217,
-0.2004114836,
0.3580948412,
0.5272207856,
-0.5638403893,
0.3739520609,
-0.1596347094,
-0.1493564099,
-0.5787887573,
0.2713032067,
0.2110978812,
0.3570271432,
0.4082065821,
-0.1614512652,
-0.1866374016,
-0.8926635385,
-0.454690665,
-0.1750121117,
-0.2822146416,
0.1681454629,
0.7438409925,
-0.1175000444,
0.8643693328,
-0.2933812439,
0.060028214,
-0.2526992261,
0.6045070291,
0.1017008051,
0.4871335924,
0.4040507376,
-0.6505114436,
-0.1598183215,
0.321187973,
-1.0949553251,
0.1164133623,
-0.0805908814,
-0.1860653162,
0.0268196594,
0.0925915614,
-1.0561351776,
0.6489637494,
-0.0280450974,
-0.4532444477,
0.6931053996,
-0.2128922939,
0.1563489288,
-0.7175126076,
-0.2026340961,
0.3214288056,
-0.1538270265,
-0.5993323326,
-0.0359785222,
-0.0183451083,
-0.054387521,
-0.0698202327,
0.5488396287,
-0.3146942556,
-0.3620623648,
-0.0076051615,
-0.0156468619,
0.1110898927,
0.5235499144,
0.0575710647,
0.9715431333,
0.4740077555,
-0.6069381237,
0.6727252007,
0.2317969948,
-0.3222528398,
0.4960895479,
-0.5182150006,
0.4230486155,
0.0088464906,
0.0877933502,
-0.558504343,
-0.601113975,
0.1087979078,
-0.6841822267,
0.2873072326,
0.177379325,
-0.8695039153,
-0.3945455849,
-0.3719009161,
0.2764983773,
0.5986668468,
-0.6239435077,
0.5847073197,
-0.0628151819,
-0.1364053041,
-0.3492281735,
-0.4221931994,
-0.0214928854,
-0.2941696644,
-0.7396445274,
0.330180198,
-0.0660312399,
-0.6460056305,
0.2356517166,
0.0951143727,
-0.1232400462,
0.2157663256,
-0.0160149503,
0.1080963984,
-0.3699194193,
0.2469116896,
-0.2986092865,
0.0112561397,
0.1919752359,
-0.4781690538,
0.2930580378,
-0.4152196944,
-0.52760005,
-0.6992031932,
0.4926472604,
0.8096913695,
-0.2787189186,
0.5772027373,
0.2910906076,
-0.3726835251,
-0.1861305833,
-0.4159828126,
-0.5507922769,
-0.3201036751,
0.248429656,
-0.6909298301,
-0.7299001813,
0.5837652087,
0.1109072641,
-0.1836051494,
0.4590783119,
0.7287282348,
-0.1165472642,
1.1430640221,
0.4454509318,
-0.218538329,
0.2055500001,
-0.302424103,
0.6306231618,
-0.7486894727,
-0.043124903,
-0.5550823808,
-0.2301734537,
-0.7062751651,
-0.0147357807,
-0.0320537351,
-0.0890823379,
-0.4726009369,
0.2652434111,
-0.530572176,
0.4598831236,
0.7860361934,
0.1452905387,
0.4166735411,
-0.1676224321,
0.0666550249,
0.2848449647,
-0.4333105087,
-0.4511106908,
1.051082015,
0.0811492726,
0.7572034001,
-0.0801461563,
0.4556109011,
0.180722177,
0.5522674918,
-0.8227987885,
0.4225406647,
0.1125966683,
-0.820309341,
-0.6064625978,
-0.4066795409,
-0.7534583211,
0.2408201247,
-0.0498748124,
-0.7290787697,
0.0258748736,
-0.0202205703,
-0.2591923773,
0.3789505959,
-0.8881020546,
0.911724329,
-0.2630505264,
-0.5248308182,
0.011906269,
-0.7060140967,
0.5125489831,
0.1002703905,
-0.1867282838,
-0.3872536123,
0.3906246424,
0.3978041708,
-0.3243502975,
0.4081116617,
-0.2780304849,
0.020650534,
0.3717455864,
-0.2252879888,
0.522067368,
0.0186315645,
-0.3284342289,
-0.1475982815,
-0.4542733133,
-0.7194343209,
-1.0065485239,
0.6585214734,
-0.8854281902,
-0.7519378066,
-0.3234196007,
-0.762493372,
-0.2028773427,
-0.0374913625,
0.4440802634,
0.4122904539,
0.0099232849,
0.0722979233,
0.6678829193,
0.362475723,
0.3358135223,
0.0895325914,
0.0324634984,
0.1344088316,
0.8178362846,
-0.0153478319,
0.4017230272,
0.2515398264,
0.1475812793,
-0.5692158341,
-0.5738868713,
-0.2937444746,
0.3358217776,
-0.7932650447,
-0.0095962668,
-0.4315158427,
-0.1926475316,
-0.4355676472,
-0.1973707229,
-0.2338645905,
-0.5340694785,
-0.0388974361,
-0.1819255352,
0.2940189838,
0.9967258573,
-0.023784617,
-0.2079465836,
-0.1425223798,
0.7097005844,
0.9887517095,
0.3484736979,
-0.1472880393,
-0.4931415617,
-0.0595442764,
0.0750760362,
-0.3645392954,
-0.4142070115,
-0.0362662077,
0.2155951709,
0.6232765317,
0.4271420538,
0.0740367249,
0.3075003922,
-0.402169466,
0.8515691757,
0.0191145483,
-0.8466107249,
0.4519407749,
-0.3553567231,
0.0425332896,
0.6082306504,
0.4012928903,
-0.1033511534,
-0.3840971291,
-0.6327857375,
-0.4947059453,
0.2085527033,
0.3528693616,
-0.0394268073,
-0.100858748,
0.4213692844,
0.3205910623,
0.0425448902,
-0.7617678642,
0.0486106761,
-0.6482869983,
0.0605322756,
0.0148977526,
0.114285849,
0.0341242366,
-0.7264580727,
0.5910850763,
-0.3003893495,
0.4467910826,
0.1816953868,
-0.1327021718,
0.1882316321,
0.4712848961,
0.6627943516,
0.9018771052,
-0.3110846579,
0.2473251373,
0.2370348424,
-0.186128065,
0.4820209444,
0.1284187585,
0.1702182144,
-0.3780167997,
0.4396615028,
0.4765868485,
-0.1086324528,
-0.1688601524,
0.5478032231,
-0.2479820997,
-0.6016383767,
-0.2857525051,
-0.0115507441,
0.1132399142,
0.1908914596,
0.2912375629,
-0.1209372506,
0.0782058835,
-0.7933306694,
0.1308050603,
0.5142202377,
-0.1343241781,
-0.607481122,
0.667221725,
0.1459874362,
-0.375919342,
1.1821914911,
-0.9872104526,
-0.5945828557,
0.4135562479,
0.6205952764,
1.0142761469,
-0.1367854923,
-0.1068078056,
0.2118837237,
0.3443426192,
-0.2725805938,
0.2406158,
-0.1987860352,
-1.1781126261,
-0.7025834918,
-0.3503820002,
-0.5842071176,
0.2017073184,
-0.4443454742,
0.0754885375,
-0.4113591015,
-0.0674708486,
0.406816721,
0.0361224264,
-0.8834233284,
-0.0906203389,
0.2308188826,
0.7073637843,
-1.0400818586,
1.1591439247,
0.7225919366,
-0.7499635816,
-0.8240911365,
0.1242480949,
-0.2234251648,
-0.5340484977,
0.7987373471,
0.2638350427,
-0.3983376026,
-0.0558058321,
-0.8541352153,
-0.2200575471,
1.1140069962,
0.2843357325,
0.1937490851,
-0.2038481981,
0.0677660555,
0.4098994434,
-0.5626755357,
-0.0896597579,
1.2132205963,
0.6784303784,
0.0045837811,
-0.9986447692,
0.0565175898,
-0.3447928429,
-0.1707819849,
0.2254703045,
-0.2092502564,
1.0891615152,
-0.4825845957,
-0.053595826,
0.2162579298,
0.7266979218,
0.2636876702,
0.3576202393,
0.2688640058,
0.9434521198,
0.9692015648,
-0.2599009573,
1.2799297571,
-0.1172413453,
0.4664177895,
1.0092235804,
-0.8359557986,
0.4764591455,
0.2256304175,
-0.4688817561,
0.5769593716,
0.3785990775,
0.1441368908,
0.498398304,
0.2693830431,
-0.6504372954,
-0.2329063267,
-0.1166825071,
-0.3255755603,
0.5134255886,
0.4685353339,
-0.0285291746,
-0.1100333929,
-0.0974908099,
0.0512656607,
0.0269645918,
-0.2921252549,
0.7377997041,
-0.0795546025,
-0.8553326726,
0.6330361366,
-0.2018114328,
0.4919950068,
-0.2451579422,
-0.1789709926,
-0.2174514979,
0.1520739496,
-0.2384385318,
-0.9113314748,
0.0380023457,
-0.2705594301,
-0.461742878,
-0.1228858754,
0.7111385465,
-0.1739310026,
-0.1129939482,
0.330268532,
0.3752777576,
0.2337063104,
-0.3882881403,
-0.3289004564,
-0.5386474729,
-0.1959414035,
-0.1171058044,
0.3130185902,
0.7312626839,
-0.1976164132,
0.609605968,
0.6778244376,
-0.0096687004,
0.0664728507,
0.1111918017,
0.9562279582,
-1.1141183376,
-0.1190191805,
-0.7831217647,
0.3026172221,
-0.2160811424,
-0.322755605,
0.4988051951,
0.4821335375,
0.7805238366,
-0.0508375466,
1.1995487213,
-0.0224241596,
0.5416061282,
-0.4017645419,
0.3444147408,
-0.0019579369,
-0.0917774662,
0.0600977577,
-1.0900747776,
-0.4145647287,
0.7169117332,
-0.4988940656,
0.1618731171,
1.106798768,
0.8589348793,
-0.1201575473,
0.2988267243,
0.4830686748,
-0.0208381694,
0.4035498202,
0.7061812878,
1.3134021759,
0.0043945126,
0.0899893269,
-0.2525956631,
-0.3077690005,
-0.1960809231,
-0.9115185738,
-1.016232729,
-0.5567647815,
-0.162629649,
-0.3911536634,
-0.0931051597,
1.1071995497,
0.8060497642,
-0.8364491463,
-0.1095064878,
-0.1859108806,
0.2982600331,
-0.3947266042,
-0.2001149207,
0.1336034387,
-0.5229077339,
-0.4015967548,
0.4176367819,
0.2817532718,
-0.0188270546,
-0.4832286835,
-0.2601816654,
-0.1952994019,
-0.0322855599,
0.6620440483,
0.5286297202,
-0.7875971198,
-0.5330700278,
-0.214520812,
-0.1129320562,
0.3938675225,
1.1311258078,
-0.7875528336,
0.1833606809,
0.4214555323,
0.6437136531,
0.60381037,
0.0510649569,
0.3285275996,
-0.589133203,
0.324898392,
0.3896609843,
0.4816503227,
0.5905779004,
-0.3704839945,
0.7345086932,
0.3617854118,
-0.8590534329,
-0.47187379,
0.5584908724,
-0.8018340468,
0.0122816125,
0.9362255931,
-0.088604711,
-0.069624804,
-0.4911030829,
0.0428892039,
-0.0538157634,
-0.4056049287,
0.6976721883,
0.9442324042,
-0.6587290168,
-0.1775093824,
-0.9182436466,
0.4993184507,
0.1421787292,
-0.972979784,
0.1841704845,
0.115853332,
0.1018256024,
0.3702613413,
0.6071625352,
-0.1355793625,
0.3938470781,
0.1791542768,
0.2307982445,
0.0990083441,
-0.3852534294,
-0.1499312967,
0.1336578578,
0.6695084572,
-0.0738385841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06531v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06531v3 | AutoTAMP: Autoregressive Task and Motion Planning with LLMs as Translators and Checkers | 2023-06-10T21:58:29 | 2024-03-22T00:21:04 | Yongchao Chen, Jacob Arkin, Charles Dawson, Yang Zhang, Nicholas Roy, Chuchu Fan | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.HC | For effective human-robot interaction, robots need to understand, plan, and
execute complex, long-horizon tasks described by natural language. Recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) have shown promise for translating
natural language into robot action sequences for complex tasks. However,
existing approaches either translate the natural language directly into robot
trajectories or factor the inference process by decomposing language into task
sub-goals and relying on a motion planner to execute each sub-goal. When
complex environmental and temporal constraints are involved, inference over
planning tasks must be performed jointly with motion plans using traditional
task-and-motion planning (TAMP) algorithms, making factorization into subgoals
untenable. Rather than using LLMs to directly plan task sub-goals, we instead
perform few-shot translation from natural language task descriptions to an
intermediate task representation that can then be consumed by a TAMP algorithm
to jointly solve the task and motion plan. To improve translation, we
automatically detect and correct both syntactic and semantic errors via
autoregressive re-prompting, resulting in significant improvements in task
completion. We show that our approach outperforms several methods using LLMs as
planners in complex task domains. See our project website
https://yongchao98.github.io/MIT-REALM-AutoTAMP/ for prompts, videos, and code. | [
-0.1291226596,
-0.7213025093,
0.6858922243,
0.1373212039,
-0.1873748153,
0.1159937605,
0.0995640233,
-0.5499122143,
0.4408222139,
0.7750430703,
-0.992334187,
-0.25482741,
-0.7249168754,
0.1003636122,
-0.39232862,
0.5504175425,
-0.4822031856,
-0.3037897348,
0.1156065166,
0.0171549041,
-0.532056272,
-0.3149044216,
-0.4800513983,
-0.5280526876,
0.1605602503,
0.3022493422,
0.7303599119,
0.8921354413,
0.746931076,
0.3608960211,
0.1980027705,
0.4618813992,
0.1178024784,
0.4529230893,
-0.393456459,
-0.1795906872,
-0.4914382696,
-0.2500200272,
0.4787706733,
0.6962147355,
-0.0326074585,
0.128952682,
-0.0923822969,
0.6948632598,
-0.680039227,
0.3776227534,
-0.3177111447,
0.3385675848,
0.082321696,
-0.2799141407,
-0.1397152394,
0.1474620104,
-0.2567023933,
-0.4252870083,
-0.0059694252,
0.0554145873,
0.7915894389,
1.0061895847,
-0.4161531627,
-0.1255467832,
-1.0952723026,
0.6263110638,
-0.5435732007,
0.3692368567,
0.494797349,
0.1532943994,
-0.6709742546,
-0.4550800323,
-0.8179649711,
-0.0404205397,
-0.1346843541,
0.0590050742,
-0.3830813169,
0.1288361847,
0.3754523396,
-0.0143670365,
-0.7870335579,
0.1469544917,
0.172238782,
-0.2094738036,
0.7239376307,
0.503521204,
0.1594376862,
-0.2492630482,
-0.5047106743,
-0.3637412786,
-0.4559340179,
-0.0224550813,
0.0565872565,
0.1189466417,
-0.0711758882,
0.790340662,
-0.6677719355,
0.8936543465,
0.1056259871,
0.0592442751,
-0.0234656744,
-0.6379780173,
-0.4803186059,
-0.4623848796,
0.8412062526,
0.3267322481,
-0.0104345772,
-0.1547286212,
-0.2594421506,
-0.0806319565,
0.1989498436,
-0.3753021657,
-0.3426965475,
0.3903156519,
-0.1038042232,
0.3095483482,
-0.1371455938,
-0.6970450282,
-0.1248001829,
-0.5807820559,
0.6166710258,
-0.2791756988,
0.3748862445,
0.3499750495,
0.1053947583,
0.2296175063,
0.6592953801,
-0.7327414155,
0.0376109555,
0.5858122706,
0.6930705309,
-0.0706387386,
-0.6494988203,
-0.8488928676,
0.5409045815,
-0.3575600684,
1.0868551731,
-0.1123237014,
-0.3465355933,
0.0074345008,
0.0614397638,
-0.1370699257,
-0.3863348961,
0.3451875746,
-0.3809681535,
0.2191254646,
0.0389031842,
-0.4329749048,
-0.2896727026,
0.2914497256,
-0.522669971,
0.8504570723,
0.0192289911,
-0.1173867881,
0.4474793375,
-0.8021089435,
-0.5979506969,
0.0049737399,
-0.0053977519,
-0.2215594947,
-0.3780578971,
0.2966513336,
0.5922511816,
-0.0641608909,
0.4976430535,
0.1295901388,
0.1318597794,
-0.1531741917,
-0.1597408801,
0.6795873046,
0.2445683181,
-0.5053377151,
0.3786247671,
-0.3473207951,
0.1043428034,
0.0123805096,
-0.2791223228,
0.1282492429,
0.2067144066,
-0.3789866567,
0.4183796346,
0.4160606861,
-0.262434572,
0.4122771323,
-0.2803702056,
0.3085876405,
0.338211596,
0.0266756658,
0.6345561147,
-0.2254393548,
0.6139169335,
-0.2740982771,
0.2966236472,
-0.4754651785,
-0.3357660472,
-0.8884424567,
-0.0910521224,
-0.1175758392,
0.8487244844,
-0.9645767212,
0.8818051219,
-0.2420810908,
-0.3560287356,
-0.0149162868,
0.2665069103,
0.434897989,
0.2847881913,
0.5807445645,
-0.333424747,
-0.4973201454,
-0.74898839,
-0.2342441678,
-0.5000479221,
-0.2339745164,
-0.180948779,
0.6269394159,
-0.4691584408,
1.0164530277,
-0.637814939,
-0.5251314044,
-0.217249155,
0.6206125021,
-0.1732193679,
0.5588813424,
0.1754027009,
-0.6470113993,
-0.3707235754,
-0.4093603492,
-0.2938691974,
-0.3615046144,
-0.4573597312,
-0.4234676659,
0.3172151744,
0.613361001,
-0.8605542779,
0.4429348409,
0.5138899088,
-0.4983967841,
0.2062133253,
-0.1806786507,
0.1763100475,
-0.9761169553,
0.1050400659,
-0.0834250599,
-0.5860777497,
-0.4334815443,
0.1804740578,
-0.1064033359,
0.0431156494,
-0.3409870863,
0.6403158307,
-0.4101830125,
-0.2763608694,
-0.5473381877,
0.0206402615,
0.0633494705,
0.4730988145,
0.3447394669,
0.6041656733,
0.0519683696,
-0.6761456728,
0.3671196699,
0.4617376029,
0.0275334399,
0.3863420784,
-0.2804918289,
-0.0166775882,
0.148469165,
0.5723966956,
-0.8282659054,
-0.5031042099,
0.555275023,
-0.44109267,
0.4709275663,
-0.3390491605,
-0.6804784536,
-0.4103167951,
0.0262762923,
-0.0003588176,
0.2933311164,
-0.3679378927,
0.8153005838,
0.6188842058,
-0.0722672269,
-0.430144161,
-0.7121942043,
0.4307093024,
0.0758325011,
-0.3993441761,
0.4546867907,
-0.109005101,
-0.2141728699,
-0.0852414742,
-0.1784878373,
-0.2933525145,
-0.0275244955,
0.2672269642,
0.2376210243,
0.2646454871,
-0.2106104046,
-0.1931956857,
-0.5128110051,
0.1619013399,
-0.1977588385,
0.6468794942,
0.2436328828,
-0.4701903164,
-0.6203989983,
0.3893366456,
0.4227492511,
-0.1790392846,
0.1236474067,
0.6146904826,
-0.4028753936,
-0.211628601,
-0.4528280199,
-0.2312963009,
-0.425500989,
0.1912963986,
-0.1827297956,
-0.6319293976,
0.2194107771,
-0.3253909349,
0.3086447418,
0.5455446243,
0.4271325767,
-0.4086222351,
0.8015309572,
0.7411550283,
-0.133797437,
0.5702050328,
-0.317979455,
0.105195269,
-0.6769513488,
-0.0787754059,
-0.5744617581,
-0.4429630935,
-0.3437283933,
-0.9009594321,
0.064262718,
-0.1124769896,
-0.2990695238,
0.8492358327,
-0.3801511526,
0.3685855567,
0.6115784645,
-0.2926745415,
0.3146728873,
-0.1471287906,
0.1998918056,
-0.0894929469,
-0.6319696903,
-0.6399686933,
0.4807485044,
0.0251450855,
0.683493197,
-0.0693240538,
0.7505186796,
0.3948647082,
-0.151087746,
-0.860830009,
0.8092201352,
-0.1480193138,
-0.4224930704,
-0.5522020459,
-0.174154222,
-1.10940516,
0.1278703809,
-0.2343323827,
-0.7115970254,
0.2574659884,
0.3930507898,
-0.5049230456,
0.2914072871,
-0.3953484595,
0.9134679437,
-0.2833287716,
-0.2654568553,
-0.2213634849,
-0.9611216187,
0.0372846499,
0.0929077268,
-0.009475816,
-0.4122703075,
-0.289999485,
0.5680764914,
-0.3269876838,
0.9991006851,
0.0433722138,
-0.0435365029,
0.3917644918,
0.6365015507,
0.9220010638,
-0.3956288695,
0.2546361089,
0.1226947755,
-0.1951546818,
-0.1796922535,
-0.4704708457,
0.3682088852,
-0.3518691659,
-0.5092794299,
-0.5616723299,
-0.7410537004,
-0.0978697315,
0.0787504017,
0.0392975174,
-0.0021047506,
0.074837938,
-0.1632273197,
0.2723818421,
0.0406614132,
0.8607727289,
0.8642246127,
-0.0726605058,
-0.3074142337,
0.4456587136,
-0.0433948301,
0.3024412096,
0.8310286999,
-0.123592943,
-0.2245864123,
-0.6070056558,
-0.5308602452,
0.1056424603,
-0.5698566437,
-0.4206046164,
-0.7808419466,
0.0523032248,
-0.3115646243,
-0.459327668,
-0.5787033439,
-0.5710077882,
0.0021992307,
0.2981434762,
0.0798689052,
0.7496607304,
-0.4311459959,
0.3272048831,
-0.9903788567,
0.5028096437,
0.2325686067,
-0.0601675995,
-0.592033565,
-0.5359187722,
-0.2117327154,
-0.0756242499,
-0.4280380607,
-0.5474480391,
0.8253965378,
-0.0755794346,
0.4204877913,
-0.0370380692,
0.1876772344,
1.0640913248,
-0.5705708861,
0.7835471034,
-0.0235794038,
-0.9792450666,
0.8266654611,
-0.2463445514,
0.5832939744,
0.5179834366,
0.3508974016,
-0.5779355168,
-0.5733713508,
-0.717086494,
-1.0273859501,
0.6241784692,
0.2026619613,
-0.1913161874,
0.0805381313,
0.272056669,
-0.0756370947,
0.1791673899,
-0.5882866383,
0.0052441275,
0.2224802524,
-0.1466110051,
-0.2436034381,
-0.1656007916,
-0.0795000568,
0.1057259515,
0.545193851,
-0.2684160471,
0.4044436514,
0.3595648706,
-0.2635003328,
-0.4388272762,
0.2410932481,
0.7654778957,
0.3263261318,
0.004187502,
0.1890992224,
0.1053545251,
-0.4769790471,
0.1636369079,
0.2462603003,
-0.3397310972,
0.0210034847,
0.5210391283,
0.3262105286,
0.1249127463,
-0.6056075096,
0.0797590315,
0.3234631121,
0.0045025027,
-0.3698530793,
0.284596771,
-0.2216377407,
0.519190371,
0.2434993833,
0.2498339117,
0.210847646,
-0.4600092769,
0.2551772296,
0.2933076322,
-0.275200814,
-0.3258518279,
0.662247777,
0.2749909461,
-0.4523681998,
0.2401220351,
-0.5230515003,
-0.6056523323,
0.6706584692,
0.2641280293,
1.188939333,
-0.2522797883,
0.1410657018,
0.5667946935,
0.5580649376,
-0.2655576468,
0.4533266127,
-0.1723625362,
-0.5757074356,
-0.9628016949,
-0.3595342338,
-0.6224426031,
-0.1776306331,
-0.2388377637,
0.1320362985,
-0.2151744366,
-0.195287168,
-0.2142191976,
0.0904771611,
-0.6045695543,
0.1995705217,
0.0734926313,
0.460550189,
-0.7686117291,
0.6806311011,
0.8482968211,
-0.2778630853,
-0.4841835797,
0.3246594071,
0.1291709244,
-0.7188601494,
1.0738521814,
-0.2024482638,
-0.5037436485,
-0.0707894489,
-0.4645423889,
-1.2106258869,
0.9831058979,
0.1671944559,
-0.6247317791,
-0.04458737,
0.2059550136,
0.3382296264,
-0.157745719,
-0.2212564498,
0.2411388904,
0.6117592454,
0.2439263016,
-1.1387665272,
0.0076377806,
0.1943281889,
-0.3215304315,
0.7468945384,
-0.538074851,
0.5107679963,
-0.1942743212,
-0.2650822699,
-0.0312715396,
0.6624522805,
0.0039666686,
0.384739846,
0.6439251304,
0.6134575605,
0.3743364215,
-0.1394273639,
0.9551236629,
-0.3762060404,
0.181472823,
1.594843626,
-0.4599413872,
1.0703289509,
0.5508165359,
-0.3378276825,
0.3569823802,
0.3902336359,
0.0882846862,
0.4182750285,
-0.2249261588,
0.0169247333,
-0.600787878,
-0.1034093648,
0.3230399191,
0.725150466,
0.3083546758,
0.0572247431,
-0.3686634004,
-0.0457588881,
0.1357393861,
0.1700867712,
-0.0584695302,
0.6907824874,
-0.0636120513,
-0.9554572701,
-0.0845880285,
-0.0031187311,
0.4831551015,
-0.5730807781,
-0.1955232769,
-0.1343905628,
0.0866087079,
-0.0156687889,
-0.9582541585,
0.703774929,
-0.0299026873,
-0.047802113,
-0.6621400118,
0.7261788845,
-0.4671944976,
-0.1049647108,
0.2337653488,
0.6421094537,
0.0898159146,
-0.0402043872,
-0.7789985538,
-0.1688750684,
-0.0376071818,
-0.206419304,
0.1594773829,
0.3724607229,
-0.03159675,
1.0759211779,
0.5020131469,
-0.0768870115,
-0.0578193963,
-0.3018891811,
0.4459874928,
-0.8940939903,
-0.3924761713,
-0.8844328523,
0.5401719809,
0.0886830688,
-0.1518333256,
0.6518019438,
0.5357676148,
0.875839293,
0.1125468537,
0.2324290723,
-0.0995500162,
0.4002712667,
-0.7543034554,
0.2032611966,
-0.360132128,
0.1226766482,
0.03219584,
-0.7020909786,
-0.5710923672,
0.6941402555,
-0.2202105671,
-0.1292660832,
0.7614744306,
0.5064284801,
0.2873214781,
-0.5813394785,
0.3053627312,
-0.0444192402,
0.3653664589,
0.6228621602,
0.6828574538,
-0.3545056581,
0.5891955495,
-0.4161797464,
0.2234730273,
-0.3685672283,
-1.16565907,
-0.5413728952,
-0.7720400691,
-0.8474377394,
-0.0509264357,
-0.0264078993,
1.2400876284,
0.7247092724,
-0.5692477822,
-0.3473984003,
-0.1430482715,
0.0597277172,
-0.1179359034,
-0.180910036,
0.2236702144,
-0.4566743374,
-0.8576456308,
0.7345304489,
0.5904302001,
0.4007712305,
-0.2839772105,
-0.0365649872,
-0.2842251062,
-0.1102249771,
0.6509735584,
0.6263833642,
-0.7015265822,
-0.2938413918,
0.0255008079,
-0.1842380166,
-0.0496181548,
0.7716422081,
-0.7487355471,
0.4829823077,
0.6481156349,
0.3236570358,
0.4911860228,
-0.0551748164,
0.763712585,
-0.4691536427,
0.1935900897,
0.3638383448,
0.4667026103,
0.2014921308,
-0.1989736259,
1.0012813807,
0.0643112212,
-0.859967649,
-0.5170194507,
0.4508319795,
-1.0751519203,
-0.2519413531,
1.137085557,
-0.0273423176,
-0.3142696321,
-0.3323814571,
-0.1503443569,
0.330083847,
-0.3146781027,
0.7989646196,
0.536390543,
-0.5408067703,
0.0347275473,
-0.7852166891,
0.5473898053,
0.3666395247,
-0.8774563074,
0.2562108934,
0.6975004673,
-0.3045262992,
0.3074477315,
0.5957496762,
0.2302514464,
0.2043569833,
-0.1359104663,
0.4735007286,
0.0993046835,
-0.2882054448,
-0.2149273455,
-0.292937696,
-0.059250202,
-0.3431433737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06524v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06524v1 | What Can an Accent Identifier Learn? Probing Phonetic and Prosodic Information in a Wav2vec2-based Accent Identification Model | 2023-06-10T21:20:47 | 2023-06-10T21:20:47 | Mu Yang, Ram C. M. C. Shekar, Okim Kang, John H. L. Hansen | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | This study is focused on understanding and quantifying the change in phoneme
and prosody information encoded in the Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) model,
brought by an accent identification (AID) fine-tuning task. This problem is
addressed based on model probing. Specifically, we conduct a systematic
layer-wise analysis of the representations of the Transformer layers on a
phoneme correlation task, and a novel word-level prosody prediction task. We
compare the probing performance of the pre-trained and fine-tuned SSL models.
Results show that the AID fine-tuning task steers the top 2 layers to learn
richer phoneme and prosody representation. These changes share some
similarities with the effects of fine-tuning with an Automatic Speech
Recognition task. In addition, we observe strong accent-specific phoneme
representations in layer 9. To sum up, this study provides insights into the
understanding of SSL features and their interactions with fine-tuning tasks. | [
-0.4739775062,
-0.6977401376,
0.2124153227,
-0.196524024,
-0.1841822416,
0.0592495501,
-0.2232988775,
-0.5942207575,
0.0656378195,
0.5053778887,
-0.5262825489,
-0.3064341843,
-0.2408294976,
0.2291354388,
0.0317933969,
0.8152417541,
0.414729327,
0.3692063093,
0.2106485069,
0.0085639162,
-0.5816997886,
-0.4024658799,
-0.8808526397,
-0.1492569894,
0.3604146838,
0.824829638,
0.4773367345,
0.6219736338,
0.4652532637,
0.3294817209,
-0.0070609557,
0.2474375516,
-0.3380683661,
-0.0424272493,
-0.242990911,
-0.6931715012,
-0.4518277347,
0.2529632151,
0.5396180749,
0.5752668381,
0.169071883,
0.4925514162,
0.2693781853,
0.3621503413,
-0.348359704,
0.3644044995,
-0.7605250478,
-0.2347810119,
-0.2945287824,
-0.1675418466,
-0.2917411327,
-0.0183726959,
0.1611647606,
-0.4802247882,
0.5618231893,
0.1745504588,
0.6084471941,
0.3650043905,
-0.343447119,
-0.2126853317,
-0.759876132,
0.7434284091,
-0.4972518682,
0.4872065187,
0.5907042623,
0.2483538091,
-0.063711524,
-0.3440209031,
-0.4635308981,
-0.1625948995,
-0.1684340686,
0.1348291636,
0.207584247,
0.082410343,
0.0129350983,
0.5964529514,
-0.326688081,
0.2391257286,
-0.5370781422,
-0.2720799744,
0.8038809896,
-0.1071400642,
0.2089998424,
-0.1087742373,
-0.1834349781,
-0.1782757938,
-0.4103740454,
0.4184365273,
0.4735425413,
0.6577227712,
-0.1770451814,
0.112939775,
0.0918127298,
0.1893497407,
0.4102902114,
0.0133575909,
0.2842766941,
-0.0915248394,
-0.1954165399,
0.2270353585,
0.5942873359,
-0.0418002643,
0.5468257666,
-0.0538424924,
-0.1554069668,
-0.3153722286,
0.2399956733,
-0.5159227252,
-0.3542431295,
0.192686826,
-0.4031003416,
-0.2926296294,
0.2237388492,
-0.1500618607,
-0.1438397765,
-0.4938773215,
0.4858721495,
-0.4790354967,
-0.7867504358,
-0.2305860817,
-0.1394454986,
0.5295732617,
0.0176912844,
-0.9849774241,
0.4290493131,
0.6974734664,
0.5449627042,
-0.2553072274,
-0.2212777287,
-0.3994412422,
-0.3742725551,
-0.6275920868,
0.500648737,
-0.4690360129,
-0.6503716111,
-0.117519103,
0.5330123305,
-0.2114958614,
-0.8746851683,
0.3848257959,
-0.4443190694,
-0.1331703812,
-0.3331645131,
-0.3508288562,
-0.1772339791,
-0.3322132528,
-0.8435354233,
1.0333338976,
0.2502692342,
-0.4382880032,
-0.0050339862,
-0.3194200397,
-0.5312296748,
0.159481287,
0.0386623181,
-0.6387893558,
0.4757715762,
-0.1601806432,
0.3935550153,
-0.1114216298,
-0.1651632339,
-0.1176673099,
-0.5909943581,
0.2516262829,
-0.2808304429,
0.7279726267,
0.164017424,
-0.1828237027,
-0.0660585016,
-1.2281197309,
-0.0130992485,
0.2010831833,
-0.3301181197,
-0.4171898365,
-0.1456411779,
-0.0671148673,
-0.2309688628,
0.2090005577,
-0.6901531219,
-0.0218726043,
-0.3100495934,
0.3802357018,
0.3503525555,
0.193433255,
0.5079163313,
0.0535748117,
0.2279878557,
0.0636872947,
0.0943429023,
-0.2404592037,
-0.4174837768,
-0.7789092064,
0.0617588386,
0.5831604004,
0.596516192,
-0.0743516907,
0.1577531993,
0.1152129546,
-0.5008246899,
-0.8724196553,
0.0269145668,
0.6947163343,
0.4986056387,
0.6466616988,
-0.3863335848,
-0.350199163,
-0.7888556123,
-0.3592358232,
-0.2105730325,
-0.2972401977,
0.5336309671,
0.2810691893,
0.3306718171,
0.6233178973,
-0.038491115,
-0.5772788525,
-0.035294544,
0.5619575381,
-0.0545364991,
0.7454865575,
0.3313263953,
-0.7417317629,
-0.3084998131,
0.0352156274,
-0.14374955,
-0.1353257895,
-0.0626500919,
0.2356353998,
-0.339420259,
0.7397331595,
-0.2028764933,
0.1130043939,
0.2872025073,
-0.2056887448,
0.8147858381,
-0.2533319592,
0.1314366758,
-0.7754493356,
-0.3080405891,
0.044539202,
0.0083814254,
-0.8390480876,
-0.1235228181,
0.4998551309,
-0.0619671904,
-0.3992304802,
0.1808222681,
-0.7243199348,
-0.1850313693,
-0.1973103881,
-0.2944484055,
-0.0182969272,
0.5633795857,
0.2438518107,
1.1710950136,
0.5404133201,
-0.6298540235,
-0.1509722024,
0.0508967079,
-0.3165213168,
0.5593707561,
-0.7420373559,
0.5201305151,
-0.0916367024,
-0.2904758155,
-1.2030959129,
-0.199304685,
-0.2205260396,
-0.7048121095,
0.6221424937,
-0.5264615417,
0.0754219741,
-0.0599389486,
0.077881299,
0.3826449215,
0.5607812405,
-0.4681688845,
0.7305905223,
0.348038435,
-0.1615812778,
-0.2745025754,
-0.5603588223,
-0.3018467426,
-0.2753183246,
-0.2505736649,
0.6066648364,
0.1726715118,
-0.2664422393,
-0.41187644,
-0.1847082824,
-0.2279867381,
0.3810950518,
0.3397046924,
-0.0727112815,
-0.5653441548,
0.2744543552,
-0.0948317721,
-0.0878181681,
0.2813169062,
-0.1435332298,
0.3251346946,
-0.1131689325,
-0.2850427032,
-0.7748154998,
0.3350816071,
0.5885588527,
-0.8680902719,
0.228968814,
0.8054939508,
-0.0548659749,
-0.242764622,
-0.575697422,
-0.3868525922,
-0.5247303843,
0.4622826278,
-0.8761709332,
-0.6679703593,
0.7343475819,
-0.2217350304,
-0.2260095179,
0.4582146406,
0.1508613378,
-0.4784494042,
1.0068190098,
0.6468977928,
-0.0676536337,
0.5445450544,
-0.3462842405,
0.0136947781,
-1.0831923485,
-0.1194129884,
-0.5651218295,
-0.1760865599,
-0.7126174569,
-0.2209931761,
0.3321774602,
0.2942591012,
-0.0656484514,
0.3105909824,
-0.3612313867,
0.4308090508,
0.704839766,
0.2671796381,
-0.1137777492,
-0.3578363061,
-0.1326812655,
0.1095170528,
-0.0051199002,
-0.2494540811,
0.9510809183,
0.5096442699,
0.5472660065,
0.1252996624,
0.6263833642,
0.3779696226,
-0.538404882,
-0.8996602297,
0.4042547345,
-0.0640119165,
-0.2408742309,
-0.5238220096,
0.1484650373,
-0.7244894505,
-0.0159442909,
-0.1286647469,
-0.4973963201,
0.601692915,
0.3357081711,
-0.5953131914,
-0.0792426839,
-0.8494467735,
0.5941719413,
-0.2060389966,
-0.2612839639,
-0.3437761962,
-0.5173408985,
-0.1991527528,
0.062695004,
0.1223902777,
-0.1334793121,
0.3604907095,
0.5105106235,
-0.1401143223,
0.8261168003,
-0.3385510445,
-0.2127993554,
0.3835730553,
0.3935671449,
0.4294501543,
-0.0590354353,
-0.2052525431,
0.483748436,
-0.0441592559,
-0.2615938187,
-0.5626121163,
0.4115847945,
-0.8259302974,
-0.8479793668,
0.1562107503,
-0.2473652065,
-0.3347907066,
0.0233330932,
0.1252684146,
0.7172545195,
-0.2250562161,
0.133046791,
0.8920024633,
0.0956461877,
0.3336035013,
0.75919801,
0.4581213593,
0.076858975,
1.0380986929,
0.3358989358,
0.4275122285,
0.282297641,
0.2925046086,
-0.1525165886,
-0.7839757204,
-0.280280441,
0.1148814112,
-0.4720557034,
0.1758376807,
-0.2988315523,
-0.3678173721,
-0.5626317859,
0.2837841809,
-0.4956896901,
-0.2568512261,
-0.6050662994,
-0.0871744007,
0.2929885089,
0.7518912554,
-0.1842935979,
0.4069188237,
-0.3564950526,
0.0324415788,
0.6323578358,
0.2077360749,
-0.1811324805,
-0.8213307261,
-0.4188474417,
-0.120943673,
0.1264145821,
-1.0330271721,
0.1735419035,
0.5258044004,
0.3721134067,
0.5970562696,
0.153223604,
0.5566319823,
-0.6250060201,
0.9687405825,
-0.4129270613,
-0.7986922264,
0.6221333742,
-0.2634132206,
0.2828937173,
0.4498211741,
0.2760845721,
-0.1281243861,
-0.4070824385,
-0.488257736,
-0.6143829823,
0.5095363259,
-0.1166609228,
0.1259777695,
-0.0701506138,
0.4649173617,
0.05387545,
-0.1870663166,
-0.1647281349,
-0.2042559087,
-0.2543204427,
-0.165049091,
-0.0199612062,
-0.5285450816,
0.0816770345,
-0.2915511727,
0.5201982856,
-0.3556697369,
0.3092027605,
0.3963567615,
-0.3020085096,
0.0916989669,
0.322347492,
0.4093199074,
0.0985159352,
-0.2341671139,
0.298832655,
0.5909870863,
-0.5905791521,
-0.1248595417,
-0.0400454849,
0.1846171618,
-0.0692454278,
0.5406761169,
0.9926031232,
0.1974716336,
-0.0563737042,
0.454695344,
-0.0253512599,
-0.3091344535,
-0.5242445469,
0.5073909163,
-0.0862229168,
0.3833990693,
0.5676996708,
-0.1290301979,
0.4454272687,
-0.4505347311,
0.0597220026,
0.6124154925,
-0.7724555135,
-0.7511973381,
0.6592587233,
0.2714577317,
-0.7889283895,
0.3638118804,
-0.1875920296,
-0.4428140819,
0.9643225074,
0.5949112773,
0.8203113079,
-0.9004997611,
-0.0394265689,
0.4835744202,
0.0618608668,
0.2873258889,
0.4306418002,
-0.6556863189,
-0.7158499956,
-0.0145023111,
-0.3606563807,
-0.2560834885,
0.3781027198,
-1.0405917168,
0.2991369367,
-0.3717324436,
-0.2012733072,
0.3552779555,
0.0605575107,
-0.9191343188,
0.5307822824,
0.3119899631,
0.7084767222,
-1.0069990158,
0.9166532755,
0.5707358718,
-0.2699440122,
-1.0808115005,
0.0633793622,
0.2142056972,
-0.8199336529,
0.6056054831,
0.3340541422,
-0.5062007308,
0.3725241721,
-0.258487612,
-1.0228885412,
0.9353837967,
-0.0412133597,
-0.682887435,
0.120905906,
0.3768516481,
0.4640432298,
-0.403452009,
0.8027938604,
0.9564139247,
0.2351896614,
-0.3353758752,
-1.3229572773,
-0.2488966435,
-0.2646430731,
0.1190171018,
-0.2655108869,
-0.8588429093,
0.9477353692,
-0.3464492261,
-0.4687786996,
-0.0023224375,
0.601397872,
-0.46281299,
-0.0967924297,
0.6724973321,
0.089903675,
0.8946136832,
-0.2781352103,
0.5351940393,
-0.5811241865,
0.0945686325,
1.1862831116,
0.0461619943,
0.8979797363,
0.1756286472,
-0.0529176705,
0.5577452183,
0.8124829531,
-0.0689026937,
0.58875072,
0.1452226043,
-0.1384154707,
-0.3268563151,
-0.0800739229,
-0.2738137543,
0.9073196054,
0.5035318136,
-0.3319365978,
0.2533774972,
0.1796726882,
-0.181899339,
-0.1032737195,
-0.4257503152,
1.2291047573,
-0.1182001084,
-0.6170694232,
0.7293063402,
-0.2165632695,
0.3679487705,
-0.393845439,
-0.2169332653,
-0.1361317039,
0.1586213112,
-0.2064508796,
-0.6728436351,
0.0230729654,
-0.5390822887,
-0.2193913609,
0.095320344,
0.6630450487,
-0.5992033482,
-0.2208496183,
0.2754910886,
0.2112998962,
0.3082889915,
-0.0811359584,
-0.4648901522,
0.0386427082,
-0.0821631476,
-0.2846413553,
0.1082720011,
0.4124679267,
-0.0122436304,
0.3640206754,
0.4330331385,
0.1948164254,
0.0463447534,
0.4394364655,
0.3843517303,
-0.6224993467,
-0.5083966851,
-0.548730731,
0.4771841466,
-0.0457989797,
-0.3883892596,
0.5384966731,
0.3989171684,
0.8789690137,
-0.1784780174,
0.7673949003,
0.5266644359,
0.9028232694,
-0.5247451067,
0.4435207546,
-0.4210436344,
0.137805745,
0.008439918,
-0.4094941318,
0.2307200879,
0.5495021939,
-0.159009248,
-0.2886538208,
0.4771201313,
1.0781018734,
-0.2326572537,
0.2512204051,
0.2833829224,
0.1523566544,
-0.0395690389,
-0.0547826476,
0.4812965989,
-0.381188333,
0.2187945694,
-0.2422649413,
-0.1894766539,
-0.1955253035,
-0.3183330297,
-0.936103642,
-0.8885344863,
-0.4224210083,
-0.1258656234,
0.1123321205,
0.7750928998,
0.8979446292,
-1.0586299896,
-0.2248895466,
0.029701788,
-0.050560914,
-0.5923015475,
-0.2712976336,
0.521632731,
-0.6093991995,
-0.87392205,
0.8056351542,
-0.0080072368,
0.1323497742,
-0.3562223017,
0.2005581409,
0.392364651,
0.1308571249,
0.2850078642,
0.4719409645,
-0.7438903451,
-0.438090831,
0.0777785331,
0.1854135394,
0.2208059728,
0.81498456,
-0.6542679071,
0.5694876313,
0.0892903805,
0.4104073048,
0.2883304954,
0.1789339781,
0.4639731348,
-0.8881562948,
0.0816698372,
-0.0489949808,
0.2598431408,
0.3033444583,
-0.7159577012,
0.2474930435,
-0.1297332644,
-0.5497371554,
-0.5768464804,
0.2994613349,
-0.7064808607,
-0.0827964172,
1.2296243906,
-0.1894646883,
-0.2648409009,
-0.4664163888,
-0.2764463127,
0.4477910697,
-0.2118282914,
0.5908378959,
0.412622869,
-0.1294496208,
-0.4681174457,
-0.3450871408,
0.9109861255,
0.4176490009,
-0.1718594432,
0.010949187,
0.0458766371,
0.523658812,
0.2971083224,
0.3958700895,
0.0226980504,
0.2804552019,
-0.1254998893,
0.027058538,
-0.3488315046,
-0.4676917195,
-0.3801575005,
0.0353143662,
0.1920872033,
-0.7465206981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06521v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06521v1 | Universal Language Modelling agent | 2023-06-10T21:09:16 | 2023-06-10T21:09:16 | Anees Aslam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models are designed to understand complex Human Language. Yet,
Understanding of animal language has long intrigued researchers striving to
bridge the communication gap between humans and other species. This research
paper introduces a novel approach that draws inspiration from the linguistic
concepts found in the Quran, a revealed Holy Arabic scripture dating back 1400
years. By exploring the linguistic structure of the Quran, specifically the
components of ism, fil, and harf, we aim to unlock the underlying intentions
and meanings embedded within animal conversations using audio data. To unravel
the intricate complexities of animal language, we employ word embedding
techniques to analyze each distinct frequency component. This methodology
enables the identification of potential correlations and the extraction of
meaningful insights from the data. Furthermore, we leverage a bioacoustics
model to generate audio, which serves as a valuable resource for training
natural language processing (NLP) techniques. This Paper aims to find the
intention* behind animal language rather than having each word translation. | [
-0.6112674475,
-0.8499581218,
0.1855518967,
0.2186276913,
-0.2616570294,
-0.0372676104,
-0.1807007343,
-0.811729908,
0.1094182059,
0.7181310058,
-0.5226535201,
-0.4961932003,
-0.3184663355,
0.005487686,
-0.3075815439,
0.8006445765,
0.4271388054,
0.0318637565,
0.3304781318,
-0.5413534045,
-0.1819274276,
-0.6252865195,
-0.5710844398,
-0.8184634447,
0.5211723447,
0.1113427505,
1.1598650217,
0.9783700109,
0.2968407869,
0.3089665473,
-0.3796290457,
0.2164869606,
-0.2150405496,
-0.0445902012,
-0.3399732709,
-0.1373116225,
-0.2684028447,
0.0206514597,
0.6170724034,
0.7826930881,
-0.3762156069,
0.0566606559,
-0.1028189212,
0.7346439958,
-0.1561277509,
0.2903317809,
-0.7451028228,
0.1864640564,
-0.2056451142,
-0.4111451805,
-0.2382098287,
-0.0058398643,
0.1719653755,
-0.7149509192,
0.1060064584,
0.057728976,
0.8747977018,
0.2982333899,
-0.5692991018,
-0.7039341331,
-0.7404889464,
0.7831227183,
-0.7833749652,
0.4897652864,
0.4094142914,
0.1173024029,
-0.6988981962,
-0.4654169083,
-0.8636755943,
-0.2337738723,
0.0420028232,
-0.2576670647,
-0.0577710681,
0.2616185546,
-0.0313760489,
0.3484967351,
-0.3977870047,
-0.1736614257,
-0.0537964292,
-0.1576745808,
0.7263050079,
-0.0402041823,
0.7817628384,
-0.21743536,
-0.2849223018,
-0.3947921991,
-0.608032763,
0.3528246284,
0.4345864952,
0.3376339078,
0.018029511,
0.5290080309,
0.1393656135,
0.4263007641,
-0.4753887653,
-0.2161064893,
0.0864814222,
-0.2840154767,
-0.0450052395,
0.3673173785,
0.7608277202,
0.0849840194,
0.3128362,
-0.133875072,
-0.2149550617,
0.0406238735,
0.4587631822,
-0.6049948335,
0.3007007241,
0.2286646068,
-0.3745042086,
-0.3248121738,
-0.0372026488,
-0.4005988836,
-0.1342799664,
-0.2524236441,
0.413443476,
-0.686303854,
-0.4879905581,
0.5614690185,
-0.1142979339,
0.6883997321,
0.0432989299,
-0.9920932651,
0.4317410588,
0.7643226981,
0.3960742056,
0.2705724537,
-0.363293916,
-0.3227787018,
0.6198738217,
-0.5153009295,
0.727889955,
-0.7759274244,
-0.5892987251,
0.0114465524,
0.0050997385,
0.3127827942,
-0.3652490377,
0.672465384,
-0.6190437078,
-0.1347873956,
-0.2778686881,
-0.4857514799,
-0.993516922,
-0.0557075962,
-0.7989997864,
0.9755841494,
-0.1396628469,
-0.6446460485,
0.1778450906,
-1.0366044044,
-0.2582978904,
0.1781587601,
-0.3626217842,
-0.5151162744,
0.0061629876,
0.066427432,
0.2316762209,
-0.4052663743,
0.6168469191,
-0.2912151217,
-0.4256878495,
0.6116001606,
-0.211373806,
0.7293688655,
0.3386174142,
-0.2398368418,
-0.0652115718,
-0.6470941305,
0.1084096059,
0.0787298605,
-0.3219456971,
-0.5505074263,
0.3601102233,
0.2196930349,
-0.0292529035,
-0.0392684191,
-0.6894581914,
0.2473722994,
-0.6860202551,
0.3992049098,
0.302865237,
-0.0131519409,
0.2700514495,
-0.4941438138,
0.2323502898,
-0.2590982616,
-0.1018419787,
-0.0671001077,
-0.4939705431,
-0.3082976043,
-0.2526498437,
0.0280143321,
0.3263584077,
0.0031054986,
0.5332564712,
0.0187294278,
-0.3869704902,
-0.7149271369,
0.2876490057,
0.3143821657,
-0.0079844873,
0.1187444329,
-0.3935980797,
-0.5736742616,
-0.9103652835,
-0.3798066676,
-0.4338856041,
-0.1093965322,
0.207031846,
0.4316390753,
-0.5884934068,
1.0290007591,
-0.0671988279,
-0.1419127882,
-0.350047648,
0.294070065,
0.2413205057,
0.5456572175,
0.6464521289,
-0.8920778036,
-0.2413050532,
0.4369733632,
-0.8909700513,
-0.0604891069,
-0.0570472032,
-0.3771025538,
-0.1407491863,
0.4037706256,
-0.663399756,
0.6732487082,
0.3876241446,
-0.3119056523,
0.140925929,
-0.0475027412,
0.2186460346,
-0.9571951628,
-0.0006738576,
-0.3348267376,
-0.0213387255,
-0.6603722572,
-0.1631325185,
-0.2021915168,
-0.0565435439,
-0.4613800049,
0.7544990182,
-0.4554291368,
-0.1819442362,
-0.4724618196,
-0.0462359078,
0.0665140748,
0.5033398271,
0.2426675558,
0.5546494722,
0.3674459457,
-0.6423030496,
0.1611415148,
0.6719105244,
-0.2108169496,
0.1276091635,
-0.7264922261,
0.1729535908,
-0.0506615043,
0.084862031,
-0.9213244915,
-0.2202917635,
0.1624338627,
-0.5652585626,
0.3352608383,
0.1794902831,
-0.499982655,
-0.1355733573,
-0.0907063708,
0.541868329,
0.3104683757,
-0.4106751084,
0.6819123626,
0.6789590716,
-0.376934737,
-0.4899786115,
-0.4034718275,
0.1086251065,
-0.2050834894,
-0.7682837248,
0.2877040505,
-0.1210748404,
-0.4663261473,
-0.0489009991,
-0.1260107905,
-0.0645113885,
0.2639147043,
0.4222333133,
-0.1165319979,
-0.5900552869,
0.4177864492,
0.140207544,
0.149748683,
0.3024270535,
-0.1959306598,
0.4315286875,
-0.1679554284,
-0.2695280313,
-0.5939106941,
0.7626357675,
0.6784817576,
-0.2762997448,
0.7606966496,
0.6050578952,
-0.3329941928,
-0.2081244141,
-0.4876567423,
-0.1270269006,
-0.5103361011,
0.410421133,
-0.406488508,
-0.4671038687,
0.4328644574,
-0.2062664181,
-0.0974232107,
0.3038600981,
0.5311508775,
-0.1575800478,
0.9742293954,
0.9480820298,
-0.053058356,
0.5072364807,
-0.0809810013,
-0.066816397,
-0.6657252908,
-0.3753585815,
-0.5267257094,
0.0099130934,
-0.4475864172,
-0.2645719349,
0.120100446,
0.182652548,
-0.3515055478,
0.0985798314,
-0.4248708487,
0.5153766274,
0.3687830567,
-0.2410862297,
0.2796734571,
0.37254107,
-0.3819016516,
0.244360581,
-0.3182674646,
-1.0404281616,
0.8045291305,
0.532556951,
0.5444955826,
0.27171278,
0.338062346,
0.4770033956,
0.2519378662,
-0.7913241982,
0.3857601881,
0.1308394074,
-0.8727462292,
-0.6620749831,
0.2038812935,
-1.1194124222,
0.5675919056,
-0.0554657578,
-0.8166489601,
-0.0572071448,
-0.3017796874,
-0.019564433,
0.3741832376,
-0.1907431632,
0.7436579466,
-0.0307108629,
0.0066716881,
-0.1822727472,
-0.682965517,
0.2410962731,
-0.2925978601,
0.5527274013,
-0.3796895742,
-0.0773340911,
1.026480794,
-0.692822516,
0.7288401723,
0.2726920545,
-0.4472942352,
0.753200829,
0.0185258333,
0.2206166685,
-0.0191434417,
-0.4499706626,
0.2333194315,
0.2883251905,
-0.5267464519,
-0.331101805,
0.2289686203,
-1.001147747,
-0.3910764456,
-0.40843907,
-0.7197636366,
-0.2015252858,
0.0848127976,
0.0324104875,
0.4774464071,
-0.4490866661,
0.2320807874,
0.4022467136,
-0.6147307158,
0.45268327,
1.0721398592,
-0.4377924502,
-0.5606027246,
0.5028509498,
-0.3455510437,
-0.0131078735,
0.4074267149,
0.3872891366,
-0.5638923645,
-0.3105646372,
-0.3742128015,
0.5844573379,
-0.6406512856,
0.0867947116,
-0.789455533,
-0.2596573532,
-0.1590465605,
-0.08855398,
-0.3387677372,
0.0986795351,
-0.1565560997,
-0.0589681864,
0.6646597385,
1.2441743612,
-0.4011811912,
0.7851744294,
-1.1428322792,
0.3950320482,
0.2900429368,
0.0406385474,
-0.0165821519,
-0.4413088858,
-0.2218441218,
0.4969814718,
-0.3454076946,
-1.1733725071,
0.7307547331,
0.652377069,
0.8305048347,
0.3736275733,
-0.0775832012,
0.4970463514,
-0.5099041462,
0.5463631153,
0.0192790404,
-0.9243741632,
0.6052526832,
-0.6413936019,
0.1517885923,
0.2374332696,
0.3371158838,
-0.7208303809,
-0.7175893784,
-0.4515246749,
-0.5816856027,
0.7369683981,
0.4490655661,
0.1601964384,
0.0286903251,
0.3892669082,
0.3098160028,
0.2950901687,
-0.6595931053,
-0.1643873602,
-0.1476054937,
-0.1989407092,
-0.1301145554,
-0.2374099046,
-0.0619032755,
-0.3803755939,
0.4907801151,
-0.0463517755,
0.1497732252,
0.1152435839,
-0.2501583993,
-0.519729495,
0.5415726304,
0.4898061752,
0.2945303917,
-0.32566908,
0.0199348778,
-0.1226250604,
-0.7904801369,
0.3602140248,
-0.2375873029,
0.083133094,
0.1510203332,
0.3511017263,
0.5508223176,
0.1963877678,
-0.7713780999,
0.402290374,
-0.0135922609,
-0.218210727,
-0.4847921133,
-0.0571434684,
0.3535585105,
0.4226098657,
0.6434661746,
-0.2204035372,
0.2773882747,
-0.7782649398,
0.5067668557,
0.4739068449,
-0.5087414384,
-0.5852724314,
0.6415836215,
-0.0781937465,
-0.4475382864,
0.4659791291,
-0.1447588056,
-0.6300777793,
0.8207589388,
0.7647457719,
0.7523568273,
-0.4641704559,
0.464566499,
0.1833796203,
0.2392473668,
0.1682344824,
0.6440167427,
-0.1745934784,
-0.8358165622,
-0.5722976327,
-1.2419741154,
-0.4175496995,
0.2244327068,
-0.7547308207,
-0.0087797251,
0.0136319995,
-0.0576896481,
0.3166104853,
0.0307969004,
-0.531968534,
0.1270677447,
0.3217755556,
0.660015285,
-0.7600672245,
1.1470761299,
0.7037897706,
-0.5487955213,
-1.1933034658,
-0.1540355831,
0.0179107673,
-0.7922769785,
1.0374381542,
0.2346975803,
-0.5255300403,
0.0606183596,
-0.8357010484,
-0.8625392318,
0.7347535491,
0.3417719901,
-0.1743554324,
0.1228925362,
0.4417700768,
0.6139981747,
-0.4465636909,
0.0724341497,
0.482422322,
0.440685302,
0.307166338,
-0.8726763725,
0.0167998672,
-0.613827765,
-0.1438569725,
0.1531487554,
-0.3195401132,
0.9027706385,
-0.1353149116,
-0.4336126447,
0.2653419673,
0.7823186517,
0.1288138628,
0.2922566533,
0.4278322458,
0.1408627033,
0.6172251701,
0.3320632577,
0.7506355047,
-0.2812571228,
0.0824061781,
0.7284265757,
-0.2737327218,
0.8441666961,
0.335836798,
-0.2730168998,
0.5742282271,
0.5994616151,
0.3151210248,
0.295781672,
0.4601821601,
-0.5004967451,
-0.3249806464,
-0.6137604117,
-0.4717692435,
0.8047476411,
0.7515566349,
-0.0272226371,
-0.0784769505,
0.184602797,
-0.1622775197,
0.0755922943,
-0.2147834599,
1.0376061201,
0.2335540354,
-0.3828564286,
0.8221495152,
-0.328954339,
0.371560514,
-0.6952418685,
-0.3496011794,
0.072366707,
-0.0207933709,
0.0992474258,
-0.4989196062,
0.2716753185,
-0.2248914987,
-0.0050684987,
-0.0023539346,
0.4766141474,
-0.6577914953,
-0.1002702862,
0.5064689517,
0.3038818836,
0.5237683058,
-0.1902061254,
-0.5467131734,
0.1646759808,
-0.0042137825,
-0.2730707228,
0.0207024664,
0.8583022952,
0.0051966002,
0.7194381952,
0.7502359748,
0.2975773215,
-0.0562813357,
-0.2361066192,
0.6294103861,
-1.3571153879,
-0.5889010429,
-0.8588843346,
0.1811538637,
0.1650630981,
0.1433130205,
0.3397135437,
0.3028785884,
0.451056838,
-0.0590867773,
0.783893168,
0.3708120584,
0.4910260439,
-0.5097628832,
0.9160808325,
-0.7635164857,
0.3313495815,
-0.3338657618,
-0.767962575,
-0.1686221361,
0.6605075598,
0.0377030484,
-0.4557100236,
0.7648180127,
0.8140438199,
0.1106477752,
0.4293632805,
0.602573812,
0.197614789,
0.393910408,
0.0599411577,
1.1694546938,
-0.2735797167,
0.6512842774,
0.1710775942,
0.1537438333,
-0.1346596628,
-0.6579427719,
-0.7735394835,
-0.5752792954,
-0.1182711348,
-0.0713387206,
0.0236356109,
1.088052392,
0.3980480433,
-0.6950369477,
-0.627487123,
0.0125207659,
0.0102261063,
-0.1110832393,
-0.1197128445,
0.4596501887,
-0.384786427,
-0.4773803949,
0.4537777901,
0.3830491602,
0.4319112599,
-0.3217480779,
-0.3649889827,
-0.2286617011,
0.6267334223,
0.562984705,
0.6231950521,
-1.1238554716,
-0.4466563165,
-0.179270342,
-0.3633182049,
0.1005784348,
0.6786531806,
-0.4867319763,
0.389092207,
0.1319116652,
0.5752848387,
0.2454757988,
-0.1605925709,
0.8684913516,
-0.3892744482,
0.3941964507,
0.0778640285,
0.216681689,
0.2814250886,
-0.105204761,
0.5378973484,
-0.0070621655,
-0.5097194314,
-0.8420695066,
0.2763907909,
-1.1493499279,
-0.3670857549,
1.2833813429,
-0.0020086344,
-0.6578732133,
-0.418353945,
-0.5981658101,
0.6873548031,
-0.4029768705,
0.4924952388,
0.6108967662,
0.0707364604,
0.3659545183,
-0.7305010557,
0.6546593904,
0.2438908517,
-0.4619232118,
-0.1509062648,
0.2467895746,
0.1873978376,
0.1329900324,
0.7123729587,
-0.1703303605,
0.1279723048,
0.145688042,
0.6570026875,
0.2842821777,
-0.0402824357,
-0.0106771588,
0.0945492163,
0.2473481894,
-0.2682313025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07297v1 | Medical Data Augmentation via ChatGPT: A Case Study on Medication Identification and Medication Event Classification | 2023-06-10T20:55:21 | 2023-06-10T20:55:21 | Shouvon Sarker, Lijun Qian, Xishuang Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The identification of key factors such as medications, diseases, and
relationships within electronic health records and clinical notes has a wide
range of applications in the clinical field. In the N2C2 2022 competitions,
various tasks were presented to promote the identification of key factors in
electronic health records (EHRs) using the Contextualized Medication Event
Dataset (CMED). Pretrained large language models (LLMs) demonstrated
exceptional performance in these tasks. This study aims to explore the
utilization of LLMs, specifically ChatGPT, for data augmentation to overcome
the limited availability of annotated data for identifying the key factors in
EHRs. Additionally, different pre-trained BERT models, initially trained on
extensive datasets like Wikipedia and MIMIC, were employed to develop models
for identifying these key variables in EHRs through fine-tuning on augmented
datasets. The experimental results of two EHR analysis tasks, namely medication
identification and medication event classification, indicate that data
augmentation based on ChatGPT proves beneficial in improving performance for
both medication identification and medication event classification. | [
-0.2096257955,
-1.0245983601,
0.624147892,
-0.1148205027,
-0.3220516741,
0.0662090778,
-0.2838952541,
-0.7998692393,
0.109438397,
0.5199421048,
-0.7176043391,
-0.4003043771,
-0.5176304579,
-0.0197510812,
-0.1629617512,
1.3249830008,
-0.2169549614,
0.3403491378,
-0.3076002896,
0.1109065861,
-0.6734404564,
-1.0551798344,
-0.7543072701,
-0.6511836648,
0.5636355877,
0.2407281995,
0.3701207638,
0.3356929123,
1.0374897718,
0.2029479444,
0.102682963,
0.4150371253,
-0.353892386,
0.0124633657,
0.1611875445,
-0.3892124891,
-0.7161028385,
-0.3040857017,
0.3527342677,
0.5449913144,
-0.1232924908,
0.1313179731,
0.077071324,
0.554690659,
-0.2873084843,
0.5231624246,
-0.4725367129,
0.1969276816,
-0.2424954027,
-0.4999632835,
-0.1337310672,
-0.2040650249,
0.3912954926,
-0.6938729882,
0.3165389597,
-0.0209392682,
1.0114219189,
0.2026036382,
-0.326077342,
-0.5057901144,
-0.6661813855,
0.3705667853,
-0.58816576,
0.3864896297,
0.2783070207,
0.1769340336,
-0.4532939196,
-0.8280077577,
-0.5660713315,
-0.1233678311,
-0.3444226384,
0.1350168288,
-0.1201876849,
0.3216708899,
0.3039195836,
0.4133901298,
-0.5179888606,
0.2803174555,
-0.3792400956,
-0.2274934351,
0.3856522143,
0.3841176331,
0.5006716847,
-0.2164231092,
-0.3804701567,
0.0743700191,
-0.5988568068,
-0.2483443618,
-0.1309900135,
0.3311522305,
-0.1216061711,
0.7778218389,
-0.0325673185,
0.4772367477,
0.1682736874,
-0.053451255,
0.6160563231,
-0.4233054519,
-0.2713714838,
0.2088588923,
0.6509921551,
0.4797688723,
-0.0136297587,
-0.0640754327,
-0.2139044255,
-0.09086629,
0.1270827204,
-0.7699286342,
-0.5546374917,
0.322104305,
-0.5264009237,
-0.2056202292,
-0.1414212584,
-0.6647263169,
-0.4877634943,
-0.6328381896,
0.6736428738,
-0.5899928808,
0.0314360037,
-0.0101193273,
0.0159081556,
0.277051568,
0.4604389071,
-0.878379643,
0.3993806243,
1.0031257868,
0.7185580134,
-0.3653319776,
0.1352309883,
-0.3003576696,
-0.0400678851,
-0.2728047073,
0.8280720711,
-0.539824307,
-0.3720673323,
0.0720487908,
0.1996176094,
-0.2770010829,
-0.6778948903,
0.6230956912,
-0.5628252029,
0.2986321449,
-0.1874160171,
-0.911590457,
0.1047954634,
0.3739521801,
-0.644041121,
0.9076398611,
0.1673655212,
-0.7390145659,
0.5900467634,
-0.8428791165,
-0.539001286,
0.4666081071,
-0.2804319263,
-0.7160174251,
0.1849712729,
0.3970325291,
0.543443799,
-0.147317946,
0.2729343772,
0.0007211202,
-0.2563053668,
0.4439282417,
-0.3518264592,
0.2876524925,
0.1079433709,
0.2504840493,
-0.0423674509,
-0.7833999991,
-0.1512004435,
0.0084470287,
-0.5922923684,
-0.2036189288,
0.0361594521,
0.3966998458,
0.127677381,
0.3804073632,
-0.353191644,
0.2977778018,
-0.3902305961,
0.1575074196,
0.3993571997,
0.4549778402,
-0.0256014112,
-0.4661698937,
0.3563928306,
-0.0045349426,
0.261974901,
-0.377612412,
-0.5698232651,
-0.5285155773,
-0.463081181,
0.6232078075,
0.7170612216,
-0.707644403,
0.6032166481,
-0.574183166,
-0.2271936536,
-0.471606344,
0.0181243252,
-0.0102293976,
0.6394854784,
0.4231736064,
-0.3210904598,
-0.6307782531,
-0.7864388824,
0.0434377715,
-0.0416145697,
-0.3656902909,
0.4212909341,
0.1800382733,
-0.4239063859,
0.5875504613,
-0.5005529523,
-0.5396794081,
-0.3730850816,
0.025107123,
0.2357221842,
0.3985399604,
0.2265668511,
-0.658356607,
-0.3864012063,
0.2044674605,
-0.5196743011,
-0.3119095564,
-0.1809022874,
-0.122520484,
-0.2230032235,
0.3347237706,
-0.4204925597,
0.2953760326,
0.3408577144,
-0.1561897546,
0.1542312503,
-0.5666126609,
0.3288602531,
-1.0135396719,
-0.0727424473,
-0.0018398267,
-0.1761903614,
-0.9076799154,
-0.1958703548,
0.2483742535,
-0.2129081935,
-0.1747553349,
0.2436816543,
-0.3576922417,
0.3091265559,
-0.2844234407,
-0.0290847495,
0.0184048545,
0.281689018,
0.2052849978,
0.4186301827,
0.5287280083,
-0.4192537069,
0.3858415484,
0.4730786383,
-0.3668701053,
0.6676679254,
-0.5611342788,
-0.0830468386,
-0.096033074,
0.2195047736,
-0.8975363374,
-0.5373154879,
0.2554280758,
-0.3330494761,
0.5285506248,
-0.2737378776,
-0.7185109854,
-0.2541570663,
-0.0316125453,
0.0416674502,
0.6739279032,
-0.5545734167,
0.5592206717,
0.4699914157,
-0.3220364153,
-0.1291742027,
-0.6074483991,
0.084416002,
-0.2094955146,
-0.3595131636,
0.3995465338,
0.1810295433,
0.103200011,
-0.1214305609,
0.1752766371,
-0.2246754915,
-0.2120307237,
0.3955506682,
0.8937345147,
-0.2207417935,
0.6700740457,
-0.0289886091,
-0.0721265003,
0.136021018,
-0.0683895275,
0.5190684795,
0.38746804,
-0.6753488779,
-0.5370604992,
0.3931345046,
0.3714911044,
-0.0984734669,
0.8055617809,
0.7441549301,
-0.543740809,
0.3935475349,
-0.8103036284,
-0.2787947357,
-0.4063760638,
0.5318826437,
0.0431221128,
-0.7178784013,
0.4212836325,
-0.2004023939,
-0.0772861764,
0.3293599486,
0.6116380095,
-0.1427217722,
0.870280683,
0.1831877083,
-0.1338610053,
0.6992008686,
0.1137115583,
0.1661206931,
-1.0777264833,
-0.4681611061,
-0.1559243053,
-0.1134233177,
-0.7978222966,
-0.6071490049,
0.7936993837,
-0.2890033126,
-0.0062506567,
-0.0751212761,
-0.3984719515,
0.287347883,
0.1641429514,
0.8026874065,
0.2657071948,
0.1770467609,
0.2047343403,
-0.1578349024,
-0.592641592,
-0.2817728519,
1.430154562,
0.3789408207,
0.5589190722,
-0.1184704974,
0.526350081,
0.2593484819,
0.3818479776,
-0.7346076369,
0.2272324264,
-0.1926623136,
-0.5162653923,
0.028226899,
-0.2772139609,
-1.0480366945,
-0.0327078104,
-0.5989561081,
-0.8686213493,
0.0823659003,
0.1827397346,
-0.4565061927,
0.0171020832,
-0.8674542904,
0.7042779326,
-0.3519065678,
-0.2028408349,
-0.0089658666,
-0.596693933,
0.087558575,
-0.4521035552,
0.1047973111,
-0.0236233007,
-0.0453648157,
0.6688488722,
-0.6791084409,
0.5967767835,
0.1324902773,
0.1189234108,
0.0708891153,
-0.5254884958,
0.7661800385,
-0.0233034659,
0.1962988079,
0.0749534518,
0.060296081,
-0.240966171,
-0.7076128721,
0.6898207664,
-0.5488592982,
-0.498105824,
-0.1939870566,
-0.2011099011,
-0.4518134892,
0.0294860415,
0.145275414,
0.6595343351,
-0.136201188,
0.1306194514,
0.7202199101,
-0.3483016491,
0.0353570692,
0.633926332,
-0.0250447709,
-0.2081224024,
0.7552008033,
0.1945098639,
0.2795536816,
0.5227553844,
0.1424008161,
-0.2820747197,
-0.6482123733,
-0.3718044162,
0.1244679391,
-0.5549468994,
0.0290726405,
-0.668792069,
-0.3892383277,
-0.2266185284,
0.099919118,
-0.0370956697,
-0.2254996151,
-0.3556776047,
-0.1326355636,
0.6831972599,
0.5283615589,
0.0090278015,
0.5597983003,
-0.8672586083,
0.4398551285,
0.1471407264,
0.3951547444,
-0.1752810925,
-0.3561649024,
-0.2116429359,
-0.1872104555,
-0.1374887228,
-0.981054008,
0.301210016,
0.1219147146,
0.7362074256,
0.3859733939,
-0.2824087143,
0.7968589067,
-0.7187070847,
0.6477062106,
0.1090249419,
-0.4718430936,
0.6448788047,
-0.3328736424,
0.0985724702,
0.4604002237,
0.27084589,
-0.492193222,
0.0278802812,
-0.5999987721,
-1.0470224619,
0.6616054773,
0.4076808095,
0.2361535132,
0.0622449778,
0.4694229364,
-0.0405766368,
0.1676761359,
-0.3064070046,
-0.3933164179,
0.3375067413,
-0.4229670465,
0.0159085467,
-0.2027612627,
0.0221768282,
-0.1756296605,
0.7303203344,
0.2193451524,
0.3485571444,
0.329867661,
0.0127394209,
0.1038729176,
0.4389148951,
0.1159934551,
0.3592780828,
-0.1466617137,
-0.1493258178,
0.3403055668,
-0.7851679921,
-0.1685463041,
0.4928257763,
0.0757052824,
0.0774297267,
0.3742170632,
0.8679695725,
0.1312086433,
-0.8257924914,
0.3437875509,
0.0169724319,
0.1045726314,
-0.2392475307,
0.0728940591,
-0.2522910535,
0.2131444812,
0.2686290443,
-0.2871537805,
0.3326572776,
-0.3899221122,
0.3444341123,
0.3756189942,
-0.5605620742,
-0.0527529046,
0.4012417495,
0.0417952873,
-0.2248499393,
0.6178067327,
0.1982128024,
-0.4625644386,
0.4408628345,
0.4144933522,
0.3653289974,
-0.2562420666,
-0.0258006938,
0.3712914586,
0.1479173154,
0.0199209079,
0.1838132143,
0.0235785134,
-0.6091724038,
-0.4594877958,
-0.3060698807,
-0.4319762886,
0.5009685755,
-0.7072299123,
0.5456626415,
-0.0330568999,
-0.3337507546,
0.2308105528,
0.0152678061,
-0.9048454165,
0.2225682139,
0.3037886322,
0.5155385137,
-0.8839005232,
0.6316896677,
0.6322591305,
-0.1883450001,
-0.8342154622,
-0.1033194289,
0.1815137714,
-0.7620721459,
0.3682743609,
-0.1625086963,
0.6129037738,
-0.2440657765,
-0.1401971281,
-0.5080094934,
0.9330192208,
-0.0912017673,
-0.6690276265,
0.0679225847,
0.4667807817,
0.8317690492,
-0.2875487804,
0.3663662672,
0.7710356712,
0.3176918626,
0.2317947149,
-1.1278841496,
-0.0655989721,
-0.2352489978,
-0.1840247661,
0.3310224414,
-0.1370707303,
0.6848604679,
-0.1353034228,
-0.056403894,
-0.1467893869,
0.1050371528,
0.310247153,
0.3261423707,
0.2298320383,
0.2999025285,
0.8885135651,
-0.2844220698,
0.9756880999,
-0.2002705336,
0.3577644527,
1.1062979698,
-0.3398513198,
0.7895127535,
0.427616179,
-0.4146398008,
0.3384638131,
0.7135643959,
-0.1911590397,
0.4338161051,
0.0780068412,
-0.5785006881,
-0.2108163834,
-0.1194506437,
-0.5401110053,
0.1421235651,
0.9124715328,
-0.6694265008,
-0.1679262072,
0.2822980583,
-0.0005997326,
-0.4943386614,
-0.2514737248,
1.2611534595,
-0.1699925363,
-0.3696782291,
0.2207496017,
-0.232421428,
0.2317039222,
-0.6429434419,
-0.2340007275,
0.0921417549,
0.1810536087,
-0.2566800117,
-0.6504766345,
-0.0730768815,
0.0019966101,
-0.0074821319,
0.2873099446,
1.03388834,
-0.4627792537,
-0.7682614326,
-0.1421969384,
0.5390961766,
0.1154529825,
0.0013811722,
-0.5989968777,
-0.0348016471,
-0.2159603685,
-0.1338552088,
0.4674935937,
0.6200186014,
0.0249145105,
0.4807224274,
0.8059808612,
0.4104024768,
-0.1450781226,
0.221691981,
0.9639632702,
-0.2185826302,
-0.4361463487,
-0.982609272,
0.290995568,
-0.2468220145,
-0.033333201,
0.6141381264,
0.7095019817,
0.3555743694,
-0.182004407,
0.8946847916,
0.1136766672,
0.8926333189,
-0.5977620482,
0.4919668734,
-0.2357889414,
0.5083804727,
-0.1744231284,
-0.3558684886,
-0.301089555,
0.338300854,
-0.5164673328,
-0.0723917261,
0.3663338125,
0.7133748531,
-0.0532820299,
-0.0082971342,
0.2313306928,
-0.0594622269,
0.290124476,
0.6422463655,
0.7940385938,
-0.6056670547,
0.215734303,
-0.1393330097,
-0.2011258155,
-0.4780266583,
-0.6599812508,
-0.9751246572,
-0.4522877932,
-0.4204371274,
-0.2038231939,
0.2416549772,
1.3507670164,
0.6664614677,
-0.9554790258,
0.402026087,
0.0913924724,
-0.1747546196,
0.0870746076,
-0.2292052507,
0.6164085865,
-0.2979362011,
-0.5269824862,
0.1065606773,
0.2233213484,
0.2568628788,
0.211724177,
0.2123140246,
0.1117635965,
0.0560603477,
0.5583621264,
0.0343623944,
-0.473323226,
-0.1307286918,
-0.0356488526,
0.026409341,
0.3478929102,
0.8701936603,
-0.7757992744,
0.6296124458,
0.3301301003,
0.5721598864,
0.3734767735,
0.3187837005,
0.4768729508,
-0.5660440922,
-0.1205669492,
-0.0283485316,
0.3790839612,
0.3049992323,
-0.5458993316,
0.3315193653,
-0.012501251,
-0.591360569,
-0.5770741701,
-0.2953985631,
-1.0374292135,
0.0899537429,
1.0865908861,
-0.0447522774,
0.0936789736,
-0.4350744188,
-0.5012856126,
0.2673219144,
-0.2240019739,
0.8253611922,
0.7226039171,
-0.6361537576,
-0.0988646671,
-0.9823027253,
0.5401901603,
0.0764482617,
-1.1989547014,
0.0105469115,
0.5349318385,
0.2693057358,
-0.0345886983,
0.6656073928,
-0.3301360905,
0.1118875891,
-0.3507973254,
-0.2279162258,
0.1542717963,
0.1820438504,
-0.2090525925,
-0.0411143452,
-0.0272864066,
-0.4590423703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06480v1 | Annotation-Inspired Implicit Discourse Relation Classification with Auxiliary Discourse Connective Generation | 2023-06-10T16:38:46 | 2023-06-10T16:38:46 | Wei Liu, Michael Strube | cs.CL | cs.CL | Implicit discourse relation classification is a challenging task due to the
absence of discourse connectives. To overcome this issue, we design an
end-to-end neural model to explicitly generate discourse connectives for the
task, inspired by the annotation process of PDTB. Specifically, our model
jointly learns to generate discourse connectives between arguments and predict
discourse relations based on the arguments and the generated connectives. To
prevent our relation classifier from being misled by poor connectives generated
at the early stage of training while alleviating the discrepancy between
training and inference, we adopt Scheduled Sampling to the joint learning. We
evaluate our method on three benchmarks, PDTB 2.0, PDTB 3.0, and PCC. Results
show that our joint model significantly outperforms various baselines on three
datasets, demonstrating its superiority for the task. | [
-0.3207066953,
-0.7176015377,
0.7482014894,
0.0327394605,
-0.442543447,
-0.0195534676,
0.0476319827,
-0.6852764487,
-0.0206822474,
0.4445102811,
-0.5709605217,
-0.3147584796,
-0.4189166725,
0.1353268772,
0.0714349672,
1.1461740732,
0.111106053,
0.1956098527,
-0.4481370449,
-0.193833366,
-0.3854173422,
-0.4459283054,
-0.8640881777,
-0.3566727042,
0.5891225934,
0.0992050394,
0.3368091583,
0.4781033993,
0.0375379771,
0.2570108771,
-0.3075761497,
0.4294158816,
-0.3459708989,
0.2986573279,
-0.0054339813,
-0.3098033667,
-0.3312426209,
-0.0755710155,
0.2710955739,
0.9879660606,
0.0307766851,
0.2350614965,
-0.0052176057,
0.2510762215,
-0.6536130309,
0.461933285,
-0.755461216,
-0.1294021457,
-0.2193510234,
-0.03446538,
-0.7112663388,
-0.6729410887,
0.2883660197,
-0.5831906199,
0.3299571872,
0.1715703756,
0.756909132,
0.1402395815,
-0.730017066,
-0.1021451205,
-0.5903814435,
0.1558114439,
-0.409041971,
0.291454196,
0.2563557625,
0.2817651033,
-0.2200957835,
-0.8890508413,
-0.5663077831,
-0.1782111675,
-0.2787994742,
0.3330126405,
0.1463272274,
0.4583713114,
0.3659007847,
0.0443421975,
-0.4243161678,
0.1439936906,
-0.4682193995,
-0.057216946,
0.6111013293,
-0.0069784187,
0.1354365051,
-0.3906516135,
-0.5922088623,
0.2742555439,
-0.9571281075,
0.0530323796,
0.4885774851,
0.2537287176,
0.1263467968,
0.3306547701,
-0.0043661739,
0.5617852807,
0.0996343568,
0.2173549682,
0.021622926,
0.0153269675,
-0.2455613017,
0.3372486532,
0.9805783033,
0.2144272327,
0.1875019222,
-0.1245558783,
-0.0261163078,
0.0382153094,
0.1087258011,
-0.6629911661,
-0.3736294806,
0.0396290831,
-0.254116267,
-0.2144715041,
-0.1202458143,
-0.4220605195,
-0.2574318349,
-0.5424479246,
0.021220237,
-0.4305221438,
-0.3418182731,
-0.5552520156,
0.066573523,
0.1014769226,
0.5273084641,
-0.9045528769,
0.6138958931,
0.5857783556,
0.7410362363,
-0.1730617434,
-0.0549766049,
-0.4481756985,
0.458037734,
-0.3562738895,
1.170042038,
-0.3342882991,
-0.3561195135,
0.0947368369,
-0.2726077735,
-0.1299289465,
-0.3333655298,
0.6567738652,
-0.4591897428,
0.4073543847,
-0.3382081687,
-0.6843390465,
-0.3814413249,
-0.0315664858,
-0.6886821389,
0.9214946032,
0.2749827802,
-0.8791338205,
0.4920870066,
-0.5446332693,
-0.4565337002,
0.3238619566,
-0.4030301869,
-0.4332835078,
0.0926216394,
0.2680903077,
0.5733158588,
-0.5114216208,
0.5594626665,
-0.416967541,
-0.2120634317,
0.0115493089,
-0.1015937179,
0.9707811475,
-0.0792158172,
-0.0515613519,
0.3743168712,
-0.8711516857,
-0.3213501573,
-0.0821810141,
0.1276135147,
-0.5792163014,
-0.0782246739,
-0.0188665837,
0.4500600994,
-0.077618666,
-0.74069947,
-0.0224021114,
-0.63027215,
0.1895459294,
0.9988855124,
0.4413073063,
0.2646231651,
-0.227218166,
0.2495121807,
0.184528932,
-0.1312213838,
-0.1890047789,
-0.6192453504,
-0.8272770643,
-0.163443163,
0.4438039958,
0.4581488371,
-0.8161756396,
0.2994310558,
-0.4193652868,
-0.3911232948,
-0.3629337549,
-0.2401158214,
0.5641422868,
0.8242648244,
0.4301240742,
-0.0797637627,
-0.6617352962,
-0.9712628126,
0.0989526063,
-0.4765427709,
-0.0180656444,
0.4095935524,
0.3539380431,
0.3203995228,
0.8469333053,
-0.5212038159,
-0.2199032456,
-0.1855090559,
0.5743022561,
-0.2093209028,
0.324426502,
0.6388611197,
-0.5615543723,
-0.6226965189,
0.0714955255,
-0.7572857738,
-0.3036341667,
-0.242870599,
-0.3195251524,
0.4899513721,
0.5212026834,
-0.693256855,
0.3300781548,
-0.0902295038,
-0.2547858357,
0.3891300261,
0.0453386493,
-0.2466863692,
-1.3720318079,
-0.0512012541,
-0.0088984529,
-0.2675948739,
-0.4237301052,
-0.4226946533,
-0.0006902607,
0.116071932,
-0.4819225073,
0.5269753933,
-0.4791841209,
0.0455411412,
-0.2189214677,
-0.1121563986,
-0.0933271199,
0.8712580204,
0.3668014407,
0.4173440635,
0.1942956895,
-0.4430279136,
0.3100345433,
0.4138027132,
0.1005283296,
0.6220211387,
-0.5820768476,
0.1826717257,
-0.1641262919,
0.4341198206,
-1.1794428825,
-0.1456445456,
0.3852285147,
-0.3213815987,
0.5135375261,
-0.3104142249,
-0.4686751366,
-0.0786808953,
-0.0647299215,
0.2206019312,
0.4524861574,
-0.7470761538,
0.6270648241,
0.3539676964,
-0.5958606005,
-0.3235696256,
-0.356862396,
-0.2991044819,
-0.036657542,
-0.4734167457,
0.5549003482,
0.3138085306,
0.0299997572,
0.0275629386,
0.0201603528,
-0.2061417103,
-0.2127374858,
0.6646713018,
0.3555606902,
0.0179325882,
0.2282608151,
0.6858444214,
-0.0335867517,
0.5739181638,
0.0550768003,
0.269675523,
0.3555779457,
-0.2484673262,
-0.3243775964,
0.5626368523,
0.3075956106,
-0.1021857858,
0.5781570673,
0.3512676656,
-0.4386329353,
-0.1900661588,
-0.5840767622,
-0.1610331684,
-0.3813047111,
0.1539386511,
-0.4793776274,
-0.7293630242,
0.5653107166,
-0.2381369472,
0.2881725132,
0.3836426139,
0.2846293747,
0.0270589907,
0.8922572136,
0.368635565,
0.3060169518,
0.2523055673,
0.0293110423,
-0.0913236588,
-0.9863759279,
-0.369509846,
-0.1807511747,
-0.0305854641,
-0.7491980791,
0.0292100664,
0.1552347988,
-0.0560425259,
-0.2523449957,
0.1522290707,
-0.3924532831,
0.2636909187,
0.5985542536,
0.2164000869,
0.1438281685,
-0.0251292307,
-0.4400830865,
-0.4173042774,
-0.5258428454,
-0.2453214675,
1.2045311928,
0.2311789691,
0.0396058895,
0.1680972427,
0.923124671,
-0.1775944382,
0.8413000107,
-0.624791503,
0.7066933513,
0.1781433672,
-0.1885161549,
0.2554680109,
-0.5268966556,
-0.6879333258,
0.3095520139,
-0.1043221056,
-0.8424626589,
0.1235123053,
-0.0186044443,
-0.3141125739,
0.0482470617,
-0.6897590756,
0.6364183426,
-0.1423117965,
-0.7606756091,
0.1245099455,
-0.7991009951,
0.7879747152,
0.096893914,
-0.2016681433,
-0.1301392168,
0.1326611638,
0.7553690672,
-0.4271271229,
0.8614207506,
-0.323779285,
0.1289488673,
0.408865869,
0.0531440526,
0.1956922114,
0.2794709206,
0.1253587753,
0.0249968376,
-0.4092773795,
-0.051928807,
-0.6208630204,
0.5236046314,
-0.7280013561,
-0.5634099245,
-0.6940602064,
-0.5082891583,
-0.2974329293,
0.0757326111,
0.2775248289,
0.1663070917,
-0.3035199642,
-0.2112532407,
0.5055235028,
0.1376595944,
0.6466218829,
0.3238945305,
-0.082566008,
-0.6794025898,
0.7774139047,
0.198949188,
-0.0035259905,
0.2428406626,
-0.1004049927,
-0.6476153135,
-0.5810473561,
-0.4145644307,
0.3141882122,
-0.5960762501,
-0.3616048992,
-0.7263768315,
-0.440837115,
-0.5028117299,
0.0482601523,
-0.2932478189,
-0.5265899301,
-0.3847909272,
-0.3517674506,
0.2809562981,
0.6948681474,
0.142639339,
0.2989941835,
-0.5527539253,
0.3075734079,
0.4128884375,
0.1313837469,
-0.102863431,
-0.4290519357,
0.3219621181,
-0.2864125371,
-0.6850113273,
-1.1640543938,
0.414938271,
0.2083856612,
0.5008826852,
0.4868886769,
0.239743486,
0.6564615965,
-0.7322229147,
0.7571133375,
0.2493649721,
-0.7279706597,
0.6914604306,
-0.4345026612,
0.171976611,
0.4225295186,
0.7599838972,
0.0805889294,
-0.3403666019,
-0.8852223158,
-1.0422106981,
0.6914756298,
0.3843578398,
-0.1973713487,
-0.1867317855,
0.4505678415,
0.2745303214,
0.2375157624,
-1.0080448389,
-0.2274898589,
-0.0422865711,
-0.2376116514,
0.537155211,
-0.465683639,
-0.0682966784,
-0.3813978732,
0.6399199367,
-0.2478420138,
0.2744153738,
0.1168826371,
-0.0561520532,
-0.1480304003,
0.0966797397,
0.4576311707,
0.5945833921,
-0.165122658,
-0.0591378212,
0.2397332937,
-0.1632961333,
0.1284591109,
0.7568135262,
-0.2993719578,
0.3142034113,
0.2008280903,
0.9193242192,
0.161787793,
-0.3099650145,
0.4480423331,
-0.4078416526,
-0.3572521508,
-0.5256007314,
-0.1365315765,
0.2888908088,
0.0506095998,
0.2404385656,
0.0902464762,
0.3262607455,
-0.1299709678,
0.1249799132,
0.3748892248,
-0.3194230795,
-0.2938962579,
0.7304614186,
0.2503434718,
-0.0035213269,
0.5400990248,
-0.4824460149,
-0.4374600649,
0.3424901366,
0.6278455853,
1.009141922,
-0.4646938741,
0.1909308881,
0.5683162212,
0.0510032997,
0.2324304432,
0.3029430211,
-0.3897048831,
-0.3989452124,
-0.5283534527,
-0.6550389528,
-0.5411950946,
0.2659555078,
-0.7084003091,
0.4411934912,
-0.5423781276,
0.0912306085,
0.032471545,
-0.096685946,
-0.340539515,
0.0593523383,
0.2435567379,
0.4345047474,
-0.9741225839,
0.7777822018,
0.7787570357,
-0.4858203828,
-0.665278852,
-0.1143026128,
-0.135881409,
-0.0895930901,
0.8635988832,
0.5395870805,
0.1381636262,
-0.0227857828,
-0.2789988518,
-0.6099376082,
1.0160416365,
0.5116934776,
-0.486874789,
-0.1693063676,
0.1957025528,
0.5259700418,
-0.4051620066,
0.6450322866,
0.3112301528,
-0.0102103436,
0.3322277069,
-0.777184546,
0.2844365537,
-0.3945113719,
0.3183881938,
0.2418218702,
-0.4429919124,
0.8022421002,
0.0474954769,
-0.3163909614,
-0.1500356495,
1.1613224745,
0.3901211023,
0.2768767476,
0.4777855873,
0.6323690414,
0.546641171,
-0.3361720741,
0.711825788,
-0.1027967706,
-0.0815511346,
1.6571331024,
-0.4804112911,
0.8444185853,
0.379730612,
0.026490856,
0.6083472371,
0.8722677231,
0.181720674,
0.410798043,
0.0784091204,
-0.5148117542,
-0.0792578459,
-0.4598635435,
-0.2678364813,
0.3666037023,
0.6427984238,
-0.5038302541,
-0.2565514147,
-0.2426132411,
0.0471533611,
0.2363621444,
-0.1577739865,
1.1993179321,
0.1806390733,
-0.9612346292,
0.5017563105,
-0.3695940971,
0.2893453836,
-0.3469471335,
-0.3960358799,
-0.0983415172,
-0.1260381788,
-0.0688112006,
-0.5776893497,
0.3222075403,
-0.2949972749,
0.0089829974,
-0.1490647495,
0.6986051202,
-0.6024348736,
-0.3981682062,
0.302056998,
0.5031250715,
-0.2001198232,
0.1108273119,
-0.5004615188,
-0.3057911396,
-0.1409903169,
-0.3322721124,
0.3282735348,
0.5332046151,
-0.1821732819,
0.2666607201,
0.7517930865,
0.1172735915,
-0.0441119671,
0.0803443044,
0.9727688432,
-0.3289091289,
-0.6238998771,
-0.7882758975,
0.5308482051,
-0.4715913236,
-0.3785377741,
0.3798906803,
0.5124243498,
0.7649083138,
0.0488274246,
0.852540493,
0.1010526344,
0.7099433541,
-0.5009906292,
0.5976835489,
-0.0144900866,
0.1535761654,
-0.2293714732,
-0.9518588185,
-0.2725489438,
0.5780867934,
-0.3293208778,
-0.0424727574,
0.828741014,
0.3779557645,
-0.1597526371,
0.4418437779,
0.0012321302,
0.0308164619,
0.3995409608,
0.7790806293,
0.762907207,
-0.3397970796,
0.4892291725,
-0.4916127324,
-0.1776299626,
0.0566269457,
-0.8750584126,
-1.1962647438,
-0.6981117129,
-0.4281593263,
-0.2500659525,
0.1703224331,
1.0264229774,
0.6107606888,
-0.5659349561,
-0.0707444325,
-0.7714620233,
-0.0003448673,
-0.0062023462,
-0.2777862251,
0.4748095274,
-0.3992188573,
-0.7204770446,
0.0554834865,
0.0274604782,
0.1963755488,
-0.2235829085,
0.1753327847,
-0.6030353904,
-0.3089045584,
0.6564843059,
0.1724027544,
-0.6951093078,
-0.2065049261,
-0.3508081734,
0.0163090918,
0.0300675929,
0.6751696467,
-0.975571692,
0.3083634973,
0.4619708657,
0.6362195015,
0.541282773,
0.0010750081,
0.8671680093,
-1.1555895805,
0.2001945525,
0.4282501638,
0.5639913678,
0.4098961353,
-0.4328306615,
0.5084322691,
0.1759118438,
-0.5052543879,
-0.9156552553,
0.3997883201,
-0.9998159409,
-0.1403519809,
1.035148263,
-0.485845536,
-0.3484796882,
-0.2512152195,
-0.4510031641,
0.692637682,
-0.4801320136,
0.6364414692,
0.3938475549,
-0.5257837176,
-0.5160706043,
-0.3021543026,
0.7044923902,
0.4052986205,
-0.9346924424,
0.0403995961,
0.68160671,
-0.0759370178,
0.3478950262,
0.5412002802,
0.1250934452,
0.507019639,
-0.0602160804,
-0.0706670359,
-0.2739000618,
-0.3179549873,
0.0754870027,
0.3724426031,
-0.0467359051,
-0.0824509636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06477v1 | Enhancing Low Resource NER Using Assisting Language And Transfer Learning | 2023-06-10T16:31:04 | 2023-06-10T16:31:04 | Maithili Sabane, Aparna Ranade, Onkar Litake, Parth Patil, Raviraj Joshi, Dipali Kadam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a fundamental task in NLP that is used to
locate the key information in text and is primarily applied in conversational
and search systems. In commercial applications, NER or comparable slot-filling
methods have been widely deployed for popular languages. NER is used in
applications such as human resources, customer service, search engines, content
classification, and academia. In this paper, we draw focus on identifying name
entities for low-resource Indian languages that are closely related, like Hindi
and Marathi. We use various adaptations of BERT such as baseBERT, AlBERT, and
RoBERTa to train a supervised NER model. We also compare multilingual models
with monolingual models and establish a baseline. In this work, we show the
assisting capabilities of the Hindi and Marathi languages for the NER task. We
show that models trained using multiple languages perform better than a single
language. However, we also observe that blind mixing of all datasets doesn't
necessarily provide improvements and data selection methods may be required. | [
-0.4707256258,
-0.5507718325,
0.271224916,
0.2399310619,
-0.0616163947,
0.1420943737,
-0.4806582332,
-0.8427544236,
0.3068497777,
0.3794592023,
-0.2755101323,
0.0543326326,
-0.6960200667,
0.4514935911,
-0.3283745944,
0.9911750555,
-0.0202977248,
0.1731832027,
0.1019513905,
-0.3723892272,
-0.7601541281,
-0.3288905621,
-1.2232949734,
-0.2109378725,
0.4184447825,
0.4058328569,
0.4100035131,
0.1596874148,
0.6605979204,
0.3678898811,
-0.0373595394,
0.2907236516,
-0.2202110589,
0.1336786151,
-0.3696586192,
-0.1924427003,
-0.276625067,
-0.4905613065,
0.7725245953,
0.7672910094,
-0.1228782833,
0.1097629964,
0.2888477147,
0.639247179,
-0.8048506975,
0.3844586313,
-0.7355133891,
-0.0796162635,
-0.3663126528,
0.2576656342,
-0.3970273137,
-0.4758913815,
0.240503788,
-0.5995150805,
0.1749264002,
-0.0704022348,
0.9345384836,
0.3331411481,
0.0024626609,
-0.3970343471,
-0.892850101,
0.9710903764,
-0.5446765423,
0.575963676,
0.5237776041,
0.4028103352,
0.0865204558,
-0.0774495378,
-0.7672428489,
-0.0817703977,
-0.3703053892,
-0.1909093112,
-0.1604101509,
-0.1198044196,
0.2378949672,
0.1493666023,
-0.1404400319,
0.1397592425,
-0.5577950478,
-0.2993983328,
0.3853507936,
-0.0831193924,
0.5514503717,
-0.4603964388,
-0.3752371371,
-0.1210052222,
-0.3577436507,
-0.0921271965,
0.0588851906,
0.8474791646,
-0.1627837718,
0.5324751139,
-0.1102561504,
1.0137057304,
0.1673603505,
-0.2169653922,
0.1611145288,
-0.3663954735,
-0.3403257728,
0.4417405128,
0.5067833662,
-0.1678421646,
0.2846615911,
-0.1656947434,
-0.1610884219,
-0.0822842196,
-0.018179832,
-0.5025647283,
-0.1544293463,
-0.5709976554,
-0.274500221,
0.1593614817,
-0.3011878431,
-0.8627226353,
-0.5761638284,
-0.4177846014,
0.3859124482,
-0.7875136137,
-0.4606293738,
-0.3546702862,
-0.0184727143,
0.8216204047,
0.4352722764,
-1.0116407871,
0.4465559125,
0.437987864,
0.7010865808,
-0.3004713953,
-0.1594326794,
-0.6000557542,
0.2160296589,
-0.0535826571,
0.8032191992,
-0.8096439838,
-0.4932122231,
-0.239272356,
0.0436163209,
-0.2832983732,
-0.5410161018,
0.4035409689,
-0.5383789539,
-0.0259281266,
-0.2483072728,
-0.2125823498,
-0.3679679632,
0.157723099,
-0.8149676919,
1.0221722126,
0.1895112246,
-0.7419475913,
0.4897949398,
-0.6587874889,
-0.5863029957,
0.2873889506,
-0.212585181,
-0.0906486884,
0.1286605448,
0.4306641519,
0.2856065631,
-0.2997833788,
-0.1899148077,
0.0017922504,
-0.1575856358,
-0.0008737697,
-0.2563708425,
0.6000158191,
0.1266403645,
0.0254255719,
-0.223182708,
-0.9428297281,
0.1210017651,
-0.0626230463,
-0.2599854767,
-0.9269037843,
-0.3199412823,
0.3309240043,
-0.0248181112,
0.1265561283,
-0.4115198553,
0.0378784686,
-0.4229134917,
0.1000147611,
0.5714994669,
0.0914502665,
0.7160083652,
-0.0169953201,
0.5753133297,
-0.0660941005,
-0.1243154481,
0.3225494921,
-0.4455413818,
-1.0656578541,
-0.2341069132,
0.8689930439,
0.6592156291,
-1.1224784851,
-0.1901219487,
-0.332428664,
-0.3672242761,
-0.9598580599,
0.329820931,
0.3777002692,
0.6987960935,
0.4976966381,
-0.416959703,
-0.7165698409,
-1.0669085979,
-0.1639021039,
0.029705625,
0.2467363924,
0.4998579323,
0.088281244,
-0.1579509377,
0.8305510879,
-0.1569769233,
-0.5977538228,
-0.4822116792,
-0.0049454584,
0.2345845103,
0.5050623417,
0.3814256489,
-0.9370624423,
-0.9393818974,
0.1318273842,
-0.5710489154,
0.1436760128,
-0.1061988175,
-0.1115933135,
0.408957541,
0.2476011366,
-0.3219811618,
0.3185742497,
0.4865403473,
0.1400776356,
0.1383333951,
-0.2757116556,
0.0623195842,
-1.2538350821,
-0.0028980209,
0.1695644855,
-0.0927530378,
-0.6256757975,
-0.2269167751,
0.0144000268,
-0.3615634739,
-0.467895776,
0.9168268442,
-0.9463753104,
-0.0204702523,
-0.4088968635,
0.2534493804,
-0.5250101089,
0.311444819,
0.3584295809,
1.07272017,
0.8091987371,
-0.8107767105,
0.0921365693,
0.4447946548,
-0.2562891245,
0.8451061845,
-0.4948245585,
0.0597166456,
-0.1800707281,
-0.4052921236,
-0.4458062053,
-0.2663182914,
0.2605138421,
-0.4078034759,
0.6815933585,
-0.4797350168,
-0.3425245583,
0.1520879865,
0.2091447115,
0.4145930409,
0.5507622361,
-0.5352419019,
0.8052645326,
0.5408573151,
-0.3502308726,
-0.6994072199,
-0.9432407618,
0.0597021841,
-0.1815749854,
-0.2133014947,
0.3036866784,
0.3225218058,
-0.1706001014,
0.2722289264,
-0.1288092881,
-0.6059357524,
-0.1610836685,
0.283801645,
0.4762436152,
-0.2218871564,
0.2454549372,
-0.1254716963,
-0.2735733092,
-0.4190139771,
0.1637008637,
0.2786680758,
-0.1517267674,
-0.3138800263,
-0.5456995368,
0.2837212086,
0.2221180052,
-0.3632296622,
0.8853655457,
0.7058432698,
-0.6454849243,
-0.0409468114,
-0.6083641648,
-0.0134351319,
-0.4008800089,
0.1692782193,
-0.4099253416,
-0.5291492939,
0.3321505785,
-0.0176644716,
-0.4386222064,
0.4339031279,
0.3290091753,
0.3917821944,
0.5731986761,
1.2455806732,
-0.4382169247,
0.7229585648,
-0.1356921792,
0.5693452358,
-1.1652017832,
-0.076413542,
-0.5980188847,
-0.2115539014,
-0.9776744246,
-0.4545813501,
0.0821072981,
0.1570902318,
0.3200078011,
0.7840934992,
-0.7481591105,
0.6147685051,
0.3727903962,
-0.0410648584,
0.198420167,
0.1480582952,
-0.0048093596,
-0.1983471662,
-0.5277178288,
-0.3553846478,
0.7304096222,
-0.1394018382,
0.9526452422,
0.2773606479,
0.9198766351,
0.234943524,
0.3803936243,
-0.6786111593,
0.5668272376,
-0.2349243909,
-0.5541120172,
-0.4212979972,
-0.3199357688,
-0.9951017499,
0.1336065382,
-0.5360718966,
-0.8196166158,
0.5809280872,
-0.0941985473,
-0.3948280811,
0.1331354678,
-0.9512938261,
0.4206412435,
-0.3210903108,
-0.3067629039,
-0.1729407459,
-0.2847042978,
0.2254274935,
-0.2292568088,
0.199694261,
-0.0214791819,
0.0216547269,
0.6946661472,
-0.2027629465,
0.56772089,
-0.2409229279,
0.2300959677,
0.0145108486,
-0.1229274496,
0.4088638127,
0.1452795863,
-0.3861606717,
0.1031932682,
-0.2931857109,
-0.4429881871,
-0.3632672727,
1.039806366,
-0.6703881025,
-0.4367485642,
-0.4739412963,
-0.3630990684,
-0.2968551219,
0.4909932017,
-0.1006210074,
0.0921170264,
0.0201524403,
0.1075007841,
0.6843942404,
-0.1731338203,
0.6456776261,
0.4482096732,
0.0335421078,
-0.1684979349,
0.873626411,
0.1366873533,
-0.0018864613,
0.3418017328,
-0.2460405678,
-0.2369483858,
-0.4116720259,
-0.5864155889,
0.3449263573,
-0.6231563091,
-0.3263426721,
-0.6900734901,
-0.4790870845,
-0.216096282,
-0.0629361272,
-0.2502906322,
-0.424823314,
-0.2290727049,
0.2175321877,
0.5823648572,
0.5315808654,
-0.0820176899,
0.1550035924,
-0.8350551724,
0.3132281303,
0.3203292787,
0.4424362481,
0.2107765675,
-0.2807257175,
-0.1281476915,
-0.1331014484,
0.0831452161,
-1.0821272135,
0.2931840122,
0.5154611468,
0.7663000226,
0.0286571085,
-0.0498949736,
0.9865947962,
-0.4350135624,
0.4611391425,
0.2078258246,
-0.9578493834,
0.6743149757,
0.2389979661,
-0.0948138908,
0.8632248044,
0.5585063696,
-0.4234381318,
0.0115020145,
-0.4238165021,
-0.9103205204,
0.9095721841,
0.2686055005,
0.214128688,
0.0344245248,
0.288733691,
0.1540255994,
-0.1391623914,
-0.7003905177,
-0.1599150151,
0.1872630268,
-0.0202011075,
0.0824548528,
-0.0354666524,
0.3195446134,
-0.1487438828,
0.9143680334,
0.1269957721,
0.1114634797,
0.3305517733,
-0.4669641256,
0.0847379789,
0.5890551209,
0.2512364984,
0.335554868,
0.1025454029,
-0.1255416125,
0.747734189,
-0.3398138583,
-0.0001589191,
0.366373986,
-0.1996325999,
0.3013548255,
0.046101775,
0.8264275789,
0.255507499,
-0.4311457574,
0.1282733083,
-0.2163099349,
0.430824548,
-0.4530782402,
0.2454513013,
-0.0241766796,
0.2476795614,
0.2957954705,
0.2104996294,
0.1398830563,
-0.4403498173,
-0.1399158388,
0.5010242462,
-0.5106384158,
-0.0984928012,
0.3511036336,
0.1705982834,
-0.6573649645,
0.9215932488,
-0.3356814682,
-0.3086000085,
0.3760112524,
0.4689157605,
0.7352287769,
-0.3092252612,
-0.0521490611,
0.5753284693,
0.3553608358,
-0.0172024332,
0.1825450808,
-0.3286981583,
-0.574262023,
-0.5300815105,
-0.797922492,
-0.4769213796,
0.0932704806,
-0.7917329073,
0.6518572569,
-0.2955764532,
-0.3241221309,
0.360088259,
-0.0384741984,
-1.0395348072,
-0.071388334,
0.3567622304,
0.7425375581,
-0.795658648,
1.0728763342,
1.055583477,
-0.7905479074,
-0.9909229279,
-0.0013271135,
-0.3074787855,
-0.7228972912,
1.0789078474,
-0.0530232377,
-0.1526713222,
0.0432560816,
0.0194748677,
-1.2141650915,
0.7938352227,
0.1884586513,
-0.4691182971,
-0.2094668895,
-0.0390089601,
0.6726421714,
-0.2106807977,
0.2565611303,
0.1180663407,
0.5930668116,
-0.1243506074,
-1.2057687044,
-0.0071493373,
-0.1017126516,
0.3857017159,
0.5317826271,
-0.4080940485,
0.6291694045,
-0.255477041,
-0.4630087018,
0.0714695081,
0.6461893916,
0.1175066084,
0.127955988,
0.5268998742,
0.4376026094,
0.7627000809,
-0.0183861107,
0.9325516224,
-0.3192856908,
0.2277737111,
1.209705472,
-0.5598035455,
0.9510966539,
0.6846353412,
-0.1158901453,
0.5439324379,
0.2852281332,
-0.2494781017,
0.6336514354,
0.1087612808,
-0.0879602581,
-0.1090442389,
-0.3976175189,
-0.4019835591,
0.5721887946,
0.4180194139,
-0.1104876548,
-0.5563582182,
0.2290009707,
-0.1452584416,
0.0303515438,
-0.2828027606,
0.9898117185,
0.063558735,
-0.4902118444,
0.6106593609,
-0.0631684139,
0.8892199397,
-0.5093689561,
-0.3118339181,
-0.1536558867,
0.2484015673,
-0.2629881501,
-0.4083637595,
0.6191680431,
0.2552138865,
-0.3558520079,
-0.0642950013,
1.0417114496,
-0.4377298057,
-0.6358104348,
0.4468858838,
0.6959866285,
0.2066608816,
0.3445025682,
-0.6399254203,
-0.2197970897,
-0.1983026713,
0.369404465,
0.490560174,
0.330260396,
-0.252377212,
0.5312263966,
0.5552248359,
0.4574795663,
0.1709989309,
-0.0766217485,
0.464761138,
-0.6393420696,
-0.1989555061,
-0.6861749887,
0.0314595215,
-0.2089790106,
-0.0531401187,
0.8191688061,
0.4232194126,
1.0130029917,
-0.1742984205,
0.7103193998,
-0.3596987724,
0.6303890944,
-0.4157324433,
0.8024067283,
-0.503223896,
0.1751946956,
-0.1783267558,
-1.0259389877,
-0.079661414,
0.7034881711,
-0.3384624422,
0.031433478,
0.33095783,
0.7089457512,
-0.2630438507,
-0.2928494215,
0.1868810207,
-0.0999809355,
-0.1434926838,
0.589333415,
0.6909821033,
-0.4750947058,
0.599999249,
-0.3108372688,
-0.0935634375,
-0.220469743,
-0.7740821242,
-0.6743542552,
-0.5705721974,
-0.4414431155,
-0.1152658984,
0.1529221684,
0.8939518929,
0.8925082684,
-1.0235803127,
-0.021698473,
0.0473909304,
0.3553090096,
-0.1721474528,
-0.226760447,
0.3885655999,
-0.367313832,
-0.9613104463,
0.4616653919,
0.1387968957,
0.0660292506,
0.0120314239,
0.0772296712,
-0.4638483822,
-0.0157949757,
0.4320275187,
0.5669669509,
-0.7142881155,
-0.1347599179,
-0.1005640253,
-0.0764624998,
-0.0187916923,
0.5704735518,
-0.910310328,
0.4741679132,
0.4316942394,
1.02534163,
0.2244020402,
-0.2107482702,
0.2191360444,
-0.8025777936,
0.1840510964,
0.1586954892,
0.4381399155,
0.8662624955,
-0.4786530137,
0.604503572,
-0.1258368343,
-0.301007241,
-0.7445219755,
-0.0442507975,
-1.0103372335,
0.1229809001,
1.0137331486,
0.2053381801,
-0.2558778226,
-0.1740911305,
-0.1126032993,
0.461281091,
-0.4784893394,
0.644130528,
0.7467748523,
-0.3092331886,
-0.3127186894,
-0.6772801876,
0.5148409605,
0.3423301876,
-0.7275031209,
-0.2224780172,
0.2214108706,
0.3839353919,
0.5113730431,
0.7151929736,
-0.0511073582,
0.0840075538,
-0.2800650001,
0.2205775827,
0.1543923467,
-0.045603063,
-0.5904072523,
-0.1784843951,
0.285356462,
-0.277659297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06476v1 | Modality Influence in Multimodal Machine Learning | 2023-06-10T16:28:52 | 2023-06-10T16:28:52 | Abdelhamid Haouhat, Slimane Bellaouar, Attia Nehar, Hadda Cherroun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multimodal Machine Learning has emerged as a prominent research direction
across various applications such as Sentiment Analysis, Emotion Recognition,
Machine Translation, Hate Speech Recognition, and Movie Genre Classification.
This approach has shown promising results by utilizing modern deep learning
architectures. Despite the achievements made, challenges remain in data
representation, alignment techniques, reasoning, generation, and quantification
within multimodal learning. Additionally, assumptions about the dominant role
of textual modality in decision-making have been made. However, limited
investigations have been conducted on the influence of different modalities in
Multimodal Machine Learning systems. This paper aims to address this gap by
studying the impact of each modality on multimodal learning tasks. The research
focuses on verifying presumptions and gaining insights into the usage of
different modalities. The main contribution of this work is the proposal of a
methodology to determine the effect of each modality on several Multimodal
Machine Learning models and datasets from various tasks. Specifically, the
study examines Multimodal Sentiment Analysis, Multimodal Emotion Recognition,
Multimodal Hate Speech Recognition, and Multimodal Disease Detection. The study
objectives include training SOTA MultiModal Machine Learning models with masked
modalities to evaluate their impact on performance. Furthermore, the research
aims to identify the most influential modality or set of modalities for each
task and draw conclusions for diverse multimodal classification tasks. By
undertaking these investigations, this research contributes to a better
understanding of the role of individual modalities in multi-modal learning and
provides valuable insights for future advancements in this field. | [
-0.4034844041,
-0.8670194149,
0.2724900544,
0.2035033256,
-0.1346013546,
-0.2364753187,
-0.2639343739,
-0.3913169503,
0.0429554768,
0.2270800024,
-0.5980495811,
-0.2337602973,
-0.6697486639,
0.3056690395,
0.4994875491,
0.9923325777,
-0.0649029687,
0.7339548469,
-0.2527840137,
-0.3701507151,
-0.7877088785,
-0.6423088312,
-0.1494416147,
-0.2423094511,
0.7166754603,
0.1423206329,
0.5651776195,
0.1820860207,
0.388024658,
0.4286166131,
0.2893098891,
0.3550243974,
-0.2143838406,
0.4250990748,
0.0159877148,
-0.5363673568,
-0.2560223639,
0.1687930822,
0.6479138732,
0.3310028315,
0.2943320572,
0.0868372247,
-0.0504410639,
0.2061744481,
-0.7827059627,
0.4904157519,
-0.3726564348,
0.2909012437,
-0.3237483501,
-0.3883763552,
-0.5634335279,
0.2447316498,
0.0513920076,
-0.4384911358,
-0.0827317312,
-0.0630501434,
0.4513409138,
0.5068588853,
-1.0302529335,
-0.4025837779,
-0.5749627948,
1.0308830738,
-0.3176754117,
0.7351911068,
0.6277742386,
0.2183039933,
0.1277911514,
-0.3611572683,
-0.6177443266,
-0.3339783549,
-0.2377751023,
0.1727731526,
0.0817703083,
0.2881627381,
0.3454472423,
0.0685332641,
-0.3704259098,
0.0141962627,
-0.2697563171,
-0.3046019375,
0.3379777968,
0.21702829,
0.1506107748,
-0.864479661,
-0.4968053401,
-0.2051279545,
-0.1390754133,
0.3147673905,
0.1131945997,
0.2020510286,
-0.0496884584,
0.4636437893,
-0.1488495618,
0.5555545092,
-0.1189258918,
-0.6240128875,
0.5593845248,
-0.6100414991,
-0.5184106827,
-0.2061056644,
0.6852665544,
0.2780574262,
-0.4193719327,
0.0849947929,
-0.2347146273,
0.0011616652,
0.3133938909,
-0.790984571,
0.2393590063,
-0.2338320613,
-0.8218216896,
-0.2518886924,
0.032034561,
-0.5833289623,
-0.4980247915,
-0.7837725282,
0.9097431302,
-0.5469702482,
-0.3878422081,
-0.2075106353,
0.1796220988,
-0.0320328847,
0.4903214872,
-0.5694155097,
-0.1678892374,
0.3762888014,
0.6161897779,
-0.0110909548,
-0.1478467286,
-0.3872809708,
0.0509040207,
0.0657804161,
0.3241460323,
-0.8979068398,
-0.2908800244,
-0.2970002294,
0.2439528406,
-0.6236792207,
-0.2238158733,
0.5112088919,
-0.5596144199,
0.6673074961,
-0.283924669,
-0.3169883788,
-1.0009424686,
0.2857862413,
-0.8067114353,
0.7062702179,
-0.1025273576,
-0.7236818075,
0.606333077,
-0.7525147796,
-0.5885742903,
-0.2616773546,
-0.4471551776,
-0.7889913917,
0.2095504403,
-0.0233265627,
0.8618943095,
-0.2590883374,
0.3105077147,
-0.3103395104,
0.0644095317,
0.7282769084,
-0.7572999597,
0.6490018368,
0.4980508685,
-0.5066815615,
0.3132123053,
-0.7154434323,
-0.0756687,
-0.4136922657,
-0.266613394,
-0.4972005785,
0.0287538078,
0.5233622789,
0.5014334321,
-0.2308100164,
-0.3023809195,
0.0181280635,
0.3549013138,
0.3991048038,
0.8642681241,
0.0521599017,
0.2130196691,
-0.3472267091,
0.7860445976,
0.3210275769,
0.2182804197,
-0.4091361165,
-0.3336441815,
-0.398509711,
-0.9090746641,
0.5195452571,
0.3108745217,
-0.9859153628,
-0.0017203457,
0.147333473,
-0.2731169164,
-0.5046905875,
0.0193604995,
0.4861511886,
0.3784886897,
0.2871899605,
-0.3454249799,
-0.7933011055,
-0.8012602925,
0.0796672553,
0.0127855539,
0.3071587086,
0.6030325294,
0.523558259,
-0.5797137022,
0.8105997443,
-0.0136867287,
-0.3460524976,
-0.067234762,
0.4100755751,
-0.2075418532,
0.5416643023,
0.6096284389,
-1.2839628458,
-0.2611428499,
-0.1107243374,
-0.7517161965,
0.0930897146,
-0.3995163143,
0.2241622806,
0.4414783418,
0.3419100344,
-0.3261782527,
0.1932667196,
0.5654946566,
-0.3454121649,
0.4329012632,
0.1236647666,
0.6562069058,
-1.1492339373,
0.073191382,
0.0694606826,
-0.0700061098,
-0.627458632,
-0.1306105554,
0.114439778,
0.0364045575,
-0.3556353152,
0.1551583409,
-0.2616147995,
0.1190049574,
0.0937625617,
-0.5205824971,
-0.0329114497,
0.517591238,
0.0795580298,
0.7023321986,
0.6627076864,
-0.5076105595,
0.0157718696,
-0.1216907203,
-0.1648848951,
0.6417181492,
-0.2872844338,
-0.101267308,
-0.3463645875,
0.225824967,
-1.0934393406,
-0.2813224196,
0.3489448428,
-0.4020246267,
0.4633900821,
-0.0045976751,
-0.4486649632,
0.3308072388,
-0.2817821801,
0.5558996797,
0.0211440064,
-0.0337765999,
1.0272608995,
0.2644542456,
0.1497656107,
-0.5718160272,
-0.4450782835,
-0.1778299063,
-0.4388737082,
-0.5409591794,
0.1525328755,
-0.1400556862,
-0.1247817725,
-0.2874764502,
0.0349373482,
-0.1064524427,
0.2748962641,
0.7233324647,
0.3011178374,
-0.2061130106,
0.435864538,
0.0749088153,
-0.1390960813,
-0.0552010015,
0.1281874478,
0.4913769364,
-0.1750909686,
-0.3961905241,
-0.5652310848,
0.3105632663,
0.8125839233,
-0.4872111082,
0.7199901938,
1.2018450499,
-0.151131168,
0.167888537,
-0.601977706,
-0.2308329642,
-0.4337872565,
0.6515669823,
-0.6278768778,
-0.7992913127,
0.2117775977,
0.0145641211,
-0.5318317413,
0.2252483815,
0.9551376104,
-0.0977464914,
1.3118370771,
0.4972449839,
-0.0151295234,
0.8724935651,
-0.3618504107,
-0.2138724923,
-0.6341135502,
-0.5909796357,
-0.2130174041,
-0.6003436446,
-0.7497338653,
-0.7413330078,
0.7269309759,
-0.2003933787,
0.1256746352,
-0.0726056695,
-0.009674185,
0.0631993115,
0.3440407217,
0.4249711335,
0.2331491858,
0.0521224402,
-0.1704153121,
-0.18587026,
-0.4508299828,
-0.2440645844,
1.1582999229,
0.4996039867,
0.7210078239,
0.3198809922,
0.2797677219,
0.4844998717,
0.1667111069,
-0.9122645855,
0.310305506,
0.0857736766,
-0.702183187,
-0.0263940152,
-0.537668407,
-0.9113981724,
0.5082566738,
-0.4510610402,
-0.0740567446,
0.2757484019,
-0.1248330697,
-0.0988530889,
-0.0057411524,
-0.749191165,
0.9940395355,
-0.3317446411,
-0.4204075336,
-0.5669147968,
-0.7859049439,
0.294344902,
-0.0376767553,
0.3714818656,
0.1260624975,
-0.154843837,
0.7235733867,
0.225467369,
1.2281507254,
-0.2839583755,
-0.0070465193,
-0.1025367528,
0.1457047462,
0.0355121009,
0.2602550983,
-0.0620579235,
0.2770131826,
0.0577261262,
-0.1718460172,
-0.4092297554,
0.4527882338,
-1.0270613432,
-0.2768319547,
-0.4156962633,
-0.8726429939,
-0.3223773241,
0.2037507445,
0.0151359579,
0.743966639,
0.0821564868,
0.5491380095,
0.8012793064,
0.0807003751,
0.5359601974,
0.6158860326,
-0.0499746948,
-0.5765798092,
1.0744390488,
0.3440303504,
0.3743668497,
0.4942064583,
0.2325239778,
-0.1853280067,
-0.36116153,
-0.561747849,
0.0151035748,
-0.6437783837,
-0.1944494098,
-0.7952820063,
0.1969412565,
-0.3355645835,
0.1404906958,
0.046480801,
-0.3285016119,
-0.4494839013,
0.2041369677,
0.1902526468,
0.4285199642,
-0.0774330273,
0.0745804459,
-0.6152284145,
0.1899058819,
0.5108838081,
0.162656635,
-0.1648191363,
-0.2221065313,
-0.2905163765,
0.0355979167,
-0.6121683121,
-0.9431066513,
0.053019233,
0.4269250333,
0.6752359867,
0.740308702,
-0.12289121,
0.4114552736,
-0.1403178424,
0.6118287444,
0.3954664767,
-0.7936659455,
0.3520882726,
-0.3472244442,
-0.0226459019,
0.4875356853,
0.7327624559,
-0.5165703893,
0.0900297612,
-0.3005152941,
-0.1133829877,
0.813994348,
0.0761793777,
0.1111240089,
0.2395490259,
-0.1739978939,
0.5373185873,
0.4735596478,
-0.7726086378,
-0.1902143955,
-0.5037781,
-0.2033248991,
-0.1606398225,
-0.1033636928,
-0.0235601738,
-0.3179900944,
0.3202647865,
-0.2493067831,
0.1877443045,
-0.0098074256,
-0.5115767121,
0.0072641456,
0.3728930056,
0.8389714956,
0.4829069078,
-0.0079733981,
0.3847655356,
0.0332904011,
-0.406237781,
0.1363116801,
-0.0359271243,
-0.2441752106,
0.0861873031,
0.4483134151,
1.0676271915,
0.1606645882,
-0.7548881173,
0.4453026354,
0.1326053888,
-0.0475520231,
0.1044368595,
-0.0525610819,
-0.4455397129,
0.5164231658,
0.1650612056,
0.5934444666,
0.3509859741,
-0.8055545092,
0.1072143763,
0.6250576377,
-0.6892746091,
-0.5321695805,
0.3889338672,
0.0155749153,
-0.0480198339,
0.2144779861,
-0.0042791213,
-0.7580530643,
0.317186743,
0.4575770199,
0.7918064594,
-0.5460959673,
0.3027306497,
0.0025165121,
0.2353011519,
0.3318604529,
0.328376621,
-0.4259442389,
-0.5612248778,
-0.4906552732,
-0.4359700084,
-0.2209147811,
-0.0005570434,
-0.5003064275,
0.4126680493,
-0.2168841958,
-0.4932639599,
-0.0572289824,
-0.0232001748,
-0.7172323465,
0.2970583439,
0.3695173264,
0.0830491483,
-0.9989939332,
0.7288876176,
0.9726186395,
-0.6209739447,
-0.5138943791,
-0.0770780966,
0.199747324,
-0.6753435731,
1.1349360943,
0.3136476576,
-0.2280817628,
-0.2418432981,
-0.0817421004,
-0.6687090397,
0.9021416306,
0.0846445635,
0.0329519957,
0.1823821664,
0.2490639836,
0.3356874287,
-0.3856370449,
0.5568769574,
0.0523704402,
0.7089821696,
0.0187999327,
-1.143419981,
-0.0081833368,
-0.3451879025,
0.0118808411,
0.1179024652,
-0.617177546,
1.0847740173,
0.1462295651,
0.0144916894,
-0.4530847967,
0.4727262855,
0.0162429661,
0.5599246025,
0.6838408113,
0.2711748481,
0.4421952665,
0.1831533015,
0.6520007849,
-0.0161470976,
0.2880110145,
0.5573987365,
0.0025276898,
0.5156801343,
0.5121046901,
-0.0869582519,
0.4900392294,
0.6440393329,
-0.0812448934,
0.5825508237,
0.0055112522,
-0.201696068,
-0.4494783878,
-0.3769298196,
-0.4925785363,
0.9238458872,
0.3433839381,
-0.5661731362,
-0.0289217439,
0.92850703,
0.1863497794,
-0.2390789688,
-0.2628289163,
0.677863121,
-0.4113197625,
-0.4192693233,
0.4792819917,
0.1168558672,
0.8613996506,
-0.6863349676,
-0.0457006544,
0.2004380673,
0.1466858536,
-0.3938582242,
-0.0363217704,
-0.0397851318,
-0.4116098583,
-0.5821537971,
-0.4277733266,
0.5523406267,
-0.3105458915,
-0.5290104151,
-0.0340284668,
0.5254519582,
-0.2227426916,
0.014184339,
-0.724224627,
0.4368702173,
-0.0400810875,
-0.3078817129,
0.606685102,
0.5751764178,
-0.0939857885,
0.3862886429,
0.5250785947,
-0.2974725366,
0.0492118523,
-0.0698734894,
0.8389387131,
-0.4023886621,
-0.4249063432,
-0.8127289414,
0.4928560853,
0.1768630892,
-0.3230156004,
1.0408176184,
0.5018145442,
0.7610493302,
-0.2143770456,
0.6370562911,
-0.4315391481,
0.1498458087,
-0.7317717671,
0.5254101157,
-0.7884510756,
0.0979196653,
-0.4716693759,
-0.5875740051,
-0.2052944154,
0.6886747479,
-0.4321622252,
0.3323178291,
0.7161587477,
0.9255472422,
-0.0096544567,
0.328812629,
0.3228300512,
0.0657976642,
0.2810052335,
0.1922467351,
1.0509599447,
-0.2954454124,
0.2197340131,
-0.4614646435,
-0.3607433438,
-0.5151283741,
-0.785053134,
-0.8955802321,
-1.0525571108,
-0.2765070498,
-0.0994623527,
-0.3895367682,
1.1830660105,
0.9202333093,
-0.6975157261,
-0.1905640662,
0.4818808138,
0.1530914307,
-0.4573961794,
-0.2484542876,
0.3013832569,
-0.5084440708,
-0.717628479,
0.3653856516,
0.1171249673,
-0.2748266459,
-0.5675390959,
-0.1456463188,
-0.2444825172,
-0.2212397605,
0.9994890094,
-0.2045314163,
-0.8654310703,
-0.1607122272,
0.245042339,
-0.110536322,
-0.0973881558,
1.2859607935,
-0.8621327877,
0.8447961807,
0.5317997336,
0.5787478089,
0.3094246089,
-0.3792089224,
0.1978453845,
-0.6848391891,
0.0893140733,
0.2715323269,
0.2079783976,
-0.0506451875,
-0.2511715889,
0.335383147,
0.5592191815,
-0.4662022889,
-0.8250720501,
0.2026832253,
-1.1136686802,
-0.4471089542,
1.0400381088,
0.1646149457,
0.046046555,
-0.2665350139,
-0.5061887503,
0.2353301644,
-0.3338067234,
0.7626255751,
0.4492429197,
-0.4282912016,
-0.2197220176,
-0.6535497904,
0.3258707225,
0.6716451049,
-0.4872626662,
-0.1958171725,
0.785797596,
0.0528862439,
0.2285509706,
0.1924612373,
0.0330543704,
0.2280749828,
-0.3218375146,
-0.0201596525,
-0.4950961471,
-0.3024450541,
-0.3792422712,
0.5136712193,
-0.346131593,
-0.2712473869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06472v1 | Modeling Structural Similarities between Documents for Coherence Assessment with Graph Convolutional Networks | 2023-06-10T16:08:47 | 2023-06-10T16:08:47 | Wei Liu, Xiyan Fu, Michael Strube | cs.CL | cs.CL | Coherence is an important aspect of text quality, and various approaches have
been applied to coherence modeling. However, existing methods solely focus on a
single document's coherence patterns, ignoring the underlying correlation
between documents. We investigate a GCN-based coherence model that is capable
of capturing structural similarities between documents. Our model first creates
a graph structure for each document, from where we mine different subgraph
patterns. We then construct a heterogeneous graph for the training corpus,
connecting documents based on their shared subgraphs. Finally, a GCN is applied
to the heterogeneous graph to model the connectivity relationships. We evaluate
our method on two tasks, assessing discourse coherence and automated essay
scoring. Results show that our GCN-based model outperforms all baselines,
achieving a new state-of-the-art on both tasks. | [
-0.2430282682,
-1.0003809929,
0.6814851761,
0.032654874,
-0.3596292138,
0.1193275154,
0.037279468,
-0.801315546,
0.4455704689,
0.2216501236,
-0.2418412268,
-0.8284112215,
-0.5403084159,
-0.0264040381,
-0.7127156258,
0.7657334805,
-0.1700817347,
-0.0374589115,
-0.6599495411,
-0.2293866575,
-0.1880595386,
-0.3701726496,
-0.7930090427,
-0.5626007318,
0.5191002488,
-0.0043691392,
0.6251545548,
0.5174447894,
0.6688722372,
0.3168208003,
-0.4218728244,
0.0131235924,
-0.4781148434,
0.0973490998,
-0.1411430836,
-0.0020564436,
-0.5393243432,
0.0921883211,
0.6544707417,
1.1531261206,
0.2004747689,
-0.0378492214,
0.7951628566,
0.2291672975,
-0.4209950268,
0.3319598436,
-0.5550074577,
0.1330840886,
0.1567413509,
-0.0183053631,
-0.3282566071,
-0.4019725025,
0.3693940938,
-0.6554407477,
0.6465606093,
0.1241979748,
1.3356472254,
-0.2516959906,
-0.4181619287,
-0.4858017266,
-0.3151632845,
0.2710345685,
-0.3623591363,
0.2861659527,
0.3487954438,
0.0256387219,
-0.1197329164,
-0.8319169879,
-0.3836046159,
-0.3875918686,
-0.2594362795,
0.6147591472,
-0.0527170114,
0.2622689903,
-0.0861136019,
0.5944210887,
-0.75597018,
0.0845254511,
-0.1272142678,
-0.4512695968,
0.2252867222,
0.2853937447,
0.439191848,
-0.2724508643,
-0.4584096968,
-0.0045380848,
-0.2780217826,
0.2342934012,
0.7194082141,
0.3515712321,
-0.2824189067,
0.5352960825,
-0.0154633326,
0.6651242971,
0.0758304223,
0.0696049482,
-0.0646056235,
-0.624239862,
-0.2211352438,
0.1591483057,
0.8488021493,
0.2404757738,
-0.0050250813,
-0.2959519923,
0.2638756931,
0.2929340899,
0.2967886329,
-0.7597154379,
-0.5427078605,
0.0314197019,
-0.7326072454,
-0.2887837589,
-0.0822507739,
-0.4560362995,
-0.0040481156,
-0.5272288322,
0.3391422331,
-0.609520793,
-0.1560539901,
-0.1311008483,
-0.1993387789,
0.1259264648,
0.3420358896,
-0.9187501669,
0.6715664268,
0.9741070271,
1.3313853741,
-0.4098162055,
-0.3723343313,
-0.2629663944,
-0.0719636977,
-0.3405681252,
0.906588316,
-0.4625328183,
-0.2935234308,
0.1390908957,
0.1026460305,
-0.2785567343,
-0.2787911892,
0.5919630527,
-0.4777132273,
0.2990270555,
-0.1202231348,
-1.0820777416,
-0.2770705521,
0.7418534756,
-0.9315520525,
0.8245579004,
0.2779530585,
-1.156365037,
0.1571513712,
-0.2896848321,
-0.4191741049,
0.0503943935,
-0.2492376268,
-0.7525843978,
0.00957218,
-0.1867916435,
0.226425305,
-0.0810685009,
0.3048710823,
-0.6901213527,
-0.7134708166,
-0.1335350126,
-0.3951162696,
1.0612945557,
-0.0964478254,
0.2718659341,
-0.06513381,
-0.8004047871,
0.1306340694,
-0.3653189242,
-0.3177966774,
-0.645465672,
-0.2716441453,
0.073716782,
0.1570899338,
0.1803688109,
-0.5377948284,
-0.1282483339,
-0.5735038519,
0.3808493912,
0.2914662957,
0.3806527555,
0.2374388427,
-0.4588546455,
0.2174899876,
0.0355497785,
0.0019782307,
-0.004610043,
-0.5650318861,
-0.336335659,
-0.2738138437,
0.3533099592,
0.4418256283,
-0.2541773021,
0.5655316114,
-0.344719708,
-0.5296958089,
-0.1129062474,
-0.2216581851,
0.3270632029,
0.8429323435,
0.3900518417,
-0.8369236588,
-0.2573933303,
-0.6621672511,
-0.2904508114,
-0.4180175364,
0.0903329179,
0.2861270607,
0.6426606774,
0.0561756268,
0.7861428261,
-0.3210096061,
-0.2571334243,
0.2015182227,
0.3680775464,
0.1694136411,
0.5436781049,
0.4866248965,
-0.6376718879,
-0.7271772027,
0.1721386462,
-0.8862553239,
0.218383804,
0.092625469,
-0.0677386895,
-0.0100906407,
0.7331995368,
-0.2415455729,
0.3813463151,
0.8499674797,
-0.3179744482,
0.6476488709,
-0.3401505053,
0.2703987658,
-1.4036005735,
0.2469490916,
-0.146291256,
-0.26056391,
-0.4264374673,
-0.161852181,
-0.1826735586,
-0.4339655936,
-0.2635390162,
0.3363354206,
-0.4586551487,
-0.241809845,
-0.1979100406,
0.261675477,
0.6246745586,
0.5942416787,
-0.205628112,
0.4460361004,
0.4738422334,
-0.1519351006,
0.2207205296,
0.3965100348,
-0.4708633423,
0.939604938,
-0.9216412306,
0.1442242265,
0.0523925759,
0.2444967479,
-1.304885149,
-0.1554604918,
0.191328615,
-0.3515141606,
0.1771402657,
-0.2969744802,
-0.11967507,
-0.1162564382,
-0.2431100309,
0.4500550628,
-0.0699666739,
-0.408264339,
0.7491406798,
0.097674638,
-0.2377747744,
-0.2879690528,
-0.617082417,
0.23571603,
0.0579469539,
-0.924701035,
0.6449256539,
0.0668701008,
0.0699818209,
0.452470839,
-0.0769463629,
-0.5187484622,
0.3351728618,
0.6550302505,
0.4007846415,
-0.295953989,
0.0744080693,
0.2543004155,
0.0038510528,
-0.0044370638,
-0.5794394612,
0.3746402562,
-0.0179916881,
-0.453209877,
-0.5124012232,
0.7210088968,
0.3016113937,
-0.0858097523,
0.8528347611,
0.4177592099,
-0.5011829138,
0.1220949143,
-0.0991879702,
0.0180199631,
-0.3722718358,
0.5294779539,
-0.511811316,
-1.0569555759,
0.8319727778,
-0.187063098,
-0.4240560234,
0.5249025226,
0.4211800992,
-0.428738147,
0.643009007,
0.7297653556,
-0.0129307406,
0.6857349873,
-0.2592170835,
0.2362529039,
-0.6651512384,
-0.0957974494,
-0.7673496008,
-0.0796692967,
-0.6483270526,
-0.0925166905,
0.1977630407,
0.1989659965,
-0.2797985375,
0.4571399391,
-0.4047020674,
0.4734530747,
0.2066810131,
0.159559384,
0.4889500737,
0.3267985284,
-0.6967695355,
0.1830737442,
-0.5793689489,
-0.4476208687,
0.6283931732,
0.1423678845,
0.5022553802,
-0.2730181217,
0.6486402154,
0.2471606284,
0.399287343,
-0.6116094589,
0.3661274314,
-0.5654023886,
-0.3536778688,
-0.3117739558,
-0.540438056,
-1.0454849005,
0.1222716495,
-0.3198367655,
-0.8105402589,
0.3012506664,
0.1122321412,
-0.1313623786,
0.154751271,
-0.5897293687,
1.020471096,
0.356892854,
-0.4032758176,
-0.0807780921,
-0.5237011909,
0.1240337715,
0.1067491844,
-0.2985918224,
0.0383260697,
0.3287267685,
0.6550270319,
-0.3679620922,
0.7292241454,
0.2615678906,
-0.0735555217,
0.6168532968,
0.0561776087,
0.5475558043,
-0.1365466714,
-0.4716209769,
0.5499646664,
0.0301656574,
-0.3759169877,
-0.6246587634,
0.7910366058,
-0.837567687,
-0.1301879734,
-0.2409098148,
-0.6125094891,
-0.0060113263,
0.2701402605,
0.4607279301,
0.663846612,
-0.8596924543,
0.1031889245,
0.2547211051,
0.3031135798,
0.3528704047,
0.0894972831,
0.1012249961,
-0.5226638913,
0.804466784,
0.4261952043,
0.3616540432,
0.2900675833,
0.1569096446,
-0.2885524929,
-0.575722754,
-0.011076089,
0.0227177255,
-0.8268632293,
0.1340536922,
-0.8903279901,
-0.5384369493,
-0.4370263517,
-0.3309934139,
-0.1159208044,
-0.2457945496,
-0.1535971761,
0.0268544089,
-0.023271814,
0.4086263478,
0.2639272809,
0.1385278255,
-0.5990265608,
0.2043455839,
0.4020291865,
0.5512701869,
0.1138988584,
-0.4023411274,
-0.4577369392,
-0.0560575947,
-0.3933793902,
-0.7159008384,
0.0371289998,
0.3019344807,
0.3509583175,
0.052977629,
-0.1709684134,
0.4516819417,
-0.3960762322,
0.677264452,
0.3849430084,
-0.9651283026,
0.2735367715,
-0.343644619,
0.1687176377,
0.8934102058,
0.5267516375,
-0.5605652928,
-0.6855181456,
-0.5631878972,
-0.5987977386,
0.1314773709,
0.1816213131,
-0.0076029547,
0.0489942469,
0.5305015445,
0.0579247698,
-0.0886397064,
-0.5074033737,
0.2478227913,
-0.5389220715,
-0.5906460285,
0.1362981349,
0.1425414681,
-0.1783506423,
-0.0972571522,
0.3524443507,
-0.5636816621,
0.2751739323,
0.5305691957,
-0.093513675,
0.0646149814,
0.0675880462,
0.3096058071,
0.33897385,
-0.1983069032,
0.4608565569,
0.3227082193,
-0.996617198,
0.3182303905,
0.2864771485,
-0.398658365,
0.1107105687,
0.7510927916,
0.6100193262,
0.0326823965,
0.1903864294,
0.5996926427,
-0.4085001945,
-0.3730454445,
0.1113623977,
0.0905195251,
0.3741715848,
0.1157623455,
-0.2480360717,
0.2148173302,
0.1707939357,
-0.7029030919,
0.2089838088,
0.3202751279,
-0.9885709286,
-0.2913833261,
0.3084347546,
0.0084071448,
-0.4980622828,
0.5218148828,
-0.2219715267,
-0.3838846982,
0.7879883647,
0.6694868803,
0.9426116347,
0.1273669004,
0.2261160165,
0.5767986774,
0.0075592976,
-0.0419288911,
0.2084530294,
-0.0298520122,
-0.5994115472,
-0.339761436,
-0.5950213075,
-0.7567549944,
-0.2525224984,
-0.5235856175,
0.174347803,
-0.3383440971,
-0.0852916688,
0.1063568145,
0.4609414935,
-0.4570240378,
0.3031726182,
-0.3133222759,
0.6548680067,
-1.0267502069,
0.8332905769,
0.4307284355,
-0.5228070021,
-1.0215731859,
0.1595241874,
-0.2279856801,
-0.2731985152,
0.2275514901,
0.1983541101,
-0.1931383908,
-0.0747091249,
-0.3091338575,
-0.5665508509,
1.3251048326,
0.6027107835,
-0.5716575384,
-0.1190671101,
0.2285366356,
0.9051966667,
-0.6871491075,
0.2986877859,
-0.0561624914,
0.0857825279,
0.0401166566,
-0.4160699844,
0.0559893176,
-0.220203042,
0.0997496918,
-0.0831039995,
-0.6294462681,
1.0401268005,
0.3157589138,
-0.407751888,
0.1019487679,
0.765941143,
-0.0802763104,
0.5179504156,
0.5620109439,
0.6492814422,
1.0709363222,
0.1192654371,
0.9411172867,
-0.5183740854,
0.7342399359,
1.5450172424,
-0.5058789849,
0.6998676062,
0.1268779635,
0.2414029837,
0.7544699907,
0.4659491479,
-0.1486876309,
0.1882071048,
0.2921839654,
-0.3281230927,
-0.1279430538,
-0.4224126637,
-0.3720496893,
0.4004372358,
-0.0259143375,
-0.4279898703,
-0.4618340731,
-0.2731351256,
-0.1557750851,
0.3651147187,
-0.1455644518,
0.6716123223,
0.2504769266,
-0.7786797881,
0.2633558512,
-0.1883436739,
0.153831616,
-0.4447658658,
-0.068253845,
-0.1348867565,
0.1037117988,
-0.1103246734,
-0.8542785048,
0.7904485464,
-0.2340538353,
-0.4757369161,
0.0978981927,
1.1951128244,
-0.7125171423,
-0.5440381169,
0.8206142187,
0.4731434882,
0.0000272638,
0.1131402925,
-0.5503764153,
-0.0149516445,
-0.6626241207,
0.1299464107,
0.3448385298,
0.421289444,
-0.0958863422,
0.1052669808,
0.6530579329,
-0.1228324622,
-0.3080064654,
0.4183579385,
0.7838707566,
-0.3003097177,
-0.7230973244,
-0.7642707825,
0.0485959277,
-0.2857042253,
-0.3737454414,
0.6894052625,
0.6705825329,
0.6238492727,
0.4031735361,
0.465980351,
0.3936193287,
0.1777815968,
-0.3961435556,
1.0477508307,
-0.4399603605,
-0.2955524921,
-0.5810518861,
-1.1059346199,
-0.431204319,
0.41124928,
-0.1063147932,
-0.2097910941,
0.9439190626,
0.8169444203,
-0.4918261468,
0.4547246993,
0.3895638883,
0.1924450845,
0.4048524797,
0.5808930993,
0.7219663858,
-0.6637491584,
0.6541756392,
0.1758899838,
-0.0883267298,
-0.1281519979,
-0.9733736515,
-0.923037529,
-0.6146572232,
-0.5511523485,
-0.7817617059,
0.3256110847,
0.4411501288,
0.5525335073,
-0.6436799765,
-0.0300154705,
-0.4739409089,
0.2720916569,
-0.3858824372,
-0.1513454765,
0.7030166388,
-0.1250324845,
-0.2569407523,
0.0371888578,
0.5609822273,
0.2547241151,
-0.0955117494,
-0.0116745755,
-0.5411115885,
0.3543051779,
0.3711602986,
0.0264752954,
-0.1220464557,
-0.7267975211,
-0.0197959375,
-0.7051568031,
0.2502852678,
0.6377756596,
-0.3417948484,
0.4093012214,
0.889005661,
0.6919720173,
0.6299010515,
0.014349306,
0.1495452225,
-0.7109699845,
-0.0560966171,
0.1332180649,
0.3193216622,
0.360420078,
-0.3378124237,
0.2634756267,
0.515512228,
-0.6021572351,
-0.459564358,
0.2048596144,
-1.2619144917,
-0.1373431534,
0.5242173672,
-0.8355562687,
-0.5339801908,
-0.5300394297,
-0.1448808461,
0.5911932588,
0.1496995091,
0.7375540733,
0.8916476965,
0.1331323832,
0.3010796905,
0.0621510297,
0.0314262994,
0.4013577104,
-0.9683287144,
-0.2948854268,
0.2323226482,
0.3352463543,
0.4689514339,
0.7222322822,
-0.0650974661,
0.2928925753,
0.4562182128,
-0.1592504233,
-0.0152690634,
-0.4462415278,
-0.3948892057,
0.8319709897,
-0.3196950853,
-0.0135181528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06466v1 | ORGAN: Observation-Guided Radiology Report Generation via Tree Reasoning | 2023-06-10T15:36:04 | 2023-06-10T15:36:04 | Wenjun Hou, Kaishuai Xu, Yi Cheng, Wenjie Li, Jiang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores the task of radiology report generation, which aims at
generating free-text descriptions for a set of radiographs. One significant
challenge of this task is how to correctly maintain the consistency between the
images and the lengthy report. Previous research explored solving this issue
through planning-based methods, which generate reports only based on high-level
plans. However, these plans usually only contain the major observations from
the radiographs (e.g., lung opacity), lacking much necessary information, such
as the observation characteristics and preliminary clinical diagnoses. To
address this problem, the system should also take the image information into
account together with the textual plan and perform stronger reasoning during
the generation process. In this paper, we propose an observation-guided
radiology report generation framework (ORGAN). It first produces an observation
plan and then feeds both the plan and radiographs for report generation, where
an observation graph and a tree reasoning mechanism are adopted to precisely
enrich the plan information by capturing the multi-formats of each observation.
Experimental results demonstrate that our framework outperforms previous
state-of-the-art methods regarding text quality and clinical efficacy | [
-0.119947128,
-0.4455355108,
1.1557482481,
0.0136483358,
-0.5409165621,
-0.4608771503,
0.0951382816,
-0.6265316606,
0.4410309196,
0.8023946285,
-0.4484470487,
-0.6103975177,
-0.3288868368,
0.2380742431,
-0.2856433988,
0.9128094912,
-0.1881809384,
-0.0070021981,
-0.1683998555,
0.0476298071,
-0.497525841,
0.2234557569,
-0.3949209452,
-0.1219129413,
0.6801413298,
0.6821693182,
0.854189992,
1.1241149902,
0.8178303242,
0.1627562642,
0.2592215836,
0.4020223618,
-0.075286828,
0.230982855,
0.1347477436,
-0.2049053907,
-0.4353216588,
-0.3392221332,
0.5760176778,
0.6547724009,
-0.1175375283,
-0.3286243975,
-0.2579488158,
0.7685171366,
-0.5093226433,
0.275701344,
-0.320892632,
0.3431353569,
-0.1555497944,
-0.8346086144,
-0.557862699,
-0.2429245263,
0.0770862475,
-0.8741987944,
-0.0871782154,
0.066256322,
0.8860894442,
0.0925696343,
-0.4526842833,
-0.4359732568,
-0.7740215063,
0.4176260829,
-0.734800756,
0.1462566257,
0.5007836223,
0.4826545417,
0.1269629449,
-0.8916749954,
0.0607163981,
0.0319082588,
-0.6047159433,
0.4786503017,
-0.1620928496,
0.2681163549,
0.167754814,
0.4097588062,
-0.8646019101,
-0.237184763,
-0.1568762362,
-0.1581426859,
0.6396179199,
0.1605553329,
0.1813912243,
-0.5126109123,
-0.4501408935,
-0.0595778562,
-0.6596846581,
-0.4803143144,
-0.0416879617,
0.0520251431,
0.1289905161,
0.6201182008,
-0.5211442709,
0.6329883337,
-0.0513470881,
-0.4913500249,
0.2792681754,
-0.3006265759,
-0.4305739999,
0.4897391796,
0.5074321032,
0.5581906438,
-0.1702855974,
0.0160291679,
-0.139648214,
0.0577296652,
0.0706189871,
-1.189217329,
-0.2386914194,
0.3816736639,
-1.0591578484,
-0.6341136098,
-0.1124293357,
-0.4219257236,
-0.1073949039,
-0.1573101282,
0.3111181259,
-0.8563638926,
-0.4701346755,
0.16897282,
0.167882964,
-0.3105629385,
0.5107489228,
-0.4504336715,
0.2188524902,
0.412912488,
0.5307950974,
0.6404218078,
0.0760482252,
-1.0377503633,
0.5957121253,
-0.4716654122,
0.899153471,
-0.5358288884,
-0.5152388811,
-0.2315349132,
-0.1603927761,
-0.0185685903,
-0.4362514913,
0.3251054287,
-0.0271049738,
0.5222571492,
0.0574330389,
-0.6210478544,
-0.1776783168,
0.1750763208,
-0.3300529718,
0.480551511,
0.322704047,
-0.987889111,
0.6429317594,
-0.6944204569,
-0.389808923,
0.3316774666,
-0.7116841674,
-0.4323239028,
0.1135246903,
0.3634739816,
0.2472035289,
-0.0037075642,
0.4331591725,
0.2570998967,
-0.0131030465,
-0.0119674774,
-0.2224718183,
0.4182447791,
0.539316833,
-0.1406107545,
0.322524339,
-0.6213721037,
0.5659424067,
-0.0110285599,
-0.1221422777,
-0.1275290996,
0.3474502265,
-0.3771927655,
-0.0562338457,
-0.0604487881,
-0.7916194201,
0.3338905871,
-0.3069836497,
0.1457291692,
0.2570871115,
0.3969708383,
-0.1384681165,
-0.6317942739,
0.4255228937,
0.3526075482,
0.3738417923,
-0.7354475856,
-0.3324199617,
-0.3873513341,
-0.1810232103,
0.1766495556,
0.3130604923,
-0.5306102633,
0.1383822709,
-0.2207307518,
-0.387547195,
-0.3244046271,
-0.5202332735,
0.5642831922,
0.7727203965,
0.2475914955,
-0.5036889315,
-0.6944028735,
-1.308770895,
0.116706185,
-0.5457464457,
0.0294071492,
0.577976346,
0.2497481555,
-0.0417556614,
0.5385991931,
-0.9530640841,
-0.527350843,
-0.2367923707,
0.3438611925,
0.0796034485,
0.4409064651,
0.4975235164,
-0.6846565604,
-0.3999951184,
0.2945852578,
-0.8571060896,
-0.1420868188,
-0.2652572095,
-0.2760802209,
0.2847839296,
0.6397749186,
-0.2162814289,
0.8707745075,
0.2927877307,
-0.3238761723,
0.51152426,
-0.3792204261,
0.3263573945,
-1.0330656767,
0.2549287081,
-0.329421699,
-0.6097572446,
-0.2225334644,
-0.0807433948,
-0.0613543279,
-0.1430022568,
-0.1281917542,
-0.0217047874,
-0.5771294236,
-0.1241602078,
-0.2186798155,
-0.2614376545,
0.1531292498,
0.2249061316,
0.4935484529,
0.1466798335,
0.6311259866,
-0.2049285918,
-0.2149444818,
0.2529669702,
-0.3075197637,
0.6080334187,
-0.5061452389,
-0.0028450992,
-0.356731981,
0.2839999199,
-0.4301961064,
-0.5391731858,
0.1054261401,
-0.4316447377,
0.5125098825,
-0.1189805791,
-0.4339897037,
-0.2976459563,
-0.0102394894,
0.1260147244,
0.3138370812,
-0.0225907657,
0.651501596,
-0.1430745572,
-0.1207463294,
-0.2788528204,
-0.6881623864,
0.1160805002,
0.1096764207,
-0.6838216782,
0.3148910701,
0.0407136157,
-0.2926976383,
0.5599892735,
-0.0677943304,
-0.0411645509,
-0.0815431848,
0.409460485,
0.0097426903,
-0.6580806971,
0.0631278679,
-0.0897314399,
-0.1210988462,
0.1008705571,
-0.3431999981,
0.3606422544,
-0.0680387989,
-0.6034319401,
-0.7306498885,
0.7639744282,
0.4981861711,
-0.1726014763,
0.1969482452,
-0.0235698018,
-0.5128549337,
0.0413115621,
-0.1268287152,
-0.0754163116,
-0.3070162237,
0.3577153981,
-0.3616679609,
-0.2265704274,
0.1402385235,
-0.0393761247,
0.3296158016,
0.4611663818,
0.2091180384,
-0.3448928595,
1.5229872465,
0.5363249183,
0.5129833817,
0.1406840086,
-0.1975236088,
-0.0424445048,
-0.9950140715,
-0.479166925,
-0.4659458995,
-0.1537047178,
-0.3911835849,
-0.3063953817,
0.7464366555,
0.0460019149,
0.054288622,
-0.2021659762,
-0.7797922492,
0.4754273593,
0.1833904088,
0.4240612686,
0.5746551752,
0.0128554394,
-0.1197979748,
-0.0561499372,
-0.8439318538,
-0.65806669,
0.9351171255,
0.0414518081,
0.4741651714,
-0.0792341009,
0.9047106504,
-0.0966448784,
0.4391480088,
-0.6063507795,
0.4362376928,
-0.2434233874,
-0.5108380914,
-0.2696840763,
-0.4100610912,
-1.0110454559,
0.1454023868,
0.0777575076,
-0.6330702305,
-0.0012957663,
0.2844992578,
-0.3129880428,
0.3256598413,
-0.339315027,
0.5684126019,
-0.5469270349,
-0.103225477,
-0.2013757974,
-0.8599790335,
0.2845197022,
0.1895771474,
0.309153825,
0.2422713339,
0.1650174409,
0.3580946326,
-0.9327450395,
0.6146033406,
-0.2687419057,
0.2485632896,
0.3359694481,
0.3005353212,
0.4223774672,
0.249279514,
0.0800925791,
-0.4881033301,
0.0413367897,
-0.2476831228,
-0.348235786,
0.36423105,
-0.5569848418,
-0.473767519,
-0.351082921,
-0.6350082755,
-0.0373527184,
0.6400835514,
0.4986366034,
0.9765017033,
-0.19421646,
0.3551024497,
0.5337232947,
-0.324485749,
0.0002566924,
0.4844274521,
-0.7462527156,
-0.4818904102,
0.7408899665,
0.0361615643,
0.4012194276,
0.684160471,
0.5859516263,
0.1907536983,
-0.7267690301,
-0.5963876247,
0.1297452301,
-0.4688315094,
-0.4890133142,
-0.6211212873,
-0.2855967283,
-0.0989516377,
-0.2911368906,
-0.2335695028,
-0.27986601,
0.0774512291,
0.2100228071,
0.3309845626,
0.7860520482,
-0.2099152505,
0.0400173105,
-0.6207794547,
0.2110651433,
-0.0601102225,
0.3068680167,
-0.0513583608,
0.1342642158,
-0.2656570077,
0.0815387666,
-0.4485208094,
-0.7600485682,
0.3785995245,
0.0588666014,
0.2744692266,
0.5882279277,
-0.0177289061,
0.8343610764,
-0.1909910142,
0.4441713095,
0.440972805,
-0.6145884991,
1.2860761881,
-0.4961745143,
0.3298201561,
0.4391994774,
-0.1711788625,
-0.3547627628,
-0.954353869,
-1.1342765093,
-0.6843479872,
0.8259304762,
0.4383994341,
-0.6730738282,
0.0017486087,
0.1439717114,
0.2465101629,
0.0619798563,
-0.2691964507,
0.2403599322,
-0.5495936871,
-0.2372858971,
0.2936974168,
0.0032876744,
-0.4415838718,
-0.0700524449,
0.4580132365,
-0.5638164282,
0.1520399004,
0.7794262171,
0.1160500199,
-0.5347315073,
0.282045722,
0.5874232054,
0.8903960586,
-0.3997896314,
0.2910036743,
-0.2971726954,
-0.3890860975,
-0.2727884352,
-0.2701753378,
-0.4732773006,
0.2414062768,
0.6494227052,
0.6789783239,
0.0757927671,
-0.5502949953,
0.5077505112,
-0.1952512115,
-0.731597662,
-0.2129945308,
0.0747038499,
0.2757666409,
0.0175609067,
0.2214489579,
0.3966322839,
0.1658433676,
-0.5832827687,
0.2247619927,
0.1879009455,
-0.4756661355,
-0.1844212711,
0.5865252614,
0.0438093767,
0.0418196768,
0.9100456834,
0.1061392277,
-0.2263732404,
0.8947621584,
0.4747455418,
0.6965559125,
0.1796626449,
0.4251005948,
0.4139086008,
0.3049444854,
0.1057797074,
0.5956619978,
-0.0123324394,
-0.2959776819,
-0.4862351418,
-0.1876147985,
-0.3019884527,
0.2302579731,
-0.8205954432,
0.3539420068,
-0.4257823825,
0.3315086067,
0.1742078662,
-0.0145777119,
-0.2198953331,
0.6247904301,
0.0861972347,
1.0053037405,
-0.4359873533,
0.6703927517,
0.5375121236,
-0.3893222511,
-1.398199439,
0.0447034091,
-0.0128601976,
-0.7477686405,
0.4582855701,
0.4152649939,
0.0352659337,
-0.2554575801,
-0.3047860265,
-0.7839132547,
1.2839493752,
0.2466218621,
-0.6305758357,
0.0397252962,
-0.0717959106,
0.582921207,
-0.8826942444,
0.341378957,
0.0177703388,
0.7798125148,
0.4129526317,
-0.8717950583,
0.1414018124,
-0.1606291533,
-0.2806106508,
0.4162699878,
-0.5046569705,
0.5649584532,
-0.5185026526,
-0.3915898204,
0.1547900736,
0.3971923888,
0.1675306559,
0.5818619728,
0.7165203691,
0.734528482,
0.6971351504,
-0.0029703761,
1.3236422539,
-0.2793490291,
-0.0898614526,
0.9181460738,
-0.4358639121,
0.4351232648,
0.4087407589,
0.1864764988,
0.6285720468,
0.4258904159,
0.0880134031,
0.6034861207,
-0.0928799063,
0.1387106776,
-0.4147409201,
-0.3796240985,
-0.5662763715,
0.58107692,
0.2160931826,
-0.7639871836,
-0.3912740946,
-0.143996194,
0.0956751704,
-0.1460943222,
-0.2937070131,
1.0116417408,
-0.2901168168,
-0.9800448418,
0.4393462241,
-0.3383564651,
-0.0751262009,
-0.6971146464,
-0.2693137825,
-0.0396020077,
0.2071400136,
-0.7188808918,
-0.874073863,
0.7584616542,
-0.0374304801,
-0.2846181989,
-0.4433678389,
0.5215749145,
-0.2227942348,
-0.6020690799,
-0.1385217011,
0.3788510263,
0.4575183392,
0.2425833046,
-0.1029034033,
-0.0252298992,
0.2976837754,
-0.2335187495,
0.2703475952,
0.7544468641,
-0.2065605223,
0.3678229749,
0.1753187031,
0.4463895559,
-0.6602128148,
-0.0651303232,
0.9259785414,
-0.2939934134,
-0.5891311169,
-0.2649447322,
0.4703908265,
-0.208001852,
-0.5393926501,
0.1201780736,
1.0664781332,
0.5793449879,
0.2880844474,
0.7940371037,
-0.1625442952,
0.5870105028,
-0.7748944759,
0.5050148368,
-0.8032751679,
0.3389518857,
-0.2048559487,
-0.4520962536,
-0.2377412468,
0.4406944811,
0.0636957288,
-0.2005577236,
1.1566035748,
0.5383927226,
-0.0694917217,
0.2827481627,
0.1269945204,
0.4256402552,
0.4565350115,
0.7366694808,
0.6296362281,
-0.0712268874,
0.7539311647,
-0.3931522071,
-0.3715123236,
-0.3138205409,
-0.9336282015,
-0.1625958383,
-0.4083895385,
-0.6815978885,
-0.1403416693,
0.0578036867,
0.2423748076,
1.0120683908,
-0.2793397605,
-0.0272844322,
-0.4021913111,
-0.061588157,
-0.3934415877,
-0.2314155996,
0.6671059132,
-0.026615845,
-0.1868109405,
0.1442104727,
0.6563923359,
-0.0848911628,
-0.0907928795,
-0.0904695094,
0.1189694405,
-0.2405454963,
0.3842587471,
0.1742820293,
-0.5264447331,
-0.4499180019,
-0.0510659479,
-0.2053147256,
0.3992520273,
0.9926712513,
-0.9003045559,
0.5990710258,
0.2542607188,
-0.0255290084,
0.733589232,
-0.1146243587,
0.4352455437,
-0.7027775645,
0.0179645307,
0.7343443632,
0.3193841279,
0.288684994,
-0.6604840159,
0.6194173694,
-0.0223995019,
-0.6476309299,
-0.8958413005,
0.3957271874,
-0.987800777,
-0.5294818282,
0.7179279923,
-0.1560798138,
-0.1890796274,
0.1633623391,
-0.4285048544,
0.1130388379,
-0.2196735442,
0.5843275785,
0.2334157974,
-0.9750885367,
-0.2214687765,
-0.2032306939,
0.4133858681,
0.2494739741,
-1.0528599024,
-0.0011027082,
0.8210062385,
0.2461289912,
0.3181086183,
0.9074855447,
-0.5019655228,
0.6047721505,
0.1773275137,
-0.293864131,
-0.3831096888,
-0.4396122694,
0.4811744988,
0.2714639604,
0.1720313728,
-0.2173424959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06427v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06427v3 | Boosting Language Models Reasoning with Chain-of-Knowledge Prompting | 2023-06-10T12:42:36 | 2024-06-03T14:59:11 | Jianing Wang, Qiushi Sun, Xiang Li, Ming Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has delivered success on complex
reasoning tasks, which aims at designing a simple prompt like ``Let's think
step by step'' or multiple in-context exemplars with well-designed rationales
to elicit Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate intermediate reasoning
steps. However, the generated rationales often come with mistakes, making
unfactual and unfaithful reasoning chains. To mitigate this brittleness, we
propose a novel Chain-of-Knowledge (CoK) prompting, where we aim at eliciting
LLMs to generate explicit pieces of knowledge evidence in the form of structure
triple. This is inspired by our human behaviors, i.e., we can draw a mind map
or knowledge map as the reasoning evidence in the brain before answering a
complex question. Benefiting from CoK, we additionally introduce a
F^2-Verification method to estimate the reliability of the reasoning chains in
terms of factuality and faithfulness. For the unreliable response, the wrong
evidence can be indicated to prompt the LLM to rethink. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our method can further improve the performance of commonsense,
factual, symbolic, and arithmetic reasoning tasks. | [
-0.225498572,
-1.0475792885,
0.698861897,
0.1606117636,
-0.1486004442,
0.2706241608,
-0.1019456163,
-0.1976875663,
0.0092205051,
0.4136458039,
-0.663022697,
-0.2585430145,
-0.0895770043,
0.0835592747,
-0.2683374584,
0.7755607963,
-0.1279708892,
-0.0891834944,
-0.3054701686,
0.1768902987,
-0.5640419126,
-0.4098670185,
-0.8488737345,
-0.5648664832,
0.741479516,
0.6292606592,
0.7057285905,
0.26084131,
-0.0060323691,
0.1306136698,
-0.1272370517,
0.5956580639,
-0.3118175864,
0.1256506592,
-0.2052735686,
-0.5877550244,
-0.6859561801,
-0.1330918968,
0.295037657,
0.706313014,
-0.0589774624,
-0.0496430956,
0.0679902583,
0.8000099063,
-0.6534505486,
0.2884796858,
-0.7745768428,
-0.2805749178,
0.2477020919,
-0.353929311,
-0.6845675707,
-0.2188154012,
0.1252355874,
-0.5502184033,
0.097183153,
0.4326889515,
0.6364834309,
0.1223506778,
-0.3327628672,
-0.3836508691,
-0.4559742212,
0.4421186447,
-0.5062591434,
0.4551464319,
0.5907586813,
0.1959866732,
-0.5856257677,
-0.3141144812,
-0.7385261059,
-0.3468625546,
-0.0327337496,
0.0478878319,
0.1447363198,
0.013994229,
0.4139207602,
0.2553214431,
-0.345569402,
-0.2358937114,
-0.1000927389,
-0.3120570183,
0.514901638,
-0.0649176836,
0.546354413,
0.0916807577,
-0.4644580185,
-0.3726842701,
-1.2627009153,
0.2184333056,
0.5070009232,
0.2759225965,
-0.0575934239,
0.3870712817,
-0.3353434205,
0.9289963841,
0.2716404796,
0.0664444044,
-0.06951534,
-0.3586260974,
-0.0481058583,
0.237129584,
0.6656511426,
0.2864474654,
0.2510106862,
-0.0615311824,
-0.2049500346,
0.0848398134,
0.1900406629,
-0.4739034474,
-0.4748060405,
0.408115983,
0.005919076,
-0.4025612175,
-0.0835691541,
-0.7140327692,
-0.2821878195,
-0.1471386403,
0.4714984298,
-0.4866028428,
-0.4261175394,
0.4042385221,
-0.0783270821,
0.0591819808,
0.3794659972,
-0.9213580489,
0.1870094538,
0.6831766963,
0.5446581244,
0.1718960255,
-0.3184842467,
-0.6478321552,
0.2139813155,
-0.6057876945,
0.9277800322,
-0.3848048747,
0.0146342125,
-0.0062772501,
-0.1802414656,
0.3133846223,
-0.3151529729,
0.596360147,
-0.5714767575,
0.180733934,
-0.7750290036,
-0.4127200246,
-0.2389727533,
0.7081430554,
-0.6998769641,
1.1602135897,
-0.1140564382,
-0.7042828798,
0.3506478965,
-0.5425608754,
-0.4291899204,
-0.0029182513,
-0.3483279645,
-0.1622701436,
-0.1407817453,
0.609408021,
0.3816417754,
-0.4337769151,
0.5425818563,
-0.4231658578,
-0.1439485997,
0.2324030697,
-0.4436939359,
0.8275169134,
0.014896079,
-0.2677362263,
0.0895881802,
-0.7203215361,
0.1404669732,
0.0905786231,
-0.2927242517,
-0.4756507576,
0.1126085445,
-0.5815544128,
0.4593703449,
0.0717707723,
-0.375736624,
0.3230183423,
-0.4056633413,
0.3032312691,
0.6091097593,
0.0573514625,
0.2406243682,
-0.4439602494,
0.4325038791,
0.2197164893,
-0.0753844827,
-0.2862641215,
-0.7343380451,
-0.7914652824,
-0.0036947064,
0.0460060649,
0.3288084865,
-1.1252930164,
0.5051216483,
-0.1701028049,
-0.2622117102,
-0.2836351395,
0.0125833312,
0.4488387406,
0.855299592,
0.5102881193,
0.1673139632,
-0.7157632709,
-0.5592722297,
-0.4557836354,
-0.5726512671,
0.0299569797,
0.0230782516,
0.6609265804,
0.1206425652,
0.9629049897,
-0.4395126104,
0.3577643037,
-0.3136726618,
0.2203512192,
0.0961230397,
0.3006249666,
0.0816192329,
-0.6044975519,
-0.1291621476,
-0.2605850995,
-0.5555829406,
-0.108412005,
-0.1566472501,
-0.4205050468,
0.1377046108,
0.4875874817,
-0.553796947,
0.2318850011,
0.4305302799,
-0.6918246746,
0.7425697446,
-0.1923282295,
0.163735494,
-1.0229388475,
0.0698788837,
-0.5168643594,
-0.1938357651,
-0.3097952902,
-0.0321586803,
0.1589595526,
0.0417198911,
-0.206539005,
0.6183443666,
-0.3876169026,
0.1647458225,
-0.1591082066,
0.2003860772,
0.2742942274,
0.6503491998,
0.0847388282,
0.6371603608,
0.4917252064,
-0.6654348373,
0.2789618671,
0.2080927938,
-0.3935759962,
0.5367584229,
-0.4904127121,
0.3308999836,
0.0133440988,
0.6274920702,
-0.9951660633,
-0.4134000838,
0.2242202163,
-0.2405580431,
0.0184163135,
-0.1905524135,
-0.6779170036,
-0.7580674291,
-0.1270262003,
0.465141356,
0.3039961457,
-0.9347443581,
0.5102763176,
0.1059325486,
0.0883939043,
-0.6360496283,
-0.5439813137,
0.0406973213,
0.124650009,
-0.8165480494,
0.1624967605,
-0.2320405692,
-0.1281684339,
-0.1395615935,
-0.3648503125,
-0.0000377423,
0.1213717908,
0.1693260074,
0.4832561314,
-0.0950003043,
0.2872621715,
0.188813284,
-0.0089102769,
0.3648458421,
-0.6564307213,
0.5590316653,
-0.4311767519,
-0.3698285222,
-0.2946656644,
0.1906090379,
0.5376061201,
-0.0464078858,
0.4638606608,
0.1518181413,
-0.4385059476,
-0.2454624921,
-0.5574626327,
-0.5090124011,
-0.4333077371,
0.0599183738,
-0.4643152058,
-0.9620181918,
0.3840386569,
-0.2435346395,
-0.0914648622,
0.195433706,
0.6735967398,
-0.1651830673,
1.0586221218,
0.1373506784,
0.1702492535,
0.060892608,
-0.163706392,
0.3869984448,
-0.6669840217,
-0.3148237467,
-0.2673538625,
-0.0701732412,
-0.0735733658,
-0.5703530312,
0.2720410824,
0.473113209,
-0.2138778567,
0.0929433256,
-0.227835834,
0.6789503694,
0.223091647,
0.2440158576,
0.3575322926,
0.0906416997,
-0.7609546185,
0.5429145098,
-0.963948071,
-0.4929331243,
0.838971138,
0.1948461086,
0.7125532627,
-0.0464047156,
0.6256999969,
0.0170156714,
0.2152595222,
-0.7044297457,
0.6275215745,
0.3182365596,
-0.7064967155,
-0.1927188188,
-0.4175633192,
-0.6822288632,
-0.1019260138,
-0.2483977079,
-0.6069580317,
0.126793921,
0.6997097731,
-0.6643889546,
0.3648839891,
-0.5011726618,
0.5846435428,
-0.2566257119,
-0.4221426845,
-0.3029013574,
-0.4573656917,
0.4991507828,
0.2350999862,
0.3687646985,
0.0303697865,
0.1184623539,
0.6346415877,
-0.6153177619,
0.8058011532,
-0.108800441,
-0.3428891897,
0.6825659275,
0.4020700753,
0.916962266,
0.1076987237,
-0.038107641,
-0.1445393711,
-0.2537220418,
-0.3344790936,
-0.9172615409,
0.5352966785,
-0.4346658885,
-0.5659831762,
-0.0836239532,
-0.7263320088,
-0.4878373146,
0.1819155663,
0.2076961249,
0.4784777761,
0.0319524072,
-0.0153995492,
0.6064636707,
0.0260755066,
0.1906488538,
0.3156019449,
-0.4292703271,
-0.5031381249,
0.8136301637,
-0.1269965172,
0.5191997886,
0.3781138361,
0.5767048001,
-0.4177232981,
-0.2108206004,
-0.4304437935,
-0.0146684619,
-0.6565064192,
-0.1693605036,
-0.6469903588,
-0.0042955135,
-0.1061958373,
-0.1686132699,
-0.4341308773,
-0.5103974938,
0.3319687247,
-0.2836227417,
0.4790399373,
0.7356783152,
-0.0313822255,
-0.0642978027,
-0.4832303524,
0.3235599697,
0.6844636202,
0.3705809116,
0.2707614899,
-0.2281838506,
-0.2594366372,
0.3056972623,
-0.2022071779,
-0.8252357244,
-0.0272833742,
-0.2011131346,
0.2927158475,
0.3246580362,
0.1240525246,
0.6950292587,
-0.4220221937,
0.6801407933,
0.3248644173,
-0.8232517242,
0.7591865659,
-0.579744935,
0.2289233655,
0.381229192,
0.2011599392,
-0.390987128,
-0.4610291123,
-0.7287349701,
-0.8023477197,
0.3651247323,
0.217737034,
-0.2816167176,
-0.3091059923,
0.4141870439,
0.0471642502,
0.110520184,
-0.546826005,
-0.0370526537,
-0.2689627111,
-0.1869893968,
0.4511054158,
-0.4194990396,
-0.2009723783,
-0.3450370431,
0.7486675382,
-0.511095643,
0.1595393717,
0.4045025706,
-0.0370862223,
-0.3931594491,
0.44291538,
0.6539964676,
0.5286473036,
-0.2417334616,
0.5672668219,
0.2067757249,
-0.1944773942,
0.3776448667,
-0.4820639789,
-0.2200974226,
-0.3966817856,
0.3127943277,
0.7243029475,
0.3337370157,
-0.5443301797,
0.3447132409,
-0.0913311169,
-0.1453820169,
-0.0907205492,
0.1867793947,
0.2848221362,
0.1109328717,
0.2674323618,
0.2420635968,
-0.1214409322,
-0.6014233232,
0.1394880414,
0.2466435581,
-0.2654830217,
-0.4314230382,
0.368180275,
0.2871296108,
-0.3678525686,
0.5869266987,
-0.355284363,
-0.8124774098,
0.3802643418,
0.8001500368,
0.7403270602,
-0.0279984232,
0.1447036862,
0.6298510432,
0.198764056,
-0.5894563198,
0.6515803933,
-0.2439281791,
-0.9416462183,
-0.595492363,
-0.3179953992,
-0.365925163,
0.2155977041,
-0.5266946554,
0.2912233472,
-0.4995270967,
0.0938404575,
-0.4380587637,
-0.1264441311,
-0.4732075036,
0.2834522426,
0.3168842494,
1.0309244394,
-0.8030097485,
0.9827499986,
0.4719777405,
-0.4147053063,
-1.1756091118,
0.1923275292,
0.0083110388,
-0.7688598633,
0.622203052,
0.2748149633,
-0.479516983,
0.0149066104,
-0.8614708781,
-0.7251564264,
1.0257153511,
0.3875117004,
-0.7271742225,
-0.2175337374,
-0.0724351779,
0.3417260647,
-0.5061906576,
0.1738791168,
0.425917536,
0.4570850432,
0.2554464638,
-0.4925210178,
0.5512647033,
-0.166069895,
-0.292728126,
0.0743221492,
-0.4576403797,
0.7888064384,
-0.6362215877,
-0.1077380553,
-0.0237649195,
0.6276039481,
0.855248034,
0.1553438455,
0.9507924914,
0.5779756308,
1.2439432144,
0.0403671116,
1.1136566401,
-0.4040315449,
0.16925098,
1.4235876799,
-0.1158430055,
0.9650040269,
0.6118425131,
-0.0161719825,
1.1304864883,
0.4644680321,
0.2129388452,
0.2821706831,
0.0981399119,
-0.2279728502,
-0.7046728134,
-9.086e-7,
-0.2284303308,
0.2712135017,
0.5890655518,
0.0138705252,
-0.141044274,
-0.3373049498,
0.1040777341,
-0.0764857978,
-0.1547817886,
0.4103844464,
0.1416410208,
-1.1885180473,
0.7442927361,
-0.4396570623,
0.3002486229,
-0.4110338688,
-0.2659424245,
-0.0301276222,
-0.0664867684,
-0.1246647537,
-0.8984809518,
0.1813535094,
-0.1346572489,
-0.3293659091,
-0.367815882,
0.7538981438,
-0.6695715189,
-0.3746138215,
0.364334017,
0.4433922172,
-0.002201458,
-0.2195465267,
-0.5772509575,
-0.1082090959,
-0.117891036,
-0.0031054737,
-0.0855360925,
0.4638609886,
-0.2489552349,
0.8107325435,
0.9605494738,
-0.007366736,
-0.173463285,
0.155082792,
0.7484539151,
-0.7364806533,
-0.6600254774,
-0.9732037187,
0.5794482231,
-0.1815220863,
0.0103819249,
0.5192774534,
0.3357351124,
0.6962410212,
-0.01830622,
0.7694425583,
-0.0316936634,
0.1383442134,
-0.7152242064,
0.7310958505,
-0.4688330293,
0.3903187811,
-0.1678362936,
-0.3743175864,
-0.1501422077,
0.4364976287,
-0.2603200078,
-0.1081442982,
1.0003120899,
0.9863792658,
0.1676636338,
0.4128729105,
0.2684490085,
0.5167532563,
0.3604036868,
0.7713097334,
1.0997867584,
-0.3581715524,
0.5099188089,
-0.1412117183,
-0.1505887657,
-0.1950422227,
-1.0937907696,
-1.0672675371,
-0.5673280954,
-0.3316391706,
-0.8083776236,
0.0456831083,
1.0962642431,
0.6218785048,
-0.8082495332,
-0.1625132561,
-0.737569809,
0.5449829102,
-0.4019230306,
-0.1666436791,
0.4084147811,
-0.4772096276,
-0.039538268,
0.609431088,
0.4482674003,
-0.0504008345,
-0.3489149213,
-0.2341947407,
-0.5076386929,
0.127444908,
0.5452959538,
0.1677702665,
-0.9501589537,
-0.4582126737,
-0.0006955548,
0.0506374575,
0.0501428172,
1.1453646421,
-1.090075016,
0.5976274014,
0.7587621808,
0.3557326794,
0.0718522072,
-0.380046308,
0.9797191024,
-0.7391782403,
-0.058150053,
0.0777772665,
0.4176273644,
0.3379022479,
-0.4963264167,
0.3475587964,
0.2853854299,
-0.3741780221,
-0.8316922188,
0.4643025696,
-0.9188812971,
-0.0980119333,
1.0741413832,
-0.2706339657,
-0.5172488689,
-0.3074990809,
-0.2854395211,
0.2867175937,
-0.3920963109,
0.878608644,
0.870146215,
-0.0721599236,
-0.0624882691,
-0.0643270016,
0.693195045,
0.4849822521,
-0.8298879266,
0.3739792705,
0.2238152176,
0.2821544707,
0.2786321342,
0.4813376367,
-0.0592150427,
0.5629016161,
0.10563723,
-0.0621699579,
-0.1806973964,
-0.576169014,
0.0460042916,
0.1109725833,
0.1107526645,
0.3505612612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06410v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06410v1 | OpenSR: Open-Modality Speech Recognition via Maintaining Multi-Modality Alignment | 2023-06-10T11:04:10 | 2023-06-10T11:04:10 | Xize Cheng, Tao Jin, Linjun Li, Wang Lin, Xinyu Duan, Zhou Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Speech Recognition builds a bridge between the multimedia streaming
(audio-only, visual-only or audio-visual) and the corresponding text
transcription. However, when training the specific model of new domain, it
often gets stuck in the lack of new-domain utterances, especially the labeled
visual utterances. To break through this restriction, we attempt to achieve
zero-shot modality transfer by maintaining the multi-modality alignment in
phoneme space learned with unlabeled multimedia utterances in the high resource
domain during the pre-training \cite{shi2022learning}, and propose a training
system Open-modality Speech Recognition (\textbf{OpenSR}) that enables the
models trained on a single modality (e.g., audio-only) applicable to more
modalities (e.g., visual-only and audio-visual). Furthermore, we employ a
cluster-based prompt tuning strategy to handle the domain shift for the
scenarios with only common words in the new domain utterances. We demonstrate
that OpenSR enables modality transfer from one to any in three different
settings (zero-, few- and full-shot), and achieves highly competitive zero-shot
performance compared to the existing few-shot and full-shot lip-reading
methods. To the best of our knowledge, OpenSR achieves the state-of-the-art
performance of word error rate in LRS2 on audio-visual speech recognition and
lip-reading with 2.7\% and 25.0\%, respectively. The code and demo are
available at https://github.com/Exgc/OpenSR. | [
-0.328671217,
-0.766636014,
0.0893129706,
-0.3898805976,
-0.3748464882,
-0.1879296601,
-0.4256177545,
-0.1692781299,
-0.061922323,
0.3134209514,
-0.4305908084,
-0.4291471839,
-0.4120685458,
-0.0912348181,
0.0992043987,
1.0514085293,
-0.0281431153,
0.4348365664,
-0.0863951668,
-0.5014573336,
-0.6422228217,
-0.2979894876,
-0.4195669889,
-0.0829400495,
0.555002749,
0.4549305737,
0.4559176564,
0.6851372719,
0.660517931,
0.2078934312,
0.0539138727,
0.1046140417,
-0.4392338693,
0.2142156065,
0.1567978859,
-0.3128854632,
-0.4392638505,
-0.2245441675,
0.931632638,
0.4414287508,
-0.3261693716,
0.1666461974,
-0.0779827237,
0.3548466563,
-0.8355064392,
0.1382959187,
-0.715095222,
0.2444000691,
-0.5628442764,
-0.4884829521,
-0.1832828373,
-0.0707010776,
0.0064308518,
-0.6499274373,
0.1407439858,
-0.1187400371,
0.5320160389,
0.4181838334,
-0.4254215658,
-0.0084533552,
-1.0021032095,
0.6667140126,
-0.3451189697,
0.8652638793,
0.3901641667,
0.5702301264,
0.1051985249,
-0.2335225046,
-0.8506069779,
0.0830351412,
0.2427750975,
0.2268484533,
-0.2011782527,
-0.0336571634,
0.1697537303,
0.4235632718,
-0.8385098577,
0.1786398292,
-0.476287514,
-0.2814887762,
0.0531594902,
-0.1625027806,
0.2358727902,
0.1959507763,
-0.5542855859,
-0.1073603705,
-0.5182719231,
0.3866682053,
0.1313593388,
0.7752598524,
-0.1610064656,
0.7990049124,
0.0714072958,
0.8482032418,
0.0212881882,
-0.5298358798,
0.3828421533,
-0.3277730644,
-0.2939105928,
0.4387257397,
0.6974765062,
0.1873072237,
-0.0976982564,
-0.0178531352,
-0.1760661006,
0.1668250859,
0.050391417,
-0.6648441553,
0.2866301537,
-0.0289831702,
-0.4424333274,
0.1535069197,
0.1376966387,
-0.3873840868,
-0.2578989267,
-0.5481037498,
0.8694947958,
-0.5494830012,
-0.435038209,
0.391181916,
0.078250587,
0.3087091744,
0.4036792815,
-0.6463013291,
0.3347993493,
0.5229890943,
0.9678447843,
-0.0908619538,
-0.1402732432,
-1.0981816053,
0.3478448987,
0.0633814856,
0.6458473206,
-0.4942544401,
-0.2865405679,
-0.0974231064,
-0.1964912862,
-0.3510180712,
-0.46668607,
0.5388919115,
-0.3351078331,
0.3583217263,
-0.155557543,
-0.2309923917,
-0.0126430886,
0.0513045713,
-0.440556705,
0.7439060211,
-0.206276685,
-0.5373769403,
0.3470924795,
-0.9360898137,
-0.4161443114,
-0.0629043058,
-0.3636755049,
-0.4066006243,
0.2016029209,
-0.0026524267,
0.0153651368,
-0.2784692645,
-0.2992013097,
-0.1195469871,
-0.330430299,
0.4844704866,
-0.5277118087,
0.5301728845,
0.5146859288,
-0.1019777656,
0.2672201693,
-0.8763085008,
0.0567983277,
-0.1150216013,
-0.3117567599,
-0.2368707508,
-0.1613745838,
0.3337846398,
0.253831774,
-0.016816102,
-0.8662481904,
0.2807986438,
-0.0272482336,
0.4069094658,
0.4739903808,
-0.2182950675,
0.6312206984,
-0.382979542,
0.5021535158,
0.3559787273,
0.1343916506,
-0.483076483,
-0.2145562768,
-0.6862089038,
-0.7416160107,
0.2930253148,
0.6540762782,
-0.5965935588,
0.5352557898,
-0.3693917692,
-0.2265700251,
-0.8252266645,
-0.1440301239,
0.5465891361,
0.7548303604,
0.47172454,
-0.6334264874,
-0.2629477978,
-0.6234511733,
-0.0738440976,
-0.0644581616,
0.1781136543,
0.298341006,
-0.011085825,
0.1650350094,
0.9892421365,
-0.2687562406,
-0.8670146465,
-0.0638538152,
0.2044341415,
0.1285032779,
0.5991864204,
0.3005532324,
-0.7475386262,
-0.2780147493,
0.2154315263,
-0.3982387483,
0.0054059485,
-0.0279294718,
-0.0259806663,
0.0980450809,
0.5281900764,
-0.4589028955,
0.2729467154,
0.4982352555,
-0.1539174914,
0.1814950556,
0.0631247461,
0.1844038069,
-1.135818243,
0.2330334634,
-0.159008503,
-0.1609868109,
-0.6420559883,
-0.3566824496,
-0.1139946952,
-0.4894126952,
-0.5150107145,
0.3151571155,
-0.4372712076,
-0.0378065519,
-0.2386022955,
0.0293170772,
-0.2929935455,
0.5319253802,
0.2069766968,
0.9329937696,
0.8873930573,
-0.2965759933,
0.0098855412,
0.4717814624,
-0.2216214687,
0.9750429988,
-0.5004965663,
0.395001024,
-0.3868345022,
0.1124261394,
-1.0820747614,
0.038999524,
0.2943060994,
-0.4978220761,
0.5123319626,
-0.2181361914,
-0.1913408935,
0.0588180721,
0.0625324696,
0.5970300436,
0.3975992501,
-0.2622337043,
0.6298494935,
0.272002995,
-0.2949436009,
-0.704262495,
-0.6716886759,
-0.1076024622,
0.028899448,
-0.4534266889,
0.0817018524,
-0.2881771326,
0.2627792656,
0.1761682034,
-0.4061238468,
-0.2569512725,
-0.3892448843,
0.2384843826,
0.2230215669,
-0.5606623888,
0.0615777746,
-0.0643096045,
-0.1811292022,
-0.5062766671,
-0.3868374825,
0.406375736,
-0.2779133618,
-0.7261443138,
-0.6848042011,
0.4545455873,
0.7907043695,
-0.7679029107,
0.52758497,
0.8319601417,
-0.3843984902,
0.1346653402,
-0.449118793,
-0.0424077213,
-0.3874067068,
0.2702452242,
-0.5638174415,
-1.1638931036,
0.214473784,
0.1880720705,
-0.0247190949,
-0.0044826847,
0.4191972911,
0.0009117782,
0.8156570196,
0.6201931238,
-0.0877009928,
0.7822495699,
-0.0039865645,
0.3060488999,
-0.7679695487,
-0.1469528824,
-0.50340873,
-0.3532601595,
-0.0769333243,
-0.4442950189,
0.7980887294,
0.301574111,
-0.1948058307,
0.3511664867,
-0.3015039861,
0.5455636978,
0.7118353248,
0.2687660456,
0.4008789957,
0.3569178283,
-0.0367326587,
-0.2141143978,
-0.530790627,
-0.1665838808,
0.7572129965,
0.2915893197,
0.8921617866,
0.4764941335,
0.5884991884,
0.1677183509,
-0.0940881371,
-1.1743549109,
0.5019930601,
-0.2008457333,
-0.4310608208,
-0.4602962434,
-0.4786754251,
-0.6970356703,
0.2751643956,
-0.3231276572,
-0.5172895789,
0.3298431337,
0.1788940877,
-0.4276804924,
0.4219174385,
-0.2239427865,
0.7579290271,
-0.2504817247,
-0.2496479005,
-0.1130251288,
-0.8848401308,
0.1801595837,
-0.1155526564,
0.0880968124,
0.0311489664,
-0.1294099987,
0.3411968052,
-0.2406757325,
0.785124898,
-0.3657678366,
-0.0818339735,
0.1435302049,
0.0199230481,
0.0532104038,
-0.4812037349,
0.0258134007,
0.1583962142,
-0.0217323564,
-0.1882772595,
-0.5117333531,
0.2559058666,
-0.7226158381,
-0.0521408059,
-0.5858294368,
-0.5965944529,
-0.3947295845,
0.4514889121,
0.2518344522,
0.7840179205,
-0.4351253808,
0.4635618925,
0.8358145952,
-0.0665481091,
0.3201502562,
0.8017389178,
0.0069763828,
-0.7550674677,
0.9268790483,
0.1136315614,
0.5159718394,
0.5580358505,
0.2943246067,
-0.3445125818,
-0.5414851308,
-0.6697147489,
0.2229219526,
-0.4172027409,
-0.4613600075,
-0.4925828278,
-0.268492341,
-0.5251611471,
-0.0384527706,
-0.3700388968,
-0.3289982378,
-0.3529193699,
0.2248936296,
0.3007323146,
0.2291920036,
-0.3748503923,
0.3796002567,
-0.910785377,
0.494827956,
0.2909447551,
0.3901612759,
-0.3703882992,
-0.8139846325,
-0.1622671038,
-0.0676546022,
-0.2110249996,
-0.5991087556,
0.0323044918,
0.6464130282,
0.4718951881,
0.7469718456,
-0.0365503579,
0.7502586246,
-0.7142036557,
0.6003776789,
0.8286342621,
-0.9814996719,
0.4448705018,
-0.4527289569,
0.4839803278,
0.7581197023,
0.2816624641,
-0.8376060724,
0.0250089578,
0.038539499,
-0.3939296007,
0.7920443416,
-0.1136248782,
-0.0589205921,
0.2370026261,
-0.0262940507,
0.2950575352,
0.2678793073,
-0.6240054369,
-0.186301589,
-0.3786041141,
-0.3242484927,
0.0210056882,
0.0102993147,
-0.3749243915,
-0.2102360278,
0.5407971144,
-0.3462893069,
0.3167184591,
0.2562836409,
-0.1552929431,
-0.6299006939,
0.6821008325,
0.9209677577,
0.3185554445,
-0.1775563806,
0.2951563299,
-0.281869024,
-0.6237806082,
0.2932382822,
0.3228965104,
-0.2345499247,
-0.1558632702,
0.0416748486,
1.1980696917,
0.121477887,
-0.5845404267,
0.9031808376,
0.0560708493,
-0.2222910225,
-0.0211632978,
-0.1190064177,
-0.3459394276,
0.3089231849,
0.2040068954,
0.4921177626,
-0.0091365008,
-0.6969222426,
0.1532368511,
0.4775022864,
-0.7376511097,
-0.4034621716,
0.700697422,
0.1147576571,
-0.3865671456,
0.3154511452,
-0.1559648514,
-0.2726942897,
-0.0667431504,
0.8503062725,
0.9524548054,
-0.3592459261,
0.1345641166,
0.2818910182,
0.1762416363,
0.0832687914,
0.7014241815,
-0.3096711934,
-0.8342934847,
-0.3517312407,
-0.6990400553,
-0.3610056341,
0.1979301274,
-0.8829908371,
0.3792391419,
-0.2732832134,
-0.0479060709,
-0.2162653357,
-0.7057899833,
-0.5189970732,
-0.0691839606,
0.3440737426,
0.7234399915,
-0.661346972,
0.8939662576,
0.7069708705,
-0.6837882996,
-0.2980200052,
-0.0618867502,
0.3713648617,
-0.7148025036,
0.4791739285,
0.1062608734,
-0.5888442397,
0.0358285159,
-0.2417757064,
-0.9609624147,
0.9901872277,
0.2687156796,
-0.7540115118,
0.1724877059,
0.2161299139,
0.3167010546,
-0.2635537386,
-0.1598811597,
0.104421936,
0.3261290491,
0.1802009344,
-1.3775873184,
-0.207111612,
-0.1132353246,
-0.2700841129,
0.3668906689,
-0.5205252171,
0.8050088882,
-0.3849397302,
-0.4083605409,
0.3018603623,
0.6918935776,
0.057218723,
0.4888065755,
0.8000277877,
0.6759978533,
0.6385855675,
-0.0241089407,
0.4817412794,
-0.1132671535,
-0.0670824125,
1.2179853916,
-0.485042721,
1.1316781044,
0.5950350761,
0.0087256134,
0.0502129681,
0.0433363952,
0.1216154024,
0.8579735756,
-0.0417914242,
-0.6936348081,
-0.1486757249,
-0.4848194122,
-0.4606646001,
0.8847401142,
0.0691523552,
0.0571902916,
-0.1970119774,
0.5654882789,
-0.1963196248,
0.0698195919,
-0.3293865621,
0.9851920605,
-0.1766188145,
-0.3023563027,
0.5539297462,
-0.3226153851,
0.6769936681,
-1.0449169874,
-0.059562508,
0.3278528452,
0.1653021872,
-0.1078928933,
-0.4748322964,
-0.0446800925,
-0.1168625057,
-0.3074522614,
-0.2754434049,
0.6097764969,
-0.9112528563,
-0.1708898395,
-0.0941142514,
0.6678745747,
0.1677558273,
0.0421592742,
-0.4905407727,
0.177979216,
-0.2617011368,
0.2054200023,
0.2872717977,
0.4157235622,
0.2716138065,
0.0096290549,
0.7715374231,
0.1132767126,
0.1258192509,
0.3903491497,
0.7573465705,
-0.4691993296,
-0.5087741613,
-0.3065237999,
0.5021888614,
0.2909885943,
-0.5160938501,
0.488940239,
0.7653631568,
0.8687315583,
-0.0402102061,
0.7686302066,
-0.1109177545,
0.6127790809,
-0.6904508471,
0.3788662851,
-0.6803313494,
-0.0947445929,
-0.068832837,
-0.8819544911,
-0.3882763386,
0.6536974311,
0.0058608009,
-0.2056257427,
0.5556412935,
0.9223075509,
-0.4824794233,
0.0383739285,
0.43855685,
-0.026230067,
0.1708309501,
0.214692831,
0.7500915527,
-0.3132893443,
0.7108401656,
0.0330827944,
-0.4735962451,
-0.1626474857,
-0.740221262,
-0.5797618032,
-0.7568594813,
-0.2715348303,
-0.2822212875,
-0.0557811782,
0.9699084163,
0.6803249717,
-0.7034266591,
-0.4087544084,
0.1294086874,
-0.5215059519,
-0.3596234918,
-0.2106379271,
0.110192813,
-0.2975187898,
-0.4629352987,
0.8164090514,
0.4934539795,
0.1947486699,
-0.1961148232,
-0.0189007856,
-0.1798497587,
-0.045854643,
0.5995796323,
0.5908471942,
-0.696015954,
-0.2318601161,
0.3284870684,
-0.0529033504,
0.3969380558,
1.2922308445,
-0.4364646673,
0.7642315626,
0.4297720194,
0.7231689095,
0.3858286142,
-0.1434864253,
0.3834469318,
-0.6457566619,
0.0432382785,
0.2049111724,
0.2869939506,
0.3693169057,
-0.115935877,
0.3096374571,
0.2699818611,
-0.4995442927,
-0.8633319139,
0.5477493405,
-1.5618964434,
-0.0663132146,
0.8941537738,
0.251037389,
0.0965087935,
-0.0403888337,
-0.5912800431,
0.4053319991,
-0.6144331694,
0.3457500637,
0.3775177896,
-0.2677804232,
-0.2297779471,
-0.30775702,
0.2911734581,
0.3375271857,
-0.5464071631,
0.0672323778,
0.7385879755,
0.2976243496,
0.1614264697,
0.8271670341,
-0.3084666133,
0.3632354438,
-0.2003702968,
0.1866603047,
-0.3938427269,
-0.5336136818,
-0.8926110268,
0.1461884081,
-0.1362000406,
-0.6593273282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06384v1 | Adversarial Training For Low-Resource Disfluency Correction | 2023-06-10T08:58:53 | 2023-06-10T08:58:53 | Vineet Bhat, Preethi Jyothi, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Disfluencies commonly occur in conversational speech. Speech with
disfluencies can result in noisy Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
transcripts, which affects downstream tasks like machine translation. In this
paper, we propose an adversarially-trained sequence-tagging model for
Disfluency Correction (DC) that utilizes a small amount of labeled real
disfluent data in conjunction with a large amount of unlabeled data. We show
the benefit of our proposed technique, which crucially depends on synthetically
generated disfluent data, by evaluating it for DC in three Indian languages-
Bengali, Hindi, and Marathi (all from the Indo-Aryan family). Our technique
also performs well in removing stuttering disfluencies in ASR transcripts
introduced by speech impairments. We achieve an average 6.15 points improvement
in F1-score over competitive baselines across all three languages mentioned. To
the best of our knowledge, we are the first to utilize adversarial training for
DC and use it to correct stuttering disfluencies in English, establishing a new
benchmark for this task. | [
-0.2247813493,
-0.8365655541,
-0.1860195249,
0.0801810399,
-0.1831005812,
0.461138159,
-0.2037693411,
-0.3732833862,
0.1966267526,
0.0328471474,
-0.5171330571,
-0.0825062543,
-0.7584456205,
0.1718143076,
-0.467130661,
1.0209056139,
0.2336443067,
0.4933269024,
0.2632206976,
-0.2281381935,
-0.5327038765,
-0.496265173,
-0.7111611962,
-0.313775003,
0.454300046,
0.2410474718,
0.8632840514,
0.7894560099,
0.508025825,
0.4216981232,
-0.5130873919,
0.4127861261,
-0.3870902359,
0.0125871953,
-0.1191472113,
-0.4578875303,
-0.3022951484,
-0.1950306594,
0.7025020719,
0.7544720769,
-0.4345090389,
-0.3256742954,
0.1706642359,
0.7667241693,
-0.513623178,
0.0235616099,
-0.8785140514,
0.0808025524,
-0.3943433464,
0.1957505941,
-0.3522717357,
-0.1551551521,
-0.2427291572,
-0.4917129278,
0.5092190504,
-0.17052643,
0.794349432,
0.8758391738,
-0.1791208982,
-0.2680464685,
-0.8652304411,
0.4072878063,
-0.5588895679,
0.0823651701,
0.6049044132,
0.3641922176,
-0.2762459517,
-0.2928346694,
-0.7446264625,
0.0426316261,
-0.2623161376,
0.0006194595,
-0.3287111819,
0.084865734,
0.4950584769,
0.5012791753,
-0.6806949377,
0.2798985541,
-0.4041988552,
-0.3738916814,
0.6582853198,
-0.0100716669,
0.3696860075,
0.0344784409,
-0.1412172019,
-0.2520313561,
-0.4418304265,
-0.2750786245,
0.5363408327,
0.5487492085,
0.1100488156,
0.3932082653,
-0.1521702111,
0.615666151,
0.0085406192,
-0.0231830105,
0.1813487411,
-0.0884804726,
-0.1511842608,
0.452560097,
0.6533205509,
-0.0442362987,
0.0972622558,
-0.2348044515,
-0.248999849,
0.5249117017,
0.1931793541,
-0.4071782231,
-0.5974502563,
-0.1794161499,
0.1570617408,
-0.1810956746,
-0.2411292642,
-0.6501238346,
-0.9318858981,
-0.403449297,
0.4256470799,
-0.6961139441,
-0.0824736133,
-0.0890515521,
-0.0068822321,
-0.2894421816,
0.2258242369,
-0.8351963758,
0.1538203508,
0.3938550651,
0.9156652689,
0.1797205359,
-0.2165111154,
-0.8068144917,
-0.0587553121,
-0.2337755859,
0.6082673669,
-0.1554756463,
-0.4500048757,
-0.0139261018,
-0.2303758264,
-0.0576686077,
-0.7067762613,
0.5357894897,
-0.2851708531,
-0.2352549881,
-0.1845145375,
-0.2225130498,
0.0449237153,
0.0229027104,
-0.8753175139,
0.6057987809,
0.0331193544,
-0.6664747596,
0.3709293008,
-0.3491837382,
-0.7993988395,
0.191587314,
-0.071605593,
-0.7939402461,
-0.0812721252,
0.3145533204,
0.0366138145,
0.1166010275,
0.2471159995,
-0.0240881164,
-0.5299574733,
0.353995353,
-0.8214204311,
0.8330289125,
0.2789610624,
-0.4377449453,
0.0459728241,
-1.2015554905,
-0.2395210564,
0.120256409,
-0.4412287474,
-0.4806060791,
-0.0344018899,
-0.0545090698,
0.1019092128,
-0.1960314512,
-0.5599443913,
0.2821772695,
-0.8588041663,
0.5210315585,
0.6623911858,
-0.2108191252,
0.3053830564,
-0.3979954422,
0.202821672,
0.3222795427,
-0.0795572624,
0.114753142,
-0.1510846317,
-0.9168216586,
-0.510823667,
0.4433410466,
0.4020885825,
-1.3251622915,
0.1993180811,
-0.1576230675,
-0.4627264142,
-0.8671038151,
0.0062556709,
0.8269053698,
0.6693412662,
0.6426001191,
-0.1872991472,
-0.7063408494,
-0.642891109,
-0.1383278519,
-0.289632231,
0.0508255139,
-0.1611245722,
0.3110700548,
-0.2323891371,
0.6038674712,
-0.4592193663,
-0.7625642419,
-0.0024439499,
0.5707717538,
-0.2994102836,
0.5268040895,
0.19885014,
-0.8950644135,
-0.5353942513,
-0.2867737114,
-0.0720489174,
-0.1172202975,
-0.1025708765,
0.1280737072,
0.7243876457,
0.3729830384,
-0.5352500677,
0.4581977427,
0.5395137668,
-0.0785540193,
0.3392364085,
-0.2458823472,
0.3320955932,
-1.0649832487,
0.0578148291,
-0.0424533188,
-0.2568925023,
-0.6166417599,
-0.3181299269,
-0.0366767794,
-0.2070464492,
-0.4322369993,
0.1598259211,
-0.3239532113,
0.2178317606,
-0.2385985702,
0.1591302454,
-0.1043815613,
0.40167889,
-0.0661327317,
0.819398582,
0.2486308515,
-0.5241652727,
0.5143685341,
0.5250555277,
-0.1705412269,
0.5162903666,
-0.3546002805,
0.1687323898,
-0.1823273301,
0.1221931577,
-1.1929938793,
-0.3054538071,
0.3001099825,
-0.6112133265,
0.6774230003,
-0.2845500708,
-0.397048682,
-0.319996208,
0.0164164305,
0.2256173342,
0.4457975328,
-0.813514173,
0.0744606107,
0.4491165876,
-0.0456459858,
-0.7490909696,
-1.009075284,
-0.0454660505,
-0.173950538,
-0.2783836126,
0.5527797937,
-0.0384191647,
-0.1565645635,
-0.0645423979,
-0.2358465791,
-0.2440334707,
0.1953693628,
0.2944819331,
0.1191959679,
0.1562374085,
0.2489573658,
-0.2805587649,
-0.0165869687,
-0.2324303687,
0.2415044606,
0.4969043434,
-0.0173010938,
-0.3983825445,
-0.4264740348,
0.1892321855,
0.3483072817,
-0.2156920284,
0.6587538123,
0.6634661555,
-0.6162088513,
-0.4248615503,
-0.3612524569,
-0.0843104422,
-0.4536002278,
0.5645565391,
-0.1642002016,
-0.5361175537,
0.4711070955,
-0.0567494743,
-0.3159373999,
0.3465510607,
0.3507820368,
-0.068252869,
1.1238275766,
0.4073200822,
-0.4460199177,
0.4679782391,
-0.2211323977,
0.3158400953,
-0.5145897269,
-0.0587534383,
-0.5567392111,
-0.304189831,
-0.4771306515,
-0.4791603684,
0.2491701543,
0.1410292685,
0.002801771,
0.3873643875,
-0.7241638303,
0.4550038278,
0.3751319945,
0.2036443502,
0.2790884078,
-0.0509634502,
0.2370937914,
-0.2361777425,
-0.5735602975,
-0.2057978362,
0.4499985576,
0.2010963261,
0.8338076472,
0.358484447,
0.6033633351,
0.4607184529,
0.1238820106,
-0.9136794209,
0.3195801377,
-0.5645919442,
-0.4105458856,
-0.4117354155,
-0.5987715721,
-0.690544486,
0.0938962623,
-0.1574572176,
-0.429281652,
0.1527529806,
0.5435297489,
-0.4296045601,
0.3216170073,
-0.7488166094,
0.5826762915,
-0.0372611769,
-0.1254425496,
-0.1621952206,
-0.6681363583,
0.3397631049,
-0.1390473396,
0.0574132465,
0.0691733956,
0.4397105575,
0.623790741,
-0.4849788845,
0.8453682661,
-0.4072476625,
-0.0382869951,
0.1452767998,
-0.0680318549,
0.6545051932,
-0.105275616,
0.0179472622,
0.2019983679,
-0.232956633,
-0.0950402096,
-0.6183882356,
0.5490754247,
-0.6639680266,
-0.4940138757,
-0.7743680477,
-0.5775947571,
-0.3869075775,
-0.1435760409,
0.2879777253,
0.3904898763,
-0.3017097116,
-0.0346391164,
0.7405183911,
-0.1672177762,
0.6140778065,
0.7575854063,
0.4273859262,
-0.3358274698,
1.1121336222,
0.2837609947,
0.1579396576,
0.2166806459,
-0.1083648354,
-0.3826806545,
-0.4977169037,
-0.6474044323,
0.0614460558,
-0.7063289881,
-0.5779219866,
-0.3857906163,
-0.4348803461,
-0.5067801476,
-0.0222723354,
-0.5703073144,
-0.4706677496,
-0.3874950409,
0.1431037635,
0.3946793377,
0.6106159091,
-0.1993284523,
0.4194751978,
-0.6168279052,
0.4644452333,
0.1658198684,
0.2189775705,
-0.2801290452,
-0.7768213749,
-0.2806100547,
0.5516149402,
-0.4465025067,
-0.5643544793,
0.6086959243,
0.4928339124,
0.1650148183,
-0.0242043734,
0.3698801696,
1.1856951714,
-0.8845463991,
0.6121439338,
0.3053972125,
-1.0104801655,
0.6417652369,
0.0668129399,
0.1730243564,
0.5019637942,
0.4426676035,
-0.4962643683,
-0.3331905901,
-0.3797964752,
-0.9159656763,
0.9453207254,
0.1321609616,
-0.0400909707,
-0.0582534224,
0.195955947,
-0.2642512619,
0.0269477163,
-0.3650497794,
-0.3230008781,
-0.2305741906,
-0.3099434674,
-0.2671255171,
-0.1590962708,
-0.4342885315,
-0.1807802916,
0.9914839864,
-0.0318200365,
-0.0423913337,
0.2958543301,
-0.2877480686,
-0.2943674624,
0.3502438664,
0.6715608239,
0.1387311518,
0.0373060778,
0.1123021469,
0.2386807948,
-0.5263752341,
0.4979644418,
0.6227475405,
0.0983585492,
0.111906141,
0.0177811105,
0.7760823369,
-0.0991093889,
-0.6194786429,
0.5742628574,
-0.3194594681,
-0.0543574393,
-0.3268738389,
-0.0431524999,
-0.1402415782,
0.2542667389,
0.1256060749,
0.4709668458,
0.3014301658,
-0.4424737692,
0.4350072145,
0.4474665523,
-0.4860120714,
-0.1042833552,
0.7983060479,
0.1486330479,
-0.3932743669,
0.6317185163,
-0.4626958966,
-0.5773768425,
0.4036362469,
0.4976243675,
0.5278705359,
-0.6861804724,
0.1741101593,
0.229565233,
0.1797409207,
-0.1405145973,
0.0060064429,
0.2112297565,
-0.5533657074,
-0.3404596746,
-0.7535938025,
-0.3805410266,
0.282045722,
-0.6927604675,
0.3844366074,
-0.4001146257,
-0.1237364411,
0.3181130886,
-0.1024906263,
-0.2787432373,
0.3697623014,
0.341447413,
0.3022563756,
-1.0153119564,
1.0134198666,
0.6795120239,
-0.5961984396,
-0.8090106845,
0.207882598,
0.4057973921,
-0.7194381356,
0.7197872996,
0.025464043,
-0.3452275097,
0.0965836719,
-0.0586974286,
-0.7177017331,
0.7553238273,
0.4940793812,
-0.9209236503,
0.1788588166,
0.3165276349,
0.8044499755,
0.2380422503,
-0.2031300515,
0.5445489287,
-0.0812799782,
0.298541218,
-0.9750518799,
0.0053483495,
-0.3371941447,
0.1204295456,
0.3025427759,
-0.6189883947,
0.6357485652,
-0.0382553823,
-0.5126176476,
0.0389335677,
0.4747338593,
0.0063645421,
0.0515268631,
0.6451167464,
0.7139568329,
0.8548486829,
-0.3247005641,
0.7309509516,
-0.1028912663,
0.173715204,
1.2931486368,
-0.2278985083,
0.5894073844,
0.3704149127,
-0.1857496351,
0.0044913082,
0.2837583423,
0.0395642035,
0.641898334,
0.5804612637,
-0.439563632,
0.2172890007,
-0.3729271293,
-0.1787281632,
0.6163032055,
0.2749853134,
-0.0595104918,
-0.0220937561,
0.3492989838,
-0.0049986024,
0.5207691193,
-0.2412840128,
1.0059254169,
-0.1273955256,
-0.5117865205,
1.1247458458,
0.0108118188,
0.7973499894,
-0.4871079028,
-0.199550122,
-0.2741469145,
0.6240282655,
-0.1624183804,
-0.3673297167,
0.8151000142,
0.1959865391,
-0.3711188436,
-0.119490236,
0.4647917151,
-0.7953165174,
-0.15002428,
0.243555814,
-0.1696425229,
-0.0046857568,
-0.1336643845,
-0.5413742661,
0.1361560225,
-0.0550627671,
0.1083665639,
0.4237342775,
0.3392677307,
0.0914304331,
0.4491142333,
0.3962188959,
0.3949942291,
-0.002681368,
0.3657301068,
1.0800642967,
-0.2462602556,
-0.319195658,
-0.8461812139,
0.6609852314,
-0.0962528363,
-0.1319905221,
0.511023283,
0.4365811646,
1.1100461483,
0.0103662955,
0.8325690031,
-0.1430026591,
0.6454207301,
-0.4378390014,
0.9325948954,
-0.4640729427,
0.3740714192,
-0.2308981717,
-0.4587984383,
-0.3785567582,
0.7031536698,
-0.0986929685,
-0.3014356792,
0.5199324489,
1.0578228235,
0.0820917636,
-0.1135483533,
0.4636805356,
0.3176153898,
0.3030850291,
0.5136994123,
0.7676095366,
-0.6491601467,
0.8284621835,
-0.5541785359,
-0.2107804418,
-0.0975233167,
-0.4421709776,
-0.7756470442,
-0.7306646109,
-0.6097742915,
-0.4853624701,
0.4305357337,
0.8437269926,
0.4005282521,
-0.9696874022,
0.2773108184,
-0.2049247622,
-0.0657689646,
-0.2902187705,
-0.179918319,
0.2567814887,
-0.4299079478,
-0.8494431376,
0.7038725615,
-0.0352916233,
0.3102366924,
-0.084675923,
-0.0051922719,
-0.3704866469,
-0.1323878318,
0.2794207633,
0.3079198897,
-0.6341536641,
-0.3036883473,
-0.4766514003,
-0.3458558321,
0.1134989932,
0.6553416252,
-0.5362416506,
0.7399139404,
0.2976754904,
0.7621194124,
0.0474310145,
0.2292259634,
0.378733784,
-1.3555281162,
0.4388906956,
0.4333076775,
0.4067007601,
0.7225444913,
-0.5582837462,
0.4605183899,
0.4591579437,
-0.5879889727,
-1.0848573446,
0.1459981054,
-0.6224848628,
-0.290523231,
1.1169377565,
-0.3496162593,
0.0145850237,
-0.135492757,
-0.5213288665,
0.8742110133,
-0.1993146688,
1.16928792,
0.668541193,
0.0563603453,
0.0889680609,
-0.0503405295,
0.9991444349,
0.4169879258,
-0.4289903939,
0.3484743834,
0.5602589846,
0.0621443875,
0.2813512683,
0.4974892437,
-0.0581275336,
0.0731415972,
0.2515090406,
0.0178632867,
-0.2665814757,
-0.3508919179,
-0.8296883106,
-0.2909228802,
0.1103766486,
-0.4323110878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06381v1 | INK: Injecting kNN Knowledge in Nearest Neighbor Machine Translation | 2023-06-10T08:39:16 | 2023-06-10T08:39:16 | Wenhao Zhu, Jingjing Xu, Shujian Huang, Lingpeng Kong, Jiajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural machine translation has achieved promising results on many translation
tasks. However, previous studies have shown that neural models induce a
non-smooth representation space, which harms its generalization results.
Recently, kNN-MT has provided an effective paradigm to smooth the prediction
based on neighbor representations during inference. Despite promising results,
kNN-MT usually requires large inference overhead. We propose an effective
training framework INK to directly smooth the representation space via
adjusting representations of kNN neighbors with a small number of new
parameters. The new parameters are then used to refresh the whole
representation datastore to get new kNN knowledge asynchronously. This loop
keeps running until convergence. Experiments on four benchmark datasets show
that \method achieves average gains of 1.99 COMET and 1.0 BLEU, outperforming
the state-of-the-art kNN-MT system with 0.02x memory space and 1.9x inference
speedup. | [
-0.0680802241,
-0.3688955307,
0.6996899843,
-0.1986301541,
-0.4624668658,
-0.1527071148,
-0.5277181268,
-0.3320475519,
0.3618896306,
0.5804449916,
-0.1156446859,
-0.445373863,
-0.7555906773,
0.0676819012,
0.0651142672,
0.6691501737,
-0.0092434483,
0.1381738782,
-0.1317830384,
-0.29881531,
-0.3036531508,
-0.0941545293,
-0.8069295883,
-0.4742349982,
0.7536206841,
0.5339313745,
0.8196895123,
1.2107889652,
0.3857945502,
0.4087485075,
-0.1207191199,
0.1884221584,
-0.3790504932,
0.1674456,
0.2241592407,
-0.8295527101,
-0.2417375147,
-0.2140441388,
0.7703875899,
0.9669891596,
0.1668462306,
-0.2142883837,
-0.1383524239,
0.9228659868,
-0.4249448478,
0.0475790165,
-0.7575047016,
0.2007143199,
-0.4135816693,
0.1953650117,
-0.373460412,
-0.3469786346,
0.2063174546,
-1.0620782375,
0.1449128687,
0.1357925981,
0.953564167,
0.3108363748,
-0.3254818618,
-0.0367491543,
-0.4887575805,
0.7115154862,
-0.9748889208,
0.5438491702,
0.5691466928,
0.3262387216,
-0.4197775126,
-0.9101825356,
-0.4345596433,
-0.3847247064,
0.0690313652,
0.3733857274,
0.4835968614,
0.0086714961,
0.3512471616,
0.2114886791,
-0.016994819,
-0.0326378755,
-0.127332285,
-0.0623436868,
0.1609667242,
-0.0152887022,
-0.1484024078,
-0.0977402925,
-0.2464247495,
-0.028016137,
-0.4674553573,
-0.1735374182,
0.451557368,
0.475476414,
-0.0213852562,
0.3070144355,
-0.3406474888,
0.6907376647,
0.1123874262,
0.025182832,
0.27314955,
0.0858445019,
-0.1041387618,
-0.0364976861,
0.8717342019,
0.4779936671,
0.0651517287,
-0.624019742,
-0.2207417786,
-0.3922678232,
0.4230726361,
-0.8700369596,
-0.3903297782,
0.0603015311,
-0.4206830859,
-0.1200589985,
-0.1034494862,
-0.8672499061,
-0.4520078003,
-0.4575296938,
0.3325976431,
-0.6623055935,
-0.4291692674,
-0.2144060135,
-0.1484908462,
-0.2564943433,
0.3016357422,
-0.7059819698,
0.0259409361,
0.5530615449,
1.1151747704,
-0.1249455735,
-0.2938922346,
-0.383823514,
0.0822559148,
-0.6372816563,
0.5742684603,
-0.4646473229,
-0.14302212,
0.1774241328,
-0.060886912,
0.0824852735,
-0.7826105356,
0.121171467,
-0.6250126362,
-0.1121831313,
-0.5471630096,
-0.7433553934,
-0.0391416699,
0.1613046378,
-0.5383628607,
1.0357830524,
0.3650936186,
-0.6154358983,
0.5840308666,
-0.6053828597,
-0.3220122457,
-0.1049136668,
0.1960785985,
-0.6726199389,
0.2325230986,
0.2083604634,
0.4308809936,
0.2658692896,
-0.134140119,
-0.5110551715,
-0.5229853392,
0.2480565459,
0.1639761776,
0.3387590051,
0.2912170589,
-0.2956130803,
-0.0917586312,
-0.5999190211,
-0.1554808319,
-0.0778519362,
-0.2153669596,
-0.5174811482,
-0.4948823452,
-0.3077659011,
-0.0407886915,
0.1916734278,
-0.6985231638,
0.4322881103,
-0.7152289152,
0.3157146573,
0.7422889471,
-0.093558915,
1.0155587196,
-0.22749722,
0.1837753803,
0.3201724589,
-0.1448756903,
-0.1191505194,
-0.7939184308,
-0.8951767683,
0.0172996297,
0.8401979208,
0.1056790426,
-1.2833528519,
-0.0039613931,
-0.6102947593,
-0.3195365369,
-0.7129237652,
0.1402276158,
0.3832671046,
0.743134141,
0.3308599889,
-0.232278049,
-0.10319525,
-0.5874881148,
-0.3506999612,
0.2993260324,
-0.1852787286,
0.2209812254,
0.297080934,
0.0442324392,
0.596599102,
-0.1976356357,
-0.3034245968,
0.1587967128,
0.3212324381,
0.4931743741,
0.5574764013,
0.2217199057,
-0.6674348116,
-0.8200285435,
0.3287236094,
-0.4981016517,
-0.0624508932,
-0.2373048514,
-0.4989199936,
0.2150698751,
0.5435093641,
-0.4346075058,
0.5142273307,
0.1221817359,
-0.0892228484,
0.2853138745,
-0.4162303209,
0.2765138745,
-1.2106307745,
0.0319929533,
-0.3179589808,
-0.5900246501,
-0.5218821168,
0.1546034068,
0.2659548819,
0.0744480714,
-0.3437808156,
0.5088840723,
-0.4438836277,
-0.1891711354,
-0.5174259543,
0.2995884717,
0.0143677033,
0.6506847739,
-0.0354607962,
0.7691820264,
0.166037187,
-0.6928585768,
0.0765029564,
0.0525289513,
-0.205359593,
0.3365273774,
-0.2213651091,
0.5845655799,
-0.0162061509,
0.0388788804,
-0.7029122114,
-0.0360667668,
0.3401370943,
-0.570644021,
0.7516214252,
-0.6187133789,
-0.5911331773,
-0.2897741795,
-0.0254217405,
0.1640168726,
0.6401901841,
-0.577362895,
0.7690898776,
-0.0156133436,
0.1988853812,
-0.6743267179,
-0.9122003317,
0.1649209559,
-0.0766602308,
-0.271484226,
0.3435299397,
0.3237991929,
0.1551090628,
0.0987371877,
-0.15928635,
-0.1922521144,
-0.1936865449,
0.2648259997,
-0.2574116886,
-0.288472265,
0.0403326787,
0.2041075081,
-0.4512498975,
-0.125260517,
-0.8272129297,
0.1809586734,
0.2232879251,
-0.104213804,
-0.3605876863,
0.215794608,
0.5304509401,
0.1831680834,
0.7029311657,
0.6955786347,
-0.1727480888,
-0.0036399409,
-0.4759834409,
-0.2979933918,
-0.50244385,
0.5115255713,
-0.6119155288,
-0.5924885869,
0.7731822729,
-0.6144214272,
-0.0239390861,
0.201430887,
0.3020535409,
-0.335831821,
0.6449226141,
0.3836238086,
-0.1039549634,
0.5584415197,
-0.5931500196,
0.1768284887,
-1.0801868439,
-0.0888054073,
-0.3417393863,
-0.7171208262,
-0.3363759816,
-0.7527401447,
0.1201555282,
0.3053303063,
-0.1252543181,
0.3973154426,
-0.4661634564,
0.4883958101,
0.7657916546,
0.2738780379,
-0.0010487955,
0.0511050075,
-0.8900262117,
-0.4949346185,
-0.8879196644,
-0.1303811222,
1.1603696346,
0.1538439542,
0.1720586717,
-0.0890456215,
0.7216737866,
-0.0690894797,
0.6772208214,
-0.6081038713,
0.4397431016,
-0.376047641,
-0.2891583443,
-0.1156270579,
-0.6657343507,
-0.9081180692,
-0.0210469086,
-0.0909147933,
-0.5559717417,
0.0993923396,
0.378752172,
-0.0908913463,
0.8300176859,
-0.7076907158,
0.627276659,
0.2636339664,
-0.5492699742,
0.0412898101,
-0.9166113734,
-0.027585566,
-0.0824310929,
-0.1235132888,
-0.0023308494,
-0.3045397699,
0.5207268,
-0.7122570872,
0.5184409022,
-0.5822095871,
0.2694843709,
0.1478272527,
0.1986840069,
0.5878807902,
-0.0290585328,
-0.44519642,
0.3856406808,
-0.5515069962,
-0.4718248248,
-1.0529316664,
0.6623805761,
-0.6499838829,
-0.1545220613,
-0.1110240966,
-0.7619748116,
-0.216886133,
0.5264897346,
0.5738191009,
0.3889006972,
0.4987987876,
-0.0044148196,
0.679256916,
-0.0496875718,
0.3210983574,
0.3376201093,
-0.369023025,
-0.8818601966,
1.0388537645,
0.3267777264,
0.3821350336,
0.5320106745,
0.3388742208,
-0.4312780797,
-0.747464776,
-0.8409389257,
0.2410251349,
-0.6502864361,
-0.5313107371,
-0.5984261632,
0.1112681627,
-0.3278636634,
-0.2503427267,
-0.7197310925,
-0.5113867521,
0.0229147244,
0.3077962101,
0.6561398506,
0.9324373007,
-0.0981794894,
0.8652060032,
-0.6525995135,
0.2819698453,
0.0076295459,
0.6276123524,
0.1556030065,
-0.6918756366,
-0.7392733097,
0.3368046284,
-0.1312024146,
-0.6570032239,
0.2571537793,
0.0855375826,
0.0561609492,
0.4454433024,
-0.0274493396,
1.0297631025,
-0.8761962056,
0.6925504208,
0.1314648241,
-0.6327816844,
0.2187630385,
-0.4752661586,
0.6761094332,
0.7346553206,
0.3679952919,
-0.4766894281,
-0.7062628865,
-0.5132137537,
-0.8365713954,
0.4838590324,
0.2301800549,
0.1791934818,
0.18204014,
1.0796364546,
0.1019584015,
0.1591278613,
-0.300114274,
-0.4778105617,
-0.2465052754,
-0.1620658487,
0.2960745692,
-0.0519960485,
0.371604234,
-0.4078677297,
0.7970815897,
-0.15496324,
0.8925672174,
0.418305397,
0.0955091491,
-0.1510635167,
-0.416103214,
0.6061398387,
0.4082117081,
-0.1456776261,
0.0404298864,
0.4628329575,
-0.6926649213,
-0.1673488319,
0.0390456133,
-0.2690638304,
0.3043652773,
0.2010085434,
0.6006728411,
0.2142946124,
0.1958314776,
0.4582472742,
-0.0365474783,
-0.3890393376,
-0.010770807,
-0.2046281993,
0.2816305161,
0.0614635497,
0.0730059966,
0.5315696597,
0.0752065331,
0.0965065584,
0.3384341002,
-0.0553408936,
-0.556193471,
-0.1037209257,
0.7567132711,
-0.0978610739,
-0.380756259,
0.7771918774,
-0.4942807555,
-0.7298256159,
0.395106405,
0.6245191097,
0.715331614,
-0.1572062671,
-0.2174413949,
0.5774196982,
0.1159107611,
0.1197222471,
0.1701346785,
0.0413674489,
-0.5436595082,
-0.7464418411,
-0.469635576,
-0.3063346148,
-0.0027247202,
-0.3298675716,
0.0911439732,
-0.3613650799,
-0.4275766909,
-0.2830177844,
0.0814449117,
-0.4693907201,
0.0705714673,
-0.0407965742,
0.8598778248,
-0.4239219129,
1.0269453526,
0.7321844697,
-0.2244849056,
-0.8860121369,
0.0318640172,
-0.3736981452,
-0.6123349071,
0.6131800413,
0.206238687,
0.0651480258,
-0.0604553595,
-0.4588378668,
-0.6617722511,
0.7959468365,
0.5135406852,
-0.5819627643,
0.2870637178,
0.4922030568,
0.4106946886,
-0.3333815038,
0.2024708539,
0.1437195539,
0.4871051908,
0.1768332273,
-0.4781490564,
-0.0850311816,
-0.2871930599,
0.3912983835,
0.5221606493,
-0.5246462226,
0.3713920712,
-0.1451016366,
0.1835247874,
0.4530302882,
1.0308617353,
-0.1297051311,
0.3129219115,
0.508564353,
1.0735160112,
0.7845770121,
-0.2676445246,
1.1574393511,
-0.3074385524,
-0.0679941103,
1.3896514177,
0.1517145932,
0.7806611657,
0.5209450126,
0.0041922671,
0.4306460917,
0.5386732221,
0.1851423085,
0.6096151471,
0.3240609467,
-0.1598364413,
-0.0549124777,
-0.137530759,
-0.3161270022,
0.0581172928,
0.2784381509,
-0.3530570865,
0.173703149,
0.1143617406,
0.2862606049,
0.2174851745,
-0.1512211859,
0.7364445925,
0.2392575592,
-0.5964000225,
0.3088659942,
-0.1716521382,
0.6093299389,
-0.5827223659,
-0.3404405117,
-0.3515248895,
0.2394004762,
0.1092871651,
-0.4416263103,
0.335855037,
-0.4728601873,
-0.0937825292,
-0.1985832304,
0.7895178199,
-0.754190743,
-0.3238446712,
0.0713850558,
0.0252217706,
0.385532707,
-0.1107869223,
-0.7685990334,
-0.1368640959,
0.0058714799,
0.0324713849,
0.254950285,
0.9872732162,
0.3740819395,
0.6041801572,
0.7693480849,
0.3757425845,
0.4476243854,
0.0970871076,
0.8165799975,
-0.2839915752,
-0.4545923471,
-0.5225979686,
0.5773468018,
-0.409807384,
-0.3965030611,
0.7955321074,
0.5449597836,
0.5865564346,
-0.0652007684,
0.1531726271,
0.1668374687,
0.4626660049,
-0.5021830797,
1.1345603466,
-0.5208570361,
-0.0692221895,
-0.1608645171,
-0.9567369819,
-0.413923353,
0.66305691,
-0.3880923986,
0.1784710735,
0.7420639992,
0.7620761991,
-0.166761741,
-0.0417700931,
0.510340929,
0.2024371773,
0.0191079043,
0.3580566645,
0.6052203178,
-0.8663675189,
0.3327198029,
-0.7719838023,
0.0956816524,
0.0440526418,
-1.1222183704,
-0.784276545,
-0.6038426757,
-0.5275048018,
-0.6461086869,
0.1332122386,
0.68184793,
1.0632276535,
-0.6581360102,
0.0943428203,
-0.2784871459,
0.3061144054,
-0.2470231056,
-0.2094727606,
0.3815747499,
-0.707308352,
-0.7728614807,
0.1486034691,
0.1668137014,
-0.0497553013,
0.2517267466,
-0.2698970735,
-0.1508763433,
-0.564532876,
0.1478613764,
-0.1121175289,
-0.6162794232,
-0.1347305179,
0.000834655,
0.0942584649,
0.3273704648,
0.8381687403,
-0.6975451112,
1.0759755373,
0.2292874157,
1.1544097662,
0.6129481196,
-0.3923970163,
0.845341146,
-1.0362118483,
0.2949414551,
0.2267222553,
0.3139249682,
0.4390253723,
-0.5964028239,
0.4518716335,
0.264413923,
-0.8679990768,
-0.474996537,
-0.0189453904,
-0.7186098099,
0.0210871622,
0.9118869901,
-0.4775012434,
-0.589644134,
-0.2375761718,
-0.0300208796,
0.6576361656,
-0.6763778329,
0.460347563,
0.4306483865,
0.2220326066,
0.0079956101,
-0.76164639,
0.5783512592,
0.633626163,
-0.2228040397,
-0.083712101,
-0.0715764835,
0.1561816633,
0.327391088,
0.4864493012,
-0.0989815965,
0.0955959558,
0.1460486203,
-0.0430285819,
-0.3973229527,
-0.2039551139,
-0.1937531978,
-0.3643464744,
0.1003156528,
-0.2498161495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06371v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06371v1 | A Comprehensive Review of State-of-The-Art Methods for Java Code Generation from Natural Language Text | 2023-06-10T07:27:51 | 2023-06-10T07:27:51 | Jessica López Espejel, Mahaman Sanoussi Yahaya Alassan, El Mehdi Chouham, Walid Dahhane, El Hassane Ettifouri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Java Code Generation consists in generating automatically Java code from a
Natural Language Text. This NLP task helps in increasing programmers'
productivity by providing them with immediate solutions to the simplest and
most repetitive tasks. Code generation is a challenging task because of the
hard syntactic rules and the necessity of a deep understanding of the semantic
aspect of the programming language. Many works tried to tackle this task using
either RNN-based, or Transformer-based models. The latter achieved remarkable
advancement in the domain and they can be divided into three groups: (1)
encoder-only models, (2) decoder-only models, and (3) encoder-decoder models.
In this paper, we provide a comprehensive review of the evolution and progress
of deep learning models in Java code generation task. We focus on the most
important methods and present their merits and limitations, as well as the
objective functions used by the community. In addition, we provide a detailed
description of datasets and evaluation metrics used in the literature. Finally,
we discuss results of different models on CONCODE dataset, then propose some
future directions. | [
-0.2984535992,
-0.7044178247,
0.1469740272,
-0.0351212583,
-0.1352211982,
0.0398697108,
-0.2794914842,
-0.714153409,
-0.3798374534,
0.9228261709,
-0.4520340562,
-0.5746400356,
-0.6619452238,
0.310226053,
-0.6043727398,
1.1771000624,
-0.0572138689,
-0.0826056153,
-0.2379478067,
0.2478676736,
-0.5792143941,
-0.3456860185,
-0.5171927214,
-0.2148853093,
-0.3037951589,
0.1648543328,
0.4512252212,
0.3962425888,
0.9206065536,
0.278929621,
-0.0750877708,
0.1835110337,
-0.2397622168,
0.3197270632,
0.1461163461,
-0.3437788785,
-0.0742726997,
-0.2285755426,
0.3146155179,
0.8369112015,
-0.0229996443,
0.4055452049,
0.0286218673,
0.7904878259,
-0.710308075,
0.3328090608,
-0.6880884171,
0.2706623375,
-0.0343285762,
-0.1056579351,
-0.6073159575,
-0.6449498534,
0.0303745363,
-0.3009291589,
0.421135962,
-0.3122337162,
0.5340527892,
0.3299597502,
-0.5576786995,
-0.9904239178,
-1.2049343586,
0.9826912284,
-1.0410122871,
0.0698118508,
-0.0589005165,
0.3233113289,
-0.4229845107,
-0.8314765692,
-0.5114315748,
-0.620385766,
0.1776836663,
0.1720203906,
-0.0759641603,
0.0682580322,
0.309884429,
0.7581371665,
-0.6082268953,
-0.0869925916,
-0.4131423235,
0.3412983716,
0.7060394883,
0.1853177249,
0.4188787937,
-0.4743932188,
-0.2144340873,
0.0272664744,
-0.4580052793,
0.1082447991,
0.1624855399,
0.2643600404,
0.023778528,
0.5693550706,
-0.3159089386,
1.0947034359,
-0.1912391335,
-0.220081374,
-0.0344470255,
-0.5043597817,
-0.4388757348,
-0.1786875576,
0.5878753066,
0.221247673,
0.4193277359,
-0.2500609457,
-0.0726532415,
0.4509230852,
0.4395675361,
-0.7610477805,
-0.2436873913,
0.1082696468,
-0.7032960653,
-0.5948765278,
0.0333263949,
-0.6229757071,
-0.2613128424,
-0.5762223601,
-0.1692207307,
-0.4115146399,
-0.4445254803,
0.5136777163,
-0.1018798947,
0.3822173178,
0.0593999363,
-0.6753305793,
0.2303182632,
0.7325280309,
0.3554894328,
-0.0204032511,
0.1370025277,
0.0976767391,
-0.0361243486,
-0.302106142,
0.2838817239,
-0.6722667217,
-0.2936044335,
0.2401746809,
-0.3067258,
0.1557168365,
-0.3355672657,
0.5071851015,
-0.5378221869,
0.2907222509,
0.1734911352,
-0.9239531159,
-0.3156496882,
0.0686224997,
-0.6635577083,
0.950186193,
0.0852293223,
-0.7919887304,
0.442492187,
-0.7303953171,
-0.5306575298,
0.1805885583,
-0.0191335306,
-0.5154104829,
0.3940041363,
0.2296729088,
0.5893143415,
-0.5010491014,
0.623801887,
0.1496067792,
-0.1773291081,
0.3715304732,
-0.3712412417,
1.0568233728,
0.4419546723,
-0.4275636673,
-0.1912939698,
-0.9470111132,
0.0949179903,
0.4024995565,
-0.3245010972,
-0.1235721037,
-0.0049601188,
-0.2074581981,
0.2027821541,
-0.0009826678,
-0.7639002204,
0.238923192,
-0.4016788304,
0.3468352854,
0.1074584872,
0.3555906117,
0.3708471656,
0.0027931067,
0.5911741257,
-0.2993212044,
0.4586192369,
-0.5047237873,
-0.5533108711,
-0.7439562678,
0.1735990644,
0.2519484162,
0.4241850972,
-0.7019324899,
0.5794535875,
-0.2956353426,
-0.7252233624,
-0.6215211153,
0.2139411122,
0.4946732819,
0.441147387,
0.3984705508,
-0.3738482893,
-0.7047236562,
-0.5323704481,
-0.2114320397,
0.0785112083,
0.1387270242,
-0.0025969255,
0.3844861388,
-0.3563435674,
0.9622911215,
-0.4177313745,
0.2183333039,
-0.6792561412,
0.0846786946,
0.3393501043,
0.7150745988,
0.1653977036,
-0.6877005696,
-0.3070759177,
0.0821330696,
-0.8470473289,
0.242302835,
-0.5098893046,
-0.0598826297,
0.1944831759,
0.5456171036,
-0.4838211834,
0.5782705545,
0.5975693464,
0.0935780331,
0.2799205482,
-0.0415960029,
0.0034138167,
-1.1039161682,
0.2645067871,
0.2101768404,
-0.0862774923,
-0.8509532809,
0.7846614718,
0.0290053077,
-0.4081816375,
-0.2682283521,
0.1168904379,
-0.4604799449,
0.0317675099,
-0.5471399426,
-0.2067711055,
0.1833582669,
0.4363981485,
0.0544099957,
0.3104094267,
0.3903014958,
-0.8180801868,
0.7245478034,
0.1041927338,
-0.5442812443,
-0.2062196434,
-0.568472445,
0.296000272,
-0.1882116348,
0.3540081978,
-0.6522097588,
-0.053533677,
0.043635577,
-0.3634363413,
0.4906808734,
-0.3214911222,
-0.3495807052,
-0.8278680444,
0.082308352,
0.2685500681,
0.7589740753,
-0.4284704328,
0.0720830783,
0.3081452847,
0.0694996119,
-0.4069293439,
-0.755069077,
0.1856931001,
0.1133013144,
-0.5995285511,
0.3516032398,
0.1799561232,
-0.0258799754,
-0.0879381001,
-0.0108903451,
-0.0181995071,
0.1204534918,
0.1673670113,
0.206919387,
-0.1732364297,
-0.0619857423,
-0.0777206346,
-0.3641040027,
0.1141557395,
-0.4868194163,
0.3637925386,
-0.0661394969,
-0.4487512708,
-0.3072706759,
0.3869139254,
0.1510753036,
-0.6114476919,
0.3933800757,
0.5537545681,
-0.2813870311,
-0.3777012825,
-0.4213446975,
0.0153720863,
-0.3671472073,
0.4611283839,
-0.1186539084,
-0.7590812445,
0.0723149106,
-0.5047118664,
0.3601609766,
0.3773650527,
0.5635355115,
0.1521746218,
0.8047044873,
1.0067446232,
0.2449986488,
0.2987876236,
-0.4078658521,
0.5627301335,
-0.5061953664,
-0.3312646151,
-0.6388350129,
0.0172880124,
-0.7374797463,
-0.2497808337,
-0.1135408506,
0.141250357,
-0.0829089209,
0.4582481086,
-1.0225619078,
0.6222822666,
0.5330194235,
-0.1443185061,
0.250718981,
-0.0621980205,
0.300106287,
0.059165325,
-0.6816675067,
-0.5322747827,
1.2381783724,
0.3219595551,
0.7246671915,
-0.1241230071,
0.8013278246,
0.2725432515,
0.0294270981,
-0.4614502788,
0.5904275775,
-0.4192461669,
-0.6601833105,
-0.1795087457,
-0.3661564589,
-1.0636024475,
-0.3092701733,
-0.1229984835,
-0.0553633943,
-0.0877771899,
-0.0399208143,
-0.3313487768,
0.2646179497,
-0.6538290977,
0.8654145002,
-0.1489397287,
0.0447321534,
0.0224033184,
-0.6104617119,
0.7556946278,
0.0802290291,
-0.0055305739,
0.059475448,
0.3407323062,
0.5410557389,
-0.3207841218,
0.7093542218,
-0.3556564152,
-0.1091876999,
0.7571819425,
0.1199854761,
0.551635921,
-0.1192074195,
-0.0913357139,
-0.0256820545,
-0.2226617336,
-0.3413157761,
-0.4176118374,
0.366966337,
-0.5115547776,
-0.2047354132,
-0.0427436158,
-0.2629987299,
-0.0016406865,
0.0789314508,
0.3967004418,
0.7446050644,
-0.1927006096,
0.1923381984,
0.656016171,
-0.5307572484,
0.7213405967,
0.024368098,
-0.3975633979,
-0.0395275727,
0.8179323673,
-0.1786358058,
0.2244855165,
0.4223056436,
-0.0856265202,
0.0341518298,
-0.8196947575,
-0.5433908701,
-0.2902444303,
-0.7640618086,
-0.4432793856,
-0.5248770714,
-0.4959860146,
-0.3173167706,
-0.3130115867,
-0.5156599283,
-0.3310290277,
0.1024748906,
-0.1162108704,
0.3080790937,
1.1241892576,
0.5199775696,
0.0405608155,
-0.8231930733,
0.3910610974,
0.1368107051,
0.3060443997,
0.2197864056,
-0.0720320493,
-0.4694290757,
-0.0330086574,
-0.1199416742,
-0.6829439998,
0.4069797695,
-0.0835184008,
0.2594668269,
-0.0846596882,
0.1613011211,
0.4298132658,
-0.2694873512,
0.951982379,
0.3295247257,
-0.8747376204,
0.8313677907,
-0.087680608,
0.44599545,
0.4714749157,
0.0749984831,
-0.5465212464,
-0.5517648458,
-0.4118278325,
-0.8872320652,
0.4400737286,
0.37683779,
0.5082576871,
-0.0789493993,
0.5188946128,
0.4703600705,
0.0051038796,
-0.9501334429,
-0.0073004421,
-0.3578927219,
-0.3610251248,
0.4707604647,
-0.1659095734,
0.264768064,
-0.1301162243,
0.4773156047,
-0.0946978256,
0.3411799371,
0.0853252485,
-0.3522121906,
0.0447482616,
0.3661391437,
0.4559244812,
0.4991876483,
-0.1035557166,
-0.2698067427,
0.0393126346,
-0.4616594613,
0.0292925239,
-0.0823001489,
-0.4564953744,
0.1340092868,
0.5211706758,
0.9904406667,
0.0026616538,
-0.5131707191,
0.6757696867,
-0.1948362589,
-0.1508494467,
-0.5818847418,
0.370999217,
-0.1615186781,
-0.1679909676,
0.2480034679,
0.4749060869,
0.2374181598,
-0.1790267378,
-0.0112648448,
0.3207474649,
-0.1520866305,
-0.0838167891,
0.3594474196,
0.5670439601,
-0.0255553797,
0.7487921715,
-0.4216910005,
-0.1506672353,
0.7997718453,
0.7752148509,
1.0656840801,
0.1628753245,
0.0806561187,
0.5741038322,
0.2951228321,
0.1969066858,
0.2218032479,
-0.0473392829,
-0.4819549918,
-1.0239369869,
-0.7897666693,
-0.2977495193,
0.1102482453,
-0.6937054992,
0.1396478266,
-0.5197644234,
-0.1792456806,
-0.1443960369,
0.1883274615,
-1.0297728777,
0.2922340631,
0.5772789717,
0.9145216942,
-0.6041653752,
0.758184135,
0.6156907082,
-0.4442259669,
-0.5477526188,
-0.0366332121,
-0.3553585112,
-0.417693615,
0.4899122417,
0.1680600941,
0.1048660874,
0.046345409,
-0.6190415025,
-0.8323862553,
0.8059001565,
0.162470445,
-0.6117519736,
-0.1976016313,
0.2775188982,
0.531319201,
-0.4580453336,
0.3213624656,
0.513913691,
0.2198600471,
-0.206966415,
-0.4593501985,
-0.038082812,
-0.5108287334,
0.5481529236,
0.3004704714,
-0.3187933266,
0.4188249409,
-0.0093907611,
-0.2514917254,
0.061630737,
0.6959984899,
0.0174539275,
0.0529982038,
0.0498561151,
0.3071654141,
0.6415678263,
0.032735344,
1.4842683077,
-0.5337523818,
0.2216971964,
0.8444122076,
-0.1704414785,
0.5869243741,
0.0359989814,
-0.3692496121,
0.6744434237,
0.2472038865,
-0.4011511207,
0.2260036916,
0.4248990417,
-0.0523448661,
-0.1275047809,
-0.0196951199,
-0.4641786814,
0.5217137933,
0.1133514643,
-0.3373093307,
-0.092903994,
0.1732558906,
-0.0403066762,
0.2408382595,
-0.1991951168,
1.0430777073,
-0.0268197581,
-0.8328825235,
0.3961774111,
0.4207131565,
0.7983814478,
-0.4894583523,
0.010623415,
-0.1883036643,
0.2381945401,
-0.3119245768,
-0.653436482,
0.5397772789,
0.3519333303,
-0.2720251381,
-0.1760173887,
1.0978213549,
-0.1684841067,
-0.7497332692,
0.1234372482,
0.333116442,
-0.1247140467,
0.2371547818,
-0.7516948581,
0.0348246917,
0.3251376748,
-0.2471645474,
-0.0219161734,
0.4067978561,
0.3218750656,
0.4230515957,
0.8815357089,
-0.1622626632,
0.5585243702,
0.2146107107,
0.5676319599,
-0.8705958128,
-0.2173871845,
-0.7203512788,
0.7095591426,
-0.1122544259,
-0.3894375563,
0.6776197553,
0.4703709483,
0.9992296696,
-0.308214277,
0.9399758577,
-0.0793567076,
0.3294883966,
-0.6607055664,
0.3874467015,
-0.0027104209,
0.0498523638,
-0.4166253805,
-1.0030196905,
-0.5809437037,
0.3335396349,
-0.0495129973,
0.1150904223,
0.4980440736,
0.5354303122,
0.0568923317,
0.4985285401,
-0.0836227983,
-0.3167252839,
0.4885849655,
0.7036148906,
0.8195435405,
-0.6270778775,
0.6532925963,
-0.4159980118,
-0.1565518081,
-0.1661008298,
-0.8822646141,
-0.699046731,
-0.4437765479,
-0.6921322346,
-0.2682324052,
-0.0751572698,
0.9417765141,
0.7943966985,
-0.9117901325,
-0.1298935711,
-0.9021937847,
-0.1277956069,
-0.1980190575,
-0.1559787542,
0.1368895471,
-0.7236388922,
-0.6516237259,
0.2194910496,
0.2901525795,
0.018997483,
-0.2881870866,
-0.292081058,
0.0703649819,
0.0421506315,
0.5976136923,
0.2641421556,
-0.6024939418,
0.3513903916,
-0.1120247766,
-0.4346582592,
-0.2389895171,
0.9438169003,
-0.8143205643,
0.5884842873,
0.5535362959,
0.9172375202,
0.4833440781,
-0.3011021912,
0.5641505122,
-0.7191322446,
-0.0146320825,
0.4498315454,
0.0931402594,
0.55550915,
-0.1930476725,
0.6098079681,
-0.003074626,
-0.5978520513,
-0.7267019749,
0.4730117321,
-0.5172745585,
-0.5111046433,
0.9028605819,
-0.0080666374,
-0.2131803036,
-0.2150477469,
-0.11046087,
0.5982300043,
0.0555584282,
0.5695790052,
0.3214814365,
-0.0675095618,
-0.1305682063,
-0.6173608303,
0.6797826886,
0.3008629978,
-0.8233721852,
0.1626523435,
0.2901907861,
-0.1722073406,
0.1678132713,
0.2851469517,
-0.2576654255,
0.1756449044,
0.2826675475,
0.6798111796,
-0.2156071514,
-0.2436780185,
-0.3306818008,
0.2636815012,
0.1569904536,
-0.0118048657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06345v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06345v2 | Improving Non-autoregressive Translation Quality with Pretrained Language Model, Embedding Distillation and Upsampling Strategy for CTC | 2023-06-10T05:24:29 | 2023-08-31T03:14:47 | Shen-sian Syu, Juncheng Xie, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Non-autoregressive approaches aim to improve the inference speed of
translation models, particularly those that generate output in a one-pass
forward manner. However, these approaches often suffer from a significant drop
in translation quality compared to autoregressive models. This paper introduces
a series of innovative techniques to enhance the translation quality of
Non-Autoregressive Translation (NAT) models while maintaining a substantial
acceleration in inference speed. We propose fine-tuning Pretrained Multilingual
Language Models (PMLMs) with the CTC loss to train NAT models effectively.
Furthermore, we adopt the MASK insertion scheme for up-sampling instead of
token duplication, and we present an embedding distillation method to further
enhance performance. In our experiments, our model outperforms the baseline
autoregressive model (Transformer \textit{base}) on multiple datasets,
including WMT'14 DE$\leftrightarrow$EN, WMT'16 RO$\leftrightarrow$EN, and
IWSLT'14 DE$\leftrightarrow$EN. Notably, our model achieves better performance
than the baseline autoregressive model on the IWSLT'14 En$\leftrightarrow$De
and WMT'16 En$\leftrightarrow$Ro datasets, even without using distillation data
during training. It is worth highlighting that on the IWSLT'14
DE$\rightarrow$EN dataset, our model achieves an impressive BLEU score of
39.59, setting a new state-of-the-art performance. Additionally, our model
exhibits a remarkable speed improvement of 16.35 times compared to the
autoregressive model. | [
-0.3815391064,
-0.632717669,
0.1854569316,
0.3335130513,
-0.8125931621,
0.2372185737,
-0.4022255242,
-0.1934211701,
0.0121053979,
0.4890087545,
-0.2043490708,
-0.5367490053,
-1.0117667913,
0.3065660894,
-0.495239675,
0.7689293623,
-0.0490179174,
0.2434233725,
0.2287159115,
-0.1758252382,
-0.4897562265,
-0.6347207427,
-0.5423654318,
-0.335098654,
0.0429277793,
0.0498027354,
0.5372650027,
0.5901838541,
0.2834079266,
0.2733837366,
-0.3475056589,
0.450632304,
-0.4780884087,
0.2387994975,
-0.0465948433,
-0.3129394352,
-0.3806856573,
0.0993099213,
0.6343145967,
0.5075092316,
-0.3288816214,
-0.1013713032,
0.3395565152,
0.6676614285,
-0.5990681648,
0.0451855958,
-0.5414329767,
0.026671797,
-0.1643712372,
-0.2253015637,
-0.6217351556,
-0.4728690982,
-0.0991888195,
-0.2721546888,
0.38256827,
0.0711339042,
0.7559480667,
0.3872619271,
-0.6687624454,
0.0829482079,
-0.8670956492,
0.9134256244,
-1.0908933878,
0.6856513023,
0.3215371966,
0.0285760239,
-0.1049644426,
-0.484328419,
-0.3405137658,
-0.4681411684,
-0.0812318474,
0.3343219757,
-0.292383194,
0.0509656258,
0.0483651571,
0.6773045063,
-0.5709609985,
0.2062520683,
0.0602702796,
-0.1677162498,
0.6954426169,
0.2215102762,
-0.2912782729,
0.171892181,
-0.300886929,
-0.282204926,
-0.5848887563,
-0.3068492711,
0.4013458192,
0.2953026891,
-0.0394167081,
0.3537940383,
-0.3833706379,
1.0097800493,
0.2989737988,
0.0791123956,
0.2713521719,
-0.7812946439,
-0.1227859259,
-0.0785224959,
0.6811277866,
0.1181651354,
0.1219749376,
-0.0362188928,
-0.4740256965,
-0.1555584669,
-0.0511287376,
-0.9053604007,
-0.4679848254,
-0.1229357198,
-0.5089925528,
-0.2773447335,
-0.0042754398,
-0.5474103093,
0.0289147533,
-0.5483047962,
0.3350810111,
-0.4469820261,
-0.5137770772,
0.0851838589,
0.0417980216,
0.0691913292,
0.5044918656,
-0.7220640182,
0.1601415724,
0.164746955,
1.0949239731,
-0.2989674509,
-0.0183969066,
-0.4534637332,
-0.1063174233,
-0.4453903735,
0.6569612622,
-0.2671395838,
-0.5453163981,
-0.278044939,
-0.1301974803,
-0.1808346659,
-0.5174922347,
0.2821724713,
-0.4712943733,
0.1830327362,
0.0218784418,
-0.5494424105,
-0.1791364402,
0.2274663001,
-0.6821351647,
1.1220430136,
-0.054103788,
-0.5646003485,
0.0731339455,
-0.6859163046,
-0.5891315341,
-0.2765358984,
0.4897826612,
-0.2940908372,
0.6992639899,
0.3658723235,
0.2937047184,
-0.3894751072,
0.4883266389,
-0.1559846252,
-0.1294162273,
0.2422679365,
-1.029289484,
0.8427227736,
0.4761508703,
-0.297590971,
-0.1109748706,
-0.7639097571,
0.135061875,
0.0114766974,
-0.3140342832,
-0.3993906081,
-0.3386274576,
0.1188765839,
0.5415492058,
0.0680068433,
-0.4751267433,
0.124566555,
-0.2860855758,
0.5785768032,
0.5651603937,
0.0446680412,
0.3853275478,
-0.1096599102,
0.3485711217,
0.259409219,
0.332182914,
-0.0075458311,
-0.3805755973,
-0.7033048868,
-0.1955442578,
0.7538160086,
0.425308466,
-0.9313876629,
0.5096067786,
-0.236644879,
-0.6658703685,
-0.5769338608,
0.0659661368,
0.5741271973,
0.5196251273,
0.6711091399,
-0.6549417377,
-0.2817302644,
-0.6458835602,
-0.1572380066,
-0.0764973164,
0.0386871323,
-0.2704450488,
0.4444775581,
-0.0049015721,
0.5885087252,
-0.5231382251,
-0.1314945221,
-0.2994270921,
0.6027474403,
0.2654961944,
0.6351855993,
0.3555451334,
-0.7535721064,
-0.5852133632,
-0.1732702553,
-0.2895474434,
-0.4006501734,
0.1853514314,
-0.1965125352,
0.4048378766,
0.4494333267,
-0.1805929095,
0.4929986,
0.9115368128,
-0.2427018881,
0.5113790035,
-0.4484046698,
0.3632282019,
-1.1538376808,
0.1657298505,
0.012628301,
-0.541496098,
-0.8039138317,
-0.2159007043,
0.2243940979,
0.0580302589,
-0.7546457052,
0.4249376357,
-0.5866844058,
0.3144581914,
-0.4926050603,
-0.0098074619,
0.4813544452,
0.2850362957,
0.3263409734,
0.6907812357,
0.2727407813,
-0.7121296525,
0.147474438,
0.3341993093,
-0.2620474398,
0.4222551286,
-0.5786451697,
0.1614414006,
-0.0734932795,
0.3382465541,
-0.8515641689,
0.4549079835,
-0.0525839925,
-0.3812000453,
0.7293711901,
-0.1334985644,
-0.7330068946,
-0.2087953836,
-0.0276423004,
0.3529804051,
0.4562574327,
-0.4409076273,
0.3492465317,
0.1232664958,
0.1789060235,
-0.4802505374,
-0.9961178303,
0.2129180133,
-0.1304512769,
-0.3006437123,
0.6285041571,
-0.1215984672,
0.0616104081,
0.0067587155,
-0.0221567582,
-0.269477874,
0.0775779858,
-0.2760350406,
0.1862174571,
-0.1058959588,
0.1341234744,
0.1924083531,
-0.4117645621,
-0.4277770817,
-0.6453956366,
0.5883734226,
-0.0290927738,
-0.203142643,
-0.6470476985,
0.4061661959,
0.49751243,
-0.5639252067,
0.9177489877,
0.5430004001,
-0.2081922591,
0.0936798379,
-0.82098943,
-0.3503569067,
-0.4057351053,
0.3254538774,
-0.1784098297,
-0.6785494685,
0.4900035858,
-0.0880333781,
0.0091214264,
0.3503620028,
0.6715162992,
0.0982171074,
1.074811697,
0.5773008466,
-0.0467468575,
0.7236702442,
-0.4430662394,
0.2151362598,
-0.8796523213,
-0.0909514278,
-0.4219228029,
-0.2177498937,
-0.5812067986,
-0.5956529379,
0.1863342971,
0.2823213637,
0.030175576,
0.6400049329,
-0.3782669008,
0.30735147,
0.7975923419,
0.034251526,
0.7397681475,
-0.1891719252,
-0.2953161299,
-0.0763853937,
-0.8955729008,
-0.255874604,
1.0273367167,
0.0449941047,
0.8808061481,
0.098451823,
0.6204472184,
0.3082535267,
0.323928684,
-0.301513195,
0.1332524717,
-0.4792915285,
-0.7587563396,
-0.10563346,
-0.6327961087,
-0.683116138,
0.4040800035,
-0.1392085254,
-0.2794706523,
0.4301615655,
0.5901371837,
-0.2891568244,
0.4022628963,
-0.6023797393,
0.8485004902,
-0.4648504257,
-0.4572434425,
-0.1437107027,
-0.6241241097,
0.230934754,
-0.2065409422,
-0.0623924211,
-0.1251772791,
0.1940007806,
0.3191021383,
-0.5028718114,
0.6343281269,
-0.3428491652,
-0.0528549775,
0.4562145472,
0.1344286352,
0.7265497446,
-0.1647346169,
-0.2132634372,
0.6402185559,
-0.0493124947,
-0.3656576276,
-0.6256447434,
0.549112916,
-0.6232056022,
-0.4355386794,
-0.2264816463,
-0.4611950517,
0.0125985723,
0.1116880104,
0.5803743005,
0.5291688442,
-0.1666404307,
0.2122184485,
0.6571148634,
-0.1176264882,
0.6514974833,
0.7185742259,
0.1444364637,
-0.5609464645,
0.6514693499,
0.3100789189,
0.7620905042,
0.5000003576,
0.1681698412,
-0.9454885721,
-0.9881886244,
-0.4864306748,
0.184279263,
-0.6234407425,
-0.5861096978,
-0.7508457303,
-0.2152592242,
-0.6384388804,
0.2209315896,
-0.8556352854,
-0.5474469066,
-0.2193493545,
-0.0170012992,
0.3862500191,
0.4160350263,
-0.3821972013,
0.5523055792,
-1.027502656,
-0.0846713558,
-0.1216769218,
0.113298215,
-0.0217187181,
-0.952191174,
-0.5182419419,
0.2178187221,
-0.3790306151,
-0.9376124144,
0.7956454754,
0.2742033899,
0.5748034716,
0.3200650215,
0.3473049402,
0.9770713449,
-0.3576538861,
0.5764753819,
0.1300802231,
-1.1990594864,
0.4823718667,
0.0399342366,
0.6029778719,
0.8177161813,
0.1918561608,
-0.5355522633,
-0.5499250889,
-0.3755851388,
-0.8272073269,
0.4320723116,
0.5150253177,
0.0894429311,
-0.1021534428,
0.2001923621,
0.1064276323,
0.4769542515,
-0.6919129491,
-0.1524211764,
-0.4602090716,
0.0522017404,
-0.3290140629,
-0.0485846139,
0.3692916036,
-0.4072603285,
1.0603209734,
0.002318434,
0.0565971695,
0.3226002455,
-0.4331896901,
0.0954498276,
0.0495712049,
0.6261313558,
0.3997501731,
-0.1748388112,
0.1695732623,
0.3362901509,
-0.3228566647,
0.4080822766,
0.1559452415,
-0.1136023551,
0.2428250015,
0.2184023112,
0.8987218142,
-0.0080121206,
-0.2059985399,
0.4463400245,
-0.2539842427,
-0.0424129441,
-0.1422598064,
-0.1877669543,
-0.1806868017,
0.1136157513,
0.1408875287,
0.1349150836,
0.0366888903,
-0.1211301684,
0.1029352918,
0.2939704061,
-0.3838373721,
-0.4436478317,
0.7404207587,
0.3456392884,
-0.0057409033,
0.9567277431,
-0.3810723126,
-0.3799063563,
0.302536279,
0.6968060136,
0.85907197,
-0.6892991662,
0.120769076,
0.5385810137,
0.5369530916,
-0.4404048324,
0.0290166717,
-0.1308021694,
-0.5949131846,
-0.7481094599,
-0.6766427159,
-0.1793143153,
0.1317697316,
-0.7635762691,
0.2983129025,
0.11748337,
-0.2867216468,
-0.5465523601,
-0.0566400737,
-0.7990781665,
0.1545668691,
0.0557042621,
0.8663678169,
-1.1688401699,
1.2340095043,
0.3157422245,
-0.2782506645,
-0.4793274105,
-0.0511032268,
-0.1758564711,
-0.4420486391,
0.5373527408,
0.0175341833,
-0.0842000321,
0.413985759,
-0.1060828939,
-1.2344841957,
0.9956687093,
0.4671172798,
-0.8292405009,
-0.0115515292,
0.1124943495,
0.6641479135,
-0.2110410184,
0.3886887133,
0.5514323711,
0.559142828,
0.1297692657,
-0.9784673452,
-0.0055530714,
-0.2178990692,
0.3245690167,
0.4599314928,
-0.6073455215,
0.7413414717,
-0.044851087,
-0.1861599088,
-0.0045604729,
0.5517774224,
0.0097050173,
0.1276251078,
0.4293006957,
0.7409514785,
0.5183243752,
-0.1513629705,
0.9370949864,
-0.5409851074,
0.4497222602,
1.2717679739,
-0.1532748789,
0.6794056892,
0.5371835828,
-0.0138536384,
0.2331583649,
0.6927379966,
0.0161803439,
0.9292924404,
0.1470011026,
-0.1632582545,
-0.3798601925,
-0.1188029796,
-0.4127661288,
0.4633023739,
0.2148624808,
-0.5409853458,
-0.4289440513,
0.3248237967,
-0.1182929575,
0.1098333225,
-0.0120358849,
0.7149317265,
0.1244561449,
-0.7625339031,
0.8607003689,
0.1786239445,
0.7106258273,
-0.6340206265,
-0.0304794796,
-0.4813372791,
0.1511478722,
0.1385301203,
-0.2680535316,
0.5851173401,
-0.0126429219,
-0.049580764,
-0.5659937859,
0.3721220791,
-0.6700136065,
-0.5604461432,
0.4446398914,
0.6326494813,
0.147157371,
-0.3024211824,
-0.7641417384,
-0.1247456223,
0.0097537767,
-0.2941812575,
0.1590301543,
0.4820358753,
-0.0012406752,
0.2973785102,
0.8355522156,
0.1295444965,
0.2514173388,
0.091147244,
0.7656341195,
-0.4826817214,
-0.3786694705,
-1.0734820366,
0.4942036569,
-0.1168382466,
-0.347522974,
0.7948308587,
0.6243697405,
1.0208581686,
-0.0740388855,
0.3702877164,
0.0634267107,
0.1418174058,
-0.6070632339,
0.6970073581,
-0.4927713275,
0.0060036313,
-0.0688287616,
-1.0749644041,
-0.3842123151,
0.4959788024,
-0.2000612617,
-0.0435838588,
0.7053286433,
0.7761082649,
-0.0203753076,
-0.2137910426,
0.611207962,
0.2051517665,
0.4211719334,
0.4536904991,
0.8763170242,
-0.5475639701,
0.4666396976,
-0.5590332747,
-0.1984376311,
-0.1754921824,
-1.086720705,
-0.7252319455,
-0.5940963626,
-0.5744245648,
-0.3271204829,
0.0892659128,
0.9534795284,
0.8654040098,
-0.8169148564,
-0.1018880531,
-0.3101606071,
-0.2169460058,
-0.4737024009,
-0.1815408319,
0.2649870515,
-0.33502388,
-1.027982831,
0.4475922585,
0.180149138,
0.456625104,
-0.1653595716,
0.0052615348,
-0.4569407403,
0.0232056566,
0.6049954891,
-0.0511737503,
-0.5782234669,
0.0054447204,
0.0396944322,
0.1320945919,
0.1650292873,
0.8548197746,
-0.5595642924,
0.66952914,
0.5590218306,
0.3467405736,
0.766348362,
0.1706378907,
0.6355619431,
-0.8668341637,
0.2630164325,
0.4722373486,
0.3128466308,
0.450666815,
-0.1871825755,
0.4070218205,
0.2101766318,
-0.4723790586,
-0.8111064434,
0.0854123086,
-0.4691837132,
-0.2563794851,
0.8850750923,
-0.4318048954,
-0.0367218964,
-0.2145929039,
0.0926573798,
0.6744160056,
-0.4140513837,
0.8636887074,
0.7240988016,
-0.0805237964,
0.0355789252,
-0.5237771869,
0.2229952365,
0.5644957423,
-0.5151144862,
0.2892502844,
0.3387474418,
0.1827640682,
-0.1274043471,
0.5373131037,
-0.5208204389,
-0.1178649366,
-0.2315607071,
0.1039474681,
-0.4024445117,
-0.3189491034,
-0.5854250193,
-0.3001689911,
0.0680318102,
-0.3194189668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07932v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07932v2 | Human-in-the-Loop through Chain-of-Thought | 2023-06-10T04:31:57 | 2023-06-23T05:56:51 | Zefan Cai, Baobao Chang, Wenjuan Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While the emergence of powerful language models along with Chain-of-thought
prompting has made automation more and more omnipresent, it sometimes
demonstrates its weakness in long-term or multi-step logical reasoning. For
example, users don't always get desirable answers for complex mathematical
problems without human involvement. Against this background, we present the
Manual Correction System (MCS) -- a human-in-the-loop system enhanced by
Chain-of-Thought prompting, which explores how manual correction of sub-logics
in rationales can improve LLM's reasoning performance. Moving one step forward,
considering a system with human-in-the-loop involves more than having humans
improve performance but also controlling the cost. Therefore, we post a
Cost-utility Analysis Model for Human-in-the-Loop systems (CAMLOP) based on
classical economics theory to analyze, quantify and balance the utility and the
corresponding cost. We conduct experiments of MCS and CAMLOP with twelve
datasets. A significant advantage w.r.t cost and utility proves its superiority
over strong baselines. | [
-0.3829828203,
-0.5049395561,
0.5545817018,
-0.2058036923,
-0.0869885534,
0.1250801682,
-0.0925961584,
-0.4877266884,
0.0346950106,
0.6075615287,
-0.5882837772,
0.2424672395,
0.0764216185,
0.3096145689,
-0.0463767461,
0.8388309479,
-0.0522052981,
0.0611381754,
-0.2389290929,
-0.0173940174,
-0.5971465707,
-0.6185741425,
-0.4801357388,
-0.7735002041,
0.6663246751,
0.6319478154,
0.9296362996,
0.28251791,
0.7004026771,
0.2353833169,
0.3000685275,
0.1252808571,
-0.1593148112,
-0.1283992976,
-0.6267494559,
-0.4917961061,
-0.8312450647,
0.0095857671,
0.4421589673,
0.6981807351,
-0.257694304,
0.1526747346,
-0.0078798784,
1.0196629763,
-0.8472470641,
-0.1753659397,
-0.6031447053,
-0.2221829146,
-0.054748144,
-0.3427425623,
-0.3325225115,
-0.398381561,
0.3041397929,
-0.3819513321,
-0.1381244212,
0.2525711656,
0.4336017072,
0.4524353147,
-0.06897486,
-0.3192386329,
-0.5998862982,
0.5181468129,
-0.5131878257,
0.1293393523,
0.339605242,
0.3283128142,
-0.3604672849,
-0.0644191355,
-0.6080998182,
-0.3076871932,
0.0454445072,
0.0736015961,
-0.2825658023,
0.2560492754,
0.5953179002,
0.064098388,
-0.2746435404,
-0.164309755,
-0.3657559454,
-0.0972919017,
0.7310093641,
0.16362454,
0.0903648362,
-0.0648490116,
-0.3810123503,
-0.1675037742,
-0.4674049616,
0.0663988441,
0.4226930439,
0.06516698,
0.2952127755,
0.7174400091,
-0.3413492739,
0.6515715718,
-0.0282855947,
-0.4224627912,
-0.1202742308,
-0.0349007696,
-0.5397288203,
0.1322187632,
0.4250274897,
0.4195229113,
0.7910861969,
-0.1350028366,
-0.5054852366,
0.4257303774,
0.3809223771,
-0.1483004242,
-0.1152264699,
-0.0122167738,
-0.0915095061,
-0.2236334234,
0.0732512623,
-0.5834609866,
-0.3421730399,
-0.6923693419,
0.5330674052,
-0.2252110541,
-0.0239620451,
0.4227854908,
-0.1920030862,
-0.0650905147,
0.2754163742,
-0.6004299521,
0.5124199986,
0.1439382881,
0.5857374072,
0.0889404789,
-0.2897672653,
-0.4195805192,
0.2664336264,
-0.3279794753,
1.1817848682,
-0.249703899,
-0.2777541578,
-0.2519925833,
-0.2795296907,
0.012672157,
-0.6877270937,
0.2920785546,
-0.4951879084,
-0.0692944899,
-0.6422793269,
-0.4616837502,
0.1057341397,
0.119470425,
-0.4690024257,
0.8009349108,
0.1863602251,
-0.8316114545,
0.4287278354,
-1.08634305,
-0.2182858735,
0.016630061,
0.1291234195,
0.0018259254,
-0.1915493906,
0.1954872757,
0.0863343254,
-0.5476757884,
0.4248654246,
-0.4289784133,
-0.4159379303,
0.6146675348,
-0.2901462615,
0.7940490842,
0.3568222225,
-0.3691874743,
0.0273786616,
-0.6632986069,
-0.1021673605,
-0.1241428033,
-0.3033950031,
-0.2828096449,
0.0068880063,
-0.4418888688,
0.2981824875,
-0.0973787382,
-0.2093353868,
0.5008351803,
-0.0160360467,
0.3592393994,
0.8985245824,
-0.2048828453,
0.6638982296,
-0.5015562177,
0.6377741694,
-0.1844664216,
0.2914560437,
-0.1481030136,
-0.3620467484,
-0.9396904707,
-0.0300747734,
0.2052257359,
0.8597593904,
-0.83708179,
0.3889784515,
0.2417612672,
0.0749665722,
-0.3684533238,
0.1393437982,
0.4116788208,
0.7386699915,
0.351301074,
-0.2765690386,
-0.3879803717,
-0.7468944788,
-0.4331783354,
-0.3382025063,
-0.289797008,
0.1311799139,
0.6468805671,
-0.6128398776,
1.130469799,
-0.3276470602,
0.1716511995,
-0.1667543948,
0.1205278262,
-0.0305777565,
0.4601905048,
-0.0676044151,
-0.0880259946,
0.1543658227,
-0.0653204918,
-0.6245874763,
-0.5772835016,
-0.1827834249,
-0.4977445602,
0.5790426135,
0.1716985106,
-0.4511624575,
0.7671024203,
-0.08948192,
-0.3551733792,
0.8798716068,
-0.7824680209,
-0.0769649372,
-0.4274117649,
0.3262842894,
0.0371713825,
-0.0324221663,
-0.1294172406,
-0.1839498132,
0.2181990743,
-0.0647229403,
0.0545156039,
0.3089461029,
-0.173789829,
-0.5143415928,
-0.3316890001,
0.0865317658,
-0.0981495082,
0.6989171505,
-0.1643419862,
0.8025651574,
0.1456960589,
-0.8566838503,
0.557995677,
-0.2947939932,
-0.198969841,
0.7319618464,
-0.505946517,
0.2915536761,
-0.1918335557,
0.5327800512,
-0.6161597967,
-0.380751431,
0.2643612325,
-0.0485722758,
-0.0153180556,
0.3032466769,
-0.6697731018,
-0.6517172456,
-0.1718973666,
0.3574544787,
0.3708024919,
-0.3510592282,
0.1084362343,
0.373860985,
0.1360434592,
-0.3154756427,
-0.2515681982,
0.2870354652,
-0.1224862263,
-0.5666852593,
-0.1134323403,
-0.093760252,
-0.7510803342,
-0.2205216289,
-0.1837539673,
0.0933568925,
-0.11603567,
-0.1710525602,
0.5305281878,
0.1307256669,
0.6590284705,
0.0725893751,
-0.6292662024,
0.2053332627,
-0.6840349436,
0.2328023911,
-0.421402663,
-0.3723183572,
-0.756000936,
0.259003371,
0.7311202884,
-0.0696085319,
0.0210097432,
-0.3088068962,
-0.4916852415,
0.0624587387,
-0.8439726233,
-0.0963264629,
-0.3652660549,
-0.2460028976,
-0.25713256,
-0.3101712465,
0.3197973371,
-0.2784278989,
-0.1044299155,
0.4674879014,
0.2391208261,
-0.5549161434,
1.1067038774,
0.3351698518,
-0.2348025292,
0.2547394037,
-0.3532234728,
0.0950647965,
-0.6977764368,
-0.1385330558,
-0.5520107746,
-0.5489499569,
-0.3995279968,
-0.4751210213,
0.4390077293,
0.325838089,
-0.8681719303,
0.395344615,
-0.420817256,
0.5583248138,
0.6305881143,
0.3910418451,
0.4499922991,
-0.2243064046,
-0.3687180877,
0.2718351185,
-1.0384836197,
-0.8071416616,
0.7995363474,
0.2832022011,
1.1453289986,
-0.30555439,
0.290589273,
0.4455239475,
0.3318090737,
-0.6560610533,
0.4871222079,
0.2903223038,
-0.3990491629,
-0.5603513718,
-0.1885315776,
-0.5657436252,
0.0214924198,
-0.1708717048,
-0.745008707,
0.331525892,
0.530955255,
-0.5261646509,
0.5183575153,
-0.7568320632,
0.4785556793,
-0.5018137693,
-0.515828073,
-0.3811491132,
-0.7999314666,
0.4548701644,
-0.011472865,
0.2672206759,
0.0849390477,
0.0295249224,
0.4722568095,
-0.7687490582,
0.6535447836,
0.0596689731,
-0.1759036034,
0.4203178287,
-0.034054812,
0.6905978918,
0.0284069665,
-0.0238163266,
-0.148611322,
-0.133378163,
-0.4354929626,
-0.6858767271,
0.3553405106,
-0.4355195463,
-0.4895828366,
-0.5771809816,
-0.7584049106,
-0.0984929577,
0.0030078371,
0.1075750068,
0.4820159972,
0.3308019638,
-0.2237942666,
0.6837163568,
-0.1951781213,
0.350328058,
0.1544177234,
-0.3004580736,
-0.4109159112,
0.4620121121,
0.0986706316,
0.5880639553,
0.2554526329,
0.5937607884,
-0.4604871869,
0.2656314075,
-0.5431777835,
0.3267506957,
-0.6512706876,
-0.3135032654,
-0.5402920246,
0.2664053142,
-0.1376781166,
-0.5468734503,
-0.0504521094,
-0.2362738997,
-0.1856849343,
0.0966468602,
0.2940373421,
0.5931198001,
-0.1205669269,
0.0774291083,
-0.5364474654,
0.419626534,
0.7705780864,
0.5380717516,
0.1365474313,
-0.2461578399,
-0.1470227242,
0.3012809157,
-0.630612433,
-0.6443511844,
0.2243224978,
-0.3907508254,
0.2786100209,
0.5473237634,
0.2106691748,
1.2197600603,
-0.2028924972,
0.3463145196,
0.4768012762,
-1.3245624304,
0.6990285516,
-0.220714882,
0.5439732075,
0.310942024,
-0.2059178948,
-0.5452615023,
-0.373752147,
-0.5517795086,
-0.3471396267,
0.7487860322,
0.15502657,
-0.5049037337,
0.0030945514,
0.4834776521,
-0.1384547204,
-0.0379177667,
-0.491289705,
0.2802306414,
-0.013222741,
0.2792762816,
0.1260955781,
-0.0749612153,
0.0979285389,
-0.6912485957,
0.6724561453,
-0.2676254809,
0.1528805643,
0.5750983357,
-0.2486473471,
-0.621584177,
0.5125650764,
0.8758135438,
1.0949529409,
-0.3364043236,
0.2534801066,
0.5561983585,
-0.0192689411,
0.1958596706,
-0.551772058,
0.0594992749,
-0.3208603263,
0.2112103254,
0.5733973384,
0.4838084877,
-0.9445443749,
-0.0037075351,
0.2996202707,
-0.2042763084,
-0.1119023412,
0.261287123,
-0.0481573604,
0.4690727592,
0.2725512683,
0.4691461623,
0.1504407525,
-0.6647421718,
0.0359438844,
0.3051024079,
-0.2017782629,
-0.1165179759,
0.5203450918,
0.3237457275,
-0.8159733415,
0.5835114717,
0.0515538119,
-0.6307695508,
0.7020722628,
0.5446351767,
0.8272504807,
0.0166189931,
0.0529501662,
0.3231248856,
0.394836098,
-0.5025743842,
0.3186653256,
-0.3083351254,
-0.4872136116,
-0.5062786937,
-0.202688992,
-0.6548085809,
-0.2279806137,
-0.6684705019,
0.412591815,
-0.2564314008,
-0.2112323791,
-0.2164996713,
0.179478392,
-0.58664608,
0.2320796996,
0.1187925041,
0.9234839082,
-0.3244648576,
1.0252658129,
0.5046437383,
-0.1498436928,
-0.6588327885,
-0.1373929381,
-0.1942412406,
-0.4335082471,
0.6614683867,
0.1114881486,
-0.713565588,
-0.1550939679,
-0.6568053961,
-0.6408799887,
1.1717815399,
0.4715519547,
-0.8273115754,
0.1443888396,
-0.1429421753,
0.4931580722,
-0.4358528554,
0.1941862255,
0.9933207035,
0.5199289918,
0.2187079787,
-1.111459136,
-0.2613145411,
-0.010443517,
0.0632404909,
0.4673896134,
-0.2559489906,
0.8483484983,
-0.7257384062,
-0.1315004975,
-0.1371595114,
0.1428948045,
0.4358700812,
0.6400635839,
0.6672200561,
0.5711107254,
1.1419199705,
0.2464646399,
1.2270348072,
0.111405611,
0.3643884659,
0.8041192293,
-0.5825443864,
0.5402622819,
0.6062796712,
-0.5923885107,
0.6107571721,
0.4065126777,
0.5508115292,
0.1818156242,
0.6259261966,
-0.2719281316,
-0.4437969327,
0.1724509895,
-0.2942210436,
0.0364990309,
0.2018029243,
-0.0229793265,
-0.0538642816,
-0.0624115877,
-0.2029056251,
-0.1673509032,
-0.4665926099,
0.6700664759,
-0.0866996497,
-0.9818793535,
0.4275150597,
-0.3552811444,
0.5624123216,
-0.3393877149,
0.0228669439,
-0.200227201,
0.4085268974,
-0.0556044169,
-0.4077953994,
0.1814588904,
0.3179029822,
-0.3587708771,
-0.3017166257,
0.8771695495,
-0.1612846106,
-0.7192137241,
0.2506825328,
0.1987466812,
0.1485557854,
-0.0404465683,
-0.5052640438,
-0.3030256033,
-0.2468582541,
0.1590712517,
0.0684295967,
0.3386885524,
-0.5243512988,
1.0283215046,
0.7228002548,
-0.1242162809,
-0.1117525548,
0.168398872,
0.9016406536,
-1.0795340538,
-0.5683705807,
-0.8631674051,
0.5495567322,
-0.1021949798,
-0.3058836162,
0.2028764933,
0.3115278184,
0.7712304592,
0.0530677885,
0.8799902797,
0.1931669861,
0.5016771555,
-0.486554265,
0.4096231759,
-0.431109041,
0.5117909908,
-0.7839547396,
-0.6061755419,
-0.3419140577,
0.7510719299,
-0.2299227118,
-0.2911696732,
0.9714179635,
0.6550650001,
0.2447010875,
0.1608344615,
0.3046992123,
-0.3271211088,
0.1514478326,
0.6140486002,
1.0964055061,
-0.1816468239,
0.2644478381,
-0.2502027154,
-0.588555932,
-0.4196013212,
-0.9778888226,
-0.6574313045,
-0.2197904587,
-0.1522430032,
-0.29652825,
0.0544100292,
1.2373024225,
0.3028964698,
-0.6913567781,
-0.7748502493,
-0.3980870843,
0.4410271347,
-0.4938418567,
-0.1272037774,
0.1417665482,
-0.7916856408,
-0.2421806604,
-0.1306794584,
0.8367832899,
-0.0227078311,
-0.3360490501,
-0.2946153581,
-0.3246613443,
0.3173424304,
0.7448667884,
0.1669279039,
-1.0114924908,
-0.295563519,
0.2675676048,
-0.1283786446,
0.0205421988,
1.4763072729,
-0.9856728911,
0.7802322507,
0.4681404233,
0.3078843355,
0.0068260957,
0.0249844827,
0.6881989241,
0.0533270389,
0.0129758725,
0.1291092783,
0.5317718983,
-0.0933735073,
-0.414211899,
0.4739933908,
0.5596290827,
-0.931593895,
-0.5882493258,
0.062999174,
-0.9472253919,
-0.2396448553,
0.9140420556,
0.2832249999,
-0.0037516351,
-0.5008234382,
-0.708304584,
0.3377349079,
-0.476290971,
1.093760848,
0.8287650943,
-0.4177082777,
0.0044800998,
-0.3711006343,
0.1366986334,
0.2251901031,
-0.9759002328,
0.0924617797,
0.6563379765,
-0.1219937801,
0.1086555868,
0.6481590271,
0.1649809778,
0.4464261234,
-0.2414473146,
0.2224533111,
0.2982786,
-0.3709505498,
-0.2338417023,
-0.2339039892,
-0.262149483,
-0.1264435947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06331v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06331v3 | Investigating the Effectiveness of ChatGPT in Mathematical Reasoning and Problem Solving: Evidence from the Vietnamese National High School Graduation Examination | 2023-06-10T02:01:02 | 2023-10-31T08:21:20 | Xuan-Quy Dao, Ngoc-Bich Le | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This study offers a complete analysis of ChatGPT's mathematics abilities in
responding to multiple-choice questions for the Vietnamese National High School
Graduation Examination (VNHSGE) on a range of subjects and difficulty levels.
The dataset included 250 questions divided into four levels: knowledge (K),
comprehension (C), application (A), and high application (H), and it included
ten themes that covered diverse mathematical concepts. The outcomes demonstrate
that ChatGPT's performance varies depending on the difficulty level and
subject. It performed best on questions at Level (K), with an accuracy rate of
$83\%$; but, as the difficulty level rose, it scored poorly, with an accuracy
rate of $10\%$. The study has also shown that ChatGPT significantly succeeds in
providing responses to questions on subjects including exponential and
logarithmic functions, geometric progression, and arithmetic progression. The
study found that ChatGPT had difficulty correctly answering questions on topics
including derivatives and applications, spatial geometry, and Oxyz spatial
calculus. Additionally, this study contrasted ChatGPT outcomes with Vietnamese
students in VNHSGE and in other math competitions. ChatGPT dominated in the SAT
Math competition with a success rate of $70\%$, followed by VNHSGE mathematics
($58.8\%)$. However, its success rates were lower on other exams, such as AP
Statistics, the GRE Quantitative, AMC 10, AMC 12, and AP Calculus BC. These
results suggest that ChatGPT has the potential to be an effective teaching tool
for mathematics, but more work is needed to enhance its handling of graphical
data and address the challenges presented by questions that are getting more
challenging. | [
-0.447435379,
-1.0638962984,
0.5421849489,
0.4811769724,
-0.0423713885,
0.1415364593,
0.0868539065,
0.0875833631,
-0.0702069625,
0.1387200952,
-0.2447379827,
-0.5279340148,
-0.834590435,
-0.1299793422,
-0.1825186312,
0.903529346,
-0.0526906773,
0.06033355,
-0.161606133,
0.158144623,
-0.7810329795,
-0.8219444752,
-1.0684797764,
-0.0838072151,
0.297406733,
0.3537720442,
0.65987885,
0.0068985447,
1.0561863184,
0.2847554684,
-0.1720639318,
0.011001192,
-0.7510105371,
-0.1092027947,
0.1379765123,
-0.5861107707,
-0.3378705382,
0.0440543108,
0.5071247816,
0.6022495031,
-0.4758089781,
-0.0753542557,
0.3132124543,
0.8410614729,
-0.3554517627,
0.5338566303,
-0.4001305699,
-0.0440679044,
-0.139001444,
-0.1090926379,
-0.2349117249,
-0.5773453712,
0.6190664172,
-0.7909799814,
-0.0301880445,
-0.366558969,
0.7482907772,
0.2111247778,
-0.7943770289,
-0.5032581091,
-0.4490815699,
0.7382157445,
-0.3897614777,
0.0709602088,
0.1931316704,
0.5939493179,
-0.3653071523,
-0.4567406178,
-0.0770959035,
-0.2392944396,
0.17860578,
0.8192884922,
-0.1378337741,
0.0783583969,
0.6777954698,
0.407304287,
-0.8372590542,
-0.4694899023,
-0.7032266855,
-0.216350168,
0.5120127201,
0.0539510511,
0.3059506714,
-0.427737534,
-0.3674123883,
-0.1626457572,
-0.5257170796,
0.1883431971,
0.0755458176,
0.1219442561,
-0.031007221,
0.8285309672,
-0.1317718327,
0.662999332,
-0.8490175009,
-0.0290619191,
-0.049683027,
-0.1795002669,
-0.0624423996,
-0.2071827799,
0.4666357934,
0.0441420898,
0.58780092,
0.4756842554,
-0.1039646342,
0.1984465271,
0.0367688276,
-0.7007964253,
-0.5673043728,
-0.0165375248,
-0.244054988,
0.1419404,
0.3668275177,
-0.6764242053,
0.0527561195,
-0.5540619493,
0.697907865,
-0.6370649338,
-0.2175271064,
0.4505749643,
-0.2565405965,
0.369328171,
0.5423555374,
-0.1720631719,
0.2102506906,
0.8544227481,
1.1123185158,
-0.2771083117,
-0.2278976291,
-0.4336579442,
-0.3779906332,
-0.0609882474,
0.9014683962,
-0.5163928866,
-0.5807909966,
-0.0011062591,
-0.4029604197,
-0.6469867229,
-0.5707638264,
0.7792153358,
-0.2783660591,
0.2518211007,
-0.3484199643,
-0.6917641759,
-0.0478079617,
0.3104862571,
-0.4081635773,
1.0166780949,
0.2504649162,
-0.4231463671,
-0.0646996722,
-0.7612663507,
-0.1742462069,
0.0212259013,
-0.1858115494,
-0.4237797558,
0.0635120198,
0.112574026,
-0.0136356493,
-0.1085886732,
-0.0941905454,
0.1199414805,
-0.521438539,
0.2695539594,
-0.7428392768,
0.9399725199,
0.1392787099,
-0.0634177327,
-0.3388109207,
-0.5803726912,
0.1596191227,
0.3127367198,
-0.2868487835,
-0.1265761405,
-0.3004299104,
-0.2582774758,
0.347736299,
0.010799041,
-0.3939606547,
0.2232012749,
-0.0730608255,
0.0909816325,
0.4534729123,
0.3832325041,
-0.2367075682,
-0.422393322,
0.7101555467,
-0.1863200963,
0.1458754539,
-0.063953504,
-1.3209887743,
-0.6647310257,
-0.1335471123,
0.4214398563,
0.951107204,
-0.7719554901,
-0.1368405521,
0.1834551692,
-0.7371724248,
-0.1614117175,
-0.1661693603,
0.3415496647,
0.7375983596,
0.0543988943,
-0.3143841326,
-0.1325710416,
-0.5748432875,
-0.2753098905,
-0.2400806099,
-0.1683044583,
0.446285814,
0.5677621961,
0.2590643764,
0.5769646168,
-1.048619628,
-0.2703598738,
0.2816947401,
0.3683185577,
0.3592375815,
0.2522587776,
0.5330318213,
-0.8261239529,
-0.7205862403,
0.070854038,
-0.6757215261,
-0.2866523266,
0.141434744,
-0.5226519704,
-0.280516535,
0.0460606292,
-0.5901039839,
0.7877367139,
0.2054596692,
-0.4792481363,
0.9521026015,
-0.2400777787,
0.3328496516,
-0.61133039,
-0.2314537764,
0.2308191806,
0.1198567227,
-0.5179197788,
-0.1638485789,
-0.2139973938,
-0.5502928495,
-0.2885732055,
0.138973847,
-0.0124746738,
0.0531413592,
-0.2226889879,
0.4365378022,
-0.3784709871,
0.4703189135,
0.0798942372,
0.750280261,
0.5372647047,
-0.3497615457,
0.4660800099,
0.1181287467,
-0.177577585,
0.8112566471,
-0.9734768271,
-0.1245934293,
-0.0243060868,
-0.0780955777,
-1.3160549402,
0.0568681695,
0.2442439795,
-0.6424317956,
-0.3748246729,
-0.3181465864,
0.115879342,
-0.2619645596,
0.1270418018,
0.3954299092,
0.701236546,
-0.0402040333,
0.4254311621,
0.0627524704,
-0.3900227845,
-0.3964124024,
-0.1754417866,
-0.0088707879,
-0.2374381721,
-0.7564504743,
-0.2123862207,
-0.0851976499,
-0.3413283527,
-0.0361812487,
-0.2223972827,
-0.3804206252,
-0.1257287115,
-0.1800379604,
0.4610310495,
-0.44043082,
0.1129395664,
-0.3712337017,
-0.5928962231,
0.2744629681,
-0.1985824704,
0.6219090819,
-0.4817678034,
-0.7620851398,
-0.2187586576,
0.3168315291,
0.3940208554,
-0.3233805299,
0.4975780249,
0.5524756908,
-0.329793036,
0.2844029069,
-0.159463793,
0.0612262748,
-0.384123981,
0.5015749931,
-0.5568366647,
-0.6617027521,
0.536137104,
0.0696078911,
0.1746834666,
0.486517787,
0.4695591629,
0.0186315645,
0.8784842491,
0.0236770362,
0.190393135,
0.5450139642,
-0.4421742558,
0.2747420967,
-0.4300361574,
-0.2073018551,
-0.5050085783,
-0.1777409464,
-0.8426375389,
-0.5029301047,
0.5541493297,
-0.0487582162,
-0.4473025501,
0.2491439134,
-0.5554401875,
0.5263926983,
0.6747034788,
0.1278026849,
0.4510019124,
0.0355784409,
0.2168782651,
-0.3900336027,
-0.7562987804,
-0.3243629336,
1.0333389044,
0.0020123678,
0.6162176728,
0.3684957623,
0.5948165655,
-0.0487431809,
0.156802997,
-0.9179255366,
0.3820148408,
-0.034597788,
-0.2840147913,
-0.4824760556,
-0.9381402731,
-0.9588265419,
0.5499057174,
0.0414094143,
-0.6314409375,
-0.2302018702,
-0.1992423236,
-0.1736774594,
-0.0470447503,
-1.0427215099,
0.7640188336,
-0.2801568806,
-0.1472240537,
-0.0322014466,
-0.3290980756,
0.3813604414,
-0.1188615635,
0.0561980456,
-0.1467399299,
0.1497428417,
0.7612951398,
-0.3943250477,
0.40438959,
-0.1728094667,
-0.155155167,
0.7666848302,
0.1951497495,
0.1527331024,
0.5530707836,
0.0496811755,
0.1316647083,
0.2616327405,
-0.8170797229,
-1.1388674974,
0.5002411604,
-0.7880809307,
-0.7754715681,
-0.6924211979,
-0.4869799912,
-0.1458058506,
0.1399619728,
0.1158577576,
0.6467898488,
0.0229188781,
0.1074298248,
0.7383418083,
-0.0153382858,
0.1241288632,
0.0465356745,
-0.3620092571,
-0.6289935112,
1.3220188618,
0.4343259335,
0.6019537449,
0.2057441622,
0.4201195836,
-0.2276071161,
0.023255527,
-0.1724460572,
0.3775285184,
-0.5012351274,
0.0672190413,
-0.2450536042,
-0.8477128148,
-0.0552889928,
-0.0226994175,
-0.3056476712,
-0.6227150559,
0.2167176604,
0.2388691157,
0.1454705,
0.5933436751,
0.1229470745,
0.5932181478,
-0.403571099,
0.217040211,
0.5268537402,
0.1636320353,
-0.1081910655,
-0.4473024607,
0.2261441201,
0.2442567199,
-0.5987362862,
-0.6416460276,
0.0192007907,
0.0045614215,
0.4137182236,
0.3710789382,
-0.126774922,
0.5974059701,
-0.0161504038,
0.7323459387,
0.0104171317,
-0.7587869763,
0.4315912426,
-0.4217324853,
0.5123593211,
0.0155714648,
0.283249259,
-0.7858363986,
-0.207033813,
-0.6575417519,
-0.2925753891,
0.3269418478,
1.0108872652,
-0.0323024914,
0.2363748252,
0.3528895676,
-0.1134330556,
0.1167913154,
-0.4166472256,
-0.3133728504,
-0.1200681105,
0.0239309315,
0.0981305093,
-0.1939182878,
0.1032264978,
-0.3105351329,
0.4428364933,
0.0073251561,
0.5457360744,
0.0316160209,
0.326285094,
0.440125227,
0.2121038884,
0.721062541,
1.1521869898,
-0.1831874698,
0.0150005668,
0.1657137275,
-0.8820158243,
-0.0262562782,
0.1377642155,
0.0664974377,
0.0720258579,
0.4512286186,
0.3417978585,
-0.1299728453,
-0.6252704263,
0.5118690729,
-0.3298668563,
-0.4047758579,
-0.1264702827,
0.1662233025,
-0.1179413944,
-0.1334606111,
0.5082219839,
0.0243599843,
0.0355752259,
-0.2263209075,
0.2317984253,
0.155587554,
-0.3202088177,
-0.0552752018,
0.3099018037,
-0.1219493747,
-0.5918109417,
0.8181970119,
0.0701261163,
-0.7869647145,
1.0161515474,
0.6907437444,
0.2549470365,
-0.349501133,
0.5276907682,
0.5955768228,
0.2903214693,
-0.0118280733,
0.6930090189,
-0.0090864375,
-0.3668011427,
-0.4477398694,
-0.0997211784,
-0.6785943508,
-0.2020608932,
-0.5636558533,
0.2485608757,
-0.2304515541,
-0.1317117065,
-0.3909939528,
0.1587355733,
-0.5914608836,
0.2445248812,
-0.1887265146,
0.8494371176,
-0.5368654728,
0.064735055,
0.7422688603,
-0.3863704801,
-0.6529869437,
-0.1321238726,
0.2209315151,
-0.9161057472,
0.3469294012,
-0.0485221818,
-0.0142367324,
0.0246504545,
-0.1246551201,
-0.8134820461,
0.6861706376,
0.4660551846,
-0.2058267742,
0.1833491027,
0.5793312788,
0.5176233053,
-0.0556188747,
0.6913123727,
0.5197691321,
0.3172165453,
0.6792213917,
-1.0503197908,
-0.5280833244,
-0.2597016394,
-0.1042838842,
0.3072241545,
-0.9408248663,
0.7514628768,
-0.1136327311,
-0.1251330525,
-0.1693145037,
0.5851273537,
0.659643054,
0.6613050699,
0.1520075053,
0.529050529,
0.7866959572,
-0.4913648665,
0.5224397182,
-0.0237200689,
0.6003614664,
0.643858552,
0.1149090454,
0.7333471179,
0.2926779091,
-0.46682477,
0.1290611923,
0.6276677847,
0.3883531094,
0.1792543381,
0.4679072499,
-0.3063034713,
-0.4325811565,
-0.0719931275,
-0.6508787274,
0.6252028346,
0.4197930098,
0.3660407066,
-0.5069414973,
-0.007213213,
-0.0468769632,
-0.0289973356,
-0.2068092525,
0.2963639498,
0.6106652617,
-0.5710555911,
0.4106289744,
-0.4119523466,
-0.044569768,
-0.5922436714,
-0.5130717754,
-0.3326116502,
0.1817116588,
-0.0675561056,
-1.150301218,
0.2826576233,
-0.0865171552,
0.357201159,
0.1161955371,
0.6091572046,
-0.2067385763,
-0.7130957246,
-0.278850168,
0.9272891879,
0.3943317831,
-0.3139536381,
-0.5889478326,
-0.0975741297,
-0.077705279,
-0.099379383,
0.0352522582,
0.8539328575,
-0.0234340653,
0.799431324,
0.5610305667,
0.0795920566,
0.1579155177,
-0.0371334851,
0.5704234838,
-0.7063253522,
-0.4707345068,
-0.7716987133,
0.3135259748,
-0.2473096102,
-0.7097392082,
1.0709006786,
0.7830415368,
0.9201567769,
0.1998354495,
0.6035872698,
0.1215049997,
0.2072832882,
-0.4551240206,
0.3974712193,
-0.2594882548,
0.108327277,
-0.5117691159,
-1.1357673407,
-0.2833277583,
0.6853721738,
-0.6854198575,
0.1801661849,
0.8443886638,
0.3386484683,
-0.0548120476,
0.2015976459,
0.4696519971,
-0.3547252715,
0.6599464417,
1.0644589663,
1.1149055958,
-0.4724339545,
0.8824499249,
-0.2821973264,
-0.5915656686,
0.0338709913,
-0.2527627051,
-0.9168913364,
-0.45312953,
-0.2970883548,
-0.3683838248,
0.0314323157,
0.5325200558,
0.156861499,
-0.4960790873,
-0.5142179728,
0.1267497987,
0.2927584052,
-0.3830372095,
-0.2984891534,
0.7768839002,
-0.3071144521,
-0.598359704,
-0.2558993101,
0.2596068978,
0.1140311956,
0.2233669907,
0.0632536709,
0.105485782,
-0.0824074671,
0.8014058471,
0.1566638947,
-0.3818835318,
-0.1682536304,
0.4144543409,
-0.2167892307,
0.2553697526,
0.9589456916,
-0.3832907379,
0.471262753,
0.588352859,
0.7272619605,
0.4735536873,
0.4591732621,
0.4432448745,
0.0098191183,
-0.0677962303,
0.11352171,
0.3403295279,
-0.2101458311,
-0.2831537127,
0.7586547136,
0.666133523,
-0.7659887671,
-0.3563780785,
0.0907549039,
-0.9394798279,
0.0379407406,
1.0064572096,
-0.0690076277,
-0.0898083746,
-0.1876323372,
-0.9480488896,
-0.0049936324,
-0.4366640747,
0.9901509285,
1.2060428858,
-0.6440169215,
-0.1370994151,
-1.1496577263,
0.0877060592,
0.6705377102,
-0.8071070313,
-0.1243221983,
0.3950531185,
-0.1796526313,
-0.1073297337,
0.448089391,
-0.0915495977,
0.6049439311,
0.1665575057,
-0.5297659636,
0.1873642951,
-0.100071609,
0.0554137528,
0.2626426816,
-0.1079129502,
-0.2557246089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06322v1 | Towards Arabic Multimodal Dataset for Sentiment Analysis | 2023-06-10T00:13:09 | 2023-06-10T00:13:09 | Abdelhamid Haouhat, Slimane Bellaouar, Attia Nehar, Hadda Cherroun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA) has recently become a centric research
direction for many real-world applications. This proliferation is due to the
fact that opinions are central to almost all human activities and are key
influencers of our behaviors. In addition, the recent deployment of Deep
Learning-based (DL) models has proven their high efficiency for a wide range of
Western languages. In contrast, Arabic DL-based multimodal sentiment analysis
(MSA) is still in its infantile stage due, mainly, to the lack of standard
datasets. In this paper, our investigation is twofold. First, we design a
pipeline that helps building our Arabic Multimodal dataset leveraging both
state-of-the-art transformers and feature extraction tools within word
alignment techniques. Thereafter, we validate our dataset using
state-of-the-art transformer-based model dealing with multimodality. Despite
the small size of the outcome dataset, experiments show that Arabic
multimodality is very promising | [
-0.6858388186,
-0.221590519,
0.2692607343,
0.221125707,
-0.3372061253,
0.2698439062,
-0.0904067382,
-0.2203184068,
0.2400596738,
0.0313287638,
-0.6630599499,
-0.718975842,
-0.8348258138,
-0.0444677435,
-0.2133693099,
1.0732227564,
-0.0332898274,
0.1734431684,
-0.047252126,
-0.7629612088,
-0.4555991888,
-0.4411545098,
-0.2144521326,
-0.0849107057,
0.8589933515,
0.4304730296,
1.0608311892,
0.1018214598,
0.2888918519,
0.2167422473,
0.1728800386,
0.3847902119,
-0.1173405573,
0.1910599768,
0.1450619102,
-0.1225333661,
-0.3130708635,
0.0498373471,
0.3464494944,
0.3518392742,
-0.0343601964,
0.2923992872,
-0.0594471805,
0.9325205088,
-0.6817718148,
0.3351346552,
-0.3545074463,
0.3644441962,
-0.1082465649,
0.2648433745,
-0.1823295504,
-0.3745441735,
0.0874362588,
0.0878211111,
-0.070070453,
-0.3066388369,
0.750428915,
0.2326074988,
-0.8875368834,
-0.4865838289,
-0.6978610754,
1.0517964363,
-0.746453464,
0.6527276635,
-0.0792307928,
0.415073365,
0.3518758118,
-0.5839129686,
-0.920843482,
-0.0468678288,
-0.0738923922,
0.3533082306,
-0.0699244514,
-0.2981423736,
-0.0515978038,
0.3988141418,
-0.441388011,
-0.0724124536,
-0.0007366897,
-0.1875803322,
0.505658865,
0.087100476,
0.3179955184,
-0.3877609968,
-0.5029804111,
-0.2241045535,
-0.6129961014,
0.3646359444,
0.4731369615,
0.4716951549,
-0.2202955335,
0.6419277787,
-0.2175222188,
0.3060145974,
-0.1563913524,
-0.0855251327,
0.6566573381,
-0.3880743682,
-0.1604601592,
-0.073515527,
0.8783064485,
0.4939303994,
0.2699270248,
0.0178435054,
-0.2055769116,
0.4490445554,
0.4708376229,
-1.0346291065,
-0.0252251737,
0.4165404737,
-0.7411012053,
-0.3943108022,
0.0254362933,
-0.9351424575,
-0.6130060554,
-0.531298995,
0.2404371202,
-0.343943119,
-0.4464035034,
-0.0340722017,
0.2217691839,
0.3233115673,
0.197316125,
-0.6389596462,
-0.362480551,
0.4608342052,
0.8126328588,
-0.0690230429,
-0.0275274329,
-0.0633489192,
-0.3102574646,
-0.2321146429,
0.6486117244,
-0.7879450321,
-0.4671162069,
0.384452194,
-0.1973210722,
-0.0636138245,
-0.2304020822,
0.8404254317,
-0.7970501184,
0.2315335572,
-0.1074317768,
-0.1823377311,
-0.499558419,
0.5587666631,
-0.8293002844,
0.832752645,
-0.1043931916,
-0.7382152677,
0.3978728354,
-0.7075375319,
-0.5101337433,
-0.4490430355,
-0.178215608,
-0.6392742991,
0.2719933093,
0.6617376208,
0.5211875439,
-0.1281945556,
0.1599337608,
-0.2954841852,
0.0031236222,
0.6532480717,
-0.810806334,
0.3938504755,
0.6416851282,
-0.1743935645,
-0.0098651974,
-0.7611588836,
0.0865236148,
-0.3344894052,
-0.1086782217,
-0.0504586808,
0.1662946641,
0.5638537407,
0.7583831549,
0.2855630517,
-0.7760490179,
0.2910115421,
-0.189291358,
0.1437618583,
0.7500773072,
-0.2449637055,
0.3628946841,
-0.0916890278,
0.6978101134,
0.6604905725,
0.1734830439,
-0.1901830733,
-0.3016459048,
-0.7076821923,
-0.5324670672,
0.3489180207,
0.3338716328,
-0.8736689091,
0.137367934,
-0.4658612013,
-0.5482625961,
-0.8642972112,
0.1330135465,
-0.0160437096,
0.153247878,
0.4294415414,
-0.420901835,
-0.6284224391,
-1.0292829275,
-0.0985619798,
0.1562049836,
0.2104401439,
0.1828152984,
0.2228768766,
-0.6892197728,
1.205827117,
-0.4813297689,
-0.4726756513,
-0.4403136969,
0.2799949348,
0.504509449,
0.2489678115,
0.5454793572,
-0.9448766708,
-0.5216112733,
0.0704545155,
-0.9262395501,
0.1419079304,
-0.1589071304,
0.0525414124,
0.2425715178,
0.0329947695,
-0.7856373787,
0.3959237337,
0.811519146,
-0.2426626086,
0.2987817824,
0.3914132118,
0.1900561899,
-1.4237290621,
0.0145364646,
0.0971492156,
-0.0130333025,
-0.6536623836,
-0.2543452084,
-0.111107789,
-0.1692989618,
-0.544772625,
0.2710334361,
-0.2208921313,
0.2533134818,
-0.4157888591,
-0.2738460898,
0.0274917576,
0.5559437871,
-0.0166845489,
0.8039508462,
0.4812986553,
-0.0242251102,
0.2826635838,
0.2130590528,
-0.3674031496,
0.5165647864,
-0.4872479439,
0.2557363808,
-0.4259772897,
0.0452341102,
-1.1763870716,
0.1669936776,
0.2181768566,
-0.3724324405,
0.2091531903,
-0.0967699885,
-0.472750634,
-0.0837461874,
-0.5935748816,
0.5064085126,
0.3673219681,
-0.4896057248,
1.1255971193,
0.2836646736,
-0.1642045528,
-0.933698833,
-0.2363945842,
0.1632007211,
-0.2404440492,
-0.5536635518,
-0.0091548534,
0.0810483173,
-0.132551387,
-0.2616975307,
0.0515373796,
0.1505399346,
-0.2049310207,
0.7669487,
0.3719371855,
-0.2711029649,
0.1368807405,
0.0983393937,
-0.2214860767,
0.0584747642,
0.0050846501,
0.6067137122,
-0.3576469123,
-0.3920095861,
-0.5308042169,
0.5922244787,
1.0358660221,
-0.4267312884,
0.8763903379,
1.0635881424,
-0.0760794729,
-0.0038593544,
-0.4923677444,
0.0167697128,
-0.4398816228,
0.4920218587,
-0.394464165,
-0.5471342802,
0.2462572753,
-0.2074279487,
0.0538130701,
0.2787135839,
0.8412965536,
-0.3792569041,
1.4565037489,
0.4639089108,
-0.6477664709,
0.285343498,
-0.229535237,
0.5257599354,
-0.6326723695,
-0.0634867549,
-0.3572327495,
-0.6797090173,
-0.7196894288,
-0.238202706,
0.4326175451,
-0.3482161164,
-0.0520524941,
-0.0456888154,
-0.0797323063,
0.0377316698,
0.2530094385,
0.0145548526,
0.0850591213,
0.2918932438,
-0.0473545901,
-0.2317713052,
-0.406080842,
-0.8245649338,
1.1286232471,
0.4362295568,
0.6809592843,
0.3715318143,
0.3397028744,
0.6631169319,
0.4632617831,
-0.9373919964,
0.3203093708,
-0.2031293511,
-0.260163039,
0.0320677869,
0.0066968813,
-0.8419685364,
0.4407685101,
-0.3117621839,
-0.2240124494,
0.2119114101,
-0.150072962,
-0.1743565947,
0.187305361,
-0.6308701634,
0.8510097861,
0.015623345,
-0.2021953166,
-0.248200193,
-0.7695632577,
0.0816773698,
0.186740011,
0.4587558508,
-0.2176354527,
0.1826623231,
0.5010883212,
-0.2541335225,
0.958503902,
-0.4347827733,
-0.3501111269,
0.2234445661,
-0.1608236432,
0.3483304679,
0.2082288861,
-0.0958825201,
0.339810878,
-0.0871586353,
-0.3244107068,
-0.6541159749,
0.7789325714,
-1.1350287199,
-0.1420971155,
-0.5974512696,
-0.7471059561,
-0.5894696712,
-0.1025020182,
-0.2170374244,
0.6756570935,
-0.1014848277,
0.199198842,
0.2962516248,
-0.0744472146,
0.7018370628,
0.2752597928,
-0.2802278101,
-0.4851281345,
1.1315147877,
0.1714349836,
-0.1945683211,
0.2278354764,
0.0183606558,
-0.5030418038,
-0.3458175957,
-0.9664655924,
-0.0071976478,
-0.7988234162,
-0.3021907806,
-0.4963383675,
-0.0298556909,
-0.3410874009,
0.1411372423,
-0.3874426186,
-0.2609227002,
-0.1480652541,
-0.1886675805,
0.227405116,
0.5446933508,
0.2428685576,
0.0569980256,
-1.205504775,
0.3347767889,
0.4665243924,
0.1513555497,
0.1682587713,
-0.2193212211,
-0.3840483129,
0.2520434558,
-0.5161754489,
-0.718010664,
0.5691603422,
0.2488723993,
0.0932101831,
0.7221133113,
-0.1633037329,
0.441940546,
-0.3836880624,
0.9634649754,
0.1531462222,
-0.7458841205,
0.2655645013,
-0.1418589652,
0.4525200725,
0.5218641162,
0.5854907632,
-0.8549381495,
-0.0724030957,
-0.1387702674,
-0.7664102316,
0.3282822073,
0.2772469819,
0.6287268996,
0.0509081818,
-0.0502676331,
0.4506918788,
0.5107514858,
-0.5492966771,
-0.4544433355,
-0.7333331704,
-0.9036934376,
-0.159851253,
-0.3682414591,
-0.0077169747,
-0.0326849557,
0.5927084088,
-0.4115203917,
0.1946672648,
-0.2079930604,
-0.4666813314,
0.3543527722,
0.6613642573,
0.4694157541,
0.4099987149,
-0.111466676,
0.2521778643,
-0.0619845912,
-0.6222190261,
0.322116226,
0.0246115029,
-0.2271436751,
0.0635798126,
0.2435974926,
0.6685494781,
-0.3412533998,
-0.7977235317,
0.6502971649,
-0.1056799889,
0.2081585377,
-0.3300425708,
-0.4574942589,
0.1049223021,
0.2489465922,
0.4371885359,
0.4647243619,
0.1249578297,
-0.5422904491,
0.059954118,
0.5760343075,
-0.8367761374,
-0.5087911487,
0.081593819,
0.1916557103,
0.1745821536,
0.6659564972,
0.0157263335,
-0.5114917159,
0.3038950562,
0.1172026023,
0.8023828268,
0.0577890016,
0.3562238812,
0.0265067182,
0.1250205189,
0.4731036425,
0.4866115451,
-0.0479940884,
-1.1090085506,
-0.424300462,
-0.7840765119,
-0.1614260674,
-0.2945827842,
-0.6364044547,
0.035459511,
-0.175949201,
-0.2998758852,
-0.2880370915,
-0.3011336923,
-0.7787113786,
0.5310391784,
0.5692285299,
0.5953399539,
-0.887206316,
0.9214857817,
0.728079915,
-0.4965198934,
-0.5611613989,
-0.1692459732,
0.0431248695,
-0.7907122374,
0.8466054797,
0.634845078,
-0.5196783543,
-0.2612044811,
-0.3930602968,
-0.6108014584,
0.9748872519,
-0.1486572623,
-0.37783283,
0.3278008997,
0.6164626479,
0.6090461612,
-0.4087973237,
0.3549126089,
0.3549822867,
0.454729706,
0.0007759645,
-0.3812990785,
-0.1235182732,
-0.4968028963,
0.0706815422,
0.2549573183,
-0.5704045892,
0.7683366537,
0.0048598326,
-0.1577242166,
-0.1013261452,
1.1753540039,
-0.2000611722,
0.3360209167,
0.5631012321,
0.8089385629,
0.3734380901,
-0.0110113341,
0.8300771117,
-0.4147360921,
0.4201487601,
0.7616436481,
-0.5378819704,
0.9630473852,
0.7411523461,
-0.3374574482,
0.9890373945,
0.154189378,
0.0695592389,
0.6664727926,
-0.1567251086,
-0.5914200544,
-0.1914025247,
-0.4157598913,
-0.3680138588,
0.7461879849,
0.1864950657,
-0.4292320609,
-0.0930098891,
0.3513157964,
0.1156010702,
0.0224643983,
-0.2495570183,
0.7830767632,
-0.0745936111,
-0.3327859342,
0.1781566739,
0.0318917893,
0.8243101835,
-0.5954012871,
0.0754099786,
-0.306725204,
0.3247918189,
-0.2778517902,
-0.7543510199,
0.2913259864,
-0.0685007721,
-0.4809007347,
-0.2213625312,
0.610100925,
-0.2508750558,
-0.8141177297,
0.0477459244,
0.6727352738,
-0.3720567822,
-0.1832076758,
-0.6234849095,
0.1351793855,
-0.035591457,
-0.2046674788,
0.354118377,
0.2697609365,
0.1429733485,
0.5205994248,
0.7364319563,
-0.1535693258,
-0.0553376041,
0.4459120929,
0.8067798018,
-0.6044040918,
-0.1627328694,
-1.0148893595,
0.7227184176,
0.0066324077,
-0.2260901183,
0.9209933281,
0.5264076591,
0.4741080999,
-0.4462700784,
0.9077802896,
-0.0939930975,
0.3536196947,
-0.5154336691,
0.7974745631,
-0.4422096014,
-0.009290887,
-0.1851900816,
-0.7128750086,
-0.2999748886,
0.4170145988,
-0.0093165562,
0.1256179065,
0.4995655417,
1.0011382103,
0.019462036,
0.4010244608,
0.0953956768,
0.0788958445,
0.4430668354,
0.3986147344,
1.1640212536,
-0.493203491,
0.4495900571,
-0.3253415227,
0.074556917,
0.0360460058,
-0.9451773167,
-0.8485209346,
-0.5299297571,
-0.0826569125,
-0.3545398712,
-0.3657684922,
1.3505687714,
0.5510101318,
-1.0888779163,
-0.2138452977,
0.4611155391,
0.0028567889,
-0.3388497531,
-0.2362925559,
0.5625100732,
-0.3117792606,
-0.7806875706,
0.3016913235,
0.1865409464,
-0.0984268561,
-0.469260931,
-0.0046144566,
-0.2412867099,
0.1394332051,
1.0100711584,
-0.1429842114,
-0.59681952,
-0.4212556183,
-0.0331373177,
-0.1841432005,
0.3502041996,
0.7938576341,
-1.0426410437,
0.4520443678,
0.3065553606,
0.6856274605,
0.1620040834,
-0.0410397723,
0.4248668849,
-0.8836866021,
0.1155088097,
0.1787413657,
0.4802337885,
0.4527028501,
0.0299508143,
0.1842994243,
-0.0200596415,
-0.2901586592,
-0.4483073652,
0.4112031758,
-1.2455165386,
0.0712686032,
0.8951566815,
0.0876466259,
0.0761114433,
-0.0643951371,
-0.7352416515,
0.1024742648,
-0.6449955106,
1.087939024,
0.7528049946,
0.0407328457,
-0.0859448761,
-0.1609551758,
0.2282503694,
0.5766973495,
-0.7653228641,
-0.1819858253,
0.4999177754,
-0.048357863,
0.3378440142,
0.1044913232,
-0.0465494059,
0.1271746755,
-0.2357518524,
0.1084836647,
-0.1052978858,
-0.3615913987,
-0.4149771929,
0.8047556281,
0.0156349707,
-0.4527322054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06297v1 | Protect Your Prompts: Protocols for IP Protection in LLM Applications | 2023-06-09T23:23:26 | 2023-06-09T23:23:26 | M. A. van Wyk, M. Bekker, X. L. Richards, K. J. Nixon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 91D10, 68T10, 03D40, I.2.6; K.6.5; F.3.2 | With the rapid adoption of AI in the form of large language models (LLMs),
the potential value of carefully engineered prompts has become significant.
However, to realize this potential, prompts should be tradable on an open
market. Since prompts are, at present, generally economically non-excludable,
by virtue of their nature as text, no general competitive market has yet been
established. This note discusses two protocols intended to provide protection
of prompts, elevating their status as intellectual property, thus confirming
the intellectual property rights of prompt engineers, and potentially
supporting the flourishing of an open market for LLM prompts. | [
-0.2078710347,
-0.6619279981,
0.484526068,
0.5171552896,
-0.0547404774,
0.2054608166,
-0.0389548093,
-0.5971164703,
0.3763198853,
0.9710513353,
-0.2152054608,
-0.2065933496,
-0.4666678011,
0.074877426,
0.0022684336,
0.797802031,
-0.1866458654,
-0.1838669777,
-0.293171674,
-0.1493067741,
-0.3862778246,
-0.6657733917,
-0.7899237275,
-0.0218555182,
0.3770405054,
0.3436639309,
0.5226264596,
0.6038928032,
0.6444274783,
0.2957572937,
-0.2723881304,
-0.2369547337,
-0.1357122511,
0.7691999674,
-0.2533383965,
-0.4553437829,
-0.2327167243,
0.3451393843,
0.4278606176,
0.4915575385,
0.0753294975,
0.0570485219,
-0.1540474892,
0.6986700296,
-0.4661630988,
0.1625031829,
-0.5969152451,
0.1190944463,
-0.4011632502,
-0.6404767632,
-0.6477256417,
-0.648753345,
0.0738334432,
-0.4330178797,
-0.2367145568,
0.573767662,
0.5698148608,
-0.1476632655,
-0.03293854,
-0.2443746775,
-0.5125911832,
0.7914736271,
-0.311324507,
-0.1035566106,
0.2421741188,
0.7071149349,
-0.4747097194,
-1.0810381174,
-0.2193159312,
-0.6493148804,
0.1542752385,
0.0503757149,
-0.4820141792,
0.2368572205,
0.5071022511,
0.434738785,
-0.4669908881,
0.4685000181,
-0.2601404786,
-0.4016079009,
0.5172200799,
0.3257989883,
0.9055095315,
0.2850576043,
-0.6000444889,
0.3879291117,
-1.3960253,
0.3017167449,
0.5728787184,
0.2777238488,
-0.0671024621,
0.8556397557,
-0.2292343527,
0.2871825993,
-0.1119845137,
-0.1902319193,
-0.1660173088,
-0.3318076432,
-0.0287162829,
0.0258988775,
0.5497269034,
0.3027886152,
0.2649893165,
-0.2024772018,
-0.4296240211,
-0.2865769565,
-0.1710487306,
-0.5293985605,
0.0230794195,
0.4599861205,
-0.9269822836,
-0.1925553828,
0.0640927404,
-0.5789046884,
-0.7082221508,
-0.1925986111,
0.2898237705,
0.2049298733,
-0.2525970638,
0.066629827,
-0.5470824838,
0.44485569,
0.2275662869,
-0.8590934277,
0.2568309009,
0.8189306259,
1.0358207226,
-0.0819629431,
-0.1823168397,
-0.5305954814,
0.2723974586,
-0.2293489575,
0.9223603606,
-0.3582648039,
-0.7004224062,
0.2399439812,
0.1225478947,
-0.0095778508,
-0.5909610987,
0.5205051899,
-1.027813077,
0.0680354536,
-0.2143247426,
-0.3016073108,
0.222389251,
0.1997110248,
-0.8185274005,
0.2737028599,
-0.1158592254,
-0.9263591766,
0.0998792127,
-0.9565235376,
-0.3717210293,
0.2388008833,
0.0702156872,
0.0094591854,
-0.1314870417,
-0.0774506554,
0.1638751477,
-0.339406848,
-0.1324041486,
-0.3606103659,
-0.1625257283,
0.5837984681,
-0.7198649645,
1.2252799273,
0.4052278697,
-0.248236388,
0.2946324646,
-0.4165585935,
-0.2533379197,
0.0128040211,
-0.3337629139,
-0.1329018176,
-0.0208358113,
-0.2565360665,
0.1874728799,
0.3238518238,
-0.6157945395,
0.4376987219,
-0.3225615919,
0.8480159044,
1.0837404728,
0.2468069196,
0.5721301436,
-0.6543574929,
1.0393816233,
0.0679785684,
0.1744496822,
-0.4951700568,
-0.839088738,
-0.6844747663,
-0.5175976753,
0.0352658182,
0.6200836301,
-0.8209949732,
0.0047640684,
0.2403950691,
-0.4011758864,
-0.6857239008,
-0.1853197813,
0.0819378272,
0.3687926829,
0.0769729912,
-0.0422698632,
-0.2813045681,
-0.8876517415,
-0.5160290003,
-0.2765769958,
-0.0427225418,
0.5772040486,
0.0485954434,
0.0066553731,
0.8450202942,
-0.4937294722,
-0.1929847896,
-0.2728528678,
0.1012367234,
0.3447583616,
0.4884164333,
0.6973404288,
-0.6371198893,
-0.6459513903,
-0.2822168469,
-0.6487503648,
-0.6042114496,
-0.1775934398,
-0.1202765554,
0.2191607803,
0.6517988443,
-0.765276432,
0.3913751841,
0.1310476214,
-0.5853902698,
0.7714266777,
-0.1820774674,
0.2431797981,
-0.7377510667,
0.0475446694,
-0.2450089902,
-0.5391520858,
-0.6430273652,
0.1563262045,
-0.3913327157,
-0.3837573826,
-0.9128429294,
1.1072510481,
-0.4988944829,
-0.0068109524,
-0.4708322883,
0.1474380493,
-0.0277484022,
-0.2214841694,
0.1079966947,
1.1774300337,
0.9281346798,
-0.8226330876,
0.5250878334,
0.3627093732,
-0.2005461007,
0.8009133339,
-0.8398120403,
0.1322102249,
-0.1141209379,
0.0586174615,
-0.8164457679,
0.0304288343,
0.7541027069,
-0.3066429496,
0.1044689417,
-0.0683382228,
-0.2455619872,
-0.2587249577,
-0.602930367,
0.1102205291,
0.6011379957,
-0.8629115224,
0.3286108375,
0.4169562161,
-0.6653615832,
-0.8093585968,
-0.4686942995,
0.2666374743,
-0.5866998434,
-0.6799943447,
0.1101426557,
-0.5656020045,
-0.5644955635,
-0.0694047585,
0.467846334,
-0.1176581681,
0.5550575852,
0.3958162963,
-0.0717747435,
-0.3349218965,
-0.172569558,
-0.0606587939,
-0.6743085384,
0.2339265943,
-0.5011637211,
0.3768544793,
0.2064731717,
-0.3865923285,
-0.5359650254,
0.5415884852,
0.7306936383,
-0.2007074505,
0.5514142513,
-0.1462106258,
-0.4118692577,
-0.0808677971,
-0.2262828201,
0.0876084715,
-0.6188198924,
-0.1297663599,
-0.3179377913,
-0.8035187125,
0.4314347208,
-0.2417679578,
0.2354793847,
0.3949708939,
0.6011239886,
-0.1084611714,
0.7717005014,
0.8073685169,
-0.2330993265,
0.5098997951,
0.1948117465,
0.4810752273,
-0.7415738106,
-0.2626350522,
-0.7515544891,
-0.2657698393,
-0.5382736325,
-0.0427576713,
0.2044418603,
-0.0000475065,
-0.3402563632,
0.15368025,
-0.3277090788,
0.8217836618,
1.1010223627,
-0.1861734986,
0.3631857932,
-0.1236263663,
0.0270060189,
0.0010208022,
-0.293094486,
-1.0312199593,
0.6585644484,
0.7090057731,
0.8206446767,
0.0580912046,
0.3315531015,
0.7274718881,
0.2190401852,
-0.4940191805,
0.7927368283,
0.2100538164,
-0.544454515,
-0.1296831816,
-0.229175508,
-0.9703577161,
-0.2280166596,
-0.0397706814,
-0.9262917042,
0.1608960778,
0.0079756323,
-0.1928840578,
0.5194105506,
-0.4712192714,
0.5715910196,
-0.2805043459,
-0.1348449141,
0.0269190352,
-0.5466073155,
0.1974840611,
-0.21204032,
-0.2408603281,
-0.2937172651,
-0.2361362875,
0.7391918898,
-0.4304369986,
0.7936293483,
-0.374840349,
0.1492451578,
0.740835309,
0.1065495163,
0.3419726193,
0.238732636,
-0.0941762626,
-0.0599692501,
-0.1149253547,
-0.3761163056,
-0.1831844747,
0.4754332304,
-0.6361831427,
-0.9569606185,
-0.4239447117,
-0.2960161567,
0.3300021589,
0.255410552,
0.3644122183,
0.0682400987,
-0.1065466404,
0.0324653238,
0.5207614303,
-0.5402493477,
0.8244478703,
0.6527534127,
0.0580587387,
-0.4771465659,
0.8459573984,
0.0709330514,
0.3742158413,
0.3849438131,
0.2432155907,
-0.4439274073,
-0.7440094352,
-0.1339049488,
-0.0572266243,
-0.9102676511,
-0.3976426721,
-0.7497757077,
-0.3723357618,
-0.3559352458,
-0.4370302558,
0.242584914,
-0.8593447804,
-0.4117635787,
-0.2364856303,
0.5651928782,
0.7980861068,
-0.3828251362,
0.5076033473,
-0.8513490558,
0.1787006855,
0.2271914035,
0.3620766997,
-0.1935773045,
-0.2463213503,
-0.0114451926,
-0.0287824012,
-0.2115167528,
-0.4986071587,
0.3251885176,
0.0429721251,
0.7995647192,
0.7072770596,
0.2937120497,
0.0189520922,
-0.6039595008,
1.0693999529,
0.201809451,
-0.9644095898,
0.5699315667,
-0.2767588496,
-0.3818855286,
0.1328013986,
0.4561526775,
-0.7335364223,
-0.3840218186,
-0.5168607235,
-0.8160071969,
0.3780913651,
0.0425941646,
0.3803031743,
-0.2403868884,
0.328951478,
0.1587157249,
0.3480359018,
-0.8657146096,
-0.1220088229,
-0.0069960952,
0.0011590654,
0.3787837029,
-0.5395198464,
-0.3101150692,
0.4626383781,
0.5582607985,
0.1306113601,
0.4974479675,
0.0291990191,
-0.0481294543,
0.1955085844,
0.2777363062,
0.6004921198,
0.4022402167,
0.1457645744,
0.3249275982,
-0.4433020055,
-0.6965397596,
0.6412320733,
-0.0729956627,
-0.4552531838,
-0.3116721511,
0.2796427608,
0.5045586824,
-0.4601228237,
-0.6839355826,
0.5660645366,
-0.077365689,
0.1784120798,
-0.0612877756,
0.0599414483,
-0.2977897823,
0.6667563915,
0.0231208429,
-0.2857144177,
0.1001970768,
-0.5332614779,
0.2302971482,
0.4711158574,
-0.2413130403,
-0.466147542,
1.0010778904,
0.5335605145,
-0.5507830977,
0.6732594967,
-0.1264356524,
-0.4358463883,
0.9220013618,
0.9214148521,
1.3330899477,
-0.0733780116,
0.1220571995,
-0.1118780151,
0.3771655858,
0.0439776853,
0.5569577217,
0.3389270306,
-0.5876732469,
0.1600892395,
-0.0422582999,
-0.8338226676,
-0.1464286149,
0.009415295,
0.428217262,
-0.723987639,
-0.3194892704,
-0.190829739,
-0.3104556203,
-0.35896644,
-0.1254652292,
0.1237436607,
1.3507119417,
-0.7487576604,
0.3476124108,
0.5747420192,
-0.4442664981,
-0.1873122901,
-0.1237429008,
-0.2658474445,
-0.8236876726,
0.7651770711,
0.1992838234,
0.3137275875,
0.0297732744,
-0.7327450514,
-0.7816335559,
1.0278276205,
0.385660708,
-0.2347356677,
0.1715902835,
0.3146951199,
0.0900828242,
-0.3538881838,
0.2880403101,
0.27006495,
0.4629096389,
-0.1336245537,
-0.3990624845,
0.0035133492,
-0.2003507018,
-0.1157830656,
0.0430380553,
-0.4986631274,
0.4543220699,
-0.2595764995,
-0.4975961745,
0.4808635414,
0.6273369193,
0.4499917626,
0.6448788643,
0.1747078896,
0.1837298572,
0.9216102958,
-0.298222363,
0.856993258,
-0.5579742789,
-0.1819059849,
0.6424825191,
-0.5850278735,
0.6074049473,
0.2886159718,
-0.1355315745,
0.0692546889,
0.8790925741,
-0.0567885637,
0.5480155945,
0.3048425019,
-0.643404603,
0.3366835713,
-0.6542771459,
-0.405693084,
-0.0505914018,
0.3209686875,
-0.2294032425,
0.1687370837,
0.082371667,
0.1175975278,
-0.1570008099,
-0.4957514703,
0.615298152,
0.3868020177,
-0.3040670455,
-0.171548456,
0.057161063,
0.4017992914,
-0.6040638089,
-0.0011281951,
-0.2884177566,
-0.2201990932,
-0.0206926651,
-0.9163092971,
0.1737367809,
0.029702235,
-0.2501754463,
-0.4322658777,
1.1581052542,
-0.0786276162,
0.0390077867,
0.196886301,
0.4722272158,
0.2336516976,
0.1937308013,
-0.6041852236,
-0.2405778766,
-0.4988225102,
-0.3006851971,
0.0747435465,
0.4589084089,
-0.2354149222,
0.8472790718,
0.5180271864,
0.4861197174,
0.3611550331,
-0.0486450866,
0.9996985793,
-0.764454484,
-0.5013853908,
-0.8721094728,
0.592874825,
-0.0269516557,
0.0695264339,
0.7293889523,
0.3820476532,
0.2839034498,
-0.2095613927,
1.0163892508,
0.1963708103,
0.2720929086,
-0.7810531259,
0.8571320772,
0.0501042008,
0.4592178166,
-0.1031831056,
-0.9764261246,
-0.2859745622,
0.1147323251,
-0.0621788613,
-0.1287786216,
0.458140552,
0.5047087669,
0.3162585795,
0.0191839337,
0.2811679542,
0.018701667,
0.6885298491,
0.4515314996,
1.4406958818,
0.1358255595,
0.0504032895,
-0.0684483349,
-0.5685315132,
-0.2205936462,
-1.338275671,
-0.783375144,
-0.01503802,
-0.4194743037,
-0.5465044975,
0.1575721055,
0.968611002,
0.3856381476,
-0.6384233832,
-0.203962326,
0.0176390428,
0.4448983073,
-0.1404301375,
-0.1522312611,
0.1586479992,
-0.3721310198,
-0.6033685803,
0.3553580046,
0.7495931387,
0.6373534799,
-0.2320025414,
0.1078215092,
0.2336743027,
0.4858696163,
0.5749149919,
0.8131472468,
-0.2695381641,
-0.1110727862,
0.1208719462,
-0.0833098367,
0.1073784158,
0.9584944248,
-0.5481335521,
0.2932378352,
1.1275002956,
0.8026909828,
-0.5344586372,
-0.092124477,
0.7716249228,
-0.5585356355,
0.5423501134,
0.3011371791,
0.6930116415,
0.0673116893,
-0.5372179747,
0.4753664136,
0.3055419028,
-0.7930153608,
-0.7832120061,
0.591625452,
-0.6236811876,
-0.0143331373,
1.0036718845,
-0.5720716715,
0.0124598788,
-0.2775862813,
-0.3900505304,
-0.2410547435,
-0.2790990472,
0.525321722,
0.6302814484,
0.0466383249,
-0.0928588733,
-0.5323410034,
0.4683609605,
-0.1469647139,
-0.8750363588,
0.1436239332,
0.0550192334,
-0.0914480686,
0.116397962,
0.9763986468,
-0.328564316,
0.1363968849,
-0.2626317739,
-0.181914404,
0.0227989405,
-0.7947890162,
-0.6129750013,
0.1178611591,
0.7859367132,
-0.318282187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06264v1 | Measuring and Modifying Factual Knowledge in Large Language Models | 2023-06-09T21:25:48 | 2023-06-09T21:25:48 | Pouya Pezeshkpour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) store an extensive amount of factual knowledge
obtained from vast collections of text. To effectively utilize these models for
downstream tasks, it is crucial to have reliable methods for measuring their
knowledge. However, existing approaches for knowledge measurement have certain
limitations, and despite recent efforts, they fail to provide accurate
measurements and the necessary insights for modifying the knowledge within
LLMs. In this work, we employ information theory-based measurements to provide
a framework estimating the factual knowledge contained within large language
models. More specifically, we measure knowledge by analyzing the LLM's
prediction probability distribution before and after instilling the target
knowledge, employing metrics such as entropy and KL-divergence. Introducing our
metrics, we first assess their accuracy in comparison to previous ranking-based
methods, surpassing them by over $35\%$ in a synthetic experiment. Then, we
explore two prominent methods of knowledge instillation, discovering that LLMs
exhibit limitations in capturing new knowledge under specific circumstances for
one of these methods. Lastly, we demonstrate the applicability of our methods
in extracting unlearned and mislearned facts in LLMs through their application
to in-context learning. We make code and data for all methods and experiments
in this paper publicly available. | [
-0.19289276,
-0.8716055751,
0.8666784763,
-0.0189570338,
-0.0903437883,
0.0761802047,
-0.5963028669,
-0.3597477376,
-0.1018735692,
0.3096296191,
-0.1104693413,
-0.6132937074,
-0.6769673824,
-0.3040801585,
-0.3163349032,
0.9569581151,
-0.074275203,
0.0827590004,
-0.6663651466,
-0.0098214056,
-0.3651567101,
-0.4099545181,
-0.2425265312,
-0.4507755637,
0.3953791261,
0.4615278542,
0.5658305287,
0.3823723793,
0.3832704425,
0.1990495622,
-0.252563864,
0.2725521326,
-0.534343183,
-0.0253368635,
-0.3438631296,
-0.6950160265,
-0.0890748799,
0.0712174326,
1.1867675781,
0.8026590943,
-0.266978085,
0.3063794076,
0.3121721745,
0.4093935192,
-0.8968530297,
0.4580617249,
-0.8911222816,
0.0840482041,
-0.222377494,
-0.3315806687,
-0.4411131442,
-0.5448128581,
0.2641884089,
-0.3908990324,
0.0146168182,
-0.0829929784,
0.477818042,
0.2151778191,
-0.6033468246,
-0.5223889947,
-0.9134477377,
0.9287400246,
-1.0589953661,
0.6063227057,
0.5499503613,
0.0232241657,
-0.3465211093,
-0.5391528606,
-0.7484871149,
-0.5305306315,
-0.1463513523,
-0.1126870736,
-0.0503514074,
-0.0912630856,
0.3560629785,
0.284039706,
-0.2286346257,
0.1543695033,
-0.2478070855,
-0.1233700141,
0.5547759533,
0.1105260178,
0.1981086582,
0.1373969764,
-0.3154744506,
-0.1044938937,
-0.772167027,
-0.11123579,
0.2129697353,
0.011241083,
-0.0783437863,
0.6463611722,
-0.0094677191,
0.5904250741,
-0.1366079003,
-0.6689677238,
0.2028246671,
-0.2988408208,
-0.3102375567,
0.1247721687,
0.6718950272,
0.113372758,
0.0145264184,
-0.1527779251,
-0.109099783,
-0.2311178148,
-0.1311220825,
-0.7304576039,
-0.0762080029,
-0.1047148407,
0.0020103289,
-0.2143353671,
0.0365329646,
-0.519146502,
-0.6626737118,
-0.2489811927,
0.4548499584,
-0.5872881413,
-0.2448200136,
0.1045538187,
-0.025580842,
0.2292226851,
0.3047821224,
-0.7680057287,
0.0183861144,
0.5975772738,
0.7362797856,
-0.0568081364,
-0.3069496155,
-0.1337687373,
0.3540949523,
-0.5849822164,
0.5514793992,
-0.3100281954,
-0.1054925919,
0.1818973273,
-0.3185848892,
-0.1234537363,
-0.5385015607,
0.3501088619,
-0.8207924962,
0.0707004666,
-0.2857998013,
-1.2050446272,
-0.310544014,
0.4856771827,
-0.2872247398,
0.8557367921,
-0.0840777084,
-0.8998351693,
0.4875165522,
-0.453222692,
-0.3356251419,
-0.0711749643,
0.0157285947,
-0.2230225503,
0.1447102875,
-0.1423146427,
0.6680446863,
-0.3356388807,
0.4999379516,
-0.5427735448,
-0.2090614438,
0.7704578042,
-0.6398599744,
0.6432561874,
0.0548772514,
-0.1283065975,
-0.2326139063,
-0.6738641262,
-0.0417657271,
-0.0254934933,
-0.5645363331,
-0.4689893425,
0.1431901604,
-0.3942300081,
-0.0512007661,
0.3840176761,
-0.628534615,
0.15926148,
-0.4353398681,
0.0725582615,
0.7057453394,
0.1762551814,
0.4590406716,
-0.2374871075,
0.2099724114,
0.0615358055,
-0.0231239684,
0.1668575704,
-0.1390164495,
-0.7220857143,
-0.1727665961,
0.3171880841,
0.4589150846,
-0.5935393572,
0.4698973894,
-0.4612928927,
-0.6346683502,
-0.1664485335,
0.404969722,
0.1725528985,
0.4586423934,
0.2550376952,
-0.0388085209,
-0.2546694279,
-0.5143243074,
-0.4240833819,
-0.4700700343,
-0.0563169383,
-0.0044135149,
0.4471683204,
-0.2918719053,
0.8807449341,
-0.5909202695,
-0.109765619,
-0.0855515897,
0.0988717154,
0.276986748,
0.4713020325,
0.3034927547,
-0.3125053346,
-0.3430767655,
0.1251024604,
-1.0322951078,
0.1022303328,
0.0025517517,
0.1525375247,
0.3371956348,
0.6060062647,
-0.6532533765,
0.3325897157,
0.5124495625,
-0.3395130932,
0.8384394646,
-0.2990552187,
0.1245430931,
-1.0070152283,
-0.1316037476,
0.0546247773,
-0.1569841504,
-0.6033757329,
0.1352106184,
0.1641313583,
0.4432324469,
-0.4131937027,
0.6276440024,
-0.3798683882,
-0.0544323064,
-0.1377717108,
0.2172053009,
-0.1499114186,
0.235747233,
-0.1691913009,
0.5128284693,
0.3999622762,
-0.8204937577,
0.3976583481,
0.0841500387,
-1.1075181961,
0.5611922145,
-0.3251969516,
-0.0023660664,
-0.1366674155,
0.1960477084,
-0.8738474846,
-0.3577383161,
0.1468231529,
-0.3862150311,
0.4231148958,
-0.1999770552,
-0.8534578681,
0.1197074801,
-0.1217986867,
0.3702239394,
0.4803178012,
-0.6135401726,
0.4793980122,
0.3631392717,
-0.1419541538,
-0.6559932232,
-0.6671173573,
0.0932060555,
-0.3768014014,
-0.5537133813,
0.1563569605,
-0.2219142914,
-0.6752448082,
0.0311746877,
0.0301801972,
-0.0498541892,
0.0591261126,
-0.0716084316,
0.1247262359,
-0.271454215,
0.6535808444,
0.1470803916,
0.2602141798,
0.3941991627,
-0.4681171775,
0.3315048814,
0.0209657345,
-0.8080993295,
-0.3468007147,
-0.176895842,
0.724693656,
-0.1016069055,
1.1293535233,
0.4841010869,
-0.4651652575,
-0.3255666792,
-0.8780318499,
-0.1677470803,
-0.4195047021,
0.5059220195,
-0.0315654203,
-0.8281440139,
0.5041320324,
-0.1428265423,
0.0474513173,
0.2451966405,
0.5111818314,
-0.2071249485,
0.7306458354,
0.6095470786,
-0.0577846244,
0.4123085439,
-0.2333582789,
0.3523441851,
-0.6875367761,
-0.3383201361,
-0.251698494,
-0.0350249708,
-0.3671660423,
-0.61338377,
0.6838653684,
0.3132607043,
-0.2717069089,
-0.1812236607,
0.3770861626,
0.4664368629,
0.4949821234,
0.1717784703,
0.507091105,
0.0195236057,
-0.0437620878,
0.0112674134,
-0.6800658703,
-0.3826058209,
1.1034272909,
0.4590150118,
0.7924587727,
0.2107615918,
0.4606354535,
0.1881114244,
0.4682987928,
-0.8633372784,
0.4166717529,
0.1950459778,
-0.4436795712,
-0.6039742827,
-0.6311021447,
-0.481970042,
0.0527748689,
-0.2450237572,
-0.7009236217,
0.0900203213,
0.312228322,
-0.0630825087,
0.735226512,
-0.5630300045,
0.5241010785,
-0.2017255574,
-0.3167025447,
-0.3991025686,
-0.2382612079,
0.5172773004,
-0.2881571054,
0.3602835238,
-0.0309544541,
0.1424119622,
0.7230545878,
-0.2804953754,
0.9303859472,
-0.2068158835,
-0.5226917267,
0.3114196956,
0.2262207717,
0.6776539087,
0.1034918576,
-0.1415711343,
0.1351700425,
0.1856663823,
-0.3782908618,
-0.8883515596,
0.6213753819,
-0.5560634136,
-0.6272465587,
-0.372284621,
-0.741874814,
-0.5974240303,
-0.0618116595,
0.1641053408,
0.2731195986,
-0.3070297837,
0.4359327555,
0.8686497211,
-0.3678475618,
0.2556609511,
0.7794408202,
-0.1877536029,
-0.1164934859,
0.8340557814,
0.3899582326,
0.5423410535,
0.4504526854,
0.5054597855,
-0.4787784517,
-0.5795083046,
0.0060498812,
0.2521387339,
-0.9708855748,
-0.248915121,
-0.463701725,
-0.2134345025,
-0.488083005,
0.0948525518,
-0.2423645705,
-0.1172393486,
-0.1626602709,
-0.4240262508,
0.3642728329,
0.8880798221,
-0.2637885809,
0.1609794945,
-0.703083694,
-0.3215041757,
0.3813991845,
0.4145396352,
0.2451208383,
-0.8014309406,
-0.6694291234,
0.3500208557,
-0.0680217147,
-0.7598361969,
0.2465598881,
0.1067037731,
0.4761675596,
0.521441102,
0.0296162367,
0.5879412293,
-0.2170695961,
0.6607246995,
0.1042264104,
-0.9926223755,
0.3744175732,
-0.1555685997,
0.2374217957,
0.2786129713,
0.233931765,
-0.5611216426,
-0.6066935062,
-0.5485011935,
-0.4838136137,
0.3666396141,
-0.2187139541,
0.2293354124,
0.1420822442,
0.3488001525,
0.0342127718,
0.1408842504,
-0.6447914243,
-0.1519694328,
0.3376934528,
-0.2598477304,
-0.3743785322,
-0.5048648119,
-0.0345585309,
-0.4612783194,
0.9777398109,
-0.0849456936,
-0.0149378674,
-0.0185525957,
-0.3658872545,
0.0140336361,
0.3888278902,
0.6305463314,
1.081884861,
-0.1561158597,
0.4094921649,
0.6146577001,
-0.4258255363,
0.131573841,
-0.1002521068,
-0.2330016643,
-0.1274016649,
0.6475327015,
0.7348556519,
0.3006930053,
-0.6820812821,
0.4578823149,
0.2704030871,
-0.0305988397,
-0.5265535712,
0.1024003327,
0.2208351642,
0.3901928365,
0.1931409091,
-0.0971601084,
-0.1691769063,
-0.674855113,
0.2161100358,
0.4703476727,
-0.5353322029,
-0.3682900071,
0.0638203248,
-0.3356820941,
0.1231421009,
0.5307222009,
-0.1896418482,
-0.3729839921,
0.331384033,
0.6963689923,
0.4790007174,
-0.3134458065,
0.3230428994,
0.3633731902,
0.3640546799,
-0.1482872814,
-0.0181050505,
0.0980570316,
-1.2309703827,
-0.5234755278,
-0.7117997408,
-0.2037503868,
0.2886390686,
-0.4440322518,
0.053997919,
-0.2796722949,
0.0776931867,
-0.2164524645,
-0.0079003805,
-0.6876143217,
0.0911078975,
-0.002678663,
0.869992137,
-0.8633352518,
0.7945754528,
0.5589669347,
-0.2267701477,
-0.8909426928,
0.3541049659,
-0.0131618474,
-0.7259739637,
0.5692511201,
-0.2764007747,
-0.0622940846,
0.023733709,
-0.7085311413,
-0.9985213876,
1.054930687,
0.6592173576,
-0.359529525,
0.2625068128,
0.2533962131,
0.4908506572,
-0.1865456998,
0.1345508844,
0.6149625778,
0.5899199247,
0.0669439808,
-0.7436440587,
-0.0127821947,
0.1099803671,
-0.273211956,
0.1143650934,
-0.2661594748,
0.6408554912,
-0.3576745093,
-0.3240412176,
-0.2555540204,
0.6839746237,
0.2629003525,
0.2931251228,
0.5281682611,
0.6673977971,
1.1326861382,
0.2064030021,
0.9122781754,
-0.2212413251,
0.4767072201,
1.0858329535,
-0.2448342741,
0.8712540865,
0.542071104,
-0.2611040771,
0.5434634686,
0.338396281,
0.2036214173,
0.2874251008,
0.3538346291,
-0.6015354991,
-0.1417996436,
-0.2603293955,
-0.2823753655,
0.4441975355,
0.5675368309,
-0.2629054487,
-0.0442646071,
0.070817709,
0.4357572496,
0.0030746525,
-0.1592382938,
0.9525029063,
0.1360601187,
-0.6397642493,
0.6380052567,
0.0953865051,
0.4844475389,
-0.6017511487,
-0.045678895,
-0.2544018328,
0.348829031,
-0.0964958742,
-0.9659715295,
0.1334502101,
0.00469526,
-0.1450036466,
0.0198018122,
0.6877279878,
-0.7818855047,
-0.6640002131,
0.1916461885,
0.5605630279,
0.0122468285,
-0.0659034029,
-0.1752053946,
-0.0520511568,
-0.0787434801,
-0.169752121,
0.3638257384,
0.6487442851,
0.2125769705,
0.739851892,
0.5768796802,
0.3094570935,
0.1333004981,
-0.1367353201,
0.541138649,
-0.4141024649,
-0.3161154389,
-1.1230208874,
0.3338727653,
-0.018101275,
-0.1273123026,
0.924762249,
0.3840530217,
1.0339109898,
-0.0725113004,
1.0212260485,
-0.0099071395,
0.3894300759,
-0.8575881124,
0.7725942731,
-0.4961586595,
0.4484224916,
-0.1850024611,
-0.8935181499,
-0.2110946923,
0.3163233399,
-0.3909309804,
-0.2151085138,
0.6714336872,
0.8603667617,
-0.0835073367,
-0.1109868363,
0.4801807106,
0.6432154775,
0.218689844,
0.2824806273,
1.1141107082,
-0.0909436345,
0.2360696197,
-0.2429836392,
-0.3799493313,
-0.0792466253,
-0.9026226997,
-0.8061477542,
-0.6873566508,
-0.3199115694,
-0.3468168974,
0.0198226776,
0.8747109771,
0.5037023425,
-0.7735931873,
-0.4508652091,
0.1330586076,
0.4560471177,
-0.1088919118,
-0.2324410826,
0.4192847311,
-0.4880201519,
-0.3445608616,
0.5522662997,
0.042911455,
0.0048973365,
-0.4453407228,
-0.104879275,
-0.3290291429,
0.1785799563,
0.8680999279,
0.1287373453,
-0.5396922231,
-0.6344922185,
-0.2786298692,
0.0573856756,
-0.2281500697,
0.6793107986,
-0.4900858998,
0.3748691678,
0.6980712414,
0.6297755241,
0.3816998005,
-0.239712894,
0.6316919923,
-0.9781250358,
-0.0746108815,
0.0170028619,
0.5057681799,
0.4752797484,
-0.2926431596,
0.2832917869,
0.3763134181,
-0.4484885037,
-1.0192745924,
0.28935799,
-0.4297571778,
-0.2772861421,
1.2003704309,
-0.2887391448,
0.0402285829,
0.0510748029,
0.2640765607,
0.2997522354,
-0.108913973,
0.8411060572,
0.8403570652,
0.1743737459,
0.0802214146,
-0.6457707286,
0.5813004375,
0.1426867694,
-0.7818648815,
0.0900351852,
0.494091779,
0.5148026943,
0.1528139263,
0.4291738868,
-0.0408273749,
-0.2063564658,
-0.2465248704,
0.1206844375,
0.2309776843,
-0.3381026387,
-0.1121918112,
0.0932782888,
0.170670107,
0.1925441474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06246v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06246v1 | Record Deduplication for Entity Distribution Modeling in ASR Transcripts | 2023-06-09T20:42:11 | 2023-06-09T20:42:11 | Tianyu Huang, Chung Hoon Hong, Carl Wivagg, Kanna Shimizu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Voice digital assistants must keep up with trending search queries. We rely
on a speech recognition model using contextual biasing with a rapidly updated
set of entities, instead of frequent model retraining, to keep up with trends.
There are several challenges with this approach: (1) the entity set must be
frequently reconstructed, (2) the entity set is of limited size due to latency
and accuracy trade-offs, and (3) finding the true entity distribution for
biasing is complicated by ASR misrecognition. We address these challenges and
define an entity set by modeling customers true requested entity distribution
from ASR output in production using record deduplication, a technique from the
field of entity resolution. Record deduplication resolves or deduplicates
coreferences, including misrecognitions, of the same latent entity. Our method
successfully retrieves 95% of misrecognized entities and when used for
contextual biasing shows an estimated 5% relative word error rate reduction. | [
-0.4044605494,
-0.5180625916,
0.2188812792,
0.0837971941,
-0.2749197781,
-0.092818372,
0.0445924699,
-0.4337584078,
0.3132665455,
0.9492748976,
-0.6565031409,
-0.1908193231,
-0.564730525,
0.0289527848,
-0.7012357712,
0.7976123095,
0.0880151019,
0.1190076247,
-0.1235416383,
-0.2396143526,
-0.7290318608,
-0.6915013194,
-0.7984269261,
-0.3657959402,
-0.0418051407,
0.2618428469,
0.3478455842,
0.9246829748,
0.4244484007,
0.2451410294,
-0.4266015589,
-0.0182564743,
-0.2339276671,
0.3497582078,
-0.0820623934,
-0.2849363089,
-0.4224635065,
-0.0436929278,
0.9377034903,
0.9287481308,
-0.3222282529,
0.0420031287,
0.0415344946,
0.5869787335,
-0.6114190221,
-0.267146647,
-0.8544925451,
0.0379918851,
-0.0966562703,
-0.2174299061,
-0.2747452259,
-0.2583807111,
0.4122082889,
-0.4330286086,
0.7903388739,
-0.2896322608,
0.6663185358,
0.6582567096,
-0.4682577848,
-0.579206109,
-1.3465692997,
0.6809268594,
-0.3561652899,
0.6826499701,
0.3458089232,
0.2992158234,
0.2278455943,
-0.5998234153,
-0.6519591212,
-0.0744801983,
0.2586488426,
-0.1793115586,
-0.2182046026,
-0.2263273299,
0.4710404873,
0.3554537594,
-0.2390085161,
0.1431838721,
-0.4179191887,
0.001023869,
0.5162356496,
0.0500550605,
0.198151499,
-0.0910134539,
-0.3878301382,
-0.2672989666,
-0.5883752704,
-0.3241236508,
0.3161139488,
0.0960170627,
0.4028021991,
0.4431352019,
-0.0320457928,
0.4741636217,
0.2754046321,
-0.0569209568,
0.3616961539,
-0.0595606305,
-0.4108355939,
0.6787444949,
0.3722348809,
0.1175742522,
-0.1190325767,
0.0616787262,
-0.3504869342,
0.0019208357,
0.4750627875,
-0.4736894667,
-0.1671447456,
0.065845713,
-0.3859902322,
0.0659982562,
-0.0450205468,
-0.7196289897,
-0.3860753775,
-0.5648226738,
0.2120554149,
-0.2642172277,
-0.2928364277,
0.0031600094,
-0.3672460914,
-0.2014766484,
0.3827745318,
-0.6038570404,
0.415063858,
0.6674366593,
0.6005442739,
-0.1270558536,
-0.1188936159,
-0.4287957549,
0.4533635378,
-0.2198745608,
0.6977041364,
-0.3622678518,
-0.77484864,
-0.1427594721,
-0.036674168,
-0.0356819034,
-1.1559705734,
0.725325942,
-0.6048676968,
-0.1889469475,
-0.4636776149,
-0.7174108028,
-0.2349007726,
0.0917041525,
-0.9132965803,
0.7240108848,
-0.0973704308,
-0.5356351137,
0.5977414846,
-0.3555196822,
-0.2587324381,
0.0436573774,
-0.179285273,
-0.4276509285,
-0.0390748456,
0.0724751353,
0.1928786188,
-0.3239008188,
0.3338728547,
0.0201330334,
-0.2399698943,
-0.0222700592,
-0.672997117,
0.83586061,
0.3893121779,
-0.4836032689,
-0.1852410138,
-0.7628301382,
-0.4241721034,
-0.0843951777,
-0.311480999,
-0.7178300619,
0.1648610085,
0.1079711914,
-0.0337210186,
-0.0347312987,
-0.2448179573,
0.117985189,
-0.3243319392,
0.2682779729,
0.4031224549,
0.4081811905,
0.6936538219,
-0.2654161453,
0.4185976088,
0.4954025745,
-0.0082965232,
0.0966090634,
-0.2457065433,
-0.7482239008,
-0.3426917195,
0.2211822122,
0.711235106,
-0.5222861171,
0.5000510216,
-0.2977465093,
-0.4101330638,
-0.4205330312,
0.0470106751,
0.4666061401,
0.7292080522,
0.465061903,
-0.3887919486,
-0.5541503429,
-1.0414720774,
-0.0853246748,
0.2384586036,
-0.3184309602,
0.3756829202,
0.1719463766,
-0.5755280256,
0.8346907496,
-0.5906404853,
-0.8649104238,
-0.0521787591,
0.1250201017,
-0.062722154,
0.7512152791,
0.3688366413,
-1.0839859247,
-0.1030479297,
-0.4379509389,
-0.5479869843,
-0.0737414584,
-0.2627297342,
0.0713818893,
0.4246870875,
0.3627235293,
-0.7355573773,
0.5401311517,
0.1495227516,
-0.1591489613,
0.1934603155,
-0.2124553919,
0.0865087062,
-1.0694041252,
0.0429768823,
0.1503678411,
-0.1253461391,
-0.6857816577,
-0.310395062,
-0.1328616291,
-0.2507126629,
-0.2520344257,
0.3078847826,
-0.7091870308,
-0.4633974135,
-0.2195024043,
0.3265154064,
-0.0023137925,
-0.0118245129,
0.2433362901,
0.6717354059,
0.2989681661,
-1.1127694845,
0.3140087128,
0.7073723674,
-0.3689990938,
0.6673997641,
-0.5995528102,
0.2535083592,
-0.3548395038,
0.3735325933,
-0.5626143813,
0.1345978826,
0.1535031945,
-0.3410887122,
0.463871181,
-0.2437426597,
-0.1772180498,
-0.2078722268,
0.0387304164,
0.23655729,
0.4128854573,
-0.5251831412,
0.7073962688,
0.6717716455,
-0.0505816489,
-0.7960653305,
-0.7577245831,
-0.1284178942,
-0.2769933343,
-0.3216506541,
0.5548406243,
0.0527530685,
-0.3889757693,
0.0758527592,
-0.3976297081,
-0.1871011406,
-0.0303163659,
0.1119446307,
0.0854272321,
-0.0793722197,
0.3157935143,
0.1309763491,
0.0380453691,
-0.0018960813,
-0.2733723819,
0.5178673863,
0.4942932427,
-0.3914066255,
-0.3985099196,
0.5679805279,
0.246441856,
-0.1176669747,
0.4853223264,
0.3132942021,
-0.8730087876,
-0.2944387496,
-0.9637545347,
-0.2109816819,
-0.399435699,
0.1435227394,
-0.5529429913,
-0.3465294838,
0.8373954892,
0.2694716156,
-0.0818397626,
0.5387938619,
0.3356691003,
0.2359681875,
0.7767552137,
0.1959582567,
-0.1881809533,
0.5452183485,
-0.4984588623,
0.0922522619,
-1.0453836918,
-0.2389234453,
-0.7792022228,
-0.1099079698,
-0.5197895169,
-0.4581940472,
0.2005393803,
0.3218930066,
-0.0441180244,
0.2759258449,
-0.7017338276,
0.3139750957,
0.9383137226,
0.2254483402,
0.4378495216,
0.0349088497,
0.2998752892,
0.0547297932,
-0.1762309819,
-0.6027985215,
0.7670519352,
0.2086632252,
0.6195462942,
0.2892192304,
0.7480073571,
0.5134336948,
0.1738446355,
-0.6736739278,
0.4631006122,
-0.337621063,
-0.6530979872,
-0.4296358824,
-0.4567565322,
-0.7794634104,
-0.0942908004,
0.0336458161,
-0.7244916558,
0.6693085432,
0.610206306,
-0.1430730522,
0.1902042329,
-0.4432242811,
0.7486999631,
0.3317262232,
0.0790047422,
-0.1341594458,
-0.4284909964,
0.1544024646,
-0.0100568803,
-0.2115046531,
0.0076443162,
0.172473073,
0.7953569889,
-0.399640888,
0.4982635379,
-0.5740673542,
-0.0237382855,
0.5246449113,
0.1945393831,
0.4822490215,
0.0397569686,
-0.0657568201,
0.0554760993,
0.056703601,
0.0080574462,
-0.4592637718,
0.9542021155,
-0.7257198095,
-0.6737784147,
-0.2956001759,
-0.2585070729,
0.0004453087,
0.1327727139,
0.5614019632,
0.582054019,
-0.2450832576,
0.1310895085,
0.947794795,
-0.138357535,
0.3304145336,
0.3995581865,
0.2755890787,
-0.1645507812,
0.6915533543,
0.3805116117,
0.098223336,
0.3526343405,
-0.0940807462,
-0.6535544395,
-0.4685289264,
-0.529098928,
0.1354487538,
-0.9861982465,
-0.1976324469,
-1.1753863096,
-0.1885055602,
-0.6688261032,
0.1163630188,
-0.4390298724,
-0.3790834248,
-0.79767102,
0.0097509213,
0.0884254128,
0.649925828,
0.0070979311,
0.2007891387,
-0.8494769931,
0.4748569131,
0.3508098722,
0.1996311396,
0.1554551125,
-0.7034913898,
0.1486785114,
0.2289375067,
-0.4336264133,
-1.0914266109,
0.6541451812,
0.1409434974,
0.6105749607,
0.227079168,
0.2162522525,
0.7292352915,
-0.6527602673,
0.8336363435,
-0.1224011034,
-1.1900345087,
0.7249474525,
-0.1679060161,
0.0814362913,
0.4479279518,
0.4400340915,
-0.6051904559,
-0.1364550442,
-0.7822173834,
-0.9032128453,
0.7030201554,
0.0047806678,
0.0340118781,
-0.2298474163,
0.4032689035,
-0.1500769556,
0.2270762771,
-0.2233100384,
-0.3704702556,
-0.3011360765,
-0.2193566561,
-0.2680926919,
-0.5529040694,
-0.0705695823,
-0.0445652269,
0.7567734122,
0.1438853294,
0.4654652178,
0.5168392062,
-0.3034459054,
-0.0525691807,
0.2538766265,
0.8070677519,
0.6069021821,
-0.3076862991,
0.0126967998,
0.1542262435,
-0.7032018304,
0.1716944724,
0.3234205246,
-0.5092368126,
0.3837200999,
-0.0925857574,
0.9481382966,
-0.0223295093,
-0.6225401759,
0.4731206894,
0.1750075966,
-0.1285738945,
-1.0728871822,
-0.06737414,
0.1058713943,
0.322265774,
0.6320743561,
0.1166843697,
0.7047204375,
-0.434117198,
0.361589551,
0.305939734,
-0.5129831433,
-0.0762244612,
0.9069716334,
0.0108724935,
-0.5353803039,
0.9951315522,
-0.0567063577,
-0.5444194674,
0.8016446233,
0.6345765591,
1.0468084812,
-0.5650048256,
-0.06881883,
0.2981027663,
-0.0371480808,
-0.6622658968,
0.1676951498,
0.0054097567,
-0.8652889132,
-0.1151551381,
-0.4235619009,
-0.428627193,
0.250380218,
-0.9725216627,
0.4273147881,
-0.3267700076,
-0.2721978426,
0.3024749756,
-0.2952786386,
-0.7004252672,
0.4253914356,
0.0290380772,
0.7315866351,
-0.7055951357,
0.763525486,
0.5694683194,
-0.5275315046,
-0.8477215171,
0.1014142707,
0.1976358891,
-0.2376506478,
1.0826935768,
0.0748409852,
-0.056232173,
0.0903097391,
-0.0073995041,
-0.6638507843,
1.1349927187,
0.1803629547,
-0.6372467875,
-0.1290660501,
-0.116148591,
0.4985531867,
-0.5042533278,
-0.0087856501,
0.7049450278,
0.0067231553,
0.1962806731,
-1.0110366344,
0.0088716913,
0.0803676695,
0.2548393309,
0.3322967589,
-0.1657271385,
0.8230920434,
0.0388661288,
-0.4069132507,
-0.2913531363,
0.2914977372,
0.2901310325,
0.5910475254,
0.738463223,
0.5537104607,
0.6337513328,
0.0511149019,
0.880533576,
0.1899298728,
0.2999773622,
1.4385883808,
-0.6255689263,
0.8886777163,
0.385956496,
0.0980848297,
0.1287536919,
0.2795940936,
0.0065182154,
0.5086321831,
0.1881791353,
-0.5165822506,
0.0662948936,
-0.3067840636,
-0.2941503823,
0.4810040593,
0.3041349351,
-0.691360116,
0.298034668,
0.1745903492,
-0.231584534,
0.1065969542,
-0.2646411359,
1.1209157705,
-0.0407196432,
-0.6531842947,
0.5196022391,
-0.3516756892,
0.4240095615,
-0.0555963144,
-0.1973965913,
-0.2903057635,
0.3939982057,
0.1211048216,
-0.4076461494,
0.6855518222,
-0.0685293376,
-0.6198685169,
-0.3668091595,
0.685690403,
-0.576118052,
-0.1755434871,
0.164468199,
0.2710003555,
0.1641698182,
-0.2366397232,
-0.3641371131,
0.1325506866,
0.0841400176,
-0.193398878,
0.0289668236,
0.4244702458,
-0.1695803553,
0.7977412939,
0.3963403404,
0.3212699294,
0.1842683703,
0.5037778616,
0.7578303814,
-0.6715215445,
-0.628575027,
-0.4956187606,
0.2627511024,
-0.3157319725,
-0.1428523213,
0.3030758798,
0.5996260047,
1.0011799335,
-0.3597135544,
0.5539842844,
0.2290833741,
1.2023993731,
-0.5087628961,
0.5670244694,
-0.4556705654,
0.6916803122,
-0.3117241859,
-1.1388764381,
-0.1430963129,
0.5924337506,
-0.1693270504,
-0.1060542688,
0.4707594216,
0.5296811461,
-0.2139426619,
-0.0220935717,
0.1212402284,
-0.0546255,
0.3322224617,
0.1791489124,
0.5715331435,
-0.5940834284,
0.5226189494,
-0.3006216884,
0.110309191,
-0.2621269822,
-0.5386929512,
-0.5259487629,
-0.7472108006,
-0.5124773383,
-0.2626864314,
-0.1148043573,
0.9917175174,
0.6254284382,
-0.8113315105,
0.0336802304,
0.0101868408,
0.0302421488,
-0.3456640542,
-0.3040310442,
0.181715101,
0.114601694,
-1.0407006741,
0.2114362568,
-0.1022587791,
0.4545618296,
-0.238189429,
0.1975664645,
-0.1847873926,
-0.0777305961,
0.34065485,
0.1806908101,
-0.7463239431,
-0.3158500791,
-0.1114903986,
-0.0336052701,
-0.0189162362,
0.9041742086,
-0.6331293583,
0.2807860076,
0.4647495449,
0.6830753684,
0.670096755,
0.3295156956,
0.5025324225,
-0.9908726215,
0.2595298588,
0.5841767192,
0.2861280739,
0.4874458611,
-0.6014104486,
0.4745278955,
0.2875306606,
-0.6570748091,
-0.9549844265,
0.3142406642,
-1.0016152859,
-0.1290325373,
1.0118476152,
0.0001168166,
0.1736854762,
-0.196214661,
-0.1600333154,
0.517975986,
-0.4994943142,
0.6097544432,
0.3796478808,
-0.0003152339,
-0.414136678,
-0.4822180867,
0.6565217376,
0.1985158324,
-0.6161502004,
0.1866731495,
0.8773233891,
0.469131887,
0.5404436588,
0.8716692328,
0.1489499956,
0.0043348968,
0.1530832201,
0.0502498038,
0.1813417226,
-0.4113581777,
-0.5350019932,
-0.0596387722,
0.1422531456,
-0.402366966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06234v1 | Using Foundation Models to Detect Policy Violations with Minimal Supervision | 2023-06-09T20:08:48 | 2023-06-09T20:08:48 | Sid Mittal, Vineet Gupta, Frederick Liu, Mukund Sundararajan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Foundation models, i.e. large neural networks pre-trained on large text
corpora, have revolutionized NLP. They can be instructed directly (e.g.
(arXiv:2005.14165)) - this is called hard prompting - and they can be tuned
using very little data (e.g. (arXiv:2104.08691)) - this technique is called
soft prompting. We seek to leverage their capabilities to detect policy
violations. Our contributions are: We identify a hard prompt that adapts
chain-of-thought prompting to policy violation tasks. This prompt produces
policy violation classifications, along with extractive explanations that
justify the classification. We compose the hard-prompts with soft prompt tuning
to produce a classifier that attains high accuracy with very little
supervision; the same classifier also produces explanations. Though the
supervision only acts on the classifications, we find that the modified
explanations remain consistent with the (tuned) model's response. Along the
way, we identify several unintuitive aspects of foundation models. For
instance, adding an example from a specific class can actually reduce
predictions of that class, and separately, the effects of tokenization on
scoring etc. Based on our technical results, we identify a simple workflow for
product teams to quickly develop effective policy violation detectors. | [
-0.3677579761,
-0.7712150812,
0.4057213962,
0.3662659824,
0.1824607402,
-0.3650287092,
-0.2147844732,
-0.2950439453,
-0.1475408971,
0.9689076543,
-0.9809539914,
-0.3954726458,
-0.3029037416,
0.1830865443,
-0.4643174112,
1.4262696505,
0.1550384164,
-0.3167941868,
0.0415555574,
0.2455551624,
-0.5353587866,
0.0976062566,
-0.5650600195,
-0.7864325047,
0.38355878,
0.5248102546,
0.7693207264,
0.4670858085,
0.3929945827,
0.3264995813,
-0.5115969181,
0.2315516174,
-0.5064694285,
-0.1625195295,
-0.3663108647,
-0.3912568688,
-0.3916470706,
-0.1160167679,
0.4238574505,
0.9433648586,
-0.1011044905,
-0.1321091205,
0.4666041136,
0.6143689752,
-0.6878342628,
0.3514458537,
-0.6751574278,
0.0892375484,
0.2278004885,
-0.1946528107,
-0.6600666642,
-0.1725723594,
0.0449067689,
-0.3514586091,
0.5291022062,
-0.1836954355,
1.0729366541,
0.4445352256,
-0.4597848952,
-0.4093263447,
-0.7464899421,
0.6692970991,
-0.4739209414,
-0.0081990296,
0.4925429225,
-0.0675223917,
-0.6050432324,
-0.6486840248,
-0.5997391343,
-0.2864064872,
-0.2480060011,
-0.2243411094,
-0.3378204703,
0.3957287073,
0.5218141675,
0.3216983974,
-0.3353161514,
0.2496361136,
-0.3594492376,
-0.3046123981,
0.5583268404,
0.0208753124,
-0.2244900912,
-0.4192688167,
-0.412588805,
-0.2662152648,
-0.9109807611,
0.3474345207,
0.3009203374,
0.5110607147,
-0.0737077966,
0.4208844602,
-0.4917463362,
0.764677465,
0.1500989497,
0.1973665953,
0.0386585891,
-0.2407153994,
-0.4676870704,
0.1407288462,
0.7408957481,
0.1335300207,
0.5067006946,
0.0098862061,
-0.6228398085,
0.2691381872,
0.3258689642,
-0.5553392172,
-0.2747764885,
0.0380145013,
-0.4627108574,
-0.8404909968,
-0.0922698453,
-0.7142241001,
-0.7204598188,
-0.4739361405,
0.2532115281,
-0.1171089113,
-0.2981174886,
0.3401742578,
0.0103399847,
0.3027463555,
0.1013114899,
-1.0197783709,
0.2995634675,
1.082413435,
0.7987686396,
-0.002603082,
-0.1078946814,
-0.7473147511,
-0.1566035599,
-0.4751659632,
0.6833251119,
-0.1222788021,
-0.5278578997,
0.3357551396,
0.2003759742,
0.1420708448,
-0.4931823313,
0.5677620769,
-0.2301749438,
-0.1734751761,
-0.2783487439,
-0.2719920576,
0.0404133126,
0.5726525784,
-0.6866872311,
0.8153839111,
0.1364579797,
-0.3258979619,
0.6169788241,
-0.9230530858,
-0.5704308748,
-0.200990364,
-0.1806492358,
-0.3899814487,
0.1862380803,
0.1556966901,
0.5674403906,
-0.016835805,
0.5992705822,
-0.1994236112,
-0.4082000554,
0.21190162,
-0.588229537,
1.1337715387,
0.1438746899,
-0.5725716949,
0.2966651022,
-0.7665358186,
-0.0176801179,
-0.1643975675,
-0.329336524,
-0.1328113675,
-0.1767597049,
0.0260915738,
0.229499042,
-0.1387845278,
-0.2274308205,
0.1408969015,
-0.4455959797,
0.4682751,
1.2237328291,
0.0337252393,
0.5700662136,
-0.4047961533,
0.3776392341,
-0.0977277383,
0.3824286163,
-0.2692665756,
-0.5258319974,
-0.5637595057,
-0.0168338735,
0.1702871472,
0.3529909551,
-0.6110621691,
0.3706601858,
-0.2283009738,
-0.1450237185,
-0.1512681097,
0.4415984452,
0.4764791429,
0.8921873569,
0.2641347349,
-0.1497187763,
-0.1896681935,
-0.7197607756,
-0.2753604054,
-0.2546611428,
0.1460606605,
0.1759993285,
0.8905990124,
-0.2373777777,
1.0843273401,
-0.4539360404,
-0.404717207,
0.1159923971,
0.4495938718,
0.5149115324,
0.7412980199,
0.3905290067,
-1.008346796,
-0.1705203056,
-0.2923278213,
-0.6966398954,
-0.239059642,
-0.084423244,
0.0322789028,
0.1916999966,
0.719456315,
-0.746206224,
0.4769618809,
0.2092298567,
-0.5219317079,
0.8208389282,
0.169325158,
-0.1939106584,
-0.486969471,
0.0577879064,
0.0158424769,
-0.1308619827,
-0.6859676242,
0.0438477024,
-0.0484000109,
-0.1771929115,
-0.6425833106,
0.339269191,
-0.1515416354,
0.0801633224,
-0.3720001876,
-0.356806308,
0.2218378037,
0.5981401205,
0.2726488411,
0.7485691309,
0.215576306,
-1.0638849735,
0.1862181127,
0.4510234892,
-0.4665527344,
0.8419323564,
-0.8140402436,
0.0503482893,
-0.1065736115,
0.366330266,
-0.8174794912,
-0.3316481709,
0.3107859194,
-0.0072453534,
0.2406721413,
-0.4418263137,
-0.4121783376,
-0.4182919264,
-0.3147288561,
-0.0635885522,
0.3096928895,
-0.7333610058,
0.4747307003,
0.0087857451,
0.2685794234,
-0.8134821653,
-0.9126189947,
-0.0805405229,
-0.0162323043,
-0.5217649937,
0.4506002963,
0.065560244,
-0.2211232483,
0.3051048815,
-0.3104875982,
-0.206123516,
0.3544412553,
0.5743488073,
0.0676132515,
-0.5247586966,
0.1437300593,
0.1089371145,
-0.1259054244,
0.2857735455,
-0.1861121804,
0.4493985772,
-0.5402489901,
-0.175533548,
-0.5518948436,
0.1832417399,
0.50351125,
-0.0626334101,
0.5150257349,
0.4400212467,
-0.5670599341,
-0.4052963257,
-0.4512092471,
-0.5454645157,
-0.6445154548,
-0.1491034925,
-0.3712219894,
-0.8163609505,
0.1831168979,
-0.3368821442,
0.0697148442,
0.1645666659,
0.3758551478,
0.0026503389,
1.1181917191,
0.7509562969,
-0.0804699883,
0.5603778958,
-0.5991575718,
0.0339940116,
-0.4824270606,
-0.3406768143,
-0.6360539794,
-0.1963971406,
-0.6785438061,
0.030204678,
0.1407370418,
0.1906191111,
-0.232679069,
0.3757766485,
-0.814896524,
0.7762002349,
0.4016934931,
0.1595061272,
0.1272199452,
-0.0534000881,
0.1630848646,
0.2984345853,
-0.5904580355,
-0.5654587746,
0.8231215477,
0.337049365,
0.8055320978,
-0.0572074652,
0.6760053039,
0.6244503856,
0.3527728617,
-0.9458202124,
0.5565937161,
-0.0537190661,
-0.6259381771,
-0.1752493382,
-0.4461715817,
-0.9455242753,
0.0805817842,
-0.3116206825,
-0.6217778325,
0.7784717083,
0.493098706,
-0.5563547611,
-0.0273864958,
-0.6685317755,
1.1971329451,
-0.1007218063,
-0.4360616207,
-0.1592499018,
-0.2987530828,
0.5694244504,
0.2679819763,
0.0718182549,
-0.1471538544,
0.2710901201,
0.5539718866,
-0.6187419295,
1.2877730131,
-0.5158916712,
-0.134189561,
0.4337262809,
0.1216223314,
0.7897833586,
-0.0716592893,
0.0634610727,
-0.1515010893,
-0.0559202917,
-0.4342245758,
-0.4463237822,
0.6866489649,
-0.383210063,
-0.4144200385,
-0.4921901822,
-0.3882176578,
-0.2619899511,
0.2634084821,
0.3108361661,
0.2486006469,
-0.2474338859,
0.3523184955,
0.9776151776,
0.1882414967,
0.4396089315,
0.6862187386,
-0.1908021122,
0.2848475277,
0.7483577728,
-0.167381838,
0.046365045,
0.0669294447,
0.4461924434,
-0.3464249372,
-0.3964688182,
-0.2213390023,
0.038576372,
-0.7018963099,
-0.494715333,
-0.4474418163,
0.0795240551,
-0.4489512146,
-0.2030469775,
-0.235158965,
-0.2611635327,
-0.4301731288,
-0.201802969,
0.3693535328,
0.8882938027,
-0.2597476542,
0.8660899401,
-0.4090572,
0.2074556053,
0.4054955542,
0.3230314255,
-0.2255348414,
-0.2120013684,
0.1847299039,
0.0298579615,
-0.3228204548,
-1.0031580925,
-0.0541038513,
0.3254783154,
0.0556208827,
0.833784461,
0.169032678,
0.3823986351,
-0.4182412624,
0.5441518426,
0.1320559382,
-1.1505042315,
0.7475474477,
-0.3300779164,
-0.0745205134,
0.8153028488,
0.216089502,
-0.4416587353,
-0.0519713126,
-0.4897067249,
-0.6275369525,
0.8011595011,
-0.1372336298,
0.3594913185,
-0.1111017838,
0.401288569,
-0.2466707826,
0.4761794209,
-0.6224827766,
0.1487308294,
-0.1677878946,
-0.1943067312,
0.2039493024,
-0.2769541442,
-0.4593682587,
0.1086044163,
0.7113220096,
-0.4759458303,
-0.0482548289,
0.0962299407,
-0.2392188907,
-0.2039075941,
0.3567995131,
0.6743404269,
0.5933317542,
0.0724572167,
0.0399542935,
0.0258284397,
-0.116200164,
0.1585579664,
-0.0579524897,
-0.6431399584,
0.0303447954,
0.3737083972,
0.7715646625,
0.6671677828,
-0.6610953808,
0.8944600821,
0.2202563584,
-0.2566103935,
-0.3113726974,
0.3231952786,
-0.4109115303,
0.1637316197,
0.1116945595,
0.2288993001,
0.3175388277,
-0.6528963447,
0.5487411618,
0.5321373343,
-0.7399356961,
-0.1644407362,
0.3725096583,
0.2553680837,
-0.4512712061,
0.625567019,
-0.4308776557,
-0.730076015,
0.8502293825,
0.5915260315,
0.4918356836,
-0.1781433821,
0.7247650027,
-0.1109977588,
0.6030858755,
-0.4690491259,
0.2917796671,
-0.2307196259,
-0.9034212232,
-0.670784533,
-0.4888856113,
-0.4770794511,
0.497541666,
-0.902266562,
0.3810502589,
-0.9333106875,
-0.2454447448,
0.1624567807,
-0.1449357718,
-0.8924126029,
0.2237988561,
-0.1373510212,
1.037019372,
-1.3472417593,
0.3746753037,
0.4135386348,
-0.4146361351,
-0.8035268784,
-0.169080779,
0.3263683915,
-0.8428753614,
0.4540254176,
0.3848451674,
-0.1821042448,
-0.1766992062,
-0.8816129565,
-0.1217035353,
0.6279605031,
0.2217217386,
-0.6170685291,
-0.1306260228,
0.0058010686,
0.5451418757,
-0.0802057683,
-0.2713098824,
0.8532627225,
0.6111853123,
-0.2634401619,
-0.7005696297,
0.1524563879,
-0.0592765212,
-0.3981105387,
0.2778129578,
-0.3935653567,
0.8554268479,
0.0179565437,
-0.0655238256,
-0.0771608278,
0.5871098638,
0.0866196603,
0.71599406,
0.864149332,
0.38578403,
0.9762629271,
-0.345397383,
1.0633928776,
-0.0705006048,
0.2441065013,
1.0626326799,
-0.368326962,
0.5341513157,
0.4856124818,
0.1062307209,
0.6131023765,
0.4927358329,
-0.2451128513,
0.6325814128,
0.1642336994,
-0.2649504244,
-0.3087808788,
-0.6973496079,
-0.1027967036,
0.5898510814,
0.5008587837,
-0.2521143258,
-0.0971797109,
0.217180118,
0.1240012199,
0.2176084518,
-0.5847404599,
0.6754130721,
0.324514389,
-0.883241713,
0.4752983451,
0.1349469572,
0.6394765377,
-0.5824283361,
-0.1445101351,
0.0339800976,
0.3685257733,
-0.4480747581,
-0.8154110909,
0.4197620749,
0.2009232789,
-0.297934413,
-0.5535388589,
0.9034564495,
-0.2116852552,
-0.0564837456,
0.3313203454,
0.2762549818,
-0.0211928654,
-0.2391186506,
-0.9869809747,
-0.0135709606,
-0.1658740342,
-0.3583234847,
0.0360118188,
0.3446186781,
-0.2277793735,
0.4566144645,
1.0136873722,
0.0701673105,
-0.0602828041,
0.0505855083,
0.6982064843,
-0.346196413,
-0.6796576381,
-0.7828397155,
0.3447377384,
-0.1905205101,
-0.4614649713,
0.1499616951,
0.221896857,
0.760013938,
-0.0679514185,
0.4840835333,
0.0310951211,
0.1576782614,
-0.7414777279,
0.5182852745,
-0.352802366,
0.2102819681,
-0.0937128142,
-0.7610324025,
-0.2107681483,
0.8046248555,
-0.3650863767,
-0.0401677378,
0.4681229293,
1.0766441822,
-0.3404438496,
0.3860327303,
-0.1171799079,
0.2073398232,
0.3435387015,
0.3586535752,
0.8820832968,
-0.0890339017,
0.8790205717,
-0.3793933392,
-0.087045379,
-0.4254602492,
-1.2041665316,
-0.9585549831,
-0.1773195118,
-0.4000576735,
-0.8633167744,
0.188978076,
0.9137734175,
0.870911479,
-1.2213263512,
-0.0054728668,
-0.7044986486,
0.5831443071,
-0.4070127904,
-0.3003179431,
0.2046255171,
-0.3895664811,
-0.3658501804,
0.7865818143,
-0.0399562791,
-0.0889151916,
-0.3081501722,
-0.158148542,
-0.0302098989,
-0.0363876075,
0.4114005566,
0.6316937208,
-0.4480359554,
-0.2995588183,
-0.1405653059,
-0.1465763301,
-0.2445815057,
1.2301958799,
-0.6623411179,
0.090542756,
0.4708085954,
0.6368862987,
0.4610100687,
-0.1718147993,
0.429667592,
-1.0591526031,
0.188676551,
0.4275608063,
0.3085440099,
0.4472511113,
-0.4758652449,
0.7368739843,
0.2411330193,
-0.4697609544,
-1.295019865,
0.5833200812,
-0.5925335884,
-0.2455471605,
0.9313107729,
-0.2003464848,
-0.4976294339,
-0.1608449668,
0.0588917546,
-0.0996122882,
-0.3850878477,
0.7460387349,
0.6724501848,
0.0323329419,
0.0542158261,
-0.3767558336,
0.8165213466,
0.536440134,
-0.6441402435,
-0.0023258335,
0.4825198948,
0.2635799944,
0.3876740634,
0.7626244426,
0.24300161,
0.6095775962,
-0.0879074857,
-0.4265265465,
-0.2175756395,
-0.6946346164,
-0.903183043,
0.0915672779,
-0.1206026077,
-0.1560376585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06232v1 | Probing self-supervised speech models for phonetic and phonemic information: a case study in aspiration | 2023-06-09T20:07:22 | 2023-06-09T20:07:22 | Kinan Martin, Jon Gauthier, Canaan Breiss, Roger Levy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Textless self-supervised speech models have grown in capabilities in recent
years, but the nature of the linguistic information they encode has not yet
been thoroughly examined. We evaluate the extent to which these models' learned
representations align with basic representational distinctions made by humans,
focusing on a set of phonetic (low-level) and phonemic (more abstract)
contrasts instantiated in word-initial stops. We find that robust
representations of both phonetic and phonemic distinctions emerge in early
layers of these models' architectures, and are preserved in the principal
components of deeper layer representations. Our analyses suggest two sources
for this success: some can only be explained by the optimization of the models
on speech data, while some can be attributed to these models' high-dimensional
architectures. Our findings show that speech-trained HuBERT derives a low-noise
and low-dimensional subspace corresponding to abstract phonological
distinctions. | [
-0.1533606052,
-0.2492319047,
0.5978470445,
0.064497821,
0.1572805941,
-0.0600376353,
-0.1936456859,
-0.5125238299,
0.4351129532,
0.6033017039,
-0.4035703838,
-0.5230165124,
-0.3086097538,
0.0599354431,
-0.4875576496,
0.4900390506,
0.3224565089,
0.0537632778,
-0.2749997079,
-0.0486451574,
-0.1261814833,
-0.9275149107,
-0.3377354145,
-0.6040655375,
0.2461519688,
0.3636074364,
0.5641801357,
1.0488010645,
0.0610391758,
0.2458153367,
-0.0416233838,
-0.2731193602,
-0.0660002977,
0.2085281909,
-0.0154619263,
-0.3001942337,
-0.1487423033,
0.3125165701,
0.7746326923,
1.3362122774,
-0.1831518114,
0.300413847,
0.344342947,
0.4663847983,
-0.5313557386,
0.2330178469,
-0.6901670694,
0.123013258,
-0.1844575405,
-0.1238830388,
-0.4816241562,
0.2998433709,
0.2845749855,
-0.6077335477,
0.3137598336,
-0.2369403988,
0.8980110288,
0.3493047357,
-0.3464375138,
-0.484991014,
-0.697319448,
0.7519310117,
-0.4512161016,
0.7021576166,
0.6601487994,
0.0069698887,
0.1658492237,
-0.6620697379,
-0.0621268749,
-0.4407469928,
-0.2112842053,
0.1510942876,
-0.341278702,
0.190144226,
0.2346528172,
0.2497996837,
-0.5713298321,
0.3800718486,
-0.601980865,
-0.5112623572,
0.6839002967,
-0.1625585109,
0.0710409284,
-0.8191863298,
-0.386169821,
-0.2061690092,
-0.3312170506,
0.2413907051,
0.373870939,
0.5536922812,
-0.2879568934,
0.5124934316,
-0.2028246671,
0.5997473001,
0.0170181505,
-0.0126065398,
0.2887117267,
-0.0841216296,
-0.3254591227,
0.4865529537,
0.8807245493,
-0.3627060652,
0.3253640234,
-0.2750652432,
-0.2684418261,
0.1130676866,
0.2567965388,
-0.8174027205,
-0.6452199221,
0.2684953511,
-0.6091238856,
-0.3281382322,
0.0683706403,
-0.1851712167,
-0.1156023517,
-0.6695882082,
0.5656701922,
-0.3855167627,
-0.2847983539,
0.1996132284,
-0.1263063401,
0.0789506286,
0.0772931054,
-1.1909343004,
0.5296067595,
0.4739709795,
0.6714315414,
-0.0406590998,
-0.1861923635,
-0.3940390646,
-0.0476344489,
-0.672462225,
0.5710496306,
-0.5989100933,
-0.5298449397,
-0.0796496198,
-0.2226400524,
-0.1921406686,
-0.9437775016,
0.5850280523,
-0.0695579723,
0.1779667139,
-0.1977428943,
-0.629471302,
-0.2720331848,
-0.1201145202,
-0.4666457176,
0.8810130358,
-0.2498797774,
-0.595127821,
0.2199155688,
-0.5046770573,
-0.335650295,
-0.112172395,
-0.7834096551,
-0.3270680904,
0.4080109298,
0.2839674056,
0.5701342225,
-0.0459173322,
0.0033967677,
-0.0725630745,
-0.1125558764,
0.2337962389,
-0.3331236541,
1.0494064093,
0.2532317936,
-0.104240343,
0.0065370416,
-1.1317660809,
0.0810395405,
0.1320202053,
-0.2741143405,
-0.483373493,
-0.0723859891,
-0.4063747823,
-0.1449882239,
0.5558605194,
-0.6712651253,
-0.0234270375,
-0.1971175522,
0.5578281283,
0.3930611312,
-0.0825424269,
0.5927149057,
-0.128103137,
0.3169969022,
0.2044843286,
-0.0133182788,
-0.326371789,
-0.4799802899,
-0.7344046831,
-0.1441394985,
0.5299805999,
0.3525902927,
-0.1522632837,
0.16003941,
-0.2652455866,
-0.2924348712,
-0.8575441241,
0.1292369515,
0.3230871558,
0.4976067841,
0.4995078444,
-0.4060546458,
-0.3269028664,
-1.1658354998,
-0.2211216688,
-0.5342877507,
-0.2351167351,
0.4470803738,
0.2400616109,
-0.2319767028,
0.827278316,
-0.1949193776,
-0.2502498627,
0.0795417726,
0.4305227101,
0.1801677197,
0.5078490376,
0.4432350397,
-0.5388337374,
-0.1643069237,
-0.0599700287,
-0.6269452572,
-0.2970080972,
-0.0859363526,
0.1605064869,
-0.3044529557,
0.7062134147,
-0.448402077,
0.2688834369,
0.5055555701,
-0.0318892933,
0.6151338816,
-0.3138275146,
-0.1655577868,
-0.7481902838,
-0.1297985762,
-0.1548830867,
-0.2095550746,
-0.9313897491,
-0.1821407825,
0.151318714,
-0.5258302093,
-0.0553087145,
0.4041773677,
-0.7996022105,
-0.4697982669,
-0.2001627237,
0.1523734629,
0.1105137691,
0.4372846186,
0.3375795186,
0.5820971131,
0.8205097914,
-0.5839516521,
-0.1492115557,
0.1240760908,
-0.2300027609,
0.2614712715,
-0.7500888705,
0.5303833485,
-0.165354684,
-0.1262545884,
-0.948573947,
-0.5017356873,
0.0895560309,
-0.8056356311,
0.3071158528,
-0.4344391525,
-0.4705672264,
-0.1648867726,
-0.050791651,
0.527568996,
0.5159312487,
-0.5569730997,
0.6768069863,
0.5731780529,
0.0015147766,
-0.1607427895,
-0.8679720759,
-0.0584177524,
-0.1749414355,
-0.4916698933,
0.4009014666,
0.3296980858,
-0.3866231441,
-0.1784843355,
-0.3020310998,
-0.2190897763,
-0.1168281361,
0.463311851,
-0.1339694113,
-0.3927424252,
0.3795358539,
0.0381734334,
0.1310832202,
0.3584062159,
-0.5161529779,
0.4370622337,
0.1015712023,
-0.3048530519,
-0.8055785298,
0.3214834332,
0.3622884452,
-0.2785860896,
0.2060708851,
0.3953598142,
-0.4884442985,
-0.1193692684,
-0.4635841548,
-0.3263286352,
-0.4604262114,
0.0912205055,
-0.6505509615,
-0.6543866992,
0.6365195513,
0.1065447405,
-0.2138033509,
0.3743847907,
0.2002113163,
-0.2492157668,
0.7006873488,
0.3754941523,
-0.0346157923,
0.3789429963,
-0.3967059553,
-0.2822833955,
-0.7016983628,
-0.233067289,
-0.6653761864,
-0.1262619197,
-0.6403045654,
-0.5235046744,
0.2828634381,
0.0262576044,
-0.2675102949,
0.3809343278,
-0.6112504601,
0.1431607753,
0.554586947,
-0.0540383868,
0.1265964955,
0.158109799,
-0.3281320632,
-0.2793034613,
-0.7510387897,
-0.4382083416,
0.9386476278,
0.5829614401,
0.7931771874,
-0.1186814532,
1.1192225218,
0.1582591981,
-0.3444669247,
-0.7883723974,
0.5689036846,
-0.3909436166,
-0.5723643899,
-0.3034790456,
-0.4504626095,
-1.2510906458,
0.3927334249,
0.057770554,
-0.9072288275,
0.745516479,
0.2348267883,
-0.6485610604,
-0.0810122937,
-0.7245716453,
0.8268341422,
-0.2368579805,
0.0270884465,
-0.242190972,
-0.7102229595,
0.0916802734,
0.0885098949,
0.1390831918,
-0.1162348241,
0.0483734421,
0.9790578485,
-0.2798596919,
0.9839074016,
-0.2837667167,
-0.2171541601,
0.4205730557,
0.2884339988,
0.0238167476,
-0.336979568,
-0.0719741583,
0.3622377813,
0.010670986,
-0.3024794757,
-0.5599796772,
0.4928112328,
-0.8907963634,
-0.545219183,
-0.0860909745,
-0.193158716,
-0.2589293718,
0.1855764836,
0.2845836282,
0.8946421742,
-0.0870575681,
0.2487445772,
0.5055603385,
-0.0909795165,
0.2391255945,
0.3766152561,
-0.4895971119,
-0.1733672619,
0.9038233161,
0.3424807787,
0.395922929,
0.4177904129,
0.36071226,
-0.5280120969,
-0.5703263879,
-0.3003968894,
0.4024758935,
-0.8355314732,
0.065093115,
-0.5987925529,
-0.5254802704,
-0.5772922039,
0.4237880707,
-0.6368552446,
-0.6367707849,
-0.7264789343,
-0.0521471463,
-0.0495838858,
1.0780457258,
-0.4571964741,
0.2435277551,
-0.4758098722,
0.3840880096,
0.5688332915,
-0.155856818,
0.0605117679,
-0.8589967489,
-0.2427528501,
0.0665910691,
-0.2209685445,
-1.0233396292,
0.3126182258,
0.6010955572,
0.3908939362,
0.5560131073,
0.0508383289,
0.6525402069,
-0.3966389298,
0.7834057808,
-0.1454762965,
-1.008236289,
0.755703032,
-0.5184348226,
0.3108435273,
0.4510342479,
0.3406733572,
-0.2027430385,
-0.2319154292,
-0.8114745617,
-0.5542370081,
0.4902758598,
0.3137724996,
0.2613447309,
0.0726434961,
0.4154584408,
0.0989624932,
0.2084650099,
-0.7427940369,
-0.1571768522,
-0.4143924117,
0.0914090052,
0.1233543977,
-0.1907626688,
0.0057159346,
-0.2692662179,
0.1034437865,
-0.0659028143,
0.4383105338,
0.5083106756,
-0.0992131531,
0.2427599877,
0.1828911006,
0.3684349656,
0.2807263434,
-0.0786553994,
0.3750109076,
-0.0829379559,
-0.3280060887,
0.1173862964,
0.1342908293,
0.1018318236,
0.1164594218,
0.6047281623,
0.8892247081,
0.4211744964,
-0.2204971313,
0.4022810757,
0.235008508,
-0.2909105122,
-0.4291538894,
0.058696907,
0.0816735029,
0.2691798508,
0.3939008713,
0.0731516853,
0.5103958249,
-0.8592825532,
0.2095893174,
0.4576798677,
-0.4932146966,
-0.5834879279,
0.7859782577,
-0.0605917871,
-0.3535155356,
0.562949717,
-0.2205180228,
-0.4489560425,
0.2889623642,
0.3399181664,
0.9086824059,
-0.4190682769,
0.242016077,
0.2924538553,
0.0552392825,
0.0660708845,
0.1551172286,
-0.777230382,
-0.9509302974,
-0.1492735147,
-0.6315080523,
-0.2914762497,
0.1208672002,
-1.1113221645,
0.1151729301,
-0.3829526007,
-0.3372975588,
0.3165136874,
-0.1714886278,
-0.6055979729,
0.3058464825,
0.5983287692,
0.5953220129,
-0.5847541094,
0.9507701397,
0.4536779523,
-0.1613316238,
-1.1678073406,
0.3517555296,
-0.1188940406,
-0.9385777116,
1.0350496769,
0.3577649593,
-0.5250791311,
0.1698902696,
-0.3959581256,
-0.8127686381,
0.7506740689,
0.6938372254,
-0.5308654308,
-0.2816754282,
0.3393499851,
0.6506595612,
-0.4103066623,
-0.1646477878,
0.5315691829,
0.1546096802,
0.0064636897,
-1.1930907965,
-0.326849401,
-0.0594919845,
-0.1065376997,
-0.2440687269,
-0.4678767025,
0.949635148,
-0.2740203142,
-0.7197907567,
0.1140933037,
0.7912396789,
0.0324811526,
0.0053410074,
0.4711747169,
0.5873334408,
0.8873829842,
0.0256829355,
1.0447745323,
-0.3315669596,
0.1668411344,
1.1353657246,
0.1018367261,
0.9703202844,
0.1696653366,
-0.1089242846,
0.4573349357,
0.7073520422,
0.2173119783,
0.5279451013,
0.3391245902,
-0.0443931185,
-0.5141477585,
-0.2224034667,
-0.196102649,
1.0813530684,
0.4939544797,
-0.495034039,
0.0752754807,
-0.1374400258,
-0.2542763948,
0.0514447205,
-0.4043852389,
0.8807824254,
0.3380699456,
-0.4784077704,
0.9518595934,
-0.2939848006,
0.374945879,
-0.3689180613,
0.1717990041,
0.1030016765,
-0.1813316941,
-0.1399957985,
-0.6205217242,
0.1233717054,
-0.3835401833,
-0.0804798529,
-0.3999725878,
0.7147506475,
-0.5786271691,
-0.3695794344,
0.6495018601,
0.5222560167,
0.5986915231,
-0.1297494024,
-0.6202980876,
0.1180174798,
-0.01709022,
0.0810324028,
-0.0228580702,
0.5313363075,
0.2669809163,
0.5389737487,
0.3552246392,
0.3855499029,
0.3276701272,
0.3816678524,
0.548935771,
-0.6001550555,
-0.6202193499,
-0.7293488979,
0.3142108917,
-0.0146447225,
-0.1785830855,
0.568380475,
0.6277322769,
0.7283311486,
0.038932357,
0.4996605515,
0.6036911607,
0.7202730775,
-0.720968008,
0.6748905778,
-0.679962635,
0.0960099995,
-0.0996586308,
-0.6605809331,
-0.0879002288,
0.8808780909,
-0.3554624617,
-0.0013426736,
0.3636806905,
0.557166636,
-0.2544003427,
-0.0024344462,
0.5691120028,
0.2182229757,
0.0405115262,
-0.0158997513,
0.8371068835,
-0.2757247388,
0.2419971079,
-0.1669251919,
0.0290658958,
-0.0387701876,
-0.3399057686,
-0.9361508489,
-0.9085589647,
-0.3133014441,
0.033012677,
-0.0745035782,
0.9657956362,
1.0438388586,
-0.6283023357,
-0.550914824,
0.092231892,
-0.3636901677,
0.1456981301,
-0.1716341227,
0.3686925471,
-0.3616753519,
-0.5082193613,
0.7810208201,
0.2967522442,
0.4905912578,
-0.5143059492,
0.1320320666,
0.4576021433,
0.2013414502,
0.4089910984,
0.3814223111,
-0.7883329988,
-0.1938025057,
0.0491460524,
-0.0714331493,
0.4535089433,
0.9828340411,
-0.8638686538,
0.5447638035,
0.1361041218,
0.5004993081,
0.523897469,
0.087090984,
0.559260428,
-0.9531806111,
0.3223665357,
0.4369173348,
0.5353485346,
0.65540874,
-0.1687294394,
0.2228894979,
0.0528683364,
-0.496065706,
-0.7940535545,
0.3665500879,
-0.9000293612,
-0.1449694335,
1.0860190392,
0.0229482595,
-0.0788696185,
-0.0813915953,
-0.0221655238,
0.078065902,
-0.4261878729,
0.6810995936,
0.6921633482,
-0.4963986278,
-0.1433653682,
-0.5966142416,
0.6704705358,
0.4612410963,
-0.4655622244,
0.2210849077,
0.3246111274,
0.1311921924,
0.6930317879,
0.6720687747,
-0.1139915735,
-0.0043903138,
0.3218608797,
-0.1852106154,
0.2686580122,
-0.5714229941,
-0.5077326894,
0.158397615,
0.2821224332,
-0.5733513832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06221v1 | Conformalizing Machine Translation Evaluation | 2023-06-09T19:36:18 | 2023-06-09T19:36:18 | Chrysoula Zerva, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Several uncertainty estimation methods have been recently proposed for
machine translation evaluation. While these methods can provide a useful
indication of when not to trust model predictions, we show in this paper that
the majority of them tend to underestimate model uncertainty, and as a result
they often produce misleading confidence intervals that do not cover the ground
truth. We propose as an alternative the use of conformal prediction, a
distribution-free method to obtain confidence intervals with a theoretically
established guarantee on coverage. First, we demonstrate that split conformal
prediction can ``correct'' the confidence intervals of previous methods to
yield a desired coverage level. Then, we highlight biases in estimated
confidence intervals, both in terms of the translation language pairs and the
quality of translations. We apply conditional conformal prediction techniques
to obtain calibration subsets for each data subgroup, leading to equalized
coverage. | [
-0.3035115898,
-0.1820017099,
0.8129661083,
0.2458107471,
-0.4615634978,
-0.2890987098,
-0.1964634061,
-0.2966879606,
-0.097695291,
0.2646684051,
-0.5368306041,
-0.4027116895,
-1.1230435371,
0.1197590604,
-0.3053748608,
0.5704342127,
-0.3449073434,
0.3513527513,
-0.0949758068,
-0.2077231258,
-0.322270155,
-0.1724219918,
-0.0111845871,
-0.2676509917,
0.0499687083,
0.351742059,
1.1982274055,
0.5918679237,
0.5235593319,
0.2172184736,
-0.1430491805,
0.2215086818,
-0.1236319691,
0.1959271729,
0.2683324516,
-0.8489144444,
-0.1655316204,
0.2005652338,
0.911419034,
0.6935753226,
-0.0780825242,
0.166114226,
-0.1266033351,
0.9050018191,
-0.7875866294,
0.061246112,
-0.7246975303,
-0.0143825784,
0.143218115,
0.2385323197,
-0.6355614662,
-0.5298008323,
0.0721263811,
-0.8105372787,
0.1217775717,
0.0771702304,
0.7504065037,
0.5958074331,
-0.3791810274,
-0.1957435459,
-0.7867791057,
1.0735822916,
-0.700447917,
0.6817651987,
0.7851983905,
0.7698510289,
-0.119413957,
-0.4463021159,
-0.4456862211,
-0.2473722249,
0.043099042,
0.2877449989,
-0.32872352,
-0.054784026,
0.0243437197,
0.3317144513,
-0.187496677,
-0.4025750458,
-0.6880103946,
-0.0887225345,
0.7512148023,
-0.2472666949,
0.0417916663,
-0.021988228,
-0.4551326334,
-0.2788253725,
-0.5460552573,
0.0852886885,
0.3294443488,
0.0050597559,
-0.1537553519,
0.7580000162,
-0.1403032094,
0.5367835164,
0.1883482933,
0.1369067878,
0.3909494281,
-0.0898745283,
-0.6594384313,
-0.1102167517,
0.8955489397,
0.5808528066,
0.4976634681,
-0.0428450853,
-0.3566333055,
0.0728585497,
0.3473300338,
-0.5900478363,
0.0395388976,
0.5147559047,
-0.2760418355,
-0.2776891291,
0.3869893551,
-0.5059757233,
-0.1187787354,
-0.1534402966,
0.1740550846,
-0.5580912828,
-0.0472193398,
0.1378145367,
-0.1157800481,
-0.1969493181,
0.4239786863,
-0.4803595841,
-0.0479035228,
0.4055642486,
0.761857152,
0.0733581483,
0.053100016,
-0.3035843074,
0.2746910453,
-0.633665204,
0.6773836613,
-0.4540115297,
-0.7351902723,
-0.0434513465,
0.0673391372,
-0.2525328398,
-0.342928797,
0.4697470367,
-0.4367998242,
0.1239802763,
0.0816388354,
-0.6743373871,
-0.261485368,
0.2760379612,
-0.8759387732,
0.7702346444,
0.399061054,
-0.778788507,
0.2561892271,
-0.1365383416,
-0.1535478085,
-0.4903073907,
0.0776694417,
-0.8085306287,
0.2012711018,
0.5361258388,
0.1954800487,
-0.0514466502,
0.2030671835,
-0.6018969417,
-0.2614948452,
0.609018743,
-0.4439777434,
0.6953141689,
0.5380572081,
-0.3779752254,
0.0994688123,
-0.3911359608,
0.4893713593,
-0.4782303572,
0.087172322,
-0.2123398185,
-0.0651376396,
-0.3105476797,
0.083581917,
0.0244863108,
-0.464156121,
-0.0074287816,
-0.6581712961,
0.1000257879,
0.6163662076,
0.1166846752,
0.6086253524,
-0.3817600608,
0.8728212714,
0.0775357261,
0.4366040826,
0.1617117077,
-0.708330512,
-0.6740868688,
-0.0500463843,
0.482722789,
0.5087613463,
-0.6039460897,
0.2267686576,
-0.3287506998,
-0.5665588379,
-1.0749052763,
0.1069855243,
0.6072212458,
0.1316457689,
0.574467361,
0.040768303,
-0.3889428377,
-0.8694004416,
-0.5250300169,
-0.3533303142,
-0.5561249256,
-0.1999615431,
0.3598888814,
-0.4228697717,
0.6894174218,
-0.5366958976,
-0.1883211732,
-0.0741948262,
0.0844786838,
-0.0014277156,
0.6356957555,
0.4098724127,
-1.0073871613,
-1.024769783,
-0.0260738321,
-0.3637107611,
0.0918841287,
-0.0487848148,
-0.1342675239,
0.2246653885,
0.2613724172,
-0.2991494536,
0.5959925652,
1.0245667696,
0.0674182326,
0.2351283729,
-0.2420603484,
0.4442765117,
-1.1347670555,
-0.050490126,
0.2927623391,
-0.5876164436,
-0.4236984253,
-0.0121882427,
0.2742529213,
0.2938008904,
-0.2395033389,
0.3657140136,
-0.5558968782,
0.09288086,
-0.2390509099,
0.2515013814,
0.1040606648,
-0.2274225205,
0.125596419,
0.821439445,
0.1116410345,
-0.3207807541,
-0.2394168526,
0.2886288166,
-0.2822803259,
0.4841617942,
-0.7320135236,
-0.0256138369,
-0.0647761226,
0.3653300703,
-0.9901316762,
-0.1422801167,
0.414808929,
-0.7812125087,
0.2996553481,
-0.1866781116,
-0.1423427165,
-0.2009266764,
-0.205066666,
0.2271010876,
0.8128914833,
-0.1081241667,
0.0387886614,
0.4443106055,
0.1573686302,
-0.5139853358,
-0.8509315848,
-0.4557973146,
-0.168828845,
-0.6934334636,
0.0997264609,
-0.1670584381,
-0.3064879477,
-0.2928416729,
-0.5481963754,
-0.4995034933,
0.1589427292,
0.3785553873,
0.1670262814,
-0.0247930828,
-0.1582425684,
0.3572506905,
-0.3097026646,
-0.0356420353,
-0.4251560569,
-0.220772922,
-0.271048665,
-0.5467595458,
-0.3158330619,
0.1709688753,
0.4676230848,
-0.0902922004,
0.6587408185,
0.4946093559,
-0.5081622005,
0.0594761521,
-0.5240749717,
0.0399903655,
-0.3947341144,
-0.0406827442,
-0.4221346974,
-0.4119734764,
0.2050673813,
-0.0681167319,
-0.0832140148,
0.7198231816,
0.3505795002,
-0.2735787928,
1.1288605928,
0.8267837167,
0.1708113104,
0.2014621645,
-0.1787800491,
-0.1383103281,
-0.9055230021,
-0.0978605971,
-0.7035392523,
0.0201106537,
-0.5131196976,
-0.9761012793,
0.5816476345,
0.4978334308,
0.0500664786,
0.4958466589,
-0.5144598484,
0.316865623,
0.5001126528,
0.1254031509,
0.4502605498,
-0.0634549335,
-0.0751739964,
-0.3148768842,
-0.2234369367,
-0.8939552307,
1.3143765926,
0.5487070084,
0.4833469391,
-0.0647730827,
0.44931072,
0.2269749492,
1.0315654278,
-0.5388387442,
-0.1206700206,
0.0222322606,
-0.7714208961,
-0.5649928451,
-0.4227781296,
-0.7613458037,
0.3987209201,
0.1624786407,
-0.5711324811,
0.3444715738,
0.2818834186,
-0.0482413135,
0.0236808974,
-0.5899143815,
0.5198103189,
0.2224384993,
0.4786635041,
-0.1004313082,
-1.0527698994,
0.4132123888,
-0.4722737968,
0.5011712313,
-0.2298407406,
-0.0599499382,
0.3111116588,
-0.442389816,
0.6442593932,
-0.2201894224,
-0.0280874781,
0.4278178215,
0.2573966384,
0.5051846504,
0.2161374539,
-0.6311776042,
0.3111206889,
0.5226450562,
-0.3788402379,
-0.6633092761,
0.0321329273,
-0.7374082208,
-0.4254845977,
-0.3074237108,
-0.5204426646,
-0.4607648849,
0.3094237149,
0.6157360077,
-0.5118180513,
-0.3444957435,
0.1921023577,
0.4248403907,
0.2808921337,
-0.2252585292,
0.2533434033,
0.101137042,
-0.8205240965,
0.2031454891,
0.0157591887,
0.8836034536,
0.3347089291,
0.2328029722,
-0.3131565452,
-0.5631886721,
-0.648344934,
0.0306303389,
-0.7313051224,
-0.230554238,
-0.2564120293,
-0.0101699429,
-0.7543982267,
-0.3475285172,
-0.4591850936,
-0.7769386172,
0.0531413034,
-0.1472902447,
-0.054439988,
0.6023983359,
0.0171876084,
0.6973385215,
-0.977745533,
0.162912488,
-0.4468678534,
0.2078396976,
-0.5648261905,
-0.6354750991,
-0.4398762882,
0.7931461334,
-0.5122724771,
-1.1988471746,
0.5493355393,
0.0174168348,
0.7284712791,
0.3052727878,
0.3263858855,
0.6892231703,
-0.5124587417,
0.5662943125,
0.3661682904,
-1.0437663794,
0.6049916744,
0.0165439341,
0.1020977572,
0.7971765399,
0.751789391,
-0.6075766683,
-0.8575041294,
-0.9008908868,
-0.5194266438,
0.3035462201,
0.5452097654,
-0.1568520218,
0.0789079294,
0.2726382613,
0.1688851267,
0.4498904347,
-0.6292346716,
-0.2389332503,
-0.4579196274,
-0.3884533346,
-0.202407375,
-0.208603248,
-0.2502623796,
-0.1402983069,
0.9573176503,
-0.2271971256,
0.0880758762,
0.5660300255,
-0.1595306396,
-0.5959879756,
0.4356374443,
0.6003303528,
0.7983835936,
-0.4643347859,
-0.0278946199,
0.1694256216,
-0.5053795576,
0.3833263218,
0.0511990599,
-0.5094700456,
0.5400637388,
0.1319139004,
0.4904457927,
-0.0381039716,
-0.3599913418,
0.7243326306,
0.2011829168,
-0.1574925184,
-0.5687758327,
-0.3028824329,
0.1583711803,
0.2259139568,
-0.0965511277,
0.2235529721,
0.1051046997,
0.1813185513,
0.4403375387,
0.3068925738,
-1.0751103163,
-0.3621772528,
0.8131110072,
-0.0484460071,
0.0001782251,
0.4448541403,
0.087139748,
-0.3664929867,
0.652102232,
0.470367223,
1.1817396879,
-0.7711529136,
0.219392553,
0.4331756234,
0.8141115308,
-0.3442935646,
0.0912439153,
0.2808549106,
-0.5930924416,
-0.1984934062,
-0.4701444507,
-0.5585099459,
-0.3694882095,
-0.7935795784,
0.2536194623,
-0.0564187653,
-0.375166744,
-0.2129907757,
-0.1560349017,
-0.3332648873,
0.5076076388,
-0.0246559642,
1.185352087,
-0.8940346837,
0.9304742217,
0.4883713722,
-0.4848874807,
-0.8975626826,
0.3195279241,
-0.0596081205,
-0.6933727264,
0.5066719055,
0.2666416466,
-0.1495893896,
-0.3624200225,
-0.2872473896,
-0.8786429763,
1.1028791666,
0.5306522846,
-0.6525042057,
-0.0056433347,
0.449149102,
0.3326710761,
-0.4179116786,
0.1940240562,
0.3156988621,
0.9690157175,
0.2168306857,
-0.9950333834,
0.1657650918,
0.1699728072,
0.1912929267,
0.0760863945,
-0.2968609929,
0.7248541713,
-0.279568404,
-0.292547524,
0.1818113178,
0.7217333913,
0.1774029434,
0.4273486137,
0.771890521,
0.1659493595,
0.850474298,
0.0779681876,
1.3159415722,
-0.3495712876,
0.6374825239,
0.9114179015,
0.0250599422,
0.8712930679,
0.6299541593,
-0.3954361677,
0.3542729914,
0.828399837,
-0.0141732628,
0.4224237204,
0.1565912813,
-0.1136833429,
-0.3858339787,
0.4339511096,
-0.5465213656,
-0.2412360162,
0.4893324077,
-0.5798392892,
-0.1585926563,
-0.2774434686,
0.0002959751,
0.2970472872,
0.0749099702,
0.271579206,
0.4954329133,
-0.6935971379,
0.828158915,
0.2741731107,
0.1411724687,
-0.4391837716,
0.2138497829,
0.0546002723,
0.3163566291,
-0.1127732843,
-0.6144241095,
0.6162377596,
-0.3744393885,
-0.147056058,
-0.2964976132,
0.3780037463,
-0.5024144053,
-0.7815027237,
-0.0584389865,
0.2988076806,
0.3030049801,
-0.5030894876,
-0.7335941195,
-0.2120755464,
0.2425226867,
-0.3400667012,
-0.0815058872,
0.5545631647,
-0.2606170774,
0.7036218047,
0.5085314512,
0.0965714231,
0.1357361972,
-0.2748969495,
0.5031315088,
-0.2964590192,
-0.4413395226,
-0.7356079221,
0.6931479573,
0.0199303254,
-0.117985554,
0.8360554576,
0.5163912177,
0.8917850852,
-0.197102502,
0.9515702724,
0.4167427421,
0.3940215707,
-0.5237910748,
0.6052703857,
-0.3729712963,
0.1705720872,
-0.1548604816,
-0.8591151834,
-0.4548566639,
0.7094980478,
-0.44320333,
-0.1339772046,
0.9292461872,
0.4610476792,
-0.2292281985,
0.1935349703,
0.5105505586,
0.0315783918,
0.29084903,
0.2759413421,
0.3934020996,
-0.8210081458,
0.6179124117,
-0.4255608022,
-0.4154972434,
-0.1240693852,
-0.9098738432,
-0.5584053993,
-0.4617180228,
-0.2222093195,
-0.8042595983,
0.1420030743,
0.663210988,
0.7617581487,
-0.974408567,
-0.1792933047,
-0.0735084638,
0.279432863,
-0.3881368935,
-0.0587261319,
0.2627168894,
-0.477581799,
-1.1118136644,
0.3238935471,
-0.1099458113,
0.4690108001,
-0.3300383985,
-0.2401278615,
0.0623256154,
0.2995083928,
-0.0233886521,
0.0064302031,
-0.7556715608,
-0.2022286952,
0.0473118573,
-0.2833768427,
0.2002024353,
0.5723575354,
-0.428799957,
0.4387998283,
0.3239681721,
0.5474680066,
0.4656371176,
0.3159654438,
1.1764597893,
-0.7129763365,
0.3146135509,
0.2421134263,
0.2016189694,
0.2623111904,
-0.4808659852,
0.6219098568,
0.0114004454,
-0.4513899684,
-0.8311757445,
0.4384392202,
-0.7700140476,
-0.235682413,
1.1354397535,
-0.5789880753,
-0.4293425679,
0.0337906033,
0.1202309951,
0.3420885205,
-0.1722308844,
0.7601521611,
0.8584983945,
0.242770195,
0.402110219,
-0.8738040924,
0.5162957311,
0.4658621252,
-0.5695186853,
0.0032426764,
0.4210606217,
0.5230230093,
0.330237329,
0.5923346281,
-0.3634524643,
0.278324455,
-0.0758953542,
0.0319866277,
0.1474547982,
-0.1762572825,
-0.2256178409,
-0.3157422841,
0.1950454861,
-0.3143899143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06205v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06205v1 | Morphosyntactic probing of multilingual BERT models | 2023-06-09T19:15:20 | 2023-06-09T19:15:20 | Judit Acs, Endre Hamerlik, Roy Schwartz, Noah A. Smith, Andras Kornai | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce an extensive dataset for multilingual probing of morphological
information in language models (247 tasks across 42 languages from 10
families), each consisting of a sentence with a target word and a morphological
tag as the desired label, derived from the Universal Dependencies treebanks. We
find that pre-trained Transformer models (mBERT and XLM-RoBERTa) learn features
that attain strong performance across these tasks. We then apply two methods to
locate, for each probing task, where the disambiguating information resides in
the input. The first is a new perturbation method that masks various parts of
context; the second is the classical method of Shapley values. The most
intriguing finding that emerges is a strong tendency for the preceding context
to hold more information relevant to the prediction than the following context. | [
-0.4863794744,
-0.8458916545,
0.4793415666,
0.0958204567,
-0.1565863043,
-0.1802769601,
-0.0545424558,
-0.5368824601,
0.2843030691,
0.5600968599,
-0.726805985,
-0.2991303504,
-0.620909214,
-0.0026713545,
-0.3340840936,
0.8953918219,
0.1251603812,
0.3546225131,
0.0476038828,
0.1329320669,
0.2150541246,
-0.7759695053,
-0.1952681988,
-0.2046999782,
0.6194107533,
-0.0804983974,
0.7064384818,
0.5579220057,
0.5519527793,
0.3236566186,
-0.425426662,
0.1048254594,
-0.1944990605,
0.6547091603,
-0.0954338014,
-0.5343260765,
-0.0702409297,
-0.2736286819,
0.7116755843,
1.0735062361,
0.2319152951,
0.0292300787,
0.0928707346,
0.28141433,
-0.4096703231,
0.32408759,
-0.7671625018,
0.0641927421,
-0.5331575871,
-0.2010438889,
-0.4302799702,
0.1217312664,
0.5119889379,
-0.0930551067,
0.3183430731,
-0.3491638303,
0.9630411863,
0.1660194248,
-0.5814275146,
-0.2549526095,
-0.5523061752,
0.8538020849,
-0.3904970288,
0.6285291314,
0.4634728134,
-0.0423150808,
0.1003455892,
-0.664717257,
-0.2521736622,
-0.4550583661,
-0.2644726336,
0.0152557939,
-0.1214572936,
0.1809927523,
0.0943682566,
0.4187496603,
-0.4032503366,
-0.2020094246,
-0.2533195019,
-0.4855942726,
0.3579313159,
-0.1254309416,
0.2777199149,
-0.5627128482,
-0.4107515812,
-0.4063972831,
-0.5104919076,
0.0835027695,
0.5486137867,
0.4784959257,
0.0389464684,
0.423227638,
0.4086782932,
0.7398985028,
-0.1282073855,
-0.0518223196,
0.3317682147,
-0.5968790054,
0.0390424095,
-0.1458891779,
0.5104148984,
-0.2478043735,
0.1567564905,
-0.2110649496,
-0.3523021638,
-0.3400719464,
0.2658835053,
-0.6325529218,
-0.4601472318,
0.0427528098,
-0.2516065836,
-0.2122819126,
0.0182924625,
-0.7718241215,
-0.0760746896,
-0.33965832,
0.4144825935,
-0.7925615907,
-0.2202070504,
-0.292910248,
-0.0770462826,
0.3084679246,
0.2264757454,
-1.2256013155,
-0.0578180961,
0.5196099281,
0.7779152393,
0.010021748,
-0.4313082695,
-0.3094588518,
0.0015009082,
-0.280190438,
0.8103234768,
-0.7917755246,
-0.3028278351,
0.1190983504,
0.1749584228,
-0.163544938,
-0.3364822268,
0.3625855744,
-0.362930119,
0.1430145949,
-0.2939064205,
-0.2948266268,
-0.363849014,
0.4404215813,
-0.8580750227,
1.0764784813,
0.3329152465,
-0.6100237966,
0.1320429444,
-0.6165367365,
-0.5337876678,
0.0705868006,
-0.2160599381,
-0.2971049249,
0.1703708023,
0.2679046392,
0.4783008695,
0.1934776455,
0.4320907891,
-0.1540775895,
0.0695414394,
0.1405222416,
-0.5135325193,
1.0964958668,
0.0992120132,
-0.3318940997,
0.1957431138,
-0.5907819271,
0.0136549724,
0.0067253113,
-0.3019203842,
-0.4148753881,
0.013877674,
0.3377093375,
0.0341527946,
0.1613311321,
-0.6382638216,
0.2087482214,
-0.429930836,
0.5608718395,
0.6544453502,
-0.1707317531,
0.0852996111,
-0.2603854537,
0.5838407874,
0.1178462431,
0.063472487,
-0.6258719563,
-0.6102209091,
-0.615700841,
-0.2463091016,
0.5231453776,
0.3685824275,
-0.6397716999,
0.2450030595,
-0.2036855668,
-0.5373833776,
-0.5481715798,
-0.1559114009,
0.5561041832,
0.3915251791,
0.3182805479,
-0.2285264432,
-0.6665673256,
-1.0354140997,
0.0802033246,
-0.0482367165,
-0.1159872189,
0.3615055084,
0.6638447046,
-0.3424491584,
0.5954325199,
-0.2194806337,
-0.2019709796,
-0.1322289556,
0.4004272223,
0.0919661,
0.3688870072,
0.8118726015,
-1.0620447397,
-0.408441782,
0.0419641994,
-0.2430618852,
-0.0342612192,
0.1890771836,
-0.0572043359,
0.1363420486,
0.4517612755,
-0.3467375636,
-0.0669340193,
1.0405553579,
-0.0444444939,
0.4851224422,
-0.0915235728,
0.2349627763,
-1.1610095501,
0.0639044493,
-0.1212249026,
-0.1946870983,
-0.8084881306,
0.3301863074,
0.2357203066,
-0.0264388602,
-0.5687122941,
0.6212075949,
-0.5312945843,
-0.0835285187,
0.2387910634,
0.0161586441,
-0.1409933269,
0.5972545743,
0.0838265419,
0.8054236174,
0.7210085392,
-0.5641032457,
0.2193387747,
0.3555840254,
-0.3444581032,
0.1740581244,
-0.4697782099,
0.030625958,
-0.1840020269,
0.1094771773,
-1.5427758694,
-0.2314383984,
-0.0054016905,
-0.5883441567,
0.2982636392,
-0.4589356482,
-0.6342291832,
0.1104869545,
-0.3470882475,
0.5647759438,
0.29579705,
-0.5047489405,
0.8048538566,
0.5572437644,
-0.2945598364,
-0.4455364048,
-0.6832480431,
-0.0435770676,
-0.1810368001,
-0.7486361265,
0.6774109602,
0.0605421439,
-0.256133914,
-0.2944600284,
-0.0409417935,
-0.4015773535,
0.0904916376,
0.1933745891,
0.2658350468,
-0.2760525346,
0.3316432238,
-0.0305988248,
0.1401576847,
0.1052336916,
-0.2111700028,
1.1214373112,
0.0247004014,
-0.3726926446,
-0.0491728857,
0.3634347618,
0.46067065,
-0.4386525154,
0.3565744758,
0.6701533794,
-0.4265332222,
0.2478143275,
-0.5014152527,
-0.2755785882,
-0.4287025034,
0.5604662895,
-0.6245379448,
-0.7238867283,
0.7406225204,
0.1917011589,
0.012386688,
0.601026237,
0.5983638763,
-0.2066477835,
1.182856679,
0.6792604327,
0.0012545431,
0.6175954342,
-0.1346175075,
0.0701826438,
-0.6702125669,
-0.2188244462,
-0.7028126717,
-0.1123566702,
-0.7445089221,
-0.3642848432,
0.6373968124,
-0.0833209157,
0.3149456978,
0.3320791423,
-0.354478538,
0.2233850509,
0.6911923289,
0.1686863601,
0.0470747985,
-0.0726377144,
-0.312001884,
-0.2265091538,
-0.4359603822,
-0.3846463263,
1.1024421453,
0.2255989015,
0.5799028873,
0.1983132362,
0.5815748572,
-0.1478438675,
0.0232455526,
-0.8435198665,
0.3725922406,
-0.3680071831,
-0.7889965177,
-0.4875864387,
-0.2670605183,
-1.2211601734,
0.4215937555,
0.2007310539,
-0.7690132856,
-0.0199704692,
0.1875344366,
-0.2865801752,
0.2884067595,
-0.4465760589,
0.5836836696,
-0.5256413817,
-0.042858623,
0.0220315456,
-0.8218767643,
0.1975956708,
-0.0698005706,
0.1142936647,
0.0216968246,
0.0621613041,
0.6784791946,
-0.0202365704,
0.8908392191,
-0.0395985432,
-0.5101034045,
-0.1681587249,
0.2026840597,
0.1391388625,
-0.1635245383,
0.0774461478,
0.3121372759,
0.3172121048,
-0.3779379129,
-0.2747554779,
0.3681903183,
-0.4390736222,
-0.4594009221,
-0.288572371,
-0.7616541982,
-0.4862757027,
0.2200209051,
0.4298597276,
0.4418612421,
-0.034955062,
0.4504052997,
0.9987593889,
0.0508472472,
0.4080581367,
0.1727670729,
-0.2987363935,
0.07590767,
0.4768600464,
0.1606289297,
0.3426404595,
0.8700779676,
0.214330703,
-0.2763232291,
-0.4613886774,
-0.3853565753,
0.2668659687,
-0.5919374228,
-0.0298860092,
-0.7365310192,
-0.3626214862,
-0.5826422572,
0.1797978282,
-0.336375922,
-0.3429200947,
0.0871464163,
0.0793153718,
0.1986464262,
0.5833056569,
-0.0060908766,
0.1358401626,
-0.9400141835,
0.0290676262,
0.3613827229,
0.1584141999,
-0.2488579154,
-0.5772672296,
0.0374025069,
0.3522269428,
-0.386990279,
-1.1290822029,
0.375649929,
0.3157684505,
0.7629753947,
0.488317281,
-0.3765078485,
0.6758939028,
-0.5748182535,
0.9142708182,
-0.2133174092,
-1.109950304,
0.7628349066,
-0.447745651,
0.2478473932,
0.1563766301,
0.8065636754,
-0.5587069988,
-0.4315587282,
-0.4883696735,
-0.9167899489,
0.5551531911,
0.0096551683,
0.6029079556,
-0.0339073539,
0.2562187314,
0.2799036205,
0.0882978812,
-0.8295684457,
-0.1823897809,
-0.0575769208,
-0.0039825412,
-0.056973625,
-0.5290299058,
-0.2073063999,
-0.2458198667,
0.494597882,
-0.1459739208,
0.3123385906,
0.1784623265,
-0.4256130159,
0.0936983526,
0.1130142435,
0.7826409936,
0.7614093423,
-0.1627014726,
0.4508777559,
-0.054843504,
-0.5151023269,
-0.1211046353,
0.2510665655,
-0.0365937054,
0.4831028581,
0.6670827866,
0.7166073918,
0.6222891808,
-0.8168744445,
0.3610784113,
0.3351008296,
-0.3702431321,
-0.1699355692,
-0.1153959855,
0.047176782,
0.2163374871,
0.3577769995,
-0.2504113913,
0.2476645559,
-0.6490547061,
0.4364466667,
0.625635922,
-0.5354254246,
-0.5835087299,
0.4006317854,
-0.1068800166,
-0.1842661053,
0.6126500964,
-0.0832421705,
-0.9804037809,
0.5133774281,
0.3582579195,
0.4391752779,
-0.7977416515,
0.1988162398,
0.2633442581,
0.1753633618,
0.1542481631,
0.3959211409,
-0.2471182644,
-0.8295789957,
-0.3857670128,
-0.5027870536,
-0.3495081365,
0.3066701591,
-0.80267483,
0.1044700891,
0.118724592,
0.0411131345,
0.4392330945,
-0.2561542988,
-0.3838237822,
0.1296587586,
0.1799892634,
0.5965901613,
-0.753184557,
0.9407411814,
0.7170908451,
-0.425244838,
-0.4810298681,
0.1040468365,
0.0579635352,
-1.1690638065,
0.998057723,
0.2243073583,
-0.1994463503,
-0.0497783162,
-0.3768603206,
-1.138789773,
0.6638857126,
0.5382421017,
-0.4413079917,
-0.3473912776,
0.081090346,
0.551499486,
0.0042381496,
0.2692296505,
0.2968844771,
0.5458399057,
0.0438255966,
-1.0432431698,
-0.389675796,
-0.3075387776,
-0.0000038081,
0.5516991615,
-0.2832942009,
1.2570775747,
-0.0057764482,
-0.154400602,
0.0442842618,
0.248223573,
0.0547123328,
-0.3801649213,
0.5995304585,
0.2246293575,
0.6005266905,
-0.3777709007,
0.9890971184,
-0.6272543669,
0.6128234267,
0.7604886889,
0.072398439,
0.7374690175,
0.7871470451,
-0.3421449959,
0.2916520834,
0.9234558344,
-0.2195224613,
0.5185332894,
0.3143658042,
-0.0380906314,
-0.1330495626,
-0.118498452,
-0.2758639157,
0.7005993128,
0.3812040091,
-0.5578407645,
-0.3528648615,
0.1640867591,
0.2999163568,
-0.1413350552,
-0.1301671863,
0.623960793,
-0.3504464626,
-0.7946793437,
0.4640749395,
-0.0538766235,
0.675401032,
-0.8473726511,
-0.1272428334,
-0.2623373866,
0.0220005549,
0.035564024,
-0.7588077188,
0.3715812266,
-0.3930262923,
-0.0811029002,
-0.5946947932,
0.3175429106,
-0.6543735266,
-0.4549200237,
0.4211027026,
0.5513260365,
0.2312842906,
-0.2404427081,
-0.5039291978,
-0.1210565493,
0.1295770258,
-0.329949975,
0.3249582648,
0.4593615532,
-0.0130629437,
0.5471523404,
0.3605959415,
0.0207670517,
0.3575665951,
0.1769278497,
0.6394718885,
-0.4785871208,
-0.3953741789,
-0.9074052572,
0.5169557929,
0.1874986738,
-0.3991238177,
0.7367957234,
0.5576604605,
1.1255402565,
-0.080604434,
0.6652101278,
0.0843699351,
0.3716469109,
-0.7471047044,
0.4369965792,
-0.4636400044,
-0.0639328286,
-0.2566910684,
-0.8795958757,
-0.3195056021,
0.7535716295,
-0.100872986,
0.1948634684,
0.6956576705,
0.6874810457,
-0.2871056795,
-0.0322378241,
0.4415344298,
0.1453244537,
0.3295604885,
0.407458216,
0.7230219841,
-0.2581675351,
0.4981530905,
-0.5311093926,
-0.165846929,
-0.1556580216,
-0.6441968083,
-0.7825865149,
-1.2865629196,
-0.0245919805,
-0.1429227293,
-0.0293312222,
0.6561249495,
0.9519988894,
-0.9259678125,
-0.2575844526,
0.0929259956,
-0.1687684208,
-0.2789873481,
-0.2109954953,
0.4025812745,
-0.7039874196,
-1.0247710943,
0.3250637352,
0.2582595944,
0.1494272053,
-0.5821250677,
0.3903265595,
-0.3406871259,
-0.0280814357,
0.4837230146,
-0.2703028023,
-1.0223605633,
-0.2727876008,
0.1544088572,
-0.1260663271,
0.3175766766,
0.997091949,
-0.3495889604,
0.5594911575,
0.4295975864,
0.7376896143,
0.6232210994,
-0.3168455958,
0.3708587289,
-0.9819605947,
0.1374754161,
0.4416661561,
0.5698799491,
0.1530417204,
-0.2802028656,
0.4158091545,
0.0195629615,
-0.1692396551,
-0.8769966364,
0.6831274033,
-0.771050036,
-0.3998930156,
0.9146183729,
-0.3047189116,
-0.0796188265,
0.0224521328,
-0.207585156,
0.0597563796,
0.0686608329,
0.9325822592,
1.1681929827,
-0.2990911007,
-0.437555939,
-0.4371020198,
0.4265393913,
0.5725830793,
-0.8287058473,
-0.1255801618,
0.3040041327,
0.1239680722,
0.6683048606,
0.2339774072,
-0.2687722445,
0.161566481,
-0.0240942501,
-0.1088144258,
0.1276847422,
-0.3789948523,
-0.3465744555,
0.2399893105,
-0.1969604939,
-0.3602031767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06199v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06199v1 | Reliability Check: An Analysis of GPT-3's Response to Sensitive Topics and Prompt Wording | 2023-06-09T19:07:31 | 2023-06-09T19:07:31 | Aisha Khatun, Daniel G. Brown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have become mainstream technology with their
versatile use cases and impressive performance. Despite the countless
out-of-the-box applications, LLMs are still not reliable. A lot of work is
being done to improve the factual accuracy, consistency, and ethical standards
of these models through fine-tuning, prompting, and Reinforcement Learning with
Human Feedback (RLHF), but no systematic analysis of the responses of these
models to different categories of statements, or on their potential
vulnerabilities to simple prompting changes is available. In this work, we
analyze what confuses GPT-3: how the model responds to certain sensitive topics
and what effects the prompt wording has on the model response. We find that
GPT-3 correctly disagrees with obvious Conspiracies and Stereotypes but makes
mistakes with common Misconceptions and Controversies. The model responses are
inconsistent across prompts and settings, highlighting GPT-3's unreliability.
Dataset and code of our analysis is available in
https://github.com/tanny411/GPT3-Reliability-Check. | [
-0.1507695913,
-1.1445444822,
0.8940115571,
0.2669712007,
-0.0792483389,
-0.0789972842,
-0.1607672572,
-0.4597114027,
-0.4731329083,
0.3372105062,
-0.4079149365,
-0.2497824878,
-0.7237712741,
0.3273801506,
-0.3605018258,
1.0602145195,
-0.2345868647,
0.0246603154,
0.1450523734,
-0.1033628285,
-0.6992616057,
-0.4246376157,
-0.7236230969,
-0.3611443639,
0.5994582176,
0.3997249007,
0.9836058617,
0.3919340968,
0.5239904523,
0.2528478801,
-0.3384864628,
-0.1216691658,
-0.3760889471,
0.1365241557,
-0.156328693,
-0.2591234446,
-0.4173030555,
0.0515677519,
0.5016614199,
0.3787927628,
-0.0796851367,
-0.0552104861,
0.3077691793,
0.5354261398,
-0.3721451163,
0.2067707032,
-0.6524589062,
-0.211952135,
-0.3054570556,
0.2262708247,
-0.4143845439,
-0.422932148,
0.0653683096,
-0.2782126069,
0.3133530021,
-0.0136790136,
0.8770421147,
0.2665267289,
-0.4403079748,
-0.287604481,
-0.7317820191,
0.521026969,
-0.7671505809,
0.1467306316,
0.6722601056,
0.1015212238,
-0.2443883866,
-0.4325256944,
-0.7172265649,
-0.5706725121,
0.0557695888,
-0.1026855633,
-0.1552098095,
0.0591836646,
0.500644505,
0.2931455076,
-0.7955190539,
0.2065077871,
-0.151036799,
-0.3989477754,
0.166482836,
0.0828599855,
0.3406951427,
-0.2710966766,
-0.2611289918,
0.0750089139,
-0.9082424045,
-0.1456205696,
0.5602449179,
0.2351991236,
-0.077354297,
0.6462212205,
-0.0555350296,
0.8723442554,
-0.0909214914,
-0.1718165278,
-0.0585206412,
-0.1687990427,
-0.2082620114,
-0.2194474787,
0.7933822274,
0.3807274997,
0.3035830855,
-0.0259126481,
-0.3356420696,
-0.06210557,
0.2480939329,
-0.4446142912,
-0.1220439598,
0.508998692,
-0.2674511969,
-0.1387651563,
-0.0021609047,
-0.2962344289,
-0.602122426,
-0.0086727496,
0.4541603923,
-0.472117275,
-0.1654758751,
0.2743181288,
0.1422883272,
0.0048374701,
0.2802353799,
-0.7193955183,
-0.1761348844,
0.8135396242,
0.853635788,
-0.1679721028,
-0.5024246573,
-0.5357851386,
-0.0154459933,
-0.2020704448,
0.6954296827,
-0.2871611118,
-0.4950368106,
0.0772979632,
0.1960224509,
-0.0722082481,
-0.4039734602,
0.5572083592,
-0.4872038066,
0.2355683744,
-0.574067235,
-0.4117302895,
0.0023111349,
0.5604900122,
-0.6925547719,
0.7598826289,
0.2208262086,
-0.9875845313,
0.3390641212,
-0.4054242671,
-0.1043498218,
0.1170636937,
-0.2496688515,
-0.4653966129,
-0.0763054788,
0.0449185222,
0.32208395,
-0.2378634214,
0.5230494142,
-0.5354675055,
-0.5790689588,
0.427621007,
-0.4068866968,
0.7082015872,
0.2089923322,
-0.4129706621,
0.1827687174,
-0.7127865553,
-0.2989219427,
0.0750648826,
-0.3773022592,
0.1265322566,
0.0063345144,
-0.246131584,
0.0305606313,
0.0878286287,
-0.4915604591,
0.1636653244,
0.0284397155,
0.4332012236,
0.7794052958,
0.1120422632,
0.1066147164,
-0.4170949757,
0.6173439026,
-0.0467027985,
0.2178725004,
0.0206027869,
-0.7020986676,
-0.5063558221,
0.0241685193,
0.0995634422,
0.6727429032,
-0.9627678394,
0.1253974736,
-0.0880517438,
-0.4084056616,
-0.0220935252,
0.0258511417,
0.3955820203,
0.6095812321,
0.2783045769,
0.1190206409,
-0.3336490393,
-0.9335318208,
-0.5499875546,
-0.7156453729,
-0.0799231827,
-0.1060785204,
0.54494977,
-0.2629648149,
0.8514851332,
-0.3162469268,
0.0798424557,
-0.3961434364,
0.3146555424,
0.2077170014,
0.4175972939,
0.306340456,
-0.3193951845,
-0.2581926584,
-0.2146003693,
-0.5223604441,
-0.1136035547,
0.1160265654,
0.2861835957,
0.1833181083,
0.3356281221,
-0.701225698,
0.1950736493,
0.6112692356,
-0.4241363406,
0.6774143577,
-0.015901912,
0.2213927358,
-0.6094822288,
0.117734693,
0.0506426804,
0.0001293762,
-0.5510201454,
-0.0600039288,
0.1918208003,
-0.1144128218,
-0.4586293995,
0.5412008762,
-0.2314688563,
0.1571038365,
-0.3996767104,
0.0154699413,
-0.2122388035,
0.2074454278,
-0.1742903739,
0.9746162295,
0.2205159813,
-0.546369493,
0.337714076,
0.2025375664,
-0.2441283911,
0.7529605627,
-0.8896760345,
0.4115296006,
0.1162980497,
0.2016072273,
-0.7303459048,
-0.6423681974,
0.446583122,
-0.4902732074,
0.126828596,
-0.2030064911,
-0.6680583954,
-0.3889050782,
-0.3125051856,
0.1745453477,
0.3014324307,
-0.3211422265,
0.5050706863,
0.1065646857,
-0.3453790545,
-0.5522286892,
-0.5003546476,
0.0388338976,
-0.0753505453,
-0.5834008455,
-0.2833752036,
-0.04080927,
-0.4699860513,
-0.134972319,
-0.1854877174,
-0.0732141137,
0.3408202529,
0.11290434,
0.3042463064,
0.06689924,
0.1315514296,
-0.4666421115,
-0.03305953,
0.1997479051,
0.06304539,
0.2367925793,
-0.5103496313,
-0.6078976393,
-0.1922657639,
0.1367405355,
0.5806497931,
0.2796626985,
0.5454642773,
0.5507180095,
-0.3187127709,
0.1814667135,
-0.6448411942,
-0.1907893419,
-0.4427955747,
0.3866426945,
-0.2811148763,
-1.3031340837,
0.5548850894,
0.4887351096,
-0.0678797886,
0.4876493514,
0.4107608497,
0.0184934195,
0.9233086109,
0.6074981689,
0.0508111902,
0.2313661426,
0.3547104895,
0.2382880598,
-0.5735419989,
-0.1977015138,
-0.7980565429,
0.1323279887,
-0.5895547271,
-0.0926762447,
0.3649499714,
-0.0469244681,
-0.6613776684,
0.0723664165,
-0.181748867,
0.5714893937,
0.3333614469,
0.0463714525,
0.4462547004,
-0.2491189688,
0.1789893359,
0.0068639764,
-0.3705896735,
-0.8221583962,
0.7340363264,
0.6416730285,
0.965349853,
0.4223366976,
0.2465545088,
0.0442740843,
0.5301998854,
-0.5796328783,
0.6045100093,
0.0825641975,
-0.6910005212,
-0.2682364881,
-0.6096666455,
-0.790351212,
0.0002099252,
0.0014364757,
-0.8581749797,
-0.0601560585,
0.2688382268,
-0.5211648941,
0.3876282275,
-0.6231729984,
0.6020407081,
-0.1640583873,
-0.395724237,
0.2199629098,
-0.6168729067,
0.799036622,
-0.3307271898,
0.0110151898,
-0.1935486197,
0.1831333041,
0.5420945287,
-0.363024056,
0.9644925594,
-0.0688440651,
-0.5005731583,
0.2631320655,
0.3483242989,
0.6493728757,
0.295432061,
-0.1125739291,
0.0542200468,
-0.1469317228,
-0.381393075,
-0.4243014157,
0.6796241999,
-0.766215384,
-0.8050630093,
-0.5760338902,
-0.395690918,
-0.6329136491,
0.2284953594,
0.3334499002,
0.2877168059,
-0.1438331753,
0.0868781433,
0.8155671954,
-0.2983808219,
0.438018322,
0.7287401557,
-0.2778482139,
-0.3272129893,
0.5862153769,
-0.035659086,
0.3022539914,
0.0102406442,
0.0846338645,
-0.2977718711,
-0.5823447108,
-0.456740886,
0.3110559881,
-0.7538382411,
-0.1477162838,
-0.5373919606,
-0.1247660369,
-0.1470092833,
0.1796341985,
-0.2617904246,
-0.0988031998,
-0.2481848598,
-0.2592161894,
0.3913493156,
1.165389657,
0.0805912763,
0.4438722134,
-0.9035186172,
0.2162340581,
0.5824042559,
0.5038912892,
-0.2731852233,
-0.564160049,
-0.0426035933,
-0.2308357954,
-0.3744819164,
-1.0166226625,
-0.2454349995,
-0.3084425628,
0.4014838636,
0.1377741992,
-0.2423770577,
0.1928770244,
-0.2596097589,
1.1445221901,
0.0396226086,
-1.0530039072,
0.437667191,
-0.7704886794,
0.4334203899,
0.5422972441,
0.2011593133,
-0.4921010733,
-0.5757889152,
-0.6955875158,
-0.6766242385,
0.5063902736,
0.1084674001,
-0.145500645,
-0.2480068803,
0.3958309889,
0.1120893434,
0.1444049627,
-0.7690773606,
-0.0437840782,
-0.2167519629,
0.1326800436,
0.0100213476,
-0.5601328015,
-0.2932474911,
0.2356779277,
0.7494367957,
-0.1941737682,
-0.0643905178,
0.038020432,
-0.085099481,
-0.0074559976,
0.511710763,
0.8780546188,
0.8875849843,
-0.4456688762,
0.3367862999,
0.1073905528,
-0.7198462486,
0.4343356192,
0.0576915331,
-0.1446386129,
-0.0348205864,
0.4532075226,
0.7132367492,
-0.0826423764,
-0.3018348813,
0.4994300306,
-0.2631132305,
-0.09706866,
-0.0253880043,
0.0451725498,
-0.0277732182,
0.0381442532,
0.2227073312,
0.0556449406,
-0.1160208732,
-0.4832358658,
0.1921655983,
0.2566793859,
-0.4279572964,
-0.2684947848,
0.5350689292,
0.2650176585,
-0.15672943,
0.7019078135,
-0.2882602513,
-0.5312932134,
0.5041380525,
0.4032600522,
0.9729702473,
-0.1740275472,
0.3061830997,
0.310126543,
0.7602093816,
-0.4904397428,
0.4870984852,
0.4702055156,
-0.6781256199,
-0.6844875216,
-0.168386668,
-0.7675529122,
0.591226697,
-0.593539238,
0.032054659,
-0.5330485106,
-0.4326146841,
-0.6461091638,
-0.2027654201,
-0.4718085825,
0.2309704572,
-0.0875210762,
0.8441236019,
-0.926620841,
0.5413236022,
0.5359295011,
-0.3256317675,
-1.0804026127,
0.4339984059,
0.2550322413,
-0.7757850885,
0.4061801732,
0.1499790996,
-0.2289562523,
-0.1619088054,
-0.7348050475,
-0.6768911481,
0.9153913856,
0.536247611,
-0.6917218566,
0.2901809514,
-0.0695722997,
0.3315765858,
0.1337943077,
0.3215095997,
0.7675485611,
0.6420809627,
-0.0798969045,
-1.1564283371,
0.2989658117,
0.0336114019,
0.1261897385,
-0.1264397353,
-0.5180496573,
0.7835504413,
-0.3866558671,
-0.2416111827,
0.1851626039,
0.5208513141,
0.6814417243,
0.1226339713,
0.4776644707,
0.5461941957,
0.8477647901,
-0.3639829755,
1.1551277637,
-0.1405870318,
0.535810411,
1.2042050362,
-0.4935807884,
0.6001765132,
0.3101828694,
-0.2039226443,
0.1917893589,
0.6629178524,
-0.0782765895,
0.1368676871,
0.120741345,
-0.2750597298,
-0.1652548015,
0.1449426711,
-0.5624754429,
0.1804699153,
0.1419729143,
-0.0208037738,
-0.2346315384,
-0.1628327072,
0.3622564673,
-0.259909898,
-0.1132425293,
0.5235843062,
0.0534226634,
-0.7266228795,
0.5052875876,
-0.0069319089,
0.4725253284,
-0.5547732115,
0.1154678613,
-0.4432256818,
0.1016149297,
-0.1012635529,
-0.951025486,
0.1247989684,
0.1518185735,
-0.175143674,
0.0071812873,
0.5863349438,
-0.1242334023,
-0.1682471484,
-0.0021268784,
0.6847018003,
-0.034369152,
-0.1010080352,
-0.7223548889,
0.5900995135,
-0.0106346356,
-0.3324407041,
0.2125355154,
0.372633785,
-0.0394517705,
0.7799608707,
0.4465892017,
0.1409886181,
-0.3621337414,
0.2753763795,
0.5544703007,
-0.6210743785,
-0.0731717274,
-1.0320113897,
0.436563164,
0.1061074808,
-0.426048398,
0.7464718223,
0.1654309779,
0.5716824532,
-0.0751037449,
0.8868157864,
0.1242143065,
0.5444821715,
-0.7513350844,
0.465867877,
-0.0220348611,
0.6607089043,
-0.1706909537,
-0.8985939026,
-0.4756304026,
0.4267829657,
-0.3997157514,
0.3479277492,
1.0927797556,
0.8000394702,
0.1603831351,
0.1688185185,
0.228785485,
0.5326507092,
0.4557371438,
0.3591848314,
1.1976354122,
-0.1259300113,
0.4916349053,
0.123320356,
-0.1926927418,
-0.0891276076,
-1.1435190439,
-0.7392747998,
-0.3644870222,
-0.3500107825,
-0.8698712587,
0.2329486459,
0.5150698423,
0.1763661653,
-0.6470783353,
0.0309662931,
-0.1443733722,
0.3105838597,
0.0942008197,
-0.2336927056,
0.2861052752,
-0.2725565135,
-0.3373229504,
0.2735723853,
0.2364626676,
0.3338796496,
-0.2743608654,
0.0728854686,
0.2742069066,
-0.07862854,
0.2340184301,
0.4797385335,
-0.8615943789,
-0.7149736881,
-0.1851290464,
-0.2805048823,
-0.2580800056,
0.8502750397,
-0.3481883109,
0.1553381532,
0.2943280041,
0.4596728981,
-0.1029777229,
0.0324855335,
0.6517373323,
-0.4247946739,
-0.2888115942,
0.1384713352,
0.5880428553,
0.7128477097,
-0.4425221682,
0.4853881896,
0.2927113175,
-0.9863597751,
-0.7084240913,
0.5170759559,
-0.792139411,
-0.1827654541,
1.5207028389,
-0.2075173557,
-0.0181220379,
-0.4671168029,
-0.2880660594,
-0.0051894919,
-0.3516606987,
0.7851303816,
1.1534485817,
-0.1272522211,
-0.0544820242,
-0.7091776729,
0.6575036049,
0.3399175704,
-0.6072848439,
0.2034371197,
0.609716475,
0.6310658455,
0.0493245758,
0.8153002262,
-0.1843527406,
0.2633396685,
-0.3006055355,
-0.1553924382,
-0.0154667273,
-0.1340104938,
-0.6683067083,
0.1274385601,
0.564240098,
0.1567540467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06190v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06190v2 | $FastDoc$: Domain-Specific Fast Pre-training Technique using Document-Level Metadata and Taxonomy | 2023-06-09T18:42:19 | 2023-11-14T21:51:21 | Abhilash Nandy, Manav Nitin Kapadnis, Sohan Patnaik, Yash Parag Butala, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | As the demand for sophisticated Natural Language Processing (NLP) models
continues to grow, so does the need for efficient pre-training techniques.
Current NLP models undergo resource-intensive pre-training. In response, we
introduce $FastDoc$ (Fast Pre-training Technique using Document-Level Metadata
and Taxonomy), a novel approach designed to significantly reduce computational
demands. $FastDoc$ leverages document metadata and domain-specific taxonomy as
supervision signals. It involves continual pre-training of an open-domain
transformer encoder using sentence-level embeddings, followed by fine-tuning
using token-level embeddings. We evaluate $FastDoc$ on six tasks across nine
datasets spanning three distinct domains. Remarkably, $FastDoc$ achieves
remarkable compute reductions of approximately 1,000x, 4,500x, 500x compared to
competitive approaches in Customer Support, Scientific, and Legal domains,
respectively. Importantly, these efficiency gains do not compromise performance
relative to competitive baselines. Furthermore, reduced pre-training data
mitigates catastrophic forgetting, ensuring consistent performance in
open-domain scenarios. $FastDoc$ offers a promising solution for
resource-efficient pre-training, with potential applications spanning various
domains. | [
-0.6350598335,
-0.5557208061,
0.452932328,
0.0551856533,
-0.3064824939,
0.1787905842,
-0.1937839538,
0.1632115543,
0.2994502783,
0.4572160542,
-0.7118142843,
-0.7320067286,
-0.7552114129,
0.2859373689,
-0.277410686,
1.1088587046,
-0.0846034214,
-0.169670105,
-0.4101505578,
0.0084819878,
-0.0272698533,
-0.2598588169,
-0.8634150028,
0.0737401471,
0.5302292705,
0.2068488896,
0.753202498,
0.9075987339,
0.7516567707,
0.2287216634,
0.2825658023,
0.320186168,
-0.4738866389,
-0.0447879024,
-0.4659337401,
-0.4564476609,
-0.6211823225,
0.3006434143,
0.4534109235,
0.7862638235,
-0.3913507462,
0.1343629211,
-0.3004464209,
0.3866409361,
-0.9715458155,
0.2150879651,
-0.8045774698,
0.1219953299,
-0.5946719646,
-0.6681822538,
-0.4925817251,
-0.150736168,
0.1071487293,
-1.167701602,
0.6063712239,
-0.1378377825,
0.8145468831,
0.3648125529,
-0.3515766859,
-0.21284841,
-0.576299727,
0.4507496655,
-0.4036332369,
0.524743557,
0.4787564278,
0.1301646233,
0.0911986083,
-1.271399498,
-0.6063402891,
0.1196571812,
0.0765402913,
0.0529067516,
0.1913901567,
0.1179119945,
0.4642740786,
0.2995400727,
-0.4604207277,
0.0379710607,
-0.0769882053,
-0.2078265548,
0.2048896253,
0.121583648,
-0.0566027239,
0.1712881625,
-0.2980753481,
-0.1895412356,
-0.5077854395,
-0.1312287301,
0.1796108186,
0.1692633182,
0.3390412033,
0.0386625119,
-0.1361018866,
0.4881944954,
0.0176357497,
-0.2508947849,
0.2976340353,
-0.4307824075,
-0.1061069816,
-0.1036737785,
0.6879863143,
-0.0007047217,
0.3129284382,
-0.3032381833,
-0.2080772221,
0.1612306535,
0.9101144671,
-0.9382241964,
-0.0331056118,
-0.1062187478,
-0.4348739982,
-0.1453414857,
-0.133434087,
-0.4706614017,
-0.231058538,
-0.3315571845,
0.2439283729,
-0.4023439586,
0.0617754459,
0.152989164,
0.1428243369,
0.1753628403,
0.4155497253,
-0.8623606563,
0.5889245868,
0.8851464987,
1.1150227785,
-0.1406000257,
-0.5658792257,
-0.8622612357,
0.07363078,
-0.394051671,
0.6960256696,
-0.5522710085,
-0.5279439092,
0.1141190082,
0.1400867254,
-0.1441281438,
-0.4924563169,
0.8267425299,
-0.6707753539,
-0.0099821016,
0.2677160501,
-0.3730884194,
0.34535864,
0.2561055422,
-0.6543723345,
0.779173851,
0.3374976218,
-1.0102955103,
0.5418114066,
-0.7831474543,
-0.6400610209,
0.1627932787,
0.1030508503,
-0.1931262612,
-0.2099591047,
0.1996522099,
0.6498816013,
-0.5668557286,
0.2664036453,
-0.1879608333,
-0.2897993326,
-0.2282371074,
0.1806211621,
0.4759112298,
0.3854210973,
-0.1899816245,
0.2647304833,
-0.8679001331,
-0.10238453,
0.3358338177,
-0.0791752562,
-0.7414421439,
-0.3391661942,
-0.2798397243,
0.2952176929,
-0.0743567497,
-0.4378555119,
0.3000037074,
-0.5697612166,
0.3609328866,
0.6692724824,
-0.107216619,
0.7187527418,
0.0742401853,
0.7492136359,
-0.1498010904,
0.2868004143,
-0.3077584505,
-0.1851288676,
-0.624099791,
-0.3553260267,
0.4552524388,
0.5124853849,
-1.2327202559,
0.2628446221,
-0.5597260594,
-0.4493009746,
-0.7380375266,
0.0629806295,
0.4774518907,
0.6357524991,
0.5072485209,
-0.8200719953,
-0.3485281765,
-0.6134221554,
-0.5312688351,
0.4100168347,
-0.2045096308,
0.1631081849,
0.6908932924,
-0.4638201594,
0.9076232314,
-0.7183569074,
-0.6817443371,
0.126977995,
0.4686172009,
0.1640484631,
0.3716491461,
0.3829950988,
-0.7870193124,
-0.5108458996,
-0.3954396546,
-0.3482687473,
0.0879398733,
-0.386700362,
-0.2411766946,
0.0114667676,
0.6495963335,
-0.8764353991,
0.2124844342,
0.0691865757,
-0.1626981944,
0.4451856315,
-0.5153447986,
-0.032427229,
-0.9836031795,
-0.0362130776,
-0.0567327999,
-0.1834630221,
-0.6660240889,
0.0648767054,
0.3519291878,
-0.2936421037,
-0.6265664101,
0.6956812143,
-0.3547683954,
0.2423635572,
-0.0876132697,
0.1213247105,
-0.066328913,
0.3748447299,
0.195532009,
0.914413929,
0.5838255882,
-0.7007058263,
0.0427904986,
0.518494308,
-0.3366588056,
0.5551676154,
-0.2476215959,
0.4686851501,
-0.0220049247,
0.5937889218,
-0.1397679597,
-0.0112709757,
-0.0014235572,
-0.1831975728,
0.266272366,
-0.0422888808,
-0.7739681602,
-0.4342826903,
-0.4515423477,
0.2955317199,
0.2323045284,
-0.6224325895,
0.5394416451,
0.3068467975,
-0.071466513,
-0.6043599248,
-0.4130174518,
-0.0017368563,
0.149229005,
-0.4602605402,
0.8157336712,
0.1609153152,
0.1782958359,
-0.0871347934,
-0.2847070098,
-0.1545262337,
0.2967941761,
0.1556910127,
-0.0793292075,
0.0105721364,
0.1151483208,
0.0010647406,
-0.3373101354,
0.1999767721,
-0.7645335197,
0.5202929974,
-0.0963369533,
0.0166507736,
-0.2266451269,
0.3259576559,
0.4423514605,
-0.7649612427,
0.8777492046,
0.7202132344,
-0.2797909677,
-0.6172617078,
-0.1700051427,
-0.2074782997,
-0.5047286749,
0.2758443356,
-0.4925475419,
-0.7751622796,
0.1408771724,
-0.615639925,
0.0059349248,
0.5084020495,
0.4170104563,
0.2682878971,
0.5799120665,
0.8355451226,
0.2967763841,
0.5876820087,
-0.5353764892,
0.3735094965,
-0.6102613807,
-0.2415191531,
-0.4945162535,
0.1364378333,
-0.3931371868,
-0.8390251398,
-0.0025149442,
-0.109162949,
-0.3756694198,
0.3038178682,
-0.4140145481,
0.37251243,
0.6454923749,
-0.33622545,
0.0074044489,
-0.28236866,
-0.1405480653,
0.0967860222,
-0.5749461651,
-0.3717602491,
1.2914077044,
0.2322819233,
0.6845080853,
-0.3317567706,
0.9398735762,
0.3699254394,
0.1034974158,
-0.7145836353,
0.6131061316,
-0.5489715338,
-0.2194821537,
-0.0843991265,
-0.5461754203,
-0.8497277498,
0.0314351767,
-0.300037384,
-0.0942454189,
0.0676130727,
0.0282982532,
-0.4109638333,
0.2891247869,
-0.5394685864,
1.1138807535,
-0.2405552268,
-0.3573530614,
-0.2158813477,
-0.9030365944,
0.0324526615,
-0.477751106,
0.2314941585,
-0.0563917346,
-0.2286326289,
1.0148444176,
-0.6107017994,
0.3836902678,
-0.4871398509,
0.0371604562,
0.1514873654,
0.0853061453,
0.6537731886,
0.141566366,
0.2148384601,
0.1522506773,
-0.1463864446,
-0.2862586677,
-0.7647070885,
0.393455863,
-0.497325778,
-0.4310861528,
-0.4409967661,
-0.3427701592,
-0.6169224977,
0.4779503942,
0.2322066426,
0.2169915736,
-0.3401941955,
0.2255924195,
0.850504756,
-0.0946781784,
0.0894262046,
0.5968164206,
0.2738103867,
-0.2196921408,
0.8419008851,
0.0328031965,
0.1301840842,
0.6010271311,
-0.0179740153,
-0.1016755402,
-0.6421180964,
0.1253749132,
0.3577077985,
-0.7567323446,
-0.2341645509,
-1.074557066,
-0.0734282359,
-0.7546448112,
-0.4912406802,
-0.5785204172,
-0.3741572797,
-0.410059303,
-0.0793649703,
0.1446141005,
0.0277306382,
0.23603791,
0.6528372765,
-0.818909049,
0.6624274254,
0.1078038812,
0.6169005632,
-0.299528867,
-0.2474566996,
-0.4778259695,
-0.4253280759,
0.0082117906,
-0.3371006548,
0.5634100437,
0.6231691837,
0.4524901509,
0.4184784293,
0.2922418118,
0.428127259,
-0.8076941967,
0.6324154139,
0.082132265,
-0.9699619412,
0.7498065829,
-0.2593586147,
0.3531263769,
0.8725426197,
0.9601791501,
-0.4794760048,
-0.2437454313,
-0.7266862392,
-1.2109825611,
0.9131081104,
0.0097830761,
-0.048454836,
-0.20197846,
0.5351473093,
0.3878083527,
0.3057100177,
-0.1216137484,
-0.1609832048,
-0.4599746168,
-0.0878018513,
-0.2671730518,
-0.0317814648,
-0.3283845782,
-0.1865158975,
0.5713605285,
-0.4993466735,
0.3729824126,
0.0588592067,
-0.3951112926,
0.4598425925,
0.2934094965,
0.4346543849,
0.4450714588,
-0.3752925396,
0.2690379918,
-0.0170149785,
-0.8022859693,
-0.0468961857,
0.1178394705,
0.0822328404,
0.0387273729,
0.3145447969,
0.9522573948,
0.1667337418,
-0.5143944025,
0.6006372571,
-0.3545221686,
-0.4294451177,
-0.0235589445,
0.0155400205,
-0.1280367672,
-0.1829036027,
0.0819195732,
0.224729538,
0.0532323346,
-0.502807498,
0.2676925659,
0.1445167065,
0.0334966108,
-0.1600665897,
0.7519850731,
0.4836736321,
-0.3273261189,
0.5764375925,
-0.3410021365,
-0.3288837969,
0.4352682531,
0.505834341,
1.0320308208,
-0.0466560498,
0.301908046,
0.1062150374,
0.160942018,
-0.3267571926,
-0.0075175944,
-0.4544629753,
-0.4872580469,
-0.2291038781,
-0.8065858483,
-0.5509778857,
-0.2301345617,
-0.6102227569,
0.0885666087,
-0.7264950275,
-0.3218954802,
0.081989646,
0.1395885795,
-1.0654804707,
0.437322706,
-0.1226941422,
1.2080522776,
-0.4717923105,
1.3301199675,
0.4463951886,
-0.195076406,
-0.7138243318,
0.1077285931,
-0.0164135583,
-0.3790203631,
0.8346428871,
0.1441628039,
-0.5366999507,
0.0728569478,
-0.1564142406,
-0.5935676098,
1.0199131966,
0.4000194371,
-0.4419085681,
-0.3539073765,
0.1396262646,
0.5861539841,
-0.5887926817,
0.170788601,
0.6456680298,
0.2513899803,
-0.2446401119,
-0.9187602401,
0.0921101719,
-0.3402469456,
0.0255831964,
0.2246609479,
-0.4075320959,
1.0062379837,
-0.1004466116,
-0.3471160233,
-0.4284649491,
0.5671918392,
-0.2285329252,
0.3598365784,
0.723593533,
0.472728014,
1.0843304396,
-0.1160418615,
1.1521767378,
-0.3860801756,
0.3111915886,
1.1640117168,
-0.5171375275,
0.5539280772,
0.392349124,
-0.1102346778,
0.354121089,
0.5861161351,
0.0661426559,
0.8819308877,
0.1213795096,
-0.1839962304,
-0.1196103916,
-0.2314980924,
-0.3751420975,
0.3424346745,
0.3193490505,
-0.1426451504,
-0.0512555316,
0.2394533604,
0.1401077211,
-0.0679541528,
-0.499478966,
0.7306440473,
0.1817813814,
-0.581158042,
0.6444309354,
0.2147177756,
1.0848402977,
-1.17022264,
0.311142087,
-0.1698056608,
0.5200836062,
-0.1542115808,
-0.4985860288,
0.3678452075,
0.0791191831,
-0.0857534781,
-0.9477385879,
0.7486807704,
-0.1830820739,
0.1020470783,
0.4782049656,
0.3101291358,
-0.0661037639,
-0.2428002506,
-0.4345259666,
-0.4344959557,
-0.4921647906,
-0.2855395675,
0.5624781251,
0.6364439726,
-0.1086775735,
0.5295078754,
0.8266843557,
0.2091599107,
0.0620215647,
0.2657437325,
0.8587002754,
-0.5640832186,
-0.7710024118,
-0.3348570168,
-0.0067684888,
-0.0464959703,
-0.55386132,
0.6091963649,
0.4609456956,
1.2822612524,
-0.442969054,
0.4452612102,
0.1524419487,
0.5073315501,
-0.6452855468,
0.8943576813,
-0.543727994,
-0.0381039158,
-0.1042272523,
-0.7725541592,
-0.4651978314,
0.439722985,
-0.2115927041,
-0.1426506788,
1.1715004444,
0.5790923238,
-0.0708366558,
-0.1038210765,
0.0993567556,
-0.0373174809,
0.4368336499,
0.2888767123,
0.4203685224,
0.0715021864,
0.4399520755,
-0.479501605,
-0.1019979641,
-0.0564371273,
-0.9126606584,
-0.7172887921,
-0.621701479,
-0.3035422564,
-0.2109746933,
0.1509102732,
0.9065034389,
0.7094051838,
-0.561404407,
0.1106380075,
-0.0173949171,
-0.1193314418,
-0.3131598532,
-0.1456335783,
0.4892273545,
-0.6553295255,
-0.44447276,
0.5762572885,
0.2370626181,
-0.4080479741,
0.0073890141,
-0.040178448,
-0.3957091272,
0.2975991666,
0.5841534138,
0.2405991405,
-0.2597860694,
0.1620634049,
-0.0322039425,
-0.2309725136,
0.0862542018,
1.5078326464,
-0.9969707727,
0.5283941627,
0.3051273227,
0.8787173629,
0.6433867216,
-0.1880271435,
0.4450373054,
-0.8491311669,
0.3030867279,
0.4857450724,
0.2010102123,
0.1836180985,
-0.2941759527,
0.7253187299,
0.4185801148,
-0.2454033792,
-0.8435211778,
0.0309420079,
-0.8902924657,
-0.392185688,
0.668585062,
-0.4519613087,
-0.2249514908,
0.0061779912,
0.0210819114,
0.3996293843,
-0.3477730751,
0.4934297502,
0.3894808292,
0.1942749918,
0.2151347399,
-0.5861795545,
0.780575335,
0.3572407067,
-1.1408762932,
0.0717921779,
0.0091766985,
0.0765844956,
0.3619557321,
1.0515788794,
0.0439957604,
0.1485858858,
0.1401291639,
0.0586843863,
-0.3717682958,
-0.7247306705,
-0.2014895529,
0.5117518306,
-0.1822398156,
-0.1395388842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06094v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models for Scalable Vector Graphics-Driven Image Understanding | 2023-06-09T17:57:01 | 2023-06-09T17:57:01 | Mu Cai, Zeyi Huang, Yuheng Li, Haohan Wang, Yong Jae Lee | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have made significant advancements in
natural language understanding and generation. However, their potential in
computer vision remains largely unexplored. In this paper, we introduce a new,
exploratory approach that enables LLMs to process images using the Scalable
Vector Graphics (SVG) format. By leveraging the XML-based textual descriptions
of SVG representations instead of raster images, we aim to bridge the gap
between the visual and textual modalities, allowing LLMs to directly understand
and manipulate images without the need for parameterized visual components. Our
method facilitates simple image classification, generation, and in-context
learning using only LLM capabilities. We demonstrate the promise of our
approach across discriminative and generative tasks, highlighting its (i)
robustness against distribution shift, (ii) substantial improvements achieved
by tapping into the in-context learning abilities of LLMs, and (iii) image
understanding and generation capabilities with human guidance. Our code, data,
and models can be found here https://github.com/mu-cai/svg-llm. | [
-0.4520054162,
-0.524169445,
0.7091641426,
-0.0921171233,
-0.703825891,
0.0324402191,
-0.3346323073,
-0.4524672031,
-0.103759639,
0.6733856201,
-0.5148189068,
-0.9200474024,
-0.7168394923,
-0.068633154,
-0.1832851171,
0.589158237,
-0.1174342409,
0.1545991153,
-0.4228597581,
-0.2655721605,
-0.4519879222,
0.0062150424,
-0.9038411975,
-0.1494570822,
0.390873909,
0.24454844,
0.7396663427,
1.1180906296,
0.4814904034,
0.3098235726,
0.1030656695,
0.1537278593,
-0.5528592467,
0.178025499,
0.0184500236,
-0.3789183795,
-0.1727351546,
-0.2050644159,
0.6505936384,
0.7172083855,
0.1695343256,
0.169305101,
0.0732300207,
0.4469574392,
-0.4118364453,
0.5665152669,
-0.7287016511,
0.1946861893,
-0.0751481056,
-0.2125639766,
-0.5008612275,
0.0042021209,
0.2185419053,
-0.923733294,
0.3273220062,
-0.0025907899,
0.6696470976,
0.5350182056,
-0.4772081971,
-0.2652782202,
-0.6185148954,
0.8856085539,
-0.3289286792,
0.37436831,
0.1216096431,
0.7558281422,
-0.2070366591,
-0.993468225,
-0.5960079432,
0.0384996384,
0.1496576518,
0.0152281262,
-0.0996931642,
-0.0444629826,
0.3097764254,
0.3958080709,
-0.4153519869,
0.2262643129,
-0.1634769142,
0.0088494299,
0.404268086,
0.1457224339,
0.5872593522,
-0.1532551348,
-0.6510714889,
-0.3120652735,
-0.7916990519,
-0.0849056318,
-0.2450020462,
0.220440805,
-0.181468904,
0.5783534646,
0.4715985358,
0.727003932,
-0.2552790344,
-0.2069216073,
0.0787091702,
-0.0896671861,
-0.313367188,
-0.410251677,
0.6027677655,
0.5229719281,
-0.0307882801,
-0.1730950326,
-0.255016923,
0.0747533515,
0.1132652611,
-0.7786915898,
-0.0982319042,
-0.1035943776,
-0.6122988462,
-0.1642379463,
-0.1946184486,
-0.731515348,
-0.644321382,
-0.3847944438,
0.2485307306,
-0.4287451804,
-0.1099117026,
0.0685252473,
-0.2391785085,
0.594250083,
0.7212148905,
-0.6651419401,
0.0402164049,
0.6455001235,
0.9164786339,
-0.2777374387,
-0.076596655,
-0.5962079167,
0.4384822845,
-0.456641227,
0.8518126607,
-0.6765594482,
-0.2760222554,
0.0455513895,
-0.0197530519,
0.464626193,
-0.5511108041,
0.5917797685,
-0.4435824752,
-0.2283483893,
-0.222178638,
-0.2763086855,
-0.2074350864,
0.1089973748,
-0.7497223616,
1.0203073025,
0.1474237293,
-0.6820552945,
0.645860076,
-0.4025906324,
-0.4220861495,
0.721459806,
-0.6526076794,
-0.3872109056,
0.1475317776,
0.4628615081,
0.825815618,
-0.3852625191,
0.0024731173,
-0.188295424,
-0.3538658917,
-0.1645683497,
-0.3028616607,
0.3897049129,
-0.0038801234,
-0.1729926467,
0.1582763791,
-0.8226457834,
-0.0752927437,
0.4559554458,
-0.397028029,
-0.4852956831,
0.2884823084,
0.1863338351,
0.3513581753,
0.1075336784,
-0.5364260674,
0.3761010468,
-0.1545404941,
0.5207721591,
0.864131093,
-0.4152701497,
0.7638581991,
0.1950439215,
0.5377322435,
-0.2565814555,
-0.0428268462,
-0.6591050029,
-0.3750483096,
-0.744348824,
-0.7499447465,
-0.219572559,
0.1597642899,
-1.465387702,
-0.0163312927,
-0.6677694917,
-0.1842122227,
-0.1633963138,
0.1314601898,
0.1292153299,
0.5006862879,
0.3021347225,
-0.0490958169,
-0.3681087494,
-0.8276143074,
0.1380582005,
-0.0181594249,
-0.5322818756,
0.6583396792,
0.3895092607,
-0.4923837483,
0.7068927884,
-0.778778255,
-0.2196790278,
-0.4514386952,
0.3006855249,
-0.0369855426,
0.2301218212,
0.6782917976,
-0.7930819392,
-0.5448142886,
0.3063667417,
-0.6779543757,
0.0208195634,
-0.1654548496,
-0.2651167214,
-0.0135808121,
0.6851270199,
-0.4525853395,
0.3591099381,
0.3956968784,
-0.2311640084,
0.1758077294,
-0.2886536121,
-0.1643901318,
-1.0417964458,
-0.4196252227,
0.4251728952,
-0.5243316293,
-0.4879674017,
0.1916638911,
0.1587727666,
-0.271702975,
-0.3368908465,
0.3605907857,
-0.5685634017,
-0.3621391654,
-0.3764567077,
-0.0527068563,
0.0287185572,
0.4197847843,
0.3745371997,
0.643013835,
0.9305232763,
-0.516866982,
0.4981307983,
0.2333053797,
-0.4811469615,
0.6888783574,
-0.4360676408,
0.1121174768,
-0.4674271345,
0.4122768044,
-1.0963674784,
-0.2781398296,
0.1335047185,
-0.3189311326,
0.3516964316,
-0.3522005081,
-0.5098164082,
-0.246298328,
-0.2553017735,
0.3262512982,
0.5096376538,
-1.2017846107,
1.0071157217,
0.4374428689,
-0.1598816216,
-0.3405500352,
-0.6017764807,
0.2700867951,
-0.1949130744,
-0.8047927022,
0.3107375503,
0.1307840645,
-0.1134499758,
-0.1640031636,
0.0280457418,
-0.0756800473,
-0.1564552188,
0.2914706469,
0.5391210318,
-0.2966915667,
0.3857688606,
-0.1608468592,
-0.0614924282,
0.1036268324,
-0.3909805715,
0.4167566001,
0.0848914906,
-0.2384037971,
-0.1169028655,
0.4690898657,
0.7781615257,
-0.3994501531,
0.5840228796,
0.716326654,
-0.376067549,
-0.6774968505,
0.0375769436,
0.0588388443,
-0.4780085087,
0.5350658894,
-0.3336870968,
-0.99137187,
0.360707432,
-0.5378614664,
0.2117998302,
0.3513363302,
0.4723396301,
-0.272100389,
1.167247057,
0.8792828918,
0.2885427475,
0.4469982088,
-0.3007498085,
0.1349103749,
-0.7943077087,
-0.1577972025,
-0.2209106088,
-0.1569550782,
-0.44251436,
-1.0564358234,
0.4012002349,
-0.2391798645,
0.000676711,
0.0183199644,
-0.4098033905,
0.6579598188,
0.0189204812,
0.0001509286,
0.065365158,
0.1927228719,
-0.0760210827,
-0.0986905545,
-0.5917327404,
-0.5563461781,
1.0566879511,
0.4663845897,
1.1447826624,
-0.0315245502,
0.1697702557,
0.2069693804,
0.3966890574,
-0.9139612317,
0.8172218204,
-0.3575675189,
0.1340277642,
-0.4465450048,
-0.3966251016,
-0.8705863953,
0.6243029833,
-0.5388594866,
-0.4491155744,
-0.1403313428,
-0.019727407,
0.0431730822,
0.4837107956,
-0.6123438478,
0.6978269815,
-0.2717060745,
-0.2553634346,
-0.0044713053,
-0.3397482634,
0.2748114467,
-0.0513594896,
0.2055354565,
-0.1249749586,
-0.2726258039,
0.1714214534,
-0.3562650979,
0.841508925,
-0.0676022246,
-0.3623278737,
-0.0778467953,
-0.0127581079,
0.7271936536,
-0.0340344161,
0.4164589345,
0.1456833482,
-0.3599662483,
-0.2872766852,
-0.8154795766,
0.7118777633,
-0.6548277736,
-0.4004507065,
-0.1126137301,
-0.6224649549,
0.0699605569,
-0.0194908101,
0.1730899215,
0.4118560553,
-0.1538184136,
0.22292234,
0.8745759726,
-0.7228881717,
0.3229216635,
0.2150853872,
-0.4021423161,
-0.0868957862,
0.9296265244,
-0.0965357348,
0.0604526699,
0.3874834776,
0.1336962432,
-0.3183166683,
-0.6557491422,
-0.6003124118,
0.1712613851,
-1.1199001074,
-0.1167527288,
-0.5148287416,
0.1382635981,
-0.2393706739,
-0.4238014221,
-0.2262221128,
-0.0455313809,
-0.3749417365,
0.0363879651,
0.2287375182,
1.0161031485,
0.4169111252,
0.2030433714,
-0.4193862081,
0.4898763001,
0.4908296466,
0.4726128876,
0.0819197148,
-0.3092654943,
-0.2319693118,
-0.2932554781,
0.013841182,
-0.4962460697,
0.4943858087,
0.244962424,
0.503940165,
0.4961445034,
-0.1527218223,
0.6382286549,
-0.7609608769,
0.7697976828,
0.3005226552,
-0.879166007,
0.4530137479,
-0.4798567891,
0.3802334368,
-0.2000370026,
0.2348718941,
-0.5420703292,
-0.4018113911,
0.0126397703,
-1.1280070543,
0.5139125586,
-0.0272382461,
0.28356269,
-0.0412013382,
0.4499369562,
0.1975125819,
-0.2911337316,
-0.7645739913,
-0.1600327343,
-0.2855038941,
-0.217132017,
-0.2023776472,
-0.1858242452,
-0.0429293811,
-0.3007940352,
0.2205578685,
-0.5230132937,
0.1277406961,
-0.1849844903,
-0.2974156141,
0.0475669168,
0.0028259561,
0.4027692676,
0.6151097417,
0.2598239481,
0.448412925,
0.1482260674,
-0.5890912414,
-0.019687064,
-0.1204844043,
-0.0184652861,
-0.0456510484,
0.3770121932,
0.9435439706,
0.1478395462,
-0.8502242565,
0.6306045055,
-0.5211187005,
-0.1855518669,
-0.358997494,
-0.2018586397,
0.0653084368,
0.3993418813,
0.5058636069,
-0.1729384363,
-0.0191920325,
-0.0470189936,
0.0393412225,
0.7263255119,
-0.1140343398,
-0.1053795367,
0.7287304997,
0.2086497694,
0.0433868952,
0.4029598236,
-0.0575450845,
-0.2038375735,
0.6615284085,
0.7500429749,
0.6914568543,
0.1063285619,
0.4189950824,
0.270994097,
0.1611826122,
0.0358870029,
0.0316971987,
-0.1786222756,
-0.8049719334,
-0.7412009239,
-0.5418969989,
-0.2439807951,
0.2795457542,
-0.5012051463,
0.308560133,
-0.4918656647,
-0.0147894369,
0.3527346551,
-0.6028444767,
-0.7120339274,
0.1022296399,
0.520192802,
0.7581586242,
-0.8526239991,
0.6553664804,
0.9814398885,
-0.1582196951,
-0.5576896667,
0.0529932827,
-0.230631128,
-0.8353329897,
0.8952947855,
0.1934848279,
-0.3533902764,
-0.1273191273,
-1.0010234118,
-0.772870183,
1.2221903801,
0.6427264214,
-0.2547773123,
0.3593701422,
0.1952863187,
0.4565591514,
-0.5237929821,
-0.1238046959,
0.2562976182,
0.1245385036,
0.6831949949,
-0.2379184663,
0.0191957019,
-0.202308476,
0.5670853853,
0.2806087136,
-0.2211247981,
0.9437025189,
-0.2303660512,
-0.5538398623,
-0.1473791897,
0.7937595844,
-0.0596496575,
0.0238445681,
0.5642495751,
0.6356724501,
0.6886177063,
-0.1099062636,
1.1051547527,
0.1194992214,
0.1355201006,
1.0031249523,
-0.1601829678,
0.6480852962,
0.363385886,
0.0790366977,
0.1964940131,
0.6219393015,
0.0530667529,
0.4021466374,
0.1734796017,
-0.5379093289,
-0.5369031429,
-0.0832804218,
0.0655233189,
0.5732493997,
0.4543114305,
-0.583863318,
-0.548971355,
0.3680948913,
-0.1684322059,
0.0924300551,
-0.7831736207,
0.5966098905,
-0.0763717815,
-0.1939512044,
0.5753430724,
0.0201671589,
0.65565449,
-0.3815609813,
-0.5307854414,
0.2082348168,
0.0686090961,
-0.0291472822,
-1.0073283911,
0.1424609721,
0.1580407768,
-0.1083212048,
-0.4567992091,
0.8449195027,
-0.419921577,
-0.4627341032,
0.1275435835,
0.1982306391,
0.1827362627,
0.1273869425,
-0.3849605918,
0.2800017893,
-0.1491836607,
0.0528833121,
0.2838279903,
0.6511385441,
-0.2519414425,
0.8163725138,
0.5621129274,
-0.1015527248,
0.059649054,
0.2092078924,
1.0099619627,
-0.4051449299,
-0.444290787,
-0.9049248099,
0.1079812869,
0.0205718968,
0.2238620222,
0.7251284122,
0.4662695825,
0.8008315563,
-0.2028013021,
1.0761942863,
0.2682819068,
0.0324644819,
-0.5366413593,
0.6564252973,
-0.4912194908,
0.082603164,
-0.260261476,
-0.7292559147,
-0.4778263569,
0.7284625173,
-0.3365090191,
-0.2840633988,
0.2974315584,
0.4226766229,
0.0122752953,
-0.2149442285,
0.5858615637,
0.1137605608,
0.495801121,
0.4731146991,
0.8306170106,
0.1720512658,
0.5766677856,
0.3030884564,
-0.3072539866,
0.164584443,
-0.9527953863,
-1.0437275171,
-0.6026981473,
-0.1825246066,
-0.110857822,
-0.4325512946,
0.7156068683,
0.5792215466,
-0.2141654044,
0.1014622077,
-0.1286810637,
0.110385932,
0.0354166925,
-0.0972472951,
0.390666306,
-0.1984499693,
-0.9043028355,
0.1401523203,
0.8271675706,
0.3078148365,
-0.5459124446,
-0.1757157892,
0.2853802741,
0.1450522691,
0.9729102254,
0.1874206364,
-0.6396725178,
-0.3017031848,
-0.1294950992,
-0.1701622456,
0.324275285,
0.765027225,
-0.7234533429,
0.5506163239,
0.4494034052,
0.8333151937,
0.6128954887,
-0.2157700509,
0.4890478253,
-0.7529469132,
0.2034275234,
0.01429254,
0.5579126477,
0.6024512053,
-0.3618849516,
0.2383347005,
-0.0264265724,
-0.2660880685,
-0.5415428877,
0.5143000484,
-0.9735202193,
-0.3986457884,
1.2078770399,
-0.2455533147,
-0.4235490859,
-0.032396771,
-0.4495436847,
0.1133659557,
-0.0185502656,
0.3938783705,
0.5551779866,
0.0734045804,
-0.5652475953,
-0.5912186503,
0.3076520562,
-0.2647672594,
-0.7811532617,
0.0795057341,
0.7276598811,
0.1183480248,
-0.1777154952,
0.5271258354,
-0.0256167334,
0.0357855409,
-0.2066431046,
0.3448438942,
0.1108931676,
-0.1111028865,
-0.4292728305,
0.0077189654,
0.0576331355,
-0.3668512404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07401v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07401v1 | Implementing BERT and fine-tuned RobertA to detect AI generated news by ChatGPT | 2023-06-09T17:53:19 | 2023-06-09T17:53:19 | Zecong Wang, Jiaxi Cheng, Chen Cui, Chenhao Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The abundance of information on social media has increased the necessity of
accurate real-time rumour detection. Manual techniques of identifying and
verifying fake news generated by AI tools are impracticable and time-consuming
given the enormous volume of information generated every day. This has sparked
an increase in interest in creating automated systems to find fake news on the
Internet. The studies in this research demonstrate that the BERT and RobertA
models with fine-tuning had the best success in detecting AI generated news.
With a score of 98%, tweaked RobertA in particular showed excellent precision.
In conclusion, this study has shown that neural networks can be used to
identify bogus news AI generation news created by ChatGPT. The RobertA and BERT
models' excellent performance indicates that these models can play a critical
role in the fight against misinformation. | [
-0.412099421,
-1.2433220148,
0.5726777911,
0.2622485161,
-0.2626985312,
0.0690485388,
-0.2019365132,
-0.8151106238,
0.2037166655,
0.2098568529,
-0.6267569065,
-0.2773051262,
-0.7928600907,
-0.2555580437,
-0.7450886369,
1.3574031591,
0.3711103499,
0.2341786772,
0.1582574248,
0.1942718476,
-0.2723370492,
-0.3162423968,
-0.8490498662,
-0.1940532029,
0.4356940091,
0.2002122253,
0.9092348218,
0.1784228981,
0.532047689,
0.2188624889,
0.0800170153,
0.7017142773,
-0.381834358,
0.0321715362,
0.1825499535,
-0.3981873989,
-0.1585564464,
0.2856396437,
0.3324015141,
-0.0062064538,
-0.1457556039,
0.371502161,
-0.0502988733,
0.6047252417,
-0.1116935387,
0.0806789994,
-1.0895963907,
0.0378462151,
-0.2985308766,
-0.3044271767,
-0.5292831063,
-0.8425566554,
0.1036259159,
-0.4580046237,
0.4210136831,
0.1264789551,
1.4305348396,
0.2785862088,
-0.1218922436,
-0.6079044938,
-0.9942808747,
0.6607130766,
-1.037347436,
0.0344809778,
0.0872448906,
0.5067614913,
-0.389698714,
-0.6063905358,
-0.8487199545,
-0.4374672771,
0.1508567184,
0.1515195668,
-0.5667238832,
-0.244170934,
0.1760375351,
0.0790041685,
-0.8302676082,
0.0372485034,
-0.5112485886,
-0.3299529254,
0.6629216671,
-0.2072191685,
0.465454191,
-0.266967684,
-0.2242153138,
0.0952145755,
-0.4639926553,
-0.3521585763,
0.7743525505,
0.2250645906,
-0.0010067804,
0.4294038713,
-0.0423789173,
0.8001664281,
0.2078165859,
-0.1696010232,
0.0993549526,
-0.0509588718,
-0.2061893493,
0.1347328424,
0.6203816533,
0.2728214264,
0.6819454432,
-0.1745294631,
-0.3493678868,
0.3375290632,
0.5730901957,
-0.4257316887,
-0.2573161125,
0.2170416266,
-0.782828927,
-0.6932497621,
0.227343753,
-0.5376366377,
-0.2448480427,
-0.3759700358,
0.4931568801,
-0.6381400228,
-0.1677309573,
-0.0827971846,
-0.5135329366,
0.2776597738,
0.793205142,
-0.3141829669,
-0.1078542843,
0.6718690395,
0.6882436872,
0.1115973964,
0.0392307453,
-0.5148201585,
-0.008343677,
-0.4606779516,
1.1101344824,
-0.3122612238,
0.1941763163,
-0.0389558896,
-0.3460910022,
0.1067270115,
-0.4270108342,
0.6598866582,
-0.7842023969,
0.5047677755,
0.1729737967,
-0.6267034411,
-0.334274739,
0.5517670512,
-0.5049734712,
0.930847168,
0.0621179678,
-0.658156693,
0.5518189073,
-0.6656336784,
-0.6119257808,
-0.0040486124,
0.2399554998,
-0.7954455614,
0.1808151454,
0.4387113154,
0.2049643397,
-0.0647701621,
0.4160099924,
-0.181647867,
-0.1834861636,
0.3555882871,
-1.0157971382,
0.822475493,
0.4560792446,
-0.4715453088,
0.1706499159,
-0.8163755536,
0.1914541721,
-0.0057353363,
-0.3740085959,
-0.113243714,
0.0890622586,
0.1182570234,
0.0336301811,
0.2012168765,
-0.6066204309,
0.106959641,
-0.2048060298,
0.3545407355,
0.6653241515,
0.183998391,
-0.020557465,
-0.808445096,
0.1715800166,
-0.0003800596,
0.3646244705,
0.1906242818,
-0.8608943224,
-0.8015127182,
-0.1076043993,
0.6579726338,
0.6177997589,
-0.6429881454,
0.516005218,
0.0501801893,
-0.762088716,
-0.787578702,
-0.1447083205,
0.0199941844,
0.3558357656,
0.3079041839,
-0.0869581476,
-0.5828829408,
-0.7919008136,
-0.5654978156,
-0.0250153616,
-0.1691029221,
0.2593637407,
0.2591952682,
-0.0812897608,
0.8505081534,
-0.1154949069,
-0.2988918424,
-0.1357515454,
0.6656178236,
0.2776470184,
0.4759602547,
0.7740488052,
-1.0170886517,
-0.5257897973,
-0.2132449895,
-0.6208460927,
0.0098503679,
-0.3215608001,
0.1024288014,
0.698407352,
0.0126832006,
-0.7227163911,
0.7648283839,
0.5718182325,
-0.0045124521,
0.7449451685,
-0.2804096639,
0.3088625073,
-0.9079557061,
-0.0873919576,
0.1191135943,
-0.5148717165,
-0.5368211865,
-0.1966706067,
-0.1166038439,
-0.2058562785,
-0.2062242478,
0.2604374886,
-0.4136349261,
-0.0989580601,
-0.3300428987,
0.2691153884,
-0.1931700259,
0.14547351,
-0.1609716266,
0.7271651626,
0.383644402,
-0.5796986818,
0.3591040969,
-0.1013470888,
-0.5914068818,
0.2594644427,
-0.6909706593,
-0.0905520171,
-0.1589088142,
0.526145637,
-1.1214914322,
-0.4458669424,
0.3774773479,
-1.1730642319,
0.0182824526,
-0.1609336138,
-0.8750674725,
-0.4995539188,
-0.0883265808,
-0.233286038,
0.7707768679,
-0.585309267,
0.5188295841,
0.3322227299,
0.0861799046,
-0.3115678132,
-0.6545317769,
0.1243456379,
-0.0583100393,
-0.8430777788,
0.1477907002,
0.1181759536,
-0.4326351881,
0.2037055045,
-0.0724481568,
-0.2744635642,
-0.0909793079,
0.0969613418,
0.2025381476,
-0.4364944696,
0.1261485219,
-0.1579553783,
-0.0252224728,
-0.0384037644,
-0.1934409142,
0.6826059818,
-0.0444691665,
-0.4264388382,
-0.8912696838,
0.0260895044,
0.9243357182,
-0.3375099003,
0.8965997696,
1.0549048185,
-0.4333573878,
-0.3611448705,
-0.8514925838,
-0.2898492217,
-0.3941358626,
-0.0308803488,
0.1981841326,
-0.3645947278,
0.4279488623,
0.0511946231,
-0.085924238,
0.6747580767,
0.4788525701,
-0.102128379,
1.2484209538,
0.4888764918,
-0.3120105863,
0.5670017004,
-0.0953207985,
0.4071570337,
-0.2396740615,
-0.0809549466,
-0.557038188,
-0.3819361329,
-0.6209319234,
-0.2034736872,
0.4736749232,
-0.116676718,
0.0254165269,
0.0497665256,
-0.7933931947,
0.2829809487,
1.1527656317,
0.3379100859,
0.2646680176,
0.153836295,
0.2990148067,
0.1047959328,
-0.6717648506,
-0.588399291,
1.1094841957,
0.2892371714,
0.712841332,
0.0926331282,
0.464011848,
0.8470569849,
0.4444418848,
-0.5218471289,
0.2886524796,
-0.1360329688,
-0.7872475982,
-0.2719886601,
-0.1596280187,
-0.7258909345,
-0.2298796773,
-0.4505569637,
-0.4599332809,
-0.182984516,
0.2009827346,
-0.4061073661,
0.4605477452,
-0.5832828283,
0.3700621128,
-0.2775284946,
0.038787894,
-0.7304086685,
-0.5075349212,
0.4631239176,
-0.0390367508,
0.1079367995,
-0.2444812506,
0.48209548,
0.4733925164,
-0.4625570476,
0.8296564817,
-0.3872685134,
-0.0067208381,
0.5955510736,
0.0226324182,
0.850276351,
0.2937505245,
-0.172495544,
0.2275535315,
-0.3980610073,
-0.3815520108,
-0.317869246,
0.6697173715,
-0.8451219797,
-0.4695024192,
-0.5064043403,
-0.7057341933,
0.0849923491,
0.1457822323,
0.4215529859,
0.2289575636,
-0.1191838384,
0.1891827881,
0.6401647925,
-0.2375863791,
0.4013394117,
0.8585160971,
0.0040911417,
-0.1130127087,
0.8731344938,
0.240462333,
-0.0113472212,
0.1344079375,
0.0007516445,
0.1286790967,
-0.5825384855,
-0.605761826,
-0.0790194571,
-0.0144532891,
-0.3922347724,
-0.3133126199,
-0.7688964009,
-0.3438420296,
-0.0804779008,
-0.3129165471,
-0.5394173861,
-0.372933358,
0.2577766478,
0.3974688947,
0.9025061131,
-0.2806061506,
0.4556479156,
-0.9170613885,
0.4777151644,
0.1414930373,
0.1198714077,
-0.0595433339,
-0.475925386,
-0.0625884086,
0.510266006,
-0.4646220505,
-0.7624759674,
0.6283447146,
-0.0227010697,
0.5403382778,
0.4656101167,
0.0242479499,
0.664116621,
-0.3554050624,
0.9255988002,
-0.1663495153,
-0.7666774392,
0.7991629839,
-0.6983349919,
-0.1101746261,
-0.0560988225,
0.3229182065,
-0.1872828305,
-0.7901872396,
-1.0300198793,
-0.449424386,
0.5800310373,
0.3434949219,
0.0918317065,
0.0897757187,
0.2134601325,
0.1071999371,
0.195603475,
-0.8436394334,
0.0203552842,
-0.0349408276,
-0.1699806303,
0.3645854294,
-0.2840811014,
-0.0081347171,
-0.1089235097,
0.9114928842,
0.1860147566,
0.4737766385,
0.1707229465,
-0.0217342712,
-0.375616312,
-0.0277518407,
0.8712729216,
0.7303754091,
-0.2122063041,
-0.3314489722,
-0.1379526705,
-0.231980741,
-0.2968873084,
0.1619992703,
-0.513600111,
0.5168043971,
0.4896498621,
0.5883021951,
-0.0908651277,
-0.653937459,
0.5127984285,
-0.1107248589,
-0.2872000337,
-0.8589490652,
0.4463243186,
-0.1546963155,
0.4356432557,
0.634822607,
0.8646214008,
-0.0056921276,
-0.6272848845,
0.3419860899,
0.8306918144,
-0.2108062059,
-0.2546147108,
0.7154337168,
0.0846829414,
-0.5156518817,
0.878023386,
-0.1629214734,
-0.5932650566,
0.9139903784,
0.5979973078,
0.5740540624,
-0.0839031711,
0.4455786049,
0.2444501668,
0.5113672018,
-0.2171197981,
0.2076220959,
0.1700569242,
-0.9051080942,
-0.1005415469,
-0.5092236996,
-0.2537549138,
0.4542800486,
-0.5154440403,
0.3309761584,
-0.3290354609,
-0.2075167298,
0.3012759686,
0.07082396,
-0.4542520642,
0.2804263532,
0.1812095046,
0.9572073221,
-0.760950923,
0.892133832,
0.4236622453,
-0.5084113479,
-0.7525247931,
0.631092906,
0.1978941113,
-0.9872469306,
0.6863560081,
0.0530656427,
0.2766834795,
0.1258877069,
-0.8671525717,
-0.861217916,
0.7546064258,
0.3423169255,
-0.5113845468,
-0.0673902333,
-0.1258208156,
0.6296187043,
-0.3294083476,
0.1004449129,
0.0665430874,
0.8565386534,
-0.0088867182,
-1.0246404409,
-0.4872059524,
-0.0219880026,
-0.1928879917,
0.0979072228,
-0.8002020717,
1.0857424736,
-0.1814692467,
-0.0900861993,
0.2062396258,
0.5414789915,
0.0629062951,
0.4770387411,
0.4016237855,
0.573864758,
0.8659365773,
-0.232240364,
0.9462474585,
-0.6485924125,
0.3146149218,
0.8581399918,
0.1011638641,
0.6985940933,
-0.0226927679,
0.0032087364,
0.6607311964,
0.7806135416,
-0.4066970348,
0.5012323856,
0.2307534069,
-0.2017963976,
-0.2402935773,
0.0629241467,
-0.3366036713,
0.4405473173,
0.6288511157,
-0.5083661079,
-0.4124123454,
0.1571215391,
0.071711354,
-0.005592776,
-0.2973616123,
0.7030800581,
-0.4024996161,
-0.8527922034,
0.4064877033,
0.0821687505,
0.7078306079,
-0.6516389847,
-0.1808876842,
-0.0846780241,
0.3112173378,
-0.1670667678,
-0.6668837667,
0.3724554479,
0.1547186822,
-0.4706559181,
0.021601541,
1.2071653605,
-0.4396221638,
-0.5824337602,
-0.0071922042,
0.6046334505,
0.2234221846,
-0.2097595185,
-0.6884123683,
0.0391116217,
0.2848853767,
-0.2441156954,
0.0182676893,
0.6216391325,
-0.0359790996,
0.7456127405,
0.9798513651,
0.3098069727,
0.0777744874,
-0.0575099289,
0.8266963959,
-0.3026122749,
-0.2966304123,
-0.8084154725,
0.1803767979,
-0.385907948,
-0.2403954417,
0.9512087703,
0.6670236588,
0.6611571908,
-0.2551771104,
1.1315441132,
-0.3635649681,
0.9527422786,
-0.46316576,
1.1397910118,
-0.4505312443,
0.2052106857,
-0.1496748775,
-0.7537974715,
-0.2998829186,
0.7084131837,
-0.2288852632,
0.0110919271,
0.3791075647,
0.8503600955,
-0.0956569389,
0.1051189229,
0.0076479786,
0.3436009884,
0.3276297748,
0.1493421793,
0.6366479397,
-0.3911389709,
0.6443353891,
0.0669908449,
-0.1926040649,
-0.6321473122,
-0.7760264277,
-0.8356561661,
-0.323605597,
-0.2322009504,
-0.4351410866,
0.4718501866,
0.6338472962,
0.9145988226,
-0.9163479209,
0.2936558127,
-0.3103498518,
0.2025365829,
-0.2680078745,
-0.3613388836,
0.2985899448,
-0.6587892175,
-0.7820779085,
0.2388195843,
0.0305116884,
0.0866473392,
-0.2690690458,
0.0511607416,
-0.3346822858,
0.4336411655,
0.4270168841,
0.1896393448,
-0.8839268088,
-0.738374114,
-0.3312184811,
-0.2385149002,
-0.0719821826,
0.4905101061,
-1.0143284798,
0.1201264113,
0.4120398462,
0.4135495424,
0.4347803593,
0.3092668056,
0.6851824522,
-0.6924509406,
0.2749598324,
0.3135391176,
0.0045518656,
0.0190598909,
-0.6756758094,
0.5379849076,
0.2044162452,
-0.8029249907,
-0.8478652239,
-0.1255625486,
-0.7928169966,
-0.3610146344,
0.7460722923,
0.1100123823,
-0.2162586302,
-0.0331697762,
-0.3793029785,
0.3648700416,
-0.6152101755,
1.3069167137,
0.7705818415,
-0.3488761485,
0.0570769608,
-0.7593315244,
0.6722732186,
0.157246843,
-0.7405459881,
-0.3736692667,
0.4846526682,
0.3593865037,
0.3807816803,
0.2931729853,
0.0664891005,
0.5415932536,
0.0982589498,
-0.0961526036,
-0.1397295892,
-0.3734238446,
0.3527834415,
0.0654811934,
-0.1328409463,
-0.2562614977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06086v1 | Developing Speech Processing Pipelines for Police Accountability | 2023-06-09T17:48:58 | 2023-06-09T17:48:58 | Anjalie Field, Prateek Verma, Nay San, Jennifer L. Eberhardt, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Police body-worn cameras have the potential to improve accountability and
transparency in policing. Yet in practice, they result in millions of hours of
footage that is never reviewed. We investigate the potential of large
pre-trained speech models for facilitating reviews, focusing on ASR and officer
speech detection in footage from traffic stops. Our proposed pipeline includes
training data alignment and filtering, fine-tuning with resource constraints,
and combining officer speech detection with ASR for a fully automated approach.
We find that (1) fine-tuning strongly improves ASR performance on officer
speech (WER=12-13%), (2) ASR on officer speech is much more accurate than on
community member speech (WER=43.55-49.07%), (3) domain-specific tasks like
officer speech detection and diarization remain challenging. Our work offers
practical applications for reviewing body camera footage and general guidance
for adapting pre-trained speech models to noisy multi-speaker domains. | [
-0.4500313103,
0.0959790796,
0.561576426,
-0.1650827527,
-0.3216421008,
0.4738936424,
-0.181614995,
-0.5831235051,
0.1240741313,
0.6105811,
-0.4692617655,
-0.2349262089,
-0.8606805801,
0.0873408616,
-0.6517984867,
0.7873981595,
0.0536073297,
0.6688911915,
0.3895048797,
0.0896425098,
-0.3896531761,
-0.5752716064,
-0.7577878833,
-0.4290341139,
0.4382681251,
0.2189595848,
0.6385622621,
0.8149468899,
0.2302887589,
0.3696001172,
0.0867920071,
0.0456881933,
-0.2750605643,
-0.0021402859,
-0.369967401,
0.2035906017,
-0.6903508902,
0.0779886767,
0.7691501975,
0.5855250955,
-0.0876525939,
0.1113299951,
0.0243405569,
0.5997864604,
-0.9460014701,
0.0687023774,
-0.4833059311,
-0.2701172233,
-0.3215966225,
-0.2996477187,
0.1567326933,
0.0842457861,
0.2007610351,
-0.3928981125,
0.3874816895,
-0.3102503419,
0.5259314775,
0.4083344638,
0.1064715162,
-0.3307897449,
-0.9225085974,
0.3751274049,
-0.4455449283,
0.7357035279,
0.6385851502,
0.2189228535,
0.2554619014,
-0.6105444431,
-0.7415664196,
0.1820199788,
0.1315958947,
0.1387747824,
-0.0036205377,
0.2468325347,
0.0179464594,
0.3309663832,
-0.3564807177,
0.3137034476,
-0.7351729274,
-0.280226469,
1.0019495487,
0.2418212146,
-0.0548329428,
0.124697119,
0.2135325074,
-0.3627507389,
-0.3822417855,
0.1341193169,
0.6035830975,
0.4238660634,
-0.084960483,
0.3301109672,
-0.6201987267,
0.7730270028,
-0.0020200999,
-0.1006370857,
0.2792114317,
-0.2076449543,
-0.3322098255,
0.4002360404,
0.6707756519,
0.5405148864,
0.5148830414,
-0.1080971658,
-0.328713119,
0.4434993565,
0.4630267024,
-0.7585154176,
-0.2781576514,
0.6093156934,
-0.0716502666,
-0.2013596147,
0.2813957036,
-0.599676609,
-0.4082780778,
-0.8045451045,
0.3394671082,
-0.2002040595,
-0.4761834741,
0.3374002576,
-0.1167123318,
0.3173273206,
0.4178574681,
-0.8710784912,
0.2597128749,
0.9340450168,
0.8178274035,
-0.0564895384,
-0.4054046869,
-0.8528197408,
0.344573319,
-0.3998135924,
0.932780087,
-0.6281813979,
-0.1417828351,
0.0372709408,
0.2907829285,
0.1999059767,
-0.5221828222,
0.6604679227,
-0.1221607253,
-0.4037787914,
0.0061157569,
-0.3095801175,
0.2784232199,
0.042257905,
-0.0692419186,
0.4077449441,
-0.0213159714,
-0.2409008294,
0.5948665738,
-0.5962074995,
-0.4920278788,
-0.0502782017,
-0.1619105637,
-0.5694768429,
-0.0012974004,
0.6274959445,
0.4727351665,
0.2185806036,
0.1143594757,
0.0575808473,
-0.6694159508,
0.1224324927,
0.0704494193,
0.6474035978,
0.4333996177,
-0.2007228583,
0.3210197091,
-0.643370688,
0.1771571636,
-0.5609748363,
-0.1353034079,
0.1857630461,
0.0999197513,
0.1474268138,
-0.2152983844,
-0.4941322505,
-0.8056198955,
-0.3003270328,
-0.3112353683,
0.6979544759,
0.7900813818,
-0.324462682,
0.475538224,
-0.1524004191,
0.532954514,
0.0288900398,
0.0775143951,
-0.2854781747,
-0.1986141801,
-0.5339807868,
-0.392487824,
0.4009871185,
0.2855695784,
-0.4161234796,
0.4608486891,
-0.2988829315,
-0.516630888,
-0.7547470331,
-0.1121372655,
0.2955113053,
0.4540588558,
0.2155763209,
-0.8913686275,
-0.7155757546,
-0.3639438152,
-0.4941421151,
-0.3295572102,
-0.435875088,
-0.1342624128,
0.3640263975,
-0.1014833003,
0.8793365955,
-0.2193660736,
-0.6078010201,
-0.0288188998,
0.0945872739,
-0.018044956,
0.6099901795,
0.1299720854,
-0.7049728036,
-0.3234974146,
-0.3271481395,
-0.3446463346,
-0.0746381581,
0.2442221344,
0.2406412512,
-0.150525555,
0.5655782223,
-0.2944144607,
0.600053668,
0.4033098817,
-0.0761770308,
0.5341439843,
0.12798132,
0.3345285058,
-0.3666359484,
-0.1258614808,
-0.3192114234,
-0.6650623083,
-0.8615704179,
0.0455362536,
-0.2772541642,
-0.8281139135,
-0.6143308282,
0.2222830057,
-0.6093732715,
-0.4655240178,
-0.4185400903,
0.2246206105,
-0.2525325418,
0.2470130026,
0.6887074709,
0.6203815341,
0.8996058106,
-0.9779395461,
0.2589683533,
0.2698565125,
-0.7506219149,
0.8024581075,
-0.6519129276,
0.3536107242,
-0.3420807421,
0.2767046094,
-0.8372762203,
-0.5514953136,
0.0091695897,
-0.7340716124,
0.2841686606,
-0.6270199418,
-0.3741216958,
-0.3152064085,
-0.2591349483,
0.1054362729,
0.2765835524,
-0.3477643132,
0.2404210418,
0.9906432629,
-0.126671806,
-0.42123276,
-0.7982832789,
0.006487947,
0.1693493128,
-0.4690853357,
0.1201687008,
0.1031510532,
-0.0356959179,
-0.2350951582,
-0.2722533047,
-0.5686516762,
-0.1713501662,
0.2184091359,
0.0420034975,
-0.041194953,
0.0639708936,
-0.3640431464,
0.053079281,
0.0348554179,
-0.0721006691,
0.6188041568,
0.0859179199,
-0.2272434086,
-0.5660277605,
0.5197947621,
0.6055202484,
-0.3824187815,
0.3145433366,
0.8432658911,
-0.3683697283,
0.3097679615,
-0.5393990278,
-0.4427009225,
-0.4793992937,
0.3550798595,
-0.0695017278,
-0.8704576492,
0.2304906994,
0.2446629554,
-0.0064478307,
-0.2380681038,
0.6204020381,
-0.3335338235,
0.9357019663,
0.4042193294,
-0.1617012769,
0.7094097733,
-0.0814412311,
0.3171430826,
-0.797177732,
0.0427601971,
-0.3925104141,
-0.2654657364,
-0.5896045566,
-0.337159276,
0.6218627095,
-0.06411957,
-0.3783525527,
0.1453125775,
-0.8828624487,
0.7028591037,
0.1733057648,
0.1417415738,
0.2639449835,
0.0972292349,
0.6563818455,
0.0760821551,
-0.4548678398,
-0.4426835179,
1.14237988,
0.528899312,
0.6297582388,
0.0076865545,
0.4050844014,
-0.0649430603,
0.3384878337,
-0.8583205938,
0.4015304744,
-0.3806483746,
-0.7788805962,
-0.5340869427,
0.1027878523,
-0.799374938,
0.2061115354,
-0.0597940758,
-0.6576758623,
0.3823774159,
0.3042840362,
-0.6257571578,
0.4017975926,
-0.5797997713,
0.4915892482,
0.1120878085,
-0.3001206517,
-0.215794161,
-0.7629056573,
0.2742963731,
0.0892795473,
0.2746842802,
-0.3621090651,
0.342543602,
0.7855430245,
-0.8391487598,
0.6320000887,
-0.4958074987,
0.1260326952,
0.4926506281,
-0.4332903624,
0.254827261,
0.07373932,
0.1208030358,
0.2817546427,
0.1011610776,
-0.0516439565,
-0.3278286159,
0.2155119479,
-0.509578824,
-0.3885838091,
-0.418926388,
-0.4309856892,
-0.5926707983,
0.1014821753,
0.2889668643,
0.5356968045,
0.1368766725,
0.0747342035,
0.3681190312,
0.2475487441,
0.5039561987,
0.8268490434,
-0.090462774,
-0.2524089813,
0.5513629913,
0.0839827657,
0.0825139359,
-0.0292091332,
0.1702544391,
-0.4358293116,
-0.5958179832,
-0.5786468983,
-0.0205545612,
-0.329192251,
-0.2705790997,
-0.6920666695,
-0.3419697583,
-0.9982911348,
-0.005289061,
-0.6997396946,
-0.3337365389,
-0.150676176,
0.1017928943,
0.332960695,
0.567625165,
-0.5789427757,
0.7298157215,
-0.470567733,
0.5246378183,
0.4827347994,
0.4217126369,
-0.0786708146,
-0.6252407432,
-0.1698148847,
0.1055905521,
-0.3558953404,
-0.5414689183,
0.4381419122,
0.2026011199,
-0.0880494937,
0.2100534588,
-0.0070866379,
1.1091299057,
-0.7952817082,
0.7030221224,
0.3052063286,
-1.1319469213,
0.6357281208,
-0.359297663,
0.4011037648,
0.6996071935,
0.034606155,
-0.3757963181,
-0.6552155018,
-0.214549914,
-0.4572793841,
0.7313329577,
0.2365397364,
0.1348233223,
0.2194285542,
0.2370647192,
-0.4804714024,
0.435410291,
-0.2462207526,
0.0196645893,
-0.4676655829,
0.1639370024,
-0.1293930262,
-0.0284559894,
-0.12179555,
-0.4995892048,
0.3636682332,
-0.114642784,
0.4003543258,
0.6953086257,
0.0923083574,
-0.2113773376,
0.5139862299,
0.638315618,
0.8682400584,
-0.259367466,
0.0215073749,
-0.0122340787,
-0.7352846861,
0.381943047,
-0.2327162772,
0.1040788963,
0.2182071954,
0.276114136,
0.6805317998,
-0.0189843439,
-0.7589274049,
0.7502511144,
0.1749958992,
-0.2125356197,
-0.7334643602,
0.0146704596,
-0.2224418074,
0.1290273368,
0.3064535558,
0.2315487564,
0.2638855278,
-1.0945625305,
0.4396679401,
0.2481562048,
-0.6041460633,
-0.2575559616,
0.828525424,
0.1513883471,
-0.4572408497,
0.3925949335,
-0.3100683093,
-0.8866388202,
0.1187000349,
0.0076146633,
0.7412848473,
-0.6939451098,
0.0188641679,
0.4455313683,
0.2486206591,
-0.2633318901,
0.3231256604,
-0.1950407177,
-0.9671149254,
-0.7646401525,
-0.5469989777,
-0.6006284356,
0.2944494188,
-0.9126790166,
0.4645705819,
-0.7937176228,
-0.2564815879,
0.1440169662,
-0.2880108953,
-0.5681726933,
0.6207290292,
0.3150428236,
0.5631248355,
-0.7234165072,
0.8822104931,
0.2740207314,
-0.1266750991,
-0.9569604397,
-0.123339586,
0.070892036,
-0.7683394551,
0.588974297,
0.1763582677,
-0.5386994481,
-0.324367702,
-0.6253774762,
-0.4595153332,
0.6159235239,
0.6256542206,
-1.0094871521,
-0.0283241998,
0.0221594404,
0.6779090166,
-0.5221283436,
0.0634976849,
0.9106587768,
0.3036639392,
0.154768154,
-1.3607100248,
-0.5298025608,
0.2664583921,
-0.3347892761,
-0.0176010597,
-0.5601573586,
0.6984710097,
-0.1810411215,
-0.3538027406,
0.0181876365,
0.4065323174,
0.4131555259,
0.4872426093,
0.6996150613,
0.5384105444,
0.7325173616,
-0.083912164,
1.114898324,
0.1545131058,
-0.0191288106,
1.5296355486,
-0.3529329896,
0.9847658277,
0.4044287503,
-0.2393158525,
0.3861146271,
0.5350301266,
0.0748039931,
0.6357795,
0.2761259973,
-0.2562571764,
-0.3681170344,
-0.4523621798,
-0.0579319745,
1.0205763578,
0.1184723675,
-0.2598382235,
0.1428669393,
-0.0034669174,
-0.2618569434,
0.047346402,
-1.1186517477,
0.6622753143,
-0.0843283609,
-0.6514849663,
0.4329025745,
-0.2637667954,
0.4886573851,
-0.2816111743,
0.1060649231,
0.2720505297,
0.1297228783,
-0.5709429979,
-1.014333725,
0.8098478317,
0.422806561,
-0.0592965297,
-0.5992497206,
0.6138635874,
-0.527369082,
-0.2983980775,
0.067067191,
0.1977789253,
0.5993872881,
-0.5329457521,
-0.2577119172,
0.3603104651,
-0.094062753,
0.2487173378,
0.0167368818,
-0.0331742764,
0.2024861127,
0.4653085172,
0.6424637437,
0.5923773646,
0.0814528763,
0.2531897426,
0.8518204093,
-0.2400321215,
-0.9164898396,
-0.6227943897,
0.732096374,
-0.2353292704,
-0.15609321,
0.1077337712,
0.6306542754,
1.0895804167,
-0.0974394456,
0.6291930676,
0.1445915103,
1.0932438374,
-0.6786648035,
0.7094269991,
-0.2276923656,
-0.0026729049,
-0.3939464986,
-0.7425721288,
-0.3168157637,
1.0079549551,
-0.1946942359,
-0.2453798056,
0.4524032474,
0.9186103344,
-0.2942886949,
0.1081118137,
0.4477166533,
-0.1750070304,
0.2238255441,
0.2661012709,
0.8058130741,
-0.6870105267,
0.5154453516,
-0.1339278668,
0.0688220635,
0.2897120118,
-0.7356519699,
-0.834725976,
-0.6054692864,
-0.5209109783,
-0.0710988194,
0.1317483783,
0.4173138142,
1.4643152952,
-0.8834366202,
-0.3699043691,
-0.0609004609,
-0.3322281837,
-0.0051769996,
-0.1774668992,
-0.0238894634,
-0.0585295558,
-0.9057232141,
0.7010971308,
0.3336797059,
-0.0708758235,
-0.1975085735,
-0.1161672696,
0.1788099408,
-0.2100599408,
0.4257044494,
0.332747072,
-0.6075220108,
-0.5398510098,
-0.5118151307,
0.3242322206,
0.2638133466,
1.2480595112,
-0.710537374,
0.5807474256,
0.1180810109,
0.4967280924,
0.9297729731,
0.0001795766,
0.7269851565,
-0.867872417,
0.4111398458,
0.3992527723,
0.1898690313,
0.5739322305,
-0.0962490067,
0.8874735236,
-0.0030171315,
-0.6956177354,
-1.1406595707,
0.3594404757,
-0.822445333,
0.0186853278,
0.6067665815,
-0.1994131953,
-0.103409104,
-0.4682256579,
0.1388747692,
0.3589877784,
-0.4378658533,
0.3673846126,
0.6265471578,
-0.3545066416,
-0.6023461223,
-0.5158084631,
0.7110620737,
0.0892922357,
-0.5323988795,
0.2707674205,
0.2945830822,
0.5903583169,
0.2880622447,
0.9924492836,
-0.2645653188,
0.5248275995,
-0.2171588242,
-0.1688657552,
-0.0014191194,
-0.2262672484,
-0.8017772436,
0.0067647439,
-0.2719940841,
-0.2997696996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06085v1 | Trapping LLM Hallucinations Using Tagged Context Prompts | 2023-06-09T17:48:54 | 2023-06-09T17:48:54 | Philip Feldman, James R. Foulds, Shimei Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; K.4.2 | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have led to
highly sophisticated conversation agents. However, these models suffer from
"hallucinations," where the model generates false or fabricated information.
Addressing this challenge is crucial, particularly with AI-driven platforms
being adopted across various sectors. In this paper, we propose a novel method
to recognize and flag instances when LLMs perform outside their domain
knowledge, and ensuring users receive accurate information.
We find that the use of context combined with embedded tags can successfully
combat hallucinations within generative language models. To do this, we
baseline hallucination frequency in no-context prompt-response pairs using
generated URLs as easily-tested indicators of fabricated data. We observed a
significant reduction in overall hallucination when context was supplied along
with question prompts for tested generative engines. Lastly, we evaluated how
placing tags within contexts impacted model responses and were able to
eliminate hallucinations in responses with 98.88% effectiveness. | [
-0.5885023475,
-1.132273674,
0.7916259766,
0.0807635188,
-0.3920187652,
-0.0108025353,
-0.2834276855,
-0.4395249784,
0.3774387836,
0.7282474041,
-0.6140680909,
-0.6871348023,
-0.3150110543,
0.1045820117,
-0.5930361152,
0.8035064936,
0.1537243128,
-0.1481209397,
-0.4793944955,
0.2171795815,
-0.7137691975,
-0.8395745754,
-0.5433687568,
-0.2819075882,
0.5284987092,
-0.0676381662,
0.5285223126,
0.3619615138,
0.3817253709,
0.2203540802,
0.0007825841,
0.7212337255,
-0.3736045361,
0.4634867013,
0.0599314645,
-0.2106800079,
-0.4040390253,
-0.1826592386,
0.3474705517,
0.4605633318,
-0.2479066849,
-0.2530920208,
0.2473363727,
0.0745369047,
-0.3869603872,
0.0742849186,
-0.9595214128,
0.2337049097,
-0.0359957628,
-0.826612711,
-0.7370712757,
-0.1543056518,
-0.1791562885,
-0.3476381004,
0.1673150957,
0.0715462193,
0.9068710208,
0.595027566,
-0.1674815565,
-0.5963237882,
-0.6429156065,
0.4545060694,
-0.4846078455,
0.3220506608,
0.6023524404,
0.2442858517,
-0.5835251808,
-0.4583268762,
-0.6731466651,
-0.398413986,
-0.1823078841,
-0.119240582,
-0.3109417558,
0.0262959711,
0.4441405535,
-0.1697295457,
-0.5324442387,
0.0498520173,
-0.0714976788,
-0.5265892148,
0.298873961,
0.2654357255,
0.4481173754,
-0.3530670404,
-0.4905536473,
0.13439399,
-0.779186368,
-0.3416939378,
0.1625723094,
0.3697746396,
0.1884966642,
0.7732215524,
-0.0205939282,
0.5288040042,
0.0189615171,
-0.1382169425,
0.0999478251,
0.0776377618,
-0.2304727882,
0.0989359915,
0.5902618766,
0.5532301664,
0.2633313239,
-0.535754621,
-0.4270472825,
0.4151232541,
0.53384763,
-0.4940413833,
-0.212067157,
0.406529963,
-0.2128394842,
-0.1654034555,
-0.1752103418,
-0.791477859,
-0.8047209978,
-0.1296850294,
0.4824827015,
-0.5899905562,
-0.1060936078,
-0.1479689479,
-0.1542130113,
0.5200628638,
0.430470407,
-0.7352741361,
0.0501732491,
0.7443795204,
0.999401927,
-0.2420287728,
-0.0860949606,
-0.7320839167,
0.2104210705,
-0.3063417077,
1.1077368259,
-0.4980318248,
-0.5780171752,
0.18762514,
-0.0458049327,
0.0619562119,
-0.7713497281,
0.3338680565,
-0.6542271972,
0.0392890684,
-0.3214600086,
-0.5489297509,
-0.0840933174,
0.5047383904,
-0.3924045265,
0.952839613,
-0.2458794862,
-0.5716925859,
0.2686218023,
-0.4116609395,
-0.3268278837,
0.4734424651,
-0.5563957095,
-0.1482761055,
0.1648271829,
0.3341477811,
0.6559432149,
0.1826894134,
0.4863015711,
-0.1185583398,
-0.4500953257,
0.443495214,
-0.5313967466,
0.421675235,
0.1246872917,
-0.4820839465,
0.3046788871,
-0.4696803689,
-0.0910076424,
0.0960788056,
-0.0931477249,
-0.4017593563,
0.0349923074,
-0.0043278951,
-0.0498950966,
0.0052675251,
-0.1543336809,
0.2353359014,
-0.2776203454,
0.2372389585,
0.788785398,
0.1331668943,
-0.0346706845,
-0.5210006833,
0.4657873511,
0.1687960029,
-0.177137658,
-0.1365064383,
-0.7537721992,
-0.7287597656,
-0.231619224,
-0.2133938819,
0.3608353138,
-1.0792120695,
0.7732040286,
-0.129686147,
-0.2183418274,
-0.2457832396,
-0.2069450319,
0.1770243496,
0.7251785994,
0.3888590634,
-0.0721453726,
-0.6144153476,
-0.621779561,
0.0185583439,
-0.2084673494,
-0.2444232702,
0.5971072316,
0.5573783517,
-0.5595487952,
1.0982847214,
-0.2986278832,
-0.3788103759,
-0.0811287016,
0.1587105542,
-0.2180644423,
0.5346237421,
0.2703717351,
-0.6681527495,
-0.048476059,
-0.1501955092,
-1.0022194386,
-0.2959685922,
-0.4104702473,
-0.108047694,
0.4873880744,
0.4513463676,
-0.912486732,
0.3863482177,
0.4008303881,
-0.2796507478,
0.4718345404,
0.0095107155,
0.103417933,
-0.9837712646,
0.0468548574,
-0.1330342889,
-0.282892555,
-0.5763304234,
-0.1847724617,
-0.109093897,
0.085892424,
-0.297672987,
0.6111477017,
-0.383312732,
-0.0976896808,
-0.271913588,
0.4775054455,
-0.0628723726,
0.3888285458,
0.4398033321,
0.9282160997,
0.3956767917,
-0.5480507016,
0.2206000984,
0.3306794465,
-0.5030738711,
0.4388941228,
-0.2941827178,
0.4650018513,
-0.273851037,
0.3065624237,
-1.0097113848,
-0.5899181366,
0.7058985829,
-0.5456076264,
-0.0002971269,
-0.0045774248,
-0.5493067503,
-0.0241955519,
-0.2011687607,
0.1343102306,
0.6444821358,
-0.7767813206,
0.5712479949,
0.4282267392,
0.3168174326,
-0.4835340679,
-0.7017310262,
0.3709167838,
-0.5816805363,
-0.4149742126,
0.3654206693,
-0.2763170302,
-0.2459287941,
-0.1517939717,
-0.064423427,
0.0553591996,
0.2500782013,
0.3892479241,
0.1879109293,
-0.1567169875,
0.1663196683,
0.0502251163,
0.1053970754,
0.3614295721,
-0.0090992274,
0.9543332458,
0.0886342451,
-0.455634445,
-0.561031878,
0.2711230814,
0.4515667558,
0.0920503065,
0.7868105769,
0.4885268807,
-0.6855086684,
-0.5264058709,
-0.706325829,
-0.5166192651,
-0.5061705709,
0.1566793472,
-0.4689576328,
-0.9272107482,
0.7540863752,
-0.0387230851,
-0.3938401937,
0.0007741518,
0.7297251821,
-0.1076007411,
1.1146684885,
0.353109777,
0.2293085456,
0.310257405,
-0.0304166339,
0.4602589011,
-1.0182472467,
-0.5047823787,
-0.2727949917,
0.0936346427,
-0.3172353804,
-0.6176646352,
0.4957569838,
0.1793026328,
0.3227176964,
0.2017638087,
-0.7683521509,
0.6530287862,
0.3748435378,
0.206513986,
0.2562266588,
0.1353110224,
-0.0365254767,
-0.0358601511,
-0.5274646282,
-0.8430278301,
0.7725906372,
0.2827423811,
0.6736072302,
-0.0125702983,
0.732960999,
0.4831189513,
0.4007908106,
-0.9441788197,
0.7467553616,
0.4732950032,
-0.4372103512,
-0.1641731262,
-0.3119396567,
-0.7348697186,
0.4214971662,
-0.0388263166,
-1.1148184538,
0.0669852123,
0.0593650267,
-0.4690502882,
0.3111278415,
-0.3999593556,
0.5732265115,
0.0142724141,
-0.1765541732,
0.1425862461,
-0.3099378943,
0.3877469301,
0.0107204318,
0.073694624,
-0.2861966789,
0.0292336214,
0.5248474479,
-0.1806505024,
1.2201402187,
-0.0688081831,
-0.4337747991,
0.4455713332,
0.2838926911,
0.6321068406,
0.239857778,
0.2500880361,
0.2929199338,
-0.2646797001,
0.0375203863,
-0.4711301625,
0.7306647897,
-0.4594602883,
-0.8372017741,
-0.3718349338,
-0.5683205724,
-0.2012161165,
-0.1354231983,
0.4732082784,
0.3809153736,
-0.0812801793,
0.0792712793,
0.8722122908,
-0.3562711477,
0.4345855415,
0.1308259666,
-0.2161053419,
-0.1765147895,
0.6877575517,
-0.1053032055,
-0.06274461,
-0.0006305647,
0.0172145329,
-0.331725359,
-0.5937805176,
-0.3955526054,
0.130500257,
-0.936668396,
-0.4271548688,
-0.9900531173,
-0.3261319995,
-0.574031949,
-0.2697784007,
-0.0533599854,
0.1256275475,
-0.4461801946,
-0.0338972583,
0.2878095806,
0.5039544702,
0.0268593282,
0.372066915,
-0.6065788269,
0.1669608951,
0.1182321534,
0.2126002908,
0.1494169384,
-0.4591285288,
0.0796357468,
0.0451023579,
0.0309469942,
-0.9932152033,
0.6036009789,
-0.2226693183,
0.55343014,
0.3781351149,
0.3205597103,
0.7691901922,
-0.4186423123,
0.9627436996,
-0.2059782147,
-0.9847804904,
0.6485718489,
-0.4774587452,
0.0856068283,
0.1832076162,
0.3896012604,
-0.7252142429,
-0.5954651237,
-0.1532889456,
-0.759449482,
0.4423152804,
0.2428940386,
0.4615391493,
-0.468888104,
0.3669925034,
0.0767365918,
0.2756558061,
-0.9860444069,
-0.0370279364,
0.0079118628,
-0.0079653366,
0.2496878654,
-0.3965028524,
-0.4412609339,
-0.1059904769,
0.4107028544,
-0.2498611808,
0.3803855777,
0.2808433473,
-0.2576482892,
-0.0541154183,
0.1248728782,
0.7889237404,
0.4840883315,
-0.2444388717,
0.383197248,
0.0192507729,
-0.1791882813,
-0.0619588196,
-0.3666198552,
-0.0970787331,
0.0526847094,
0.4050504267,
0.5916218758,
-0.0749727339,
-0.9488694072,
0.3904955685,
-0.1603186578,
0.0803004205,
-0.5470398664,
0.2009947747,
-0.0999317616,
0.3076663911,
0.2241944224,
-0.1049611196,
0.1672108918,
-0.3972866833,
0.3702760637,
0.7778851986,
-0.3625749052,
-0.2826835811,
0.6418776512,
0.1357852817,
-0.539865613,
0.6292316914,
-0.3142816126,
-0.6306853294,
0.5763001442,
0.7938039303,
1.0458389521,
-0.0882448182,
0.2461213022,
0.1540223956,
0.3261344433,
0.0618512891,
0.0905484781,
-0.398498863,
-1.048463583,
-0.0878304467,
-0.6477084756,
-0.419888705,
0.4591659307,
-0.4372847974,
0.1656644195,
-0.3646002114,
-0.2527433634,
-0.1549065411,
-0.4786355495,
-0.304910779,
-0.0529834442,
0.5009940863,
0.441925317,
-0.802426219,
1.0056499243,
0.4395990074,
-0.3388486803,
-0.3657792509,
0.4009337723,
0.0916499272,
-0.8019384742,
0.4751013517,
0.6404594183,
-0.4447104931,
0.086735934,
-0.7058335543,
-0.6500400901,
0.785989821,
-0.0044636908,
-0.2848840654,
0.1157224998,
0.1231776401,
0.5358518958,
-0.5899871588,
0.0077453102,
0.5702078938,
0.3786143661,
0.2856874168,
-0.5264835358,
0.3670172393,
-0.2144266814,
-0.0533440039,
-0.0495925434,
-0.348585844,
0.5886349678,
-0.0454644188,
-0.6246510148,
0.1818196625,
0.4658332467,
0.4994514883,
0.4170948267,
0.4594706893,
0.201474458,
0.928288877,
-0.1168173328,
0.7032635808,
-0.3598089218,
0.2315394133,
1.0055027008,
-0.5245526433,
0.6813299656,
0.8055542707,
0.3777252734,
0.3831743896,
0.6498317122,
-0.2939756513,
0.5438944101,
0.2111550122,
-0.4499303997,
-0.458301872,
-0.4784032702,
-0.5126767159,
0.3510547578,
0.6357631683,
-0.0962226316,
-0.0722719133,
0.2612258196,
0.2154109031,
0.1513400078,
0.1410072297,
0.8969944715,
-0.0523395352,
-0.7981083989,
0.6937250495,
-0.1082064509,
0.9026492238,
-0.2922641039,
-0.2080835104,
-0.4867507517,
-0.168061763,
-0.14676328,
-0.4548382461,
0.5518285036,
0.1756575853,
0.1118807271,
-0.1905759871,
0.6868118048,
-0.4815856814,
-0.028898323,
0.4033960998,
0.4728948474,
0.4251076877,
-0.2890705764,
-0.203617394,
0.369238168,
-0.1647633612,
-0.170205012,
0.181629017,
0.317124784,
-0.1652054191,
0.6795880198,
0.5734664202,
-0.0924842507,
-0.0842207,
0.0344691239,
1.0025656223,
-0.7135737538,
-0.365195334,
-0.9894646406,
0.4461264312,
-0.1101843342,
-0.0931663364,
0.8298777938,
0.357889235,
0.8141534328,
-0.0293217972,
0.6536491513,
-0.0521296822,
0.0879496858,
-0.649241209,
0.8998702168,
-0.5942399502,
0.6610819697,
-0.0803549588,
-0.8976085186,
-0.4478633404,
0.7426037192,
-0.1849012673,
0.1089311093,
0.5760720372,
1.1607016325,
0.1562314183,
-0.0657147691,
0.662745297,
0.1424501985,
0.4525653422,
0.4235986769,
1.3132468462,
-0.0745553672,
0.3379198611,
-0.2559311092,
-0.104443796,
-0.362569809,
-0.8138008714,
-1.3739596605,
-0.614779532,
-0.3366742432,
-0.5346263051,
0.0471765511,
0.906436801,
0.6757808328,
-0.8321170211,
-0.0659193173,
0.0529432818,
0.1698940396,
0.1001241505,
-0.3061066866,
0.2725194991,
-0.6298729181,
-0.5767084956,
0.6066011786,
0.3024297655,
0.2509699762,
-0.4540801644,
0.0717677325,
0.1191850081,
0.3154241443,
0.5571303368,
-0.1931279153,
-1.2112383842,
-0.6287847161,
-0.0551532917,
-0.2346275896,
0.2057008743,
0.7603965402,
-0.9480384588,
0.3703896701,
0.2464487702,
0.4643766582,
0.1354164779,
0.2287115902,
0.3124113381,
-0.9816699624,
0.1687054038,
0.3506955504,
0.1804068834,
0.3998728395,
-0.7949410677,
0.3867280185,
0.3105294704,
-0.3504355252,
-1.2263994217,
0.1705736071,
-0.9097380042,
-0.3981271684,
1.1771115065,
0.0069884239,
-0.2933868766,
-0.1063925251,
-0.2733003497,
0.1479191482,
-0.2812435627,
1.2700407505,
0.7351956964,
-0.2926158309,
0.0299606156,
-0.549571991,
0.7752854824,
0.3371595442,
-0.9500181675,
0.2003335953,
0.7534730434,
-0.121315442,
0.220490098,
0.5945466161,
0.1962772459,
0.0055489298,
0.1395523399,
0.1276064515,
0.0465532802,
-0.5618910193,
-0.5172588825,
0.3276049793,
-0.168885842,
-0.1666154861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06070v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06070v3 | Mind2Web: Towards a Generalist Agent for the Web | 2023-06-09T17:44:31 | 2023-12-09T05:57:46 | Xiang Deng, Yu Gu, Boyuan Zheng, Shijie Chen, Samuel Stevens, Boshi Wang, Huan Sun, Yu Su | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Mind2Web, the first dataset for developing and evaluating
generalist agents for the web that can follow language instructions to complete
complex tasks on any website. Existing datasets for web agents either use
simulated websites or only cover a limited set of websites and tasks, thus not
suitable for generalist web agents. With over 2,000 open-ended tasks collected
from 137 websites spanning 31 domains and crowdsourced action sequences for the
tasks, Mind2Web provides three necessary ingredients for building generalist
web agents: 1) diverse domains, websites, and tasks, 2) use of real-world
websites instead of simulated and simplified ones, and 3) a broad spectrum of
user interaction patterns. Based on Mind2Web, we conduct an initial exploration
of using large language models (LLMs) for building generalist web agents. While
the raw HTML of real-world websites are often too large to be fed to LLMs, we
show that first filtering it with a small LM significantly improves the
effectiveness and efficiency of LLMs. Our solution demonstrates a decent level
of performance, even on websites or entire domains the model has never seen
before, but there is still a substantial room to improve towards truly
generalizable agents. We open-source our dataset, model implementation, and
trained models (https://osu-nlp-group.github.io/Mind2Web) to facilitate further
research on building a generalist agent for the web. | [
-0.6295779347,
-0.5684766173,
0.6120884418,
0.1634063125,
-0.0140767926,
-0.0565788634,
-0.356754452,
-0.7783751488,
0.2018808872,
0.3840503693,
-0.5866508484,
-0.3501882851,
-0.3318346143,
-0.0709099174,
-0.4177577794,
0.8493914008,
0.2576937675,
-0.0747780651,
-0.2964150906,
0.287517935,
-0.0158432405,
-0.3609108031,
-0.7334781289,
-0.4579142332,
0.603302598,
0.2393292636,
0.9566908479,
0.384958148,
0.4242546558,
0.278275311,
0.5044042468,
0.2214697003,
-0.4631253183,
-0.0798335075,
-0.7770710588,
-0.6002627611,
-0.6823154092,
0.2046574801,
0.0954316109,
0.4989386201,
-0.3267543018,
0.1930090189,
0.1355785728,
0.4617373943,
-0.4918283224,
0.2227998078,
-0.4054881334,
-0.1998679191,
-0.0268968046,
0.1195893884,
-0.3284641504,
-0.2143997103,
0.1977211237,
-0.7892181873,
0.1880938858,
0.1341511607,
0.5439559221,
0.0731653348,
-0.2777072191,
-0.4678900242,
-0.7481691241,
0.8901975751,
-0.4709212184,
0.542155385,
0.6036859751,
0.2883160412,
-0.5404402018,
-0.7370586991,
-0.8459818363,
-0.2157423794,
0.184669137,
0.0460875072,
-0.6480813622,
0.0505561158,
0.0998354033,
0.0792849362,
-0.8817285299,
0.2751387656,
0.1561562866,
-0.1932405829,
0.4483854771,
0.0813757256,
0.5844537616,
0.2999518514,
0.0116231646,
-0.1626042426,
-0.3837853074,
-0.0322057456,
0.5307996273,
0.3209460974,
-0.1748491377,
0.4833263457,
-0.2457051128,
0.7990271449,
0.0079607535,
-0.0722630098,
-0.2474574149,
0.0729606226,
-0.1276476234,
-0.659940362,
0.6197323203,
0.6625097394,
0.9104918242,
-0.5485550761,
-0.1425309479,
0.2892843783,
0.6175795197,
-0.8514009714,
-0.3018022776,
0.5515263081,
-0.3392455876,
-0.0470526628,
-0.0374218747,
-0.6202432513,
-0.4283557832,
-0.5320449471,
0.1850413084,
-0.2668934166,
-0.4648450911,
0.1189344153,
-0.2132922113,
0.5313341618,
0.5365867019,
-0.783107698,
0.6456611753,
0.7289961576,
0.5606218576,
-0.211058557,
-0.2337611765,
-0.1135488823,
0.1963232607,
-0.5349397659,
0.9117068648,
-0.7032209635,
-0.1243160293,
0.2709528804,
-0.3001334369,
0.372674495,
-0.3829832077,
-0.1260076612,
-0.8495681882,
0.275347203,
-0.0569362417,
-0.3856652975,
-0.2201975584,
0.4196078479,
-0.7231321335,
0.4598298073,
0.1802684069,
-0.311807394,
0.0753913671,
-0.783052206,
-0.5132867098,
0.1367785335,
-0.1576576084,
0.3769474328,
0.0006083901,
-0.1045152321,
0.5490043759,
-0.6444399953,
-0.0393701531,
-0.4684531093,
-0.2526664734,
0.2692601085,
-0.0175590441,
0.7013196349,
0.1576267034,
-0.2191086113,
-0.2228958458,
-0.6975153685,
0.4224990308,
0.3372123539,
-0.4231236279,
-0.4623581171,
0.2765610218,
0.1832912564,
0.0876971483,
0.216203317,
-0.366687417,
0.4095848799,
-0.2344601005,
0.1939729154,
0.8021630645,
-0.2486696243,
0.3319368958,
-0.2552756667,
0.5208609104,
-0.4165759087,
0.0610514432,
0.5067011714,
-0.6616427302,
-0.7793068886,
-0.1796687841,
0.1806389093,
0.653437376,
-0.6712436676,
0.4753957987,
-0.3353581429,
-0.5367361903,
-0.3439427912,
0.2407288104,
0.3092954755,
-0.2241919786,
0.4956359863,
-0.3056818545,
-0.4912340343,
-0.9782834053,
-0.2570494711,
-0.1526210457,
-0.5220873356,
0.0672320351,
0.5620573163,
-0.6612883806,
1.2671042681,
-0.5819932222,
-0.4069238007,
-0.3508566022,
-0.0354377776,
0.0382687226,
0.2666597068,
0.3776077032,
-0.8782276511,
-0.4910037518,
0.173950538,
-0.844139874,
-0.0644242838,
0.2597299814,
-0.1132889017,
0.0010050508,
0.2051087171,
-0.9112096429,
0.2327362895,
0.4227431715,
-0.0878768861,
0.3972181976,
0.088097088,
-0.1643771082,
-1.089161396,
0.1727425307,
0.2916743159,
-0.5374290943,
-0.9419074059,
0.404974699,
-0.0184324887,
-0.0331852734,
-0.2802888155,
0.7943975329,
-0.5004853606,
-0.0390789099,
-0.564384222,
0.0957487002,
-0.1333491802,
0.8148782253,
-0.2220129073,
0.874576211,
0.2020901442,
-0.8756737113,
0.5453915,
0.0582907163,
-0.1202401593,
0.4344655573,
-0.4268798828,
0.630615592,
0.0425600372,
0.3909841478,
-0.684179008,
-0.4530184269,
0.4807584882,
-0.3464328945,
0.2080007792,
0.0361378156,
-0.5248702765,
-0.6374772787,
-0.1828535348,
-0.0825348198,
0.4915140569,
-0.3317700624,
0.7500236034,
0.5915448666,
-0.1505557299,
-0.3870591223,
-0.5129308105,
0.3886320293,
0.1946803629,
-0.5080859065,
0.2803741097,
-0.2941266298,
-0.5918790698,
0.1535962671,
-0.0088904155,
-0.3357159197,
0.2544171512,
0.1268412322,
-0.1774731278,
0.1203531697,
0.0119072422,
-0.2070504278,
0.111666359,
0.1353168935,
-0.5784215927,
0.7182378173,
-0.1577943265,
-0.2406886667,
-0.5892393589,
0.4880080223,
0.281375289,
-0.0939782858,
0.2663103938,
0.5237995982,
-0.5626430511,
-0.5676689148,
-0.6495530009,
-0.0680514127,
-0.4772714376,
0.443515718,
-0.5894754529,
-0.899384439,
0.3072969317,
-0.0921784788,
0.1485333294,
0.2998303771,
0.5757485628,
-0.4120750129,
1.009873867,
1.0481209755,
-0.2386694103,
0.4069661498,
-0.2707435787,
-0.1929083467,
-0.6001070738,
-0.0523088388,
-0.3838555515,
-0.4603173435,
-0.4791191518,
-0.6405282021,
-0.1505146623,
0.0004450515,
-0.1627680212,
0.2005680352,
-0.3493102193,
0.5811266899,
0.6394279003,
0.2190858424,
0.1350025535,
0.3208398521,
-0.0119274817,
0.3604291677,
-0.3132618964,
-0.7029749751,
1.4363322258,
0.1020817831,
0.8305019736,
0.5358711481,
0.3013360798,
1.0432465076,
0.4661056995,
-0.7743505836,
0.8404465914,
-0.1398288161,
-0.640691936,
-0.3251327872,
0.0940617323,
-1.0885185003,
0.3615908623,
0.2509126067,
-0.8285181522,
0.0710053667,
0.2356699705,
-0.0944963768,
0.1379008442,
-0.3667734563,
0.5419479012,
0.0071265344,
-0.4173258543,
-0.7161635756,
-0.6100349426,
0.151896432,
0.0242589861,
0.2246817648,
0.0512416735,
-0.2702120841,
0.6233279109,
-0.3397782743,
1.0832688808,
-0.3808337748,
-0.338549912,
0.4615991116,
0.1233278736,
0.7645129561,
-0.4434351325,
0.1859891117,
0.0965134352,
-0.5284129977,
-0.5508818626,
-0.5815395117,
0.4666585326,
-0.9314047694,
-0.8167167902,
-0.366728425,
-0.3333315253,
-0.5181317925,
0.2056375444,
-0.1346183866,
0.2848943472,
-0.4885144234,
0.118122533,
0.624502182,
0.101304546,
0.2709777057,
0.9308202863,
-0.4100408256,
-0.2457859963,
0.9081934094,
-0.1252210736,
0.1852495968,
0.5025063157,
-0.064118959,
-0.2806872427,
-0.5479534268,
-0.5211518407,
0.1617923975,
-0.6687202454,
-0.0501796752,
-0.7025963664,
0.1124543548,
-0.4247054756,
0.0577855408,
-0.0371166691,
-0.1478817016,
-0.3498322368,
0.0480820686,
0.129895851,
0.8220045567,
-0.2423664182,
0.4187845886,
-0.3131425381,
0.6647149324,
0.7901666164,
0.3274121284,
0.167363137,
-0.1908633262,
-0.4360896945,
0.298725009,
-0.2168483287,
-0.9389136434,
0.0685571879,
0.1598700434,
0.6043123007,
0.5768268108,
-0.268342495,
0.637848258,
-0.614053905,
0.617079556,
0.2393808216,
-0.8180189729,
0.4522045255,
-0.5541676879,
0.1567091346,
0.2025815994,
0.5815281868,
-0.5825884342,
-0.4031943977,
-0.1432070881,
-0.4401162267,
0.6019776464,
0.059859205,
0.1707651764,
0.0026755172,
0.3859990239,
0.0098761097,
0.3119361103,
-0.5484146476,
-0.0929965973,
-0.2528177798,
-0.212324962,
-0.0927922279,
-0.1700129211,
-0.1481219381,
0.1675281525,
0.7474496365,
-0.5031403303,
0.4269400537,
0.0938199162,
-0.5913922787,
-0.2462065816,
0.3439225554,
0.3886580169,
0.903629899,
-0.225647673,
0.0608024597,
-0.0809281915,
-0.5475446582,
0.3507339954,
0.143958956,
-0.1078523323,
-0.4419436753,
0.2131607085,
0.3378627896,
-0.0889545679,
-0.8688970804,
0.4169853628,
-0.092672497,
-0.0090099415,
-0.430357784,
0.3873368502,
0.2760342062,
0.4476078153,
0.5721079111,
-0.1220815778,
0.3755115569,
-0.4949967563,
0.1048720777,
0.5756502151,
-0.3090059459,
-0.6436787844,
0.6031057239,
0.3682615161,
-0.4610928893,
0.5190493464,
-0.5111119747,
-0.3108314872,
0.4932512939,
0.6463772655,
1.0650240183,
-0.2196350545,
0.1957583725,
-0.1585055441,
0.4598281384,
-0.0924019888,
0.5123684406,
0.0242726244,
-0.874958694,
-0.357701987,
-0.7058632374,
-0.8042616248,
0.2689931989,
-0.5134435892,
-0.2684213221,
-0.5815734267,
-0.3339368701,
-0.015307311,
0.1989528835,
-1.1339956522,
0.4466333091,
0.2113242596,
0.8323478699,
-0.5114338398,
0.8901127577,
0.9939721823,
-0.3642833233,
-0.4503052533,
0.14423576,
0.1173807606,
-0.8863921762,
0.3058238029,
0.2970531583,
-0.2826068699,
0.3386029005,
-0.8105407953,
-0.7001995444,
1.0024876595,
0.2062551677,
-0.6426754594,
-0.3021951616,
0.3845131695,
0.717653513,
-0.2701407969,
0.1177944243,
0.3254990578,
0.5997303724,
-0.4706925452,
-0.6335974932,
0.1639866382,
-0.4190482199,
0.0592879951,
-0.0659721121,
-0.8040572405,
0.6945314407,
-0.1794508249,
-0.2691913247,
0.1827446073,
0.7664018869,
-0.1996956468,
-0.0399385802,
0.6894293427,
0.7210839987,
0.7532271743,
0.2041739821,
1.1445277929,
-0.0577840358,
0.0660785809,
1.0651737452,
-0.5315788388,
0.7853019834,
0.1819355786,
-0.5830785036,
0.7034287453,
0.3806439638,
-0.0999398902,
0.263412863,
0.3928109109,
-0.0849022269,
-0.4607698023,
-0.2124890834,
-0.1910716891,
0.4712040126,
0.4080292583,
0.1233467683,
-0.2147488743,
0.0311201159,
0.0674680099,
-0.0013851646,
-0.3109674156,
0.8360449076,
0.1644064188,
-0.7122958302,
0.2388712168,
0.2351732701,
0.5185200572,
-0.9163813591,
0.0362459049,
-0.2458516359,
0.2434199005,
-0.036202237,
-0.7251699567,
-0.1641556621,
0.2413312197,
-0.4431859553,
-0.1855894923,
0.9157190323,
-0.2275725603,
-0.1275833249,
0.594596386,
0.6863439083,
0.4109281301,
-0.4816296697,
-0.6048617959,
-0.2115008235,
0.1604340374,
-0.5663808584,
0.6530240178,
0.185564816,
-0.1328184903,
0.8985491991,
0.8914371133,
0.001934918,
-0.2530108094,
-0.0025798043,
0.8283200264,
-0.7849283814,
-0.4931502938,
-0.6552885771,
0.3995981216,
-0.0738180056,
-0.0186972432,
0.5107745528,
0.5109836459,
0.7430827022,
-0.0821655765,
1.1850373745,
-0.217395246,
0.4624132812,
-0.2107991129,
0.5999001861,
-0.6596376896,
-0.2960596383,
0.1709073633,
-1.0253633261,
-0.2110423893,
0.4081935883,
0.1117644534,
0.0039533605,
0.3100331426,
0.8661328554,
-0.0465444699,
0.0193319973,
0.4568150342,
0.2282336056,
0.6266001463,
0.3841587305,
0.7357333899,
-0.0602233186,
0.6447722316,
0.0391920134,
-0.3928699791,
-0.3476111591,
-0.4532742202,
-1.0050866604,
-0.2565265596,
-0.0732385442,
-0.3833076954,
0.2790437937,
1.1430184841,
0.6182881594,
-0.871566534,
-0.4691241384,
-0.0897902846,
-0.0411295369,
-0.2952063978,
-0.1918780059,
-0.0519176982,
-0.3044107258,
-0.9103682637,
0.5262512565,
0.1054499075,
0.0898749977,
-0.3875705004,
-0.1158274934,
-0.3058616519,
0.2773406506,
0.6126956344,
0.3893829584,
-0.8542854786,
-0.3751131296,
-0.1724467725,
-0.4305801094,
-0.256619066,
0.5502633452,
-0.6631175876,
0.2892771065,
0.0894082934,
0.5402044654,
0.2732561231,
-0.0057519558,
0.608577311,
-0.5270513892,
-0.0081962692,
0.241714865,
0.0969755277,
0.1144533604,
-0.0052363495,
0.8295087814,
0.1421473473,
-0.3158429563,
-0.4678211808,
0.3162897527,
-1.0123348236,
-0.5695030689,
1.3176618814,
-0.0417386256,
-0.0329657234,
-0.1685959995,
0.0791124925,
0.1762641072,
-0.5347840786,
0.4927604496,
0.6926266551,
0.0300938133,
0.3180418313,
-0.5185379386,
0.3925860822,
-0.0812336877,
-1.0220628977,
-0.053117618,
0.7014417648,
0.4329029024,
0.2381069064,
0.7761920094,
0.6721192598,
0.2768883109,
-0.0462333895,
0.5842864513,
-0.0807515308,
-0.5584875941,
-0.011574368,
0.3105121553,
-0.1005956158,
-0.0796387568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06058v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06058v1 | Assisting Language Learners: Automated Trans-Lingual Definition Generation via Contrastive Prompt Learning | 2023-06-09T17:32:45 | 2023-06-09T17:32:45 | Hengyuan Zhang, Dawei Li, Yanran Li, Chenming Shang, Chufan Shi, Yong Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The standard definition generation task requires to automatically produce
mono-lingual definitions (e.g., English definitions for English words), but
ignores that the generated definitions may also consist of unfamiliar words for
language learners. In this work, we propose a novel task of Trans-Lingual
Definition Generation (TLDG), which aims to generate definitions in another
language, i.e., the native speaker's language. Initially, we explore the
unsupervised manner of this task and build up a simple implementation of
fine-tuning the multi-lingual machine translation model. Then, we develop two
novel methods, Prompt Combination and Contrastive Prompt Learning, for further
enhancing the quality of the generation. Our methods are evaluated against the
baseline Pipeline method in both rich- and low-resource settings, and we
empirically establish its superiority in generating higher-quality
trans-lingual definitions. | [
-0.4986486137,
-0.7909671068,
0.0845965222,
0.0068590832,
-0.4303822815,
0.3437825143,
-0.2255940288,
-0.2280508876,
0.1125348955,
0.1397944093,
-0.6879082322,
-0.5304135084,
-0.468639344,
0.5664503574,
-0.1111128777,
0.8308249712,
-0.0162022337,
-0.1552744508,
0.1910305768,
-0.1748121679,
-0.8000627756,
0.1372679174,
-0.9829335213,
-0.2710187435,
0.7082054019,
0.7421984076,
0.7531031966,
0.7540122867,
-0.0025037271,
0.2594710588,
0.0974689126,
0.5057456493,
-0.2393838167,
0.1122032702,
-0.2411133051,
-0.0860181451,
-0.0541775115,
-0.12057928,
0.7512887716,
1.2451813221,
0.2319407016,
0.0243651643,
0.3686135113,
0.6839840412,
-0.4982994795,
0.018719906,
-0.5415484905,
0.2754310668,
-0.1820936054,
-0.2331494093,
-0.3098473847,
-0.2837594748,
0.2442749739,
-0.7035235763,
0.4158807993,
0.1698720604,
0.6949717999,
0.355114162,
-0.6514548659,
-0.2563416362,
-0.3929773569,
0.6375366449,
-0.3253240883,
0.6502315402,
0.1709422171,
0.2741146982,
0.1438044459,
-0.4917333126,
-0.5819644332,
-0.183086887,
-0.3521764278,
0.059819527,
-0.0449204929,
0.170785144,
0.1593805254,
0.3520216346,
-0.8054258227,
0.2988287807,
-0.4496175349,
-0.3354005814,
0.3584876955,
0.2366749793,
0.2384616882,
-0.3660960495,
-0.3288516104,
0.0268705226,
-0.7570958138,
-0.0539223962,
0.2127353549,
0.6480870843,
-0.2147181332,
0.4936523438,
-0.1452594697,
0.7332491875,
0.1472409815,
-0.0267647747,
0.4903565347,
-0.5545384288,
-0.1492700428,
0.052260723,
0.5944926739,
0.4813755453,
0.0356196724,
-0.1636780202,
-0.4230598509,
-0.0803452209,
-0.1923013479,
-0.6816392541,
-0.2435116917,
0.0195227955,
-0.3203574121,
-0.2415548265,
-0.1563431919,
-0.7675255537,
-0.3584766686,
-0.5368010998,
0.5236210227,
-0.3773761392,
-0.3781575859,
-0.1412368566,
-0.0637538135,
0.1283884197,
0.106446892,
-0.7941344976,
-0.0063603641,
0.1444606334,
0.662373662,
-0.4171713889,
-0.3843230307,
-1.0166144371,
0.0727828965,
-0.621152997,
0.464669466,
-0.2598476708,
-0.8498666286,
0.2200047374,
0.0966782644,
0.2317205817,
-0.5399497747,
0.038029708,
-0.3188670278,
0.7046368122,
-0.1678946167,
-0.2607390285,
-0.0870509818,
0.1312026232,
-0.5225778222,
0.8957604766,
0.3670632839,
-0.6533661485,
0.5112648606,
-0.8242592812,
-0.7894548774,
0.5836843252,
-0.058911711,
-0.0638900027,
0.0855858028,
0.0757507235,
0.3772138655,
-0.1989810914,
0.34979707,
0.4065623581,
-0.0280092936,
-0.2013387531,
-0.2270601392,
1.1020760536,
0.3748593628,
-0.3380662203,
0.1226475537,
-0.6947362423,
-0.0729738176,
0.0311187338,
-0.506948173,
-0.2734072804,
-0.4373792708,
0.1417119205,
0.2177879661,
0.4182876348,
-0.2886853516,
-0.053296987,
-0.5142373443,
0.0765368268,
0.6546724439,
0.023812253,
0.419749707,
-0.0947473124,
0.581043005,
0.0814133063,
-0.153503418,
-0.5278445482,
-0.2217270136,
-0.9135029316,
0.1200340241,
0.5591571927,
0.6855540276,
-1.3531826735,
0.4940879047,
0.1315673888,
-0.1906219125,
-0.6571950316,
0.5099411011,
0.6574935913,
0.9747241139,
0.5633578897,
-0.0171052665,
-0.6708711386,
-0.7932078838,
0.0822979361,
-0.1409270614,
-0.2587224543,
0.2369304597,
0.1590087116,
-0.4071596861,
0.6953733563,
-0.2192013115,
-0.0990658104,
-0.2786839008,
0.5656143427,
-0.113672331,
0.4933778644,
0.3542673588,
-0.6653431654,
-0.7510308623,
0.1612704396,
-0.6678735614,
-0.4560873508,
-0.0360911563,
0.0138030015,
0.4881814718,
0.5653178692,
0.0387399495,
-0.1567295194,
0.4514217079,
-0.4443747401,
0.4991468191,
-0.4788732231,
0.0882746503,
-1.4477847815,
0.0484677888,
0.1279151589,
-0.1987883002,
-0.6994231939,
0.2122033238,
-0.0037088466,
-0.3007502854,
-0.6155419946,
0.8132563829,
-0.4324534535,
0.1071210206,
-0.2823167741,
0.5154246688,
-0.0531041995,
0.33449018,
0.2137701064,
0.7985545397,
0.7096993923,
-0.7918370962,
0.5162919164,
0.1671269089,
-0.0623731278,
0.6233277321,
-0.6773946881,
-0.0430954657,
-0.2515687644,
-0.2381356955,
-1.1576060057,
-0.1836210042,
0.1873831749,
-0.3143927455,
0.3531255424,
0.1878816187,
-0.3676254749,
-0.1078606918,
-0.005378399,
0.5198766589,
0.689819932,
-0.740046978,
0.388376385,
0.2474763691,
-0.2293248624,
-0.4760951698,
-0.6900776625,
0.2187324166,
-0.3129708469,
-0.4042110443,
0.3251451254,
-0.0748642311,
-0.4522232711,
-0.1031467468,
0.3344242573,
0.2074915916,
0.1731127501,
-0.178080827,
0.361042738,
-0.1627937853,
0.4296251535,
0.2635721266,
-0.1426247656,
-0.0378564112,
-0.4047535062,
0.3861387372,
0.0543827116,
-0.0571253411,
-0.0446699411,
0.6191886663,
-0.0236655567,
-0.2510960698,
0.2267246246,
0.744156599,
-0.3037137687,
-0.5391467214,
-0.2087500691,
-0.1559870392,
-0.5070091486,
0.1102860272,
-0.3860206306,
-0.7213046551,
0.3576390147,
-0.1216364875,
0.3037499487,
0.324010551,
0.4699990749,
0.0389456898,
0.9065873623,
0.8693578243,
0.3183816075,
0.4812409878,
0.0477649681,
0.105547905,
-0.3002916574,
-0.0635497198,
-0.4784595966,
-0.296266526,
-0.8207325935,
-0.4155820608,
0.6804159284,
-0.0674043298,
-0.1707739979,
0.2623645663,
-0.3428697884,
0.4275705814,
0.818764329,
-0.0509254038,
0.2772493362,
-0.1574094892,
-0.6500993371,
-0.0627429485,
-0.5778136253,
-0.42565009,
0.8548820019,
-0.0590733327,
0.2575732768,
0.0561064668,
0.8327003717,
0.3460040689,
-0.0068255942,
-0.6969151497,
0.5205228925,
-0.2594528198,
-0.1824872941,
-0.3554863036,
-0.4369660616,
-0.956866622,
0.0466063321,
-0.3032910228,
-0.1845449805,
-0.0562061593,
0.2795844376,
-0.2104310989,
-0.0612988956,
-0.7896617055,
1.0093826056,
-0.1619207412,
-0.398244679,
-0.1429112107,
-0.7615940571,
0.3592185974,
-0.1883540303,
0.1038669124,
0.2897461653,
-0.3416121006,
0.5707056522,
-0.1985760927,
0.9161779881,
-0.3189850152,
-0.3522073627,
0.2637304366,
0.3050652444,
0.2591668069,
-0.0338557512,
-0.0110104335,
-0.2085023075,
-0.3751906455,
-0.559175849,
-0.2939434052,
0.3725666106,
-0.5036925673,
-0.6033635139,
0.1221592724,
-0.5791423321,
-0.3477044702,
0.4155876637,
0.3574575484,
0.4898525476,
-0.4261173904,
-0.2175346017,
0.8435135484,
-0.5735267401,
0.5041266084,
0.6234203577,
-0.1310601383,
-0.1461109966,
1.1872547865,
-0.10850811,
0.3250972629,
0.4968338013,
0.4279509783,
-0.5504063368,
-0.406006813,
-0.742816925,
0.1620553583,
-0.7407556772,
-0.0281159021,
-0.1990630031,
0.0269888528,
-0.3884870112,
-0.3747622669,
0.1187896281,
-0.3201294839,
-0.2737862468,
-0.1053314209,
0.0595765226,
0.7080187798,
-0.2815943956,
0.1385308504,
-0.7844796777,
0.4210122228,
0.6296858788,
0.0185412876,
-0.333044976,
-0.4145136178,
-0.2516014576,
0.098006919,
-0.3656592667,
-0.693939507,
0.345123142,
0.3148596585,
0.5172924995,
0.5668872595,
0.1644071639,
0.3496725857,
-0.5754500031,
1.0344570875,
0.2821255624,
-1.0673991442,
0.7834647298,
-0.318941474,
0.5711026192,
0.3514138162,
0.4466254115,
-0.9128801227,
-0.4896221459,
-0.4150822461,
-0.6417652965,
0.3832906485,
-0.403067857,
0.2269431353,
-0.3018138111,
-0.0905357525,
0.5183692575,
0.3125599921,
-0.5334422588,
-0.3305847943,
-0.3563634753,
-0.1078921035,
-0.3582035005,
0.0332531892,
-0.0836190581,
0.0544738024,
0.6438815594,
-0.4407604635,
-0.2353381366,
-0.1619633883,
-0.2292807698,
-0.2729174197,
0.3464457691,
0.4508233964,
0.5726512671,
0.3048459589,
0.4171172976,
0.2705605328,
-0.0783357248,
0.0750229135,
0.0983640477,
-0.4062760174,
0.4102562368,
0.3052157164,
0.7377570868,
0.1387654245,
-0.8401322365,
0.3228257298,
0.1061313897,
-0.3721400797,
0.0684762597,
-0.0260298476,
-0.0351407602,
-0.0149333477,
0.2911287248,
-0.09573403,
0.0304224677,
-0.4755832553,
0.1799860001,
0.5264364481,
-0.1552114338,
-0.1954257935,
0.5782236457,
0.6602725387,
-0.4599568844,
0.6393175721,
-0.714502871,
-0.4291915894,
0.3134792745,
0.5488201976,
0.9578944445,
-0.3260966241,
0.3318868279,
0.5459110141,
0.0923443511,
0.2617187202,
0.3303207457,
-0.3632924557,
-0.807254076,
-0.4397608936,
-0.460093081,
-0.3879086375,
0.0662914589,
-0.3190262318,
0.5782777071,
-0.2055200636,
0.4425293803,
-0.1504652053,
0.0706387982,
-0.6134932637,
0.2140520811,
0.3422809541,
0.8684978485,
-1.0874232054,
0.7231647968,
0.8122918606,
-0.3579466939,
-0.816173315,
-0.0060657514,
-0.1010052115,
-0.7150868177,
0.7909721136,
-0.0094606066,
-0.228234902,
0.0878914893,
-0.1526504457,
-0.3309008777,
0.8258340955,
0.2863454819,
-0.3079807162,
-0.2738010287,
0.2963731289,
0.473741442,
-0.2509622276,
0.0038940215,
0.4414185286,
0.6238395572,
0.1124472991,
-0.9848859906,
0.0233116057,
-0.3264222741,
-0.0134129012,
0.0650136769,
-0.292242825,
0.7891008258,
-0.3384861648,
-0.6088273525,
-0.2360322624,
0.6205212474,
-0.0566635616,
0.1429277062,
0.6873667836,
0.2567192018,
0.8882499933,
-0.0841796696,
0.5180002451,
-0.4988100529,
-0.1735664904,
0.7733260989,
0.027508311,
0.3913380802,
0.6087329388,
0.1006643474,
0.2823092341,
0.8227126598,
0.0933653414,
0.4176592231,
0.1345931292,
-0.5712114573,
-0.2843953371,
-0.5698108673,
-0.1708743274,
0.1701351553,
0.4151693285,
-0.3783603907,
-0.6207922101,
0.2896202207,
-0.4230926633,
0.3773879707,
-0.6328274012,
0.9203215241,
-0.1459127963,
-0.9780429006,
0.9936618805,
-0.0270642564,
0.8182250857,
-0.3687610626,
-0.175741151,
-0.3621139526,
-0.1252026707,
-0.2392058223,
-0.7741491199,
0.3080825508,
0.1064185798,
0.1513745338,
-0.5784986615,
0.4073447287,
-0.8696891069,
-0.2762551606,
0.1290183663,
1.0395816565,
0.1056886837,
0.6102746129,
-0.6084672809,
-0.3415974081,
0.0685334206,
0.102418974,
0.0600549169,
0.7241355181,
-0.0782401636,
0.4476807714,
0.0976996794,
0.0375536568,
0.1993908733,
0.1353907585,
0.5898802876,
-0.395178616,
-0.6530589461,
-0.5301802158,
0.5905758142,
0.2636038661,
-0.4524789751,
0.6988952756,
0.559229672,
1.2858003378,
-0.1466306746,
1.0612317324,
-0.2556089163,
0.6127221584,
-0.5074347854,
0.1587745994,
-0.6923827529,
0.0823664889,
-0.1393430084,
-0.6534062028,
-0.3035569787,
0.3167933226,
-0.0488310531,
-0.1498731673,
0.8093152046,
0.9696186781,
-0.0935148969,
-0.0927577391,
0.4760284424,
-0.1561529785,
0.0657160059,
0.6834771633,
0.6471175551,
-0.1873754561,
0.6749183536,
-0.2721237242,
-0.1154076383,
-0.0614594556,
-0.9559388757,
-1.0859969854,
-0.9105009437,
-0.261752516,
-0.3138513863,
0.0094781751,
1.2395631075,
0.4765811563,
-0.7283447385,
-0.3568086624,
-0.4259860516,
0.4189220071,
-0.3610363305,
-0.1940847784,
0.2979169488,
-0.857114017,
-1.1581747532,
0.5650327206,
-0.1735620052,
0.275093466,
-0.6072934866,
-0.2697895169,
0.0338082202,
-0.2552467287,
0.5186020732,
0.2897725999,
-0.5732781887,
-0.3119376004,
-0.1454241127,
-0.2294914275,
-0.0414786227,
0.7258104682,
-0.9722911119,
0.5271565914,
0.5609779954,
0.8429807425,
0.032431446,
-0.0779395774,
0.8119171858,
-1.2067091465,
0.0814555585,
0.1137531102,
0.3018715382,
0.6241717935,
-0.1936714947,
0.2868951261,
0.2174998522,
-0.119525969,
-0.6404789686,
0.5519225597,
-0.6031861901,
-0.4153394997,
1.0488004684,
0.0095317569,
0.0185457859,
-0.2490020394,
-0.3379865289,
0.5171900392,
-0.2928778529,
0.7471744418,
0.3597702682,
0.0962443352,
-0.2931971848,
-0.2339194119,
0.8198264837,
0.253000766,
-0.6247483492,
0.2083360851,
0.6190610528,
0.1679549366,
0.2582897544,
0.2705945969,
0.2720459402,
0.5659983158,
-0.1114104167,
-0.069844313,
-0.3195400834,
-0.2842255533,
-0.5548045635,
0.193278268,
0.0932665318,
-0.2922164202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06031v1 | FinGPT: Open-Source Financial Large Language Models | 2023-06-09T16:52:00 | 2023-06-09T16:52:00 | Hongyang Yang, Xiao-Yang Liu, Christina Dan Wang | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.TR | Large language models (LLMs) have shown the potential of revolutionizing
natural language processing tasks in diverse domains, sparking great interest
in finance. Accessing high-quality financial data is the first challenge for
financial LLMs (FinLLMs). While proprietary models like BloombergGPT have taken
advantage of their unique data accumulation, such privileged access calls for
an open-source alternative to democratize Internet-scale financial data.
In this paper, we present an open-source large language model, FinGPT, for
the finance sector. Unlike proprietary models, FinGPT takes a data-centric
approach, providing researchers and practitioners with accessible and
transparent resources to develop their FinLLMs. We highlight the importance of
an automatic data curation pipeline and the lightweight low-rank adaptation
technique in building FinGPT. Furthermore, we showcase several potential
applications as stepping stones for users, such as robo-advising, algorithmic
trading, and low-code development. Through collaborative efforts within the
open-source AI4Finance community, FinGPT aims to stimulate innovation,
democratize FinLLMs, and unlock new opportunities in open finance. Two
associated code repos are \url{https://github.com/AI4Finance-Foundation/FinGPT}
and \url{https://github.com/AI4Finance-Foundation/FinNLP} | [
-0.0995266736,
-0.7729113698,
0.3023451865,
0.2404259741,
-0.1231103167,
0.1582348943,
-0.529845655,
-0.4602686167,
-0.2155068964,
0.8230125904,
-0.2768070102,
-0.7029436827,
-0.4670077562,
-0.2346523553,
-0.4550274611,
1.3431613445,
0.0048916587,
0.0921337381,
0.1410894841,
0.0936815739,
-0.084999986,
-0.5867988467,
-1.0376944542,
-0.0702725351,
0.2597920299,
0.432007283,
0.6515030861,
0.6974291205,
0.930306375,
0.2546732128,
0.3867965043,
-0.4703214467,
-0.5662267804,
-0.0563792102,
-0.3761509359,
-0.0813739747,
-0.7001568675,
0.2137423158,
0.5534173846,
0.5263980627,
-0.3711821139,
0.2525672019,
-0.127631858,
0.7659396529,
-0.4520716369,
0.7709153295,
-0.4633540213,
-0.2806293368,
-0.4549083412,
0.111300759,
-0.2305805683,
-0.3973515928,
0.1744312495,
-0.5142738819,
-0.0304626506,
0.3355258703,
0.3902826309,
0.1470382363,
-0.2083559483,
-0.3261899352,
-0.7034192085,
0.4340884387,
-0.87710917,
0.601598382,
0.3385192454,
0.5122659206,
0.03497307,
-0.9268743992,
-0.2274693549,
-0.4436226487,
0.1314662993,
0.0581486635,
-0.3084542751,
0.0344184823,
-0.0270219389,
0.6437069774,
-0.47967875,
0.3517228663,
-0.5505582094,
-0.0364642777,
0.5351883769,
-0.1813812703,
-0.1211651638,
0.0917094648,
-0.6983671188,
-0.147136718,
-0.6426770091,
-0.1237784103,
0.7166487575,
0.7167950273,
-0.2019488811,
0.7006797791,
-0.1965465397,
0.6478776932,
-0.0746038482,
-0.0998179317,
0.106642127,
-0.3142420053,
-0.3246002793,
0.1660783142,
0.7300447822,
0.1022456139,
0.1975646019,
0.0110076582,
-0.4103385508,
-0.5909730792,
0.1037149206,
-0.6301514506,
-0.4417336583,
0.2419165075,
-0.4445371628,
-0.1476822644,
0.1689406782,
-0.9599016309,
-0.2351668477,
-0.3433914781,
0.3126034439,
-0.2883488536,
-0.1643550545,
0.3129057884,
-0.0887335241,
0.3913057446,
0.2355358601,
-1.0445489883,
0.5997806787,
1.1165647507,
0.9075937867,
-0.0471551195,
-0.0250544995,
-0.8381078839,
0.2896736264,
0.0422893092,
0.5132139921,
-0.3537721038,
-0.1650343388,
-0.2107785046,
-0.1801681519,
0.0899705216,
-0.2684978843,
0.4081546664,
-0.4611321092,
0.1578144282,
0.0713292584,
-0.5763575435,
0.0047938735,
0.0821167156,
-0.7454746962,
0.6903870702,
0.3678877354,
-0.7524072528,
0.1825470924,
-1.3261201382,
-0.1361845583,
0.410291642,
-0.0309492182,
-0.3091201186,
-0.3315673769,
0.0512923263,
0.382262826,
-0.5279219747,
0.3899925351,
-0.5328519344,
-0.2060523033,
0.2183281481,
-0.4770591259,
0.5183721781,
0.1356092095,
-0.3716685176,
0.2854934335,
-0.6604285836,
-0.4142113328,
0.2738156021,
-0.0303478371,
-0.4857185483,
-0.0797853097,
0.4430667758,
-0.0495242625,
0.5781511068,
-0.5329310298,
0.2678250968,
-0.45972386,
0.8122614622,
1.1383669376,
-0.2701555789,
0.3346080184,
-0.2177952528,
0.4060309529,
-0.2351837158,
0.2817100585,
0.0195545517,
-0.3348228931,
-0.2501884103,
-0.4374899864,
0.3863685727,
0.551618576,
-0.3931678832,
0.2199601978,
-0.0783894509,
-0.5463275313,
-0.3301459253,
0.2825296223,
-0.0205166992,
0.3514882922,
0.0841391534,
-0.281581521,
-0.2784214318,
-1.0733895302,
0.0043493523,
-0.3244634271,
-0.1806169897,
0.286234647,
0.4592210948,
-0.0504238382,
0.8506478667,
-0.8537141085,
-0.2877817154,
-0.154851988,
-0.0500475094,
0.3634420335,
0.5422484279,
0.6475382447,
-0.8126168847,
-0.1339823604,
0.3209783733,
-0.2658403516,
0.0130472975,
-0.0177745949,
-0.1989834458,
-0.0353206284,
0.5306029916,
-0.4850120544,
0.0516509563,
0.750356257,
-0.4459268153,
0.3338167965,
-0.2733914256,
-0.1575460881,
-1.0313038826,
0.5003110766,
0.1624245942,
-0.4362829626,
-0.3810796738,
0.100279972,
-0.1437999755,
-0.2243727297,
-0.1373980343,
0.9148128033,
-0.1680398285,
-0.486369431,
-0.0597576648,
0.2838225663,
-0.2467737794,
0.23898305,
-0.0552549176,
0.9339845777,
0.3650295734,
0.0313857682,
0.5803738236,
0.2222443074,
-0.3006462455,
0.3869427443,
-0.6443910003,
-0.0142094949,
0.1502144188,
0.1672420502,
-0.6927519441,
-0.3808746338,
0.4473987818,
0.0346110426,
0.0395426638,
-0.2060676664,
-0.4008846879,
-0.2631610036,
-0.2307011187,
0.2926106751,
0.340959996,
-0.472207129,
0.0619107932,
0.4121846557,
-0.9050163627,
-0.539518714,
-0.302339375,
0.2308269292,
-0.1764609069,
-0.456763804,
0.0927091315,
-0.2323654145,
-0.5433776975,
0.1005837917,
0.0440986603,
-0.1247198731,
0.211499393,
0.1425821632,
0.7055903077,
-0.383977443,
0.1972445995,
-0.3339828253,
-0.2117049247,
-0.1073613465,
-0.942063272,
0.4988467395,
-0.4607863426,
-0.4758048356,
0.0444414467,
0.1998685449,
0.6037483811,
-0.4216690958,
0.683304131,
0.585210979,
-0.2123247236,
-0.2617208362,
-0.5058828592,
0.1029127911,
-0.5240454078,
0.1169914752,
-0.0379898548,
-1.3814855814,
0.480019033,
-0.1008286551,
0.2757418752,
0.5765867233,
0.8279642463,
0.2634090185,
0.2365626991,
0.891667068,
-0.2247945964,
0.644572854,
0.0462443829,
0.5462508202,
-0.3090333045,
-0.0982692316,
-0.5972908735,
-0.0647739768,
-0.4339863658,
-0.3733476698,
0.19302167,
0.1241361499,
-0.5546634793,
0.2617069483,
-0.1659814417,
0.487782836,
0.7106184363,
-0.1862208843,
0.6196678877,
-0.1819875091,
0.0796319172,
0.2560496032,
-0.4836376905,
-0.3942402601,
1.1625418663,
0.7134572864,
0.9295930862,
0.0705225542,
0.4198654294,
0.5647745728,
0.4548898339,
-0.7420963645,
0.1648500115,
-0.5082401633,
-0.3753005564,
-0.4952916503,
-0.6427510381,
-0.5253741145,
-0.4164837003,
0.0540543795,
-0.4875453115,
0.0204129554,
-0.0379831344,
-0.424017638,
0.5019365549,
-0.4951523244,
1.0067344904,
-0.3069573045,
-0.337985456,
0.2123794705,
-0.3031748831,
0.6873246431,
-0.6479806304,
0.4130704701,
-0.1251710802,
-0.0566723682,
0.5952674747,
-0.6060763597,
0.7706359029,
-0.0816394836,
-0.4637975097,
0.1962937564,
-0.172375977,
0.6780078411,
0.3186795115,
-0.0993068144,
0.364574492,
-0.167086482,
-0.4180461764,
-0.2376170903,
0.860868454,
-0.5047622919,
-0.360798955,
-0.2365383655,
-0.6150647998,
-0.1610505879,
0.2556075156,
-0.2512185574,
0.0915930122,
-0.3597258627,
0.2919990122,
0.2760934532,
-0.1067815274,
0.3622322679,
0.4132474661,
-0.3733521402,
-0.4221162498,
0.8002160788,
-0.1225895211,
0.2915353179,
0.1913533211,
0.2000893354,
-0.4280046523,
-0.7095700502,
-0.4311642349,
0.2065173835,
-0.5418233275,
-0.2910016477,
-0.319193244,
-0.3516247272,
-0.6629477739,
-0.3165193796,
-0.5735419989,
-0.463429004,
0.03851391,
-0.3278681934,
0.9989854693,
0.8236106634,
-0.426363647,
0.2156984657,
-0.7712056041,
0.2667722702,
0.36972332,
1.024210453,
-0.1119677722,
-0.0036033734,
-0.3839996457,
-0.0765215456,
0.2836710215,
-0.3457104862,
0.4230664074,
-0.0483426936,
0.4041657746,
0.4190501273,
0.0352263488,
0.2649315,
-0.117522113,
0.5360721946,
0.1532187611,
-0.8859494925,
0.2730869949,
-0.7681658864,
0.1568973511,
0.6224961281,
0.22316432,
-0.7945066094,
-0.4226748049,
-0.3481002152,
-0.9456551075,
0.5962283611,
0.2608723342,
-0.112735644,
0.1372871697,
0.4416903555,
0.5025938153,
0.4794711173,
-0.7408205271,
0.1040238887,
-0.3942211568,
-0.2000755072,
-0.2855541408,
0.0610119961,
-0.0591088608,
0.0313794278,
0.7317926884,
-0.294837296,
0.0125586512,
-0.0874916762,
0.3057931662,
0.0153985312,
0.3387597799,
0.3884624839,
0.4628459811,
-0.5557010174,
-0.0918186307,
-0.2982865274,
-0.5871341825,
-0.0243454576,
0.3983280361,
-0.1555814445,
-0.254373461,
0.2429569513,
0.6684705615,
0.5439896584,
-0.8916707635,
0.6978110075,
-0.0355166197,
-0.2424355298,
-0.5468552709,
-0.0083542373,
0.1020594761,
0.6373490691,
0.4770602286,
0.0387993455,
0.0664503872,
-0.5581009984,
0.3857665062,
0.2691923082,
-0.4026091993,
-0.0658075362,
0.8617494702,
0.1458938122,
-0.0304718614,
0.8023082614,
0.1006117836,
-0.1682137847,
0.3857871592,
0.4372747838,
1.0073765516,
-0.0253675822,
0.1807616204,
0.0860386565,
0.2566572428,
-0.4843218923,
0.1456733197,
0.1777261794,
-0.4218812883,
-0.6591602564,
-0.9497767091,
-0.6691548824,
0.1509893537,
-0.501263082,
0.4027615786,
-0.8465336561,
-0.032212723,
0.095462054,
-0.1729203016,
-0.4942185879,
-0.4090354443,
0.2186060548,
1.1109595299,
-0.5160529613,
0.754313767,
0.3101459444,
-0.29806602,
-0.3430817723,
-0.2038298845,
-0.0915045366,
-0.7452955842,
0.4975696802,
-0.2348643541,
0.022344755,
0.1870072484,
-0.6324840784,
-0.8134992719,
1.0217313766,
0.5554389358,
-0.6893379092,
-0.3158921897,
0.1411308497,
0.2245760113,
-0.3371683657,
-0.1304320246,
0.5201994777,
0.9426635504,
0.194232583,
-0.9940879345,
-0.2781017423,
-0.1678284258,
-0.3439586461,
0.4755015969,
-0.7539871335,
1.0867836475,
-0.0314439982,
0.1150479242,
-0.0621735491,
0.4135622382,
0.0074245436,
0.2993759811,
0.2908252478,
0.2862835824,
0.6902134418,
-0.0817202032,
1.0577340126,
-0.422308296,
0.6554860473,
1.1410939693,
-0.3801087439,
0.8948021531,
0.2190553248,
-0.1629487425,
0.1947047114,
0.4641173184,
-0.3273742199,
0.2250752002,
0.2210495025,
-0.3464337289,
-0.1322025806,
-0.0054622754,
-0.2553151846,
0.6697186232,
0.2333647162,
-0.3190584183,
-0.2616339028,
0.0097344378,
0.0144178327,
-0.1256807446,
-0.5632070899,
0.6061621904,
0.3105399311,
-0.0655476898,
-0.1326551586,
0.3309132755,
0.5709850192,
-0.9137204885,
-0.0106642088,
-0.1765309423,
0.0508698225,
0.0274089742,
-0.6479993463,
0.4146209657,
0.2083025873,
0.0086187171,
-0.5244514942,
0.7292565703,
-0.3870696723,
-0.7131363153,
0.4190372229,
0.6313953996,
0.0592889264,
-0.1378575116,
-0.578186214,
-0.2121068537,
-0.2295479029,
-0.405661881,
0.3673928976,
0.2429664582,
-0.116212517,
0.6225633025,
1.0864357948,
0.1599086374,
-0.2482475787,
-0.1437282264,
0.6905263066,
-0.865801096,
-0.5433752537,
-0.9503757954,
0.0375642851,
0.044573836,
-0.1619614363,
0.5952569842,
0.7827295065,
0.8899003863,
-0.0861792639,
0.8018908501,
0.2172680348,
0.2784101069,
-0.7131215334,
0.9431522489,
-0.0778472051,
0.3019447923,
-0.3497776389,
-0.9743711352,
-0.4276973605,
0.4453220069,
-0.5166889429,
-0.1241956949,
0.1938789934,
0.4544812143,
-0.3421760798,
0.2934863865,
0.190683648,
0.3321380615,
0.1524016559,
0.3319145441,
0.3063628376,
-0.0144070638,
0.3599708378,
-0.1010121405,
-0.1396179497,
-0.4493848681,
-0.9937264919,
-0.5672557354,
-0.439768523,
-0.1554505378,
0.0860088095,
-0.0104283392,
1.2131603956,
0.4471786916,
-0.6139630079,
-0.5546957254,
0.1026582494,
0.048671063,
-0.1756247878,
-0.2360274792,
0.3496738672,
-0.0222919006,
-0.6475903392,
0.4919036925,
0.7022998929,
0.2771303952,
-0.5499247909,
0.0678721294,
0.1679856777,
0.0031451117,
0.6016599536,
0.2569128871,
-0.1749228686,
-0.3180515766,
-0.1351155341,
-0.0452582017,
0.1348170191,
0.9769102931,
-0.3170797229,
0.0514061749,
0.3112610281,
0.7941309214,
0.5511081219,
0.2376065105,
0.8028988838,
-0.2839773595,
0.1698299348,
0.1617640108,
0.3210913837,
0.0704737157,
-0.4280985892,
0.6405007243,
0.159087956,
-0.4506799281,
-0.5750687718,
-0.1034402028,
-1.0993683338,
-0.2977074087,
0.8626443744,
-0.0565418378,
-0.281743288,
-0.1222087368,
-0.1239945441,
-0.1430971473,
-0.7450174689,
0.4263961911,
0.7128450871,
0.1706961244,
-0.1821272969,
-1.1558170319,
0.4324552417,
-0.3493467569,
-0.8282972574,
0.5164754987,
0.4964251816,
0.2140810192,
-0.2280919403,
0.8407478929,
-0.1820392907,
0.0039670682,
-0.0094189346,
0.1850460917,
-0.4577251673,
-0.1122048199,
-0.3395974338,
0.3977874517,
0.2505064905,
0.3646399975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06029v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06029v1 | HiTZ@Antidote: Argumentation-driven Explainable Artificial Intelligence for Digital Medicine | 2023-06-09T16:50:02 | 2023-06-09T16:50:02 | Rodrigo Agerri, Iñigo Alonso, Aitziber Atutxa, Ander Berrondo, Ainara Estarrona, Iker Garcia-Ferrero, Iakes Goenaga, Koldo Gojenola, Maite Oronoz, Igor Perez-Tejedor, German Rigau, Anar Yeginbergenova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Providing high quality explanations for AI predictions based on machine
learning is a challenging and complex task. To work well it requires, among
other factors: selecting a proper level of generality/specificity of the
explanation; considering assumptions about the familiarity of the explanation
beneficiary with the AI task under consideration; referring to specific
elements that have contributed to the decision; making use of additional
knowledge (e.g. expert evidence) which might not be part of the prediction
process; and providing evidence supporting negative hypothesis. Finally, the
system needs to formulate the explanation in a clearly interpretable, and
possibly convincing, way. Given these considerations, ANTIDOTE fosters an
integrated vision of explainable AI, where low-level characteristics of the
deep learning process are combined with higher level schemes proper of the
human argumentation capacity. ANTIDOTE will exploit cross-disciplinary
competences in deep learning and argumentation to support a broader and
innovative view of explainable AI, where the need for high-quality explanations
for clinical cases deliberation is critical. As a first result of the project,
we publish the Antidote CasiMedicos dataset to facilitate research on
explainable AI in general, and argumentation in the medical domain in
particular. | [
-0.3186196387,
-0.8243829012,
0.745131135,
-0.2594240904,
-0.5023751259,
-0.011906879,
0.1204592213,
-0.3671209812,
0.2797194421,
0.3265838325,
-0.8811298013,
-0.41163674,
-0.4535847902,
0.0385186896,
-0.4623688161,
1.4020687342,
-0.1346966028,
0.4589661658,
-0.4809706211,
-0.2464586496,
-0.3021244109,
-0.3958057761,
-0.8051315546,
-0.7468722463,
0.8109151721,
0.5382377505,
0.6889045238,
0.8113947511,
0.5435518026,
0.2623732686,
0.542894125,
-0.0884344503,
-0.1654354334,
0.0417260788,
-0.4997238517,
-0.5896372199,
-0.4443648458,
-0.0567047633,
-0.073959209,
0.6232081652,
-0.2049127966,
-0.1856362224,
-0.5986022353,
0.7954365611,
-0.4827941954,
-0.1571053565,
-0.367488265,
0.4293020368,
-0.1063978598,
-0.3782788515,
-0.145727694,
-0.3070091903,
0.4079474509,
-0.8702817559,
0.2725652456,
-0.1863417625,
0.607370019,
0.6084524989,
-0.0560301282,
-0.469455272,
-0.7796547413,
0.3904748261,
-0.7167910337,
-0.0586919114,
0.1519147009,
0.6596297622,
-0.0539362058,
-0.9202589393,
-0.5544084907,
-0.0619745851,
0.1422959119,
0.3966669142,
-0.474545747,
0.2669111192,
0.0497866869,
0.4045945108,
-0.5938073993,
0.3388791382,
-0.2211769521,
-0.1182760745,
0.7709177136,
0.4176335037,
0.4827480912,
0.3739043772,
-0.3055763245,
0.467040509,
-0.7011014223,
0.0098900879,
0.25083974,
0.1324387193,
-0.0769073367,
0.2036188394,
-0.2241674364,
0.5830932856,
0.2450127453,
0.4136318862,
0.2057622224,
-0.2323092669,
-0.3046904206,
0.6417037249,
0.9077823758,
0.1732866764,
0.3048671782,
-0.1550771445,
0.266987443,
0.1612972915,
0.7918592691,
-1.1078919172,
-0.537719965,
0.7489036322,
-0.7123565078,
-0.6174482107,
-0.1372980475,
-0.8596856594,
-0.7010309696,
-0.303758949,
0.6135623455,
-0.4576340616,
-0.2213160247,
0.2877676487,
-0.2222627252,
-0.1192521602,
0.3705582619,
-0.7110564113,
0.2777681351,
0.4638341069,
0.6149876118,
-0.1479534507,
-0.1708724946,
-0.3271728754,
0.0837557688,
-0.6331669092,
1.2638241053,
-0.5454766154,
-0.2225195467,
-0.0350969806,
-0.0071448521,
0.0147015043,
-0.731754601,
0.5778149962,
-0.1756059974,
0.3754504025,
-0.3574145436,
-0.6028661728,
-0.254771769,
0.0827163234,
-0.3028168082,
0.0848078132,
0.174717471,
-0.7209312916,
0.6021718383,
-1.4849210978,
-0.5832152963,
0.1952758431,
-0.2329908758,
-0.4934487641,
0.1037660241,
0.2565623224,
0.2663810849,
-0.3987533748,
0.3423658609,
-0.2847900391,
-0.3781443834,
0.293120116,
-0.251827985,
0.9241426587,
0.3679919243,
-0.5770322084,
0.6821835637,
-0.6698698401,
-0.1744339317,
0.4859907031,
0.2207824737,
-0.2074716836,
0.1681125313,
-0.5753841996,
0.0481877178,
-0.084902063,
-0.6652662158,
0.2612786889,
-0.6240509748,
0.688072741,
0.5170119405,
0.1964880377,
-0.0703755915,
-0.3370396793,
0.7119269967,
0.3948512971,
0.4100248218,
-0.2700266838,
-0.3206574619,
-0.5415947437,
-0.4238648713,
0.1890324801,
0.773021698,
-0.6958486438,
0.1199069247,
-0.0590849593,
-0.6095010638,
-0.6624464393,
-0.1601005048,
0.4834112823,
0.8776866794,
0.5110086203,
-0.1498259306,
-0.6526688337,
-1.2333619595,
-0.2427771688,
-0.2202708572,
-0.1849158108,
0.4444981813,
0.6470456719,
-0.629159987,
0.8928999901,
-0.423700422,
-0.140602693,
-0.4198666215,
0.2602290213,
0.3664091229,
0.2592381537,
0.5138009191,
-0.6913542151,
-0.1101437807,
-0.1294450462,
-1.0604203939,
-0.3482458591,
-0.4025115073,
-0.168811962,
-0.2255871892,
0.4450000525,
-0.636619091,
0.6010292768,
-0.2023981065,
-0.3330418766,
0.6066758633,
-0.4161750078,
0.3624081016,
-0.9843025208,
0.0942461938,
0.0152733391,
0.0717349127,
-0.7517027855,
-0.1824569404,
-0.4436725974,
-0.1934164166,
-0.3957479,
0.3449481428,
0.3049648404,
0.2878893018,
-0.3772066534,
0.012100148,
0.1267686039,
0.0858132318,
-0.0440957323,
0.68520087,
0.7263359427,
-0.4594509006,
0.8897781372,
0.2452398837,
-0.1521768719,
0.7788847685,
-1.061450243,
-0.0727912113,
-0.0068578431,
0.3399463892,
-0.8012766838,
-0.3974522948,
0.3711432517,
-0.5511954427,
0.2013626546,
-0.0844572559,
-0.2404990345,
-0.6933606267,
-0.0589880869,
0.4926079512,
0.1865931004,
-0.5265193582,
0.3063330054,
0.3632853627,
-0.0364145488,
-0.4677824974,
-0.5747662187,
0.3734458983,
-0.4722158313,
-0.2841601968,
0.5269443393,
-0.2055523396,
-0.6060475707,
0.0253145564,
0.1199331135,
-0.2000854462,
0.2796243727,
0.4653086364,
0.0496581048,
-0.3696478903,
0.325422883,
0.2377755642,
-0.5211827159,
0.4720400572,
-0.2482063174,
0.1855482757,
-0.0690515265,
-0.6755827069,
-0.6931989193,
0.6170661449,
0.7477630973,
0.0870580673,
0.6122277379,
0.4622514844,
-0.5343367457,
-0.2404631674,
0.050917767,
-0.1675449908,
-0.4251336157,
0.3831487596,
-0.310939163,
-0.1533143967,
0.7704747319,
-0.1865819246,
0.0957409889,
0.8024064302,
0.8790390491,
-0.2088540643,
1.191318512,
0.1581822336,
0.095873639,
0.1185562983,
-0.2807708681,
0.5474256873,
-0.141399622,
-0.4394798577,
-0.3583788276,
-0.2366034389,
-0.135589987,
-0.0339390598,
0.2150320113,
-0.087767683,
-0.3975156844,
0.0050360183,
-0.697734952,
0.3401070535,
0.7015859485,
0.2488762736,
-0.0008377779,
-0.183450684,
-0.0387939028,
0.0694458783,
-0.888810873,
-0.2471555769,
0.8739873171,
0.2865436673,
0.5594835877,
-0.1808080822,
0.5063267946,
0.9828802347,
0.0785629451,
-1.1744769812,
0.3417459726,
-0.2975151837,
-0.7465097904,
-0.1047509983,
-0.1657101959,
-1.109297514,
-0.2116081715,
-0.2704533637,
-0.4695051312,
0.0033355937,
0.3036314845,
-0.7308201194,
0.3420023322,
-0.5234928131,
1.146056056,
-0.2884197235,
-0.1655439138,
-0.6382585764,
-0.8402138352,
-0.0025850777,
0.0036070338,
0.107782796,
0.2397239208,
0.3324348032,
0.9027591348,
-0.8284978271,
0.6460548639,
-0.3333107531,
-0.0008042542,
0.4326123893,
0.0598268993,
-0.2178387344,
-0.1170769632,
-0.1721025109,
0.3488615155,
0.1006520316,
-0.4883813262,
-0.7238516212,
0.5321651697,
-0.6284121275,
-0.548935771,
-0.262016505,
-0.5808031559,
-0.1454861909,
0.1035976708,
0.5106378198,
0.758102417,
-0.2554352582,
-0.0870032758,
0.7137160897,
-0.5333153605,
0.1382168829,
0.3583773375,
0.3758859336,
-0.4860381484,
1.0544785261,
0.0821164697,
-0.2195484787,
0.2787569165,
0.6053555012,
-0.2834850848,
-1.0868835449,
-1.048140049,
-0.1443814933,
-0.6041903496,
-0.086664632,
-0.4500954747,
-0.2309110761,
-0.2665429115,
-0.4252992272,
-0.3401789069,
-0.3641692996,
-0.2730725706,
-0.1130048782,
0.4110558629,
0.8707984686,
-0.1345808357,
0.1949128062,
-0.6373873353,
0.6122758985,
0.0885937586,
0.4090107679,
-0.166198507,
-0.4736373127,
-0.5154235959,
0.1951938272,
-0.1248091757,
-0.8796725273,
0.0992938504,
0.1780734956,
0.8426977992,
1.1642913818,
0.3788637221,
0.7277616262,
-0.4115871191,
0.884980619,
0.19913809,
-0.8120775819,
1.1891890764,
-0.3987771869,
-0.0007831609,
0.6035667062,
0.6295908093,
-0.1484393477,
-0.103686206,
-0.5437626243,
-0.7825534344,
0.5023654699,
-0.2051786482,
-0.1867105663,
-0.056892179,
0.6763232946,
0.6286128759,
0.0000803355,
-0.284284085,
-0.1185983866,
-0.4513429999,
-0.768084228,
0.0645283312,
-0.0899877697,
-0.5948960185,
-0.2528567612,
0.7066788673,
-0.1618943065,
0.3960085213,
0.3200155199,
-0.0646954924,
-0.3015979528,
0.051335495,
0.6912304759,
1.0756980181,
0.0036444312,
0.1217325926,
-0.0756059811,
-0.4510833025,
-0.0383123755,
0.2630087137,
-0.0192460585,
-0.1158288717,
0.7781133056,
0.7848212719,
-0.4740545154,
-0.9917812943,
0.4138950109,
-0.082637459,
-0.4821875095,
-0.3090172112,
0.3895274997,
-0.2560673654,
0.4851757288,
0.444393307,
-0.0758846179,
0.3711822927,
-0.611302197,
0.2904862463,
0.3942777812,
-0.6789286137,
-0.2999148667,
0.7464373112,
0.1496148556,
-0.5335341096,
0.5295636058,
0.309440434,
-0.4678653479,
0.883710742,
0.5598311424,
0.7786950469,
-0.0627887771,
0.368509233,
0.1710108519,
-0.1701381505,
0.4738215506,
0.1711945534,
-0.1078156382,
-0.3906254768,
-0.1172678694,
-0.0487149134,
-0.66962111,
0.0790571123,
-0.5548676252,
0.0277208295,
-0.6561771631,
-0.0281162951,
0.5338129997,
0.1098487079,
-0.0959312618,
0.5348438621,
0.069754906,
0.9313226342,
-1.0180501938,
0.5098240972,
0.5952403545,
-0.5563302636,
-0.0580563508,
-0.0603790283,
-0.0586978309,
-0.8628454208,
0.4087437987,
0.2127151489,
-0.3040044606,
-0.4566554129,
-0.7588244677,
-0.1857813597,
0.7017024755,
0.2712246776,
-0.169292748,
0.1901596487,
0.0615300164,
0.8589547873,
-0.6108208299,
0.3570486605,
0.3051601648,
0.3223635554,
0.0668700114,
-0.5179613829,
0.2377344072,
-0.5022055507,
-0.6559910178,
-0.0494798943,
-0.1768730581,
0.3715588152,
-0.9120947123,
0.1691583246,
-0.0580654815,
0.3231492639,
-0.0176569298,
1.0152240992,
0.3883964717,
0.8325650692,
0.6449795961,
-0.0646227822,
0.9914374948,
-0.1441791803,
-0.2436878383,
0.9091585279,
-0.1286979467,
0.3610761762,
0.4205889106,
-0.2631627321,
1.0623397827,
1.1224393845,
-0.1338129342,
0.7103468776,
0.2863170505,
-0.2817241848,
-0.4342259467,
-0.2864411771,
-0.4450116456,
0.3954734206,
0.5510101318,
-0.6527204514,
0.0221037492,
0.173836723,
-0.1920152605,
-0.006462798,
-0.4810362458,
1.145704627,
-0.1437475681,
-0.6192502379,
0.495216012,
-0.3138711154,
-0.0407274961,
-0.457639277,
-0.1756194234,
-0.0624284707,
0.5348309278,
-0.3933132291,
-0.8472118974,
0.4265742302,
0.0219934937,
-0.5368371606,
0.0421939455,
0.4872675538,
0.0191517007,
-0.2732537687,
0.2150120884,
0.3343036175,
0.4745532572,
0.1405885667,
-1.0794707537,
-0.4056867361,
-0.1519832015,
-0.0447480194,
0.1923620403,
0.6535627246,
-0.0646365955,
0.9464915991,
0.612406075,
0.1481675506,
-0.5262463689,
0.3372377157,
0.9378832579,
-0.5178042054,
-0.3927264214,
-1.1841694117,
0.4196589291,
-0.1157224998,
-0.2261165679,
0.3310533762,
0.5022093654,
0.1516115814,
0.1349767894,
0.7786981463,
0.2501635849,
0.6093724966,
-0.2019028366,
0.852104485,
-0.7114967704,
-0.2383106202,
-0.0575360581,
-0.2623960674,
-0.5249512792,
0.5434365273,
-0.2741039097,
-0.1589492559,
0.4446528852,
0.3082032502,
-0.1074938253,
0.2153189182,
0.0251721945,
0.4218567014,
0.4311984181,
0.7181417346,
0.6489441395,
-0.1992572695,
0.4415525496,
-0.1047260538,
-0.4228273332,
-0.4482160807,
-0.8819730282,
-0.9341291785,
-0.3749842048,
-0.6034016609,
-0.5125546455,
0.335197717,
0.9660276771,
0.8251543045,
-1.1768711805,
0.3437315226,
-0.4537195563,
0.2109676003,
-0.2326683849,
-0.1490443051,
0.4684512913,
-0.0557301901,
-0.2418056279,
0.586630404,
0.3250387013,
-0.2585960627,
-0.2516003251,
-0.1256801784,
0.0367529541,
0.3940085769,
0.4889953136,
0.5635043383,
-0.63474828,
0.0872536823,
-0.3273598254,
0.1046921313,
0.2559123635,
1.0255248547,
-1.0780863762,
0.8037558198,
0.4762314558,
0.8478298783,
0.1938683838,
-0.0193928126,
0.7901293635,
0.0852189884,
-0.0540488511,
0.4610751569,
0.3776221275,
0.1036893502,
-0.4287320673,
0.3701926768,
0.2914316654,
-0.4786331952,
-0.8210756779,
0.2676682472,
-0.7248536348,
-0.7006113529,
0.6988576055,
-0.5124338865,
-0.050346978,
-0.5119727254,
-0.1965756863,
0.5652945638,
-0.1466844529,
1.1598614454,
0.343187511,
-0.7004820704,
-0.0431367829,
-0.4688417017,
0.5355383158,
0.3436199725,
-1.105713129,
0.1617618799,
0.3908090591,
0.1306880116,
0.1631165445,
0.4040923119,
-0.1921893656,
0.4970980883,
0.0651511252,
-0.1746430099,
-0.496447891,
-0.4990847111,
-0.3243508637,
0.1021004841,
-0.3341623843,
-0.5063235164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05997v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05997v2 | Automated Labeling of German Chest X-Ray Radiology Reports using Deep Learning | 2023-06-09T16:08:35 | 2023-07-07T11:36:11 | Alessandro Wollek, Philip Haitzer, Thomas Sedlmeyr, Sardi Hyska, Johannes Rueckel, Bastian Sabel, Michael Ingrisch, Tobias Lasser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiologists are in short supply globally, and deep learning models offer a
promising solution to address this shortage as part of clinical
decision-support systems. However, training such models often requires
expensive and time-consuming manual labeling of large datasets. Automatic label
extraction from radiology reports can reduce the time required to obtain
labeled datasets, but this task is challenging due to semantically similar
words and missing annotated data. In this work, we explore the potential of
weak supervision of a deep learning-based label prediction model, using a
rule-based labeler. We propose a deep learning-based CheXpert label prediction
model, pre-trained on reports labeled by a rule-based German CheXpert model and
fine-tuned on a small dataset of manually labeled reports. Our results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, which significantly outperformed
the rule-based model on all three tasks. Our findings highlight the benefits of
employing deep learning-based models even in scenarios with sparse data and the
use of the rule-based labeler as a tool for weak supervision. | [
-0.1808976233,
-0.2996767461,
0.703727901,
-0.2523341179,
-0.5205542445,
-0.2394043505,
0.0589001477,
-0.8176777959,
-0.0500209033,
0.6142333746,
-0.5043106675,
-0.6361820102,
-1.0251172781,
-0.0130147347,
-0.2330624163,
1.2065559626,
-0.0653814077,
0.2816664279,
-0.0742258355,
0.2548728585,
-0.6538131833,
-0.2815636694,
-0.4767895043,
-0.885163784,
0.7164309621,
0.4995688498,
1.2610156536,
0.9746527672,
0.7372717261,
0.2035045326,
0.0398178473,
-0.0313322097,
-0.1873845607,
-0.1592648029,
-0.054507535,
-0.1314507723,
-0.6177626848,
-0.0558038317,
0.1322574466,
0.9426769018,
0.2238324583,
-0.2472171336,
-0.1918656826,
0.4582364261,
-0.4932253659,
0.4522328377,
-0.0439731255,
0.4286085665,
0.1194821149,
-0.1493706107,
-0.3375300765,
-0.2251433432,
0.5729941726,
-0.3381763697,
0.2331493348,
-0.1422650665,
1.0268279314,
0.2320476323,
-0.4229275286,
-0.5593403578,
-0.6765971184,
0.6040582657,
-0.6421333551,
0.5114274025,
0.7389748096,
0.5091413856,
0.2502084076,
-1.158800602,
0.2752738595,
-0.3051709533,
-0.6668530703,
0.2152879983,
-0.386326015,
0.1458290219,
-0.0102966158,
0.3141988218,
-0.4008292854,
0.5137056708,
-0.5016073585,
-0.1284703314,
0.728289485,
0.1640168577,
0.080259122,
-0.152237162,
-0.5166245699,
-0.2103818059,
-0.1352953315,
-0.5420166254,
-0.3945141137,
0.5969601274,
-0.0222307108,
0.3376521766,
-0.5156368017,
0.4460513592,
0.1347759217,
-0.0846329033,
0.5984489322,
0.0744665787,
-0.564532876,
0.6797165871,
0.6605606675,
0.0770248845,
0.0172910485,
-0.375913471,
-0.4226155281,
0.1435338855,
0.0313149206,
-0.8385426998,
-0.653663218,
0.0121570555,
-0.5149133801,
-0.5156175494,
0.0175192636,
-0.4144670963,
-0.6239945889,
-0.5097287893,
0.5904807448,
-0.3142085969,
0.0770250633,
0.3358719945,
0.1322651505,
-0.088022694,
0.4310699105,
-0.5149179697,
0.3054829836,
0.318354696,
0.6183301806,
0.1624666601,
0.0978294536,
-0.942989707,
0.1403866112,
-0.3127880394,
0.6880861521,
-0.5093013048,
-0.3708411455,
-0.2282861918,
0.2503637075,
0.1288255155,
-0.5404952765,
0.6839518547,
-0.4904763401,
0.0322159193,
0.063805446,
-0.579043448,
-0.0866942927,
0.0402092524,
-0.6393516064,
0.4788016379,
0.1760503352,
-0.3681769371,
0.5585360527,
0.0995866284,
-0.7460678816,
0.3236236572,
-0.1297644824,
-0.8289993405,
0.0497453734,
0.3707079589,
1.0125622749,
-0.3657245934,
0.5238021612,
-0.186765492,
-0.2893279493,
0.2910988331,
-0.1786174327,
0.6869288087,
0.2746846676,
-0.4759023786,
-0.0176570751,
-0.8087614179,
0.2359324545,
0.0151259163,
-0.2486591935,
-0.2485286891,
-0.1357681602,
-0.0822336525,
0.3974550068,
-0.205941394,
-0.410733223,
0.1508529633,
-0.2357009947,
-0.1603304297,
0.546521008,
-0.0351785161,
0.1880856305,
-0.3847778141,
0.4810090959,
0.0469180048,
0.147917226,
-0.0340326615,
-0.2055696249,
-0.7538193464,
-0.4922726154,
0.3907344639,
0.5639271736,
-0.4785027206,
0.309411943,
-0.1581261158,
-0.7433237433,
-0.5176068544,
0.3145621121,
0.6769356132,
0.6131344438,
0.5263390541,
-0.49558869,
-0.5691446066,
-1.1150963306,
0.1052552089,
0.3428577781,
0.0143405516,
0.4305244684,
0.4548354149,
-0.7170186043,
0.3574821055,
-0.9761427045,
-0.981898725,
-0.2141795158,
0.3972122371,
0.2259522974,
0.2989136279,
0.0647057965,
-0.6571950316,
-0.5310633183,
0.2657348812,
-1.0314334631,
-0.1862475276,
-0.1405629963,
0.2025644183,
0.0358449258,
0.9599456191,
-0.2023884952,
0.4889693856,
0.3314142525,
-0.1777600497,
0.3180816472,
-0.3807145953,
-0.3398981094,
-0.4742321968,
-0.0990478769,
0.3218121231,
-0.3705599308,
-0.6198506355,
-0.2908058465,
0.2178899199,
-0.2835527956,
-0.5640261769,
0.2451592982,
-0.5639013648,
0.3072639704,
-0.3179472089,
-0.4144212604,
0.2005354017,
0.2353563607,
0.5822931528,
-0.1433512419,
0.7485746741,
-0.5184221268,
0.2820104659,
0.2608143389,
-0.3663477302,
0.2570141852,
-0.6189360023,
0.1308198571,
-0.2949919105,
0.330610007,
-0.6828320622,
-0.3670461774,
0.3056712151,
-0.0204607453,
0.7916469574,
-0.3775056303,
-0.5479717851,
-0.3899111152,
0.1613141,
0.2327101827,
0.5227506757,
-0.435844332,
0.4138555825,
0.2404002845,
-0.1074244305,
-0.2337400913,
-0.9097581506,
-0.0211424269,
0.1261241585,
-0.1915357113,
0.2122268975,
0.1890773326,
-0.1404471397,
0.2623557746,
-0.1515029371,
-0.3561486602,
-0.0177475326,
0.5296086669,
0.1916451454,
-0.2990761399,
0.1759025156,
-0.093173638,
-0.4639165103,
0.2079949826,
-0.3027869761,
0.0625823736,
-0.4409300387,
-0.1286602467,
-0.5722410679,
0.2913066745,
0.2888531983,
0.0726480931,
0.3156707883,
0.6375481486,
-0.3223696649,
-0.2066104412,
-0.2984627187,
-0.2114165127,
-0.4382140636,
0.3160172403,
-0.0181720722,
-0.6096582413,
0.1433386952,
-0.259552002,
-0.5851082206,
0.467689544,
0.4914118052,
-0.4109947383,
1.1391472816,
0.7250304222,
0.1337088048,
-0.0219257064,
-0.2341697514,
-0.0514348298,
-0.2514902651,
-0.5006363392,
-0.2746177316,
-0.1213926002,
-0.4252065718,
-0.1820231527,
0.398775965,
-0.3551144004,
0.0373606011,
0.1012787148,
-0.8658492565,
0.4708380997,
0.4599977136,
0.4940294325,
0.2284799516,
-0.1616122574,
0.3175975978,
-0.0022654252,
-0.9185117483,
-0.0949117616,
0.8864456415,
0.2529288232,
0.9571046233,
-0.3016070127,
0.9921566248,
0.547144711,
0.1723002195,
-0.8768054247,
0.1695954949,
-0.4768611789,
-0.5119724274,
-0.1039230004,
-0.2625924945,
-1.219045043,
0.0407590829,
-0.1725307107,
-0.2336353064,
0.5392177701,
0.0259254538,
-0.4370963573,
0.1135046557,
-0.8610010743,
0.8477730155,
-0.5225283504,
-0.1519958526,
0.1485503465,
-0.8582898974,
0.3072814941,
-0.4273494184,
0.3648227751,
-0.2608683109,
0.1582434922,
0.7381903529,
-0.7024985552,
1.4134479761,
-0.039876435,
-0.2184607685,
0.1690065265,
0.0569311865,
0.5376184583,
-0.0778190345,
0.2657023072,
0.0185397789,
0.0144147873,
-0.3519814312,
-0.1829245985,
0.582192719,
-0.8424824476,
-0.3416104317,
-0.7712622285,
-0.5952391624,
-0.1336125284,
0.5677707791,
0.4096644819,
0.5486935377,
0.0072853938,
0.0477312841,
0.7879424691,
-0.2115801573,
-0.0535997786,
0.5431973338,
0.1892545968,
-0.3399793506,
1.1536898613,
0.5242005587,
0.0430738777,
0.3928673863,
0.4642486274,
0.0582722053,
-0.3162686527,
-0.1457963288,
0.0707181394,
-0.9251157641,
-0.5907796025,
-0.506077528,
-0.4132224321,
-0.2025301158,
-0.6362402439,
-0.2691277266,
-0.1180270612,
-0.4920429587,
-0.0601833016,
0.2191655934,
0.8200152516,
-0.2362800092,
0.2889016569,
-0.7176355124,
0.3039595783,
0.4815897644,
0.5211548805,
-0.0830484405,
-0.2670682371,
-0.6235669851,
-0.3661557734,
0.0182181653,
-0.691490531,
0.5632499456,
-0.013684609,
0.2983204722,
0.3661122918,
0.380315125,
0.4243279099,
-0.1599779725,
-0.0051598675,
0.2178507447,
-0.6688183546,
0.7500269413,
-0.4127555192,
0.5507044792,
0.4729922116,
0.4099150598,
-0.1887021661,
-0.4205792546,
-0.6445052624,
-1.1385045052,
0.8797673583,
-0.1368589401,
0.001731027,
-0.1432849914,
0.0601694435,
0.3938214183,
-0.0892479494,
-0.5173549056,
-0.2570729554,
-0.1703044325,
0.0763872042,
-0.1257914305,
-0.3247220516,
-0.1166580394,
-0.3762253523,
0.9560235143,
-0.1071956977,
-0.0151906619,
0.3907151222,
-0.4587374628,
-0.2660731673,
0.2265207022,
0.4405291975,
0.5063473582,
-0.5790558457,
0.3833904862,
0.1053096429,
-0.269993037,
0.1943001896,
0.475449115,
-0.1240766123,
0.141272977,
0.4279543161,
0.810970366,
0.3609292805,
-0.5679885745,
0.428878665,
-0.0348128155,
-0.5573651195,
-0.2948420346,
-0.0804910362,
-0.0595929921,
0.2987269461,
0.2227011919,
0.2237160206,
0.2091792077,
-0.1481845975,
0.6205523014,
0.1553863883,
-1.155677557,
0.1623188406,
0.6724290252,
-0.0580040216,
0.2392385155,
0.7249224186,
-0.0364516824,
-0.0700876936,
0.8235684633,
0.4456128776,
0.6860179901,
0.0388041139,
0.4133733511,
0.063688308,
0.3421571851,
0.058092013,
-0.2090390623,
0.2946344018,
-0.3213947415,
-0.6084013581,
-0.1589942575,
-0.4139682353,
0.3356964588,
-0.978318274,
0.4642305672,
-0.7756055593,
-0.037058156,
0.3610829115,
0.088571623,
-0.8016839623,
0.9442834258,
0.7261394262,
0.7098904848,
-1.0529087782,
0.9672796726,
0.4038393795,
-0.3820461035,
-0.8657884598,
-0.4591546655,
0.3326085508,
-0.8245843649,
0.9371489882,
0.2457316965,
-0.0403244309,
-0.252056241,
-0.3510626256,
-0.8752462268,
0.9709983468,
0.1921446323,
-0.532998383,
0.3508277535,
0.0689124092,
0.5137056112,
-0.1267660409,
-0.0307662692,
0.4870894551,
0.4345434904,
0.2270710319,
-0.774825573,
0.3928340375,
-0.1828396022,
-0.5057995915,
0.15882577,
-0.4648172855,
0.5657287836,
-0.4083414078,
-0.0184283555,
-0.1903173327,
0.7416549325,
-0.2975008488,
0.4702098966,
0.2178079188,
0.6749702096,
0.822974205,
0.1153929159,
1.2440931797,
0.336293608,
0.2364812046,
1.3162446022,
-0.362236321,
0.2565146387,
0.0340570994,
0.2409612387,
0.463411361,
0.4187449515,
-0.7048053741,
0.6007992029,
-0.0710665658,
-0.0881984532,
-0.4970888793,
-0.38676247,
-0.5733394623,
0.3767448366,
0.2025276423,
-0.7580267191,
-0.4455317259,
0.1379200369,
0.2788166404,
-0.3702093959,
-0.47999084,
1.0423805714,
0.175212875,
-0.3709553778,
0.9239845276,
-0.1058113948,
0.2697841227,
-0.6518359184,
0.164118886,
-0.1107382774,
0.6473923922,
-0.5375483632,
-0.6766499281,
0.2539789677,
-0.3469489813,
-0.3019863665,
-0.3500879705,
0.9134330153,
-0.3303385973,
-0.813521862,
0.3925975263,
0.4730463028,
0.1289082468,
0.1646598428,
-0.5901890993,
0.0086734891,
0.0459058993,
-0.1722605526,
0.7978165746,
0.3492740691,
-0.1721325964,
0.6685815454,
0.359516412,
0.0056067472,
-0.2689088881,
-0.0483900458,
1.0501385927,
-0.3251435459,
-0.3322707415,
-0.7072632909,
0.3298996985,
0.2824680507,
-0.0128257237,
0.5244140029,
0.6152258515,
0.7196747065,
-0.1610969901,
1.007941246,
0.1645080745,
0.238586843,
-0.4881323278,
0.6893158555,
-0.5265501738,
0.2534014285,
-0.4080669284,
-0.3888996542,
-0.852285862,
0.2928709984,
-0.5113614202,
-0.1616405398,
0.6342856884,
0.6444314718,
-0.4723893106,
-0.1994231045,
0.4083918631,
0.3458147049,
0.0751971304,
0.5926560163,
0.3685739338,
-0.2630958557,
0.9881071448,
-0.8999596238,
-0.1108375564,
-0.3244557381,
-0.8140112758,
-0.8884916306,
-0.2422167361,
-0.8930094242,
-0.5419868827,
0.0952961892,
0.5855811238,
1.0638021231,
-0.8378708959,
0.0594539121,
0.1819142252,
-0.0562635399,
-0.4560877085,
-0.1708520949,
0.9586549401,
-0.4254586399,
-0.3455637395,
0.4278926253,
0.1277516186,
0.2786258757,
0.4377021194,
-0.1069913357,
-0.0152389975,
-0.2833749056,
0.4313085973,
0.4418933392,
-0.2713135481,
0.0556998998,
-0.3798376918,
-0.3900992572,
0.1731134504,
0.478553623,
-1.1415909529,
0.6454520822,
0.1642382294,
0.4967758656,
0.777702868,
-0.3141368032,
0.3587869704,
-0.7858715653,
0.0948742926,
0.5241752863,
0.2325367033,
0.2230285108,
-0.608094573,
0.556907475,
0.0964683816,
-0.4777952731,
-0.7615280747,
0.0527198166,
-0.9363881946,
-0.7037992477,
0.9898935556,
-0.0877702981,
-0.1363991499,
-0.2362481356,
-0.2386016101,
0.269033432,
-0.3262448311,
0.626293838,
0.1416014731,
-0.2958519459,
-0.4488686323,
-0.5092853904,
0.460032016,
0.4603692889,
-0.561205864,
-0.0917877778,
0.4813535213,
0.2019392252,
-0.0108168991,
0.553889513,
0.0515256859,
0.5414525867,
-0.1841445565,
-0.0113473143,
-0.3939507902,
-0.2462893724,
-0.3458378911,
0.3325193524,
-0.0260411594,
-0.0026655027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03687v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03687v2 | Leveraging text data for causal inference using electronic health records | 2023-06-09T16:06:02 | 2024-05-20T18:14:42 | Reagan Mozer, Aaron R. Kaufman, Leo A. Celi, Luke Miratrix | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP, stat.ME | In studies that rely on data from electronic health records (EHRs),
unstructured text data such as clinical progress notes offer a rich source of
information about patient characteristics and care that may be missing from
structured data. Despite the prevalence of text in clinical research, these
data are often ignored for the purposes of quantitative analysis due their
complexity. This paper presents a unified framework for leveraging text data to
support causal inference with electronic health data at multiple stages of
analysis. In particular, we consider how natural language processing and
statistical text analysis can be combined with standard inferential techniques
to address common challenges due to missing data, confounding bias, and
treatment effect heterogeneity. Through an application to a recent EHR study
investigating the effects of a non-randomized medical intervention on patient
outcomes, we show how incorporating text data in a traditional matching
analysis can help strengthen the validity of an estimated treatment effect and
identify patient subgroups that may benefit most from treatment. We believe
these methods have the potential to expand the scope of secondary analysis of
clinical data to domains where structured EHR data is limited, such as in
developing countries. To this end, we provide code and open-source replication
materials to encourage adoption and broader exploration of these techniques in
clinical research. | [
0.2358685881,
-1.0432258844,
0.8743423223,
0.3488491476,
-0.1010223255,
-0.3735334575,
-0.0159450155,
-0.4715495706,
0.3716131747,
0.7614188194,
-0.1915194094,
-0.5778244734,
-0.6515274048,
0.2407647222,
-0.2429380119,
1.2433453798,
-0.142551735,
0.266357094,
-0.3782826364,
-0.1631644666,
-0.7992027998,
-0.3791868687,
-0.5965285301,
-0.491642952,
0.6480513215,
0.6484297514,
0.474774003,
0.6760024428,
0.7754639983,
0.1726595461,
0.2743879259,
0.0928727239,
-0.1875649989,
0.2316435277,
0.0151104694,
-0.4252964258,
-0.3971021473,
-0.3287516236,
0.6014635563,
0.8523733616,
-0.2247557789,
0.041252017,
-0.0926979259,
0.7277867198,
-0.4771619737,
0.0688154027,
-0.2489359677,
0.2090902328,
-0.3973348141,
-0.5229316354,
-0.4051312506,
-0.6572616696,
0.3084102571,
-0.4655878544,
0.3667250574,
-0.078768976,
0.5218523741,
0.3255949914,
-0.8997102976,
-0.4953808486,
-0.8872723579,
0.6121031642,
-0.7294103503,
0.2744442821,
0.7928746939,
0.126310274,
-0.3637908101,
-0.9432837367,
-0.2947845459,
-0.1462597549,
-0.5667617917,
0.1006066948,
-0.1483759284,
0.1923016459,
0.4459208548,
0.345880568,
-0.4168878794,
-0.0597631596,
-0.4217379689,
-0.2018001825,
0.5760495067,
0.2668173909,
0.6272574067,
-0.1663583219,
-0.1480055004,
0.0936283916,
-0.5788997412,
-0.0358955115,
-0.0641313419,
0.4312704504,
-0.3988158405,
0.8425001502,
-0.0012501944,
0.523887217,
-0.1186515093,
-0.2047450393,
0.2262495756,
-0.5157199502,
-0.2786061466,
0.3067551553,
0.7677946091,
0.235969767,
-0.2055427134,
-0.1699772179,
0.1550494879,
0.1386903673,
0.1342367828,
-0.9159062505,
-0.3259912729,
0.5014605522,
-0.827983439,
0.1840954572,
0.1453773528,
-1.2157315016,
-0.3238274455,
-0.3569880426,
0.162701875,
-0.2305188626,
0.0009111392,
0.1703116745,
-0.5077365637,
-0.1124476716,
0.1342695653,
-0.6746272445,
0.6387287974,
0.4416506886,
0.871850431,
0.0163847562,
0.0735916346,
-0.6345992088,
0.2304961383,
0.0208143014,
0.7554880977,
-0.5343075991,
-0.5030646324,
0.2688956559,
0.0317532606,
-0.3838258088,
-0.3093470037,
1.072360754,
-0.2881769538,
0.4952559471,
-0.2026388645,
-0.8966000676,
0.127169624,
-0.1253355294,
-1.00639534,
0.8776334524,
-0.108846955,
-1.1153993607,
0.5432105064,
-0.4728262424,
-0.9660933614,
-0.1609683633,
-0.4034206271,
-0.9945888519,
0.1586290002,
0.0877003744,
0.2718848884,
-0.6314240098,
0.5664906502,
-0.4284855425,
-0.1132164821,
0.1525964588,
-0.1548597813,
0.5484037995,
0.0501732565,
-0.3545076251,
0.0053435895,
-0.8336705565,
-0.2148696184,
0.0363480523,
-0.1361316592,
-0.7502003908,
0.4135667086,
0.361441493,
-0.0118688159,
-0.1612820774,
-0.4155214429,
-0.1476469785,
-0.0650630966,
0.0894556791,
0.1056299657,
0.383949548,
0.3438794017,
-0.5054552555,
0.3655830622,
-0.1533945948,
0.1425749213,
-0.2502014339,
-0.6833177209,
-0.0324865878,
-0.3603124917,
0.1756824702,
0.4820595682,
-0.4933055341,
0.0955351219,
-0.1650001258,
-0.0524970666,
-0.4256849587,
-0.2792313695,
0.4410603046,
0.8643408418,
0.5813302994,
-0.086781837,
-0.6546421647,
-0.8686472178,
-0.5044338703,
-0.0870924667,
-0.3202110827,
0.2546782196,
0.4320504367,
-0.2466237843,
0.8792542219,
-0.6408591866,
-0.5419062972,
-0.1474845111,
0.2903108895,
0.0558095574,
0.6165085435,
0.2127370387,
-1.1635839939,
-0.3951154649,
0.0312654674,
-0.9704295993,
-0.3778497577,
-0.3016670942,
0.0447235219,
-0.3232227564,
0.6271317005,
-0.1676300466,
0.5952166319,
0.3318202198,
-0.502288878,
0.1596235484,
-0.437928915,
0.5826998949,
-0.6789950728,
0.3836326003,
0.2442229539,
-0.0373999774,
-1.0177263021,
-0.4463386536,
0.0545805767,
0.0728539005,
0.2296212316,
0.5464935899,
-0.2071390301,
0.3905887604,
-0.1504376084,
-0.0440216437,
0.0555711724,
-0.0187566075,
0.1366795748,
0.1889205724,
-0.1483707577,
-0.2813136876,
-0.3571718335,
0.5079202056,
0.0617484041,
0.6729832888,
-0.9526410103,
-0.1880518198,
-0.4421449602,
0.1775136888,
-0.7926498055,
-0.52854532,
0.2584101558,
-0.3759208322,
0.0145078981,
-0.154526189,
-0.4455215335,
-0.2856221497,
-0.3422549367,
0.2529007196,
0.1691235155,
0.0307088699,
0.4764583111,
0.5325672626,
-0.2619959116,
-0.1321363449,
-0.7262943983,
-0.0587559678,
-0.4625212848,
-0.3174466491,
0.5600162148,
-0.0315219201,
-0.3636402488,
0.3006797135,
0.1004704461,
-0.5789321661,
-0.0904472768,
0.3586914837,
0.3519897461,
-0.1594288647,
0.3972604275,
0.4281685352,
-0.0248448011,
0.274205476,
-0.0951376855,
-0.071303077,
0.4746696651,
-0.3724471927,
-0.6013398767,
0.7542884946,
0.355425179,
-0.0400431007,
0.7955446243,
0.1203327402,
-0.8050162196,
0.1197128445,
-0.3881555796,
-0.1235925481,
-0.2675698996,
0.1143373027,
0.0850210264,
-0.6006056666,
0.3195504248,
0.0868917555,
0.0660568029,
0.4969679117,
0.3969046772,
0.0817429796,
0.8372030854,
0.7699875832,
0.0683234856,
0.5181338191,
0.4421851933,
0.0182788409,
-0.61910218,
-0.475001961,
-0.9056301713,
0.0462135114,
-0.8078562021,
-0.2502018213,
0.5578724146,
0.0715668947,
-0.2542361915,
-0.0972219706,
-0.1764517277,
0.1726670116,
0.2381328642,
0.7185575962,
0.8002243042,
-0.0566147566,
0.1846114844,
-0.3377641737,
-0.5784276724,
-0.4806701839,
1.2108843327,
0.0800431296,
0.4575054646,
-0.0529310107,
0.4586004615,
0.4804926217,
0.6064016223,
-0.4098599255,
-0.1252145618,
-0.0787393898,
-0.6801039577,
-0.294385165,
-0.5666298866,
-1.2200897932,
0.2745119929,
-0.3552401066,
-0.5226050019,
0.1209583804,
0.346589148,
-0.2216228545,
0.0004511659,
-0.6490108371,
0.8852010369,
-0.0709194168,
-0.3053496778,
-0.0164713506,
-0.9825929403,
0.4059081376,
-0.3244993687,
0.4019677341,
0.1652576476,
0.0967405811,
0.7965766788,
-0.4328354001,
0.6843100786,
0.0281645134,
0.1078808457,
0.1500596106,
-0.4429257214,
0.3822708428,
0.2217082828,
-0.020720996,
0.0808470771,
0.0733738318,
-0.5352452993,
-0.5766308904,
0.4654068947,
-0.2439204454,
-0.0843737274,
-0.3669532239,
-0.1851140261,
-0.1401697546,
0.4106526077,
0.089772813,
0.4849642515,
-0.3330198228,
-0.0553318001,
0.5443461537,
-0.2998628318,
0.121486336,
0.4177712798,
0.2108079642,
-0.4825686216,
0.3186232448,
-0.1173960343,
0.160076946,
0.6641034484,
0.5513328314,
-0.1510375887,
-0.4994680285,
-0.1915710866,
0.2809116542,
-0.3924481571,
-0.1343040466,
-0.7916556001,
0.2815507948,
-0.2261704057,
-0.0056483252,
0.0305520315,
-0.0109249316,
-0.3037818372,
0.0644363761,
0.349304527,
0.7021653652,
0.0984688848,
0.3289752901,
-0.9663065672,
0.5489560962,
0.0073776757,
0.2358778566,
0.085898675,
-0.1169787943,
-0.4314824641,
-0.0127235912,
-0.1242348775,
-1.0357728004,
0.2345757186,
0.1675250828,
0.4141795635,
0.2309400886,
0.022170417,
0.8114467859,
-0.8060632944,
0.3375867605,
0.3013614118,
-0.6133577228,
0.8374378681,
-0.3453744352,
0.0423891544,
0.7172839046,
0.4200947285,
-0.7324827313,
-0.1710320413,
-0.6471732259,
-0.8397125006,
0.4179506004,
0.4448045492,
-0.565718472,
-0.052369304,
0.4074265361,
0.041880291,
0.1953100562,
-0.3367542624,
-0.4564433694,
0.1930382103,
-0.4919412732,
-0.0599924028,
0.0651498213,
-0.3148938417,
-0.0081747025,
0.2898236215,
-0.0934818909,
0.2337103635,
0.8059056997,
-0.0929817036,
-0.272405684,
0.2884562314,
0.3513861001,
0.4257866442,
-0.2044965923,
0.1484543681,
-0.2160277218,
-0.6864275932,
-0.1654388607,
0.4459744096,
-0.2034968734,
0.1425465792,
0.7660315037,
0.5000784993,
0.4417035878,
-0.6510065794,
0.4768973887,
-0.1597746611,
0.1691086441,
-0.1985344887,
-0.4225024879,
-0.1640014797,
0.1470118016,
0.1777258664,
-0.1668727249,
0.5517721772,
-0.3693297207,
0.615599215,
0.1586613208,
-0.6416658759,
-0.4927302301,
0.9339109659,
0.0286946781,
-0.2571952641,
0.3668421209,
0.4462855756,
0.022886252,
0.8355872631,
0.6916202307,
0.6050539613,
0.0561272129,
0.2485875189,
0.3725216687,
0.202697739,
-0.4119023383,
0.3198918998,
0.337393254,
-0.2167372406,
-0.6121720076,
-0.2009671926,
-0.4875607491,
-0.1536006182,
-0.7763626575,
0.3225286603,
-0.0420183577,
-0.1307243407,
0.1842784137,
-0.1980208755,
-0.6267507672,
0.1839247644,
-0.1242509708,
0.5642190576,
-1.1151531935,
0.6347885728,
0.5385305285,
-0.465462625,
-0.5471050143,
0.0785453916,
0.380636394,
-0.2409932315,
0.3511159718,
-0.0966532454,
0.2465384156,
-0.3013876081,
-0.2931669354,
-0.51491189,
0.8285329342,
0.1624494344,
-0.4504416585,
0.1235846505,
0.1345500499,
0.6940734386,
-0.0942867622,
0.3824236095,
0.6823946238,
0.4600579739,
0.0088365292,
-0.7595253587,
0.3046404719,
-0.0569358468,
-0.3038204014,
0.6363456249,
-0.1553251743,
0.6844623089,
-0.2767361999,
-0.1731321514,
-0.0204421729,
0.5168573856,
0.1433402747,
0.9335532188,
0.0802225769,
0.3928500414,
1.0866565704,
0.2159148157,
1.1176301241,
0.1630223244,
0.473351419,
1.226421833,
-0.4024940431,
0.5710501671,
0.5614075065,
-0.3732397258,
0.5461262465,
0.3189218044,
0.2595385015,
0.4706681967,
-0.0422984324,
-0.3258470595,
0.24561055,
-0.3112182319,
-0.3670330942,
-0.0303864349,
0.268558979,
-0.4941814542,
-0.1493905485,
0.0262195244,
0.2937023044,
0.2137168944,
-0.0769037679,
0.6739486456,
0.2479418814,
-0.4915106595,
-0.1707234383,
-0.1529947072,
0.2604716122,
-0.6801690459,
-0.5487507582,
-0.1692715734,
0.078169398,
-0.4096666276,
-0.3464179635,
0.4817224741,
-0.0328630991,
-0.3273642659,
-0.0406617895,
0.969638288,
-0.4217018187,
-0.3442552388,
0.2791226208,
0.4698900878,
-0.1283905059,
0.1459295005,
-0.272436142,
-0.2807565033,
-0.177188307,
-0.062319681,
0.1809140593,
0.7942485213,
-0.2287347168,
0.1245142594,
0.7267576456,
0.4250429273,
-0.3288048804,
0.1442987323,
0.6046614647,
-0.9060487747,
-0.3526695967,
-1.0403680801,
0.6125352383,
-0.3563792408,
-0.4767965376,
0.9243667722,
0.5305276513,
0.4350187182,
0.1318867207,
0.7827629447,
-0.2295835465,
0.65906322,
-0.6042463779,
0.3930596411,
-0.4805263877,
0.087604858,
-0.4688613117,
-0.2084185481,
-0.8628299236,
0.1857519448,
-0.1387501508,
-0.2958121896,
0.9499751329,
0.1387162656,
0.1476521045,
0.3285138905,
-0.0511507653,
0.1480060667,
0.3958414495,
0.307066232,
0.3127559721,
-0.6451802254,
-0.0107262479,
-0.0700939894,
-0.4764808714,
-0.1036352143,
-0.9229494929,
-0.7433258295,
-0.3340169191,
-0.288025558,
-0.3087137938,
0.0281036813,
0.8173495531,
0.2620659769,
-0.7789507508,
-0.0437146015,
-0.1469322443,
0.404099822,
-0.3464272618,
-0.1601846665,
0.6960812211,
-0.0972289741,
-0.5123557448,
0.064976126,
0.2597811818,
-0.0674396679,
0.4167101383,
0.117345944,
-0.2319031805,
-0.1381985992,
0.614287436,
0.4223769605,
-0.1360615939,
0.0530043989,
0.0188024584,
-0.0854060501,
0.1094227061,
1.4911938906,
-0.6182022095,
0.4762935042,
0.4527985454,
0.7092189193,
0.3784889877,
-0.014801194,
0.5682553053,
-0.3466711938,
-0.1074718684,
0.2667826712,
0.3745624721,
0.2454073876,
-0.3474678099,
0.409201026,
0.2544753551,
-0.7003314495,
-0.6314243078,
-0.1569259316,
-0.6003035903,
-0.2238638252,
0.9589637518,
0.0392509252,
0.0679657832,
-0.6466360092,
-0.1292365044,
0.4472318888,
-0.3655681908,
0.7916899323,
0.3898864985,
-0.4573385417,
0.2748833895,
-1.0193566084,
0.5192514062,
0.2219858468,
-1.3682777882,
-0.0597922392,
0.5851509571,
0.0147363283,
-0.1892110854,
1.0725660324,
-0.3155866861,
0.0539163388,
-0.1737798154,
-0.2525158525,
0.5819552541,
-0.2459814996,
-0.4939315915,
0.0656323656,
-0.3893389404,
-0.051621262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07941v1 | GPT-Calls: Enhancing Call Segmentation and Tagging by Generating Synthetic Conversations via Large Language Models | 2023-06-09T15:47:22 | 2023-06-09T15:47:22 | Itzik Malkiel, Uri Alon, Yakir Yehuda, Shahar Keren, Oren Barkan, Royi Ronen, Noam Koenigstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Transcriptions of phone calls are of significant value across diverse fields,
such as sales, customer service, healthcare, and law enforcement. Nevertheless,
the analysis of these recorded conversations can be an arduous and
time-intensive process, especially when dealing with extended or multifaceted
dialogues. In this work, we propose a novel method, GPT-distilled Calls
Segmentation and Tagging (GPT-Calls), for efficient and accurate call
segmentation and topic extraction. GPT-Calls is composed of offline and online
phases. The offline phase is applied once to a given list of topics and
involves generating a distribution of synthetic sentences for each topic using
a GPT model and extracting anchor vectors. The online phase is applied to every
call separately and scores the similarity between the transcripted conversation
and the topic anchors found in the offline phase. Then, time domain analysis is
applied to the similarity scores to group utterances into segments and tag them
with topics. The proposed paradigm provides an accurate and efficient method
for call segmentation and topic extraction that does not require labeled data,
thus making it a versatile approach applicable to various domains. Our
algorithm operates in production under Dynamics 365 Sales Conversation
Intelligence, and our research is based on real sales conversations gathered
from various Dynamics 365 Sales tenants. | [
-0.4668982327,
-1.4001477957,
0.3804560006,
0.1309275031,
-0.4876581728,
0.6929442286,
-0.1265611053,
-0.5395691395,
0.2931417227,
0.2462801486,
-0.7239342332,
-0.5660455823,
-0.02751345,
-0.2197109759,
-0.1143074706,
0.8193244934,
0.3808439672,
0.24161084,
-0.0230846461,
0.0339107662,
-0.5868558884,
-0.4691831768,
-0.6347362995,
-0.0668778643,
0.1493780762,
-0.0733464137,
0.4344370663,
0.5871226192,
0.1220385432,
0.3820272386,
-0.1446382552,
0.427734971,
-0.118206203,
0.1476409137,
-0.2109459043,
-0.1505457163,
-0.7923035026,
0.1366658062,
0.3943443596,
0.4645883441,
-0.3367080092,
0.0085341362,
-0.1355562806,
0.0884884372,
-0.0375793912,
0.2958010733,
-0.8861050606,
-0.102032721,
-0.0114666428,
-0.5090562701,
-0.2285918146,
-0.3057619333,
0.6602481008,
-0.2617763579,
0.4746125638,
-0.4239023924,
1.0415427685,
-0.0453523844,
-0.1966572106,
-0.4970983565,
-0.8247864842,
0.833152771,
-0.5870804191,
0.1426927745,
0.2064370662,
0.2383487523,
-0.0957319736,
-0.6602676511,
-0.4442307651,
-0.3854453266,
0.0087388456,
0.0767306983,
-0.2878525257,
0.1824868619,
0.2748977542,
0.2636676133,
-0.4352079034,
-0.2367812842,
-0.3940620422,
-0.0759818926,
0.6074867249,
0.1036639288,
0.4390492141,
-0.0669441372,
-0.2430178076,
0.2437509298,
-0.2262431979,
-0.2385928929,
0.3266158402,
0.5254439116,
0.2204966396,
0.278459549,
-0.2656918466,
0.921014905,
0.0775883421,
-0.6869986653,
0.1337162107,
-0.321770221,
-0.109964326,
0.1707794368,
0.5720553398,
0.5726146102,
0.1134420857,
-0.2592937946,
0.1982561946,
-0.0633210912,
0.265239656,
-0.9678672552,
-0.0675770938,
0.322866559,
-0.3043223023,
-0.0021315021,
0.1640985459,
-0.8433325291,
-0.0981809795,
-0.621794045,
0.2359957695,
-0.3374090195,
-0.2990407944,
-0.0825294778,
-0.0361283831,
0.2999152541,
0.2996109724,
-0.5294393897,
0.3687235713,
0.7144524455,
1.0530308485,
-0.2513237,
0.2808842659,
-0.5951296687,
0.134008497,
-0.0135993389,
0.6564577222,
-0.5957899094,
-0.6692588329,
-0.3026530147,
-0.1821229011,
-0.2069620937,
-0.5533736348,
0.2279289961,
-0.5664381981,
0.3164391518,
0.1211626604,
-0.5303171873,
0.0953088105,
0.5337255001,
-0.1985862106,
0.8450806737,
0.0614217818,
-0.4354403913,
0.4597060084,
-0.9239751101,
-0.3785336912,
0.4651633799,
-0.2237182409,
-0.5354459882,
-0.2016216516,
0.2801371217,
0.3757316172,
-0.34325701,
0.4800053835,
-0.1175632551,
-0.0319221318,
0.2412346601,
-0.1467648894,
0.5006506443,
0.4531851113,
-0.5115027428,
0.1830959767,
-0.6160788536,
0.2467492372,
0.1252061576,
-0.043535769,
-0.286852926,
0.0470077395,
-0.1726492643,
0.0610851906,
-0.086374253,
-0.7520260811,
0.4583428502,
-0.2167430669,
0.6432077885,
0.222907111,
0.2663959861,
0.2531272173,
-0.094449386,
0.4688256383,
-0.1733392328,
0.1230292022,
-0.2203458548,
-0.6911060214,
-0.5792707801,
-0.7335003614,
0.5735296607,
0.7143919468,
-0.7321804762,
0.5293585658,
-0.479167074,
-0.6835571527,
-0.3107181191,
-0.3540709913,
0.1557576358,
0.4955609739,
0.3730018139,
-0.2874410152,
-0.3565505147,
-0.740411818,
-0.1661742777,
-0.1952889711,
0.0984089971,
0.3372456133,
-0.0254937727,
-0.2744031847,
1.5960323811,
-0.9400830865,
-0.318379283,
-0.2585407197,
0.312740624,
0.1865912974,
0.364218235,
0.3923661709,
-0.9803783894,
-0.7373722792,
-0.1307186037,
0.0181528777,
-0.1453652531,
-0.4194148183,
-0.0635799617,
0.0235825982,
0.2827147841,
-0.5677140355,
0.4942900836,
-0.013369848,
-0.0299648345,
0.2004021108,
-0.134531945,
0.1155553758,
-1.3217583895,
-0.1436364949,
0.2048743814,
-0.4056318402,
-0.8809939623,
-0.4693788886,
-0.3979272544,
-0.4611673951,
-0.3909094334,
0.1953234524,
-0.5509639978,
-0.1734137982,
-0.441444546,
-0.00341624,
-0.2938516438,
0.3520064056,
0.2323644459,
0.8794129491,
0.4114469588,
-0.4994234443,
0.588698864,
0.4972900152,
-0.308984071,
0.3200082481,
-0.5883312225,
0.5138224959,
0.2637118399,
0.3424822688,
-1.0908317566,
0.079107061,
0.4487134814,
-0.2819360197,
0.1918075979,
-0.7411209941,
-0.4103338122,
-0.1709009409,
-0.1525854915,
0.1839681715,
0.3999705911,
-0.1371433884,
0.5664903522,
0.8247410059,
-0.789573431,
-0.0722774863,
-0.307040751,
0.0976578444,
-0.550355792,
-0.4949690104,
0.6210634708,
0.2032121867,
-0.2527247667,
-0.1875372231,
-0.0629503056,
-0.4428407252,
-0.0564636923,
0.2804910839,
0.3751866519,
-0.0366144218,
0.0492350981,
-0.0272001699,
-0.1964008361,
-0.0958773866,
-0.4976849854,
0.9388802052,
0.0917693451,
-0.3278375566,
-0.4239985645,
0.7490189672,
0.4212654531,
-0.3887662292,
0.3580573201,
0.6437156796,
-0.2329287529,
-0.2857302725,
-0.4753284156,
-0.1236038208,
-0.5078104734,
0.2790286839,
-0.4102538824,
-0.9270932078,
0.3858809173,
-0.2763395905,
-0.0621845946,
0.2785819471,
0.5735095143,
0.2176602036,
0.8735573292,
0.3318635523,
0.0079006944,
0.7759132981,
-0.162302047,
0.5736943483,
-0.368632406,
-0.1244836152,
-0.2840691805,
0.0561989024,
-0.6939659715,
-0.7062956691,
0.404702872,
-0.0705261603,
0.2345336825,
0.4538360834,
-0.6542071104,
0.5607026815,
0.4641781747,
0.0416757353,
0.2570106983,
0.2399868965,
0.326705724,
-0.1567997187,
-0.3450021446,
-0.5146059394,
0.7265881896,
0.3301841915,
0.5067774653,
-0.1699967682,
0.5896647573,
0.3627907932,
0.2809085846,
-1.0354100466,
0.7081384063,
0.2304245383,
-0.5949203372,
-0.1384910643,
-0.5825408697,
-0.6641928554,
0.3218902349,
0.220654875,
-1.1743127108,
-0.1257092357,
-0.0155448746,
-0.8209398389,
0.2263725996,
-0.8432397246,
0.5925415754,
-0.2346717715,
-0.2326456904,
-0.1627732068,
-0.6130296588,
-0.0371186435,
-0.1282863617,
-0.0830055848,
-0.4775284529,
0.4991492927,
0.8152118325,
-0.6116015911,
0.7723093033,
-0.4004466236,
-0.3579617143,
0.9342787266,
-0.2595160604,
0.2921770215,
0.1694055498,
0.3428339064,
0.0101970201,
0.2079286575,
-0.1035192907,
-0.41119048,
0.5805582404,
-0.3510583639,
-0.7519034147,
-0.4134690464,
-0.2571007311,
-0.4691775143,
-0.0076588369,
-0.0871359855,
0.780846715,
-0.2842318714,
-0.2726165354,
0.21724765,
-0.1786726713,
0.5916571617,
0.4655683041,
-0.1736190915,
-0.4163054526,
1.26299119,
0.2463682145,
0.1516338438,
0.1915533394,
0.1517643481,
-0.8056818843,
-0.6434189677,
-0.2892411947,
0.2394813597,
-0.4250097275,
-0.2501736581,
-1.0565011501,
0.0085855387,
-0.4056004286,
0.3541466296,
-0.3502215743,
-0.3910143673,
-0.0660535619,
-0.0616676696,
0.4112399817,
0.3178245127,
0.1524418741,
0.4602742493,
-1.1314567327,
0.4439625442,
0.4866385758,
0.096933119,
-0.2670901418,
-0.1976674646,
-0.003506043,
0.2722559869,
-0.5690619349,
-0.870275557,
0.5804062486,
0.2375732511,
0.4577274919,
0.2049042732,
0.134183526,
1.04753232,
-0.6494284868,
0.7807571888,
-0.0028346262,
-1.1918270588,
0.6121254563,
-0.6497440338,
-0.2054626197,
0.5164467692,
0.2051982731,
-0.4194138348,
0.0062193233,
-0.7621636987,
-0.9884964824,
0.8114124537,
0.2034441978,
0.3386962116,
-0.1071913242,
0.0744982064,
0.0816141963,
0.1748278439,
-0.2567922473,
-0.2343069017,
0.0498921089,
0.2081657648,
0.2647307515,
-0.1912621558,
-0.2014371753,
-0.36109519,
0.414506346,
-0.1245146543,
0.6070058942,
0.2762044966,
0.0505166501,
0.3175191581,
0.4915948212,
0.6849256158,
0.8728531003,
-0.3227750361,
-0.2912097573,
0.2713623643,
-0.4363219738,
0.1657675654,
0.3551559448,
0.2009986043,
0.3058480918,
-0.0934162065,
0.5685373545,
-0.3016891181,
-0.5334113836,
0.2726653814,
0.0533447191,
-0.0211980212,
-0.3783403933,
-0.1388697028,
-0.0656163394,
0.2383762598,
0.4754430652,
-0.3176607192,
0.2297305614,
-0.7379461527,
0.6036823392,
0.3586778343,
-0.402243793,
-0.2348616421,
0.189686209,
0.6114547849,
-0.4149320722,
0.4444137812,
-0.3532764316,
-0.8597632051,
0.3234084547,
0.3509919345,
0.9085898399,
-0.2440418452,
0.6830162406,
0.0598430149,
-0.4349513948,
0.0817664638,
0.158619523,
-0.2602687478,
-0.6333511472,
-0.7386586666,
-0.4900148809,
-0.5012429953,
0.2519720495,
-0.5802251101,
0.0182218887,
-0.2189963609,
-0.5636498332,
0.2855961621,
0.1241096258,
-0.0622804463,
0.1617694497,
0.2386490256,
0.5808956623,
-0.4652972519,
0.9651674628,
0.5220144987,
0.0544720255,
-0.6964170933,
0.165161401,
0.0039891405,
-0.3762620091,
0.7206239104,
0.3366917968,
-0.2134067267,
0.2172898948,
-0.1474074274,
-0.2451940179,
0.9535157681,
0.1189310998,
-0.4125428796,
-0.0412038341,
0.3891539872,
0.3320244253,
-0.4645722806,
0.3097547293,
0.6578753591,
0.1965022683,
0.3328421414,
-1.0665881634,
-0.1210051924,
-0.1315112412,
-0.1793614626,
0.5430967808,
-0.7081872225,
0.6292356849,
0.0645973459,
-0.4868451357,
0.0112156719,
0.3922400475,
-0.133730039,
0.2459048778,
0.6361441016,
0.3443743587,
0.5820587277,
-0.4197152555,
0.8117904663,
0.1269373447,
0.6233551502,
1.1545274258,
-0.5284467936,
0.3657335937,
0.3447919786,
-0.1536180526,
0.0061264993,
0.7483093739,
-0.2165166885,
0.7396903634,
0.6303339005,
-0.4614698887,
-0.2816999853,
-0.2783266306,
-0.4281631708,
0.6674012542,
0.4001422822,
-0.0764569864,
-0.5167411566,
-0.1980228275,
0.0123398434,
-0.3238998652,
0.061176125,
1.0239981413,
-0.0982711837,
-0.523447454,
0.3859674037,
0.1039448828,
0.4024865329,
-0.5729289055,
-0.2488023192,
-0.0936314762,
0.2264970392,
0.0166739784,
-0.3065901995,
0.4985951185,
0.1604635864,
0.1803119928,
-0.3200724423,
0.6875305176,
-0.6810378432,
0.0056028981,
0.0978316441,
0.7103788853,
0.1155157834,
-0.5132002234,
-0.9478721023,
0.0963352621,
0.2647223771,
-0.0469580553,
0.0582797974,
0.2836550474,
-0.1543036848,
0.4989962578,
0.7965002656,
0.0098477248,
-0.0189857855,
0.0724168792,
1.0787830353,
-0.6923734546,
-0.7007178068,
-0.9756233692,
0.6530621648,
-0.5460106134,
-0.4538652301,
0.6145346165,
0.8574649096,
0.5715034604,
-0.0816714838,
0.8106104136,
-0.0631158799,
0.6411064863,
-0.4857375026,
0.6453210711,
0.0218683016,
0.1623919606,
-0.4709742367,
-1.1341650486,
-0.1259479225,
0.4875226319,
-0.6068665981,
-0.1396912336,
0.3447142839,
0.707680583,
-0.2170899957,
0.2884699106,
0.1896470189,
-0.3722495139,
0.8506048322,
0.0385797918,
1.2795250416,
-0.25913167,
0.5031314492,
0.0008717577,
-0.1788520068,
-0.1446076185,
-0.6718742251,
-0.9289873242,
-0.6207121611,
-0.7656488419,
-0.1591618955,
0.0626979545,
1.1060545444,
1.0444293022,
-0.6914200783,
-0.1737837046,
0.0575741343,
-0.3935303986,
0.0927534625,
-0.2829704285,
0.4732504189,
-0.2779667079,
-1.0052579641,
0.6804661751,
0.2483747452,
0.3622366488,
0.38078776,
0.3033404648,
-0.1547864228,
-0.0714559704,
0.4551018476,
0.1608750373,
-0.4582147002,
-0.057307072,
-0.174715057,
0.1534181535,
0.2197651416,
1.2825787067,
-0.4172415435,
0.4269498587,
0.282925725,
0.7677369714,
0.7481369376,
0.6561412215,
0.7716963291,
-0.8841170669,
0.3330375254,
0.3530575633,
0.0588540807,
0.4161196947,
-0.1808714271,
0.4394640625,
0.4973163903,
-0.147465229,
-0.765157342,
0.4276596904,
-1.2826658487,
-0.1020308733,
1.160377264,
-0.4167672396,
0.1191551834,
-0.4031480849,
-0.7439426184,
0.3382876813,
-0.6173709035,
0.5094643831,
0.5243679881,
-0.3319070637,
-0.0430305153,
-0.4217639267,
0.5085551739,
0.0294000581,
-0.9899133444,
0.0973901525,
0.4174125195,
0.2353187203,
0.5160810947,
0.4480610192,
-0.1816805601,
-0.3578222096,
-0.2320108563,
-0.4623999596,
-0.1394313723,
-0.023122238,
0.0975501835,
0.3135070205,
-0.3200814426,
-0.8750471473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07933v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07933v1 | Understanding Telecom Language Through Large Language Models | 2023-06-09T15:44:41 | 2023-06-09T15:44:41 | Lina Bariah, Hang Zou, Qiyang Zhao, Belkacem Mouhouche, Faouzi Bader, Merouane Debbah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent progress of artificial intelligence (AI) opens up new frontiers in
the possibility of automating many tasks involved in Telecom networks design,
implementation, and deployment. This has been further pushed forward with the
evolution of generative artificial intelligence (AI), including the emergence
of large language models (LLMs), which is believed to be the cornerstone toward
realizing self-governed, interactive AI agents. Motivated by this, in this
paper, we aim to adapt the paradigm of LLMs to the Telecom domain. In
particular, we fine-tune several LLMs including BERT, distilled BERT, RoBERTa
and GPT-2, to the Telecom domain languages, and demonstrate a use case for
identifying the 3rd Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) standard working
groups. We consider training the selected models on 3GPP technical documents
(Tdoc) pertinent to years 2009-2019 and predict the Tdoc categories in years
2020-2023. The results demonstrate that fine-tuning BERT and RoBERTa model
achieves 84.6% accuracy, while GPT-2 model achieves 83% in identifying 3GPP
working groups. The distilled BERT model with around 50% less parameters
achieves similar performance as others. This corroborates that fine-tuning
pretrained LLM can effectively identify the categories of Telecom language. The
developed framework shows a stepping stone towards realizing intent-driven and
self-evolving wireless networks from Telecom languages, and paves the way for
the implementation of generative AI in the Telecom domain. | [
-0.4974197745,
-0.6959555745,
0.4808968604,
0.1271024197,
-0.1967486888,
-0.1171629652,
-0.3818410039,
-0.6925491095,
-0.1585337073,
0.712500155,
-0.3978413641,
-0.1750388294,
-0.5325141549,
0.1947611123,
-0.181851685,
0.6906268597,
0.0359243564,
0.0170253124,
0.4983008802,
0.0184933376,
-0.3844430745,
-0.4662632048,
-0.7295758724,
-0.8137927651,
0.1536102891,
0.2595386207,
0.7035154104,
0.3913371265,
0.1802109033,
0.4026497006,
-0.1479966491,
0.1137735993,
-0.3511429131,
-0.4600189924,
0.0845764279,
-0.5665177107,
-0.4669116735,
0.1229970604,
0.537328124,
0.7399115562,
-0.29251194,
0.0318836085,
0.131754443,
0.7512302995,
-0.0143254586,
0.3918026388,
-1.0753487349,
-0.0215803664,
-0.1675922126,
-0.24182643,
-0.5777073503,
-0.1606846601,
0.4014241099,
-0.551310122,
0.1077977344,
-0.0996253788,
0.8984701037,
0.1932007074,
-0.5584157705,
-0.3983019888,
-0.8801817894,
0.8446469903,
-0.8619468808,
0.4315217137,
0.3574943542,
0.4446924329,
-0.3095364571,
-0.5980929136,
-0.6958994269,
-0.3276804984,
0.3685013056,
0.0024664379,
-0.1653515399,
0.1365962476,
0.0607169829,
0.3093212545,
-0.2501315773,
0.5605300665,
-0.5959554911,
0.0021852192,
0.6009738445,
-0.0867918059,
0.1186343357,
0.1821251512,
-0.1967623234,
0.5192833543,
-0.8140571713,
-0.3911669552,
0.2477201521,
0.3257691562,
-0.3022921383,
0.5131406784,
-0.1357557476,
0.9618864059,
-0.0447580591,
0.0537164807,
0.1622615904,
-0.0111265127,
-0.5750020742,
-0.0596091412,
0.6775387526,
-0.0898671746,
0.9254481196,
-0.2461132109,
-0.0101278443,
-0.3010876477,
0.2956660986,
-0.5038474798,
-0.309795469,
0.0540346056,
-0.7833368778,
-0.2270167768,
-0.2753571868,
-0.2781985104,
-0.0979231447,
-0.5533732772,
0.1881996095,
-0.3912688494,
-0.4559892416,
0.4635924697,
0.2976038754,
0.6599801779,
0.4739180505,
-1.0324600935,
0.0462001078,
0.8545268178,
0.695530355,
0.1615286469,
-0.3671072721,
-0.1919121444,
0.3150699139,
-0.2814562023,
0.468600899,
-0.3348270059,
-0.2950550914,
0.1355431825,
-0.1245221943,
-0.0280180424,
-0.5186206698,
0.4188694358,
-1.0314868689,
0.1551813781,
0.483215034,
-0.4539111257,
-0.2915979922,
0.0216329508,
-0.5968294144,
0.6287401915,
0.0541567728,
-0.3433333933,
0.1712408215,
-0.7918971777,
-0.3198363185,
0.1987478435,
0.1408068836,
-0.4295775294,
0.2205181122,
-0.0108376835,
0.4951789975,
-0.5032073259,
0.232923314,
-0.4325955808,
-0.0918600559,
0.1675950736,
-0.2934867442,
1.0700155497,
0.482627809,
-0.2574944198,
-0.1485715359,
-0.6514950991,
0.4126284719,
-0.1538923532,
-0.2064372599,
-0.1358140558,
0.3068858087,
-0.0981192961,
0.4063656628,
0.1949676871,
-0.4402152896,
0.1345083565,
-0.5107283592,
0.9684383273,
0.768633306,
-0.3524222374,
0.4311634898,
0.0016399184,
0.2525931299,
-0.0335900746,
0.2457920164,
0.0630169809,
-0.5355608463,
-0.913941741,
0.0283033252,
0.3794812858,
0.3561056554,
-0.770681262,
0.4439021051,
-0.4142565131,
-0.5194928646,
-0.3185395002,
0.3143228292,
0.0289795976,
0.2952413559,
0.3765148222,
0.0780261979,
-0.337751776,
-1.0002795458,
-0.0473033153,
-0.4254277647,
-0.1009447202,
0.4187799394,
0.2457583398,
-0.4127079248,
0.8142901063,
-0.4299828112,
-0.4676813483,
-0.5652214885,
0.3510361314,
0.3876029849,
0.2574816048,
0.3920844793,
-0.9648677707,
-0.4958121479,
0.3297361135,
-0.5203478336,
-0.2194213867,
-0.0058384622,
0.3856246471,
0.1921033412,
0.5204253197,
-0.3404475451,
0.0275209006,
0.7898820639,
-0.2152952999,
0.3691419661,
-0.2465087473,
-0.3142489791,
-1.0852291584,
-0.32543841,
0.266374439,
-0.1794153452,
-0.6683253646,
-0.0819332153,
-0.0599014014,
-0.3331460357,
-0.5093102455,
0.3464045227,
-0.6210688949,
-0.2182012051,
-0.3508113623,
-0.1283525825,
-0.2541928291,
0.3816154003,
0.0288306829,
1.0657082796,
0.526992619,
-0.6786982417,
0.1269519478,
0.1921152025,
-0.4376354218,
0.0431367569,
-0.8553003669,
0.1459183097,
0.1059587747,
0.1922207773,
-0.4913998246,
-0.0550550371,
-0.2061386406,
-0.1603782177,
-0.0003163134,
-0.4805772901,
-0.5401116014,
-0.3025609851,
0.3518145382,
0.4650154114,
0.536708653,
-0.5712991953,
0.8809971213,
0.6376684904,
-0.0959051102,
-0.3291244805,
-0.4456748962,
0.3184443414,
-0.2764333785,
-0.7875906229,
0.3604713976,
0.163359493,
-0.0097996453,
-0.3927181661,
0.1591311395,
-0.5145264864,
0.26987046,
0.1378638744,
0.1270066798,
-0.3110462129,
-0.0177919213,
-0.4956112504,
-0.1434154958,
0.116347827,
-0.684373796,
0.6723789573,
-0.3644229472,
-0.1449147463,
-0.6419177651,
0.1714303941,
0.6219732761,
-0.4552975893,
0.2989444435,
0.5575650334,
-0.0342921391,
-0.4741839468,
-0.7086256146,
0.1151205674,
-0.5844569206,
0.4468880892,
-0.5006343722,
-1.0885382891,
0.4511801004,
-0.5003832579,
-0.1183801964,
0.3845083117,
0.6096865535,
-0.0061531672,
0.982829988,
1.1125890017,
-0.3828671575,
0.5570352674,
-0.296204567,
0.3246673644,
-0.7444466352,
-0.1369731724,
-0.6423739791,
0.0251976904,
-0.8002850413,
-0.2833329439,
0.5331264734,
0.1645011008,
-0.1395457089,
0.5429383516,
-0.0973656848,
0.4814450145,
0.1753396988,
-0.0402089804,
0.1798354983,
-0.0047215684,
0.0927252471,
0.3002324104,
-0.5787127614,
-0.659978807,
1.050409317,
0.7336702943,
0.7770040631,
0.3152967393,
0.5484181643,
0.2503196299,
0.3130758107,
-0.8086641431,
0.5922627449,
-0.4020957947,
-0.384627521,
-0.3117569089,
-0.5669339895,
-0.8820053339,
-0.1205096841,
0.0935335681,
-0.8458718061,
0.0791228637,
0.003486587,
-0.1437361389,
0.1667256355,
-0.813416481,
0.5466275811,
-0.3113342822,
-0.1234268174,
-0.5483990312,
-0.2897694707,
0.288579613,
-0.3502255976,
0.1314498782,
-0.260725528,
-0.008009648,
0.4460318089,
-0.3972018361,
0.8301368356,
-0.1046144217,
-0.5061714649,
0.3014960885,
-0.2137525827,
0.3946254849,
-0.0178705361,
-0.6024790406,
0.6291723847,
-0.3591936231,
-0.2949469388,
-0.3514587283,
0.6172876358,
-1.0785776377,
-0.6014969945,
0.0065279561,
-0.5385349989,
-0.4076803923,
0.458419621,
-0.0690841004,
0.5044943094,
-0.1478929371,
0.1077783555,
0.75951612,
-0.1964428276,
0.72373873,
0.7318630815,
-0.0576310009,
-0.1692916453,
0.6074123383,
-0.1072473675,
0.4081742764,
0.2771550715,
0.035727419,
-0.4807147086,
-1.0008836985,
-0.392890662,
0.2019302696,
-0.4220716357,
-0.1969629526,
-0.6058835387,
-0.3907924294,
-0.1201126277,
-0.0479642712,
-0.2278931737,
-0.2761725485,
-0.3570127785,
0.3577003181,
0.0876670554,
0.8073569536,
0.1313406676,
0.6611557007,
-0.7614844441,
0.3655445874,
0.4125065207,
0.6728444099,
-0.1129725352,
-0.5701009631,
-0.3548052907,
0.0433615483,
-0.4108555317,
-0.6587003469,
0.3480427563,
0.4230336249,
0.5258972645,
0.1951272637,
-0.2964128256,
0.5797288418,
-0.7914037704,
0.7843503356,
0.1748577058,
-1.1551437378,
0.4000378549,
-0.6319162846,
-0.0058459355,
0.2488348335,
0.0696381852,
-0.2685425282,
-0.0509008206,
-0.5232394934,
-0.4567467272,
0.6670199037,
0.0634180829,
0.4589370191,
0.185764268,
0.4872597158,
-0.1789755672,
-0.0524884388,
-0.8995655179,
-0.0752130821,
-0.0424385853,
-0.1258763969,
-0.0553451106,
-0.2431044579,
-0.0649496913,
0.0156431366,
0.6705296636,
-0.1974161863,
0.3580832779,
-0.1179620177,
0.0727853179,
0.0459151715,
0.3959541917,
0.6092652678,
1.0004848242,
-0.0513002686,
-0.1906658858,
0.305460155,
-0.2020831406,
0.1934038401,
0.2342481464,
0.1133115739,
-0.0165898167,
0.2962366641,
0.5473335385,
-0.1131316721,
-0.4025930464,
0.4605354965,
0.1207360327,
-0.3167294562,
-0.6948245764,
0.2575474977,
0.0006442197,
0.333984077,
0.5441404581,
-0.1789667159,
0.0016377862,
-0.4918841422,
0.1496483088,
0.6353247166,
-0.3461827934,
-0.2618564665,
0.6801368594,
0.666043818,
-0.4367600083,
0.4766363502,
-0.0439378694,
-0.6694014668,
0.7930914164,
0.8145282269,
0.9343636632,
-0.0106936246,
0.2138538957,
-0.0310751963,
0.2454066724,
-0.1754341871,
0.2426168919,
0.0539338626,
-0.9081191421,
-0.7653238177,
-0.5293272138,
-0.2048248053,
0.4830711484,
-0.4261789918,
0.4882693291,
-0.3885148764,
-0.0822632015,
0.4397209883,
0.0327282324,
-0.7755256295,
0.2402854562,
0.103827931,
1.1162824631,
-0.6508070827,
1.454947114,
0.6413422227,
-0.0186168551,
-1.115527153,
0.2034856081,
-0.2845660746,
-1.1293889284,
1.101680398,
-0.0877240673,
-0.152784735,
0.4485213459,
-0.3911414146,
-0.6346430182,
0.9912233949,
0.0413700044,
-0.5398602486,
-0.0441896133,
0.4089311957,
0.4934745133,
-0.4543071389,
0.3399081528,
0.3408679962,
0.3170610666,
-0.1629930437,
-1.2803715467,
-0.3856212795,
-0.0587655082,
0.2985193133,
0.3481707871,
-0.8537741303,
0.7912501693,
-0.2132404298,
-0.0716234148,
0.064752534,
0.6843651533,
-0.2214708924,
0.1062540486,
0.7498174906,
0.3193657398,
0.1842808276,
-0.0745505542,
0.6635317206,
-0.3082970977,
0.2738801539,
0.8257360458,
-0.3593491316,
0.6994027495,
0.3655009568,
-0.1861172915,
0.490106672,
0.3666453362,
-0.1325728148,
0.4521774352,
0.2929474711,
-0.2304790318,
-0.2612844706,
0.0570474565,
-0.3722526431,
0.9693639874,
0.4854954779,
-0.3235171139,
-0.4311776459,
0.0032850609,
-0.0208313689,
0.0076848683,
-0.5489054918,
0.9331001043,
0.2122395635,
-0.539676249,
0.8391237855,
0.3332914114,
0.55443573,
-0.6441799402,
-0.0481611937,
0.0947776958,
0.354462713,
-0.0231011324,
-0.70633775,
0.2650710046,
-0.0068600019,
-0.1106183305,
-0.2872759104,
0.4416768849,
-0.2374500036,
-0.3571588993,
0.2446584255,
0.3730379045,
0.1353932023,
0.2103402615,
-0.843046844,
0.2676179111,
0.164472729,
0.1795874089,
0.0921908915,
0.7840261459,
0.1586272866,
0.8467447162,
0.5569489598,
0.3563324809,
-0.156167239,
0.1383054703,
0.83819139,
-0.4843239188,
-0.4010904431,
-0.7789366245,
0.2523275018,
-0.0843505636,
-0.4261919856,
0.5042487383,
0.3946346641,
0.8434117436,
-0.168405652,
0.9572200775,
0.0184835829,
0.1548232138,
-0.6935853362,
0.5856367946,
-0.4104294777,
0.5727846622,
-0.0856848806,
-0.7894957066,
-0.064336665,
0.484952122,
-0.5692579746,
0.009885476,
0.1280205697,
0.7176950574,
-0.2953828573,
0.2729850113,
0.2236070782,
0.1662224829,
0.5945630074,
0.6332293153,
0.8440899253,
-0.3312226236,
0.6213951707,
0.0293660574,
-0.3856355548,
-0.347858578,
-1.128629446,
-0.9809799194,
-0.5271973014,
-0.1558908522,
-0.2484699339,
0.1430580467,
0.7397970557,
0.9554258585,
-0.5793333054,
-0.4340825081,
-0.4217817783,
-0.0141805066,
-0.1125691831,
-0.1972221136,
0.1436534226,
-0.6257042885,
-0.7340595722,
0.289555639,
0.2505729198,
0.2226408422,
-0.3361171484,
-0.0673863366,
0.2020295262,
-0.0359689966,
0.7684623599,
0.3507626355,
-0.8694393039,
-0.3416944742,
-0.1403947026,
0.0058213221,
-0.1437054873,
0.9712526202,
-0.6144344211,
0.2586972117,
0.0757209957,
0.6735447645,
0.3433678746,
-0.1478286535,
0.9542617202,
-0.4050729275,
0.1273298711,
0.2661546469,
0.3416023254,
0.1870267689,
-0.2697651982,
0.6032127142,
-0.240751937,
-0.7989237905,
-0.633878231,
0.6593147516,
-0.9633867741,
-0.2086914033,
1.2902705669,
-0.0214971751,
0.2014420331,
-0.5214936733,
-0.0875175297,
0.2437067777,
-0.0208601765,
1.0173959732,
0.460308969,
-0.0756530315,
-0.1965783536,
-0.8091256618,
0.5338925719,
0.4856247008,
-0.9204109311,
0.3203982413,
0.3473202586,
0.2445668131,
-0.0645844042,
0.6550984383,
-0.1208524108,
-0.0748212337,
-0.5562981367,
-0.265684098,
-0.1947159916,
-0.259539336,
-0.1832092553,
0.0532921627,
0.2548705041,
-0.1274113059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05969v1 | Language Models Can Learn Exceptions to Syntactic Rules | 2023-06-09T15:35:11 | 2023-06-09T15:35:11 | Cara Su-Yi Leong, Tal Linzen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial neural networks can generalize productively to novel contexts. Can
they also learn exceptions to those productive rules? We explore this question
using the case of restrictions on English passivization (e.g., the fact that
"The vacation lasted five days" is grammatical, but "*Five days was lasted by
the vacation" is not). We collect human acceptability judgments for passive
sentences with a range of verbs, and show that the probability distribution
defined by GPT-2, a language model, matches the human judgments with high
correlation. We also show that the relative acceptability of a verb in the
active vs. passive voice is positively correlated with the relative frequency
of its occurrence in those voices. These results provide preliminary support
for the entrenchment hypothesis, according to which learners track and uses the
distributional properties of their input to learn negative exceptions to rules.
At the same time, this hypothesis fails to explain the magnitude of
unpassivizability demonstrated by certain individual verbs, suggesting that
other cues to exceptionality are available in the linguistic input. | [
0.0273293797,
-0.6754666567,
0.7884342074,
0.2119560689,
-0.1793416739,
-0.6557065845,
-0.547321558,
-0.2527918816,
-0.0543165132,
0.373226583,
-0.3480023146,
-0.2667363584,
-0.4119777679,
0.0920734257,
-0.5579900742,
0.9162051678,
0.0896864012,
-0.1471628547,
-0.2254483104,
-0.2240535319,
-0.3549253941,
-0.5138221383,
-0.4876110852,
-0.3468594253,
0.50445503,
0.1436153054,
0.6234366298,
0.4085082412,
0.1982414871,
0.2974744737,
-0.2618778646,
-0.0521780141,
0.2089655995,
0.1956913769,
-0.5429819226,
-0.8499202132,
0.0367206931,
0.2170446515,
0.6877442598,
0.7673080564,
-0.4824909866,
-0.2718019485,
0.0684145316,
0.4142424464,
-0.4650804102,
0.1210275441,
-0.6398640871,
0.0230228715,
0.0411288477,
0.0830183104,
-0.4728820324,
-0.3924199641,
0.1871815771,
-0.5314520001,
0.4641383588,
-0.5049204826,
1.0801815987,
0.3691962063,
-0.490455091,
-0.3312821686,
-0.663556695,
0.5335148573,
-0.804893434,
0.3319142759,
0.5963583589,
0.1753267348,
-0.1960340291,
-0.7391342521,
-0.886516273,
-0.3680173159,
-0.1527766138,
0.2230729461,
-0.4035263956,
0.3925047517,
0.0949167833,
0.0767809302,
-0.4768268168,
0.0953030884,
-0.4314409792,
0.1968516558,
0.291962117,
-0.1853572428,
0.6394430399,
-0.1803594381,
0.070741795,
0.0771647766,
-0.6220142245,
0.3609992862,
0.3413980305,
0.3987245262,
-0.0070362068,
0.2638224959,
0.0395844243,
0.3901420832,
-0.2381775975,
0.5637181401,
0.0920068398,
-0.2235472649,
-0.3165183663,
-0.4190449715,
0.4154065847,
-0.0641557053,
0.5211503506,
-0.3335222304,
-0.284468621,
0.2063665837,
0.232689023,
-0.2471201867,
-0.3530339301,
-0.1508122236,
-0.4871764779,
0.0248860996,
0.2612589598,
-0.0284956172,
-0.2100357562,
-0.1597288996,
0.3417671025,
-0.426558435,
-0.3605186045,
-0.0279356204,
-0.6154939532,
0.2570401132,
0.2640406191,
-0.9039729834,
0.5290367603,
0.6996750236,
0.8644514084,
-0.0512181595,
-0.6655138731,
-0.2488449514,
-0.107903868,
-0.2406876087,
0.5332131386,
-0.6964193583,
-0.1383787841,
-0.0206098463,
0.1853591353,
-0.6456825733,
-0.7738081217,
0.6500512958,
-0.5778504014,
0.1190465987,
0.0763260275,
-0.3604128063,
-0.641947031,
0.0143977944,
-0.4046415985,
0.180094853,
0.1305907816,
-0.1564513594,
0.5672587156,
-0.6326003075,
-0.8202818632,
-0.0760284811,
-0.1981681436,
-0.3267692327,
0.6921816468,
-0.431651175,
0.2801249027,
0.1725496799,
0.4316830039,
-0.0925681293,
-0.1600205898,
0.4150683582,
-0.6747161746,
0.946181953,
0.2513543665,
-0.6140320897,
-0.0287730023,
-0.3997621238,
-0.0500660278,
-0.0032727777,
-0.7002179027,
-0.3871255517,
0.4046195745,
0.0221788008,
0.272761941,
-0.3140965998,
-0.2121250033,
0.1684506834,
-0.4494210184,
0.6270192266,
0.8556220531,
0.0197243597,
0.3424450159,
-0.2220542431,
0.5737578869,
0.1555542499,
0.0664100572,
-0.0070590489,
-0.4600083828,
-1.0216803551,
-0.1230788901,
0.3202699125,
0.5789644122,
-0.2997569144,
0.3081560731,
0.1483249217,
-0.0162894912,
-0.1367833316,
0.420568496,
0.4214231372,
0.0413107462,
0.1753924489,
-0.1104651615,
-0.6352154016,
-0.9506322145,
-0.5256024599,
-0.1948006898,
-0.0769372359,
0.4540556073,
0.3013403714,
-0.0453861244,
0.5495115519,
-0.0535366647,
-0.2221178561,
-0.4808665812,
-0.1170196012,
0.5277294517,
0.3876037896,
0.6245571375,
-0.9210511446,
-0.2852654755,
-0.1642746627,
-0.6743941307,
0.0893350393,
-0.3055636585,
0.2801729739,
0.2829752564,
0.6234375834,
-0.7466234565,
0.4474364221,
0.4529725611,
-0.8294742703,
0.0550468452,
-0.3880208135,
-0.3567267656,
-0.8733219504,
-0.2341645658,
0.1608923525,
-0.313816756,
-0.6670181155,
0.1303760558,
-0.1054417565,
0.1542290747,
-0.4194021225,
0.1839747429,
-0.2834206223,
0.1714946032,
-0.2932251394,
-0.0344493873,
-0.1460948437,
0.2918540537,
0.1169486865,
0.2910871506,
0.4435079992,
-0.9897113442,
0.1347304881,
-0.0744783953,
-0.1799482703,
0.1109474003,
-0.9050819278,
-0.0513353944,
-0.560775578,
0.2486281842,
-1.0228434801,
-0.3289858699,
0.0067423736,
-0.4530736208,
0.0859407112,
-0.1402552724,
0.0095134601,
0.1204095259,
0.0599364042,
0.0886485055,
0.9303671718,
-0.3881480992,
0.625233531,
0.1839242727,
-0.0287757292,
-0.3002366424,
-0.7489699125,
-0.0735266656,
-0.0852223784,
-0.2765183747,
0.0649072602,
0.1671801358,
-0.5667467117,
0.3987340629,
0.1260848939,
-0.0517567545,
0.4190468788,
0.4953655303,
0.0590640344,
-0.2947799861,
0.2271614969,
-0.1764982939,
0.3137627244,
0.0711536333,
-0.5430369377,
0.348872304,
-0.0578245893,
-0.2226490676,
-0.4273485243,
0.0086412095,
0.4427535832,
0.1747443527,
0.6841946244,
0.0666712672,
-0.6230990291,
-0.4443112314,
-0.2313958704,
-0.1534274071,
-0.4508641362,
0.281236738,
-0.3318847716,
-0.4491967559,
0.3630000949,
0.4109543264,
0.0109198643,
0.7923310995,
0.2475521564,
-0.0274091791,
0.861359179,
0.7544534206,
0.146841675,
0.7373381853,
-0.2968476117,
-0.0338320136,
-0.4634748995,
-0.0813954547,
-0.3802200854,
-0.5745981336,
-0.7619577646,
-0.1095327958,
0.0806319788,
0.2180977762,
-0.0434397124,
0.3379610777,
-0.2029040009,
0.8274372816,
0.7266410589,
0.0688906685,
-0.1386805028,
-0.2755583525,
-0.3503620923,
0.0472396389,
-0.6463167071,
-0.2996121943,
0.6389710307,
0.286932826,
0.3957333565,
0.4887960255,
0.5363576412,
0.3651854396,
0.3411550224,
-0.650816679,
0.4564174414,
-0.508462131,
-0.4883253574,
-0.3577185869,
-0.429526031,
-0.9531124234,
0.2869500518,
0.1923507899,
-0.8273108602,
0.5717625022,
0.3130827844,
-0.3006731272,
0.2204107046,
-1.1759516001,
0.9891002774,
-0.1247006059,
-0.2409262359,
-0.2592463791,
-0.3896321654,
0.144167617,
0.2959415913,
0.1639612913,
-0.2065512985,
-0.0347668603,
0.6615489721,
-0.3443756998,
1.1882853508,
-0.6026520133,
0.3092668653,
0.34918046,
-0.012173445,
0.6283841729,
-0.1958103329,
0.0488620959,
-0.2088181823,
-0.1697523445,
-0.39798069,
-0.9073040485,
0.530172646,
-0.8724838495,
-0.6118510962,
-0.3989695013,
-0.2084353119,
-0.0050885314,
0.1749938428,
0.3979531229,
0.0741295889,
0.000846888,
0.1806528866,
0.3161200881,
-0.1141895652,
0.7102121115,
0.6187900901,
0.1298473924,
-0.091639854,
1.0603047609,
0.3709779382,
0.2965374887,
0.1066244096,
0.5301974416,
-0.2139376402,
-0.6688760519,
-0.0212881695,
0.2503329515,
-0.7316499949,
0.1706756502,
-0.5725049973,
-0.1953464746,
-0.4801543653,
-0.169417128,
0.0868496522,
-0.7171687484,
-0.3219323456,
-0.274712652,
0.1350767314,
1.051199317,
-0.2164550275,
-0.0580998063,
-0.5034196377,
0.0722848326,
0.3460351229,
0.1959208548,
-0.0013424872,
-1.0960111618,
-0.0722093657,
0.0286448132,
-0.2890031934,
-0.5861794949,
0.1818142533,
0.7699762583,
0.9359106421,
0.514944315,
-0.0699718148,
0.1030628532,
-0.3836767673,
0.7758871317,
0.0353509113,
-0.8725417852,
0.6819469929,
-0.4256339073,
0.2802292109,
0.3996309936,
0.3219659328,
-0.9238511324,
-0.604947269,
-0.9221352935,
-0.9045442343,
0.5744345784,
-0.0198310371,
0.6894721389,
-0.2219790667,
0.4101413488,
0.0459235534,
0.1429010481,
-0.9322627187,
0.0355540514,
-0.2740418315,
-0.2653758228,
-0.3042266667,
-0.0748845413,
0.2601980865,
-0.2157165557,
0.5927713513,
-0.0147504061,
-0.0125713525,
0.1292972267,
-0.4056711793,
0.257147938,
0.4547394216,
0.9268399477,
0.7212240696,
-0.0693702921,
0.5564510226,
0.170967117,
-0.5748794079,
0.2509570122,
0.0245046522,
-0.5580745339,
0.1372305304,
0.4732863605,
0.61536479,
-0.05755575,
-0.70661515,
0.5679359436,
0.0423597507,
-0.323533237,
-0.6937900782,
0.4007434547,
-0.079122901,
0.3230114579,
0.1966650933,
0.3337919116,
0.1773641407,
-1.0184651613,
0.4274637103,
0.2850410342,
-0.5573344827,
-0.8399573565,
0.6137937307,
0.0433395132,
-0.4308462739,
0.6657711864,
-0.42845276,
-0.7984243631,
0.8749361634,
0.6940425634,
1.1201367378,
-0.2476440966,
0.1548152864,
0.1074696332,
0.4064246416,
-0.1698483676,
0.2517760098,
-0.1290691495,
-1.0068925619,
-0.237763226,
-0.3150402308,
-0.1805447191,
0.0376464576,
-0.3743347228,
0.2644580603,
-0.6442015767,
-0.0188547596,
0.35117203,
-0.682967186,
-0.694232285,
0.0519968905,
0.0570496395,
0.5367106199,
-1.1913449764,
0.6624199152,
1.0395430326,
-0.7157068253,
-0.6796754599,
0.2485111356,
-0.0839081928,
-0.7668625712,
0.8100191951,
0.035593573,
0.2141254842,
-0.3469749689,
-0.2037214339,
-0.4346292317,
0.4247639477,
0.3333735466,
-0.1383069605,
-0.2437476218,
-0.2282279581,
0.7007691264,
-0.0998322591,
0.2559562027,
0.5773175359,
0.2394450903,
-0.2070438862,
-0.8282222748,
0.0894538462,
-0.4908707142,
-0.2986092865,
0.0614633523,
-0.7608098388,
1.0595976114,
-0.4793965816,
-0.264217943,
-0.3863916993,
0.3885622025,
-0.3141745925,
0.4431959093,
0.60232687,
0.4647996128,
0.6151319146,
-0.0286101811,
1.0759525299,
0.2198227048,
0.2017906606,
0.9592328072,
-0.0046447655,
0.9687571526,
0.3868082762,
-0.3201939166,
0.6535813808,
0.3808467388,
0.0993953347,
0.7607648969,
0.3841309547,
-0.4029718041,
-0.2130357027,
-0.3719202876,
0.1179519519,
0.5936958194,
0.3354075849,
-0.6963999271,
-0.1823858172,
0.2144595981,
-0.0202998742,
0.2632234097,
-0.148736462,
0.8196764588,
0.2712922394,
-0.8327531815,
0.7003920078,
-0.0004881867,
0.6346954703,
-0.3051579893,
-0.1200411096,
-0.3231124282,
0.5877275467,
-0.3646061122,
-0.4005752802,
0.4025510848,
-0.256840378,
-0.3721057773,
-0.08534614,
0.4968630672,
-0.2638918161,
-0.2918952703,
0.0183472,
0.4035634398,
0.3240136206,
0.1890691072,
-0.2396061718,
-0.3957279027,
-0.0389380194,
-0.4284625351,
0.1321854889,
0.3607523143,
0.0335693397,
0.4774190187,
0.2703798115,
0.4132066369,
0.038312804,
0.2876142859,
0.5954449177,
-0.7009345889,
-0.5699716806,
-1.1492043734,
0.3680413961,
0.0472754017,
-0.5434817076,
0.7734110355,
0.4793601632,
0.9078096747,
-0.0470574088,
1.2271100283,
0.0066315248,
0.4541721642,
-0.6544779539,
0.5293779969,
-0.4911291897,
0.2223494947,
0.0243378878,
-0.6477413774,
-0.262483865,
0.7956984043,
-0.4843128622,
0.0806780383,
0.817502737,
0.4104906023,
-0.1788502634,
-0.098844938,
0.453001976,
-0.0334712677,
0.3279055655,
0.5443860292,
0.9636710286,
-0.1793530434,
0.4813280106,
0.1269820333,
0.05649646,
-0.2566528618,
-0.4045939147,
-0.765309155,
-0.7317263484,
-0.1753229201,
-0.4788521826,
0.3106381595,
1.0469942093,
0.5568401217,
-0.9428325295,
-0.1000639647,
-0.6155794859,
0.4371472001,
-0.5273909569,
-0.247297883,
0.2172630429,
-0.5025948286,
-0.6056675315,
0.4135037959,
-0.0249276534,
0.4186633825,
0.0343622789,
-0.0714723542,
-0.1591856331,
0.2923815548,
0.3436975777,
0.6276577115,
-0.6541349888,
-0.4270432591,
0.1573969275,
0.0829566196,
-0.2226124555,
1.1164560318,
-0.4290028811,
0.1783902943,
0.5937356353,
0.6281865835,
0.0986650586,
-0.155716151,
0.5296787024,
-0.8798516393,
0.5063368082,
0.373367995,
0.4367490709,
0.0419334657,
-0.2072542012,
0.4739105403,
0.5246468782,
-0.3762391806,
-0.72540766,
0.3757506609,
-0.3477216661,
-0.3144510984,
1.2863750458,
-0.3307440579,
-0.2598652244,
-0.2393167168,
0.2751753926,
0.0558850318,
-0.2642397583,
0.7901406288,
0.8530477881,
-0.3255563378,
-0.3162936568,
-0.7958305478,
0.5076311231,
0.6080494523,
-0.5862062573,
-0.094308272,
0.4149030447,
0.3683692813,
0.0176575165,
0.4901289642,
0.4231922626,
0.6158471704,
0.1196116209,
-0.1528208703,
-0.055435881,
-0.3356758058,
-0.57184726,
-0.0590630993,
0.6000004411,
-0.3743157387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05887v1 | An Efficient Speech Separation Network Based on Recurrent Fusion Dilated Convolution and Channel Attention | 2023-06-09T13:30:27 | 2023-06-09T13:30:27 | Junyu Wang | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | We present an efficient speech separation neural network, ARFDCN, which
combines dilated convolutions, multi-scale fusion (MSF), and channel attention
to overcome the limited receptive field of convolution-based networks and the
high computational cost of transformer-based networks. The suggested network
architecture is encoder-decoder based. By using dilated convolutions with
gradually increasing dilation value to learn local and global features and
fusing them at adjacent stages, the model can learn rich feature content.
Meanwhile, by adding channel attention modules to the network, the model can
extract channel weights, learn more important features, and thus improve its
expressive power and robustness. Experimental results indicate that the model
achieves a decent balance between performance and computational efficiency,
making it a promising alternative to current mainstream models for practical
applications. | [
-0.7421172857,
-0.6696830392,
-0.2627124488,
0.21791704,
-0.5789861679,
0.0700390264,
-0.2228327394,
-0.387222141,
0.3013349175,
0.4650022089,
-0.6078557372,
-0.1457066089,
-0.7846203446,
-0.0862250403,
-0.7350357771,
0.6363750696,
0.6004298329,
0.0284360275,
0.2873954475,
-0.2223390043,
-0.0791722983,
-0.1493700594,
-0.7615205646,
-0.5405039191,
0.5620865226,
0.2875347435,
0.4070432186,
0.7963417172,
0.9045020342,
0.3721645474,
-0.5341587663,
0.2019947171,
-0.3588456213,
0.1644938141,
0.0206610672,
0.1211684495,
-0.0410644859,
-0.0489429198,
0.8714694381,
0.666485846,
-0.2901652455,
-0.1630174667,
-0.1892959177,
0.6549423933,
-0.5980885029,
0.1259752065,
-0.5936447978,
0.2188522816,
0.2515658438,
0.4215057492,
-0.0665544868,
-0.1849949956,
0.4219159484,
-0.0786460042,
0.3002831638,
-0.4215732515,
0.5820223689,
0.4442075491,
-0.039858561,
0.2342701107,
-0.8304951191,
0.649471283,
-0.4174551368,
0.867990613,
0.0640834868,
0.4257654548,
0.2466278523,
-0.9359722733,
-0.4946815968,
0.1278405339,
0.036963664,
0.0115160262,
-0.2951368988,
0.1782844365,
0.0010757787,
0.6481994987,
-0.5257638693,
-0.164381668,
-0.5781645775,
-0.1413004696,
0.5253015757,
-0.2794827521,
0.1150709465,
0.0104813576,
-0.5367484093,
-0.0589594543,
-0.4759938717,
-0.0389248207,
-0.0216662735,
0.3883876801,
-0.1792035848,
0.3482270241,
-0.3359691799,
0.8725358844,
0.2871956825,
-0.2444533557,
0.163939178,
-0.2913592458,
-0.5681474209,
0.4291027486,
0.7578331828,
-0.3704111576,
0.0615487099,
-0.3592694998,
-0.1549728215,
0.0790279657,
0.102467753,
-0.680362463,
-0.3322416842,
0.3171109259,
-0.7079377174,
-0.4260420501,
-0.1125492007,
-0.7170675397,
-0.2603819668,
-0.406345576,
0.2006017566,
-0.4422990084,
-0.6080341935,
-0.1106187254,
-0.0520772301,
0.3367494941,
-0.1207158715,
-0.9875007272,
0.505338192,
0.5773861408,
1.0286926031,
-0.3295089602,
-0.0656008124,
-0.8062635064,
-0.2936230898,
0.1337215006,
0.5902464986,
-0.4734796286,
-0.3389180899,
-0.3858057857,
-0.1109163612,
-0.2212628275,
-0.7675689459,
0.3105275035,
-0.6599444747,
-0.0814758837,
0.4408900142,
-0.3573210835,
-0.5352264643,
0.1472363025,
-1.0940756798,
0.150750041,
0.0879591927,
-0.3648869395,
-0.0635122806,
-0.5084739327,
-0.7139505148,
0.0425539128,
-0.094573684,
-0.5958802104,
-0.1986328065,
0.3693864346,
0.3654298484,
-0.3119976223,
0.0828918368,
-0.2048354596,
-0.1861400604,
0.2916989028,
-0.5511978865,
0.8300715089,
0.5964873433,
-0.3838550746,
0.3646269739,
-1.1686743498,
-0.1673454046,
-0.0272664335,
-0.6618397236,
0.3276477754,
-0.4195513129,
-0.0949224904,
0.2268426418,
-0.1339558363,
-0.5838409066,
-0.4686906338,
-0.6629422307,
0.7136098146,
0.2585152686,
0.1474958807,
0.7372646928,
-0.1330679357,
0.448225379,
0.0944447592,
0.0127066979,
-0.0867626593,
-0.2049640417,
-0.6680634022,
-0.6304904222,
0.3884887695,
0.491541326,
-0.3090768754,
0.838799119,
-0.0217455402,
-0.4394212067,
-0.5303247571,
0.3063478172,
0.3602980375,
0.6144269109,
-0.001873103,
-0.2837031484,
-0.4183859527,
-0.9502316713,
0.1851671934,
0.2287708819,
0.177639693,
0.2591536045,
0.0577455349,
0.1186185107,
0.767911315,
-0.116102621,
-0.5237957239,
-0.6263071895,
-0.1750108749,
0.1732726842,
0.3015460968,
-0.1166983247,
-1.3945510387,
-0.1983153224,
0.3144100308,
-0.3752390742,
0.2055416554,
0.0955228731,
-0.1381853223,
-0.1495166868,
0.3251722157,
-0.7157030702,
0.153586179,
0.5574764609,
-0.1358476877,
0.1609995663,
0.2683836818,
-0.0583856851,
-0.9313738942,
0.3500951231,
0.167308107,
-0.2731108367,
-0.8218103647,
-0.2000259608,
0.025504604,
-0.632417798,
-0.968284905,
0.2010148466,
-0.3506954312,
0.0807244331,
-0.3587311804,
0.284563601,
0.2343606949,
0.7790147662,
0.3297349215,
0.3028368354,
0.4338260293,
-0.6147007942,
0.9732061625,
0.2130300552,
-0.1107098982,
0.1866875142,
-0.6935335994,
0.086915195,
0.0017950231,
0.1268921047,
-0.9961224198,
-0.1900287569,
0.2795479,
-0.5255969167,
0.4110555351,
-0.0786766484,
0.153850764,
-0.3185284138,
0.0111198928,
0.60476017,
0.3469741642,
-0.8021181226,
0.6428133249,
0.530939877,
-0.1007950902,
-0.5090518594,
-0.7441029549,
-0.3197373152,
-0.2768154144,
-0.8645072579,
0.1638965607,
0.4362424612,
-0.2876259089,
-0.0435229093,
-0.0923287943,
-0.3430262208,
0.0033325297,
0.2678279579,
-0.0594689585,
-0.0570494197,
0.3005979955,
-0.1266137511,
0.100673601,
0.0342937969,
-0.3816864491,
0.5697422028,
-0.1779438257,
-0.194321245,
-0.4662148356,
0.6886087656,
0.8618426919,
-0.7717422247,
0.6153718829,
0.7810877562,
-0.7434065938,
-0.1273781806,
-0.4789440334,
-0.4261348248,
-0.4046497345,
0.6633962393,
-0.0934399217,
-0.9092267156,
0.5531525612,
-0.1030779406,
-0.0742208213,
0.2904101312,
0.4148255885,
0.4288585186,
0.9010622501,
0.3403944671,
-0.1765889078,
0.6588922739,
-0.4886755347,
0.3755666018,
-1.0602593422,
-0.3692168295,
-0.3133969307,
-0.5122463703,
-0.1447459608,
-0.218231827,
0.1350889206,
-0.0204790756,
-0.2740998566,
0.0930545777,
-1.0391590595,
0.4685973823,
0.4425183535,
0.2162093073,
-0.0109004462,
0.1274007708,
0.1884114742,
0.3114420474,
-0.6901521683,
0.2631142735,
0.646977067,
0.5620244741,
0.8005231023,
0.2031474262,
0.5015714765,
0.1682280451,
-0.0957478508,
-0.9734873772,
0.404140383,
-0.2471626401,
-0.4365804493,
-0.6794161201,
-0.5330067277,
-0.7460038066,
0.6568239927,
-0.1557709575,
-0.5575529933,
0.5598009229,
-0.4320784509,
-0.7125814557,
0.3658450842,
-0.8617506027,
0.5083053112,
0.0996053442,
-0.2091062516,
-0.1540214419,
-0.8339569569,
0.5294288993,
0.0642424524,
-0.1336452961,
-0.0412074551,
0.35630548,
1.0172821283,
-0.4390921295,
0.512870729,
-0.0126039116,
0.0767213777,
0.5728398561,
-0.0182618331,
0.4785337746,
-0.0140661588,
-0.0434346199,
-0.0029029511,
-0.55192101,
0.1540965438,
-0.6229282022,
0.763320148,
-0.6968173385,
-0.3685045838,
0.1061709374,
-0.6563591361,
0.0222147387,
0.238959372,
0.1830105484,
0.703473568,
-0.0706548616,
0.480008781,
0.9149020314,
0.1886400133,
0.7428001761,
-0.075655371,
0.0238079838,
-0.9816190004,
0.9187429547,
-0.0156255234,
0.5794041753,
0.3072046638,
0.1233091131,
-0.5896455646,
-0.1194255576,
-0.333871454,
0.4629898071,
-0.7385849953,
-0.176857546,
-0.6608604789,
-0.9755349159,
-0.5842493773,
0.3329477906,
-0.6380590796,
-0.3901493251,
-0.4496558011,
0.0256280601,
0.2401233912,
0.2550501227,
-0.0988492742,
0.3490018249,
-0.7337374091,
0.5607602,
0.851739049,
0.3387152553,
0.1075499654,
-0.6100273728,
-0.3136832118,
-0.1154903471,
-0.2370145023,
-0.5350373387,
0.512340486,
0.3663279414,
0.4105389714,
0.6452667713,
-0.0393977016,
0.1703490466,
-0.0276257265,
0.4405892789,
0.5716618299,
-0.8297491074,
0.5241187215,
-0.1806359142,
0.6764076352,
0.1517985612,
-0.0782786608,
-0.4357011616,
-0.1434101015,
-0.5122084618,
-0.6104605794,
0.9161325693,
0.3372978568,
-0.2965724766,
-0.0017168315,
0.2309037596,
-0.3189772069,
0.1264718324,
-0.4937999845,
-0.5099808574,
-0.1015050933,
-0.0959947556,
0.1832442433,
-0.1329928935,
-0.3935348988,
-0.3488222361,
0.5931953192,
0.0282876678,
0.3758246303,
0.3948387504,
0.1634086818,
-0.228968665,
0.2270995229,
0.6928801537,
0.4387972057,
-0.1673133224,
0.4201903939,
0.3047440946,
-0.5922424197,
0.3277852237,
0.4604365826,
0.2749838233,
-0.0294030346,
0.0340618156,
0.8910820484,
-0.0004542458,
-0.4346345365,
0.5062423944,
-0.3118189573,
-0.3264757097,
0.0159430038,
0.2465693057,
0.3696514964,
0.4701060355,
0.2194997221,
0.2134967297,
0.3067157567,
0.0522340126,
0.4260877371,
0.4471853673,
-0.6423644423,
0.2515324652,
0.5291567445,
0.5388236642,
-0.665507555,
0.5907338858,
0.1325707883,
-0.3654720783,
0.8524890542,
0.5180363655,
1.046397686,
-0.4331571758,
0.1221693009,
0.0912686884,
0.0984720662,
0.2691934705,
-0.0192003436,
-0.37292853,
-0.5578404665,
-0.461337626,
-0.6332000494,
-0.1675393581,
0.3692781925,
-0.3770856261,
0.1353509277,
-0.689702034,
-0.1796394587,
0.0668039545,
-0.1084999815,
-0.3148496449,
0.6069788933,
0.5472052693,
0.7552543283,
-0.5463446975,
0.8169599175,
0.4018273652,
-0.0770612136,
-0.9438099861,
-0.3531221747,
-0.1412718147,
-0.2641203701,
0.4183543026,
0.3845637143,
-0.4868231118,
-0.1158095896,
-0.3089888692,
-0.9635617137,
0.9462189674,
0.3982532918,
-0.8738155961,
0.2463681102,
-0.2198647708,
0.1876068115,
-0.6552755237,
-0.113538079,
0.8087694049,
0.1729851216,
0.336758256,
-0.6322060823,
-0.2186570019,
-0.4415183663,
-0.1219624504,
0.2276799679,
-0.8863341808,
0.7842814326,
-0.1330341548,
-0.3111551702,
-0.2218667567,
0.8801191449,
0.2324293554,
0.0920875147,
0.7128338218,
0.6777564883,
0.5974609852,
-0.1323026419,
0.6522753835,
-0.0184057411,
0.2790963054,
0.8921032548,
0.0021456566,
0.4584438205,
0.4142482281,
-0.0233263914,
0.1662944108,
0.4105831087,
0.17782785,
0.9067274332,
0.3312591314,
-0.7918562889,
-0.4427623749,
-0.2566782236,
-0.5258805156,
0.7163941264,
0.2178373486,
-0.7447236776,
-0.1705295444,
0.3114806116,
-0.4587665498,
-0.2005897462,
-0.2411021441,
1.0070171356,
0.2651783824,
-0.4982214272,
0.6459401846,
-0.3127682805,
0.4081648886,
-0.5436320901,
-0.0514292419,
-0.1125725731,
0.4338992834,
-0.356267035,
-0.5924577713,
0.4015119076,
-0.2863985598,
-0.3995864987,
0.3975523412,
0.8947988749,
-0.6255273819,
-0.5066278577,
0.3044918776,
0.3239683509,
0.0871323198,
-0.2237177491,
-0.4903689921,
0.3787608743,
0.1823556125,
-0.2061156482,
0.1318890154,
0.2668609023,
0.4854799509,
0.7026389241,
0.5716202855,
0.3769878745,
0.0888546333,
0.2872941494,
0.9472109079,
-0.435772568,
-0.6979472637,
-0.7592265606,
0.2734352052,
-0.1669833511,
-0.0234545767,
0.0334374085,
0.2429851592,
0.388139993,
0.2199332118,
0.834546864,
0.1478702724,
0.5413148999,
-0.2092335373,
1.1147320271,
-0.1608816236,
0.096924603,
0.1880410016,
-0.8768435121,
-0.6715186834,
0.6181894541,
0.1047868654,
0.1935259402,
0.3475178182,
0.6718289256,
-0.0790398195,
0.5436009765,
0.4969747961,
-0.2175031006,
0.5136971474,
0.5648056865,
0.5808634162,
-0.3658054471,
0.8060791492,
-0.766697228,
-0.2638179958,
-0.0074992259,
-0.2474491,
-0.6872144938,
-0.5679279566,
-0.4135602713,
-0.3263903558,
-0.1546109915,
0.7206988931,
1.0297321081,
-0.753801465,
0.0240414273,
-0.2833292186,
0.4847590327,
-0.3397336006,
-0.2713880241,
0.5947055221,
-0.1694450825,
-0.6400873661,
0.4268565178,
0.4109866023,
-0.0831984505,
-0.5328832269,
-0.0100177219,
-0.4861647189,
-0.0485909991,
0.478641659,
0.3850421906,
-0.7405982018,
-0.1901491731,
-0.1569268554,
-0.1718335301,
0.0220692959,
0.7347935438,
-0.7218747139,
0.7063806653,
0.5477986336,
0.8868195415,
0.1643746793,
0.0926546305,
0.3823831975,
-0.6342420578,
0.2560783625,
0.2567221522,
0.3238078058,
0.5445510745,
-0.4707708061,
0.1390601248,
0.3167052269,
-0.7252214551,
-0.4512464702,
0.0392262265,
-1.0422974825,
-0.0797470808,
1.2339092493,
-0.0911881998,
-0.5829257965,
0.0098848278,
-0.3651533425,
0.6521685719,
-0.4393330514,
0.4761587381,
0.5614347458,
-0.2498544157,
-0.6537892818,
0.4427278042,
0.3575925529,
0.2387332171,
-0.5328198671,
0.1939029843,
0.2365915775,
0.1573980749,
0.3034232855,
0.0977555662,
-0.3997000754,
0.7151944637,
0.0541802943,
-0.1023361832,
-0.262650311,
-0.6257731915,
-0.8078628778,
0.5797219276,
-0.2669083178,
-0.8083014488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05882v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05882v2 | Good, but not always Fair: An Evaluation of Gender Bias for three commercial Machine Translation Systems | 2023-06-09T13:24:27 | 2024-03-26T22:54:48 | Silvia Alma Piazzolla, Beatrice Savoldi, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation (MT) continues to make significant strides in quality and
is increasingly adopted on a larger scale. Consequently, analyses have been
redirected to more nuanced aspects, intricate phenomena, as well as potential
risks that may arise from the widespread use of MT tools. Along this line, this
paper offers a meticulous assessment of three commercial MT systems - Google
Translate, DeepL, and Modern MT - with a specific focus on gender translation
and bias. For three language pairs (English/Spanish, English/Italian, and
English/French), we scrutinize the behavior of such systems at several levels
of granularity and on a variety of naturally occurring gender phenomena in
translation. Our study takes stock of the current state of online MT tools, by
revealing significant discrepancies in the gender translation of the three
systems, with each system displaying varying degrees of bias despite their
overall translation quality. | [
-0.1020490974,
-0.6534461975,
0.5069434643,
0.3524590731,
0.0087171737,
0.2176564038,
0.0722563714,
-0.5288097262,
-0.24924317,
0.4454689622,
-0.5405055881,
-0.187764883,
-0.9726896882,
0.5266005993,
-0.6866322756,
1.3132755756,
-0.2119105011,
0.6114826202,
-0.0259206314,
-0.4446720779,
-0.9650965333,
-0.6249287128,
-0.4027892649,
-0.4811349511,
0.2021916807,
0.0131090209,
1.1215765476,
0.2268990129,
0.8065798283,
0.2162418216,
-0.075790301,
0.2450839281,
-0.5205293894,
0.2839436829,
-0.1346947551,
-0.6438162327,
-0.6750673056,
0.2291119695,
0.4888816178,
1.0252201557,
-0.0245045889,
0.4126907289,
0.2423787564,
0.9805289507,
-0.602971971,
-0.2009391636,
-0.413870424,
0.3643871546,
-0.1829779595,
0.1946254522,
-0.4751519561,
-0.7702001333,
0.3591315746,
-0.4970677495,
0.2384209186,
0.2887262404,
0.7646817565,
0.2114029676,
-0.6604090333,
-0.5136565566,
-0.7568572164,
1.0617260933,
-0.4800246954,
0.2599616051,
0.3264137208,
0.7464578748,
-0.0618484505,
-0.3393714726,
-0.2196611017,
-0.1749224067,
0.009308299,
-0.0452887937,
-0.4392950237,
-0.3613207638,
0.1505660862,
0.4132288992,
-0.3742294312,
-0.0471276902,
-0.4165800512,
0.0003380985,
0.2275805026,
0.0525537506,
0.6692101359,
0.0126969675,
-0.1777362972,
0.050199192,
-0.7706875205,
-0.1237388402,
0.916993916,
0.3687404692,
-0.1434050798,
0.5693815947,
0.1376661509,
0.5683611631,
0.1315586418,
0.0601587147,
0.5755922198,
-0.286680311,
-0.3641268015,
0.031524092,
0.9759755731,
0.8050912023,
0.5243684053,
-0.3556473255,
-0.4220460355,
-0.0789138526,
0.458073765,
-0.346342802,
0.3166129589,
0.2388740778,
-0.7166195512,
-0.370898366,
0.2142446041,
-0.5597732663,
-0.4948998094,
-0.2275306135,
0.4959097207,
-0.0313968398,
-0.138353765,
0.0924707726,
-0.4068401754,
-0.0628903583,
0.2945057452,
-0.6832370758,
0.3521795571,
0.6088398099,
0.6666708589,
-0.2835378051,
-0.1990927309,
-0.4997096062,
0.017579319,
-0.5008007288,
0.3816025853,
-0.2885484695,
-0.4179975688,
-0.0692406446,
0.0924179256,
-0.028138198,
-0.7944332957,
0.6128714085,
-0.2495704442,
0.6031556129,
-0.538746655,
-0.0428640358,
-0.1477257311,
0.3052500784,
-0.6150023937,
0.7303690314,
0.0860442445,
-0.9748441577,
0.649798274,
-0.655888021,
-0.5424104333,
-0.4172279537,
-0.1550696194,
-0.3584352136,
0.198387742,
0.2930296659,
0.2146172374,
-0.4040215909,
0.6485406756,
-0.3410404027,
-0.5587510467,
0.5270758867,
-0.4944730103,
0.7923170328,
0.4704956114,
-0.5708758831,
0.0060777804,
-0.1312529296,
-0.2467831522,
0.0408280864,
-0.1269732565,
-0.191933006,
0.0213380605,
-0.0631365329,
0.3843092322,
0.2012616247,
-0.2553622127,
0.0669534728,
-0.2712400854,
0.6125628352,
0.6238662004,
-0.5511513352,
0.9590563774,
-0.1090701371,
0.5289352536,
-0.1418178678,
0.3991000056,
0.2457796782,
-0.5468067527,
-0.6203622818,
-0.042792961,
0.5990336537,
0.6006585956,
-0.8492972255,
0.0335560329,
-0.5682371855,
0.0035523216,
-0.8317587972,
0.0307617635,
0.5552933812,
0.0172768887,
0.0606897585,
-0.2438341081,
-0.0933535472,
-1.4261516333,
-1.0110300779,
0.2484226376,
-0.322001636,
0.2280065268,
0.4875441492,
-0.2409877479,
0.7811800241,
-0.1875350177,
-0.4709644616,
-0.2594777048,
0.2845968008,
0.3040667176,
0.4544375539,
0.6749428511,
-0.5446845293,
-0.3186050057,
0.2717706859,
-0.8539716005,
-0.3189508319,
0.1109989434,
-0.2449440211,
0.0702893212,
0.2558857203,
-0.2459736466,
0.1617690623,
0.8024604321,
-0.3309566677,
0.0740552098,
-0.4040873349,
0.3615692854,
-0.6145887375,
0.1645944118,
-0.147855714,
-0.6038826108,
-0.4038316309,
0.428494215,
0.1291245222,
0.1606092453,
-0.6469601393,
0.2768219411,
-0.432064712,
-0.5335372686,
-0.3293456435,
0.0674447566,
0.1273801923,
-0.1073625311,
-0.5314658284,
0.8957298994,
0.0757837594,
-0.4633524716,
-0.1539504826,
0.0725526139,
-0.0523982197,
0.7873137593,
-0.4810762703,
0.3731727004,
-0.2021794915,
0.3851113021,
-0.6019802094,
-0.0628977492,
0.5990427136,
-0.6096277833,
0.1244405806,
-0.1904008836,
-0.8100669384,
-0.3538746834,
-0.2736047506,
0.4913321137,
0.4267372787,
-0.2812865973,
0.3308689892,
0.4734031558,
0.0166122932,
-0.7388558984,
-1.1149550676,
0.4257817566,
-0.0980041102,
-0.490819633,
-0.1699848622,
0.1326416135,
-0.4655176997,
-0.121149011,
-0.1285880059,
-0.1944978684,
0.2360787392,
0.2024164647,
0.0626074299,
0.1588688493,
-0.2065591365,
0.333853513,
-0.1242696643,
-0.0032826685,
-0.3746459484,
0.3447536528,
-0.4080090821,
-0.3144373894,
-0.2982407212,
0.4483970106,
0.7033365369,
0.0680012479,
0.6533873081,
0.7144099474,
-0.458101213,
0.1393233538,
-0.4487072229,
0.0777694881,
-0.3789261281,
0.0006371126,
-0.4351536334,
-0.690138638,
0.4647904932,
0.2570987344,
0.1531439126,
0.6492620707,
0.398165822,
-0.235144645,
1.5991336107,
0.4454698563,
0.0698264763,
0.0271215551,
0.0367233008,
0.298130393,
-0.6321168542,
-0.1838096827,
-0.7897490859,
-0.6444176435,
-0.9017090797,
-0.2977887094,
0.1934008598,
-0.2083488107,
-0.3985392451,
0.338798672,
-0.328905344,
0.4435255229,
0.5521643758,
-0.2425437421,
0.478549093,
-0.0134134339,
-0.2266720682,
-0.3170045912,
-0.5701314211,
-1.0960634947,
1.2300137281,
0.5670987964,
0.4737570286,
0.3106924891,
0.139359951,
0.7823113203,
0.5012124181,
-0.4871148467,
0.2071084678,
-0.6520113349,
-1.1128263474,
0.1957315356,
-0.7280416489,
-1.0045244694,
0.4136659205,
-0.1979473382,
-0.3661207259,
0.1385925114,
0.0063394583,
0.0503383651,
0.3530333042,
-0.845698595,
0.7357936502,
-0.2720014453,
-0.331800282,
0.0167158395,
-0.8036699891,
0.5976853967,
-0.1775838733,
0.717446506,
-0.2333178222,
0.0228467826,
0.5659505129,
-0.1008110791,
0.550190568,
-0.1066173837,
-0.3320723474,
-0.0864568353,
0.7011865377,
0.1429565102,
-0.2683320642,
-0.1067780107,
0.5545597076,
0.0490408018,
-0.5404993296,
-0.3681118786,
0.7038410306,
-0.8448058963,
-0.2028030604,
-0.458694309,
-0.429273963,
0.0091548264,
0.4646594524,
0.2292784601,
0.0781945214,
-0.2671141326,
-0.0486543179,
0.2965376973,
-0.351118207,
0.0380814634,
0.1326496899,
-0.5131672025,
-0.4275560379,
0.9399218559,
0.0488097221,
0.4581829607,
0.1830843985,
0.0658215582,
-0.2928940654,
-0.3185583949,
-0.9700345397,
-0.0312799513,
-0.7089371681,
0.1538723856,
-0.6084038019,
0.3455610275,
-0.1871880442,
-0.0713267028,
-0.4451738,
-0.4880610108,
-0.0523729473,
0.0955836847,
-0.370141089,
0.9314497709,
0.5477657318,
0.5525777936,
-0.690028131,
0.4665425122,
0.1666243374,
0.3338557482,
-0.4352423549,
-0.4361727536,
0.0915973932,
0.2232303023,
-0.595051229,
-0.7387477756,
0.4419773519,
-0.2859926224,
0.6022905111,
0.3783912063,
-0.2714134455,
0.144984141,
-0.7132419348,
0.9933433533,
0.3751653135,
-1.1992799044,
0.2771995664,
-0.5320411325,
0.124591738,
0.6402211189,
0.2224402577,
-0.6596559286,
-0.6170560718,
-0.39474383,
-0.6746706963,
0.6579506397,
0.7253022194,
0.3023851514,
0.0462172627,
0.0271429569,
0.7272465229,
0.7689532042,
-0.8714106679,
-0.3837037683,
-0.2756588757,
-0.2062758356,
0.056266088,
0.1408359557,
-0.1764379144,
0.1625965536,
0.2835845649,
-0.0141795743,
0.3015556633,
0.0155896116,
-0.5825999975,
-0.1116757467,
0.5547856092,
0.6092131734,
0.8415663838,
-0.4376785755,
0.225078553,
0.2336634248,
-0.4036838412,
0.2145071328,
-0.4209036827,
-0.415993005,
0.0776839033,
0.1420135051,
0.7800245285,
0.0157509912,
-0.4250608981,
0.6087613702,
-0.2803476155,
-0.4023765326,
0.1634013802,
-0.3220233321,
-0.2008799911,
0.0344668813,
0.2457968146,
0.5325693488,
0.5234383345,
-0.626734674,
-0.5751875639,
0.4059050083,
-0.7376275063,
-0.2753834426,
0.8932757378,
0.651160419,
-0.3567197919,
0.3186868131,
-0.3635992408,
-0.6481607556,
0.3628365397,
0.2530505955,
1.2222281694,
0.0970261097,
0.1011931598,
0.075832516,
0.9214220047,
-0.3895713985,
-0.0053748223,
0.4667956233,
-0.3427861631,
-0.3213049173,
-0.0942055136,
-0.442809999,
-0.1721346229,
-0.5053130984,
0.2251264602,
-0.0789055824,
-0.7627795935,
-0.405344069,
-0.2755869925,
-0.9231065512,
-0.025052622,
0.1738127321,
0.4928538203,
-0.9347438812,
0.2522252798,
0.7562014461,
-0.2007261664,
0.0490106307,
0.0838326961,
0.0578896999,
-0.5584488511,
0.9007775784,
0.18958956,
-0.3953358829,
-0.4566277564,
-0.3656585217,
-0.4452212453,
0.6673167348,
0.5586555004,
-0.4512759447,
0.0517310537,
0.5058864951,
0.2993530929,
-0.1461013556,
0.4730366766,
0.6486856341,
0.7386778593,
-0.622192502,
-1.3885685205,
-0.0603330955,
0.0295036901,
-0.0641279817,
0.1201707572,
-0.3291402757,
0.8363381028,
0.1249386668,
-0.2755882144,
-0.209534809,
0.0833999142,
0.0132882604,
0.6478527784,
0.6659631729,
0.2067343295,
0.6455978155,
-0.3714912236,
1.2244944572,
0.1266056746,
0.263127774,
0.7965427041,
-0.3131438494,
0.5337884426,
0.5683140755,
-0.3692960739,
0.1020404324,
0.4801665246,
0.1589865386,
0.2303287387,
0.2712596059,
0.2457141578,
-0.1365017891,
0.1033124849,
-0.5056946278,
0.0286323857,
0.2070091814,
-0.4998019934,
-0.2063134611,
0.0674130172,
0.2111400664,
0.0369979665,
0.0611070246,
0.3781319857,
0.3375902176,
-0.6601740122,
0.2780351639,
0.3684458435,
0.7521756887,
-0.2484859973,
0.2476757318,
-0.2934550941,
0.0880002677,
-0.172725901,
-0.7549698949,
0.2335178703,
0.3198911846,
-0.2545234263,
-0.6117658019,
0.44568488,
-0.0020690616,
-0.5414064527,
0.2142578363,
0.8959088326,
0.3098715544,
-0.205483526,
-0.7856525779,
0.1968095899,
0.0530913137,
0.1710279882,
0.2621316314,
0.2835126817,
-0.3045032024,
0.891735673,
0.6440138817,
-0.0324713737,
0.2189720869,
0.2707000673,
0.3272581398,
-0.63587147,
-0.3305300176,
-0.906853199,
0.3431738913,
-0.0766660199,
-0.3478597999,
0.9264432788,
0.5094615221,
0.6312450767,
-0.1059930101,
0.6871148944,
0.3258282244,
0.3634805083,
-0.3336183429,
0.9500684738,
-0.5734336376,
0.2679977715,
-0.6452424526,
-1.3185580969,
-0.4498742521,
0.4585753679,
-0.460207969,
0.1954873502,
0.9057222605,
0.1042577624,
-0.2696331143,
0.1863425225,
0.1944013238,
0.1350902766,
0.4194760621,
0.1407689005,
1.2156472206,
-0.676461935,
0.7104535103,
0.316198051,
-0.06468606,
-0.4708784521,
-1.1502894163,
-0.7230135798,
-0.0059950179,
-0.2819477618,
-0.3026839495,
0.2579890192,
0.8485793471,
0.6376132369,
-0.4843242466,
-0.2620074153,
0.1344759464,
0.3464059532,
-0.1794828773,
-0.1321672201,
0.0259922165,
-0.2093376517,
-1.0637971163,
0.1563531607,
0.0740202963,
0.010572413,
-0.3633491397,
-0.0316891074,
0.4087303281,
-0.1568768024,
0.6283479929,
-0.320956409,
-0.8062905073,
-0.0829166695,
0.1666136086,
-0.3868626654,
0.0336408466,
0.7070450187,
-0.4175320268,
0.5829924941,
0.6883317232,
0.4108169079,
0.1895015389,
-0.2589232624,
0.9583919048,
-0.4374708831,
-0.1882153451,
0.0525908619,
0.2624158561,
0.5800156593,
-0.0632839277,
0.3586316109,
0.093521826,
-0.5756388307,
-1.0587296486,
0.0365389027,
-0.7008856535,
-0.472438097,
1.050530076,
0.118107304,
-0.0002585562,
-0.1339050233,
-0.4985824227,
0.2015811056,
-0.4284871817,
0.576259017,
0.9904121757,
0.3248014748,
0.5865551233,
-1.5668181181,
0.074152559,
0.5218554735,
-0.5322691202,
-0.1353739649,
0.337949872,
0.373786509,
0.052183412,
0.3157689571,
-0.3583880663,
0.0998379067,
-0.3970583975,
0.1821126491,
0.3113507032,
-0.1239566877,
-0.4466655552,
-0.1094279438,
0.0714588389,
-0.3140571415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05871v1 | Towards a Robust Detection of Language Model Generated Text: Is ChatGPT that Easy to Detect? | 2023-06-09T13:03:53 | 2023-06-09T13:03:53 | Wissam Antoun, Virginie Mouilleron, Benoît Sagot, Djamé Seddah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in natural language processing (NLP) have led to the
development of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT. This paper
proposes a methodology for developing and evaluating ChatGPT detectors for
French text, with a focus on investigating their robustness on out-of-domain
data and against common attack schemes. The proposed method involves
translating an English dataset into French and training a classifier on the
translated data. Results show that the detectors can effectively detect
ChatGPT-generated text, with a degree of robustness against basic attack
techniques in in-domain settings. However, vulnerabilities are evident in
out-of-domain contexts, highlighting the challenge of detecting adversarial
text. The study emphasizes caution when applying in-domain testing results to a
wider variety of content. We provide our translated datasets and models as
open-source resources. https://gitlab.inria.fr/wantoun/robust-chatgpt-detection | [
-0.2663640678,
-1.043682456,
0.3788148463,
-0.0822282583,
-0.2082355767,
-0.001546715,
-0.4399935901,
-0.2869858742,
-0.2529477179,
0.6299607158,
-0.3077598214,
-0.3849303424,
-0.9434267879,
0.0466549173,
-0.7580325007,
1.0027743578,
0.0017658254,
-0.1228899136,
0.0511103086,
0.128687501,
-0.1702081412,
-0.9726679921,
-0.8897488713,
-0.2780201137,
0.0372194536,
0.0727801844,
0.6915767789,
0.0068597817,
0.6470543742,
0.1979129016,
-0.1170811057,
0.3974131942,
-0.5823685527,
0.2314134687,
0.1027882695,
-0.241238907,
-0.3693481088,
-0.297947675,
0.5351225138,
0.0645243376,
-0.0131673161,
-0.3766756058,
0.4480936825,
0.4009380937,
-0.2676308453,
0.253855288,
-1.0825589895,
-0.2097106427,
-0.4635208547,
-0.3760014474,
-0.9885810018,
0.0393248573,
-0.1427255869,
-0.0051147011,
0.359401077,
-0.0060943491,
0.8752484918,
-0.1289579719,
-0.4760887623,
-0.5872176886,
-0.4896046221,
0.6016588807,
-0.7152445912,
0.5387657285,
0.3962323368,
0.412987709,
-0.8385072947,
-0.7539348006,
-0.5262459517,
-0.3204964995,
-0.089396663,
0.0458611026,
-0.6703104377,
-0.286582619,
0.1177267954,
0.3361535072,
-1.0550057888,
-0.082409583,
0.1951290369,
-0.3988863528,
0.5414642692,
-0.3307843804,
0.8634164929,
-0.0490232408,
-0.2127045393,
-0.0538539216,
-0.7707508802,
-0.2522319853,
0.5943040252,
0.6178889871,
-0.2967510819,
0.5942087173,
0.1534874141,
0.5387676358,
-0.328386575,
-0.0753080994,
-0.1529113203,
-0.2386713773,
0.017498469,
-0.1968476921,
0.9640283585,
0.1831374466,
0.7567015886,
-0.2178564072,
-0.5240319371,
0.1148626804,
0.1690603495,
-0.9423189759,
-0.6365877986,
-0.0235849079,
-0.3028614223,
-0.5625647306,
-0.3449656963,
-0.587826848,
-0.3682607114,
0.3440137208,
0.2667999268,
-0.5713017583,
-0.2298407555,
0.2463028282,
0.0468792506,
0.1606625021,
0.0398428105,
-0.7698305845,
0.2840747535,
0.4882952273,
0.8039854765,
-0.3336542547,
0.1413080394,
-0.75448668,
-0.09606307,
-0.0358403139,
1.0671542883,
-0.3096179366,
-0.5617167354,
0.1784759015,
0.0085582146,
-0.1339794397,
-0.3903891742,
0.9017663002,
-0.6859089732,
0.4316918552,
0.2719768584,
-0.7036369443,
0.0880748555,
0.5947562456,
-0.6878129244,
1.1938035488,
0.0367763974,
-1.1876257658,
0.1839523613,
-0.4095153809,
-0.4882706702,
0.1168320253,
-0.0345340595,
-0.7385235429,
-0.1963089854,
0.6496959329,
0.6254178286,
-0.2431093007,
0.2108360827,
-0.2191165835,
0.029675262,
0.6263309121,
-1.0732200146,
0.7276822329,
0.1656420976,
-0.1257813275,
-0.22107853,
-0.6085767746,
0.1236533001,
0.4378315508,
-0.2948511243,
-0.2308070809,
0.2060694396,
0.4316626191,
-0.0416747667,
0.077620998,
-0.4022037089,
0.0877636224,
-0.5217562318,
0.6065548062,
0.4010020792,
0.325671941,
0.3065958023,
-0.148488,
0.4648424685,
-0.1615271568,
0.1155384034,
-0.3786765039,
-0.9464511275,
-0.562436223,
-0.4836904109,
0.2798435986,
0.6755799055,
-1.0801851749,
0.5818225145,
-0.1838394105,
-0.2883480191,
0.267752409,
0.0782947019,
0.278444916,
0.308440268,
0.1752955765,
-0.2880342305,
-0.1520176232,
-0.630662322,
-0.5642225146,
-0.3682134449,
-0.1852805316,
-0.0037332645,
0.8360440135,
-0.2180239111,
0.6589045525,
-0.4645638466,
0.0983605012,
-0.5290376544,
0.0094253365,
0.086135067,
0.3156923354,
0.705765605,
-0.9026848078,
-0.7367163897,
0.1952133179,
-0.716393888,
-0.2054038346,
0.0346735045,
-0.0682329684,
-0.0764737502,
0.5393036008,
-0.4645467401,
0.4280585945,
0.5473740101,
-0.1655647755,
0.1918451786,
0.0390870012,
0.0939943343,
-1.1952896118,
-0.1501714885,
0.2108988464,
-0.819588542,
-1.0309807062,
0.2756611705,
0.1542909592,
-0.4016980827,
-0.5560184717,
0.6225344539,
-0.1881334484,
0.3609325588,
-0.3582379818,
0.3165309131,
0.1492902339,
0.3936797678,
0.2027025223,
0.7227377892,
0.4148018062,
-0.3717247844,
0.2611702383,
0.1899739653,
-0.431366235,
0.592371285,
-0.59529531,
0.336779505,
0.1175301448,
0.3436364532,
-0.9759460688,
-0.2980223,
0.6396670938,
-0.8077789545,
0.4235014319,
-0.6759864092,
-0.7238179445,
-0.0582208037,
-0.0550637245,
0.1411402225,
0.3753919601,
-0.6817980409,
0.4180073738,
0.4897580743,
-0.1714838743,
-0.269865334,
-0.699713707,
0.2760286927,
-0.3803757131,
-1.0021066666,
0.0239157025,
0.0311663449,
-0.1864899248,
-0.2801674008,
0.0594242439,
-0.4713200927,
0.2687575519,
-0.0961502343,
0.1202610359,
-0.2189855278,
0.0124654686,
-0.2356904596,
-0.0504539348,
-0.0402492955,
-0.3953964412,
0.7124398947,
-0.0691602007,
-0.5101285577,
-0.2816559076,
0.4476791918,
0.4219767451,
-0.3034849465,
0.6836662889,
0.6021417975,
-0.5394769311,
-0.6516829729,
-0.1372237355,
-0.2972141802,
-0.4755581319,
0.246261254,
-0.2207641602,
-0.6637303233,
0.4898753762,
0.0590005144,
-0.1057068184,
0.3099288344,
0.7820949554,
0.2161398679,
1.1180636883,
0.625649035,
-0.0919842571,
0.4619395435,
-0.0713153929,
0.7381845117,
-0.2664800286,
0.209242478,
-0.6511287689,
0.3920336366,
-0.7328974009,
-0.4350167811,
0.2850225866,
0.0338657051,
0.0705472603,
0.5379419923,
-0.4658397138,
0.6028193831,
0.2224853337,
0.2122574598,
0.383746922,
0.1363675147,
0.1384368837,
0.030703526,
-0.6719092727,
-0.8766242862,
1.2293752432,
0.4731796384,
0.5918720365,
0.3200936615,
0.5047903061,
0.4738772213,
0.3034245372,
-0.8737701774,
0.3483013511,
-0.2488357723,
-0.4984292686,
0.098676838,
-0.3810367882,
-0.8174385428,
0.2391305268,
-0.2992382646,
-0.8699169159,
-0.1103599817,
0.1077234745,
0.0679556653,
0.5023675561,
-0.7870942354,
0.9550947547,
-0.1881037056,
-0.0003157992,
0.3044815063,
-0.097369723,
0.3814841807,
-0.3785021305,
0.2432181388,
-0.1835447252,
0.3638896644,
0.4279191792,
-0.2240667045,
0.8835167289,
0.1184929758,
-0.4741258323,
0.5100918412,
0.2815340161,
1.0149629116,
0.3439741731,
0.0714406744,
0.1022042111,
-0.260689646,
-0.4446842968,
-0.466026932,
0.5559603572,
-0.2271484286,
-0.1843624413,
-0.4945875108,
-0.5365246534,
-0.1680725962,
0.2144634575,
0.7152535319,
0.6492606997,
-0.5560521483,
0.0120153809,
0.8843525648,
-0.3950120807,
0.36406371,
0.4582174718,
-0.3293514252,
-0.0336453579,
0.894587934,
-0.3715973198,
0.2752592862,
0.5368989706,
0.0916414484,
-0.3182937205,
-0.7878784537,
-0.6887198687,
-0.1971137673,
-0.7680384517,
-0.2406304926,
-0.4674708545,
-0.437189877,
-0.3189878464,
-0.0988208428,
-0.4836108983,
-0.1386727393,
-0.0334063955,
0.2138415128,
0.4068532586,
0.4403780401,
0.4486200809,
0.6869796515,
-0.7413066626,
0.236319378,
0.1348737627,
0.060624402,
-0.3557831347,
-0.6209787726,
-0.1631157696,
0.1208833978,
-0.307682842,
-0.7256884575,
0.7318953276,
0.1530463547,
0.4184355736,
0.2473831624,
0.1257434636,
-0.1709287167,
-0.5218777061,
0.7577346563,
-0.0520688407,
-0.8059533238,
0.5619064569,
-0.6595306396,
0.1551795006,
0.1504188031,
0.2113432884,
-0.5076733828,
-0.6309868097,
-0.481264323,
-0.5926308632,
0.3934038579,
0.8673444986,
0.3150879443,
-0.1571341902,
0.1083214656,
-0.0698405951,
-0.084718667,
-1.0589625835,
-0.0437474474,
-0.0280630458,
-0.1844103336,
0.0123718772,
-0.0249158051,
-0.056194324,
0.4345018268,
0.7523894906,
-0.1855505556,
0.4202655256,
-0.108394675,
-0.3066670597,
0.2516020536,
0.3573255241,
0.3700273931,
0.1789130718,
-0.1288209707,
0.2125738561,
-0.0015280928,
-0.6595723033,
0.0593655705,
0.1173803434,
-0.2846956253,
0.1991221607,
0.6478185654,
0.4381089509,
0.0667102858,
-0.6532734632,
0.961101234,
-0.4262875617,
-0.0267838724,
-0.2105352134,
-0.1168491766,
-0.1357875168,
0.1571211815,
-0.09350802,
0.1275803,
0.0491974279,
-0.3845452666,
0.5059561729,
0.6604668498,
-0.4335968196,
-0.3383992016,
0.5871531367,
0.2008150816,
-0.2894080281,
0.4122627676,
-0.3516066968,
-0.9149300456,
0.4049705565,
0.6434853673,
0.9626951218,
-0.0490202829,
0.215192005,
-0.0635638461,
0.6213475466,
-0.2260152549,
0.0567948818,
0.2016576976,
-1.2544667721,
-0.3208465874,
-0.3110865057,
-0.3530568779,
0.3670763969,
-0.3401746154,
0.4284293354,
-0.0075278482,
-0.1673950404,
0.0342636257,
-0.4177266657,
-0.4469052851,
0.0426224284,
0.3184021413,
0.7889813185,
-0.9821639657,
1.0558325052,
0.3247089386,
0.0141484672,
-0.3656281829,
0.3670037389,
0.1946273148,
-1.0405361652,
0.3474337757,
0.1253409535,
-0.2201194465,
-0.205251351,
-0.6020857096,
-0.4901043475,
0.3437201977,
0.4431411922,
-0.3118679821,
0.2774324715,
0.2399631292,
0.5401079059,
-0.0665606037,
0.1063849926,
0.5046194792,
0.3340024948,
-0.1740323305,
-0.7345593572,
-0.2301330268,
-0.3956854045,
-0.3625512719,
0.5703776479,
-0.2957027256,
0.6470335126,
0.3741863668,
-0.4658512473,
0.1091663986,
0.5089892745,
-0.1471609026,
0.200263992,
0.3209308684,
0.4479801953,
0.6666567922,
-0.2826153934,
1.2080630064,
-0.41150859,
0.4300820827,
0.9199077487,
-0.2040010393,
0.7851043344,
0.1498519033,
0.0180099476,
0.1074250266,
0.43482095,
-0.0423145853,
0.4948887825,
0.2269230634,
-0.5511900187,
-0.3307247162,
-0.0486888364,
-0.2768743634,
0.4945794046,
0.4608027041,
-0.2025560886,
-0.4238705337,
-0.0284001119,
0.4724005759,
0.3666407764,
-0.1540992558,
0.4477047324,
0.2054089755,
-0.3742344379,
0.5858527422,
0.1447261721,
0.6699727774,
-0.6527462602,
0.1645779163,
-0.1760125905,
0.446092844,
-0.0014012062,
-0.7810943723,
0.1524648666,
0.4730935395,
0.1363694072,
-0.2346767336,
1.1405470371,
-0.4979924858,
-0.5114509463,
0.1612835675,
0.6964326501,
0.0973709822,
-0.4036404192,
-0.5925480723,
-0.0745925531,
0.0907361358,
-0.3058153987,
0.476742357,
0.5495631099,
-0.1877310276,
0.6644023061,
0.5814193487,
-0.1106486693,
-0.1268046945,
0.1042646021,
0.7877592444,
-0.105597131,
-0.4054741859,
-1.0318300724,
0.269128114,
-0.1908774823,
-0.0867639184,
0.9185837507,
0.5798512697,
0.8336020708,
0.0287715886,
1.0008140802,
0.0865523815,
0.4072570801,
-0.7582470179,
0.8223145604,
-0.2274437696,
0.5485949516,
-0.1648640782,
-0.8088197708,
-0.5271085501,
0.4980247915,
-0.1690457314,
-0.1336479038,
0.6298491359,
0.9655524492,
-0.286537379,
0.0565984063,
0.4006467462,
-0.0391134545,
0.8120783567,
0.5599629283,
0.9447674155,
-0.5991849303,
0.8053674698,
-0.1338595003,
-0.2091525793,
-0.0240087006,
-1.1922454834,
-1.4836642742,
-0.3997849524,
-0.3741316199,
-0.5204015374,
0.0631988719,
0.4626054168,
0.4040551484,
-1.0502470732,
-0.0648469403,
-0.1245600954,
0.0387053266,
0.1206018403,
-0.1954504997,
0.5118641853,
-0.2914363444,
-0.8478035331,
0.6907990575,
0.2267803252,
0.3203880489,
0.0077785286,
0.1230007559,
0.0281626116,
0.3760988712,
0.6306228042,
0.2741061151,
-0.359844625,
-0.3410981596,
-0.0950371698,
-0.1615722179,
-0.0739910454,
0.8002545238,
-0.2895949781,
0.4372785985,
0.643879354,
0.4534466565,
0.353913784,
-0.3109372556,
0.7480751872,
-1.0333852768,
0.3864671886,
0.2133693844,
0.5934506655,
0.5478182435,
-0.323510021,
0.6260365248,
0.1567811668,
-0.6820734143,
-1.0318778753,
0.4265669286,
-0.8937601447,
-0.1807508767,
1.1950618029,
-0.3944253325,
-0.0114702284,
-0.3008968532,
-0.3122968078,
0.0969103947,
-0.4391722083,
0.4907857478,
0.7553469539,
0.2039085776,
0.1101571172,
-0.8667730093,
0.6083546877,
-0.0471547507,
-0.8357804418,
0.2210916728,
0.0563106872,
0.1062980294,
-0.0358710587,
0.4557914734,
-0.1785156578,
0.0392895453,
0.0170017648,
-0.0083964029,
0.4233434796,
-0.101846762,
-0.0971135274,
-0.0060650506,
0.1116559729,
0.0231174696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05861v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05861v1 | Efficient Encoder-Decoder and Dual-Path Conformer for Comprehensive Feature Learning in Speech Enhancement | 2023-06-09T12:52:01 | 2023-06-09T12:52:01 | Junyu Wang | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Current speech enhancement (SE) research has largely neglected channel
attention and spatial attention, and encoder-decoder architecture-based
networks have not adequately considered how to provide efficient inputs to the
intermediate enhancement layer. To address these issues, this paper proposes a
time-frequency (T-F) domain SE network (DPCFCS-Net) that incorporates improved
densely connected blocks, dual-path modules, convolution-augmented transformers
(conformers), channel attention, and spatial attention. Compared with previous
models, our proposed model has a more efficient encoder-decoder and can learn
comprehensive features. Experimental results on the VCTK+DEMAND dataset
demonstrate that our method outperforms existing techniques in SE performance.
Furthermore, the improved densely connected block and two dimensions attention
module developed in this work are highly adaptable and easily integrated into
existing networks. | [
-0.393117696,
-0.6714016795,
0.1712999344,
0.5418205857,
-0.4121950269,
0.1668313444,
-0.3080690503,
-0.3623992205,
0.2494049221,
0.3871577382,
-0.5784401894,
-0.2074908465,
-0.5724767447,
-0.0530649796,
-0.3775830567,
0.1565758437,
0.348143369,
0.0940384567,
0.2086203098,
0.0988782942,
-0.4008568227,
-0.4396770895,
-0.671018362,
-0.3410410583,
0.2991198897,
0.2212376446,
0.1615044624,
0.4703083038,
0.5202563405,
0.3207012713,
-0.3461607397,
0.1861088276,
-0.4610837102,
0.1419845223,
-0.1994235218,
0.2571829259,
-0.6669453979,
-0.5454548001,
0.8423309922,
0.8614198565,
-0.1534056515,
-0.0904738382,
0.3919736147,
0.5868029594,
-0.7527452111,
0.0960785002,
-0.5278250575,
0.2221202701,
-0.1797325164,
-0.2257055789,
-0.2703453302,
-0.1650420874,
0.4759094417,
-0.5283387303,
0.350130409,
-0.6072762609,
0.5036808252,
0.3876455724,
-0.4492978156,
0.0620681532,
-0.8130239844,
0.6070657969,
-0.2077581286,
0.9696941972,
0.1748976558,
0.4254364669,
-0.0619819574,
-0.941121459,
-0.1870640963,
-0.1219616309,
0.0823216811,
0.2542974949,
-0.2491014749,
0.3602156043,
0.1578271389,
0.308613658,
-0.5000674129,
0.030431252,
-0.4515276253,
-0.2824770808,
0.4621286094,
-0.0830676183,
-0.0366010778,
0.1778887659,
-0.2712459862,
-0.0216571484,
-0.3644532561,
0.312492609,
-0.2558217347,
0.3400268555,
-0.0969161242,
0.1616432369,
-0.1830196679,
0.7852699757,
0.2961711287,
-0.0215406325,
0.3749372661,
-0.3048457503,
-0.3377169371,
0.3534115255,
0.3181997836,
-0.3035435081,
0.1052367911,
-0.2879450023,
-0.1603726596,
-0.0545128994,
0.2996339798,
-0.8652233481,
-0.317520231,
0.144696191,
-0.3545728624,
-0.2092229724,
0.215192914,
-0.6931229234,
-0.01940904,
-0.552372694,
0.4326025546,
-0.3381360769,
-0.442434907,
0.3590522707,
-0.2529363334,
0.2182067037,
0.1955947876,
-0.8775438666,
0.5626528859,
0.6797056198,
1.0708516836,
0.0094945943,
0.0879825056,
-0.6095657945,
0.3254070878,
-0.1409883797,
0.6994784474,
-0.8018063307,
-0.5199347734,
-0.2248354554,
-0.0364863463,
-0.0592745878,
-0.6095664501,
0.6667076945,
-0.4933869541,
-0.2767710984,
-0.2122821957,
-0.1696154177,
-0.2776677012,
-0.2151361406,
-0.5363715291,
0.7675106525,
0.2550415099,
-0.2004695833,
0.3033193946,
-0.7160460353,
-0.7004984021,
0.2169117779,
-0.0012120793,
-0.3204045594,
0.1993951648,
0.4671193063,
0.3575371206,
0.1547607332,
0.4561063051,
-0.5020534396,
-0.5993446708,
0.1585468352,
-0.5150622725,
0.6975164413,
0.1715798378,
-0.4813478291,
0.121819891,
-0.954498589,
-0.0408245064,
0.0746812597,
-0.4318138063,
-0.1856465787,
-0.1110571846,
0.086239554,
0.1054813936,
0.0779114068,
-0.5861031413,
-0.1903782338,
-0.4954821467,
0.6231339574,
0.7062342167,
0.2312561721,
0.5348428488,
-0.1278977841,
0.2300633192,
0.0889140442,
0.1982551962,
0.0348591618,
0.0564194769,
-0.7543908358,
-0.3548090458,
0.1100176498,
0.2609575987,
-0.3749523759,
0.7456932068,
-0.4723150432,
-0.3506779969,
-0.2613550127,
-0.0232658777,
0.2765835822,
0.6170107722,
0.4827822447,
-0.372390449,
-0.5219482183,
-0.7627561688,
0.053411983,
0.25765118,
-0.2416850328,
0.6153174043,
0.0852343515,
0.0872264057,
0.7351260781,
-0.3952157497,
-0.4101630449,
-0.1607900858,
-0.5373416543,
0.1122436896,
0.2165927589,
0.6319997907,
-0.7671350837,
-0.5994205475,
-0.0246463306,
-0.2023987472,
-0.2606694698,
-0.0639748722,
-0.0969636738,
-0.2545333803,
0.123366341,
0.121321924,
0.2508065403,
0.4087309241,
-0.2060785294,
0.1522577852,
0.1276088059,
0.0069395364,
-0.8642119765,
0.1641410738,
0.2561352253,
-0.2376893163,
-1.0696004629,
-0.6461467147,
0.1793043762,
-0.3218219578,
-0.3556890786,
0.2103871852,
-0.2369263768,
-0.0381634906,
-0.2723638117,
0.2990969121,
0.2553081512,
0.7165103555,
0.2313642204,
0.7713021636,
0.7618973851,
-0.7487397194,
0.3329620361,
0.3045314848,
0.1035024151,
0.3427608907,
-0.8990001678,
0.3707076311,
-0.0941305384,
0.2682397664,
-0.7023766041,
-0.2277458161,
-0.0373838618,
-0.3903748691,
0.5729410052,
-0.1092829853,
0.0704404861,
-0.3981778324,
-0.2856684029,
0.4056164026,
0.417930603,
-0.9366303086,
0.4200035036,
0.6250748634,
-0.0476102382,
-0.622623384,
-0.749370873,
0.0925341845,
0.0267247055,
-0.8882516026,
0.5305595398,
0.2356850654,
0.1682916433,
-0.1329915822,
-0.4221285582,
-0.2566483021,
0.2071221471,
-0.0836571828,
-0.3399100304,
-0.1825263947,
0.1584926546,
0.3364916742,
0.107056506,
-0.0676575676,
-0.6187758446,
0.461763382,
0.0490057468,
-0.1249881536,
-0.6855112314,
0.4677835107,
0.363008827,
-0.5417492986,
0.2459614575,
0.6489685774,
-0.4553291798,
-0.4547737241,
-0.424827069,
-0.4550391734,
-0.5543156266,
0.7737920284,
-0.5006061196,
-1.3025426865,
0.2300077677,
-0.1624267846,
-0.1565480679,
0.095055759,
0.1062494144,
0.1919889748,
0.809717834,
0.2745220065,
0.0581616499,
0.8290577531,
-0.2997399867,
0.0308481343,
-1.1570012569,
-0.4709976017,
-0.52380687,
-0.4290026128,
-0.2001811266,
-0.2518621981,
0.5185226798,
0.128502652,
-0.3775616288,
0.2692564428,
-0.7132976055,
0.1372703165,
0.2262804657,
0.5939459205,
-0.2022784054,
0.3359838426,
0.1447202116,
-0.0500686765,
-0.6962743402,
-0.003270207,
0.7127361298,
0.4895162582,
0.4646421671,
0.3640298545,
0.2548939288,
0.1162625626,
-0.3911755681,
-0.8201221824,
0.5156366825,
-0.7287656665,
-0.1637905389,
-0.2115635127,
-0.468783766,
-0.7094961405,
0.3449124992,
-0.1666505188,
-0.5291586518,
0.9097052217,
0.216294691,
-0.4202475548,
0.1705256701,
-0.4505517483,
0.3888892531,
-0.2454252392,
-0.4000680447,
-0.4038465619,
-0.4933118224,
0.0515548587,
-0.2467410564,
-0.2701365352,
0.0543832742,
-0.0864532143,
0.6799647808,
-0.2123069912,
0.7898616195,
-0.5412861705,
0.171601072,
0.1969178021,
-0.1784798652,
0.3209115267,
0.0870110765,
-0.2581436932,
0.2854822576,
-0.5899406672,
-0.2825669646,
-0.5406348705,
0.4528540969,
-0.7242105603,
-0.5794818997,
0.0737827048,
-0.1340315342,
-0.4240436256,
0.2348456383,
-0.111507453,
1.0679167509,
-0.3148580194,
0.5547529459,
0.8612478971,
-0.025276769,
0.4829752445,
0.2416540235,
0.4136753678,
-0.7244058251,
0.7399882674,
0.1469382346,
0.3739764988,
0.5256623626,
0.3184905052,
-0.3922670484,
-0.7041047812,
-0.0761709809,
0.1930090338,
-0.3365723491,
-0.2019627243,
-0.8393250108,
-0.6468392611,
-0.701960206,
-0.066612646,
-0.3643478453,
-0.4432959259,
-0.4482404292,
0.0330961458,
0.2400672585,
0.5593337417,
-0.1972323507,
0.5028075576,
-0.734175086,
0.2649671137,
0.5333708525,
0.5417221785,
0.1966805756,
-0.9331279397,
-0.3812080324,
-0.0171459541,
-0.3333808482,
-0.6328282356,
0.2608270049,
0.797322154,
0.5890431404,
0.5853855014,
-0.0756386742,
0.7810397744,
-0.4134960473,
0.5569961667,
0.0198783111,
-1.0292391777,
0.755107224,
-0.2936053276,
0.458574295,
0.3200504184,
-0.1155665442,
-0.3955565095,
-0.0236649495,
-0.1606005132,
-0.7368804812,
1.0163968801,
0.218747884,
0.0699287876,
0.2166645825,
0.5587694645,
-0.1538148522,
-0.0029164869,
-0.3321775496,
-0.2207757831,
-0.6205762029,
-0.0623775385,
0.0901436359,
-0.4519460201,
0.1207119748,
-0.3433275521,
0.5257959962,
-0.0386205427,
0.3565571904,
0.5105534196,
0.0587756447,
-0.0533211306,
0.317027539,
0.6853755713,
0.4431000054,
-0.309678942,
0.0948548466,
0.3388593197,
-0.9232252836,
0.152504921,
0.2532944381,
0.0236212742,
-0.0560713038,
0.2220252752,
1.221965313,
0.0866656676,
0.1451665908,
0.615041554,
-0.2421610206,
-0.380484879,
-0.4428350925,
0.3235527277,
-0.0746989101,
0.2834692001,
0.1963503659,
0.252432555,
0.5464326739,
0.0541459359,
0.3835688531,
0.3864668012,
-0.8062318563,
-0.4145315588,
0.4778170288,
0.6520110965,
-0.3214480877,
0.4864087999,
0.121621944,
-0.5608707666,
0.5822786689,
0.7025211453,
1.2748920918,
-0.6811870933,
-0.0992682874,
0.4654061794,
0.1509335041,
0.2761634886,
0.3532781601,
-0.4564010501,
-0.3803734779,
-0.4128167331,
-0.6697016358,
0.1089709103,
0.1883845925,
-0.5358996987,
0.448925525,
-0.3675860763,
-0.1867769361,
-0.0698106959,
-0.1107507646,
-0.4447272122,
0.2070384771,
0.1344020814,
0.8357037306,
-0.5519981384,
1.1063899994,
0.631867826,
0.186625272,
-0.7527165413,
0.0672179312,
-0.0302075669,
-0.4229761362,
0.4424971342,
0.153175801,
-0.4891064465,
0.0975497812,
0.0119724981,
-1.0001548529,
1.20588696,
0.3411654234,
-0.9588577151,
0.224731788,
0.2400175333,
0.4031393528,
-0.338004142,
0.1075393036,
0.4544524252,
0.2402762473,
0.2348301113,
-0.863075316,
-0.0561294779,
-0.1796309948,
0.3203502595,
0.2343727797,
-0.8379661441,
0.2038081884,
0.0371360779,
-0.2914208472,
-0.3759428263,
0.6142295599,
0.0410212353,
0.1025399044,
0.8563050032,
0.2568776608,
0.6114897728,
-0.2364018857,
0.4813784361,
-0.0378055684,
0.1201625913,
0.8932800889,
0.0523236543,
0.6098723412,
0.1283967644,
-0.1064856425,
0.2193384171,
0.5979473591,
-0.038897559,
0.8322901726,
0.1547147632,
-0.5114970207,
-0.4750621021,
-0.3047906756,
-0.4426854253,
0.7617127895,
0.6660190225,
-0.2804709077,
-0.0732973665,
0.1646574736,
-0.4217050374,
-0.1038883701,
-0.4145463407,
0.9610483646,
0.3869989216,
-0.0559996031,
0.4407258928,
-0.4070563316,
0.5079320669,
-0.7557581663,
-0.0722942278,
-0.0917481259,
0.2722364366,
-0.2877123654,
-0.607088387,
0.3599206507,
-0.2618233263,
-0.144627884,
0.1017318442,
0.8505614996,
-0.5779296756,
-0.3421711326,
0.5773791075,
-0.0648737848,
-0.2549104095,
0.013347391,
-0.6261584759,
0.1109801084,
0.0234063156,
-0.1721204966,
-0.0001338211,
0.2569649518,
0.264834553,
0.3150241077,
0.477820158,
0.1387774199,
-0.1079217941,
0.6051847339,
1.0334039927,
-0.478534013,
-0.6318534017,
-0.6173753738,
0.5604866743,
-0.4267894328,
0.1429302841,
0.2524224222,
0.44991678,
0.6053706408,
0.2506715357,
0.7284329534,
0.2196614593,
0.4321233034,
-0.4313419759,
0.5926886201,
-0.5871258974,
0.3841244578,
-0.157655552,
-0.9903720021,
-0.4762108624,
0.4021320343,
0.1500441283,
0.3066124618,
0.5559886098,
0.6559483409,
-0.4306225479,
0.2416751683,
0.4158757627,
0.2222377658,
0.5788429379,
0.7449626327,
0.4730103314,
-0.3271054924,
0.6023492217,
-0.6532962322,
-0.6270179749,
-0.0205639116,
-0.3584489822,
-0.8198739886,
-0.5798672438,
-0.3307369351,
-0.26715976,
0.2650435269,
0.6621575952,
0.882641077,
-0.9199674129,
-0.1742717028,
-0.004679536,
-0.2963699996,
-0.2901271284,
-0.1545075625,
0.7411838174,
-0.4292851686,
-0.5978301167,
0.7341009378,
0.5440641046,
0.0449594744,
-0.0940424874,
0.0506970584,
0.1782257855,
0.0374393538,
0.6034275889,
-0.0237425976,
-0.4342342615,
-0.4589467943,
0.3018139303,
0.0999765471,
0.1091544181,
0.9806858897,
-0.6791825294,
0.6943264008,
0.4851310849,
0.6716715097,
0.4972150922,
0.0294012036,
0.578746438,
-0.8552000523,
0.1622897536,
0.3975182474,
0.4584338069,
0.169062838,
-0.5847170949,
0.2624443769,
0.2443834245,
-0.7489209771,
-0.3635686338,
0.3115803897,
-1.2896556854,
-0.2012517601,
1.1074590683,
-0.0662675053,
-0.2811573744,
-0.5204902291,
-0.0663664639,
0.2879836559,
-0.7422584891,
0.497323662,
0.0864026621,
-0.227766946,
-0.1203260645,
-0.0615656674,
0.555901885,
0.2825638056,
-0.413731575,
0.1345821619,
0.4324633479,
0.1750196517,
0.0198550094,
0.3984246552,
-0.3439149261,
0.4350131154,
-0.0617183745,
-0.3080926538,
-0.376814425,
-0.465577811,
-0.8521351218,
0.281576246,
-0.022149479,
-0.2866865396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05836v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05836v3 | Can Large Language Models Infer Causation from Correlation? | 2023-06-09T12:09:15 | 2024-04-17T04:27:10 | Zhijing Jin, Jiarui Liu, Zhiheng Lyu, Spencer Poff, Mrinmaya Sachan, Rada Mihalcea, Mona Diab, Bernhard Schölkopf | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Causal inference is one of the hallmarks of human intelligence. While the
field of CausalNLP has attracted much interest in the recent years, existing
causal inference datasets in NLP primarily rely on discovering causality from
empirical knowledge (e.g., commonsense knowledge). In this work, we propose the
first benchmark dataset to test the pure causal inference skills of large
language models (LLMs). Specifically, we formulate a novel task Corr2Cause,
which takes a set of correlational statements and determines the causal
relationship between the variables. We curate a large-scale dataset of more
than 200K samples, on which we evaluate seventeen existing LLMs. Through our
experiments, we identify a key shortcoming of LLMs in terms of their causal
inference skills, and show that these models achieve almost close to random
performance on the task. This shortcoming is somewhat mitigated when we try to
re-purpose LLMs for this skill via finetuning, but we find that these models
still fail to generalize -- they can only perform causal inference in
in-distribution settings when variable names and textual expressions used in
the queries are similar to those in the training set, but fail in
out-of-distribution settings generated by perturbing these queries. Corr2Cause
is a challenging task for LLMs, and would be helpful in guiding future research
on improving LLMs' pure reasoning skills and generalizability. Our data is at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/causalnlp/corr2cause. Our code is at
https://github.com/causalNLP/corr2cause. | [
-0.0142034339,
-0.9824122787,
0.5554966927,
0.44131428,
-0.0251537357,
-0.4492785335,
-0.3253674805,
-0.5916669965,
-0.0858947411,
0.5715040565,
-0.4878016412,
-0.3067786992,
-0.4594888687,
-0.0554322712,
-0.4787459373,
0.8405026793,
0.2395667732,
0.1494059265,
-0.339743346,
-0.1594366133,
-0.6650838256,
-0.409040302,
-0.9478634596,
-0.5363530517,
0.7668864131,
0.4321086407,
0.5273700356,
0.2897937,
0.5172089934,
0.0724769607,
0.0496103168,
0.2591264844,
-0.7369921207,
0.018128505,
-0.5473189354,
-0.6488128901,
-0.1001529992,
-0.0902021229,
0.5506368876,
1.0510292053,
-0.2081476599,
0.0460224189,
0.1329783052,
0.4624775946,
-0.8489074111,
0.2167592049,
-0.8599200845,
-0.0355339982,
-0.1345496327,
-0.1890964955,
-0.7355064154,
-0.1736344844,
0.0539998151,
-0.6360766888,
0.3862783015,
0.4550565183,
0.8375806808,
0.4487295747,
-0.5140400529,
-0.2675516009,
-0.830722928,
0.8867465854,
-0.7051131129,
0.2541226745,
0.4481344223,
0.2684985995,
-0.539450109,
-0.7070230246,
-0.6177180409,
-0.2717684805,
-0.0900606066,
0.2252181768,
0.0046427543,
-0.2449550331,
0.4364155233,
0.064367868,
-0.577794075,
0.6047539711,
-0.0287282374,
-0.1186747253,
0.5191891193,
0.3502388597,
0.1704790294,
0.1855505556,
-0.5582277179,
-0.3056462705,
-1.0207979679,
0.0587652065,
0.1750027537,
0.359133631,
-0.3422103822,
0.5289636254,
-0.0819642618,
0.6995429397,
-0.1903518587,
0.0378287993,
-0.1783049405,
-0.1581592709,
-0.3900005221,
-0.0133197065,
0.8073841333,
0.1888311356,
0.366882503,
-0.2999143898,
0.2563378513,
-0.0482760593,
-0.1846178323,
-0.6141827106,
-0.2548300028,
0.0880097151,
0.0479920171,
0.0221383385,
-0.0500817746,
-0.5937043428,
-0.5247514844,
-0.3524856567,
0.3319437206,
0.036377117,
-0.048953969,
0.5097094774,
-0.1783792526,
0.3090791702,
0.1694346815,
-0.6773843169,
0.3303428292,
0.8709326982,
0.5169650912,
-0.1654737443,
-0.4530639648,
-0.6395779848,
0.1669957787,
-0.3943251073,
0.8134441376,
-0.2776786983,
0.0316618085,
0.1138457209,
-0.0276844874,
-0.2119026333,
-0.6195361614,
0.9047372341,
-0.6944031715,
-0.0302161854,
-0.4253227413,
-0.6642025709,
0.0789507106,
-0.1214910448,
-0.6159179211,
0.6902436614,
-0.3917904794,
-0.9477881789,
0.4664030075,
-0.0459310003,
-0.5031304359,
-0.2899678946,
-0.2648088038,
-0.6497245431,
-0.0600567013,
-0.0586361103,
0.5788833499,
-0.9363738894,
0.919030726,
-0.7989529967,
-0.2790683806,
0.2256307751,
-0.4275780022,
1.0449584723,
-0.1826968789,
-0.2097450495,
-0.2797949612,
-0.7275873423,
-0.3541549742,
0.2446206659,
0.1238504425,
-0.506144166,
0.2804448903,
-0.1193072721,
0.2562413812,
-0.048180908,
-0.3537245095,
-0.0723509118,
-0.1687174886,
0.0695720538,
0.5305864215,
0.1440729499,
0.2377509177,
-0.2522521615,
-0.0263841283,
0.1501494199,
0.0592578277,
0.2949644923,
-0.498416394,
-0.7985534072,
-0.2486457974,
-0.179747358,
0.559581995,
-0.5720373988,
0.544036746,
-0.180061236,
-0.4580382407,
0.1535369307,
0.1392613798,
0.5581194162,
0.7839915156,
0.5040300488,
-0.0553396344,
-0.4587358236,
-1.0176122189,
-0.473998189,
-0.0064033121,
-0.1111108884,
0.2381417602,
0.4852505028,
-0.1121446043,
0.8202909231,
-0.7118866444,
-0.3426010013,
0.0568133108,
0.3146218657,
0.3773351312,
0.3715820014,
0.2727764249,
-0.5146388412,
-0.1086589172,
-0.3143693209,
-0.9614965916,
-0.3096747398,
-0.225295186,
-0.1797842234,
-0.2032539696,
0.830075264,
-0.3806040585,
0.0959864855,
0.5771365762,
-0.5427958965,
0.7236683965,
-0.3401865959,
-0.2858923674,
-0.8499501944,
0.4327168167,
0.2122839689,
0.0888150185,
-0.5218774676,
-0.0075780493,
-0.0588654429,
0.1015417352,
-0.2235582024,
0.8036874533,
-0.3010010719,
-0.1311276406,
-0.0642021149,
0.1683116704,
0.0802225918,
0.44333902,
0.1252839118,
0.4903050065,
0.3337017,
-0.5911156535,
0.0524642728,
0.2760692835,
-0.5096601248,
0.4703069031,
-0.811126709,
-0.1760449857,
-0.1830351502,
0.4186953604,
-1.1499158144,
-0.4716010094,
-0.2168278545,
-0.0609603636,
0.1338517964,
0.0358208232,
-0.8669735193,
-0.365760535,
0.1393295974,
0.2909696102,
0.2983199656,
-0.783602953,
0.074573189,
0.1975437105,
0.1316603124,
-0.5159937143,
-0.8252786398,
0.1398165226,
-0.2976356447,
-0.5342998505,
-0.040908765,
0.0961918905,
-0.3320169449,
-0.4525571764,
0.1595068425,
-0.2122098058,
0.3486596346,
0.2387515754,
0.1328105927,
-0.0502743572,
0.3564730585,
0.0666329265,
-0.0314772986,
0.3287508488,
0.2008890659,
0.4894658029,
0.2395012379,
-0.4531056583,
-0.4383147359,
-0.0250116624,
0.2562004924,
-0.1329907328,
0.8501497507,
0.456174165,
-0.1345813125,
-0.3545992076,
-0.8222076297,
-0.4087442756,
-0.2976062,
0.2949910462,
-0.0136834001,
-0.9538035989,
0.736463666,
-0.0598048642,
-0.1121463329,
0.5384901762,
0.4959146082,
0.0165229179,
0.60944736,
0.1882422417,
-0.2339479178,
0.2698180079,
-0.270916909,
0.169896543,
-0.8199166059,
-0.1266130656,
-0.6186576486,
0.0503434688,
-0.5387483239,
-0.6194147468,
0.3984623849,
0.2650336921,
-0.6169441342,
0.0395127572,
0.1910169572,
0.2711654007,
0.3787248135,
0.2828046978,
0.4667162597,
0.0352920145,
0.0484313555,
0.2115970254,
-0.7215414643,
-0.086334236,
1.0148037672,
0.1109603345,
0.791380465,
0.0520301498,
0.4215486348,
0.0362131819,
0.284701854,
-0.3450098932,
0.4358228743,
-0.3163169622,
-0.6556727886,
-0.3197838366,
-0.4508790076,
-1.0939021111,
0.1714868695,
-0.3325416148,
-0.6890306473,
0.3730175197,
0.1718648523,
-0.2241268754,
0.1467638016,
-0.6357142925,
0.8417335749,
0.0426847115,
-1.0951291323,
-0.3594184518,
-0.7230231166,
1.0107501745,
-0.1475819349,
0.1781451702,
-0.2813401818,
0.3155460358,
0.694077909,
-0.3031909764,
1.130009532,
-0.1270284355,
-0.0805565789,
0.28579247,
-0.0325374901,
0.7213196158,
0.1335632652,
-0.2625223398,
0.1657871902,
-0.2063253373,
-0.4717304707,
-0.5474613309,
0.8545896411,
-0.6766514778,
-0.4863617122,
-0.1732853353,
-0.5931187868,
-0.429248035,
0.135329634,
-0.1301969886,
0.5479623079,
-0.3151381016,
0.3198339641,
0.6587821841,
-0.3235372603,
0.3645449877,
0.6449878216,
-0.0755186453,
-0.3187104464,
0.623960793,
-0.1853087097,
0.3276162446,
0.3962561786,
0.5864199996,
-0.3199472129,
-0.2647567689,
-0.0730802342,
0.3592362404,
-0.4906330407,
-0.1459860951,
-0.4937045574,
0.0974726081,
-0.0779698268,
-0.0657765344,
-0.1926114261,
-0.1721626818,
-0.3017300367,
0.1543433815,
0.3215126097,
0.3646984398,
-0.1651655436,
0.2319883257,
-0.4462940991,
0.4772875309,
0.497004807,
0.1895184666,
0.4008261859,
-0.5375394225,
-0.305901885,
0.0396171324,
-0.079034999,
-0.2652341425,
0.2466422915,
0.2401932031,
0.4314726889,
0.6137810349,
0.0840201676,
0.7962039709,
-0.4419107437,
0.6865736842,
0.3269233704,
-0.3546464443,
0.2322943211,
-0.6349313259,
0.1427042484,
0.5536360145,
0.4088185132,
-0.424760133,
-0.5316441059,
-0.6638257504,
-0.755964458,
0.317938894,
0.0643390343,
-0.2308860719,
-0.3236869276,
0.4849824607,
0.0244441815,
-0.1693102717,
-0.452721417,
-0.2547384202,
0.4045425653,
0.0856121555,
-0.5215887427,
-0.3664183319,
-0.1124088541,
-0.2386877239,
0.5126990676,
-0.1131840572,
0.014317547,
0.2912658453,
-0.162656635,
-0.0947412401,
0.0360047854,
0.6771015525,
0.7652209401,
-0.3111302555,
0.200240463,
0.141403392,
-0.2346736193,
-0.0330504477,
0.0541694984,
-0.1204623356,
-0.3697086573,
0.8146323562,
0.5930005312,
0.6081482172,
-0.7344782352,
0.5852413774,
-0.0236486159,
0.1092621759,
-0.5468505621,
0.1171997935,
0.3321720958,
0.1586135328,
0.3345195949,
-0.2324265242,
0.0600336082,
-0.6107031703,
0.2120237797,
0.4774118662,
-0.1774463505,
-0.3423790932,
0.8607548475,
-0.0920296684,
0.1643442363,
0.5538705587,
-0.0805412158,
-0.0403793752,
0.7679521441,
0.6469369531,
0.6645824909,
-0.0269525852,
-0.067655161,
0.7869289517,
-0.0047802306,
-0.4977108538,
0.0595289655,
0.3007612228,
-0.9481164813,
-0.6531667113,
-0.5162917972,
-0.4145459831,
0.2188192308,
-0.7456461787,
0.288477689,
-0.3673882186,
0.1259369701,
0.0084339548,
0.0215137284,
-0.8631042838,
0.331931293,
-0.137420848,
0.8180277348,
-1.3587297201,
0.8130961657,
0.1605446488,
-0.3696915805,
-0.6450837851,
-0.077674821,
-0.0973110646,
-0.9145408869,
1.1361943483,
-0.1108630225,
0.111308746,
0.0274220966,
-0.677750349,
-0.63639009,
1.1616741419,
0.2903822958,
-0.7285235524,
0.0229778402,
0.3562866151,
0.6366399527,
-0.0421200655,
0.323247999,
0.578780055,
0.3789139092,
0.1077824086,
-0.7710914016,
0.1505669206,
0.3390475512,
-0.1735248417,
-0.1120987013,
-0.8027177453,
0.7349939346,
-0.2126857936,
0.1112411544,
0.0209333058,
0.6973504424,
0.5218154192,
0.4236496389,
0.3869989514,
0.9468050003,
0.8431811929,
0.1563655585,
1.1471323967,
-0.0830523819,
0.4637929201,
1.6355677843,
-0.4239185154,
1.0369366407,
0.5212378502,
-0.1705360413,
0.4394181371,
0.1841783375,
0.1040210649,
0.4589370489,
0.3655268848,
-0.1728233546,
-0.5113294125,
-0.3945320547,
-0.0098006697,
0.4120184481,
0.3759429455,
-0.1915294081,
-0.4365701675,
-0.1838404089,
0.1791153103,
0.1004945934,
-0.1115285903,
0.6104219556,
0.3642475605,
-0.6788319945,
0.5665755868,
-0.3042070866,
0.4169405699,
-0.5451033115,
0.0359116793,
-0.4720068872,
0.4400019348,
-0.0577728972,
-0.5223376751,
0.2888566256,
-0.381424129,
-0.2118980438,
0.0977569893,
0.587222755,
-0.4340456426,
-0.4690080881,
0.4760707617,
0.3796336651,
-0.0391799957,
-0.0700807795,
-0.2653775811,
-0.1288488656,
-0.2356131226,
-0.0001963544,
0.4115563631,
0.4332025349,
-0.3317467272,
0.6882122159,
0.711779058,
0.1629280597,
-0.0018399406,
0.3281658888,
0.6488054991,
-0.6172086,
-0.151508674,
-0.8468036056,
0.2265803665,
-0.1654672325,
-0.2293571681,
0.7880904078,
0.7145074606,
0.5736497045,
-0.2600493729,
0.4464379549,
0.1901158541,
0.5562535524,
-0.6132600904,
0.5372191668,
-0.5345447063,
-0.0021782592,
-0.191495508,
-0.6062956452,
-0.6406778097,
0.1914834529,
-0.6325326562,
-0.385653019,
0.8780642152,
0.9894368649,
-0.1550071388,
-0.1642972529,
0.4674345851,
0.4378648698,
0.4830447435,
0.7685701847,
0.6397004724,
-0.5409432054,
0.1021458432,
-0.2189761102,
-0.0721233636,
-0.4749296308,
-1.0174039602,
-1.2178237438,
-0.5258361101,
-0.2405695021,
-0.2135939151,
0.1406831294,
0.5950956941,
0.3214078546,
-0.7759471536,
-0.3463335335,
-0.4613806903,
0.2967731357,
-0.1205829903,
-0.2207058221,
0.6324604154,
-0.4936290979,
-0.3245047033,
0.255505681,
-0.0766231343,
-0.2712537348,
-0.1535369456,
0.213795647,
-0.4391616881,
-0.1114560515,
0.7102114558,
0.4869178832,
-0.6149453521,
-0.4601052999,
-0.2634858191,
-0.0847647488,
-0.32081604,
0.9084675908,
-0.3539717197,
0.2656026781,
0.5349429846,
0.5400835276,
0.4253461063,
-0.2382466942,
0.4684849381,
-0.6115877628,
0.4453585148,
0.0418762788,
0.4978105426,
0.1337546557,
-0.1481074393,
0.5646244884,
0.4046705365,
-0.7432436943,
-0.6180343032,
0.1714914441,
-1.0907685757,
-0.0449918546,
1.3886384964,
-0.111136131,
-0.1205996871,
-0.2027034909,
0.1065241471,
0.2910273969,
-0.0287622027,
0.8672297597,
0.4713051617,
-0.0254948251,
0.1153113544,
-0.7402165532,
0.3299731314,
0.5064425468,
-0.7986613512,
0.4104982913,
0.5237002969,
0.2716266513,
-0.0111723356,
0.3367528021,
0.2090957463,
0.1669200361,
-0.1129157096,
0.1966947466,
0.1233501807,
-0.2358562648,
-0.0905617401,
0.0068272809,
0.1780461669,
0.4562776089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06147v1 | SentiGOLD: A Large Bangla Gold Standard Multi-Domain Sentiment Analysis Dataset and its Evaluation | 2023-06-09T12:07:10 | 2023-06-09T12:07:10 | Md. Ekramul Islam, Labib Chowdhury, Faisal Ahamed Khan, Shazzad Hossain, Sourave Hossain, Mohammad Mamun Or Rashid, Nabeel Mohammed, Mohammad Ruhul Amin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces SentiGOLD, a Bangla multi-domain sentiment analysis
dataset. Comprising 70,000 samples, it was created from diverse sources and
annotated by a gender-balanced team of linguists. SentiGOLD adheres to
established linguistic conventions agreed upon by the Government of Bangladesh
and a Bangla linguistics committee. Unlike English and other languages, Bangla
lacks standard sentiment analysis datasets due to the absence of a national
linguistics framework. The dataset incorporates data from online video
comments, social media posts, blogs, news, and other sources while maintaining
domain and class distribution rigorously. It spans 30 domains (e.g., politics,
entertainment, sports) and includes 5 sentiment classes (strongly negative,
weakly negative, neutral, and strongly positive). The annotation scheme,
approved by the national linguistics committee, ensures a robust Inter
Annotator Agreement (IAA) with a Fleiss' kappa score of 0.88. Intra- and
cross-dataset evaluation protocols are applied to establish a standard
classification system. Cross-dataset evaluation on the noisy SentNoB dataset
presents a challenging test scenario. Additionally, zero-shot experiments
demonstrate the generalizability of SentiGOLD. The top model achieves a macro
f1 score of 0.62 (intra-dataset) across 5 classes, setting a benchmark, and
0.61 (cross-dataset from SentNoB) across 3 classes, comparable to the
state-of-the-art. Fine-tuned sentiment analysis model can be accessed at
https://sentiment.bangla.gov.bd. | [
-0.3702586293,
-0.4863581955,
-0.2301896662,
0.7695690989,
-0.315574348,
0.2543393672,
-0.3439478874,
-0.216404438,
0.1920599341,
0.4278802872,
-0.4775865376,
-0.4682530463,
-0.7844831347,
0.2867947817,
0.0517914817,
1.3367220163,
0.3361674845,
0.0116046797,
0.0641717166,
-0.4671978354,
-0.6418557167,
-0.385928303,
-0.1686029881,
-0.1914881468,
0.4940066934,
0.1740809232,
0.6789937019,
-0.2507027984,
0.7445866466,
0.2130653411,
-0.2860417962,
0.4056393802,
-0.3818061948,
-0.0369366147,
-0.3750310838,
-0.3369729221,
-1.0351110697,
0.1707026958,
0.5563527346,
0.8936429024,
0.091256395,
0.5424162149,
0.2551663518,
0.8374134898,
-0.7555865645,
0.249829188,
-0.4252593219,
0.0593616217,
-0.4356536567,
-0.2627032399,
-0.3597538173,
-0.9170849323,
0.199936524,
-0.1314429641,
-0.1462991983,
-0.1149788573,
0.6502603292,
0.1427313387,
-0.3865908086,
-0.292806834,
-0.4022291005,
1.0965874195,
-0.6166577339,
0.3389962018,
0.3092327416,
0.5221107602,
0.0523611456,
-0.2624140382,
-0.2839984596,
0.2323566824,
0.118316479,
0.4885958433,
-0.2116713971,
-0.1941300333,
0.0964606255,
0.528028965,
-0.8418304324,
-0.4424208403,
-0.5712116957,
0.1868219823,
0.8103490472,
0.166076228,
-0.0875925794,
-0.5133453012,
-0.1458016336,
0.2437130809,
-0.708199203,
-0.1031780764,
0.7826806903,
0.8016389012,
-0.1528334618,
0.6462604403,
-0.2526297867,
0.9819592237,
0.0666750893,
-0.1059037969,
0.7148845792,
-0.1211564019,
-0.4405689836,
-0.0081810923,
0.8712290525,
0.657504797,
0.5804196,
0.1906490177,
-0.0153403115,
0.1353612393,
0.2680178583,
-0.7297981381,
-0.0026233771,
0.42973876,
-0.6974403858,
-0.4183529615,
-0.0060995696,
-1.3400725126,
-0.4989436865,
-0.1715835482,
0.1937998682,
-0.027354328,
-0.6433727741,
0.1261637658,
-0.142648384,
0.3566104472,
0.4159141183,
-0.7289450765,
0.1320405602,
0.6100359559,
0.8799106479,
0.0177699625,
-0.2786130905,
-0.0628919229,
-0.2826297879,
-0.5149448514,
0.8443493843,
-0.7809776068,
-0.3327201903,
0.1538723856,
-0.1394026577,
-0.3352247477,
-0.6914367676,
0.3038750291,
-0.517167449,
0.1293576211,
-0.0044171526,
-0.4625159502,
-0.5524676442,
0.5155185461,
-0.7028586864,
0.835904181,
0.2904970348,
-0.9290063381,
0.6100622416,
-0.8965209126,
-0.2758064866,
0.1460193247,
0.0606227554,
-0.3098322451,
-0.0015904529,
0.1273541301,
0.4926376641,
-0.3931869566,
0.391294688,
-0.6287619472,
-0.4477081001,
0.44796893,
-0.468149364,
1.1882196665,
0.3101506829,
-0.1655990928,
0.1080472022,
-0.7072718143,
0.1737604439,
-0.4911858141,
-0.1879073679,
-0.1015460864,
-0.4463357627,
0.3722967505,
0.1995371282,
0.1733562648,
-0.7253100276,
0.361908108,
-0.4429979622,
-0.007440533,
0.6584212184,
-0.0370295346,
0.0112851495,
-0.0687884763,
0.7251511216,
-0.1275815964,
0.4067554474,
0.2573156357,
-0.5797866583,
-0.3088178933,
-0.6565180421,
0.4181916118,
0.5884452462,
-0.0659333393,
0.6050285697,
-0.4285705686,
-0.6180570722,
-1.1076283455,
0.0296335947,
0.183716327,
-0.118859686,
0.2650280297,
0.0802225024,
-0.5351887345,
-0.9412289262,
-0.2159686685,
-0.1066565514,
0.3725633323,
0.1095771044,
0.5522020459,
-0.716704011,
1.0841277838,
-0.5089178681,
-0.4495256841,
-0.5656421185,
0.2848966718,
0.457390368,
0.2217437774,
0.6826075315,
-0.8745117188,
-0.4194831252,
0.2592168748,
-1.0154628754,
-0.2739474773,
0.2620874941,
-0.035396602,
0.2455265969,
-0.0024265281,
-0.4698595405,
0.6485437155,
0.7413318753,
-0.3170330226,
0.769707799,
0.3708523512,
0.5981447697,
-1.0638403893,
0.2504023314,
-0.1050510928,
-0.2875715494,
-0.3427056372,
0.1087198108,
-0.2513810396,
-0.272888869,
-0.2648905218,
0.4749696255,
-0.0180778336,
-0.1200769693,
-0.5584135056,
-0.1496583372,
0.0559071787,
0.2955650687,
0.044156488,
0.6579361558,
0.6490733027,
-0.233140409,
0.7890576124,
0.3067568839,
-0.1908243299,
0.7978756428,
-0.6284707189,
-0.1372101009,
0.119954966,
0.1325995922,
-0.7882449031,
-0.3418181837,
0.3771588206,
-0.6058713794,
0.1312210262,
-0.1661079526,
-0.2964513302,
-0.4429534078,
-0.4585556388,
0.4284793437,
0.2159838825,
-0.4047787786,
0.4356161952,
0.4594859183,
-0.3202026784,
-0.9386112094,
-0.8629276752,
0.1912832707,
-0.5148538947,
-0.3882334232,
-0.5527799726,
-0.4671544433,
-0.3933948278,
-0.0579982102,
0.2778704762,
-0.470553726,
-0.1153289601,
0.5093280673,
0.0295888521,
-0.0126055013,
-0.1055821478,
0.0928083807,
0.0497643836,
-0.1369927675,
0.1453109235,
0.4629904926,
-0.4827932417,
-0.0168560185,
-0.3866553605,
0.3937740624,
0.7024484873,
-0.0473028682,
0.7455975413,
0.4780027568,
-0.3490783572,
-0.2203468531,
-0.2551360726,
0.3231061101,
-0.3735202551,
0.1987394989,
-0.4533616006,
-0.5785081387,
0.5021772981,
-0.0360081941,
0.1182146966,
0.3152733445,
0.8314240575,
0.1341035813,
0.6775553823,
0.5423042774,
-0.2315709591,
-0.1176856086,
-0.3177219033,
0.3762989044,
-0.7051659822,
-0.2255784422,
-0.2610882521,
0.0188257657,
-0.7579615712,
-0.0713215843,
-0.0880695805,
-0.3663129508,
-0.119846113,
0.1294404119,
-0.1264732182,
0.1551249325,
0.2779935002,
0.0503492802,
0.0674040988,
-0.2415234745,
0.3541656435,
-0.1283201128,
-0.3871479034,
-0.7119852304,
1.2813220024,
0.2145309001,
0.9155450463,
0.2335934043,
0.5505014658,
0.9366509914,
0.3485459387,
-0.8011314273,
0.525210619,
-0.1869430691,
-0.9090778232,
0.1310053617,
-0.372260958,
-0.8415085077,
0.2959581316,
0.0431312956,
-0.4502623081,
0.3095357716,
-0.1552394181,
-0.3599303663,
0.0770470127,
-0.3089835048,
0.8268483281,
0.2622072995,
-0.4592933357,
-0.1922879964,
-0.5872133374,
0.5193102956,
-0.3831290901,
0.2890367806,
-0.1103118435,
0.4926466942,
0.8835670948,
-0.210135892,
0.732396245,
-0.2474299371,
-0.0118967816,
0.3934615552,
-0.161071822,
-0.4521456957,
0.0075641638,
-0.5176727176,
0.3489441574,
-0.1854968667,
-0.4630408883,
-0.6332639456,
0.6640396714,
-0.7381635308,
-0.0750981122,
-0.6442898512,
-0.6729459167,
-0.16519095,
0.0117217666,
0.2567664981,
0.7346411347,
-0.2423199415,
0.2997376919,
0.3159198761,
-0.3445490301,
0.1824470907,
0.0993920267,
-0.4533954859,
-0.6551088095,
0.9421067834,
0.2928284109,
-0.0782483146,
-0.0673133284,
0.1385561526,
-0.357118696,
0.0227190293,
-0.6105573177,
0.0830895454,
-0.7126440406,
-0.4822306037,
-0.3667725921,
-0.2273301035,
-0.5882470012,
-0.2687745392,
-0.569393456,
-0.3844347298,
0.1502540112,
-0.2333785146,
0.3038959503,
0.7447300553,
-0.0334955268,
0.5526995659,
-0.6752607822,
0.0701814815,
0.0199662279,
0.3832477629,
-0.2801857591,
-0.6005764604,
-0.2818686366,
0.0153518366,
-0.0704195648,
-0.9003326297,
0.5548420548,
0.3143669665,
0.310590893,
0.5986065269,
-0.1503513455,
0.7072992325,
-0.1494694054,
0.8634980321,
-0.1170227602,
-0.8814309835,
0.7494227886,
-0.5686014295,
0.1020686328,
0.6323897243,
0.4319829941,
-0.2288889587,
-0.5751900077,
-0.5824053288,
-0.6476781368,
0.3232238889,
0.1170708686,
0.0068046483,
0.0336742513,
0.1018493846,
0.6095107794,
0.6567550302,
-0.8805971146,
-0.2436384857,
-0.3272880018,
-0.5328682065,
0.0258678924,
-0.2693183124,
0.0692130476,
-0.2380633056,
0.6080281734,
0.0740037411,
0.3264777362,
-0.1708355397,
-0.3941332102,
0.058573924,
0.3780680597,
0.308555156,
0.9573233724,
-0.6629291773,
-0.1025778726,
-0.2121035159,
-0.5741121769,
0.1369672865,
-0.0031055729,
-0.1767051965,
0.0284592304,
0.5445607901,
0.7707645893,
-0.1510858983,
-0.5774001479,
0.5742678642,
0.0523443967,
-0.0339462347,
-0.1339553148,
-0.1789369285,
-0.490226835,
0.3508868814,
0.3559501469,
0.2521082461,
0.4843341112,
-0.5136896372,
0.3740321994,
0.2638628185,
-0.4528147578,
-0.6377854943,
0.1803703308,
0.1456246525,
0.173143819,
0.3771234453,
-0.2524950206,
-0.6136164069,
0.170736745,
0.4519796371,
0.9324494004,
-0.4856429994,
0.4944804311,
0.4330533743,
0.4067701995,
0.1529475003,
0.6364967227,
0.2640233636,
-0.5194191337,
-0.3260098696,
-0.8992480636,
-0.4060085714,
0.0250643436,
-0.8141496778,
0.1690527499,
-0.523119688,
-0.4315966666,
-0.1665015966,
0.3041161001,
-0.4736305475,
0.4994947016,
-0.1187963113,
0.615496397,
-1.2648595572,
0.3376066685,
0.8996059895,
-0.3595706522,
-0.3430422246,
0.0407216251,
0.0476049148,
-0.387047112,
0.9770330191,
0.3989932835,
-0.2856752276,
-0.2197479308,
-0.377528131,
-0.3956665099,
0.5248944163,
-0.0007013076,
-0.1016979739,
0.7859047055,
0.2025193572,
0.5291101933,
-0.4051021338,
0.5113527179,
0.6423062682,
0.6264980435,
-0.1708922684,
-0.8885217905,
-0.248058036,
-0.5948848128,
-0.4705892503,
0.0186443683,
-0.9938537478,
0.8379543424,
0.1109762788,
0.2324657589,
-0.2240743637,
0.8427850604,
0.3205430806,
0.4777228236,
0.2381734401,
0.5388224721,
0.9205137491,
0.0483837575,
0.6927951574,
0.2311879247,
0.5131212473,
0.7712969184,
-0.6446910501,
0.7466034889,
0.0772012323,
-0.3801701665,
0.5580246449,
0.7098963857,
-0.0766582936,
0.6231566072,
0.0568714701,
-0.2633341849,
-0.0295147058,
-0.2730225921,
-0.3642363548,
0.8772533536,
0.3924618959,
0.1695750058,
-0.269421339,
0.4330496192,
-0.0874981806,
-0.1225606427,
-0.5733351707,
0.4934144318,
-0.0200683642,
-0.2248275578,
0.3384523988,
-0.3074173927,
0.6623158455,
-0.4768311381,
0.0385137349,
-0.3913044035,
0.4436706603,
-0.4675113857,
-0.9255310297,
0.6494699717,
0.4488973618,
-0.2243779451,
0.3247454464,
0.772234261,
-0.4088569283,
-0.6612560153,
0.4437366724,
0.433738023,
0.5602575541,
0.0465204604,
-0.6975064278,
0.3643571734,
-0.1252672374,
-0.4428972602,
0.0890636519,
0.4655284882,
-0.1292167157,
0.7028663158,
0.1726547927,
0.5687553883,
0.0754566491,
0.3338273168,
0.5551658869,
-0.6713366508,
-0.4561653733,
-0.8367356658,
0.2411612123,
-0.2052452266,
-0.4042438269,
1.137123704,
0.7670078874,
0.3670912385,
-0.256404072,
0.9655385017,
-0.0549426973,
0.6086770296,
-0.221607253,
0.8245625496,
-0.5215047002,
-0.2099103183,
-0.600714922,
-1.1755720377,
-0.7584484816,
0.8968389034,
-0.2593688071,
0.1947567761,
0.4846743345,
0.6703054309,
-0.0495624319,
0.2280228585,
0.2589539587,
0.0244032405,
0.1629655659,
0.2120503485,
0.9428622127,
-0.5032685995,
0.1604278386,
0.1309573948,
-0.5485928059,
-0.3748328388,
-0.6433915496,
-1.202673912,
-0.2690921724,
-0.3913320899,
-0.2418545038,
0.2791656852,
1.1510130167,
0.5467162132,
-0.7900448442,
-0.5858489275,
0.4895839989,
-0.1313446462,
-0.2186849117,
-0.3257782757,
0.4861327112,
-0.236051172,
-0.8090952635,
0.2528408468,
0.377832979,
-0.4243221581,
-0.1261801124,
0.1214506775,
-0.3470968604,
0.2110569924,
0.8315435052,
-0.0695938691,
-0.3643272817,
-0.2322049141,
-0.2635829151,
-0.0304032061,
0.0029258912,
0.4782480001,
-0.4680203199,
0.3175116479,
0.50051862,
0.4958441257,
-0.0317338817,
0.2136900127,
0.3471416235,
-0.7935663462,
0.4527305961,
0.1752898991,
0.2205259949,
0.514729023,
-0.1450014859,
0.5478076339,
0.1997264773,
-0.7161870599,
-0.8947912455,
0.0232651718,
-1.0728024244,
-0.2388173342,
1.1797044277,
-0.2580815256,
-0.2650975883,
-0.2337056696,
-0.1910138428,
0.244529441,
-0.4056953788,
0.6073093414,
0.7453411222,
-0.0413060337,
0.1725834608,
-0.588689208,
0.3584595621,
0.1948780119,
-0.8251048923,
0.5533905029,
0.6958637238,
0.0636756644,
0.1170039922,
0.6514317393,
-0.2117431015,
0.3067169785,
-0.0410436839,
0.1087591872,
0.3186209202,
-0.8043031693,
-0.4510222375,
0.2835367918,
-0.160169214,
-0.2550959885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05827v1 | Towards the Exploitation of LLM-based Chatbot for Providing Legal Support to Palestinian Cooperatives | 2023-06-09T11:57:57 | 2023-06-09T11:57:57 | Rabee Qasem, Banan Tantour, Mohammed Maree | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the ever-increasing utilization of natural language processing (NLP), we
started to witness over the past few years a significant transformation in our
interaction with legal texts. This technology has advanced the analysis and
enhanced the understanding of complex legal terminology and contexts. The
development of recent large language models (LLMs), particularly ChatGPT, has
also introduced a revolutionary contribution to the way that legal texts can be
processed and comprehended. In this paper, we present our work on a
cooperative-legal question-answering LLM-based chatbot, where we developed a
set of legal questions about Palestinian cooperatives, associated with their
regulations and compared the auto-generated answers by the chatbot to their
correspondences that are designed by a legal expert. To evaluate the proposed
chatbot, we have used 50 queries generated by the legal expert and compared the
answers produced by the chart to their relevance judgments. Finding
demonstrated that an overall accuracy rate of 82% has been achieved when
answering the queries, while exhibiting an F1 score equivalent to 79%. | [
-0.263366282,
-0.7052614689,
0.4254335463,
0.2648549676,
-0.564743638,
0.3354603052,
-0.1375730485,
-0.6144618988,
0.1640629917,
1.0312689543,
-0.4175493419,
-0.7222825289,
-0.6614046693,
-0.0200725347,
-0.3607318401,
0.9653875232,
0.2690972686,
0.2514587939,
-0.0822020024,
-0.3764731586,
-0.6780177355,
-0.5050258636,
-0.8185756803,
-0.0908306465,
0.3785573542,
0.2008952945,
0.9171773791,
-0.0169088375,
0.5225912333,
0.4141579866,
-0.0623299778,
-0.0666627437,
-0.5793174505,
0.3226456344,
-0.013024129,
-0.9726495147,
-0.28727597,
0.0021179568,
0.1025977507,
0.315507561,
-0.4469107687,
0.0312596709,
-0.2043891847,
0.6792031527,
-0.2056749314,
0.2148777395,
-0.7299727798,
0.2359067798,
0.2649131119,
-0.4525960982,
-0.354591012,
-0.3239068389,
0.1744209528,
-0.5243665576,
0.064602308,
0.4354312122,
0.6512153745,
0.4348516762,
-0.2517898381,
-0.9317291379,
-0.365406841,
0.4401890039,
-0.608818531,
0.164254263,
0.3568743467,
0.5927329659,
-0.6563296914,
-0.6266803145,
-0.5467172265,
-0.6302402616,
-0.2580741644,
0.4924995899,
-0.4930047691,
0.0938830674,
-0.1789422631,
0.1637770683,
-0.4982907772,
0.2698625624,
-0.1856964231,
-0.3695895672,
0.645029664,
-0.0882078856,
0.5023950934,
-0.1546892375,
-0.3037678897,
0.140736565,
-0.5281571746,
0.1456987411,
0.5386579633,
-0.0618999079,
-0.3414074779,
0.8603315949,
-0.0504290611,
0.6099163294,
0.0517900325,
0.1402842999,
-0.100440897,
-0.255525887,
-0.2683486044,
0.0561116636,
0.9850373268,
0.4884673357,
0.3949258626,
-0.1988031417,
-0.1035974175,
-0.3353036344,
0.1302892864,
-0.2975945473,
0.0275797285,
0.3172930777,
-0.4623664618,
-0.3433167338,
0.0112552112,
-0.4402537346,
-0.484246403,
-0.245018959,
0.199094519,
-0.3086426854,
-0.016225012,
0.4218143225,
-0.2108567208,
0.6040956974,
0.4941614568,
-0.479924798,
0.4819154143,
0.8095191717,
0.6907194257,
0.1357435435,
0.3701085448,
-0.8017645478,
0.0757640898,
-0.1682674587,
0.6487380266,
-0.2870142758,
-0.5436119437,
0.1275347769,
-0.2800519764,
0.2978598773,
-0.5276062489,
0.4346262515,
-1.2518759966,
0.2846755087,
0.006733628,
-0.7100132108,
-0.0960194245,
0.7013722062,
-0.5000966191,
0.5621007681,
-0.175543651,
-0.6803001165,
0.3439868093,
-0.8221027255,
-0.1568837911,
0.570251286,
-0.5021476746,
-0.2350288033,
-0.3878354728,
0.2137931585,
0.4039364457,
-0.2845599353,
0.5989694595,
-0.0738445222,
-0.0120085841,
0.7269116044,
-0.455062747,
1.0311301947,
0.12981309,
-0.2417951524,
0.2060130686,
-0.4588847756,
-0.2594802976,
-0.1569411904,
-0.550632894,
0.0923901126,
-0.1318306178,
-0.3986977637,
0.2137820125,
0.4750314951,
-0.5646679401,
-0.1016657129,
-0.3505409658,
0.0868587047,
0.810784936,
0.1750016958,
0.2894263864,
-0.5932224393,
0.7231381536,
-0.3865344524,
0.0978090465,
0.2484865487,
-0.9791965485,
-0.7747586966,
-0.1860762686,
0.2098032981,
0.572168529,
-0.5981305242,
0.5870728493,
-0.1569484621,
-0.6020265818,
-0.6915111542,
-0.0386637747,
0.1352482587,
0.411536485,
0.2061954141,
-0.2767421603,
-0.4415836036,
-0.8930761814,
-0.1619716883,
-0.4546796083,
0.0063249497,
0.7717558146,
0.3143528402,
-0.0781581551,
1.0827760696,
-0.118069537,
-0.2755782306,
-0.3712984622,
0.0536928773,
0.4192661643,
0.1220815554,
0.4410749972,
-1.0069346428,
-0.9722910523,
0.2665385008,
-0.6121034622,
-0.4617832303,
-0.0936799347,
-0.3273081481,
0.1039405912,
0.4677743018,
-0.6723716259,
0.2606907487,
0.5436449647,
-0.6965076923,
0.7792054415,
-0.3295533061,
0.2825867534,
-1.0065683126,
-0.1657541245,
-0.3199620843,
-0.7206372023,
-0.3868997991,
0.1827947795,
-0.4360930622,
0.1123897284,
-0.6724363565,
0.2335445285,
-0.1731299311,
-0.4611011147,
-0.3667939305,
0.6022349596,
-0.3651699126,
0.1369580925,
-0.3096344769,
0.9878978729,
0.6070752144,
-0.5094580054,
0.9492779374,
0.4675983787,
-0.0237372145,
0.6315954924,
-0.6633732319,
0.1308601499,
0.0944218263,
0.2478099912,
-0.830532968,
-0.1136724949,
0.6529341936,
-0.4211295843,
-0.0709981024,
-0.4469881952,
-0.9961134195,
-0.2142255157,
0.0956292301,
-0.0163378082,
0.6903301477,
-0.2196947932,
0.7328568101,
0.6497581601,
-0.1643349975,
-0.6271364689,
-0.4399939179,
0.3099832237,
-0.211153239,
-0.9434056282,
0.1852440387,
0.0538108833,
-0.5854715705,
0.3179840147,
0.1703687012,
-0.0217536371,
0.0215086956,
0.4402151704,
0.0700513273,
-0.1716561466,
0.0293261576,
-0.1079795882,
-0.1174266264,
0.3319917023,
0.0535563342,
1.1486580372,
-0.2940433323,
-0.4255855978,
-0.6125909686,
0.183848694,
0.2771010399,
-0.056515038,
0.5816648006,
0.4193172157,
0.1355821788,
0.111560151,
-0.8276578784,
0.174846828,
-0.5638933778,
0.1069818288,
-0.0457645357,
-1.4397395849,
0.578255415,
0.0310095791,
0.1439256221,
0.4842884541,
1.0386925936,
-0.2500610948,
0.1891937256,
0.6068888903,
-0.2669253051,
0.1825906336,
0.2264990211,
-0.0433946252,
-0.1819604039,
-0.3930875063,
-0.5189334154,
-0.1950020045,
-0.9205913544,
-0.5777881145,
0.4143128097,
-0.3480759561,
0.10506697,
0.6186595559,
-0.034437485,
0.552277267,
0.7603734732,
0.2047936618,
0.4525715411,
-0.2965670526,
-0.1042882577,
0.4460917115,
-0.7555744648,
-0.8357534409,
0.9211649895,
0.1175487787,
0.4687799215,
0.4078969061,
0.7757724524,
0.6337929964,
0.3033272028,
-0.8096996546,
1.0234364271,
-0.0005975058,
-0.5648536086,
-0.3180187941,
-0.4048002064,
-1.1486544609,
0.3638363183,
-0.3410820365,
-0.6445819736,
-0.3304866552,
-0.2415536493,
-0.477555573,
0.143383041,
-0.4618200064,
0.6113519073,
-0.3349606097,
-0.3479137421,
-0.6341125965,
-0.7717877626,
0.0546589792,
-0.0561698787,
0.3133739829,
-0.2899646163,
-0.1764061302,
0.7071549296,
-0.4150385261,
1.0771224499,
-0.029892968,
-0.2459186018,
0.741592586,
0.1903573275,
0.2088176459,
0.3323159516,
-0.1700529009,
-0.3163855672,
0.0386556163,
-0.2065902352,
-0.5724338293,
0.4849322736,
-0.8470341563,
-0.9082014561,
-0.2891848087,
-0.7935932279,
0.0274307579,
0.1908000857,
-0.3854463398,
-0.2338502556,
-0.2502824664,
0.2832714915,
0.0807638317,
-0.4691284895,
0.3704989552,
0.9201500416,
-0.2209765613,
-0.1861356944,
0.259952426,
-0.1464085132,
0.0671631172,
0.2871697545,
0.3113988638,
-0.4252416492,
-0.3905944228,
-0.2358083576,
0.2825081944,
-0.8571801186,
-0.2023334652,
-0.6186267138,
-0.0925464407,
-0.1057877988,
-0.3405797482,
-0.0134768561,
-0.1642004699,
-0.2134607136,
0.1043579951,
0.4374237657,
0.6012932062,
0.0085082427,
0.3654720485,
-0.9861620069,
0.3983480334,
0.4558265209,
0.2817163765,
-0.5894133449,
-0.6057391167,
0.3052885234,
-0.1091256514,
-0.1409477144,
-0.9168474078,
0.2488225102,
-0.1711674035,
0.4962622225,
0.0071962634,
0.1059482619,
0.5214734077,
-0.5071107149,
0.8090323806,
0.1631547362,
-0.6607454419,
0.3505547643,
-0.3807847798,
-0.2390778065,
0.4617245793,
0.2882446051,
-0.6216729283,
-0.7707774639,
-0.7513823509,
-0.556084156,
0.4924041629,
0.7805708647,
0.6024441123,
0.2947654426,
0.5267485976,
0.2178230137,
0.3286228478,
-0.9543626308,
0.0874321759,
0.4517895579,
-0.0071612219,
0.3488204777,
-0.1825317442,
-0.1370008886,
0.3026461303,
0.6669484377,
0.2541691363,
0.0686487481,
0.1216049865,
-0.00268544,
-0.0203874968,
0.5431129932,
0.2247295976,
0.3542084694,
0.0154117774,
-0.0411869325,
0.1469968557,
-0.0988115743,
0.1540420055,
0.0667387098,
-0.0025207847,
-0.0766308829,
0.2206998765,
0.3275850117,
-0.0232371744,
-0.9605516791,
0.8551642299,
-0.1726159453,
-0.365185231,
-0.5382410288,
0.4037558734,
0.2319631875,
0.8173803687,
0.1709805727,
-0.1179921478,
0.0711989552,
-0.5305899978,
0.5059491396,
0.6953946352,
-0.3018392622,
0.0847650766,
0.4346750081,
0.2010571808,
-0.75191468,
0.2511512637,
-0.3708038926,
-0.5792872906,
0.6847748756,
0.4552454352,
0.4844875336,
0.3660408556,
0.3685989678,
0.0351743735,
0.0176334847,
0.1077362671,
0.3613626659,
-0.0910331458,
-0.8335480094,
-0.4981744885,
-0.3500783443,
-0.7687051892,
-0.251170367,
-0.2423735708,
0.2824885249,
-0.3229094744,
-0.169151932,
-0.2540856898,
-0.0356894769,
-0.6334446669,
-0.0592166372,
-0.1417803466,
0.6101155281,
-0.1641658694,
0.5601600409,
0.4514557421,
-0.3899164796,
-0.3884580433,
-0.1062094867,
-0.2584003806,
-1.0536708832,
0.7759292126,
0.0635079667,
-0.3362005949,
0.0827096999,
-0.8058546782,
-0.2842232585,
1.1295589209,
0.198627606,
-0.7956886292,
0.1902677566,
0.5981342793,
0.9038228989,
-0.1672627479,
-0.0053197863,
0.3433675468,
0.2449627519,
0.1641948819,
-0.8691637516,
0.0354392901,
-0.1334789693,
-0.6644127965,
-0.1334083974,
-0.661703527,
0.3935805261,
0.1211203858,
-0.118051447,
0.2563330531,
0.5480434299,
0.2732800245,
0.1147635505,
0.6144039035,
0.2493489236,
0.7251739502,
0.1453582644,
0.9392397404,
-0.6518957615,
0.318212986,
1.0251376629,
-0.1934279799,
0.5935223699,
0.6388382316,
-0.1911293715,
0.3668661416,
0.174709335,
-0.3748164177,
0.2741397917,
0.535199821,
-0.5338790417,
-0.2903611064,
-0.3561534882,
0.1430885941,
0.5132647157,
0.3559166789,
-0.2684673369,
-0.2854760587,
-0.3933638632,
-0.2063245177,
0.2651335597,
-0.2037832588,
1.0534849167,
0.2039735168,
-0.6990522146,
-0.2975530028,
0.2947795391,
0.5333865285,
-0.3541128635,
0.2100867182,
-0.0303813349,
-0.3461312354,
0.0036957327,
-1.2086924314,
0.3253103197,
0.3548939228,
0.5915030837,
-0.1034129858,
0.7515841126,
-0.0744503066,
-0.1717690378,
0.4376860857,
0.8475340009,
0.3398127556,
0.0844497532,
-1.0114123821,
-0.2815974057,
-0.3012486696,
0.1290412992,
-0.065684095,
0.6776155829,
0.2694002986,
0.8427497745,
0.8294443488,
0.1258635074,
0.3239786327,
0.1037328765,
1.1297703981,
-0.5077746511,
-0.6279606223,
-1.056427002,
0.409548223,
-0.2202184647,
-0.0088627208,
0.5940690637,
0.4610080421,
0.6048902869,
0.0567027815,
0.6577864885,
-0.2987395823,
0.193691805,
-0.7124467492,
0.7741325498,
-0.1199863628,
0.4456134439,
0.0545854867,
-0.509344399,
-0.5971071124,
0.4271014929,
-0.4389831722,
-0.3031412959,
0.0653544441,
0.8052380085,
0.0053198924,
-0.0435993671,
0.563574791,
0.049935203,
0.766448319,
0.341353029,
0.9511426687,
-0.1691754758,
0.7826837301,
-0.0953886658,
0.1371340007,
-0.3646687567,
-0.6697602868,
-1.0681960583,
-0.0485397764,
-0.1658127308,
-0.3055175543,
0.1649445891,
1.2176431417,
0.265837431,
-0.614705801,
-0.4845792949,
-0.442974925,
-0.208872661,
0.4706892967,
-0.1715812236,
0.232964769,
-0.5674957633,
-0.4451501369,
0.2657278478,
0.3534482419,
0.2125028074,
-0.1189784259,
-0.2777071297,
-0.3300125897,
-0.0014759834,
0.5337055326,
-0.1116238907,
-0.748785913,
-0.2859960794,
-0.0835776553,
-0.2514633238,
0.3443544805,
0.6815476418,
-0.3145058453,
0.4748799801,
0.2704154253,
0.9111148715,
0.3270739615,
0.0370787904,
0.6257358193,
-0.6358520389,
0.2331774235,
0.5671898127,
0.457759589,
0.0774621367,
-0.3188908994,
0.5711295009,
-0.0394366123,
-0.6123608947,
-0.1003773361,
0.3461095989,
-1.0920439959,
0.0083993785,
1.177603364,
-0.3926164806,
-0.2278275639,
-0.4595021904,
-0.8516103029,
0.5878731012,
-0.6343699098,
0.8786847591,
0.7415023446,
-0.0992297679,
-0.1636802703,
-0.6526099443,
0.1724858582,
0.4078356028,
-0.7799364328,
-0.2432026416,
0.4908750653,
0.2508237064,
0.0809057131,
0.9386254549,
-0.1987871826,
0.2427821308,
-0.2735519707,
-0.2557390928,
0.1986329257,
0.3259668946,
-0.0508080386,
0.4042339623,
0.2445809096,
-0.1089932099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05803v1 | Causality between Sentiment and Cryptocurrency Prices | 2023-06-09T10:40:22 | 2023-06-09T10:40:22 | Lubdhak Mondal, Udeshya Raj, Abinandhan S, Began Gowsik S, Sarwesh P, Abhijeet Chandra | q-fin.CP | q-fin.CP, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | This study investigates the relationship between narratives conveyed through
microblogging platforms, namely Twitter, and the value of crypto assets. Our
study provides a unique technique to build narratives about cryptocurrency by
combining topic modelling of short texts with sentiment analysis. First, we
used an unsupervised machine learning algorithm to discover the latent topics
within the massive and noisy textual data from Twitter, and then we revealed
4-5 cryptocurrency-related narratives, including financial investment,
technological advancement related to crypto, financial and political
regulations, crypto assets, and media coverage. In a number of situations, we
noticed a strong link between our narratives and crypto prices. Our work
connects the most recent innovation in economics, Narrative Economics, to a new
area of study that combines topic modelling and sentiment analysis to relate
consumer behaviour to narratives. | [
-0.2186056077,
-0.8526263833,
0.5861634612,
0.1404142529,
-0.5943407416,
0.4498336315,
-0.0487644598,
-0.6112873554,
0.9535057545,
0.6131644249,
-0.4055701792,
-0.564119935,
-0.6210938096,
-0.3782894015,
-0.3799241483,
1.2933830023,
0.0866493285,
-0.0664629266,
-0.0392943472,
-0.0574223846,
-0.0977540761,
-0.568099618,
-0.7172849774,
-0.0779561698,
0.6611657143,
0.2397416532,
0.9159766436,
0.2650544941,
0.684612155,
0.250588119,
0.1787118167,
-0.2115011364,
-0.4030299187,
0.2009574175,
-0.2661770284,
-0.2399772257,
-0.068020761,
0.0900677964,
0.0922689885,
0.6550193429,
-0.0949706212,
0.1330656856,
0.0455790944,
0.625217557,
-0.5736077428,
0.1753876656,
-0.4321201742,
-0.2783050239,
-0.1249415353,
-0.5145772696,
-0.0578409955,
-0.267991364,
0.2229022831,
-0.4293361902,
0.2851603329,
0.2854328752,
0.7549849749,
-0.1274049133,
-0.2201513946,
-0.781283617,
-0.6482256651,
0.5724176168,
-0.4116352201,
0.0641892254,
0.2486118525,
-0.0154965753,
0.2772704065,
-0.7536661625,
-0.4697074294,
0.0214640312,
-0.0827983916,
-0.0819956809,
-0.4405708611,
-0.2582935095,
0.0222492423,
0.3707902133,
-0.1278873235,
-0.2304034382,
-0.5880849957,
-0.2574003041,
0.5135487318,
0.4403886497,
0.4240322709,
-0.5268362761,
-0.4310424328,
-0.1164923459,
-0.7066402435,
0.2119707912,
0.9703819752,
0.5148198009,
-0.2943120301,
0.5247789621,
0.0629082546,
0.2252788395,
0.000084622,
-0.4275124967,
0.0288012847,
-0.3826067448,
0.0943567678,
0.6187549233,
0.9886035323,
0.6350599527,
0.1290237308,
-0.1891361624,
-0.1157961041,
0.0665247589,
0.2885858417,
-0.8414136171,
0.0366079882,
0.3693847954,
-0.8307728767,
-0.8634976745,
0.3283287585,
-0.8843242526,
-0.3746722341,
-0.1782665551,
0.3242930174,
0.1346068084,
-0.5129448175,
0.326865375,
-0.5072196126,
-0.1414968669,
0.0426944233,
-1.0730977058,
0.4480765462,
0.8503689766,
0.8882287741,
0.3010351956,
-0.2149817795,
-0.0747960359,
0.295106411,
-0.4424364269,
0.8401663303,
-0.061926797,
-0.4762065709,
0.118219234,
-0.1676870733,
0.2564356327,
-0.0519248396,
0.2774301171,
-0.672283411,
0.0758212507,
-0.2960851789,
-0.3982268274,
0.2145167291,
0.0861802548,
-0.7445853949,
0.559800446,
0.0283888504,
-1.5211386681,
0.376496464,
-0.5154454708,
-0.4837615788,
0.1004708335,
-0.1838671565,
-0.1715005934,
0.2282107323,
0.0204743035,
0.302806437,
-0.8331928849,
0.7459930778,
-0.5594066978,
-0.2861866951,
0.8167721629,
-0.3482222855,
0.804084301,
-0.0263437126,
-0.479024142,
0.0124733839,
-0.4614862502,
-0.6725866199,
0.030034326,
0.4865876734,
-0.5457078815,
0.2400017381,
0.3314981461,
0.3154695034,
0.3372183144,
-0.4114001691,
0.2066335827,
-0.4455963671,
0.783850193,
0.793164432,
0.7080835104,
0.2037999332,
-0.1681083888,
0.3603762984,
0.0285451654,
0.3794716001,
-0.016428465,
-0.4292042851,
-0.411503762,
-0.0168578122,
0.0521852784,
0.4072910547,
-0.3761791587,
0.0610102676,
-0.0296387244,
-0.2649612129,
-0.4364162982,
-0.2279183716,
-0.4218301177,
0.5982572436,
-0.0175239798,
0.0642964169,
-0.4132146537,
-1.0152244568,
-0.3247207701,
-0.6055333614,
0.0400392674,
0.2088713795,
0.4582105875,
-0.1199041903,
0.826759398,
-0.7615851164,
0.1283937693,
0.0912037417,
0.6513391733,
0.3131051362,
0.2416016757,
0.6122579575,
-0.8635908365,
-0.2232810408,
0.1452277452,
-0.5110040307,
0.3003314734,
-0.3494234979,
0.3073275089,
0.1843985766,
0.44775033,
-0.575461328,
0.4832375348,
0.2546853125,
-0.5671983361,
0.3953125179,
-0.1645410508,
0.6507846713,
-1.2210438251,
0.0257338248,
0.1182551458,
0.2713071108,
-0.2975940406,
-0.3067307174,
-0.1994376779,
-0.2955392897,
-0.4286601841,
0.4879478514,
-0.0323254131,
0.1183591634,
-0.6687387228,
0.2043356895,
-0.0497064553,
0.1454308778,
-0.1613821089,
0.7044690251,
0.823084712,
-0.192842856,
0.5089573264,
-0.1607363522,
-0.1585349441,
0.1905666292,
-0.8793118596,
-0.1315615922,
0.3081995845,
-0.2222774774,
-1.287706852,
-0.0829111636,
0.456733346,
-0.6205253005,
-0.0657652467,
0.0178185161,
-0.8702563643,
-0.1796543747,
-0.6728467345,
0.1888649613,
0.2491633743,
-0.1157952696,
0.496022433,
0.3020533323,
-0.425524056,
-0.735471189,
-0.4192459881,
0.2462157756,
-0.5993475914,
-0.6379830837,
0.3452832103,
0.0495292954,
-0.7734801173,
0.2605353296,
0.1206535399,
0.3828937411,
0.0779792666,
0.4903660417,
0.5331993699,
-0.1051130891,
0.1086641029,
0.1864027381,
-0.6937516928,
0.6847720146,
-0.4744961262,
0.4556132555,
-0.1024258062,
0.1815543771,
-0.3843472004,
0.2108758688,
0.4572086334,
0.2707544565,
1.3581860065,
0.3337366581,
-0.2512854934,
0.1138719544,
-0.4540118873,
-0.2782361209,
-0.4812847972,
-0.2382724136,
-0.0793525279,
-0.9833288193,
0.9092627764,
0.0567723848,
-0.5468927026,
1.0144709349,
0.5496049523,
-0.2242254764,
0.8944160342,
0.7208407521,
-0.6101160645,
0.3051372766,
-0.0695731491,
0.6711151004,
-0.272711724,
-0.3685024381,
-0.7013334632,
-0.1669265777,
-1.101682663,
-0.0730616376,
-0.0453701317,
0.2266946882,
-0.2275010347,
0.0328650698,
-0.2244949192,
0.0994585231,
0.3081816137,
0.1977790594,
0.2522819638,
0.1208845973,
0.1516180336,
-0.1539954394,
-0.2867725492,
-0.5446755886,
1.259483099,
0.1462008208,
0.5262688398,
-0.1483197361,
0.3738622963,
0.6963472962,
0.3686365485,
-0.6299247742,
0.1013277099,
0.1512345523,
-0.5709350109,
-0.3038353622,
-0.1883666068,
-0.5262647271,
-0.3915513456,
-0.3648477197,
-0.6018194556,
0.328961283,
-0.4637213051,
-0.3127038181,
0.4441742003,
-0.0976604596,
0.8647181988,
-0.1263198704,
-0.7767010927,
-0.4747830629,
-0.6948434711,
0.1971909702,
-0.1135081723,
0.3340185285,
-0.0784572884,
-0.2395227998,
0.862477839,
-0.3814334869,
0.8986619711,
0.278251946,
-0.0916069373,
0.5857176781,
-0.3495421112,
0.2904617488,
0.6229875684,
0.1573799103,
0.296805203,
-0.3811142743,
-0.6332805157,
-0.3412061036,
1.1984373331,
-0.9451771379,
-0.5719087124,
-0.4427645206,
-0.3776940405,
0.093401432,
-0.0008164714,
0.3357390463,
0.3676801026,
-0.5049619079,
0.0023189916,
0.6362619996,
-0.0203886572,
0.5930064321,
0.1494188458,
-0.1029228568,
-1.0025347471,
0.8196322918,
-0.1175816059,
-0.0053787287,
0.6868245602,
0.6151230335,
-0.1002375782,
-0.4845044613,
0.0267265029,
0.3415748775,
-0.6731086373,
-0.1869734079,
-0.7282969356,
0.1546586603,
-0.5510886908,
-0.642421186,
-0.3781288564,
-0.2911607921,
-0.536519289,
-0.605522871,
0.8404582739,
0.5470618606,
-0.283129245,
0.4165305197,
-0.5656533241,
0.399461627,
0.2763597071,
-0.0362160243,
0.1236254722,
-0.1166272908,
-0.2483997196,
-0.0072297491,
-0.1046715155,
-0.9392886758,
0.3314898908,
-0.8099791408,
0.0084369816,
0.9435243011,
0.1092528254,
0.4737459123,
-0.0060035456,
0.7875978351,
0.6231686473,
-1.1285045147,
0.7497035265,
-0.6899917722,
-0.5177311897,
0.4429611862,
0.653608799,
-0.5932427645,
-0.3957314193,
-1.1721616983,
-1.0039973259,
0.3856568336,
0.3066004217,
0.2935223281,
-0.3005393445,
0.5627423525,
0.3032529354,
0.5379459262,
-0.5212327242,
-0.4620392025,
-0.4082650542,
-0.2356538028,
-0.22951442,
-0.6060280204,
-0.0895342901,
-0.2436411679,
0.5169429779,
-0.0044281119,
-0.043110691,
-0.1257881671,
0.1211641058,
-0.2504691184,
0.0043935692,
0.4078839123,
0.9055957198,
-0.435208559,
0.1572441012,
-0.2799152732,
-0.1923244298,
-0.0714231208,
0.0650161803,
-0.2693159282,
-0.0568904504,
0.5479812622,
0.8496038318,
0.6490082741,
-0.5221340656,
0.6492756009,
-0.1254431605,
-0.5075697899,
-0.2831543386,
-0.3348376155,
0.4905353487,
0.3684139252,
0.5706342459,
0.4005827606,
0.5193150043,
-0.866464138,
0.1723771542,
0.144950375,
-0.7480676174,
-0.6156001091,
0.8224713206,
0.0541767292,
-0.3254581094,
0.8124358654,
0.4471009672,
-0.325748086,
0.7623186707,
0.1100761816,
0.9633549452,
0.1194804609,
0.5706237555,
0.3285388947,
0.3386870623,
-0.1225529835,
0.2685013711,
0.0144594824,
-0.5544866323,
-0.1802797765,
-0.2790432274,
-0.1570807397,
-0.0903205127,
-0.5055626035,
0.5604431033,
-0.324103117,
-0.1962901056,
0.3596285582,
0.3787868023,
-0.2702266872,
0.3174423575,
-0.0573864095,
0.4279105067,
-1.0971636772,
0.5330476165,
0.2481564879,
-0.7484170198,
-0.4232695401,
0.0094623882,
-0.3950098753,
-0.477560848,
0.6197212934,
0.1027445048,
-0.2365687639,
-0.3130918145,
-0.6845040321,
-0.4209048152,
1.1110752821,
0.1675015986,
-0.3336986601,
0.1700375974,
0.3227944076,
0.6674553752,
-0.8077121377,
0.0464857854,
0.0751559362,
0.235831365,
0.190412879,
-0.0325889252,
-0.0117923636,
-0.1598940492,
-0.1599493176,
0.6790813804,
-0.6768998504,
0.7051592469,
-0.2086288482,
0.0647932738,
-0.1690048575,
0.5170000196,
0.1428780854,
0.9175999165,
0.301774919,
0.210376963,
0.5068857074,
0.1087674648,
1.0362401009,
-0.876606524,
0.7232164741,
0.4713012278,
-0.1170666516,
0.6937463284,
0.8988089561,
-0.0936763585,
0.6286661029,
0.8251143694,
0.2899199724,
0.6676589847,
0.0986870155,
-0.2347792834,
-0.1464035511,
-0.1861515492,
-0.3057600856,
-0.0259211585,
0.3328619301,
-0.5928558111,
0.3263208866,
-0.0426018983,
-0.0133585269,
-0.0191808436,
-0.3622782528,
0.6289024353,
0.1536113173,
-0.1323387325,
-0.4739859402,
0.0135484608,
0.4948602319,
-0.6757224202,
0.3072410226,
-0.284534961,
0.0159579441,
0.1067322418,
-0.5709152818,
0.6188099384,
-0.2277217805,
-0.2848251164,
-0.4947077036,
0.9233048558,
-0.0555617325,
-0.6571686864,
0.3518725038,
0.4119735956,
-0.3127518594,
-0.3634036481,
-0.5479143858,
-0.2509914041,
-0.1438577771,
-0.2114043832,
0.3731790781,
0.7621483803,
0.064525798,
0.2756434083,
0.7256920934,
-0.2049827576,
-0.5758835077,
0.086006932,
0.999466002,
-1.131274581,
-0.8812972307,
-1.2033573389,
0.4773340523,
-0.3329442739,
-0.3306856751,
0.7010958195,
0.7069783807,
0.5779879689,
-0.1180680618,
0.4632130861,
0.2156331688,
0.2418275326,
-0.3059588075,
0.870580554,
-0.4675301015,
0.4309249222,
-0.4477601945,
-0.5382277369,
-0.0424004048,
0.3231409788,
-0.5149794221,
-0.3569926023,
0.8815738559,
0.4146598876,
0.1771566421,
0.5167030096,
-0.0650125816,
-0.2614037097,
-0.1202368736,
-0.1700481623,
0.9522352815,
-0.6238649487,
0.3351180851,
-0.5924586058,
0.1541379243,
-0.3656431735,
-0.880196631,
-0.9067904949,
-0.5949313045,
-0.582608819,
-0.6045603752,
0.080353938,
0.4853324592,
0.0769706219,
-0.6351528168,
-0.4794401824,
-0.0675617158,
0.4228588641,
-0.3040127456,
-0.3214064538,
0.641361475,
-0.0197511334,
-0.187064901,
-0.3870299757,
0.6680607796,
-0.1160372123,
-0.3180418909,
0.1376924515,
0.0100881821,
0.2997011542,
0.5647801161,
-0.2777271569,
-0.5075754523,
-0.0862218887,
0.172868073,
-0.2497863322,
0.1459525228,
1.5561425686,
-0.3323885798,
0.0034187702,
0.4398457706,
0.3549750745,
0.6606302261,
-0.2072352469,
0.3766313493,
-0.2033486813,
0.3837695718,
-0.0217649844,
0.2559028268,
0.2596331239,
-0.6283560395,
0.1195674837,
0.7403938174,
-0.3120246828,
-0.4319949746,
-0.2190630436,
-0.8965325952,
-0.7139558196,
0.6646195054,
0.2167112827,
-0.3551649749,
0.1742528975,
-0.0838228092,
0.0102887899,
-0.4796288311,
1.268804431,
1.0022040606,
0.1209095642,
-0.1426189691,
-0.6121203303,
0.1531748176,
-0.3718062639,
-0.5935400128,
0.0311110392,
0.3771627545,
0.1803774089,
0.1236772612,
0.6795377731,
0.1232904047,
-0.0621873885,
0.4865518808,
0.0277407356,
0.0462270565,
-0.2635914385,
0.1007396877,
0.6832947135,
-0.1138561592,
-0.1526963264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05783v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05783v3 | Xiezhi: An Ever-Updating Benchmark for Holistic Domain Knowledge Evaluation | 2023-06-09T09:52:05 | 2024-03-11T09:49:04 | Zhouhong Gu, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Haoning Ye, Lin Zhang, Jianchen Wang, Yixin Zhu, Sihang Jiang, Zhuozhi Xiong, Zihan Li, Weijie Wu, Qianyu He, Rui Xu, Wenhao Huang, Jingping Liu, Zili Wang, Shusen Wang, Weiguo Zheng, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | New Natural Langauge Process~(NLP) benchmarks are urgently needed to align
with the rapid development of large language models (LLMs). We present Xiezhi,
the most comprehensive evaluation suite designed to assess holistic domain
knowledge. Xiezhi comprises multiple-choice questions across 516 diverse
disciplines ranging from 13 different subjects with 249,587 questions and
accompanied by Xiezhi-Specialty and Xiezhi-Interdiscipline, both with 15k
questions. We conduct evaluation of the 47 cutting-edge LLMs on Xiezhi. Results
indicate that LLMs exceed average performance of humans in science,
engineering, agronomy, medicine, and art, but fall short in economics,
jurisprudence, pedagogy, literature, history, and management. We anticipate
Xiezhi will help analyze important strengths and shortcomings of LLMs, and the
benchmark is released in~\url{https://github.com/MikeGu721/XiezhiBenchmark}. | [
-0.3906137645,
-0.446052134,
0.463804394,
0.1972928792,
0.0533348471,
0.4167279303,
-0.5981529951,
-0.8236244321,
-0.2739259899,
0.5586436987,
-0.4840149283,
-0.4985846877,
-0.4779751003,
-0.014963096,
-0.4612059593,
0.9528279901,
-0.0702362284,
0.0314909332,
-0.121500656,
-0.499376893,
-0.2665049732,
-0.1402880996,
-0.5481401682,
-0.5951376557,
0.2993384004,
0.2806403637,
0.5963324308,
0.4658837616,
0.5445988774,
0.3117662966,
0.0629528761,
0.1080386937,
-0.0447343774,
0.2687290311,
-0.209624365,
-0.4681717455,
-0.6531535387,
-0.1397246718,
0.9091541171,
1.0958893299,
-0.0922190025,
0.4335344136,
0.0984038189,
0.7503455281,
-0.543951273,
-0.0936544389,
-0.6536394358,
0.1023988947,
-0.4860008955,
0.0350795388,
0.0095980698,
-0.3647001088,
0.3913926482,
-0.4838741124,
-0.0283209328,
0.3648251295,
0.7529090047,
0.2145749927,
-0.3030572832,
0.1466290206,
-0.3975102901,
0.9289649725,
-0.645368278,
0.5254998207,
0.1208201945,
0.6627578139,
-0.0540493354,
-0.7975343466,
-0.5606735945,
-0.278740555,
0.4262061417,
-0.0244471822,
-0.2640900016,
-0.1936789453,
0.226595521,
0.6291125417,
-0.6785796881,
-0.0452808216,
0.0883484408,
-0.0350792147,
0.7980841398,
0.4121500552,
0.61604321,
0.0520079397,
-0.3655377328,
-0.1282737106,
-0.7120446563,
-0.0640837029,
0.1605488956,
0.0919462219,
0.2515660822,
0.1802309752,
-0.6825397015,
0.722242713,
-0.1992984712,
0.1299874932,
0.5002758503,
-0.2546131313,
-0.3529210985,
-0.1796727926,
0.9249823093,
0.3229245543,
0.0654305667,
-0.2921228707,
-0.1562385708,
0.0026135384,
0.3329322338,
-0.5180510283,
-0.0488122553,
0.0919956341,
-0.2725310922,
-0.0776366442,
-0.1400669068,
-0.9450992942,
-0.2597784996,
-0.2662923634,
0.3719110787,
-0.2814666331,
-0.1427579522,
0.2311175317,
0.1669219881,
0.3775452971,
0.3872722387,
-0.8705567122,
0.8835810423,
0.9107393026,
0.7384721637,
-0.4681996107,
-0.5983476043,
-0.4419874549,
-0.2932273746,
-0.3887048066,
1.098459959,
-0.4572106302,
-0.2377695143,
-0.0391051173,
-0.070068866,
0.2608789504,
-0.8761843443,
0.8822243214,
-0.5621679425,
-0.1851189137,
-0.4812788665,
-0.5588088632,
-0.1209223866,
0.3728356063,
-0.6216950417,
1.2110960484,
0.3545157313,
-0.337623477,
0.5128050447,
-0.5993407369,
-0.4683209956,
0.4278330207,
-0.2801912725,
-0.2098304182,
-0.1025123224,
-0.1101733744,
0.1948679388,
-0.8579537272,
0.5503421426,
-0.1994079053,
-0.2304500341,
0.0107829319,
-0.2980004847,
0.843308568,
-0.0216463022,
-0.7033947706,
0.2154304683,
-0.9722511768,
0.6902184486,
0.0840207934,
-0.114489913,
-0.3110661507,
0.055803895,
0.0214274153,
0.273347944,
0.2169619203,
-0.4624241889,
0.049987074,
-0.5440190434,
0.3781266809,
0.7053624392,
-0.1282442659,
0.1144209132,
-0.4370831251,
0.4286763072,
-0.286012888,
0.12301898,
0.0421150886,
-0.7667117119,
-0.6108391881,
0.3050729036,
0.1441930681,
0.2882963121,
-0.3959822953,
0.5979991555,
-0.3379848301,
-0.910847187,
-0.5520679355,
0.2949717939,
0.4250317216,
0.5245863199,
0.5254691839,
-0.3179479539,
-0.3753549159,
-0.7906718254,
-0.5522113442,
-0.0651976466,
-0.0578204952,
-0.0319058374,
0.6283361912,
-0.333647877,
0.8345087171,
-0.5670400858,
-0.2887887359,
-0.1989388466,
0.2905266583,
0.1256730855,
0.1301181763,
0.677205801,
-0.5070709586,
-0.7771089077,
0.5250678062,
-0.5272634029,
-0.3537487686,
0.3398537934,
-0.4111567438,
0.1714578122,
-0.0792793185,
-0.4670061171,
0.0452733152,
0.4739920795,
-0.3402197063,
0.7788431644,
-0.0460730419,
0.3383116126,
-0.5662568212,
0.2868044078,
0.1901629269,
-0.1889115572,
-0.4966880679,
0.1845291406,
0.090574719,
0.0375593491,
0.0212556031,
0.9899278879,
-0.5222887993,
-0.1269872636,
-0.333439827,
0.4949662983,
0.1442292333,
0.3788848519,
0.0774443448,
0.6599974036,
0.7420625687,
-0.4266873896,
0.5081645846,
0.3894230723,
-0.9846972823,
0.6313859224,
-0.8014104962,
0.0283990148,
0.3651446998,
-0.0907463655,
-0.6259503365,
-0.072818771,
0.0969610587,
-0.3302862942,
0.1061367691,
0.3269054592,
-0.3802244961,
-0.3746064305,
-0.5744785666,
0.1912939996,
0.6293404698,
-0.5916262269,
0.2436649501,
0.6452353001,
-0.3123202324,
-0.7100193501,
-0.3896662593,
0.2415124029,
0.0104598692,
-0.5162682533,
0.4814492762,
-0.3037770987,
-0.4681261182,
0.0994651169,
-0.347126931,
-0.1015360579,
0.164457947,
-0.0684608892,
0.2667875886,
-0.445718348,
-0.1610488445,
0.073369652,
-0.0113542182,
0.482889086,
-0.1511313617,
0.548658967,
-0.4024201334,
-0.4197286665,
0.0127169751,
0.2207269967,
0.3392409384,
-0.2065748125,
0.244725883,
0.4702771902,
-0.634503901,
-0.5484123826,
-0.4671770334,
0.2216931581,
-0.4039925933,
0.541782558,
-0.1581363082,
-0.7801165581,
0.4147641957,
-0.12198928,
0.2353808135,
0.616291523,
0.6556513906,
0.3070584238,
0.9379872084,
0.2799457014,
-0.4014129341,
0.013639587,
-0.2634422481,
0.3602781892,
-0.9667615294,
-0.1266709417,
-0.6534355879,
-0.0633032024,
-0.3782920241,
-0.5519695878,
0.2624545693,
-0.2924210131,
-0.0595059432,
0.3747436106,
-0.19564493,
0.3050449491,
0.3488862514,
-0.1714446843,
0.6737964153,
-0.2695350349,
0.2267794907,
-0.1081692949,
-0.4349683523,
-0.581065774,
1.1662733555,
0.2944068015,
0.4973102212,
-0.0873559117,
0.3576615751,
0.5782145858,
0.6677818894,
-0.8380846977,
0.7092255354,
0.0808381364,
-0.797563076,
-0.5200046897,
-0.4407759011,
-0.8169248104,
0.4008609354,
-0.1879010051,
-0.7619978786,
-0.1037076637,
0.0211562458,
-0.5077269077,
0.4034746587,
-0.2221095115,
0.833876133,
-0.4783559442,
-0.6015163064,
-0.2751272619,
-0.7158152461,
0.4743585289,
-0.2919163406,
0.1287451535,
-0.5427027941,
0.0251625292,
0.972887218,
-0.3123963773,
0.4700804055,
-0.1127603054,
-0.2064748257,
0.2763855457,
-0.2417956591,
0.0415152758,
0.0250457171,
-0.3048216999,
0.4548419416,
0.1752961874,
-0.1307164133,
-0.671428442,
0.8014156818,
-0.7659025192,
-0.5760949254,
-0.563123405,
-0.2357951403,
-0.7849546075,
0.4176409543,
0.1785127372,
0.3988962173,
-0.5883713365,
-0.0344292596,
0.6411659718,
-0.1722101122,
0.0674501657,
0.4810487032,
-0.3142506182,
-0.3654425144,
0.9568454623,
0.1842934042,
0.0104821119,
0.2177161723,
0.2766595185,
-0.198621735,
-0.6922226548,
-0.523506403,
0.1592091024,
-0.9353074431,
-0.59457165,
-0.7598559856,
-0.3159623146,
-0.4037274122,
0.1321037412,
-0.3424802721,
0.0270158779,
0.2737824023,
0.135296911,
0.0407696106,
0.7336996198,
0.2248306423,
-0.0248875413,
-0.9972348809,
0.5350306034,
0.2806192636,
0.7453085184,
0.1950155348,
-0.4941934049,
-0.4356664717,
-0.0437693931,
-0.3187876344,
-0.5692470074,
0.2446261048,
0.4551048577,
1.0649675131,
0.3889048696,
0.046182286,
0.6058501005,
-0.7674833536,
0.6408596039,
0.0641463026,
-1.4070426226,
0.4608781636,
-0.2636045814,
0.2939913571,
0.8501960635,
0.4998390675,
-0.7686066031,
-0.1707111299,
-0.3564976156,
-0.8243091106,
0.609905839,
-0.1775717735,
0.1528513134,
-0.1587385237,
0.2720160186,
0.4529229701,
0.3019792736,
-0.553319335,
-0.332126677,
0.227642253,
-0.1240195855,
0.2943657339,
-0.2224236578,
-0.0411077552,
-0.5134803057,
0.8791911602,
-0.3446125388,
0.1470020711,
0.0808912888,
-0.14844881,
-0.404910475,
0.2701852322,
0.2828980386,
0.7975600362,
0.007871653,
-0.1454806924,
0.2176127285,
-0.4171650112,
0.1323766559,
-0.075409472,
-0.0644970089,
-0.0793704912,
0.5404619575,
0.7172486186,
0.4486926496,
-1.084749341,
0.3821256459,
0.094926998,
-0.3910273314,
-0.172352463,
0.3302658796,
-0.2159781605,
0.1602604985,
0.4293002188,
0.0606719963,
0.615504086,
-0.781272471,
0.1053235978,
0.4330793917,
-0.3510915637,
-0.4154857397,
0.6568412185,
0.0681479499,
-0.023662515,
0.3035832047,
-0.2661277056,
-0.5462483764,
0.2667817473,
0.4548773468,
0.9433290958,
-0.3681595027,
0.2158836573,
0.4481466711,
0.1855675727,
-0.3632469475,
0.3143276572,
-0.398314178,
-0.8073806167,
-0.3698807359,
-0.7943093777,
-0.8524439335,
-0.036514625,
-0.7562144399,
0.3128708601,
-0.3867781162,
-0.1588768214,
0.0305853933,
0.4327239096,
-0.5244061947,
0.407584846,
0.1663357466,
1.1436232328,
-0.6303091645,
0.8889139891,
0.7976010442,
0.1176880747,
-0.2192206085,
0.2658587396,
-0.1967492104,
-0.8369598985,
0.573829174,
0.0331262872,
-0.5471388698,
-0.1423896998,
-0.3321981132,
-0.9528390169,
0.9576649666,
0.1704670787,
-0.7356824279,
0.0928281322,
0.0835234001,
0.7848774195,
-0.1983887106,
0.0945942551,
1.0329571962,
0.78300488,
-0.4234897196,
-0.7790123224,
-0.0480510481,
-0.7500872016,
-0.0050908825,
0.2763186395,
-0.6491919756,
0.5741311312,
-0.1916960329,
-0.3184800446,
0.1344306469,
0.7701396942,
0.2789264023,
0.4527610242,
0.4717231393,
0.5070161223,
0.8531774282,
-0.3210333288,
0.8210458159,
-0.4617624283,
0.2671972513,
1.1477919817,
-0.9541314244,
0.9091078043,
0.2065621912,
-0.5572328568,
0.4633473754,
0.3558056056,
-0.1398687065,
0.3336631656,
0.4294137359,
-0.2820240855,
-0.103670612,
-0.0352425054,
-0.3892586827,
0.4076168239,
0.3020198941,
0.2604458034,
-0.1976445466,
0.0480167456,
0.0537385233,
0.2949150801,
-0.1549148262,
0.4761831164,
0.054687582,
-0.8038833737,
0.376298666,
0.0586542301,
0.7149347663,
-0.7981482744,
0.0819931179,
-0.1736405194,
0.0055469093,
-0.1625037193,
-1.0395669937,
0.5805651546,
0.0667448789,
0.1967698187,
-0.0583710074,
0.6623247862,
-0.3222802877,
-0.3053474724,
0.734757185,
0.6008799076,
-0.1571682394,
-0.1991983205,
-0.6016667485,
0.2812648118,
-0.2943860292,
-0.5493281484,
0.3639270663,
0.3611074686,
-0.2360664457,
0.7951417565,
0.3111336827,
0.1780969501,
-0.0898697823,
0.3006124198,
0.8154525161,
-0.7727353573,
-0.2238171101,
-0.7481812239,
0.2019741237,
-0.2096482366,
-0.5641612411,
0.9383594394,
0.4126971066,
0.8895512819,
0.0995712429,
0.9339959621,
-0.1171020418,
0.4314582348,
-0.3942624927,
0.8034890294,
-0.8789789677,
0.0987743139,
-0.4477083981,
-0.9772020578,
-0.4163155854,
0.4209344983,
-0.3384015858,
0.3029338419,
0.81942451,
0.1504013836,
0.3272835612,
0.094754532,
0.6866494417,
-0.072748892,
0.0644096062,
0.485442549,
1.0051739216,
-0.5539334416,
0.0599537604,
-0.4831288755,
-0.3119395077,
-0.1600326747,
-0.7795102,
-0.751024425,
-0.7597588301,
-0.5630786419,
0.2209397405,
-0.1096694171,
0.9839771986,
0.6045240164,
-0.8313281536,
-0.4952525795,
0.1774540693,
0.0267815031,
-0.5574620366,
-0.2298610657,
0.0603561737,
-0.3144355118,
-0.7234443426,
0.4405747652,
0.7583643198,
-0.3596712351,
-0.4508272111,
0.072189562,
0.0580926426,
-0.0298931375,
0.7233512998,
0.206006363,
-0.6177008152,
-0.1766802967,
0.2530395389,
0.0285448804,
0.4123226106,
0.9340513349,
-0.5184165239,
0.0260041878,
0.5277790427,
0.7435275316,
-0.0244575571,
-0.375295192,
0.4149500132,
-0.3319445252,
-0.4357917011,
0.347987175,
0.618989706,
0.2988843024,
-0.2452841699,
0.5100055933,
0.0793343112,
-0.6955054998,
-0.9525895119,
-0.0583204888,
-1.0019997358,
-0.0760028362,
0.6862226725,
-0.2074744999,
-0.4385431409,
-0.1840722859,
-0.0527450293,
0.0481451303,
-0.029016193,
0.8249031305,
0.7616491318,
-0.0169250499,
-0.0829280317,
-0.8085303903,
0.4666481912,
0.600654006,
-1.429369688,
0.3007560074,
0.2171334475,
0.3377206326,
0.1858294606,
0.7610823512,
-0.2362387031,
0.4016503096,
-0.1641087383,
0.2944180965,
0.5294008255,
-0.3786870241,
-0.3328039348,
-0.040656779,
0.4327548146,
0.3046447337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05779v1 | Transformer-based Time-to-Event Prediction for Chronic Kidney Disease Deterioration | 2023-06-09T09:46:38 | 2023-06-09T09:46:38 | Moshe Zisser, Dvir Aran | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Deep-learning techniques, particularly the transformer model, have shown
great potential in enhancing the prediction performance of longitudinal health
records. While previous methods have mainly focused on fixed-time risk
prediction, time-to-event prediction (also known as survival analysis) is often
more appropriate for clinical scenarios. Here, we present a novel deep-learning
architecture we named STRAFE, a generalizable survival analysis
transformer-based architecture for electronic health records. The performance
of STRAFE was evaluated using a real-world claim dataset of over 130,000
individuals with stage 3 chronic kidney disease (CKD) and was found to
outperform other time-to-event prediction algorithms in predicting the exact
time of deterioration to stage 5. Additionally, STRAFE was found to outperform
binary outcome algorithms in predicting fixed-time risk, possibly due to its
ability to train on censored data. We show that STRAFE predictions can improve
the positive predictive value of high-risk patients by 3-fold, demonstrating
possible usage to improve targeting for intervention programs. Finally, we
suggest a novel visualization approach to predictions on a per-patient basis.
In conclusion, STRAFE is a cutting-edge time-to-event prediction algorithm that
has the potential to enhance risk predictions in large claims datasets. | [
0.0647810549,
-0.4802269638,
0.6847435832,
0.2605398595,
-0.616265595,
0.1801362336,
0.1574191898,
-0.3908732533,
0.2726649642,
0.2745731175,
-0.4325696528,
-0.5361223221,
-0.8226242065,
-0.1786645949,
0.0021385092,
1.0243474245,
-0.0147477994,
0.5045795441,
0.0623900816,
-0.16825822,
-0.8090151548,
-0.0824990049,
-0.8901155591,
-0.4599509537,
0.6282554865,
0.1812118888,
0.7038795352,
0.4654407203,
0.6837486625,
0.098613359,
0.1875692755,
-0.2491547316,
-0.3645467758,
0.1671959758,
0.2008840591,
-0.0900484473,
-0.4240431786,
-0.4484215975,
0.1105222479,
0.6100440025,
-0.1730466783,
-0.1053791344,
-0.1619691849,
0.6767501235,
-0.4051002562,
0.0029593452,
-0.2096582949,
0.5748807788,
-0.0267678071,
-0.5973621607,
-0.6391379237,
-0.3551118672,
0.5018815398,
-0.269693017,
0.2114097178,
-0.2133786231,
0.5871365666,
0.6149141788,
-0.5609493852,
-0.2218771726,
-0.8262989521,
0.4285031259,
-0.3601509929,
0.5284770727,
0.2038797438,
0.856271565,
-0.1193433404,
-0.9920768738,
-0.0947307274,
-0.2252050042,
-0.1378086358,
0.4043827057,
0.2830378115,
0.2197936326,
-0.0114097083,
0.4397814572,
-0.7521636486,
0.2285277843,
-0.4015195072,
-0.0997713804,
0.698992312,
0.2253464162,
0.3489423394,
-0.2452666312,
-0.6364033222,
-0.0418072492,
-0.6785901785,
-0.0619242154,
-0.2667656541,
-0.1431085467,
-0.423458308,
0.1531363279,
0.0598676465,
-0.052438166,
0.1698220521,
0.0742878392,
0.4146738052,
-0.0330437496,
-0.4462719858,
0.2545351386,
0.6502477527,
0.5253517628,
0.0471480861,
-0.4175529778,
0.1597647965,
-0.0507025495,
0.3203657568,
-1.1590342522,
-0.5557147264,
0.5838442445,
-0.9283620119,
-0.5473413467,
-0.2087919861,
-0.8727765679,
-0.4834428132,
-0.0284840576,
0.1932135671,
-0.5266188979,
-0.1280691475,
0.2044968754,
-0.1418266892,
-0.1057168171,
0.3718801737,
-0.4237006605,
0.143275097,
0.4003533721,
0.8095018864,
-0.4619771838,
0.0984670967,
-0.7241773009,
0.0182505026,
-0.2773720324,
0.799151957,
-0.5747256279,
-0.6662727594,
0.1014056951,
0.0272341017,
0.0295259207,
-0.3125471771,
0.7030718327,
-0.540354073,
-0.2205221057,
0.3938373923,
-0.493332535,
0.1922295988,
-0.0383424647,
-0.9421100616,
0.7163887024,
0.1752445847,
-0.6614179015,
0.8568781018,
-0.561119318,
-0.6273187995,
0.3799250126,
-0.1890806705,
-1.3853360415,
0.4314132929,
-0.0397277512,
0.5295760036,
-0.1940975338,
0.7637129426,
-0.4810050428,
-0.0712461844,
-0.031968344,
-0.5114306211,
0.3789236546,
0.2417636663,
-0.3711394072,
0.2690042257,
-0.6805164814,
-0.0251425188,
0.0459586643,
-0.2412362546,
-0.1117475107,
0.3244060576,
0.252648443,
0.2069402188,
-0.3624296784,
-0.6243518591,
0.3078573644,
-0.2817548215,
0.5800467134,
0.5956229568,
0.2554079592,
0.348867774,
-0.3842735291,
0.2884376347,
0.2614698112,
0.7831683755,
-0.0582504794,
-0.4569787085,
-0.4205238521,
-0.0781583488,
0.4531769753,
0.4811400771,
-0.4804106355,
0.0022101069,
-0.8624248505,
-0.5633786917,
-0.2839048207,
-0.4654306173,
0.1667441279,
0.2082512826,
0.77219522,
-0.2553577125,
-0.480055958,
-1.0515682697,
0.0296113547,
-0.1909415573,
-0.5024068356,
0.3614655733,
0.6991681457,
-0.5904970765,
0.3234308064,
-0.666185081,
-0.5473816991,
-0.2421193123,
0.3135708869,
0.1742437035,
0.5964218974,
0.3112049699,
-0.9767507315,
-0.6564109921,
0.0680294707,
-0.581474483,
0.4097851813,
-0.1502197981,
0.1116504371,
-0.1926410943,
0.1748421937,
-0.3721359074,
0.9033393264,
0.5090606213,
-0.3715683818,
0.6204183102,
-0.2426191717,
0.1721706241,
-0.8697951436,
-0.1082888395,
-0.1220291778,
0.1217290834,
-0.9443028569,
-0.5476872921,
0.2509342134,
-0.2650464773,
-0.1978937984,
0.5934052467,
-0.0387905091,
0.2892719209,
-0.1323915869,
-0.4662263095,
-0.2599736154,
0.2923535407,
0.4295504689,
0.3292568624,
0.2463661432,
-0.2869042754,
-0.1571977735,
0.4540688097,
-0.57453233,
0.2978731096,
-0.8158669472,
0.0605649874,
-0.337395817,
0.4721873999,
-0.5782396793,
-0.3305490017,
-0.0667011961,
-0.7273097634,
0.6240536571,
-0.2016406953,
0.1121689081,
-0.6360570788,
-0.4852107763,
0.5844753385,
0.1561338454,
-0.2137060016,
1.2304085493,
0.2390625626,
-0.1755060107,
-0.4777942002,
-0.7157090902,
0.0659797043,
-0.2551504374,
-0.5909045935,
0.6114544272,
-0.2234899402,
0.0876339599,
-0.0406079665,
0.0296650007,
-0.2661896646,
0.2558819354,
0.8445962071,
0.5442227721,
-0.1704223007,
0.4775587916,
0.0085082669,
-0.436543107,
-0.1039460897,
-0.4491845071,
0.4606433809,
0.2600082159,
-0.33097139,
-0.7008447647,
0.5725063682,
0.4971022308,
-0.098339729,
0.5722491741,
0.391664952,
-0.6599748731,
-0.0703833923,
-0.6041944027,
-0.1907165945,
-0.4078581631,
0.3853346109,
-0.1763014346,
-0.5256536007,
0.4222088456,
-0.0156281702,
0.1185881868,
0.6239165664,
0.3983035386,
-0.4099707007,
0.8663629889,
0.5692334771,
-0.2494229972,
0.2417452633,
-0.4302647114,
0.2620267868,
-0.6405724883,
-0.6275187731,
-0.3630787134,
-0.4953356087,
-0.6111314893,
-0.5745443106,
0.602073729,
-0.0190018937,
-0.4883675873,
0.131286934,
-0.5637738705,
-0.0022515655,
0.0456267931,
0.4628856182,
0.2948820293,
-0.0525713079,
0.1338180304,
-0.1489915699,
-0.6051125526,
-0.1694510728,
1.3153597116,
0.5271339417,
0.5332624912,
-0.2858973145,
0.5790615082,
0.7961734533,
1.0293118954,
-0.7516458631,
-0.260250181,
-0.1490672976,
-0.6348389983,
-0.394826889,
-0.3610437214,
-0.8923177123,
-0.2309419811,
-0.2531698644,
-0.4331441224,
0.4294780791,
0.4092471898,
-0.6113069057,
0.454215467,
-0.3793674707,
0.8097851276,
-0.5631504655,
-0.2108659595,
-0.3906725645,
-0.6351183057,
-0.066307418,
-0.054220628,
0.2176727802,
0.008891453,
0.2737357318,
0.5220295191,
-0.2948367,
0.6913657784,
-0.2834241688,
0.3714646697,
-0.1841815263,
0.1277565658,
0.7726376653,
0.5908170342,
-0.1665391624,
0.2164996415,
-0.2140328139,
-0.57840693,
-0.4472636282,
0.6378025413,
-0.5490014553,
-0.3300748169,
-0.3541882336,
-0.1778182983,
-0.3327874243,
0.1182144955,
0.2609685063,
0.6868162155,
-0.3376942575,
0.3733573854,
0.5490394831,
-0.3685732186,
0.3433039486,
0.1970243603,
0.5605319142,
-0.9299964309,
0.7310162783,
0.0281368494,
0.2359805107,
0.6530413628,
0.3422017097,
-0.1904127449,
-1.0286513567,
-0.4999708831,
0.1016261131,
-0.370752275,
-0.5884867311,
-0.6286237836,
-0.1852922738,
0.0668916851,
-0.5942207575,
-0.321231395,
0.1148450375,
-0.0282645784,
-0.4938637316,
0.0505271219,
0.5676774979,
0.2121759355,
0.2423734367,
-0.7108492255,
0.0902906284,
0.1250371933,
0.5397270918,
-0.0320261382,
-0.2839163244,
-0.1625374705,
-0.1389774978,
-0.5058079362,
-0.6590262651,
0.3444639742,
0.4288261235,
0.3765490353,
0.681286335,
0.2522469461,
0.6560782194,
-0.6453635693,
0.6031932235,
0.8252449036,
-0.4494762719,
0.6315795183,
-0.1418615729,
-0.1108821332,
0.4925344586,
0.3716187775,
-0.6732316613,
0.0580771454,
-0.8789294958,
-0.8076023459,
0.0961330011,
0.2150927931,
-0.08124125,
-0.082311824,
0.2514976561,
0.3224016726,
-0.0987561867,
-0.4857867658,
-0.3872030973,
-0.5323393941,
-0.3205499351,
-0.1074979827,
-0.4468946159,
0.1422832757,
-0.0323747396,
0.5123466253,
-0.312687099,
0.3844920397,
0.4679292142,
-0.1622094363,
-0.1950585097,
0.2548951507,
0.3834651113,
0.434361577,
-0.271481663,
-0.169463113,
0.5714969039,
-0.4944587648,
0.1059178784,
0.1469267756,
-0.2750595212,
-0.0764430314,
0.6438422203,
1.0350519419,
0.5934697986,
-0.6017858386,
0.6905642152,
-0.1185575649,
-0.4143846631,
-0.8335558772,
-0.4152185321,
0.0861801058,
0.1421097368,
0.6367043257,
0.1159173623,
0.234700188,
-0.2444654405,
0.4971624911,
0.1449097842,
-0.8836336732,
-0.4782869518,
1.1530823708,
0.4547918439,
-0.3528165519,
0.5963700414,
0.3658775091,
-0.1650181413,
0.8169537783,
0.1889721751,
0.9612881541,
-0.4256483018,
0.4811649024,
0.4669063985,
0.0490591675,
0.1435222626,
0.0020445748,
0.1725719571,
-0.2724591494,
-0.6108349562,
-0.8755332232,
0.0482240766,
0.5162003636,
-0.5861976147,
0.3664853275,
-0.4901269376,
-0.2638825178,
0.1790231168,
0.1769965142,
-0.8324075937,
0.5072099566,
0.3102706671,
1.1493608952,
-0.6769599915,
0.8267423511,
0.1390543729,
-0.2195735276,
-0.5422632098,
-0.2102500051,
-0.0882487893,
-0.4518113434,
0.7243332267,
0.2833764553,
0.2641943395,
-0.1367439032,
0.0354810879,
-0.5141111016,
1.3086065054,
0.1071217507,
-0.6015968323,
-0.2789840698,
0.1665178537,
0.529265523,
-0.3413138688,
0.3120761812,
0.4605108798,
0.5174120665,
0.0031892182,
-0.8950951695,
-0.10384617,
-0.1764344275,
0.071224831,
0.5127698183,
-0.4279821515,
0.2378346175,
-0.5531273484,
-0.3996461034,
-0.0485183597,
0.6259840727,
-0.184979856,
0.7647824883,
0.4206323922,
0.6705695987,
0.4857654572,
-0.2853504121,
1.1759892702,
-0.172787413,
0.4459558129,
0.9316831827,
-0.0766469017,
0.6909163594,
0.1593542099,
-0.2093974799,
0.486504823,
0.5370761752,
-0.1848204881,
0.6884034872,
-0.0186442267,
-0.3164291978,
-0.543338418,
0.1398108006,
-0.3984732926,
-0.0669098943,
0.4409025908,
-0.7442126274,
-0.1482064575,
0.3680387437,
-0.3823741376,
-0.2820122242,
-0.2092196196,
0.6392703056,
0.1567816585,
-0.4931049347,
0.4332213402,
-0.596960187,
0.2956273854,
-0.5106209517,
-0.2120150924,
-0.1670103818,
0.4184709787,
-0.3910363913,
-0.623030901,
0.3058452308,
-0.7528424859,
-0.3364184797,
-0.0810905322,
0.7156748176,
-0.1121537685,
-0.44264552,
0.6835939884,
0.094948709,
-0.2442889959,
0.1920264214,
-0.4857464731,
0.0913837925,
-0.0764585212,
-0.1971870363,
0.4811640382,
0.0448545627,
-0.0798198804,
1.1209284067,
0.4958307743,
0.1490912586,
-0.2602460086,
0.0199624337,
1.0084768534,
-0.6186829209,
-0.1438988894,
-0.5394765139,
0.8079392314,
-0.276591301,
-0.4052335918,
-0.0598187484,
0.7051080465,
0.475545764,
-0.2916221917,
0.9965116978,
0.0483452529,
0.3765127957,
-0.2551470101,
0.5489622355,
-0.4078118503,
-0.0641001984,
0.2127826661,
-0.0588320903,
-0.4833738506,
0.2264238894,
-0.5118845105,
-0.3972804546,
0.7204137444,
0.4139041901,
-0.0053947419,
0.023952825,
0.3296850026,
0.2606306672,
0.6514391899,
0.6974598169,
0.3199805021,
-0.4964850247,
0.7589127421,
-0.2617850602,
-0.3351333737,
-0.6937243938,
-0.5664222836,
-0.7416165471,
-0.5606578588,
-0.3414876163,
-0.2933517396,
0.4263388813,
0.6889936328,
0.8314623237,
-1.1500436068,
0.3387382627,
0.0461631902,
-0.3310731947,
-0.3879876733,
-0.1070022658,
0.9001153111,
-0.1095132455,
-0.3219261467,
0.4060110152,
0.5629296303,
-0.0903474092,
0.1934105158,
-0.3301930726,
0.3427464366,
-0.3648529649,
0.6658008099,
0.2364293337,
-0.4799298346,
-0.5762155056,
-0.0626482964,
0.0052480293,
0.2569026351,
0.9260664582,
-0.7566812038,
0.33482638,
0.3061582148,
0.5883120298,
0.8247967958,
0.0449335203,
0.6080409288,
0.0231882036,
-0.1296441853,
0.714283824,
0.4417063594,
0.0188719183,
-0.5158315897,
0.3642314076,
0.2441354543,
-0.7329503894,
-0.5367393494,
0.1882638782,
-0.6922240257,
-0.0800480843,
0.6728415489,
-0.1469558328,
-0.1203463227,
-0.6079665422,
0.1090331525,
0.2271843702,
-0.3085102141,
1.125231266,
0.1275094748,
-0.1908022314,
0.018885294,
-0.9117953181,
0.6700132489,
0.2488782108,
-0.7283918262,
0.1481260061,
0.2924822271,
0.6331244111,
0.3229067326,
0.4346500635,
-0.1410173774,
0.5871175528,
-0.2580688,
-0.1875479668,
-0.1080222353,
-0.3876409233,
0.1437589526,
0.3641483188,
-0.3974435925,
-0.026866708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05741v1 | Challenges and Opportunities for the Design of Smart Speakers | 2023-06-09T08:18:58 | 2023-06-09T08:18:58 | Tao Long, Lydia B. Chilton | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.RO | Advances in voice technology and voice user interfaces (VUIs) -- such as
Alexa, Siri, and Google Home -- have opened up the potential for many new types
of interaction. However, despite the potential of these devices reflected by
the growing market and body of VUI research, there is a lingering sense that
the technology is still underused. In this paper, we conducted a systematic
literature review of 35 papers to identify and synthesize 127 VUI design
guidelines into five themes. Additionally, we conducted semi-structured
interviews with 15 smart speaker users to understand their use and non-use of
the technology. From the interviews, we distill four design challenges that
contribute the most to non-use. Based on their (non-)use, we identify four
opportunity spaces for designers to explore such as focusing on information
support while multitasking (cooking, driving, childcare, etc), incorporating
users' mental models for smart speakers, and integrating calm design
principles. | [
-0.7858130932,
-0.0576453879,
0.575612843,
-0.134234935,
-0.1846382916,
-0.0826661438,
0.2247462273,
-0.4976233244,
0.2101001889,
0.4297613204,
-0.9795538187,
0.1878890097,
0.0127857476,
0.0283781029,
-0.2464010268,
0.4386931956,
0.393622905,
-0.2402065694,
0.0320447907,
-0.0928861797,
-1.262665987,
-0.169739455,
0.3449099958,
-0.1912504435,
0.5545040369,
1.1004308462,
0.7360454798,
-0.2863497138,
0.2052834332,
0.3022828102,
-0.0433564559,
0.3286876976,
0.1410247087,
0.1636107713,
0.0135727813,
-0.0271137059,
-0.599265337,
0.2096816599,
0.2981217504,
0.6106207967,
0.000487096,
0.0652790964,
0.0255170818,
0.5426953435,
-0.6463260651,
-0.0396699309,
-0.3517122567,
0.2372868061,
-0.4323961139,
-0.6178659797,
-0.2550161183,
-0.360357821,
0.1042988896,
-0.862090826,
-0.1567205936,
-0.1599795371,
0.7066136003,
0.1736055315,
-0.3567211926,
-0.2405571043,
-1.5544520617,
0.9692839384,
-0.662144959,
0.6816784739,
0.2910780609,
0.1232249737,
-0.439743191,
-0.1567592472,
-0.7891392112,
0.1193143725,
0.049677182,
0.0906159878,
-0.3254832625,
-0.0002377101,
-0.0369681194,
0.2286532968,
-0.3021740913,
0.029722413,
-0.4761759341,
0.1053843573,
0.6015821099,
-0.1396264285,
0.4453363419,
-0.2612916529,
-0.3059239089,
0.1132592484,
-0.5387920737,
0.1767669618,
0.4242185354,
0.4158914089,
0.302391082,
0.6029430032,
-0.099762693,
0.8473805785,
-0.1055326462,
-0.4818371236,
0.3842750192,
-0.7046215534,
0.1388178915,
-0.0131528312,
0.3194315732,
0.5185625553,
0.3134171367,
-0.1601539254,
-0.1551899165,
-0.3863734007,
0.7513616085,
-0.2721856534,
0.1736076772,
0.5560653806,
-0.3541831672,
0.1546083838,
-0.1497543454,
-0.6792864203,
-0.5707201362,
-0.5019891858,
0.4966746867,
-0.088724643,
-0.5199806094,
0.1286155581,
-0.7957593799,
0.2803656757,
0.0583230332,
-0.9505624175,
0.4419744611,
0.5187854767,
0.5209316611,
0.2699051499,
0.2544749975,
-0.0964283571,
0.0109317163,
-0.2689269185,
0.7971606851,
-0.2609346807,
-1.2457361221,
-0.1236189678,
-0.1795538068,
-0.1760185659,
-0.680021286,
0.8554700613,
-0.0825166255,
0.3681937158,
-0.6680706143,
-0.3265094459,
0.206735611,
-0.2073650956,
-0.3816607893,
0.4388009608,
-0.2129355967,
-0.5592475533,
0.3544167578,
-0.8346359134,
-0.5328998566,
0.4683215916,
-0.2221840322,
-0.5792418718,
0.4528153837,
-0.0120457401,
0.2014595866,
-0.1450064033,
0.1473750919,
-0.2030644417,
-0.6110352874,
0.1806015968,
-0.1367472857,
0.5265163779,
0.6716448069,
-0.5607164502,
0.0971347988,
-0.9828598499,
0.0537520014,
0.1566074491,
-0.0339368582,
-0.4895075858,
0.5616030693,
0.3305209279,
0.2661208808,
-0.1230161041,
-1.0072176456,
-0.2086231411,
0.0085941004,
0.6451714039,
0.4930505753,
-0.2147212029,
0.1395211965,
-0.4538975954,
0.4627690017,
-0.2168962508,
0.6090993881,
-0.2331518829,
-0.8311800957,
-0.6885048151,
-0.2356351912,
0.0266637076,
0.7617758512,
-0.5513843298,
0.5838567019,
-0.1628205031,
-0.6320047379,
-0.614074111,
0.139478907,
0.1042834818,
0.2403931916,
0.2567190528,
-0.155016616,
-0.3511084318,
-1.2046225071,
-0.3736128211,
-0.2124700248,
-0.0816909447,
0.7374020815,
0.0754685029,
-0.2663029134,
1.3337397575,
-0.0418103188,
-0.3528591096,
-0.1799302995,
0.1340148896,
0.1381968111,
0.4035057425,
0.5100454688,
-1.1303693056,
-0.0273295809,
0.2293435633,
-0.6982268095,
-0.3436275423,
-0.4483750165,
0.6052339077,
-0.2507633269,
0.3323836327,
-1.0091152191,
0.7072961926,
0.1153560057,
-0.141959995,
0.2530998588,
0.0562119335,
0.2040420175,
-0.6888082027,
0.2002960891,
0.3443596959,
0.2699227929,
-0.9275095463,
-0.3525226414,
-0.0931137353,
-0.764716208,
-0.6039978862,
0.6622347832,
-0.4343705177,
-0.0985946134,
-0.3850527704,
0.3152408302,
0.1856520176,
0.1356094927,
-0.2312739044,
0.6782966852,
-0.0505761243,
-0.5806288123,
0.3737344742,
0.1913626492,
-0.3938958347,
0.6639609933,
-0.9201921225,
0.1661491096,
0.0368313752,
0.1030079946,
-1.1086986065,
0.1074337736,
0.29783234,
-0.2772973478,
0.1511414647,
0.3841764033,
-0.433483988,
-0.6522600651,
-0.4699238837,
0.333923161,
0.4160705805,
-0.2744623721,
0.977368176,
0.625156939,
-0.6493151188,
-0.0060738926,
-0.5040539503,
0.0949959382,
-0.50743258,
-0.5778925419,
0.4802470505,
-0.3115684092,
-0.5186906457,
-0.2095435262,
-0.1407633573,
0.2664290965,
0.213288188,
0.4240269363,
-0.0970066413,
0.2130965441,
0.2058004886,
-0.3036865294,
-0.5402043462,
-0.3126273453,
-0.1825068593,
0.0395754054,
-0.1140325665,
-0.626470089,
-1.1543493271,
0.9151067734,
0.8713801503,
-0.3571007848,
0.0656727925,
0.3653204739,
-0.2298445553,
0.1224640235,
-0.9286221266,
-0.1594643593,
-0.5517134666,
0.0554161035,
-0.5362420082,
-0.6206156611,
0.3698473275,
-0.0891639069,
0.356092006,
-0.0664845482,
0.4541372657,
-0.3783465922,
0.8276740909,
0.9278891683,
0.1644095033,
0.9024101496,
0.1685468107,
0.9315954447,
-0.6674638987,
-0.6300963163,
-0.8607084751,
-0.3359005153,
-0.8262360096,
-0.0204713643,
0.3858141899,
-0.243443504,
0.1579714864,
0.4833735228,
-0.5573544502,
-0.2168838531,
0.9820286632,
-0.2677353919,
0.1845398098,
-0.2878392041,
0.1605166644,
-0.2457295358,
-0.6410554647,
-0.4090815187,
0.5160144567,
0.4547287822,
0.922611177,
0.1562153399,
0.4633556604,
0.4073253572,
-0.5067824125,
-0.7046523094,
0.5808104277,
0.228908971,
-0.611058712,
-0.2523183227,
0.0189761315,
-1.1300472021,
0.2706626654,
0.2073868364,
-1.0890250206,
0.9514309168,
0.1784834713,
-0.6457157731,
0.0387906469,
-1.2760611773,
0.4427341521,
-0.4012052119,
-0.0680384934,
-0.1155827641,
-0.4979542196,
-0.0642256811,
0.0482206084,
0.6251655817,
0.088706769,
0.5297329426,
0.6038755178,
-0.2919065058,
0.7867982388,
-0.2402073443,
-0.0660802275,
0.8816606998,
-0.4387198389,
0.0434157327,
-0.084297061,
-0.0873978734,
-0.1955875903,
0.0597750358,
-0.4239756167,
-0.4420663714,
0.5346723199,
-0.7764161825,
-0.8092027903,
-0.5091776252,
-0.285600692,
-0.5762364268,
0.2191954404,
0.2149505466,
0.5191895366,
-0.1856545061,
0.307428062,
0.7084178925,
-0.2086313218,
0.4738174379,
0.1221370697,
0.0230292771,
-0.0233187247,
1.1981687546,
0.4451353252,
-0.0407233648,
0.1364756376,
0.4111765921,
-0.1525542438,
-0.4183517694,
-0.1885806471,
0.0083560124,
-0.2710625529,
0.3802578747,
-0.5466889143,
-0.1943667084,
-0.6555869579,
-0.0044233901,
-0.6167491078,
-0.4214605391,
-0.4482344985,
-0.2289894819,
-0.0226798058,
0.7747430801,
-0.0959047601,
0.2218675166,
-0.5275063515,
0.5791057944,
0.9010634422,
0.2572264671,
-0.1457437128,
-0.2228238732,
-0.0128336502,
-0.3176628053,
-0.6801156998,
-0.7678880692,
0.164367646,
0.0366352536,
1.0488033295,
0.3653979599,
0.3430601358,
0.4601435065,
-0.4108177125,
0.9582738876,
0.0066585122,
-0.6050998569,
0.7083992958,
-0.5889019966,
0.5417681336,
0.4430606365,
0.1728937775,
-0.5659538507,
0.1341182739,
-0.8106590509,
-1.0769942999,
0.3057306111,
0.3778283894,
0.2666583955,
0.4163253903,
-0.1033766866,
0.0829367712,
0.6436746716,
-0.5269745588,
-0.030466225,
-0.658634603,
0.1884651929,
0.0143202553,
-0.4050584733,
-0.1794042438,
-0.425848037,
0.6511304379,
0.002575075,
0.5758224726,
0.0779015869,
0.4810044765,
-0.0592300855,
0.8208703995,
0.9354599714,
0.5902892947,
-0.309358716,
-0.1614185125,
-0.152538076,
-0.0089803394,
-0.2963855267,
0.1554338336,
-0.2218938172,
0.2053070813,
-0.0301452633,
0.7403656244,
0.3102277815,
-0.567117095,
0.3167561889,
-0.3287862241,
-0.0427768975,
-0.5844032764,
-0.0235078353,
0.1064700112,
0.1547561288,
0.4679406285,
0.1449170113,
0.1862612218,
-0.7583811283,
0.0865308046,
0.6245982051,
-0.756809175,
-0.3467494845,
0.4909138381,
0.7599312663,
-0.9208387136,
0.4337556064,
-0.1193717793,
-0.0909578875,
-0.0583725125,
0.0544557162,
0.9024345279,
-0.1465447396,
0.3044551909,
-0.5201010704,
0.3838943541,
0.696524322,
0.7698298693,
-0.3370442688,
-0.4794129133,
0.2416974753,
-0.0084705036,
-0.5279636383,
0.3391431272,
-0.5029044151,
0.1915537268,
-0.4262326658,
-0.9494382739,
0.2458514869,
0.0505128689,
-0.564001441,
0.0908456519,
0.3820088208,
0.558879137,
-0.8160890341,
0.4670628905,
0.6198953986,
0.246219784,
-0.3758098185,
-0.039093744,
0.5330554247,
-0.1578250378,
0.1303754449,
-0.2538190484,
-0.4042235315,
-0.3407055736,
-0.1944020241,
-0.4720368385,
0.7479280233,
-0.0426799506,
-0.5221175551,
0.1324446052,
0.0280849449,
0.3124508858,
0.0210493095,
0.2613474727,
0.3041214943,
0.8490352631,
-0.063895978,
-1.0777797699,
-0.6303088665,
-0.9403534532,
0.1424794495,
-0.1164075136,
-1.0601178408,
0.6471375227,
-0.1759299636,
-0.1162290722,
0.236934334,
0.3841615319,
0.1867257208,
0.5702263117,
0.4802286029,
0.1200356185,
0.4607236981,
-0.1988541037,
0.8522696495,
0.1956011951,
0.0292065423,
0.6550488472,
-0.2767749727,
0.4532514215,
0.7813165784,
0.0521850139,
0.2973713875,
0.5187048912,
0.0664846674,
0.7049335241,
0.0168944467,
-0.2871236503,
-0.3240933716,
-0.787129283,
-0.5709127784,
0.4160792828,
0.6107167006,
0.3603710234,
0.0247984491,
0.4336385727,
-0.1413017213,
0.0818894804,
0.1184997037,
0.6260660291,
0.3831745684,
-0.3643639088,
0.1873046458,
-0.140717268,
0.5508061051,
-0.4533995986,
0.0043644942,
0.0843800977,
0.2572977245,
-0.2642465234,
-0.3093161881,
0.0273171421,
-0.2897519469,
-0.1833518296,
-0.8272833824,
0.9081527591,
0.4284338057,
-0.4958493412,
0.4189254642,
0.5744247437,
-0.1003014669,
0.2259598821,
-0.5555100441,
0.3088016808,
-0.1435276717,
-0.4446591735,
0.2901887894,
0.4155278504,
-0.174055323,
0.9128397703,
0.3106503785,
0.0265712291,
0.1270702034,
0.1594786942,
0.811819911,
-0.76289922,
-0.5670529604,
-0.2542649806,
0.7340579033,
0.0228358172,
-0.8371120095,
0.9755089283,
0.2603422403,
0.7470829487,
-0.0005524295,
0.898768425,
0.0424058288,
0.8042377234,
0.0593033209,
0.4895028174,
-0.7340196371,
0.1907135695,
-0.668443799,
-0.6167402267,
0.0436907262,
0.4719687998,
-0.2265346199,
0.3737677336,
0.4155478477,
0.4119332731,
0.1247504577,
0.8029583097,
0.4028173983,
-0.2318601012,
0.7095223069,
0.0146534648,
0.8584960699,
-0.3503119349,
0.1968179196,
-0.4994857907,
-0.2963167727,
-0.6396663189,
-0.5889706016,
-0.5312530398,
-0.8498886824,
-0.5540556312,
0.2288392633,
0.1335613281,
0.6099846363,
1.1657756567,
-0.8653163314,
-0.2674610913,
0.1804780215,
0.3927791715,
-0.3558005691,
-0.1732643843,
-0.2003066987,
0.1199494079,
-0.5583872199,
1.0245393515,
0.3614500463,
0.1635599732,
-0.207713902,
0.3813318908,
-0.2350020856,
0.2259389609,
0.6084163189,
0.8909282684,
-0.8399983048,
-0.4934048653,
0.134349063,
0.0820214376,
-0.040404439,
1.0536476374,
-0.8180164099,
0.7910314798,
0.4652749896,
0.3874692619,
0.1500075459,
0.2041769624,
0.5136278272,
-0.5324888229,
0.2013930529,
0.3430517316,
0.2014335245,
0.2597156465,
-0.018996112,
-0.0349409543,
0.6446397901,
-0.4398596585,
-0.802854836,
0.4153921604,
-1.1827151775,
-0.3025271595,
0.8409987688,
0.2903461158,
0.087104544,
-0.8662384152,
-0.1787420362,
-0.0653409585,
-0.2968256772,
0.4923031032,
0.5089440942,
-0.4310415387,
-0.2239305079,
-1.1239010096,
0.2660814524,
0.5394910574,
-0.3595499694,
-0.2699996829,
-0.1579872668,
-0.0720547512,
0.7435730696,
0.7264075875,
-0.1299025118,
0.1485084891,
0.0183431394,
0.1036418676,
-0.0466107093,
-0.7473788261,
-0.0389811397,
0.2494306415,
0.2186109424,
-0.5170534849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07926v1 | A Theory of Unsupervised Speech Recognition | 2023-06-09T08:12:27 | 2023-06-09T08:12:27 | Liming Wang, Mark Hasegawa-Johnson, Chang D. Yoo | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Unsupervised speech recognition (ASR-U) is the problem of learning automatic
speech recognition (ASR) systems from unpaired speech-only and text-only
corpora. While various algorithms exist to solve this problem, a theoretical
framework is missing from studying their properties and addressing such issues
as sensitivity to hyperparameters and training instability. In this paper, we
proposed a general theoretical framework to study the properties of ASR-U
systems based on random matrix theory and the theory of neural tangent kernels.
Such a framework allows us to prove various learnability conditions and sample
complexity bounds of ASR-U. Extensive ASR-U experiments on synthetic languages
with three classes of transition graphs provide strong empirical evidence for
our theory (code available at cactuswiththoughts/UnsupASRTheory.git). | [
-0.3285768628,
-0.349170506,
0.368039012,
-0.1031252593,
-0.2045892626,
0.3363143206,
-0.4777331054,
-0.1691979319,
0.0097979838,
0.1873750687,
-0.2371203005,
-0.1615095586,
-0.3923076093,
-0.0405593552,
-0.9131664038,
0.7550403476,
0.2522768378,
0.2317005694,
-0.0574999675,
-0.2004514933,
-0.04200783,
-0.6087993383,
-0.3412697017,
-0.5867199302,
0.2697579861,
0.4111154079,
0.1967274845,
0.5593240857,
0.38057971,
0.2843598425,
-0.0859013423,
-0.5440603495,
-0.0215469319,
0.0104614589,
-0.1294739842,
-0.5742099881,
0.2021501362,
-0.1703154743,
0.9306499362,
1.040754199,
-0.4918961823,
0.043330837,
0.4047394693,
0.5943127275,
-0.3865066171,
-0.0138053969,
-0.538264513,
0.1958913654,
-0.2982699275,
-0.3189108074,
-0.3654956818,
-0.1397557408,
0.300799489,
-0.6076496243,
0.4923803806,
-0.2067147791,
0.3995703459,
0.0947155356,
-0.2680014372,
-0.1829243153,
-1.1780742407,
0.6187340021,
-0.361104399,
0.7666053772,
0.094906047,
0.4416460097,
-0.2836175859,
-0.6626958847,
-0.4928665161,
-0.2508054376,
0.0109922262,
-0.087207824,
-0.4928943813,
0.1832943857,
0.1511578709,
0.3615918458,
-0.4881978333,
0.2421321422,
-0.6472716928,
-0.2664921582,
0.2190711349,
-0.1078054979,
0.2505699098,
0.0160406251,
-0.2473894358,
-0.155823186,
-0.5922253132,
0.4900879264,
0.3058733642,
0.3672159314,
-0.0102064218,
0.536839664,
-0.0544187203,
0.4823413491,
0.0114302961,
0.0817941874,
0.2062985152,
0.3361928463,
-0.2540658116,
0.1948019713,
0.8540019393,
-0.2623459697,
0.5149675608,
-0.5120805502,
-0.1317104399,
0.5425983667,
0.2033648044,
-0.2375186831,
-0.3527283072,
-0.010048693,
-0.2641410828,
-0.1629570276,
0.1771827787,
-0.60733217,
-0.0984503403,
-0.49542588,
0.462379843,
-0.6122264862,
-0.4738598764,
-0.0948022977,
-0.2289190292,
-0.2083952576,
0.1104049906,
-0.5259929895,
0.8069061637,
0.198685959,
0.4488812387,
-0.466071099,
-0.5126016736,
-0.3496575952,
0.014652024,
-0.0562963597,
0.7706867456,
-0.578553915,
-0.4138453007,
0.1001358852,
-0.2790480852,
-0.3011139929,
-0.3255504072,
0.4929609001,
-0.5282108784,
-0.201898858,
-0.0836967453,
-0.6366219521,
-0.399931401,
-0.4271582365,
-0.2357760966,
0.5887343287,
-0.1403207332,
-0.7212043405,
0.2407912761,
-0.9551544189,
-0.4962718487,
-0.0990869477,
-0.3549012244,
-0.0776885971,
0.3349523246,
-0.1261929274,
0.3693685234,
-0.3157916367,
0.2354416251,
0.0413756855,
-0.4698191881,
0.6206244826,
-0.4118358791,
0.9387074113,
0.6484949589,
-0.2174115032,
0.0604391135,
-1.3086832762,
0.1445478946,
-0.0785453543,
-0.7322036028,
-0.2966832817,
0.1145024076,
0.2439982742,
-0.0819618478,
-0.2120688856,
-0.8588296771,
-0.2088025063,
-0.2264794856,
0.694388032,
0.5250650048,
-0.2960248291,
0.5847905874,
0.1675559282,
0.1030886769,
0.318985641,
-0.1856565922,
0.2070021778,
-0.3201849461,
-1.0345174074,
-0.2248138785,
0.5529939532,
0.3959791064,
-0.4277280271,
0.3497226834,
-0.0195018109,
-0.0614820458,
-0.1860510409,
0.044173032,
0.7977093458,
0.3055518568,
0.3569499254,
-0.4922758639,
-0.6962844133,
-0.7116878629,
-0.1612655967,
-0.3133616149,
-0.4429470003,
-0.0317928009,
0.0341731571,
-0.3509645462,
1.1296015978,
-0.2823188901,
-0.3665334582,
-0.1365087181,
0.3333933353,
0.0493832156,
0.6203629971,
0.0470136553,
-0.4861676991,
-0.0879495889,
-0.1197285876,
-0.6127452254,
0.050697159,
0.5675691366,
0.704631865,
0.3021813333,
0.5771870017,
-0.3779116869,
0.6329498887,
0.1238660365,
0.0426716916,
0.2243208885,
-0.6697891951,
-0.3385803401,
-0.8012790084,
0.0708718523,
0.3628467917,
0.0810784549,
-0.9819764495,
-0.0397142693,
-0.1480904967,
-0.2437390387,
-0.2477108538,
-0.0351697393,
-0.4025188386,
-0.548256278,
-0.269757539,
-0.2062447965,
-0.5677515268,
0.732935369,
0.0565364584,
0.3979476988,
0.8060904741,
-1.0843502283,
0.1662376374,
-0.0875944495,
-0.1860557199,
0.6038101912,
-0.6149911284,
0.1909418702,
-0.382152319,
0.1567703485,
-0.9840452075,
-0.007656977,
-0.1162307188,
-0.7347761989,
0.4745744765,
-0.2163482308,
-0.1098876745,
-0.4938172102,
0.2795004547,
0.5074674487,
0.4705186486,
-0.4546023607,
0.5133075118,
0.620741725,
0.3865591884,
-0.384304136,
-0.4029741585,
-0.3460929096,
-0.1680234224,
-0.1778569818,
0.0621156022,
0.0982287005,
-0.2447479963,
-0.00757107,
0.0995498002,
-0.3700036705,
-0.1824477166,
0.5915446877,
-0.1757782251,
-0.2543248236,
-0.076029174,
-0.2457838506,
-0.3189526498,
0.0194504727,
-0.3458490372,
0.6539772153,
-0.3307539821,
-0.3497880101,
-0.6597318053,
0.1652707458,
0.4190208614,
-0.0690859631,
-0.2340517044,
0.592904985,
-0.2924366891,
-0.1835291088,
-0.4345574081,
-0.2211120427,
-0.4508240819,
0.2380386442,
-0.4660641551,
-0.8982478976,
0.7972708941,
0.2558533549,
-0.2119418681,
0.5555799603,
0.5523464084,
-0.1214259192,
0.6462446451,
0.7298757434,
-0.2137563974,
0.1780420542,
-0.3006441295,
-0.0040100189,
-0.907091558,
-0.3331416249,
-0.6424185038,
-0.3077747822,
-0.7791438699,
-0.165792644,
0.4659532905,
-0.1637377292,
-0.4990898669,
0.4559818804,
-0.5763475299,
0.2432464361,
0.9185832739,
-0.1612247974,
0.3090991974,
0.3481198251,
-0.7641273141,
0.1124441326,
-0.6558129191,
-0.002169841,
1.0564039946,
0.4381507337,
0.9105146527,
-0.0665803552,
0.4065880179,
0.3425572515,
-0.2373653948,
-0.5607856512,
0.5430790782,
-0.2648975253,
-0.6384197474,
-0.6644874215,
-0.4268110096,
-1.0656434298,
0.1407373101,
-0.0473385528,
-1.1615992785,
0.5969682336,
0.2469959259,
-0.3460492194,
0.4329257905,
-0.5000950694,
0.0013345882,
0.1701329648,
0.2185946703,
-0.0119011709,
-0.9085512757,
0.0846709386,
0.0467573777,
0.1484824419,
0.1714854389,
0.5636412501,
1.1710879803,
-0.2079661787,
0.7700596452,
-0.3763280213,
0.2865818441,
0.4303230643,
0.1520929188,
0.0697135851,
-0.0531077087,
0.2255449742,
0.3243491948,
0.1356044561,
0.0978650451,
-0.4612036049,
0.5438223481,
-1.0238710642,
-0.2526569664,
-0.561532557,
-0.6182030439,
-0.4460766912,
0.1383462548,
0.7040657401,
0.5536210537,
-0.4428713322,
0.2369513363,
0.6566205025,
0.0098296609,
0.6209152937,
0.8144729733,
-0.1434435695,
-0.3001261652,
1.1545693874,
0.4545332789,
-0.139178887,
0.3083608747,
0.3145069182,
-0.4172024131,
-0.5657281876,
-0.4558078051,
-0.0834702104,
-0.5533636212,
-0.0270565487,
-0.6028720737,
-0.6668668985,
-0.2673653662,
0.1603857279,
-0.4346541464,
-0.6808781624,
-0.5322262049,
0.0016586243,
0.421087712,
0.9368764758,
-0.6687706113,
0.3326316476,
-0.240735516,
0.2085245848,
0.6684722304,
0.3408978879,
0.0021228914,
-0.9009662867,
0.0712752789,
0.2991018295,
-0.3042394817,
-0.3859685361,
0.3383927643,
0.3068006635,
0.5820761323,
0.6858542562,
0.0513699464,
0.2706656754,
-0.7716456652,
0.2546558678,
0.5657469034,
-0.9605925083,
0.2960263193,
-0.4620802402,
-0.288359195,
0.5124173164,
0.1593097895,
-0.205769375,
-0.3126798868,
-0.6791343093,
-0.5614928603,
0.5374575257,
0.3108195961,
-0.0289366599,
0.5010188818,
0.3463635147,
-0.082773529,
0.1459374428,
-0.509339571,
-0.4905145168,
-0.5008146167,
-0.1379578561,
-0.3233571649,
-0.2828348875,
-0.0252796859,
-0.466563195,
0.1911739409,
0.1273078918,
0.6829757094,
0.0188704245,
-0.1538721025,
-0.4850803018,
0.5182610154,
0.7341302037,
0.7710652351,
-0.6584985256,
0.5542241335,
-0.0734360516,
-0.7210326791,
0.6498262882,
0.3004323244,
-0.2680814862,
-0.1025288403,
-0.3180009127,
0.6835532188,
0.3102414608,
-0.2509809434,
0.4054898918,
-0.168863982,
-0.1416028738,
-0.4457392991,
0.2234339863,
-0.1839035749,
0.2268007994,
0.8504710197,
0.1330227256,
0.2555063963,
-0.56269449,
0.5528452992,
0.5275711417,
-0.8626146913,
-0.6531305909,
0.5750125647,
0.0637452379,
-0.7479246259,
0.4506829381,
0.1333829015,
-0.5293065906,
0.3882365525,
0.9895623326,
0.730897963,
-0.6504805088,
0.3563106656,
-0.056903217,
0.1527389735,
-0.0926226526,
-0.0280177537,
-0.1620950252,
-0.9013871551,
0.0232108254,
-0.809055984,
-0.5240327716,
0.2288735062,
-1.0193301439,
-0.0090296827,
-0.5704528689,
0.0458376557,
0.393945694,
-0.2283724099,
-0.4531682134,
0.5033508539,
-0.1884963214,
0.4248372018,
-0.7928575277,
0.9809198976,
0.7178779244,
-0.163198337,
-0.893193841,
-0.1612810642,
0.0191871412,
-1.1068907976,
0.7185860276,
-0.1181875095,
-0.1870633662,
0.2751273513,
-0.3317659497,
-0.9421051741,
0.6543290019,
0.4738714099,
-0.3798168898,
0.052049052,
0.3761799932,
0.5999584794,
-0.4111963212,
-0.1124617085,
0.641338706,
-0.0465021767,
0.434679538,
-0.9602765441,
-0.2251530886,
-0.2507523298,
0.0793993473,
0.0388228931,
-0.1973363906,
0.9384962916,
-0.4061237872,
-0.2263265699,
-0.1277312338,
0.7074578404,
0.2024412155,
0.3723775148,
0.5377926826,
0.7959173322,
0.4017045498,
0.0563147627,
0.5966754556,
0.0490470752,
0.3480314314,
0.79041785,
-0.1344308406,
0.9358321428,
0.4106416404,
-0.6424608827,
0.3478827775,
0.1944140494,
0.1714159697,
0.603556931,
0.6220856309,
-0.0911247656,
0.0110079218,
-0.0673415437,
-0.4788820446,
0.7859876752,
0.3479110897,
-0.403932333,
-0.1984312236,
0.2373265773,
-0.1220416427,
-0.0285696462,
-0.4158941209,
0.7545916438,
0.3219777942,
-0.1784630269,
0.6765729785,
0.051961638,
0.5720901489,
-0.3283763826,
0.2818681598,
0.2086154222,
0.2126333863,
-0.1299550533,
-0.4943775237,
0.1446887553,
-0.0558856167,
-0.3054256737,
0.3773783743,
0.7058665156,
-0.3041641116,
-0.7262920141,
0.1308078766,
0.3204742074,
0.2642885149,
0.1047301069,
-0.2183282673,
-0.0530589968,
-0.1385225803,
0.0764483586,
0.6147111654,
0.4735404253,
0.1458189785,
0.6404495835,
0.7993447781,
0.0894172266,
0.1366625279,
-0.0095721018,
1.0770294666,
-0.4116230905,
-0.6277422905,
-0.6155269146,
0.2134243995,
0.4264354408,
-0.0930901021,
0.5815655589,
0.4379284978,
0.6807115674,
0.1639603227,
0.6699936986,
0.2053089291,
0.8411195278,
-0.3690223992,
0.9762317538,
-0.4275745749,
0.2131861746,
-0.5338831544,
-0.8753928542,
-0.5216380954,
0.8943422437,
0.063702926,
-0.100116685,
0.6085422635,
0.4519404173,
-0.2637574673,
0.2039288878,
0.5581077933,
0.108561866,
0.0602905974,
0.3709931672,
0.7226250768,
-0.2277905047,
0.458825767,
-0.2622571886,
-0.1612518579,
-0.078306444,
-0.4739878178,
-0.9060266018,
-1.1666942835,
-0.0933136344,
-0.3929784894,
0.1684389561,
0.8764993548,
0.4490590394,
-0.9854094386,
-0.6433323622,
-0.557842195,
0.0159361251,
0.0856805518,
-0.1586865187,
0.6226688027,
-0.0390154608,
-0.1251098663,
0.3832463026,
0.3677985966,
0.2263413668,
-0.3444907069,
-0.163030684,
-0.008587244,
0.1173397526,
0.3629468977,
1.0052706003,
-0.5685502887,
-0.1692335308,
-0.1265434176,
0.3793735206,
0.3900180757,
1.0877782106,
-0.7322669625,
0.3834096193,
0.1290402412,
0.3491074145,
0.3741098344,
-0.2102131695,
0.557513237,
-0.6319120526,
0.4311291277,
0.176352784,
0.4402607083,
0.3425169587,
-0.0263532996,
0.2134485841,
0.4660528302,
-0.5324966908,
-1.1225680113,
0.3061484396,
-0.9646644592,
0.1058927625,
1.2920808792,
-0.080568023,
-0.2329558134,
-0.4929507673,
0.1722817868,
0.4834854007,
-0.6463981271,
0.7940431833,
0.1145533249,
-0.3676698506,
-0.1752182692,
-0.0814374238,
0.7705863714,
0.1489717513,
-0.2624633312,
0.0043406524,
0.2442606241,
0.4371728003,
0.6161355376,
0.7848356366,
0.0131104263,
0.1680355966,
-0.3310607076,
0.0294983536,
-0.1328044385,
-0.5956841707,
-0.5442711115,
0.2756358385,
0.0522077344,
-0.4202395678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07929v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07929v2 | Large Language Models Are Semi-Parametric Reinforcement Learning Agents | 2023-06-09T08:08:18 | 2023-10-30T01:52:11 | Danyang Zhang, Lu Chen, Situo Zhang, Hongshen Xu, Zihan Zhao, Kai Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Inspired by the insights in cognitive science with respect to human memory
and reasoning mechanism, a novel evolvable LLM-based (Large Language Model)
agent framework is proposed as REMEMBERER. By equipping the LLM with a
long-term experience memory, REMEMBERER is capable of exploiting the
experiences from the past episodes even for different task goals, which excels
an LLM-based agent with fixed exemplars or equipped with a transient working
memory. We further introduce Reinforcement Learning with Experience Memory
(RLEM) to update the memory. Thus, the whole system can learn from the
experiences of both success and failure, and evolve its capability without
fine-tuning the parameters of the LLM. In this way, the proposed REMEMBERER
constitutes a semi-parametric RL agent. Extensive experiments are conducted on
two RL task sets to evaluate the proposed framework. The average results with
different initialization and training sets exceed the prior SOTA by 4% and 2%
for the success rate on two task sets and demonstrate the superiority and
robustness of REMEMBERER. | [
-0.0455947891,
-0.8686759472,
0.7884261012,
0.0549995527,
-0.0499985106,
0.2534778118,
-0.4710332751,
-0.2151012719,
0.2135139853,
0.5706068277,
-0.1808428615,
-0.3428211808,
-0.199948594,
-0.1054394767,
0.0167174991,
0.9174690247,
-0.2573729753,
-0.3450373411,
0.1381535232,
-0.2733415961,
-0.4796562493,
-0.538716197,
-1.338952899,
-0.6073344946,
0.5900836587,
0.0572775528,
0.4712847471,
0.2361594588,
-0.1168512776,
0.3476779759,
-0.0262092073,
0.0315227583,
-0.7361462116,
0.1201210842,
-0.6468060613,
-0.5254704952,
-0.3927252889,
-0.47044155,
0.8622965217,
0.1179130226,
-0.6914374828,
-0.1378606558,
-0.0350062773,
0.5392175913,
-0.3122066557,
0.3942651153,
-0.6323906779,
0.1308780015,
0.4778424203,
-0.3827129006,
-0.6441113949,
0.0540944897,
0.0101517001,
-0.4119237661,
0.0254796725,
0.3919972479,
0.5803996921,
0.0686490908,
-0.1326099634,
-0.282397449,
-1.0034650564,
1.0090453625,
-0.7895649076,
0.3457818031,
0.1374475807,
0.7455997467,
-0.4817159474,
-0.7729610801,
-0.4815730453,
-0.4980584383,
0.2012860775,
-0.068560265,
0.0872017667,
0.0858728588,
0.2614333928,
0.2248608172,
-0.4270740747,
0.069457002,
-0.3339360952,
-0.2733215392,
0.2729249001,
0.3761743605,
0.444794029,
0.2220644206,
-0.5463365912,
-0.1089158654,
-0.4948334098,
0.1382864565,
-0.0809911266,
0.2269510329,
-0.0862357095,
0.2323305756,
-0.1103673428,
0.4715176523,
-0.1175875887,
-0.407961756,
0.1212608069,
0.3451271355,
-0.3339267075,
0.0988977551,
0.6965167522,
0.0051094671,
0.4341270924,
-0.441976577,
-0.6842944026,
-0.1440746486,
0.4553303123,
-0.5492480993,
-0.2113548368,
-0.0670437142,
-0.4390482605,
0.0894754454,
-0.178221643,
-0.7758782506,
-0.1654003561,
-0.0086481748,
0.5286311507,
-0.8095110059,
-0.219089672,
0.1627179831,
0.0330259465,
0.3057537079,
0.2977900505,
-0.6740342975,
0.3437415361,
0.596218884,
0.6412949562,
-0.1129519492,
-0.9161983728,
-0.5351161361,
0.3778879344,
-0.2119110227,
0.6601604223,
-0.6291539073,
-0.3745157719,
0.1248005554,
0.0481481664,
-0.1948298663,
-0.5786727071,
0.0785908476,
-0.8698726892,
0.0487201326,
-0.0687595904,
-0.5555980206,
-0.3198312819,
0.5819953084,
-0.7723374367,
0.9196756482,
0.1813579947,
-0.2013198882,
0.3952433169,
-0.2041181475,
-0.3117307723,
0.0797345042,
-0.2624335587,
-0.4068728983,
0.0867854878,
-0.0907455608,
0.4152634442,
-0.292103678,
0.5283839703,
-0.3539161086,
-0.4943620861,
0.3426356018,
-0.3433104753,
0.2433419824,
-0.0249071885,
-0.0844656229,
0.1969825774,
-0.8337970972,
-0.0432011187,
0.2697222233,
-0.8784387708,
-0.3043535948,
0.0158534013,
-0.0092136348,
0.6655851603,
0.377649039,
-0.5151203275,
-0.1272415221,
-0.2839772403,
0.6007164717,
0.822573185,
0.4642678797,
0.3373295069,
-0.5208772421,
0.5740554333,
0.1695032418,
-0.1056211889,
-0.2018052787,
-0.0064959051,
-0.8055173755,
-0.3392929733,
-0.0638398156,
0.4376404881,
-0.8034827709,
0.3087253869,
-0.2237645835,
-0.2117806375,
0.0217914712,
0.2124699056,
0.6010932922,
0.0935234129,
0.2331941873,
0.1312792897,
-0.536747098,
-0.9637055993,
-0.204758808,
-0.2537781298,
0.2182971537,
0.3659591973,
0.7248035669,
0.0757901594,
0.76082021,
-0.2259711772,
-0.2927908897,
-0.7107567787,
-0.0297909863,
0.2131419331,
0.2306472659,
0.3006525636,
-0.5477899313,
-0.2575969696,
-0.0652588606,
-0.9796286821,
0.6213601232,
-0.3757927716,
0.0596321598,
0.4149380326,
0.5888591409,
-0.6804968715,
0.2366236299,
0.1385906339,
-0.3995752931,
0.4199636281,
-0.939481914,
-0.0568940416,
-0.998703599,
-0.0646671057,
0.0026834258,
-0.4062683582,
-0.4577504694,
-0.0507673509,
0.2204161435,
-0.2283908427,
-0.6175589561,
0.9184476733,
-0.5088840127,
-0.1615896523,
-0.4799761176,
-0.0720635056,
-0.3920856714,
0.9530799985,
0.1224742755,
0.7303974628,
0.5988350511,
-0.9051645398,
0.2717104554,
-0.1226534545,
-0.3168367445,
0.5043205619,
-0.587795198,
0.153797552,
-0.1743635982,
0.3689028919,
-0.5972343087,
0.1540290564,
0.0624083094,
-0.0588607416,
0.3890094757,
0.2535201609,
-0.5889764428,
-0.4239479899,
-0.1524653435,
0.0706225559,
0.7780712843,
-0.5201613903,
1.0325298309,
0.1665207148,
-0.1068255529,
-0.3613029122,
-0.2202453911,
0.1256918162,
-0.3500638306,
0.0366026796,
0.0865316018,
0.0380045697,
-0.0584541745,
0.1181644127,
-0.0684450492,
0.143488273,
-0.2612311542,
0.1221185178,
0.3634458482,
-0.1513121128,
0.1633805186,
-0.3039781749,
-0.300070107,
0.1822351515,
-0.3794645071,
0.6436469555,
-0.1390019506,
-0.1729449928,
-0.1819541603,
0.1419372559,
0.782998085,
-0.1645403802,
1.02252388,
0.0880229697,
-0.4397896528,
-0.7008296847,
-0.6296390891,
-0.1513881534,
-0.4411863983,
0.8500307798,
-0.5568258166,
-0.9770670533,
0.7455004454,
-0.141820699,
0.0885765105,
0.0281397011,
0.6358366013,
0.0718520284,
0.5896770358,
0.5992686152,
-0.4209657609,
0.5221669078,
-0.1402404308,
0.2012377828,
-0.767355144,
-0.4112660587,
0.1202281043,
-0.4283669889,
-0.1396065056,
-0.3250935078,
0.1386993229,
-0.0903072953,
-0.5979930162,
0.1186251268,
-0.0934865847,
0.3139194548,
0.4215105474,
0.3126251101,
-0.0077889361,
-0.194067955,
-0.2315173447,
0.1638471931,
-0.5993854403,
-0.5148804784,
0.9208714366,
0.4229309261,
1.0274541378,
-0.0455244817,
0.7194699645,
0.377526015,
-0.2517147958,
-0.4825838506,
0.9504047036,
0.3290713131,
-0.4982861578,
-0.5444369912,
-0.24642241,
-0.7738508582,
0.2325167656,
-0.042831216,
-1.0672498941,
-0.0742598549,
0.2552174926,
-0.2657100558,
0.6438421607,
-0.219942078,
0.618165493,
-0.3126342893,
-0.5122838616,
-0.5294850469,
-0.3585292995,
0.1545495093,
-0.1721429825,
-0.0182570424,
0.0921465382,
-0.2412572801,
0.8915313482,
-0.2127838433,
0.8749659061,
-0.4921138585,
0.0960601196,
0.3766671121,
0.1387019008,
1.1034692526,
-0.0361771807,
-0.1345662475,
-0.4539476633,
-0.2215358168,
-0.5690296888,
-1.0380840302,
0.8167889714,
-0.6760717034,
-0.6117417216,
-0.382453382,
-0.7022385597,
-0.3140831292,
0.182137087,
-0.3058986962,
0.2634991705,
-0.5010992289,
0.1246253476,
0.9724733233,
-0.5487954021,
0.5625574589,
0.8162056208,
-0.5023980141,
-0.4318452775,
1.0445319414,
-0.0412001014,
0.2666736841,
0.6190367937,
0.0524856821,
-0.1575882435,
-0.549282074,
-0.2938628793,
0.5619946718,
-0.6272718906,
0.070250921,
-0.7449538708,
-0.3871010244,
0.2028182447,
-0.2343179882,
-0.4544760287,
0.077479884,
0.1128747761,
-0.2709576786,
0.3689111471,
0.5802195072,
0.2032695115,
0.0997856334,
-0.3680920899,
0.4020504057,
0.5085099339,
0.1519983411,
0.4264245927,
-0.6218654513,
-0.415676564,
-0.2767148018,
0.1264560521,
-0.5585756302,
0.5703723431,
0.1774004996,
0.8825984597,
0.2536255121,
-0.1117907241,
0.3830803633,
-0.486106962,
0.5468043685,
0.1614107788,
-0.410733521,
0.3865639269,
-0.3389112353,
0.3052660823,
0.428491503,
-0.1000088602,
-0.3649322689,
-0.4778625965,
-0.6416248083,
-0.7574442029,
0.7955141664,
-0.2112885565,
0.1541149467,
0.0080510015,
0.476844281,
0.0822485611,
0.0956463888,
-0.5545491576,
-0.2148959786,
0.082446754,
-0.1396122873,
-0.4389849305,
-0.6146789193,
0.2181804329,
0.0399546698,
0.8564136624,
0.1075195596,
0.4081873298,
-0.1888212413,
-0.3141474128,
0.0315322466,
0.6633857489,
0.503205359,
0.9179041982,
-0.3468218148,
0.2286541462,
0.7566322088,
-0.2889576554,
0.4291055799,
-0.1662664711,
-0.1949253827,
-0.4007452428,
0.3263921142,
1.0825948715,
0.7932977676,
-1.0799297094,
0.1818312705,
0.0738026947,
-0.146842435,
-0.6953565478,
0.2954997718,
0.3811834455,
0.578101635,
0.4058211744,
-0.3238252699,
-0.189804092,
-0.7720454931,
0.324804157,
0.2508359849,
-0.6499137282,
-0.3452242911,
0.4574529231,
-0.1956271827,
-0.610684216,
0.510342896,
-0.2966364622,
-0.6130800247,
0.6056219935,
1.2569026947,
0.6036940217,
-0.2390043885,
0.0952789038,
0.2989425659,
0.0969927385,
-0.3779830039,
0.4234763682,
-0.0684484988,
-0.6216850877,
-0.0198391303,
-0.6676767468,
-0.198691994,
0.3296372592,
-0.6443546414,
0.0581222065,
-0.8909620643,
0.1782479584,
-0.3804171383,
0.042100817,
-0.6267560124,
0.402059257,
0.0096038263,
0.9598241448,
-0.7505143285,
1.1848194599,
1.026986599,
-0.3952597678,
-0.9838508964,
-0.1646485031,
-0.1734496653,
-1.1424853802,
0.5936768055,
-0.1224505454,
-0.2340231985,
0.1192955524,
0.0869483352,
-0.6442966461,
1.4116953611,
0.1685208082,
-0.7464967966,
-0.3298215866,
-0.2406163067,
0.6679021716,
-0.476005286,
0.2200407982,
0.5614496469,
0.2521826327,
0.2045432627,
-0.6715320349,
0.3090057969,
-0.1506817937,
0.321200192,
0.4625239372,
-0.9110179543,
0.7421889305,
-0.3252150416,
-0.0680250823,
-0.0247306749,
1.0398160219,
0.7775535583,
0.2897945642,
0.3952304423,
0.6913949251,
0.569221139,
0.6148844361,
0.9334629178,
-0.2141516358,
0.3610946834,
1.2667138577,
-0.3776831031,
0.9515874982,
0.4197919965,
-0.273078233,
0.5673680902,
0.1511703283,
0.144913733,
0.7118201852,
0.2544724047,
-0.4106607735,
-0.4430285692,
0.2962678373,
-0.0951199532,
0.1520614475,
0.3204348385,
-0.6939410567,
-0.3878678381,
0.4178269207,
0.092513144,
0.2065902799,
-0.4052422941,
0.73161906,
0.364008069,
-0.6345437169,
0.347155571,
-0.0314232744,
0.4974240363,
-0.7048519254,
-0.0918428376,
-0.1215915978,
0.5900149941,
0.2441700846,
-0.6213188767,
-0.0734104216,
-0.2686476409,
-0.2194322199,
-0.0097248852,
0.9177613258,
-0.3578783274,
-0.4228256345,
0.6016104817,
0.4938317537,
0.1719714552,
0.1159221455,
-0.7891269326,
0.027146427,
-0.0293018781,
-0.5366669297,
0.6703587174,
0.6063852906,
-0.1084631234,
1.1115188599,
0.1976635456,
0.2924963832,
-0.1126688868,
-0.0621240288,
0.7840202451,
-1.2374023199,
-0.7497431636,
-1.0193837881,
0.0871729478,
0.0554536395,
-0.0405845381,
0.6061964631,
0.722237289,
0.4214136899,
-0.2335765213,
0.9015182853,
0.0189373344,
0.486518234,
-0.6327179074,
0.7335096002,
-0.3297397196,
0.1356370002,
0.1081126183,
-1.006528616,
0.1471506953,
0.4176236093,
-0.484490931,
0.4202783704,
0.9725679755,
0.8954077959,
-0.147966519,
-0.1536956728,
0.8214085102,
0.2811264992,
0.3281890154,
1.2923452854,
1.007401824,
-0.075829573,
0.4827502966,
-0.0043718442,
-0.2186538875,
-0.2105970979,
-0.4653855264,
-1.386731863,
-0.55662781,
-0.0872781351,
-0.299777776,
0.529294312,
1.0317548513,
0.3688119948,
-0.717875421,
-0.1170995012,
-0.0979152173,
-0.0467159376,
-0.2947613597,
-0.1366438419,
0.3930998743,
-0.3167681694,
-0.5073771477,
0.4587157965,
0.5151665807,
-0.1445916295,
-0.492760241,
-0.6225583553,
-0.1289921701,
0.1239209995,
0.3988727033,
0.816452086,
-0.8055068254,
-0.3616480231,
-0.3425824046,
-0.1325370222,
-0.008585644,
0.8012576699,
-1.1683652401,
0.3684058785,
0.0508969463,
0.5408400893,
0.6756247878,
-0.3227017522,
0.6015049815,
-0.0154147334,
0.2595399022,
0.0020159718,
0.5785765648,
0.0582172163,
-0.3661090434,
-0.0114074675,
-0.1378903687,
-0.6500502825,
-0.5884019136,
0.0623720102,
-0.9538912177,
-0.2567285895,
1.1235179901,
-0.3561291397,
-0.6050918102,
-0.1429289579,
-0.2294754088,
0.2168496251,
-0.6819630861,
0.7387834191,
0.496252954,
-0.0272013061,
-0.5770542622,
-0.6011583805,
0.177584365,
0.1936918497,
-0.699510932,
-0.0384179726,
0.4046650529,
0.559083879,
-0.1612015814,
0.867700994,
0.0441391766,
0.3913729489,
0.246768102,
0.2520689666,
-0.4617315531,
-0.5631529093,
-0.1790792644,
0.3538760841,
0.4843051732,
-0.1374834329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05715v1 | Exploring the Responses of Large Language Models to Beginner Programmers' Help Requests | 2023-06-09T07:19:43 | 2023-06-09T07:19:43 | Arto Hellas, Juho Leinonen, Sami Sarsa, Charles Koutcheme, Lilja Kujanpää, Juha Sorva | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SE | Background and Context: Over the past year, large language models (LLMs) have
taken the world by storm. In computing education, like in other walks of life,
many opportunities and threats have emerged as a consequence.
Objectives: In this article, we explore such opportunities and threats in a
specific area: responding to student programmers' help requests. More
specifically, we assess how good LLMs are at identifying issues in problematic
code that students request help on.
Method: We collected a sample of help requests and code from an online
programming course. We then prompted two different LLMs (OpenAI Codex and
GPT-3.5) to identify and explain the issues in the students' code and assessed
the LLM-generated answers both quantitatively and qualitatively.
Findings: GPT-3.5 outperforms Codex in most respects. Both LLMs frequently
find at least one actual issue in each student program (GPT-3.5 in 90% of the
cases). Neither LLM excels at finding all the issues (GPT-3.5 finding them 57%
of the time). False positives are common (40% chance for GPT-3.5). The advice
that the LLMs provide on the issues is often sensible. The LLMs perform better
on issues involving program logic rather than on output formatting. Model
solutions are frequently provided even when the LLM is prompted not to. LLM
responses to prompts in a non-English language are only slightly worse than
responses to English prompts.
Implications: Our results continue to highlight the utility of LLMs in
programming education. At the same time, the results highlight the
unreliability of LLMs: LLMs make some of the same mistakes that students do,
perhaps especially when formatting output as required by automated assessment
systems. Our study informs teachers interested in using LLMs as well as future
efforts to customize LLMs for the needs of programming education. | [
-0.262614578,
-0.7097055912,
0.772698164,
0.1904602051,
0.0245926715,
0.2795811594,
-0.2738139629,
-0.3991761506,
-0.0966400504,
0.4363924563,
-0.3862093091,
-0.2467885613,
-0.6324680448,
0.1714348495,
-0.5774440765,
1.0449542999,
-0.2064271122,
0.2105943263,
-0.4793106616,
0.4922602475,
-0.7277393937,
-0.5734581947,
-0.9552795887,
-0.0358108245,
0.6284561753,
0.5253062844,
0.5184462667,
0.2089428902,
0.722966969,
0.3123564124,
0.0431792066,
-0.3498678803,
-0.3922385275,
0.2123985887,
0.0804314017,
-0.5516412854,
-0.2804444134,
-0.1781339198,
0.3770400286,
0.9382303357,
-0.0908701271,
0.3065007031,
0.1667854935,
0.6500297189,
-0.470466882,
0.1322247237,
-0.5139188766,
-0.0242973566,
-0.3417418897,
-0.1251254827,
-0.5800576806,
-0.3297928572,
-0.0979583636,
-0.3803658485,
0.0044251629,
-0.116432488,
0.3621373177,
0.2262703776,
-0.1606878787,
-0.7255420089,
-0.6429566741,
0.7778837085,
-0.704582274,
0.1061448529,
0.3846476078,
0.4267421961,
-0.5303718448,
-0.3923856318,
-0.4174953699,
-0.3378972113,
0.0867623687,
0.0691639632,
-0.4472810924,
-0.0675604269,
0.4873926342,
0.2288771868,
-0.6950150728,
0.3522700369,
-0.5533782244,
-0.3430480957,
0.5422847271,
0.2401807606,
0.5649116039,
-0.1254112124,
-0.0515056588,
0.0147297671,
-0.7697708011,
0.3228637278,
0.8022891283,
0.3898909092,
-0.1557210535,
0.6249339581,
0.3229566216,
0.9585416317,
-0.2296838462,
-0.007262981,
-0.3002532125,
-0.0708972886,
-0.1642884016,
-0.2086499333,
0.4765413404,
0.2146034837,
0.7048155665,
-0.0744033456,
-0.274320513,
-0.1600719541,
0.3935195208,
-0.6401837468,
-0.2254895717,
0.269900769,
-0.326280266,
0.005037704,
0.1463865191,
-0.6327872872,
-0.668200314,
-0.3137102425,
0.1023866236,
-0.0813077316,
-0.2243211567,
-0.0072732638,
0.1147338375,
0.1785848886,
0.4134761691,
-0.7378054261,
0.1595691592,
0.6240196228,
0.6714892387,
-0.2447368056,
0.1233747825,
-0.4765547514,
-0.211802274,
-0.2774811387,
0.6325652599,
-0.5655729771,
-0.5540390611,
-0.0098323869,
-0.034763027,
-0.0142331515,
-0.5735984445,
0.3253706396,
-0.4239803553,
0.0326687135,
-0.0399216041,
-0.3599421978,
0.2910814285,
0.3336350322,
-0.4086609483,
0.8620006442,
0.2400149703,
-0.6917296052,
-0.2476047873,
-0.56585145,
-0.1478270888,
0.2110126317,
-0.2356012911,
-0.0519476719,
0.1201365367,
-0.0712914541,
0.4766397476,
-0.3031485081,
0.0183978751,
-0.1925055534,
-0.4069543481,
0.5955658555,
-0.429738909,
0.7446783185,
0.2955393493,
-0.154108122,
0.0966754109,
-0.660256505,
0.3449462354,
0.4351814687,
-0.5774670839,
-0.4242158234,
-0.0508101694,
0.0580705851,
0.1603839546,
0.2423677742,
-0.3734968603,
0.5161796212,
-0.3670318127,
0.2918614149,
1.0147173405,
-0.1144015938,
0.018086005,
-0.2212933004,
0.9955494404,
-0.2609708905,
-0.0148364417,
-0.236268416,
-0.5881198049,
-0.6782189608,
0.0002748989,
-0.0680103526,
0.4682016671,
-0.6544444561,
-0.1473190784,
0.1897972226,
-0.375950247,
-0.3637063503,
0.4758109748,
0.4814289212,
0.2880277634,
0.1957326382,
-0.0097038345,
-0.5787106752,
-0.8349714875,
-0.4121406376,
-0.3784698546,
-0.2980296314,
0.4577699006,
0.3113667071,
-0.1777688861,
0.8996905684,
-0.6144082546,
0.1228731647,
-0.3131350577,
-0.1410544068,
0.3070187867,
0.3280488551,
0.5597900748,
-0.6120998263,
-0.6784604788,
-0.2376171649,
-0.3497940302,
-0.3551873863,
-0.1064480618,
0.1861763895,
0.2878058553,
0.4461203218,
-0.2300608903,
0.1487745941,
0.56431669,
-0.2559549212,
0.5888843536,
-0.2622403204,
-0.1209890395,
-1.093021512,
0.0056459336,
0.0247745737,
-0.075270392,
-0.5296269059,
0.24421224,
0.0130958464,
-0.1766948849,
-0.426794976,
0.3618213534,
-0.4567228556,
-0.0091875074,
-0.361124903,
0.2500542998,
-0.4449990392,
0.0993473306,
-0.3148407936,
0.9421744943,
0.4839213192,
-0.4184757471,
0.4829168618,
-0.1330714971,
-0.3169784844,
0.446472466,
-0.8974973559,
0.4483943284,
-0.0457425602,
0.0670597628,
-1.2865862846,
-0.3136953413,
0.1747006029,
-0.5872862935,
0.3020995259,
-0.247101143,
-0.4001171887,
-0.8029975295,
-0.2161713392,
0.3458963335,
0.3839092851,
-0.4586030543,
0.1837581247,
0.0830427185,
-0.5229734182,
-0.4857774675,
-0.565105617,
0.1438169181,
0.0139973471,
-0.4294419587,
-0.1521279514,
-0.5083408952,
-0.4658794999,
-0.2832873762,
-0.1721473038,
-0.1091016531,
0.5800446868,
0.5025953054,
0.469799906,
-0.1474681944,
-0.0255626682,
-0.3156118691,
-0.0430247001,
0.3963350952,
-0.1016342044,
0.6479592323,
-0.2679348588,
-0.6871293187,
0.0932698622,
0.3678883612,
0.4956427813,
0.0194395296,
0.4508675039,
0.3350020647,
-0.3567410409,
-0.1122439504,
-0.4922424257,
-0.1151382327,
-0.4628019333,
0.4443140924,
-0.0304732844,
-0.7748970389,
0.3253524005,
0.1950674057,
0.0607464053,
0.0505770259,
0.6700150371,
-0.2209787965,
1.0756771564,
0.7926482558,
-0.1988334507,
0.3892394006,
-0.2156293243,
0.5210092068,
-0.5948588252,
-0.4578534663,
-0.8725819588,
-0.0423092283,
-0.4146026373,
-0.2657509744,
0.1818839163,
0.0664688349,
-0.1143735275,
0.3189701736,
-0.4032745659,
0.6861253977,
0.277970165,
-0.3761207461,
0.1356526017,
-0.0243843421,
-0.0038590727,
-0.1243450791,
-0.5302183628,
-0.7267457247,
1.165156126,
0.4449755251,
0.9992120266,
0.4738613963,
0.5746673942,
0.2105792165,
0.4776658118,
-0.9391410351,
0.5619476438,
0.0327107646,
-0.44096452,
-0.1538421661,
-0.4986256659,
-0.9716470838,
-0.050135728,
-0.0137076192,
-0.8465723395,
-0.3012899756,
0.0313736498,
-0.2751584351,
0.3207283318,
-0.7801738977,
0.7015393376,
-0.4366618693,
-0.3210463226,
0.172562331,
-0.4279258549,
0.1694353968,
-0.2591565549,
0.5386679173,
0.1028240025,
0.0714112148,
0.779583931,
-0.3785580993,
1.0937678814,
-0.1165329814,
-0.5138128996,
0.3681208789,
0.1886305809,
0.3543035388,
-0.0025312831,
-0.0088858297,
-0.2357501388,
0.1941032261,
-0.4562534988,
-0.5545623899,
0.8843275905,
-0.8929598331,
-0.9404699802,
-0.4717710316,
-0.752540648,
-0.1813127398,
0.2809956372,
-0.0519273356,
0.3812260926,
0.1376170963,
0.2064205557,
0.6120978594,
-0.3106189072,
0.6652668118,
0.8077579737,
-0.3240012228,
0.1446842104,
1.021450758,
0.0285876319,
0.4172898531,
-0.1347682774,
0.1364593655,
-0.0334491581,
-0.6231151819,
-0.5516111255,
0.0508311391,
-0.7529307008,
-0.3118378222,
-0.4328686893,
-0.107269302,
-0.6421900988,
-0.2732526362,
-0.1106088981,
-0.1990750134,
-0.1979196221,
0.043117702,
0.065899983,
0.973349154,
0.3464947045,
0.3026458323,
-0.7682288885,
-0.086999625,
0.2505789995,
0.2105480283,
0.0920762494,
-0.5700805783,
-0.1132012904,
-0.0407779664,
-0.5140935779,
-0.9826248884,
0.2157448977,
-0.1591387391,
0.6639488339,
0.4615062773,
0.1535317302,
0.4276776612,
-0.2076850235,
0.9038168788,
0.1011219174,
-0.734388411,
0.4761071801,
-0.3092699349,
0.3327141702,
0.2362932265,
0.7706195712,
-0.7592520118,
-0.6672179699,
-0.2777914405,
-0.8212852478,
0.7112447619,
-0.0503199957,
0.4897456765,
-0.1248135418,
0.4754730463,
-0.0669400841,
0.212873593,
-0.8833990693,
-0.3392392993,
0.052847825,
-0.2449142486,
-0.0085854605,
-0.3323667347,
0.0406157002,
0.0458104908,
0.4852020442,
-0.2180220783,
0.0980191603,
-0.130194664,
-0.0040086755,
-0.2985961437,
0.6684350371,
0.6719682217,
0.8461495638,
-0.000307145,
0.1167666614,
-0.011285333,
-0.5383858681,
0.076575771,
-0.1180326045,
-0.0318838842,
-0.3178569078,
0.5493873358,
0.3351938725,
0.2277091146,
-1.0000247955,
0.673360765,
-0.1424114406,
0.0975356549,
-0.5077723861,
0.1956519485,
0.08782655,
0.0017983847,
0.4844945669,
-0.2172791809,
0.0026382681,
-0.6542358398,
-0.3951900005,
0.5536860824,
-0.252481848,
-0.1925588101,
0.2480028272,
0.1357257813,
-0.6667348742,
0.6799770594,
0.0743053481,
-0.6085917354,
1.0379054546,
1.0934958458,
0.5205149651,
-0.1229111701,
0.2603191137,
0.2300495058,
0.3269225061,
0.2144463956,
0.2087331265,
0.0201575235,
-0.4145523608,
-0.332701236,
-0.4616071284,
-0.7824916244,
0.1579330713,
-0.7181305289,
0.1825757027,
-0.7316710353,
0.0039051017,
-0.2357822806,
0.0073923813,
-0.544716239,
-0.1189633682,
0.3602370024,
0.9105657935,
-0.8589512706,
0.6619121432,
1.1807159185,
-0.5197651386,
-1.1263326406,
-0.0597450472,
0.1564877331,
-0.7335986495,
0.7569763064,
0.0324832015,
-0.0150357699,
-0.1190822273,
-0.703551054,
-0.7414895892,
0.7003436089,
0.4965815544,
-0.726105392,
-0.1351768076,
0.2743234634,
0.560716331,
-0.1640595347,
0.5666362643,
0.4178292155,
0.4914927483,
0.0392811857,
-0.8830787539,
0.0629324242,
-0.2880497873,
0.1429006755,
0.298150003,
-0.4813792408,
0.9056313038,
-0.5281539559,
-0.1357816458,
0.2512503564,
0.258059144,
0.1643244475,
0.3928717673,
0.3664689362,
-0.0223242249,
0.7872533202,
-0.1023141965,
1.1275873184,
-0.2831424475,
0.209899351,
0.8320007324,
0.0317713879,
0.8614590168,
0.840986073,
-0.5149019957,
0.3751764596,
0.7016291022,
-0.0443254784,
-0.0153369755,
0.7480573654,
-0.1186037287,
-0.3812607527,
0.0733493865,
-0.5695748329,
0.0164506994,
0.2877727151,
-0.0122834388,
-0.292820394,
0.2898139358,
0.1264012307,
0.2697040737,
-0.4814434052,
0.4837292731,
0.2131677121,
-0.5121999383,
0.393351227,
0.209125936,
0.6591118574,
-0.6362856627,
-0.100998193,
-0.4244255424,
0.2295243293,
-0.540895164,
-0.7148634791,
0.2161774635,
0.4524045885,
-0.3168860674,
-0.1255436093,
0.5680491328,
-0.2814725339,
-0.5634493232,
0.3173384964,
0.3551634252,
0.5054860115,
0.140618965,
-0.579400003,
0.3081183732,
-0.0073502352,
-0.0490354002,
0.6161957979,
0.0337650478,
-0.2031080425,
0.8050714135,
0.6726149321,
0.1692163199,
0.1900119185,
-0.0320467427,
0.8782324791,
-0.3096594214,
-0.1089456901,
-0.7532584071,
0.2581767142,
0.2390897125,
-0.2066079825,
1.0145413876,
0.3979269266,
1.0522489548,
-0.1724689156,
0.7277792692,
-0.0711550787,
0.3583527803,
-0.482878238,
0.5439811945,
-0.4778280556,
0.6569700241,
-0.3894362152,
-0.9973583221,
-0.2249827385,
0.5430272818,
-0.6493322849,
0.2042384446,
0.5231199265,
0.6680552959,
0.1310205758,
-0.0557870828,
0.3342719972,
0.2321997136,
0.6320392489,
0.7633664608,
1.0150682926,
0.0374889225,
0.7796027064,
-0.0840560794,
-0.1873292476,
-0.3276718855,
-0.7207866907,
-0.9007353187,
-0.2703082263,
-0.311435163,
-0.4269177616,
0.0349639989,
1.1233786345,
0.15622437,
-0.9188845158,
-0.3115493059,
0.0988172665,
0.2138298452,
0.2106939107,
-0.2088475823,
0.1028524265,
-0.4338383973,
-0.7323365808,
0.4291864038,
-0.1786801368,
0.2850855291,
-0.4665753543,
-0.0813136175,
0.1893083006,
0.0421113558,
0.474894762,
0.4880223572,
-0.6166394949,
-0.4696080685,
0.1332320571,
-0.3459427953,
-0.2826755643,
1.1067774296,
-0.3783082366,
0.3361322284,
0.157031104,
0.8896978498,
0.0700029284,
-0.2407149523,
0.3398502469,
-0.530553937,
-0.0237118527,
0.1350475699,
0.3802863359,
0.3931754231,
-0.4051608741,
0.3024583459,
0.0677452236,
-0.5677374601,
-0.9643362761,
0.0418743528,
-0.7909421921,
-0.2817938328,
1.1989572048,
-0.4181197584,
-0.0907419398,
-0.1308604032,
-0.5523068905,
-0.1640025675,
-0.0526647232,
0.6576808095,
0.9601870775,
-0.0948041305,
-0.0743638575,
-0.758638978,
0.1055564359,
0.5437694788,
-0.7642517686,
0.0735946074,
0.5592759848,
0.4851698875,
0.1834995002,
0.5211911201,
-0.0608188249,
0.3520179689,
-0.255644381,
-0.0329563618,
-0.422617197,
-0.4609062076,
-0.5099157691,
0.2292235941,
0.5525628328,
0.159940362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.06141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.06141v1 | Zero-Shot Dialogue Relation Extraction by Relating Explainable Triggers and Relation Names | 2023-06-09T07:10:01 | 2023-06-09T07:10:01 | Ze-Song Xu, Yun-Nung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Developing dialogue relation extraction (DRE) systems often requires a large
amount of labeled data, which can be costly and time-consuming to annotate. In
order to improve scalability and support diverse, unseen relation extraction,
this paper proposes a method for leveraging the ability to capture triggers and
relate them to previously unseen relation names. Specifically, we introduce a
model that enables zero-shot dialogue relation extraction by utilizing
trigger-capturing capabilities. Our experiments on a benchmark DialogRE dataset
demonstrate that the proposed model achieves significant improvements for both
seen and unseen relations. Notably, this is the first attempt at zero-shot
dialogue relation extraction using trigger-capturing capabilities, and our
results suggest that this approach is effective for inferring previously unseen
relation types. Overall, our findings highlight the potential for this method
to enhance the scalability and practicality of DRE systems. | [
-0.420892477,
-0.4703817666,
0.7505952716,
-0.3119241297,
-0.2437865883,
-0.2590975165,
0.1811354607,
-0.5411561728,
0.2062767446,
0.6658291817,
-0.9845938683,
-0.3132044077,
-0.5385727286,
0.0042146519,
-0.4303377867,
1.0928578377,
0.1812282205,
-0.4755240381,
0.2256228179,
-0.5270555615,
-0.5636917353,
-0.4730603397,
-0.3497611284,
-0.2003669143,
0.6405373812,
0.4382358193,
0.6445050836,
0.5123751163,
0.1984497458,
0.1603207588,
-0.0845703334,
-0.0989114568,
-0.6196594834,
0.5045879483,
0.1259626746,
-0.275123626,
-0.4772192538,
0.0932999179,
0.4672769308,
0.7207733393,
0.0308565255,
0.3689033687,
-0.2530787587,
0.2665366828,
-0.8075883985,
0.4991795719,
-0.7163521051,
0.2142898142,
0.0257090032,
-0.3414283693,
-0.4398759007,
-0.0865957886,
0.2385488749,
-0.6126698852,
0.0227559488,
-0.5381516218,
0.8875657916,
0.0603486486,
-0.3837481737,
0.0080682915,
-1.0991976261,
0.3564320207,
-0.9087162018,
0.279199779,
-0.0512401387,
0.4729420841,
-0.0376595035,
-0.5557293296,
-0.7316068411,
-0.2294872701,
-0.3159508109,
0.1266199946,
-0.2530305386,
-0.0140079614,
0.7244839072,
0.4702054262,
-0.1122266352,
-0.0422117598,
-0.0559649058,
-0.1024331227,
0.3866307437,
0.2455688864,
0.0889552012,
-0.1166793853,
-0.4043180645,
0.268892765,
-0.726624012,
0.037441913,
-0.1147046238,
0.5713863373,
-0.0748504028,
0.6408104897,
-0.2946706116,
0.7751120925,
0.2964406908,
-0.1772414297,
-0.0163036268,
-0.3678842783,
-0.4952637553,
-0.095342882,
0.8015655875,
0.274391979,
0.3762804866,
-0.1220706478,
0.0250728875,
-0.1710284203,
-0.100795351,
-1.2385131121,
-0.0274602547,
0.2621842921,
-0.324139595,
-0.4970506728,
-0.1540993303,
-0.7942349911,
-0.2871688604,
-0.0086007491,
0.3197039664,
-0.3379403949,
-0.6947943568,
-0.3344809115,
-0.3826361001,
0.3840783834,
0.4738274515,
-0.8122925162,
0.1754651964,
0.3998509645,
0.9132410288,
0.2996680737,
0.2833722234,
-0.8142656088,
0.2924100161,
-0.2104385048,
0.6360444427,
-0.6641583443,
-0.4306825697,
0.180130139,
-0.2148778588,
-0.0021028593,
-0.5570235252,
0.1704863161,
-0.643807292,
0.429783076,
-0.0491416454,
-0.7442399263,
-0.1126595512,
0.1634846181,
-0.6805242896,
0.821089983,
0.282900393,
-0.5981975198,
0.4239181876,
-0.6590554714,
0.0194795802,
0.3581131101,
-0.5222652555,
-0.3333057463,
0.0908991769,
0.3874239624,
0.4628000557,
-0.1344844699,
0.24223575,
-0.4960595667,
0.0195255484,
0.1464225948,
-0.4089213908,
0.8543057442,
0.1098544598,
-0.1596523672,
-0.0654949769,
-0.9256925583,
-0.1862687469,
0.0703867525,
0.2690300941,
-0.312297821,
-0.3898096383,
-0.5365800261,
0.4587447941,
-0.0552242957,
-0.6231098175,
0.2271513492,
-0.3051189482,
-0.0274577215,
0.2496284992,
0.633857429,
0.620950222,
0.1347402334,
0.7820991874,
0.3729434311,
0.0039798585,
-0.8946577311,
-0.2779302001,
-0.7520625591,
-0.3893115222,
0.2870965898,
0.5731104612,
-0.9034822583,
0.2685965598,
-0.1721072048,
-0.3165018857,
-0.169451192,
0.0682956055,
0.3408195078,
0.9339284897,
0.0310325623,
-0.4335264564,
-0.3253997266,
-0.7032259107,
-0.311558336,
-0.2972338498,
-0.4237774611,
0.6564350128,
-0.0588419028,
0.1267163455,
1.3593943119,
-0.8338128328,
-0.2771166861,
-0.3862242103,
0.4619021118,
0.5102492571,
0.042109549,
0.6810913682,
-0.4600273371,
-0.4257665575,
-0.0711345002,
-1.1327818632,
-0.2008231729,
-0.326198101,
-0.018403396,
-0.063768059,
0.4764871597,
-0.7814340591,
0.7979344726,
0.0809361935,
-0.0856607631,
0.5939688683,
0.3342058957,
0.071016483,
-1.0221805573,
-0.0987148583,
0.05791099,
-0.3608378768,
-1.0586620569,
-0.2519743443,
0.050149262,
-0.526445508,
-0.4823581874,
0.5054469705,
-0.6946338415,
-0.1326598376,
0.0733341426,
0.3422121108,
-0.3215919137,
0.6623210311,
0.2692847252,
0.6173592806,
0.580104351,
-0.582745254,
0.3438995481,
0.4649085701,
-0.010109609,
0.6903085709,
-0.4331617951,
0.1192814559,
-0.1178293005,
0.0517119579,
-0.8295446038,
-0.2196666747,
0.3370118737,
-0.5886879563,
0.4965416193,
-0.7463175058,
-0.1358219534,
-0.1454581022,
-0.1837512404,
0.3071992397,
0.333514601,
-0.5490024686,
0.52281183,
0.3601875007,
-0.3893447518,
-0.5585327744,
-0.1435290724,
0.1857116371,
-0.506233871,
-0.1470905989,
-0.1303260028,
0.2204484344,
-0.2402246445,
-0.0768938884,
-0.426825285,
-0.5861664414,
-0.2257282883,
0.5232864022,
0.4710992873,
-0.3618049324,
0.4884810448,
-0.2969460487,
-0.2952040136,
-0.0540296026,
0.1195781901,
0.192863971,
0.4923595786,
0.0845497996,
-0.5956946611,
0.6547520161,
0.8527475595,
-0.1718292236,
0.8406081796,
0.2848597765,
-0.29021281,
-0.1471648663,
-0.4367953241,
-0.4769760668,
-0.4252626896,
0.1876903325,
-0.4958277047,
-0.993227303,
0.7593892813,
-0.4703013301,
0.1449994594,
0.3809833825,
0.2558962107,
0.1025143936,
0.5652054548,
0.9581260085,
-0.2674067914,
0.6608376503,
-0.0373268276,
0.6925727129,
-0.6728540659,
-0.1372557282,
-0.3403279185,
0.1538808197,
-0.2994875014,
-0.1212050095,
0.4304478168,
0.3000979125,
-0.2051690519,
0.9832874537,
-0.2191085964,
0.2344020605,
0.3962306678,
-0.3274831176,
0.5983639359,
-0.1315322369,
0.087690182,
-0.1313367784,
-0.6874774098,
-0.4531654119,
0.7110437751,
0.2096563876,
0.5901213884,
0.0448591858,
0.7791714668,
0.0226501916,
0.3725961447,
-0.9643522501,
0.5780336857,
0.4043558538,
-0.803858161,
-0.4605614543,
-0.5360281467,
-0.8542565703,
0.2196646333,
-0.2895148993,
-1.262188673,
0.5557869077,
0.0177693535,
-0.7067627311,
0.2724664211,
-0.6804336905,
0.6849868298,
0.1322566569,
-0.0598973595,
0.1135400161,
-0.6943347454,
0.6650860906,
-0.0655912831,
-0.100922972,
-0.3496045172,
0.272230953,
0.6018869281,
-0.6891854405,
0.8783515692,
-0.2482494712,
-0.3155632615,
0.2721689045,
0.3960859179,
0.3108919263,
0.1892898679,
-0.0473150387,
0.2064936757,
-0.0433252119,
0.011725327,
-1.0288467407,
0.4946602881,
-0.177865237,
-0.3235168755,
-0.3817217052,
-0.6489494443,
-0.3684455454,
0.3523080349,
0.0965044871,
0.7697475553,
-0.3466450572,
-0.2731724977,
0.2984483838,
-0.1268039495,
0.7819849253,
1.0906925201,
-0.2292016149,
-0.203922838,
0.3914173841,
0.1787625104,
0.480697602,
0.3131392896,
-0.3616991043,
-0.1361586154,
-0.030309258,
-0.4257952571,
0.1391608417,
-0.1763472259,
-0.6181372404,
-0.7091732025,
-0.4828636944,
-0.3120319545,
0.0175873153,
-0.317497164,
-0.6762654185,
-0.4266678393,
-0.2577670515,
0.6685357094,
0.5641750097,
-0.1993809193,
0.4717832506,
-1.0378174782,
0.7789069414,
0.5145384669,
0.3278532326,
-0.0098042972,
-0.3855457902,
0.0979781002,
0.0285034385,
-0.3012591004,
-1.2537661791,
0.6013287306,
0.2751642764,
0.3157634735,
0.7760426998,
0.4293606579,
0.8310099244,
-0.4790426493,
0.6814200282,
0.4967894554,
-0.7284808159,
0.8061507344,
-0.4611470997,
0.2180166692,
0.5576120615,
0.3793550432,
-0.4030341804,
-0.3428915143,
-0.8700454235,
-0.643879354,
0.8176257014,
0.5269114375,
0.1770997494,
0.1154976711,
0.5445756912,
0.1717246473,
0.41414994,
-0.5790449381,
-0.4733554721,
0.2813257277,
0.3502812386,
-0.0072639068,
-0.5385046005,
-0.174349457,
-0.0469939671,
0.2979727983,
0.07325124,
0.338742584,
0.2089227885,
-0.0382516608,
-0.2122891694,
0.5051698685,
0.1616593003,
0.5240690112,
-0.6124305725,
-0.1602918208,
0.0037643765,
-0.0399007462,
0.0329450481,
0.1288467795,
-0.3528622687,
0.4038468599,
0.6035009027,
0.8560848832,
0.2938926518,
-0.3362368643,
0.6567732096,
-0.1480962187,
-0.0499489531,
-0.2584146261,
0.1023740619,
-0.1021491736,
0.35719347,
0.4154285491,
-0.1786279678,
0.1881202757,
-0.9012087584,
0.545984149,
0.5277933478,
-0.8094571233,
-0.2230930179,
0.4329390526,
0.3732788861,
-0.5513314605,
0.6334217787,
-0.1234048232,
-0.259441644,
0.3289639056,
0.4398009181,
0.9025077224,
-0.1296099871,
0.5340990424,
0.5845293403,
-0.0194807108,
0.5372770429,
-0.2452085763,
-0.7093163729,
-0.8099243641,
-0.481583029,
-0.2616683543,
-0.6546604037,
0.3560188711,
-1.0897808075,
0.3691758811,
-0.1205028892,
-0.1049186438,
0.255437851,
-0.1655102372,
-0.5271431804,
-0.0752658397,
0.015087775,
0.9268432856,
-0.9515151381,
0.76328969,
-0.0844461322,
-0.618894875,
-1.0212258101,
-0.096431464,
0.1195588782,
-0.8067132235,
0.6377007961,
0.16035299,
-0.0941247493,
-0.0533879139,
-0.3706574142,
-0.4895885289,
0.9241008759,
0.493920058,
-0.6786193252,
0.0848296583,
-0.0943869054,
0.5209044814,
-0.7145610452,
0.6546978951,
0.7805332541,
0.0954747349,
0.56870085,
-0.923275888,
0.0117137646,
-0.1927873343,
-0.3556918502,
0.476991713,
-0.1070927829,
0.2167119831,
-0.3509917259,
-0.700052917,
0.1102316082,
0.3802364469,
-0.0756334886,
0.4861245453,
0.3730269372,
0.5202416182,
0.3232938051,
0.1593046933,
0.7526621222,
0.0458071232,
0.4199717343,
1.7238209248,
-0.7189027667,
0.807133317,
0.3317762017,
-0.1350873709,
0.6305588484,
0.1993371397,
0.1382665038,
0.5621071458,
-0.3676889837,
-0.754701674,
-0.3238795102,
-0.3528443873,
-0.2686747015,
0.5615000129,
0.2953522503,
-0.5647226572,
-0.8251934052,
-0.3793132603,
0.10995958,
-0.253349781,
-0.0538434349,
1.4081220627,
0.1739052683,
-0.5175319314,
0.5143703222,
-0.9210098982,
0.1073504835,
-0.6115976572,
-0.3749186993,
-0.2581830919,
-0.0384003371,
-0.0420945622,
-0.6309897304,
0.2613032162,
0.173325792,
-0.2037863433,
-0.0935358405,
0.8997306228,
-0.6354810596,
-0.395568043,
0.4511834979,
0.8425270915,
0.2085393071,
-0.1896230429,
-0.1944941431,
-0.2686498761,
0.1036253646,
-0.0256052017,
0.2778475583,
0.6423621178,
0.2428290397,
0.5354613662,
0.5918923616,
0.1652057469,
-0.254588604,
0.0504580699,
0.9646936655,
-0.8828992248,
0.0225047935,
-0.7225876451,
0.6435730457,
-0.6127046347,
-0.1264427453,
0.656716764,
0.2518017292,
0.2199728191,
-0.0057465299,
0.6282324791,
-0.0708238557,
0.8690087795,
0.1995844841,
0.5367280841,
-0.0558562241,
0.2007832676,
-0.387847513,
-0.9573386312,
-0.6074398756,
0.1848447174,
-0.0796868205,
-0.1822185665,
0.5198433399,
0.8848893046,
-0.1767596751,
-0.2046099454,
0.6719086766,
0.3589962721,
0.3239299953,
0.5712183118,
0.6239970922,
-0.4104526937,
0.6455247402,
-0.1622247398,
-0.5283057094,
0.0049490398,
-1.1632467508,
-1.0023913383,
-0.3864116371,
-0.6227992773,
0.083392553,
-0.1337816268,
0.2351479977,
0.8686728477,
-0.8463236094,
0.0871947855,
-0.1080638543,
0.0901212543,
-0.0648888275,
-0.260210216,
-0.0990923122,
-0.244553566,
-0.3712469339,
0.4494134784,
0.6932713985,
0.0513318218,
0.2546527088,
0.2641088068,
-0.0229099207,
0.2406592518,
0.7099951506,
0.9075587988,
-0.5087433457,
-0.3786044717,
-0.2670871019,
0.466375649,
0.0544816926,
0.9916633964,
-1.1086974144,
0.6136309505,
0.1938019246,
0.1297183186,
0.7728754282,
0.1863052696,
0.9666302204,
-0.8807881474,
0.2914643288,
0.1940331459,
0.1502352059,
0.132816568,
-0.4512574971,
0.5782898664,
-0.08928065,
-0.3369946182,
-0.8229957819,
0.6834793687,
-1.2061340809,
0.1210579574,
0.8914157748,
-0.4995182753,
0.5167087913,
-0.2781707942,
-0.1872475147,
0.4498358965,
-0.4752058387,
0.6490603685,
0.3750894964,
-0.4511528909,
-0.6736502647,
-0.4797322154,
0.4816820323,
0.0345582776,
-0.7338898778,
0.4520885348,
0.5908794403,
0.1377424598,
0.2690910995,
0.7805125117,
-0.2792540491,
0.0973543152,
-0.0383872651,
-0.0489577837,
-0.0263324454,
-0.1018105224,
-0.4321970642,
0.3172956109,
-0.117084831,
-0.3742932677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05709v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05709v1 | Learning Emotional Representations from Imbalanced Speech Data for Speech Emotion Recognition and Emotional Text-to-Speech | 2023-06-09T07:04:56 | 2023-06-09T07:04:56 | Shijun Wang, Jón Guðnason, Damian Borth | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Effective speech emotional representations play a key role in Speech Emotion
Recognition (SER) and Emotional Text-To-Speech (TTS) tasks. However, emotional
speech samples are more difficult and expensive to acquire compared with
Neutral style speech, which causes one issue that most related works
unfortunately neglect: imbalanced datasets. Models might overfit to the
majority Neutral class and fail to produce robust and effective emotional
representations. In this paper, we propose an Emotion Extractor to address this
issue. We use augmentation approaches to train the model and enable it to
extract effective and generalizable emotional representations from imbalanced
datasets. Our empirical results show that (1) for the SER task, the proposed
Emotion Extractor surpasses the state-of-the-art baseline on three imbalanced
datasets; (2) the produced representations from our Emotion Extractor benefit
the TTS model, and enable it to synthesize more expressive speech. | [
-0.3835360706,
-0.2710256577,
-0.0407548063,
0.0730165988,
-0.3644201458,
0.2890792787,
-0.1111042276,
-0.608905375,
0.5203325748,
0.184099108,
-0.4885997474,
-0.0334033966,
-0.6644571424,
0.1847317815,
-0.3250118494,
1.0239605904,
0.1337200552,
0.2572004497,
0.0861193165,
-0.4071472585,
-0.5093675852,
-0.7267451882,
-0.430604279,
-0.656229794,
0.3265847564,
0.5066151619,
0.2722139955,
0.300588727,
-0.0916282609,
0.3310832679,
-0.0317045785,
0.2061342597,
-0.5164105296,
0.5335472226,
0.0219675023,
-0.5877333283,
-0.2027117163,
0.1894589216,
0.5325914025,
0.1580060571,
-0.2769507468,
-0.0465199389,
-0.1182862371,
0.6454888582,
-0.8715722561,
0.1653193831,
-0.6948886514,
0.3351112902,
-0.1541546583,
-0.3089238107,
-0.3243849874,
-0.2189552486,
0.3091365993,
-0.179266274,
-0.0648024604,
-0.1788020879,
0.4587754905,
0.3111372292,
-0.5784944296,
-0.2304078937,
-0.7377030849,
0.8173499107,
-0.5862978697,
0.4494222403,
0.0772002488,
0.3725330234,
0.358851403,
-0.3743548393,
-0.5475257039,
-0.0754247531,
0.2979034483,
0.4626566172,
-0.4282877743,
-0.0772235915,
0.3812534511,
0.5766560435,
-0.1938563287,
0.1706921607,
-0.1188072637,
0.0071305484,
0.5119387507,
0.0553268008,
0.4579008222,
-0.1598823369,
0.0233775359,
-0.3091095984,
-0.1565601975,
-0.0037981207,
0.3898198605,
0.4671150744,
-0.2970882356,
0.6466299295,
0.0485029779,
0.4019941986,
0.2410528809,
0.1204245165,
0.7393288016,
0.4515200257,
-0.1558356136,
0.3944369555,
0.394651711,
0.1366988122,
0.4184280336,
-0.2383313477,
-0.3554793894,
0.2014281899,
0.4628033936,
-0.7550899982,
0.0444221012,
0.4195608199,
-0.2271297872,
-0.2298904359,
0.0334541835,
-1.2570383549,
-0.5446707606,
-0.514160037,
0.3487686515,
-0.3501645327,
-0.4636090994,
-0.282345891,
-0.3105612397,
0.065425925,
0.0267474037,
-1.1142929792,
0.0849424228,
0.418614924,
0.7203649879,
-0.113041997,
0.14601098,
-0.8075316548,
-0.0936081707,
-0.0790022388,
0.2874754071,
-0.6741352677,
-0.3631153107,
0.116496779,
0.1809883714,
-0.053466972,
-0.6489508748,
0.7772432566,
-0.1405774355,
0.3202165365,
-0.1357929558,
-0.8238967061,
-0.0490247011,
-0.113908954,
-0.8036924005,
0.8572292924,
0.3616633415,
-0.6571796536,
0.1274994463,
-0.4498069584,
-0.4035170674,
-0.1153417528,
-0.07120087,
-0.621485889,
0.627720952,
0.4986099899,
0.3852541149,
-0.2456074506,
-0.095578745,
-0.4405825436,
-0.2161051631,
0.3826909959,
-0.5462371707,
0.5075373054,
0.3764470816,
-0.298034668,
-0.1398147345,
-0.8538496494,
-0.0078779766,
0.2141586393,
-0.2005773634,
-0.4440494478,
0.0498591736,
0.2963349819,
0.1098049879,
0.1046625227,
-0.7389950156,
-0.1702175438,
-0.6234175563,
0.342009604,
0.7017285228,
-0.2074176967,
0.5138424635,
-0.1857875884,
0.7211292386,
0.1547018588,
-0.4279251397,
-0.3367501795,
0.0240984205,
-0.7634800076,
-0.3226857781,
0.1362190843,
0.7095305324,
-0.5328045487,
0.5385180116,
-0.1091047302,
-0.6768601537,
-1.1025012732,
-0.2881582081,
0.3104463816,
0.6772700548,
0.5753855705,
-0.0211225189,
-0.697334826,
-0.4381350875,
-0.3598907888,
0.16057989,
-0.0078372564,
0.1908723265,
0.0707668364,
-0.3007686436,
0.9108926654,
-0.0548693277,
-0.0183845367,
-0.106395416,
0.573343575,
-0.1099344715,
0.6391064525,
0.6330689192,
-0.8060377836,
-0.3238674402,
0.0983485729,
-0.5613577962,
-0.3563116789,
0.0602963716,
0.1788125038,
0.2142878324,
0.2896529436,
-0.3330822885,
0.1002288386,
0.4736875892,
-0.1283790767,
0.3257425725,
0.091598317,
0.289750427,
-1.0522750616,
-0.1292413026,
0.1231768802,
-0.3649613857,
-0.7458205819,
-0.4115900993,
0.0232637543,
-0.4969497025,
-0.3581590354,
0.5140634179,
-0.5190381408,
-0.1411783248,
-0.5106980801,
0.0023937714,
-0.1103009507,
0.346270293,
-0.0519681945,
0.5567713976,
0.538895905,
-0.1665066481,
0.5028225183,
0.2189578414,
0.1045784131,
0.9653278589,
-0.6000628471,
0.2118887752,
-0.5661671162,
-0.0152319297,
-0.7743085623,
-0.3860094547,
-0.026995182,
-0.4898882508,
0.7094657421,
-0.3005014658,
0.076943852,
-0.3775040507,
-0.0771653354,
0.1970844418,
0.7835556269,
-0.7587540746,
1.0814141035,
0.7378692031,
-0.4868695736,
-0.6685481668,
-0.8427992463,
-0.1912017018,
-0.4264262915,
-0.2802648842,
0.2039292455,
0.2601665258,
-0.0125785172,
-0.0047938521,
-0.2926456034,
0.0114543103,
0.0109672677,
0.3957102895,
-0.0220914651,
0.0068759187,
0.3845129907,
0.1132836938,
-0.2301967293,
0.1339781731,
-0.0829806328,
0.5918011069,
-0.2040049881,
-0.39457798,
-0.4646830559,
0.5788762569,
0.8191850781,
-0.3638191819,
0.4322984517,
0.9042410851,
-0.6460232735,
-0.2351547778,
-0.5830746889,
-0.2493855059,
-0.4546984434,
0.6886146665,
-0.0482774675,
-0.8341752887,
0.4618971944,
-0.0673857331,
0.1156122759,
0.3446806073,
0.4211084247,
-0.1305704713,
1.4435217381,
0.492462337,
-0.5293871164,
0.9157229066,
0.0271564554,
-0.0547700748,
-0.7466695309,
-0.1152454913,
-0.5802711248,
-0.4207616448,
-0.5064807534,
-0.0192358512,
0.3517657518,
-0.3553440869,
-0.1533019841,
-0.2137984484,
-0.5700432062,
0.2392660826,
0.5607705712,
0.1858260334,
-0.3547186553,
0.4180684686,
0.4205453694,
-0.4156059325,
-0.2643945813,
-0.2805994749,
0.7192311883,
0.3429206014,
0.6375498176,
-0.1267107427,
0.8114459515,
0.3141615689,
0.3207731247,
-0.8842117786,
0.1086749956,
-0.5980709791,
-0.2422331423,
-0.0838948637,
-0.6773378849,
-0.6035224795,
0.3219507933,
-0.4499853849,
-0.7770764232,
0.4530609548,
0.2733528316,
0.0702566803,
0.1062646359,
-0.9316469431,
0.6715984344,
-0.2697679996,
-0.207219243,
-0.1650763154,
-0.6200205684,
0.1492984444,
-0.0260530729,
0.0041646804,
-0.1131939739,
0.2458054125,
0.7976008654,
-0.4484547079,
0.7338169217,
-0.5841005445,
0.0371918529,
0.2554529905,
-0.214119032,
0.6745991707,
-0.4235089719,
-0.6565790176,
-0.1489872485,
-0.3390981853,
-0.3152836561,
-0.8116585612,
0.3465578556,
-0.8098100424,
-0.1789530367,
-0.4108259082,
-0.4079194367,
-0.5370084643,
-0.1480119824,
0.2879363,
0.5373370647,
-0.146463275,
0.2708874941,
0.3387534022,
-0.1481736451,
0.3490183651,
0.3158241808,
0.2313808352,
-0.7750036716,
1.1718398333,
0.2116918713,
0.2250394076,
0.123875469,
0.1617589444,
-0.5045011044,
-0.0926391855,
-0.1930321604,
-0.1306957752,
-0.7275621891,
-0.1879834086,
-0.7231574655,
-0.2088005096,
-0.3227040172,
-0.1400197595,
-0.4650556743,
-0.3979385495,
-0.7573087215,
-0.4505468309,
0.5682649016,
0.249307394,
-0.3217265904,
0.5512482524,
-0.8497350812,
0.3853513896,
0.5756434798,
-0.0982189998,
0.114855051,
-0.566319108,
-0.2323597968,
0.2586331069,
-0.2628270984,
-1.0421392918,
0.9552161098,
0.4402395487,
0.3363975585,
0.4843654931,
0.1367972642,
0.8221538663,
-0.3598093987,
0.600299716,
0.4039960802,
-1.3251103163,
0.5231633782,
-0.0218294524,
0.1607522517,
0.373229146,
0.3077563047,
-0.4752277136,
-0.3324881196,
-0.6095798612,
-1.1164679527,
0.8824822903,
0.1672449708,
0.4036931992,
0.1357765645,
0.3617843986,
0.0300170742,
0.2430780083,
-0.8963696361,
-0.2244657725,
-0.5560147166,
-0.7621219754,
-0.1290141046,
-0.4621227086,
0.1761798561,
0.0730634034,
0.6433542967,
-0.0049519059,
0.3606977463,
0.120978184,
-0.1441788673,
-0.3271948993,
0.5317577124,
-0.0234312024,
-0.2833358645,
-0.3269867599,
0.2974725068,
0.179858163,
-0.4375259876,
0.2786105871,
0.5209559202,
0.1638453305,
0.0594807602,
0.1576247513,
1.1730341911,
-0.0433467105,
-0.8733552694,
0.4911937416,
0.146147728,
0.4106550813,
-0.0723726079,
-0.0747290328,
-0.2164776623,
0.4035401642,
0.4672983885,
-0.0009856682,
0.2517696619,
-0.4171426892,
0.2884495854,
0.4415761232,
-0.8101355433,
-0.2371704131,
0.4670152068,
0.4321677983,
-0.1427330375,
0.5656301975,
-0.2251066118,
-0.7444304824,
0.5991984606,
0.7698050737,
1.0540895462,
-0.614233017,
0.0541130453,
0.155695945,
0.1433252245,
0.0402486101,
0.7027163506,
-0.0075902045,
-0.4402822852,
-0.2826143503,
-0.3817638457,
-0.7026420236,
-0.1075341627,
-0.7961876988,
0.3452590108,
0.0853566527,
-0.2327220291,
-0.265732199,
-0.1939571202,
-0.4055332839,
0.415617913,
0.5096997619,
0.3182706535,
-0.9100746512,
0.3109794855,
0.555963099,
-0.2630811632,
-0.8459047675,
-0.3103598356,
0.0118345059,
-0.6075142622,
0.3001795709,
0.4830891788,
-0.1162219197,
0.1630007625,
-0.4898713827,
-0.413169533,
0.6972057223,
0.8905339837,
-0.7251831889,
0.3011781871,
0.1397531033,
0.6021881104,
-0.4583387673,
0.58725214,
0.2459089756,
0.09607324,
0.0189380012,
-0.5226002336,
-0.1943309605,
-0.6218422055,
-0.3511923552,
0.1405854225,
-0.4385579526,
1.0012668371,
0.0903247073,
-0.3063880205,
-0.1688979715,
0.7322735786,
0.2981344163,
0.4572544098,
0.7148136497,
0.6493156552,
1.1363707781,
-0.1669586748,
0.7448874712,
-0.0415152721,
0.1284113377,
1.119733572,
-0.4150672257,
0.7241356969,
0.2331192493,
0.1957687289,
0.2744776309,
0.4702250063,
-0.0686040521,
0.5711313486,
0.1586295664,
-0.413389802,
-0.1814941913,
-0.2920890152,
-0.5147963762,
0.4771987796,
0.4854888916,
-0.3393563628,
-0.1762340367,
0.4158032537,
-0.194827795,
-0.1945655495,
-0.3292699754,
0.8358206749,
0.1393082738,
-0.1872080564,
0.487635076,
-0.3655641079,
0.6597755551,
-0.39292413,
-0.1377672404,
0.032614816,
-0.0136661483,
-0.3330260217,
-0.4987210631,
0.1750580668,
0.2888175845,
-0.1798015535,
-0.1934228539,
0.7876416445,
-0.8991479278,
-0.3351302743,
0.2556251884,
0.409068346,
-0.1156726331,
-0.3042171299,
-0.4998431206,
0.0100522619,
0.0355218649,
-0.1057804003,
-0.0599257238,
0.803935349,
0.3003001511,
0.5265345573,
0.3789482713,
0.216077894,
0.0668225586,
0.3276241124,
0.7919344902,
-0.5801026225,
-0.711119771,
-0.7964457273,
0.8527088165,
-0.2487595826,
-0.1242889836,
0.3247176707,
0.2670718729,
0.1932795346,
-0.1526712328,
1.0211611986,
0.0294363685,
0.7882056236,
-0.4000603557,
0.3906913102,
-0.8202168941,
-0.0440985188,
-0.6018483043,
-0.6223159432,
0.0643524602,
0.7011243105,
0.0067177145,
-0.0390907302,
-0.013647316,
0.3980694115,
-0.0410578661,
0.577511847,
-0.0447530597,
0.2458753884,
0.4498340487,
0.5195137858,
1.1270298958,
-0.259024024,
0.2654778957,
-0.2575252354,
-0.2420244366,
-0.2901073694,
-0.8982233405,
-0.597917974,
-0.5271219015,
-0.2829721868,
-0.2779108882,
0.1258653104,
1.273566246,
0.7010949254,
-0.7990608215,
-0.0463867337,
-0.0713684037,
0.0184074622,
0.0209049843,
-0.2151892632,
-0.0666898489,
-0.4577953815,
-1.0113625526,
0.3747084737,
0.078918159,
0.5118194818,
0.1369466335,
-0.0323034935,
0.4179629683,
-0.0695482865,
0.579297483,
0.464032352,
-0.2774473429,
-0.1467625797,
-0.167042017,
0.1553343087,
0.1321356893,
0.5110045075,
-0.6960073709,
0.7663350105,
0.3507686257,
0.9563698769,
0.4684547186,
0.0036593159,
0.7005285025,
-0.9796461463,
0.3247775733,
0.6027639508,
0.6222479343,
0.4910270572,
-0.2527335584,
0.3693271577,
0.1133715957,
-0.4635087848,
-0.9516173005,
0.1000860706,
-1.1901673079,
0.1834605485,
0.8254819512,
0.0043718312,
0.0109336888,
0.1596156806,
-0.416275382,
0.7116661668,
-0.857889533,
0.7536397576,
0.4981015623,
-0.0777147338,
-0.3231073916,
-0.0494030565,
0.308285147,
0.6310778856,
-0.9207171202,
0.3363029361,
0.6363722682,
-0.2361011952,
0.187012583,
0.1588891894,
-0.1662174314,
0.1256143898,
-0.2408017665,
0.176665023,
0.0741908476,
0.0524460599,
-0.7454013824,
0.2438779026,
-0.460528791,
-0.1996636093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05685v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05685v4 | Judging LLM-as-a-Judge with MT-Bench and Chatbot Arena | 2023-06-09T05:55:52 | 2023-12-24T02:01:34 | Lianmin Zheng, Wei-Lin Chiang, Ying Sheng, Siyuan Zhuang, Zhanghao Wu, Yonghao Zhuang, Zi Lin, Zhuohan Li, Dacheng Li, Eric P. Xing, Hao Zhang, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Ion Stoica | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evaluating large language model (LLM) based chat assistants is challenging
due to their broad capabilities and the inadequacy of existing benchmarks in
measuring human preferences. To address this, we explore using strong LLMs as
judges to evaluate these models on more open-ended questions. We examine the
usage and limitations of LLM-as-a-judge, including position, verbosity, and
self-enhancement biases, as well as limited reasoning ability, and propose
solutions to mitigate some of them. We then verify the agreement between LLM
judges and human preferences by introducing two benchmarks: MT-bench, a
multi-turn question set; and Chatbot Arena, a crowdsourced battle platform. Our
results reveal that strong LLM judges like GPT-4 can match both controlled and
crowdsourced human preferences well, achieving over 80% agreement, the same
level of agreement between humans. Hence, LLM-as-a-judge is a scalable and
explainable way to approximate human preferences, which are otherwise very
expensive to obtain. Additionally, we show our benchmark and traditional
benchmarks complement each other by evaluating several variants of LLaMA and
Vicuna. The MT-bench questions, 3K expert votes, and 30K conversations with
human preferences are publicly available at
https://github.com/lm-sys/FastChat/tree/main/fastchat/llm_judge. | [
-0.5288019776,
-0.6125632524,
0.7758828402,
0.2571772933,
-0.4217575192,
-0.0106234355,
-0.5553363562,
-0.5700878501,
0.2043882161,
0.7024364471,
-0.2786188126,
-0.3696507812,
-0.7683421373,
0.2675016224,
-0.2017496079,
0.655854404,
-0.1256792843,
0.2194854021,
-0.4177460074,
-0.473985225,
-0.5615130067,
-0.7368267179,
-0.7138214707,
-0.4946839809,
0.4696491361,
0.5564131141,
0.9171423316,
0.3971958756,
0.4868063629,
0.4032359719,
-0.1412960887,
0.310221374,
-0.3935806453,
0.1031273827,
-0.1754220873,
-0.8248103857,
-0.5625388026,
0.2063275874,
0.2503081262,
0.3119341731,
-0.2227561921,
0.0632642657,
-0.0764199272,
0.5878927708,
-0.3459678292,
0.0386389829,
-0.8843255043,
0.1271362007,
-0.2938701808,
-0.3026988804,
-0.5082583427,
-0.3129141927,
-0.1136654615,
-0.4610906839,
-0.1889469475,
0.2605904341,
0.8342912793,
0.4986668825,
-0.6763602495,
-0.1790041178,
-0.6101123691,
0.6135004163,
-0.7241511941,
0.3811606467,
0.8711707592,
0.6892364025,
-0.2915407121,
-0.5887175798,
-0.5902503729,
-0.591216445,
-0.0682312697,
0.1171830893,
-0.2734584808,
0.0724831447,
0.2833715677,
0.2400960773,
-0.397857517,
0.561706841,
-0.000230772,
0.0601658858,
0.5535257459,
0.1566984206,
0.0052929688,
-0.1785118431,
-0.3080942631,
-0.1288200766,
-0.6165953875,
-0.0476129018,
0.4563927352,
0.2230371386,
0.0702339932,
0.605224669,
-0.4791024923,
0.5610492229,
0.095145084,
0.052762229,
0.1651256979,
0.0742025375,
-0.226134792,
-0.420810163,
1.0507763624,
0.729863584,
0.2208474278,
-0.1582651585,
-0.1305142194,
-0.0439339578,
0.3353429437,
-0.6474020481,
0.2368679345,
0.3014335334,
-0.4729385078,
-0.2036267221,
-0.2260756642,
-0.6789603233,
-0.9009208083,
-0.4815679789,
0.4882358611,
0.0713156164,
-0.0783455595,
0.085866116,
0.0201706197,
0.112612471,
0.6611537933,
-0.7698071003,
0.4666217566,
0.6879048944,
0.6421909928,
-0.1603638828,
-0.2516898215,
-0.6929037571,
-0.3412722349,
-0.2292807996,
0.9516918659,
-0.4898519218,
-0.5230326653,
-0.1262052953,
-0.2197349519,
0.0927000344,
-0.7879543304,
0.8292863369,
-0.6281747818,
0.2107864171,
-0.177970618,
-0.489374429,
0.1230087802,
0.4592838585,
-0.4506388903,
0.7649240494,
-0.1612315774,
-0.3444000781,
0.4939061403,
-0.6176288128,
-0.293159008,
0.1589572281,
-0.2529678941,
-0.2751032412,
-0.0576522984,
0.5576612353,
0.3665181994,
-0.4247816801,
0.3927579522,
-0.7424451113,
-0.3761743903,
0.5133944154,
-0.4337924421,
0.3978922665,
0.2976780236,
-0.2940610051,
0.5289190412,
-0.5604317188,
-0.0275511537,
0.0690306798,
-0.46420151,
-0.0381573215,
0.3454554081,
-0.1651966274,
0.1218198463,
0.2133290321,
-0.3480098844,
0.155504033,
-0.202792719,
0.4896780252,
1.1066286564,
-0.1226938963,
0.2871035635,
-0.2446276844,
0.385746479,
-0.4388157725,
0.5032524467,
0.4024522603,
-0.4629102349,
-0.8459470868,
-0.256955415,
0.4308452606,
0.2805421352,
-0.5990983248,
0.5918645263,
-0.1568598747,
-0.5270427465,
-0.8169835806,
0.2411263287,
0.2611597776,
0.1646050215,
0.223320663,
-0.4729349017,
-0.4082552493,
-0.973911643,
-0.3583237529,
-0.2644186914,
-0.257889539,
0.6821628809,
0.2833034396,
-0.2636113167,
0.921429038,
-0.1732244343,
-0.1592813581,
-0.0502436496,
-0.1636701822,
0.3497248292,
0.0408703052,
0.4686017931,
-0.6319265962,
-0.5179222822,
0.0095315892,
-0.7042342424,
-0.2641639709,
0.1183313578,
-0.2742041349,
0.0508268885,
0.3066064119,
-0.7962238193,
0.4218045175,
0.5200579166,
-0.4537303448,
0.4593214393,
-0.1574395448,
0.4350497127,
-0.6844006777,
-0.0840114951,
-0.1349956244,
-0.5353545547,
-0.5291314721,
0.3182182014,
-0.0607884452,
0.0751584396,
-0.4602345824,
0.8996989727,
-0.1517249495,
-0.3204239309,
-0.6722673178,
0.3924844861,
-0.1010777801,
0.5859786272,
-0.027593391,
0.4859775007,
0.2240186632,
-0.4908642769,
0.5733823776,
0.3438170254,
-0.4083971381,
0.6727601886,
-0.6825187802,
0.4897578061,
0.3529755771,
0.5949921608,
-0.8915600181,
-0.0459410846,
0.2737201154,
-0.5043295026,
0.1223364398,
-0.3101921082,
-0.8237039447,
-0.5405141115,
-0.3124227822,
-0.0151373297,
0.2967698574,
-0.9113838673,
0.514330864,
0.387586087,
-0.0646772832,
-0.5294555426,
-0.2574583888,
0.4150452614,
-0.2819746733,
-0.5323078036,
-0.0122802313,
-0.375949055,
-0.5490143895,
-0.3331353962,
-0.1561859846,
0.14836061,
0.2781230211,
0.5785298347,
0.1483317167,
0.046056889,
-0.0230737366,
-0.2765124738,
-0.1559577286,
-0.0360612236,
0.1546119899,
0.6737410426,
-0.3332861066,
-0.6248754859,
-0.3996653557,
-0.0645682216,
0.7667818666,
-0.148522526,
0.4162537754,
0.2473658919,
-0.0561091453,
0.1588811129,
-0.9347570539,
-0.1321079731,
-0.4697699845,
0.1690354794,
-0.4357854724,
-1.0226054192,
0.4962498546,
0.001861605,
0.2499178052,
0.4149246514,
1.0062497854,
-0.0522943996,
0.9091139436,
-0.0400116295,
-0.3089109361,
0.5320944786,
0.2427805513,
-0.0995925218,
-0.7915887237,
0.0700811446,
-0.6577137709,
-0.5140789151,
-0.5055610538,
-0.4732060432,
0.2925603092,
-0.1276143193,
-0.2416401803,
0.169578895,
-0.1619838029,
0.4849763811,
0.6482992172,
0.3325879872,
0.3736459017,
-0.4859701097,
-0.1275365651,
0.2514335811,
-0.2063170671,
-0.7644266486,
1.2734013796,
0.546046555,
0.572722137,
0.1970595121,
0.5977976322,
0.3490023613,
0.5730707049,
-0.7854347825,
0.7386457324,
0.0170427747,
-0.7619569302,
-0.420443505,
-0.5474873781,
-0.8540210724,
0.7698310018,
-0.4733621478,
-0.8143856525,
-0.0148254996,
-0.0047573741,
-0.2250469625,
0.3886882663,
-0.7353183031,
0.9201460481,
-0.577428937,
-0.5356048346,
-0.3677098453,
-0.6516013145,
0.3694148362,
-0.0159583576,
0.3930335939,
-0.3623023927,
-0.0148751503,
0.5668230653,
-0.6091505885,
0.8311238885,
-0.2302466631,
0.0450529754,
0.1747883111,
0.0353682376,
0.5163682699,
0.2376383394,
-0.2858889699,
0.2090241015,
-0.2532775104,
-0.1847120523,
-0.5581928492,
0.7018636465,
-1.1802245378,
-0.9254233241,
-0.2287498713,
-0.2377307415,
-0.5891658664,
0.063798286,
-0.2761263549,
0.0656228215,
-0.2394245863,
0.3360328972,
0.0808007643,
-0.2320335805,
0.0825982988,
0.863041997,
-0.4981430173,
-0.4092849493,
0.4590340853,
-0.3292655945,
0.1663143486,
0.4290190339,
0.4463360608,
-0.3860779703,
-0.5511425734,
-0.5272212029,
0.1062984914,
-0.637932837,
-0.2092930377,
-0.4722328186,
0.0436030887,
-0.1147419363,
0.0791826695,
-0.3445192277,
-0.4021314979,
-0.2191838473,
-0.1047178879,
0.351722002,
0.5589123964,
0.1605775058,
0.3831663728,
-0.5096305609,
0.5193993449,
0.6435540318,
0.62897259,
-0.1324597746,
-0.7544239759,
0.1069391742,
-0.1926258504,
-0.3461163938,
-0.4837616384,
0.2187299579,
-0.2997260392,
0.6820241213,
0.5714396834,
-0.0177623127,
0.6953658462,
-0.5202477574,
0.6423684359,
0.1552737355,
-0.6849996448,
0.4534505904,
-0.2349810302,
0.0001482133,
0.7505790591,
-0.0100312764,
-0.4155436158,
-0.6383705735,
-0.453500092,
-0.521617949,
0.8362149596,
0.3057045341,
0.1197417006,
0.0039463188,
0.2076018155,
0.1974710971,
0.2439906895,
-0.7350131273,
-0.0369232669,
-0.1025739536,
0.3358968198,
-0.302836895,
-0.2168274969,
-0.1882463694,
-0.1774849743,
0.4576155543,
0.0292669702,
-0.054628361,
-0.1803914905,
-0.0015161411,
-0.1864755899,
0.7223325372,
0.5433931351,
0.5302429199,
-0.3836277425,
0.1183718964,
0.5106262565,
0.0934720337,
-0.0749553218,
0.1490818262,
0.2281817794,
-0.3207921088,
0.1721881032,
1.0425102711,
0.4175199568,
-0.8428352475,
0.5629411936,
-0.5650458932,
-0.4501529038,
0.1224478558,
0.1006082296,
0.3237692714,
0.4088672996,
0.1505535692,
0.1078451201,
-0.1600623429,
-0.5955289006,
-0.003106341,
0.4960334003,
-0.2267350256,
-0.012042325,
0.7078438401,
0.4650040865,
-0.4197273552,
0.401037395,
-0.0931716561,
-0.4532284439,
0.3614856899,
0.1339170486,
0.7258633971,
-0.1159069836,
-0.2221514881,
0.0217926223,
0.1766661555,
-0.1135080382,
-0.0328721106,
-0.3010749817,
-0.8492138982,
-0.1332580745,
-0.5951025486,
-1.1263927221,
0.0807906985,
-0.4066392481,
0.3860586882,
-0.4224422574,
-0.5125146508,
-0.0052440884,
0.2292734981,
-0.7476568818,
-0.1611192673,
0.0923401862,
0.7524327636,
-0.3904004693,
0.6788781285,
0.5051810145,
-0.0885761157,
-0.4696691334,
-0.2642211914,
0.1582904309,
-1.1325713396,
0.3855727613,
-0.0169084426,
0.1447045356,
-0.535456419,
-0.4460991323,
-0.4338868856,
0.9943461418,
0.2845569551,
-0.8320252895,
0.2353423983,
-0.0026741652,
0.7930583358,
-0.0959365144,
0.7413405776,
0.5124159455,
0.6797500253,
0.3233661056,
-1.3040322065,
-0.1821784377,
-0.3342888057,
-0.3472570479,
0.0081315106,
-0.944912672,
0.4688061476,
0.0029380452,
0.08769238,
0.1349843889,
0.4820257723,
0.3787513673,
0.3712267876,
0.8591058254,
0.5246124864,
0.6596134305,
0.0713064149,
1.1055341959,
-0.2607240379,
0.1247235015,
1.2130544186,
-0.6371799707,
1.1015201807,
0.4755936265,
-0.4935668409,
0.2960482836,
0.7087789774,
-0.0328831151,
0.1155721918,
0.3818977475,
-0.0313232727,
-0.4120564461,
-0.0518585071,
-0.1144219786,
0.5966125131,
0.1877977699,
-0.098874867,
-0.0768844038,
-0.1846731156,
-0.0511159487,
0.1519223005,
-0.270298928,
0.8314303756,
0.2445012778,
-0.8081972003,
0.2781642973,
0.2567486167,
0.6702679992,
-0.5772795081,
0.2980626822,
-0.2729122043,
0.253072381,
-0.0801085532,
-0.8430466056,
-0.1711059958,
0.372421205,
0.2163524628,
-0.3170795739,
0.658277154,
-0.0080142338,
-0.0447000749,
0.3816577196,
0.6512631774,
0.3543285728,
-0.2193701565,
-0.641706109,
0.0937040672,
-0.253688395,
-0.4742861092,
0.5449344516,
0.2308941931,
-0.212551862,
0.7648044825,
0.6578813791,
0.0025754441,
-0.2389802784,
0.586181581,
0.886318028,
-0.5315362215,
-0.4027237594,
-0.9400469065,
-0.0132038658,
-0.1129481494,
-0.2240866721,
0.6751509905,
0.5812197328,
0.4122563004,
0.1619585752,
0.4973504245,
0.179121688,
0.5264055729,
-0.3876485229,
0.7306315899,
-0.4701748192,
0.3113800585,
-0.0769920945,
-0.6279503703,
-0.1045821905,
0.3553074002,
-0.5199420452,
0.0931948498,
0.4137499034,
0.608081162,
0.0919395313,
0.1877400279,
0.5233101845,
0.1630998254,
0.5723515153,
0.6221696734,
1.1720004082,
0.0644788072,
0.7145480514,
0.1608589292,
-0.3546546102,
-0.4814563394,
-0.5397031307,
-1.3091504574,
-0.13045533,
0.0403519459,
-0.1494268179,
-0.1369566321,
1.1160675287,
0.7275440097,
-0.5019792318,
-0.3816773593,
0.497672081,
0.343270272,
0.000596262,
-0.1857773215,
0.142035991,
-0.2021890283,
-0.7564604282,
0.6082035303,
0.1411669999,
-0.1868994534,
-0.1573550701,
-0.3702589869,
0.0320516638,
-0.0008921288,
0.7424431443,
0.2035595626,
-0.9833658934,
-0.4622893929,
-0.1444010139,
-0.2459424287,
0.2822718918,
0.5631198287,
-0.6357939839,
0.5745629072,
0.1518155187,
0.489895165,
0.7885851264,
0.1331762224,
0.4724621773,
-0.5268610716,
-0.0781381801,
0.1416337639,
0.5580251217,
0.2001360357,
0.0126690241,
0.6551324129,
-0.0426744595,
-0.7603664994,
-0.7699264884,
0.0014798889,
-1.178091526,
-0.0658565462,
1.2153295279,
0.0490980186,
-0.0487271585,
0.0564568602,
-0.5036825538,
0.0267204791,
-0.5266634822,
0.8417976499,
0.804813087,
-0.2680231035,
-0.0791513696,
-0.7180796862,
0.1978954077,
0.239006415,
-0.9492333531,
0.2188000232,
0.2970775664,
0.1708389074,
-0.0564401783,
0.9556638002,
-0.1452969015,
0.2637693882,
-0.2752308249,
0.07928624,
-0.0912658051,
-0.002000021,
-0.2828196883,
-0.0116993459,
0.4978330433,
-0.1098175868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05672v1 | I run as fast as a rabbit, can you? A Multilingual Simile Dialogue Dataset | 2023-06-09T05:04:13 | 2023-06-09T05:04:13 | Longxuan Ma, Weinan Zhang, Shuhan Zhou, Churui Sun, Changxin Ke, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | A simile is a figure of speech that compares two different things (called the
tenor and the vehicle) via shared properties. The tenor and the vehicle are
usually connected with comparator words such as "like" or "as". The simile
phenomena are unique and complex in a real-life dialogue scene where the tenor
and the vehicle can be verbal phrases or sentences, mentioned by different
speakers, exist in different sentences, or occur in reversed order. However,
the current simile research usually focuses on similes in a triplet tuple
(tenor, property, vehicle) or a single sentence where the tenor and vehicle are
usually entities or noun phrases, which could not reflect complex simile
phenomena in real scenarios. In this paper, we propose a novel and high-quality
multilingual simile dialogue (MSD) dataset to facilitate the study of complex
simile phenomena. The MSD is the largest manually annotated simile data
($\sim$20K) and it contains both English and Chinese data. Meanwhile, the MSD
data can also be used on dialogue tasks to test the ability of dialogue systems
when using similes. We design 3 simile tasks (recognition, interpretation, and
generation) and 2 dialogue tasks (retrieval and generation) with MSD. For each
task, we provide experimental results from strong pre-trained or
state-of-the-art models. The experiments demonstrate the challenge of MSD and
we have released the data/code on GitHub. | [
-0.3107414842,
-0.9010530114,
0.1784129292,
0.4004075527,
-0.4105964303,
-0.0333760157,
-0.5310873985,
-0.4877903759,
0.3649163246,
0.5346683264,
-0.7392214537,
-0.4312852919,
-0.3146893084,
0.3215414286,
-0.1110296398,
1.1267415285,
0.3575628698,
0.3715260923,
0.1176232845,
-0.5383635759,
-0.1600499898,
-0.4860793352,
-0.609218061,
0.0596898831,
0.4707053602,
0.2508188188,
0.7883174419,
0.6914712191,
0.2864714861,
0.3611980081,
-0.0640893131,
0.2221872807,
-0.2186169028,
0.4279410243,
-0.1504463702,
-0.3781213462,
-0.0474347807,
0.1095751226,
0.5766710639,
0.6329966187,
-0.1148455516,
-0.0472975075,
0.1209340915,
0.3572984636,
-0.1311408877,
0.4639502764,
-0.5192047954,
-0.1027788967,
-0.2854571044,
-0.066122517,
0.1576516032,
-0.4610735178,
0.0743523687,
-0.8121321201,
0.3391931653,
0.1324484497,
0.9625409842,
0.0709974393,
-0.3274256885,
-0.3612162173,
-0.5124046803,
0.7620044947,
-0.6727440357,
0.3746922314,
-0.1503834128,
0.5566797853,
-0.0628593341,
-0.4921816289,
-0.8199983835,
-0.439011544,
0.0303382874,
-0.0854320526,
0.3596206903,
-0.1834460199,
0.5183388591,
0.1765072197,
-0.7403982282,
-0.159090668,
-0.0311757885,
-0.2930577099,
0.4099350572,
0.4187081456,
0.2608017623,
-0.2096853554,
-0.4667994678,
-0.2638936937,
-0.3613800704,
0.2919541299,
0.5724663138,
0.7582527995,
-0.1245938987,
0.4832925498,
-0.7073625326,
0.5834808946,
-0.1769716889,
-0.4179466069,
0.4734867513,
-0.5675235391,
0.1093894914,
0.1424130648,
0.9912703037,
0.6077991724,
0.528529644,
-0.0396039635,
-0.0680392608,
0.2088029981,
-0.326321125,
-0.7024128437,
-0.3033539355,
0.0232744459,
-0.2817810178,
-0.3127204776,
-0.1494410485,
-0.8103362322,
-0.3062528372,
-0.3843201399,
0.2484811395,
-0.8051722646,
-0.2791215181,
0.3091630638,
-0.1193768606,
0.1262034923,
0.294179529,
-0.7087346911,
0.2578544617,
0.7521890998,
0.8370380998,
0.1627433896,
-0.7267078161,
-0.7227476239,
0.1949988604,
-0.0134357363,
0.9366468191,
-0.7065112591,
-0.2209026963,
-0.108085908,
0.2267994732,
-0.3161284626,
-0.5604770184,
0.6740413904,
-0.1845308095,
0.0268038474,
-0.0227773692,
-0.3837111294,
-0.2478407621,
0.3777647316,
-0.7298790216,
0.8641284108,
-0.1759463698,
-1.003672719,
0.1599676013,
-0.4899958074,
-0.5447912812,
-0.1412666142,
-0.4080680311,
-0.1489351094,
-0.247250393,
0.1159278601,
0.3492666185,
-0.6322320104,
0.1506706327,
-0.5853734612,
-0.1555534154,
0.2522446811,
-0.3962613642,
0.9337503314,
0.4454473257,
-0.1542687267,
-0.0843561888,
-0.8369651437,
0.1571329683,
0.2046775371,
-0.2512709796,
-0.4393826425,
-0.0079097301,
0.3049276471,
0.4266607761,
0.2285564691,
-0.9662478566,
0.1750759482,
-0.3311009407,
0.2737266421,
0.4576306641,
-0.1015570536,
-0.027115982,
-0.471658051,
0.4780970216,
0.5094863772,
-0.2354401797,
-0.3545013666,
-0.6255095601,
-0.6992029548,
-0.21011208,
0.1626592577,
0.7042155266,
-0.8522158265,
0.0490951873,
-0.3752034903,
-0.4420154989,
-0.6507966518,
0.0963191614,
0.5578594208,
0.5213797092,
-0.0021570376,
0.0366285071,
-0.0757505372,
-1.168736577,
-0.691486299,
-0.0660732612,
-0.1387479901,
0.2363865972,
0.187856093,
0.0686831325,
0.7086761594,
-0.7053419352,
-0.3417644501,
-0.1958328038,
0.0445857719,
-0.0099565908,
0.5426644087,
0.5103455782,
-0.9713428617,
-0.4710860252,
0.111715816,
-0.7831797004,
0.0414241776,
-0.0876087546,
-0.0273854211,
-0.2140622884,
0.4920009375,
-0.8131985664,
-0.0182594676,
0.1952032447,
-0.1817877889,
0.8449631929,
-0.2296565473,
0.3735745549,
-1.2325960398,
-0.3032645583,
0.0848529339,
-0.0856464058,
-0.514195919,
0.2075606734,
-0.0294891391,
-0.2747546434,
-0.5949385762,
0.3684686422,
-0.0055590388,
0.1643935591,
0.1303535998,
0.1987277716,
-0.0251273941,
0.6455706358,
0.3296032846,
0.7898027301,
0.9164454937,
-0.5671157837,
0.741574645,
0.3247112334,
-0.4808898568,
0.7924618721,
-0.5616255999,
-0.0160969961,
-0.1182007566,
0.2795554698,
-0.8195618391,
-0.3118819296,
0.1223670766,
-0.1446063519,
-0.0754536763,
0.245974049,
-0.8453912735,
-0.0998991728,
-0.2716201544,
0.4091769755,
0.1467623562,
-0.4175799191,
0.3606344461,
0.1160960048,
-0.4038132131,
-0.3017063141,
-0.4627747834,
0.0781666487,
-0.5863773823,
-0.9115700126,
-0.3438571393,
-0.2770026326,
-0.0800667107,
-0.178650409,
0.1818360537,
-0.1992574334,
-0.1691044718,
0.2362271249,
-0.1616589874,
-0.7374001145,
0.1872008592,
-0.2330988497,
-0.2133806497,
-0.1098542809,
-0.1782890707,
0.3352336884,
-0.3046915233,
-0.1646023244,
-0.7441214323,
0.7869729996,
0.6026080251,
-0.3803707957,
0.416743964,
0.6270231009,
-0.0993623883,
-0.0404984131,
-0.4391352832,
-0.0328800343,
-0.4601820111,
0.3290377557,
-0.9551340342,
-0.7738419771,
0.5642827153,
-0.280418545,
0.0747480839,
0.1617578715,
0.5825281143,
-0.2312366664,
0.9122335911,
0.4416393042,
0.0884746164,
0.2056312561,
-0.1604222804,
0.2996739149,
-0.7039905787,
-0.2477171421,
-0.6810767055,
-0.2784939408,
-0.6960513592,
-0.5561930537,
0.2349543422,
-0.0792404637,
-0.2067575902,
0.4618104994,
-0.1047262698,
0.3496657908,
0.4923722446,
0.1001926064,
0.6502201557,
-0.0899899378,
-0.3261959255,
-0.2010257989,
-0.4521704912,
-0.6041926146,
0.7595757246,
-0.0019216654,
0.7943982482,
0.0702522546,
0.6307953596,
0.0253781751,
-0.2353053391,
-0.7179837227,
0.7683447003,
-0.2466786951,
-0.6506435871,
-0.3191150129,
-0.3461304605,
-0.8210631609,
0.3629417717,
0.0045814738,
-0.9193906188,
-0.2430531085,
0.0226524528,
-0.3797022998,
0.2361880541,
-0.7093400955,
1.0576754808,
-0.1810124815,
0.0526321381,
-0.1385693699,
-1.0687551498,
0.4818864167,
-0.2017967105,
0.3326719701,
-0.4716535807,
-0.0614330247,
0.6721262336,
-0.4790243804,
0.3462080956,
0.0555771403,
0.1214723811,
0.3756383359,
0.2267861515,
0.3274244964,
0.073211275,
-0.0834196582,
0.0370142348,
0.2751128972,
-0.443885237,
-0.8538476825,
0.9746168256,
-0.4938299656,
-0.5764231086,
-0.2617671788,
-0.863982141,
-0.4499956965,
0.1208522469,
0.1399805099,
0.6629990339,
-0.1995933354,
0.0165961068,
0.3066169024,
-0.1899475306,
0.2729256749,
0.7160691023,
0.103783302,
0.0003426271,
1.3617026806,
0.0255987272,
0.5182052255,
0.1111170575,
0.2294873446,
-0.4418644905,
-0.0251104888,
-0.7002498507,
0.4378039539,
-0.5876803398,
0.1475704908,
-0.8878445625,
-0.0806722865,
-0.262873143,
0.271097213,
-0.4071067274,
-0.7569746375,
0.0725355819,
0.1011613607,
0.5180091262,
0.7079072595,
0.1209368855,
0.1248119846,
-0.7255600691,
0.6878698468,
0.3165318072,
0.2597633004,
-0.2345704734,
-0.1474348456,
-0.2908601761,
0.3423108459,
-0.2956712842,
-0.5982827544,
0.2208803296,
0.5295159817,
0.2218863517,
0.4403214455,
0.2680640221,
0.8324754238,
-0.8225330114,
0.8575238585,
0.3286679089,
-0.4488340318,
0.39277035,
-0.5167274475,
0.0341981091,
0.5129804611,
0.2939963341,
-0.5790999532,
-0.8284538984,
-0.573523283,
-0.3647311628,
0.8197944164,
0.3601000607,
0.0366442278,
0.0035679711,
-0.1230065897,
0.1986088008,
0.3247765303,
-0.1996721923,
-0.4417939186,
-0.3167115152,
-0.1477514058,
-0.4578030407,
0.3613815308,
-0.1878863275,
-0.0468352921,
0.3926590383,
-0.1198372394,
0.0193108413,
0.0440513231,
0.0015494871,
0.2516117692,
0.2723257244,
0.3378240466,
-0.0844561011,
-0.3085474372,
0.0093517955,
-0.0753296614,
-0.4019452035,
0.3342407644,
0.1236152202,
0.1583776325,
0.2687968314,
0.0207282919,
0.5290612578,
0.1974371076,
-1.0321669579,
0.5409235954,
-0.1915182024,
0.2382576168,
0.0576670244,
0.082254149,
0.4366692305,
0.4243338108,
-0.0542831644,
0.1306669414,
0.3964439929,
-0.6900007725,
0.4453737736,
0.2779642045,
-0.2733235359,
-0.2795071006,
0.8804718852,
0.4122757316,
-0.5245203972,
0.561509192,
-0.3565479815,
-0.5146180391,
0.7557459474,
0.4702909589,
0.8429957032,
-0.096160531,
0.0930774137,
0.222920537,
-0.0049876017,
0.0452097878,
0.2656881213,
-0.0942296311,
-0.6641594768,
-0.1338624954,
-0.7861078978,
-0.2521119714,
0.1427289248,
-0.8326318264,
0.3887003958,
-0.1937182993,
0.0107054533,
0.4386408627,
-0.1308647096,
-0.766430974,
0.36518839,
0.0536767431,
0.8447693586,
-0.9268778563,
1.2001895905,
0.740203023,
-0.2015676498,
-0.8095024824,
0.2086681724,
0.1902061105,
-0.5793197155,
0.731492877,
0.330733031,
-0.2525886297,
-0.1571552306,
-0.2548760176,
-0.422015965,
0.6211335063,
0.4766382277,
-0.4179476202,
-0.2067420334,
0.2758923471,
0.5045824647,
-0.7283044457,
0.2239212841,
0.8825724721,
0.2755816877,
0.0803098008,
-1.1582453251,
-0.0383291468,
-0.3115751743,
0.0823596418,
-0.046517618,
-1.0677261353,
1.0445758104,
-0.364841789,
0.0385012142,
0.6366794705,
0.5941470861,
0.351472497,
0.3208142221,
0.7270111442,
0.5363398194,
0.4095258117,
-0.0595880598,
0.9941288829,
-0.5542049408,
0.4865246415,
1.2197276354,
-0.4792864621,
0.6897479892,
0.2228809446,
-0.0062897946,
0.3774080873,
0.6362265348,
0.3158763647,
0.4027398229,
-0.0030284668,
-0.30923751,
-0.601780057,
-0.4388264418,
-0.3582808673,
0.4357866049,
0.3667421341,
0.1262267232,
-0.5812447667,
0.409408927,
-0.1697915643,
0.1876469553,
0.249487251,
0.6762293577,
-0.0317576528,
-0.2764861286,
0.6021134257,
-0.2686062455,
0.4297880828,
-0.7364835739,
-0.1324803233,
-0.0070040342,
0.1286016256,
0.0158123858,
-0.8590884209,
0.0149195939,
0.0275311992,
-0.0406447202,
0.2203448415,
-0.0130540626,
-0.8738539219,
-0.5560181141,
0.2780297399,
0.4962414503,
0.6495808959,
-0.1179879382,
-1.0957647562,
0.1237796023,
0.0966703445,
-0.2224450409,
0.2773177326,
1.0908608437,
-0.1350845248,
1.0161030293,
0.4086716473,
0.2509904206,
0.2927479148,
0.1162071675,
1.0130023956,
-0.9931076765,
-0.7834439278,
-0.3040059209,
0.2971402705,
0.0025994394,
-0.2968215346,
0.9133456945,
0.95570755,
0.8305417299,
-0.1836799085,
0.7385441065,
0.0373385884,
0.9904006124,
-0.4604374468,
0.415953666,
-0.7342724204,
0.1372429878,
-0.4411555827,
-0.8973158002,
0.0785823762,
0.4826316833,
0.0989274308,
-0.2067390084,
0.9039414525,
1.0871046782,
-0.2902224958,
0.3443235159,
0.4616069794,
0.3441963792,
0.3169372678,
0.7129557133,
0.975276649,
-0.4789116085,
0.7025330663,
-0.4301474392,
0.1482497156,
-0.0029463093,
-0.3782474101,
-0.9582106471,
-0.8768561482,
-0.481497407,
-0.3507667184,
0.026222473,
1.0163490772,
0.6118919849,
-0.8530554175,
-0.4410631955,
0.3198495805,
-0.0062142024,
-0.2168233991,
-0.2435909659,
0.2955361307,
-0.3511574566,
-1.1324931383,
0.182339564,
0.145675838,
0.0172448698,
0.1022805497,
-0.1622022837,
-0.2882906199,
-0.0185565539,
0.3745321035,
0.1461022049,
-0.8847965002,
-0.4439112544,
-0.3372094631,
-0.1871229857,
0.0813620239,
1.067174077,
-0.7103349566,
0.8082993031,
0.0743229911,
0.3633353114,
0.260416925,
0.2318239659,
0.5079798698,
-0.5193904042,
0.7475389242,
0.2070962787,
0.2176660746,
0.3785779476,
-0.1140125543,
0.2682884932,
0.3746176958,
-0.3235843778,
-0.6800896525,
0.4105605483,
-1.2134625912,
-0.1624602824,
1.1756169796,
-0.466279,
-0.0399383157,
-0.3478397131,
-0.5827190876,
0.1549110562,
-0.6054512262,
0.3348160684,
0.6491763592,
-0.2935824394,
0.2061489373,
-0.7101614475,
0.6771289706,
0.234591037,
-0.4012585282,
0.3186457455,
0.3247185946,
0.5713970065,
0.3291916847,
0.2683516145,
0.1297945231,
0.247433126,
0.1870187372,
-0.3430983722,
-0.0354733653,
-0.3350019455,
-0.376057595,
0.1332084239,
-0.2884424627,
-0.4706858993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05659v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05659v3 | COVER: A Heuristic Greedy Adversarial Attack on Prompt-based Learning in Language Models | 2023-06-09T03:53:42 | 2023-09-14T03:23:34 | Zihao Tan, Qingliang Chen, Wenbin Zhu, Yongjian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt-based learning has been proved to be an effective way in pre-trained
language models (PLMs), especially in low-resource scenarios like few-shot
settings. However, the trustworthiness of PLMs is of paramount significance and
potential vulnerabilities have been shown in prompt-based templates that could
mislead the predictions of language models, causing serious security concerns.
In this paper, we will shed light on some vulnerabilities of PLMs, by proposing
a prompt-based adversarial attack on manual templates in black box scenarios.
First of all, we design character-level and word-level heuristic approaches to
break manual templates separately. Then we present a greedy algorithm for the
attack based on the above heuristic destructive approaches. Finally, we
evaluate our approach with the classification tasks on three variants of BERT
series models and eight datasets. And comprehensive experimental results
justify the effectiveness of our approach in terms of attack success rate and
attack speed. | [
-0.3195019662,
-0.9850866199,
0.3382119238,
-0.0599083565,
-0.2896578014,
0.0171637796,
-0.1142785624,
0.042853076,
-0.2367700338,
0.6197387576,
-0.5842370987,
-0.157846421,
-0.7920593023,
-0.0180582497,
-0.3443677723,
0.8184614182,
0.355815649,
0.1325491816,
0.1791701466,
-0.1064101905,
-0.7248272896,
-0.6347250938,
-0.7251633406,
0.1225845441,
0.6546422839,
0.0075072567,
0.7533015609,
0.4243609607,
0.0832949504,
0.264027983,
-0.058705654,
-0.1449114382,
-0.4383940697,
0.2179481089,
-0.0904728025,
-0.6774899364,
0.0156743862,
0.3035273552,
0.2185170949,
0.4073021412,
-0.0442289598,
-0.1616604179,
0.1408436894,
0.3910288811,
-0.5945780277,
-0.0823043361,
-0.9932518601,
0.0201173835,
-0.2072433233,
-0.3381924033,
-0.8244100213,
-0.1625153571,
0.2247285396,
-0.3753190041,
0.2829385698,
0.0671484396,
0.8188866973,
0.3825446069,
-0.2130229771,
-0.2690027058,
-0.180437088,
0.8181322217,
-0.650456965,
-0.023153862,
0.3625642955,
0.6536893845,
-0.3717860281,
-0.3493695557,
-0.4321253896,
-0.3861417472,
-0.0561565496,
-0.159998998,
-0.2288995236,
-0.0588352978,
0.5065616965,
0.0287869722,
-0.7160941362,
0.253495127,
-0.3185376525,
-0.2322617471,
0.5210047364,
0.033906281,
0.5302346945,
-0.3671556115,
-0.7748456001,
-0.2328264117,
-0.7831727266,
0.1629570276,
0.7086034417,
0.6382116675,
-0.1183161587,
0.3679344356,
0.3822658956,
0.9322038889,
-0.056968268,
-0.0172915012,
-0.2347437143,
-0.2410617471,
-0.1690152287,
0.0655541718,
0.8693233132,
-0.1144803837,
0.2906364799,
-0.3368310034,
-0.362195909,
0.1101689637,
0.5891352296,
-0.4432119727,
-0.0109212724,
0.1737107188,
-0.2324919403,
-0.674833715,
-0.012300062,
-0.717720747,
-0.6088648438,
0.1130219325,
0.5007061958,
-0.7855094075,
0.111407645,
-0.1000032201,
-0.0874339268,
0.1458072215,
0.3531232476,
-0.4969269037,
-0.0412622839,
0.6187999249,
0.6404989958,
0.216828078,
-0.2951498032,
-0.9849731326,
-0.0795692578,
-0.2069805562,
0.3835471869,
-0.2201015055,
-0.6318154931,
0.0406135693,
-0.1383465677,
-0.1189473718,
-0.1111907586,
0.4247947633,
-0.8687683344,
0.4217353761,
-0.3600174189,
-0.5464589596,
-0.1391370595,
0.5076204538,
-0.8785146475,
0.4661714435,
0.0387086272,
-0.7150641084,
0.3143514991,
-0.2443440855,
-0.5817816854,
0.1850209385,
-0.1147696227,
-0.4079397321,
0.0254349206,
0.2187599242,
0.415020436,
-0.2468914092,
0.3074703515,
-0.452622056,
-0.195340082,
0.6131949425,
-0.8102930188,
1.3732677698,
0.3435801566,
-0.4770078957,
0.0947009996,
-0.5810832977,
-0.1393337399,
0.5036975741,
-0.0054195221,
-0.532207191,
-0.2232630551,
-0.361528039,
0.3883099258,
0.2838104665,
-0.2913382053,
0.4489195347,
-0.5948140621,
0.2615872025,
0.9976834059,
0.0993207097,
0.491568774,
-0.3666984439,
0.7984469533,
-0.0583109036,
0.3181969523,
-0.5590457916,
-0.3435363173,
-0.292050153,
-0.413182497,
0.4280281961,
0.7340964079,
-1.2261517048,
0.3976638615,
0.4139080346,
-0.4568237066,
-0.6451533437,
0.1567616761,
0.6280705333,
0.6050519943,
0.3080359697,
-0.0275174249,
-0.1376835704,
-0.4702247679,
-0.4835051894,
0.0020737194,
0.0603366718,
0.3256139755,
0.3532676101,
0.1040572748,
0.6564236283,
-0.5204466581,
-0.1856901348,
-0.4012522101,
0.1579073668,
0.0733889416,
0.4508150518,
1.0337760448,
-0.4946058691,
-0.464802146,
-0.7195826173,
-0.6462151408,
0.082686618,
-0.349028796,
0.1125073805,
0.2048814446,
0.4690295458,
-0.5051341057,
0.3567776978,
0.2320203483,
-0.5140340328,
0.5630374551,
-0.1911320239,
-0.2300654054,
-1.0279347897,
-0.123331584,
0.3148210943,
-0.1241131276,
-0.6218029261,
0.3699658811,
0.0841673091,
-0.4568909705,
-0.755920589,
0.8375889659,
-0.3267661333,
0.1909304261,
-0.1616823524,
-0.226390928,
-0.1311834008,
0.6331524849,
-0.2813275456,
0.9361681938,
0.7506191134,
-0.4456816018,
0.2427465767,
0.0618360937,
-0.2662745118,
0.5952530503,
-0.6837751269,
0.1822871268,
-0.2158529013,
0.1387111545,
-0.8283455372,
0.2774465978,
0.5008377433,
-0.6903057098,
0.6869451404,
-0.0904950276,
-0.7181250453,
-0.0443325751,
-0.5064661503,
0.0159876961,
0.4618770182,
-0.6002483368,
0.2057619989,
0.0382948108,
-0.0868851468,
-0.8895300627,
-0.2077835202,
0.2057665884,
-0.2652671039,
-0.3681833148,
-0.0420727208,
-0.1336839497,
-0.1763963103,
-0.1101925969,
0.1410142183,
0.129053548,
0.696716845,
-0.0734714568,
0.2543755174,
0.0494008176,
-0.3980849385,
-0.3675159812,
-0.1584783643,
0.155109778,
-0.3984146118,
0.6598746777,
0.0201916806,
-0.2571821511,
-0.3688440323,
0.349955678,
0.6470379829,
-0.2782986462,
0.9187092185,
0.6289371848,
-0.4384465218,
-0.550419569,
-0.2980390191,
-0.3739044964,
-0.5041817427,
0.1677403748,
-0.1329248548,
-0.3142060935,
0.3001943529,
0.2664662004,
0.1152461469,
0.2145580053,
0.3646239936,
-0.1600504518,
1.1069626808,
0.4327893257,
-0.3568454087,
0.516966939,
-0.4475525022,
-0.078043662,
-0.3773311079,
-0.1889805347,
-0.6394218802,
-0.0276279412,
-0.307598561,
-0.2389474362,
0.3630368412,
-0.0258644875,
-0.2161750495,
0.4170041084,
-0.1283852905,
0.2210673839,
0.903232336,
0.1190493479,
-0.2320737243,
-0.0550411753,
-0.5030981302,
-0.0113132382,
-0.9764224887,
-0.4081129432,
1.1844483614,
0.3422875404,
0.8516578078,
0.1339503974,
0.4753603637,
0.4979555011,
0.0447860062,
-0.5002518296,
0.5439719558,
-0.2140206099,
-0.637889564,
-0.2878723443,
-0.3872385621,
-0.8888295889,
0.078869611,
-0.1631738394,
-0.4989900589,
-0.0221753623,
0.1222632229,
-0.4710575342,
0.4184710979,
-0.8681126833,
0.9507839084,
-0.6344642043,
-0.534811914,
0.0483102277,
-0.773843348,
0.3700034618,
0.0839370117,
0.0526820831,
0.2796171606,
0.1638928801,
0.5872294307,
-0.6184147,
1.1789668798,
-0.5870035887,
-0.0593644567,
0.211567536,
0.2044633478,
0.7608677745,
0.2333783954,
-0.0149183655,
-0.0104912408,
-0.3435836434,
-0.8798132539,
-0.6589324474,
0.4726967216,
-0.836022079,
-0.8678981662,
-0.7348889112,
-0.3568720818,
-0.2664388418,
0.0865108892,
0.4936324954,
0.5683900118,
-0.1018210351,
-0.184474051,
0.934868753,
-0.5518209338,
0.4801206291,
0.5345144272,
0.5464673042,
-0.4452288747,
1.1698713303,
0.1081709042,
0.3560793698,
0.2600778639,
0.1061252952,
-0.2965635061,
-0.5738506317,
-0.5888423324,
0.1350685954,
-0.461710155,
-0.3574748635,
-0.3928270638,
-0.1207985431,
-0.4497711658,
-0.4579007924,
-0.0319618918,
-0.2182668447,
-0.6142069101,
0.0900268704,
0.1725754887,
0.3449853957,
0.3935078979,
0.6223520041,
-0.7579844594,
0.0448838808,
0.5245811939,
0.1195603684,
0.0476102158,
-0.2914780378,
-0.0810305998,
-0.1226105094,
-0.4168820977,
-1.2062512636,
0.6837362051,
-0.2880259752,
0.8334142566,
0.6469848156,
0.297973156,
0.0675182864,
-0.4778192043,
0.7726284266,
0.3481050432,
-0.6691702008,
0.4365358055,
-0.3694762588,
0.3506218791,
0.5713934302,
0.3479717076,
-0.1084092036,
-0.4848365486,
-1.0889163017,
-0.6264408827,
0.8607919216,
-0.0413257293,
0.0156200333,
0.0760867372,
0.2820894718,
0.3459273577,
0.4755392075,
-0.5424304605,
-0.5989671946,
-0.4395329356,
-0.0461346284,
-0.3305447996,
-0.3971453905,
-0.1134425104,
0.2618170977,
0.6925054789,
-0.0129409973,
0.0343513899,
-0.1650562584,
-0.4975771606,
0.1788737476,
0.4647923708,
0.5321806073,
0.0333139971,
-0.1130317152,
0.0286852662,
-0.0664801821,
-0.2004952729,
0.2221062183,
0.4501872659,
-0.5010876656,
-0.1113570705,
0.4760956168,
0.896288991,
0.1515797973,
-0.5768351555,
0.7654402256,
-0.3219694197,
0.118278265,
-0.2871012688,
0.0671698302,
-0.3010134995,
0.1093976721,
0.3450165391,
0.2330915183,
-0.1902361214,
-0.4616571665,
0.3833151162,
0.8937407732,
-0.5395042896,
-0.4493494034,
0.6707091331,
0.316334337,
-0.3382630944,
0.3259107172,
-0.5677028298,
-0.9957268834,
0.6944390535,
0.5336098671,
0.87028265,
-0.4716512263,
0.2077040523,
0.1128584296,
0.7189679146,
0.0536800437,
0.1392043084,
-0.0428889021,
-0.5846229196,
-0.0840370581,
-0.2566221654,
-0.3793187141,
0.5375387073,
-0.484131813,
0.4748998284,
-0.8549090624,
-0.0086469343,
-0.2066085637,
0.1724062264,
-0.6576160192,
0.1073505282,
0.14545618,
1.005828619,
-0.6791985631,
0.7153610587,
0.6124406457,
-0.4365895987,
-0.4499634802,
0.1073302701,
0.1281221956,
-0.8876522779,
0.5873907804,
0.0034069356,
0.2592520118,
-0.0654795095,
-0.567353487,
-0.4572476149,
0.6876913309,
0.5813001394,
-0.4542394876,
-0.2533342838,
-0.1902069449,
0.0974334702,
0.0902723074,
-0.0789788514,
0.3178802729,
0.3802807629,
-0.1711432189,
-0.5326735973,
0.1465743035,
-0.2093749493,
-0.2920792103,
0.1199259311,
-0.5319007039,
0.933799386,
-0.3464492261,
-0.2559426129,
-0.0792542696,
0.5888820291,
0.242614463,
0.093217887,
0.7169826627,
0.6038045883,
0.6387948394,
0.1385191232,
1.1830918789,
-0.3600062132,
0.1109030545,
0.7894078493,
-0.2040715814,
0.1825007945,
0.2218836695,
-0.0034600222,
0.0059409924,
0.4144770503,
-0.1865404546,
0.7717725635,
0.2975817919,
-0.2365780324,
-0.085801892,
0.0961737335,
-0.3035306931,
0.1374135613,
0.5263102651,
-0.1860264838,
-0.4186567664,
0.2675883472,
0.4425672591,
0.2791267335,
-0.2852632701,
0.7732172608,
0.1268773079,
-0.5879917741,
0.6925547123,
0.2031556517,
0.8375172019,
-0.7463550568,
0.2066483498,
0.1111989096,
-0.0451433957,
0.236427784,
-0.2700047195,
-0.1503487378,
0.1547998786,
0.1497890651,
-0.2791541815,
0.8058041334,
-0.2342598885,
-0.351834625,
0.1122287363,
0.5585541129,
-0.6240036488,
-0.0541551225,
-0.9120005369,
-0.2362205088,
-0.1012437865,
-0.1597441286,
0.5587087274,
0.3353376389,
0.1054046899,
0.6931020617,
0.6424637437,
0.2068821788,
0.0185161959,
-0.1540789753,
0.7462638021,
-0.7010628581,
-0.9916611314,
-0.9200629592,
0.2515021563,
-0.0443305708,
-0.0482041351,
0.820584476,
0.2366360426,
0.6595236659,
0.0018779383,
1.217203021,
0.3819701672,
0.3799620569,
-0.7280833125,
0.8857161403,
-0.3851859868,
0.6477349997,
-0.3237729967,
-0.2316113412,
-0.217032209,
0.1532176137,
-0.4521744251,
0.0486774258,
0.6151104569,
0.5085507035,
0.2281126827,
-0.0388231464,
0.3235162497,
0.1729045063,
0.4897729754,
0.5709881186,
0.8718957901,
-0.0764865205,
0.6013674736,
-0.3831393719,
-0.2831767797,
-0.3582465053,
-0.8122475743,
-1.2784359455,
-0.5410197973,
-0.2026559263,
-0.6531915069,
0.3991811275,
0.8994124532,
0.426271826,
-0.6050486565,
0.1531500518,
0.1066023037,
0.3367164135,
-0.3037170172,
-0.2569102943,
0.4925616086,
-0.4944370985,
-0.5330033898,
0.6330077648,
-0.1403572261,
0.3036133647,
-0.5639038682,
0.1231039166,
-0.2031063884,
0.157608375,
0.2526484132,
0.5395764112,
-0.5945445299,
-0.0885324255,
0.1014574096,
-0.2446958721,
-0.3504534662,
0.9870942831,
-1.1721248627,
0.3633245826,
0.3562993109,
0.8660498261,
-0.1598452479,
-0.0205831155,
0.7883720994,
-1.0824197531,
0.374956578,
0.3476134539,
0.5585472584,
0.4032089114,
-0.6257762909,
-0.0091000367,
0.4701289237,
0.0721823275,
-1.0587527752,
0.4273784161,
-0.8682616949,
-0.7898954749,
1.064278245,
-0.2970392108,
-0.4703725576,
-0.1361880302,
-0.1678103209,
0.1664828807,
-0.6595711708,
0.9396256804,
0.5069257617,
0.5172431469,
0.1026486456,
-0.5400118828,
0.5631588697,
0.3038483262,
-0.469017446,
-0.0327544957,
0.2086924016,
0.2021620125,
0.0417122468,
0.1470841318,
-0.0947410464,
0.5199341774,
-0.143720746,
-0.3835649192,
-0.5458728075,
-0.397649914,
-0.7875960469,
0.6298594475,
0.0786138177,
-0.2535548806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05652v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05652v1 | Privacy Aware Question-Answering System for Online Mental Health Risk Assessment | 2023-06-09T03:37:49 | 2023-06-09T03:37:49 | Prateek Chhikara, Ujjwal Pasupulety, John Marshall, Dhiraj Chaurasia, Shweta Kumari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Social media platforms have enabled individuals suffering from mental
illnesses to share their lived experiences and find the online support
necessary to cope. However, many users fail to receive genuine clinical
support, thus exacerbating their symptoms. Screening users based on what they
post online can aid providers in administering targeted healthcare and minimize
false positives. Pre-trained Language Models (LMs) can assess users' social
media data and classify them in terms of their mental health risk. We propose a
Question-Answering (QA) approach to assess mental health risk using the
Unified-QA model on two large mental health datasets. To protect user data, we
extend Unified-QA by anonymizing the model training process using differential
privacy. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of modeling risk assessment
as a QA task, specifically for mental health use cases. Furthermore, the
model's performance decreases by less than 1% with the inclusion of
differential privacy. The proposed system's performance is indicative of a
promising research direction that will lead to the development of privacy-aware
diagnostic systems. | [
-0.3819690645,
-0.6221518517,
0.8755660057,
0.2802740335,
-0.0990677848,
0.0930345729,
0.1696638018,
-0.5830596089,
0.400055021,
0.424405545,
-0.7736058831,
-0.5913391709,
-0.6549965739,
-0.287704289,
-0.4415424466,
0.844307363,
-0.0757941529,
0.1370748132,
-0.0908545852,
0.064360626,
-0.2298854291,
-0.6142708063,
-0.6577593088,
0.3020662069,
0.5809584856,
-0.0794536695,
0.7518063784,
0.0678336769,
0.6538659334,
0.2219625413,
-0.0367029905,
-0.029756587,
-0.4112180769,
0.2181269377,
-0.2390382737,
-0.276040107,
-0.6637308002,
-0.0810106546,
0.3518054187,
0.4385413229,
-0.3603134155,
0.5970499516,
-0.0678088441,
0.2845307589,
-0.7753448486,
-0.1563847065,
-0.2326995581,
0.0772600099,
0.1398034096,
-0.1295951605,
0.071694389,
-0.8335412145,
0.008555497,
-0.4432107806,
0.0120367026,
-0.4369394779,
0.4367814958,
0.2456423491,
-0.2843019962,
0.0756061673,
-0.9816120863,
0.2115307003,
-0.5186234117,
0.3299090862,
0.7138937116,
0.6460668445,
0.1833074093,
-0.570361197,
-0.3407601118,
0.16369012,
-0.1656451374,
0.072047323,
-0.443700701,
0.1051203161,
0.3655775785,
0.2185793668,
-0.6962233782,
-0.0403924957,
-0.4139881432,
-0.3511483669,
0.9672948718,
0.2564455867,
0.3978553712,
0.1113848016,
-0.2152810693,
0.1048452556,
-0.3009388745,
0.233324334,
0.2217295468,
-0.1111535579,
-0.1507340521,
0.6064865589,
-0.1909211576,
0.1636716723,
0.0458519682,
-0.0471350811,
-0.0037513608,
0.0817207098,
-0.0653377175,
-0.0772319064,
0.7307652831,
0.7010588646,
-0.0060580969,
-0.2839162946,
-0.0239143483,
0.4420793056,
0.4883577228,
-0.6839969754,
-0.1351929754,
0.5284124613,
-0.320953697,
0.0033584884,
0.1098192334,
-0.8010306358,
-0.8513228893,
0.0254677702,
0.7029070854,
-0.2964450121,
-0.4101394117,
0.3518783152,
0.0923977569,
-0.1918298751,
0.1110026836,
-0.3921923041,
0.6323518157,
0.4363504052,
0.6408679485,
0.0462826379,
0.1817309558,
-0.5353576541,
0.1088261977,
-0.1004135162,
0.3978799582,
-0.2754120231,
-0.363057524,
0.1098197326,
0.1877158433,
0.0150792887,
-0.2224776447,
0.2710927725,
-0.6319846511,
0.3191868067,
-0.4176157415,
-0.5276486874,
-0.1765292585,
0.1693406552,
-0.4564655125,
0.6649212837,
0.3038797379,
-1.1503026485,
0.0066081886,
-0.7205169201,
-0.2185430676,
0.3119926751,
-0.0479876883,
-0.4103455842,
0.0870304927,
0.3070522547,
0.6941979527,
0.0150702894,
0.3716211319,
-0.9223537445,
-0.5108232498,
0.5929079652,
-0.2660769224,
0.9960092902,
0.180003494,
-0.3000646234,
0.0046986463,
-0.7815462947,
0.2222558558,
0.1639852971,
0.1004403308,
-0.6772482395,
-0.2287904769,
-0.1083565056,
0.2761801481,
0.2842386067,
-0.6558094621,
-0.4698750377,
-0.2218828946,
0.3258258104,
0.5247781873,
0.3962234855,
0.0334549472,
-0.3855746984,
0.8367820382,
0.0388078541,
0.7429647446,
0.395699203,
-0.6593602896,
0.0150662176,
-0.4446920753,
0.1152384356,
0.8228507638,
-0.3685142994,
0.7543670535,
-0.0957204401,
-0.4281025231,
-0.6656033993,
-0.0660942569,
0.2047431022,
0.1689967066,
0.2418656349,
-0.4195989966,
-0.2921838164,
-0.7355548143,
-0.2801295221,
-0.1300721169,
-0.1970683038,
0.227610603,
-0.0324521475,
-0.6679316163,
0.7096050978,
-0.7334532142,
-0.214726463,
-0.0969807878,
-0.23507303,
-0.2946131825,
0.201847747,
0.3002111018,
-0.7876513004,
-0.4991410077,
-0.260163039,
-0.7672376633,
-0.0965206996,
0.2358693033,
-0.2547982335,
-0.3472153246,
0.006716073,
-0.5729405284,
0.6481309533,
0.6999661922,
-0.2601133883,
-0.0448956601,
-0.3447168171,
0.0303399581,
-1.2195885181,
0.2618095279,
0.0564890653,
-0.4190033078,
-0.8505207896,
-0.0186314527,
0.0095996372,
-0.480871886,
-0.4662628472,
0.310728997,
-0.155268237,
0.015579273,
-0.1897452623,
-0.0659791753,
0.0412839726,
0.2885369956,
-0.2190905064,
0.396241039,
0.7877287269,
-0.5124178529,
0.0566136241,
0.0502135493,
-0.0488237031,
0.5533850193,
-0.3206394911,
0.3709003627,
-0.238332361,
-0.0165679511,
-0.8722648025,
-0.3576607406,
0.5344346166,
-0.3920680881,
0.0608547963,
0.4197226465,
-0.3132063448,
-0.5059903264,
-0.5201101303,
0.2978414595,
0.3168739378,
-0.0809187815,
0.1941748261,
0.9623593688,
-0.4322724044,
-0.3898970187,
-0.4148125052,
-0.0832490474,
-0.5724827647,
-0.3460150659,
0.1274915934,
-0.1480577439,
-0.3123296201,
0.2087019533,
-0.0706573501,
-0.5867580175,
0.5776854753,
0.5943168402,
0.2166392058,
0.1464511752,
0.3666121662,
0.3135710359,
0.057771448,
0.4120197892,
0.0506489575,
0.3796028495,
-0.1384658217,
-0.2590630651,
-1.0097831488,
0.8262072206,
0.2934016585,
-0.1393565685,
0.8561184406,
0.3982226849,
-0.9259631634,
0.1587117463,
-0.6567412615,
-0.3999866247,
-0.4632633328,
0.0583954677,
0.1713809073,
-1.0579319,
0.5502324104,
0.0722010583,
-0.163399443,
0.2160420418,
0.4200810194,
-0.4038398266,
1.2278807163,
0.8172595501,
-0.042643737,
0.0947074369,
0.1007622257,
0.4976062179,
-0.2352232933,
0.0311438385,
-0.2249505371,
-0.0613624863,
-0.7534240484,
-0.2214607298,
0.5679813623,
-0.0331184193,
-0.1551675498,
0.3266379833,
-0.5693388581,
0.1119804904,
0.419420898,
0.6025746465,
0.3744166493,
-0.1028272733,
0.3317497373,
-0.1372372806,
-0.2310298085,
-0.5611954331,
1.2208497524,
0.5550918579,
0.8626947403,
0.0419882573,
0.8191351891,
0.4096338749,
0.564345181,
-0.1637424678,
0.4768101275,
-0.0118213193,
-0.9920383096,
-0.5058411956,
-0.5152369142,
-0.650850594,
-0.0798659921,
-0.1342014372,
-0.9943960309,
0.3362226188,
0.1548026055,
-0.9603868127,
0.2987819612,
-0.5659762621,
0.6054798961,
-0.3444559276,
0.0063015111,
-0.0101425126,
-0.8969615102,
0.5467016101,
-0.4693646729,
0.2830244005,
-0.3027896285,
0.221059218,
0.7870848775,
-0.0832167268,
0.8179997802,
-0.394556433,
0.0390782654,
0.2422485948,
-0.0554629453,
0.1103261337,
0.5465298295,
0.171190992,
0.0736324713,
0.7093686461,
-0.1319702864,
-0.7305492759,
0.479495585,
-0.7733040452,
-0.5759122372,
-0.3121915162,
-0.4553401768,
-0.6536492109,
0.1995098293,
0.0993786529,
0.021869909,
-0.2421889752,
-0.0661806166,
0.6501147151,
-0.3666145802,
-0.1221397668,
0.6295669079,
-0.3150455356,
-0.3302851021,
0.5925952196,
0.1657062769,
-0.1634092182,
0.1046477109,
0.4604983926,
-0.5763001442,
-0.1857486963,
0.0181986764,
0.3858425021,
-0.6564708948,
-0.1363297552,
-0.8102101684,
-0.5949707031,
-0.5465532541,
0.1805908233,
-0.1546109766,
-0.3459152579,
-0.1881468594,
-0.4757846296,
0.4374845028,
0.6540542841,
-0.1531483233,
0.2954327762,
-0.8375447392,
0.5195439458,
0.7449283004,
0.6726757288,
-0.3572974801,
-0.1163370311,
0.0744515732,
0.1651759148,
-0.268247962,
-1.2568392754,
0.2634866238,
0.023446342,
0.4600037038,
0.6355010271,
0.6352115273,
0.4603314996,
-0.1877325922,
0.3190026283,
0.2943908274,
-0.673989594,
0.5509390831,
-0.1837981343,
-0.312540859,
0.9516540766,
1.0048211813,
-0.6962045431,
-0.5895453691,
-0.6673605442,
-0.4045509398,
0.3914631605,
0.129152894,
0.2516103089,
0.0534196608,
0.4804597497,
0.0075791762,
0.2102680802,
-0.7232708335,
-0.28492257,
-0.2705869675,
-0.1543048918,
-0.1205795258,
-0.3053571284,
-0.5565987825,
-0.3011237085,
0.4836635888,
0.0884226337,
0.486989826,
0.2724972069,
0.1683297902,
-0.2307678014,
0.4511957467,
0.1297954619,
0.6800838709,
-0.5188126564,
0.2412386984,
0.0642434061,
-0.4737171531,
0.4199339449,
0.4287658334,
-0.3519562483,
-0.012058842,
-0.3946056068,
0.4310090542,
-0.137688905,
-0.6460666656,
0.6856536865,
-0.3438721001,
-0.3712280989,
-0.1949532926,
0.017516546,
0.4201752245,
0.1447832882,
-0.0595154613,
-0.4257626832,
0.3820339739,
-0.2508013248,
0.2971351147,
0.3481843472,
-0.7104132175,
-0.4953936338,
0.6611199975,
-0.1538446546,
-0.5587416291,
0.2443912625,
-0.0958567634,
-0.2224569917,
0.270431608,
0.2534602582,
0.8848943114,
-0.6924366951,
0.5834375024,
0.0554826818,
0.300132215,
0.0014665702,
0.7733588815,
0.3018540442,
-0.4916786849,
0.2442407161,
-0.3942221999,
-0.5802921653,
0.5542209744,
-1.1001749039,
-0.1711967736,
-0.8250201941,
-0.7630434632,
-0.135962531,
0.0055612689,
-0.6909129024,
0.5684235692,
0.2709623277,
0.462451309,
-0.9261023402,
0.5774967074,
0.7417648435,
-0.0613448359,
-0.7275567055,
0.1758166105,
0.0424250104,
-0.4270958304,
-0.0944103077,
0.428401649,
0.0092034955,
-0.2299481481,
-0.188286081,
-0.7581933141,
1.0251518488,
0.721422255,
-0.4736715555,
0.0090097012,
0.4032555521,
0.8441491127,
-0.1194538921,
-0.1216912642,
0.2348263264,
0.219610557,
-0.296880573,
-0.6829724908,
0.2716888785,
-0.0513147339,
0.0296045188,
-0.2312946171,
-0.2801350057,
0.4883275032,
-0.1631339043,
-0.7905748487,
-0.2392651737,
0.332796216,
0.0878136829,
0.491951257,
0.4694310129,
0.3950049877,
1.039629221,
0.4752286971,
0.9078127742,
-0.4177891314,
0.4202333391,
0.9264753461,
-0.5834668875,
0.8576068282,
0.1191770062,
-0.3489926755,
0.2510389984,
0.6710913777,
0.3362285495,
0.4770083129,
0.2727861106,
-0.5940123796,
-0.2220761478,
-0.1653080881,
-0.5265040398,
0.121571444,
0.288058579,
-0.3314621747,
-0.2951872349,
0.130931899,
-0.1695722789,
0.1637636423,
-0.163104102,
0.6405658722,
0.2430088818,
-0.2377170026,
0.1825922728,
0.1574676782,
0.2886375785,
-0.6831379533,
0.4016398489,
-0.2404802591,
0.0316048674,
-0.0560779311,
-0.4962488115,
0.6547911167,
0.2707832456,
0.0068447343,
0.0347986221,
0.858387351,
-0.2677164972,
-0.829869926,
0.6128247976,
0.7380430698,
0.2734276354,
-0.4305486381,
-0.6989882588,
-0.5114708543,
-0.5305541754,
-0.1248559952,
0.5987814069,
0.0776976347,
-0.3697943091,
0.6507771611,
0.4902175367,
0.1989975572,
0.0805294737,
0.0048940871,
0.9196650386,
-0.4546759129,
-0.784820199,
-0.5666425228,
0.07591369,
-0.1442635953,
-0.1279459894,
0.629221499,
0.1786920726,
0.5675965548,
0.170577839,
0.7625030279,
0.2232160419,
1.0465115309,
0.0351512544,
1.1849635839,
-0.5411254168,
0.0246591568,
-0.0249689315,
-0.5394116044,
-0.4104858041,
0.3813475966,
-0.3619361818,
-0.2233086228,
0.5499426723,
0.8974668384,
0.1361668557,
0.066442132,
0.4420040548,
-0.0177273992,
0.1888741702,
0.5524737239,
0.7809042931,
-0.3989047408,
0.1907036752,
-0.7577376366,
-0.3189905584,
0.2038710713,
-0.4745823145,
-0.9793126583,
-0.3092660904,
-0.4081122875,
-0.2837159634,
0.2286265194,
0.6877813339,
0.4594608247,
-0.8494375348,
0.097921066,
0.3468828201,
-0.0728119612,
-0.3005663753,
-0.1883756518,
0.3637656271,
0.4468204677,
-0.0926823169,
0.1641995311,
0.2781475782,
0.0251290835,
-0.472127974,
0.2316963524,
-0.1095393971,
0.1460954249,
0.1252185851,
0.3537078202,
-0.483019501,
-0.1504176259,
0.1176448762,
-0.4402247667,
-0.1425089836,
0.4140447676,
-0.2292799503,
0.4675060213,
0.2951277494,
0.986572504,
0.2065859884,
0.2831971943,
0.3359738588,
-0.2739550471,
-0.2834040821,
0.3690976202,
-0.0602947585,
0.258131206,
-1.1149228811,
0.0575966947,
0.0994045436,
-0.1482826918,
-0.7500737906,
-0.033546146,
-0.8466629982,
-0.2266772687,
0.8935006857,
-0.6346040368,
-0.0743343532,
-0.4016001523,
0.0348243639,
0.2950851917,
-0.1781690866,
1.3123346567,
0.4281296134,
0.086037077,
0.0353281386,
-0.4779738188,
0.3952251971,
0.109932892,
-0.9856211543,
-0.0310164224,
0.0797027275,
0.5961866975,
-0.0546464585,
1.1007524729,
-0.1996127367,
0.5904867053,
-0.486423105,
-0.0473591872,
-0.14310655,
-0.1962970495,
-0.6192395687,
0.3276955187,
-0.2502598763,
-0.2911671102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05644v2 | WSPAlign: Word Alignment Pre-training via Large-Scale Weakly Supervised Span Prediction | 2023-06-09T03:11:42 | 2023-10-19T05:47:52 | Qiyu Wu, Masaaki Nagata, Yoshimasa Tsuruoka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing word alignment methods rely on manual alignment datasets or
parallel corpora, which limits their usefulness. Here, to mitigate the
dependence on manual data, we broaden the source of supervision by relaxing the
requirement for correct, fully-aligned, and parallel sentences. Specifically,
we make noisy, partially aligned, and non-parallel paragraphs. We then use such
a large-scale weakly-supervised dataset for word alignment pre-training via
span prediction. Extensive experiments with various settings empirically
demonstrate that our approach, which is named WSPAlign, is an effective and
scalable way to pre-train word aligners without manual data. When fine-tuned on
standard benchmarks, WSPAlign has set a new state-of-the-art by improving upon
the best-supervised baseline by 3.3~6.1 points in F1 and 1.5~6.1 points in AER.
Furthermore, WSPAlign also achieves competitive performance compared with the
corresponding baselines in few-shot, zero-shot and cross-lingual tests, which
demonstrates that WSPAlign is potentially more practical for low-resource
languages than existing methods. | [
-0.4106302559,
-0.4423668683,
0.2763587534,
-0.0033282619,
-0.3434271216,
-0.3414191902,
-0.5217982531,
-0.4966549575,
0.2989878654,
-0.0624861084,
-0.7455403805,
-0.4149729013,
-0.8167161345,
0.1210205853,
-0.3691488802,
1.0654066801,
-0.2060124278,
0.2728064954,
-0.2575751543,
-0.1789556146,
-0.3239982426,
0.090271607,
-0.1101463288,
-0.2460699826,
0.7146908045,
0.5562849045,
0.9126080275,
0.7350446582,
0.5827649236,
0.3817056119,
0.0389951319,
0.0648309365,
-0.506723702,
-0.1241517961,
-0.1863183677,
-0.3155809939,
-0.2311696112,
0.0123338597,
0.4786838591,
1.1330652237,
-0.2473984957,
0.3248443604,
0.2455913723,
0.5803857446,
-0.838426888,
-0.1048746184,
-0.5712817311,
0.2182696611,
-0.7672895193,
0.1736155599,
-0.2457088083,
-0.4481912851,
0.2526904941,
-0.933698833,
0.2560902834,
0.2977843583,
1.2965172529,
0.5474066138,
-0.2049410343,
0.1672213227,
-0.6097540259,
0.7000709176,
-0.600225091,
0.3772701323,
0.249614194,
0.2111362517,
-0.0328187831,
-0.8565725088,
-0.455701381,
0.1974637061,
-0.1910213977,
0.2504567802,
-0.1177907735,
0.1215027943,
0.2815595269,
0.5034134984,
-0.7794513702,
0.4853953719,
-0.4780627489,
-0.288634032,
0.4493062198,
-0.1249708384,
0.1230573282,
0.4411440492,
-0.5117641687,
-0.1167874038,
-0.6631858945,
-0.0219350271,
0.3719551265,
0.4532828927,
0.0400130376,
0.8069373965,
-0.1550706178,
0.8825163841,
0.4486481249,
-0.2001235038,
0.3399685621,
-0.1234551072,
-0.2336707413,
0.5720353723,
0.9732555151,
0.3177802861,
0.4439420998,
-0.2400582582,
-0.2497399598,
0.3870063722,
0.2016842514,
-0.4925922751,
-0.2570692003,
-0.0826886594,
-0.2489722669,
-0.2305811048,
0.0566626452,
-0.5834758282,
-0.3039430678,
-0.7529916763,
0.5938770771,
-0.3144742548,
-0.052795548,
0.3413506746,
-0.2075756788,
0.134043023,
0.2190409899,
-0.9550226331,
0.362425983,
0.5980775952,
0.7191036344,
-0.2849263251,
-0.7584342957,
-0.6164842248,
0.3011767864,
-0.4380299747,
0.9038752317,
-0.3591514826,
0.0326924883,
0.2768746018,
0.0938830078,
-0.1519555748,
-0.2282564044,
0.5196599364,
-0.2012673467,
0.6395391822,
-0.2628239095,
-0.7487039566,
0.4545211196,
0.1453664303,
-0.6517358422,
1.0326322317,
-0.1172833666,
-1.1545964479,
0.7768360376,
-0.3087595999,
-0.7816262841,
-0.0236870572,
0.0884797052,
-0.5866676569,
0.2134741843,
0.3932397366,
0.1853556335,
0.164737463,
0.1422062665,
-0.4634479284,
-0.7170886397,
-0.0842289478,
-0.1321156174,
0.3666966558,
-0.0753200799,
-0.3940955102,
0.0945215747,
-0.3946296871,
-0.0036576996,
-0.0399258323,
0.1260249168,
-0.3777423203,
-0.0235341787,
-0.1922606528,
0.1160315275,
0.6369915009,
-0.5602376461,
0.1265838146,
-0.5554914474,
-0.0812866092,
0.8058680296,
-0.426356554,
0.8279781342,
-0.3333042264,
0.5704265237,
-0.1299239844,
0.3014507294,
0.2842441201,
-0.2491966188,
-0.6755618453,
-0.2000723332,
0.4810711741,
0.4556129873,
-0.3975305855,
0.7550887465,
-0.4258992374,
-0.5189106464,
-0.6932768822,
0.4489435256,
0.5092278123,
0.7837641239,
0.628782928,
-0.1773463488,
-0.5419340134,
-0.853371799,
-0.3924281001,
0.1754897088,
0.2162510753,
-0.4177895784,
0.0446379185,
0.1379184574,
0.8457471728,
-0.9385384321,
-0.6948032975,
-0.3078950644,
0.4261521995,
0.0987270176,
0.3921569884,
0.1290734857,
-0.6630656719,
-0.5267746449,
-0.239291355,
-0.4546422064,
-0.234297812,
0.2082763314,
-0.3869422078,
-0.045228187,
0.8580041528,
-0.6006502509,
0.1949116588,
0.7633289695,
-0.1111552417,
0.5031638741,
-0.2123994082,
-0.3663475215,
-1.2203046083,
0.1157684326,
0.3254744411,
-0.1486753821,
-0.4473325312,
-0.5496585965,
0.1760557592,
-0.1798051745,
-0.4541893303,
0.1525209397,
-0.6713684201,
-0.0957552344,
-0.1111108214,
0.2221979052,
0.0363228023,
0.3083986044,
0.2790982127,
0.8163363934,
0.5054311752,
-0.407283932,
-0.065841049,
0.3585823476,
-0.4175902903,
0.7597584128,
-0.6064989567,
-0.2700354159,
-0.324349016,
0.3204122186,
-0.959700942,
-0.1491162777,
-0.2772952318,
-0.1503508985,
0.6217534542,
-0.0490644835,
-0.4738870263,
-0.4747346044,
-0.3075098395,
0.2947050631,
0.3641351163,
-0.5541793108,
-0.1260053217,
0.4505081773,
-0.1315018386,
-0.7801862955,
-0.6466667652,
-0.23812069,
-0.2594989836,
-0.3626011908,
0.5122133493,
0.206237182,
0.0387787856,
0.0256147757,
-0.4268046618,
-0.0494178683,
-0.182916075,
0.2340607047,
0.4306272864,
-0.3544544578,
0.3211117387,
0.2745189667,
-0.3690365255,
-0.3769737482,
-0.4565088451,
0.3610117733,
-0.0673207119,
-0.4930891693,
-0.5779772997,
0.0614850782,
0.4104151428,
-0.5170450211,
0.7173727751,
0.8925783038,
-0.5153278708,
-0.0760115162,
-0.4939494729,
-0.0791303292,
-0.5200397968,
0.1899075359,
-0.0047415849,
-1.0459496975,
-0.2144191861,
-0.4131656587,
0.1427169293,
0.3646490574,
0.1138466224,
-0.3682332039,
1.1494735479,
0.719632566,
-0.4213072658,
0.4932254553,
0.2291321754,
0.2565940619,
-0.5234953761,
-0.0324755684,
-0.4455770254,
-0.8372513652,
-0.454453826,
-0.0534141995,
-0.0167623404,
0.3590756953,
-0.3731726706,
0.7414649725,
-0.734294951,
0.5973498225,
0.3284162581,
-0.1489412785,
0.0689801648,
-0.164987877,
-0.223418653,
-0.42162624,
-0.374224633,
-0.3195234835,
0.8104635477,
0.057650011,
1.0729050636,
-0.0994576588,
0.8838248849,
-0.0316322222,
0.2682798505,
-0.8788001537,
0.2803661525,
-0.3586038053,
-0.347299248,
-0.6073889136,
-0.2754152715,
-1.1077373028,
0.1849758476,
-0.4137267768,
-0.7557721734,
-0.0318760611,
0.3879876137,
-0.3179017305,
0.1222975776,
-0.9291655421,
1.1230300665,
-0.335070312,
-0.3950473368,
0.3365631998,
-0.7314937115,
0.3232617676,
0.005424737,
0.0872406736,
-0.2220326364,
-0.2299285382,
0.6802431345,
-0.6919441223,
0.8947467804,
-0.4294966459,
-0.0963605344,
-0.0587825626,
-0.2836031914,
0.5594885349,
-0.3207239509,
0.2459009141,
-0.140140295,
-0.0593260378,
-0.3109628856,
-0.2825730741,
0.5719761252,
-0.5917853713,
-0.3312661648,
-0.4969166815,
-0.6017795801,
-0.5787511468,
0.5473416448,
0.660812676,
0.3032702506,
-0.3309889734,
-0.0157025103,
0.7385505438,
0.2298060656,
0.4912534654,
0.3798646033,
0.0355830602,
-0.3868481815,
0.6662489772,
0.138879627,
-0.0614880659,
0.6697278619,
0.3446062803,
-0.7574976683,
-0.3549442291,
-0.2781015038,
0.3780237436,
-0.1783541292,
-0.5344671011,
-0.2423663735,
0.0590276085,
-0.4636476934,
-0.4829603732,
-0.5505436063,
-0.48111552,
-0.1306864619,
-0.1941465735,
0.2590704858,
0.6056467295,
-0.0373896435,
0.5143060684,
-0.6192239523,
0.1636184007,
0.1573037356,
0.4135352373,
-0.4967769682,
-0.407528311,
-0.1215301529,
-0.1530698836,
-0.247248292,
-0.4780003428,
0.1164410412,
0.4640847147,
0.3534253538,
0.8497129083,
0.2524091899,
1.2909389734,
-0.897372365,
0.5758053064,
0.6711831689,
-1.0697751045,
0.6405473351,
-0.1838237345,
0.4046300948,
1.1209238768,
0.5351410508,
-0.3301612735,
-0.3492248654,
-0.4421401322,
-0.7864022255,
0.613807261,
-0.1468905807,
-0.1468223333,
0.2045847774,
-0.0930206552,
0.0778146982,
0.1593954414,
-0.534080565,
0.0399982743,
-0.2132478952,
-0.7080900669,
-0.3405940533,
0.1840334833,
-0.3374628425,
-0.3409686685,
0.5970171094,
-0.3053798974,
-0.0068019065,
-0.0450880863,
-0.5505358577,
-0.2127283663,
0.0504390039,
0.6603884697,
0.6514228582,
0.0989737883,
0.3261221945,
0.3639819324,
-0.4759374857,
0.1471138,
0.4797076583,
0.1324510574,
0.1041528434,
0.4297945499,
0.6271727085,
0.5067116618,
-0.4440544844,
1.1216887236,
-0.0122860791,
-0.480420053,
-0.3538309336,
-0.2473905385,
0.2638662159,
-0.0303182248,
-0.0604607277,
0.1313141733,
-0.1023699343,
0.1167374104,
0.3784403503,
0.3671045005,
-0.7183896303,
-0.253885597,
0.7247940302,
-0.1537346542,
0.25057289,
0.4821241498,
-0.2371677756,
-0.2870244384,
0.2064125985,
0.7735477686,
0.3989325762,
-0.2668008506,
0.1943302006,
0.3957490325,
0.2973439991,
-0.7220947146,
0.0816230923,
-0.0980403945,
-0.6821014285,
-0.6941205859,
-0.695825994,
-0.2570300996,
0.0128301214,
-1.0303142071,
0.47256881,
-0.3625742197,
-0.1771255732,
-0.1205497682,
-0.0259958506,
-0.6149735451,
0.2848774791,
0.3328828216,
0.9736873507,
-1.3083095551,
0.8246585727,
0.8728907704,
-0.3600916266,
-0.8869076371,
0.3123721778,
0.2199236602,
-0.8019421101,
0.2265639752,
0.4214533567,
-0.165164113,
-0.0488538556,
-0.5465085506,
-1.0376147032,
1.0907568932,
0.4984999895,
-0.7633466125,
-0.1145947725,
0.1691541374,
0.5308830738,
0.2093742937,
-0.2189705521,
0.3983328938,
0.559006393,
0.1117903367,
-0.8852789402,
0.0307299122,
-0.2463506162,
0.0351173542,
0.6249055266,
-0.5717517138,
0.4367064238,
0.0782738924,
-0.1467531621,
0.0661002323,
0.9195677638,
-0.0188656263,
0.1053552032,
0.6605506539,
1.1734417677,
1.0007053614,
-0.337448895,
0.5356369019,
-0.3008603454,
0.1088679656,
1.4254590273,
-0.5449105501,
0.9270772934,
0.603490591,
-0.1555227339,
0.43513906,
0.5993362665,
-0.0785789937,
0.6894385815,
0.2399964184,
-0.1110349,
-0.2588502169,
-0.2251430005,
-0.3484427035,
0.4718202651,
0.1757563204,
-0.034211915,
-0.2858828902,
-0.0998261124,
0.1898907423,
0.2707326114,
-0.2805041969,
0.8279485106,
0.0564968809,
-0.8369138241,
0.4197316766,
-0.3315765262,
1.0207341909,
-0.8302310705,
0.3767335713,
-0.1684990525,
0.4340635836,
-0.4493868947,
-0.640884757,
0.2230422199,
-0.0138063645,
0.1187853664,
-0.4132510722,
0.7680935264,
-0.7183536887,
-0.4639085233,
0.1239699423,
0.3908610344,
0.0019522478,
0.1470891982,
-0.5475636125,
-0.2227641195,
-0.3190258443,
0.0064769215,
0.5758748651,
0.7260580063,
0.0625816807,
0.1234771088,
0.4831843674,
0.3388273418,
0.0588669144,
0.3012323081,
0.7489075661,
-0.3048196435,
-0.4122201204,
-0.6312162876,
0.4970301986,
-0.3726525903,
-0.6402348876,
0.6888766885,
0.7917848825,
0.9503155947,
0.0546431839,
0.5438607335,
0.0912558958,
0.4621175528,
-0.3964875638,
0.6382392645,
-0.645816505,
-0.3819800913,
-0.5233968496,
-0.8623124957,
-0.5211402774,
0.5111611485,
-0.4044669867,
-0.3176823854,
0.8490633368,
0.8131420612,
-0.4293142557,
0.0318570137,
0.1441914141,
-0.3292629421,
-0.2011479884,
0.2910908461,
0.6438317299,
-0.1264969558,
0.859228909,
-0.4063782692,
-0.2568278015,
0.1282692254,
-0.8952305913,
-0.695494473,
-0.5199329257,
-0.3467352986,
-0.1308910102,
-0.0044793454,
0.7475975156,
0.7277216911,
-0.6550694108,
-0.0758927763,
-0.2794800103,
-0.2485721707,
-0.4922141731,
-0.1580226272,
0.508097291,
-0.9547672868,
-0.7688301206,
0.4299431741,
0.0833749399,
0.2574006021,
0.0950133353,
-0.0592215471,
-0.2111701071,
-0.3123862147,
0.306891948,
0.4255391061,
-0.2372287065,
-0.1155001372,
-0.0522039533,
-0.3383505046,
-0.0333454646,
0.6054882407,
-0.3496545255,
0.2620949149,
0.4126082659,
0.6116939783,
0.5138404369,
0.3560495973,
0.6952615976,
-1.0207616091,
0.3415670395,
0.0356099531,
0.6238680482,
0.3338468969,
-0.2062199265,
0.3134309649,
0.0731314123,
-0.3892336488,
-0.5588388443,
0.1848394275,
-0.8391470909,
-0.1076147705,
0.9803723097,
-0.039811369,
-0.1752365828,
0.0439016484,
-0.1353684366,
0.5121484399,
-0.2038526535,
0.6107429266,
0.5442130566,
-0.0778605342,
0.0197864193,
-0.0064126118,
0.7621957064,
0.6649575233,
-0.716775775,
-0.0583863184,
0.4412145317,
0.153966248,
0.1163488105,
0.5219465494,
-0.2759911418,
0.1220265701,
-0.0713675395,
0.1036843136,
0.0933984965,
-0.2057669908,
-0.3144383132,
0.0167545825,
0.3147669137,
-0.4866948724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05642v1 | Customizing General-Purpose Foundation Models for Medical Report Generation | 2023-06-09T03:02:36 | 2023-06-09T03:02:36 | Bang Yang, Asif Raza, Yuexian Zou, Tong Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Medical caption prediction which can be regarded as a task of medical report
generation (MRG), requires the automatic generation of coherent and accurate
captions for the given medical images. However, the scarcity of labelled
medical image-report pairs presents great challenges in the development of deep
and large-scale neural networks capable of harnessing the potential artificial
general intelligence power like large language models (LLMs). In this work, we
propose customizing off-the-shelf general-purpose large-scale pre-trained
models, i.e., foundation models (FMs), in computer vision and natural language
processing with a specific focus on medical report generation. Specifically,
following BLIP-2, a state-of-the-art vision-language pre-training approach, we
introduce our encoder-decoder-based MRG model. This model utilizes a
lightweight query Transformer to connect two FMs: the giant vision Transformer
EVA-ViT-g and a bilingual LLM trained to align with human intentions (referred
to as ChatGLM-6B). Furthermore, we conduct ablative experiments on the
trainable components of the model to identify the crucial factors for effective
transfer learning. Our findings demonstrate that unfreezing EVA-ViT-g to learn
medical image representations, followed by parameter-efficient training of
ChatGLM-6B to capture the writing styles of medical reports, is essential for
achieving optimal results. Our best attempt (PCLmed Team) achieved the 4th and
the 2nd, respectively, out of 13 participating teams, based on the BERTScore
and ROUGE-1 metrics, in the ImageCLEFmedical Caption 2023 Caption Prediction
Task competition. | [
-0.1978731602,
-0.4892116487,
0.336342752,
0.0284035336,
-0.6285666823,
-0.1045155004,
-0.2543883622,
-0.7369995117,
0.3118371367,
0.8501788974,
-0.3580547869,
-0.4717739522,
-0.8278394938,
0.2416137904,
-0.1795958877,
1.0382076502,
-0.1374343932,
0.3279784322,
-0.460223496,
-0.1563110948,
-0.4932800531,
-0.4682066441,
-0.5173574686,
-0.3848600388,
0.1832533181,
0.2878220677,
0.6095926166,
0.6773617268,
0.835734427,
0.2351164818,
0.3495495617,
0.1877421141,
-0.2451112419,
-0.124383539,
-0.1021076515,
-0.4331539869,
-0.3773926795,
-0.1325483471,
0.2649603784,
0.686785996,
-0.202872172,
0.0230271481,
-0.2300627232,
0.6775104403,
-0.4450730085,
0.3429370522,
-0.6067126393,
0.2540948093,
0.2277320623,
-0.4951813519,
-0.607986331,
-0.1771928817,
0.4113326669,
-0.5195076466,
0.4863321781,
0.1453083009,
1.0113791227,
0.3466676176,
-0.1737183928,
-0.4495794773,
-0.5020961165,
0.4289744794,
-0.625865221,
0.263374716,
0.3076610267,
0.5710757971,
0.0686924085,
-0.9145518541,
-0.1034896225,
-0.3165504634,
-0.3922109008,
0.3035102785,
-0.0819110051,
0.0982524976,
-0.1686546654,
0.3238029182,
-0.6864013672,
0.1743826717,
-0.5001943707,
-0.0914978087,
0.5533521175,
0.1849535555,
0.2622985542,
0.0523905009,
-0.3733257651,
-0.0156616457,
-0.804697454,
-0.106525518,
-0.4993001521,
0.0796941593,
-0.3533300161,
0.4502359033,
-0.1395092905,
0.7915760875,
0.2544710636,
-0.1672866046,
0.3403947949,
-0.3575186133,
-0.514962256,
0.1069726571,
0.8426995277,
0.4715209305,
0.3541918695,
-0.4071217477,
-0.2203461975,
0.0599818863,
0.4751668572,
-1.15858078,
-0.4124583304,
-0.0869394839,
-0.5566539168,
-0.5677756667,
-0.0222942475,
-0.698204577,
-0.4452977479,
-0.471028924,
0.4098196328,
-0.3386383355,
0.1099338457,
0.3389682472,
0.1364237964,
0.1029387712,
0.3885597885,
-0.973805964,
0.277821213,
-0.0070389276,
0.6423342228,
-0.3252209723,
0.0925497785,
-0.6251030564,
0.3706059456,
-0.4394468367,
0.7182955146,
-0.5359123349,
-0.4464170635,
0.0320738479,
0.0172060113,
-0.1813217402,
-0.5849128366,
0.101675421,
-0.3486497104,
0.3368346691,
0.1250086278,
-0.2895047069,
-0.062057849,
0.2485226393,
-0.5096836686,
0.2729759216,
0.3245968521,
-0.6106364727,
0.3176009059,
-0.6593948007,
-0.8354051113,
0.2557583153,
-0.5037412047,
-0.607853353,
0.2301772684,
0.5268192887,
0.7380561233,
-0.6105428338,
0.4472741485,
0.2760297656,
-0.3738131821,
0.2128626406,
-0.1285512745,
0.3761518598,
-0.0584460981,
-0.4367287755,
0.3499819338,
-0.6938224435,
-0.1535037607,
0.2880010605,
-0.4381472468,
0.1353013366,
-0.1495943815,
-0.0327358283,
-0.0128062535,
0.0373502299,
-0.3579354286,
0.020972427,
-0.5145423412,
0.453379035,
0.3260858953,
0.0068537761,
0.4271847308,
-0.2682819664,
0.7279317975,
0.0327120833,
0.1888688505,
-0.5003145933,
-0.4237779081,
-0.5734785795,
-0.3561160564,
0.3491509259,
0.5694410205,
-0.7728705406,
0.2742676139,
-0.3617224097,
-0.3365338743,
-0.5617589355,
-0.0474145897,
0.5025017262,
0.9346535206,
0.5317900181,
-0.4399916232,
-0.5914846659,
-1.1017022133,
0.0936399996,
-0.0138271283,
-0.0280916393,
0.4879902005,
0.4477284551,
-0.4536448121,
0.7801736593,
-0.5474354029,
-0.6283264756,
-0.3953884542,
-0.015672531,
0.1622711122,
0.4394341111,
0.8675403595,
-0.9258860946,
-0.5269728899,
0.1441506147,
-0.7021212578,
0.0235969517,
-0.1420522779,
0.0160319898,
0.3822180927,
0.6056621671,
-0.6362059712,
0.5683086514,
0.6182194948,
-0.2467600852,
0.7467525601,
-0.3715228438,
0.2525354326,
-1.1615999937,
0.2791293561,
0.019015383,
-0.2430243641,
-0.5021853447,
0.0844009072,
0.0761520192,
-0.2011502832,
-0.3828069568,
0.5602981448,
-0.4952870905,
0.153713882,
-0.1458177716,
-0.2982762158,
0.0970319957,
0.353539288,
0.2494153827,
0.4815297723,
0.6531782746,
-0.410356462,
0.2578081489,
0.4354617596,
-0.2551579177,
0.4183419049,
-0.636941433,
-0.0198389646,
-0.2830385864,
0.3382848203,
-0.9886417389,
-0.6007428169,
0.3219662309,
-0.5312384963,
0.661616683,
-0.2340093851,
-0.3932404518,
-0.5704709291,
0.0671930164,
0.1630752534,
0.7339087725,
-0.5231363177,
0.8576877117,
0.2321372777,
-0.2473647892,
-0.4178866744,
-1.106718421,
0.3105893433,
0.0641500875,
-0.591455996,
0.5507887602,
-0.0297539961,
0.1425349116,
0.0741460323,
0.0206648167,
-0.2803129554,
-0.1653920859,
0.4352088273,
0.5272849798,
-0.4758670926,
0.0951050073,
0.0425443873,
-0.0150244348,
0.1554671973,
-0.0973075405,
0.3539856672,
-0.1197298765,
-0.0984811783,
-0.2662207782,
0.217550531,
0.6991689801,
-0.6381903887,
0.6358274817,
0.3913038373,
-0.5221672654,
-0.0865373835,
-0.5222008824,
-0.2697829902,
-0.4543539584,
0.6057673097,
-0.1143382415,
-0.8447656035,
0.24089773,
-0.0895994827,
-0.00834917,
0.3393316865,
0.6313592196,
-0.0494226478,
0.8406008482,
0.671420753,
-0.0120048616,
0.1070253775,
-0.2985203266,
-0.1148712486,
-0.5079174042,
-0.3915871978,
-0.2409044355,
-0.1408671439,
-0.0179993007,
-0.4075510204,
0.3961521983,
-0.0802499652,
0.1103010625,
0.0211894382,
-0.6839976311,
0.6334806085,
0.0958074406,
0.2228622586,
0.2830792069,
0.3374914527,
-0.084855698,
0.0933720618,
-0.718031168,
-0.1732271314,
1.1799322367,
0.1333295405,
0.6435338855,
-0.2628686428,
0.588280797,
0.0629643872,
0.7787541747,
-0.6525781751,
0.3510227501,
-0.7608135343,
-0.3767766953,
-0.1214456856,
-0.3181395829,
-0.9008064866,
0.2947832048,
-0.4309601188,
-0.3687024713,
-0.0676871985,
0.3356397748,
-0.4251393676,
0.2183238715,
-0.6624912024,
0.7982649207,
-0.2755325735,
0.000636966,
-0.2062026262,
-0.8716082573,
0.4133324027,
-0.1527381092,
0.1457899958,
0.3023985624,
0.1647817343,
0.4516852498,
-0.1734103709,
1.0088351965,
-0.2011953294,
0.2206114829,
0.2061793357,
-0.0172662623,
0.3071351647,
-0.0522142462,
0.152075842,
-0.0457567349,
-0.3243157268,
-0.0957853124,
-0.2379731089,
0.3897486627,
-0.5720677376,
-0.5426772833,
-0.1358481944,
-0.5374317765,
-0.327722162,
0.2463391572,
0.6911219358,
0.645436883,
-0.3310883641,
0.3796485662,
0.6827459335,
-0.3058177233,
0.2535410821,
0.5578731894,
-0.1810695827,
-0.5937097669,
0.6828977466,
-0.0365741067,
0.1675159335,
0.4931433797,
0.3258600533,
-0.1538890898,
-0.8649214506,
-0.7548676133,
0.4159310162,
-0.6439218521,
-0.4740645289,
-0.517624259,
-0.4017011523,
-0.2297444046,
-0.5216288567,
-0.2599976659,
-0.0650556758,
-0.5527361035,
0.0642661825,
0.1987206638,
0.6379607916,
0.3194147944,
0.3860443532,
-0.8217751384,
0.5142533779,
0.060917113,
0.3958256543,
-0.1289608032,
-0.5358350873,
-0.3487149775,
-0.1317514628,
-0.0994537622,
-0.6529259682,
0.3970475197,
0.2612985075,
0.4567173719,
0.4198673069,
-0.1524922103,
0.3923419416,
-0.7093297243,
0.5131231546,
0.7348458767,
-0.4347756803,
0.6673019528,
-0.232392624,
0.2031158209,
0.5366193056,
0.2571943402,
-0.133300975,
-0.3015506268,
-0.3356587291,
-0.6340277791,
0.4775726199,
-0.0911786854,
0.1005501971,
0.093993105,
0.5192096829,
0.3007934988,
0.2532547116,
-0.4394330382,
0.116834864,
-0.3102530241,
-0.4132539034,
-0.1674049944,
-0.0513183512,
-0.2322669625,
-0.2890260816,
0.1525498927,
-0.3870330155,
0.1708082855,
0.3814866245,
-0.1698511541,
-0.2187368125,
0.1337101758,
0.6308510303,
0.7292968035,
-0.1866754293,
-0.0491996408,
-0.1183043197,
-0.6221148372,
0.0800156295,
0.1978158653,
-0.0367009006,
0.1495949328,
0.3775193393,
0.9600035548,
0.1172183976,
-0.7534513474,
0.686683476,
-0.0196208879,
-0.6222597361,
-0.2269191593,
0.0392799415,
0.1901492327,
-0.0739410073,
0.3722336888,
0.3297721148,
0.0868788287,
-0.4121961892,
0.2547281086,
0.2691684067,
-0.3691046238,
-0.3311935663,
0.7871305346,
0.354552716,
-0.0029956799,
0.6230905652,
0.0259481035,
-0.3861823976,
0.8118225336,
0.8313292861,
0.6967384815,
-0.3252412379,
0.3454244137,
0.257383287,
0.2860741019,
-0.3024309874,
-0.025130216,
0.3639932871,
-0.5535128117,
-0.6158501506,
-0.5926421285,
-0.2945758998,
0.2716842294,
-0.5530208945,
0.303391099,
-0.6529259086,
-0.041706007,
0.0269417036,
-0.3540407121,
-0.8177170753,
0.6340545416,
0.1690596938,
0.770078361,
-0.603327632,
0.5960350037,
0.8954603672,
-0.3218868971,
-0.5846132636,
-0.2756621838,
-0.249106586,
-0.8103110194,
0.5554287434,
0.4711582363,
0.0337878987,
-0.1053656489,
-0.59258008,
-0.4527420402,
1.1212613583,
0.5325981975,
-0.7433801293,
-0.3146117926,
0.325826019,
0.6638852954,
-0.9071726203,
-0.2248707116,
0.4581884146,
0.1790541261,
0.2832781374,
-0.9169828892,
0.2527482808,
-0.1681305468,
-0.1752289683,
0.0527319275,
-0.4793304205,
0.5941320658,
-0.6326647401,
-0.0615605079,
0.2150872201,
0.2748296559,
0.2847753167,
0.2006458044,
0.3844892681,
0.4571253955,
0.498200655,
0.0522458665,
1.2941939831,
-0.126847133,
-0.1769340038,
1.042044282,
-0.0124954851,
0.6783679724,
0.2975537479,
0.1124704108,
0.3687566519,
0.2734378874,
-0.4637008607,
0.630804956,
0.2519491911,
0.0796062946,
-0.2561146021,
0.0408989526,
-0.3776433766,
0.3971502781,
0.4013931453,
-0.8528687358,
0.0203304905,
0.2285031527,
-0.267571032,
0.030848939,
-0.4452440143,
0.6984237432,
0.1044379771,
-0.5911747813,
0.6789280772,
-0.0852617249,
0.6089911461,
-0.6314588785,
-0.0882022381,
-0.1054991186,
0.1230270267,
-0.3179754615,
-0.5121148229,
0.238563627,
-0.1145096049,
-0.3086360097,
-0.0049083591,
0.8305900693,
-0.4933215678,
-0.6400689483,
0.1502973139,
0.3585815132,
-0.0627870858,
-0.0613935068,
-0.4934485257,
-0.1463871002,
0.1298061013,
-0.1203961149,
0.4438199401,
0.1646515727,
-0.0116409436,
0.6138370037,
0.5756843686,
0.2664809227,
-0.1012605503,
0.2086618692,
0.8685749173,
-0.374465555,
-0.640730083,
-0.5898557901,
0.5453509092,
0.1514236182,
-0.185358569,
-0.0520179234,
0.6215574145,
0.390912503,
-0.5972554088,
0.8690434098,
0.1366500705,
0.2321305573,
-0.6300927997,
1.0566239357,
-0.5111737251,
-0.1018084139,
0.0348536968,
-0.6320341229,
-0.6154862642,
0.445567131,
0.0527997427,
-0.1526793838,
0.6368166208,
0.5636245608,
-0.0459140241,
-0.1085646152,
0.3204891682,
0.1148749143,
0.3232580125,
0.6883349419,
0.3640092313,
-0.1980339736,
0.8312102556,
-0.0628734156,
-0.3523131311,
-0.4589468539,
-0.5797584653,
-1.1942552328,
-0.3450888097,
-0.4701188505,
-0.2140155435,
0.2080465704,
0.5351681709,
0.7452730536,
-0.7401628494,
0.0311096273,
-0.0275839232,
-0.5397143364,
0.1136758551,
-0.1604958773,
0.6060166955,
-0.3128579557,
-0.1971786171,
0.2678322196,
0.3162362576,
0.3702573478,
-0.0612383746,
-0.1467631757,
0.262601465,
-0.0703997612,
0.612082839,
0.138064146,
-0.6388152242,
-0.1247820631,
0.0740704611,
-0.246316269,
0.3366690874,
0.7946092486,
-0.8266144991,
0.4080837667,
0.0703528896,
0.8435982466,
0.5568422079,
-0.0100542018,
0.6022301912,
-0.6266263723,
0.0648950413,
0.2902169228,
0.378118366,
0.5200680494,
-0.416107595,
0.6796140671,
0.1827503145,
-0.3419199288,
-0.6801675558,
0.1021118984,
-0.9176399708,
-0.4516689777,
0.9397295713,
-0.1551216692,
-0.135588333,
0.2365390062,
-0.3296061456,
0.144339487,
-0.0640464202,
0.7306399941,
0.4149567783,
-0.2524378598,
-0.2989901006,
-0.3560291529,
0.5245292187,
0.2849709392,
-0.9494397044,
-0.1007075533,
0.5198982358,
0.4929196537,
0.2595915794,
0.5793088078,
-0.4671602547,
0.6068617702,
-0.2631996572,
0.1273079813,
-0.4354585409,
-0.4070042372,
-0.2382031828,
0.2367002368,
-0.2490911782,
-0.154307723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05617v1 | Low-rank Adaptation Method for Wav2vec2-based Fake Audio Detection | 2023-06-09T01:43:41 | 2023-06-09T01:43:41 | Chenglong Wang, Jiangyan Yi, Xiaohui Zhang, Jianhua Tao, Le Xu, Ruibo Fu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Self-supervised speech models are a rapidly developing research topic in fake
audio detection. Many pre-trained models can serve as feature extractors,
learning richer and higher-level speech features. However,when fine-tuning
pre-trained models, there is often a challenge of excessively long training
times and high memory consumption, and complete fine-tuning is also very
expensive. To alleviate this problem, we apply low-rank adaptation(LoRA) to the
wav2vec2 model, freezing the pre-trained model weights and injecting a
trainable rank-decomposition matrix into each layer of the transformer
architecture, greatly reducing the number of trainable parameters for
downstream tasks. Compared with fine-tuning with Adam on the wav2vec2 model
containing 317M training parameters, LoRA achieved similar performance by
reducing the number of trainable parameters by 198 times. | [
-0.3494131267,
-0.681876421,
0.2853925228,
-0.0604022183,
-0.2958190739,
-0.0649992526,
0.1261121631,
-0.5830967426,
0.0868021697,
0.5639435649,
-0.5083170533,
-0.0661782026,
-0.7356345654,
-0.3499028683,
-0.505628109,
0.6758093834,
0.2968508303,
-0.0282877367,
-0.0175404586,
-0.1345282197,
-0.6937414408,
-0.2128769606,
-0.8885123134,
-0.0899322852,
0.3718577027,
0.5715934038,
0.2996448874,
0.5036639571,
0.0584570169,
0.2509150207,
0.074136354,
0.1482731551,
-0.7718650699,
-0.1795128733,
-0.0420329981,
-0.5963574648,
-0.7409443259,
0.2347639054,
0.4458208382,
-0.0344117172,
-0.2019823343,
0.550711453,
0.0539944731,
0.3946865797,
-0.665035367,
-0.056650538,
-0.9738883972,
-0.1358895302,
-0.1004686505,
-0.5092425942,
-0.4444070458,
-0.1016138718,
-0.1648001373,
-0.6707530022,
0.1330207735,
-0.0175934322,
0.6146287322,
0.7569652796,
-0.1040441617,
0.048969239,
-1.114038229,
0.7003570199,
-0.8266746402,
0.2672046423,
0.636123836,
0.5452302098,
0.0728029907,
-0.6534429789,
-0.6492908597,
0.2604598999,
0.4201840162,
0.4155611992,
-0.5920440555,
-0.2753678858,
0.1739900112,
0.1025995463,
-0.3847211003,
0.6359380484,
-0.5410324335,
-0.3458200693,
0.5434657335,
-0.2802802622,
0.079097189,
-0.155440852,
-0.3321517706,
-0.1863471419,
-0.4331775904,
0.1706065983,
0.5517171621,
0.4634599388,
-0.1769557893,
0.1805341095,
-0.1174632609,
0.2271419317,
0.3641867042,
-0.4377760589,
0.4061695337,
-0.057792794,
-0.2542104721,
0.4496453404,
0.3685735762,
-0.0633163378,
0.2594335675,
0.2391345799,
-0.142763406,
0.2245386541,
0.4616316557,
-0.8320956826,
-0.4415529966,
0.2685611546,
-0.5283431411,
-0.4651824534,
-0.2966619134,
-0.4462898672,
0.0230352245,
-0.2898027301,
1.1340813637,
-0.2072004676,
-0.3259475529,
-0.2073934376,
-0.0660288706,
0.4236135781,
0.3789971769,
-0.7203782201,
0.5949620008,
0.437196523,
0.6914981008,
-0.2221192867,
-0.0155763943,
-1.1910854578,
0.0560572855,
-0.2877219319,
0.9513184428,
-0.0881458819,
-0.2170295566,
-0.3739939332,
0.0276921671,
0.0249087196,
-0.7543094754,
0.6728584766,
-0.3834786117,
0.2438157052,
0.0035643056,
-0.2567822635,
0.1351593733,
-0.2859674096,
-0.4074128866,
1.3269052505,
0.2160289437,
-0.4145466685,
0.3831622005,
-0.7184299231,
-0.4965368807,
0.0282395463,
0.2584997416,
-0.7014625072,
0.1649568379,
0.4865559936,
0.3420809805,
0.1253478974,
-0.4033118188,
-0.1298384815,
-0.6560454369,
-0.0847364739,
-0.4698710442,
0.5204116702,
0.1661523879,
-0.4043952525,
0.0461300462,
-0.9898281693,
-0.0311953351,
0.2691346705,
-0.3326420784,
-0.3740723133,
0.1533540487,
0.1040314808,
0.2563914359,
-0.0691486597,
-0.4706209004,
-0.0468899794,
-0.7403315306,
0.5362868309,
0.7693672776,
-0.1049750149,
0.3945428729,
-0.1726202667,
0.2667394578,
0.1772955954,
0.2247278839,
0.2006962597,
-0.4932979047,
-0.9436989427,
-0.554764986,
0.3636094928,
0.6798841357,
-0.5384730101,
0.6117383838,
-0.2413824648,
-0.4639252424,
-0.9091048837,
0.1829683483,
0.3256136477,
0.5830389261,
0.8890281916,
-0.1550031304,
-0.4434637725,
-0.8682050109,
-0.1847541928,
0.0082060434,
-0.2833540142,
0.3303705156,
0.5500656962,
-0.0584368259,
1.004966259,
-0.2715565562,
-0.8452939987,
0.0657551289,
0.1787363291,
0.1412974596,
0.6378744245,
0.6464330554,
-0.598962009,
-0.2344781309,
-0.4153522849,
-0.2525885999,
-0.0536293574,
0.1514183134,
0.0489829145,
0.2747519612,
0.5782347322,
-0.1768915206,
0.6303194165,
0.7530978918,
0.0110512953,
0.1898845881,
-0.4267752767,
0.0503403433,
-1.2261419296,
-0.2246730477,
-0.1132654846,
-0.5903555155,
-0.6332967281,
-0.5283783674,
-0.157213062,
-0.2881003916,
-0.6000896692,
0.3665389717,
-0.2559764981,
-0.3046081066,
-0.5428931713,
0.1519963443,
-0.053529799,
0.4308212101,
-0.0662940592,
0.7091966867,
0.4090457559,
-0.4721711874,
0.1431416422,
0.3503571749,
-0.4147619903,
0.513664782,
-0.595213294,
0.5357521772,
0.1046336442,
0.4064382315,
-1.1044750214,
-0.0950322002,
0.3036462069,
-0.5513180494,
0.1274698228,
-0.9241125584,
-0.3724030554,
-0.2894834578,
-0.1120094806,
0.5458319187,
0.9983433485,
-0.9213216305,
0.668241024,
0.4479777217,
-0.0891431794,
-0.1669614762,
-0.7375998497,
-0.2923339307,
-0.2298991233,
-0.3701581657,
0.5000032187,
-0.059338402,
0.1386054307,
-0.251293093,
-0.4272067845,
-0.0557392836,
0.1978870928,
0.4062629342,
0.0403520428,
-0.4781019986,
-0.1641018242,
0.3065295219,
-0.2790100276,
-0.0355047472,
-0.2355849296,
0.3653706312,
0.2545701861,
-0.3368567824,
-0.9439498782,
0.1444583684,
0.5867339969,
-0.0491926223,
0.4498255849,
0.8097471595,
-0.4912550747,
-0.6713843346,
-0.6724900007,
-0.2339319587,
-0.537953794,
0.3422164619,
-0.3915298879,
-0.6486717463,
0.3287702203,
-0.067598924,
-0.4322137237,
0.4592459798,
0.4404908717,
-0.4822298586,
0.9440439343,
0.3857193291,
-0.2857047915,
0.2866739929,
-0.1399651468,
0.2352877706,
-0.7164686918,
-0.1393238306,
-0.5659557581,
-0.3498912454,
-0.5476821065,
-0.7192504406,
0.4687206447,
0.1408906877,
-0.0156654082,
0.388708353,
-0.6466316581,
0.3825418055,
0.598539114,
0.1389869452,
0.1528695822,
0.2759237587,
0.5127214789,
-0.0253434889,
-0.5248554945,
-0.0528978072,
0.8170449734,
0.5133135915,
0.5536006689,
0.2406852692,
0.5365399718,
0.6800994277,
-0.1729279906,
-0.9645571709,
0.284622848,
-0.3299047649,
-0.2987056971,
-0.5466342568,
-0.1508210748,
-0.8282964826,
0.1862581968,
-0.4135315418,
-0.6295025945,
0.3113981485,
0.4293156266,
-0.4286646247,
0.2034887969,
-0.5881639123,
0.4839661121,
-0.0713840723,
-0.0081637902,
-0.394100368,
-0.2803592086,
0.1874476373,
-0.2770243585,
0.3964650929,
-0.2598903477,
0.4407312572,
1.1829118729,
-0.4840559661,
0.6368986964,
-0.6802068949,
-0.2258452773,
0.3614903688,
0.0764537528,
0.775891006,
0.0346626081,
0.0904451534,
0.2895694971,
0.2936672568,
-0.4715853035,
-0.4860847592,
0.686481297,
-1.0925291777,
-0.4938170612,
-0.1651173681,
-0.2447827011,
-0.5182096958,
0.0141806556,
0.4095962346,
0.5217173696,
-0.1305919588,
0.0766980797,
0.6397839189,
-0.1011979431,
0.5034095049,
0.429320991,
-0.000677644,
-0.3529855311,
1.0437597036,
0.229987517,
0.1255209744,
0.0408579297,
0.2806740105,
-0.1042342409,
-0.8650993705,
-0.1466963589,
0.0130935358,
-0.494802177,
-0.1051852629,
-0.4463863969,
-0.4310139418,
-0.697319746,
0.0671052411,
-0.9987043142,
-0.4206339121,
-0.5653586984,
0.203529954,
0.4211914241,
0.4136819839,
-0.0687404796,
0.5798297524,
-0.3916974962,
0.9522963762,
0.6041556597,
0.1599898487,
-0.1662302017,
-1.546628356,
-0.1662279963,
-0.0307370778,
0.1823461354,
-0.3765941858,
0.346682936,
0.265224129,
0.4662860632,
0.4275445342,
0.136539638,
0.8423751593,
-0.4334612489,
0.5538042188,
0.0706898049,
-0.9769710302,
0.7855317593,
-0.3943061233,
0.161181733,
0.413158983,
-0.0581408739,
0.0298934225,
0.1481485814,
-0.4208268821,
-0.7418431044,
0.8895824552,
0.4134111106,
0.393348515,
0.4932754934,
0.3511137962,
-0.0151419519,
-0.34381935,
-0.6543294191,
-0.36759305,
-0.7659689188,
-0.0162572749,
-0.1816544533,
-0.5331116319,
-0.1926722229,
-0.4860272408,
0.8849228621,
-0.3181745112,
0.4619956315,
0.0370782241,
-0.4045166671,
-0.0794316754,
0.3115995824,
0.7246373892,
0.2869969606,
-0.3782708049,
-0.0983636752,
0.5167405009,
-0.334872961,
0.1681919843,
-0.1661584675,
0.1377345771,
-0.2401923537,
0.292896688,
0.938051939,
0.2758211493,
-0.1449114233,
0.7983235717,
0.1457382292,
-0.4475223124,
-0.7006003261,
0.3338595927,
-0.000751217,
0.2835632265,
0.6573989987,
0.2914507389,
0.0305401944,
-0.4093584418,
0.1243227348,
0.1800710261,
-0.6418033838,
-0.3179838955,
0.7063403726,
0.2297809869,
-0.5581434369,
0.4508385062,
0.1088592783,
-0.1633225083,
0.3726398349,
0.7850381136,
0.6315391064,
-0.5688299537,
0.0339710563,
0.2388504744,
0.2072864622,
-0.1076221913,
0.147935003,
-0.0439452045,
-0.7014353275,
-0.3589484394,
-0.7438860536,
-0.0444175415,
0.5858736634,
-0.8548221588,
0.348829329,
-0.5017803311,
-0.0403455533,
0.0957586616,
-0.2621012926,
-0.511408329,
0.2756364644,
0.4681415856,
0.7884578705,
-0.9442317486,
1.3161226511,
0.0610461608,
-0.1481876224,
-0.7812949419,
-0.0257209819,
0.10311535,
-0.8289596438,
0.6563984156,
-0.0723022148,
-0.619692862,
0.3061085939,
-0.6064526439,
-0.950158596,
1.0546789169,
0.307610631,
-0.5713650584,
0.006425506,
0.1216684505,
0.552999258,
-0.4009664357,
-0.0544018,
0.5879833102,
0.4970351458,
0.0782923028,
-0.9690906405,
-0.2531341016,
-0.0613607913,
-0.1199754849,
-0.2776542604,
-0.5711766481,
0.6420953274,
0.0197892785,
-0.0543688461,
0.1792313308,
0.7215440869,
0.0358045585,
0.2548730373,
0.9281592369,
0.3885003924,
0.6872268915,
0.131759882,
0.5169697404,
0.1374724358,
0.2093315721,
1.3693677187,
-0.2877711058,
1.2010912895,
0.4848216772,
-0.0916119665,
0.6580008864,
0.3192678988,
-0.3703729808,
0.7587962151,
0.1328890175,
0.1284946948,
-0.4876936972,
0.1532642692,
-0.4348448813,
1.0199095011,
0.272718519,
-0.0837741718,
0.2387035787,
0.307990253,
-0.1793259382,
-0.1460880637,
-0.4790744185,
0.8714032769,
-0.0377836339,
-0.2105977088,
0.7937485576,
-0.1049019396,
0.6838639379,
-0.2130238861,
0.002394709,
0.0027470021,
0.1893146336,
-0.234983623,
-0.0763146281,
0.0413161628,
-0.0217041131,
-0.4379766583,
0.0018278076,
0.7954109907,
-0.0547009185,
-0.4523777962,
0.5856645703,
0.4524413049,
0.1703270078,
-0.3144061863,
-0.5397408009,
0.0468213372,
-0.3124856949,
-0.3232544959,
0.4604153633,
-0.1321135163,
-0.0133266812,
0.5289766788,
1.0372760296,
0.1452522427,
0.0414757207,
0.2427865863,
0.6685155034,
-0.4639821053,
-0.6580133438,
-0.3681538403,
0.3499917686,
0.1692218333,
0.0934469923,
0.4820578694,
0.6123825908,
0.738433063,
-0.1532464176,
0.7564982176,
0.2808932066,
0.7551642656,
-0.8089379072,
0.930582583,
-0.7213736773,
0.3632953465,
-0.2788446546,
-0.8954607248,
0.106237337,
0.4862333834,
-0.0382000543,
0.1061753035,
0.3962097168,
0.8593975306,
-0.5231437683,
-0.5011605024,
0.6708039641,
0.5565788746,
0.0159500986,
0.168563664,
0.7715771794,
-1.042475462,
0.6452614069,
-0.1305324882,
-0.0981476083,
-0.5012035966,
-0.6481081843,
-0.9619178772,
-0.4864944518,
-0.5876232982,
-0.4987292588,
0.0348386392,
0.6353314519,
1.2910625935,
-1.0393562317,
0.1825310886,
0.4355775416,
-0.2170152217,
-0.3097985685,
-0.238346383,
0.4596777558,
0.2369122058,
-0.7457949519,
1.2146395445,
0.2138881981,
-0.0181487147,
-0.0146064274,
-0.1284379959,
-0.0345971808,
0.4476294816,
0.54489398,
0.4060565531,
-0.8720630407,
-0.7228631973,
-0.5855873823,
0.1364480555,
0.5014973879,
0.5017917752,
-0.9732589126,
0.2343990952,
0.3322871327,
0.1801144332,
0.9886663556,
0.2825530767,
-0.1007499322,
-0.6980495453,
0.336327374,
-0.047563877,
0.1825357825,
0.0564310253,
-0.2872973979,
0.0839836672,
0.458547771,
-0.4098210335,
-1.0579750538,
-0.0020241798,
-1.523911953,
-0.4002819061,
0.9744454026,
0.1859904081,
-0.1790435314,
-0.281454742,
-0.1454230398,
0.4657494724,
-0.3433766663,
0.7068153024,
-0.0323290303,
-0.194652155,
-0.1974074394,
-0.5658342242,
0.6661058068,
0.2896483243,
-0.837503016,
-0.1126148403,
0.1872443259,
0.7945774794,
0.0800438076,
0.5528827906,
0.052689217,
0.3505663276,
-0.0113207716,
0.0823684335,
-0.3645048141,
-0.4030322433,
-0.524620533,
0.2379373461,
0.1142699942,
-0.2598621845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05609v1 | Word sense extension | 2023-06-09T00:54:21 | 2023-06-09T00:54:21 | Lei Yu, Yang Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans often make creative use of words to express novel senses. A
long-standing effort in natural language processing has been focusing on word
sense disambiguation (WSD), but little has been explored about how the sense
inventory of a word may be extended toward novel meanings. We present a
paradigm of word sense extension (WSE) that enables words to spawn new senses
toward novel context. We develop a framework that simulates novel word sense
extension by first partitioning a polysemous word type into two pseudo-tokens
that mark its different senses, and then inferring whether the meaning of a
pseudo-token can be extended to convey the sense denoted by the token
partitioned from the same word type. Our framework combines cognitive models of
chaining with a learning scheme that transforms a language model embedding
space to support various types of word sense extension. We evaluate our
framework against several competitive baselines and show that it is superior in
predicting plausible novel senses for over 7,500 English words. Furthermore, we
show that our WSE framework improves performance over a range of
transformer-based WSD models in predicting rare word senses with few or zero
mentions in the training data. | [
-0.5347194672,
-0.5546598434,
0.4859464169,
-0.1501827538,
-0.3900025487,
0.0718262866,
-0.3472890556,
-0.6332969069,
0.3882872164,
-0.0677843019,
-0.5718230009,
-0.2969726324,
-0.5585069656,
0.0675333515,
-0.342379421,
0.7268978357,
0.1629908234,
-0.3996391892,
-0.0312041715,
-0.4693927169,
-0.442094326,
-0.197596699,
-0.0781669617,
-0.3749068379,
0.6942422986,
0.1229473054,
0.6542639136,
0.3971827626,
0.2083956897,
0.2763471603,
-0.1206433997,
0.2838698328,
-0.2395928055,
-0.1320134848,
-0.7080398202,
-0.582828939,
-0.2633908987,
0.110721916,
0.2590744793,
1.160888195,
-0.2006605268,
-0.1125795171,
0.0380421914,
0.3503873646,
-0.7437425852,
-0.2349552661,
-0.8871885538,
-0.1248114407,
-0.0312378071,
0.0185591616,
-0.2744290829,
0.1871487647,
0.5467578769,
-0.7315011621,
0.1881937832,
0.0735682026,
0.8459409475,
-0.2248030007,
-0.4545448422,
-0.0880422816,
-0.4269164205,
0.5414276719,
-0.5320422053,
0.6534401774,
0.0628521293,
0.0843120515,
-0.0943982452,
-0.8408606052,
-1.0132694244,
-0.2403975576,
0.0864550546,
0.0797529742,
-0.0735318735,
0.186376527,
0.2133698165,
0.4616179764,
-0.4019158781,
-0.0447741859,
-0.308652252,
-0.0568320341,
0.461017549,
0.1624289751,
0.3069314361,
-0.0792195424,
-0.7669597864,
-0.3475601971,
-0.4685379863,
0.2242837399,
0.1873769313,
0.2946086228,
0.1639490277,
0.5067109466,
-0.0183875021,
0.9590233564,
-0.2170028836,
0.1054697484,
0.4233273268,
-0.1344967335,
-0.0610295013,
-0.332084924,
0.3018038273,
0.6239351034,
-0.0446798429,
-0.3608877957,
-0.3433318138,
0.6805730462,
0.1998175532,
-0.4299133718,
-0.1834972948,
-0.1489309818,
-0.4313569367,
-0.2981788814,
0.2724314034,
-0.435435921,
-0.3527729809,
-0.5134930611,
0.6602213979,
-0.9320374131,
-0.5154126287,
0.5547460318,
-1.0707583427,
0.1935862154,
-0.0058658053,
-0.7621728778,
0.3615241945,
0.6501401067,
0.5938239098,
-0.576154232,
-0.6344715953,
-0.3020352721,
0.2176085413,
-0.3517839313,
0.8524115086,
-0.7141396403,
-0.4913625419,
-0.0248526223,
0.238480106,
-0.1498109549,
-0.3778990507,
0.2836515903,
-0.5662873983,
0.3996633887,
-0.3644745946,
-0.7640378475,
-0.3656639457,
0.2406072915,
-0.5307406187,
0.8201741576,
0.3412879407,
-0.5726414919,
0.8687131405,
-0.8666626215,
-0.5711246729,
0.6247082353,
-0.0842972994,
0.4474889934,
0.7662938237,
-0.0950172395,
0.0120081939,
0.0267600548,
0.1465279907,
-0.33599177,
-0.3530317545,
0.222697556,
-0.2659063041,
0.2689707577,
0.1237984374,
0.0779883564,
-0.0692740157,
-0.8164131641,
0.1084856167,
-0.0553283319,
-0.1407597363,
-1.107873559,
-0.0954937488,
0.2183431089,
0.0437820889,
0.4315622449,
-0.7176734209,
0.3827864826,
-0.8130558133,
0.4799357951,
0.5271304846,
0.0010151451,
0.6862126589,
-0.2816098034,
0.7027553916,
0.2384595722,
-0.1391969323,
-0.3617545664,
-0.4782090187,
-0.5190646648,
-0.2765845358,
0.2171933204,
0.2545510828,
-0.960447669,
0.5877308249,
-0.4627135396,
-0.3011437953,
-0.1694093794,
-0.0921511352,
-0.0555980727,
0.2862714529,
0.3090424538,
-0.3144474626,
-0.4826773107,
-0.7536293864,
-0.7967528105,
-0.2059299499,
-0.4490276873,
0.0415578336,
0.3582279384,
-0.3779304326,
1.4578852654,
-0.7891103625,
-0.1720217913,
-0.3458174467,
0.0967154354,
0.235986352,
0.10469044,
0.3085151613,
-0.8165057302,
0.2636119127,
-0.1401817501,
-0.3362367749,
0.237682566,
-0.0876204967,
0.0337865576,
-0.2322011441,
0.3671175241,
-0.4571787417,
0.3660344183,
0.5256724358,
-0.462883234,
0.6816421151,
-0.0470184721,
-0.4253009558,
-1.285081625,
-0.0659030676,
-0.027662646,
0.1128561795,
-0.5050207376,
0.4078177512,
-0.0228044,
-0.062445838,
-0.3490050733,
0.8514835835,
-0.4862764478,
0.1706394702,
-0.6788563132,
0.1837992221,
0.3883307874,
0.2996877134,
0.2158116996,
0.6059549451,
0.4306185246,
-0.685113132,
0.3451077342,
0.1697358638,
-0.6703762412,
0.3895077109,
-0.5535754561,
-0.1628187746,
-0.2825293839,
0.0869357437,
-0.9163770676,
0.037723463,
-0.332639426,
-0.411025703,
-0.018055385,
0.2502962649,
-0.1861080229,
-0.8890736699,
-0.3227950335,
0.5684422851,
0.4242773354,
-0.9002260566,
0.6889141202,
0.2227830589,
0.3558362126,
-0.1438551843,
-0.7302668691,
0.2074748725,
-0.4202148914,
-0.408716321,
0.5484288931,
0.0688125715,
-0.1226378828,
0.23080495,
-0.0922550261,
0.0620045476,
0.1432681978,
0.0800608993,
0.2066228986,
-0.0736697838,
0.4021748602,
0.2740072012,
0.0228222758,
-0.1055780128,
-0.7810083628,
0.4422471523,
-0.1987930238,
-0.3754514158,
0.4491886497,
0.4895775318,
0.4491858184,
-0.2863138616,
0.5844718218,
0.4677596688,
-0.6598710418,
-0.5645497441,
-0.1752258837,
-0.6023223996,
-0.5716898441,
0.5042325258,
-0.9343357682,
-0.9024567008,
0.252684623,
-0.5595902205,
0.0532523096,
0.2513180077,
0.1522727013,
-0.0388971977,
0.6215261817,
0.8816908598,
0.0750920177,
0.4014187753,
-0.1725424528,
0.6289945841,
-1.0663809776,
0.1276860386,
0.1219685301,
-0.522533536,
-0.49532637,
-0.5077861547,
0.2537306547,
0.4185704291,
0.4355804622,
0.7656015754,
-0.3793705404,
0.4338649213,
0.4465605915,
0.0912717134,
0.2081425339,
0.1807956845,
-0.8316666484,
-0.019704489,
-0.8152828217,
-0.2752724886,
0.6738510728,
0.2927702069,
0.4852135479,
0.082839638,
0.4437095523,
0.3118989766,
0.2474043369,
-1.0795170069,
0.6781111956,
-0.082161665,
-0.4042249024,
-0.3367988169,
0.0814889222,
-0.9526349902,
0.4702862501,
-0.1037656814,
-0.9384481311,
0.4712392986,
0.0027303207,
-0.3126482368,
0.2920731306,
-0.701371491,
0.4297401309,
0.0425359569,
-0.3752182126,
-0.2605350912,
-0.3580517173,
0.4555238485,
-0.004801414,
0.2240552008,
-0.0754481927,
-0.4487555027,
0.7142285705,
-0.4955956042,
0.6585456133,
-0.1685933024,
-0.4127934575,
0.231260404,
0.03986286,
0.3474514186,
-0.1582155973,
-0.3334824443,
0.1430602968,
0.0846194625,
-0.1763215363,
-0.7229344249,
0.6207492352,
-0.1388899535,
-0.5560551882,
-0.352820009,
-0.6238994002,
-0.5485411882,
0.2289427519,
0.3913762271,
0.4279349148,
-0.387458533,
-0.1349258125,
0.1952636093,
-0.09949065,
0.4670733213,
0.6038077474,
-0.1961745024,
-0.2514257431,
0.973721683,
0.0073680608,
0.1179133654,
0.3293658495,
0.6083421707,
-0.7787536979,
-0.316901058,
-0.2620993853,
-0.1450107694,
-0.3874354064,
-0.040051803,
-0.4788381457,
-0.0041491943,
-0.2547857761,
-0.247477442,
0.1532209069,
-0.4824014008,
0.112164855,
-0.5508180857,
0.6988823414,
0.4607655406,
-0.1963443905,
0.3329552114,
-0.759072423,
0.3058878779,
0.3877218068,
0.5999738574,
0.1136364862,
-0.6915017962,
-0.2440398633,
0.0543376505,
-0.1548760086,
-0.8636794686,
0.4558524489,
0.514677763,
0.2682074904,
0.9461911321,
0.2085624337,
0.8127011657,
-0.6843065023,
0.9220471382,
0.6360684633,
-0.9580807686,
0.3399521708,
-0.6032160521,
0.515899539,
0.5544821024,
0.1046285257,
-0.8993067741,
-0.2198706269,
-0.6193614602,
-0.8965095878,
0.0534404032,
-0.2776965797,
0.4244463146,
-0.698148787,
0.2385832965,
0.3662595451,
0.2139339596,
-0.3707777262,
0.0567541271,
0.0010561798,
-0.2199978679,
-0.2407196015,
-0.1895428747,
0.0298515651,
-0.5437117219,
0.2744573951,
-0.4923036397,
0.1389301419,
0.0177320633,
-0.1602285057,
0.2226529568,
0.274948746,
0.3145802915,
0.5667511225,
0.213990584,
0.3955987394,
0.4390481114,
-0.3552061617,
0.0819189176,
-0.2053481042,
0.1183992699,
0.145576939,
0.3689482808,
0.749307096,
0.3139955401,
-0.7607662082,
0.6621692777,
0.0714093149,
-0.2447511405,
-0.1300223172,
0.1080700085,
0.2389811873,
-0.0473777764,
0.5475085378,
0.0864813924,
0.438860327,
-0.6092272997,
0.6508795023,
0.5837321281,
-0.1165354475,
-0.4759574831,
0.341769278,
0.2523340583,
-0.1462934017,
0.1559731364,
-0.4882980287,
-0.7837189436,
0.2703438699,
0.7668073773,
0.7021440864,
-0.1160286218,
-0.1038677916,
0.3136660457,
0.2463047057,
0.0636420846,
0.4769955277,
-0.3730199933,
-1.1038709879,
-0.2413411736,
-0.8033102751,
-0.0242138952,
0.1163906455,
-0.7626574636,
0.2731268108,
-0.2602483332,
-0.2784711421,
-0.3674174249,
-0.1682680398,
-0.624533236,
0.2753656209,
0.2268712074,
1.2884594202,
-1.0311334133,
0.876378715,
0.9422570467,
-0.0331821777,
-0.7509248257,
0.2483877391,
-0.3215356767,
-0.7498925924,
0.2517450154,
0.3432899415,
-0.1342414021,
0.033083573,
-0.2379750013,
-0.7086877823,
0.8340063095,
-0.2197054625,
-0.9186201692,
-0.150372684,
0.238948524,
0.4829163253,
-0.2675991356,
0.1663723737,
0.5310484171,
0.3462069035,
0.1284328699,
-0.5301856399,
0.1800994575,
-0.3667494655,
0.4301611483,
0.2524307966,
-0.1743380874,
0.4520349503,
-0.2866628766,
-0.3579994738,
0.1011536792,
0.9118922949,
0.1815925241,
0.2964616716,
1.0443643332,
0.9327765703,
0.8674004078,
0.1433345526,
0.6959206462,
-0.4191739857,
-0.0515866131,
1.2982023954,
-0.5187351108,
0.929895699,
0.6432719827,
-0.2290617228,
0.8069598079,
0.4734788239,
0.0336172357,
0.5968367457,
0.4339179099,
-0.6944041252,
-0.1416318566,
-0.2971078455,
-0.3895339668,
0.5734334588,
0.7865525484,
-0.167351827,
-0.1881352514,
0.5669956207,
-0.5336871147,
0.1502336711,
-0.0402289443,
0.8577617407,
0.3432885706,
-0.7707799673,
0.34965837,
0.1746679991,
0.9709229469,
-0.5832890272,
0.1134826243,
-0.1475415975,
0.2510484457,
0.0295121502,
-0.5928512216,
0.3121536076,
-0.4084911942,
-0.4006914794,
0.1062354594,
0.8951640129,
-0.4810259044,
-0.5440856218,
0.4756103158,
0.58855474,
-0.1584899575,
-0.081926614,
-0.3556351364,
-0.0217101928,
-0.3186363876,
-0.0869087428,
0.3423600793,
0.7458620071,
-0.2746324539,
0.3332962096,
0.8697440028,
0.111836873,
0.1912958473,
0.2134020925,
0.8491204381,
-0.5346159339,
-0.9176573753,
-0.5465468764,
0.2047834992,
-0.2119378299,
-0.3351320624,
0.7465162873,
0.4307707846,
0.7101240158,
-0.1368025541,
0.9661328197,
-0.0502635762,
0.332479775,
-0.1321781874,
0.4980089664,
-0.7014652491,
0.0246672966,
-0.2601163387,
-0.6577432156,
0.1019124165,
0.4713410139,
-0.3081035912,
-0.2283996344,
0.8202792406,
0.7891054153,
-0.15867652,
0.2711176574,
0.5991923213,
-0.1047208384,
0.0282037165,
0.5686159134,
0.893210113,
-0.297421664,
-0.0566488206,
0.1232245266,
-0.5019437671,
0.1879564971,
-0.8962581158,
-0.5715814829,
-0.8710608482,
-0.0427173823,
-0.081531167,
-0.1007081196,
0.9087609053,
0.7481363416,
-0.3469872177,
0.0086836442,
-0.3738411069,
-0.1529209763,
-0.5034761429,
-0.2908279896,
0.0855282545,
-0.3726439476,
-0.502578795,
0.7592590451,
0.1490990818,
-0.1255564392,
-0.1811212301,
-0.0025919536,
-0.0346031301,
0.3192877173,
1.0366806984,
0.2018662542,
-0.6790643334,
-0.2516854107,
0.0343912169,
0.3679986,
-0.4130788743,
0.8297352195,
-1.2156689167,
0.3224152923,
0.489236176,
0.5512011647,
0.1272029877,
-0.0300980266,
0.8271929622,
-0.7306827307,
0.4112903774,
0.0833563283,
0.4436021149,
-0.0014673752,
-0.1849529445,
0.0388477445,
0.5926878452,
0.4191090465,
-0.6759389043,
0.6128878593,
-0.768713057,
-0.6179305911,
1.2228944302,
0.0851760209,
-0.3178890944,
0.0321468562,
0.1506913751,
-0.0908760875,
-0.1540841162,
0.6543184519,
0.6268562675,
0.172183454,
0.0520858988,
0.179172501,
0.2846266627,
0.6307433844,
-0.3927505314,
-0.0375216939,
0.424816817,
0.3810958862,
0.1365477145,
0.2424186766,
0.0612906255,
0.176248759,
-0.1237023994,
0.0586655363,
0.0363776796,
-0.3430100083,
-0.3840740025,
0.2811729014,
0.0641632453,
-0.6240283251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05605v1 | A Unified Generative Approach to Product Attribute-Value Identification | 2023-06-09T00:33:30 | 2023-06-09T00:33:30 | Keiji Shinzato, Naoki Yoshinaga, Yandi Xia, Wei-Te Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Product attribute-value identification (PAVI) has been studied to link
products on e-commerce sites with their attribute values (e.g., <Material,
Cotton>) using product text as clues. Technical demands from real-world
e-commerce platforms require PAVI methods to handle unseen values,
multi-attribute values, and canonicalized values, which are only partly
addressed in existing extraction- and classification-based approaches.
Motivated by this, we explore a generative approach to the PAVI task. We
finetune a pre-trained generative model, T5, to decode a set of attribute-value
pairs as a target sequence from the given product text. Since the attribute
value pairs are unordered set elements, how to linearize them will matter; we,
thus, explore methods of composing an attribute-value pair and ordering the
pairs for the task. Experimental results confirm that our generation-based
approach outperforms the existing extraction and classification-based methods
on large-scale real-world datasets meant for those methods. | [
-0.1665206403,
-0.6072511673,
0.2426512092,
0.2859400213,
-0.3993526101,
0.0940195918,
-0.0142933838,
-0.5059319735,
0.0512772277,
0.1373703927,
-0.7444604635,
-0.3912222981,
-0.3586317897,
-0.1488545984,
-0.3615816236,
1.109806776,
0.4096987844,
-0.2772323191,
-0.2195730656,
-0.2607694864,
-0.1656402349,
-0.5852555633,
-0.3840782642,
-0.0262535717,
0.7256338,
0.2102824301,
0.4305114746,
0.4309376776,
0.6702289581,
0.2596094012,
-0.0010041316,
0.4855996668,
-0.6349472404,
0.163940534,
-0.1144129038,
-0.271368295,
-0.6765780449,
0.3471197188,
0.1982630193,
0.781105876,
0.117555216,
0.719137609,
0.1216177419,
0.2874088287,
-1.0008596182,
0.2117230445,
-0.4215167761,
0.1520322561,
-0.3058989048,
-0.3075219393,
-0.7427205443,
-0.2679719329,
-0.0968342945,
-1.0008496046,
0.5913392901,
0.2404119819,
1.3706519604,
-0.0517215468,
-0.3267077506,
-0.2452066839,
-0.9196257591,
0.7872846723,
-0.2051868886,
0.3500700295,
0.2461668849,
0.0477928631,
-0.1975323409,
-0.7457744479,
-0.7769297957,
0.149497509,
-0.1523135751,
0.2132117301,
0.0504857413,
-0.0633531734,
0.094489865,
0.7503787279,
-0.3749212921,
0.1142393574,
-0.4797697961,
0.2213751227,
0.7424486279,
-0.0379301123,
0.3323830664,
-0.1818404198,
-0.5402813554,
-0.2790205479,
-0.7688600421,
0.1530416757,
0.1903796494,
0.2827128172,
0.0168423876,
0.5537805557,
-0.1892368197,
0.5668098927,
0.5358453989,
-0.426330626,
0.6096126437,
-0.3611398339,
-0.3848212957,
-0.1593479067,
0.8098712564,
0.1410659552,
-0.1338582784,
-0.3443222344,
-0.2860598862,
-0.251450032,
0.3485560417,
-0.4617345929,
-0.2864572406,
0.0781152621,
-0.8352130055,
-0.8273764849,
0.4287304878,
-0.9240310192,
-0.2553731799,
-0.2156189233,
0.8341594338,
0.0068816743,
-0.207682237,
-0.2204359621,
-0.1635534465,
0.9118663073,
0.1343330145,
-1.0051077604,
0.068064779,
0.8188324571,
0.5846379399,
-0.0866466612,
0.1895682365,
-0.6180362105,
0.330370754,
-0.2153078318,
0.6154910326,
-0.606182456,
-0.5057752728,
-0.1887799203,
0.1301296204,
0.4771688282,
-0.4107567072,
0.5689820051,
-0.7559871674,
0.1381510049,
-0.5669355392,
-0.3115210235,
0.0456755422,
0.1283059567,
-0.9444078207,
0.6897931099,
-0.0844726115,
-0.5468833447,
0.6275648475,
-0.6300591826,
-0.5599418283,
0.351102978,
-0.1527238488,
-0.8732609153,
0.5758797526,
0.2890044749,
0.5950660706,
-0.6587156057,
-0.1794163138,
-0.3673115075,
-0.0495866276,
0.364122957,
-0.8185521364,
0.8571994901,
0.3823355436,
-0.1378498971,
-0.3694499731,
-1.0289791822,
0.0646943226,
0.4121299982,
-0.1173945218,
-0.2882009149,
-0.0582795329,
0.2341813743,
-0.0731361657,
0.3175491095,
-0.5534691811,
0.4096724093,
-0.0759874582,
-0.0113888858,
1.0383892059,
0.1684107482,
0.3584911227,
-0.1363325119,
0.5546116829,
-0.1712068766,
0.29076913,
-0.1696265787,
-0.5652530193,
-1.248711586,
-0.2099755853,
0.3437667489,
0.2542801201,
-0.5608846545,
0.2697953284,
-0.4177138209,
-0.5031974316,
-0.2690017521,
-0.0151104452,
0.7034131289,
0.5203710198,
0.403296113,
-0.4384879172,
-0.091574572,
-0.8388070464,
-0.0389374048,
-0.1320099831,
-0.3587409556,
0.2188630253,
0.2258574814,
0.2235195041,
0.8300542235,
-1.0124218464,
-0.3200772703,
0.0592773668,
0.8789634705,
0.1847086847,
0.4515946507,
0.2725420594,
-1.261570096,
-0.3622913659,
0.2467063069,
-0.6578733921,
-0.392254591,
-0.187326178,
-0.0258019567,
-0.1033372656,
0.1364752352,
-0.2930313945,
0.5159371495,
0.3001184762,
-0.1848634183,
0.4183109105,
-0.3283325434,
0.2794936597,
-1.4167290926,
0.2467593253,
0.309058249,
0.1886302531,
-0.6483194828,
0.0747742206,
-0.0214869063,
-0.2638497353,
-0.4898423851,
0.0208249371,
-0.7163258195,
-0.430880636,
0.0414328948,
-0.5781909227,
0.4222046435,
0.5435759425,
-0.1132890508,
1.0005594492,
-0.028847402,
-0.8029851317,
0.5307741165,
0.3422119319,
-0.2162094861,
1.1324282885,
-0.6323693991,
0.2416229993,
-0.486423105,
-0.1530740559,
-0.6851494908,
-0.0850474536,
0.2411462367,
-0.6152255535,
0.3064604104,
-0.1156512126,
-0.5683624148,
-0.1451278478,
0.0204350762,
0.8097955585,
0.685628593,
-0.8705456257,
0.8021104336,
0.3285213113,
-0.1099900976,
-0.3547187448,
-0.3004115522,
-0.1184259802,
-0.5375766754,
-0.3423119485,
0.7610262632,
-0.1154222563,
-0.0369184725,
-0.113782905,
-0.0063648932,
-0.4201809764,
0.2170314342,
0.3621662557,
0.3637179136,
-0.1479059309,
0.5748927593,
-0.2289469689,
-0.3684815764,
0.0251392275,
-0.4542655647,
0.1787104309,
-0.0549086109,
-0.3559924364,
-0.3833000362,
0.5482883453,
0.4739341438,
-0.7245835662,
0.7112420201,
0.6249872446,
-0.3227645159,
-0.4251233041,
-0.5260617733,
0.3179887235,
-0.5493041277,
-0.0018055412,
-0.8085590005,
-0.0817573294,
0.2105913162,
-0.2592293918,
-0.2239675671,
0.5767133832,
0.3974533975,
-0.6225055456,
0.9310839772,
0.8301123977,
0.0251305662,
0.2118448615,
-0.3233501315,
0.6421598792,
-0.6201380491,
-0.8710241318,
-0.6084085703,
-0.427906245,
-0.4761207104,
-0.3780461848,
0.6597159505,
0.0370376185,
-0.2816066146,
0.4077161849,
-0.6772530675,
0.6099943519,
0.8795204759,
0.4301791489,
0.2284843475,
0.2474106401,
0.2573683262,
0.1764525175,
-0.3425700665,
0.0035819644,
1.2437946796,
0.055288773,
0.8098292351,
0.3086602092,
0.3742169738,
0.3514909148,
0.2273930013,
-0.6910753846,
0.250223279,
-0.3609122932,
-0.1921484619,
0.1497708857,
-0.181912899,
-1.038559556,
-0.0721329451,
-0.4635191262,
-0.5637515783,
0.5833101869,
0.2082190812,
-0.5302560925,
0.0783493668,
-0.681996882,
0.7492696643,
-0.8609351516,
-0.4580447972,
0.0771241933,
-0.410274297,
0.0166255627,
-0.071412392,
0.0793123096,
0.1033933163,
0.013183197,
0.618996501,
-0.5349344015,
0.5580323339,
0.313528806,
-0.0989793465,
-0.0071790228,
-0.3224994838,
0.3911295831,
-0.2321913987,
0.2569503188,
-0.2280780673,
-0.3806949854,
-0.683889091,
-0.6782751083,
0.6007711291,
-0.8106144071,
-0.4988745749,
-0.6114301682,
-0.1651469618,
-0.2224372178,
-0.0209390074,
0.4926553369,
0.4695013165,
-0.2512736022,
0.3753778934,
1.0018320084,
-0.3289093971,
0.5284949541,
0.1874174923,
0.3352526128,
-0.3404571116,
1.183180809,
-0.1532831043,
0.3641883433,
0.7180877328,
0.047370214,
-0.2130376697,
-0.2021090835,
-0.1327992976,
-0.1486747861,
-0.754121244,
-0.2432994097,
-0.222069025,
-0.2315333933,
-0.236369431,
-0.2132642567,
-0.2202921361,
0.0025480902,
-0.4758029282,
-0.0933518484,
0.3235198259,
0.9267570972,
0.1089206636,
0.1229718924,
-0.6954693794,
0.6400440931,
0.7926719189,
0.3176447749,
-0.1994264275,
-0.0548952259,
0.0125103313,
0.0067546726,
-0.2895958722,
-1.120470643,
0.5007879138,
0.313470304,
0.5043210983,
0.7790897489,
0.1695117354,
0.7780015469,
-0.2606367171,
0.7599840164,
0.4069344401,
-0.8808515668,
0.5593881607,
-0.2461958081,
-0.0492951423,
0.2597561479,
0.5481719375,
-0.3561965525,
0.5232390165,
-0.6763600707,
-0.9085268378,
0.4247927964,
0.3959721029,
0.0373485088,
0.1221735924,
0.1235476136,
0.1493964195,
0.2891589999,
-0.9037328362,
-0.2634148002,
-0.1561762244,
-0.3198556006,
-0.1182937622,
-0.2928184271,
0.0311340168,
-0.2027652264,
0.4285464585,
-0.0201331452,
0.4069718421,
-0.1239733174,
-0.292422086,
0.1876994371,
0.2447774559,
0.154380396,
0.6090196371,
-0.1155269891,
0.1227956936,
-0.2060420513,
-0.1343346089,
0.408300966,
0.0308028683,
-0.2357345372,
-0.1673709005,
0.0588111691,
0.5203027129,
-0.1763763428,
-0.2817168236,
0.9238644242,
0.1707095802,
0.2053522468,
-0.496237576,
-0.3827670515,
-0.3291539848,
0.0643359944,
0.4196201861,
-0.2003227621,
0.3430868685,
-0.6558662057,
0.1245664656,
0.3688956201,
-0.2118621171,
-0.4415754974,
0.6802718639,
0.5511959195,
-0.5272888541,
0.7679267526,
-0.4405146539,
-0.3987114131,
0.8264778852,
0.5706514716,
1.0814511776,
-0.1155220568,
0.3535569012,
0.1095780879,
0.0229107272,
0.2869560122,
0.132036835,
-0.339980185,
-0.6989552379,
-0.1481782049,
-0.8157436252,
0.0112991268,
0.3669218719,
-0.8078688383,
0.3134573102,
-0.4149752855,
0.1408954263,
0.3690753281,
-0.3645516336,
-0.9149307013,
0.5026860237,
0.328591466,
0.0817251131,
-1.2291842699,
0.597543478,
0.2762598097,
-1.1268671751,
-0.7485266328,
0.1285346895,
0.0684606656,
-0.6613411903,
1.0187726021,
0.2298913747,
-0.0016477917,
-0.253642261,
-0.4524753392,
-0.7704902887,
1.3153041601,
-0.0312395096,
-0.204321593,
-0.1579869837,
0.4446803629,
0.3503489792,
-0.2991446853,
0.2118614465,
0.3200980723,
0.2497764379,
0.3608934283,
-0.7605189681,
-0.1253786236,
-0.7986342907,
0.3705633283,
0.292263478,
-0.535251379,
0.8751060963,
0.2212563008,
-0.366384238,
0.1865830719,
0.5720973015,
-0.179774493,
0.1224939972,
0.5083031654,
0.9378069043,
0.7509323359,
-0.1370707005,
0.7982415557,
-0.026155632,
0.4364567697,
0.9804096222,
0.1271983087,
0.9256008863,
0.3318862319,
-0.2832058072,
0.4741491675,
0.3997687101,
-0.3210385442,
0.6646369696,
0.083612591,
-0.7064660192,
-0.2735323906,
-0.3051939011,
-0.3155246675,
0.4519192576,
0.5442500114,
-0.7021696568,
0.0947810262,
0.0705090836,
-0.1579117626,
-0.0801624209,
-0.4075090885,
1.0884511471,
-0.1227244586,
-0.4959738553,
0.3459810913,
0.0003827049,
0.2981776297,
-0.2846325338,
-0.3200002611,
-0.1027705818,
0.2289603949,
-0.1359060556,
-0.4310071468,
-0.0919239894,
0.0369488522,
-0.2314874977,
-0.6124110222,
0.5307797194,
-0.2342924774,
-0.9005355239,
-0.2821626961,
0.144008562,
-0.3482142091,
0.1041931957,
-0.3776750863,
-0.178549841,
-0.1822966188,
-0.0304349363,
0.0823427141,
0.3095449805,
-0.0229944848,
0.4611084461,
0.7853620052,
-0.2398647368,
0.0558772348,
-0.2297607213,
0.7583167553,
-0.5259853601,
-0.5100031495,
-0.4669933617,
0.7531199455,
-0.4996110797,
-0.3920336366,
0.4906158149,
0.4505175054,
0.9383924603,
-0.0906133801,
0.749345839,
-0.1954095811,
0.0393316709,
-0.4136455357,
0.6029511094,
-0.6452935934,
0.3514919877,
-0.2339724302,
-0.9035795331,
-0.1783365458,
0.4458372593,
-0.0239471234,
-0.1245373711,
0.5909137726,
0.8321437836,
-0.3941231072,
-0.2471127659,
0.1023082286,
0.1612636745,
0.3088783622,
0.7397956848,
0.5573269725,
-0.5649197698,
0.6386929154,
-0.2928966284,
-0.3177750111,
-0.0116712907,
-0.9791540504,
-0.4721158743,
-0.8115098476,
-0.2255858034,
-0.2900832295,
0.3844310641,
0.8462886214,
0.7842882276,
-0.7645531297,
0.0508537069,
-0.2476373762,
-0.4054671526,
-0.2982363999,
-0.1399954408,
0.4734070897,
-0.2946677506,
-0.7393810749,
0.2101921439,
0.3066900969,
0.1325645447,
-0.1920497268,
0.1611957848,
-0.0258276109,
0.0233638808,
0.4639131725,
0.4767431319,
-0.7756388783,
-0.2999891937,
-0.0006969112,
0.2950573862,
0.2793620527,
0.7256620526,
-0.8687924147,
0.7578981519,
0.823816359,
0.6992681623,
0.4771726429,
0.2832835317,
0.9864297509,
-0.957511723,
0.2200286239,
0.0728930533,
0.2341329157,
0.1100902557,
-0.2402300388,
0.1752463281,
0.3581992686,
-0.2321296483,
-0.3457770646,
0.6067276597,
-1.0922954082,
-0.0784974322,
0.9250434637,
-0.4328590631,
-0.3482098281,
0.184331581,
0.0620212369,
0.1245518625,
0.0231857672,
0.8258389831,
0.2099805623,
0.3524310291,
-0.3913261592,
0.2531261444,
0.2779029906,
0.216506958,
-0.9059820771,
-0.4557497799,
0.4648744166,
-0.0540960133,
0.2703742385,
0.2903279066,
0.0420429222,
0.3633707762,
0.0099495538,
0.0560614429,
0.0091851503,
-0.3945333362,
-0.2402839512,
0.6976472735,
0.2043680847,
-0.6026448607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05596v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05596v1 | LOST: A Mental Health Dataset of Low Self-esteem in Reddit Posts | 2023-06-08T23:52:35 | 2023-06-08T23:52:35 | Muskan Garg, Manas Gaur, Raxit Goswami, Sunghwan Sohn | cs.CL | cs.CL | Low self-esteem and interpersonal needs (i.e., thwarted belongingness (TB)
and perceived burdensomeness (PB)) have a major impact on depression and
suicide attempts. Individuals seek social connectedness on social media to
boost and alleviate their loneliness. Social media platforms allow people to
express their thoughts, experiences, beliefs, and emotions. Prior studies on
mental health from social media have focused on symptoms, causes, and
disorders. Whereas an initial screening of social media content for
interpersonal risk factors and low self-esteem may raise early alerts and
assign therapists to at-risk users of mental disturbance. Standardized scales
measure self-esteem and interpersonal needs from questions created using
psychological theories. In the current research, we introduce a
psychology-grounded and expertly annotated dataset, LoST: Low Self esTeem, to
study and detect low self-esteem on Reddit. Through an annotation approach
involving checks on coherence, correctness, consistency, and reliability, we
ensure gold-standard for supervised learning. We present results from different
deep language models tested using two data augmentation techniques. Our
findings suggest developing a class of language models that infuses
psychological and clinical knowledge. | [
-0.4694091678,
-0.8022660017,
0.7099103928,
0.3677294552,
-0.0717939511,
-0.0286967512,
-0.0548509434,
-0.3544054031,
0.6312775016,
0.1539093554,
-0.8621738553,
-0.4932853281,
-0.8187320828,
0.2255080789,
-0.3646257818,
0.8601337671,
0.043158669,
0.0450656824,
-0.4484695196,
0.0148337288,
-0.5148519874,
-0.5317432284,
-0.3483724892,
-0.2369640917,
0.7820137143,
0.5331786871,
0.5797497034,
0.0389287323,
0.8233757615,
0.1021791399,
0.220962882,
0.1251119971,
-0.7839848995,
-0.2049845308,
-0.4458716214,
-0.1300892979,
-0.5324433446,
0.2344950885,
0.0234073494,
0.8530451655,
-0.0820825174,
0.6972666383,
0.1157906875,
0.5233300924,
-0.6341242194,
-0.0162719544,
-0.1465323418,
0.0398943685,
-0.0540058129,
-0.1631894708,
0.1152356118,
-0.4960832,
-0.144202292,
-0.4087266326,
0.2787626982,
-0.4013800919,
0.640109539,
0.4811679423,
-0.5400541425,
-0.1832700819,
-0.6653383374,
0.5626912117,
-0.5208963752,
0.1411490291,
0.7934131622,
0.0470304079,
0.0159755424,
-0.2504246235,
-0.2886849642,
0.1926209629,
-0.5392983556,
0.0854038745,
-0.2436503321,
-0.0143378694,
0.0574622452,
0.3523474932,
-0.4756238759,
-0.1700220108,
-0.5349444747,
0.0386149697,
0.9896796346,
0.0386036858,
0.5198169947,
-0.2991251945,
0.1738083214,
0.0570164472,
-0.3238499165,
-0.065846011,
0.2443573624,
0.3762517273,
-0.389380157,
0.7192206383,
-0.0830635354,
0.1719707996,
0.2990038693,
-0.256811291,
0.0985306501,
-0.2670261562,
0.1153865084,
0.0491499789,
0.5211904049,
0.6853477359,
0.2664712667,
0.2968037724,
0.0161942132,
0.2986714542,
0.5454577208,
-0.5682707429,
-0.4274818897,
0.0399776772,
-0.7481014729,
-0.318538785,
-0.1494802237,
-0.4254866838,
-0.6072941422,
-0.1553083062,
0.4782110155,
-0.3560516834,
-0.3853202462,
-0.0524636395,
-0.0156853627,
-0.3499123156,
0.4229492545,
-0.7103666663,
0.4147216082,
0.4133400619,
0.8677834272,
0.068300508,
-0.1125495359,
-0.124118574,
-0.288217783,
-0.4143371582,
0.4856674373,
-0.4224393964,
-0.160096854,
0.0559349991,
0.4159424007,
0.0878797099,
-0.2287744135,
0.6283670664,
-0.1491698325,
0.1370665282,
-0.3984099627,
-0.5281251073,
-0.1794267744,
0.2030241638,
-0.3965753615,
0.791413486,
0.303789258,
-0.6673260927,
0.1291034371,
-0.3625094891,
-0.7171803713,
0.2859783769,
0.1522558779,
-0.2614474893,
0.3942850232,
0.3130858839,
0.8479978442,
-0.0658444464,
0.0540464073,
-0.9575121999,
-0.570276916,
0.1522865593,
-0.0849027336,
0.5913982391,
0.0477298126,
-0.0051833987,
-0.5490947366,
-0.7021545172,
0.026576208,
0.1447868943,
-0.1520465761,
-0.8966988921,
-0.0005926166,
-0.0958708674,
0.1196764708,
0.2950275242,
-0.5429519415,
-0.1512567252,
-0.2732493281,
0.447686106,
0.440292865,
0.4736188352,
0.0516709685,
-0.15902628,
0.4487732947,
0.062875323,
0.3029868305,
0.3552641869,
-0.2484868765,
-0.3639236689,
-0.1137553751,
-0.1627314687,
0.4438607991,
-0.2370415926,
0.6211268902,
0.0199500173,
-0.5733445883,
-0.905985415,
0.1128855646,
0.1249276251,
0.3684740067,
0.5855170488,
-0.0254409648,
-0.5631260872,
-1.0060068369,
-0.3306231499,
-0.0478374325,
0.2111421824,
0.1196302772,
0.4709507823,
-0.7336865664,
0.581362009,
-0.4264646173,
-0.7441407442,
0.0128198816,
0.0660766885,
0.0996416509,
0.3895382285,
0.3470793962,
-0.5366779566,
-0.5081315041,
-0.1449155509,
-1.1698001623,
-0.1911584586,
-0.0143952593,
0.107672669,
-0.2903175354,
0.3445820212,
-0.4673984647,
0.6093800664,
0.5636273026,
-0.1173274815,
0.0438395292,
-0.1574528366,
0.3680928349,
-0.7469400764,
-0.0531598367,
0.3009865284,
-0.0954970568,
-0.4662522078,
-0.3866861165,
-0.0331887566,
-0.4218504727,
0.1001895815,
0.3297405243,
-0.315048188,
0.1303002238,
-0.2621788085,
0.2191859186,
0.1425075382,
0.1535404474,
-0.3791098297,
0.6884443164,
0.3750196993,
-0.2006160319,
-0.0370971598,
0.3063980341,
-0.0565623678,
0.9213477969,
-0.473293215,
-0.0056707561,
-0.6707043648,
-0.1299813837,
-1.1159206629,
-0.5992283821,
0.147535488,
-0.7389683127,
-0.0582872368,
0.0112886429,
-0.1504884511,
-0.5383081436,
-0.1624386162,
0.4194649458,
0.1725727022,
-0.0405771472,
0.1000647023,
0.7640327215,
-0.3458678424,
-0.404514879,
-0.7926329374,
0.2105383128,
-0.3165955245,
-0.2432347983,
0.3257650733,
-0.0980370566,
-0.3056697547,
0.2863030732,
0.2533654571,
-0.2525992393,
0.2729696035,
0.481973201,
-0.2157754898,
0.0941676125,
0.7673063278,
0.2157779932,
-0.0166471228,
0.3264553547,
0.1965727061,
0.2852460742,
-0.3339500129,
-0.3236348927,
-0.7160927653,
0.6317572594,
0.3809220195,
0.1868357509,
0.6425549984,
0.3419755399,
-0.7622030973,
-0.0215993207,
-0.6064728498,
-0.3323753178,
-0.3525386751,
0.2458715141,
-0.1196617857,
-0.9014748931,
0.3648753464,
0.2039532661,
-0.4631305039,
0.3526462615,
0.3592234254,
-0.6934739351,
1.0287615061,
0.8051359057,
-0.0263326578,
0.0934991613,
0.121801585,
0.7570279837,
-0.3461069763,
0.1670794487,
0.0663053393,
-0.3715741634,
-0.6791122556,
0.0673573613,
0.4544934332,
0.1027193442,
-0.2437676191,
0.1667318791,
-0.7572863698,
0.2730647922,
0.5114383698,
0.5992711186,
0.2854374647,
-0.2139644623,
0.5835149288,
-0.5727594495,
-0.4616095722,
-0.56945467,
0.686106801,
0.4041490853,
1.1054950953,
-0.0454166979,
0.9361355305,
0.9916759729,
0.4648450315,
-0.6407811642,
0.3586612344,
-0.0350606963,
-0.7836377025,
-0.3001800478,
-0.3331128657,
-0.6741361618,
-0.2315591574,
-0.3035741746,
-0.5593517423,
0.347153008,
0.3741203547,
-0.692591548,
-0.1694054008,
-0.8698247075,
0.8661676645,
-0.2731713057,
-0.1578311622,
-0.3453747034,
-0.8019875884,
0.5227401257,
-0.2688710392,
0.1800110489,
-0.5510599613,
0.4741339087,
0.5343657136,
-0.4477407336,
1.0406880379,
-0.0899389461,
0.1844235361,
0.2694120109,
0.1056186408,
0.2076766938,
0.2226375639,
0.2003579885,
0.1039458215,
0.4546115994,
-0.2893878222,
-0.6600886583,
0.7118705511,
-0.9710290432,
-0.3557196856,
-0.3349402547,
-0.1081264615,
-0.0577234961,
0.3871780932,
0.0923934728,
-0.0210187808,
-0.2467197925,
0.1498230547,
0.4476328492,
-0.2440792471,
0.0277934354,
0.1193263233,
0.048506517,
-0.524484098,
0.6776219606,
0.4965444803,
-0.0635963306,
0.1018988416,
0.2043061852,
-0.0684274063,
0.1482952982,
0.3489877582,
0.6552672386,
-0.8477228284,
-0.2829324305,
-0.4101044834,
-0.2276444137,
-0.7892638445,
-0.1729634106,
-0.5717685819,
-0.1485709995,
-0.6695159674,
-0.438278228,
0.4785987437,
0.8952286839,
-0.5506033301,
0.3182662725,
-0.678193748,
0.1736389697,
0.3854216337,
0.44826442,
0.1267621815,
-0.0999215171,
-0.3081774116,
0.2182567418,
0.0163493678,
-0.7968369126,
0.3268056214,
0.1592580974,
0.1850181669,
0.4079684615,
0.5624341369,
0.8445363045,
0.0879969597,
0.1703351885,
0.1985146552,
-0.6808734536,
0.7624146938,
-0.44231534,
-0.1153952479,
0.973991394,
0.6719170213,
-0.8370953798,
-0.0355078205,
-0.6691666245,
-0.3863617182,
0.416703254,
0.1514550894,
0.1429836303,
-0.4089881182,
0.6660994887,
-0.1098864675,
0.1486103237,
-0.9054411054,
-0.4329449236,
-0.3379639089,
-0.5333894491,
-0.11548125,
-0.6557041407,
-0.2314561605,
-0.389146626,
0.5544779301,
-0.0246889107,
0.4184719324,
0.5864604115,
0.0516354889,
-0.4417915344,
-0.172845155,
0.0584330633,
0.4136532247,
-0.5163398981,
0.45884794,
-0.0009106762,
-0.255636394,
0.3219632208,
0.1174524873,
-0.1985953152,
-0.2199982703,
0.4417856038,
0.2944400609,
0.1241632998,
-0.5886415839,
0.8009858131,
-0.1711011529,
-0.0404319204,
-0.6715525389,
-0.2277892232,
0.3108437061,
0.2374479771,
0.1283214688,
-0.0646437034,
0.1167621985,
-0.6178241372,
0.3757783771,
0.3632532656,
-0.7179870605,
-0.6049550772,
0.5683494806,
0.1575988829,
-0.4896841347,
0.4394463897,
-0.1549429893,
-0.0503130555,
0.0424859673,
0.2605593801,
0.5529937148,
-0.1829356402,
0.4872149825,
0.4124966264,
0.5461263657,
0.0658003688,
0.1915774345,
0.1270207018,
-0.5937521458,
0.0217491835,
-0.4731063247,
-0.1421748102,
0.3074763119,
-0.6127582192,
0.260250628,
-0.4236517549,
-0.5540463924,
-0.1123239174,
0.1388130486,
-0.5944406986,
0.4700481296,
0.1423444897,
0.4170033038,
-1.0817502737,
0.3160800934,
0.5795328617,
-0.5418788791,
-0.5668573976,
0.1622648388,
-0.0006633075,
-0.6000572443,
0.4601297081,
0.2420996875,
-0.0258059632,
-0.0383000225,
-0.5271567106,
-1.2708237171,
0.7389133573,
0.3617348075,
0.057634756,
-0.0409607291,
0.367410928,
0.7644526362,
-0.3721925616,
0.0386129506,
0.260666877,
0.3206223249,
-0.3286270499,
-0.5137066245,
0.0308923405,
-0.3031240404,
-0.0148752108,
-0.1372265816,
-0.7968254685,
0.9098161459,
-0.221452117,
-0.630361557,
-0.2331780195,
0.3322669566,
-0.1371061057,
0.1876908541,
0.1486616135,
0.7317031622,
0.7022805214,
0.1582832783,
0.6478456259,
-0.2118119448,
0.6889790297,
0.9488381743,
-0.190464437,
0.6743630767,
0.2085508704,
0.0491044335,
0.3458977342,
0.9507895708,
0.0885702744,
0.6573415995,
-0.2173512876,
-0.0818365514,
-0.3821189404,
-0.2868844569,
-0.2376267016,
0.3147651553,
0.5503387451,
-0.470680505,
-0.3923662007,
0.2042340785,
0.1271252036,
0.2004205883,
0.0075983028,
0.5772600174,
0.2722988725,
-0.4395876527,
0.5797679424,
-0.2718500793,
0.1884795576,
-0.2143458873,
-0.1523293406,
-0.4890288115,
0.4748878479,
-0.285675168,
-0.7076144814,
0.5703228712,
-0.4384899735,
-0.1918323785,
-0.1742357612,
1.2803621292,
-0.4401507378,
-0.8487697244,
0.6894021034,
0.8196083307,
0.1775013357,
-0.3511849344,
-0.6094148755,
-0.1966788471,
-0.265317589,
-0.1306480169,
0.2429188788,
0.5664497614,
0.0788416341,
0.7777590156,
0.2960536778,
0.0952075347,
-0.3469313383,
-0.0913908854,
0.723641336,
-0.6919900179,
-0.1223231629,
-0.7228332758,
0.1716712564,
-0.2070233524,
-0.1990186125,
0.9249490499,
0.1037760526,
0.7235866189,
-0.1080446616,
0.9209031463,
-0.0711316317,
1.041836381,
0.2123213261,
0.884740591,
-0.8962241411,
-0.122200042,
-0.4579522908,
-0.3802000284,
-0.5205135942,
0.6632038951,
-0.3704171777,
-0.20214504,
0.4792678654,
0.777946949,
-0.0064662276,
-0.3519461453,
0.3697666526,
0.1587179154,
0.021937158,
0.38164258,
0.6040675044,
-0.5861857533,
0.0670906529,
-0.6420277953,
-0.3338281512,
-0.3782863915,
-0.3889455795,
-1.1708146334,
-0.6098888516,
-0.3218663335,
-0.276134491,
0.2142704278,
0.94272542,
0.473347038,
-0.3467169702,
-0.0228915699,
-0.0906311423,
0.2356065065,
-0.1667155176,
-0.2426869571,
0.2688090801,
-0.0945415273,
-0.1855331361,
0.1733418852,
0.340077281,
0.1680309325,
-0.5626029372,
0.2541892231,
-0.4110464156,
-0.0004174817,
0.5889037251,
-0.0035165751,
-0.5507304668,
-0.5248393416,
-0.0697290897,
-0.1439054906,
0.0794924274,
0.2850531936,
-0.4935311973,
0.2229412496,
0.3049085736,
0.3758085966,
0.1597779393,
0.5018193126,
0.3082531095,
-0.8842883706,
-0.2596821189,
0.3383801877,
0.2476836592,
0.5493014455,
-0.8603754044,
0.5950478315,
0.5423333049,
-0.4146021008,
-0.841394186,
-0.0159543771,
-0.5833166838,
-0.2886342704,
0.6248620152,
-0.0832736641,
-0.1022576839,
0.0277800653,
-0.0336675383,
0.1166955084,
-0.4422780871,
1.3873298168,
0.7965450883,
-0.1797250062,
-0.5307326913,
-0.3671663105,
0.4935442209,
0.0913314372,
-0.7330390811,
0.1851066947,
0.3533813953,
0.1317943931,
0.2136313915,
0.7818171382,
0.2254099995,
-0.0473070405,
-0.1268222183,
0.1234119311,
0.3954560459,
-0.1185439378,
-0.0536781177,
0.2906738222,
-0.2719477415,
0.1468853205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07944v1 | Speech-to-Text Adapter and Speech-to-Entity Retriever Augmented LLMs for Speech Understanding | 2023-06-08T22:33:22 | 2023-06-08T22:33:22 | Mingqiu Wang, Izhak Shafran, Hagen Soltau, Wei Han, Yuan Cao, Dian Yu, Laurent El Shafey | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been applied in the speech domain, often
incurring a performance drop due to misaligned between speech and language
representations. To bridge this gap, we propose a joint speech and language
model (SLM) using a Speech2Text adapter, which maps speech into text token
embedding space without speech information loss. Additionally, using a
CTC-based blank-filtering, we can reduce the speech sequence length to that of
text. In speech MultiWoz dataset (DSTC11 challenge), SLM largely improves the
dialog state tracking (DST) performance (24.7% to 28.4% accuracy). Further to
address errors on rare entities, we augment SLM with a Speech2Entity retriever,
which uses speech to retrieve relevant entities, and then adds them to the
original SLM input as a prefix. With this retrieval-augmented SLM (ReSLM), the
DST performance jumps to 34.6% accuracy. Moreover, augmenting the ASR task with
the dialog understanding task improves the ASR performance from 9.4% to 8.5%
WER. | [
-0.2089883238,
-0.8044105172,
0.5719249249,
0.0741540641,
-0.4947947264,
0.2748700976,
-0.2800724804,
-0.6824523211,
0.1898743212,
0.6686066389,
-0.4420331717,
-0.39882496,
-0.7673569918,
-0.0117001664,
-0.2343965024,
0.8497477174,
0.1289493293,
0.0909333825,
-0.2965809405,
-0.2160685062,
-0.6645793319,
-0.4994253814,
-0.8201528788,
-0.5234888792,
0.2959215939,
0.187395975,
0.462454319,
0.614838779,
0.2028409094,
0.2530318499,
-0.5236566663,
0.3397056162,
-0.4309887886,
0.1806352586,
-0.3627262115,
-0.4279376268,
-0.6001047492,
-0.322211206,
0.702314496,
0.7018504739,
-0.3283975124,
0.0374254361,
0.0819296911,
0.4171612561,
-0.489462167,
0.2604288161,
-0.8895471692,
-0.1312808543,
-0.0482976325,
-0.3015178442,
-0.4947108328,
0.0452707373,
0.2929252982,
-0.6465210319,
0.0960147157,
0.10324312,
0.5042700768,
0.5127456784,
-0.6514245272,
-0.4216154218,
-0.6772476435,
0.5874061584,
-0.6964581609,
0.6977928281,
0.2639833689,
0.0165505782,
-0.0610582046,
-0.7862405181,
-0.6801812053,
0.0102061359,
-0.1003184095,
0.1551950574,
-0.2374769896,
0.3840858042,
0.2344852239,
0.2813629806,
-0.5629902482,
0.1982224733,
-0.2217406929,
-0.4794676602,
0.3807176054,
0.2119408846,
0.3825088441,
-0.1089263335,
-0.458632797,
0.1557735801,
-0.5985239744,
0.0093935654,
-0.0946377441,
0.4771779776,
0.0564527623,
0.6684188247,
0.1999790072,
0.9230282903,
-0.0498535521,
-0.3056229949,
0.2174250036,
-0.5490033627,
-0.225852102,
0.3818155229,
0.3207994998,
0.1298545599,
0.0047281384,
-0.3028417528,
-0.2855088711,
0.0388051532,
-0.0033545878,
-0.7925540209,
-0.1118451133,
-0.0714273453,
-0.2824116647,
0.2634108961,
-0.2162147611,
-0.597869873,
-0.5054061413,
-0.4351731241,
0.4592226446,
-0.3667445481,
-0.2797940969,
0.0205728486,
-0.1081645042,
0.2175044715,
0.5040937066,
-0.7566378713,
0.4899265766,
0.7584823966,
0.88489604,
-0.3784863651,
-0.0302628372,
-0.8432241082,
0.4103064239,
-0.1218133196,
0.9072076082,
-0.6261000633,
-0.4847489297,
-0.1631536335,
0.0005985784,
-0.3030892611,
-0.5986242294,
0.5887480974,
-0.7050719857,
0.0672483444,
-0.0188506264,
-0.9618449807,
-0.3770899177,
0.0290795583,
-0.609698832,
0.8912988305,
-0.1720046699,
-0.4831081629,
0.1828600168,
-0.7082095146,
-0.3705853224,
0.1485936344,
-0.0832916275,
-0.0864085183,
0.2520449758,
0.3241568506,
0.0702719018,
-0.2665542662,
0.1604931951,
-0.0453228056,
-0.5719085932,
0.072334148,
-0.5987638235,
0.5224929452,
0.1314706355,
-0.0577725694,
0.1248293668,
-0.7415752411,
-0.0345693566,
-0.0517581105,
-0.5237461329,
-0.4077329934,
0.0630717874,
0.3729133606,
0.2168049663,
0.2538197637,
-0.4218558669,
-0.1301526427,
-0.5341806412,
0.4849772155,
0.6159030795,
-0.0531575754,
0.5214778185,
0.0541570894,
0.3392801881,
0.237736389,
-0.446406126,
-0.3583440185,
-0.3972330987,
-0.7278413177,
-0.3255472183,
0.297732383,
0.7452454567,
-0.9211987853,
0.5231466889,
-0.4633597136,
-0.0814507082,
-0.7479947805,
0.1386601925,
0.4689488113,
0.7399805784,
0.3572537899,
-0.1197834313,
-0.5108359456,
-0.6728996038,
-0.5261208415,
-0.2154404968,
-0.1914395243,
0.4819202721,
0.1497115642,
-0.2350450307,
0.9491407871,
-0.3319114149,
-0.4160407484,
-0.3715925217,
-0.1164271459,
0.0697263703,
0.3138691187,
0.1886605322,
-0.760312438,
-0.1733929217,
-0.1852770001,
-0.5166124701,
-0.0176232737,
0.2400851548,
0.3723110259,
0.463924408,
0.4483090639,
-0.4685891867,
0.589897573,
0.6531711817,
-0.6536008716,
-0.0181566682,
-0.2771650255,
0.0425719544,
-1.2400009632,
-0.0532741845,
0.0385019556,
-0.4743303061,
-0.9576710463,
-0.3179982603,
0.0472400077,
-0.2542399168,
-0.5469577312,
0.6724208593,
-0.4751874506,
-0.4112955034,
-0.5416679382,
0.7455484867,
0.168605268,
0.44569996,
0.107318908,
1.3337510824,
0.3495225608,
-0.5008116364,
0.2557516396,
0.425126791,
-0.3175845444,
0.4447063208,
-0.6900186539,
0.5008097291,
-0.2297713459,
0.4933877885,
-1.0933903456,
0.0224398617,
0.1045288146,
-0.5247040391,
0.3802596629,
-0.2205984294,
-0.4652860165,
0.0806999505,
-0.0711767897,
0.4529959857,
0.2697892487,
-0.8593597412,
0.9945226312,
0.5547330976,
-0.3286668658,
-0.4358022809,
-0.8129359484,
0.234867394,
-0.0328723714,
-0.7575155497,
0.5491662621,
0.0185579024,
-0.0249789357,
0.1152722314,
-0.2152931392,
-0.111586079,
-0.0169717148,
0.2760215998,
0.3991705477,
-0.316064477,
0.3799872398,
0.0389263816,
-0.1195206195,
-0.0598257259,
-0.3072049618,
0.6630871892,
-0.0281505715,
-0.3035653234,
-0.6984220743,
0.2874824703,
0.4701010883,
-0.0911095217,
0.8235957623,
0.4854203761,
-0.5766596198,
0.2451805472,
-0.6088157892,
-0.1931394041,
-0.384372592,
0.6536810994,
-0.5860596895,
-1.2379301786,
0.4780358374,
-0.1287855655,
-0.0517299399,
0.3935733438,
0.381945014,
-0.0326795913,
0.9724135995,
0.4593507946,
-0.3346141875,
0.5417366028,
0.1610256732,
0.4075677097,
-1.2245066166,
-0.3504740298,
-0.4536527395,
-0.0905016586,
-0.4616502523,
-0.5762986541,
0.342956841,
0.1814650893,
0.0430973284,
0.1560347527,
-0.2545849383,
0.3335050344,
0.4158785343,
0.1506337672,
0.5828563571,
0.2241633087,
0.1340123117,
-0.266114831,
-0.5368704796,
-0.4451214373,
0.7407470345,
0.4453580379,
0.6889720559,
0.2124890536,
0.3664273322,
0.2123269439,
-0.0912248343,
-0.9050753117,
0.4832351506,
-0.3376262188,
-0.4349320531,
-0.2174636722,
-0.4193280637,
-0.6153311729,
0.4131454229,
-0.049819909,
-1.030197382,
0.0669694394,
0.3308973908,
-0.2524621487,
0.2652153969,
-0.7863590121,
0.4641532898,
-0.0843829885,
-0.1595678926,
-0.461186558,
-0.4346026778,
0.1937529147,
0.1084697694,
0.0859890655,
-0.1940862834,
-0.2587519884,
0.8564779758,
-0.2014985681,
0.6244178414,
-0.4424335063,
-0.1013596803,
0.3752067387,
-0.2070805132,
0.7377508283,
0.1526355892,
-0.2210361212,
0.2533118427,
-0.1171548888,
-0.2103673369,
-0.8118010163,
0.8575202823,
-0.6706216931,
-0.6450136304,
-0.2728805244,
-0.7250121832,
-0.2942698598,
-0.13128151,
0.0101973349,
0.6333017349,
0.0164167359,
0.1360848397,
0.8653360605,
-0.2237433046,
0.393702507,
0.6169167757,
-0.179428041,
-0.5452356339,
0.9005471468,
0.0042816279,
0.2982199192,
0.3907344639,
-0.1304631531,
-0.8118624091,
-0.6213325262,
-0.5681846142,
0.2197427452,
-0.6736837626,
-0.1984242201,
-0.8170074224,
-0.434763819,
-0.5289857984,
0.3236536384,
-0.2074858844,
-0.5183035135,
-0.6231863499,
-0.050166931,
0.6107521653,
0.5519908071,
0.0270534009,
0.4749789834,
-0.6980474591,
0.4884207249,
0.2863524258,
0.3598227203,
-0.1183645427,
-1.1554050446,
-0.0319454037,
0.1668743789,
-0.0739427209,
-0.6318361759,
0.2723634541,
0.3445800245,
0.3569881916,
0.1611475945,
-0.2210007906,
1.0806524754,
-0.6212634444,
0.8529230356,
0.2096266299,
-1.1623716354,
0.6607245803,
-0.0211136825,
0.3072961867,
0.4379627705,
-0.2750959694,
-0.6857891679,
-0.0542318188,
-0.1631786823,
-0.8856092095,
1.068934679,
0.1456756294,
0.0612146296,
0.2292611748,
0.5206715465,
-0.2675032616,
0.093496412,
-0.4653112292,
-0.5061725974,
-0.0425381027,
-0.3204935193,
-0.2051158398,
-0.5542090535,
0.0747518539,
-0.1757042855,
0.7235018015,
-0.1149372905,
0.411749959,
0.2576627433,
-0.4801014066,
-0.0161853246,
0.4347526133,
0.7765355706,
0.6442714334,
-0.0755423605,
0.2580678463,
0.5884349346,
-0.6326191425,
0.0191832166,
0.4758202732,
0.078132458,
0.1355433315,
0.2951623499,
1.2016215324,
0.2324444503,
-0.7887510657,
0.3286818564,
-0.1664365828,
0.0214729551,
-0.2503555417,
0.0376753099,
0.2655097246,
0.302639395,
0.4829639792,
0.0340298116,
0.339061439,
-0.3506987393,
0.0793039873,
0.3665693104,
-0.5734872818,
-0.3099690974,
0.592176199,
0.2021204531,
-0.6439522505,
0.6071842313,
0.0674888119,
-0.5533136725,
0.4269553125,
0.9487839341,
0.6882096529,
-0.3395815194,
-0.2163298279,
-0.0069849002,
0.0403817631,
0.0100425677,
0.1612589657,
-0.15156883,
-0.7644783854,
-0.5906432271,
-0.4547999203,
-0.2970979512,
0.1852528751,
-0.7407271266,
0.1054470167,
-0.0378781222,
-0.0261086114,
0.0161975082,
0.0340472311,
-0.5784344673,
0.1349458843,
0.1810492128,
0.9773216248,
-0.5150510669,
1.006074667,
0.7681530118,
-0.0287245214,
-0.8050984144,
0.0589604005,
0.0517190211,
-0.9659437537,
0.464066416,
0.1544485092,
-0.3566105962,
0.2425942421,
-0.0778261796,
-0.8843636513,
1.1426827908,
0.4559069872,
-0.9363964796,
-0.1130264774,
0.1653404832,
0.4829548299,
-0.314835459,
0.3092161119,
0.7754245996,
0.2349292785,
0.3293319046,
-1.0381301641,
-0.135593459,
-0.0426318012,
0.3132870197,
0.3603946269,
-0.3454912007,
0.393900454,
-0.0976098776,
-0.2398313731,
0.0143176941,
0.7636470795,
0.5044687986,
0.7349902391,
0.7094516754,
0.5449538827,
0.7748995423,
-0.0376624018,
0.6764711738,
-0.3271518648,
0.3321355283,
1.4949989319,
-0.3445467055,
0.9923657179,
0.6390975118,
-0.0260445122,
0.1814423501,
0.4781737924,
0.4030055106,
0.601311028,
-0.0064795143,
-0.6986814737,
-0.2328823358,
-0.4929659367,
-0.2108910084,
0.546005547,
0.7676491141,
-0.2814314365,
-0.1159377769,
0.1976449043,
-0.0741194785,
0.2503089607,
-0.3754086792,
1.1668266058,
0.1736519188,
-0.43994084,
0.3172929287,
-0.140617162,
0.7353317142,
-0.2387090176,
-0.1171165183,
-0.0791853666,
0.2330282182,
-0.1015653461,
-0.7228729129,
0.425131768,
0.0884591714,
-0.4325889647,
-0.034641888,
0.9398975968,
-0.7622151971,
-0.4166543484,
0.461828351,
0.4626610279,
0.2087036222,
-0.0514444038,
-0.5518753529,
0.3332368731,
0.0292429514,
-0.0865763724,
0.2309027612,
0.2842870653,
0.1272132844,
0.5370064974,
0.4109275341,
0.0966687649,
-0.0201457068,
0.2378930598,
0.8537697196,
-0.6206804514,
-0.2905208766,
-0.8594689965,
0.2403345704,
-0.1017871648,
-0.0075088213,
0.3549636602,
0.7312600017,
0.5349906683,
0.267835021,
0.6569535136,
0.1637391001,
0.8983931541,
-0.6817238927,
0.5990104675,
-0.5147371888,
0.4637174308,
-0.0825490206,
-0.8266639709,
-0.1801745445,
0.4657391012,
-0.1122470573,
-0.1416252106,
0.4066356421,
0.8749721646,
0.0545840263,
0.1591022015,
0.4625201821,
0.1655091494,
0.4699581861,
0.4634686708,
0.8003591299,
-0.6638614535,
0.665124774,
0.0186848231,
-0.0276792329,
-0.0936582685,
-0.516960144,
-0.8750494123,
-0.6169669628,
-0.2720912993,
-0.4011603296,
0.2831139863,
1.151525259,
0.7292481065,
-0.7830271721,
-0.1041831225,
-0.0876842439,
0.1317741722,
0.1762411892,
-0.2331187576,
0.3690671623,
-0.2870629132,
-0.8717186451,
0.7560212612,
0.5033252835,
0.0061445255,
0.1146038473,
-0.2025903165,
-0.062206123,
-0.0376090407,
0.726626575,
0.0121093569,
-1.1382011175,
-0.3597646356,
-0.0375561491,
0.0585779399,
0.0819212124,
0.8636831045,
-0.9181137085,
0.5948672891,
0.2144652158,
0.9554470778,
0.6428358555,
0.0427239202,
0.3663449585,
-0.6742678881,
0.3332332075,
0.2866574228,
0.3306034505,
0.3448407352,
-0.4185398221,
0.2069656402,
0.1168082207,
-0.5676714182,
-0.8341339827,
0.1023590043,
-1.0475091934,
-0.0201799106,
1.0134397745,
-0.1787028313,
-0.0512211286,
-0.2502887845,
-0.2960384488,
0.4776573777,
-0.7150745988,
0.5067119002,
0.4890030622,
-0.251924932,
-0.4954644144,
-0.4909519553,
0.3842110336,
0.4782130122,
-0.8734891415,
0.0046039307,
0.4224759042,
0.3515682518,
0.0961530879,
0.4960089326,
0.1064484566,
0.1161094606,
-0.2984421253,
-0.1758381128,
0.0297936108,
-0.1367968768,
-0.6841185689,
-0.1319820285,
0.0659584329,
-0.4321947694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05561v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05561v1 | Privacy- and Utility-Preserving NLP with Anonymized Data: A case study of Pseudonymization | 2023-06-08T21:06:19 | 2023-06-08T21:06:19 | Oleksandr Yermilov, Vipul Raheja, Artem Chernodub | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work investigates the effectiveness of different pseudonymization
techniques, ranging from rule-based substitutions to using pre-trained Large
Language Models (LLMs), on a variety of datasets and models used for two widely
used NLP tasks: text classification and summarization. Our work provides
crucial insights into the gaps between original and anonymized data (focusing
on the pseudonymization technique) and model quality and fosters future
research into higher-quality anonymization techniques to better balance the
trade-offs between data protection and utility preservation. We make our code,
pseudonymized datasets, and downstream models publicly available | [
-0.0081502367,
-0.4703269601,
0.264775157,
0.3588624597,
0.0300374944,
0.2235681862,
-0.1628639251,
-0.5266848803,
0.5568453074,
1.098377943,
-0.2655035257,
-0.5966484547,
-0.5125165582,
0.1504416615,
-0.5539124608,
1.1014451981,
0.1390407234,
0.1718736291,
-0.21323286,
-0.0933015868,
-0.1139588133,
-1.0304739475,
-0.7518485188,
-0.0689381957,
0.4674997032,
0.106726326,
0.7800729275,
0.8430939913,
0.3688136637,
0.1846238226,
-0.0847110301,
-0.0486744009,
-0.513526082,
0.2305041701,
-0.0315375887,
-0.4594852328,
-0.3364224732,
0.2244357467,
0.795665741,
0.6906198859,
-0.3514519632,
0.4621827602,
-0.0873159245,
0.6259632111,
-0.7746417522,
0.1539882869,
-0.3814885318,
0.1928753555,
-0.2866645753,
-0.3593485355,
-0.462043196,
-0.7008088827,
-0.0668530017,
-0.3494449556,
0.2479382008,
0.4505377114,
0.6963977814,
0.3742819428,
-0.0133438678,
-0.1500092745,
-0.808542788,
0.9574978948,
-0.8384507298,
0.1984524876,
0.8125591874,
0.2280545235,
0.2205403745,
-0.9525178671,
-0.2667565048,
-0.1848932803,
-0.4541477561,
0.0848455653,
-0.2004598975,
0.1046881676,
0.3602586091,
0.5230686665,
-0.4319060445,
0.5311729908,
-0.3268088102,
-0.3739334047,
0.9408642054,
0.1456798911,
0.0846470669,
-0.212226361,
-0.3569639623,
0.130483821,
-0.8323459029,
0.092777282,
0.8556352854,
0.0384767279,
-0.0378227122,
0.7100502253,
-0.2652213871,
0.573513329,
-0.400570631,
-0.1510043293,
0.1487525553,
-0.4428325891,
-0.2177699059,
0.0177840944,
0.6132326722,
0.4987298846,
0.1327111274,
-0.4165785909,
-0.0670849532,
-0.23568286,
0.090419203,
-0.5810585022,
-0.3152576983,
0.3459275365,
-0.8165280223,
-0.1775642931,
-0.0512947813,
-0.7118150592,
-0.6308169365,
-0.4706712365,
0.1115368605,
-0.0176006593,
-0.0445549637,
0.536013782,
-0.3010675609,
0.1592041701,
0.1238084659,
-1.1566486359,
0.7534836531,
0.6014422774,
0.8438299298,
-0.3285008073,
-0.1598283798,
-0.2855506539,
0.1951484382,
-0.134220019,
0.1393385381,
-0.0900391489,
-0.3920987546,
0.0906427503,
-0.0598118305,
-0.0940163508,
-0.4922443926,
0.4104084373,
-0.4730043113,
0.4288003743,
-0.2745777071,
-0.8230338097,
-0.3093770742,
0.095561929,
-0.780492425,
0.7963895202,
0.008456273,
-1.0510855913,
0.1041167155,
-0.710308969,
-0.1043137312,
0.1360635012,
0.0274955761,
-0.5591404438,
0.0551351383,
-0.0805122778,
0.6884588003,
-0.0206063632,
0.1975108832,
-0.0365551636,
-0.1499611735,
0.3643386662,
-0.3313173056,
1.3457937241,
0.0692531392,
0.0874007791,
0.0263655446,
-0.6759406924,
-0.2306543291,
0.0918266773,
-0.0656735599,
-0.4808400273,
0.09980762,
0.2095142454,
-0.1391679347,
0.6550232172,
-0.6760579348,
0.1739462018,
-0.4582017958,
0.3378207088,
0.5181891918,
0.1340378225,
0.441096127,
-0.6246535182,
0.7423903942,
-0.5075247288,
0.3028452396,
-0.1433176696,
-0.546813786,
-0.5801128745,
-0.4227410555,
0.7002796531,
0.7574837208,
-0.475294292,
0.4160426855,
-0.1445770711,
-0.2693807781,
-0.4000231624,
-0.0431867875,
0.3358713388,
0.3859266341,
0.3366864324,
-0.2623152435,
-0.6031219363,
-1.0603067875,
-0.3893826604,
0.238148272,
-0.3052095473,
0.2921690643,
0.2920290828,
-0.1738344878,
1.0551413298,
-0.5554273129,
-0.4321668446,
-0.287799865,
-0.0101176621,
-0.0403791815,
0.6153165102,
0.8524002433,
-0.7984490395,
-0.3881760538,
-0.3591808379,
-0.7213680148,
-0.2250639051,
-0.0993370712,
0.0415226966,
-0.0568850636,
0.6338935494,
-0.336140573,
0.6387951374,
0.8348681927,
-0.1589133441,
0.5906142592,
-0.3628458679,
0.1338711381,
-1.1173499823,
0.0591787361,
-0.2389083803,
-0.4991423786,
-0.9418846369,
0.0025996468,
-0.0493583567,
-0.0533583574,
-0.3520253003,
0.5852752328,
-0.4945301712,
-0.0863068849,
-0.2250498086,
-0.3806214929,
-0.1386054158,
0.2161684632,
0.1580150425,
0.7111073732,
0.7422712445,
-0.5374310017,
0.2121536583,
0.4227724075,
-0.2213398814,
-0.0272704028,
-0.5554072857,
0.110925965,
-0.2279050499,
-0.0356427245,
-0.7375155687,
-0.3786146045,
0.268604517,
-0.2494573593,
0.215349257,
-0.1708978117,
-0.9901436567,
0.1521885842,
-0.6639550924,
0.3165150583,
0.5695729256,
-0.6890568733,
0.638148129,
0.6197066903,
-0.4577247202,
-0.7783018351,
-0.6920781136,
0.3953205645,
-0.4643611908,
-0.2099561393,
0.6282821298,
-0.0652905926,
-0.3106447458,
0.0155792739,
0.1067455634,
-0.2355589718,
0.262055546,
0.328489244,
0.2444802523,
0.2545077503,
-0.047262419,
0.2340213656,
-0.1673118323,
0.2414564639,
-0.0023535718,
0.6098117232,
0.279270947,
0.0092632221,
-0.6676213145,
0.5044540763,
-0.0430658273,
-0.1385618746,
1.0785034895,
0.255969584,
-0.4328770936,
-0.276294589,
-0.6557176709,
-0.0914205983,
-0.4634573162,
-0.1043741927,
0.238553077,
-1.0805120468,
0.6624943614,
-0.0360824652,
0.3706254661,
0.0562588908,
0.1531989872,
-0.0907546058,
0.522711575,
0.8859083056,
-0.3504052758,
0.3937811852,
-0.3346404433,
0.3850999475,
-0.6325517297,
-0.1492597163,
-0.6127511263,
-0.0497717746,
-0.7963733673,
-0.1058360487,
0.1741594225,
-0.0647678375,
0.1647339314,
0.4324730933,
-0.416246444,
0.8392257094,
0.6206688285,
0.1378394812,
0.5159176588,
-0.0084802154,
0.593373239,
-0.1907482743,
-0.5310422182,
-0.5532090664,
1.4327328205,
0.3723313808,
0.4795023501,
0.1414500326,
1.0026712418,
0.4473047256,
0.2594716549,
-0.7179162502,
0.5638160706,
-0.4334010482,
-0.5903586745,
-0.5126969218,
-0.5442384481,
-1.0469582081,
0.0572591349,
-0.1896057427,
-1.1802737713,
0.0628777072,
0.2601537704,
-0.1891616583,
0.2513016462,
-0.5476792455,
0.6172148585,
0.0294495318,
-0.1582699716,
0.0688229129,
-0.8005775213,
0.6092496514,
-0.1645264924,
0.259347707,
0.0338372365,
-0.1694486588,
1.0368448496,
-0.210110873,
0.7354005575,
-0.1364677697,
0.0301458091,
-0.2203905433,
-0.1230110303,
0.244860515,
0.1490232199,
-0.0200468916,
0.6497184038,
0.0974693075,
-0.3389777243,
-0.5141793489,
0.5323654413,
-0.2633059025,
-0.5810487866,
-0.3030372858,
-0.5687922835,
-0.1373906732,
0.3129722178,
0.4627109468,
0.1836193651,
0.0286026541,
0.5702654123,
0.9671117663,
-0.2570607364,
0.8211894035,
0.3811003864,
-0.2001326084,
-0.2728283107,
0.7172098756,
0.2403259724,
0.1857956201,
0.4971115291,
0.2865575254,
-0.5372998118,
-0.7880156636,
0.0406192243,
0.3357127607,
-0.4316039383,
-0.1425259858,
-0.7646207213,
-0.5570869446,
-0.268707633,
-0.2212518901,
-0.4492000639,
-0.8477085829,
-0.3148057163,
-0.0555630289,
0.2443155944,
0.6343243122,
-0.1025053188,
0.3296706378,
-0.4847326577,
0.4985368848,
0.0430534519,
0.320319891,
-0.2563958466,
-0.304312259,
-0.131000638,
-0.2322804034,
0.195821479,
-0.8488361239,
0.6569746733,
0.0130026182,
0.591232419,
0.0609821752,
0.252712518,
-0.0125311762,
-0.3949730992,
1.0110986233,
0.2489807904,
-0.9624757171,
0.3196637034,
-0.3088575602,
0.0290151834,
0.6455168128,
0.553950429,
-0.3448547423,
-0.4533833861,
-0.6849406362,
-1.0185773373,
0.4721338153,
0.5372920036,
0.2517668903,
0.643203795,
0.3965834975,
0.3983011246,
0.6902247071,
-0.8125183582,
-0.691308856,
-0.1588486433,
-0.2705753744,
-0.2711455822,
-0.3355448544,
-0.3103060722,
-0.2327224016,
0.5312072039,
0.3720232844,
0.0084900241,
-0.1864819378,
0.0209476929,
0.7038913369,
0.1084386706,
0.4471987784,
0.5677643418,
-0.0629004017,
0.0703698099,
-0.0765899345,
-0.8024631739,
0.1146869287,
0.2004897445,
-0.7218583226,
0.2359638363,
-0.001737604,
0.461199373,
0.0742667839,
-0.5274991393,
0.590960443,
-0.2798427045,
-0.4138658047,
-0.5435665846,
0.1417312026,
-0.032914117,
-0.0574122556,
0.1954756975,
-0.0074347788,
0.6273527741,
-0.0309528764,
-0.0979717299,
0.3965353966,
0.4014698565,
-0.1293665469,
0.8926132917,
-0.322190702,
-0.5467728376,
0.2534059584,
-0.1804268807,
-0.0179514159,
0.3709556758,
0.1362580806,
0.9720938206,
-0.4810406566,
0.2900452912,
0.0267179981,
0.2174992859,
-0.3586081564,
0.0547885597,
-0.25637272,
-0.6433520913,
-0.184311375,
-0.4757041633,
-0.7531798482,
0.4239419997,
-0.9429581761,
0.1099453866,
-0.7628046274,
-0.217091158,
0.273211211,
-0.2008157074,
-0.3403275013,
-0.0231298953,
-0.2536877394,
0.5454619527,
-0.7656815052,
0.6354928017,
0.1651777774,
-0.0724666789,
-0.647934258,
0.099117808,
-0.1398363411,
-0.3296014965,
0.3495618701,
0.0048492854,
-0.2044110447,
0.2279144228,
-0.7915179133,
-0.9441421032,
1.05902493,
0.5185277462,
-0.3308086693,
0.1943857074,
0.0565077849,
0.6214382052,
-0.1136264279,
-0.4662679732,
0.5079380274,
0.2150928974,
-0.307180196,
-1.0321829319,
-0.1971209496,
-0.0646911785,
0.1265739501,
-0.0638870001,
-0.5919551849,
0.7147264481,
0.1587242037,
-0.2960277498,
0.2331464589,
0.2460818291,
0.1043957546,
0.4393235743,
0.1640893817,
0.2316731364,
0.7597368956,
0.0577160157,
1.0125159025,
-0.3553484976,
0.4501459897,
1.1111493111,
-0.2636057436,
0.6433255076,
0.3593847156,
-0.0500918366,
0.1953164935,
0.3610097766,
-0.096724622,
0.4983153641,
0.398940593,
-0.4013918936,
0.2641444206,
-0.2721890509,
-0.3055367768,
0.5086188912,
0.1692687124,
-0.3853602409,
0.0327734724,
-0.0455551669,
0.3200578094,
0.1956418306,
-0.199074626,
0.8137741685,
-0.1075326502,
-0.1799729466,
0.2098421305,
0.2792367637,
0.6487216353,
-0.6439486742,
0.0701205581,
-0.0783332139,
-0.2408914119,
-0.3086336255,
-0.4336500764,
0.4789019823,
0.0662292168,
-0.1759885848,
-0.7700327039,
0.6724175811,
-0.3946894705,
-0.2721761763,
0.0473083518,
0.3350728154,
0.3414803445,
0.3051267564,
-0.3822478652,
-0.2459547073,
-0.20939219,
-0.3397348821,
0.5463268161,
-0.2043705285,
0.1649152189,
0.7090263367,
0.5666225553,
0.3880270123,
0.1625863165,
0.2665460408,
0.5948585272,
-0.6115770936,
-0.8326153159,
-0.818864882,
0.3002716005,
-0.4972482622,
-0.2635570765,
1.29451406,
0.9562058449,
0.7589865923,
-0.371198684,
0.7629198432,
0.3658282161,
0.8969322443,
-0.9438428879,
0.9889038205,
-0.1502239406,
0.4432630837,
-0.0588747226,
-0.7838816643,
-0.5759033561,
0.4559679925,
-0.1118469015,
-0.1790834665,
0.494596988,
0.6949902177,
0.1873535067,
0.092578873,
0.421759814,
-0.160473302,
0.1065149605,
-0.0707127377,
0.7523225546,
-0.2176209539,
-0.4080714583,
-0.468534261,
-0.2225214541,
0.027751619,
-0.9720351696,
-0.9482182264,
-0.5110023022,
-0.5755053163,
-0.0696579665,
0.0452372059,
0.4097311497,
0.6677771807,
-0.7221633196,
-0.4721447229,
-0.10993056,
0.1209502593,
-0.1904602498,
-0.2084039748,
0.3080061972,
0.0228941981,
-0.6668543816,
0.2765850127,
0.2544809282,
0.3397621512,
-0.4321179986,
0.0751772821,
0.0869346485,
0.2569513917,
0.4748294652,
0.423884213,
-0.4829406738,
0.0615255162,
0.0295017473,
0.230089426,
-0.2776814699,
0.9144605398,
-0.3360401988,
0.3905341029,
0.3411398828,
0.7128119469,
0.5981337428,
0.2643569708,
0.3597840071,
-1.0933032036,
0.2195466608,
0.5207257867,
0.3180205226,
0.3105509281,
-0.6877662539,
0.4570726752,
0.0268805586,
-0.5935601592,
-1.0143824816,
0.1927807331,
-1.1335865259,
-0.1925150901,
1.1882688999,
-0.354298383,
0.0603912175,
-0.3594293296,
-0.074171789,
-0.1030330285,
-0.1356253028,
0.8963967562,
0.593390286,
-0.2851516008,
-0.1521152705,
-0.734434545,
0.9530822635,
0.0008227588,
-0.9332426786,
0.2934347093,
0.4807734191,
0.318778336,
0.1091562957,
0.8247388601,
-0.0994388983,
-0.0563524701,
-0.1136971265,
-0.1700729281,
-0.2423106581,
-0.459954232,
-0.5931431055,
0.3747377396,
-0.1939181536,
-0.3950539529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05556v1 | Emotion and Sentiment Guided Paraphrasing | 2023-06-08T20:59:40 | 2023-06-08T20:59:40 | Justin J. Xie, Ameeta Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Paraphrase generation, a.k.a. paraphrasing, is a common and important task in
natural language processing. Emotional paraphrasing, which changes the emotion
embodied in a piece of text while preserving its meaning, has many potential
applications, including moderating online dialogues and preventing
cyberbullying. We introduce a new task of fine-grained emotional paraphrasing
along emotion gradients, that is, altering the emotional intensities of the
paraphrases in fine-grained settings following smooth variations in affective
dimensions while preserving the meaning of the original text. We reconstruct
several widely used paraphrasing datasets by augmenting the input and target
texts with their fine-grained emotion labels. Then, we propose a framework for
emotion and sentiment guided paraphrasing by leveraging pre-trained language
models for conditioned text generation. Extensive evaluation of the fine-tuned
models suggests that including fine-grained emotion labels in the paraphrase
task significantly improves the likelihood of obtaining high-quality
paraphrases that reflect the desired emotions while achieving consistently
better scores in paraphrase metrics such as BLEU, ROUGE, and METEOR. | [
-0.3218608499,
-0.8567463756,
0.5814255476,
0.4184949398,
-0.4825096428,
-0.1966423988,
-0.0262849908,
-0.0536819696,
0.1218052804,
0.773362875,
-0.3926737309,
-0.4490662515,
-0.5059400797,
0.1561729163,
-0.4882447124,
1.4506924152,
-0.2884686589,
-0.0154240392,
-0.3566654325,
-0.1034359857,
0.1456781924,
-0.6129405499,
-0.5111577511,
-0.2518073916,
0.6227070093,
0.4949216545,
0.5934118032,
0.4478351772,
0.6746737361,
0.2706884146,
-0.2119530439,
-0.2227655351,
-0.3627323806,
0.5534014702,
-0.2310154289,
-0.50844419,
-0.3993548751,
0.0061306036,
0.3062473834,
0.4047369361,
-0.3580514491,
-0.1012948602,
0.3668530881,
0.7852629423,
-0.779727459,
0.1894145161,
-0.5486802459,
0.278167367,
-0.1548043638,
-0.4080371857,
-0.1577281356,
-0.7886736393,
0.2488783002,
-0.3409014344,
0.3553895354,
-0.0854232162,
0.5998109579,
0.3887635469,
-0.1584438533,
-0.7532889843,
-0.1725414544,
0.797727704,
-0.7676599622,
-0.248349458,
0.3129134178,
-0.0412910953,
0.2474202514,
-1.0319024324,
-0.3775587976,
-0.0087549137,
-0.0783518776,
0.1401374638,
-0.2048940957,
0.2070310712,
0.0857193321,
0.4442580342,
-0.1502643973,
-0.3821742535,
-0.1049293131,
-0.0209236331,
0.4084631205,
0.1494512409,
0.340392828,
-0.4934240282,
-0.2503097951,
-0.2477541566,
-0.1487619579,
0.154709667,
0.1418611705,
0.3675085902,
0.1302149892,
0.4231386185,
-0.420784533,
0.2859711945,
0.1441932619,
0.1018266752,
0.2787650228,
-0.0104359007,
-0.3968502879,
0.0723958015,
0.635050118,
0.8612946868,
0.6127391458,
-0.0238893591,
-0.220869571,
0.1036592647,
0.2363484204,
-0.9376474023,
-0.3986187875,
0.0172179956,
-0.5345146656,
-0.4967308342,
-0.0999343172,
-1.7225542068,
-0.5704579353,
-0.4753317237,
0.3834365606,
-0.4971375763,
0.301217854,
0.0040721232,
-0.3375943899,
0.0445076264,
0.049594447,
-0.786976099,
0.3264415264,
0.6671677828,
0.8000189066,
0.1800426841,
-0.3098913729,
-0.6098756194,
-0.1080936491,
-0.1032113731,
0.6026004553,
-0.9668927789,
-0.418043524,
0.0879567564,
-0.0133094275,
0.0095807407,
-0.4631317258,
0.8328217864,
-0.0915121883,
0.1322773099,
-0.2857567668,
-0.4962326884,
-0.1642384976,
0.1788691133,
-0.1798718423,
0.9425508976,
0.0698721111,
-0.6685603857,
-0.2162655294,
-0.0956083685,
-0.6831905246,
-0.2610316873,
0.3094930351,
-0.3359091282,
0.6273682117,
0.2814264894,
0.8848691583,
-0.3103955388,
0.0335630886,
-0.378513217,
0.0109584574,
0.0810800046,
-0.2733943462,
0.1975067258,
0.3678739071,
-0.4459882677,
-0.2460220754,
-0.7548401356,
0.1560851038,
-0.1247726381,
-0.0809700415,
-0.7694779038,
0.0174564552,
0.0234617367,
0.6069514751,
0.3265605867,
-0.5410398245,
-0.3150064349,
-0.3168843985,
0.4809563756,
0.5787118673,
0.4663027227,
0.5762357116,
-0.1222695485,
0.7596312761,
-0.0917004198,
0.1340872645,
-0.1221633404,
-0.1176344454,
-0.5090575218,
0.0671642125,
-0.1899080724,
0.4740533233,
-0.7547231913,
-0.0650295913,
0.0990208685,
-0.6778247356,
-0.7354894876,
0.2560465634,
0.4504777789,
0.8200339079,
0.8685228229,
0.0262204688,
-0.2902081013,
-0.7253456116,
-0.5314134359,
0.2707258463,
0.1024709269,
0.2176925093,
0.0685545653,
0.0721332878,
0.5483664274,
-0.6281368732,
-0.0008182228,
-0.3253076375,
0.5823474526,
-0.4215375483,
0.3792515993,
0.6527466774,
-0.8118857145,
-0.708060503,
-0.1412116438,
-0.7623089552,
-0.5573103428,
-0.2621830106,
-0.5025109053,
-0.3160598278,
0.7298388481,
-0.7575243711,
0.1885854304,
0.4137482941,
-0.3822639287,
0.2713830471,
-0.1749190688,
0.4239105582,
-1.2134487629,
-0.2290899009,
0.196757406,
0.0748977214,
-0.5664178133,
0.1376065314,
-0.0484668203,
-0.0531448349,
-0.5494219065,
0.4228971899,
-0.2398872674,
0.2480860949,
-0.5731215477,
0.2776126266,
0.3485200703,
0.465359062,
-0.115047656,
0.2599679232,
0.7542579174,
-0.6046319604,
0.4078837037,
0.4083672464,
-0.0887212306,
1.0773360729,
-0.4733523726,
-0.0482697561,
-0.5871815085,
0.2804191709,
-0.6037586927,
-0.1992944628,
0.1602707654,
-0.125526309,
0.0993990153,
0.1971752197,
-0.181710124,
-0.1576625407,
-0.4988355041,
0.1703525782,
0.731138885,
-0.3129560649,
0.4747329652,
-0.0674943551,
-0.7075865269,
-0.125993371,
-0.5965359211,
0.2548396587,
-0.6234394312,
-0.1213402227,
0.2242588848,
-0.0706383064,
-0.3950131536,
-0.3089778423,
0.0194311664,
-0.1538696587,
0.1516501307,
0.2895859182,
-0.1474044919,
-0.0137072634,
0.1466903687,
0.3184167147,
0.1243853867,
0.3379463553,
0.1434451491,
0.5035743713,
-0.0349117666,
0.2338841259,
-0.4142052531,
0.6192493439,
0.7943775654,
-0.3332130015,
0.4402489066,
0.7245886922,
-0.3298702836,
-0.1838163137,
-0.0912929475,
-0.1225041747,
-0.4633088708,
0.3383516669,
-0.2289374024,
-0.4621340334,
0.1578235924,
-0.1143361926,
-0.1461027712,
0.290564239,
0.4306247532,
-0.3807391822,
1.0103571415,
0.1236820221,
0.0352236517,
0.5019624829,
0.3246286809,
0.085274376,
-0.8145220876,
-0.1218619347,
-0.6638790369,
-0.7232480645,
-0.5508207083,
-0.331289947,
-0.070769228,
0.2965024114,
-0.0186200757,
-0.0504304171,
-0.5048533082,
0.3297133446,
0.7336604595,
0.4024375379,
-0.2698331475,
0.0002985466,
0.246208325,
-0.2890184522,
-0.2425253391,
-0.5600324869,
0.6770695448,
0.0199729893,
0.6686037183,
-0.2978385687,
1.0076098442,
0.2502475679,
0.1734142601,
-0.6032015681,
0.7662588358,
-0.4488539398,
-0.2067923844,
0.0016725045,
-0.3855204284,
-0.6754857302,
-0.0441191941,
0.0736599043,
-0.8529551625,
0.1319345236,
0.3632077575,
-0.3761049509,
0.0490565971,
-0.6184267998,
0.8543200493,
-0.0416723862,
-0.2556550503,
-0.1429167837,
-0.983314693,
0.1264079362,
-0.1075799465,
0.0855878964,
-0.3287338614,
0.3012758195,
0.7536097169,
-0.4927805662,
0.7038024068,
-0.500469327,
0.0952618569,
0.5509483218,
0.3821046054,
0.5792672634,
-0.2720677853,
-0.3922740817,
-0.4519488215,
0.0264559314,
-0.3664721847,
-0.5894965529,
0.7683649063,
-0.2454056442,
-0.3623733819,
0.0480553359,
-0.5945264697,
-0.4057384133,
-0.1254855841,
0.4882882535,
0.4387953877,
-0.0033077067,
0.5587004423,
0.620847106,
-0.2038746774,
0.6141664982,
-0.2044386268,
0.1333300322,
-0.4220612049,
1.1794940233,
-0.3048481941,
0.3937216997,
0.5493462086,
0.4118731618,
0.0323601589,
-0.2328221202,
0.175508976,
0.0779722035,
-0.8916195631,
-0.301125735,
-0.8859989643,
0.1746709645,
-0.4002659619,
-0.7371052504,
-0.2308428735,
-0.2420855165,
-0.6257283688,
-0.2714913785,
0.4834657311,
0.4430857301,
0.0314115807,
0.6300984621,
-0.9758923054,
0.4691330194,
0.4829950333,
-0.068927601,
0.0989213958,
-0.4980824888,
-0.1097755581,
0.2172715664,
-0.4229971468,
-0.7594075203,
0.8033401966,
0.4621067345,
0.0636488348,
0.394494921,
0.3953919411,
0.6862265468,
-0.5709174871,
1.0197483301,
0.1448140442,
-1.2457081079,
0.6790386438,
-0.2415259331,
0.295881927,
0.7487854958,
0.2633158565,
-0.5890552998,
-0.6845449209,
-0.6549450755,
-1.0968712568,
0.5139138699,
0.1325986981,
0.5964627862,
-0.3825112879,
0.4646405578,
0.1571308672,
0.4485725164,
-0.741574347,
-0.0204736777,
-0.4354120493,
-0.9803308249,
-0.363956511,
-0.4937391579,
0.0748956129,
-0.1276565343,
0.4802687168,
0.0436828882,
0.2076831609,
0.0969798118,
-0.0957402065,
-0.0576007813,
0.362890631,
0.4211610854,
-0.1403760016,
-0.0567117892,
0.3890964985,
0.0774838924,
-0.2459735423,
0.1200208664,
0.1613942683,
0.0415910594,
0.1033358127,
0.1065872833,
1.0114892721,
0.4688616991,
-0.5183334947,
0.3466233611,
0.2423353195,
-0.2550248206,
0.5121899843,
0.016048409,
0.0104943644,
0.5708448887,
0.2127903998,
0.0169948973,
0.345928967,
-0.5823299885,
0.2420914322,
0.1119073629,
-0.4690147638,
-0.5123110414,
0.7429043055,
0.256085664,
-0.3881478906,
0.2957975268,
-0.0252725594,
-0.6594699025,
0.4812909067,
0.4840883613,
1.2323417664,
-0.4671866298,
0.4920873046,
0.1637437046,
-0.1539650261,
-0.3352669775,
0.3670651913,
-0.3067775965,
-0.3881360292,
0.2139657289,
-1.0588004589,
-0.4549867809,
-0.2554142475,
-1.0589489937,
0.0610807687,
-0.3491398692,
0.0569501296,
-0.1778361201,
-0.6835727692,
-0.3539815545,
0.9294402003,
0.5348285437,
0.5110402703,
-0.7590124607,
0.4602877498,
0.6933461428,
-0.0818994641,
-0.7653841376,
0.3688904643,
-0.2252734005,
-0.5184922218,
0.3516277671,
0.2756773233,
-0.0569832474,
0.4690562487,
-0.5160065293,
-0.5090767741,
0.8092475533,
0.2306919396,
-0.1692622304,
-0.2772116959,
0.1711052656,
0.7829836607,
-0.213734448,
-0.0333916321,
0.5093700886,
0.3506863117,
0.0624553561,
-0.2543509901,
-0.0184580572,
-0.1884615123,
-0.0168663356,
0.206751585,
-0.5366538167,
1.1074229479,
0.2995146513,
0.2844871581,
0.0478326567,
0.5909297466,
-0.1206674278,
0.4206761718,
0.3206937313,
0.4509724975,
0.5681296587,
-0.1115561724,
1.0642185211,
-0.4985665381,
0.3214689493,
1.0078659058,
-0.1753571332,
0.7464622259,
0.6168431044,
0.2064795047,
0.3674015403,
0.3992958069,
0.3152042627,
0.8147121668,
0.053297773,
-0.4117953479,
-0.2333105057,
-0.2014212012,
-0.0726520866,
0.4001393914,
0.3654880822,
-0.7191812992,
-0.4083604217,
0.4757884741,
0.2574283183,
0.2472710907,
-0.5902872682,
0.730599165,
0.4344780147,
-0.8216674328,
0.3493591547,
-0.055707559,
0.532764554,
-0.4273535013,
0.1634494066,
-0.594343245,
0.1937356889,
-0.2359017134,
-0.8796037436,
0.22721681,
0.4084665179,
0.0501565561,
-0.7312852144,
0.4197679758,
-0.6915259361,
-0.4254572988,
0.2482785583,
0.2402153313,
0.0166784823,
-0.3704480529,
-0.6091264486,
-0.3027504683,
0.2259709239,
-0.8157482743,
0.3247965574,
1.0943670273,
0.3893864751,
0.38614133,
0.1562360674,
-0.0839424729,
0.0459886342,
0.017203385,
0.5713374019,
-0.9192013741,
-0.5761315823,
-1.2152898312,
0.5379664898,
-0.0723626316,
-0.4512698054,
0.8407880068,
0.1058178842,
0.0618053973,
-0.2356214821,
0.7197206616,
-0.0680840015,
0.2456621826,
-0.5125434399,
0.4160894156,
-0.5462999344,
-0.3607363403,
-1.0245904922,
-0.9387765527,
-0.0630133748,
0.7393651009,
-0.1707233191,
-0.2802816629,
0.6359438896,
0.5785962939,
0.1284039319,
0.07075423,
0.2353173643,
0.2008285373,
0.1414899379,
0.4505110383,
0.690772295,
-0.262678355,
0.5707753897,
-0.4191630781,
-0.0290845428,
-0.2782623172,
-0.7523932457,
-0.5956865549,
-0.3574669361,
-0.5746420622,
-0.2318957001,
-0.0387721844,
0.7977356911,
0.0497364402,
-0.5809346437,
0.1934645623,
-0.5954148769,
-0.1955970526,
-0.0614539161,
-0.3198990822,
-0.0039055878,
-0.5684961677,
-1.0382801294,
0.1377078593,
0.2068620622,
0.2667125463,
0.3936181068,
0.0999601781,
-0.1282977611,
0.5753653049,
0.6249997616,
0.1033270508,
-0.3167591691,
-0.4749494493,
-0.2407699972,
-0.4113576412,
0.0257910639,
0.6036176682,
-0.391717881,
0.2291914076,
0.3939013779,
0.5741271377,
0.1852952689,
0.4622117877,
0.612474978,
-0.9774941802,
0.1106326282,
0.424220562,
0.338347435,
0.4818136692,
-0.1578350365,
0.0796770304,
0.1643385589,
-0.6134752035,
-0.7213975191,
-0.0152224768,
-0.9431440234,
-0.3256433606,
1.3822772503,
-0.3161274791,
-0.0478249229,
0.4024580717,
-0.5181310177,
0.4958233237,
-0.3431269526,
0.822353363,
0.8590747118,
0.0330859274,
-0.1479746997,
-0.2221988142,
0.7613027692,
0.7244100571,
-0.9851415157,
0.4149305224,
0.5152416229,
-0.1069941819,
-0.1677533686,
0.0591871291,
0.167200014,
0.0327480659,
0.0695624053,
0.3868438303,
0.3395006657,
-0.0844774395,
-0.1850888878,
0.54644835,
-0.2428602874,
-0.2339908481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05550v1 | Bias Against 93 Stigmatized Groups in Masked Language Models and Downstream Sentiment Classification Tasks | 2023-06-08T20:46:09 | 2023-06-08T20:46:09 | Katelyn X. Mei, Sonia Fereidooni, Aylin Caliskan | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, K.4; I.2.7; I.2.0 | The rapid deployment of artificial intelligence (AI) models demands a
thorough investigation of biases and risks inherent in these models to
understand their impact on individuals and society. This study extends the
focus of bias evaluation in extant work by examining bias against social
stigmas on a large scale. It focuses on 93 stigmatized groups in the United
States, including a wide range of conditions related to disease, disability,
drug use, mental illness, religion, sexuality, socioeconomic status, and other
relevant factors. We investigate bias against these groups in English
pre-trained Masked Language Models (MLMs) and their downstream sentiment
classification tasks. To evaluate the presence of bias against 93 stigmatized
conditions, we identify 29 non-stigmatized conditions to conduct a comparative
analysis. Building upon a psychology scale of social rejection, the Social
Distance Scale, we prompt six MLMs: RoBERTa-base, RoBERTa-large, XLNet-large,
BERTweet-base, BERTweet-large, and DistilBERT. We use human annotations to
analyze the predicted words from these models, with which we measure the extent
of bias against stigmatized groups. When prompts include stigmatized
conditions, the probability of MLMs predicting negative words is approximately
20 percent higher than when prompts have non-stigmatized conditions. In the
sentiment classification tasks, when sentences include stigmatized conditions
related to diseases, disability, education, and mental illness, they are more
likely to be classified as negative. We also observe a strong correlation
between bias in MLMs and their downstream sentiment classifiers (r =0.79). The
evidence indicates that MLMs and their downstream sentiment classification
tasks exhibit biases against socially stigmatized groups. | [
-0.5235059857,
-0.6878184676,
0.3544384539,
0.3450186253,
0.0391783528,
0.1097624078,
-0.2509186566,
-0.4852335155,
0.4326616526,
0.4735257924,
-0.5281715989,
-0.6444057226,
-1.03563416,
0.1009575799,
-0.1629758179,
1.2465233803,
0.4543009102,
0.4703671336,
-0.1802107841,
-0.1073493734,
-0.3699869514,
-1.0466042757,
-0.2691018879,
-0.2002379894,
0.3388253748,
-0.1093126163,
0.7327045798,
0.0595709644,
0.3920452595,
0.1740896404,
-0.0032507204,
-0.3948906362,
-0.298568815,
-0.036581248,
-0.0462192371,
-0.3181972206,
-0.4254391491,
0.582248807,
0.1489549726,
0.9573204517,
0.5072633624,
0.5933123231,
0.1599062532,
0.600586772,
-0.6015813351,
-0.024827268,
-0.5851898789,
0.3191956878,
-0.3554006219,
0.2152070999,
-0.5211469531,
-0.5376841426,
0.1578144878,
-0.3397235274,
0.4324585795,
0.1710463911,
0.8249115348,
0.4421246648,
-0.5252642035,
-0.2710644901,
-0.3978507519,
0.8555431366,
-0.3580532074,
0.3151634932,
0.7367097139,
-0.1535631418,
0.097339876,
-0.1341320276,
-0.2295320034,
-0.5259256959,
0.0310771987,
-0.0586786792,
-0.2097094506,
0.4053142965,
0.6503921747,
0.1537754536,
-0.4987757206,
0.1221063659,
-0.82122159,
-0.5162045956,
0.7452529073,
-0.1187130064,
0.4169927835,
-0.3293639421,
-0.333239615,
0.2689515352,
-0.5016205907,
0.0546409115,
0.6326076984,
0.0976956487,
0.0975719094,
0.5123021007,
0.0671453252,
0.4168274701,
0.0758006871,
-0.0002375824,
0.3508464098,
0.0565136112,
-0.2533918023,
0.0086911544,
0.6738993526,
0.7802968621,
0.7000053525,
-0.1792179793,
-0.1480277181,
0.6330302954,
0.3026809096,
-0.4386425614,
0.0471494012,
-0.0740382224,
-0.7764028311,
-0.2901906073,
-0.2563726306,
-0.6835418344,
-0.9121693969,
-0.1029033288,
0.4099147618,
-0.1155003756,
0.0002326284,
-0.1046573296,
-0.4438927472,
-0.0066944063,
0.237638548,
-0.4605190158,
0.4392206967,
0.4836426675,
0.6975588799,
-0.2115950882,
0.1619342864,
-0.4557263553,
-0.3568045497,
-0.2699639797,
0.416028589,
-0.601886034,
-0.3968967497,
-0.0595979504,
-0.0739515796,
0.035502363,
-0.5952982306,
0.6544528604,
-0.1884045452,
0.2969176173,
-0.378983438,
-0.3174450397,
-0.2746560574,
0.0690935403,
-0.5579153299,
0.8023691773,
0.1735838354,
-0.9036443233,
0.7152285576,
-0.5905458331,
-0.5251567364,
0.0406738557,
-0.1450302899,
-0.2728109062,
0.1857198477,
0.1032154486,
0.4733707607,
-0.1837683916,
0.4809041917,
-0.8025260568,
-0.5113710761,
0.2793793976,
-0.5136826038,
1.0042612553,
0.1478374302,
-0.7290261984,
0.0785501227,
-0.3621647656,
-0.4474095702,
-0.2323821187,
0.0444451757,
-0.9027830362,
-0.1626170427,
0.0542987362,
0.4865745306,
-0.094362475,
-0.5881211758,
-0.0776679218,
-0.2334418595,
0.3102510571,
1.079116106,
0.0377539508,
0.4093278348,
-0.0605829209,
0.7015166283,
0.0207398143,
0.6861063242,
0.4177502692,
-0.704767108,
-0.826582253,
-0.2594710588,
0.0357053764,
0.5269506574,
-0.5881353021,
0.4374317527,
0.0396378674,
-0.1009971574,
-0.6140776277,
-0.0312276725,
0.3973153532,
0.3677657843,
0.3057145476,
-0.4237959385,
-0.4549931586,
-1.2920103073,
-0.4802918136,
-0.1346186101,
-0.1496474594,
0.2958237827,
0.523454845,
-0.3638640046,
0.6959868073,
-0.3888859749,
-0.7113150358,
0.2005084455,
0.1362404525,
-0.0509014279,
0.2843383551,
0.5374168754,
-0.5268459916,
-0.252764076,
-0.4647783041,
-0.5738919377,
-0.3971412778,
0.2361833751,
-0.1338335872,
0.411303699,
0.4830392897,
-0.4658837318,
0.7453097105,
0.4456258714,
-0.5014643669,
0.4447737038,
0.4876363277,
-0.0795811191,
-0.7956796288,
-0.0598524362,
0.6499153376,
0.0535796545,
-0.6122781634,
-0.4649413824,
-0.2735283971,
-0.0083957696,
-0.2828130126,
0.4326877594,
-0.4306350946,
0.0285963044,
0.1047309637,
-0.1424725354,
0.0353801399,
0.2966762483,
0.0862391293,
0.3649430573,
0.7858216763,
-0.5159769654,
0.0111496747,
-0.3497427702,
-0.3064451218,
0.2152309865,
-0.3981519043,
0.1738436669,
-0.3518217802,
0.4807043374,
-0.7345110774,
0.0417185873,
0.3321574628,
-0.5351797342,
-0.1897483617,
-0.0310698338,
-0.157433331,
-0.5544761419,
-0.3793725669,
0.4291860461,
0.6621426344,
0.0353444926,
0.2475846708,
0.621333003,
-0.0044318661,
-0.6773584485,
-0.6916544437,
0.0566071384,
-0.7331548333,
-0.2661086321,
-0.0895112306,
0.0945881084,
-0.8106110096,
-0.1865586638,
-0.0656900182,
0.0735273361,
0.1623225808,
0.6867016554,
0.2591159642,
0.1131671071,
0.25222978,
0.0089332908,
0.1183584929,
0.4182827175,
-0.2888783813,
0.4862256348,
0.0983507633,
-0.2904585898,
-0.1258078218,
0.4801875949,
0.4692197442,
-0.0363796316,
0.7505850196,
0.6452812552,
-0.6032268405,
0.0180884302,
-0.8988912702,
-0.4152604342,
-0.3814640939,
0.4466746449,
-0.1043650508,
-1.1922556162,
0.4212548733,
0.5160956979,
-0.217009306,
0.3986788094,
0.5180808902,
0.0995014831,
1.3138855696,
0.4991239607,
-0.4582202435,
0.3364142776,
0.0842971876,
0.3185429871,
-0.6378797293,
-0.1122886688,
-0.6388319135,
-0.1836136281,
-0.7714148164,
-0.4682475328,
0.4093386829,
-0.0960745066,
-0.207877174,
-0.3177140951,
-0.6696914434,
0.13940081,
0.6493167877,
0.1092591807,
0.0284021739,
-0.0103100492,
-0.0427723825,
-0.1235606,
-0.2957049012,
-0.6981954575,
1.210875988,
0.7784194946,
0.7608538866,
-0.2852317691,
0.6102029681,
1.0493950844,
1.0829159021,
-0.8283868432,
0.4635800123,
-0.1471037567,
-1.0518580675,
-0.1593115479,
-0.1505120695,
-0.6359719634,
0.1256430745,
-0.0837809369,
-1.0182174444,
0.4420669973,
0.1369489431,
-0.2350570261,
0.0346496813,
-0.9037690759,
0.5088953376,
-0.0163875222,
-0.097799167,
-0.0074656717,
-0.869854331,
0.7795000672,
-0.1074387804,
0.4764804244,
-0.4069812596,
0.2172252536,
1.0263903141,
-0.2786518037,
1.0408892632,
-0.5047156215,
-0.0774620101,
0.033390712,
-0.1247739792,
0.0055658915,
0.0426540487,
-0.3864926398,
0.5518527627,
-0.27044186,
-0.4218799472,
-0.3692192733,
0.5542607307,
-0.9583078027,
-0.8956129551,
-0.522167623,
-0.4832588136,
-0.2297321856,
0.0200515706,
0.4559434652,
0.2414151132,
-0.0696259886,
-0.1431998014,
0.4699242413,
-0.441872865,
0.1817517579,
0.2373280674,
-0.3758355081,
-0.3510689735,
0.6497905254,
0.3437686861,
0.4607923627,
-0.0844087824,
0.0539947152,
-0.247330606,
-0.253370434,
-0.252378583,
0.1105182096,
-0.6043472886,
-0.1204066128,
-0.7922575474,
-0.1139532775,
-0.8580676913,
-0.0337162726,
0.0528073087,
-0.2706228793,
-0.2135386765,
-0.1970985085,
0.2105001211,
0.8576737046,
0.0308225304,
-0.0524540916,
-0.2904138565,
0.2397443652,
0.1474039555,
0.1227229759,
0.0038393126,
-0.4777561426,
-0.147491172,
-0.0400757603,
-0.1951907128,
-1.0299267769,
0.2153317779,
-0.0005591717,
0.4680493772,
0.6892307997,
0.4318763912,
0.3916693926,
-0.2610985637,
0.871704936,
0.0921899527,
-1.0169975758,
0.5701413155,
-0.1406440884,
-0.0864106715,
0.5542693138,
0.838562429,
-0.6605123878,
-0.9169210792,
-0.5483253598,
-0.6401225328,
0.647185266,
0.1179812774,
0.1888354868,
-0.3301224709,
0.251875639,
0.2349223495,
0.2404510826,
-1.1915625334,
-0.7127887011,
-0.3803925812,
-0.0153973494,
-0.2250117809,
-0.2138327658,
-0.0993203521,
-0.3480874598,
0.5897535682,
0.0729039684,
0.291787833,
0.2422811091,
-0.3045161963,
-0.0128262741,
0.2232860923,
0.557444334,
0.4761322141,
-0.2339301854,
0.4066779315,
0.156039089,
-0.7911001444,
0.2720430195,
0.1576776206,
-0.3870507777,
0.0245782044,
0.3303551972,
0.9430963993,
-0.5373841524,
-0.4850507379,
0.5603786707,
-0.0365900174,
-0.0972905084,
-0.260361284,
-0.1022326052,
-0.3499760926,
0.0513335541,
0.4632548988,
0.2827551961,
0.4903373718,
-0.4746743441,
0.0167168695,
0.8563328981,
-0.8843023181,
-0.4381801188,
0.4585854113,
0.1786748916,
-0.3956481814,
0.4338954985,
-0.2754214704,
-0.7779676914,
0.4794850051,
0.2700689733,
0.9699422121,
-0.2932235599,
0.3997642994,
0.13288939,
0.8288955688,
0.2817648649,
-0.1766100079,
0.0604457706,
-0.8230364323,
-0.2702964842,
-0.8736035228,
-0.0066806003,
0.4109415114,
-0.889927268,
0.1278775483,
-0.4926851392,
-0.7009663582,
-0.0173696261,
-0.0449523441,
-0.6031157374,
0.4474439919,
0.5344429612,
0.7864770293,
-1.4506548643,
0.577670157,
0.8214856982,
-0.3676847219,
-0.5747335553,
0.432736516,
0.2124129236,
-0.7863742113,
0.7784935236,
0.5460612178,
-0.0088446271,
-0.2710001469,
-0.3665104806,
-0.7068117857,
0.2823824883,
0.3493273556,
-0.1416439265,
0.1568919569,
0.3040429056,
0.6818548441,
-0.3194801509,
0.3672866523,
0.5015186667,
0.4732190669,
-0.3786747754,
-1.0076606274,
0.134439677,
-0.4524224997,
0.1316371709,
-0.0034439701,
-0.6020789742,
0.7664955854,
0.0128647191,
-0.082982786,
-0.4892168939,
0.3494412303,
0.1315930039,
0.4180606902,
0.6466372013,
0.3387876749,
0.5354874134,
0.0771703944,
0.9118971825,
-0.0494409874,
0.1593276858,
0.5434325337,
-0.3910984993,
0.1544310898,
0.4174459875,
-0.1498585194,
0.4259132445,
0.7953603864,
0.2959824204,
0.4269685149,
0.687017262,
-0.3944996297,
-0.1201322749,
-0.5683484077,
-0.3893942833,
0.3035256863,
0.44061023,
-0.7076122165,
0.1724489182,
0.5367723107,
0.303144902,
-0.0858860984,
-0.5354648232,
0.5029667616,
0.2447300553,
-0.6557673812,
0.3585046828,
0.0543631539,
1.0126779079,
-0.2322159857,
0.2990181148,
-0.2998142838,
0.0881576166,
-0.2424378395,
-0.3439084291,
0.2628448606,
0.0629842281,
-0.4677624404,
-0.2812209725,
1.0202161074,
-0.0748182833,
-0.7493749261,
0.5583615899,
0.3093025386,
0.2322567254,
-0.3129799664,
-0.6784541011,
0.2371651828,
0.1228657812,
-0.2342512608,
0.5228338838,
0.1782642603,
-0.5676295757,
0.7000918984,
0.3742478192,
0.1136146337,
0.3588750958,
0.4369790554,
0.7443107367,
-0.5677235723,
-0.3399941623,
-1.0536726713,
0.241502136,
-0.0325824171,
-0.1469039768,
0.8960250616,
0.4281850457,
0.5567225218,
-0.115447633,
1.0478259325,
0.0696227476,
0.4083128572,
-0.1829405874,
0.9157500863,
-0.3625645638,
-0.0048482213,
-0.7338947654,
-0.9171404839,
-0.3161572516,
0.6015219092,
-0.8163153529,
0.474258393,
0.5101243258,
0.768848002,
0.3082068861,
-0.1224127784,
0.2211371213,
0.2069782466,
0.1382351816,
0.3128648102,
0.9564425349,
-0.1063168943,
0.0578661785,
-0.2121429443,
-0.5029227734,
0.0713628009,
-0.6748188138,
-1.1486616135,
-0.4572624266,
-0.3997630179,
-0.5869147182,
0.0922706798,
0.9507875443,
0.7930234671,
-0.698954761,
-0.1067249253,
0.3896517754,
0.4669326246,
0.089887403,
-0.3859521449,
0.2158226669,
-0.1081736237,
-0.5950628519,
-0.3149364591,
0.3083442152,
-0.252767235,
-0.7104783058,
0.0842437446,
-0.0650573894,
0.10089086,
0.742498517,
-0.2826475501,
-1.0318112373,
-0.4190432727,
0.0529889762,
-0.1501499116,
-0.1978128105,
0.5130013227,
-0.7125855088,
0.1080298126,
0.0324529484,
0.1434967518,
-0.0214738958,
0.0734806657,
0.4124090672,
-0.7631182671,
0.2166172266,
0.4040763378,
0.1373541653,
0.3477011323,
-0.6459844112,
0.1889020205,
0.4555858076,
-0.4178747237,
-0.921413362,
0.0953716859,
-0.6233856678,
-0.0750139281,
1.273678422,
-0.013376506,
-0.0548943393,
-0.4553390145,
-0.1805815995,
0.240996033,
-0.5275574327,
0.9666404128,
0.8135037422,
-0.1274480224,
-0.03669158,
-0.5995954275,
0.7308195829,
0.4755975306,
-0.5624174476,
-0.1993647367,
0.6976775527,
0.2388271093,
0.1645780653,
0.8232873082,
0.0116561055,
-0.0556952842,
-0.3378863037,
0.4023991525,
0.3183099926,
0.0166428722,
-0.2648656964,
0.1496416777,
-0.023039626,
-0.0409687161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.07402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.07402v1 | The economic trade-offs of large language models: A case study | 2023-06-08T20:35:53 | 2023-06-08T20:35:53 | Kristen Howell, Gwen Christian, Pavel Fomitchov, Gitit Kehat, Julianne Marzulla, Leanne Rolston, Jadin Tredup, Ilana Zimmerman, Ethan Selfridge, Joseph Bradley | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Contacting customer service via chat is a common practice. Because employing
customer service agents is expensive, many companies are turning to NLP that
assists human agents by auto-generating responses that can be used directly or
with modifications. Large Language Models (LLMs) are a natural fit for this use
case; however, their efficacy must be balanced with the cost of training and
serving them. This paper assesses the practical cost and impact of LLMs for the
enterprise as a function of the usefulness of the responses that they generate.
We present a cost framework for evaluating an NLP model's utility for this use
case and apply it to a single brand as a case study in the context of an
existing agent assistance product. We compare three strategies for specializing
an LLM - prompt engineering, fine-tuning, and knowledge distillation - using
feedback from the brand's customer service agents. We find that the usability
of a model's responses can make up for a large difference in inference cost for
our case study brand, and we extrapolate our findings to the broader enterprise
space. | [
-0.3747428656,
-0.3840793073,
0.4290877879,
0.273691386,
0.1286411583,
-0.034786623,
-0.3292956948,
-0.9518744946,
0.1610353887,
0.8664692044,
-0.4854173064,
0.196404025,
-0.0722548291,
0.0959529355,
-0.2548158467,
0.5909373164,
0.3730460405,
-0.1380606592,
0.0358238518,
0.0907639861,
-0.337431103,
-0.7349039912,
-1.2774940729,
-0.3705778718,
0.6580551267,
0.4318825603,
0.888523221,
0.3194874227,
0.5005373955,
0.3343353271,
0.0266820155,
0.1028738618,
-0.2179798335,
0.2109160423,
-0.0580167323,
-0.4380224347,
-0.6093329191,
0.1801450104,
0.3331669569,
0.9626999497,
-0.3130681515,
0.2846227884,
0.0686520487,
0.8200631142,
-0.5251381397,
0.1965516508,
-0.9096252322,
-0.1227908358,
0.3170800209,
0.1244219691,
-0.6414575577,
-0.1134405285,
0.3755793869,
-0.4336125851,
-0.2379547209,
0.2342201322,
0.9593074918,
0.3205219209,
0.0647534654,
-0.5938704014,
-0.9062553048,
0.8934567571,
-0.7712413669,
0.2211000174,
0.3602303267,
0.3427328169,
-0.2739437222,
-0.4645283818,
-0.2845906317,
-0.5279070139,
-0.0889088213,
-0.0003578734,
-0.5907028913,
0.0896249563,
0.2956819534,
0.1655133665,
-0.2034004033,
0.5821593404,
-0.1319959313,
0.2025434077,
0.7715905905,
0.1956294477,
0.3639240563,
0.0129609033,
-0.2366455048,
-0.0129214143,
-0.6627460718,
0.1425419003,
0.2970310152,
0.514469862,
0.2901375592,
0.5177972317,
-0.1369558573,
0.7005338669,
-0.0324549489,
-0.1474232972,
-0.2844264805,
-0.0280808676,
-0.5587901473,
-0.0816576555,
0.5046178699,
0.4899805486,
0.6769455671,
-0.457906574,
-0.3632121384,
-0.1347871274,
0.3336870372,
-0.7925630808,
0.1850580573,
0.2987239659,
-0.4045706689,
-0.0008043878,
-0.4889562726,
-0.6141406894,
-0.3487905562,
-0.4894354045,
0.2477852702,
-0.0151244486,
-0.2508220971,
0.244901523,
-0.2367099673,
0.3017887771,
0.2827907503,
-0.8971868753,
0.3417986035,
0.4653556943,
0.7160526514,
0.0803383216,
0.0561973751,
-0.4366026521,
0.0535323545,
-0.3531560898,
0.9132202864,
-0.2902552187,
-0.5204951763,
0.140758574,
-0.1181509793,
0.0627706274,
-0.936853528,
0.3967956007,
-0.6604829431,
-0.1666170508,
-0.3117149472,
-0.654111743,
0.1892175227,
0.0021081767,
-0.8191199899,
0.6166917086,
0.0502631664,
-0.4735167027,
0.5334256291,
-0.5155908465,
-0.3972958326,
0.5792495012,
0.1269311458,
-0.2017396092,
0.0239995364,
-0.1188954934,
0.7015479803,
-0.6612395048,
0.0320722163,
-0.4827535152,
-0.0064447131,
0.5326510668,
-0.2518202662,
0.6865044832,
0.4741035402,
-0.1986432225,
-0.4035156667,
-0.8389866352,
-0.0463817753,
0.1018918008,
-0.5447884798,
-0.6318725348,
0.1077079251,
-0.0470549241,
0.0623285957,
0.0712921917,
-0.1845811605,
0.1083456799,
-0.6128053069,
0.198144123,
0.5599414706,
-0.0615896918,
0.6190586686,
-0.1965891272,
0.7655262947,
-0.5623649359,
0.331058979,
0.1330502033,
-0.4275401533,
-0.9055820704,
-0.5154262185,
0.0564640611,
0.1679824442,
-0.734895885,
0.1694736332,
0.124142766,
-0.4175891578,
-0.3761186302,
0.0340646282,
0.0756509975,
0.3740921617,
0.1813244969,
-0.0419148803,
-0.4443710744,
-1.1096771955,
-0.5630719066,
-0.1733144224,
-0.362493515,
0.3717015088,
0.0746785328,
0.0286942944,
1.1666202545,
-0.4278254807,
-0.1439660639,
-0.3428030312,
-0.0726925433,
0.1953600943,
0.0540136136,
0.6064596176,
-0.4808342159,
-0.7940734029,
0.0168927331,
-0.3163665831,
-0.4110830724,
-0.3259420097,
0.0407272391,
0.7180031538,
0.224090904,
-0.6909677982,
0.3344017863,
0.6309725642,
-0.2685886919,
0.6189291477,
-0.3994285762,
0.0943699405,
-0.9406139851,
0.2040594816,
0.3257939816,
-0.0693075657,
-0.6567199826,
-0.197909385,
-0.2305498868,
-0.2554305494,
-0.3007733226,
0.7122231126,
-0.6066631079,
-0.4205803275,
-0.5426266193,
0.0814744681,
0.1182086542,
0.4440610409,
0.2021634728,
0.9286996126,
-0.0714427978,
-0.8832711577,
0.3547142148,
0.0562908687,
-0.4407827258,
0.6397010088,
-0.9989686608,
-0.0173091609,
0.2149193287,
0.0163086113,
-0.7606732845,
0.1283839494,
0.0113938553,
-0.3214664161,
0.1996704489,
-0.3501244187,
-0.5623291135,
-0.345143944,
0.0491798483,
-0.3327050507,
0.6767854691,
-0.6026752591,
0.6357401013,
0.463419497,
-0.4216691554,
-0.3619115353,
-0.8121209145,
0.460927099,
-0.3957605362,
-0.6840040088,
-0.0609766543,
-0.0267237779,
-0.5360563397,
-0.0479402654,
-0.0447261333,
-0.1664081365,
0.3172425032,
-0.017289998,
0.2266795933,
-0.231150195,
0.3419158161,
-0.2854076028,
-0.2468034029,
0.2444197685,
-0.3435992301,
0.6530908346,
-0.0801427662,
-0.3074474931,
-0.362513721,
0.3795991838,
0.4974975288,
-0.2785103917,
0.8855130076,
-0.1511991471,
-0.2543744445,
-0.3840455115,
-0.7592452765,
-0.0528656095,
-0.5141537786,
0.3827480972,
-0.2666663229,
-0.3635813594,
0.4077049196,
-0.119600758,
0.4090144336,
0.3538677096,
0.5568265915,
-0.0805243701,
0.9988924265,
0.5536548495,
-0.0505235717,
0.412804842,
-0.0846145451,
0.6449417472,
-0.5033886433,
-0.1252868325,
-1.0305939913,
-0.1510856152,
-0.4087342024,
-0.2272674888,
0.1387187243,
-0.1233649701,
-0.2595287859,
0.5482783914,
-0.2524692714,
0.3475978076,
0.5751563311,
-0.2918278277,
0.6006982327,
0.1118304655,
0.3437886536,
0.0099394694,
-0.8217483759,
-0.8140528202,
0.8739034534,
0.5134282112,
1.075165391,
0.2898850143,
0.2049073875,
0.2761023939,
0.3640196025,
-1.0830934048,
0.5208608508,
-0.2445690036,
-0.4137264788,
-0.5715260506,
-0.5479415655,
-1.179369688,
0.1995242238,
-0.3469762206,
-0.7748669386,
0.0434078798,
0.3009546101,
-0.3835428953,
0.2381032407,
-1.0118345022,
0.5716236234,
-0.3796447217,
-0.1641417742,
-0.2412984818,
-0.1642113328,
0.1474687904,
-0.231553033,
0.1735428721,
-0.0856437683,
0.1027009562,
0.7682083845,
-0.3120161295,
0.8535866141,
0.0098229218,
-0.2544996738,
0.0029811705,
-0.0504421219,
0.4096292555,
-0.1334188581,
-0.1643782854,
-0.1499352008,
0.0040114666,
-0.3978085518,
-0.5640673637,
0.6400333643,
-0.5039871335,
-0.5634369254,
-0.0732659996,
-0.634665072,
-0.6318665743,
0.0240885951,
-0.1290833205,
0.4835008085,
-0.2149808258,
0.1127749234,
0.6940580606,
-0.6235005856,
0.6617962718,
0.7924130559,
-0.3124870062,
-0.1204330176,
0.4108797908,
0.1618077755,
0.7614762783,
0.234874323,
0.3407551944,
-0.3880134821,
0.1338079721,
-0.3177981973,
0.3312235177,
-0.6467581391,
-0.1738504916,
-0.7388522625,
0.0025450396,
-0.3117896318,
-0.1977585852,
-0.6135523915,
-0.3130375743,
-0.1511595249,
0.0426179506,
0.3374650776,
0.4825071692,
-0.0105136083,
0.339607805,
-0.7548978925,
-0.0446404777,
0.4902762473,
0.271948576,
0.3922065198,
-0.5294364095,
-0.5666741729,
0.1073893011,
-0.0924278647,
-0.5471790433,
0.4303851128,
0.0259647164,
0.6719136834,
0.4295656979,
0.2630770802,
0.3843054473,
-0.5327104926,
0.6919488907,
0.5047822595,
-0.9411939383,
0.0540505312,
-0.0529337823,
0.2586854994,
0.2308943719,
0.6072331667,
-0.887280643,
-0.3110771775,
-0.5926177502,
-1.0012428761,
0.6593530774,
0.0198166091,
0.4124152362,
-0.0194947515,
0.3389542401,
-0.2058690488,
0.1763003469,
-0.5755602121,
-0.2293682396,
0.4606208503,
0.177477017,
-0.0891334191,
-0.3194524944,
-0.0023019866,
0.0526713505,
0.8168126941,
-0.0202236921,
0.1086176112,
-0.0721282586,
-0.0262469314,
0.1869186908,
0.357848525,
0.3950937688,
0.5454423428,
0.0083397422,
-0.1470589042,
0.0364978909,
0.1191545203,
-0.1810377985,
-0.1334240586,
0.0129115554,
0.0489028953,
0.1247914284,
0.7902387977,
0.1863325089,
-0.9075416327,
0.2226606905,
0.0314528458,
-0.2508819401,
-0.1760353595,
-0.1687434167,
0.5236330628,
0.3947571218,
0.3275526464,
-0.2380409986,
0.2981523275,
-0.4847366214,
0.0909445435,
0.6976857781,
-0.187260434,
-0.0148520181,
0.3524077833,
0.4651023746,
-0.8306704164,
0.4643424153,
0.1489993632,
-0.5759087205,
0.6925940514,
0.3070076108,
0.8484312892,
-0.2888298929,
0.416036129,
-0.05555797,
0.3656160831,
-0.0319133028,
-0.281794101,
0.2493066043,
-0.6898564696,
-0.5829954743,
-0.480004847,
-0.7831593156,
0.2142103761,
-0.6489982009,
0.4223303795,
-0.3410511017,
-0.3365677893,
0.2864187062,
-0.0063126213,
-0.908095181,
0.1495173872,
0.2278226465,
0.9259064794,
-0.6226835251,
0.4550856054,
0.531055212,
-0.7758655548,
-1.1276437044,
-0.1180428639,
-0.4336130619,
-0.9796258807,
0.8957039714,
0.0222190749,
-0.3805709481,
-0.2168154716,
-0.2993177772,
-0.6353562474,
0.6192843914,
0.4129385352,
-0.7633195519,
-0.1507878304,
0.382338047,
0.5786605477,
-0.3670784235,
0.2922042608,
0.7463766336,
0.2876240909,
0.222124815,
-0.9871276617,
-0.087217696,
0.1365497112,
0.1987068951,
0.1147190183,
-0.5841414928,
0.5233602524,
0.0168957599,
-0.2819088697,
-0.0384945236,
0.204449743,
-0.138727352,
0.1781675518,
0.6496362686,
0.2637913525,
0.5702037811,
0.3957396448,
1.0219990015,
-0.301699996,
0.4135604501,
1.0042488575,
-0.5236293674,
0.7431446314,
0.7190544009,
-0.466943562,
0.0902398601,
0.5112572908,
0.0022476846,
0.2935628295,
0.5980007648,
-0.0868592858,
-0.2712743282,
-0.2154355347,
-0.1619255245,
0.2281649262,
0.2439375371,
-0.1809735596,
-0.2006805688,
-0.2325796932,
0.302976191,
-0.021908721,
-0.1138541177,
0.9242196679,
0.3876422048,
-0.6762214899,
0.5035994649,
-0.0795188397,
0.4622313678,
-0.6182948351,
0.1934047788,
-0.4095808566,
0.2698339224,
-0.1055811942,
-0.3741012812,
0.5647859573,
0.1496563703,
-0.0507144332,
-0.3628681898,
0.4639590681,
-0.3776336014,
-0.3562531769,
0.5210189223,
0.3874865174,
0.0672902316,
-0.378978312,
-0.6942677498,
-0.0429184772,
-0.1944858283,
-0.4656643569,
0.4002787471,
0.2005538344,
0.3028894365,
0.8741887808,
0.4991419017,
0.209826827,
-0.2025024295,
0.2584159672,
0.6273152232,
-0.3055060208,
-0.4774475098,
-0.5605524182,
0.5108001828,
-0.3582816124,
-0.1158615574,
0.6082348824,
0.2532678843,
0.5186983347,
-0.0595820136,
0.7786976695,
0.2165887207,
0.6338182092,
-0.6327388883,
0.8303367496,
-0.8427621126,
0.6784923673,
-0.3131338656,
-0.9575259089,
-0.1018073112,
0.4931681752,
-0.3995415866,
-0.0721621886,
0.6336472631,
0.6852678061,
0.2456368357,
0.1311802715,
0.656678021,
0.00195877,
0.4655946195,
0.3050887287,
0.9611773491,
0.0139817651,
0.504562676,
0.1029674262,
-0.3693022728,
-0.3040061891,
-0.8973132968,
-0.9180253744,
-0.3171060681,
-0.3370660245,
-0.4786293805,
-0.0657607391,
1.1380079985,
0.5950247645,
-0.5113788843,
-0.5269360542,
0.3806715906,
-0.0775142163,
-0.094130069,
-0.1829635799,
0.0811375529,
-0.797426343,
-0.7881142497,
0.0771799907,
0.3289848566,
0.0131163504,
-0.3821720183,
0.0822155997,
0.0552139096,
0.6159968972,
0.8206312656,
0.3075576425,
-0.6892296076,
-0.1772426814,
0.4455415905,
-0.0678830743,
-0.0627781451,
0.9580649734,
-0.1888968349,
0.1019804254,
-0.0507154167,
1.2398388386,
0.3577097356,
-0.4345131218,
0.8504368663,
-0.3606848419,
0.1065353528,
0.1002180353,
0.3424502611,
0.3567387462,
-0.5580980182,
0.4589248896,
-0.0835736394,
-0.7746049762,
-0.5933853388,
0.4834293127,
-0.7812463641,
-0.5011278987,
1.3509814739,
-0.2161004245,
0.0553773753,
-0.1262266338,
-0.1940012872,
-0.1756576449,
-0.5097732544,
0.8044692278,
0.7586421371,
-0.1223961413,
-0.008252711,
-0.4901658595,
0.5083682537,
0.5054588318,
-0.9485110044,
0.2315291315,
0.54257828,
0.1700896174,
0.0861100554,
0.4946739674,
0.4116186202,
-0.1707209796,
-0.1059855521,
0.5382343531,
0.3125154674,
-0.2440284193,
-0.2104441822,
-0.1163729727,
0.5130205154,
-0.1354110837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05499v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05499v2 | Prompt Injection attack against LLM-integrated Applications | 2023-06-08T18:43:11 | 2024-03-02T09:12:23 | Yi Liu, Gelei Deng, Yuekang Li, Kailong Wang, Zihao Wang, Xiaofeng Wang, Tianwei Zhang, Yepang Liu, Haoyu Wang, Yan Zheng, Yang Liu | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | Large Language Models (LLMs), renowned for their superior proficiency in
language comprehension and generation, stimulate a vibrant ecosystem of
applications around them. However, their extensive assimilation into various
services introduces significant security risks. This study deconstructs the
complexities and implications of prompt injection attacks on actual
LLM-integrated applications. Initially, we conduct an exploratory analysis on
ten commercial applications, highlighting the constraints of current attack
strategies in practice. Prompted by these limitations, we subsequently
formulate HouYi, a novel black-box prompt injection attack technique, which
draws inspiration from traditional web injection attacks. HouYi is
compartmentalized into three crucial elements: a seamlessly-incorporated
pre-constructed prompt, an injection prompt inducing context partition, and a
malicious payload designed to fulfill the attack objectives. Leveraging HouYi,
we unveil previously unknown and severe attack outcomes, such as unrestricted
arbitrary LLM usage and uncomplicated application prompt theft. We deploy HouYi
on 36 actual LLM-integrated applications and discern 31 applications
susceptible to prompt injection. 10 vendors have validated our discoveries,
including Notion, which has the potential to impact millions of users. Our
investigation illuminates both the possible risks of prompt injection attacks
and the possible tactics for mitigation. | [
-0.3028318882,
-1.3496305943,
0.6227813363,
0.3652158678,
-0.1645803005,
0.1625024825,
0.395602107,
-0.6487143636,
-0.1176964864,
0.6938592196,
-0.6442170739,
-0.3273545504,
-0.4188194275,
0.1098302603,
-0.1558617502,
0.406111002,
0.2017441392,
-0.2527442575,
0.0690627247,
0.0435938574,
-0.9765405655,
-0.3305869102,
-0.4977636337,
0.0924143121,
0.5268663764,
0.3431139588,
0.6803305745,
0.3143071234,
0.4630582631,
0.2020078301,
0.0530492552,
-0.4158310294,
-0.3296950459,
0.2001548558,
0.0789288878,
-0.5601375103,
-0.4151369929,
-0.1703575552,
0.3745197356,
0.5822779536,
-0.0110475579,
-0.0715348721,
0.1828995645,
0.3060448468,
-0.976650238,
-0.4329458773,
-0.74225986,
0.0745530128,
-0.6049107313,
-0.2151088566,
-0.6381564736,
-0.0875533447,
0.0877476409,
-0.3819683194,
-0.369808048,
0.2174032032,
0.6590737104,
0.207422182,
-0.6702135801,
-0.5015323162,
-0.3323728442,
0.7693144083,
-0.8543880582,
-0.2456775904,
-0.1382309645,
0.6134684682,
-0.7684960961,
-0.1958583146,
-0.5212388039,
-0.0016630805,
-0.0323824137,
-0.0034388425,
-0.4846442044,
0.2642434239,
0.4504102767,
0.2243739814,
-0.8534944654,
0.4727328718,
0.0618516952,
-0.0952627733,
0.4134542346,
0.1088926941,
0.8610676527,
-0.4717070162,
-0.5964561701,
0.2666732669,
-0.9878796339,
0.3063967526,
0.5375014544,
0.0899580419,
-0.1694669276,
0.4560379982,
-0.0499842577,
0.9233219624,
-0.0927228853,
-0.2386466861,
-0.3291684389,
-0.0718371868,
-0.2346159965,
0.3027163446,
1.0434474945,
0.1938623637,
0.150687024,
-0.004929835,
-0.2989041805,
-0.1831088066,
0.2595744133,
-0.763276279,
0.3710687459,
0.7426691651,
-0.0798425302,
-0.7113907933,
0.1507804096,
-0.7896481156,
-0.4872241616,
0.393832624,
0.362136066,
-0.3132008612,
-0.0445324145,
-0.0976340324,
-0.1652476192,
0.6941555738,
0.2144454271,
-0.4921944141,
-0.0188554078,
1.096164465,
0.9176699519,
-0.4721200168,
-0.1526726782,
-0.8823170066,
0.4873838127,
-0.0787945911,
0.6114116311,
-0.543269515,
-0.7840817571,
0.4321520925,
0.0679635257,
0.4298582971,
-0.5328794718,
0.2763998508,
-0.8768312335,
-0.2060230523,
-0.1433134675,
-0.4497483969,
0.1240629181,
0.2672283947,
-0.5737888217,
0.7323454022,
-0.0136667322,
-0.6245137453,
-0.0400434844,
-0.3998335898,
-0.6553218365,
0.5424364805,
-0.0054209735,
0.092368342,
0.275477469,
0.022074867,
0.6825119853,
-0.0737130195,
0.4269270003,
-0.4932132363,
-0.2761188149,
0.513065815,
-0.345911026,
1.1083246469,
0.3139609694,
-0.1939993501,
-0.0489574894,
-0.8284267187,
-0.2674562931,
0.0781865641,
0.1425792724,
-0.6340739131,
-0.607396245,
-0.2166041583,
-0.1551424861,
0.4728324413,
-0.6708685756,
0.2820008099,
-0.4864087701,
0.5743344426,
0.6740684509,
0.6851760745,
0.6110850573,
-0.0130906776,
0.7308671474,
0.2136404216,
0.7536494136,
-0.4842383265,
-0.7286856174,
-0.0577126965,
-0.3590941727,
-0.0346575752,
0.8291287422,
-1.0882301331,
0.3032066524,
-0.0033724853,
-0.5460987687,
-0.3307819068,
-0.0410853252,
0.226768598,
0.6198567748,
-0.0318710804,
0.3941326141,
0.0148748085,
-0.9682570696,
-0.4764643908,
-0.0001266855,
-0.1457363665,
0.1624866128,
0.4279787838,
-0.7677651048,
1.1026798487,
-0.5589053035,
0.1341155618,
-0.0740115717,
-0.057421159,
0.6620847583,
0.5057715774,
0.7192086577,
-0.4063253403,
-0.5787872672,
0.0681742057,
-0.7841192484,
-0.6064135432,
-0.4763371944,
-0.4466635287,
-0.2698227763,
0.1545403153,
-0.60073632,
0.4164758623,
0.5753017664,
-0.1259893924,
0.5392783284,
-0.1111102849,
0.0965635777,
-1.055005908,
-0.1905664653,
0.1201777086,
-0.035081096,
-1.0005508661,
0.423319906,
0.2611891329,
-0.4843019247,
-0.867243886,
0.9147467017,
-0.3683175147,
0.1495027691,
-0.2613884509,
0.1127217412,
0.2071991861,
0.1433563232,
-0.5037324429,
0.9608142972,
0.7102048993,
-0.8994281292,
0.3164412081,
-0.0265245959,
-0.2784261107,
0.7172106504,
-1.0277879238,
0.0839702711,
0.2046997398,
-0.0158500038,
-1.1639654636,
-0.2703284323,
0.5774126649,
-0.1267157495,
0.4220613241,
-0.054809738,
-0.2236782312,
0.0299548693,
-0.5595146418,
0.4663080275,
0.6047682166,
-0.6801506281,
0.6833301187,
0.4477934837,
-0.1732943207,
-0.8019942641,
-0.7249287963,
0.3824867904,
-0.4029586613,
-0.7963497043,
0.2555104792,
-0.0105572771,
-0.4883831739,
-0.3662074208,
0.2571450174,
-0.1022421569,
0.63099581,
0.278339237,
0.4280743897,
0.0905424133,
-0.6565976143,
0.424746722,
-0.1528538615,
0.1617610604,
0.022487456,
0.2788996994,
0.3391162753,
-0.5665506721,
-0.6612224579,
0.7251078486,
0.5813645124,
0.0811835453,
0.6678945422,
0.159376353,
-0.2986768782,
-0.0305240657,
-0.6560308337,
0.0524028428,
-0.5625488162,
0.1313184649,
-0.4792057276,
-0.5658512712,
0.4359027743,
-0.2265468389,
0.2957537174,
0.004861135,
-0.0030841003,
-0.1792127043,
0.7652022839,
0.2094785124,
-0.0188187361,
0.4336506128,
-0.0625857115,
0.1449906826,
-0.864058733,
-0.1758166403,
-0.3254157901,
-0.1436185539,
-0.4854473472,
-0.0960746109,
0.4008507133,
0.1472691894,
-0.0149938762,
0.2281884253,
-0.1450901777,
0.3160949051,
0.3255989254,
0.0105506657,
0.1264476329,
-0.1481987834,
-0.0013450166,
0.0492237099,
-0.410163939,
-0.6041021347,
0.7454849482,
0.4765656292,
0.8946025372,
0.2815838158,
0.731148243,
0.6618783474,
0.1198931336,
-0.9445767403,
0.7242687941,
0.3093432784,
-0.1794408262,
-0.1274315119,
-0.2960271239,
-1.1245377064,
0.1254416704,
-0.0093534729,
-0.4399932325,
0.347350657,
0.0332445316,
-0.559142828,
-0.0715503171,
-1.0129132271,
0.7096706629,
-0.5710032582,
-0.4518587887,
0.1221097112,
-0.5558630824,
0.5201134682,
-0.2339451313,
0.5930045247,
-0.0387083367,
-0.2037366778,
0.388836503,
-0.3980121315,
1.0246092081,
-0.3449317813,
-0.5243393779,
0.3025723994,
0.4165548682,
0.6892753243,
0.4071066082,
0.1121956483,
0.5828260183,
0.109340474,
-0.7201564312,
-0.6770210266,
0.6925388575,
-0.4490258992,
-1.1033779383,
-0.5403435826,
-0.3481133878,
-0.0384367183,
0.1523082256,
0.2687963843,
0.5686960816,
-0.4205512404,
-0.3177921772,
0.8118180037,
-0.6418823004,
0.7307590842,
0.4138635099,
-0.1597255766,
-0.644015789,
0.7108489275,
-0.0715005472,
0.5324057937,
0.4873155355,
0.2493899763,
0.0285065174,
-0.566706121,
-0.532105267,
0.5392468572,
-0.5662135482,
-0.1513924748,
-0.4926354587,
0.2336486131,
-0.568936944,
-0.3907005787,
0.1875835359,
0.0319318622,
-0.3404144943,
0.1733922213,
0.055685699,
0.7527876496,
0.4978131056,
0.8586063385,
-1.0250128508,
0.1749719232,
0.3890519142,
-0.294331789,
0.0421957448,
-0.3995236158,
-0.0038725648,
0.0736101642,
-0.1709000468,
-1.4029010534,
0.420247823,
-0.0010626855,
0.5557412505,
0.9865572453,
0.1659805924,
0.6179375648,
-0.7696662545,
0.9009552002,
0.2025122046,
-0.8650628328,
0.7184636593,
-0.2718675733,
0.5976560116,
0.3380275667,
0.444639504,
-0.5451992154,
-0.369467169,
-0.4097236693,
-0.5672953725,
0.3157771826,
-0.0751625374,
0.2615166605,
-0.1772446185,
0.719233036,
0.3030919433,
0.2834966481,
-0.4615971446,
-0.2703568935,
0.1110095158,
-0.0474639535,
0.4072496891,
-0.7723077536,
0.0238911137,
0.1193558052,
0.6202955246,
0.1634278595,
-0.0050767418,
-0.0849257559,
-0.4198548794,
0.3461330533,
0.4940176606,
0.4851740301,
0.1490619034,
0.2385789007,
0.19875817,
0.0775293633,
-0.6308743954,
0.1909073889,
-0.4986104369,
-0.5276397467,
-0.0146630351,
0.5280039907,
0.6563352942,
0.3877086937,
-0.7552288771,
0.6229153872,
-0.0375388898,
0.5063754916,
-0.3213930726,
0.0768987238,
-0.3246334791,
0.1097134799,
0.410520494,
-0.0977632105,
0.276704967,
-0.685831666,
-0.1474769861,
0.8695141077,
-0.490203917,
-0.5188848972,
0.2151609361,
0.3130917251,
-0.4154579043,
0.1780127734,
0.0188687313,
-0.37433213,
0.342009455,
0.5996758938,
0.9611904621,
-0.6878529191,
0.0804294124,
0.1942238659,
0.4352236092,
0.2035845369,
0.1613755822,
-0.0619785488,
-0.5314232111,
-0.1321657896,
-0.4571954906,
-0.4681915045,
0.0553167015,
-0.4987309575,
0.3876945376,
-0.4476451576,
-0.250652194,
-0.572707057,
-0.4997282326,
-0.2619662881,
-0.4233243167,
-0.0285167471,
0.7781986594,
-0.7241908908,
0.494314611,
0.5185160637,
0.05273927,
-0.1931245029,
0.1431806535,
-0.0920465067,
-0.8641220927,
0.474951297,
0.2941945791,
0.0053009368,
0.0117634954,
-0.4612773955,
-0.5503309369,
0.8127618432,
0.3270477653,
-0.567258358,
-0.0459757783,
0.4817646444,
-0.0316559374,
-0.239234224,
0.3920764923,
0.7261683345,
0.4988774061,
0.036955487,
-0.3614584208,
0.2733210623,
-0.0509532169,
0.2814669311,
0.0308515877,
-0.269187212,
0.6018739939,
-0.0299997199,
-0.6728140116,
-0.1521868706,
0.5707218051,
0.2421071976,
0.2820253968,
0.2987221479,
0.3057023883,
0.6769096255,
0.0934617519,
1.1864278316,
-0.2244782448,
-0.312078476,
0.6260078549,
-0.6755123138,
0.7131544948,
0.8169081807,
0.055399809,
0.2915001214,
0.4949299693,
0.252145648,
0.5472195148,
-0.0281524938,
-0.5805845857,
0.1646592915,
-0.3912885487,
-0.246625796,
0.0286614764,
0.472863853,
0.4827681482,
-0.0889135748,
0.5546387434,
0.2669781744,
-0.2269482315,
-0.1996268183,
0.8378149867,
0.3341804445,
-0.5071728826,
0.4809874892,
-0.1600193083,
0.8413869739,
-0.6775546074,
0.0422457978,
-0.0135238059,
-0.21401456,
-0.2467901409,
-0.6570204496,
0.0292991307,
0.0805255473,
0.2744577825,
-0.1786153167,
0.6180889606,
-0.0441054106,
0.0236055143,
0.2054665238,
0.2975877225,
-0.0728985518,
-0.3260907233,
-0.5318667293,
0.2602081895,
-0.1408705711,
-0.2016053498,
0.4666413963,
0.6899785399,
0.0862882286,
0.6269940138,
0.6954136491,
0.0662126765,
0.1452776194,
-0.0816864967,
0.4820718169,
-0.5345017314,
-0.5699509382,
-1.3692450523,
0.5539340377,
-0.2333796173,
0.0925097615,
1.0417107344,
0.4378994703,
0.3182604611,
-0.2366982847,
0.7992818952,
0.3590131104,
-0.0682639852,
-0.7551316023,
0.6209901571,
-0.3253421187,
0.6758500934,
-0.4370800555,
-0.6908717752,
-0.0549399108,
-0.1005662829,
-0.2107014358,
-0.427957803,
0.7364503145,
0.752812624,
0.2682740688,
-0.1416483223,
0.5490888357,
0.2618376911,
0.6693640351,
0.4906107187,
1.2166534662,
-0.5075703263,
0.2553755045,
-0.3029460311,
-0.6983433366,
-0.305183351,
-1.1040883064,
-1.1052269936,
-0.1614851356,
-0.4026333988,
-0.2209447622,
-0.1958972067,
0.5305763483,
0.1542100608,
-0.9768579006,
-0.3137629032,
0.075615339,
0.2640522718,
0.0624135435,
-0.2914153636,
-0.1047807336,
-0.1390362829,
-0.6399088502,
0.6016901135,
0.5373834968,
0.2472417206,
-0.5038953424,
0.1853483319,
-0.1240776926,
0.2084571421,
0.610575676,
0.2554829717,
-0.7930285335,
-0.1643273532,
0.2833779156,
-0.1029815972,
-0.1710065901,
0.9133767486,
-0.5753228068,
0.22370857,
0.5596323609,
0.9796692729,
-0.3603301942,
-0.0168507881,
0.5881619453,
-0.8470683694,
0.3664170802,
0.0293205362,
0.5259240866,
0.077611126,
-0.9262677431,
0.0899726972,
0.3068661094,
-0.198334381,
-1.2019207478,
0.6545661688,
-1.1095986366,
-0.4341048002,
1.222910881,
-0.0072125681,
-0.8015459776,
-0.3331250548,
-0.2807559371,
-0.1470405459,
-0.5928237438,
0.4233770072,
0.6040052176,
0.1707836837,
0.0450076014,
-0.8857021332,
0.2127592266,
-0.0027256955,
-0.8545333147,
-0.1334372908,
0.2813909352,
-0.107154578,
0.1199350879,
0.2192947268,
-0.0033346366,
0.1882224381,
-0.341160804,
-0.1079571024,
-0.0511595756,
-0.1030460671,
-0.62360847,
0.4057245255,
-0.009128307,
-0.0907931626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05477v1 | Hexatagging: Projective Dependency Parsing as Tagging | 2023-06-08T18:02:07 | 2023-06-08T18:02:07 | Afra Amini, Tianyu Liu, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce a novel dependency parser, the hexatagger, that constructs
dependency trees by tagging the words in a sentence with elements from a finite
set of possible tags. In contrast to many approaches to dependency parsing, our
approach is fully parallelizable at training time, i.e., the structure-building
actions needed to build a dependency parse can be predicted in parallel to each
other. Additionally, exact decoding is linear in time and space complexity.
Furthermore, we derive a probabilistic dependency parser that predicts hexatags
using no more than a linear model with features from a pretrained language
model, i.e., we forsake a bespoke architecture explicitly designed for the
task. Despite the generality and simplicity of our approach, we achieve
state-of-the-art performance of 96.4 LAS and 97.4 UAS on the Penn Treebank test
set. Additionally, our parser's linear time complexity and parallelism
significantly improve computational efficiency, with a roughly 10-times
speed-up over previous state-of-the-art models during decoding. | [
-0.2999464571,
-0.1012537479,
0.611692369,
0.6802697778,
-0.083828941,
0.4628394544,
-0.0085241329,
-0.7736765742,
0.2868841588,
0.1189378202,
-0.2643468976,
-0.64223665,
-0.6802886128,
-0.0949809477,
-0.1846586168,
0.6788369417,
-0.240984574,
-0.236174807,
-0.1215385497,
-0.072882466,
-0.1548220068,
-0.5344696641,
-0.1414796561,
-0.2461726516,
0.6034677029,
0.347784102,
0.5491654277,
1.0234774351,
0.4545505345,
0.3181904256,
-0.2463719696,
-0.297739774,
-0.0687810034,
-0.1280946136,
-0.3207410872,
-0.1989367753,
-0.3796535432,
-0.1456308365,
0.6405155063,
1.1346459389,
-0.0218995456,
0.2038859874,
-0.102017805,
0.5523945093,
-1.004501462,
0.4630304575,
-0.6451093554,
-0.0071540345,
-0.3102333844,
-0.1207289472,
-0.6776214838,
-0.1050437018,
-0.0003548152,
-0.6010116935,
0.1834281385,
0.2631717324,
1.1083419323,
0.1918058395,
-0.2551336884,
-0.0256584045,
-0.6799623966,
0.6745616198,
-0.5209688544,
0.3091216981,
0.5237626433,
0.4073668122,
-0.0638433099,
-0.8688603044,
-0.1458214521,
-0.2047214061,
-0.2401838601,
-0.1702440977,
-0.0380219594,
0.4559713006,
0.238090843,
0.5578796268,
-0.4830622077,
0.0475949086,
0.0543257818,
-0.2445580214,
0.4325967133,
0.2291362882,
0.2544174492,
-0.4988123477,
-0.5290890336,
0.0218071714,
-0.4170508981,
0.1742872298,
0.4493344128,
0.3586105704,
0.1610607654,
0.5292492509,
-0.3284648061,
0.6134703755,
-0.1746118963,
0.0930204019,
0.1199859232,
-0.3372170925,
-0.0846492425,
0.3143781424,
1.0173162222,
0.1204734966,
0.2911494672,
-0.1988757849,
-0.0277641304,
0.6762301922,
0.1722953022,
-0.633100152,
-0.6621756554,
0.2370363772,
-0.5861353278,
-0.0703354478,
-0.1617340893,
-0.5286637545,
-0.1782279164,
0.0151636144,
0.1658476442,
-0.9475576282,
-0.2976875305,
0.5305464864,
-0.140144065,
0.0258669239,
0.0273020677,
-1.1744230986,
0.5261641741,
0.8724008799,
0.5913663507,
0.1797620803,
-0.51118958,
-0.6652356386,
0.3958234489,
-0.1801489294,
1.2528501749,
-0.7980262041,
-0.0986887962,
-0.0678166971,
-0.2851398289,
-0.1396445483,
-0.3634748459,
0.6830348372,
-0.2925291061,
-0.0969999433,
-0.467427969,
-0.760453105,
-0.210283801,
0.3079954684,
-0.5035908222,
0.7365230322,
0.4764003754,
-0.8551643491,
0.4254613817,
-0.0525323972,
-0.1708288789,
0.4876145124,
-0.364674598,
-0.3686035872,
0.0141917653,
-0.0173355192,
0.2601131499,
-0.2346079797,
0.2828496993,
-0.2771219015,
-0.0358618088,
-0.5041287541,
0.2330959141,
0.8927816153,
0.061486844,
-0.2929063737,
0.3288434446,
-1.1102443933,
-0.0194652844,
0.014300677,
-0.5730727315,
-0.2871243358,
0.626926899,
0.2202389687,
0.0009658096,
0.1755271554,
-1.0175265074,
0.3367091715,
-0.5954683423,
0.1303832829,
0.6219060421,
-0.3232116699,
0.4057695568,
-0.195225969,
0.4538583457,
0.1483840048,
-0.172810927,
-0.5263256431,
-0.5902956128,
-0.5870321393,
-0.3726221621,
0.4606851041,
0.5336399674,
-0.6620493531,
0.7297924161,
-0.0587113276,
-0.358900398,
-0.3467351198,
0.0037302952,
0.6324639916,
0.2831320465,
0.2918834984,
-0.4403770268,
-0.7889463305,
-0.7624719739,
-0.4680337608,
-0.4562155306,
0.3073923588,
-0.137557134,
0.266730845,
-0.0981649235,
0.9222823381,
-0.646445632,
-0.3744904995,
-0.5179973841,
0.3461679816,
0.1044163555,
0.5517591834,
0.7479841709,
-0.181280911,
-0.9394257069,
0.1212886721,
-0.5440896749,
-0.0392180532,
0.0003058584,
0.2482255548,
0.1028101072,
0.5128856897,
-0.6521161199,
0.475863874,
0.3454522491,
-0.8143441081,
0.6134212613,
-0.2570040822,
-0.4372429252,
-1.0592392683,
-0.0980713144,
-0.0595501475,
-0.4061985612,
-0.4924197495,
-0.0248846039,
0.0182475243,
0.4473451972,
-0.3054134846,
0.1213967502,
-0.6026862264,
-0.2537287772,
-0.18124412,
-0.5013405085,
-0.0049401335,
0.5190655589,
-0.0298906825,
0.3717255294,
0.6148987412,
0.0284817349,
0.3706068695,
0.2180078626,
-0.3290282786,
0.1688776612,
-0.4477900267,
-0.2826620638,
-0.3501743972,
0.1860767454,
-1.0830177069,
-0.0104569672,
0.3397238851,
-0.3980502188,
-0.0002352913,
-0.2879983187,
-0.8709279895,
-0.2322969437,
-0.3263082206,
0.7025756836,
0.4155088663,
-0.7657669783,
0.6768876314,
0.1249677762,
0.1846664101,
-0.5508691072,
-0.0384448767,
0.1426477134,
0.1687869877,
-0.5974160433,
0.5606408119,
0.1790381819,
-0.2488153875,
0.3558179736,
-0.0061290823,
-0.1451107264,
0.0639746934,
0.300185591,
0.0454346761,
-0.3952574432,
-0.2663783133,
-0.1721079201,
-0.5734709501,
0.2862214446,
-0.3209057152,
0.8203905821,
-0.2224156111,
-0.2613946795,
-0.5135069489,
0.7392270565,
0.138389796,
-0.3364911675,
0.6825559735,
0.6286584139,
-0.4854216278,
-0.1317627579,
-0.2179391235,
0.3602820933,
-0.5031018257,
0.0384426676,
-0.5302453637,
-0.9363725781,
0.488694787,
-0.0441721864,
0.0549171194,
0.2561005354,
0.3960927427,
-0.0014538664,
1.1890358925,
0.9615064859,
-0.0933416188,
0.3887863457,
-0.135513261,
0.4306554794,
-0.3936733007,
-0.1770468801,
-0.7423363924,
-0.0937174484,
-0.8089614511,
-0.1752123088,
-0.0889541134,
0.2316391617,
-0.089974463,
0.5586984158,
-0.6326819062,
0.7044825554,
0.7191023231,
-0.3763131201,
0.2774735093,
-0.0730678365,
-0.205499813,
0.0956578702,
-0.599768579,
-0.1757977456,
0.5885580778,
0.4410481155,
0.553047657,
-0.1007068902,
0.6699160933,
-0.2034234107,
-0.03972435,
-0.9434669018,
0.5786167383,
-0.4789711237,
-0.1600799859,
0.3262195587,
-0.2840822339,
-1.0336315632,
0.1520833075,
-0.0490293726,
-1.1775664091,
0.2887791991,
0.4256624877,
-0.562007308,
0.5833227038,
-0.8739624023,
0.8418449759,
0.1283097118,
-0.2631874084,
-0.0923357755,
-0.8228543401,
0.2052454501,
0.5174056292,
-0.1843164861,
-0.4471066296,
0.1484070718,
0.6949387789,
-0.6119829416,
0.6970246434,
-0.2217535824,
0.1448936909,
0.176115647,
0.2103143185,
0.1257012039,
0.0624088831,
0.291849941,
0.083050251,
0.4154608846,
-0.6394278407,
-0.1778603941,
0.487051785,
-0.8923968673,
-0.4098039865,
-0.940826118,
-1.01062572,
-0.3257158995,
0.3048695028,
0.2238280624,
0.3641437292,
0.0076820492,
-0.4617854357,
0.4520400763,
-0.3243198097,
0.8407213092,
0.0758483037,
-0.477816999,
-0.484025836,
1.1956849098,
-0.0781733245,
0.0656360462,
0.4714922607,
0.2689741254,
0.0258137751,
-0.491628468,
-0.3096720278,
0.6004880071,
-0.4746925533,
-0.2757629156,
-0.8433684111,
-0.4665346146,
-0.4710719287,
-0.2620315552,
-0.598516643,
-0.6308024526,
-0.0911290348,
0.0347788855,
0.386193186,
1.0915941,
-0.1380688101,
0.723380208,
-1.0104533434,
0.4179081619,
0.2310548723,
0.9008272886,
-0.3035341501,
0.3192668855,
-0.1947603226,
-0.5998753905,
-0.1862496436,
-0.7859095335,
0.4871737361,
-0.039419625,
0.2568606734,
0.3909450769,
-0.1134138852,
0.427379787,
-0.8547366858,
0.6893307567,
0.3326530457,
-1.100528121,
0.2353821099,
-0.6114547253,
0.4324954152,
0.7004867196,
0.5459486842,
-0.3933148682,
-0.0208331384,
-0.5876091123,
-1.0412428379,
0.9510217309,
0.0401671454,
-0.3572961092,
-0.0719772652,
0.3151713312,
-0.0000960226,
0.0083643766,
-0.3016511202,
-0.1977237314,
-0.152075693,
-0.2748741508,
-0.1407332271,
-0.872066915,
0.2798375189,
-0.5244138241,
0.2709147632,
0.0335181691,
0.4533863068,
-0.1303962916,
0.0308921486,
-0.2464400977,
0.0889931321,
0.3626877666,
0.4312590957,
-0.6515336633,
0.6701315641,
-0.4870873094,
-0.3176793754,
0.2030165941,
0.3573741019,
0.3147345185,
0.2699902952,
0.2200634331,
0.72203511,
-0.1350406557,
-0.5409618616,
0.4306561053,
-0.1953442842,
-0.2829709351,
-0.3323625326,
-0.093944408,
0.4609615505,
0.0196003225,
-0.3136072159,
0.0688083842,
0.1161503196,
-0.3084558845,
0.2338965088,
0.2145520449,
-0.2478924096,
-0.5920732617,
0.6310979724,
0.021857651,
-0.4927273989,
0.4529711902,
-0.5790300965,
-0.5573286414,
0.5254153609,
0.6813876033,
0.9700529575,
-0.5669547319,
0.2017232478,
0.3681240678,
0.2341069579,
0.000111578,
0.6963226795,
-0.3602170646,
-0.8696399927,
-0.7332118154,
-0.7805628181,
-0.3759159148,
-0.2925602496,
-0.6406040788,
0.004377739,
-0.8560353518,
0.2739948332,
0.3669276834,
-0.2739022672,
-0.1064744666,
-0.1154952198,
0.2649589181,
1.1729255915,
-0.7969452739,
0.9860988855,
0.913862288,
-0.19961299,
-0.7380610704,
-0.0815425217,
0.0318660811,
-0.5487880111,
0.5295428038,
0.4817321599,
0.0971350521,
0.1582276225,
-0.1540786624,
-0.9744846225,
0.4548251033,
0.4226769805,
-0.5789253116,
-0.3110382855,
0.7068225741,
0.4129600525,
-0.1623973548,
0.1041933671,
0.8870411515,
0.1770887673,
0.1205575988,
-0.9624946117,
-0.0429696403,
-0.4250373542,
0.2795013189,
0.7434523106,
-0.4518054128,
0.8360358477,
0.1472744048,
-0.2223058343,
0.1058954298,
0.7305151224,
0.1467329413,
0.0411828719,
0.6700458527,
1.1418081522,
0.2112597823,
-0.0535764694,
0.9748175144,
-0.4878782332,
0.4088985026,
1.1792451143,
-0.2971466482,
0.829842329,
0.5281516314,
-0.109647803,
0.5463775992,
0.536601305,
0.2844977975,
0.4004346132,
0.190184921,
-0.7704249024,
-0.4475728869,
-0.4612223804,
-0.0734409988,
0.4322752357,
0.4878434837,
-0.2826546729,
-0.9411933422,
-0.1009720713,
0.142307505,
0.3025672436,
-0.1831575185,
0.7264744639,
0.113167949,
-0.6252053976,
0.6529251933,
0.0834423602,
0.485098958,
-0.4261572063,
-0.1778624505,
0.3122241199,
0.5940991044,
-0.4661461711,
-0.8930518627,
0.7474588156,
-0.2203764766,
-0.2284030616,
-0.625667274,
0.5691259503,
-0.2307429165,
-0.4682391882,
0.5778996944,
0.3759955168,
-0.2346639931,
0.0012557852,
-0.4884260893,
0.199302122,
-0.0977971032,
-0.0638780296,
0.4368204176,
0.1934965849,
-0.058468882,
0.3488924503,
0.3041315377,
0.0061479039,
0.2313820571,
-0.0373619385,
1.1721762419,
-0.7877344489,
-0.5001718402,
-0.8668522835,
0.54418993,
0.2848585546,
-0.1070035771,
0.6348984241,
0.5452064872,
0.9640536308,
0.3103931844,
0.6386470795,
-0.2850734591,
0.4257946014,
-0.0207239967,
0.3562952876,
-0.0838750899,
0.2177205235,
-0.1701577455,
-0.7485693693,
-0.6626264453,
0.4275033772,
-0.3752655387,
-0.3528945744,
0.9096142054,
0.5346642733,
-0.0547869727,
0.0345184058,
0.1637641937,
0.1947265416,
0.6290562153,
0.8432640433,
1.1074787378,
-0.168474257,
0.292275399,
-0.8177399039,
-0.3463237882,
0.2609753907,
-0.74659127,
-0.9474386573,
-0.7356901765,
-0.2213144749,
-0.492692709,
0.0118811289,
1.1253786087,
0.4814731777,
-0.7529324293,
-0.5946410894,
-0.5074734092,
0.1383904219,
0.012678748,
-0.1955490112,
0.2507978082,
-0.7806534171,
-0.3847423792,
0.2485949844,
0.5412921309,
-0.4494021535,
0.1119453162,
0.4156237543,
-0.599301219,
-0.2484955937,
0.7314397693,
0.2802292109,
-0.3514947891,
-0.4570426941,
-0.2263619751,
0.0952240601,
0.5863011479,
0.812958777,
-1.1655344963,
0.2893081903,
0.9024634957,
0.6765760779,
0.3083400428,
-0.0883293524,
0.5100775361,
-0.6648716927,
0.1581283063,
0.2896904349,
0.5766880512,
0.1348659694,
-0.2151042819,
0.1279117763,
0.5282682776,
-0.5310021639,
-0.6727176905,
0.5581412911,
-1.2439587116,
-0.2639427483,
1.0773599148,
-0.343344152,
-0.5967443585,
-0.4195294678,
-0.3117800653,
0.0155354105,
-0.284275651,
0.5905693769,
0.253550142,
-0.3941026926,
-0.2939920723,
0.1787053645,
0.5788533688,
0.5308573246,
-0.9162437916,
0.1753584594,
0.4163399339,
0.3500181735,
0.4538429677,
0.633980155,
0.1079912111,
0.3915830255,
0.095409669,
0.3703893125,
0.1448403001,
-0.3464942575,
-0.2626689076,
0.639554441,
0.405123055,
-0.2841699719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05425v1 | MIMIC-IT: Multi-Modal In-Context Instruction Tuning | 2023-06-08T17:59:56 | 2023-06-08T17:59:56 | Bo Li, Yuanhan Zhang, Liangyu Chen, Jinghao Wang, Fanyi Pu, Jingkang Yang, Chunyuan Li, Ziwei Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | High-quality instructions and responses are essential for the zero-shot
performance of large language models on interactive natural language tasks. For
interactive vision-language tasks involving intricate visual scenes, a large
quantity of diverse and creative instruction-response pairs should be
imperative to tune vision-language models (VLMs). Nevertheless, the current
availability of vision-language instruction-response pairs in terms of
quantity, diversity, and creativity remains limited, posing challenges to the
generalization of interactive VLMs. Here we present MultI-Modal In-Context
Instruction Tuning (MIMIC-IT), a dataset comprising 2.8 million multimodal
instruction-response pairs, with 2.2 million unique instructions derived from
images and videos. Each pair is accompanied by multi-modal in-context
information, forming conversational contexts aimed at empowering VLMs in
perception, reasoning, and planning. The instruction-response collection
process, dubbed as Syphus, is scaled using an automatic annotation pipeline
that combines human expertise with GPT's capabilities. Using the MIMIC-IT
dataset, we train a large VLM named Otter. Based on extensive evaluations
conducted on vision-language benchmarks, it has been observed that Otter
demonstrates remarkable proficiency in multi-modal perception, reasoning, and
in-context learning. Human evaluation reveals it effectively aligns with the
user's intentions. We release the MIMIC-IT dataset, instruction-response
collection pipeline, benchmarks, and the Otter model. | [
-0.5113869905,
-0.6920639873,
0.1981222183,
0.2481272668,
-0.3723036647,
0.0132293757,
-0.2252356559,
-0.5028181672,
0.1420504898,
0.3151181042,
-0.6894737482,
-0.2645094693,
-0.3720992804,
0.0128473314,
-0.2547352612,
0.7743139863,
0.1335552782,
0.2861393094,
0.0465643741,
-0.2254367024,
-0.6407151222,
-0.3549004793,
-0.5978775024,
0.1955977976,
0.3364872932,
0.2545115948,
0.4741747975,
1.0322390795,
0.3250798881,
0.2663323283,
0.2160174251,
0.3909628987,
-0.4170035124,
0.0834484994,
-0.260225445,
-0.1590638459,
-0.436910063,
-0.0743224099,
0.8859046698,
0.4381485581,
-0.0335280225,
0.3590150476,
0.2496690303,
0.2609448731,
-0.7164943218,
0.4753422737,
-0.5592336059,
-0.2113135308,
-0.214793399,
-0.3294718266,
-0.6065405011,
0.0402385816,
0.1184673011,
-0.8514962792,
0.1562172621,
0.414039433,
0.7814865708,
0.3051879704,
-0.4364796281,
-0.1280127615,
-0.4461534321,
0.9546772838,
-0.5109106302,
0.3238372207,
0.2414457947,
0.3179906011,
-0.0134892361,
-0.5535709858,
-0.5872323513,
-0.2296199352,
-0.0998022333,
0.2941337228,
-0.0048041842,
0.2339348048,
0.451885432,
0.2187473327,
-0.5167191029,
-0.0727056041,
-0.3133947551,
-0.281745106,
0.2888565958,
0.4683646262,
0.2768499851,
-0.0871017724,
-0.488004148,
-0.4953647554,
-0.4896939993,
0.3994688392,
0.3753440082,
0.2634061575,
-0.0720639899,
0.6236166358,
-0.1864641011,
1.1816312075,
0.1375200748,
-0.1178606227,
0.2060656101,
-0.6176136136,
-0.2554732561,
0.0332104191,
0.5148046613,
0.4595520794,
0.1992743015,
0.0909841731,
-0.2818324864,
0.1826021373,
0.4739878476,
-0.7631242275,
-0.0846585631,
-0.2044285387,
-0.3388487995,
-0.0497119091,
0.139737919,
-0.7766292095,
-0.0662475005,
-0.7131031752,
0.8627585769,
-0.5645627975,
-0.1918794513,
0.2123716325,
-0.2332703918,
0.4863888621,
0.4227032959,
-0.8126652837,
0.3236224949,
0.5854260325,
0.555980742,
-0.0188098364,
-0.5627599955,
-1.032379508,
0.4338147938,
-0.3032748401,
0.6520192027,
-1.189183712,
-0.2893077433,
-0.1059961393,
0.0679058805,
-0.558393538,
-0.477291882,
0.084638983,
-0.0985091105,
0.3423745036,
-0.3887108266,
-0.4862766564,
-0.1975003034,
0.2448877692,
-0.707508862,
0.8475636244,
0.1824743003,
-0.6892219782,
0.4969584942,
-0.6188768148,
-0.4478859007,
0.0780808479,
-0.2035584301,
-0.2073612362,
0.2801963687,
0.3151683211,
0.2436983585,
-0.1823302805,
-0.1800993979,
-0.2821812034,
-0.7380172014,
-0.0368925221,
-0.3649412692,
0.5948850513,
0.0026193406,
-0.5975488424,
0.2757770419,
-0.5937674642,
0.3682355881,
-0.2774918079,
-0.2901710868,
-0.3555802107,
-0.1491881162,
0.0773711205,
0.1388652176,
0.1698687524,
-0.538911283,
0.4550583959,
-0.1295755506,
0.2835206687,
0.8989221454,
-0.1308065653,
0.3145218492,
-0.3752145767,
0.4094229639,
-0.0366199315,
0.583630085,
-0.8324160576,
-0.5867487192,
-0.6689714193,
-0.6364747882,
-0.2509720922,
0.3631474078,
-0.7933921218,
-0.0380496681,
-0.1439082623,
-0.0607849024,
-0.7867168784,
0.1310751885,
0.7338468432,
0.6907464862,
0.4865184426,
-0.3670042455,
-0.3570089638,
-0.9712389708,
-0.2131945193,
-0.095198445,
0.0699694604,
0.6857278347,
0.2205724865,
-0.0276793316,
0.6269032359,
-0.1351821423,
-0.3867691159,
-0.0034208433,
0.2903226018,
-0.158480227,
0.2385455072,
0.5778550506,
-0.6837648749,
-0.4935742319,
0.0808019713,
-0.6691139936,
-0.0681730583,
-0.0353494287,
-0.0927111208,
0.2435424924,
0.3872573674,
-0.278963238,
0.254717499,
0.6731008291,
-0.3243677616,
0.5367947221,
-0.2812970877,
0.5322102904,
-1.3135874271,
0.1708056182,
-0.0449264795,
0.0724006072,
-0.2797595859,
0.2748725414,
0.2665937543,
0.0714430958,
-0.3161635995,
0.720718801,
-0.6386145949,
-0.0340780541,
-0.0881246477,
-0.259960711,
-0.1852332205,
0.5667829514,
0.1539060771,
1.0649749041,
0.857446909,
-0.446711123,
0.4915183187,
0.0889740288,
-0.1982858628,
0.9250426888,
-0.5367280245,
0.0698154569,
-0.0986005142,
0.0709748268,
-0.76375103,
-0.5053579807,
0.1514136195,
0.0009541271,
0.4511836171,
-0.0649529248,
-0.3982226551,
-0.2644184828,
-0.4595084786,
0.3670524955,
0.3301214576,
-0.6494563222,
0.9055514932,
0.0310762115,
0.0323600955,
-0.763974905,
-0.1671778709,
0.1837009937,
-0.0516891368,
-0.4520091414,
0.1767870337,
-0.3757391572,
-0.1315845549,
0.1099494994,
-0.2347320169,
-0.0824884027,
-0.2578562498,
0.3941692412,
0.3557743132,
-0.3648821115,
0.0108812992,
0.0371704213,
-0.0718585625,
-0.2116176784,
-0.2492937148,
0.3970556557,
-0.4172525108,
-0.6413849592,
-0.4682163894,
0.3645707965,
0.7539001107,
-0.28905797,
0.3947516978,
0.7033627629,
-0.0886664838,
-0.2462044656,
-0.5254055262,
-0.576225996,
-0.4422126412,
0.4311107695,
-0.458398968,
-0.7589387298,
0.0740489736,
-0.036552038,
0.2311365455,
-0.1442081481,
0.3528782129,
-0.2429897487,
1.3032827377,
0.7828118801,
-0.1477340758,
0.7327834368,
-0.1476008445,
0.026455624,
-0.8781043291,
-0.3846324384,
-0.2341275811,
-0.4893616736,
-0.1689730585,
-0.2963735163,
0.5632879734,
-0.1663778871,
-0.1779669225,
0.6772954464,
-0.3863494098,
0.5330318213,
0.8739533424,
0.3042091727,
0.2944959402,
0.1978909075,
-0.1470770836,
-0.3030352294,
-0.406058073,
-0.3404178023,
0.912663579,
-0.0452923775,
1.0791541338,
0.011451547,
0.4852877259,
-0.0407983437,
0.135354057,
-0.678234458,
0.6042770147,
-0.2214538455,
-0.4133080244,
-0.214183718,
-0.2027714998,
-0.6670688987,
0.1352975219,
-0.1324074566,
-0.8454343677,
-0.283939153,
0.5489083529,
-0.2085309923,
0.1206193343,
-0.9628206491,
0.8896182179,
-0.2799826562,
-0.6797062755,
-0.4141323864,
-0.6981258988,
0.220898211,
-0.0630358532,
-0.035182301,
0.2721439302,
-0.2005192786,
0.0830689818,
-0.0092350645,
0.9399334192,
-0.0096281618,
0.0106479656,
0.0230680872,
0.3365592062,
0.3447850645,
-0.0203420967,
0.1166589037,
-0.0785400569,
0.076792039,
-0.3325714767,
-0.5855659246,
0.7404467463,
-0.5823740363,
-0.6271535754,
-0.1233691126,
-0.7849411964,
-0.2281427532,
0.1088100746,
0.3287596107,
0.8302643299,
0.0970800146,
0.2775012851,
0.7676907182,
-0.1586522013,
0.5412448645,
0.5841134787,
-0.001051142,
-0.1700289845,
1.138568759,
-0.0601149723,
0.3655586541,
0.4252012372,
-0.0265278295,
-0.2218911499,
0.0281378813,
-0.8929831386,
0.0792727768,
-0.3886523843,
-0.0399011485,
-0.4525004923,
-0.0636558533,
-0.0313756727,
-0.1854960471,
-0.2875994444,
0.0026819368,
-0.0957940966,
0.2600660324,
0.0856868699,
0.787651062,
0.0527009517,
0.1624134332,
-0.6254771352,
0.3771781921,
0.6178866029,
0.3681255579,
-0.2588075399,
-0.5913193822,
-0.0163743738,
0.2113509029,
-0.0706415251,
-0.8051036596,
0.2031355649,
0.6023418307,
0.7830910683,
0.3989832103,
-0.2065925449,
1.0661301613,
-0.3741695881,
0.7283779383,
-0.0041791955,
-0.9285255075,
0.5529785156,
-0.316630125,
0.4017316997,
0.0988134891,
0.1954484284,
-0.3040638268,
-0.4670413136,
-0.3216282129,
-0.6596599817,
0.9103937745,
-0.0628751367,
0.4789279103,
0.0508799702,
0.0209578536,
0.243842423,
0.3884683251,
-0.5186170936,
0.0175311025,
-0.4783866107,
-0.2366667986,
0.1471397877,
-0.0144206975,
-0.3392787278,
-0.3624926209,
0.5106185079,
-0.5256359577,
0.0697696358,
-0.2639846206,
-0.2496354282,
-0.2619736493,
0.0930272117,
0.78082335,
0.5847177505,
-0.0341446511,
0.1586562246,
0.0930746198,
-0.511684835,
-0.147383824,
-0.0396651737,
-0.0114243831,
-0.1631392539,
0.4852568805,
0.8329536915,
0.4956797957,
-0.8675498366,
0.7028287649,
-0.1767428964,
0.0270228218,
0.044541914,
0.4210166633,
-0.136975795,
0.2636703849,
0.2578936517,
0.2800921798,
0.1397107244,
-0.521854043,
0.2459629625,
0.609280467,
-0.4128310978,
-0.5080965161,
0.6047216654,
0.0318828262,
-0.1371229589,
0.6977268457,
-0.0499720424,
-0.2652318478,
0.5782679319,
0.7819194794,
0.6663375497,
-0.1690795571,
0.3371636569,
0.5939065218,
0.2651018202,
-0.0219084658,
0.3506105542,
-0.3486689031,
-0.3564409614,
-0.4293619096,
-0.6007286906,
-0.2889837325,
0.1872739494,
-0.8713172674,
0.2760721743,
-0.4711834192,
0.0329692513,
-0.1132122353,
-0.5215762258,
-0.7674953938,
-0.1037128344,
-0.0572694354,
0.8921666741,
-0.7552040815,
0.7833848,
1.0760952234,
-0.5217346549,
-1.0769230127,
0.2272156477,
0.1874226481,
-1.1379913092,
0.7992538214,
0.3063441217,
-0.4208704829,
0.2406471819,
-0.7572228909,
-0.5493226647,
0.9509221315,
0.7452397943,
-0.6401131153,
-0.0797453448,
-0.193399027,
0.5204330683,
-0.3254697919,
0.3106666505,
0.2586635649,
0.3909024894,
0.1261726171,
-1.3764287233,
-0.1486838013,
-0.3508920372,
0.0272294711,
0.1453270614,
-0.7895284295,
0.9110431075,
-0.4340837598,
-0.1353824735,
0.1361543387,
0.0671175197,
0.1481831372,
0.0903265774,
0.504244566,
0.5223858356,
0.260186553,
-0.057388287,
0.994531095,
-0.5815988183,
-0.0279622842,
1.0043941736,
-0.111788705,
0.7958686948,
0.6471715569,
0.380502969,
0.330803901,
0.4126763046,
0.0100532379,
0.5587030053,
-0.085581094,
-0.5247263908,
-0.5975514054,
-0.3667778373,
-0.2862282097,
0.5501485467,
0.3064419329,
-0.2929796875,
-0.3487637937,
0.1570681334,
-0.2865146399,
0.1640583575,
-0.2641014755,
0.9289928079,
-0.1365901083,
-0.7629968524,
0.3790861368,
-0.3747299612,
0.5716177225,
-0.6443285346,
-0.5490625501,
-0.2449484318,
0.1881081909,
0.0588256344,
-0.8133255839,
-0.1111838147,
-0.1591583639,
-0.1565043628,
-0.2611592412,
0.3078047931,
-0.4172597229,
-0.2163846493,
0.3246127665,
0.364623785,
-0.0656623393,
0.0138621349,
-0.4978737831,
0.2353140116,
-0.0968334824,
-0.2275651097,
0.3846004307,
0.3397227228,
-0.2657293081,
0.8812888265,
0.483305335,
0.0344614685,
0.2826861143,
0.1001982391,
0.9958698153,
-0.3556731343,
-0.209437713,
-0.593313396,
0.5783871412,
-0.1806969196,
-0.4866347015,
0.6767299771,
0.5306360722,
1.0754086971,
-0.358294785,
0.6086577773,
-0.0401565917,
0.1524022371,
-0.5125582218,
0.1250690967,
-0.7031493187,
0.0321502127,
-0.2868328094,
-1.0571148396,
0.1158325449,
0.7904412746,
0.089191705,
0.1630203575,
0.6204915047,
1.0608128309,
-0.472987175,
-0.0458169505,
0.4114743769,
-0.0122918691,
0.1162432134,
0.5398865342,
0.7786846757,
-0.2319722474,
0.5919478536,
-0.2229646444,
-0.3576846719,
-0.211942628,
-0.8792148829,
-0.8479260206,
-0.8437774181,
-0.031014163,
-0.06472186,
0.2668623626,
0.9554846883,
0.9709975123,
-0.6740753651,
-0.2485478371,
0.1608867496,
-0.4997004569,
-0.6319747567,
-0.2311995327,
0.0976168662,
-0.6145689487,
-0.9318811297,
0.4846947491,
0.688251555,
-0.0051572323,
-0.2414775789,
-0.1946084052,
0.3202520609,
-0.1233880669,
0.6334434748,
0.2935979664,
-0.8920292854,
-0.4738600552,
0.593749702,
-0.3055812716,
-0.3237343431,
0.8065354228,
-0.7296826839,
1.1352905035,
0.0289112478,
0.5278872252,
0.4735530615,
0.0468127504,
0.7293349504,
-0.9540271163,
0.1379631162,
0.0153542571,
0.3071564734,
0.157047987,
-0.09806256,
0.281264931,
0.2343253046,
-0.177862227,
-0.6806877255,
0.3112540841,
-1.1655596495,
-0.1482802927,
1.0546665192,
0.0318191834,
-0.1382938325,
0.0608750656,
-0.8665406704,
-0.0518417433,
-0.4839406312,
1.0157883167,
0.557928741,
-0.20077236,
-0.3593804836,
-0.557842195,
0.4682885408,
0.4996427894,
-0.7510847449,
-0.0400478765,
0.7510589957,
0.2973484695,
0.0585882924,
0.3626123071,
0.0622578338,
0.5551299453,
0.1164349318,
-0.136492759,
-0.4787971079,
-0.5497779846,
-0.0344666727,
0.0686657578,
-0.0522295609,
-0.4367828965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05406v1 | Mixture-of-Domain-Adapters: Decoupling and Injecting Domain Knowledge to Pre-trained Language Models Memories | 2023-06-08T17:54:36 | 2023-06-08T17:54:36 | Shizhe Diao, Tianyang Xu, Ruijia Xu, Jiawei Wang, Tong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) demonstrate excellent abilities to
understand texts in the generic domain while struggling in a specific domain.
Although continued pre-training on a large domain-specific corpus is effective,
it is costly to tune all the parameters on the domain. In this paper, we
investigate whether we can adapt PLMs both effectively and efficiently by only
tuning a few parameters. Specifically, we decouple the feed-forward networks
(FFNs) of the Transformer architecture into two parts: the original pre-trained
FFNs to maintain the old-domain knowledge and our novel domain-specific
adapters to inject domain-specific knowledge in parallel. Then we adopt a
mixture-of-adapters gate to fuse the knowledge from different domain adapters
dynamically. Our proposed Mixture-of-Domain-Adapters (MixDA) employs a
two-stage adapter-tuning strategy that leverages both unlabeled data and
labeled data to help the domain adaptation: i) domain-specific adapter on
unlabeled data; followed by ii) the task-specific adapter on labeled data.
MixDA can be seamlessly plugged into the pretraining-finetuning paradigm and
our experiments demonstrate that MixDA achieves superior performance on
in-domain tasks (GLUE), out-of-domain tasks (ChemProt, RCT, IMDB, Amazon), and
knowledge-intensive tasks (KILT). Further analyses demonstrate the reliability,
scalability, and efficiency of our method. The code is available at
https://github.com/Amano-Aki/Mixture-of-Domain-Adapters. | [
-0.5823923349,
-0.3883351386,
0.3044730723,
0.2700315714,
-0.3627416193,
0.2220031023,
-0.4123948812,
-0.0107543916,
-0.0603286698,
0.613648355,
-0.4969303608,
-0.0670208558,
-0.607791841,
-0.014841822,
-0.277775377,
1.05990839,
-0.0699178576,
-0.1037497818,
-0.3980360329,
-0.1486015171,
-0.6370776296,
-0.2196776867,
-0.3816165328,
-0.3978325129,
0.304179579,
0.2777912021,
0.4634766579,
0.4538097382,
0.2618871033,
0.333635062,
0.224037379,
0.529469192,
-0.69490242,
-0.040088363,
-0.527233541,
-0.3454699516,
-0.3115932047,
-0.1061855927,
0.5025667548,
0.8271519542,
-0.1067217663,
-0.159600392,
0.4052560925,
0.6549251676,
-0.6366752386,
-0.0166146439,
-0.8759427071,
-0.2697702944,
-0.1526302397,
-0.3557359874,
-0.4391905665,
-0.0110206828,
0.1725400984,
-0.9748792052,
0.253210485,
0.2108503431,
0.7759960294,
0.3905618787,
-0.3604341447,
-0.0201574024,
-0.9544953704,
0.8931304216,
-0.551781714,
0.3774945736,
0.1926128566,
0.392399013,
-0.2160340995,
-0.8573203087,
-0.7385705113,
0.4841796458,
-0.2473617345,
0.2099960893,
-0.0892996266,
-0.1309358627,
-0.0990425199,
0.5317761302,
-0.5718567967,
0.056005124,
-0.1424587071,
-0.0927290693,
0.2936367691,
-0.0167491548,
0.2884185016,
0.4635844827,
-0.3906435966,
-0.2095550746,
-0.7394106388,
-0.2374978811,
0.2707012892,
0.2720422149,
-0.0349398069,
0.1840991229,
-0.0546131879,
0.9554353356,
0.5253471732,
-0.2295183241,
0.2596901655,
-0.4765624106,
-0.2942969203,
-0.3446221054,
0.5122019649,
0.0250990614,
0.3750266135,
-0.4920656085,
-0.3492941558,
0.1144515723,
0.5368931293,
-0.8012377024,
-0.5683916211,
0.1202567443,
-0.3976739645,
-0.0048001069,
-0.0506154522,
-0.635316968,
-0.1953618973,
-0.4397810698,
0.9837035537,
-0.6788213253,
-0.3667568862,
0.4072811007,
-0.1290853173,
0.155458793,
0.1548954099,
-0.8906389475,
0.5999311209,
0.6179008484,
0.5408430099,
-0.5795394182,
-0.5341541171,
-0.3694899082,
0.0514902584,
0.0016807914,
0.9221507311,
-0.4903238118,
-0.2822512984,
-0.0050426563,
0.2069403231,
-0.570400238,
-1.0639977455,
0.3593516052,
-0.8846197128,
0.0996468365,
-0.0511847287,
-0.6640471816,
-0.1645449549,
-0.0086184125,
-0.5947844386,
0.7487861514,
0.4316052198,
-0.4832841158,
0.3403025866,
-0.5168182254,
-0.6966688037,
0.0146643147,
0.0739405975,
-0.2888255715,
-0.0384384282,
0.2455713898,
0.4167673588,
-0.333158493,
0.3737158477,
-0.1190939397,
-0.2960115075,
0.2284841835,
-0.1363052726,
0.5820140243,
0.2775098979,
-0.0021771272,
0.1262836456,
-0.8733639121,
-0.1754286438,
0.0603571422,
-0.2473573387,
-0.4456191361,
0.0070989202,
-0.0526390299,
0.368303895,
-0.0435016081,
-0.2510419786,
-0.1215898916,
-0.4140933454,
0.4069828093,
0.469573468,
-0.0427508987,
0.8378709555,
-0.6280962229,
0.412178427,
0.641872406,
-0.0664476678,
-0.4330325127,
-0.3420658112,
-0.8743484616,
-0.3385379016,
0.4103603959,
0.3964959979,
-1.1541528702,
0.7391075492,
-0.4603154063,
-0.3221700788,
-0.6445475817,
0.2222843915,
0.1831366569,
0.7052084208,
0.5260249972,
-0.2943130732,
-0.5003468394,
-0.5662634969,
-0.3225433826,
0.3960911632,
-0.1727917492,
0.301576674,
0.3593542278,
-0.2187423557,
1.0661816597,
-0.4957084358,
-0.3163695335,
-0.1738122553,
-0.2041353285,
0.2176142484,
0.5241564512,
0.6167045832,
-0.7438722253,
-0.5488123894,
0.0758112222,
-0.4439742267,
-0.0168546196,
-0.0430931039,
-0.3876025975,
-0.3652551472,
0.0644669682,
-0.3365175426,
-0.0531310514,
0.6167790294,
-0.2043554932,
0.3295110464,
-0.2853245735,
-0.0104435794,
-1.0771347284,
-0.1174966395,
-0.0550609604,
-0.244036898,
-0.9293167591,
-0.2393015921,
0.2083782107,
-0.0100650862,
-0.447562784,
0.492459625,
-0.2184639871,
0.1389266104,
-0.5779644251,
0.0915004238,
0.3675013185,
0.568551898,
0.0216301121,
0.9428342581,
0.7192801237,
-0.932528615,
0.0097544752,
0.3086771369,
-0.3859615624,
0.3521565199,
-0.3478516638,
0.1412411481,
-0.190010637,
0.1868356764,
-0.8840720654,
0.0484449007,
0.1535494179,
0.016144624,
0.3337350786,
-0.0022439787,
-0.1648861766,
-0.1423928738,
-0.1310339421,
0.6516673565,
0.5780618787,
-0.9027697444,
1.0054341555,
0.5050227046,
-0.0660840347,
-0.2987354398,
-0.4204857051,
-0.2563069761,
-0.2843721807,
-0.6602062583,
0.8238222599,
-0.1784745157,
0.045944728,
0.1072210595,
-0.2148353308,
-0.3261603415,
-0.0695159808,
0.1066811979,
0.1957955658,
-0.4527699351,
-0.2424093336,
0.4748313725,
-0.0710816011,
-0.1824767143,
-0.783131063,
0.600153327,
0.1975369006,
-0.1458075643,
-0.1227904782,
0.2737913728,
0.4293876588,
-0.2784507871,
0.9703831673,
0.4944328666,
-0.2152579725,
-0.7038396001,
-0.4594229758,
-0.233326897,
-0.523568809,
0.1116911694,
-0.5101726055,
-1.0169978142,
0.3671727479,
-0.6786082983,
-0.1269189417,
0.3683661819,
0.523268044,
-0.0779492855,
0.3077896237,
0.5545238256,
-0.0929713771,
0.369833529,
-0.2662312388,
0.3805336952,
-0.8234407902,
0.01579866,
-0.3810444772,
-0.3591312766,
-0.2263871729,
-0.5325770378,
0.0251491517,
0.0101512158,
-0.1504314244,
0.4663598835,
-0.1684734225,
0.5555466413,
0.3543736935,
0.2006271034,
0.1845229864,
-0.1181104705,
0.0928828269,
0.1358571649,
-0.8829815388,
-0.1744098365,
1.0945714712,
0.0416187756,
0.6078305244,
-0.1236555725,
0.4789327681,
0.0853305906,
0.245259434,
-0.6225838661,
0.3100973666,
-0.5886899829,
-0.2166864723,
0.0233214442,
-0.2358687073,
-0.7237035036,
0.4612344205,
-0.1786197424,
-0.2676492631,
0.700909555,
0.2239830345,
-0.4685255289,
0.1459309757,
-0.7870561481,
0.7852560282,
-0.0475584455,
-0.1281161457,
-0.1472649276,
-0.6446339488,
0.3080630302,
-0.7032809258,
0.2069847286,
0.0971818939,
0.2018962502,
0.7185232639,
-0.3787380755,
0.7534697652,
-0.1271925122,
-0.0477701724,
0.2832825482,
-0.1119442284,
0.3635894656,
-0.1009196416,
0.0084011219,
0.1633590907,
-0.1007494479,
-0.4193965197,
-0.8214197755,
0.6564458013,
-0.9939293265,
-0.3158072829,
0.0755463094,
-0.6991890669,
-0.5497294068,
0.1758552045,
0.1769482344,
0.4528829455,
-0.1506378651,
0.0205085389,
0.960000515,
-0.1729189306,
0.3253588974,
0.7071721554,
0.0241844598,
-0.3837612867,
1.3371747732,
-0.2135917991,
0.3312565684,
0.5413444638,
0.0173351076,
-0.068403244,
-0.6198539734,
-0.3774557114,
0.2872831821,
-0.4881198704,
-0.3118669987,
-0.5682529807,
-0.2486731708,
-0.2578657269,
0.0242731739,
-0.3920794129,
-0.2154570371,
-0.421923697,
0.1994766444,
0.1886817068,
0.4100062549,
0.3242664337,
0.7571414709,
-0.7296179533,
0.5199427605,
0.3091544807,
0.4456941485,
-0.1203612834,
-0.8410527706,
-0.4628143311,
-0.0409016721,
-0.146375373,
-0.6162540913,
0.3938761353,
0.6599490643,
0.4327409267,
0.4570561051,
0.1017020419,
0.7107766867,
-0.6861008406,
0.4572836161,
-0.1939486265,
-0.8177538514,
0.2528461814,
-0.2442218363,
0.119072035,
0.6495325565,
0.4530987442,
-0.0254991502,
-0.15711689,
-0.2292884439,
-0.7019937038,
0.9342617989,
0.1056682393,
0.0714989975,
0.2411833853,
0.4495656192,
0.5477327108,
0.2076191157,
-0.2342860997,
-0.4350505769,
-0.3610485494,
-0.3245288134,
-0.1551759094,
-0.0526857637,
-0.2461811751,
-0.4019324183,
0.6561093926,
-0.1832511127,
0.1740912795,
-0.3410049677,
-0.5440123677,
0.0143132797,
0.0989133716,
0.4745259881,
0.7170535326,
-0.0354872011,
0.1697699279,
0.0507210158,
-0.5563954711,
0.2182459533,
0.1368089616,
-0.1117647514,
-0.1517859548,
0.021090921,
1.0891264677,
0.3112936914,
-0.557151854,
0.3909086585,
-0.1006325185,
-0.3097746074,
0.2036172003,
0.3091894388,
0.0595738925,
0.1727766991,
0.2105461508,
0.5733773708,
-0.0382194966,
-0.2020954341,
0.402240485,
0.1877542436,
0.1196070462,
-0.5270161629,
0.5046259761,
0.2590952814,
-0.199701488,
0.2894796133,
0.0220135022,
-0.2849100232,
0.2051578313,
1.0886765718,
0.7625195384,
-0.3963064849,
0.0724680871,
-0.1954392344,
-0.0806721225,
-0.15978764,
0.0694963336,
-0.0894880369,
-1.339764595,
-0.6538774371,
-0.7769198418,
-0.0845818892,
0.1042506099,
-0.5453404784,
0.044555895,
-0.1928745359,
0.0941980183,
0.0563759767,
-0.2928266227,
-0.826174736,
0.4209731519,
-0.2287163883,
0.8601647019,
-1.0894880295,
1.3258520365,
0.7807435393,
-0.1238144413,
-0.7444986105,
0.1021107137,
-0.4441843033,
-0.7253069282,
0.3616304696,
-0.2931521535,
-0.0841035619,
0.3335516751,
0.0256879646,
-0.6866855025,
0.9578182697,
0.394025445,
-0.5567537546,
0.1426074356,
0.2964006364,
0.359495312,
-0.5615673065,
-0.0304128379,
0.9116574526,
0.2978502214,
0.0036850602,
-0.7363977432,
0.0557225533,
-0.2194837779,
0.0581938513,
0.1640919298,
-0.4090953171,
0.8367905021,
0.295924902,
-0.0238621514,
-0.3463096917,
0.7899038792,
-0.0606198944,
0.0990472585,
0.7841671109,
0.5428596139,
0.6218387485,
-0.0456364937,
0.7408557534,
-0.5618768334,
0.1635676026,
1.012249589,
-0.4353066087,
0.6400225759,
0.4728984833,
-0.2651178539,
0.4101447463,
0.2205388993,
0.2716100812,
0.9667041302,
-0.0403777324,
-0.4432308376,
-0.2724857628,
0.2049598098,
-0.1833134145,
0.2051360756,
0.4012592137,
-0.1278643012,
-0.1552555114,
0.428172797,
-0.2104987949,
0.0728470311,
-0.0174033809,
0.9658615589,
0.1890415698,
-0.6992573142,
0.6040196419,
0.0293392222,
0.7944867015,
-0.6205092669,
0.2316750288,
-0.2796534002,
0.3515423536,
-0.1731765568,
-0.5641130805,
0.4961724579,
-0.2764561474,
-0.412355274,
-0.2920268178,
1.0339132547,
-0.7473186851,
-0.0117151281,
0.2912186086,
0.6531686187,
-0.2960685194,
-0.2462580502,
-0.3535685241,
0.1501042992,
-0.0977884531,
0.0037158621,
0.8506374955,
0.4845435917,
0.182503432,
0.3551509976,
0.5512081385,
0.0177227352,
0.200110808,
0.1361217946,
1.3164241314,
-0.303994596,
-0.2724945545,
-0.620808363,
0.4760077298,
0.239656046,
-0.1151645258,
0.6073046923,
0.5119059086,
0.8993278742,
-0.3717784882,
0.8125833869,
0.1415811479,
0.3628155589,
-0.4543783367,
0.7886580229,
-0.4408159852,
0.2557837963,
0.0234066341,
-0.9595712423,
-0.1892483383,
0.3088580966,
-0.1191204488,
-0.0012344926,
0.6573163867,
0.7936490774,
-0.3840761483,
0.1023277119,
0.3001201749,
0.058832258,
0.1432557702,
0.3794803023,
0.6079084873,
-0.4798751175,
0.3949284852,
-0.3356473446,
-0.268958509,
0.0397753678,
-0.6104281545,
-0.7596170306,
-0.6463551521,
-0.363601923,
-0.2419788241,
0.1901875883,
0.5220941901,
0.8104416728,
-1.0518696308,
-0.2460169941,
0.0147027066,
-0.0621864535,
-0.3731882572,
-0.1753193587,
0.3041469753,
-0.4893415272,
-0.6416242719,
0.8412007093,
0.3969503939,
-0.2818706632,
0.1399562657,
-0.1205660179,
0.0957235098,
0.1833616346,
0.6949878335,
0.0580223203,
-0.3796709478,
-0.0720147341,
-0.0584281906,
0.2485519797,
0.1233258918,
1.0309979916,
-1.0822318792,
0.3637690842,
0.3654584587,
1.089681983,
0.4593732357,
0.2022316456,
0.7205457687,
-0.7553955913,
0.1095354185,
0.1364471316,
0.4104677141,
0.0986486152,
-0.1174952388,
0.0412847027,
0.29695189,
-0.6064693928,
-0.4776792824,
0.1213947907,
-1.1259782314,
-0.3216946125,
0.9123318195,
-0.313605994,
-0.2187280655,
-0.32306391,
-0.1020010263,
0.217714563,
-0.1362051517,
0.4982728064,
0.3558352888,
-0.0030945383,
-0.0171657,
-0.1259719282,
0.5173574686,
0.4521654546,
-0.8404722214,
-0.1701298654,
0.083909981,
0.4985314012,
-0.0819628164,
0.5962188244,
0.0502438657,
-0.1969154626,
-0.1240042374,
-0.3662391305,
0.0132580614,
-0.5683161616,
-0.3527978659,
0.0984529182,
-0.07956139,
-0.3600237966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05392v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05392v1 | Modular Visual Question Answering via Code Generation | 2023-06-08T17:45:14 | 2023-06-08T17:45:14 | Sanjay Subramanian, Medhini Narasimhan, Kushal Khangaonkar, Kevin Yang, Arsha Nagrani, Cordelia Schmid, Andy Zeng, Trevor Darrell, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a framework that formulates visual question answering as modular
code generation. In contrast to prior work on modular approaches to VQA, our
approach requires no additional training and relies on pre-trained language
models (LMs), visual models pre-trained on image-caption pairs, and fifty VQA
examples used for in-context learning. The generated Python programs invoke and
compose the outputs of the visual models using arithmetic and conditional
logic. Our approach improves accuracy on the COVR dataset by at least 3% and on
the GQA dataset by roughly 2% compared to the few-shot baseline that does not
employ code generation. | [
-0.4065444171,
-0.9165458679,
0.5776070952,
-0.0870307609,
-0.2585785687,
0.0029867524,
0.2282846272,
-0.0637727305,
-0.0603721775,
0.72350806,
-0.8881146312,
-0.4792394936,
-0.0961058214,
0.0475825109,
-0.1994663179,
0.6243799329,
0.1349790245,
0.4295895696,
-0.8928629756,
-0.0772816166,
-0.4790704548,
-0.5993329287,
-0.1695128828,
-0.0492071137,
0.4282072484,
0.6255106926,
0.4731200635,
0.3665222228,
0.5192598701,
0.3737822473,
0.2511323988,
0.087501809,
-0.3955236375,
-0.1854911894,
0.024307901,
-0.8218332529,
-0.2449311614,
-0.4708302915,
0.2206155509,
0.3565862477,
0.099365592,
0.6869670153,
-0.6338348389,
0.7622179389,
-0.6278386116,
0.2282361984,
-0.7592137456,
0.1277738959,
0.2065880895,
-0.3837699592,
-0.3594147563,
-0.5303506851,
0.0836516768,
-0.5859009027,
0.109415099,
-0.0139164887,
0.6409056187,
0.3815309107,
-0.6324208975,
0.0017915736,
-0.1756134331,
0.6014692187,
-0.6235377192,
-0.1934351623,
0.1321277767,
0.6562096477,
-0.0696372315,
-1.1468142271,
-0.875669539,
0.0617903434,
-0.0350499563,
0.2407454848,
-0.2582085729,
0.2001971304,
0.4994565248,
0.4491104186,
-0.7474632263,
-0.3487062454,
-0.8443347216,
-0.1837866455,
0.532520175,
0.5150091052,
0.7282190919,
-0.5011160374,
-0.3803319335,
0.0693169013,
-0.8743479848,
0.5485372543,
0.1308306307,
-0.1098232791,
0.0255740695,
0.9457736015,
-0.4875960648,
0.9348781109,
0.1651183814,
-0.0259447638,
0.247567758,
-0.5921328664,
-0.5132604837,
-0.3164162338,
0.4600332379,
0.5279157758,
0.473133713,
0.1179281324,
-0.1523821652,
0.0385481678,
0.4937780499,
-0.8582959771,
-0.4296464026,
0.4058774114,
-0.2459732443,
-0.32194677,
0.089716278,
-0.3194288313,
0.2002118677,
-0.4374229014,
0.8830114603,
-0.1643858254,
0.0352174081,
0.1184860393,
-0.4643053114,
0.6307029128,
0.5147230029,
-0.5980077386,
0.1953734457,
0.4770586193,
0.4221398532,
0.04850493,
-0.0204887278,
-0.9216554165,
0.0333657451,
-0.4764324129,
0.6837135553,
-0.2614408135,
-0.1074087769,
0.12210197,
-0.0220242161,
0.0738230199,
-0.5749891996,
-0.2813864648,
-0.7567725182,
0.4858597517,
-0.4246146977,
-0.540577352,
-0.3284037113,
0.1722635925,
-0.6166962981,
0.7816255689,
0.3977451921,
-0.7197614908,
0.3921636343,
-0.4606020153,
-0.1857919395,
0.4635965824,
-0.592074573,
-0.3387847245,
0.1474915743,
0.6439898014,
0.3973015845,
0.1593449712,
0.2322250754,
-0.0289064031,
-0.4558213651,
0.2698647976,
0.0132361334,
0.6323791742,
0.1782387942,
-0.4058787227,
0.391675055,
-0.7518433332,
0.5937917829,
-0.1448403746,
-0.4097909927,
-0.0981811434,
-0.0209482182,
-0.1171835661,
0.3332664967,
0.0941024274,
-0.338104248,
0.3323471844,
-0.2684553266,
0.4865036607,
0.5405282974,
0.3752198219,
0.6289489865,
-0.2796525359,
0.7992175221,
0.2488256097,
0.1140318289,
-0.563828826,
-0.719407022,
-0.90150702,
-0.5657755733,
-0.0053786659,
0.6333085895,
-1.5861763954,
0.0894605145,
-0.0835884586,
-0.2296953201,
-0.1108175293,
0.1997387111,
0.6189160943,
0.5517543554,
0.4072855711,
-0.4169777334,
-0.6495523453,
-0.8281368017,
0.2245665789,
-0.3180938065,
0.060428746,
0.3170807362,
0.8569108248,
0.0786204487,
1.037419796,
-0.5894685388,
0.3209986985,
-0.4514617622,
0.0379919559,
0.1208968163,
0.4311598837,
0.6167508364,
-0.9761028886,
-0.3006329536,
-0.2472482771,
-0.8628599048,
0.0351673961,
-0.0529786237,
-0.2177620679,
0.0998313874,
0.7401301861,
-0.4425476789,
0.770588994,
0.4015239179,
-0.2318119258,
0.6498449445,
-0.0326278433,
0.2518080771,
-1.1699515581,
-0.1653769314,
-0.2245121747,
-0.4901294112,
-0.6955266595,
0.4311944544,
0.1384079158,
-0.3699992299,
-0.817085743,
0.4140974581,
-0.5198443532,
-0.0432974696,
0.0834935606,
-0.1987019181,
0.1296856701,
0.7739306688,
0.1594182104,
0.9476238489,
0.475356847,
-0.480394721,
0.5497216582,
0.2327240258,
-0.6857899427,
0.5094859004,
-0.9960535169,
0.0300196931,
-0.3112589717,
0.1190626547,
-1.2522735596,
-0.4893858433,
0.2052343339,
-0.4124180079,
-0.0178952813,
-0.385419637,
-0.1472990215,
-0.6314570904,
-0.2381711304,
0.6610620022,
0.6869955659,
-0.5884369016,
0.2684968114,
0.1396657377,
-0.1979602575,
-0.6794695854,
-0.8562368751,
-0.0356902778,
-0.0803186148,
-0.8037835956,
-0.2482986748,
-0.2283582687,
-0.3014202714,
-0.0269093756,
-0.1195947751,
-0.4938079715,
-0.1593836248,
0.3124077618,
0.3606265187,
-0.6729308963,
0.1345574707,
-0.0217609573,
0.1476616114,
0.1446108967,
-0.4023035467,
0.3749189675,
-0.2254994959,
-0.4248890281,
-0.4173439741,
0.6610044837,
0.5041978359,
-0.4125771224,
0.3337277472,
0.363689214,
-0.2553884089,
-0.3089275658,
-0.271958679,
0.2398184687,
-0.5353989005,
0.5496048331,
-0.3480692208,
-0.9775653481,
0.2868935764,
0.3803551793,
-0.2056326866,
0.171276167,
0.9583982825,
-0.2025141418,
0.7972130775,
0.7538442612,
0.3932915032,
0.6072326899,
-0.2770678997,
0.0440841578,
-0.3033288121,
-0.3591270447,
-0.1279483885,
-0.0095391907,
-0.2229194492,
-0.8251733184,
0.4407172799,
0.2594980001,
-0.4298954606,
0.3934056163,
-0.4332381487,
0.5966163874,
0.8562026024,
0.3636265695,
0.2225679159,
0.1306643188,
0.0370636843,
0.0814409181,
-1.0661523342,
-0.2709727287,
1.2070643902,
-0.0924999118,
0.7576782107,
0.1402556002,
0.6934895515,
0.1380167156,
0.1205615476,
-0.7557657957,
0.685836792,
0.2441447377,
-0.6228163838,
-0.3733435273,
-0.4595965743,
-0.4211677313,
0.030900877,
-0.3380181193,
-0.6147944927,
0.2611820996,
0.3192203045,
-0.4121329188,
-0.0554714389,
-0.9507066607,
0.8998625875,
-0.151195839,
-0.2139745653,
0.0251788218,
-0.5452843308,
0.6806713939,
0.1911838949,
-0.1863967627,
0.2892246246,
0.0025325203,
0.3740389347,
-0.7277545929,
0.8041185141,
-0.094105728,
0.1644093394,
0.7426861525,
-0.0781836286,
0.1985455453,
0.4370186329,
0.3165729344,
-0.1684077978,
0.1450666338,
-0.7444723248,
-0.646137774,
0.1879811734,
-0.6296308637,
-0.6053246856,
-0.1360082626,
-0.5646877289,
-0.0656167418,
0.0750449002,
0.4097261131,
0.9048212171,
-0.1383508146,
0.3371707499,
0.6851406693,
-0.6110829115,
0.4651961625,
0.1128586605,
-0.3497648835,
-0.8044729233,
0.7103224993,
-0.0279472861,
0.5796042085,
0.5880997181,
-0.2473001927,
-0.0839063004,
-0.3471880853,
-0.8284996748,
-0.1254254133,
-0.9305057526,
-0.3878187239,
-0.4379299879,
-0.2949492037,
-0.2175640315,
-0.2743840516,
0.0724345669,
-0.6469775438,
-0.0182675067,
-0.1967900991,
0.3993920386,
0.7446331382,
0.3112967014,
0.2605935633,
-0.7466456294,
0.7741670609,
1.126495719,
-0.0540015921,
-0.158135578,
-0.113202855,
-0.2702865005,
0.0279366504,
-0.0596750006,
-0.6870542169,
0.11143554,
0.3024400771,
0.5139949918,
-0.0056909448,
-0.0975418761,
0.9405309558,
-0.6596850753,
1.2058817148,
0.6216858029,
-1.0124799013,
0.521851778,
-0.3416066766,
0.5707974434,
0.4711396694,
0.1401079893,
-0.0277451891,
-0.233592391,
-0.4848757684,
-0.7226725817,
0.3259003162,
0.1955306679,
0.3243212998,
-0.0587560087,
0.4498134255,
-0.0484295487,
0.5825238824,
-0.7001300454,
-0.1087638289,
-0.5316917896,
-0.2066823542,
-0.031609077,
-0.1728742123,
-0.2211854756,
-0.6712338924,
0.1274989843,
-0.4835494161,
0.3825458884,
0.3707754612,
-0.5783204436,
-0.0505732782,
0.030006906,
0.637773335,
1.021192193,
0.0965603441,
-0.0124501595,
0.098921515,
-0.3596721292,
0.0109936493,
-0.6772431731,
-0.3260107338,
-0.0959189385,
0.4370414913,
0.6940316558,
-0.1047370061,
-0.8592931628,
0.9425546527,
-0.2360048294,
-0.5581458807,
-0.3905702829,
0.3773444295,
0.2513151467,
0.5399391651,
0.4221608043,
0.1328096688,
0.0472495183,
-0.6855080724,
0.5559908748,
0.3518755734,
-0.3062748611,
-0.1858997196,
0.6338207722,
0.1130101532,
-0.2440980971,
0.5926957726,
0.0887494162,
-0.485220015,
1.0237071514,
0.383946836,
0.6450117826,
0.4099483788,
0.5748564005,
0.5701156259,
0.293512553,
0.0742234364,
0.7668738961,
-0.3505608737,
-0.3684372604,
-0.678101778,
-0.4529407918,
-0.6156722903,
-0.1059099361,
-0.8594979048,
0.2329326719,
-0.4683915675,
0.196156472,
-0.3874718845,
-0.2146091908,
-0.8112854958,
0.598109901,
0.3813272715,
1.0537807941,
-0.6470297575,
0.7348829508,
0.7869024873,
-0.7601186037,
-0.8099942803,
-0.1424785703,
-0.3077948689,
-0.9388287067,
0.7137024999,
0.1182021797,
0.1597050577,
0.1138928458,
-1.2957159281,
-0.5693046451,
1.2060300112,
0.3253645003,
-0.1445072591,
0.0629107505,
0.1181920916,
0.5644487739,
-0.6528066993,
0.1772099882,
0.0290966034,
0.1858482063,
0.1646121889,
-0.499460578,
-0.0283194128,
-0.6277797222,
0.1471002996,
-0.2398877442,
-0.2606631219,
0.8890534639,
-0.5481722951,
-0.1217779443,
0.4319326878,
0.7442722321,
0.0496321991,
0.2486219406,
0.218813166,
0.3789257407,
0.5104535818,
-0.1632649899,
1.0429540873,
-0.0533277765,
0.1413743049,
0.9815992117,
0.2530679107,
0.9447511435,
0.7085977197,
0.0401842222,
0.7137337327,
0.4484063089,
0.0289891865,
0.5134574175,
0.3832118809,
-0.181480363,
-0.751314342,
0.4331647754,
-0.4589047134,
0.3974837959,
0.0555572174,
-0.0870910957,
-0.1294639111,
-0.0754732341,
-0.4215418994,
0.0917304009,
-0.6470925808,
0.8118786812,
0.0760372803,
-0.7481223345,
0.6971604228,
-0.4520822167,
0.3416635394,
-0.5744985342,
-0.199308902,
-0.4100459814,
-0.0332619138,
-0.3716521263,
-0.6382641792,
0.1236149967,
0.1333918124,
-0.3234107792,
0.0161693189,
0.4518325031,
-0.4870887995,
-0.6956365108,
-0.4366823435,
0.8730165362,
-0.1065684408,
0.0054711737,
-0.4257333279,
-0.4622839987,
-0.0064518889,
-0.242422387,
0.1321068555,
0.5453284383,
-0.10398487,
0.6211633086,
0.6483228803,
-0.322668761,
0.5823000669,
-0.1213599518,
1.0013464689,
-0.7650718689,
-0.4442762136,
-0.5023666024,
1.075225234,
-0.0423617549,
-0.3825804591,
0.6792194843,
0.3792521358,
0.8374859691,
-0.548648119,
0.9210847616,
-0.1400464326,
-0.2059267759,
-0.7414084077,
0.4256183803,
-0.8110374212,
0.0500839651,
-0.4775592983,
-0.7043219209,
-0.4353521168,
0.2993605733,
-0.3192951679,
-0.3466000855,
0.7284437418,
1.0825424194,
-0.0289266296,
-0.311919868,
0.5708169937,
-0.2099899203,
0.0489974543,
0.8334335685,
1.0946389437,
-0.5783542395,
0.563339293,
-0.0890370086,
-0.04833607,
0.0388669595,
-0.7256367207,
-1.1832965612,
-0.498233974,
-0.2770376503,
-0.3252279162,
0.0511291102,
0.5738847852,
0.6497217417,
-0.7403929234,
-0.1076808721,
-0.0784865543,
0.1786698997,
-0.101403892,
-0.2133555114,
0.1192344129,
-0.4259938002,
-0.4109759629,
0.1154844388,
0.4437265694,
-0.2009561658,
-0.1762600094,
-0.1445126832,
0.0068306043,
0.2652942538,
0.7528799772,
0.3084876537,
-0.5098810196,
-0.5807018876,
0.3068836927,
-0.2703646719,
0.3473952413,
0.8266783357,
-0.9278942943,
0.5629212856,
0.9995584488,
0.6043268442,
0.5305424333,
0.2939352989,
0.9263158441,
-0.5928699374,
0.1956191063,
-0.0614340343,
0.2394347489,
0.1536999047,
-0.1015809104,
0.1506339014,
0.2594037354,
-0.3046975136,
-0.6291326284,
0.5030089617,
-1.2420426607,
-0.1575211883,
0.9898932576,
-0.1474006772,
-0.510002315,
-0.2111057043,
-0.3224274516,
-0.1911159605,
0.0747380778,
0.2488568425,
0.160694316,
-0.0679401606,
-0.2626741529,
-0.4355368018,
0.3655679524,
0.1138565019,
-0.8254502416,
-0.5260307193,
0.7220565677,
0.516667068,
-0.1144326627,
0.9088690877,
-0.1111307666,
0.9400390387,
0.2382426113,
0.3148625493,
-0.2876812816,
-0.2400078773,
-0.3329169154,
0.4268257022,
-0.2433478981,
-0.2288676649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05387v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05387v1 | Utterance Emotion Dynamics in Children's Poems: Emotional Changes Across Age | 2023-06-08T17:38:14 | 2023-06-08T17:38:14 | Daniela Teodorescu, Alona Fyshe, Saif M. Mohammad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emerging psychopathology studies are showing that patterns of changes in
emotional state -- emotion dynamics -- are associated with overall well-being
and mental health. More recently, there has been some work in tracking emotion
dynamics through one's utterances, allowing for data to be collected on a
larger scale across time and people. However, several questions about how
emotion dynamics change with age, especially in children, and when determined
through children's writing, remain unanswered. In this work, we use both a
lexicon and a machine learning based approach to quantify characteristics of
emotion dynamics determined from poems written by children of various ages. We
show that both approaches point to similar trends: consistent increasing
intensities for some emotions (e.g., anger, fear, joy, sadness, arousal, and
dominance) with age and a consistent decreasing valence with age. We also find
increasing emotional variability, rise rates (i.e., emotional reactivity), and
recovery rates (i.e., emotional regulation) with age. These results act as a
useful baselines for further research in how patterns of emotions expressed by
children change with age, and their association with mental health. | [
-0.0475431718,
-0.5245386958,
0.5835796595,
0.2571634054,
-0.0565430485,
-0.0093867686,
0.0135342544,
-1.0159521103,
0.0505545251,
0.0058465935,
-0.7570726871,
-0.2139745653,
-0.8877728581,
0.121709615,
-0.3002013862,
1.1330879927,
-0.2508480549,
-0.2419641763,
-0.1253215969,
0.0472033657,
-0.367846638,
-0.6036108732,
-0.8113248944,
-0.5732877254,
0.8631683588,
0.2847644687,
0.3730820417,
0.382478863,
0.5113572478,
0.3076623678,
-0.6139488816,
-0.2831263542,
-0.3124485016,
0.9295923114,
-0.1275482476,
-0.6384378076,
-0.201311022,
0.1085218936,
0.3741871715,
0.4486146867,
-0.1273591369,
-0.1500058621,
0.0654762462,
1.2013834715,
-0.5315087438,
0.2469741404,
-0.5070850849,
0.63314116,
-0.238390103,
-0.3576654196,
-0.1984399557,
-0.4185216427,
0.3804363906,
-0.2649999261,
-0.0080839414,
-0.0752941445,
0.6998767257,
-0.0180675164,
-0.6393906474,
-0.7407121658,
-0.5557457805,
0.6802316308,
-0.4775131941,
0.0235623904,
0.438639015,
-0.0239976086,
-0.1337225884,
-0.6256691217,
-0.4162937999,
-0.4412365258,
-0.0865679085,
0.2323688716,
-0.6777971983,
-0.1052510217,
0.420501709,
0.1382007897,
-0.5450397134,
-0.2608809173,
-0.2507667243,
0.1157737747,
0.5766499639,
0.5065493584,
0.9254009724,
-0.1427221745,
-0.1310237944,
0.063861154,
-0.0953383595,
0.6638864875,
0.3645650148,
0.3449695706,
-0.3660440147,
0.6041217446,
-0.0056827832,
0.1432532519,
0.2567438483,
0.0341855697,
0.1660327762,
0.1029061601,
0.130972594,
0.2327345908,
0.7117823958,
0.5631389618,
0.5885031223,
-0.0928645283,
-0.2113176882,
0.6473299861,
0.4412232041,
-0.7521258593,
-0.466745019,
0.1460451335,
-0.7763260007,
-0.4161687493,
-0.2397007942,
-1.1015233994,
-0.75233078,
-0.4065884948,
0.0695407093,
-0.6968619227,
-0.1792347133,
-0.0610636808,
-0.4521198571,
0.069905661,
0.1644389927,
-1.0277035236,
0.2651386559,
0.5176033974,
0.7997531891,
-0.1238711476,
-0.1645661294,
-0.1154074296,
-0.408837676,
-0.7590466738,
0.6671885848,
-0.9517614245,
-0.2409044057,
0.0107279848,
0.1324054301,
-0.3662931919,
-0.5843724608,
0.5188992023,
-0.280061394,
0.0995920524,
-0.0198742263,
-0.4583975673,
0.0953808352,
-0.0475905873,
-0.3793801367,
0.9130367637,
0.1253394932,
-0.8565355539,
0.496317029,
-0.5850536227,
-0.5095626712,
-0.1321727484,
0.1872237772,
-0.3833575845,
0.6383518577,
-0.1446378082,
0.3392747343,
0.1980511844,
-0.2298797965,
-0.264064014,
-0.169105351,
0.3728606403,
-0.2757620215,
0.4491831064,
0.3945278823,
-0.5549008846,
0.0235112067,
-0.6491283178,
-0.1590049565,
0.1082852632,
-0.2206160277,
-0.2753448784,
0.4020743072,
-0.1620163769,
0.1692053378,
0.2039947957,
-0.5502563119,
0.2172545493,
-0.2089801282,
0.5442467332,
0.3203954101,
0.4828497469,
0.1916093975,
-0.8571928144,
0.7008100152,
0.3958255649,
0.5021528602,
-0.3067787588,
-0.7454290986,
-0.3127322495,
0.0881482735,
-0.3084944189,
0.4123658836,
-0.0949411988,
0.3538791835,
0.0516654849,
-0.6351046562,
-0.2051687688,
-0.166203469,
0.1090630889,
0.2984579206,
0.2089769691,
-0.5373001099,
-0.4446297884,
-0.2284804881,
-0.3517170548,
-0.5705838799,
0.4047253728,
0.4940728545,
0.156043157,
-0.3827641308,
0.6793786287,
-0.3201726973,
0.1831658334,
0.3326312602,
0.6917231083,
-0.2086865604,
0.7013155222,
0.4574747086,
-0.6533415318,
-0.427998662,
0.1675978452,
-0.4200525582,
-0.4239036739,
-0.0301364698,
-0.3481405377,
0.1824112087,
0.2033178061,
-0.585293591,
0.4986388385,
0.4600009024,
-0.6234124303,
0.6374223232,
-0.0456442609,
0.2261972874,
-0.4302856624,
-0.1266201288,
0.0036274293,
0.0239040144,
-0.7147656679,
-0.2032709867,
0.0881009325,
-0.0492470004,
-0.4645562768,
0.0000181654,
-0.2976700366,
0.2384745479,
-0.4429385662,
-0.0991476402,
-0.0266468022,
0.1334409714,
-0.1854171753,
0.4278760254,
0.7809395194,
-0.3792926371,
0.6616029143,
-0.2646850348,
0.1009398177,
0.8769574761,
-0.2966389954,
0.320325762,
-0.6094056368,
0.2659611106,
-0.9405926466,
-0.0505123585,
0.1590524465,
-0.7725500464,
0.2673403919,
-0.1099108905,
-0.2518552542,
-0.337374121,
-0.2086711973,
0.094834052,
0.6592184305,
0.0087409681,
0.793079257,
0.2832203507,
-0.5784912109,
-0.3183599114,
-0.6878722906,
0.2593346536,
-0.5189012289,
-0.3175857663,
0.2182741016,
-0.5201231241,
-0.418974489,
0.4285279512,
-0.2494347245,
-0.1535839438,
0.1838475615,
0.5893779993,
-0.0860781148,
0.0999309123,
0.5056152344,
0.4132571816,
-0.0768202022,
0.4107974768,
-0.0897236243,
0.6132975221,
-0.1323005855,
0.1158669963,
-0.4958809614,
0.3554352522,
0.8637346029,
-0.0795240626,
0.7884582877,
0.3126268387,
-0.7653628588,
-0.1794097126,
0.1745119393,
0.3012234867,
-0.3660727739,
-0.2455843687,
-0.5238488913,
-0.5721192956,
0.8468176723,
-0.0104440395,
-0.2808644772,
0.5817415714,
0.7557306886,
-0.602232933,
1.0087487698,
0.3670413196,
-0.1590385735,
0.7760425806,
-0.1153217256,
-0.2052672058,
-0.7470220923,
-0.2352670282,
-0.6678037643,
-0.7378524542,
-0.8562502861,
0.1159638464,
0.0559296273,
-0.0114384862,
-0.3704303503,
-0.1446980536,
-0.6722564697,
0.4153959453,
0.133888483,
0.0431465022,
-0.0423746333,
-0.6124815345,
-0.039265655,
-0.1519980431,
-0.2680763602,
-0.3553226888,
0.8612598181,
0.3294498324,
0.779069066,
0.4954678416,
0.6708543897,
0.5689008236,
0.4069087207,
-0.8565467,
0.2371104211,
-0.4201993942,
-0.5840418935,
-0.2353199869,
-0.5788453817,
-1.591727972,
-0.1890964508,
-0.374247998,
-1.1116379499,
0.3654006422,
0.0649281517,
-0.129293099,
0.230492264,
-0.5431839228,
0.5504310131,
-0.1356240362,
-0.0634170175,
-0.0563684814,
-0.9460397363,
0.0122633521,
-0.0953120217,
-0.0105051147,
-0.3632708788,
-0.0405472107,
0.5433396697,
-0.3221546412,
0.8042340875,
-0.1248216107,
-0.1886308789,
0.4396662414,
0.1111072674,
0.4649538696,
-0.4441237152,
0.1021396369,
-0.4943581223,
0.3419372439,
-0.3780374825,
-0.7691435814,
0.9727182388,
-1.0899384022,
0.0408327393,
-0.5847039819,
-0.7868436575,
-0.0053352667,
-0.1035229191,
0.0911476165,
0.450186938,
0.3115143776,
0.2620610595,
0.6013752222,
-0.2336474955,
0.5819602609,
0.0967862308,
-0.2632604837,
-0.3703654408,
0.4564055204,
0.3554232717,
0.2999239862,
0.2471704334,
0.7120397091,
-0.203495577,
-0.1008764282,
-0.2432163507,
0.0573594384,
-0.622189939,
0.2137715071,
-0.4923056066,
-0.0375784077,
-0.5074439049,
-0.141929239,
0.0753296241,
-0.2074093074,
-0.271181792,
0.0442273654,
0.6397858858,
0.8641186357,
-0.0530997477,
-0.1622125804,
-0.8303632736,
0.2671509981,
0.5695793033,
0.5422695279,
0.4530147016,
-0.4362133443,
-0.145166412,
-0.4222077429,
-0.4080914855,
-1.4322823286,
0.2648252249,
0.4117112458,
0.2765848935,
0.4068760872,
0.1824816614,
0.5841869116,
-0.3727667332,
1.0230835676,
0.1204441488,
-1.0208727121,
0.7395009398,
-0.4368918836,
0.2748675942,
0.1882762611,
0.218501702,
-1.2290172577,
-0.2042948008,
-0.8122841716,
-0.859591186,
0.5679118037,
0.1496423334,
0.51080513,
0.2651718557,
0.6007683277,
-0.0023507501,
0.0975467041,
-0.27749753,
-0.4092439115,
0.0161613971,
-0.738894403,
0.018335022,
-0.2093700916,
-0.1643507332,
-0.3402594924,
0.2964235842,
0.0021561135,
0.3683768511,
0.2522226572,
0.0720953494,
-0.8957912922,
0.1421491057,
0.4874543846,
0.328987807,
-0.1612019837,
0.5670304894,
0.066196166,
-0.4776413441,
0.308883667,
0.2549235523,
-0.0583931096,
-0.1683573127,
0.6320988536,
1.047826767,
0.0922394246,
-0.6253301501,
0.2360950857,
0.1532576978,
-0.1100155786,
-0.1384153068,
0.319642514,
0.0613059327,
0.717068851,
0.1780654788,
-0.040258836,
0.1237460077,
-0.8927522898,
0.1969586313,
-0.0293495171,
-0.7626200318,
-0.3086003065,
0.4817043543,
-0.3108760417,
-0.4229254425,
0.3193043172,
-0.1669182479,
-0.4500592947,
0.7360610366,
0.5232653618,
1.0754439831,
0.0110240784,
0.1082281917,
-0.0783328339,
0.2675456405,
0.4112090468,
0.6476452947,
-0.1193920746,
-0.668074429,
-0.2535588741,
-0.3942325115,
-0.6360613704,
-0.0594536103,
-0.8469792604,
-0.3010626733,
-0.2733779252,
-0.6973910928,
-0.036111135,
0.2688229382,
-0.6103782058,
0.6337886453,
0.6548343897,
0.4904893935,
-1.0359683037,
0.3532601893,
1.1502747536,
-0.2118308544,
-0.6619024873,
0.3245289922,
0.2946360111,
-0.1979632825,
0.66952461,
0.289940387,
-0.2127594054,
0.0572032444,
-0.6965529919,
-0.7439411879,
0.8119339347,
-0.2233403921,
-0.3145219386,
0.3036288917,
-0.2467501163,
1.0519543886,
-0.273832649,
0.2172393203,
0.5553787947,
0.466904819,
-0.1188638434,
-0.5500596166,
-0.4519647956,
-0.6890782118,
0.2474772036,
0.4307728708,
-0.5157243609,
0.9929984212,
-0.0250978637,
-0.5529934168,
-0.0244523883,
0.6571557522,
0.2916463614,
0.8322560787,
0.6410123706,
0.7882003784,
0.7391228676,
-0.1633630693,
0.9032914042,
-0.6647832394,
0.3532572985,
0.4302312732,
-0.0332110785,
0.7625438571,
0.1960451901,
-0.435316205,
0.8150975704,
0.6780097485,
0.4925056994,
0.2604121566,
0.6778680086,
-0.3934991062,
0.2820180953,
-0.1674003005,
-0.0279620532,
-0.0578084365,
0.2497456074,
-0.4047966301,
0.2481669784,
0.1987905055,
0.3766357601,
0.1033355221,
-0.2116347551,
0.773997426,
0.2248854339,
-0.3152619004,
0.1616122276,
-0.2406063825,
0.5951405168,
-0.4910257161,
0.1178855002,
-0.0550129674,
-0.1248760447,
-0.1730344743,
-1.1577029228,
0.1993087977,
0.5397186875,
-0.44468683,
-0.2296105325,
0.9804621935,
-0.557223022,
-0.2647792399,
0.3662161529,
0.4163565338,
0.3993399143,
0.1123449355,
-0.8323940039,
0.3134642839,
-0.5537648797,
-0.4980888367,
0.2317489237,
1.019081831,
0.131666407,
0.6330704093,
0.5668513179,
0.5312030315,
0.4676998258,
0.2095082849,
0.4206692278,
-0.6822369099,
-0.1692186147,
-0.7184222341,
0.6911090612,
0.2612719238,
-0.6409168839,
0.1138668731,
0.067678839,
0.2635800838,
0.2074749023,
0.6969476938,
-0.2333204001,
0.3202980161,
-0.2715993226,
0.7019746304,
-0.5866918564,
-0.5396518111,
-0.3202055693,
-0.7876445651,
-0.2475286722,
0.5958049297,
-0.3334951401,
0.1505189389,
0.6450044513,
0.3362619281,
0.6089325547,
0.1576073915,
0.0855126381,
0.1756904572,
0.4337243736,
0.6811047196,
1.1217137575,
-0.0972766504,
-0.0682638064,
-0.6287874579,
-0.3174015582,
-0.1836589426,
-0.8740720749,
-0.1384715289,
-0.6327217817,
-0.3802792132,
-0.2802523673,
0.3138338327,
1.0272356272,
0.2178229094,
-0.6055921912,
0.1081698239,
0.0380338691,
-0.4264871478,
-0.5440407395,
-0.2392966002,
0.216479376,
-0.4969216585,
-0.8187327981,
0.0996836051,
0.164637655,
0.2691827416,
0.0223006383,
0.0962222368,
0.1921931952,
0.543817699,
0.5572799444,
0.1352073103,
-0.4916056693,
-0.335257262,
-0.2588701248,
-0.5011351705,
0.0713980719,
0.7141206861,
-0.479415834,
0.7967023253,
0.7618137002,
0.2956444025,
0.1763893366,
0.1856148094,
-0.0050484319,
-0.4733593166,
-0.3812095225,
0.2346976697,
0.3069490194,
0.1969477534,
-0.3709453046,
0.2799825072,
0.607583344,
-0.7637803555,
-0.5906103849,
0.2771705389,
-0.8489587903,
-0.0560451597,
0.609813571,
-0.1244721562,
0.099936299,
0.1790475994,
-0.2515408695,
0.6637111306,
-0.5126307011,
0.9539446235,
0.9873499274,
-0.7177959085,
-0.499083817,
-0.426759094,
0.2652449906,
0.3824793696,
-1.0131177902,
0.073077172,
0.5577923059,
-0.2154790759,
0.0644767657,
0.1187669933,
-0.1858760566,
-0.0027540466,
0.0851738527,
0.1142677963,
0.5558168292,
-0.3483310342,
-0.381706953,
0.2650154829,
-0.017480243,
-0.0111838179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05446v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05446v1 | Latent Phrase Matching for Dysarthric Speech | 2023-06-08T17:28:28 | 2023-06-08T17:28:28 | Colin Lea, Dianna Yee, Jaya Narain, Zifang Huang, Lauren Tooley, Jeffrey P. Bigham, Leah Findlater | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Many consumer speech recognition systems are not tuned for people with speech
disabilities, resulting in poor recognition and user experience, especially for
severe speech differences. Recent studies have emphasized interest in
personalized speech models from people with atypical speech patterns. We
propose a query-by-example-based personalized phrase recognition system that is
trained using small amounts of speech, is language agnostic, does not assume a
traditional pronunciation lexicon, and generalizes well across speech
difference severities. On an internal dataset collected from 32 people with
dysarthria, this approach works regardless of severity and shows a 60%
improvement in recall relative to a commercial speech recognition system. On
the public EasyCall dataset of dysarthric speech, our approach improves
accuracy by 30.5%. Performance degrades as the number of phrases increases, but
consistently outperforms ASR systems when trained with 50 unique phrases. | [
0.0821169764,
-0.5549283624,
0.5039713979,
0.2405880243,
-0.3442352116,
0.5230740905,
0.0729689896,
-0.175216198,
0.797801137,
0.4258845747,
-0.1836425215,
-0.4467098713,
-0.4495347738,
0.068996042,
-0.3023253977,
0.5001788735,
0.2814294696,
0.0225790869,
0.1942597628,
-0.3118969202,
-0.3910507858,
-0.500641942,
-0.5274948478,
-0.3281398714,
0.234963119,
0.4023679197,
0.8298784494,
0.6449377537,
0.1954404116,
0.3069823086,
-0.5782422423,
0.1156658009,
-0.2842624784,
0.4319225252,
-0.0982882529,
-0.2549999356,
-0.4503240883,
-0.0051278812,
0.4211882651,
1.1096051931,
-0.5904925466,
-0.2443895936,
-0.0088094454,
0.4386042058,
-0.1451076418,
-0.3314536214,
-0.804682672,
0.2799438834,
-0.5985725522,
-0.3419491053,
-0.0453891866,
-0.438778758,
0.139064908,
-0.5998057723,
0.5480069518,
0.2350472063,
0.4087916315,
0.3162253499,
-0.1033558697,
-0.4323585629,
-0.4285241961,
0.3650222719,
-0.6121926904,
0.4166374505,
0.8560762405,
0.241693452,
-0.4109026492,
-0.6887316108,
-0.6242669821,
-0.3505286276,
0.0238891449,
0.0620490909,
-0.3786036968,
0.1000272706,
0.3781442344,
0.4583177865,
-0.9822080135,
0.3044583499,
-0.3210317194,
-0.2451114506,
0.3696719706,
0.3538129032,
0.2113514245,
-0.3987020552,
-0.1489890814,
0.1207392961,
-0.6085845828,
0.1648150384,
0.3931061029,
0.6916821599,
0.0175992846,
0.7096060514,
-0.4286182225,
0.9281905293,
0.3283147812,
-0.3766486347,
0.5554331541,
0.1220658943,
0.0074824421,
0.567913413,
0.2866962552,
0.1374049485,
-0.0191047862,
-0.6931018233,
-0.0534875169,
0.0507495403,
-0.0036899941,
-0.5615514517,
-0.5728648901,
0.0937233865,
-0.3737682104,
-0.0877710357,
-0.1524730176,
-0.5821250677,
-0.8220056295,
-0.4141783714,
0.0503116846,
-0.2888359427,
0.026731316,
0.2793927193,
-0.2976277173,
-0.0591278747,
0.0308557693,
-0.8537670374,
0.3791311681,
0.376544863,
0.9609122276,
-0.2589141428,
-0.0672546178,
-1.2215406895,
0.3049215972,
-0.3670608699,
0.7856978178,
-0.659367919,
-0.6553375721,
-0.4182879925,
-0.049319312,
-0.1763948351,
-1.0064935684,
0.6039188504,
-0.4170271158,
-0.0257895086,
-0.1855216473,
-0.6715024114,
0.3041787744,
-0.0695915669,
-0.4491055906,
0.5057315826,
0.0136125684,
-0.720279336,
0.3043039441,
-0.2734961212,
-0.424372524,
0.4814948142,
-0.4902722538,
-0.2328442633,
0.4790362716,
0.0223892722,
0.0832405835,
-0.1399002522,
0.1728506386,
-0.4445575476,
-0.534879148,
0.3202886283,
-0.4473479688,
0.451682806,
0.4582090378,
-0.1124981493,
-0.0209721196,
-1.0548633337,
0.1777057946,
-0.1238246486,
-0.5818202496,
-0.5938016176,
0.054110799,
0.0467828177,
-0.0004258389,
0.0673128292,
-0.7064074278,
0.1572626233,
-0.7899289131,
0.62781775,
0.6580119729,
-0.1373129189,
0.1769332141,
-0.3607220352,
0.4569500089,
0.126771152,
-0.4382039309,
0.1298541576,
-0.5852802396,
-0.2599855363,
-0.4800021052,
0.2998641729,
0.6553615332,
-0.6995541453,
0.6474690437,
-0.3558010459,
-0.1188057363,
-0.5184569955,
-0.0466981009,
0.4103482664,
0.9490389228,
0.3483200967,
-0.1558540314,
-0.3964913487,
-0.6760161519,
-0.2757908404,
-0.1277925372,
-0.3050810695,
0.6238352656,
-0.1451508254,
-0.0204012021,
1.1138603687,
-0.6266005635,
-0.6520755887,
-0.0279175714,
0.1751161814,
0.2612703741,
0.1795733273,
0.2555240989,
-0.7604430318,
-0.5099923611,
0.0484725051,
-0.4322267473,
-0.1629043967,
0.4330523312,
0.470097661,
-0.0005626545,
0.5952106714,
-0.1932236403,
0.5824338198,
0.545068264,
-0.7269601822,
0.0271523427,
-0.5510438085,
0.012872248,
-1.2998806238,
0.0426175855,
-0.2398726344,
-0.3938996792,
-0.5445905328,
-0.4364903569,
-0.2098033279,
-0.6870960593,
-0.2936779261,
0.476360023,
-0.146721065,
-0.2660029531,
-0.3549556732,
0.340977788,
-0.0760878325,
-0.058248654,
-0.0627579466,
1.0162197351,
0.7238730192,
-0.4825607538,
0.4101187587,
0.6187526584,
-0.2972249389,
0.8121620417,
-0.8815979958,
0.4267178178,
0.0401452146,
0.1289107949,
-1.0043752193,
-0.4064261615,
0.1394595355,
-0.473405391,
0.2173719108,
-0.0149557786,
-0.3177612424,
-0.4244544208,
-0.1057858765,
0.2109017521,
0.3176503778,
-0.8680227995,
0.5029422641,
0.4339577854,
-0.5672522187,
-0.1878644228,
-0.5847755671,
0.4493217766,
-0.4841887057,
-0.6340733767,
0.9079070687,
-0.060810864,
-0.065470852,
-0.1585543454,
-0.151311025,
-0.3831241131,
0.0652363747,
0.0676822066,
-0.3108872473,
-0.1102723852,
0.4515805244,
0.1887219846,
-0.1085194796,
-0.6642470956,
-0.1991481483,
0.5914097428,
-0.1102735028,
-0.3498509526,
-0.7101008892,
0.5334891081,
0.3837062716,
-0.0945324004,
-0.0873392746,
0.3948500454,
-0.4372550547,
0.2469053864,
-0.6199667454,
-0.1438957304,
-0.50291574,
0.2423131317,
-0.7515257001,
-0.7434470654,
0.6247450113,
0.0763292536,
-0.6968435049,
-0.1264401078,
0.1809410453,
-0.2078777254,
0.989338994,
0.2722184956,
-0.2018776089,
0.2281393856,
0.3981054127,
0.1416512281,
-0.8662779927,
0.0073698983,
-0.6518653631,
-0.3321863115,
-0.615410924,
-0.3251270652,
0.1035861298,
0.0712991878,
0.0706183091,
0.1562131941,
-0.6274169683,
0.422372371,
0.4456122518,
0.4644759893,
0.3794752359,
0.2813715339,
-0.2577462792,
-0.3338541985,
-0.4521384537,
-0.5103602409,
0.5663098693,
0.0102581084,
1.0951154232,
0.4219432473,
0.7657559514,
0.607789278,
-0.2102255523,
-0.7463877797,
0.3529001176,
-0.9883210063,
-0.278532654,
-0.296785295,
-0.5249865651,
-1.1391999722,
0.027893981,
0.1499791741,
-0.9811522961,
0.5209465027,
0.3711869419,
-0.7830658555,
0.0058347052,
-0.5633903742,
0.518281281,
-0.2463706732,
-0.1201459542,
-0.1250199527,
-0.5603653789,
-0.2688726485,
-0.0295008644,
-0.1781153232,
-0.2636271715,
-0.121849902,
0.6698528528,
-0.4545255303,
0.7587357759,
-0.5195412636,
0.3324941397,
-0.082324855,
-0.1888771653,
0.4168983996,
-0.0310955215,
-0.2164815515,
-0.2125339359,
-0.0324296728,
-0.1956957877,
-0.4255553186,
0.9771769047,
-0.5331228971,
-0.5956810713,
-0.5199503899,
-0.2807150185,
-0.5018393993,
-0.0672042444,
0.0787878484,
0.5770576,
-0.3085465431,
0.4269406796,
0.6945787072,
-0.1847047806,
0.1698925346,
0.8798961639,
0.1037375256,
-0.5066526532,
1.0223163366,
0.137397632,
-0.2780720592,
0.2995066345,
0.6415323019,
-0.6304004192,
-0.6401761174,
-0.4479340613,
0.1052922308,
-0.5658496618,
-0.2283034921,
-0.7313542962,
0.0197102688,
-0.6559967399,
0.0455882475,
0.0385154076,
-0.4120218456,
-0.6771619916,
0.0200332049,
0.4401932657,
0.5342553854,
-0.123290509,
0.4695948958,
-0.5165038705,
0.7433411479,
0.6105547547,
0.4964472651,
-0.3304689229,
-0.9324252605,
0.299993515,
-0.0652486086,
-0.4241616428,
-0.8436578512,
0.5061635971,
0.6904045939,
0.6770740151,
0.0662658438,
0.1842346787,
1.1666306257,
-0.6870433092,
0.5116063356,
0.308111757,
-0.9850900173,
0.694344461,
0.0102830539,
0.0958371609,
0.6913898587,
0.2732480168,
-0.6009599566,
-0.0919050425,
-0.4473139942,
-0.742302835,
0.7412490249,
0.0634857714,
0.01242969,
-0.1509602517,
0.5461010337,
-0.1110267043,
0.0861158594,
0.0553574488,
-0.0395473689,
-0.260889858,
-0.4740238786,
-0.2042677402,
-0.061126478,
-0.1738164276,
-0.311196506,
0.1861804873,
-0.4598965049,
0.1410901248,
0.26515311,
-0.167920664,
0.1141313091,
0.1422946304,
0.5624060631,
0.5739336014,
-0.2474772781,
-0.0501359738,
0.0962026641,
-0.5446957946,
0.2757584751,
0.7517404556,
0.0093742218,
0.2381358594,
-0.2979635894,
0.7939516902,
0.117385678,
-0.616209805,
0.7173677087,
-0.3084954023,
0.0376387909,
-0.3463050723,
-0.0930665433,
0.2236039042,
0.4138020873,
0.3529344797,
0.0694499537,
0.3930338025,
-0.2462631017,
0.4069173932,
0.3907047808,
-0.5942651033,
-0.3696691394,
0.7888005376,
0.1690584123,
-0.7394250631,
0.6095598936,
-0.2572688758,
-0.2620511949,
0.1657026708,
0.5742462277,
0.8659502268,
-0.4794158041,
0.0574338511,
-0.207036376,
-0.4836456478,
-0.0528556593,
0.4450422227,
-0.2223023027,
-0.397657752,
-0.0160271041,
-0.6693404317,
-0.419272989,
0.0183491874,
-0.6425889134,
0.2589475513,
-0.2154535204,
-0.3165947795,
0.3038598001,
0.0449219234,
-0.4359481037,
0.2593833804,
0.1529405713,
0.5907593369,
-0.657977581,
1.1081998348,
0.743827939,
-0.4290053844,
-0.6996366978,
0.3294613361,
-0.1158498675,
-0.8928066492,
0.7121921182,
0.0314159766,
-0.2946969569,
0.1926397532,
0.0816905424,
-0.7252292633,
1.1526691914,
0.3836129308,
-0.7638068795,
-0.1376112998,
0.0988504663,
0.717589736,
-0.4392876029,
-0.2819550931,
0.5670143366,
0.0302614104,
0.4683993161,
-1.1118240356,
-0.1709918827,
0.0962147415,
0.1826880276,
-0.2495904714,
-0.2022604942,
0.7141343951,
-0.1814882457,
-0.231948033,
0.6241451502,
0.3916600943,
0.4467770457,
0.6567243934,
0.6416753531,
0.589264214,
1.3279932737,
0.0669525936,
0.8849458098,
-0.4274373353,
0.015370938,
1.331379652,
-0.4710137248,
0.9468345642,
0.2858176529,
-0.2255845815,
0.1466182619,
0.5180532336,
0.4348560572,
0.811821878,
0.4749813676,
-0.3020634651,
-0.2248987108,
-0.2636590898,
-0.5432351828,
0.7293503881,
0.4779650569,
-0.403280437,
-0.1527586728,
0.1873118728,
-0.1111207381,
0.4157576859,
-0.044161737,
0.9866629839,
0.0077930726,
-0.2462200373,
0.8099178076,
-0.1739987582,
0.7790919542,
-0.4629822969,
0.2390761822,
-0.3847194612,
0.3146818578,
-0.2685298324,
-0.5517092943,
0.5713589787,
0.0552867576,
-0.4008603096,
-0.1740703732,
0.6301441193,
-0.3742956519,
-0.4948495924,
0.1539501846,
0.6234921813,
0.3484820724,
-0.3439002633,
-0.5881596804,
-0.0414232984,
0.0216312837,
0.1964057833,
0.2892122865,
0.2970976532,
-0.0006542539,
0.4294870794,
0.3694594204,
0.3452264965,
0.0776731148,
0.4112843871,
1.0797438622,
-0.7411189079,
-0.7119733095,
-0.2594054341,
-0.0146355387,
-0.2210598439,
-0.5674375296,
0.3752658665,
0.5499663353,
0.341689676,
0.1420833915,
0.6166441441,
0.033992175,
1.2422090769,
-0.3104976118,
0.6694629788,
-0.7416084409,
0.2743386328,
-0.0485552251,
-0.6528995633,
-0.3187194169,
0.9241181016,
-0.3146050274,
-0.1752268374,
0.3312096298,
0.9890387654,
-0.2999995649,
0.0741961598,
0.6761096716,
0.1515323371,
0.6477895975,
0.0759679601,
0.8401325941,
-0.101944074,
0.5525287986,
-0.1373113841,
-0.4333776534,
-0.3777838647,
-0.6658016443,
-0.4833900034,
-0.4938435555,
-0.3353835344,
-0.3536145687,
0.4932367206,
1.0789625645,
0.6635852456,
-0.6086092591,
-0.185085699,
-0.0695692599,
-0.1953357011,
-0.1181826815,
-0.1725263298,
0.3946585059,
-0.2555579841,
-0.4839526415,
0.8913900852,
0.2743372321,
0.2289988697,
0.0655766949,
-0.0551299751,
0.2275263667,
-0.128095597,
0.5265149474,
0.4966348708,
-0.81863451,
-0.325499326,
0.3024747372,
0.0117447004,
0.2270588726,
0.9881317019,
-0.9899597168,
0.5712673068,
0.3783164322,
0.5758491755,
0.4238756001,
0.184855178,
0.1409992874,
-0.8544083238,
0.3072012663,
0.6974870563,
0.2959734201,
0.7110211253,
-0.1590830386,
0.0781570524,
0.4201987684,
-0.4414182901,
-0.7858703732,
0.3095889688,
-1.1366081238,
-0.0093443664,
0.8659670353,
-0.3738286495,
0.2323185951,
-0.5934820771,
-0.2275292575,
-0.1258090436,
-0.5603790879,
0.9895735383,
0.2249878645,
-0.4006678462,
0.4402902424,
-0.0137110483,
0.3760069311,
0.1863807887,
-0.2850683331,
0.1955851018,
0.4707960188,
0.4703339338,
0.1408566087,
0.8585734963,
0.0787454918,
0.0527782477,
0.0051465374,
-0.5341128707,
-0.0141380234,
-0.0706303641,
-0.5912408829,
0.1488843858,
0.3448148668,
-0.3828665614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05360v1 | The ADAIO System at the BEA-2023 Shared Task on Generating AI Teacher Responses in Educational Dialogues | 2023-06-08T17:05:38 | 2023-06-08T17:05:38 | Adaeze Adigwe, Zheng Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | This paper presents the ADAIO team's system entry in the Building Educational
Applications (BEA) 2023 Shared Task on Generating AI Teacher Responses in
Educational Dialogues. The task aims to assess the performance of
state-of-the-art generative models as AI teachers in producing suitable
responses within a student-teacher dialogue. Our system comprises evaluating
various baseline models using OpenAI GPT-3 and designing diverse prompts to
prompt the OpenAI models for teacher response generation. After the challenge,
our system achieved second place by employing a few-shot prompt-based approach
with the OpenAI text-davinci-003 model. The results highlight the few-shot
learning capabilities of large-language models, particularly OpenAI's GPT-3, in
the role of AI teachers. | [
-0.4810412824,
-0.8843026757,
0.6055020094,
-0.1205515787,
0.1194395348,
-0.2217937857,
0.1590575576,
-0.3316203058,
-0.240628466,
0.069649972,
-0.5280057192,
-0.3351971507,
-0.4165361822,
0.3334864378,
-0.4539445341,
0.9555470347,
-0.1070951074,
0.3529292047,
-0.0959577039,
0.2568184733,
-0.793813169,
-0.043818824,
-0.9796563387,
-0.0514415801,
0.3183797896,
0.7463553548,
0.3718660474,
0.296914041,
0.4416234791,
0.231953904,
0.2312054634,
0.0649205595,
-0.1090982109,
0.0931291506,
0.0220824908,
-0.297868669,
-0.7025824785,
0.0677096099,
0.6803082228,
0.414672941,
-0.0381350741,
0.2867047787,
0.2671553493,
0.3082318604,
-0.4600377381,
0.2361080498,
-0.4678158462,
0.0358788893,
0.0434531532,
0.0620468594,
-0.462903738,
-0.3601367772,
0.1185263097,
-0.5914421678,
0.1419501752,
-0.2286154628,
0.5639913082,
0.2499365509,
-0.3167403042,
-0.4328021407,
-0.6753854752,
0.4691225886,
-0.5435595512,
-0.0451383889,
0.482326299,
0.3448834717,
-0.1058604494,
-0.4413558245,
-0.7853595018,
0.03956737,
0.2445804477,
0.4897696674,
-0.0644667521,
-0.0486947559,
0.0903336778,
0.265306741,
-0.5749971867,
0.105344817,
-0.6279841065,
0.2208215445,
0.4337241352,
0.5945125818,
0.3149457574,
-0.251832813,
-0.3737832904,
-0.1118137017,
-0.6856180429,
0.0350047015,
0.5002086163,
0.3910687566,
-0.1848899573,
0.4481245577,
0.0179734919,
0.9279312491,
-0.39915663,
-0.0852293596,
-0.29342556,
-0.5164087415,
-0.1054255515,
-0.0025322253,
0.9550194144,
0.2100975513,
0.1995253116,
0.1419946402,
-0.0713292882,
0.3320936561,
0.0187549051,
-0.7763958573,
-0.2958398461,
0.2568832934,
-0.0795857459,
-0.4215969145,
-0.0690692142,
-0.906683445,
-0.1317783743,
-0.0145176258,
0.4147028625,
-0.2563283145,
-0.1215449646,
-0.1641397625,
0.0977251232,
0.1167090312,
0.5649132133,
-0.9130428433,
0.4257315695,
0.4944229126,
0.7192069292,
-0.1141557693,
-0.4561518431,
-0.823325634,
0.3568061292,
-0.2486833185,
0.7794323564,
-0.680069983,
-0.7774153352,
-0.1166597083,
-0.5732244253,
-0.1950363964,
-0.3889292479,
0.2615537047,
-0.3195495009,
0.5334635377,
-0.0769039467,
-0.4242137969,
0.1448541582,
0.4341424704,
-0.5562318563,
0.6777778268,
0.0462880395,
-0.6737497449,
0.1511674374,
-0.9885848165,
-0.0300794542,
0.4803315103,
-0.4260369539,
-0.238938868,
-0.253755033,
0.4929838777,
0.2822816372,
-0.4438887239,
0.2280610502,
-0.0839740857,
-0.4858449697,
0.1342528909,
-0.6861697435,
0.8855319023,
0.3134820461,
-0.3264099061,
0.1681091338,
-0.692810595,
-0.163882181,
0.2162645757,
-0.3412276506,
0.063782014,
-0.1506419182,
-0.1233870536,
-0.1479999721,
0.0661700442,
-0.7452099323,
0.5187682509,
-0.2419971079,
0.3101255596,
1.0727069378,
0.1006954089,
-0.0167248454,
-0.1621356905,
0.7826078534,
-0.0735130087,
0.0588284172,
-0.576159656,
-0.817694366,
-0.5262729526,
-0.3709717989,
0.213254109,
0.5638095737,
-0.6666554213,
-0.1774292439,
-0.2723658979,
-0.2182938457,
-0.8250299692,
0.0623678416,
0.3081799746,
0.707308352,
0.1281209886,
-0.2214163095,
-0.3410513997,
-0.4157465696,
0.2840864658,
-0.7127030492,
0.034265466,
0.5309998989,
0.6043263674,
0.0242490321,
0.8221971393,
-0.6428781748,
-0.0923853666,
-0.1242526844,
0.3458942473,
0.0059122574,
0.3310589492,
0.5932895541,
-0.6707184911,
-0.6756055355,
-0.1603426486,
-0.674967587,
0.1797913909,
0.1160545051,
-0.1319078356,
0.0641070977,
0.1306888461,
-0.6953901649,
0.6413158774,
0.4041900635,
-0.164208889,
0.4102009237,
0.3689548373,
0.4517607987,
-1.3994576931,
0.1238677651,
-0.3336188197,
-0.1336119175,
-0.2820326388,
0.0465295911,
-0.5121239424,
-0.6633455157,
-0.5420281291,
0.7008786201,
-0.077191785,
-0.0800777674,
-0.3728655279,
0.4750907123,
-0.1433137953,
0.4905230403,
0.0222947877,
1.1408815384,
0.6177663207,
-0.6312144995,
0.8944483995,
0.7380330563,
-0.2796106339,
0.7365707755,
-0.8478220701,
0.4031614065,
0.1993674636,
0.3667602539,
-1.0725818872,
-0.4520148337,
0.46043396,
-0.7488324642,
-0.0701019317,
-0.0980372056,
-0.5324345231,
-0.7624475956,
-0.2865509689,
0.547321558,
0.2653562427,
-0.5410174131,
0.2423194647,
0.030595826,
-0.6278237104,
-0.3870034218,
-0.3615759015,
0.231194362,
0.0814631656,
-0.5134320259,
-0.1733607203,
-0.3513272107,
-0.2156242579,
0.2340796292,
0.2227004319,
-0.0387096927,
0.2860654593,
0.2171435505,
0.6530520916,
-0.2489644736,
-0.0805277526,
-0.1161101907,
-0.0707734153,
0.1194194108,
-0.0034569202,
0.578836441,
-0.2325308174,
-0.5595856309,
-0.6020802259,
0.5465454459,
0.3521955311,
-0.3314446807,
0.6485767961,
0.4268839061,
-0.3419905901,
-0.0420609973,
0.0125616463,
-0.2376559377,
-0.3880027235,
0.2371184379,
-0.5266174078,
-0.644390583,
0.2625166774,
0.2614387572,
0.1458633691,
0.1815937161,
0.7151145339,
-0.0249805003,
1.3740367889,
0.4744873047,
-0.1492429078,
0.4802508652,
-0.5144508481,
0.1742576212,
-0.7944089174,
-0.22607252,
-0.5841011405,
-0.1189264357,
-0.2629762888,
0.0808809474,
0.6316584349,
-0.1313855797,
-0.2800104618,
0.2798925042,
-0.4057586193,
0.161570996,
0.8402084708,
-0.0109887626,
0.1493361145,
-0.0232984237,
0.0807994381,
0.4462426007,
-0.5205023885,
-0.7461822033,
1.158015132,
0.2430811673,
0.5860263705,
0.4186872542,
0.9017558098,
0.0280908458,
0.2657826543,
-0.7009453773,
0.8074527979,
0.1951876283,
-0.7379909158,
-0.4515039623,
-0.341803968,
-0.7555948496,
-0.0567169748,
0.1625208855,
-0.6791352034,
-0.0150278201,
-0.1295836121,
-0.7441166639,
0.3828555644,
-0.65870893,
0.7914251685,
0.1099427193,
-0.3836481273,
-0.0671662837,
-0.4519236088,
0.1493420899,
0.0444811322,
-0.0973020718,
0.0037248763,
0.1945604533,
0.6597541571,
-0.3707116544,
0.922303319,
-0.2640673518,
-0.2130537778,
0.8437345028,
0.0392760709,
0.17298612,
0.195875898,
-0.2105457336,
-0.3695765436,
-0.1328566372,
-0.4455605745,
-0.407556653,
0.72708565,
-1.0151435137,
-0.8005696535,
-0.3389010727,
-0.5280331373,
-0.3052858114,
0.1203412414,
0.2811365128,
0.5914303064,
-0.2979530394,
-0.1606792063,
0.3206984103,
0.1193886101,
0.6829279661,
0.468675971,
-0.0529557206,
-0.3534334302,
0.9875153899,
-0.1409478933,
0.0849117115,
0.0409735441,
0.0208417159,
0.1035096273,
-0.3032971621,
-0.8435091972,
-0.0625838935,
-0.4903959036,
-0.5780685544,
-0.4156328142,
-0.3029639423,
-0.9114193916,
-0.1253798306,
0.0603724197,
-0.2740458548,
-0.4169753492,
-0.3779466152,
0.0830865055,
1.2060608864,
-0.0786235332,
0.279312253,
-0.8391523361,
0.1876052171,
0.8517795801,
0.0889919475,
0.0877774432,
-0.4762658477,
-0.2845951915,
0.2379139662,
-0.7761036754,
-0.9250483513,
0.2198818326,
0.3544176221,
0.4136749804,
0.3016331494,
-0.0917498544,
0.4637821615,
-0.5376633406,
1.2283581495,
0.0780192539,
-0.8322669864,
1.1287100315,
-0.4886975586,
0.2800980806,
0.2849541903,
0.4748941362,
-0.0626669526,
-0.4651175737,
-0.4760168195,
-0.6281781197,
1.0065102577,
0.1244637296,
0.3967942595,
-0.2700166702,
0.0207796097,
0.1061474085,
0.3312613666,
-0.7117310166,
-0.1131962389,
-0.3864243031,
-0.4758683145,
0.2922292352,
-0.2256696075,
-0.4357122481,
0.1066926718,
0.6733735204,
-0.2727856338,
0.3367059827,
0.0153204985,
0.2047863156,
-0.2615683079,
0.5461708903,
0.4385872185,
0.4164410233,
-0.132474184,
-0.1318770349,
0.0210347604,
-0.5022110939,
0.127020821,
0.1442145258,
-0.1808279306,
-0.2789161503,
0.4935228527,
1.0723304749,
-0.2020977288,
-0.4925255477,
0.752507031,
-0.1534132212,
0.0460525565,
-0.1751233041,
0.2896085382,
-0.3808335066,
0.2188996375,
0.3183517754,
0.0002877463,
0.4843223393,
-0.8522969484,
0.1155132875,
0.1665679067,
-0.1807205677,
-0.5485259295,
0.9088158011,
0.5755337477,
-0.2930555046,
0.9120005369,
-0.1689873934,
-0.5750836134,
0.6581676602,
0.8639811277,
0.9763681889,
-0.3779146075,
0.614628911,
0.6019357443,
-0.2511855662,
0.2352069765,
0.3375440836,
-0.3749807477,
-0.6697369218,
-0.0743436962,
-0.1982755065,
-0.7426829934,
-0.0778834447,
-0.7950322032,
0.2806298435,
-0.4168111384,
-0.1183910072,
-0.1565502882,
0.0441230424,
-0.6833993196,
0.4345627725,
0.43345505,
0.5449886322,
-0.9738634825,
0.6758250594,
1.1508740187,
-0.8021166325,
-1.0677444935,
0.1404233277,
-0.0981556699,
-0.856179893,
0.9008896351,
0.0888483673,
-0.2510428429,
0.3555086851,
-0.9279383421,
-0.2478079349,
1.068267107,
0.1455096304,
-0.2090464979,
-0.3152758181,
0.0449217595,
0.4869219065,
-0.4691605568,
0.5942578316,
0.1727581471,
0.2048420608,
0.2119875848,
-0.9025258422,
-0.3714953959,
-0.4265580773,
-0.0591629297,
-0.2089537978,
-0.665151298,
0.8163640499,
-0.4968990982,
-0.2449308485,
0.544154644,
0.8754345179,
0.3509978652,
0.4404928088,
0.2487577051,
0.5849767923,
0.5889548659,
-0.0173327271,
1.0394517183,
-0.3550263643,
0.113034375,
1.0985358953,
-0.0806981102,
1.0859371424,
0.1242870837,
-0.3364584446,
0.5683666468,
0.4105157852,
-0.0738826096,
0.5126513839,
-0.0862456933,
-0.7415577173,
0.0026555075,
-0.4471321404,
-0.4268293977,
0.5413227081,
0.2356282324,
0.2668645084,
0.0233234931,
0.4153393805,
-0.1010785922,
0.0930621624,
-0.5174520612,
0.9282688498,
0.0136333713,
-0.8103211522,
0.2119403034,
-0.1432813406,
0.3485763967,
-0.1381836832,
-0.3576129377,
-0.3586321771,
-0.0561878197,
-0.0989404842,
-0.9280383587,
-0.1138011366,
0.3976810873,
-0.0887848139,
-0.0956760272,
0.155406341,
-0.5488027334,
-0.3954215348,
-0.0927684307,
0.0731424987,
0.0823326409,
0.4374440014,
-0.4988073111,
0.1296404749,
-0.0231006332,
0.0008196785,
-0.14303343,
0.3515852988,
0.0476227216,
0.5395200253,
0.099595584,
0.0280485209,
0.0625473484,
0.2057963014,
0.7854447961,
-0.2159800231,
-0.2735617459,
-0.3411886692,
0.559674859,
0.2070337087,
-0.4495759904,
0.6289372444,
0.5004138947,
0.8395027518,
-0.0902154744,
0.9070113301,
-0.0459823087,
0.6481133699,
-0.3380344212,
0.2573114336,
-0.410361141,
0.2042059898,
-0.4858893454,
-0.8719994426,
0.1577887088,
0.6275354028,
-0.3286410272,
0.2182052732,
0.5324684978,
0.5174791217,
0.1151802167,
0.2807002664,
0.3123508394,
0.113880828,
0.5775500536,
0.8000243306,
0.8996642232,
-0.833450675,
0.7131578922,
-0.0755131692,
-0.1835965216,
-0.1150840744,
-0.2751178443,
-0.7803393602,
-0.8041495085,
-0.4852321744,
-0.0960730463,
0.212528646,
0.6547931433,
0.2660365701,
-0.9505601525,
-0.1883726716,
-0.1828157604,
-0.0370348692,
0.2678856254,
-0.2696690261,
0.3650712669,
-0.282046169,
-1.260751605,
0.5652534366,
-0.0141410595,
0.2289210707,
-0.3045757711,
-0.021844307,
-0.022072427,
0.1565839797,
0.3410718739,
0.2284874171,
-0.4951329529,
-0.3573210537,
-0.0218456443,
-0.3291350007,
-0.1495260298,
0.5593484044,
-0.8197110295,
0.6157842278,
0.4487255216,
0.6062632799,
0.1895079315,
0.0183542147,
0.7141985297,
-0.4961445928,
0.1125791594,
0.278221935,
0.0892260224,
0.3769915998,
-0.1595701277,
0.6445590258,
0.2130299211,
-0.6216043234,
-1.066814661,
0.3056992888,
-0.5697866678,
0.0039681145,
0.7673096061,
-0.4150307477,
-0.0705941096,
0.2610011995,
-0.4342543185,
0.2191408575,
-0.2948436141,
0.5162895918,
0.7241181731,
-0.0268675424,
-0.1876571923,
-0.5514127016,
0.1718975455,
0.36496979,
-0.880078733,
-0.4407960176,
0.6099408269,
-0.0573692694,
0.1558201313,
0.7773952484,
-0.0354389474,
0.5650474429,
0.2506234646,
0.0106594199,
-0.1946558952,
-0.8255464435,
-0.0386163518,
0.1157178134,
0.1705051363,
-0.5651387572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05323v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05323v2 | Advancing Italian Biomedical Information Extraction with Transformers-based Models: Methodological Insights and Multicenter Practical Application | 2023-06-08T16:15:46 | 2024-01-15T11:05:23 | Claudio Crema, Tommaso Mario Buonocore, Silvia Fostinelli, Enea Parimbelli, Federico Verde, Cira Fundarò, Marina Manera, Matteo Cotta Ramusino, Marco Capelli, Alfredo Costa, Giuliano Binetti, Riccardo Bellazzi, Alberto Redolfi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; J.3 | The introduction of computerized medical records in hospitals has reduced
burdensome activities like manual writing and information fetching. However,
the data contained in medical records are still far underutilized, primarily
because extracting data from unstructured textual medical records takes time
and effort. Information Extraction, a subfield of Natural Language Processing,
can help clinical practitioners overcome this limitation by using automated
text-mining pipelines. In this work, we created the first Italian
neuropsychiatric Named Entity Recognition dataset, PsyNIT, and used it to
develop a Transformers-based model. Moreover, we collected and leveraged three
external independent datasets to implement an effective multicenter model, with
overall F1-score 84.77%, Precision 83.16%, Recall 86.44%. The lessons learned
are: (i) the crucial role of a consistent annotation process and (ii) a
fine-tuning strategy that combines classical methods with a "low-resource"
approach. This allowed us to establish methodological guidelines that pave the
way for Natural Language Processing studies in less-resourced languages. | [
-0.4379197061,
-0.4741862416,
0.7458336949,
-0.1155976951,
-0.21300897,
-0.1369737536,
-0.3991424739,
-0.5805051327,
0.5207484365,
0.2702640891,
-0.6462544799,
-0.4287048876,
-0.9049245715,
0.2347190231,
-0.3266506195,
1.2739826441,
0.2496628314,
0.5122295022,
0.1631830931,
-0.1347740889,
0.0512757227,
-0.603285253,
-0.679305017,
-0.4440757632,
0.5238445997,
0.3647201955,
0.4139280021,
0.4981568456,
0.8307486773,
0.2211188078,
-0.13546215,
0.1481565088,
0.0080314567,
-0.0229975339,
-0.2096617967,
-0.570794642,
-0.3727148771,
-0.0667739064,
0.3844205141,
0.6957200766,
-0.3386461735,
0.1023700535,
-0.0463607647,
0.6406350732,
-0.4672609568,
0.2758569717,
-0.4992301762,
0.4790943563,
-0.291588366,
-0.4355153143,
-0.4757929444,
-0.2508929074,
0.305591464,
-0.627563715,
0.5014477372,
-0.4069063663,
0.7420634031,
0.2885729969,
-0.1767396629,
-0.599996388,
-0.661393404,
0.7306687236,
-0.773468852,
0.3254754543,
0.2544749081,
0.3463086188,
-0.2316486388,
-1.0333989859,
-0.1814198643,
0.1192557141,
-0.3249548078,
0.0589640997,
-0.4310572445,
-0.0814499855,
0.5783674717,
0.2905380726,
-0.1706834882,
0.1584335268,
-0.6359704733,
-0.3010281324,
0.3571744263,
0.0217794888,
0.409433037,
-0.3618267179,
-0.2277661562,
0.3382339478,
-0.5952367187,
-0.0309409499,
-0.1030262858,
0.4038917422,
0.1593119353,
0.7190197706,
-0.2483638376,
0.164309904,
0.1719507128,
-0.2757087946,
0.4930945337,
-0.199252829,
0.0174274892,
0.1687016785,
1.0477536917,
0.2992702127,
0.2375128716,
-0.6107086539,
-0.0821438134,
-0.0820415914,
0.4813518524,
-0.7614942789,
-0.4430988729,
0.288857311,
-0.7720634937,
-0.1699818373,
0.0707731247,
-1.3996124268,
-0.5944093466,
-0.420029968,
0.1943730116,
-0.6995899081,
-0.1963910311,
-0.0888640359,
-0.2122212797,
0.0246634204,
0.1297273934,
-0.9140398502,
0.4198524654,
0.4466578662,
1.0064681768,
-0.515750587,
0.2188395262,
-0.4680123925,
-0.0416566133,
0.0456845313,
0.9125410318,
-0.2355470359,
-0.3990348577,
-0.2369363457,
0.2930197418,
-0.1872884929,
-0.5157262087,
0.8322864771,
-0.005767962,
0.4952840507,
-0.2255727053,
-0.4199912846,
0.0599950813,
-0.0581953153,
-0.880902648,
0.7958649397,
-0.2013122439,
-0.9815300107,
0.424120605,
-0.6820680499,
-0.4506230652,
0.0926982015,
-0.3023188412,
-0.3226830959,
0.5800572038,
0.389179647,
0.2970996499,
-0.571418345,
0.5722277164,
0.0585491173,
-0.1200104207,
0.0585446917,
-0.5420098901,
0.9362602234,
0.032648325,
-0.405351907,
-0.1253590435,
-0.9176230431,
-0.0088488264,
-0.0747124106,
-0.0963515192,
-0.2918697298,
0.2741094828,
0.2162421197,
0.4161508679,
0.1234059259,
-0.7311365604,
0.1916226298,
-0.4201636016,
0.6336081624,
0.3017778099,
0.1070758253,
0.4714037478,
-0.2001705021,
0.5307577848,
0.1447983831,
0.2520621419,
-0.0460779518,
-0.4355377555,
-0.61294204,
-0.678825438,
0.4056709409,
0.6974560022,
-0.8259874582,
0.5434424281,
-0.211721763,
-0.8062884808,
-0.6585175395,
-0.3319442868,
-0.1478065401,
0.8299434781,
0.7198021412,
-0.3655461371,
-0.5060522556,
-1.2115525007,
-0.0193264056,
0.1974964887,
-0.1726433635,
0.1588767618,
0.3409873545,
-0.321015507,
0.9069618583,
-0.6105505228,
-0.4452769756,
-0.2550763786,
0.3658527732,
0.6042036414,
0.5952703953,
0.2300506681,
-0.6477923393,
-0.1032233834,
0.063299641,
-0.9154011011,
-0.055653248,
0.0813729987,
0.0431100018,
-0.199321419,
0.3742624819,
-0.8834875822,
0.4806436598,
0.2638278306,
0.2054343224,
0.2855632901,
-0.3394502401,
0.0121342503,
-1.2577543259,
0.458073318,
0.175747022,
-0.0532837994,
-0.7969946265,
-0.3586380482,
0.09593907,
-0.1983194798,
-0.2413594574,
0.1483052522,
-0.3942435384,
0.1932668984,
-0.149582237,
-0.0721124038,
0.1355521828,
0.3558982313,
0.2998509705,
0.5304356217,
0.5300620198,
-0.2673281133,
0.1468596905,
0.1284981072,
-0.2809614241,
0.5485488176,
-0.6100474,
0.0708155781,
-0.3656623065,
-0.0631026179,
-0.7298343778,
0.0130192842,
0.2271765172,
-0.2912176251,
0.2563087642,
-0.1225664243,
-0.5677751899,
-0.1535652578,
-0.0188409444,
0.0943590775,
0.204852134,
-0.292457372,
0.7439875603,
0.8135400414,
-0.5927527547,
-0.4436671734,
-0.703541398,
-0.0018396378,
-0.323328048,
0.0069135488,
0.5494775176,
0.126966387,
-0.0158584323,
-0.0661385432,
-0.1485622972,
-0.4957080483,
0.1843807399,
0.1570871472,
0.3639882803,
-0.2014624476,
0.5436136723,
0.2700113952,
-0.4278638959,
0.0904109851,
0.0127522117,
0.439375639,
0.1758525223,
-0.1394572705,
-0.8500189185,
0.5656965375,
0.6564292312,
-0.3603212833,
0.7013646364,
0.6993579268,
-0.9502388239,
0.0550832301,
-0.4241535366,
-0.6828437448,
-0.337697804,
0.3606485724,
-0.1413222849,
-0.3942394257,
0.4355138242,
-0.339183569,
-0.0935887545,
0.5973385572,
0.482562393,
-0.0361406952,
1.0345108509,
0.7531474829,
0.0300331339,
0.3286705911,
-0.1348116547,
0.4569346607,
-0.730502367,
-0.3949466348,
-0.8758162856,
-0.290155232,
-0.8274593949,
0.0087644998,
0.6198907495,
-0.0287067406,
0.4275867641,
0.4345380366,
-0.6688942313,
0.2075230479,
0.4322928786,
0.4358061552,
0.4898659885,
0.051566124,
-0.0344112627,
-0.5171160102,
-0.8025987148,
-0.5114479065,
1.0256922245,
0.2861861587,
0.4069554508,
-0.1888943911,
0.7084395289,
-0.0075648706,
0.6124985218,
-1.0255161524,
0.1062095836,
-0.3056949675,
-0.6907939315,
-0.0166894849,
-0.3750336468,
-0.7998376489,
0.1722416729,
-0.6114330888,
-0.8894107938,
0.6432259083,
-0.2825701833,
-0.6528897285,
0.2476245463,
-0.7739190459,
0.7503465414,
-0.3388299644,
-0.1936996281,
-0.0099998601,
-0.5682680607,
-0.0426739641,
-0.3325536549,
0.3247076869,
-0.1023326069,
-0.1188579276,
0.7224410176,
-0.076070264,
0.6009777188,
-0.1817578077,
0.3066546619,
-0.141958937,
-0.1203827709,
0.1927734166,
0.1599030793,
-0.3101294637,
0.5991863012,
0.3701849878,
-0.1137971729,
-0.5869064331,
0.4581521451,
-0.4272176027,
-0.1369642764,
-0.5903017521,
-0.5082142353,
-0.4006828666,
0.4525527358,
0.7693501115,
0.6181674004,
-0.1124151722,
0.2364847809,
0.4223915339,
-0.2671639919,
0.4852868617,
0.4927872717,
0.3879234791,
-0.5442892909,
0.567278564,
0.2993029952,
-0.2271734178,
0.3336699605,
0.0326032639,
-0.1155158877,
-0.5591261983,
-0.2704153061,
0.2175928056,
-0.4297235608,
-0.325283736,
-0.7202798724,
-0.2994244397,
-0.0939805657,
0.3610284925,
-0.4670620263,
-0.5252976418,
-0.3746523559,
-0.0792452395,
-0.0385720693,
0.5786247253,
-0.0140366228,
0.4434391558,
-0.9824523926,
0.346262753,
-0.3010341823,
0.3335031569,
-0.2084444612,
0.01605081,
-0.3902063072,
-0.0882103369,
-0.1880174428,
-1.2318433523,
0.6871349812,
0.1229942143,
0.7807350159,
0.2749691904,
-0.2289604098,
0.7058392167,
-0.7207437158,
0.3936960399,
0.2857108712,
-0.8426997662,
0.6489759684,
0.0408001393,
-0.0147479344,
0.9547944665,
0.6389891505,
-0.448720336,
0.0442980491,
-0.8204256892,
-0.9282813668,
0.8135953546,
0.147924751,
-0.3406073451,
-0.1532487273,
0.5358963013,
0.2953059077,
0.4475048482,
-0.6193776727,
-0.1230931953,
0.1635133773,
-0.6032091379,
-0.2751130164,
0.0940525457,
-0.1445942074,
-0.2870360315,
0.4827875793,
-0.1310696602,
0.4340752065,
0.664973855,
-0.2188085914,
0.0190473069,
0.3022952676,
0.1786020398,
0.5379126668,
-0.0280256849,
0.0719283298,
-0.0172018316,
-0.5705242753,
-0.1139490902,
0.4989877045,
-0.2430619299,
0.3146811426,
0.3826110065,
0.4681389332,
0.0935243145,
-0.7283327579,
0.5390604138,
-0.2598606646,
0.2275570035,
-0.4409513175,
-0.2738872766,
-0.2468532622,
0.3257744312,
0.4300721884,
0.3842172325,
0.6453750134,
-0.2108225673,
0.4998705089,
0.3921901882,
-0.7960392237,
-0.3944729865,
0.3213160634,
-0.086359106,
-0.3426055014,
0.7197214961,
0.2316023111,
-0.1468388438,
0.5669257641,
0.3417296112,
0.7433467507,
-0.0348830074,
0.2681443691,
0.4471366107,
0.2882544696,
-0.3282433152,
0.030867938,
-0.1152698174,
-0.6681796312,
-0.4664683938,
-0.3427188098,
-0.271096766,
0.0928774327,
-1.0195288658,
0.4548741579,
-0.4301687181,
-0.6756760478,
0.320245415,
-0.0977435112,
-0.5640551448,
0.1959398091,
-0.0032696289,
0.8243127465,
-0.8481218815,
0.8780779839,
0.491245091,
-0.464561671,
-0.4502722025,
-0.112121731,
-0.0414560772,
-0.3876399398,
0.3558155596,
0.3341485858,
0.2239945382,
-0.0408867188,
-0.1634636968,
-0.5960693955,
0.9901673198,
0.3423947394,
-0.7310040593,
-0.3676605225,
-0.0815987736,
0.9701519608,
-0.3535524905,
0.6082428098,
0.7729892135,
0.1530406773,
-0.2579109967,
-0.845130384,
-0.2035318762,
-0.5352912545,
-0.5685759783,
0.4082477987,
-0.0842145234,
0.8231015205,
-0.0525137149,
-0.2584318519,
0.1103321686,
0.0815063566,
-0.0851533711,
0.2799853683,
0.2982549369,
0.5154491663,
1.1016392708,
-0.3518020809,
0.8719452024,
-0.5967614651,
0.4101617932,
1.0025035143,
-0.1302628964,
0.7403317094,
0.8142864108,
0.0224351771,
0.5236746669,
0.2912194729,
0.0153489783,
0.4819709957,
-0.1943539381,
-0.1729941517,
-0.0158483572,
-0.4012447298,
-0.2587268949,
0.5874079466,
0.498731643,
-0.7717077732,
-0.2296117842,
0.1219955385,
0.0328002647,
-0.1360880584,
-0.0149221905,
1.1738306284,
0.1076835021,
-0.5720164776,
-0.0523616262,
-0.013816773,
0.3713209331,
-0.5845528841,
-0.0354142413,
-0.0341335647,
0.2310288548,
-0.3758547902,
-0.3301582038,
0.4344392121,
0.1318639368,
-0.3281510472,
-0.0888220146,
0.5080630779,
-0.3165234923,
-0.7326754332,
0.289868027,
0.6646571755,
-0.0109247826,
-0.0747078136,
-0.5781007409,
-0.3264363408,
-0.0556065328,
0.0450231358,
0.0694136098,
0.6474168301,
0.0282073859,
0.3371111453,
0.6015971899,
0.7963656187,
-0.2301297933,
-0.0501715913,
0.6973158121,
-0.7441157699,
-0.2835690081,
-0.9625836015,
0.4862757325,
-0.4129000604,
-0.3548829556,
0.3294757605,
0.5373932719,
0.2171460688,
0.060916964,
0.6842406392,
-0.0959636793,
0.702164948,
-0.3303988278,
0.6394755244,
-0.3779423833,
0.0152701437,
-0.1145786345,
-0.8023923039,
-0.4007081687,
0.698544085,
-0.363403827,
-0.3937874436,
0.9060970545,
0.6018158197,
-0.1103110537,
0.3780657053,
-0.1693837494,
0.269300282,
0.3613558114,
0.6566242576,
0.4361070096,
-0.6223986149,
0.1144382879,
-0.6538972259,
-0.4229227602,
0.2819445729,
-0.825948298,
-0.5250351429,
-0.4444938302,
-0.1827058792,
-0.1977322847,
-0.0631411076,
1.1040406227,
0.7561623454,
-1.0899022818,
-0.0348035097,
-0.1376787424,
-0.0921526104,
-0.2213711888,
-0.1900334507,
0.4033125043,
-0.3655833602,
-0.7204220295,
0.3480526805,
0.4056068957,
-0.1733886302,
-0.0670373067,
0.443207562,
-0.2440856248,
-0.3824934363,
0.3271078169,
0.1195209399,
-0.2790104151,
0.0902241617,
0.0578095764,
-0.173284173,
0.4368829429,
0.9356666207,
-0.7425595522,
0.5423437357,
0.480279237,
0.6678486466,
0.4514507055,
-0.0084712943,
0.5878077745,
-0.4012286961,
0.4923533797,
0.4809212983,
0.5786124468,
0.4008109272,
-0.461550355,
0.4431812465,
0.4173780382,
-0.317065388,
-0.636341691,
-0.0501053706,
-0.6963905692,
-0.1878967285,
0.6169270873,
-0.0311431009,
-0.1325122714,
-0.1700971723,
-0.3508490026,
0.3809467852,
-0.3559524417,
1.0772333145,
0.7005131841,
-0.41630584,
-0.1137131825,
-0.6865526438,
0.6710945964,
0.2938201129,
-0.9874588251,
-0.2933111191,
0.4470546246,
0.1297178268,
0.5781763196,
0.5413455963,
-0.6405133605,
0.2021394372,
-0.4210573435,
0.2191955447,
0.3196286559,
-0.4731039703,
-0.6414652467,
0.5348951221,
-0.1678124815,
0.0793239027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05320v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05320v3 | KIT's Multilingual Speech Translation System for IWSLT 2023 | 2023-06-08T16:13:20 | 2023-07-12T04:41:47 | Danni Liu, Thai Binh Nguyen, Sai Koneru, Enes Yavuz Ugan, Ngoc-Quan Pham, Tuan-Nam Nguyen, Tu Anh Dinh, Carlos Mullov, Alexander Waibel, Jan Niehues | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD | Many existing speech translation benchmarks focus on native-English speech in
high-quality recording conditions, which often do not match the conditions in
real-life use-cases. In this paper, we describe our speech translation system
for the multilingual track of IWSLT 2023, which evaluates translation quality
on scientific conference talks. The test condition features accented input
speech and terminology-dense contents. The task requires translation into 10
languages of varying amounts of resources. In absence of training data from the
target domain, we use a retrieval-based approach (kNN-MT) for effective
adaptation (+0.8 BLEU for speech translation). We also use adapters to easily
integrate incremental training data from data augmentation, and show that it
matches the performance of re-training. We observe that cascaded systems are
more easily adaptable towards specific target domains, due to their separate
modules. Our cascaded speech system substantially outperforms its end-to-end
counterpart on scientific talk translation, although their performance remains
similar on TED talks. | [
-0.20686391,
-0.2891745269,
-0.043631319,
0.7664874196,
-0.5629553795,
0.794860363,
-0.4037282169,
-0.6690485477,
0.1946233064,
0.1325770915,
-0.4381207824,
-0.3999678195,
-0.5946286321,
0.3914658427,
-0.4562207162,
1.0425564051,
-0.014041868,
0.4232108295,
0.0019071662,
-0.3639269471,
-0.4931688309,
-0.2818005681,
-0.6440111995,
-0.6081820726,
0.3884660006,
0.3868373036,
0.3838227689,
0.3658211231,
0.579341948,
0.2194035202,
0.1529589593,
0.0519441143,
-0.3384715021,
-0.0127415136,
-0.3829979599,
-0.2232451737,
-0.5600363016,
-0.1868022978,
0.7695674896,
0.6371046305,
0.0540032014,
0.1431995034,
0.1711360216,
0.043798171,
-0.1343677044,
0.2786075473,
-0.6570806503,
0.1650621742,
-0.2355721593,
-0.5371802449,
-0.6435602903,
0.0005474722,
0.079987891,
-0.5706372857,
0.0793185756,
0.1028404385,
0.6361994743,
0.321323812,
-0.4432661831,
0.0360975601,
-0.5613582134,
0.9309452176,
-0.7185598612,
0.6633728743,
0.1904898137,
0.3159190118,
-0.2619590163,
-0.68681705,
-0.3408323228,
-0.1448680907,
0.0432898104,
0.3937757909,
-0.1093504131,
0.0198446624,
-0.1975121796,
0.091295816,
-0.7886123061,
0.0501778498,
-0.4325551093,
-0.2396961153,
0.7528623939,
-0.2357463986,
0.1920418441,
-0.1465698034,
-0.3646712303,
-0.4062511623,
-0.1402718425,
-0.1957090646,
-0.0531047434,
0.8398028612,
-0.1971612275,
0.2711633146,
-0.4569559395,
0.5404165983,
-0.2227681428,
-0.4943920672,
0.627119422,
-0.6293646097,
0.0885686278,
0.4263159633,
0.7009663582,
0.2303356528,
0.0685574412,
-0.4103855193,
-0.1141436473,
-0.4541657567,
0.165326491,
-0.5790570974,
-0.0545621626,
0.0432930104,
-0.1951417029,
-0.0653031617,
-0.3287007213,
-0.3908470273,
0.0757601708,
-0.3518135548,
0.579657793,
-0.3671721816,
-0.2317183465,
0.0514239408,
-0.1491427571,
0.1030736119,
0.2507565022,
-0.4379816651,
0.3204871416,
0.4439356029,
0.9933925271,
-0.6068737507,
-0.5802807212,
-0.755197823,
0.0853664204,
-0.3907123506,
0.6626430154,
0.0649853498,
-0.2611982524,
-0.1766525656,
0.1441518664,
-0.0078497818,
-0.4509865642,
0.5411458611,
-0.3782525361,
0.0723956674,
0.0370441675,
-0.2272170484,
0.1076538414,
0.0847018138,
-0.1499198526,
0.8929008842,
-0.0642000735,
-0.3994812965,
0.3484605849,
-0.6734027863,
-0.6121799946,
0.5132009387,
0.1874164045,
-0.0058956137,
-0.1572473645,
-0.1267560869,
0.3116211295,
-0.0344048776,
0.5242789984,
-0.163408041,
-0.2549715638,
0.0759871379,
-0.5556901693,
0.4730274677,
0.4408723414,
-0.35156551,
0.1883707643,
-0.8854925036,
0.208913669,
-0.1864857823,
-0.6482554674,
-0.210900411,
-0.0053516156,
0.413043499,
0.3286724985,
0.1554716974,
-0.7049332857,
0.0656508803,
-0.2088303268,
0.5117843747,
0.4000887871,
-0.2552556098,
0.4090196192,
0.019418953,
0.3097121716,
-0.0530107208,
0.1551997811,
-0.0416091383,
-0.5563265085,
-0.5960907936,
-0.0763498321,
0.36891222,
0.8054068685,
-0.9232484698,
0.2592989206,
-0.575637579,
-0.3719370365,
-0.5853640437,
-0.1644507498,
0.5388482809,
0.4857179821,
0.6841610074,
-0.2779364288,
-0.4788825512,
-0.8800251484,
-0.2831392586,
-0.1253770292,
-0.0424308367,
-0.0515452288,
0.3397291601,
-0.0358434096,
0.4022798538,
0.1385646015,
-0.0596736744,
0.0469504856,
0.3165039122,
0.3281401992,
0.5838513374,
0.1009763181,
-0.6953498125,
-0.5939543843,
0.4757098854,
-0.5029396415,
-0.0623316951,
-0.1736100167,
-0.206593439,
0.0562096499,
0.5283183455,
-0.3154757619,
0.3330800533,
0.8650186658,
-0.1942371428,
0.4973583817,
-0.0650301129,
0.4013271928,
-1.1965005398,
0.0916611329,
-0.3339146674,
-0.7193899751,
-0.6508662105,
0.0897727683,
0.2605536282,
-0.1597140878,
-0.6373331547,
0.628742516,
0.0108384071,
-0.2772908807,
-0.2537149787,
0.4160808325,
0.1354197711,
0.1341986656,
-0.0695720315,
1.0948191881,
0.2008162886,
-0.6389696002,
0.3307644725,
0.5246005058,
-0.4105019867,
0.9943507314,
-0.222081691,
0.1081126928,
0.2529696524,
0.5729107857,
-0.6821329594,
-0.3800813854,
0.0121528637,
-0.5951632857,
0.4386485815,
0.2430741787,
-0.3108195066,
-0.332521677,
0.0741844475,
0.2222354263,
0.1603863835,
-0.7039163709,
0.2208009064,
-0.0066945339,
-0.6123746037,
-0.7610341907,
-0.8306469917,
0.8052264452,
-0.0237949882,
-0.4467725456,
0.8748010993,
-0.4272999465,
-0.0172403213,
0.0048224428,
-0.1671039909,
-0.1305471808,
-0.1238502935,
-0.3209059834,
-0.1073966548,
-0.3600775003,
0.2470093817,
0.1310203969,
0.0064603449,
-0.2609058022,
-0.5975156426,
0.4945545793,
-0.0527491048,
-0.2643553615,
-0.5256773829,
0.6195593476,
0.7414717674,
0.1025161073,
0.418048203,
0.8898092508,
-0.2984639704,
0.0385352969,
-0.5664458871,
-0.2056954652,
-0.3884576559,
0.918621242,
-0.6912250519,
-0.5973686576,
0.3307761848,
-0.0452873856,
0.2828247845,
0.3612249792,
0.2437092215,
-0.2458257377,
1.1634458303,
0.3884374797,
0.0300117638,
0.3904148936,
0.2057512403,
0.2663799524,
-0.9881560206,
-0.3959482312,
-0.5652887821,
-0.3098310828,
-0.3993621171,
-0.3522223532,
0.2695483565,
0.2015146464,
-0.0321467891,
0.6082841754,
-0.4989820421,
0.282117784,
0.6373108029,
-0.2287404239,
0.4703882933,
-0.0967352763,
0.2324284911,
-0.1753907651,
-0.8068244457,
-0.3551918566,
0.6904734969,
0.1618272513,
0.3348655999,
0.046945259,
0.5474684834,
0.2590492666,
0.3940098286,
-0.6181789041,
0.2817045748,
-0.4109321535,
-0.4964935482,
-0.3405427337,
-0.4835119545,
-0.8185655475,
0.471013695,
-0.0544492267,
-0.436522007,
0.1836859435,
-0.1910112649,
0.0698960125,
0.1997436136,
-0.4936906993,
0.5100412369,
-0.4019910395,
-0.1131806001,
-0.3500894904,
-0.7984224558,
0.1457917392,
-0.4959054887,
0.5717192888,
-0.3336142004,
0.1671629399,
0.8376196623,
0.090356566,
0.4268203378,
0.0489267185,
-0.0135300076,
-0.1706499308,
-0.0780027509,
0.2370452285,
0.0133147761,
-0.5099880695,
0.2263507992,
0.2489484251,
-0.5192366242,
-0.318087548,
0.6575165391,
-0.8112291694,
-0.303925693,
-0.2391856611,
-0.9986071587,
-0.4566809535,
0.2325831354,
0.3714369237,
0.3564098477,
-0.3220692277,
0.3939330578,
0.3965255916,
-0.2386973649,
0.5395706892,
0.6193419695,
-0.1679633707,
-0.766054213,
1.0096381903,
0.2469278574,
0.6787526608,
0.3407224417,
0.1464006752,
-0.4088484347,
-0.6245190501,
-0.8505314589,
0.0976831615,
-0.9235355854,
-0.4744545817,
-0.6873368025,
-0.3282001019,
-0.5556591153,
-0.1686822921,
-0.4502130747,
-0.5224499702,
-0.2304739058,
-0.0009489426,
0.2160244435,
0.6763079166,
-0.1668946445,
0.3574867547,
-0.6071224213,
0.1468319744,
0.158183828,
0.175142929,
-0.5170589089,
-0.9621537924,
-0.4118713737,
-0.0879439637,
-0.2073233575,
-0.5567194223,
0.4100179374,
0.6803295612,
0.5234096646,
-0.276429683,
-0.0731864497,
1.0000511408,
-0.585029304,
0.6238327622,
0.3201285899,
-0.9354409575,
0.4406631589,
-0.2704778612,
0.676789999,
0.7616291642,
0.2455592752,
-0.7294887304,
-0.4399800003,
-0.4389405847,
-0.7721682191,
0.7390654087,
-0.0837361813,
0.3763381839,
0.1440923661,
0.3065785468,
0.1578208208,
0.3091319203,
-0.6757292151,
-0.0853341147,
-0.2757176459,
-0.0814939141,
-0.3148259819,
0.2790753543,
-0.1766496301,
-0.2667098939,
1.0502460003,
-0.3075203598,
0.0925222039,
0.1485738456,
-0.0294915792,
-0.1015467867,
0.3279631436,
0.6698002219,
0.4834435582,
-0.2674725056,
0.1042198017,
0.5358819962,
-0.4949838221,
0.3107210398,
0.2576011121,
0.0476485454,
0.3072638512,
0.4336370528,
0.7070645094,
0.4442025125,
-0.3387361765,
0.4853202999,
0.0359002315,
-0.2856715322,
0.2161673754,
-0.3569161296,
0.0655253306,
0.1840868741,
0.5697008371,
0.4069930911,
0.2521130443,
-0.5347308517,
0.3644159138,
0.1757854819,
-0.6296004653,
-0.3906691372,
0.6256021261,
0.4329679012,
-0.6703770161,
0.2999227047,
-0.4233638942,
-0.3012501895,
0.042363923,
0.9900695086,
0.6684942842,
-0.663138926,
0.2399860024,
0.5668173432,
0.2818529308,
0.0346637778,
0.3086328208,
-0.0244118907,
-0.2282968014,
-1.0659646988,
-0.8258088827,
-0.4935846627,
0.0958403051,
-0.7026264071,
0.3821893632,
0.1606110334,
-0.1719843149,
-0.232826069,
-0.331558764,
-0.6220964789,
0.1936839223,
0.0905569643,
1.0398602486,
-0.7485749125,
0.8841596246,
0.48306337,
0.0747260377,
-0.4601621926,
-0.3315792978,
-0.1924129128,
-0.5358690619,
0.5162356496,
-0.2660378218,
-0.2473357618,
0.2734840512,
-0.3589692712,
-1.2293963432,
0.9109629989,
0.4549372196,
-0.6988874674,
0.2422235757,
0.1205341741,
0.3764434159,
-0.1415738016,
-0.0998255238,
0.4659315348,
0.5458199978,
0.1109859049,
-1.6316173077,
-0.3644475043,
-0.168198809,
-0.2177909762,
-0.075054504,
-0.4935027659,
0.5377812982,
0.1340213865,
-0.0766949132,
0.0739989728,
0.5826360583,
0.2304361463,
0.3473742008,
0.2403684109,
0.1810315847,
0.7801268697,
-0.1606088281,
0.8409682512,
-0.1614999324,
0.1096175537,
1.2793699503,
-0.2054178715,
1.0761336088,
0.6461313367,
-0.2916145325,
0.2197561711,
0.4639594555,
0.4584036171,
0.7193040252,
0.1419814974,
-0.4787136912,
-0.143816337,
-0.5124006271,
-0.6476406455,
0.4634899497,
0.4130451083,
0.1217378005,
-0.0658617392,
0.5943527818,
-0.129291594,
-0.0736304745,
0.0367919803,
0.7900368571,
0.1629746705,
-0.6429357529,
0.6060786843,
-0.0175066181,
0.7997576594,
-0.709638536,
0.0981001779,
-0.1149927303,
0.0816678256,
-0.2772005498,
-0.7098275423,
0.3410599828,
-0.2253515124,
0.0070964568,
-0.5266712308,
0.3402803838,
-0.480442971,
-0.4461381733,
0.4116841257,
0.4306855202,
0.5217030644,
0.1276980639,
-0.770601213,
0.375790596,
0.1155620962,
-0.0638358518,
0.4355059862,
0.2557579875,
-0.2577895224,
0.5078657269,
0.5944567323,
0.2314148992,
0.2424943,
0.3381445706,
0.4358493388,
-0.2951361239,
-0.2969560623,
-0.3772285581,
0.5105433464,
-0.1431284547,
-0.4898710251,
0.6946150064,
0.5643572807,
0.8791168928,
0.0731910393,
0.7869396806,
0.1829980314,
0.3995809257,
-0.2857639194,
0.5071876645,
-0.3927408457,
-0.1956738979,
-0.2210241854,
-1.0089869499,
-0.5669804811,
0.5349186063,
0.0083572734,
-0.442148596,
0.7577077746,
0.4293699861,
-0.1527673155,
0.1265114993,
0.5589574575,
0.0993570015,
0.6201120615,
0.1274475455,
0.6889078617,
-0.8436238766,
0.787501812,
-0.283578217,
-0.2774343193,
-0.2576912045,
-0.977463007,
-0.1625936478,
-0.83414644,
-0.6700344086,
-0.2946577072,
0.1908837557,
0.8111391068,
1.1797355413,
-0.9005618095,
-0.3762963712,
0.1522125453,
-0.3381812871,
-0.1924762726,
-0.1913370639,
0.0433800146,
-0.5324789286,
-0.7346661091,
1.2640587091,
0.5654185414,
-0.01736545,
-0.1424665004,
-0.2069409043,
-0.3250056207,
-0.0204256866,
0.8288105726,
0.166931048,
-0.845236659,
-0.5413977504,
0.1328515261,
0.0524549559,
0.1827685684,
0.3142128885,
-0.6131355762,
0.6522306204,
0.2412816882,
0.5932798982,
0.7356086373,
-0.2360267639,
0.4345161915,
-0.9460560083,
0.254745692,
0.397454679,
0.1301025152,
0.6148604751,
-0.0684955567,
0.5369639993,
-0.0337528847,
-0.7448408604,
-1.031824708,
-0.0102525475,
-0.913517952,
-0.0435862988,
0.9252188206,
-0.0721242577,
0.1082614213,
-0.4464421868,
-0.1690009683,
0.338516891,
-0.2526189983,
0.5031012893,
0.8040418625,
-0.3042961955,
0.2618363202,
-0.9691548347,
0.2435284853,
0.519423902,
-0.6546263695,
-0.1865766644,
0.051609274,
0.2526882589,
0.5314347148,
0.6778945923,
-0.1143795103,
0.2140978277,
-0.1193323955,
0.2872093916,
0.3539066613,
-0.2521017492,
-0.2534672618,
-0.209236294,
0.1454408616,
-0.2481192499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05317v1 | CUED at ProbSum 2023: Hierarchical Ensemble of Summarization Models | 2023-06-08T16:08:10 | 2023-06-08T16:08:10 | Potsawee Manakul, Yassir Fathullah, Adian Liusie, Vyas Raina, Vatsal Raina, Mark Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we consider the challenge of summarizing patients' medical
progress notes in a limited data setting. For the Problem List Summarization
(shared task 1A) at the BioNLP Workshop 2023, we demonstrate that Clinical-T5
fine-tuned to 765 medical clinic notes outperforms other extractive,
abstractive and zero-shot baselines, yielding reasonable baseline systems for
medical note summarization. Further, we introduce Hierarchical Ensemble of
Summarization Models (HESM), consisting of token-level ensembles of diverse
fine-tuned Clinical-T5 models, followed by Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding.
Our HESM approach lead to a considerable summarization performance boost, and
when evaluated on held-out challenge data achieved a ROUGE-L of 32.77, which
was the best-performing system at the top of the shared task leaderboard. | [
-0.0734523982,
-0.2874803841,
0.5798817873,
0.0577238873,
-0.2454936206,
0.2578719854,
0.1187813282,
-0.6920809746,
0.3454541564,
0.4210914075,
-0.5994143486,
-0.889334321,
-0.7334656715,
0.1660406291,
-0.3032081127,
1.5989508629,
0.1229181662,
0.0392195061,
-0.2273984104,
-0.2092200518,
-0.4041694701,
-0.2650072873,
-0.3346068561,
-0.3419808149,
0.5035660863,
0.5137079954,
0.4051808417,
0.6706287861,
1.1441210508,
0.2284502685,
-0.2021049857,
0.049088791,
-0.2399598658,
0.0665141121,
-0.103196457,
-0.4546428621,
-1.1994475126,
-0.2662341893,
0.5778501034,
1.0409014225,
-0.1428483278,
0.367942512,
-0.0937540382,
0.5444429517,
-0.3583562076,
0.1590196788,
-0.2817696929,
0.0933328196,
-0.1700124294,
-0.269269079,
-0.438439846,
-0.2062271237,
0.2382947654,
-0.4405507147,
0.3889636099,
-0.0776485428,
0.6832056046,
0.125433594,
-0.1927881688,
0.0452124327,
-0.4203936756,
0.4914087057,
-0.8077037334,
-0.2117490172,
0.354190737,
0.3929549754,
-0.1006880477,
-0.8543092608,
0.2451546043,
0.1730894595,
-0.043255616,
0.433018446,
-0.0433040783,
0.2712368071,
-0.0174033828,
0.4967536926,
-0.4548003078,
0.1351140887,
-0.5371034741,
-0.1314094216,
0.8318417072,
0.6397354007,
0.0578622222,
-0.0840350837,
-0.1101031527,
0.1078349352,
-0.4339833856,
-0.2002275288,
-0.3594202995,
0.2416432053,
-0.3971398473,
0.3700098395,
-0.1418067813,
0.4417874813,
0.0493889675,
-0.3880929053,
0.2997518182,
-0.6296138763,
-0.2035576403,
-0.0325997509,
0.7695962191,
0.6289797425,
-0.0212104153,
-0.2507311404,
-0.083863683,
-0.1840238124,
0.2145092636,
-0.629993856,
-0.5421569347,
0.5603593588,
-0.7902465463,
-0.5662677288,
-0.1717866808,
-0.8272148967,
-0.2601681054,
0.0888215899,
0.3953967392,
-0.3400017023,
0.0072481502,
-0.0487789214,
-0.3924166262,
-0.408551991,
0.6061214805,
-0.9696888924,
0.7010045052,
0.5600845814,
0.9722694159,
-0.3832345307,
-0.0710950047,
-0.405163914,
0.3552244902,
-0.3167435229,
1.0139300823,
-0.1220751107,
-0.773286581,
-0.2478531152,
0.062534079,
-0.1108882278,
-0.8284564614,
0.5432606339,
0.0654833466,
0.1131150723,
-0.3286598921,
-0.6560293436,
0.2722009718,
0.0625060499,
-0.3915765584,
0.4396207333,
0.1057145745,
-0.8655043244,
0.4462661743,
-0.6125211716,
-0.525929749,
0.1670904011,
-0.1556250751,
-0.7723972797,
0.3478410542,
0.2851921916,
0.6044588685,
0.2475574911,
0.2356380075,
-0.2923737764,
-0.4125194252,
-0.1006544232,
0.049019333,
0.6123290658,
0.1448001713,
0.1125838757,
0.4645060897,
-0.7764126658,
-0.15008834,
0.0380599089,
-0.4243068993,
-0.15379861,
0.1285245717,
-0.0690558404,
-0.0315122306,
0.3016916215,
-0.2969898283,
0.2903272808,
-0.2637341619,
0.3329288661,
0.5640303493,
0.3515357673,
0.2301447839,
-0.8395329118,
0.4898890555,
0.1020319909,
0.0424894057,
-0.6018846631,
-0.530167222,
-0.1171045229,
-0.6750289798,
0.4960421622,
0.7453093529,
-0.1825035959,
0.3299898207,
-0.2929546535,
-0.5102881789,
-0.5884329081,
-0.3558620811,
0.3157817423,
0.5199995041,
0.554965198,
-0.3663830161,
-0.6111794114,
-0.8233631849,
-0.1752242297,
-0.2432830036,
-0.1908714026,
-0.0026548628,
0.6058099866,
0.0249788556,
0.5364130735,
-0.4936894476,
-0.4196848273,
-0.7156737447,
0.262114048,
0.4086769819,
0.5973466635,
0.2578779161,
-0.0586590283,
-0.1476013362,
-0.1173774824,
-0.6979635358,
-0.2029658407,
-0.1738431901,
0.1906953156,
0.0881328955,
0.4777594805,
-0.4448455274,
0.3052920997,
0.2599769831,
-0.1794990152,
0.3485834897,
-0.7967103124,
0.1157088727,
-1.2927844524,
0.218350634,
0.0547866598,
-0.5297336578,
-0.4993523955,
-0.0580032356,
-0.006587964,
0.0246849153,
0.1414150149,
0.1669929773,
-0.3434610963,
-0.3363095522,
-0.1972993016,
-0.0647461042,
-0.2654833198,
0.3187890351,
0.1854586303,
0.1910265386,
0.2084348947,
-0.453165859,
-0.1942212135,
0.4383853078,
-0.1847236902,
0.3441912532,
-0.6525046229,
-0.1890893131,
-0.1730635464,
0.5457570553,
-0.9290969968,
-0.5920034051,
-0.2410393506,
-0.5750446916,
0.3650201559,
0.2126110941,
-0.1887804568,
-0.3688934147,
-0.5056917071,
0.1725306064,
0.7983486056,
0.0956460461,
0.2460596412,
0.551615715,
-0.5984137654,
-0.4053700864,
-0.6283712387,
0.2749777734,
-0.233272627,
-0.2990356386,
0.7936881781,
0.1109911948,
-0.3388003707,
-0.1068190038,
-0.2143602669,
0.1855704486,
0.0679519475,
0.1643266231,
0.350800693,
-0.0985339954,
-0.0681364909,
0.276920557,
-0.1954931915,
0.0483963788,
-0.2839893997,
0.2388121188,
0.0046218233,
-0.0726156309,
-0.7318988442,
0.6282383204,
0.5036719441,
0.0769538954,
0.4551253319,
0.3371082842,
-0.769672811,
0.2707514167,
-0.1202066466,
-0.1181891859,
-0.3160779476,
0.4652061164,
-0.0275483318,
-0.7682502866,
0.8694063425,
-0.0399785638,
0.5583918095,
0.7193577886,
0.7349160314,
-0.5494766831,
1.0998607874,
0.6432062984,
-0.1386445463,
0.2201809287,
-0.2227241844,
-0.0641957819,
-0.4644958079,
-0.4613528252,
-0.7184687853,
-0.3162512481,
-0.6908788681,
-0.1056280583,
0.9412414432,
-0.0556499846,
0.0809686705,
0.2307095975,
-0.2873823643,
0.3169462085,
0.3320059478,
0.3664611578,
0.4880264103,
-0.2347138226,
0.0855587423,
0.0585851781,
-0.8683932424,
-0.390557915,
1.0281410217,
0.5246043205,
0.4888029695,
0.0363150239,
1.0631135702,
0.4836120903,
0.2391232401,
-0.3218692243,
0.6641483307,
-0.5035746098,
-0.5137416124,
-0.2619955242,
-0.2549027503,
-0.9276923537,
0.1701783687,
-0.274541527,
-1.0466058254,
0.1289623976,
0.3838584423,
-0.9846159816,
0.0403921567,
-0.4146134853,
0.8234378099,
0.2105721235,
-0.2467906475,
-0.2474592626,
-1.1480813026,
0.3793811202,
0.2257189602,
0.4221751094,
0.0777662545,
-0.1959819198,
0.7241977453,
-0.5487550497,
0.7592382431,
-0.0208097026,
0.0315455645,
0.0392167494,
-0.0263897777,
0.373237431,
0.0006382076,
0.373664856,
0.0453191996,
0.2803119719,
-0.6966459155,
-0.1039799899,
0.2443785518,
-0.3824778199,
-0.3380542397,
-0.2924494147,
-0.7514462471,
-0.1805414706,
0.0332284197,
0.673740983,
0.7232897282,
-0.1047478393,
-0.0866385102,
0.4943571985,
-0.2559877634,
0.5510014892,
0.1416771859,
0.0437619463,
-0.6322597265,
0.9013761878,
0.1404186785,
0.3792556524,
0.6046347022,
0.1864251196,
-0.090460293,
-1.0224272013,
-0.3946627676,
0.0897724777,
-0.5488556027,
-0.0542744361,
-0.9417073727,
-0.027211722,
-0.5758544803,
-0.3647205532,
-0.115568839,
-0.7509504557,
-0.2079561502,
-0.1320938617,
-0.0438994057,
0.7637870908,
-0.2207333744,
0.2483186573,
-1.2266749144,
0.2689494491,
-0.3858676851,
0.0092760809,
-0.2746878564,
-0.5197518468,
-0.4169082642,
-0.5580589771,
-0.359221518,
-0.8379812837,
0.4650509059,
0.0708371699,
0.461145848,
0.3675074875,
-0.0799607784,
0.805929482,
-0.3003977537,
0.8206829429,
0.2000379711,
-0.6672162414,
0.5750508308,
-0.8893966675,
0.6413190365,
0.7412039638,
0.1202149913,
-0.1833907068,
-0.6530358195,
-0.9774162173,
-0.9478806853,
0.6678568125,
0.0393216535,
-0.4601146281,
0.0298910514,
0.376537621,
0.1375640631,
0.2204549462,
-0.2829363346,
0.1210532263,
0.1292770654,
-0.7598686814,
-0.0703362375,
-0.0891080424,
-0.0689213127,
-0.1824653745,
0.3947587013,
-0.2093267292,
0.4010617137,
0.3642137051,
0.1648570299,
-0.1828850806,
0.2335816026,
0.9367218018,
0.5038143992,
-0.6104770303,
-0.0162216034,
0.3890294433,
-0.6042428613,
-0.1814599037,
0.042754434,
-0.0920910984,
0.0102445977,
1.0596151352,
0.6539274454,
0.1205943674,
-0.6813691258,
0.3506468236,
-0.0430048965,
-0.3759355545,
-0.1039118245,
0.0562084131,
0.0470541827,
0.1911548525,
0.1743456423,
0.4164077342,
0.5053654313,
-0.6468061805,
0.3566788137,
0.0200176835,
-0.3123124242,
-0.5367757678,
0.8354212642,
0.0982149914,
-0.1832155287,
0.1282535642,
0.1212278754,
-0.1167619824,
0.7846599817,
0.6052752733,
0.7202164531,
-0.2113119513,
0.1113193631,
0.5210941434,
0.2299246788,
-0.2534950674,
0.4037331343,
-0.1904650778,
-0.1749256104,
-0.5007759333,
-0.1475951672,
-0.6478753686,
0.0087801302,
-0.7793053985,
0.2734224796,
-0.3960270584,
-0.123027198,
0.158725366,
-0.0867314488,
0.1271888018,
0.2824730873,
-0.1548076421,
1.0361813307,
-0.6589416862,
0.4245579839,
0.6521843672,
-0.0922910646,
-0.3140476644,
0.0502622239,
0.0700590387,
-0.4822950959,
0.0463260785,
-0.0387974642,
0.3731338978,
-0.1468158513,
-0.2237517983,
-0.4530257881,
1.1190848351,
0.119896777,
-0.665495038,
-0.3080967665,
-0.101154536,
0.7585999966,
-0.3888357878,
0.2764259279,
0.6852632761,
0.0131233372,
0.2267633975,
-1.0834215879,
-0.1440458894,
-0.1879956275,
-0.5647409558,
0.2499289513,
-0.6011549234,
0.8722738624,
-0.8379631639,
0.1093688905,
0.3359792829,
0.6190936565,
0.5032749772,
0.7649008632,
0.0967202932,
0.494807303,
0.755658567,
-0.0984982252,
1.2170479298,
0.0003681077,
0.079735592,
1.2153505087,
-0.2210036963,
0.7046531439,
0.1623851657,
-0.2486656904,
0.2689155042,
0.8545781374,
0.3293556273,
0.5824545026,
0.1829256564,
-0.239390403,
-0.3800767064,
0.0539138876,
-0.3483762741,
0.2220606655,
0.4155276716,
-0.4732837081,
-0.3399241865,
-0.2381568402,
0.1935132891,
-0.0381601453,
-0.6334419847,
1.202308774,
0.2361181229,
-0.8373466134,
0.3027073145,
0.0150377676,
0.2466074675,
-0.3738878369,
0.0118469531,
-0.2371039838,
0.5613467693,
-0.389857918,
-0.4687713683,
0.4337843359,
0.1079877093,
-0.0868787318,
-0.071742326,
0.5904657245,
-0.419029057,
-0.4396493733,
-0.2306434959,
0.3351765871,
0.2262600064,
0.3788971007,
-0.2719428539,
-0.1484144628,
-0.2576722205,
0.0023819043,
0.6053630114,
0.2370481789,
-0.2979772687,
0.5079501867,
0.0232094061,
0.1711144596,
-0.3117206693,
0.1375910193,
0.5460406542,
-0.6700226665,
-0.7489771247,
-0.9629487395,
0.6303506494,
-0.1122069135,
-0.4099420309,
0.3332837224,
0.5145367384,
0.4381429553,
-0.0531466566,
0.8763167262,
0.2015576512,
0.7524096966,
-0.471003443,
0.60635221,
-0.5845325589,
0.1513110399,
-0.5238166451,
-0.1595180929,
-0.5607165694,
0.3214432001,
0.1560725272,
-0.0309302732,
0.7488594651,
0.1166041121,
0.3672943115,
0.2531254888,
0.1416065097,
0.1238588765,
0.2625144124,
0.9618595243,
0.4024025798,
-0.4397283196,
0.1675044596,
-0.0840208381,
-0.4346022606,
-0.2590510249,
-0.7576383948,
-0.872503221,
-0.4552085102,
-0.5220085979,
-0.3378397226,
0.292422235,
1.0212266445,
0.598313272,
-1.0068184137,
-0.2372812778,
-0.1199975759,
-0.2220217884,
-0.4895523489,
-0.0478191227,
0.4915588796,
-0.2776798606,
-0.5145944953,
0.2438955456,
0.6443834901,
0.2769913971,
0.1705364585,
0.1608985066,
0.1437482983,
-0.1159869581,
0.3537357748,
0.0157352984,
-0.2355079651,
-0.1220467612,
0.0658210218,
-0.0065089464,
0.013511749,
0.8696913123,
-0.6220460534,
-0.0448687635,
0.5987609625,
0.4771690071,
0.4677465558,
0.0733966529,
0.573848784,
-0.5845442414,
-0.2462018132,
0.2992166281,
0.4444918036,
-0.0291013084,
-0.2610165179,
0.5252389908,
0.4878529608,
-0.5094095469,
-0.9964326024,
-0.1642691344,
-1.1461508274,
-0.2460622936,
0.5221518874,
-0.2784189582,
-0.1104938313,
-0.2530010045,
-0.1411304921,
0.2885533571,
-0.2808202505,
1.0012518167,
0.5319398642,
-0.5010028481,
-0.2795585394,
-0.5214363337,
0.5428940654,
0.4353746474,
-1.326343894,
-0.028858006,
0.5086674094,
0.1171430573,
0.1197700724,
1.2064455748,
-0.4997440875,
0.5200667977,
-0.0630344227,
-0.1593819112,
0.0224360693,
-0.717505455,
-0.377992928,
0.6119283438,
-0.1478303224,
-0.2710326612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05307v1 | Are fairness metric scores enough to assess discrimination biases in machine learning? | 2023-06-08T15:56:57 | 2023-06-08T15:56:57 | Fanny Jourdan, Laurent Risser, Jean-Michel Loubes, Nicholas Asher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, stat.ML | This paper presents novel experiments shedding light on the shortcomings of
current metrics for assessing biases of gender discrimination made by machine
learning algorithms on textual data. We focus on the Bios dataset, and our
learning task is to predict the occupation of individuals, based on their
biography. Such prediction tasks are common in commercial Natural Language
Processing (NLP) applications such as automatic job recommendations. We address
an important limitation of theoretical discussions dealing with group-wise
fairness metrics: they focus on large datasets, although the norm in many
industrial NLP applications is to use small to reasonably large linguistic
datasets for which the main practical constraint is to get a good prediction
accuracy. We then question how reliable are different popular measures of bias
when the size of the training set is simply sufficient to learn reasonably
accurate predictions. Our experiments sample the Bios dataset and learn more
than 200 models on different sample sizes. This allows us to statistically
study our results and to confirm that common gender bias indices provide
diverging and sometimes unreliable results when applied to relatively small
training and test samples. This highlights the crucial importance of variance
calculations for providing sound results in this field. | [
-0.3043860197,
-0.3061854839,
0.5155940652,
0.3112319708,
0.2153507769,
-0.2313412875,
0.0667009652,
-0.4682983458,
-0.191772595,
0.0658405945,
-0.5473908782,
-0.4108200073,
-0.7968398929,
0.2135848701,
-0.3326068521,
1.0954304934,
0.3797923028,
0.7464627028,
-0.4298379719,
-0.5949939489,
-0.770403564,
-0.2912850082,
-0.4954547286,
-0.0429923125,
0.4115796089,
0.199675858,
0.5129239559,
0.5829111934,
0.4690886736,
0.2873279154,
-0.1311119348,
-0.0047190832,
-0.3384330869,
0.1450350881,
-0.2757250667,
-0.7620059252,
-0.2962525487,
0.5986014009,
0.7345022559,
1.3277151585,
0.1109304801,
0.558732748,
0.1717499346,
0.8579679132,
-0.7322107553,
0.0029816385,
-0.6676328778,
0.6183646321,
-0.2965175211,
0.240372926,
-0.3891372085,
-0.5545222163,
0.0933586657,
-0.240407154,
0.5855709314,
0.3667702973,
0.3742934465,
0.3468963504,
-0.3472245336,
-0.1716418862,
-0.4804109633,
1.3225097656,
-0.4570299089,
0.4614036679,
0.5136321783,
0.5670149326,
-0.1030692756,
-0.317399323,
-0.2363696396,
-0.0100420276,
-0.1395315826,
-0.0763803646,
-0.2085691243,
-0.144548595,
0.6297061443,
0.2685821354,
-0.2705202997,
0.380022794,
-0.6115821004,
-0.1819187105,
0.5022289157,
0.2792155445,
0.0222940687,
-0.2503033876,
0.0608066022,
0.0247091446,
-0.2459675074,
0.2162253112,
0.7277359366,
0.4238473773,
0.0072717089,
0.3151918948,
-0.0261576865,
0.5136997104,
0.0334921256,
0.2223075926,
0.4373369813,
-0.0897834897,
-0.1851394027,
-0.1915932596,
0.781221509,
0.4315252006,
0.1873413622,
-0.3540006578,
-0.0416614525,
0.0769886225,
0.393540889,
-0.5810786486,
0.17803891,
0.0986877009,
-0.6690635085,
-0.2764906883,
0.2052932084,
-1.2816474438,
-0.5737298727,
-0.0739024207,
0.0522258431,
0.103833206,
0.0263343547,
-0.0810509771,
-0.6114619374,
0.1225197613,
0.1991689354,
-0.8171939254,
0.3389966488,
0.6451092958,
0.7190369964,
-0.3172167838,
-0.2675388157,
-0.789210856,
-0.3764201403,
-0.3530544639,
0.1388379633,
-0.4909500182,
-0.3052010238,
-0.108525604,
-0.0150558036,
-0.0695597008,
-0.6896742582,
0.6393655539,
-0.1719260663,
0.45814538,
-0.4032709897,
-0.5082579255,
-0.0774899125,
0.0350466147,
-0.6744242907,
0.6301624775,
0.2255776972,
-1.1180199385,
0.8382349014,
-0.8975206614,
-0.3337094784,
-0.3341144621,
-0.4594448209,
-0.7553318739,
0.1085847095,
0.0253790952,
0.4868933558,
-0.0468236096,
0.3534934223,
-0.8235188127,
-0.4752029479,
0.3846600652,
-0.5622057319,
1.0656075478,
0.1051702127,
-0.6913198233,
-0.3533171117,
-0.4014348686,
-0.1059557796,
-0.1910798401,
-0.025552744,
-0.1123551726,
0.1071273759,
-0.238905549,
0.1147250235,
-0.0687642395,
-0.7493007779,
-0.4520433247,
-0.2807336152,
0.0738117993,
1.167304039,
-0.7106585503,
0.6709042788,
-0.4038196206,
0.4818887115,
-0.1285188049,
0.2741294205,
0.4878173172,
-0.6295448542,
-0.5165995955,
-0.4071071446,
0.7644864321,
0.4221899211,
-0.1785181761,
0.5784143806,
-0.0179995764,
-0.3602563441,
-0.7674444318,
0.0703545213,
0.4518958628,
0.5094531775,
0.2077495307,
-0.579210341,
-0.6434161663,
-1.0131695271,
-0.7741594911,
-0.0582128391,
-0.3974473178,
0.5299322009,
0.6490551233,
-0.2052065581,
1.2229231596,
-0.0787901506,
-0.3371954262,
0.281607002,
0.1387792677,
0.3074942231,
0.5220549107,
0.8530476689,
-0.79909724,
-0.1216349229,
-0.298243016,
-0.93531847,
-0.1646758169,
0.5127825141,
-0.1661975235,
0.0463261455,
0.2070663422,
-0.2007206231,
0.59331429,
0.504814744,
-0.6483394504,
0.6044746041,
0.1671378762,
0.2750873864,
-0.3639670908,
0.2024876624,
0.2450390756,
-0.5937374234,
-0.2032555491,
-0.1645977199,
-0.2927768528,
0.2804629803,
-0.4687174261,
0.7170642018,
0.0836399198,
-0.5524617434,
-0.0933483094,
-0.1269626915,
-0.0940129906,
0.4255536199,
-0.3929191828,
0.5492833853,
0.275106281,
-0.8215280771,
-0.0675292835,
0.2573765218,
-0.2434278727,
0.8916817307,
-0.3695423305,
0.152480334,
-0.3503601551,
0.5106227994,
-0.7612816691,
-0.0941748321,
0.1874840409,
-0.6078339219,
-0.322414875,
0.088116616,
-0.1509835869,
-0.4645617604,
-0.427508831,
0.5301770568,
0.7215170264,
-0.6200833917,
0.4883523881,
0.7234576344,
-0.0118437782,
-0.9255716205,
-0.8927969337,
-0.5164673328,
-0.5257471204,
-0.35649845,
0.0975729451,
-0.1255767196,
-0.5161563754,
-0.180406183,
-0.0023715633,
-0.1999421567,
0.2910004258,
0.4363796711,
0.1872646064,
0.0968463346,
0.2016121745,
0.1616192758,
0.0491435938,
0.2813987136,
-0.2300018072,
0.1118420437,
-0.1839041114,
-0.3231973946,
-0.4317478538,
0.2872180641,
0.3551528752,
0.198620975,
0.6854886413,
1.0684649944,
-0.4615522027,
-0.150687322,
-0.4911264777,
-0.0789198577,
-0.4329044521,
0.4888447821,
-0.0185195096,
-1.0282891989,
0.589335382,
0.2105683684,
0.3870889843,
0.7898045778,
0.3439014554,
-0.5021606684,
1.2976299524,
0.6970230341,
-0.2402121574,
0.3384578526,
0.033990398,
0.041464027,
-0.5713068247,
-0.0121319136,
-1.0056865215,
-0.6813321114,
-0.9726126194,
-0.2378158718,
0.330383122,
-0.3188861907,
-0.6138514876,
-0.454218924,
-0.4058731198,
0.5663325787,
0.6139076352,
0.0276886225,
0.0181923788,
-0.0254993066,
-0.0321798623,
-0.422607094,
-0.5421263576,
-0.5846409798,
1.3033374548,
0.5749660134,
0.2381934077,
-0.2203559279,
0.3470028341,
0.8738206029,
0.5394155979,
-0.3450988233,
0.28989622,
-0.8495673537,
-0.8118641973,
-0.3260430992,
-0.9094212055,
-0.905393064,
0.2621481717,
-0.3136514425,
-0.7138927579,
0.3512360156,
0.0830767229,
-0.0191433523,
0.4758696854,
-0.5506542325,
0.8769387007,
-0.0896946266,
-0.2960748374,
-0.0167595539,
-0.6587349772,
0.4372841418,
-0.1359271407,
0.6198387146,
-0.2335186154,
0.3355015218,
1.3835437298,
-0.1519095749,
0.8473665714,
-0.6482977867,
0.2022392899,
-0.0302875917,
-0.0055909506,
-0.2870801687,
-0.0059419037,
-0.6577205062,
0.5666677952,
-0.053435158,
-0.6616874337,
-0.4368084371,
0.2988926172,
-0.6660302281,
-0.3334282637,
-0.3734080195,
-0.3723662198,
-0.4011169672,
0.1049784422,
0.0941200107,
-0.0273070801,
-0.4268385172,
0.2821785212,
0.587151289,
-0.3829511702,
0.0185372587,
0.3260992169,
-0.2104227394,
-0.1695799083,
0.7036129236,
-0.0505977198,
0.0182009842,
0.0202324688,
0.2045846134,
-0.2950312793,
-0.1323514432,
-0.4235725105,
-0.0104385763,
-0.5648736954,
-0.2327917516,
-0.519767344,
-0.0783377662,
-0.2704822421,
0.0441384166,
-0.2176610082,
-0.3343453705,
-0.1568577141,
-0.1197671294,
0.0129668349,
0.7579136491,
-0.1623792946,
0.116210945,
-0.3070995808,
0.4562113285,
0.3855206966,
0.4975813031,
0.0648431033,
-0.57598418,
-0.161267519,
0.2378459573,
-0.4238130748,
-0.5898751616,
0.0903470144,
0.0336731561,
0.6059042215,
0.2572577,
-0.1918452531,
0.0221876949,
-0.5563845634,
0.7526128888,
0.2903310359,
-0.9549103975,
0.3549818993,
-0.3241460323,
-0.1632270217,
0.8138554692,
0.4130687416,
-0.456074357,
-0.7479751706,
-0.6264030933,
-0.3268409073,
0.7900080681,
0.2250001431,
-0.007825614,
0.0747121125,
0.4006973207,
0.7556361556,
0.4196792245,
-0.6762894392,
-0.3196491897,
0.0610276796,
-0.5238835216,
-0.0897355005,
0.2018567026,
0.0179404225,
-0.4474386871,
0.4412539005,
-0.1140420064,
0.3749394417,
-0.1173683628,
0.091135554,
0.1250951737,
0.2970708609,
0.0491712652,
0.6302102804,
-0.2841717005,
-0.0368361697,
0.4953121841,
-0.5522853136,
0.1634891182,
-0.0294146705,
-0.1752999276,
0.3330367208,
-0.047372032,
0.5946204662,
-0.2370434701,
-0.5624006391,
0.8127564192,
-0.4979113936,
-0.4458599985,
-0.0595107377,
0.2396739572,
-0.2771145999,
0.3257582784,
0.1991222799,
0.3516395688,
0.4089939296,
-0.38530761,
0.1968199164,
0.6129467487,
-0.8698333502,
0.0176816601,
0.844896853,
0.3446167409,
-0.3045555055,
0.6576638222,
-0.2991583347,
-0.4928100705,
0.8723988533,
0.0829119533,
0.7711319327,
-0.1205289513,
0.2705259025,
0.2382924408,
0.1367290169,
-0.2724871635,
-0.254509151,
0.1421904415,
-0.5594491363,
0.0010568018,
-0.879907012,
-0.4923104048,
-0.0562945455,
-0.5837952495,
0.136713624,
-0.4812886119,
-0.4818635583,
-0.0005083841,
-0.0348228961,
-1.1743412018,
0.4903084338,
-0.0493696481,
0.5825291276,
-1.1464196444,
0.0120136868,
0.2296042591,
-0.1477363259,
-0.2509453595,
-0.0900198594,
-0.1015496179,
-0.5962302685,
0.7170982957,
0.4940145612,
0.0043384847,
-0.6409907341,
-0.5386930704,
-0.226018697,
0.7283256054,
0.7172545791,
-0.4280745685,
-0.0153829744,
0.3908532858,
0.4487147331,
-0.2902987003,
0.6782951951,
0.8083254695,
0.5217481256,
-0.766942203,
-1.0069582462,
-0.1473305374,
-0.2524419725,
-0.184011668,
-0.1478304714,
-0.5399952531,
0.8250416517,
-0.0072297216,
0.1409678608,
0.0300527439,
0.6667889953,
0.36191383,
0.8881105185,
0.9985187054,
0.2620745301,
1.3219463825,
-0.1334599406,
1.0961220264,
0.442905128,
0.3632427752,
0.7860655785,
-0.0931460038,
0.4282478988,
0.3123441935,
-0.649763763,
0.4732497334,
0.6582568288,
-0.0891803578,
0.1021848917,
0.4834994674,
0.0141185401,
0.0223684441,
-0.2276514918,
-0.3072722852,
0.3782062232,
0.0976180062,
-0.5675703287,
0.2062449306,
0.1279218048,
-0.1237924993,
0.2123999149,
-0.4014390707,
0.2972485423,
0.2186685652,
-0.4187491536,
-0.0797735974,
0.2458287477,
1.1632899046,
-0.2311237901,
0.0130960699,
-0.2964520156,
0.1480720341,
-0.3184002936,
-0.6001537442,
0.2762702107,
0.3313373923,
-0.5787370801,
-0.0568415858,
0.5228196979,
-0.1298462003,
-0.6774711609,
0.2170705944,
0.5947666764,
0.2209688574,
0.240927875,
-0.5990017056,
-0.4202586114,
0.0715649351,
0.2362435311,
0.4186551273,
0.3086104095,
0.0478094481,
0.5231399536,
0.3075533807,
0.0529090762,
0.3189646304,
0.0687122047,
0.0914399922,
-0.6345368624,
-0.8842852116,
-0.7856885195,
0.2196135074,
-0.1947423369,
-0.2260757387,
0.648628056,
0.4552378058,
0.8278945684,
0.0603062324,
0.8552225232,
0.1618289053,
0.835301578,
-0.4462497234,
0.7330781221,
-0.6297249198,
0.1058749855,
-0.4367528856,
-0.879483521,
-0.2334424853,
0.5759990811,
-0.3865623772,
0.7937476635,
0.5108488202,
0.336147815,
-0.1791879088,
0.3679174185,
0.1038455218,
0.0208143853,
0.2634589076,
0.3820044398,
0.6832081676,
-0.4087056518,
0.2740678489,
0.0765746459,
-0.2850708663,
-0.2246283889,
-0.7102586627,
-0.8230446577,
-0.2329294384,
-0.1570752114,
-0.4089908898,
0.2652505636,
0.4592953026,
0.6721460223,
-0.6848211288,
-0.2448302507,
0.0200921167,
0.5296401978,
-0.2082479596,
-0.2815952003,
0.2086564302,
-0.3217200041,
-0.8913046122,
-0.244042322,
-0.0966530144,
-0.3761816621,
-0.3602572381,
-0.3114290833,
0.1843256056,
-0.152745381,
0.2431836277,
0.1218006089,
-0.2614577115,
-0.2192334086,
-0.4147177041,
-0.0973699465,
0.036038775,
0.7251604199,
-0.7700573206,
0.2217511684,
0.3250045478,
0.8226314187,
0.0965880603,
-0.2126877159,
0.5966282487,
-0.7934708595,
0.0497884229,
0.3399998546,
0.4388568401,
0.4790732861,
-0.2474881709,
0.533356607,
0.2687806487,
-0.6413626075,
-1.0095399618,
0.0660785213,
-0.5293439031,
-0.2648291588,
0.8940977454,
-0.0190583803,
-0.4542853236,
-0.1676568538,
0.0927195624,
0.2428610325,
-0.3958516121,
0.9528709054,
0.5641602874,
0.0609403998,
0.6668030024,
-0.9752887487,
0.5805032849,
0.8300634623,
-0.6686221957,
0.0351244621,
0.3789900541,
0.2363943011,
0.0399234556,
0.6886607409,
-0.2917455733,
0.5410456657,
-0.2098316699,
-0.1295478046,
0.4564234912,
-0.1834127605,
-0.2977519631,
0.10612721,
-0.1717379689,
-0.2886215746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05301v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05301v2 | ToolAlpaca: Generalized Tool Learning for Language Models with 3000 Simulated Cases | 2023-06-08T15:46:32 | 2023-09-07T12:20:45 | Qiaoyu Tang, Ziliang Deng, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Qiao Liang, Boxi Cao, Le Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Enabling large language models to utilize real-world tools effectively is
crucial for achieving embodied intelligence. Existing approaches to tool
learning have either primarily relied on extremely large language models, such
as GPT-4, to attain generalized tool-use abilities in a zero-shot manner, or
utilized supervised learning to train limited scopes of tools on compact
models. However, it remains uncertain whether smaller language models can
achieve generalized tool-use abilities without tool-specific training. To
address this question, this paper introduces ToolAlpaca, a novel framework
designed to automatically generate a diverse tool-use corpus and learn
generalized tool-use abilities on compact language models with minimal human
intervention. Specifically, ToolAlpaca first automatically creates a highly
diversified tool-use corpus by building a multi-agent simulation environment.
The corpus contains 3938 tool-use instances from more than 400 real-world tool
APIs spanning 50 distinct categories. Subsequently, the constructed corpus is
employed to fine-tune compact language models, resulting in two models, namely
ToolAlpaca-7B and ToolAlpaca-13B, respectively. Finally, we evaluate the
ability of these models to utilize previously unseen tools without specific
training. Experimental results demonstrate that ToolAlpaca achieves effective
generalized tool-use capabilities comparable to those of extremely large
language models like GPT-3.5, demonstrating that learning generalized tool-use
ability is feasible for compact language models. | [
-0.3215028048,
-0.9653606415,
0.65606004,
0.0449446738,
-0.4678783417,
0.2323045284,
-0.2735234201,
-0.4675460756,
0.1966936141,
0.2686328888,
-0.4788730145,
-0.6986053586,
-0.5045252442,
-0.0361329317,
-0.5007882118,
0.8015621305,
0.2151577324,
0.0446596444,
0.1358096898,
-0.2511816025,
-0.5588546991,
-0.4680744112,
-0.3301788568,
-0.1461869329,
0.4673205912,
0.4013362825,
0.9364910126,
0.5470314026,
0.0396878906,
0.3650589883,
0.4236485362,
0.0111969449,
-0.3461662233,
-0.360255003,
-0.2089481354,
-0.5250747204,
-0.5016397238,
0.21301274,
0.4401262105,
0.8748860359,
-0.1894406527,
0.3183821142,
-0.1818166673,
-0.1973369718,
-0.6347907186,
0.0436523445,
-0.9704306722,
-0.0506753996,
-0.048294019,
0.1415226609,
-0.3059841096,
-0.1819188446,
0.1761992872,
-0.881172955,
0.4649315774,
-0.1878322214,
0.7421605587,
0.2086642981,
-0.2470227331,
-0.501185596,
-0.7128328085,
0.874551475,
-0.4333157837,
0.4260788858,
0.485576421,
0.5361803174,
-0.0114086242,
-0.7684235573,
-0.7506560087,
-0.2641474009,
0.0912574977,
-0.1004193202,
-0.1536843926,
-0.0496198051,
0.3206665516,
-0.0787620991,
-0.640062511,
0.2267726064,
-0.451300323,
-0.1415089071,
0.3917303979,
0.1278670579,
0.3360673487,
0.2524752319,
0.0672923103,
-0.5165444613,
-0.665096879,
-0.0005378276,
0.4325408041,
0.4149203598,
-0.1918097138,
0.3222746551,
0.1975584626,
0.5626811385,
-0.1610124409,
-0.4984288514,
0.4547450542,
-0.0632862076,
-0.6073259115,
-0.3936825693,
0.5703158975,
-0.3201223314,
0.130294174,
-0.7175285816,
-0.1813317984,
0.0769258365,
0.7033765316,
-0.764198184,
-0.0838123485,
0.0951538235,
-0.0819862112,
-0.3753493428,
-0.1366775632,
-0.5686721802,
-0.2166281044,
-0.2910676897,
0.5464134812,
-0.3176814318,
-0.4121429026,
0.1861525774,
-0.0222238153,
0.5502431393,
0.3189282715,
-0.7924858928,
0.3930136561,
0.5376142263,
0.9385518432,
-0.1547161192,
-0.440616101,
-0.8522256613,
0.0812768042,
-0.4592627585,
0.7302193642,
-0.8879068494,
-0.7566149831,
0.0658719167,
0.2154848129,
0.0231224317,
-0.4942585826,
0.3434580266,
-0.4590589702,
0.1647598296,
0.0008690687,
-0.1348907351,
-0.4602145553,
0.1331811994,
-0.6292412281,
0.6957780719,
0.332488507,
-0.289416641,
0.5925014019,
-0.5845731497,
-0.4434837997,
0.0247916486,
-0.388005048,
-0.5755218863,
0.1947490871,
0.1262409538,
0.6151830554,
-0.2916350067,
0.4910863638,
-0.6793193817,
-0.488333106,
-0.2431103587,
-0.1823634505,
0.6635422111,
-0.0025055432,
-0.2776206136,
0.2830060124,
-0.6784470081,
-0.1104499325,
0.4339129925,
-0.0565644577,
-0.2396086901,
-0.3030461371,
0.1090335846,
0.2357732356,
-0.0356359556,
-0.5892912149,
0.3651064336,
-0.645252645,
0.1096941829,
0.5651852489,
-0.275357604,
0.6964873075,
-0.0739524961,
0.7143905163,
-0.2995779216,
0.0385859832,
0.1967069656,
-0.3220051229,
-0.5707976818,
-0.263277024,
0.3522219062,
0.6297819018,
-0.7689043283,
0.3911756575,
-0.0854559317,
-0.8306022286,
-0.2955027223,
0.3399892151,
0.3845064342,
0.1347934008,
0.3159437776,
-0.6249126792,
-0.3107182682,
-0.7869944572,
0.0190700833,
-0.0946123526,
-0.4039163589,
0.3134808838,
0.4801900685,
-0.2470647395,
0.9815910459,
-0.4189788997,
-0.3034679592,
-0.5979989767,
0.1853253543,
0.097313337,
0.3390532434,
0.8722966909,
-0.6183002591,
-0.1521014422,
0.0151192844,
-0.5917409658,
-0.0210993737,
-0.2896166742,
-0.0397479162,
-0.0623438545,
0.3915130496,
-0.5166038871,
0.373562336,
0.5213893056,
-0.1742002368,
0.749894619,
-0.4143739939,
-0.4636612833,
-1.014852047,
0.3496745229,
-0.1074154899,
-0.1857602,
-0.716376245,
0.13528952,
0.1076166257,
-0.2211775035,
-0.6175484061,
0.9501700401,
-0.4408752918,
-0.2368818521,
-0.4880702496,
0.2048166692,
-0.2674029171,
0.7334371805,
0.1341747493,
0.9036388397,
0.4760782421,
-0.5607253909,
0.0158096533,
0.1075805649,
0.0187760051,
0.1455357224,
-0.8116858602,
0.3561851978,
0.0733355656,
-0.0312593617,
-0.4498816431,
-0.2857910097,
0.1234630793,
-0.0670851544,
0.2771914005,
-0.1157096177,
-0.694599092,
-0.2120879591,
-0.142553851,
0.1750867367,
0.6124676466,
-0.4773280621,
1.2042862177,
0.6926986575,
-0.1873432398,
-0.6613716483,
-0.2535498142,
-0.0320902281,
-0.2720338404,
-0.2786636353,
0.0992118567,
-0.1936936229,
0.0949788988,
-0.2776952088,
0.0573877469,
-0.1507723778,
0.3436635435,
0.4201497436,
0.2133435756,
0.2233669907,
0.6420607567,
0.2471716255,
0.1274130046,
-0.194830671,
0.0815787241,
0.8356896043,
-0.3114590943,
-0.6010648012,
0.0548897795,
0.2416717857,
0.2525825799,
-0.3463580608,
0.5082979202,
0.9920978546,
-0.1829755455,
-0.3759747446,
-0.6161251664,
-0.3168696761,
-0.4824289382,
0.5841532946,
-0.5348489881,
-0.9320473671,
0.5285125375,
-0.3866951466,
0.4025545418,
0.056415502,
0.8221344948,
0.6257808208,
0.9898898602,
1.16700387,
-0.3367370665,
0.4501669109,
-0.4038645327,
0.0907312036,
-0.4807773829,
0.0701737255,
-0.5359897614,
-0.0978794396,
-0.2434844971,
-0.6291040182,
0.1750146896,
0.0622341745,
-0.2670260668,
0.5485935807,
-0.3486500382,
0.6451799273,
0.522482276,
-0.1392164528,
0.2024782598,
-0.0686852783,
-0.4995845854,
0.639529705,
-0.6216173768,
-0.7398633957,
1.3881267309,
0.2547471821,
0.3661901951,
0.008144049,
0.6384975314,
0.1188425869,
0.4840164185,
-0.9148847461,
0.5678437948,
0.132320106,
-0.3327481449,
-0.2630844116,
-0.0680059418,
-1.0753759146,
0.3925804198,
-0.3165759444,
-0.7891783714,
0.141761288,
0.0281383153,
-0.349917978,
0.2812206745,
-0.9663704038,
0.8988656402,
0.0016373992,
-0.273073107,
-0.3234165013,
-0.6496371031,
0.2545378506,
-0.3863907754,
0.3178696334,
-0.1065444052,
-0.1961402297,
0.3685113788,
-0.0862621665,
1.2244274616,
-0.2485958189,
-0.1636311859,
0.1203121915,
0.2991940081,
0.6445846558,
0.149614051,
0.1251029223,
0.0297359675,
0.0347624123,
-0.4801380634,
-0.5202319026,
0.3478421271,
-0.9552191496,
-0.5466216207,
-0.1990460157,
-0.5905838609,
-0.4499917328,
0.3679201603,
-0.1265657991,
0.5418655276,
-0.6552535892,
-0.0810736194,
0.3012548387,
-0.2344278991,
0.4582720697,
0.632299304,
-0.1971752197,
-0.0322243944,
0.9141346812,
-0.0249146949,
0.0927688405,
-0.0295940135,
0.010628934,
-0.0514495932,
-0.7044664621,
-0.5849399567,
0.4620748758,
-0.5719013214,
-0.1246468425,
-0.9068801999,
0.1775300056,
-0.1499614567,
-0.3251002431,
-0.2386849523,
-0.2796761394,
-0.3227921724,
-0.1369740069,
-0.0511775389,
0.733025372,
0.1059713364,
0.4588088095,
-0.7030221224,
0.2780870497,
0.7089365721,
0.3087407649,
0.0235268585,
-0.2342745066,
-0.1434176415,
-0.0349390246,
-0.4162210524,
-0.6616097689,
0.5633639693,
0.4039323032,
0.6734434366,
0.3517257273,
-0.0286834612,
0.4902337193,
-0.6175951958,
0.6426872611,
-0.1067094281,
-0.9428034425,
0.2758329213,
-0.3413808942,
0.4934129119,
0.3884878755,
0.444330126,
-0.2507270873,
-0.7651257515,
-0.8643253446,
-0.5747676492,
0.6458168626,
0.0639644638,
0.4069435,
-0.0804019868,
0.1544876099,
0.50916785,
0.2580294311,
-0.5675798655,
0.3968347609,
-0.4032209814,
-0.2229966074,
-0.0360224061,
0.1570330858,
-0.1975366622,
-0.0179490056,
0.7347971201,
-0.7205758095,
0.0832576975,
-0.1869342774,
-0.4503079355,
0.2035574466,
0.3369346559,
0.4952707291,
0.8026732802,
-0.1386029571,
0.0334280618,
0.652033329,
-0.7394245267,
0.0884210467,
-0.0256169997,
0.0841858611,
-0.2360046357,
0.2371691912,
0.6727045178,
0.2063497603,
-1.174990654,
0.5663682818,
-0.2370916158,
-0.2258082479,
-0.4572798014,
0.3314906061,
0.3569402099,
0.3143559098,
0.2039600015,
-0.1488738954,
0.181330353,
-0.5569027066,
0.1590376943,
0.6838480234,
-0.4174905419,
-0.5667162538,
0.3650219142,
0.0431335084,
-0.0354425274,
0.2615427375,
-0.610198617,
-0.0757321343,
0.5286861658,
0.5333700776,
0.9124635458,
-0.1953350455,
0.4399936497,
0.1995200068,
0.2417166382,
-0.0781882927,
-0.0104334224,
-0.2171002179,
-0.7652906179,
-0.3913979232,
-0.7520491481,
-0.5851273537,
0.1356444657,
-0.2057006806,
0.3441579044,
-0.6263055205,
-0.1099973992,
-0.1330102086,
0.0155990347,
-0.9905931354,
-0.0495469272,
-0.2719237804,
0.7813955545,
-0.9326038361,
1.3071097136,
0.7136613727,
-0.4625329971,
-1.185079217,
-0.1794236451,
0.1203696355,
-0.9216239452,
0.2666805089,
0.2895514667,
-0.3365396261,
0.0244032443,
-0.656275928,
-0.5416097641,
1.2205034494,
0.6315891743,
-0.1235282645,
-0.2273099869,
0.0899650156,
0.5663866997,
-0.5931779742,
0.3955186903,
0.6911177039,
0.1144701019,
0.1898607463,
-1.1666511297,
0.0593874939,
-0.3327642381,
-0.0035929061,
0.0399890319,
-0.4661646485,
0.6728175282,
-0.2522157133,
-0.4775125682,
0.0536229424,
0.3974960148,
0.3104501665,
-0.0321675874,
0.6725789905,
0.488484323,
0.6154025197,
0.1239085346,
0.9036923647,
0.0006977288,
0.1930955648,
1.0457500219,
-0.4443383515,
0.7542014122,
0.1070792153,
0.0317440517,
0.4780740738,
0.1657981128,
0.019121835,
0.3062660992,
-0.0119726816,
-0.1995286793,
-0.5622722507,
-0.0171127077,
-0.0820234716,
0.8860818744,
0.411005199,
-0.1054917872,
-0.4424307048,
0.3046934605,
0.2120843679,
-0.018931713,
-0.0924126133,
0.9532994628,
-0.0192584246,
-0.268874675,
0.6086146832,
-0.0104581853,
0.6655070782,
-0.8431859016,
-0.1234013438,
0.1390387565,
0.0152096404,
0.2863005698,
-0.3187946975,
0.3612983227,
-0.0489252582,
0.1830568761,
0.1901011765,
0.6957845688,
-0.2681301534,
-0.6317570806,
0.3598820567,
0.8217197061,
0.0937601402,
-0.1559699774,
-0.572801888,
-0.0655415654,
-0.2812618315,
-0.1806369722,
0.7230544686,
0.2598340511,
-0.14139314,
0.8127349019,
0.7249436378,
0.0742846951,
-0.1763018519,
0.156482622,
1.0616190434,
-0.4894670546,
-0.5246192813,
-0.3584451377,
0.1512935311,
-0.2042984515,
-0.0249152724,
0.3845264018,
0.3114187419,
0.9851821065,
-0.2732198834,
0.8825834394,
-0.1015726253,
0.6462605596,
-0.3525497317,
0.5955173969,
-0.4964235127,
0.187135905,
-0.2468105853,
-0.9029929638,
-0.3783646822,
0.5692203045,
-0.4419315159,
0.0523425601,
0.48180902,
0.8317481875,
-0.5104139447,
-0.0804501697,
0.5635528564,
-0.185171321,
0.5862324238,
0.5250053406,
0.0606395267,
0.0122931786,
0.7149662375,
-0.3139408529,
-0.2443499863,
-0.1019481868,
-0.7923748493,
-1.1166064739,
-0.6392259002,
0.1210537329,
0.26648736,
-0.0215008538,
1.1038091183,
0.8617280722,
-0.6436505318,
-0.3181966543,
-0.009409396,
-0.0618325546,
-0.1860188842,
-0.1314892769,
0.4349593222,
-0.5723674893,
-0.889078021,
0.4982351065,
0.1930956393,
0.1086030006,
-0.3683515489,
-0.0180762038,
-0.0255698115,
0.1525731832,
0.6005210876,
0.5438694954,
-0.5748735666,
-0.5727331042,
-0.0688354746,
0.1365039349,
-0.1561607867,
0.8549748659,
-1.3031126261,
0.4632841349,
0.0954575092,
0.6448676586,
0.3058467805,
-0.2001604587,
0.673812449,
-1.0036377907,
0.7367697358,
0.2288603336,
0.3644292653,
0.2135412842,
0.0211531632,
0.6281072497,
0.0189604852,
-0.3365443945,
-0.7329082489,
0.3448378146,
-0.9677191377,
-0.3663365245,
0.9671084881,
-0.1326783746,
-0.1373513341,
-0.5310092568,
-0.4667609334,
0.3124061525,
-0.45436427,
0.8404070139,
0.3177740574,
0.2177881002,
-0.1221055016,
-0.7049307823,
0.3836357594,
0.1538437158,
-0.8377348781,
0.0750928819,
0.2961897552,
0.3213705122,
0.2915394306,
0.563067615,
-0.008722988,
0.4549900293,
0.0105914986,
0.1750839055,
-0.3910695016,
-0.3606918156,
-0.1048231721,
0.4959580302,
0.2411278933,
0.2479030192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05278v1 | Revisit Few-shot Intent Classification with PLMs: Direct Fine-tuning vs. Continual Pre-training | 2023-06-08T15:26:52 | 2023-06-08T15:26:52 | Haode Zhang, Haowen Liang, Liming Zhan, Xiao-Ming Wu, Albert Y. S. Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the task of few-shot intent detection, which involves training a
deep learning model to classify utterances based on their underlying intents
using only a small amount of labeled data. The current approach to address this
problem is through continual pre-training, i.e., fine-tuning pre-trained
language models (PLMs) on external resources (e.g., conversational corpora,
public intent detection datasets, or natural language understanding datasets)
before using them as utterance encoders for training an intent classifier. In
this paper, we show that continual pre-training may not be essential, since the
overfitting problem of PLMs on this task may not be as serious as expected.
Specifically, we find that directly fine-tuning PLMs on only a handful of
labeled examples already yields decent results compared to methods that employ
continual pre-training, and the performance gap diminishes rapidly as the
number of labeled data increases. To maximize the utilization of the limited
available data, we propose a context augmentation method and leverage
sequential self-distillation to boost performance. Comprehensive experiments on
real-world benchmarks show that given only two or more labeled samples per
class, direct fine-tuning outperforms many strong baselines that utilize
external data sources for continual pre-training. The code can be found at
https://github.com/hdzhang-code/DFTPlus. | [
-0.4132765234,
-0.6144269705,
0.8464730978,
-0.1602172107,
-0.4419288933,
-0.2317596823,
-0.4332928061,
-0.1442298591,
-0.4066039026,
0.7521608472,
-0.7221331,
-0.4071702063,
-0.5676009059,
0.1616954654,
-0.0847503319,
0.9097363949,
-0.0267508365,
-0.1231464446,
-0.2584702969,
-0.1186152995,
-0.6712636352,
-0.3183466792,
-0.7374155521,
-0.3991251886,
0.4389005899,
0.6965305209,
0.2692203522,
0.5369882584,
0.4035087228,
0.3067243099,
0.1375779659,
0.3873489201,
-0.7793913484,
0.0026773547,
0.1709228456,
-0.4171794653,
-0.1949567199,
0.3061619997,
0.6483722329,
0.6941619515,
0.1821692139,
0.0989242494,
0.3989763558,
0.7550403476,
-0.6423755884,
0.0053364113,
-0.5090869665,
-0.0057131355,
-0.349938184,
-0.4205359221,
-0.6511211991,
-0.1153826043,
0.3344540894,
-0.5325891972,
0.0890654176,
-0.0511494316,
0.4630836844,
0.6176944375,
-0.3576252759,
-0.2077247202,
-0.9795829058,
0.8780610561,
-0.6247915626,
0.3905839026,
0.4904106557,
0.2031413019,
-0.3339752853,
-0.8247920275,
-0.5503758788,
-0.1869571805,
-0.1607997417,
0.0005659555,
-0.0446765274,
0.403072387,
0.401777178,
0.374037087,
-0.4631842375,
0.1866464764,
-0.1667452604,
0.0699921101,
0.4660447538,
0.0941367745,
-0.1427571625,
0.3157569468,
-0.5112897754,
0.0201096218,
-0.7200225592,
0.258493036,
0.1467965692,
0.3348079622,
0.0567238964,
0.3677814901,
-0.2659138739,
0.82223171,
0.4306315184,
-0.2076366246,
0.1708576679,
-0.4330452979,
-0.3222137392,
0.3246761262,
0.693362236,
-0.1562262326,
0.3547698855,
0.0864111632,
-0.1042720973,
-0.0075496724,
0.3591803908,
-0.7842383385,
-0.2825250626,
0.3709044755,
-0.2059435844,
0.1186563149,
-0.0333006158,
-0.0211129542,
-0.2712354064,
-0.6021776199,
0.4445286095,
-0.4133642018,
0.0481462777,
0.3634851575,
0.1191439405,
0.081764102,
0.4592788517,
-0.7548458576,
0.2554105818,
0.9268840551,
0.8742901087,
-0.2032555938,
-0.4801619649,
-0.7427558899,
0.1071204394,
-0.2959580123,
0.8094453812,
-0.5203630924,
-0.2992424071,
-0.1318193227,
-0.0838827416,
-0.0835597515,
-0.4825495481,
0.595225811,
-0.3315016925,
0.1248465702,
-0.2074153274,
-0.8295611143,
-0.0757884458,
0.1078381389,
-0.4006423354,
0.5633247495,
-0.061558716,
-0.469001621,
0.7683090568,
-0.6623186469,
-0.547852695,
0.2478243858,
-0.1215085313,
-0.4607938826,
0.1692842692,
-0.0994841531,
0.5071880221,
0.3056915104,
0.2649405003,
-0.3238583803,
-0.5605507493,
0.2783834934,
-0.5557482243,
0.3372113705,
0.1687200963,
-0.2370028347,
0.1270736307,
-0.6603534818,
-0.119277373,
-0.2746768594,
-0.5112383962,
-0.2598569393,
0.1277455091,
-0.5565387607,
0.3300818503,
0.1906412095,
-0.5655577183,
0.1524924487,
-0.5783591866,
0.2402442247,
0.7265734673,
-0.1450375319,
0.8033365607,
-0.3655371666,
0.1643238217,
0.1683333516,
0.3846693337,
-0.4379618764,
-0.4510979652,
-0.7670302987,
-0.2389441133,
0.151103422,
0.370228678,
-0.4891610444,
0.6085409522,
-0.2859754264,
-0.0741020367,
-0.370982945,
0.5682935715,
0.2582808733,
0.450936079,
0.4835647345,
-0.4257993102,
-0.5516479611,
-0.4481899738,
-0.1511100084,
0.0140215624,
0.0390679836,
0.4272683561,
0.2424825877,
-0.138164416,
1.1669205427,
-0.3385435641,
-0.7662223577,
-0.428899914,
0.2557297349,
0.150703162,
0.5474575162,
0.4165727198,
-0.5746025443,
-0.5885814428,
-0.1791492701,
-0.4365366995,
-0.0122766793,
-0.3569653928,
0.0161724277,
0.1173251271,
0.3806903362,
-0.4986493587,
0.3610989451,
0.275172323,
0.0122635094,
0.2667161822,
-0.1766518652,
-0.0245995205,
-0.4481633306,
-0.1950415075,
-0.127628684,
-0.2525928915,
-0.9163134098,
-0.5416111946,
-0.0105808983,
0.0636325777,
-0.8018901944,
0.5037317872,
-0.4473891258,
0.1514153481,
-0.8165985346,
-0.1371122152,
0.0276656337,
0.4113263488,
0.2824706137,
0.5661577582,
0.4514924586,
-0.9587709308,
0.1574062258,
0.1652224809,
-0.4283664227,
0.3187201917,
-0.283351481,
0.3819767237,
-0.3378992081,
0.572257936,
-1.165379405,
-0.15687567,
0.3891977668,
-0.2281147093,
0.4881649017,
-0.4690121412,
-0.3388384581,
-0.4370926917,
-0.2843813598,
0.2646307051,
0.6116262078,
-0.7201337218,
0.3879816234,
0.0764569193,
0.1303124577,
-0.4142768681,
-0.7321894169,
-0.3534372449,
-0.363665849,
-0.3669873774,
0.2455136776,
-0.1218015328,
0.1670779586,
-0.2865447104,
-0.3369787335,
-0.1580296457,
0.1190227941,
0.3044560254,
-0.1380910277,
-0.08914309,
0.2821017802,
0.0112999883,
-0.2023142427,
-0.1065400988,
-0.4147346914,
0.5598300099,
-0.118590802,
-0.2408901453,
-0.8070346713,
0.019164335,
0.2833839953,
0.0278935321,
0.4982098937,
0.675540328,
-0.0416969433,
-0.1911403537,
-0.7214559913,
-0.3596743345,
-0.5649881959,
-0.1686244905,
-0.5054885149,
-0.9950929284,
0.170572862,
-0.4164361358,
0.1401771456,
0.0650145784,
0.1640133858,
-0.4186355472,
0.8438646793,
0.7296620607,
0.0804958567,
0.763949573,
-0.3633629084,
0.0638742819,
-0.7072457075,
0.0703236088,
-0.0855769292,
-0.5369530916,
-0.4343031347,
-0.246486783,
0.204069525,
0.0618632175,
-0.1214930117,
0.1956633329,
-0.3596499562,
0.6641361117,
0.4976536036,
0.2526384294,
0.2876172662,
-0.124048315,
0.4211797416,
-0.0498753488,
-0.8505063057,
-0.4071888328,
1.1360280514,
0.4094530046,
0.7920286655,
-0.152561903,
1.1655349731,
-0.159332037,
0.2764245868,
-0.9977995157,
0.4103944302,
-0.5312757492,
-0.4672861099,
-0.3260877132,
-0.3434671462,
-1.1521735191,
0.11744266,
-0.0114165815,
-0.4460246265,
0.4079248607,
0.5413681865,
-0.9390886426,
0.0593215823,
-0.9249302745,
1.0596549511,
-0.6399341226,
-0.5798860788,
-0.2019719481,
-0.6975443363,
0.3955595493,
-0.2264226377,
-0.0039162314,
-0.2548389137,
0.0643393844,
0.7199175954,
-0.3082166612,
1.1200156212,
-0.3372507393,
-0.0699451119,
0.4968065619,
-0.3465219438,
0.5050403476,
0.1073185727,
0.3058352768,
0.0188701991,
-0.1647860706,
-0.2877638638,
-0.4513005912,
0.6481606364,
-0.4787935913,
-0.6091458797,
-0.4290198088,
-0.1549187005,
-0.2441859096,
0.245947957,
0.3406086862,
0.3996141851,
-0.0573750846,
0.3998608291,
0.9114245176,
-0.1171849146,
0.5008565784,
0.594892323,
0.2456460148,
0.042606011,
0.7202957869,
0.1796697825,
0.1725311577,
0.3868606389,
0.3607112467,
-0.4432915151,
-0.7818384767,
-0.1239525676,
0.1624412686,
-0.4785755575,
-0.1707790494,
-0.5720347762,
0.025912527,
-0.4861467183,
-0.0892384127,
-0.6337935925,
0.1234904677,
-0.6878528595,
0.2710838616,
0.2704604268,
0.5372692347,
-0.0686732978,
0.7754966617,
-0.8570198417,
0.4675292969,
0.3910962343,
0.63793993,
-0.4087949991,
-0.7448510528,
-0.2076479495,
0.1696352065,
-0.2295363098,
-0.6407397985,
0.143979311,
0.6276710629,
0.6384646297,
0.6631942987,
0.2833936214,
0.7748528719,
-0.5688443184,
0.5932199955,
0.0750069916,
-0.6450431347,
0.8008429408,
-0.0129549308,
0.7625945807,
1.1071702242,
0.6059550643,
-0.2351478934,
-0.1149225384,
-0.4374161363,
-0.74508214,
1.0939574242,
-0.0371201783,
0.1907202899,
-0.0762677789,
0.3257360756,
0.3724301755,
0.173410356,
-0.5898964405,
-0.1765096188,
-0.0955588445,
-0.1173688993,
-0.2678713799,
-0.365943104,
-0.0180718675,
-0.4800358117,
0.4649586678,
-0.1176934689,
-0.021522671,
0.1120656878,
-0.3917642534,
0.0262500346,
0.457478106,
0.6942144036,
0.5247967839,
-0.3810755014,
0.0620140657,
0.1181931794,
-0.5038555264,
0.2491319031,
0.0300400183,
0.046461232,
-0.066174984,
0.0053943382,
1.2192668915,
0.3308043182,
-0.5056632161,
0.5530008674,
-0.0496761128,
-0.1199812293,
-0.3400761187,
0.2019086778,
-0.4955410659,
0.1371183693,
0.2205795795,
0.0031415543,
0.2558572888,
-0.5275756717,
0.3525586426,
0.2889740169,
-0.1885988861,
-0.1983547509,
0.2083761841,
0.454308182,
0.0072069732,
0.4744111896,
-0.4626184404,
-0.3471283913,
0.212210536,
0.2930727601,
1.0031666756,
-0.1674208939,
0.1389328688,
0.282201767,
0.3056082428,
-0.5069959164,
0.0279886946,
-0.6416831017,
-0.7872948647,
-0.6030813456,
-0.5888331532,
-0.3168292046,
0.5330674648,
-0.1722595394,
0.3228870034,
-0.537919879,
-0.1656672955,
-0.0318684541,
0.0098399008,
-0.7721743584,
-0.0084048323,
0.4175900221,
0.5237967968,
-0.6987293363,
1.0787578821,
0.7042969465,
-0.0187516175,
-0.3931052089,
-0.0186726935,
-0.042185653,
-0.3057346642,
0.661885798,
0.5276554823,
-0.2065556645,
0.259264648,
-0.5104736686,
-0.8532227874,
0.8326810002,
0.1289952248,
-0.9063432813,
0.1425670087,
0.1843133122,
0.5050057769,
-0.3398403525,
-0.1579940021,
0.9655644298,
0.3989416957,
0.0590480082,
-0.8179112673,
-0.3131408691,
0.276176393,
-0.2105971128,
0.0987643823,
-0.3568795323,
0.4608436823,
-0.164983958,
-0.5778483748,
-0.1445338428,
0.5676211715,
0.1722683609,
0.6350799203,
0.6247034669,
0.6226997972,
0.4635945261,
-0.3512343764,
0.8429546356,
-0.0258308854,
0.1930690855,
1.5169781446,
-0.4398961067,
0.7714556456,
0.4623381793,
-0.2469186485,
0.0857660919,
0.5673667192,
0.1467575878,
0.7801799774,
-0.0921896473,
-0.252420038,
-0.3442754745,
0.165274173,
-0.2328827381,
0.6881349087,
0.4981202185,
-0.0894252136,
-0.1988825798,
0.4711584151,
-0.4732172191,
-0.1469693631,
-0.3821900189,
1.2388088703,
0.1967267245,
-0.7603838444,
0.7043960094,
-0.5007951856,
1.1419513226,
-0.5870910883,
0.2916885316,
-0.1931108981,
0.3496471047,
-0.2329338491,
-0.8533047438,
0.231442377,
-0.1037504748,
0.0187564362,
-0.5831429362,
0.9228189588,
-0.5441285372,
0.0763521641,
-0.020577943,
0.252169013,
0.278183043,
-0.2534630299,
-0.673994422,
0.0001010236,
-0.2622284889,
-0.2135858536,
0.374812156,
0.2602424026,
0.3544347882,
0.5523702502,
0.6675064564,
-0.2038443834,
0.2778744996,
0.2157444954,
0.6515117288,
-0.3486502171,
-0.6724916101,
-0.8699069619,
0.3140975535,
0.0778675452,
-0.3747774363,
0.6718226075,
0.4828619957,
1.215466857,
-0.1727891266,
0.6060797572,
0.291672498,
0.248952359,
-0.5901975632,
0.2803471386,
-0.3614265323,
0.3604046106,
0.084537521,
-0.7069795728,
-0.1019545645,
0.6272110343,
-0.6328712702,
0.1354155988,
0.5217702389,
0.3756799996,
-0.1569493711,
-0.0783422366,
0.3992752135,
-0.0313794427,
0.0166933425,
0.6078513265,
1.0658798218,
-0.2204943299,
0.5217530131,
-0.5479528904,
-0.1636436284,
-0.4258064628,
-0.5750482082,
-0.7766250968,
-0.4494857192,
-0.5136426091,
0.185824424,
0.0547047034,
0.8358518481,
0.8448697925,
-0.7519099116,
-0.1005707756,
-0.4703945518,
0.0122143039,
-0.1911345869,
-0.2126492858,
-0.1588405073,
-0.8770159483,
-0.7278850675,
0.6528165936,
0.3687826693,
0.3138739765,
0.0034878824,
-0.1848779619,
-0.3151206374,
-0.1380246282,
0.8200378418,
0.4625692368,
-0.5923577547,
-0.2178466022,
-0.1878037304,
-0.0011274378,
0.2296812683,
1.0283530951,
-0.9629940391,
0.5349309444,
0.6098045111,
0.6765631437,
0.5984913111,
0.2369617969,
0.2180336863,
-1.1601314545,
0.1535857916,
0.3711611331,
0.1740317792,
0.225413397,
-0.4349988997,
0.2577500343,
-0.0245871153,
-0.5810037255,
-0.8460211158,
0.3662152588,
-1.1622741222,
-0.4760481119,
1.1279630661,
-0.1057938486,
-0.108239688,
-0.4008945525,
-0.2226333171,
0.2473243326,
-0.4587372839,
0.4840758443,
0.472869575,
-0.5605657101,
-0.3417743146,
-0.4190593362,
0.9334381223,
0.4970290959,
-0.7102398872,
0.0861062557,
0.5360432267,
0.188546434,
0.1374315917,
0.9598847628,
0.1602224559,
0.4273315668,
-0.3566595614,
-0.4129319191,
-0.1336574852,
-0.6791939735,
-0.6488969326,
0.0453358591,
0.0848916173,
-0.4894638062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05276v1 | Extensive Evaluation of Transformer-based Architectures for Adverse Drug Events Extraction | 2023-06-08T15:25:24 | 2023-06-08T15:25:24 | Simone Scaboro, Beatrice Portellia, Emmanuele Chersoni, Enrico Santus, Giuseppe Serra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Adverse Event (ADE) extraction is one of the core tasks in digital
pharmacovigilance, especially when applied to informal texts. This task has
been addressed by the Natural Language Processing community using large
pre-trained language models, such as BERT. Despite the great number of
Transformer-based architectures used in the literature, it is unclear which of
them has better performances and why. Therefore, in this paper we perform an
extensive evaluation and analysis of 19 Transformer-based models for ADE
extraction on informal texts. We compare the performance of all the considered
models on two datasets with increasing levels of informality (forums posts and
tweets). We also combine the purely Transformer-based models with two
commonly-used additional processing layers (CRF and LSTM), and analyze their
effect on the models performance. Furthermore, we use a well-established
feature importance technique (SHAP) to correlate the performance of the models
with a set of features that describe them: model category (AutoEncoding,
AutoRegressive, Text-to-Text), pretraining domain, training from scratch, and
model size in number of parameters. At the end of our analyses, we identify a
list of take-home messages that can be derived from the experimental data. | [
-0.0711397752,
-0.7933911681,
0.7499940991,
0.0574211515,
-0.1024582013,
-0.3235540688,
-0.032582026,
-0.8945204616,
0.0936056376,
0.4118335247,
-0.2016907483,
-0.5151233077,
-0.9632128477,
0.1267336607,
-0.7342330217,
1.1888390779,
-0.04438724,
0.0589760356,
0.3424967527,
0.0058908369,
-0.3380641937,
-0.5211942196,
-0.51647681,
-0.1572737247,
0.4623758495,
0.0653997213,
0.4496137202,
0.5439229608,
1.0903007984,
0.2753561139,
-0.0045814887,
-0.2088622153,
-0.2008532882,
0.0574413165,
-0.0709875301,
-0.1754426956,
-0.6386450529,
-0.0925664753,
0.2124270052,
0.3600049913,
-0.240191862,
0.1711594015,
-0.1363145411,
0.5144049525,
-0.8208073378,
-0.0263423454,
-0.5986248851,
0.0225681793,
-0.0511190332,
0.1874050796,
-0.3783978522,
-0.3767076731,
0.660538733,
-0.4051416814,
0.1278537214,
-0.151944831,
1.1961932182,
0.0648903996,
-0.5250550508,
-0.6897947192,
-1.0366200209,
0.4402153194,
-0.9176554084,
0.4237502217,
0.1593035161,
0.3165286481,
-0.0574632622,
-1.2047977448,
-0.4724978805,
0.1313427836,
-0.4755817652,
0.0088670989,
-0.4241968095,
0.3005459905,
-0.1938100755,
0.5270220041,
-0.4023320377,
0.4077055752,
-0.5362903476,
-0.2276524007,
0.3416048288,
0.134770751,
0.3114319146,
-0.517457664,
-0.5938355327,
-0.0336648636,
-0.4895508885,
0.2025560439,
-0.0595461652,
0.0775186718,
-0.2547890544,
0.339895308,
0.2224258929,
0.4447651207,
0.037424203,
0.0576912053,
0.0826010332,
-0.3923220932,
-0.2952911258,
-0.0774609223,
1.1799710989,
0.0409554206,
0.0189786255,
-0.244466573,
-0.3618458211,
-0.2630850673,
0.5443518162,
-1.0618566275,
-0.5617585182,
0.6409465075,
-0.8824635744,
-0.6346014738,
0.2065452933,
-1.1076420546,
-0.4428571761,
-0.1039147973,
0.6282262802,
-0.5816555619,
-0.0246293843,
0.0130773513,
-0.0978472233,
0.3924969733,
0.1537421793,
-0.7317814231,
0.6388214231,
0.6886606216,
0.696662426,
-0.5050010085,
0.140979588,
-0.4201039672,
-0.2187479734,
-0.2306780964,
1.2065838575,
-0.4168967903,
-0.2673291266,
0.1217435747,
-0.0032416487,
-0.4279027283,
-0.5472455621,
1.2312700748,
-0.6605162621,
0.3055028021,
-0.0496109612,
-0.4794129431,
-0.2913890779,
0.0250489693,
-0.844026804,
0.829618454,
-0.1345581561,
-0.5684273839,
0.5907564163,
-0.8664049506,
-0.6474659443,
-0.0487240031,
0.0124973077,
-0.8123716116,
0.1715329587,
0.5218200088,
0.5190931559,
-0.1973587722,
0.5948880315,
-0.0130340112,
-0.3947171867,
0.2758943141,
-0.5809583664,
0.6028105021,
0.3458390832,
-0.5343734026,
0.1095598564,
-1.0206444263,
-0.3253032863,
0.0844448358,
-0.5099198818,
-0.3153649569,
0.1291963607,
0.4411430955,
0.478889972,
0.0195878185,
-0.5600915551,
-0.1187751889,
-0.5601297021,
0.2569972873,
0.6669778228,
0.4323782623,
0.2326266617,
-0.0437490903,
0.2393081337,
0.0864376798,
0.3478403687,
-0.2794043422,
-0.2057977468,
-0.631431818,
-0.5789688826,
0.4564099908,
0.7064757943,
-0.490006417,
0.6511595249,
-0.498742789,
-0.3123310804,
-0.5625368953,
-0.1024014801,
0.3033078611,
0.2328223586,
0.4539097846,
-0.2023880035,
-0.4959302843,
-0.9552725554,
-0.2602616549,
-0.0479411669,
-0.1779519022,
0.3980236351,
0.3824307323,
-0.4596886337,
0.7847662568,
-0.6198949218,
-0.3872203827,
-0.332133323,
0.0915281624,
0.0739966705,
0.0760319233,
0.5835698247,
-0.6189191937,
-0.2607345581,
-0.1006982476,
-0.6192113757,
-0.325740397,
-0.1521336883,
-0.0902031735,
0.0750136673,
0.236589402,
-0.5964986086,
0.4881893694,
0.3879794776,
-0.2314954847,
0.3089119494,
-0.1563531905,
0.4002888799,
-0.9383047819,
0.287212193,
0.2367419899,
-0.1070898995,
-1.0649198294,
-0.2312775403,
0.112127848,
-0.2491160035,
-0.4272272885,
0.460614562,
-0.3271394074,
0.1591273993,
-0.0771840513,
0.0739753023,
0.3025868833,
0.4271798432,
0.1647901088,
0.1959751993,
0.3616507947,
-0.5285565853,
0.0102297049,
0.1596888155,
-0.3053265214,
0.1831433922,
-0.9134097695,
0.052186083,
0.0069600702,
0.1117165536,
-1.1432471275,
-0.2658236921,
0.2934780419,
-0.036807511,
0.522867918,
-0.0449294299,
-0.173255682,
-0.483246237,
-0.4017744958,
0.053240139,
0.374350816,
-0.4890388846,
0.7532474399,
0.5638794899,
-0.3421526849,
-0.4257771075,
-0.3816610873,
0.210350737,
-0.3445227444,
-0.2294862419,
0.1788578779,
0.5128754973,
-0.3042440414,
-0.0668314472,
-0.0190758295,
-0.3186798096,
-0.0317108184,
0.2200249285,
0.5363193154,
-0.2229973525,
0.1500521898,
0.0337559097,
-0.1478826404,
0.221654579,
0.1180667803,
0.2422563285,
-0.0566327162,
-0.2305018902,
-0.5865731239,
0.3601619899,
0.5724355578,
-0.3518478274,
0.8308385015,
0.5579971075,
-0.4581240416,
-0.0126247862,
-0.5629232526,
-0.3778660595,
-0.414157927,
0.4489187002,
0.0682214051,
-0.2450844198,
0.6503898501,
-0.0251586773,
0.2281809747,
0.6088671684,
0.4514656067,
-0.0742264315,
0.4459958673,
0.3953973651,
-0.0332720168,
0.6498785615,
-0.0633520558,
0.5209997296,
-0.4646075964,
-0.2039900422,
-0.4394595623,
-0.1676235795,
-0.4832738936,
-0.2412405759,
0.5736312866,
-0.4132717848,
-0.0068196659,
0.3751222789,
-0.5041974783,
0.0177627318,
0.0851765051,
0.2119427919,
0.2351977378,
-0.0794017762,
0.3960919976,
-0.1285568327,
-0.635189116,
-0.6446189284,
1.2079315186,
0.6244121194,
0.5525044799,
-0.0130516728,
0.4862017632,
0.3634176552,
0.4240947068,
-0.7642709613,
0.2653697133,
-0.4967274964,
-0.6097123027,
-0.0073253298,
-0.2306089997,
-0.996711731,
0.19171983,
-0.4646621943,
-0.7556576133,
0.6795081496,
-0.3061455488,
-0.7219536901,
0.2368618101,
-0.9555581808,
0.8129261732,
-0.2123566121,
-0.0035842126,
0.0716165155,
-0.8154732585,
0.3770920634,
-0.2526653707,
0.4835822284,
0.1745447218,
0.0639447942,
0.8092190623,
-0.3664715588,
0.8957964182,
0.0173702966,
-0.1843978912,
0.471762687,
0.0680692792,
0.7320812345,
-0.1862758398,
0.0203912631,
0.4332818389,
0.0435686409,
0.0145971449,
-0.4563064873,
0.5946172476,
-0.7067350745,
-0.2140393406,
-0.2368553281,
-0.0915616825,
0.2399475425,
0.271615833,
0.4097224474,
0.8264052868,
-0.4072884619,
0.0703736544,
0.5378800631,
-0.3782536089,
0.6193625927,
0.6462097764,
0.2818378508,
-0.39535743,
0.6082872748,
0.3237651885,
0.134665966,
0.494058609,
0.248822391,
-0.1889010221,
-0.6986780763,
-0.2933460772,
-0.093305327,
-0.7785997987,
-0.2671232522,
-1.2522922754,
-0.3918125033,
-0.5109648705,
0.0208911318,
-0.6456585526,
-0.4898574948,
-0.0179526471,
-0.2344630212,
0.3804268837,
0.9523991942,
0.0970065594,
0.3473632336,
-1.0670464039,
0.4892145097,
0.0197239555,
0.3855785429,
-0.1671205163,
-0.3760369122,
-0.2331721187,
-0.2870584726,
-0.4268952906,
-1.0526863337,
0.205504775,
0.350669831,
0.6626164913,
0.6057155728,
0.1316968352,
0.5038321614,
-0.4403319359,
0.7683392167,
-0.207099393,
-0.7715685964,
0.7314516902,
-0.3478790224,
-0.127081275,
0.7009020448,
0.3016823232,
-0.31934762,
-0.2642111182,
-0.5944342017,
-1.2441693544,
0.6630465388,
0.4905240238,
-0.1826211214,
-0.18174842,
0.4773617983,
0.1259679049,
-0.0634738207,
-0.8770699501,
-0.4064331651,
0.1692416519,
-0.3046809733,
0.3922396898,
-0.3563148975,
0.095682092,
0.1606956124,
0.5825941563,
0.4087503552,
0.3205132186,
0.4262100458,
-0.1374274641,
0.0041598091,
0.5177291036,
0.3645414412,
0.2574747801,
-0.3413849771,
0.0896622986,
0.100543052,
-1.0251170397,
-0.0547762364,
0.5102527142,
-0.0017271728,
0.0298007969,
0.7406494021,
0.6221277714,
0.3112549782,
-0.6426181793,
0.6028411388,
-0.1104629636,
0.3149887323,
-0.0943297893,
-0.0699605569,
-0.6235938072,
0.0567338504,
0.4862985313,
0.2392730117,
0.7468381524,
-0.3373737931,
0.5135574937,
0.166529119,
-0.7127581835,
-0.4212141633,
0.4963561594,
0.3592087626,
-0.3618281186,
0.3282575011,
0.0784971491,
-0.3369089067,
0.5246108174,
0.2116963714,
1.0481551886,
-0.34710446,
-0.0262640808,
0.4515236914,
0.4035282135,
0.2507452667,
-0.1906082332,
0.1727634966,
-0.4718982279,
-0.3146938086,
-0.4711886346,
-0.0069857473,
0.3128130436,
-0.651453197,
0.5124325752,
-0.0655973926,
-0.2213522196,
0.1953454465,
-0.1302565932,
-0.5514897108,
0.2231431454,
-0.0597887859,
0.4863379896,
-1.0346214771,
0.4216014743,
0.6254527569,
-0.0213493071,
-0.728328824,
0.1468393207,
0.0440740138,
-0.4723071754,
0.3734399974,
0.0579972602,
0.1287471503,
-0.4364804327,
-0.0106061762,
-0.6290925145,
1.0228385925,
-0.1611169726,
-0.609749198,
-0.2171972245,
0.2627980113,
0.8800281286,
-0.3584944904,
0.4810516834,
0.830314219,
0.0602451041,
0.0953836665,
-0.7981965542,
0.1034723371,
-0.3478417993,
-0.2364703864,
0.3858182132,
-0.0226113349,
0.513997376,
-0.2653891146,
-0.3531276882,
-0.3504375517,
0.158982262,
-0.042903576,
0.2163615376,
0.225659281,
0.2588525712,
0.4691776633,
-0.1227178499,
1.2533142567,
-0.2631074488,
0.3633627892,
1.037863493,
-0.2529446781,
0.9068994522,
0.3374652863,
-0.1602101177,
0.7571092844,
0.5139524341,
0.1005002186,
0.7000451088,
-0.3296844363,
0.005167495,
0.0593028478,
0.207429111,
-0.1920385063,
0.5172471404,
0.6101338863,
-0.7644686699,
-0.3913109899,
0.0770641938,
0.0184356961,
-0.2246386856,
-0.0071104025,
1.2274909019,
0.10796462,
-0.4890531301,
0.2356387526,
0.0906415284,
0.3628269434,
-0.5125308633,
-0.0770364702,
-0.0111573823,
0.429725498,
-0.1914985031,
-0.6206893325,
0.4160572588,
0.1314693987,
0.0081210267,
0.2128677815,
1.1276545525,
-0.1277685463,
-0.6237546802,
0.3045584857,
0.4080379009,
-0.0355074145,
0.1099024266,
-0.6207323074,
-0.0231880397,
-0.3003948629,
-0.6949565411,
0.1212148592,
0.5918760896,
-0.0259423573,
0.2810538411,
0.67244488,
0.3620557487,
-0.112460807,
0.1246211156,
0.9083128572,
-0.3967654705,
-0.3875299394,
-1.0880709887,
0.7874413729,
-0.2378640175,
-0.1412946135,
0.5959761739,
0.4803669751,
-0.1831736714,
0.0419897139,
0.5127387643,
-0.0051903524,
0.4588011503,
-0.3525161445,
0.7544401884,
0.0367638581,
0.7333481908,
-0.3902724683,
-0.7408298254,
-0.2968383133,
0.3933271468,
-0.5874399543,
-0.0385896601,
0.5599104762,
0.3956241012,
-0.095765844,
0.0634759441,
-0.0755300894,
0.3624530733,
0.7250521779,
0.4946917593,
0.431931138,
-1.122756362,
0.5735583305,
-0.1960763186,
-0.2709304988,
-0.1649988592,
-0.8201758862,
-0.9054959416,
-0.471961081,
-0.22449404,
-0.3402716517,
0.0462596901,
0.9769690633,
0.642765224,
-1.0958968401,
0.3684010208,
0.1130234972,
0.0624020435,
-0.170671463,
-0.3129299283,
0.7187246084,
-0.2127241641,
-0.4128635824,
-0.025773583,
0.4534840286,
0.1370100379,
0.152379632,
0.4697936475,
-0.1974725723,
0.3797914088,
0.6415936947,
-0.0848788694,
-0.4187528491,
-0.231395632,
0.1661160439,
-0.4133208394,
0.1578706503,
0.9692679644,
-0.6241566539,
0.4646381438,
0.4197339416,
0.4135449231,
0.368385762,
0.0384699032,
0.7034472227,
-0.5171192288,
0.0822338015,
0.2674320638,
0.4014711976,
0.0859302431,
-0.6862209439,
0.2422664165,
-0.0210272707,
-0.5920546055,
-0.7205932736,
-0.1841858029,
-0.6333041191,
-0.3723129034,
1.2361372709,
-0.1542423069,
-0.187859416,
-0.5784272552,
-0.2432963103,
0.1091793403,
-0.3630217314,
1.1506799459,
0.6168233752,
-0.1773140281,
0.0511662997,
-0.7007088661,
0.6160348058,
-0.1946906447,
-1.0397356749,
0.1027303711,
0.3267924488,
0.1847055405,
0.3475640118,
0.648440659,
-0.4976482093,
0.1747801602,
-0.0794555023,
0.1960518509,
0.1524961442,
-0.3197101653,
-0.493986845,
0.1515081227,
-0.3287222087,
-0.0903875232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05270v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05270v1 | Overview of the Problem List Summarization (ProbSum) 2023 Shared Task on Summarizing Patients' Active Diagnoses and Problems from Electronic Health Record Progress Notes | 2023-06-08T15:19:57 | 2023-06-08T15:19:57 | Yanjun Gao, Dmitriy Dligach, Timothy Miller, Matthew M. Churpek, Majid Afshar | cs.CL | cs.CL | The BioNLP Workshop 2023 initiated the launch of a shared task on Problem
List Summarization (ProbSum) in January 2023. The aim of this shared task is to
attract future research efforts in building NLP models for real-world
diagnostic decision support applications, where a system generating relevant
and accurate diagnoses will augment the healthcare providers decision-making
process and improve the quality of care for patients. The goal for participants
is to develop models that generated a list of diagnoses and problems using
input from the daily care notes collected from the hospitalization of
critically ill patients. Eight teams submitted their final systems to the
shared task leaderboard. In this paper, we describe the tasks, datasets,
evaluation metrics, and baseline systems. Additionally, the techniques and
results of the evaluation of the different approaches tried by the
participating teams are summarized. | [
-0.3269530535,
-0.3491445184,
0.6613524556,
0.2946140766,
-0.0328569189,
-0.1171396673,
0.08457762,
-0.5895041227,
0.4259770215,
0.6080496907,
-0.4706842899,
-0.623929143,
-0.3869282305,
0.1481465101,
-0.4721335173,
1.5218223333,
-0.0152573977,
0.007387172,
-0.298386544,
0.086553961,
-0.6122641563,
-0.4219446778,
-0.5686376095,
-0.2475242615,
0.2547904253,
0.5328580141,
0.6271875501,
0.1124004647,
1.1609386206,
0.2091099769,
-0.0426344499,
0.1623151153,
-0.0692915767,
0.2416536063,
0.0634831637,
-0.2141580731,
-1.0645958185,
-0.2762882113,
0.5225348473,
0.9650672674,
-0.1631820202,
0.6097205281,
0.0023083563,
0.5342655182,
-0.2809484005,
0.1571129858,
0.1168326512,
0.3949633241,
0.1655536294,
0.0639792308,
-0.4110490084,
-0.3714240789,
0.2481507659,
-0.552349925,
0.3083187938,
-0.0472846217,
0.5940987468,
0.25081563,
-0.0429841951,
-0.1820168346,
-0.7933185101,
0.5322102904,
-0.8737661242,
0.1025108173,
0.3008984625,
0.3765265346,
-0.3393586874,
-0.8280518055,
0.0124900658,
0.1071976051,
-0.2560533285,
0.5038910508,
-0.177829057,
0.1681426913,
0.008182371,
0.296032548,
-0.7474101782,
-0.072689265,
-0.3849922717,
-0.1436224729,
0.8126789331,
0.4628668725,
0.2759858072,
-0.1058828756,
-0.1689598262,
0.481736958,
-0.2012906522,
-0.1070009992,
-0.3979702592,
-0.0003999802,
-0.3026529253,
0.3846941292,
-0.3433515429,
0.9312838912,
-0.2759539187,
-0.2094511241,
0.2680747211,
-0.6821121573,
-0.2852648497,
-0.0119064292,
0.5068112016,
0.853272438,
-0.108817257,
-0.2664203644,
-0.1079668775,
-0.1438326985,
0.1425452083,
-0.4755857885,
-0.4404903948,
0.7168607712,
-0.8913680315,
-0.2806597054,
-0.1718032509,
-0.7865414619,
-0.2634784579,
-0.3663331568,
0.2397223413,
-0.1898595542,
-0.4524146318,
0.2242661417,
-0.1794091761,
-0.6282221079,
0.373053968,
-0.4318008423,
0.7950095534,
0.5599324107,
0.7487374544,
-0.2290569246,
0.1427614838,
-0.4845176041,
0.2749072611,
-0.1473562568,
0.8694800138,
-0.0983843356,
-0.5667999983,
-0.1097097173,
0.0866263807,
-0.0497164577,
-1.0783369541,
0.5777876377,
0.2108668834,
-0.0459869802,
-0.4668928981,
-0.3630800247,
0.0334508345,
0.3239435852,
-0.6327716112,
0.5312514901,
0.0784557611,
-0.7599257827,
0.1436479092,
-0.7385923266,
-0.0999197438,
0.5001257658,
-0.0953970701,
-0.5266302228,
0.0119615588,
-0.0143562937,
0.8405183554,
-0.1997225434,
0.5854426026,
0.0677864999,
-0.3345773518,
-0.1089650914,
0.3841340542,
0.6748767495,
0.2214196473,
0.0328673013,
0.3415075243,
-0.7785348892,
-0.05020722,
0.1313759238,
-0.3521592319,
-0.1076834053,
0.3282699287,
-0.1280729324,
0.0005951566,
0.2916882932,
-0.2070492804,
0.2418669909,
-0.2251025289,
0.1176573858,
0.2603209317,
0.3807494044,
-0.0996211395,
-0.7889765501,
0.647923708,
0.0488456488,
0.5435545444,
-0.1820121706,
-0.8986598849,
-0.3976383507,
-0.1899950951,
0.2379465997,
0.8066407442,
-0.1135381982,
0.3459425271,
-0.0427941382,
-0.5760820508,
-0.3446289897,
-0.3548000753,
0.474293083,
0.6170335412,
0.5307168961,
-0.2123168111,
-0.9039154649,
-0.9830818176,
0.091061376,
-0.3559414446,
0.0062975134,
0.0796297789,
0.3646841049,
-0.2080702484,
0.5757281184,
-0.6776195168,
-0.424847573,
-0.6324490905,
0.1074235663,
0.4833390415,
0.5170129538,
0.3494337797,
-0.2797364593,
-0.2459552437,
-0.0566528477,
-0.7589222789,
-0.2408047915,
0.0246009417,
-0.0213927459,
-0.1754519343,
0.314825505,
-0.3357298374,
0.3306076825,
0.432662189,
-0.4343599975,
0.8172944188,
-0.3719158769,
0.0507750213,
-1.0874246359,
0.2647387087,
0.0344549082,
-0.388022542,
-0.5274540186,
0.0062953308,
-0.4023683667,
-0.2347788215,
0.0286529381,
0.1407521814,
-0.2404960245,
-0.267213732,
0.2169926614,
0.1884382665,
0.0471620709,
0.0121014239,
0.0574430935,
0.1574529707,
0.267640084,
-0.8227547407,
0.3837907016,
0.3257747591,
-0.1689626873,
0.3930429816,
-0.7117961645,
-0.4595848322,
0.0301236194,
0.2725192606,
-0.7659022212,
-0.0989187732,
0.2273840755,
-0.3812922835,
0.1659574509,
0.3008211553,
-0.2763485312,
-0.6305021048,
-0.0265533514,
0.2266114652,
0.4251880944,
0.2474217862,
0.2926606536,
0.6384015083,
-0.4487940967,
-0.4605837166,
-0.6154617667,
0.0359981209,
0.0177563541,
-0.3310182095,
0.8550334573,
-0.21414195,
-0.7259351015,
0.2246923298,
0.0448354445,
0.0252150521,
0.3488585353,
0.2521089613,
0.2649664581,
-0.1031049639,
0.0635924488,
-0.1844236404,
-0.3488861322,
0.1496376544,
-0.0150168156,
0.5247077942,
-0.2986742854,
-0.1056101248,
-0.609619379,
0.7780042291,
0.1302937567,
-0.1373935938,
0.5058993101,
0.4054690897,
-0.8768821359,
0.0059555797,
-0.1686682403,
-0.0484764613,
-0.2684439421,
0.4563701749,
0.0533834547,
-0.3816190958,
0.9210860133,
-0.2314722985,
0.5162694454,
0.620509088,
0.5533613563,
-0.3883904815,
1.0393669605,
0.6356656551,
0.3621580005,
-0.1102175266,
-0.4920350611,
0.3949748278,
-0.6982800961,
-0.5896716714,
-0.5475982428,
-0.3260985315,
-0.4907749593,
-0.2684316039,
0.7079408765,
0.3216491938,
0.004113521,
0.4079699516,
-0.8315508962,
-0.006861127,
0.1759796143,
0.3580271304,
0.2592341602,
-0.4492025673,
-0.2212690115,
0.0006077206,
-0.6838078499,
-0.4726883769,
0.9273890853,
0.2641861737,
0.0126194311,
0.0468682311,
0.9638269544,
0.5734965205,
0.1698110104,
-0.6502677798,
0.8120205998,
-0.3249512315,
-0.5258942842,
-0.1975871772,
-0.0619611144,
-0.9724974036,
-0.2000745386,
-0.1241762415,
-0.7231485248,
0.1461580992,
0.2204230577,
-0.9790309072,
-0.0432272777,
-0.5808328986,
0.998494029,
-0.1827039421,
0.0997544825,
-0.3392626643,
-0.7963497043,
0.2575678527,
0.1996981353,
0.4897709191,
-0.116028294,
0.0295550525,
1.1351617575,
-0.2725906074,
0.7148432732,
-0.3589674234,
0.1671334952,
0.2268239409,
0.057462249,
0.0303836875,
0.1759327203,
-0.1127678901,
0.1230586916,
0.3390797377,
-0.2702687979,
-0.2666558325,
0.2905898392,
-0.4309053719,
-0.4200174809,
-0.3738417029,
-0.3959274292,
-0.2449836433,
0.1433826089,
0.077569969,
0.9378377199,
-0.2248341143,
-0.0875824764,
0.4239897132,
-0.4975037277,
0.4282470047,
0.5691532493,
-0.4165658057,
-0.2983652353,
0.9134984016,
0.3157522082,
0.0685707182,
0.3702756166,
0.1662272364,
0.2263761312,
-0.8376722932,
-0.1872904599,
0.2212249488,
-0.5797274113,
-0.3416619003,
-0.7935330272,
-0.3146494031,
-0.4696255624,
-0.2282016724,
-0.0949437693,
-0.548915565,
-0.3339318335,
-0.0672595277,
0.0143914325,
0.9861165881,
-0.2909721434,
0.215722993,
-1.0948392153,
0.5025178194,
-0.2270462215,
0.079815194,
-0.1778250337,
-0.1731556803,
-0.5968497396,
-0.3259846866,
-0.3741187155,
-1.1110724211,
0.5077189207,
0.1099627465,
0.9004573822,
0.2673328519,
0.117835395,
0.6976550221,
-0.2723608911,
1.042144537,
0.329020679,
-0.7044964433,
0.9358837605,
-0.3079922497,
0.1536661834,
0.5567917228,
0.5699682832,
-0.5683630705,
-0.3826579452,
-0.7512377501,
-0.850818038,
0.5773002505,
-0.1834914088,
-0.7181608677,
-0.1479336917,
0.4569824934,
-0.0823106244,
-0.0671388581,
-0.2551554739,
-0.2692475021,
0.0197053719,
-0.6318703294,
0.0451182947,
-0.2969489992,
-0.2278761417,
-0.391574055,
0.6043003201,
0.0618681647,
0.5787431598,
0.5219825506,
0.143278271,
-0.1268036515,
0.0858873725,
0.6098952293,
0.8641541004,
-0.4889621735,
-0.0199897531,
0.1163301095,
-0.4742979407,
-0.124678202,
0.0368575938,
-0.2244013399,
0.2561221123,
0.6150055528,
0.5390565395,
0.1198572516,
-0.7376295924,
0.4459981918,
-0.1073685661,
-0.1963973194,
-0.4645473957,
-0.0094831381,
0.2376879156,
0.1793866903,
0.1815819293,
0.3540225923,
0.6380243301,
-0.4266413152,
0.3947662711,
0.0945226625,
-0.3399008512,
-0.6064794064,
0.3409715295,
0.3009581268,
-0.475451082,
0.2701213062,
-0.2031203806,
-0.4651182294,
0.8804736733,
0.8285934329,
0.4248778522,
-0.451033622,
0.4828204513,
0.5301603675,
0.1700277776,
-0.1030208617,
0.6894769073,
0.0896017402,
-0.4723521173,
-0.6453079581,
-0.4261243939,
-0.5863094926,
0.2994158268,
-0.9222998619,
0.5818872452,
-0.5313178301,
-0.3459936082,
-0.0249823704,
0.0746640563,
-0.3298742175,
0.5062816739,
0.0927838609,
0.6017379165,
-0.8561860323,
0.1578676403,
0.8113427758,
-0.3544081151,
-0.5949720144,
-0.2050826252,
-0.22318995,
-0.5834816098,
0.467064321,
0.0533480681,
0.4776080847,
0.0200500935,
-0.1661313623,
-0.7227622867,
0.808077395,
0.0725101307,
-0.7559499741,
-0.2398525774,
-0.101733245,
0.5839264989,
-0.3404767513,
0.4450727999,
0.5152283311,
0.6348085403,
-0.2810358405,
-1.2894968987,
0.1502857506,
-0.4272353053,
-0.6395449638,
0.1327854991,
-0.5864169598,
0.6351510286,
-0.441806674,
-0.0063742194,
-0.1907106787,
0.3359327018,
0.3293117583,
0.5633453727,
0.2050854713,
0.790327549,
0.6998073459,
-0.2350857109,
0.9283648729,
-0.1983186603,
-0.070542641,
1.0085396767,
-0.2843173742,
0.6875269413,
0.0759347901,
-0.5526648164,
0.3504206836,
0.5659277439,
0.1474326253,
0.3072383702,
0.2652629018,
-0.2121407837,
-0.4154423177,
-0.4672810137,
-0.6267405152,
0.2830740213,
0.6966154575,
-0.3378030956,
-0.2751212418,
0.0248721018,
-0.0474798568,
-0.1187230796,
-0.3012057245,
1.0618501902,
0.0227672327,
-0.6956999898,
0.4566335082,
0.0854290724,
0.1985315382,
-0.2102768123,
-0.1685314924,
0.0468167178,
0.2420035899,
-0.5775123835,
-0.6758858562,
0.8295317888,
-0.0367516279,
-0.4559500217,
-0.2754586935,
0.5189470649,
-0.1084590629,
-0.4703618586,
0.2218356133,
0.3929457068,
0.5811550021,
0.1804893017,
-0.7684850097,
0.0669807643,
-0.016199043,
0.0229370128,
0.1848093271,
-0.0137134632,
-0.2184844464,
0.5891898274,
0.2047336251,
0.4428508878,
-0.1698108763,
0.3265527785,
0.6404131055,
-0.3742446303,
-0.2432192266,
-0.5208937526,
0.7494702935,
-0.0355373211,
-0.2438332289,
0.2994741201,
0.583783567,
0.4393355548,
0.026176177,
0.9276336432,
0.019161569,
0.9959980249,
-0.0740936622,
0.6259210706,
-0.5411886573,
0.0776545629,
-0.2495405227,
-0.516043067,
-0.5667459369,
0.5238414407,
0.0896220654,
-0.3134970367,
0.7147374153,
0.1928475052,
0.4297529161,
0.0183849931,
0.1343917996,
0.2678801119,
0.4317433536,
0.6561152935,
0.4734043479,
-0.6363655329,
0.1872471124,
-0.2933564484,
-0.4087305069,
-0.471773088,
-0.829406321,
-0.3710330725,
-0.6691130996,
-0.6961299777,
-0.1348450184,
0.3552272022,
0.7992720008,
0.7074947357,
-1.1834044456,
-0.2398064137,
-0.1548014879,
-0.0647864789,
-0.6290357113,
-0.193743661,
0.4055072367,
-0.0470470749,
-0.2181462795,
0.3888759017,
0.3751075864,
0.0161938481,
0.0450732447,
0.2069296688,
-0.0395751633,
-0.3743823469,
0.4915491343,
-0.0133160995,
-0.5787747502,
0.0927759483,
0.1306982636,
0.1708314866,
-0.3239720166,
0.6178514957,
-0.7534406185,
0.2476804703,
0.6691890359,
0.3372721374,
0.1753967553,
-0.0077058082,
0.5540772676,
-0.1689800769,
-0.2103014439,
0.6074246764,
0.4204660356,
0.0824941024,
-0.4488606453,
0.4679507613,
0.5014893413,
-0.7511505485,
-1.0588458776,
0.0089712851,
-1.016002059,
-0.1512533575,
0.7268127799,
-0.312574625,
0.1454538107,
-0.5292419791,
-0.1485837847,
0.5728597641,
-0.0445535369,
0.5597850084,
0.424918443,
-0.5655387044,
0.1354226172,
-0.8216095567,
0.5382828116,
0.4609555602,
-1.0680967569,
-0.1584047079,
0.3881343305,
0.0145267658,
0.232805565,
1.1140407324,
-0.1427132338,
0.3519784212,
-0.2944777012,
0.2927618623,
-0.1256418973,
-0.7436414361,
0.1937223971,
0.217528075,
-0.1101407036,
-0.0186416339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.05268v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.05268v2 | Factorized Contrastive Learning: Going Beyond Multi-view Redundancy | 2023-06-08T15:17:04 | 2023-10-30T05:31:05 | Paul Pu Liang, Zihao Deng, Martin Ma, James Zou, Louis-Philippe Morency, Ruslan Salakhutdinov | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | In a wide range of multimodal tasks, contrastive learning has become a
particularly appealing approach since it can successfully learn representations
from abundant unlabeled data with only pairing information (e.g., image-caption
or video-audio pairs). Underpinning these approaches is the assumption of
multi-view redundancy - that shared information between modalities is necessary
and sufficient for downstream tasks. However, in many real-world settings,
task-relevant information is also contained in modality-unique regions:
information that is only present in one modality but still relevant to the
task. How can we learn self-supervised multimodal representations to capture
both shared and unique information relevant to downstream tasks? This paper
proposes FactorCL, a new multimodal representation learning method to go beyond
multi-view redundancy. FactorCL is built from three new contributions: (1)
factorizing task-relevant information into shared and unique representations,
(2) capturing task-relevant information via maximizing MI lower bounds and
removing task-irrelevant information via minimizing MI upper bounds, and (3)
multimodal data augmentations to approximate task relevance without labels. On
large-scale real-world datasets, FactorCL captures both shared and unique
information and achieves state-of-the-art results on six benchmarks | [
-0.722264111,
-0.2992596924,
0.4131647944,
0.3323899209,
-0.3026611209,
0.2511276305,
-0.0456240103,
-0.2204715163,
0.3819330335,
0.2879399657,
-0.7542883158,
-0.2413114011,
-0.647881031,
-0.0174450781,
-0.0311890561,
0.927957356,
0.014570985,
0.2744545341,
-0.5997636318,
-0.5500392914,
-0.357262224,
-0.6504901648,
-0.293068409,
-0.4748406112,
0.8322726488,
0.5361702442,
0.2413410842,
0.4044337273,
0.4735437334,
0.3305257857,
0.3251958787,
0.715931654,
-0.529940486,
0.0485139713,
-0.2023147792,
-0.1499920785,
-0.1393018067,
0.258382529,
0.4485325813,
0.8387954831,
0.1718140692,
0.0124971038,
0.0957367346,
0.818908155,
-0.6867187619,
0.6448227167,
-0.2294956744,
0.256657958,
0.1742063612,
-0.5742788315,
-0.4840637445,
0.0852413252,
0.0054488573,
-0.9134055972,
0.55214113,
0.0076379054,
0.3029166162,
0.3605856001,
-0.8695572019,
-0.1941307932,
-0.4851837754,
0.860073626,
0.1093312129,
0.5610058904,
0.3819539845,
0.1484077722,
0.227757901,
-0.449431181,
-0.4034083784,
0.1634957492,
-0.4439007342,
0.2832324505,
-0.0070918892,
-0.0480539389,
-0.0104785664,
0.4606629014,
-0.3916677833,
-0.4818542004,
-0.4336171746,
-0.4984126687,
0.4652243853,
-0.1253142953,
-0.0962642431,
-0.060066238,
-0.979839623,
-0.4217422903,
-0.4936087728,
-0.0892377272,
-0.045043122,
0.2588573098,
-0.3754381239,
0.2942098379,
-0.1530315578,
0.2303064317,
0.3819214106,
-0.1135631055,
0.6883164048,
-0.5726884604,
-0.1055493727,
-0.0896365717,
0.5456991196,
0.4253811538,
-0.2174414545,
0.0085393479,
-0.2484592497,
-0.0289034508,
0.1608899236,
-0.5878472328,
-0.7267186642,
0.0279388595,
-0.3582530916,
-0.2006744444,
0.1173856407,
-0.7862650752,
-0.5917842984,
-0.605504334,
0.6360744834,
-0.3080842197,
-0.4239643812,
-0.1957892776,
0.1068638936,
-0.1336485595,
0.5528236032,
-0.71283108,
0.1265663803,
0.4802841842,
0.6278094649,
-0.4051110446,
-0.3143422902,
-0.9647223353,
0.0666692778,
-0.3130122423,
0.5841710567,
-0.6918603778,
-0.2764875889,
-0.0366045125,
0.0534857847,
-0.1655850708,
-0.5042758584,
0.1508055329,
-0.6339178681,
0.3031612039,
-0.4387935996,
-0.2973276377,
-0.6176284552,
0.3540763557,
-0.9171907902,
0.6313923597,
-0.0775522217,
-0.7553320527,
0.5024662614,
-0.32431674,
-0.4741750956,
-0.0827375501,
-0.2770086825,
-0.3955565691,
0.3370240629,
0.3117114305,
0.6256837845,
-0.0110621415,
0.2428640574,
-0.3446260691,
-0.2096198797,
0.2568773627,
-0.5455302596,
0.3217099607,
0.2038993388,
-0.1149776354,
0.5354748368,
-0.6914519668,
-0.2674870491,
-0.0934893191,
-0.413554877,
-0.2474106699,
-0.3006807268,
0.1480973512,
0.5976952314,
0.1691019982,
-0.5757877231,
-0.0559697971,
0.328971982,
0.2343373001,
0.7451826334,
-0.0372800454,
0.537638545,
-0.443570286,
0.2532072961,
0.4677456319,
0.0851020515,
-0.4805877805,
-0.0739051849,
-0.9867159128,
-0.7637986541,
0.1704015881,
0.1636951566,
-1.2834187746,
0.0473314971,
-0.1761632711,
-0.1946556717,
-0.2671694458,
0.3974895477,
0.4649027884,
0.3685405254,
0.5679430962,
-0.4245405197,
-0.5009174943,
-0.9218268394,
0.4957550168,
0.1796617657,
0.2101951838,
0.3147126734,
0.5368916988,
-0.1776678264,
0.4585189521,
-0.436029166,
-0.6969195008,
-0.3151540756,
0.4297719598,
-0.1664213687,
0.7240803838,
0.2001926899,
-1.3526598215,
-0.3313116133,
0.0081503531,
-0.7458247542,
0.2633346915,
-0.4644754529,
0.1047252491,
0.0969376788,
0.708445847,
-0.1011540741,
-0.0079097552,
0.8394908309,
-0.2119753361,
-0.0137098692,
-0.604078114,
0.4106483161,
-0.8255898356,
-0.0466317236,
0.1508281529,
-0.3362789154,
-0.5582464337,
-0.0193749089,
0.4054604769,
-0.296304673,
-0.4886565804,
0.4171232581,
-0.4659022689,
-0.0023618334,
-0.2102067322,
0.111763522,
0.1093240529,
0.9774223566,
0.1021215469,
0.7128526568,
0.4834920466,
-0.5492424965,
0.1809055358,
0.18033427,
-0.0231418945,
0.6914023161,
-0.1009848341,
-0.0008018779,
-0.3059136868,
0.4054554701,
-1.2515382767,
-0.3247822225,
0.1499413848,
-0.3446410894,
0.4954122305,
0.0615050979,
-0.3161182106,
0.1349029541,
-0.4087890387,
0.9423499107,
-0.0374246389,
-0.9524991512,
0.8591040373,
0.2236056775,
-0.0202500988,
-0.6303321123,
-0.5239079595,
-0.4921315014,
-0.0629688501,
-0.359682411,
0.3580355346,
-0.1576635092,
0.3223105073,
-0.0522267148,
-0.3703946471,
-0.2243996263,
-0.0764801875,
0.4747944772,
0.233449012,
0.1025943309,
0.5078584552,
-0.1052778959,
-0.3848246336,
-0.074804917,
0.0721510872,
0.568551302,
-0.1643012166,
-0.5793072581,
-0.4161971807,
0.7365142703,
0.5328896046,
-0.5339047313,
0.2937858701,
1.0602064133,
-0.257761389,
0.1262204349,
-0.703686893,
-0.3445161879,
-0.4502927363,
0.3682813048,
-0.3172938228,
-1.0524858236,
0.3239850402,
-0.1902996749,
-0.017353015,
0.1819484383,
0.1439332217,
-0.2642348111,
1.0573279858,
0.9210496545,
0.1865121871,
0.5601316094,
-0.3495189846,
0.1074905396,
-0.8499762416,
-0.6620358229,
0.1588017344,
-0.3831385374,
-0.5164692998,
-0.9084098339,
0.4315934181,
-0.0339205749,
-0.2236006707,
-0.0722015873,
-0.1265180409,
0.4122539461,
0.652844131,
0.4499331415,
0.451259017,
0.1982686222,
-0.1872013062,
-0.1420023739,
-0.7588612437,
0.1621435434,
0.9291162491,
0.082469821,
0.6044210196,
0.1398905814,
0.7715796828,
0.658205986,
0.3147498965,
-0.5407957435,
0.471155107,
-0.2268884182,
-0.5057898164,
0.145859316,
-0.4699655175,
-0.6828052402,
0.7957530618,
-0.681086719,
-0.0756436139,
0.5899766684,
0.4037429988,
-0.0851038322,
0.2504645586,
-0.6537832618,
0.6974306703,
-0.1325144023,
-0.6883226037,
-0.5607638955,
-0.6134179235,
0.3548399806,
-0.1423936635,
0.385276407,
0.0320592485,
-0.163657546,
0.5521674156,
0.0352651924,
1.1046862602,
-0.0967062041,
0.2927271724,
-0.0387223177,
0.2708296776,
0.1060225144,
0.0838662833,
0.3545791209,
0.0643545985,
-0.2315866053,
-0.6332861781,
-0.5101157427,
0.9282182455,
-0.5540310144,
-0.3636874557,
-0.7040327787,
-0.6783249974,
-0.4059259892,
0.1429966986,
-0.130932495,
0.8774111271,
0.1288903058,
0.4990281463,
0.7650818825,
-0.0308387168,
0.4396637976,
0.3311570883,
-0.0774135366,
-0.838650465,
1.4249054193,
-0.341752708,
0.2049143165,
0.6482065916,
0.053500291,
-0.3727132082,
-0.1709121168,
-0.2253670692,
0.5274083018,
-0.9786639214,
-0.1817023158,
-0.4805186689,
0.1095697954,
0.2046320438,
-0.4462838769,
-0.4793499708,
-0.1496156156,
-0.3884851635,
-0.1739563495,
-0.2193865031,
0.8615014553,
-0.548815012,
-0.180388689,
-0.7034361362,
0.2217451781,
0.6653235555,
0.1919464916,
0.0520804934,
-0.0412481725,
-0.0919717327,
-0.2278420031,
-0.2749842107,
-0.4611383677,
0.4010495245,
0.1500755847,
0.6658788919,
0.3763966858,
0.1654798239,
0.5046872497,
-0.0382707231,
0.5461975932,
0.9083239436,
-0.7650675178,
0.1890656799,
-0.082411021,
0.2341954559,
0.6939316392,
0.7644745111,
-0.3452803791,
0.2690360248,
-0.4451883435,
-0.743901372,
0.5471925735,
0.0123853814,
0.005786025,
-0.0610598028,
-0.0992212221,
0.4241493046,
0.4817983508,
-0.8629900217,
-0.3216564655,
-0.4589056075,
-0.3077816367,
-0.3294816017,
-0.2729942501,
-0.5170453787,
-0.2389471382,
0.3638402224,
-0.4394854605,
0.2951905727,
0.3425622284,
-0.4466764629,
0.2092657387,
0.1380088329,
0.8384816051,
0.6040561199,
-0.0776429474,
0.681316793,
0.1044606715,
-0.1526549011,
0.2328279614,
0.1046417728,
0.2250784636,
-0.4050801098,
0.4898780286,
0.6558172107,
0.5649926662,
-0.6236245036,
0.7049131393,
0.0442644805,
-0.3756019473,
-0.0922340974,
-0.1736758798,
-0.1201320142,
0.5740783215,
0.4539413154,
0.4566967189,
-0.001853979,
-0.6139832139,
0.4265691936,
0.2951131463,
-0.8537768722,
-0.2596543431,
0.4815104902,
0.798825264,
0.2146152407,
0.3720466495,
-0.4030833542,
-0.4425333142,
0.1995817125,
0.3551810086,
0.5279501081,
-0.0384429246,
0.4802865982,
0.4451822639,
-0.0451346226,
0.0400585271,
0.235108465,
-0.5716263056,
-0.6415557265,
-0.4653184116,
-0.1036540717,
-0.3842417002,
0.009016633,
-0.7140756845,
-0.2343218029,
-0.5482959151,
0.1043214202,
-0.3136334121,
-0.1129668951,
-0.7354276776,
0.1381674111,
0.1927546859,
0.3564985693,
-0.9798480272,
0.686860323,
0.6913431287,
-0.5187701583,
-0.2788647115,
-0.2129800618,
0.1599716842,
-0.6464893222,
0.9658864737,
0.4002652168,
-0.2566426396,
-0.3804884851,
-0.1526055634,
-0.8257128,
1.2007857561,
0.2280395627,
-0.237537995,
0.2855945528,
-0.1615742892,
0.0726493672,
-0.7359178662,
0.0614498705,
0.0202828869,
0.3245846927,
0.3324269354,
-0.4636243582,
0.0885571316,
-0.3031726182,
-0.2090937048,
0.1046602428,
-0.7520487905,
0.9203813076,
-0.3198164999,
-0.2651472688,
-0.409160763,
0.6693570614,
0.1346022338,
0.4668069482,
0.7385651469,
0.1563994735,
0.7389876842,
-0.1386343688,
0.9278019071,
-0.190710783,
0.4080908298,
1.2267959118,
-0.0596737303,
0.7058844566,
0.4773001671,
0.2365142256,
0.2020325959,
0.3862719536,
0.0903072432,
0.8557811379,
-0.378226459,
-0.4397354722,
-0.9799553752,
-0.2275927514,
-0.1836857796,
0.4293720126,
0.2787892222,
-0.3163411915,
-0.3646980524,
0.2690943182,
-0.3346720338,
0.3154972494,
-0.2887013257,
0.6174411774,
-0.1565457582,
-0.4412594438,
0.3562982976,
-0.43420434,
0.878668189,
-0.5188850164,
-0.4486581981,
-0.321128726,
0.1951582581,
-0.4022817612,
-0.4831817746,
-0.0093721095,
-0.6387169957,
-0.3760718703,
-0.3570489883,
0.5564333797,
-0.6827754378,
-0.4472328126,
0.3268914521,
0.5294806361,
-0.3062383235,
-0.047476925,
-0.3665993214,
0.2548095584,
0.2656548321,
0.2116179615,
0.5266001821,
0.143156305,
0.1712757051,
0.8774952292,
0.5546319485,
-0.2166227698,
-0.1412359476,
-0.1243386567,
1.0198038816,
-0.6016876101,
-0.3922234476,
-0.2710624635,
0.4830224812,
-0.2539588809,
-0.2397039086,
0.4294080734,
0.5593761802,
1.0930806398,
-0.1994999051,
0.4687299132,
0.2727718949,
0.2427173108,
-0.5467531681,
0.2291576713,
-0.8988555074,
0.0903988332,
-0.0059815394,
-0.7895424962,
-0.3801306188,
0.7173830271,
-0.1094315946,
0.0210432578,
0.9270694852,
0.6849325299,
-0.3317403495,
0.0184407402,
0.4714414775,
-0.2605144083,
0.305705905,
0.5696210265,
0.6659331322,
-0.247726962,
0.8059446216,
-0.6701232195,
-0.2246492505,
-0.3603215814,
-0.8073085546,
-0.8131351471,
-1.2074400187,
-0.5995699167,
0.1103796959,
-0.1789999604,
1.1230882406,
1.098806262,
-0.7097586989,
0.0123689035,
0.2233207226,
0.1174914539,
-0.5263208151,
-0.1661441922,
0.3353303373,
-0.2595511079,
-0.6248745918,
0.4746113718,
0.3119422793,
-0.1308448464,
-0.376403749,
-0.1613020897,
-0.2796504498,
-0.1400563717,
0.9090661407,
0.188025251,
-0.5937070847,
-0.5202935934,
-0.3794323802,
0.0050165025,
0.2977489531,
1.1470251083,
-0.7639436126,
0.8427677751,
0.5422278047,
0.6447373033,
0.7406712174,
0.0588526055,
0.4196741581,
-1.0082541704,
0.1742679626,
-0.0529688224,
0.5705673099,
0.6897254586,
0.0755877048,
0.5890221596,
0.3419930935,
-0.2722730041,
-0.3617217839,
0.4227776825,
-1.396753788,
-0.2346904576,
0.9395148158,
-0.2545670867,
0.1426665336,
-0.1940582842,
-0.217062965,
0.0546058789,
-0.5298585892,
0.6113907099,
0.497148484,
-0.3489298224,
-0.4985949397,
-0.144233942,
0.221777454,
0.2990352511,
-0.5035846233,
-0.0092578856,
0.7607694268,
0.308935374,
0.498367995,
0.3885965347,
-0.0669192821,
0.3162607551,
0.1000791937,
0.0770690665,
-0.6059358716,
-0.6243484616,
-0.2996991873,
0.7663632035,
-0.2606071234,
-0.393509686
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.