title
stringlengths
6
55
author
stringlengths
4
15
school
stringclasses
18 values
sentence_spacy
stringlengths
20
2.65k
sentence_str
stringlengths
20
2.65k
original_publication_date
int64
-350
1.99k
corpus_edition_date
int64
1.65k
2.02k
sentence_length
int64
20
2.65k
sentence_lowered
stringlengths
20
2.65k
tokenized_txt
stringlengths
2
3.76k
lemmatized_str
stringlengths
17
2.67k
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Suppose we required each of the things mentioned to be done according to written rules, and we required the person elected or appointed to office by lot, on the basis of chance, to oversee these written rules of ours: what then if this person were to take no notice of what is written down, in order either to profit in some way or to do some personal favor, and were to take it upon himself to do different things, contrary to these, when he possesses no knowledge?
Suppose we required each of the things mentioned to be done according to written rules, and we required the person elected or appointed to office by lot, on the basis of chance, to oversee these written rules of ours: what then if this person were to take no notice of what is written down, in order either to profit in some way or to do some personal favor, and were to take it upon himself to do different things, contrary to these, when he possesses no knowledge?
-350
1,997
466
suppose we required each of the things mentioned to be done according to written rules, and we required the person elected or appointed to office by lot, on the basis of chance, to oversee these written rules of ours: what then if this person were to take no notice of what is written down, in order either to profit in some way or to do some personal favor, and were to take it upon himself to do different things, contrary to these, when he possesses no knowledge?
['suppose', 'we', 'required', 'each', 'of', 'the', 'things', 'mentioned', 'to', 'be', 'done', 'according', 'to', 'written', 'rules', 'and', 'we', 'required', 'the', 'person', 'elected', 'or', 'appointed', 'to', 'office', 'by', 'lot', 'on', 'the', 'basis', 'of', 'chance', 'to', 'oversee', 'these', 'written', 'rules', 'of', 'ours', 'what', 'then', 'if', 'this', 'person', 'were', 'to', 'take', 'no', 'notice', 'of', 'what', 'is', 'written', 'down', 'in', 'order', 'either', 'to', 'profit', 'in', 'some', 'way', 'or', 'to', 'do', 'some', 'personal', 'favor', 'and', 'were', 'to', 'take', 'it', 'upon', 'himself', 'to', 'do', 'different', 'things', 'contrary', 'to', 'these', 'when', 'he', 'possesses', 'no', 'knowledge']
suppose -PRON- require each of the thing mention to be do accord to write rule , and -PRON- require the person elect or appoint to office by lot , on the basis of chance , to oversee these write rule of our : what then if this person be to take no notice of what be write down , in order either to profit in some way or to do some personal favor , and be to take -PRON- upon -PRON- to do different thing , contrary to these , when -PRON- possess no knowledge ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Would this not be an evil still greater than the previous one?
Would this not be an evil still greater than the previous one?
-350
1,997
62
would this not be an evil still greater than the previous one?
['would', 'this', 'not', 'be', 'an', 'evil', 'still', 'greater', 'than', 'the', 'previous', 'one']
Would this not be an evil still great than the previous one ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yes, for if, I imagine, contrary to the laws that have been established on the basis of much experiment, with some advisers or other having given advice on each subject in an attractive way, and having persuaded the majority to pass them if someone were brazen enough to act contrary to these, he would be committing a mistake many times greater than the other, and would overturn all expert activity to a still greater degree than do the written rules.
Yes, for if, I imagine, contrary to the laws that have been established on the basis of much experiment, with some advisers or other having given advice on each subject in an attractive way, and having persuaded the majority to pass them if someone were brazen enough to act contrary to these, he would be committing a mistake many times greater than the other, and would overturn all expert activity to a still greater degree than do the written rules.
-350
1,997
453
yes, for if, i imagine, contrary to the laws that have been established on the basis of much experiment, with some advisers or other having given advice on each subject in an attractive way, and having persuaded the majority to pass them if someone were brazen enough to act contrary to these, he would be committing a mistake many times greater than the other, and would overturn all expert activity to a still greater degree than do the written rules.
['yes', 'for', 'if', 'imagine', 'contrary', 'to', 'the', 'laws', 'that', 'have', 'been', 'established', 'on', 'the', 'basis', 'of', 'much', 'experiment', 'with', 'some', 'advisers', 'or', 'other', 'having', 'given', 'advice', 'on', 'each', 'subject', 'in', 'an', 'attractive', 'way', 'and', 'having', 'persuaded', 'the', 'majority', 'to', 'pass', 'them', 'if', 'someone', 'were', 'brazen', 'enough', 'to', 'act', 'contrary', 'to', 'these', 'he', 'would', 'be', 'committing', 'mistake', 'many', 'times', 'greater', 'than', 'the', 'other', 'and', 'would', 'overturn', 'all', 'expert', 'activity', 'to', 'still', 'greater', 'degree', 'than', 'do', 'the', 'written', 'rules']
yes , for if , -PRON- imagine , contrary to the law that have be establish on the basis of much experiment , with some adviser or other have give advice on each subject in an attractive way , and have persuade the majority to pass -PRON- if someone be brazen enough to act contrary to these , -PRON- would be commit a mistake many time great than the other , and would overturn all expert activity to a still great degree than do the write rule .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yes how would he not?
Yes how would he not?
-350
1,997
21
yes how would he not?
['yes', 'how', 'would', 'he', 'not']
yes how would -PRON- not ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
For these reasons, then, the second best method of proceeding, for those who establish laws and written rules about anything whatever, is to allow neither individual nor mass ever to do anything contrary to these anything whatsoever.
For these reasons, then, the second best method of proceeding, for those who establish laws and written rules about anything whatever, is to allow neither individual nor mass ever to do anything contrary to these anything whatsoever.
-350
1,997
233
for these reasons, then, the second best method of proceeding, for those who establish laws and written rules about anything whatever, is to allow neither individual nor mass ever to do anything contrary to these anything whatsoever.
['for', 'these', 'reasons', 'then', 'the', 'second', 'best', 'method', 'of', 'proceeding', 'for', 'those', 'who', 'establish', 'laws', 'and', 'written', 'rules', 'about', 'anything', 'whatever', 'is', 'to', 'allow', 'neither', 'individual', 'nor', 'mass', 'ever', 'to', 'do', 'anything', 'contrary', 'to', 'these', 'anything', 'whatsoever']
for these reason , then , the second good method of proceeding , for those who establish law and write rule about anything whatever , be to allow neither individual nor mass ever to do anything contrary to these anything whatsoever .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well, imitations of the truth of each and every thing would be these, wouldn't they the things issuing from those who know which have been written down so far as they can be?
Well, imitations of the truth of each and every thing would be these, wouldn't they the things issuing from those who know which have been written down so far as they can be?
-350
1,997
174
well, imitations of the truth of each and every thing would be these, wouldn't they the things issuing from those who know which have been written down so far as they can be?
['well', 'imitations', 'of', 'the', 'truth', 'of', 'each', 'and', 'every', 'thing', 'would', 'be', 'these', 'wouldn', 'they', 'the', 'things', 'issuing', 'from', 'those', 'who', 'know', 'which', 'have', 'been', 'written', 'down', 'so', 'far', 'as', 'they', 'can', 'be']
well , imitation of the truth of each and every thing would be these , would not -PRON- the thing issue from those who know which have be write down so far as -PRON- can be ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Now we said if we remember that the knowledgeable person, the one who really possesses the art of statesmanship, would do many things in relation to his own activity by using his expertise, without taking any notice of the written laws, when other things appear to him to be better, contrary to those that have been written down by him and given as orders to people who are not currently with him.
Now we said if we remember that the knowledgeable person, the one who really possesses the art of statesmanship, would do many things in relation to his own activity by using his expertise, without taking any notice of the written laws, when other things appear to him to be better, contrary to those that have been written down by him and given as orders to people who are not currently with him.
-350
1,997
397
now we said if we remember that the knowledgeable person, the one who really possesses the art of statesmanship, would do many things in relation to his own activity by using his expertise, without taking any notice of the written laws, when other things appear to him to be better, contrary to those that have been written down by him and given as orders to people who are not currently with him.
['now', 'we', 'said', 'if', 'we', 'remember', 'that', 'the', 'knowledgeable', 'person', 'the', 'one', 'who', 'really', 'possesses', 'the', 'art', 'of', 'statesmanship', 'would', 'do', 'many', 'things', 'in', 'relation', 'to', 'his', 'own', 'activity', 'by', 'using', 'his', 'expertise', 'without', 'taking', 'any', 'notice', 'of', 'the', 'written', 'laws', 'when', 'other', 'things', 'appear', 'to', 'him', 'to', 'be', 'better', 'contrary', 'to', 'those', 'that', 'have', 'been', 'written', 'down', 'by', 'him', 'and', 'given', 'as', 'orders', 'to', 'people', 'who', 'are', 'not', 'currently', 'with', 'him']
now -PRON- say if -PRON- remember that the knowledgeable person , the one who really possess the art of statesmanship , would do many thing in relation to -PRON- own activity by use -PRON- expertise , without take any notice of the write law , when other thing appear to -PRON- to be well , contrary to those that have be write down by -PRON- and give as order to people who be not currently with -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yes, that's what we said.
Yes, that's what we said.
-350
1,997
25
yes, that's what we said.
['yes', 'that', 'what', 'we', 'said']
yes , that be what -PRON- say .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well, any individual whatever or any large collection of people whatever, for whom there are actually written laws established, who undertake to do anything at all that is different, contrary to these, on the grounds that it is better, will be doing, won't they, the same thing as that true expert, so far as they can?
Well, any individual whatever or any large collection of people whatever, for whom there are actually written laws established, who undertake to do anything at all that is different, contrary to these, on the grounds that it is better, will be doing, won't they, the same thing as that true expert, so far as they can?
-350
1,997
318
well, any individual whatever or any large collection of people whatever, for whom there are actually written laws established, who undertake to do anything at all that is different, contrary to these, on the grounds that it is better, will be doing, won't they, the same thing as that true expert, so far as they can?
['well', 'any', 'individual', 'whatever', 'or', 'any', 'large', 'collection', 'of', 'people', 'whatever', 'for', 'whom', 'there', 'are', 'actually', 'written', 'laws', 'established', 'who', 'undertake', 'to', 'do', 'anything', 'at', 'all', 'that', 'is', 'different', 'contrary', 'to', 'these', 'on', 'the', 'grounds', 'that', 'it', 'is', 'better', 'will', 'be', 'doing', 'won', 'they', 'the', 'same', 'thing', 'as', 'that', 'true', 'expert', 'so', 'far', 'as', 'they', 'can']
well , any individual whatever or any large collection of people whatever , for whom there be actually write law establish , who undertake to do anything at all that be different , contrary to these , on the ground that -PRON- be well , will be do , will not -PRON- , the same thing as that true expert , so far as -PRON- can ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well then, if they were to do such a thing without having expert knowledge, they would be undertaking to imitate what is true, but would imitate it altogether badly;
Well then, if they were to do such a thing without having expert knowledge, they would be undertaking to imitate what is true, but would imitate it altogether badly;
-350
1,997
165
well then, if they were to do such a thing without having expert knowledge, they would be undertaking to imitate what is true, but would imitate it altogether badly;
['well', 'then', 'if', 'they', 'were', 'to', 'do', 'such', 'thing', 'without', 'having', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'they', 'would', 'be', 'undertaking', 'to', 'imitate', 'what', 'is', 'true', 'but', 'would', 'imitate', 'it', 'altogether', 'badly']
well then , if -PRON- be to do such a thing without have expert knowledge , -PRON- would be undertake to imitate what be true , but would imitate -PRON- altogether badly ;
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
but if they did it on the basis of expertise, this is no longer imitation but that very thing that is most truly what it sets out to be?
but if they did it on the basis of expertise, this is no longer imitation but that very thing that is most truly what it sets out to be?
-350
1,997
136
but if they did it on the basis of expertise, this is no longer imitation but that very thing that is most truly what it sets out to be?
['but', 'if', 'they', 'did', 'it', 'on', 'the', 'basis', 'of', 'expertise', 'this', 'is', 'no', 'longer', 'imitation', 'but', 'that', 'very', 'thing', 'that', 'is', 'most', 'truly', 'what', 'it', 'sets', 'out', 'to', 'be']
but if -PRON- do -PRON- on the basis of expertise , this be no long imitation but that very thing that be most truly what -PRON- set out to be ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
I agree completely I think.
I agree completely I think.
-350
1,997
27
i agree completely i think.
['agree', 'completely', 'think']
-PRON- agree completely -PRON- think .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
But it is established as agreed between us
But it is established as agreed between us
-350
1,997
42
but it is established as agreed between us
['but', 'it', 'is', 'established', 'as', 'agreed', 'between', 'us']
but -PRON- be establish as agree between -PRON-
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
we agreed to it before, at any rate that no large collection of people is capable of acquiring any sort of expertise
we agreed to it before, at any rate that no large collection of people is capable of acquiring any sort of expertise
-350
1,997
116
we agreed to it before, at any rate that no large collection of people is capable of acquiring any sort of expertise
['we', 'agreed', 'to', 'it', 'before', 'at', 'any', 'rate', 'that', 'no', 'large', 'collection', 'of', 'people', 'is', 'capable', 'of', 'acquiring', 'any', 'sort', 'of', 'expertise']
-PRON- agree to -PRON- before , at any rate that no large collection of people be capable of acquire any sort of expertise
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yes, it remains agreed.
Yes, it remains agreed.
-350
1,997
23
yes, it remains agreed.
['yes', 'it', 'remains', 'agreed']
yes , -PRON- remain agree .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Then if some sort of kingly expertise exists, neither the collection of people that consists of the rich, nor all the people together, could ever acquire this expert knowledge of statesmanship.
Then if some sort of kingly expertise exists, neither the collection of people that consists of the rich, nor all the people together, could ever acquire this expert knowledge of statesmanship.
-350
1,997
193
then if some sort of kingly expertise exists, neither the collection of people that consists of the rich, nor all the people together, could ever acquire this expert knowledge of statesmanship.
['then', 'if', 'some', 'sort', 'of', 'kingly', 'expertise', 'exists', 'neither', 'the', 'collection', 'of', 'people', 'that', 'consists', 'of', 'the', 'rich', 'nor', 'all', 'the', 'people', 'together', 'could', 'ever', 'acquire', 'this', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'of', 'statesmanship']
then if some sort of kingly expertise exist , neither the collection of people that consist of the rich , nor all the people together , could ever acquire this expert knowledge of statesmanship .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
The requirement, then, as it seems, for all constitutions of this sort, if they are going to produce a good imitation of that true constitution of one man ruling with expertise, so far as they can, is that given that they have their laws they must never do anything contrary to what is written or to ancestral customs.
The requirement, then, as it seems, for all constitutions of this sort, if they are going to produce a good imitation of that true constitution of one man ruling with expertise, so far as they can, is that given that they have their laws they must never do anything contrary to what is written or to ancestral customs.
-350
1,997
318
the requirement, then, as it seems, for all constitutions of this sort, if they are going to produce a good imitation of that true constitution of one man ruling with expertise, so far as they can, is that given that they have their laws they must never do anything contrary to what is written or to ancestral customs.
['the', 'requirement', 'then', 'as', 'it', 'seems', 'for', 'all', 'constitutions', 'of', 'this', 'sort', 'if', 'they', 'are', 'going', 'to', 'produce', 'good', 'imitation', 'of', 'that', 'true', 'constitution', 'of', 'one', 'man', 'ruling', 'with', 'expertise', 'so', 'far', 'as', 'they', 'can', 'is', 'that', 'given', 'that', 'they', 'have', 'their', 'laws', 'they', 'must', 'never', 'do', 'anything', 'contrary', 'to', 'what', 'is', 'written', 'or', 'to', 'ancestral', 'customs']
the requirement , then , as -PRON- seem , for all constitution of this sort , if -PRON- be go to produce a good imitation of that true constitution of one man rule with expertise , so far as -PRON- can , be that give that -PRON- have -PRON- law -PRON- must never do anything contrary to what be write or to ancestral custom .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
In that case, when the rich imitate it, then we shall call such a constitution an 'aristocracy'; when they take no notice of the laws, we shall call it an 'oligarchy'.
In that case, when the rich imitate it, then we shall call such a constitution an 'aristocracy'; when they take no notice of the laws, we shall call it an 'oligarchy'.
-350
1,997
167
in that case, when the rich imitate it, then we shall call such a constitution an 'aristocracy'; when they take no notice of the laws, we shall call it an 'oligarchy'.
['in', 'that', 'case', 'when', 'the', 'rich', 'imitate', 'it', 'then', 'we', 'shall', 'call', 'such', 'constitution', 'an', 'aristocracy', 'when', 'they', 'take', 'no', 'notice', 'of', 'the', 'laws', 'we', 'shall', 'call', 'it', 'an', 'oligarchy']
in that case , when the rich imitate -PRON- , then -PRON- shall call such a constitution an ' aristocracy ' ; when -PRON- take no notice of the law , -PRON- shall call -PRON- an ' oligarchy ' .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Alternatively: 'Well, wouldn't those laws written with the advice of people who know so far as is possible be imitations of the truth on each subject?'.
Alternatively: 'Well, wouldn't those laws written with the advice of people who know so far as is possible be imitations of the truth on each subject?'.
-350
1,997
152
alternatively: 'well, wouldn't those laws written with the advice of people who know so far as is possible be imitations of the truth on each subject?'.
['alternatively', 'well', 'wouldn', 'those', 'laws', 'written', 'with', 'the', 'advice', 'of', 'people', 'who', 'know', 'so', 'far', 'as', 'is', 'possible', 'be', 'imitations', 'of', 'the', 'truth', 'on', 'each', 'subject']
alternatively : ' well , would not those law write with the advice of people who know so far as be possible be imitation of the truth on each subject ? ' .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And, in turn, when one person rules according to laws, so imitating the person with expert knowledge, we shall call him a king, not distinguishing by name the one ruling on his own with expert knowledge or the one doing so on the basis of opinion, according to laws.
And, in turn, when one person rules according to laws, so imitating the person with expert knowledge, we shall call him a king, not distinguishing by name the one ruling on his own with expert knowledge or the one doing so on the basis of opinion, according to laws.
-350
1,997
266
and, in turn, when one person rules according to laws, so imitating the person with expert knowledge, we shall call him a king, not distinguishing by name the one ruling on his own with expert knowledge or the one doing so on the basis of opinion, according to laws.
['and', 'in', 'turn', 'when', 'one', 'person', 'rules', 'according', 'to', 'laws', 'so', 'imitating', 'the', 'person', 'with', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'we', 'shall', 'call', 'him', 'king', 'not', 'distinguishing', 'by', 'name', 'the', 'one', 'ruling', 'on', 'his', 'own', 'with', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'or', 'the', 'one', 'doing', 'so', 'on', 'the', 'basis', 'of', 'opinion', 'according', 'to', 'laws']
and , in turn , when one person rule accord to law , so imitate the person with expert knowledge , -PRON- shall call -PRON- a king , not distinguish by name the one ruling on -PRON- own with expert knowledge or the one do so on the basis of opinion , accord to law .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well then, if in fact some one person rules who really possesses expert knowledge, in every case he will be called by the same name of king and not by any other one.
Well then, if in fact some one person rules who really possesses expert knowledge, in every case he will be called by the same name of king and not by any other one.
-350
1,997
165
well then, if in fact some one person rules who really possesses expert knowledge, in every case he will be called by the same name of king and not by any other one.
['well', 'then', 'if', 'in', 'fact', 'some', 'one', 'person', 'rules', 'who', 'really', 'possesses', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'in', 'every', 'case', 'he', 'will', 'be', 'called', 'by', 'the', 'same', 'name', 'of', 'king', 'and', 'not', 'by', 'any', 'other', 'one']
well then , if in fact some one person rule who really possess expert knowledge , in every case -PRON- will be call by the same name of king and not by any other one .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
As a result of this the five names of what are now called constitutions have become only one.
As a result of this the five names of what are now called constitutions have become only one.
-350
1,997
93
as a result of this the five names of what are now called constitutions have become only one.
['as', 'result', 'of', 'this', 'the', 'five', 'names', 'of', 'what', 'are', 'now', 'called', 'constitutions', 'have', 'become', 'only', 'one']
as a result of this the five name of what be now call constitution have become only one .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And what of the case when some one ruler acts neither according to laws nor according to customs, but pretends to act like the person with expert knowledge, saying that after all one must do what is contrary to what has been written down if it is best, and there is some desire or other combined with ignorance controlling this imitation?
And what of the case when some one ruler acts neither according to laws nor according to customs, but pretends to act like the person with expert knowledge, saying that after all one must do what is contrary to what has been written down if it is best, and there is some desire or other combined with ignorance controlling this imitation?
-350
1,997
338
and what of the case when some one ruler acts neither according to laws nor according to customs, but pretends to act like the person with expert knowledge, saying that after all one must do what is contrary to what has been written down if it is best, and there is some desire or other combined with ignorance controlling this imitation?
['and', 'what', 'of', 'the', 'case', 'when', 'some', 'one', 'ruler', 'acts', 'neither', 'according', 'to', 'laws', 'nor', 'according', 'to', 'customs', 'but', 'pretends', 'to', 'act', 'like', 'the', 'person', 'with', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'saying', 'that', 'after', 'all', 'one', 'must', 'do', 'what', 'is', 'contrary', 'to', 'what', 'has', 'been', 'written', 'down', 'if', 'it', 'is', 'best', 'and', 'there', 'is', 'some', 'desire', 'or', 'other', 'combined', 'with', 'ignorance', 'controlling', 'this', 'imitation']
and what of the case when some one ruler act neither accord to law nor accord to custom , but pretend to act like the person with expert knowledge , say that after all one must do what be contrary to what have be write down if -PRON- be good , and there be some desire or other combine with ignorance control this imitation ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Surely in those circumstances we must call every such person a tyrant?
Surely in those circumstances we must call every such person a tyrant?
-350
1,997
70
surely in those circumstances we must call every such person a tyrant?
['surely', 'in', 'those', 'circumstances', 'we', 'must', 'call', 'every', 'such', 'person', 'tyrant']
surely in those circumstance -PRON- must call every such person a tyrant ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Then it is in this way that the tyrant has come about, we say, and the king, and oligarchy, and aristocracy, and democracy because people found themselves unable to put up with the idea of that single individual of ours as monarch, and refused to believe that there would ever come to be anyone who deserved to rule in such a way, so as to be willing and able to rule with virtue and expert knowledge, distributing what is just and right correctly to all.
Then it is in this way that the tyrant has come about, we say, and the king, and oligarchy, and aristocracy, and democracy because people found themselves unable to put up with the idea of that single individual of ours as monarch, and refused to believe that there would ever come to be anyone who deserved to rule in such a way, so as to be willing and able to rule with virtue and expert knowledge, distributing what is just and right correctly to all.
-350
1,997
455
then it is in this way that the tyrant has come about, we say, and the king, and oligarchy, and aristocracy, and democracy because people found themselves unable to put up with the idea of that single individual of ours as monarch, and refused to believe that there would ever come to be anyone who deserved to rule in such a way, so as to be willing and able to rule with virtue and expert knowledge, distributing what is just and right correctly to all.
['then', 'it', 'is', 'in', 'this', 'way', 'that', 'the', 'tyrant', 'has', 'come', 'about', 'we', 'say', 'and', 'the', 'king', 'and', 'oligarchy', 'and', 'aristocracy', 'and', 'democracy', 'because', 'people', 'found', 'themselves', 'unable', 'to', 'put', 'up', 'with', 'the', 'idea', 'of', 'that', 'single', 'individual', 'of', 'ours', 'as', 'monarch', 'and', 'refused', 'to', 'believe', 'that', 'there', 'would', 'ever', 'come', 'to', 'be', 'anyone', 'who', 'deserved', 'to', 'rule', 'in', 'such', 'way', 'so', 'as', 'to', 'be', 'willing', 'and', 'able', 'to', 'rule', 'with', 'virtue', 'and', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'distributing', 'what', 'is', 'just', 'and', 'right', 'correctly', 'to', 'all']
then -PRON- be in this way that the tyrant have come about , -PRON- say , and the king , and oligarchy , and aristocracy , and democracy because people find -PRON- unable to put up with the idea of that single individual of -PRON- as monarch , and refuse to believe that there would ever come to be anyone who deserve to rule in such a way , so as to be willing and able to rule with virtue and expert knowledge , distribute what be just and right correctly to all .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
They think that a person in such a position always mutilates, kills and generally maltreats whichever of us he wishes; although if there were to come to be someone of the sort we are describing, he would be prized and would govern a constitution that would alone be correct in the strict sense, steering it through in happiness.
They think that a person in such a position always mutilates, kills and generally maltreats whichever of us he wishes; although if there were to come to be someone of the sort we are describing, he would be prized and would govern a constitution that would alone be correct in the strict sense, steering it through in happiness.
-350
1,997
328
they think that a person in such a position always mutilates, kills and generally maltreats whichever of us he wishes; although if there were to come to be someone of the sort we are describing, he would be prized and would govern a constitution that would alone be correct in the strict sense, steering it through in happiness.
['they', 'think', 'that', 'person', 'in', 'such', 'position', 'always', 'mutilates', 'kills', 'and', 'generally', 'maltreats', 'whichever', 'of', 'us', 'he', 'wishes', 'although', 'if', 'there', 'were', 'to', 'come', 'to', 'be', 'someone', 'of', 'the', 'sort', 'we', 'are', 'describing', 'he', 'would', 'be', 'prized', 'and', 'would', 'govern', 'constitution', 'that', 'would', 'alone', 'be', 'correct', 'in', 'the', 'strict', 'sense', 'steering', 'it', 'through', 'in', 'happiness']
-PRON- think that a person in such a position always mutilate , kill and generally maltreat whichever of -PRON- -PRON- wish ; although if there be to come to be someone of the sort -PRON- be describe , -PRON- would be prize and would govern a constitution that would alone be correct in the strict sense , steer -PRON- through in happiness .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
But as things are, when as we say a king does not come to be in cities as a king bee is born in a hive, one individual immediately superior in body and mind
But as things are, when as we say a king does not come to be in cities as a king bee is born in a hive, one individual immediately superior in body and mind
-350
1,997
156
but as things are, when as we say a king does not come to be in cities as a king bee is born in a hive, one individual immediately superior in body and mind
['but', 'as', 'things', 'are', 'when', 'as', 'we', 'say', 'king', 'does', 'not', 'come', 'to', 'be', 'in', 'cities', 'as', 'king', 'bee', 'is', 'born', 'in', 'hive', 'one', 'individual', 'immediately', 'superior', 'in', 'body', 'and', 'mind']
but as thing be , when as -PRON- say a king do not come to be in city as a king bee be bear in a hive , one individual immediately superior in body and mind
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
so it seems for people to come together and write things down, chasing after the traces of the truest constitution.
so it seems for people to come together and write things down, chasing after the traces of the truest constitution.
-350
1,997
115
so it seems for people to come together and write things down, chasing after the traces of the truest constitution.
['so', 'it', 'seems', 'for', 'people', 'to', 'come', 'together', 'and', 'write', 'things', 'down', 'chasing', 'after', 'the', 'traces', 'of', 'the', 'truest', 'constitution']
so -PRON- seem for people to come together and write thing down , chase after the trace of the true constitution .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Do we wonder, then, Socrates, at all the evils that turn out to occur in such constitutions, and all those that will turn out for them, when a foundation of this sort underlies them, one of carrying out their functions according to written rules and customs without knowledge which if used by another expertise would manifestly destroy everything that comes about through it?
Do we wonder, then, Socrates, at all the evils that turn out to occur in such constitutions, and all those that will turn out for them, when a foundation of this sort underlies them, one of carrying out their functions according to written rules and customs without knowledge which if used by another expertise would manifestly destroy everything that comes about through it?
-350
1,997
375
do we wonder, then, socrates, at all the evils that turn out to occur in such constitutions, and all those that will turn out for them, when a foundation of this sort underlies them, one of carrying out their functions according to written rules and customs without knowledge which if used by another expertise would manifestly destroy everything that comes about through it?
['do', 'we', 'wonder', 'then', 'socrates', 'at', 'all', 'the', 'evils', 'that', 'turn', 'out', 'to', 'occur', 'in', 'such', 'constitutions', 'and', 'all', 'those', 'that', 'will', 'turn', 'out', 'for', 'them', 'when', 'foundation', 'of', 'this', 'sort', 'underlies', 'them', 'one', 'of', 'carrying', 'out', 'their', 'functions', 'according', 'to', 'written', 'rules', 'and', 'customs', 'without', 'knowledge', 'which', 'if', 'used', 'by', 'another', 'expertise', 'would', 'manifestly', 'destroy', 'everything', 'that', 'comes', 'about', 'through', 'it']
do -PRON- wonder , then , Socrates , at all the evil that turn out to occur in such constitution , and all those that will turn out for -PRON- , when a foundation of this sort underlie -PRON- , one of carry out -PRON- function accord to write rule and custom without knowledge which if use by another expertise would manifestly destroy everything that come about through -PRON- ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Or should we rather wonder at something else, namely at how strong a thing a city is by its nature?
Or should we rather wonder at something else, namely at how strong a thing a city is by its nature?
-350
1,997
99
or should we rather wonder at something else, namely at how strong a thing a city is by its nature?
['or', 'should', 'we', 'rather', 'wonder', 'at', 'something', 'else', 'namely', 'at', 'how', 'strong', 'thing', 'city', 'is', 'by', 'its', 'nature']
or should -PRON- rather wonder at something else , namely at how strong a thing a city be by -PRON- nature ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
For in fact cities have suffered such things now for time without limit, but nevertheless some particular ones among them are enduring and are not overturned.
For in fact cities have suffered such things now for time without limit, but nevertheless some particular ones among them are enduring and are not overturned.
-350
1,997
158
for in fact cities have suffered such things now for time without limit, but nevertheless some particular ones among them are enduring and are not overturned.
['for', 'in', 'fact', 'cities', 'have', 'suffered', 'such', 'things', 'now', 'for', 'time', 'without', 'limit', 'but', 'nevertheless', 'some', 'particular', 'ones', 'among', 'them', 'are', 'enduring', 'and', 'are', 'not', 'overturned']
for in fact city have suffer such thing now for time without limit , but nevertheless some particular one among -PRON- be endure and be not overturn .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yet many from time to time sink like ships, and perish, and have perished, and will perish.
Yet many from time to time sink like ships, and perish, and have perished, and will perish.
-350
1,997
91
yet many from time to time sink like ships, and perish, and have perished, and will perish.
['yet', 'many', 'from', 'time', 'to', 'time', 'sink', 'like', 'ships', 'and', 'perish', 'and', 'have', 'perished', 'and', 'will', 'perish']
yet many from time to time sink like ship , and perish , and have perish , and will perish .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Reading eniote kathaper at a. in the future through the depravity of their steersmen and sailors, who have acquired the greatest ignorance about the greatest things although they have no understanding at all about what belongs to the art of statesmanship, they think they have completely acquired this sort of expert knowledge, most clearly of them all.
Reading eniote kathaper at a. in the future through the depravity of their steersmen and sailors, who have acquired the greatest ignorance about the greatest things although they have no understanding at all about what belongs to the art of statesmanship, they think they have completely acquired this sort of expert knowledge, most clearly of them all.
-350
1,997
353
reading eniote kathaper at a. in the future through the depravity of their steersmen and sailors, who have acquired the greatest ignorance about the greatest things although they have no understanding at all about what belongs to the art of statesmanship, they think they have completely acquired this sort of expert knowledge, most clearly of them all.
['reading', 'eniote', 'kathaper', 'at', 'in', 'the', 'future', 'through', 'the', 'depravity', 'of', 'their', 'steersmen', 'and', 'sailors', 'who', 'have', 'acquired', 'the', 'greatest', 'ignorance', 'about', 'the', 'greatest', 'things', 'although', 'they', 'have', 'no', 'understanding', 'at', 'all', 'about', 'what', 'belongs', 'to', 'the', 'art', 'of', 'statesmanship', 'they', 'think', 'they', 'have', 'completely', 'acquired', 'this', 'sort', 'of', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'most', 'clearly', 'of', 'them', 'all']
read eniote kathaper at a. in the future through the depravity of -PRON- steersman and sailor , who have acquire the great ignorance about the great thing although -PRON- have no understanding at all about what belong to the art of statesmanship , -PRON- think -PRON- have completely acquire this sort of expert knowledge , most clearly of -PRON- all .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
So which of these 'incorrect' constitutions is least difficult to live with, given that they are all difficult, and which the heaviest to bear?
So which of these 'incorrect' constitutions is least difficult to live with, given that they are all difficult, and which the heaviest to bear?
-350
1,997
143
so which of these 'incorrect' constitutions is least difficult to live with, given that they are all difficult, and which the heaviest to bear?
['so', 'which', 'of', 'these', 'incorrect', 'constitutions', 'is', 'least', 'difficult', 'to', 'live', 'with', 'given', 'that', 'they', 'are', 'all', 'difficult', 'and', 'which', 'the', 'heaviest', 'to', 'bear']
so which of these ' incorrect ' constitution be least difficult to live with , give that -PRON- be all difficult , and which the heavy to bear ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Should we take a brief look at this, although a discussion of it will be a side issue in relation to the subject now set before us?
Should we take a brief look at this, although a discussion of it will be a side issue in relation to the subject now set before us?
-350
1,997
131
should we take a brief look at this, although a discussion of it will be a side issue in relation to the subject now set before us?
['should', 'we', 'take', 'brief', 'look', 'at', 'this', 'although', 'discussion', 'of', 'it', 'will', 'be', 'side', 'issue', 'in', 'relation', 'to', 'the', 'subject', 'now', 'set', 'before', 'us']
Should -PRON- take a brief look at this , although a discussion of -PRON- will be a side issue in relation to the subject now set before -PRON- ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And yet, at any rate in general, perhaps everything that all of us do is for the sake of this sort of thing.
And yet, at any rate in general, perhaps everything that all of us do is for the sake of this sort of thing.
-350
1,997
108
and yet, at any rate in general, perhaps everything that all of us do is for the sake of this sort of thing.
['and', 'yet', 'at', 'any', 'rate', 'in', 'general', 'perhaps', 'everything', 'that', 'all', 'of', 'us', 'do', 'is', 'for', 'the', 'sake', 'of', 'this', 'sort', 'of', 'thing']
and yet , at any rate in general , perhaps everything that all of -PRON- do be for the sake of this sort of thing .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
We should certainly look at it.
We should certainly look at it.
-350
1,997
31
we should certainly look at it.
['we', 'should', 'certainly', 'look', 'at', 'it']
-PRON- should certainly look at -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well then, what you should say is that, if there are three sorts of constitution, the same one is at the same time exceptionally difficult and easiest.
Well then, what you should say is that, if there are three sorts of constitution, the same one is at the same time exceptionally difficult and easiest.
-350
1,997
151
well then, what you should say is that, if there are three sorts of constitution, the same one is at the same time exceptionally difficult and easiest.
['well', 'then', 'what', 'you', 'should', 'say', 'is', 'that', 'if', 'there', 'are', 'three', 'sorts', 'of', 'constitution', 'the', 'same', 'one', 'is', 'at', 'the', 'same', 'time', 'exceptionally', 'difficult', 'and', 'easiest']
well then , what -PRON- should say be that , if there be three sort of constitution , the same one be at the same time exceptionally difficult and easy .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Just this: monarchy, I'm saying, rule by a few and rule by many
Just this: monarchy, I'm saying, rule by a few and rule by many
-350
1,997
63
just this: monarchy, i'm saying, rule by a few and rule by many
['just', 'this', 'monarchy', 'saying', 'rule', 'by', 'few', 'and', 'rule', 'by', 'many']
just this : monarchy , -PRON- be say , rule by a few and rule by many
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
there were these three sorts of constitution we were talking about at the beginning of the discussion with which we have now been deluged.
there were these three sorts of constitution we were talking about at the beginning of the discussion with which we have now been deluged.
-350
1,997
138
there were these three sorts of constitution we were talking about at the beginning of the discussion with which we have now been deluged.
['there', 'were', 'these', 'three', 'sorts', 'of', 'constitution', 'we', 'were', 'talking', 'about', 'at', 'the', 'beginning', 'of', 'the', 'discussion', 'with', 'which', 'we', 'have', 'now', 'been', 'deluged']
there be these three sort of constitution -PRON- be talk about at the beginning of the discussion with which -PRON- have now be deluge .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well then, let's divide these, each single one into two, and make six, separating off the correct one from these on its own, as a seventh.
Well then, let's divide these, each single one into two, and make six, separating off the correct one from these on its own, as a seventh.
-350
1,997
138
well then, let's divide these, each single one into two, and make six, separating off the correct one from these on its own, as a seventh.
['well', 'then', 'let', 'divide', 'these', 'each', 'single', 'one', 'into', 'two', 'and', 'make', 'six', 'separating', 'off', 'the', 'correct', 'one', 'from', 'these', 'on', 'its', 'own', 'as', 'seventh']
well then , let -PRON- divide these , each single one into two , and make six , separate off the correct one from these on -PRON- own , as a seventh .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Out of monarchy let's make kingly and tyrannical rule; out of the sort that doesn't involve many, we said there was the auspiciously named aristocracy, and oligarchy, while out of the sort that does involve many, there was democracy, which we then called single and put it down as such, but now in turn we must put this too down as double.
Out of monarchy let's make kingly and tyrannical rule; out of the sort that doesn't involve many, we said there was the auspiciously named aristocracy, and oligarchy, while out of the sort that does involve many, there was democracy, which we then called single and put it down as such, but now in turn we must put this too down as double.
-350
1,997
339
out of monarchy let's make kingly and tyrannical rule; out of the sort that doesn't involve many, we said there was the auspiciously named aristocracy, and oligarchy, while out of the sort that does involve many, there was democracy, which we then called single and put it down as such, but now in turn we must put this too down as double.
['out', 'of', 'monarchy', 'let', 'make', 'kingly', 'and', 'tyrannical', 'rule', 'out', 'of', 'the', 'sort', 'that', 'doesn', 'involve', 'many', 'we', 'said', 'there', 'was', 'the', 'auspiciously', 'named', 'aristocracy', 'and', 'oligarchy', 'while', 'out', 'of', 'the', 'sort', 'that', 'does', 'involve', 'many', 'there', 'was', 'democracy', 'which', 'we', 'then', 'called', 'single', 'and', 'put', 'it', 'down', 'as', 'such', 'but', 'now', 'in', 'turn', 'we', 'must', 'put', 'this', 'too', 'down', 'as', 'double']
out of monarchy let -PRON- make kingly and tyrannical rule ; out of the sort that do not involve many , -PRON- say there be the auspiciously name aristocracy , and oligarchy , while out of the sort that do involve many , there be democracy , which -PRON- then call single and put -PRON- down as such , but now in turn -PRON- must put this too down as double .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And dividing it by what criterion?
And dividing it by what criterion?
-350
1,997
34
and dividing it by what criterion?
['and', 'dividing', 'it', 'by', 'what', 'criterion']
and divide -PRON- by what criterion ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
By one that is no different from the other cases, even if its name, 'democracy', is now double; but certainly ruling according to laws and contrary to laws belongs both to this and to the others.
By one that is no different from the other cases, even if its name, 'democracy', is now double; but certainly ruling according to laws and contrary to laws belongs both to this and to the others.
-350
1,997
195
by one that is no different from the other cases, even if its name, 'democracy', is now double; but certainly ruling according to laws and contrary to laws belongs both to this and to the others.
['by', 'one', 'that', 'is', 'no', 'different', 'from', 'the', 'other', 'cases', 'even', 'if', 'its', 'name', 'democracy', 'is', 'now', 'double', 'but', 'certainly', 'ruling', 'according', 'to', 'laws', 'and', 'contrary', 'to', 'laws', 'belongs', 'both', 'to', 'this', 'and', 'to', 'the', 'others']
by one that be no different from the other case , even if -PRON- name , ' democracy ' , be now double ; but certainly rule accord to law and contrary to law belong both to this and to the other .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well, at the time when we were looking for the correct constitution, this cut was not useful, as we demonstrated in what we said before; but since we have now set that correct constitution to one side, and have put down the rest as necessary, in the case of these, certainly, the criterion of contrary to and abiding by laws cuts each of them in two.
Well, at the time when we were looking for the correct constitution, this cut was not useful, as we demonstrated in what we said before; but since we have now set that correct constitution to one side, and have put down the rest as necessary, in the case of these, certainly, the criterion of contrary to and abiding by laws cuts each of them in two.
-350
1,997
350
well, at the time when we were looking for the correct constitution, this cut was not useful, as we demonstrated in what we said before; but since we have now set that correct constitution to one side, and have put down the rest as necessary, in the case of these, certainly, the criterion of contrary to and abiding by laws cuts each of them in two.
['well', 'at', 'the', 'time', 'when', 'we', 'were', 'looking', 'for', 'the', 'correct', 'constitution', 'this', 'cut', 'was', 'not', 'useful', 'as', 'we', 'demonstrated', 'in', 'what', 'we', 'said', 'before', 'but', 'since', 'we', 'have', 'now', 'set', 'that', 'correct', 'constitution', 'to', 'one', 'side', 'and', 'have', 'put', 'down', 'the', 'rest', 'as', 'necessary', 'in', 'the', 'case', 'of', 'these', 'certainly', 'the', 'criterion', 'of', 'contrary', 'to', 'and', 'abiding', 'by', 'laws', 'cuts', 'each', 'of', 'them', 'in', 'two']
well , at the time when -PRON- be look for the correct constitution , this cut be not useful , as -PRON- demonstrate in what -PRON- say before ; but since -PRON- have now set that correct constitution to one side , and have put down the rest as necessary , in the case of these , certainly , the criterion of contrary to and abide by law cut each of -PRON- in two .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
It seems so, given what has now been said.
It seems so, given what has now been said.
-350
1,997
42
it seems so, given what has now been said.
['it', 'seems', 'so', 'given', 'what', 'has', 'now', 'been', 'said']
-PRON- seem so , give what have now be say .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well then, when monarchy is yoked in good written rules, which we call laws, it is best of all six; but if it is without laws, it is difficult and heaviest to live with.
Well then, when monarchy is yoked in good written rules, which we call laws, it is best of all six; but if it is without laws, it is difficult and heaviest to live with.
-350
1,997
169
well then, when monarchy is yoked in good written rules, which we call laws, it is best of all six; but if it is without laws, it is difficult and heaviest to live with.
['well', 'then', 'when', 'monarchy', 'is', 'yoked', 'in', 'good', 'written', 'rules', 'which', 'we', 'call', 'laws', 'it', 'is', 'best', 'of', 'all', 'six', 'but', 'if', 'it', 'is', 'without', 'laws', 'it', 'is', 'difficult', 'and', 'heaviest', 'to', 'live', 'with']
well then , when monarchy be yoke in good write rule , which -PRON- call law , -PRON- be good of all six ; but if -PRON- be without law , -PRON- be difficult and heavy to live with .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And as for the rule of those who are not many, just as few is in the middle between one and a large number, let's suppose it to be middling in both ways; while that of the mass, in its turn, we may suppose to be weak in all respects and capable of nothing of any importance either for good or for bad as judged in relation to the others, because under it offices are distributed in small portions among many people.
And as for the rule of those who are not many, just as few is in the middle between one and a large number, let's suppose it to be middling in both ways; while that of the mass, in its turn, we may suppose to be weak in all respects and capable of nothing of any importance either for good or for bad as judged in relation to the others, because under it offices are distributed in small portions among many people.
-350
1,997
415
and as for the rule of those who are not many, just as few is in the middle between one and a large number, let's suppose it to be middling in both ways; while that of the mass, in its turn, we may suppose to be weak in all respects and capable of nothing of any importance either for good or for bad as judged in relation to the others, because under it offices are distributed in small portions among many people.
['and', 'as', 'for', 'the', 'rule', 'of', 'those', 'who', 'are', 'not', 'many', 'just', 'as', 'few', 'is', 'in', 'the', 'middle', 'between', 'one', 'and', 'large', 'number', 'let', 'suppose', 'it', 'to', 'be', 'middling', 'in', 'both', 'ways', 'while', 'that', 'of', 'the', 'mass', 'in', 'its', 'turn', 'we', 'may', 'suppose', 'to', 'be', 'weak', 'in', 'all', 'respects', 'and', 'capable', 'of', 'nothing', 'of', 'any', 'importance', 'either', 'for', 'good', 'or', 'for', 'bad', 'as', 'judged', 'in', 'relation', 'to', 'the', 'others', 'because', 'under', 'it', 'offices', 'are', 'distributed', 'in', 'small', 'portions', 'among', 'many', 'people']
and as for the rule of those who be not many , just as few be in the middle between one and a large number , let -PRON- suppose -PRON- to be middling in both way ; while that of the mass , in -PRON- turn , -PRON- may suppose to be weak in all respect and capable of nothing of any importance either for good or for bad as judge in relation to the other , because under -PRON- office be distribute in small portion among many people .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
For this reason, if all the types of constitution are law abiding, it turns out to be the worst of them, but if all are contrary to law, the best; and if all are uncontrolled, living in a democracy takes the prize, but if they are ordered, life in it is least liveable, and in first place and best by far will be life in the first, except for the seventh.
For this reason, if all the types of constitution are law abiding, it turns out to be the worst of them, but if all are contrary to law, the best; and if all are uncontrolled, living in a democracy takes the prize, but if they are ordered, life in it is least liveable, and in first place and best by far will be life in the first, except for the seventh.
-350
1,997
355
for this reason, if all the types of constitution are law abiding, it turns out to be the worst of them, but if all are contrary to law, the best; and if all are uncontrolled, living in a democracy takes the prize, but if they are ordered, life in it is least liveable, and in first place and best by far will be life in the first, except for the seventh.
['for', 'this', 'reason', 'if', 'all', 'the', 'types', 'of', 'constitution', 'are', 'law', 'abiding', 'it', 'turns', 'out', 'to', 'be', 'the', 'worst', 'of', 'them', 'but', 'if', 'all', 'are', 'contrary', 'to', 'law', 'the', 'best', 'and', 'if', 'all', 'are', 'uncontrolled', 'living', 'in', 'democracy', 'takes', 'the', 'prize', 'but', 'if', 'they', 'are', 'ordered', 'life', 'in', 'it', 'is', 'least', 'liveable', 'and', 'in', 'first', 'place', 'and', 'best', 'by', 'far', 'will', 'be', 'life', 'in', 'the', 'first', 'except', 'for', 'the', 'seventh']
for this reason , if all the type of constitution be law abide , -PRON- turn out to be the bad of -PRON- , but if all be contrary to law , the good ; and if all be uncontrolled , live in a democracy take the prize , but if -PRON- be order , life in -PRON- be least liveable , and in first place and good by far will be life in the first , except for the seventh .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
For of all of them, that one we must separate out from the other constitutions, like a god from men.
For of all of them, that one we must separate out from the other constitutions, like a god from men.
-350
1,997
100
for of all of them, that one we must separate out from the other constitutions, like a god from men.
['for', 'of', 'all', 'of', 'them', 'that', 'one', 'we', 'must', 'separate', 'out', 'from', 'the', 'other', 'constitutions', 'like', 'god', 'from', 'men']
for of all of -PRON- , that one -PRON- must separate out from the other constitution , like a god from man .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
This seems both to follow, and to be, as you say; and we must do as you suggest.
This seems both to follow, and to be, as you say; and we must do as you suggest.
-350
1,997
80
this seems both to follow, and to be, as you say; and we must do as you suggest.
['this', 'seems', 'both', 'to', 'follow', 'and', 'to', 'be', 'as', 'you', 'say', 'and', 'we', 'must', 'do', 'as', 'you', 'suggest']
this seem both to follow , and to be , as -PRON- say ; and -PRON- must do as -PRON- suggest .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
So then we must also remove those who participate in all these constitutions, except for the one based on knowledge, as being, not statesmen, but experts in faction; we must say that, as presiding over insubstantial images, on the largest scale, they are themselves of the same sort, and that as the greatest imitators and magicians they turn out the be the greatest sophists among sophists.
So then we must also remove those who participate in all these constitutions, except for the one based on knowledge, as being, not statesmen, but experts in faction; we must say that, as presiding over insubstantial images, on the largest scale, they are themselves of the same sort, and that as the greatest imitators and magicians they turn out the be the greatest sophists among sophists.
-350
1,997
391
so then we must also remove those who participate in all these constitutions, except for the one based on knowledge, as being, not statesmen, but experts in faction; we must say that, as presiding over insubstantial images, on the largest scale, they are themselves of the same sort, and that as the greatest imitators and magicians they turn out the be the greatest sophists among sophists.
['so', 'then', 'we', 'must', 'also', 'remove', 'those', 'who', 'participate', 'in', 'all', 'these', 'constitutions', 'except', 'for', 'the', 'one', 'based', 'on', 'knowledge', 'as', 'being', 'not', 'statesmen', 'but', 'experts', 'in', 'faction', 'we', 'must', 'say', 'that', 'as', 'presiding', 'over', 'insubstantial', 'images', 'on', 'the', 'largest', 'scale', 'they', 'are', 'themselves', 'of', 'the', 'same', 'sort', 'and', 'that', 'as', 'the', 'greatest', 'imitators', 'and', 'magicians', 'they', 'turn', 'out', 'the', 'be', 'the', 'greatest', 'sophists', 'among', 'sophists']
so then -PRON- must also remove those who participate in all these constitution , except for the one base on knowledge , as be , not statesman , but expert in faction ; -PRON- must say that , as preside over insubstantial image , on the large scale , -PRON- be -PRON- of the same sort , and that as the great imitator and magician -PRON- turn out the be the great sophist among sophist .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
This term 'sophist' looks
This term 'sophist' looks
-350
1,997
25
this term 'sophist' looks
['this', 'term', 'sophist', 'looks']
this term ' sophist ' look
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
as if it has been only too correctly turned round against the so called experts in statesmanship.
as if it has been only too correctly turned round against the so called experts in statesmanship.
-350
1,997
97
as if it has been only too correctly turned round against the so called experts in statesmanship.
['as', 'if', 'it', 'has', 'been', 'only', 'too', 'correctly', 'turned', 'round', 'against', 'the', 'so', 'called', 'experts', 'in', 'statesmanship']
as if -PRON- have be only too correctly turn round against the so call expert in statesmanship .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
So: this is our play, as it were as we said just now that there was some band of centaurs and satyrs in view, one that we had to set apart from the expertise of the statesman; and now it has been set apart, as we have seen, with great difficulty.
So: this is our play, as it were as we said just now that there was some band of centaurs and satyrs in view, one that we had to set apart from the expertise of the statesman; and now it has been set apart, as we have seen, with great difficulty.
-350
1,997
246
so: this is our play, as it were as we said just now that there was some band of centaurs and satyrs in view, one that we had to set apart from the expertise of the statesman; and now it has been set apart, as we have seen, with great difficulty.
['so', 'this', 'is', 'our', 'play', 'as', 'it', 'were', 'as', 'we', 'said', 'just', 'now', 'that', 'there', 'was', 'some', 'band', 'of', 'centaurs', 'and', 'satyrs', 'in', 'view', 'one', 'that', 'we', 'had', 'to', 'set', 'apart', 'from', 'the', 'expertise', 'of', 'the', 'statesman', 'and', 'now', 'it', 'has', 'been', 'set', 'apart', 'as', 'we', 'have', 'seen', 'with', 'great', 'difficulty']
so : this be -PRON- play , as -PRON- be as -PRON- say just now that there be some band of centaur and satyr in view , one that -PRON- have to set apart from the expertise of the statesman ; and now -PRON- have be set apart , as -PRON- have see , with great difficulty .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yes, but there is something else remaining that is still more difficult than this, by reason of its being both more akin to the kingly class, and closer to it, and harder to understand; and we seem to me to be in a situation similar to that of those who refine gold.
Yes, but there is something else remaining that is still more difficult than this, by reason of its being both more akin to the kingly class, and closer to it, and harder to understand; and we seem to me to be in a situation similar to that of those who refine gold.
-350
1,997
266
yes, but there is something else remaining that is still more difficult than this, by reason of its being both more akin to the kingly class, and closer to it, and harder to understand; and we seem to me to be in a situation similar to that of those who refine gold.
['yes', 'but', 'there', 'is', 'something', 'else', 'remaining', 'that', 'is', 'still', 'more', 'difficult', 'than', 'this', 'by', 'reason', 'of', 'its', 'being', 'both', 'more', 'akin', 'to', 'the', 'kingly', 'class', 'and', 'closer', 'to', 'it', 'and', 'harder', 'to', 'understand', 'and', 'we', 'seem', 'to', 'me', 'to', 'be', 'in', 'situation', 'similar', 'to', 'that', 'of', 'those', 'who', 'refine', 'gold']
yes , but there be something else remain that be still more difficult than this , by reason of -PRON- be both more akin to the kingly class , and closer to -PRON- , and hard to understand ; and -PRON- seem to -PRON- to be in a situation similar to that of those who refine gold .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
I imagine that these craftsmen also begin by separating out earth, and stones, and many different things; and after these, there remain commingled with the gold those things that are akin to it, precious things and only removable with the use of fire: copper, silver, and sometimes adamant, the removal of which through repeated smelting and testing leaves the 'unalloyed' gold that people talk about there for us to see, itself alone by itself.
I imagine that these craftsmen also begin by separating out earth, and stones, and many different things; and after these, there remain commingled with the gold those things that are akin to it, precious things and only removable with the use of fire: copper, silver, and sometimes adamant, the removal of which through repeated smelting and testing leaves the 'unalloyed' gold that people talk about there for us to see, itself alone by itself.
-350
1,997
445
i imagine that these craftsmen also begin by separating out earth, and stones, and many different things; and after these, there remain commingled with the gold those things that are akin to it, precious things and only removable with the use of fire: copper, silver, and sometimes adamant, the removal of which through repeated smelting and testing leaves the 'unalloyed' gold that people talk about there for us to see, itself alone by itself.
['imagine', 'that', 'these', 'craftsmen', 'also', 'begin', 'by', 'separating', 'out', 'earth', 'and', 'stones', 'and', 'many', 'different', 'things', 'and', 'after', 'these', 'there', 'remain', 'commingled', 'with', 'the', 'gold', 'those', 'things', 'that', 'are', 'akin', 'to', 'it', 'precious', 'things', 'and', 'only', 'removable', 'with', 'the', 'use', 'of', 'fire', 'copper', 'silver', 'and', 'sometimes', 'adamant', 'the', 'removal', 'of', 'which', 'through', 'repeated', 'smelting', 'and', 'testing', 'leaves', 'the', 'unalloyed', 'gold', 'that', 'people', 'talk', 'about', 'there', 'for', 'us', 'to', 'see', 'itself', 'alone', 'by', 'itself']
-PRON- imagine that these craftsman also begin by separate out earth , and stone , and many different thing ; and after these , there remain commingle with the gold those thing that be akin to -PRON- , precious thing and only removable with the use of fire : copper , silver , and sometimes adamant , the removal of which through repeat smelting and testing leave the ' unalloyed ' gold that people talk about there for -PRON- to see , -PRON- alone by -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yes, they certainly do say these things happen in this way.
Yes, they certainly do say these things happen in this way.
-350
1,997
59
yes, they certainly do say these things happen in this way.
['yes', 'they', 'certainly', 'do', 'say', 'these', 'things', 'happen', 'in', 'this', 'way']
yes , -PRON- certainly do say these thing happen in this way .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well, it seems that in the same way we have now separated off those things that are different from the expert knowledge of statesmanship, and those that are alien and hostile to it, and that there remain those that.
Well, it seems that in the same way we have now separated off those things that are different from the expert knowledge of statesmanship, and those that are alien and hostile to it, and that there remain those that.
-350
1,997
215
well, it seems that in the same way we have now separated off those things that are different from the expert knowledge of statesmanship, and those that are alien and hostile to it, and that there remain those that.
['well', 'it', 'seems', 'that', 'in', 'the', 'same', 'way', 'we', 'have', 'now', 'separated', 'off', 'those', 'things', 'that', 'are', 'different', 'from', 'the', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'of', 'statesmanship', 'and', 'those', 'that', 'are', 'alien', 'and', 'hostile', 'to', 'it', 'and', 'that', 'there', 'remain', 'those', 'that']
well , -PRON- seem that in the same way -PRON- have now separate off those thing that be different from the expert knowledge of statesmanship , and those that be alien and hostile to -PRON- , and that there remain those that .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
are precious and related to it.
are precious and related to it.
-350
1,997
31
are precious and related to it.
['are', 'precious', 'and', 'related', 'to', 'it']
be precious and related to -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Among these, I think, are generalship, the art of the judge, and that part of rhetoric which in partnership with kingship persuades people of what is just and so helps in steering through the business of cities.
Among these, I think, are generalship, the art of the judge, and that part of rhetoric which in partnership with kingship persuades people of what is just and so helps in steering through the business of cities.
-350
1,997
211
among these, i think, are generalship, the art of the judge, and that part of rhetoric which in partnership with kingship persuades people of what is just and so helps in steering through the business of cities.
['among', 'these', 'think', 'are', 'generalship', 'the', 'art', 'of', 'the', 'judge', 'and', 'that', 'part', 'of', 'rhetoric', 'which', 'in', 'partnership', 'with', 'kingship', 'persuades', 'people', 'of', 'what', 'is', 'just', 'and', 'so', 'helps', 'in', 'steering', 'through', 'the', 'business', 'of', 'cities']
among these , -PRON- think , be generalship , the art of the judge , and that part of rhetoric which in partnership with kingship persuade people of what be just and so help in steering through the business of city .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
As for these, in what way will one most easily portion them off and show, stripped and alone by himself, that person we are looking for?
As for these, in what way will one most easily portion them off and show, stripped and alone by himself, that person we are looking for?
-350
1,997
136
as for these, in what way will one most easily portion them off and show, stripped and alone by himself, that person we are looking for?
['as', 'for', 'these', 'in', 'what', 'way', 'will', 'one', 'most', 'easily', 'portion', 'them', 'off', 'and', 'show', 'stripped', 'and', 'alone', 'by', 'himself', 'that', 'person', 'we', 'are', 'looking', 'for']
as for these , in what way will one most easily portion -PRON- off and show , strip and alone by -PRON- , that person -PRON- be look for ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
It's clear that we must try to do this somehow.
It's clear that we must try to do this somehow.
-350
1,997
47
it's clear that we must try to do this somehow.
['it', 'clear', 'that', 'we', 'must', 'try', 'to', 'do', 'this', 'somehow']
-PRON- be clear that -PRON- must try to do this somehow .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well, if it depends on our trying, we'll find him; music will help us reveal him.
Well, if it depends on our trying, we'll find him; music will help us reveal him.
-350
1,997
81
well, if it depends on our trying, we'll find him; music will help us reveal him.
['well', 'if', 'it', 'depends', 'on', 'our', 'trying', 'we', 'll', 'find', 'him', 'music', 'will', 'help', 'us', 'reveal', 'him']
well , if -PRON- depend on -PRON- try , -PRON- will find -PRON- ; music will help -PRON- reveal -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
I imagine we recognize such a thing as the learning of music, and in general of the sorts of expert knowledge involving work with the hands?
I imagine we recognize such a thing as the learning of music, and in general of the sorts of expert knowledge involving work with the hands?
-350
1,997
140
i imagine we recognize such a thing as the learning of music, and in general of the sorts of expert knowledge involving work with the hands?
['imagine', 'we', 'recognize', 'such', 'thing', 'as', 'the', 'learning', 'of', 'music', 'and', 'in', 'general', 'of', 'the', 'sorts', 'of', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'involving', 'work', 'with', 'the', 'hands']
-PRON- imagine -PRON- recognize such a thing as the learning of music , and in general of the sort of expert knowledge involve work with the hand ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And what of this the matter of whether we should learn any one of these or not?
And what of this the matter of whether we should learn any one of these or not?
-350
1,997
79
and what of this the matter of whether we should learn any one of these or not?
['and', 'what', 'of', 'this', 'the', 'matter', 'of', 'whether', 'we', 'should', 'learn', 'any', 'one', 'of', 'these', 'or', 'not']
and what of this the matter of whether -PRON- should learn any one of these or not ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Shall we say that this too, in its turn, is a sort of knowledge, concerned with these very things, or what shall we say?
Shall we say that this too, in its turn, is a sort of knowledge, concerned with these very things, or what shall we say?
-350
1,997
120
shall we say that this too, in its turn, is a sort of knowledge, concerned with these very things, or what shall we say?
['shall', 'we', 'say', 'that', 'this', 'too', 'in', 'its', 'turn', 'is', 'sort', 'of', 'knowledge', 'concerned', 'with', 'these', 'very', 'things', 'or', 'what', 'shall', 'we', 'say']
Shall -PRON- say that this too , in -PRON- turn , be a sort of knowledge , concern with these very thing , or what shall -PRON- say ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Yes, we'll say that it is.
Yes, we'll say that it is.
-350
1,997
26
yes, we'll say that it is.
['yes', 'we', 'll', 'say', 'that', 'it', 'is']
yes , -PRON- will say that -PRON- be .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Then shall we agree that this sort of knowledge is distinct from those?
Then shall we agree that this sort of knowledge is distinct from those?
-350
1,997
71
then shall we agree that this sort of knowledge is distinct from those?
['then', 'shall', 'we', 'agree', 'that', 'this', 'sort', 'of', 'knowledge', 'is', 'distinct', 'from', 'those']
then shall -PRON- agree that this sort of knowledge be distinct from those ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And shall we agree that no one of them should control any other, or that the others should control this one, or that this one should manage and control all the others together?
And shall we agree that no one of them should control any other, or that the others should control this one, or that this one should manage and control all the others together?
-350
1,997
176
and shall we agree that no one of them should control any other, or that the others should control this one, or that this one should manage and control all the others together?
['and', 'shall', 'we', 'agree', 'that', 'no', 'one', 'of', 'them', 'should', 'control', 'any', 'other', 'or', 'that', 'the', 'others', 'should', 'control', 'this', 'one', 'or', 'that', 'this', 'one', 'should', 'manage', 'and', 'control', 'all', 'the', 'others', 'together']
and shall -PRON- agree that no one of -PRON- should control any other , or that the other should control this one , or that this one should manage and control all the other together ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
This one should control them.
This one should control them.
-350
1,997
29
this one should control them.
['this', 'one', 'should', 'control', 'them']
this one should control -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
In that case you, at any rate, declare it to be your opinion that the one that decides whether one should learn or not should be in control, so far as we are concerned, over the one that is the object of learning and does the teaching?
In that case you, at any rate, declare it to be your opinion that the one that decides whether one should learn or not should be in control, so far as we are concerned, over the one that is the object of learning and does the teaching?
-350
1,997
235
in that case you, at any rate, declare it to be your opinion that the one that decides whether one should learn or not should be in control, so far as we are concerned, over the one that is the object of learning and does the teaching?
['in', 'that', 'case', 'you', 'at', 'any', 'rate', 'declare', 'it', 'to', 'be', 'your', 'opinion', 'that', 'the', 'one', 'that', 'decides', 'whether', 'one', 'should', 'learn', 'or', 'not', 'should', 'be', 'in', 'control', 'so', 'far', 'as', 'we', 'are', 'concerned', 'over', 'the', 'one', 'that', 'is', 'the', 'object', 'of', 'learning', 'and', 'does', 'the', 'teaching']
in that case -PRON- , at any rate , declare -PRON- to be -PRON- opinion that the one that decide whether one should learn or not should be in control , so far as -PRON- be concern , over the one that be the object of learning and do the teaching ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And also, in that case, that the one which decides whether one should persuade or not should control the one which is capable of persuading?
And also, in that case, that the one which decides whether one should persuade or not should control the one which is capable of persuading?
-350
1,997
140
and also, in that case, that the one which decides whether one should persuade or not should control the one which is capable of persuading?
['and', 'also', 'in', 'that', 'case', 'that', 'the', 'one', 'which', 'decides', 'whether', 'one', 'should', 'persuade', 'or', 'not', 'should', 'control', 'the', 'one', 'which', 'is', 'capable', 'of', 'persuading']
and also , in that case , that the one which decide whether one should persuade or not should control the one which be capable of persuade ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well then: to which sort of expert knowledge shall we assign what is capable of persuading mass and crowd, through the telling of stories, and not through teaching?
Well then: to which sort of expert knowledge shall we assign what is capable of persuading mass and crowd, through the telling of stories, and not through teaching?
-350
1,997
164
well then: to which sort of expert knowledge shall we assign what is capable of persuading mass and crowd, through the telling of stories, and not through teaching?
['well', 'then', 'to', 'which', 'sort', 'of', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'shall', 'we', 'assign', 'what', 'is', 'capable', 'of', 'persuading', 'mass', 'and', 'crowd', 'through', 'the', 'telling', 'of', 'stories', 'and', 'not', 'through', 'teaching']
well then : to which sort of expert knowledge shall -PRON- assign what be capable of persuade mass and crowd , through the telling of story , and not through teaching ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
This too is clear, I think: it must be given to rhetoric.
This too is clear, I think: it must be given to rhetoric.
-350
1,997
57
this too is clear, i think: it must be given to rhetoric.
['this', 'too', 'is', 'clear', 'think', 'it', 'must', 'be', 'given', 'to', 'rhetoric']
this too be clear , -PRON- think : -PRON- must be give to rhetoric .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And the matter of whether to do through persuasion whatever it may be in relation to some people or other, or else by the use of some sort of force, or indeed to do nothing at all: to what sort of expert knowledge shall we attach this?
And the matter of whether to do through persuasion whatever it may be in relation to some people or other, or else by the use of some sort of force, or indeed to do nothing at all: to what sort of expert knowledge shall we attach this?
-350
1,997
235
and the matter of whether to do through persuasion whatever it may be in relation to some people or other, or else by the use of some sort of force, or indeed to do nothing at all: to what sort of expert knowledge shall we attach this?
['and', 'the', 'matter', 'of', 'whether', 'to', 'do', 'through', 'persuasion', 'whatever', 'it', 'may', 'be', 'in', 'relation', 'to', 'some', 'people', 'or', 'other', 'or', 'else', 'by', 'the', 'use', 'of', 'some', 'sort', 'of', 'force', 'or', 'indeed', 'to', 'do', 'nothing', 'at', 'all', 'to', 'what', 'sort', 'of', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'shall', 'we', 'attach', 'this']
and the matter of whether to do through persuasion whatever -PRON- may be in relation to some people or other , or else by the use of some sort of force , or indeed to do nothing at all : to what sort of expert knowledge shall -PRON- attach this ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
To the one that controls the art of persuasion and speaking.
To the one that controls the art of persuasion and speaking.
-350
1,997
60
to the one that controls the art of persuasion and speaking.
['to', 'the', 'one', 'that', 'controls', 'the', 'art', 'of', 'persuasion', 'and', 'speaking']
to the one that control the art of persuasion and speak .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
This would be none other, I think, than the capacity of the statesman.
This would be none other, I think, than the capacity of the statesman.
-350
1,997
70
this would be none other, i think, than the capacity of the statesman.
['this', 'would', 'be', 'none', 'other', 'think', 'than', 'the', 'capacity', 'of', 'the', 'statesman']
this would be none other , -PRON- think , than the capacity of the statesman .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
This matter of rhetoric too seems to have been separated quickly from statesmanship, as a distinct class, but subordinate to it.
This matter of rhetoric too seems to have been separated quickly from statesmanship, as a distinct class, but subordinate to it.
-350
1,997
128
this matter of rhetoric too seems to have been separated quickly from statesmanship, as a distinct class, but subordinate to it.
['this', 'matter', 'of', 'rhetoric', 'too', 'seems', 'to', 'have', 'been', 'separated', 'quickly', 'from', 'statesmanship', 'as', 'distinct', 'class', 'but', 'subordinate', 'to', 'it']
this matter of rhetoric too seem to have be separate quickly from statesmanship , as a distinct class , but subordinate to -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
What should we think about the following sort of capacity, in its turn?
What should we think about the following sort of capacity, in its turn?
-350
1,997
71
what should we think about the following sort of capacity, in its turn?
['what', 'should', 'we', 'think', 'about', 'the', 'following', 'sort', 'of', 'capacity', 'in', 'its', 'turn']
what should -PRON- think about the follow sort of capacity , in -PRON- turn ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
The one that decides how to make war against each group of people against whom we choose to make war.
The one that decides how to make war against each group of people against whom we choose to make war.
-350
1,997
101
the one that decides how to make war against each group of people against whom we choose to make war.
['the', 'one', 'that', 'decides', 'how', 'to', 'make', 'war', 'against', 'each', 'group', 'of', 'people', 'against', 'whom', 'we', 'choose', 'to', 'make', 'war']
the one that decide how to make war against each group of people against whom -PRON- choose to make war .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
The question is whether we shall say that this is or is not a matter of expertise.
The question is whether we shall say that this is or is not a matter of expertise.
-350
1,997
82
the question is whether we shall say that this is or is not a matter of expertise.
['the', 'question', 'is', 'whether', 'we', 'shall', 'say', 'that', 'this', 'is', 'or', 'is', 'not', 'matter', 'of', 'expertise']
the question be whether -PRON- shall say that this be or be not a matter of expertise .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And how could we suppose it not to involve expertise:
And how could we suppose it not to involve expertise:
-350
1,997
53
and how could we suppose it not to involve expertise:
['and', 'how', 'could', 'we', 'suppose', 'it', 'not', 'to', 'involve', 'expertise']
and how could -PRON- suppose -PRON- not to involve expertise :
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
that capacity which is exercised by generalship and all activity concerned with war?
that capacity which is exercised by generalship and all activity concerned with war?
-350
1,997
84
that capacity which is exercised by generalship and all activity concerned with war?
['that', 'capacity', 'which', 'is', 'exercised', 'by', 'generalship', 'and', 'all', 'activity', 'concerned', 'with', 'war']
that capacity which be exercise by generalship and all activity concern with war ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
And are we to understand as different from this the expertise that is able and knows how to reach a considered decision about whether we should make war, or whether we should withdraw in friendly fashion?
And are we to understand as different from this the expertise that is able and knows how to reach a considered decision about whether we should make war, or whether we should withdraw in friendly fashion?
-350
1,997
204
and are we to understand as different from this the expertise that is able and knows how to reach a considered decision about whether we should make war, or whether we should withdraw in friendly fashion?
['and', 'are', 'we', 'to', 'understand', 'as', 'different', 'from', 'this', 'the', 'expertise', 'that', 'is', 'able', 'and', 'knows', 'how', 'to', 'reach', 'considered', 'decision', 'about', 'whether', 'we', 'should', 'make', 'war', 'or', 'whether', 'we', 'should', 'withdraw', 'in', 'friendly', 'fashion']
and be -PRON- to understand as different from this the expertise that be able and know how to reach a consider decision about whether -PRON- should make war , or whether -PRON- should withdraw in friendly fashion ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Or are we to take it to be the same as this one?
Or are we to take it to be the same as this one?
-350
1,997
48
or are we to take it to be the same as this one?
['or', 'are', 'we', 'to', 'take', 'it', 'to', 'be', 'the', 'same', 'as', 'this', 'one']
or be -PRON- to take -PRON- to be the same as this one ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Anyone who was following what was said before must suppose that it is distinct.
Anyone who was following what was said before must suppose that it is distinct.
-350
1,997
79
anyone who was following what was said before must suppose that it is distinct.
['anyone', 'who', 'was', 'following', 'what', 'was', 'said', 'before', 'must', 'suppose', 'that', 'it', 'is', 'distinct']
anyone who be follow what be say before must suppose that -PRON- be distinct .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Shall we then declare our view that it controls it, if in fact we are going to take things in line with what we said before?
Shall we then declare our view that it controls it, if in fact we are going to take things in line with what we said before?
-350
1,997
124
shall we then declare our view that it controls it, if in fact we are going to take things in line with what we said before?
['shall', 'we', 'then', 'declare', 'our', 'view', 'that', 'it', 'controls', 'it', 'if', 'in', 'fact', 'we', 'are', 'going', 'to', 'take', 'things', 'in', 'line', 'with', 'what', 'we', 'said', 'before']
Shall -PRON- then declare -PRON- view that -PRON- control -PRON- , if in fact -PRON- be go to take thing in line with what -PRON- say before ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Then what mistress will we even try to propose for so terrifying and important an expertise, the whole of that concerned with war, except the true art of kingship?
Then what mistress will we even try to propose for so terrifying and important an expertise, the whole of that concerned with war, except the true art of kingship?
-350
1,997
163
then what mistress will we even try to propose for so terrifying and important an expertise, the whole of that concerned with war, except the true art of kingship?
['then', 'what', 'mistress', 'will', 'we', 'even', 'try', 'to', 'propose', 'for', 'so', 'terrifying', 'and', 'important', 'an', 'expertise', 'the', 'whole', 'of', 'that', 'concerned', 'with', 'war', 'except', 'the', 'true', 'art', 'of', 'kingship']
then what mistress will -PRON- even try to propose for so terrifying and important an expertise , the whole of that concern with war , except the true art of kingship ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
In that case we shall not set down the expert knowledge of generals as statesmanship, since it is subordinate.
In that case we shall not set down the expert knowledge of generals as statesmanship, since it is subordinate.
-350
1,997
110
in that case we shall not set down the expert knowledge of generals as statesmanship, since it is subordinate.
['in', 'that', 'case', 'we', 'shall', 'not', 'set', 'down', 'the', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'of', 'generals', 'as', 'statesmanship', 'since', 'it', 'is', 'subordinate']
in that case -PRON- shall not set down the expert knowledge of general as statesmanship , since -PRON- be subordinate .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
It seems unlikely that we shall.
It seems unlikely that we shall.
-350
1,997
32
it seems unlikely that we shall.
['it', 'seems', 'unlikely', 'that', 'we', 'shall']
-PRON- seem unlikely that -PRON- shall .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Come on then; let's look at the capacity that belongs to those judges who judge correctly.
Come on then; let's look at the capacity that belongs to those judges who judge correctly.
-350
1,997
90
come on then; let's look at the capacity that belongs to those judges who judge correctly.
['come', 'on', 'then', 'let', 'look', 'at', 'the', 'capacity', 'that', 'belongs', 'to', 'those', 'judges', 'who', 'judge', 'correctly']
come on then ; let -PRON- look at the capacity that belong to those judge who judge correctly .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Well then, does its capacity extend to anything more than taking over from the legislator king all those things that are established as lawful in relation to contracts, and judging by reference to these the things that have been prescribed as just and unjust, providing its own individual excellence by virtue of the fact that it would not be willing to decide the complaints of one citizen against another contrary to the prescription of the legislator through being overcome by presents of some sort, or fears, or feelings of compassion, or again by any enmity or friendship?
Well then, does its capacity extend to anything more than taking over from the legislator king all those things that are established as lawful in relation to contracts, and judging by reference to these the things that have been prescribed as just and unjust, providing its own individual excellence by virtue of the fact that it would not be willing to decide the complaints of one citizen against another contrary to the prescription of the legislator through being overcome by presents of some sort, or fears, or feelings of compassion, or again by any enmity or friendship?
-350
1,997
577
well then, does its capacity extend to anything more than taking over from the legislator king all those things that are established as lawful in relation to contracts, and judging by reference to these the things that have been prescribed as just and unjust, providing its own individual excellence by virtue of the fact that it would not be willing to decide the complaints of one citizen against another contrary to the prescription of the legislator through being overcome by presents of some sort, or fears, or feelings of compassion, or again by any enmity or friendship?
['well', 'then', 'does', 'its', 'capacity', 'extend', 'to', 'anything', 'more', 'than', 'taking', 'over', 'from', 'the', 'legislator', 'king', 'all', 'those', 'things', 'that', 'are', 'established', 'as', 'lawful', 'in', 'relation', 'to', 'contracts', 'and', 'judging', 'by', 'reference', 'to', 'these', 'the', 'things', 'that', 'have', 'been', 'prescribed', 'as', 'just', 'and', 'unjust', 'providing', 'its', 'own', 'individual', 'excellence', 'by', 'virtue', 'of', 'the', 'fact', 'that', 'it', 'would', 'not', 'be', 'willing', 'to', 'decide', 'the', 'complaints', 'of', 'one', 'citizen', 'against', 'another', 'contrary', 'to', 'the', 'prescription', 'of', 'the', 'legislator', 'through', 'being', 'overcome', 'by', 'presents', 'of', 'some', 'sort', 'or', 'fears', 'or', 'feelings', 'of', 'compassion', 'or', 'again', 'by', 'any', 'enmity', 'or', 'friendship']
well then , do -PRON- capacity extend to anything more than take over from the legislator king all those thing that be establish as lawful in relation to contract , and judge by reference to these the thing that have be prescribe as just and unjust , provide -PRON- own individual excellence by virtue of the fact that -PRON- would not be willing to decide the complaint of one citizen against another contrary to the prescription of the legislator through be overcome by present of some sort , or fear , or feeling of compassion , or again by any enmity or friendship ?
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
No, the function of this capacity extends, roughly speaking, to what you have said.
No, the function of this capacity extends, roughly speaking, to what you have said.
-350
1,997
83
no, the function of this capacity extends, roughly speaking, to what you have said.
['no', 'the', 'function', 'of', 'this', 'capacity', 'extends', 'roughly', 'speaking', 'to', 'what', 'you', 'have', 'said']
no , the function of this capacity extend , roughly speak , to what -PRON- have say .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
In that case we discover the power of judges too not to be that belonging to the king, but to be a guardian of the laws and a subordinate of that other capacity.
In that case we discover the power of judges too not to be that belonging to the king, but to be a guardian of the laws and a subordinate of that other capacity.
-350
1,997
161
in that case we discover the power of judges too not to be that belonging to the king, but to be a guardian of the laws and a subordinate of that other capacity.
['in', 'that', 'case', 'we', 'discover', 'the', 'power', 'of', 'judges', 'too', 'not', 'to', 'be', 'that', 'belonging', 'to', 'the', 'king', 'but', 'to', 'be', 'guardian', 'of', 'the', 'laws', 'and', 'subordinate', 'of', 'that', 'other', 'capacity']
in that case -PRON- discover the power of judge too not to be that belong to the king , but to be a guardian of the law and a subordinate of that other capacity .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
If then one looks at all the sorts of expert knowledge that have been discussed, it must be observed that none of them has been declared to be statesmanship.
If then one looks at all the sorts of expert knowledge that have been discussed, it must be observed that none of them has been declared to be statesmanship.
-350
1,997
157
if then one looks at all the sorts of expert knowledge that have been discussed, it must be observed that none of them has been declared to be statesmanship.
['if', 'then', 'one', 'looks', 'at', 'all', 'the', 'sorts', 'of', 'expert', 'knowledge', 'that', 'have', 'been', 'discussed', 'it', 'must', 'be', 'observed', 'that', 'none', 'of', 'them', 'has', 'been', 'declared', 'to', 'be', 'statesmanship']
if then one look at all the sort of expert knowledge that have be discuss , -PRON- must be observe that none of -PRON- have be declare to be statesmanship .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
For what is really kingship must not itself perform practical tasks, but control those with the capacity to perform them, because it knows when it is the right time to begin and set in motion the most important things in cities, and when it is the wrong time; and the others must do what has been prescribed for them.
For what is really kingship must not itself perform practical tasks, but control those with the capacity to perform them, because it knows when it is the right time to begin and set in motion the most important things in cities, and when it is the wrong time; and the others must do what has been prescribed for them.
-350
1,997
317
for what is really kingship must not itself perform practical tasks, but control those with the capacity to perform them, because it knows when it is the right time to begin and set in motion the most important things in cities, and when it is the wrong time; and the others must do what has been prescribed for them.
['for', 'what', 'is', 'really', 'kingship', 'must', 'not', 'itself', 'perform', 'practical', 'tasks', 'but', 'control', 'those', 'with', 'the', 'capacity', 'to', 'perform', 'them', 'because', 'it', 'knows', 'when', 'it', 'is', 'the', 'right', 'time', 'to', 'begin', 'and', 'set', 'in', 'motion', 'the', 'most', 'important', 'things', 'in', 'cities', 'and', 'when', 'it', 'is', 'the', 'wrong', 'time', 'and', 'the', 'others', 'must', 'do', 'what', 'has', 'been', 'prescribed', 'for', 'them']
for what be really kingship must not -PRON- perform practical task , but control those with the capacity to perform -PRON- , because -PRON- know when -PRON- be the right time to begin and set in motion the most important thing in city , and when -PRON- be the wrong time ; and the other must do what have be prescribe for -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
For this reason, then, the sorts of expertise we have just examined control neither each other nor themselves, but each is concerned with some individual practical activity of its own, and in accordance with the individual nature of the activities in question has appropriately acquired a name that is individual to it.
For this reason, then, the sorts of expertise we have just examined control neither each other nor themselves, but each is concerned with some individual practical activity of its own, and in accordance with the individual nature of the activities in question has appropriately acquired a name that is individual to it.
-350
1,997
319
for this reason, then, the sorts of expertise we have just examined control neither each other nor themselves, but each is concerned with some individual practical activity of its own, and in accordance with the individual nature of the activities in question has appropriately acquired a name that is individual to it.
['for', 'this', 'reason', 'then', 'the', 'sorts', 'of', 'expertise', 'we', 'have', 'just', 'examined', 'control', 'neither', 'each', 'other', 'nor', 'themselves', 'but', 'each', 'is', 'concerned', 'with', 'some', 'individual', 'practical', 'activity', 'of', 'its', 'own', 'and', 'in', 'accordance', 'with', 'the', 'individual', 'nature', 'of', 'the', 'activities', 'in', 'question', 'has', 'appropriately', 'acquired', 'name', 'that', 'is', 'individual', 'to', 'it']
for this reason , then , the sort of expertise -PRON- have just examine control neither each other nor -PRON- , but each be concern with some individual practical activity of -PRON- own , and in accordance with the individual nature of the activity in question have appropriately acquire a name that be individual to -PRON- .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
That seems so, at any rate.
That seems so, at any rate.
-350
1,997
27
that seems so, at any rate.
['that', 'seems', 'so', 'at', 'any', 'rate']
that seem so , at any rate .
Plato - Complete Works
Plato
plato
Whereas the one that controls all of these, and the laws, and cares for every aspect of things in the city, weaving everything together in the most correct way this, embracing its capacity with the appellation belonging to the whole, we would, it seems, most appropriately call statesmanship.
Whereas the one that controls all of these, and the laws, and cares for every aspect of things in the city, weaving everything together in the most correct way this, embracing its capacity with the appellation belonging to the whole, we would, it seems, most appropriately call statesmanship.
-350
1,997
292
whereas the one that controls all of these, and the laws, and cares for every aspect of things in the city, weaving everything together in the most correct way this, embracing its capacity with the appellation belonging to the whole, we would, it seems, most appropriately call statesmanship.
['whereas', 'the', 'one', 'that', 'controls', 'all', 'of', 'these', 'and', 'the', 'laws', 'and', 'cares', 'for', 'every', 'aspect', 'of', 'things', 'in', 'the', 'city', 'weaving', 'everything', 'together', 'in', 'the', 'most', 'correct', 'way', 'this', 'embracing', 'its', 'capacity', 'with', 'the', 'appellation', 'belonging', 'to', 'the', 'whole', 'we', 'would', 'it', 'seems', 'most', 'appropriately', 'call', 'statesmanship']
whereas the one that control all of these , and the law , and care for every aspect of thing in the city , weave everything together in the most correct way this , embrace -PRON- capacity with the appellation belong to the whole , -PRON- would , -PRON- seem , most appropriately call statesmanship .