workspace
stringclasses
4 values
channel
stringclasses
4 values
text
stringlengths
1
3.93k
ts
stringlengths
26
26
user
stringlengths
2
11
elmlang
general
<@Christoper> yep, that's a good solution.
2019-04-01T21:51:47.234200
Earlean
elmlang
general
There are at least two issues for code that has similar behavior. <https://github.com/elm/core/issues/993> <https://github.com/elm/core/issues/980> Apparently, it doesn’t work to change `Time.every` subscriptions dynamically. I’m going to just use a single `Time.every(100, SomeMsg)` call, with a tiny state machine. That appears to work.
2019-04-02T03:49:10.235100
Granville
elmlang
general
Anyone hit this use case when doing an SPA? <https://github.com/elm/browser/issues/71>
2019-04-02T03:59:03.235400
Zachary
elmlang
general
Maybe you’re looking for <https://package.elm-lang.org/packages/elm/browser/latest/Browser-Navigation#replaceUrl> ? (re-reading your issue, probably not)
2019-04-02T04:06:14.235800
Lea
elmlang
general
I think this still trigger url change msg
2019-04-02T04:14:17.236100
Zachary
elmlang
general
Probably, I can’t think of a component level solution
2019-04-02T04:19:38.236300
Lea
elmlang
general
Can you expand on what you're trying to do? I don't really understand what the problem you're encountering is
2019-04-02T04:23:25.236500
Earlean
elmlang
general
If you use "path" based url routing for the different pages of your SPA, maybe you could handle tabs via fragments in the url <https://package.elm-lang.org/packages/elm/url/latest/Url-Parser#fragment> ?
2019-04-02T04:41:33.236700
Mindy
elmlang
general
<@Earlean> I'm trying to add a path to history without triggering onUrlRequest
2019-04-02T05:06:45.236900
Zachary
elmlang
general
Can you explain why you want to do that?
2019-04-02T05:08:04.237100
Earlean
elmlang
general
Because the user is switching between tabs, inside a fraction of the page. SPA routing would trigger reload, while I already handle the transition inside the component itself
2019-04-02T05:09:29.237400
Zachary
elmlang
general
You write the onUrlRequest function so you get to decide what it does. If you don't want it to result in any changes to your model you can just have it do that.
2019-04-02T05:10:18.237600
Earlean
elmlang
general
Hmm, that got me thinking, I could filter out the routes I'm not interested in
2019-04-02T05:13:41.237800
Zachary
elmlang
general
Thanks <@Earlean>
2019-04-02T05:14:07.238000
Zachary
elmlang
general
Is there any editor plugin out there for elm that adds a project tree? Like a list of links to functions/types in a file, as opposed to just filenames?
2019-04-02T05:34:36.238900
Gertrude
elmlang
general
Also, some guidelines about how to refactor a large single Main into smaller files maybe ... I'm hitting 700 lines here and it's getting unweildy
2019-04-02T05:35:13.239600
Gertrude
elmlang
general
Intellij Idea with help of <@Carl>'s Elm plug-in displays structure of selected Elm file in a separate pane. It is also accessible by Ctrl/Cmd+F12 - very easy to navigate. And there is also "Go to symbol" action to navigate to a known function anywhere
2019-04-02T05:41:47.242000
Lynne
elmlang
general
<@Gertrude> one thing you can do is pull dependencies out by concern. For example, you could extract the `Model` type from your main into its own `Model.elm` file and pick things that focus on the model (transformation functions used in `update`, etc.) into this file, maybe factor some parts of update into it, taking care about not putting other concerns into it (i.e. a function that uses `Model` and `Msg` like `update` should probably not go into your `Model.elm` file).
2019-04-02T05:43:26.243600
Antonette
elmlang
general
Once you've got a `Model.elm` file you may want to extract your `view` function from your main file to put it into its own `View.elm` file ; this `View.elm` file can import whatever it needs from your `Model.elm` module just as the `Main.elm` file does, etc.
2019-04-02T05:44:56.245400
Antonette
elmlang
general
Another thing is recognizing parts that repeat ; maybe you've got tabs that are very similar but for a couple of params (the message they send when clicked on, the label of the tab, whether it's the current tab or not, ...) ; that might be tighter and easier to update if you factored the common code.
2019-04-02T05:47:25.247800
Antonette
elmlang
general
One last way I'd mention here is when you've got something that clearly is a subpart of the main view and acts like its own little view (its got its own subpart of your `Model`, it could have its own `Msg` and `update`, it has its own `view`, ...) ; this is a good sign that you could factor this out in its own module (or set of modules depending on its size and complexity).
2019-04-02T05:49:29.250200
Antonette
elmlang
general
The trouble I seem to come to is circular dependencies, as well as where to separate concerns
2019-04-02T05:50:06.250700
Gertrude
elmlang
general
<@Gertrude> 700 lines is not much though I think
2019-04-02T05:51:42.252000
Nana
elmlang
general
So much relies on each other, ie. Model and Msg are referred to almost everywhere, for example, so it's hard to refactor anything out.
2019-04-02T05:51:46.252100
Gertrude
elmlang
general
especially when you have something like the IntelliJ structure view
2019-04-02T05:52:13.253100
Nana
elmlang
general
<@Gertrude> that's why I started mentionning that your `Model` and `Msg` types could live in their own file actually :wink: they're usually good "leaf" modules that you can (and probably should) de-couple as soon as possible to make factoring parts easier and less loop-inducing.
2019-04-02T05:52:37.253700
Antonette
elmlang
general
The anti-pattern as far as my experience got me is to bring into your `Model` and `Msg` module dependencies that don't exclusively work on their own concern (i.e. how to manipulate the model and how to define your messages).
2019-04-02T05:53:51.254600
Antonette
elmlang
general
One mantra that could help is: "that it works with my `Model`/`Msg`/`whatever` does not necessarily mean I should put it in the `Model`/`Msg`/`whatever` module".
2019-04-02T05:56:46.256100
Antonette
elmlang
general
<@Gertrude> is it helping a bit? :slightly_smiling_face:
2019-04-02T05:59:35.257700
Antonette
elmlang
general
<@Antonette> a bit. (sorry about slow reply, so many meetings ...)
2019-04-02T07:22:42.258400
Gertrude
elmlang
general
I think the take away is separating types in their own namespaces and not necessarily bringing more than helper functions along with.
2019-04-02T07:23:02.258900
Gertrude
elmlang
general
I also have some past experience with a much larger project that was largely split along Model/Update/View lines, and the problem I had with that was that it wound up with every change having to touch a dozen files and it being hard to find out where Compenent lives, where Component has to refer to Model, send Msg, needs update changes to handle Msg, etc etc
2019-04-02T07:24:48.260800
Gertrude
elmlang
general
Also I think one problem with this as written is that I often pass down the entire model even to relatively small subcomponents, because the nature of the design I'm replicating is such I often need access even at the micro level
2019-04-02T07:34:45.262400
Gertrude
elmlang
general
As a side question, do you know about Evan's talk "The Life of a File"? He addresses the topic of when and what to extract to modules
2019-04-02T07:43:03.263500
Sharon
elmlang
general
I have heard of it, but not watched it yet.
2019-04-02T07:45:46.263800
Gertrude
elmlang
general
I should.
2019-04-02T07:45:48.264000
Gertrude
elmlang
general
Once upon a time I was shown a website similar to Haskell's Hoogle[1], but for Elm. It allows the user to search for functions by type. It was magical. Now, I can't find it. Please help. [1] <https://hoogle.haskell.org/>
2019-04-02T07:57:15.265100
Briana
elmlang
general
<@Briana> <https://klaftertief.github.io/elm-search/>
2019-04-02T07:57:58.265400
Nana
elmlang
general
B O O K M A R K E D
2019-04-02T07:58:13.265700
Briana
elmlang
general
Thank you!
2019-04-02T07:58:17.265900
Briana
elmlang
general
If you ever loose the bookmark, the search is linked as “Fancy Search” int the sidebar of the elm package website.
2019-04-02T08:07:31.266100
Jin
elmlang
general
(my time to be late to the party :sweat_smile: sorry, lunch happened)
2019-04-02T08:35:38.266300
Antonette
elmlang
general
I know your pain there :wink: coming to elm from a background in imperative programming I was under the impression the Elm architecture was a lot more constricting than it is (I was trying to always write my `update` functions as `Msg -&gt; Model -&gt; (Model, Cmd Msg)` for example).
2019-04-02T08:38:23.266500
Antonette
elmlang
general
So I tended to work as if with components (as in every component had a `Model`, `Msg`, `init`, `update` and `view`, ... even when there was no need for a state or messages).
2019-04-02T08:39:21.266700
Antonette
elmlang
general
Also I was using a lot of `Html.map` and `Cmd.map` and `Sub.map` etc.
2019-04-02T08:40:28.267000
Antonette
elmlang
general
Now I tend to grow my code more organically, starting with one file, then extracting when I feel like a file has grown too large usually getting types and their helpers out first then maybe extracting sub-views, etc. not necessarily giving them a `Model` or `Msg` and all the bells and whistles.
2019-04-02T08:41:40.267300
Antonette
elmlang
general
As for touching a dozen files, it's not necessarily always as bad as it sounds. I especially like using refactor pattern like using type aliases for simple types then growing them into full-fledged types and using the compiler as a refactor tool that tells me where the change in contract is messing things up and working them from there.
2019-04-02T08:43:15.267500
Antonette
elmlang
general
Yeah. I think in this case, the types that are all that big are mostly already factored out, ie. I have a `Types` module ATM which contains all my common data types and their JSON encoders/encoders and any helper functions for working with them. But something like `Msg` almost doesn't make sense to factor out because it's basically the smallest type in my code. XD
2019-04-02T08:43:33.267700
Gertrude
elmlang
general
ie. It's not Msg that's big, it's `update`, but factoring that out without also factoring out `Model` and `Msg` quickly gets into cyclic dependency territory
2019-04-02T08:44:38.267900
Gertrude
elmlang
general
Indeed.
2019-04-02T08:45:40.268100
Antonette
elmlang
general
That's why I wouldn't advise you to start with factoring out something that has dependencies.
2019-04-02T08:45:53.268300
Antonette
elmlang
general
It's like playing mikado ; you want to pull the fancy stick at the bottom only once you've moved enough of the easy ones up.
2019-04-02T08:46:25.268500
Antonette
elmlang
general
:wink:
2019-04-02T08:46:26.268700
Antonette
elmlang
general
I'm building an elm app that should be embeddable/reused in different apps, and it takes some configuration (via flags). What's the best way to include/embed the elm app in different sites?
2019-04-02T09:05:43.270400
Chin
elmlang
general
Here are some framework Integration examples created by Evan. There can be some additional life cycle stuff you have to address but they're a good starting point how to implement it in general. <https://github.com/andys8/components?files=1>
2019-04-02T12:32:23.271100
Millie
elmlang
general
Interesting math: ``` &gt; xCoordinates 5 0.1 [0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.30000000000000004, 0.4] : List Float ``` List is computed by adding 0.1 to the previous item
2019-04-02T13:16:17.272400
Jana
elmlang
general
welcome to floating points :slightly_smiling_face:
2019-04-02T13:17:41.272700
Virgie
elmlang
general
:cry:
2019-04-02T13:18:03.272900
Jana
elmlang
general
equalz f1 f2 = (fabs (f1-f2)) &lt; 0.0000000001 :grimacing:
2019-04-02T13:18:56.273700
Lindsey
elmlang
general
there are other solutions (like rationals) but they have much worse performance
2019-04-02T13:19:58.274400
Virgie
elmlang
general
<@Jana> in general there's no avoiding floating point roundoff completely, but you should be able to get nicer/more accurate results by using division instead of repeated floating point addition: ``` &gt; List.map (\i -&gt; toFloat i / 10) (List.range 0 4) [0,0.1,0.2,0.3,0.4] : List Float ```
2019-04-02T13:40:20.276400
Janiece
elmlang
general
<@Janiece> Thanks, that’s a great suggestion. Am making a little barChart widget.
2019-04-02T13:49:00.278500
Jana
elmlang
general
Using division has the advantage that something like ``` List.map (\i -&gt; toFloat i / 1000) (List.range 0 1000000) ``` to step from 0 to 1000 in 0.001 increments will give you *exactly* 1000 as the last value - repeatedly adding 0.001 a million times would definitely not guarantee that
2019-04-02T13:49:41.278700
Janiece
elmlang
general
And in general you tend to get nice numbers even near the end: ``` &gt; List.map (\i -&gt; toFloat i / 1000) (List.range 0 1000000) |&gt; List.reverse |&gt; List.take 5 |&gt; List.reverse [999.996,999.997,999.998,999.999,1000] ```
2019-04-02T13:50:09.279200
Janiece
elmlang
general
happy to help <@Jana>!
2019-04-02T13:50:39.279400
Janiece
elmlang
general
BTW I actually experimented a while ago with an API for generating `Float` ranges in a flexible/accurate/efficient way <https://github.com/ianmackenzie/elm-geometry/blob/master/src/Float/Range.elm> See the doc comments for `numSteps` and `maxStepSize` for basic usage examples I didn't end up needing the module myself, but I'd be happy to publish it if it would be useful for others (perhaps part of <https://package.elm-lang.org/packages/ianmackenzie/elm-float-extra/latest/>) Or feel free to just copy that module into your own project and tweak it to fit your needs - zero dependencies!
2019-04-02T14:04:05.282200
Janiece
elmlang
general
(the code is relatively long/complex because I tried to handle all sorts of input corner cases, and generate lists "in reverse" to avoid the unnecessary list traversals/memory allocations you get when using `List.range`/`List.map` etc.)
2019-04-02T14:06:03.283500
Janiece
elmlang
general
There's some Decimal packages: ``` $ npx elm repl &gt; import Decimal as D &gt; import List.Extra exposing (scanl) &gt; scanl (\_ acc -&gt; D.add acc (D.fromIntWithExponent 1 -1)) D.zero (List.repeat 4 ()) |&gt; List.map D.toString ["0","0.1","0.2","0.3","0.4"] ```
2019-04-02T14:07:04.283600
Earnest
elmlang
general
Thanks <@Janiece>, I’ll take a look at that.
2019-04-02T14:12:56.284300
Jana
elmlang
general
looking at the code again I realize that it's not actually using the division trick, it's basically using `start + n * stepSize` which should be more accurate than repeated additions but a bit less accurate than division
2019-04-02T14:15:10.286100
Janiece
elmlang
general
can't remember exactly why I went that route :stuck_out_tongue:
2019-04-02T14:15:42.286700
Janiece
elmlang
general
Floating points are so weird!
2019-04-02T14:18:52.287000
Jana
elmlang
general
The inaccuracy here really has no effect, other than a psychological one on me :smile:
2019-04-02T14:19:25.287700
Jana
elmlang
general
yeah the psychological effect is strong!
2019-04-02T14:26:17.288200
Janiece
elmlang
general
but I think can be counterbalanced a bit when you look at how accurate something like 0.30000000000000004 actually is
2019-04-02T14:27:01.288700
Janiece
elmlang
general
4e-17 is a ridiculously tiny number
2019-04-02T14:27:24.289300
Janiece
elmlang
general
a `Float` can represent the radius of the earth (6371 kilometers) to an accuracy of about a ten-millionth of a millimeter
2019-04-02T14:30:28.290100
Janiece
elmlang
general
Hi, what's the canonical way to manage the user authentication with Elm? (is there an auth0 support ?)
2019-04-02T15:04:53.291100
Jesusa
elmlang
general
there’s no canonical way, it’s left up to you
2019-04-02T15:22:02.291400
Alicia
elmlang
general
there is an auth0 package to help with it for auth <https://package.elm-lang.org/packages/kkpoon/elm-auth0/latest/>
2019-04-02T15:22:16.291800
Alicia
elmlang
general
Also, what's the story with mobile app dev? are there any docs/posts I could checkout
2019-04-02T15:29:29.292500
Jesusa
elmlang
general
<@Jesusa> Cordova or another kind of webview should definitely work if you're into that
2019-04-02T15:44:10.293300
Nana
elmlang
general
Did anyone here use bytes so far as a replacement for JSON? Did you run benchmarks? (I'm running benchmarks preparing for my elm-europe talk, and it seems that at least for data with a lot of strings, bytes are much slower than json)
2019-04-02T17:49:45.293900
Virgie
elmlang
general
and for those interested, the kernel code is here <https://github.com/elm/bytes/blob/master/src/Elm/Kernel/Bytes.js#L152>. maybe we can pre-allocate the minimal string width (no idea if that helps) and make larger reads (so read 32 bits at once instead of 8 bits repeatedly)
2019-04-02T17:52:29.296000
Virgie
elmlang
general
That's interesting! json parsing has the advantage of being implemented in C++ in the browser I guess.
2019-04-02T17:54:01.296800
Lindsey
elmlang
general
How much time do you have at hand? I could probably patch you the compiler so you could experiment with it.
2019-04-02T17:54:40.297700
Niesha
elmlang
general
I think json could efficiently copy the whole string (i.e. find opening quote, find closing quote, `String.slice` the intermediate part), and `Bytes` needs to do more work
2019-04-02T17:55:44.298800
Virgie
elmlang
general
<@Niesha> I will give that a go, but would like some more data first. I want to also try an example with mostly numbers
2019-04-02T17:57:17.300100
Virgie
elmlang
general
I'm decoding a list of objects from JSON and right now, everything blows up if one of the objects are formatted incorrectly. How can I just ignore the broken objects and keep the good ones?
2019-04-02T18:10:06.301500
Janna
elmlang
general
if the json is incorrectly formatted it cannot be decoded
2019-04-02T18:12:58.301700
Virgie
elmlang
general
and the parser cannot know from what point the input is correctly formatted again
2019-04-02T18:13:24.301900
Virgie
elmlang
general
I have a small example of decoding a bunch of numbers here: <https://github.com/bburdette/stl/tree/master/example>
2019-04-02T18:16:09.302400
Lindsey
elmlang
general
Can't I do some magic with `Json.Decode.oneOf` or `.andThen` or something?
2019-04-02T18:16:17.302500
Janna
elmlang
general
<@Janna> yep, you can use `Json.Decode.oneOf` and have the second decoder listed produce a value indicating failure to decode
2019-04-02T18:16:40.302700
Earlean
elmlang
general
depends on how ill-formatted the json is though. If the list structure is correct then `oneOf` should work
2019-04-02T18:18:02.303000
Virgie
elmlang
general
<https://ellie-app.com/592mLqnXrWha1>
2019-04-02T18:19:02.303200
Nana
elmlang
general
oh actually you don't even need `oneOf` :smile: just `Decode.list (Decode.maybe <http://Decode.int|Decode.int>)` <https://ellie-app.com/592scSKT4jYa1>
2019-04-02T18:25:19.303600
Nana
elmlang
general
Thanks :slightly_smiling_face:
2019-04-02T19:06:05.304000
Janna
elmlang
general
You can also slip in a `filterMap` to get rid of the `Maybe` <https://ellie-app.com/593vG3m3W8ja1>
2019-04-02T19:34:27.304300
Hoyt
elmlang
general
I’m kind of a lurker here, but I wanted to let everyone know that I was really inspired by the json decoders/encoders in Elm. they reminded me a little of the scalaz stuff I used to work on. I build a similar decoder library to elm’s in Go: <https://github.com/go-functional/dcode/>
2019-04-02T20:18:00.305600
Lakita