text
stringlengths 347
2.65M
| id
stringlengths 9
16
| submitter
stringlengths 2
64
⌀ | authors
stringlengths 4
36.7k
| title
stringlengths 0
245
| comments
stringlengths 1
625
⌀ | journal-ref
stringlengths 4
246
⌀ | doi
stringlengths 12
113
⌀ | report-no
stringlengths 2
261
⌀ | categories
stringlengths 5
95
| license
stringclasses 5
values | abstract
stringlengths 35
3.01k
| versions
listlengths 1
64
| update_date
timestamp[s] | authors_parsed
listlengths 1
2.83k
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 JUN TANAKA (L2) the associative law: x(yz) = (xy)zandx(yz) = (xy)z (L3) the absorption law: x ( yx ) =x and x ( yx ) = x. Hereinafter, the lattice (L, ,) will often be written L for simplicity. A mapping h from a lattice L to another L'is called a if it satisfies h(xy) =h(x)h(y) andh(xy) h is a bijection, that is, if h is one-to-one and onto, it is called a lattic e- isomorphism; and in this case, L'is said to be to L. A lattice (L, ,) is called distributive if, for any x,y,z in L, (L4) the distributive law holds: x(yz) = (xy)(yz) andx(yz) = (xy)(yz) A lattice L is called complete if, any subset A of L, L contain the suprem um A and the infimum A. If L is complete, then L itself includes the maximum and minimum elements, which are often denoted by 1 and 0, or I and O, res 1. Complete Heyting algebra (cHa) A complete lattice is called a complete Heyting algebra (cHa), if iI(xiy) = (iIxi)y holds for xi,yL(iI); where I is an index set of arbitrary cardinal number. A distributive lattice is called a Boolean algebra or a Boolean lattice, if fo r any element x in L, there exists a unique complement xCsuch that x xC= 1 and xxC= 0. It is well-known that for a set E, the power set P(E) = 2E. The set of all subsets of E, is a Boolean : Generalized fuzzy sets In this section we will consider an algebraic structure of a family of fu zzy sets. We will show that the following three families are mutually equivalent: a r ing of generalized fuzzy subsets, an extension of (Boolean) Lattice P(X ), and a set of L-fuzzy sets (introduced by Gouen [3]). Definition 2. A family GF(X), which is closed under operations and, is called a ring of generalized fuzzy subsets of X, if it satisfies: (1) GF(X) is a complete Heyting algebra with respect to and, (2) GF(X) contains P(X) = 2Xas a sublattice of GF(X), (3) the operations andcoincide with set respectively, in P(X), and (4) for any element A in P(X), A X= X and A =. Definition 3. LetLxbe a lattice which is assigned to each x in X, and let L denote{Lx|xX}. An L-fuzzy set A is characterizedby an L-valued uAwhich associates to each point x in X an element uA(x) inLx.MODERN SET 3 Theorem 1. If eachLxis a cHa, then LF(x), the family of all L-fuzzy sets, is a ring of generalized fuzzy subsets of X. We will show that LF(X) satisfies all the conditions in Definit ion 2. First, by the definition, LF(X) is closed under and. (1) LF(X) is a cHa, because each Lx is a cHa. Condition (2) LF(X) and (3) =and=in P(X) follow from the fact that any element of P(X) is defined with the eleme nt of LF(X) whose membership function takes just two values, 1 and 0. (4) It fol lows from uX(x)=1 andu(x)= 0 that A X = X and A =, for any A in LF(X). 4.Modern Sets Definition 4. Boolean union of elements will be defined is well known, it follows from the definition of Boolean algebra that t here exists a unit element I and a null element O for which we have the that andcommute at this 5. Weak Boolean algebra Let H be an algebraic space with two distinct operators *,*from H to itself. H is called a Weak Boolean Algebra if distinct O, I H such and I and I note that **are associated with and, respectively. O and I are associated with the minimum element and the maximum element, respec 6. Modern Sets Suppose a weak Boolean Algebra Hxis assigned to each x in X and let H denote
{Hx|xX}. Each modern set A is characterized by a membership function uA such that for each x X,uAassigns an element uA(x)Hx. We define H(X) as the family of all modern sets. When A is a set in the ordinary sense of t he term (in P(X)), its membership function can take on only two values to whether x does or does not belong to A. The operation with the set respectively, in P(X). A modern set is empty if and only if its membership function is identically Ox for all x in X. Two modern sets A and B are equal if and only if uA(x) =uB(x) for all x in X. IfHxis partially ordered by <=for each x, then we can define containment as follows: A is contained in B if and only if uA(x)<=uB(x) for all x in X.4 JUN TANAKA Union. The union of two modern sets A and B with respective s uA(x) anduB(x) is a modern set, written as C = A B, whose member- ship function is related to those of A and B by uC(x) =uA(x)*xuB(x), xX Note that the order does matter if Hxis not The intersection of two modern sets A and B with functions uA(x) anduB(x) is a modern set, written as C = A B, whose membership function is related to those of A and B by uC(x) =uA(x)*xuB(x), xX The notion of complement was not given in Definition 5 since we can trivia lly define the complement on a Modern Set for each x in X such as ({Ix})C=Ox even while ( {Ax})Ccan be anything for all 2. For any modern sets A, B , C whose membership function take on valuesOxorIx, (L1)-(L4) the proof is more or less clear, herein we will briefly indicate the p roof for the commutative and distributive cases. Let's check the commu tative law. Call C = AB. We only have to check the four possible all x X Thus,uC(x) =uA(x)*xuB(x) =uB(x)*xuA(x). Therefore, C = A B = B A. We can show the commutative law for intersection similarly. We will show the two most important cases of the distributive law briefl y. Call C = A( BC ). Ox*(Ix*Ox) =Ox*Ox=Ox=Ix*Ox= =Ox*Ix=Ix=Ix*Ix= all x X Please check the rest of cases. That should not be too 3. Hxis commutative for all x in X iff H = {Hx|xX}is is obvious. /square Theorem 4. Hxis distributive for all x in X iff H = {Hx|xX}is is obvious. /square Theorem 5. Similar equivalent statement (as above) hold for the absorp tion law, the law of excluded middle, the law of th e associative law, etc...MODERN SET 5 Remark 1. As you see from the previous theorems, if ( Hx,*x,*x,*C) is defined to be in the sense of fuzzy sets such as *x= max,*x= min,(*)C= 1- (*) in the interval [0,1], then H(X)becomes the family of fuzzy the definition of Lattice for each x in X , then H(X)becomes a family of L-fuzzy set. If Hxadditionally satisfy the definition of a complete Heyting algebra, it is a ring of generalized fuzzy proof is clear. /square Example 6. We will present an example of a non-commutative modern set. L et Hxbe a space of linear bounded operators on a Hilbert space Hfor each x in X. Then we take the zero Oxand the identity IxinHx. We define the composition *=
*xand the addition + = *x. In order to create a weak Boolean Algebra, we must define an equivalence class ~asA~Biff A = B or there exist n, m N- {0}
such that A = nIxand B = mIx. Ox(Ix) =OxandIx(Ox) =OxandIx(Ix) 2Ix=Ix Now we have a weak Boolean Algebra Hxwhere the composition operation is typ- ically not commutative. Thus H(X) is a family of modern sets o f if one of Hxis not commutative under the composition. Needless to say, i f all ofHxis commutative under the composition, then H(X) satisfies th e 7. Let (M, n xn , + ,*) be an n xn matrix space closed under addition
+ and matrix multiplication *. Then call the matrix multiplication identity I and the addition identity matrix O. Now we take *=*xand + = *x. By considering the same equivalence class as in Example 6, we can create a mod ern set from the nxn matrix space. Theorem 8. Gelfand Theorem IfUis a commutative a C*-algebra, then Uis*-isomorphism to C(X), some compact Hausdorff space X. Remark 2. For a given commutative C*-algebra, we have a representation of it as a space of continuous functions on some compact Hausdorff b y theorem 8. Thus we can always create a commutative Modern set from any commut the same construction as in Example 6. We give the following definition and theorem as more examples of Moder n Sets. Definition 7. By a representation of a C*-algebra Uon a Hilbert space H, we mean a*homomorphism phfromUintoB(H). If in addition, phis one-to-one, it is called a faithful 9. The Gelfand-Neumark has a faithful representation on some Hilbert spac e. Example 10. For a given C*-algebra, we have a representation of it as bounded linear operators on a Hilbert space by theorem 9. Thus we can a lways create a Modern set from any C*-algebra under the same construction as in Example 6.6 JUN and observation As we mentioned in the Introduction, systematic expression of our thought re- quires room for at least the non-commutative property. I strong ly believe that this new logic system will open up a new blanch of Artificial Intelligence. Pro perty-like verbs such as be, have, and own seem valid in classical logic. H owever, most of the other verbs are required to be non-commutative with respe ct to objects and time. This modern set does not need to be commutative, in some sens e, this is closer to the system of our thought. We need further investigatio n to improve the systematic expression of our thought in order to create a real Ar tificial Intelligence. I dream the day will come, when we make a real G. Birkhoff, Lattice Theory, 3rd ed. AMS colloquim Public ation, Providence, RI, 1967. [2] J.A. Goguen, L-fuzzy sets, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 18, 145- 174, 1967 [3] M. Heidegger, being and time, HarperOne; Revised editio n, 1962 (English) [4] T. Iwamura, Sokuron (Kyoritsu Shuppan, Tokyo, 1966). [5] R. V. Kadison, J.R. Ringrose, Fundamentals of the Theory of Opreator Algebra, AMS, 1997. [6] N. Nakamura, generalized fuzzy sets, Fuzzy sets and Syst ems 32 (1989), 307-314. [7] G. Takeuti, Senkei-Daisu to 131-162 , Shokabo, Tokyo, 1981 (Japanese) [8] L.A. Zadeh, Fuzzy sets, Information and Control 8 (1965) , of California, Riverside, USA E-mail address junex
|
0806.2943
|
Jun Tanaka
|
Jun Tanaka
|
Modern Set
| null | null | null | null |
math.GM cs.IT math.IT
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this paper, we intend to generalize the classical set theory as much as
possible. we will do this by freeing sets from the regular properties of
classical sets; e.g., the law of excluded middle, the law of non-contradiction,
the distributive law, the commutative law,etc....
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 18 Jun 2008 09:45:18 GMT"
}
] | 2008-06-19T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Tanaka",
"Jun",
""
]
] |
The authors of Ref. [1] adduced the following argument against our criticism [2] . amplitude vanishes for gauge invariance when the photon momentum vanishes, only those terms of the integrand have the ph ysical sense which van- ish with vanishing the photon momentum. What actually happens is tha t cancellation of contributions from different places of momentum (or co-ordinate) space is realized. It is commonplace in electrodynamics. In particular, low energy theorem s are based on this. Discarding the integrand in the third term of Eq. (3), the second te rm in Eq. (4), and the contribution of Eq. (5) the authors of [1] distort the physical significance of the K+K- loop model because these contributions represent the high momen tum and charge flow dis- tributions of kaons. Below we show that the K+K-loop model describes the basing the experimental investigations of the light scalar meso ns production in the phradiative decays there was suggested [3] the kaon loop model with the pointlike interaction, see Fig. 1. This model is used in the data treatment and ratified by experimen t. In Refs. [4, 5] an analysis of mechanisms of decays under consideration was carried o ut, which gave the clear arguments for this kaon loop (b) (c) FIG. 1: Diagrams contributing to the radiative decay amplit ude. Every diagram contribution (a)+(b)+(c) (1) is divergent hence should be regularized in a gauge invariant manner, for example, in the Pauli-Wilars (2) anu(p,q) (3) bnu(p,q) (4) cnu(p,q) the regulator field mass. M- in the (6) We can shift the integration variables in the regularized amplitudes an d easily check the gauge invariance = 0. (7) It is instructive to consider how the gauge invariance = 0 (8) holds = (o(ph)o(g))(1-1) = 0.(9) The superscript mKrefers to the nonregularized amplitude and the superscript Mrefers to the regulator field amplitude. So, the contribution of the (a), (b ), and (c) diagrams does not depend on a particle mass in the loops ( mKorM) atp=q[6]. But, the physical meaning of these contributions is radically different. The contribution 3is caused by intermediate momenta (a few GeV) in the loops , whereas the regulator is caused fully by high momenta ( M- ) and teaches us how to allow in a gauge invariant way. Needless to say the integrand of is not equal to 0. It is clear (10) So, the regulator field contribution tends to the subtraction cons tant when M- . The finiteness of the subtraction constant hides its high momentum origin and gives rise to an illusion of a nonrelativistic physics in the K+K-model with the pointlike for example, Ref. [7]; see Section 2 in this paper. This work was supported in part by the Presidential Grant No. NSh- 1027.2008.2 07-02-00093from Basic Research. A.V.K. thanks very much the Dynasty Foundat ion and ICFPM for support, too.
*Electronic address: address: Yu. S. Kalashnikova, A. E. Kudryavtsev, A. V. Nefediev, J . Haidenbauer, and C. Hanhart, Phys. Rev. D 78, 058501 (2008). [2] N.N. Achasov and A.V. Kiselev, Phys. Rev. D 76, 077501 (2007) [3] N.N. Achasov and V.N. Ivanchenko, Nucl. Phys. B 315, 465 (1989). [4] N.N. Achasov and V.V. Gubin, Phys. Rev. D 63, 094007 (2001); Yad. Fiz. 65, 1566 (2002) [Phys. At. Nucl. 65, 1528 (2002)]. [5] N.N. Achasov, Nucl. Phys. A 728, 425 (2003); Yad. Fiz. 67, 1552 (2004) [Phys. At. Nucl. 67, 1529 (2004)]. [6] A typical example of such integrals is 1. [7] Yu. S. Kalashnikova, A. E. Kudryavtsev, A. V. Nefediev, C . Hanhart, and J. A 24, 437 (2005). 4
|
0806.2993
|
Nikolay Achasov
|
N.N. Achasov and A.V. Kiselev
|
Reply to the "Comment on `Once more about the $K\bar{K}$ molecule
approach to the light scalars' "
|
4 pages, 1 figure, there are specified the title, the abstract, and
the first paragraph, typos are removed
|
Phys.Rev.D78:058502,2008
|
10.1103/PhysRevD.78.058502
| null |
hep-ph hep-ex nucl-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The need to regularize loop integrals in a manner that preserves gauge
invariance, for example, using the Pauli-Villars method, requires a subtraction
that in the large mass limit hides its high momentum origin. This gives rise to
the illusion that only nonrelativistic kaon loop momenta are relevant, when in
fact this is not the case, as we show.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 18 Jun 2008 13:20:37 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 1 Oct 2008 11:32:05 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Achasov",
"N. N.",
""
],
[
"Kiselev",
"A. V.",
""
]
] |
/GP/GG/GJ/GR /GG /G8/H3 /GI /GF/GL/G8 /GV/GD/GL/GG/H3 /GO/G8/GA/GL/G81 /BA /FE /B8 /GQ /BA/GD/BA /GA/GP/GD /GF/GL/G8 /GV/GD/GL/GG/H3 /H3 /GL/GM /GA /GM/G9/GX/GD/GK /H1/GQ/GM /GL/GD/GQ /G8/GI/BA /GV/GG/GK /GL/GR /GJ/GG /G9/GD/GF /GR/GV/GD/GQ/G8 /GI/GO /B4/GQ /GM /GN/GO/GGj=k /B5/B8 /G9/GR /GC/GD/GK /GA/GD/GP/GQ/GG /GA /GN/GM/GO /H3/GC/GI /GD /G8/GL/GG/H3 /GK/GM /GC/GR /GJ/H3/B8 /G8 /GA /GK/GM /GC/GR /GJ/GD/GH /AM /GN/GM /G8/GL/GG/H2 /G8/B8 /GF/GL/G8 /GV/GD/GL/GG/H3 /GI /H3/GG/GF (-p,p] /BA /GM/GH /GG/GF /GG /GF/GL/G8 {y0 k, y1 k, ..., ypk-1 k} /B8 /GB 0 /GA/GP/GD/GTj= 1, ..., p k-1 /BA /GL/GD/GM /GV/GL/GM /GG/B8 /GP/GJ/GD/GC/GR /H3 /CJ/BK/B8 /GJ/H2/G9/GR/H2 /GK/G8/GI /GC/GJ/GG/GL/GR /BA /FG/GJ/GG/GL/GR /GI /GM/GH /GI/GO /GF/GL/G8 /FE /GL/G8/GW/GD/GK /GI /GR/H2 /GK/GM /GE/GL/GM /H3/GA/GL/GM/B8 /GV/GQ/GM /GK/GZ /GG /GN/GO/GM /GP/GQ/H0uk
/AM /GL/GM/GJ/H0 /GI/GO qk
/BA /GV/GQ/GM /B8 j= 1,2,...,q k-1 /GR /H3/H2/GQ l(o(j) l) =lo(j) l+o(j-1) l
/B8o(j) l(0,l)0 /BA /FM/GO/GM/GK/GD = 0 /B8 /GN/GM/GP/GI /GM/GJ/H0/GI/GR uk
/GD/GP/GQ/H0 /GL/GM/GJ/H0 /GI/GO qk
/BA/FU /G8/GI/GG/GK /B8j= 0,1,...,q k-1 /GG/GF /GG /GF/GL/G8 /FM/G8/GI /GG /GJ/H2/G9/G8/H3 /G8/GG/GF /GG /H1/GQ /G8 /G8 /GF/GL/G8 /GV/GG/GQ /B8/GN/GM/GO/GM /GE/GC/G8/GD/GQ /GN/GM qk
/BA /FU /GD/GN/GD/GO/H0 /GM/GP/GQ /G8/GD/GQ/GP /H3 /B4/GP/GK/BA /CJ/BL/B8 /GJ/BA /C1/B8 /H1/GQ /G8 /G8 /H3 /GI /GM/GH/B8 /GQ /BA/GD/BA /GG/GK/GD/GD/GQ /GK/G8/GI /GC/GJ/GG/GL/GR /G9/GR /GC/GD/GQ /GR /GC/GM/G9/GL/GM /GG /GG /BA/FR/GM /GC /GG /G9/GR /GC/GD/GK /GA/GD/GF/GC/GD /B8 /GM/GH 1 /GV/GG/GK /GL/GR /GJ/GG /GA /GN/GM/GO /H3/GC/GI /GD /G8/GL/GG/H3 /GK/GM /GC/GR /GJ/H3 /GP /GR/GV/GD/GQ/GM /GK/GI/GO /B4/GQ/GM/GB {wn}
n=1
/GI {yn}
n=1
/BA /GV/GQ/GM /GN/GO/GG /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GKk /GB /GC/GDzj k(x) =o(j-1) l(x,uk) /B8 /H3 /GG/GF /GG /GC/GJ/H3 L*=-d2 dx2+q /B8 /GM/GQ/GA/GD/GV/G8/H2/GX/GD/GH /GF/GL/G8 /FR/GM/GI /G8/GE /GD/GK /B8 /GI /G8/GI /GP /GI /GI /GI{yn}
1 /BA /GJ/GD/GE/GG/GQ /GA /GI /GN/GM L*/B8 /GF/GL/G8 /G8 /AM /GA /GI /GN/GM L /B8 /GF/GL/G8 /GB /B8 /GQ/GM /GGz /GC/GJ/H3 uk(y,z) = (Ly,z) = (y,L*z) =ul(y,z) /B8 /GQ /BA/GD/BA(y,z) = 0 /BA /FH/GP/GJ/GG y/AM /G8z /AM /GQ/GM/B8 /GV/GQ/GM /GR/GE /GD /GC/GM/GI = (Ly,z) = (y,L*z) =ul(y,z) /FU /G8/GI/GG/GK /GC/GM/GP/GQ /GA/GI /G8/GE/GC/GM/GK /GI /GN/GM /GN/GM/AL/GM/GQ /FE /GF/GL/G8 /H1/GQ/GM /GJ/GD/GB/GI /GM/BMwn(x) /B8 /G8 /GC/GJ/H3 /GF/GL/G8 /GV/GD/GL/GG/GH /GI/GO pk>1/BE/GK/GZ /H3 /GL/G8 /CJ/BD/BC/B8 /EF/BE /GG/GJ/GG /CJ/BG/B8 /GJ/BA /BD/B8 /GC/GDbj k
/AM /GL/GD/GI /GL/GD/GL/GR /GJ/GD/GA/GZ/GD /GV/GG/GP/GJ/G8 /GQ /G8/GI/GG/GD/B8 /GV/GQ/GM /GO/G8/GF/GJ/GM /GE /GD/GL/GG/GD (L-lI)-1/GA /GO /GA /BD/BA /B4/GP /GK/BA /CJ/BE /B8 /GQ/GD/GM/GO/GD /GK/G8 /BE/BA/BJ/BA/B5 /BA /FU /GM/GB/GC/G8 /GP/GG/GP/GQ/GD /GK/G8 {yn(x)}
n=1 /GG /GM/GN/GD/GO /G8/GQ/GM/GO /G8 L /GM/G9/GO /G8/GF/GR/GD/GQ /G9 /G8/GF/GG/GP /GG/GP/GP /G8 /GA /BE/BA /B4/GP /GK/BA /CJ/BE/B8 /GQ/GD/GM/GO/GD /GK/G8 /BA /FU /GM/GB/GC/G8/B8 /GP /GL/GD/GI/GL/GM /GK/GD/GO /G8N=Nu
/B8 /GA/GP/GD /GM/GN/GD/GO /G8/GQ/GM/GO /G8 L /G8 /GC/GJ/H3 yn
/GGwn/GP/GN/GO /GO wn(x) /GK /GN/GM/GP /GD/GD/GL/GM/GO /GK/G8 /GA /H1/GQ/GM /GK /GM/GB/GO /GQ/GM /GJ/H0/GI/GM /GM/GQu /BA /FM/GO/GM /GL/GM/GO /GK/G8 /GN/GM/GP l2
/GM/GB/GO /GA/GD = /GN/GM/GP l1
/GG /GD/GD /GL/GM/GO /GK/G8 /GA /H1/GQ/GM /GK /GL/GD /BD/BA /G8/GP/GP /GM/GN/GD/GO /G8/GQ/GM/GO /B4/BD/B5 /B8 /GA L2[0,p] /B8 /GP /GB/GO /GR/GP /GI /GR/H3/GD/GQ /GP /GR/GP =u'(x) /B8 /GB/GC/GD /GI/GM /BA /GP/GG/GP/GQ/GD /GK/G8 /GG /GM/GN/GD/GO /G8/GQ/GM/GO /G8 L /GI /GL/GD/GH /GP/GG/GP/GQ/GD /GK/G8/BA /FG/GJ/H3 /GJ/H0/GL/GM/GH (f(x),wn(x)) /BA /FU /GM/GB/GC/G8 /GG/GK/GD/GD/GQ /GK/GD/GP/GQ/GM /GO /G8/GA/GL/GM /GL/G8 /GA/GP/GD [0,p] /GO /GO /GA /GO/H3/GC /GN/GM /GP/GG/GP/GQ/GD /GK/GD {yn(x)}
n=1
/GG /GK/GD /GN/GO/GGm-+ /FE /CJ/BD/BF /G9/GZ/GJ/GM /GC/GM/GI /GV/GQ/GM /GA /G9/GM/GJ/GD/GD /GB /GJ/G8/GC/GI /GM/GB/GM /B8/GI /GM/GB /B8 /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /BA/FG/GM/GI /BD/BA /G8/GP/GP /B8 /GN/GM /GC/GDfL2[0,p]. /FR/GO/GGN= 1 /G9/GR /GC/GD/GK /GM/GN/GR /GP/GI /G8/GQ/H0 /GG/GL/GC/GD/GI /GF/G8 /GG/GI /GP/GG/GO/GR /GD/GK /GG/GL/GC/GD/GI /GPN /B8 /GN/GM/GJ/GM /GB /GC/GDNu
/AM /GI /GN/GM/GP/GQ/GR /GJ/GG/GO/GR /GD/GQ/GP /H3 /GA /GR/GQ/GA/GD/GO /BE/BA /GV/GQ/GM /GA Nu= 1 /GV/GQ/GM /GC/GJ/H3 /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GM/GD /G9/GR /GC/GD/GK /GD/GB/GM /B4/BI/B5/FU /GD/GN/GD/GO/H0 /GK/GZ /GT /GM/GQ/GG/GK /GN/GM/GI /GV/GQ/GM /GC/GJ/H3 /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GN/GM/GP /GM/GB/GO/BM
/bardblBm,N/bardblL2-C/lessorequalslantCu. /GI /G8/GE/GC/GM/GD /GG/GF /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GZ/GT /GA /GV/G8/GP/GQ/GG /B4/BI /B5 /GN/GM /GM/GQ /GC/GD/B4/GL/G8/GG/G9/GM/GJ/GD/GD /GQ/GO/GR /GC/GL/GM/GH /GF/GC/GD/GP/H0 /G9/GR /GC/GD/GQ /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /G8 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /BD /G8 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GG/GK/GD/GD/GQ /GK/GD/GP/GQ/GM /GL/GD/GO /B4/BK/B5/FE /GP/GG/GJ/GR /GG/GT /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ /G8/GI/GG/GK /GL/G8/GK /GL/GD/GM/G9 /GT /GM /GC/GG/GK/GM /GN/GM /GA/GZ/GO/G8/GE /B4/BL/B5/FU /G8/GI /GI /GP/GN/GO /GG /GC/GJ/H3 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GA /B4/BL/B5 /BA /GP/GJ/GM /GC/GJ/H3 /H3 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ/GR /GI /GM/GP/GG/GL/GR /GP/GM/GA/B8 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GA /GV/G8/GP/GQ/GG /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /H3 /GC/GDDm(x) = 1/2 /AL /H3/GC/GO/GM /FU /G8/GI /GI /G8/GI /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GA /GL/GD /GM/GQm /B8 /GQ/GM /GC/GJ/H3 /GL/GD/GB/GM /GP/GO/G8/GF/GR /GL/GD/GM/G9 /GT /GM /GC/GG/GK/GR/H2 /H3 /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /GM/GH /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GA /B4/BD/BC /B5/BA /GA L2[0,p] /GN/GM /GN/GM/GJ/GM /GE/GG/GK /GN/GM Am:=Am,0
/BA /FP/G8/GK /GL/GD/GM/G9 /GT /GM /GC/GG/GK/GM /GL/GM/GO/GK/GZ Am,-x /GN/GMmN /GGx[0,p] /BA/FR/GM/GI /G8/GE /GD/GK/B8 /GV/GQ/GM /G8/GO/GL/GM /GP/GR/GK/GK/GD Am
/GG /GL/GD/GI ~Am,x
/B8 /GL/GM/GO/GK/GR /GI /GAL2[0,p] /GJ/GD/GB/GI /GM/BA /FR/GR /GP/GQ/H0Txg(t) =g(t+x) /AM /GC/GA/GG/GB /G8 /GA L2[0,p] /B4/GP/GV/GG/GQ /G8/GD/GK/B8 /GV/GQ/GM /GA/GP/GD /GN/GO/GM /GC/GM/GJ/GE /GD/GL/GZ /GF/G8 /FU /GM/GB /GC/G8 /GK/GM /GE /GD/GK =T-xAm,-xu(x+t) /GC/GD~Am,xu(t) /BA /FP/GD/GP/GJ/GM /GE/GL/GM /GV/GQ/GM /GI =kh[0,x]u(t) /GG Sm
/B8 /GB /AL /GI /FW/GR/GO/H0/GD v(t) /BA /FO/GZ /GN/GM/GI /GV/GQ/GM /GL/GM/GO/GK/G8 ~Am,x
/GAL2[0,p] /GL/GD /GT /GM /GC/GG/GQ /GN/GO/GG /GJ/H2/G9/GZ/GT /GF/GL/G8 /GGx[0,p] /BA/BI/FU /GD/GN/GD/GO/H0 /GL/G8/GK /GM/GP/GQ /G8/GJ/GM/GP/H0 /GC/GM/GI /G8/GF/G8/GQ/H0 /GN/GMmN Am
/GA L2[0,p] /BA /GV/GQ/GM Amu(t) /GC/GD Sm
/GM/GN/GO/GD/GC/GD/GJ/GD/GL /GA /B4/BD/BD/B5/B8 /G8E*
m /H3 /GP/GM/GN/GO /H3/GE /GD/GL/GL/GZ/GK /GI /GREm
/B8 Emu(t) /BA /FU /G8/GI/GG/GK /GF/G8/GC/G8 /GV/G8 /GI /GD/GH /GM/GJ/H0/GI/GR Em
/AM /GQ/GG/GN/G8 /FX/G8/GO /GC/GG/B8 /GQ/GM /GD/GB/GM /GK/GM /GE /GD/GQ /G9/GZ/GQ/H0 /GC/GM/GI /B4/GP/GK/BA/B8 /CJ/BD/BG/B8 /GJ/BA /C1/CG/B8 /GN/BA /BF/B5/BA /G8/GP/GP /B8 /GB /GC/GDf,gL2[0,p] /GG /GC/GM/GI /G8/GE /GD/GK /GD/GD /BA /FE /GP/GG/GJ/GR
|Dm(x)|/lessorequalslantC
|x|
/B8 /GB /GC/GDC /AL /GL/GD/GI /GN/GM/GP/GQ/GM /H3/GL/GL/G8/H3 /B4/GP/GK/BA/B8 /CJ/BD/BH /B8 /GJ/BA /BD /EF/BF/BE/B5/B8/GG/GK/GD/GD/GK/BM
|(Emf,g)|=/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsinglep/integraldisplay 0t/integraldisplay 0f(s)g(t)Dm(2t-s)dsdt/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/lessorequalslantp/integraldisplay 0t/integraldisplay 0|f(s)||g(t)||Dm(2t-s)|dsdt/lessorequalslant
/lessorequalslantCp/integraldisplay 0t/integraldisplay 0|f(s)||g(t)|1 2t-sdsdt=Cp/integraldisplay 0t/integraldisplay 0|f(s)|12t-s4/radicalbiggs t|g(t)|12t-s4/radicalbigg t sdsdt/lessorequalslant
/lessorequalslant p/integraldisplay 0t/integraldisplay 0|f(s)|21 2t-s/radicalbiggs tdsdt 1/2 p/integraldisplay 0t/integraldisplay 0|g(t)|21 2t-s/radicalbigg t sdsdt 1/2 . /GV/GG/GK /GA /GV/G8/GP/GQ/GG /GG /GI /G8/GE/GC/GZ/GH /GG/GF /GL/GG/GT /GA /GM/GQ /FE /GV/GG/GQ /B4/BK/B5 /GC/GM/GI /BE /G8 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GA /GO/G8/GA/GD/GL/GP/GQ/GA/GD/B5/BA /BA /FU /GM/GB/GC/G8 /GC/GJ/H3 /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GG/GK/GD/GD/GQ /GK/GD/GP/GQ/GM /GL/GD/GO /B4/BD/BE/B5 /GV/GQ/GM /GA /GP/GG/GJ/GR /GG/GT /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ /B4/BG /B5 /GL/G8/GK /GL/GR/GE/GL/GM /GA/GZ/GO/G8/GE /G8/GE /GD/GK/B8 /GV/GQ/GM /GC/GJ/H3 /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GA /GP/GR/GK/GK/GD /B4/GC/GJ/H3 /H1/GQ/GM/GB/GM /GK/GD/GP/GQ /G8/GK/GG /GA /B5/BM
/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsinglem/summationdisplay n=Nsinnx 2np/integraldisplay 0f(t)sinntt/integraldisplay 0u2(s)sin(2ns)dsdt/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/lessorequalslant
/lessorequalslantp/integraldisplay 0|u(s)|2/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsinglem/summationdisplay n=Nsin(2ns) 2nsinnxp/integraldisplay sf(t)sinntdt/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingleds/lessorequalslant
/lessorequalslantp/integraldisplay 0|u(s)|2m/summationdisplay n=N1 2n/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsinglep/integraldisplay sf(t)sinntdt/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingleds/lessorequalslantCu/bardblf/bardblL2, /G8/GI /GI /G8/GI /GN/GM/GP/braceleftbiggp/integraltext sf(t)sinntdt/bracerightbigg n=N={(Hsf,sinnt)}
n=N /GN/GO/GM/B9/GP/GQ/GOl2
/GG /GD/GD /GL/GM/GO/GK/G8 /GA /H1/GQ/GM/GK /GL/GD /GT /GM /GC/GG/GQ /bardblHsf/bardblL2/lessorequalslant/bardblf/bardblL2
/B4/GF/GC/GD/GP/H0Hs
/AL /GA L2[0,p] /GK/GM /GE/GL/GM /GC/GJ/H3 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GA /GV/G8/GP/GQ/GG /B4/BD/BF/B5/BA /G8/GP/GP /GP/GJ/G8/GB
/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsinglem/summationdisplay n=Np/integraldisplay 0t pf(t)cosntp/integraldisplay 0u(s)sin(2ns)dsdtsinnx/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/lessorequalslantC m/summationdisplay n=N/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsinglep/integraldisplay 0tf(t)cosntdt/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle2 1/2
*
*
m/summationdisplay n=N/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsinglep/integraldisplay 0u(s)sin(2ns)ds/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle/vextendsingle2 1/2
/lessorequalslantCu/bardblf/bardblL2. /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GK/GM /GE/GL/GM /GN/GM /GT /GM /GE/GG/GK /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GA /B4/BD/BF/B5 /GD/GK/B8 /GM/GJ/H0/GI/GR /H3 /GP/GJ/H0/GL/GM/B8/GN/GO/GM/GG/GF/GA/GD/GC/GD/GL/GG/GD f(t)U(t) L2[0,p] /GI /GA /GV/G8/GP/GQ/GG /B4/BD/BF /B5/BA /G8/GP/GP /GG/GF /GM/GJ/H0/GI/GR /GV/GD/GL /tildewideHsf(t) =kh[s,p]f(t) /BA/FK/GF /B5 /GP/GJ/GD/GC/GR /GD/GQ /GM /B4/BD/BG /B5 /B4/G8 /GF/GL/G8 /GV/GG/GQ /B8 /GG /B4/BD/BE /BF /G8 /GB/GM /GG /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GZ/GT /GA /G8 /GB/GM /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GA /B4/BI/B5 /H3 /B4/BE/BD/B5/GQ /G8/GI /GI /G8/GI /GN/GM/GP l1 /GI /GV/GJ/GD/GL/GR /B4/BI /B5/BA /FE /GP/GG/GJ/GR /GG/GT /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ /B4/BE/BE/B5/GB /BA/FP/G8/GI /B4/BK/B5/B8 /B4/BD/BE/B5 /GG /B4/BE/BD /GA/GZ/GQ/GD/GI /G8/GD/GQ /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /G8 /B4/BJ/B5/BA/FU /GD/GN/GD/GO/H0 /GK/GZ /GK/GM /GE /GD/GK /GJ/GD/GB/GI /GM /GC/GJ/H3 /GL/GM/GO/GK/GZ Bm
/BA /GV/GQ/GM /GM/GL /H3 /GA /GA/GG/GC/GD /FR/GM/GP/GI /GM/GJ/H0/GI/GR /GA/GZ/G9/GM/GO /GV/GG/GP/GJ/G8N /GQ/GM/GJ/H0/GI /GM /GM/GQu /B8 /GQ/GM /H3/GP/GL/GM/B8 /G8/GI /GI /G8/GI /H1/GQ/GM/GQ /H3 /GA /GI /GV/GG/GP/GJ/G8 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /FQ/GQ/GP/H2 /GC/G8 /GG /GG/GF /GL/GD /B4/BJ/B5 /GP/GJ/GD/GC/GR /GD/GQ /B8 /BG /B4/GC/GM/GI /GT /GM /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GA/GZ/GN/GM 0. /B4/BE/BH/B5 /G8/GP/GP Bm
/GL/G8 /GG /BM Bmyk(x) /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GA /GV/G8/GP/GQ/GG /GO/G8/GA/GL/GM /BC /GN/GO/GGm < k /GG /BA /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GP/GM/G9/GM/GH /GP/GR/GK/GK/GR /GO /H3/GC/G8 /FW/GR/GO/H0/GDk
/BA /FU /G8/GI /GI /G8/GI /GA/GP/GD kW1 2[0,p] /B8 /GQ/GM /GO /H3/GC /FW/GR/GO/H0/GD k
/GP /GT /GM /GC/GG/GQ/GP /H3 /GI /GL/GD/GH /GL/G8 /GD[0,p] /B8 /GG /GK/GZ /B8 0./FQ/GP/GQ /G8/GJ/GM/GP/H0 /GV/GQ/GM/B8 /GA /GP/GG/GJ/GR {yk(x)} /B4/GP/GK/BA /GR/GQ/GA/GD/GO /BD/B5/B8 /GG/GF /GD/GQ /B4/BE/BH /B5/BA/G0/G8/GB /BG /GF/G8/GA/GD/GO/GW/GD/GL /GI /GC/GM/GI /GR/GQ/GA/GD/GO /GM /GP/GI /GT /GM /FG/GJ/H3 /GV/GG/GK gk(x) /GV/GQ/GMcn= (f(x),wn(x)) /B5/BA /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GG /GC/GJ/H3 m /BH /G8 /GA C[0,p] /FU /B8 /G8uu(k)-0 /GN/GO/GGk-+ /BA/FT /GG/GT /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ /B4/BE/B5 /BM
/bardblf(x)-gk(x)/bardblL2/lessorequalslant/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/summationdisplay n=k+12 p(f(x),sinnx)sinnx/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble L2+/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/summationdisplay n=k+1/radicalbigg 2 p(f(x),psn(x))sinnx/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble L2+
+/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/summationdisplay n=k+1/radicalbigg 2 p(f(x),sinnx)phn(x)/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble L2+/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/summationdisplay n=k+1(f(x),psn(x))phn(x)/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble/vextenddouble L2/lessorequalslant
/lessorequalslantCu/parenleftBigg/summationdisplay n=k+1|cn,0|2/parenrightBigg1/2
+/bardblf/bardblL2uu(k),/BD/BD/GB /GC/GDuu(k)-0 /GN/GO/GGk-+ /BA/FE /GP/GG/GJ/GR /B4/BE/BG/B5 /GL/G8 /GL/GM/GO/GK/GR Bm
/GG/GF /GC/GM/GI /GL/GD /GA/GZ/GQ/GD/GI /G8/GD/GQ /GM /B4/BE/BJ/B5/BA /G0/G8/GB /BH /GF/G8/GA/GD/GO/GW/GD/GL /GI /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /GD /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GA /B4/BE/BI /B5/BA /FR/GR /GP/GQ/H0m > k /BA /GV/GG/GK /GV/GD/GO/GD/GFSm/B8 /GG/GF /G8/GL/GP/GQ/GA/G8 W1 2[0,p] /GA /G8/GL/GP/GQ/GA/GM C[0,p] /GN/GM = /BA /GM/GJ/H0/GI/GR /GA/GP/GD /GG L /G8/GQ /GN/GO/GM/B9/GP/GQ/GOW1 2[0,p] /B8 /GQ/GM Sm
/GL/G8 /GL/GG/GT /GI /FU /GM/GB /BI /G8 /GA C[0,p] /GL/G8/GQ/GR/GO /GV/GG/GP /GJ/GM/BA /FU /GM/GB/GC/G8 /GC/GJ/H3 /GJ/H2/G9/GM/GH /GG/GF /GG /GC/GJ/H3 e>0 /GP/GN/GO /GP/GQ/H0m > /GV/GQ/GM /GJ/GD/GA/GR/H2 /GV/G8/GP/GQ/H0 /GL/GD /B4/BE/BL /B5 /GK/GM /GE/GL/GM /G8/GA/GG/GQ/H0 /G8/GI /GI /G8/GIyn(x) /B8 /GB /GC/GDphn(x) /GA /B4/BE /B5/BA /GA/GZ/GA/GM /GC/GD /GL/GD /GK/GZ /GR/GV/GJ/GG /GQ/GM/GQ /G8/GI/GQ /B8 /GA/GJ/GM /GE /GD/GL/GG/H3 /G8/GL/GP/GQ/GA/GM We+1/2 2[0,p]-C[0,p] /B4/CJ/BD/BI /B8 /GN/BA /GV/GQ/GM /GC/GJ/H3 e>0 /GK/GZ /GN/GM /GV/G8/GP/GQ /H3/GK /GG /GR/GV/GJ/GG /GQ/GM/GQ /G8/GI/GQ /B8 /GV/GQ/GM phn(0) =phn(p) = 0 /BA/FU /G8/GI /GI /G8/GI /GG/GF /GG/GT /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ /B4/BE/B5 /GP/GJ/GD/GC/GR /GD/GQ /B8 =nen(x) +u(x)yn(x) /B8 /GB /FJ/GL/G8 /GV/GG/GQ /G8/GI/B8 /GP/GJ/G8/GB /G8/GD/GK/GM/GD /GA /B4/BE/BK /B5 /GK/GM /GE/GL/GM /GP /BI /GF/G8/GA/GD/GO/GW/GD/GL /GI /GM /GP/GJ/G8/GB /GA /B4/BE/BK/B5/BA Sm
/GL/G8 gN
/GM/GU/GD/GL/GG/B9/GA/G8/GD/GQ/GP /H3 /GQ/GM/GV/GL/GM /GQ /G8/GI /GE /GD/B8 /GI /G8/GI /GA /G8/GI /GI /B4/BE/BK /B5/B8 /B4/BE/BL /B5 /GG /B4/BF/BD /B5 /GP/GO/G8/GF/GR /GA/GZ/GQ/GD/GI /G8/GD/GQ /B8 /GV/GQ/GM /GC/GJ/H3 k/greaterorequalslantNu
/bardblBmgk/bardblC=/bardblf/bardblL2uu(m), /B4/BF/BE/B5/GB /GC/GDuu(m)-0 /GN/GO/GGm-+ /BA /FQ/GU/GD/GL/GI /G8 /B4/BH/B5 /GP/GJ/GD/GC/GR /GD/GQ /GG/GF /B4/BE/BI /B5/B8 /B4/BE/BJ/B5 /GG /B4/BF/BE /B5/BA /FU /GC/GM/GI /BA/FE /H1/GQ/GM/GK /GK/GZ /GT /GM/GQ/GD/GJ/GG /G9/GZ /GO/GD/GF/GR /GJ/H0 /GQ /G8/GQ /B8 /H3 /GA /GL/GD/GP/GI /GM/GJ/H0/GI /GM /G9/GM/GJ/GD/GD /FG/GD/GJ/GM /GA /GQ/GM/GK/B8 /GV/GQ/GM /GC/GM/GI /GR/GQ/GA/GD/GO /GA /CJ/BE/B8 /GL/G8 /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ/GZ /GC/GJ/H3 L /B8 /GA /GQ/GM/GH /GE /GD /GP/GQ /G8/GQ/H0/GD/BA /FQ/GC/GL/G8/GI /GM /GN/GM/GF/GE /GD /GQ/GD/GK/GG /GE /GD /GF/GL/G8 /GV/GD/GL/GG/GH /GP /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /G8/GK/GG /GM/GP/GQ /G8/GQ/GI /GM/GA/B8 /GN/GM /B4/H1/GQ/GG /GO/GD/GF/GR /GJ/H0 /GQ /G8/GQ/GZ /GD/GX/GD /GL/GD /FT /GN/GM/GJ/GR/GV/GD/GL/GL/GZ/GT /GG/GT /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ/B8 /GK/GG/B8 /GC/GM/GI /BF/BA/BD/BF /CJ/BE/B8 /GK/GM /GE/GL/GM /GM/GO/GK/GR /GJ/GZ /B5/B8 /GL/GM /GR/GE /GD /GP /GM/GU/GD/GL/GI /GA/GP/GD/GT /GN/GM/GP/GJ/H0/GL/GM/GP/GQ/GD/GH/B8 /GF/G8/GA/GG/GP /H3/GX/GG/GK/GG /GL/GD /GM/GQ /GI /G8 /GJ/GG/GW/H0 /GP/G8 /GW/G8/GO/G8R /BA/FE /H1/GQ/GM/GK /G9/GR /GC/GD/GQ /BE/BA /FR/GR/GP/GQ/H0 /GA /GR/GP /GQ/GD/GM/GO/GD /GK/GZ /BD /H3 /GC/GJ/H3 /GL/GD/GI R>0 /BA /FU /GN/GO/GGm-+ /G9/GJ/G8/GB/GM /GC/G8/GO/GG/GQ /GN/GO/GM /BA /G8/GJ/GG/GI /GM/GA/G8 /GG /GC/GM/GU/BA /G8 /GF/G8 /FC/BA /FO/BA/B8 /G0/GI /G8/GJ/GG/GI /GM/GA /FC/BA /FC/BA /GP /GP/GG/GL/GB/GR /BB/BB /FU /BA /BI/BI/BA /ED/BI/B8 /BD/BL/BL/BL/B8 /FT/BA /FC/BA /FO/BA/B8 /G0/GI /G8/GJ/GG/GI /GM/GA /FC/BA /FC/BA /GP /GK/GG /BB/BB /FU/GO/GR /GC/GZ /FO/GM/GP/GI /GM/GA/GP/GI /GM/GB/GM /FO/G8/GQ /BA /FU /BA/BI/BG/B8 /BE/BC/BC/BF/B8 /FT/BA /BT/BA /C5/BA/B8 /G0/GI /G8/GJ/GG/GI /GM/GA /FC/BA /FC/BA /FQ /GF/GL/G8 /GP /GK/GG /GG/GF /G8/GL/GP/GQ/GA /FU /BA/BK/BC/B8 /FT/BA /GM /FE/BA /FC/BA /GG /GG/GT /GN/GO/GG/GJ/GM /GE /GD/GL/GG/H3/BA /FM/GG/GD/GA/BM /FP/G8 /GR/GI /GM/GA/G8 /GC/GR/GK/B9/GI /G8/B8 /FK/GJ/H0/GG/GL /FE/BA /FC/BA /G8/GA/GL/GM/GP /GT /GM /GP /GO /H3/GC/GM/GK /GO/G8/GF/GJ/GM /GE /GD/GL/GG/GH /GN/GM /GI /GM /GP /GI /GP/GL/GZ/GK /GM/GK /BB/BB /FG/GG /BA /FU /BA /BE/BJ/B8 /ED/BG/B8 /BD/BL/BL/BD/B8 /FT/BA /FE/BA /FC/BA/B8 /FE/BA /FC/BA /G8/GA/GL/GM /GT /GM /GO /H3/GC/G8 /FW/GR/GO/H0/GD /GF/G8/GC/G8 /GV/GG /GG /GM/GB/GM /GO /H3/GC/G8 /FC/FP/B8 /FU /BA /BF/BK/BC/B8 /ED/BI/B8 /BE/BC/BC/BD/B8 /FT/BA /FK/BA /FE/BA /FQ /GT /GM /GO/G8/GF/GJ/GM /GE /GD/GL/GG/GH /GA /GO /H3/GC/GZ /GN/GM /GM/GH /GG /GN/GM /GP /GM/GK/AL/GO/G8/GP/GN/GO/GD/GC/GD/GJ/GD/GL/GG/GD/GK /BB/BB /FG/GM/GI/GJ/BA /FC/FP/B8 /FU /BA /BF/BL/BE/B8 /ED/BE/B8 /BE/BC/BC/BF/B8 /FT/BA /FO/BA /FE/BA /FQ /GF/GL/G8 /GG /GL/GD/GI /H3/GE /GD/GL/GL/GZ/GT /BB/BB /FG/FC/FP /FT/FT/FT /B8 /BD/BL/BH/BD/B8 /FU /BA /BJ/BJ/B8 /ED/BD/B8 /FT/BA /FO/BA /FC/BA /BA /FO/BA /FP/G8 /GR/GI /G8/B8 /G0/GI /G8/GJ/GG/GI /GM/GA /FC/BA /FC/BA /GA /GG /GF/G8/GC/G8 /GV/GG/B8 /GP /GL/GG/GK/GG /BB/BB /FU/GO/GR /GC/GZ /GP/GD/GK/BA /GG/GK/BA /FK/BA /GM/GB/GM/B8 /FU /BA /B8 /CB/CP /DA
/CW /D9/CZ /BT/BA /C5/BA /CU/D3/D6/D1 /D9/D0/CP/CT /CU/D3/D6 /D3/CU /DB/CX/D8/CW /D4 /D3/D8/CT/D2 /CP/D6/CG/CX/DA /FM/G8/GQ/GM /FU /BA /FU /GD/GM/GO/GG/H3 /BB/BB /FO/BA/BM /FO/GG/GO/B8 /FK/BA /FE/BA /FQ /GP/GI /GT /GM /GO/G8/GF/GJ/GM /GE /GD/GL/GG/GH /GA /GO /H3/GC/GZ /GN/GM /GM/GH /GG /GN/GM /GP/GM/GK/AL/GO/G8/GP/GN/GO/GD/GC/GD/GJ/GD/GL/GG/GD/GK /BB/BB /FG/GG /BA /FU /BA /BG/BG/B8 /ED/BH/B8 /BE/BC/BC/BK/B8 /FT/BA /BA/CJ/BD/BG /FX/G8/GO /GC/GG /BA /BA/B8 /FN/GG/GQ/GQ /GJ/H0/GA/GR /GC /FG/GE/BA /FH/BA/B8 /FR/GM/GJ/GG/G8 /BA /FP/GD/B8 /FO/BA/BM /GM/GP/GR /FD/G8/GO/GG /FP/BA /FM/BA /GO /H3/GC/GZ/BA /FO/BA/BM /GM/GP/GR /BA /FX/BA /FU /GD/GM/GO/GG/H3 /G8/GL/GP/GQ/GA /BB/BB /FO/BA/BM /FO/GG/GO/B8
|
0806.3016
|
Shkalikov
|
I. V. Sadovnichaya
|
Uniconvergence theorems for Sturm--Liouville operators with potentials
from Sobolev space $W_2^{-1}[0,\pi]$
|
15 pages
| null | null | null |
math.SP math.FA
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We consider a Sturm--Liouville $Ly=-y''+q(x)y$ in space $L_2[0,\pi]$ with
potential from Sobolev space $W_2^{-1}[0,\pi]$. Moreover, we assume, that
$q=u'$, where $u\in L_2[0,\pi]$. We consider Direchlet boundary conditions
$y(0)=y(\pi)=0$, although we can treat a boundary conditions of Sturm type. It
is known, that operators of such class have a discrete spectr with only
accumulation point $+\infty$ and the system $\{y_k\}_1^\infty$ of eigen and
associated functions is a Riesz basis in $L_2[0,\pi]$. Moreover, this basis is
a Hilbert--Schmidt perturbation of the basis $\{sin(kx)\}_1^\infty$. In this
paper we prove the uniconvergence theorem: for any element $f\in L_2[0,\pi]$
the sequence $P_nf-S_nf\to0$ as $n\to\infty$ in $C[0,\pi]$ (here $P_n$ and
$S_n$ are the Riesz projectors to $\{y_k\}_1^n$ and $\{\sin(kt)\}_1^n$
respectively).
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 18 Jun 2008 14:32:11 GMT"
}
] | 2008-06-19T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Sadovnichaya",
"I. V.",
""
]
] |
uration. These unequal momenta or skewing are a consequence of the mass theoutgoingreal ph [7, opportunity to constrain the gluon contribution to GPD s and to study the evolution in virtuality Q2of the quark and gluon distributions. On the other hand, rece ntly provided a tion of photoninduced pro- cess. The inclusive deep inelastic reaction and the photon d iffractive dissociation the following, we examine the most recent data in view of th e dipole [7, 8] and their implication on the quarks/gluo ns imaging of the nucleon [2,9, 10]. THE COLOR DIPOLE MODEL The colour dipole model provides a simple unified picture of i nclusive and and enables hard and soft physics to be incorporat ed in a single At high energies, in the proton's rest frame, the virtual photon fluctuates into a hadronic system (the simplest of which is a q-qdipole) a long distance upstream of the target proton. The formation time of this hadronic sys tem, and of the of the hadronic final state, is much longer than the interaction time with the target. DVCS is a good probe of the transition between soft and hard re gimes in the dipole model for two reasons. Indeed, the transverse photon wave fu nction can select large dipoles, even for large Q2, and certainly for the Q2range 2<Q2<20 GeV2. in the colour dipole approach, the DIS (or DVCS) proces s can be seen as wit t=0 is [7, the light cone photon wavefunctions for transverseand l ongitu- dinal photons. The quantity Q1is the virtuality of the incoming photon, whereas Q2is the virtuality of the outgoing photon. In the DIS case, one ha sQ2 1=Q2 2=Q2and The relative transverse quark pair (dipole) separation i s labeledby should be noticed that the non-forward kinematics for DVC S is encoded in (1). whichaffect the gluonand fthedipolecross section. At the present stage of the development of the dipole formali sm, we have no arguments on how to compute skewedness effects from first principles. A consistent approach would be to compute the scattering ampl itude in the since the non-forward photon wave function has been re cently obtained. In this case, the dipole cross section, depends on the momenta Pomeronand A first attemptin thisd very small values of the Bjorken scaling variable xthe saturation regime of QCD can be reached. In this domain, the gluon density in the proto n is so large that non- linear effects like gluon recombination tame its growth. In the dipole model approach, the transition to the saturation regime is characterised by the so-called saturation here as Qs(x) =Q0(x0/x)-l/2, parameters. The transition to saturation occurs when Qbecomes comparable to Qs(x). An of dipole models that incorporate saturation is tha t the total cross section can beexpressed as (2) This property, called geometric scaling, has already been o bserved to hold for the total epDIS cross section [11] and in diffractive processes [8]. It h as also recently been addressed in the context of exclusive processes including D VCS and extended to cases with non-zero momentum transfer to the proton [7]. It is ther efore interesting to test if the present DVCS measurements obey the geometric scaling laws predicted by FROMTHE of DVCS cross section have been realised at HER A within the H1 and ZEUS experiments [2, 3]. As mentioned in the introduction, t hese results are given 2 orders of magnitude. It makes possible to study the tra nsition from the low (around 1 GeV2) towards higher values of Q2where the higher twists effects are lowered (above 10 GeV2). The last data on DVCS cross section as a function of presented on figure 1. They show a strong 20 40 60 80 100 120 140ZEUS HERA IH1 HERA II e-p (prelim.)H1 HERA II e+p (prelim.) H1 HERA I Q2 = 8 GeV2H1H1 DVCS Analysis HERA II W [GeV] sDVCS [nb] FIGURE1. DVCS fun characteristic of a hard process, which can thus be describ ed as described and model comparisons are presented on figures 2 and 3. Th ey show that the dipole approach is very efficient in describing the DVCS m easurements for the HERA kinematics. It must be noticed here that the non-forwar d kinematics for DVCS is encoded only through the different weights coming from th e photon wavefunctions in Eq. (1). It means that without taking into account non-dia gonal effects that drive all the physics of GPDs, we can get a good descritption of all exis ting lowxBjdata in cross sections, a major of H1 [2] has been the measurement of DVCS cross sections, differenti al int= (p'-p)2, the momentum transfer (squared) at the proton vertex. Some resu lts are presente on figure 4: we observe the good description of dsDVCS/dtby a fit of the form e-b|t|. Hence, an extraction of the t-slopeparameter bis accessible for different values of 4and 5). HERA IH1 HERA II e-p Dipole 102 tsDVCS [GeV2] Dipole modelH1 HERA II 102 t dsDVCS/dt [nb/GeV2] FIGURE 2. DVCS cross section measurements as a function of the scaling (GeV2)10-11101s (nb)W=82 GeV 102 W (GeV)1101s (nb)Q2 (GeV2) 4 8 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
|t| (nb.GeV-2)W=71 GeVQ2=4 GeV2 (x2) W=82 GeVQ2=8 GeV2 FIGURE3. crosssection[7] dsDVCS/dt [nb/GeV2] Q2 = 8 GeV2 Q2 = 15.5 GeV2 Q2 = 25 GeV2 W = 82 GeVH1 10-1110 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 -t [GeV2]W = 40 GeV W = 70 GeV W = 100 GeV Q2 = 10 GeV2(prelim.)H1 DVCS Analysis HERA II (e-p) FIGURE4. DVCS tpresentedwitha fit oftheform 5 10 15 20 25 30 Q2 [GeV2] b [GeV-2] H1 HERA IH1 HERA II e-p (prelim.) A (1-B log(Q2/2))H1 DVCS Analysis HERA II 20 40 60 80 100 120H1 HERA II e-p (prelim.) H1H1 DVCS Analysis HERA II (e-p) W [GeV] b [Gev-2] FIGURE5. basa fit 40 60 80 100 120 140 W [GeV]R FIGURE 6. The skewing factor Ras a function of WatQ2=8GeV2. The curves represent define a basic quantity giving an overall measurement o f the skewing Namely, we set the ratio between the imaginary part s of the DIS and momentumtransfer attheprotonve rtex. In [12, 13], it has been shown how to extract this quantity fro m the DVCS cross sections. The factor Ris presented as a function of energy Win figure 6. An is observed within the present precision. This f eature can be since the Wdependence of both the DIS and DVCS cross section is value R0.5 is consistent with its early theoretical estimates using t he aligned jet model and the colour dipole model (see figure 6). We also di splay a dipole model prediction with an 'ad hoc' parametrisation for the off-dia gonal effects. It does sent in particular DVCS. Indeed, a Fourier transform from momentum to impact parameter space readily shows that the t-slopebis related to the typical between the colliding objects [6]. At high scale, t heq-qdipole is almost point- like, and the tdependence of the cross section is given by the transverse ex tension of the gluons (or sea quarks) in the proton for a given xBjrange. More precisely, intheintroduc tion,wecan labeled R,in theproton.Both by aFouriertrans of a single proton, and, in contrast to hadron-hadron sc attering, it does not expand as energy Wincreases. This result is consistent with perturbative QCD calculations in terms of a radiation cloud of gluons and quarks emitted aroun d the incoming short, gluonsare located at thepreiphery of thep roton as measured here areassumedto sm otherwords, amplitudei at Rin an image plane after focusing by an idealized lens. The squ are of the profile amplitude, producing the PDF (in transverse plane) i s positive, real-valued, and corresponds to the image, a weighted probability to find quar ks in the transverse CERN The complete parton imaging in the nucleon would need to get m easurements of bfor several values of xBj, from the low xBj<0.01 tillxBj>0.1. Experimentally, it appears to be impossible. Is it the breakout of quark and gluon imagin g in the proton? In fact, there is one way to recover over the whole xBjdomain: we Charge Asymmetry(BCA) [1,12, 14]. A determination of a cross section asymmetry with respect to the beam charge has been realised by the H1 experiment by measuring the ratio a function of f, wherefis the azimuthal angle between leptons and proton plane [1, 5]. The result is presented on figure 7 with a fit in cos f. After applying a deconvolution method to account for the resolution on f, the coefficient of the cos f dependence is found to be This result a major progress in the understanding of the very r ecent field of the parton imaging in the proton. We are at the hedge of the giving a new re ading on the qua rksand for future BCA measurements at COMPASS have b een studied muon beams and hydrogen targets, and then access experim entaly the DVCS pro- cessmp-mgp. The BCA can be determined when using positive and negative m from0 .05till0.1.It meansthat itis possibleto (degrees)bel.F0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180)-s + +s)/(-s - +sBCA = DVCS Analysis HERA II H1H1 data (prelim.) )bel.F cos(1p FIGURE7. Beam fmeasuredbyH1[1, measurements in the HERA kinematics at low xBjare well described within weights coming from the photon wavefunctions. No te that the dipole auniqueframework tha t givesagood description of all hard processes accessible at HERA. For the first time, w e have also shown that proton tomography enters into the experimental domain of hi gh energy physics, with a first experimental evidence that gluons are located at the p eriphery of the proton. A new frontier in understanding this structure would be poss ible at CERN within L. Schoeffel, proceedingsof the 27th International Conf erence on Physics in Collision (PIC F. D. Aaron et al.[H1 Collaboration], Phys. Lett. B 659(2008) 796 [arXiv:0709.4114 [hep-ex]] ; A. Aktas et al.[H1 Phys. J. C 44, 1 ; C. Adloff et S.Chekanov et Mod.Phys.A L. Schoeffel, proceedings of the 16th International Work shop on Deep Inelastic Scattering J.P. RalstonandB. Pire,Phys.Rev.D K.J. L.Favart,M. V. Phys L. Schoeffel, proceedings of the 15th International Wor kshop on Deep-Inelastic Scattering Kerhoas-Cavata ,J.
|
0806.3047
|
Schoeffel Laurent
|
Laurent Schoeffel
|
Deeply Virtual Compton Scattering at HERA and perspectives at CERN
|
8 pages, 6 figures, Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference
on Perspectives in Hadronic Physics, 12 - 16 May 2008, Trieste, Italy
|
AIPConf.Proc.1056:372-379,2008
|
10.1063/1.3013066
| null |
hep-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
Standard parton distribution functions contain neither information on the
correlations between partons nor on their transverse motion, then a vital
knowledge about the three dimensional structure of the nucleon is lost. Hard
exclusive processes, in particular DVCS, are essential reactions to go beyond
this standard picture. In the following, we examine the most recent data in
view of the dipole model predictions and their implication on the quarks/gluons
imaging (tomography) of the nucleon.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 18 Jun 2008 19:52:45 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 19 Jun 2008 10:27:53 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Schoeffel",
"Laurent",
""
]
] |
The unit disc is constructively compact; it can be effectivel y approximated with finite sets. When a computer attempts to display the unit disc, only a finit e set of the pixels can be shown. So instead of displaying an ideal disc, the computer display s a finite set that approximates the disc. This is the key criterion that Penrose's examples enjo y. They can be approximated to arbi- trary precision and displayed on a raster. Technically the epigraph of the exponential function is not compact; however, it is locally compact. One may wish to consider constructive locally comp act sets to be computable. This would mean that any finite region of a computable set has effect ive approximations of This definition of constructively compact sets has been form alized in the Coq proof assis- tant [11]. Approximations of compact sets can be rasterized and displayed inside Coq (sec- tion 6). For example, figure 1 shows a theorem in Coq certifyin g that a plot is close the expo- nential function. The plot itself is computed from the defini tion of the graph of the Figure 1. A theorem in Coq stating that a plot on a 42 by 18 raster is close to the graph of the expo- nential function on [- 6,1]. The standard definition of computable sets used in computabl e analysis says that a set is computable if the distance to the set is a computable real-va lued function. This definition is equivalent to our definition using computable approximatio ns (although, this has not been veri- fied in Coq). However, I believe defining computable sets by eff ective approximations of finite sets more accurately matches our intuition about sets that c an be drawn by a computer. 2 Constructive constructive logic is presented as a restriction of classical logic where proof by contradic- tion and the law of the excluded middle are not allowed. While this is a valid point of view, constructive logic can instead be presented as an extension of classical logic. Consider formulas constructed from universal quantificati on (), implication ( =), conjunc- tion ( ), true ( ), false ( ), and equality for natural numbers ( =N). Define negation by !ph /4ph= . One can (constructively) prove !!ph=phholds for any formula phgenerated from this set of connectives by induction on the structure of phbecause the atomic this case are equalities on N--are decidable. Thus, one can deduce classical results with con- structive proofs for formulas generated from this restrict ed set of connectives. 2 Section 2This set of connectives is not really restrictive because it can be used to define the other con- nectives. One can define the classical disjunction ( ~) byph~ps /4!(!ph !ps). Similarly, one can define the classical existential quantifier ( ~) by~x.ph(x) /4!x.!ph(x). With this full set of connectives, one can produce classical mathematics. The la w of the excluded middle (ph~!ph) has a constructive proof when the classical disjunction is u sed. Given this presentation of classical logic, we can extend th e logic by adding two new connec- tives, the constructive disjunction ( ) and the constructive existential ( ). These new connec- tives come equipped with their constructive rules of infere nce (given by natural deduction) [12]. These constructive connectives are slightly stronger than their classical counterparts. Construc- tive excluded middle ( ph !ph) cannot be deduced in general, and our inductive argument th at !!ph=phholds no longer goes through if phuses these constructive connectives. We wish to use constructive reasoning because constructive proofs have a A constructive proof of phpstells which of the two disjuncts hold. A proof of n: N.ph(n)gives an explicit value for nthat makes ph(n)hold. Most importantly, we have a functional interpretation of =and. A proof of n: N.m: N.ph(n,m)is interpreted as a func- tion with an argument nthat returns an mpaired with a proof of ph(n,m). The classical fragment also admits this functional interpr etation, but formulas in the typically end in /= . These functions take their arguments and return a proof of false. Of course, there is no proof of false, so it must be the c ase that the arguments be satisfied. Therefore, these functions ca n never be executed. In this sense, only trivial functions are created by proofs of classical formul as. This is why constructive mathe- matics aims to strengthen classical results. We wish to crea te proofs with non-trivial From now on, I will leave out the word constructive from phr ases like constructive disjunc- tion and constructive existential and simply write dis junction and existential. This follows the standard practice in constructive mathematics of using names from classical mathematics to refer to some stronger constructive notion. I will explicit ly use the word classical when I wish to refer to classical concepts. 2.1 Dependently Typed Functional Programming This functional interpretation of constructive deduction s is given by the Curry-Howard isomor- phism [12]. This isomorphism associates formulas with depe ndent types, and proofs of formulas with functional programs of the associated dependent types . For example, the identity function lx: A.x of a proof of the tautology A=A. Table 1 lists the logical connectives and type constructors. Logical Connective Type = function type: =
conjunction: product type: x disjunction: disjoint union type: +
true: unit type: () false: void type: for all: x.ph(x) dependent function type: Px.ph(x) exists: x.ph(x) dependent pair type: Sx.ph(x) Table 1. The association between formulas and types given by the Curr y-Howard isomorphism In dependent type theory, functions from values to types are allowed. Using by values, one can create dependent pair types , Sx: A.ph(x), and dependent func- tion types, Px: A.ph(x). A dependent pair consists of a value xof typeAand an value of type ph(x). The type of the second value depends on the first value, x. A dependent function is a function from the type Ato the type ph(x). The type of the result depends on the value of the input. Constructive Mathematics 3The association between logical connectives and types can b e carried over to We associate mathematical structures, such a s the natural numbers, with induc- tive types in functional programming languages. We associa te atomic formulas with types. For example, we can define equality on the na tural numbers, x=Ny, as a recur- sive function: 0 =N0 /4 Sx=N0 /4 0 =NSy /4 Sx=NSy /4x=Ny One catch is that general recursion is not allowed when creat ing functions. The problem is that general recursion allows one to create a fixpoint operator fix : (ph=ph)=phthat corresponds to a proof of a logical inconsistency. To prevent this, we allow o nly well-founded recursion over an argument with an inductive type. Because well-founded recu rsion ensures that functions the language is not Turing complete. However, on e can still express fast like the Ackermann function without difficulty [12 ]. Because proofs and programs are written in the same language , we can freely mix the two. For example, in my previous work [7], I represent the real num bers by the type f: Q+=Q.e1e2.| f(e1)-f(e2)| <=e1+e2. (1) Values of this type are pairs of a function f: Q+=Qand a proof of e1e2.| f(e1)-f(e2)| <=e1+e2. The idea is that a real number is represented by a function f that maps any requested precision e: Q+to a rational approximation of the real number. Not every function of type Q+=Qrepresents a real number. Only those functions that have coherent approximations should be allowed. The proof objec t paired with fwitnesses the fact thatfhas coherent approximations. This is one example of how mixi ng functions and formulas allows one to create precise datatypes. 2.2 Notation I will use the functional style of defining multivariate func tions with Curried types. A binary function will have type X=Y=Zinstead ofXY=Z(=is taken to be right associative). To ease readability, I will still write binary function appl ication as f(x, y), even though it should really be f(x)(y). Anonymous functions are written using lambda expressions. A function on natural numbers that doubles its input is written lx: N.2x. The type of the parameter will be omitted when it is clear from context what it should be. The type of propositions is . Predicates are represented by functions to . These predi- cates are often used where power sets are used in classical ma thematics. The type X=can be seen as the power set of X. I will often write xAin place of A(x)when A: X=andx: X. The notation xlis also used when lis a finite enumeration (section 4). Also x Swill be used when Sis a compact set (section 5). The types will make it clear what the be. I will use shorthand to combine membership with quantifiers. I will write x A.ph(x)for x.x A=ph(x), and x A.ph(x)will mean x.xA ph(x). Quotient types are not used in this theory. In place of quotie nts, setoids are used. A setoid is a dependent record containing a type X(its carrier), a relation : X=X=, and a proof that is an equivalence relation. When we define a function on setoi d, we usually prove it is respectful , meaning it respects the setoid equivalence relations on it s domain and codomain. Respectful functions will also be called morphisms . I will often write f(x)whenfis a record (or existential) with a function as its carrier (o r witness) and leave implicit the projection of finto a function. 4 Section 23 Metric a metric space is defined as a set Xwith a metric function d: Xx certain axioms. The usual constructive formulation r equiresdbe a computable function. In my previous work [7], I have found it useful to take a more re laxed definition for a metric space that does not require the metric be a function. Instead , I represent the metric via a respectful ball relation B: five axioms: 1. xe.B e(x,x) 2. xye.B xyze 1e2.Be1 +e2(x,z) 4. xye.(d.e<d ball relation Be(x, y)expresses that the points xandyare within eof each other. I call this a ball relationship because the partially applied rela tionBe(x): X=is a predicate that represents the ball of radius earound the point x. The first two axioms are reflexivity and sym- metry of the ball relationship. The third axiom is a version o f the triangle inequality. The fourth axiom states that the balls are closed balls. Clos ed balls are used because being closed is usually a classical formula. This means they can be ignored during they have no computational content [4]. We want to mi nimize the amount of computa- tion needed to get our constructive results. The fifth axiom states the identity of indiscernibles. This m eans that if two points are arbi- trarily close together then they are equivalent. The revers e implication follows from the reflex- ivity axiom and the fact that Bis respectful. In some instances, axiom 5 can be considered a s the definition of onX. For example, Qcan be equipped with the usual metric by defining the ball rela tion as BeQ(x,y) /4| x-y| <=e. This definition satisfies all the required axioms. 3.1 Uniform Continuity We are interested in the category of metric spaces with unifo rmly continuous functions between them. A function f: X=Ybetween two metric spaces is uniformly continuous with modulus uf: call a function uniformly continuous if it is uniformly continuous with some modulus. We use notation X-Ywith a single bar arrow to denote the type of uniformly contin uous functions from XtoY. This record type consists of three parts, a function fof typeX=Y, a modulus of continuity, and a proof that fis uniformly continuous with the given modulus. Again, we will leave the projection to the function type impl icit and allow us to write f(x)when f: X-Yandx: X. 3.2 Classification of Metric Spaces There is a hierarchy of classes that metrics can belong to. Th e strongest class of metrics are the decidable metrics where xye.B eX(x,y) !BeX(x,y). The constructive disjunction here implies there is an algor ithm for computing whether two points are within eof each other or not. The metric on Qhas this property; however, the metric onRdoes not because of the lack of a decidable equality. Metric Spaces 5The next strongest class of metrics is what I call located metrics . These metrics have =BdX(x,y) !BeX(x,y). This is similar to being decidable, but there is a little extr a wiggle room. If xandyare between eanddfar apart, then the algorithm has the option of either return a proof of BdX(x, y)or !BeX(x,y). This extra flexibility allows Rto be a located metric. Every decidable metric is also a located metric. Some metrics are not located. The standard sup-metric on functions between metric spaces may not be located. The weakest class of metrics we will discuss are the stable metrics . A metric is stable located metric is stable. Although we will discuss the possibility of non-stable metrics in section 7, it appears that metric spaces used in practice are stable. This work relies crucially on stability at one point, so we will be assuming that metric spa ces are stable throughout this paper. 3.3 Complete Metrics Given a metric space X, one can create a new metric space called the completion of X, or simply C(X). The type C(X)is defined to be f: Q+=X.e1e2.Be1 the ball relation defined to be BeC(X)(x,y) /4d1d2.Bd1 definition of C(X)may look familiar. It is a generalization of the type that I ga ve for real numbers in equation 1. In fact, in my actual implementation t he real numbers are defined to be C(Q). A complete metric comes equipped with an injection from the o riginal space unit: X-C(X) and a function bind: lifts uniformly continuous functions with domain Xto uniformly continuous function with domain C(X). One of the most common way of creating functions that operate on complete metric sp aces is by using bind. One first defines a function on X, which is easy to work with when Xis a discrete space. Then one proves the function is uniformly continuous. After that, bi nd does the rest of the work. A second, similar way of creating functions with complete do mains is by using map: The function map can be defined by map (f) /4bind(unit*f), but in my implementation, map is more fundamental than bind [ 7]. I will use the following notation: x^ /4unit(x) fV completion operation, C, and the functions unit and bind together form a standard con - struction called a monad [6]. Monads have been used in functional programs to capture many different computational notions including exceptions, mut able state, and input/output [13]. We will see another example of a monad in section 4. 3.4 Product Metrics Given two metric spaces XandY, their Cartesian product Xx Yforms a metric space with the standard sup-metric: BeXx Section 3The product metric interacts nicely with the completion ope ration. There is an C(Xx Y)andC(X)x C(Y). One direction I call couple . The other direction is defined by lifting the projection functions: couple : C(X)x C(Y)-C(Xx Y) p1- : C(Xx Y)-C(X) p2- : C(Xx Y)-C(Y) We denote couple The following lemmas prove that these functions form an iso - morphism. (z),p2- Hausdorff Metrics Given a metric space X, we can try to put a metric on predicates (subsets) of X. We start by defining the Hausdorff hemimetric. A hemimetric is a metric wi thout the symmetry and identity of indiscernibles requirement. We define the hemimetric rel ation /4xA.~y the use of the classical existential in this definitio n. In general, we do not need to know which point in Bis close to a given point in A; it is sufficient to know one exists without knowing which one. Furthermore, there are cases when we cann ot know which point in Bis close to a given point in A. This relation is reflexive and satisfies the triangle inequal ity. It is not symmetric. We define a symmetric relation by BeX=(A,B) relationship is reflexive, symmetric, and satisfies the triangle inequality. Notice that if B A thenHe(A,B)holds for all e. The hemimetric captures the subset relationship. If B A andA B (i.e. A B ), thenBe(A,B)holds for all e. However, axiom 5 for metric spaces requires the reverse implication; if Be(A,B)holds for all e, then we want A B . Unfortunately, this does not hold in general. Neither does the closedness pr operty required by axiom 4 hold. To make a true metric space, we need to focus on a subclass of pred icates that have more structure. 4 Finite Enumerations A finite enumeration of points from Xis represented by a list. A point xis in a finite enumera- tion if there classically exists a point in the list that is eq uivalent to x. We are not required to know which point in the list is equivalent to x; we only need to know that there is one. An equivalent definition can be given by well-founded recursio n on lists: xnil /4 xconsyl /4xy~xl Two finite enumerations are considered equivalent if they ha ve exactly the same members: a metric space, then the space of finite enumerations over X, F(X), is also a metric space. The Hausdorff metric with the membership predicate de fines the ball relation: BeF(X)(l1,l2) l2) This ball relation is both closed (axiom 4) and is compatible with our equivalence relation for finite enumerations (axiom 5), so this truly is a metric space . Finite Enumerations 7Finite enumerations also form a monad (I have yet to verify th is in Coq). The unit : X-F(X)function creates an enumeration with a single member. The bind: takes an f: X-F(Y)and applies it to every ele- ment of an enumeration l: F(X)and returns the union of the results. 4.1 Mixing Classical and Constructive the ball relation for finite enumerations is closed m akes essential use of classical rea- soning. Given e, whenever e<d . We need to show that By the definition of the metric, this requires proving (in part) xl1.~yl2.BeX(x, y). From our assumptions, we know that for every dgreater than e. If we had used a constructive existential in the definition of the Hausdorff hemimetric, we would have a problem. Each different value dcould produce a BdX(x,y). In order to use the closedness property from Xto conclude BeX(x, y), we need a singleysuch that BdX(x, y)holds for all dgreater than e. Classically we would use the infinite pigeon hole prin- ciple to find a single ythat occurs infinitely often in the stream of ys produced from d {e+1 n| n: N+}. Such reasoning does not work constructively. Given an infin ite stream of ele- ments drawn from a finite enumeration, there is no algorithm t hat will determine which one occurs infinitely often. Fortunately, because we used classical quantifiers in the de finition of the Hausdorff metric, we can apply the the infinite pigeon hole principle to this pro blem. We classically know there is someythat occurs infinitely often when d {e+1 n| n: N+}, even if we do not know which one. For suchy, BdX(x,y)holds fordarbitrarily close to e, and therefore BdX(x,y)must hold for all d greater than e. By the closedness property for X, BeX(x,y)holds as required. The other half of the definition of BeF(X)(l1,l2)is handled similarly. Recall that the classical fragment of constructive logic re quires that proof by for atomic formulas in order to deduce the rule !!ph=ph. BecauseBeX(x, y)is a param- eter, we do not know if it is constructed out of classical conn ectives. To use the classical rea- soning needed to apply the pigeon hole principle, we assume t This is the crucial point where stability of the metric for Xis used. 5 Compact Sets Completing the metric space of finite enumerations yields a m etric space of compact sets: K(X) /4C(F(X)) The idea is that every compact set can be represented as a limi t of finite enumerations that approximate it. In order for a compact set to be considered a s et, we need to define a member- ship relation. The membership is not over Xbecause compact sets are supposed to be complete andXmay not be a complete space itself. Instead, membership is ov erC(X), and it is defined forx: C(X)andS: K(X)as xS +e2X(x(e1),y). A point is considered to be a member of a compact set Sif it is arbitrarily close to being a member of all approximations of S. Thus K(X)represents the space of compact subsets of C(X). 5.1 Correctness of Compact Sets Bishop and Bridges define a compact set in a metric space Xas a set that is complete and totally bounded [1]. In our framework, we say a predicate A: X=is complete if for every x: C(X)made from approximations in A, thenxis inA: x: C(X).(e.x(e) A)= zA.z^ x8 Section 5A set B: X=is totally bounded if there is an e-net for every e: Q+. Ane-net is a list that for every x Bthere (constructively) exists a point zthat is construc- tively inlandBe(x,z). Bishop and Bridges use the strong constructive definition o f list mem- bership that tells which member of the list the value is. e: Q+.l: listX.(xl.x B) x our definition of compact sets correspond with Bishop an d Bridges's definition? The short answer is yes, but there is a small caveat. Our definition of me tric space is more general than the one that Bishop and Bridges use. Bishop and Bridges requi re a distance function d: X=X=R. Our more liberal definition of metric space does not have thi s requirement. I have verified that our definition of compact is the same as Bish op and Bridges's assuming that Xis a located metric. If a metric space has a distance function , then it is a located metric. Thus our definition of compact corresponds to Bishop and Brid ges's definition of compact for those metric spaces that correspond to Bishop and Bridges's definition of metric space. It may seem impossible that our definition can be equivalent t o Bishop and Bridges's defini- tion when we sometimes use a classical existential quantifie r while Bishop and Bridges use con- structive quantifiers everywhere. How would one prove Bisho p and Bridges version of x Sfrom our version of x S? The trick is to use the constructive disjunction from the de finition of located metric. Roughly speaking, at some point we need to pr ovezl.BeY(x, This can be done by doing a search though the list lusing the located metric property to decide for each element The is sufficient to prove that this finite search will su ccessfully find some zsuch The extra dcan be absorbed by other parts of the proof. The full proof of t he isomorphism is too technical to be presented here. A detaile d description can be found in my forthcoming PhD thesis or by examining the formal Coq proofs . 5.2 Distribution of FoverC The composition of two monads A*Bforms a monad when there is a distribution function dist : certain laws [5]. For compact sets, K(X) /4(C*F)(X), the dis- tribution function dist : defined by dist(l)(e) function interprets a finite enumeration of points from C(X)as a compact set. Thus Kis also a monad (I have yet to verified this in Coq). 5.3 Compact Image We define the compact image of a compact set S: K(X)under a uniformly continuous function fV : C(X)-C(Y)by first noting that applying fto every point in a finite enumeration is a uni- formly continuous function, map (f): F(X)-F(C(Y)). Composing this with dist yields a uni- formly continuous function from finite enumeration F(X)to compact sets K(Y). Using bind, this function can be lifted to operate on K(X). The result is the compact image function: f| S Bishop and Bridges would agree that the result of th is function is compact, they would not say that it is the image of Sbecause one cannot constructively prove yf| S = xS.fV (x)y. However, I believe one can prove (but I have not verified this y et) the classical statement yf| S = ~xS.fV (x)y. WhenfV is injective, as it will be for our graphing example in sectio n 6.1, the constructive exis- tential statement holds. Compact Sets 96 Plotting Functions There are many examples of constructively compact sets. Thi s section illustrates one application of compacts sets, plotting functions. 6.1 Graphing Functions Given a uniformly continuous function fV : C(X)-C(Y)and a compact set D: K(X), the graph of the function over Dis the set of points {(x,fV (x))| x D} . This graph can be constructed as a compact set G: K(Xx Y). A single point is graphed by the function g(x) , This function is uniformly continuous, g: X-C(Xx Y). The graph Gis defined as the compact image of Dunderg. G /4g| D 6.2 Rasterizing Compact Sets Given a compact set in the plane S: K(Qx Q), we can draw an image of it, or rather we can draw an approximation of it. This process consists of two ste ps. The first step is to compute l /4S(e). The finite enumeration lis a list of rational coordinates. The next step is to move these points around so that all the points lie o n a raster. A raster is simply a two dimensional matrix of Booleans. Given coordinates for t he top-left and bottom-right cor- ners, a raster can be interpreted as a finite enumeration. Usi ng advanced notation features in Coq, a raster can be displayed inside the proof assistant. Mo st importantly, when the con- structed raster is interpreted, it is provably close to the o riginal compact set. 6.3 Plotting the Exponential Function. Given a uniformly continuous function fV : R-Rand an interval [a,b], the graph of fV over this compact interval is a compact set. The graph is an ideal mathe matical curve. This graph can then be plotted yielding a raster that when interpreted as a fi nite enumeration is provably close to the ideal mathematical curve. Recall figure 1 from section 1. It is a theorem in Coq that state s the (ideal mathematical) graph of the exponential function (which is uniformly conti nuous on (-, 1]) restricted to the range [0,3]on the interval [-6,1]is is equivalent to1 8) of the finite set repre- sented by raster shown with the top-left corner mapped to (-6,3)and the bottom-right corner mapped to (1,0). The raster is 42 by 18, so, by considering the domain and rang e of the graph, each pixel represents a1 6by1 6square. The error between the plot and the graph must always b e greater than half a pixel. I chose an ethat produces a graph with an error of3 4of a pixel. In this case3 4* 1 61 8, which is the error given in the theorem. There is one small objection to this image. Each block in the p icture represents an infinites- imal mathematical point lying at the center of the block, but the block appears as a square the size of the pixel. This can be fixed by interpreting each block as a filled square instead of as a single point. This change would simply add an to the error term. This has not been done yet in this early implementation. 7 Alternative Hausdorff Metric is another possible definition for the Hausdorff metric . One could define the as He'(A,B) /4xA.d.y extra flexibility given by the dterm also allows one to conclude that there is some y B that is within eofxwithout telling us which one (again, it may be the case that we cannot know which yis the one). Our original definition He(A,B)is implied by He'(A,B); however, the alternative definition yields more constructive informati on. 10 Section 7The two definitions are equivalent under mild assumptions. W henXis a located metric, This is very common case and allows us to recover the constru in the H'version from the Hversion. The constructive existential in the definition of H'would make the resulting metric not provably stable. It is somewhat unclear which version is the right definition for the metric. The key deciding factor for me was that I had declared the ball relation to be in theProp universe. Coq has a Prop /Set distinction where values in the Prop universe are removed during program extraction [11]. To make program ext raction sound, values outside the Prop universe cannot depend on information inside the Prop universe. This means that even if I used theH'definition in the Hausdorff metric, its information would not be allowed by Coq to construct values in Set. For this reason, I chose the Hversion with the classical quantifiers for the definition of the Hausdorff metric. Values with classical existential quantifier type have no information in them and naturally fit into the Prop universe. 8 Conclusion This work shows that one can compute with and display constru ctively compact sets inside a proof assistant. We showed how to graph uniformly continuou s functions and render the results. We have turned a proof assistant into a graphing calculator. Moreover, our plots come with proofs of (approximate) correctness. Even though a classical quantifier in the Hausdorff metric is u sed, it does not interfere with the computation of raster images. This development shows th at one can combine classical rea- soning with constructive reasoning. The classical existen tial quantifier was key in allowing us to use the pigeon hole principle to prove the closedness proper ty of the Hausdorff metric. All of the theorems in this paper have been verified by Coq exce pt where indicated other- wise. Those few theorems that have not been verified in Coq are not essential and have not been assumed in the rest of the work (the statements simply do not a ppear in the Coq formalization). This formalization will be part of the next version of the CoR N library [3], which will be released when Coq 8.2 is released. Given my previous work about metric spaces and uniformly con tinuous functions [8], the work of defining compact sets and plotting functions took onl y one and a half months of addi- tional work. This work provides a foundation for future work. One can cons truct more compact sets such as fractals and geometric shapes. Proof assistants could be modified so that the high of a monitor could be used instead of the ASCII art n otation that is used in this work. 9 would like to thank my advisor, Bas Spitters, for suggestin g the idea that compact sets can be defined as the completion of finite sets. I would also like to thank Jasper Stein whose implementation of Sokoban in Coq [10] using ASCII art inspired the idea of using Coq's notation mechanis m for displaying graphs inside Coq. Errett Bishop and Douglas Bridges. Constructive Analysis . Number 279 in Grundlehren der mathematis- chen Wissenschaften. Springer-Verlag, 1985. [2] Vasco Brattka. The emperor's new recursiveness: The epigra ph of the exponential function in two models of computability. In Masami Ito and Teruo Imaoka, editors, Words, Languages & Combinatorics III , pages 63-72, Singapore, 2003. World Scientific Publishing. ICWLC 2000, Kyoto, Japan, March 14-18, 2000. Bibliography 11 [3] L. Cruz-Filipe, H. Geuvers, and F. Wiedijk. C-CoRN: the cons tructive Coq repository at Nijmegen. In A. Asperti, G. Bancerek, and A. Trybulec, editors, Mathematical Knowledge Management, Third Interna- tional Conference, MKM 2004 , volume 3119 of LNCS , pages 88-103. Springer-Verlag, 2004. [4] L. Cruz-Filipe and B. Spitters. Program extraction from lar ge proof developments. In D. Basin and B. Wolff, editors, Theorem Proving in Higher Order Logics, 16th International Conference, TPHOLs 2003 , volume 2758 of LNCS , pages 205-220. Springer-Verlag, 2003. [5] Mark P. Jones and Luck Duponcheel. Composing monads. Techni cal Report Yale University, 1993. [6] E. Moggi. Computational lambda-calculus and monads. In Proceedings of the Fourth Annual Symposium on Logic in computer science , pages 14-23, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 1989. IEEE Press. [7] Russell O'Connor. A monadic, functional implementation of real numbers. Mathematical. Structures in Comp. Sci. , 17(1):129-159, 2007. [8] Russell O'Connor. Certified exact transcendental real numb er computation in Coq. In Otmane Ait- Mohamed, editor, TPHOLs , volume 5170 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science , pages 246-261. Springer, 2008. [9] Roger Penrose. The Emperor's New Mind: Concerning Computers, Minds, and Th e Laws of Physics . Oxford, NY, 1989. [10] Jasper Stein. Coqoban, September 2003. . [11] The Coq Development Team. The Coq Proof Assistant Reference Manual - Version V8.0 , April 2004. . [12] S. Thompson. Type Theory and Functional Programming . Addison Wesley, 1991. [13] P. Wadler. Monads for functional programming. In Proceedings of the Marktoberdorf Summer School on Program Design Calculi , August 1992. 12 Section
|
0806.3209
|
Russell O'Connor
|
Russell O'Connor
|
A Computer Verified Theory of Compact Sets
|
This paper is to be part of the proceedings of the Symbolic
Computation in Software Science Austrian-Japanese Workshop (SCSS 2008)
| null | null |
RISC-Linz Report Series 08-08
|
cs.LO
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
Compact sets in constructive mathematics capture our intuition of what
computable subsets of the plane (or any other complete metric space) ought to
be. A good representation of compact sets provides an efficient means of
creating and displaying images with a computer. In this paper, I build upon
existing work about complete metric spaces to define compact sets as the
completion of the space of finite sets under the Hausdorff metric. This
definition allowed me to quickly develop a computer verified theory of compact
sets. I applied this theory to compute provably correct plots of uniformly
continuous functions.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 19 Jun 2008 18:09:01 GMT"
}
] | 2010-08-04T00:00:00 |
[
[
"O'Connor",
"Russell",
""
]
] |
2 dynamical evolutions in each side may be different due to different con trol parameters ( u1,n1,g1) and (u2,n2,g2). We represent the interface between the two domains by I, then the following boundary conditions are required on a derivative of Uiover space variable along the direction perpendicular to the interfa ceI. We assume that U1=U2= 0 is a stable point of Eq.(1) and ui(ni) controls (not controls) the linear terms of Uifor the reaction parts. Hopf bifurcation with frequency o0is supposed to occur at parameters u1=u2=u0. Moreover, we assume further that both u1andu2are slightly beyond the Hopf bifurcation i= 1,2 periodic oscillation of frequency oi, o0asuireduces to u0(i= 1,2). Eq.(1) can be reduced to amplitude equations, i.e., the b idomain complex Ginzburg-Landau by the approach standard for the derivative of single-do main CGLE [15, (ai,ohmi), (bi, ai) and (ci, bi) arerelated to ui-u0, (ui-u0,ni) and (ui-u0,gi), respectively. The Eq.(4c) can be derived from condition (2) because the tr ansformation from U1toA1is exactly the same as that from U2toA2(in the two domains, amplitude equations are derived at a common Hop f bifurcation point with an identical linear matrix at u0), and the transformations from UitoAi(i= 1,2) are determined only by this linear matrix. In Eq.(4) A1andA2are complex variables in each side of the interface. With scaling trans formations we can fixa1, b1, c1and ohm 1, and the remaining 8 parameters are irreducible for BCGLE systems . In the following study we will seta1=b1=c1= 1,ohm1= 0 for numerical simulations without mentioning and all the theoretic al formulas are given generally for 12 parameters. Without the interface interact ion, the two media have their single-domain planar wave solutions [2, 17] Ai(x,t) ai,bi,ci>0 (5b) Waves in media M1andM2are classified to NWs and AWs under the conditions [3, 12, ;or, (6b) By AWs we mean waves with negative phase velocity, while both NWs and AWs have positive group velocities [11, 12, 14]. Now we focus on the interface related problems, and start from a one-dimensional (1D) BCGLE system. We are interested in the problem how the interface can significantly influ ence the system dynamics. In Fig.1(a)-(c) we study the system evolutions at two different parameter sets with r andom initial conditions, and find features in the asymptotic states. The most significant a nd new observation is given in Figs.1(a) and 1(b) where we find homogeneous planar waves moving in both media from rig ht to left with a constant velocity crossing the interface. These homogeneous runn ing waves originate from the interface (see called interface selected waves (ISWs). The phenome non of Fig.1(a) is surprising. With two media having different we intuitively expect that the waves in two media must have different wavenumbers (even if both sides may have the same frequency). This common feature is clearly seen in Fig.1(c) where we observe uniform bulk oscillation in the right medium and waves propagating from left to r ight in the left medium, clearly manifesting the interface I. However, in Fig.1(a) wavespropagate seemly in a homogeneous med ium without feeling any the interface is transparent to the waves. Moreover, the realiz ation of these running waves is stable against different initial perturbations. This characteristic phenom enon can never exist in linear systems, and has never been observed so far in nonlinear systems. It is interesting that we can predict the frequency and wave numbe r of ISWs explicitly and exactly under conditions. For case of Fig.1(a) we can determine the fr equency and wave number by the following =o2(k2), k1=k2,|A1|=|A2| (7) Inserting Eqs.(7) into Eq.(5) we obtain a unique set of solutions these solutions are exact in the parameter surface for 0 :if and only 0 (8c) for c1b2-c2b1= 0 :if and only if a 1b2-a2b1= 0 which is obtained by inserting Eq.(8a) into Eq.(5a), and by the identify ing|A1|=|A2|. It can be easily confirmed that on the parameter surface Eq.(8c) the planar wave solution Eq .(5) with frequency and wave numbers given by Eqs.(8a) and (8b) are exact solution of BCGLE. Moreover, the pre dictions of Eqs.(7) and (8) agree exactly with the numerical results of Fig.1(a). In Figs.2(a) and 2(b) we specify the surface of Eq.(8c) in some para meter planes where solid lines represent the parameters satisfying condition (8c). In Figs.2(c) and 2(d) we var y parameters along the solid line of Fig.2(a) and numerically compute 1D BCGLE. we compare the numerical results (e mpty cycles and triangles) with of Eqs.(8a) and (8c) (solid lines), and find: (i) ISWs exist in a large area of surface Eq.(8c); (ii) the predictions ofEqs.(8a)and (8b) coincide with numericalresults exa ctly(within computation precision). In Fig.2(e) we fix a parameter set on the surface (black disk T) and present the a symptotic pattern evolution of the BCGLE system. It is clearly shown that ISWs, with the wave number and frequency p redicted by Eqs.(8a) and (8b), the entire bidomain during their propagation. For demonst rating the possibility of observation of ISWs in experiments, we study a model: bidomain Brussela tor. In Fig.2(f), we show ISWs of this chemical model, satisfying all conditions of Eqs.(7). The solutions of Eqs.(8a) and (8b) are exact for BCGLE only on the p arameter surface of Eq.(8c). Slightly away from this surface Eqs.(8a) and (8b) can no longer predict the wave numbers and the frequencies of ISWs exactly. In Figs.3(a) and 3(b) we compare the theoretical predictions of Eqs.( 8a) and (8b) with numerical results of frequencies and wave numbers by varying parameters along the dashed line in Fig.2 (a). We find: (i) The solutions of Eqs.(8a) and (8b) are not exact; the wave numbers in the two domains deviat e from each other (about 7 .7% difference in Fig.3(d)); (ii) However, slightly away from the surface Eq.(8c), the feature that the interface generates waves is still clearly observed (compare Fig.1(b) with Fig.3(c)), i.e., ISWs still exist ; (iii) By continuously increasing the from condition Eq.(8c), the deviation of the numerical res ults from the theoretical predictions Eqs.(8a) and (8b) increases continuously from zero too, and for small paramet er deviation the solutions Eqs.(8a) and (8b) can still be used for predicting frequency and wave numbers with very good approximation. In Figs.3(c) and 3(d) we show ISWs for a parameter set away from the surface Eq.(8c) (Disk Q in F ig.2(a)). It is clear that even away from surface Eq.(8c) the waves of Fig.3(c) are generated by the interface in the similar way as in Fig.1(b) though we have k1=k2 in Fig.1(b) but Fig.3(c). Thus the waves in Fig.1(a), 1(b) and Figs.3(c), 3(d), hav e obviously the nature which is essentially different from the wa ves of Fig.1(c). Similar ISWs with also be observed in bidomain Brusselator. In Figs.3(e) and 3(f) we take p arameter set far away from that in Fig.2(f), and can still observe ISWs. Here the wave numbers in the two sides have slight difference are some necessary conditions for ISWs to appear. Let us a nalytically specify some of these conditions under Eq.(8c) (Eqs.(8a) and (8b) are exact solutions of oIandkI). From Eqs.(8a) and (5a) we have an obvious condition for ISWs, i= 1,2 (9a) which should be satisfied because wave number kImust be real. If this condition is violated, there is no solutions of kIandoI, and thus no ISWs can be observed. This is the case of Fig.1(c). ISW s are generated by the interface and propagate along a certain directio n. Therefore, the waves must forwardly propagate in one domain. Precisely, ISWs are NWs in the left (or right) domain while AWs in the right (left) domain for from right (left) to left (right), and this requires ano ther parameter 1,-i= 2or i= 2,-i= 1 In order to provide an idea how these conditions influence the existe nce of ISWs, we show Fig.4, where one can numerically observe ISWs in the regions enclosed by disks, called ISW regions. In Fig.4 dashed-dotted lines with k2 I= 0 and ai=bi, i= 1or2 are the boundaries of ISW theoretically predicted by Eqs.(9a)a nd (9b), respectively. In No ISW regions ISWs do not exist due to violations of conditions o f Eq.(9a) or (9b). In the regions Unstable, ISWs exist while waves with wave number kIare unstable due to Eckhaus instability, and there ISWs cannot be numerically observed. Figures 4(a) and 4(b) are plotted in a small pa rameter surface under the condition of Eq.(8c). Similar structure of distributions ISW, No ISW and Unstable r egions can be observed when parameters are varied slightly away from the set of Eq.(8c). Though the above investigations are made for 1D bidomain systems, the observations of ISWs exist generally systems. In 2D oscillatory systems, much richer t ypes of waves, including spirals and antispirals, can be self-sustained, and wave competitions become an important issue. Now we explore how ISWs play crucial roles in wave competitions. We consider a 2D BCGLE system with an interfac e lineII'in between. Without the M1supports normal spirals (Figs.5(a), (d), (g)) and M2supports antispirals ( Figs.5(b), (e), (h)). With the interface interaction we find different result s of wave competitions. Fig.5(c): the antispiral wins the competition and dominates the system with frequency o2; Fig.5(f): the spiral wins; Fig.5(i): ISWs win and dominate the two domains. The reasons why we can observe so diver se results in similar competitions between spiral and antispiral waves can be completely understood based on the an alysis of ISWs. For explaining the results of Fig.5 we briefly introduce some known con clusions on wave competitions in If competitions occur in a homogeneous medium, the resu lts are [3, 18]: NWs against NWs :faster waves win (10a) AWs against AWs :slower waves win (10b) NWs against AWs :NWs win (10c) With the competition rules Eq.(10) and the analytical results of Eqs.( 7)-(9) we can fully understand and predict the diverse results of Fig.5. Inserting the parameters of Fig.5(c) into Eq.(8) we have oI= 0.636. Considering conditions Eq.(6) we conclude that ISWs are NWs in M1and AWs in M2(note, the interface is the source of ISWs). The frequencies of t he spiral in M1and the antispiral in M2areo1= 0.288 ando2= 0.626, respectively. According to conclusion (10) ISWs win the competition in M1against the spiral while losing the battle in M2against the AW spiral. Therefore, the antispiral waves of frequency o2finally dominate the whole system. The parameters of Fig.5(f) do not satisfy condition Eq.(9a), and no ISWs can be generated. In Figs.5(d) and (e) we observe o1=-0.0567 and o2= 0.151. According to Eq.(6) waves of o1(o2) are NWs (AWs) in both M1andM2. On the basis of (10c), the spiral of frequency o1wins the competition. The most interesting observation is given in Fig.5(i) wher e we have oI= 0.932. The frequency of in M1(M2) iso1= 0.293 (o2= 1.037). Therefore, ISWs win both competitions against the spiral in M1(condition (10a)) and against the antispiral in M2(condition (10b)). The asymptotic state is ISWs in 2D system where ISWs suppress both spiral and antispiral in Fig.5(i). In conclusion, we investigated the role played by interfaces. A new t ype of waves, interface selected waves (ISWs) were found in bidomain systems with one medium supports AWs and the other NWs. When control parameters are5 on a well defined parameter surface ISWs propagate with analytica lly predictable same frequency and wave number in two media with different parameters. When the parameters are aw ay but near this surface, ISWs can be also observed, of which the frequency and wave numbers can be locate d approximately. These waves are selected by interfaces between two media, and some necessary conditions for observing these ISWs are specified. These ISWs play important roles in wave competitions. For instance, under certain c onditions ISWs can suppress spiral and antispiral waves in both media. These roles are important in practical applicatio ns. Experimental realizations of ISWs in chemical systems are strongly suggested, bas ed on the well-behaved ISWs of Fig.2(f), Fig.3(e) and Fig.3(f) computed for a chemical Cao is supported by the knowledge innovation program of the Chin ese Academy of Sciences. [1] R. A. Shelby, D. R. Smith, and S. Schultz, Science 292, 77 (2001). [2] M. Hendrey, E. Ott, and T. M. Antonsen Jr., Phys. Rev. Lett .82, 859 (1999); Phys. Rev. E 61, 4943 (2000). [3] Z. Cao, H. Zhang, and G. Hu, Eur. Phys. Lett. 79, 34022(2007). [4] M. Vinson, Physica D 116, 313 (1998). [5] M. Zhan, X. Wang, X. Gong, and C. H. Lai, Phys. Rev. E 71, 036212 (2005). [6] L. B. Smolka, B. Marts, and A. L. Lin, Phys. Rev. E 72, 056205 (2005). [7] R. Zhang, L. Yang, A. M. Zhabotinsky, and I. R. Epstein, Ph ys. Rev. E 76, 016201 (2007); [8] C. G. Parazzoli, D. B. Brock, and S. Schultz, Phys. Rev. Le tt.90, 107401 (2003). [9] V. K. Vanag and I. R. Epstein, Science 294, 835 (2001); Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 088303 (2002). [10] L. Yang, M. Dolnik, A. M. Zhabotinsky, and I. R. Epstein, J. Chem. Phys. 117, 7259 (2002). [11] Y. Gong and D. J. Christin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 088302 (2003); Phys. Lett. A 331, 209 (2004). [12] L. Brusch, E. M. Nicola, and M. B ar, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 089801 (2004); E. M. Nicola, L.Brusch, and M. B ar, J. Phys. Chem. B 10814733 (2004). [13] P. Kim, T. Ko, H. Jeong, and H. Moon, Phys. Rev. E 70, R065201 (2004). [14] Z. Cao, P. Li, H. Zhang, and G. Hu, the International Jour nal of Mordern Physics B 21, 4170 (2007). [15] M. Cross and P. Hohenberg, Rev. Mod. Phys. 65, 851 (1993). [16] I. S. Aranson and L. Kramer, Rev. Mod. Phys. 74, 99 (2002). [17] I. S. Aranson, and L. Aranson, Phys. Rev. A 46, R2992 (1992). [18] K. J. Lee, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 2907 (1997).6 FIG. 1: (a)-(c) Contour patterns of Re Aiof a 1D BCGLE system with interface I. Domains Mi,(i= 1,2) have length Land parameters ai, bi, andai=bi=ci= 1,ohmi= 0, i= 1,2. Numerical simulations are made with space step dx= 0.5, time step dt= 0.005, and L= 200. No-flux boundary condition, randomly chosen initial c onditions and the above time and space steps are used in all figures for numerical simulations unless spec ified otherwise. (a) a1= 0.1, b1=-1.4, a2=-0.2, b2= waves (ISWs) homogeneous in M1andM2are observed, and the interface is transparent to ISWs. (b) T he same as (a) with early time evolution plotted. It is clearly s hown that ISWs originate from the interface. (c) a1= 0.1, b1=
-1.4, a2= 0.5, b2= different regular waves, clearly manifesting inter faceI. FIG. 2: (a) Surface Eq.(8c) (Solid line) is plotted in a2-b2plane with ohm 2= 0, c2= 2.0, a1= 0.6, b1=-1.4, a2=
0.1, b2= 1.2. (b) The same as (a) with surface (8c) plotted in a2-a2plane,b2= 1.778. Point E corresponds to the boundary k2= 0. (c) Frequency of ISWs which are selected along the solid l ine of (a). Theoretical prediction Eq.(8a) (solid line) coincides with numerical simulation for 1D BCG LE (empty circles and triangles) perfectly. (d) The same as (c) with wave numbers k1=k2plotted. Agreement between theoretical prediction Eq.(8a ) and numerical results is also confirmed. (e) ISW pattern obtained by using the parameter se ta2= 1.8, b2= 1.778 (point T in (a)). (f) The same as (e) with contour pattern of vvariable of Brusselator RD which is numerically computed fo r 1D chain. The system i= 1,2, a1= 1.0, b1= 2.24, g1=s1= 0.0, du1=
2.31, dv1= 2.17;a2= 1.02, b2= 2.2624, g2= 0.02, s2= 0.01, du2= 0.95, dv2= 2.47;dx=dy= 0.5, dt= 0.0025, L= 300. ISWs with identical wandkare observed.7 FIG. 3: (a) (b) The same as Figs.2(c) and (d), respectively, w ith parameters varied along the dashed line of Fig.2(a). Num are made for 1D BCGLE. Now deviations between th eoretical results of Eqs.(8a), (8b) and the numerical resul ts are observed. Deviation increases as parameters varyaway from thesurface Eq.(8c). (c)(d)The same as Fig.2(e) with differe nttime intervals plotted, respectively, in which parameters are t akenaway from the solid line of Fig.2(a) (pointQ, a2= 1.6, b2= 1.778). Now ISWs are still observed while wave numbers in the two side s are slightly (e) (f) The same as (c) and (d), respectively, with 1D Brusselato r chain computed. The parameter set is considerable differen t from that of Fig.2(f): a1= 1.0, b1= 3.2, g1=s1= 0.0, du1= 1.0, dv1= 0.5;a2= 1.1, b2= 3.2, g2= 0.1, s2= 0.0, du2=
1.0, dv2= 2.5. Now the wave numbers of the two sides are also slightly diffe rent 4: The distributions of different types of waves in ( a1, a2) parameter planes for different sets of ( b1, b2). Black disks represent the boundaries of ISW regions (ISW regions) ide ntified by direct numerical simulations of 1D BCGLE. In No IS W regions, ISWs do not exist due to the violations of condition Eq.(9a) (boundary k2 I= 0, i.e., a1=a2) or condition ai=bi, i= 1 or 2) (both presented in dashed-dotted lines). In the regi on Unstable, both conditions Eqs.(9a) and (9b) are satisfied, but waves with the given kIare unstable due to the Eckhaus instability. ai=bi=ci= 1,ohmi= 0, i= 1.4, (b)b1= 2.5,b2= 0.5. Black triangles A and B in Fig.4(a) represent the paramete r sets used in Figs.1(a), (c), 5: Wave competitions between spiral, antispiral and IS Ws in 2D BCGLE with interface II'.ai=bi=ci= 1,ohmi= 0, i=
1,2. (a)(d)(g) Spirals in M1medium. (b)(e)(h) Antispirals in M2medium. Snapshots in (a)(b), (d)(e) and (g)(h) are used as the initial conditions for the dynamic evolutions of (c), (f ) and (i), respectively. (c)(f)(i) The asymptotic states of bidomain systems with interface II'. (a)(b)(c) a1= 0.2, b1= 2.0, a2= 1.0, b2=-0.5. Antispiral initially in M2dominates the system in (c). (d)(e)(f) a1= 0.2, b1=-2.0, a2= 0.5, b2=-1.4. Spiral initially in M1dominates the system in (f). (g)(h)(i) a1= 0.1, b1= 3.2, a2= 1.2, b2= 0.0. In (i) ISWs suppress both spiral in M1and antispiral in M2, and dominate the whole system.
|
0806.3312
|
Zhoujian Cao Dr
|
Xiaohua Cui, Xiaoqing Huang, Zhoujian Cao, Hong Zhang, and Gang Hu
|
Novel interface-selected waves and their influences on wave competitions
| null | null |
10.1103/PhysRevE.78.026202
| null |
nlin.CD nlin.PS
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The topic of interface effects in wave propagation has attracted great
attention due to their theoretical significance and practical importance. In
this paper we study nonlinear oscillatory systems consisting of two media
separated by an interface, and find a novel phenomenon: interface can select a
type of waves (ISWs). Under certain well defined parameter condition, these
waves propagate in two different media with same frequency and same wave
number; the interface of two media is transparent to these waves. The frequency
and wave number of these interface-selected waves (ISWs) are predicted
explicitly. Varying parameters from this parameter set, the wave numbers of two
domains become different, and the difference increases from zero continuously
as the distance between the given parameters and this parameter set increases
from zero. It is found that ISWs can play crucial roles in practical problems
of wave competitions, e.g., ISWs can suppress spirals and antispirals.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 20 Jun 2008 03:30:34 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Cui",
"Xiaohua",
""
],
[
"Huang",
"Xiaoqing",
""
],
[
"Cao",
"Zhoujian",
""
],
[
"Zhang",
"Hong",
""
],
[
"Hu",
"Gang",
""
]
] |
2 FIG. 1: Schematic diagram for the light transmitting in a scattering 1. is the impulse response function with no scattering media, and hsca(x,x0) is the impulse from the plane x0to the plane xbecause of scattering, and a,bare the prob- ability amplitudes ofthe incident light and the respectively. From Eqs. (1)-(3), we have h(x,x0) probability distribution function in scattering me- dia is called point scattering function. The impulse re- sponse function hsca(x,x0) has close contact with the point scattering function which is Dirac delta function when there is no scattering media. However, in the scattering media, it is a spread function with a broad- ening length, and generally the point scattering func- tion has two forms: and Gaussian- shaped distribution [39, 40]. In multiple scattering Mie theory[30, 31, 32], both of probability amplitudes a,b are depending on the diameter size of the particle D, the wavelength of the incident light l, the concentration of suspended particles wand the effective length of scatter- ing media L. According to the experiments and theories [33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40], we have a=a(D,l,w,L )lba DaawcaLda, (5a) b=b(D,l,w,L )DabwcbLdb lbb, 2: Scheme for ghost imaging with thermal light in the scattering 1. point scattering probability ampli- tude. xLAis broadening length because of the interac- tions of multiple scattering, and it becomes wider with the increase of the scattering length. With the increase of the broadening length, the frequency spectrum of the optical transfer function becomes narrower, which is the main reason leading to the degradation of the quality of information transmission and images [37, 38]. We sup- pose point scattering function is Gaussian-shaped distri- bution without considering the absorption of All the coefficients in Eq. (5) should be deter- mined by specific experimental conditions. The schemefor ghostimagingwith thermal light in the scattering media is shown in Fig. 2. The light source S, first propagates through a beam splitter, then is divided into a test and a reference path. In the test path, the light propagates through a single lens of focal length f1, the scattering media and then to the detector Dt. In the reference path, the light propagates through a single lens of focal length fthen to an array of pixel detector Dr. By optical coherence theory [17, 28], we can obtain the correlation function of intensity fluctuations between G( xr,xt) is the first-order func- tion of two different points from the test and the light source is fully spatially =I0d(x1-x2). (7) whereI0is a constant, and d(x) is the Dirac delta the effective apertures of the lenses in the optical system are large enough, the impulse response function of the reference system the Lens (10) The impulse response function of the test system = Eqs. (7) and (9)-(11b) into Eq. (6b), we can get the intensity distribution in the test (12) describes the images in the scattering media for the direct illumination of the thermal light . (13)substituting Eqs. (7)-(11b) and (13) into Eq. (6), we can obtain the correlation function of intensity ghost imaging in the scattering media is (14a)-(14e). forC1andC2, which implies we can still get a image with high quality by ghost imaging in the scattering me- dia. From Eqs. (14a)-(14e), if the test detector is an array of pixel detector, and xt=-xr, after some the test detector is a bucket detector, (15) and (16) representghost imagingwhen the From Eqs. (15), if b1= 0(namely L1= 0) orb2= 0(namely L2= 0), it is clear to find that we can still obtain a image with high quality by ghost imaging in the scattering media. if b1ne}ationslash= 0 and b2ne}ationslash= 0 and as the increase of b1andb2, the qualities of ghost images will reduce, and the term including C4is the main reason leading to the degradation of the qualities of the images. ForL1= 0, there is only multiple scattering between the object plane and the test detector, then we have
|a1|= 1,b1= 0. By Eq. (12), the intensity distribu- tion in the test path last term in Eq. (17a) is the main reason leading to the decrease of the quality of the image when there is multiple scattering between the object plane and the detector. With the increase of b2(and the decrease of the probability amplitude a2), the quality of the image will be further degraded. Form Eq. (15), when the test detector is an array of pixel detector, after some calculation, the test detector is a bucket detector, By Eq. Eqs. (18)-(19c), we find that whether the test de- tector is an array of pixel detector or a bucket is multiple scattering between the object plane and the test detector. ForL2= 0, there is only multiple scattering between the source and the object plane, then we can gain |a2|=
1,b2= 0. By Eq. (12), the intensity distribution in the test path Eqs. (20a)-(20c), we find that the multiple scatter- ing between the source and the object plane has no effect on the quality of the image. From Eq. (15), when the test detector is an array of pixel detector, after some calculation, reveals that we can still obtain a image with object plane. If the test detector is a bucket detector, By Eq. the main factor leading to the decrease of the qualities of ghost images. f1> fis helpful to improve the quality of the image. The second-order degree of coherence g(2)(x1,x2) at the positions x1andx2can be defined as ghost imaging, The second-order degree of obtained only by the correlation measure- ment in the test path reveals the characteristic of the source, whereas g(2)(xr,xt) describes the correlation be- tween two paths. And the degradationof g(2)(xr,xt) will lead to the decay of intensity fluctuations, which has a great effect on the visibility of ghost images. Figs. 3-7 present numerical results of imaging a single slit in scattering media based on Eqs. (12) and (15)-(16) (in which we take l=650nm, f1=400mm, f=250mm, the single slit width a=0.2mm). From Fig. 3(a), as the in- creaseof when the object is illuminated directly by the ther- mal light. The quality of the image also degrade rapidly with the increase of the broadening length ^x2and the5
/s45/s52 /s45/s50 /s48 /s50 /s45/s50 /s48 /s50 of the probability amplitude a2when the ob- ject isfixed inthe positionof (c)), which accord with the results described by the Eqs 4 shows the numerical results when the position of the object in the scattering media is shifted. By Fig. 4(a), we can find that if the test detector is an array of pixel detector, multiple scattering has no effect on either between the object plane and the test detec- tor or between the object plane and the source. As the object is fixed closing to the middle of scattering media, the qualities of ghost images will decay. However, if the test detector is a bucket detector, the qualities of ghost images will decrease sharply with the degradation of L1, which is opposite absolutely to imaging when the object is illuminated directly by the thermal light (Fig. 3(a)). In Fig. 5, We give the comparison of the qualities of images between imaging by the direct illumination of the thermal light and ghost imaging when the object is fixed in the middle of scattering media. It is easy to find that we can only obtain the same image with low quality as imaging by the direct illumination of the ther- mal light when the test detector is a bucket detector by ghost imaging. But a image with high quality can still be/s45/s50 /s48 3: Factors which have the effect on the qualities of the images when the object is illuminated directly by the therma l light. (a). Images of a single slit at different positions in the scattering media; (b). Images of a single slit for differe nt probability amplitude a2whenL1=0mm, L2=100mm and the broadening length ^x2=5.0; and (c). Images of a single slit for different probability amplitude and the broadening length /s48 if the test detector is an array of pixel shown in Fig. 6 reveals that the qualities of ghost images will reduce obviously as the degradation of the probability amplitude a1anda2. And the object is still fixed in the middle of scattering media. In order to improve the qualities of ghost images fur- ther, we investigate a new method to the effect on the qualities of ghost images by using a circular aperture gating to change the transverse coherent length near the scattering media in Fig. 7, which is different from the method to change the transverse size of the source. But when the space interval sis greater than the character- istic scale of the object, the diffraction will /s45/s50 /s48 /s50 4: Relationship between the qualities of ghost images and the position of the object in scattering media. (a). the test detector is an array of pixel detector; and (b). the test detector is a bucket /s48 5: Comparison between imaging by the direct illumina- tion of the thermal light and ghost imaging when the broadening length ^x1=2.0,^x2=2.0 EXPERIMENT In the experiments, we prepare a suspension liquid which is composed by emulsion polymerization par- ticles with particle diameter D=3.26um and the the density r=1.19g/cm3. The vessel used to put the suspension liquid is designed as 40mm x40mmx20mm. The liquid can be con- sidered as strong multiple scattering media. And we take l=650nm, f1=400mm, f=250mm, z2=390mm, z3=243.8mm. The scale of the object ( 'zhong' ring) is 60 um and the diameter ofthe ring is 1.6mm. And the detectors in both paths are arrays of pixel shown in Fig. 8 (1) and (2) were the experi- mental results of the object ( 'zhong' ring) by direct illu-/s45/s49 /s48 6: Dependence of probability amplitude a2on the qual- ities of ghost images when L1=50mm, L2=50mm and the broadening length /s48 7: The effect of the space interval son the qualities of ghost images when a circular aperture gating with differ- ent space interval sis fixed on the plane x0. the broadening length ^x1=2.0,^x2=2.0 and ghost imaging when the object was fixed at different positions in the scattering media, Fig. 8, when the object is illuminated directly by the thermal light, the qualities of images will reduce as the increase of the length L2of scattering media. How- ever, when there is only strong multiple scattering be- tween the object plane and the source or between the object plane and the detector Dt, we can both obtain ghost images with high qualities. If the object is fixed in the middle of the scattering media, the visibility of ghost images will reduce, but the resolution doesn't degrade. All discussed above accord with the theoretical by the Eqs. (1). In Fig. 9, we demonstrated experimentally that the effect of the concentration of scattering media or the co-7 (1) (2) (a) (b) (c) FIG. 8: Images of the aperture ( 'zhong' ring) when the ob- ject is fixed in different position of the scattering media. (a ). L1=0mm, L2=40mm; (b). L1=20mm, L2=20mm; and (c). L1=40mm, L2=0mm. (1). when the object was by thermal light; (2). ghost (b) (c) FIG. 9: Effect of the concentration of scattering media and the coherent length located at the object plane on ghost imag - ing. (a). Lc=40.6um, 6 drops; (b). Lc=40.6um, 3 drops; 6 drops. (1). when the object was illumi- nated directly by thermal light; (2). ghost imaging. herent length located at the object plane on ghost imag- ing when the object is fixed in the middle of The visibility reducewith the increase of the concentration of scattering media. When the coherent length located at the object plane becomes long, the visibility of ghost images will improve. How- ever, the resolution will degrade. Carves shown in Figs. 10 and 11 are the effect of con- centration of emulsion polymerization particles on g(2) whenL1=40mm and L2=0mm and when L1=20mm and L2=20mm without the object, respectively. We can andg(2)(xr,xt) decay sharply with the increase of concentration of emulsion When there is two drops emulsion polymer- ization particles put into the solution NaCl, the coefficient will be lower than 1.10. When there are five drops emulsion /s49 /s50 /s51 /s52 /s53 /s54 /s55 /s45/s51/s48/s48 /s45/s50/s48/s48 /s45/s49/s48/s48 /s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s50/s48/s48 /s51/s48/s48 /s45/s51/s48/s48 /s45/s50/s48/s48 /s45/s49/s48/s48 /s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s50/s48/s48 /s51/s48/s48 /s45/s51/s48/s48 /s45/s50/s48/s48 /s45/s49/s48/s48 /s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s50/s48/s48 /s51/s48/s48
/s114/s44/s120 /s112 FIG. 10: The effect of concentration of emulsion polymeriza- tion particles on g(2)whenL1=40mm and L2=0mm without the put into the solution NaCl, the intensity distri- bution on the detector Dris heterogenous because there is no multiple scattering. However, we can find the ho- mogeneous intensity distribution on the detector Dt(in Fig. 12).8
/s48 /s49 /s50 /s51 /s52 /s53 /s54/s49/s46/s48/s49/s46/s50/s49/s46/s52/s49/s46/s54/s49/s46/s56/s50/s46/s48/s32/s103/s40/s50/s41
/s40/s120
/s114/s44/s120
/s116/s41/s84/s104/s101/s32/s115/s101/s99/s111/s110/s100/s45/s111/s114/s100/s101/s114/s32/s100/s101/s103/s114/s101/s101/s32/s111/s102/s32/s99/s111/s104/s101/s114/s101/s110/s99/s101/s32/s103/s40/s50/s41
/s67/s111/s110/s99/s101/s110/s116/s114/s97/s116/s105/s111/s110/s32/s111/s102/s32/s112/s111/s108/s121/s109/s101/s114/s105/s122/s97/s116/s105/s111/s110/s32/s112/s97/s114/s116/s105/s99/s108/s101/s115/s32/s40/s100/s114/s111/s112/s115/s41
/s45/s52/s48/s48 /s45/s51/s48/s48 /s45/s50/s48/s48 /s45/s49/s48/s48 /s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s50/s48/s48 /s51/s48/s48 /s45/s51/s48/s48 /s45/s50/s48/s48 /s45/s49/s48/s48 /s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s50/s48/s48 /s51/s48/s48 /s45/s51/s48/s48 /s45/s50/s48/s48 /s45/s49/s48/s48 /s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s50/s48/s48 /s51/s48/s48
/s114/s44/s120 /s112 FIG. 11: The effect of concentration of emulsion polymeriza- tion particles on g(2)whenL1=20mm and L2=20mm without the object. IV. DISCUSSION AND INCLUSION When the object is illuminated directly by thermal light, multiple scattering between the object plane and the detector Dtis the main reason leading to the degra- dation of the qualities of images (Fig. 3). In different from images obtained by the of light field, ghost imaging causes the sep- aration of detection and imaging. Even if the informa- tion from the object is distorted by multiple is no effect on ghost imaging. Because destroys the correlation of the light field, the (a) (b) FIG.12: Images fromasingle frame n L1=20mm and L2=20mm without the object and there are five drops emulsion polymerization particles put into the so - lutionNaCl, (a). from the CCD camera Dt, (b). from the CCD camera Dr. visibility of ghost images is degraded but the degrade. However, the visibility of ghost images can be enhanced by means of the decrease of the reso- lution [41, 42, 43, 44]. The experimental result in Fig. 9 (c) also demonstrated that. Transmission information of the light on the object plane (namely a1) has a great effect on the visibility of ghost images. Because leads to the decay of the correlation between the test and reference pathes with the decrease of Trans- mission information of the light (Figs 8 and 9). The higher the Transmission information is, the better visi- bility the ghost image has. When there is no between the object plane and the source, then ballistic component of the light on the object plane is equal to 1, so we can always obtain a ghost image with high quality whether there is multiple scattering Dt. Otherwise, because the ballistic component of the light is impossible to be 0, we can always see the shapes of the object (Figs. 3(b) and 6). The degradation of the qualities of the images is provoked by the decay of visibility in scattering me- dia, which is different absolutely from the low by When the object is fixed in the middle of the scattering media, as shown in Fig. 11, even if the second-order degree of coherence g(2)is very low, we can obtain a ghost image with much better quality than the image gained when the object is illumi- nated directly by thermal light. By the ghost imaging, the qualities of ghost images does not depend on the intensity of the light but on the inten- sity fluctuations. As the multiple scattering increased, the intensity fluctuations will reduce (Figs 10 and 11), which leads to the degradation of the visibility of the image. The expression in the Eq. (15) can explain ba- sically the experimental results and the fact discussed above, which shows that the results described by the Eq. (15) are reasonable for the description of ghost imaging in scattering media. However, when the test detector is9 a bucket detector, the qualities of ghost images depend on the multiple scattering between the object plane and the source, which is opposite to imaging by the of the thermal light (Fig. 3(a)). By the re- sults in Fig. 8 (a) and (c), maybe we can also obtain a ghost image with high visibility by means of eliminat- ing the multiple scattering between the object plane and the source or between the object plane and the detector Dt. One is like the technique of DOT. Firstly we obtain a improved image by iterative recovery method of DOT from a single frame of image collected by the detector Dt, then we will get a ghost image with improved visibil- ity by the correlation measurement of intensity fluctua- tions between the detector Drand the improved images. The other is that we get the intensity distribution on the object plane by the measurement to transmission and re- flection coefficients, then do the the intensity fluctuations between the detector Dtand intensity distribution obtained by numerical simulation. The method discussed in Fig. 7 can improve the visibil- ity of ghost images to some extent. Generally speaking, by ghost imaging method, we can always obtain a im- age with much better quality on the base of the image obtained by a novel conventional imaging technique with thermal light. For entangled source, because of the en- tanglement characteristic of the two photons, maybe we can also improve the visibility of ghost images. Based on the effect of photon bunching, and the new source with highg(2)can be obtained, the visibility of ghost images may also be enhanced obviously. In medical science, in order to avoid ionizing radiation of X-ray, optical photons provides nonionizing and safe radiation for medical applications. Recently there has been increasing interest in the field of the imaging, test and diagnosis of the biological tissues with the infraredand the near infrared light [6, 11, 15]. Because the near infrared light around 700-nm wavelength can centimeters into biological tissue [15]. But sev- eral factors still limit the imaging quality. Because and hence are referred to as scattering media or turbid media. The images suffer reduced resolution and contrast due to multiple scattering, which leads to a low efficiency and accuracy of diagnosis and a difficulty of analysis in medical science. So the diffusion-like in biologicaltissue presentsa key imaging. The ghost imaging discussed here may solve the problems about the low quality of the imaging in biological tissues. In conclusion, for the first time, detection and imaging of the object information are separated by ghost imag- ing, which provides a new way for imaging in we have demonstrated experimentally and the- oretically for the first time that the images with high qualities in a scattering media can still be obtained for ghost imaging when the test detector is an array of pixel detector and there is only multiple scattering between the object plane and the source or between the object plane and the detector. When the object is fixed in the middle of scattering media, we can also gain ghost im- ageswith much better qualities than the the object is illuminated directly by the thermal light. The probability amplitudes of the incident a great effect on the visibility of ghost images. These results will be very useful for the imaging and diagnosis in medical science. The work was partly supported by the Hi-Tech Re- search and Development Program of China, Project and Shanghai Fundamental Project No. 06JC14069. [1] G. W. Kamerman, Proc. SPIE, 4377, 126-131 (2001). [2] H. G. Booker, and D. C. Miller, Joural of Atmospheric and Terrestrial Physics, 42, 3 (1980). [3] T. S. Mckechnie, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 8,2 (1991). [4] Raine D. A. , and Brenizer J. S. Materials evalution, 55, 1174 (1997). [5] K. P. Maher, J. F . Malone, and Brain Chance, Contem- porary Physics, 38, 131 (1997). [6] Lihong V. Wang and Hsin-i Wu, Biomedical optics: prin- ciple and imaging, (2007). [7] A. P. Gibson, J. C. Hebden and S. R. Arridge, Phys. Med. Biol. 50R1-R43 (2005). [8] A. Yodh, and B. Chance, Phys. Today, 48, 34 (1995). [9] S. R. Arridge, M. Cope, and D. T. Deply, Phys. Med. Biol.37, 1531 (1992). [10] S. R. Arridge, Topical Review, R41-93 (1999). [11] Sachin V. patwardhan, and Joseph P. Culver, J. 011009 (2008). [12] J. C. Hebden, S. R. Arridge, M. Cope, and D. T. Deply, Phys. Med. Biol. 42, 825 (1997). [13] B. Chance and R. R. Alfano, Proc. SPIE, 2389 (1995).[14] M. Laubscher, M. Ducros, B. Karamata, Opt. Exp. 10, 9 (2002) [15] Brian C. Wilson, Eva M. Sevick, Michael S. Patterson, and Britton Chance, Proceedings of the IEEE. 80, 6 (1992). [16] T. B. Pittman, Y. H. Shih, D. V. Strekalov, and A. V. Sergienko, Phys. Rev. A. 52. R3429 (1995). [17] J. Cheng and S. Han, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92. 093903 (2004). [18] A. Gatti, E. Brambilla, M. Bache, and L. A. Lugiato, Phys. Rev. A. 70. 013802 (2004). [19] A. Gatti, E. Brambilla, M. Bache, and L. A. Lugiato, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93. 093602 (2004). [20] A. Valencia, G. Scarcelli, M. D'Angelo, and Y. Shih, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94. 063601 (2005). [21] R. S. Bennink, S. J. Bentley, and R. W. Boyd, Phys. Rev. Lett.89. 113601 (2002). [22] L. Basano and P. Ottonello, Appl. Phys.Lett. 89, Minghui Zhang, Qing Wei, and Shensheng Han, Phys. Lett. A. 366, 569-574 (2007). [24] G. Scarcelli, V. Berardi and Y. Shih, Phys. Rev. Lett.10 96, 063602 (2006). [25] A. Gatti, M. Bondani, L. A.Lugiato, M. G. A. Pairs, and C. Fabre, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 039301 (2007). [26] G. Scarcelli, V. Berardi and Y. Shih, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 039302 (2007). [27] Pengli Zhang, Wenlin Gong, Xia Shen, and Shensheng Han, arXiv. (2008). [28] R. J. Glauber, Phys. Rev. 130, 2529 (1963). [29] J. W. Goodman, Introduction to Fourier optics (1976). [30] G. Mie, Ann. Phys. 330, 377 (1908). [31] D. Toublanc, Appl. Opt. 35, 3270 (1996). [32] S. K. Sharma, and A. K. Roy, J. Quant. Spectrosc. Ra- diat. Transfer. 64, 327 (2000). [33] Jessica C. Ramella-Roman, Scott A. Prahl, and Steven L. Jacques, Opt. Exp. 13, 25 (2005). [34] Milun J. Rakovic and George W. kattawar, Appl. opt. 37, 15 (1999).[35] A. A. M. Mustafa and Daphne F. Jackson, Phys. Med. Biol.26, 461 (1981). [36] J. S. Faulkner and Eva A. Horvath, Phys. Rev. B. 44, 8467 (1991). [37] W. H. Wells, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 59, 6 (1969). [38] H. T. Yura, Appl. opt. 10, 1 (1971). [39] Rene Hassanein, Eberhard Lehmann, and Peter Vonto- bel, Nucl. Ins. Meth. Phys. Res. A. 542, 353 (2005). [40] P. N. Segre and P. N. Pusey, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 4 (1996). [41] Shen Xia, Bai Yan-Feng, and Han Shen-Sheng, Chin. Phys. Lett. 25, 11 (2007). [42] Y. Cai and S. Zhu, Opt. Lett. 29, 2716 (2004). [43] Y. Cai and S. Zhu, Opt. Lett. 30, 388 (2005). [44] A. Gatti, M. Bache, E. Brambilla, and L. A. Lugiato, J. Mod. Opt. 53, 739 (2006).
|
0806.3543
|
Peng-Li Zhang
|
Wenlin Gong, Pengli Zhang, Xia Shen, and Shensheng Han
|
Ghost imaging in scattering media
|
10 pages, 17 figures
| null | null | null |
physics.optics physics.med-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Ghost imaging with thermal light in scattering media is investigated. We
demonstrated both theoretically and experimentally for the first time that the
image with high quality can still be obtained in the scattering media by ghost
imaging. The scattering effect on the qualities of the images obtained when the
object is illuminated directly by the thermal light and ghost imaging is
analyzed theoretically. Its potential applications are also discussed.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 22 Jun 2008 04:02:35 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Sun, 14 Dec 2008 14:28:42 GMT"
}
] | 2008-12-14T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Gong",
"Wenlin",
""
],
[
"Zhang",
"Pengli",
""
],
[
"Shen",
"Xia",
""
],
[
"Han",
"Shensheng",
""
]
] |
The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 2 Oglavlenie Vvedenie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Glava I Strukturnye uravneniia Kartana SS1.1 Poniatie mnogoobraziia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 SS1.2 Vektory i 1-formy na mnogoobraziiakh . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 SS1.3 Tenzory i vneshnie formy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 SS1.4 Metricheskii tenzor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 SS1.5 Sviaznost' i kovariantnaia proizvodnaia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 SS1.6 Formy so znacheniiami v vektornykh prostranstvakh . . . . . . . . . . 21 SS1.7 Vneshnee . Obobshchennyi vneshnii differentsial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 SS1.8 Poniatie krivizny mnogoobraziia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 SS1.9 Pervoe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana . 2-forma krucheniia . . . 26 SS1.10 Vtoroe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana . 2-forma krivizny . . 29 SS1.11 Tozhdestvo Bianki dlia krucheniia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 Glava II Sviaznost' i krivizna mnogoobrazii s volnovoi metrikoi SS2.1 Uravnenie Einshteina i volnovaia metrika . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 SS2.2 1- forma sviaznosti i koeffitsienty sviaznosti dlia volnovoi metriki . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 SS2.3 2-forma krivizny , tenzor Rimana i tenzor Richchi dlia volnovoi metriki na mnogoobraziiakh bez krucheniia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 Zakliuchenie . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45 Literatura . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47 Prilozhenie 1. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 Prilozhenie 2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 50 Prilozhenie 3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 Prilozhenie 4. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 3 Vvedenie Geometriia kak nauka , voznikla bolee chem dve tysiachi let nazad i obiaza - na svoim takim pervichnym fenomenam mira , kak prostran - stvo i vremia . Segodnia geometriia - eto prezhde vsego geo- metriia , kotoraia predstavliaet soboi odin iz samykh vazhnykh razdelov sovre - mennoi matematiki . Pervonachal'no sozdannaia na osnovanii koordinatnogo metoda R.Dekarta i P.Ferma s uchetom idei N.I. Lobachevskogo , geometriia nachala burno razvivat'sia blagodaria vkladu B.Rimana , kotoryi sdelal printsipial'no novyi shag - stal izuchat' proizvol'nye , tak nazyvae - mye rimanovy prostranstva , srazu zhe nashedshie vazhnye prilozheniia v me- khanike i v teorii otnositel'nosti Einshteina , kotoraia v to vremia byla ot- niud' ne bessporna . Voznikli novye razdely geometrii - vektornoe i ten- zornoe ischislenie , rimanova geometriia , zakladyvaiutsia osnovy topologii , kak chasti geometrii , posviashchennoi svoistvu nepreryvnosti . Bol'shuiu rol' v sozdanii topologii i ee primenenii sygrali L. Eiler , K. Zhordan , M. Fre- ne, F. Khausdorf , A. Lebeg , L. Bauer , A. Puankare . Soedinenie idei neli - neinykh koordinat , vektornogo i tenzornogo ischisleniia , teorii poverkhno - stei, a takzhe plodotvornost' geometricheskikh predstavlenii v razlichnykh zadachakh estestvoznaniia priveli k vazhneishemu v geometrii poniatiiu - mno- goobraziiu . Predmetom geometrii iavliaetsia izuchenie geometri - cheskikh zadach , dopuskaiushchikh ispol'zovanie analiza . Poetomu ob'ektami izu- cheniia iavliaiutsia prostranstva , v kotorykh imeiut smysl takie poniatiia kak i integrirovanie . Takoi klass prostranstv obrazuiut mnogoobraziia . Vazhneishim analiticheskim metodom izu- cheniia etikh prostranstv iavliaetsia issledovanie ikh beskonechno malykh uchast - kov. Osnovnoe preimushchestvo perekhoda k beskonechno malym ob'ektam zakliu - chaetsia v tom, chto pri etom vse oni stanoviatsia lineinymi . Kazhdaia krivaia v beskonechno malom est' priamaia liniia , v tom smysle , chto ee mozhno zamenit' kasatel'noi . Odnim iz samykh poleznykh i plodotvornykh analiticheskikh me-The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 4 todov v geometrii iavliaetsia ischislenie differentsial' - nykh funktsii , sozdannyi v nachale XX veka E. Kartanom . Dopolnitel'nymi strukturami na mnogoobrazii iavliaiutsia sviaznost' i metrika , kotorye pozvoliaiut opredelit' pravilo parallel'nogo perenosa i poniatie rasstoianiia , imeiushchie ogromnoe prikladnoe znachenie v fizike , v cha- stnosti , v fizike elementarnykh chastits . Sovremennaia obshchaia teoriia otnositel'nosti , v chastnosti - teoriia gra- vitatsii Einshteina , osnovana na geometrizatsii fizicheskikh zakonov . V ka- chestve ob'ekta , na kotorom stroitsia geometricheskaia interpretatsiia teorii , mnogoobrazie prostranstva -vremeni - chetyrekhmernoe psev - dorimanovo mnogoobrazie s lorentsevoi metrikoi . V obshchei teorii otnositel'nosti gravitatsionnoe pole otozhdestvliaet - sia s geometricheskoi strukturoi prostranstvenno -vremennogo kontinuuma na osnove predstavleniia rimanovoi geometrii . Izvestno , chto vse material'nye tela procherchivaiut v prostranstve -vremeni odinakovye traektorii , esli na nikh deistvuiut lish' gravitatsionnye sily . Na osnovanii etogo fakta byla vydvinuta ideia o tom, gravitatsionnoe pole iavliaetsia neot'emlemym svoist - vom prostranstva . Sovremennye fiziki -reliativisty traktuiut gravitatsi - onnoe pole , kak geometricheskuiu strukturu prostranstva -vremeni - kriviz - nu. Odnoi iz osnovnykh zadach sovremennoi teorii gravitatsii iavliaetsia pro- blema gravitatsionnykh voln . Gravitatsionnaia volna - eto vozmushchenie gravi - tatsionnogo polia , to est' krivizny prostranstva -vremeni , rasprostraniaiu - shcheesia s konechnoi skorost'iu i nesushchee s soboi energiiu . V sviazi s vyshe skazannym , pervaia glava dannoi raboty posviashchena ras- smotreniiu osnovnykh ob'ektov i operatsii vneshnego is- chisleniia Kartana , obobshchennogo na sluchai proizvol'nogo differentsirue - mogo mnogoobraziia . Dlia etogo neobkhodimo izlozhit' osnovy teorii diffe - rentsiruemykh mnogoobrazii . Krivye i funktsii na mnogoobrazii vvodiatsia na iazyke koordinatnykh otobrazhenii , vektory traktuiutsia kak operatory vdol' krivykh . Takzhe opredeliaiutsia 1-formy , tenzory i V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 5 r-formy , vneshnee proizvedenie form , vvodiatsia osnovnye geometricheskie struktury na mnogoobrazii : metrika , sviaznost' , krivizna i kruchenie sviaz- nosti . Zdes' zhe izlagaetsia na iazyke vneshnikh form osnovnye geometricheskie uravneniia na mnogoobrazii (v kotorom zakliucheny vse geometricheskie svoi - stva poslednego ) - strukturnye uravneniia Kartana dlia krivizny . Vtoraia glava raboty posviashchena izucheniiu problemy gravitatsionnykh voln . Izvestno , chto gravitatsionnye volny vdali ot izluchaiushchikh istochnikov vedut sebia kak ploskie elektromagnitnye volny , poetomu budem rassmatri - vat' ploskie volny s zadannoi metrikoi . Rabotaia nad sozdaniem obshchei teorii otnositel'nosti , Einshteinu udalos' ustanovit' sviaz' mezhdu gravitatsiei i rimanovym prostranstvom - vremenem . A znachit , poiavilas' vozmozhnost' otozhdestvit' geometricheskie struktury s elementami gravitatsionnogo polia , chto i sdelal Einshtein , po- luchiv sleduiushchee uravnenie : GuauA u e shguA au kh T u , poluchivshee nazvanie uravneniia Einshteina . V dannoi rabote budem rassmatrivat' tak nazyvaemoe pustoe pro- stranstvo (eto prostranstvo , gde krome gravitatsionnogo net drugikh tel i polei ). V takom prostranstve uravnenie Einshteina zametno uproshchaetsia i priobretaet vid Auau0 . Nasha zadacha budet sostoiat' v nakhozhdenii usloviia , pri kotorom vol- novaia metrika rimanova prostranstva iavliaetsia resheniem uravneniia Ein- shteina v pustote . Dlia etoi tseli budut vychisleny 1-formy sviaznosti , 2- formy krivizny i tenzor Richchi , priravnivaia kotoryi k nuliu budet naide - no iskomoe uslovie . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 6 Glava I Strukturnye uravneniia Kartana SS1.1 Poniatie mnogoobraziia Oboznachim cherez A sovokupnost' vsekh naborov iz + veshchestvennykh chi- sel shi,sh,...,shaa. Govoriat , chto nekotoroe mnozhestvo nadeleno topologicheskoi struktu - roi, esli kazhdomu ego elementu , nazyvaemomu tochkoi , sootvetstvuet semei - stvo mnozhestv , nazyvaemykh okrestnostiami etogo elementa , i udovletvoriaiu - shchikh sleduiushchei sisteme aksiom : 1. A soderzhitsia v kazhdoi svoei okrestnosti , eA shishaa eshishaa . 2. Dlia vsiakoi tochki eA shishaa sushchestvuet eshishaae shishaa. 3. Esli zadany okrestnosti eshishaa i eshshishaa to sushchestvuet essshishaaaue shishaaet shshishaa. 4. (aksioma otdel'nosti ili aksioma Khausdorfa ) Esli tochka ne sovpadaet s tochkoi ,to sushchestvuiut okrestnosti eshishaa i eshishaa: . Mnozhestvo ,nadelennoe topologicheskoi strukturoi , nazyvaetsia prostranstvom . Mnogoobrazie - eto topologicheskoe prostranstvo , kazhdaia tochka koto - rogo obladaet okrestnost'iu e ,gomeomorfnoi oblasti v A. Postavim v sootvetstvie kazhdoi tochke Aa nabor chisel to est' vvodim koordinaty dlia tochki . a :' ! sheeiishe, au 1,2, ... , + Otobrazhenie ' nazyvaetsia koordinatnym , ' -nepreryvno i vzaimno - odnoznachno . Rassmotrim dve okrestnosti tochki Aa( sm. Ris.1) V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 7 Ris1. Okrestnosti e i e iz peresekaiutsia . koordinat - nye otobrazheniia 'i g v A daiut v zone peresecheniia dva razlichnykh otobra - zheniia (a, sledovatel'no , dve sistemy koordinat ). Sootvetstvie mezhdu etimi koordinatami kharakterizuet klass gladkosti mnogoobraziia . a:' ! ' au 1,2, ... , + a: ! shiashaaau u, au 1,2, ... , + ' - koordinatnoe otobrazhenie , sledovatel'no , sushchestvuet 'i. Rassmotrim 'li:A!A, znachit , imeem , (1.1.1a) to est' uauushiiishaa. (1.1.1 v) Preobrazovaniia (1.1.1) nazyvaiutsia funktsiiami perekhoda . Esli eti funktsii @ raz differentsiruemy , to oni nazyvaiutsia funktsiiami klassa `. Esli @au1 ,to est' sushchestvuiut pervye proizvodnye , to funktsii perekhoda (1.1.1) nepreryvny . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 8 Opredelenie . Para shi',e shaa nazyvaetsia kartoi , gde e - okrestnost' , ' - koordinatnoe otobrazhenie . Esli funktsii perekhoda mezhdu kartami mnogoobraziia iavliaiutsia funktsiia - mi klassa `, to takie karty nazyvaiutsia `-soglasovannymi . Opredelenie . Ob'edinenie vsekh kart mnogoobraziia nazyvaetsia atlasom . Topologicheskoe prostranstvo s ego `-soglasovannymi atlasami nazyvaetsia mnogoobraziem mnogoobraziem pri @1 ). Krivye na mnogoobraziiakh . Krivaia - eto otobrazhenie otkrytogo podmnozhest - va iz T` v ( sm. ris. 2). Takim obrazom , kazhdoi tochke iz veshchestvennym chislom , kotoroe my oboznachim cherez )otvechaet tochka iz , nazyvaemaia tochkoi -obrazom . Veshchestvennoe chislo l nazyvaetsia paramet - rom krivoi . Sovokupnost' tochek -obrazov i est' krivaia . Esli dve krivye imeiut sovpavshie obrazy , a odinakovye tochki otvechaiut razlichnym znacheni - iam parametrov , to eti krivye iavliaiutsia razlichnymi . Ris.2. ( Krivaia v - eto otobrazhenie iz T` v .Tochka l iz T` perekhodit v tochku a iz . ) Funktsiia na mnogoobraziiakh . V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 9 Funktsiia na - eto pravilo , kazhdoi tochke iz chislo , kotoroe nazyvaetsia znacheniem funktsii . Esli nekotoraia oblast' v otobrazhaetsia pri pomoshchi gladkogo koordinatnogo otobrazheniia na oblast' v T`, to funktsiia na perekhodit v funktsiiu na T` (sm. ris. 3). I esli funktsiia na T` iavliaetsia , to ona differentsiruema na [3]. Ris.4. (Funktsiia ' na est' otobrazhenie iz v T`. Koordinatnoe oto- brazhenie iz oblasti e mnogoobraziia ,soderzhashchei a ,na oblast' shieshaa v T` obratimo . Sostavnoe otobrazhenie l'i perevodit T` v T`, t.e. iavliaet - sia funktsiei na T`. Eto prosto vyrazhenie 'shiashaa cherez koordinaty tochki a .) SS1.2 Vektory i 1-formy na mnogoobraziiakh Opredelim poniatie vektora na mnogoobrazii . Dlia etogo rassmotrim krivuiu , kotoraia zadaetsia uravneniem vida iiauiishishaa, au1 , ... , + i diffe - rentsiruemuiu funktsiiu 'shi,sh,...,shaa v okrestnosti nekotoroi tochki Aa . V kazhdoi tochke krivoi opredeleno znachenie ' .Pri etom na krivoi voznikaet novaia funktsiia shi )i shishaaau' 5 shi iishishaashaa. Differentsiruia ee poluchaem : The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 10 (1.2.1) Eto ravenstvo spravedlivo dlia liuboi funktsii ,znachit mozhno zapisat' (1.2.2) Nabor chisel qee+5
+oqe v evklidovom prostranstve iavliaetsia komponentami nekotorogo kasatel'nogo vektora k krivoi iishishaa. Eto sleduet iz togo, chto sheeiishe - beskonechno maloe peremeshchenie vdol' krivoi i delenie ego na meniaet lish' dlinu , a ne napravlenie etogo peremeshcheniia . Poskol'ku krivaia beretsia s opredelennym parametrom , dlia kazhdoi krivoi odnoznachno oprede - len nabor qee+5
+oqe. Znachit , kazhdaia krivaia imeet edinstvennyi kasatel'nyi vektor . Poetomu v tochke a sushchestvuet kasatel'nyi vektor k etoi krivoi , a tak kak v tochke a mozhno provesti beskonechnoe mnozhestvo krivykh zadannogo tipa , to vozmozhno i beskonechnoe mnozhestvo kasatel'nykh vektorov k etim krivym . Mnozhestvo kasatel'nykh vektorov obrazuet prostranstvo e, koto - roe nazyvaetsia kasatel'nym prostranstvom kovariantnykh vektorov k v tochke a . Iz vysheskazannogo sleduet , chto v teorii mnogo - obrazii kasatel'nyi vektor v tochke Aa iavliaetsia lineinym differentsi - al'nym operatorom , deistvuiushchim na mnozhestvo gladkikh funktsii ' ,zadan - nykh na v okrestnosti tochki a .Operatsii vdol' koor - dinatnykh linii imeiut vid chastnykh proizvodnykh dd dd5. Sistema qeedd dd5qe obrazu - et koordinatnyi bazis vektornogo prostranstva . Prostranstvo vsekh kasa- tel'nykh vektorov e v tochke Aa i prostranstvo vsekh funktsii vdol' krivykh , prokhodiashchikh cherez tochku a ,nakhodiatsia vo vzaimno - odnoznachnom sootvetstvii . Kasatel'nye vektory v tochke a mozhno vyrazit' ne tol'ko cherez koordinatnyi bazis , no i cherez proizvol'nyi bazis shee`p'iishe vtau viidd dd5 ii v tauvii`p'ii (1.2.3) V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 11 Pravilo , zadaiushchee vektor v kazhdoi tochke mnogoobraziia , nazyvaetsia vektornym polem . Poetomu v tochke a kasatel'nye vektora obrazuiut vek- tornoe pole . Teper' rassmotrim 1-formu na mnogoobrazii .1-forma - eto linei - naia funktsiia na vektorakh . Eto oznachaet , chto 1-forma v tochke a nekotoroe veshchestvennoe chislo , oboznachaemoe cherez shivtshaa. (Volna nad bukvoi oboznachaet 1-formu ). V kazhdoi tochke a mnogoobraziia mozhno po- stroit' lineinoe prostranstvo , otlichnoe ot prostranstva 1-form . Sovokup - nost' vsekh 1-form v tochke a obrazuet lineinoe vektornoe prostranstvo - kokasatel'noe (dual'noe , dvoistvennoe , sopriazhennoe ) v tochke Aa , ko- toroe oboznachaetsia eKH .Analogichno vektoram 1-formy obrazuiut bazis . Ras- smotrim nekotoruiu 1-formu , deistvuiushchuiu na vektor vt: Znacheniia 1-form opredeliaiutsia na vektorakh aus otho Znachit , deistvitel'no iavliaetsia bazisom . I etot bazis budet dvoistve - nen bazisu prostranstva e. SS1.3 Tenzory i vneshnie formy Rassmotrim tochku a na .Tenzor tipa 5ee eeNs9 v tochke opredeliaetsia kak lineinaia funktsiia , argumentami kotoroi sluzhat a 1-form i a vektorov , a znacheniiami - veshchestvennye chisla . Eto obobshchennoe opredelenie 1-form . Komponentami tenzora iavliaiutsia ego znacheniia na bazisnykh vektorakh i 1- formakh . Kak i v sluchae vektorov i 1-form , tenzornoe pole tipa 5ee eeNs9 - eto pravilo , kazhdoi tochke tenzor tipa 5ee eeNs9 v etoi tochke . Svoi - stvo lineinosti tenzorov i na tenzornye polia . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 12 Rassmotrim tenzor e tipa 5 9. Etot tenzor predpolagaet nalichie dvukh argumentov . Znachit eshi,vshaa est' veshchestvennoe chislo , pri fiksirovannom my poluchim 1-formu eshi,_ _ shaa, poskol'ku siuda nuzhno podstavit' vektor , dlia togo chtoby poluchit' veshchestvennoe chislo ; eshi~,vtshaa est' vektor . Takim obra - zom, tenzor tipa 5 9 mozhno rassmatrivat' kak lineinuiu funktsiiu na vekto - rakh so znacheniiami v vektorakh , a takzhe kak lineinuiu funktsiiu na 1-formakh , znachenie takzhe v 1-formakh . Eto pravilo na liubye tenzory . Kazhdomu tenzoru mozhno sopostavit' matritsu ego komponent . 1. Slozhenie i vychitanie komponent tenzora po pra- vilu slozheniia i vychitaniia matrits . 2. Umnozhenie tenzora na skaliar - umnozhenie matritsy na skaliar . 3. Rassmotrim velichiny v, kotorye iavliaiutsia komponentami ten- zora tipa 5 9. Summiruia komponenty s uchetom togo, chto XauQ polu - chim, chto v - chislo , ne zavisiashchee ot bazisa , a imenno znachenie na v, kotoroe mozhno schitat' tenzorom tipa 5 9. Eta operatsiia nazy - vaetsia svertkoi . Znachit , sverka - eto otobrazhenie priamogo proiz - vedeniia kasatel'nogo i kokasatel'nogo prostranstva v T`: eaieKHuueT` . 4. Simmetrizatsiia tenzora . Simmetrizatsiia v komponentnom vide oznachaet sleduiushchee : eshioo,au,...,o e au,oo,...,o K9
+ - eto kolichestvo indeksov , v simmetrizatsii . Eta formu - la zapisana dlia nizhnikh indeksov , analogichno ona vygliadit i dlia verkh - nikh. Tenzor nazyvaetsia simmetrichnym , esli pri perestanovke liubykh dvukh indeksov on ne meniaet znak. V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 13 5. Al'ternirovanie Operatsiia al'ternirovaniia vypolniaetsia po sleduiushchei formule : ee au,oo,...,o K9
+ - eto kolichestvo indeksov , v al'ternirovanii . Pri al'ter - nirovanii poluchaem tenzor , kotoryi pri liuboi chetnoi perestanovke ne- skol'kikh indeksov on ne meniaet znak, a pri liuboi nechetnoi perestanovke meniaet ego na protivopolozhnyi . Takoi tenzor nazyvaetsia kososimmetrich - nym . Tenzor nazyvaetsia , esli pri perestanovke liubykh dvukh indeksov on meniaet znak. P-formoi shi2 shaa (ili formoi stepeni p) nazyvaetsia tenzor tipa qa qu. Mnozhe - stvo vsekh p-form obrazuet vektornoe prostranstvo otnositel'no operatsii slozheniia i umnozheniia na chislo : razmernost' etogo prostranstva `. Teper' , pust' tenzor eR - tenzor tipa 5e ee9, a SR - tenzor tipa 5eNs eeNs9. Tenzor eRS'R - tenzor tipa Operatsiia nazyvaetsia tenzornym proizvede - niem . eRS'Rshi,..., ,,..., ,vt,...,v t,ut,...,u ,vt,...,v ,ut,...,u tshaa Vneshnim (kosym ) proizvedeniem nazyvaetsia tenzor - noe proizvedenie form . Pust' i - 1-formy , togda ikh vneshnim proizvedeniem budet iavliat'sia 2-forma [2]: thau' e'au2 ! @s 5 ' 9 The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 14 Rassmotrim proizvol'nyi bazis vektornogo prostranstva shee`p'iishe au 1, . . , + , ii - dvoistvennyi emu bazis 1-form i naidem znachenie 2-fomy na vektorakh t i vt: ooauau Takim obrazom , poluchili razlozhenie 2-formy po bazisu vektornogo prostranstva vsekh 2-form oothau: gde (1.3.1) Prichem , chislo nezavisimykh bazisnykh 2-form (razmernost' vektornogo prostranstva 2-form ) ravno chislu nenulevykh komponent ooau, t.e. `sh. Sledovatel'no , proizvol'naia p-forma raskladyvaetsia po bazisu sleduiu - shchim obrazom : au !ooau...uu oothauth...th uu. (1.3.2) Naidem kompaktnoe predstavlenie (p+q)-formy , poluchennoi primeneni - em operatsii vneshnego proizvedeniia k proizvol'noi p-forme i proizvol' - noi q-forme s uchetom formuly (1.3.2). Pust' u au Togda thau1 shi iith...th uthooth...th au S drugoi storony auau au 1 !! iith...th uthoo...th au V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 15 Priravnivaia dva poslednikh ravenstva poluchim : aushi shaa! !! shoii...u oo...aushwa au`aashoii...u oo...aushwa Sledovatel'no oo...aushwa iith...th uthooth...th au (1.3.3) Operatsiia vneshnego proizvedeniia obladaet sleduiushchimi svoistvami : 1) : thaushi e 1 shaath, 2) distributivnost' : shi shshshaathau th shsh, ,shAT`, 3) assotsiativnost' : 5th9thau thshi thshaa, 4) thau e au0 , gde - p-forma , - q-forma , - proizvol'naia r-forma . SS1.4 Metricheskii tenzor Rassmotrim odnu iz operatsii vektornoi algebry , kotoraia nazyvaetsia skaliarnym proizvedeniem vektorov . Dlia etogo voz'mem dva proizvol'nykh vektora ut,vteA shishaa i sopostavim im chislo po sleduiushchemu pravilu : u: ut,vt!u tdyvtAT` (1.4.1) Iz svoistv skaliarnogo proizvedeniia sleduet simmetrichnost' i bili - neinost' u: auv tdyutau ushivt, utshaa, ushiut,vtshaaau u tdy v tau shiutdyvtshaaau ushiut,vtshaa. (1.4.1) vedet sebia kak abstraktnyi tenzor tipa qa0 2qu, simmetrichnyi po svoim elementam , on nazyvaetsia metricheskim tenzorom . Takzhe mozhno ska-The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 16 zat', chto metricheskii tenzor - eto bilineinaia , simmetrichnaia , veshchestven - noznachnaia forma na vektorakh [10]. Komponentami metricheskogo tenzora nazyvaiutsia ego znacheniia na bazisnykh vektorakh , oni predstavliaiut soboi simmetricheskuiu matritsu tipa + ai + . Esli zhe matritsa edinichnaia , to metricheskii tenzor nazyvaetsia evk- lidovoi metrikoi . ooauau8 sh ... sh shsh ... sh ngngng sh ... p'oo`dyp'au . (1.4.2) Polozhim `h ooauh0 , togda sushchestvuet obratnaia matritsa metriche - skogo tenzora , prichem : ooauoauau ooo (1.4.3) S pomoshch'iu metriki mozhno vypolniat' operatsiiu podniatiia i opuska - niia indeksov . Eto vozmozhnost' poluchit' , naprimer , iz proizvol'nogo ten- zora smu tipa qa2 0qu tenzor tipa qa1 1qu: sauooau auosooo. Etot tenzor v svoiu ochered' mozhno prevratit' v tenzor tipa qa0 2qu: schauau chii sauiiau chiiauosiio. Takim ob- razom , metricheskii tenzor daet vozmozhnost' otobrazhat' elementy kasatel' - nogo i kokasatel'nogo prostranstva drug v druga . Pust' - mnogoobrazie klassa `. Psevdorimanova struktura na est' tenzornoe pole u tipa qa0 2qu, usloviiam : 1. utshaa dlia vsekh ut,vteA shishaa 2. V kazhdoi tochke Aa znacheniia polia u est' nevyrozhdennaia bili - neinaia forma eaie . Psevdorimanovym mnogoobraziem nazyvaetsia sviaznoe mnogoobrazie klassa ` s psevdorimanovoi strukturoi . Esli (i tol'ko esli ) forma po-V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 17 lozhitel'no opredelena dlia kazhdoi tochki Aa , to mozhno govorit' o rima - novoi strukture i rimanovom mnogoobrazii [10]. Tak kak metrika na - eto tenzornoe pole tipa qa0 2qu, to teper' mozhno opredelit' poniatie rasstoianiia na .Poluchim vyrazhenie dlia kvadrata beskonechno malogo vektora peremeshcheniia (kvadrata intervala ) cherez metricheskii tenzor : AshauA p'*A p'auushiAp',A u`p'u9au au iiuiiu Ashau iiuiiu. (1.4.4) Zdes' - simvol beskonechno maloi velichiny . SS1.5 Sviaznost' i kovariantnaia proizvodnaia Rassmotrim metricheskii tenzor na mnogoobrazii .Etot tenzor in- dutsiruetsia koordinatnym otobrazheniem na prostranstvo T`. On otobrazha - et elementy kasatel'nogo eshishaa i kokasatel'nogo eKHshishaa prostranstv drug v druga , to est' podnimaet i opuskaet indeksy . Chasto dlia resheniia zadach trebuetsia sravnivat' elementy raznykh ten- zornykh polei (vektornykh polei i polei 1-form ) v raznykh tochkakh . Dlia etogo ikh nuzhno umet' perenosit' v odnu tochku , to est' nado znat' pravilo paral - lel'nogo perenosa na mnogoobraziiakh . Itak , na liubom mnogoobrazii rezul' - tat parallel'nogo perenosa , to est' perenosa s sokhraneniem uglov , zavisit ot puti . Takim obrazom , dlia sravneniia tenzornykh polei v raznykh tochkakh mnogoobraziia nuzhno znat' tot put' , vdol' kotorogo proiskhodit parallel' - nyi perenos dannogo ob'ekta v iskhodnuiu tochku . Znaia izmenenie parametra krivoi i izmenenie samogo ob'ekta , mozhno naiti proizvodnuiu v tochke po napravleniiu . No vid krivoi i vid proizvod - noi dolzhny soderzhat' informatsiiu o puti , vdol' kotorogo proiskhodit The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 18 . Vsiu etu informatsiiu neset v sebe kovariantnaia pro- izvodnaia . Vyiasnim , kak nakhoditsia kovariantnaia proizvodnaia . Rassmotrim vektornoe pole E ,opredelennoe v oblasti U mnogoobra - ziia ,zdes' zhe opredelena krivaia @ s parametrom .Esli zhe pole E zadano v kazhdoi tochke krivoi @ ,to mozhem opredelit' ego kovariantnuiu proizvod - nuiu vdol' @ v tochke ashi au shaa: ththaul i m (1.5.1) gde - znachenie parametra v tochke a ,a vektor thobaaLKH() poluchaetsia paral - lel'nym perenosom vektora thshi +e nazad v tochku ashi shaa, ut pokazyvaet , vdol' kakoi krivoi proiskhodit . Dalee rassmotrim kovariantnuiu proizvodnuiu ot funktsii ' vdol' vektora u t. Eto est' proizvodnaia po napravleniiu dannoi funktsii vdol' krivoi s parametrom i kasatel'nym vektorom ut: 1.5.2) Operatsiia kovariantnogo obladaet sleduiushchimi svoistvami [1,2]: 1 kovariantnaia proizvodnaia ot skaliarov sovpadaet s chastnoi proizvodnoi , to est' th'au+
+o, (1.5.3) 2 2th - operator : thshifthshaaauf thth th th'auf thth th auf thth thutshi'shaa , (1.5.4) 3 pravilo Leibnitsa pozvoliaet rasprostranit' opredelenie kovariantnoi proizvodnoi na tenzory proizvol'nogo vida : thshis's thsshaa, (1.5.5) th@, thWau@th, thW@, ththW( , 1.5.6) V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 19 4 poniatie parallel'nogo perenosa vdol' krivoi ne zavisit ot vybora para - metrizatsii , to est': ththaug thth, (1.5.7) 5 kovariantnaia proizvodnaia additivna po raznym napravleniiam : shiththshaashi ththshaaaushi thaaththshaa, (1.5.8) Vychislim kovariantnuiu proizvodnuiu ot vektora : ththau utu5oeto9auuqa5 tueto - eto bazisnogo vektora eto vdol' koordinatnoi linii s kasatel'nym vektorom et. Razlozhim etot vektor po bazisu : tuetoauG oooetoo (1.5.9) Velichiny G ooo nazyvaiutsia koeffitsientami sviaznosti . Oni nesut informatsiiu o tom, kakoi ob'ekt , vdol' kakoi krivoi mnogoobraziia i kakoi rezul'tat poluchaetsia . Takim obrazom : ththaushi iioo`p'uuoG oooshaa`p'uu. ooau iioouG ooo - komponenta kovariantnoi proizvodnoi ot vektora . Analogichno rassmotrim kovariantnuiu proizvodnuiu ot 1-formy , uchi- tyvaia , chto tuuthauG ooothoo: thauuutuu5o ii9auuo6qa tuuiiquii iituiiau auuo65 oo9th iituuthauuoqa5 oooo9thooo G G ooo9thoo ooooau ooooo G ooo - komponenta kovariantnoi proizvodnoi ot 1-formy . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 20 Sviaznost' opredeliaetsia koeffitsientami sviaznosti , kotorye v svoiu ochered' zadaiut pravilo parallel'nogo perenosa po zadannomu puti na . Voznikaet vopros , a kak zhe sviazany G ooo i G ooo? Vychislim kovariant - nuiu proizvodnuiu vdol' krivoi s kasatel'nym vektorom ut ot svertki 1- formy i vektora dvumia sposobami . 1 sposob . th@, vtWau p'iiqu up'viiauuuqa5 uii9vii iiuvii9 (1.5.10) 2 sposob . th@, vtWau@th, vtW@, ooovii (1.5.11) Priravniaem (1.5.10) i (1.5.11): viiuuuiivuuuuG vuuuuG oooiiuuuuG oooviiau0 viiuuG ooouuuuuuG oooviiau0 uuviiuuqaG oooG oooquau0 . V silu proizvol'nosti , v i imeem : G oooG oooau0. Takim obrazom , poluchim : G oooaue G ooo V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 21 Zametim , chto dannye koeffitsienty sviaznosti ne iavliaiutsia tenzorami , tak kak zakon , po kotoromu proiskhodit preobrazovanie koeffitsientov (G ooauo v G auNZooNZoNZ): G dd5RNZ dd5LNZ dd5L dd5LNZ dd5uuNZ dd5uu G ooauo, (1.5.12) ne budet tenzornym . On sovpal by s tenzornym , esli by v pravoi chasti ne bylo pervogo slagaemogo [7]. Opredelenie . Metricheskii tenzor i sviaznost' mnogoobraziia soglaso - vany , esli skaliarnoe proizvedenie dvukh liubykh vektorov pri ikh parallel' - nom perenose vdol' proizvol'noi krivoi na mnogoobrazii sokhraniaetsia . Uslovie soglasovannosti metriki i sviaznosti na mnogoobrazii op- redeliaetsia po sleduiushchei formule : ooauau0, to est', pri parallel'nom perenose po zamknutomu konturu dlina vektora ne meniaetsia . Sledstviem iz etogo usloviia iavliaetsia formula : G e iiuuushaa, (1.5.13) gde ngauooiiuuuau ngiiauuoouue auiioounguu ooiinguauuu - skobka Skhoutena . Eshche odno oboznachenie skobki Skhoutena - { }. Vyvod formuly dlia koeffitsientov sviaznosti v prostranstve s kruche - niem priveden v Prilozhenii 1. SS1.6 Formy so znacheniiami v vektornykh prostranstvakh Formoi so znacheniiami v vektornom prostranstve ili tenzorno - znachnoi formoi nazyvaiutsia formy , komponentami kotorykh iavliaiutsia vek- tor ili tenzor proizvol'nogo ranga . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 22 Prosteishim primerom tenzornoznachnoi 1-formy iavliaetsia gradient vektora (kovariantnaia proizvodnaia dannogo vektora v - nom napravlenii ). Rassmotrim vektor th i vypishem gradient etogo vektora (1.6.1) V pervyi kanal mozhno pomestit' vektor . Zametim , chto (1.6.1.) obladaet svoistvom lineinosti po pervomu kanalu , to est' esli ' , - funktsii , t, vt - vektory , toga lineinuiu kombinatsiiu 't v t mozhno ispol'zovat' v kachest - ve argumenta v pervom kanale (1.6.1): thwthg thwth (1.6.2) Sledovatel'no , ob'ekt (1.6.1) po pervomu kanalu obladaet svoistvami formy . Esli zhe tuda pomestit' vektor , to my poluchim inoi ob'ekt , v koto - ryi mozhno vvesti 1-formu , to est' eto budet tenzor ranga qa1 0qu, inymi slo- vami vektor : thwthshi~shaa Itak , ob'ekt (1.6.1) iavliaetsia tenzornoznachnoi formoi so znacheniiami v vektornom prostranstve . Dalee opredelim ob'ekt eRshi~ ~ ~ shaa, kotoryi mozhno predstavit' kak 0-formu . Pust' thshi~shaa - ob'ekt , komponen - tami kotorogo iavliaiutsia vektora , to est' tenzor ranga qa1 0qu, a eRshi~ ~ ~ shaa - ob'ekt , komponentami kotorogo iavliaiutsia tenzory vida qa3 0qu. S tochki zreniia form , eto 0-formy . Poetomu oni nazyvaiutsia 0-formami , so znacheniiami v vektor - nom prostranstve . Vernemsia k rassmotreniiu ob'ekta (1.6.1). Do togo, kak my podeistvo - vali na nego operatorom ob'ekt thshi~shaa iavlialsia tenzornoznachnoi 0-formoi (to est' vektorom ). Posle primeneniia poiavilsia odin kanal formy . Sledo - vatel'no (1.6.1) teper' 1-forma . Analogichno rassuzhdaia , poluchim , chto ieR - 1-forma . V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 23 SS1.7 Vneshnee . Obobshchennyi vneshnii differentsial V dannom paragrafe opredelim operator mi, koto - ryi sokhraniaet svoistva form i obraten k operatsii integrirovaniia v smysle formuly N'iutona -Leibnitsa . Operatsiia vneshnego byla vvedena Puankare , i mi - operator , kotoryi -formu otobrazhaet v shi 1shaa -formu . Pust' odnomernoe mnogoobrazie , togda operator mi prevrashchaet 0-formu v 1-formu mi. Esli rasshirit' poniatie operatora mi na formy starshikh stepenei , to operator budet obladat' sleduiushchimi svoistvami : Pust' u - p-forma , , - q-formy , togda 1 miu - (p+1)-forma 2 mi59 au mimi (lineinost' ) 3 mishiur shaaau miur shi e 1 shaar mi (anti ) 4 mi5miu9 au mishuau0 (neimpotentnost' ) V (1.6.1) povyshaet rang vektornoznachnoi 0-formy - vektora th na 1, t.e. (1.6.1) est' obobshchenie poniatiia vneshnei proizvodnoi mi ot vektornoznachnoi 0-formy , t.e. ithau th (1.7.1) (ith est' deistvie nekotorogo operatora ,uvelichi - vaiushchego rang vektornoznachnoi 0-formy na edinitsu ). Analogichno , obobshchennaia vneshniaia proizvodnaia ot tenzornoznachnoi 0-formy eRshi ~, ~, ~shaa The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 24 eRau ieR (1.7.2) Obobshchennaia vneshniaia proizvodnaia ot -formy prosto sov- padaet s obychnoi vneshnei proizvodnoi mi, kotoraia obladaet svoistvom anti - ( - -forma , - proizvol'naia -forma ): mi5th9au (1.7.3) Itak , my opredelim poniatie obobshchennoi vneshnei proizvodnoi (obobshchen - nogo vneshnego differentsiala ) ,kak operatora , obla - daiushchego sleduiushchimi svoistvami : 1) obobshchennyi vneshnii differentsial ot funktsii sovpadaet s ee gradi - entom : ' au mi' ,'@ tWautshi'shaa, gde t - proizvol'nyi vektor ; (proizvodnaia po napravleniiu vektora t) 2) obobshchennyi vneshnii differentsial ot vektora (ili vektornoznachnoi 0-formy ) sovpadaet s kovariantnoi proizvodnoi dannogo vektora : thau ith, (ith - gradient vektora th)
@th,tWau 2thth, gde t- proizvol'nyi vektor ; (2thth - kovariantnaia proizvodnaia vdol' vektora t) 3) obobshchennyi differentsial ot tenzora Amu 0-formy ) sovpadaet s kovariantnoi proizvodnoi dannogo tenzora : Amuau iAmu, A@mu,tWau 2thAmu, gde t - proizvol'nyi vektor ; 4) obobshchennyi vneshnii differentsial ot -formy sovpadaet s obychnym vneshnim differentsialom ot -formy : au mi, gde - -forma Uslovii (1) - (4) dostatochno dlia togo, chtoby rasprostranit' poniatie obobshchennogo vneshnego differentsiala na tenzornoznachnye -formy Amimu so svoistvom , (1.7.3): V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 25 qa AmimuthquauA mimuthshie1shaa AmimuthauA mimuthshie1shaa Amimuthmi (1.7.4) ( - proizvol'naia -forma ). SS1.8 Poniatie krivizny mnogoobraziia Krivizna kharakterizuet izmenenie kasatel'nogo vektora pri perenose ego po zamknutomu konturu . Pri parallel'nom perenose vektora iz odnoi tochki v druguiu v prostranstve s kriviznoi rezul'taty poluchaiutsia raznye , esli on sovershaetsia po raznym putiam . Eto vidno iz (ris. 5) Ris. 5 Vektor vt proidet put' ss v tochke s zaimet polozhenie t (na vsem puti vt dvigaetsia , sokhraniaia ugol ). Analogichno dvigaias' po puti `s vektor t zaimet polozhenie th. I, nakonets , proidia put' `s ,vektor th v tochke s budet nakho - dit'sia v polozhenii vt', chto otlichno ot pervonachal'nogo polozheniia . Tenzorom krivizny Rimana nazyvaetsia velichina , vyrazhaemaia cherez kompo - nenty sviaznosti [7]: Aaungoooau2 shoiiG |au|oshwaoo2 G ghshoiiooG |au|oshwang. (1.8.1) Svertkoi pervogo i tret'ego indeksov tenzora krivizny mozhno obrazovat' simmetricheskii tenzor vtorogo ranga : Aaungooooongau AauoooooauA auo, (1.8.2) The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 26 kotoryi nazyvaetsia tenzorom Richchi . Esli zhe svernut' tenzor Richchi , to poluchim nekotoryi invariant : AauauoAauoau A auau, (1.8.3) kotoryi nazyvaetsia skaliarnoi kriviznoi . Tenzor krivizny obladaet sleduiushchimi svoistvami v prostranstve bez krucheniia (sviaznost' simmetrichna ): 1 Aoonnongaue Aooonnng, 2 Aoonnong auA ongoonn (u tenzora Rimana mozhno meniat' mestami pary indeksov ), 3 Ashooonno shwangau0, 4 (tenzor krivizny antisimmetrichen po pervym 2-m indeksam ), 5 shogh (tozhdestvo Bianki ). SS1.9 Pervoe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana . 2-forma krucheniia Vyiasnim obobshchennyi vneshnii differentsial (dalee prosto vneshnii differentsial ) ot bazisnykh vektorov vdol' vektora t:
`@p'ii,tWau iiuuu`p'uau`p'uG au ` p'uG iiushitshaa. (1.9.1) V silu proizvol'nosti vektora t ego mozhno ubrat' : G iiushiishaaau uushiishaa - 1-forma sviaznosti s komponentami G iiuuu. (1.9.2) Kruchenie mnogoobraziia proshche vsego v koordinat - nom bazise , a imenno , ego komponentami . V etom sluchae komponenty tenzo - ra krucheniia - eto chast' koeffitsientov sviaznosti : eiiuuuaue 2 G shoiiushwauuaue qa G iiuuueG uiiuuqu. (1.9.3) V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 27 Matematicheskii smysl poniatiia krucheniia , proiasnit pervoe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana , vyvod kotorogo zakliuchaetsia v sleduiushchem . Rassmotrim 1-formu , nazyvaemuiu kanonicheskoi 1- formoi kokasatel'nogo prostranstva : mip'shi~, ishaaau` p'iishi~shaa' iishiishaa. (1.9.4) (1.9.4) imeet dva kanala dlia vvoda : odin dlia vvoda formy i odin - dlia vvoda vektora . (1.9.4) igraet vazhnuiu rol' v teorii gladkikh mnogoobrazii , t.k. on, deistvuia na ob'ekty kak lineinyi operator , ostavliaet ikh bez izmenenii . Pokazhem eto dlia proizvol'noi 1-formy au uu: mip'shi, ishaaaushi ` iiiiau. Analogichno , dlia proizvol'nogo vektora tauu`p'u: mip'shi~,tshaa au shi` mip'au 5 ` p'ii'ii9au iiau`
`p'iiau` p'iiau`p'u'G iiu (po (1.9.1)) S uchetom etogo mip'au`p'uqa G iiuthiiqu` uiithu9` uiithu9 Vvedem oboznachenie dlia kovariantnoi proizvodnoi ot 1-formy : iiaumiiiG uiithu Togda mip'au`p'ii ii (1.9.5) Znachenie ot tenzornoznachnoi 1-formy Amimu na vektorakh t i vt: 2thA@mimu,vtWe . 1.9.6) Vmesto Amimu podstavim 1-formu mip': The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 28 2th@mip',vtWe 2thvte thte shot,vtshwa. (1.9.7) Vmesto t i vt podstavim `p'ii i, prichem `p'iiau ii qamip'qu5 `p'ii,`p'u9au p'`p'ue p'`p'iie ` p'ii,`p'u1, ` p'ii,`p'u1au ii,u1au0 qamip'qu5 `p'ii,`p'u9auG uiiuu`p'uueG iiuuu`p'uuauqa G uiiuueG iiuuuqu`p'uuau - komponenty tenzornoznachnoi 2-formy krucheniia eR. eRiiuaue e Ruii Dokazhem ravenstvo Uchityvaia to, chto iiauuooau2 iishooo uaushwa poluchim iishooo uaushwaaueRiiu. Takim obrazom qamip'qu5 `p'ii,`p'u9aue R5`p'ii,`p'u9, mip'aueR. (1.9.8) Priravniaem (1.9.5) i (1.9.8) eRau`p'ii ii eRau`p'uuqa sh! p'uueuu, gde euu - 2-forma krucheniia eRau`p'iieii V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 29 eiiau ii ili e iiaumiiiG uiithu. (1.9.9) (1.9.9) - pervoe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana . SS1.10 Vtoroe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana . 2-forma krivizny Dlia vvedeniia poniatiia krivizny sviaznosti rassmotrim dvukratnoe primenenie obobshchennogo vneshnego differentsiala k tenzornoznachnoi 0-forme th (vektoru ) thau shi`p'iiiishaaau uiiu` uiiu9 shthau shithshaaauqa ` p'ii5miiiG uiiu9qu au au` p'iith5miiiG miiiG uiiu9au au` p'iith5miiiG uiiu9` p'ii5 miii5 G uii9ushie1shaaG iiuuthii9` p'uu5G iiuuthG uiiu9
`p'iiqo mishiiblbpph 5 miG uii9ueG iiuuthmiii9` p'uuG iiuuthG uiiu`p'ii5miG uii9u e`p'ii5G uuiithG uuuu`p'ii5miG uii9u e`p'uu5G miG uiiG uuiithG uuuquu. Oboznachim 2-formu v skobke cherez uii - 2-forma kriviz - ny. Togda shthau` p'ii uiiu, (1.10.1) gde uiiaumiG uiiG uuiithG uuu (1.10.2) (1.10.2) - 2- oe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana . Poluchim v koordinatnom bazise 2-oe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 30 uiiaumiG uiiG uuiithG uuu, bazis miii 2-forma uiiau sh! 1-forma G uiiauG togda 5mishauau0 9 mi5G uauiimiau9au miG uauiithmiauau shoooG G uuiithG uuuauG uuooiimioothG uauuumiauauG uushoooiiG Levaia chast' : sh! Pravaia chast' : qashoooG |u|aushwaiiG uushoooiiG uooauiiau2 shoooG |u|aushwaii2 G uushoooiiG |u|aushwauu. (1.10.3) Eto izvestnoe vyrazhenie dlia tenzora krivizny Rimana . SS1.11 Tozhdestvo Bianki dlia krucheniia Naidem obobshchennyi vneshnii differentsial ot tenzornoznachnoi 2- formy krucheniia eRau`p'iieii. eRau 5 ` p'iieii9au` iiau` ` p'uG iiuqueth ii`p'iimi5miiiG G iiuethiiqu` p'iiqo mishiiblbpph miG uiithushie1shaaG uiiethu9` p'ii5miG uiithueG uiiethu9` p'ii6 miG uiithueG uiithqa eueG uuuthuuqu au au`p'iiqa G uiiethumiG uiithueG uiiethuG uiithG uiithuth u9au` p'iiqa miG uiiG uuiithG uuuquth uau au`p'ii5 uiithu9au` p'iiuth uii eRau`p'ii5uth uii9 (1.11.1) V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 31 (1.11.1) - 3- e strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana ili tozhdestvo Bianki dlia krucheniia . Poluchim formulu (1.11.1) v koordinatnom bazise . eRau 5 ` p'iieii9au` p'iith1 2 iiod euuuii`p'ii o euuuiiG o euuuauG o au1 2`p'ii5 o euuuiiG auoii euuuaueG uoaueG uuoauG shouoshwaau eauuuii G sho uuoshwaau o euuuiie6 e1 2 eouau euuauiie1 22 eouau o euuuiie eouau Komponenty levoi chasti : sh5shoo euuushwaiie eshoouau euushwaauii9.
`p'ii5uth uii9au` p'ii5u th9au` p'ii5o Komponenty pravoi chasti : sh shoouuu shwaii. Tozhdestvo Bianki dlia krucheniia v komponentnom vide imeet vid: shoouuushwaiiau shoo euuushwaiie eshoouau euushwaauii (1.11.2) v Vs euuuiiau0 (1.11.3) The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 32 Glava II Sviaznost' i krivizna mnogoobrazii s volnovoi metrikoi SS2.1 Uravnenie Einshteina i volnovaia metrika Neevklidovy geometrii igraiut bol'shuiu rol' v prikladnykh voprosakh sovremennoi teorii estestvoznaniia . Na osnove neevklidovoi geometrii stroitsia teoriia gravitatsii . Sovremennaia teoriia gravitatsii - obshchaia teoriia otnositel'nosti , kotoraia pridala geometricheskii smysl gravitatsii , sviazav ee s rimanovoi kriviznoi [6]. V osnove obshchei teorii otnositel'nosti Einshtein polozhil printsip ekvivalentnosti , sut' kotorogo zakliuchaetsia v lokal'noi ekvivalentnosti polia i sil inertsii , voznikaiushchikh v neinertsial'nykh sis- tema otscheta , perekhod k kotorym mozhet byt' osushchestvlen vvedeniem krivo - lineinoi sistemy koordinat . Velichiny , kotorye opredeliaiut v kazhdoi dan- noi krivolineinoi sisteme koordinat svoistva geometrii , ustanavlivaiut , kak izvestno , metriku prostranstva -vremeni ooau. V obshchei teorii otnosi - tel'nosti ooau s potentsialami gravitatsionnogo polia , a ko- effitsienty sviaznosti G ooauo, parallel'nyi perenos vdol' krivykh v dannoi geometrii , s siloi , prichem eti koeffi - tsienty simmetrichny po pervym dvum indeksam , to est' G uauG ooauo. Pri etom krivizna prostranstva -vremeni auooo otlichna ot nulia i vyrazhaetsia che- rez G ooauo po formule (1.8.1).Osnovnye dinamicheskie uravneniia OTO byli polucheny nezavisimo Gil'bertom i Einshteinom . Pri etom Gil'bert polu - chil uravneniia na osnove variatsionnogo ischisleniia dlia sistemy <<gravita - tsionnoe pole - materiia >>, a Einshtein pri poluchenii uravnenii gravitatsi - onnogo polia tem printsipom , chto tenzor energii -impul'sa materii eooau dolzhen porozhdat' otlichnuiu ot nulia kriviznu prostranstva - vremeni , a krivizna prostranstva -vremeni dolzhna opredeliat' dvizhenie ma- terii . Eti uravneniia imeiut sleduiushchii vid [8]: V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 33 qooauauA ooaue shooauAaue ooau, gde qooau- binom Einshteina , postroennyi na osnove Aooau - tenzora Richchi i A - skaliara , opredelennogo v SS8, a - koeffitsient , koto - ryi nazyvaetsia gravitatsionnoi postoiannoi Einshteina . Rassmotrim vid uravneniia Einshteina v pustote . <<Pustoe >> zdes' ozna - chaet otsutstvie materii i kakikh -libo fizicheskikh polei , za iskliucheniem samogo gravitatsionnogo polia . Gravitatsionnoe pole ne narushaet pustoty , vse ostal'nye polia narushaiut . Itak , v pustote uravnenie Einshteina v silu ravenstva nuliu tenzora energii -impul'sa materii prinimaet vid: . (2.1.1) Svernem (2.1.1) po i .V rezul'tate poluchim : Aau0 . (2.1.2) Takim obrazom v silu (2.1.2) uravnenie Einshteina v pustote imeet vid: Aooauau0. (2.1.3) Napomnim sleduiushchee opredelenie : metrikoi [5] signatury shi, shaa na gladkom mnogoob - razii razmerennosti +au nazyvaetsia takaia gladkaia simmetrichnaia forma na ,chto dlia liuboi tochki A forma 5 na e5shishaa nevyrozhdena i imeet signaturu shi, shaa. Para shi, shaa nazyvaetsia psev - dorimanovym mnogoobraziem . Esli au0 (to est' 5 polozhitel'no opredelena ), forma nazyvaetsia rimanovoi metrikoi , a para shi, shaa - rimanovym mnogoobraziem . Esli au1 , a 0 , to forma nazyvaetsia lorentsevoi metrikoi , a para shi, shaa - lorentsevym mnogoobraziem . V dal'neishem my budem rassmatrivat' psevdorimanovo mnogoobrazie s lorentsevoi signaturoi . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 34 povedenie gravitatsionnykh polei , sozdavaemykh izo- lirovannymi istochnikami , kak izvestno , imeet bol'shoe skhodstvo s povede - niem ploskikh voln v prostranstve -vremeni Minkovskogo . Eto stalo motivirovkoi dlia Bondi , Pirani i Robinsona [11] dat' strogo gruppovoe opredelenie poniatiia ploskikh gravitatsionnykh voln v pustom prostranstve dlia metricheskogo polia , dvum postulatam : 9 Pole odinakovo v liuboi tochke volnovogo fronta . 9 Metricheskii tenzor prostranstva -vremeni podobno vektornomu potentsialu ploskikh voln dopuskaet oprede - lennuiu gruppu simmetrii . Nakladyvaetsia uslovie , chto eti volny obladaiut stepen'iu simmetrii , analogichnoi toi, kotoroi obladaet volna v ploskom pro- stranstve -vremeni . Simmetriia ploskikh volnovykh polei nastol'ko velika , chto trebovanie takoi simmetrii dlia gravitatsionnykh po- lei avtomaticheski vlechet ikh volnovoi kharakter . Volnovoi kharakter proiav - liaetsia vo vnutrennikh izotropnykh svoistvakh etikh metrik . Eto ne <<koordi - natnyi vektor >>, ch'ia metrika mozhet byt' preobrazovana k staticheskoi forme s pomoshch'iu koordinatnogo preobrazovaniia . Izotropnost' stanovitsia vidi - moi iz fizicheskikh svoistv metrik . Esli rassmatrivat' ploskuiu volnu , rasprostra v polozhitel'nom napravlenii osi ,to ochevidnye svoistva sim- metrii takoi volny zakliuchaiutsia v tom, chto sushchestvuet gruppa preobrazovaniia prostranstva -vremeni Minkovskogo v sebia, ostav - liaiushchaia elektromagnitnoe pole neizmennym . Eto dvizheniia -transliatsii v napravleniiakh i vdol' izotropnoi 3-poverkhnosti eau+o .Krome etikh ochevidnykh simmetrii sushchestvuiut dopolnitel'nye simmetrii ploskoi volny , kotorye menee ochevidny , tak kak oni iavliaiutsia vnutrennimi 4-mernymi . Eti simmetrii opisyvaiutsia gruppoi dvizhenii , perevodiashchei izotropnye 3-poverkhnosti eau +o v sebia. Eti dvizheniia nazyvaiutsia <<izotropnymi vrashcheniiami >>. V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 35 Ploskie volny mogut byt' interpretirovany kak gravitatsionnye po- lia na bol'shikh rasstoianiiakh ot izluchaiushchikh tel. Kak izvestno [11], problemu gravitatsionnykh voln udobnee rassmatrivat' v spetsial'nym obrazom vybrannom koordinatnom bazise [12], obrazovannom dvumia nulevymi (izotropnymi ) vektorami `p'au , `p'au 2 i dvumia -podobnymi `p'shau 5 , `p'ssau 6 , prichem vektor `p' kovariantno postoianen i napravlen vdol' volnovogo lucha , a koordinaty i paramet - rizuiut volnovuiu poverkhnost' shi, vshaaau+o .Metricheskii tenzor v etom ba- zise 1-form raven au801 0 0 10 0 0 00e 1 0 0 00e 1 (2.1.4) Ploskaia volna metriki opredeliaetsia kak chastnyi sluchai metriki plosko -frontovykh gravitatsionnykh voln s parallel'nymi luchami (pp-volny ), imeiushchii v ukazannom bazise vid [11]: Ashau2 r shi,, shaash 2 e she sh, (2.1.5) gde koordinata imeet smysl vremeni i kak faza volny . Poetomu (2.1.5) - eto volnovaia metrika . Metrike (2.1.5) so- otvetstvuet bazis iz 1-form : aur mi miv, aumi ,shaumi ,ssaumi( .2.1.6) v kotorom eta metrika imeet vid au ' Naidem uslovie , pri kotorom metrika (2.1.5) iavliaetsia resheniem uravneniia Einshteina v pustote . Dlia etogo vychislim geometricheskie kharak - teristiki mnogoobraziia bez krucheniia , nadelennogo metrikoi (2.1.5). The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 36 SS2.2 1-formy sviaznosti i koeffitsienty sviaznosti dlia volnovoi metriki . Poluchim vid 1-formy sviaznosti dlia volnovoi metriki (formula (2.1.5)) v sluchae , kogda kruchenie ravno nuliu eau0. Dlia etogo ispol'zu - em formulu sviaznost' v sleduiushchem vide [13]: (2.2.1) Formula (2.2.1) poluchena v [13], gde skobki { } nazyvaiutsia skobkami Skhoutena , i v komponentnom vide sovpadaet s formuloi (1.5.13). Ispol'zuia opisannyi v paragrafe SS1 dannoi glavy bazis 1-form (2.1.6), naidem vnesh - nii differentsial ot 1-formy bazisa (2.1.6), pol'zuias' svoistvami etogo differentsiala : miaue r 5thsher 6thssaue r 5mithmier 6mithmi, miau0 , mishau0 , missau0, (2.2.2) gde vvedeny sleduiushchie oboznacheniia : r5 - proizvodnaia ddu dd5, r6 - proizvodnaia ddu dd6. Posle raskrytiia skobki Skhoutena formula (2.2.1) prinimaet vid: +5`p'Hmi+9e +`p'H5`p'Hmi+91 (2.2.3) Ispol'zuia formulu (2.2.3) poluchim : +5`p'Hmi+9e +5`p'Hmi+9e +`p'H5`p'Hmi+9 e +`p'H5`p'Hmi+9e V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 37 aue1 27 d 5`p'Hmi9e d 5`p'Hmi9e d
`p'H5`p'Hmi9 e d
`p'H5`p'Hmi9e d 5`p'Hmi9e d 5`p'Hmi9e d
`p'H5`p'Hmi9 e d
`p'H5`p'Hmi9e shd 5`p'Hmish9e shd 5`p'Hmish9e ssd 5`p'Hmiss9e ssd 5`p'Hmiss9e . Pri dal'neishem vychislenii budem ispol'zovat' formuly (2.2.2). Ot- kuda sleduet , chto est' smysl rassmatrivat' lish' summatsionnyi indeks au0 , tak kak pri vsekh ostal'nykh vneshnie differentsialy ot bazisnykh 1-form (2.1.6) zanuliaiutsia . Opredeliv odnoznachno i ispol'zuia metriku (2.1.5), mozhem utverzhdat' , chto poslednee slagaemoe ne ravno nuliu tol'ko pri summatsionnom indekse au1 (Prilozhenie 2) Sledovatel'no : Gshaur 5 , Gshaue r 5 , Gssaur 6, Gssaue r 6 . (2.2.4) Teper' poluchim vid 1-formy sviaznosti . Budem ispol'zovat' izvestnoe so- otnoshenie : G auG (2.2.5) The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 38 G . Dlia nakhozhdeniia 1-formy sviaznosti pereberem vse vozmozhnye znacheniia in- deksa u . G , G , G G sh , G G ss , G , G , , G , G , G , G , G , G , G , V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 39 Takim obrazom , poluchim : shaur 5mi ssaur 6mi shaur 5mi ssaur 6mi (2.2.6) Vse ostal'nye 1-formy sviaznosti ravny nuliu . Dalee poluchim iavnyi vid koeffitsientov sviaznosti . Napomnim , chto 1- formy sviaznosti sviazany s koeffitsientami sviaznosti sleduiushchim obrazom : G uiiauG uuuiiuu , To est' G uuuii iavliaiutsia komponentami 1-formy sviaznosti G uii . Togda raskroem summatsionnyi indeks : G shauG shuuuuauG shG shG shshshG shssss. S drugoi storony , soglasno (2.2.6) imeem : G shaur 5mi . Priravnivaem koeffitsienty pri : dd au . G ssauG ssuuuuauG ssG ssG ssshshG ssssss, S drugoi storony po (2.2.6) imeem : G ssaur 6mi . Priravnivaem koeffitsienty pri : au . G shauG uushuuauG shG shG shshshG ssshss. S drugoi storony imeem : G shaumi. Priravnivaem koeffitsienty pri : dd au . G ssauG uussuuauG ssG ssG shssshG ssssss. The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 40 S drugoi storony imeem : G ssaur 6mi . Priravnivaem koeffitsienty pri : dd au . Mozhem vypisat' koeffitsienty sviaznosti v vide matrits sleduiushchim obra - zom: G iiuau8000 0 000 0 0r 500 0r 600 G G iiushau8000 0 0r 500 000 0 000 0 G iiussau8000 0 0r 600 000 0 000 0 SS2.3 2-forma krivizny , tenzor Rimana i tenzor Richchi dlia volnovoi metriki na mnogoobraziiakh bez krucheniia Dlia vychisleniia 2-formy krivizny ispol'zuetsia vtoroe strukturnoe urav - nenie Kartana , rassmotrennoe v SS10 pervoi glavy . Eto uravnenie imeet vid: uiiaumiG uiiG uuiithG uuu . Dannoe strukturnoe uravnenie Kartana mozhno raspisat' v sleduiushchem vide : uiiaumiG uiiG iithG uG iithG uG shiithG ushG ssiithG uss . Otlichnye ot nulia vyrazheniia dlia 2-formy krivizny primut vid: shaur 55shthr 56ssth ssaur 66ssthr 65shth shaur 55shthr 56ssth ssaur 66ssthr 65shth (2.3.1) Vyvod izlozhen v Prilozhenii 3. V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 41 Dalee , na osnove razlozheniia 2-formy po bazisu , rasschitaem komponenty tenzora Rimana : au sh A+th+ o dhdhdhdhdhdhdh A+th+ . Togda : sh o dhdhdhdhdhdhdh Ash+th+
au Ashth Ashshshthsh Ashssthss Ashshthsh Ashssthss Ashshssshthss . S drugoi storony , soglasno (2.3.1): shaur 55shthr 56ssth . Priravnivaem koeffitsienty pri shth i ssth, ostal'nye nuli . S uchetom antisimmtrii po dvum pervym i dvum poslednim indeksam , poluchaem : e au au, e au au. Analogichno : ss o dhdhdhdhdhdhdh Ass+th+
au Assth Assshthsh Assssthss Assshthsh Assssthss Assshssshthsh . S drugoi storony : ssaur 65shthr 66ssth . Priravnivaem posledovatel'no koeffitsienty pri shth i ssth, ostal' - nye nuli . S uchetom antisimmetrii po poslednim indeksam , poluchaem ot- lichnye ot nulia koeffitsienta tenzora Rimana : e au au, e au au. sh o dhdhdhdhdhdhdh A+shth+
au Ashth Ashshthsh Assshthss Ashshthsh Assshthss Ashssshshthss . S drugoi storony : shaur 55shthr 56ssth . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 42 Priravnivaem koeffitsienty pri shth i ssth, ostal'nye nuli : e au au, aue au. Dalee : ss o dhdhdhdhdhdhdh A+ssth+
au Assth Ashssthsh Assssthss Ashssthsh Assssthss Ashssssshthss . S drugoi storony : ssaur 65shthr 66ssth . Priravnivaem koeffitsienty pri shth i ssth sootvetstvenno , ostal'nye nuli . Poluchaem komponenty tenzora Rimana : aue au, aue au. Takim obrazom , poluchim sleduiushchie otlichnye ot nulia komponenty tenzora Rimana : Ashshaue Ashshaur 55 Assshaue Assshaur 65 Assssaue Assssaur 66 Ashssaue Ashssaur 56 Ashshaue Ashshaur 55 Assshaue Assshaur 56 Ashssaue Ashssaur 65 Assssaue Assssaur 66 (2.3.2) Napomnim vid uravneniia Einshteina v pustom prostranstve : Ae shAau0 . (2.3.3) Pravaia chast' uravneniia ravna nuliu , tak kak tenzor energii -impul'sa mate - rii v pustote otsutstvuet . Kak govorilos' v pervom paragrafe dannoi glavy , uravnenie (2.3.3) v pustom prostranstve imeet vid: Aau0 . (2.3.4) V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 43 Poluchim vid etogo uravneniia dlia metriki (2.1.4), ispol'zuia vychislennye komponenty tenzora Rimana (2.3.2). Dlia vychisleniia tenzora Richchi ispol' - zuem ego opredelenie : Aau Aau A+ + , (2.3.5) Gde A+ - komponenty tenzora Richchi , vychislennye vyshe , a + - simvol Kronekera . Aau A A Ashsh Assss A A Ashsh Assss Ashsh Ashsh Ashshshsh Assshsssh Assss Assss Ashssshss Assssssss . Ispol'zuia opredelenie simvola Kronekera i (2.3.2) poluchim sleduiushchii vid poslednego ravenstva : Aau Ablbpph Ablbpph Ashshblbpph Assssblbpph au 0 . Analogichno vychislim i vse ostal'nye komponenta tenzora Richchi . (Prilozhenie 4.) Itak , tol'ko odna komponenta tenzora Richchi otlichna ot nulia , a imenno : Aaur 55r 66 . (2.3.6) Teper' proverim , chto skaliarnaia krivizna A dlia rassmotrennoi volno - voi metriki v mnogoobrazii bez krucheniia ravna nuliu . Pri dokazatel'stve budem ispol'zovat' opredelenie A : AauA auA t au0 . (2.3.7) Itak , v rezul'tate provedennykh vychislenii dlia volnovoi metriki (2.1.5) na mnogoobraziiakh s nulevym krucheniem poluchili sleduiushchee uravne - nie: r55r 66au 0 . (2.3.8) ili The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 44 . (2.3.9) Uravnenie (2.3.9) - eto uravnenie ellipticheskogo tipa , nazyvaemoe uravneniem Laplasa . Eto uravnenie (2.3.9) iavliaetsia iskomym usloviem , pri kotorom volnovaia metrika (2.1.5) iavliaetsia resheniem uravne - niia Einshteina v pustote . V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 45 Zakliuchenie V rabote bylo naideno uslovie , pri kotorom volnovaia metrika rima - nova prostranstva iavliaetsia resheniem uravneniia Einshteina v pustote . Dlia etogo snachala byli izucheny geometricheskie struktury na differentsirue - mom mnogoobrazii : sviaznost' , krivizna i kruchenie sviaznosti . Pri etom is- pol'zuetsia takoi analiticheskii apparat geometrii , kak ischislenie vneshnikh form . Na osnovam geometrii byl sdelan referativnyi obzor po prilagaemoi literature , vse ispol'zovannye v rabote formuly byli vychisleny i izlozheny v edinoi sisteme oboznachenii . Na osnove vneshnego ischisleniia byli vyvedeny strukturnye uravneniia Kartana . Pervoe strukturnoe uravnenie , opisyvaiushchee takuiu strukturu mnogoobraziia , kak kruchenie sviaznosti , bylo vy- vedeno na osnove poniatiia kanonicheskoi vektornoznachnoi 1-formy i svoist - va obobshchennogo vneshnego differentsiala . Pri poluchenii vtorogo struk - turnogo uravneniia Kartana dlia 2-formy krivizny ispol'zuetsia formula dlia obobshchennogo vneshnego differentsiala ot vektornoznachnoi bazisnoi 0- formy . Na osnove pervogo strukturnogo uravneniia Kartana vyvoditsia for- mula , opredelit' 1-formu sviaznosti rimanova prostranstva (pri ravnom nuliu kruchenii ). Dalee , ispol'zuia pervoe i vtoroe strukturnye uravneniia Kartana dlia mnogoobraziia bez krucheniia nadelennogo volnovoi metrikoi , v rabote byli vychisleny : 1-formy sviaznosti i koeffitsienty sviaznosti , a takzhe 2-formy krivizny , tenzor Rimana , tenzor Richchi i skaliar krivizny . Na osnove vychislennykh geometricheskikh kharakteristik mnogoobraziia poluchen vid uravneniia Einshteina v pustote . Eto uravnenie iavliaetsia uravneniem ellipticheskogo tipa , nazyvaemoe uravneniem Laplasa i soboi summu vtorykh chastnykh proizvodnykh ot funktsii volnovoi metriki po koordinatam . Poluchennoe The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 46 uravnenie iavliaetsia iskomym usloviem , pri kotorom rassmatrivaemaia volno - vaia metrika iavliaetsia resheniem uravneniia Einshteina v pustote . V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 47 Literatura 1. V.T. Bazylev . Geometriia mnogoobrazii . - M.: Vyssh . shk., 1989. - 224 s. 2. B.Shutts . Geometricheskie metody v matematicheskoi fizike . - M.: Pla- ton, 1995. - 304 s. 3. V.I Arnol'd . Matematicheskie metody klassicheskoi mekhaniki . - M.: Editorial URSS , 2003. - 416 s. 4. V.N. Ponomarev , A.O. Barvinskii , Iu.N. Obukhov . Geometro - dinamicheskie metody i kalibrovochnyi podkhod k teorii gravitatsion - nykh vzaimodeistvii . - M.: Energoatomizdat , 1985. - 168 s. 5. A. P. Norden . Prostranstva affinnoi sviaznosti . - M.: Nauka , 1976. - 432 s. 6. Ch. Mizner , K. Torn , Dzh. Uiler . Gravitatsiia T.1-3. - M.: Editorial URSS , 1995. - 1512 s. 7. P.K. Rashevskii . Rimanova geometriia i tenzornyi analiz . - M.: Edito - rial URSS . 2006. - 664 s. 8. A. Besse . Mnogoobraziia Einshteina . V 2-kh tomakh . T. 1-2. - M.: Mir , 1990. - 704 s. 9. V.D. Zakharov . Gravitatsionnye volny v teorii tiagoteniia Einshteina . - M.: Nauka , 1972. 10. S. Khelgason . geometriia , gruppy Li i simmetriche - skie prostranstva . - M.: Faktorial , 2005. - 605 s. 11. W. Adamowicz. Plane waves in gauge theories of gravitation.// Gen. Rel. Grav. - 1980. - V.12. - N9. - pp. 677-691. 12. Ehlers J., Kundt W. Exact solutions of the gravitational field equations.// Gravitation / ed L. Witten, John Wile y. - New York. - 1962. - P. 49-101. 13. Hehl F.W., McCrea J.D., Mielke E.W., Neeman Y. Metric affine gauge theory of gravity: field equations, No ether identities, world spinors and breaking of dilaton invariance. // P hys. Rep. - 1995. - V.258. - P. 1-171. 14. Kurapova E.I. Volnovoe reshenie uravnenii Einshteina . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 48 Prilozhenie 1 Rassmotrim mnogoobraziia , gde metrika i sviaznost' soglasovany , i po- luchim vyrazhenie dlia koeffitsientov sviaznosti cherez metricheskii tenzor . uuuau iiuuueG uiingnguueG uuii ngungau0 uuuiiau uuuiieG uuu ngngiieG iiu nguungau0 uuiiuau uuiiueG iiuungngueG uuungiingau0 uii9 uuu uuuiie uuiiuau iiuuu uuuiie uuiiue5 G uiingG iiu shishaa nguu 5G iiuungeG uuii ng9 shoNshwangu5 G uuungeG uuu shoNshwaiingau0 Mnogoobraziia , na kotorykh chast' sviaznosti ravna nuliu , nazyvaiutsia mnogoobraziiami Rimana (). V Vs metricheskii tenzor i sviaznost' soglasovany , i sviaznost' simmetrichna (t.e. G uuungau G uuung). Prostranstva , na kotorykh chast' sviaznosti otlichna ot nulia , to est', prostranstva s krucheniem (), vpervye byli rassmotre - ny frantsuzskim matematikom E. Kartanom . Na etikh prostranstvakh pri pa- rallel'nom perenose vektora sam kontur ne zamykaetsia , i komponenty ten- zora krucheniia imeiut vid: 2G shouuushwangau euuung. iiuuu uuuiie uuiiue2 G G G shoiiushwangnguu 2G G iiuuu uuuiie uuiiue2 G iiu ngnguue eiiungnguu e uuiingngue euuungiingau0 G iiu uuuiie uuiiuee iiuuu e uuuii ee uuiiu9 G iiu uiiuue uuiiue iiuuu ee uiiuu e uuuii9 vvedem oboznachenie : echjhau chjh,e G iiu iiuu,u e uii,uu91 25eii u o euiioeeuii o9 G ooau e auoo,ng oong,au91 25 eauoooee auoo oe oo au o9 V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 49 G ooau oau1 2ngo5ooaung aungooe ngooauee ooaunge aungooee ngooau9 G e iiuuu9 ngauooiiuuuau ngiiauuoouue auiioounguu ooiinguauuu - skobka Skhoutena . The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 50 Prilozhenie 2 +5`p'Hmi+9e +5`p'Hmi+9e +5`p'Hmi+9 e +`p'H5`p'Hmi+9e d 5`p'Hmi9e d
`p'H5`p'Hmi9 e d
`p'H5`p'Hmi9e . Analogichno vychisliaia , naidem znacheniia dlia drugikh 1-form sviaznosti : +5`p'shHmi+9e +5`p'shHmi+9e d 5`p'shHmi9e , +5`p'ssHmi+9e +5`p'ssHmi+9e d 5`p'ssHmi9e , V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 51 +5`p'Hmi+9e +5`p'Hmi+9e +`p'H5`p'Hmi+9 e +`p'H5`p'Hmi+9e d 5`p'Hmi9e , +5`p'Hmi+9e +`p'H5`p'Hmi+91 . V poslednei formule tret'e slagaemoe zanuliaetsia , v silu (2.2.2). Togda formula prinimaet vid: +5`p'Hmi+91 au e1 2d 5`p'Hmi9e , +5`p'shHmi+9e +5`p'shHmi+9e d 5`p'shHmi9e , +5`p'ssHmi+9e +5`p'ssHmi+9e d 5`p'ssHmi9e , The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 52 sh+5`p'Hmi+9e sh+5`p'Hmi+9e sh+5`p'Hmi+9she shd 5`p'Hmi9e , sh+5`p'Hmi+9e sh+5`p'Hmi+9e shd 5`p'Hmi9e . Rassmatrivaia sleduiushchuiu formulu , srazu zametim , chto poslednee slagaemoe ravno nuliu (ispol'zuem (2.2.2)): sh+5`p'shHmi+9e shd 5`p'shHmi93 au 0 , sh+5`p'ssHmi+9e sh+5`p'ssHmi+9e . Znaia , chto tol'ko mi0, poluchim : shd 5`p'ssHmi9e , V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 53 ss+5`p'Hmi+9e ss+5`p'Hmi+9e ssd 5`p'Hmi9e , ss+5`p'Hmi+9e ss+5`p'Hmi+9e ssd 5`p'Hmi9e , ss+5`p'shHmi+9e ss+5`p'shHmi+9e ssd 5`p'shHmi9e . Tret'e slagaemoe v sleduiushchei summe zanuliaetsia (v silu (2.2.2)): ss+5`p'ssHmi+9e ss+5`p'ssHmi+9e ssd 5`p'ssHmi93 au 0 . Itak , my poluchili sleduiushchie nenulevye sviaznosti : The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 54 , , , . Vse ostal'nye sviaznosti pri vychisleniiakh zanuliatsia . Ispol'zuia formuly (2.2.2), naidem znacheniia etikh sviaznostei : au1 2qi`p'shH5er 5rsher 5rsher 6rss9qu qaa au1 2qier 52shshoshshwaer 5`p'H1aur 5 . Analogichno vychislim sleduiushchie sviaznosti : aue1 2qie`p'ssH5er 5thsher 5thsher 6thss9qu qaa aue1 2qier 52ssshoshshwaer 52ssshoshshwaer 6 , aue1 2qi`p'shH5er 5rsher 5rsher 6rss9qu qaaaue1 2r5r 51 aue r 5 . V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 55 5rsher 5rsher 6rss9qu qaaaue r 6 . Sledovatel'no : Gshaur 5 , Gshaue r 5 , Gssaur 6, Gssaue r 6 . (2.2.4) The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 56 Prilozhenie 3 Soglasno (2.2.6): aumiG d G thG blsgbpsgph G d thG G shthG shd G ssthG ssd au0 , aumiG d G d thG d G d thG d G shthG shG ssthG ssau auG shthG shG ssthG ss , shaumiG shG d thG shG d thG shd G shthG shshd G ssthG shssd aumiG sh , ssaumiG ssG d thG ssG d thG ssd G shthG ssshd G ssthG ssssd aumiG ss , aumiG d G d thG d G d thG d G shd thG shd G ssd thG ssd au0 , aumiG d G d thG d G thG blsgbpsgph G shd thG shG ssd thG ssau0 , shaumiG shd G d thG shG d thG shd G shd thG shshd G ssd thG shssd au 0 , ssaumiG ssd G d thG ssG d thG ssd G shd thG ssshd G ssd thG ssssd au 0 , shaumiG shd G shthG d G shthG d G shshd thG shG ssshd thG ssau0 , shaumiG shG shthG d G shthG d G shshd thG shG ssshd thG ssd aumiG sh , shshaumiG shshd G shd thG shG shthG shd G shshthG shshblsgbpsgph G ssshd thG shssd au0 , ssshaumiG ssshd G shd thG ssG shthG ssd G shshd thG ssshd G ssshd thG ssssd au 0 , ssaumiG ssd G ssd thG d G ssthG d G shssd thG shd G ssssd thG ssd au 0 , ssaumiG ssG ssd thG d G ssthG d G shssd thG shG shssd thG ssaumiG ss , shssaumiG shssd G ssd thG shG ssthG shd G shssd thG shshd G ssssd thG shssd au 0 , ssssaumiG ssssd G ssd thG ssG ssthG ssd G shssd thG ssshd G ssssthG , V.N. Shcherban', O.V. Baburova 57 Podstavim (2.2.6) v poluchennye vyrazheniia dlia 2-formy krivizny : auG shthG shG ssthG ssaur 5mirth 5mir 6mirth 6miaur , slagaemye ravny nuliu po svoistvu operatora vneshnego . shaumiG shaumi5r5mi9 au iir5iithmi au r5th r5th shr5shth ssr5ssth aur 55shthr 56ssth , ssaumiG ssaumi5r6mi9 au iir6iithmiaur 66ssthr 65shth , shaumiG shaumi5r5mi9 au r 55shthr 56ssth , ssaumiG ssaumi5r6mi9 au r 66ssthr 65shth , gde r55, r66, r65, r56 - vtorye proizvodnye . Takim obrazom , poluchili sleduiushchie otlichnye ot nulia vyrazheniia dlia 2- formy krivizny : shaur 55shthr 56ssth ssaur 66ssthr 65shth shaur 55shthr 56ssth ssaur 66ssthr 65shth (2.3.1) The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's equation 58 Prilozhenie 4. Tak kak pri o simvol Kronekera +au0, to dlia uproshcheniia zapisi nulevye elementy vypisyvat' ne budem . Aau A++au Ablbpph Ablbpph Ashshblbpph Assssblbpph au0 , Ashau A+sh+au Ashblbpph Ashblbpph Ashshshblbpph , Assau A+ss+au Assblbpph Assblbpph Ashssshblbpph , A= A++au Ablbpph Ablbpph Ashshblbpph Assssblbpph au0 , Aau A++au Ablbpph Ablbpph Ashsh Assssaur 55r 66 , Ashau A+shs+au Ashblbpph Ashblbpph Ashshshblbpph Assshssblbpph au 0 , Assau Ash++au Ashblbpph Ashblbpph Ashshshblbpph Ashssssblbpph au 0 , Ashau Ash++au Ashblbpph Ashblbpph Ashshshblbpph , Ashau Ash++au Ashblbpph Ashblbpph Ashshshblbpph , Ashshau Ash+sh+au Ashshblbpph Ashshblbpph Ashshshshblbpph , Ashssau Ash+ss+au Ashssblbpph Ashssblbpph Ashshssshblbpph , Assau Ass++au Assblbpph Assblbpph Assshshblbpph , Assau Ass++au Assblbpph Assblbpph Assshshblbpph , Assshau Ass+sh+au Assshblbpph Assshblbpph Assshshshblbpph , Assssau Ass+ss+au Assssblbpph Assssblbpph Assshssshblbpph .
|
0806.3586
|
Vladimir Shcherban'
|
Vladimir N. Shcherban, Olga V. Baburova
|
The structural equations of Cartan and the wave solution Einstein's
equation
|
p.58
| null | null | null |
math.DG
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Work consists of introduction, two chapters, conclusion and four
applications. In this work is examined the condition, with which the wave space
metrics of Riemann- Cartan is the solution of Einstein equation in the void.
Geometric structures were for this purpose studied on the differentiated
variety: connectedness, curvature and twisting connectedness. For this was used
this analytical apparatus of differential geometry as the calculation of
exterior forms.
In the first chapter the following concepts are examined: - variety; -
vectors and 1- forms on the varieties; - metric tensor, connectedness and the
covariant derivative; - form with the values in the vector spaces; - the
structural equations of Cartan. The second chapter is dedicated to the presence
of condition, during which wave certificate is the solution of Einstein
equation in the void. Using the first and second structural equations of Cartan
for the variety without twisting of that allotted by wave certificate, they
were calculated: the 1- forms of connectedness and the coefficients of
connectedness, and also Riemann tensor, Ricci tensor and scalar of curvature.
In appendix 1 the derivation of formula for the coefficients of
connected-ness in the space with the twisting is given. In appendix 2 the
calculation of the components of the 1- forms of connectedness is carried out.
In appendix 3 the calculations of the components of the 2- forms of curvature
are presented. In appendix 4 the components of Ricci tensor are calculated.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 22 Jun 2008 20:18:24 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 25 Jun 2008 18:24:25 GMT"
}
] | 2008-06-25T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Shcherban",
"Vladimir N.",
""
],
[
"Baburova",
"Olga V.",
""
]
] |
2 wherea(l,ph)is an undefined phase factor. Apart from +a(-l,-ph) =-lph. The displacement op- erators form a on the Hilber = the periodic delta function (or 2p. Next, we introduce the Wigner kernel as a kind of Theintegralof yields unityand we may thusregard ^w(l,ph)as =^D(l,ph) (4) Since for the plane and the sphere, the Wigner kernel can be seen as the transform of the parity by the displacement op- erators [19], this seems to call for interpreting ^w(0,0)as next define the Wigner function of a quantumstate de- scribedbythe densitymatrix ^as W(l,ph) = Tr[^^w(l,ph)]. (5) Using the previous results for ^w(l,ph)one can show all the properties required for a as a quasiprobability distribution. Indee d, due to the hermiticity of the Wigner kernel, W(l,ph)is real. It also provides the proper marginal distributions and it is co - variant, which means that if the state ^'is obtained from ^
by a displacementin phase space ^'=^D(l',ph') the Wigner function follows along rigidly: W'(l,ph) All these propertiesare fulfilled basis,we can writethe (6) where(l,ph) = Intermsof (l,ph), function a(l,ph). One natural option is to set a(l,ph) = agrees with the kernel derived by Pleba' nski in the context of =1 2pdll0, itisflatin (10) Now, it is flat in the conjugate variable l, and thus, the inte- gral over the whole phase space is not finite, which is a thestate coherentstates pointson the cylinder) introducedin Ref. [21] (see also Ref. [22] for a de third Jacobi theta function. One 1: Plot of the Wigner function for a coherent state with l0= 0 andph0= 0. l=-4tol= +4. Weshow the twocorresponding marginal c set to construct the Wigner kernel, their Wigner function ha ions withperiods pand2p, 0,ph0= the discrete cylinder. We can see a pronounced peak at ph= 0forl= 0and slightly smaller ones forl=+-1. A closer look at the picture reveals also for valuesclose to ph=+-pandl=+-1, the Wigner function takes negative values. Actually, a numeric analysis suggests the existence of negativities close to ph=
+-pfor odd values of l. We also plot the marginals phorsummingover l. Asourlast example,we lookat Theanalysiscan be carried outfor (15) is enoughto display the relevantf ea- tures. Wigner function presents then three contributions: two flat slices coming from the states origin(seeFig. 2). To complete our theory we also propose a for these sates. A reconstruction of ^(or, equiva- lently, of its Wigner function) is tantamount to finding the coefficients (l,ph). To this end, we need a allows usto reconstruct (l,ph). Forl= 0, FIG. 2: Plot of the Wigner function (and the for a superposition state (15) with l0= 3andph0=p. and its marginal distributions. The cylinder extends verti cally from l=-4tol= (17) where we have made use of the fact that the valuesof ph,forit 0, we introducethe operator ^Ut= we recall that the generic Hamiltonian of a quantum ro- tator the rotational moment of in- ertia), the operator ^Utis simply the free propagator of the system (in appropriate units). This quantum rotator Hamil- tonian describesa variety of situations, such as molecular ro- tations[24], single-photonOAM [25] orthe azimuthalevolu - tion of optical beams [26]. For all of them, our proposal for o(ph,t)is t, thatis, o(ph,t) other cases, the scheme also works ^L2. for ^and(1)for the reconstruction procedure itself does no t de- pend on the undetermined phase a(l,ph)of the while the Wigner function does have such a depen- dence. The phase factor acts as a metric coefficient for the mapping from Hilbert space onto the phase space. We recall that for the harmonic oscillator, one can recover the Wigner function via an inverse Radon transform from the [27]. Equation(20) is then the an a rather simple yet illustrative example, let us note that for the vortex state ^Utis diagonal, so the independent of phandland all of them equal to1/(2p). Performing the integration in Eq. (20) we Sincethese to the measurement of a continuous variable, such a measurement can be done only approximately. A good , although other experimental schemes are also available [28 ter- minationof the reconstruction errors for each particular summary, we have carried out a full program for of generic vortex states, including a compl bonafide on the system under consideration, our formulation pro- vides a common theoretical framework on the Hilbert Ex- perimental demonstrations of the method in terms of optical beams are presently underway in our laboratory and will acknowledge discussions with Hubert de Guise, Hans Kastrup, Jakub Rembielinski and Krzysztof Kowalski. This work was supported by the Czech Ministry of Education, Project MSM6198959213, the Czech Gran Agency, Grant 202/06/0307, the Spanish Research P.Dirac, Proc.R.Soc. London, Ser.A 133, 60 (1931). [2] J. Nye and M. Berry, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 336, 165 (1974).[3] L. Allen, M. W. Beijersbergen, R. J. C. Spreeuw, and J. P. W o- erdman, Phys.Rev. A 45, 8185 (1992). [4] K. Y. Bliokh, Y. P. Bliokh, S. Savel'ev, and F. Nori, Phys. Rev. Lett.99, 190404 (2007). [5] Z. F. Ezawa, Quantum Hall Effects (World Scientific, Singa- pore, 2000). [6] M. M. Salomaa and G. E. Volovik, Rev. Mod. Phys 59, 533 (1987). [7] A. Hubert and R. Sch afer, Magnetic Domains (Springer, New York, 1998). [8] A. J. Leggett, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73, 307 (2001); E. A. Cornell and C.E.Wieman, ibid.74, 875 (2002). [9] B.T.Hefner andP.M.Marston, J.Acoust.Soc.Am. 106, L. Allen, S. M. Barnett, and M. J. Padgett, Optical Angular Momentum (Institute of N. B. Simpson, K. Dholakia, L. Allen, and M. J. Padgett, O pt. Lett.22, 52 (1997); L. Paterson, M. P. MacDonald, J. Arlt, W. Sibbett, P. E. Bryant, and K. Dholakia, Science 292, 912 (2001). [12] J. R. Abo-Shaeer, C. Raman, J. M. Vogels, and W. Ketterle , Science292, 476 (2001). [13] M.G.A.ParisandJ. VReh' aV cek,eds., , vol. 649 of Lect.Not.Phys. (Springer, Heidelberg, 2004). [14] Z. Hradil, D. Mogilevtsev, and J. VReh' aV cek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 230401 (2006). [15] N. Mukunda, Am.J.Phys. 47, 182 (1979). [16] J. A 49, 3255 (1994). [17] Z. Hradil, J. VReh' aV cek, Z. Bouchal, R. VCelechovsk' y, and L. L. S' anchez-Soto, Phys.Rev. Lett. 97243601 (2006). [18] W.K. Wootters,Ann. Phys.(NY) 176, 1(1987). [19] mun. 258, 210 (2006). [20] J. F. Pleba' nski, M. Prazanowski, J. Tosiek, and F. K. Tu rrubi- ates, Acta Phys.Pol.B 31, 561(2000). [21] K. Kowalski, J. Rembieli' nski, and L.C.Papaloucas, J. Phys.A 29, 4149 (1996). [22] H. A.Kastrup, Phys.Rev. A 73, 052104 (2006). [23] A. A.Zeilinger,J. Opt.B A. S. Mouritzen and K. Molmer, J. Chem. Phys. 124, G. Molina-Terriza, A. Vaziri, J. VReh' aV cek, Z. Hradil, and A. Zeilinger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 167903 (2004); N. K. Lang- ford, R. B. Dalton, M. D. Harvey, J. L. O'Brien, G. J. Pryde, A. Gilchrist, S. D. Bartlett, and A. G. White, ibid.93, J.VReh' aV cek, Z. Bouchal, R. VCelechovsk' y, Z. Hradil, and L. L. S' anchez-Soto, Phys.Rev. A 77, 032110 (2008). [27] K. Vogel and H.Risken, Phys. Rev. A 40, 2847 (1989). [28] pan- ner, D. M. Villeneuve, and P. B. Corkum, Phys. Rev. A 68, 023406 (2003). [29] J.VReh' aV cek, D. Mogilevtsev, and Z. Hradil, New J. Phys. 10, 043022 (2008).
|
0806.3661
|
Luis L. Sanchez. Soto
|
I. Rigas, L. L. Sanchez-Soto, A. B. Klimov, J. Rehacek, and Z. Hradil
|
Full quantum reconstruction of vortex states
|
Final published version
|
Phys. Rev. A 78, 060101 (2008) (Rapid Communication)
|
10.1103/PhysRevA.78.060101
| null |
quant-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We propose a complete tomographic reconstruction of any vortex state carrying
orbital angular momentum. The scheme determines the angular probability
distribution of the state at different times under free evolution. To represent
the quantum state we introduce a bona fide Wigner function defined on the
discrete cylinder, which is the natural phase space for the pair angle-angular
momentum. The feasibility of the proposal is addressed.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 23 Jun 2008 12:14:10 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 17 Dec 2008 08:45:55 GMT"
}
] | 2008-12-17T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Rigas",
"I.",
""
],
[
"Sanchez-Soto",
"L. L.",
""
],
[
"Klimov",
"A. B.",
""
],
[
"Rehacek",
"J.",
""
],
[
"Hradil",
"Z.",
""
]
] |
memory Hamiltonian structure prediction pote ntials are not overly rugged, thereby suggesting their landscapes are like those of actua l proteins. In the present con- tribution we show how basin-hopping global optimization ca n identify low-lying minima for the corresponding mildly frustrated energy landscapes. Fo r small systems the succeeds inlocating bothlower minimaandconfor mations closer structure than does molecular dynamics with simulated a nnealing. For large systems the efciency of basin-hopping decreases for our initial implem entation, where the steps consist of random perturbations to the Cartesian coordinates. We im plemented umbrella sampling using basin-hopping to further conrm when the global minima are reached. We have also im- proved the energy surface by employing bioinformatic techn iques for reducing the roughness or variance of the energy surface. Finally, the basin-hoppi ng calculations have guided im- provements in the excluded volume of the Hamiltonian, produ cing better structures. These results suggest a novel and transferable optimization sche me for future energy function Introduction The complexity of the physical interactions that guides the folding o f biomolecules presents a significant challenge for atomistic modeling. Many current protein mo dels use a coarse grained approach to remove degrees of freedom, such as non-polar hydr ogens, which increases the fea- sible time step in molecular dynamics a more dramatic improvement of efficiency solvent degrees of freedom can be reduc ed.3In this case more can prevent the model from reproducing experime ntal results. Another option is to reduce the number of degrees of freedom of the solute. The as sociative memory a coarse-grained molecular mechanics potential inspired by physic al models of the protein folding process, but flexibly incorporates bioinformatic dat a to predict protein structure. The AMH is first optimised using the minimal frustration principle in term s of Along with using the energy of the native structure to estimate Tf, a random energy the glass transition temperature, Tg, is used based on a set of decoy structures. Tgrepresents a characteristic temperature scale at which kinetic trapping in misfo lded states dominates the dynamics. An improved potential is next obtained that uses better estimates of the by maximizing the normalized difference between the native s tate and a sampled set of misfolded decoys which are obtained from the pot ential itself. The potential so obtained is transferable for the prediction of structures outside of the training set. The ratio Tf/Tg has provided a powerful metric for the optimisation of both this bioin formatically informed well as other types of energy functions incorporating only phys ical parametersusing atraining set ofevolved natural proteinssmo oths the energy landscape from what it would be for a random hetero-po lymer, the common problem of multiple competing minima persists even when using a reasonably acc urate structure suchasthisone. dynamic search the rugged landscapes of optimised structure predictio n free energy profiles indicate that better structures actually are present at lo w temperatures, the slow kinetics 3of a glass-like transition during annealing has prevented these minima from being investigate difficulties itisdesir we implement the basin-hopping global optimisation has proved ca- pable of overcoming large energetic barriers in a wide range of differe nt systems. Basin-hopping is an algorithm where a structural perturbation is followed by energy minimisation. This transforms the potential energy surface, by removin g high barriers, as shown in Fig. 1. Moves between local minima are accepted or rejected based upon a Monte Carlo criterion. Avoid- ing barriers by employing a numerical minimisation step not only facilitat es movement between local minima, but also broadens their occupation probability distribut ions, which overlap over a wider temperature range, thereby increasing the probability of int it does not alter the nature of the local minima since the Hamiltonian itse lf is not changed, enabling the comparison between molecular dynamics and basin-hopping gene rated minima. This method has previously been applied to find global minima in atomic and molecular c solids.24Since the algorithm only requires coordinates, energies, and gradie nts, it can be transferred between different molecular systems such as binary Lennard-Jones biomolecules, or coarse-grained proteins models as in this st udy. 2 Theory and Computational Details The AMH energy function used in the present work has previously be en optimised over a set ahelical proteins, and consists of a backbone term, Eback, and an which has an additive form.25,26This model is sometimes termed the AMC memory contact) to distinguish it from one that uses n onadditive water before,15,28 we will only summarize its form here. We employ a version of the coarse -grained model where the twenty letter amino acid code has been reduced to four, and the nu mber of atoms per residue is limited to three (C a, Cb, and O), except for glycine residues. The units of energy and temp erature 4were both defined during the parameter optimisation. The interact ion energy owas defined in terms of the native state energy excluding backbone contribution s,EN amc, (1) whereNis the number of residues of the protein being considered. Tempera tures are quoted in terms of the reduced temperature Tamc=kBT/o. While Ebackcreates self-avoiding Eintintroduces the majority of the attractive interactions that prod uce folding. The interactions described by Eintdepend on the sequence separation |i-j|. The residues less than 12 amino acids apart were defined by Eqs . index uruns over all Nmemmemory proteins to which the protein has previously been aligned using a threading in the protein has an with it in every memory protein; if, due to gaps in the alignm ent, there is no with i-jfor a particular memory then this memory protein simply gives no cont ribution to the interaction between residues iandj). The interaction between C aand C batoms is a sum of Gaussian wells centred at the separations ru i'j'of the corresponding memory atoms. The widths of the Gaussians are given by sij=|i-j|0.15@A. The scaling factor ais used to satisfy Eq. 1. The weights given to each well are controlled by which depends on the identities Pi'andPj'of the residues to which iandjare aligned, as well as the identities The self-consistent optimisation calculates the gparameter which originates the cooperative folding in the model. A three well contact potential [Eq. (3)] is used for residues separated by more than 12 residues as described (3) 5Here, the sequence indices iandjsum over all pairs of C batoms separated by more than 12 residues. The sum over kis over the three wells which are approximately square wells between rmin(k) andrmax(k) defined parameters ( are (4.5 @A, 8.0@A) , (8.0@A, 10.0@A), and (10.0 @A, 15.0@A) fork=
1,2 and 3 respectively. In order to approximately account for the va riation of the of pair distances with number of residues in the protein ( N) a factor ck(N) has been included in Elong. It is given by c1= 1.0,c2= andc3= individual wells are also weighted by gparameters which depend on the identities of using above. Incont rast between residues closer in sequence, this part of the potential does not de pend on the database structures that define interactions. To pinpoint the effects of frustration or favorable non-native con tacts always present in any coarse gained protein model, we simulated a perfectly smooth energ y function often called a G- o model.30G- o models are an essential tool for understanding protein folding the same backbone terms,33in this single structure based Hamiltonian [Eq. (5)], all of the interactions, Eintare defined by Gaussians whose minima are located at the pair distribu tion found in the experimental o=-o aG- (5) The global minima of such an energy function should be the input stru cture. Many have used additional constraining potentials to characterise unsampled regions of co- ordinate space while using molecular dynamics.15,34To characterize the landscape sampled we also used a structure constraining potential to identify ensembles with fixed but varying fractions of native structure. Using such a potential allows us to access that are unlikely to be thermally sampled. The constr aining potential also called umbrella potentials are centered on different values of an order par ameter to sample along the collective coordinates. One of the collective coordinates is Q, an order parameter that measures the structural similarity of two conformat ions by computing the of C-alpha pairwise contact differences, as defined in Eq. (6) The resulting order parameter ranges from zero, where there is n o similarity between structures, to one, which represents an exact overlap. The form of the poten tial isE(Q) = be varied in order to sample different regions of the chosen orde r parameter. As in equilibrium sampling, simulations were initiated at the native state and theQiparameter was reduced throughout the sampling. We have also studied the potential energy landscape when multiple su rfaces are each other by the use of multiple homologous target proteins. This manipulation of the energy landscape has been shown to further reduce local energe tic frustration that arises inthesequence optima lsequence reducing the number of non-native traps, this averaging often improves the quality of results.35-38As seen in Eq. (7), the form and the parameters of the energy fun ction are maintained fromEqs. (2) and(3), but the normalized summation is ta ken over a set of (7) Since proteins are not random heteropolymers, the differences in t he energy function for homolo- gous proteins are randomly distributed, therefore the mean over multiple energy functions should have less energetic variation than the original function. Indeed, p erforming this summation is a way of incorporating to the optimisation of the Tf/Tgcriterion into any energy function. The target sequences of the homologues can be identified using PSI-Bla st with default classes of proteins have a large number of sequence homologu es, therefore performing a alignment Removing redundant seq uences homologues also removes biases that can be introduced wh ere there are few This is done by preventing sequences in the collected seque nces from having greater than 90% sequence identity. The remaining sequences are aligned in a multiple sequence within the sequence alignment can be addressed within the AMH e nergy function in a variety of ways. In the present work, gaps in the target seque nce were removed, while gaps within homologues were completed with residues from the target pro tein. While this procedure may introduce small biases toward the target sequence, it is prefe rable to ignoring the we made several ad hocchanges to the backbone potential, Eback. Eliminating some compromises necessary for rapid molecular dynamics simulations allow ed the AMH potential to theover excluded volume energy term, which should reduce the number o f states available The terms shown in Eq. (8) are used to reproduce the p eptide-like conformations in the original molecular dynamics energy (8) Eevmaintains a sequence specific excluded volume constraint between t he Ca-Ca, Cb-Cb, O-O, and C a-Cbatoms that are separated by less than rev. Previously,26we have seen that produce a less frustrated energy surface when using therma l equilibrium sampling, but slow dynamics was often found to result since the local barrier heigh ts became too large. The ability of basin-hopping to overcome such large, but local barriers a llows us therefore to consider a potential whose dynamics would otherwise be too slow for molecular dynamics. In the final part 8of the paper, we altered the excluded volume term, as shown in Eq. ( 9) to prevent changing the default molecular dynamics parameters, lC EV= 20,lO EV= 20,rC ev(j-i <5) = 4.5@A, andrO ev= 3.5@A, tolC EV= 250,lO EV= 250,rC ev(j-i <5) = = 3.85@A, andrO ev= 3.85@A. The force constant are over an order of magnitude larger than those used in the molecular dynamics, and the radii of th e Ca, Cb, and O atoms are also 10% larger than previously used values. This increase in excluded volume slows the onset of chain collapse, but improves steric interactions. The other chan ge to the backbone terms which maintain chain connectivity. In molecular dynamic s annealing, covalent bonds are preserved using the SHAKE permits an increase of the time step. For basin-hopping in all parts of this paper, we r emoved the SHAKE method and replaced it with a harmonic potential, Eharm, between the C a-Ca, Ca-Cb, and C a-O atoms. This replacement permits the location of local minima without requiring an internal and avoids discontinuous gradients. When minimise d, the additional harmonic terms typically contribute only only .015 kBTper bond. The remaining terms of the potential are maintained. Depending on the sidechain, th e neighbouring residues in sequence sterically limit the variety of positions the backbone atoms can occupy, as evidenced in a Ramachandran plot.43This distribution of coordinates is reinforced by a potential, ERama, low barriers to encourage rapid local movements. The plan arity of the peptide bond is ensured by a harmonic potential, Echain. The chirality of the C acentres is maintained using the scalar triple product of neighbouring unit vectors of carbon and nit rogen bonds, Echi. For basin-hopping simulations, whose algorithm is outlined in Fig. 2 the m ost important sam- pling parameters are the temperature used in the accept/reject steps for local minima Tbh, and the maximum step size for perturbations of the Cartesian coordinates d. A higher temperature to an increased energy minima to be accepted, and also c reates a larger the number of iterations typically required to minimise the greater perturbed co nfigurations. Too high a tem- 9perature leads to insufficient exploration of low-energy regions. Th e temperature ( Tbh) for was 10 Tamc. Lower temperatures resulted in slower escape rates from low ene rgy traps, while higher temperatures prevented adequate exploratio n of low energy regions. The step size needs to be large enough to move the configuration into the bas in of attraction of one local minimum to a neighbouring one, but not be so large that the new minimum is unrelated to the previous state. Every Cartesian coordinate was displaced up to a m aximum step size( d) of 0.75@A, the optimum value determined from preliminary tests. Each run cons isted of 2500 saving structures every 5 basin-hopping steps. The conve rgence condition ( dEmin) on (RMS) gradient for each minimisation was set to 10-3o, and the 5 from each run were subsequently converged more tightly ( dEfinal) to an RMS gradient of 10-5o. It is important to note that basin-hopping does not provide equilibr ium In structure prediction there, however, is no rigorous n eed for the search to obey de- tailed balance since the global energy minimum is the primary interest. Basin-hopping provides a means for the optimal global search of the energy landscape, ho wever other methods must be used when calculating free energy and entropy. In previous structure prediction studies with the AMH, low energy s tructures were identified using off-lattice Langevin dynamics with simulated annealing, employing a linear annealing sched- ule of 10000 steps from a temperature of 2.0 to 0.0, starting from a random and length of simulations needed in both strategies were det ermined by the number of uncorrelated structures encountered. The current basin-hop ping method with the AMC energy function encounters roughly one deep trap per run. In order to s ample 100 independent structures in molecular dynamics 20 separate runs were needed, because simula ted annealing samples about five independent states before the glass transition temperature is encountered, as measured by the rapid decay of structural correlations. We compared several ahelical proteins, both from within and outside the training set of the AMH energy function. 103 Results and Discussion We performed initial calculations with a G- o potential for the 434 rep ressor (protein data bank (PDB44) ID 1r69). In Fig. 3 we show this model accurately represents the native basin. on the G- o model provide a useful benchmark for comparin g the computer time required for the different global optimisation strategies. Using the sampling p arameters used in this report, we compared the time for initial collapse between the molecular dynam ics and basin-hopping runs. The initial collapse required about 7 minutes for the annealing runs an d 31 minutes for basin- hopping on a desktop computer. However, these values do not refl ect the actual performance of the two approaches in locating global minima, which will depend upon th e move sets, step and convergence criteria. While using the AMC structure prediction Hamiltonian, we found that b asin-hopping was often able to locate lower energy structures and also identified minim a that have greater with the native state than annealing. These results are pro duced for structure predictions for proteins both inside and outside the training set, as demonstra ted in Table 1. The first three proteins (PDB ID 1r69, 3icb, 256b) in Table 1 are in the training set of the the other three are not, and can therefore be considered as predictions from the algorithm. The minima located with basin-hopping show an increase in structural overlap with the native state [Eq. (6)] when compared to the Langevin dynamics approach .Qscores of 0.4 for single domain proteins generally correspond to a low resolution root mean s quare deviation (RMSD) of around 5 @Aor better. Qscores of 0.5 and higher have still more accurate tertiary packing and are of comparable quality to the experimentally derived models. T he high quality suggest the form of the backbone terms is appropriate, since the physically is reproduced. Lower energy structures are s ampled by basin-hopping for the non-training set proteins, but the structural overlap improveme nt found in these deeper minima was smaller. Larger proteins pose a greater challenge for basin-ho pping with this Hamiltonian due to the random steps in Cartesian coordinates. Dihedral coordinat e move steps would probably be 11more efficient, and will be considered in future work. The distribution of minima encountered from multiple simulations for bo th search methods is shown in Fig. 4 where a greater density of high quality structures is o btained by the . The potential energy surface still includes, therefore , significant residual frustration in the near-native basin in the form of low-lying minima separated by re latively high the parameter optimisation to reduce frustration, folding would exhibit more characteristics. Most of the cooperative folding occurs du ring collapse until Qvalues of around 0.4 are reached. While the structures from simulated annea ling are accurate enough for functional determination, we see basin-hopping can better overc ome barriers that are created after collapse. The density of the high quality structures is also important for post-simulation analysis45. Another way of representing the data of a set of independent ba is by selecting the lowest energy structures from each s imulation of the 434 repressor (PDB ID 1r69) and HDEA (PDB ID 1bg8) proteins and ordering them w ith respect to their structural overlap. As shown in Fig. 5, the protein in the training se t (434 repressor) produces better results than the non-training protein, as expected. We have decomposed the different energy terms in the Hamiltonian in T able 2, to examine which interactions are most effectively minimised. The AMC potential h as three different dis- tance classes in terms of sequence separation, and these are defi ned as short ( |i-j|<5), medium (5<= |i-j| <=12), and long ( |i-j|>12). Most importantly, the long-range AMH interactions are successfully minimised in the basin-hopping runs, due to the ability of basin-hopping to over- come large energetic barriers. This term will govern the quality of st ructures sampled using an approximately smooth energy landscape. The other terms that de fine secondary structure for- mation are not as well minimised. This result is due to the disruption of h elices by the random Cartesian perturbation move steps. These move steps benefit fa vorable steric packing and there- fore do well at minimising the excluded volume energy term of the Hamilt onian. A approach might be more efficient, where larger dihedral s teps could be made early during minimisation to sample a wider number of structures, followed b y random Cartesian steps 12to optimise the steric we sampled high quality structures, we would like to confirm that w e have the global minima of the energy surface. To access these u nsampled states we used um- brella potentials. When constraining a set of simulations to different v alues ofQ, we have obtained energy minima for cytochrome c, roughly15 odeeper with a randomized structure, as shown in Fig. 6. For the 43 4 repressor the minima ob- tained from randomized states and those found with the Qconstraints applied differ by only a few kBT. This shows basin-hopping does indeed act as a global optimisation me thod, by the global energy minimum from multiple independent uncon strained simulation. This behavior is predictable from the choices that governed the design o f the Hamiltonian. Low energy barriers between structures are desirable during a molecular dyna mics simulation because they accelerate the dynamics. However, for basin-hopping these low ba rriers encourage tertiary before secondary structure units condense for sequ ences greater than 110 amino of Multiple Energy a Hamiltonian by calculating the arithmetic average of t he potential over a set increased thequality ofpredictions inbothe quilibrium andannealing simu- lations. improved theperformanc einbasin-hopping proteins, 100independent and Hamiltonians. By the superposition o f multiple energy landscapes we saw a reduction in the number of competing low energy traps arou ndQvalues of 0 .3 for both the 434 repressor and uteroglobin (PDB ID 1UTG), as shown in Fig. 7 . Improvement of Hamiltonians can be statistically described by the average energy gap between the native basin and a set of unfolded structures, and by the roughne ss of the energy surface, The sequence based limited the energetic variance of the sampled landscapes, thereby reduc ing the glass transition temper- ature. This improvement, even at the low temperatures sampled in b asin-hopping, is predicted 13from theory, but difficult to observe in conventional equilibrium simula tions due to the emergent glassy dynamics, which slows the kinetics. The energy gap improveme nt was smaller than the reduction of the energetic variation of the Hamiltonian. In terms of the goal of maximizing the ratio ofTf/Tg, this increase came primarily from to reducing the glass transition te mperature Tg. In the low energy region we saw fewer competing states, and an incr eased correlation between E andQfor the Hamiltonian compared to the original H amiltonian. For the 434 repressor the lowest energy structure had the highest Qvalue of Polymer Collapse When we annealed the Hamiltonian using molecular dynamics we observe d some over-collapse of the polypeptide chain, producing a smaller radius of gyration than th e experimental structure. In basin-hopping runs we also found structures exhibiting a larger n umber of contacts than the experimental structure, as show in Fig. 8, where a contact is defin ed as a C a-Cadistance of less than 8 @A. While the low-energy structures may be native-like, these struc tures were more compact than those observed experimentally. To investigate this b ehavior, we examined theG- surprisingly, the G- o model also produces over-collapse , as shown in Fig. 9. Hence the interaction parameters of the structure prediction Hamiltonian we re not responsible for all of the over-collapse. These minimal model-dependent frustrations w ere only eliminated in the final stages of minimisation. The most effective technique for reducing ov er-collapse was to increase the force constant and the atomic radius in the excluded volume terms [E q. (9)]. The barrier these parameter changes. The glass-like transition seen in simulated annealing prevents further collapse in molecular dynamics, as the rearrangement rate s slow down exponentially The improved parameter set of Fig. 10 shows more n ative-like collapse, but the lowest energy structures had Qvalues of 0.36 and the best Qvalue was 0.45, which are worse simulations with the original parameters. 144 Conclusion In this report we have demonstrated that minima with lower energy a nd higher quality structures can often be located for the AMH potential using basin-hopping glob al optimisation compared to annealing. Encouragingly, the long range in sequence energy contr ibutions are better minimised than with simulated annealing. Umbrella sampling using basin-hopping ca n also show when the global minima are reached for a selected order parameter. Previou s techniques for reducing basin-hopping also permits improvements in certain backbone t erms of the changes would make the kinetics too slow in molecular dynamics a nnealing runs, but larger barriers can be easily crossed using results highlight strategies where thede ep non-native traps could be used as decoys for further parameter refi nement, rather than the higher- lying minima obtained by quenching with simulated annealing. This re-opt imisation of the po- tential results in getting a better estimate for Tf/Tgnow possible because of the efficiency of the basin-hopping algorithm at identifying low energy decoys. Anoth er future direction would be evaluating the equilibrium properties of low-lying structures ident ified by basin-hopping also provides a means to calculate free energy barriers, which would be d ifficult to characterise via conventional thank Dr Joanne Carr, and Dr Justin Bois for helpful comments t hroughout this research. The efforts of P.G.W. and M.C.P. are supported through the National Institutes of Health Computing resources were supplied by the Center f or Theoretical andPHY0225630. acknowledges the support by the International Institute fo r Complex Adaptive NSF Grant J. C. Phillips et al., J. Comp. Chem. 26, 1781 (2005). [2] D. V. D. Spoel et al., J. Comp. Chem. 26, 1701 (2005). [3] Y. Levy and J. N. Onuchic, Annu. Rev. Biochem. 35, 389 (2006). [4] M. S. Friedrichs and P. G. Wolynes, Science 246, 371 (1989). [5] M. S. Friedrichs and P. G. Wolynes, Tet. Comp. Meth. 3, 175 (1990). [6] M. S. Friedrichs, R. A. Goldstein, and P. G. Wolynes, J. Mol. Biol. 222, 1013 (1991). [7] B. Derrida, Phys. Rev. B. 24, 2613 (1981). [8] R. A. Goldstein, Z. A. Luthey-Schulten, and P. G. Wolynes, Proc . Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 4918 (1992). [9] P. Barth, J. Schonbrun, and D. Baker, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U SA104, 15682 (2007). [10] J. Lee et al., J. Phys. Chem. B 105, 7291 (2001). [11] Y. Fujitsuka, S. Takada, Z. A. Luthey-Schulten, and P. G. Wo lynes, Proteins 54, 88 (2004). [12] Y. Fujitsuka, G. Chikenji, and S. Takada, Proteins 62, 381 (2006). [13] In this paper we note, the word optimisation will be used with two s imilar but distinct function. The second use is to find the global energy minima o n a surface that has multiple minima of nearly equal energies. [14] C. Zong, G. Papoian, J. Ulander, and P. Wolynes, J. Am. Chem. S oc.128, 5168 (2006). [15] M. P. Eastwood, C. Hardin, Z. Luthey-Schulten, andP. G. Woly nes, I.B.M. Systems Research 45, 475 (2001). [16] D. Wales and J. Doye, J. Phys. Chem. A 101, 5111 (1997). 16[17] Z. Li and H. A. Scheraga, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84, 6611 (1987). [18] D. J. Wales and H. A. Scheraga, Science 285, 1368 (1999). [19] J. P. K. Doye and D. J. Wales, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1357 (1998). [20] D. Wales, Energy Landscapes , Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2003. [21] D. J. Wales et al., The Cambridge Cluster Database, (2001). [22] J. M. Carr and D. J. Wales, J. Chem. Phys. 123, 234901 (2005). [23] A. Verma, A. Schug, K. H. Lee, and W. Wenzel, J. Chem. Phys. 124, 044515 (2006). [24] T. F. Middleton, J. Hern' andez-Rojas, P. N. Mortenson, and D. J. Wales, Phys. Rev. B 64, 184201 (2001). [25] C. Hardin, M. Eastwood, Z. Luthey-Schulten, and P. G. Wolyne s, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA97, 14235 (2000). [26] M. Eastwood, C. Hardin, Z. Luthey-Schulten, and P. G. Wolyne s, J. Chem. Phys. 117, G. Papoian, J. Ulander, M. Eastwood, Z. Luthey-Schulten, an d P. G. Wolynes, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 101, 3352 (2004). [28] M. C. Prentiss, C. Hardin, M. Eastwood, C. Zong, and P. G. Woly nes, J. Chem. Ther. Comp. 2:3, 705 (2006). [29] K. K. Koretke, Z. Luthey-Schulten, and P. G. Wolynes, Prote in Sci.5, 1043 (1996). [30] N. G- o, Ann. Rev. Biophys. Bioeng. 12, 183 (1983). [31] J. J. Portman, S. Takada, and P. G. Wolynes, Phys. Rev. Lett .81, 5237 (1998). [32] N. Koga and S. Takada, J Mol Biol 313, 171 (2001). 17[33] M. P. Eastwood and P. G. Wolynes, J. Chem. Phys. 114, 4702 (2002). [34] X. Kong and C. L. Brooks III, J. Chem. Phys. 105, 2414 (1996). [35] F. R. Maxfield and H. A. Scheraga, Biochemistry 18, 697 (1979). [36] C. Keasar, R. Elber, and J. Skolnick, Folding and Design 2, 247 (1997). [37] R. Bonneau, C. E. M. Strauss, and D. Baker, Proteins 43, 1 (2001). [38] C. Hardin, M. P. Eastwood, M. C. Prentiss, Z. Luthey-Schulte n, and P. G. Wolynes, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100, 1679 (2003). [39] S. Altschul et al., Nucleic Acids Res. 25, 3389 (1997). [40] J. E. Stajich et al., Genome Res. 12, 1611 (2002). [41] J. Thompson, D. Higgins, and T. Gibson, Nucleic Acids Res. 22, 4673 (1994). [42] J. Ryckaert, G. Ciccotti, and H. Berendsen, J. Comput. Phys .23, 327 (1977). [43] G. Ramachandran and V. Sasisekharan, Adv. Protein. Chem. 23, 283 (1968). [44] H. M. Berman et al., Nucleic Acids Res. 28, 235 (2000). [45] D. Shortle, K. T. Simons, and D. Baker, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U SA95, 11158 (1998). 18Figure Captions 1. In the basin-hopping approach the original potential energy su rface (solid) is transformed into a set of plateaus (dashed). The local minima are not changed, b ut the transition state regions are removed. 2. Variation of the energy of the current minimum as a function of Qfor minima encountered in the Markov chain during a basin-hopping run using a G- o model. Step s that increase the energy are sometimes allowed by the Monte Carlo criterion, which emp loyed a temperature of 10kb/o. 4. Energy as a function of Qfor local minima of 434 repressor encountered during 100 inde- pendent basin-hopping optimisations (top) and 20 annealing simulatio ns (bottom). 5. The lowest energy structures of the training set protein, 434 r epressor (top) and the blind prediction proteins, HDEA (bottom) identified from 100 independen t basin-hopping simu- lations. Each minimum has values for energy illustrated by the dots an d structural overlap to the native state Qrepresented by lines. These minima are ordered with respect to the ir structural overlap Qwith the native state (Index). The data shows correlations betwe en the energy and Q, while the number of high quality structures is superior for the train ing protein. 6. Energy as a function of Qfor the 434 repressor and cytochrome c proteins obtained in basin - hopping calculations with the structure prediction Hamiltonian. Thes e runs employed an additional umbrella potential that constrains the simulation to differ ent values of Q. The results for the 434 repressor are similar to the unconstrained bas in-hopping results, but the structures for cytochrome c are 15 olower in energy than those found in runs. 197. Energies of local minima obtained using basin-hopping with the origin al and a Hamiltonian for two training proteins. Importantly for bo th the top graph (434 repressor) and the bottom graph (uteroglobin) fewer non-nativ e states are seen with the sequence averaged (red) Hamiltonian when compared to standard Hamiltonian (black). 8. that was optimised for molecular dynamics. Structure s were saved every 20 basin-hopping steps. The ratio of contacts to native state conta cts shows that most of the structures are more compact than the native state. 9. A G- o potential simulation for the 434 repressor shows a modest amount of a basin-hopping simulation, which is resolved as the structure approaches a Qvalue of 1.0. 10. r that was optimised for molecular dynamics. Structure s were saved every 20 basin-hopping steps. An altered set of backbone parameters pro duces structures that have similar collapse behavior when compared to the native 1: 21Basin Hopping Algorithm Monte Carlo Step (nsteps) random Cartesian move step with maximum distance ( d) and temperature ( quasi-Newtonian method for condition ( dEmin) is RMS gradient of with tight convergence condition ( dEfinal) is RMS gradient of 10-5o/r Figure 2: 22PSfrag 0 .4 0.6 0.8 3: 23PSfrag 0.2 0.3 4: 24PSfrag 20 40 60 80 20 40 60 80 5: 25PSfrag 0.40.50.60.70.8 PSfrag 0.40.50.60.70.8 6: 26PSfrag 0.3 0 .2 0 .3 0 7: 27PSfrag StepsTotal Contacts/Native 20 30 40 50 Figure 8: 28PSfrag Contacts/Native 0 9: 29PSfrag StepsTotal Contacts/Native 20 30 40 50 Figure 1: Minima located by molecular (MD) and ba sin-hopping (BH); the first three proteins are in the training set of the Hamiltonian, wh ile the results for the second three proteins are predictions. MD BH PDB ID 63-428.92 0.39 0.53 -307.96 -435.82 0.39 0.52 -408.482 3icb 75-536.98 0.47 0.52 -390.54 -546.57 0.40 0.49 -518.92 256b 106-735.02 0.42 0.65 -707.51 -737.31 0.37 0.40 -716.51 1uzc 69-457.55 0.36 0.42 -383.08 -458.09 0.37 0.45 -433.41 1bg8 76-469.49 0.25 0.34 -465.19 -468.67 0.36 0.39 -461.50 1bqv 110-737.91 0.21 0.27 -441.92 -764.20 0.23 0.27 -481.22 31Table 2: Contribution of different energy terms in local minima obtain ed using molecular (MD) and basin-hopping (BH). PDBMethod lengthEx Vol Rama Short Range Medium Range Long Range 1r69 MD 639.77-101.64 -128.90 -84.87 -123.28 1r69 BH 632.65-91.06 -125.04 -84.80 -137.57 3icb MD 7511.74-127.70 -177.21 -90.11 -153.69 3icb BH 754.40-115.76 -178.47 -83.37 -173.38 1uzc MD 6910.10-118.66 -134.00 -90.75 -124.24 1uzc BH 692.22-106.20 -137.95 -92.40 -123.77 1bg8 MD 7611.68-136.39 -173.45 -94.40 -76.94 1bg8 BH 762.72-112.13 -151.95 -94.23 -113.09 32
|
0806.3652
|
Michael Prentiss
|
Michael C. Prentiss, David J. Wales, Peter G. Wolynes
|
Protein Structure Prediction Using Basin-Hopping
| null |
J. Chem. Phys. 128, 225106 (2008)
|
10.1063/1.2929833
| null |
q-bio.BM
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Associative memory Hamiltonian structure prediction potentials are not overly
rugged, thereby suggesting their landscapes are like those of actual proteins.
In the present contribution we show how basin-hopping global optimization can
identify low-lying minima for the corresponding mildly frustrated energy
landscapes. For small systems the basin-hopping algorithm succeeds in locating
both lower minima and conformations closer to the experimental structure than
does molecular dynamics with simulated annealing. For large systems the
efficiency of basin-hopping decreases for our initial implementation, where the
steps consist of random perturbations to the Cartesian coordinates. We
implemented umbrella sampling using basin-hopping to further confirm when the
global minima are reached. We have also improved the energy surface by
employing bioinformatic techniques for reducing the roughness or variance of
the energy surface. Finally, the basin-hopping calculations have guided
improvements in the excluded volume of the Hamiltonian, producing better
structures. These results suggest a novel and transferable optimization scheme
for future energy function development.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 23 Jun 2008 11:01:38 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Prentiss",
"Michael C.",
""
],
[
"Wales",
"David J.",
""
],
[
"Wolynes",
"Peter G.",
""
]
] |
2 FIG. 1: Crystal field transition in PrAu 2Si2. Inelas- tic neutron scattering from PrAu 2Si2measured at 1.5 K on IN6 with an incident energy of 3.1 meV. The solid line is a fit to the singlet-doublet crystal field transition at = 0 .7 meV (dashed line) and an elastic peak fr om nuclear incoherent scattering. The shaded area from the transition at 2. Further detai ls of the crystal field refinement are given in Ref. [8]. The the mechanism for induced moment formation, in which interionic exchange coupling, Jex, admixes the excited magnetic doublet into the singlet ground France) on the high spectrometer IN6, using an incident energy of 3.1 meV, at temperatures ranging from 1.5 K to 30 K. In an earlier report, we determined the parameters of the crystal field potential in PrAu 2Si2 [8] and showed that the ground state is a with the first excited level a magnetic doublet at an energy = 0 .7 meV (see Fig. 1). The remaining lev- els are all above 7 meV, so this is effectively a two-level system at temperatures close to the glass discussing the origin of spin glass behaviour, we review what is known about magnetic order in sin- glet ground-state systems. Since the ground state of the isolated ion is non-magnetic, a magnetic moment can only result from an admixture of excited crystal praseodymium ions. There is a considerable body of research on such induced moment systems, both theoret- ical [9, 10] and experimental [11, 12, 13], showing that, for any given value of the low-lying crystal field transi- tion energy (), there is a critical value of the exchange energy (Jex). Below this critical value, the system re- mains paramagnetic ( i.e., a Van Vleck paramagnet) at all temperatures. However, when the exchange is ground state moment forms spontaneously. In a two- level system, this temperature is given in a mean field model by Tc= 2: Phase diagram of PrAu 2(Si1-xGex)2. A self- consistent mean-field calculation of the phase diagram exchange en- ergy,Jexfor energy, = 0 .7meV. The light area represents the region in which moments are induced by the exchange. The red circles are the transition temperature s as a function of germanium concentration, x. The blue circle is the spin glass freezing temperature in PrAu 2Si2. whereais the dipole matrix element coupling the two levels and nis the degeneracy of the excited state. A calculation of Tcas a function of Jexfor = 0 .7 meV andn= 2 is shown in Fig. 2. In most induced moment systems, Tcmarks the Pr 3Tl [11], Pr 3In [14] and PrNi 2Si2[13]. However, in the pres- ence of static disorder, the low-temperature phase could also be a spin glass, as shown by Sherrington [15] in a mean field model developed to explain [16] and PrP 0.9[17]. Sherrington calculated that a sufficiently large distribution of exchange could lead to spin glass freezing. There is a multi- critical point at zJex=z dJex= /(2a2) (2) wherezis the number of nearest neighbours. At larger values of dJex, spin glass order would supercede long- range order. In the case of PrAu 2Si2, for which z=
4,dJexshould be more than twice Jexso requires a high degree of disorder to generate spin glass such strong disorder appears unlikely in PrAu2Si2, we have explored the Sherrington model fur- ther by deliberately disordering the silicon germanium substitution. Krimmel et alhad already found that long-range stabilized at concentrations x >
0.12 [7]. Our inelastic neutron scattering that the energy of the singlet-doublet transition is nearly independent of x(Fig. 3). What does change is the strength of the interionic exchange, Jex. In Figure 2, we estimate the strength of the3 FIG. 3: Crystal field transitions in PrAu 2(Si1-xGex)2. Inelastic neutron scattering from the singlet-doublet tr ansition as a function of germanium doping at 20K (red circles). The so lid line is a fit to two components shown as dashed lines; the inelastic singlet-doublet transition and quasielastic sc attering within the excited doublet. The fitted peaks have be en broadened by a convolution of Lorenzian and Gaussian lineshapes with t he instrumental values of Tcin equation 1. This shows that Jex increases by a factor 4 from x= 0 tox= 1. Germanium doping should therefore be an ideal way of enhancing the exchange disorder that is central to the 4:Broadening of the singlet-doublet crystal field transition . (a) The standard deviation of the of the 0.7 meV transition as a function of ger- manium doping, x, measured at 20 K, i.e., aboveTc. The red dashed line marks the critical concentration separating sp in glass from order. (b) The Lorenzian half - width of the 0.7 meV transition in PrAu 2Si2as a function of temperature. The blue dashed lines are guides to the eye.The most noticeable effect of chemical disorder is the large increase in the energy width of the (Fig. 3). There are two main contributions to the overall width; lifetime broadening, which is Loren- zian in shape and will be discussed later, and inhomoge- neous broadening from the chemical disorder, which has a Gaussian form [18]. If we convolve both the instrumental resolution to produce the fits in Fig. 3, we estimate that the Gaussian width rises ap- proximately linearly with x, forx<=0.2 (Fig. 4a). This shows that there is no correlation between the broadening and the transition to long- range order and confirms that static disorder is not the critical factor determining the occur- rence of spin glass freezing. If static disorder is not responsible for the state, we must seek an alternative explanation, one that should take into account the observation in Fig- ure 2 that spin glass freezing only occurs in proximity to the induced moment phase boundary. We propose broadening of the singlet-doublet the key. Figure 4b shows the temperature de-4 FIG. 5:Dynamic instability of induced moment formation . The mean field calculation of the phase diagram of PrAu 2Si2 and PrAu 2Ge2as a function of crystal field energy for the estimated respe ctive values of Jex. The light areas of induced moment stability. The red circle marks th e measured singlet-doublet transition energy, and the widt h of the blue hatched region corresponds to the relaxational bro adening of the transition. This illustrates that the induce d moment is stable in PrAu 2Ge2because of the strength of the exchange interactions wherea s it is unstable in PrAu 2Si2because of its proximity to the phase of the transition half-width in PrAu 2Si2, which increases from about 0.13 meV at 1.6 K to 0.26 meV at 20 K. The data are consistent with standard models to fluctuations in the field populations, which causes the rapid increase at low temperatures, and conduction electron scattering [19]. The important result is that the width down to the lowest temperature, with the FWHM only falling to a value of 43% of the at the glass transition. This energy broadening will play a significant role in disrupting induced moment formation. Figure 5 shows the complementary phase diagram to Figure 2, in which Jexis fixed to the estimated values in PrAu plotted against . The induced moments are predicted to be stable in both compounds, but, if we superimpose the broadened peaks, we see compound but not in the germanium speaking, the width isproportionalto the inverse lifetime of the excited state and not the lifetime of the induced ground state, but it makes it highly plausible that dynamic fluctuations would disrupt the stability of such moments in PrAu 2Si2, but not in PrAu 2Ge2. In induced moment systems, a precursor of long- range order is the appearance in neutron scattering of a quasielastic central peak close to the wavevector of the ordered phase, which is caused by fluctuating re- gions of short-range magnetic order [20]. For example, in Pr3Tl, the correlation length associated with this central peak diverges as the critical temperature is approached [21]. Our conjecture is that any divergence of the mag- netic correlation length in PrAu 2Si2is suppressed by dynamic fluctuations that limit the lifetime of inducedmoments and so introduce magnetic site and This scenario is similar to the 'avoided critical- ity' discussed in the theory of structural glass transitions by Tarjus et al[22]. In their review, they argue that many glasses are close to a conventional second order phase transition, but that frustration prevents the diver- gence of the correlation length. This would make promising candidates to test their scaling predictions since the degree of frustration can be tuned by varying Jexor with dopant concen- tration or pressure. There is considerable interest in the ways that spin systems respond to the presence of substantial frustra- tion. Historically, this subject was stimulated by the ob- servation of spin glass freezing in disordered alloys and compounds, and has more recently focused on systems where the lattice geometry produces a macroscopic spin configurations. We a new avenue to achieving frustration in systems with neither static disorder nor lattices, through dynamic fluctuations, either thermal or quantum, in proximity to a critical thank Amir Murani and Ross Stewart for scien- tific discussionsand assistancewith the ILL work was supported by the U.S. Department of En- ergy Office of Science, under Contract No. Fischer, K. H. & Hertz, J. A. Spin Glasses Press, Cambridge, 1991). [2] Ramirez, A. P. Geometric frustration: Magic 483 (2003) [3] Krimmel, A. et al.Spin-glass behaviorinPrAu 2Si2.Phys. Rev. B59, R6604-R6607 (1999). [4] S ullow, S. et al.Spin Glass Behavior in URh 2Ge2.Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 354-357 (1997). [5] S ullow, S. et al.Disorder to order transition in the mag- netic and electronic properties of URh 2Ge2.Phys. Rev. B61, 8878-8887 (2000). [6] Ryan, D. H. et al.Site disorder and spin-glass ordering in PrAu 2Si2.J. Appl. Phys. 97, 10A908 (2005). [7] Krimmel, A., et al. The evolution from long- range magnetic order to spin-glass behaviour Phys. Cond. Matt. 11, Goremychkin, E. A., Osborn, R., Rainford, B. D., Adroja, D. T. & Koza, M. Magnetic dynamics of the spin-glass system PrAu 2Si2: an inelastic neutron scat- tering study. J. Magn. Magn. Mater. ,310, 1535 (2007). [9] Grover, B. Dynamical Properties of Phys. Rev. 140, A1944-A1951 (1965). [10] Cooper, B. R. Magnetic Excitons in Real Ferromagnets: Application to Pr 3Tl and fcc PrPhys. Rev. B 6, 2730-2743 (1972). [11] Birgeneau, R. J., Als-Nielsen, J. & Bucher, E. in Ferromagnets. Phys. Rev. Lett. 27, 1530-1533 (1971). [12] Houmann, J. G. et al.Magnetic Excitations and Mag- netic Ordering in Praseodymium. Phys. Rev. Lett. 34, 587-590 (1975). [13] Blanco, J. A., Nicklow, R. M. & Schmitt, D. Paramag- netic excitations in singlet ground state PrNi 2Si2.Phys. Rev. B56, 11666-11672 (1997). [14] Heiniger, F., Bucher, E., Maita, J. P. & Longinotti, L. D. Thermodynamic properties of superconductors con- taining impurities in a crystal-field singlet ground state.Phys. Rev. B 12, 1778-1789 (1975). [15] Sherrington, D. The induced-moment spin glass: theory. J. Phys.C 12, L929-L933 (1979). [16] Sarkissian, B. V. B., and Coles, B. R. Spin-Glass Transitions in Yt-Rare-Earth and Sc- Rare-Earth Alloys. Commun. Phys. 1, 17 (1976). [17] Yoshizawa, H., Shapiro, S. M., Hasanain, S. K., &
Guertin, R. P. Neutron scattering study of the crys- tal electric field levels in an induced-moment Rev. B 27, 448-455 (1983). [18] In principle, there will also be broadening due to the en - ergy dispersion of the crystal field excitations, which is normally modelled with aGaussian lineshape [de Gennes, P. G. Inelastic magnetic scattering of neutrons at J. Phys. Chem. Solids 4, 223-226 (1958)]. This could explain the small Gaussian contribution in PrAu2Ge2(s= 0.13 meV), where there should be no inhomogeneous broadening. No Gaussian component is required to fit the data from PrAu 2Si2, although the Lorentzian widths are verysimilar in foursmaller in the silicide, we believe that its contribution is not Jensen, J., McEwen, K. A. & Stirling, W. G. in the longitudinally polarized antiferromag - netic phase of praseodymium. Phys. Rev. B 35, 3327- 3340 (1987). [20] Lindg@ ard, P.-A. Correlation Theory of Planar Magnets . Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 690-693 (1983). [21] Als-Nielsen, J., Kjems, J. K., Buyers, W. J. L. & Birge- neau, R. J. inan J. Phys. C 10, 2673- 2678 (1977). [22] Tarjus, G., Kivelson, S. A., Nussinov, Z. & Vlot, P. approach of supercooled liquids and the glass transition: a review and critical assessment. J. Phys. Condens. Matter 17, R1143-R1182 (2005).
|
0806.3935
|
Ray Osborn
|
E. A. Goremychkin, R. Osborn, B. D. Rainford, R. T. Macaluso, D. T.
Adroja, and M. Koza
|
Spin Glass Order Induced by Dynamic Frustration
|
5 pages, 5 figures
| null |
10.1038/nphys1028
| null |
cond-mat.str-el
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
Spin glasses are systems whose magnetic moments freeze at low temperature
into random orientations without long-range order. It is generally accepted
that both frustration and disorder are essential ingredients in all spin
glasses, so it was surprising that PrAu2Si2, a stoichiometric compound with a
well-ordered crystal structure, was reported to exhibit spin glass freezing. In
this article, we report on inelastic neutron scattering measurements of the
crystal field excitations, which show that PrAu2Si2 has a singlet ground state
and that the exchange coupling is very close to the critical value to induce
magnetic order. We propose that spin glass freezing results from dynamic
fluctuations of the crystal field levels that destabilize the induced moments
and frustrate the development of long-range magnetic correlations. This novel
mechanism for producing a frustrated ground state could provide a method of
testing the concept of `avoided criticality' in glassy systems.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 24 Jun 2008 17:26:03 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Goremychkin",
"E. A.",
""
],
[
"Osborn",
"R.",
""
],
[
"Rainford",
"B. D.",
""
],
[
"Macaluso",
"R. T.",
""
],
[
"Adroja",
"D. T.",
""
],
[
"Koza",
"M.",
""
]
] |
Attilio Sacripanti Movement and Man at th e end of Random Walks 1 Introduction Fractals in Human Body Physiology Starting from the Mandelbrot work (1977) frac tal is most often associated with irregular geometric objects that display self similarity. In an idealized model, this property holds on all scale, but in real world this is not all truth. In the human body a number of complex anatomic structures display fractal like geometry, that in our special language we will call th em Static, related to the irregular geometric definite form of the structure. Many of these self-similar struct ure serve at least at one f undamental physiologic function: rapid and efficient transport over complex spatially distribut ed structures or organs. Fractal geometry also appears to underlie im portant aspects of heart mechanical functions. and brain structure. Really in the human body a variety of other organs systems contain fractal-like structure that ease information dissemination ( nervous system) or, nutrient ab sorption ( bowel) , all that shows the ubiquity of S tatic fractals in the human body. The fractal concept can be found out, in th e human body, not only as static like the irregular geometric structures, but also in that we will call in our special agreement Kinematics form of fractals. They are connected to body's complex processes that generate irregular fluctuations across multiple time scales A easy understanding of this behaviour can be obt ained by plotting their fluctuations at different time resolutions. 2 Inside the Body 2.1 Fractal Dimension and Self Si milarity and Self affinity Since the fractals occupy an intermediate position between standard geometric subject with integer dimensions, they can be conveniently characterized by their fractal dimension Then an important parameter describing fractal ge ometrical structures is the fractal dimension which generalizes the usual integer valued topological dimension., for each structure it was empirically found that the tota l length L varies as a pow er of the length scale l 2Dl l L-1) ( (1) The parameter D is called fractal dimension of the curve, another way to wr ite the equation (1) is Dl l N l l N l L- = ) ( ) ( ) ( (2) Where N(l) is the minimum numb er of boxes with side l needed to cover the fractal curve. There are several generalization of the fractal dime nsion but it is possible find them in every fractal book. However data are usually a sequence of real numb ers ( time series ) and in this case we may have not information about detail of the problem that we call Kinematics. Assuming that the time series is determined by an unknown deterministic dynamics it os still possible under general conditions , to reconstruct its phase sp ace and analyze the system Kinematics . This is the foundation of the non lin ear time series analysis. In e ffect we can obtain from the dynamical equation of the system an apparent random time series that reveals simple structure of the dynamics when embedded in R2. Fractal dimensions, as seen, can be introduced in various distinct way, each emphasizing a different geometric aspect of the pattern. An important property of a fractal is its self-s imilar nature. In other wo rds if we magnify some fragment of such pattern ( both st atic geometrical or kinematics te mporal ) we would see precisely the same structure reproduced on a new scale. Moreover if the miniature copy may be distorted in other way, for example, somewhat skewed , in this case we call this , self- affinity. A favourite example of self similarity in many textbook is the trajectory of the Brownian Motion of a particle. Although this trajectory is extremely irregular, it displays some remarkable invariance, if we take a small region containing part of the traj ectory, and enlarge it the result would look very similar to the original whole trajectory. In the next figure we can see two example of self-similarity the first geometric the second time related. 2.2 Fractal as Geometrical Self Organization We speak of self - organization or, more exactly, of self organized behaviour if every part of the complex system acts in a well defined way on the given internal or der or configuration. To show in a rigorous mathematical terms the se lf organization , it is possible on the track of Haken, Liupanov and others to develop a very general theory app licable to a large class of different systems comprising not only sociologi cal systems, but also physical, chemical , and biological systems. If the internal organizing force is obeying themselves equations of motion. In the general case of a chemical systems we show that the solution is not linear, if q 1 is a function of the concentration of the ch emical and the effect are q 2 it is possible to write for a self- organized chemical system: 3 3 ) 2 1 1 1 q aq q qg - - =
4) These equations (3) show in very simple way that the self similar structures in the human body could got by nonlinear (Brownian) se lf - organized chemical reactions (4). If the system possesses a macroscopically infinite simal time scale, so that during any dt on that scale all of the reactio n channels fire many more times th an once yet none of the propensity functions change appreciably, we can approximate the discrete Markov process by a continuous Markov process defined by the Ch emical Langevin (SDE) Equation (5) where N 1......N m are M temporally uncorrelated, statistically independent normal variables with mean 0 and variance 1 In the specific structures of the human body like, coronary artery tree or Purkjne cells in cerebellum or in the human heart these Fractal geometrical comes more easily from the corresponding Fokker Plank equation (5): ( 6 ) In several cases like chemical reaction dynamics, a Fokker Planck equation is more easy to obtain than the corresponding Langevin equation. This short speech , show very clearly , that Ra ndom Walk or is continuous limit the Brownian motion are at the basis of th e fractal in human physiology. In the next figures there are shown two well known example of physiological the coronary artery tree, and the Purkinje cells in cerebellum. 3 1 2 1 1 12 1 222 1 2 2 21 ) ( qabq qqbtbq q q gggg - - =- - )( ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( dt t N t X a v dt t X a v t X dt t Xjn jj jn jj j i i
= =+ + = +
() () ) , (1) , f K K q f++ =2) , ( (22 22 2 s u ss uu s u u s s ss u u u us u q qq qq q f bq qqq aq qqq
+
-+ +g g
42.3 Gauss and Pareto Inverse Power Law Chance in physics is connected to the concept of probability, many pr ocess in real life are random and their dynamic evolution is very difficult to understand from a determ inistic point of view. Probability theory born to explain the outcome of games, one of the simplest games is tossing a coin where one can find head or tail. Normally the number of proof are determined and finite ( binomial distri bution) but more known is the limiting case to the infinite proof number , this analysis was performed by Gauss . In definite form we, today, can define the world of Gauss simple as scientific world view, in this ( linear) theory the output is proportional to th e input, the algebra is additive , the presence of simple rules yield simple result of the prob lem, these results are stable, the phenomenon are predictable, their result stable and the final distribution obviously Gaussian . In mathematical form the system evolution is defined by the following equation: (7) )(t XdtdXx m+ =
In this Langevin like equation we can see that the fluctuation is simply additive and the bell curve that define the Gauss distribu tion is the well known simple inverse curve of the normal distribution: (8) De P -2 ) (x xm But a more complex scientific vision is connected to a not well known great It alian scientist, except outside the social and economic world, Pareto. By his law , it is possible to de scribe a more complex scientific vision of the world, this world is non linear, in which small changes may produce divergence in the solutions. It is a multiplicative world , in which simple rules yield complex results, the processes are unstable the predictability is limited and the descrip tion of the phenomena is both qualitative and quantitative, the Pareto di stribution it is also an i nverse power law distribution. In mathematical form the system evolution is defined by the following equation: (9) In this more complex world fluctuation is multiplicative and the Pareto inverse power law distribution satisfies the following form: Dxx Pm+
11) ( (10) t XdtdX(x m+ = X) 5 2.4 Random Walk and its limits If we consider a stochastic process going on time, for example the motion of a particle which is randomly hopping backward and forward; this ex ample is known in the scientific world as Random Walk . If we would know the probability that after n hopp ing the particle will be in a position m , it could be common to connect this proba bility in mathematical discrete form and to write: ) ; ( ) , ( ) ; ( ) , ( ) ; (n l m P l m m w n l m P l m m w l n m P+++ - - = + (11) This discrete probability equation has two very im portant limits in his continuum form. The limit of the random walk with infinitesimal, independent step s is called Brownian Motion. The first form is the limit that explains more carefully the dynamic of a single particle in time and its mathematical form is known as Langevin Equation from the French Scie ntist that proposes it i n1905 (12) ) ( ) () (t t vdtt dvx m+ - =
In which the first term after the equal is the dissi pation suffered by the particle and the second is the stochastic fluctuation applied on it and, if Gaussian type, this dissipati on will be zero in mean over time. The second form, is the limit that take in account more the point of view of the global probabilistic aspect of the random process analyzed in phase space , and its mathematical form is well known as Fokker Planck Equation from the two Germ an Scientists that propose it in 1930. (13) [] ) , ( ) , () , ( 22 t v DPvt v vPv tt v P
+ -- =m In the next figure (showing in it also the self similarity property of this random process) we can see one example of two dimensional Random Walk or Br ownian Motion of a particle, that as before described, it is view in two different conceptual way, by the two previous limit equation. 62.5 Continuum limit of fractional random walks An interesting way to approach complex systems derives also from a special view of the Random walks, it is based to incorporate this complexity in it introducing memo ry in the random walks through fractional differences, this generaliza tion has the same signifi cant limits previously introduced. If we see more carefully at the dynamic aspect of the process it is possible to write a generalized fractional Langevin equation and to in troduce the Fractiona l Brownian Motion. In mathematical form it is possible to write: ( 1 4 ) [] ) In which the first term is a fractional derivative, the second is connected to the initial condition of the process , and the third is always the random force acting on the particle. ()t D xa=G1 () 0 () ( tXt Xta a --- In this case is important to know the mean square displacement of the particle : ( 1 5 ) [] Ht t X t X2 1 22 -a 22 ) ( ) 1 2 () 0 ( ) ( G -= -a ax From this expression it is possible to understa nd, that we are in presence of an anomalous diffusion process, identified by the H parameter usua lly called Hurst parameter , in particular this parameter is time independent , and it describes th e fractional Brownian motion with anti-correlated samples for 0<H<1/2 and with correlated samples for 1/2<H<1 if H is = to 1/2 we can speak of Brownian Motion. If in general H could be a function of time.. In recent time this important extension is called multifractional Brownian motion.. This important generalization come from certain situa tion occurring either in the field of turbulence ( Frisch 1999) or from Biomechanics ( Collins and De Luca 1994) where there are the needs of a more flexible model necessary both: to control locally the dependence structure and to allow the path regularly to vary with time. Pure Brownian motion: next step is unc orrelated with previous step H=0.5 Persistent Fractional Brownian motion: each step is positively correlated with previous step H<0.5 Anti-Persistent Fractional Brownian motion: each step is negatively correlated with previous step H> 0.5 72.6 Time series : some exampl e of internal body answers. any organs inside the human body could be controlled or analyzed by instrumentation which grip characteristics - self-similarity, 1/f-like ke EEG, ECG, have 1/f-like power spectrums (16) nce parameterised by Hurst exponent 0 < H < 1 are simply al basis for analysis and s ynthesis of fractal proce sses in the human body, l of a Healthy Heart, again a Severe nother interesting properties of these signals is th at Fractal Complexity degrades with Disease. M electric time series signals as answers of the specific organ. For example Brain imaging data may generally show fractal spectral properties ( like Pareto inverse power law ). Normally Self-similar or scale-invariant time seri es li with these accepted classification - if a = 0, noise is w h i t e - if a = 2, noise is brown (random walk ) - if a = 3, noise is black (Nile floods) - if 0 < a < 2, noise is pink (J. S. Bach) Fractional Brownian Motion ha s covaria The Hurst exponent, the spectral ex ponent a, and the fractal (Haus dorf) dimension FD, related: 2H+1 = a or 2-H = FD For example classical Br ownian motion has a = 2, H = 0.5 and FD = 1.5 as easily it is seen in the next figure Wavelets are the natur a-f fP they are used in the brain image analysis, but the same method could be applied to the heart analysis. In the first two figures we can see, as example of diseases in white blood cells and circulatory dynamics. In the next four, respec tively, it is possible to see: One example of Severe Congestive Heart Failure, on signa Congestive Heart Failure et the last example is the signal of a Cardiac Arrhythmia, Atrial Fibrillation A 8In the next example it is possible to see a degrad ation of a signal from complexity to a simplifie d the signal; time irreversibility is .7 Myosin (II) Brownian Ratche t and the Muscul ar Contraction ow it experimentally well known that the model of Brownian Ratchet , give us a good explanation s power stroke ( lever arm) model for manipulating a single actin filaments allow to test the lever arm model but the displacement varied signal index of disease. Another hypothesis is connected to the time irreve rsibility of greatest for healthy physiologic dynamics, which have the highest adaptability. Time irreversibility decreases with aging and disease in the first heart rate in the next Human Respiration: Loss of Long-Range (Fractal) Correlations with Age 2 N of the non processive motor , the Myosin II , using the thermal fluctuation and also the energy stored in the ATP structure, can move long the Actin filament Till now two models are in comp etitions the Huxley and Simmon and the Brownian ratchet. The problem is to compute the real Myosin transl ation to evaluate the correctness of the model. The translation caused by the pivoting of the leve r arm would be about 5 nm. New technologies Single Scale Periodicity Uncorrelated Randomness Two Patterns of Pathologic Breakdown ics: Multisca le Fractal Variability Healthy Dynam 9considerably some report have shown myosin displ acement of about 5nm which is consistent with the lever arm model . However others have shown that if myosin is orie nted correctly relative to actin filament axis as in muscle the value inc reases to 10-15 nm out of model predictions. 0-40 nm . ent of individual ore likely that a Myosin head For the ratchet model one problem is that the scale of the motion is smaller than the Brownian motion of microneedles , because the aver age amplitude is between 3 Recently Yanagida et others 2000 , has shown , manipulating a single myosin head and measuring the displacements with a scanning probe. This assay allowed measur em displacements of single myosin head with high resolution. The data sh owed that a myosin (II) head mowed along an actin filament with single mechanical steps of 5.5 nm; groups of two to five rapid steps in succession often can pr oduce displacements of 11 to 30 nm. Similar sub-steps observed are constant in size with the repeat actin monomers (5.5 nm) , independent of force, and because some subsets ar e backward, it is m may step along the Actin monomer re peat by biased Brownian Motion. In the next figure we can see for the Myosin II and V , both the models: .8 On the Boundary odel as Random Walk Model of the Human Skin Permeation was resented by Frash in 2002 in this model the skin normally made by heterogeneous different Normally Effective path length can be define d as the thickness of a homogeneous membrane rties as the skin, and the Effective diffusivity is a diffusivity of a homogeneous membrane having identical permeation properties as the body's skin. 2 In this years a very interesting m p material in different layer, was presented first as homogeneous membrane: made by the same material having identical permeation prope 10 The next figure shows the interesting results an skin Random walk simulations for ma 3 Outside the Body etric fractals and tempor al fractals are widely common inside the human ody, but if we remember that, also at microscopic level, Brownian motion is ubiquitous like in or the seven myosin fam ily, axon transmission command etc. this means at also the basis of the muscular contraction are Brownian, then by scheletric muscles we can go a thermocamera we can see at the equation describing this topological situation in steady state condition, in which the z (t) is d radiation. And DT(t) is the surface body difference ergy e. of this random walk model of the hum ss penetrati on through SC with log Kcor_ lip=0 Dcor/Dlip = 1.0/0.01 As there is shown the geom b DNA, molecular motors f th outside the human body , to fi nd other interesting presence of the Brownian motion, and astonishingly there are many others random process or situations in which the Brownian motion normal, fractal and also multi fractals are present. In the following paragraphs there are show some interesting examples. 3.1 Fluctuation of surface body temperature. If the surface body temperature fluctuation are anal yzed for example by th the random fluctuation of the incident absorbe f temperature depending from the time and the position o (17) Langevin like equation (18) Fluctuation in en ()vv c kT E Et t T hdtt T dc 22) ( ) () (
= -= D +Dz (19). Fluctuation in temperatur () vckTT2 2= D 11 shows th at the surface temperature fl uctuation of the human body is logy of the surface te mperature taken by thermocamera eas y shows that the superficial not controll ed condition, then the e quation considered as a ( 2 0 ) v it is st approximation, to identify a constant number as specific heat for the etter called body's Thermal Inerti a is not constant but a complex he previous But the topo temperature is a function not only of time but also of position. In the next frame the last consideration is very clear If the body makes a motion or works in whole could take this form in his fr ee evolution captured by thermocamera: eally speaking the situation is more complex because the specific heat c is not constant, but 0) ( ) ( ) ( 22
= -D+ +D t d dtt T d dtdchdtt T dcv vz dt R a very complicate function at leas t of time, space, food , fat, .and body dimensions; some works in this field to identify the real shape of this f unction, where made by Sacrip anti and co-workers about ten years ago ( 1995-1997). In fact it is a mistake or a fir human body that is, in reality, a complex engine with continuous production and dispersion of energy ( the metabolic heat). In this case the function c v b function with shape as lennard-Jone s potential. lso h the thermal coefficient is not A really co nstant but is dependence is very more complex because for work like normal activity or sport move ment in not controlled thermal condition, it must satisfy the following experimental Sacripanti's relationship: 12 In the next figures we can see some thermogram s of a judo technique taken by a thermocamera in a very pioneering work of the author and co -wor kers (1989) in which the thermal emission was .2 Human balance Centre Of Pressure ( COP ) vs. Centre of Mass ( CM) ssure) would lie on the ame vertical line COP would coincide w ith the projection of the CM on the ground. te at the point (- z, e) which is the COP. y zz - + = (22) The component F z is the same force as is obtained from th e readings of the force transducers. For a mall deviation around the vertical z axis, we may replace cos a by y/L and in the first connected to the oxygen consumption by means of the previous Sacripanti's relation. 3 In static equilibrium the CM ( centre of Mass) and the COP (centre of pre s This can be illustrated in Biomechanics using a s imple model , the inverted pendulum, Winter 1998, Pedotti 1987 .for the anterior posterior balance. The pendulum rotates around the ankle joint which we take as origin of the Cart esian system if we denote as F the force acting on f oot by force pla The system is described in Newt onian approximation by the equations: F y my=
a z e a cos mgL F F Img F z m- = we may also set F z= mg then the last equation will be : yIy + -ze (23) mgL g dtdOet t TT T Te M Te M h RlSc D S t t TT T hlk Set tT T lkSnt tT T PPvava vs aa a ss s h aa s hT TT T lhS a i a s a bb s 2) 7 . 0 5 . 0 2 . 0 (02 . 02 . 1 233 . 0 8 . 0 2 02 . 02 . 1 233 . 0 8 . 0 24 033 . 0 8 . 0 04 4 1) () ( Re 4) 1 ( 16 . 0) () ( Pr Re 4132 . 0Pr Re6 . - + + ---- ll e ele ese S
13After some easy manipulation and putting the equation in term of the angle p/2- a= th we obtain: 0=
I-a amgL (24) This equation of course describes an unstable situation, the inverted pendulum topples over. owever this clas ure do not explain th e Random Walks characterist ics of quiet standing oordinates of the COP they can be explained by the equation of Hastings & Sugihara 1993 that ere dB is the uncorrelated noise with zero mean Posturogram- Random Walk of the COP coordinates. .3 Multifractals in Hum alking is a very complex volunta ry activity, the typical pattern s hown by the stride interval time echanisms that can be mathematical modelled. e series of human was incorporated into a dynamical model by eed. H sical random walk with a friction term like a Langevin equation: ) ( ) ( ) (t dB dt t rx t dx+ - = (25) H 3 an Gait W series suggest particular ne uromuscular m The fractal nature of the stride tim Hausdorff using a stochastic mode l that was later extended by Askhenazi et others so as to describe the analysis of the gait dynamics during aging. The model was essentially a rando m walk on a Markov or short ra nge correlated chain, wh ere each node is a neural that fires an action potential w ith a particular intensity when interested by the random walker. This mechanism generates a fractal process with a multifractals aspects, in which the Holder time dependent exponent depends parametrically on the range of the random walker's step size. The multifractal gait analysis is also used to study the fractal dynamics of body motion for patients with special agin g problems or diseases, like Parkinson or post-stroke hemiplegic. In the next figures we can see. The variation of the time dependent Holder expone nt , with the walker step size for free p ace and metronome pace at different speed. The different time series produced by free pace and metronome pace at different sp s and th e related fractal values in post stroke and Parkinson patients. The relative acceleration signal 14 4 From Usual Moveme nt to Sport Movement 4.1 Multifractals in Running training The fractal nature of the physiological signals: heart and respiratory fr equencies and oxygen uptake in long distance runs was compared and an alyzed by Billat et others 2001-2002-2004. Today middle and long distance running are characterized by speed variability. The statistics show that if there are considered the last three world record on a middle or long distance running, it can be observed that velocity varies of 5%. In races the variation of the velocity and the choice of the optimal speed , obviously involve a complex interplay between physiolo gical and psychological factors . Multifractal analysis is used in biomechanics of running for classi fying signals which exhibit a rough behaviour . This behaviour is quantified calculating th e holder exponent using multifractal analysis. The following equations give the formula of the exponent: ( 26) 00 0log ) ( ( loglim ) (t P fH- -=)inf 0 t tt ttm t t -- 15 Free and constant he art rate scaling law behaviour Heart rate spectrum and scaling exponent 4.2 Situation Sport In the field of Biomechanics of Sport it is interest ing to classify the sport , in order to study the athletic performance. There are many potential classifications, for example in function of performance energy expenditure, but one of the more useful one's is the biomechanical classification that is in function of the most basic movement performed during the performance. This classification allows to single out the most basic complex movement that must be measured by specific scientific discipline as whole or in step size. In alternative this most basic movement coul d be the goal of an expert group like: Sport Physiologist, Neurologist, Biomechanics, engineering, trainers, technicians. The aim of this classification is to allow to find rightly what kind of specific observational approach must be applied to solve the probl em by mechanical or mathematical models both qualitative or quantitative one's. This classification allows us to group all the sports in four big families. Cyclic Sports There are all the sports in which the basic movement is repeated continuously in time like: gait, running, marathon cycling, swimming, etc. Acyclic Sports There are all the sports in which the basic movement is applied only once in the performance, like : discus, shot put, hammer throw, pole vault, high jump, long jump, triple jump, ski jump, javelin throw, etc. 16 Sport There are all the sports in which two basic move ments are applied alternatively in time, like 110 hurts , 400 hurts, steepchase , golf. Situation Sport There are all the sports with the presence of the adversary. These sports, can be divided in two classes (without and with contact) a nd each class in two sub classes dual sports and team sports. The first dual ones are tennis and ping pong, and as team sports we can find: volleyball, beach volley. The last dual ones, in which athletes can cont act together, are: figh ting sports: judo, boxing, wrestling, karate, etc. and as team sport, socc er, basketball, football, water polo, hockey, etc. The situation sports are sport in which it is not possible to find a repeatable motion pattern for each specific game- For each game the motion in it, is a random process, then there are not basic specific movement during the motion, but it is possible to find these repeatable movements .only during the interaction among athletes. In fact the correct way to analyze such macro phenomena is to study them. in two steps: motion and interaction with basic repeatable movements.. And we can find astonishing that motion for each cla ss of these sports could be associate at one of the previous Brownian Motion that we show. In fact if we consider for each sport the motion basic pattern of a big number of games from the statistical point of view, like cla ssical Gaussian approach, it appear s easily that the motion belongs to the classes of Brownian Motion. 4.3 Dual sport We take in consideration the couple of athletes as a single system, then the motion of the centre of mass system is definite by a push pull random forces. That in formulas can be express as: ( 2 7 ) The system is isolated no external forces less the random push-pull forces then the motion equation will be a Langevin like equation, ( Sacripanti 1992 ) and it is possible to write: ) ( (- =j jt ud ph) (28) t t ) 1 ( F F t t u v ma Fa j j + = - +- + - = = d ) (j m ' Tacking in account the well known work of Smoluchovski on the Brownian Moti on , the Physical that produce the random evolution of the contest allo ws us to obtain the basi c probability of this Markovian process. 17Then for dual sports it is possible to obtain from the transition probability Q the solutions of conditional Probability , which give at infinite time limit the probabi lity to find an athlete between x and x + dx at time t , in mathematical form we can write: ) 1 , (21) 1 , (21) , ( + + - =k m k m m k Qd d (29) that give us the solution ()s s v s vss m n P (30) The experimental proof of this model can be f ounded in some Japanese works , on the world championship of the 1971. In the next figure we can see the summation of motion patterns of 1,2,7, and 12 contests of judo .it is easy to see that the random fluctuation not have a preferential direction over the time this means that and the motion of the Centre of Mass systems is Brownian. 0 '=F 0 '=F 4.4 Active Brownian Motion Motion in team sport is better modelized by the active Brownian motion proposed by Ebeling and Schweitzer tacking in account the oxygen uptake fr om the particles and its consumption from the environment. Particle with mass m, position r, velocity v, self-propelling force connected to energy storage depot e(t); velocity dependent friction g(v), external parabolic potential U(r) and noise F(t) could satisfy the following Langevin like e quation that could be wrote: This is the motion system equation for the active Brownian motion 2() ( ) ( ) ()tmd e t U F (31) t g = - - +vv v v r t=rv From the original work of Ebeling et co-w orkers it is possible to take in account the energy depot: space-dependent take-up q(r), the internal dissipation c e(t), and also the conversion of internal energy into kinetic energy d2 e( t) v2 then the relative equation is: (32) 2 2 () ( ) () ()tet q c et d et - -rv =
Energy depot analysis (for q(r) = q0) that are special constant c onditions, gives the following result, after some calculation, in term of friction non linear coefficient: 18 (33) 20 0 2()dq cdgg=-+2vv This data can be specialized for human people play ing in team games, as it is shown in the following pages. 4.5 Team sport In the first Sacripanti's model, relative to the du al situation sports, the motion of the centre mass of couple of athletes systems is a classical Brownian Motion, that means there is not a special direction in their motion patters. In the case of team sport, the situation is completely different, there is, in mean, a special preferential direction in motion pattern and every single athlete is not in stable equilibrium as the couple of athlete's system. In this case, it is necessary to adopt a differe nt model for the motion, like the active Brownian motion proposed by Ebeling and Schweitzer., to take in account the oxygen uptake from the environment. In this special case it is possible to write for the energy depot variation : ) ( ) ( ) () (2 2t E Kv v t Vdtt dEe- = If we take the hypothesis that the energy E(t) is slowly varying, the previous equation can be simplified on th e basis of the following considerations: ) ( ) (0) ( t V t Vdtt dE
Then it is possible to obtain the special value for the energy namely : )(0t E 2 0KvVEe= the equation achieves a term kE 0v as shown by Ebeling, the friction coefficient in this case will be: 2 00 2 00 0 0vV kvV kEveg eg g g - = - + = (34) considering also the potential interaction agains t the adversary , collision or avoidance we can present the second Sacripanti model. On the basis of the Ebeling and Schweitzer model and the Helbing e quation, the following Langevin type equation proposed in the Sacripanti's second model accounts of: motion, oxygen uptake, kinetic energy from uptake and potential mechanical interaction like collision and avoidance manoeuvres: [] () () ) ( 12cos 11) ( ) ( ) , ( 2 , 1 1 1 2 , 1 2 , 12 , 1 2 , 1 2 , 1 10 2 0 2 , 1 2 , 1 j jBd r t t u e N AN d r k v t e vtmt r vvVma - +- +
+- - ++ - + - +
- =
- dphl ltheg (35) In compact form it is possible to write [] [] ') ( ) 1 ( 2 12 1 F F F F vt t u F F F v ma acc vjj acc v
+ S + S + + - == - +- + S + S + + - = gd g (36) 19 The specific preferred direction in motion patterns of the team sports, could be modellized by the solution model proposed by Erenfest, but with a sp ecial modification made by the author it is possible to modellize the basic probability of this Markovian process ( the game) in function of the special attack strategy utilized. In effect for th e team sports it is possible to write the transition probability Q in function of the attack strategy a. The a parameter can vary from 1 to 5 , with these meanings : 1= lightning attack ; 2= making deep passes; 3= manoeuvring ; 4= attack by horizontal passes; 5= melina The solution of the conditional pr obability P are connected to the limit of mean value in time for finding the athlete between x and x + dx at time t, in formulas: av mavs mRs m n P m s mconk mRk Rk mRk Rm k Q ) 1 (11 ) , [ ( ) (5 1) 1 , (2) 1 , (2) , ( -
- = =<= <= -+-+ -+=
aaa aa ad d (37) In the next four figures it is possi ble to see that, in spite of the pr eferential direction present in each motion pattern, from the statistica l point of view ( summation of se veral motion patters from several games) also in team games the random fluctuati on not have a preferentia l direction over the time, this means that and the global motion also in this case is Brownian. 0 '=F 0 '=F 5 Conclusions From this article it is understandable that all th e self organizing complex systems, especially the biological ones, like the human bod y , are better described by non linear evolutions equations that show themselves in their static, kinematics and dynamics forms. ( fractals ). The only connection among these di fferent aspects is the genera lized Brownian Motion in every known formulation : classic, fractional, active and so on. Its results starting from fractals till to multifractals aspects assure us, at light of our knowledge , that Brownian dynamics is one of the basic mode lling of the mathematical alphabets of Life. 20 6 Bibliography illat V. et al. Fractal analysis of Speed and Physiological Oscillations in long-and Middle Sa J. Fractals in P hysiology Universitade do Porto 2001 modelling animal mobility the social force model for pedestrian tion Physics- Uspekhi 37 (1994) 737-767 ica Rivista s with inte rnal energy depot Traffi c and granular flow rownian particles Stochastic process in Physics Chemistry and ean squa re displacement Condensed matter physics 7 Brownian Mo tion Draft version May 2006 o the kine tic theory of nonlinear Brownian motion and ton University second edition 2001 ople tracking Paper 2002 le robot localization and mb tissue perfusion during loading Journal of rehabilitation patients with Parkinson's disease J ournal of neural body motion in post stroke hemiplegic patients during walking 97 (2000) 9357-9359 es Journal of theoretical , non linear families of Markov process and nonlinear Fokker-Planck cular motor movement and chemomechanical energy ts 2002. 1-583 g pnas 99 tion of multifractional Brownian motion Paper 2004 rocess Statistics and B distance Running Effect of training Int. Juor. Of Computer Scien ce in Sport Vol 2 (2003) 16-30, Gaspard P. Brownian motion,dyna mical randomness and irreversibil ity New Juor. of Physics 7 (2005)77 . Marques de Ebeling, Schweitzer Active Brownian Particle s with energy 49 (1999) 17-29 Lakoba et al. Modifications of evolution Simulation 1 ( 2005) 339-352. Klimontovich Yu. Nonlinear Brownian Movimiento browniano activo mediante velo cidades de fisica 49 (2003) 429-438. Schweitzer Active Brownian Berlin 2000 161-172. Schweitzer Active motion of B Biology Springer Berlin 2000 97-107. Ebeling Nonlinear Brownian motion m (2004) 539-550 Morters & Peres Rudnick Lectures on Random walks 2001 Ebeling et al. Klimontovich's cont ributions t new developments journal of physics 11 (2005) 89-98 Nelson Dynamical Theories of brownian motion Prince Faris Lectures on stochastic processes 2001. Bruce&Gordon Better Motion predicti on for pe Montemerlo & Wittaker conditional particles filter for simultaneous mobi people tracking IEEE (ICRA) 2002 Silver-Torn Investigatio n of lower li research and development 35 (2005) 597-608 Sekine et al Fractal dyn amics of body motion in engineering 1 (2004) 8-15 Akay et al Fractal dynamics of Journal of neural engi neering 1 (2004) 111-116 Yanagita & Iwane A large step for Myosin pnas Verdier Rheological properties of living materials from cells to tissu medicine 5 (2003) 67-91. Frank Stochastic Physica A 331 (2004) 391-408. Quian The mathematical theory of journal of mathematical chemistry 27 (2000) 219-234- Borg Review of nonlinear methods and modelling 1 Biosignal projec Scafetta et al. Holder exponent spectr a for human gait Physica A 328 (2003) 56 Goldberger et al Fractals dynamics in physiol ogy: alterations with disease and agin (2002) supplement 1 Coeurjolly et al. identifying the multifractional func tion of a Gaussian p probability letters 39 (1998) 337-345. 21Lauk et al Human balance out of equilibrium nonequilibriunm st atistical mechanics in posture control Physical review letters 80 (1998) 413-416. Maciejewski et. Alt . The impact of autonomus robots on crowd behavior Colorado state university 2003 Belair et alt. Behavioral dynamics for pedestrian final draft 2003 Sacripanti et Al. Serie - Valutazione del costo energetico degli sport remote sensing: Progress report Ndeg 2 operativa ENEA-RT- INN / 90/06 Sacripanti. Serie - Valutazione del costo energe tico degli sport di combattimento in remote sensing: Progress report Ndeg 3 Teoria biomeccanica della competizione. ENEA-RT- INN/ 90 / 07. Sacripanti et Al. Serie -Valutazione del costo en ergetico degli sport di combattimentoin remote sensing: Progress reports Ndeg4/5. Stima dell'effetto schermo del judogi ENEA-RT- INN / 91 / 50. Sacripanti et Al. Serie - Valutazione del costo energetico degli sport di combattimento in remote sensing:Progress report Ndeg 6 Valutazione dell'effett o schermo del judogi ENEA-RT-INN /91/ 51 Sacripanti, Dal Monte, Rossi. Serie - Valutazione de l costo energetico degli sport di combattimento in remote sensing: Progress report Ndeg 7. Man-environment , heat - exchange equations a new thermodynamic approach Eighth meeting of the European So ciety of Biomechanics Rome 92 ENEA-RT- INN/ 92/ 08. Sacripanti et Al. Serie - Valutazione del costo en ergetico degli sport di combattimento in remote sensing: Progress report Ndeg 8. New trends in the judo and wrestling biomechanics research Eighth meeting of the European Society of Biomechanics Rome 92 ENEA-RT- INN/ 92/ 09 Sacripanti et Al. Serie - Valutazione del costo energetico degli sport di combattimento in remote sensing: Progress report Ndeg 9 Physical work and thermal emission X International Symposium of Bi omechanics in Sport - Italy 1992 ENEA-RT- INN/ 92/ 1 Sacripanti, Dal Monte, Rossi. Serie - Valu tazione del costo energetico degli sport di combattimento in remote sensing: Progress report Ndeg 10 Man-Environment heat exchange equation, evolution and improvement ENEA-RT- INN/ 93/ 32 Sacripanti et Al. Serie - Valutazione del costo energetico degli sport di combattimento in remote sensing: Progress report Ndeg 11 Apparato sperimentale e procedura esecutiva ENEA-RT- INN/ 94/ 15 Sacripanti Biomeccanica del Judo ed mediterranee 1989 Sacripanti Biomeccanica degli Sport ed il vascello 2004 Mc Garry Sport competitions as a dy namical self organizing system Jouof sport science 20 2002 Pers et alt Errors and mistakes in aut omated player tracking computer video workshop 2003 . Bloomfield et alt. Temporal pattern analysis and his applicability in soccer The hidden structure of interaction IOS Press 2005 Yamamoto et al On the fractal nature of heart rate variability in humans: effects of vagal blockade The American physiology society 1995 Tempaku Random Brownian motion regulates th e quantity of human i mmunodeficiency virus type1 (HIV-1) attachment and inf ection of target cell Journal of health science 51 (2005) 237-241. Deligneres et al. Time interv al production in tapping and osci llatory motion Human movement science 23 (2004) 87-103 Burggren & Monticino Assessing phys iological complexity the jour nal of experimental biology 208 (2005) 3221-3232. Westfreid at al Multif ractal analysis of heartbeat time series in human race Applied and computational harmonic analysis 18 (2005) 329-335. Frasch, A Random Walk Model of Skin Pe rmeation, Risk 2002 A. Schatzlein, G. Cevec. Non-uniform cellular packing of the stratum corneum and permeability barrier function of intact skin: a high-resolution confocal lase r scanning microscopy study using highly deformable vesicles (Transfersomes). 1996 22
|
0806.3946
|
Attilio Sacripanti
|
Attilio Sacripanti (ENEA, University of Tor Vergata)
|
Movement and Man at the end of the Random Walks
|
22 pages, 48 figures presented at International conference Movement
as Prevention and Health (MPH) University of Rome Tor Vergata Conference
site: Villa Mondragone 25/27 September 2006
| null | null | null |
physics.med-ph physics.gen-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this paper, it is presented the well known aspect of non linearity of
internal human body structures. Similarity on the basis of the Fractional
Brownian Motion from the static ones, as the geometrical fractals like the
Intestine and placenta linings, Airways in lungs, Arterial system in kidneys
and so on. To the kinematics ones, as the temporal fractals like Heart beat
sequences, Electroencephalograms, Respiratory tidal volumes, DNA sequences
mapping and so on. But this internal well known knowledge is astonishing
extendible from the internal, through the Brownian basis of the muscular
contraction, to the macroscopic external human movements, like the orthostatic
equilibrium, gait, running training, judo contest and soccer, basketball,
football or water polo games, by means of the ubiquitous continuous presence;
the Brownian Dynamics.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 24 Jun 2008 18:32:10 GMT"
}
] | 2008-06-25T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Sacripanti",
"Attilio",
"",
"ENEA, University of Tor Vergata"
]
] |
In this way the two athletes are blended in only one system in stable equilibrium ; this system moves itself by the third principle of dynamics. The ground reaction forces will be, in this case, the resultant of overall pus h/pull forces produced by both athletes. B) Couple of Athletes open system . The two biomechanical athletes have no fixed c ontact point , and to keep their condition of unstable equilibrium , they will be at best like a simple inverted pendulum model ( Pedotti 1980 ) (4) while friction will made motion possibl e by the third principle of Dynamics. Having defined the Couple of Athletes open and closed systems and its components i.e. the Athletes, the biomechanical analysis of c ontest dynamics will be st udied in terms of system motion and mutual interaction, which acco rding to the principl e of the overlap of effects wd be able to be seen separately in order to obtain an easier and more understandable solution . The mechanics of competition ( not r epeatable situations wh ich happen randomly with small probability of repetiti on on a very large number of contests) cannot be analysed with the deterministic tools of Newton 's mechanics. In effect it would be more useful to study the problem according to statistical mechani cs to obtain verifiable ex perimental results. III MUTUAL DISTANCE AS MAIN PARAMETER OF CONTEST DYNAMICS The study of Couple of Athletes open system easily show s us the main parameter which allows us to classify usefully the mutual position of bodies. The relative distance between th e two Athletes, the attack strategy and the execution of techniques are directly dependent on this parameter. It is useful to classify three kids of dist ances which need three di fferent biomechanical approaches. 1) Long distance ( Karate). It is the distance from which the unarmed Athlete will effect a successful kick attack. It is the main distance in Karate contests 2) Average distance ( Boxing ). It is the distance from whic h it is possible to box 3) Short distance ( Wrestling ). It is the distance from which it is possible to gr ip or grasp the adversar y. In this condition the Athlete changes his position from unstable to stable . Grips are the main tools to transfer the energy to the adversary both in opposition and in helping the throwing techniques. IV REFERENCE SYSTEMS AND INTERACT ION : DEFINITION AND CLASSIFICATION After defining the physical system and the main interaction paramet er and specifying the boundary conditions connected to system dynamics, the next step is to define the reference systems in which to describe motion and interaction. Obviously the first reference system will be put in the gym ( a Cartesian reference system solid with the gymnasium walls ) it is in a good approssimation: the inertial reference system or the laboratory reference system. The second reference system, useful for the simp lified study of mutual interaction will be put in the movable barycentre of Couple of Athletes open or closed system; this reference system will be called, C entre of mass reference system. In all contest sports: interaction can be seen, in the function of mutual distance, as a continuous shortening and lengthening of this parameter, during contest time; plus a few physical specific mechanisms to win for each sports. These mechanisms can be classified, for contest sports, in two categories.. A) Couple of Athletes closed system Winning mechanisms able to throw the adv ersary by two physical principles. 1) application of a couple of forces; 2) applicat ion of a physical lever ( Wrestling, Free stile, Greco -Roman stile, Canary st ile, Lion stile, Judo, Sam bo, Sumo, Koresh, ... ). So interaction happens by finding a contact poi nt. In the case of the second mechanism , the stopping point, the use of unbalance is necessary. B) Couple of Athletes open system Winning mechanisms able to defeat the advers ary following the impact theory by direct strokes to the conventional or sensitive points of the body (Boxing, Karate, Kick boxing, Tae Kwon do, Kung fu, Savate, Kendo, Fencing, ... ) So interaction happens by shor tening the distance since it bec omes useful to stroke the adversary. V POSSIBLE CLASSES OF POTE NTIALS : A GENERAL STUDY In each contest sports, interaction is founded on two separate phases, a common one (shortening of mutual distance ) and a specif ic one ( application of permitted ways to seek advantage: strokes or throwing mechanisms ) T he common part is comparable to a classic two body problem in central fiel d .From mechanics we remember: a) instead of studying the motion of two athletes, it is possi ble to analyse the equivalent more simple motion, in the centre of ma ss reference system, of only one sham athlete gifted with a reduced body mass 2 121 m mmm
+ b) In the centre of mass reference system, motion can be described by a two dimensional trajectory on the ground (mat) maki ng use of the coordinates: r e th. C) Instead of solving the integral of motion by differential equations, it is better to use for the solution the Lagrangian of the system that is potential and kinetic energy. To single out the general class among many potentials which will describe the common part of interaction, it is better to study t he simplest kind of motion with constant angular momentum. In this case the bi-dimensional trajectory can be treated as one-dimensional because 2mrl=th and the interaction force F(r) will be function of distance between sham athlete and Centre of mass of Couple of Athletes syst em, that is of t he sham potential ()21'mrrVV+= with ()aKr rV--= and the a parameter a will take int egral values 0,1,2,3, ... The sham potential V'(r) will belong to one of subs equent classes of attractive potentials Fig.( 1 ). Fig 1 attractive sham potentials This example shows very clearly that onl y potentials as V'(r 1) will be useful to describe the common part of interaction during contest. VI POTENTIAL AND INTERACTION IN THE CENTER OF MASS REFERENCE SYSTEM The general potential which will describe the interaction will have the general exponential form: aar rV2'--+= From previous considerations, it is possible to declare that the common part of interaction can be described by the cu rves family showed in a generalised Morse's potential : () ()( )rora rorae eDV-- --- = 22obviously V' is a particular expansion of this expression. The specification of a general form of interaction pot ential, is able to give us a lot of useful information: 1) r o is the equilibrium distance (g rip distance in wrestling ). 2) D is the mechanical potentia l energy in the equilibrium poi nt equal to mechanical mean energy valued in terms of oxygen consumption as eO2. 3) It is possible to evaluate the constant a expanding the potential near the minimum point. We get in this case the connection with the harmonic term of expansion ()c o E rr Da =-2 2or DE Lac 1= To know the potential let us go back to the Algebraic expression of force ()ar are eaD maF22- -- == To single out the comm on part of the interaction as a two body problem in the central field allows us to utilize an important result of classi ca1 physics about the mean time value of a few variables ( Viri al's Theorem ) ; both for motion and interaction it guarantees that, if the generalized force F is a sum of friction and central forces , the mean kinetic energy of the system in time is i ndependent from friction forces : V O V OerrVT -=--=2 21 2/1 ee Where e1 is the global efficiency of contest, always smaller than e. The conservation of mean mechani cal energy in time, on the basis of Virial's Theorem, allows us to obtain the expressi on of shifting velocity (2). () -- =- - ar are eDdrO mr222 2122 th te& The limit for r - O of this expression allows us to calculate the attack velocity, at the instant of impact (r=O) which can be express ed (3) with regard to attacking oxygen consumption: mO mD rr22 2 0lim e==-& VII MOTION IN THE LABORATORY REFERENCE SYSTEM A) Couple of Athletes closed system. B) Couple of Athletes open system. A) Couple of Athletes closed system. This system achieves random shifting by c hanging couple velocity direction in push/pull forces produced by Athletes themselves to gener ate specific situation in order to apply winning techniques. In this case random means that statistically there is not a preferent ial shifting direction. The motion can be accomplished by friction between soles and ground on the base of the IIIdeg principle of Dynamics; the general equation descr ibing the situation is the IIdeg Newton's Law ma= F . In the generalized force F will appear both friction and push/pull contribution. The friction component is propor tional to the velocity F a = -mn . The changing in velocity and direction produced by push/pulls are created by resultant of force developed by the two Athletes themselves. They are, with regard to the whole contest time , acting impulses in very short intervals of time. Consequently the single variation can be de scribed by Dirac's of the impulse u from the elementary force, where u means the mechani cal momentum variation Dv m. The resultant will be the algebraic sum of the push/pull forces (8), in which the random changes in direction will be evalua ted as the variation ( +- 1) j of the elementary force. The whole force is : () ( ) () ' 1 F tjt utj j =+-- =d ph Then the generalized force is F = F a + F' and the general equati on of the motion has the well-known structure of Langevin's Equation: ()() ' 1 FF ttmuvmva j j j +=-+-+-=dm& Because the push/pd resultant is random it is not possible to forecast the trajectory in only one contest, but the statistical analysis of many contests will be able to have information about the system behaviour. 1) Because the direction changes have the sa me probability, that is, over many contest there is not a preferred dire ction, then the mean value of F' in a random sequence of directions will be zero ( F' ) = 0 2) The mean over time and directions of two push/pull forces product give us information about force variation in time (8): () () () ()() () ()j oj j j j tttmuttttmutFtF ' ' 1 1 '' '22 22 - =--+-+-= d dd Checking these conditions allows us to see easily that the mo tion of the Athletes can be described in terms of statistical mechanics as Brownian motion over an unlimited surface. The motion equation can be solved ( with const ant variation methods ) The solution states that the system velocity is directly propor tional to push/pull impulse u and inversely proportional to total mass m, t hen the biggest Athletes move themselves, statistically, at less velocity. ()mutv In these cases it is correct to evaluate only mean values of the quantit ies, for example the correlation function ()()'tvtv gives us the delay time of measurable velocity variation (8) The solution is ()()() ()
- =+- -- ' ' 2'ttmttme eCmtvtvm m m if we think of steady state (t+t')>> (t-t') the result is the delay time is mmt=* directly proportional to the Athletes' ma ss (8). If we put zero as the starting speed then it is possible to evaluate the kinetic energy mean value of more contests (8):
-=- tme Cmvmm m2 2 214 2for t- . This expression speedily t ends to zero and then it is possible to write the steady state relationship Cmvm m4 22 2= The C constant can be evaluated by a modifi ed Einstein's method for the classic Brownian motion. Therefore if we think that the Athlete biosystem show s one of the lowest working efficiency or 1 2ppe=OL, then (8) it is possible to write 22 2 4 2O Cmvmem== or 2 24OmCem= From this equation it is possible to get (8) th e square momentum is di rectly proportional to friction and to overa ll oxygen consumption 2 024 Ot uem= , while the correlation velocity function takes (8) the value from which the speedy fluctuation is inversely proportional to mass m , directly proportional to oxygen consumption and independent of friction. B) Couple of Athletes open system . We have proved that the bo und system, on an unlimited surfac e, moves with a Brownian motion; on the contest surface it is reasonable to think, for the overlap of effects, that the motion would be shaped by reflections from the surface edges (expressible as central field) plus the Brownian motion previously fo unded. Or alternatively the motion belongs to the class of generalized Brownian motions (2). In the case of Couple of Athletes open s ystem, the whole is given by two subsystems parted ( the Athletes ) which ar e in unstable equilibrium. If the biomechanical athlete is modelized as the classic model of inverted pendulum, then the oscillations will be the best way to struggle with gravity force. In this case , with this contrivance, the two biomechanical athletes will be regarded, with good approximation, in stable equ ilibrium; so to the whole Couple of Athletes open syst em can be extended the met hodology first applied to the Couple of Athletes closed system ( with however, bigger mutual distance and with oscillations annulling the gravity force ). Also in this condition the whole system mo ves, in the laborator y reference system, as generalized Brownian motion. In the laboratory reference system, the equat ions of the motion of a single athlete considered as inverted pendulum have been tak en from several authors ( Pedotti 1980, Mc Ghee 1980, Mc Mahon 1981 ). Narrowing our study, for simplicit y, to the bi-dimensional path on the ground and not to the tri-dimensional in space, and remembering the Brownian shifting (3) this relation will be valid : t rddt r1 22===thth or 224rdvp= It is possible to understand the physical me aning of this frequency in the limits r - and r- 0, in this way we can deduc e that it is the contact freque ncy ( or attack frequency ) or as function of measurable parameters: rv m = VIII EXPERIMENTAL CHECK ( VERIFICATION- VALIDATION) The results about shifting trajectories study for Couple of Athletes system during contest, analysed by statistical mech anics techniques concerning random situations not repeatable in time, with a definite probability frequency, could appear only a theoretical exercise if they were not verified and validated with experimental results. The next illustration shows dromograms from judo (1) championships which took place in Japan in 1971 and it is evident that ther e is not a preferential direction in push/pull forces over time. ( Fig. 2 ) Fig 2 1,2, 7, 12 j udo contest motion patterns in 1971 Japan championships. IX PHYSICAL PRINCIPLES AND INTERACTION TRAJECTORIES Couple of Athlete closed system. The interaction second face was solved by the author in the year s 1985-1987 and led to the corollaries, about the use of forces in s pace, (static conditions) , with the analysis of flight paths and symmetries ( dynamic conditions ) and with the identif ication of the basic physical principles of throwing techniques . Using Galileo's principle of relativity it will be possible to extend the validity of the known results from static to dy namic conditions of contest. 1) Couple of forces techniques For this class of techniques , we will apply the prin ciple of simultaneous actions; then the problem of body motion in space can be simplif ied in the summation of a flat motion in sagittal or frontal plane, plus an ev entually simplified motion in space. So the first motion, produced by t he application of the principal couple of forces, is a rotary flat motion independent of gravity force. While the second ( applied in another group of the same clas s of techniques ) is the summation of motions produced by gravity force plus a secondary couple of forces, acting in a perpendicular plane to the gravitational field. In terms of variational analysis the first motion flight path is obtained from the extremals of general function. () dx y y Ix xr2/12 12'1+= for r=-1 with solutions x=a- b sin th e y = c - b cos th in this case the external is the circle arc of radius b an d centre B ( a,c). While the second flight path is, with good approximation, th e parabola arc with vertex V coincident with the rotation centre B of pr incipal couple of forces Fig 3,4,5 Fig 3,4,5 Technique of c ouple of forces -Uchi Mata 2) Techniques of physical lever. Considering the biomechanical athlete as a rigid cylinder, applying the stopping point ( fulcrum), then the starting impulse must be regarded as necessary and sufficient to perform the unbalance, that is to shift the baricentral perpendicular ou t from the support base, while it sets to the adversary's body a rotational momentum under the condition Mgl I zz 2212ppo So the athlete can be assimilated to a symmetric heavy top, falling down in the gravitational field. Because the starting impulse is acting during a short time lapse, the trajectory, in a force field, is given by the solution of the variational principle : () -2 12 1,t tj jq qj dtqpH dqpd d In our case the external field is conservative , then it is possible to apply the principle of minimum action, that is: () -D=D=D= D2 11 tt dt dt dtqp tt The body will go along the path of the least transit time. The Jacobi form of the principle of minimum action gives us other information: () dtr rrr t The p parameter measures the length of the path and makes sure the body will go along a geodetic of a special symmetry. In this case it is possible to show that it is going along a spiral arc , geodetic of a cyli ndrical symmetry. Fig 6,7 Fig 6,7 Technique of lever Tai Otoshi X Probabilistic analysis of interaction Couple of Athlete open system. In the study of the specific interaction fo r the Couple of Athlet es open system, the attack mechanics guarantees that there are only two solutions: to be successful or not , faced to a defence which is effective or not. Then comes the question of what probability of success have defence and attack, and how can they be connected whit each ot her by the probabilistic analysis. In the first approximation direct attacks, t hat is without shams or combinations are independent. That means we have a series of Bernoulli tries. By applying the binomial distribution to the attack, the probability of having 2 successes every 10 tries over the 12 possibilities of attacks is : 10!2!10210 2
=
-
-=- A While the defence probability to have 2 success ev ery 10 tries over the 8 kind of defence is: ()05.081181 !2 10!2!10210 2
=
-
-=- ppP The mathematical probability of 2 successes every 10 direct attacks is 16% while 2 every 10 defence is 5% . So this case the probabilistic analysis shows us that in Couple of Athletes open system, attack will be easier and better than defence. XI CONCLUSIONS The biomechanical analysis of contest sports competitions has given us some very important results: a) the motion of Couple of Athletes system is a Brownian generalized motion; b) interaction between athletes can be subdivid ed into two steps: the first is common to all contest sports (shortening of mutual distance ); the second step is peculiar to each sport. Ex. long distance sports: direct blows to sensible or conventional body points ; very short distance sport: tools for throwing the adver saries by two physical principles ; c) the kinetic energy of t he athlete depends on oxygen c onsumption and the athlete's efficiency; d) The capability of changing velocity does not depend on friction; it is inversely proportional to the mass and directly dependent on oxygen consumption and efficiency; e) the variation time of ve locity is dependent on the ma ss and inversely proportional to friction; f) the attack velocity at contact is given by square root of double of oxygen consumption multiplied by efficiency divided by body or limb mass; g) the measure of variation of push/pull force is related to the measure of the friction in direct proportion to oxygen consumption; h) the flight path of th rown athlete is a geodetic of thre e specified symmetry or their linear composition; i) the couples of forces techniques are independe nt of friction; it is possible to use them whatever the shifting velocity is; j)the physical lever techniques depend on friction ; that means it is possible to use them only for stopping the adversary; k)the techniques of couple of fo rces are energetically the best; l) among the techniques of physical le ver, the maximum a m are energetically the best; m) attack frequency is directly proportional to impact velocity and indirectly to mutual distance; n) attack frequency is directly proporti onal to kinetic energy for time and inversely to mass and square of distance; o) the direct attack blow has a success pr obability of 66% compared to defence . XII REFERENCES (1) Y. Matsumoto &Y. Takeuchi & R.Naka mura-Analytical studies on the contest performed at the all Japan j udo championship tournament KdK Report V Tokyo Japan 1978 (2) A.S. Mikhailov & A.Yu. Loskutov- Fund ation of Synergetics II ( complex patterns) Springer -Verlag Berlin 1991 (3)A. Pasculli & A.Sacripanti -T eoria biomeccanica della com petizione di karate ENEA /RT in print 1996 (4) A.Pedotti - Motor coordination and neurom uscular activities in human locomotion - Biomechanics of motion Ed. Springer Verlag N.Y. USA 1980. (5) R. Petrov- Lutte libre et lu tte Greco-Romaine Ed. Fila 1984. (6) A.Sacripanti - Biomechanical classification of judo throwing techni ques ( Nage Waza). Int. Simp. of Biomechanics in Sport Athens Greece 1987. (7) A.Sacripanti - Biomechanical classification of wrestling standing techniques. Int. Simp. of Biomechanics in Spor t Bozeman USA 1988. (8) A.Sacripanti - Valutazione del cost o energetico degli sport di combattimento in<<Remote Sensing>> Report 3 Teoria biome ccanica della competizione ENEA/RT/INN/ 1990/07 (9) A.Sacripanti - Biomecanica do judo competiqao aos metodos de treino nas diversas estrategia de competiqao I simp. de ciencias de disporto aplicadas ao judo Lisbona Portougal l991 (10) A.Sacripanti - Fondamenti di biome ccanica Ed. Filpjk Roma Italia l995 (11) A.Sacripanti - Biomeccanica degli sport di combattimento Ed. Filpjk Roma Italia l996
|
0806.4069
|
Attilio Sacripanti
|
Attilio Sacripanti (ENEA; University of Tor Vergata, Rome)
|
Contest dynamics general biomechanical theory of contest sports
|
14 pages 7 figures ENEA technical report 1997
| null | null |
ENEA-RT- INN 97/25
|
physics.gen-ph physics.class-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this report it is approched the Contest dynamics as mathematical theory,
therefore applicable to all contest sports. Starting with the physical
definition of Athlete and Couple of Athlete systems and after singling out the
interaction basic parameter, there are analyzed the classes of possible
potentials describing the interaction. At the end there are specified the
physical bases of mutual interaction between athletes and the trajectories of
flight motion. All the matter will be connected to measurable quantities or
parameters useful for researchers and trainers.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 25 Jun 2008 10:58:58 GMT"
}
] | 2008-06-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Sacripanti",
"Attilio",
"",
"ENEA; University of Tor Vergata, Rome"
]
] |
This classification collects the throwing techniques under two groups; First-Class of turning Uke's body around an obstacle (hip, leg, etc.) - Sec ond- Class of striking Uke 's legs. This historical survey through vari ous classifications introduces the a ttempt to rationalize the matters in a scientific way, looking for the basi c physical principles of Nage Waza. II) BIOMECHANICAL CLASSIFICATION A biomechanical analysis of judo th rowing techniques must be dealt with in the following steps: firstly by simplification and se condly by generalization. As a simplification principle for th e problem of classes of forces i nvolved, at first we can use the differential method pointed out by dr. Kano: subdivision of the thro wing movement in three steps: 1deg Tsukuri (preparatory movements aimed at throwing out of balance Uke's body); 2deg Kuzushi (the final unbalancing action); and 3deg Kake (execution of movements aimed at thro wing), and later we analyse the motion of Uke's body cutting out secondary forces. Then we generalize the classes of forces, putting out the inner physic al principles of standard judo throwing techniques. This method, applied to Nage Waza. is able to group 77 throwing techniques (40 Kodokan go kyo and 37 others) under two dy namic principles only. It is correct to remark that this is one of many possible biomechanical classifications, and we select it for its valuable simplicity and immediateness. 2It comes very handy to find the <<General Principles, first to define two coro llaries on direction of forces (Static Analysis), and then to analyze Uke's body flight pa ths (Dynamical Analysis) and their symmetries. STATIC ANALY SIS Principium of resolution of forces. These two corollaries determine the w hole directional problem of static use of forces to execute throws. UNBALANCES 1) Forces are effective and can be applied, on the horizontal plane, on the w hole round angle (360deg). Unified under these terms are the biomechanical problems of forces employed for unbalancing Uke's body. (Tsukuri-Kuzushi steps). THROWS 2) Forces are effective and can be applied, on the vertical plane, near ly for the width of a right angle (90deg). Determined under these terms are the biomechanical problems of forces employed for throwing Uke's body. (Kake step). Real limits of throwing forces can be obtained with an angle of nearly 45 degrees, up or down a horizontal line, because the resistan ce caused by Uke's body structure or by force of gravity, beyond these angles, allows throwi ng again but with more waste of energy. DYNAMICAL ANALYSIS Principium of composition of forces - Study of flight paths and its symmetries If in the space the composition of forces obeys, at the same time, the previous static two corollaries the solution of dynamical problem (considering time) goe s through the study of flight paths and their symmetries. Trajectories along which Uke's body moves during flight following throwing can be collected under two simple types or their composition: Circular paths and Helicoidal paths. I) CIRCULAR PATH: SPHERICAL SYMMETRY For throwing techniques in which the limbs of Uke's body follow a circular path 3 the radius of circumference coincides with the dist ance r from the rotation axis of inertial momentum. These techniques have spherical symmetry and circumfere nce that is the geodeti c line of sphere (the shortest line between two points) is the path of minimum work th en the trajectory of least waste of energy which extreme parts of Uke's body can cover. II) HELICOIDAL PATH: CYLINDRICAL SYMMETRY For throwing techniques in which Uke's body follows a helicoidally path the be nding radius of helix is proportional to distance r from the ro tation axis of inertial momentum. These techniques have cylindrical symmetry and the helix that is the <<geodetic line>> of right cylinder is also the path of minimum work or the trajectory of least waste of energy which Uke's body can cover. If we think both ,of the two corolla ries on direction of forces (Static Analysis) and of the study of trajectories followed by Uke's body (Dynamical Analys is) it is possible to state the two dynamical principles of biomechanical clas sification, which show the inner mechanisms of throwing techniques. A)Techniques where Tori makes use of a couple of forces for throwing Uke. B) Techniques where Tori makes use of physical lever for throwing Uke. Movements, that seemingly make different th rowing techniques, in appearance but non in biomechanical essence, can be collected in Tsukur i - Kuzushi stages and other preparatory actions (Taisabaki, etc.). We think this classification, grounded on clear scientific crite ria, is very suitable to give an easier understanding of physical principles linking judo throwing techniques. A) Techniques of couple of forces. In the first group, we found al1 throws produced by sweeping away legs and pulling or pushing Uke's body in the opposite direction simultaneously. The techniques of Group of couple of forces can be classified by parts of Tori's body which apply the couple of forces on Uke's body. 4Namely: two arms, arm and leg, trunk and leg, trunk and arms, two legs. (Tab. 2). This biomechanical classification is able to show new likeness not evident in standard techniques, e.g. the asymmetry face-back of human body explains astonishing examples of bi omechanical likeness: O Soto Gari and Uchi Mata are the same tech niques applying the couple of forces on Uke's body. It is very interesting to note that most throws of couple of forces (the ones applied by Tori standing on one leg) can be led to only one Tori's basic actio n: rotation on coxo-femoral articulation with three degrees of freedom each of it, lying into the three symmetry planes of the human body. First: rotation of trunk-leg set on coxo-femoral articulation around a horizontal lateral-latera l axis of rotation. ( motion lying in the sagittal plane ) 5 Second: rotation of trunk-l eg set on coxo-femoral articulation around a horizontal antero-posterior axis of rotation. ( motion lying in the frontal plane ) Third: rotation of trunk-leg set on coxo-femoral articulation around a vertic al axis of rotation. (motion lying in the transverse plane) This points out the fundamenta l role played by COXO-FEMORAL ARTICULATION in this group, and entails that this athlete's articulation must be provided with a great flexibility. B) Techniques of physical lever In the second group we found all throws produced by turning Uke's body round a stopping point (hip, leg, foot, etc.). The techniques of Group of physical le ver can be classified by length of arm of lever, applied on Uke's body. Namely: minimum arm (fulcrum under Uke's wais t), medium arm (fulcrum under Uke's knees), maximum arm (fulcrum under Uke's malleola), variable arm (variable fulcrum from the waist down to Uke's knees) (Tabl. 3). Because in this group throws of minimum arm are energetically unfavorable (greatest force applied), that clears why, for competition, people like more to turn them in throws of variable arm, pulling down fulcrum under Uke's waist more and mo re. That means less waste of energy. 6 Again this biomechanical classification shows, in this group, likeness examples : classical Ashi Guruma and Hiza Guruma are the same techniques applying a lever of medium arm on Uke's body. It is very interesting to note that most throws of group of lever can be led to only one Tori's basic action, if we do not consider the several Tori's legs pos itions: rotation of trunk on waist around a generic variable axis of rotation. 7 Also the body-abandoning techniques must be classified as throws of Group of physical lever with maximum arm, in this case the stopping point (ful crum) is given by friction between foot and mat (tatami). Although they are more favorable energetically sp eaking, the starting force (body weight falling down) is applied with an angle greater of 45deg (see Il corollary of static analysis). That is matters need high, directional help by arms or legs, for rightly throwing Uke's body. At the light of our analysis we th ink the clarification of basic physical principles and the evidence of basic action, proving the leading role of Tori's pelvic belt, can be us eful for a better understanding of inner mechanisms and for looking at new improvements in traini ng theory, which should prevent erroneous methods and possible damages in the joints. 8 9 9 III) JUDO SKILLS AND THEIR TREND IN TOP COMPETITION With the continuous evolution of competitive style, for a right training of <<top>> athletes, we need a better understanding of judo skills and their trend in top competitions. Obviously the basic physical principles of st andard judo techniques a nd judo skills (competitive throwing techniques) are the same, but the dynamical conditions are quite different (fast movements, more opposition, timing, change of speed, etc.). The right way to learn the connection with standard techniques, and to understand the competitive evolution of judo skills, was signed for the first time, by dr. Kano with the formulation of principium of Maximum effect with minimum effort. This principium can be translated in two useful biomechanical remarks: 1) To improve techniques to win, signifies to produce maximum economy of movements. 2) To better techniques to win, signifies to produce maximum economy of strain. The explication of remarks is: in competition cham pions, consciously or unawares, tend to find the right methods of minimizi ng the total energy to win. In two ways: either minimizing his own muscular st rain with right changes in throwing patterns (e.g. pulling down the fulcrum), or minimizing the defens ive antagonist capability with right changes in attack directions (e.g. attack in the direction of the a dversary side where the resistive muscular capability is weaker). These are two biomechanical rules, wh ich give us a better understandin g of trend of judo skills in top competitions. 10 BIBLIOGRAPHY Judo Kyohan - Yokoyama Sakujiro and Oshima Eisuke : traduit par Messieur Le Prieur, Berger Leverault ED. Paris 1911. My Study of Judo - G. Koizumi, Sterling Publishing New York 1966. Lo Judo - A. Geesink, A. Mondadori ED. Milano 1975. Judo for the West - G. R. Gleeson 1973. I Principi dell'Analisi Quantitativa Biomeccani ca - Kronenberg ED. Stam pa Sportiva Roma 1983. Muscles Reflexes and Locomotion -T. Mc Mahon, Princeton University Press 1984. Biomeccanica del Judo - A. Sacripanti, In print 1987-88. The Kinetics of Judo - M. Ikai and Y. Matsumoto 1958. Studies on the Nage Waza (throwi ng techniques) of Judo - M. Ikai et al. 1963. Studies on Judo Techniques with Respect to Distri bution of Body Weight Matsumoto, Y. et al. 1963. Analysis of the Kuzushi in the Na ge Waza - Matsumoto, Y. et al. 1978. Kinetic Analysis of Judo Technique - Tezuka, M. et al. 1983. Fisica e Judo - Sacripanti, A. 1986. Lo Squilibrio Statico in Judo - Sacripanti, A. 1987. 11
|
0806.4091
|
Attilio Sacripanti
|
Attilio Sacripanti (ENEA; University of Tor Vergata Rome; Italian
Wrestling, Weightlifting and Judo Federation)
|
Biomechanical Classification of Judo Throwing Techniques (Nage Waza)
|
11 pages, 14 Figures, 3 Tables, Presented at fifth International
Symposium on Biomechanics in Sport Athens 1987
| null | null | null |
physics.gen-ph physics.pop-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this paper it is applied the classic mechanical point of view to classify
all the movements known as throwing judo techniques; the application of the
Newtonian physical methods and principles is able to rationalize the whole
matter and to group under only two very simple and clear principles all the
movements, before grouped in many generic and not very clear way.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 25 Jun 2008 13:13:48 GMT"
}
] | 2008-06-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Sacripanti",
"Attilio",
"",
"ENEA; University of Tor Vergata Rome; Italian\n Wrestling, Weightlifting and Judo Federation"
]
] |
2 showingan in I (FR I) radio source, which was first re- vealed by Dreher&Feigelson (1984). Furthermore, the two jets in Herc A are quite different in appearance. The east- ern jet appears to have continuous twisting flows, while the western jet leads to a unique sequence of rings. The ly at a certain distance from the nucleus. An explanation for the presence of such different structures in the same source is still unresolved in the literature. Herc A is not a typical FR I source, either; its jets are well-collimated and has kno t components. Therefore, Herc A might be classified an FRI/II. Various models have been proposed for explaining the formation of the jets and rings in Herc A, including both kinematic (Masonet al. 1988; Morrison&Sadun 2002) and dynamic (Meieretal. 1991; Saxtonet al. 2002) points of view. By performing ax- isymmetric, two-dimensional hydrodynamic al. undergoesa highly over-pressured compared to the background gas at a certain distance from the core. This causes a subse- quent conical expansion, giving rise to the ice cream However,at present,thereis nothingin th e X-ray observationsto suggest that the jet becomes thermall y over-pressured as required in this model. In Saxtonet agat- ing throughthe jet cocoon. Also, these authorsconclude tha t the absence of hot spots in Herc A results fromthe Gizani& Leahy (2003) have revealed of total intensity, spectral index, polarizati on, and projected magnetic field in Herc A by using y visible, implying flow instabilities. The projected magnet ic field, after correcting for Faraday rotation, closely follo ws the edges of the lobes, the jets, and the rings; the two lobes have generally similar field patterns. This observational p al. with the extragala en examinedby using Stokes (RM), and the field ( 1981; Clarkeet al. 1989, 1992; Hardee& Rosen 1999, 2002; Lainget al. 2006). In general, helical za- tion profiles; they are symmetrical only if the field is purely toroidal or the jet is at 90*to the line of sight (Laing 1981). Lainget al. (2006) conclude that, to the first approximation , thefield Ijet (2004)'s gas in the Herc A cluster have revealed extende a radiusof2.2Mpc. The d X-ray surface brightness profile is well fitted by a modified King (b) model (King 1972; Cavaliere& with core radius Rc= 121+-10kpc and b=
0.74+-0.03. Their X-ray analysis supports the conclusion that the inner jets are confined thermally by the cluster core gas: thermal pressure in the cluster core is almost 10 Theradiolob beyondthe X-ray to the R2profile needed to give the lobes a 1991). These observational evidence motivate us to apply our dy- namical magnetic tower jet model to Herc A. To our knowl- edge, no MHD model has been applied to Herc A before though there are several hydrodynamic models as we have already referred. Radio observations suggest that the mag- netic fields need to be taken into account to discuss about jet/lobe dynamics in Herc A. We believe that a key clue andthelobema y be whether or not the inner jets become over-pressured dur- ing their propagation in the X-ray thermal cluster gas. than thermally, dominated. This is in contrast to previous model s (Meieret al. 1991). lobe transition, wiggling, and the magnetic field distribution a sso- ciated with the eastern jet of Herc A, which are not yet fully discussed among the past hydrodynamic models of Herc A. We do not discuss the formationof ringsin the western jet paper is organized as follows. In SS2, we outline In SS3, we describeour givenin solve the nonlinear system of time-dependent ideal MHD equations numerically in a 3-D Cartesian y, z). The basic numerical treatments -III.We assume aninitial in the gravitationally stratified medium, adopting an isother mal King model. The magnetic flux and the mass are steadily in- jected in a central small volumeduring a certain time period ill evolve as a magnetic tower and interact with the ambient medium. The of MHD equationsis in- tegrated in time by using the TVD upwind scheme (Li&Li 2003). Computations were performed on the parallel Linux clustersat the in the system. Other quantities are derived from e.g., the typical time t0isR0/Cs0, etc. In this paper, we use some observed quantities associated with Leahy to determine our normalization units. A central electro n densityne= 1984). r0= 1.7x10-26gcm-3. withkT= 4.25keV is assumed for the b-model cluster, giving a unit temperature T0= 4.9x107K, a unit pressure p0= = 1.2x108cms-1. Here,we choosea unit lengthR0= t0= 2.4x107 yr. The unit magnetic field 3 In the King model we use here, we take the cluster core ra- diusRcto be 120 kpc, correspondingto the normalized core radius 4.0, and take the exponential slope kto user0andp0as the initial quantities at the origin (x, y, z) = randpareset to unity at the origin in these simulations. The total compu- tational domainis taken to be |x|,|y|,|z| <=15. The number of grid pointsin the is 3603, The simulation domain is from -450to450kpc, with x= y= ~2.5kpc. The injections of magnetic flux, mass, and the the same as those described in Paper I. The ratio between the toroidal to poloidal fluxes of the injected fields is characterized by a parameter a= 25. The magnetic field injection rate is described by gband is set to be gb= 1. The mass is injected at a rate of gr= 0.1over a central volume with a characteristic radius rr= 0.5. Magnetic fluxes and massare tinj= 3.0,after which g- netic energy injection rate of ~2.7x1046ergs s-1and an injectiontime ~72Myrs. a similar range to that of other hydrodynamic al. 2002). We use the outflow boundary conditions at all outer bound- aries. es and magnetic fields stay within the simulation box, and on our simulations, we make synthetic to compare with the real observations of Herc A (Gizani&Leahy 2003, hereafter GL03). The synthetic ra- dio telescope observations presented here were produced us - ing a modified form of the synthetic observation technique first described in Tregilliset al. (2001). Here we provide an overview of the key points relevant to the present investiga - tion; a complete description of the technique is provided in Tregillis (2002). Our method utilizes the vector magnetic field within these MHD calculations a nd a momentum distribution, f(p), chosen by fiat during postprocessing. The function f(p)is defined over eight bins. Each bin has an associated slope value, q, and within each bin the dis- tribution is a power law ( f~p-q). Slope values may vary between bins, however, making it possible to specify non- power law distributions, such as would be appropriate for cases where radiative aging is significant. The specified dis - tribution functions are free to vary from location to locati on within the simulated flows, as is expected to be the case in real radio galaxies. We note that although these distributi ons arenotderivedwithinthecomputedflows al. 2001,2004) , imposing it as a postprocessing step does provide a this paper we choose the sign conventionsuch that a >
0, and the flux density Snn-a. For the present which do not incorporate the effects of radiative agi um slope value q= 4.5throughout the simulated source. a index a= 0.75, thinindividual radio galaxies. For example, mapped the spectral index distribution in Herc A be- tween 1.3 and 4.8 GHz, finding with the flattest values within the western jet and the steepest value Theyalsofound the eastern jet. Our choice, a= 0.75, is also consistent with typical hotspot spectral index values a5.0 1.4in the sample of3CR local magnetic energy density (i.e., neB2). This field and particle energies, such as is posited by (Miley 1980). However, the overall scaling was chosen such that the energy density of relativistic electro e our simulated object is out of equipartition, which is consi information about the local magnetic field and the local distribution of energetic electrons, we compute a syn - chrotron emissivity jnin every zone of the (1974),the the local field onto the sky, and ja0is an order- unity dimensionless constant, defined in Joneset al. (1974) n, thedistribution, m therelation ps= [2n/(3nB)](1/2), withpsin zone, we compute surface brightnessmaps for optically - thin emission via line-of-sight integrations. Similarly, we can obtain the Stokes QandUparameters for the as well as the correctionfor Faradayrot a- tion throughthe source, making detailed polarimetric stud ies possible. We write the resultant data in FITSformat, and an- alyze it using conventional observational packages ( theHerc structur esin the jets: the jet/lobe transition, the non-axisymmetric de for- mation, and the projected magnetic field distribution assoc section at t= 8.0(192 Myr). As we have examined in papers II and III, the global structure of the magnetic tower consists of a well-collimated body and radially extended lobes in the gravitationally stratified atmosphere. A tra r coreradius. Thisinteresting propertycan be confirmedin re se magnetic tower jets (the MHD wave structures, the ilib- riumat the toweredge,andthe similar to the results of paper II (see also Fig. 1 of paper II for details of time evolution). The ma f current circuits. Each circuit contains a forward electric cur- rent path (the jet flow itself, with its toroidal magnetic fiel d,4 1.-- Distribution of the gas pressure p(logarithmic scale) with the velocity field ( Vx, Vz) (arrows) in thex-zplane at 192 Myr. The dimens ionalvalues. The cavities (low density and gas pressure) are formed due to the magnetic tower expansion as corresponding lobes. The jets are deformed int o the inside the lobes. toward the lobe) and a return current (along some path e central engine and the hot spots was introduced by Benford (1978, 2006) and applied to AGN double radio sources. As seen in Fig. 1, the high-pressure material of the ambient gas seems to follow the edge of the jet near the bottom of each lobe. However, this is not the case, but the local the lobes. In the jet and lobe sys- tem, the axial currents drive the current-driven instabili ties; it in our ideal MHD assumption (the magnetic field will As a result, some local heating may occur, but it ly. For a full 3-D visualization of the magnetic lines of force, the reader is referred to paper III. The basic behavior of the magnetic field in the present paper appea hasawell - orderedhelical field a tightly-woundce d helix coming back at the outer edge of the magnetic tower. The outer edge of the magnetic tower may be identified as a tangential discontinuity without the normal field compo- nent. The interior of tower (lobe) is separated from the non- magnetized external gas via this discontinuity. At the towe r edge, the outward-directed magnetic pressure gradient for ce is roughly balanced with the pre s- sure gradient force. On the other hand, at the core part of jet body, a quasi-force free equilibrium is achieved. In lical field in the magnetic tower can be regarded as the profile. The jet axial current and the ambient gas pressure can to- gether determine the radius of the (paperII). That is, the internal gas pressure playsa m i-4 5 6 700.511.522.5 zr VzCs Shock frontLobe front FIG. 2.-- Axial profiles of physical quantities along the z-axis att= 3.0 (t= 72Myrs). Density r,soundspeed component Vz. Thepositions of the expanding shock and lobe fronts aresho wn. nor role in the lobes (even if the thermal pressure is greater than the non-thermal pressure (Morgantiet al. 1988) as is typically seen in FR I radio galaxies (Crostonet al. 2003). The Alfv' en speed becomes large (about three times the local sound speed), while the plasma b(2p/B2)becomes inside the density cavities due to the expansion of magnetic fluxes. As we have already discussed in paper II, it is remarkablynoted that the expandingtower launchesa pre- ceding in the ICM, which may be (Formanet al. 2005; Nulsenetal. 2005; 2 exhibits physical quantities along the z-axis at t= 3.0(t= 72Myrs). The magnetic tower-driven hy- drodynamic shock front can be seen around z~6.4in the profiles of r,Cs, andVz. The sound speed jumps by 27 %
[the temperature T(C2 s)increases by 61 %] in the post- shocked region due to the shock compression. The magnetic tower front,which is identified as the lobe front,is located at z~5.2. Thereis anotherMHD wave frontat 2),indicat ing the reverse MHD slow mode. In later time, this can head of magnetic tower as seen in Fig. 1 (see also Fig. a function of time along the z-axis (propagating towards the positive direction). The shock front has a constant prop - agation speed s-1) that implies a Mach number ~1.63. On the other hand, the lobe front expands subsonically. This lobe front also has a quasi-constant propagation speed s-1) that implies a Mach number see alsoFig. 5 0 2 4 60510 t zShock front Lobe front FIG. 3.-- The temporal evolution of the shock and lobe front posit ions along the z-axis. During the time evolution, both fronts propagate wit h al- most constant speeds. The shock front expands supersonical ly with to the unshocked ICM), while the lobe front pro- ceeds subsonically with Mach number ~0.9(relative to the shocked ICM cocoon). The current-carrying magnetic tower jet, which possesses a highly-wound helical field, is subject to the current-driv will be modified by the ambient gas and the RFP configuration of the tower, we find that the propagating magnetic tower jets can develop the non-axisymmetric CDI modes. As seen in Fig. 4, both the internal elliptical ( m= 2) mode like the double helix and the external kink ( m= 1) mode grow to produce the wiggles at different locations (see also pa- per III for details). We see no disruption owing to shear- driven, Kelvin-Helmholtz modes and/or the pressure-drive 5 shows the synthetic radio at 5 GHz, along with the polarization magnetic field vectors. The wiggled structures can be observed in both the jet and lobe. Also, filamentary structures appear beyond Rc. The projected magnetic field is aligned with the jet and along the lobe edge. The magnetic tower model produces that are qualitatively consistent with those seen in the Herc A observations of GL03. Furthermore, our dynam- ical solution of magnetic tower's evolution may give a self- consistent explanation to a feasible magnetic configuratio Bph> Bz inside the lobe) - Sheath ( Bz> Bph) structure in FR I jet over 10 kpc scale as discussed in Laing (1981); Lainget al. (2006). The image contrast in our synthetic synchrotron st pixels (beams) near the central core and the faintest region s inside the lobes. Outside the small bright core region, the synthetic 5 GHz synchrotron map is scaled to an angular size comparable to that of Herc A, the brightest FIG. as Fig. 1. Two types of growing current-driven (ext arevisible in the lobe and jet. FIG. 5.-- Synthetic synchrotron surface brightness computed at 5 GHz (greyscale), overlaid with polarization magnetic field vec tors. The field vec- tors are corrected for Faraday rotation, and represent the fi eld orientations at the source. The polarization field is nicely aligned with t he jets and (beam) in the synthetic 5 GHz surface brightness map is 875 mJy/beam. However, away from the small, bright re- gionnear the core, the jets generallyexhibit flux densities on the order of 30-70 mJy/beam, the central sheath exhibits flux densities in the range 20-30 mJy/beam, and the darkest parts6 simulated source exhibits a fractional linear polariza - tion,m, at 5 GHz ranging from a few percent in the the lobesto m30-50%
on the lobe edges. These values are consistent with those typically observed in radio galaxies (Bridle&Perly small, isolated pockets in the sheath around the central jet and near the central core, which may indicate insufficien t computational resolution near the core for properly captur ized lobes, where the ambient medium in our calculational the degree of polarization approaches 72%. This ns withq= features about the shock and lobe expansions in the simulation are discussed by comparing with observations. A Chandra X-ray image of the Herc A cluster shows that it has cavities and a shock front associated with the powerful radi o lobes (Nulsenet al. 2005). Unusually, these cavities show no clear connectionto the radio sources, while manycavitie s are associated with radio sources in other cluster cases (e. g., McNamaraet al. 2000), indicating that they might be (2005)'s observation reveals that a shock front surrounds the Herc A radio source. It is elongated in the direction of the radio lobes and appears to be a cocoon shock (Scheuer 1974). Their fitting of a simple hydrody- namic model to the surface brightness profile gives a Mach number for the shock front of ~1.65and its total is estimated. As we examinedin SS3, the in the ambientICM. De- rived Mach number M~1.63matches quite well to the radio lobes of Herc A lack anything it seems likely that they are expanding at around the sound speed, and so are confined by the thermal pres- sure of the ambient ICM, rather than by strong 2004). To our knowledge, there may be no direct result revealing the lobe expansion speed of al. (2006)'sargument . It is believed that the radio lobes are greatly overpressuri zed relative to the ambient medium, indicating that sharp X-ray surface brightness discontinuities or large jumps in gas te m- perature at the lobe edges. A high Mach number ( M~8.5) shock is detected around the SW radio lobe of Centaurus A (Kraftet al. 2003). However, there is no evidence especially for FR I or low-power FR II radio galaxies, including Herc A (Gizani&Leahy 2004) and 3C 388 (Kraftetal. 2006). If thermal conduction in the ICM is efficient (an order of s difficult to detect (Fabianetal. 2006). However, Vikhlininet al. 2001; Kraftet al. 2003). Thus, some lobes including Herc A may be inflating transonically and subsonically (i.e., M<=1). Based on hydrodynamic lly- dominated lobe expands subsonically with M~0.91, dis- cussed in SS3. Thiswill also match the next discuss the radial size of the lobes rlobeas al. 2006). and the poloidal current Izin the lobes remain well collimated around the central axis even after the system (2) When the lobe experiences sufficient expansion, we can ex- pect|Bz| ~ |Bph|at the outer edge of the RFP 1982). The magnetic and background pressures tend to balance each other at the tower edge. Thus, we (3) wherepeis the external gas pressure at the tower edge. By combiningeqs. (2)and(3),we (5) Figure 6 shows the distributionof palong a 8.5(255 kpc), when the lobe has a maximum 1and4). gas pressure begins to decrease around x~5(150 z)axis. lobe of our magnetic tower. We can estimate the lobe From Fig. 2, we take a radius r~0.75(22.5kpc), which makes 4,weestimate cm-2) for the external gas pressure. We therefore obtain rlobe~5.2or roughly 156 kpc. Thus, we find that the depression radius in Fig. 6 is qualitatively con - sistent with rlobeand is comparable with the physical scale seenin 2003). Based on this numerical result, we estimate that one simulated lobe o f Herc-A may contain a total energy ~1.8x1061ergs, out ~1.4x1060 ergs are in kinetic energy, and ~6.6x1060ergs are in ther- mal energy, respectively. In order to explain the lobe radiu s by this lobe system, an axial curren t
~5x1017A, which is flowing along the jet central axis, nonlinear dynamics of magnetic tower jets in a galaxy cluster environment. In this fourth paper of the series, 7 -5 0 8.5 FIG. 6.-- Transverse profile in the x-direction of the gas pressure pon z= 8.5(255 kpc). The lobe radius rlobecalculated via eq. (5) is also shown. The pressure cavity radius and agree with each other. have applied our numerical modeling of the magnetic tower toa our knowledge, this is the first trial of discussing Her- cules A jet by using a model. Pro- jectedmagneticfieldwiththejet and therefore, the dynamics including magnetic field s plays a role in understanding this source. In the present pa- per, we have investigated the jet-driven shock, jet/lobe tr an- sition, wiggling, and projected magnetic field distributio n of Hercules A and, in general, these feasutres can be A transition from the narrow jet to the fat lobe can occur at the cluster core radius. This can also be confirmed in recent 2003, 2004). In our models, the tightly collimated helical field configuration of a to the decreasing external gas pressure. Thus, role in determining the morphologyof a The expanding magnetic tower jet produces the pre- cedingwave in the ambientICM. This can be interpreted as AGN-driven shock in X- ray observation and the derived shock Mach al. This may be a general understanding of FR I or low al. 2006). 3. The size of the magnetic tower lobe can be at the lobe edge. The estimated lobe size de- rivedby ournumericalsimulationisqualitativelycom- parablewiththephysicalscaleseenin. (b) in the King profile, the magnetic jet can Magnetic tower jets, which have a reversed magnetic pinch profile, are subject to current-driven instabili- ties. Specifically, the apparent distortions by the kink mode are visible at the jet body exciting external kink mode; this situation may coreradius. 5. the jets of Hercules A. The magnetic tower Magnetic tower jets may producea self-consistent pic- ture ofthe field several non- dynamical model of FR I jets. It consists of spine inside the lobe and poloidally domi- nated sheath at the lobe edge (a closed poloidal mag- netic flux with a toroidal magnetic component, discussions with Philipp Kronberg and Steven Diehl are gratefully acknowledged. The authors thank the anonymous referee for helpful suggestions. This work was carried out under the auspices of the National Nuclear Secu- rity Administration of the U.S. Department of Energy at Los Alamos National Laboratory under Contract No. It was supported by the Laboratory and Development Program at LANL and by P.&Leahy, J.P.1987, MNRAS, 225, 1 Benford, G.1978, MNRAS,183, 29 Benford, G.2006, MNRAS,369, 77 Bridle, A.H.,&Perley, R.A. 1984, A.,& Fusco-Femiano, R. 1976, A&A,49, ohringer,H.2002 J. H., Hardcastle, M. J., Birkinshaw, M., & Worrall , D. M. 2003, MNRAS, 346,1041 Clarke, D. A.,Norman, M.L.,&Burns, J.O.1989, ApJ,342, 700Clarke, D. A., Bridle, A. H., Burns, J. O., Perley, R. A., & Nor man, M. L., 1992, ApJ,385, 173 Dreher, J.W.,&Feigelson, E.D.1984, Nature, al. 2005, ApJ,635, 894 Fabian, A.etal. 2006, MNRAS,366, 417 Falle, S.A.E.G.1991, MNRAS,250, 581 Fanaroff, B &Riley, J.M.1974, MNRAS, 167,31 Ferrari, A.1998, J.P.1982, Rev. Mod. N.A.B.,& Leahy,J.P.2003, MNRAS,342, 399 (GL03)8 N.A.B., &Leahy,J.P.2004, MNRAS, 350,865 (GL04) Gooch, R. E. 1995, in ASP Conf. Ser. 101, Astronomical Data and Systems V , ed. G. H. Jacoby & J. Barnes (San P.E.,&Rosen, A. 1999, ApJ,524, 650 Hardee, P.E.,&Rosen, A. 2002, ApJ,576, 204 Hsu,S.C.,& Bellan, P.M.2002, MNRAS, 334,257 Jones, T.W.,O'Dell, S.L.,&Stein, W.A.1974, ApJ,188, 353 Jones, C.,&Forman, W.1984, ApJ,276,38 Kato, Y.,Hayashi, M.R., &Matsumoto, R.2004, ApJ,600, 338 Kato, Y.,Mineshige, S.,&Shibata, K. 2004, ApJ,605, 307 King, I.1972, ApJ,174, L123 Kraft R.P.,et al. 2003, ApJ,592, 2006, ApJ,639, 753 Kudoh, T.,Matsumoto, R.,& Shibata, K.2002, PASJ,54, 26 Laing, R. A.1981, ApJ,248, 87 Laing, R. A., Canvin, J. R., & Bridle, A. H. 2006, Astron. Nach r. 327, No. 5/6, 523 Lebedev, S.V.et al. 2005, MNRAS, R. V. E.,Finn, J.M.,&Colgate, S.A.2001, A pJ,561, 915 Li, S., & Li, H. 2003, Technical Report, LA-UR-03-8935, Los A lamos National Laboratory Li, H., Lapenta, G., Finn, J. M., Li, S., & Colgate, S. A. 2006, ApJ, 643, 92 (Paper I) Lynden-Bell, D.1996, MNRAS, 279, 389 Lynden-Bell, D.,&Boily, C.1994, MNRAS, R. V. E., Li, H., Koldoba, A. V., Ustyugova, G. V., & Romanova, M. M.2002, ApJ,572, 445 Lovelace, R. V. E.,&Romanova, M.M.2003, ApJ,596, L159 Mason, A.,Morrison, P.,& Sadun, A.C. 1988, Nature, B.R.,et al. 2000. ApJ,534, L135McNamara, B.R.,et al. 2001. ApJ,562, L149 Meier, D.L.,Sadun, A.C.,&Lind K.R. 1991, ApJ,379, 141 Meier, D.L.,Koide, S.,& Uchida, Y.2001, Science, 291, 84 Miley, G.1980, ARA&A,18, 165 Morganti, R., Fanti, R., Gioia, I. M., Harris, D. E., Parma, P ., & Ruiter, H. 1988, A&A,189, 11 Morrison, P.,& Sadun, A.C. 1996, MNRAS,278, 265 Muxlow, T. W. B. & Garrington, S. T. 1991 Beams and Jets in York: ambridge University M.,Li, H.,& Li,S.2006, ApJ,652, 1059 (Paper II) Nakamura, M.,Li, H.,& Li,S.2007, ApJ,656, 721 (Paper III) Nulsen, P.E.J.,et al. 2005, ApJ,625, L9 Romanova, M. M., Ustyugova, G. V., Koldoba, A. V., Chechetki n, V. M., &
Lovelace, R.V. E.1998, ApJ,500, 703 Rybicki, G. B., & Lightman, A. P. 1979, Radiative Process in York: John Wiley and A.C.,&Hayes, J.J.E.1993, PASP,105, 379 Sadun, A.C.,&Morrison, P.2002, ApJ,123, 2312 Saxton, C. J.,Bicknell, R. S.2002, ApJ, 579, 176 Scheuer, P.A.G.1974, MNRAS, 166,513 Siebert, J.,Kawai, N.,& Brinkmann, W.1999, A&A,350, 25 Tregillis, I.L.,Jones, T.W.,& Ryu, D.2001, ApJ,557, 475 Tregillis, I.L.2002, Ph.Dthesis, U.of I.L.,Jones, T.W.,& Ryu, D.2004, ApJ,601, 778 Turner, P.,& R' o. zyczka M.1999, ApJ,52 4, 12 Ustyugova, G. V., Lovelace, R. V. E., Romanova, M. M., Li, H., ApJ,541, L21 Uzdensky, D.A.,&MacFadyen, A.I. 2006, ApJ,647, 1192 Vikhlinin, A.,Markevitch, M.,&Murray, S. S.2001, ApJ,549 , L47
|
0806.4150
|
Masanori Nakamura
|
Masanori Nakamura (T-6, LANL), Ian L. Tregillis (X-1, LANL), Hui Li
(T-6, LANL), and Shengtai Li (T-7, LANL)
|
A Numerical Model of Hercules A by Magnetic Tower: Jet/Lobe Transition,
Wiggling, and the Magnetic Field Distribution
|
8 pages, 6 figures, Accepted for Publication in ApJ
| null |
10.1086/591222
|
LA-UR-07-8343
|
astro-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We apply magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) modeling to the radio galaxy Hercules A
for investigating the jet-driven shock, jet/lobe transition, wiggling, and
magnetic field distribution associated with this source. The model consists of
magnetic tower jets in a galaxy cluster environment, which has been discussed
in a series of our papers. The profile of underlying ambient gas plays an
important role in jet-lobe morphology. The balance between the magnetic
pressure generated by axial current and the ambient gas pressure can determine
the lobe radius. The jet body is confined jointly by the external pressure and
gravity inside the cluster core radius R_c, while outside R_c it expands
radially to form fat lobes in a steeply decreasing ambient thermal pressure
gradient. The current-carrying jets are responsible for generating a strong,
tightly wound helical magnetic field. This magnetic configuration will be
unstable against the current-driven kink mode and it visibly grows beyond R_c
where a separation between the jet forward and return currents occurs. The
reversed pinch profile of global magnetic field associated with the jet and
lobes produces projected B-vector distributions aligned with the jet flow and
the lobe edge. AGN-driven shock powered by the expanding magnetic tower jet
surrounds the jet/lobe structure and heats the ambient ICM. The lobes expand
subsonically; no obvious hot spots are produced at the heads of lobes. Several
key features in our MHD modeling may be qualitatively supported by the
observations of Hercules A.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 25 Jun 2008 17:08:08 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Nakamura",
"Masanori",
"",
"T-6, LANL"
],
[
"Tregillis",
"Ian L.",
"",
"X-1, LANL"
],
[
"Li",
"Hui",
"",
"T-6, LANL"
],
[
"Li",
"Shengtai",
"",
"T-7, LANL"
]
] |
multiplicity distribution starting at the highest multiplicities. The range s used were 0-5% (most central collisions), 5-10%, 10-20%, 20-30%, 30-40%, 40-50%, 50 -60%, 60-70%, and 70-80% for Au+Aucollisions. Similarly, collision centrality slices used in 0-10% (most central), 10-20%, 20-30%, 30-40%, 40-50% and 50-60% (most peripheral). Each centrality bin is associated with an averagenumber of participating n ucleons,Npart, using Glauber Monte Carlo calculation [5]. III. NET CHARGE FLUCTUATION RESULTS We present, in Fig. 1, measurements of the dynamical net charge fl uctuations, n+-,dyn, as a function of collision centrality in Au+Aucollisions atsNN= 19.6, 62.4, 130, and 200 atsNN= 62.4 and 200 GeV. The dynamical net charge fluctuations, in partN0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 200 GeV AuAu 200 GeV AuAu 130 GeV AuAu 62.4 GeV CuCu 62.4 GeV AuAu 19.6 GeVSTAR Preliminary FIG. 1: Net charge dynamical fluctuations, n+-,dyn, of particles produced within pseudorapidity |e|<0.5, as function of the number of participating exhibit a monotonic dependence on the number of participa ting nucleons. At a given number of participants the measured fluctuations also exhibit a mod est dependence on beam energy, with n+-,dynmagnitude being the largest in Au+Aucollisions atsNN= 19.6 GeV. measured for p+pcollisions ats= 200 GeV amounts to -0.230 on the number of participating nucleons can be seen in F ig. 2(b), discussed in Section III A. A. Collision Centrality Dependence Fig. 2(a) shows the dynamical fluctuations scaled by the measured particle multiplicity density in dNch/de). Datafrom solid and open symbols, respectively. Values of dNch/deused for the scaling correspond to charged particle multiplicities measured by STAR [6] and PH OBOS [7]. The by GeV data is significantly different from the results of other systems and energies. The observed with the increase in The dashed line in the figure corresponds to charge con servation effect and the solid line to the prediction for a resonance gas. The data indicates that dyn amical net charge by dNch/defor the most central collisions are qualitatively consistent with reso nance gas prediction [1].Fig. 2(b) presents the dynamical fluctuation scaled by the number of participants, are thus consistent with no or a very weak collision centrality depen dence. However, a definite system size and energy dependence is observed. Vertical error bars represent 100 200 300 400 500 600 pp 200 GeV CuCu 200 GeV AuAu 200 GeVAuAu 130 GeV AuAu 62.4 GeV CuCu 62.4 GeV AuAu 19.6 GeV STAR 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 pp 200 GeV CuCu 200 GeV AuAu 200 GeV AuAu 130 GeVAuAu 62.4 GeV CuCu 62.4 GeV AuAu 19.6 GeV STAR Preliminary FIG. 2: Net charge dynamical fluctuations, n+-,dyn, of particles produced with pseudorapidity |e|<0.5 scaled by (a) the multiplicity, dNch/de, (b) the number of participants. The dashed line correspond s to charge conservation effect and the solid line to the predicti on for a resonance gas. B. Longitudinal and Azimuthal Dependencies of the Dynamica l Fluctuations We plot in Fig. 3 values of n+-,dyn(e) measured for different ranges of pseudorapidity, e, nor- malized by the magnitude of n+-,dyn(e) for a pseudorapidity range |e|<1 (n+-,dyn(1)) to of different centralities, beam energies and system size . The magnitude of the normal- ized correlation is maximum for the smallest pseudorapidity ranges an d decreases monotonically to unity, at all energies and centralities, with increasing pseudorap idity range. This shows that the collision dynamics in p+pcollisions, 0-10% Cu+Cuand 0-5% Au+Aucollisions are signifi- cantly different. Indeed, we find the relative magnitude of the corr elations measured for by nearly 25% for Au+Au200 GeV relative to those in p+p. Note in particular that the slope ( dn+-,dyn/de) depends on the correlation length (in pseudorapidity): the shorter the correlation, the larger the s lope. The observed indicate that the correlation length is shorter for central co llisions and for larger systems, in agreement with the observed reduction of the charge balance fun ction [8]. Fig. 4 displays mea- sured values of n+-,dynas a function of azimuthal angle ranges from 10 to 360 degrees for at 200 GeV. are compared at similar number of participating nucleons. One observes that the magnitud e ofn+-,dynwith respect to azimuthal angle, ph, is similar for similar number of participating nucleons in both systems w ith best agreement for collisions with more than 20 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS We have presented measurements of dynamical net charge fluctu ations in 19.6, 62.4, 130, 200 GeV, Cu+Cucollisions atsNN= 62.4, 200 GeV and p+p|e|0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 200 GeV CuCu 200 GeV AuAu 200 GeV AuAu 62.4 GeV CuCu 62.4 Preliminary FIG. 3: Dynamical normalized to their value for|e|<1, as function of the inte- grated pseudorapidity range. atsNN=
62.4, 200 GeV(0-5%) alongwith atsNN=
62.4, 200 GeV (0-10%), are p+pdataatsNN= 200 GeV.ph0 50 100 150 200 250 300 200 GeV CuCu 200 GeVSTAR Preliminary FIG. 4: Dynamical fluctuations n+-,dyn, as a function of the integrated similar number of Au+Au200GeVand Cu+Cu 200 GeV. collisions atsNN= 200 GeV, using the measure n+-,dyn. The fluctuations are non vanishing at all energies and exhibit a rather modest dependence on beam energ y in the range 19.6 <sNN
<200 GeV for Au+Auas well as Cu+Cucollisions. Net charge dynamical fluctuations violate the trivial 1 /Nchscaling expected for nuclear collisions consisting of independent nuc Scaled dynamical net charge fluctuations by up to 40% from peripheral to central collisions. This centrality dependence may ar ise, in part due to the large radial collective flow produced in Au+Aucollisions. We also studied fluctuations as a function of azimuthal angle and pseudorapidity and found that dynamical flu ctuations exhibit a on rapidity and azimuthal angular ranges which could be attributed in part to radial flow S. Jeon and V. Koch, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 2076 (2000); H. Heiselberg and A. D. Jackson, Phys. Rev. C63, 064904 (2001); M. Asakawa, U. Heinz, B. Mueller, Phys. Rev. Let t.85, 2072 (2000). [2] K. Adcox et al.(PHENIX Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 082301 (2002). [3] J. Adams et al.(STAR Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C68, 044905 (2003). [4] M. Anderson et al., Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A499, 624 (2003); Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A499, 659 (2003). [5] J. Adams et al., (STAR Collaboration), C. Adler et al., (STAR collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 112303 (2001). [7] B. B. Back et al., (PHOBOS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 102303 (2001); Phys. Rev. Lett.88, 022302 (2002); Phys. Rev. C65, 061901R (2002); Phys. Rev. C70, 021902 (2004); Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 052303 (2003); Phys. Rev. C74, 021901(R) (2006); J. Adams et al., (STAR Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 172301 (2003).
|
0806.4166
|
Monika Sharma
|
Monika Sharma (for the STAR Collaboration)
|
Beam-Energy and System-Size Dependence of Dynamical Net Charge
Fluctuations
|
4 pages, 4 figures, presented at the 19th International Conference on
Ultra-Relativistic Nucleus-Nucleus Collisions, "Quark Matter 2008", Jaipur,
India, February 4-10, 2008
|
Indian J.Phys.85:855-860,2011
|
10.1007/s12648-011-0089-4
| null |
nucl-ex
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We present measurements of net charge fluctuations in $Au + Au$ collisions at
$\sqrt{s_{NN}} = $ 19.6, 62.4, 130, and 200 GeV, $Cu + Cu$ collisions at
$\sqrt{s_{NN}} = $ 62.4, 200 GeV, and $p + p$ collisions at $\sqrt{s} = $ 200
GeV using the net charge dynamical fluctuations measure $\nu_{+-,dyn}$. The
dynamical fluctuations are non-zero at all energies and exhibit a rather modest
dependence on beam energy. We find that at a given energy and collision system,
net charge dynamical fluctuations violate $1/N_{ch}$ scaling, but display
approximate $1/N_{part}$ scaling. We observe strong dependence of dynamical
fluctuations on the azimuthal angular range and pseudorapidity widths.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 25 Jun 2008 19:06:25 GMT"
}
] | 2019-08-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Sharma",
"Monika",
"",
"for the STAR Collaboration"
]
] |
Quantum coherence in atoms has led to a variety of novel phenomen a. In induced transparency (EIT), destructive quantum interfer ence introduced by a strong coupling laser cancels the absorption from the ground state to coh erent superposing upper states [1]. The observation of nonabsorbing resonance through a tomic coherence has led to novel concepts, such as lasing without inversion [2]. Since the EIT line -width can be made extremely narrow, the resulting steep linear dispersion has been us ed to reduce the velocity of light. This technique has been developed for coherent optical inf ormation storage and to freeze light [3, 4, 5, 6]. Since EIT results from destructive quantum interference, it has b een recognized that similar coherence and interference effects can also occur in classica l systems, such as plasma [7, 8], coupled optical resonators [9, 10, 11, 12, 13], mechanical or electric oscillators the phenomenology of the EIT and the dynamic Stark e ffect are studied theo- retically in a dissipative system composed by two coupled oscillators us ing quantum optics model in Ref. [15]. The optical parametric amplifier (OPA) is one of the most and quantum optical devices. Recently, we studied the co herence phenomena in the phase-sensitive degenerate OPA inside a cavity [16, 17]. This phe nomenon results from the interference between the harmonic pump field and the subharm onic seed field in OPA. The destructive and constructive interferences correspond to optical parametric and amplification respectively. The absorptive response of an optical cavity for the probe field is changed by optical parametric interaction in the ca vity. Agarwal [18] generalized our observation of interferences in the classical doma in [16] to in the quantum domain and studied the interferences in the quantum fluctuations o f the output fields from a parametric amplifier when the cavity is driven by a quantized field at t he signal frequency. In the previous works [16, 17], we studied the absorptive and disper sive properties of de- 2generate double-resonant OPAwhere onlythe degenerate subha rmonic field resonated inside the cavity but the pump field did not. Although in the experiment with d the mode splitting in the transmission spectra [16] and the M shap e in the reflec- tion spectra were observed experimentally [17], the shape of the ph ase shift of the reflected field was unchanged [17]. Further, we investigated the triple-reson ant OPA which both the subharmonic and harmonic wave ares simultaneously resonate inside the cavity [17]. We found that the EIT-like effect can be simulated with a tr iple-resonant OPA. In this Letter, we present the results of the experimental invest igation on the absorptive and dispersive properties of a triple-resonant OPA for the subharmon ic field. The frequency and polarization of signal and idler fields in the OPA are totally degenerate . We demonstrate that EIT-like effect can be simulated in OPA when the cavity line-width f or the harmonic wave is narrower than that for the subharmonic field. A narrow tra nsparency window ap- pears in the reflected field. Especially, we measured the dispersive s pectra of and a very steep variation in the dispersive profile was observed . The experimental setup is shown schematically in Fig. 1, which is similar t o that used in our previous work [17]. A diode-pumped intra-cavity frequency-d oubled Nd:YVO 4/KTP single-frequency laser severs as the light sources of the pum p wave wave at 532 nm) and the probe wave (the subhar monic wave at 1064 nm) forOPA. Weactively control the relative phase between the subha rmonic andthe pump field by adjusting the phase of the subharmonic beam with a mirror mount ed upon a (PZT). Both beams are combined together by a dichro ic mirror and injected into the OPA cavity. OPA consists of type I periodically poled KTiOPO 4(PPKTP) crystal (12 mm long) and two external mirrors separated by 61 mm. Two end faces of crystal are polished of5 32nm and1064nm. 1. Schematic of the experimental setup. DC: dichroic mirror; l/2: half-wave detectors; T-C: temperature controller, HV-AMP: high voltage amplifier; PZT: piezoelectric transducer; EOM: electric-optic block, whose level around the phase-match temperature for optical par ametric process (31.3*C). The input coupler M1 is a 30 mm mirror with a power reflectivity 99%
for 1064 nm in the concave and 97% for 532nm, which is mounted upon a PZT for adjusting the length os the optical cavity. The back mirror M2 is a 30-mm mirror with a reflectivity 93% for 1064 nm and a high reflectivity coefficient fo r 532 nm in the concave. This structure forms the triple-resonant OPA, in which t he pump wave and idler and signal waves are all resonating inside the same cavity. field dueto gin< gc+gl, resulting from internal losses, input mirror and back mirror res pectively. The for the harmonic wave is narrower than for the subharmo nic field because the total damping of the pump field is much less than that of the subharm onic field ( gbg). Due to the high nonlinear coefficient of PPKTP, the measured thresh old power is Pth= 90 mW. In order to measure the phase of the reflected beam, we employ t he method (or spectrum) [19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24], which provides a way to indirectly measure the phase. The frequency of the inject ed subharmonic field is modulated with an electric-optic modulator (EOM), driven by a local o scillator with a radio frequency of 100 MHz. Here the depth of frequency modulation is very small, thus we only can observe two sidebands. The reflected beam is picked off with an o ptical isolator and send into a photodetector D3, whose output is compared with the local oscillator's signal via mixer. A low-pass filter on the output of the mixer extracts the lo w frequency signal, which is called the error signal. When the frequency of the injected s ubharmonic field is near resonance and the modulation frequency is high enough, the s idebands are out of the resonance and the error signal is the imaginary part of the reflect ed field. In our scheme, the cavity is an under-coupled resonator, whose dispersive respo nse results in fast light [13]. When an under-coupled resonator is far from th e imaginary part of the reflected field approximates to the phase shift. First, tr the reflection as the functions of the cavity detuning at the cas e without the existence of thepumpfield, which areshowninFig.2. Two small sidebandmodes gene can be seen in the transmission spectrum (See arrows in F ig.2 b). Then we hold the frequencies of the injected subharmonic and the pump field at op= 2o, and the phase difference ph=p/2 (i.e. OPA at the state of and mode two optical field s 5Detuning (MHz)
E
r
r
o
r
s
i
g
n
a
l
(
a
r
b
.
u
n
i
t
s
)
T
r
a
n
s
m
i
s
i
o
n
R
e
f
l
e
c
t
i
o
n
a
b
c
-200
-100
0
100
-100
0
100
-100
0
100
Fig. 2. The spectra of the subharmonic reflection, transmission an d phase shift of the reflected field as a function of the cavity detuning when the pump fie ld is simultaneously in the OPA by adjusting the cavity length an d the temperature of PPKTP. The cavity length is scanned around the resonant point. In Fig.3, the curves e, f and g show the spectra of the subharmonic reflection, transmissio n and phase shift of the reflection respectively withthe pumppower below thethreshold P= 0.15Pth, andthecurves h, j and k with P= 0.3Pth. We can see that the narrow transparency window appears in the reflection spectrum and is accompanied by a very steep variatio n of the dispersive profile whose dispersive response can result in slow light as that in EIT medium . This is in good agreement with the theoretical predictions in Ref.[17 ]. The observed phenomenon is easily understood: since the narrow a bsorption and dis- persion of the pump field are introduced into the subharmonic field via the in triple-resonant OPA, the reflected field of the subha rmonic field presents the EIT-like effect [17]. For the case of EIT in atomic systems, the analog ous condition of gbgis obtained when a pair of lower energy states have long lifetime. Note that we did not observe the phenomena under higher pump power as that pred icted theoretically in [17]. There are two main reasons. One is that the OPA will produce a large q uantum (MHz)
E
r
r
o
r
s
i
g
n
a
l
(
a
r
b
.
u
n
i
t
s
)
R
e
f
l
e
c
t
i
o
n
T
r
a
n
s
m
i
s
i
-20
0
20
40
-0.5
0.0
0.5
-40
-20
0
20
0
-20
0
20
-20
0
20
-20
0
20
-20
0
20
-20
0
20
-20
0
20
3. The spectra of the subharmonic reflection, transmission an d phase shift of the reflected field as a function of the cavity detuning for different pum p powers. a,b and c correspond to Fig.2 with narrow frequency detuning. e, f, and g at the pump power 0 .15Pth. h, j and k at 0 .3Pth. on the subharmonic field under higher pump power. The other is that the pump field had the strong thermal effect at the high pump power, which would influe nce the When scanning the cavity length, the thermo-in duced effect for the pump field was observed as shown in Fig.4, from which we can see, it seems like the Kerr The transmission profile of the pump field appears large asym metry at higher pump power when cavity length is scanned from shorter to longer and whe n the opposite. Thus it 7Detuning Transmisiona b c Fig. 4. The spectra of transmission of the pump field as a function of the cavity detuning for different pump powers: a at 0 .2Pth; b at 0.5Pth; c at 0.9Pth. The dot line represents the voltage on PZT, which denotes the cavity length scanned from shor ter to longer, then from longer to shorter. is difficult to measure the unusual line shape in the reflection spectru m and the steep vari- ation of the dispersive profile for triple-resonant OPA in the case of the strong between two we have investigated experimentally the absorptive a nd dispersive response of the reflected subharmonic field from a triple-resonant phase-s ensitive OPA. It is demon- strated that an EIT-like effect is simulated when the cavity line-width for the harmonic wave is narrower than for the subharmonic field. The narrow trans parency window appears in the reflected field and is accompanied by a very steep variation of t he dispersive profile. This novel system accompanying parametric gain for the probe sign al will be important for practical optical and photonic applications such as in optical filters , delay lines, and closely relate to the coherent phenomenon of EIT as that predicted for q uantum author's email address: jz Zhang thanks K. Peng and C. Xie for the helpful discussions. This research was sup- ported in part by NSFC for Distinguished Young Scholars (Grant No. 10725416), National Basic Research Program of China (Grant No. 2006CB921101), Nat ional Natural of China (Grant No. S. E. Harris, Phys. Today 50, 37 (1997); J. P. Marangos, J. Mod. Opt. 45, 471 (1998). 2. A. S. Zibrov, M. D. Lukin, D. E. Nikonov, L. Hollberg, M. O. Scully, V . L. Velichansky, and H. G. Robinson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1499 (1995). 3. L. V. Hau, S.E. Harris, Z. Dutton and C.H. Behroozi, Nature (Lon don)397, 594 (1999). 4. M. M. Kash, V. A. Sautenkov, A. S. Zibrov, L. Hollberg, G. R. Welc h, M. D. Lukin, Y. Rostovtsev, E. S. Fry, and M. O. Scully, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 5229 (1999). 5. D. Budker, D. F. Kimball, S. M. Rochester, and V. V. Yashchuk, P hys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1767 (1999). 6. C. Liu, Z. Dutton, C. Behroozi and L. V. Hau, Nature (London) 409, 490 (2001); D. F. Phillips, A. Fleischhauer, A. Mair, and R. L. Walsworth, Phys. Rev. Lett.86, 783 (2001). 7. S.E. Harris, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 5357 (1996). 8. A.G. Litvak and M.D. Tokman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 095003 (2002); G. Shvets and J.S Wurtele, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 115003 (2002). 9. T. Opatrny, and D. G. Welsch, Phys. Rev. A 64, 023805 (2001). 10. D. D. Smith, H. Chang, K. A. Fuller, A. T. Rosenberger, and R. W . Boyd, Phys. Rev. 9A69, 063804 (2004); L. Maleki, A. B. Matsko, A. A. Savchenkov, and V . S. Ilchenko, Opt. Lett. 29, 626 (2004). 11. M. F. Yanik, W. Suh, Z. Wang, and S. Fan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 233903 (2004). 12. A. Naweed, G. Farca, S. I. Shopova, and A. T. Rosenberger, Phys. Rev. A 71, 043804 (2005); Q. Xu, S. Sandhu, M. L. Povinelli, J. Shakya, S. Fan, and M. Lipson, Phys. Rev.Lett. 96, 123901 (2006); 13. D.D. Smith, H. Chang, J. Mod. Opt. 51, 2503 (2004); 14. P.R. Hemmer and M.G. Prentiss, J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 5, 1613 (1988); C. L. Garrido Alzar, M. A. G. Martinez, P. Nussenzveig, Am. J. Phys. 70, 37 (2002). 15. M. A. de Ponte, C. J. Villas-Boas, R. M. Serra, and M. H. Y. Mous sa, e-print H. Ma, C. Ye, D. Wei, and J. Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 233601 (2005). 17. C. Ye and J. Zhang, Phys. Rev. A 73, G. S. Agarwal, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 023601 (2006). 19. R. W. P. Drever, J. L. Hall, F. V. Kowalski, J. Hough, G. M. Ford, A. J. Munley, and H. Ward, Appl. Phys. B 31, 97 (1983). 20. G. C. Bjorklund, Opt. Lett. 5, 15 (1980). 21. G. C. Bjorklund, M. D. Levenson, W. Lenth, C. Ortiz, Appl. Phy s. B32, 145 (1983). 22. A. Schenzle, R. G. DeVoe, and R. G. Brewer, Phys. Rev. A 25, 2606 (1982). 23. J. Zhang, D. Wei, C. Xie and K. Peng, Opt. Express 11, 1338 (2003). 24. E. D. Black, Am. J. Phys. 69, 79 (2001). 10
|
0806.4218
|
Jing Zhang
|
Chenguang Ye, Jing Zhang
|
Electromagnetically-Induced-Transparency-Like Effect in the Degenerate
Triple-Resonant Optical Parametric Amplifier
|
10 pages, 4 figures, appear in Opt. Lett
|
Opt. Lett. 33,1911 (2008)
|
10.1364/OL.33.001911
| null |
quant-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We investigate experimentally the absorptive and dispersive properties of
triple-resonant optical parametric amplifier OPA for the degenerate subharmonic
field. In the experiment, the subharmonic field is utilized as the probe field
and the harmonic wave as the pump field. We demonstrate that EIT-like effect
can be simulated in the triple-resonant OPA when the cavity line-width for the
harmonic wave is narrower than that for the subharmonic field. However, this
phenomenon can not be observed in a double-resonant OPA. The narrow
transparency window appears in the reflected field. Especially, in the measured
dispersive spectra of triple-resonant OPA, a very steep variation of the
dispersive profile of the subharmonic field is observed, which can result in a
slow light as that observed in atomic EIT medium.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 26 Jun 2008 01:11:02 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Ye",
"Chenguang",
""
],
[
"Zhang",
"Jing",
""
]
] |
2 Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG Theorem 1.1. a= 1,***,m, be smooth functions in Rn. Suppose their graph M= (x,f(x))is a submanifold with parallel mean curvature in Rn+m. Suppose that there exists a number b0with (1.1) 1; such that (1.2) to be affine linear representing an affine n-plane. The key point of the proof is to find a geodesic convex set BJX(P0) sum of any two Jordan angles between a geodesic polar coordinate of the Grassmannian manifold, where P0denotes a fixedn-plane. It is larger than the largest geodesic convex ball of The geometric meaning of the condition of the above result is that t he image under the Gauss map of Mlies in a closed subset the authors [24] studied complete minimal submanifolds wh ose Gauss image lies in an open geodesic ball of radius 2 4p. They carried out the type curvature estimates and the Ecker-Huisken type curvature esti- mates, and on the basis, the corresponding Bernstein type theor ems with or growth assumption could be derived. It is natural to study the situation when b0in the condition (1.1) and (1.2) of the Theorem 1.1 approach to 2. The present paper will devote to this pr oblem. We shall follow the mainidea of our previous paper [24]. But, we view now the Gra as submanifolds in Euclidean space via Pl ucker imbedding. T he are constructed from this viewpoint. As shown before, BJX(P0) is defined in a coordinate neighborhood Uof the Grassmannian Gn,m. We introduce two functions vanduinU. Via the Gauss map we can obtain useful functions on our minimal n-submanifold MinRm+nwithm>=2. Then, we can carry out type curvature estimates and the Ecker-Huis ken type which enable us to get the corresponding Bernstein typ e theorems and other geometrical conclusions. In Section 2, we give some facts of a Grassmannian manifold Gn,m, which can be isometric imbedding into a Euclidean space. There is the height func tion for a submanifold in Euclidean space. Such a height function is called Then we have an open domain of UGn,m, where the w-function is positive. Every point in Uhas a one-to-one correspondence to an nxmmatrix. We describe canonical metric and the corresponding connection on Uwith respectCONVEX FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 3 to the coordinate. On the basis, the Hessian of an arbitrary smoot h function could be calculated. In Section 3 we define v=1 wonU. We also define another function uonU. In the section, we shall show vanduare convex on BJX(P0) and give estimates of the Hessian of them. The estimates are quite delicate. We use the radial to accurate the estimates. In Section 4, we define four auxiliary functions, They are defined on the minimal submanifolds of Rn+mwhose Gauss image is confined, and they are expressed in term of vandu. We also estimate the Laplacian of them, which is useful for the next sections. Later in Section 5, not only we give the Schoen-Simon-Yau type curv ature ~h1and~h3, with the aid of ~h2and~h4. Our method is completely similar to the previ- ous paper [24], so we only describe the outline of process. Fromthe e stimates conclusions follow, including the following Bernstein type 1.2. LetM= (x,f(x))be ann-dimensional entire minimal graph to be affine linear functions representing an affine n-plane. Theorem 1.3. LetM= (x,f(x))be ann-dimensional entire minimal graph (2 Thenfahas to be affine linear functions and hence Mhas to be an affine linear subspace. Those are what shall be done in Section 6. It is worthy to note that T heorems 1.2-1.3 still hold true when Mis a submanifold with parallel mean curvature. Dong generalized Chern's result [5] [4] to higher codimension, which states that a M= (x,f(x)) with parallel mean curvature has to be minimal if the slope offis uniformly bounded. Hence our results improve Theorem 1.1. It is natural to ask what is the relations between the results here a nd that of the previous paper [24]. Since the v-function varies the open geodesic ball of wherep= min(n,m), the results4 Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG of the present article do not generalize those in the previous one. B oth results on the Grassmannian manifold Gn,m LetRn+mbe Euclidean space. All oriented the Grassmannian manifolds Gn,m, which is an irreducible symmetric space of compact the sequel, which is spanned by a unit anyPGn,m, spanned by a n-vectore1 *** en, we define an on detW, whereW= is well known an orthogonal matrix and L p= min(m,n), where each 0 <=u2 i<=1.The Jordan angles between PandP0are defined by thi= arccos( such that {ei,en+a}form an orthornormal basis of Rm+n. Then we can span arbitrary (zia) are the local coordinate of PinU. Here and in the sequel we use the summation convention and agree the range of 1<=a,b,g,d <=m. The canonical metric on Gn,min the local coordinate can be described as (see [22] Ch. VII) (2.1) g= by an wherela= the Jordan angles between PandP0. (Here and in the sequel weCONVEX FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM loss of generality; for it is similar for n < m.) LetX,Y,W denote arbitrary nxmmatrices. Then (2.1) tells that if m+1<=i<=n,li= 0.) Furthermore, letEiabe the matrix with 1 in the intersection of row iand column aand 0 otherwise. Denote the inverse matrix Denote by the Levi-Civita connection with respect to the canonical matric on Gn,m, and by EiaEjb= from (2.2), gia,jb(P) = (1+ (2.4) and obviously (2.5) gia,jb(P) = (1+ a direct calculation from (2.3) and (2.5) Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG From (2.5), we see that (2.7) (1+ an orthonormal basis of TPGn,m. Denote its dual basis in T*
PGn,mby (2.8) estimates of two smooths functions on Gn,m OnU,w >0, then we can define (3.1) v=w-1onU. For arbitrary QUdetermined by an nxmmatrixZ, it is easily seen that (3.2) v(Q) the Jordan angles between QandP0. Now we calculate the Hessian of vatPwhose corresponding matrix is Z0. At first, by noting that for any nxnorthogonal matrix an isometry of Uwhich keeps vinvariant, we can assume Z0= (ladia) without loss of generality, where la= Jordan angles between PandP0. We also need a Lemma as follows. Lemma 3.1. LetMbe a manifold, Abe a smooth nonsingular on M,X,Ybe local tangent fields, then (3.3) that e1,***,enis a standard basis in Rn, then detA FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 7 Hence XdetA e1***en. Thereby (3.3) immediately follows. (3.4) follows from (3.3) = 0.
/square Now we let M=U,A(Z) =In+ZZT, then log v=1 2logdetA. A we compute from Lemma 3.1 that at Y.L. XIN AND LING Eiav(P) otherwise. Then, from (2.6), (3.5) and (3.6) we =EiaEjbv-(EiaEjb)v
=EiaEjbv-Gkg ia,jbEkgv FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 9 In other could be simplified further. Please note (3.5), which also tells us (3.9) oaa; then (3.10) dvdv=/summationdisplay al2 av22oaaobb. Substituting (3.10) into (3.8) that la>=0 and 1-lalb= which implies that Hess( v)Pis positive definite if and only if tha+thb<p 2for arbitrary (3.2), equality holds if and only if la=lbandlg= 0 for each Hence, we have 1-lalb>=2-v. Finally we arrive at an estimate (3.12) Hess( we introduce another smooth function on U. For any QU, (3.13) Y.L. XIN AND LING the Jordan angles between QandP0. Denote by Zthe coordinate of Q, then it is easily seen that (3.14) u(Q) = tr(ZZT). We can calculate the Hessian of uatPUwhose corresponding matrix is Z0in the same way. Similar to above, we can assume wherela= the Jordan angles between at other is positive if and only if 1 -lalb= Hence Hess( u)Pis positive definite if and only PBJX(P0).CONVEX FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 11 Moreover, the right side of (3.18) can be estimated = 2-1 2u2. (Here we used the fact By combining it with (3.17) and (2.9), we arrive that (3.19) Hess( later applications the estimates (3.12) and (3.19) are not accur ate enough. Using the radial compensation technique we could refine those estim ates which are based on the following lemmas. Lemma 3.2. LetVbe a real linear space, hbe a nonnegative definite quadratic form positive definite on V1,h(V1,V2) = 0and o(V2) = 0. Denote by o*the unique vector in V1such that for any zV1, o(z) =h(o*,z). Then we have (3.20) arbitrary yV, there exist lR,z1V1andz2V2, such = 0. Then h(y,y) (3.20) 3.3. Letohmbe a compact and convex subset of Rk, such that for every sS(k)andx= Ts(x) = S(k)denotes the permutation group of {1,***,k}. Iff: ohm-Ris a and (D2f)is nonpositive definite everywhere in ohm, then there existsx0= such that f(x0) = sup ohmf.12 Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG Proof.By the compactness of ohm, there exists x= (x1,***,xk)ohm, such that f(x) = supohmf. Furthermore we = sup ohmf sS(k) from the fact that fis symmetric. Denote by Cs(x) the convex closure of {Ts(x) : sS(k)}, thenCs(x)ohm supohmffor since ( D2f)<=0; which then x0= (x1 0,***,xk 0) which (3.22) (3.12), (3.23) hdef.= nonnegative definite on TPGn,m. Denote (3.24) V and (3.11), (2.9), (3.9) tell us h(V1,V2) = 0, dv(V2) = 0 and (3.25) Denoteby in V1such thatforany XV1, h(~v,X) =dv(X). From (3.25) and (3.9), it is not difficult to dv(~v) FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 13 Then Lemma 3.2 and (3.23) tell us (3.27) Hess( is necessary to estimate the upper bound Denote (3.28) na= log(1+ since logv=1 2/summationdisplay alog(1+l2 a) we define (3.29) ohm obviously ohm is compact and convex, Ts(ohm) = ohm for every sS(m) (cf. Lemma 3.3), fis a symmetric function and a direct calculation when v(1,2]. Then from Lemma is an upper bound Substituting it into (3.27) summary, we have the following 3.1. vis a convex function on BJX(P0)UGn,m, and (3.30) Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG Similarly, we consider (3.31) ~hdef.= is nonnegative definite on TPGn,m. The definition of V1andV2is similar to above. It is easily seen from (3.17) and (2.9) that
~h(V1,V2) = 0 and (3.32) positive definite. By (3.15), (3.33) = 0. Hence Lemma 3.2 can be applied for us to obtain (3.34) Hess( the unique element in V1such that for arbitrary XV1,
~h(~u,X) =du(X). From (3.32) and (3.33), we can hence (3.35) du(~u) tells us it is necessary for us to estimate the upper bound of t he right side ohm = ohm is compact and convex, Ts(ohm) = ohm for every sS(m),fis a symmetric function and a direct calculation FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 15 To show ( D2f)<=0 whenu(0,2], it is sufficient to prove F: a nonnegative function, where C=u2 4(0,1]. IfFattains its minimum at t0(0,u), then 0 =F'(t0) = = 6(3C-1)t0+12C. (3.37) On the other hand, when 3 C-1>=0, we have which causes a contradiction; when 3 C-1<0, from (3.37), t0<=2C 1-3C, =
9C-3C2>0, which also causes a contradiction. conjunction with F(0) = 4 C-2C2>0 F(u) = a nonnegative function. Thereby applying Lemma 3.3 we have (3.38) (3.38) into (3.34) rewrite the conclusion as the following 3.2. uis a convex function on construction of auxiliary h1=v-k(2-v)k,16 Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG wherek >0 to be chosen, derivative with respect to v. Hence, from (3.30) Hess(h1) note thatv-1 v2 p-1is an increasing function on [1 ,2]: it is easily seen when pis even, when pis follows we take (4.3) FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM and then (4.2) becomes (4.4) Hess( h1)<= h3= >0 to be chosen. A direct calculation derivative with respect to u. Combining with (3.39), we have Hess(h3) 1+2 p. Thereby (4.8) becomes (4.10) Hess( h3)<= Y.L. XIN AND LING h4=h-3p p+2 3= ann-dimensional submanifold in Rn+mwithm>=2.The Gauss map g:M-Gn,mis defined by g(x) =TxMGn,m via the parallel translation in Rm+nfor arbitrary xM. The energy density of the Gauss map (see [21] Chap.3, SS3.1) is e(g) proved that the mean curvature vector of Mis parallel if and only if its Gauss map is a harmonic map [17]. If the Gauss image of Mis contained in {PUGn,m:v(P)<2}, then the composition function ~h1=h1*gofh1with the Gauss map gdefines a function on M. Using composition formula, we have (4.13)~h1= is the tension field of the Gauss map, which is zero, provided Mhas parallel mean curvature by the Ruh-Vilms theorem mentioned above . Similarly, on M, we have (4.14)~h2= the Gauss image of Mis contained in {PUGn,m:u(P)<2}, we can defined composition function Again formula, we obtain (4.15) ~h3<= FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 19 and (4.16) the aid of ~h1and~h3, we immediately have the following lemma. Lemma 4.1. LetMbe ann-dimensional minimal submanifold of Rn+m(Mneeds not be complete), if the Gauss image of Mis contained in respectively, then we any function phwith compact support DM. Remark 4.1. For a stable minimal hypersurface there is the stability ine quality, which is one of main ingredient for curv ature esimates for sta- ble minimal hypersurfaces. For minimal submanifolds with t he Gauss image restric- tion we have stronger inequality as shown in (4.17). Our proo f is similar to [23]and [24], so we omit the detail of it. 5.Curvature estimates We are now in a position to carry out the curvature estimates of Sch oen-Simon- Yau type. LetMbe ann-dimensional minimal submanifold in Rn+m. Assume that for arbitrary function phwith compact support DM, wherelis a phby|B|1+qphin (5.1) Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG Using Bochner technique, the estimate done in [14][7], and the Kato-t ype in [24], we obtain (5.3) the detail, see [24] Section 2.) It is equivalent |B|2qph2with both sides of (5.4) and integrating by parts, we both sides of (5.2) and then adding up both sides of it and (5.5), we using Young's inequality, (5.6) l we can choose esufficiently small, such depends on n,m,landq.CONVEX FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 21 Combining with (5.2) and (5.10), we can again using Young's inequality. By replacing phbyph2+qin (5.11) and then using H older inequality, we (5.12) whereCis a constant only depending on replacing phbyph1+qin (5.11) and then again using H older (5.13) whereC'is a constant only depending on a function on Mwith|r| <=1. For any R[0,R0], whereR0= r<=R}
is compact. (5.12) and Lemma 4.1 enable us to prove the following results by taking ph C c(MR) to be the standard cut-off function such that ph1 inMthRand|ph| 5.1. LetMbe ann-dimensional minimal submanifolds of Rn+m. If the Gauss image of MRis contained in {PUGn,m:v(P)<2}, then we have arbitrary and the Gauss image of MRis contained in (5.14) still holds for arbitrary can also fulfil the curvature estimates of Ecker-Huisken type. Assume that his a positive function on Msatisfying the following estimate (5.15) h>=3h g+c0h-1dhdh,22 Y.L. XIN AND LING a positive constant. We compute from (5.15) and Young's inequality, when 2 i.e., (5.16) a smooth function with compact support. Integrating by parts in con- junction with Young's inequality lead H older (5.21) into (5.20), we finally arrive FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 23 TakeeC c(MR) to be the standard cut-off function such that e1 inMthR and|e| <=C(1-th)-1R-1; then from (5.22) we have the following 5.2. LetMbe ann-dimensional minimal submanifolds of Rn+m. If there exists a positive function honMsatisfying (5.15), then there exists C1=
C1(n,m,c 0),such (4.14) and (4.16), if the Gauss image of Mis contained in orp<=4 and the Gauss image of Mis contained in there exists a positive function on M, which is ~h2or respectively ~h4, satisfying (5.15). Hence the estimate (5.23) holds for both the mean valueinequality forany subharmonic funct ionon in Rm+n(ref. [8], [16]) can be applied to yield an estimate of the upper bound of |B|2. We write the results as the following theorem without detail of proo f, for it is similar to [24]. Please note that BR(x)Rm+ndenotes a ball of radius R centered at xMand its restriction on Mis denoted by DR(x) =BR(x)M. Theorem 5.3. LetxM,R >0such that the image of DR(x)under the Gauss map lies in {PUGn,m:v(P)<2}. Then, there exists C1=C1(n,m), such that (5.24) arbitrary s>=C1. Ifp<=4, the image of DR(x)under the Gauss map lies in then there exists C2=C2(n,m)such that (5.25) for any type theorems and related results IfMis a submanifold in Rn+m, then the function wdefined on Gn,m(see yielding M, which is also denoted by w. By studying the properties of w-function, we can obtain:24 Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG Proposition 6.1. [24]LetMbe a complete submanifoldin Rn+m. If thew-function is boundedbelow by a positive constant w0. ThenMis an entire graph with Euclidean volume growth. Precisely, (6.1) we let Mbe a complete minimal submanifold in Rn+mwhose Gauss image lies Proposition 6.1 tells usMis an entire graph. Precisely, the immersion F:M-Rm+nis realized by a graph ( x,f(x)) with f:Rn-Rm. At each point in Mits image n-planePunder the Gauss map is spanned the local coordinate of (3.2), v(P) eachxRn. Conversely, if M= (x,f(x)) is a minimal graph given by f:Rn- Rmwhich satisfy (6.2), then the Gauss image of Mlies that u(P) then cos2tha= Proposition 6.1 could be applied when Mis a complete minimal Gauss image lies in {PUGn,m:v(P)<2}; which is hence a minimal graph given by f:Rn-Rm. Thereby (3.14) vice versa. Theorem 5.1 and Proposition 6.1 give us the following Bernstein-type t heorem.CONVEX FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 25 Theorem 6.1. LetM= (x,f(x))be ann-dimensional entire minimal graph to be affine linear functions representing an affine f<2, then the Gauss image of Mis contained in We choose s= letrbe the Euclidean distance function from letting R-+in (5.14) 0. i.e.,|B|= 0.Mhas to be an affine linear subspace. For the case L f<2, the proof is similar. /square Theorem 5.3 and Proposition 6.1 yield Bernstein type results as follows . Theorem 6.2. LetM= (x,f(x))be ann-dimensional entire minimal graph (2 Thenfahas to be affine linear functions and hence Mhas to be an affine linear 6.3. LetM= (x,f(x))be ann-dimensional entire minimal graph min{n,m} <=4. (2 Thenfahas to be affine linear functions and hence Mhas to be an affine linear subspace.26 Y.L. XIN AND LING YANG Proof.Here we only give the proof of Theorem 6.2, for the proof of Theore m 6.3 is similar. From (4.5), it is easily seen a positive constant. Thus, for any point qM, by Theorem 5.3 and Proposition 6.1, we the above inequality forces |B(q)|= 6.1. Ifn= 2or3, the conclusion of Theorem 6.1-6.3 could be inferred from the work done by Chern-Osserman [6], Babosa [1]and Fischer-Colbrie [10]. From (5.13) it is easy to obtain the following result. Theorem 6.4. LetM= (x,f(x))be ann-dimensional entire minimal graph fa(x1,***,xn). Assume Mhas finite total curvature. If f<2, or p<=4andLf<2, thenMhas to be an affine linear subspace. There are other applications of the strong stability inequalities (4.17 ), besides its key role in S-S-Y's estimates. We state following results, whose deta il proof can be found in the previous paper of the first author [23]. Theorem 6.5. LetM= (x,f(x))be ann-dimensional entire minimal graph fa(x1,***,xn). Iff<2orLf<2, then any L2-harmonic 6.6. LetMbe one as in Theorem 6.5, Nbe a manifold with curvature. Then any harmonic map f:M-Nwith finite energy has to be J.L.M.Babosa: An extrinsic rigidity theorem for minimal immersion fro mS2intoSn. J. dif- ferntial Geometry 14(3)(1980), 355-368. 2. S. Bernstein: Sur un th' eor` eme de g' eom' etrie et ses applicat ion aux ' equations aux d' eriv' es partielles du type elliptique. Comm. de la Soc Math. de Kharkov (2' e s' E. Bombieri, E. De Giorgiand E. Guusti: Minimal conesand Bernste in problem. 243-268. 4. Yuxin Dong: On graphic submanifolds with parallel mean curvature in Euclidean S. S. Chern: On the curvature of a piece of hypersurfaces in Eu clidean space, Abh. Math. Sem. Univ. Hamberg 29(1965), 77-91. 6. S. S. Chern and R. Osserman: Complete minimal surfaces in Euclide ann-space. J. 15-34.CONVEX FUNCTIONS AND LAWSON-OSSERMAN PROBLEM 27 7. Qing Chen and Senlin Xu: Rigidity of compact minimal submanifolds in a u nit sphere. Geom. Dedicata 45 (1)(1993), 83-88. 8. S. Y. Cheng, P. Li and S. T. Yau: Heat equations on minimal subma nifols and their applica- tions. Amer. J. Math. 103(1981), 1021-1063. 9. K. Ecker and G. Huisken: A Bernstein result for minimal graphs of controlled growth. J. 397-400. 10. D. Fischer-Colbrie: Some submanifo ldsofthe 29-46. 11. S. Hildebrandt, J. Jost, J and K. O. Widman: Harmonic mappings a nd minimal math. 62(1980), 269-298. 12. J. Jost and Y. L. Xin: Bernstein type theorems for higher codim ension. Calculus. Var. PDE 9 (1999), 277-296. 13. H. B. Lawson and R. Osserman: Non-existence, non-uniquene ss and irregularity of solutions to the minimal surface system. Acta math. 139(1977), 1-17. 14. An-Min Li and Jimin Li: An intrinsic rigidity theorem for minimal subma nifolds in a sphere. Arch. Math. 58(1992), 582-594. 15. J. Moser: On Harnack's theorem for elliptic differential equation s. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 14(1961), 577-591. 16. Lei Ni: Gap theorems for minimal submanifolds in Rn+1. Comm. Analy. Geom. 9 E. A. Ruh and J. Vilms: The tension field of Gauss map. Trans. Ame r. Math. R. Schoen, L. Simon and S. T. Yau: Curvature estimates for min imal hypersurfaces. 275-288. 19. J. Simons: Minimal varieties in Riemannian manifolds. Ann. Math. 88(1968), 62-105. 20. K. Smoczyk, Guofang Wang and Y. L. Xin: Bernstein type theor ems with flat normal bundle. Calc. Var. and PDE. 26(1)(2006), 57-67. 21. Y. L. Xin: Geometry of harmonic maps. Birkh auser PNLDE 23, ( 1996). 22. Yuanlong Xin: Minimal submanifolds and related topics. World Scien tific Publ., (2003). 23. Y. L. Xin: Bernstein type theorems without graphic condition. A sia J. Math. of Mathematics, Fudan University, Shanghai 2004 33, China and Key Laboratory of Mathematics for Nonlinear Sciences (Fudan Un iversity), Ministry of Education E-mail address
|
0806.4247
|
Yuanlong Xin
|
Y. L. Xin and Ling Yang
|
Convex functions on Grassmannian manifolds and Lawson-Osserman problem
|
27 pages
| null | null | null |
math.DG
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We derive estimates of the Hessian of two smooth functions defined on
Grassmannian manifold. Based on it, we can derive curvature estimates for
minimal submanifolds in Euclidean space via Gauss map. In this way, the result
for Bernstein type theorem done by Jost and the first author could be improved.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 26 Jun 2008 06:58:03 GMT"
}
] | 2008-06-27T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Xin",
"Y. L.",
""
],
[
"Yang",
"Ling",
""
]
] |
The great interest which DNA attracted in molecular electronic experiments is related to the vision of a truly bottom up electronics at the molecular scale.1 The very controversial results concerning the conduction of DNA oligomers are ascribable to their internal complexity and their sensitivity to the surrounding environment. It is currently well accepted2 that the mechanisms of charge migration in DNA wires cannot be addressed independent ly of their mechanical properties. Recently, magnetic AFM experiments in the Bustamante group3 allowed, while independently stretching and twisting single double stranded DNA oligomers, to access many well controlled structural configurations of DNA wires. When stre tching a DNA short molecule by pulling one of its ends with a standard AFM tip and having th e other end fixed on a surface, the angle f between consecutive base pairs reduces from its e quilibrium value of 36 degrees. Smaller angle f lead to an increased p-p overlap, resulting in larger charge transfer integrals.6-8 On the other hand, the combined twist-stretch process leads increased inter-base dist ances d, effectively decreasing the values of the charge transfer integrals, therefore, antagonizing the effect of twist. This may lead to a complex behavior of electronic properties of DNA durin g the stretching process. Interestingly, a non monotonous behavior of the transp ort response of stretched DNA has been in fact reported by Cohen et al .4 and switching and intermittency in DNA break j unctions experiments has been observed by Kang et al .5 As one possible explanation Kang et al. discuss the change in overlap between neighboring bases as a result of a changed DNA configuration during th e stretching process, which has been investigated theoretically before,9 however, only for few geometry snapshots. In this letter, we investigate the conductance chan ge of DNA along the conformation transition for the stretch-twist process in more detail. Our calculations demonstrate, that the charges transfer integrals and the tunneling current show such a no n monotonic dependence for this process, leading to a switching behavior of the electric al response; the resulting intermitting I-d characteristics may explain the recent experiments findings.4,5 Our numerical calculations are further supported by a minimal analytical solvable model. For this study, we parameterize a model Hamiltonia n from the density functional theory based tight binding (DFTB) method.10,11 For every geometry snapshot along the stretch-twist path, the effective HOMO-HOMO t, between two nearest neighbor GC pairs and the effective HOMO level, e, within one GC pair are calculated from DFTB. Subsequently, we use model Hamiltonian methods based on these parameters to estimate the non-equilibrium current-voltage characteristics for bias voltages of the order of the HOMO-LUMO gap. In order to calculate the parameters t and e, we have implemented in DFTB the molecular fragment orbitals method.12 The whole molecule is then partitioned into several fragments (shown in figure 2), consisting of hydrogen bonded base pairs, thereby neglecting the electronically inactive sugars and phosphate groups. Every fragment molecular orbital (FMO) Ps, which is localized on the base pair, is calculated within DFTB independently, as a linear combination of atomic orbitals, , ii cmmme Ps= . Here m is the index of atomic orbitals (AOs) and i is used for FMOs. Furthermore, we can transform the Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian from the AO picture to the FMO one as follows,
*=
nmnnm m ,,KS , ,KS , j i ji cHc H . Therefore, by means of the method presented in Refs. [6, 12], in the case of small overlaps ,ijS between consecutive FMOs, the HOMO-HOMO t between the nearest neighbor GC pairs can be perturbatively obtained as ()ji ii jj ji ji ji SH HS H t,KS ,KS , ,KS , ,21+ - = , (2) Here i and j are HOMO indexes for the molecular wire made of consecutive GC-FMOs. The system we considered consists of a poly(GC) wire containing N base pairs, contacted to left and right electrodes (figure 2). The resulting Hamiltonian can then be read as follows, DNA-lead leads DNA H H H H + + = , (3) with () () ( ) ,.. ,1 DNA-lead,,+
, , leads+ +
, 1+
DNA
= = =
+ + + ==+ + =
kk N kN kk kkk k kN jiij j i jiN iiii ch cd V ch cdV Hcc Hdd ddt dd H aa aaaa a aee where DNAH is a model for DNA. +
id and id are the electron operators on the FMO i. The parameters jit, can be obtained from Eqs. (2), while ie is the HOMO level of base-pair; a is lead index and c are lead electron operators; k,ae are k space energies in lead a; DNA-leadH describes the electron hopping between DNA and leads. The Green function r/aG can be calculated by mean s of the technique, ()1() () ,r/a r/a DNAI GHoo o-=- - S (4) where I is the identity operator, ),( )( )(r/a Rr/a Lr/ao o o S+ S= S while ,2/ i )(1, 1,Lr/a ,;L j i ji dd o G-= S and .2/ i )(, , Lr/a ,;R jNiN ji dd o G-= S aG is the level-width function from lead a. The current can be obtained by Landauer formula, []- = )( )()(2 R L o o oo f f TdheI (5) { } ()ra LR Tr TG Go=G G (6) with ()a ri~
a a a S-S=G , )(oaf is the Fermi function of lead a, and )(oT is the transmission function. The poly(GC) wire process can be described by in linear response as proposed by the Bustamante group3 dkD-=Dph , (7) where Sg k /1=-, pN200 1100 +- =S is the stretch modulus13-16 and nmpN100 200 +- =g is the stretch-twist The stretching distance is eqddd -=D , and the twisting angle is eqphphph -=D , while d is the distance between the two nearest-neighbor GC pairs, ph is the angle between them, and subscript 'eq' indicates equilibrium position ( 4.3eq=d A, D36eq=ph ). For every molecular mechanic co nfiguration in the process, the HOMO-HOMO t between two GC pairs is then calculated . The results for the transfer integral t are shown in figure 1: Starting from the equilibrium position the distance is increased and the twist angle ph reduced following Eq. (8); t is first suppressed and it then exhibits a local maximum. The physics of this process can be understood in terms of the competition between stretching and twisting. As known in the literature,6,7 for a pure twisting process (distance eqdd is fixed), decreasing the angle ph, implies a reduction of | t| followed by a rapid increase. Fo r a pure stretching process, | t| is always exponentially suppressed as it happens in tunneling through vacuum. Therefore the full stretch- twist process can be understood as the dominanc e of an angle enhanced transfer integral t over pure stretching after the critical value 0phph= ( 45.40 =dd A). Further in the stretching process, the exponentially suppressed distance-related t unneling dominates over the increase of the p orbital alignment in the eclipsed configuration. The physics for this process can also be visualized by means of the density distribution of electrons in the bonding and anti-bonding orbitals of the two HOMOs (figure 3). At the equilibrium position, the overlap of p-p bond from two GC pairs is strong enough (figure 3(a,b)). For 0phph= (0dd= ), the HOMO of each GC pair is completely lo calized (figure 3(c,d)). This results in no overlap between the two HOMOs. After that, the HOMO-HOMO overlap is agai n increased (figure 3(e,f)), before being again suppressed due to over-distance tunneling. Ignoring boundary effect on the level structure of DNA, we can consider si te independent quantities e ei and t tji, in rest of this work. With these parame ters, we investigate the response of the current through a poly(GC) wire in depende nce of the different lead-DNA couplings G in the process. We consider here 30=N consecutive base pairs and fix the bias voltage biasV at -2.0 V; V5.1F e E -= -e , FE is the Fermi level at zero bias. In DNA nanoelectronic experiments the backbone is thiol-anchored to gold electrodes, which we model with injection rate values of G in the meV regime. The calculat ed current-distance response is shown in figure 5. Remarkably enough wh ile reducing the coupling G the current signal oscillates between equal-height on-values and off values. The presence of such on-plateau in the proc ess can be understood by an analytic treatment of the two base pair limit. In this la tter case, we can elaborate from Eq. (7) a formula for the transmission function in dependence of lead-DNA coupling G: [] [], )2/(4 )2/() )( ()2/() )( (2 )2/() (1 )2/() (1 4)( 2 2222 2 2 2 22
G + G+ - -G+ - --G+ -+G+ -G=
- +- +
- + tT eoeoeoeo eo eoo (8) here e ee = =2 1 , t t=2,1 , G=G=GR L and 2/iR L G-=S=S , t+-=+-e e . For the case of t G, at the poles +-=eo , we can attain the quantum limit 1)(=oT independently of t. This explains the emerging of the current on-plateau. In a conclusion, we have investigated the electr ical response of poly(GC) wires under a mechanical process. In the overstretchi ng regime we find local maxima for the t between two nearest-neighbor GC pairs, arising from the competition between stretching and twisting. This leads to an intermitte nt current response which strongly depends on the DNA-electrode coupling G. For those mechanical configuratio ns, where the transfer integral t is larger than G, a current plateau is observed. In the case of experimentally relevant small G's, several equal height on/off switching responses are observed. These results are supported by the independe nt experimental observation in the Scheer5 and the Porath groups.4 Our results suggest, that these finding can be understood as a competition of stretching and twisting effects on the charge tran sfer parameters. The poly-GC structures presented here server as a model for the more complex sequenc es used in experiments. However, the behavior of the t parameters upon stretch and twist is very simila r for other base pair combinations like A-G, AA 6-8. Therefore, we expect for ot her sequences the same qualitative pictures. Of course, dynamic aspects and the effects of solvent are neglected in this model study. During dynamics, the base pairs will fluctuate around equilibrium positions, ther efore proper sampling would have to calculate averages of t and ealong the trajectories. However, it can be expected that the behavior of the averages is qualitatively the same as for the parameters along th e ideal stretching pathway as considered here. The solvent degrees of freedom lead to fluctuations in the onsite parameters. Again, averages have to be taken, which we assume to be not relevant to understand the qualitative picture. ACKNOWLEDGMENT. We acknowledge fruitful discu ssions with Rafael Gutierrez. This work was funded by Deutsche (DFG) within the project CU 44/5-1 of the Priority Program SPP 1243, by the DFG project CU 44/3-2, and by the EU project IST-029192-2 DNA-based nanoelectronic devices. Support from the Volk swagen Foundation under grant No. I/78 340 is also gratefully acknowledged. FIGURE CAPTIONS Figure 1. (Color online) The t for the process as a function of the distance between two GC pairs, d, and the angle f. The green dashed line represents the equilibrium position 4.3eq=d A, D36eq=ph . The blue dashed-dotted line represents the suppression point ( 45.40d A, D6.240ph ). The three horizontal shot-dashed gr ay lines are the references used for the intensity of the DNA coupling to the electrodes displayed in figure 5. Figure 2. (Color online) Partition of the DNA molecular junctions for the fragment molecular orbital calculation. See text for details. Figure 3. (Color online) Electron density distribution. (a) HOMO at 4.3eq=d A, D36eq=ph . (b) HOMO-1 at 4.3eq=d A, D36eq=ph . (c) HOMO at 45.40d A, D6.240ph . (d) HOMO-1 at 45.40d A, D6.240ph . (e) HOMO at 0.5=d A, D6.18=ph . (f) HOMO-1 at 0.5=d A, D6.18=ph . Figure 4. (Color online) Coupling vs distance de pendence of the transfer integral t at V0.2bias -= V for a 30 base pair long poly(GC). Here V5.1GC e -=e , and d is for the distance between two GC pairs. The green dash line is for equilibrium position ( 4.3eq=d A). Figure 5. (Color online) Current-distance relations along the three red (dash-dot) lines in figure 4 with same parameters. (a) Vm5.9 e =G , (b) Vm3e =G , (c) Vm1e =G . The blue dash-dot lines are for the position (0dd= , 0phph= ). REFERENCES [1] Lecture Notes in Physics , Cuniberti G., Fagas G., Richter K., Ed., Springer Berlin, 2005 , Vol. 68. [2] Porath D., Cuniberti G., and Di Felice R., Topics in Current Chemistry 2004 , 237, 183. [3] Gore J., Bryant Z., Nollmann M., Le M. U., Cozzarelli N. R., and Bustamante C., Nature 2006, 442, 836. [4] Cohen H., Nogues C., Naaman R., and Porath D., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 2005 , 102, 11589. [5] Kang N., Erbe A., Scheer E., New J. Phys. 2008 , 10, 023030. [6] Senthilkumar K., Grozema F. C., Guerra C. F., Bickelha upt F. M., Lewis F. D., Berlin Y. A., Ratner M. A., and Siebbeles L. D. A., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005 , 127, 14894. [7] Grozema F. C., Siebbeles L. D. A., Berlin Y. A., and Ratner M. A., CHEMPHYSCHEM 2002 , 3, 536. [8] Felice R. D., Calzolari A., Molinari E., and Garbesi A., Phys. Rev. B 2001 , 65, 045104. [9] Maragakis P., Barnett R. L., Kaxiras E., Elstner M., and Frauenheim T., Phys. Rev. B 2002, 66, 241104. [10] Elstner M., Porezag D., Jungnickel G., Elsner J. , Haugk M., Frauenheim T., Suhai S., and Seifert G., Phys. Rev. B 1998 , 58, 7260. [11] Frauenheim T., Seifert G., Elstner M., Hajnal Z. , Jungnickel G., Porezag D., Suhai S., and Scholz R., Phys. Stat. Sol. (b) 2000 , 217, 41. [12] Newton M. D., Chem. Rev. 1991 , 91, 767. [13] Bustamante C., Smith S. B., Liphardt J., and Smith D., Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol. 2000 , 10, 279. [14] Bryant Z., Stone M. D., Gore J., Smit h S. B., Cozzarelli N. R., and Bustamante C., Nature 2003 , 424, 338. [15] Smith S. B., Cui Y., and Bustamante C., Science 1996 , 271, 795. [16] Wang M. D., Yin H., Landick R., Gelles J., and Block S. M., Biophys. J. 1997 , 72, 1335. [17] Strick T. R., Allemand J.-F., Bensimon D., Bensimon A., and Croquette V., Science 1996 , 271, 1835. [18] Marko J. F., Europhys. Lett. 1997 , 38, 183. [19] Kamien R. D., Lubensky T. C., Nelson P., and O'Hern C. S., Europhys. Lett. 1997 , 38, 237. [20] Moroz J. D. and Nelson P., Macromolecules 1998 , 31, 6333. [21] Cluzel P., Lebrun A., Heller C., Lavery R., Viovy J.-L., Chatenay D., and Caron F., Science 1996 , 271, 792. Figures Figure 1 Figure 2 Figure 3 Figure 4 Figure 5
|
0806.4486
|
Bo Song
|
Bo Song, Marcus Elstner, Gianaurelio Cuniberti
|
Anomalous conductance response of DNA wires under stretching
| null | null |
10.1021/nl801542g
| null |
cond-mat.mes-hall cond-mat.mtrl-sci physics.bio-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The complex mechanisms governing charge migration in DNA oligomers reflect
the rich structural and electronic properties of the molecule of life.
Controlling the mechanical stability of DNA nanowires in charge transport
experiments is a requisite for identifying intrinsic issues responsible for
long range charge transfers. By merging density-functional-theory-based
calculations and model-Hamiltonian approaches, we have studied DNA quantum
transport during the stretching-twisting process of poly(GC) DNA oligomers.
During the stretching process, local maxima in the charge transfer integral t
between two nearest-neighbor GC pairs arise from the competition between
stretching and twisting. This is reflected in local maxima for the conductance,
which depend very sensitively on the coupling to the electrodes. In the case of
DNA-electrode couplings smaller than t, the conductance versus stretching
distance saturates to plateau in agreement with recent experimental
observations.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 27 Jun 2008 11:06:38 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Mon, 30 Jun 2008 12:11:34 GMT"
}
] | 2015-05-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Song",
"Bo",
""
],
[
"Elstner",
"Marcus",
""
],
[
"Cuniberti",
"Gianaurelio",
""
]
] |
Contents 1. Background 1 2. Results 2 3. The SU(2/1)lepton representation 4 4. The SU(2/1)quark representation 5 5. The scalar propagator 7 6. The scalar potential 10 7. Scalar Ward identities 12 8. The mass of the Higgs 13 9. The 14 10. The electro-weak angle 16 11. Discussion 16 1. Background The Weinberg-Salam SU(2).U(1) model of the electro-magnetic and weak Sa68] is extremely accurate. At high energy, the Fer mions are describedas massless SU(2) doublets of left spinors: the electron neutrino left dou blet (eL,nL) withU(1) charge (-1), and the up and down left quark doublet ( uL,dL) with charge (2/3), accompanied by right singlets: the right electron ( eR) with charge (-2) and the right quarks ( uR),(dR) with respective charges (4/3) and (-1/3). The right neutrino is SU(2) andU(1) neutral and drops out from the SU(2) andU(1) Yang-Mills gauge fields [YM54] are the ( W+,W-), theZ0and the photon. The existence and interactions of the W+, theW-and the Z0 were beautifully confirmed over the last 30 years. The only co mponent of the model that has not yet been observed is the scalar Higgs field. In the mini mal approach, it is predicted to be a scalar SU(2) doublet phwithU(1) charge (-1). The Higgs potential is assumed to be of the form V(ph) = (ph2-v2)2So, in the vacuum the Higgs field does not vanish. The gauge group breaks down to the electro-magnetic U(1), the maximal subgroup leaving v - 1 -invariant. The photon and the left neutrino remain massless . All other particles acquire a mass proportional to v(see for example [AL73]). This construction is superb, but the number of arbitrary par ameters is very large. Since the left and right chiral states are independent, we ne ed to choose 10 charges to describe the leptons and the quarks. For example, a massless electrically charged particle, which experimentally does not exist, would be acceptable at the classical level and is only ruled out by the study of the quantum anomalies. Also, since t he Higgs field plays such a central role, one would wish to derive it from first principle . The Yang-Mills gauge fields are well understood, but the Higgs potential and even the num ber of Higgs fields needed in the standard model remain arbitrary. In 1979, Ne'eman [N79] and Fairlie [F79] have independently proposed to Lie superalgebra as a basis for describing the weak intera ctions. Indeed, the fundamental representation, recalled in section 3, exactl y corresponds to the lepton triplet if we grade it by chirality. The representation is Hermitian (3.2) and scaling the trace of all the even matrices to a common value seemed to predict a electr o-weak angle sin2thW= 1/4, a good value at the time, although higher than today's experi mental value .22. In addition, the odd generators have the quantum numbers of the Higgs field s. The quarks were either left out [F79] or mentioned as a counterargument [N79]. But r emarkably, it was found a few weeks later [DJ79, NT80] that SU(2/1) also admits a 4 dimensional in section 4, exactly fitting the quarks, with 2 righ t singlets and a left doublet with electric charges 2 /3 ], but also some doubts [S92]. A superalgebraic structure seems in direct conflict with unitarity. The supertrace, which is the natural invariant of a superalg ebra, yields a negative sign for the propagator of the U(1) vector, the quark representation (4.3) is neither Hermi tian and even the Hermitian nature of the lepton representation is the odd generators of antilepton representation are a nti-Hermitian (3.8). It was therefore often argued that the SU(2/1) superalgebra could not play a role in the quantum field theory. The present paper reverses the situation. 2. Results By following literally the paradigm of the minimal coupling s and turning immediately to the renormalization theory, we predict 2 Higgs doublets HandK. This solves the problem of the metric and allows to adjust freely the electro-weak an gle. We prove that in vacuum the photon remains massless beca use of the super-Jacobi iden- tity. For a particular choice of the scalar coupling constan ts, we find a scalar Ward that the 1-loop counterterms do not depend on the nu mber of families and derive the mass relation M2 H0 1+M2 H0 2= 32/9M2 W= 2 (107 .2GeV)2. The whole on balance between the leptons and the quarks which ens ures the cancellation of the triangle anomaly [BIM72]. The theory is however incomplete , because the scalar loops and the gluon loops disturb the superalgebraic structure. - 2 -We start in section 5 from the assumption that the adjoint rep resentation of the SU(2/1) superalgebra directly describes the Bosons of the theory , and that the quark and lepton representations, graded by chirality, describe their interactions to the Fermions. The even generators are gauged as usual as Yang-Mills vector fields. But since the odd generators are not Hermitian, we propose (5.3) to separate t he left and right interactions and construct 2 sets of scalar fields, Ph Land PhRby projecting out the relevant chiral part of the odd matrices, and to define the interactions We then construct the rest of the Lagrangian by studying the counter terms induced by the shown in (5.4), the left-trace of the odd matrices induces the propagator of the scalar fields. It is antisymmetric and proportional to the su per-Killing metric, as befits a superalgebra. But since the Ph Land Ph Rare distinct, the propagator does not vanish by symmetrization and can be rediagonalized (5.9) in the for m of 2 Higgs scalar HandK.His coupled to the negatively charged right particles (elect ron and down quark) and Kto the positively charged right up quark. This re-shuffling de pends on the same balance between the leptons and the quarks which can cels the triangle anomaly and the equations are similar. In the later case, one compute s the triple vector Fermion loop, which is possibly spoiled by the impossibility to regu larize the chiral Fermions in a gauge invariant way, and depends on a supertrace condition ( 4.5). In the present paper we compute the 2 scalars and 4 scalars Fermion loops, which ar e a priori spoiled by the non Hermitian nature of the SU(2/1) scalar-Fermion couplings. In all cases, we find that the respective contributions of the leptons and the quarks c ancel each other and induce a canonical 6, we construct theHiggs potential. A priori, sin ce we have 2 Higgs doublets, there are 3 possible SU(2)U(1) invariant quartic terms V1= (H2)2+(K2)2which controls the mass of the neutral Higgs fields, a kind of vector product s quaredV2(H,K) which controls the mass of the charged Higgs fields, and a scalar pro duct squared V3= (H.K)2. We show that V2vanishes if HandKare parallel as a consequence of the and that V3is absent, because of the lepton quark compensation. The pot ential can then berewrittenin termsof /tildewideG(6.2) whichplays theroleof the Killing metric and contains a free parameter alater associated (10.3) to the This construction gives the structure of the scalar p otential, but not the strength of the couplings. In section 7, we show that for a particular value of the scalar Fermion coupling, we have a Ward identity insuring that the Fermion loops do not modify the of the scalar and vector couplings and that the scal ar potential This indicates that the mass of the neutral Higgs fields shou ld satisfy the 32/9M2 W= (151.6GeV)2. In the symmetric situation, we would 107.2GeV. However, we also observe that other quantum the universality of the scalar-Fermion coupling, i ndicating that the theory is section 9, we show that the chiral decomposition of the Hig gs scalars, in conjunction with the Dirac 1-forms G of [TM06], naturally constructs a co variant differential corre- - 3 -sponding to the SU(2/1) Hermitian algebra first defined by Ste rnberg and Wolf [SW78]. The chirality operator and the complex Higgs structure cons pire so that the 2-forms is well defined and indeed valued in the adj oint representation of the SU(2)U(1) even Lie to construct the vector Lagrangian and show that the squa reof theH-algebra curvature tensor reproduces the Higgs quartic potential induced by re normalization. Within this SU(2/1) framework, the electro-weak angle is free. The theory is not complete and several important problems ar e presented in the dis- cussion. But even considering these difficulties, the result s so far are new and to 30 years after the initial proposal [N79, F79], this is the first time that SU(2/1) is shown to play a role in the quantized theory, and the first time that the super-Killing met- ric is used, both in the construction of the propagators (5.9 and 10.1) and of the while explicitly respecting unitarity. 3. TheSU(2/1)lepton smallest nontrivial simple Lie superalgebra is SU(2/1), also called A(1/0) in the Cartan-Kac classification. The Lie sub-algebra A0isSU(2)U(1), and the odd A0module A1is a complex doublet with U(1) charge -1. The fundamental representation [SNR77] is of superdimension (2/1) and fits the leptons [N79, F79]. In the (nL, eL;eR) basis, the 4 even generators read: l1=
0 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 , l2=
0-i0 i0 0 0 0 0 , l3=
1 0 0 0-1 0 0 0 0 , l8=
1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 . (3.1) the 4 odd generators read: l4=
0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 , l5=
0 0-i 0 0 0 i0 0 , l6=
0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 , l7=
0 0 0 0 the chirality operator (3.3) By inspection, we find that the anticommutator of the odd matr ices close on the even matrices, defining the symmetric structure constants da ijand that the commutators of the odd matrices close on khtimes the even matrices, defining the skew-symmetric struct ure constants kh fa ijla, a= 1,2,3,8 ;i,j= 4,5,6,7(3.4) - 4 -in these conventions, the are real. Finally, the vacuum vis chosen along the l6direction, whose centralizer is the photon: photon = =
0 0 0 0-1 0 0 0 -1 . (3.5) Thereis noloss of generality in this choice of v, it just correspondsto theway wenamed the particles. If we rotate vwe just have to rotate the name of the electron and the neutrin o and keep the photon in the direction of v2. Notice that, with respect to the : Str(.) =Tr(kh .)
/hatwidegMN= 1/2STr(lMlN), M,N= photon is on the light-cone of the generator of antilepton representation, in the ( basis, are: l1=
0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 , l2=
0 0 0 0 0-i 0i0 , l3=
0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0-1 , l8=
-2 0 0 0-1 0 0 0 -1 . (3.7) the 4 odd 0-1 0 0 0 1 0 0 , l5=
0 0i 0 0 0 i0 0 , l6=
0 1 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 , l7=
0-i0 -i0 0 0 0 0 , (3.8) and the chirality operator (3.9) Equations (3.4-5) are again true in this representation. No tice however that the odd ma- trices (3.8) are anti-Hermitian, this is necessary to maint ain (3.5) since the electric charge of the antielectron is positive. Notice also that the charge and parity (CP) are linked. The doublet and antidoublet must be of opposite parity with resp ect tokh(3.3) and (3.9) in order to maintain the commutator (3.4b). This switches the s ign of the supermetric (3.6), as befits a CP invariant theory. 4. TheSU(2/1)quark the standard model [Wei67, Sa68, GIM70, BIM72], each fami ly of quarks consists of 4 states, a left doublet and two right singlets, i.e. ( uR/(uL,dL)/dR) for the 'electron the second smallest irreducible representatio n of the SU(2/1) to this chiral decomposition, it contains a fre e parameter nwhich allows us to fix the charge of the up quark. From the mathematical point o f view [SNR77], the existence of this 4 dimensional representation is a simple c onsequence of the isomorphism - 5 -between SU(2/1) andOSp(2/2), which is a generalization of the well known the first members of the infinite families of simple Li e algebras. But from the physical point of view, it came as a great surprise. In the ori ginal papers [F79, N79], the quarks were respectively left out and listed as a counterarg ument. The incorporation a few weeks later of the quarks [DJ79, NT80] really appeared as a si gnificant confirmation of the model. The 4 even generators read: l1=
0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 , l2=
0 0 0 0 0 0-i0 0i0 0 0 0 0 0 , (4.1) l3=
0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0-1 0 0 0 0 0 , l8=1 n -n-1 0 0 0 0-1 0 0 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 n-1 .(4.2) The 4 odd generators are not Hermitian, for any value of n, they read: l4=1 2n 0 0 -n+1 0 0 0 0n-1n+1 0 0 0 0n-1 0 0 , l5=1 2n 0 0 in+1 0 0 0 0 -in-1 in+1 0 0 0 0in-1 0 0 , l6=1 2n 0n+1 0 0 -n+1 0 0 0 0 0 0n-1 0 0n-1 0 0 -in+1 0 0 0 0 0 0 -in-1 0 0 in-1 0 .(4.3) Finally the chirality operator (4.4) We have normalized the quark matrices (4.1-4.4) so that they have exactly the same as the lepton matrices (3.1,3.2). As desire d, the super-Killing metric (3.6) is also identical in the lepton and the quark represent ation. Notice however that the commutators of the odd quark matrices do not close on khtimes the even matrices. - 6 -Sincenis a free parameter, SU(2/1) does not predict the charge of the quarks, or the number of colors. However, the superalgebra does relate the U(1) charges of the singlets and a number of desired relations (post-dictions) are autom atically for n=-1 (orn= 1), we recover the lepton (or antilepton) representation w ith only 3 states. In other words, SU(2/1) implies that if the charge of the electron is equal to the charge of the Wvector, the U(1) neutral right-neutrino is also neutral with respect to the odd we should impose the cancellation of the triangle anom = 0, a,b,c = 1,2,3,8, (4.5) If we consider a lepton family, with one lepton of U(1) charge 1, and n'quarks of U(1) charge-1/n, theSU(2)2U(1) anomaly vanishes if and only if we choose n=n'. But although there are no other adjustable parameters, SU(2/1) then implies that the U(1)3 anomaly also = 0 (4.6) for any value of n. The vacuum and the photon direction were already chosen in t he In the same conventions (3.5) where the ele ctric charge of the electron is -1, we find: photon = =1 2n n+1 0 0 0 0n+1 0 0 0 0 1 -n0 0 0 0 1 the correct number of colors n= 3 implies the correct electric charges for the upquark 2/3 and the downquark-1/3 . Finally, the odd sector antisymmetric and trace metric also = 0, a= = 0, i,j= 4,5,6,7.(4.8) We will now study in the next sections some consequences of th ese identities. 5. The scalar propagator We would like to construct a quantum field theory, based on the SU(2/1) toitsmaximal SU(2)U(1) Lie sub-algebra and incorporate in some way the odd matrices. In [TM06], we have shown that we can construct an associative covariant exterior different ial, mixing left and right chiral Fermions, if and only if the Fermion form a representation of a Lie superalgebra, graded by the chirality. As we have just seen, these conditions are m et exactly by the Fermions: the leptons and the quarks. The conne ction is then defined as the sum of the usual Yang-Mills 1-form Audxuplus the constant Dirac 1-form gudxu multiplied by scalar field valued in the odd sector of the supe ralgebra. - 7 -The natural idea would therefore be to introduce a scalar-fie ld Ph with a minimal coupling to the Fermions of the form Ps+PhiliPs. However, this is not directly possible since the liare not Hermitian. To fix this problem, we postulate that the fi eld Phiis composed of 2 parts, each with intrinsically chiral couplin gs. Considering the kh(3.3,4.4) with eigenvalue 1 ( -1) on the left (right) Fermions, we define the left and right projectors pL= (1+kh)/2 andpR= (1-kh)/2, and define, for any matrix M, the chiral traces. TrL(M) =Tr(pLM), TrR(M) =Tr(pRM), Str(M) =Tr(kh M).(5.1) We then decompose the odd lmatrices assume the existence of 2 scalar fields Ph Lwhich absorbs right Fermions and emits left ones and Ph Rwhich absorbs left Fermions and emits right ones, according to the (5.3) To find the correct propagator of the Ph field, we compute the qua ntum corrections due to the insertion of a Fermion loop between 2 Ph states. This induces a scalar counterterm of the =1 n+1TrR(ljli). (5.5) There are two contributions, one coming from the lepton loop and one from the quark 1, all other components being zero, which coincides with the odd part of (3.6). Summing over a whole family fwithncolored quarks, we find that the Fermion loop is proportional to the canonical supermetr ic oij=/hatwidegij (5.7) For the moment, we have a weird scalar model, with an antisymm etric propagator and non Hermitian couplings. But now a miracle occurs. If we chan ge variables as follows, the Lagrangian becomes canonical. Consider the two SU(2/1) odd valued scalar fields ai=1 2(Hi+i bi=1 2(Hi-i Ki),(5.8) - 8 -whereaiandbiare convenient intermediate variables which are not reused below. Substi- tuting (5.8) in (5.4) we obtain the canonical propagator Ls=i (5.9) We then define the u+-Hermitian matrices: li= (u- i-i u+
i), (u- i+i u+
i), rewrite the scalar-Fermion interaction in terms of thes e new Ps = Ps. (5.11) The matrices u+- isplit according to the electric charge and are Hermitian. Th e charged rightsinglets( electron, with the positively charged right singlets (up quark). In the lepton are equal to the Hermitian matrices given in (3.2) u- 4=
0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 , u- 5=
0 0-i 0 0 0 i0 0 , u- 6=
0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 , u- 7=
0 0 0 0 the quark representation, the u- iare equal to the right and low Hermitian corner of the matrices 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 , 0 0 0 0 0 0 -i 0 0 0 0 0i0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 , 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -i 0 0i0 .(5.13) The top left corner of the u+
imatrices are proportional to the antielectron matrices (3. 0i0 0 0 0 0 -i0 0 0 0 0 0 0 , 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 , 0 0 -1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 .(5.14) - 9 -If we sum over a complete family, we find that the matrices asso ciated to HandKhave the same = 0, Tr(u+
iu+
j) =Tr(u- iu- j) = (n+1)dij, i,j = identity, like (4.8), is a consequence of the vanishing of the sum of the charges of all the right singlets (electron + n up quarks + n down quarks) of a family. It shows that one can compute the renormalization of the scalar propagator ei ther using the Ph or using the H, Kfields (5.8), and obtain the same result (5.9). 6. The scalar potential From now on, we restrict our attention to the case n= 3 colors. Consider the structure of the scalar potential induced by a Fermion loop. The cubic t erms vanish, since each interaction with a scalar changes the chirality of the Fermi ons. The term of degree 6 or higher converge. So we only have to compute the quartic poten tial. If we work in terms of the Ph fields, the counterterm is proportional (5.6), we find that many unfriendly terms, for e xample are eliminated by the balance between the leptons and the quarks . If we introduce the (6.2) and the products Za L= (fa ij-i da ij) (fa ij+i da ij) the da ijand the fa ijare defined in (3.4), the direct calculation of the Fermion lo op induces, up to an infinite multiplicative constant, a scalar potential of the is arbitrary in (6.4), because we have the identit 0. (6.5) If we work with the u+-Hermitian matrices (5.12-14), we find, generalizing (5.15) , that the symmetrized quartic traces are 32/9 10 -Finally the mixed traces satisfy, for all = = 0,for any i, no sum implied.(6.7) If we now introduce the symmetric K , (6.8) the direct calculation of the Fermion loop induces, up to the same infinite a scalar potential of the (6.2) is arbitrary in (6.9), because in any Lie sup eralgebra, we have 0 (6.10) Notice that for the same reason, the mixed H Kterm vanishes if and only if This identity insures that the centralizer of the true vacuum is nontrivial, or in other words, that the photon remains massless. If we change variable again and define u1= (H4+iH5)/
2, u2= (H6+iH7)/
2, v1= (K4+iK5)/
2, v2= substitute in (5.9) and (6.9), we recover up to a scale fac torsthe propagator and potential of Fayet [F74, F75] Ls+V=uu uu+uv these variable, it is immediately clear that, assuming a s ymmetry breaking negative mass term for the scalars, the potential is minimal when uandvare parallel, and therefore the photon remains massless. The scalar potential (6.9) is i nvariant under the if we use the variables uandv: u= (u.v)v ,v=-(v.u)u , v= (u.v)u ,u=-(v.u)v ,(6.14) whereas the term ( u.v)(u.v) which could give a mass to the photon and is absent from our Lagrangian, is not invariant under . - 11 -7. Scalar Ward identities The study of the counterterms induced by the Fermion loop has given in the previous section the structure of the propagator and of the potential , but not their scale. If we write our Lagrangian ) Ps,(7.1) The factor 2 in g/2 is needed because our SU(2) matrices (3.1) are normalized as usual in mathematics, not as the standard spin 1 /2 isospin matrices of physics. The weak angle and the coefficients landxare not yet known. We will now fix them by requiring that they do not depend on the number of lepton families. The only contribution of the other families to the coupling o f the vectors and scalars to the Fermion of the first family is through the renormalizat ion of the wave function of the vector and the scalar. The counterterms are proportiona l to Z(A2 a) =2 3g2 4Trfl2 a, Z(A2 8) Z(H2) factor 2 /3 in the vectors comes from the kinematic contribution of the Dirac matri- ces. We count 2 /3, not the usual 4 /3 of a massive Fermion, since here the left and right spinors contribute separately to the trace term. Over a full family, the SU(2) even ma- trices (3.1,4.1) are normalized to Trf(lalb) = 8dab. TheU(1) matrix is normalized to Trf(l8l8) = 40/3, and the odd matrices to Trf(u+- iu+- j) = 4dij. To integrate these 3 counterterms in the renormalization of the coupling consta ntg, and insure that tgthandx are not renormalized, we fix tg2th=3 5, sin2th=3 8, x=2 3. (7.3) The weak angle coincides with the value derived from the SU(5) grand unified theory [GG74]. We then look at the renormalization of the scalar pot ential. The standard Lie algebra Ward identities ensure that the contribution of the Fermions to the self coupling of the vectors, the g2A4term, can be reabsorbed in the renormalization of g2. A holds for the scalar potential l g2H4. Z(V) =1 3(gx)4 lg2 (7.4) The contribution of the Fermions is reabsorbed in the renorm alization of g2and therefore lis not renormalized if we choose Z(V) =Z(H2) ==> we note that the Bosonic counterterms, induced by t he vector and scalar 1-loops perturb all the scalar couplings, except the very st ructure of the scalar the strong interactions gluon vector fields int eract with the quarks, but not with the leptons. The photon-quark coupling is protected by a Ward identity and is not - 12 -renormalized by the gluon-quark interaction, but the scala r-quark vertex is not whichiscent ral counterterms. This problem can either be interpreted as a fatal flaw of the SU(2/1) model or as sign that the quantum theory is still incomplete. 8. The mass of the Higgs Since we have now fixed the scale of the potential we can derive the mass of the the two neutral fields H0 1or2and the charged field H+-. Suppressing the Fermions, the Lagrangian V (8.1) whereVis given in (6.9). If we develop the potential and show explic itly the occurrences of the component fields H4. We find: l points should be noticed. The lparameter is scaled as usual to give l/4H4 4. There are no terms finally the coefficients of H4are invariant under a l8 rotation of the Kfields, which rotates now add by hand in the Lagrangian a quadratic symmetry brea king 'imaginary mass' H2+cos2b K2). (8.3) We assume that the vacuum expectation value of His in the direction H6. As discussed in section 3, this choice just fixes the name of the particles. To minimize the mixed H2K2 potential, the Kvacuum expectation value must be in the plane ( K6,K7). The vacuum correctly preserves the photon (3.5, 4.7). We then rotate < K >to< K6>. This corresponds to the fact that one of the 4 neutral s tates in the usually called the ' A0' pseudo-scalar, is absent from the quartic potential and its mass can be fixed arbitrarily in the symmetry-breakin g term. We minimize the potential and find:
< H6>=v sinb , < K 6>=v cosb , M W=v g/2, (8.4) wherebis defined modulo p/2. We then expand the potential around the vacuum to second order in v. We find 4 massless states which produce the A0and the of the massive vector fields ZandW+- H7, K7,(sinb H 4+cosbK 4)+-i(sinb H 5+cosbK 5), (8.5) two charged physical scalars H+-= (cosb H 4-sinbK 4)+-i(cosb H 5-sinbK 5), MH+-=
2l MW= 75.8GeV(8.6) - 13 -and two neutral scalars in the ( H6,K6) plane, usually called H0 1andH0 2, with masses MH0 1= 2 2l cosb M W= ( 2cosb) 107.2GeV , MH0 2= 2 2l sinb M W= ( 2sinb) 107.2GeV .(8.7) In the symmetric case b=p/4 the 2 neutral scalar are at 107 .2GeV. 9. The Since the scalar fields (5.3) play the role of a gauge field asso ciated to the odd generators of the superalgebra, it seems natural to introduce them as pa rt of the covariant differential and curvature 2-form. Such a construction was proposed in [T M06], where we found that the covariant differential is associative if and only if the Fe rmions sit in a the superalgebra graded by the chirality. As shown in sect ions 2 and 3, this condition is met by the observed leptons and quarks. But we found in sect ion 3 the that the quark representation is non Hermitia n, so the scalar field is complex, so effectively, the numberof oddgenerators in the quantum fiel dtheory is twice thenumber of odd generators of the SU(2/1) superalgebra. We are going to show that the construction of the curvature ca n be generalized and yields a structure we would like to call a H-curvature, by ref erence to Fayet and Iliopoulos [F74, F75], who were the first to consider, in the context of Hy per-Symmetry, a doubling of the Higgs field introduced by Weinberg [Wei67] and to Stern berg and Wolf [SW78] who introduced the Hermitian [TM06], we define the Dirac 1-forms G =dxusu+dxusu. (9.1) wheresmaps the right Fermions on the left Fermions and vice versa. W e then define the chiral Yang-Mills 1-form /tildewideAand covariant differential Phi LliL+G . (9.2) Notice that /tildewideAis an exterior form of homogeneous degree 1, in contradistin ction with the Ne'eman Quillen connection [TMN82, Q85] sometimes discuss ed in the SU(2/1) NSF05] and references therein). The curvature is de fined as the square of the covariant . (9.3) Since the dxuanticommute, the classical term A (9.4) is antisymmetric in aband is internal provided the even matrices laclose by fc ablc. (9.5) - 14 -Similarly, the scalar vector term in G DPh generate the covariant differential of the scalars provided the even odd sector close by fj ailj. (9.6) However, the structure of the scalar-scalar term is more inv olved. Since Ph Land the lmatrices are neither symmetrized nor skew symmetrized and w e (9.7) We now decompose the matrix product into the symmetric and sk ew symmetric (9.8) and we find that the scalar-scalar term can be expressed as a li near combination of even generators provided the anticommutator of the odd matrices close on the even matrices and the commutators of the odd matrices close on khtimes the even matrices, defining structure constants kh the unsymmetrized product of the odd matrices sat kh fa ij)la. (9.10) By inspection (3.4), all these conditions are satisfied by th e lepton representation (3.1- 3). In fact, the construction works with the fundamental rep resentation of any because all the generators coincide with the generators of SU(m+n) U(1)butkh U(1)istraceless structure (9.9) was introduced by Sternberg and Wolf [SW 78], who call it a Her- mitian algebra and discussed by Ne'eman and Sternberg in sev eral subsequent papers [NS90, NSF05], but its exact relevance to quantum field theor y remained unclear. The unusual presence of the chirality operator khon the right hand side of the commutator (9.9) was not explained, because they did not consider the po ssibility of splitting the odd generators and doubling the number of Higgs fields. But in our modified framework, if we compare (9.7) and (9.10) and use kh2= 1, we see that the khoperator present in (9.9) disappears from the curvature 2-form which is now correctly valued on the even matrices and can be written Bianchi identity = 0 follows from the associativity of the matrix productand implies theHermitian Jacobi identity of [SW78]. We can also construct a second solution /hatwideFRby switching the sign of the dconstants changing the da ij). (9.12) We recover in (9.11-12) the object ZL/Rintroduced in (9.13) - 15 -10. The electro-weak angle From the definition of the classical curvature 2-form given i n the previous section, we can construct the Lagrangian in the usual way, using the Hodge ad junction*and the which reproduces the scalar potential induced by the F ermion loops. The Lagrangian can be written the new bilinear scalar term in the H-curvature (9.13) coincides with (6.3), the scalar potential is proportional to (6.4) which can be rewri tten as (6.9). It is curious to see that the combined effect of the leptons and quarks in (6.9) i s mimicked in the (10.1) by combined effect of the 2 chiral ways (9. 11-12) of extending the superalgebra SU(2/1) curvature of [TM06] to the H-algebra. The interesting point is that, using (6.2) and (3.6), the effec tive metric for the Yang- Mill curvature Facomes out diag(1 -a,1-a,1-a,3+a), a,b = 1,2,3,8 (10.2) and we learn the choice of the aparameter in the definition of the corre- sponds to the choice of the electro-weak angle in the classic al Lagrangian according to: tg2th= (1-a)/(3+a)<=> a= 1-4sin2th . (7.3), we find a=-1/2. 11. model appeared in 1979 as very compelling, but so far no set ting had been found that could explain how to extend the Yang-Mills quantu m field theory from gauging an internal Lie algebra symmetry to the case of a superalgebr a. We believe that the present paper represents a step in this direction. The original observation [N79, F79] is that, provided we gra de the Fermions by their chirality, SU(2/1) exactly leptons and the quarks fit the 2 smallest irreducible repr esentations (3.1-2) and (4.1-4) of the superalgebra SU(2/1). The U(1) hyper-charge, which is supertraceless, coincides with the original choice of Weinberg [Wei67] who wanted to av oid a current coupled to the lepton number, and explains the non existence of any mass less charged particle. The difficulty is to understand the role of the odd generators. Our new idea is to take the SU(2/1) matrices at face value, despite the fact that they are not Hermitian (4.3), and to construct the whole Lagr angian by studying the counterterms induced by the Fermions. The caveat is to remem ber the triangle anomaly (4.5). It is avoided if and only if we always consider as our bu ilding block a whole of one lepton triplet and three quark quadruple ts, for example the electron, the left neutrino and 3 colored copies of the up and down quark s, counting independently - 16 -the left and right chiral states. If we associate a single rea l scalar to each odd generator the induced scalar propagator vanishes (4.8). But if we spli t the odd matrices into their chiral parts (5.2), and consider 2 sets of scalars Ph Land Ph R(5.3) the leptons and the quarks conspire to induce a the scalar propagator (5.7) prop ortional to the odd part of the skew-symmetric Killing metric of the superalgebra (3.6 ). It is then possible to change variables (5.8) from Ph L,PhRtoH, Kand recover two Higgs scalar doublets, Hcoupled to the electron (5.12) and down quark (5.13), and Kcoupled to the up quark (5.14). If we compute in the same way the quartic scalar counterterms we re cover (6.12) the byFayet [F74], abuildingstoneof what late r becametheMinimal Model (MSSM). This is rather surprising, be cause we have not introduced any Wess-Zumino supersymmetry in our construction, but may be attributed to the near unicity of the SU(2)U(1) quartic invariants. Some interesting results follow from the analysis of the qua ntum stability of the sym- metry breaking pattern of the theory. In the Fayet potential , the crucial element is the form of the mixed term which insures that, in the vacuum, the 2 fieldsHandKare par- allel, and therefore leave an unbroken U(1) symmetry, gauged by a massless photon. In our model, this condition is a consequence of the super-Jaco bi identity (6.10) and is stable against the Fermionic 1-loop quantum corrections, since th is is the way we derived the scalar potential. Furthermore, if fix (7.3) the relative str ength of the 2 vectors coupling to tg2th= 5/3 (as inSU(5) grand unified theory [GG74]), the strength of the scalar t o 2/
3, and the quartic self coupling to l= 4/9, these coefficients are stable against the induced by the Fermion loops for any number of fam ilies, thanks to the Ward identities (7.5). These identities are typical of a Yang-Mi lls minimal coupling and states that scalar Fermion coupling and the scalar quartic self cou pling are indeed the Yang-Mills SU(2) coupling constant. This fixes (8.7) the mass of the neutral Higgs at M2 H0 1+M2 H0 2= 2 (4/3MW)2= 2 (107 .2GeV)2. The mass of the charged Higgs corresponds to the mixed H Kterm in the potential and gives (8.6): MH+-= 2 2/3MW= 75.8GeV, a value a few GeVtoo low relative to the minimum given by the particle data group [Yao06]. Finally the mass of the 'A0' pseudo-scalar is the other hand, we clearly have a difficulty with the mass of t he quarks. If we assume that the 2 Higgs have the same mass and that the SU(2/1) minimal coupling (5.3) directly gives the mass of the heaviest quark, we predi ctMtop=MH0= falls way under the current experimental value Mtop= from direct observations [Yao06]. But a worse probl em is that the in the two other families should have the same mass, w hen actually they are very light (1 .25GeVand 2MeV). This problem is possibly solved by the SU(2/1) inde- composable representations which have been shown by Haussl ing and Scheck to the Masakawa quark mixing phenomenology [HS94]. Assuming that the masses get redistributed, we are not so far from the relation 3M2 H. This question needs further studies. A classical geometric interpretation of the theory is also p ossible. When expressed in - 17 -terms of the Ph Land PhRfields, we found that the potential involves both the symmetr constants of the superalgebra and the skew symmet constants of SU(3), times the chirality operator (3.4). This gives the idea of revisiting the introduced by Sternberg and Wolf [SW78]. Our new re sult is to show that this structure exactly fits the chiral decomposition (5.3) of the Ph fields, allowing us to construct a classical curvature 2-forms (9.12), where the unexpected apparition of the chirality op- eratorkhin the definition of the Hermitian Lie bracket (9.9) exactly c ompensates the signs implied when adapting our chiral connection 1-form to the doubling of the Ph fields. There is also a probable relation with non commutativ e differential geometry, as discussed in geometrical const of our Lagrangian as the square of the curvature of the SU(2/1) Hermitian algebra. In the earlier work of Ne'eman and others, the central problem w as the choice of the quadratic form needed to compute the squareof the curvature. Thenatur al choice was the (3.6), but this yields a negative propagator for the U(1) field and breaks unitarity. The phenomenological choice seemed to be the trace of the lep ton representation (3.1) which yields sin2th=.25. In 1979, this value was acceptable, but is now too high. Al so the trace metric is not a good invariant for a superalgebra, and t his choice was often criticized. Our new result is to deduce the relevant quadratic form from t he renormalization theory. We found the very elegant hyper metric /tildewideG(6.2) which is a combination of the trace and the supertrace metric and, thanks to the super-Jacobi ident ity, contains a free parameter a. The 2 rows and columns of /tildewideGare used to combine the 2 CPconjugated versions of the H-curvature (10.1), and this combination restores unit arity, because in the we can switch between the native SU(2/1) geometric but non-Hermitian Ph L and Ph R(6.4) variables and the good Hermitian quantum field theory s When we inject this metric in our Lagrangian (10.1), w e find that the freedom in the choice of areflects a freedom in the choice of the electro-weak angle a= 1-4sin2th (10.3) and that the simplest choice a= 0 corresponds to the trace-metric choice, to sin2th= 3/8. Let us now recall the distinction between this model and the m inimal model (MSSM). The geometrical space behind Yang-M ills theory is the principal fiber bundle. The base is space-time, the fiber is the gauge gro up. In both cases, a super- algebra is introduced but not in the same way. In the MSSM, the Poincare superalgebra is introduced in the base space, acts on Bose/Fermi supermul tiplets and naturally leads to supergravity. In our approach, the superalgebra is intro duced in the fiber, by embed- ding the SU(2)U(1) Lie algebra in SU(2/1), it acts of chiral supermultiplets and groups the Higgs scal ars with the Yang-Mills vectors. This construction is not incompatible with supergravity at much higher energy or but does not lead to these theories. In both mod els, (5.11) and [F74], we are led to introduce 2 sets of scalar doublets, Hcoupled to the electron and down-quark right singlets, and Kto the up-quarksinglet. Thequarticscalar potential has th esame and implies the survival of an unbroken U(1) and a massless photon. So the scalar spectrum is similar, 3 states become the longitudinal compo nents of the WandZvector - 18 -fields, 5 survive. In both models the scale of the potential is fixed and the values are in the same range. But of course the main difference is that the MSS M predicts for every known particle the existence of supersymmetric partner, li ke the winos, gluinos, squarks and sleptons, whereas SU(2/1) fits exactly the known particles but does not predict any new ones, except the Higgs fields. The existence or non existe nce of these particles below 1TeVwill allow us to choose between the 2 kinds of theory is testable, but incomplete in several directions . At the experi- mental level, the model predicts 2 complex doublets of Higgs fields, rather than 1 as in the original Weinberg paper, and constrains their masses withi n the range of the new CERN collider which opens this year. At the phenomenological lev el, the mixing of the quark families is not understood in details, but may be linked to th e indecomposable ofSU(2/1). At the theoretical level, the balance between the quarks and leptons is broken by the quantum counterterms induced by the gluons, an d all the scalar those insuring the existence of a massless photon, ar e perturbedby the Boson loops. We believe that this problem could indicate the incompleten ess of the current and will discuss it elsewhere. But even if these difficulties cannot be solved immediately, t he 1-loop stability of the structure of the scalar potential, ensuring a massless phot on, and the resulting prediction of the number and masses of the Higgs fields seem worth reporti ng as a first step towards the construction of SU(2/1) Quantum Astheno many ways, this paper is a concretization of our long lasti ng collaboration with Yuval Ne'eman on SU(2/1). It is also a pleasure to thank Pierre Faye t and Victor Kac for Florian Scheck and Shlomo Sternberg for commu nications, David Lipman for always prompting new ideas and Danielle Thierry-Mieg for im portant E.S. Abers and B.W. Lee, Gauge Theories, Physics Reports ,9Cno. 1 1973 [BIM72] C.Bouchiat, J.Iliopoulos and P.Meyer, An anomaly free version of Weinberg's model Phys. Let. A38, 519 (1972) [CL90] A. Connes and J. Lott, Particle models and noncommutative geometry, Nucl. Phy. 18B (Proc. Suppl.) 29 (1990) [DJ79] P.H. Dondi and P.D. Jarvis, A supersymmetric Weinberg-Sala m model, Physics 87B403 (1979) [F79] D.B. Fairlie, Higgs Fields and the Determination of the Weinberg A ngle,Phys. Lett. B82 97 (1979) [F74] P.Fayet, Nucl. Phy. B78, 14 (1974) [F75] P.Fayet, Nucl. Phy. Lett. B90, 104 (1975) - 19 -[GG74] H.Georgi and S.Glashow, Phys. Rev. Lett. 32, (1974) [GIM70] S.Glashow, J.Iliopoulos and L.Maiani, Phys. Rev. D2, 1285-1292 (1970) [BIM72] C.Bouchiat, J.Iliopoulos and Ph.Meyer Phys. Lett. B38, 519-523 (1972) [HS94] R.Haussling and F.Scheck, Quark mass matrices and generat ion mixing in the standard model with non-commutative geometry, Phys. Lett. B336, 477-486 (1994) [N79] Y. Ne'eman, Irreducible Gauge Theory of a Consolidated Salam -Weinberg Model, Phys. Lett.B81, 190 (1979) [NS90] Y. Ne'eman, S. Sternberg, and interna l supersymmetry dynamics, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 877875 (1990) [NSF05] Y. Ne'eman, S.Sternberg and D.Fairlie ele ctroweak su(2/1) and extensions, and the mass of the Higgs, Physics Reports 406, 303-377 (2005) [NT80] Y. Ne'eman and J. Thierry-Mieg, Geometrical Gauge Theory of Ghost and Goldstone Fields and of Ghost Symmetries, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., USA 77720-723 (1980) [Q85] D. Quillen, and the Chern character, Topology 2489 (1985) [Sa68] A. Salam, in Elementary Particle Theory , N. Svartholm, ed. Almquist Verlag A.B., Stockholm (1968) [S92] F.Scheck, Anomalies, Weinberg angle and a non-commutative g eometric description of the standard model, Phys. Lett. B284, 303-308 (1992) [SNR77] M. Scheunert, W. Nahm & V. Rittenberg, Irreducible Repr esentations of the osp(2/1) and sp1(2/1) graded Lie algebras, J. Math. Phys. 18156-167 (1977) [SW78] S. Sternberg, J. Wolf, Hermitian Lie algebras and metaplect ic Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2311 (1978) [TMN82] J. Thierry-Mieg and Y. Ne'eman, Exterior Gauging of an Int ernal Supersymmetry and SU(2/1) Quantum in Proc. of Nat. Acad. of Sciences, USA 79(1982) p. J. Thierry-Mieg, Chiral Yang-Mills theory, non commutative differential geometry, and the need for a Lie superalgebra, JHEP 2006 038 [Wei67] S. Weinberg, A Model of Leptons, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19(1967) 1264. [Yao06] W.-M. Yao et al, Particle Data Group //pdg.lbl.gov J. Phys. G 331 (2006) [YM54] C.N. Yang and R. Mills, Conservation of isotopic spin and isospin gauge Rev. 96191-195 (1954) - 20 -
|
0806.4628
|
Jean Thierry-Mieg
|
Jean Thierry-Mieg
|
Quantum construction of a unitary SU(2/1) model of the electro-weak
interactions with 2 Higgs doublets
|
20 pages
| null | null |
PTA/07-058
|
hep-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The interactions and even the number of the Higgs scalar fields are not fixed
in the SU(2)U(1) standard model of the electro-weak interactions and the
intrinsically chiral nature of the weak interactions is not explained.
Embedding SU(2)U(1) into the Lie super-algebra SU(2/1) fills these gaps. The 2
smallest representations of SU(2/1) adequately describe the electron, neutrino,
up and down quarks and correlate their chiralities with their U(1) charges, and
the Higgs fields have the quantum numbers of the odd generators. But so far,
there was an apparent conflict with unitarity, because the quark representation
is not Hermitian and the super-Killing metric is not positive definite. We
solve this paradox by assuming the existence of 2 complex Higgs doublets
minimally coupled to the Fermions via the chiral projections of the odd
generators of SU(2/1). We find that Lagrangian induced by the Fermion loops is
unitary, thanks to the balance between the leptons and the quarks needed to
cancel the triangle anomaly and that the super-Jacobi identity guarantees that
the photon remains massless after symmetry breaking. In addition, the
Lagrangian has a classical geometric interpretation in terms of the curvature
of the corresponding Hermitian algebra. Assuming that the relative strength of
the scalar and vector couplings does not depend on the number of families
constrains the mass of the Higgs to $M^2_{H^0_1} + M^2_{H^0_2} = 32/9 M^2_W = 2
(107.2 GeV)^2$. Contrary to grand-unified or Wess-Zumino super-symmetric
models, the SU(2/1) internal super-unification does not predict any unobserved
particle besides the 2 Higgs doublets.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 29 Jun 2008 18:06:52 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-01T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Thierry-Mieg",
"Jean",
""
]
] |
2 However, as seen below, surface states are pand s. Let us consider wave function including ABS localized at the surface. Consider a two-dimensional on x>0 where the surface is located at x= 0. The corresponding wave function is given by [17] PsS(x) = Fermi momentum of the small and large magnitude of Fermi surface given by respectively. k1(2)x denotes the xcomponent of the Fermi momentum k1(2), The wave func- tions are given withg= sgn( p-s). In the above, u1(2)andv1(2)are given we have introduced a1= (k+
2x-iky)/k2, ~a1= (-k- 1x-iky)/k1, and
~a2= the quasiparticle energy measured from the Fermi energy. By postulating Ps S(x) = 0 atx= 0, we can determine the ABS. The bound state condition can be expressed cosph1=k1x/k1and cosph2=k2x/k2. The critical angle phCis defined as sin-1(k1/k2). Forl= 0, eq. (3) reproduces the previous result [16]. As seen from eq. (3), the ABS including zero energy state is only pos- sible for |ph2|<=phCandg= 1,i.e., p>s. The present ABS is just the edge state, where the can move along the edge. The energy level of the edge state depends crucially on the direction of the motion of the quasiparticle. The inner gap edge modes are absent for large magnitude of ky,i.e.ph2. The param- eter regimewherethe edge modessurviveis reduced with the increase of the magnitude of l. However, as far as we concentrate on the perpendicular injection, the edgemodes survive as the mid gap ABS [18, 19] irrespective of the strength of l. If we focus on the low energy limit, ABS can be written (5) with s<pfor anylwith small magnitude of ky. For s>=p, the presnet ABS vanishes since the value of right side of eq. (3) becomes negative due to the nega- tive sign of It should be remarked that the present ABS do not break the time re- versal symmetry, since the edge current carried by each Kramers doublet flows in the opposite direction. Thus they can be regarded as helical edge modes, where two modes are connected to each other by time reversal op- eration. Now we give an argument why the with p>shas the ABS from the viewpoint class [3]. We commence with the state without the spin-orbit interaction l. Spin Chern number [5] for the Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) Hamiltonian is 2. Turning on leaves the T-symmetry intact and keeps the gap open, one can arrive at the BdG Hamiltonian of interest. Upon this adiabatic change of l, the number of the heli- cal edge mode pairs does not change. Then we increase the magnitude of sfrom zero. As far as p>s is satisfied, the number of helical edge modes does not change, since it is a topological number. However, if s exceeds p, the helical mode disappears. In this regime, the topological nature of superconducting state belongs to pures-wave state without l. It is remarkable, just at s= p, closes, where a quantum phase transition occurs. Now we turn to the spin transport property governed by the ABS in the NCS superconductors [20]. First, we point out that the spin Hall effect, i.e., the appearance of the spin Hall voltage perpendicular to the current is suppressed by the compressive nature of the superconducting state by the factor of ( kFlm)-2 (kF: Fermi momentum, lm: penetration depth) [21]. In- stead, junction between the ballistic normal metal at x<0 and NCS superconductor, i.e., (N/SC) junction, can be enhanced by the Doppler effect at the Andreev reflection. We assume an insulating barrier at x= 0 expressed by a delta-function potential Ud(x). The wave function for spinsin the normal metal Ps N(x) is given by PsN(x) = The corre- sponding Ps S(x) is given by eq. (2). The between Ps N(x) and Ps S(x) given by Ps N(0) =
PsS(0), =2mU -h2PsS(0). We as- sume that the Fermi momentum kFof normal metal and NCS superconductor before putting lare the same. The quantities of interest are the angle resolved spin and charge conductance fC(ph) defined by [22] fS(ph) = [(|a|,||2- |a|,||2- |a|,||2- = the injection angle measured from the normaltothe interface. First weconsiderpure( px+-ipy)- wave state. In Fig. 1, the angle resolved spin conduc- tance is plotted as a function of injection angle phand bias voltage VwithE=eV. Note here that the ky is related to phasky=kFsinph. It is remarkable that spin conductance has a non zero value although the does not break time reversal symmetry. fS(ph) has a peak when the angle phorkygives the energy Ein the energy dispersion of ABS. With this condition, the spin-dependent Andreev reflection occurs to result in the spin current. Besides this property, we can show that fS(ph) =-fS(-ph) is satisfied. By changing the sign of eV,fS(ph) changes sign as seen in Fig. 1(a). Next, we look at the case where s-wave component coexists. We can calculate spin current similar to the pure ( px+-ipy)- wave case. For s<p, where helical edge modes exist, fS(ph) has a sharp peak and fS(ph) =-fS(-ph) is 1(b)]. Thesefeaturesaresimilartothoseof case. On the other hand, for s>p, where the helical edge modes are absent, sharp peaks of fS(ph) as shown in Fig. 1 are absent. We have checked that there is negligible by taking l= 0 limit compared to Fig. 1, e.g., less than 0.5% change of the peak height. In this limit, for pure (px+-ipy)-wave state, fS(ph) is given simply = 0 for of the interface sNis given by with a dimensionless constant Z= 2mU/-h2kF. The magnitude of fS(ph) is largely en- hanced to the duetothe spin-dependent ABS. even if we take into account the spatial dependence of the (px+-ipy)-wave pair potential explicitly, the does not qualitatively change [20].Summarizing these features, we can conclude that the presence of the helical edge modes in NCS superconduc- tor is the origin of the large angle resolved spin current through N/NCS superconductor junctions. However, conduc- tance becomes zero since fS(ph) =-fS(-ph) is satisfied. FIG. 1: (Color online) Angle resolved spin conductance for Z= 5. a:eV= 0.1p, b:eV=-0.1pand c:eV= 0.6p withlkF= 0.1u. (a)pure ( px+-ipy)-wave case with s= 0. (b)s= 0.3p. Magnetic field offers an opportunity to observe the spin current in a much more accessible way, where T- symmetry is broken by the shielding current at the in- terface. Here we consider the angle averaged normalized spin conductance sSand charge conductance sCas a function of magnetic field which are given by [19, denotes the angle resolved charge conduc- tance in the normal state with p= s= 0. Now we consider the magnetic field Happlied perpendicu- lar to the two-dimensional plane, which induces a shield- ing current along the N/NCS superconductor interface. When the penetration depth of the NCS much longer than coherence length, the vector poten- tial can be approximated as A(r) = (0,Ay(x),0) with Ay(x) =-lmHexp(-x/lm) with the penetration depth lm. Here we consider the situation where the quantiza- tion of the Landau level can be neglected. Then qua- siclassical approximation becomes available. The ap- plied magnetic field shifts the quasiparticle energy E in wave function of Ps S(x) andx= -h2kF/(pmp) [23]. For typical values of x~10nm,lm~100nm, the magnitude ofH0is of the order of 0.2Tesla. Here the order of the energy of Doppler shift is given by Hp/H0. Since the Zeeman energy is given by uBH, the order of the energy of Doppler shift is kFlmtimes larger than that of Zee- man energy. Thus, we can neglect the Zeeman effect in4 the present analysis. This is in sharp contrast to QSHS where the Zeeman energy is the main effect of H, which opens the gap in the helical edge modes and modulates the transport properties [6]. The enhanced spin current due to the Doppler shift is specific to not realized in QSHS. FIG. 2: (Color online) Angle averaged spin conductance and charge conductance as a function of eVwith bias voltage V withlkF= 0.1u. a:H= 0, b:H= 0.2H0, c:H=-0.2H0, and d:H= 0.4H0. Curves bandcof the right panel shown in Fig. 1, to discuss ofthe helical edge modes, it is sufficient to consider pure ( px+- ipy)-wave state. In the following, we choose ( In Fig. 2, the spin conductance sSand normal state are plotted. It should be noted that sS becomes nonzero in the presence of the magnetic field H(see curves b,candd), sincefS(ph) is no more odd function of phdue to the imbalance of the helical edge modes. For l= 0 limit, the corresponding helical edge modes are given by E= p(1 As seen from the curves bandc, the sign ofsSis reversed by changing the direction of the applied magnetic field. On the other hand, the resulting charge conductance has different features. For H= 0, the resulting line shape of sCis the same as that ofchiral p-wave superconductor (see curve aof right panel) [16, 17, 24]. As seen from curves bandcof right panel, sC does not change with the change of the direction of the magnetic field H. Finally, we show in Fig. 3 the nearly linearly proportional to H. Note that with a small magnetic field already of the order of 1. Meanwhile, sCis almost independent of H. In conclusion, we have studied the spin of (NCS) superconduc- tor from the viewpoint of topology and Andreev bound state (ABS). We have found the incident angle depen- dent spin polarized current flowing through the inter- face. When the weak magnetic field is applied, even the angle-integrated current is largely spin polarized. AsFIG. 3: (Color online) Angle averaged spin and charge con- ductance for eV= 0 as a function of HwithlkF= 0.1u. a: spin conductance and b: charge conductance. the analogy to quantum spin Hall system (QSHS), the ABS in NCS superconductor corresponds to the helical edge modes in QSHS. The Andreev reflection via helical edge modes produces the enhanced spin current specific to NCS work is partly supported by the under the Grant No. 20654030, and Project from the Ministry of Sports, Science, and Technology, Japan, NTT basic research laboratories, DOE BES and by LDRD. [1] See for e.g., The Quantum Hall effect , edited by R.E. Prange and S.M. Girvin, 1987), and references therein. [2] D. J. Thouless, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 405 (1982). [3] C. L. Kane and E. J. Mele, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 146802 (2005); C. L. Kane and E. J. Mele, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 226801 (2005). [4] B. A. Bernevig, and S. C. Zhang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 106802 (2006). [5] L. Fu and C. L. Kane, Phys. Rev. B 74, 195312 (2006); L. Fu and C. L. Kane, Phys. Rev. B 76, 045302 (2007). [6] M. K onig et al., Science, 318, 766 (2007). [7] Y. Maeno et al., Nature 394, 532 (1994) [8] M. Matsumoto and M. Sigrist, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 68, 994 (1999). [9] N. Read and D. Green, Phys. Rev. B 61, 10267 (2000). [10] D. A. Ivanov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 268 (2001). [11] E. Bauer, et. al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 027003 (2004). [12] P. A. Frigeri, et. al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 097001 (2004). [13] N. Reyren et al., Science 317, 1196 (2007). [14] X.L. Qi, et. al., arXiv:0803.3614; M. R. Roy, A. F. Andreev, Sov. Phys. JETP 19, 1228 (1964). [16] C. Iniotakis, et. al., Phys. Rev. B 76, 012501 (2007). [17] T. Yokoyama, Y. Tanaka and J. Inoue, Phys. Rev. B 72 220504(R) (2005). [18] L. J. Buchholtz and G. Zwicknagl, Phys. Rev. B 23, 5788 (1981); C. R. Hu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 1526 (1994). [19] Y. Tanaka and S. Kashiwaya, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3451 (1995). S. Kashiwaya and Y. Tanaka, Rep. Prog. Phys.5 63, 1641 (2000). [20] A.B. Vorontsov, I. Vekhter, M. Eschrig, Phys. Rev. Lett . 101, 127003 (2008). [21] J. Goryo and K. Ishikawa, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 67, 3006 (1998); A. Furusaki, M. Matsumoto, and M. Sigrist, Phys. Rev. B 64054514 (2001).[22] S. Kashiwaya, et. al., Phys. Rev. B, 603572 (1999). [23] M. Fogelstr om, D. Rainer and J. A. Sauls, Phys. Rev. Lett.79281 (1997). [24] J. Linder and A. Sudbo, Phys. Rev. B 76, 054511 (2007).
|
0806.4639
|
Yukio Tanaka
|
Yukio Tanaka, Takehito Yokoyama, Alexander V. Balatsky and Naoto
Nagaosa
|
Topological spin-current in non-centrosymmetric superconductors
| null | null |
10.1103/PhysRevB.79.060505
| null |
cond-mat.supr-con
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study the spin transport properties of the non-centrosymmetric
superconductor with time-reversal-symmetry where spin-triplet $(p_{x} \pm i
p_{y})$-wave and spin-singlet s-wave pair potential can mix each other. We show
that when the amplitude of $(p_{x} \pm ip_{y})$-wave pair potential is larger
than that of s-wave one, the superconducting state belongs to the topologically
nontrivial class analogous to the quantum spin Hall system, and the resulting
helical edge modes as Andreev bound states are topologically protected. We find
that the incident angle dependent spin polarized current flows through the
interface due to the presence of the helical edge modes. With a weak magnetic
field, also the angle-integrated current is strongly spin polarized.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sat, 28 Jun 2008 01:37:28 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Sun, 19 Oct 2008 04:21:12 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Tanaka",
"Yukio",
""
],
[
"Yokoyama",
"Takehito",
""
],
[
"Balatsky",
"Alexander V.",
""
],
[
"Nagaosa",
"Naoto",
""
]
] |
2 FIG. 1: Electron emission signals for different E and B. (a)-(c) constant E and different B; (d)-(f) constant Band different E. The red curves (with large periodic emission) ar e single shot; the blue curve (with much less periodic emissio n) is the average of 40 shots. the black curve (with large prompt peak) is the electron signal without a magnetic field. a smallB/bardbl. We observeperiodic pulsed electron emission even with a very small B, as shown in Fig. 1a-1c. As we increase Bfrom zero, the electron signal starts to about 30-50 us after the formation of the plasma with frequency of several hundred KHz. The three traces in each panel of Fig. 1 correspond to individual single for each shot, although the phases are random. As wecontinueto increase Btoabout 2-2.5G (Fig.1b), the amplitude of the emissions gets larger, comparable to the prompt peak in the absence of a magnetic field. The frequency decreases to 50-100 KHz and the prompt peak gets even smaller. The background electron emission sig- nal almost vanishes except for few peaks at about 3-3.5 G (Fig. 1c). The frequency and amplitude of the periodic elec- tron signal also depends on the applied electric field E (Fig. 1d-1f). The frequency increases and the amplitude of the emissions decreases as we increase E, which is sim- ilar to the case of decreasing B. Using fast (FFT) of the electron signals in Fig. 1, we can extract the emission frequency as a function of E/B (electron drift velocity Vd), as shown in Fig. 2. The emis- sion frequency depends linearly on the drift velocity withFIG. 2: The emission frequency as a function of E/B; each symbol for varying Bfrom 1 to 3.2 G and constant E; differ- ent symbol for varying E from 7 to 33 mV/cm and constant B. The emission frequency is linearly dependent on the elec- tron drift velocity Vd. a slope of 10 .2+-0.2m-1. FIG. 3: Electron projection images in weak crossed magnetic field and electric field. All the units of the images here are in pixels, and one pixel is about 150 um. By using a time-of-flight projection imaging technique [19], we image the electron spatial distribution onto detector (a phosphor screen CCD camera. Figure 3 shows the electron at different delay times after the formation of the3 UCP for different Band E. All the images are single shot, with little variation from shot to shot. In the ab- sence of a magnetic field (Fig. 3a), the electron images show a Gaussian density profile. Note that the electron image size slowly decreases during the lifetime of the electrons, electron loss and electron Coulomb ex- plosion effects, unlike ion images (whose sizes decrease in the first 20 us due to the strong Coulumb explosion ef- fect of the dense ion cloud, and then increase the real size of the plasma) [19]. As we in- creaseBto about 1 G (Fig. 3b), the electron images start to split into two lobes at about 30 us, coincident with the observation of large periodic electron At about 2 G, we observe up to 3 lobes in extra electron lobes are in the E xBdirection, and they show up in the other side of the main electron cloud if we change the sign of B. We did not observe any changes in the ion images and ion current in the cross- field to those without a magnetic field. distribution to closely follow the ion distribution for a cold neutral plasma. In order to confirm that the extra lobes of the electron images are coming from the plasma itself, rather than dynamics during the flight to the detectorofthe technique, we took a series of images at different extraction parameters such as the high-voltage amplitude and width and the accel- erating voltages on the middle and front grids (located between the plasma and the detector, and strongly affect the sizes of electron images). We always observe the sim- iliar results as Fig. 3, implying this is a good measure of the electron distribution in the plasma. Using a simple model of the electron space charge effects during transit to the detector, we find the separation between the main cloudandthe offlight wherestis the plasma size at delay time t. That is, the extra lobes are located inside the plasma. There are a multitude of different instabilities in plas- mas, but given our parameters we can constrain possible choices to a small number. We identify the periodic elec- tron emission signals as well as the extra lobes in the electron projection images as a signature of a plasma in- stability due to electrons drifting relative to ions across the magnetic field. The crossed magnetic and electric fields will drive the electrons to drift with a velocity Vd (Vd=E/B) in the ExBdirection. The ions not affected by the small B(several G), due to their largemass (the ion gyroradiusis much larger thanthe UCPsizeandthe iongyro-periodis muchlonger than the UCP lifetime). In our UCP the electrons are unmagnetized in the first ~30us because the is about the same order of magnitude as the UCP size and the electron collision rate is higher than the electron cyclotron frequency. As the UCP expands,the plasma size gets larger, the plasma density gets lower andthe smaller(due mechanisms) [4]. The electrons become magne- tized at about 30-50 us after the formation of the UCP because the electron collsion rate starts to be less than the electron gyrofrequency and the plasma size at that time is about a factor of 10 larger than the electron gyro- radius, which is consistent with our observation that the periodic emissions start at the same time. The frequency is in the range from 50 KHz up to a few hundred KHz, which is much larger than the ion cyclotron Hz at 1 G) and much less than the electron fce(~2.8MHz at 1G) and the electron plasma wave fpewhich is about 10-20 MHz at the delay time of about 30-50 us. The periodic emission signal is roughly independent of plasma density (or plasma fre- quency) as shown in Fig. 1 (note that the plasma density drops by a factor of 8 from 50 us to 100 us). There are periodic emissions with different frequencies (Fig. 1b and 1d), which also indicates that we have plasma switching) in the cross-field configuration. A candidate instability is the high-frequency electron drift instability, which has been studied in Hall thrusters (a type of plasma-based propulsion systems for space- crafts) experimentally [15, 16] and theoretically [17, 18] in the past few years to explain the transport of electrons across the magnetic field lines. A 2D fully kinetic model ofthe Hall thruser developed in ref. [17] has demonstated that the largedrift velocity at the exhaust ofthe thruster was the source of an instability that gives rise to and could induce a significant current across the magnetic field. It is a high-frequency electron with frequency frlower than the electron cy- clotron frequency fceand short wavelength close to the electron gyroradius rce, which is studied in ref. [18]. The theory of high-frequency electron drift instabil- ity is developed from the dispersion equation of electro- static waves in a hot magnetized electron beam drifting across a magnetic field with unmagnetized cold ions, and is closely related to the instabilities in other plasma systems, such as non-specular radar me- teor trails [10], the ionosphere of the earth [11, 12], dusty plasmas [13] and magnetic pulses [14], but they usually restrict the analysis to the cases where the drift veloc- ityVdis much smaller than the electron thermal veloc- ityVeth. For high-frequency electron drift instabilities in Hall thrusters and here, Vdis about the same order of magnitude as the Veth, and much larger than the mag- netic field gradientdrift velocity and the density gradient drift an electrostatic field perturbation and a Maxwellian electron with mean velocity Vdand temperature Te, the dispersion equation can be written in the limit kz= 04 FIG. 4: Numerical solutions of the 1D dispersion relation of equation (1) as in [18], but for our condition. (a) repre- sents the envelopes of the real (frequency) and the imaginar y (growth rate) as a function of kyVd/ope. (b) the correspond- ing ones for small wavenumbers. The electron cyclotron fre- quency is equal to 0 .2ope, andVeth/Vd= 0.5. (wherekzis the wavenumber along B) (1) wherekxyis the wavenumber in the plane the Debye length; ohm ceis the electron cyclotron frequecy; opeis the electron kyis the wavenumberin the The functions Inare modified Bessel functions of order n. In order to find the dependence of orandoion the wavenumber ky, we have solved numerically equation (1) by taking a further approximation to neglect the pertur- bations perpendicular to the drift motion ( kx= 0, the wavenumber along E) because the electron drift velocity Vdis about an orderof magnitude largerthan the density gradient drift velocity. Figure 4 shows the frequency and the ofthe unstable modes as a function of ky. Figure 4a and 4b are the envelopes of the solutions and the first 5 modes, respectively. The values offrfor the maximum growth rate correspond to fre- quencies ranging from 90 KHz to 140 KHz for fpe= 21 MHz,B= 2 G,E= 20 mV/cm and Te= 2.7 K at delay time of about 30 us (where Teis from [4]), which agrees with the measured frequencies at Vd= 104m/s in Fig. 4. The ratio of the frequency to the drift velocity isabout 9-14 m-1, in agreement with the measured slope of Fig. 2 (10.2 m-1). The maximum of the growth rate is reached for kyVd/ope= 1.2, and the is about 0.5 mm, close to the electron gyro- radius (about 0.2 mm for B= 2 G and Te= 2.7 K). We can also see the transitions from stability to instabil- ity whenever kyVd/opeis close to a cyclotron The growth ratereachesa maximum and then decreases sharply between each cyclotron harmonic, and is separated by stable regions. The frequency is several orders of magnitude below the growth rate except in the vicinity of the maximum. The frequency roughly linearly depends on the drift velocity (below kyVd/ope= 1), but is independent of the plasma frequency (i.e. plasma density) before the fre- quency reaches the maximum value (both axis are scaled by electron plasma frequency in Fig. 4a), which explains the lack of density dependence seen in Fig. 1. We mea- sure the growth rate by suddenly applying the electric field at different delay times, and find the periodic emis- sion occurs within 1-2 us after application of the to a growth rate of ~100-150 KHz for B= 2 G and E= 20 mV/cm, which is about the same as the frequency fr. Although we see large scale density structures in the electron images, we do not have a model of the micro- scopic electron motion that produces the periodic detection, since it is transverse to the detector di- rection. This is seen in the strong suppression of the prompt electron emission peak. Nevertheless, we detect large pulses of electrons, presumably due to large elec- tron trajectories that extend past the grid (1.5 cm below the plasma) where the large acceleration field can direct the electrons to the detector, even in the presence of the transverse magnetic field. In summary, we have observed large periodic and splitting of the electron distribution into two or three lobes from an expanding UCP in the pres- ence of crossed magnetic and electric fields. We iden- tify them as a signature of high-frequency electron due to the electrons drifting relative to the ions across the magnetic field. We calculate the unstable mode frequencies and growth rates by solving 1D dis- persion equation and find good agreement. The large scale changes in the electron spatial distribution remain a mystery, as does the exact mechanism that leads to the emission of electrons. This work shows that UCPs will continue to provide an interesting place to study funda- mental plasma physics phenomena. This work was supported by the National T. C. Killian et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 83,4776 (1999). [2] J. L. Roberts et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 92,253003 (2004). [3] P. Gupta et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 99,075005 (2007). [4] R. S. Fletcher et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 99,145001 (2007). [5] S. Kulin et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 85,318 (2000). [6] S. D. Bergeson et al., Phys. Rev. E 67,026414 (2003). [7] F. Robicheaux et al., J. Phys. Plasmas 10,2217 (2003). [8] R. S. Fletcher et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 96,105003 (2006). [9] G. D. Conway et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 84,1463 (2000).[10] M. Oppenheim et al., J. Geophys. Res. 108,0163 (2003). [11] D. T. Farley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 10,279 (1963). [12] O. Buneman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 10,7 (1963). [13] R. L. Merlino et al., Phys. Plasma 5,1607 (1998). [14] N. A. Krall and P. C. Liewer, Phys. Rev. A 4,5 (1971). [15] A. A. Litvak et al., Phys. Plasma 11,1701 (2004). [16] A. Lazurenko et al., Phys. Plasma 12,013501 (2005). [17] J. C. Adam et al., Phys. Plasma 11,295 (2004). [18] A. Ducrocq et al., Phys. Plasma 13,102111 (2006). [19] X. L. Zhang et al., Preprint arXiv:0806.1511. (2008). [20] X. L. Zhang, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 100,235002 (2008).
|
0806.4691
|
Xianli Zhang
|
X. L. Zhang, R. S. Fletcher, and S. L. Rolston
|
Observation of an ultracold plasma instability
|
5 pages, 4 figures, submitted to PRL
|
Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 195002 (2008)
|
10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.195002
| null |
physics.plasm-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We present the first observation of an instability in an expanding ultracold
plasma. We observe periodic emission of electrons from an ultracold plasma in
weak, crossed magnetic and electric fields, and a strongly perturbed electron
density distribution in electron time-of-flight projection images. We identify
this instability as a high-frequency electron drift instability due to the
coupling between the electron drift wave and electron cyclotron harmonic, which
has large wavenumbers corresponding to wavelengths close to the electron
gyroradius.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 29 Jun 2008 12:15:35 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 24 Jul 2008 14:41:02 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-06T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Zhang",
"X. L.",
""
],
[
"Fletcher",
"R. S.",
""
],
[
"Rolston",
"S. L.",
""
]
] |
2 01234567 -4-2 0 2 4 601 -10 0 10 20 30 energy (eV)0123456XANES cross section (arb. units) -4-2 0 2 4 1: (Color online) Calculated and measured [23] Ni K- edge XAS of NiO including partial fluorescence yield (PFY) (this work). The dashed (solid) curves correspond to ofref. [16, 17]. The wavefunctions are expanded using a 140 Ry energy cutoff for NiO. The calculated value of U for NiO is U=7.6 eV. XAS spectra are computed in a supercell approach in- cluding core-holeeffects in the pseudopotential of the ab- sorbingatom. spectra are obtained using the continued fraction [14] and the PAW method of ref. [22]. We considered 2x2x2 supercells of the magnetic cell (32 atoms). We used 4x4x4 k-points grid both for the charge density and the continued fraction calculation. In fig. 1 we show calculated NiO XAS spectra and their decomposition into dipolar and quadrupolar parts using GGA and GGA+U, as compared to [23] for single crystals. We consider the following two sets of polarization oand wavevector k: , denoted by egorientation (dashed by lines). The directions are in terms of the param- agnetic cubic crystal cell. We note that U has no effect on high-energy near-edge and far-edge features (labeled C,D,E). On the contrary the energy and angular depen- dence of pre-edge structures (see insets in Fig. 1) are incorrect in the framework of GGA. Peak B is at too low energy and a too large mixing occurs between structures A and B. In the GGA+U calculation the dipolar peak B is shifted to 2 eV higher energies and the is in excellent agreement with . The CGA+U calculation also shows that a very small dipolar component is present in peak A, as purely quadrupolar. Detailed analysis of the angular dependence of the experimental NiO quadrupolar transition occurs because the t 2gstates are occupied, a small peak is present [24], in agreement with our findings. Thus, in correlated insulators, the use of the DFT+U approximation is mandatory to obtain a correct description of the pre-edge features. To complete the understanding of the pre-edge fea- tures in NiO we resolve the XAS spectrum in its spin dependence and calculate the density of states projected over atomic orbitals using L owdin projections. Without loss of generality we have considered the absorbing Ni to be spin-up polarized. As can be seen in Fig. 2, the quadrupolar part of peak A is mostly due to to d-states lowered by core-hole since the hybridization between Ni and O is very strong, core-hole attraction lowers a small portion of the O 2p states generating a small dipolar component in peak A. In a atomic orbital picture, peak A is due to direct dipole transitions from Ni 1s states to O 2p states. In our calculation the intensity of this excitations is of the order of 1% of the edge jump. In experiments it is somewhat smaller because of the larger linewidth. This estimate is crucial for the quantitative description of this off-site excitation in multiplet calculation. The spin-resolved dipolar spectrum shows that peak B is mostly due to transition to up spin-polarized states. Since the absorbing atom has 5 up electrons in d- states, the B excitation musthave an off-site component. L owdin projections demonstrate that it is due to transi- tion to on-site Ni empty 4p-states hybridized to empty 3d-states of next-to-nearest neighbours Ni atoms. hoppingpro- cess leading to superexchange in NiO and a direct probe of the upper Hubbard band in NiO. To understand the role of core-hole effects on the A and B features we have performed calculations with and without acoreholein the final state. We found thatpeak A is shifted by 4 eV with respect to the edge by core- hole attraction. On the contrary peak B is due to the non-local nature of peak B. We now demonstrate that the non-local nature of the B excitation and its weakdependence on be used to measure the correlation gap between the We consider hole-doped NiO. In practice this can be achieved through Li doping [25], as in the case of Li xNi1-xO. A large range of doping can be experimentally obtained with 0 < x <0.7. It has been shown [26, 27] that, when NiO is doped with holes, the holes mainly reside on O atoms, due to the charge transfer character of NiO. Thus the top of the NiO va-3 00.51dip. up dip. down qua. up qua. down -101Ni abs. 3d 010DOS n.n. 3d Ni next to n.n. 3d -4 -2 0 2 4 68 energy (eV)-505O n.n. 2pABXANES cross sec. (arb. 2: (Color online) Comparison between GGA+U calcu- lated K-edge Ni XAS and L owdin projected density of states. lence band has mainly p character. This suggests that in Ni K-edge XAS of Li xNi1-xO, in the low doping regime, an additional dipolar peak should occur in the from the holes entering the top of the valence band. This is confirmed by oxygen K-edge absorption where the top of the valence band is seen even at dop- ings as low as x= 0.05)[26]. At somewhat larger doping, a similar peak due to Oxygen p-holes should also occur in the dipolar part of Ni K-edge XAS. Since no exper- imental data are available in the literature, we Ni K-edge XAS in Li xNi1-xO. We calculate hole-doping of NiO in two different ways, namely (i) by rigid-band doping of NiO and (ii) adding a compensating charge background and recalculating the charge-density and the XAS spectra. The results of the Ni K-edge XAS in Li xNi1-xO in the pre-edge region with and without a core-hole in the final state are shown in Fig. 3. We find that the top of the valence band should be visible in Ni K-edge XAS at dop- ings ofx15-20%. In the calculated spectra, with or without a core-hole in the final state, the energy position of the top of the valence band and of peak B are indepen- dent on doping. The agreement between the rigid band picture and the background calcu- lation validates the rigid band picture for 0 < x <0.2 In NiO the experimentally measurable gap is due to the excitation between the top of the valence band and the empty d-states. In DFT+U [28] and GW [29] cal- culations the lowest single particle excitation is between the valence band and an s band occurring at energies-2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5core-hole in the no core-hole in energy (eV)XANES cross section (arb. units)GAP = 5 eV GAP = 5.25 state the final state A B BVB VB 3: (Color online) Calculated pre-edge features of Ni K- edge XAS spectra of Li xNi1-xO with (a) and without (b) core-hole effects using a rigid doping (solid line) approach or adding a compensating charged background Peaks labeling is the same as in Fig. 1, VB stands for Valence Band. (c) Band structure of NiO along GX. lower than the empty d states (see Fig. 3). This band is invisible in experiments since its optical matrix elements are extremely weak [28]. Moreoverits also invisible in K- edge XAS since it is highly dispersive and has mostly Ni s and O s components. Thus in the absence of the distance between the top of the valence band and peak B is a measure of the correlation gap, being the dependence of the energy position on doping very weak (see Fig. 3, right panel). When core-hole attraction is considered (see Fig. 3, left panel), we find that, despite the occurrence of a core-hole exciton (peak A), the dis- tance between the top of the valence band and peak B is very weakly affected ( 5%). Consequently in NiO the distance between the top of the va- lence band and peak B is a measure of the correlation gap even in the presence of a core-hole in the final state. In our calculation the charge-transfer gap is 5 3.1 eV and reaches its maximum at 4 .0 eV [30, 31]. This value is reduced respect to our due to excitonic ef- fects. In photoemission and inverse photoemission [32] the gap (peak-to-peak distance) is roughly 5.5 eV, in fairly good agreement with our value. Thus our proposal allows for an independent estimate of the optical gap charge-transfer gap and the upper Hubbard band In these systems the top of the valence band is due to Oxygen p-states and it is4 thus visible in dipolar TM K-edge XAS upon doping. If the doping necessary to detect this feature is low enough not to affect substantially the electronic structure then a rigid-band doping picture applies and the top of the valence band is at the same energy as in the undoped system. Moreover, hole states being dipolar in nature, the effects of core-hole attraction are weak. The top of the valence band ofthe doped systemcan then be used as a reference energy for the measurement of the excitations seen in TM K-edge XAS. The second necessary condition is the features[5, 6] (peak B) in the pre-edge region due to transitions to d-states of neighboring TM atoms promoted by hybridization with the TM absorbing atom p-states. If these excitations are visible, we have shown that they represent the up- per Hubbard band of the material and the energy differ- ence between this excitation and the top of the valence band in the is a transfer gap. Thus, TM K-edge XAS in charge-transfer insulators is unbiased experi- mental tool to measure the charge-transfer gap. In this work we have developed a new method to calculate K-edge XAS core-holeeffects in the finalstate at the DFT+U level. We have shown that the method provides spectra in excellent agreement data for NiO, the prototype correlated in- sulator. We have interpreted all the pre-edge and near- edge features in the experimental data. In particular, we have identified a dipolar pre-edge feature as due to non-local excitations to d-states of the second Ni atoms, namely the upper Hubbard band. We have shown that, due to its non-local nature, this excitation is unaffected by the presence of a core-hole in the final state. Starting from this result we have pro- posed a new way to measure the intrinsic correlation gap in charge-transfer insulators based on TM K-edge XAS. This method is complementary to optical mea- surements and more straightforward than a photoemission experiment. We acknowledge useful conversation with A. Kotani, G.Dr ager,O. VSipr, Ph. Sainctavit, M.Arrio, D.Cabaret, A. Juhin, H. Kulik, N. Marzari and L. Reining. Cal- culations were performed at the IDRIS (project 071202). [1] M. Z. Hasan, E. D. Isaacs, Z.-X. Shen, L. L. Miller, K. Tsutsui, T. Tohyama, S. Maekawa, Science H. Hayashi, Y. Udagawa, W. A. Caliebe, and C. -C. Kao, Phys. Rev. B 66, 033105 (2002) [3] E. Collart, A. Shukla, J.-P. Rueff, P. Leininger, H. Ishii , I. Jarrige, Y. Q. Cai, S.-W. Cheong, and G. Dhalenne, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 157004 (2006)[4] Y. J. Kim, J. P. Hill, C. A. Burns, S. Wakimoto, R. J. Birgeneau, D. Casa, T. Gog, and C. T. Rev. Lett. 89, 177003 (2002) [5] A. Shukla, M. Calandra, M. Taguchi, A. Kotani, Gyrgy Vanko, and S.-W. Cheong, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, G. Vanko, F. M. F. de Groot, S. Huotari, R. J. Cava, T. Lorenz, M. Reuther, A. Kotani and S. Shin, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73, 203 (2001) [8] J. Kunes, V. I. Anisimov, S. L. Skornyakov, A. V. Lukoy- anov, D. Vollhardt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 156404 (2007) [9] M. Taguchi, M. Matsunami, Y. Ishida, R. Eguchi, A. Chainani, Y. Takata, M. Yabashi, K. Tamasaku, Y. Nishino, T. Ishikawa, Y.Senba, H.Ohashi, S. Shin, Phys- ical Review Letters 100, 206401 (2008) [10] T. Uozumi, K. Okada, A. Kotani, O. Durmeyer, J. P. Kappler, E. Beaurepaire, and J. C. Parlebas, 85 (1992) [11] Y. Joly, D. Cabaret, H. Renevier and C. R. Natoli, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2398 (1999) [12] T. Uozumi, K. Okada, A. Kotani, O. Durmeyer, J. P. Kappler, E. Beaurepaire and J. C. Parlebas, 85 (1992) [13] H. Tolentino, M. Medarde, A. Fontaine, F. Baudelet, E. Dartyge, D. Guay, and G. Tourillon, Phys. Rev. B 45, 8091 (1992) [14] M. Taillefumier, D. Cabaret, A-M. Flank, and F. Mauri, Phys. Rev. B 66, 195107 (2002) [15] V. I. Anisimov, J. Zaanen, and O. K. Andersen, Phys. Rev. B44, 943 (1991), V. I. Anisimov, F. A. I. Liechtenstein, J. Phys. Condens. Matter 9, 767 (1997). [16] M. Cococcioni and S. de Gironcoli, Phys. Rev. B 71, 035105 (2005) [17] H.J. Kulik, M.Cococcioni, D.A. Scherlis and N. Marzari , Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 103001 (2006) [18] S.P. Srivastava, R.C. Srivastava, I.D. Singh, S.D. Pan dey and P.L. Gupta , J. Phy. Soc. Jap. 43, 885 (1977) [19] S. Baroni, et al., Rev. Mod. Phy s. 73, 515-562 (2001) [20] N. Troullier and J. L. Martins, Phys. Rev. B 43, 1993 (1991) [21] J.P.Perdew, K.Burke, M.Ernzerhof, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865 (1996) [22] P. Bl ochl, Phys. Rev. B 50, 17 953 (1994) [23] R.V. Vedrinskii, V.L. Kraizman, A.A. Novakovich, S.M. Elyafi, S.Bocharov, T.Kirchner, G. Dr ager, Phys. Stat. Sol.226, 203 (2001) [24] In fig. 1 of this work and in fig. 3 of ref. [23] a very small peak is present for t F. Reinert, P. Steiner, S. H ufner, H. Schmitt, J. Fink, M. Knupfer, P. Sandl, E. Bertel, Z. Phys. B 97, 83 (1995) [26] P. Kuiper, G. Kruizinga, J. Ghijsen, G. A. Sawatzky, and H. Verweij, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 221 (1989) [27] J. van Elp, H. Eskes, P. Kuiper, and G. A. Sawatzky, Phys. Rev. B 45, 1612 (1992). [28] O. Bengone, M. Alouani, P. Bl ochl, and J. Hugel, Phys. Rev. B 62, 16392 (2000) [29] S. V. Faleev, M. van Schilfgaarde, and T. Kotani, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 126406 (2004) [30] G. A. Sawatzky and J. W. Allen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53, 2339 (1984) [31] S. H ufner, Advances in Physics 43, 183, (1994) [32] S. H ufner and T. Riesterer, Phys. Rev. B, 337267 (1986)
|
0806.4706
|
Matteo Calandra
|
C. Gougoussis, M. Calandra, A. Seitsonen, Ch. Brouder, A. Shukla and
F. Mauri
|
Measuring the intrinsic charge transfer gap using K-edge X-ray
absorption spectroscopy
|
4 pages, 3 figures
| null | null | null |
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Pre-edge features in X-ray absorption spectroscopy contain key information
about the lowest excited states and thus on the most interesting physical
properties of the system. In transition metal oxides they are particularly
structured but extracting physical parameters by comparison with a calculation
is not easy due to several computational challenges. By combining core-hole
attraction and correlation effects in first principles approach, we calculate
Ni K-edge X-ray absorption spectra in NiO. We obtain a striking, parameter-free
agreement with experimental data and show that dipolar pre-edge features above
the correlation gap are due to non-local excitations largely unaffected by the
core-hole. We show that in charge transfer insulators, this property can be
used to measure the correlation gap and probe the intrinsic position of the
upper-Hubbard band.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sat, 28 Jun 2008 16:35:28 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-01T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Gougoussis",
"C.",
""
],
[
"Calandra",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Seitsonen",
"A.",
""
],
[
"Brouder",
"Ch.",
""
],
[
"Shukla",
"A.",
""
],
[
"Mauri",
"F.",
""
]
] |
120 V. BRAVERMAN,K. R.OS TROVSKY 1. d celebrated sketching techniques and showed that 4-wise independence is sufficient to obtain good approximati ons of the second frequency moment. Indyk and McGregor [12] make use of this te chnique in their work introduce the problem of measuring independence in the streaming mode l. There they give efficient algo- rithms for approximating pairwise independence for the l1andl2norms. In their model, a distribution corresponds toapproximating thedistan andthe product of the marginal distributions for the pairs. Indyk a nd McGregor state, as an explicit open question in their paper, the problem of whether one can estim atek-wise independence on k-tuples for anyk >2. In particular, Indyk and McGregor show that, for the l2norm, they can make use of theproduct of functions on method ofAlon, Matias, and Szegedy. We extend their approach to show that on the product domain[n]k, the sketching method of Alon, Matias, and Szegedy works when using the product of kcopies of 4-wise on [n]. The cost is that the memory requirements of our approach gro w proportionally to 3k. Measuring independence and k-wise independence is a fundamental problem with many ap- plications (see e.g., Lehmann [13]). Recently, this proble m was also addressed in other models by, among others, Alon, Andoni, Kaufman, Matulef, Rubinfeld an d Xie [1]; Batu, Fortnow, Fischer, Kumar, Rubinfeld and White [5]; Goldreich and Ron [11]; Batu , Kumar and Rubinfeld [6]; Alon, Goldreich and Mansour [3]; and Rubinfeld and Servedio [15]. Traditional non-parametric methods of testing independence over empirical data usually requir e space complexity that is polynomial to either the support size or input size. The scale of contemp orary data sets often prohibits such space complexity. It is therefore natural to ask whether we w ill be able to design algorithms to test for independence in streaming model. Interestingly, this s pecific problem appears not to have been introduced until theworkof Indyk andMcGregor. Whileargua bly results for the l1norm wouldbe stronger thanfor the l2norm inthis setting, theproblem for problem for the l1norm has been recently resolved by Braverman and Ostrovsky i n [8]. They gave algorithm that makes a single pass over a dat a stream and memory. 1.1. OurResults In this paper we generalize the sketching of sketches resu lt of Indyk and McGregor. Our specific theoretical contributions can besummarized as fol lows: Main vR(nk)be a vector with entries /vector vpRforp[n]k. Leth1,...,h k: copies of 4-wise independent hash functions; t hat is,hi(1),...,h independent hash functions for each i[k], andh1(*),...,h k(*)are mutually and the sketch vpH(p). We prove that the sketch Ycan be used to give an efficient approximation for /bardbl/vector v/bardbl2; our result isstated formally inTheorem 4.2. Notethat Hisnot4-wise independent. As a corollary, the main application of our main theorem is to extend the result of Indyk and McGregor [12] to detect the dependency of krandom variables in streaming model.AMS WITHOUT 4-WISE INDEPENDENCE ON PRODUCT DOMAINS 121 Corollary 1.1. For every o >0andd >0, there exists a randomized algorithm that computes, given a sequence a1,...,a mofk-tuples, in one pass and using logn)) memory bits, a number Yso that the probability Ydeviates from the l2distance between product and joint distribution bymore than afactor of (1+o)is at most d. 1.2. Remark This paper is merge from [7, 9, 10], where the same result was o btained with different proofs. The proof of [10] generalizes the geometric approach of Indy k and McGregor [12] with new geo- metric observations. The proofs of [7, 9] are more combinato rial in nature. These papers offer new insights, but due to the space limitation, we focus on the pro of from [9] in this paper. Original papers are available online and are recommended tothe inter ested reader. 2. The Model Weprovide the general underlying model. Herewemostly foll ow the notation of mwithelements a1,...,a (When we have a sequence of elements that are themselves vectors, w e denote the sequence number by a subscript and the vector entry by a superscript when both ar e needed.) The stream Sdefines an empirical distribution over [n]kasfollows: thefrequency f(o)ofanelement number of timesit appears in S,and the empirical distribution is Pr[o] =f(o) mfor (o1,...,o k)is a vector of size k, we may also view the streaming data as defining a joint distribution over the random variables X1,...,X kcorresponding to the values in each di- mension. (Inthecase of k= 2, wewritetherandom variables as XandYrather than X1andX2.) There is a natural way of defining marginal distribution for t he random variable Xi: number of times oiappears in the ithcoordinate of an element of S,or fi(oi) marginal distribution Pri[*]for theith coordinate isdefined as Pri[oi] =fi(oi) mfor anyoi[n]. Next let/vector vbethe vector in R[n]kwith/vector vo= allo[n]k. Our goal isto approximate the wewould expect to beclose tozero inthe case where the Xiweretruly our algorithms will assume the availability of 4-w ise independent hash functions. For moreon4-wise independence, including efficient implement ations, see[2,16]. Forthe purposes of this paper, the following simple definition will suffice.122 V. BRAVERMAN,K. R.OS 2.1. (4-wise independence) A family of hash functions Hwith domain [n]and independent if for any distinct values the following equality =b1,h(i2) =b2,h(i3) =b3,h(i4) =b4] = 1/16. Remark 2.2. In [12], the family of 4-wise independent hash functions Hiscalled 4-wise indepen- dent random vectors. For consistencies within our paper, we will always view the object Has a hash function family. 3. The Algorithmand itsAnalysisfor k= algorithm andassoc iated proofforthe l2normgiven in [12]. Reviewing this result will allow us to provide the ne cessary notation and frame the setting for our extension to general k. Moreover, in our proof, we find that a constant in Lemma 3.1 from [12] that we subsequently generalize appears incorrec t. (Because of this, our proof is and more detailed than the original.) Although th e error is minor in the context of their paper (it only affects the constant factor in the order notat ion), it becomes more important when considering the proper generalization to larger k, and hence it isuseful tocorrect here. Inthecase k= an item. Each is an element in [n]2. The random variables XandY over[n]can be expressed = Pr[ X=i,Y=j] =|{l: (a1 l,a2 l) = (i,j)}|/m Pr1[i] = Pr[ X=i] =|{l: (a1 l,a2 l) = (i,*)}|/m Pr2[j] = Pr[ Y=j] =|{l: (a1 l,a2 l) = (*,j)}|/m. We simplify the notation and use Pr[X=i,Y=j]. and si,j= and McGregor's algorithm proceeds in a similar fashio n to the streaming algorithm pre- sented in[4]. Specifically let s1= 72o-2ands2= 2log(1 /d). Thealgorithm computes Y1,Y2,...,Y s2and outputs their median. The output is the algorithm's esti mate on the norm ofvdefined in Equation 2.1. Each Yiis the average of s1random variables identically distributed random variable s. D=Dij can becomputed from the algorithmic routine shown inFigure 1. 2-D Independently generate 4-wise independent random functi = (i,j) 4 Return Y= 1: Theprocedure for generating random variable Yfork= A PPROXIMATION ,wehave Also, when a vector is in R(n2), its indices can be represented by (i1,i2)[n]2. In what follows, we will use a bold letter to represent the in dex of aAMS WITHOUT 4-WISE INDEPENDENCE ON PRODUCT DOMAINS 123 high dimensional vector, e.g., vivi1,i2. Thefollowing Lemmashowsthat the expectation of the variance of Yisat most 3.1. ([12]) Leth1,h2be two independent instances of 4-wise independent hash fun Let us define ThenE[Y] which implies have E[Y] = vi)2] v2 iE[H2(i)] vi/vector vjE[H(i)H(j)]. For all i[n]2, we know h2(i) = 1. On the other hand, H(i)H(j){-1,1}. The probability that H(i)H(j) = 1isPr[H(i)H(j) = 1] = Pr[ = 1] = 1 /16 +
1/16 = 1/2. The last equality holds is because = 1is equivalent to saying either all these variables are 1, or exactly two of the se variables are -1, or all these variables are -1. Therefore, E[h(i)h(j)] = 0. Consequently, E[Y] vi)2. Nowwebound the variance. Recall that Var[Y] = E[Y2]-E[Y]2, webound E[Y2] vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector Thequantity 0ifandonly if the following relation holds, s[2] : the set of 4-tuples (i,j,k,l)that satisfy the above relation by D. We may also view each 4-tuple asanordered set thatconsists of4pointsin [n]2. Consider theunique smallest in [n]2that contains a given 4-tuple in D(i.e. contains the four ordered points). Note this could either be a (degenerate) line segment or a (non-degene rate) rectangle, as we discuss the function that maps an element sDto the smallest by s. Since a rectangle can be uniquely determined by its diagona ls, we the isunderstood tobetheone withdiagonal Also, theinverse thepre-images of if either in which case the rectangle (and its diagonals) correspond to the segment itself, or and the rectangle isjust asingle point. Example 3.2. Leti= (1,2),j= (3,2),k= (1,5), andl= (3,5). The tuple is in Dand its corresponding bounding rectangle is a non-degenerate r ectangle. The function M(i,j,k,l) 3.3. Leti=j= (1,4)andk=l= (3,7). The tuple is also in Dand minimal bound- ing rectangle formed by these points is an interval {(1,4),(3,7)}. The function M(i,j,k,l) cases. Fixany kh2andph1<
ph2. = Twenty- four of these tuples correspond to the setting where none of i,j,k,lare equal, as there are twenty- four permutations of the assignment of the labels i,j,k,lto the four points. (This corresponds to the first example). In this case the four points form a recta ngle, and we have |/vector vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vl| <=
1 2((/vector vkh1,ph1/vector vkh2,ph2)2+ (/vector vkh1,ph2/vector vkh2,ph1)2). Intuitively, in these cases, we assign the weight of the tuple tothe diagonals.124 V. BRAVERMAN,K. R.OS TROVSKY The remaining twelve tuples in to intervals. (This corre- sponds to the second example.) In this case two of to one endpoint of the inter- val, and the other two labels correspond to the other endpoin t. Hence we have either |/vector vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vl|=
(/vector vkh1,ph1/vector vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vl|= (/vector vkh1,ph2/vector vkh2,ph1)2, and there are six tuples for each case. Therefore for any kh1< kh2[n]andph1< analysis is similar for the degenerate cases, where the c onstant 18 in the bound above is now quite loose. When exactly one of the size of toverticalorhori zontal lines. Whenboth 1. asfor the non-degenerate cases, vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vkh1,ph1/vector vkh1,ph2/vector vkh1,ph1/vector vkh1,ph2/vector vkh1,ph1/vector vkh1,ph2/vector vkh1,ph1/vector vi/vector vj)2= 9E2[Y]. Finally, we vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector thegeometric interpretation of the aboveproo f asfollows. Thegoal isto times E2[Y] lines in plane [n]2(each line appears twice). Wefirst show that vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector sinanaturalway. to use inequalities of the form |/vector vi/vector vj/vector vk/vector vkh1,ph1/vector vkh2,ph2)2+ (/vector vkh1,ph2/vector vkh2,ph1)2)to assign the weight ofeach rectangle. The aboveanalysis s. ing rectangle, using vertical or horizontal edges is problematic. The reas on is that there are ohm(n4) 4-tuples or horizontal edges, so some lines would receive ohm(n)weight, requiring ohm(n) copies. This problem is already noted in[7]. Our bound here is E[Y2]<=9E2[Y], while in [12] the bound obtained is appears to have been an error in the derivation in [12]; some intuition comes from the fol- lowing example. We note that |D|is at 9n4-9n2. (This counts the number of non-degenerate 4-tuples.) Now if we set vi= 1for all1<=i<=n2, we have Var[D]>3E2[D]. thisdiscrepancy is oflittle importance to[12]; thepoint there isthat thevari ance isbounded byaconstant factor timesAMS WITHOUT 4-WISE INDEPENDENCE ON PRODUCT DOMAINS 125 the square of theexpectation. It ishere, where weare genera lizing tok>=3,that the exact constant factor isof the bounds on the expectation and variance for the Di,j, standard techniques yield a bound on theperformance of our Forevery o >0andd Medsothat the probability Meddeviates than oisat most d. Proof.Recall the algorithm described in the beginning of Section 3 : lets1= Wefirstcomputes Y1,Y2,...,Y the average of s1random variables independent, random variables computed by Figure 1. By Cheby shev's inequality, we know that for any fixed bystandard Chernoff bound arguments (see for exam ple Chapter 4of [14]), o/bardbl/vector v/bardblisatmost d. themedian /bardbl/vector The General Case k>=3. Recallthat /vector visavectorin statistics of a data stream, and we are interested in estimating its v/bardbl. There is a natural generalization for Indyk and McGregor's method for k= 2to construct an estimator v/bardbl: leth1,...,h k: [n]-{-1,1}be independent copies of 4-wise independent hash hi(1),...,h independent hash functions for each i[k], and h1(*),...,h k(*)are mutually independent.). Let H(p) The estimator goal is to show that E[Y] =/bardbl/vector reasonably small so that a maintaining multiple independent instances of e stimatorYwill be able to output an ap- proximately correct estimation of /bardbl/vector Noticethatwhen /bardbl/vector the l2 distance between the joint distribution and the tensors of t he marginal distributions, the estimator can be computed efficiently in a streaming model similarly to as in Figure 1. We stress that our result is applicable to a broader class of l2-norm estimation problems, as long as the vector /vector vto be estimated has a corresponding efficiently computable est imatorYin an appropriate streaming model. Formally, weshall prove the following mainlemmain t he next 4.1. Let/vector vbe a vector in Rnk, andh1,...,h k: [n]-{-1,1}be independent copies of 4-wise independent hash functions. Define H(p) =||/vector remark that the bound on the variance in the above lemma is t ight. One can verify that when the vector /vector vis a uniform vector (i.e., all entries of /vector vare the same), the variance of With the above lemma, the following main theorem mentioned in the follows by a standard argument presented in the proof of Theorem 3.4 in the V. BRAVERMAN,K. R.OS TROVSKY Theorem 4.2. Let/vector vbe a vector in R[n]kthat maintains an arbitrary statistics in a data stream of sizem, in which every item is from [n]k. Leto,d(0,1)be real numbers. If there exists an algorithm that maintains an instance of ))memory bits, then there exists an algorithm Lsuch that: (1) Withprobability v|2] and (2) thespace complexity of )). As discussed above, an immediate corollary is the existence of a one-pass space algorithm todetect the dependency of krandom variables in 4.3. For every o >0andd >0, there exists a randomized algorithm that computes, given a sequence a1,...,a mofk-tuples, in one pass and using logn)) memory bits, a number Yso that the probability Ydeviates from the square of the product and joint distribution bymore than afactor of(1+o)is at most d. 4.1. Analysis of theSketch Y Thissection isdevoted llenge istobound thevariance ofY. The geometric approach of Indyk and McGregor [12] presente d in Section 3 for the case of k= 2can be extended to analyze the general case. However, we rema rk that the new ideas. In particular, instead of performing l ocal analysis that maps each rectangle to its diagonals, a more complex global analysis is needed in higher dimensions to achieve the desired bounds. The alternative proof we present here utili zes similar ideas, but relies on a rather than geometric approach. For theexpectation of Y, wehave E[Y] = vp*/vector vp*/vector v2 p=||/vector v||2, where the last equality follows by H(p)2= 1, andE[H(p)H(q)] = us start toprove Var[Y]<=3kE[Y]2. Bydefinition, Var[Y] = E[(Y-E[Y])2], sowe need to understand the following random vp/vector vq. (4.1) The random variable Erris a sum of terms indexed by pairs At a very high level, our analysis consists of two steps. In the fi rst step, we group the terms in Err properly and simplify the summation in each group. In the sec ond step, we expand the square of thesumin Var[Y] = E[Err2]according tothegroups andapply Cauchy-Schwartz inequali ty three times tobound the variance. We shall now gradually introduce the necessary notation for grouping the terms in the summation. We remind the reader that vector s over the reals (e.g., /vector vRnk) areAMS WITHOUT 4-WISE INDEPENDENCE ON PRODUCT DOMAINS 127 denotedby /vector v, /vector w,/vector r,andvectorsover [n]aredenotedby indexvectors . We useS[k]to denote a subset of [k], and let -S= [k]S. We use Ham(p,q)to denote the Hamming distance of index vectors p,q[n]k, i.e., the number of coordinates where 4.4. (Projection and inverse projection) Letc[n]kbe an index vector and S[k]a subset. We define the projection of ctoS, denoted by PhS(c)[n]|S|, to be the vector S. Also,let Wedefinethe of aandbwith respect to S, denoted by Ph-1 S(a,b)[n]k, as the index vector c[n]k such that PhS(c) =aandPh-S(c) =b. Wenext define pair groups and use the definition togroup the terms in Err. Definition 4.5. (Pair Group) LetS[k]be a subset of size |S|=t. Letc,d[n]tbe a pair of index vectors with Ham(c,d) =t(i.e., all coordinates of canddare distinct.). The pair group sS(c,d)is the set of pairs that (i) on coordinate S,PhS(p) =cand PhS(q) =d,and (ii) on coordinate -S,pandqare the same, i.e., Ph-S(p) = Ph-S(q). Namely, sS(c,d) = give some intuition for the above definitions, we note that for every a[n]|-S|, there is a unique pair Ph-S(p) = Ph-S(q), and On the other hand, for every pair there is a unique non-emtpy distinct on exactly coordinates in S. Therefore, (p,q)belongs to exactly one Itfollowsthat wecanpartition thesummationin Erraccording vp/vector vq. (4.3) We next observe that for any pair (p,q)sS(c,d), sincepandqagree on coordinates in -S, the value of theproduct H(p)H(q)depends only on S,candd. More depends only on =candPhS(q) =d. This motivates the hashing . Definition 4.6. (Projected hashing) a subset of [k], wheres1< s2<
***< sj. Letc[n]t. Wedefine the projected hashing HS(c) now translate the random variable vp/vector vq . vp/vector vq. Recallthat there is a unique pair Ph-S(p) = Ph -S(q). The sum can be128 V. BRAVERMAN,K. R.OS TROVSKY viewed astheinner product of twovectors of dimension n|-S|withentries indexed by a[n]|-S|. To formalize this observation, weintroduce the definition of hyper-projection 4.7. Let/vector vRnk,S[k], andc[n]|S|. v)of/vector v(withrespectto Sandc)isavector /vector w= US,c(/vector /vector wd=/vector vPh-1 S(c,d) for the above definition, wecontinue to rewrite the v),US,d(/vector (4.5) Finally, we consider the product HS(c)HS(d)again and introduce the following definition to further simplify the Err. Definition 4.8. (Similarity and dominance) Lettbeapositive of index vectors for all i[t], the equal. Wedenote this as two index vectors. We say cis dominated by difci< difor all i[t]. Wedenote this as cd. Note that cd=Ham(c,d) =t. Now, note that if (a,b)~(c,d), thenHS(a)HS(b) =HS(c)HS(d)since the value of on the values {ci,di}only as a set. It is also not hard to see that ~
isan equivalence relation, and for every equivalent class [(a,b)], there is aunique Therefore, wecanfurther rewritethe v),US,b(/vector are ready to bound the term E[Err2]by expanding the square of the sum according v),US,b(/vector of Furthermore, = that h1,...,h kare independent copies of 4-wise independent uniform random vari- ables over{-1,1}. Namely, for every i[k],hi(1),...,h i(n)are4-wise independent, and h1(*),...,h k(*)are mutually independent. Observe that for every i[k], there are at most 4 terms out of hi(1),...,h i(n)appearing in the product It follows that alldistinct termsappearing in uniformAMS WITHOUT 4-WISE INDEPENDENCE ON PRODUCT DOMAINS 129 random variable over {-1,1}. Therefore, the expectation is either 0, if there is some an odd number of times, or 1, if all hi(j)appear an even number of times. By inspection, the latter case happens if and only if above lemma, Equation (4.1) issimplified to Var[Y] v),US,b(/vector (4.8) We next apply the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality three times to bound the above formula. Con- sider asubset S[k]and apair cd[n]|S|. Notethat there are precisely Thus, by the Cauchy-Schwartz v),US,b(/vector v),US,a(/vector Notice that in the second inequality, we applied Cauchy-Sch wartz in a component-wise manner. Next, for a subset S[k], we can apply the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality a third time (f rom the third line tothe fourth line) as v),US,b(/vector v),US,a(/vector v),US,b(/vector v),US,c(/vector v),US,d(/vector v),US,c(/vector v),US,d(/vector v),US,c(/vector Finally,wenotethatbydefinition,wehave/summationtext c[n]|S|/a}bracketle{tUS,c(/vector v),US,c(/vector It follows that the variance in Equation (4.8) can bebounde d (3k-1)E[Y]2,130 V. BRAVERMAN,K. R.OS TROVSKY which finishes the proof of Lemma4.1. 5. Conclusion There remain several open questions left in this space. Lowe r bounds, particularly bounds that depend non-trivially on the dimension k, would be useful. There may still be room for better algo- rithms for testing k-wise independence in this manner using the l2norm. A natural be to find a particularly efficient algorithm for testin gk-out-of-s-wise independence Moregenerally, variables whose correlation exceeds some threshold according to some measure, remains widely Noga Alon, Alexandr Andoni, Tali Kaufman, Kevin Matulef , Ronitt Rubinfeld, and Ning Xie. Testing k-wise and almost k-wise independence. In STOC '07: Proceedings of the Thirty-ninth Annual ACM Sympos ium on Theory of Computing , pages 496-505, New York, NY,USA,2007. ACM. [2] NogaAlon,L' aszl' erandomized indepen- dent set problem. J. Algorithms ,7(4):567-583, 1986. [3] Noga Alon, Oded Goldreich, and Yishay Mansour. Almost k- wise independence versus k-wise independence. ,88(3):107-110, 2003. [4] Noga Alon, Yossi Matias, and Mario Szegedy. The space com plexity of approximating the frequency moments. J. Comput. Syst. Sci. ,58(1):137-147, 1999. [5] T. Batu, L. Fortnow, E. Fischer, R. Kumar, R. Rubinfeld, a nd P. White. Testing random variables for independence and identity. In FOCS '01: Proceedings of the 42nd IEEE symposium on Foundati ons of Computer Science , page 442, Washington, DC,USA,2001. IEEEComputer Society. [6] Tugkan Batu, Ravi Kumar, and Ronitt Rubinfeld. Sublinea r algorithms for testing monotone and unimodal distri- butions. In STOC '04: Proceedings of the Thirty-sixth Annual ACM Sympos ium on Theory of Computing , pages 381-390, New York,NY, USA,2004. ACM. [7] Vladimir Braverman and Rafail Ostrovsky. Measuring $k$ -wise independence of streaming data. 2008. [8] RafailOstrovsky. Measuring ind ependence of datasets. 2009. [9] Vladimir Braverman and Rafail Ostrovsky. AMS without 4-wise independence on product domains. 2009. [10] Kai-Min Chung, Zhenming Liu, and Michael Mitzenmacher . Testing k- wise independence over streaming data. Unpublished manusc ript, available ,2009. [11] Oded Goldreich and Dana Ron. On testing expansion in bou nded-degree graphs. Technical report, Electronic Col- loquium onComputational Complexity, 2000. [12] PiotrIndyk and Andrew McGregor. Declaring independen ce via the sketching of sketches. In SODA '08: Proceed- ings of the nineteenth annual ACM-SIAM symposium on Discret e algorithms , pages 737-745, Philadelphia, PA, USA,2008. Societyfor Industrial and E.L.Lehmann andSpringer. (Springer TextsinStatist ics).Springer, January 1997. [14] andEliUpfal. York, ne high-dimensional distributions.In STOC'05: Proceed- ings of the thirty-seventh annual ACM symposium on Theory of computing , pages 147-156, New York, NY, USA, 2005. ACM. [16] Mikkel Thorup and Yin Zhang. Tabulation based 4-univer sal hashing with applications to second moment estima- tion. InSODA '04: Proceedings of the Fifteenth Annual ACM-SIAM Symp osium on Discrete Algorithms , pages 615-624, Philadelphia, PA,USA,2004. Societyfor Industri al and work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attributio To view .
|
0806.4790
|
Vladimir Braverman
|
Vladimir Braverman, Kai-Min Chung, Zhenming Liu, Michael Mitzenmacher,
Rafail Ostrovsky
|
AMS Without 4-Wise Independence on Product Domains
| null | null | null | null |
cs.DS
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In their seminal work, Alon, Matias, and Szegedy introduced several sketching
techniques, including showing that 4-wise independence is sufficient to obtain
good approximations of the second frequency moment. In this work, we show that
their sketching technique can be extended to product domains $[n]^k$ by using
the product of 4-wise independent functions on $[n]$. Our work extends that of
Indyk and McGregor, who showed the result for $k = 2$. Their primary motivation
was the problem of identifying correlations in data streams. In their model, a
stream of pairs $(i,j) \in [n]^2$ arrive, giving a joint distribution $(X,Y)$,
and they find approximation algorithms for how close the joint distribution is
to the product of the marginal distributions under various metrics, which
naturally corresponds to how close $X$ and $Y$ are to being independent. By
using our technique, we obtain a new result for the problem of approximating
the $\ell_2$ distance between the joint distribution and the product of the
marginal distributions for $k$-ary vectors, instead of just pairs, in a single
pass. Our analysis gives a randomized algorithm that is a $(1 \pm \epsilon)$
approximation (with probability $1-\delta$) that requires space logarithmic in
$n$ and $m$ and proportional to $3^k$.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 29 Jun 2008 21:34:28 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Fri, 15 May 2009 19:16:27 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Thu, 17 Sep 2009 16:21:56 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Tue, 5 Jan 2010 22:23:35 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v5",
"created": "Wed, 3 Feb 2010 14:19:09 GMT"
}
] | 2010-02-03T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Braverman",
"Vladimir",
""
],
[
"Chung",
"Kai-Min",
""
],
[
"Liu",
"Zhenming",
""
],
[
"Mitzenmacher",
"Michael",
""
],
[
"Ostrovsky",
"Rafail",
""
]
] |
J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. cuprates,5,6from which possibility of the common mechanism of is argued between oxypnictides and in terms of the doping phase diagram, there are cert ain differences between these two systems, e.g., (i) Tc(>0 for 0.4< x <0.12) does not vary much with x1as in cuprates known as bell-shaped and (ii) the magnetic (sp in density wave, SDW) phase shares a boundary with the superconducting phase near x0.04.1,7The insensitivity of Tc toxis reasonably understood from the conventional BCS theory w here condensation energy is predicted to be independent of carrier concentration. Th e close relationship of magnetism and suggests that a detailed investigat ion of how these two phases coexist (and compete) near the phase boundarywill provide importan t clues to elucidating the Among various techniques, uSR has a great advantage in that it can be applied in systems consisting of spatially inhomogeneous multiple phases, providing information on respective phases according to their fractional yield. Our uSR measurement in the LFAO-F sample with x= 0.06 (Tc18 K) reveals that these two phases indeed coexist in the form of macroscopic phase separation, and more interestingly, tha t a spin glass-like magnetic phase develops in conjunction with in the para magnetic phase. This suggests a common origin of the electronic correla tion leading to these two the oxypnictide with rare-earth ( R) substitution RFeAsO 1-xFxexhibits higher Tcthan that of LFAO-F, strong random fields from rare-earth ion s preclude a detailed study of the ground state using sensitive magnetic probes like uSR. Therefore, we chose the original LFAO-F system for our uSR study. The target concentration of LaFeAsO 1-xFxis set near the phase boundary, x= 0.06, for which a polycrystalline sample was synthesized by so lid state reaction. The detailed procedure for sample preparation is described in an earlier report.1 The sample was confirmed to be mostly of single phase using X-r ay diffraction analysis. Of two possible impurity phases, namely, LaOF and FeAs, only th e latter exhibits a order with TN77 K.8As shown in Fig. 1, magnetic susceptibility exhibits no trac e of FeAs phase or local magnetic impurities except below ~50 K where a small upturn is observed. The susceptibility at a lower field [shown in Fig. 3 (a)] provides evidence of bulk with Tc~18 K from the onset of diamagnetism. Conventional uSR mea- surement was performed using the LAMPF spectrometer instal led on the M15 beamline of TRIUMF, Canada. During the measurement under a zero field (ZF ), residual magnetic field at the sample position was reduced below 10-6T with the initial muon spin direction parallel to the muon beam direction [ For longitudinal field (LF) measurement, a magnetic field was applied parallel to /vectorPu(0). Time-dependent muon polarization [ Gz(t) = ^z*/vectorPu(t)] was monitored by measuring decay-positron asymmetry along the ^z-axis. Transverse field (TF) condition was realized by rotating the initial muon polariz ation so that where the 2/9J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. /s50/s53/s48 /s50/s48/s48 /s49/s53/s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s53/s48 /s50/s48 /s49/s48 1. (Color online) Magnetic susceptibility of LaFeAsO 1-xFxwithx= 0.06 for the sample used foruSR measurement. Inset shows a reduced view of the region below 35 K. asymmetry was monitored along the ^ x-axis to obtain Gx(t) = ^x*/vectorPu(t). All the a magnetic field were made by cooling the sample to the ta rget temperature after the field is the most sensitive technique for examining magnetism i n any form, where the development of local magnetic moments leads to either the sp ontaneous oscillation (for long- range order) or exponential damping (inhomogeneous local m agnetism) of Gz(t). Figure 2 shows examples of ZF- uSR time spectra collected at 2 and 30 K. The spectrum at 30 K (> Tc) exhibits a Gaussian-like relaxation due to weak random loc al fields from nuclear magnetic moments, indicating that the entire sample is in th e paramagnetic state. Meanwhile, the spectrum at 2 K is split into two components, one that exhi bits a steep relaxation and the other that remains to show Gaussian-like relaxation. Th is indicates that there is a finite fraction of implanted muons that sense hyperfine fields from l ocal electronic moments. The absence of oscillatory signal implies that the hyperfine fiel d is highly inhomogeneous, so that the local magnetism is characterized by strong randomness o r spin fluctuation. The fractional yield of the component showing steep relaxation is as large a s 25% (see below), which is hardly attributed to impurity and therefore implies that th e sample exhibits a separation into two phases. The magnitude of the hyperfine field and that of spin fluctuatio n are evaluated by observ- ing the response of the uSR spectrum to a longitudinal field (LF). It is shown in Fig. 2 t hat the relaxation in the paramagnetic component is quenched by applying a weak magnetic field (LF=5 mT), which is perfectly explained by the suppression o f static nuclear dipolar fields (<100mT). Meanwhile, the faster relaxation (seen for 0 < t <1us) due to the magnetic 3/9J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Gx(t) 1086420 t / = 0.06ZF 30K ZF 2KTF 2KLF 5mT, 2K Fig. 2. (Color online) uSR time spectra observed in LaFeAs(O 1-xFx) withx= 0.06 at 2 K under a longitudinal field (LF), a zero field (ZF), and a transverse field (TF ), and that under ZF at 30 K. The spectrum under TF is plotted on a rotating reference frame of 6.78 MHz to extract the envelop function. phase is recovered only gradually over a field range of 101~2mT, and there still remains a slow relaxation even at the highest field of 60 mT. This residu al depolarization under LF is a clear sign that local spins are slowly fluctuating, leading to the spin-lattice relaxation of
/vectorPu(t). Such quasi-two-step relaxation is also observed in dilut e spin-glass systems,9which is understood as a distribution of spin correlation time. A det ailed analysis is made considering that these two components coming from the magnetic phase (se e below). Undera transversefield, implanted muonsexperience an inho mogeneity of thefield [ Bz(r)] due to flux line lattice formation below Tcthat leads to relaxation, in addition to those ob- served undera zero field. TheTF- uSR time spectrumin Fig. 2 (envelop part of the under a field of 50 mT exhibits complete depolarizat ion at 2 K, indicating that the entire volume of the paramagnetic phase falls into the super conducting state. The rapidly re- laxing component observed underZF is also visible (althoug h thecoarse binningof the spectra for extracting the envelop part makes it slightly obscure), indicating that the of the sample remains the presence of the magnetic phase besides the p aramagnetic below Tc) phase, we take special precaution to analyze both TF and ZF/ LFuSR spectra in a consistent manner. For the determination of phy sical parameters describing the behavior of signals from the magnetic phase, we first analyze ZF/LF spectra at 2 K using the kh-square minimization fit with the relaxation function Gz(t) = (1) 4/9J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. is the Kubo-Toyabe relaxation function for describing the Gaussian damp- ing due to random local fields from nuclear moments (with dNbeing the fractional yield for the paramagnetic phase, w2andw3are those for the magnetic 1) with L 2and L3being the corresponding relaxation rate described by the Re 2,3), the muon gyromagnetic ratio (= 2 px135.53 MHz/T), HLFis the longitudinal field, d2andd3are the means of the hyperfine fields exerting on muons from local electronic moments, and n2andn3are the fluctuation rates of the hyperfine field. The solid curves in Fig. 2 show the result of analysis where all th e spectra at different fields (only ZF and LF=5mT are shown here) are fitted simultaneously using eqs. (1) and (2) with common parameter values (except outhat is fixed to the respective value for each spectrum), which show excellent agreement with all the spectra. The ded uced parameters are as follows: w1= 0.754(9),w2= 0.165(9),w3= 0.081(4),d2= 0.71(5)us-1,d3= 3.9(3)us-1,n2= 1.7(2) us-1, andn3= 4(1)us-1. Although in themagnetic phaseis appro by two components with different hyperfine coupli ngs (di), the fluctuation rates (ni) are close to each other (107s-1at 2 K), suggesting that the randomness is primarily due to the distribution in the size of local moments (or in their d istances to muons). Since no impurity phase with a fraction as large as 25% is detected by X -ray diffraction analysis, it is concluded that this magnetic phase is intrinsic. In the analysis of TF spectra, we use d the relaxation function Gx(t) = exp( fixed to the values obtained by analyzing ZF/LF- uSR spectra. The first component in the above equation represents the contributio n of flux line lattice formation in the superconducting phase, where dscorresponds to the linewidth the mean B(r)], while the second term represents the relaxation in the magnetic phase. Here, the relaxation rate for the latter is represented by a single value Lm(instead of L 2,3), as it turns out that the two components observed under LF ar e in TF- uSR spectra. [This does not affect the result of the analysis, be cause the amplitude is fixed to w2+w3so that L mmay represent a mean fit analysis using the above form indicates that all the sp ectra are perfectly reproduced while the partial asymmetry is fixed to the value determined f rom ZF- uSR spectra. This strengthens the presumption that the paramagnetic phase be comes superconducting below Tc. The result of analysis is summarized in Fig. 3, together wit h the result of dc in the sample from the same batch as that used for uSR. 5/9J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Letter It is interesting to note in Fig. 3(b) that, although the cent ral frequency in the phase ( fs) does not show much change below Tc18 K probably owing to a large magnetic penetration depth (it is indeed large, see below), that in the magnetic phase ( fm) exhibits a clear shift in the negative direction below TmTc. The magnitude of the shift is as large as ~1% and thus is readily identified despite a relatively low ext ernal field of 50 mT. As shown in Fig. 3(c), the relaxation rate in the magnetic pha se (Lm) also develops below Tcin accordance with the frequency shift, demonstrating that a spin-glass-like magnetism sets in below Tc. Here, we note that the development of magnetic phase is alre ady evident in the ZF/LF- uSR spectra, and results are fully consistent with each other . The onset of below Tcis also confirmed by an increase in ds, as observed in Fig. 3(c). This remarkable accordance of onset temperature between ma gnetism and strongly suggests that there is an intrinsic relationsh ip between the superconducting and magnetic phases that leads to a common characteristic tempe rature. The temperature dependence of ssin Fig. 3(d) is compared with theoretical predictions for a variety of models with different order parameters. The we ak-coupling BCS model ( s- wave, single gap) apparently fails to reproduce the present data, as they exhibit a tendency to vary with temperature over the region T/Tc<0.4. Although a fit using a two-gap model11 shown by a dotted line seems to exhibit reasonable agreement with data, the deduced gap parameters (2 i/kBTc) are largely inconsistent with the prediction of the weak-c oupling BCS model (see Table I). These observations suggest that the sup erconducting order parameter used in fitting the data, we obtain a curve shown by the broke n line in Fig. 3(d) with an exponent b2. This is in good agreement with the case of d-wave symmetry at the dirty limit. In the limit of extreme type II superconductors [i.e., l/x1, where lis the effective London penetration depth and is the Ginzburg-Landau coherence length, Ph0is the flux quantum, and Hc2is the upper critical field], ssis determined by lusing the relation12ss/gu= I. Parameters for defining the lines in Fig. 3(d). Two-gap Power law Tc(K) 18.0(5) Tc(K) 18.9(4) s(0) (us-1) 0.291(5) s(0) (us-1) 0.291(4) w 0.73(6) b Phys. Soc. Jpn. / H-1 / emu / L / / exp. s-BCS double dS Lm fS fm 1 3. (Color online) Temperature dependence of dc magnetic susc eptibility measured at 1mT (a), and that of physical parameters deduced by analyzing TF- uSR spectra in superconducting ( fs, ds) and magnetic ( fm, Lm) phases (b-c), and of ss(=
2ds) proportional to superfluid density (d). Curves in (d) are fits by models described in the text. andHTFis the magnitude of external field. From ssextrapolated to T= 0 and l=595(3) e layered structure of this compound, lin the polycrystalline sample would be by in-plane penetration depth ( lab). Using the formula l= 1.31labfor such a situation,14we obtain lab=454(2) nm. This value coincides with that expected from empirical relation between this may not be uniquely attributed to the superfluid density because ldepends not only nsbut also on the effective mass, Phys. Soc. Jpn. Letter Finally, we discuss the feature of the spin glass-like phase . Assuming that the local mo- ments are those of iron atoms with a moment size close to that in the SDW phase (~0.36uB4), the mean distance between muon and iron moments in the rele vant phase is estimated to be ~0.5 nm from an average of di. Given the unit cell size ( a= 0.403 nm, c= 0.874 nm1), this would mean that more than a quarter of iron atoms in the magnetic phase (i.e., 7% of the entire sample) should serve as a source of local mome nts. It is unlikely that such a significant fraction of iron atoms remains as impu rities in the present sample. It might also benoteworthy that there is an anomaly near Tm212 K in onset of ZFC/FC hysteresis in Fig. 1 and a steplike kink i n Fig. 3(a)]. This seems to be in accordance with the onset of a steeper increase in L mbelowTm2, suggesting a change in magnetic correlation. uSR studies of LFAO-F have been made by a number of groups. Acco rding to studies, no clear sign of magnetism is observed in the sample over relevant except for a weak relaxation observed far b elowTcforx= 0.05 and 0.075 in ZF-uSR spectra and an unidentified additional relaxation observ ed in TF- uSR spectra for x= 0.075.5-7This led us to recall the sensitivity to chemical stoichiome try in the emergence of the spin glass-like A-phase observed near the boundary between the antiferromag netic and superconducting phases in CeCu 2Si2.16In addition to the A-phase, the present LFAO-F system exhibits a closer similarity to this classical heavy -fermion superconductor such as the phase diagram against study of the dependence of fractional yield for the magnetic phase with varying x(in small steps near the phase boundary) would provide further insight into the true nature of these phases and the m echanism of itself that is working behind the . In summary, it has been revealed by our uSR experiment that superconducting and mag- netic phases coexist in LaFeAs(O 0.94F0.06) withx= 0.06. These two phases just below Tc, strongly suggesting an intimate and intrinsic relationsh ip between these two phases. The result of TF- uSR measurement suggests that the of LaFeAs(O 0.94F0.06) cannot be explained by the conventional weak-BCS model (si ngle gap, s-wave). We would like to thank the TRIUMF staff for their technical sup port during the uSR experiment. This work was partially supported by the KEK-MS L Inter-University Program for Oversea Muon Facilities and by a Grant-in-Aid for Creati ve Scientific Research on Priority Areas from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Scie nce and Technology, Japan. 8/9J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Y. Kamihara, T. Watanabe, M. Hirano, and H. Hosono: J. Am. Che m. Soc.130(2008) 3296. 2) X. H. Chen, T. Wu, R. H. Liu, H. Chen, and D. F. Fang : Nature 453(2008) 761. 3) H. Takahashi, K. Igawa, K. Arii, Y. Kamihara, M. Hirano, and H. Ho sono: Nature C.de la Cruz, Q.Huang, J.W.Lynn, J.Li, W.Ratcliff II, J.L.Zare stky, H. A.Mook, G.F. Chen, J. L. Luo, N. L. Wang and P. Dai: Nature 453(2008) 899. 5) H.Luetkens, R.Klingeler, I.Hellmann, N.Leps, A.Kondrat, C. Hess, A. K ohler, G. Behr, J. Werner, and B. B uchner: arXiv:0 804.3115. 6) J. P. Carlo, Y. J. Uemura, T. Goko, G. J. MacDougall, J. A. Rodrig uez, W. Yu, G. M. Luke, P. Dai, N. Shannon, S. Miyasaka, S. Suzuki, S. Tajima, G. F. Chen, W. Z . Hu, J. L. Luo, and N. L. Wang: H. Luetkens, H. H. Klauss, M. Kraken, F. J. Litterst, T. Dellman n, R. Klingeler, C. Hess, R. Khasanov, A. Amato, C. Baines, J. Hamann-Borrero, N. Leps, A. Kondrat, G. Behr, J. Werner and B. B uchner: K. Selte, A. Kjekshus and A. Andresen: Acta Chemica Scandinav ica26(1972) 3101. 9) Y. J. Uemura, K. Nishiyama, T. Yamazaki and R. Nakai: Solid State Comm.39(1981) 461. 10) R. S. Hayano, Y. J. Uemura, J. Imazato, N. Nishida, T. Yamaza ki, and R. Kubo: Phys. Rev. B 20(1979) 850. 11) F. Bouquet, Y. Wang, R. A. Fisher, D. G. Hinks, J. D. Jorgense n, A. Junod, and N. E. Lett. 56(2001)856. 12) E. H. Brandt: Phys. Rev. B 37(1988) 2349. 13) F. Hunte, J. Jaroszynski, A. Gurevich, D. C. Larbalestier, R. Jin, A. S. Sefat, M. A. McGuire, B. C. Sales, D. K. Christen, and D. Mandrus: Nature 453(2008) 903. 14) V. I. Fesenko, V. N. Gorbunov, and V. P. Smilga: Physica C 176(1991) 551. 15) Y. J. Uemura, V. J. Emery, A. R. Moodenbaugh, M. Suenaga, D . C. Johnston, A. J. Jacob- son, J. T. Lewandowski, J. H. Brewer, R. F. Kiefl, S. R. Kreitzman, G. M. Luke, T. Riseman, C. E. Stronach, W. J. Kossler, J. R. Kempton, X. H. Yu, D. Opie, an d H. E. Schone: Phys. Rev. B38(1988) 909. 16) R. Feyerherm, A. Amato, C. Geibel, F. N.Gygax, P.Hellmann, R. H.Heffner, D. M uller-Reisener, G. J. Nieuwenhuys, A. Schenck, F. Steglich: P hys. Rev. B 56(1997) 699. 17) P. Monthoux, D. Pines, and G. G. Lonzarich: Nature 450(2007) 1177. 9/9
|
0806.4798
|
Soshi Takeshita
|
S. Takeshita, R. Kadono, M. Hiraishi, M. Miyazaki, A. Koda, Y.
Kamihara, H. Hosono
|
Coexistence of Supercondcutivity and Magnetism in LaFeAs(O0.94F0.06)
Probed by Muon Spin Relaxation
|
11 pages, 2 figures, 2 tables
|
J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 77 (2008) 103703
|
10.1143/JPSJ.77.103703
| null |
cond-mat.mtrl-sci cond-mat.supr-con
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Recent discovery of oxypnictide superconductor LaFeAs(O,F) (LFAO-F) with the
critical temperature (Tc) of 26 K and succeeding revelation of much increased
Tc upon substitution of La for other rare earth elements (such as Sm, leading
to ~43 K) and application of pressure for LFAO-F (~ 43 K) has triggered broad
interest in the mechanism yielding relatively high Tc in this new class of
compounds. While they share a feature with high-Tc cuprates that
superconductivity occurs upon carrier doping to pristine compound which
exhibits magnetism, they also resemble the heavy-fermion compounds in the sense
that superconductivity appears in the vicinity of magnetic phase. Investigation
of electronic states near the boundary between these two phases might provide
some useful information on the mechanism of superconductivity, as it has been
proved to be the case in many exotic superconductors. Here we show by muon
experiment in the LFAO-F compound that a macroscopic phase separation into
superconducting and spin glass-like magnetic phases occurs at x=0.06 that is
near the phase boundary, where both the magnetism and superconductivity develop
simultaneously below a common Tc ~ 18 K. This accordance strongly suggests
intimate relationship between magnetism and superconductivity typically found
in heavy-fermion systems near the quantum critical point.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 30 Jun 2008 03:14:09 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Tue, 19 Aug 2008 09:57:11 GMT"
}
] | 2008-10-02T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Takeshita",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Kadono",
"R.",
""
],
[
"Hiraishi",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Miyazaki",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Koda",
"A.",
""
],
[
"Kamihara",
"Y.",
""
],
[
"Hosono",
"H.",
""
]
] |
2Unda-Sanzana et al. density (36 .5gcm-3), which, if it is a main-sequence star, also fixes its mass, which turns out to be M2~0.13M. This would cause a much larger K1than observed, unless the inclination is low. More recent theoretical work has revised HH1990's esti- mate a little to M2~0.15Mfrom GD 552's orbital period (Kolb & Baraffe 1999), but the problem is qualitatively un- changed. However, this work also suggests a very Cataclysmic variables at long orbital periods ar e thought to evolve towards shorter periods until the com- panion becomes degenerate at a period near 70 minutes. After this time, the mass donor increases in size as it loses mass and the orbital period lengthens (e.g. Howell, Nelson
& Rappaport, 2001; Kolb 1993). Thus although if GD 552 is approaching the period minimum its donor mass must be M2~0.15M, if it has already passed the minimum and is now evolving to longer periods, it would be about a fac- tor of four times less massive, and there would be no need for HH1990's massive white dwarf, face-on model. Moreover, such a system would have an extremely low mass transfer rate, consistent with GD 552's lack of outbursts and prob- ably low intrinsic luminosity. The evolution just describe d is the standard explanation for the observed minimum or- bital periods of CVs, which however fails on two counts. First, the observed minimum around 80 min is than the theoretical value of 70 min (Kolb & Baraffe 1999; although Willems et al. (2005) propose that the period minimum might be longer than expected because of extra angular momentum loss from circumbinary disks), and, sec- ond, while we expectmost systems tohavepassed there is just one single well-established example o f such a system known (SDSS Littlefair et al. 2006) although there are a few other good et al. 2001; Littlefair, Dhillon & Martin 2003; Patterson, Thorstensen & Kemp 2005; Araujo-Betancor et al. 2005; Southworth et al. 2006). Therefore it is of con- siderable interest to establish whether GD 552 is a pre- system. In this article we carry out a test to distinguish between the two models of GD 552. If the model is correct, then, as we show in this paper, we should be able to detect features from the M star in a low system such as GD 552. If, conversely, the model is correct, the donor will be extremely faint and it should not be detectable. In summary, our task is to set the strongest possible limit upon the presence of a hypothetical M dwarf such that we can say that we would have seen it had GD 552 been a pre-bounce system. 2 OBSERVATIONS AND DATA REDUCTION We carried out observations of GD 552 in January and Au- gust 2001 on the island of La Palma in the Canary Islands (see Table 1 for details). In January 2001, the 2.5-m Isaac Newton Telescope (INT) was used in conjunction with the Intermediate Dispersion Spectrograph (IDS) to acquire one dataset. Another dataset obtained in January 2001 used the 4.2-m William Herschel Telescope (WHT) in conjunction with the double-beamed high-resolution ISIS spectrograph . In August 2001 only WHT/ISIS was used. The weather wasFigure 2. Low resolution spectra acquired in January 2005. The upper panel is a vertical enlargement of the lower one. Note t he broad absorption wings around the emission lines. good during both runs, with no clouds and a typical seeing of 1 arcsecond. An additional low-resolution spectrum was acquired on January 4, 2005, again with WHT/ISIS (see Table 1 for details). This spectrum was acquired with a vertical slit in order to obtain approximately correct relative fluxes. It wa s calibrated using observations of Feige 34 (Oke 1990). The seeing on this night was around 2 .5 and variable and so the flux calibration is only approximate. See Table 1 for details . We fluxcalibrated the earlier the standard HD19445 which we also used to remove the effect of telluric lines on the red data (Bessell 1999). Flat-fields and comparison arc spectra were taken at regular intervals (every ~60min). The spectra were optimally extracted (Marsh from themanyones takenduring the night. The wavelength scales for each science spectrum were obtained by interpolating the solutions of the nearest twoarc spectra. For theJanuary 2001 datasets a comparison star was included in the slit. In this case slit losses were co r- rected using the ratio of the spectra of the comparison star to a spectrum taken with a wide slit close to the zenith. For the August 2001 datasets no comparison star was observed, so we simply normalised the continua of these spectra. Six images were acquired with the WHT on 25 RAS, MNRAS 000, 1-10GD 552: a cataclysmic variable with a brown dwarf companion? 3 Figure 1. Average spectra for the high-resolution datasets. A correc tion for telluric absorption has been made to the I-band spec tra, although the very heavy absorption at 7600 @A could not be successfully removed. ber 2006 using a Harris I-band filter. One Landolt standard (Mark A1) with very similar airmass was observed to flux calibrate the images. Observations from the nearby Carls- berg Automatic Meridian Circle1on the same night show that the night was mostly photometric with normal 5.4h of filterless CCD photometry of GD552 was obtained on 29 July 2005 using a SI-502 516 x516 pixel camera on the 1.2m telescope at Kryoneri Observatory. The data were reduced using the pipeline described in G ansicke et al. (2004), where we used USNO-A2.0 1500-09346766 of GD552, B= 16.8,R= 15.6) as comparison STIS spectroscopy of GD552 was retrieved from the HST archive. The system was observed with (FUV)G140L on 24 October 2002 for a total of ~4h. The obser- vation was split into 15 individual exposures of 970s each. An additional three 1410s near-ultraviolet spectra using t he G230LB grating were obtained on 31 August 2002, again us- ing the ~dwe/SRF/camc extinction.html3 ANALYSIS 3.1 Average profiles and trailed spectra Figure 1 shows average spectra for our data. Figure 2 shows the available low resolution spectra. We observe double peaked profiles in all the detected lines: He i4471.68 @A (hereafter He i 4471), Heii4685.750 @A (hereafter He ii), Hei 4921.93 @A (hereafter He i 4921), Hei6678.15 @A (hereafter Hei 6678), Oi 7773, Oi 8446and the Paschen and Balmer series. In the general theory of CVs, the double peaked pro- files are consistent with disc emission. A second order polynomial was fitted to the continuum of each dataset and then the data were divided by these fits. The normalised continua were subtracted, and the datasets were binned in 20 (Jan) or 30 (Aug) orbital phase bins be- fore plotting Figure 3. These trailed spectra display doubl e peaked emission following a sinusoidal motion with orbital phase. We interpret this as the rotating accretion disk, ap- proximately tracking the emission of the white dwarf it sur- rounds. The other remarkable feature in these spectra is sinusoid also varying with orbital phase , but shifted with respect to the assumed zero phase. It can be seen very clearly, for instance, in O i 7773(Figure 3). This emission is produced in the stream/disc impact RAS, MNRAS 000, et al. Table 1. Summary of the WHT and INT spectroscopic data used in the anal ysis. In this table MD stands for 'mean dispersion'. FWHM is the full width at half maximum of the unblended arc lines. T is the mean exposure time per frame and DT is the average dead t ime between exposures. N is the number of spectra collected per n ight per arm. Telescope/ CCD/Grating Date Start - End Orbits lrange MD FWHM T/DT N Instrument (UT) covered ( @A) ( @Apixel-1) (@A) (s) INT/IDS EEV10/R1200B 12/13 Jan 2001 19:48-22:06 1.343 6318 -6719 0.39 0.78 300/30 26 WHT/ISIS EEV12/H2400B 12/13 Jan 2001 19:52-21:13 0.788 461 8-4985 0.21 0.42 300/12 32 WHT/ISIS EEV12/R1200B 13/14 Aug 2001 23:28-05:34 2.979 430 1-4962 0.22 0.69 290/16 61 WHT/ISIS TEK4/R316R 13/14 Aug 2001 23:35-05:34 2.911 7306- 8814 1.48 3.43 300/5 63 WHT/ISIS EEV12/R1200B 04/05 Jan 2005 19:50-19:58 0.081 390 0-5390 0.88 1.8 500/0 1 WHT/ISIS TEK4/R316R 04/05 Jan 2005 19:50-19:58 0.081 6110- 8930 1.65 3.2 500/0 1 which is usually termed the bright spot. Note that the phas- ing of this sinusoidal is different for the January and August datasets. This is due to the uncertainty in the zero phase of the ephemeris used to fold the data the average of the WHT spectra acquired in Jan- uary2005, of line fluxes H a: Hb: Hg. We did this flux from each profile after subtracting a low order fit to the continua. We computed H a: Hb: Hg= 2.0 : 1.0 : 0.56. Our values for the Balmer decrement differ noticeably from HH1990's (H a: Hb: Hg= 6.2 : 1.0 : 0.26), being rather closer to Greenstein & Giclas (1978) (H a: Hb: Hg= 2.2 : 1.0 : 0.5). Qualitatively, though, our conclusion is the same: the Balmer decrements suggest that the accretion disk is op- tically thin and cool (see, for example, Williams & Shipman, 1988). This conclusion is strengthened by the detection of Oi 7773which, according to Friend et al. (1988) is a good indicator of the state of the disc, its emission indicating a n optically thin accretion disc. 3.2 The primary star HH1990 measured a value of 17 +-4kms-1forK1. We tried to check and refine this value by using Schneider & Young (1980)'s method. We convolved our data with a difference of Gaussians equidistant from a candidate line centre, and define the velocity as the displacement of the double Gaus- sians such that the convolution equals zero. By increasing the separation of the Gaussians we gather information from the wings of the profile, which is produced in regions of the disc closer to its centre (Horne & Marsh 1986). We assume that the motion of these regions tracks the motion of the accreting object, so the further into the wings the measure- ment is made, the better the estimate of the motion of the white dwarf. The process does not continue indefinitely be- cause there is a maximum velocity in the line wings, to the Keplerian motion of the innermost ring of gas just before settling onto the white dwarf. However, in practice, before reaching this limit the reliability of t he calculation is constrained by the noise present at the con- tinuum level. The motion of each disc region is calculated by fitting the orbital the measurements. gis the systemic velocity, Kis thevelocity of the source of the emission, t0is the time of su- perior conjunction of the emission-line source, and P is the orbital period of the system. Further, we avail ourselves of a diagnostic diagram (Shafter, 1986) to decide when the calculation is becoming dominated by noise as the separation of Gaussians ( a) increases. This should re- veal itself as a sharp rising of the statistics sK/K. At the same time, we also expect to see convergence of the calcu- lated parameters ( K,g) and a phasing appropriate to the white dwarf. In our diagrams (Fig. 4) we do not put a strong con- straint on the value of convergence for the phasing (bottom panels) because the ephemeris of this system has a large un- certainty and thus its orientation is arbitrary for the date of our observation. For alarger than 2500kms-1the noise dominates both diagrams so this is the upper limit for the abscissa in our plots. The H bdiagram displays a of convergence when aapproaches 2000kms-1. On reaching that value the noise takes off. On the other hand, for large values of ain Hawe are picking data contaminated by the wings of He i 6678and thus we do not expect a in this diagram, although the noise seems to dominate once areaches 2200kms-1. Eventually, as it is not obvious which value to favour in H awe take as K1 the value of Kfora= 1900kms-1in Hb, right before the noise begins todominate. This is 14 HH1990. The uncertainties were estimated by means of the bootstrap method, repeating the calculation for 10000 bootstrap samples (Diaconis & Efron 1983). The high resolution B-band spectrum of Fig. 1 shows signs of broad absorption wings flanking the Balmer lines. These are often seen in low luminosity dwarf novae (e.g. Szkody et al. 2007) and originate in the photosphere of the white dwarf. Low resolution spectra taken in January 2005 and September 2006 confirm the presence of the white lines (Fig. 2). The white dwarf is also reveale d in HST/STIS ultraviolet spectra through the a very broad Lafeature extending to 1600A (Fig. 6). This feature, which results from L afrom neutral hydrogen plus at 1400 and 1600 @A fromH+
2andH2, is a hallmark of cool white dwarfs. For the purpose of the spectral analysis, we have com- puted a grid of white dwarf models covering effective tem- peratures in the range 8000K-15000K and surface grav- ities of log g= 7.5, 8.0, and 8.5 using the stellar atmo- sphere and spectral synthesis codes & Lanz 1995). Metal abundances were set to RAS, MNRAS 000, 1-10GD 552: a cataclysmic variable with a brown dwarf companion? 5 Figure 3. Phase binned data. The fluxes in this figure have been normalis ed by the maximum value the flux reaches for each wavelength. We set the colour scale to white for 0 flux and to black for 85% of this normalised flux, with the exception of line He i 4921for which black corresponds to 40% of the normalised flux. Figure 4. Diagnostic diagram forH a(left)and H b(right), using INT January 2001 and WHT August 2001 data their solar values, as suggested by the weakness of the Mgll2796,2803 resonance doublet. The assumed value for the metal abundance is within the typical range for CVs (Sion & Szkody 2005). A first exploratory fit revealed that none of the white dwarf model spectra could repro- duce the STIS data alone, as the flux of the model spec- tra rapidly drops to zero shortward of ~1300@A, in con- trast to the observed spectrum that has a substantial non- zero flux down to 1150 @A. Moreover, it turns out that the15 individual far-ultraviolet spectra show substantial flu x variability, supporting the presence of a second (variable ) component. The ultraviolet flux variability shows a clear dependence on wavelength, and we have fitted the con- tinuum slope of the spectrum with a linear slope, a slope is what could be expected from either an op- tically thin emission region (where absorption is dominate d by bound-free absorption) or an optically thick relatively cool quasi-blackbody component (where the far-ultraviole t emission is on the Wien part of the blackbody spectrum). We then explored two-component fits to the STIS data con- sisting of this linear slope plus a white dwarf model, with the contributions of the slope and the white dwarf being normalised to match the observed continuum below 1300 @A and in the range 1580-1620 @A, respectively. The best fit for logg= 7.5 is shown in Fig.5 (left panel). This simple model provides a surprisingly good match to the STIS spectrum over the entire ultraviolet range. However, an extrapolati on of this simple linear slope over a broader wavelength range, i.e. into the optical, is not warranted, as the exact nature o f this emission component is not known. The parameters determined from the fit are the white dwarf effective temperature Teff, and the flux scale factor between the synthetic and the observed spectrum. Assum- ing a white dwarf radius, the flux scaling factor can be used to calculate the distance to the system. As the white dwarf mass is unconstrained by this analysis, we ran the fit for logg= 7.5, 8.0, and 8.5, corresponding to white dwarf masses and radii of (0.33M , 1.15x109cm), (0.57M , 8.65x108cm), and (0.9M , 6.15x108cm), we have assumed a Hamada-Salpeter (1961) Carbon- Oxygen core mass-radius relation). The best fit parameters for logg= 7.5, 8.0, and 8.5 are (10500K, 125pc), (10900K, 105pc), and (11300K and 85pc), respectively. Because of the very strong temperature dependence of the 1600 @A H+
2 the STIS spectrum constrains the white dwarf a very narrow RAS, MNRAS 000, et al. Fig.5 (right panel) shows that the white dwarf model obtained from the fit to the STIS data extended into the ~50%. The presence of double-peaked Balmer emission lines clearl y reveals the presence of an accretion disc in the system that i intheoptical. Wemodel theaccretion di sc by an hydrogen slab, which has three free parameters: the disc temperature Td, the column den- sity S, and the flux scaling factor (see G ansicke et al. 1997, 1999 for details). A disc temperature of Td= 5800K and a column density of S = 2 .3x10-2gcm-2, scaled to the observed H aemission line flux provides an adequate model of the optical spectrum. The emission line flux ratios of the model are H a: Hb: Hg= 2.2 : 1.0 : 0.56, fairly close to the observed values (Sect.3.1). For a distance of ~100pc, the area of hydrogen slab implied by the flux scaling factor is consistent with the size of the Roche lobe of the white dwarf. The disc parameters found here are very similar to those found in a number of other studies of quiescent ac- cretion discs in CVs (e.g. Williams 1980, Marsh 1987, Lin et al. 1988, Rodriguez-Gil et al. 2005). We refrained from more detailed modelling of the optical data as the spec- trum was obtained under non-photometric conditions, is subject tosome e- less the temperature derived from the UV data is consistent with our detection of the white dwarf's photosphere in our optical spectra. The recent discovery of several non-radially pulsating white dwarfs in CVs (e.g. van Zyl et al. 2004, Warner
& Woudt 2004, Araujo-Betancor et al. 2005, Patterson et al. 2005, Warner & Woudt 2005 and G ansicke 2006) mo- tivated the short photometric time series observation of GD552 carried out at Kryoneri observatory. Visual inspec- tion of the light curve (Fig.6) reveals substantial variabi lity on time scales of tens of minutes, plus a modulation over
~4.5h. A Lomb-Scargle period analysis (Lomb 1976, Scar- gle 1982) shows no substantial power at periods shorter than
~15min, where non-radial pulsations would be expected to show up. The conclusions from this admittedly limited set of data is that the white dwarf in GD 552 is probably too cool to drive ZZ Ceti pulsations in its envelope and the varibilit y seen in the light curve is probably due to flickering in the accretion disc. 3.3 The secondary star The presence of a secondary star (assumed to be an M dwarf since we are testing for the presence of a star of mass 0.15M)is notobvious either in the average or in the main aim was to detect photospheric especially the NaI doublet near 8200 @A which is strong in late M dwarfs. To do so we compared our GD 552 spectra with a set of M dwarf template spectra kindly provided by Kelle Cruz (personal communication) following the classifi - cation by Kirkpatrick, Henry & McCarthy (1991). The stars used are listed in Table 2. The Na I doublet near 8200 @A and nearby molecular bands are the fingerprints of M dwarfs. As we were not able torecognise any such features in the GD 552 data, we looked for a constraint upon its presence given that its features ar e not detectable. First we normalised the spectra of GD 552Figure 6. Kryoneri CCD photometry of GD 552. Table 2. List of M star templates used for estimating of an M star to the GD 552 Type Star M0.5 Gl 720A M1 Gl 229 M1.5 Gl 205 M2.5 Gl 250B M3 Gl 752A M3.5 Gl 273 M4 Gl 213 M4.5 Gl 83.1 M5.5 Gl 65A M6 Gl 406 M6.5 G 51-15 M7 VB 8 M8 VB 10 M9 LHS 2065 and of each template in Table 2. We did this by dividing by a constant fit to the continuum in the range 8100-8400 @A, excluding the ~8200@A doublet. Then we subtracted each normalised template from the GD 552 data in 5% steps. In Figure 7 we show an example of this procedure. GD 552 is at the bottom of the plot. Each profile above GD 552 increases the amount of template subtracted from the data by 5%. Consistently, we found that for all the templates the presence of M star features is obvious once we reach 10%. 3.4 System parameters In section 3.3 we placed an upper limit of 10% upon the contribution of an M star to the spectrum of GD 552 in the range 8100 to 8400 @A. We now use this restriction to estimate the mass of this hypothetical star. This will allow us to compare directly to HH1990's M2value, and thus to test their model. We first need to convert our constraint into one upon theI-band magnitude of the M star. We start from the relation between magnitudes and fluxes, including a to make our data match the profile of the I RAS, MNRAS 000, 1-10GD 552: a cataclysmic variable with a brown dwarf companion? 7 Figure 5. Left: The archival STIS ultraviolet spectrum of GD552, plot ted in gray. The solid line shows a two-component fit consisti ng of a linear slope plus a white dwarf model spectrum ( Teff= 10500K, log g= 7.5), both components are plotted individually as dashed lines. Shown as dotted line are the same two-component model s, but for Teff= 11000K (top curve) and 10000K (bottom curve). Right: The STIS ultraviolet spectrum along with our WHT low-resolu tion spectrum, plotted in gray. Plotted as solid black line i s the sum of the white dwarf model as shown in the left panel plus the spect rum of an hydrogen slab. Both model com ponents are plotted individually as dotted lines. Figure 7. From bottom to top: normalised template star (Gl 65A); norma lised GD 552; and the four following curves are normalised GD 552 minus 5%, 10%, 15% and 20% of the normalised template re spectively. When 10% of Gl 65A is subtracted from GD 552 (thir d curve, top to bottom), the presence of M star features is easi ly seen from the growing bump at 8200 @A due to the Na I doublet. The vertical scale in the figure includes an offset of 0.5 between e ach plot and thus it is this equation, 10% MSstands for 10 percent of the tem- plate M star; oIis the transmission for the I Band; liandlf are the limits of the observed range in wavelength. fl,10%MS is 10% of the normalised flux density of the M star, ob- tained by dividing by a constant fit to the 8100-8400 @A re- gion (the Na I doublet at 8200 @A excluded) and multiplied by 0.10. Similarly, fl,GD552is the flux density of GD 552 calculated by dividing by a constant fit to its continuum. A field star in front of GD 552 made difficult to do this in previous years. By September 2006, however, the inter- loper had moved enough to make this calculation straight-forward (see Figure 8). We measured mI,GD552= 16.3 from our data. Then we use equation 2 with the M star templates listed in Table 2, obtaining mI,10%MSas a (mild) function of the assumed spectral type (hereafter this will be referre d to simply as mI). In Figure 9 we compare these values after conversion to absolute magnitude MIfor distances of 70 and 125pc with the absolute magnitudes of young M dwarfs of the same spectral type from Leggett (1992). In doing this we are assuming solar-like vertical line in Figure 9 marks the spectral type for a hydrogen burning star with the lowest possible mass (~0.08M, Kirkpatrick & McCarthy 1994). The the top and bottom panels is the distance assumed in each case. In the top panel we used the value RAS, MNRAS 000, et al. AB Figure 8. GD 552 (marked with an A) and a field star (marked with a B) in September 2006 (image scale is ~1'by 1'). The field star was in front of the system in previous years and made impossible to estimate GD 552's magnitude with any certaint y. The high proper motion of GD 552 results in it and the field star now being resolved. Using our data we measured I= 16.3 for GD 552 and I= 17.6 for the field star. Figure 9. Comparison of the upper limit on MIderived from our I-band spectra for the mass donor in GD 552 (solid line, open squares plus arrows, to indicate the upper-limit natur e of the point) and MIfor young M dwarfs of the same spectral type (dashed line,open circles, Leggett 1992). The vertical lin e at M6.5 marks the limit set by Kirkpatrick & McCarthy (1994) for a hy- drogen burning star. The pannels assume different distances to the system. The upper one uses the old Greenstein & Giclas (1978) value while the lower panel uses the distance estimat ed in this paper.from Greenstein & Giclas (1978); it is clear from it that the absolute magnitudes allowed by our data are the assumption that the mass donor in GD 552 is a main-sequence star. This implies that the mass of the com- panion star M2<0.08M, ruling out near such as that of HH1990. Our conclusion remains un- altered even if GD 552 is at the maximum distance of 125 pc calculated for a 0 .33Mwhite dwarf (Section 3.2) which is lower than any white dwarf mass measured in any CV. 4 DISCUSSION Our model of GD 552 is radically different from that of HH1990. Where they have a very high mass white dwarf in an almost face-on system, with an M dwarf donor of mass
~0.15M, our failure to detect the mass donor requires that it is a brown dwarf with M2<0.08M. This makes GD 552 an excellent candidate for a sys- tem with an age of about 7 Gyr (Politano et al. 1998). Our explanation of the low K1is therefore simply a case of ex- treme mass ratio, and we do not require a particularly low orbital inclination. If the secondary is low mass, there is n o need for the system to be face on to get K1= 17.4kms-1, and therefore neither is there any need for the white dwarf to have a high mass to produce the double peaked profiles. For example, the observed value of K1can be matched with a white dwarf of mass M1= 0.6Min orbit with a compan- ion of mass M2= 0.03Mwith a moderate inclination et al. (2005) suggested that GD 552 is a likely period bouncer (post period minimum CV) because of its lack of outbursts and small K1. We have now given support to their suggestion. However, HH1990's original model could have been correct and the search for the donor was a crucial step in ruling out HH1990's hypothesis. Mass donors are easily visible in other systems with hotter white dwarfs and with orbital periods similar to GD 552 (e.g. HT Cas, Porb=
106.1min, M5-M6V secondary spectral type, Marsh 1990; Z Cha,Porb= 107.3min, M5.5V secondary spectral type, Wade & Horne 1988; compared to Porb= 102.73minfor GD 552). Our search for the mass donor was thus a realistic and critical test for the suitability of HH1990's model. There is a key point about our analysis that is we have managed to derive particularly because of GD 552's relatively long orbital pe- riod which maximises the difference between the pre- and systems. In particular it means that th e mass donor in the pre-bounce model is relatively easy to de- tect, so that failure to detect it is a clear indication of the post-bounce alternative. We believe that this makes GD 552 one of the most secure CV known (RE J1255+266 may be even better if its relatively long period can be confirmed, see Patterson et al. 2005). The method we employ is indirect, but necessarily so, since if the donor is a brown dwarf it is likely to contribute far less light than the upper limit we have derived. It can be argued that there is also the possibility that GD552 is not a post-bounce system at all, even if its compo- nents are a WD with a brown dwarf donor. If GD552's pro- genitor was a binary composed of a main sequence star and a brown dwarf, instead of a double main sequence binary, RAS, MNRAS 000, 1-10GD 552: a cataclysmic variable with a brown dwarf companion? 9 would have evolved into the CV we see today without the need of going through the minimum period. We would not be able to distinguish between these two systems at all. Poli - tano (2004) found that CVs that evolve directly to a short orbital period are expected to be rare because the progeni- tor systems containing a solar-type star and a brown dwarf are known to be rare (the brown-dwarf desert). 5 CONCLUSIONS We have used I-band spectroscopy in an attempt to detect the mass donor of the cataclysmic variable GD 552. donor star putsstronglimits on its mass, rulin g out a main sequence nature. We have shown GD 552 data to be consistent with a model in which its components are an ordinary white dwarf and a brown dwarf, at a moderate inclination angle. Popu- lation synthesis calculations favour the idea that the mass donor reached the stage of brown dwarf through of being born as such. This suggests that GD 552 is likely to be a post-period minimum CV, making it the pe- riod bouncer with the longest orbita l period known. We confirm the value obtained by HH1990 for the ra- dial velocity semiamplitude of the white dwarf and deter- mine for it a Teffof 10900 +-400 K by fitting the spectra with a grid of white dwarf models. The temperature deter- mined for the white dwarf in GD552 is consistent with the red edge of the instability strip (11000 < Teff<12000 K; Bergeron et al. 1995). From the 5.4h stretch of photome- try presented, we find no indication of the presence of pul- sations. The lightcurve shows significant varibility but no t with the periodicities and amplitudes characteristic of ZZ Cet was supported by PPARC (UK) and Fundaci' on Andes (Chile) under the program Gemini PPARC-Andes through- out most of this research. EU and RH-Gwere also supported by Universidad Cat' olica del Norte's Proyecto de Investi- gaci' on en Docencia 220401-10602015. TRM was supported under a PPARC SRF during some of the period over which this work was undertaken. LM-R is supported by NWO VIDI grant 639.042.201 to P. J. Groot. BTG was supported by a PPARC Advanced Fellowship. The authors acknowledge the data analysis by the Starlink Project which is run by the Uni- versity of Southampton on behalf of PPARC. This research has made use of NASA's Astrophysics Data System Biblio- graphic Services. We acknowledge with thanks the variable star observations from the AAVSO International by observers worldwide and used in this re- search. The INT and the WHT are operated on the island of La Palma by the Isaac Newton Group in the Spanish Ob- servatorio del Roque de los Muchachos of the Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias This research was also partly based on observations made with the NASA/ESA Hubble SpaceTelescope, obtained from the data archive at the Space Tele- scope Science Institute. STScI is operated by the Associa- tion of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc. under NASA contract NAS 5-26555; these observations are associ- ated wirh program S. et al., 2005, A&A 430, 629 Bessell, M., 1999, PASP 111, 1426 Bergeron P., Wesemael F., Lamontagne R., Fontaine G., Saffer R.A., Allard N.F., 1995, ApJ 449, 258 Cannizzo, J., 1993, ApJ 419, 318 Delfosse, X. et al., 2000, A&A 364, 217 Diaconis, P., Efron, B., 1983, Sci. Am., v. 248, n. 5, 96 Friend, M., Smith, R., Martin, J., Jones, D., 1988, MNRAS 233 , 451 G ansicke, B.T., Sion, E.M., Beuermann, K., Fabian, D., Che ng, F.H., Krautter, J., 1999, A&A 347, 178 G ansicke, B.T., Araujo-Betancor, S., H.-J. Hagen, E.T. Ha rlaftis, S. Kitsionas, S. Dreizler, D. Engels, 2004, A&A 418, 270 G ansicke, B.T., 2006, MNRAS, 365, 969 G ansicke, B.T., Beuermann, K, Thomas, H.-C., 1997, MNRAS 289, 388 G ansicke, B.T., Sion, E.M., Beuermann, K., Fabian, D., Che ng, F.H., Krautter, J., 1999, A&A 346, 151 Giclas, H., Burnham, R., Thomas, N., 1970, Lowell Obs. Bull. 153 Greenstein, J., Giclas, H., 1978, PASP 90, 460 Hamada, T., Salpeter, E., 1961, ApJ 134, 683 Hessman, F., Hopp, U., 1990, A&A 228, 387 Horne, K., Marsh, T., 1986, MNRAS 218, 761 Howell, S., Nelson, L., Rappaport, S., 2001, ApJ 550, 897 Hubeny, I, Lanz, T, 1995, ApJ 439, 875 Kirkpatrick, J., McCarthy, D., 1994, AJ 107, 333 Kirkpatrick, J., Henry, T., McCarthy, D., 1991, ApJS 77, 417 Kolb, U., 1993, A&A 271, 149 Kolb, U., Baraffe, I., 1999, MNRAS 309, 1034 Leggett, S., 1992, ApJS, 82, 351 Lin, D.N.C., Williams, R.E., Stover, R.J., 1988, ApJ 327, 23 4 Littlefair, S., Dhillon, V., Martin, E. , 2003, MNRAS 340, 26 4 Littlefair, S., Dhillon, V., Marsh, T., G ansicke, B., Sout hworth, J., Watson, C., 2006, Science, 314, 1578 Lomb, N., 1976, Ap&SS 39, 447 Marsh, T.R., 1987, MNRAS 229, 779 Marsh, T.R., 1988, MNRAS 231, 1117 Marsh, T.R., 1989, PASP 101, 1032 Marsh, T.R., 1990, ApJ 357, 621 Marsh, T.R., Horne, K., 1988, MNRAS 235, 269 Mennickent, R. E., Diaz, M., Skidmore, W., Sterken, C., 2001 , A&A 376, 448 Oke, J., 1990, AJ 99, 1621 Patterson, J., Thorstensen, J., Kemp, J., 2005, PASP 117, 42 7 Politano, M., 2004, ApJ 604, S.,1998,inWilds tarsin the Old West., Howell S., Kuulers E., Woodwards, C. (eds.), ASP Conference Series 137, p. 207 Putte, D., Smith, R., Hawkins, N., Martin, J., 2003, MNRAS 34 P., G ansicke, B.T., Hagen, H.-J., Marsh, T .R., Harlaftis, E.T., Kitsionas, S., Engels, D., 2005, A&A 431, 2 69 Scargle, J., 1982, ApJ 263, 835 Schneider, D., Young, P., 1980, ApJ 238, 946 Shafter, A., Szkody, P., Thorstensen, J., 1986, MNRAS 308, 7 65 Sion, E., Szkody, P., 2005, in White Dwarfs: Cosmological a nd Galactic Probes, Sion, E., Vennes, S., Shipman, H. and Space Science Library 332, p. 217 RAS, MNRAS 000, et al. Smak, J., 1981, Acta Astron. 31, 395 Smith, M., Dhillon, V., Marsh, T., 1998, MNRAS 296, 465 Southworth, J., G ansicke, B., Marsh, T., de Martino, D., Ha kala, P., Littlefair, S., Rodrguez-Gil, P., Szkody, P., 2006, MNR AS 373, 687 Szkody, P. et al., 2007, AJ 134, 185 van Zyl, L. et al., 2004, MNRAS 350, 307 Wade, B., Horne, K., 1988, ApJ 324, 411 Warner, B., Woudt, P.A., 2004, MNRAS 348, 599 Warner, B., Woudt, P.A., 2005, PASP 334, 453 Willems, B., Kolb, U., Sandquist, E., Taam, R., Dubus, G., 20 05, ApJ 635, 1263 Williams, G., Shipman, H., 1988, ApJ 326, 738 Williams, R.E., 1980, ApJ 235, 939 Wilson, R., 1953, Carnegie Inst. Washington D.C. Publ. RAS, MNRAS 000, 1-10
|
0806.4892
|
Eduardo Unda-Sanzana
|
E. Unda-Sanzana, T. R. Marsh, B. T. Gansicke, P. F. L. Maxted, L.
Morales-Rueda, V. S. Dhillon, T. D. Thoroughgood, E. Tremou, C. A. Watson, R.
Hinojosa-Goni
|
GD 552: a cataclysmic variable with a brown dwarf companion?
| null | null |
10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13458.x
| null |
astro-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
GD 552 is a high proper motion star with the strong, double-peaked emission
lines characteristic of the dwarf nova class of cataclysmic variable star, and
yet no outburst has been detected during the past 12 years of monitoring. We
present spectroscopy taken with the aim of detecting emission from the mass
donor in this system. We fail to do so at a level which allows us to rule out
the presence of a near-main-sequence star donor. Given GD 552's orbital period
of 103 minutes, this suggests that it is either a system that has evolved
through the ~80-minute orbital period minimum of cataclysmic variable stars and
now has a brown dwarf mass donor, or that has formed with a brown dwarf donor
in the first place. This model explains the low observed orbital velocity of
the white dwarf and GD 552's low luminosity. It is also consistent with the
absence of outbursts from the system.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 30 Jun 2008 13:38:42 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Unda-Sanzana",
"E.",
""
],
[
"Marsh",
"T. R.",
""
],
[
"Gansicke",
"B. T.",
""
],
[
"Maxted",
"P. F. L.",
""
],
[
"Morales-Rueda",
"L.",
""
],
[
"Dhillon",
"V. S.",
""
],
[
"Thoroughgood",
"T. D.",
""
],
[
"Tremou",
"E.",
""
],
[
"Watson",
"C. A.",
""
],
[
"Hinojosa-Goni",
"R.",
""
]
] |
We don't think enough is known about how teacher change occurs, why it is difficult, or how we can better facilitate it.Teacher Learning of Formative Assessment (TLT) is a five-year research project focused on studying teacher learning and pedagogical change. Our goals today are to tell you a little bit about the project, to give you a glimpse through our window into teacher change, and to share some of our preliminary findings.The core of this presentation, in part 2, consists of four stories: narratives of teacher change for four of our participating teachers. But first, in part 1, we'll describe the context of those stories: our project participants, our intervention, and our research design. At the end, in part 3, we'll describe some general findings that cut across these four cases and others, present a model of teacher change that we've been developing, and identify some implications for professional development.part 1: contextTo study teacher change, we need three ingredients: teachers, an intervention that induces change, and a research design for observing that change.a. the teachersWe are working with approximately 39 teachers from three school systems. W e say approximately because there is some attrition, and the number depends on exactly when you count. The total number about whom we have at least a little data is larger; the number currently active is smaller .We have four sites in three school districts, all in western Massachusetts. W e've staggered the start dates to distribute the load on our professional development and research staf f, and to provide us the opportunity for mid-course corrections.Our first site is a combined middle-and-high school in a rural multi-town district. For a while it was flirting with a high needs designation, but seems to have escaped that. W e began our first intervention year there -- in August 2006 -- with ten participating teachers, six from the high school and four from the middle school. Four taught science (two at each level), and the remainder taught math. After the first intervention year ended, four teachers left the project for various reasons, although two indicated that they wanted to continue practicing the pedagogy , but without participating in professional development or data collection activities.Our second site, begun one year later , is a high school in a diverse college town. These teachers were so enthusiastic that they basically pestered us into letting them join; we accommodated them by switching from a two-site to a three-site design. All seven teachers of the science department are participating, as well as one math teacher .beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
2/29Our third and fourth sites have just recently been organized, and the intervention will begin in August 2008. The third site is one of the largest high schools in western Massachusetts, in a sprawling suburban area adjacent to a large city . We have ten science teachers and one math teacher participating, as well as one science teacher from the nearby vocational school.As we were negotiating with that school, the district's middle school teachers asked to join. The opportunity to learn more about how our pedagogy and professional development work at the middle school level, and to impact an entire district's secondary schools at once, was too good to pass up. So, we combined the interested teachers from the two middle schools into a fourth site that will run in parallel with the third site. This fourth site has eight teachers, all in science.(This causes our total number of participants to significantly exceed the number we planned on. Due to unforeseen economies, our budget can handle this, but it will place a severe strain on our person-power , and we will be forced to become more efficient. This is not necessarily bad, since we want to look down the road towards scalability , anyway .)So, you can see that we have quite a mix of math and science, middle and high school, although we're slanted towards high school science since that was our original focus and mandate.We also have a cross-section of socioeconomic types. It's not quite as broad as we wanted: we tried hard to find an urban school with a large minority population that we could partner with, and we came close, but the ones we negotiated with couldn't pull together the basic technical infrastructure that the project required. Which, of course, simply highlights the difficulties facing that kind of school district.b. the interventionThe second ingredient of our study is the intervention. Our intervention consists of a hook, a pedagogy, and a professional development program.the hookThe hook is the bit that catches teachers' attention and captures their initial interest. It's not a shallow gimmick, but rather something distinctive and characteristic that they can immediately see potential in. Our hook is the use of classroom response system (CRS) technology , known informally as clickers (Beatty , 2004; Dufresne, Gerace, Leonard, Mestre & W enk, 1996; Fies & Marshall, 2006).In essence, a CRS is nothing more than a set of simple transmitters that students use to send in their answers to some question; a receiver and software that runs on the teacher's computer , collecting and instantly aggregating answers from the whole class; and a way to display the distribution of answer choices to the teacher and the students, typically as a histogram on a data projector or wall-mounted monitor . In our experience, CRSs are becoming increasingly common in universities (Banks, 2006), but are still rare in K-12
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
3/29A CRS is just a tool, and a teacher can use that tool for many , many dif ferent purposes. This raises the question of what a teacher should use one for . And that is where our pedagogy comes in.the pedagogyThe pedagogy part of our intervention is something we've been developing since 1993. It began in the context of university physics, expanding to other subjects and into secondary schools. W e call it Formative Assessment -- TEF A for short. It's quite rich and rather carefully designed, and we could easily fill a ninety-minute session talking about just that. So, we'll barely scratch the surface here. A more detailed description of some of its components and aspects is available in previous writings (Dufresne et al., 1996; Beatty , Leonard, Gerace & Dufresne, 2006), and we are currently preparing a definitive exposition and defense for journal publication.At the heart of TEFA, defining and directing it, are four core principles: question-driven instruction, dialogical discourse, formative assessment, and meta-level and focus student learning with question-driven instruction (QDI). This means posing tough, rich, meaty , often messy questions to students in order to contextualize and motivate subsequent learning, and often in order to catalyze or precipitate learning. It is grounded in the conceptual change tradition (Scott, Asoki & Leach, 2007). It is motivated by an understanding that students perceive, process, and store information dif ferently in response to a need, and that they get ideas by wrestling with the application of those ideas (Bransford et al., 1999, p. 139).2.Develop students' understanding and scientific fluency with dialogical discourse (DD). This means engaging students in discussion in which multiple ideas and ways of thinking are explored and contrasted, and in which students articulate and explore their own thinking. It is grounded in the sociocultural tradition (Carlsen, 2007; Mortimer & Scott, 2003). It is motivated by an understanding that learning science largely means learning the social language of science (Bakhtin, summarized in W ertsch, 1991, pp. 93-1 18), and one must practice speaking a language to develop fluency . It is also motivated by an understanding that the tools students use for internal cogitation are appropriated from social interactions (Vygotsky , 1987).3.Optimize teaching and students' learning with formative assessment (FA) In this context, this means making students' knowledge and thinking visible in order to adjust and optimize subsequent learning and teaching. It is motivated by an understanding that ef fective instruction requires detailed and current information about the specific students being taught, and that ef fective learning requires accurate self-knowledge (Wiliam, 2007). According to a seminal literature review by Paul Black and Dylan Wiliam (1998), educational innovations beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
4/29involving formative assessment produce learning gains that are among the largest ever found for educational students cooperate in the learning process and develop metacognitive skills with meta-level communication (MLC). This means communicating about communication, about cognition, about learning, and about the purposes of instructional experiences. It is grounded in literature on student motivation and self-regulation (Koballa & Glynn, 2007; Wilson, 2006). It is motivated by an understanding that learning works better when students frame their participation appropriately and understand what they are supposed to be paying attention to (Hammer , 1996; Hammer & Elby , 2003).These four principles are not independent and arbitrary beliefs. Rather , they interlock and reinforce each other in a highly synergistic way . This can be seen in the way they come together in the question cycle, the canonical or prototypical way that TEFA is enacted in the classroom (figure 1).The teacher begins a cycle by presenting a question or problem to the class. Students think about it, ether individually or talking in small groups, and and decide upon their answers. They then enter their responses into their classroom response system transmitters. The software aggregates the answers and constructs a histogram indicating how many students have picked each answer , which the teacher shares with the class.Then, the teacher moderates a whole-class discussion about the question. This typically begins by asking for volunteers to explain the reasoning behind their particular choice. I see someone chose 'not enough information.' Could you tell me what else you would like to know in order to solve it? Several people picked answer three. Who can give me an argument why that's a good choice? Hm, okay . Did anyone have a different reason for choosing that same answer?The teacher's initial goal is to draw out the range and diversity of thinking behind different answers, in as much depth and rigor as possible, and then to evolve the discussion of these into examination and comparison of the ideas, exploration of related topics, and development of understanding or insight. Finally , the teacher ends the cycle by providing some kind of summary , micro-lecture, or other closure, and then transitioning to another question or a dif ferent activity (or beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
5/29 Figure 1: The TEF A question cycle.perhaps ending class).We often use a sequence of related questions to develop students' understanding of some set of ideas, homing in on the desired learning through multiple iterations of the question cycle.It is important to understand that TEFA, enacted in the question cycle, is not meant as a drop-in for occasionally quizzing students about what they are supposed to have learned already . It is intended to contextualize, motivate, and actually precipitate student learning, as well as to keep the teacher well informed about students' understanding and thinking. W e do not mean that a K-12 teacher should use TEFA for all of their class time every day , but we do advocate it as a regular engine of learning, something used frequently and predictably to drive instruction, with other activities surrounding it and relating to it.the professional development programOur intervention includes a professional development program designed to help our participating teachers learn to use the CRS technology and implement the TEFA pedagogy . In a sense, the intervention is the PD program, although it is inseparable from the technology and pedagogy .TEFA isn't lightweight, and neither is our PD. W e've tried to design in known best practices from the in-service teacher PD literature (Supovitz & Turner , 2000; Ball & Cohen, 1999; NEIR TEC, 2004). As we gain experience implementing it, we make improvements for each subsequent site.Because we're working with several teachers at a time from one school (or from nearby schools with a close administrative relationship), we can provide all PD on-site, at the teachers' own schools. This is efficient for the teachers, and we expect it to reduce absenteeism at PD meetings.Because we work with a critical mass of teachers from a school, and especially from its science department, we can foster a community of peers who learn together , act as a problem-solving resource for each other , and sometimes collaborate on question design (curriculum).The PD program is intensive. We begin with a four-day workshop in August, where we paint the big picture of TEFA, provide some hands-on time using the technology and creating questions to use with their classes, and generally help them get ready to try the approach out when the school year starts. During the first academic year , we meet once a week, after school, for an hour and a half.For the second and third academic years of the intervention (second year only at sites 3 and 4), we meet after school every two to three weeks to provide sustained, ongoing support. Our experience from previous projects is that it typically takes about three years for most teachers to really internalize TEFA (Feldman & Capobianco,
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
6/29The three-year program starts intensively and with a strong agenda. During years two and three, our focus shifts to scaffolding, switching to a teacher-driven mode in order to develop sustainable habits of ongoing professional growth. This is done by involving the teachers in a form of collaborative action research known as enhanced normal practice (Feldman, 1996; Feldman & Capobianco, 2000; Feldman & Minstrell, 2000).We try to be self-consistent, using the TEFA methodology to teach TEFA. W e do this because we believe it works, and also so that teachers get to see the pedagogy modeled and experience it as students.The PD remains grounded in teachers' real-world classroom experiences. At every meeting, participants discuss their current problems, insights, observations, and ideas. This helps the teachers connect the content of PD with their practice.It also helps PD staf f keep the program agile. Because every teacher's outlook, context, and learning trajectory are dif ferent, and because each school has its own characteristics, we keep PD highly responsive to our participants' evolving needs. W e solicit feedback through multiple channels and make frequent adjustments.In previous work (Feldman & Capobianco, 2008), we have identified five general skill areas that a teacher must develop to master TEFA and be comfortable with it.1 The general scope of the PD program follows this framework.The most obvious set of skills to master are related to the technology: those required to reliably operate the CRS hardware and software, manage the logistics of the classroom, and deal gracefully with any glitches that arise.The second skill area addresses crafting questions for TEFA question cycles that reliably produce good classroom interaction and achieve learning goals (Beatty , Gerace, Leonard & Dufresne, 2006) -- and doing it without consuming more preparation time than the teacher can afford. Teachers quickly discover that typical quiz, homework, and end-of-chapter questions rarely lead to satisfactory TEFA experiences.The third skill area involves orchestrating the discourse of the classroom: encouraging students' participation, eliciting thoughtful and extended contributions, drawing out multiple points of view , and gently steering discussion in order to achieve instructional goals.The fourth skill area centers on understanding and reacting to students: probing their knowledge and thinking through QDI questions and verbal interaction, interpreting their responses and comments, building and refining mental models of the students, and making beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
7/291 Most of our previously published work identifies four skill areas; we've since expanded that to five, adding one we had neglected.sound and agile adjustments -- often in real-time -- to the information provided by formative assessment. Formative assessment is only formative if the information is actually used to adjust teaching or learning (Black, Harrison, Lee, Marshall, & Wiliam, 2002).The fifth skill area includes everything necessary to integrate TEFA practice with everything else in a teacher's context: their curriculum and syllabus, other instructional activities, students' needs and capacities, impending standardized exams, scheduled and unscheduled disruptions, and everything else that fills a teacher's life. The skills learned to deal with these are idiosyncratic to each school and teacher's particular circumstances, which means they're hard for us to teach. Also, these kinds of problems don't tend to stay solved, since circumstances change.c. the research designThe third ingredient of our project is the research design: the part that examines how teachers are (hopefully) changing in response to the intervention.We are using a longitudinal, staggered site, delayed intervention design (figure 2). For each of our four sites, we start with one semester for collecting baseline data, followed by three years of intervention and collection of longitudinal data. Each cohort begins one year after the previous one, both to distribute our workload and to give us a chance to improve our intervention, instrumentation, and methods as we go. (The final two cohorts, consisting of the high school and middle schools from the same district, are running simultaneously .)As this is written, we are approximately 1.5 semesters into the action research phase at site 1, 1.5 semesters into the intensive PD phase at site 2, and part-way through baseline data collection at sites 3 and 4. In terms of analysis, we've recently collected enough longitudinal data on the teachers at our first site to begin constructing and pondering reasonable case study profiles and starting cross-case analysis. (W e've been making observations and kicking around ideas all the time, of course, but now we can get more formal and serious about it.)data sourcesWe are collecting data through multiple instruments and
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
8/29 Figure 2: Project timeline.PD meetings: We audio-record and transcribe all professional development meetings, and take field notes as well.journals: As part of PD, teachers are encouraged to write journal entries on their TEFA thinking and learning. The frequency and quality of these varies drastically from teacher to teacher , however: journaling is sufficiently time-intensive that we don't feel we can insist on log: Teachers complete a simple, 2-page paper log form every day , indicating whether they used TEFA, how many questions they posed, how satisfied they were with the outcome, what fraction of the class participated in discussions, what fraction of class time was spent on TEFA, and whether any technical problems arose.monthly survey: Once a month, teachers go online to complete a fairly extensive web-based survey about their experiences with TEFA over the preceding month. It combines multiple choice scales and short essay questions, and some of the questions require significant reflection.class video: Twice per semester , we videotape each teacher teaching an entire class, scheduling -- if possible -- a day on which they use TEFA. The protocol includes short pre- and post-class interviews to provide us with context and insight.student survey: Once per semester , we administer a Likert scale, optically scanned survey to every student in every class of each participating teacher . The survey has been designed to solicit students' perceptions of the class environment and the teacher's expectations, so we can see whether use of TEFA impacts the learning environment in a way students perspectives survey & interview: Once a year , teachers take a Likert scale survey on their general pedagogical views, and an accompanying intensive interview (two parts of approximately 45 minutes each) on perspectives more directly related to TEFA.biography: During the baseline phase, we elicit aspects of each teacher's professional preparation and background through a web-based survey .miscellaneous: Finally , we do some more spontaneous interviews and focus-group discussions on an as-needed, as-possible basis, in order to gain additional insight into teachers' experiences as they encounter and learn of all this data is what one might call M3: massively mixed methods. We are, quite frankly , bringing several dif ferent approaches to bear in an exploratory way , looking for the most
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
9/29We've been applying quantitative methods to data from the student survey , the monthly reflection survey , and the daily implementation log. W e're also quantifying aspects of teachers' TEFA practice, as captured in the classroom video, for quantitative analysis.We've been applying qualitative methods to transcripts of the various interviews, open-ended responses to the monthly reflection survey , and select video segments. For this, we've been exploring theory-driven coding based on our prior research and experiences with TEFA. W e've also been exploring a more grounded theory approach, applying open coding, microanalysis, and axial coding to the data.Our collaborators at SRI International have recently begun discourse analysis of selected video all analytic tactics, our general strategy is to start by constructing detailed, rich case study profiles of each teacher's starting point and evolution. W e want to understand their individual learning trajectories in as much detail as possible. As those profiles develop, we do cross-case analysis in an ef fort to identify general patterns and trends, distinct categories of experience, and central themes.research objectivesAt this point, we've presented enough context that our official research objectives should make some sense.Our first and primary goal is to develop a better understanding of how teachers learn TEF A, how they develop comfort with it, and how they adapt it to suit their needs. Although we're studying TEFA in particular , we believe TEFA is rich enough that much of what we learn will generalize to other pedagogies and instructional technologies.Our second goal, building on the first, is to improve our TEF A professional development: to get better at helping teachers become happy and skilled with TEFA, faster and with less angst on their part.Our third goal looks toward the future. W e see a need for a rigorous, controlled implementation study of TEFA's measurable learning impacts on students and of the feasibility of large-scale TEFA professional development. To conduct such a study , we need to develop knowledge and scalable instrumentation that will allow efficient tracking of teachers' learning progress and implementation fidelity . Among other things, we need to know when in the course of a teacher's TEFA learning we should expect to see learning impacts.part 2: storiesEach teacher's experience of confronting TEFA and coming to terms with it is unique. It's a very personal journey , a narrative. It is tempting, but dangerous, to boil all our research down to a beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
10/29few concise bullet-points of generalized findings. W e believe this would lose the essence of the teacher change process that we seek to illuminate. Therefore, we will tell four stories -- narratives of the TEFA learning process for four of our participating teachers. Afterward, we will presenting some general findings, conclusions, and implications that cut across these cases as well as the others we are studying.We've chosen this particular set of four four in order to illustrate four qualitatively dif ferent learning trajectories, all dif ferent and all illuminating. Every teacher's learning process is unique in at least some aspects, so it is difficult to call these four Nevertheless, they do illustrate a reasonable portion of the range of variability we have is a very experienced, confident high school chemistry teacher . She took to TEFA like a duck to water . Even so, she did encounter tensions between TEFA and her teaching style.Kim is an experienced high school math teacher , but new to this particular school. She struggled with TEFA and has had persistent doubts about its worth, but has kept working at it consistently , and has grown in the process.Renee is a very experienced middle school science teacher whose personal style and outlook seemed to clash strongly with TEFA. Nevertheless, through cautious consideration and experimentation, she found creative ways to make it work for her .Gina is a new middle school math teacher . She initially found TEFA to be thoroughly intimidating and got nowhere at all with it, but then she dramatically changed her approach to the project and took of f -- on her own terms.a. Tracy's storyTracy is a high school chemistry teacher with over twenty years of experience. She is usually confident, positive and enthusiastic. At the outset of the project, her typical style of instruction was largely traditional and frontal. She expressed a strong need to be in control of classroom events, and in fact referred to herself as a control freak. She struck us as an ef fective, competent traditional teacher . Student surveys suggest that she is very popular with her students. She has high expectations for her students, and wants them to be active and engaged learners.Tracy started the project strongly enthusiastic about TEFA. Once the intervention began, she took to TEFA very naturally , and quickly demonstrated what we would judge to be high implementation fidelity . Nevertheless, she encountered several tensions between her perception of TEFA and her style, perspectives, and values. W e can identify six specific tensions:1.TEFA encourages teachers to help students' develop a deep understanding of concepts, but Tracy was more concerned with covering curriculum at a sufficient
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
11/292.Good TEFA questions require time to craft, but -- like most teachers -- Tracy's prep time was limited.3.TEFA seeks to foster student-driven dialogue, but Tracy's desire for control of the classroom led her to strongly mediate all classroom talk, with students interacting serially with her rather than with each other .4.The typical TEFA question cycle respects the anonymity of students' answers to CRS questions, and relies on volunteerism in discussion participation, but Tracy's insistence that all students be engaged and participating caused her to frequently call on students by name to speak in encourages teachers to be noncommittal in response to students' answers and let students struggle (up to a point) to figure things out for themselves, but Tracy was inclined to tell students the correct answer if she felt that they were taking too long to respond.6.The final phase of the TEFA question cycle is for closure, in which the teacher summarizes or otherwise helps students know what the point of the cycle was and what they should carry away from it, but Tracy had a self-identified weakness of not summarizing in general, and usually omitted this phase, leaving students unsure of what they were supposed to be learning.Despite these tensions, Tracy's initial alignment with TEFA was good, and she struggled less with it than other teachers at that project site. She hit her stride quickly , and gradually made several adjustments to her practice that reduced these tensions.One innovation Tracy introduced to TEFA was her practice of scribing: writing the key ideas from students' statements on her white-board, in order to keep track of the various ways of thinking raised and facilitate uptake of those ideas into later discussion. This practice had not been modeled in PD. Although it tends to keep students' attention focused on the teachers as the controller of dialogue, the practice seems to promote dialogicity in the discourse.The initial tension between Tracy's desire to keep a rigorous pace in covering curriculum topics and TEFA's focus on spending time to thoroughly explore and solidify student understanding of central ideas was gradually mitigated as her views on the efficient use of classroom time changed. By the end of the first intervention year , she conceded that it was acceptable to budget more time for TEFA, claiming that developing students' reasoning skills was more important than covering , Tracy's concern over taking time to prepare good TEFA questions subsided as she became more efficient at it, and also recognized how valuable the ef fort was. She was innovative in her question designs, developing styles more complex than those modeled in PD. beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
12/29Tracy felt that one new type of question was ef fective in eliciting students' thinking and in her words, ef fective at generating challenge to what kids the first year and into the second, Tracy was concerned about student participation: some students would not speak up in class discussion unless directly called upon. Later in the second year , however , she expressed satisfaction at their degree of voluntary participation and at the depth of their responses.Tracy has wrestled with the challenge of loosening control of classroom activity and discussion, but she has tried dif ferent tactics for relinquishing at least some control without consequences that she considers unacceptable. As a result, we have seen a considerable increase in the frequency of exchanges during whole-class the first year , Tracy made an ef fort to break her habit of quickly telling students the answer, and by the spring she admitted to us that she now liked not revealing answers, instead focusing on eliciting students' thinking. However , this change has resulted in a new tension between this practice and her students' desire to be told the answer .Tracy's pre-existing, self-identified weakness of failing to summarize lessons for students was exacerbated by her initial extreme interpretation of our PD assertion that it is frequently useful to refuse to tell students the right answer to a question at all, instead letting the discussion of ideas speak for itself. In one videotaped class, she told her students that doing TEFA meant not being allowed to tell them the answer . Eventually , this misunderstanding was clarified, and Tracy made an ef fort to provide explicit closure at the end of each question cycle. Typically , she would tell students how I would answer the question to end the as Tracy both adjusted her ways of implementing TEFA and evolved in her pedagogical views, most of the initial tensions she experienced were resolved and she became quite comfortable with the overall approach. During the second implementation year , she chose to focus her action research investigations on ways that she can use TEFA to motivate more students to do their homework and engage in non-TEF A aspects of the course. To us, this signifies that TEFA is no longer an issue for her or something that she wrestles with, but rather a trusted tool that she can use to address other challenges.b. Kim's storyKim is a high school math teacher with seven years of experience before joining the project. However , she was new to this school and to the curriculum being used; the TEFA intervention began in her first semester with each. Not surprisingly , she was concerned about being successful, and being perceived as successful, in preparing her students for subsequent courses. She was interested in TEFA, but she had doubts and uncertainties about whether it would work in her
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
13/29Our early installation of the classroom response system software at that school used a pre-release beta version, which had several bugs. This led to an early tension for Kim, as bugs and her own unfamiliarity with the software led to unexpected technology glitches that flustered her , thwarted her desire to conduct class smoothly and competently , and wasted precious class time. Within a month, however , the bugs were fixed, she had developed comfort with the software, and technology glitches were no longer an issue. Another tension she wrestled with was a conflict between her students' behavior at this new school and her standards for how students should act. She found this new school to be far more relaxed about discipline than her previous one, and she was unhappy that when the bell rang to start a new period, students were still talking in the hallways rather than sitting in their seats. She disliked spending time settling students down at the beginning of every class.This tension was not introduced by TEFA, but by her new situation. However , she figured out a way to use TEFA to address it: starting in November , she developed a pattern of beginning each class by posing a TEFA question, since she knew that students enjoyed these and wouldn't want to miss them. She discovered that she could use TEFA as a classroom management tool.A third tension that Kim faced was between her doubt and uncertainty about TEFA's worth and her desire to be successful as a teacher . Since she wanted to try TEFA in her class but also wanted to be as successful as she had been in her previous school, she implemented the TEFA pedagogy in a safe, limited, conservative way . During the first semester , her questions tended to be simple and straightforward -- what we call the you know it or you don't type. Unfortunately , such questions rarely lead to successful her caution, she had a traumatic experience. One student asked her to define the word term (of a mathematical expression), as used in a TEFA question, and she realized she didn't know how to define it. She had always assumed that the meaning was obvious to students. She struggled unsuccessfully to define it in class, and eventually gave up. In her journal, she described the experience as panic, fear , frustration, anger , and embarrassment, and seems to have considered it a very negative event. From our perspective, however , it was a valuable learning experience for her , sensitizing her to the inherent ambiguities in even clear questions, the challenges of communicating reliably with students, the value of formative assessment to discover unexpected learning obstacles students face, and the challenge and importance of instructional agility .As time went on and she had some rewarding experiences with TEFA, her doubts eased. Near the end of the first semester , she said that she realized that trying it was fine; if it didn't work, ok, and if it did work I was ahead of where I had been. Also, she started to recognize the connection between the nature of the questions she posed and the quality of the resulting
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
14/29At the start of the second semester , Kim had an eye-opening experience while teaching with a question that she had developed in PD. She wrote in her journal that The result was amazing. Students boldly shared opinions and gave sound reasoning and examples to support their ideas... For the first time ever I experienced with my students what I would consider to be the 'beauty' of using TEFA/PRS. It really worked! This proved conclusively to her that TEFA could generate strong student discussion and change the class atmosphere, and that she, personally , could be successful with TEFA. It also cemented her belief that the key to generating good discussion was developing good questions.During this second semester , we see evidence that her overall view of teaching evolved, becoming more In our baseline interview , she said that her responsibility as a math teacher was to convey information in such a way that it is easy to learn by as many students as possible. But one year later , she said, I realize that I was planning it from the standpoint of what I need instead of what the students need. She also changed the way she approached lesson planning. She said, TEF A makes me think about the big picture, especially when I'm introducing a topic. It makes me come up with a stimulating question... that provides that some of her tensions with TEFA had been resolved, she still struggled with others. For one thing, she was now very concerned with creating ef fective questions that would enhance class discussion, but found that this required more prep time than she could easily af ford to spend. For another , she found that good classroom discussion took considerable class time, and was concerned about how that might af fect her ability to cover content at a sufficient pace.These concerns continued into the second intervention year as Kim persisted with TEFA. Another concern that grew in her mind was dissatisfaction with poor student participation in whole-class discussion, and concern whether TEFA was of much benefit to them. In particular , she noticed that boys were more likely than girls to speak up. So, she created and administered a survey for her students, inquiring about their perceptions of how valuable dif ferent kinds of learning activities -- including whole-class discussion, small-group discussion, homework, reading, and the like -- were. She reported that their perception is that whole class discussion is not as helpful a way to learn as small group work... Interestingly , she found that boys were more likely than girls to value whole-class discussion, whereas girls preferred small-group a result, she adjusted her use of TEFA, placing more emphasis on small group discussion and using whole-class discussion primarily to have students report out the results of their small-group work.As of the second semester of the second intervention year , Kim is still struggling with the pressure TEFA exerts on both her preparation time and class time. She tells us quite frankly that using TEFA is valuable, but she's not sure it's worth the time required to create good questions beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
15/29week after week. Nevertheless, we see that her perspectives and practices have changed significantly over the past year and a half. She has become more focusing on students' thinking and needs and modifying her lessons and teaching practice based on what she learns from her students' responses. In other words, formative assessment has become an integral part of her teaching, and seems likely to remain so whether she uses TEFA itself or not.c. Renee's storyRenee is a middle-school science teacher who, like Tracy, has over twenty years of experience. She displays confidence in her teaching abilities. She is respectful of her students, and firm and clear about her expectations. Her interactions with students are concise and highly structured. She expresses and manifests a strong concern with shaping students' social skills.At the outset of the project, Renee seemed curious and optimistic about TEFA. However , she seemed to find our initial professional development workshop unpleasant, exhibiting severe reluctance to either be videotaped (we taped the entire workshop, for our own records), or to practice-teach a mock TEFA lesson with her peers in the role of students. As far as we can tell, she simply hates to be on the stage or the object of attention. This is consistent with her teaching style, which relies on student seat-work and almost never involves frontal acquiesced to our normal videotaping schedule of four classes during the year , but she did not use TEFA during a taping for the first two visits, despite our attempts to schedule taping to coincide with TEFA. Her logs and journal indicate that she was using TEFA when we weren't present. In fact, she documented her TEFA usage in meticulous detail, including highly reflective comments on both the successes and the failures. However , she rarely spoke during PD meetings.Renee also struggled with a tension between what she believed her students capable of, and what she thought TEFA expected of them. She considered her students to be concrete thinkers unable to handle the abstract reasoning and argumentation she had seen modeled in PD meetings. She noted early that her students' attention span was short and their focus poor , so that they had trouble staying engaged in lengthy TEFA discussions.Her solution was to restrict TEF A usage to one or two days a week, for a maximum of fifteen minutes at a time, and to keep her questions relatively simple. This introduced a new tension between what she was doing and what she thought PD staf f wanted and would consider acceptable, but she was willing to live with that.Another tension Renee encountered was between the format of our PD program and her needs. In her monthly surveys, she regularly complained that she expected more time to create TEFA questions and discuss them with peers. This tension was never resolved to her satisfaction, beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 because we were backlogged with data and did not see these complaints in time to address them.This state of af fairs lasted for several months, through the fall semester of the first intervention year and into the spring. During that period, she gradually expanded her repertoire of uses for TEFA. Each month she would introduce one or two new styles of question or ways of using TEFA, often inspired by examples and ideas from the PD program. She generally reported success and satisfaction with the outcome, but remained cautious and reserved in her embrace of TEFA. During the third quarter of the year , she finally allowed us to videotape her doing a question cycle with the CRS.During the spring, Renee was concerned about her students' decreasing participation in TEFA discussions. About half-way through the term, she engaged her classes in a frank, meta-level conversation about the problem. They told her they'd prefer not to see the histogram of responses until after they'd discussed a question. In response, she modified her implementation of the question cycle: she'd pose a question and collect answers, but not show the histogram. Instead, she'd let students discuss the question as a whole class. Then, she'd collect a second round of answers, present both histograms, and let students discuss how and why their answers had changed between the rounds of polling. This pattern seemed to be more comfortable for students, and Renee reported that participation levels rose dramatically .Shortly thereafter , Renee tried an innovative solution to the tension she had experienced between her dislike of frontal instructional modes and the canonical TEFA pattern of having the teacher moderate whole-class discussion. She formulated an explicit set of rules for whole-class discussion, and presented them to her students. Then, during the whole-class discussion phase of the TEFA question cycle, she would physically and verbally remove herself from the group and allow the students to self-moderate, responding entirely to each other and setting their own direction. The experiment was successful enough on the first try that she allowed us to record the second on our fourth and final videotaping visit of the year .Unfortunately , a new technical problem prevented her from using her CRS for the last month of the year . Without warning, her classroom computer was replaced with a new and more powerful one, but without the CRS software installed. Because our PD and data collection schedules for the term were over by this time, we did not find out about the problem until much later. Her final monthly survey expressed irritation that she wanted to use her CRS and could not.Overall, Renee manifested a remarkable transformation over the first year . She began as a teacher doubtful about TEFA's suitability for her students, very conservative in her use of it, and deeply uncomfortable with core portions of the pedagogy . By the end of the year , she had developed a wide range of TEFA uses and question styles, found ways to elicit quality student participation, and reconciled her enactment of TEFA with her values and views. She came to beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
17/29value the formative assessment information TEFA provides, and added a new mode of classroom interaction -- the self-moderating whole-class student discussion -- to her , two major tensions remained unresolved. One was the conflict between her deep dislike of being scrutinized and the project's need to conduct research on her learning process. The other was her continuing feeling that PD was not meeting her needs. She found a way to rectify those, too: before the second intervention year began, she sent us a terse email stating that she was exercising her right to drop out of the project, that she would like to keep her CRS if we would allow , and that she did not want us to contact her for the rest of the summer . She has not responded to email from us since then.So, as far as we know , Renee may still be practicing some form of TEFA, but she has dropped completely of f our radar .d. Gina's storyGina teaches middle-school mathematics. When we began our intervention, she was starting her second year as a teacher , and her first year with a new curriculum. Her incoming class of eighth graders was rumored to be unusually difficult. As if all that wasn't challenge enough, she was dealing with some complex and emotionally draining personal issues that would demand a lot of her attention and energy for the next year or more.At the beginning of the school year , after the summer workshop, Gina was generally optimistic about TEFA. She was a little concerned about how well it would work with her particular students, and about her ability to operate the technology . Nevertheless, she had high hopes for diving head-first into TEFA and mastering it.Like most participants, she quickly got the hang of using the technology's essential features, and initial tech glitches were resolved within a month. However , she discovered very quickly that TEFA is far harder to learn and execute than she'd imagined.For the rest of the fall semester , she struggled with two general tensions between her picture of TEFA and her assessment of the reality of her classroom. One had to do with how well TEFA fit her students. As she saw it, TEFA expects students to engage each other and the teacher in rich, thoughtful, extended discussion and argument about abstract ideas. However , she saw her students as concrete thinkers with limited ability to reason abstractly , poor social skills, and little willingness to engage thoughtfully in discussion. This led her to struggle to find questions that were accessible to her students, and yet in the spirit of TEFA. She spent many hours vainly searching the web for question ideas. It also led her to struggle with managing behavior and eliciting struggles were exacerbated by a second tension, having to do with expectations. She formed an extreme view of what successful TEFA should look like. For example, PD staf f had argued that ambiguous questions, and questions with more than one defensible answer , are beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 efficacious. She interpreted this to mean that TEFA questions should never have one unambiguously right answer . Similarly , she believed that all questions must be deeply conceptual, and all questions must provoke rich and extensive discussion among students. It seems that in our attempts to paint a vision of TEFA that contrasted with traditional instruction and showed what was possible and worth aspiring to, we had accidentally created a forbiddingly high bar for Gina.Thus, Gina struggled greatly trying to find or create questions that would meet this self-imposed standard. W eek after week, we would present new question styles in PD and assign homework asking teachers to create their own questions of that type and try them out in class. And week after week, Gina would find herself unable to do that in a way that she could see working with her students. Not surprisingly , she became quite frustrated, and her self-confidence as a new teacher took a severe hit.Over the December holidays and January , no project PD occurred for nearly two months. During this time, Gina recognized that her own fears about using PRS well enough were a barrier to her. She realized that if TEFA was going to work for her , she would have to do it for herself and her students, not for us. For the rest of the spring semester , Gina adopted a new attitude and resolutely ignored all professional development requests to do or try specific things with TEFA, even though she feared this might harm her grade when she got graduate course credit for the program. Instead, she explored dif ferent ways of using TEFA, guided by her own ideas and discussion with peers instead of professional development. And she started thinking of PRS more as a tool she could use for her own ends, and less as a way that she had to follow .One of the things she found was a niche for TEFA: a way of using it that seemed manageable, reliable, and productive for her , even though it was a pale shadow of the TEFA she'd seen presented and modeled by project staf f. For her , TEFA became a way to have students review questions for the upcoming state-wide math exam, and to find out more about what topics on that exam they needed help with. She largely ignored the dialogical discourse and question-driven instruction aspects of TEFA, instead focusing on a relatively patterned, but useful, formative assessment role.She also experimented, cautiously and modestly , using TEFA in dif ferent roles. She had some success experiences that motivated her to keep going. Over the spring semester , her confidence rebounded, and the degree of stress she felt regarding TEFA was drastically reduced. She still perceived a tension between TEFA as it was portrayed in PD meetings and TEFA as she was practicing it, but she was willing to live with that.Another tension that persisted was between her students' ability to behave responsibly in small-group work and Gina's desire to have more small-group experiences for them, both with and without TEFA. She persevered and had some limited successes with this. She also noticed that beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
19/29some classes were much better at small-group work than others, which reassured her that the source of the problem was with the students, not with her competence.After the summer break, Gina confidently fell into a pattern of using TEFA every day to review for the state-wide exam. For the entire fall semester , however an intermittent and unpredictable technical problem with the school network prevented her from using her computer , and thus her CRS, perhaps one day a week or more. She found this very distressing. Interestingly , one year ago she had struggled to make herself use TEFA at all; now she felt hamstrung if she couldn't start every class with it.Gina also continued experimenting with TEFA in dif ferent roles, gradually expanding her repertoire of ways she felt comfortable using it. She started spontaneously inserting on-the-fly questions, in order to gauge student understanding of something that had just occurred. She started adjusting instruction in real-time based on student responses. She linked TEFA to hands-on activities, using pairs of questions around an activity to first motivate it and then later assess and solidify learning from it. She made status-check questions a regular part of her TEFA pattern, asking students how confident they felt about a topic. She even began sprinkling in questions designed to foment discussion or provoke wrestling with challenging ideas -- exactly the use of TEFA that had so intimidated her a year ago.In other words, she couldn't handle TEFA as the whole big intimidating entity she initially perceived it as. But by rejecting everything except a narrow and limited aspect, developing confidence and skill with that, and then gradually extending at her own pace, she has ended up making a relatively rich and varied implementation of TEFA an essential part of her instruction. And in the process, she seems to have raised her perceptions about what students are capable of handling, sharpened her appreciation of formative assessment, developed her ability to make agile adjustments in class, and become much more at home as a teacher .part 3: findingsa. some observationsIt is clear to us from the preceding four stories and from the remainder of our data that TEFA is hard, change is hard, TEFA can be intimidating, and that teachers need to develop a range of new skills to succeed with it. It is also clear that teachers can change and learn TEFA, and they can make significant progress in this over course of one year of professional development. In the lessons that we videotaped and analyzed from our first school, we have seen several changes exhibited by most teachers:*the time spent in discussion during the question cycle increased;*the frequency of student-student interactions during discussions
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 use of IRE types of interactions decreased, especially in the earlier parts of question cycles;*teachers increased the variety of discussion formats that they used as part of the question several teachers reported that the use of a CRS and TEFA helped them gain more information about how their students were thinking about concepts. And they reported (verified by videotape data and pre/post-taping interviews) instances where they changed their lessons as a result of the formative information that they gained about students' thinking.The stories above depicted each teacher's coming to terms with TEFA as a path or trajectory he or she follows. One aspect of this trajectory is the skills learned and knowledge gained at each point in time. Individual teachers' learning trajectories are personal and idiosyncratic, but trajectories seem to share certain general features.Earlier , we indicated that the skills necessary to master TEFA can be grouped into five general skill areas: using the technology , creating questions, orchestrating classroom discourse, understanding and adjusting to students, and integrating TEFA with all other constraints and context. It seems that teachers typically encounter and wrestle with the first three skill areas in that order . Operating the technology and dealing with glitches looms large to them at first, but most become comfortable with that within a month. Then, they realize that designing ef fective questions is more challenging than it at first appears, and spend much of the first year (or more) focused on this. Slightly later -- usually before question design has been mastered, but after some degree of comfort has been reached -- teachers become concerned with the dynamics of their classroom discussion, and reconsider their role and practices in that.The fourth skill area, which we colloquially refer to as getting inside students' heads, and then knowing what to do about it, seems to stay implicit for the first year or more of TEFA learning. It is a factor , but not one that most teachers explicitly focus on. However , we have known at least one extremely proficient, experienced TEFA practitioner who claims that if he focuses on understanding what his students are thinking, everything else falls into place.The fifth skill area, integrating TEFA with everything else, is more idiosyncratic. Teachers' contexts (and their perceptions of those contexts) vary drastically , so both the degree and the nature of the challenge this skill area poses to them varies equally drastically . And, because context tends to change, this area must frequently be revisited. In general, this seems to be a skill area teachers worry about intermittently , and more strongly at the beginning of each academic term.Our four stories ended with the teachers in very different places on their trajectories. Tracy has become an expert user of TEFA, and we believe that she has incorporated it deeply into her way of being a teacher . Kim has steadily increased her proficiency in TEFA, and her conception beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
21/29of TEFA pedagogy has become increasingly similar to ours, but it is still a struggle and she has doubts about whether it is worth the time it requires. Gina has transformed TEFA into pedagogy that she is comfortable with and is using it extensively in her classes, in an increasing variety of roles. Finally , we saw that Renee has developed an understanding of TEFA consonant with ours, has had success using it in her classes in a careful and limited way , but has disassociated herself from the research project. One of the dominant findings of our study is that all teachers are individuals, and the TEFA learning trajectory is TEFA learning trajectory is also bumpy. What we mean by this is that the changes in the teachers and in their pedagogy does not happen smoothly , as a continual and gradual progression. Rather , their conception of TEFA, their ways of using it, and their facility with it can vary considerably and shift suddenly as they wrestle with tensions and dissonances, experience seminal events, have insights, and get input from their peers and from the PD program.Another phenomenon we have observed is that teachers need to find an entry point for TEFA: a way of using it and a niche for it within their practice that is within their zone of proximal development (ZPD, V ygotsky , 1978). That is, they must be able to envision a way of using TEFA that they believe is within their ability , is within their students' capacities, suits their subject matter and level, integrates with their overall teaching patterns, and will produce worthwhile results. Tracy found an easy entry point using TEFA for whole-class discussions about key chemistry concepts; Kim eventually developed one using TEFA to introduce new topics at the start of a class period; Gina struggled, feeling that TEFA was completely beyond her ZPD, but ultimately discovered one using TEFA for standardized exam preparation; and Renee had various success experiences, but did not seem to find a comfortable entry point or niche for TEFA within the year we studied her .We have found that helping teachers learn TEFA gets more challenging as teachers get farther from the PD staff's own background, which is university-level physics instruction. W e have more trouble communicating productively with middle school teachers than with high school teachers, and more trouble with mathematics or biological science teachers than with physical science teachers. The result is that many of these groups feel more left on their own to figure out TEFA and create ef fective questions. Dif ferences in language are one source of difficulty: physicists talk about problem solving where biologists might talk about model-based reasoning, and math teachers talk about problem solving but typically mean something more procedural and less conceptual. Dif ferences between our pedagogical content knowledge (PCK, van Driel, V erloop & de V os, 1998) and theirs is another source of difficulty: we are better at generating compelling examples of CRS questions or responses to student questions in subjects we have taught ourselves.b. co-evolution modelLooking more closely at stories of teacher change from the project, we have realized that a useful way to see and describe the process is in terms
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
22/29*the alignment or misalignment (perceived as tensions) between a teacher's skills, views, and context, on the one hand, and her of TEFA and attempts to enact it on the other; *the conflicts, struggles, and rewards she experiences as a result of these alignments and changes to her of TEF A and to her ways of attempting TEFA that occur in response to these conflicts, struggles, and rewards; and*the changes to her skills, perspectives, and general way of being a teacher that also occur in response to the conflicts, struggles, and rewards.This has led us to formulate our model for the co-evolution of teacher and pedagogy (figure 3). This model is the result of some very recent thinking on our part, and should be considered a work in progress.TEFA, represented at the far top left of the figure, is the pedagogy that we hope the teachers will become skilled at and internalize, recognizing that exactly how they practice it will vary depending on who they are and how they perceive their context.TEFA as represented in PD is not identical to TEFA itself; consciously and unconsciously , we stress some aspects, omit others, and communicate it in specific ways in response to the details beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
23/29 Figure 3: Graphical representation of a model for the co-evolution of teacher and pedagogy .of the PD situation and our assessments of the teachers and their needs. This representation of TEFA evolves over time as the PD program continues and we adjust the message in response to our observations of the teachers.The understanding each teacher forms of TEFA is not identical to the TEFA we attempt to present, either , since all they experience will be filtered through the lens of their own preconceptions, sensitivities, and needs. Furthermore, the TEFA they aim to implement will be yet dif ferent, as they choose some portions, discard others, and generally adapt this interpretation of a representation of TEF A to fit their needs.What the teacher brings to this -- to the version of TEFA they aspire to implement -- is everything that makes them who they are as a teacher: their values, beliefs, perceptions, and skills. In every case we have seen, this who they are as a teacher has some points of misalignment, some tensions, with TEFA as they understand it and aspire to practice it. Tensions result in conflicts and struggles that the teacher experiences in their practice of TEFA. W e see these conflicts and struggles as the driving engine of teacher change: in attempting to resolve them, the teacher is motivated to either evolve their understanding of TEFA, adjust their ways of implementing TEFA, or grow in their views and skills.Points of good alignment between teacher and TEFA -- the opposite of tensions -- can produce rewarding experiences, often unanticipated. These can also drive change as the teacher seeks to capture or maximize them, and they can confirm the teacher and provide motivation to continue with the struggle.Thus, the model represents teacher change as a series of transitions or change process steps between states. The transitions are depicted as discrete and sequential, but they need not be; we have seen both gradual evolution (as in Tracy's case) and sudden change (as in Gina's). Ongoing professional development serves to help mediate these transitions, both by provoking additional tensions (for example, by raising the bar in terms of what quality TEFA implementation ought to aspire to), and by suggesting resolutions (for example, by teaching specific skills or suggesting alternative perspectives).To us, a dominant and very significant feature of the model is that it can be viewed as an evolving dialectic between three narratives. One, which is indicated only very generally and vaguely in figure 3, is our narrative as professional development staf f: the evolution in our understanding of our participating teachers, the development of our PD skills and tools, and the story we present in PD. W e intend to examine this narrative further and building a more detailed model of it in subsequent project work.The other two narratives are internal to the teacher . One, which we have labeled teacher change, is the story of the teacher's growth as a practitioner: acquisition of new skills, development of new perspectives, realization of new or newly emphasized values, and the like. beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
24/29This is the narrative we had been focused on when we began the project; we thought of professional development as helping teachers to develop skills and change views.The second internal narrative, which we have labeled pedagogical transformation, is new to our thinking. Although we acknowledged that every teacher would implement TEFA slightly differently , we desired to minimize the dif ferences and aspired to good implementation fidelity . Quite frankly , it was rather horrifying for us, TEFA's developers, to watch teachers such as Gina and Renee take a machete to TEFA, hacking of f parts we saw as essential in order to come to terms with it -- or , rather , in order make TEFA come to terms with them. But we have come to see such customization and personalization of TEFA as essential to the teacher learning process.Thus, one can view the model vertically (in the figure), as a progression of states and transitions, where states are defined by tensions and their consequent conflicts and struggles, and transitions are defined by changes to the teacher and her enactment of TEFA. Or , one can view it horizontally , as two ongoing narratives, one describing change in the teacher and one describing change in her understanding and enactment of the pedagogy; the narratives are connected dialectically by the tensions and dissonances between them at any point in time.c. the significance of the pedagogical transformation narrative to the teacher change process has produced a shift in our thinking that goes much deeper than simply admitting that teachers will adapt our pedagogy , and accepting it as a necessary evil of professional development. W e realized that we had implicitly been trying to recast our participating teachers in our own image, and make them our proxies in the classroom, teaching the way we would. Recognizing the necessity of the pedagogical transformation narrative in our model of the teacher change process, we are coming to think of our goal more as to help each teacher blossom in his or her own way , by providing a rich and powerful pedagogy that they can and should adapt to their own strengths, needs, and outlook. Language along these lines was always in our talk, but now we realize its implications much more deeply .(In retrospect, this should have been obvious. Even those of us closely involved in developing, refining, and articulating TEFA do not implement it identically .)This new perspective also challenges the utility of the implementation fidelity concept. Against what should a teacher's TEFA implementation be compared, if the goal is not to have all teachers approach some hypothetical ideal implementation? A canonical reference implementation may be necessary for a study that seeks to establish the student learning impacts of TEFA, but measurements of fidelity must be suitably lenient in end with some other implications for in-service teacher professional development that arise from our co-evolution model or from our general findings and experiences to
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
25/29*For PD to succeed, it must be sustained over time as teachers follow an extended process of personal change and pedagogical should be structured so that teachers have multiple entry points into the new practices, so that what they are exhorted to try does not exceed their ZPD.*Given the impact of critical events in teachers' adoption of new practices, PD should help teachers recognize seminal experiences for what they are, and to help them use evidence about those events as a way to see that their new pedagogy is sensible, beneficial, and enlightening (Feldman, 2000).*While PD should be sustained, breaks from PD (e.g., school holidays or summer vacation) can help teachers reassess their practice and reflect on the implications of what they have been learning.*PD staf f should monitor the tensions and dissonances that the teachers experience and provide strategies for eliminating or mitigating them, so that resulting conflicts and struggles do not seem insurmountable. Similarly , staf f can help teachers recognize the rewards of new high-quality curriculum (CRS questions) for TEFA has been a major difficulty and source of stress for teachers. If possible, PD should provide at least a minimal core of curriculum materials suitable for each teacher's subject and level, so teachers can become familiar with the approach without the burden of curriculum design. At the very least, a wide range of exemplary materials are necessary , varied in subject, level, style, and goals.*A PD program must strike a careful balance between careful design to address all requisite skill areas in an ef fective learning sequence, and attentive responsiveness to teachers' idiosyncratic and changing needs.*Finally , the staf f of a PD program should recognize the difficulty of communicating across disciplinary and teaching-level boundaries, and seek collaborators or other resources to help bridge gaps.d. the futureAt present, we are slightly more than half-way through the three-year intervention at our first site, still in the intensive first intervention year at our second site, and still collecting baseline data at our third and fourth sites. This means all findings herein should be considered preliminary .In the future, we will be collecting data to substantiate these findings. W e will also be modifying our PD design for sites 3 and 4, in order to take advantage of and test our co-evolution model of teacher change. With additional case study analysis, we hope to develop a more beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 description of teachers' TEFA learning pathways and stages, perhaps identifying distinct categories of teacher , common entry points, typical stumbling blocks, and the like. Further on in the project, we will turn to the development of more scalable PD and more scalable research instrumentation, as we look towards a controlled study of student learning impacts due to D. and Cohen, D. (1999). Developing practice, developing practitioners: Toward a practice-based theory of professional education. In Sykes, G. and Darling-Hammond, L., editors, Teaching as the Learning Profession: Handbook of Policy and Practice, pages 3-32. Jossey Bass, San Francisco.Banks, D. A., editor (2006). Audience Response Systems in Higher Education: Applications and Cases. Idea Group Inc., Hershey , PA.Beatty , I. D. (2004). Transforming student learning with classroom communication systems. Research Bulletin ERB0403, Educause Center for Applied Research.Beatty , I. D., Gerace, W . J., Leonard, W . J., and Dufresne, R. J. (2006a). Designing ef fective questions for classroom response system teaching. American Journal of Physics, , I. D., Leonard, W . J., Gerace, W . J., and Dufresne, R. J. (2006b). Question driven instruction: Teaching science (well) with an audience response system. In Banks, D. A., editor , Audience Response Systems in Higher Education: Applications and Cases. Idea Group Inc., Hershey , PA.Black, P ., Harrison, C., Lee, C., Marshall, B., and Wiliam, D. (2002). Working inside the black box: Assessment for learning in the classroom. King's College London Department of Education and Professional Studies, London, UK.Black, P . and Wiliam, D. (1998). Assessment and classroom learning. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 5(1):7-74.Blum, L. (1999). Ethnicity , identity , and community . In Katz, M., Noddings, N., and Strike, K., editors, Justice and Caring: The Search for Common Ground in Education. Teachers College Press.Carlsen, W . S. (2007). Language and science learning. In Abell, S. K. and Lederman, N. G., editors, Handbook of Research on Science Education, chapter 3, pages 57-74. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ.Davis, K., Feldman, A. P., Irwin, C., Pedevillano, E., Capobianco, B., and W eiss, T. (2003). Wearing the letter jacket: Legitimate participation in a collaborative science, mathematics, beatty-2008tlt2
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 and technology education reform project. School Science and Mathematics, R. J., Gerace, W . J., Leonard, W . J., Mestre, J. P ., and W enk, L. (1996). Classtalk: A classroom communication system for active learning. Journal of Computing in Higher Education, 7:3-47.Feldman, A. (1996). Enhancing the practice of physics teachers: Mechanisms for the generation and sharing of knowledge and understanding in collaborative action research. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, A. (2000). Decision making in the practical domain: A model of practical conceptual change. Science Education, A. and Capobianco, B. M. (2008). Teacher learning of technology enhanced formative assessment. Journal of Science Education and Technology, A. and Minstrell, J. (2000). Action research as a research methodology for the study of the teaching and learning of science. In Kelly , E. and Lesh, R., editors, Handbook of Research Design in Mathematics and Science Education, pages 429-455. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ.Feldman, A. P. and Capobianco, B. M. (2000). Action research in science education. Eric digest, ERIC Clearinghouse for Science, Mathematics, and Environmental Education, Columbus, OH.Fies, C. and Marshall, J. (2006). Classroom response systems: A review of the literature. Journal of Science Education and Technology, , D. (1996). More than misconceptions: Multiple perspectives on student knowledge and reasoning, and an appropriate role for education research. American Journal of Physics, , D. and Elby , A. (2003). Tapping epistemological resources for learning physics. Journal of Learning Sciences, 12:53-90.Kennedy , M. (2006). Inside Teaching: How Classroom Life Undermines Reform. Harvard University Press.Koballa, T. R. and Glynn, S. M. (2007). Attitudinal and motivational constructs in science learning. In Abell, S. K. and Lederman, N. G., editors, Handbook of Research on Science Education, chapter 4, pages 75-102. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ.Mortimer , E. F . and Scott, P . H. (2003). Meaning Making in Secondary Science Classrooms. Open University
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
28/29NEIR TEC (2004). Professional development. Technical brief 5, Northeast & The Islands Regional Technology in Education Consortium. P ., Asoki, H., and Leach, J. (2007). Student conceptions and conceptual learning in science. In Abell, S. K. and Lederman, N. G., editors, Handbook of Research on Science Education, chapter 2, pages 31-56. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ.Supovitz, J. A. and Turner , H. M. (2000). The ef fects of professional development on science teaching practices and classroom culture. Journal of Reseach in Science Teaching, Driel, J. H., V erloop, N., and de V os, W . (1998). Developing science teachers' pedagogical content knowledge. Journal of Reseach in Science Teaching, , L. S. (1978). The development of higher psychological processes. Harvard University Press.Vygotsky , L. S. (1987). Thinking and speech. In Rieber , R. W . and Carton, A. S., editors, The Collected W orks of L. S. V ygotsky. Plenum Press.Wertsch, J. V . (1991). Voices of the Mind: A Sociocultural Approach to Mediated Action. Harvard University Press.Wiliam, D. (2007). Keeping learning on track: Classroom assessment and the regulation of learning. In Lester , F. K., editor , Second Handbook of Mathematics Teaching and Learning, pages 1051-1098. Information Age Publishing, Greenwich, CT .Wilson, T. D. (2006). The power of social psychological interventions. Science,
NARST 2008 conference paper April 9, 2008 9:47 AM
29/29
|
0806.4924
|
Ian Beatty
|
Ian D. Beatty, Allan Feldman, William J. Leonard, William J. Gerace,
Karen St. Cyr, Hyunju Lee, Robby Harris
|
Teacher Learning of Technology-Enhanced Formative Assessment
|
Conference paper accompanying a special symposium presented at the
2008 Annual International Conference of the US National Association for
Research in Science Teaching (NARST), Baltimore, MD, Apr 01
| null | null |
beatty-2008tlt2
|
physics.ed-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Technology-Enhanced Formative Assessment (TEFA) is a pedagogy for teaching
with classroom response technology. Teacher Learning of TEFA is a five-year
research project studying teacher change, in the context of an intensive
professional development program designed to help science and mathematics
teachers learn TEFA. First, we provide an overview of the project's
participating teachers, its intervention (consisting of the technology, the
pedagogy, and the professional development program), and its research design.
Then, we present narratives describing the unfolding change process experienced
by four teachers. Afterward, we present some preliminary findings of the
research, describe a "model for the co-evolution of teacher and pedagogy" that
we are developing, and identify general implications for professional
development.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 30 Jun 2008 15:30:19 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-01T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Beatty",
"Ian D.",
""
],
[
"Feldman",
"Allan",
""
],
[
"Leonard",
"William J.",
""
],
[
"Gerace",
"William J.",
""
],
[
"Cyr",
"Karen St.",
""
],
[
"Lee",
"Hyunju",
""
],
[
"Harris",
"Robby",
""
]
] |
solutions of the cubic and quintic nonlinear Schr odinger equation fo r a cylindrical ge- ometry. Mihalache and Panoin [MN] used the method in [AEK] to obtain n ew solutions which describe the propagation of dark envelope soliton light pulses in optical fibers in the normal group velocity dispersion regime. Furthermore, Saied, EI- Rahman and Ghonamy [SEG] used various similarity variables to reduce the above equation t o certain equations and obtain some exact solutions. However, m any of their solutions are equivalent to each other under the action of the known symmet ry transformations of the above equation. The coupled two-dimensional cubic nonlinear Schr odinger equation 0, 0 (1 .3) are used to describe interaction of electromagnetic waves with diffe rent polarizations in nonlinear optics, where real constants. Radhakrishnan and Lak- shmanan [RL1] used Painlev' e analysis to find a Hirota bilinearization of the above system of partial differential equations and obtained bright and dark multip le soliton soutions. They also generalized their results to the coupled nonlinear Schr od inger equations effects in [RL2]. Gr' ebert and Guillot [GG] construcetd periodic solutions of coupled one-dimensional nonlinear Schr odinger equations with per iodic boundary condi- tions in some resonance situations. Moreover, Hioe and Salter [HS] f ound a Lam' e functions and solutions of the above coupled equat ems equations. Such systems can not be solved exactly with out observe that the argument functions of many known solutions f or these equations are quadratic in the spacial variables xandy, in particular, those in [SEG]. Moreover, some of these solutions are actually equivalent to each other under the L ie point symmetries equations. by imposing the quadratic condition on the related argument f unctions and using their symmetry transformations. More complete families of explicit e xact solutions of this type with multiple parameter functions are obtained. Many known int eresting solutions, such soliton ones, turn out to be special cases of our solutions. Va rious singular solutions and periodic solutions that we obtain may reflect some important phy sical phenomena in practical models. Our solutions can also be used to solve some bound ary-value problems. Below we give more details. 2For convenience, we always assume that all the involved partial der ivatives of always exist and we can change orders of taking partial d erivatives. We also use prime'to denote the derivative of any one-variable function. It is known that the equation (1.1) is invariant under the following kno wn 0. Inotherwords, (1.1)into another solution. Our solutions containall t hesolutions in[SEG] up to the above transformations. In particular, our solutions with elliptic functions were not given in [SEG]. Our approach is quite elementary and accessible to la rge audiences such as physicists and engineers. For the reader's convenience, w e list in this paper all the solutions of the equation (1.1) found by our method although some o f them are This may help to applythe solutions of theSchr odinger equation to their fields. In fact, applying the transformations in (1 .4) and (1.5) to any of our solutions will yield more sophisticated one. Similarly, we have the following known symmetric transformations of t he (1.2) and (1.3): T1(ps) (1.7) T2(ps) (1.8) T2(ph) (1 0. In addition to the above symmetries, we also solve the coupled equations modulo the following (1.10) Again for the reader's convenience, we list in this paper all the solutio ns of the (1.2) and (1.3) found by our method although some of the m are known and obvious. For convenience, we always assume that all the involved pa rtial derivatives of related functions always exist and we can change orders of taking p artial derivatives. We also use prime'to denote the derivative of any one-variable function. In Section 2, we solve the Schr odinger equation (1.1). In Section 3 , we use the results in Section 2 to solve the coupled Schr odinger equations (1.2) and (1 .3). 32 Exact Solutions of the Schr odinger Equation In this section, we will present our approach to the nonlinear Schr odinger equation (1.1) and find more exact solu tions than [SEG] in the modulo real functions in t,x,y. Note pst= (xt+ixpht)eiph, ps x= (xx+ixphx)eiph, ps y= psyy= the equation (1.1) = 0, = 0, 0. (2.6) Note that it is very difficult to solve the above system without pre-as sumptions. We observe that the functions phin all the solutions of [SEG] are quadratic in xandy. characteristics of theabove system of partialdiffer ential equations, it is most affective to assume that phis quadratic in xandy. After sorting case by case, we only have the following four cases that lead us to exact solutions, modulo the (1.4) and (1.5). Case 1.ph=b(t) is a function of t. According to (2.5), xt= 0. Moreover, (2.6) 0. (2.7) So we take b=bt+d, b,d R. (2.8) Ifb= 0 andac <0, modulo the transformations (1.4), we take d= 0 and the (2.9) 4Next we assume b/ne}ationslash= 0. Modulo the transformation (1.4), we can take d= 0. Note that (tans)''= 2sec3s-secs, Jacobi elliptic functions sns= sn(s|m),cns= cn(s|m),dns= dn(s|m), (2.12) wheremis the elliptic modulus (e.g., cf. [WG]). Then (sns)''= lim m-1dns= sechs. (2.16) Consider solutions modulo the transformation (1.4). If ac<0, we have the b= 2c; (2 b=-c; (2 b=-2c; (2 b=c; (2 b=-(1+m2)c. (2.21) Whenac>0, we get the following b= (2m2-1)c, b= (2-m2)c. (2.23) Theorem 2.1 .LetmR. solutions psof the nonlinear cubic nonlinear Schr odinger equation (1. 1): (2.26) Remark 2.2 . Although the above solution are simple, we can obtain more . Forinstance, applying the transformation (1.4) to the first solution in (2.24), we get a solu d 1,d2R. (2.27) Applying the transformation (1.5) to the above solution, we obtain a nother d 2.ph=x2/4ct+bfor some function boft. In this case, (2.5) 0. u=x t, (2.30) for some two-variable function z. Now (2.6) becomes (2.7). x yy=t-1/2zyy, x3=t-3/2z3. (2.31) So (2.7) 0, (2.32) whose coefficients of t-3/2force us to take x=b t, bR. (2.33) Now (2.7) 0 ==b=ab2lnt (2.34) 6modulo the transformation in (1.5). Case some function boftwith this case, (2.5) 0. (2.35) So we u=x t, v=y t-d, (2.36) for some two-variable function z. Again (2.6) becomes (2.7). x (2.7) 0,(2.38) whose coefficients of us to bR. (2.39) Now (2.7) 0 the transformation in (1.5). Theorem 2.3 0. The following function are solutions psof cubic nonlinear cubic nonlinear Schr odi nger 2.4 . Applying (1.4) to the above first solution, we get another Moreover, we obtain a more sophisticated (2.43) 7by applying the transformation (1.5) to (2.42), where brR. Case 4.ph= (x2+y2)/4ct+bfor some function boft. Under our assumption, (2.5) 0. (2.44) Thus we u=x t, v=y t, (2.45) for some two-variable function z. Moreover, (2.6) 0. (2.46) An obvious solution is z=d, b =-ad2 t, dR. (2.47) Ifac<0, we have the simple following solutions with b= we the transformation in (1.2), where bis a real constant to be determined. Suppose z=I(), =l1u+l2v+l3 that (0,0). Then (2.46) is equivalent 0. (2.51) According to (2.10), (2.11) and (2.13)-(2.15), we have the following solutions: If ac <0, we have the following b = 2c(l2 1+l2 2); (2 b =-c(l2 1+l2 2); (2 b =-2c(l2 1+l2 2); (2 b =c(l2 1+l2 2); (2 b (2.56) Whenac>0, we get the following b = b = (2.58) Theorem 2.5 that (0,0). The following func- tions are solutions psof the two-dimensional cubic nonlinear cubic nonlinear Sch r if 2.6 . Applying we getan Exact Solutions of the Coupled Equations In this section, we will use our results in previous section to find exac t solutions of the coupled two-dimensional cubic nonlinear Schr odinger equations (1 .2) and real functions in t,x,y. As the arguments in (2.1)-(2.6), the system (1.2) and (1.3) is equivalent to the following system for real function = 0, 0, = 0, 0. (3.5) Based on our experience in last section, we will solve the above syste m according to the following cases. For the convenience, we always assume the conditio ns on the in an expression such that it make sense. For instance, whe n we used1-d2, we naturally assume d1>=d2. Case 1. (ph,u) = (0,0) 0. In this case, xt=et= 0 by (3.2) and (3.4). Moreover, (3.3) and (3.5) 0, c e=i2 x. (3.7) Then (3.6) is equivalent 0, a 2i2+b2i2+2c2= 0. (3.8) 10Solving the above linear algebraic equations for i2 1andi2 2, we (3.9) Thus we have the following {1,-1}. Similarly, we have the 2. (ph,u) = (k1t,k2t) we have xt=et= 0 by (3.2) and (3.4). Moreover, (3.3) and (3.5) 0,-k2e+c 0.(3.12) First we assume 0 and x=i1I(x), e=i2I(x). (3.13) Then (3.12) to (2.10) and (2.11), when I= cschx, we always 0, a 2i2+b2i2+2c2= 0. (3.15) Thus foro1,o2 {1,-1}, we have the following = 2(c1,c2); =-(c1,c2); (3.18) 11and (k1,k2) = (2.13)-(2.15) give us the following e (k1,k2) (k1,k2) = e (3.22) and (k1,k2) = (a1,b1) =a1(1,d2) and(a2,b2) =a2(1,d2) withdR, we have the following solution of e=lcosx,(k1,k2) = (3.23) forlR. When (a1,b1) =a1(1,-d2) and (a2,b2) =a2(1,-d2) withdR, we get e =lsinhx,(k1,k2) = summary, we have the following theorem. Theorem 3.1 .Letd,l,mRand leto1,o2 {1,-1}. If 0, we have the following solutions of the coupled two-dimensional cubic n onlinear Schr odinger equations (1.2) and (3 ph (3 (3 ph (3.37) Remark 3.2 . Applying the symmetric transformations (1.6)-(1.9) to the above solu- tions, we can get more sophisticated ones. For instance, applying T1in (1.6) and (1.7) to (3.25) and (3.37), we (1.8) and (1.9) to (3.26), we some functions b1andb2oftand real constants dandl. First we assume u= Then (3.2) and (3.4) 0, e 0. (3 .44) for some two-variable functions ^xand ^e. On the other hand, (3.3) and (3.5) 0, (3.45) -b' 2e+c 0. (3.46) As (2.31)-(2.33), the above two equations force us to take x=k1 t, e=k2 t-l. (3.47) So (3.45) and (3.46) are implied by the (3.48) Modulo the transformation (1.6) and (1.7), we b same approach holds for 3.3 .Letd,l,k1,k2R. We have the following solutions of the cubic nonlinear Schr odinger equations ( 1.2) and (1.3) real constants d,d1andd2. In this case, (3.2) and (3.4) 0, (3.53) for some two-variable functions ^xand ^e. Again (3.3) and (3.5) become (3.45) and Moreover, they force us to take x=k1 t, (3.54) So (3.3) and (3.5) are implied by the the transformation (1.6) and (1.7), we b b 3.4 We have the of the coupled two-dimensional cubic nonlinear S chr odinger equations (1.2) (3 (3.61) Case 5. functions in the above case, we (3.63) So (3.3) and (3.5) are implied by the (3.64) Modulo the transformation (1.6) and (1.7), we b 0 b 0 b 0 andl1=l2. Therefore, we obtain: Theorem 3.5 We have the following solutions of the coupled two-dimensional cubic n onlinear Schr odinger equations (1.2) and (1.3) (3 (3.73) Case 6. For two functions u=x2+y2 4c2t+b2. (3.74) As in Case 4, (3.2) and (3.4) e=1 t^e(u,v), u=x t, v=y t. (3.75) Moreover, (3.3) and (3.5) 0, 0. (3.77) To solve the above system, we assume b1=-k1 t, b 2=-k2 t, k 1,k2R. (3.78) Then (3.77) and (3.78) are equivalent 0, 0. we set
=l1u+l2v+l3. (3.81) If (a1,b1) =a1(1,d2) and (a2,b2) =a2(1,d2) withdR, we have the following = (3.82) 17forlR. When (a1,b1) =a1(1,-d2) and (a2,b2) =a2(1,-d2) withdR, we get = 3.6 we have the following solutions of the cubic nonlinear Schr odinger equations ( 1.2) and (1.3) (3.85) if(a1,b1) we assume 0. Recall the notion in (3.81). Taking k1=k2= 0, the we have the following solutions of the system of (3.79) and (3.80) In general, we (3 .91) for some one-variable function Iandk1,k2R. Then (3.79) and (3.80) implied 0, 0. {1,-1}. Again by (2.10)-(2.15), Case 1 and Case 2, we (I,k1,k2) as snand (k1,k2) cnand (k1,k2) = (3.99) I= dnand (k1,k2) = 3.7 leto1,o2 {1,-1}. We have the of the coupled two-dimensional cubic nonlinear S chr odinger equations (1.2) (3 (3 (3 (3 (3 (3 (3 Akhmediev, V. Eleonskii and N. Kulagin, First-order exact solutio ns of the nonlinear Schr odinger equation, Teoret. Mat. Fiz. 72(1987), 183-196. [GG]B. Gr' ebert and J. Guillot, Periodic solutions of coupled nonlinear Sch r in nonlinear optics: the resonant case, Appl. Math. Lett. 9(1996), 65-68. [GW]L. Gagnon and P. Winternitz, Exact solutions of the cubic and quintic nonlinear Schr odinger equation for a cylindrical geometry, Phys. Rev. A 22(1989), 296 [HS]F. Hioe and T. Salter, Special set and solutions of coupled nonlinear S chr , J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 35(2002), no. 42, H. Ibragimov, Lie Group Analysis of Differential Equations , Volume 2, CRC Hand- book, CRC Press, 1995. [MP]D. Mihalache and N. Panoin, Exact solutions of nonlinear Schr odinge r equation for positive group velocity dispersion, J. Math. Phys. 33(1992), no. 6, Radhakrishnan and M. Lakshmanan, Bright and dark soliton solut ions to cou- pled nonlinear Schr odinger equations, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 28(1995), no. Radhakrishnan and M. Lakshmanan, Exact soliton solutions to co upled non- linear Schr odinger equations with higher-order effects, Phys. Rev. E(3) 54(1995), no. 3, Saied, R. EI-Rahman and M. Ghonamy, On the exact solution of (2 +1)- dimensional cubic nonlinear Schr odinger (NLS) equation, J. Phy. A: Math. Gen. 36(2003), Wang and D. Guo, Special functions , World Scientific, Singapore, 1998. 22
|
0806.4929
|
Xiaoping Xu
|
Xiaoping Xu
|
Quadratic-Argument Approach to Nonlinear Schrodinger Equation and
Coupled Ones
|
22pages
| null | null | null |
math-ph math.AP math.MP nlin.SI physics.optics
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The two-dimensional cubic nonlinear Schr\"{o}dinger equation is used to
describe the propagation of an intense laser beam through a medium with Kerr
nonlinearity. The coupled two-dimensional cubic nonlinear Schr\"{o}dinger
equations are used to describe interaction of electromagnetic waves with
different polarizations in nonlinear optics. In this paper, we solve the above
equations by imposing a quadratic condition on the related argument functions
and using their symmetry transformations. More complete families of exact
solutions of such type are obtained. Many known interesting solutions, such
soliton ones, turn out to be special cases of our solutions.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 30 Jun 2008 15:48:57 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-01T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Xu",
"Xiaoping",
""
]
] |
2 the annotation of personal photograph collections. Once a user has annotated a photograph its metadata is au- tomatically transferred to photographs taken at similar times and locations. For example, a user photographs a group of friends at 3:45PM. Another photograph is made at 3:47PM. Since the second photograph was taken only two minutes after the rst, it is likely that it depicts a similar scene. The system therefore transfers metadata from photograph 1 to photograph 2. Similarly, [21] proposes a method of web page metadata co-citation networks. The general idea is that if two web pages cite other web pages in common, then the probability that they share similar metadata is higher. The user can later correct and augment any mentioned systems are strongly related to col- laborative ltering [11]. Collaborative ltering systems are commonly employed in online retail systems to rec- ommend items of interest to individual users. Using the principle that similar users are more likely to items, users are recommended items that are missing from their proles but occur in the proles of similar users. The collaborative ltering process can thus be regarded as an instance of metadata propagation. If users are considered resources and their proles are considered
esource metadata, it can be said ltering systems
ecommend metadata from one resource to another based on resource similarity. A generalization of the above metadata can be made in terms of the following elements: 1. A mechanism to generate resource relations, i.e. as- sess their similarity. 2. The determination of a metadata-rich subset of the repository's collection that can serve as a A means of propagating metadata from reference set to a of the collection using the established re- source relations as a substrate. Such systems for the generation of metadata can be said to operate on a Robin Hood principle; they take from metadata-rich resources and give to with the exception that metadata is not a zero-sum resource. This mode of operation has a number of desirable properties. First, it reduces the need for the costly generation of metadata; metadata is from an existing metadata-rich to a metadata-poor subset. Second, can be dened independent of content and metadata extrapolation can thus be implemented for wide range of heterogeneous resources, e.g. audio, video, and images.This article outlines a proposal for a metadata prop- agation system designed for scholarly repositories that takes advantage of the multiple means by which two resources can be related (e.g. co-citation, citation, co- author, co-keyword, etc.). Figure 1 presents the outline of the proposed system's components and First, resource metadata is extracted from the collection of a repository. Second, an network (i.e. a directed labeled graph) of resource relations is derived from a subset of the available metadata. Third, a metadata-rich subset of the collection is selected to serve as a reference data set. Fourth, and nally, metadata is propagated (i.e. extrap- olated) from the metadata-rich reference set to all resources over the associative network of resources after which the repository is updated. Human validation can vet the results of the before insertion into the repository occurs. 5. update metadata-poor Network extract resource metadata2. generate associative network3. provide and existingresource metadata5. propagate metadatato metadata-poor 1: System outline It is important to emphasize that this system requires the existence of some preliminary metadata both for the construction of resource relations and for Furthermore, the quality or accuracy of the preliminary metadata is important in results (i.e. to avoid a garbage in, garbage out scenario). However, the metadata being propagated can be di erent from the metadata used to relations. For instance, in the the propagation of keyword metadata may be most ecient along resource relations derived from citation metadata. Therefore, two aspects a ect the eciency of metadata propagation: the type of and the algorithm used to propagate metadata. It is important to note that no new metadata values are created in model proposed in this article. While it is important for resources to maintain metadata, this method only propagates pre-existing metadata values and thus, does not increase the discriminatory aspects that metadata should and generally provides. While like resources should have similar metadata, also exist to make sure that a resource's the unique characteristics of the resource.3 This paper will rst discuss two algorithms to dene sets of resource relations and represent these relations in terms of associative networks. It will then formally dene a metadata propagation algorithm which can operate on the basis of the generated resource relations. Finally, the proposed metadata generation system is validated using a modied version of the KDD Cup 2003 bibliographic dataset (hep-th 2003)[30]. While it is theoretically possible for this method to work on other resource types (e.g. video, audio, etc.) as it doesn't require an analysis of the content of the resources, only their metadata; it is only speculated that the results of such a method would be viable in these other, CONSTRUCTING AN OF REPOSITORY RESOURCES An associative network is a network that according to some measure of similarity. An associative network is represented by the data structureG= (N;E;W ) whereNis the set of set of directed resources, and Wis the set of weight values for all edges such that jWj=jEj. Any edge ei;j;
with corresponding weight wi;j; expresses that there exists a directed weighted relationship constructed using properties of type from resource nito resource nj. The explicit representation of is necessary because an associative network can be constructed according to di erent properties (i.e. authorship, citations, key- words, etc.). As will be demonstrated, certain are better (in terms of precision and recall) at propagating certain property types than others. The remainder of this section will describe two asso- ciative network construction algorithms. One is metadata where a resource is to another if there is a direct reference from one resource to the other (e.g. a direct citation). The other algorithm is based on co-occurrence metadata and thus, considers two resources to be similar if they share similar metadata. That is, two resources are deemed similar if the same metadata values occur in both their properties (i.e. same authors, same keywords, same publication venue, etc.). Depending on how the repository represents its metdata some property types will be direct reference properties and others will have to be infered through indirect, co-occurence algorithms. A. Occurrence Associative Networks An associative network can be constructed if connect one resource to another. The WorldWide Web, for instance, is an associative network based on occurrence data because a web-page makes a direct reference to another web-page via a hyper-link (i.e. the href HTML tag). For manuscript information usually exists in citations. For instance, if resource nireferences (i.e. cites) resource njthen their exists an edge ei;j;cite. One for determining the edge weight is to rst determine how many other citations resource nicur- rently maintains. That is, if resource nialso cites 50 other resources then resource niis1 50as similar Similarly, if resource nionly the strength of tie to resource 1:0. The general equation is dened by Eq. II A where the function meta( ni;cite) returns the set of all citations for resource ni. This equation only holds if resource Eq. II A makes use of the notation in order to generalize the equation for use with any direct reference property running time of the algorithm to construct an associative network based on direct, occurrence prop- erty types is O(N) since each resource must be checked once and only once for direct reference to other resources. B. Co-occurrence Associative networks are created when resources share the same metadata property values. For instance, if two resources share the same keyword, author, or ci- tation values then there exists some degree of similarity. For a co-occurrence network the edge weight for any two resources, is a function of the amount of metadata properties of type in common. A specic example of this could be a co-keyword associative network created when two resources have similar keywords. For example, suppose the resource nodes niandnjhave the following list of keyword properties presented in Table I. resource keyword-1 keyword-2 metadata particle nj images repository metadata TABLE I: Keyword metadata for resources niandnj In Table I, resource niandnjshare two keywords in common, namely repository and metadata . The edge weight between these two resources is a function of the amount of keywords they share in common,4 Eq. II B, and the size of the keyword count of both resources. Therefore, according to Eq. II B, the edges connecting resource a =wnj;ni;cokey = 0:5. co(ni;nj;) = that the co-occurrence algorithm in Eq. II B returns a co representation. This means for the returned weight is a co-keyword Similarly, for authorship metadata, the returned weight is a co-authorship weight. The running time of the algorithm to construct a co-occurrence since each resource's -properties must be checked against every other resource's except itself ( N), once and only once (1 2). III. METADATA PROPAGATION the metadata for a of resources is dependent not only on the associative network data structure, but also upon the use of a metadata propagation algorithm. The algorithm chosen is a derivative of the particle-swarm algorithm [22]. Particle-swarm algorithms are a discrete form of the spreading activation algorithms [2, 3, 4, 5, 12]. are indivisible entities, it is easy to properties as being encapsulated inside a particle. These metadata particles are then propagated over the edges of the associative network. Upon reaching a resource node that is missing a particular property type, the particle recommends its property value to the visited resource. This section will formally describe the metadata propagation algorithm before discussing the results of an experiement using a bibliographic dataset. Every resource node in an associative network is supplied with a single particle, pi2P, such that jPj=jNj. The particle piencapsulates all the meta- data properties of a particular resource ni. for all. Particle pihas a reference to its current node ci2Nsuch that at t= 0, ci=ni. The particle pibegins its journey ( t= 0) at its home node, ni, and traverses an outgoing edge of ni. Particle edge traversal is a stochastic process that requires the outgoing edge weights of each node to form a probability distribution. Therefore, the set of outgoing edge weights of relation type forni, out(ni;), must be normalized as represented in Eq. III and Eq. III. Unlike Eq. II B, for co-occurrence edges, these equationsdo not guarantee that 1:0 The function (out(ni;)) is dened such that it takes a set of outgoing edges of relation type of a single node njbased upon the outgoing edge weight probability distribution, where is how a particle traverses an associative network. The particle pialso has an associated energy value
i2[0;1]. Each time an edge is traversed, the particle pi decays its energy content, i, according to a global Particle energy decay over discrete timetis represented in Eq. III. The rational for decay is based on the intuition that the metadata property values of a particular particle become less relevant the further the particle travels away from its source node (ciatt= 0). Therefore, the further a particle travels in the network, the more that particle's energy value in
uence), , is decayed.
i(t+ 1) = (1 )i(t) The energy value of a particle denes how much rec- ommendation in
uence a particle's metadata property values has on a visited metadata-poor node. Each time a particle traverses a node with missing metadata prop- erties, it not only recommends its metadata property values to that node, but also increments the value with its current energy value i. In Figure 2, att= 0, before the propagation algorithm has been executed, resource n3has no keyword values. Therefore, when particle p1reachesn3att= 1, particle p1recom- mends its keyword property values (keyword= to noden3with an in
uence of 1= 0:85. Att= 2, particle p2, with2= 0:723, recommends its keyword property (keyword= fswarmg) to node n3. Notice that the recommendation of the keyword property value `swarm' is reinforced each time that property value is presented to n3. The function of a single particle, pi, at a is represented in pseudo-code in Algorithm 1 where rec( nj;) returns the set of previous property values tonjfor a property of type t=2keyword property keyword = 0.723 e1 = 0.85keyword propertykeyword n3 t=0keyword property n3 FIG. 2: Particles recommending metadata information to a metadata-poor node Input : recommendMeta( the metadata of njfor all property types; 1 foreach ( property) do 2
# rst ensure that njis metadata-poor at the particular 0) then 4
# update the metadata-poor node's -property with 5 theproperty value of pi; foreach (x2meta(pi;))do 6 found =false ; 7
# if property value already exists, increment its 8 energy value with ei; foreach (y2rec(nj;))do 9 if(x== value(y))then 10 energy(y) = energy( y) +i; 11 found =true; 12 end 13 end 14
# if no recommended value exists, add to nj's then 16 addRec(x;i) =x; 17 end 18 end 19 end 20 end 21 Algorithm 1 : values to nj If Algorithm 1 is called recommendMeta( nj;pi) then the full particle propagation algorithm can be described by the pseudo-code in Algorithm 2. The process of moving metadata particles through the associative net- work and recommending metadata-poor nodes values continues until some desired tis reached or all particle energy in the network has decayed to 0 AN EXPERIMENT USING THE 2003 HEP-TH BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATASET This section will present the results of the generation system when attempting to recon- struct an articially atrophied bibliographic dataset.Input : propagate( )
#is a global energy decay value ; 1
= 0:15 ; 2
# create a particle for each node ;3 foreach (ni2N)do 4 meta(pi;) = meta(ni;) :8; 5
i= 1:0 ; 6 ci=ni; 7 end8
# propagate metadata particles throughout network ; 9 t= 0 ; 10 while (P 8pi2Pi>0:0 &&t<maxSteps) do 11 foreach (pi2P)do 12
# ifcihas no outgoing edges, freeze the particle ; ; 15
i=i(1 ) ; 16
# do not recommend metadata to the particle's 17 home node ; if(ci! =ni)then ci;pi) ; 19 end 20 end 21 end 22 t=t+ 1 ; 23 end 24 Algorithm 2 : Propagating metadata an associative network of type
By articially reducing the amount of metadata in the full bibliographic dataset, it is possible to simulate a metadata-poor environment and at the same time still be able to validate the results of the metadata The section is outlined as follows. First, the dataset used for this experiment is described. Second, a short review of the validation metrics (precision, recall, and F-score) is presented. Third, the various are discussed. Finally, the results of the experiment are presented as a validation of the systems use for manuscript-based digital library research into other domains besides manuscripts will demonstrate the validity of this method for other resource types. The dataset used to validate the proposed system is a modied version of the hep-th 2003 for high energy physics and theory [19].[31] A modied version of the hep-th dataset, as used in [16], is represented as a semantic network (29,014), authors (12,755), journals (963), keywords (40), and publication date in year/season pairs (60). These nodes are then connected according to the following authorawrote manuscript m
date published(m,d): manuscript mwas published on of(a,o): authoraworks for in(m,j): manuscript mwas published manuscript mxcites manuscript my
keyword of(m,k): manuscript mhas keyword k For the purposes of this experiment, the semantic net- work from [16] was transformed into a list of manuscripts and their associated metadata property These manuscript properites include: authors, date of publication, citations, keywords, and organizations. Of the 29,014 di erent occurrence and co-occurrence algorithms were used to construct the following associative networks: 1. citation: manuscript mimaintains an edge to manuscript edges) 2. co-author: manuscripts maintain an edge if they share authors (724,406 edges) 3. co-citation: manuscripts maintain an edge if they share citations (23,089,616 edges) 4. co-keyword: manuscripts maintain an edge if they share keywords (12,418,172 edges) 5. co-organization: manuscript maintain an edge if they share organizations (33,947,083 edges) Though not explored empirically, it is worth noting that link prediction algorithms can be employed to resolve issues relating to edge sparsity in the network. In particular, the methods proposed in [15] and [13] are such algorithms. A. A Review of Precision, Recall, and F-Score The results of the metadata generation experiment are evaluated according to the F-score measure so therefore, it is important to provide a quick review of precision , recall , and F-score within the framework of the thus far. For a particular property , precision is dened as the amount of property values of type
received that were relevant relative to the total number of property values retrieved overall. This is represented in Eq. IV A where the function rec( ni;) returns the set of recommended property values for resource niof type
, while meta( ni;) returns the set properties values of typepreviously existing for resource ni. Since the validation is against an articially atrophied resource set, the recommended property values are checked against the previously existing property values (prior to articial atrophy).Pr() Eq. IV A, on the other hand, is dened as the proportion of relevant property values received to the total amount of relevant property values possible. For example, if resource nipreviously (before had the property value keyword= fswarmgand is recommended the property value keyword= fswarmg, then there is a 100% recall. On the other hand, if resource nipreviously had the property networkgand is recommended the property value keyword= fswarmg, then there is a 50%
recall, whereas its precision is 100% in both cases. Re() and recall tend to be inversely This inverse relationship is understood best when examining the extreme cases. If every possible property value was provided to a ), and that resource originally only had one property value ( jmeta(ni;)j= 1) then the recall would be 100% while the precision would be near 0%. At the opposite extreme, if a resource previously had every possible property value in its original ! 1 ) and was recommend only one property value ( jrec(ni;)j= 1), then the precision would be 100%, but the recall would be near 0%. While, in some systems, precision and recall can be it is the goal of information retrieval systems that are validated according to this criterion to achieve both high precision and recall values. Finally, F-score, Eq. IV A, can be used to and recall into a single measure. Note that di erent associative networks will perform di erently for di erent property types. For instance, will, intuitively, preform better at propa- gating keyword values than co-organization the F-score measure will be represented as F(x;y) in order to express the F-score of a network created from metadata properties of type values of type x. Precision and recall can be represented in a similar fashion though the results of the experiment to follow are expressed according to the F-score measure only. F(x;y) +Re(x)7 B. Experiment Parameters The experiment was set up to deter- mine various F-scores, F(x;y), where
x2 f This means that for every type of associative network generated, an F-score for each metadata property type was deter- mined. Since the hep-th 2003 bibliographic dataset is a metadata-rich dataset, it was necessary to destroy a percentage of the metadata to test whether or not the metadata generation algorithm could reconstruct the property values for the selected Therefore, the tunable parameter, was created. The density of the network metadata ranges from 1% of the network metadata to 99% of the resources. Given the percentage parameter, resources were randomly selected for atrophy before the metadata propagation algorithm was run. With the potential for 99% of the network the propagation of metadata to the lacking 1% would be overwhelming (a high recall with a low pre- cision). In order to allow nodes to regulate the amount of metadata property values they accept, a second parameter exists. The percentile parameter, the energy threshold for property Since each rec( ni;) entry has an associated energy value (recommendation in
uence), a range from 0thpercentile, meaning all provided property values are accepted to 100thpercentile, meaning only the top energy property value is accepted, is used. The pseudo-code for the experimental set-up is presented in Algorithm 3. In Algorithm 3, killMeta(), calculateF() do not have accompanying pseudo-code. The general expected trend is that as the density of the network increases, the recall increases and the precision decreases. With more property values any metadata-poor record, on average, will receive more recommendations than are needed. For instance, a manuscript only has one publishing a recommendation of 100 journals is going to yield a very low precision (0 :01). To balance this e ect, a percentile increase will tend to increase the precision of the algorithm at the expense of recall. When only the highest energy recommendations are accepted, the probability of rejecting a useful In the case of journal propagation, if only the 100thpercentile recommendation is accepted, then only the highest energy recommendation is accepted. If this journal recommendation is the correct then there is 100% recall and precision. If not, then there is 0% recall and precision. Depending on the amount of values needed to ll a particular will be most suitable than others.Input : experiment()
# run the metadata propagation algorithm for network type ; foreach do 2 loadNetwork( y) ; 3 foreach do 4
# atrophy a randomly selected percentage of the 5 network ; for(@= 0:01; @ < 1:0; @=@+ 0:2)do 6 killMeta(1 @) ; 7 propagateMeta( x) ; 8
# allow metadata-poor resources to accept only a 9 certain percentage of their recommended property values ; for(= 0:0; < = 1:0; =+ 0:1)do 10 acceptMeta( ) ; ; 12 end 13 end 14 end 15 end 16 Algorithm 3 : Determining the F-score for the various experimental parameters C. The Results This section presents the results of the previously in Algorithm 3. For every type and for every metadata type, a F-score ma- trix was determined for every combination of These F-score values were calculated as the average over 20 di erent runs of the II and III provide the max and mean F-scores for each network/metadata pair over the entire @/set. Note that the bold faced values are those x/ypairs for which a landscape plot is provided. The italicized values are experimental anomalies since the same metadata that was used to generate the associative network is also the same metadata being propagated. For all metadata of a particular type exists to create an associative network and metadata properties of a di erent type is being propagated over those edges. For instance, a co-authorship network is used to propagate citation property values. The following landscape plots expose the A short explanation of the intuition behind each plot is also it makes sense that a would perform well when propagating keyword, and organization property values which are represented in Figure 3a, Figure 3b, Figure 4a, Figure 4b respectively. The performance is a result of the fact that collaborating authors tend to cite themselves, publish in similar journals, write about similar topics, and are within similar the e ect that percentile ( ) has on Figure 3a as opposed to Figure 3b. Since there tend to author citation date journal keyword 0.1829 0.1757 0.0606 0.2438 0.3913 0.2782 co-author 0.6218 0.1300 0.0717 0.2630 0.2795 0.0770 0.1821 0.0780 0.2081 0.2213 0.0073 0.0248 0.0472 0.1904 0.8689 0.0709 0.0236 0.0508 0.1918 0.1180 0.5000 TABLE II: Max author citation date journal keyword 0.1367 0.1327 0.0441 0.2133 0.3246 0.2218 co-author 0.2848 0.0780 0.0548 0.2004 0.1958 0.0338 0.0697 0.0539 0.1554 0.1509 0.0032 0.0160 0.0385 0.1468 0.3240 0.0312 0.0145 0.0392 0.1410 0.0909 0.1554 TABLE III: Mean 3: Co-authorship network propagating a.citation F(cite;coauth) and b.journal F(jour;coauth) metadata many citation property values (manuscripts cite lower percentile values ( 0) ensures that there is a high recall. When = 1:0, only the top citation is accepted and therefore the F-score drops (very poor recall). On the other other hand, in Figure 4, when= 0:0, there are many journal is not desirable since a journal property only has one value (a manuscript is published in only one at = 1:0, only one journal value is accepted into the resource's journal property. In situations where few property values are expected, the F-score is best with a high . A co-citation network, Figure 5, performs best with journal and keyword properties. This means that manuscripts are likely to cite other manuscripts with similar journal venues and since citation tends to be within the same subject domain, the probability of similar keyword metadata increases. Again, notice the e ect ofon journal metadata propagation. The shape of the Figure 5a graph nearly mimics the shape of Figure 3b. Likewise, for Figure 5b and Figure 4a. Again, the expected property value number is a major factor in determining the system's parameter. A citation network, like a co-citation network performs well for author, journal, keyword, and Figure 6 and Figure 8. It is interesting to note how much better a citation network works for
0:0. Since a citation network isn't symmetric, there is a chance that a particle will reach a dead end. When a particle reaches a dead end, it no property values. Furthermore, citations are in a hierarchy with more recent publications being at the top of the hierarchy (manuscripts can not cite forward in time). Particles therefore trickle down the hierarchy via a single, non-recurrent path from top to bottom. This plinko ball e ect is represented in Figure 7. The lack of recurrence in citation networks tends to produce a high precision with a lower recall. High precision and low recall is exactly what a low produces. Therefore, since the topology of the citation network yields the same e ect, the e ect of as!0:0 isn't as pronounced. As can be noticed from Table II, Table III, and Figure 8a, the keyword property performs best in a A direct reference from one document to an- other is a validation of the similarity between documents with respect to subject domain. Therefore, the tendency for citing documents to contains similar keyword values is high. For instance, refer to the citations of this in this manuscript's bibliography). Every cited manuscript is either about automatic bibliographic networks, or network 4: Co-authorship network propagating a.keyword F(key;coauth) and b.organization F(org;coauth) 5: Co-citation network propagating a.journal F(jour;cocite) and b.keyword F(key;cocite) 6: Citation network propagating a.author F(auth ;cite) and b.journal F(jour;cite) properties A co-keyword network does not perform well for most property types except the journal property, Figure 9a. This makes sense since manuscripts on similar topics are likely to be published in similar journals. V. FUTURE WORK This paper has provided a preliminary exploration of metadata generation in terms of metadata within an associative network of Further research in this area may prove useful for other network types such as those generatedfrom other metadata properties. For instance, it may be of interest to study the e ect of this algorithm on usage networks [1]. Usage metadata, unlike citation and journal metadata, is applicable to every It would be interesting to see what co-usage means for a particular genera of resources by metadata properties these networks are best variety of propagation algorithms may also be explored. It is assumed that a particle will take only edges of a particular type for the duration of their life-span. Di erent path types might be an important aspect of increasing the precision and recall performance of this method. For instance, keyword metadata past FIG. 7: Citation networks are non-recurrent networks rst propagates over co-authorship edges and then over co-citation edges might provide better results. Methods to implement such propagation algorithms have been presented in [22, 23]. Also, di erent edge types can be merged such that all co-keyword and are collapsed to form a single edge. What has been presented in this study is the results of this algorithm without the intervention of any human components (besides the initial creation of metadata through the hep-th dataset creation process). Future work that studies this method with the inclusion of hu- mans that help to validate and clean the would be telling of how much this method is able to speed up the process of generating accurate and reliable metadata for metadata-poor resources. Such an analysis is left to future multiplicative e ects due to particle interac- tion may e ect the results of the algorithm. For instance, if two particles, piandpj, meet at a particular node, nk, andpiandpjhave similar metadata then the foot- print they leave at nkshould be more noticeable. Be- cause two di erent metadata sources are supplying the same property values, there is an increased probability of that recommended metadata value being correct. Cur- rently, only a summation is being provided. It may be interesting to multiply this summation by the number of unique particles that provided energy for a particu- lar recommended metadata value. The variations of this preliminary framework will be explored in future work. VI. metadata generation is becoming an increasingly important eld of research as digital become more prevalent and move into thearena of less strongly controlled, decentralized arXiv and CiteSeer). The creation and mainte- nance of high-quality, detailed metadata is hampered on numerous levels. Manual metadata creation methods are costly. Recent e orts to leverage the collective power of social tagging (i.e. olksonomies) may address some of the shortcomings of the manual creation of metadata and result in viable models for online resources that do not require strongly controlled vocabularies and However, it is doubtful that be generalized to situations that require metadata. The automated creation of metadata on the basis of content-analysis is a to the manual creation of metadata. It is conceivably more ecient in situations where textual data is available and allows for more formal control of the type and nature of metadata that is it can be unreliable for non-text resources, yield low-quality metadata and can be article proposed another possible component of the metadata generation toolkit which may complement and support the above mentioned approaches. Instead of creating new metadata, metadata is propagated from a metadata-rich subset of the collection to similar, subsets. The substrate for this extrapo- lation is an associative network of resource relations cre- ated from other available metadata. Metadata propa- gation may provide a computationally feasible means of generating large amounts of metadata for which can later be ne-tuned by manual inter- vention or cross-validation with content-based methods. The article nally provided experimental results using the High-Energy Physics bibliographic data set (hep-th 2003). Human intervention may play an important role in ne-tuning the metadata propagation algorithm. The results of this experiment are promising and there still exists a range of potential modications to this basic framework that may lead to even better results. VII. research was nancially supported by the Re- search Library at the Los Alamos National Laboratory. The modied hep-th 2003 bibliographic dataset was generously provided by Shou-de Lin and Jennifer H. Watkins provided editorial assistance. Finally, the hep-th 2003 database is based on data from the arXiv archive and the Stanford Linear Accelerator database provided for the 2003 KDD Cup competition with additional preparation performed by the Knowledge Discovery Laboratory, University of Massachusetts 8: Citation network propagating a.keyword F(key;cite) and b.organization F(org;cite) 9: Co-keyword and co-organization networks propagating a.journal F(jour;cokey) and b.F(jour;coorg) Johan Bollen, Herbert Van de Sompel, Joan Smith, and Rick Luce. Toward alternative metrics of journal impact: a comparison of download and citation data. and Management , 41(6):1419{1440, 2005. [2] Paul R. Cohen and Rick Kjeldsen. Information re- trieval by constrained spreading activation in seman- tic networks. Information Processing and Management , 23(4):255{268, 1987. [3] A.M. Collins and E.F. Loftus. A spreading activation the- ory of semantic processing. Psychological Review , 82:407{
428, 1975. [4] Fabio Crestani. Application of spreading activation tech- niques in information retrieval. Articial Intelligence Re- view, 11(6):453{582, 1997. [5] Fabio Crestani and Puay Leng Lee. Searching the web by constrained spreading activation. Information Processing and Management , 36(4):585{605, 2000. [6] Erik Duval, Wayne Hodgins, Stuart Sutton, and Stu- art L. Weibel. Metadata principles and practices. D-Lib Magazine , 8(4), 2002. [7] G. Giurida and J. Shek, E. Yang. Knowledge-based meta- data extraction from postscript le. In Proceedings of Conference on Digital Libraries , pages 77{
84. ACM, May 2000. [8] Scott A. Golder and Bernardo A. Huberman. Usage pat- terns of collaborative tagging systems. Journal of Infor- mation Science , 32(2):198{208, 2006. [9] Jane Greenburg. Metadata extraction and harvesting:A comparison of two automatic metadata generation ap- plications. Journal of Internet Cataloging , Hui Han, C. Lee Giles, Eren Manavoglu, and Hongyuan Zha. Automatic document metadata extraction using support vector machines. In Proceedings of the Joint Conference on Digital Libraries (JCDL03) , Huston, TX, May 2003. ACM. [11] Johnathan L. Herlocker, Joseph A. Konstan, Loren G. Terveen, and John T. Riedl. Evaluating recommender systems. ACM Transactions on Information Systems , 22(1):5{53, 2004. [12] Zan Huang, Hsinchun Chen, and Daniel Zeng. retrieval techniques to alleviate the sparsity problem in collaborative ltering. ACM Trans. Inf. Syst. , 22(1):116{142, 2004. [13] Zan Huang, Xin Li, and Hsinchun Chen. Link to collaborative ltering. In Proceedings of the Joint Conference on Digital Libraries (JCDL05) , Denver, CO, June 2005. ACM. [14] H. Kuwano, Y. Matsuo, and K. Kawazoe. Reducing the cost of metadata generation by using video/audio index- ing and natural language processing techniques. NTT Technical Review , pages 68{74, 2004. [15] David Liben-Nowell and Jon Kleinberg. The link predic- tion problem for social networks. In Twelfth on Information and Knowledge Management , pages 556{559. ACM, November 2003.12 [16] Shou-de Lin and Hans Chalupsky. Issues of verication for unsupervised discovery systems. In KDD04 Workshop on Link Discovery , Seattle, WA, 2004. [17] Song Mao, Jong Woo Kim, and George R. Thoma. A dynamic feature generation system for automated meta- data extraction in preservation of digital materials. In First International Workshop on Document Image Anal- ysis for Libraries DIAL'04 . IEEE, January 2004. [18] Adam Mathes. Folksonomies - cooperative communication through shared metadata. Com- puter Mediated Communication - LIS590CMC December 2004. [19] A. McGovern, L. Friedland, M. Hay, B. Gallagher, A. Fast, J. Neville, and D. Jensen. Exploiting to understand publication patterns in high- energy physics. ACM SIGKDD Explorations Newsletter , 5(2):165{172, December 2003. [20] Mor Naaman, Ron B. Yeh, Hector Garcia-Molina, and Andreas Paepcke. Leveraging context to resolve identity in photo albums. In Proceedings of the 5th Joint Confer- ence on Digital Libraries (JCDL 05) , Denver, CO, June 2005. [21] Camille Prime-Claverie, Michel Beigbeder, and Thierry Lafouge. Metadata propagation in the web using co- citations. In Proceedings of the 2005 IEEE/ACM In- ternational Conference on Web Intelligence , of Technology, France, September 2005. IEEE Computer Society. [22] Marko A. Rodriguez. Social decision making with networks and grammar-based particle of the Hawaii International Conference on Systems Science , pages 39{49, Waikoloa, Hawaii, Jan- uary 2007. IEEE Computer Society. [23] Marko A. Rodriguez. Grammar-based random walk- ers in semantic networks. Knowledge-Based Systems , 21(7):727{739, 2008. [24] Fabrizio Sebastiani. Machine learning in automated ACM Computing Surveys , Jewel Ward. A quantitative analysis of unqualied dublin core metadata element set usage within data with the open archives initiative. In JCDL '03: Proceedings of the 3rd ACM/IEEE-CS joint con- ference on Digital libraries , pages 315{317, Washington, DC, USA, 2003. IEEE Computer Society. [26] Hsin-Chang Yang and Chung-Hong Lee. generation for web pages using a text mining approach. In International Workshop on Challenges in Web Information Retrieval and Integration , pages 186{
194. IEEE, April 2005. [27] The Dublin Core 1.1 specication is available The most frequently used are creator ,identier ,title, date, and type. [29] CiteSeer available at: hep-th 2003 available The details of how the hep-th dataset was cre- ated can be found in the disseminated of the data set and a few specics are quoted here: Object and link properties such as title, authors, journal (if published), and various dates were extracted from the abstract les with additional date information coming from the slacdates Because institutions were often not presented in a consistent format, the email domain of the submitter (if available) was used as a surrogate for many authors had no associated email address, domain information is not available for all authors. Con- solidation was performed on journal names, domains, and author names. A nominal amount of hand-cleaning to correct spelling or formatting problems was also performed.
|
0807.0023
|
Marko A. Rodriguez
|
Marko A. Rodriguez, Johan Bollen, Herbert Van de Sompel
|
Automatic Metadata Generation using Associative Networks
| null |
ACM Transactions on Information Systems, volume 27, number 2,
pages 1-20, ISSN: 1046-8188, ACM Press, February 2009
|
10.1145/1462198.1462199
|
LA-UR-06-3445
|
cs.IR cs.DL
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
In spite of its tremendous value, metadata is generally sparse and
incomplete, thereby hampering the effectiveness of digital information
services. Many of the existing mechanisms for the automated creation of
metadata rely primarily on content analysis which can be costly and
inefficient. The automatic metadata generation system proposed in this article
leverages resource relationships generated from existing metadata as a medium
for propagation from metadata-rich to metadata-poor resources. Because of its
independence from content analysis, it can be applied to a wide variety of
resource media types and is shown to be computationally inexpensive. The
proposed method operates through two distinct phases. Occurrence and
co-occurrence algorithms first generate an associative network of repository
resources leveraging existing repository metadata. Second, using the
associative network as a substrate, metadata associated with metadata-rich
resources is propagated to metadata-poor resources by means of a discrete-form
spreading activation algorithm. This article discusses the general framework
for building associative networks, an algorithm for disseminating metadata
through such networks, and the results of an experiment and validation of the
proposed method using a standard bibliographic dataset.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 30 Jun 2008 21:23:28 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Sat, 7 Mar 2009 01:20:48 GMT"
}
] | 2009-03-07T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Rodriguez",
"Marko A.",
""
],
[
"Bollen",
"Johan",
""
],
[
"Van de Sompel",
"Herbert",
""
]
] |
- 2 - 1. Introduction The formation of galaxies is a classic problem in astrophysics. Contem porary galaxy formation models combine the well-established L Cold Dark Matter (LC DM) cosmology, which describes behavior of dark matter on very large scales, with b aryonic physics to model galaxy formation. In the early Universe, pockets of dark matter d ecoupled from the Hubble flow, collapsed into virialized halos, and then clustered hierarchically in to larger gas aggregated in the interiors of the halos to form rota ting disks, which are the building blocks of galaxies (Steinmetz & Navarro 2002; Cole et al. 2 000). Such disks are typically destroyed during major mergers of galaxies with mass r atioM1/M2>1/4 (e.g. Steinmetz & Navarro 2002; Naab & Burkert 2003; Burkert & Naab 2 004; Mihos & Hernquist 1996). When the mass ratio is close to unity, the remnant is a sphero id with properties close to that of a classical bulge, namely a steep de Vaucouleurs r1/4surface brightness profile and a high ratio of motion ( v/s). We shall return to this point in SS5. Within this hierarchical framework, the disk of spiral galaxies forms when gas of higher specific angular momentum subsequently accretes around the bulg e (Steinmetz & Navarro 2002; Burkert & Naab simulations of galaxy formation face several challenge s. One issue is problem; simulated scalele ngths and, & D'Onghia 2004; D'Onghia et al. 2006). A second issue is the p roblem of bulgeless or low bulge-to-total mass ratio ( B/T) spirals. Within the LCDM paradigm, galaxies that had a past major merger at a time when its mass was a fairly large frac tion of its present- day mass are expected to have a significant bulge with large B/Tand high S' ersic index. Depending on the merger history and hence the fraction of spiral g alaxies that fulfill this criterion (see SS5.8) we can end up with a small or large fraction of present-day galax ies is rising evidence that low B/Tand bulgeless galaxies are quite common in the local Universe, especially in low mass or late-type galaxies. Late-typ e Sd galaxies often harbor no bulge (B oker et al. 2002). Kautsch et al. (2006) and Ba razza, Jogee & Marinova (2007, 2008) also find from the analysis of several thousand late- type SDSS galaxies that 15-20% of such disk galaxies out to z~0.03 appear bulgeless. Of the 19 local galaxies (D <8 Mpc) with circular velocity Vc>150 km s-1, 11 (58%) have pseudobulges instead of merger-built classical bulges (Kormendy & Fisher work by Koda et al. (2007) conclude the survival of dis k-dominated systems in a LCDM universe is compatible with observational constraints prov ided classical bulges form only in mergers where M1/M2>0.3 and the primary halo has virial velocity Vvir>- 3 - 55 km s-1. Evidence alsosuggests B/TandlowS' ersic index in high mass and/or early-type spirals. Balcells et al. (2003) rep ort that early-type disk galaxies tend to have n <3 and often from 1 to 2. Laurikainen et al. (2007) find barred and unbarred early-type disk galaxies to have mean B/Tbetween 0.25 and 0.35, while later Hubble types have B/T <0.2; they also find mean bulge S' ersic indices to be ~2.5 or less across the Hubble sequence. Graham & Worley (2008) report lo wB/Dratios across the Hubble sequence based on bulge-disk decomposition of K-band images of local spiral galaxies. They suggest that these low values are problematic for LC DM simulations, but no quantitative assessment of the extent of the problems is present ed. These emerging statistics on the fraction of bulgeless ( B/T~0) galaxies, and galaxies with low B/Tand lownbulges provide important first constraints. More work is needed to fully explore the the distribution of bulge properties in both high and lo w mass galaxies. In particular, we need to explore how the observed distributions of bu the predictions from LCDM-based simulations of galaxy evolution . To the best of our knowledge, few such quantitative comparisons have been atte mpted, so that it remains unclear how serious the problem of low B/Tgalaxies is. This study is an attempt to derive robust observational constraints on bulge properties in high mass spirals and to attempt such a comparison with resolving the issue of low B/Tsystems will require understanding the differ- ent types of bulges and their formation pathways. Bulges are comm only divided in several groups: classical bulges, boxy/peanut bulges, and 'pseudobulges ' or disky bulges. Classi- cal bulges are believed to be built by major mergers ( M1/M2>=1/4) and the relaxation of stars. They are associated with modest-to-h igh bulge S' ersic indices, in the range 2 < n <6 (Hopkins et al. 2008; Springel et al. 2005; Robertson et al. 2006; SS5.8). Boxy/peanut bulges are believed to be the result of vertical r esonances and in bars, which are viewed at high inclination (Combes & Sande rs 1981; Combes et al. 1990; Pfenniger & Norman 1990; Bureau & Athanassoula 2005 ; Athanassoula etal.2006). gas inflow into the central kiloparsec and subsequent star form ation building a compact disky, high v/sstellar component (Kormendy 1993; Jogee 1999; Kormendy & Kenn icutt 2004, hereafter KK04; Jogee, Scoville, & Kenney 2005; Athanass oula 2005; Kormendy &
Fisher 2005). Pseudobulges tend to have a bulge n <2.5 (Kormendy & Fisher 2005; Fisher
& Drory 2008). One possibility for the formation of disky bulges or pseudobulges is th e idea of (Kormendy 1993; KK04; Jogee, Scoville, & Kenney 2005), where a stellar bar or- 4 - globally oval structure in a non-interacting galaxy drives the gas inflow into the inner kpc via shocks and gravitational torque. Another idea for building disky bu lges is that the gas inflow into the inner kiloparsec is driven by external non-secular processes , such as tidal interaction and minor mergers. The gas inflow in such cases can be caused by a tid ally induced feature, such as a bar (e.g., Quinn et al. 1993; Hernqu ist & Mihos 1995), and by tidal torques from the companion. The subsequent central st ar formation can still form a compact high v/sstellar component, akaa this paper, we avoid making any a about the origin of different types of bulges by simply referring to them according to th eir bulge S' ersic index nor bulge-to-total mass ratio ( B/T). We consider bulges of high ( n>=4), intermediate (2< n <4) and low ( n<=2) index, as well as those of low or high B/T. The structural properties of galaxy components, such as bulges , disks, and bars can be derived throughthe decomposition of the 2 Dlight distribution, taking into account the PSF. Many early studies have performed only two component 2 Dbulge-disk decomposition (e.g., Allen et al. 2006; Byun & Freeman 1995; de Jong 1996; Simard1998; W adadekar et al. 1999), ignoring the contribution of the bar, even in strongly barred galaxie s. However, recent work has shown that it is important to include the bar in 2 Ddecomposition of barred galaxies, else theB/Tratio can be artificially inflated, and bulge properties skewed (e.g., La urikainen et al. 2005, 2007). Furthermore, since most ( >=60%) bright spiral galaxies are barred in the NIR (Eskridge et al. 2000; Laurikainen et al. 2004; Marinova & Jogee 2007, hereafter et al. 2007), the inclusion of the bar is quite imp ortant. This has led to several recent studies, where 2 Dbulge-disk-bar decomposition are being performed et al. 2007; Reese et al. 2007; Gadotti & Kauffmann 200 7). Another advantage of bulge-disk-bar decomposition over bulge-d isk decomposition is that the former allows us to constrain the properties of the bar its elf. Bars provide the most important internal mechanism for redistributing angular momentum in baryonic and dark matter components (e.g. Weinberg 1985; Debattista & Sellwood 199 8, 2000; Berentzen, Shlosman, & Jogee 2006). They efficiently drive g as inflows into the central kpc, feed central starbursts (Elmegreen 1994; Knapen et al. 19 95; Hunt & Malakan 1999; Jogee et al. 1999; Jogee, Scoville, & Kenney 2005; Jogee 2006) and lead to the formation of disky or pseudobulges (see above). Furthermore, the prominenc e of strong bars out to z~1 over the last 8 Gyr (Jogee et al. 2004; Sheth et al. 2008) suggest t hat bars have been present over cosmological times and can shape the dynamical and secular ev olution of disks. bar properties, such as the fractional light and mass r atio (Bar/ T), can yield insight into these processes. In this paper, we constrain the properties of bulges and bars along the Hubble sequence,- 5 - and compare our results with LCDM-based simulations of galaxy evolu tion. InSS2, we define our complete sample of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) spirals from the Ohio State University Bright Spiral Galaxy Survey (O SUBSGS; Eskridge et al. 2002), which is widely used as the local reference sample for brigh t spirals by numerous studies (e.g., Eskridge et al. 2000; Block et al. 2002; Buta et al. 2005 ; MJ07 ; Laurikainen et al. 2004, 2007). In SS3, we perform 2 Dbulge-disk and bulge-disk-bar decompositions of H-band images using GALFIT (Peng et al. 2002), and derive fractiona l light ratios ( B/T, Bar/T, Disk/T), as well as S' ersic indices and half light radii or scale lengths. Tests to verify the robustness of our decompositions are presented in SS4. InSS5, we present our the total stellar mass present in bulges, disks, and bar s is calculated ( SS5.2). InSS5.3, the distribution of bulge S' ersic index nandB/Tas a function of galaxy Hubble type and stellar mass is presented, and the surprising prevalence o f bulges with low S' ersic indexnand lowB/Tis established. A comparison with other works is presented in SS5.4. We examine how Bar/ Tand bar fraction (the fraction barred disks) change as a function of host galaxy properties in SS5.5. InSS5.8, we compare our observed distribution of bulge B/T andnin high mass ( M>=1.0x1010M) spirals with predictions from LCDM models. SS6 summarizes our results. 2. Sample Properties 2.1. OSUBSGS Our dataset is derived from the 182 H-band images from the public data release of the Ohio State University Bright Spiral Galaxy Survey (OSUBSGS; Es kridge et al. 2002). These galaxies are a subset of the RC3 catalog that have mB<=12, Hubble types 0 <=T<=9 (S0/a to Sm), D25<=6'.5, and-80*< d <+50*. Imaging of OSUBSGS galaxies spans optical and near infrared (NIR) wavelengths with BVRJHK images available for most galaxies. OSUBSGS images were acquired on a wide range of telescope s with from 0.9-2.4m. The JHKdata were acquired with a variety of telescopes and detectors, but mainly with the 1.8 m Perkins reflector at Lowell Obse rvatory and the CTIO 1.5 m telescope with the OSIRIS detector, having 18.5 micron pixels (D epoy et al. 1993). Pixel scale is dependent on the telescope and for these observatio ns ranged between 1 - 1.50''/pix. Exposure times were heterogeneous, but the total observ ing time per object was typically between 10-15 minutes in H. The resulting limiting H-band surface brightness is~20 mag arcsec-2. The typical limiting surface brightnesses of the images ~26 and ~20 mag arcsec-2inH-band (Eskridge et al. 2002). The seeing depends on observing time and location. We find the H-band images have seeing of ~3''.- 6 - We choose to use the NIR images rather than optical ones for seve ral reasons. Firstly, NIR images are better tracers of the stellar mass than optical imag es, and the is less affected by age or dust gradients. Secondly, obscurat ion by dust and SF are minimized in the NIR, compared to the optical. As the K-band images are of poor quality, we settle on using the H-band images. The OSUBSGS is widely used as the local reference sample for bright s pirals by numer- ous studies (e.g. Eskridge et al. 2000; Block et al. 2002; Buta et al. 2 005; MJ07; Laurikainen et al. 2004, 2007). Thus, there are numerous complementary res ults that we can use or com- pare with. In particular, MJ07 have identified bars in this sample using quantitative criteria based on ellipse fitting, and characterized their sizes, position angle s, and is a survey with objects whose distances range up to
~60 Mpc. Faint galaxies are inevitably missed at larger distances, resu lting in the distribution in Figure 1. We compare the B-band LF of this sample with a Schechter (Schechter 1976) LF (SLF) with Ph*= and M*
B=-20.5 (Efstathiou, Ellis & Peterson 1988) in Figure 2. The volume used to d etermine the number density in each magnitude bin = the maximum distance out to which a galaxy of absolute magnitude Mcan be observed given the cutoff magnitude mc. If the SLF is representative of the true LF, then Figure 2 suggests that the OSUBSGS sample is seriously incomplete at MB>-19.3, while at the brighter end (-19.3 to -23) the shape of its LF matches fairly well th e SLF. We thus conclude that the sample is reasonably complete for bright ( MB<= -19.3 orLB>0.33L*) galaxies. We exclude highly inclined ( i >70*) galaxies for which structural decomposition does not yield accurate results. Thus, our final sample S1 consists of 14 3 bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) spirals with Hubble types mainly in the range S0/a to Sc(Figure1). Ofthe126for which we couldderive stellar masses (se eSS2.2, most have 3). Table 1 summarizes the morphologies, stellar masses of the sample. Note that there are few galaxies o f late Hubble types (Scd or later) and we do not draw any conclusions on such systems from o ur study. In a future paper, we will tackle galaxies of lower mass and later Hubble types.- 7 - 2.2. Stellar Masses We derive global stellar masses for most of the OSUBSGS sample galax ies using the relation between stellar mass and rest-frame B-Vcolor from Bell et al. (2003). Using population synthesis models, the latter study calculates stellar M/Lratio as a function of color using functions of the form log10(M/L) =al+blxColor+C, dependent constants and C is a constant that depends on the stellar initial mass function (IMF). For the Vband Bell et al. (2003) find al=-0.628 andbl= 1.305; assuming a Kroupa (1993) IMF, they find C=-0.10. This yields an expression for the stellar mass inMfor a given (3) where vlum= 10-0.4(V-4.82). (4) Here,vlumis the luminosity parametrized in terms of absolute Vmagnitude. How reliable are stellar masses determined from this procedure? Clea rly, the between MandB-Vcannot apply to all galaxies, and must depend on the assumed stellar IMF, and range of ages, dust, and metallicity. Howe ver, it is encouraging studies (Bellet al.2003; Droryetal.2004; Salu cci, Yegorova, &Drory2008) find generally good agreement between masses based on broad-ba nd colors and those (e.g. Kauffmann et al. 2003) and dynamical (Drory e t al. 2004) errors are within a factor of two to three. Salucci et al. (2 008) derive disk masses with both photometric and kinematic methods and find the two metho ds are equivalent on average. For a sample of 18, they find an rms scatter of 0.23 dex, w hile on an individual basis the deviation can be as high as 0.5 dex. We used this relation to compute stellar masses for 126 of 143 (88%) objects. The remainder did not have B-Vcolors available in the Hyperleda database or RC3. The is summarized in Figure 3. Individual masses are listed in Ta ble 1. This sample of 126 galaxies is referenced henceforth as sample S2. 3. Method and Analysis The structural properties of galaxy components, such as bulges , disks, and bars can be derived through the decomposition of the 2D light distribution, takin g into account the PSF. There are several algorithms for 2 Dluminosity decomposition, including GIM2D (Simard et- 8 - al. 2002), GALFIT (Peng et al. 2002), and BUDDA (de Souza et al. 20 04). The latter two allow bulge-disk-bar decomposition, while the former only allows bulge- disk example, performed bulge-disk decomposition of B-band images with GIM2D on Driveret al.2005). However, recent work (e.g., Laurikainen et al. 2005; Graham & Balcells, in prepa ration) has shown that the B/Tratio can be artificially inflated in a barred galaxy unless the bar compo nent is included in the 2 Ddecomposition. The fact that most ( >=60%) bright spiral galaxies are barred in the NIR (Eskridge et al. 2000; Laurikainen et al. 2004; MJ0 7; al. 2007), further warrants the inclusion of the bar. Another a dvantage of aritself, of bar-driven evolution (see several studies have tackled theproblemof2 Dbulge- disk-bar decomposition. Laurikainen et al. (2005, 2007) have deve loped a 2 decomposition code designed to model bulges, disks, primary a nd secondary bars, and lenses; they apply S' ersic functions to bulges and use either S' ers ic or Ferrers functions to describe bars and lenses. Reese et al. (2007) have written a non-p arametric algorithm to model bars in ~70I-band images. Gadotti & Kauffmann (2007) are performing 2 Dbulge- disk-bar and bulge-disk decomposition of 1000 barred and unbarre d galaxies from SDSSwith the BUDDA software. In this study, we perform 2 Dtwo-component bulge-disk decomposition and three- component bulge-disk-bar decomposition of the OSUBSGS sample wit h GALFIT. We note that Laurikainen et al. (2007) have also performed bulge-disk-bar decomposition on the OS- UBSGS sample. However, there are also important complementary d ifferences between our study and theirs. The decomposition algorithm and tests on the rob ustness performed in our study are different (see SS3 andSS4). Furthermore, unlike Laurikainen et al. (2007), we also compare the bulge-to-total ratio ( B/T) with predictions from hierarchical models of galaxy evolution ( SS5), and also present the distribution of bar-to-total ratio (Bar/ T). 3.1. Image GALFIT on an image requires initial preparation. The desired fitting region and sky background must be known, and the PSF image, bad pixel ma sk (if needed), and pixel noise map must be generated. We addressed these issues as f ollows: (1) The GALFIT fitting region must be large enough to include the outer galaxy disk, a s well as some sky- 9 - region. Since cutting out empty regions of sky can drastically reduc e GALFIT run-time, a balance was sought between including the entire galaxy and some dec ent sky region, while excluding large extraneous blank sky areas. (2) It is possible for GA LFIT to fit the sky background, but this is not recommended. When the sky is a free pa rameter, the wings of the bulge S' ersic profile can become inappropriately extended, res ulting in a S' ersic index that is too high. Sky backgrounds were measured separately and design ated as fixed parameters; (3) GALFIT requires a PSF image to correct for seeing effects. Sta tistics of many stars in each frame can be used to determine an average PSF. However, ma ny of our images contain merely a few stars. Instead, a high S/N star from each frame was u sed as a PSF. (4) We used ordered lists of pixel coordinates to make bad pixel masks, which ar e useful for blocking out bright stars and other image artifacts. (5) We had GALFIT interna lly calculate pixel noise maps for an image from the noise associated with each pixel. Noise valu es are determined from image header information concerning gain, read noise, exposu re time, and the number of combined exposures. 3.2. Decomposition Steps Figure 4 summarizes our method of decomposition, which we now deta il. GALFIT requires initial guesses for each component it fits. It uses a Leven berg-Marquardt algorithm to determine the minimum kh2based on the input guesses. GALFIT con- tinues iterating until the kh2changes by less than 5e-04 for five iterations (Peng et al. 2002). We recognize that a drawback to any least-squares method is that a local minimum, rather than a global minimum, in kh2space may be converged upon. We explore this possibil- ity with multiple tests described in SS4. We adopted an iterative process, involving three separate invocations of GALFIT, to perform 1-component, 2-co mponent, and Stage 1 (single S' ersic): In Stage 1, a single S' ersic component is fitted to the galaxy. This serves the purpose of measuring the total luminosity, which is c onserved in later Stages, and the centroid of the galaxy, which is invariant in later fits . 2. Stage 2 (exponential plus S' ersic): In Stage 2, the image is fit wit h the sum of an exponential disk and a S' ersic component. During the Stage 2 fit, t he diskb/aandPA are held constant at values, which we take from the published ellipse fi ts of MJ07, as well as ellipse fits of our own. This procedure reduces the number of free parameters in the fit by fixing the disk b/aandPA, which are easily measurable parameters. It also prevents GALFIT from confusing the disk and bar, and artificia lly stretching the- 10 - disk along the bar PA in an attempt to mimic the bar. As initial guesses f or the S' ersic component in Stage 2, the output of Stage 1 is used. The S' ersic component in Stage 2 usually represents the bulge, in which case Stage 2 corresp onds to a in a few rare cases, where the galaxy has just a bar and a disk, the S' ersic component in Stage 2 represents a bar. The latter is recognizable b y a low S' ersic index and large half-light radius. 3. Stage 3 (exponential plus two S' ersic components): In Stage 3 , a consisting of an exponential disk, a S' ersic bulge, and a S' er sic bar is fit. As suggested by Peng et al. (2002), the bar can be well described by a n elongated, low- index S' ersic ( n <1) profile. As in Stage 2, the disk b/aandPAare held constant at values predetermined from ellipse fits. We provide initial guesses for the barb/aand PA, based on ellipse fits of the images from MJ07 or analysis of the images in DS9. We provide GALFIT with input guesses for the bulge parameters, ba sed on the output from Stage 2. In principle, it is also possible to generate reasonable g uess parameters for the bulge and disk from a bulge-disk decomposition on a 1 Dprofile taken along a select PA. As described in SS4.3, we also experiment with initial guesses derived in this way, and find that the final convergence solution is the same. W e also note that GALFIT fixes the bulge b/aand does not allow it to vary with radius, while real bulges may have a varying b/a. We tested the impact of fixed and varying bulge b/aon and find that there is no significant change in B/T. For objects with central point sources, the bulge S' ersic index in t he Stage 2 and Stage 3 models can be inadvertently overestimated unless an extra nuclea r component is added to the model. Balcells et al. (2003) note that for galaxies imaged both from the ground andHST, the combination of unresolved central sources and seeing effect s mimic high- index bulge S' ersic profiles in the ground images. Depending on sample and resolution, the frequency of central sources can range from 50% to 90% (Ravind ranath et al. 2001; B oker et al. 2002; Balcells et al. 2003). Ravindranath et al. (2001) find a fr equency of 50% in early type (E, S0, S0/a) galaxies, while B oker et al. (2002) measur e a frequency of 75% for spirals with Hubble types Scd to Sm. Balcells et al. (2003) determine a f requency of 84% for S0-Sbc galaxies imaged with HST. Our dataset most closely resembles the latter sample, so we might expect that, as an upper limit, a similar fraction of our gala xies will need to be corrected with an extra compact component. We added point sources as third or fourth components to the initial models. For those cases where the model successfully converged with the extra com ponent, the images were visually inspected to verify the presence of a central bright sourc e. Sometimes, the model- 11 - converged to significantly different and unreasonable parameters for all components. Other times, parameters. Where new model parameters were not unrea sonable and not identical to the case without the point source, the new model was adopted. This was the case for 111 of 143 (78%) of our sample. The point sources contribute less t han 1%, 3%, and 5% of the total luminosity 55%, 86%, and 95% of the time, respectively. As the point sources take up such a small fraction of the light distribution, their contribution is folded back into B/T in all cases where a point source was modeled. Inclusion of the point s ource reduced bulge index by ~0.8 for both barred and unbarred galaxies. Such a change is expecte d based on the above discussion. The decline in bulge index caused a minor decr ease inB/T; on the mean, this change was 1.04% for barred galaxies and 0.32% for un barred galaxies. For barred galaxies, this light most primarily added to D/Trather than Bar/ T. It is important to recognize the physical significance of the added n uclear components. We began by determining which objects show evidence for AGN activit y. The sample was checked against the catalog of Ho et al. (1997), the V' eron Catalo g of Quasars & AGN, 12th Edition (V' eron-Cetty & V' eron 2006), and NED. Of the 111 objec ts fit with point sources, 43 (39%) contain AGN. An additional 20 (18%) possess HII nuclei acco rding to Ho et al. (1997) and visibly show bright compact nuclei. The remaining 48 (43%) probab ly contain neither AGN nor HII nuclei, but could house nuclear star clusters. For thes e objects, we the images to ensure there was a bright compact source at the center. We are confident that the fitted point source components have physical counterparts in the also allows a parameter to be added to an y S' ersic or expo- nential profile. We did not use this parameter for any bulge or disk pr ofiles. Bars in general have boxy isophotes, andwe could have included the diskiness/boxin ess parameter in the bar profiles. However, it was found that adding boxiness to the bar did n ot change any including fractional luminosities B/T,D/T, and Bar/ T, by more than a even though the appearance of the residual images improved in some cases due to the change in bar shape. Consequently, we chose to neglect bar boxiness altogether. 3.3. Choosing the Best Fit Between Stage 2 and Stage 3 All objects in our sample were subjected to Stages 1, 2, and 3. Dep ending on whether a galaxy with a bulge is unbarred or barred, its best fit should be take n from the Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition or the Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decompos ition, respectively. For objects with prominent bars, it is obvious that the Stage 3 model pr ovides the best fit.- 12 - However, it is more difficult to decide between Stage 2 versus Stage 3 fits in galaxies which host weak bars with no strong visual signature. In practice, we th erefore applied the set of criteria below to each galaxy in order to select between the Stage 2 b ulge-disk Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition. Table 1 lists the model ch osen for each galaxy. Table 2 summarizes the model parameters from the best fits. For completeness, we note that for the few rare galaxies (see SS3.2) that have just a bar and a disk, the choice of a final solution is between the Stage 2 bar-d isk decomposition and Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition. The same guidelines below can be used to identify the best model. 1. Itwasfoundthat kh2almost between the Stage 2 and Stage 3 fits for a given object. Th is is because in the Stage 3 fit, five extra free parameters (bar luminosity, re, S' ersic index, b/a, andPA) are added with the S' ersic bar component, allowing GALFIT to almost always make a lowerkh2model during Stage 3. However, this does not necessarily mean tha t the solution in Stage 3 is more correct physically. Thus, an increasing kh2was interpreted as a sign that the Stage 3 fit should not be adopted, but a decreasin gkh2was not considered as a sufficient condition to adopt Stage 3. 2. In cases with prominent bars, a symmetric light distribution due to unsubtracted bar light was often found in the Stage 1 and Stage 2 bulge-disk residuals. This was strong evidence that the Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar fit be selected. NGC 4643 is shown in Fig- ure 5 because it has a particularly striking bar residual; the corresp onding fit param- eters appear in Table 3. Note that in all figures and tables, we adopt the convention that PA values are if they are measured from Nor th The Stage 2 and Stage 3 models were selected only so long as the mo del parameters were all well behaved. In unbarred galaxies, the Stage 3 model par ameters might be unphysically large or small, in which case the Stage 2 fit was favored. C onversely, in galaxies with prominent bars, the bulge component of the Stage 2 bu lge-disk fit insize. k-bar fit removes this artifact, giving a more physical solution. An extreme example of this situation is the barred galaxy NGC 4548, which has a prominent bar and a faint dis k. The Stage 2 fit, based on a S' ersic bulge and exponential disk, is highly inadequat e to describe the bulge, disk, andthe bar because it leads to an extremely extended bulge. The Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar fit, however, yields a believable fit with a prominent b ar. The results of Stage 1, Stage 2, and Stage 3 are displayed in Figure 6 and Table 4.- 13 - 4. Not all barred galaxies had unphysical Stage 2 models. Instead, the bulge could be stretched along the PAof the bar, giving the bulge a lower S' ersic index and larger effective radius. A Stage 3 model that returned the bulge to a size a nd shape of the input image was favored over the Stage 2 fit . Figure 7 and Table inNGC4902. Wedistinguish thiseffect fro mcases likeNGC 4548 (Figure 6 and Table 4) where the Stage 2 fit is completely wrong. 5. In cases where there was no bar, GALFIT can sometimes be entic ed into fitting a bar to any existing spiral arms, rings, or the clumpy disks of late-type s pirals. Stage 3 fits in these cases could be discarded by noting the resulting discrepanc ies in the galaxy images and the Stage 3 model images. Examples o f false bars are shown in Figure 8. After fitting the whole sample and picking the best fit from either the Stage 2 or the Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition, we also performed the following extra tests. For our sample S1 of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) spirals in the OSUBSGS survey, we determine the fraction (75 of 14 3 or~52%) of spiral galaxies where a bulge-disk-bar decomposition was picked a s the best fit for the H- band image. There are also eight galaxies with pure bar-disk fits. The H-band bar fraction, which is defined as the fraction of disk galaxies that are barred, is th erefore 58 .0+-4.13%
(83 of 143). We then compared our results (58 .0%+-4.13%) with the H-band bar fraction (60%) determined from ellipse fits of the OSUBSGS sample by MJ07, wit h a slightly inclination cut ( i<=60*). The two numbers are in excellent agreement. As a further check to our fits, we compare the bar and unbarred clas sification for from our fits with those from MJ07, which were based on ellips e fits. Of the 73 galaxies that we classify as barred, and that are mutually fitted by M J07, 54 (74%) are also classified as barred by MJ07. The remaining 19 (26%) galaxies are main ly weakly barred (with Bar/ Tbelow 0.08). Their RC3 optical types are weakly barred AB (10), bar red B (7), and unbarred A (2). In most previous bulge-disk and bulge-disk-bar 2 Ddecomposition, the issue of param- eter coupling and the systematic exploration of local versus global minima in kh2have been ignored. Quantifying how the parameters are coupled is important in measuring error bars for the model parameters. With 2 Dmodels containing several free parameters, this is not an easy task. Although we also do not address this problem in rigorou s detail, we describe inSS4.4 simple test that explores parameter coupling in our models.- 14 - 4. Extra Tests to Verify Correctness of Fits 4.1. Varying b/aas a Function of Radius Models generated with GALFIT do not allow the b/aof the bulge, disk, or bar to vary with radius. Since real bulges may have a varying b/a, it is legitimate to investigate the impact of fixing the bulge b/aon the estimated B/T. We therefore performed the following test on NGC 4548. To mimic a model bulge of varying b/a, we fitted the bulge light of NGC 4548 with ten concentric S' ersic profiles of increasing reand varying b/a. Thereof the outermost profile comes from the original bulge model (see Tab le 4) where b/awas kept constant with radius. The separation in rebetween adjacent profiles is 0.5 pixels (0.75). The luminosity, S' ersic index, b/a, andPAof each profile were free parameters. The disk and bar components were fixed to the values in Table 4, as the empha sis was on the change in the bulge. Figure 9 compares the B/Tobtained by fitting the bulge of NGC 4548 with a S' ersic model of constant b/aas opposed to a S' ersic model varying b/a. The bulge and B/T(13%) from the original S' ersic fit of constant b/a(Table 4) are indicated with horizontal lines on the 3 panels. The top two panels show the run ofb/a(0.85 to +90*) of the ten concentric S' ersic profiles. It can be seen that the S' ersic indices of the tenbulge models were generally higher toward the cent er anddeclined at larger re, indicating that the 'fitted bulge is more concentrated at the cente r. The bottom panel shows the cumulative B/Tcalculated by summing all models with r<=re. The last the summed B/Tfrom all ten components is 14.5%, in good agreement with the 13.0% value from the S' ersic fit of constant b/a. Thus, using a S' ersic model of constant b/a, does not have any significant adverse impact on our derived B/Tin NGC 4548. 4.2. Fitting Artificially Simulated Images An elementary test is to determine if GALFIT can recover the known parameters of artificially simulated noisy images. The images were simulated by taking p arametric model images produced by GALFIT, and adding noise to the images with the P yFITS module for Python (Barrett & Bridgman 1999). Noise in each pixel was calcu lated by adding in quadrature the noise due to the source, sky, and read noise. The standard deviation of pixel noise in electrons was computed (5)- 15 - whereTsourceis the number of electrons due to the source, Tskyis the number of electrons due to the sky, and Treadis the detector read noise. The contribution due to detector dark current was very small and therefore neglected. The offset adde d to each pixel was drawn from a normal distribution centered at zero with standard deviatio ns. Our test sample consisted of 40 models (20 bulge-disk and 20 bulge-d isk-bar) with noise added as described. Thirty of the images included point source s as extra components. The range explored for each parameter in the model images is a fair r epresentation of the parameter space covered by our full sample (e.g., B/Tranges from 0 .02-0.70, the bulge index ranges from ~0-5, and the full range of possible bulge and bar PA was also tested (-90*to +90*)). In terms of surface brightness, the models span five magnitud es in mean surface brightness inside thedisk scalelength. Examples of thenois e-added models areshown in Figure 10. The noisy images were subjected to the 2 Ddecomposition procedure outlined in Fig- ure 4. GALFIT reproduced the model (bulge, disk, bar, and point s ource) parameters quite closely for the majority of the test cases. Figure 11 compares the recovered versus original model parameters. Except for some extreme cases where the ima ges were highly distorted by noise, all parameters were recovered to within a few percent. F igure 12 plots the ratio parameter against mean surface brightnes s inside the disk is no strong trend in error with dimming surface brightness. T his suggests our de- compositions are effective across the parameter space spanned b y our sample. The overall success of this test is evidence that GALFIT is able to converge to t he absolute minimum in kh2space for our bulge-disk and bulge-disk-bar decompositions when t he input is the sum of parametric functions. 4.3. Using 1DDecomposition To Generate Guesses for Bulge Parameters It is important to verify that GALFIT converges to the same solutio n even if the initial guesses for the bulge parameters in Stage 2 and 3 are different. Bu lge-disk 1Dprofiles provides an alternative means of generating initial guesses . While 1 D bulge-disk decompositions of radial profiles along the bar major axis can be influenced by the bar, decomposition of cuts along the bar minor axis will not be influ enced as heavily. The resulting bulge and disk parameters should be adequate guesse s for Stage 3 of our 2 D decomposition method. We tested the robustness of our Stage 3 fits by extracting initial g uesses for the bulge and disk using 1 Ddecomposition along the bar minor axis. The nonlinear least-squares- 16 - algorithm designed to perform the 1 Ddecomposition simultaneously fits the with the sum of a S' ersic bulge and an exponential disk, while ig noring the PSF. The results from the 1 Ddecomposition include a bulge magnitude, re, S' ersic index, disk magnitude, and disk scalelength. The robustness of several bulge-disk-bar fits were tested by us ing the results of the 1 The1 Ddecompositions axis ratio ( b/a) orPA, so these parameters for the bulge were estimated by eye; for th e disk, the b/aandPAwere fixed to the values determined by ellipse fitting, as described in SS3.2. The initial bar parameters were unchanged from the earlier Sta ge 3 fits. In all cases, the new models were identical to the Stage 3 models. As an example, T able 6 compares Stage 3 input derived from 1D decomposition and GALFIT for NGC 454 8 and NGC 4643. In each case, both sets of input reproduced the same results. 4.4. Parameter the coupling between model parameters is complicated wh en models have a largenumber lateconfidence ellipsoids for a given kh2contour. As the errors in the GALFIT models are not normally distributed, but are instead dominated by the syst ematics of galaxy struc- ture, this approach does not yield meaningful results because of t he ambiguity in assessing which kh2contour levels are statistically significant. We carry out a simple test for representative galaxies to determine not only the effects of parameter coupling, but also the the effect parameter coupling h as on model paying particularly close attention to B/T,D/T, and Bar/ T, as they are of We perform this test on four representative galaxies (N GC 3885, NGC 4151, NGC 4643, and NGC 7213). Two are barred (NGC 4151 and NGC 4643). Tw o have high ( n >2) bulge indices (NGC 4643 and NGC 7213), and the other two have low ( n <2) bulge indices. We fit two and three-component bulge-disk and bulge-disk-bar mod els using fixed bulge indices of n= 1 and n= 4. The initial inputs to these fits were the same as those used to generate the model in which bulge nis a free parameter. We then had GALFIT re-fit the models with bulge index as a free parameter using these output mode l parameters as input initial guesses. We compare the output of these two fits with the th e best fit as selected in SS3.3, in which bulge nis a free parameter. Ideally, the re-fits should converge to the sa me final parameters as the selected best fit. Table 7 displays the outcome of this test for the four representat ive systems. For barred- 17 - galaxies NGC 4643 and NGC 4151, the n= 1 and n= 4 re-fits converged to the same kh2 as when bulge nis initially left a free parameter. B/T,D/T, and Bar/ Tare precisely equal for NGC 4643, while for NGC 4151 there is a small dispersion of 0.1-0.2% . For NGC 3885 and NGC 7213, the n= 1 re-fits again converged to the same kh2and model parameters as when bulge nis initially left a free parameter. This is not true for the n= 4 re-fits. When the n= 4 condition is enforced, the bulges in these cases become too extended and luminous while the kh2drop below those when bulge nis initially left a free parameter. During the n= 4 re-fits, B/Tincreases further at the expense of D/Tand the kh2remain unchanged or decrease further. The B/Dratio from the n= 4 re-fit for NGC 3885 is 1.3, roughly 3.5 times higher than when nis free. Given that NGC 3885 is an S0/a galaxy with a bulge embedded in a smooth extended disk, the latter B/Dis arguably too large. For NGC 7213, the n= 4 re-fit yields starkly unphysical values. The B/Dratio is 11.3, and re/h, the ratio between bulge effective radius and disk scalelength is 9.0. T he lower kh2in these cases cannot be taken seriously as the bulges are too lumino us and the do not match the data images. As illustrated by the above discussion and Table 7, this test shows th at in some cases (e.g., NGC 4643 and NGC 4151) GALFIT converges to the similar model parameters and B/T,D/T, and Bar/ Twhile starting from highly different initial input guesses (e.g. bulge n= 1, bulge n= 4, and bulge nbased on the Stage 2 fits) in different regions of parameter space. For NGC 3885 and NGC 7213, however, during the n= 4 re-fits GALFIT that were unphysical anddifferent comparedwith therea sonable input guesses corresponding to the bulge fixed at n= 1 or the bulge nbased on output from Stage 1. In effect, when the initial input guesses were very diff erent from the data images, the resulting models were found, in spite of the lower kh2, to be unphysical with the input data images. We emphasize that for all sou rces analyzed in the paper, the data, converged model output, and residuals are alwa ys inspected before adopting the best final fit (see SS3.3). Table 7 also provides hints as to how the model parameters are coup led to bulge index. As suggested in the above discussion, fixing the bulge index to n= 4 leads to a more extended and luminous bulge, causing bulge reandB/Tto rise without fail for increasing bulge index. The disk is coupled with the bulge such that increasing bulg e index, bulge re, andB/Tyields a reduction in D/T. At the same time, disk scalelength either increases (NGC 3885 and NGC 4643) or decreases (NGC 3885 and NGC 4151); in the latter two cases, the disk becomes very compact and the bulge quite extende d. The behavior of the bar is coupled with boththe bulge and disk. In the case of NGC 4643, as bulge index is raised to n= 4, bar rebecomes slightly larger, but Bar/ Tfalls by a factor of 2.6 as light is redistributed from the bar and disk to the bulge. Bar index also declin es as the bar assumes- 18 - a flatter profile. For NGC 4151, bar reagain increases slightly, but this time Bar/ Trises by a factor of 1.7 as light is transferred from the disk to the bulge and b ar. Based on the above test, we stress that GALFIT was able to overc ome this in the cases where the input guess parameters well-reflect ed the data images. 5. Results and Discussion 5.1. Impact of Bars in the Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition and Stage 3 bulge-disk-b ar we performed on all objects ( SS3.2) we saw firsthand the effects of adding a bar to the fit of a barred galaxy. We summarize below some of these effects in order to underscore the importance of including a bar component in the 2 Dluminosity decomposition of During the Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition of a barred galaxy, t he luminosity which comes from the galaxy's disk, bulge, and bargets distributed only between two the model bulge and disk. Since the disk b/aandPAare and held constant during the fits, the Stage 2 model tends to distort the bulge inorder to fit the bar. Thus, the bulge inthe Stage2 bulge-disk decomposition of a barred galaxy can be artificially long or too bright and extended. Wh en a model bar component is added in the Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition of a barred galaxy, it forces a reshuffling of the luminosity between the three componen ts. Generally, the bulge declines in luminosity, whereas light can be either taken from, or added back, to the disk. 2. We find that the inclusion of a bar component in the Stage 3 bulge-d isk-bar decom- position of a barred galaxy reduces the bulge fractional luminosity B/T, compared with the Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition. For our 75 barred galaxie s, the to factors of less than two, 2 to 4, and above 4, in 36% , 25%, and 39%
of barred galaxies, respectively. The larger changes in B/Toccur in very strongly barred galaxies, where a prominent bar cause the Stage 2 bulge-dis k decomposition to overestimate the bulge. For instance, B/Tdeclines in both of NGC 4643 (Figure 5 and Table 3) and NGC 4548 (Figure 6 and Table 4). In the latter case, B/Tis reduced by a factor of ~5 between Stage 2 and Stage 3. These examples underscore the imp ortance of including bars in 2 Dluminosity decomposition of very strongly barred galaxies.- 19 - 3. The scalelength of the disk is generally unchanged by including the b ar. NGC 4548 (Figure 6 and Table 4) is a good example. Sometimes, however, the dis k from the Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition of a barred galaxy is erroneous du e to a poor fit. The disk parameters from the Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decompositio n are quite different in such cases. NGC 4643 (Figure 5 and Table 3) illustrates this behavio r. We find that for our sample S1 of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) spirals (Figure 1) in the OSUBSGS survey, 75 of 143 or ~52% are better fit with a Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition than a Stage 2 bulge-disk de composition. There are also eight galaxies with pure bar-disk fits. As stated in SS3.3, the resulting H-band bar fraction (58 .0%+-4.13% or 83 of 143) is in excellent agreement with the H-band bar fraction of 60% reported by MJ07 based on ellipse fits of the OSUBSGS sample, with a slightly inclination cut ( i<=60*). 5.2. Mass in Bulges, Disks, and Bars The fractional H-band luminosities in the bulge, disk, and bar ( B/T,D/T, Bar/T) of each galaxy can be considered as a fractional mass if we assume tha t the same ratio can be used to convert the H-band luminosities of both the numerator ( B,D, or Bar) and the denominator ( T) terms into a stellar mass. This is not an as the H-bandM/Lratio is not very sensitive to differences in dust or age that might exist between the bulge, disk, and bar. The uncertainties in M/Lcan be estimated by looking at population synthesis models. Charlot, Worthey, & Bres san (1996) find that for idealized galaxies with a single generation of stars, the uncertain ties inM/Lratio due to different input stellar models and spectra are roughly +-35% for a fixed metallicity and IMF. Furthermore, as the age of a stellar population varies from ~0.5 Gyr to 10 Gyr, rises by a factor of ~2 to 3 (Charlot 1996). Asymptotic giant branch (AGB) stars dominate the NIR light for ages between 0.1 and 1 Gyr, w hile red giant branch (RGB) and super-giant branch (SGB) stars dominate between 1 Gy r and 10 Gyr. In this paper, we convert the B/Tlight ratio determined from H-band images to a aconstant mass-to-light( M/L) rest of the galaxy. However, Moorthy & Holtzman (2006) pres ent line strengths of bulges and inner disks for 38 spirals with Hubble types S0 to Sc. They show 76 % of spirals have negative metallicity gradients. B-Kcolor gradients are shown to largely match and are likewise negative outward, indicating bulge M/Lis higher than in the disk and bar. If bulges are much older than the disks, then our prescrip tion would trueB/Tmass ratio. If we assume an extreme case where bulges are ~12 Gyr and the- 20 - disk light is dominated by a young 3 Gyr population, our assumption of a constant H-band M/Lratio would underestimate the true B/Tby a factor of <=2 (Charlot 1996). In several sections of the paper (e.g., SS5.3,SS5.8), we illustrate how our main results would change if the true B/Twas higher by up to a factor of two. On the other hand, central re gions of galaxies may harbor intense episodes of star formation. If the b ulge is younger than the disk and happens to have star formation and a significant young pop ulation of massive stars, then our prescription could overestimate the true B/Tmass ratio. This would make our current results on the high fraction of low B/Tbulges even stronger. Using the total galaxy stellar mass from SS2.2, the fractional masses can be converted into absolute masses. (We do not convert the H-band luminosity directly into a mass as theH-band images do not have photometric calibration). The results are shown in Table 8. For our sample S1 of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) spirals with a mass-weighted mean Hubble type of Sab-Sb, we find that ~70%of the stellar mass is in disks, ~10% is in stellar bars and ~20%is in bulges (with ~11%inn while bulges with n<=2 are highly ubiquitous (see next section), they only account for a small fraction of the total stella r mass budget. Figure 13 shows the stellar mass for bulges, disks, and bars along th e Hubble sequence. It is useful to compare our results with those of Driver et al. (2006 ), who decomposition of B-band images with GIM2D on 10,095 galaxies from the Mil- lennium Galaxy Catalog (Liske et al. 2003; Driver et al. 2005). They fo und 68.6% of the stellar mass to be in disks, and 32.6% in bulges (with 30.8% in high nbulges, and 1.8% in lown<=2 bulges). Their study thus finds a higher stellar mass fraction in all b ulges (32.6%
vs our 18.9%), and in high nbulges (30.8% vs our 10.4%), and a lower fraction in low n<=2 bulges (1.8%vs our 8.4%), and disks+bars (68.6% vs our 71.6%+ 9.6%). This difference can be attributed to the fact that the Driver et al. (2006) study did no t perform and thus, their B/Tratios may be skewed to higher values. 5.3. Distribution of Bulge Index and B/T Figure 14 shows the individual and mean B/Tand bulge S' ersic index, plotted, as a function of Hubble type and galaxy stellar mass. Barred and unbarr ed galaxies are Figure 15 shows the relationship between bulge index an dB/T. We first consider the B/Tvalues in Figure 14. The mean B/Tin barred galaxies is lower than in unbarred galaxies, but there is a large overlap in the indiv idual values. The offset in the mean B/Tof barred and unbarred galaxies reported here, agrees with the r esult- 21 - of Laurikainen et al. (2007; see SS5.4) on the same sample. We also note that B/Tdoes not correlate with Bar/ T(Fig. 16): aside from the six galaxies with large Bar/ T(>0.3), most galaxies have low-to-moderate Bar/ Tand a wide range of B/Tis seen at each Bar/ T. This is reassuring and suggests that the bar fit is not arbitrarily biasing t heB/Tvalues. The distribution of Bar/ Tis further discussed in SS5.5. How does the B/Tvary as a function of Hubble type and galaxy stellar mass? Bulges with very high B/T(>0.4) exist primarily in galaxies with high mass ( M>6x1010M) and early types (S0/a to Sab). Bulges with very low B/T(<0.1) lie primarily in lower It is striking that ~69%of bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) spirals have B/T<=0.2: these bulges are pervasive and exist across the whole spectrum of S0/a to Sd. The results are summarized in Table 9. We shall return to this point in SS5.8. We note again that these B/Tmass ratios were a constant M/Lratio in the H-band for the bulge and disk components. As noted inSS5.2, if the bulge in these high mass spirals is much younger (older) than the disk and bar, then the B/Tcan be overestimated (underestimated) by up to a factor of two, and the limiting value of 0.2 for the B/Tcited in the above fraction, would have to be modified in the extreme case to 0.1 and 0.4, of the low B/T<=0.2 values for six barred S0/a and Sa galaxies in Figure 14 may at first look suspicious. Balcells et al. (2007) report the mean B/Tfor S0 galaxies to be 0.25, so much smaller B/Tare potentially worrisome. OSUBSGS H-band images of these objects in Figure 17 show a smooth extended disk around the bulge. It should be noted that Hubble types were originally assigned on a combination of criteria includ ing disk smoothness and spiral arm topology in addition to the prominence of the bulge. It is likely that these galaxies were assigned early Hubble types due to their smooth exten ded disks, in spite of their low bulge-to-disk some of the high B/T~0.4 bulges in three of the Sc galaxies may at first seem odd. However, again, visual inspection of their image (Figure 1 7) reveals prominent spiral arms and clumpiness, which may explain why they were assigned late Hubble types. How does the bulge S' ersic index nvary as a function of Hubble type, and galaxy stellar mass (Figure 14), as well as B/T(Figure 15)? The results are summarized in Table 9. Only a small fraction ( ~1%) of bright spirals have high n>=4 bulges; such bulges lie primarily in S0/a to Sab, and have a large B/T >0.2. A moderate fraction ( ~22%) have intermediate 2< n <4 bulges; these exist in barred and unbarred S0/a to Sd, and their B/Tspans a wide range (0.03 to 0.5) with a mean of 0.29. A strikingly large fraction ( ~76%) of bright spirals have low n<=2bulges; such bulges exist in barred and unbarred galaxies ac ross a wide range of Hubble types, and their B/Tvaries from 0.01 to 0.4, with most having B/T<=0.2.- 22 - 5.4. Comparison With Other Work As an independent check of our decomposition method, we compare our results published find our mean H-bandB/D(Figure 18) ratios are comparable to the with the 1 Dbulge-disk decompositions of Graham (2001) and Trujillo et al. (2002 ). Like Graham (2001) and Trujillo et al. (2002), we find B/Dis widely variable with Hubble type and that mean B/Dsteadily declines from Sa through Scd galaxies. Graham (2001) and Trujillo et al. (2002) find bulge indices are widely variable within a Hub ble type, but they are ingeneral >1 for early types and <1 forlate types. We likewise find wide scatter in bulge index with n <1 bulges existing in both early and late types. Figure 18 is also in good agreement with the more recent results of Graham & Worley (2008) , who have calculated, as a function of morphology, inclination and dust-corrected B/Dand bulge S' ersic indices. They find B/Dvalues are typically <1/3. Another meaningful comparison can be made with Laurikainen et al. ( 2007) who, using their own 2 Ddecomposition code, fit a hybrid sample containing some OSUBSGS gala xies combined with additional S0 galaxies. One difference between their wo rk and ours is that they typically model bars with a Ferrers function, but may sometime s use a S' ersic profile, while we use only the latter. Also, they include additional components to model secondary bars or inner disks. They report a distinct offset in the mean B/Tbetween barred and unbarred galaxies, which we confirm in Figure 14. Their mean B/Tare similar to ours, and they conclude that pseudobulges exist throughout the Hubble seq uence. The S' ersic indices derived by Laurikainen et al. (2007)are likewise similar, onthe mean, t o oursfor both barred and unbarred systems. They likewise find n<=2 bulges across early and late Hubble et al. (2003) emphasized that bulges typically have indices ~3 or lower. Our results in Figure 14 are consistent. We find a low frequency ( ~1%) of high n>=4 bulges, with most bulges having n<=3. 5.5. Bar Strength Stellar bars exert gravitational torques on the gaseous compone nt and are in driving gas from the outer disk into the inner kiloparsec (se eSS1). Thus, it would be natural to have a measure of bar strength that is sensitiv e to the strength of torque and hence measures both the shape and mas s of the bar.- 23 - Many measures of bar strength have been formulated. The Qbmethod of (Block et al. 2002; Buta et al. 2003; Buta et al. 2005) measures directly the g ravitational torque at a single point along the bar. This method requires a value of scaleheight for the disk and a model of the potential to be made from the image. In the bar/inter -bar contrast method of Elmegreen & Elmegreen et al. (1996), bar str ength is parameterized as the ratio between peak surface brightness in the bar region and th e minimum surface bright- ness in the inter-bar region. Elmegreen & Elmegreen (1985) and Elme green et al. (1996) bar strength with the maximum amplitude of the m= 2 mode from When ellipse fitting is applied, the maximum ellipticity of th e bar,ebar, can be used to characterize bar strength (e.g. MJ07). This constitut es a partial measure of bar strength only, however, as it offers no information about mass of t he decomposition in the H-band provides another partialmeasure of bar strength through the H-band Bar/ Tlight ratio, which is a measure of the Bar/ Tmass ratio under the assumption that the H-bandM/Lratio is the same for the bar and the rest of the galaxy, as discussed in SS5.2. Figures 19 and 20 explore the derived bar properties. The upper left panel of Figure 19 plots the individual and mean Bar/ Tagainst Hubble type. There is a wide range ( ~0.03 to~0.47) in the individual Bar/ Tat a given Hubble type. The mean Bar/ Tremains fairly constant with Hubble type from Sa to Sb, but shows a possible weak decline by about 0.1 from Sb to Sc. Their number statis tics are too small to make any robust statement for later Hubble types. We also note th at six systems have high Bar/Tabove 0.3; these are displayed in Figure 21. Bar S' ersic indices are mostly below unity. Neither the individual, nor t he mean bar S' ersic index, show any trend with Hubble type or with stellar mass, f or Sa to Sc galaxies (Fig. 19). Thus, the steepness of the bar profile does not seem to depend onthe Hubble type. Is the bar mass ratio and its mass profile related? There is a wide rang e in the a given bar S' ersic index (Fig. 20). The mean Bar/ Trises with bar index out to a bar index of ~0.6, and then flattens out. This suggests that on the mean, bars of lower Bar/Thave flatter profiles. Is there a relation between the bar strength and the bulge presen t in a galaxy? There is a wide range in the individual Bar/ Tat a given B/T, and at a given bulge S' ersic index (Fig.20). ThemeanBar/ Similarly the mean Bar/ Tshows a weak rise from 0.1 to 0.25 as B/Trises out to 0.15, after which the trend flattens or reverses. Both Bar/ Tand maximum bar ellipticity ebarare partial measures of bar strength. Figure 19 shows mean Bar/ Tmay scale weakly with Hubble type. The bars with highest- 24 - ebar(i.e, thin bars) are often termed strong bars, and ebarhas been shown to correlate with Qb. Total bar strength should scale with bothbar mass andbar ellipticit y. Doesbar strength have a dependence on Hubble type? The upper left panel of Figure 2 0 plots the product of Bar/Tandebar, as determined by MJ07 for galaxies mutually classified as barred, ag ainst Hubble type. There is a wide range in Bar/ Txebarin each bin, and mean bar strength shows no definite trend with Hubble type. We note that bars with high Bar/Tand high ebar should exert the largest gravitational torque and be most effectiv e at driving gas inflows. A nice example is the oval or lens galaxy NGC 1317 (Figure 21); the bar h as a low ellipticity, but itsB/Tis large as it is extended and massive. Such bars or lenses may exert s torques although they are not very elongated. 5.6. Bar Fraction as a Function of B/Tand Bulge Index As outlined in SS5.3, we found that as many as ~76% of bright spirals have bulges with n<=2; such bulges exist in barredand unbarred galaxies across a wide ra ngeof Hubble types, and their spread in B/Tis from 0.01 to 0.4, with most having B/T<=0.2. The variation of the bar fraction as a function of B/Tand bulge ncan provide important constraints on bulge formation scenarios ( SS5.8). Table 10 shows our results. The bar fraction declines with bulge index; ~65% of the spirals with low n<=2 bulges host bars while intermediate 2< n <4 bulges have a lower bar fraction ( ~38%). The high n>=4 bulges in the sample are unbarred, so the bar fraction is 0%. Systems with low B/Tare more likely to be the bar fraction is high ( ~68%). Systems with 0 .2< B/T < 0.4 and B/T>=0.4 have lower bar fraction ( ~42% and ~17%). Overall, Table 10 shows bulges with low n<=2 and low B/T<=0.2 preferentially exist in barred galaxies. This is consistent with earlier work (Odewahn 1996 ; Barazza et al. 2008; Marinova et al. 2008; Aguerri et al. 2008, in prep.) where an enhanc ed optical bar fraction is seen is galaxies with late Hubble types or low B/D. It may be tempting to infer this result to mean the formation pathway of two-thirds of low- B/Tbulges is related to bars in that spontaneous or/and tidally induced bars play a role in bulge formation (with the of such bulges may have been formed either by mechanism s like retrograde minor mergers or short-lived bars). We caution that this type of cause- effect relationship is not the only scenario consistent with this result. It may also be possible t hat bar favored in galaxies with low B/Tand no inner Lindblad resonances (ILR). Under the swing amplifier model with a feedback loop (Julian & Too mre 1966; Toomre 1981; Binney & Tremaine 1987) may be responsible for bar formation and partly account for the high bar fraction in galaxies of low B/T.- 25 - 5.7. Formation of Bulges Our observational results provide some interesting challenges for models of Anysuc cessful for the observed distribution of bulge B/Tandnin high mass ( as shown in Table 9 and Table 10. In particular, the following re sults must In terms of the overall distribution of bulge n, as much as ( ~74%) of high mass spirals have bulge n<=2: such bulges exist in barred and unbarred galaxies and their B/T ranges from 0.01 to 0.4, with most having B/T<=0.2 (Table 9). A moderate fraction (~24%) of high mass spirals have 2 < n <4, and just ( ~2%) have n>=4. 2. Theoretical models often make more robust predictions on the b ulge-to-total on the bulge index n, so we consider the empirical detail. We note that as much as ~66% of high mass spirals have bulges with B/T<=0.2 (Table 9). In terms of bar fraction, ~68% are barred (Table 10). 3. The fraction of bars rises among spirals with low bulge index n. About 63% of spirals with low n<=2 bulges host bars, while the bar fraction in spirals with 2 < n <4 bulges (44%) is two-thirds as large (Table 10). In a hierarchical Universe, there are several physical processe s that contribute to the assembly ofbulges: majormergers, minormergers, andsecular ev olution. expanding on our introduction in SS1. Major mergers, defined as those with mass ratio M1/M2>=1/4, typically destroy the extended outer stellar disks during violent relaxation, leaving behind a classical bulge. Such bulges are associated with modest-to-high bulge S' ersic indices, in t he range 2 < n <6 (Hopkins et al. 2008; Springel et al. 2005; Robertson et al. 2006; SS5.8) in simulations. This trend is also consistent with the fact that among ellipticals, high lumino sity ones tend to have a S' ersic index n >4, while low luminosity ones tend to have 2 <=n<=3.5 (Caon et al. 1993; Kormendy et al. 2008). The final S' ersic index depends on the amount of residual gas the settles into a somewhat disky component. Simulations by Hop kins et al. (2008) find that the S' ersic indices of remnants from 1:1 gas-rich major me rgers lie in the range of 2< n <4, with most above 2.5 (see Fig. 22). This body of evidence strongly s uggests that many bulges with n >2 might have a major merger origin. Minor mergers, typically defined as those with mass ratio 1 /10< M1/M2<1/4, do not destroy the stellar disk of the primary system, but can contrib ute to building bulges via- 26 - three pathways. Firstly, a fraction Fsatof the satellite's stellar mass can end up in the The valueof Fsatdepends onhowcentrally concentrated thein- falling satellite is. Typically, the more diffuse outer stellar body is tidally s tripped, while the central core sinks by dynamical friction to the central region (e.g ., Quinn et al. 1993; Walker et al. 1996). Secondly, a non-axisymmetric feature (e.g., a stellar b ar or bar-like feature) can be induced in the main disk, and gravitational torques exerted b y the feature can drive gas into the inner kpc (e.g., Hernquist & Mihos 1995; Jogee 2006 and r eferences therein), where subsequent SF forms a compact high v/sstellar component, or disky of the gas inflow happens during the merger phase and large ga s inflow rates (e.g., 1Mper year) may be generated. Thirdly, gas inflow can also be caused b y direct tidal torques from the companion (e.g., Hernquist & Mihos 1995; Eliche-Mo ral et al. 2006). It is to be noted that inthe simulations by Hernquist & Mihos (1995), the g asinflow generated features (e.g., bar-like features) in the inner pa rt of the disk is much larger thanthat caused bydirect tidal torques Inthe recent workof Eliche-Moral et al. (2006), N-body simulations of minor mergers followed by fits of 1D S' to the remnants, suggest that the bulge S' ersic index and B/Dratio can grow as a result of the central re-concentration of stellar disk material in t he primary system by tidal forces. Minor mergers are frequent under LCDM, and the likelihood of multiple successive minor mergers occurring during the formation of a galaxy is high. Bou rnaud, Jog, & Combes (2007) study the effects of repeated minor mergers on galaxy str ucture. They show that a disk galaxy undergoing successive minor mergers will eventually tran sform into an with an r1/4-law profile and high V/s. However, galaxy growth is not and the efficiency of minor mergers at creating elliptic als must be regulated by other mechanisms (e.g., cold gas accretion). In addition, the process of secular evolution can build a disky bulge (p merger events. Here a stellar bar or globally oval structu re in gasinflow into theinner kpc, where subsequent star f ormationformsa component (e.g., Kormendy 1993; Jogee 1999; KK04; Jogee , Scoville, &
Kenney 2005; Athanassoula 2005; Kormendy & Fisher 2005; Korme ndy 2008). This process is different from that of minor mergers in the sense that it happens in the quiescent phase of the galaxy, between minor or major merger events. The prevale nce of pseudobulges in galaxies of different Hubble types is discussed in KK04, and select exa mples of S0 galaxies with pseudobulges are also shown in Kormendy & Cornell (2004) and K K04. The present-day bulge mass can be written as the sum of mass cont ributed from (6)- 27 - where
*fmajis the percentage of the bulge stellar mass, which is built by major mer gers,
*fmin1is the percentage of the bulge stellar mass, which is built during minor m ergers from stars of the satellite. This depends on the fraction Fsatof the satellite's stellar mass, which ends up in the central region of the primary galaxy durin g each the percentage of the bulge stellar mass, which is built during minor m ergers from gas inflow caused by a tidally induced bar.
*fmin3is the percentage of the stellar mass, which is built during minor merge rs from gas inflow caused by tidal torques from the the percentage of the stellar mass, which is built secularly between merger events from gas inflow caused by bars or ovals InSS5.8, we compare our derived distribution of bulge nandB/Twith that model major and minor mergers, but not secular evolut ion. The main goal of the model is to see whether bulges built via major mergers can acc ount for the large fraction of high mass spirals with bulges of low B/Tor/and low n. A secondary goal is to see if a first order simplified prescription for minor mergers can br oadly account for We stress here that bulge-building during minor merg ers is modeled in a very simple way: all the stars in the satellite are assumed to contribute to the bulge of the larger galaxy (i.e., Fsat= 100%), and bulge-building via gas inflow driven through tidal torque s and via gravitational torques from induced bars are ignored (i.e., fmin2= 0, and fmin3= 0). Furthermore, the models entirely ignore secular evolution between mergers. In a future paper, these extra terms will be addressed and a comprehensive p icture built of the of minor mergers and secular processes in making prese nt-day bulges. 5.8. Comparison of B/TWith Hierarchical Models of Galaxy Evolution We compare our data with the predictions from cosmological semi-an alytical models based on Khochfar & Burkert (2005) and Khochfar & Silk (2006). W e briefly describe the models first. The merger trees of dark matter (DM) halos are deriv ed by using the 1974),asinSome rville &Kolatt(1999). When two DM halos merge, the merger time scale of the galaxies is calculated by considering the- 28 - timescale it would take the satellite galaxies to reach the central gala xy at the center of the halo via dynamical friction (e.g., Kauffmann et al. 1999; Springel et al. 2001). The which includes radiative cooling, star formation, and feedb ack from supernovae, is treated via semi-analytic prescriptions (see Khochfar & Silk (2006) and references mass inside the dark matter halos is divided between hot gas , cold gas, and stars. The hot gas is initially shock-heated to the halo virial temperature. A s the gas it settles down into a rotationally supported disk at the halo ce nter. Cold disk gas is allowed to fragment and subsequently form stars according to th e (Kennicutt 1998). Star formation is regulated by feedback fro m supernovae using the prescription in Kauffmann et al. (1999). Major mergers are typically considered as those with stellar mass ra the simulations, one assumes that during a major merger any exis ting stellar disk is destroyed, gas is converted to stars with some star formation effi ciency (SFE), and all stars present undergo violent relaxation to form a bulge. Therefore, th e bulge-to-total stellar mass ratio (B/T) of a bulge immediately after a major merger is always one. Note that the SFE during a major merger is not assumed to be 100% as there is mounting evidence from SPH simulations (Springel & Hernquist 2005; Cox et al. 2008) that not all cold gas is converted to stars. Instead, the burst efficiency defined by Cox et al. (2008 ) is applied to control the fraction of stars formed due to the interaction. This efficiency is de pendent on the relative masses of merging galaxies and is expressed (7) wheree1:1is the burst efficiency for a 1:1 merger and gfixes the dependence on mass ratio; Cox et al. (2008) find e1:1= 0.55 andg= 0.69. The remaining fraction (1- e) of gas is added to the gaseous disk and can start making stars. As stated above, immediately after a major merger, the remnant is a bulge with a B/T equal to one. As time proceeds, B/Tfalls because a stellar disk grows around the bulge as hot gas in the halo cools, settles into a disk, and forms stars. The fo rmation of stars by any residual cold gas left at the end of the major merger also helps to gr ow the disk. Thus B/T falls until the next major merger happens, at which point B/Tis reset to one in the models. The bulge may also grow in stellar mass due to minor mergers. Minor mer gers are defined as mergers with mass ratio 1 /10< M1/M2<1/4, and the stellar disk of the large companion is not destroyed during such mergers. The models assum e that during minor mergers, all the stars in the satellite are added to the bulge of the h ost, while the gas settles in the disk. When DM halos grow by accretion or minor mergers, the ho t gas that comes in with a satellite is immediately stripped and added to the hot gas compo nent of the host.- 29 - The cold gas in the disk of the satellite is only added to the cold gas of th e host if they merge. Until they merge the satellite is using up its own cold gas to mak e stars. Fig. 23 shows the relationship between the present-day B/Tof a a high mass ( M>=
1.0x1010M) spiral and the redshift zlastof its last major merger. As expected, systems where the last major merger occurred at earlier times, have had mo re time to grow a disk and have a lower B/T. The dispersion in the present-day B/Tat a given zlastis due to the different times spent by a galaxy in terms of being a satellite versus a c entral galaxy in a DM halo, since the cooling of gas and the growth of a disk is stopped when a galaxy becomes a satellite. Thus, galaxies that became a satellite galaxy shortly after their last major merger stayed at high B/T. Conversely, galaxies that continued to be a central galaxy for a lo ng time after their last major merger will have low B/T. The present-day B/Tof a high mass ( M>=1.0x1010M) spiral depends on its major merger history. In particular, we note from Fig. 23 that a high mass which has undergone a past major merger since z<=2 will end up hosting a present- dayB/T >0.2. In effect, a high mass spiral can have a present-day B/T<=0.2only if its last major merger occurred at z >2(lookback times >10Gyr). The predicted distribution of present-day B/Tdepends on the galaxy merger history in the models and it is relevant to ask how well the latter is constrained o bservationally. Over the redshift range z~0.24 to 0.80 (lookback times of 3 to 7 Gyr), recent studies by Jogee et al. (2008, 2009) find that among high mass ( M>=2.5x1010M) galaxies, ~10% of galaxies are undergoing mergers of mass ratio >1/10, and~3% are undergoing major mergers of mass ratio >1/4. These findings agree within a factor of less than ~2 with the merger rates from the models of Khochfar & Burkert (2001) over z~0.24 to 0.80. At higher redshifts, the empirical merger rate/fraction is uncertain due to relatively modes t volumes and Conselice et al. 2003). The models used here (Khochfar & Burk ert 2001) agree with this trend and predict that ~13.5% and ~20% of high mass ( M>=1.0x1010M) spirals have undergone major mergers since z<=2 andz<=4, respectively (see Table 11). The contribution of galaxies with different merger histories to the pr esent-day B/T distribution are shown in Table 11. The top and middle parts of the tab le describe systems with and without major mergers since z<=2 andz<=4, respectively. In the model, ~13.5%
of present-day high mass ( M>=1.0x1010M) spirals, experienced a major merger since z<=2, high B/T ( ~0.1%) to have a low present-day B/T<=0.2. In contrast, the remaining ~86.5%
spirals experienced no major merger at z<=2, and most (67.2%) of them have a If the comparisons are extended to systems without a major me rger since- 30 - z<=4, the numbers are very similar (see middle part of Table between themodelan high mass spirals with present-day low B/T<=0.2 (~67% in the model versus ~66% in the data). The model contribution to low B/T<=0.2 comes almost entirely from galaxies, which have not had a major merger since z<=2 (see column 4 in Table 11). In fact, most of these galaxies have not even had a major merger since z<=4, as illustrated by the bottom part of Table 11. In the model, the fraction ( ~1.6%; column 3 of Table 11) of high mass spirals, which have undergone a major merger since z<=4and host a bulge with a is a factor of over thirty smaller than the observed fractio n (~66%) of high mass spirals with B/T<=0.2.Thus, bulges built via major mergers since z<=4 seriously fail to account for the bulges present in ~66% of high mass spirals. These results are also illustrated in Fig. 24, which shows the comparison between da ta and models for the cumulative fraction of high mass spirals as a function of present-da yB/T. It is also interesting to note from Table 11 that although the models r eproduce well the frequency of bulges with present-day low B/T<=0.2, they tend to over-produce the frequency of present-day high B/T >0.4 systems by nearly a factor of two ( ~14% in the model versus ~8% in the data; see columns 6 and 2 in middle part of Table 11). Most of this overproduction stems from major mergers at z<=4 (~13%; column 4 in middle part of Table 11). This suggests that major mergers, as currently modele d here, are building bulges too efficiently. One possible solution to this problem might relate to the suggestion by Hopkins ofbulge-building only on the mass ratio M1/M2of the merger, but also depends on the cold gas the disk. In their semi-analytic models, the entire stellar mass of th e relaxes, but the fraction of stellar mass in the primary disk t hat violently relaxes and adds to the bulge is M1/M2. This differs with our models where the entire primary stellar disk is always destroyed in a major merger. Furthermore, th e fraction Fof the total gas mass, which loses angular momentum, falls to the nucleus, and is t ransformed into stellar mass in a nuclear starburst, is In particular, Fis lower for more gas- rich disks, causing a suppression of the burst efficiency in gas-rich s ystems, and a reduction in the stellar mass that ends up in the bulge built during the major merg er. The predictions for the distribution of B/Tfrom the Hopkins et al. (2009) models are shown in the bottom of Table 11, with major mergers considered as those with baryonic g alaxy-galaxy mass ratio
>/1/3. Due to the reduced stellar mass that ends up in the bulge afte r a major merger, the Hopkins et al. (2009) models tend to yield lower B/Tafter such a merger. Thus, the models produce overall fewer high B/T >0.4 systems, and more intermediate 0.2 < B/T < 0.4 and- 31 - lowB/T<=0.2 systems (see column 6 in Table 11). Nonetheless, the predictions a re not very different from the models by Khochfar & Burkert (2005) and K hochfar & Silk (2006), which we use in this paper. In particular, the conclusion that the larg e frequency of high mass (M>=1.0x1010M) spirals with low B/T<=0.2 bulges can only be accounted for by spirals without a major merger since z<=2 also holds with the Hopkins et al. (2009) models. Thus, we conclude that the observed large frequency ( ~66%) of high mass ( M>=
1.0x1010M) spirals with low present-day B/T<=0.2can be accounted for in our and models by high mass spirals, which have not und ergone a major merger since z<=2, and most of which have not even experienced a major merger ov er the last 12 Gyr sincez<=4.In the models, most of these present-day low B/T<=0.2 bulges are built z<=4. Asnotedearlier, mergers, but do not explicitly incorporate secular processe s (seeSS5.7). In processes may contribute to the building of present-day lo wB/T<=0.2 bulges, and are particularly relevant at z<=2, where major mergers cannot build such bulges. For completeness, we further explore how sensitive are our result s to other assumptions made in the data and models of Khochfar & Burkert (2005) and Khoc hfar & Silk (2006):
*How sensitive are the results to the mass ratio used to separate ma jor and minor mergers? Fig. 25 is similar to Fig. 24 except that the model now define s major mergers as those with mass ratio M1/M2>=1/6. In this case, about 30% of the model spirals undergo major mergers since z<=4 rather than ~20%. The overall model F(black dashed line) now under-predicts the data Fby about 10% for B/T >0.2. However, the main conclusion that bulges built by major mergers since z<=4 cannot account for most of the low B/T<=0.2 bulges, present in a large percentage ( ~66%) of spirals still holds.
*How sensitive are the results to the B/Tcut used to define spirals? Fig. 26 is similar to Fig. 24 except that here spirals are considered to be systems wit h than 0.75 in the models, and a corresponding cut is applied to t he data points. The results are similar to Fig. 24
*How sensitive are the results to our assumed constant H-band mass-to-light ( M/L) for the bulge, disk, and bar? Fig. 27 is similar to Fig. 24 except that the B/Tof all the observed galaxies has been multiplied by a factor of two, in order to t est what would happen in the case where the M/Lratio of the bulge in H-band is twice as high as that of the disk and bar. This could happen in an extreme example where th e dominant bulge stellar population was much older (e.g. 12 Gyr) than the age of t he dominant disk stellar population (e.g., 3 Gyr). In such a case, the fraction of h igh mass would change from ~66% in Fig. 24 to ~55%, and deviate from the- 32 - model overall model F(black dashed line) by ~20%. However, the main conclusion that bulges built by major mergers since z<=4 cannot account for most of the low B/T<=0.2 bulges, present in a large percentage ( ~55%) of spirals still holds. Finally, it is important to note that so far we have compared the data and model only in terms of bulge B/T, but not in terms of bulge index nor in terms of bar fraction. In effect, we have only shown that the models reproduce a subset of t he results outlined in points (1)-(3) of SS5.7. Since the semi-analytic models do not produce a distribution of bu lge indexn, we resort to presenting only an indirect comparison in Table 12. We a ssume that bulges, which form in major mergers have a bulge n >2.5. This assumption is based the evidence presented in SS5.7. Thus, in Test 1 of Table 12, we compare the fraction ( ~66%) of galaxies in the semi-analytic models having B/T<=0.2 and no major merger since z<=4, to the observed fraction ( ~65%) of galaxies with B/T<=0.2 and bulge n<=2.5. There is close agreement between the two values. In Test 2 of Table 12, the frac tion (~12.7%) of model galaxies with B/T >0.4 and no major merger since z<=4 is a factor of ~3 higher than the fraction ( ~3.5%) of high mass spirals with B/T >0.4 and bulge n >2.5. Similarly, the fraction ( ~1.6%) of model galaxies with B/T<=0.2 and a past major merger since z<=4 is also a factor of ~2 higher than the observed fraction ( ~0.9%) of high mass spirals with B/T<=0.2 and bulge n >2.5 (Test 3, Table 12). Thus, in terms of bulge B/Tandn, there is good agreement between data and model for Test 1 (involving mod el galaxies with no major mergers since z<=4). This suggests that the vast majority of bulges with likely formed in galaxies having had no major merger since z<=4. However, the agreement is less good for Tests 2 and 3 (involving model galaxies with major mergers since z<=4) and this suggests that the models may be building bulges a little bit to o a major merger, in agreement with the conclusion reached ea rlier. What about the role of bars in the formation of these bulges of low B/Tand low n? A detailed direct comparison with the semi-analytic models is not possib le as the role of bars is not yet modeled, but related comparisons are possible. First , it is important to note that bar-driven gas inflow into the inner kpc and the subseque nt building of disky stellar components or 'pseudobulges' (see SS1) can happen in both isolated galaxies and in minor mergers ( SS5.7), since bars can be spontaneously induced in an isolated disk or tidally induced during an interaction or minor merger. The triggering o f a bar is favored in a prograde interaction or minor merger. Thus, bulge-building via ind uced bars is more likely to happen in prograde rather than retrograde minor mergers . Statistically about half of minor mergers might be prograde or prograde-like, and half retr ograde. Thus, one would expect bars to be induced in only half of the minor mergers. If this as sumption is correct and if most of the mass in bulges with present-day B/T<=0.2 is formed in minor mergers, then one would expect only about half of these bulges to host bars. This is close to what is- 33 - observed, as shown by Table 10. We see that ~63% of high mass spirals with low n<=2 bulges and ~68% of spirals with low B/T<=0.2 bulges host bars. This suggests that in high mass spirals, spontaneous and/or tidally induced bars mayplay a part in forming up to two-thirds of B/T<=0.2 orn<=2 bulges. The remaining one-third of such bulges may have been formed either by mechanisms that do not involve bars (e.g., ret rograde minor mergers) or by bars that are not long-lived. 6. Summary The properties of galaxy components (bulges, disks, and bars) in t he local Universe provide key constraints for models of galaxy evolution. Most previo us focused on two-component bulge-disk decomposition, and ign ored the contribution of the bar even in strongly barred galaxies. However, as shown by t his work and other recent studies (e.g., Laurikainen et al. 2005; Laurikainen et al. 2007 ; Reese et al. 2007), it is important to include the bar component in the 2 Ddecomposition, in order to the bulge-to-total ratio ( B/T) and disk properties. In this paper we have developed an iterative 2 D, bulge-disk-bar decomposition technique using GALFIT and applied it to H-band images to a complete sample (S1) of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) spirals from the OSU Bright Spiral Galaxy Survey (OSUBSGS). M>=1.0x1010M. We performed two-component bulge-disk decomposition, as well as three-component bulge- disk-bar decomposition on the 2 Dlight distribution of all galaxies, taking into account the PSF. We use an exponential profile for the disk, and S' ersic profiles for the bulge and bar. A number of quantitative indicators, including bar classification from e llipse fits, are used to pick either the bulge-disk-bar decomposition or bulge-disk decompo sition, as the best final fit for a galaxy. Our main results are the following. 1. We find that it is necessary to include the bar component in 2 Ddecomposition of barred galaxies, otherwise, the bulge-to-total ratio ( B/T) will be overestimated and the disk properties may be skewed. Examples of the effect of includin g the bar are shown for the prominently barred galaxies NGC 4643 (Figure 5, Table 3) and NGC 4548 (Figure 6, Table 4). 2. We find that out of the 143 inclined ( i<=70*) spirals in our sample, 75 of 143 or ~52% are better fit with a Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition than a Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition. There are also eight galaxies with pure bar-disk fits. The resulting H-band bar fraction, defined as the fraction of disk galaxies that- 34 - are barred, is 58 .0+-4.13% (84 of 143). This fraction is in excellent agreement with theH-band bar fraction of 60% reported by MJ07, based on ellipse fits of the same OSUBSGS sample, with a more conservative inclination cut ( images tend to trace the overall mass fairly well and are not o verly impacted by extinction and age gradients. We therefore assume a constant mass-to-light ( M/L) in theH-band for the bulge, disk, and bar, and assume their H-band light fraction is a measure of their mass fraction. For our sample S1 of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) spirals with a mass-weighted mean Hubble type of Sab-Sb, we find that 71.6% of the stellar mass is in disks, 9.6% is in ste llar bars and 18.9% is in bulges (with 10.4% in n >2 bulges and 8.4% in n<=2 bulges). If disks and bars are much younger (e.g., ~3 Gyr old ) than bulges (e.g., ~12 Gyr old), then our prescription would underestimate the true B/Tby a factor of <=2. On the other hand, if the bulge is younger than the disk and happens to harbor a significant young population of massive stars, then our prescriptio n trueB/Tmass ratio, and make our current results on the high fraction of low B/T bulges (see point 4 below) even stronger. 4. B/T,bulgeS' ersicindex, Fig. 15). Only a small fraction ( ~1%) of bright spirals have high n>=4 bulges; such bulges lie primarily in S0/a to Sab, and have a large B/T >0.2. A moderate fraction (~22%) have intermediate 2 < n <4 bulges; these exist in barred and unbarred S0/a to Sd, and their B/Tspans a wide range (0.03 to 0.5) with a mean of 0.29. Finally, a strikingly large fraction ( ~76%) of bright spirals have low n<=2bulges; such bulges exist in barred and unbarred galaxies across a wide range of H ubble types, and their B/Tvaries from 0.01 to 0.4, with most having B/T<=0.2. 5. Bulges with very high B/T(>0.4) exist primarily in galaxies with high mass ( M>
6x1010M) and early types (S0/a to Sab). Bulges with very low B/T(<0.1) lie primarily in lower mass galaxies with later morphologies (Sb to Sc). As many as
~69%of bright spirals have bulges with B/T<=0.2: these bulges are pervasive and exist across the whole spectrum of S0/a to Sd (Figure 14). 6. Modeling bars with 2 Ddecomposition allows us to measure bar properties and the bar-to-total ratio (Bar/ T), which is a measure of bar strength. There is a wide range (~0.03 to~0.47) in the individual Bar/ Tat a given Hubble type. The mean Bar/ T remains fairly constant with Hubble type from Sa to Sb, but shows a p ossible weak decline by about 0.1 from Sb to Sc (See Figure 19 and Figure 20). The b ar fraction (Table 10) declines with B/T; it is highest ( ~68%) for bright spirals with B/T<=0.2, and lower ( ~36%) by nearly a factor of two in spirals with B/T >0.2.- 35 - It may be tempting to infer this to mean the formationof two-thirds of low-B/Tbulges is related to spontaneous or/and tidally induced bars. Such a cause -effect relationship is not the only scenario consistent with this result. It may also be pos sible that are favored in galaxies with low B/Tand no inner Lindblad these conditions, the swing amplifier model with a feedback loo p may be re- sponsible for bar formation and partly account for the high bar fra ction in galaxies of lowB/T. 7. We compare the observed distribution of bulge B/Tandnin high mass ( M>=1.0x 1010M) spirals with predictions from a set of LCDM cosmological semi-analyt ical models (Table 11, Table 12, and Figs. 24 to 27). Major mergers are c onsidered as those with stellar mass ratio M1/M2>=1/4. In the models, a high mass spiral can have a bulge with a present-day low B/T<=0.2 only if it did not undergo a major merger since z<=2 (Fig. 23). The model merger history shows that only ~13.5%
and~20% of the high mass spirals experience major mergers since z<=2 The fraction ( ~1.6%) of high mass spirals which have undergone a major merger since z<=4 and host a bulge with a present-day low B/T<=0.2 isa factor of over thirty smaller than the observed fraction ( ~66%) of high mass spirals 11). Thus, bulges built via major mergers since z<=4, over the last 12 Gyr, seriously fail to account for most of the low B/T<=0.2bulges present in two- thirds of high-mass spirals . The overall picture that emerges is that the observed large frequency ( ~66%) of high mass ( M>=1.0x1010M) spirals with low can be accounted for in our hierarchical models by high mass spirals, which have not undergone a major merger since z<=2, and most of which have not even experienced a major merger since z<=4.Most of these present-day low B/T<=0.2 bulges are likely to have been built by a combination of minor mergers an d/or since z<=4. S.J. and T.W. acknowledge support from the National Aeronautics a nd Space Admin- istration (NASA) LTSA grant NAG5-13063, NSF grant AST-060774 8, and GO-10861 from STScI, which is operated by AURA, In c., for NASA, We thank Chien Peng for technical assistance in the o peration of GALFIT. We acknowledge the usage of the Hyperleda database (http://leda .univ-lyon1.fr). This re- search has made use of the NASA/IPAC Extragalactic Database (N ED) which is operated by the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technolo gy, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.- 36 P. D., Driver, S. P., Graham, A. W., Cameron, E., Liske, J., & de Pr opris, R. 2006, MNRAS, 371, 2 Athanassoula, E. 2002, ApJL, 569, E. 2003, MNRAS, 341, E. 2005, MNRAS, 358, 1477 Balcells, M., Graham, A. W., Dom' inguez-Palmero, L., & Peletier, R. F. 2 003, ApJL, M., Graham, A. W., & Peletier, R. F. 2007, ApJ, 665, 1084 Barazza, F. D., Jogee, S., & Marinova, I. 2007, in IAU Symposium 235 , Galaxy Evolu- tion across the Hubble Time, ed. F. Combes & J. Palous (Cambridge: C Press), 76 Barazza, F. D., Jogee, S., & Marinova, I. 2008, ApJ, 675, 1194 Barrett, P. E., & Bridgman, W. T. 1999, in ASP Conf. Ser. 172, Astr onomical Data and Systems VIII, ed. D. M. Mehringer, R. L. Plante, & D . A. Roberts (San Francisco: Astronomical Society of the Pacific), 483 Bell, E. F., McIntosh, D. H., Katz, N., & Weinberg, M. D. 2003, ApJS, 1 49, 289 Benedict, F. G., Smith, B. J., & Kenney, J. D. P. 1996, AJ, 111, 1861 Berentzen, I., Shlosman, I., & Jogee, S. 2006, ApJ, 637, 582 Binney, J., & Tremaine, S. 1987, Galactic Dynamics (Princeton: Princ eton Univ. Press) Blanton, M. R., Lupton, R. H., Schlegel, D. J., Strauss, M. A., Brinkma nn, J., Fukugita, M., & Loveday, J. 2005, ApJ, 631, 208 Block, D. L., Bournaud, F., Combes, F., Puerari, I., & Buta, R. 2002, A&A, 394, L35 B oker, T., Laine, S., van der Marel, R. P., Sarzi, M., Rix, H.-W., Ho, L. C ., & Shields, J. C. 2002, AJ, 123, 1389 Bottinelli, L., Gouguenheim, L., Paturel, G., & Teerikorpi, P. 1995, A&A , 296, 64 Bournaud, F., Jog, C. J., & Combes, F. 2007, A&A, 476, 1179- 37 - Bureau, M., & Athanassoula, E. 2005, ApJ, 626, 159 Burkert, A. M., & D'Onghia, E. 2004, in Penetrating Bars Through Ma sks of Cosmic Dust: the Hubble Tuning Fork Strikes a New Note, ed. D. L. Block, I. Puera ri, K. C. Freeman, R. Groess, & E. K. Block (Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Pu blishers), 341 Burkert, A., & Naab, T. 2004, in Carnegie Observatories Astrophy sics Series, Vol. 1: Co- evolution of Black Holes and Galaxies, ed. L. C. Ho (Cambridge: Cambr idge Univ. Press), 421 Buta, R., Block, D. L., & Knapen, J. H. 2003, AJ, 126, 1148 Buta, R., Vasylyev, S., Salo, H., & Laurikainen, E. 2005, AJ, 130, 506 Byun, Y. I., & Freeman, K. C. 1995, ApJ, 448, 563 Caon, N., Capaccioli, M., & D'Onofrio, M. 1993, MNRAS, 265, ed. E. & J. L. Sanz (New York: Sp ringer-Verlag), 53 Charlot, S., Worthey, G., & Bressan, A. 1996, ApJ, 457, 625 Cole, S., Lacey, C. G., Baugh, C. M., & Frenk, C. S. 2000, MNRAS, 319 , 168 Conselice, C. J., Bershady, M. A., Dickinson, M., & Papovich, C. 2003, AJ, 126, 1183 Combes, F., Debbasch, F., Friedli, D., & Pfenniger, D. 1990, A&A, 233 , 82 Combes, F., & Sanders, R. H. 1981, A&A, 96, 164 Cox, T. J., Jonsson, P., Somerville, R. S., Primack, J. R., & Dekel, A. 20 08, MNRAS, V. P., & Sellwood, J. A. 1998, ApJL, 493, L5 Debattista, V. P., & Sellwood, J. A. 2000, ApJ, 543, 704 de Jong, R. S. 1996, A&A Suppl., 118, 557 Depoy, D. L., Atwood, B., Byard, P. L., Frogel, J., & O'Brien, T. P. 199 3, Proc. SPIE, 1946, 667 de Souza, R. E., Gadotti, D. A., & dos Anjos, S. 2004, ApJS, 153, 41 1- 38 - de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., & Corwin, H. G. 1976, Secon d Reference Cata- logue of Bright Galaxies, University of Texas Monographs in Astrono my, of Texas Press) de Vaucouleurs, G., de Vaucouleurs, A., Corwin, H. G., Jr., Buta, R. J ., Paturel, G., &
Fouque, P. 1991, Third Reference Catalogue of Bright Galaxies, Vo lume 1-3, (New York: E., Burkert, A., Murante, G., & Khochfar, S. 2006, MNRAS , 372, 1525 Driver, S. P., Liske, J., Cross, N. J. G., De Propris, R., & Allen, P. D. 20 05, MNRAS, 360, 81 Driver, S. P., et al. 2006, MNRAS, 368, 414 Drory, N., Bender, R., & Hopp, U. 2004, ApJL, 616, L103 Efstathiou, G., Ellis, R. S., & Peterson, B. A. 1988, MNRAS, 232, M. C., Balcells, M., Aguerri, J. A. L., & Gonz' alez-Garc' ia , A. C. 2006, A&A, 457, 91 Elmegreen, B. G. 1994, ApJL, 425, L73 Elmegreen, B. G., & Elmegreen, D. M. 1985, ApJ, 288, 438 Elmegreen, B. G., Elmegreen, D. M., Chromey, F. R., Hasselbacher, D . A., & Bissell, B. A. 1996, AJ, 111, 2233 Eskridge, P. B., et al. 2000, AJ, 119, 536 Eskridge, P. B., et al. 2002, ApJS, 143, 73 Fisher, D. B., & Drory, N. 2008, AJ, 136, 773 Gadotti, D., & Kauffmann, G. 2007, in IAU Symposium 241, Stellar Popu lations as Build- ing Blocks of Galaxies, ed. A. Vazdekis & R. F. Peletier (Cambridge: Ca Press), 507 Graham, A. W. 2001, AJ, 121, 820 Graham, A. W., & Worley, C. C. 2008, MNRAS, 752 Hernquist, L. & Mihos, J. C. 1995, ApJ, 448, 41- 39 - Ho, L. C., Filippenko, A. V., & Sargent, W. L. W. 1997, ApJS, 112, 315 Hopkins, P. F., Cox, T. J., Dutta, S. N., Hernquist, L., Kormendy, J., & Lauer, T. R. 2008, ArXiv e-prints, 805, P. F., et al. 2009, ApJ, submitted L. K., & Malkan, M. A. 1999, ApJ, 516, 660 Jogee, S. 1999, Ph.D. thesis, Yale S. 2006, in Physics of Active Galactic Nuclei at all Scales, ed. D. Alloin, R. Johnson,
& P. Lira (Berlin: Springer), 143 Jogee, S., Kenney, J. D. P., & Smith, B. J. 1999, ApJ, 526, 665 Jogee, S., Scoville, N., & Kenney, J. D. P. 2005, ApJ, 630, 837 Jogee, S., et al. 2004, ApJL, 615, L105 Jogee, S. 2008, in 'The Galaxy Disk in a Cosmological Context', Procee dings of IAU Sympo- sium 254, Eds. J. Andersen, J. Bland-Hawthorn & B. Nordstrom, h eld in Copenhagen in June 2008, in press S., et al. 2009, ApJ, accepted Julian, W. H., & Toomre, A. 1966, ApJ, 146, 810 Kauffmann, G., Colberg, J. M., Diaferio, A., & White, S. D. M. 1999, MNR AS, 303, 188 Kauffmann, G., et al. 2003, MNRAS, 341, 33 Kautsch, S. J., Grebel, E. K., Barazza, F. D., & Gallagher, J. S., III 2 006, A&A, 445, 765 Kenney, J. D. P., Carlstrom, J. E., & Young, J. S. 1993, ApJ, 418, 6 87 Kennicutt, R. C., Jr. 1998, ApJ, 498, 541 Khochfar, S., & Burkert, A. 2001, ApJ, 561, 517 Khochfar, S., & Burkert, A. 2005, MNRAS, 359, 1379 Khochfar, S., & Silk, J. 2006, MNRAS, 370, 902 Knapen, J. H., Beckman, J. E., Heller, C. H., Shlosman, I., & de Jong, R . S. 1995, ApJ, 454, 623- 40 - Knapen, J. H., Shlosman, I., & Peletier, R. F. 2000, ApJ, 529, 93 Koda, J., Milosavljevic, M., & Shapiro, P. R. 2007, preprint (arXiv:071 J.1993, inIAUSymposium 153, GalacticBulges, ed. H.De Kluwer), 209 Kormendy, J. 2008, in IAU Symposium 245, Formation and Evolution o f Galaxy Bulges, ed. M. Bureau, E. Athanassoula, & B. Barbury (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press), in press Kormendy, J., & Cornell, M. E. 2004, in Penetrating Bars Through Ma sks of Cosmic Dust: the Hubble Tuning Fork Strikes a New Note, ed. D. L. Block, I. Puera ri, K. C. Freeman, R. Groess, & E. K. Block (Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Pu blishers), 261 Kormendy, J., & Fisher, D. B. 2005, Rev. Mex. AA Ser. Conf., 23, 10 1 J., & Fisher, D. B. 2008, in Formation and Evolution of Gala xy Disks, ed. J. G. Funes, S. J., & E. M. Corsini (San Francisco: ASP), 297 Kormendy, J., Fisher, D. B., Cornell, M. E., & Bender, R. 2008, ApJS, in J., & Kennicutt, R. C., Jr. 2004, ARAA, 42, 603 (KK04) Kroupa, P., Tout, C. A., & Gilmore, G. 1993, MNRAS, 262, 545 Laine, S., Shlosman, I., Knapen, J. H., & Peletier, R. F. 2002, ApJ, 56 7, 97 Laurikainen, E., Salo, H., & Buta, R. 2004, ApJ, 607, 103 Laurikainen, E., Salo, H., & Buta, R. 2005, MNRAS, 362, E., Salo, H., Buta, R., & Knapen, J. H. 2007, MNRAS, 381 , 401 Liske, J., Lemon, D. J., Driver, S. P., Cross, N. J. G., & Couch, W. J. 2 003, MNRAS, I., & Jogee, S. 2007, ApJ, 659, 1176 (MJ07) Marinova, I., et al. . 2008, ApJ, I., Shlosman, I., & Heller, C. 2006, ApJ, 637, 2 14- 41 - Men' endez-Delmestre, K., Sheth, K., Schinnerer, E., Jarrett, T. H., & Scoville, N. Z. 2007, ApJ, 657, 790 Mihos, J. C., & Hernquist, L. 1996, ApJ, 464, 641 Moorthy, B. K., & Holtzman, J. A. 2006, MNRAS, 371, 583 Mulchaey, J. S., & Regan, M. W. 1997, ApJL, 482, L135 Naab, T., & Burkert, A. 2001, ApJL, 555, L91 Naab, T., & Burkert, A. 2003, ApJ, 597, 893 Navarro, J. F., & Steinmetz, M. 2000, ApJ, 538, 477 Odewahn, S. C. 1996, in Barred Galaxies, IAU Coll. 157, ed. R. Buta, D. A. Crocker & B. G. Elmegreen, ASP Conf. Ser. 91 (San Francisco: ASP), 30 PaturelG., PetitC., PrugnielP., BroutyM ., DuboisP., Cambr' esy L., 2003, A&A, 412, 45 Peng, C. Y., Ho, L. C., Impey, C. D., & Rix, H.-W. 2002, AJ, 124, 266 Pfenniger, D., & Norman, C. 1990, ApJ, 363, 391 Press, W. H., & Schechter, P. 1974, ApJ, 187, S., Ho, L. C., Peng, C. Y., Filippenko, A. V., & Sargent, W. L. W. 2001, AJ, 122, 653 Reese, A. S., Williams, T. B., Sellwood, J. A., Barnes, E. I., & Powell, B. A. 2007, AJ, B., Bullock, J. S., Cox, T. J., Di Matteo, T., Hernquist, L ., Springel, V., &
Yoshida, N. 2006, ApJ, 645, 986 Robertson, B., Yoshida, N., Springel, V., & Hernquist, L. 2004, ApJ, 606, 32 Salucci, P., Yegorova, I. A., & Drory, N. 2008, MNRAS, 388, 159 Schechter, P. 1976, ApJ, 203, 297 Schlegel, D. J., Finkbeiner, D. P., & Davis, M. 1998, ApJ, 500, 525 Sheth, K., et al. 2008, ApJ, 675, 1141- 42 - Simard, L. 1998, in ASP Conf. Ser. 145, Astronomical Data Analysis Software and Systems VII, ed. R. Albrecht, R. N. Hook, & H. A. Bushouse (San Francisco : of the Pacific), 108 Simard, L., et al. 2002, ApJS, 142, 1 Somerville, R. S., & Kolatt, T. S. 1999, MNRAS, 305, 1 Springel, V., Di Matteo, T., & Hernquist, L. 2005, MNRAS, 361, 776 Springel, V., & Hernquist, L. 2005, ApJL, 622, L9 Springel, V., White, S. D. M., Tormen, G., & Kauffmann, G. 2001, MNRAS , 328, 726 Steinmetz, M., & Navarro, J. F. 2002, NewA, 7, 155 Toomre, A. 1981, in The Structure and Evolution of Normal Galaxies , ed. S. M. Fall &
D. Lynden-Bell (New York: Cambridge University Press), 111 Trujillo, I., Asensio Ramos, A., Rubi~ no-Mart' in, J. A., Graham, A. W ., Aguerri, J. A. L., Cepa, J., & Guti' errez, C. M. 2002, MNRAS, 333, 510 Tully, R. B. 1988, Nearby Galaxies Catalog (Cambridge: Cambridge Un iversity Press) Quinn, P. J., Hernquist, L., & Fullagar, D. P. 1993, ApJ, 403, 74 V' eron-Cetty, M.-P., & V' eron, P. 2006, A&A, 455, 773 Wadadekar, Y., Robbason, B., & Kembhavi, A. 1999, AJ, 117, 1219 Walker, I. R., Mihos, J. C., & Hernquist, L. 1996, ApJ, 460, 121 Warren, S. J., et al. 2007, MNRAS, 375, 213 Weinberg, M. D. 1985, MNRAS, 213, 451 This preprint was prepared with the AAS L ATEX macros v5.2.- 43 - Table 1. Sample S1 of Bright ( MB<= -19.3) Inclined ( i<=70*) Spirals in OSUBSGS (N=143) Galaxy Name Best Fit Hubble Type Bar Type D M BB-V M (RC3) (RC3) (Mpc) (mag) (mag) ( M) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) ESO138-10 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)cd A 15.75 -20.2 - - IC0239 SAB(rs)cd AB 15.21 -19.3 0.70 1. 34e+10 IC4444 Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)bc AB 28.82 -20.9 0.64 4.35e+10 IC5325 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)bc AB 19.39 -19.6 0.56 9.78e+ 09 NGC0150 SB(rs)bc B 20.57 -20.1 0.64 2.1 7e+10 NGC0157 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)bc AB 22.39 -21.4 0.59 5.81e +10 NGC0210 Bulge+Disk+Bar SAB(s)b AB 21.75 -20.4 0.71 3.77e+1 0 NGC0278 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)b AB 12.64 -19.5 0.64 1.24e+ 10 NGC0289 SAB(rs)bc AB 20.79 -20.2 0.73 3 .33e+10 NGC0428 SAB(s)m AB 15.96 -19.4 0.44 5.2 8e+09 NGC0488 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(r)b A 31.39 -21.8 0.87 2.44e+11 NGC0578 SAB(rs)c AB 20.89 -20.5 0.51 1. 87e+10 NGC0613 SB(rs)bc B 18.75 -20.8 0.68 4.9 2e+10 NGC0685 Bar+Disk SAB(r)c AB 16.29 -19.4 0.46 5.47e+09 NGC0779 Bulge+Disk+Bar SAB(r)b AB 18.54 -20.0 0.79 3.64e+1 0 NGC0864 SAB(rs)c AB 21.43 -20.6 0.55 2. 31e+10 NGC0908 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 19.07 -21.3 0.65 6.60e+10 NGC1042 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)cd AB 17.89 -20.2 0.54 1.63e +10 NGC1073 SB(rs)c B 16.29 -19.9 0.50 1.04 e+10 NGC1084 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 18.32 -20.6 0.58 2.64e+10 NGC1087 Bar+Disk SAB(rs)c AB 20.36 -20.6 0.52 2.09e+10 NGC1187 SB(r)c B 17.46 -20.2 0.56 1.66e +10 NGC1241 SB(rs)b B 28.50 -21.7 0.85 2.05 e+11 NGC1300 SB(rs)bc B 20.14 -20.9 0.68 5.3 9e+10 NGC1302 (R)SB(r)0 B 21.43 -20.2 0.89 6. 37e+10 NGC1309 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc A 27.86 -20.5 0.44 1.46e+10 NGC1317 Bulge+Disk+Bar SAB(r)a AB 18.11 -20.2 0.89 6.42e+1 0 NGC1350 (R')SB(r)ab B 18.11 -21.1 0.87 1.38e+11 NGC1371 SAB(rs)a AB 18.32 -20.0 0.90 5. 43e+10 NGC1385 PSF+Bar+Disk SB(s)cd B 18.75 -20.3 0.51 1.61e+10 NGC1511 Bulge+Disk SAa;pec A 16.18 -19.7 0.57 1.15e+10 NGC1559 PSF+Bar+Disk SB(s)cd B 15.32 -20.4 0.35 9.33e+09 NGC1703 PSF+Bulge+Disk SB(r)b B 18.64 -19.4 0.56 8.43e+09 NGC1792 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(rs)bc A 14.57 -20.5 0.68 3.71e+1 0 NGC1808 (R)SAB(s)a AB 11.57 -19.9 0.81 3.57e+10 NGC1964 SAB(s)b AB 21.43 -20.8 0.77 6.5 4e+10 NGC2090 Bulge+Disk+Bar SA(rs)c A 10.93 -19.3 0.79 1.90e+10 NGC2139 Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)cd AB 24.00 -20.3 0.36 8.35e+09 NGC2196 PSF+Bulge+Disk (R')SA(s)a A 30.86 -21.0 0.81 9.22e +10 NGC2442 SAB(s)bc;pec AB 18.32 -20.8 0. 82 8.28e+10 NGC2559 Bulge+Disk+Bar SB(s)bc;pec B 21.43 -21.0 - - NGC2566 Bulge+Disk (R')SB(rs)ab;pec B 22.61 -20.7 0.81 6.9 8e+10 NGC2775 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(r)ab A 18.21 -20.6 0.90 9.46e+10 NGC3059 Bar+Disk SB(rs)c B 15.86 -20.1 0.68 2.52e+10- 44 - Table Name Best Fit Hubble Type Bar Type D M BB-V M (RC3) (RC3) (Mpc) (mag) (mag) ( M) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) NGC3166 Bulge+Disk+Bar SAB(rs)0 AB 23.57 -20.2 0.93 7.41e+ 10 NGC3169 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)a;pec A 21.11 -20.3 0.85 6.09e +10 NGC3223 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)b A 40.82 -21.9 0.82 2.36e+11 NGC3227 SAB(s)a;pec AB 22.07 -20.1 0.8 2 4.42e+10 NGC3261 SB(rs)b B 35.79 -21.3 - - NGC3275 SB(r)ab B 45.43 -21.2 - - NGC3319 PSF+Bar+Disk SB(rs)cd B 12.32 -19.4 0.41 4.76e+09 NGC3338 SA(s)c A 24.43 -20.6 0.59 2.67e +10 NGC3423 Bulge+Disk SA(s)cd A 11.68 -19.5 0.45 5.89e+09 NGC3504 Bulge+Disk+Bar (R)SAB(s)ab AB 21.43 -20.5 0.72 4.0 6e+10 NGC3513 Bulge+Disk+Bar SB(rs)c B 18.21 -19.9 0.43 7.52e+09 NGC3583 Bulge+Disk+Bar SB(s)b B 36.43 -20.8 - - NGC3596 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)c AB 24.64 -19.6 - - NGC3646 PSF+Bulge+Disk Ring - 59.79 -22.9 0.65 2.82e+11 NGC3675 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)b A 13.71 -20.2 - - NGC3684 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(rs)bc A 25.07 -19.4 0.62 1.00e+1 0 NGC3686 SB(s)bc B 25.18 -19.6 0.57 9.97 e+09 NGC3705 SAB(r)ab AB 18.21 -19.9 0.79 3. 15e+10 NGC3726 SAB(r)c AB 18.21 -20.6 0.49 1.9 3e+10 NGC3810 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(rs)c A 18.11 -20.1 0.58 1.72e+10 NGC3885 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)0 A 29.79 -19.6 0.95 4.62e+10 NGC3887 SB(r)bc B 20.68 -20.4 - - NGC3893 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)c AB 18.21 -19.9 - - NGC3938 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 18.21 -20.0 0.52 1.23e+10 NGC3949 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc AB 18.21 -19.9 0.45 8.66e+0 9 NGC4027 Bar+Disk SB(s)dm B 27.43 -20.6 0.54 2.25e+10 NGC4030 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc A 27.75 -20.8 - - NGC4051 SAB(rs)bc AB 18.21 -20.0 0.65 1 .95e+10 NGC4062 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 10.39 -19.5 0.76 2.07e+10 NGC4123 SB(r)c B 17.68 -19.8 0.61 1.50e +10 NGC4145 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)d AB 22.18 -20.1 0.51 1.34e+ 10 NGC4151 (R')SAB(rs)ab AB 21.75 -20.1 0 .73 2.93e+10 NGC4212 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAc A 18.00 -20.4 0.67 3.28e+10 NGC4254 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 18.00 -22.6 0.57 1.61e+11 NGC4293 (R)SB(s)0 B 18.21 -20.1 0.90 5. 94e+10 NGC4303 Bulge+Disk+Bar SAB(rs)bc AB 16.29 -21.8 0.53 6.76e +10 NGC4314 SB(rs)a B 10.39 -19.8 0.85 3.69 e+10 NGC4394 (R)SB(r)b B 18.00 -19.4 0.85 2. 61e+10 NGC4414 SA(rs)c A 10.39 -20.0 0.84 4.38 e+10 NGC4450 SA(s)ab A 18.00 -21.9 0.82 2.22 e+11 NGC4487 SAB(rs)cd AB 21.32 -19.6 - - NGC4490 PSF+Bulge+Disk SB(s)d;pec B 8.36 -21.7 0.43 4.10e+ 10 NGC4527 Bulge+Disk+Bar SAB(s)bc AB 14.46 -21.5 0.86 1.87e+ 11 NGC4548 SB(rs)b B 18.00 -20.8 0.81 7.85 e+10- 45 - Table Name Best Fit Hubble Type Bar Type D M BB-V M (RC3) (RC3) (Mpc) (mag) (mag) ( M) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) NGC4593 (R)SB(rs)b B 42.32 -20.8 - - NGC4618 PSF+Bar+Disk SB(rs)m B 7.82 -19.3 0.44 4.62e+09 NGC4643 Bulge+Disk+Bar SB(rs)0 B 27.54 -19.9 0.96 6.49e+10 NGC4647 Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)c AB 18.00 -19.8 0.65 1.67e+10 NGC4651 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(rs)c A 18.00 -19.6 0.57 1.05e+10 NGC4654 Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)cd AB 18.00 -20.6 0.60 2.99e+10 NGC4665 SB(s)0 B 19.18 -19.3 - - NGC4689 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(rs)bc A 18.00 -20.7 0.65 3.84e+1 0 NGC4691 (R)SB(s)0;pec B 24.11 -19.6 0. 58 1.04e+10 NGC4698 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)ab A 18.00 -19.9 0.91 5.15e+10 NGC4699 Bulge+Disk+Bar SAB(rs)b AB 27.54 -21.5 0.89 2.06e+ 11 NGC4772 SA(s)a A 17.46 -19.4 0.92 3.30e +10 NGC4775 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)d A 28.50 -20.4 - - NGC4781 PSF+Bulge+Disk SB(rs)d B 24.11 -20.8 - - NGC4818 SAB(rs)ab;pec AB 23.04 -19.7 0 .89 3.88e+10 NGC4856 SB(s)0 B 22.61 -20.2 0.99 9.04e +10 NGC4902 SB(r)b B 42.00 -21.4 0.69 8.33e +10 NGC4930 SB(rs)b B 37.50 -21.2 0.90 1.61 e+11 NGC4939 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc A 47.46 -22.2 0.64 1.43e+11 NGC4941 PSF+Bulge+Disk (R)SAB(r)ab AB 6.86 -19.4 0.84 2.50 e+10 NGC4995 SAB(rs)b AB 30.00 -20.6 0.87 8. 25e+10 NGC5054 Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc A 29.25 -21.1 0.76 8.31e+10 NGC5085 Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 30.96 -19.3 0.87 2.54e+10 NGC5101 (R)SB(rs)0 B 29.36 -20.8 1.00 1 .69e+11 NGC5121 PSF+Bulge+Disk (R')SA(s)a A 23.68 -19.4 0.95 3.68e +10 NGC5161 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 35.89 -21.7 0.79 1.65e+11 NGC5247 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc A 23.79 -21.2 0.54 3.86e+10 NGC5371 SAB(rs)bc AB 40.50 -22.1 0.70 1 .74e+11 NGC5427 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c;pec A 40.82 -21.2 0.57 4.61e +10 NGC5483 Bulge+Disk+Bar SA(s)c A 26.46 -20.3 - - NGC5643 SAB(rs)c AB 18.11 -20.9 0.74 6. 68e+10 NGC5676 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(rs)bc A 36.96 -21.5 0.68 9.01e+1 0 NGC5701 (R)SB(rs)0 B 27.96 -19.9 0.88 4 .67e+10 NGC5713 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(rs)bc;pec AB 32.57 -21.1 0.64 5 .21e+10 NGC5850 SB(r)b B 30.54 -21.5 0.79 1.37e +11 NGC5921 SB(r)bc B 27.00 -20.6 0.66 3.51 e+10 NGC5962 Bulge+Disk+Bar SA(r)c A 34.07 -20.9 0.64 4.43e+10 NGC6215 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)c A 21.96 -20.4 0.54 1.84e+10 NGC6221 Bulge+Disk+Bar SB(s)bc;pec B 20.79 -21.6 0.74 1.31 e+11 NGC6300 SB(rs)b B 15.32 -20.3 0.78 4.49 e+10 NGC6384 Bulge+Disk SAB(r)bc AB 28.50 -21.5 0.72 1.05e+11 NGC6753 (R)SA(r)b A 43.82 -21.6 0.83 1. 81e+11 NGC6782 (R)SAB(r)a AB 54.43 -21.4 - - NGC6902 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(r)b A 38.25 -21.2 0.71 8.12e+10- 46 - Table Name Best Fit Hubble Type Bar Type D M BB-V M (RC3) (RC3) (Mpc) (mag) (mag) ( M) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) NGC6907 SB(s)bc B 46.07 -21.8 0.69 1.21 e+11 NGC7083 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc A 41.46 -21.8 0.65 1.05e+11 NGC7205 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)bc A 21.96 -20.7 0.60 3.11e+10 NGC7213 PSF+Bulge+Disk SA(s)a A 23.57 -21.0 0.89 1.26e+11 NGC7217 PSF+Bulge+Disk (R)SA(r)ab A 17.14 -20.5 0.90 8.38e +10 NGC7412 SB(s)b B 22.61 -20.2 0.53 1.50e +10 NGC7479 SB(s)c B 34.71 -21.7 0.75 1.44e +11 NGC7552 Bulge+Disk+Bar (R')SB(s)ab B 20.89 -20.5 0.68 3.49 e+10 NGC7723 SB(r)b B 25.39 -20.5 0.73 4.32e +10 NGC7727 PSF+Bulge+Disk SAB(s)a;pec AB 24.96 -20.8 0.91 1.1 3e+11 NGC7741 Bulge+Disk+Bar SB(s)cd B 13.18 -19.3 0.53 6.67e+09 Note. -- Columns are: (1) Galaxy name. (2) The best fit chosen ba sed on the criteria outlined in SS3.3. (3) Hubble type from RC3 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1991). (4) RC3 bar type, which is based on visual inspection of optical images and runs as 'B'='strongly barred', 'AB'='we akly barred', and 'A'='unbarred'. (5) The distance in Mpc from the Nearby Galaxies Catalog (Tully 1988) scaled to a Hubble constant of 70 km s-1Mpc-1. Distances are adjusted assuming the Galaxy is retarded by 300 km s-1from the universal expansion by the mass of the Virgo Cluster. Exceptions are NGC 6753, NGC 6782, and NGC 6907 wher e distances are from RC3, NGC 3504 where the distance is from Kenney et al. (1993), and NGC 4314 where t he distance is from Benedict et al. (1996). (6) Absolute B-band magnitude from Hyperleda. Corrections have been appl ied for galactic and internal absorption is computed based on Schlegel et al. (19 98). Internal extinction is corrected for et al. (1995). K-correction co-efficients are dra wn from RC2 (de Vaucouleurs et al. 1976). (7) B-V color from Hyperleda. Corrections for extinction and k-cor rection have been applied as in column 6. (8) Stellar mass, calculated as outlined in SS2.2.- 47 -Table 2. Parameters From 2 DLuminosity Decomposition for Sample S1 (N=143) Galaxy Name Best Fit B/T D/T Bar/T B/D h Disk h Bar reBarreBarn
% % (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) ESO138-10 PSF+Bulge+Disk 16.25 83.75 - 0.19 10.94 0.86 2.07 27.10 2.14 - - - IC0239 2.45 92.65 4.91 0.03 6.63 0.41 0. 23 34.56 2.15 13.95 0.87 0.19 IC4444 Bulge+Disk 31.97 68.03 - 0.47 7.94 1.06 2.33 17.67 2.3 6 - - - IC5325 PSF+Bulge+Disk 6.79 93.21 - 0.07 15.17 1.56 1.75 23.1 8 2.39 - - - NGC0150 5.72 81.18 13.11 0.07 4.22 0.44 0.05 33.57 3.52 17.82 1.87 0.39 NGC0157 PSF+Bulge+Disk 2.29 97.71 - 0.02 3.44 0.41 0.44 31.8 2 3.78 - - - NGC0210 Bulge+Disk+Bar 30.07 48.54 21.39 0.62 4.81 0.57 1.7 1 83.21 9.92 29.41 3.51 0.31 NGC0278 PSF+Bulge+Disk 4.23 95.77 - 0.04 3.46 0.15 0.57 13.4 8 0.58 - - - NGC0289 8.83 85.99 5.18 0.10 4.91 0.57 0 .46 20.28 2.36 18.90 2.19 0.04 NGC0428 5.50 71.64 22.86 0.08 9.27 0.67 0.38 32.55 2.34 30.70 2.21 0.37 NGC0488 PSF+Bulge+Disk 21.72 78.28 - 0.28 9.91 1.52 3.07 38. 94 5.96 - - - NGC0578 2.05 93.63 4.32 0.02 4.19 0.46 0 .56 40.73 4.47 14.95 1.64 0.18 NGC0613 13.14 56.97 29.90 0.23 6.12 0.6 4 1.05 44.69 4.64 62.49 6.49 0.53 NGC0685 Bar+Disk - 96.53 3.47 - - - - 41.24 4.28 20.68 2.15 0.16NGC0779 Bulge+Disk+Bar 16.18 57.69 26.13 0.28 6.04 0.59 2.3 1 38.74 3.79 29.00 2.84 0.25 NGC0864 2.77 86.88 10.35 0.03 3.52 0.38 0.66 39.54 4.22 21.07 2.25 0.37 NGC0908 PSF+Bulge+Disk 8.86 91.14 - 0.10 7.18 0.84 1.62 48.9 6 5.72 - - - NGC1042 PSF+Bulge+Disk 3.00 97.00 - 0.03 5.91 0.57 0.09 39.8 3 3.86 - - - NGC1073 2.36 79.58 18.06 0.03 5.47 0.46 0.41 50.02 4.17 34.24 2.85 0.83 NGC1084 PSF+Bulge+Disk 5.23 94.77 - 0.06 3.24 0.32 0.77 18.6 8 1.82 - - - NGC1087 Bar+Disk - 93.13 6.87 - - - - 28.55 2.78 7.79 0.76 1.27NGC1187 6.94 64.96 28.10 0.11 4.81 0.51 1.57 38.20 4.06 51.85 5.51 0.72 NGC1241 11.70 69.10 19.21 0.17 2.61 0.7 0 0.91 27.69 7.43 17.89 4.80 0.49 NGC1300 11.04 74.94 14.02 0.15 4.63 0.5 1 1.19 63.53 6.96 65.89 7.21 0.25 NGC1302 17.65 63.79 18.57 0.28 4.96 0.5 9 2.01 44.92 5.34 20.44 2.43 0.76 NGC1309 PSF+Bulge+Disk 27.07 72.93 - 0.37 10.86 1.68 2.27 16 .67 2.58 - - - NGC1317 Bulge+Disk+Bar 13.86 41.48 44.65 0.33 3.99 0.53 1.9 4 47.37 6.31 20.22 2.69 2.19 NGC1350 19.52 69.99 10.50 0.28 7.41 0.9 5 1.59 52.77 6.73 51.07 6.51 0.31 NGC1371 12.46 80.16 7.38 0.16 5.17 0.52 1.11 29.34 2.93 18.92 1.89 0.36 NGC1385 PSF+Bar+Disk - 75.54 24.46 - - - - 28.69 2.87 15.63 1.5 6 1.28 NGC1511 Bulge+Disk 28.47 71.53 - 0.40 27.78 2.55 1.35 23.99 2 .20 - - - NGC1559 PSF+Bar+Disk - 97.06 2.94 - - - - 31.16 2.86 9.84 0.90 0 .53 NGC1703 PSF+Bulge+Disk 6.32 93.68 - 0.07 2.83 0.30 0.56 18.2 4 1.91 - - -- 48 -Table Name Best Fit B/T D/T Bar/T B/D h Disk h Bar reBarreBarn
% % (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) NGC1792 PSF+Bulge+Disk 2.65 97.35 - 0.03 3.72 0.31 0.84 38.5 0 3.23 - - - NGC1808 3.92 74.27 21.82 0.05 2.78 0.19 0.45 38.78 2.71 5.71 0.40 0.67 NGC1964 41.78 49.87 8.35 0.84 8.31 0.97 2.58 18.59 2.17 8.05 0.94 0.05 NGC2090 Bulge+Disk+Bar 14.67 58.39 26.94 0.25 17.68 1.12 2. 19 160.02 10.17 33.74 2.14 0.43 NGC2139 Bulge+Disk 15.16 84.84 - 0.18 8.27 1.04 1.53 18.12 2. 27 - - - NGC2196 PSF+Bulge+Disk 46.38 53.62 - 0.86 13.42 2.12 2.38 28 .38 4.48 - - - NGC2442 13.33 62.47 24.19 0.21 4.78 0.4 6 1.68 78.46 7.55 60.15 5.79 0.24 NGC2559 Bulge+Disk+Bar 6.98 81.64 11.37 0.09 4.01 0.43 1.38 34.65 3.72 21.40 2.30 0.24 NGC2566 Bulge+Disk 22.71 77.29 - 0.29 1.74 0.20 4.42 23.05 2. 60 - - - NGC2775 PSF+Bulge+Disk 60.87 39.13 - 1.56 47.35 4.37 4.85 28 .09 2.59 - - - NGC3059 Bar+Disk - 90.68 9.32 - - - - 64.22 5.92 23.94 2.21 1.43NGC3166 Bulge+Disk+Bar 24.97 50.74 24.29 0.49 3.25 0.30 0.8 1 20.14 1.84 13.85 1.26 0.53 NGC3169 PSF+Bulge+Disk 38.53 61.47 - 0.63 11.01 0.96 2.41 55 .12 4.79 - - - NGC3223 PSF+Bulge+Disk 11.71 88.29 - 0.13 5.39 1.06 1.74 29. 05 5.73 - - - NGC3227 10.78 45.23 44.00 0.24 4.84 0.4 4 0.32 44.67 4.07 39.51 3.60 1.27 NGC3261 15.06 70.15 14.79 0.21 2.95 0.5 2 1.96 28.89 5.08 14.19 2.49 1.05 NGC3275 14.15 63.44 22.41 0.22 2.21 0.4 8 1.85 28.25 6.20 20.75 4.55 0.94 NGC3319 PSF+Bar+Disk - 91.41 8.59 - - - - 66.08 14.49 14.60 3.2 0 0.43 NGC3338 5.29 81.96 12.75 0.06 4.39 0.39 0.76 36.42 3.25 20.62 1.84 0.39 NGC3423 Bulge+Disk 28.10 71.90 - 0.39 24.09 1.39 2.39 31.21 1 .80 - - - NGC3504 Bulge+Disk+Bar 23.15 39.49 37.37 0.59 2.37 0.25 1.0 4 29.55 3.09 26.02 2.72 0.78 NGC3513 Bulge+Disk+Bar 4.45 92.08 3.47 0.05 10.73 0.88 1.46 33.18 2.72 18.32 1.50 0.08 NGC3583 Bulge+Disk+Bar 8.62 53.40 37.98 0.16 1.29 0.19 1.28 21.78 3.19 14.89 2.18 0.68 NGC3596 PSF+Bulge+Disk 12.15 87.85 - 0.14 5.34 0.43 0.67 18. 54 1.50 - - - NGC3646 PSF+Bulge+Disk 13.53 86.47 - 0.16 3.60 1.04 1.20 26. 01 7.54 - - - NGC3675 PSF+Bulge+Disk 44.42 55.58 - 0.80 28.41 1.42 2.66 47 .12 2.35 - - - NGC3684 PSF+Bulge+Disk 26.92 73.08 - 0.37 11.43 1.10 2.15 15 .96 1.53 - - - NGC3686 3.02 95.00 1.98 0.03 4.39 0.31 0 .66 27.57 1.96 21.32 1.52 0.03 NGC3705 27.73 59.20 13.07 0.47 8.62 0.6 3 1.83 37.77 2.74 30.00 2.18 0.07 NGC3726 3.09 95.10 1.81 0.03 5.64 0.37 0 .53 49.58 3.24 41.09 2.69 0.05 NGC3810 PSF+Bulge+Disk 38.43 61.57 - 0.62 12.35 0.82 1.28 23 .78 1.57 - - - NGC3885 PSF+Bulge+Disk 27.10 72.90 - 0.37 3.13 0.41 0.46 11. 94 1.57 - - - NGC3887 4.19 83.01 12.80 0.05 5.27 0.44 1.01 42.69 3.55 37.62 3.13 0.62- 49 -Table Name Best Fit B/T D/T Bar/T B/D h Disk h Bar reBarreBarn
% % (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) NGC3893 PSF+Bulge+Disk 54.61 45.39 - 1.20 20.05 1.31 2.05 23 .40 1.52 - - - NGC3938 PSF+Bulge+Disk 7.30 92.70 - 0.08 6.43 0.34 1.18 32.8 4 1.75 - - - NGC3949 PSF+Bulge+Disk 7.75 92.25 - 0.08 4.67 0.22 0.64 15.2 2 0.72 - - - NGC4027 Bar+Disk - 79.48 20.52 - - - - 43.11 2.03 26.50 1.25 1.8 0 NGC4030 PSF+Bulge+Disk 47.29 52.71 - 0.90 17.18 1.73 2.22 20 .67 2.08 - - - NGC4051 14.99 46.99 38.02 0.32 11.29 0. 54 1.20 65.81 3.12 69.69 3.31 0.40 NGC4062 PSF+Bulge+Disk 1.69 98.31 - 0.02 3.62 0.19 0.50 34.9 8 1.79 - - - NGC4123 6.87 79.23 13.90 0.09 6.55 0.56 0.59 56.76 4.84 42.98 3.66 0.46 NGC4145 PSF+Bulge+Disk 7.75 92.25 - 0.08 12.90 0.82 0.68 63. 59 4.05 - - - NGC4151 41.32 50.26 8.42 0.82 9.36 0.62 0.44 37.74 2.49 57.00 3.76 0.10 NGC4212 PSF+Bulge+Disk 3.67 96.33 - 0.04 1.44 0.01 1.38 22.5 6 0.13 - - - NGC4254 PSF+Bulge+Disk 38.98 61.02 - 0.64 30.46 5.03 2.68 34 .19 5.64 - - - NGC4293 8.49 61.70 29.81 0.14 8.00 0.40 0.99 58.26 2.88 55.17 2.73 0.46 NGC4303 Bulge+Disk+Bar 8.28 82.81 8.91 0.10 2.67 0.30 1.55 4 4.58 4.93 32.35 3.58 0.55 NGC4314 26.49 52.44 21.07 0.51 11.22 0. 74 2.05 62.35 4.14 48.98 3.25 0.35 NGC4394 15.20 69.58 15.22 0.22 4.20 0.2 2 1.63 41.74 2.22 28.70 1.53 0.59 NGC4414 11.48 83.86 4.65 0.14 3.50 0.17 1.72 21.27 1.05 17.66 0.87 0.05 NGC4450 16.86 71.49 11.65 0.24 8.19 1.1 0 2.26 47.16 6.33 36.13 4.85 0.33 NGC4487 3.10 93.77 3.13 0.03 6.66 0.47 0 .83 27.92 1.99 14.52 1.04 0.27 NGC4490 PSF+Bulge+Disk 6.64 93.36 - 0.07 21.41 0.88 0.35 44. 02 1.81 - - - NGC4527 Bulge+Disk+Bar 18.24 63.84 17.91 0.29 5.17 0.61 1.9 9 55.52 6.59 41.19 4.89 0.50 NGC4548 12.96 68.65 18.39 0.19 6.97 0.2 3 1.56 58.22 1.96 44.91 1.51 0.51 NGC4593 25.13 28.15 46.72 0.89 5.27 0.9 7 1.04 33.07 6.11 41.94 7.75 0.64 NGC4618 PSF+Bar+Disk - 86.11 13.89 - - - - 46.22 8.54 17.05 3.1 5 0.66 NGC4643 Bulge+Disk+Bar 24.96 54.10 20.95 0.46 5.43 0.52 2.5 3 48.22 4.64 21.30 2.05 0.62 NGC4647 Bulge+Disk 33.39 66.61 - 0.50 12.90 1.26 1.61 42.63 4 .17 - - - NGC4651 PSF+Bulge+Disk 41.67 58.33 - 0.71 18.52 1.01 0.63 30 .46 1.66 - - - NGC4654 Bulge+Disk 1.74 98.26 - 0.02 3.78 0.27 0.93 30.16 2.1 8 - - - NGC4665 14.74 67.38 17.89 0.22 6.92 0.3 7 1.12 50.48 2.73 30.68 1.66 0.70 NGC4689 PSF+Bulge+Disk 5.22 94.78 - 0.06 6.97 0.73 1.14 41.8 5 4.38 - - - NGC4691 15.80 69.09 15.11 0.23 11.62 0. 89 0.61 33.90 2.59 24.99 1.91 0.42 NGC4698 PSF+Bulge+Disk 21.72 78.28 - 0.28 6.78 0.48 1.78 28. 34 2.02 - - - NGC4699 Bulge+Disk+Bar 19.93 76.48 3.59 0.26 2.62 0.27 2.08 15.93 1.62 13.49 1.37 0.02- 50 -Table Name Best Fit B/T D/T Bar/T B/D h Disk h Bar reBarreBarn
% % (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) NGC4772 34.25 51.55 14.20 0.66 9.29 0.6 7 1.49 58.16 4.17 52.58 3.77 0.50 NGC4775 PSF+Bulge+Disk 32.85 67.15 - 0.49 21.43 2.31 1.75 18 .48 1.99 - - - NGC4781 PSF+Bulge+Disk 10.18 89.82 - 0.11 12.02 1.04 0.94 32 .82 2.85 - - - NGC4818 7.04 73.74 19.22 0.10 2.82 0.21 0.47 36.31 2.69 16.38 1.21 0.51 NGC4856 27.44 61.22 11.35 0.45 5.95 0.5 1 1.53 30.61 2.64 17.07 1.47 0.44 NGC4902 5.59 84.44 9.97 0.07 4.31 0.80 0 .85 29.24 5.45 14.13 2.64 0.39 NGC4930 23.74 61.29 14.98 0.39 6.46 1.1 4 1.37 45.02 7.93 32.96 5.80 0.38 NGC4939 PSF+Bulge+Disk 21.37 78.63 - 0.27 9.52 2.01 2.78 32. 14 6.79 - - - NGC4941 PSF+Bulge+Disk 15.08 84.92 - 0.18 4.30 0.25 0.84 23. 23 1.36 - - - NGC4995 6.62 87.18 6.20 0.08 4.14 0.50 0 .05 19.56 2.34 18.03 2.16 0.34 NGC5054 Bulge+Disk 9.64 90.36 - 0.11 5.28 0.65 2.42 52.65 6.4 8 - - - NGC5085 Bulge+Disk 6.04 93.96 - 0.06 5.53 0.74 1.48 33.88 4.5 5 - - - NGC5101 32.63 48.31 19.06 0.68 7.61 0.9 6 2.28 28.39 3.59 37.85 4.78 0.31 NGC5121 PSF+Bulge+Disk 36.43 63.57 - 0.57 4.68 0.48 2.41 15. 62 1.61 - - - NGC5161 PSF+Bulge+Disk 27.14 72.86 - 0.37 20.54 3.38 1.47 43 .98 7.24 - - - NGC5247 PSF+Bulge+Disk 7.54 92.46 - 0.08 8.46 0.79 1.04 50.8 5 4.78 - - - NGC5371 8.60 76.08 15.32 0.11 3.13 0.55 1.29 55.81 9.84 23.03 4.06 1.05 NGC5427 PSF+Bulge+Disk 7.76 92.24 - 0.08 4.74 0.45 0.60 24.5 9 2.31 - - - NGC5483 Bulge+Disk+Bar 0.98 91.28 7.73 0.01 3.23 0.39 1.22 2 3.25 2.83 8.74 1.06 0.32 NGC5643 8.21 81.78 10.01 0.10 5.68 0.46 2.14 45.30 3.63 48.58 3.89 0.43 NGC5676 PSF+Bulge+Disk 6.67 93.33 - 0.07 3.71 0.54 1.29 23.1 0 3.39 - - - NGC5701 24.43 63.47 12.09 0.38 11.13 1. 19 2.41 70.67 7.56 26.01 2.78 0.40 NGC5713 PSF+Bulge+Disk 33.40 66.60 - 0.50 15.59 2.02 1.84 18 .52 2.40 - - - NGC5850 14.76 63.74 21.50 0.23 6.22 1.0 6 1.58 72.24 12.29 46.05 7.83 0.90 NGC5921 10.43 70.50 19.06 0.15 2.55 0.2 6 1.97 40.88 4.10 35.05 3.51 0.92 NGC5962 Bulge+Disk+Bar 10.30 78.82 10.88 0.13 2.33 0.32 1.3 7 14.56 1.99 13.85 1.89 0.02 NGC6215 PSF+Bulge+Disk 6.95 93.05 - 0.07 2.55 0.27 0.96 14.0 2 1.47 - - - NGC6221 Bulge+Disk+Bar 5.27 81.98 12.76 0.06 3.16 0.29 2.73 51.47 4.78 19.33 1.80 0.87 NGC6300 5.98 86.55 7.47 0.07 5.43 0.42 1 .44 47.08 3.60 31.64 2.42 0.30 NGC6384 Bulge+Disk 27.92 72.08 - 0.39 15.66 1.82 3.13 40.05 4 .65 - - - NGC6753 5.08 72.91 22.02 0.07 1.50 0.32 0.94 19.17 4.12 7.88 1.69 0.80 NGC6782 26.27 51.75 21.98 0.51 3.90 1.0 3 1.10 27.14 7.20 19.27 5.11 0.38 NGC6902 PSF+Bulge+Disk 40.55 59.45 - 0.68 12.68 2.43 3.03 30 .13 5.77 - - -- 51 -Table Name Best Fit B/T D/T Bar/T B/D h Disk h Bar reBarreBarn
% % (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) NGC6907 10.32 63.12 26.56 0.16 3.49 0.7 5 1.10 28.99 6.19 23.37 4.99 0.33 NGC7083 PSF+Bulge+Disk 13.23 86.77 - 0.15 5.87 1.23 1.37 23. 26 4.86 - - - NGC7205 PSF+Bulge+Disk 6.08 93.92 - 0.06 4.70 0.48 0.88 31.0 3 3.16 - - - NGC7213 PSF+Bulge+Disk 65.74 34.26 - 1.92 19.55 2.42 2.68 63 .19 7.83 - - - NGC7217 PSF+Bulge+Disk 53.71 46.29 - 1.16 21.07 1.36 2.21 26 .84 1.73 - - - NGC7412 4.09 68.60 27.31 0.06 2.84 0.34 1.28 23.58 2.78 35.06 4.13 1.20 NGC7479 8.76 63.51 27.72 0.14 6.00 0.98 1.09 37.59 6.17 40.63 6.67 0.47 NGC7552 Bulge+Disk+Bar 23.44 61.08 15.48 0.38 2.70 0.31 0.6 4 17.54 1.99 42.05 4.78 0.24 NGC7723 5.11 85.03 9.85 0.06 2.61 0.34 0 .54 21.70 2.82 21.81 2.84 0.90 NGC7727 PSF+Bulge+Disk 41.77 58.23 - 0.72 8.31 1.05 2.02 24. 46 3.09 - - - NGC7741 Bulge+Disk+Bar 3.09 89.02 7.90 0.03 9.51 0.50 0.31 6 0.98 3.18 30.02 1.56 0.40 Note. -- Columns are: (1) Galaxy name. (2) The best fit chosen ba sed on the criteria outlined in SS3.3. (3) Bulge-to-total light ratio. If a PSF is included in the model, the contribution from the PSF is also added in. (4) Disk-to-total light ratio. (5) Bar-to-total light ratio. ( 6) Bulge-to-disk ratio (7) Bulge effective radius in arcseconds. (8) Bulge effective radius in kpc. (9) B ulge S' ersic index. (10) Disk scalelength in arcseconds. (1 1) Disk scalelength in kpc. (12) Bar effective radius in arcseconds. (13) Bar Bulge effective radius in kpc. (14) Bar S' ersic index.- 52 - Table 3. Decomposition For NGC 4643 Fit reor hreor hn b/a Position Angle Fractional light ('') (kpc) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) Stage 1 S' ersic 27.90 2.66 4.44 0.80 -51.03 100%
Stage 2 Bulge 23.86 2.30 4.16 0.80 -51.08 34.6%
Disk 335.88 32.33 1.00 0.84 66.94 65.4%
Stage 3 Bulge 5.43 0.52 2.53 0.90 60.52 25.0%
Disk 48.22 4.64 1.00 0.84 66.94 54.1%
Bar 21.30 2.05 0.62 0.37 -45.84 20.9%
Note. -- Columns are: (1) Indicates whether the model is for Stage 1 (pure S' ersic profile), Stage 2 (bulge+disk or bar+disk), or Stage 3 (bulge+disk+ bar). (2) One of pure S' ersic profile, S' ersic bulge, exponential disk, or S' ersic bar. (3) Effective radius of the bulge/bar or disk scalelength in arcseconds. (4) Effec tive radius of the bulge/bar or disk scalelength in kpc. (5) The S' ersic index of the pro file. (6) Axis ratio of the component. (7) Position angle in degrees of the compon ent. Positive angles are East of North. (8) The percentage of total galaxy light contributed by the component.- 53 - Table 4. Decomposition For NGC 4548 Fit reor hreor hn b/a Position Angle Fractional light ('') (kpc) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) Stage 1 S' ersic 154.59 5.19 5.19 0.80 78.31 100%
Stage 2 Bulge 57.86 1.94 4.32 0.76 75.77 61.5%
Disk 60.39 2.03 1.00 0.75 -32.54 38.5%
Stage 3 Bulge 6.98 0.23 1.56 0.88 -66.50 13.0%
Disk 58.22 1.96 1.00 0.75 -32.54 68.6%
Bar 44.91 1.51 0.51 0.35 66.65 18.4%
Note. -- Columns are: (1) Indicates whether the model is for Stage 1 (pure S' ersic profile), Stage 2 (bulge+disk or bar+disk), or Stage 3 (bulge+disk+ bar). (2) One of pure S' ersic profile, S' ersic bulge, exponential disk, or S' ersic bar. (3) Effective radius of the bulge/bar or disk scalelength in arcseconds. (4) Effec tive radius of the bulge/bar or disk scalelength in kpc. (5) The S' ersic index of the pro file. (6) Axis ratio of the component. (7) Position angle in degrees of the compon ent. Positive angles are East of North. (8) The percentage of total galaxy light contributed by the component.- 54 - Table 5. Decomposition For NGC 4902 Fit reor hreor hn b/a Position Angle Fractional light ('') (kpc) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) Stage 1 S' ersic 154.4 28.8 5.11 0.54 69.0 100%
Stage 2 Bulge 11.5 2.15 1.02 0.38 68.5 17.4%
Disk 32.8 6.12 1.00 0.84 81.1 82.6%
Stage 3 Bulge 4.31 0.80 0.85 0.68 -52.96 5.59%
Disk 29.2 5.45 1.00 0.84 81.1 82.6%
Bar 14.1 2.64 0.39 0.22 66.37 9.97%
Note. -- Columns are: (1) Indicates whether the model is for Stage 1 (pure S' ersic profile), Stage 2 (bulge+disk or bar+disk), or Stage 3 (bulge+disk+ bar). (2) One of pure S' ersic profile, S' ersic bulge, exponential disk, or S' ersic bar. (3) Effective radius of the bulge/bar or disk scalelength in arcseconds. (4) Effec tive radius of the bulge/bar or disk scalelength in kpc. (5) The S' ersic index of the pro file. (6) Axis ratio of the component. (7) Position angle in degrees of the compon ent. Positive angles are East of North. (8) The percentage of total galaxy light contributed by the component.- 55 - Table 6. Checking GALFIT robustness with different input guesses f or Stage 3 B/T BulgereBulgen D/T () () (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) NGC 4548 Initial guesses from 1D decomposition 17.5% 7.39 1.17 63.5% 28.4 19.0% 37.5 0.54 Stage 3 Output 13.0% 6.98 1.56 68.6% 58.2 18.4% 44.9 0.51 Initial guesses from from Stage 2 11.1% 7.50 1.70 69.9% 64.5 1 9.1% 37.5 0.54 Stage 3 Output 13.0% 6.98 1.56 68.6% 58.2 18.4% 44.9 0.51 NGC 4643 Initial guesses from 1D decomposition 33.6% 7.18 0.86 40.4% 37.5 26.0% 22.0 0.60 Stage 3 Output 25.0% 5.43 2.53 54.1% 48.2 20.9% 21.3 0.62 Initial guesses from Stage 2 24.1% 5.30 2.5 51.8% 46.4 24.1% 2 2.0 0.60 Stage 3 Output 25.0% 5.43 2.53 54.1% 48.2 20.9% 21.3 0.62 Note. -- For each galaxy, the rows are: (1) The initial guesses to Stage 3 provided by 1D decomposition. (2) output for the input of row (1). (3) The initia lguesses to Stage 3 provided by Stage 2. (4) The correspondin g output for the input of row (3). The columns are: (2) Bulge-to-total luminosity fraction. ( 3) Effective radius of the bulge in arcseconds. (4) The S' ersi c index of the profile. (5) Disk-to-total luminosity fraction . (6) Disk scalelength in arcseconds. (7) Bar-to-total lumi nosity fraction. (8) Bar effective radius in arcseconds. (9) Bar S' e rsic index.- 56 - Table 7. Parameter Coupling Type of Fit kh2BulgereBulgen B/T Diskh D/T () () (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) NGC 3885 initial input 11241.33 2.32 2.00 27.7% 10.44 72.3% - - - n=free 8210.12 3.13 0.46 27.1% 11.94 72.9% - - - n=1 fixed [8307.82] [2.96] [1.00] [29.1%] [12.90] [70.9%] - - - n=4 fixed [7373.55] [6.28] [4.00] [53.7%] [20.45] [46.3%] - - - n=1 re-fit 8210.12 3.13 0.46 27.1% 11.94 72.9% - - - n=4 re-fit 7258.46 7.11 4.49 57.3% 19.87 42.7% - - - NGC 7213 initial input 605757.39 5.80 4.00 56.4% 9.25 43.6% - - - n=free 71170.10 19.55 2.68 65.7% 63.19 34.3% - - - n=1 fixed [96312.29] [7.81] [1.00] [31.4%] [27.79] [68.6%] - - - n=4 fixed [70998.69] [41.11] [4.00] [95.4%] [6.75] [4.6%] - - - n=1 re-fit 71170.10 19.53 2.68 65.7% 63.16 34.3% - - - n=4 re-fit 69970.51 72.04 5.60 91.9% 7.98 8.1% - - - NGC 4643 initial input 7841.46 5.34 2.50 24.1% 46.40 51.8% 22.04 0.60 24.1%
n=free 2111.59 5.43 2.53 25.0% 48.22 54.1% 21.30 0.62 20.9%
n=1 fixed [3001.98] [2.31] [1.00] [9.6%] [53.37] [57.0%] [15 .05] [0.88] [33.4%] n=4 fixed [2491.06] [12.08] [4.00] [35.4%] [87.22] [51.7%] [ 23.37] [0.61] [12.9%] n=1 re-fit 2111.59 5.43 2.53 25.0% 48.21 54.1% 21.30 0.62 20.9 %
n=4 re-fit 2111.59 5.43 2.53 25.0% 48.22 54.1% 21.30 0.62 20.9 %
NGC 4151 initial input 1388891.11 7.50 0.50 24.6% 33.00 65.0% 55.50 0 .10 10.3%
n=free 16391.66 9.36 0.44 41.3% 37.74 50.3% 57.00 0.10 8.4%
n=1 fixed [18100.67] [11.58] [1.00] [42.2%] [86.28] [41.1%] [56.70] [0.17] [16.7%] n=4 fixed [20051.12] [108.39] [4.00] [51.4%] [8.21] [20.4%] [68.23] [0.28] [28.2%] n=1 re-fit 16391.58 9.38 0.44 41.2% 38.31 49.7% 55.57 0.12 9.0 %
n=4 re-fit 16390.93 9.36 0.44 41.3% 38.20 49.8% 55.88 0.11 8.8 %
Note. -- For each galaxy, the rows are: (1) The model outputs (c olumns 2 to 10) from GALFIT based on the Stage 1 or Stage 2 fits. These outputs are used as initial guess es in the fits for rows 2 and 3. (2) The model outputs (columns 2 to 10) from GALFIT when the bulge nis allowed to vary freely, and the input guesses are based on the parameters in columns 2 to 10 of row 1. (3) The mode l outputs (columns 2 to 10) from GALFIT when the bulge S' ersic index is held fixed at n= 1, and the input guesses are based on the parameters in colum ns 2 to 10 of row 1. The model is not always physically meaningful because the bulge index is fixed. (4) As in row 3, except that the bulge S' ersic index is now held fixed at n= 4. The model is not always physically the bulge index is fixed. (5) The model outputs (colum ns 2 to 10) from GALFIT, when the bulge nis- 57 - allowed to vary freely, but the input guesses are now based on the parameters in columns 2 to 10 of row 3. (6) The model outputs (columns 2 to 10) from GALFIT, when the bulg enis allowed to vary freely, but the input guesses are now based on the parameters in columns 2 to 10 of ro w 4. The columns are: (1) The type of fit whose model outputs are shown in columns 2 to 10. (2) The kh2of the fit. (3) Effective radius of the bulge in arcseconds. (4) The S' ersic index of the bulge (in the case of Stage 2 bulge -disk fits in row 1 and in the case of all fits in rows 2 to 6), or the S' ersic index of a single component (in the case of Stage 1 fits in row 1). (5) fraction. (6) Disk scalelength in arcseconds. ( 7) Disk-to-total luminosity fraction. (8) Bar effective radius in arcseconds. (9) Bar S' ersic index. (10) Bar-to-to tal luminosity fraction.- 58 - Table 8. Mass Breakdown of Galactic Mass Bulges 18 .9%+-3.49%
Disks 71 .6%+-4.02%
Bars 9 with n >2 with n<=2 8.42%+-2.47%- 59 - Table 9. B/Tand bulge nin bright/high mass spirals Sample ( MB<= -19.3) Fraction of spirals with bulge n>=4 1 of spirals with bulge 2 < n <4 of spirals with bulge n<=2 76 of spirals with bulge n >2 23 of spirals with B/T<=0.2 68 of spirals with B/T >0.2 31 of spirals with 0 .2< B/T < 0.4 of spirals with B/T>=0.4 8 of spirals with bulge n>=4 1 of spirals with bulge 2 < n <4 of spirals with bulge n<=2 74 of spirals with bulge n >2 25 of spirals with B/T<=0.2 66 of spirals with B/T >0.2 33 of spirals with 0 .2< B/T < 0.4 25 of spirals with B/T>=0.4 7 .96%+-2.55%- 60 - Table 10. Bar Fraction as a Function of B/Tand Bulge Index Sample ( MB<= -19.3) Bar fraction in spirals with bulge n>=4 0 .00%+-0.00%
Bar fraction in spirals with bulge 2 < n <4 37.5%+-8.56%
Bar fraction in spirals with bulge n<=2 65 .1%+-4.56%
Bar fraction of spirals with bulge n >2 35 .3%+-8.20%
Bar fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.2 68 .4%+-4.70%
Bar fraction of spirals with B/T >0.2 35 .6%+-7.14%
Bar fraction of spirals with 0 .2< B/T < 0.4 42.4%+-8.60%
Bar fraction of spirals with B/T>=0.4 16 fraction of spirals with bulge n>=4 0 .00%+-0.00%
Bar fraction of spirals with bulge 2 < n <4 44.4%+-9.56%
Bar fraction of spirals with bulge n<=2 63 .1%+-5.27%
Bar fraction of spirals with bulge n >2 41 .4%+-9.15%
Bar fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.2 68 .0%+-5.39%
Bar fraction of spirals with B/T >0.2 36 .8%+-7.83%
Bar fraction of spirals with 0 .2< B/T < 0.4 41.4%+-9.15%
Bar fraction of spirals with B/T>=0.4 22 .2%+-13.9%- 61 - Table 11. B/T: Data versus Hierarchical Models of Galaxy Evolution Data Model Model spirals with Model spirals with All model major mergers no major merger spirals since redshift z1since redshfit z1 (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Forz1<=2 For z1<=2 Fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.2 66.4% +-4.44% SK 0.1% 67.2% 67.3%
Fraction of spirals with 0 .2< B/T<=0.4 25.7% +-4.11% SK 2.2% 16.6% 18.8%
Fraction of spirals with 0 .4< B/T<=0.75 8.0% +-2.5% SK 11.2% 2.6% 13.8%
Fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.75 100% SK 13.5% 86.5% 100.0%
Forz1<=4 For z1<=4 Fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.2 66.4% +-4.44% SK 1.6% 65.7% 67.3%
Fraction of spirals with 0 .2< B/T<=0.4 25.7% +-4.11% SK 5.5% 13.3% 18.8%
Fraction of spirals with 0 .4< B/T<=0.75 8.0% +-2.5% SK 12.6% 1.3% 13.9%
Fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.75 100% SK 19.8% 80.2% 100.0%
Forz1<=2 For z1<=2 Fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.2 66.4% +-4.44% PH 3.0% 67.7% 70.7%
Fraction of spirals with 0 .2< B/T<=0.4 25.7% +-4.11% PH 7.1% 13.1% 20.1%
Fraction of spirals with 0 .4< B/T<=0.75 8.0% +-2.5% PH 5.9% 3.1% 9.0%
Fraction of spirals with B/T<=0.75 100% PH 15.7% 84.0% 99.8%
Note. -- Column 2 shows the empirical fraction of high mass spi rals with a given B/T. Columns 3 to 6 show the fraction of high mass spirals with a given B/Tin the models, which define spirals as systems with B/T<=0.75. Column 3 indicates the model used: SK refers to the models by Khochfar & Burkert (2005) and Khochfar & Silk (2006), while PH refers to those by Hopkins et al. (2009). The models are described in SS5.8 and have different prescriptions for the amount of mass th at gets converted into bulge stars. Column 4 shows the fraction of spirals, which have a gi venB/Tand have had one or more major mergers since redshift z1. Column 5 shows the fraction of spirals, which have a given B/Tand have had no major merger since redshift z1. Column 6 is the sum of column 4 and 5, and shows the fraction of spirals with a g ivenB/Tin the models. It can be directly compared to the data in column 2.- 62 - Table 12. Comparison of model merger fraction since z<=4 and bulge S' ersic index Stellar mass limit: 1 .0x1010M Model galaxies: 7674 Observed galaxies: 113 Test 1
% of model galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 with no major merger since z<=4: 5040/7674 = 65 .7%+-0.54%
% of observed galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 and bulge n<=3: 75/113 = 66 .4%+-4.44%
% of observed galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 and bulge n<=2.5: 74/113 = 65 .5%+-4.47%
% of observed galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 and bulge n<=2: 67/113 = 59 .3%+-4.62%
Test 2
% of model galaxies w/ B/T>=0.4 and a major merger since z<=4: 971/7674 = 12 .7%+-0.38%
% of observed spirals w/ B/T>=0.4 and bulge n >3: 2/113 = 1 .77%+-1.24%
% of observed spirals w/ B/T>=0.4 and bulge n >2.5: 4/113 = 3 .54%+-1.74%
% of observed spirals w/ B/T>=0.4 and bulge n >2: 7/113 = 6 .19%+-2.27%
Test 3
% of model galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 and a major merger since z<=4: 126/7674 = 1 .64%+-0.15%
% of observed galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 and bulge n >3: 0/113 = 0 .00%+-0.00%
% of observed galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 and bulge n >2.5 1/113 = 0 .88%+-0.88%
% of observed galaxies w/ B/T<=0.2 and bulge n >2 8/113 = 7 .08%+-2.41%- 63 -- 64 - Fig. 1.-- Our final sample S1 consists of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) spirals in the OSUBSGS survey. The distribution of absolute B-band magnitude for the sample of bright spirals in the OSUBSGS survey is sh own in the top panel before (solid line) and after (shaded greyscale) the cut to remove highly inclined ( i >70*) spirals. The distribution of Hubble types for the sample is shown in the bottom panel before (solid line) and after (shaded greyscale) the cut to remove highly inc lined (i >70*) spirals.- 65 - Fig. 2.--The luminosity functionof the full OSUBSGS sample is compared with the B-band Schechter luminosity function (SLF). The former is calculated as de scribed in SS2.1 using equation (1). The parameters for the SLF are Ph*= and M*
B=-20.5 (Efstathiou, Ellis & Peterson 1988), corresponding to H0=70 km/s Mpc-1.- 66 - Fig. 3.-- Out of our final sample S1 of 143 bright ( MB<= -19.3) inclined ( i<=70*) OSUBSGS spirals, stellar masses could be estimated for 126 galaxies . Their stellar mass distribution is shown, as determined in SS2.2. Most have stellar This sample of 126 galaxies is referenced henceforth as the sample S2.- 67 - Fig. 4.-- An overview of the method of decomposition. All images are su bjected to Stages 1, 2, and 3. Either the best fit of Stage 2 or Stage 3 is chosen as the best model.- 68 - Fig. 5.-- Complete 2 Ddecomposition for NGC 4643. Note the prominent bar residuals in the residual for the Stage 1 and Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition. This is a case where the prominent bar causes the Stage 2 bulge-disk fit to artificially extend the bulge and inflate theB/T. The disk fitted in Stage 2 has a low surface brightness and is very ex tended, well beyond the real disk: the b/aandPAof the fitted disk is shown as contours. Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition provides the best model. The kh2for the Stage 1, Stage 2, and Stage 3 residual images are 7360.7, 7284.8, and 2111.59, respectiv ely. See Table 3 for the fit parameters.- 69 - Fig. 6.-- The complete 2 Ddecomposition for NGC 4548. This is an extreme example where the prominent bar results in an extended bulge and inflated B/Tin the Stage 2 bulge-disk fit. Like NGC 4643 in Figure 5, the disk fitted in Stage 2 has a low surfac e brightness and is very extended: its b/aandPAare shown as contours. Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar the best model. The kh2 nfor the Stage 1, Stage 2, and Stage 3 residual images are 7076.1, 6301.3, and 3260.4, respectively. See Table 4 for the fit par ameters.- 70 - Fig. 7.-- This plot shows the data image, Stage 2 model, and Stage 3 mod el for NGC 4902. The Stage 2 bulge is too bright and is extended along the major axis of the bar In Stage 3, the bulge and bar are fit with distinct component s Bar/ T=9.97%, bar b/a=0.22). All other fit parameters appear in Table 5.- 71 - Fig. 8.-- The data images and Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition mo dels of NGC 5427 and NGC 7412 are shown. The Stage 3 models each distinctly show a fa lse bar component, which is not present in the data images. The false components can be inspired by prominent spiral arms, such as those present in these galaxies. Such cases a re flagged during the of fits and the Stage 3 bulge-disk-bar decomposition is dis carded in favor of the Stage 2 bulge-disk decomposition.- 72 - Fig. 9.-- This plot compares the B/Tobtained by fitting the bulge of NGC 4548 with a S' ersic model of constant b/aas opposed to a S' ersic model varying b/a. To mimic a S' ersic model with varying b/ain GALFIT, the bulge was fitted with ten concentric S' ersic profiles with fixed re, each separated by 0.75. The top two panels show the run of b/aandPAof the ten concentric S' ersic profiles. The bottom panel shows the c umulative B/Tcalculated by summing all models with r<=re. The bulge and B/T(13%) from the original S' ersic fit of constant b/a(Table 4) are indicated with horizontal lines on the 3 panels.- 73 - Fig. 10.-- An elementary test is to determine if GALFIT can recover th e known parameters of artificial noisy images. Noisy images were simulated by taking param etric model images (left panels) produced by GALFIT, and adding noise and sky backgr ound (right panels). The noisy images were then fitted to see if the original known parame ters can be for details.- 74 - Fig. 11.-- The plots compare recovered versus original model param eters for the simulated images discussd in SS4.2. The vertical axis limits demonstrate the range explored for eac h parameter. The dotted line shows y=xfor comparison. Except for some extreme cases where the images were highly distorted by noise, all parameters wer e recovered to within a few percent.- 75 - Fig. 12.-- The ratio of parameter is plotted aga inst mean inside the disk scalelength, u=mag+ for the simulated images discussed in SS4.2. Surface brightness is not photometrically calibrated and is shown for a zeropoint of 0.- 76 - Fig. 13.-- The top, middle, and bottom panels show stellar mass for bulg es, disks, and along the Hubble sequence. Values are shown for sam ple S2 of 126 galaxies in Fig. 3. The legend in each panel indicates the type of decomposition u sed for each data point.- 77 - Fig. 14.-- The individual and mean B/T(left panels) and bulge S' ersic index (right alaxies, galaxy stellar mass for sample S2. The error bars indicate the sta ndard deviation of the population around the mean in each bin. The legend in each panel indica tes the type of decomposition used for each data point. The mean B/Tand bulge index in barred galaxies differ systematically from unbarred galaxies, but there is a large ove rlap in the As many as ~69% of bright spiral galaxies have B/T<=0.2; these bulges are pervasive and exist across the Hubble sequence. Furthermore, a s many as ~76% of bright spirals have low n<=2 bulges. Such bulges exist in barred and unbarred galaxies across a wide range of Hubble types.- 78 - Fig. 15.-- The relation between B/Tand bulge index is shown. In the top panel, galaxies are coded according to bar class. The legend indicates the type of d ecomposition used for each data point. In the lower panel, galaxies are coded according to Hubble type. A striking
~76% of bright spirals have low n<=2 bulges. Such bulges exist in barred and across a wide range of Hubble types, and their B/Trange from 0.01 to 0.4, with most having B/T<=0.2. A moderate fraction ( ~22%) have intermediate 2 < n <4 bulges. These exist in barred and unbarred S0/a to Sd galaxies, and their B/Tspans a wide range (0.05 to 0.5). Only ( ~1%) have n>=4.- 79 - Fig. 16.-- B/Tis plotted against Bar/ Tand sorted by bulge S' ersic index. There are six galaxies with Bar/ T>=0.3.- 80 - Fig. 17.-- The top two rows showH-band images of barred galaxies, which have early RC3 Hubble types, but yet have B/T<=0.2. Thebottom row showsH-band images of unbarred galaxies, which have late RC3 Hubble types, but yet have B/T~0.4. The Hubble types assigned to these objects more reflect disk smoothness an d spiral arm topology than B/T. All images are from OSUBSGS with characteristics as described in SS2.- 81 - Fig. 18.-- B/Dis plotted against Hubble type. The legend indicates the type of deco mpo- sition used for each data point. The mean values for barred and unb arred together in each bin are shown.- 82 - Fig. 19.-- The properties of bars are shown. The error bars indicate the standard deviation of the population around the mean in each bin. The legend in each pane l indicates the type of decomposition used for each data point. Upper left: Mean and ind ividual Bar/ Tplotted against Hubble type. Upper right: Mean and individual bar S' ersic ind ices plotted against Hubble type. Lower left: Bar/ Tplotted against total galaxy stellar mass. The mean Bar/ T in bins of stellar mass is indicated. Lower right: Bar S' ersic index plott ed against total galaxy stellar mass.- 83 - Fig. 20.-- Bar strength is plotted against Hubble type and the proper ties of bars are compared with bulges. The legend in each panel indicates the type of decomposition used for each data point. Upper left: Bar strength, the product of Ba r/Tand peak bar MJ07 is plotted against Hubble type. Upper right: Bar/ Tis plotted against bar S' ersic index. Lower left: Bar/ Tis plotted against bulge S' ersic index. Lower right: Bar/ Tis plotted against B/T. In the first plot, mean bar strong is calculated for each Hubble typ e. In the latter three plots, mean Bar/ Tis calculated for bins along the ordinate axis. The error bars indicate the standard deviation of the population aroun d the mean in each bin.- 84 - Fig. 21.-- H-band OSUBSGS images of spirals with prominent bars of Bar/ T(>0.3) are shown. An interesting example is the oval or lens galaxy NGC 1317: th e bar has a low ellipticity, but its B/Tis large because it is extended and massive. Such bars/lenses may exert significant gravitational torques although they are not ver y elongated.- 85 - 123456 Sersic ns (1-1 (< ns (1-1 Fig. 22.-- Shown is the distribution of S' ersic indices nfor remnants of 1:1 gas-rich major mergers in the simulations of Hopkins et al. 2008: they lie in the range o f 2< n ~22% of the remnants have classical n>=4, as much as 20% have low n<=2.5, while 50% have n<=3. Almost none have n<=2. [Figure: courtesy of Phil Hopkins]- 86 - Fig. 23.-- For those high mass ( M>=1.0x1010M) galaxies in the theoretical models that experienced a major merger (see SS5.8), the B/Tof the remnant at z~0 is plotted against the redshift zlastof the last major merger. Systems where the last major merger oc curred at earlier times have had more time to grow a disk and thus have a lower B/Tatz~0. The dispersion in the present-day B/Tat a given zlastis due to the different times spent by a galaxy in terms of being a satellite versus a central galaxy in a DM halo, since the cooling of gas and the growth of a disk is stopped when a galaxy becomes a sate llite. In the model, a high mass galaxy that has undergone a major merger at z<=2 has a present-day B/T >0.2. In effect, a high mass spiral can have a present-day B/T<=0.2 only if its last major merger occurred at z >2 (lookback times >10 Gyr).- 87 - Fig. 24.-- The cumulative fractionFof high mass ( M>=1.0x1010M) spirals with present-day B/T<=the x-axis value is shown for the data (colored lines/ points) and for the theoretical model (black lines/points) described in SS5.8. Model and data spirals are defined as systems with B/T<=0.75. The magenta line shows Ffrom the data, while the other two colored lines break this Fin terms of bar class (top panel) or bulge n(lower panel). The black dashed line shows Ffrom all model galaxies, while the black dotted line and black dots show the contribution of model galaxies that experienced, re spectively, no major merger andone or more major mergers sincez<=4. Major mergers are defined here as those with M1/M2>=1/4. In the model, the fraction ( ~1.6%; see Table 11) of high mass spirals, which have undergone a major merger since z<=4 and host a bulge with a present-day B/T<=0.2 is a factor of over 20 smaller than the observed fraction ( ~66%) of high mass spirals with present-day B/T<=0.2. Thus, bulges built via major mergers since z<=4 seriously fail to account for most of the low B/T<=0.2 bulges present in two-thirds of high-mass spirals.- 88 - Fig. 25.-- This figure is similar to Fig. 24, except that the model now defi nes major mergers as those with mass ratio M1/M2>=1/6.- 89 - Fig. 26.-- This figure is similar to Fig. 24, except that here spirals are co nsidered to be systems with a B/T<=0.55 rather than 0.75 in the models, and a corresponding cut is applied to the data points.- 90 - Fig. 27.-- This figure is similar to Fig. 24, except that B/Tof all the observed galaxies has been multiplied by a factor of two, in order to test what would happen in the case where the M/Lratio of the bulge in H-band is twice as high as that of the disk and bar. This could happen in an extreme example where the dominant bulge stellar popula tion was much older (e.g. 12 Gyr) than the age of the dominant disk stellar population (e.g ., 3 Gyr). In such a case, the fraction of high mass spirals with B/T<=0.2 would change from ~66% in Fig. 24 to~50%. However, the main conclusion that bulges built by major merger s sincez<=4 cannot account for most of the low B/T<=0.2 bulges, present in a large percentage ( ~55%) of spirals still holds.
|
0807.0040
|
Tim Weinzirl
|
Tim Weinzirl (1), Shardha Jogee (1), Sadegh Khochfar (2)(3), Andreas
Burkert (4), John Kormendy (1) ((1) Univ. of Texas at Austin, USA, (2) Univ.
of Oxford, UK (3), Max Planck Institut fur extraterrestrische Physik,
Germany, (4) Universitats-Sternwarte Munchen, Germany)
|
Bulge n and B/T in High Mass Galaxies: Constraints on the Origin of
Bulges in Hierarchical Models
|
Accepted by the Astrophysical Journal. 42 pages of text, 27 figures,
12 tables
|
Astrophys.J.696:411-447,2009
|
10.1088/0004-637X/696/1/411
| null |
astro-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We use the bulge Sersic index n and bulge-to-total ratio (B/T) to explore the
fundamental question of how bulges form. We perform 2D bulge-disk-bar
decomposition on H-band images of 143 bright, high stellar mass (>1.0e10 solar
masses) low-to-moderately inclined (i<70 degrees) spirals. Our results are: (1)
Our H-band bar fraction (~58%) is consistent with that from ellipse fits. (2)
70% of the stellar mass is in disks, 10% in bars, and 20% in bulges. (3) A
large fraction (~69%) of bright spirals have B/T<0.2, and ~76% have low n<2
bulges. These bulges exist in barred and unbarred galaxies across a wide range
of Hubble types. (4) About 65% (68%) of bright spirals with n<2 (B/T<0.2)
bulges host bars, suggesting a possible link between bars and bulges. (5) We
compare the results with predictions from a set of LCDM models. In the models,
a high mass spiral can have a bulge with a present-day low B/T<0.2 only if it
did not undergo a major merger since z<2. The predicted fraction (~1.6%) of
high mass spirals, which have undergone a major merger since z<4 and host a
bulge with a present-day low B/T<0.2, is a factor of over thirty smaller than
the observed fraction (~66%) of high mass spirals with B/T<0.2. Thus, contrary
to common perception, bulges built via major mergers since z<4 seriously fail
to account for the bulges present in ~66% of high mass spirals. Most of these
present-day low B/T<0.2 bulges are likely to have been built by a combination
of minor mergers and/or secular processes since z<4.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 1 Jul 2008 17:28:42 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 2 Jul 2008 19:58:33 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Tue, 24 Mar 2009 01:42:41 GMT"
}
] | 2014-11-18T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Weinzirl",
"Tim",
""
],
[
"Jogee",
"Shardha",
""
],
[
"Khochfar",
"Sadegh",
""
],
[
"Burkert",
"Andreas",
""
],
[
"Kormendy",
"John",
""
]
] |
a directed acyclic graph with only one root, which represent s the last universal common ancestor and which we assume, thus, of out-degree greater th an 1. In such a graph, nodes represent species (or any other taxonomy unit) and arcs repr esent direct descendance. A node with only one parent (a tree node ) represents a species derived from its par- ent species through mutation, and a node with more than one pa rent (ahybrid node ) represents a species derived from its parent species throug h some reticulation event. The interest in representing phylogenetic histories by mea ns of networks has lead to many hybridization network reconstruction methods [13, methods often search for hybridization net works satisfying some restric- tion, like for instance to have as few hybrid nodes as possibl e (inperfect phylogenies ), or to have their reticulation cycles satisfying some struct ural restrictions (in galled ). Two popular and biologically meaningful such restrictio ns are the time consistency [1,18], the possibility of assigning times to the nodes in su ch a way that tree children exist later than their parents and hybrid chil dren coexist with their par- ents (and in particular, the parents of a hybrid species coex ist in time), and the tree child condition [8,31], that imposes that every non-extant species has some mutation alone. The tree-child time consistent (TCTC) hybridization networks have been recently proposed as the class where meaningful ph ylogenetic networks should be searched [30]. Recent simulations (reported in [27]) hav e shown that over 64% of 4132 hybridization networks obtained using the coalescent model [15] under various pop- ulation and sample sizes, sequence lengths, and recombinat ion rates, were TCTC: the percentage of TCTC networks among the time consistent netwo rks obtained in increases to 92.8%. The increase in the number of available hybridization netwo rks reconstruction al- gorithms has made it necessary the introduction of methods f or the comparison of hy- bridization networks to be used in their assessment, for ins tance by comparing with either simulated or true phylogenetic histor ies, and by evaluating the ro- bustness of reconstruction algorithms when adding new spec ies [18,32]. This has lead recently to the definition of several metrics defined on differe nt classes of [4-6,8,9,18,20]. All these metrics generalize in one way or another for phylogenetic trees. Some of the most popular metrics for phylogenetic trees are b ased on the comparison of the vectors of path lengths between leaves [3,11,12,22,2 6,29]. Introduced in the early seventies, with different names depending on the author and th e way these vectors are compared, they are globally known as nodal distances . Actually, these vectors of paths lengths only separate (in the sense that equal vectors means isomorphic trees), on the one hand, unrooted phylogenetic trees, and, on the other han d, fully resolved trees, and therefore, as far as rooted phyloge netic trees goes, the through these vectors are only true metrics for fully resolved trees. These generalized phylogeneti c trees [7]. path length between two leaves was replaced by the pair o f distances from the leaves to their least common ancestor, and the vector of path s lengths between leaves was replaced by the splitted path lengths matrix obtained in this way. These arbitrary rooted phylogenetic trees, and therefo re thesplitted nodal through them are indeed metrics on the space of rooted phylogenetic trees. In a recent paper [6] we have generalized these splitted noda l distances to networks with all their hybrid nodes of out-d egree 1. The goal of this paperis to go onestep beyondin two directions: to generaliz e to the TCTC setting both the classical nodal distances for ful ly resolved rooted and the new splitted nodal distances for rooted phylog enetic trees. Thus, on the one hand, we introduce a suitable generalization of the vectors of path lengths between leaves that separate fully resolved (where every non extant species has exactly two children, and every reticulation event involves exactly two parent sp ecies) TCTC . ifwesplit thesenew pathlengthsin asuitable way and we add a bit of extra information, the resulting vecto rs separate arbitrary TCTC hybridization networks. Then, the vectors obtained in both cases can be used to define metrics that generalize, respectively, the nodal dis tances for fully resolved trees and the splitted nodal distances for roo ted phylogenetic trees. The key ingredient in the proofs of our main results is the use of sets of that applied to TCTC hybridization networks wit hnleaves and networks with either n-1leaves or with nleaves and m-1 internal nodes (in the fully resolved case, the reductions we use are specifically tai- lored to make them remove always one leaf). Similar sets of re ductions have already been introduced for TCTC hybridization networks with all their h ybrid nodes of out-degree 1 [6] and for tree sibling (where every hybrid node has a tree sibling) time networks with all their hybrid nodes of in-de gree 2 and out-degree 1 [4], and they have been proved useful in those contexts not only to establish properties of networks by algebraic induction, but also to generate in a recursive way all networks of the type under consideration. We hope that th e reductions introduced in this paper will find similar applications elsewhere. 2 Notations on DAGs LetN= (V,E) denote in this subsection a directed acyclic (non-empty, fi nite) graph; aDAG, for short. A node vVis achildofuVif (u,v)E; we also say in this case that uis aparentofv. All children of the same parent are said to be siblingof a node vV, itsin-degree degin(v) and its out-degree degout(v) are, respec- tively, the number of its parents and the number of its childr en. The typeofvis the ordered pair A node vis arootwhen degin(v) = 0, a tree node when ahybrid node when aleafwhen degout(v) = 0,internal when andelementary when and degout(v) = 1. A tree a hybridization arc ) is an arc with head a tree node (respectively, a hybrid node). A DAG Nisrootedwhen it has only one a sequence of nodes ( v0,v1,...,vk) such that ( vi-1,vi)Efor all i= 1,...,k. We call v0theoriginof the path, nodes , and vkitsend. Thelengthof the path ( v0,v1,...,vk) isk, and it is non-trivial The acyclicity ofNmeans that it does not contain cycles: non-trivial paths from a node to itself. We denote by path with origin uand end v. Whenever there exists a we shall say that vis adescendant ofuand also that uis anancestor ofv. When the path non-trivial, we say that vis of uand that uis of v. Thedistance from a node uto a descendant vis the length of a shortest path from of a node vin a DAG Nis the largest length of a path from vto a leaf. The absence of cycles implies that the nodes of a DAG can be stratified by means of their heights: the nodes of height 0 are the leaves, the nodes of height 1 are those nodes all whose children are leaves, the nodes of height 2 are those nodes all whose children are leaves and nodes of height 1, and so on. If a node has height m >0, then all its children have height smaller than m, and at least one of them has height exactly m-1. A nodevofNis astrict descendant of a node uif it is a descendant of it, and every path from a root of Ntovcontains the node u: in particular, we understand every node as a strict descendant of itself. When vis a strict descendant of u, we also say that uis astrict ancestor ofv. The following lemma will be used several times in this paper. Lemma 1. Letube a proper strict ancestor of a node vin a DAG N, and let wbe an intermediate node in a path Then,uis also a strict ancestor of a path from a root of Ntow, and concatenate to it the piece the path consideration. This yields a path must contain u. Sinceudoes not appear in the piece we conclude that it is contained in the This proves that every path from a root of Ntowcontains the node u. For every pair of nodes is the set of all common ancestors of uandvthat are strict ancestors of at least one of them; -theleast common semi-strict ancestor (LCSA) ofuandv, in symbols [ u,v], is the node inCSA(u,v) of minimum height. The LCSA of two nodes u,vin a phylogenetic network is well defined and it is unique: it is actually the unique element of CSA(u,v) that is a descendant of all elements of this set [5]. The following result on LCSAs will be used often . It is the generalization to DAGs of Lemma 6 in [6], and we include its easy proof for the sak e of 2. LetNbe a DAG and let u,vbe a pair of nodes of Nsuch that vis not a descendant of u. Ifuis a tree node with parent u', then[u,v] = shall prove that CSA(u,v) Since uis not an ancestor of hence any non-trivial. Then, since u'is the only parent of u, it appears in this path, and therefore xis also an ancestor of u'. This shows that xis a common ancestor of u'and v. Now, if xis a strict ancestor of v, we already conclude that xCSA(u',v), while if xis a strict ancestor of u, it will be also a strict ancestor of u'by Lemma 1, and too. This proves that let xCSA(u',v). Since u'is the parent of u, it is clear that xis a common ancestor of uandv, too. If xis a strict ancestor of v, this implies that xCSA(u,v). Ifxis a strict ancestor of u', then it is also a strict ancestor of contain the only parent u'ofu, and then xwill belong to the the path and therefore xCSA(u,v), too. This finishes the proof of the equality. LetSbe any non-empty finite set of labels. We say that the DAG Nislabeled in S, or that it is an S-DAG, for short, when its leaves are bijectively labeled by eleme nts ofS. Although in real applications the set Swould correspond to a given set of extant taxa, for the sake of simplicity we shall assume henceforth that S={1,...,n}, withn=|S|. We shall always identify, usually without any further notic e, each leaf of an S-DAG with its label in , in symbols N~=N', when they are isomorphic as directed graphs and the isomorphism maps each leaf in Nto the leaf with the same label inN'. 2.2 Path lengths in phylogenetic tree on a setSof taxa is a rooted S-DAG without hybrid nodes and such that its root is non-elementary. A phylogenetic tree is fully resolved , orbinary, when every internal node has out-degree 2. Since all ancestors of a node in a phylogenetic tree are strict, the LCSA [ u,v] of two nodes u,vin a phylogenetic tree is simply their least common ancestor : the unique common ancestor of them that is a descendant of ev ery other common ancestor of them. LetTbe a phylogenetic tree on the set S={1,...,n}. For every i,jS, we shall denote by lT(i,j) andlT(j,i) the lengths of the paths [ respectively. In particular, lT(i,i) = 0 for every i= 1. LetTbe a phylogenetic tree on the set S={1,...,n}. Thepath length between two leaves iandjis LT(i,j) lengths vector ofTis the vector L(T) its entries ordered in (i,j). 5The following result is a special case of Prop. 2 in [7]. Proposition 1. Two fully resolved phylogenetic trees on the same set Sof taxa are isomorphic if, and only if, they have the same path lengths ve ctors. The thesis in the last result is false for arbitrary phylogen etic trees. Consider for instance the phylogenetic trees with Newick strings (1,2,(3,4)); Fig. 1. It is straightforward to check that they have the sa me path lengths vectors, but they are not isomorphic. 1234 1234 Fig.1.Two non-isomorphic phylogenetic trees with the same path le ngths vectors. This problem was overcome in [7] by replacing the path length s vectors by the fol- lowing matrices of 2. Thesplitted path lengths matrix ofTis thenxnsquare matrix l(T) Mn(N). Now, the following result is (again, a special case of) Theor em 11 in [7]. Proposition 2. Two phylogenetic trees on the same set Sof taxa are isomorphic if, and only if, they have the same splitted path lengths matrices. 3 TCTC networks While the basic notion of phylogenetic tree is well establis hed, the notion of is much less well defined [16]. The networks we consid er in this paper are the (almost) most general S-DAGs we shall call them hybridization networks . In these hybridization networks, every node represents a different species, and the arcs represent di rect descendance, be it through mutation (tree arcs) or through some reticulation e vent (hybridization arcs). It is usual to forbid elementary nodes in hybridization netw orks [23], mainly because they cannot be reconstructed. We allow them here for two reas ons. On the one in graphical representations of DAGs, hybrid n odes are represented by squares, tree nodes by circles, and indeterminate nodes, that is, nodes that can be of tree or hybrid type, by squares with rounded allowing them simplifies considerably some proofs, as it will be hopefully clear in Section 5. On the other hand, because, as Moret et alpoint out [18, SS4.3], they can be useful both from the biological point of view, to include aut o-polyploidy in the model, as well as from the formal point of view, to make a phylogeny sati sfy other constraints, like forinstance timeconsistency (seebelow) ortheimpossibil ity of successive course, our main results apply without any modification to hybridization networks without elementary nodes as well. Following [5], by a phylogenetic network on a setSof taxa we understand a rooted S- DAGN y tree node. Although, from the mathematical point of view, p hylogenetic networks are a special case of hybridization networks, from the point of vi ew of modelling they represent in a different way evolutive histories with reticulation even ts: in a phylogenetic network, every tree node represents a different species and every hybri d node, a reticulation event that gives rise to the species represented by its only child. A hybridization network N= (V,E) istime consistent when it allows a [1]: a that t(u)< t(v) for every tree arc ( u,v) andt(u) =t(v) for every (u,v). Such a temporal representation can be understood as an ass ignment of times to nodes that strictly increases from parents to tree childr en and so that the parents of each hybrid node coexist in time. Remark 1. LetN= (V,E) be a time consistent hybridization network, and let N1=
(V1,E1) be a hybridization network obtained by removing from Nsome nodes and all their descendants (as well as all arcs pointing to any remove d node). Then N1is still time consistent, because the restriction of any temporal re presentation a temporal representation of N1. A hybridization network satisfies the tree-child condition , or it is tree-child , when every internal node has at least one child that is a tree node ( atree child ). So, networks can beunderstoodas general models of reticulate evolution where every species other that the extant ones, represented by the leaves, has some mutation. Tree-child hybridization networks incl ude galled trees [13,14] as a particular case [8]. Atree path in a tree-child hybridization network is a non-trivial path such that its end and all its intermediate nodes are tree nodes. A node vis atree descendant of a nodeuwhen there exists a tree path from utov. By [9, Lem. 2], every internal node u of a tree-child hybridization network has some tree descend ant leaf, and by [9, Cor. 4] every tree descendant vofuis a strict descendant of uand the path unique. To simplify the notations, we shall call TCTC-networks the tree-child time consis- tent hybridization networks: these include the tree-child time consistent s, which were the objects dubbed TCTC-networks in [5 ,6]. Every is also a TCTC-network. Let TCTC ndenote the class of all TCTC-networks prove now some basic properties of TCTC-networks that wil l be used later. Lemma 3. Letube a node of a TCTC-network N, and let vbe a child of u. The node vis a tree node if, and only if, it is a strict descendant of u. Proof.Assume first that vis a tree child of u. Sinceuis the only parent of v, path ending in vmust contain u. This shows that uis a strict ancestor of v. Assume now that vis a hybrid child of uthat is also a strict descendant of it, and let us see that this leads to a contradiction. Indeed, in this case the set H(u) of hybrid children of uthat are strict descendants of it is non-empty, and we can cho ose a node v0in it of largest height. Let v1be any parent of v0other than u. Sinceuis a strict ancestor of v0, it must be an ancestor of v1, and since uandv1have the hybrid child v0 is common, they must have the same temporal representation, and therefore v1as well as all intermediate nodes in any path be hybrid. Moreover, since uis a strict ancestor of v0, it is also a strict ancestor of v1as well as of any intermediate node in Lemma 1). In particular, the child of uin a path belong to H(u) and its height will be larger than the height of v0, which is 1. All children of the root of a TCTC-network are tree node in a hybridization network is a strict descendant of the root. Then, Lemma 3 applies. The following result is the key ingredient in the proofs of ou r main results; it general- izes to hybridization networks Lemma 3 in [6], which referre d to phylogenetic networks. A similar result was proved in [4] for tree-sibling (that is, where every hybrid node has a sibling that is a tree node) time consistent phylogenetic n etworks with all its hybrid nodes of in-degree 2. Lemma 4. Every TCTC-network with more than one leaf contains at least one n odev satisfying one of the following an internal tree node and all its children are tree leaves. (b)vis a hybrid internal node, all its children are tree leaves, a nd all its siblings are leaves or hybrid nodes. (c)vis a hybrid leaf, and all its siblings are leaves or hybrid nod es. Proof.LetNbe a TCTC-network and ta temporal representation of it. Let v0be an internal node of highest t-value and, among such nodes, of smallest height. The tree children of v0have strictly higher t-value than v, and therefore they are leaves. And the hybrid children of v0have the same t-value than v0but smaller height, and therefore they are also a tree node all whose children are tree nodes, taking v=v0we are in a hybrid node all whose children are tree nodes, then its pa rents have its same t-value, which, we recall, is the highest one. This implies th at their children ( v0's siblings) cannot be internal tree nodes, and hence they are l eaves or hybrid nodes. So, taking v=v0, we are in case (b). -Ifv0has some hybrid child, take as the node vin the statement this hybrid child: it is a leaf, and all its parents have the same t-value as v0, which implies, arguing as in the previous case, that all siblings of vare leaves or hybrid nodes. Thus, introduce now some reductions for TCTC-networks. Each of these to a TCTC-network with nleaves and minternal nodes produces a TCTC- network with either n-1 leaves and minternal nodes or with nleaves and m-1 internal nodes, and given any TCTC-network with more than tw o leaves, it will always be possible to apply to it some of these reductions. This lies at the basis of the proofs by algebraic induction of the main results in this paper. LetNbe a TCTC-network with leaves. (U) Letibe one tree leaf of Nand assume that its parent has only this child. The U(i) reduction ofNis the network NU(i)obtained by removing the leaf i, together with its incoming arc, and labeling with iits former parent; cf. Fig. 2. This reduction removes the only child of a node, and thus it is clear that NU(i)is still a TCTC-network, with the same number of leaves but one internal node less than of N(that may, ormay not,haveother ofNis the network NT(i;j)obtained by removing the leaf i, together with its incoming arc; cf. Fig. 3. This reduction procedure r emoves one tree leaf, but its parent ukeeps at least another tree child, and if uwas the root of Nthen it would not become elementary after the reduction, because and therefore, since jis a leaf,ushould have at least another child. Therefore, NT(i;j)is a TCTC-network with the same number of internal nodes as Nandn-1 leaves. (H) Letibe a hybrid leaf of N, letv1,...,vk, be its parents, and assume that each one of these parents has (at least) one tree leaf chi ld: for every l= 1,...,k, letjlbe a tree leaf child of vl. ofNis the by removing the hybrid leaf iand its incoming arcs; cf. Fig. 4. This reduction procedure preserves the time consistency an d the tree-child condition (it removes a hybrid leaf), and the root does not become eleme ntary: indeed, the 9ji possibility for the root to become elementary is to be on e of the parents of i, which is impossible by Corollary 1. Therefore, a TCTC-network with the same number of internal nodes as Nandn-1 k)-reduction. We shall call the inverses of the U, T, and H reduction procedu res, respectively, the U-1, T-1, and H-1expansions , and we shall denote them by U-1(i),R-1(i;j), More specifically, for every TCTC-network N: -IfNhas some leaf labeled i, the expansion U-1(i) can be applied to Nand the resulting network NU-1(i)is obtained by unlabeling the leaf iand adding to it a tree leaf child labeled with i.NU-1(i)is always a no leaf labeled with iand some tree leaf labeled with j, the can be applied to N, and the resulting network NT-1(i;j)is obtained by adding to the parent of the leaf jan new tree leaf child labeled with a no leaf labeled with iand some tree leaves labeled with are not sibling of each other, the expansion H-1(i;j1,...,jk) can be applied to Nand the resulting network obtained by adding a new hybrid node labeled with iand arcs from the parents of j1,...,jktoi. always a tree child hybridization network, but it need not be time con sistent, as the have different temporal representations in N(for instance, one of them could be a tree descendant of another one). The following result is easily deduced from the explicit des criptions of the reduction and expansion procedures, and the fact that isomorphisms pr eserve labels and parents. Lemma 5. LetNandN'be two TCTC-networks. If N~=N', then the result of applying to bothNandN'the same U reduction (respectively, T reduction, H reductio n, U-1 10expansion, T-1expansion, or H-1expansion) are again two isomorphic . Moreover, if we apply an U reduction (respectively, T reduct ion, or H reduction) to a TCTC-network N, and then we apply to the resulting TCTC-network the inverse U-1 expansion (respectively, T-1expansion, or H-1expansion), we obtain a to N. As we said above, every TCTC-network with at least 3 leaves al lows the application of some 3. LetNbe a TCTC-network with more than two leaves. Then, at least one U, R, or H reduction can be applied to N. Proof.By Lemma 4, Ncontains either an internal (tree or hybrid) node vall whose children are tree leaves, or a hybrid leaf iall whose siblings are leaves or hybrid nodes. In the first case, we can apply to Neither the reduction U(i) (ifvhas only one child, and it is the tree leaf i) orT(i;j) (ifvhas at least two tree leaf children, iandj). In the second case, let v1,...,vk, be the parents of i. By the tree child withl= 1,...,k, has some tree child, and by the assumption on i, it will be a leaf, say jl. Then, we can apply to Nthe reduction every TCTC-network with leaves and minternal nodes is obtained by the application of an U-1, T-1, or H-1expansion to a TCTC-network with either n-1 leaves or nleaves and m-1 internal nodes. This allows the recursive construction of all TCTC-networks from TCTC-networks (actually, phylog enetic trees) with 2 leaves and 1 internal node. Example 1. Fig. 5 shows how a sequence of reductions transforms a certai n TCTC- network Nwith 4 leaves into a phylogenetic tree with 2 leaves. The sequ ence of would then generate Nfrom this phylogenetic tree. This sequence of expan- sions generating Nis, of course, not unique. 4 Path lengths vectors for fully resolved networks LetNbe a hybridization network on S={1,...,n}. For every pair of leaves andlN(j,i) be the distance from [ i,j] toiand toj, 3. TheLCSA-path length between two leaves lengths vector ofNis L(N) its entries ordered in 43==H(3;1,4) 12 4
==T(2;1) 1 4 Fig.5.A sequence of that LN(i,j) =LN(j,i), for every pair of leaves i,jS. IfNis a phylogenetic tree, the LCSA-path length between two lea ves is the path length between them as defined in SS2.2, and therefore the vectors L(N) defined therein and here are the same. But, contrary to what happens in phylog enetic trees, the LCSA- path length between two leaves iandjin a hybridization network need not be the smallest sum of the distances from a common ancestor of iandjto these leaves (that is, the distance between these leaves in the undirected grap h associated to the 2. Consider the TCTC-network Ndepicted in Fig. 6. Table 4 gives, in its upper triangle, the LCSA of every pair of different leaves, and in its lower triangle, the LCSA-path length between every pair of different leaves. Notice that, in this network, [3 ,5] =r, because the root is the only common ancestor of 3 and 5 that is strict ancestor of some of them, and hence LN(3,5) = 8, but eis a common ancestor of both leaves and the length of both paths e/squiggleright3 is 3. Similarly, fis also a common ancestor of both leaves and the length of both is 3. This is an example of LCSA-path length between two leav es that is largest than the smallest sum of the distances from a common a ncestor of these leaves to each one of them. In afully resolved phylogeny with reticulation events, every non extant speci es should have two direct descendants, and every reticulation event s hould involve two parent species, as such an event corresponds always to the exchange of genetic two parents: as Semple points out [23], hybrid nodes with in-degree greater than 2 actually represent an uncertainty of the exact order of 'h ybridization'. Depending on whether we use hybridization or phylogenetic networks to model phylogenies, we distinguish between: 121 2 3 4 5 6 5A Ba b c de fr Fig.6.The network Nin Example 2. Table 1. For every < the entry ( i,j) of this table is [ i,j], and the entry ( j,i) network in Fig. resolved hybridization networks : hybridization networks with all their nodes of types (0,2), (1,0), (1,2), (2,0), or (2,2). -Fully resolved phylogenetic networks : phylogenetic networks with all their nodes of types (0,2), (1,0), (1,2), or (2,1). To simplify the language, we shall say that a hybridization n etwork is quasi-binary when all its nodes are of types (0 ,2), (1,0), (1,2), (2,0), (2,1), or (2,2). These include as special cases the fully resolved hybrid ization and phylogenetic net- works. Our main result in this section establishes that the LCSA-pa th lengths vectors sep- arate fully resolved (hybridization or phylogenetic) TCTC -networks, thus 1 from trees to networks. To prove this result, w e shall use the same strat- egy as the one developed in [4] or [6] to prove that the metrics introduced therein were indeed metrics: algebraic induction based on reductions. N ow, we cannot use the reduc- tions defined in the last section as they stand, because they m ay generate elementary nodes that are forbidden in fully resolved networks. Instea d, we shall use certain of them that always reduce in one the number of l eaves. 13So, consider the following reduction procedures for quasi- binary TCTC networks Leti,jbe two sibling tree leaves of N. ofNis the NR(i;j)obtained by applying first the T(i;j) reduction to Nand then theU(j) reduction to the resulting network. The final result is that the leaves iand jare removed, together with their incoming arcs, and then the ir former common parent, which now has become a leaf, is labeled with j; cf. Fig. 7. u j Letibe a hybrid leaf, let v1andv2be its parents and assume that the other children of these parents are tree leaves j1andj2, respectively. The the quasi-binary TCTC-network by applying first the reduction H(i;j1,j2) toNand then the reductions U(j1) andU(j2) to the The overall effect is that the hybrid leaf iand the tree leaves together with their incoming arcs, and then the for mer parents labeled with j1andj2, respectively; cf. Fig. 8. iv1 j1v2 j2== j1 LetAbe a hybrid node with only one child i, that is a tree node. Let v1andv2 be the parents of Aand assume that the other children of these parents are respectively. The ofNis the by applying first the reduction U(i) toN, followed by the to the resulting network. The overall effect is that the leaf i, its parentAand the leaves j1,j2are removed, together with their incoming arcs, and then the former parents labeled with j1andj2, Fig. 9. We use H 0and H1instead of H and U because, for our purposes in this section, i t has to be possible to decide whether or not we can apply a given red uction to a given j1 network Nfrom the knowledge of L(N), and this cannot be done for the U reduction, while, as we shall see below, it is possible for H 0and H1. H0reductions cannot be applied to fully resolved phylogeneti c networks (they don't have hybrid leaves) and H 1reductions cannot be applied to fully resolved hybridizati on networks (they don't have out-degree 1 hybrid nodes). The ap plication of an R or an H 0 reduction to a fully resolved network is again a fully resolved network, and the application of an R or an H 1reduction to a fully resolved TCTC phylogenetic network is again a fully resolved TCTC phy logenetic network. We shall call the inverses of the R, H 0and H1reduction procedures, respectively, the R-1, H-1 0and H-1 1expansions , and we shall denote them by More specifically, for every quasi-binary TCTC-network Nwith no expansion R-1(i;j) can beapplied to Nif it has a leaf labeled j, and the NR-1(i;j)is obtained by unlabeling the leaf jand adding to it two leaf tree children labeled with iandj; -the expansion H-1 0(i;j1,j2) can be applied to Nif it has a pair of leaves labeled j1,j2, and the resulting network obtained by adding a new hybrid leaf labeled with i, and then, for each l= 1,2, unlabeling the leaf jland adding to it a new tree leaf child labeled with jland an arc to i. -the expansion H-1 1(i;j1,j2) can be applied to Nif it has a pair of leaves labeled j1,j2, and the resulting network obtained by adding a new node A, a tree leaf child ito it, and then, for each l= 1,2, unlabeling the leaf jland adding to it a new tree leaf child labeled with jland an arc to A. A R-1(i;j) expansion of a quasi-binary TCTC-network is always a quasi -binary TCTC- network, but an H-1 0(i;j1,j2) or an H-1 1(i;j1,j2) expansion of a quasi-binary instance, the leaves j1andj2could be a hybrid leaf and a tree sibling of it. Moreover, we have the following result, which is a direct consequence o f Lemma 5 and we state it for further reference. Lemma 6. LetNandN'be two quasi-binary TCTC-networks. If N~=N', then the result of applying to both NandN'the same R reduction (respectively, H 0reduction, H 1 reduction, R-1expansion, H-1 0expansion, or H-1 1expansion) is again two if we apply an R reduction (respectively, H 0reduction or H 1reduction) to a quasi-binary TCTC-network N, and then we apply to the resulting network the (respectively, H-1 0expansion or H-1 1expansion), we obtain a isomorphic to N. We have moreover the following 4. LetNbe a quasi-binary TCTC-network with more than one leaf. Then, at least one R, H 0, or H1reduction can be applied to some internal node with two tree leaf children iandj, then the reduction R(i;j) can be applied. If Ndoes not contain any node with two tree leaf children, then, by Lemma 4, it contains a hybrid node vthat is either a leaf (say, labeled withi) or it has only one child, which is a tree leaf (say, labeled wi thi), and such that all siblings of vare leaves or hybrid nodes. Now, the quasi-binarity of Nand the tree child condition entail that vhas two parents, that each one of them has exactly one child other than v, and that this second child is a tree node. So, vhas exactly two siblings, and they are tree leaves, say j1andj2. Then, the reduction H0(i;j1,j2) (ifvis a (ifvis not a leaf) can be 2. (a) IfNis a fully resolved TCTC hybridization network with more than one leaf, then, at least one R or H 0reduction can be applied to it. (b) IfNis a fully resolved TCTC phylogenetic network with more than one leaf, then, at least one R or H 1reduction can be applied to it. We shall prove now that the application conditions for the re ductions introduced above can be read from the LCSA-path lengths vector of a fully resolved TCTC-network and that they modify in a specific way the LCSA-path lengths of the network which they are applied to. This will entail that if two fully resolved (h ybridization or vectors, the n can be applied to both networks and the resulting fully resolved TCTC-networks still have the same LCSA-path lengths vectors. This will be the basis of the proof by induction on the number of leaves that two TCTC hybridization or phylogen etic networks with the same LCSA-path lengths vectors are always 7. Leti,jbe two leaves of a quasi-binary TCTC-network N. if, and only if, LN(i,j) = = 2, then the paths [ length 1, and therefore [i,j] is a parent of iandj. Conversely, if iandjare siblings and uis a parent in common of them, then, by the quasi-binarity of N, they are the only children of u, and by the tree-child condition, one of them, say i, is a tree node. But then, uis a strict ancestor of i, an ancestor of j, and no proper descendant of uis an ancestor of both iandj. This implies that u= [i,j] and hence that LN(i,j) = 2. Lemma 8. LetNbe a quasi-binary TCTC-network on a set Sof taxa. 16(1) The reduction R(i;j)can be applied to Nif, and only if, LN(i,j) = 2and, for =LN(j,k). (2) If the reduction R(i;j)can be applied to N, =LN(j,k)-1for every =LN(k,l)for every far as (1) goes, R(i;j) can be applied to Nif, and only if, the leaves iandj are siblings and of tree type. Now, if iandjare two tree sibling leaves and uis their parent, then on the one hand, LN(i,j) = 2 by Lemma 7, and on the other hand, since, by Lemma 2, [ i,k] = [u,k] = [j,k] for every leaf we have that lN(i,k) =lN(j,k) = 1+distance from [ u,k] tou lN(k,i) =lN(k,j) = distance from [ u,k] tok and therefore LN(i,k) =LN(j,k) for every assume that LN(i,j) = 2 and that LN(i,k) =LN(j,k) for every k S{i,j}. The fact that LN(i,j) = 2 implies that iandjshare a parent u. If one of these leaves, say i, is hybrid, then the tree child condition implies that the ot her,j, is of tree type. Let now vbe the other parent of iandka tree descendant leaf of v, and let hbe the length of the unique path Thenvis a strict ancestor of kand an ancestor of i, and no proper tree descendant of vcan possibly be an ancestor of i: otherwise, there would exist a path from a propertree descendant of vtou, and then the time would forbid uandvto have a hybrid child in common. Therefore v= [i,k] andLN(i,k) =h+1. Now, the only possibility for the equality LN(j,k) =h+1 to hold is that some intermediate node in the path an ancestor of the only parent uof j, which, as we have just seen, is impossible. This leads to a co ntradiction, which both tree sibling leaves. This finishes the proof of jbyitsparent. By Lemma 2, this does not modify the LCSA [ j,k] ofjand any other remaining leaf k, and since we have shortened in 1 any path ending in j, we deduce that LNR(i;j)(j,k) =
LN(j,k)-1 for every {i,j}. On the other hand, for every k,lS{i,j}, the reduction R(i;j) has affected neither the LCSA [ k,l] ofkandl, nor the paths [ which implies that LNR(i;j)(k,l) =LN(k,l) Lemma 9. LetNbe a fully resolved TCTC hybridization network on a set Sof taxa. (1) The reduction H0(i;j1,j2)can be applied to Nif, and only if, LN(i,j1) =LN(i,j2) =
2. (2) If the reduction H0(i;j1,j2)can be applied to N, =LN(j1,k)-1for every =LN(j2,k)-1for every =LN(k,l)for every far as (1) goes, the reduction H0(i;j1,j2) can be applied to Nif, and only if,iis a hybrid sibling of the tree leaves j1andj2. If this last condition happens, then LN(i,j1) = 2 and LN(i,j2) = 2 by Lemma 7. Conversely, LN(i,j1) =LN(i,j2) = 2 implies that i,j1andi,j2are pairs of sibling leaves. Since no node of Ncan have more than 2 children, and at least one of its children must be of tre e type, this implies that i is a hybrid node (with two different parents), and j1andj2are tree nodes. As far as (2) goes, the tree leaves j1andj2are replaced by their parents. By Lemma 7, this does not affect any LCSA and it only shortens in 1 the path s ending in j1orj2. Thus, the H0(i;j1,j2) reduction does not affect the LCSA-path length between any pa ir of remaining leaves other than j1andj2, it shortens in 1 the LCSA-path length any remaining leaf other than j1orj2, and it shortens in 2 the LCSA-path length between j1andj2. Lemma 10. LetNbe a fully resolved TCTC phylogenetic network on a set Sof taxa. (1) The reduction H1(i;j1,j2)can be applied to Nif, and only if, -LN(i,j1) =LN(i,j2) = = 4, thenLN(j1,k) =LN(j2,k)for every If the reduction H1(i;j1,j2)can be applied to N, =LN(j1,k)-1for every =LN(j2,k)-1for every =LN(k,l)for every far as (1) goes, the reduction H1(i;j1,j2) can be applied to Nif, and only if, j1andj2are tree leaves that are not siblings and they share a sibling hybrid node that has the tree leaf ias its only child. Now, if this application condition for H1(i;j1,j2) is satisfied, then LN(i,j1) = 3, because the parent of j1is an ancestor of i, a strict ancestor ofj1, and clearly no proper descendant of it is an ancestor of iandj1; by a = 3. Moreover, since j1andj2are not sibling, But if LN(j1,j2) = 3, then there would exist an arc from the parent of j1to the parent of j2, or vice versa, which would entail a node of out-degree 3 that c annot exist in the fully resolved network N. Therefore, Finally, if LN(j1,j2) = 4, this means that the parents are tree nodes, because they have out-degree 2 and Nis a phylogenetic network) are sibling: let ube their parent in common. In this case, no leaf other than j1,j2,iis a descendant of u, and therefore, for every = [x,k] = [u,k] = [y,k] = [j2,k] by Lemma 4, and thus lN(j1,k) =lN(j2,k) = 2+distance from [ u,k] tou lN(k,j1) =lN(k,j2) = distance from [ u,k] tok, 18which implies that LN(j1,k) assume that LN(i,j1) =LN(i,j2) = 3, that and that if LN(j1,j2) = 4, then LN(j1,k) =LN(j2,k) for every {j1,j2,i}. Letx,yand zbe the parents of j1,j2andi, respectively. Notice that these parents are (otherwise, the LCSA-path length between a pair amo ngj1,j2,iwould be 2). Moreover, since LN(i,j1) =
LN(i,j2) = 3 implies that there must exist an arc between the nodes xandzand an arc between the nodes yandz. Now, if these arcs are ( z,x) and (z,y), the node zwould have out-degree 3, which is impossible. Assume now that ( x,z) and (z,y) are arcs of N. In this case, both zand xhave out-degree 2, which implies (recall that Nis a phylogenetic network) that they are tree nodes. Then, x= [j1,j2] (it is an ancestor of j2, a strict ancestor of j1, and no proper descendant of it is an ancestor of j1andj2) and therefore LN(j1,j2) = 4. In this case, we assume that LN(j1,k) =LN(j2,k) for every {j1,j2,i}. Now we must distinguish two cases, depending on the type of node y: -Ifyis a tree node, let pbe its child other than j2, and let kbe a tree descendant leaf ofp. In this case, [ j1,k] =xand [j2,k] =y(by the same reason why xis [j1,j2]), and hence LN(j1,k) =LN(j2,k)+2, against the assumption LN(j1,k) a hybrid node, let pbe its parent other than z, and let kbe a tree descendant leaf because j2is not a tree descendant of p). In this case, [ j2,k] =p (because pis an ancestor of j2and a strict ancestor of k, and the time implies that no intermediate node in the path be an ancestor of y). Now, if the length of the (only) path thenLN(j2,k) =h+ 2, and for the equality LN(j1,k) =h+2 to hold, either the arc ( x,p) belongs to N, which is impossible because xwould have out-degree 3, or a node in the path an ancestor of x, which is impossible because of the time consistency proper ty. In both cases we reach a contradiction that implies that the a rcs (x,z),(z,y) do not exist inN. By symmetry, the arcs ( y,z),(z,x) do not exist in N, either. Therefore, the only possibility is that Ncontains the arcs ( x,z),(y,z), that is, that zis hybrid child of the nodesxandy. This finishes the proof of (1). As far as (2) goes, it is proved as in Lemma 9. Now we can prove the main results in this 5. LetNandN'be two fully resolved TCTC hybridization networks on the same set Sof taxa. Then, L(N) =L(N')if, and only if, N~=N'. Proof.The 'if' implication is obvious. We prove the 'only if' impli cation by induction on the number nof elements of S. The cases n= 1 and n= 2 are straightforward, because there exist only one TCTC- network on S={1}and one TCTC-network on S={1,2}: the one-node graph and the phylogenetic tree with leaves 1,2, now that the thesis is true for fully resolved TCTC hyb ridization and let NandN'be two fully resolved TCTC hybridization networks on the same set Sofn+1 labels such that L(N) =L(N'). By Corollary 2.(a), an R(i;j) or aH0(i;j1,j2) can be applied to N. Moreover, since the possibility of applying one such reduction depends on the LCSA-path lengths vector by Lemmas 8.(1) and 9.(1), and L(N) =L(N'), it will be possible to apply the same reduction to N'. So, letN1andN' 1 be the fully resolved TCTC hybridization networks obtained by applying the same R or H0reduction to NandN'. From Lemmas 8.(2) and 9.(2) we deduce that L(N1) =L(N' 1) and hence, by the induction hypothesis, N1~=N' 1. Finally, if we apply to N1andN' 1the R-1or H-1 0 expansion that is inverse to the reduction applied to NandN', then, by Lemma 6, we obtain again NandN'and they are isomorphic. A similar argument, using Lemmas 8 and 10, proves the followi ng 6. LetNandN'be two fully resolved TCTC phylogenetic networks on the same set Sof taxa. Then, L(N) =L(N')if, and only if, N~=N'. Remark 2. consider the TCTC-networks N,N'depicted in Fig. 10. They are neither fully resolved phylogenetic networks nor full y resolved hybridization net- works), and a simple computation shows that L(N) =L(N') = network Nin Fig. 10 also shows that Lemma 10.(1) is false for quasi-bin ary hy- bridization networks. 1 2 34 N1 234 N' Fig.10. These two quasi-binary TCTC-networks have the same LCSA-pa th length vectors. 20Let FRH n(respectively, FRP n) denote the classes of fully resolved TCTC hybridiza- tion (respectively, phylogenetic) networks on S={1,...,n}. We have just proved that the mappings L: FRHn-Rn(n-1)/2, L: injective, and therefore they can be used to induce metri cs on FRH nand FRP nfrom metrics on 7. For every letDbe any metric on Rn(n-1)/2. The mappings by d(N1,N2) the axioms of metrics up to = 0if, and only if, (3) and(4) aredirect consequences of theco while property (2) follows from the separation axiom for D(which says that D(M1,M2) = 0 if, and only if, M1=M2) and Proposition 5 or 6, depending on the case. For instance, using as Dthe Manhattan distance on Rn(n-1)/2, we obtain the metric on FRH nor FRP n d1(N1,N2) =/summationdisplay
<j/lessorequalslantn|LN1(i,j)-LN2(i,j)|, and using as Dthe Euclidean distance we obtain the metric d2(N1,N2) =/radicaligg/summationdisplay
<j/lessorequalslantn(LN1(i,j)-LN2(i,j))2. ThesemetricsgeneralizetofullyresolvedTCTC(hybridiza classical distances for fully resolved phylogenetic tr ees introduced by Farris [11] and Clifford [29] around 1970. 5 Splitted path lengths vectors for arbitrary networks As we have seen in SS2.2 and Remark 2, the path lengths vectors do not separate arb Since to separate arbitrary phylogenetic t rees we splitted the path lengths (Definition 2), we shall use the same strategy in the n etworks setting. In this connection, we already proved in [6] that the matrix l(N) TCTC phylogenetic networks on S={1,...,n}with tree nodes of and hybrid nodes of arbitrary in-degree. But it i s not true for TCTC hy- bridization networks, as the following example These two hybridization TCTC-networks are such that lN(i,j) =lN'(i,j), for every pair 3. Consider the pair of non-isomorphic TCTC-networks NandN'depicted in Fig. 11. A simple computation shows that l(N) =l(N') =
0 12 2 12 1 01 1 22 2 10 2 22 2 12 0 12 1 22 1 01 2 22 2 10
So, in order to separate arbitrary TCTC-networks we need to a dd some extra infor- mation to the distances lN(i,j) from LCSAs to leaves. The extra information we shall use is whether the LCSA of each pair of leaves is a strict ances tor of one leaf or the other (or both). So, for every pair of different leaves i,jofN, lethN(i,j) be-1 if [i,j] is a strict ancestor of ibut not of j, 1 if [i,j] is a strict ancestor of jbut not of i, and 0 if [i,j] is a strict ancestor of both iandj. Notice that hN(j,i) 4. LetNbe a hybridization network on the set S={1,...,n}. For every i,jS, thesplitted LCSA-path length fromitojis the ordered = LCSA-path lengths vector ofNis Ls(N) =/parenleftbig Ls N(i,j)/parenrightbig
<j/lessorequalslantn(NxNx{-1,0,1})n(n-1)/2 with its entries ordered in (i,j). Example 4. Consider the quasi-binary TCTC-networks NandN'depicted in Fig. 5. Consider the TCTC-networks NandN'depicted in Fig. 11. 3. IfNis a phylogenetic tree on S, thenhN(i,j) = 0 for every i,jS. We shall prove now that these splitted LCSA-path lengths vec tors separate TCTC-networks. The master plan for proving i t is similar to the one used in the proof of Proposition 5: induction based on the fact tha t the application conditions for the reductions introduced in Section 3 can be read in the s plitted LCSA-path lengths vectors of TCTC-networks and that these reductions modify i n a controlled way 11. LetNbe a TCTC-network on a set Sof taxa. (1) The reduction U(i)can be applied to Nif, and only if, every j S{i}. (2) If the reduction U(i)can be applied to N, then LNU(i)(i,j) every =LN(j,k)for every j,{i}
Proof.As far as (1) goes, the reduction U(i) can be applied to Nif, and only if, the leaf iis a tree node and the only child of its parent. Let us check now that this last condition is equivalent to for every jS{i}. To do this, we distinguish three cases: -Assume that iis a tree node and the only child of its parent x. Then, for every jS{i}, the LCSA of iandjis a proper ancestor of x, and therefore . -Assume that iis a tree node and that it has a sibling y. Letxbe the parent of i andyand letjbe a tree descendant leaf of y. Then [i,j] =x, because xis a strict ancestor of i, an ancestor of jand clearly no descendant of xis an ancestor of both iandj. Therefore, in this case, lN(i,j) = 1 for this leaf j. -Assumethat iis ahybridnode. Let xbeany parent of iandletjbea tree descendant ofx. Then, [ i,j] =x, because xis a strict ancestor of j, an ancestor of i, and no intermediate node in the unique path an ancestor of i(it would violate the time consistency property). Therefore, in this case, lN(i,j) = 1 for this leaf j, too. Since these three cases cover all possibilities, we conclud e thatiis a tree node without siblings if, and only if, for every jS{i}. This finishes the proof of (1). As far as (2) goes, in NU(i)we replace the tree leaf iby its parent. By Lemma 2, this does not modify any LCSA, and it only shortens in 1 any path end ing ini. =lN(i,j)-1, lNU(i)(j,i) =lN(j,i) for every =lN(j,k), lNU(i)(k,j) =lN(k,j) for every j,{i}
23As far as the hcomponent of the splitted LCSA-path lengths goes, notice th at a node uis a strict ancestor of a tree leaf iif, and only if, it is a strict ancestor of its parent x(because every path ending in icontains x). Therefore, an internal node of NU(i)is a strict ancestor of the leaf iinNU(i)if, and only if, it is a strict ancestor of the leaf iin N. On the other hand, replacing a tree leaf without siblings by its only parent does not affect any path ending in another leaf, and therefore an intern al node of NU(i)is a strict ancestor of a leaf and only if, it is a strict ancestor of the leaf jinN. So, by Lemma 2, the LCSA of a pair of leaves in Nand inNU(i)is the same, and we have just proved that this LCSA is a strict ancestor of exactl y the same leaves in both networks: this implies that hNU(i)(i,j) =hN(i,j) for every =hN(j,k) for every j,{i}
Lemma 12. LetNbe a TCTC-network on a set Sof taxa. (1) The reduction T(i;j)can be applied to Nif, and only if, Ls N(i,j) = (1,1,0). (2) If the reduction T(i;j)can be applied to N, =Ls N(k,l)for every far as (1) goes, T(i;j) can be applied to Nif, and only if, the leaves iandjare tree nodes and sibling. Let us prove that this last condition is equivalent to lN(i,j) =
lN(j,i) = 1 and hN(i,j) = 0. Indeed, if the leaves iandjare tree nodes and sibling, then their parent is their LCSA and moreover it is a strict anc estor of both of them, which implies that lN(i,j) =lN(j,i) = 1 and hN(i,j) = 0. Conversely, assume that lN(i,j) =lN(j,i) = 1 and hN(i,j) = 0. The equalities lN(i,j) =lN(j,i) = 1 imply that [i,j] is a parent of iandj, andhN(i,j) = 0 implies that this parent of iandjis a strict ancestor of both of them, and therefore, by Lemma 3, that iandjare tree nodes. This finishes the proof of (1). As far as (2) goes, in NT(i;j)we simply remove the leaf iwithout removing anything else. Therefore, no path ending in a remaining leaf is affected , and as a consequence no Ls(k,l) is modified. Lemma 13. LetNbe a TCTC-network on a set Sof taxa. (1) The reduction be applied to Nif, and only if, -Ls N(i,jl) = (1,1,1), for every l every a,b {1,...,k}. -For every s / {j1,...,jk}, iflN(i,s) = 1andhN(i,s) = 1, thenlN(jl,s) = 1 andhN(jl,s) = 0for some l {1,...,k}. (2) If the reduction be applied to N, =LN(s,t)for every far as (1) goes, H(i;j1,...,jk) can be applied to Nif, and only if, j1,...,jk are tree leaves that are not sibling of each other, the leaf iis a hybrid sibling of j1,...,jk, and the only parents of iare those of j1,...,jk. Now: -For each l= 1,...,k, the condition Ls N(i,jl) = (1,1,1) says that iandjlare sibling, and that their parent in common is a strict ancestor of jlbut not of i. Using Lemma 3, we conclude that this condition is equivalent to the fact t hatiandjlare sibling, jlis a tree node, and ia hybrid node. -Assume that j1,...,jkare tree leaves, with parents v1,...,vk, respectively. In this case, the condition is equivalent to the fact that ja,jbare not sibling. Indeed, if jaandjbare sibling, then lN(ja,jb) =lN(jb,ja) = 1. Conversely, if jaandjbare not sibling, then there are two possibilities: either vais an ancestor of jb, but not its parent, in which case va= [ja,jb] or vais not an ancestor of jb, in which case [ ja,jb] is a proper ancestor of vaand hence . -Assume that j1,...,jkare tree leaves, with parents v1,...,vk, respectively, and that iis a hybrid sibling of them. Let us see that the only parents of and only if, for every s / = 1 and hN(i,s) = 1 imply that lN(jl,s) = 1 and hN(jl,s) = 0 for some l= 1,...,k. Indeed, assume that the only parents of iarev1,...,vk, and let s / {j1,...,jk}be a leaf such that lN(i,s) = 1 and hN(i,s) = 1. Since lN(i,s) = 1, some parent of i, say vl, is the LCSA of iands, andhN(i,s) = 1 implies that vlis a strict ancestor of s. But then vlwill be the LCSA of its tree leaf jlandsand strict ancestor of both of them, and thus lN(jl,s) = 1 and hN(jl,s) = 0. Conversely, assume that, for every s / = 1 and hN(i,s) = 1 imply that lN(jl,s) = 1 and hN(jl,s) = 0 for some l= 1,...,k. Letvbe a parent of i, and let sbe a tree descendant leaf of v. Then,v= [i,s] (vis a strict ancestor of s, an ancestor of i, and no intermediate node in the unique path an ancestor ofi, by the time consistency property) and thus lN(i,s) = 1; moreover, hN(i,s) = 1 by Lemma 3. Now, if s=jl, for some l= 1,...,k, thenv=vl. On the other hand, if s / {j1,...,jk}, then by assumption, there will exist some jlsuch that lN(jl,s) = 1 andhN(jl,s) = 0, that is, such that vlis a strict ancestor of s. This implies that v=vl. Indeed, if then either vlis an intermediate node in the path in particular a tree descendant of v, which is forbidden by the time vandvlhave the hybrid child iin common, or vis a proper a path where vland all the intermediate nodes are hybrid (if some of these nodes were of tree type, the temporal representation o fvwould be greater than that ofvl, contradicting again the time consistency), in which case t he child of vlin this path would be a hybrid child of vlthat is a strict descendant of it (because it is intermediate in the path a strict descendant of vl), which is impossible by Lemma 3. This finishes the proof of in else, and therefore no splitted LCSA-path length o f a pair of remaining leaves is 1. LetNandN'be two TCTC-networks on the same set Sof taxa. Then, Ls(N) =Ls(N')if, and only if, N~=N'. Proof.The 'if' implication is obvious. We prove the 'only if' impli cation by double in- duction on the number nof elements of Sand the number mof internal nodes of N. As in Proposition 5, the cases n= 1 and n= 2 are straightforward, because both TCTC 1and TCTC 2consist of a single m= 1,forevery the network Nis in this case the phylogenetic tree with Newick , consisting only of the root and the leaves, and in particula rLs N(i,j) =
(1,1,0) for every < IfLs(N) =Ls(N'), we have that Ls N'(i,j) = (1,1,0) for every < and therefore all leaves in N'are tree nodes and sibling of each other by Lemma 3. Since the root of a hybridization network ca nnot be elementary, this says that N'is also a phylogenetic tree with Newick string (1,2,...,n); and hence it is isomorphic to N. Let now NandN'two TCTC-networks with leaves such that Ls(N) internal nodes. Assume as induction hypothesis that the th esis in the theorem is true for pairs of TCTC-networks N1,N' 1withn-1 leaves or with nleaves and such that N1hasm-1 internal nodes. By Proposition 3, a reduction U(i),T(i;j) orH(i;j1,...,jk) can be applied to N. Since the application conditions for such a reduction depen d only on the splitted LCSA- path lengths vectors by Lemmas 11.(1), 12.(1) and 13.(1), an dLs(N) =Ls(N'), we conclude that we can apply the same reduction to N'. Now, we apply the same reduction to NandN'to obtain new TCTC-networks N1 andN' 1, respectively. If the reduction was of the form and N1hasm-1 internal nodes; if the reduction was of the forms T(i;j) leaves. In all cases, Ls(N1) =Ls(N' 1) by Lemmas 11.(2), 12.(2) and 13.(2), and therefore, by the induction hypothesis, by Lemma 5, NandN'are obtained from N1andN' 1by applying the same expansion U-1, T-1, or H-1, and they are isomorphic. The vectors of splitted LCSA-path lengths vectors do not sep arate much more general than the TCTC, as we following exa mples show. Remark 4. The vectors of splitted distances do not separate arbitrary (that, is, phylogenetic networks NandN'depicted in Fig. 12 have the same Lsvectors: Ls(N) =Ls(N') 2 3 N1 2 3 N' Fig.12. These two tree-child binary phylogenetic networks have the same splitted LCSA-path 5. The splitted LCSA-path lengths vectors do not separate tree -sibling time consistent phylogenetic networks, either. Consider for in stance the tree-sibling time con- sistent fully resolved phylogenetic networks NandN'depicted in Figure 13. A shows that they have the same Lsvectors, but they are not isomorphic. As in the fully resolved case, the injectivity of the mapping Ls: TCTC it possible to induce metrics on TCTC nfrom metrics on R3n(n-1)/2. The proof of the following result is similar to that of Proposition 7. Proposition 8. For every letDbe any metric on R3n(n-1)/2. The mapping ds: TCTC nxTCTC n-Rdefined by d(N1,N2) the axioms of metrics up to isomorphisms. 2712 3456 78 N 12 7856 34 N' Fig.13. These two tree-sibling time consistent binary phylogeneti c networks have the same lengths , respectively, the metrics on TCTC n ds 1(N1,N2) =/summationdisplay
<j/lessorequalslantn/parenleftbig
|lN1(i,j)-lN2(i,j)|+|lN1(j,i)-lN2(j,i)|
+|hN1(i,j)-hN2(i,j)|/parenrightbig
=/summationdisplay
/negationslash=j/lessorequalslantn/parenleftbig
|lN1(i,j)-lN2(i,j)|+1 2|hN1(i,j)-hN2(i,j)|/parenrightbig ds 2(N1,N2) =/parenleftig/summationdisplay
<j/lessorequalslantn/parenleftbig (lN1(i,j)-lN2(i,j))2+(lN1(j,i)-lN2(j,i))2
+(hN1(i,j)-hN2(i,j))2/parenrightbig/parenrightig1 2
=/radicaligg/summationdisplay
/negationslash=j/lessorequalslantn/parenleftbig (lN1(i,j)-lN2(i,j))2+1 2(hN1(i,j)-hN2(i,j))2/parenrightbig 28These metrics generalize to TCTC-networks the splitted nod al metrics for trees defined in [7]. and the nodal metric for TC TCphylogenetic networks defined in [6]. 6 Conclusions A classical result of Smolenskii [24] establishes that the v ectors of distances between pairs of leaves separate unrooted phylogenetic trees on a gi ven set of taxa. This easily to fully resolved rooted phylogenetic t rees [7], and it lies at the basis of the classical definitions of nodal distances for unrooted as well as for fully resolved trees based on the comparison of these vectors But these vectors do not separate arbitrary rooted phylogenetic tree s, and therefore they cannot be used to compare the latter in a sound way. This problem was o vercome in [7] by introducing the splitted path lengths matrices and showing that they separate arbitrary rooted phylogenetic trees on a given set of taxa. It is possib le then to define splitted nodal metrics for arbitrary rooted phylogenetic trees by compari ng these matrices. In this paper we have generalized these results to the class T CTCnof tree-child time consistent hybridization networks (TCTC-networks) with nleaves. For every pair i,jof leaves in a TCTC-network N, we have defined the LCSA-path length LN(i,j) and the splitted LCSA-path length Ls N(i,j) between iandjand we have proved that the vectors L(N) = (LN(i,j))<j/lessorequalslantnseparate fully resolved networks in TCTC nand the vectors Ls(N) = (Ls N(i,j))<j/lessorequalslantnseparate arbitrary vectors L(N) andLs(N) can be computed in low polynomial time by means of simple algorithms that do not require the use of sophisticat ed data structures. Indeed, letnbe the number of leaves and mthe number of internal nodes in N. As we explained in [5,SSV.D], for each internal node vand for each leaf i, it can be decided whether v is a strict or a non-strict ancestor of i, or not an ancestor of it at all, by computing by breadth-first search the shortest paths from the root to ea ch leaf before and after removing each of the mnodes in turn, because a non-strict descendant of a node will still be reachable from the root after removing that node, wh ile a strict descendant will not. All this information can be computed in O(m(n+m)) time, and once it has been computed the least common semi-strict ancestor of two leave s can be computed in O(m) time by selecting the node of least height among those which a re ancestors of the two leaves and strict ancestors of at least one of them. This allo ws the computation of L(N) andLs(N) inO(m2+n2m) time. These vectors L(N) andLs(N) can be used then to define metrics for fully resolved and arbitrary TCTC-networks, respectively, from metrics f or real-valued vectors. The metrics obtained in this way can be understood as generaliza tions to TCTC nof or splitted) nodal metrics for phylogenetic trees and they can be computed in low polynomial time if the metric used to compare the vecto rs can be done so: this is the case, for instance, when this metric is the Manhattan or t he Euclidean metric (in the last case, computing the square root with O(10m+n) significant digits [2], which should be more than enough). 29It remains to study the main properties of the metrics defined in this way, like for instance their diameter or the distribution of their values . It is important to recall here that these are open problems even for the classical nodal dis tances for fully resolved rooted phylogenetic research reported in this paper has been partially suppo rted by the Spanish DGI projects MTM2006-07773 COMGRIO and . References 1. M. Baroni, C. Semple, M. Steel, Hybrids in real time, Syst. Biol. 55 (2006) 46-56. 2. P.Batra, complexi Notes Theor. Comput. Sci. 202 (2008) 201-218. 3. J. Bluis, D.-G. Shin, Nodal distance algorithm: Calculat ing a phylogenetic tree comparison metric, in: Proc. 3rd IEEE Symp. BioInformatics and BioEngineering , 2003. 4. G. Cardona, M. Llabr' es, F. Rossell' o, G. Valiente, A dist ance metric for a class of tree-sibling phy- logenetic networks, Bioinformatics 24 (13) (2008) 1481-14 88. 5. G.Cardona, M.Llabr' es, F.Rossell' o, G. Valiente,Metri csfor the Robinson-Foulds metric, submitted (2008). 6. G. Cardona, M. Llabr' es, F. Rossell' o, G. Valiente, Metri cs for phylogenetic networks II: Nodal and triplets metrics, submitted (2008). 7. G. Cardona, M. Llabr' es, F. Rossell' o, G. Valiente, Nodal metrics for rooted phylogenetic trees, sub- mitted, available at (2008). 8. G. Cardona, F. Rossell' o, G. Valiente, Comparison of tree -child phylogenetic networks, IEEE T. Comput. Biol. preprint, 30 June 2008 , doi: . 9. G. Cardona, F. Rossell' o, G. Valiente, Tripartitions don ot always discriminate phylogenetic networks, Math. Biosci. 211 (2) (2008) 356-370. 10. W. F. Doolittle, Phylogenetic classification and the uni versal tree, Science 284 (5423) (1999) 2124- 2128. 11. J. S. Farris, A successive approximations approach to ch aracter weighting, Syst. Zool. 18 J. S. Farris, On comparing the shapes of taxonomic trees, Syst. Zool. 22 (1973) 50-54. 13. D. Gusfield, S. Eddhu, C. Langley, The fine structure of gal ls in phylogenetic networks, INFORMS J. Comput, 16 (4) (2004) 459-469. 14. D. Gusfield, S. Eddhu, C. Langley, Optimal, efficient recon struction of phylogenetic networks with constrained recombination, J. Bioinformatics Comput. Bio l. 2 (1) (2004) 173-213. 15. J. Hein,M. H.Schierup,C. Wiuf, GeneGenealogies, Varia tion andEvolution: APrimer Oxford University Press, 2005. 16. D. H. Huson, D. Bryant, Application of Phylogenetic Netw orks in Evolutionary Studies, Mol. Biol. Evol. 23 (2) (2006) 254-267. 17. D.H.Huson,T. H.Kl -decompo sition Proceedings RECOMB 2007, vol. 4453 of Lecture Notes in Co mputer Science, B. M. E. Moret, L. Nakhleh, T. Warnow, C. R. Linder, A. Thol se, A. Padolina, J. Sun, R. networks: Modeling, an d accuracy, IEEE T. Comput. Biol. 1 (1) (2004) 13-23. 19. L. Nakhleh, J. Sun, T. Warnow, C. R. Linder, B. M. E. Moret, A. Tholse, Towards the development of computational tools for evaluating phylogenetic networ k reconstruction methods, in: Proc. 8th Pacific Symp. Biocomputing, 2003. 3020. L. Nakhleh, J. Sun, T. Warnow, C. R. Linder, B. M. E. Moret, A. Tholse, Towards the development of computational tools for evaluating phylogenetic networ k reconstruction methods, in: Proc. 8th Pacific Symp. Biocomputing, 2003. 21. L. Nakhleh, T. Warnow, C. R. Linder, K. S. John, Reconstru cting reticulate evolution in species: Theory and practice, J. Comput. Biol. 12 (6) (2005) 796-811. 22. J. B. Phipps, Dendrogram topology, Syst. Zool. 20 (1971) 306-308. 23. C. Semple, Hybridization networks, in: O. Gascuel, M. St eel (eds.), Reconstructing evolution: New mathematical and computational advances, Oxford Universi ty Press, 2008, pp. 277-314. 24. Y. A. Smolenskii, A method for the linear recording of gra phs, USSR Computational Mathematics and Mathematical Physics 2 (1963) 396-397. 25. Y. S. Song, J. Hein, Constructing minimal ancestral reco mbination graphs, J. Comput. Biol. 12 (2) (2005) 147-169. 26. M. A. Steel, D. Penny, Distributions of tree comparison m etrics--some new results, Syst. Biol. 42 (2) (1993) 126-141. 27. G. Valiente, Phylogenetic networks, course at the Int. S ummer School on Bioinformatics and Com- putational Biology Lipari (June 14-21, 2008). 28. L. Wang, K. Zhang, L. Zhang, Perfect phylogenetic networ ks with recombination, J. Comput. Biol. 8 (1) (2001) 69-78. 29. W. T. Williams, H. T. Clifford, On the comparison of two cla ssifications of the same set of elements, Taxon 20 (4) (1971) 519-522. 30. S. J. Willson, Restrictions on meaningful phylogenetic networks, contributed talk at the EMBO Workshop on Current Challenges and Problems in Phylogeneti cs (Isaac Newton Institute for Math- ematical Sciences, Cambridge, UK, 3-7 September 2007). 31. S. J. Willson, Reconstruction of certain phylogenetic n etworks from the genomes at their leaves, J. Theor. Biol. 252 (2008) 338-349. 32. S. M. Woolley, D. Posada, K. A. Crandall, A comparison of p hylogenetic network methods using computer simulation, Plos ONE 3 (4) (2008) e1913. 31
|
0807.0087
|
Francesc Rossell\'o
|
Gabriel Cardona, Merce Llabres, Francesc Rossello, Gabriel Valiente
|
Path lengths in tree-child time consistent hybridization networks
|
31 pages
| null | null | null |
q-bio.PE cs.CE cs.DM q-bio.QM
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
Hybridization networks are representations of evolutionary histories that
allow for the inclusion of reticulate events like recombinations,
hybridizations, or lateral gene transfers. The recent growth in the number of
hybridization network reconstruction algorithms has led to an increasing
interest in the definition of metrics for their comparison that can be used to
assess the accuracy or robustness of these methods. In this paper we establish
some basic results that make it possible the generalization to tree-child time
consistent (TCTC) hybridization networks of some of the oldest known metrics
for phylogenetic trees: those based on the comparison of the vectors of path
lengths between leaves. More specifically, we associate to each hybridization
network a suitably defined vector of `splitted' path lengths between its
leaves, and we prove that if two TCTC hybridization networks have the same such
vectors, then they must be isomorphic. Thus, comparing these vectors by means
of a metric for real-valued vectors defines a metric for TCTC hybridization
networks. We also consider the case of fully resolved hybridization networks,
where we prove that simpler, `non-splitted' vectors can be used.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 1 Jul 2008 09:13:32 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-06T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Cardona",
"Gabriel",
""
],
[
"Llabres",
"Merce",
""
],
[
"Rossello",
"Francesc",
""
],
[
"Valiente",
"Gabriel",
""
]
] |
2 Flavor Physics and CP Violation Conference, Taipei, 2008 tensor structures are omitted for simplicity. the branching ratios or conversion rates are
~(mW/L)4or (mW/LF)4. Thus, L and L Fshould be larger than ~10(5-6)GeV from the This implies that the cLFV searches have quite sensitivities to the BSMs. We have several motivations to consider the BSMs at TeV scale. The naturalness argument for the Higgs boson mass terms is one of them. The dark matter In addition, some people consider origin of the neutrino masses at TeV scale. Why does nature hide clues of the BSMs from FCNC processes including cLFV processes? Some of BSMs, such as the two- or multi-Higgs doublet and/or gauge bosons at TeV scale. Some mod- els, such as supersymmetric models, extra and the little Higgs model with T parity, in- troduce partners of leptons and quarks. Those new fields introduce new sources of FCNCs. While FC- NCs in the SM are suppressed by small or small mixing angle due to the GIM mecha- nism, the suppression is not necessarily automatic in the BSMs. First, let us consider the cLFV processes in the su- persymmetric standard model (SUSY SM), since it of the BSMs. Supersymmetry is a symmetry between bosons and fermions, and superpartners for each particles in the SM are introduced to the is not exact in nature. We need to introduce SUSY-breaking mass terms for SUSY parti- cles, which have not yet been discovered. The SUSY- breaking terms are new sources of the flavor violation, since the squark and slepton mass matrices are not necessarily simultaneously diagonalized with those leads toso-calledthe SUSY flavor problem. We will discuss this problem from a viewpoint of cLFV in the following. In the SUSY SM u-egis generated by and the branching ratio is SUSY breaking scale, sin mixing angle, m2
~lis the slepton mass R parity is assumed here. When it is violating, new LFV sources are introduced in the SUSY SM. See Ref. [16] for the detail discussion.While the branching ratio of u-egis suppressed by one-loop factor, we need much more suppression in order to make it below the experimental bound. Three directions are proposed. First is the univer- sal scalar mass hypothesis, in which the squarks and sleptons with common quantum numbers are degen- erate in mass ( m2
~lm2 SUSY). Many models are constructed following this direction; the gravity me- diation [17], the gauge mediation [18], the [19], and the anomaly mediation [20]. Sec- ond is the alignment hypothesis (sin th~e~u1). It is assumed that squark and slepton mass matrices can be diagonalized in the same basis as those of quarks and leptons due to some flavor symmetries or some mechanism [21]. Third is the decoupling Squarks and sleptons in the first and second generations are so heavy ( O(104-5) GeV) that the flavor violation in the first and second gener- ations are suppressed [22]. In these three hypothesis, the cLFV processes are suppressed. However, the experi- mental sensitivities may probe the origin of the the universal scalar mass hypothesis, if some physics has LFV interactions below the the induced radiatively by the [23]. In this case the LFV mass terms are not suppressed by powers of the energy scale for the LFV interactions. The seesaw mechanism and the GUTs are nowadays ones of attractive models from the phenomenological and theoretical points of view. In these models, LFV Yukawa interactions are intro- duced. Thus, if the SUSY breaking mediation scale is higher than the GUT [24] or the right-handed neu- trino mass scale [25], sizable LFV processes might be predicted. In Fig. 1, Br( u-eg) in the SUSY seesaw model is shown. The observed large neutrino mixing angles enhances the cLFV processes of muon and tau lepton [26, 27]. Various studies are performed under the universal scalar mass hypothesis. See references in Ref. [1]. In the decoupling hypothesis, squarks and addition, even when SUSY particle masses contributions to the cLFV processes [28]. The SUSY SM has twodoublet Higgs bosons ( H1andH2), and their effective couplings for leptons are -LY= -eRiYliLiH1+ the tree-level Yukawa coupling and ij is non-holomorphic correction generated at one-loop level. ijis not suppressed by the SUSY breaking scale, in addition to enhancement of tan b. Then, when the SUSY particles are heavy enough, the Higgs boson exchange dominates in the cLFV processes. Fig. 2 shows the branching ratios for cLFV processesFlavor Physics and CP Violation Conference, Taipei, 2008 eg)M2=130 GeV, m~eL=170 GeV, mnt=0.07eV, 1: Br( u-eg) in the SUSY seesaw model. This figure comes from Ref. [26]. of muon, induced by the Higgs boson exchange in the SUSY SM. This figure comes from Ref. [29]. u-eg is induced by the Barr-Zee type loop diagrams, in nuclei are attree-level. The Higgs boson exchange contributions to the cLFV pro- cesses of tau lepton are also discussed in Ref. [30]. Figure 2: Branching ratios for cLFV processes of muon induced by the Higgs boson exchange in the SUSY SM. This figure comes from Ref. [29]. If the alignment between lepton and slepton masses is not complete in the third hypothesis, the cLFV processes are predicted. Let us show an flavor symmetries, which is given in Ref. [31]. The charge assignments of the right- and left-handed leptons L2(2,2), L3(0,4), and the flavor symmetries are broken by VEVs of flavon fields, ph1(-1,0) andph2(0,-1). In this case, the charged lepton mass matrix is (ml)~l l40 0 l4l20 l4l21 , (12) and the hierarchical structure of lepton masses is ex- plained with l~0.1-0.2. In this setup, the slep- ton mass matrices are aligned, and the left-handed and right-handed slepton mixings are suppressed However, these mixings are marginal to the bounds from u-eg. The SUSY flavor problem is one of the guidelines to construct realistic SUSY SMs. As shown above, in the proposed ideas and models to suppress the FCNC processes, the cLFV processes are not neces- sarily suppressed, and the on-going and planed exper- iments cover the predictions. The cLFV processes also have good sensitivities to non-SUSY models at TeV scale as expected. The BSMs at TeV scale are severely constrained from them. In the following, some concrete examples are the little Higgs model, the Higgs boson is a boson for symmetry breaking, and quadratic divergence in the radiative correction to the Higgs boson mass term is cancelled by heavy particles at one-loop level. The T parity is introduced for the heavy particles not to contribute to the at tree level. This extension has a bonus. The lightest T-odd particle is stable and a candidate of the dark matter in the universe. In the little Higgs model with T parity, SU(2) L doublet mirror leptons with T parity odd are intro- duced. The mirror leptons have coupling with lep- tons and the heavy gauge bosons, which is lepton- flavor violating. The cLFV processes are generated at one-loop level, similar to the SUSY SM. In Fig. 3, Br(u-eg) and Br( u-3e) are shown in this model. It isshownin Ref. [34] that the Br( u-eg) and two processes have compara- ble branching ratios. Then, this model still is viable even the mirror leptons are around 1 TeV. Next is the SM on the Randall-Sundrum (RS) back- ground. The RS geometry is known as a solution of the hierarchy problem [35]. In addition, when the SM fermions and gauge bosons propagate in the space, the fermion mass hierarchy this model the Kaluza-Klein (KK) particles have the LFV interaction. In Fig. 4 Br( u-eg) and R(u-e;Ti) are shown for the KK scale 10 TeV. The current experimental bounds give constraints on4 Flavor Physics and CP Violation Conference, Taipei, 3: Br( u-eg) and Br( u-3e) in the little Higgs model with T parity. Here, the mirror leptons masses are taken from 300 GeV and 1.5 TeV. This figure comes from Ref. [34]. this model. While u-egis a one-loop process, is generated at tree level. Figure 4: Br( u-eg) and R( u-e;Ti) in the SM on the Randall-Sundrum background. Here, the Kaluza- Klein scale is 10 TeV. This figure comes from Ref. [37]. Finally, we discuss the relation of the cLFV pro- cesses and the neutrino masses. The seesaw mecha- nism is the most promising in the candidates of at much higher energyscale than the TeV scale. In such models we cannot expect some direct the cLFV processesand the originof the Exceptionsarethe SUSY 39]; however, the relations are indirect. On the other hand, there are attempts to construct models of the neutrino mass origin at TeV scale. One of the models is the triplet Higgs model (type- II seesaw model) [40]. In this model, the triplet Higgs boson with mass at TeV scale has sizable coupling, and the coupling is directly linked to the neutrino mass matrix. In Fig. 5 the branching ratios for the cLFV processes of muon in this model are shown. The pattern depends on the neutrino mass structure [41].-0.2 -0.1 0.0 0.1 -0.1 0.0 0.1 5: Branching ratios for cLFV processes of muon in the triplet Higgs model. Here, neutrino mass spectrum is (hierarchical) in the upper (low er) figure. These figures come from Ref. the cLFV processes are discovered, it would be important to take correlations among various pro- cesses in order to unveil the origin of the and the realistic BSM. The first correlation is among the cLFV processes with common flavor transition. The correlation dis- criminates BSMs at TeV scale since the pattern of correlation depends on models. In Table I, the ratios of the cLFV rates of muon are shown in three models; the SUSY SM in which the dipole moment contribu- tion to the cLFV processes is dominant, the SUSY SM in which the SUSY particles are so heavy that the Higgs boson exchange dominates, and the little Higgs model with T parity. While the cLFV processes are radiatively generated in those models, the pattern of the ratio of the cLFV rates are quite different. Corre- lations among the cLFV processes of tand among s in various nuclei [42] are also useful to discriminate different flavor transitions. In some models the cLFV processes are related to the neutrino masses. In the triplet Higgs model, the interaction of the triplet Higgs boson with leptons is directly linked to the neu- trino mass matrix ( mn), as mentioned above. TheFlavor Physics and CP Violation Conference, Taipei, 2008 5 Table I Ratios of the cLFV rates of muon in three models. This table comes from SM (dipole) SM (Higgs) Higgs with T parity 0.4-2.5 10-2-102 model is one of realizations of the minimal flavor vi- olation hypothesis in the lepton sector [43]. As the result, the ratios of the cLFV rates of tau lepton and muon are given theSUSY seesawmodels, related to the origin of the neutrino masses even if the energy scale is high. Under the universal scalar mass hypothesis, the cLFV processes give in- formation of the type-I SUSY seesaw model, which is independent of the neutrino mass from a viewpoint of the reconstruction of the model [39]. In the [39]. The third correlation is between the hadronic and leptonic FCNC processes. In GUTs, quarks and lep- tons are unified so that the cLFV processes are corre- lated with hadronic FCNC processes [44]. Let us con- sider the SUSY SU(5) GUT with right-handed neutri- nos. In this model, lepton doublets and quarks are embedded in common Then, neutrino Yukawa coupling affects both the right-handed sdown and left-handed slepton mass matrices [45]. In Fig. 6 we show the CP phase of theBsmixing amplitude, phBs, and Br( t-ug) in the SUSY SU(5) GUT with right-handed neutrinos. The CP violation in the Bsmixing is suppressed in the SM, and then it is alsosensitive to the BSMs. by the [46] that phBs deviates more than 3 sfrom the SM prediction. In the figure, we show the region for phBs. The constrainedfrom nullresult of t-ugsearch in this model, and the 95% probability region derived by the is marginal in this model. When the deviation of phBsis established, search for t-ugwould be an important test of the SUSY SU(5) GUTs. When the flavor-violating mass terms for the right-handed squarks are non-vanishing, the hadronic EDMs are generated at one-loop [48] and two-loop Figure 6: Correlation between CP phase of the Bsmix- ing amplitude, phBs, and Br( t-ug) in the SUSY SU(5) GUT with right-handed neutrinos. Here, tan b= 10 and 30, and we show the region for phBs, derived by the These figures come from Ref. [47] . levels [49]. The non-zero ( chromoelectric dipole moment, to the hadronic EDMs [50]. Thus, the the would be the tests of the SUSY GUTs. But, this program still has difficulties in precisions of the hadronic EDM evaluation [51], and the further im- provements would be required for it. 4.Summary In this talk, I discussed charged lepton-flavor vio- lation in physics beyond the standard model and re- viewed topics related to it. The cLFV processes are accidentally suppressed by the GIM mechanism in the SM even after tiny neutrino masses are introduced. On the other hand, the suppression is not necessar- ily automatic in physics beyond the SM. Studies of cLFVs probe BSMs, hidden flavor symmetries, and underlying flavor bounds on cLFVs give constraints on physics even around O(10(5-6)) GeV. In practical BSMs, cLFVs are suppressed by loop-factors or or accidental cancellation. Thus, com-6 Flavor Physics and CP Violation Conference, Taipei, 2008 ing MEG experiment, and planed experiments, Mu2e, COMET and PRISM/PRIME, will cover in various BSMs. Since the cLFVs are pieces of puzzles in the BSMs, it is important to stress that taking various correlations are useful to solve the work of JH was also supported in part by the Grant-in-Aid for Science Research, Japan Soci- ety for the Promotion of Science (No. 20244037 and No. M. Raidal et al., arXiv:0801.1826 [hep-ph]. [2] M. L. Brooks et al. [MEGA Phys. Rev. Lett. 83(1999) U. Bellgardt et al.[SINDRUM Phys. B 299(1988) 1. [4] C. Dohmen et al.[SINDRUM II Lett. B 317(1993) 631. [5] W.Bertl et J. C 47(2006) 337. [6] S. Banerjee, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 169(2007) 199 K. Abe et al. [Belle B. Aubert et al. [BABAR Phys. Rev. Lett. 95(2005) B. Aubert et al. [BABAR Phys. Rev. Lett. 96(2006) Homepage of MEG T. Mori, talk given in the 4th on Nuclear and Particle Physics at J-PARC (NP08), Mito, Ibaraki, Japan, March, 2008 R. Bernstein, talk given in the 4th on Nuclear and Particle Physics at J-PARC (NP08), Mito, Ibaraki, Japan, March, 2008 A. Sato, talk given in the 4th on Nuclear and Particle Physics at J-PARC (NP08), Mito, Ibaraki, Japan, March, 2008 A. G. Akeroyd et al.[SuperKEKB Physics Work- ing Group], M. A. Giorgi et al. [SuperB group], INFN Roadmap Report, March 2006.[16] A. de Gouvea, S. Lola and K. Tobe, Phys. Rev. D63(2001) 035004 As a review, H. P. Nilles, Phys. Rept. M. Dine, A. E. Nelson and Y. Shirman, Phys. Rev. D51, 1362 (1995); M. Dine, A. E. Nelson, Y. Nir and Y. Shirman, Phys. Rev. D 53, D. E. Kaplan, G. D. Kribs and M. Schmaltz, Phys. Rev. D 62(2000) 035010; Z. Chacko, M. A. Luty, A. E. Nelson and E. Ponton, JHEP 0001(2000) 003; M. Schmaltz and W. Skiba, Phys. Rev. D 62(2000) 095005. [20] Nucl.Phys.B 557 (1999) 79; G. F. Giudice, M. A. Luty, H. Mu- rayama and R. Rattazzi, JHEP 9812(1998) 027. [21] Y. Nir and N. Seiberg, Phys. Lett. B M. Dine, A. Kagan and S. Samuel, Phys. Lett. B 243,(1990)250; S. Lett. B 357 (1995) 573; A. Pomarol and D. Tommasini, Nucl. Phys. B 466 (1996) 3; A.G. Cohen, D.B. KaplanandA.E. Nelson, Phys.Lett. B 388 (1996) 588 ; J. Hisano, K. Kurosawa and Y. Nomura, Phys. Lett. B 445 (1999) 316; Nucl. Phys. B 584 (2000) 3. [23] L. J. Hall, V. A. Kostelecky and S. Raby, Nucl. Phys. B 267, 415 (1986). [24] R. Barbieri and L. J. Hall, Phys. Lett. B 338 (1994) 212; R. Barbieri, L. J. Hall and A. Stru- mia, Nucl. Phys. B 445(1995) 219; J. Hisano, T. Moroi, K. Tobe and M. Yamaguchi, Phys. Lett. B 391(1997) 341 [Erratum-ibid. B 397 (1997) 357]. [25] F. Borzumati and A. Masiero, Phys. Rev. Lett. 57(1986) 961; J. Hisano, T. Moroi, K. Tobe, M. Yamaguchi and T. Yanagida, Phys. Lett. B 357(1995)579; J.Hisano, T. Moroi, K.Tobe and M. Yamaguchi, Phys. Rev. D 53(1996) 2442. [26] 59(1999) 116005 J. Hisano, D. Nomura and T. Yanagida, Phys. Lett. B437(1998) 351 K. S. Babu and C. Kolda, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89 (2002) 241802. [29] P. Paradisi, JHEP 0608(2006) M. Sher, Phys. Rev. D 66(2002) A. Brignole and A. Rossi, Nucl. Phys. B 701(2004) A. Brignole and A. Rossi, Phys. Lett. B 566(2003) P. Paradisi, JHEP 0602 (2006) 050 J. L. Feng, C. G. Lester, Y. Nir and Y. [hep-ph]. [32] N. Arkani-Hamed, A. G. Cohen and H. Georgi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86(2001) 4757Flavor Physics and CP Violation Conference, Taipei, 2008 Phys. Lett. B 513 (2001) 232 H. C. Cheng and I. Low, JHEP 0309(2003) JHEP 0408(2004) M. Blanke, A. J. Buras, B. Duling, A. Poschen- rieder and C. Tarantino, JHEP 0705(2007) L. Randall and R. Sundrum, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83 (1999) 3370 T. Gherghetta and A. Pomarol, Nucl. Phys. B 586(2000) 141 K. Agashe, A. E. Blechman and F. Petriello, Phys. Rev. D 74(2006) J. A. Casas and A. Ibarra, Nucl. Phys. B 618 (2001) 171 J. R. Ellis, J. Hisano, M. Raidal and Y. Shimizu, Phys. Rev. D66(2002) 115013 A. Rossi, Phys. Rev. D 66(2002) J. Schechter and J. W. F. Valle, Phys. Rev. D 22 (1980) 2227. [41] M. Kakizaki, Y. Ogura and F. Shima, Phys. Lett. B566(2003) 210 R. Kitano, M. Koike and Y. Okada, Phys. Rev. D66(2002) 096002 [Erratum-ibid. D 76(2007) 059902] V. Cirigliano, B. Grinstein, G. Isidori and M. B. Wise, Nucl. Phys. B 728(2005) J. Hisano and Y. Shimizu, Phys. Lett. B 565 (2003) 183 M. Ciu- chini, A. Masiero, L. Silvestrini, S. K. Vem- pati and O. Vives, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92(2004) 071801 M. Ciuchini, A. Masiero, P. Paradisi, L. Silvestrini, S. K. Vem- pati and O. Vives, Nucl. Phys. B 783(2007) T. Moroi, JHEP 0003 (2000) M. Bona et al. [UTfit [hep-ph]. [47] J. Hisano and Y. Shimizu, arXiv:0805.3327 [hep- ph]. [48] S. Dimopoulos and L. J. Hall, Phys. Lett. B 344 (1995) 185 R. Barbieri, A. Romanino and A. Strumia, Phys. Lett. B A. Romanino and A. Strumia, Nucl. Phys. B 490(1997) J. Hisano, M. Nagai and P. Paradisi, Phys. Lett. B642(2006) 510 [hep-ph]. [50] J. Hisano and Y. Shimizu, Phys. Lett. B 581 (2004) 224 Phys. Rev. D70(2004) 093001 Hisano, M. Kakizaki, M. Nagai and Y. Shimizu, Phys. Lett. B 604(2004) S. Narison, arXiv:0806.2618 [hep-ph].
|
0807.0149
|
Junji Hisano
|
Junji Hisano
|
Charged Lepton-Flavor Violation in Beyond-Standard Models
|
Flavor Physics & CP Violation Conference, Taipei, 2008
| null | null | null |
hep-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
I discuss charged lepton-flavor violation in physics beyond the standard
model and review topics related to it.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 1 Jul 2008 14:55:40 GMT"
}
] | 2009-09-29T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Hisano",
"Junji",
""
]
] |
2 In compliance with problem specification it is necessary to decide this equation at mx(0) = X(0) = N - quantity of mistakes in program in initial time. At constant rates l = const a n d m = const equation (1) type will take: ( )t t xeN e tmx- x-x+-x=m m ml1 )( of mistakes on stages of life cycle W e wi l l c on si de r si m pl i s ti c ex am pl e of s of tw a re w ork . In te n si ty of s tre am s of d e s tru c ti on m and duplications l mistakes on different stages of life cycle of software they are shown in the picture: intensity Figure 1 - Intensity of streams of destruction and error-spread effect On first stage ( 0PS tPS t1) - stage of designing. This is process of pure error-spread of this stage can give stream of destruction of mistakes in end of this stage, but I consider that its contribution not essential). On second stage (stage of coding t1PS tPS t2) error flow is stabilized and depend mainly from those error sources, that were pawned on previous stage. At this point process of debugging also occurs, so each mistake can be corrected. On third stage (operation phase and testing t > t 2) pure process of destruction of mistakes exists, moreover to rectify errors then all becomes developers of the development more of forgetting. In addition we consider that new mistakes are not given rise. We will mx(t)numbers of program errors, if on moment of beginning of software designing t=0 mistakes were not in him ( mx(t) = D x(t) =0 ). Solution of equation (1, 2) for each stage give graph to dependence mx(t), shown in the picture: mx(t) = D x(t) t1 I t2 II 2 - Quantity of mistakes in software during the life-cycle F r o m g r a p h o n e c a n s e e t h a t i t i s u s e l e s s t o i n c r e a s e t i m e o f d e v e l o p m e n t o f ( c o d i n g ) t2 indefinitely, as quantity of mistakes will not anyway decrease. And only on third stage it is possible to reach essential decrease of quantity of mistakes, when new mistakes are not practically brought in program, and old are quickly of model of reliability of client programs in software of client-server type F a r w i t h h e l p m e t h o d o f d y n a m i c of a v e r a g e ( s e e f o r e x a m p l e [ 1 ] ) w e w i l l b u i l d M a r k o v model of behaviors of program of consisting of many (approximately same) modules or (what is now used most often) we will build model of program system of type client-server. Characteristic feature of such a system is start server of parallel same streams, each of which services requests of one program- client or work of server with many same client programs. In that case streams or program- clients are completely identical and each of them can fail independently from other. Feature of this system in difference from systems of considered in queueing theories (for example, service repair crew of car, or same hardware complexes) it is concluded in that, that at failure (finding mistakes) in one module (stream or client) and removal this mistake, this mistake is automatically avoided also in all another units (streams), as these streams are duplicated with way of start on performance of the same program4 code. We will consider this feature at using of method of dynamic of average. In addition on change of module with mistake on corrected module we neglect with time. So, let complex is (type client -- server) program system S, consisting from big number of homogeneous modules (streams or clients) N, each of whi ch can wi th at ran dom go f rom con di ti on able. Let (for simplicity) all event flows (in case program - this is streams of external datum or requests from client programs to server), translating system S and each of its module) from condition able is Poisson (can be even with intensities, depending from time). Process, running in system, will then be Markov. We will spread model on case most often met on practice, when each module-client is in one of two conditions: worker or non-working. Let system S consists from large number N homogeneous elements (modules or streams of one unit), each of which can be in one of two conditions: x1- is efficient (work); x2 - not worker (mistake is found and it is corrected). On each module stream of mistakes with intensity acts l, that depends from quantity of corrected more early in module of mistakes. Each defective component is corrected in average at the ratem in unit of time. In initial moment ( t = 0 ) all the elements (modules) they are serviceable. All event flows is Poisson (can be with variable intensity). We will write equations of dynamic of average for average numbers of conditions. Graph of conditions of one unit has type, presented in the picture: Figure 3 - Graph of condition of module Here l` -- intensity of stream of mistakes subject to previous l` from number of previous corrections of this module. We will state suggestion that l`
f a l l w i t h q u a n t i t y o f c o r r e c t e d m i s t a k e s t o s o m e c o n s t a n t v a l u e o f t o l e r a n c e t o c o r r e c t i o n s ( f o r example, when quantity of corrected mistakes becomes equal to quantity of brought mistakes, or quantity of mistakes in module becomes so small, that they begin to work with constant rate) also to5 strive on exponential law to some minimum the more quickly, mistakes are the more quickly corrected m. On base of graph (see Figure 3 - Graph of condition of module) differential conditions of dynamic means will enter the name in the )(')( 1 222 11 tm tmNdtt dmtmN tmdttdm l mml where m1(t),m2(t) - Average number of conditions x1 and x2. Of these two equations it is possible to choose one - for example, second, and to reject first. In second equation we will substitute expression for m1(t) from condition: m1(t) +m2(t) = N . In addition quantity of modernizations m depend from intensity of correction of module m and quantities of programmers (or groups of programmers) P working above correction of modules. We will expect that: m(m) =mxPxtand 1 0' l llm+x=xx-tPe . It is necessary to decide this equation at starting condition m2(t=0) = 0 of numerical methods. This equation was decided with help package of mathematical programs MatLab 6.5 methods Runge - Kutt (function ode45 ) and following result is got for problem specifications: m = 0,2 times in day one mistake is corrected by one programmer; l0 =10 times are found in day in program mistakes in initial time; P = 3 - quantity of programmers (or groups of programmers), correcting mistakes with intensity m each; N = 10 - quantity of modules (streams or clients) in programs of client-server type; l1 = 0,1 . We get decision, shown in the picture:6 Figure 4 - Decision for exponential to figure: continuous line - m2(t) - number of idle modules; dash line (point of d a s h ) - m1(t) - number of working modules; intermittent lines of (light dot) - representation of behaviour of crooked at absence of dependence m m x=N' -- features inherent of software. One can see that in that case time behaviors occur much more slowly. From figure one can see that quantity of working modules will exceed quantity of idle modules on3 days. Since this moment it is possible to consider that program work steadily. If originally l0 =
100, then at the same other starting conditions program began steadily to work only on 7 days. In technology, where m are not proportional N, at given starting conditions all technology would be faulty already on first day and would be never brought operational. So, without looking on that, that software in beginning of operation or (testing) contains in abundance (much more than in technology) mistakes with big intensity of their display, mistakes are quickly corrected in programs and very quickly software become firm. This occurs because of double-quick correction of mistakes as contrasted to of general reliability model of software of client-server type how Markov model of mixed mode 1.4.1. Formulation and finding of basic formulas We will consider equations of mixed mode now. Heretofore we described processes, running in software, or with help equations for state probabilities, or with help equations of dynamic of average, where unknown functions are averages of number of conditions. Equations of first type are used then, when software is comparative simple and its conditions are rather small. Equations of second type are specially reserved for description of processes, occurring in software, consisting of multiple modules. For such a systems we managed to find not state probability, and average number of conditions. On practice situations of mixed mode are more often met. Also for such software we will write equations. This model is applicable for software, that consists of element- modules of different type: small (unique) (for example, in architecture client-server this - server) and multiple (in this - clients), moreover conditions of those and others are relative. I n t h i s c a s e f o r m o d u l e s o f f i r s t t y p e i t i s p o s s i b l e t o m a k e d i f f e r e n t i a l e q u a t i o n s , w h e r e unknown functions are state probabilities. For modules of second type - average number of conditions. We will call such equations call equations of mixed mode. We will consider software S, consisting from plenty N identical client programs and one server, that coordinates work of all client programs. How server, and separate clients can refuse (to hang). Intensity of stream of refusals of server depends from number x of working program- clients (that is actually depend from intensity of input datum and their range): ' )( ljl==xs. Intensity of stream of faults of each module- client at working server is equal l`. A v e ra g e ti m e of rem ov al of m i s ta k e i n s e rv e r, ta ki n g i n to a c c ou n t d i f fi c ul ty of s e rv e r, m ore that average time of removal of mistake in client: 0/mS ts ispr=, where m0- - s p e e d o f r e m o v a l o f mistakes in client (speed of error correction programmer), S - factor of difficulty of server.8 We will describe process, running in program provision with help equations of mixed mode, w h e r e t h e y w i l l b e u n k n o w n f u n c t i o n s : p r o b a b i l i t i e s o f c o n d i t i o n s o f s e r v e r ; a v e r a g e n u m b e r o f conditions of clients. We will describe our system at help column, shown in the picture: Figure 5 - Graph of combination system This graph breaks up on two subgraph. First (top) - this is subgraph of conditions of server, that can be in one of two conditions: C(t) - work; S'(t) - do not work (mistake is found and it is corrected). What touches program- client, then for her we take into account opportunity to be in one of three conditions: P1S(t)- client works at working server; P2S(t) - client does not work at working server; P2S'(t) - client does not work at not working server. Condition of server is characterized in instant tone of events C(t) and C'(t) . We will of these events through p(t) and p'(t) = 1 - p(t) , and number of conditions accordingly: X1S(t),X2S(t) iX2S'(t). It is obvious, for any instant t: NtmtmtmC C C=++ )( )( )(' 2 2 1(3) where is N - number of clients, working with server. We will determine intensity of streams of events for graph (see Figure 5). Before all, under the statement of problem:: ' )( )( 1 1 'ljjll =>>==C C C CCm X ,S tC isprCC0 '1 ml == .9 Far, program-client goes from condition P1S(t) in condition P2S'(t) not themselves on themselves, and only together and it is simultaneous with server (when that hangs). So: ' )( )( 1 1 ' '2,1ljjll =>>==C C CC CCm X . It is similar:SCC CC0 ' 1,'2m ll == . For other transitions it is not difficult to establish corresponding to intensity, if to consider that fact that vote (low) subgraph is distinguished from considered more early (see Figure 3) only presence of still one condition P2S', when client program stands on time of correcti on of mistake in program- server. With account this we have: 1 0 2,1' l ; N CCx=0 1,2ml ; C C C C 1,'2 2,'2ll=. We will write for graph (see Figure 5) differential equations of mixed mode, our system (argument t are lowered for brevity of CCCCC CCCC CC m mdtdmm m mdtdmm m mdtdmp pdtdpp pdtdp 1 '2,1' 2 2',2 1',2' 2' 2 2',2 1 2,1 2 1,222 1,2' 2 1',2 1 2,1 '2,11' '' ' ) (''' l lll l ll l llllll (4) We will note that, having placed in (4) all first members 0, i t i s p o s s i b l e t o p u z z l e o u t f o r stationary condition, and he exists, as system ergodic. W e will n oti ce th at f rom thi s set of equati ons i t i s possi bl e to ex cl ude tw o equa ti ons: on e of first two, using equation p + p' = 1 , and one - from following three, using parity of normalization (3). These equations are decided on the assumption, that at the beginning server and all program- clients work: t = 0; p = 1; p' = 0; N mC=1; 0' 2 2==C Cm m . 1.4.2. Example of model use We will allow set of equations (4) for following conditions: S = 3 - factor of difficulty of server; N = 10 - number of program- clients; l0 = 10 mistakes / day; P = 3 - quantity of = 0 , 5 mistakes / day. Decision of foregoing model was leaded with help package ode15s ) method of Runge - Kut. Following results are got: Figure 6 - p and p' From figure one can see that server will begin steadily to work on 8 days. Figure 7 - m 1C, m2C, m2C' From figure one can see that clients will begin steadily to work on 4days. I f t o i n c r e a s e q u a n t i t y o f p r o g r a m - c l i e n t s w i t h 10 to100, then results will not practically c h a n g e o r o u t p u t w i l l o c c u r o n o p e r a t i o n a l s t a b i l i t y e v e n m o r e q u i c k l y . I f t o r e d u c e n u m b e r o f programmers from 3- kh people to one, then server will begin steadily to work on 14 days, and clients - on10 days.11 2.STUDY OF WAYS OF INCREASE OF RELIABILITY OF SOFTWARE ON BASE OF OFFERED SOFTWARE problem of presence of reliability of software at help many reliability models is need to know initial quantity of mistakes in program provision. Regrettably, offered reliability model does not allow to find this value. She does not in general use her. That not less, results got at use of this model well are in agreement with with practice. So it is possible to try to use these results for finding N0 - i n i t i a l q u a n t i t y o f p r o g r a m e r r o r s f r o m m e t h o d o f b a c k c a l c u l a t i o n . T h i s w i l l l e t u s e a l s o o t h e r rel i ab i l i ty m od el s . S u ch si m ul a ti on p rog ra m wi l l al s o l e t f i n d s u ch f e a tu re s of s of tw a re s af e ty , h ow time to following refusal, its probability and time of achievement of necessary reliability at given starting conditions. Also such simulation program will let research to way of increase of software safety, varying one of available in order of developers resource, such as quantity of of purification, speed of entering of mistakes, time of testing and intensity of candidate solution is offered to this problems: with allowance for more early got results about character of behaviour of reliability of program provision from time mixed model of type client-server, when server is faulty, then clients stand: of mistake in all clients at correction of mistake in some of one client) to write program of modeling of behaviour of software safety (modelling process of finding of mistakes in and purifications) and to select N0 with its help with hence, so that final features of software safety coincided with results, got at help more early offered reliability of operation of simulation program Program provision of type is client-server. Server services requests from N program- clients (far simply clients). In program provision is even on area of definition of input datum (ADI) (A, B) they are arranged Er mistakes. Server in a complicated more way than program- clients from point of sight of development of software in S time. S - factor of diffi cul ty of serv er wi th respect to cl i en ts. Each k-client ( k = 1, 2, ..., N ) generates Poisson stream of data to server with intensity lobr. Data from12 the client are distributed on ADI on normal law with features mk and sk, where mk are clients evenly on all area of input datum, 3sk - it is distributed evenly on small of sites of cut mk on axes of data area. This is necessary for imitation of unevenness of use ADI at small quantity of clients. O n r e q u e s t o f c l i e n t s e r v e r a n s w e r s w i t h d a t a , t h a t a r e d i s t r i b u t e d e v e n l y o n a l l d e f i n i t i o n domain (A, B). In the picture (see Figure 8) distribution of requests of one is represented client on area of all possible requests to server, and also even distribution of mistakes on ADI is shown. At hit of request of client or answer of server in area ADI, containing mistake, it is considered that mistake is found and appropriate module is decommission for its 1 Error 2 Error 3 Error m Error Er ... Figure 8 - Distribution of requests k-client on data areas For modeling of streams of destruction and duplication of mistakes in program provision is used Monte-Carlo methods. Input datum for drawing they are: P - quantity of programmers, servicing system; K - quantity of program- clients; a; - width of one request of client how share from ADI (from 0 to1, where 1 - this is all ADI); Dt - step of iteration (day); s - factor of difficulty of server as contrasted to program- client; lobr - i n tensi ty of stream of addresses of on e cli en t to serv er (1 / day ); lispr - intensity of stream of error correction one programmer (1 / day); lvnes - i n te n si ty of en te ri n g of m i s ta k e a t c or re c ti on o n e p rog ra m m e r (1 / d ay ) or pvnes - probability to bring mistake at correction by one programmer; M - quantity of iterations (quantity of attempts of addresses of program- clients to server one drawing); R -13 quantity of drawings for averaging; Er - initial quantity of mistakes. Program text and are placed on site of . 2.3.Practical simulation results 2.3.1. Influence of quantity of clients on software safety We will study influence of quantity of program- clients on behaviour of software. Drawing was conducted at following initial conditions of ( 10 clients): Number of program-clients: 10, Number of programmers: 3, Share from general data area (ADI) in one request of client: 1E-5, Initial number of mistakes: 250, Factor of difficulty of server: 2, Intensity of stream of addresses of client to server: 500 (1 / day), Intensity of stream of error correction: 1 (1 / day), Intensity of entering of mistake at correction: 0,1 (1 / day), Step Of Iteration: 0,002, Number of iterations: 50000, General time of drawing: 100 (day); Number of results are Got (average values for all 50 draws, see Figure 9 -- Drawing No. 1): Figure 9 -- Drawing No. 1 F rom fi g u re on e c an s e e th a t s of tw a re wi l l b e gi n s te a d i l y to w o rk (i . e . q u a n ti ty of w ork i n g clients) will moved into line with quantity of idle clients on 15 days, what well is in agreement model, see Figure 6 and 7. We will now increase quantity of clients with 10 to100: Following results are Got (average values for all 50 draws, see Figure 10 - Drawing No. 2):14 Figure 10 - Drawing No. 2 On e can see th at on 170 day s al l mi stakes are alm ost corrected . Thi s occurs b ecause of th at, that clients more and their requests cover big data area and, hence, great quantity of mistakes is found and great quantity of mistakes is corrected. At ten clients in program provision will still remain on 170 days about 50 mistakes. 2.3.2. Influence of quantity of programmers on software safety W e w i l l n o w s h o w t h a t a t l i g h t l o a d o n s e rv e r ( s m a l l q u a n ti ty c l i e n t p r o g r a m s ) i n c r e a s e of quantity of programmers, correcting a mistake, gives small effect. Quantity of uncorrected errors to end of testing remains the previous. Only time of waiting of program of correction in turns decreases. For example, if to increase quantity of programmers with 3 to 12, that we will get: Initial conditions of drawing: Number of program-clients: 10, Number of programmers: 12, Share from general data area (ADI) in one request of client: 1E-5, Initial number of mistakes: 250, Factor of difficulty of server: 2, Intensity of stream of addresses of client to server: 500 (1 / day), Intensity of stream of error correction: 1 (1 / day), Intensity of entering of mistake at correction: 0,1 (1 / day), Step Of Iteration: 0,002, Number of iterations: 50000, General time of drawing: 100 (day); Number of of 11 - Drawing No. 3 One can see that program will begin it is firm to work how and earlier only on 10-15 days, then not big effect lets eat increase of quantity of programmers and sooner than all, part of programmers will stand. Much more effectively to increase load in this situation at testing. How for example, this was already shown more highly, increasing quantity of clients. Increase of quantity of programmers can render even adverse effect on software safety, if at removal of mistakes in program they intensively bring provision in him new mistakes. We will show this on example. Let at 12 programmers each of them brings mistake with intensity 0,6 instead of 0,1 mistakes in day. Results of drawing: Figure 12 - Drawing No. 4 From figure one can see that for 100 days of system operation quantity of mistakes did not practically Influence of intensity of addresses of clients to intensity of address of each client to server does not give such effect, because each client usually works in the narrow part of data area and dislodges mistakes from this part, and significant remains data area not checked, and mean in errors. Example of drawing at increases of intensity of addresses on order with 500 to 2500 in day. Initial conditions of draw: Number of program-clients: 10, Number of programmers: 3, Share from general data area (ADI) in one request of client: 1E-5, Initial number of mistakes: 250, Factor of difficulty of server: 2, Intensity of stream of addresses of client to server: 2500 (1 / day), Intensity of stream of error correction: 1 (1 / day), Intensity of entering of mistake at correction: 0,1 (1 / day), Step Of Iteration: 0,0004, Number of iterations: 250000, General time of drawing: 100 (day); Number of drawings: 10 Results of drawing: Figure 13 - Drawing No. 5 2.3.4. Definition of initial quantity of mistakes in program provision Given model allows with a combination with offered Markov model of software safety to value quantity of program errors with in the following way - to get accounting result, and then to select initial quantity of mistakes in program provision such, so that results of draw coincided with result decision of this it is necessary to obtain problem with help simulation program that, so that initial intensity of error flow l0f rom m odel of rel i abili ty of program provi si on of ty pe cli en t-serv er (see paragraph 1.4) coincided with initial intensity of stream of mistakes in simulation program. It is directly impossible to do this, as in program there is modeling of such parameter not. For that in simulation program it is necessary to place a = 0.5 , then there is each address of client to server and17 answer of server to client should with probability 1 to generate mistake. It is then necessary to obtain that, so that quantity of addresses for day of clients to server (i. e. K* lobr) was equal l0. It is necessary to place other initial parameters of simulation program with equal to similar parameters of will find initial quantity of mistakes as an example considered in paragraph 1.4.2. In order that initial intensity of stream of mistakes in simulation program was equal l0=10 from example of paragraph 1.4.2, we will place a = 0.5, and lobr at 3-th programmers we will place equal 3,3. Initial conditions of drawing: Number of program-clients: 10, Number of programmers: 3, Share from general data area (ADI) in one request of client: 0,5, Initial number of mistakes: 9, Factor of difficulty of server: 3, Intensity of stream of addresses of client to server: 3,3 (1 / day), Intensity of stream of error correction: 0,5 (1 / day), Intensity of entering of mistake at correction: 0 (1 / day), Step Of Iteration: 0,0001, Number of iterations: 100000, General time of drawing: 10 (day); Number of drawings: 50 Results of drawing: Figure 14 - Drawing No. 6 How one can see from figure at initial quantity of program errors equal 9 got result similar got i n m od el , th en cl i en ts wi l l b e gi n to e a t s te a d i l y to w ork on 4 d ay s . N um b e r 9 of Er were got with method of selection of different initial values of quantity mistakes in program on initial time. Hence, combining model and drawing it is possible to calculate initial quantity of mistakes in program provision and other its e w m a t h e m a t i c a l m o d e l o f r e l i a b i l i t y o f s o f t w a r e o n b a s e o f M a r k o v q u e u e s y s t e m s , allowing to conduct calculation of features of software safety is built. Offered model more simpler than used more early than model. Master advantage of model is absence of use in her initial quantity of mistakes in program provision. Consideration of software how black box give consistent on practice without detailed description of all software properties are considered duplication and destruction of mistakes in on different stages of life cycle. Master dependences of distribution of mistakes on stages of life cycle for many typical case are got. 3.For increase of software safety it is necessary to control two master making, influencing on software safety: before all - to raise intensity of testing or uses; and to raise quantity of programmers and / or efficiency of their work. In addition it is necessary to determine in condition limitation of resource and often taking into account uniqueness of development (software is often developed in single copy and for single unique object) how required software safety long should test software or conduct experienced operation of software in order to achieve. Estimation is given to time of achievement of required level of reliability of software at given quantity of programmers and their efficiency works. Probabilistic approach let to reliability give an answer on question of one of the most complex problems at testing: When it is necessary to finish testing in order to satisfy requirements on reliability to software? 4.For presence of optimum parity of features developments and software of modeling of behaviour of reliability of software during is developed - program of modeling on base of Monte-Carlo method and based on offered to model of software safety are developed. On its base recommendations are developed for increase of software safety. allows, setting different starting conditions, to observe behaviour of reliability of software during. This allows to value expenses and resource for building and support of highly It is shown that dominant factor, allowing greatly to raise software safety, intensity of two approaches - Markov model of reliability of software and forecasting at help Monte-Carlo method - allow more exactly and more comprehensively to value features of software safety. Personallies, this allows to find initial quantity of mistakes in program E.S . Issledovanie operatsii . - M.: Sov. radio , 1972. - 552 s. 2.Venttsel' E.S ., Ovcharov L.A . Teoriia sluchainykh protsessov i ee inzhenernye primeneniia . - M.: Vysshaia shkola , 2000. - 284 s. 3.Ovcharov L.A . Prikladnye zadachi teorii massovogo obsluzhivaniia . - M.: Mashinostroenie , 1969. - 324 A.O . Model' i modelirovanie nadezhnosti programmnogo obespecheniia kak sistemy . //Tekhnika i tekhnologiia , No. 2(8), 2005 - M., s. 76 - 85 5.Khandzhian A.O . Analiz sovremennogo sostoianiia razrabotki nadezhnogo programmnogo obespecheniia .
//Estestvennye i tekhnicheskie nauki , No. 2, 2005 - M., s. 220 - 227 6.Khandzhian A.O . Model' nadezhnosti programmnogo obespecheniia kak sistemy massovogo obsluzhivaniia .
//Ob'edinennyi nauchnyi zhurnal , No. 7(135) mart , 2005 - M., s. 63 - 71. 7.Program text and performed program are placed on site of
|
0807.0161
|
Arkadiy Khandjian
|
Arkadiy Khandjian
|
Increase of Software Safety
| null | null | null | null |
cs.SE
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
New model of software safety is offered. Distribution of mistakes in program
on stages of life cycle is researched. Study of ways of increase of reliability
of software at help simulation program is leaded.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 1 Jul 2008 13:53:44 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-02T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Khandjian",
"Arkadiy",
""
]
] |
2 Daniele De Martino, Matteo Marsili: On the role of volatili ty in the evolution of social of Silicon Valley during the computer industy crisis of the 1980s[9], or the recent development of sustained against large odds, thanks to a dense web of collaboration and coexistence. Under apparently conditions, social networks can be found both in a dense or sparse state. A good illustration is alone can explain wheter there is a degradation in a ghetto with rampant social paper focuses on analyzing the effect of node volatility in these simple models. Indeed, the effect of volatility is limited to link removal in Ref. [13], but the turnover of agents (i.e. node removal and arrival) may be an important factor in many real systems. Our focus here will be mostly on the statistical phenomenon, than on its interpretation in socio-economic terms. Indeed we find that the introduction of node volatility brings in a qualitative change, which can be described as a continu- ous phase transition with unusual critical properties. In order to show this, we concentrate on the simplest model for which a full analytic treatment is possible. In the con- cluding section, we argue that this qualitative change is expected in a wider class of model, and it can have much stronger effects. 2 model Our model is a variant of one in the general class of[13]. It reproduces in a stylized manner the mechanisms of co- evolution in social networks aforementioned, and shows some common elements of the observed resilience, equilibrium coexistence); in particular, it also shows how the alternative assump- tions of link or node based volatility have profound effects on the dynamics of network formation. The model sitting on the nodes of a network, each of which is characterized by a variable siwhich represents the social norm (convention or technological by agent i. There are qpossible social norms, i.e. si {1,...,q}. In terms of statistical physics, the model can be thought of as a qstate Potts model defined on a graph of Nnodes, that evolves in a coupled fashion to the dynamics of the system. The rules of the dynamics are node attempts to establish a new link with a ran- domly chosen node at rate e/2. The link is established only if the two nodes have the same color -links are destroyed at rate 1 -all the links of a node are destroyed with rate a -the color of a node is updated with rate nto the color of any of its neighbors, unless the node is isolated. In the latter case the nodes takes a random color. So, the parameter ainterpolates between two kinds of volatility. For a= 0 volatility only affects links and fora1 it mostly affects nodes. With respect to theparameters introduced in Ref. [13], we observe that the link decay rate has been set to l= 1 and that, for no- tation convenience, we scaled by a factor 2 the link cre- ation rate e. As observed in Ref. [13], the color update rule is effective only for isolated nodes, in the long run, and in that case the color is drawn at random. Since only links between same type agents are created, after a tran- sient all nodes are either isolated, or connected to nodes of the same color. Therefore the particular way in which the neighbor is chosen is immaterial. For example, both a majority rule (most frequent color) or a voter-type rule (random neighbor) would give the same dynamics. The model can be generalized to a probabilistic update rule forthe temperature do not change considerably as long as Tis small enough, so we shall confine ourselves to the T= 0 case. Fig. 1.Our model: links are formed with rate ebetween nodes having the same color, links are destroyed with rate 1, all th e links of a node desappear with rate aand colors of isolated nodes are randomly updated with rate a= transition in efrom a symmetric to an asym- metric state. The symmetric state is characterized by a sparse network, with average degree with a sym- metric distribution of colors. In the asymmetric state, in- stead, a dense network with arises, along with a dominant color, which is adopted by agents more fre- quently than the others. In this sense, the model shows how order and disorder are intimately related with the dynamics of the social network in a volatile environment. In what follows, we solve the model in the stationary state for N- , for all the values of a. We find that the a= 0 behavior is generic for all a <1, but the transi- tion is softened as aincreases. For a >1 instead we show that the system is always in the symmetric phase. Hence, in terms of statistical mechanics, a= 1 is a second or- der critical point separating a phase with symmetry from a symmetric phase.Daniele De Martino, Matteo Marsili: On the role of volatilit y in the evolution of social networks 3 3 Theory If we call nk,sthe density of nodes with klinks and color s= 1,...,qwe have the following rate (2) where, for future convenience, we have introduced the dy- namical (4) which implies that, in the stationary state, each compo- nent has the same fraction n0,s=n0/qof disconnected (k= 0) nodes. This is equivalent to a detailed for the density of the different components. It is straightforward to derive an equations for functions ps(s) of the degree the component s. In the sta- tionary state this stationary solution is found by direct is easy to see that this interpolates between a Pois- son distribution, ps(s) which coincides with the result of Ref. [13], and an exponen- tial distribution ps(s) =l/[l+xs(s-1)] fora- . Notice also that the average degree in component =xs/(1 +a). This is precisely what one expects from balance of link creation and destruction of links in component s. Observing that ps(0) find an equa- tion forxsin the stationary state, which that the r.h.s. of Eq. (7) is independent of s. The variables xsare determined by Eq. (7) and the normal- ization condition, which takes the (8)The properties of the solutions of Eqs. (7,8) depend on the behavior of the function Ga(x), which are discussed in the appendix, and can be classified in symmetric and asymmetric solutions. 3.1a >1: The symmetric solution Fora >1 the function Ga(x) is a monotone (see appendix), Hence Eq. (7) has a single solu- tion and Eq. (8) implies that xs=e/qfor all components s. Hence Eq. (7) yields the total fraction of a function of the parameters q,aande. We can ana- lyze the stability of the symmetric solution recalling Then Eq. (4) becomes a dynamical equa- tion (9) Linear stability of the symmetric solution is addressed 0. Then to as long as Ga(x) is an increasing function of x, the symmetric solution is stable. This is always the case for a >1, as we shall see, it fails to hold for a <1. 3.2a <1: The asymmetric solution Fora <1 the symmetric solution still exists. However the function Ga(x) now has a maximum for some x0(a) (see the appendix) and Ga(x)-afrom above as x- . Therefore the symmetric solution becomes unstable when e > e+where e+qx0(a) (11) because beyond that point G' a(e/q)<0. The occurrence of a maximum in Gaalso implies that Eq. (7) admits solutions with xs=x-< x0(a) for some s's andxs=x+> x0(a) for the other components. Since xsis related to the density of a component s, we shall call a component dense if xs=x+and diluted if xs=x-. As in Ref. [13], all solutions with more than one dense component are unstable. Indeed, by the same argument used to analyze the stability of the symmetric solution, os= modes correspond to density fluctuations across dense components and are clearly absent in the we shall focus on in what follows. There are q of them, depending on which color is associated with the4 Daniele De Martino, Matteo Marsili: On the role of volatili ty in the evolution of social networks dense component. The variables x+-are determined by the system of equations Ga(x+) =Ga(x-) Fig.2. Actually,ofthe twoasym- 0 5 10 15 20 0 5 10 15 20 25 30x-, 2. Solutions x+-as a function of eforq= 10 and a=
0.4. The dashed line x=e/qseparating the two curves is the symmetric solution. metric solutions the one with x+decreasing with eis clearly unphysical as this would have a connected com- ponent with an average degree which decreases with the rate ewith which links are formed. As in ref. [13], it is easy to see that only solutions with x+
increasing in eare stable. Indeed, regarding of x+in Eq. (13) we find de dx+= perturbations of the form xs=x++ofor the dense component and xs=x--o/(q-1) for the others. Then by a derivation analogous to that leading to Eq. (10), we that G' a(x-)>0, this implies that on with e, the perturbation ogrows asymmetric solution ceases to exist for e < e-1. In the region e[e-,e+] both the symmetric and the asymmetric solutions co-exist. The coexistence region, in thea,eplane is reported in Fig. 4. The practical relevance of the results derived so far is best discussed introducing an order is the difference in the density of the dense and diluted components.This vanishesin the symmetric phase 1We note, in passing, that the condition de/dx += 0 pro- vides an equation which allows to determine e-.and is non-zero in the asymmetric one. In Fig. 3 where we report the behavior of the average degree of the 3 shows that as esweeps through the the system undergoes an hysteresis loop: the de- gree jumps from low to high values at e+aseis when edecreases from large values, the back to the symmetric phase when e-is crossed. In the case a= 0 [13], the symmetric phase is character- ized by sparse networks, with a vanishing giant compo- nent. This is no more true when 0 < a <1, specially close toe+2. Numerical simulations fully confirm this picture, even though for finite systems the symmetric (asymmet- ric) phase is meta-stable close to e+(e-) and therefore the transition occurs for lower (larger) values of e. 0 5 10 15e05101520 <k>a = 0 a = 0.2 Fig. 3.Mean degree < k >as a function of e/lfor a system withq= 10 colors, for a= 0 and 0 .2, simulations are for systems of 1000 nodes. 10 100 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2e aq=10 Fig. 4. Phase diagram for q= 10. The symmetric phase ex- tends below and to the right of the (full) line e-(a) whereas above the (dashed) line e+(a) only the asymmetric phase is stable. The coexistence region, where both phases are stabl e, is delimited by the two curves. 2Indeed the condition for the presence of a giant by a straightforward +a/2). At the critical point e+=qx0(a) which holds true for all a >0.Daniele De Martino, Matteo Marsili: On the role of volatilit y in the evolution of social networks 5 3.3 The critical region: a1 The behavior of the order parameter mon the critical lines which confine the coexistence region is shown in Fig. 5. This shows that the transition is continuous but with a peculiar critical behavior. In order to shed light on this, the appendix shows that, asymptotically for a1 e+(a) =qx0(a) >0 a constant. A detailed asymptotic analysis of the limit a-1 (see appendix) also shows that m~1/x0(a)~ |log(1-a)|-1. (17) In terms of the usual description of critical |1-a|b, this model is consistent with an exponent b= 0+. Indeed, the singular behavior of mis very close to that of a first order phase transition. 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1a00.20.40.60.8 m Fig. 5.Order parameter mon the boundaryof the e-(full line) and e+(dashed line) as a function of afor q= 10. 4 Conclusions The introduction of node volatility, in the simple model discussed here, makes the transition from a diluted network to an asymmetric i.e. when the number of links lost per unit time by node decay outnumber those lost from link decay ( a >1), the transition disappears altogether, and the stateprevails.Thephenomenologyisstrongly reminiscent of that of first order phase transitions (e.g. liquid-gas or though the criti- cal behavior is highly non-trivial. The virtue of the particular model studied is that it al- lows a detailed analytic approachwhich allows one to gain insight on all aspects of its behavior. This model belongs to a general class of models which embody a generic feed- back mechanism between the nodes and the network they are embedded in, which can be expressed in the followingway: while the network promotes similarity or nodes, proximity or similarity enhances link volatility, which acts removing links at a con- stant rate. Interestingly, the emergence of an ordered state plays a key role in this evolutionary struggle. We believe the general findings discussed here will ex- tend to the general class of models of Ref. [13]. In partic- ular, we expect the phase transition to be blurred by the effect of node volatility and to disappear when the latter exceed a particular Fig. 6 shows that this is the case even for the model of Ref. [12]. This is a model where link creation occurs either by long distance search at rate e(as in the model discussed here) or through local search (on at rate x. Again links decay at unit rate. We refer the interested reader to Ref. [12] for further details, for the present discussion let it suffice to say that the ef- fects of (link) volatility are contrasted by the creation of a dense network with small-world features (a somewhat similar model with node volatility has been considered in Ref. [11]). Fig. 6 shows that the effects of node volatility are very strong. Indeed, even a very small areduces con- siderably the size of the coexistence region and the value acat which the latter disappears is also relatively small. 0 5 10 15 e = 0.01 a = 0 0.01 0.1 0 5 10 15 = 0.1 a = 0 0.1 0.5 Fig. 6. Mean degree as a function of the rate xof formation of links with neighbours of neighbours, for N= 1000 ( l= 1). Right:e= 0.01, Left: e= 0.1.6 Daniele De Martino, Matteo Marsili: On the role of volatili ty in the evolution of social networks These results suggest that node volatility is indeed a relevant effect in the co-evolution of socio-economic net- works, as it may affect in dramatic ways the ability of the system to reach a dense and/or coordinated function Ga(x) can be written as Ga(x) >1 we also in the symmetric solution is a decreasing function of e/q. In addition Ga(x)xfor x1, i.e.n0-1. Fora= 1-owe can is the exponential integral function, and for o-0 we have x+-- have at the critical point such that G' a(x0) = 0 sooex0 x2 0= 1 andx0 definition so from Ga(x+) =Ga(x-) we have mx0-cwherecis given H. P. Young The Journal of Economic Perspectives ,10, 105-122, (Spring, 1996) 2. Topa, G., Rev. Ec. Studies 68, 261 (2001). 3. M.Granovetter, Am. J. Sociol. 91, 481 (1985)4. C. Nardini, B. Kozma, A. Barrat, Rev. Lett. 100, 158701 (2008); F. Vazquez, V.M. Eguiluz, M. San Miguel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 108702 (2008). 5. T. Gross and B. Blasius, J. R. Soc. Interface 5, 259 (2008). 6. J.Crane, Am. J. Sociol. 96, 1226 (1991) 7. S.Goyal, M.J.van der Leij, J. L. Moraga-Gonzales, J. Poli t. Econ.114, 403 (2006) 8. J.Hagedoorn, Research policy 31, 477 (2002) 9. A.Saxenian, Regional Advantage: culture and competition in Silicon Valley and route 128 (Harvard university 1994) 10. Y.Benkler, Yale Law Journal 112369 (2002) 11. J.Davidsen, H.Ebel and S.Bornholdt, Phy.Rev.Lett. 88, 12, 128701 (2002) 12. M.Marsili, F.Vega-Redondo and U.S.A. 101, 1439 (2004) 13. G.Ehrardt, M.Marsili and F.Vega-Redondo, Phy.Rev. E 74, 036106 (2006)
|
0807.0348
|
Daniele De Martino
|
Daniele De Martino and Matteo Marsili
|
On the role of volatility in the evolution of social networks
|
6 pages 6 figures. submitted to EPJ B
| null |
10.1140/epjb/e2008-00365-8
| null |
physics.soc-ph cond-mat.stat-mech
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study how the volatility, node- or link-based, affects the evolution of
social networks in simple models. The model describes the competition between
order -- promoted by the efforts of agents to coordinate -- and disorder
induced by volatility in the underlying social network. We find that when
volatility affects mostly the decay of links, the model exhibit a sharp
transition between an ordered phase with a dense network and a disordered phase
with a sparse network. When volatility is mostly node-based, instead, only the
symmetric (disordered) phase exists These two regimes are separated by a second
order phase transition of unusual type, characterized by an order parameter
critical exponent $\beta=0^+$. We argue that node volatility has the same
effect in a broader class of models, and provide numerical evidence in this
direction.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 2 Jul 2008 13:53:13 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"De Martino",
"Daniele",
""
],
[
"Marsili",
"Matteo",
""
]
] |
whereu0(x) is a divergence-free smooth vector field. We fix a time interval [0,T], and rewrite equations ( 1) with respect to the function
~u(t,x) ( 1) is equivalent to the 0,
~u(T,x) =u0(x),(2) where ~p(t,x) =p(T-t,x). In what follows, system ( 2) will be referred to as the backward Navier- Stokes equations. To this system we associate a certain system of stochastic differential equations on the group of volume of a flat torus. For simplicity, we work in two dimension s. However, the generalization of most of the results to the case of ndimensions is straightforward. The necessary constructions and non-stra ightforward related to the n-dimensional case are considered in the the existence of a solution of ( 2) with the final data in the Sobolev space Hafor sufficiently large a, we construct a solution of the associated system of FBSDEs. Conversely, if we assume that a solu tion of the system of FBSDEs exists, then the solution of the Navier-Stokes e quations can be obtained from the solution of the FBSDEs. In fact, the cons tructed FBSDEs onthe group of diffeomorphisms can be r egarded as an alternative object to the Navier-Stokes equations for stud ying the properties of the latter. The connection between forward-backward SDEs and quasi-linear PDEs in finite dimensions has been studied by many authors, for example in [ 9], [18], and [21]. Our construction uses the approach originating in the work of Arno ld [1] which states that the motion of a perfect fluid can be described in te rms of geodesics on the group of diffeomorphisms of a c ompact manifold. The necessary structures were d eveloped in later work by Ebin and Marsden [ 10]. We note here that [ 1] and [10] deal only with differential geometry on the group of maps without involving associated system of FBSDEs is solved using the existence of a s o- lution to ( 2), and by applying results from the works of Gliklikh ([ 13], [14], [15], [16]). The latter works use, in turn, the approach to stochastic differ en- tial equations on Banach manifolds developed by Dalecky and Belopols kaya [4], and started by McKean [ 19]. Conversely, a solution of ( 2) is obtained using the existence of a solution to the associated FBSDEs as well as some ideas and constructions from [ 9]. However, unlike [ 9], we work in an of the Navier-Stokes velocity field as a drift of a d iffu- sion process were initiated in [ 23] and [24]. A different system of (but not a system of two SDEs) associated to the Navier -Stokes system was introduced and studied in [ 5]. This system also includes an SDE on the group of diffeomorphisms, but is not a sys tem SDEs. Also, we mention here the works [ 2] and [3] dis- cussing probabilistic representations of solutions to the Navier-St okes equa- tions, and the work [ 6] establishing a stochastic variational principle for equations. Different probabilistic representations of the solu- tion to the Navier-Stokes equations were studied for example in [ 17] and [7]. We note that the list of literature on probabilistic approaches to the Navier- Stokes equations as well as connections between l FBSDEs and PDEs cited in this paper is by no means complete. The method of applying inl forward-backward SDE s in connection to the Navier-Stokes equations is employed, to the au for the first time. 2. Geometry of the diffeomorphism group of the the two-dimensional torus, and let Ha(T2),a >2, be the space of Ha-Sobolev maps T2-T2. ByGawe denote the subset of Ha(T2) whose elements are Let Ga Vbe the subgroup of Gaconsisting of diffeomorphisms preserving the volume measure on T2. Lemma 1.Letgbe anHa-map and a local diffeomorphism of a compact manifold M,Fbe anHa-section of the tangent bundle TM. Then,F*gis [15] (p. 139) or [ 10] (p. the right translation on Ga, i.e.Rg(e) =e*g. Lemma 2.The map RgisC-smooth for every gGa. Furthermore, for everyeGa, the tangent map TRgrestricted to the tangent space TeGais defined by the proof easily follows from the a-lemma (see [ 10], [15], groups GaandGa Vare inlHilbert manifolds. The group Ga Vis a subgroup and a smooth submanifold of Ga. Lemma4.The tangent space TeGais formed by all Ha-vector fields on T2. The tangent space TeGa Vis formed by all divergence-free Ha-vector fields on T2. The proof of Lemmas 3and4can be found for example in [ 10], [15], anHa-vector field on T2. Then the vector by ^X(g) =X*gis right-invariant. Furthermore, ^Xis Ck-smooth if and only if XHa+k. Proof.The first statement follows from Lemma 2. The proof of the second statement can be found in [ 10]. The vector field ^XonGadefined in Lemma 5will be referred to below as vector field generated by Consider the weak ( *,*)0and the metrics on Ga(see the differential, dis the codifferential, ^Xand^Yare the right- invariant vector fields on Gagenerated by the Ha-vector fields XandY. Metric (3) gives rise to the L2-topology on the tangent spaces of Ga, and 4metric (4) gives rise to the Ha-topology on the tangent spaces of Ga(see [16]). IfgGa V, then scalar products ( 3) and (4) do not depend on g. Moreover, for the strong metric on Ga V, we have the following = ( dd+dd) is the Laplace-de Rham operator (see [ 22]). Let us introduce the ork1= 0,k2>0}; k= (k1,k2)Z+
2,-k= the vectors -Ak(th) the right-invariant vector fields on Gagener- ated i.e. Ak(g) =-Ak*g, B k(g) =-Bk*g, gGa, A0=-A0, (see [ 15]),AkandBkare C-smooth vector fields on Ga. Lemma 6.The vectors {0},gGa V, form an orthogonal basis of the tangent space TgGa Vwith respect to both the weak and the strong inner products in TgGa V. In particular, the vectors form an orthogonal basis of the tangent space TeGa V. Moreover, the weak and the strong norms of the basis vectors are bounded by the suffices to prove the lemma for the strong norm. Let us compute a-Ak. Note that the an orthonormal basis of R2. 5Let us observe that by the identity ( -k,)cos(k*th) = 0,d-Ak= 0. Hence dd-Ak= 0 which implies -Ak=dd-Ak. We and the property of gGa Vimply (-Bm,-Ak)a= * /badblais the norm corresponding to the scalar product ( *,*)a. Clearly, for the obtain the same. It hasbeen shown, forexample, in[ 10]and[16] thattheweak has the Levi-Civita connection, geodesics, the exponential map, and the spray. Let -and~denote the covariant derivatives of the of the weak Riemannian metric ( 3) onGaandGa V, respectively. In [10] (see also [ 16], [15]), it has been shown that
~= P*- where P : TGa-TGa Vis defined in the following way: on each P maps, and Pe:TeGa-TeGa Vis the projector defined by the 7.Let^Ube the right-invariant vector field on Gagenerated by an Ha+1-vector field UonT2, and let ^Vbe the right-invariant vector field on Ga generated by an Ha-vector field VonT2. Then-^V^Uis the field on Gagenerated by the Ha-vector field VUonT2. 6Lemma 8.Let^Ube the right-invariant vector field on Ga Vgenerated by Ha+1-vector field UonT2, and let ^Vbe the field on Gagenerated by a divergence-free Ha-vector field Von T2. Then~^V^Uis the right-invariant vector field on Ga Vgenerated by Ha-vector field on GaandGa V(see [16]). Remark 1.The basis be extended to a basis of the entire tangent space TeGa. Indeed, let us introduce the vectors: -Ak(th) kZ+
2. The system form an orthogonal basis ofTeGa. Further let AkandBkdenote the right-invariant vector fields on Ga generated by -Akand-Bk. 3. The FBSDEs on the group of diffeomorphisms of the 2D a divergence-free Ha+1-vector field on T2, and let ^hbe the right-invariant vector field on Gagenerated by h. Further let the p: =p(s,*) for alls[t,T]. For each s[t,T],^V(s,*) denotes vector field on Gagenerated by a Euclidean space spanned on an orthonormal, relative to the scalar product in E, system ofvectors Consider the map s(g) gGa, i.e.s(g) is a linear operator E-TgGafor eachgGa. Let (ohm,F,P) be a probability space, and Ws,s[t,T], be asequence of independent Brownian motions. We consider the following system of forward and backward forward SDE of ( 5) is an SDE on Ga VwhereGa Vis considered as a Hilbert manifold. Stochastic differentials andstochastic differential equations on Hilbert manifolds are understood in the sense of Dalecky and Belop ol- skaya's approach (see [ 4]). More precisely, we use the results from [ 15] which interprets caseofSDEson Hilbert man- ifolds. The stochastic integral in the forward SDE can be explicitly wr itten as us consider the backward (7) Note that the processes ^V(s,Zt,e s) 7)asan SDE in the Hilbert space Ha(T2,R2). We would like to find an Fs-adapted triple of stochastic processes ( solv- ing FBSDEs ( 5) in the following sense: at each time s, the process ( values in an Ha-section of the tangent bundle TGa V. Namely, for each s[t,T] Therefore, the forward SDE is well-posed on both GaandGa V, and can be written in the form: dZt,e s= ~ exp and ~ exp are the exponential maps of the Levi-Civita con nection of the weak Riemannian metrics ( 3) onGaand resp. Ga V. Below, we will 8show that using either of these representations leads to the same solution of FBSDEs ( 5). Finally, the process Xt,e stakes values in the space of linear (8) where the processes values in 2.The results obtained below also work in the situation when the Brownian motion Wsis infinite dimensional (as in [ 8]). Namely, {0}, are real numbers However, this requires an additional analysis on the solvability of the forward SDE based on t he approach of Dalecky and Belopolskaya [ 4] since the results of Gliklikh ([ 13], [15], [16]) applied below are obtained for the case of a l Brownian motion. 4. Constructing a solution of the FBSDEs 4.1 The forward SDE Let us consider the backward Navier-Stokes equations in R2: y(s,th) = andare the Laplacian and the 1.Let us assume that on the interval [t,T]there exists a that the functions p: the coordinates of y(s,*) with respect to the basis i.e. y(s,th) denote the right-invariant vector field on Gagenerated by the solution y(s,*), i.e.^Ys(g) =y(s,*)*g. On each tangent space TgGa, the vector^Ys(g) can be represented by a series converging in the (10) In this paragraph we will study the (11) Later, in Theorem 6, we will show that the solution Zt,e sto (11) and two processes inthetriple( that solves FBSDEs ( 5). Theorem 1.There exists a unique strong solution Zt,e s,s[t,T], to(11) onGa V, with the initial condition we verify the assumptions of Theorem 13.5 of [ 16]. The latter theorem will imply the existence and uniqueness of the strong solutio n to (11). Note that, if sum ( 6) representing the stochastic only the terms i.e., infor- mally speaking, if the Brownian motion runs only along the constant ve ctors A0andB0, then the statement of the theorem follows from Theorem 28.3 of [16]. If sum ( 6) contains also terms with AkandBk,kZ+
2, or, informally, when the Brownian motion runs also along non-constant vectors AkandBk, kZ+
2, then the assumptions of Theorem 13.5 of [ 16] require the bounded- ness ofAkandBkwith respect to the strong norm. The latter fact holds all the assumptions of Theorem 13.5 of [ 16] are satisfied. In- deed, the proof of Theorem 28.3 of [ 16] shows that the Levi-Civita con- nection of the weak Riemannian metric ( 3) onGa Vis compatible (see Def- inition 13.7 of [ 16]) with the strong Riemannian metric ( 4). The function s(g) C-smooth since Akand Bkare C-smooth. Moreover, by Lemma 6,s(g) is bounded on Ga V. Next, sincey: is continuous, then it is also bounded with respect to (at least) the Ha-norm. Hence, the generated right-invariant vec- tor field ^Ys(g) is bounded in swith respect to the strong metric ( 4), and it is at least C1-smooth in g. The boundedness of ^Ysingfollows from the property of g. 10Theorem 2.There exists a unique strong solution Zt,e s,s[t,T], to(11) onGa, with the initial condition Zt,e t=e. This solution coincides with the solution to SDE the identical embedding i:Ga V-Ga. By results of [ 4] (Proposition 1.3, p. 146; see also [ 16], p. 64), the stochastic process i(Zt,e s) =
Zt,e s,s[t,T], is a solution to SDE ( 11) onGa, i.e. with respect to exp(Ti*X). The solution Zt,e sto (11) onGais unique. This follows from the uniqueness theorem for SDE ( 11) considered on the manifold Gaequipped with the weak Riemannian metric. Indeed, s(g) and^Ys(g) are bounded with respect to the weak metric ( 3) since the functions -Ak,-Bk,kZ+
2 {0}, are bounded on T2, andy(*,*) is bounded on [ t,T]xT2. Moreover s(g) is C-smooth and ^Ysis at least C1-smooth on Ga. One can also consider ( 11) as an SDE with values in the Hilbert 3.There exists a unique strong solution Zt,e sto SDE (11)on[t,T], with the initial condition Zt,e t=ewhereeis the identity of Ga V. This solution coincides with the solution to SDE Theorem 1, SDE (11) onGa Vhas a unique strong solution Zt,e son [t,T]. Let us prove that the solution Zt,e sto (11) solves this SDE considered as an SDE in Ha(T2,R2). Consider the identical imbedding o'sformulato =-Akth*g=Ak(g) and that Ak(g)Ak(g)iV(g) =Ak(g)Ak(g) = 0, we obtain that the solution Zt,e sto (11) onGa Vsolves the (11). Note that by the uniqueness theorem for SDEs in Hilbert its solution in Ha(T2,R2) as well. Thus the solutions to ( 11) onGa,Ga V, and inHa(T2,R2) coincide. Let us find the representations of SDE ( 11) in normal coordinates on Ga andGa V. First, we prove the following following equality instead of the It^ o stochastic integral in (11)we can write the we have to prove that = 0 and = 0. For simplicity of notation we use the notation Anfor both of the vector the notation Also, we use thenotation 0 which holds by the identity ( -k,)cos(k*th) = (-k,)sin(k*th) = 0 or of constant vector the vector of local coordinates of the solution Zt,e sto (11) onGa V, i.e. the vector of normal coordinates provided by the exponential map ~ exp : TeGa V-Ga V. LetUebe the canonical chart of the map ~ exp. Theorem 4 (SDE ( 11) in local coordinates) .Let t= inf{s[t,T] :Zt,e s/Ue}. (12) On the interval [t,t], SDE(11)has the following representation in anddk= 0if|k|> N. 12Proof.Let local coordinates in the by the map ~ exp. Let fC(Ga V), and let ~f:TeGa V-Rbe such that~f=f*~ exp. Since ~ exp is a C-map (see [ 10]), then~fC(U0), where U0= ~ exp-1Ue. Note that gkA~f(-g) =Ak(g)f(g) and gkB~f(-g) =Bk(g)f(g). By It^ o's formula, we representations ( 10) and (6) we shows that the SDE ( 11) on the interval [ the vector of local coordinates of the solution Zt,e sto (11) onGa, i.e. the vector of normal coordinates provided by the exponential map ex p :TeGa- Ga. Further let VUebe the canonical chart of the map exp. 13Theorem 5.Let Vt= inf{s[t,T] a.s. Vt=t, where the stopping time tis defined by (12), and on 0,kZ+
2, a.s. Proof.Let us introduce additional local coordinates gkA,gkB,kZ+
2, and perform the same computation as in the proof of Theorem 4. We have to take into account that YkA s=YkB s= 0,kZ+
2, and that the components of the Brownian motion are non-zero only along divergence-free and c onstant vector fields. We obtain that the coordinate SDEs ( 13) and the equations 0,kZ+
2. 4.2 The backward SDE and the solution of the FBSDEs We have the following result: Theorem 6.Let^Ysbe the right-invariant vector field generated by the the backward Navier-Stokes equations (9). Further let Zt,e sbe the solution to SDE (11)onGa V. Then there exists an o >0such that the triple of stochastic FBSDEs (5)on the interval [t,T]. Remark 3.The expression means the following: is regarded as a function Ga V-Ha(T2,R2), differentiation of along the vector field Akat thepoint gGa V. Letgxbe thegeodesic in Ga Vsuch that the stochastic integral in ( 7) can be represented particular, if N= result similar to Lemma 10below was obtained in [ 6]. Lemma 10 (The Laplacian of a right-invariant vector field) .Let^Vbe vector field on G~agenerated by an H~a+2-vector field Von T2. Further let o >0be such Then =nV*g. (16) Here ~ais an integer which is not necessary equal to a. Proof.By the right-invariance of the vector fields 7), it suffices to show ( 16) forg=e. We observe = (-k,)sin(k*th) = 0. Then, for -Bk-Bk^V(e)(th) Hence, for that for each kZ+
2, either-kor--kis inZ+
2, over in (17), and coupling the terms that ( = V(th). Finally, we lemma is 1.Let the function Further mean the differentiation of the resp. Bk. Then for all computation that we made in ( 14) but applied to we compute Bk(g)[ph*g]. Now we just have to repeat the proof of Lemma10to come to ( be whose trajectories are integrable, and let phTbe random elementso that both expectations. Then there exists an Fs-adapted pair of es (Ys,Xs)solving the (19) on[t,T]. TheYs-part of the solution has the (20) and therefore is unique. The Xs-part of the solution is unique with respect to the norm proof of the lemma uses some ideas from [ ( 20) follows from ( 19). Let us extend the process Ys to the entire interval [0 ,T] by setting Ys=Ytfors[0,t], and note that the extended process Ysis a solution of the [0,T]. LetXs be such (21) The process Xsexists by the martingale representation theorem. Indeed, on the right-hand side of ( 21) we have a Hilbert space valued martingale. By Theorem 6.6 of [ 12], each component of the on the right-hand side of ( 21) can be represented as a sum of real-valued stochastic integrals with respect to the Brownian mo Hence, there exist Fs-adapted stochastic the process Xsbe defined by ( 8) via the processes It^ o's isometry shows that that for all This shows that Xs= 0 for almost all oohm and almost all s[0,t], and therefore can be chosen equal to zero on [0 ,t]. Thus, ( 21) takes the (22) It is easy to verify that the pair ( Ys,Xs) defined by ( 20) and (22) solves BSDE (19). To prove the uniqueness, note that any Fs-adapted solution to (19) takes the form ( 20), (22). Moreover, if the processes 0. Proof of Theorem 6.Let us consider BSDE ( 7) as an and ^Ysas a function Ga V-L2(T2,R2). Since for each anda >2 by assumption, then at least C2-smooth. Equations ( 2) show that the function sy(*,*) is continuous since p, y, and (y,y) are continu- ous functions [ t,T]-L2(T2,R2) by Assumption 1. Taking into account that the diffeomorphisms of Ga Vare , we conclude that for each fixed gGa V,s^Ys(g) : [t,T]-L2(T2,R2) is a continuous is C1-smooth in s[t,T] and C2- smooth in gGa V. It^ o's formula is therefore applicable to ^Ys(Zt,e s). Below we use the fact that Zt,e sis a solution to forward SDE ( 11) and the Forthe latter derivative we substitute equationof ( 2).Thenotation without square brackets) means differentiation of the function the right-invariant vector field ^XonGa Vat the point gGa V. The same argument as in Remark 3implies that ^X(g)[^Ys(g)] =-^X^Ys(g). Taking 18into account this argument, we = let us observe the latter equality holds by Lemma 10, ando >0 is chosen so Note that the terms are elements of TGa-1, and therefore are well defined in L2(T2,R2). Continuing ( 23), we the pair of stochastic processes ( ^Ys(Zt,e s),o) is a solu- tion to BSDE ( 7) inL2(T2,R2). It isFs-adapted since Lemma 11, we know that there exists a unique Fs-adapted to (7) inHa(T2,R2). Clearly, ( Yt,e s,Xt,e s) is also a unique Fs- adapted solution to ( 7) inL2(T2,R2). Hence, and/integraltextT t/badblXt,e s- o)/badbl2 L(E,Ha(T2,R2))ds= 0, and therefore the pair of stochas- tic processes/parenleftbig^Ys(Zt,e s),o/parenrightbig is a unique Fs-adapted solution to BSDE (7) inHa(T2,R2). The theorem is proved. 5. Some identities involving the Navier-Stokes solution The backward SDE allows us to obtain the representation below for t he Navier-Stokes solution. Also, it easily implies the well-known energy ide ntity for the Navier-Stokes equations. 5.1 Representation of the Navier-Stokes solution Theorem 7.Lett[0,T], and let Zt,e sbe the solution to SDE (11)on[t,T] with the initial condition Zt,e t=e. Then the following representation holds for the solution that ^Yt(Zt,e t) =y(t,*), = 0. Taking the ex- pectation from the both parts of ( 7) at time s=twe obtain the A simple derivation of the energy identity It^ o's formula applied to the squared L2(T2,R2)-norm of representation ( 15) for the process Xt,e swe the expectation in ( 25) and using the we Constructing the solution to the Navier-Stokes equa- tions from a solution to the FBSDEs Let us prove now a result which is, in some sense, a converse of Theo rem6. In this section we consider ( 5) as a system of forward and backward SDEs in the Hilbert space Ha(T2,R2), where As before, let ^V(s,Zt,e s) and let Fsdenote the filtration 8.Assume, for an Ha+1-smooth function p(s,*),s[0,T], and for anyt(0,T), the existence of an Fs-adapted solution (to (5)on[t,T]such that the processes a.s. continuous trajec- tories and such that Zt,e stake values in Ga V. Then there exists T0>0such that for all T < T 0there exists a deterministic function such that a.s. on [t,T]the relation Moreover, the pair of functions (y,p)solves the backward Navier-Stokes equations 12-18below are the steps in the proof of Theorem 8. 21Lemma12.For allt[0,T)and for any Ft-measurable Ga V-valued the triple of stochastic = and solves the the interval [t,T]in the space us apply the operator Rxof the right translation to the both sides of FBSDEs ( 5). We only have to prove that we are allowed to write Rxunder the signs of both stochastic integrals in ( 5). Let us prove that it is true stepwise function wheregiGa Vand Indeed, let sandSbe such that < let Ph rbe anFr-adapted stochastically integrable process. We we find a sequence of Ft-measurable stepwise functions converging to xin the space of continuous functions C( T2,R2). This is possible due to the separability of C( T2,R2). Indeed, let us consider a countable number of disjoint Borel sets On icovering C( T2,R2), and such that their diameter in the norm of C( T2,R2) is smaller than1 n. andI(Ph*x) We have to prove that a.s. I(Ph)*x=I(Ph*x). For this it suffices to prove 0, 0. (29) Due to the property of Hence, by Lebesgue's theorem, in ( 28) 22we can pass to the limit under the expectation sign. Relation ( 28) holds then by the continuity of I(Ph) inthT2. To prove ( 29) we observe that by It^ o's isometry, the limit in ( 29) equals to lim same argument that we used to prove ( 28) implies that we can pass to the limit under the expectation and the integral signs. Relation ( 29) follows from the continuity of Ph rinthT2. Hence, is a solution to ( 27). This solution 13-17below use some ideas and constructions from [ 9]. Lemma13.The map us extend the solution ( to the interval [0 ,t] 0 for all s[0,t]. The extended process solves the random vector and hence is deterministic by Blu- menthal's zero-one law. Since Yt,e t=Yt,e 0, the result exists a constant T0>0such that for T < T 0the ( and be solutions to ( 27) which start at the identity eat times tand resp. t', and let t < t'. These solutions can be regarded as solutions of ( 30) if we extend them to the entire interval [0,T] as it was described in Lemma 13. The application of It^ o's formula the backward SDE of ( 27) imply that the bounded. The forward SDE of ( 30), Gronwall's lemma, and usual stochastic integral estimates imply that there exists a c onstant K1>0 such us apply It^ o's formula to using the backward SDE of ( 30). Again, Gronwall's lemma, usual stochastic integral estimates 23and the above estimate for that there exists a constant K2>0 such take T0smaller than1 K2. Then there exists a constant K >0 such K(t'-t). (31) Evaluating the right-hand side at the point s=t, and taking into obtain K(t'-t). ( 30) with respect to thwe obtain the following system of for- ward and backward standard estimates imply the boundedness of The same argument that we used to obtain ( 32) as well as the estimate for the which easily follows from (31), and the forward SDE imply that there exists a constant L >0 such that for all tandt'from the interval [0 L|t'-t|. ( 30) the second time and using the same argument once again we obtain that there exist a constant M >0 such that for all tandt' belonging to [0 M|t'-t|. (34) Now (32), (33), and (34) imply the continuity of the map to the T < T Lemma 14. Lemma15.For every t[0,T)and for every Ft-measurable random variable x, the solution unique on [t,T]. Proof.Let us assume that there exists another solution ( to (27) on [t,T]. The same argument as in the proof of Lemma 14implies the uniqueness of solution to ( 27). Specifically, the argument that we applied to the pair of solutions ( and has to be applied to and (, and it has to be taken into the function y: [0,T]xT2-R2be defined by the formula: y(t,th) =Yt,e t(th). (35) Then, for every and (36) Proof.Note that ( 26) implies that if xisFt-measurable (37) Further, for each fixed u[t,T], ( is a solution of the on [ uniqueness of solution, it holds that on [u,T]. Next, aset ohmu(which depends on u) of fullP-measure such that ( 36) holds everywhere on ohmu. Clearly, one can find a set ohm Q,P(ohmQ) = 1, such that ( 36) holds on ohmQfor all rational u[t,T]. But the trajectories of a.s. continuous. Furthermore, Lemma 14implies thecontinuity of to (at least) the Therefore, ( 36) holds a.s. with respect to the Since both sides of ( 36) are also holds a.s. for all function ydefinedby formula (35)isC1-smooth in >0. We the right-invariant vector field on Gagenerated by y(s,*). Lemma 16implies that we obtain that use the backward SDE for the second difference and apply It^ o's formula to the first difference when considering ^Yt+das aC2-smooth function Ga V- L2(T2,R2). We same argument as in Theorem we we obtain that Zt,e r,p(r,*), and continuous in ra.s. with respect to the By Lemma 14,y(t,*) in twithrespect tothe Formula (38) and the fact that Zt,e t=eimply that in the the right-hand side of ( 39) is anHa-2-map, so is the left-hand side. This implies that ty(t,*) is continuous in thT2. Relation ( 39) is obtained so far for the right derivative of y(t,th) with respect to t. Note that the right- hand side of ( 39) is continuous in twhich implies that the right ton[0,T).Hence, subinterval of [0 ,T). This implies the existence of the left on [0 ,T]. Lemma18.For every t[0,T], the function y(t,*) :T2-R2is Moreover, the pair (y,p)verifies the backward Navier-Stokes at >0, and consider the TeGa V-valued curve in a neigborhood of the origin of TeGa V. The forward SDE of ( 27) can be represented as an SDE on the right-invariant vector field on Gagenerated by y(s,*). This implies therefore y(t,*)TeGa V. Next, the backward SDE of ( 27) implies This and relation ( 36) imply that y(T,*) =h. Since we already obtained ( 39) in Lemma 17the proof of the lemma is now complete. 7. The backward SDE as an SDE on a tangent bundle Let ( be a solution to FBSDEs ( 5). We will show that the backward SDE can be represented as an SDE on the tangent bundle TGa Vas 27well as an SDE on TGa. We will construct a backward SDE in the form (see [ 4]) and show that the process Yt,e sis its The representation of the backward SDE on be the solution to the backward Navier-Stokes equa- tions(9).Let^Ysbevectorfieldon Ga Vgeneratedby y(s,*). The connection map on the manifold Ga Vgenerates the connection map on the manifold TGa Vas it was shown in [ 4], p. 58 (see also [ 11]). As before, we consider the Levi-Civita connection of the weak Riemannian metric (3) onGa V. Letexp denote the exponential map of the generated connection on TGa V. More precisely, exp is given as the geodesic curve on TGa Vwith the initial data g' a(0) =a, e' b(0) =b,ga(0) =x,eb(0) =a. Let the vector fields AH kandBH kbe the horizontal lifts of Further let s^Yl sbe the vertical lift Let us consider the backward SDE on S is the geodesic spray of the Levi-Civita connection of the we ak Riemannian metric ( 3) onGa V(see [15] or [16]), is the solution to ( 11) onGa Vwith the initial condition 9.There exists a solution to (40)on[t,T]. Moreover, then this solution is unique and coincides with the Yt,e s-part of the unique Fs-adapted solution the proof of Theorem 6we know that the pair of stochastic pro- cesses (^Ys(Zt,e s),o) is the unique Fs-adapted solution to ( 7) a system of local coordinates ( a neigh- borhood The vector - g= the vector of normal Ueg,gGa V. The vector -X= the coordinates of the decomposition of the vector ^X(g)TGa Vin Letfbe a smooth function on TGa V, and let ~f(-X,-g) =f(^X(g)), where the exit time of the process Zt,e rfrom the neighborhood UeZt,e s. We will compute the difference using It^ o's formula. Let (-Zr,-Yr) = the vector of local coordinates of the process ^Yr(Zt,e r) on [s,t]. Using SDE ( 40), we obtain: 1 anddk= 0 otherwise. Since fis a smooth all its restrictions to the tangent spaces of Ga Vare smooth. Hence, one can talk about derivatives of frestricted to a tangent space along the vectors of this tangent space. Namely, the following relation that the differentiation of ~fwith respect to ZkA randZkB rcan be ofthecomposite function This extended the integration to the entire interval [ s,T] since the local coor- dinates no longer appear under the integral signs. This is also possib le since (41) holds also with respect to the local coordinates in the neighborhoo d UeZt,e tand a new exit time t1. The same argument can be repeated with respect to the local coordinates in the neighborhood UeZt,e t1, etc. Let us con- sider now f*^Ysas a time-dependent function of gGa V. Applying It^ o's formula to ( f*^Ys)(Zt,e s) on the interval [ s,T] and using SDE ( 11) onGa V, we obtain exactly the above identity. This proves that is a strong solution to ( 40) onTGa V. By results of [ 15],s^Yl sis C1-smooth. Moreover are C-smooth. Again, by results of [ 15], the solution of BSDE ( 40) onTGa Vis unique. 7.2 The representation of the backward SDE on TGa Applying Proposition 1.3 (p. 146) of [ 4] (see also [ 16], p. 64) to the the identical imbedding iV:TGa V-TGa, we obtain that the process solves the following backward - is the geodesic spray of the Levi-Civita connection of the weak Riemannian metric on the vertical lift of the horizontal lifts of AkandBkontoTTGa, the Zt,e t=e. The exponential map - exp on TTGais defined similarly to the map exp on TTGa V. Namely, the Levi-Civita connection of the weak Riemannian aconnectionon TGa. Thelattergives - exp on TTGaas it was described in Paragraph 7.1. We actually have obtained the following theorem. Theorem 10.Backward SDE (43)has a unique strong solution. Moreover, this solution coincides with the unique strong solution to B with the Yt,e s-part of the unique Fs-adapted solution have already shown that the process ^Ys(Zt,e s) solves BSDE ( 43). The uniqueness of solution can be proved in exactly the same way as t he uniqueness of solution to ( 40) onTGa V(see the proof of Theorem 9). 8. Appendix 8.1 Geometry of the group of diffeomorphi sms of then-dimensional the n-dimensional torus. Let us describe a basis of the tangent space TeGa Vof the group Ga Vof volume of Tn. We introduce the following n)Zn:k1>0 ork1=***=ki-1= 0, ki>0, i= 2,...,n}; k= (k1,...,k (th1,...,th every kZ+
n, (-k1,...,-kn-1) denotes an orthogonal system of vectors is also orthogonal to k. Introduce the vector fields on i= 1,...,n-1, kZ+
n, 31and the constant vector fields -Ai 0,i= 1,...,n, whoseith coordinate is 1 and the other coordinates are 0. Let Ai k,Bi k,i= 1,...,n-1,kZ+
n, denote the right-invariant vector fields on Ga Vgenerated by -Ai k,-Bi k,i= respectively, and let Ai 0=-Ai 0,i= 1,...,n, stand for constant vector fields on Ga V. The following lemma is an analog of Lemma 6. Lemma19.The vectors 1,...,n, form an orthogonal basis of the tangent space TgGa Vwith respect to both the weak and the strong inner products in TgGa V. In particular, 1,...,n, form an orthogonal basis of the tangent space TeGa V. Moreover, the weak and the strong norms of the basis vectors are bounded by the same constant. The other lemmas of Section 2hold in the n-dimensional case, with re- spect to the system 1,...,n, without changes. The index aof the Sobolev space Hais an integer The Laplacian of a right-invariant vector field on Ga(Tn) One of the most important steps in the proof of Theorems 6and8is Lemma 10, i.e. the computation of the Laplacian of a right-invariant vector fie ld on Gawith respect to the subsystem be fixed arbitrary. Below we prove an n-dimensional analog of this the right-invariant vector field on G~a(Tn)generated field VonTn. Further let o >0be such +n-1 n/summationdisplay kZ+
n,|k|/lessorequalslantN1
|k|2a/parenrightBig
=n. Then for all =nV*g. Proof.As it was mentioned in the proof of Lemma 7, it suffices to consider the case g=e. We observe that for all i= = 0. 32Similarly, ( -ki,)sin(k*th) = 0. Then, for latter equality holds by the (k,)2=|k|2 that follows, in turn, from the fact that the 1,...,n-1, forms an orthonormal basis of Rn. for each we and due to the factor1 2we perform the summation over all kZn. Clearly, the second sum is zero. To show this, we have to specify th e way of summation. Let us collect in a group the terms kikjijattributed to thosekZnwhose coordinates except the ith and the jth coincide, while theith and the jth coordinates satisfy the following rules: they are to one of the vectors of the group by means of an arbitrary assignment of a sign. This operation specifies four vec tors. The other four vectors are obtained from the first four vectors of t he group by means of the permutation of the ith and the jth coordinates. In total, we 33get eight vectors in the group. Clearly, the summands kikjijattributed to these vectors cancel each other. Let us compute the first with ( 44) it also have to take into consideration the = V(th). Finally, we lemma is would like to thank the referee for meaningful questions. This wo rk was supported by the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Techno logy (FCT) under the projects and SFRH/BPD/48714/ I. Arnold , Sur la g' eom' etrie diff' erentielle des groupes de lie de dimen- sion infinie et ses applications a l'hidrodynamique des fluides parfaits. Ann. Inst. Fourier 16, 316-361, 1966. [2]S. Albeverio, Ya. Belopolskaya , Probabilistic approach to In the book Probabilistic Methods in Fluids. World Scien- tific, p. 1-21, 2003. [3]S. Albeverio, Ya. Belopolskaya , Generalized solutions of the Cauchy problem for the Navier-Stokes system and diffusion [math.PR] . [4]Ya. I. Belopolskaya,Yu. L. Dalecky Series: Mathematics and its Applications, Kluwer Academ ic Publishers, Netherlands, (1989), 260 p. [5]Ya. I. Belopolskaya , Probabilistic Representation of Solutions of Hydro- dynamic Equations, Journal ofMathematical Sciences (New York) ,101, no. 5, (2000), 3422-3436. [6]F. Cipriano, A. B. Cruzeiro , Navier-Stokes Equation and Diffusions on the Group of Homeomorphisms of the Torus, Commun. Math. Phys. 275, (2007), 255-269. [7]P. Constantin, G. Iyer , A stochastic Lagrangian representation of incompressible Navier-Stokes equations, Comm . Pure Appl. Math., 61, no. 3, (2008), 330-345. [8]A. B. Cruzeiro, P. Malliavin , Nonergodicity of Euler fluid dynamics on tori versus positivity of the Arnold-Ricci tensor, J. Funct. Anal. 254, (2008), 1903-1925. [9]F. Delarue , On the existence and uniqueness of solutions to FBSDEs in a non-generate case, Stochastic Processes and their Applicatio ns,99, (2002), 209-286. [10]D. Ebin, J. Marsden , Groups of diffeomorphisms and the motion of fluid, Annals Math, 92, no. 1, (1970), Eliasson , Geometry of manifolds of maps, J. Differential geometry, 1, (1967), 169-194. [12]N. Ikeda, S. Watanabe , Stochastic differential equations and 2nd ed. (English) North-Holland Mathematical Library , 24. Amsterdam etc.: North-Holland; Tokyo: Kodansha Ltd. xvi, (1981 ), 555 p. [13]Yu. E. Gliklikh , Calculus on Riemannian manifolds and Problems of Mathematical Physics, press, (1989),192p E. Gliklikh , New version of the Lagrange approach to the dynamics of a viscous incompressible fluid, Mathematical Notes, 55, No. 4, E. Gliklikh Mathematical Physics, Springer (1996), 189 p. [16]Yu. E. Gliklikh , Global Analysis in Mathematical Physics: Geometric and Stochastic Methods, Springer (1997), 213 p. [17]Y. Le Jan, A.-S. Sznitman , Stochastic cascades and equations. Probab. Theory Rel. Fields 109, (1997) , 343- 366. [18]J. Ma, P. Protter, J. Yong , Solving forward-backward stochastic differ- ential equations explicitly - a four step scheme, Probab. Theory Re lated Fields,98, (1994), 339-359. [19]H. P. McKean , Stochastic integrals, Academic Press, N. Y., (1969). [20]E. Pardoux, S. G. Peng , Adapted solution of a backward equation, Systems and Control Letters, 14, No. 1, Pardoux, S. Tang equations and quasilinear parabolic PDEs, Probab. Theory Relat. Fields, 114, (1999), 123-150. [22]S. Shkoller , Geometry and curvature of diffeomorphisms groups with H1 metric and mean hydrodynamics, J. Funct. Anal. 160,(1998), Yasue , A variational principle for the Navier-Stokes equation, J. Funct. Anal., 51(2), (1983), 133-141 [24]T. Nakagomi, K. Yasue, J.-C. Zambrini , Stochastic variational deriva- tions of the Navier-Stokes equation, Lett. Math. Phys., 160,
|
0807.0421
|
Evelina Shamarova
|
Ana Bela Cruzeiro and Evelina Shamarova
|
Navier-Stokes equations and forward-backward SDEs on the group of
diffeomorphisms of a torus
| null |
Stochastic Processes and their Applications 119 (2009) 4034-4060
| null | null |
math.PR math.AP
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We establish a connection between the strong solution to the spatially
periodic Navier-Stokes equations and a solution to a system of forward-backward
stochastic differential equations (FBSDEs) on the group of volume-preserving
diffeomorphisms of a flat torus. We construct representations of the strong
solution to the Navier-Stokes equations in terms of diffusion processes.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 2 Jul 2008 19:02:09 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Tue, 9 Sep 2008 19:22:00 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Thu, 23 Oct 2008 19:47:20 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Wed, 22 Jul 2009 14:24:07 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v5",
"created": "Thu, 21 Jan 2010 17:54:11 GMT"
}
] | 2010-01-21T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Cruzeiro",
"Ana Bela",
""
],
[
"Shamarova",
"Evelina",
""
]
] |
50AMeV. The known 4.83-MeV excited state was strongly populate d and its spin and parity were assigned to 1/2+by comparing the angular differential cross section data with DWBA calculations. This low-lying 1/2+state is interpreted as a proton intruder state and indicates a deformation of the nu cleus. Key words: Intruder state, Proton single particle state, Proton trans fer 25.55.Hp, 27.20.+n, 29.30.Kv The existence of intruder states in light neutron-rich unstable nuc lei is often considered to be evidence for one or more - hoconfigurations in the low-lying states around the psdshell. The ground state of11Be is 1/2+which is lower in energy by 0.3 MeV than the 1 /2-state [1]. In12Be, there is a 1-intruder state at 2.7-MeV excitation energy [2]. The energies of these low-lyin g, non- normal parity states indicate 1- Furthermore, the presence of low-lying 2+
1[3] and 0+
2[4,5] states in12Be suggests a 2- theoretical interpretations have been proposed for thes e one or more - in the low-lying states of neutron-rich unstable nuc lei: (1) the monopole interaction of the tensor force [6], (2) the loosely bound n ature of some orbitals [7], and (3) nuclear deformation [5,8,9]. In Ref. [6],the effe was determined so that the model reproduces the ene rgy levels in light, neutron-rich nuclei including intruder states, and the impor tance of monopole interaction due to the tensor force was pointed out. R eference [7] discusses the fact that in the psdshell, the 2 s1/2orbital gains its energy relative to the other orbitals due to its loosely bound nature. The no can also be intuitively explained by the deformed mean field picture. As seen in the Nilsson diagram, the gap becomes smaller w ith increasing deformation [5,8,9]. Since the combination of these effects , which are provided by their corresponding theoretical models, changes the neutron shell structure in neutron-rich nuclei, such as11,12Be, the relative importance of the three theoretical approaches has not been clarified. For the proton shell in light neutron-rich nuclei, the effects due to t he tensor force and the loosely bound nature of the orbitals are expected to be small since the are fully filled and the proton(s) are deeply bound. However, deformation is still presumed to affect the proton shell s tructure. Proton intruder states are, therefore, signatures for the impo rtance of defor- mation. In the present study, we focus on the proton shell struc ture in the N= 8 nucleus13B by investigating the proton single-particle states. In order to investigate the proton single-particle states in13B, we used the (a,t) reaction on12Be in inverse kinematics. This process at an has a relatively large cross section since the proton to be tr ansferred is deeply bound in the aparticle and, thus, has high-momentum reduce the effect of the momentum mismatch of the ( a,t) reaction [10]. The experiment was performed at the RIKEN Accelerator Researc h Facility. A12Be beam was produced by the fragmentation reaction of a 100 AMeV18O beam on a9Be target with a thickness of 1.85-g/cm2. The12Be beam was sep- arated by the RIKEN Separator (RIPS) [12]. The were identified on an event-by-event basis using the meas ured time- of-flight and the energy deposited. The time-of-flight, over a pat h length of 5.4 m, and the energy deposited were measured using two plastic scin at the last two foci of the RIPS. The intensity and the purit y of the 12Be beam respectively were typically 2 x105counts per second and 90%. The 50AMeV12Be beam bombarded a secondary target of liquid at the final focus of the RIPS. A liquid helium target was chos en because of its statistical advantage in terms of the experimental yields. The helium was condensed by a cryogenic refrigerator and kept below 4 K during the experiment. A target thickness of 143 +-5 mg/cm2was estimated from the velocity difference between outgoing particles measured with and wit hout the liquid helium. The positions and directions of the incident particles on th e secondary target were deduced from the position information of t wo parallel plate avalanche counters [13] located 30-cm apart from each othe r around the final focus. The outgoing particles were detected by a plastic s 3.5-m downstream from the secondary target with a 1 x1 m2 active area and an angular acceptance of up to 8 degrees in the labo ratory frame. The plastic scintillator hodoscope consisted of 5-mm thick Eand 60-mm thick Elayers. The Elayer was divided into 13 plastic vertically and the Elayer into 16 plastic scintillator bars outgoing particles were identified on an event-by-event basis u sing the measured time-of-flight and the energy deposited in the EandElayers. The mass distribution for the Z= 5 particles is shown in Fig. 1; the mass resolution ( dA) was determined to be ~0.25. The time-of-flight between the secondary target and the hodoscope was deduced from the time in formation of the plastic scintillators located upstream from the secondary ta rget and the plastic scintillator hodoscope. Position information for the outgoing particles was deduced from the time difference between the output signals fr om the tubes attached to both ends of each scintillator bar , and in the laboratory frame was 0.5 degrees in one standard deviat ion. The de-excitation grays were detected by an array of germanium RAPE)[14]. This consisted of 6 germanium detectors located at 140*with respect to the beam axis. Each detector contains two cylindrical crystals 6 cm in dia meter and 2 cm thick, with a common anode between them. The each cathod e at- tached to each crystal is segmented into a 3 x3 matrix. The GRAPE information of the g-ray interaction point, which is extracted from a pulse shape analysis of the signal from the cathode [14,15]. The intr insic energy resolution and the full energy peak efficiency were typically 2 .7 keV (FWHM) and 0.4%, respectively, for 1332-keV grays from a60Co standard source. The energy resolution after correcting for the Doppler s hift was de- duced to be 1.3% (FWHM) for 2.1-MeV grays, corresponding to the decay of the first 2+state of12Be moving with 30% the light velocity. The excited states of13B populated inthereaction were identified by measuring the energy of the de-excitation grays. Figure 2 shows the energy spectrum of grays measured in coincidence with 13B after correcting for the Doppler shift. There are three peaks c orresponding to the transitions from (3.68-, 3.73-), 4.13- and 4.83-MeV excited s tates to the ground state. The peaks seen in the low energy region is conside red to originate from the reaction of the beam and the window of the targe t cell. Other significant transitions including those between the excited st ates were not observed in the present measurement. In the figure, hatche d areas show the response functions of the GRAPE for the de-excitation grays obtained by means of a Monte Carlo simulation using the GEANT4 code [16,17] and 5for the background grays. The background was assumed to consist of two components, the natural background grays, estimated by putting the gate in the non-prompt region of the time spectrum of the GRAPE, and the grays from the isomer state of12Be, which were simulated by assuming a life time of 331 ns [5]. The ratio of the isomer state to the ground state in the se condary beam was less than 2 percent at the secondary target. In the simu lations, all the resolutions of the detectors associated with the correction f or the Doppler shift were taken into account. The intensity of each decay to the g round thed of the observed grays from the known excited states are shown in Table 1, together with the previously reported data including two ne utron transfer [18], neutron knockout [19], b-decay followed by neutron decay [20], and multi-nucleon transfer [21]. In the present reaction, the excit ed state at 4.83 MeV is strongly populated relative to the other excited states, while it is less excited in the other reactions except for the multi-nucleon t ransfer reaction which is expected to populate proton excited states. Con sidering the selectivity of the proton transfer reaction, it is conceivable that t he 4.83-MeV excited state is of proton single-particle individual g-ray spectra with cuts were fitted with the same response functions and background describe d above, distribution for the 4.83-MeV excitation with filled circles. The trans- ferred angular momentum ( L) in the reaction is determined by comparing the obtained angular distributions with predictions of the distorted -wave (DWBA), calculated with the DWUCK5 code [22]. The op ti- cal potentials for the entrance and exit channels were obtained by adopting a single folding model used in Ref. [23]. The density distribution of12Be for ,25]. The density distribution of13B is assumed to be the same as that of12Be = (13 /12)1/3. For the entrance channel, the depth of the imaginary potential is adjusted so as to represent the inelastic sca ttering data of12Be, excited to the2+
1state. Fortheexit channel, the depths ofthe real and imaginary potentials are varied in order to estimate the statistical e rror for the spectroscopic factor. The DWBA predictions with L= 0,1,2 are shown as curves in Fig. 3. The absolute magnitudes of the predictions are n ormalized so as to minimize the kh2values. The reduced kh2value is 0.74 for the L= 0 calculation. The forward angle peak in the experimental angular dist ribution is well described by the L= 0 DWBA calculation. Therefore, we assigned a spin and parity of 1/2+to the 4.83-MeV excited state. Its low energy indicates that it is a proton intruder state from the sdshell. The spectroscopic strength C2Swas deduced to be 0 .20+-0.02, where Sis a spectroscopic factor and C2 is an isospin Clebsch-Gordan coefficient. The systematic errors of t heC2Sdue to the choice of the optical potentials in the DWBA calculation and to t he geometrical uncertainty of the GRAPE in the simulation were evaluat ed to be 50% and 10%, respectively. The former one is obtained from the d the folding model and a separate calculation using a global o ptical potential for12C in Ref. [26,27]. In the absolute magnitude of the section, there is no ambiguity originated from cascade decay s to or from the 4.83-MeV excited state. No excited state was found above 4.83 MeV up to the neutron threshold of 4.87 MeV in13B, therefore, the cascade decays to the 4.83-MeV excited state are unlikely to occur. On the other hand, th e cascade 7decay from the 4.83-MeV excited state is also small as explained below . The excited state (1/2+) is expected to decay to the ground state (3/2-) via anE1 transition, whose decay rate is proportional to the cube of the tr ansition The maximum possible transition energy to a known excited state is 1.4 MeV corresponding to the decay to the 3.48-MeV excited state. Even if the decay to this state is by E1 transition, its decay rate is about 40 times smaller than to the ground state. Decay rates other than E1 are also expected to be much smaller. In fact, no cascade decay of the 4.83-MeV excited state was observed in the present and the previous exper iments. There are few theoretical predictions for13B. In Ref. [19], the result of a shell model calculation for13B has been shown, however, the calculation Focusin structure, we performed a shell model calculation for13B(12Be) with the calculation code, OXBASH [28], wherein the interaction including the eff ect of the tensor force and reproducing intruder states in the neutr on-rich nuclei such as11,12Be [6], is used. The model space consisting of the psdshell with maximum 3(2)- hoexcitation was considered for13B(12Be). The was calculated as the overlap between each excited state o f13B and the ground state of12Be. The shell model calculation predicts four 1/2+states below 10 MeV excitation energy. Three lower states are predicted a t 3.7, 6.5 and 9.1 MeV with spectroscopic strengths of 0.01, 0.03 and 0.003, re strengths are too small to explain the experimental result. The fourth 1/2+state with a spectroscopic strength of 0.30 is close to the experime strength; however itsexcitation energy is9.5 MeV. These app roachbased on the effect of the tensor force does not explain the experimenta l result, or 8the model space consisting of the psdshell and the excitation of 3- hoare not large enough. A simple expression for the observed 1 /2+state with proton single particle nature is ( psd)112Be. Concerning the possible large deformation of12Be, we examine the qualitative consequence of a deformed core. The 1 /2+state arises with a configuration of ( p[2201 2])1to the12Be(g.s.) core. As seen in the Nilsson diagram, at large deformation, the p[2201 2] orbital gains energy. The energy gain of the total system compared to the spherical s1/2is estimated to be around 7 MeV from the diagram and the semi-empirical mass for mula with a of 0.5. The discrepancy between the shell model prediction mentioned above and the present result for the 1 /2+state is thus ascribed to a core deformation effect. In the present reaction, t he is considered to be populated by the transfer of a proton to the p[2201 2] orbital. Hence, the low excitation energy of the 1/2+state suggests a deformed mean field. Since the proton is transfered to the [2201 2] orbital by an s-wave ( L= 0), the spectroscopic factor of the spherical 2 s1/2component in the [2201 2] orbital, e.g.S= 0.273 atd= 0.4 [8], may also reproduce the experimental result. Based on the discussion above, the 1 /2+intruder state at 4.83 MeV is a signature of a deformed field and indicates the importance of a defo rmation in this nuclei. On the other hand, the ground state of13B is supposed to be spherical with a normal p-shell configuration [29]. The excitation of only one proton thus changes the structure of the an AMD calculation related to the experimentally assigned 1/ 2+
state of13B was carried out by Kanada-En'yo et al [30]. The calculation pre- 9dicts a largely deformed 1/2+
1state with proton 1- hoexcitation and In the excited state, the last proton occupies a molecu lars orbital which has a density distribution similar to the [2201 2] Nilsson orbital. The 1/2+
1state predicted by AMD may correspond to the experimental one although the calculated excitation energy is 8 MeV. In summary, we have studied the proton transfer reaction on12Be in A spin and parity of 1 /2+for the 4.83-MeV excited state in13B were assigned for the first time. A spectroscopic strength of 0 .20+-0.02 was also obtained with 60% systematic error. This state is interpreted t o be a proton intruder state from the sd-shell because of its non-normal parity and small Thenuclear asimplem echanism for the existence of such a low-lying proton intruder state. The pr esent study shows the importance of deformation for protonshell structure in and the change of the proton shell structure deu to the ex citation of one proton. We would like to thank the RIKEN Ring Cyclotron staff members for the ir operation during the experiment. The present work was partially su pported by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (No.15204018) by the M inistry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, of Wilkinson, et al., Phys. Rev. 113 (1959) 563. [2]H. Iwasaki, et al., Phys. Lett. B 491 (2000) 8. [3]H. Iwasaki, et al., Phys. Lett. B 481 (2000) 7. 10[4]S. Shimoura, et al., Phys. Lett. B 560 (2003) 31. [5]S. Shimoura, et al., Phys. Lett. B 654 (2007) 87. [6]T. Suzuki, et al., Phys. Rev. C 67 (2003) 044302. [7]I. Hamamoto, Nucl. Phys. A 731 (2004) 211. [8]A. Bohr, B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure, Vol. II, World S cientific (1998). [9]I. Hamamoto, S. Shimoura J. Phys. G 34 (2007) 2715 [10]S. Michimasa, et al., Phys. Lett. B 638 (2006) 146. [11]H. Ryuto, et al., Nucl. Instr. and Meth. A 555 (2005) 1. [12]T. Kubo, et al., Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 70 (1992) 309. [13]H. Kumagai, et al., Nucl. Instr. and Meth. A 470 (2001) 562. [14]S. Shimoura, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. A 525 (2004) 188. [15]M. Kurokawa, et al., IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NUCLEAR SCIENCE 50 (2003) 1309. [16]S. Agostinelli, et al., Nucl. Instr. and Meth. A 506 (2003) 25 0. [17]Geant4 a toolkit for the simulation of the passage of particl es through et al., Phys. Rev. C 17 (1978) 1283. [19]V. Guimar~ aes, et al., Phys. Rev. C 61 (2000) 064609. [20]N. Aoi, et al., Phys. Rev. C 66 (2002) 014301. [21]R. Kalpakchieva, et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 7 (2000) 451. [22]P. D. Kunz, computer code DWUCK5, unpublished . [23]G. R. Satchler, Phys. Rev. C 55 (1997) 285. 11[24]C. J. Horowitz, Computational Nuclear Physics, Vol. I, Spri nger-Verlag (1991). [25]C. J. Horowitz, Nucl. Phys. A 368 (1981) 503. [26]A. Ingemarsson, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 676 (2000) 3. [27]A. Ingemarsson, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 696 (2001) 3. [28]B. A. Brown, A. Etchegoyen, W. D. M. Rae, The computer code OXB ASH, MSU-NSCL report number 524 (1986). [29]T. Nagatomo, et al., Nucl. Phys. A 746 (2004) 509c [30]Y. Kanada-En'yo, et al., submitted to Phys. Rev C number (a.u.)10 11 12 13 14count Z=5 Fig. 1. Mass distribution of the outgoing particles for Z= 5 extracted from the correlation between TOF and Emeasured with the plastic scintillator hodoscope. 13 (keV)gE0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 2. Doppler corrected g-ray spectrum in coincidence with13B particles. The spectrum is decomposed with the sum of response functions of the GRAPE for and background grays. The resulting responce functions are summed. The response function for the background includ es the natrural back- ground and the decay of the12Be isomer (see the text). 14 (deg)cmth0 5 10 15 20 25 3. Angular distribution of the 4.83-MeV excited13B. Experimental data errors.Thesoli the DWBA predictions with assumptions of L= 0, 1, and 2, the text for more detail including the optical potential s. 15Table 1 List of the relative populations of the excited states. The i ntensities are normalized by the most intense population. The errors are statistical o nly. In the last column, the spins and parities which have been assigned in the previo us and present studies are listed. a:Present reaction b:11B (t,p)13B. c:9Be n. For the reaction b the relative intensity is atthlab= 10*and for the reaction e at thc.m.= 5.4*. Relative a b c d e Jp 3.48 0.19 +-0.05 0.06 0.60 +-0.14 3.53 0.20 +-0.05 0.19 1 3.68 0.74 +-0.07 0.38 1 3.71 0.68 +-0.07 0.25 4.13 0.49 +-0.04 1 0.04 +-0.04 4.83 1 0.03 1 1/2+
16
|
0807.0478
|
Shinsuke Ota
|
S. Ota, S. Shimoura, H. Iwasaki, M. Kurokawa, S. Michimasa, N. Aoi, H.
Baba, K. Demichi, Z. Elekes, T. Fukuchi, T. Gomi, S. Kanno, S. Kubono, K.
Kurita, H. Hasegawa, E. Ideguchi, N. Iwasa, Y.U. Matsuyama, K.L. Yurkewicz,
T. Minemura, T. Motobayashi, T. Murakami, M. Notani, A. Odahara, A. Saito, H.
Sakurai, E. Takeshita, S. Takeuchi, M. Tamaki, T. Teranishi, Y. Yanagisawa,
K. Yamada and M. Ishihara
|
Low-lying Proton Intruder State in 13B
|
16 pages, 3 figures
|
Phys.Lett.B666:311-314,2008
|
10.1016/j.physletb.2008.07.081
| null |
nucl-ex
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The neturon rich nucleus 13B was studied via the proton transfer reaction
4He(12Be,13B \gamma) at 50AMeV. The known 4.83-MeV excited state was strongly
populated and its spin and parity were assigned to 1/2+ by comparing the
angular differential cross section data with DWBA calculations. This low-lying
1/2+ state is interpreted as a proton intruder state and indicates a
deformation of the nucleus.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 3 Jul 2008 02:49:57 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Ota",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Shimoura",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Iwasaki",
"H.",
""
],
[
"Kurokawa",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Michimasa",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Aoi",
"N.",
""
],
[
"Baba",
"H.",
""
],
[
"Demichi",
"K.",
""
],
[
"Elekes",
"Z.",
""
],
[
"Fukuchi",
"T.",
""
],
[
"Gomi",
"T.",
""
],
[
"Kanno",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Kubono",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Kurita",
"K.",
""
],
[
"Hasegawa",
"H.",
""
],
[
"Ideguchi",
"E.",
""
],
[
"Iwasa",
"N.",
""
],
[
"Matsuyama",
"Y. U.",
""
],
[
"Yurkewicz",
"K. L.",
""
],
[
"Minemura",
"T.",
""
],
[
"Motobayashi",
"T.",
""
],
[
"Murakami",
"T.",
""
],
[
"Notani",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Odahara",
"A.",
""
],
[
"Saito",
"A.",
""
],
[
"Sakurai",
"H.",
""
],
[
"Takeshita",
"E.",
""
],
[
"Takeuchi",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Tamaki",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Teranishi",
"T.",
""
],
[
"Yanagisawa",
"Y.",
""
],
[
"Yamada",
"K.",
""
],
[
"Ishihara",
"M.",
""
]
] |
X - 2 NOVOTRYASOV AND STEPANOV: INTENSIFICATION OF INTERNAL KEL VIN T(0C)Depth (m) 0 2 4 6 8 10 12-0.200.2Speed (m/s) 0 2 4 6 810 12 14 16 18010 Time (day)Temp. 1. (a) Study area on the Japan/East Sea shelf, September 1999, 2004. The mooring location in 2004 is shown in Arabic. The circle indicates the mooring loca- tion in 1999 and the location of the mooring vessel, from which hourly casts were conducted on September, 1999, 2004. (b) Daily mean vertical profiles of temperature N. curve) and zonal (heavy curve) components of the current at the 35-m depth in autumn 1999. (d) Record of the temperature variations at the mooring buoy 1 in autumn 2004. of the Japan/East Sea in 1999 year. The records of current meter collected from a mooring deployed water depth 40 m, during 2 weeks in September (Figure 1a). To gauge temper- ature, speed and direction of currents, the buoy was instru- mented with the Russian-made POTOK integral instrument at a depth of 35 meters. The POTOK had a resolution of 0.05*C. The sampling rate was 15 minutes. The time series of the meridional (light curve) andzonal fromthis moor- ing are shown on Figure 1c. The Canadian Guideline CTD profiler was used for the vertical profiling of water. The hydrostatic pressure, temperature and electric conductiv ity of seawater were measured during profiling. The profiling errors were no greater than 0.01*C in temperature and 0.02 psu in salinity. Figure 1b shows the mean temperature and buoyancy frequency profiles for the study site. Details of this experiment (results, methods of their processing, etc .) were reported by Novotraysov, et. al [2003]. In the second experiment, measurements of internal wave band temperature fluctuations were performed during 18 days starting 3 September 2004. The time records of tem- perature were collected from two moorings deployed along the coastline at a distance of 800m from it, approximately at 40m depth and separated by a distance of 5.5 km from each other. The first of them was deployed at 28m depth and the second one, at 35m depth (below the surface). The moor- ings were equipped with digital thermographs made by the Russian manufacturer. The devices had a measuring pre- cision of 0.05*C for temperature. The sampling rate was 1 minutes. The temperature and salinity vertical profiles wer e performed on 20-21 September, from a vessel anchored be- tween the moorings with the Canadian Guideline CTD pro- filer. In total, 25 hourly casts were made.The obtained data were analyzed by unified techniques [ Emery and Thomson , 1997]. The ap- proach involved (i) the elimination of low-frequency compo - nents with a Tukey's cosine filter, (ii) the splitting of the resulting series into nine 37.2-hour segments (three semid i- urnal tidal periods each), (iii) the calculation and averag ing of spectral densities by segments, and (iv) the smoothing of the averaged spectral densities by a five-point Tukey's fil- ter. The number of degrees of freedom in the to approximately 10 for the first experiment and 20 for the second, providing a reasonable reliability of the results of spectral analysis. 3. The model A spectrum model of nonlinear interactions among inter- nal Kelvin waves is developed. It is assumed that H/l1, andA/H1, where His the water depth, lis a character- istic wave-length, Ais a representative wave amplitude. The basic component of this model is the simple wave equation. For the first most powerful mode of the waves the equation is written as u/x-auu/t = 0, (1) whereu(t,x) is the alongshore current, xis a horizontal co- ordinate, t=t-x/c,tis time. The parameters aand care the coefficient of nonlinearity and the phase speed of long internal waves, respectively. Parameter of nonlinear ity is determined by the background density and is related in the Boussinesq approximation a vertical coordinate, positive upward. The phase speedcand the amplitude function of the wave mode ph(z) are determined from the solution of the eigenvalue 0, (3) with boundary condition ph(-H) =ph(0) = 0, (4) and with the 1. (5) Equation (1) is a basic model for study of Kelvin Let us consider interaction nonlinear Kelvin wave with frequency o0(tidalotor inertial oi) and narrow- band synoptic noise (later SN) with frequency ohm o0using the spectrum model of nonlinear internal waves described in terms of the equation (1). Let the alongshore current u(x,t) at the boundary of the coastal area x= 0 be the superposi- tion of internal wave with frequency o0, amplitude A0and the noise th(t) with typical frequency g << o 0 u(t,x= 0) =u0(t) =A0cos AND STEPANOV: INTENSIFICATION OF INTERNAL KEL VIN WAVES X - (relative (cph)0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 (cph) Figure 2. (a) Normalized clockwise rotary spectra of currents versus for current measured at 35-m depth in autumn 2004 near the Gamov peninsula. The numerical digits over pea ks are their periods (h). (b) The increased fragment of the spectrum in the surrounding of the semidiurnal frequency. D ark numerals 12.2; 6.2; 4.3 are carrier periods (h). whereph- is a random phase with uniform distribution in the interval [ -p,+p]. We confine our analysis to the wave evolution stage, which is characterized by condition x < x *, where x*=
(aA0o0)-1. In this stage the front Kelvin wave appears and it is not accompanied by generation of internal solitons. We introduce parameter d=x/x*, which determine the similar- ity between a Kelvin shock-wave and the wave and consider the case d <1. For this case the spectral density of the equation (7) we can affirm that the first term is the spectral density of the synoptic oscillations and the secon d term is the spectral density of the Kelvin waves distorted by the synoptic oscillations. We consider the spectral composition of the Kelvin wave near of the harmonics with the number nof the carrier fre- quencyo0. Given that go0we make replacement oat no0in the exponential rate of the equation (7). Then we obtain the equation for the harmonic with number n un(t,x) (8) and her amplitude depending on the parameter = 2Jn(nd)A0/nd. (9) From the equation (9), we can affirm that the amplitude of the harmonic is decreased with increasing of the more detailed spectral analysis of the nonlin- ear Kelvin waves, when the synoptic noise consists of regula r0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 12.4h 11.4h10h (cph)Spt/s2 (relative units) Figure 3. Normalized spectrum versus for record of the temperature variations at the mooring buoy 1 in autumn 2004 near the Gamov peninsula. The numerical digits over peaks are their periods (h). and stochastic components: th(t) =acos(ohmt) +thns(t). Let the amplitude of the phase modulation related with M=anohmxis small, that is M1. Let the Kelvin waves have narrow-band spectrum, and the synoptic noise width go0, besides the noise, amplitude and phase of Kelvin waves have Gaussian distribution. In this case the correlation function of the harmonic with number ntaking into account the equation (8) is Bn(t,x) =Dph(t) + Here Dphis the structure function of the Kelvin wave phase,X - 4 NOVOTRYASOV AND STEPANOV: INTENSIFICATION OF INTERNAL KEL VIN WAVES Table 1. The periods of the peaks of the temperature variations spect rum (digit numerals) and the calculated periods 10.8 12.4 14.5 14.7 17.8 22.6 8.0 8.9 10.0 84 11.0 12.4 14.5 15.0 17.5 22.5 8.0 8.7 10.0 168 11.5 12.4 13.4 16.1 17.8 19.9 8.5 8.9 9.4 168 11.5 12.4 13.0 16.2 17.5 - 8.5 8.7 9.5 Bns(t) =< the correlation function of the synoptic noise. We perform the Fourier transform of the correlation function Bn(t,x) and obtain the formula for the spectrum of the harmonic Sn(o;x) equation (10), we can affirm that spectrum of the wave have harmonics with frequencies no0as well as har- monics with sum and dif frequencies o+-=no0+-ohm and am- plitudes increasing with growth of distance traversed by th e wave. This means that at the coastal zone between Kelvin waves and synoptic noise takes place nonlinear interaction , which is accompanied by intensification Kelvin waves with side frequencies o+-=no0+-ohm. 4. Discussion and Conclusion Let us turn to the records of the current velocity. Fig- ure 1c presents records smoothed by Tukey window with the width 1 h of the meridional (light curve) and zonal (heavy curve) components of the current in the coastal zone of Japan/East Sea in autumn 1999 year. It is of interest to note a low-frequency component of the variation in the record of the current velocity. Let us analyze circular rota ry current component with the rotary spectral analysis [ Emery and Thomson , 1997]. The spectrum of the clockwise rotary (CWR) component of the velocity is S-(o) = the one-sided autospectra of the u andvCartesian components of the velocity and Quvis the quadrature spectrum between the two components. These spectra were determined by unified statistical spectral tec h- niques using the algorithms presented in [ Emery and Thom- son, 1997]. The spectra have N degrees of freedom, where N>=10. Figure 2a shows the CWR spectrum of currents versus log onormalized by maximal value. It is of interest to note the groups of the well defined significant spectral peaks in the surrounding of the semidiurnal frequency andher 1,2,3 and 4 harmonics. Our estimations show that the magnitudes of these spectral peaks interrelated with numbe r harmonics by the approximate : 2 : 3 : 4 : 5 (with error <20%). There are two peaks with light and heavy tops at the rep- resentative frequencies ohm 1~1/64 and ohm 2~1/102 (cph) in the low-frequency band of the spectra. Figure 2b presents the increased fragment of the spec- trum in the surrounding of the semidiurnal frequency. It is of interest to note a significant well defined spectral peak at theos= 1/12.2 (cph) frequency surrounded by side peaks with dark end light tops. Not hard to make sure that the frequencies of these picks are determined by error equals of experimental er- ror uncertainty. In particularly the strong spectral peak a t the difference frequency o-= 1/12.2-1/64 (cph) suggests that the motion in study region is dominated by not only the tide movements, but and the inertial movements. The pick at the frequency oi= 1/17.7 (cph) is formed by the inertial movements. Thus the spectrum has fine structure in the band 1/14 - 1/16.5 (cph), which don't segregate with help our dates and methods of analyses. Letus consider insurround- ings of the harmonics of semidiurnal frequency os(Fig- ure 2b). As in the past picks at the carrier surrounded by side picks at the are determined by formula spectral analysis of the clockwise rotary velocity shows that her spectrum is determined by oscillations with the tidal frequency os1/12.2 (cph) and the (cph) from synoptic band and also that spectrum has the fine structure in the neighborhood of the frequency oswith side peaks at the frequencies, which are determined by formula similar struc- ture has spectrum in the neighborhood of the first and the second harmonics of the semidiurnal frequency records of thetemperature of thecoastal water of Japan/East sea collected in autumn 2004 year. Figure 3 shows the averaged spectrum of the collected from two moorings and normalized by the maximum value of the spectrum. Spectra are calculated by unified standard spectral techniques [ Emery and Thomson , 1997]. The number of freedom degrees amounted to approx- imately 20. Of particular interest are the groups of the peaks at the inertial frequency and her first har- monic and also the peaks in the surrounding of the semidi- urnal frequency os.NOVOTRYASOV AND STEPANOV: INTENSIFICATION OF INTERNAL KEL VIN WAVES X - 5 Arabic numerals over spectral peaks equal the periods (hour) of these peaks. These periods (h) are placed in the Table 1. Digit numerals equal the periods of the spectral peaks and light numerals equal the periods calculated by the formula 1 /o+-= indicated by Table 1 the periods of the spectral peaks and the periods calculated by the formula have approxi- mately equal values. Thus the spectral analysis of cur- rent and temperature meter records of the Japan/East Sea coastal water shows that the spectrum is determined by oscillations with frequencies of near inertial oi1/17.8 (cph) and tidal os1/12.2 (cph) frequencies as well as the frequencies ohm 1,21/72,106 (cph) from synoptic band. The analysis shows that the spectrum has the fine struc- ture in the neighborhood of the frequencies oi,swith side picks at the frequencies, which are determined by The similar structure has spectrum in the neighborhood of the first harmonics of the inertial frequenc y oi. As aconclusion, we showed nose with representative frequency ohm ooccur the parametric interaction, i.e. among the low-frequency band and high-frequency band of internal Kelvin waves occur the energy exchange. Hence, as a result of nonlinear interactio n the energy of internal Kelvin waves in the coastal and trop- ical oceans can grow at the expense of the nose work was supported by the Presidential Grant No. MK- 1364.2008.5 by the Prezidium of the Russian Academy of Sci- ences (Program Mathematical methods in nonlinear dynamic s. Project No. W. J., and R. E. Thomson (1997), Data Analysis Methods in Physical Oceanography , 634 pp., Pergamon, New York. Brink, K. H. (1991), Coastal-trapped waves and wind-driven cur- rents over the continental shelf Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech., 23 J. A., and the ATOS Group (1999), A review of recent results on ocean acoustic wave propagation in random media: Basin scales, IEEE J. Oceanic Eng., 24 , A. V., and W. K. Melville (1995), Propagation and breaking of nonlinear Kelvin waves, J. Phys. Oceanogr., 25 A.V., W. Hydraulic jumpsatbou nd- aries in rotating fluids, J. Fluid Mech., 324 , 55-82. Fedorov, A. V., W. K. Melville (2000), Kelvin fronts on the eq ua- torial thermocline, J. Phys. Oceanogr., 30 , A., and V. Novotryasov (2005), Features of the nonl inear wave spectrum in the coastal zone, Geophiys. Res. Lett., 32 , L15602, doi: A., and V. Novotryasov (2007), On a spectrum of non- linear internal waves in the oceanic coastal zone, Nonlin. Pro- cesses Geophys., 14 , S.N., A.N. Malakhov, and A.I. Saichev (1990), Nonlin- ear Random Waves in Media with Zero Dispersion , 215 pp., Nauka, K.R., A.C. Kuo, L.J. Pratt (1999), Nonlinear Ross by adjustment in a channel, J. Fluid Mech., 390 , 187-222. Hibiya, T., Y. Niwa and K. Fujiwara (1998), Numerical experi - ments of nonlinear energy transfer within the oceanic inter nal wave spectrum, J. Geophys. Res., 103 , M. J. (1978), it Waves in Fluids, 504 pp., Cambrid ge University Press, UK. Novotryasov, V. V., N. S. Vanin, A. A. Karnaukhov (2005), Man - ifestation of nonlinear properties of Kelvin internal wave s in the coastal zone of the sea of Japan, Izv. Atm. and 41 , S.G. (1990), El Ni~ no, La Ni~ na and the Southern Os- cillation , 293 pp., Academic Press, New York. Polzin, K. L., J. M. Toole and R. W. Schmitt (1995), of turbulent disspation, J. Phys. Oceanogr., 25, 306-328. Reznik, G.M. and R. Grimshaw (2002), Nonlinear geostrophic ad- justment in the presence of a boundary, J. Fluid Mechanics, 471, 257-283. Vadim Novotryasov, V.I.Il'ichev Pacific Oceanological Ins ti- tute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 43 Baltiiskaya Stre et, 690041 Vladivostok, Russia. Stepanov, V.I.Il'ichev Pacific Oceanological Inst itute of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 43 Baltiiskaya Street, 6 Russia.
|
0807.0479
|
Stepanov Dmitriy
|
Vadim Novotryasov and Dmitriy Stepanov
|
Parametric interaction and intensification of nonlinear Kelvin waves
|
5 pages, 3 figures
| null | null | null |
physics.ao-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Observational evidence is presented for nonlinear interaction between
mesoscale internal Kelvin waves at the tidal -- $\omega_t$ or the inertial --
$\omega_i$ frequency and oscillations of synoptic -- $\Omega $ frequency of the
background coastal current of Japan/East Sea. Enhanced coastal currents at the
sum -- $\omega_+ $ and dif -- $\omega_-$ frequencies: $\omega_\pm
=\omega_{t,i}\pm \Omega$ have properties of propagating Kelvin waves suggesting
permanent energy exchange from the synoptic band to the mesoscale $\omega_\pm $
band. The interaction may be responsible for the greater than predicted
intensification, steepen and break of boundary trapped and equatorially trapped
Kelvin waves, which can affect El Ni\~{n}o. The problem on the parametric
interaction of the nonlinear Kelvin wave at the frequency $\omega $ and the
low-frequency narrow-band nose with representative frequency $\Omega\ll\omega $
is investigated with the theory of nonlinear week dispersion waves.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 3 Jul 2008 04:24:55 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-04T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Novotryasov",
"Vadim",
""
],
[
"Stepanov",
"Dmitriy",
""
]
] |
2Statements in our model are organized into a network. While statements considered true are the points, links are logical connections or associations that are either positive (+1), negative (-1), or neutral (0). These weights are the only attributes of the undirected links. Rules of the structuring (automatic processes like in connectionist networks) are given: linking takes place on a probabilistic basis (for the need of a probabilistic system see Pleh, 1998). Points with a great number of connections strongly attract new links. The evolving network structure affects the way new statements are integrated or rejected and the further evolution of the belief network. Linking processes are decomposed into time steps. The stressed importance of network structure and time may recall connectionist theories, while the sequential mechanism used (single processes in time flow) is similar to the classical propositional idea. We agree that symbolic and connectionist representations complement each other (Eysenck and Keane, 2005). While classically knowledge was conceived as a list of statements and connectionists contended that it was encoded in network patterns (and points were deemed to be meaningless), we claim that it is fruitful to use a network of statements for a representation of opinion systems. Let us declare at the outset that our model is a theoretical construct. There is at present no unequivocal proof for its relevance that will satisfy all skeptics. Nor is it obvious what conclusive evidence could be obtained. Although we accept that none of the examples by itself proves the existence of the phenomenon, we hope that when they are taken together - like weak fibers woven into a rope - the total structure will bear weight. THE MODEL Having seen the basic context, we outline the model in two parts. First we draft the main definitions and static parameters, then dynamic parameters and the mechanism of changes is static 1: A network is a complex system of vertices (or points) and 2: A vertex (or point) is a statement considered true. Definition 3: A link is a logical connection or any kind of association. The first definition is unambiguous, but two short comments can be helpful regarding opinion networks. First it is obvious that each of us has a different network with different points and link structures. Secondly it worth mentioning that if something is not represented in such a network, then the given person has no opinion concerning this information. The other definitions need some further are simple statements; a compound statement is represented as more simple statements linked together. Vertices may contain any kind of information: facts and beliefs are handled in a uniform way. (Practically, it is not easy to distinguish facts and beliefs, provided we may talk about facts.) We claim that our system involves local truth as a driving force (this is in fact soft relativism in cognitive science, for further details see Meiland and Krausz, 1982). That is the reason for using belief systems and opinion networks as synonyms. The conduciveness of this approach can be supported by experimental studies: a great example of reasoning fallacies, the myside bias, and interactions between opinions and factual information is the article of Macpherson and Stanovich, 2007. Links may be logical connections: one statement is a consequence of another, two statements are contradicting etc. Another possibility is that links are built on an associative 3basis: two statements have similar topics, subjects, subjectives etc., or there are emotional liaisons, grammatical similarities, even sub-symbolic connections. In a static case, vertices are characterized by their degree parameter: 1. Degree: ik- the number of connections of vertex i Links are characterized by their one attribute: 2. Weights +1, 0 and -1 show whether the linked vertices are in positive, neutral or negative connection. (This scale can be made more precise in a later version of the model.) A short description of these factors may be useful here: Degree is simply the number of statements connected with the given vertex. A central statement is connected to a huge number of other statements; peripheral statements are linked to only a few others. Links are positive, negative or neutral: two vertices are more solid together (+1), they rather impair each other (-1), or they are independent (0) like two facts about the same topic. Positive links strengthen the network; points help each other to remain in the system. Negative links stress the network and act towards a collision. These effects will play important role in the system's dynamics. Dynamic mechanism and parameters As we strive to give account of dynamic processes and use simulation results of a computer code (available at ), a correct presentation of dynamics is inevitable. The main definitions of network dynamics are the 4: An input is a new point for the network (with non-existing 5: At a certain time one and only one point of the network is active (it has a distinguished role in dynamic 6: A time step is a discrete time interval for elementary changes in the network. (Detailed elucidation is given 7: In every time step n links randomly vanish. (This random process can be interpreted as forgetting (Bednorz and Schuster, 8: A vertex losing all its links vanishes. Main dynamic parameters driving all processes: 3. Compatibility factor of a vertex: ig- gives the probability that the given vertex is in positive (strengthening) connection with a randomly chosen vertex - a number between 0 and 1 4. Contradiction factor of a vertex: ih- gives the probability that the given vertex is in negative (weakening) connection with a randomly chosen vertex - a number between 0 and 145. Fitness factor of a vertex: if- shows how much a vertex takes part in linking processes (compared to other vertices with the same number of connections) - a number between 0 and 1. (If 0if then this vertex never makes connections, if 1if then it is maximally capable of linking.) 6. Negativity tolerance (consistency) of the network: H- shows what proportion of the connections of a certain vertex can be negative - a number between 0 and 1, global parameter. If the proportion of negative links is proved to exceed H, the vertex is ejected. Some remarks about these and contradiction factors show how much a certain point fits in the network: if we believe in something and our network treats an inconsistent point, than g is small and h is big. There are neutral connections, so 1i ihg does not hold for every i. Fitness factors allow newcomers to become richer in links than elder points. If one point has 51k links and fitness factor of 1 . 01f and another vertex has 12k link and 5 . 02f then an input is linked to each of them with an equal probability. If we did not use fitness factors, then the older vertices would always dominate the networks. The importance of older vertices holds true even by the usage of fitness factors, but in this case changes in the order of significance are permitted. For a correct mathematical description see Appendix A. Negativity tolerance is a crucial factor: if 0H , then no contradictions may occur, just as in the network of some mentally ill people. On the other hand, 1H resembles the case of schizophrenic belief systems. Here we point out that there are two different ways of vertex ejection in the model: one due to the loss of links and another due to an inadmissibly high ratio of negative links. Having defined all the needed notions and parameters we are ready to delineate rules in opinion networks. These rules impose different kinds of changes: new links are formulated other links vanish, points are integrated others losing all their connections processes are deemed to depict the way we organize our opinion always takes place in the vicinity of an active point: linking and checking procedures start there causing vertex integration and/or ejection. An active point is considered to be a statement one is currently thinking about. There are two mainly different cases: input processing, when a new point containing unknown information is built in; and active point processing that is the general case for network structuring starting from already existing active points. Input processing starts when an input arrives and takes activity. (Here we see that the notion of active point includes the one of input: all inputs are active points for a certain time.) The first step of input processing is preferential attachment: links are established between the input and vertices of the network. The probability of the formulation of a new link is directly proportional to the degree of the existing vertex and to its fitness factor. If all links are built of an input (an input carries a given number of links), then the types of the established links are decided in a second step in accordance with the input's compatibility and A consistency test is run in a third step. It is checked whether the ratio of negative links does not exceed the negativity tolerance limit )(Hfor any of the points. If there is a vertex with an unadmittable proportion of negative links, then it is ejected. Special cases and a possible chain of tests are elucidated in Appendix A. As the sum of link-weights controls 5changes regarding statements considered true and this sum is decisive whether statements remain in the network or they are ejected we may speak about local truth as a driving force. If a point (the former input) is linked in, it becomes a point of the network. If the point is still active (that is time-dependent), there is a further linking process. The mechanism to treat existing points in the network (viz. thinking processes) is the following. A two step random walk on the network starts from the active point. Random walks are weighted with the fitness factors, i.e. the probability to reach a certain neighbor is proportional to its fitness factor. We reach a vertex and link it with the active point. (One time step is needed till this point.) Then there is a decision based on the compatibility and contradiction factors of the input, whether the link is positive, negative or neutral. Then comes the consistency test. (Ending in one time step if there are not too many negative links and no ejection is needed but consuming much time if a chain of tests is needed due to vertex ejections.) Two step random walks, linking and consistency tests are repeated till time runs out (e.g. a subsequent input arrives). According to the scale-free structure and small world property various formulations may grow up, and time devoted to a vertex highly influences its future role in the network. Details are elucidated in the next AND features In this section we analyze networks given by the former mechanism from a structural point of view. First, we ascertain that there is very a special parameter setting: if all fitness factors are equal, all links are positive, no time is given for random walks (time is devoted to consecutive input processing procedures), and there is no random edge removal (forgetting), then we obtain scale-free distributions (Barabasi and Albert, 1999). The degree distribution of a scale- free network is a power-law decay (details in Appendix B). If we use logarithmic scales, we get linear decay. (Throughout the article logarithmic plots are used for degree scale-free distributions are central to our investigations we show that if we do not use any of our parameters, we get back the original Barabasi model (Fig. 1a), and that scale-free structure is kept even if we use all parameters (Fig. 1b). In the latter case inputs had more links, uniformly distributed fitness factors, and equal chances for contradiction, compatibility and neutrality ( 3 / 1 1 i i i i hg h g ), moreover time was given for linking processes. Negativity tolerance was chosen to be 2 / 1H and even random link removal was settings and details about all figures are given in Appendix B.)6Fig.1. Scale-free degree distributions 1 10 of 1a. Degree distribution of the Barabasi model1 10 100 network - Type 1 General network - Type 2Number of 1b. Degree distribution of our model with general settings These simulation results prove that the two structures are essentially the same. Consequences of this observation are far-reaching since preferentially built scale-free structures have special characteristics as outlined in the world The first structural feature resembling common experience about belief networks is small worldness. It is an everyday observation that associations in our mind may lead very far in a few steps. In terms of networks this feature is called small world property. The diameter (average shortest distance between two randomly chosen points) of a small world network is incomparably smaller than the number of points, the order of magnitudes widely differs (Albert, Jeong, and Barabasi, 1999). The small world characteristic makes an flow of thoughts possible. Thus, we expect a model encompassing small world 2. Diameter as a function of network size 1 10 100 100001234 Barabasi-Albert network Our network, General Type 2Diameter of the network Network size7Fig. 2 shows simulation results: the average distance between two points in a network of 1000 points is approximately 4,1 in the original Barabasi network and 2,7 in a general version of our networks. Clearly, in keeping with the expectations, the model produces small network The second expected feature given by simulations is scale-freeness. The distribution itself means that the number of statements of a given importance obeys a power-law. (Here we note that importance and the degree of a point are not equivalent e.g. because it is also interesting how central they are concerning walks on the network, though, to a first approximation we use degree distributions to capture importance.) No single supreme thought is present in a healthy mind and the few very important core statements are closely followed by others. We can always find more and more statements of slightly smaller importance till we arrive to the most populous periphery. Scale-free distribution implies that opinion systems obey Pareto's 80/20 law. As expected, the majority of time is devoted to a minority of statements in our structures are robust: if a randomly chosen point is removed, it usually does not affect system behavior, as disappearing points are usually peripheral. However, error tolerance comes at a high price in that these networks are extremely vulnerable to attacks (that is, to the selection and removal of a few nodes playing a vital role in maintaining the network's connectivity) (Albert, Jeong, and Barabasi, 2000, p. 378). We argue that our belief systems work in this way: the loss of peripheral statements does not mean much for the network, but attacks against core opinions may ruin the system causing serious psychological problems. (If conceiving thinking as a random walk on a network of thoughts, we always encounter routes crossing large centers; if they are attacked, a number of walks are spoilt.) As our networks are scale-free, we obtain error tolerance and attack fact that we imagine opinion systems as preferentially evolving scale-free and Albert, 1999; Barabasi, 2002) should not be stunning for several reasons. First, it is shown that words in human language linked by co-occurrence in sentences form a scale- free network with small world characteristic (Cancho and Sole, 2001). Secondly, small world and scale-free properties also appear in conceptual networks where similarities of concepts connect words of a language (Motter, de Moura, Lai, and Daspguta, 2002). Moreover, the same features hold for cognitive maps (Ozesmi and Tan, 2006). If we conceive texts as linearized versions of subnetworks, we may also refer to strong correlations between text quality and complex network features (Antiqueiraa, Nunesa, Oliveira, and da Costa, 2007). Finally, the principle of preferential attachment also seems to be reasonable: people associate to statements that are strongly represented in their networks. Anomalies from scale-free structures do not prevail in some cases: in the beginning when the network consists of a small number of points, our structures rather resemble random networks. On the contrary, if a point with a high fitness factor is present star shaped networks may occur. Such environment dependent transitions are generally observed in networks (Derenyi, Farkas, Palla, and Vicsek, 2004). The former case (random network) can be interpreted as an immature, not well structured system that is characteristic for the inception of development processes. (Apparently, a small number of points can not form a scale-free degree distribution due to statistical reasons, but as the number of points grows scale-free distribution emerges.) The latter (star shaped network) is something completely different: 8there is a statement of unique importance in a network. This leads to a conformation that determines behavior: the exceptional point gathers a large number of links, most random walks go that way, and that point will be the absolute center as shown in Fig. 3. (The peak in the right is not a single point with a probability of 1 but approximately 100 points close to each other with probabilities of approximately 0.01, as the average of 10000 simulations is depicted in the figure. Colors indicate different simulations: the ordinal number of the special point was modified from 1 to 32.) Fig. 3. Degree distribution of a star shaped network 1 10 100 point: 1st Special point: 32ndNumber of could it mean in reality? As random walks cross the exceptional point extremely often, a star shaped structure hampers sufficient thinking. Instead of reaching vertices more or less proportionately (e.g. according to a scale-free distribution), we always get back to the center. Vertices of lower degrees are unlikely to be linked, normal system behavior and structuring are inhibited, and significant changes are improbable. This polarization can be observed in many areas as pointed out by Lord, Ross and Lepper in 1979. Politics, racism, and private life are all fields of star network conformation. Often, there is absolutely no chance to integrate certain statements in a network, see political views. Too strong (usually emotional) centers lead to a grotesque case: for instance people evaluate information in the mirror of political parties and not the parties in the mirror of information. (It is shown that emotions play a decisive role in political reasoning, see Westen, Kilts, Blagov, Harenski, and Hamann, 2006) This is a typical devastating effect of a star shaped subnetwork: new information are connected to the center and only allowed to remain in the network if there is a non-negative link between them. Similarly, there are conflict zones in private life: we know which part of the network should not be activated so as to avoid conflicts. Usually, star shaped structures are problematic parts of opinion encompassed phenomena A major advantage of the outlined model is that it inherently encompasses phenomena emerging in a diverse range of everyday life. In the followings we show particular of the model that can be matched to observations of reality. Crucial early points9First, it is a common experience that statements accepted in an early phase of opinion system formulation are of huge importance. In other words, first stimuli have a massive effect on our future way of thinking and it is not easy to remove old, entrenched ideas from belief systems. Here we may refer to upbringing of children and the stressed importance of early inputs largely determining mentality (Dawson, Ashman, and Carver, 2000). It is often argued that lots of psychological problems stem from early ages - when incorrect centers are built in, we claim. As a smaller scale example: if we first meet someone and thus a new part of the system arises, first impressions have great importance. In our model all these effects are deemed to be manifestations of based on preferential attachment, where early vertices are of great importance, being located at the high degree end of degree distribution (Barabasi, 2002). For an illustration, see Fig. 4. Fig. 4. Degree of points by their sequential order 1 10 100 1000110100 Barabasi-Albert network Our network (General, Type number of the points Time as a determinant of it is unquestionable that time plays an essential role in the formulation of belief systems. Advertisers try to capitalize the fact that the more time is given to process an input, the bigger is the probability that it gets integrated and becomes a center. Besides, people who are rarely stimulated (and thus have much time for each input) are greatly affected by the few stimuli, these vertices become centers. These effects are included in our model: the more time is given to a vertex, the more connections it will build and the higher degree it will reach. Extremely long processing times lead to extreme degrees as shown in Fig. 5. Apparently, the peak refers to the high degree of a single point while other points have much lower degrees. (Again, the peak in the right is not a single point with a probability of 1 but approximately 100 points close to each other with probabilities of approximately 0.01, as the average of 10000 simulations is depicted in the figure.)10Fig. 5. Degree distribution of a star shaped network with extremely long time 1 10 of as a measure of robustness In a third section we analyze possibilities of changes in opinion structures. There is an enormous difference between statement integration chances if developed and undeveloped belief networks are juxtaposed with one another. New ideas may swiftly achieve great significance in an immature network but are not likely to lead to drastic changes in massively diversified, highly developed structures. Children and illiterate people are strongly exposed to fanatic ideas while academic professors usually do not commit suicide attacks. Children are gullible while old people are sometimes unable to integrate new information. These are natural consequences of network size in the model. Once again, drawing parallel between significance of a statement and its actual place in the degree distribution (how many links does a point have compared with the others) we can assert that points (e.g. with a relatively high fitness factor) reach higher levels of significance more easily in networks containing less points and edges. This effect is represented in Fig. 6. By smaller sizes, the attacker point can achieve maximal degree in the network while by greater sizes the maximal degree is significantly larger than the attacker's degree. (Please note that we use logarithmic scales.) Fig. 6. Influence on different sized networks 10 100 100010100 Degree of the attacker point Maximal degree in the of the network11Elder, highly qualified people usually have more developed networks as it follows from the previous arguments about the role of time, so their degree distribution is wider, they have more vertices with large numbers of links. Obviously, it is not easy for newcomers to attain such high degrees what is an explanation for the above mentioned experiences. On the other hand, networks with a smaller number of vertices and less connections are more easily affected by novelties. Though, there are a number of different ways of change that are under study in the following three - optimal input for instance is a changing mechanism of pivotal importance. While classically it was deemed to be the sheer enlisting of a new statement and connectionists described learning with changing weights of links, we combine the two approaches. The appearance of new statements and the construction of links (viz. structuring) jointly explain the way we learn. Our model precisely reproduces some nontrivial observations. Again, we start from a large scale example. It is well known from international surveys that Prussian school systems, where a comprehensive knowledge is offered and large amounts of facts are taught (so there are lots of inputs) produce an excellent elite class and a poor average (OECD, 2004a). That can be underpinned by the model behavior: the complexity of an evolving network heavily depends on the linking capability of the student. (This can be interpreted as the real time equivalent of a time step in the model: those who learn or think faster need less time in reality to perform steps of linking and checking procedures.) Without sufficient linking capabilities information is useless, they form rapidly vanishing islands. Further information have no vertices where they could link to, the network does not improve. That happens to most children in a Prussian-type school: they just do not have enough time for structuring. (The previous quite general statement pertaining to overall performance relies on the fact that e.g. text understanding - that is clearly strongly related to linking capability - is remarkably correlated with overall performance (OECD, 2004b).) In contrast, sufficient linking capability plus a huge amount of vertices expedites structuring: the number of possible links rises very fast with a growing number of vertices allowing optimal this case differentiated education is introduced in several schools: learning (linking) methods are taught for those who require it and information for the others who are ready to integrate. Here we reach a smaller scale problem: similarly to school systems, efficiency of individual lectures is by large determined by its speed. Frequency of inputs (the amount of information given in a time period) determines performance. Our model gives account of this feature: starting from a given network, working with nonzero random link removal and fixing the number of time steps available there is an optimal number of points to be given in the time period to reach a maximum number of integrated vertices after the process. The number of points in the network after the learning process is depicted in Fig. 7. The original network consisted of 1000 points and 1000 links (2 links for each point on average); the number of added points varied between 10 and 100, the number of available time steps was fixed to be 1000. Fig. 7. The effect of input frequency on learning120 20 40 60 80 of the network after the learning proceess Number of points added in the given time Obviously, it is worth building more connections if there is a danger of losing access paths due to forgetting. Moreover, the constructed topology determines resistance against random link removal. If we build a linear network with statements linked only to the subsequent statement as it often happens in history lessons, then large parts of the curriculum may be unreachable in the network due to the loss of certain connections. It is an everyday observation that we forget everything about some former studies and once being reminded of a certain statement we are able to bring up a few connected statements but then we are stuck again; the system is not integrated as a whole. Arguably, the curriculum structure is very important. Perhaps robustness of scale-free networks could be exploited so as not to lose access paths so fast. (As a matter of course, the problem and the need for appropriate structures are recognized without such theoretical foundations.) In addition, we may refer to exams and particularly oral exams as examples of the usefulness of network based thinking. Teachers usually try to roam through the network of the student so to check the existence of certain points and connections. This is a reason for stressing the importance of links and the structure as a whole in contrary to the barren subsistence of vertices. We contend that understanding is hidden in the integration in debates Another often encountered type of change where people try to shape the other's network is debating. In a dispute the goal is to build a strong system (a network) of own arguments and to destroy the network of our opponent. The latter is done by causing percolation of the opponent's structure by building in as many negative links as possible. There are different means how we can achieve this: we may point out contradictions of the structure, integrate new vertices for establishing negative links between existing vertices or integrate new vertices that are in contradiction with existing vertices themselves. It can be useful to draw a network of the opponent's arguments so to analyze it and find the ideal vertices to attack or vertices that are not worth considering (e.g. peripheries that percolate after an attack). The frequently applied technique to simply confute all the statements with one argument is far from optimal. The same means can be used when defending our own network under attack. This method can also be a valuable tool of evaluating debates. A further application of such a representation of debates arises from the fact that the center of a debate - the topic - is often unequivocal. If we drew up lots of networks of high quality argumentations then we could evaluate existing indicators of the centrality of a vertex in a integration - manipulation or some interesting experiences about manipulation and scientific productivity. The model allows a very special way of vertex integration: if a new part of the network evolves separately from the former parts of the network and only a few connections are built between the two parts, then it is possible that contradictions remain undiscovered until enough time is given for thinking about the new points. This is certainly the case of urban legends and conspiracy theories: a vast amount of new information is delivered with a few obvious connections to reality and the theory itself is a positively linked network. A nearly disjoint structure of points strengthening each other does not allow vertices to be dropped. This strategy can also be used in a persuasion to get our information across without being rejected (e.g. due to a star shaped subnetwork) and this may lead to changes in the original network if we manage to build such viable structures that can override formerly developed parts. If two distinct substructures are not controversial but connections are unnoticed, we may talk about local discoveries when connections are finally built. If local discoveries uncover unknown relations between two research areas, then we may produce scientific results. The magnitude of restructuring thus follows scale-free distribution due to the distribution of the size of connected parts. This means that most useful scientific ideas are distributed unevenly: a researcher produces the majority of his results in a minority of the time devoted to the job. Further implications and conjectures In this section we demonstrate applicability of network theoretical notions for belief systems then point out to the potential of the model to interpret widely used but vaguely defined everyday notions. This chapter does not include systematic simulations, so arguments are rather conjectures for future in structure and is an external effect causing changes, possibly destruction in a network; noise filtration is a mechanism to avoid dramatic harmful changes. Self-organizing evolutionary networks always have methods to resist such changes (Csermely, 2006). In our case noise is coded in inputs with high contradiction factors, its filtration is tackled by the negativity tolerance factor, the modularized structure itself (destructions can be localized) and perhaps by protecting modules (consciously giving negative links to certain inputs). In general, diversity of behavior emerges if the number of links decreases. In our model it means that a great number of links enable associations to reach local centers in a few steps as the small world feature takes shape. In the lack of a sufficient number of links behavior becomes highly dependent on the structure defined by the existing links, behavior will not be averaged by the densely linked conformation. Indeed, unexpected reactions are characteristic for people who have undeveloped it is observed that too densely linked structures are also vulnerable (Watts, 2002). This phenomenon is also encompassed in the model: if a vertex drops out and another is ejected due to the loss of the first (to which it was positively linked) then there will be a high probability that some vertices loose two positive partners and have to be dropped. If the network is too densely linked, the process can result in system-level destruction. (Such a process can be generated with the computer code, although, there is no simple way to include results in the and communication problems14If a network is exposed to abounding new information containing inputs with relatively high contradiction factors then checking procedures may be interrupted by new inputs leaving inadequate points in the network. This lack of enforcement of rules in the network can lead to a feeling firmly associated with cognitive dissonance. More generally, psychological problems are often related to the fact that our own rules are not vindicated. If there are forbidden parts of the network containing unacceptable proportions of contradictions, then these locked up problems can cause psychological malfunctions. Psychologists often do not really intervene in the development of belief systems but they lead the patient to certain problematic areas of their own network. Also, there is a possibility to interpret communication problems like failed talks. If partners do not want to follow the routes dictated by the other's speech and only perceive single inputs or activations from it, then there will be no real conversation: both speakers roam their own and humor - distant linking Intelligence and creativity are notions definitely included in the scope of the model. If we think about intelligence as a quantity measured by IQ tests, then it is a kind of problem solving capability where two main features are required: having well-shaped local, small- scale statement structures on the one hand and being fast in searching on the other. In contrast, creativity is an ability of distant linking or more precisely, we call someone creative if his network is well-structured on a larger scale with sufficient connections between otherwise disjoint subnetworks. These definitions explain why intelligence and creativity are correlated till a certain IQ value (about 115) and become independent above. Fast search in confined areas help problem solving on a larger scale as well. It is needed in creative problem solving to reach vertices that are a few steps away, i.e. before or after using the creative link between the distant areas. Although, no matter how fast we are in local search there is no real chance to find connections between two distant points without sufficient creative links because after a few steps there is an astronomic number of possible routes that can not be checked by a brute force technique. Given an eligible speed of search (depending on local structures and rapidity) the determining factor in creative problem solving will be the existence of far-reaching creative links. The observed connection between humor and creativity is also originated from this point: distant linking appears in humor in most cases - the punch line is usually a statement from a completely unexpected part of the network. A sense of humor thus relies mainly on two factors: the advanced state of the used structures (not all kinds of jokes are equivalently understood by people) and the ability of distant and perspectives In the present article we delineated a model of belief systems with a potential that can be harnessed in a wide range of research areas. The sheer structure of opinion networks, changes determining evolution, and specific behaviors that are given by the model have relevant implications regarding a number of cognitive psychological processes. Naturally, we are far from a proper description of opinion system formation and development, but the usage of scale-free network theory for modeling statement networks is promising. There are some obvious extensions of the method making specific properties or descriptive features more precise but complicating the model on the other hand. First, weighting of connections can be refined to give a nuanced picture of binding strength between statements. Though, a weighting mechanism is to be defined then. A possible solution can be 15to relate weights with usage frequency (like in several connectionist PDP models). Secondly, activation spreading can be included in the model. In the lack of inputs activation may spread on the network enabling more complex structuring processes. Thirdly, points may be characterized with an additional factor - call it color - that refers to its topic that are relevant in linking (object, emotions, grammatical form etc.). All relevant features give one color to the point. If an input comes (with given colors), then linking starts with a probabilistic decision about the color that will be used when building the connection. The following step is the one we used in the original model applied to vertices that are marked with the given color. Consequently, points with more common colors (viz. stronger similarity) are linked with a bigger probability. Such modifications may improve the effectiveness of the model in several there are scores of other possible improvements out of which we mention only one here. Networks are sensitive to drastic changes. A factor showing the magnitude of changes in a given time period tells a lot about the mental state of the person. It could be analyzed how certain environmental circumstances (frequency and type of inputs) affect mental status. The role of the original network may also be of crucial are some questions that will determine the future of this model: exact methods for network mapping and quantifiable tentative steps for further substantiation are surely such. Still, without answering these questions some applications are ready to be tried and perhaps the approach towards opinion structure research is expanded in a way. We hope that a proper guidance was given to roam through a statement network about belief systems and researchers are inspired with properly fitting inputs. If new connections arise in the integration processes developing the structure of knowledge about belief systems, then this article attained its thank Prof. Peter Csermely for valuable comments and careful proofreading. R., Jeong, H., Barabasi, A.L. (1999): Diameter of the World Wide Web, Nature 401, 130. Albert, R., Jeong, H., Barabasi A.L. (2000): Error and attack tolerance of complex networks, Nature 406, L., Nunesa, M.G.V. Oliveira, O.N., da Costa, L.F. (2007): Strong correlations between text quality and complex networks features, Physica A , 373, A.L., Albert, R. (1999): Emergence of Scaling in Random Networks Science 286, A.L. (2002): Linked - The New Science of Networks , Cambridge MA: Perseus P., Schuster, M. (2006): Einfuhrung in die Lernpsychologie , Munchen: UTB, Reinhardt Verlag. Cancho, R.F, Sole, R.V. (2001): The small-world of human language, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London , B 268, 2261-2266. Clark A. (1993): Associative Engines: Connectionism, Concepts, and Representational Change , Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press. Csermely, P. (2006): Weak links: Stabilizers of Complex Systems from Proteins to Social Networks , Springer Verlag.16Dawson, G., Ashman, S.B., Carver, L.J. (2000): The role of early experience in shaping behavioral and brain development and its implications for social policy, Development and 12, I., Farkas, I., Palla, G., Vicsek, T. (2004): Topological phase transitions of random networks, Physica A 334, M.W. and Keane, M.T. (2005): Cognitive Psychology: A Student's Handbook 5th Edition , Hove: Psychology Press. Lord, C.G., Ross, L., and Lepper, M.R. (1979): Biased assimilation and attitude polarization: The effects of prior theories on subsequently considered evidence, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology , 37, R., Stanovich, K.E. (2007): Cognitive ability, thinking dispositions, and instructional set aspredictors of critical thinking, Learnincg and Individual Differences , 17, J.W., Krausz, M. (1982): Relativism, Cognitive and Moral , Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press. Motter, A.E, de Moura, A.P.S., Lai, Y.C. and Dasgupta, P. (2002): Topology of the conceptual network of language, Physical Review E , Vol. 65, 065102(R). OECD (2004a): Program for International Student Assessment: Learning for Tomorrow's World, First Results from PISA 2003, Paris. OECD (2004b): Education at a Glance: OECD Indicators - 2004 Edition - U., Tan C.O. (2006): Cognitive Maps of Complex Systems Show Hierarchical Structure and Scale-Free Properties, arXiv : Cs. (2003): An introduction to cognitive science (in Hungarian), Budapest, Hungary: Z.W. (1973): What the mind's eye tells the mind's brain . Psychological Bulletin, 80, 1-24. Rumelhart, D.E. and J.L. McClelland, (eds., 1986): Parallel distributed processing: Explorations in the microstructure of cognition . Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Russel B. (2001): My philosophical development. Routledge: London. Watts, D.J. (2002): A simple model of global cascades on random networks. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 99, 5766-5771 (2002). Westen, D., Kilts, C., Blagov, P., Harenski, K., and Hamann, S. (2006). The neural basis of motivated reasoning: An fMRI study of emotional constraints on political judgment during the U.S. Presidential election of 2004, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience , 18, A Mechanism of the model Fig. 8. Flowchart of the algorithm First linkingStart we explain the mechanism of our model in details (see Fig. 8). The computer program from which simulation results are obtained uses exactly these definitions and algorithms. A short summary is given regarding structural consequences. We realize network construction in a series of cycles. In each cycle the system processes only one input point: establishment of new connections between the point and the existing network is endeavored. According to the parameters it will succeed or not. If the input point joins the network it induces further linking until a new input arrives. The main units of the process are shown in Fig. 8. There are three parameters in the cycle process denoted by U, E and F. They stand for the followings: U- the number of edges carried by the input point, E- available time steps for the whole cycle (time for thinking about the input information), F- determining the amount of edges to be forgotten (disappearing randomly) in one cycle.18Adding new points We create input points (denoted by index i in the followings) with parameter values if, ig and ih. (Parameters ig and ih may be considered in the following way: the probability for a particular edge to be positive, negative or neutral is i i ii cbaa ig , i i ii cbab ih and i ihg1 , where ia, ib and ic denote the number of possible positive, negative and neutral links, respectively. We used these expressions to evaluate parametersig and ih from factors ia, ib and ic.) First linking As mentioned before new points should follow preferential linking in order to get scale- free network structure. Mathematically it means that the probability of a new edge attaching to a particular vertex (denote this non-neighboring target vertex by t) is proportional to tk. Taking into account our extra parameter referring to the attractiveness of points, one can formulate the vertexto linkingP) ( (A.1) p means that index p runs over all points which are not connected to point i, factors pf and pk denote the compatibility factor and the degree of point p, respectively. The probability of building a positive, negative or neutral link is ig, ih and i ihg1 , respectively. (If there are no edges in the network i.e. in the very beginning of a simulation one cannot evaluate expression A.1, so the following formula can be used instead: ppt ff, where notations are similar to those used before, but now the sum p runs over all points except i.) This linking step must be repeated U times. Then we should check whether the new point is consistent enough with the old network. This is performed by calling a i Killing function (discussed below). If the output of i Killing is YES - meaning that the new point does not fit in the network - all of its edges will be cleared and the First linking process will be restarted. If the output of i Killing is NO - meaning that there are not too many negative links - operation Structuring follows. In this process time is needed for checking as it is elucidated in the next section (killing). If the available time runs out without attaching the new point, we go on to the next input an arbitrary point j, j Killing returns YES if point j is more inconsistent with the network than the limit value fixed by parameter H. j Killing returns NO if the ratio of negative links of point j does not exceed H.
HH j Killing jof links#jof links negative#if NOjof links#jof links negative#if YES )( (A.2) where # denotes the number of elements of the set, H is the consistency or negativity tolerance of the network. One i Killing test consumes 1 time step. Structuring To construct new edges between the input point and former points of the network, two- step random walks start from the input point. The first step from i leads to its neighbor 1n with the following probability: ppn ff nP1)(1 . (Where p means a summation over all first neighbors of i.) In the next step we arrive to a second neighbor 2n with the probability given here: ppn ffnP2)(2 . (Here p means a summation over all neighbors of 1n, except for i itself.) Then we establish a link between the input and the afore mentioned point 2n. The new link will be positive, negative or neutral, respective probabilities areig, ih and i ihg1 . Checking After structuring processes it is possible that a point due to a growing number of negative connections does not fit in the network any more. To avoid discrepancy in the network checking mechanisms are needed. First, two tests are called: i Killing and 2n Killing . According to the results of these tests: 1. If none of these two points should be removed: Structuring goes on. 2. If input point i should be removed and 2n not: we clear all the edges of the input and restart the First linking section. (This can be considered as a new chance for the input to get integrated.) 3. If point 2n should be removed and point i not: we remove 2n and start a checking mechanism to investigate, whether the removal of 2n affected other points as well. (The falling number of positive links may lead to ejection of new points.) Details are elucidated in the next section Test). 4. If both input point i and point 2n should be removed: we remove the one with a smaller number of edges and go on with processes described in either case 2 or case Test20This is a test aiming to remove negatively linked points (where Killing would result in YES). The test requires a starting point (to be tested first) and time for the process. When we remove a point, it can happen that a positively linked neighboring point - by losing this positive connection - gets under the required level of consistency ( H). Therefore we should check each point which is positively linked to an ejected point. We introduce a list (called blacklist hereafter) to store the points that are waiting for such a test. A brief delineation of the process is shown in Fig. 9. Fig. 9. Algorithm of the Self-Consistency Test START with an empty blacklist Is there any point on the blacklist[1] ) = ? Remove the blacklistAdd those points to the blacklist that are connected to blacklist[1] with a positive edge Delete the networkNO YES NO YES Each Self-Consistency Test starts with a blacklist containing only the first point that induced the process. (A previous blacklist - if there was such - is lost while starting a new test.) We always analyze the first element of the blacklist. (Denoted by blacklist[1] on Fig. 9.) We determine whether blacklist[1] is to be removed or not - of course - by calling a 1] blacklist[ Killing function. If the output of 1] blacklist[ Killing is YES, we delete it and put all positively connected points to the end of the blacklist ranked by their f values. (One point is put on the list only once - here we refer to the case when it is already on the list when another neighbor is ejected.) If the output of 1] blacklist[ Killing is NO, we remove the point from the blacklist without any further operation and continue with the current first element of the blacklist. (Removing one point from the blacklist does not mean that it would be out of the blacklist forever. It can be put back if other ejections induce this.) This algorithm runs till we get an empty blacklist or till available time runs out. Again, the running of one 1] blacklist[ Killing function consumes one time rules determine the structure of the evolving network. Preferential attachment leads to a so called scale-free network, viz. where degree distribution obeys a power law: k kP)( , where is a fixed number. In case of preferential attachment (where is usually between 2 and 3) the 80/20 law and the emergence of the small world characteristic 21are straightforward consequences. Our linking processes involve preferential attachment and further linking based on random walks. This mechanism also produces scale-free networks, as it is shown in the original text of the article. Appendix B Network features and simulations In the course of network research degree distribution plays an inevitable role. A diagram shows the number of points with a given number of links. For scale-free structures the probability of having k links is:
ZkkP , (B.1) where is the exponent of the distribution, N kk Z 1 is a normalization factor, N is the total number of points. A conspicuous presentation of power law distributions is possible, if log-log scales are used, since: k Z kP log log log (B.2) is a linear function and is the slope of the line. As the network is built on a probabilistic basis, all concrete networks differ. Usually a great number of networks are built with the same parameter set and degree distributions are averaged to get smoother, more precise 1a and 1b : The following simulation was performed to prove that our model produces scale-free degree distribution under quite general circumstances. The Barabasi model was built with appropriate parameters and a general setting (with no distinguished parameters that could cause special effects) of our model was run. The given parameters are given in Table 1, results are depicted in Fig. 1a and 1b. (RND means a random number between 0 and 1 from a uniform probability recall the meaning of the parameter we give short explanations for the letters: H: negativity tolerance factor of the network U: number of prospective edges of the input E: amount of available time steps for a cycle F: number of edges to be forgotten (thus EFn / with the original notation) f: fitness factor a, b and c: relative probabilities for an edge to be positive, negative, or neutral, 1. Settings for the scale-free of averaged runsNumber of pointsH U E F f a b c Barabasi model 200 x 10000 - 2 1 0 1 - - -22General settings Type 1200 x 10000 0.5 2 10 1 1 1 1 1 General settings Type 2200 x 10000 0.5 2 10 1 RND RND RND RND Obviously, if all parameters are removed we get back the Barabasi model that is undoubtedly scale-free. For a general parameter set we have scale-free properties in a wide range. We do not have lower degree values with higher probabilities as there is more time ( 1E ) to connect each input to other points. Behavior is otherwise similar to the one observed in the original Barabasi model. Figure 2 : The key property of a small world network is its diameter. To check whether we really have small word networks we calculated the diameter of our networks and plotted them with respect to the network size. The original Barabasi network and our model (General Settings Type 2) are represented in Fig. 2 (parameters are listed in Table 1). Please note that the scale of the plot is log-lin so the diameter is approximately a logarithmic function of network size. Our network seems to be an even smaller world than the Barabasi network. The cause is simple: in this general case extra time is given for structuring that enables points to collect more links than in the Barabasi model. Figure 3 : As mentioned afore, if we deal with inhomogeneous inputs, then some points may obtain outstanding significance. In this simulation the fitness factor of a point is different from the others. (As earlier points usually become big centers, we performed two simulations. In the first run the special point was the first, in the second run the special point was the 32nd. Thus, we see that in these simulations conspicuous effects occur mainly due to the changed fitness factors, and not the early integration.) The network was expanded to 1000 points. Table 2. Settings for the star shaped network examination (the role of the fitness factor) H U E F f a b c Special point (1st or the 32nd)3 1 1 1 Other points0.5 1 10 1 RND RND RND RND An average of 10000 simulations is shown on Fig. 3. As it is unambiguous from Fig. 3, an outstanding fitness factor creates a distinct position for the exceptional vertex. It gains a huge amount of links (in this extreme case more than half of the points are linked to the special point), far more than others have - this leads to its disjoint situation at the high degree end in the degree distribution. In the same time, others lose linking opportunities that causes decline at the high degree end of the distribution. Links missing here are responsible for the insufficient behavior. Figure 4:23General Settings Type 2 and the original Barabasi model were used to obtain Fig. 4 and prove that earlier points are of high importance. From the graph one can see that in the Barabasi case the statement exactly holds (the first three points must have the same importance due to symmetrical reasons). In our model, the vast majority of points show the prescribed behavior. The first few points are of lower importance as time given to process them is not effective: all links are built and their degree can not grow further. If we reduced E in the simulation, the prescribed behavior would be extended. (In this parameter set the first two points must have the same degree due to symmetrical reasons, which is correctly 5 : Similar effects can be reproduced to those of star shaped networks' due to high fitness factors, if extremely long processing time is given for a special point, while other parameters are 3. Settings for the star shaped network examination (time dependency) H U E F f a b c Special points0.5 1 101 1 RND RND RND Figure 6 : Again, we used General Settings Type 2. The attacker point under investigation had the same parameters as the others, except for its processing time 100E and fitness factor 1f . Figure 7 : We used a basic network of 1000 points and in each run added a different number of new points in 1000 time steps. Fig. 7 shows the final number of points in the network. Standard deviations are marked to characterize uncertainties. We used a high F parameter (forgetting) to get this curve. Settings are given in Table 4. Table 4. Settings for the study on learning H U E F f a b c Base network (1000 points)2 0 New information0.5 1 variable 101 1 0 0
|
0807.0517
|
Miklos Antal Mr
|
Miklos Antal, Laszlo Balogh
|
Modeling belief systems with scale-free networks
|
23 pages, 9 figures
| null | null | null |
cs.AI physics.soc-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Evolution of belief systems has always been in focus of cognitive research.
In this paper we delineate a new model describing belief systems as a network
of statements considered true. Testing the model a small number of parameters
enabled us to reproduce a variety of well-known mechanisms ranging from opinion
changes to development of psychological problems. The self-organizing opinion
structure showed a scale-free degree distribution. The novelty of our work lies
in applying a convenient set of definitions allowing us to depict opinion
network dynamics in a highly favorable way, which resulted in a scale-free
belief network. As an additional benefit, we listed several conjectural
consequences in a number of areas related to thinking and reasoning.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 3 Jul 2008 09:38:19 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-04T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Antal",
"Miklos",
""
],
[
"Balogh",
"Laszlo",
""
]
] |
In this review [5] I first describe searches for graviton production in theg+E /Tand jet +E /Tsignatures reported by CDF and in the g+E /Tsignature reported by DO. Then I briefly describe searches sensitive to graviton exchange in dimuon, dielectron and diphoton final states reported by DO and in ZZfinal states by both CDF and DO. 2 CDF and DO detectors A detailed description of the CDF and the DO detectors can be found in Ref. [6, 7]. The vertexing and the tracking detectors surrounding the interactio n region are used to recon- struct charged particle trajectories. Further out are the calor imeters with hadronic longitudinal segmentation used to identify and measur e photons, electrons, and jets. Outside thecalorimeter arethe muondetectors used to iden tify muons fromthe collisions and cosmic rays. In analyses of g+E /Tevents one of the major backgrounds is from cosmic ray as photons. The detector features used to reject t his background are: photon pointing available at DO allowing the reconstruction of direction of the photon from the longitudinal segmentation of the electromagnetic calorimeter [8]; photon timing available at CDF from the EMTiming system [9] providing the measurement of the t ime of the energy deposit and allowing to suppress cosmic-ray background by a facto r of 20 or more. 3 Searches for graviton production The production of gravitons in hadron collisions is probed in events wh ere the jet or photon recoils against the graviton, which is not det ected and results in E /T. Background Events Z-nn 388+-30 W-ln 23+-20 g+jet 10+-10 Total predicted 808+-62 Data observed 809 Table1: and observed events in the jet + E /Tsample used by CDF.Searches in both the jet+ E /Tand theg+E /Trequire witha veto on the presence of other objects. These searches have similar backgrounds. The dominant and only is production of Z-nnin association with a photon or a jet. A search for LED in jet + E /Tevents has been per- formed by CDF using 1.1 fb-1of data, updating the anal- ysis in Ref. [10]. Events with high E /T, a high-ETjet and no second jet with ET>60 GeV are selected. All ma- jor backgrounds are estimated in a data-driven way. from Z-nnand from W-ln, where the lepton is lost, are estimated using measured After an a priori optimization for the best sensitivity to LED, events with the leading jet ET>150 GeV and E /T>120 GeV are selected. The summary of predicted and observed events is given in Table 1. The constraints on LED are given at the end of this CDF DO Zg-nng -2.2+-1.5 gg-g predicted data 40 29 Table 2: The numbers of expected background and observed events in the g+E /Tsamples ana- lyzed by CDF and DO. The contribution from jet-gin CDF is included in ( W/g)gby virtue of the background estimation method.Results for the g+E /Tsignature in the Tevatron Run II have been recently reported by CDF in 2 fb-1of data and by DO in 1.05 fb-1of data [8]. Both analyses use events with high E /Tand a high- ETphoton in the central detector region with |e|<1.1 [4]. No jets with ET>15 GeV are allowed in the event no high- pTtrack is allowed, suppress- ing contributions from leptonic WandZde- cays: tracks with pT>10 GeV/c) are vetoed by CDF (DO). The contribution from cosmic rays is suppressed based on presence of hits in the muon detectors as well as using the photon pointing or thephoton timing mentioned in Section 2. The background contributions for both analyses are summarized in Table 2. The number of events from Z-nnis estimated from simulation. The contribution from W-en, where the electron is identified as the photon, is extracted from the numb er of events with all other requirements applied to the photon signal sample, scaled by the rate. Contributions from cosmic rays and jets misidentified a s photons are estimated at DO using the photon pointing method. The remaining backgrounds in the analysis by DO are estimated using simulation. The contribution from cosmics at CDF is estimated using events with the photon time significantly different from the collision tim e. The at CDF are from processes where an object is lost. E xcept for W-tn, which is estimated from simulation, each of these backgrounds is given by t he number of events in data with this object identified, scaled by the simulated rate for it to be lost. This includes contributions from a jet identified as a photon. Source LEP DO CDF n g+E /Tg+E /Tjet+E /Tg+E /Tcombined 2 1600 921 1310 1080 1400 3 1200 877 1080 1000 1150 4 940 848 980 970 1040 5 770 821 910 930 980 6 660 810 880 900 940 Table 3: Lower limits on MDin GeV/c2at 95% C.L. for nfrom 2 to 6 observed in the jet+ E /T andg+E /Tsignatures and the combination of the two at CDF, and in the g+E /Tsignature at DO, along with the constraints from the LEP experiments [11]. Con straints provided by DO fornabove 6 can be found in [8]. After an a for the best sensitivity, events with a photon with ET>90 GeV and E /T>50(70) GeV are selected in the CDF (DO) signal sample. Event count s observed in the data are consistent with expectations from the ba ckgrounds. The constraints on the LED model are summarized in Table 3. Since the sensitivity in the g+E /Tis similar to that in the jet+ E /Tmode, the constraints can be improved in a combination. The result o f this combination using the CDF data is shown in Table 3. Depending on th e number of the sensitivity to LED at the Tevatron is comparable to o r better than that from the LEP experiments [11]. 4 Searches for virtual graviton exchange In hadron collisions the processes most sensitive to virtual gravito n exchange in LED are those with two leptons (electrons or muons), two photons, or two Zbosons in the final state, where it is possible to reconstruct the full kinematics of the final st ate with high precision. The value of the graviton exchange amplitude depends on the cutoff energy L, presumably of orderMD[3]. The cross section is proportional to L-8. A search for LED in the dimuon final state has been reported by DO u sing 200 pb-1 of data [12]. The sample is comprised of events with two opposite char ge muons with pT above 15 GeV /cand both muons passing additional quality and isolation requirements . The dilepton invariant mass and the scattering angle in the dilepton cente r of mass are to improve sensitivity to the exchange of a graviton ( spin 2 particle). A similar analysis using a di-emfinal state where no discrimination is made between electrons and photons has been performed at DO with 240 pb-1of data [13]. In this case events were selected if they had two emobjects with ET>25 GeV passing quality and No excess over the expected backgrounds is obse rved. The constraints on the parameter L are in the range of 1 to 2 TeV depending on the theoret ical parameters. Both CDF and DO have recently reported on searches for pp-ZZproduction in a four-lepton final state [14, 15]. The observed number of events is consistent with the SM expectations. Although no constraint has been provided on LED by either experiment, based on Ref. [16] the constraint on L is expected to be in the range of 1.5 t o 2.5 TeV. 5 Summary Searches withdirect thosewithvirtual are explored by the CDF and the DO experiments. No evide nce of LED has been seen. Additional ppcollision data currently produced at the Tevatron is expected to giv e more insight about the possible presence of large extra spacial dimension would like to acknowledge the funding institutions supporting the CD F and DO The full list of agencies can be found in, e.g, [6, N. Arkani-Hamed, S. Dimopoulosand G. R.Dvali, Phys.Lett. B 429, W. M. Yao et al.[Particle Data Group], J. Phys. G 33, 1 (2006). [3] G. F. Giudice, R. Rattazzi and J. D. Wells, Nucl. Phys. B 544, 3 (1999) The polar coordinate system is used with an origin at the center of a detector and the z-axis (th= 0) along the proton beam. The pseudorapidity eis defined as The transverse momentum pTis defined as pT=p*sinth, wherepis the particle's momentum. The transverse energy is defined as ET=E*sinth, whereEis the energy measured by the calorimeter. The missing ET(E /T) is defined as
/vectorE whereiis the index of a calorimeter tower (a segmentation unit in e-ph) and ^niis a unit vector perpendicular to the beam axis pointing to the tower fro m the origin. [5] A. Abulencia et al.[CDF Collaboration], J. Phys. G 34, 2457 (2007) V. M. Abazov et al.[D0 Collaboration], Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 565, 463 V. M. Abazov et al.[D0 Collaboration], arXiv:0803.2137 [hep-ex], accepted by Phys. Rev. Lett. [9] M. Goncharov et al., Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 565, 543 (2006) A. Abulencia et al.[CDF Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 171802 (2006) J. Abdallah et al.[DELPHI Collaboration], Eur. Phys. J. C 38, 395 (2005) Achard et al.[L3 Collaboration], Phys. Lett. B 587, 16 (2004) V. M. Abazov et al.[D0 Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 161602 (2005) V. M. Abazov et al.[D0 Collaboration], DO note 4336 (2004), T. Aaltonen et al.[CDF Collaboration], arXiv:0801.4806 [hep-ex]. [15] V. M. Abazov et al.[D0 Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 131801 (2008) [arXiv:0712.0599 [hep-ex]]. [16] M. Kober, B. Koch and M. Bleicher, Phys. Rev. D 76, 125001 (2007) [arXiv:0708.2368 [hep-ph]] and references therein.
|
0807.0645
|
Vyacheslav Krutelyov
|
Vyacheslav Krutelyov (for the CDF and D0 Collaborations)
|
Searches for Large Extra Dimensions at the Tevatron
|
5 pages, not using DIS2008 typesetting. In proceedings of the XVI
International Workshop on Deep-Inelastic Scattering and Related Subjects, DIS
2008, 7-11 April 2008, University College London
| null | null |
FERMILAB-CONF-08-218-E
|
hep-ex
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The presence of extra dimensions can be probed in high energy collisions via
the production or exchange of gravitons. The former corresponds to signatures
with missing energy while the latter corresponds to modifications of the final
state spectra. Here I review results of analyses performed by the CDF and D0
Collaborations on ppbar collisions at 1.96 TeV in signatures sensitive to large
extra dimensions. These include analyses of photon+(missing transverse energy)
and jet+(missing transverse energy) as signatures of graviton production as
well as analyses of dilepton and diboson final states sensitive to graviton
exchange.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 3 Jul 2008 20:58:12 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-08T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Krutelyov",
"Vyacheslav",
"",
"for the CDF and D0 Collaborations"
]
] |
2 the pressure intregrated along the line of sight, where T0is the CMB temperature, neandTearethe densityand in intracluster gas, and its magnitude is redshift. On the other hand, X-ray emission from the intraclust er gas has a different dependence on the density of electrons, whereLeH is the X-ray cooling function. It is possible to take advantage of the dependencies in these phenomena and evaluate the angular (ADD) of the galaxy cluster by (1) wherezis the redshift os galaxy cluster and thcis its core radius obtained from the SZE and X-ray analysis. Hence, it is possible to construct a Hubble diagram with which some cosmological parameters, such as, matter density, dark energy density, Hubble parameter ( H0), etc, can be estimated [3]. This technique for measuring distances is completely independent of other methods (as the one provided by the luminosity distance), and it can be used to measure distances at high redshifts directly. Review papers on t his subject have been published by Birkinshaw[6] and Carlstrom, Holder and Rees e[7]. More recently, such a technique has been applied for a fairly large nu mber order to estimate the ADD of a galaxy cluster from its SZ E/X- ray observations, one needs to add some complementary assumpt ions about its geometry. In the last decade, many studies about the intraclus ter gas and dark matter distribution in galaxy clusters have been limited to the st andard spherical geometry [14,11,15]. The importance of the intrinsic geo metry of the cluster has been emphasized by many authors [16,17,18,19] and t he geometry has been severely questioned, since Chandra and XMM- Newton observations have shown that clusters usually exhibit an ellip tical surface brightness. In general, different cluster gas profiles give different thc values, for instance, where the core radius obtained by using an isothermal elliptical bmodel and an bmodel, respectivelly, and eprojis the axial ratio of the major to the minor axes of the projected isophotes. Therefore, the assumed cluster shape can affect considerably the SZE/X-ray distances, and, conseque ntly, the H0 estimates and other astrophysical quantities. The first determination of the intrinsic (3D) sha pes of galaxy clusters was presented in Ref. [20] by combining X-ray, wea k-lensing and strong-lensing observations. Their methodology was applied to the galaxy cluster MACS J1423.8+2404and it was found the presence of a triax ial galaxy cluster geometry with DM halo axial ratios 1 .53+-0.15 and 1.44+-0.07 on the plane of the sky and along the line of sight, respectively. More recen tly, the elliptical description to galaxy clusters was shown to be the most com patible with the validity of the cosmic distance duality relation DL(1+z)-2/DA= 1, whereDL(z) andDA(z) luminosity and distances the other hand, in 2005, Eisenstein et al.[25] presented the large function from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) show ing clear evidence for the baryon acoustic peak at 100 h-1Mpc scale, a result in good agreement with the analyses from CMB data[26]. The breaking on the degen- eracy between H0andohmmby applying this BAO signature is possible because it does not depend on H0and is highly sensitive to the matter density param- eter. The combination SZE/X-ray with BAO has been recently discus sed in the literature by Cunha, Marassi and Lima[27]. In this article, we discuss the determinations of H0andohmmby consider- ing the Bonamente et al.sample [11]. This sample is formed by 38 ADD of galaxy clusters at redshifts 0 .14< z <0.89, derived from Chandra X-ray (see Fig. 1a).In orderto perfor ma realistic model for the cluster gas distribution and take into account the po ssible pres- ence of the cooling flow, the gas density was modeled by the non-isot hermal spherical double b-model. This model generalizes the single b-model [28] and it has two core radius that describe the shape of the inner and oute r portions of the density distribution. Analysis of the SZE and X-ray observat ions has shown that the outer core radius in this model is bigger than ones ob tained by using an isothermal elliptical bmodel or an isothermal spherical bmodel (see tables in Ref.[11]). Our basic findings follow from a joint analysis involving the data from SZE and X-ray surface brightness with the recent S DSS mea- surements of the baryon acoustic peak. The influence of the intrin sic cluster geometry on H0it will be quantified by comparing the results derived here with a recent determination of both parameters[27] based on De Filip piset al. sample formed by 25 clusters, where was used a isothermal elliptical bmodel [10]. 2 Basic Equation and Statistical Analysis Let us now consider that the Universe is described by a flat Friedman (FRW) (2) driven by cold dark matter plus a cosmological constant ( LCDM). In this background, the angular diameter distance, DA, can be s-1Mpc-1and the dimensionless function H(z';ohmm) is given by it appears, the above expres- sion has only two free parameters ( h,ohmm). In this way, we perform a statistical fit over the h-ohmmplane in light of Bonamente et al.data sample[11]. In our4 analysis we use a maximum likelihood that can be determined by a (4) whereDAo,iis the observational ADD, sDAo,iis the uncertainty in the indi- vidual distance, sstatis the contribution of the statistical errors (see table 3 in Bonamente et al.[11] (2006)) added in quadrature ( 20%) and the complete set of parameters is given by p(h,ohmm). It is interesting to note that for type Ia supernovae analyses, his usually marginalized over. In what follows, we first consider the SZE/X-ray distances separa tely, and, further, we present a joint analysis including the BAO signature fro m the SDSS catalog. Note that a specific flat LCDM cosmology has not been fixed a priori in the analysis below. 2.1 Limits from SZE/X-ray To begin with, let us consider the influence of the Hubble parameter o n the ADD once the cosmology is fixed. In Fig. 1(a), we display the residual Hubble diagram and the galaxy clu ster data sample by considering a flat cosmic concordance model ( ohmm= 0.3,ohmL=
0.7). As expected, for a given redshift, the distances increase for smaller values ofH0. In Fig. 1(b) we show the contours of constant likelihood (68.3%, 95.4 % and 99.7%) in the parameter space h-ohmmfor the SZ/X-ray data above discussed. Note that hparameteris allowed,(0 confidence level. In particular, we found h= 35.2 at 68.3% confidence level (c.l.). Naturally, such bounds on hare onthe xohmm= 0.3 wehaveh= 0.76,forohmm= 1.0wehave h= high degree of confidence. This means that using only the Bonam ente et al.sample we can not constrain severely the energetic components of the LCDM model with basis on the SZE/X-ray data alone. As one may conclu (fixing ohmmorh)is necessaryin ordertobreak the degeneracy on the ( ohmm,h) plane. As we are interested in galaxy clusters observations, it is interesting to use a cosmolo gical test sensitive only to ohmmto break the degeneracy on the ( ohmm,h) /s48/s46/s49 /s48/s46/s50 /s48/s46/s51 /s48/s46/s52 /s48/s46/s53 /s48/s46/s54 /s48/s46/s55 /s48/s46/s56 /s48/s46/s57 /s49/s46/s48 /s49/s46/s49 /s48/s46/s50 /s48/s46/s52 /s48/s46/s54 /s48/s46/s56 1a) Angular diameter distance as a function of redshift for ohmm= 0.3,ohmL= 0.7 and some selected values of the hparameter. The data points correspond to the the for 38 clusters from Bonamente et al.sample. b) Confidence regions (68 .3%, 95.4%
and 99.7%) in the ( ohmm,h) plane provided by the SZE/X-ray data. The best fit values are h= 0.743 and ohmm= 0.37. As remarked in the text, the possible values of H0are on the allowed values of ohmm, and, therefore, such a degeneracy need to be broken by adding a new cosmological test. 2.2 Joint analysis for SZE/X-ray and BAO As remarked in the introduction, more stringent constraints on th e parameter space (h,ohmm) can be obtained by combining the SZE/X-ray with the from the SDSS Main Sample) is predicted to arise at the meas ured scale of 100 h-1Mpc. Let us now consider it as an additional over the spherical cluster sample. Such a measurement is cha racterized by A 0.469+-0.017, (5) wherez*= 0.35 is the redshift at which the acoustic scale has been mea- sured and G(z*) is the dimensionless comoving distance to z*. Note that the above quantity is independent of the Hubble constant, and, as suc h, the BAO signature alone constrains only the Fig. 2(a), we show the confidence regions for the SZE/X-ray clu ster distance and BAO joint analysis. By comparing with Fig. 1(b), one may see how the BAO signature breaks the degeneracy in the ( ohmm,h) plane. As it appears, the BAO test presents a striking orthogonality centere d respect to the angular diameter distance data as determined from SZE/X-ray processes. We find h= 68.3% c.l. and 68.3% c.l. for 1 free parameter ( kh2 min= 35.3). In light of these results, the important lesson here is that the combination of SZE/X -ray with BAO provides an interesting approach to constrain the Hubble cons tant.6 In Fig. 2(b), we have plotted the likelihood function for the hparameter in a flatLCDM universe for the SZE/X-ray + BAO data set. The dotted lines are cuts in the regions of 68 .3% probability and 95 .4% (1 free parameter). At this point, it is interesting to compare our results with other rece nt works. In table 1, a list of recent Hubble parameter determinations based on cluster data is displayed. Note that in the first five works the hvalues were obtained by fixing the cosmology ( ohmm= 0.3,ohmL= 0.7), while in our estimate the SZE/X-ray + BAO technique was used (no one specific cosmology has been /s48/s46/s49/s53 /s48/s46/s50/s48 /s48/s46/s50/s53 /s48/s46/s51/s48 /s48/s46/s51/s53 /s48/s46/s52/s48 /s48/s46/s52/s53 /s48/s46/s54 /s48/s46/s55 /s48/s46/s56 /s48/s46/s57 2 a) Contours in the ohmm-hplane using the SZE/X-ray and BAO joint analysis. The contours correspond to 68 .3%, 95.4% and 99 .7% confidence levels. The best-fit model converges to h= 0.765 and ohmm= 0.27. b) Likelihood function for the hparameter in a flat LCDM universe from SZE/X-ray emission and BAO. The horizonta l lines are cuts in the regions of 68 .3% probability and 95 .4%. Table 1 Limits to husing SZ/X-ray method from galaxy clusters ( LCDM) Reference (data) ohmm h(1s) Masonet al.2001 (7 clusters)[13] 0 .3 0 al.2002 (18 cluster) [8] 0 .3 0 2004 (41 clusters) [32] 0 .3 0 al.2005 (5 clusters) [9] 0 .3 0 et al.2006 (38 clusters) [11] 0 .3 0 al.2007 (24 triaxial clusters) + BAO [27] 0 paper (38 clusters)+BAO the other hand, the importance of the intrinsic geometry of the clus- ter has been emphasized by many As a cons equence, the standard spherical geometry has been severely questioned, since Chandra and XMM-Newton observations have shown that clusters usually ex hibit an elliptical surface brightness. In this concern, a previous determin ation of H0 from SZE/X-ray + BAO by Cunha et al.[27] was based in a smaller sample7 (25 galaxy clusters described by an elliptical profile) observed by De Fillipis and Their results suggested that 15 clusters ar e in fact more elongated along the line of sight, while the remaining 10 clusters are co m- pressed. Actually, the assumed cluster shape seems to affect con siderably the SZE/X-ray distances, and, therefore, the H0estimates. As shown in table 1, the central value of H0in this case (elliptical profile) is the same determined by Riess et al.[30] by using a hybrid sample (Cepheids
+ Supernovae), H0= 73.8+-2.4 km/s/Mpc . It is also closer to the Hub- ble Space Telescope (HST) key project determination of the Hubble param- eter announced by Friedman et al.[31] based only on Cepheids as H0= 72+-8 km/s/Mpc. 3 Comments and Conclusions In this paper we have discussed a new determination of the Hubble co nstant based on the technique for a sample of 38 clust ers as com- piled by Bonamente et al.assuming spherical symmetry[11]. The degeneracy on theohmmparameter was broken through a joint analysis applying the SDSS catalog.The Hubble con to be h= 1sandohmm= These limits were derived assuming the flat LCDM scenario and a spherical b-model. derived here is in perfect agreement with the Bonamente et al.value,h= 0.769 (assuming a hydrostatic equilibrium and fixing the con- cordance model), as well as with other recent estimates coming fro m WMAP and Hubble Space telescope Key Project, where h= 0.73. However, it differs slightly of a recent estimation by Cunha, Marassi & Lima, h= 0.74, where the SZE/X-Ray + BAO technique was applied for 24 triaxial galaxies clu sters. In general ground, such results are suggesting that the combina tion of these three independent phenomena (SZE/X-ray and BAO) provides an in teresting method to constrain the Hubble Sunyaev, R. A., Zeldovich, Ya. B.:The Observations of Rel ic Radiation as a Test of the Nature of X-Ray Radiation from the Clusters of Galaxies. Com ments Astrophys. Space Phys.4, 173 (1972) 2. Itoh, N., Kohyama, Y., Nozawa, S.: Relativistic Correcti ons to the for Clusters of Galaxies. Astrophys. J. 502, 7 (1998). 3. Bartlett, J. G.:The Effect and its Uses . Astrop. Space Sci. 290, 105 (2004) 4. Silk, J., White, S. D. M.: The determination of Q0 using X-r ay and microwave obser- vations of galaxy clusters. Astrophys. J. 226, L103 (1978) 5. Cavaliere, A., Danese, L., De Zotti, G.: Cosmic distances from X-ray and of clusters of galaxies. Astron. and Astrophy s.75, 322 (1979). 6. Birkinshaw, M.: The effect. Phys. Rep. 310, 97 (1999) 7. Carlstrom, J. E., Holder, G. P., Reese, E. D.: Cosmology wi th the . ARA&A 40, 643 (2002)8 8. Reese, E. D., et al.: Determining the Cosmic Distance Scal e from Interferometric Mea- surements of the Effect. Astrophys. J. 581, 53 (2002) 9. Jones, M. E., et al.: H0 from an samp le of and X-ray clusters. MNRAS 357, 518 (2002) 10. De Filippis, E., Sereno, M., Bautz, M. W., Longo, G.: Meas uring the of Galaxy Clusters. I. Application to a Sample of 2 5 Clusters. Astrophys. J. 625, 108 (2005) 11. Bonamente,M., et al.: Determination of the Cosmic Dista nce Scale from Effect and Chandra X-Ray Measurements of High-Red shift Galaxy J. 647, 25 (2006) 12. La Roque, S., et al.: X-Ray and Effect M easurements of the Gas Mass Fraction in Galaxy Clusters. Astrophys. J. 652, 917 (2006) 13. Mason,B. S.et al.:A Measurement ofH0 fromthe Sunyaev-Z eldovich Effect. L11 (2001). 14. Reiprich, T. H., Bohringer, H.: The Mass Function of an X- Ray Flux-limited Sample of Galaxy Clusters. Astrophys. J. Letters 567, 716 (2002) 15. Shang, C., Haiman, Z., Verde, L.: Probing cosmology and g alaxy cluster structure with the decrement versus X-ray temperature scaling relation. MNRAS, 400, 1085 (2009) 16. Fox,D. C., Pen, U.-L.:The Distance to Clusters: Correct ing for Asphericity. 38 (2002) 17. Jing, Y. P., Suto, Y.:Triaxial Modeling of Halo Density P rofiles with Simulations. Astrophys. J. 574, 538 (2002) 18. Plionis, M., Basilakos, S., Ragone-Figueroa, C.: Morph ological and Dynamical Proper- ties of Low-Redshift Two Degree Field Galaxy Redshift Surve y Groups. Astrophys. J. 650, 770 (2006) 19. Sereno, M., De Filippis, E., Longo, G., Bautz, M. W.: Meas uring the ofGalaxy Clusters.II. AreClusters ofGalaxies O blate or Prolate?. 170 (2006). 20. Morandi, A., Pedersen, K., Limousin, M.: Unveiling the T hree-dimensional Structure of Galaxy Clusters: Resolving the Discrepancy Between X-ra y and Lensing J. 713, 491 (2010) 21. Etherington, I. M. H.:On the Definition of Distance in Gen eral Relativity. Phil. Mag. 15, 761 (1933); reprinted in Gen. Rel. Grav., 39, 1055, 2007 22. Holanda, R. F. L., Lima, J. A. S., & Ribeiro, M. B.; Testing the with Galaxy Clusters and Type Ia Supernovae. Astro phys. J. letters 722, L233 (2010) 23. Holanda, R. F. L., Lima, J. A. S., Ribeiro, M. B.: Cosmic di stance duality relation and the shape of galaxy clusters. Astron. Astrophys. Letters, 5 28, L14 (2011) 24. t Testsforthe from Galaxy Clusters and Type Ia Supernova. Astrop hys. J. letters 729, L14 (2011) 25. Eisenstein, D. J.: Detection of the Baryon Acoustic Peak in the Large-Scale of SDSS Luminous Red Galaxies. Astrophys. J. 633, 560 (2005) 26. Komatsu, E., et al.: Seven-year Wilkinson Microwave Ani sotropy Probe (WMAP) Ob- servations: Cosmological Interpretation. Astrophys. J. S eries192, 18 (2011) Cunha, J. V., Marassi, L., Lima, J. A. S.: Constraining H0 from the effect, galaxy cluster X-ray data and baryon oscillations. M NRAS379L1 (2007) 28. Cavaliere, A., & Fusco-Fermiano, R.: The Distribution o f Hot Gas in Clusters of Galax- ies. Astron. Astrophys. 667, 70 (1978) 29. Lima,J. A. S., Alcaniz, J. S.: Constraining the cosmic eq uation of state fromold galaxies at high redshift. Astron. Astrophys. 357, 393 Riess, A., et al.: A 3% Solution: Determination of the Hub ble Constant with the Hubble Space Telescope and Wide Field Camera 3. Astrophys. J. 730, 119 (2011) 31. Freedman, W. L., et al.: Final Results from the Hubble Spa ce Telescope Key Project to Measure the Hubble Constant. Astrophys. J., 553, 47 (2001). 32. Reese, E. D.: Measuring and Modeling the Universe, ed. W. L. Freedman (CUP) p. 138 (2004).
|
0807.0647
|
Rodrigo Holanda
|
R. F. L. Holanda, J. V. Cunha and J. A. S. Lima
|
New constraints on H_0 and Omega_M from SZE/X-RAY data and Baryon
Acoustic Oscillations
|
8 pages, 4 figures, 1 table, accepted version in the general
relativity and gravitation
| null |
10.1007/s10714-011-1292-5
|
General Relativity and Gravitation Volume 44, Issue 2, Page 501-508
(2012)
|
astro-ph gr-qc
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The Hubble constant, $H_0$, sets the scale of the size and age of the
Universe and its determination from independent methods is still worthwhile to
be investigated. In this article, by using the Sunyaev-Zel`dovich effect and
X-ray surface brightness data from 38 galaxy clusters observed by Bonamente
{\it{et al.}} (2006), we obtain a new estimate of $H_0$ in the context of a
flat $\Lambda$CDM model. There is a degeneracy on the mass density parameter
($\Omega_{m}$) which is broken by applying a joint analysis involving the
baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) as given by Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS).
This happens because the BAO signature does not depend on $H_0$. Our basic
finding is that a joint analysis involving these tests yield $H_0=
0.765^{+0.035}_{-0.033}$ km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$ and
$\Omega_{m}=0.27^{+0.03}_{-0.02}$. Since the hypothesis of spherical geometry
assumed by Bonamente {\it {et al.}} is questionable, we have also compared the
above results to a recent work where a sample of triaxial galaxy clusters has
been considered.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 3 Jul 2008 21:09:17 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 2 Nov 2011 13:57:16 GMT"
}
] | 2012-01-20T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Holanda",
"R. F. L.",
""
],
[
"Cunha",
"J. V.",
""
],
[
"Lima",
"J. A. S.",
""
]
] |
point (although not necessarily at Ts due to end effects as will be discussed later). I n several works it has been noted that the temperature independent point occurred at a sig nificantly different temperature than expected from the spacer glass This impacts the thermal design of the vacuum sys tem to minimize frequency drift. Clearly it would be useful to specify an optical cavity's turning po int with at least modest accuracy in advance of it' s installation in a vacuum chamber. This will be especially important for smaller portable systems that are constrained b y power, weight and space. The main focus of this paper is to report progress toward the ability to fabricate reference cavities with the first order temperature independence point known by design. Fi rst, a model of the resonant frequency versus tempe rature is presented that includes deformation at the cavity ends and other factors th at cause temperature dependence. Structural finite-element analysis is incorporated into the model in an analy tical fashion. Secondly, even with a valid model in hand we still need a means to obtain low expansion glass with a k nown a(T) characteristic. The tolerance of a(T) that commercially available glasses exhibit is si mply too wide. A means to test potential glass spacer pieces by building temporary surface-mounted cavities on fine ground glass is p roposed and demonstrated. This introduction would be incomplete without notin g that even with a cavity at the turning point, the frequency fluctuations are still temperature de pendent for several reasons. There are temperature dependent fluctuations of the cavity length attributed to Bro wnian motion. 11 Secondly, laser power that is absorbed in the coa tings and substrates causes length changes through the ma terial CTE. This dynamic effect has been investiga ted both theoretically 12 and experimentally 13 . 1.1 Previous literature As will be discussed below, mirror substrates const rained by an optical contact to a spacer will cause a temperature dependent deformation of the cavity ends due to dif ferential expansion between the spacer, substrate a nd coating materials. The differential expansion of a special ly shaped fused silica mirror on a sapphire spacer has been analyzed and shown to move the temperature independent point of the cavity, allowing the turning point to be tu ned by selecting the mirror parameters.14 And the possibility of differential expansion be tween the substrates and spacer influencing the cavity length has been mentioned by many authors pr eviously (e.g., ref 10). However, to this author's knowledge a general treatment applicable to all mirror and spac er geometries that allows end deformation to be inc luded in the cavity's temperature dependence has not been discus sed. 2. CAVITY TEMPERATURE DEPENDENCE The description of the temperature dependence of th e resonance frequency is developed by starting with the phase accumulated in one round-trip of a cavity of length l and equating this to an integer multiple of 2 p: mlp psphlp2 222=- - . (1) The length l is defined as the physical distance between the di electric mirror surfaces, l is the wavelength in the medium, and ph is the phase-shift upon reflection from the coatin gs (both mirrors assumed to be the same). ps is the phase difference between the plane wave propagation given in the first term and the actual Gaussian be am propagation. Siegman 15 gives a close approximation of ps in terms of the cavity geometry, ) 1 ( cos ) 1 ( 21 Rl qp - ++ =-ps , (2) where p and q are transverse mode indices and R is the radius of curvature. Solving Eq.(1) for th e frequency of the cavity resonance in vacuum one finds that ). 22(2 ppsphn++ = mlc (3) Taking the derivative of Eq. (3) with respect to te mperature for l << l results in ,)22 (2) 1)( ( )( TT T lc lTTl T To +
+
- =pps ph n n (4) where T = T-T o. Eq.(4) gives the expected resonance frequency at some temperature T as a function of the resonance frequency at an arbitrary temperature To. The second term is dominated by the change in th e coating phase shift, as ph /T >> ps /T. The change of ph with temperature can be estimated from the slope o f the spectral phase shift upon reflection and the temperature response of the high -reflectivity mirror's band-pass. The mirrors used in the experiments to be described were visible band (centered at 578 nm) IBS coatings on low expansion substrates. At the measurement wavelength of 633 nm, ph /T -0.2 mr/K. The corresponding frequency shift depe nds on the (FSR), and the cavities described ar e about 10 cm long. The frequency shift contributi on from the last term (approximately -95 kHz/K) is small in comparis on to the measured frequency shift that will be sho wn below. As the temperature changes uniformly, the cavity's physical length will change due to the spacer expan sion or contraction but there are other factors that cause the mirror spacing to change. The elastic modulus and Poisson's ratio of fused silica (the primary constituent of ULE and TSG) are both slightly temperature dependent (~0.0 2%/K). This may translate to a temperature dependent change in the cavity length under gravity depending on how th e cavity is supported. And a gradient in the spacer CTE that i s transverse to the optical axis would cause the sp acer to bend with temperature. As mentioned previously, structural d eformation at each end of the cavity due to the dif ferent CTE of the spacer, mirror substrate, and coating is also a fac tor that causes the mirror separation to vary with temperature. The mirror substrate may be a different material than t he spacer purposely for low-noise considerations. 11 But use of the same type of glass for substrate and spacer does no t preclude distortion at the ends. Indeed, with a ULE substrate and spacer at the ideal zero expansion temperature Ts, finite element analysis (of the structure present ed below) reveals an on-axis inward deformation that is more than twice as large as the linear thermal expansion of the 5 um thick coating. However, it is much more likely that a ULE mirror s ubstrate will actually have a different coefficient of expansion than the end of a spacer made from ULE. Often this aris es because the mirror substrate material is acquire d from a different source than the spacer, allowing for the distinct i f not probable possibility that the two pieces of g lass are from different boules entirely. Even if the substrate glass is cu t from the part of the boule adjoining the spacer g lass, the spatial variation of a(T) in ULE can be several (10 -9)/K per cm. 16 In general then, temperature dependent deformation of the cavity ends contributes to l. This is treated here with finite element analysis (FEA) under the assumption that op tical contacting constrains the substrate to the sp acer and does not slip as stress builds up. No f requency discontinuities that would indicate slippi ng were observed over the limited temperature range measured and rep orted on here. The assumptions relied on here may not be valid for every cavity or for wide temperature excursions. The physical length change, l, may be written as the sum of the change of the sp acer's length and also contributions from the ends, l = lS + 2 lE. The factor of 2 is because a symmetrical cavity is assumed. The sign of lE is defined such that a positive change at either end makes the cavity longer. We explicitly include these contri butions by rewriting Eq.(4) as ). 22 (2)) ( 2) ( 1)( ( )(pph n TE S o
+
- - = (5) The part of the last term concerning the diffractio n phase shift has been dropped as it is not signifi cant. The length temperature dependences lS/T and lE / T are functions of temperature because the glass CTE is temperature dependent. Eq.(5) can be used to predict resonance temperature dependence from an arbitrary n(To) if the variables can be expressed as a function of temperature. Importa ntly, if the variables can be written analytically, then Eq.(5) can be used by a least-squares routine to compare the mode l with measured data. For instance, starting from a measured point n(To), a routine could adjust parameters in the model t o match n(T) to the data. Writing lS as a function of the initial and final temperature is straightforward as the CTE of spacer glasses ca n be represented by a polynomial, for instance a(T) = Ko+K1T+K2 T 2. The fractional change in length is given by inte grating the CTE over the temperature interval, =T TS S odT T ll )(a . (6) Determining lE / T as a function of temperature can be accomplished b y FEA of the end structure to the extent that the material parameters (CTE, Elastic modulus, Poisson' s ratio) of the spacer, substrate and coating are k nown. However the crux of the matter is that in many instances th e CTE of either the spacer or the mirror substrates or both is not known with sufficient precision to make any useful predic tion. Examples are the tolerance of the average CT E value of ULE,
+-30 ppb/K, or that of Zerodur 7, +-20 ppb/K. But, as noted already, if lE(T) can be expressed in an analytical form then Eq.(5) offers a means to analyze experimental data to measure the CTE of components. That is achieved here by first using FEA to find an analytical approximation of th e z-axis deformation as a function of the CTE value s of the spacer and substrate, independent of temperature. Then, g iven the task of determining the end deformation th at arises from To to a temperature T, this approximation can be used in conjunction wit h the CTE equations of the materials involved to provide an analytical form of Eq.(5). As an example we analyzed optical frequency versus temperature data from a cavity fabricated with a TS G spacer and contacted high-finesse fused silica mirrors (Fig.1) . The CTE of the TSG bar was unknown other than th e material specification of a mean CTE in the range of +-100 ppb/K over the temperature interval from 5 to 3 5 C. The measurement was performed by recording the beat-note between an HeNe laser and an extended cavit y diode laser that was frequency locked to a longitudinal mode of the cavity. The cavity was in a thick-walled blac kbody vessel inside a vacuum chamber (P < 1 Pa) as the outside temperat ure of the chamber was very slowly ramped. The cav ity was supported on a soft rubber o-ring in a v-block to a void imparting the expansion of the mounting to the cavity. A parabolic fit to the Fig. 1 data has a turning poin t at -22.2 C and a quadratic coefficient of -346 kH z/K 2. The physical geometry is modeled by supporting the TSG bar at one end and calculating the z-axis defor mation of the center of the opposing coated mirror for a selected set of spacer and mirror substrate CTE values ( aS and aM respectively) given in Table I. The deformation is calculated fo r a +1 degree T and the units are nm/K. This is followed by accounting for the spacer expansion or contraction by suppressing the opposing mirror and calculating the z- axis position of the end of the spacer, again in nm /K. The difference between the two calculations is taken as the end deformation corresponding to this physical structur e and coating with those particular values of aS and aM . The HR Fig. 1 (Left) The thick line is the optical frequ ency versus temperature data for a mode of the TSG glass cavity, the thin line is a fit to the model described in the te xt. (Right) The cavity consisted of a 99 mm long T SG spacer, 25.4 mm diameter, with polished ends, a 6.5 mm dia center b ore and an air relief hole. Fused silica mirrors w ith an outer flat annulus (25.4 mm dia, 5.75 mm thick, 50 cm radius) were contacted to the ends (contacted at radius > 9 .5 mm). The spacer had an 8 mm wide flat ground along the entir e length as depicted by the dashed line in the end view for the placement of the surface mounted mirrors described in section 3. 473612400 473612300 473612200 473612100 Optical Frequency (MHz) 28 26 24 22 20 18 Temperature (C) quarter-wave stack (~60 layers) is modeled as a uni form 5 um thick layer on the central 18 mm of the substrate diameter. The coating parameters are taken as ac = 1.8 x 10 -6 K -1, E = 106 GPa, s = .21 and the density = 8200 kg/m3 following work on similar coatings,17 although these assumptions are a possible source o f error as the physical constants of thin- films are typically less well known than the bulk m aterial. Care was taken to insure an adequate FEA mesh around the contacted regions of the components. With the values of lE / T calculated by FEA in hand we can approximate them with a simple analytical form C B ATl S ME+ + =a a . (7) In eq.(7) the units of the CTE terms are ppb/K, the resulting deformation lE / T is in nm/K, and the coefficients A, B, and C are found by a least-squares fit to the calculated poin ts to be A = 0.0063 nm, B = -0.0059 nm, and C = -0.064 nm/K. Indeed as the last column of the table shows, at least over the l imited range of CTE values in the table Eq.(7) is a very good appro ximation to the end deformation calculated by FEA. These coefficie nts are unique to the physical structure and coating analyzed. The CTE terms aM and aS in Eq.(7) can be represented by temperature dependent polynomials, thus providing t he analytical representation of the end deformation. The lE term in Eq.(5) can be calculated for an arbitrary temperature by utili zing eq.(7) and integrating from To to T. The fused silica polynomial, aM , is relatively well known and so the unknown TSG spacer polynomial coefficients ( Ko, K1 and K2) can be determined by fitting Eq.(5) to the data sho wn in Fig. 1. The uncertainty in this process is due primarily to the uncertainty of the fused silica CTE. Two sets of best-fit spacer coef ficients were determined (Fig. 2) since published values of the f used silica CTE near room temperature differ slightly, perhaps due to SiO 2 purity issues. 18 The best-fit result is that the TSG spacer zero-c rossing point TS is in the range of 16 to 20 C, limited by the unce rtainty in the CTE of the fused silica substrate. Thus the mo del indicates that the spacer zero crossing TS is approximately 38 to 42 K higher than the optical cavity's turning point of -22 C. 3. SURFACE MOUNT CAVITIES AND TEMPORARY FABRY-PERO TS Spacer CTE Substrate CTE lE/T From FEA Eq.(7) error (ppb/K) (ppb/K) (nm/K) %
+30 460 2.6549 0.039
+30 480 2.7823 -0.012
+30 500 2.9077 .009
+30 520 3.0346 -0.021
+10 460 2.7766 -0.074
+10 480 2.9022 -0.056
+10 500 3.0281 -0.051
+10 520 3.1545 -0.061 -10 460 2.8898 0.117 -10 480 3.0161 0.102 -10 500 3.1419 0.105 -10 520 3.2676 0.110 -30 460 3.0138 -0.068 -30 480 3.1396 -0.058 -30 500 3.2653 -0.046 -30 520 3.3909 -0.033 20 10 0 -10 -20 CTE ppb/K 35 30 25 20 15 Temperature (C) Table 1. Finite element analysis calculations of the end deformation over a +1 K temperature change are given in the third column. In each case the spacer and mirror substrate CTE are held constant at the value s given in the first two columns. The data in the th ird column can be approximated by Eq.(7). The fourth column gives the error of this approximation. Fig. 2. Two estimates of the TSG spacer CTE from o ptical frequency measurements after accounting for end deformation. The short dashed line is with fused silica aM(T) per ref [18], and the long dashed line is with aM(T) per the discontinued NIST Standard Reference Material 739. The NIST SRM CTE values exceed than those of ref [18] by about 8 %. 3. SURFACE MOUNT CAVITIES AND TEMPORARY FABRY-PEROTS For some time at NIST we have been experimenting wi th building optical cavities on flat polished surfa ces as shown in Fig. 3. The mirrors have been cut off and polished to provide a flat mounting surface that is paralle l to the optical axis to within +-10 arc minutes. The mounting surfaces have been sp ecified flat to l/8 with a 60/40 surface finish. With two mirrors placed on the surface of the flat spacer it is possible to manually orient the mirror axis wit h the horizontal degree of freedom to form a cavity, and align an incoming beam such that cavity modes are evident on the tran smitted beam. This construction has been investigated for use as a wavelength reference for stage interferometers, b ecause it can provide a mechanically stable cavity that is also o pen to the free flow of air. 19 Although the specified flatness and surface finish are sufficient for optical contactin g, the mirrors are not attached by conventional con tact since alignment would be difficult. Instead, bon ding using a potassium hydroxide (KOH) solution is employed.20 This provides an adhesive-free permanent bond that also allows the mirror positions to be adjusted (at leas t for several minutes) after they have been set on the surface. Cleanliness and a particle-free environment are int egral to this process as in conventional optical-co ntacting. Bonding is accomplished one mirror at a time by applying appro ximately 0.5 uL of KOH/H 2O solution (ph = 12.5) to the interface after cleaning, then re-aligning the mirror before the bonding sets. As discussed in reference [20] t he bond curing is a de-hydration process. The permanently attached mir rors appear to have no internal reflection at the i nterface if the bond completely covers the interface once cured. Howeve r partial bonding over the interface area is possib le. This is easily detected, for if the bonding surfaces are non-ideal in terms of flatness or particle contamination, th e non-bonded portion of the interface will reflect light. Our concern here is the application of the surface- mount approach to fabricating a Fabry-Perot test ca vity on the non- polished (fine ground) glass surface of the TSG spa cer. Specifically, a measurement of a test cavity built on the TSG spacer surface could corroborate the spacer's longi tudinally averaged CTE measured in section 2. Furt hermore, a demonstration of such a metrology capability with t emporary mirrors is important because it offers ano ther means to measure the CTE of potential spacer and mirror glas s prior to expensive machining. Uncertainty in the measurement would be reduced if the mirrors were attached to the ground glass such that lE of Eq.(5) is negligible. In other words, mounted in s uch a manner that the distance between the coated s urfaces depends only on the spacer. As with mirrors contacted on t he spacer ends, that is generally not true of the s urface mounted mirrors bonded to a polished surface. FEA modeling of a fully-bonded surface-mounted substrate with a different CTE than the spacer indicates that at the position of t he cavity mode in the center of the mirror, several mm away from the constrained interface, the substrate expands freely with temperature. Therefore unless the ULE mirror substrate CTE is well known this introduces an uncertainty in the de sired measurement of the spacer CTE. The same prin ciple applies with a surface mounted mirror attached via hydroxy- catalysis bonding to a fine ground surface. One ap proach to minimize the uncertainty is to bond the test mirror near the coated surface only, allowing the rear po rtion to freely expand. For this purpose a saw cut was introduced as shown in Fig. 4, and a minimal amount of KOH liq uid applied (~0.1 uL). The solution wicked in to the thin front porti on when applied to the bottom of the coated surface as the Fig. 3 (Left) Four 50 cm radius (7.75 mm dia) mir rors arranged in a surface-mounted bow-tie ring cavity fabricated on a 15 cm long ULE block. The mirrors are aligned manually in the horizontal direction by gentle forces applied with a hand-held probe. mirror was properly positioned on the fine ground s urface of the TSG. After 30 minutes the bond was t ested by holding the spacer upside down to check that the mirrors we re in fact attached. The TSG spacer with the surfa ce-mounted cavity was then placed in the chamber as in the previous t est and the frequency data recorded. As shown on t he right in Fig. 4, the temporary cavity has a turning point at 17.5 C, fully consistent with the previous conclusion of t he TSG spacer CTE based on the model. After the measurement was comp lete, the spacer was removed and an inspection dete rmined that the surface-mounted mirrors were still bonded. (Ou r limited experience to date with KOH bonding on no n-polished surfaces is that the bond does not always set prope rly). The substrates were removed with minimal for ce and appeared unharmed, as did the spacer surface. 4. CONCLUSION A method to incorporate finite element analysis cal culations of deformation at the ends of optical cavities has been presented. This may prove to be a useful tool in the measurement of low-expansion m aterial constants, as similar optical cavity frequency measurements ha ve been used for CTE calibration. The analysis may also be a useful tool for the design of optical cavities with tightl y specified turning point temperatures. The method was used to measure the CTE versus temperature profile of a TSG glass s pacer. Separately, a temporary Fabry-Perot cavity was fabricated on the side of the TSG spacer enabling a second measur ement of the spacer CTE, in very good agreement wit h the first. Such temporary cavities could be used to tighten th e CTE tolerance of prospective pieces of cavity gla ss prior to machining. Together, the analysis method and tight er tolerances on low-expansion CTE materials provid e a path to fabricating optical cavities with temperature indep endence at specified temperatures. This manuscript is a contribution of the U. S. Governmen t and is not subject to copyright. REFERENCES 1 Drever, R. W. P., et al., Laser phase and frequen cy stabilization using an optical resonator, Appl. Phys. B 31, 97 (1983). 2 Young, B. C., Cruz, F. C., Itano, W. M. and Bergqu ist, J. C., Visible Lasers with Subhertz Linewidth s, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82(19) 3799 (1999). 3 Rosenband, T., European Union network for Cold Ato ms and Ultra Precise Atomic Clocks meeting, Porquer olles France, April 2004. 473611800 473611780 473611760 473611740 O ptical Frequency (M H z) 30 28 26 24 22 20 18 16 14 Temperature (C) Fig 4. (Left) A drawing of a saw cut near the f ront of a surface mounted mirror for the purpose of limiting the bonding to the edge nearest the coating. (Right) O ptical frequency versus temperature of a temporary cavity bonded to the TSG spacer using two such saw-cut mir rors. The data points were spaced by 5 minute inte rvals over a three day period except when the laser unlocked. The turning point is approximately 17.5 C, in very good agreement with Fig. 2. 4 Notcutt, M., Ma L.-S., Ye, J. and Hall J. L., Sim ple and compact 1-Hz laser system via an improved m ounting configuration of a reference cavity, Opt. Lett. 30 (14), 1815 (2005). 5 Nazarova, T., Riehle, F. and Sterr, U., Vibration -insensitive reference cavity for an ultra-narrow-l inewidth laser, Appl. Phys. B: Lasers and opt. 83, 531 (2006). 6 Webster, S. A., Oxborrow, M. and Gill, P., Vibrat ion insensitive optical cavity, Phys. Rev. A75, 01 1801(R) (2007). 7 low expansion glasses ULE and TSG are trademarks f or TiO 2-doped silica products of Corning Inc.; Zerodur is a trademark of Schott North America, Inc. Trade name s are used for clarity only and do not imply endors ement. 8 Webster, S. A., Oxborrow, M., Pugla, S., Millo, J. and Gill, P., optical cavit y, Phys. Rev. A77, 033847 (2008). 9 Poli, N., Drullinger, R. A., Ferrari, G., Prevedel li, M., Sorrentino, F., Tarallo, M. G., and G. M. T ino, Prospect for a compact strontium optical lattice clock, Time and Frequency Metrology , Proc. SPIE 6673 (2007). 10 Alnis, J., Matveev, A., Kolachevsky, N., Wilken, T ., Udem, Th. and Hansch, T. W., Sub-Hz line width diode lasers by stabilization to vibrationally and thermally com pensated ULE Fabry-Perot cavities, www.arXiv.org:0 801.4199, Submitted to Applied Physics B (2008). 11 Numata, K., Kemery, A. and Camp, J., Thermal-Nois e Limit in the Frequency Stabilization of Lasers wi th Rigid Cavities, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 250602 (2004). 12 M. Cerdonio, L. Conti, A. Heidmann, and M. Pinard, Thermoelastic effects at low temperatures and qu antum limits in displacement measurements, Phys. Rev. D 63(8) 0 82003 (2001). 13 M. De Rosa, M., Conti, L., Cerdonio, M., Pinard, M . and Marin, F., Experimental Measurement of the D ynamic Photothermal Effect in Fabry-Perot Cavities for Gra vitational Wave Detectors, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 23 7402 (2002). 14 Wong, E. K., Notcutt, M., Taylor, C. T., Mann, A. G. and Blair, D. G., cryog enic Fabry- Perot cavity, App. Opt. 36(33) 8563 (1997). 15 Siegman, Lasers , University Science Books, Mill Valley, CA (1986). 16 Hamilton, C. T., Hrdina, K. and Kenny, S., 2nd Ann ual International Workshop on EUV Lithography, San Francisco, Oct. (2000). 17 Coyne, D., Beamsplitter coating strain induced ra dius of curvature, LIGO document (2005). 18 Okaji, M., Yamada, N., Nara, K. and Kato, H., Las er interferometric dilatometer at low temperatures: application to fused silica SRM 739, Cryogenics 35, 887 (1995). 19 Fox, R. W., Washburn, B. R., Newbury, N. R. and Ho llberg, L., Wavelength references for interferomet ry in air, Appl. Opt. 44(36) 7793 (2005). 20 Reid, S. et al ., Influence of temperature and hydroxide concentratio n on the settling time of bonds, Phys. Lett. A 363(5-6) 341 (2007). See al so Gwo, D. H., U. S. patents 6,284,085 and 6,548,17 6.
|
0807.0656
|
Richard Fox
|
Richard W. Fox
|
Fabry-Perot temperature dependence and surface-mounted optical cavities
|
SPIE Proceedings of Photonics North 2008 Conf., Montreal, June 2008
| null |
10.1117/12.806850
| null |
physics.optics
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
Factors that contribute to the temperature dependence of a resonant frequency
in a low-expansion optical cavity are discussed, including deformation at the
cavity ends due to different coefficients of thermal expansion (CTE) of the
spacer, optically-contacted mirror substrate and coating. A model of the
temperature dependence is presented that incorporates finite-element-analysis
of the cavity ends. A measurement of frequency versus temperature of a cavity
mode is used along with the model to deduce a spacers CTE versus temperature
profile. The measured profile correlates very well with a separate experiment
utilizing a temporary surface-mounted Fabry-Perot cavity fabricated on the
outside of the spacer with hydroxy-catalysis bonding.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 3 Jul 2008 22:14:08 GMT"
}
] | 2015-05-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Fox",
"Richard W.",
""
]
] |
wavelength employed was 2.359 A using a pyroly tic graphite (PG) monochromator, and PG filter to suppress higher-order reflections to achieve a monochromatic incident beam. The diffraction patterns were collected with a 50 ' Soller collimator before the sample, and an 80 ' radial collimator between the sample and the PSD. Data were obtained in steps of 0.25 deg so that the intensity at each scattering angle was measured many times, and then the data were binned to obtain th e diffraction pattern. Measurements of the magnetic scattering vers us temperature were obtained at a fixed angular position and varying the temperatur e. The polycrystalline sample weighed approximately 8.2 g and was prepared using the method described elsewhere [20]. The sample was sealed in an aluminum contai ner with helium exchange gas and mounted on the cold finger of a closed cycle helium re frigerator. Data were collected in the temperature range from 5.5 K to 225 K. III. Experimental Results Figure 1 shows the diffraction data take n at 30 K, which is well above the ordering temperature of Nd in order to av oid possible influence of the Nd moments on the scattering. The Nd sp ins order around 2 K, and this ordering has already been investigated by powder magnetic diffraction, wh ile the iron magnetic order was too weak to be observed [46,47]. In the present work three magnetic peaks originating from the iron spins have been observed between the strong structural Bragg peaks. The intensities of these peaks are considerably weaker than observed in the other materials investigated so far [19, 22, 23] and indicate that the ordere d moment is smaller (for example compare with Fig. 3 of ref. 19). The peaks can be indexed on the basis of the magnetic unit cell that consists of chains of parallel spins along one of the in-plane axes, and antiparallel along the other. This is th e identical spin c onfiguration as found for all the other materials investigated so far. The c-axis, on the other hand, needs to be doubled to describe the magnetic structure, which means that nearest-neighbor spins are antiparallel in that direction. This is the same magne tic structure as obser ved in LaOFeAs [19], which is shown in Fig. 2, with an ordered moment of 0.25(7). The temperature dependence of the magnetic in tensity of the (1,0,3) magnetic peak is shown in Fig. 3. The solid curve is a fit to mean-field theory and gives an estimated ordering temperature of T N=141(6) K. The uncertainty he re represents one standard statistical deviation, and is th e uncertainty indicated throughout this work when error bars are presented. Alternatively, a pow er law fit to the data using ()b2T T IN- , is shown as the dashed curve. The lower temperature data were excluded from the fit since a power law is not expected to valid well away from the critical temperature. This fit yields an orde ring temperature of TN = 143(5) K and b=0.25(4). The value of b is smaller than that expected for a three-dime nsional Heisenberg system, and likely is a reflection of the layered nature of the magnetic system. We remark that when there are two types of magnetic spins in the system, the spins that order at higher temperatures can induce a moment on the spins that order at lower T, such as is found in the related Nd 2CuO 4 material [49,50]. The size of the induced moment is just a reflection of the susceptibility of the Nd, which increases w ith decreasing T. Thus we have also performed mean field fits excluding the data below 30 K, but the fitted value of the 2ordering temperature remained within the stated uncerta inties. We therefore don't believe that the present fits are signi ficantly influenced by the Nd moments. For all of these iron-based undoped systems the magnetic scattering from the iron spins is quite weak, and develops near or below the te mperature of the struct ural phase transition. To establish that this scattering is indeed magnetic in origin and not structural scattering associated with the lattic e distortion, we carried out polarized neutron diffraction measurements with polarization analysis of the scattered neutrons, using He3 polarizers before and after the sample.[51] The polariza tion analysis technique as applied to this problem is in principle straightforward [52,53] . Nuclear coherent Bragg scattering never causes a reversal, or spin-flip, of the neutron spin direction upon scat tering. Thus ideally the nuclear peaks will only be observed in the non-spin-flip scat tering geometry. We denote this configuration as (+ +), where the neutron is incident with up spin, and remains in the up state after scattering. Non-spin-flip scattering also occurs if the incident neutron is in the down state, and remains in th e down state after scattering (denoted ( - -)). The magnetic cross sections, on the other hand, depend on the relative orientation of the neutron polarization P and the reciprocal lattice vector t. In the configuration where Pt, half the magnetic Bragg scatte ring involves a reversal of the neutron spin (denoted by ( - +) or (+ -)), and half does not. Thus for the case of a purely magnetic reflection the spin-flip ( - +) and non-spin-flip (+ +) intensities should be equal in intensity. For the case where Pt, all the magnetic scatteri ng is spin-flip, and should be twice as strong as for the Pt configuration, while ideall y no non-spin-flip scattering will be observed. Fig. 4 shows the data fo r the (1,0,3) magnetic Bragg peak and the (0,0,2) nuclear Bragg peak. The instrumental flipping ratio decreas ed from a high of 17 during the experiment as the He 3 cells relaxed, and for the data in the figure the non-spin- flip to spin-flip scattering fo r the nuclear peak is 10, the inst rumental flipping ratio at that time. This indicates that this peak is indeed purely structural in origin. For the magnetic peak, on the other hand, we see that the peak is observed in the spin-flip scattering geometry, indicating that it has a magnetic contribution. For the Pt configuration the spin-flip scattering is reduced as expected. Note also that the background is lower, which is due to the paramagnetic scattering fr om the Nd spins; paramagnetic scattering follows the same selection rule as the magnetic Bragg scattering, that the spin-flip scattering for the Pt geometry is double the intensity for the Pt geometry. Then the subtraction of the Pt intensity from the Pt intensity eliminates any structural cross sections. The observed peak, (together with the Nd paramagnetic background) confirms that the peak observed in Fig. 3 is magnetic in origin. We remark that in the course of these measur ements we also noted that there is residual scattering in the non-spin-flip ch annel at the position of this magnetic peak, so there is some very weak structural scattering at this position as well. The unpolarized beam measurements indicate that this scattering is still present at 225 K, and hence it is not associated with either the structural or ma gnetic transition. The position of this very small structural peak indexe s precisely with the lattice of the primary phase, and in particular does not coincide w ith any known impurity phases. Therefore we attribute it to scattering from NdOFeAs, which indicates a subtle addition to the crystallographic structure, which has not been studied previously at this level of detail. It is likely that 3single crystals will be necessary to unravel some of these more subtle crystallographic issues in these materials. In summary, we have observed the magneti c ordering of the iron spins in NdOFeAs, which order at 141 K with the same in-plane spin configuration as found for all the systems investigated so far, and with the same antiparallel c-axis arrangement as observed in LaOFeAs. For the cuprate supe rconductors the parent materials are Mott insulators, where a single electron is localized on the Cu site. In the iron-based family of superconductors, on the other hand, the undope d systems are ordered metallic materials, and are better though t of as itinerant electron systems. For the cuprates all the spin structures in the a-b plane are simple coll inear antiferromagnets where nearest neighbors are antiparallel, whil e in the present systems the iron spins only order when the crystal distorts, with the spin s parallel in one direction and antiparallel in the other, as expected from calculations. It is clear that the Fermi surface is playing an essential role in the magnetic ordering, a nd thus with the small moment it may be justified to refer to this state as a spin density wave even though it is commensurate in nature. In addition, correlat ion effects and on-site physics may also play an important role. Upon doping into the superconducting state the crystal di stortion and magnetic order vanish in the system that has so far been investigated [22] , again suggesting that these two phenomena are closely related. In the tetragonal su perconducting state the magnetic interactions are therefore expected to be frustrated, yielding strong spin fluctuations in analogy with the cuprates, and it will be particularly interesting to explore the spin excitations in both the parent and superconducting systems. One of the exciting aspects of these new superconductors is that they belong to a comprehensive class of materials where many chemical substitutions ar e possible. This versatility is already opening up new research avenues to understand the origin of the and should also enable the superconducting prope rties to be tailored for commercial technologies. There is no doubt that the ne wly discovered materials have re-energized the community. IV. Acknowledgements We thank Qingzhen Huang and Yasutomo Uemura for helpful discussions. This work is supported in part by the US National Science Foundation through DMR-0756568, and by the US Department of Energy, Division of Materials Science, Basic Energy Sciences, through DOE The work at the Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, is supported by the National Science Foundation of China, the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the Minist ry of Science and Technology of China. V. References 1) Y. Kamihara, H. Hiramatsu, M. Hirano, R. Kawamura, H. Yanagi, T. Kamiya, and H. Hosono, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128, 10012 (2006). 2) Y. Kamihara, T. Watanabe, M. Hirano, and H. Hosono, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 130, 3296 (2008). 3) H. Takahashi, K. Igawa, K. Arii, Y. Kamihara, M. Hirano, and H. Hasono, Nature 453, 376 (2008). 4) H. H. Wen, G. Xu, L. Fang, H. Yang, and X. Zhu, Europhys. Lett. 82, 17009 (2008). 45) X. H. Chen, T. Wu, G. Wu, R. H. Liu, H. Chen, and D. F. Fang, Nature 453, 761 (2008). 6) Z. A. Ren, J. Yang, W. Lu, W Yi, X. Shen, Z. Li, G. Che, X. Dong, L. Sun, F. Zhou, and Z. Zhao, Europhys. Lett. 82, 57002 (2008). 7) G. F. Chen, Z. Li, D. Wu, G. Li, W. Z. Hu, J. Dong, P. Zheng, J. L. Luo, and N. L. Wang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 247002 (2008). 8) Z. A. Ren, W. Lu, J. Yang, W Yi, X. Shen, Z. Li, G. Che, X. Dong, L. Sun, F. Zhou, and Z. Zhao, Chinese Phys. Lett. 25, 2215 (2008). 9) J. Yang. Z. Li, W. Lu, W. Yi, X. Shen, Z. Ren, G. Che, X. Dong, L. Sun, F. Zhou, and Z. Zhao, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 21, 082001 (2008). 10) P. Cheng, L. Fang, H. X. Yang, X. Zhu, G. Mu, H. Luo, Z. Wang and H. Wen, Science in China G 51, 719 (2008). 11) Z. Ren, J. Yang, W. Lu, W. Yi, G. Ch e, X. Dong, L. Sun, and Z. Zhao, . 12) W. Lu, X-L. Shen, J. Yang, Z.-C. Li, W. Yi, Z.-A. Ren, X.-L. Dong, G.-C. Che, L.-L. Sun, F. Zhou, and Z.-X. Zhao, . 13) C. Wang, L. Li, S. Chi, Z. Zhu, Z. Ren, Y. Li, Y. Wang, X. Lin, Y. Luo, S. Jiang, X. Xu, G. Cao and Z. Xu, . 14) J.-W. G. Bos, G. B. S. Penny, J. A. Rodgers, D. A. Sokolov, A. D. Huxley and J. P. Attfield, . 15) G. Wu, H. Chen, Y. L. Xie, Y. J. Yan, T. Wu, R. H. Liu, X. F. Wang, D. F. Fang, J. J. Ying and X. H. Chen, . 16) C. Wang, L. Li, S. Chi, Z. Zhu, Z. Ren, Y. Li, Y. Wang, X. Lin, Y. Luo, S. Jiang, X. Xu, G. Cao and Z. Xu, . 17) L. Li, Y. Li, Z. Ren, X. Lin, Y. Luo, Z. Zhu, M. He, X. Xu, G. Cao, and Z. Xu, 18) Z.-A. Ren, G. C. Che, X.-L. Dong, J. Yang, W. Lu, W. Yi, X. L. Shen, Z. Li, L. Sun, F. Zhou, and Z. Zhao, Europhysics Letters 83, 17002 (2008). 19) C. de la Cruz, Q. Huang, J. W. Lynn, Jiyi ng Li, W. Ratcliff II, J. L. Zarestky, H. A. Mook, G. F. Chen, J. L. Luo, N. L. Wang, and P. Dai, Nature 453, 899 (2008). 20) J. Dong, H. J. Zhang, G. Xu, Z. Li, G. Li, W. Z. Hu, D. Wu, G. F. Chen, X. Dai, J. L. Luo, Z. Fang, N. L. Wang, Europhysics Letters 83, 27006 (2008). 21) H.-H. Klauss, H. Luetkens, R. Klingeler, C. Hess, F. J. Litterst, M. Kraken, M. M. Korshunov, I. Eremin, S.-L. Drechsler, R. Khasanov, A. Amato, J. Hamann-Borreo, N. Leps, A. Kondrat, G. Behr, J. Werner, and B. Buchner, . 22) J. Zhao, Q. Huang, C. de la Cruz, S. Li, J. W. Lynn, Y. Chen, M. A. Green, G. F. Chen, G. Li, Z. C. Li, J. L. Luo, N. L. Wang, and P. Dai, . 23) Q. Huang, Y. Qiu, W. Bao, J. W. Lynn, M. A. Green, Y. C. Gasparovic, T. Wu, G. Wu, and X. H. Chen, . 24) S. Kitao, Y. Kobayashi, S. Higashitaniguc hi, M. Saito, Y. Kamihara, M. Hirano, T. Mitsui, H. Hosono and M. Seto, . 25) Y. Nakai, K.Ishida, Y. Kamihara, M. Hi rano, and H. Hosono, J. Physical Society Japan 77, in press 526) J. P. Carlo, Y. J. Uemura, T. Goko, G. J. MacDougall, J. A. Rodriguez, W. Yu, G. M. Luke, P. Dai, N. Shannon, S. Miyasaka, S. Suzuki, S. Tajima, G. F. Chen, W. Z. Hu, J. L. Luo, and N. L. Wang, . 27) J. Drew, F. L. Pratt, T. Lancaster, S. J. Bl undell, P. J. Baker, R. H. Liu, G. Wu, X. H. Chen, I. Watanabe, V. K. Malik, A. Dubr oka, K. W. Kim, M. Roessle, and C. Bernhard, . 28) M. A. McGuire, A. D. Christianson, A. S. Se fat, B. C. Sales, M. D. Lumsden, R. Jin, E. A. Payzant, D. Mandrus, Y. Luan, V. Keppens, V. Varadarajan, J. W. Brill, R. P. Hermann, M. T. Sougrati, F. Grandjean, and G. J. Long, . 29) X. C. Wang, Q. Q. Liu, Y. X. Lv, W. B. Gao, L. X.Yang, R. C.Yu, F. Y.Li, and C. Q. Jin, . 30) K. Haule, J. H. Shim, and G. Kotliar, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 226402 (2008). 31) D. J. Singh and M.-H. Du, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 237003 (2008). 32) C. Cao, P. J. Hirschfeld, and H. P. Cheng, Phys. Rev. B 77, 220506(R) (2008). 33) T. Yildirim, Phys. Rev. Lett 101, 057010 (2008) . 34) Z.-Y. Weng, . 35) F. Ma, Z. Lu, and T. Xiang, . 36) Z. P. Yin, S. Lebegue, M. J. Han, B. Neal, S. Y. Savrasov, and W. E. Pickett, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 047001 (2008). 37) S. Ishibashi, K. Terakura, and H. Hosono, . 38) Q. Si and E. Abrahams, . 39) C. Fang, H. Yao, W. F. Tsai, J. P. Hu, and S. A. Kivelson, Phys. Rev. B 77, 224509 (2008). 40) C. K. Xu, M. Muller, and S. Sachdev, . 41) Y. Ran, F. Wang, H. Zhai, A. Vishwanath, and D-H. Lee, . 42) J. S. Wu, P. Phillips, and A. H. Castro Neto, . 43) M. Daghofer, A. Moreo, J. A. Riera, E. Arrigoni, D. J. Scalapino and E. Dagotto, . 44) I. I. Mazin, M. D. Johannes, L. Boeri, K. Koepernik, and D. J. Singh, . 45) H. Nakamura, N. Hayashi, N. Nakai, and M. Machida, . 46) M. Fratini, R. Caivano, A. Puri, A. Ricci , Z. Ren, X. Dong, J. Yang, W. Lu, Z. Zhao, L. Barba, G. Arrighetti, M. Polentarutti, and A. Bianconi, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 21, 092002 (2008). 47) Y. Qiu, Wei Bao, Q. Huang, T. Yildirim, J. Simmons, M. A. Green, J. W. Lynn, Y. C. Gasparovic, J. Li, T. Wu, G. Wu, and X. H. Chen, . 48) S. Skanthakumar, H. Zhang, T. W. Clinton, W-H. Li, J. W. Lynn, Z. Fisk, and S-W. Cheong, Physica C 160, 124 (1989). 49) J. W. Lynn, I. W. Sumarlin, S. Skanthakumar , W-H. Li, R. N. Shelton, J. L. Peng, Z. Fisk, and S-W. Cheong, Phys. Rev. B 41, 2569(R) (1990). 50) W. C. Chen, G. Armstrong, Y. Chen, B. Collett, R. Erwin, T. R. Gentile, G. L. Jones, J. W. Lynn, S. McKenney and J. E. Steinberg, Physica B 397, 168 (2007). 51) R. M. Moon, T. Riste, and W. C. Koehler, Phys. Rev. 181, 920 (1969). 652) See, for example, Q. Huang, P. Karen, V. L. Karen, A. Kjekshus, J. W. Lynn, A. D. Mighell, N. Rosov, and A. Santoro, Phys. Rev. B 45, 9611 (1992). 7Figure Captions Fig. 1. (color online) A portion of the diffraction pattern taken on the BT-7 triple axis spectrometer is shown, indicating the iron magne tic Bragg peaks and the structural peaks in NdOFeAs. The data were collected at 30 K, well above the ordering of the Nd to avoid any significant contributi on from those moments. The structural peaks are labeled using the tetragonal unit cell, while the ma gnetic peaks are indexed with the magnetic unit cell which is twice as long along the c-axis (2c N). Fig. 2. (color online) The an tiferromagnetic spin structure of the iron moments, with moments directed in the a-b plane. The moments are indicated as along one of the axes for illustrative purposes, but it was not possible in these measurements to determine the spin direction within the plane since the magnetic intensit ies were too weak to distinguish a from b. Fig. 3 (color online) Temperature dependen ce of the magnetic intensity of the (1,0,3) peak. The solid curve is a fit to mean fi eld theory to provide an estimate of T N=141(6) K for the ordering temperature. The dashed curve is a power law fit as described in the text. The magnetic intensity is proportional to the square of the ordered (staggered) moment. Fig. 4. (color online) Polarized neutron diffraction results. a) shows the spin flip (solid (red) circles) and non-spin-flip scattering (solid (green) square s) for the (0,0,2) structural peak at ~32 deg the and the magnetic peak at ~34 deg. The ratio of the intensities for the structural peak is just the instrumental flipping ratio, while the ma gnetic peak is observed in the spin-flip scattering. Error bars are sma ller than the data points. b) solid (green) squares are for the Pt configuration and the solid (green) diamonds are for the Pt configuration. The change in the bac kground originates from the (diffuse) paramagnetic scattering of the Nd moments. c) The subtraction of the scattering in the Pt configuration from th e scattering in the P t configuration yields the purely magnetic peak (plus the para magnetic diffuse component). 8 Fig. 1 Fig. 2 9 Fig. 3 Fig. 4 10
|
0807.0662
|
Jeffrey Lynn
|
Ying Chen, J. W. Lynn, J. Li, G. Li, G. F. Chen, J. L. Luo, N. L.
Wang, Pengcheng Dai, C. dela Cruz, and H. A. Mook
|
Magnetic Order of the Iron Spins in NdOFeAs
|
7 pages, 4 figures
|
Phys. Rev. B 78, 064515 (2008)
|
10.1103/PhysRevB.78.064515
| null |
cond-mat.supr-con cond-mat.str-el
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
Polarized and unpolarized neutron diffraction measurements have been carried
out to investigate the iron magnetic order in undoped NdOFeAs.
Antiferromagnetic order is observed below 141(6) K, which is in close proximity
to the structural distortion observed in this material. The magnetic structure
consists of chains of parallel spins that are arranged antiparallel between
chains, which is the same in-plane spin arrangement as observed in all the
other iron oxypnictide materials. Nearest-neighbor spins along the c-axis are
antiparallel like LaOFeAs. The ordered moment is 0.25(7) muB, which is the
smallest moment found so far in these systems.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 4 Jul 2008 16:20:11 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Fri, 22 Aug 2008 19:09:38 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Chen",
"Ying",
""
],
[
"Lynn",
"J. W.",
""
],
[
"Li",
"J.",
""
],
[
"Li",
"G.",
""
],
[
"Chen",
"G. F.",
""
],
[
"Luo",
"J. L.",
""
],
[
"Wang",
"N. L.",
""
],
[
"Dai",
"Pengcheng",
""
],
[
"Cruz",
"C. dela",
""
],
[
"Mook",
"H. A.",
""
]
] |
I. Introduction To discover the signature of new physics beyond the standard model(SM)[1, 2] is one of the main goals for the forthcoming collider experiments. Th e precision measurements of the trilinear gauge-boson couplings are helpful for veri fication of non-abelian gauge structure, and the investigation of the quartic gauge-boso n couplings can either confirm the symmetry breaking mechanism or present the direct test o n the new physics beyond the SM[3]. The direct study of quartic gauge-boson coupling s requires the the processes involving at least three external gauge-bo sons. In Refs.[4, 5, 6, 7, 8], the precise predictions for the VVVproductions at hadron colliders were provided. It shows that the QCD corrections increase the WWZcross section at the LHC by more than 70%, and the QCD corrections to ZZZproduction at the LHC increase the LO cross section by about 50% [6]. Thus, any quantitative measurement of the c oncerned gauge couplings will have to take QCD corrections into account, Due to heavy backgrounds, the precise measurement at a hadro n collider is more difficult than at linear collider. The proposed Internationa l Linear Collider (ILC) by the particle physics community will be built with the entire col liding energy in the range of 200GeV <s <500GeVand an integrated luminosity of around 500 ( fb)-1in four years. The machine should be upgradeable tos~1TeVwith an integrated luminosity of 1 (ab)-1in three years[9]. Among all the ILC physics goals, the verifi cation of gauge theory in the SM and finding the evidence of new physics via exp erimental measurement of the electroweak gauge boson couplings are crucial tasks t oo. The measurement will be able to be improved considerably at ILC compared with at Ferm ilab Tevatron and CERN LHC, and therefore a precise understand of the SM phenomenol ogy at ILC to at least one-loop order is necessary[10]. Without the accurate theo retical predictions and reliable error estimates for important observables at ILC, it is impo ssible to interpret ofvecto r bosons 2at ILC is not only an important process as a background for var ious new physics processes, but also possible to provide further tests for the quadrilin ear gauge boson the four gauge boson coupling, such as between ZZZZ, which does not exist at tree-level in the SM, because this kind of quadrilinear coup lings would induce deviations from the SM predicted this paper we present the calculations of the cross sectio ns for the process e+e-- Z0Z0Z0at the leading order(LO) and involving complete electrowea k (EW) corrections. The paper is organized as follows: In the nex t section we present the calculation descriptions for the tree-level process e+e--Z0Z0Z0. The calculation of the electroweak corrections at one-loop level is reporte d in section III. The and discussions are given in section IV. In the last s ection we give a short summary. II. Leading-order the calculations of the tree-level and one-loop level cro ss sections for the we use the 't Hooft-Feynman gauge. The analyticall y calculation of the leading order cross section for is presented in this section. We describethe lowest order adopted for evaluating the cross (2.1) wherepi(i= 1-5) label the four-momenta of incoming positron, electron an d respectively. Since the mass of electron/positro n is negligible comparing with the colliding energy and the Yukawa coupling strength betwe en Higgs/Goldstone and fermions is proportional to the fermion mass, in our work we i gnore the contributions of the Feynman diagrams involving the couplings of We depict the tree-level Feynman diagrams contributing to the cross section of the three Z0-bosonsat theILCinFig.1. Therewe have l diagrams for the process e+e--Z0Z0Z0in the framework of the SM. All the Born-level 1: The generic tree-level Feynman diagrams for . can be grouped in two different topologies. Figs.1(a-c) belon g to s-channel, Figs.1(d-i) are grouped in t(u)-channel. The differential cross section for t he process tree-level is then obtained (2.2) whereMLOis the amplitude of all the tree-level diagrams in Fig.1. The due to three identical final Z0-bosons and spin-averaging of the initial The summation in Eq.(2.2) is taken over the sp ins of the initial and final particles, and dPh3is the three-particle phase space element defined (2.3) III. Electroweak ( O(aew)) order electroweak corrections to the Born-level consist of two parts, i.e.,
*The virtual contributions to the leading order process e+e--Z0Z0Z0from the electroweak one-loop and their corresponding counterterm fromthe real photonemission process e+e--Z0Z0Z0g. Thesoft photon emission process e+e--Z0Z0Z0(g) consists IR singularities, which will be cancelled ofth eone-loop diagrams. There is no collinear IR singularity since we keep the nonzero mass of the following subsections, we describe in detail the calc ulation procedure and discuss the calculation of each contribution part. III..1 Virtual are totally 2313 electroweak one-loop and correspond ing counterterm Feynman diagrams being taken into account in our calculation, and th ey can be classified into self- energy, triangle, box, pentagon and counterterm diagrams. We depict some among 66 pentagon diagrams in Fig.2. In our calculat ion of the corrections to , all the one-loop Feynman diagrams and their relevant amplitudes are created by using FeynArts 3.3[12], and the Feynman ampli- tudes are subsequently implemented by applying FormCalc5. 3 programs[13] and our in- house routines. The electroweak one-loop amplitude involv es five point tensor integrals up to rank 4. The numerical calculation of the integral functio ns(n<=4) are implemented by using the expressions presented in Refs.[14, 15]. We use our independent Fortran subrou- tines following the expressions for the scalar and tensor fiv e-point integrals in Ref.[16], and find agreement with The Grace2.2.1 progr am[17] is used to phase-space integration for hard photon radiatio n process total unrenormalized amplitude corresponding to all th e one-loop Feynman di- agrams contains both ultraviolet (UV) and infrared (IR) sin gularities. We regulate adopting dimensional s cheme [21] where the dimensions of spinor and space-time manifolds are extended to D= 4-2o. The relevant fields are renormalized by taking the on-mass-shell (OMS) scheme [22, 23]. The IR singularity is regularized by introducing a infinitesimal fictitious mass mg. All the tensor 2: Some representative pentagon Feynman diagrams fo r the process the one-loop integrals can be calculated by using the redu ction formulae presented in Refs.[16, 24]. As we expect, the UV divergence contributed b y virtual one-loop diagrams can be cancelled by that contributed from the counterterms e xactly both analytically Real photon emission process e+e--Z0Z0Z0g In our calculation for one-loop diagrams, there exists soft IR divergence. In order to get an IR finite cross section for e+e--Z0Z0Z0up to the order of O(a4 ew), we should corrections to due to real photon emission. The soft IR divergence in virtual photonic corrections for the p be exactly cancelled by adding the real photonic bremsstrahlu ng corrections to this process in the soft photon limit. In the real photon emission (3.1) a real photon radiates from the and can b e soft or hard. The (PSS) method [25] is adopted to isolat e the soft photon emission sin- gularity part in the real photon emission process e+e--Z0Z0Z0g, and the cross section of the real photon emission process (3.1) is decomposed into soft and hard terms sreal= (3.2) where the 'soft' and 'hard' describe the energy nature of the radiated photon. The energy E6of the radiated photon in the center of mass system(c.m.s.) f rame is considered soft ifE6<=E, and hard if E6>E, respectively. Then both sSandsHshould depend on the arbitrary soft cutoff dsE/Eb, whereEbis the electron beam energy in the c.m.s. frame and equals tos/2, but the total cross section of the real photon cutoff E/Ebindependent. Since the soft cutoff E/Ebis taken to be a small value in our calculations, the terms of order E/Ebcan be neglected and the soft contribution can be evaluated by using the soft photon a pproximation 23, (3.3) Our calculation demonstrates that the IR singularity in the soft contribution from Eq.(3.3) is cancelled exactly with that from the virtual pho tonic corrections. Therefore, sv+ sreal, the sum of the O(a4 ew) cross section corrections from virtual, soft and hard photon emission contribution parts, is independent of the cutoff value ds. The which is UV and IR finite, is computed by using t he Monte Carlo the electroweak corrected cross section for the up to the order of O(a4 ew) can be obtained (3.4) III..3 QED and total O(aew)order corrections In analyzing the originations of the electroweak correctio ns, we split the full to the process e+e--Z0Z0Z0into two parts, the QED correction part and the weak correction part. Correspondingly we define the t otal relative correction The QED correction part is contributed by the diagrams with virtual photon in loop, and real photon emission process e+e--Z0Z0Z0g. For the countert- erms involved in the QED contribution, the electron/positr on wave function constants include only photonic contribution. The rem ainders of the total corrections belong to weak correction part. Wi th above definitions we can ex- press the full one-loop electroweak corrected total cross s ection as a summation of =sLO(1+dtot), corrections diagrams and the soft photon emission process resp ectively, sv,QED, ss, sh 8and sv,weakare the corrections from the virtual QED contribution, the s oft photon emission process, the hard photon emission process and the v irtual weak the relative corrections contributed by the QED correction part, theweak correction part andthetotal elec troweak correction, respectively. As we mentioned above, there exist both ultraviolet(UV) div ergency and singularity in the contributions of the electroweak on e-loop diagrams for but no collinear IR singularity since we keep the no nzero mass of in our calculation of one-loop order correct ions. After doing the procedure, we verified that the UV singularity is vanished, and the IR soft divergency appeared in the virtual correction is cancelled by the the soft photon order to discuss the origin of the large correction when th e colliding energy is close to the threshold of the production of three Z0-bosons, we discuss the photonic (QED) corrections and the genuine total electroweak correc tions separately. The QED corrections comprise two parts: the QED virtual correction s sv,QEDwhich contributed by the loop diagrams with virtual photon exchange in loop and the corresponding QED parts of the counterterms, and the real photon emission corr ections sreal. Therefore, the QED relative correction dQEDcan be expressed sv,QED/sLO, and the genuine weak relative correction dwcan be (3.7) IV. Numerical results and discussion For the numerical calculation, we take the input parameters as follows[27]: me= 0.51099892 MeV , mu= 105.658369 MeV , mt= 1776.99 MeV, 9mu= 66 MeV , m c= 1.25 GeV, m t= 174.2 GeV, md= 66 MeV , m s= 95 MeV , m b= 4.7 GeV, mW= 80.403 GeV , m Z= 91.1876 GeV . (4.1) There we use the experimental value of W-boson mass as input p arameter, but not the mWevaluated from Guas inaewscheme[28]. We take the electric charge defined in the Thomson limit aew(0) = 1/137.036 and the effective values of the light quark masses ( mu andmd) which can reproduce the hadronic contribution to the shift in the fine aew(m2 Z) [29]. As we know that the LEP II experiments provide the lowe r limit on the SM Higgs mass as 114 .4GeVat the 95% confidence level from the results of direct searches for 31], and the electroweak indicate indirectly the upper bound as the 95% C.L., when the lower limit on mHis used in determination of this upper limit[31]. Therefore , in our numerical evaluation it is reasonable to take the mass of Higgs-boson being in the range of 115 GeV < m H<170GeV. Then we shall not encounter the resonance problem of Higgs-boson during our calculation. We checked the correctness of the numerical results of the LO cross section for by [12 , 13] In adopting Grace2.2.1 and alc5.3 programs, we used both 't Hooft-Feynman andunitary gauges separately in the calcu lations of the LO cross section to check the gauge invariance, and we got coincident numeric al results. The oftheLOcrosssection fortheprocess e+e--Z0Z0Z0, and takings= 500GeVand the other input parameters shown in Eqs.(4.1), are listed in Table 1. There it is shown that there is a good agreem ent between the by adopting different packages. Inthe one-loop calculation, we must set the values of theIR r egulator mg, mass, and soft cutoff ds= E/Ebbesides the parameters mentioned in Eqs.(4.1). As we know, the total cross section should have no relation wi th these two parameters sLO(fb) (FeynArts) 115 1.0056(4) 1.0055(2) 120 1.0139(4) 1.0138(2) 150 1.0975(4) 1.0975(2) 170 1.2565(4) 1.2564(2) Table 1: The numerical results of the LO cross sections for th e process e+e--Z0Z0Z0 by using Grace2.2.1 and alc5.3 packages separately, and taking the input parameters as shown in Eqs.(4.1) ands= 500GeV. the IR divergency does really vanish. Our numerical results show that the cross at O(a4 ew) order stot= sreal+svis invariable within the calculation errors whenmH= 120GeV,s= 500GeV,ds= 10-3and the fictitious photon mass mgvaries from 10-15GeVto presents a verification of the correctness of our ca lculation for process O(aew) order corrections. The amplified curve for errors is depicted in Fig.3(b). Both figures are to show the independenceof the totalO(aew) electroweak correction on the soft cutoff ds, when we take mH= 120 GeV ands= 500 GeV. From Fig.3(b) we can say that the total EW relative c no relation to the value of dswithin the calculation error range. In the we set mg= 10-2GeVandds= 10-3. In Table 2, we list some representative numerical results of the LO and one-loop EW corrected cross sections( sLO,stot), the QED and total EW corrections to the cross sections for ( sQED, stot), and their corresponding dQED,dtot) whens= 500GeVand the values of Higgs-boson mass are taken to be 115 GeV, 150GeVand From these data we can see that the one-loop EW corrections suppressthe LO cross section of the process e+e--Z0Z0Z0 , and the relative corrections are about minus few percent. W e can conclude also the LO and EW corrected cross sections increase with the increment ofmH, while the absolute total EW correction decreases when the value of Higgs-boson mass goes /s45/s51/s46/s56 /s45/s51/s46/s54 /s45/s51/s46/s52 /s45/s51/s46/s50 /s45/s51/s46/s48 /s45/s50/s46/s56 /s115 /s45/s51/s46/s56 /s45/s51/s46/s54 /s45/s51/s46/s52 /s45/s51/s46/s50 /s45/s51/s46/s48 /s45/s50/s46/s56 /s45/s50/s46/s54 /s45/s51/s46/s56 /s45/s51/s46/s54 /s45/s51/s46/s52 /s45/s51/s46/s50 /s45/s51/s46/s48 /s45/s50/s46/s56 /s45/s50/s46/s54 /s104 3: (a) Thedependenceof the O(aew) correction to cross section of e+e--Z0Z0Z0 on the soft cutoff dswithmH= 120GeVands= 500GeV. (b) the amplified plot of the curve for the total correction stotin Fig.3(a), where it includes calculation 1.0055(2) 0.9159(7) -0.0451(7) -0.0896(7) -4.49(7) -8.91(7) 150 1.0975(2) 1.0194(8) -0.0444(8) -0.0780(8) -4.04(7) -7.11(7) 170 1.2564(2) 1.1989(9) -0.0393(8) -0.0575(9) -3.12(7) -4.58(7) Table 2: The numerical results of sLO,stot, sQED, stot(in femto bar), and relative EW and QED corrections( dtot,dQED) for the process e+e-- Z0Z0Z0, whens= 500GeVandmH= /s53/s48/s48 /s54/s48/s48 /s55/s48/s48 /s56/s48/s48 /s57/s48/s48 /s53/s48/s48 /s54/s48/s48 /s55/s48/s48 /s56/s48/s48 /s57/s48/s48 4: (a) The LO( sLO),O(aew) EW, QED corrected cross sections( stot,sQED) for the process e+e--Z0Z0Z0as the functions of colliding energyswithmH= (b) The corresponding relative EW, QED relativ e corrections( dtot, dQED) versuss. The numerical results of the LO, O(aew) EW, QED corrected cross sections( sLO,stot, sQED) and the total relative EW, QED corrections( dtot,dQED) for the process 120GeV,150GeVas the functions of colliding in Figs.4(a) and (b) respectively. As indicated in F ig.4(a), The curves for the cross sections of quickly in thesregion of [350 GeV,550GeV] and decrease whens >600GeV. The two figures show the O(aew) corrections always suppress the corresponding LO cross sections of process e+e--Z0Z0Z0in both cases ofmH= 120GeVandmH= but the QED correction parts can enhance the LO cross sections whens >700GeV. We can read out from Fig.4(b) that the corresponding total EW relative corrections for mH= 120GeVand 150 GeVvary in the ranges of [ -15.8%,-7.5%] and [ -13.9%,-6.2%] respectively, whensruns from 350GeVto 1TeV. We can see also from these two plots that in the colliding ene rgys region near the threshold of the production of three Z0-bosons, the main contribution to the total EW relative correction( dtot) comes from the QED correction part. That is due to the Coulomb singularity effect coming from the instantaneous photon exchange in loops which has a small spatial momentum. 13/s48 /s53/s48 /s49/s48/s48 /s49/s53/s48 /s100/s112/s90 5: The distributions of the transverse momenta of Z0-bosons ( PZ T) at the LO and up to EW one-loop order with mH= 120GeVands= 500GeV. We present the distributions of the transverse momenta of fin alZ0-bosons at leading order and up to one-loop order, whenmH= Fig.5. There we pick the pZ Tof each of the three Z0-bosons as an entry in this histograms, then the final result of the differential cross sec tion is obtained by 1/3. In this figure we can see that the EW one-loop correction sup presses obviously the LO differential cross section but the EW correction is small when pZ T<25GeV. It also shows that the EW corrections do not observably chan ge the LO distribution line-shape of pZ T, and both the differential cross sections of their maximal values at about plot the distributions of the invariant mass of Z0Z0-pair, denoted as MZZ, at the LO and up to EW one-loop order with mH= 120GeVands= 500GeVin Fig.6. Here we can see that the EW correction slightly enhances the L O differential cross but suppresses when MZZ>250GeV. The suppression of dsLO/dMZZis due to the contribution from the hard photon theO(a4 ew) order, in which the momentum balance /s50/s48/s48 /s50/s53/s48 /s51/s48/s48 /s51/s53/s48 /s52/s48/s48 6: The distributions of the invariant mass of Z0Z0-pair(MZZ) at the LO and up to EW one-loop order when mH= 120GeVands= 500GeV. the sum of the momenta of three Z0-bosons and that of the radiated hard photon will reduce the value of invariant mass MZZand change the line-shape in the range with large MZZ. V. Summary In this paper we describe the impact of the complete one-loop EW corrections to the scattering process e+e--Z0Z0Z0in the SM. This channel can be used to measure the quartic vector boson coupling at ILC. We investigate the dep endence of the LO, O(aew) EW and QED corrected cross sections on colliding energysand Higgs-boson mass, and present the LO and EW one-loop corrected distributions of th e transverse momenta and the LO and EW corrected differential cross section s of invariant To see the origin of some of the large corrections clea rly, we calculate the QED and genuine weak corrections separately. We conclude th at both the Born cross section and the EW corrected cross section for are sensitive to 15the Higgs boson mass in the range of 115 GeV < m H<170GeV. We find the generally suppress the LO cross section, the LO distribution of the momenta of Z0-bosons and the LO differential cross sections of invariant ma ss ofZ0Z0-pair for Our numerical results show that when mH= 120GeV(150GeV) and the colliding energy goes up from 350 GeVto 1TeV, the relative EW correction This work was supported in part by the National Natural Scien ce Foundation of China, Specialized Research Fund for the Doct oral Program of and a special fund sponsored by Chinese Ac ademy of S. L. Glashow, Nucl. Phys. B 22(1961) 579 ; S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19(1967) 1264; A. Salam, in Proceedings of the 8th Nobel Symposium , Stockholm, 1968, edited by N. Svartholm (Almquist and Wiksells, Stockholm, 1968), p .367; H. D. Politzer, Phys. Rep. 14(1974) 129. [2] P. W. Higgs, Phys. Lett 12(1964) 132, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13(1964) 508 ; Phys. Rev. 145(1966) 1156; F. Englert and R. Brout, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13(1964) 321; G. S. Guralnik, C. R. Hagen, and T. W. B. Kibble, ibid.13(1964) 585 ; T. W. B. Kibble, Phys. Rev. 155(1967) 1554. [3] T. Han, H.-J. He, and C.-P. Yuan, Phys. Lett. B422(1998) J. Ohnemus, L.J. Dixon, Z. Kunsz t and A. Signer, Phys. Rev. D60(1999) 114037, L.J. Dixon, Z. Kunsz t and A. Signer, Nucl. Phys. B531(1998) 3, J. Ohnemus, Phys. Rev. D50 (1994) 1931, Phys.Rev. D60(1999) 113006, A. Lazopoulos, K. Melnikov and F. Petriello, Phys. Rev. D76(2007) V. Hankele and D. Zeppenfeld, KA-TP-35-2007, SFB/CPP-0 7-94, J.Bagger, V. Barger, K. Cheung, J.Gunion, T.Han, G.A. Ladinsky, R. Rosenfeld, and C.-P. Yuan, Phys. Rev. D49(1994) 1246; D52(1995) 3878. [8] T. Binoth, G. Ossola, C.G. Papadopoulos and R. Pittau, JH EP0806, 082 O.J.P. Eboli, M.C. Gonzalez-Garcia, S.M. Lietti and S. F. Novaes, Phys. Rev. D63 (2001) 075008, D. Green, arXiv:hep M.Baillargeon, F. Boudjema, F.Cuypers, E. Gabrielli, and B. Mele, Nucl. Phys. B424 (1994) 343; Y.-J. Zhou,W.-G. Ma, R.-Y. Zhang, Y. Jiang, and L . Han, Phys. T. Hahn, Comput. Phys. Commun. T. Hahn, M. Perez-Victoria, Comput. Phys. Commun. G.'t Hooft and M. Veltman, Nucl. Phys. B153(1979) 365. [15] A. Denner, U Nierste and R Scharf, Nucl. Phys. B367(1991) 637. [16] A. Denner and S. Dittmaier, Nucl. Phys. B658(2003) 175. [17] T. Ishikawa, et collaboration) GRACE User's manual versio n 2.0, August 1, 1994. [18] G. 't Hooft and M. Veltman, Nucl. Phys. B44, (1972) 189. 17[19] D. A. Ross and J. C. Taylor, Nucl. Phys. B51, (1979) 25. [20] A. Denner, Fortschr. Phys. 41, (1993) 307, G. 't Hooft and M. Veltman, Nucl. Phys. B44, (1972) 189. [22] D. A. Ross and J. C. Taylor, Nucl. Phys. B51, (1979) 25. [23] A. Denner, Fortschr. Phys. 41, (1993) 307. [24] G. Passarino and M. Veltman, Nucl. Phys. B160, (1979) 151. [25] W. T. Giele and E. W. N. Glover, Phys. Rev. D46, (1992) 1980; W. T. Giele, E. W. Glover and D. A. Kosower, Nucl. Phys. B403, 1993) 633. [26] G. 't Hooft and Veltman, Nucl. Phys. B153, (1979) 365. [27] W.M. Yao, et al., J. of Phys. G33(2006) 1. [28] G. Eilam, P.R. Mendel, R. Migneron, and A. Soni, Phys. Re v. F. Jegerlehner, Report No. DESY 01-029, arXiv:hep-ph/ 0105283v1. [30] R.Barate et al., Phys. Lett. B565(2003) 61. [31] The LEP Collaborations ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, OPAL, and the LEP Group. LEPEWWG/2007-01 and
|
0807.0669
|
Su Jijuan
|
Su Ji-Juan, Ma Wen-Gan, Zhang Ren-You, Wang Shao-Ming, Guo Lei
|
Complete one-loop electroweak corrections to $ZZZ$ production at the ILC
|
18 pages,8 figures, to appear in Physical Review D
|
Phys.Rev.D78:016007,2008
|
10.1103/PhysRevD.78.016007
| null |
hep-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study the complete ${\cal O}(\alpha_{ew})$ electroweak (EW) corrections to
the production of three $Z^0$-bosons in the the framework of the standard
model(SM) at the ILC. The leading order and the EW next-to-leading order
corrected cross sections are presented, and their dependence on the colliding
energy $\sqrt{s}$ and Higgs-boson mass $m_{H}$ is analyzed. We investigate also
the LO and one-loop EW corrected distributions of the transverse momentum of
final $Z^0$ boson, and the invariant mass of $Z^0Z^0$-pair. Our numerical
results show that the EW one-loop correction generally suppresses the
tree-level cross section, and the relative correction with $m_{H}=120 GeV(150
GeV)$ varies between $-15.8%(-13.9%)$ and $-7.5%(-6.2%)$ when $\sqrt{s}$ goes
up from $350 GeV$ to $1 TeV$.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 4 Jul 2008 03:27:18 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Ji-Juan",
"Su",
""
],
[
"Wen-Gan",
"Ma",
""
],
[
"Ren-You",
"Zhang",
""
],
[
"Shao-Ming",
"Wang",
""
],
[
"Lei",
"Guo",
""
]
] |
2 k-mesh. The lattice constants of the doped systems are fixed to those of the undoped hosts since changes only marginally the lattice constant [7, 9]. Tocomparethe dopabilityofCuin bulk GaNandGaN NWs and identify stable dopant position, we first calcu- late the formation energy of Cu substitution for Ga in GaN host as Hf=E(GaN : Cu) -E(host)+ u(Ga)-u(Cu)
= : Cu) is the total energy of the doped sys- tem,E(host) denotes the total energy of the GaN host for the same supercell in the absence of the defect, u(Ga) andu(Cu) are the chemical potential for Ga and Cu, re- spectively. We note that the absolute formation energy depends on u(Ga) and u(Cu). However, it is sufficient to calculate Efor the purpose of comparing the rela- tive stability of Cu in GaN host. For a NW as shown in Fig. 1(a) and (b), there are three inequivalent Ga po- sitions, i.e., A, B, and C. In all cases, we confirm that Cu will not form AX center in GaN due to the delocal- ization of the Cu 3d related defect bands. Our results are reported in Table. I. For bare GaN NW, we find that the Gais smaller than that in the bulk. The loweringof the most dramatic at the surface of the NW, where the formation energy is about 0.96 eV smaller. For the passivated GaN NW, we find that the formation energy of Cu Gais about 0.3 eV largerthan that in bulk GaNand is most stable at the A site. This result follow the general trends observed in nanocrystal quantum dots [16] suggesting that the in- creased formation energy for this non-isovalent dopants is mainly due to the quantum band gap increase, but not sensitive to the shape of the quan- tum structure. The above results show that the doping ability of Cu in GaN NW depends sensitively on the sur- face termination of the NW. We also find that in all cases with an isolated Cu atom in GaN hosts, the total mag- netic moment is 2 uBand the local moment on Cu is about 0.65 uBdue to the strong Cu 3d and N 2p hy- bridization the valence state of Cu in Cu doped GaN NW is found to be close to that of Cu in CuO [11]. To confirm this theoretically, we calculate the charge tranfer in Cu doped NWs using atoms in molecules (AIM) theory [17]. We find that the valence state of Cu dopant in bare (passivated) GaN NW is about 0.84 (0.88). For CuO and Cu 2O, the calculated Cu valence state is 0.99 and 0.55, respectively. So, the valence state of Cu dopant in GaN NW is indeed close to that in CuO. The calculated valence state is not close to the nominal value due to the strong covalency in the system. The results also indicate that Cu occupies Ga site in the ex- perimental sample [11].To investigate the interaction between Cu dopants in GaN NWs, we substitute two Ga atoms with two Cu atoms. The most stable configuration of two Cu atoms in GaN NWs is shown in Fig. 1. We can see that two Cu atomstend to be next to eachother, i.e., they arebonded to the same N atom. This is due to the strong between Cu 3d tstates. In case of passivated NW, both Cu atoms occupied A positions. In contrast, these Cu atoms occupied C positions for the bare GaN NW case. This is understandable since an isolated Cu atom prefers to occupy the C (A) position in case of GaN GaN NWs is studied through calculating different spin states, i.e., ferromagnetic (FM) and states. In case of Cu doped passivated GaN NW (Fig. 1(d)), the FM state with a total moment 2.8 uBis more favorable over the AFM state by 90 and 31 meV for the unrelaxed and relaxed structures, for the doped bare GaN NW as shown in Fig. 1(c), it is a non-magnetic semiconductor with a gap of 0.44 eV within the d bands. To probe the origin of the different nature of magnetism in these two cases, we plot the density of states (DOS) in Fig. 2. To facilitate the analysis, the DOSs of the systems with an isolated Cu dopant are also shown. In both cases, we can see that there is a band gap in the spin up component. In case of the passivated NW, the spin down torbitals (In the crystal field of a wurtzite system, 3d orbitals are split- ted into low-lying two-fold estates and three nearly de- generated torbitals) are partially occupied. However, when a Cu atom occupies the surface position [position C in Fig. 1(a)] of the bare GaN NW, the different crys- tal field arising from a missing neighbor N atom at the surface will split the torbitals into a low-lying one-fold aand a high-lying two-fold e'sets. The presence of the band gap is consistent with the stability of the surface Cu atom. When the two Cu dopants are next to each other [Fig. 1(c)], the coupling between two Cu will result in a splitting between the bonding and anti-bonding orbitals. Since the distance between two Cu atoms in bare NW is only 2.93 @A (the Cu-Cu dis- tance in bulk GaN and passivated GaN NW are 3.13 @A and 3.12 @A respectively), the splitting will be largerthan the spin resulting in the low spin non- magnetic state. Similar results are observed in turnthe system from a high-spin to a low-spin configuration, diminish the fer- romagnetism [5, 18]. Our calculations reveal that passi- vation of the surface is crucial in this system to Cu doped GaN NWs. It is noted that previous theoretical studies focused only on TM (Mn [19] and Cr [20]) doped GaN bareNWs. In addition, the cou- pling between a pair of Cr atoms substituted in unsatu- rated GaN nanoholes was found to be FM [21]. To comparethe different magnetic behaviorofCu dop-3 TABLE I: Relative formation energy Eof an isolated Cu Ga defect in bare andpassivated GaN NWs. Please refer to Fig. 1 for the definition of positions A, B, and C. Eis related to the absolute formation energy Hby Eq. 1. For bulk GaN, Eof an isolated Cu Gadefect is 3.33 eV. site A site B site C Bare NW 3.05 3.27 2.37 Passivated NW 3.52 3.68 1: (a) Top view of a bare GaN NW with a atoms, (c) side view of the most stable configuration of two substitutional Cu atoms in the bare GaN NW, (d) side view of the most stable configuration of two substitutional C u atoms in a passivated GaN NW, (e) side view of a 3 x3x2 bulk GaN supercell, and (f) top view of a configuration of two substitutional Cu atoms in a passivated GaN NW with a larger diameter 1.6 nm. A, B, and C in (a) and (b) denote three inequivalent Ga positions. The numbers in (c) and (d) give the distance (in @A) between two Cu dopants. Number 1, 2 , and 3 in (e) label different Ga atoms in the supercell. ing in bulk GaN and GaN NW, we also study the in bulk GaN. First, we find that Cu dopants in bulk GaN also tend to be nearest neighbor. The most favorable configuration is that two Cu atoms occupy the in-plane nearest neighbor positions [positions 1 and 2 in Fig. 1(e)] with a magnetic moment of 0.6 uB/Cu. How- ever, the energy difference between the FM and the AFM state in this configuration is only -1.6 meV (the value for the unrelaxed structure is 10.5 meV), which is -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 Energy (eV)-6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 Energy (eV)TDOS Cu 3d N 2pTDOS Cu1 3d Cu2 3d N 2p(a) (c) (d) (e) tte a e' FIG. 2: DOS of (a) a bare GaN NW with an isolated Cu dopant at the C position (Fig. 1(a)), (b) a bare GaN NW with two Cu dopants (Fig. 1(c)), (c) a passivated GaN NW with an isolated Cu dopant at theA position (Fig. 1(b)), (d) a passivated GaN NW with two Cu dopants (Fig. 1(d)), (e) an isolated (Fig. 1(e)), and(f ) two Cu dopants at positions 1 and 2 in a bulk GaN supercell (Fig. 1(e)), respectively. Here, high energy conduction ba nds of GaN hosts are not shown. smaller than that in passivated NW and in the case when the Cu-Cu distance is about 6.2 @A[7]. In some other we find that the AFM state could be even more stable than the FM state. For instance, if two Cu atoms occupy positions 1 and 3 [Fig. 1(e)], the FM state has higher energy by 41 meV. These results indicate that FM in Cu doped bulk GaN is not robust, which is consis- tent with experimental observations and the recent cal- culations of Rosa and Ahuja [10]. To unravel the origin of the different behavior of Cu dopants in bulk GaN and passivated GaN NWs, we il- lustrate the DOS of the torbitals near the fermi level in Fig. 3. For the isolated Cu dopant, the main differ- ence between bulk GaN:Cu and GaN:Cu NW is that the band width of the tstates is smaller in NWs than that in bulk GaN (0.13 eV v.s. 0.53 eV) due to the quasi-1D nature of NWs. The DOSs for an isolated Cu in bulk GaN and GaN NWs resemble those shown in Fig. 3(a) and (d), respectively. When two Cu dopants are close to each other, the torbitals in the same spin will couple to each other, resulting in a low-lying bonding set and a high-lying anti-bonding one in the FM state, broaden- ing the band. This stabilize the FM state over the AFM state due to the more occupation of the spin-down bond-4 ing orbitals than the anti-bonding state [6, 22]. However, it also increases the overlapping between the spin-up the spin- up states to spin-down states as shown in [Fig. 3(b) and (e)], bulk GaN than in GaN NW because the band width in bulk GaN is wider. The reduced magnetic moment further leads to a reduced exchange splitting and more charge transfer. The final DOSs of the FM state for two Cu atoms in bulk GaN is shown in Fig. 3(c). This ex- plains why Cu-Cu pairs in bulk GaN has a very small magnetic moment when the Cu-Cu distance is small for bulk GaN:Cu, when Cu-Cu distance is small, the coupling between Cu dorbital is large, but the magnetic moment is recovered, but the dorbital cou- pling becomes small. On the other hand, the Cu torbital band width is much smaller in GaN NW, thus the charge transfer and reduction of magnetic moment is small in GaN:Cu NWs even when the Cu-Cu distance is small [Fig. 3(f)]. This explains why magnetization and ferro- magnetism is enhanced in GaN:Cu NWs. Due to the configurational entropy, Cu dopants might have many different configurations in GaN NWs growth condition. Here to examine the dependence of the magnetic properties on the configu- ration, we study all possible inequivalent configurations in total) of two Cu atoms in passi- vated GaN NW. To reduce the computational amount, no structural relaxation is performed. It turns out that in all cases, FM is always preferred over the AFM state, as shown in Fig. 4. Interestingly, the maximum magni- tude of the energy difference occur at some configura- tions with the Cu-Cu distance about 6 @A, instead of the nearest neighbor configurations. This is because when the Cu-Cu distance is smaller than 6 @A the magnetic moment start to decrease, thus reducing the as discussed above. However, unlike in bulk GaN:Cu, the energy difference is still negative and large at nearest neighbor Cu-Cu distance. Thus FM in Cu doped passivated GaN NW is robust with respect to in GaN NWs. In the experimental work by Seong et al.[11], the di- ameter of the GaN NW is larger than that of the NW we discussed above. Here to investigate the magnetic inter- action between Cu dopants in larger GaN NWs, we also consider two Cu dopants in passivated GaN NW with a diameter about 1.6 nm, as shown in Fig. 1(f). From our calculation, the FM state is more stable by 75 and 54 meV than the AFM state for the unrelaxed and re- laxed structures, respectively. So the change of between Cu atoms in GaN NW is not very significant when the diameter of the NW changes. In summary, we explained why the ferromagnetism of GaN:Cu is enhanced in passivated GaN NWs. We show W WEX Fix EXFix EX Change EX Change EX(a) (d)(b) (c) (e) (f) FIG. 3: Schematic illustration of the origin of the behavior between Cu doped passivated GaN NW and Cu doped bulk GaN. (a) shows the DOS for the torbitals of an isolated Cu atom in bulk GaN, (b) and (c) are the DOSs of two in-plane neighbor Cu atoms in bulk GaN in the FM state with the exchange splitting (EX) fixed and (d), (e), and (f) are the corresponding DOSs f or Cu in a passivated GaN NW (Fig. 1(d)). W denotes the band width. 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Cu-Cu Distance (eV) FIG. 4: Energy difference between the AFM and FM state for all possible inequivalent configurations of two Cu dopan ts in a passivated GaN nanowire as shown in Fig. 1(b). that due to the 1D nature of the NW, the band width of the Cutdband is reduced, thus increases the magnetiza- tion. It is found that passivation of the nanowire surface has a significant impact on the substitutional position, and thus on the magnetic properties: For the bare GaN NWs, Cu tends to substitute Ga on the surface, and the strong direct interaction between two neighboring sur- face substitutional Cu atoms results in a state. However, when the surface is pas- sivated, Cu tends to substitute Ga inside the NW, and leads to ferromagnetism arising from the d-ds. Our findings, thus, indicate that of the NW is crucial to sustain the FM state. This work is supported by the U.S. Department of En- ergy, under Contract No. We5 thank Dr. Juarez L. F. Da Silva and Dr. Sukit Limpi- jumnong for useful discussions. [1] Dietl, T.; Ohno, H.; Matsukura, F.; Cibert, J.; 2000, 287, 1019. [2] Sarigiannidou, E.; Wilhelm, F.; Monroy, E.; Galera, R. M.; Bellet-Amalric, E.; Rogalev, A.; Goulon, J.; Cibert, J.; Mariette, H. Phys. Rev. B 2006, 74, 041306(R). [3] Sonoda, S.; Shimizu, S.; Sasaki, T.; Yamamoto, Y.; Hori, H.J. Cryst. Growth 2002, 237, 1358. [4] Ando, K. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2003, 82, 100. [5] Dalpian G. M.; Wei, S.-H. J. Appl. Phys. 2005, 98, 083905. [6] Dalpian, G. M.; Wei, S.-H.; Gong, X. G.; da Silva, A. J. R.; Fazzio, A. Solid State Commun. 2006, 138, 353. [7] Wu, R. Q.; Peng, G. W.; Liu, L.; Feng, Y. P.; Huang, Z. G.; Wu, Q. Y. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2006, 89, 062505. [8] Lee, J.-H.; Choi, I.-H.; Shin, S.; Lee, S.; Lee, J.; Whang , C.; Lee, S.-C.; Lee, K.-R.; Baek, J.-H.; Chae, K. H.; Song, J. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2007, 90, 032504. [9] Seipel, B.; Erni, R.; Gupta, A.; Li, C.; Owens, F. J.; Rao, K. V.; Browning, N. D.; Moeck, P. J. Mater. Res. 2007, 22, 1396. [10] Rosa, A. L.; Ahuja, R. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2007, 91,232109. [11] Seong, H.-K.; Kim, J.-Y.; Kim, J.-J.; Lee, S.-C.; Kim, S .- R.; Kim, U.; Park, T.-E.; Choi, H.-J. Nano Lett. 2007, 7, 3366. [12] Bl ochl, P. E. Phys. Rev. B 1995, 50, 17953; Kresse, G; Joubert, D. Phys. Rev. B 1999, 59, 1758. [13] Kresse, G; Furthm uller, J Comput. Mater. Sci. 1996, 6, 15;Phys. Rev. B 1996, 54, 11169. [14] Perdew, J. P.; Burke, K.; Ernzerhof, M. Phys. Rev. Lett. 1996, 77, 3865. [15] Xiang, H. J.; Yang, J. L.; Hou, J. G.; Zhu, Q. S. Appl. Phys. Lett. 2006, 89, 223111. [16] Li, J.; Wei, S.-H.; Li, S. S.; Xia, J. B. Phys. Rev. B 2008 77, 113304. [17] Bader, R. F. W. Atoms in Molecules-A Quantum Theory (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1990). [18] Wang, Q.; Sun, Q.; Jena, P.; Kawazoe, Y. Phys. Rev. Lett.2004, 93, 155501. [19] Wang, Q.; Sun, Q.; Jena, P. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2005, 95, 167202. [20] Wang, Q.; Sun, Q.; Jena, P.; Kawazoe, Y. Nano Lett. 2005, 5, 1587. [21] Wang, Q.; Sun, Q.; Jena, P.; Kawazoe, Y. Phys. Rev. B 2007, 75, 075312. [22] Sluiter, M. H. F.; Kawazoe, Y.; Sharma, P.; Inoue, A.; Raju, A. R.; Rout, C.; Waghmare, U. V. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2005, 94, 187204.
|
0807.0918
|
H. J. Xiang
|
H. J. Xiang and Su-Huai Wei
|
Enhanced Ferromagnetic Stability in Cu Doped Passivated GaN Nanowires
|
Nano Lett., ASAP Article, 10.1021/nl080261n
| null |
10.1021/nl080261n
| null |
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
Density functional calculations are performed to investigate the room
temperature ferromagnetism in GaN:Cu nanowires (NWs). Our results indicate that
two Cu dopants are most stable when they are near each other. Compared to bulk
GaN:Cu, we find that magnetization and ferromagnetism in Cu doped NWs is
strongly enhanced because the band width of the Cu td band is reduced due to
the 1D nature of the NW. The surface passivation is shown to be crucial to
sustain the ferromagnetism in GaN:Cu NWs. These findings are in good agreement
with experimental observations and indicate that ferromagnetism in this type of
systems can be tuned by controlling the size or shape of the host materials.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 6 Jul 2008 17:24:17 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-08T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Xiang",
"H. J.",
""
],
[
"Wei",
"Su-Huai",
""
]
] |
- 2 - 1. Introduction The prompt emission of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) is believed to arise from outflows with bulk Lorentz factors G (see, e.g., reviews by Piran 2005; M' esz' aros 2006). In the popular internal shock model, collisions a mong the flow lead to formation of shocks that convert a fraction o f the bulk kinetic energy into relativistic electrons, whosesynchrotron emission powers & M' esz' aros 1994). Initially, most o fthekinetic energyaswell as the internal energy generated via shock dissipation are likely car ried by protons, so such models entail the operation of a physical mechanism that transfer s energy from protons to electrons on sufficiently short timescales. This presumably occur s via collective processes, as simple Coulomb collisions may be too slow. A gen eral problem in collisionless shock theory and GRB models in particular is that this mech anism is and one must frequently resort to a phenomenologic al parametrization. In view of the large observed energy in MeV gamma rays, the efficiency of pr oton-to-electron energy transfer isusually considered tobehigh. However, thisisby nomean s physically guaranteed. In the case of supernova remnant shocks, the total energy in ac celerated electrons is observationally to be much less than in protons (e.g. Ah aronian et al. 2006). Since we do not yet understand the nature and total energy budg et of the central engine, we cannot readily exclude the possibility that GRBs actually contain a s ignificantly larger amount of energy in protons compared to that radiated by the acc elerated sarealso. The physical conditions in internal shocks may allow maximum energies so GRBs are potential sources of the observed cosmic rays (UHECRs; Waxman 1995; Vietri 1995; Milgrom & Usov 1996). The total energy in accele rated protons that must be supplied per burst depends on a number of uncertain facto rs (see also App. B of Murase et al. (2008)). The required local UHECR emissivity at proto n energy Mpc-3yr-1(Waxman & Bahcall 1998; Dermer 2007). of the local rate of long GRBs range from 0 .2-1 Gpc-3yr-1if the GRB rate is proportional to the star formation rate, down to ~0.05 Gpc-3yr-1if the GRB rate evolves vored(e.g.Daigne et al. 2006; Le & Dermer 2007; Guetta & Piran 2007). Assuming a power-la w proton spectrum with index pp= 2, the necessary energy per burst in accele rated which isapproximately inde- pendent of the actual beaming factor. Steeper spectra andhen ce even larger Epare calledfor if GRBs also contribute significantly to CRs below 1019eV (Wick et al. 2004). To be com- pared is the corresponding energy in accelerated electrons Ee, which can be roughly equated with the observed, MeV gamma-ray energy Eg,iso, typically ~1053erg- 3 - and up to ~1054erg in the 1 -104keV rest-frame band (Kocevski & Butler 2008). Thus, in order for GRBs to be viable sources of UHECRs, the latest observ ations point to a energy budget, The observed heterogeneity of GRBs also suggests that not all bursts may be equally efficient UHECR acce lerators, in which case even higher Ep/Eemay be warranted for a subset of the bursts. It is therefore of great interest whether such proton-dominat ed GRBs can be di- agnosed observationally. A promising window is GeV-TeV gamma-rays , where of UHE proton acceleration may show up, such as synch rotron emission from pro- tons, muons or secondary particles injected via photomeson inter actions (e.g. Vietri 1997; B ottcher & Dermer 1998; Gupta & Zhang 2007; Asano & Inoue 200 7, hereafter AI07). AI07 recently undertook a detailed investigation of such emission pr ocesses utilizing a comprehensive Monte Carlo code. However, having assumed that t he accelerated protons do not carry excessive extra energy, their study was restricted toEp/Ee= 1. In view of the above possibilities, here we follow and extend the work of AI07 to Ep/Ee>1. The results, which are often qualitatively and drastically different from A I07, are discussed andupcoming observations. Notethat high-ene rgy emission GRBs has been discussed previously in different contexts (e.g. Totani 1998; Asano & Takahara 2003). After a recap of our formulation in SS2, we discuss the results and their in SS3 andSS4, respectively, and conclude in SS5. 2. Model and Methods We briefly summarize the model and methods of AI07, which should be consulted for more details. In accord with the internal shock paradigm, the emitt ing region pulseintheprompt light curve eous shell expanding with G at radii Rfrom the central engine. The comoving width of the shell is l=R/G and the pulse timescale in the observer frame is t=R/G2c, as long as Rexceeds the shell spreading radius (M' esz' aros et al. 1993), which is always the case here. Shock dynamics and time variability are not explicitly treated, so our results should be interpreted as spectra for each pulse. With given injection of accelerated electrons and protons in magnet ic fieldB, we for the distribution of particles and photons in th e shell using Monte The time steps are always taken to be sufficiently short er than the particle cooling timescales (Asano 2005). In addition to synchrotron and inv erse Compton (IC)- 4 - emission from all particles, our code includes synchrotron self-abs orption, cascade scattering, as well as proton-induced processes such a s photomeson ( pg) interac- tions and secondary pion, muon and pair injection. We adopt experim ental results for the cross sections of whilepg-pp0p0is neglected in view of its small cross section. In case the primary proton is converted to a neutron, we assume that it continues to interact with photons in the shell during the comoving expansion We do not acccount for the minor contribution from neutron-dec ay & M' esz' aros 2006). More details on the treatment of meson production and their decay products can be found in Asano (2005) and Asano & Nagatak i we now account for the Bethe-Heitler (BH) pair pro duction process ( pg- pe+e-), whose cross section and inelasticity are taken from Chodorowsk i et al. (1992). and the huge compactness of GRBs implies that the resultant electroma gnetic cascade emission is not very sensitive to the details of particle injection at high energie s. Thus, compared to cases neglecting the BH process, we find that its inclusion here on ly leads to of the secondary photon emission, by at most a few tens of the range of Lorentz factors The balance of andradiative gives ge,max. Likewise, injected with a distribution np(gp)g-pp pin the range obtain gp,maxby equating tacc=gpmpc2/eBc, the Fermi acceleration time in to min( texp,tloss), where tlossis the energy loss time due to synchrotron, IC and pg cooling (Asano 2005). In mildly relativistic internal shocks, gp,minshould be of order unity; here we take gp,min= 10. The injection index for electrons is fiducially chosen to be pe= 2.5, implying b2.25 for the spectral index above the synchrotron peak energy. This is consistent with the mean of thebvalues measured by BATSE, albeit with a considerable dispersion, fro et al. 2000;Kaneko et al. 2006). Forprotons, ourfiduc ialindexis pp= 2.0, appropriate when GRBs contribute to UHECRs only above 1019eV (Waxman & Bahcall 1998); steeper spectra would increase still the energy demands. Note that the values of pe andpprelevant to our results each correspond to very different energy ranges; GeV-TeV for electrons and 10-100 PeV for protons in the comoving frame. A lthough the for the two species are expected to be the same at low ene rgies where their ppmay be effectively realized if the proton spectrum covering 7-8 deca des in energy deviates from a pure power-law and becomes concave. This may plausibly occur due- 5 - to 1) nontrivial geometry and wavelength distribution of magnetic t urbulence at the shock (Niemiec et al. 2006), 2) nonlinear back-reaction of CR pressure on the shock & Kirk 1991;Malkov & Drury 2001), e-existing particles originating from different regions in the outflow (B osnjak & Daigne in view of the observed spread in band the uncertainties associated with obtaining time-integrated spectra, we also discuss cases with combinations of the remaining parameters are constrained so as to observed properties of the MeV emission. For given Band G,ge,minis chosen such that the observed synchrotron peak energy for nearby bursts isepk= ec 300 keV. Since the fast-cooling, primary electrons radiate away mo st of their energy as MeV photons within t,Ee= be identified with Esh, the observable, MeV pulse energy. Instead of hereafter we use oe,opandoB, the of the corresponding energies as fractions of th e shock-dissipated internal energy (e.g. M' esz' aros 2006). Thus In place ofR, we choose the observable tas a parameter and set t= 0.1 s for simplicity. Below we only show the spectra corresponding to single pulses. For burst s composed of Nsimilar pulses, the energy would be simply Ntimes larger, Eg,iso=NEsh. The set of parameters are then t,Esh, G,oB/oeandop/oe. All spectra are plotted as observed fluence versus photon energy, assuming a GRB redshift z= 0.1. Spectral attenuation by intergalactic ggabsorption is neglected. 3. Results 3.1. Fiducial Spectral Indices First we discuss different cases with our fiducial values of pe= 2.5 andpp= 2.0. As mentioned above, epkis chosen to have the typically observed value of 300 keV. Prompt emission spectra of single pulses for Esh= 1051erg, G = 300, oB/oe= 1 and varying op/oe= 10-100 are shown in Figure 1. The sharp spectral cutoffs at low and high energies are due to synchrotron self-absorption and ggabsorption, respectively. This applies to all spectra below when such sharp cutoffs are seen. Most remarka ble is the prominent e+- cascade component, i.e. synchrotron and IC emission from second arye+-triggered by pg interactions of UHE protons with low energy photons. For the lower range ofop/oe, pgtarget. However, target photons become dominated by synchrotron emission fr om the low energy part of- 6 - the secondary e+-themselves. The dependence of the spectra on op/oeis therefore nonlinear and not simply proportional, as apparent in Figure 1. The secondary photons also affect the primary synchrotron component (dashed curves in Figure 1) thro ugh enhanced IC cooling, even though the injection distribution is unchanged. e [eV]ef(e) erg, B/e=1, t=0.1 s, 1.-- Singlepulse, prompt photonspectra forvarying op/oeaslabeled. marked above the figure. Dashed curves denote the primary c ontribution only, whose peak flux decreases with op. Dot-dashed curves denote separately the electron synchrotr on (labeled eSY) and inverse Compton (eIC) components without gg-absorption effects for op/oe= 100. In general, cascade emission significantly hardens the high-energy spectra. Since Lorentz factors < ge,mincan be injected in the cascade, it can also give rise to excess UV-to-X-ray emission lying above the extrapolation of th e sub-MeV spectra, as- 7 - seen forop/oe= 10-30 in Figure 1. The entire spectra thus tends to become flat in ef(e). The case of op/oe= 100 is drastically different. Here the proton-induced totally overwhelms any primary electron component, result ing in a hard spectrum peaking at 10-100 MeV. Although approximately a single power-law be tween 100 eV and 30 MeV, in fact it comprises two emission processes by secondary e+-, mainly synchrotron and IC (dot-dashed curves in Figure 1). Despite oB/oe= 1, IC can dominate over synchrotron since the energy density of secondary e+-exceeds both UBandUe. The comoving photon density ngis decisive for both 1) the ggoptical depth tggand hence the ggcutoff energy egg, and 2) the efficiency of pginteractions and hence the sec- ondary cascade emission. Figure 2 displays single pulse spectra for G = 300,oB/oe= 1, op/oe= 10, and varying pulse energies Esh= 1049-1051erg. Higher Eshimplies higher ng, and consequently stronger pgcomponents as well as lower egg. SincengG-5with other parameters fixed, varying G has larger effects. Shown in Figure 3 ar e single pulse spectra forEsh= 1050erg,oB/oe= 1,op/oe= 30 and G = 100 -1000. G = 100 allows a high spectrum, even though op/oeis 3 times less than the analogous case in Figure 1. Increasing G leads to higher maximum energies and less casc ade contribution. The spectral hardening GeV for G = 300 and GeV for G = 1000 is due to p if G is sufficiently high. Conversely, the absence of hard, high-en ergy components does not necessary rule out proton-dominated GRBs. In fact, the con ditions most favorable for contributing to UHECRs is that they escape the source with minimal pglosses, which cor- responds roughly to the criterion G our model (AI07). On the other hand, G can be observationally constrained through it s strong influence on egg (e.g. Lithwick & Sari 2001, AI07). Since the pulse energy Eshand timescale tare also measurable, we may hope to identify bursts where pglosses are likely to be efficient, and then constrain op/oefrom the high-energy spectra, although some degeneracy with 4 shows single pulse spectra for Esh= 1051erg, G = 300, op/oe= 30 and varying oB/oe= 0.1-10. The oB/oe= 1 case is the same as in Figure 1. Higher Bcauses steeper spectra with stronger secondary synchrotron relative to secon dary IC, while lower Bis vice- versa and produces a 100 MeV peak spectrum. However, the depe ndence on Bcan also be nontrivial. In Figure 5, we show spectra for Esh= 1051erg, G = 1000, op/oe= 100, 0.1-100 (note that oB/op<=1). The higher G allows spectra extending into the TeV regime, but renders pgprocesses inefficient despite the high cases exhibit spectral bumps around 0.1-1 TeV, but their origins are quite different. For- 8 - e [eV]ef(e) [erg/cm2]p/e=10, B/e=1, t=0.1 s, G=300 Esh=1049 ergEsh=1050 ergEsh=1051 ergHH 2.-- Single pulse, prompt photon spectra for varying Eshas labeled. Other parameters are marked above the this is due to secondary e+-IC, which is weaker for higher B. However, when oB/oe, the bump is stronger again, owing to the appearance of synchr otron emission from protons and muons, their ratio being roughly 2 to 1 for oB/oe= 10 (dot-dashed curves in Figure 5). For oB/oe= 100, we obtain a pronounced proton synchrotron TeV peak, as well as enhanced emission at lower energies from synchrotron radia tion bye+-produced 9 - e [eV]ef(e) erg, p/e=30, t=0.1 s, H H 3.-- Single pulse, prompt photon spectra for varying G as labeled. Other parameters are marked above the figure. 3.2. Equal Proton and Electron Indices We now consider situations with pe=pp, as would occur if the proton spectrum was a single power-law over its entire energy range. Similar to the above, F igure 6 testifies that the spectrum for op/oe=30 and pe=pp=2.0 can result in a hard GRB with photon index ~2 up to 10 GeV. It is interesting to note that in such cases, the spectra l shape around the MeV peak alone may not always reveal the correct value of pe. However, for pe=pp= 2.2, emission isgre atlydiminished, except for a slight distortion of the spectrum above 100 MeV. The proton cont ribution becomes for pe=pp= 2.5, for which neither UHECRs nor neutrinos are significantly- 10 - e [eV]ef(e) erg, p/e=30, t=0.1 s, 4.-- Singlepulse, oB/oeaslabeled. marked above the figure. Dashed curves denote the primary c omponents only, whose peak flux decreases with oB. generated at any rate. 4. Observational Implications A unique property of proton-dominated GRBs is that their photon s pectra can some- times manifest very high peak energies in the 10 MeV-1 GeV range due (Figures 1,3,4,6). This seems at variance with commonly obser ved values of epk~
0.1-1 MeV (Kaneko et al. 2006). However, through a recent re-an alysis of EGRET TASC- 11 - e [eV]ef(e) erg, p/e=100, t=0.1 s, H HH HH HH H HB/e=10 5.-- Single pulse, prompt photon spectra varying oB/oeas labeled. Other parameters are marked above the figure. Dot-dashed curves denote separa tely the electron proton synchrotron (pSY) and muon synchrotron ( uSY) components without gg- absorption effects for oB/oe= 10 and 100. data, Kaneko et al. (2008) reported a GRB with apparently very hig hepk>170 MeV, as well as a few others with significant high-energy excess (see also Gonz' alez et al. 2003). Some studies have also indicated potential observational biases ag ainst BATSE detections of highepk(Lloyd & Petrosian 1999). At this moment, it is unclear how often suc h high epkbursts occur, and whether they are relevant to the proton-dom inated cases discussed here, or simply reflect a primary synchrotron peak energy that is m uch higher than average (rather than the values we have assumed here). In any case, the existence and nature of such bursts will be definitively probed through ongoing observations by Fermi(Omodei 2006)- 12 - e [eV]ef(e) erg, G=330 ,p/e=30, t=0.1 s, H H 6.-- Single pulse, prompt photon spectra for varying values of pe=ppas labeled. Other parameters are marked above the figure. Thick and thin das hed curves denote the primary components only, for pe=pp=2.0 and 2.2, AGILE (Longo et al. 2007). Note that it is also conceivable that s ome GRBs proton energies, say Ep~1053erg, but with Ep/Ee1 so that the MeV emission is relatively weak. Even if unimportant for UHECRs ( SS1), new generation also probe such MeV-weak can also induce excess low-energy emission (Figures 1,2,4), which do not seem typical of known GRBs. However, they may be relevant for so me BATSE bursts with soft excess components (Preece et al. 1996), or possibly a fract ion of the X-ray rich GRBs (Sakamoto et al. 2005). Fermiand AGILE observations of the accompanying will provide a test. TeV detections of GRBs have yet to be achieved (e.g. Atkins et al. 20 05; Albert et al.- 13 - 2007; Horan et al. 2007; Aharonian et al. 2009), but some of the co mponents discussed above may be eventually observed by current ground-based facilit ies such as MAGIC (II), HESS (II), VERITAS, CANGAROO III, or the future projects CTA , AGIS, HAWC, etc. For example, MAGIC may detect the luminous proton synchrotron e mission for oB/oe= 100 in Figure 5 at 0.1 TeV beyond z~1, assuming Eg,iso= 1053erg and the latest estimates of intergalactic ggabsorption (Albert et al. between primary electron IC and proton-induced emis sion components may not be easy from the spectral shape alone. However, since th e synchrotron cooling timescales for UHE protons are considerably lon ger than the for GeV-TeV emitting primary electrons, we can expect im portant differences in their variability properties, which should provide further observat ional clues. Although this work waslimited totime-averaged pulse spectra, adesirable next st epis calculations. 5. Conclusions and GRBs are motivated by physical considerations of particle accelera- tion in collisionless shocks, as well as their potential to be the origin of UHECRs. In GRB UHECR scenarios, the spectral index for protons at UHE must gen erally be harder than the typical indices for electrons emitting in the multi-MeV range, whic h may be possible de- pending on the physics of particle acceleration, cooling and/or shoc k formation, as discussed inSS2. Characteristic emission signatures can then result, such as high peak energy bursts and/or excess low-energy emission from p air cascades, or bumps from proton synchrotron emission. If the indices for electrons and protons at the respective energies are equal, proton-related components m ay still be visible as long as the index but not for steeper spectra. Through detailed observations o f spectra and variability, we may hope to disentangle the proton-induced compone nts from the process of inverse Compton from primary electrons. Other observable consequences of proton-dominated GRBs may in clude contributions to Galactic CRs (e.g. Wick et al. 2004) and the diffuse high-energy neu trino background (e.g. Murase as discussed here, they could play an increased role in pro bing high- fields (Inoue et al., in prep.) as well as intergalactic magnetic fields (Ichiki et al. 2008, and references therein).- 14 - We thank Chuck Dermer for very informative correspondence, an d Kohta Murase The Next Generation of Physics, Spun from Universality a nd Emergence from the Ministry of E.C.S.S.T. (MEXT) of F. A. et al. 2006, A&A, 449, 223 Aharonian, F. A. et al. 2009, A&A, submitted, J. et al. 2007, ApJ, 667, 358 Albert, J. et al. 2008, Science, 320, 1752 Asano, K. 2005, ApJ, 623, 967 Asano, K., & Inoue, S. 2007, ApJ, 671, 645 (AI07) Asano, K., & Nagataki, S. 2006, ApJ, 640, L9 Asano, K., & Takahara, F. 2003, PASJ, 55, 433 Atkins, R. et al. 2005, ApJ, 630, 996 Baring, M., & Kirk, J. 1991, A&A, 241, 329 Bosnjak, Z., & Daigne, F., A&A, submitted, ottcher, M., & Dermer, C. D. 1998, ApJ, 499, M. J., Zdziarski, A. A., & Sikora, M. 1992, ApJ, 400, 18 1 Daigne, F., Rossi, E., & Mochkovitch, R., MNRAS, 372, 1034 Dermer, C. D. 2007, alez, M. M. et al. 2003, Nature, 424, 749 Guetta, D., & Piran, T. S. 2007, JCAP, 07, 003 Gupta, N., & Zhang, B., 2007, MNRAS, 380, 78- 15 - Horan, D. et al. 2007, ApJ, 655, 396 Ichiki, K., Inoue, S., & Takahashi, K., ApJ, 682, 127 Kaneko, Y. et al. 2006, ApJS, 166, 298 Kaneko, Y. et al. 2008, ApJ, 677, 1168 Kocevski, D., & Butler, N. 2008, ApJ, 680, 531 Le, T., & Dermer, C. D. 2007, ApJ, 661, 394 Lithwick, Y., & Sari, R. 2001, ApJ, 555, 540 Lloyd, N., & Petrosian, V. 1999, ApJ, 511, 550 Longo, F. et al. 2007, AIP Conf. Proc., 906, p.147 Malkov, M. A., & Drury, L. O'C. 2001, Rep. Prog. Phys., 64, 429 M' esz' aros, P., Laguna, P., & Rees, M. J., 1993, ApJ, 414, 181 M' esz' aros, P. 2006, Rep. Prog. Phys., 69, 2259 Milgrom, M. & Usov, V. 1996, Astropart. Phys., 4, 365 Murase, K. 2007, Phys. Rev. D, 76, 123001 Murase, K., Ioka, K., Nagataki, S., & Nakamura, T. 2008, Phys. Rev . D, 78, 023005 Niemiec, J., Ostrowski, M., & Pohl, M. 2006, ApJ, 650, 1020 Omodei, N. T. 2005, Rev. Mod. Phys., 76, 1143 Preece, R. D. et al. 1996, ApJ, 473, 310 Preece, R. D. et al. 2000, ApJS, 126, 19 Razzaque, S. & M' esz' aros, P. 2006, JCAP, 6, 006 Rees, M. J., & M' esz' aros, P. 1994, ApJ, 430, L93 Sakamoto, T. et al. 2005, ApJ, 629, 311 Totani, T. 1998, ApJ, 509, L81- 16 - Vietri, M. 1995, ApJ, 453, 883 Vietri, M. 1997, Phys. Rev. Lett., 78, 4328 Waxman, E. 1995, Phys. Rev. Lett., 75, 386 Waxman, E. & Bahcall, J. 1998, Phys. Rev. D, 59, 023002 Wick, S. D., Dermer, C. D., & Atoyan, A. 2004, Astropart. Phys., 21 , 125 This preprint was prepared with the AAS L ATEX macros v5.2.
|
0807.0951
|
Katsuaki Asano
|
Katsuaki Asano, Susumu Inoue, and Peter M\'esz\'aros
|
Prompt High-Energy Emission from Proton-Dominated Gamma-Ray Bursts
|
16 pages, 6 figures
|
Astrophys.J.699:953-957,2009
|
10.1088/0004-637X/699/2/953
| null |
astro-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The prompt emission of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) is widely thought to be
radiation from accelerated electrons, but an appreciably larger amount of
energy could be carried by accelerated protons, particularly if GRBs are the
sources of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs). We model the expected photon
spectra for such "proton-dominated" GRBs in the internal shock scenario through
Monte Carlo simulations, accounting for various processes related to
high-energy electrons and protons. Besides proton and muon synchrotron
components, emission from photomeson-induced secondary pair cascades becomes
crucial, generally enhancing the GeV-TeV and/or eV-keV photons and offering a
signature of UHE protons. In some cases, it can overwhelm the primary electron
component and result in GRBs peaking in the 10 MeV - 1 GeV range, which may be
relevant to some bursts discussed in a recent re-analysis of EGRET TASC data.
The dependence of the spectra on key quantities such as the bulk Lorentz
factor, magnetic field and proton-to-electron ratio is nontrivial due to the
nonlinear nature of cascading and the interplay of electron- and proton-induced
components. Observations by {\it Fermi}, ground-based telescopes and other
facilities should test these expectations and provide critical constraints on
the proton acceleration efficiency.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 7 Jul 2008 05:59:51 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Tue, 3 Feb 2009 11:21:42 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Thu, 2 Apr 2009 03:49:09 GMT"
}
] | 2011-02-11T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Asano",
"Katsuaki",
""
],
[
"Inoue",
"Susumu",
""
],
[
"Mészáros",
"Peter",
""
]
] |
2 A. Normal ordering form of the SECST For the simplicity in our later calculation, we first per- form the integration in Eq.(2) by using the technique of integration within an ordered product (IWOP) of oper- ators [14, 15]. Using the normal ordering form of the vacuum projector exp(-a+a):,we can reform Eq.(2) as the following (5) In the last step of (5), we noticed that for any two independent variable that operators a+,acan be considered as C-number within the normal order : : ), thus Eq.(5) can be rewrit- ten as r=Ca,m -nt: we have set -nt) using the integration expression of polynomial can put Eq.(7) (9)In particular, when m= 0, corresponding to the case to r=1 -nt+1D(a) can be directly checked by using Eqs.(2) and (3) as well as noticing employing the relation between Hermite poly- nomial and Laguerre polynomial [16], Hm,n(x,k) m > m < n, (11) we can see (12) Eqs.(9) and (12) are the normal ordering form of distributions, such as Q-function, Wigner function. B. The matrix elements we calculate the matrix elements of rin Eq.(2) between two number states the overcompleteness of coherent states, one can express the matrix elements the overlap between the coherent state and the number state is given (14) and the matrix elements be obtained from Eq.(9) due to r's normal ordering we have used the generating function of two- variable Hermite polynomial Hm,n, Hm,n(x,y) just the photon number dis- tribution of the SECST. Then combing with Eqs.(15), (13) and (14), after a lengthy but straightforward calcu- lation, one can get the matrix elements loss of generality, let we have used the integral formula another expression of two-variable Hermite particular, when m= 0, noticing Eq.(11), Eq.(17) reduces is just the Glauber-Lachs formula [9] when - nt=
(ebo-1)-1. While for a= of number state with thermal light, using Eq.(19), Eq.(17) (21) where (k0= is just the result of Ref. [13]. III. SUB-POISSONIAN PHOTON STATISTICS To see clearly the photon statistics properties of the SECST, in this section, we pay our attention to the variance of the photon number particular, we will examine the evolu- tion of the Mandel Qparameter defined (23)which measures the derivation of the variance of the pho- ton number distribution of the field state under consid- eration from the Poissonian distribution of the 1,Q >1 andQ <1 correspond to Poisso- nian photon statistics (PPS), super-PPS and order to calculate the average value in Eq.(23), we first calculate the value of fact, = -nm tm!dm,n, (25) we can evaluate (for writing's convenience, let -nt-1, Eqs.(26) and (27) into (23) leads the zero-temperature limit (- nt-0), Eq.(28) just reduces to Eq.(2.20) in wedisplaythe parameter Q(nt,|a|) asafunc- tion of (nt,|a|) for different values m.From Fig.1, we see that, for the excitation photon number m= 0 (see 0,|a|) = 1 corresponding to coherent state (a PPS); while 0,|a|)>1, i.e., the SECST field exhibits a significant amount of super-PPS due to the presence of - nt. From Fig.1 (b) and (c), we see that, 0,the SECST field presents the sub-PPS when - nt is less than a threshold value for a given |a|; the thresh- old value increases as mincreases. For example, when
|a|= 0,the threshold values are about 0.414 and for m= 1 and m= 6. IV. INFORMATION TRANSMITTED BY THE SECST BEAM According to the of Brillouin [18], the maximum information Itransmitted by a beam is I=Smax-Sact, (29) in which the maximum entropy and the actual entropy, respectively, possessed by the4 (a) m=0 (b) m=1 (c) m=6 FIG. 1: (Color online) The evolution of Mandel Qparameter as a function of ( nt,|a|) for different values m. quantum mechanical system described by a density ma- trixr. Here the maximum information Iis an ideal one transmitted through an ideal optical communication sys- tem. For the SECST system, the actual entropy sNcan be obtained from Eq.(17), is independent of the phase of a.On the other hand, for a system in thermal equilibrium, described by the density matrix rth, with mean photons number - nt, (a) m=0 (b) m=1 FIG. 2: (Color online) The I(-nt,|a|)as a function of (- nt,|a|) for some different values (a) m= 0,(b) m= 1,(truncating the infinite sum at Nmax= 70). its entropy ln(1+ - nt)+ from Eq.(20) un- der the condition m= 0,a= 0.Note that the maximum entropy of the system is equal to the entropy of a system in thermal equilibrium, with an equal mean number of photons. The mean photons number of the SECST is given by Eq.(26). Therefore, using Eq.(32), we have Smax= Eqs.(29), (30) and (33), we can calculate the maximum information transmitted by the SECST beam. In Fig. 2, the maximum information I(-nt,|a|) is plot- ted as a function of (- nt,|a|) for some different values m (truncating the infinite sum at Nmax= 70). From Fig.2, we can see that, for a given - nt, I(-nt,|a|) increases as for given |a|,in general, I(-nt,|a|) grows up as the value - ntincreases. In order to see clearly the effect of different parameter presented a plot in Fig.3, from which it is obvious5 1 2 3 m=1 m=0 FIG. 3: (Color online) The maximum 1)as a function of (- nt) for some different values (a)m= 0,(b)m= 1,(c)m= 2 (truncating the infinite sum atNmax= becomes bigger due to the presence of m, and increases as mincreases. In other words, the max- imum information transmitted by the SECST beam is larger than that by the SCST ( m= 0). The channel of ECS can carry with more information than that of co- herent state. In Ref. [13], Vourdas has pointed out that the coherent signals (of known phase) can transmit more information than the number eigenvectors signals. beams, the SECST beamcan transmit most information. V. THE WIGNER FUNCTION OF THE SECST A. The Wigner function The Wigner function (WF) plays an important role in quantum optics, especially the WF can be measurements [19, 20]. The WF is a powerful tool to investigate the nonclassicality of optical fields. The presence of negativity in the WF of optical field is a sig- nature of its nonclassicality is often used to describe the decoherence of quantum states. In this section, using the normally ordered form of the SECST, we evaluate its WF. For a single-mode system, the WF is given by [21] W(g,g*) the coherent state and g=x+iy. From Eq.(34) it is easy to see that once the normal ordered form ofris known, we can conveniently obtain the WF ofr. On substituting Eq.(9) into Eq.(34) we obtain the WF (a) m=1, tn=0 (b) m=2, tn=0.3 (c) m=3, tn=0.3 FIG. 4: (Color online) The evolution of the Wigner function of the SECST with a= 0.2+0.2ifor several different values mand -nt. of the SECST W(g,g*) we have set A2 1= that when 1 the WF of the SECST is always positive under the condition of - nt>1/2. In6 particular, when m= 0, Eq.(35) becomes W(g,g*) corresponds to the thermal state with mean photon number - nt. While for a= x, Eq. (35) yields W(g,g*) the zero-temperature limit, now the WF of co- herent state (a Guassian form), which can be seen from Eq.(2) yielding the condition m= 0; while Eq.(38) to the WF of number state. Using Eq.(35), the WFs of the SECST are depicted in Fig.4 in phase space with a= 0.2 + 0.2ifor values mand -nt.It is easy to see that the nega- tive region of WF gradually disappears as mand The marginal distributions of the SECST We now find the probability distribution of position or momentum |---the by performing the WF either over the variable yor the variable x, re- spectively. is single variable Hermite polynomial and E1= Eq.(39) is the marginal distribution of WF of the SECST in x- direction.On the other hand, performing the integration over dx yields the other marginal distribution in As expected, the two marginal distributions are both real. VI. CONCLUSIONS In summary, we have investigatedthe photon We have calculated the matrix elements Fock space and the Mandel Qparameter. It is found that the SECST field exhibits a significant amount of super-PPS due to the presence of thermal noise (- nt) m= 0andthat, for m/ne}ationslash= 0and a given|a|,the SECST field presents the sub-PPS when -ntis less than a threshold value. In addition, the thresh- old value increases as mincreases. We have presented the maximum information (channel capacity) transmit- ted by the SECST beam. It is shown that the maxi- mum information transmitted increases as mincreases. This implies that among the coherent signals, the eigen- number signals and the ECS in thermal light, the last one can transmit the most information. Further, as one of the photon statistical properties, the Wigner function and the marginal distributions of the SECST have also been derived, from which one can clearly see the The negative region has no chance to be present when the average photon number - ntof thermal noise ex- ceeds 1/2.The marginal distributions are related to the Hermite work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No 10775097). L.-Y. Hu's email address is G. S. Agarwal, K. Tara, Phys. Rev. A 43,492 (1991). [2] A. Zavatta, S. Viciani, M. Bellini, Science A. Zavatta, S. Viciani, M. Bellini, Phys. Rev. A 72, (2006) 023820. [4] Y. Li, H. Jing and M. S. Zhan, D. K.alamidas, C. C. Gerry, A. Benmoussa, Phys. (2008). [6] Truong Minh Duc, Jaewoo Noh, Opt. Commun. 281, 2842 (2008). [7] R. J. Glauber, Phys. Rev. 130,2529 (1963); R. J.7 Glauber, Phys. Rev. 131,2766 (1963). [8] J. R. Klauder and B. S. Skargerstam, Coherent States, (World Scientific , Singapore, 1985). [9] B. R. Mollow and R. J. Glauber, Phys. Rev. 160, 1076 (1967); G. Lachs, Phys. Rev. B 138, 1012 (1965). [10] A. Vourdas, Phys. Rev. A 34, 3466 (1986). [11] B. Saleh, Photoelectrons Statistics (Springer-Verla g, Berlin, 1978). [12] A. Vourdas, Phys. Rev. A 39, 206 (1989). [13] A. Vourdas, Phys. Rev. A 37, 3890 (1988). [14] H.-Y. Fan, H. R. Zai and J. R. Klauder, Phys. Rev. D 35, 1831 (1987); H.-Y. Fan, H.-L. Lu and Y. Fan, (2006).[15] A. W unsche, J. Opt. B: Quantum Semiclass. Opt. A. W unsche, J. Phys. A: Math. and Gen. 33, R. R. Puri, Mathematical Methods of Quantum Berlin, 2001), Appendix A. [18] L. Brillouin, J. Appl. Phys. 24, 1152 (1953); A. Wehrl, Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, 221 (1978). [19] K. Vogel and H. Risken, Phys. Rev. A 40,2847 (1989). [20] D. T. Smithey et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1244 (1993). [21] M. O. Scully and M. S. Zubairy, Quantum Optics (Cam- bridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997).
|
0807.1028
|
Liyun Hu
|
Li-yun Hu and Hong-yi Fan
|
Density matrix of the superposition of excitation on coherent states
with thermal light and its statistical properties
|
7 pages, 9 figures, revtex4
| null | null | null |
quant-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
A beam's density matrix that is described by the superposition of excitation
on coherent states with thermal noise (SECST) is presented, and its matrix
elements in Fock space are calculated. The maximum information transmitted by
the SECST beam is derived. It is more than that by coherent light beam and
increases as the excitation photon number increases. In addition, the
nonclassicality of density matrix is demonstrated by calculating its Wigner
function.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 7 Jul 2008 14:57:36 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-08T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Hu",
"Li-yun",
""
],
[
"Fan",
"Hong-yi",
""
]
] |
2 FROM AFFINELY CONNECTED SPACE TO THE RIEMANN SPACE 2 The systems of the second order differential equations in 0 (2) are best suited to do that. They can be considered as geodesic of affinely connected space Mkin local coordinates xk. The values Pi jk= Pi kjare the coefficients of affine connections on Mk. With the help of such coefficients can be constructed curvaturete nsor and others on variety Mk. 2 From affinely connected space to the Riemann space We shall construct the Riemann space starting from a given affinely c onnected space defined by the systems of the second order ODE's. With this aim we use the notion of the Riemann extension of nonriemann ian space which was used earlier in the articles of author. Remind the basic properties of this help of the coefficients of affine connection of a given n-dimension al space can be Riemann space D2nin local coordinates ( xi,Psi) having the metric of Ps kare an additional coordinates. The important property of such type metric is that the geodesic eq uations of metric (3) decomposes into two 0, 0, the curvature tensor of n-dimensional space with a given affine connection. The first part (4) of the full system is the system of equations for geodesic of basic space with xiand it do not contains the supplementary coordinates Ps k. The second part (5) of the system has the form of linear NxNmatrix system of second order ODE's for supplementary coordinates Ps = 0. (6) Remark that the full system of geodesics has the first (7) which is equivalent to the (8) whereu,nare parameters. The geometry of extended space connects with geometry of basic space. For example the property of the space to be Ricci-flat Rij= 0 or symmetrical Rijkl;m= 0 keeps also for an extended space.3 RIEMANN SPACE FOR THE R OSSLER SYSTEM OF EQUATIONS 3 It is important to note that for extended space having the metric ( 3) all scalar curvature invariants are vanished. As consequence the properties of linear system of equation (5-6) depending from the the change of the coordinates Ps kcan be of used for that. First applications the notion of extended spaces for the studying o f nonlinear second order ODE's connected with nonlinear dynamical systems have been considered by author (V.Dryuma 2000-2008). 3 Riemann space for the R ossler system o f equations To investigation the properties of the R ossler system (9) we use its presentation in homogeneous 0, where x=x r, y=e r, z=th r. The relation between both systems is defined by the conditions x(s) =x r, y(s) =e r, z(s) =th r. Remark that for a given 0 is fulfield. Such type of the system can be rewriten in the 0, which allow us to consider it as geodesic equations of the space with co nstant affine connection. In our case nonzero components of connection RIEMANN SPACE FOR THE R OSSLER SYSTEM OF EQUATIONS metric of corresponding Riemann space (10) where (P,Q,U,V ) are an additional of the metric (10) for coordinates ( x,y,z,u) = 0 and they have a form of homogeneous R ossler system in the variab les x=dx ds, r=du ds. The system of second order differential equations for additional c oordinates can be reduced to the linear system of the first order equations with variable = = = = 0, whereAi, Bi, Ci, Eiare the functions of the variables x, y, z, u ). Properties of such type of the systems can be investigated with he lp of the Wilczynski invariants.4 LAPLACE OPERATOR 5 4 Laplace operator In theory of Riemann spaces the = 0 (11) can be used to the study of the properties of spaces. For the space with the metric (10) corresponde d the R ossler system we get the equation on the function ) =th(P,Q,U,V 0. This equation has varies type of particular solutions. A simplest one is ) the conditions on parameters of the R ossler system b=25 2n, a=-3/2n. As examples obtained by direct substitutions we get the quadratic s ) =
= conditions n= 8/3a, s ) EIKONAL EQUATION the condition n= 6a and arbitrary coefficients l,m,k,n. A polynomial solution of degree four th(P,Q,U,V ) the that the properties of of such type of solutions depend on parameters and may be complicated solutions of the Laplace equation can be obtained b y application of the method of (u,v)- transformation developed in the works of author. 5 Eikonal of eikonal 0 (12) also gives useful information about the properties of Riemann spac e. In particular the = 0 where function F(xi) satisfies the equation (12), determines ( N-1)-dimensional hypersurface with normals forming an isotropic vector field. For the space with the metric (10) the eikonal equation on the func tion ) =
e(P,Q,U,V ) takes the 0. (13)5 EIKONAL EQUATION 7 A simplest solution of this equation is e(P,Q,U,V ) condition on the coefficients of the R ossler 0. (14) From here we hemethodof( the sake of convenience we rewrite the equation (12) in the for 0 (15) Now after change of the function and derivatives in accordance wit h the v(x,t,z,p) =
to(x,t,z,p)5 EIKONAL EQUATION 8 we find the equation on the function = 0.(16) In spite of the fact that this equation looks not a simple than equatio n (15) its particular solutions can be find without trouble. As example the substitution of the form o(x,t,z,p) the equation (16) lead to expression on the function arbitrary function A(t) and the conditions on coefficients of the R ossler system b= 1/5a(8+5k) k2, from arbitrary parameter k. Using the function o(x,t,z,p) we can obtain the solution of the equation (13) by elimination of the = 0, y- to(x,t,z,p) = 0. As example at the choice ( A(t) = 1+t2we get e(x,y,z,p) = the condition A(t) = ln(t) we get e(x,y,z,p) = that parameters a,b,nin these cases the relation (14) is satisfied. To cite another the the equation (16) lead to the system of equations on the funct ionsA(t), = 0,REFERENCES 0. From this system of equations we find the condition on parameters n= 3/5b-a (17) and expression on the function A(t) A(t) in this case satisfies the = 0. Its solution is defined by the = 0. Using the expression on the function C(t) we can find the function o(x,t,z,p) and after elimination of the parameter tfrom corresponding relations it is possible to get the solution of the e ikonal equation at the condition (17) on parameters of the R ossler system of equ Dryuma V., The Riemann Extension in theory of differential equatio ns and their fizika, analiz, geometriya , 2003,v.10, No.3, 1-19. [2] DryumaV., al.), Kluwer Academic Publishers, (ArXiv: nlin: SI/0303023, 11 Mar ch, 2003, 1-37). [3] Dryuma V., Applications of Riemannian and Einstein-Weyl Geometry in the theory of second order ordinary differential equations, Theoretical and Mathematical Physics , 2001, V.128, N 1, 845-855. [4] Valery Dryuma, On theory of surfaces defined by the first orde r sustems of equations de Stiinte a Republicii Moldova , (matematica), 1(56), 2008, p.161-175. [5] Valery Dryuma, Riemann extensions in theory of the first order s ystems of differential DG/0510526 v1 25 Oct 2005 , 1-21. [6] Valery Dryuma, Riemann geometry in theory of the first order sy stems of differential equations ArXiv: 0807.01178 v1 [nlin.SI] 1 Jul 2008 , 1-17.
|
0807.1063
|
Valerii Dryuma sem
|
Valery Dryuma
|
On Geometry of the R\"ossler system of equations
|
9 pages
| null | null | null |
nlin.SI nlin.CD
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
On a basis of theory of Riemann extension of the space of constant affine
connection associated with the R\"ossler system of equations relations between
its parameters are investigated.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 7 Jul 2008 16:29:49 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-08T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Dryuma",
"Valery",
""
]
] |
1 Introduction The purpo se of this paper is to present a simp le method for gener ating ration al triangles. These are triangl es with rational side lengths and rationa l area. We do this in Section 5, wherein we generate a certain family of such triang les. In Section 2, we present some well known triangle form ulas involving a triangl e's side lengths, heigh ts, area, the Law of Sines, and the Law of Cosines. Also two form ulas for R and r, the radius of a triangle's circu mscr ibed circle and the radius of its inscribed circle respec tively. We offer a short derivat ion of these two formu las in Section 7. In Section 3, we state the well known parametric form ulas for Pythagor ean triples, as well as a table fea turing a few P ythagorean triples. In Section 4 we stat e two defin itions; that of a rational triang le and the defin ition of a Pythagorean rationa l. And in Section 6, we offer two closing remarks. 2 Triangle F ormula s For a triangle ABG, let , ,B A B a b g=G=G=G, be its three side lengths; ,,hhha b g the three heights (corresp onding to the perpendiculars from the vertex A to the side BG, from B to AG, and from G to AB respe ctively); E the triangle's area. Also let R be the radius of the triangle's circumscribe d circle, and r the radius of the triangle's inscribed circle. The following four sets of formulas are very well known to a wide mathematical audience. (1) 1 1 1.. .. ..2 2 2E h h ha b g a b g = = =(2) 1 1 1sin sin sin2 2 2E A B bg ag ab = = = G (3)2A notat ional remark here: We have used the single Greek letters ,,ABG to denote the triangle ABsG internal angles (in other words A for instance, stands for the angle *BAG ; or simila rly for the angle *ABG. Of course, the same single capital letters also denot e the triangl es verti ces. The next two form ulas are not as well known to a wide m athematical audience as the first fo ur. We present a short deriv ation for these two for mulas in Sect ion 7. 3 Py thagor ean Triples A Pythagorean triple (a, b, c) of positive integers a, b, c; is one which satisfies a2 + b2 = c2. In effect, the integers a and b are the leg lengths o f a right triangle; Law of sines: 2sin sin sinRA Ba b g= = =G (4)2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 Law of cosines: cos= ,cos = ,cos=2 2 2A Bbga agb abg bg ag ab+- +- c is its hypoten use length. Such a right triangle is widely known as a Pytha gorean triangle. I f (a, b, c) is a Pythagorean triple, then 2 2 2 2( ), .(2), .( ) a m nb mnc m n d d d = - = = +, for some positive integers ,,mnd such that m > n, (m,n) = 1(i.e., m and n are relatively prime, and 1(mod 2)mn+o (that is, m and n have different parities; one is odd, the other even). (Altern ative ly, of course, we can have (2)a mnd=, and 2 2( )b m nd= -, any triple (a, b, c) which satisfies (7) must be a Pythagorean triple, as a straightforward calculation shows. In effect, formulas (7) describe the entir e family of Pythagorean triple s. When 1d=the resulting Pythagorean triple is called primitive . This mater ial can be found in almost any number theory text. For exampl e, re- fer to [1] for such a text. L.E. Dicksons monumental book (see [2]) has a wealth of historical informati on on the subject. Below, we prese nt a listing of the first six primitive Pythagorean triples: those obtained from formulas (7) with 1d= and under th e constraint 1(7) 44Two 1: A rational numbe r r is called a Pythagorean rational, if arb=, where a and b are relatively prime positive integers such that a2 + b2 = c2, for some positive integer c. Remark 1: If r is a Pythagorean rational, then obviously, so is the rational number 1 r; since a2 + b2 = c2 = b2 + a2. Remark 2: Note that the positive integers a and b in Definition 1, are the leg lengths of a primitive Pythagorean triangle whose hypotenuse length is c; (a, b, c) is a primitive Pythagorean 2; A triangle ABG with side lengths ,,abgand area E, is sai d to be a rational triangle, if all four ,,abgand E, are rational numbers. Remark 3: It is easy to come up with a triangle whose side lengths are rational numbers. Indeed, all one has to do is pick three positive rationals ,,abg, that satisfy the three triangle inequalities ,abgbga+> +>, and agb+>. To ensure that the triangle is non-isosceles, the three rationals must be distinct. And if we want it to be non-right, we must ensure that 2 2 2abg+1,2 2 2agb+1, and 2 2 2a bg1+ . On the other hand, to find by trial and error, a non-right non- isosceles rational triangle is significantly more difficult. One would have to find positive rationals, which in addition to the above conditions, must be such that the product ( )( )( )( ) abgabgabgabg ++-++ -+ +- is the square of a rational number. This is because the area E satisfies the formula, 51.( )( )( )( )4E abgabgabgabg = ++-++ -+ +-, well-known in the literature as Herons inspection of formuals (1) - (6) the following is evident. 1. If ,,abgare rational, then the three cosine values cos ,cos ,cosA BG, are always rational , regard less of whether the triangle ABG is rational . 2. If ABG is a rational triangle, then the three heights, the three sine values, and the radii R and r are also rational . 3. If ABG is not a rational triangle, then E is an irrational number, and consequently the three sine values, the three heights, and the two radii are all irrational numbe rs. Remark 4: Note that a Pythagore an rationa l as defined in Defini tion 1, is alwa ys a proper rationa l; that is, it canno t be an integer. This can be easily seen from the condit ions and formulas in (7). On the other hand, the notion of a Pythagor ean numbe r, is often found in the literature of num ber th eory. A Pythagorean number is a numb er which is equal to the area of a Pythagorean triangle. Thus, by (7), it is always an integer equal to 2 2 2..( )mnm nd- a Pythagorean number is never a proper rat ional. 65A Famil y of Rational Triang les Figure 1 Let 111arb= and 222arb= be two Pythagorean rationals, which means that 2 2 21 1 1a b c+=, and 2 2 22 2 2a b c+= for some positive integer 1c and c2. In the x- y plane, consider two rays emanating from the origin O(0,0). One ray lies in the first quadrant and has slope 111amb=, the other ray lies in the fourth quadrant and has slope 222amb=-. Also consider the points 1 1(1,)Am and 2 2(1,)A mon the first and second rays respectively; T(l, 0) on the positive o>axis. The triangle 1 2AOA is a rational triangle. We put, 71j= degree measure of acute angle *1AOT; 0< 1j < 90 2j= degree measure of acute angle *2AOT; 0 < 2j < 90 1 2jjj=+= degree measure of angle *1 2AOA; 0 < j < 180 1w= degree measure of acute angle *1 2AOA; 0 < 1w < 90 2w= degree measure of acute angle *2 1AOA; 0 < 2w < 90 Also for side lengths: 1 2 12 , ,OA OA AA a b g= = =. Heights: ,,hhha b calculations yield the following results. Side leng 2 1 2 12 21 1 2 1 2 1 2 121 , 1 ,c c ababm m mmb b bba b g+=+= =+ = =-=
212 211 2121Area .1.( )2 2ababE mmbb+= - = (8) (9) (10)12 21 12 21 12 212 2, , 1abab abab E Eh h hcb cba b ga b+ += = = = =
8Cosine and Sine Values and Rr (To obtain these we use (5) and (6), co mbined with (8) and (9)) 12 12 21 12 12 12 12 212( ),2cc ababRbb cbbcababr+= =++ + (11)1 1 2 21 1 2 21 1 2 2 12 121 2 1 2 1 212 12 211 2 1 2 2 112 1 1 2 21 1 2 21 1 2 2cos ,sin ,cos ,sin cos cos( )cos cos sinsin sin sin( )sin cos sincos cos ,sin ,cos ,sinb a b a c c c b a b c c c cj j j j j jj j j j j j jj j j j j w w w w= = = =
-= += - =
+= += + =
= = = One can easily see from Figure 1, that the triangle 12OAA will be a non- right one, if and only if 12 21aa bb1. Equivalently, the same triangle will be a right triangle, precisely when 12 21aabb=. This couched with the coprimeness conditions 11 2 2()1(,)ab ab==, and a bit of number theory, easily implies that 1 2ab= and 1 2ba=. In other words, 12OAA will be a right triangle, exactly when the two Pythagorean rationals are reciprocals of each other (and so, 121mm=-). 5. Also easily, by inspect ion from Figure 1, one sees that the triangle 1 2AOA will be non-iso sceles if and only if, 12 21abab1. Equiv alently, it will be isosceles precisely when 12 21abab= which when combined with the coprimeness conditions, it easily implies 1 2aa=and 1 2bb=; the two Pythagorean rationa ls 1rand r2 are equal in this case. If two distinct Pythagorea n rationals are given, say r and s; then eight different triangles 1 2AAocan be f orme d as f ollows: Triang le 1: By taking 1m r= and 2m s=- 10 Triang le 2: By taking 1m = r and 21ms=- Triangle 3: B y takin g 1m = s and 2m r=- Triangle 4: B y takin g 1m = s and 21mr=- Triang le 5: By taking 11mr= and 2m s=- Triangle 6: B y taking 11mr= and 21ms=- Triangle 7: B y taking 11ms= and 2m r=- Triang le 8: By taking 11ms= and 21mr=- However , Triang le 3 is simply the perpendicul ar reflection of Triangle 1 through the x-axis, as it is eviden t from Figure 1. Thus, Triangles 1 and 3 are congruen t. Likewise Triangles 2 and 7 are congruen t. Triangl es 4 and 5, and Triang les 6 and 8 are also congruent. In summary, the group of eight triangles, can be divided into four sets, each set conta ining a pair of congruen t triangles, because of reflection through the x-axis. Now , let us take a look at Table 1, which conta ins six rows of numb ers. If we fix two of the six rows; we construc t eight triang les 1 2AAo as the above analysis shows. In how many ways can we choose two rows from the given six? Ever y combin atorics student knows that the answer to this is given by the bino mial coef = =c/eo. Thus, by implementing the above method, we see that there are 120 such triang les that arise from Table 1; sixty pairs of triangles; each pair containing two congruent 11triangles. 6 A Closing R emark A glan ce at formulas (7) with 1d= shows that, 2 21 2( ), 2a mn b mn b nm am n= - =- Thus, if we ta ke n = 1 (a nd m even), it is ob vious that the Pyt hagorean rat ionals a b can be arbitraril y large; wh ile b a arbitrari ly small. Therefore in Figure 1, ei ther 1m or m2 can be ar bitraril y large or small ; and so th e degree measure j of the angle 1 2AOA can be arbitraril y close to 180 or to 0. 7 A Derivation of Formul as (5) a nd (6) The derivat ion of (5) is ver y short indeed. Fro m (2) and (3) we obtain 1 1.sin ; .2 2 4E AE RR Ea abgbg bg = = U=2 The derivat ion of (6) is also very short, if we ju st take a look at Figure 2. We have () ()()() Area Area Area Area ; 1 1 1.. .. ..;2 2 2 1 2.( ); 2AB E AIB BI IA E EErg ra rb rgabrabgG== + G+ G
= + +
= ++ =++
12Figure 2 8 References 1. Rosen, Kenneth H., Elementary Number Theory and its Applications, Third edition, 1993, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company (there is now a fourth edition as well), 544 pp. For Pythagorean triples, see pages 436-442. 2. Dickson, L.E., History of Theory of Numbers, Vol. II, AMS Chelsea Publishing, Providence, Rhode Island, 1992. ISBN: 0-8218-1935-6; 803 pp (unaltered textual reprint of the original book, first published by Carnegie Institute of Washington in 1919, 1920, and 1923). (a) For material on Pythagorean triangles and rational right triangles, see pages 165-190. (b) For material on rational triangles in general, see pages 191-216. 13
|
0807.1073
|
Konstantine Zelator
|
Konstantine Zelator
|
A simple method for generating rational triangles
|
8 pages and two figures
| null | null | null |
math.GM
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In the early part of the paper, various geometrical formulas are derived.
Then, at some point in the paper, the concept of a Pythagorean rational is
introduced. A Pythagorean rational is a rational number which is the ratio of
two integers which are the leglengths of a Pythagorean triangle. Using the idea
of Pythagorean rationals, we generate two families of rational triangles. We
define a rational triangle to be a triangle with rational sidelengths and area.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 7 Jul 2008 17:05:36 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-08T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Zelator",
"Konstantine",
""
]
] |
2 (a) a b pha d b ca b phmg g(b) a1 a2 anM1 M2 Mn(c) FIG. 1: Entanglement swapping and 1D repeater. Circles are qubits. Heavy lines represent pure ed states. Loops represent the entanglement swapping measure - ment on a pair of qubits. a) Two states aandbof the form specified in (1). After the operation, qubits aanddmay be in an entangled, mixed state. b) swapping as the first step in a repeater. c) a 1D chain of only allow the establishment of entangle- ment between distant nodes that decays exponen- tially with both the distance, as well as the quality of entanglement of NN bonds.
*In 2D and higher dimensions, the possibilities for protocols are greatly expanded. The most naive protocol-- the one we use as a base- line to evaluate other protocols-- is the one we termclassical entanglement percolation (CEP), al- though it does involve obviously some quantum op- erations. This protocol begins with converting (us- ing LOCC) each of the entangled bonds into a sin- glet (i.e.maximally entangled state) with so-called singlet conversion probabil- ity (SCP) [17, 18]). After the conversion, each of the parties (nodes) knows obviously which of the bonds are now perfectly entangled. Using classi- cal communications, the parties establish whether there exists an infinite percolating cluster (or one spanning the lattice ) and who belongs to it. Then, by performing a series of entanglement swappings, it is possible to propagate entanglement between any two (widely) separated nodes that belong to the We call this scheme classi- cal because it essentially maps the problem onto a classicalbond andits suc- cess or failure is equivalent to the success or failure of bond percolation in the same lattice. Namely, ifp > p c, wherepcis the criti- cal percolation threshold (or, in other words, >0, which asymptotically does not de- pend on the distance.
*At the same time that we introduced CEP, we pre- sented several schemes that went beyond the sim- ple by entanglement swapping along a path. We callthese quantum entanglement percolation (QEP) protocols because they use some kind of quan- tum pre-processing-- for instance quantum mea-surements to transform one percolation problem to another one. In these protocols CEP is also used, but is preceded by application of certain LOCC, which in the different long-range properties. The pre- processing in QEP may greatly improve the possi- bility of entanglement percolation, either by reduc- ingpc, or by increasing P. In this paper we present a more systematic and thor- ough study of QEPs based on lattice transformations. In particular, we explore the entire parameter space with the addition of Monte Carlo and series-expansion meth- ods. Although general principles remain to be found, we do discover certain rules and regularities governing such strategies (see Sec. III). The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we formulate and describe the mod- els and fix the notation. Section IIA discusses quantum networks and percolation, whereas Sec. IIB deals with LOCCs used for lattice transformations. Our main five examples of transformations enhancing CEP: i) the transformation of the kagom' e lattice to the square lattice, ii) the transformation of the double-bond hon- eycomb (hexagonal) lattice to the triangular lattice, iii) the transformation of the square lattice to two decoupled copies of the square lattice, iv) the transformation of the bowtie lattice to the decoupled triangularand square lat- tices, and v) the transformation of a triangular lattice with two different degrees of entanglement into the de- coupled square and triangular lattices. The cases ii), iii), and v) were discussed already in Ref. 15, but we present here more general and stronger results. We conclude in Sec. IV. Over the past few decades, classical percolation theory has seen the development of a number of quite sophis- ticated and powerful methods, which we have adapted to the questions at hand. In order to demonstrate the supremacy of QEP over CEP in each of the cases i)-v) we employ these methods combined with the methods of quantum An overviewofthese meth- ods is presented in the appendices: Appendix A presents the necessary facts from majorization theory and protocols [18], Appendix B explains some de- tails of our Monte Carlo (MC) simulations, and finally Appendix C deals with series expansions. II. FORMULATION OF THE MODELS A. Quantum networks and percolation In this section, we describe the classes of quantum Networks of bipartite states The networks we consider consist, prior to application of communication protocols, of a collection of qubits par- titioned into pairs, each pair being prepared in an iden- tical pure state C2C2. With appropriate choice of bases, any such state can be written
=a0|00/an}bracketri}ht+a1|11/an}bracketri}ht, (1) where the Schmidt coefficients 1. We identify these pairs with bonds on a two-dimensional lattice or edges on a graph, with two qubits, one occupying each end of the bond. At regular positions, a small set of these qubits are arranged near enough to one another to on any subset. Such a set of qubits then constitutes a vertex (or node or site) which is incident to each edge that contributes a qubit to the vertex. This defines a lattice to which we apply methods of In particular, many results on the possibility of long-range entanglement are described using [19, 20], and depend only on the graph structure of the system. 2. Classical entanglement a lattice prepared as described above, we search for the protocols consisting of local operations and clas- sical communication (LOCC) that yield the between two nodes separated by an arbitrarily large distance. The answer depends on the single parameter a1characterizing the state. Even with a small palette of possible opera- tions, finding the globally optimal solution is a difficult task. Instead, we search for promising classes of pro- tocols. The simplest protocol consists of attempting to convert the state associated with each bond to a singlet via the Procrustean method of entanglement concen- tration, which is the optimal strategy at the level of a single bond [17, 18]. This conversion succeeds with prob- abilityp= 2a1(See Appendix A.), while failure leaves the pair in a state with no entanglement. In this way the system is described exactly by a bond percolation pro- cess with open-bond density p. If there is a path of open (maximally entangled) bonds connecting twonodes, a se- quence of entanglement swapping measurements, one node, is then applied in orderto entan- gle the first and last node. This protocol is the simplest example of classical entanglement percolation. 3. Percolation theory for CEP. Here we review a few fundamental ideas in necessarytoanalyzeCEP.Thenodesinthelattice can be partitioned into sets such that each node within aset is connected to each other node in the set via a path of open bonds. Such a set of nodes is called an open clus- ter, or sometimes simply a cluster. The central fact of percolation theory is that percolation processes on lattices in dimension 2 and higher ex- hibit a continuous phase transition as the bond density passes through a critical value pc. Forp>pcthere exists with probability one a unique (for the lattices we study here) cluster of infinite mass (number of nodes), while forp <pcall clusters are finite with probability one. It follows that improving an LOCC protocol to obtain a small change in pcan have a dramatic effect on the prob- ability of long-range entanglement. In the long-range entanglement is possible, while in the subcritical phase it is not possible. Serving as the order parameter is the density of the infinite cluster th(p) which we define via th(p) =P[A C], (2) the probability that a fixed node A(say, the node at the origin) is in the the infinite cluster C. When referring to thon a specific lattice, we use a symbol representing the lattice as a subscript. The probability that two selected nodes are members of the same cluster decays in their separation distance to an asymp- totic value of th2(p). (The length scale of decay is the correlation length x(p).) This means, for the problem at hand, that in CEP the probability that information can be propagated between two nodes is Transformations of lattice structure It was proven in Refs. 14 and 15 that CEP is not the optimal strategy for establishing long-distance entangle- ment. The demonstration is based on applying certain LOCC prior to CEP. All of these pre-processing LOCC acton pairsofqubits, and theyeither transformthe state on a given bond, or they replace two adjacent pure-state bonds by one, in general, mixed state bond. There are essentially three types of generalized mea- surement used:
*Singlet conversion The optimal LOCC singlet pro- tocol [18] is used in three situations. In CEP with single-bond lattices we apply it directly to the state (1), 2a1. If the protocol is successful, the bond that is converted to the singlet can be used for en- tanglement propagation (swapping), otherwise it is useless. In CEP with a double-bond lattice we ap- ply it directly to the two copies of the state (1), which lives in C4C4, and has Schmidt singlet is p= (3)4 Finally, in all of the QEP strategies that we study, we also apply singlet conversion to any bonds after the lattice swapping This protocol [13], illus- trated in Fig. 1a, consists of performing the so- called Bell measurement on a pair of qubits (b and c) in a node, i.e. a von Neumann measurement in a basis of 4 maximally entangled orthonormal states (in the computational basis). It allows conversion of a pair of adjacent singlets into a singlet connect- ing end points (a and d) with probability 1, i.e. al- lowsfor perfect a con- nected cluster of singlets. At the same time, when applied toa pairofimperfect states(1), it produces a mixed state, which, amazingly, has the average singlet conversion probability equal to p= Thislast point places a significant constraint on our choice of lattice use entanglement swapping in both CEP In thethe locally move entanglement between neighbor- ing nodes, an operation that is repeated in hopes of transporting entanglement over long distances (This is, roughly speaking, a brute-force method). But with QEP, before attempting to transfer en- tanglement, we search for a way to selectively ap- ply entanglement swappings to alter the geometry of the lattice and hence its long-range as given by percolation theory. The goal of this paper and future work is to enumerate the rich possibilities and point a way towards a of QEP.
*Worst case entanglement Finally, in Refs. 14 and 15 the worst case protocol was used, which maxi- mizes minimal entanglement over all This protocol consists also of Bell mea- surement, but the basis is computational for one qubit, and corresponding to eigenstates of sxfor the second. When applied to qubits, it produces a mixed state with the property that for all measure- ment outcomes, the resulting pure states have the same singlet conversion probability. We will not use this protocol here. In order to describe the lattice transformations in- volved in QEP, we need a more general formulation of the lattice than the one given in Sec. IIA1 for CEP. It is useful to define the percolation processes a bit more precisely. We begin with a graph, that is, a set of a set of vertices (nodes) V. We the graph in R2in order to treat geomet- ric properties. In fact, the important properties don't change if we force the vertices to occupy points in Z2.a) 2: (Color online) a) Mapping a quantum network to a percolation problem. Qubits are represented by small circl sixqubits. nt swapping to transform the lattice structure. The two red (grey) bonds in a) are replaced by the red bond in b). This process can be continued to produce a configuration of open and closed bonds can be de- scribed by a probability sample space ohm points o= (o(e) :eE), whereo(e) takes the values 0 and 1. We allow each bond to be open with a different probability, i.e.p= (p(e) :eE). The appropriate measure is a product measure on ohm with marginal probabilities defined by ue(o(e) = 1) =p(e), ue(o(e) = 0) = 1 -p(e). To allow all via LOCC, we take the graph to be complete-- that is, all possible edges (In fact, sometimes we need double bonds, as well.) For percolation properties, any graph with fewer edges can be identified with this complete graph by set- ting the appropriate p(e) to zero. Now we describe the correspondence of entanglement on the physical system of qubits to this percolation for- mulation. We denote the set of the indices of all qubits byA. Each qubit aAis assigned to a vertex v=V(a), with, in general, multiple qubits assigned to each a triangular lattice is shown in figure Fig. 2a, sixcircled qubits. we denote the reduced state byrab, and byS(a,b) the singlet conversion proba- bility (SCP), that is, the probability of conversion of rab to a singlet, maximized over all possible we assign p(e) =S(a,b) for all reduced bipartite states have either p(e) = 0 for separable states, or p(e) =p= 2a1for the prepared, pure, In Fig.2athe edgeswith p(e) =pare shown in black, while edges with p(e) = 0 are simply absent in the diagram. Two bonds are col- ored red (grey) only to show that they will be replaced by another bond (in the sense of altering the SCP) via entanglement swapping. For QEP, a successful prepro- cessing, entanglement swapping operation such as that depicted in Fig. 1, alters the percolation process by = 0 and = 0 =p. Likewise, in the example in Fig. = = 0, =p. Each of the examples discussed below conforms to this EXAMPLES We consider five examples of lattice this paper, each exhibiting a different combination of features, with implications for the analysis of protocols. In particular, two transformations convert one lattice to another, while the other three convert a lattice into two decoupled lattices. Four transformations involve lattices with single bonds, while the fifth involves double arising in the analysis, such as th(p), are ana- lytic about p= 1. In fact, the lowest-order term in the expansion about p= 1 is typically much larger than the remaining terms even relatively far from p= 1, with the result that most of the interesting crossover behavior in comparing protocols occurs for smaller values of p. But this behavior does not appear when using the for double bonds that leads to (3). The reason is that distillation produces a saturation point for th(p) smaller than p= 1. This results in a much stronger dif- ference between classical and quantum protocols in (two-qubit pure states). Four of the produce a smaller critical density on at least one of the resulting lattices, which gives the most in the regime near the critical density. The fifth example shows that on some lattices where a partic- ular QEP strategy is not advantageous, allowing bonds of different strengths pandp'can produce regions in the phase space ( p,p') where QEP is indeed consider comparing CEP in which singlet con- version is applied to each bond separately, with QEP that results in a single transformed lattice. In every such case we find that QEP is better than CEP overthe range of p. It is an open question whether this is generic behavior. We analyze the results of the transformation of each lattice in three regimes: near the critical density (or den- sities); near p= 1; and between these tworegimes. Argu- ments near the critical densities typically rely simply on the fact that long-range entanglement is impossible on a lattice with density below the critical density. These re- sults are the most insensitive to details of the definitions of entanglement and connectivity. Near p= 1 we com- pute high-density expansions for th(p) and related quan- tities (see Sec. C.) Often the difference between the per- formance of CEP and QEP in this regime is marginal. It is important nonetheless to carry out the analysis if we hope to make general statements about hold for all p. Between the critical regime and high- density regime there are some techniques widely used in percolation theory that may be useful, such as Russo's formula, which is used to prove inequalities in the rate of change ofth(p). However, we leave these techniques forFIG. 3: One of three transformations of the kagom' e lattice to the square lattice. Pairs of qubits that are subjected to entanglement swapping are marked with loops. future work and use Monte Carlo computations in the present paper. A. Kagom' e lattice to square lattice In our first example we compare CEP on the kagom' e lattice to quantum entanglement percolation consisting of transformation of the kagom' e lattice to the square lattice via entanglement swapping at nodes specified in Fig. 3. Although we do not treat them here, there are at least two more ways to transform the kagom' e lattice to the square lattice using the same kind of entangle- ment swapping. Rigorous bounds have been obtained for pc(kagom' e) [19] (as well as a high-precision Monte Carlo estimate [21]) while pc(/square) is known exactly, proving and the lower bound for pc(kagom' e). As shown in Table II, the series for the same to the first non-trivial order in q= 1-p. But the next term shows that th/square> thkagforpclose enough to 1. The MC data provides strong evidence that near p= 1, where the statistical error is too large to distinguish the curves. But as is evident from the lower plot in Fig. 3, the terms in the expansions that we computed dominate at values of pfor which the MC data is still accurate. Thus we find that QEP is advantageous over the entire range of p. B. Double-bond hexagonal lattice to hexagonal lattice with double bonds, each in the state specified by (1) (see Fig. 5a), was discussed in Refs. 14 and 15, in which it was shown that a trans- formation of the lattice to a triangular lattice offers an advantage over CEP protocols for values of pbetween pc(^) and another critical value defined below. Here we extend the analysis to determine over the entire range of pwhich ofthree highest we call CEP I, consists of performing an 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.7 0.75 0.8 0.85 0.9 4: Upperplot: MonteCarlo of1 -th(p)v.s.p= 2a1. The solid line is on the square lattice. The dashed line is on the kagom' e lattice. Lower plot: Normalized difference The solid line is computed from MC data. The dashed line is computed from expansions from Table II. (a) (b) FIG. 5: (a) Double-bond hexagonal lattice. (b) transformed into the triangular lattice (b). Pairs of qubits that are sub - jected to entanglement swapping are marked with loops. singlet conversion to each bond separately so that the probability of getting at least one singlet connecting two nodes isp'= 1-(1-p)2. Communication on the result- ing lattice is then determined by bond percolation on the hexagonal lattice with bond density p'. In particular, the critical density (see Table I) is p=pc(CEP I) 0.4107. In the second protocol, we perform a more efficient con- version, namely distillation, on all four qubits in a doublebond. This protocol succeeds in producing a pair with probability p''= (3) and Appendix A.) This results in bond percola- tion on the hexagonal lattice with density p''= (4) We refer to this method as CEP II, with critical density p=pc(CEP II) 0.358. In the third method, the en- tanglement swapping that maximizes SCP is applied at everyother node (see Fig. 5), convertingthe to the triangular lattice with bond den- sityp, three protocols are compared in Fig. 6. We first observe that each method fails below its and Tocompare the methods away from the critical points, we computed series expansions of th(p) aboutq= 0 with results listed in Table II. Defining ~th(q) =th(1-q) we see that
~thCEP I(q) =~th/hexagon(q2) = (5) to th^(p) from Table II we see that for p-1 the conversion to the triangular lattice is better than CEP I. As is evident from Figs. 6a and 6b, the two curves have the same leading behavior as p-1, with the result that the the Monte Carlo cannot distinguish them in this region. However, the series expansion p= 1, thCEP Ieven in the region where the MC the curves. Finally, the MC clearly Ifor smallerp, where the now to CEP II, we know that th^>thCEP IIfor pc(^)< p < p c(CEP II) and from (4) that thCEP II= 1 forp>=2- 2. It follows that there must be a crossover point. The MC data suggests that this occurs for p 0.375. In summary, we see that QEP gives an advantage over CEP I for all p, but that CEP II, which is more efficient in its use of double bonds, is better than QEP at high densities. C. Square lattice to two decoupled copies of the square lattice This transformation replaces the square lattice with two decoupled copies of the square lattice. To effect at selected nodes the two bonds are joined into one bond and likewise with the vertically opposing bonds. This procedure shifting rows as shown in Fig. 7. Because splits the original lattice into two each taking half the surviving nodes, we between a single pair of nodes before and after the transformation. Rather, we consider on the original lattice connection between, on the one hand, 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 bond 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 0.85 0.9 bond hexagonal CEP 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6double-bond hexagonal CEP I double-bond hexagonal CEP 6: Monte Carlo and series expansions about p= 1 of 1-th(p)v.s.p= 2a1for various strategies on the double- bond hexagonal lattice. (a) Solid lines are Monte Carlo data . Dashed lines are series expansions. (b) Solid lines are MC. S e- ries expansions are from MC over the enti re plot. (c) Monte Carlo data. pair of nodes A,A'separated by a small distance, and on the other hand, the same pair translated a distance much larger than the correlation length to a pair B,B'. We choose AandA'so that each one goes to a in the transformation. After the is the possibility of connection between AandB on one lattice and between A'andB'on the other. We choose the nodes as shown in Fig. 7. In addition to the(a) (b) A A' FIG. 7: Doubling the square lattice. Large circles represen t nodes at which entanglement swapping is 0.84 0.86 0.88 0.90.92 0.94 0.96 0.98 pconnection 8: Monte Carlo and series expansions for doubling the square lattice. Lower points: 1 -Pdoubv.s.p. Upper Solid lines are series of splitting, this example is subtle because the critical density is the same on all three lattices. In Ref. 15 it was shown that just above pc(/square) = 1/2, givesanadvantageoverCEPasmeasured by the choice of nodes A,A'. Here we examine the connectivity for all p > p c(/square). The probability that at least one of the pairs on the 0.55 0.6 0.65 probability FIG. 9: Monte Carlo for doubling the square lattice. Upper points: 1 Lower points: (2 lattices is connected is Pdouble= compare Pdoubleto the probability on the original lattice that at least one of AandA'is connected to at least one of BandB'. This probability is CorA' C]. (6) (In this paper 'or' in ' XorY' doesnotmean exclusive or.) We prove that the doubling is advantageous in the limitp-1 using the power series about q= 0 in Table II. This follows from = Monte Carlo evidence suggests that the trans- formation improves on CEP for all p > pc(/square).In Fig. 8 one sees from the accuracy of the series expansion in the region of high-quality MC data that that the advantage is maintained even when the Monte Carlo becomes noisy nearp= 1. The same MC data is not useful near pc(/square) for two reasons. Firstly, both at the same critical point with infinite slope. Secondly, the systematic error due to finite lattice size and large fluc- tuations in cluster statistics further complicate distin- guishing the curves. We instead make use of an alter- nate expression for p, that where o=P[A C|A' C]. The condition for advantage over CEP then (7) The MC data for owas generated by considering in the finite lattice to representthe if it is not a spanning cluster. The MC data supports (7), and furthermore, shows no evidence of non-analyticity at pc(/square), as is evident in Fig. 9. The foregoing analysis of the doubled square lattice was based on the choice of A,A'shown in Fig. 7. whether the doubling transformation is better than CEP depends somewhat on the details of how the nodes are chosen. Although this is an extreme example, sim- ilar questions arise in analyzing other the ambiguity in the measures comparing the var- ious protocols must be addressed in future work. D. Bowtie lattice to decoupled triangular and square lattices This is our second example that transforms a lat- tice into two decoupled lattices. Figure 10 shows the measurements that decouple the bowtie lattice into 10: Transformation of the bowtie lattice to decoupled square and triangular lattices. Loops marking pairs of qubi ts represent swapping lattice and the triangular lattice. For c() (the exact critical values are listed in Table I), the transformation is obviously advantageous. In carrying out further analysis, the bowtie presentin in this paper: While the other lattices are regular in the sense that each vertex has the same environment up to rotations and reflections, the bowtie lattice has two kinds of vertices in this sense. Notice first that all the surviving nodes on the square and triangular lattices shown in Fig. 10 were generated from nodes of coordina- tion number z= 6 on the bowtie lattice, with all nodes ofz= 4 disappearing. Each node of z= 6 on the bowtie lattice has four nearest neighbors of z= 6, ofz= 4 (for example node Ain Fig. 10.) Further- more, two of these nearest neighbors are connected by a diagonal bond (node A'') and two are not (node A'.) In treating the example of doubling the square lattice in Sec. IIIC, the fact that the lattice decouples forced us to consider connections between two widely separated pairs of nodes. We treat the present example in the same way, except that the more complicated local structure of the bowtie lattice forces us to consider a cluster of than a pair. In Fig. 10b we sent to the square lattice and Ais sent to the triangular lattice. We consider a distant cluster toA,A',A''by translation, and examine the probability that a connection exists between at leastoneof A,A',A''andat leastone of B,B',B''. On the bowtie lattice, this probability is p2 where p=P[A CorA' CorA'' 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.4 0.45 0.5 1-p2 pconnection 11: Monte Carlo estimates of The inset is the same data on a linear scale. Solid lines are high- density pcfor bond 2sin( 0.4045 square 0 .5 kagom' e 0.5244053 MC 1 I: pcfor bond percolation on some lattices. pc() is the unique root of 1 -p-6p2+6p3-p5. All critical densities are exact[19] except for pc(kagom' e)[21]. If instead we decouple the lattices via the lattice this probability is given CorA'' C]. (9) A comparison of Monte Carlo estimates and of these quantities is shown in Fig. 11. The MC data shows that for small densities, the lattice trans- formation gives an advantage, while for higher densities CEP is the better protocol. The cross-over occurs at p0.425. As with the other examples, the curves repre- senting the series expansions suggests that no in the high-density region. E. Asymmetric triangular lattice With this example we demonstrate that QEP can suc- ceed when the initial bonds are not all in the same state, but fail if they are in the same state. Consider the lattice in Fig. 12a composed of two different kinds of bonds, each of the form given by (1). The solid and dashed bonds represent the states (withp= 2a' 1) respectively. In general, 1-q4-6q6 p 1-4q14 TABLE II: A few terms in series expansions about q= 0 ofp andthfor various lattices. defined via (2). p/squarebis defined via (9), p/squarevia (6) , and pvia (8). (a) (b) FIG. 12: a) The asymmetric triangular lattice. Solid bonds represent the state p). Dashed bonds represent the state density p'). b) Entanglement swapping is performed on pairs of solid bonds resulting in a with bond density p. The remaining dashed bonds form a kagom' e lattice which is then transformed into a squar e lattice with bond density p'as in Sec. IIIA. We consider two entanglement distribution protocols: a) classical entanglement percolation on the original lattice and b) QEP consisting of creating two decoupled lat- tices (the square and triangular lattices) via entangle- ment swapping, followed by CEP on each of the The transformationis describedin Fig.12. Note that, forp'= 0, the initial lattice is a triangular lattice with serial double bonds and therefore the critical On the other hand for p= 0 0 the initial lattice is the kagom' e lattice. We first examine the most robust measure of a pro- tocol's effectiveness-- the binary measure that tells whether long-range entanglement is possible or not. The phase diagrams for this example before and after are shown in Fig. 13. We see that there are regions in the phase space for which QEP is better than CEP, and vice versa. In the region in which both protocols allow a more detailed measure similar to those in previous sections is necessary. For example, for p=p', we performed an analysis similar to the one used for dou- bling the square lattice. The two critical boundaries in- tersect atp=p'=pc(^), but comparing above the critical point shows that the transforma- tion does not improve the probability of long-range en- tanglement. Likewise for p=p'andpnear 1, showed that the transformation is not an im- provement on CEP. We have not yet determined 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 e)
`
pc(^), 13: Phase diagram for the asymmetric triangular lattic e. The heavy solid curve (obtained by Monte Carlo) separates the supercritical and subcritical regions on the original a sym- metric triangular lattice (CEP). The dashed curve andsubcri tical regions after ion, the supercritical region is defined to be the region for which at least one of the disjoint lattices is supercritical. In th e light gray regions, long-range entanglement is possible with QEP , but not with CEP. In the dark gray region it is possible with CEP, but not with QEP. QEP in this scenario succeeds for some other p=p', but this seems unlikely. IV. CONCLUSIONS In this paper we have considered the problem of es- tablishing long-distance entanglement in quantum pure- state networks on regular 2D lattices. We have discussed in detail several examples of quantum entanglement per- colation strategies that are better than the correspond- ing classical strategies, i.e. those consisting of a direct attempt to convert bonds into singlets. Our results illus- trate nicely the interplay between quantum and classical percolation theory. Despite the fact that we do find certain rules and regularities governing QEP strategies, many questions remain open. For in- stance, we cannot say anything about optimality of our QEP protocols-- and most probably they are not opti- mal. All of our protocols involve LOCC acting on pairs of qubits only; can multipartite LOCC, which leads in- evitably to creation of multipartite entanglement, help? We know that for sufficiently large initial entanglement between remote nodes may be es- tablished with probability P >0. Is it also possible for arbitrarily small initial thank A. Ac' in, J.I. Cirac, and D. Cavalcanti for discussions. We thank S. Perseguers for kindly supply- ing figures. We acknowledge support of the EU IP Pro- gramme SCALA, and Spanish MEC grants (FIS 2005- 04627, Consolider Ingenio 2010 QOIT). J.W. thanks Lluis Torner and ICFO for hospitality. He was by NSF grant DMS 0623941. M. L. thanks also the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation for A: MAJORIZATION theory has been applied to questions of transforming one bipartite pure state to another that such a transformation can be achieved via an optimal protocol (without specifying that proto- col.) We state the result and apply it to the used in this paper. We must first introduce a certain partial order on vectors. Consider two real, d- dimensional vectors rands. We define the vector r|
by reordering the elements of rinto non-decreasing or- der, and likewise with s. We say that ris denoted by rws, (A1) for allk= 0,...,d-1. Denoting the vector of of psbyl(ps), the theorem states that be transformed into probability p, wherep is the largest number on [0 ,1] such that l(ps)wpl(ph). A simple, relevant application is the computation of the probability that optimal conversion of a state CdCdto a singlet will succeed. Application of (A1) givesp= we consider distillation, defined here as the opti- mal protocol for converting npure states C2C2 ton-1 product states and one maximally entangled state in the Schmidt bases. This operation is useful, for instance, in attempting to get a single, bond from nbonds connecting two nodes. Ex- plicitly,
=ai,0|00/an}bracketri}hti+ai,1|11/an}bracketri}hti, withai,0>=ai,1and elements of the ordered n-1,0) non-increasing. As usual, shorthand for Forj {0,1}nde- fine the bijective numeration k(j) Then we can write n-1/circlemultiplydisplay i=0=2n-1/summationdisplay j:k(j)=0gkn-1/circlemultiplydisplay m=0|jmjm/an}bracketri}htm.(A2)11 In order to apply the theorem, we need to show that this state can be written as a bipartite state with that can be chosen to satisfy our To this end collect all the first qubits of the bipartite states and all the second qubits, that (A2) becomes n-1/circlemultiplydisplay i=0=2n-1/summationdisplay j:k(j)=0gk|k(j)/an}bracketri}hta|k(j)/an}bracketri}htb.(A3) Note = 1n= 1 so that (A3) defines a state in C2nC2nalready in Schmidt form. The submajorization condition which the only nontrivial inequality is the penulti- mate one 1 -g0>=p/2. Thus the maximum is p= that this result agrees with the special case in (3). APPENDIX B: MONTE CARLO ESTIMATES computed Monte Carlo estimates of th(p) andp(p) using the Hoshen-Kopelmann [22] algorithm with modi- fications for efficiency [23] and the Mersenne twister [24] random number generator. Together with series expan- sions and exactly known critical densities, the quality of the data we obtained is more than sufficient to determine which transformations are advantageous. We estimated th(p) by computing the mean density ofthe anLxLlattice. Near the critical density we typi- cally used lattices of size L= 2-5x105. We took the value ofLat the inflection point of plots of th(p)v.s.L at fixedpas estimates of the correlation length x(p). We typically found that x(p)> Lforp-pc<0.0005. poses no problem because the curves are never close to one another in these regions. (We reformulated the problem when this is the case.) We computed but the error bars are at most barely visible on the plots, so we omitted them. Exceptions are very near p=pcwhere fluctuations in the size of the largest cluster become large, and near p= 1, where finite clusters are rare, so collecting sufficient samples to distinguish curves is too expensive. We discuss the effects of these errors in the main body of the paper.We wrote a single computer code to study all the lat- tices. The code supports lattices with vertices that oc- cupy points on Z2with bonds connecting each pair asadiagonalbond from ( Because the connectivity properties that we calculated depend only on the graph structure of the lat- tice, we embedded the graph of each lattice in the square lattice plus above. Depending on the lattice being modeled, some of the bonds in the underly- ing lattice are closed with probability one, and some are open with probability one, with the vertices identified in the embedded lattice. The graph structures of all in this paper were modeled in this way. APPENDIX C: SERIES 26,27] to compute high-density series expansions of th(p) and p(p) listed in Table II. Here we discuss the method for computing the series for th(p), but our method for com- putingp(p) is similar. Here, a cluster is any that contains at least one vertex. We denote byS0the collection of all finite clusters that include the vertex at the origin, and by Sthe partition of S0induced by equivalence under translation, in other words the col- lection of free clusters. Choosing an enumeration ajof clusters in S, the probability that a randomly selected site is in the infinite open cluster is easily seen to be th(p) = the number of sites and bjthe number of bonds in cluster aj, andtjis the number of aj). series expansion in qby enumerating the clusters in an order that is non-decreasing in tj. For instance, on the hexagonal lattice, only the cluster consisting of an isolated site has a perimeter tof size less than or equal to 3 (see Fig. 14), so that to lowest non-trivial order th(p) = 1-q3. Percolation theory is a difficult because the full enumeration is difficult. The series forth^(for bond percolation) was calculated by machine to high order in Ref. 27. Although tables of cluster numbers have been published, all the others that we are aware of are either for site percolation or for bond percolation with cluster size measured by the number of bonds rather than sites (neither of which can be mapped to our notsodifficult. In that it is also essential to categorize the clusters by symme- try. As an example, the clusters contributing to thon the hexagonal lattice to sixth order in qare shown in Fig. 2 b= 0 s= 1 t= 3 n= 1q32-axis m= 3 b= 1 s= 2 t= 4 n= 33pq4m= 6 b= 2 s= 3 t= 5 n= 9axis rot-axis m= 2 b= 3 s= 4 t= 6 n= 4 none m= 12 b= 3 s= 4 t= 6 n= 24axis m= 6 b= 3 s= 4 t= 6 n= 12all m= 1 b= 6 s= 6 t= 6 n= 3 FIG.14: Clusters onthehexagonal lattice contributingto thto sixth order in q. Symmetries and multiplicities mare: none- 12, one axis-6, rotation-4, two axes-3, rotation and axis-2 , all-1. The number of contributing clusters per figure is give n byn=ms/2, the factor of 1 /2 accounting for the fact that each site only supports half the rotations. The contributio n tothis R. Horodecki, P. Horodecki, M. Horodecki, and K. Horodecki, Rev. Mod. Phys. , in press, J.I.Cirac, P.Zoller, H.J.Kimble, andH.Mabuchi, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 3221 (1997), A. D. Boozer, A. Boca, R. Miller, T. E. Northup, and H. J. Kimble, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 193601 (pages 4) (2007), . [4] A. K. Ekert, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 661 (1991). [5] C. H. Bennett, G. Brassard, C. Cr' epeau, R. Jozsa, A. Peres, and W. K. Wootters, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1895 (1993). [6] A. Poppe, M. Peev, O. Maurhart, and (on behalf of the Integrated European Project SECOQC), Int. J. Quant. Inf.6, 209 (2008), J. I. Cirac, A. K. Ekert, S. F. Huelga, and C. Mac- chiavello, Phys. Rev. A 59, 4249 (1999), M. Nielsen and I. Chuang, Quantum Computation and Quantum Information (Cambridge University 2000). [9] H.-J. Briegel, W. D ur, J. I. Cirac, and P. Zoller, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5932 (1998), W. D ur, H.-J. Briegel, J. I. Cirac, and P. Zoller, Phys. Rev. A59, 169 (1999), L. Childress, J. M. Taylor, A. S. Sorensen, and M. D. Lukin, Phys. Rev. A 72, 052330 (pages 16) (2005), . [12] L. Hartmann, B. Kraus, H.-J. Briegel, and W. Dur, Phys. Rev. A 75, 032310 (pages 17) (2007), .[13] M..Zukowski, A.Zeilinger, M. A. Horne, andA.K. Ekert, Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 4287 (1993). [14] A. Ac' in, J. I. Cirac, and M. Lewenstein, Nature Physics 3, 256 (2007), . [15] S. Perseguers, J. I. Cirac, A. Ac' in, M. Lewen- stein, and J. Wehr, Phys. Rev. A 77, 022308 (pages 14) (2008), arXiv:0708.1025, . [16] K. Kieling and J. Eisert, in Quantum Percolation and Breakdown (Springer, Heidelberg, 2008), in G. Vidal, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 1046 (1999), M. A. Nielsen and G. Vidal, Quantum Inf. Comput. 1, 76 (2001). [19] G. Grimmett, Percolation Berlin, 1999), 2nd ed. [20] D. Stauffer and A. Aharony, Introduction to & Francis, London, 1992), 2nd ed. [21] R. M. Ziff and P. N. Suding, J. Phys. A 30, 5351 J. Hoshen and R. Kopelman, Phys. Rev. B 14, H. Nakanishi and H. E. Stanley, Phys. Rev. B 22, T. Nishimura, ACM Trans. on Modeling and 10, 348 (2000). [25] C. Domb, Nature 184, 589 (1959). [26] C. Domb and M. F. Sykes, Phys. Rev. 122, 77 (1961). [27] J. Blease, J. W. Essam, and C. M. Place, J. Phys. C. 11, 4009 (1978).
|
0807.1118
|
Gerald Lapeyre Jr.
|
G. John Lapeyre Jr, Jan Wehr, Maciej Lewenstein
|
Enhancement of Entanglement Percolation in Quantum Networks via Lattice
Transformations
|
12 pages, 17 figures, revtex4. changes from v3: minor stylistic
changes for journal reviewer, minor changes to figures for journal editor
| null |
10.1103/PhysRevA.79.042324
| null |
quant-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study strategies for establishing long-distance entanglement in quantum
networks. Specifically, we consider networks consisting of regular lattices of
nodes, in which the nearest neighbors share a pure, but non-maximally entangled
pair of qubits. We look for strategies that use local operations and classical
communication. We compare the classical entanglement percolation protocol, in
which every network connection is converted with a certain probability to a
singlet, with protocols in which classical entanglement percolation is preceded
by measurements designed to transform the lattice structure in a way that
enhances entanglement percolation. We analyze five examples of such comparisons
between protocols and point out certain rules and regularities in their
performance as a function of degree of entanglement and choice of operations.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 8 Jul 2008 19:51:46 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 20:56:29 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Fri, 16 Jan 2009 09:18:16 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Wed, 4 Mar 2009 17:14:31 GMT"
}
] | 2013-05-29T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Lapeyre",
"G. John",
"Jr"
],
[
"Wehr",
"Jan",
""
],
[
"Lewenstein",
"Maciej",
""
]
] |
2 T. la and K. Piotrzkowski [ GeV ]g gW0 200 400 600 800 1000 ]-1 [ GeV g gdWg luminosity spectrumg g with VFD double tag Figure 1. Elastic luminosity spectrum of photon- photon collisions at the LHC assuming the max- imal photon virtuality Q2 max = 2 The luminosity spectrum assuming the photon tagging range 20 GeV < Eg<900 GeV is also shown (dashed line). that apart from such elastic two-photon processes where both protons have survived the production can also be considered, when at least one of the two protons dissociates into a low mass state. The corresponding two- photon luminosity increases then by about a fac- tor of three [2]. By integrating the above some minimal center-of-mass en- ergyW0, one can introduce the relative photon- photon luminosity Lgg, shown in Fig. 2. a fraction of the which is available for is especially useful if a given is approximately constant as a func- tion ofWgg. For example, the relative photon- photon luminosity at the LHC is equal to 1%
forW0= 23 GeV (i.e. for Wgg>23 GeV), and 0.1% for W0= 225 GeV. Given the very large LHC luminosity, this leads to rates of high-energy processes with rela- tively small photon-photon cross sections. In the following only the proton cross-sections arequoted. [ GeV ]0W0 500 1000 1500 2000g g dW g g/dW g gdL 0W luminostyg grelative Figure 2. Relative elastic ggluminosity for pho- ton collisions at the center-of-mass energy above W0, obtained using the EPA for proton collisions ats= 14TeV, and assuming the maximal pho- ton virtuality Q2 max= 2 GeV2. One needs however to consider corrections be- yond the EPA due to a possibility of strong inter- actions between protons, or the so-called rescat- tering effects. The resulting suppression of the cross sections weakly depends on the invariant mass of the exclusively produced state X, and for the processes discussed in the following, as pp-pWWp , it is estimated to be about 15%
[7]. This correction is ignored in the present anal- ysis. In addition, one should stress that poten- tially dangerous background due to the exclu- sive diffractive production is heavily suppressed for non particles and can be safely neglected. For example, the gluon medi- ated exclusive production of W boson pairs, is about 100 times smaller than the two-photon pro- duction at the LHC [8]. Anomalous quartic couplings of the elec- troweak gauge bosons could directly reveal the exchange of new heavy bosons [9,10], and theAnomalous quartic gauge couplings in gginteractions at the LHC 3 two-photon exclusive production of WW and ZZ pairs is particularly well suited for studies of the quartic couplings ggWW andggZZ . In the Standard Model (SM), the cross section of the exclusive two-photon production pp-pWWp is large about 108 fb-1[1]. This means that unique, high statistics tests of the gauge boson sector in the SM can be performed at the LHC. In contrast, the cross section of the exclusive two-photon is very small in the SM, since this proccess is not allowed at the tree level. It means that an observation of even a few events of this type could signal the new physics. 2. Anomalous quartic gauge couplings The anomalous quartic gauge can be introduced in various ways, usually by building an effective lagrangian which models a low energy behavior of a wide class of possible extensions of the SM. For example, one can introduce new terms in such a are allowed by the local U(1) YxSU(2)L gauge invariance, and then consider two scenar- ios, with [11] and without [12] the Higgs boson. In the present analysis, the are used, which allow for quartic vector boson couplings, with- out need for associated trilinear gauge the simplest lagrangian term of power six in energy for two photon interaction with weak bosons has to conserve local U(1) emand custo- dial SU(2) c. Then, by imposing conservation of discrete C and P symmetries one finally obtains two new terms (1) whereeis the electron charge and L is the en- ergy scale of the new physics. When the is not imposed then one can distinguish the neutral and charged couplings of the W and Z bosons. Since this more general model has been assumed for studies at LEP [14], to allow for a direct comparison of is also assumed in the following: L0 6 (2) Using this formalism, one obtains a general rela- tion for the WW andZZcross sections (which is also valid after applying the acceptance cuts) as a function of the anomalous corresponds, for a fixed cross section s, to an ellipse on the a0,acplane. 3. Estimation of of the exclusive two-photon pair production at the LHC was performed using the modified [16] and CalcHep [17] packages. The generated events were then passed to the modified Pythia generator [18] to allow for decays and hadronisation. The sen- sitivity to the anomalous quartic vector boson couplings at the LHC has been investigated us- ing the signature of two opposite charge lep- tons (eoru) within the generic lepton accep- tance window - |e|<2.5 andpT>10 GeV. In theWW case it corresponds to the in the ZZcase to the subprocesses gg-ZZ-l+l-jj. It is as- sumed that both processes are background free. Under this condition, the upper limits of number of events lupat the 95% confidence level (CL) were calculated assuming the number of observed events equal to the SMprediction N obs=ssm accL for a given integrated luminosity (lup=supL; k) = 1 -CL (4) This is a simplified approach and for more precise analysis one should use formula from [15], how- ever the difference in the obtained limits is small, less than 20%.4 T. la and K. Piotrzkowski The expected 95% CL limits luphave been then used to calculate the upper limits on the observed cross section supat the 95% CL for the integrated luminosity L = 1 fb-1and L = 10 fb-1, shown in the Table 1. Table 1 Expected 95% CL upper limits for the cross sec- tions after acceptance cuts for chosen The assumed numbers of the observed WW events correspond to the SM cross using MG/ME and the N obs= 0 ssm acc= 4.081 fb lup= 2.996 L = 1 fb-19.2 3 .0 L = 10 fb-15.3 0 .30 The calculated cross section upper limits can be directly converted to the limits of the anoma- lous quartic couplings as presented at the Fig. 3 where the 95% CL contours are shown. In Fig. 4 one parameter limits (with the other set to zero) are shown, and the obtained limits are quoted in the Table 2. Table 2 Expected one-parameter limits for vector boson couplings at 95% CL for two values of the integrated Limits [10-6GeV-2] L = 1 fb-1L = 10 fb-1
|aZ 0/L2| 0.49 0 .16
|aZ C/L2| 1.84 0 .58
|aW 0/L2| 0.54 0 .27
|aW C/L2| 2.02 0 .99]-2 [GeV2L/0a-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5-610x]-2 WWs ZZs WWs ZZs}
}-1 L=1fb -1 L=10fb Figure 3. Profiles of the 95% CL upper limits of the cross section after the acceptance cuts a function of relevant anoma- lous couplings aW 0/L2, aW c/L2, aZ 0/L2and aZ c/L2. The contours are shown assuming two values of the integrated obtained limits are about 40 000 times bet- ter than the best limits established at LEP2 [14] clearly showing large and unique potential of such studies at the LHC. 4. Impact of unitarity bound condition The lagrangian terms in Eq.(2), do not pre- serve the SU(2) Llocal symmetry. In consequence, for the center-of-mass energies amplitude will grow and eventually will violate the unitarity condition. It is therefore nec- essary to investigate the impact of the on the derived limits. For simplicity, the unitarity violation is checked only for the the anomalous coupling ggZZ is set to zero) processes are neglected, as well as the production of fermion pairs as it drops fast with Wgg[1]. For spin one particles one ob- tains the partial wave amplitudes aJusing theAnomalous quartic gauge couplings in gginteractions at the LHC 5 ]-2 [GeV2L/0a-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1-610x WW-g g ZZ-g 4. Cross sections of the acceptance cuts are shown as a func- tion of the genuine anomalous quartic vector boson couplings aW 0/L2and aZ 0/L2(for 0), together with the upper cross section limits at CL=95% (horizontal lines). Legendre polynomial PJ: aJ(s) the cosine of the W boson polar angle in system, and Mis the amplitude of the process gg-W+W-. Then, the unitarity bound condition has a the Lorentz velocity of a W boson in the cms frame and polstands for polarization states in bounds of Eq. 6 for J=0 as a func- tion ofWggare shown for both neutral, in Fig. 5, and charged, in Fig. 6, AQGCs together with the obtained limits of anomalous couplings for the in- tegrated luminosity L= 10 fb-1. It shows that for these limits the unitarity will be violated when Wggis above 2 TeV, also if one allows for a contri- bution of some other channels, by requesting the [GeV]g gW310]-2 2unitarity limit 0.5 2unitarity limit 0.4 -1L = 10 fb Figure 5. Unitarity limit for the W coupling according to Eq. 6 for J=0 (full line), and assuming that the left hand side of Eq. 6 is smaller than (0 .4)2 (dashed line). The arrow indicates the obtained limit at 95% CL from Tab. 2 for 10 fb-1. left hand side of Eq. 6 to be smaller than (0 .4)2 instead of (0 .5)2. Other WW states with differ- ent total angular momentum do not violate the unitarity earlier, and a1is close to 0 when a2is much smaller than a0. The unitarity violation occurs due to the in- creasing contribution of longitudinally polarized W bosons, which in the SM is fully to the local SU(2) Lsymmetry and the tri- linear gauge couplings. As a consequence, one has to verify if the limits quoted in Tab. 2 are not driven by gginteractions at Wggabove 2 TeV. As one can see in Fig. 7, this is actually the case, since the anomalous cross-section is large for the energies well above 2 TeV. This can be avoided in two ways. The double tagging using very would limit the maximal energy to 1.8 TeV [6]. One should note that the tagging efficiency in this energy range is high, about 80% [19]. In other case, one can introduce dipole form-factors for each anomalous coupling, as in Eq. 7. The form-factors suppress the anoma-6 T. la and K. Piotrzkowski [GeV]g gW310]-2 limit 0.5 2unitarity limit 0.4 -1L = 10 fb Figure 6. Analogous plot to Fig. 5 but for the W charged anomalous coupling aW C/L2. Also in this case, unitarity will be violated for Wggabove 2 TeV. lous amplitudes when the energies are close to the new physics energy scale (7) where the power Xis chosen so to preserve the unitarity - in the present analysis X= 2. 5. Expected limits for anomalous quartic gauge couplings The sensitivity analysis has been repeated for the process gg-W+W-using the above form- factors. In Fig. 8 and in Fig. 9 the new for the integrated luminosity L= 10 fb-1 are shown. The limits were calculated for 5 different L val- ues and linearly interpolated. Moreover, the uni- tarity limit (solid line in Figs. 8,9) is L, after correcting for the This choice can be explained in the following way. If one obtains a limit of an anoma- lous coupling for Wgg= L than for the energies below L the unitarity is automatically preserved. For higher energies, bigger than L the 201 Mean 2646 RMS 2343 [GeV]g gW0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 fb]-1 [GeVg 201 Mean 2646 RMS 2343 Figure 7. Differential cross section ds/dW acceptance cuts, for the SM (solid line) and for the AQGC case (dashed line), assuming aW 0/L2= 0. suppression should be strong enough to keep the unitarity unbroken. By repeating the sensitivity analysis from Sec. 3, the results shown in Fig. 8 and in Fig. 9 are ob- tained, and the following 95% CL limits for the anomalous quartic couplings can be derived for gg-W+W-fully leptonic events, for the inte- grated luminosity L= 10 (9) which are about 4 000 times stronger than achieved at LEP [14], and are 10 times weaker than results from Tab. 2, obtained ignoring the unitarity constraints. 6. Summary and perspectives The initial analysis of sensitivity to genuine AQGCs in photon-photon collisions at the LHC has been presented. A simple method of event counting has provided very promising results, showing improvements of the LEP AQGC limitsAnomalous quartic gauge couplings in gginteractions at the LHC 7 [GeV]L310]-2 with form-factor, L=10 fb unitarity limit -1L = 10 fb Figure 8. The 95% CL limits of the W quartic coupling (dashed line) calcu- lated for the integrated luminosity L= 10 fb-1 with the dipole form-factor. The unitarity curve (solid line) is calculated for Wgg= L, and due to inclusion of the from-factor is four times higher than in Fig. 5. The solid arrows indicate the strongest limit without violating the unitarity, and the corresponding energy scale L of the new physics. Dashed arrow recalls the limit obtained without the form-factors. by a factor of about 4 000, for the integrated lu- minosity 10 fb-1. The effects of the to preserve unitarity constraints, are taken into account. In addition, the the sensitivity to the new physics energy scale up to 2 TeV. There are still several possible ways to improve the sensitivity. First, one can include also semi- leptonic channels in gg-WW , which will in- crease statistics about 6 times. In addition, one can increase sensitivity by studing the differential distributions, like the lep- ton pseudo-rapidity (see Fig. 10), or the (see Fig. 11) distributions. Finally, assuming the cus- todial SU(2) csymmetry, one can convert the lim- its the single a0limit, and [GeV]L310]-2 with form-factor, L=10 fb unitarity limit -1L = 10 fb Figure 9. The sensitivity plot for the W quartic coupling. The plot is analo- gous to Fig. 8. similarly the into the single aC limit (see. Eq. 1). This will be the subject of a future J. de Favereau et al. ,High energy photon inter- actions at the LHC , CP3-08-04, July 2008, to be submitted to EPJC. 2. K. Piotrzkowski, Phys. Rev. D M. Albrow et al. ,The FP420 R &D Project: Higgs and New Physics with forward protons at the LHC FP420 , arXiv:0806.0302 [hep-ex]. 4. V. M. Budnev et al. , Phys. Rept. 15(1974) 181. 5. J. de Favereau de Jeneret, X. Rouby and K. Piotrzkowski, JINST 2: P09005 [physics.acc-ph] (CP3-07- 13). 6. X. Rouby, Tagging photon interactions at the LHC , these proceedings, V. A. Khoze et al. , Eur. Phys. J. C 23(2002) 311; private communication from V. Khoze. 8. B. E. Cox et al. , Eur. Phys. J. C 45(2006)8 T. la and K. 201 Mean 0.01152 RMS 1.261 -le-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 201 Mean 0.01152 RMS 1.261 Figure 10. Differential cross sections ds/de acceptance cuts for the SM (solid line) and for the anomalous quartic coupling (dashed line), aW 0/L2= L = 2 TeV. 401. 9. G. Belanger and F. Boudjema, Phys. Lett. B 288(1992) 201. 10. C. Arzt, M. B. Einhorn and J. Wudka, Nucl. Phys. B 433(1995) 41. 11. M. Maniatis, A. von Manteuffel and O. couplings in gg-W+W-at the LHC and ILC , these proceedings. 12. O. Eboli, LHC potential to study the quartic elec- troweak gauge boson couplings , these O. J. P. Eboli, M. C. M. Lietti and S. F. Novaes, Phys. Rev. D 63(2001) 075008 G. Abbiendi et al. [OPAL Phys. Rev. D 70(2004) G. Zech, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A J. Alwall et al. , JHEP 0709:028 (2007). 17. A. Pukhov, Nucl. Inst. Meth A 502 (2003) 596. 18. T. Sj ostrand et al. , Comput. Phys. 201 Mean 0.9237 RMS 0.9041 [rad]+l-lph d0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 [fb]+l-lph 201 Mean 0.9237 RMS 0.9041 Figure 11. Differential cross section ds/d (dph) acceptance cuts, for the SM (solid line) and for the anomalous quartic coupling (dashed line), aW 0/L2= L = 2 TeV. 135(2001) 238. 19. N. Schul and K. Piotrzkowski, Detection of two-photon exclusive production of supersym- metric pairs at the LHC , these [hep-ph].
|
0807.1121
|
Tomasz Pierzcha{\l}a
|
Tomasz Pierzchala, Krzysztof Piotrzkowski
|
Sensitivity to anomalous quartic gauge couplings in photon-photon
interactions at the LHC
|
8 pages and 11 figures, Contribution to the CERN workshop on "High
energy photon collisions at the LHC", 22-25 April 2008
|
Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl.179-180:257-264,2008
|
10.1016/j.nuclphysbps.2008.07.032
|
CP3-08-32
|
hep-ph hep-ex
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The exclusive two-photon production at the LHC of pairs of W and Z bosons
provides a novel and unique test-ground for the electroweak gauge boson sector.
In particular it offers, thanks to high gamma-gamma center-of-mass energies,
large and direct sensitivity to the anomalous quartic gauge couplings otherwise
very difficult to investigate at the LHC. An initial analysis has been
performed assuming leptonic decays and generic acceptance cuts. Simulation of a
simple counting experiment has shown for the integrated luminosity of 10 fb-1
at least four thousand times larger sensitivity to the genuine quartic
couplings, a_0^W, a_0^Z, a_C^W and a_C^Z, than those obtained at LEP. The
impact of the unitarity constraints on the estimated limits has been studied
using the dipole form-factors. Finally, differential distributions of the decay
leptons have been provided to illustrate the potential for further improvements
of the sensitivities.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 7 Jul 2008 20:36:10 GMT"
}
] | 2009-02-05T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Pierzchala",
"Tomasz",
""
],
[
"Piotrzkowski",
"Krzysztof",
""
]
] |
2 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO are always defined, they do not have the expected domain or codom ain. When i>=1, one could takephm,n= Inf*i*
Lm/Ln, where Inf denotes the inflation; and, when i<=-1, one could consider the deflation Defl (see [Wei59]), setting pm,n= N*
Lm/Ln*Defl. But, in general, for a given iZ, only one of these would be defined. In particular, a relation like (1.1) involv even be stated. Moreover, taking Gn-cohomology kills the Gn-action, so all abelian are trivial Gn-modules. On the other hand, these Tate cohomology groups are certainly int eresting arithmetic objects: they havethe finite(at leastforall Bnasabove)and they class field theory. For alln>=0 (see, for instance, [Nuc10, Proposition 2.2]) or, even more fundam the Hilbert class field of Ln. To give one more example, one that has been at the origin of our investigation, assume that pis odd and suppose that there exists a subfield kF such that, for every n,Ln/kis Galois with dihedral Galois group Dnof order 2 pn. Denote by Kn a subfield of index 2 in Ln/k: then the up to a power of 2 (see [CN20, Theorem 3.14]). Hence, it looks compelling to regard the assignment as an analogue of nmapsto-Bn, or perhaps of nmapsto-ALn, since the ALnare also finite groups. Yet, this seems to down, at least insofar techniques from Iwasawa theory are involved: to explain why, it is probably necessary to clarify what we mean by studying or analy sing the above assignment. As mentioned, the groups are all finite, and the most basic question one could ask is to describe the behaviour of their orders ||asn-+. After all, the whole subject of Iwasawa theory begun with the (Iwasawa) .There exists three integers uL,lL,nLand an index n0such that (1.3) alln>=n0. Recall now the usual strategy of proof of on e first considers the inverse limit, with respect to the norm maps, XIw= lim--ALnand regardsit as a module overthe completed group algebraL = Zp[[G]], showingthat Secon dly, afineanalysis of the Galois action on XIw, coupled with global class field theory, shows that one can closely re late ALnwith the co-invariants ( XIw)Gn; finally, a structure theorem for L-torsion modules of finite type yields the formula. Inherent to this approach is the asymptot ic flavour of Iwasawa's result: at several stages, some adjustment is required, which modifies the o utcome by a finite, bounded error term. Now, all this breaks down when replacing the finite groups ALnwith any of the : already, they might not form an inverse system, when i>=1; and, even if they do, the triviality of the Galois action implies that the co-invariants of the inverse limit coinc ide with the whole limit and are, in general, infinite. Hence, they are of no use to recover t he finite groups .COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 3 To describe our approach, it is important to consider the somewhat dual strategy of considering the direct limit AL= carry the same information, and could be used interchan geably; Iwasawa himself occa- sionally works with the latter module instead of the former (see, for instance, [Iwa81]). than ALn, the direct limit occurs, for instance, in [Iwa83, SS5]: there, Iwasawa claims that the inflation maps (1.4) Inf: =Hi(G,Ox L)[pn] for i= 1,2 have kernel and cokernel which have bounded order as ngrows. Given that the structure of the direct limits lim-- =/hatwideHi(G,B) is, in general, quite explicit (but up to finite groups) we interpret this as a weak analogue of Iwasawa's descent theorem leading to (1.3), replacing the operation of taking co-invariants by taking the pn-torsion subgroup. Hence, we set out to find an algebraic setting where the boundedness of kernels and cokern els as in (1.4) could be proven in general. But we were still confronted with two problems: first, in s ome formulae, for instance in (1.2), negative cohomological degrees must be considered and in t his case the Tate naturally form an inverse, rather than a direct, system; a nd secondly, that working up to finite groups, would turn all inflation maps occurring in (1.4) into the 0 map. At this point, we were inspired by Vauclair's approach in [Vau09], where he defines normic systems in quite a general context: in particular, all the examples {Bn}n>=0above are normic systems. Rather than taking limits, he works in the category whose objects are collections of Gn- modules simultaneously carrying the structure of a direct and an inv erse system, subject to With this in mind, we define, at least under the assumptio 2.4 on the normic system {Bn}n>=0, ascending and descending morphisms
/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm)pm,n/d47/d47 phn,m/d111/d111 for the collection of abelian groups in what we call a double system. Inside double systems, we identify a a certain thick subcategory BGof double systems of bounded orders (see Definition 2.20), such that the correspon ding quotient category DSG/BG turns out to be the framework we were looking for. Indeed, upon r estricting to a by some very natural co-finiteness condition of the direct limit, we define an to a double system X= (Xn)n>=0the double system ( with morphisms), where X= lim--Xn. Writing anbnto mean that two natural numbers are eventually proportional (see Definition 2.2 7), we obtain this introduction, we confine ourself to a special case of o ur main result, which holds for profinite groups D which are more general than G. Although this generalised app roach is crucial for the dihedral applications we have in mind, we prefer to stick to the case D= G here, to lighten notation. In particular, all subscripts G decorating the several categories that we are going to introduce, actually read asDin the body of the paper.4 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO Corollary 2.32. LetX= (Xn)n>=0be a double system in DSco-f.g. G, and suppose that group) . In this language, we can reinterpret Iwasawa's claim about the boun dedness of the kernels and cokernels in (1.4) as the statement that the double systems whose components are the cohomology groups satisfy fori= 1,2. This is proved in Theorem 3.8 (see also Remark 3.12). It is worth noting that the rigidity yielded by requiring that the objec ts in the DSGare simul- taneously inverse and direct systems is forced upon us by an intere sting phenomenon: during the proof of Theorem 3.8, two morphisms in DSGneed to be shown to become injective in DSG/BG, in order to perform some homological algebra. Now, the analogous de finitions of the thick subcategory BGcan be given for the category of inverse (resp. direct) systems. Yet, it turns out that the kernel of the first morphism (regarded simply as an inv erse system) does not belong toBinv G, and the kernel of the second one (regarded simply as a direct sys tem) does not belong toBdir G: so, working either with direct or with inverse system alone would bre ak our On the other hand, since both kernels belong to BG, become injective in DSG/BG, as wanted: for a more comprehensive analysis of this phenomenon , we refer to Remark 3.9. We explicitly mention Yamashita's paper [Yam84], which ha s been very helpful at this point: she regards Iwasawa's boundedness claim concerning (1.4) in the setting of abelian groups endowed with two (not necessarily compatible) structures of direct and inverse systems, and this was the starting point for our definitions of DSGandBG. With this formalism at our disposal, we are in shape to let ngo to + in (1.2). To state our result, as well as to motivate our title, we record the Definition 4.1. Letpbe an odd prime. Suppose that there exists a subfield kFsuch that Galois, with dihedral Galois group Dnof order 2pn. Denote by Kna subfield of index2inLn/k, chosen so that KnKn-1for alln>=1, and put K=/uniontextKn. The extension K/kis said to be a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type, the extensions L/kis the Galois closure of the fake Zp-extension and the field Fis said to be the normalizing quadratic extension. With this definition, one of our main results is the 4.6. LetK/kbe a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type. There exist constants alln0. Observe that in a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type, none of the subextensions Kn/kis normal, so the groups AKnare not Galois modules and Iwasawa's original formula do not apply. We refer toSS4.2 for a more precise version of the above statement, describing t he invariants ufakeandlfake in terms of explicit arithmetic quantities. In SS4.3 we derive, in some special cases, explicit bounds for the values taken by the invariant lfake: as an example, let us state the following result2 2In its actual formulation, the quoted corollary is more prec ise: in order to avoid too much notation, we with a slightly weaker statement in this Introduc tion, referring to SS4.3 for the full OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 5 Corollary 4.14. LetK/Qbe a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type: in particular, the normalizin g extension F/Qis imaginary quadratic and the Galois closure L/Qis the anticyclotomic extension ofF. in F/Q lIw 2ifpdoes not split in F/Q and therefore lIwis odd if psplits in Fand it is even if pdoes not 4.16 and 4.18 extend the above one to more general CM fie lds beyond the case. In the Galois setting of Zp-extensions, the invariant lIwresponsible for the linear growth in the exponent of ALncan be interpreted as the Qp-dimension of XIwQp, whereXIw= lim--ALn. In the final Section SS4.4 we extend this result to our non-Galois setting, by studying the s tructure of the projective limit Xfake= lim--AKn with respect to norm maps. We prove the 4.27. Given a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type K/k, we have lfake= dim QpXfakeZp Qp. We conclude this Introduction by observing that our results conce rning pro-dihedral extensions are not entirely new. We refer to Remark 4.7 for a comparison with Ja ulent's work [Jau81], to Remark 4.17 for a comparison with the works [Gil76] by Gillard and [CK82] by well as to Remark 4.15 for some results concerning the anticyclot paper has a long history, which has been summarized in [CN20, Ac knowledgment]. As mentioned in loc. cit., the original arXivpreprint has been split up in two articles, the first be- ing [CN20]. This work is the second one, focusing on fake Zp-extensions. We are grateful to the anonymous referee for a thorough reading of our manuscript and for several remarks that improved the clarity and the readability of the text. 2. Algebraic Group cohomology: notation and generalities. Given a group Gand aG-module B, we denote by BG(resp.BG) the maximal submodule (resp. the maximal quotient) of Bon which G acts trivially. Moreover,let Nm be the norm, B[NG] the kernel augmentation ideal of Z[G] defined as IG= Ker(Z[G]--Z) where the morphism is induced by gmapsto-1 for all gG. Forevery iZ, Gwithvaluesin B. letHi(G,B) be theith cohomology group of Gwith values in B. For standard properties of these groups (which will be implicitly used without specific mention) t he reader is referred to [NSW08]. If B'is another G-module and f:B-B'is a homomorphism of abelian groups, we (resp. if f(gb) =gf(b) (resp.f(gb) =-gf(b)) for every gGandbB.6 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO 2.2. Normic systems and their Tate cohomology. Fix a prime number p. Arithmetic objects attached to layers of Zp-extensions have a structure of normic system, in the sense of Va uclair (see [Vau09]). After recalling the definition of a normic system, we will study its Tate is our primary goal in this paper. We start with the definition of a normic system, in a slightly different co ntext than the one of [Vau09, D' efinition 2.1]. Let G be a profinite group isomorphic to Zp, endowed with a by closed subgroups G 0= GG1***Gn***for which there exists g=g(G)N, such that for all m>=n>=gthe equality (G n: Gm) =pm-nholds. Assume also that we are given an exact sequence of topological groups (2.1) 1 --G--D-- D0--1. SetGn= G/GnandGm,n= Gn/Gmfor allm>=n. Since the subgroups G nare closed, they in G and hence normal in D, so that the quotient groups Dn=D/Gnare defined for alln>=0; in particular, Gncan be regarded as a subgroup of Dn. Remark 2.1.The most common choice for the filtration {Gn}in the above setting is given by Gn= Gpnfor alln>=0, and the reader can have this in mind in most of what follows. In that case,g= 0 and (G n: Gm) =pm-nfor allm>=n>=0. The reason for the slight above comes from the arithmetic setting considered in S ection 3.1, where G is the group inside a global Galois group. When the correspo nding prime ideal splits, a shift in the numbering occurs and a more general filtration than {Gpn}needs to be A(G simply aD-normic system or a normic system if the groups are understood) is a collection of Zp[D]-modules Bntogether with homomorphisms of for (resp. ( Bn,km,n)) is a direct (resp. inverse) system of Zp[D]-modules: in par- ticular, for all n>=0, the compatibilities fixed by G n(in particular, it can be regarded as a Nm (Gn: Gm). IfB= (Bn,jn,m,km,n) andB'= are two normic systems, a collection f= (fn) a morphism of normic systems if it is both a morphism of direct system and of inverse systems ( This defines the category NSDof normic systems. The following lemma shows that NSDis abelian, using the concept of category of diagrams. For a general reference about categories of diagrams see [Gro57, SS1.6 and SS1.7]: we adopt notation and definitions from ibid. Lemma 2.3. The category NSDis a category of diagrams with commuting relations valued in the abelian category of Zp[D]-modules, so it is the diagram scheme S= (N,PsdxPsi,d) that n<=m}and Ps i={(m,n)N2such that m>=n}COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 7 and the map dsends every /vector vn,m= (n,m)Psdto the pair ( n,m) and every /vectorvm,n= (m,n)Psito the pair ( m,n). Fix a topological generator g0G and for every ( i,j)N2consider the set vi,k= (Gi: Gk)ei,/vector vk,j/vector vi,k=/vector > > j where the eiare auxiliary elements corresponding to the identity, as ibid. Set S = ( S,R): then NSDis the category of commutative diagrams D: the and is therefore abelian thanks to [Gro57, Proposition 1.6 .1]. /square Given a normic system B= (Bn,jn,m,km,n) one can consider the Tate cohomology foriZas well as the usual cohomology groups Hi(Gn,Bn) fori>=0. These groups acquire the structure of Zp[D0]-modules via the conjugation action of D0. Definition 2.4. We say that the normic system B= (Bn,jn,m,km,n) satisfies condition (Inj)if (Inj) jn,mis injective for all m>=n>=0 and that it satisfies condition (Gal)if (Gal) jn,m(Bn) =BGm,n mfor (Bn,jn,m,km,n) be a normic system. Our next task is to construct, under functorial morphisms of Zp[D0]-modules
/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm)/hatwideHi(k)/d47/d47
/hatwideHi(j)/d111/d111 for allm>=n>=0. The ascending maps /hatwideHi(j) are well-defined independently of any assumption on the normic system, and we show in SS2.2.4 that they are related to inflation in positive degrees. The definit ions of the descending maps /hatwideHi(k) require condition (Inj)in odd degrees and both conditions (Inj) and(Gal)in even degrees. 2.2.1. Cohomology maps in degree -1.We first define /hatwideH-1(j) =jn,m(y) modIGmBmfor that /hatwideH-1(j) is well-defined, and now that Bsatisfies(Inj). Then we define /hatwideH-1(k) =km,n(x) modIGnBnfor L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO To see that /hatwideH-1(k) is also well-defined, observe Nm Gn*jn,m*km,n
= Nm Gn*NmGm,n
= Nm Gm. Sincejn,mis assumed to be injective, this shows that it is immediate that so/hatwideH-1(k) is that we = (G n: Gm) and = (G n: Gm). Indeed, using the relation between km,nandjn,min the definition of a normic system, we =km,n*jn,m(x) modIGnBn
= (Gn: Gm)xmodIGnBn and (xmodIGnBn) =jn,m*km,n(x) modIGmBm
= Nm Gm,nxmodIGmBm
= (Gn: the last equality follows from the fact that the action of Gm,nis trivial on both are morphisms of Zp[D0]-modules, because both Cohomology maps in degree 0. We first define /hatwideH0(j) Nm GnBn) = (G n: Gm)jn,m(y) mod Nm GmBmfor that, since jn,mtakes values in BGm,n m, there are inclusions (G n: Gm)jn,m*NmGn= Nm Gn*jn,m*(Gn: Gm) = Nm Nm Gm*jn,m so that (G n: showing that /hatwideH0(j) is now that Bsatisfies both (Inj)and(Gal). Then we define /hatwideH0(k) Nm GmBm) = (jn,m)-1(x) mod Nm GnBnfor check that /hatwideH0(k) is well-defined, observe that that jn,mdefines a Gn- isomorphism of BnontoBGm,n m, which restricts to an isomorphism of BGnnontoBGmm. the element ( jn,m)-1(x)BGnnis uniquely defined. Moreover, if x= Nm Gmzfor somezBm, thenw= Nm Gm,nzbelongs to BGm,nm, so that x= Nm Gmz= Nm Gn(w) = Nm This concludes the proof that /hatwideH0(k) is well-defined. As in the case i=-1, we = (G n: Gm) and = (G n: Gm) andboth OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 9 2.2.3. Cohomology maps in arbitrary degree. Fix a topological generator g0G. For each nN,g0maps to a generator gnGnand we let khnHom(Gn,Q/Z) be the map sending gnto (G : G n)-1. We claim that Inf(khn) = (G n: Inf: is the inflation map. Indeed, since gmmaps to sendsgmtokhn(gn) = (G : G n)-1, which in turn is equal to the ratio (G n: Gm)(G : G m)-1= (Gn: Gm)khm(gm). Since the connecting homomorphism corresponding to the exact by the inclusion ZQis an isomorphism, there exists a unique element that d(1)(khn) =kn. We now go back to the cohomology of the normic system B. FixiZand, for all h>=0, let (kn)h:--/hatwideHi+2h(Gn,Bn) be the isomorphism obtained by taking the cup product with knhtimes. Extend the definition to h <0 by setting (kn)h= inverse of (kn)-h. Ifiis odd (resp. even), write i= 2h-1 and set e=-1 (resp. i= 2hande= 0). Then we = (km)h*/hatwideHe(jn,m)*(kn)-h:--/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm). Similarly, if iis odd (resp. even) and both (Inj)and(Gal)), we = (kn)h*/hatwideHe(km,n)*(km)-h:/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm)--. Remark 2.5.The definition of these homomorphisms is independent of the choice o fg0. To see this, letg' 0G be another topological generator, that must be of the form gu 0for some uZx p. the image of g' 0and be the map sending g' nto (G : G n)-1: it corresponds to a unique class We have =khn(gu n) =ukhn(gn) =u*(G : in that the definitions of /hatwideHi(j) and of /hatwideHi(k) are independent of the choice of g0. Arguing by induction, one can show that /hatwideHi(km,n) already observed this in the cases i=-1,0. To prove the assertion for iZ, homomorphism defined allgD, denote by g*the corresponding conjugation automorphism in cohomology. Then (see [NSW08, Proposition = L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. =d(1)(g**khn) Therefore, on the one hand we can the other hand we deduce *g*==g**/hatwideHi+2(jn,m) the inductive step. A similar proof works when jis replaced by k. 2.2.4. Comparison with other maps. Wheni>=1, other maps -/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm) exist for m>=n>=0. These are obtained by composing the inflation map Inf = the map induced by jn,m:Bn-BGmmin cohomology j*=j*,i n,m:--/hatwideHi(Gn,BGm,n m), and they are denoted Infi*j*,i n,mor simply Inf*j*. In what follows we analyse the relationship of these maps with the ones defined in SS2.2.3. Remark 2.6.For every [ there is an explicit description of the cup product [ as the class x(b) nof the 1-cocycle sending the This is probably well-known, but we provide a proof because we were unable to find an explicit reference in the literature. By [NSW08, Proposition I.1.4.8], the cup product [ b]knis the class of the 2-cocycle (2.3) any 2-cochain representing kn. To compute this expression explicitly, recall where khn:Gn-Q/Zis the character sending gnto (G : G n)-1. The definition of the connecting homomorphism is given explicitly in [NSW08, proof of Theorem I.1.3.2] in terms of homogeneous cocycles: it is the connecting homomorphism d: 7]. By invoking [NSW08, page 14], we can replace homogeneous cochains b y inhomogeneous ones andCOHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 11 transform the diagram in loc. cit. into the commutative diagram of exact /d47/d47C2(Gn,Z) /d47/d47C2(Gn,Q) this notation, khnKer2 Q/Zand, by definition of the connecting homomorphism in the is the class of where ~ khn:Gn-Qis any As lift, choose the cochain ~ : Gn)-1for 1<=a<=(G : Gn). By the of 1 Qon inhomogeneous 1-cochains given in [NSW08, page 14], we = ~khn(ga n) ifa= (G : G n) 0 if 1<=a<=(G : sumin summandcorre spondingto s=g(G:Gn) n= idGn and this term equals b, showing that [ 2.7. LetBbe a normic system and let i>=1be an integer. Then odd (resp. even), write i= 2h-1 and set e=-1 (resp. i= 2hande= 0). By definition of /hatwideHi(j) and since (km)his an isomorphism, the statement of the lemma is equivalent to the commutativity of the following diagram, for all m>=n>=0:
/hatwideHe(Gm,Bm)(km)h
/d47/d47/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm)
/hatwideHe(Gn,Bn)(kn)h
/d47/d47/hatwideHe(j)/d79/d79 Infi*j*/d79/d79 (2.4) We claim that commutativity of (2.4) for all i>=1 follows once we can prove it commutes for i=e+2. Indeed, for arbitrary i>=3 we = assumption) = ( of and Infi*j*) = Infi*j*. Hence, it now remains to show that (2.4) is commutative for i= 1,2 Consider first the case i= 1. Given the definition of /hatwideH-1(j) and the explicit description of the cup product described in Remark 2.6, commutativity of (2.4) is equiva lent =x(j(b)) m and this follows by the definition of the map Inf1*j*on cocycles (see [NSW08, SSI.5]).12 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO Suppose now that i= 2. We first show Note that in the above diagram we have ordinary cohomo logy on the left-hand side (as opposed to Tate cohomology): this allows us to consider inflation in de gree 0, which is simply the compatibility of the cup product with inflation = (Gn: shows that the above diagram commutes. To show that (2.4) co mmutes for i= 2 and conclude the proof, we just need to observe that the cup product on Tate cohomology is compatible with that on ordinary cohomology. This can be checked, for instance, u sing the definition on cochains of the two cup products (compare [NSW08, ( *),SSI.4] and [NSW08, proof of Proposition I.1.4.6]). /square Remark 2.8.Assume that km,nis surjective. Then the map /hatwideH0(jn,m) factors through by (G n: Gm),i. e.there is a map such = (G n: Gm)/hatwiden,m. This is defined Nm GnBn) =jn,m(y) mod Nm GmBmfor allyBGn n. To see that this is well defined, let bnBGnn. Then it is clear that jn,m(b)BGmm. Suppose now that bn= Nm Gn(b' n)NmGnBn. Sincekm,nis surjective, there exists b' mBmsuch that km,n(b' m) =b' n. Then jn,m(bn) = Nm Gm(bm) showing that /hatwiden,mis well-defined. By definition of /hatwideH0(j), the relation /hatwideH0(jn,m) = (G n: Using /hatwiden,m, Lemma 2.7 can be restated, under the assumption that km,nis surjective, as theCOHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 13 commutativity of the following diagram 2.9.One can wonder whether results similar to that of Lemma 2.7 hold when jis re- placed by k. Assume under this assumption, the inverse are defined and we have maps (j*)-1= by ( jm,n)-1. Writei= 2hori= 2h-1, according to whether iis even or odd. Then we claim that (2.5) ( (Gn: for all i<=0 where Defl denotes the deflation map Defl = defined by Weiss (see [Wei59]). Equality (2.5) is clear for i= 0,-1 since in these cases h= 0 and we have Defl0(xmod Nm GmBm) =xmod Nm well = Nm [Wei59, (1) and Proposition 1]). For arbitrary i, we argue by backward induction: assume that (2.5) holds for a given i<=0. Then for (by [Wei59, Theorem 3])
= Gm)km)
= (Gn: (Gn: the cup product with knis an isomorphism, (2.5) holds for i-2. 2.2.5. Functorial behaviour. We now come to the main results of this section, describing the functorial behaviour of the maps defined in SS2.2.3. First of all, observe that if f= (fn):B-B'is a morphism of normic systems then, for every iZ, there are maps f*=f*,i n:--/hatwideHi(Gn,B' n).14 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO The diagrams (2.6)
/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm)f*/d47/d47/hatwideHi(Gm,B' m) f*/d47/d47/hatwideHi(j)/d79/d79
/hatwideHi(Gn,B' n)/hatwideHi(j)/d79/d79 and/hatwideHi(Gm,Bm)
/hatwideHi(k)
/d15/d15f*/d47/d47/hatwideHi(Gm,B' m)
/hatwideHi(k)
/d15/d15 f*/d47/d47/hatwideHi(Gn,B' n) are commutative (in the rightmost one we are assuming that /hatwideHi(k) is defined): to show this, it is enough to consider the cases i=-1,0 because the isomorphism ( kn) commutes with f*
n. Since fncommutes with jn,mandkm,n, the cases i=-1,0 are easily proved by direct inspection. The behaviour of the maps /hatwideHi(j) and/hatwideHi(k) with respect to connecting homomorphisms is given by the following two 2.10. an exact sequence of normic systems. Then, for allm>=n>=0, the following diagram with exact rows commutes 0 /d47/d47***
0 Lemma 2.7 we can replace /hatwideH1(j') with Inf*(j')*, and likewise for the other vertical maps. The result follows from functoriality of inflation and of the map /square The above proposition holds for the full long exact sequence of ord inary cohomology extended in every positive degree but we will only need it for the truncated exa ct sequences up to degree 2, as in the statement. The following proposition, on the other hand, o nly holds in degrees smaller or equal than 2, in general. This is because we assume that B''only satisfies (Inj)(instead as forBandB'). Such formulation of the statement reflects how this result will be used for arithmetic applications (see for instance the exact s equence 3.10 which is the basic ingredient of Theorem 2.11. an exact sequence of normic systems and thatB''satisfies (Inj). Then, for all m>=n>=0, theCOHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 15 following diagram with exact rows commutes 0 k'
/d15/d15 k
/d15/d15/d47/d47H0(Gm,B'' m) k''
/d15/d15d(0)/d47/d47/hatwideH1(Gm,B' m)
/hatwideH1(k')
/d15/d15/d47/d47***
0 /d47/d47***
***
/hatwideH1(k)
/d15/d15/d47/d47/hatwideH1(Gm,B'' m)
/hatwideH1(k'')
/d15/d15d(1)/d47/d47/hatwideH2(Gm,B' m)
/hatwideH2(k')
/d15/d15/d47/d47/hatwideH2(Gm,Bm)
/hatwideH2(k)
/d15/d15
*** of all, the existence of vertical maps in degree greater than 0 is guaranteed by the assumptions on the normic systems. The commutativity of the two leftmost squares follows immediately fr om the fact that B'-B andB-B''are morphisms of normic systems. The commutativity of the third square is equivalent to ( and let bBmbe an element mapping to b''. By the definition of the connecting homomorphism, d(0)(b'') is represented by the cocycle maps to k'' m,n(b''), the element is represented by the cocycle defined and, in turn, this is the map because the morphisms In the notation of Remark 2.6, we thus need to show t the description of ( km) given in Remark 2.6, this amounts to [k' m,n(b')] follows from the definition of for the remaining part of the diagram, since the definitions of /hatwideH1(k) and/hatwideH2(k) rely on cup products which are isomorphisms compatible with long exact Tate cohomology sequences, it is enough to show that the shifted /d47/d47/hatwideH-1(Gn,B'' n)/hatwided(-1) commutative. The two leftmost and the fourth squares are comm utative as discussed in (2.6). As for the third square, let b''B'' m[NmGm] and pick bBmmapping to b''. Then, the image of km,n(b) = Nm Gn([km,n(b)]).16 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO On the other Gmb])
= = Nm that the third square in (2.7) is commutative. /square Remark 2.12.Observe that although in SS2.2.2 we have considered Tate cohomology of a normic system and defined morphisms /hatwideH0(j) Propositions 2.10 and 2.11 start with in degree 0. The appearance of ordinary cohomology is s omehow exceptional, because we will mainly be working with Tate cohomology. For instance, in the follo wing section, we will see that for each iZ, theith Tate cohomology groups of a normic system form a double system , a notion to be defined ibid. 2.3. The category of double systems. In the previous section, we have considered Tate coho- mology groups of a normic system, showing that (under some condit ions) these can be simultane- ously endowed with the structure of direct systems and of inverse systems of Zp[D0]-modules with respect to the maps defined in SS2.2.3, where D0is the group appearing in (2.1). In this section, we focus on the study of such double 2.13. In the setting of Definition 2.2, a (G system (or simply a D-double system or a double system if the groups are understood) X= collection of Zp[D0]-modules Xnwhich are Zp-torsion and such that
*(Xn,phn,m) is a direct is an inverse (Gn: Gm) for allm>=n>=0. The morphisms Hom DSD(X,X') between two double systems XandX'are collections of fn:Xn-X' nwhich are both morphisms of direct and of inverse systems. This defines the category DSDofD-double systems. The results in SS2.2 yield the 2.14. LetBbe a normic system. If Bsatisfies (Inj), then (2.8) /hatwideHi(B) =/parenleftbig,/hatwideHi(jn,m),/hatwideHi(km,n)/parenrightbig m>=n>=0 is a double system for every odd integer i. If condition (Gal)is also satisfied, then /hatwideHi(B)is a double system for all iZ. Remark 2.15.The category DSDis abelian: the proof is analogous to that of Lemma 2.3, by replacing the requirement /vector (2.2) with /vector vl,i/vectorvi,l= (Gl: Gi) one can observe that DSDis a full subcategory of NSDclosed under direct sums, kernels and cokernels and it is therefore abelian, thanks to [Rot09, Proposition 5.92]. LetX= a double system, and write the direct limit of the maps phn,m(form>=n). Similarly, write pn: lim--Xn-Xnfor the inverse limit of pm,n. Let (2.9)^Xn= OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 17 as well as (2.10)
+Xn= ++Xn= next proposition shows that^X= (^Xn),+X= (+Xn), as well as /trianglesolidX= and++X= (++Xn) inherit the structure of double systems from X. It also shows that the assignments X 2.16. LetX= a double system. The restrictions of thus a structure of double system. These double systems satisfy: i)The formation of^Xand functorial, and the functor Xmapsto-^Xis left exact. Similarly, the formation of+Xand++Xis functorial, and the functor Xmapsto-++Xis right exact. ii)Write /trianglesolidX= Then injective and+pm,nis surjective for all m>=n>=0. iii)For every double system X'= that ph' n,mis injective for m>=
n>=0, and every morphism f:X-X', there exists a unique map following diagram given a double system X''= that p'' m,nis surjec- tive form>=n>=0 (and soX''=+X''), every morphism g:X''-Xfactors through the subsystem+X, making the following diagram claim that the restriction of phn,m(resp. of pm,n) This is obvious for phn,m, thanks to the relation phm*phn,m=phn. Concerning pm,n, (Gn: Gm) shows that for all x^Xmit 0 and hence pm,n(x)^Xn. The claim implies that, to be the X. the double system /trianglesolidX. The claim that+Xis a double system which is a that ++X=X/+X(in the category DSD) is analogous: the fact that the values in+Xnis automatic, and the relation phn,m*pm,n= (Gn: Gm) as well as the claimed exactness properties of X mapsto-^Xand ofX mapsto- given a morphism X-X', the rightmost square of the diagram (2.11) below is commutative for all n>=0, implying the existence of the leftmost vertical morphism (making t he18 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO whole diagram commute): 0 is injective (resp. surjective) if an only if each of its compo nents has this property. Hence, ifX-X'is injective, (2.11) shows that each component of the induced morp so^X-^Xis again injective. This is well-known to be equivalent to the exactness on the left of the functor abelian), establishing the first part of i). Analogously, a a commutative diagram of exact that each component of the induced morphism^X-^X'is surjective, finishing the proof ofi). To prove ii), observe that injective for all m>=n>=0 by construction: indeed, for all [x] the definition of =phn,m(x) (mod^Xm). = 0 implies phn,m(x)^Xm, which means phmphn,m(x) =phn(x) = 0 and hence x^Xn and[x] = 0, establishingthe injectivityof are left with the proof of iii). LetX'= be such that ph' n,mis injective for m>=n>=0, and let f:X -X'. Write f: the direct limit of the maps fn. The injectivity of all ph' n,mimplies that also injective. It follows that fn(^Xn) = 0, = 0 ==fn(x) = 0 for all x^Xn. In particular, for all n, there exists a unique map the (2.12) ph' n,m*/trianglesolidfn=/trianglesolidfm* (2.13)COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 19 This is tantamount to showing the commutativity of the right oblique s quares in the s: Xm pm,n
/d15/d15/d34/d34 the left oblique squares commute, and so do the straight squa res and triangles, one obtains that (2.12) (resp. (2.13)) holds after composing with surjective, the required commutativity follows. The argument for the universal property enjoyed by+Xis analogous. This finishes the proof of the proposition. /square From now on, we drop the^from the transition their restrictions to^Xmand to^Xn, respectively. The same convention is adopted for the other three double systems 2.17.We are grateful to the referee for pointing out that Proposition 2 .16-iii) can be interpreted as saying that X mapsto- mapsto-+X, suitably restricted to certain subcategories of DSD, are adjoint to a forgetful functor. Since we have no use for this in our work, we omit 2.18.IfXis a double system such that pm,nis injective for all m>=n0, if phn,mis surjective for all m>=n0 andXnhas bounded exponent for every n, then X=++X. To see the first implication, let xXnand pick m>=nsuch that (G n: Gm)x= 0. Writing (Gn: Gm) =pm,n*phn,mand using that pm,nis injective, we deduce phn,m(x) = 0, hence phn(x) = 0 andx^Xn. This showsX=^X. Similarly, suppose that phn,mis surjective for m>=n0, and letx+Xn. Pickm>=nsuch that (G n: Gm)Xn= 0 and let yXmbe such that pm,n(y) =x, which exists because x+Xn. Surjectivity of phn,mguarantees the existence of an element zXn such that phn,m(z) =y, = (G n: Gm)z= 0. Then+X= 0 andX=++X. Before stating the next lemma, observe that if X= (Xn) is a double system such that the exponents of Xnare bounded independently of n, for n>=0 andx+Xn, one can write x=pn(x) for some xlim--Xm. The element xis torsion, because every Xmhas bounded exponent, and we pick msuch that (G n: Gm)x= 0. Then phn(x) 0 showing x^Xn, and thus (2.14). Lemma 2.19. LetX= aD-double system such that the orders |Xn|
are bounded independently of n. The following conditions are equivalent:20 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. an isomorphism for all an isomorphism for all or equivalently for alln0. When any of the above conditions is met, the orders |Xn|are eventually constant, and both isomorphisms for all m>=n0. Proof.To prove that BD-1) implies BD-3), observe that it is enough to show^Xn+Xnfor all n0, in light of (2.14). By BD-1) we can find nsuch that pm,n:^Xm~- -^Xnfor allm>=n, and letx^Xn. For all m>=nthere exists a unique xm^Xmsuch that pm,n(xm) =x. It follows thatx= and x=pn(x), showing x+Xn. Assuming BD-3), Proposition 2.16- ii) implies that injective for all m>=
n0. It follows that nmapsto-|++Xn|is an non-decreasing sequence of bounded, positive integers and thus eventually constant. As an injection of finite groups of the sa me order is an isomorphism, this proves the implication assume BD-2) and let n0be such that phn,mis an isomorphism for all the shifted double lim--X' n. It follows that alln>=0, soX'satisfies BD-2) for all m>=n>=0. By Proposition 2.16- iii), the natural surjection X':++X'factors as X' /d47/d47 /d33/d33 the other hand, the inclusion (2.14) induces a surjection Since all groups finite, the existence of surjections that these surjec- tions are isomorphisms, proving BD-3) for the systemX'. Upon reindexing, this implies BD-3) for X. To establish the statement concerning the stabilisation of the orde rs|Xn|, Thanks to BD-3) this coincides with |^Xn|*|++Xn|, and both the orders eventually constant because of BD-1) andBD-2). Replacing in the isomorphisms in BD-1) andBD-2) the equalities of BD-3) yields the final statement. 2.20. LetBDbe the full subcategory of DSDwhose objects are the D-double systems of finitep-groups whose order is bounded independently of nand that satisfy any of the BD-1)-BD-3) of Lemma 2.19. In particular, the order of the components of the system is in fact eventually constant, independently of n0. Remark 2.21.In Example 2.29, we construct a double system of finite p-groups of constant order which is not an object of BD. Example 2.22.Suppose that G is filtered by G n= Gpnfor alln>=0 and consider the double system X= (Z/p,id,0), where all components Xncoincide with Z/p, the ascending morphisms are the identity and the descending ones are the 0 map. One computes that lim--X= 0 and OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 21 so that^Xn=+Xn= 0, and conditions BD-1) andBD-3) (and thus BD-2)) are satisfied, showing thatXis an object of BD. Similarly, one can consider the system Y= (Z/p,0,id), that is again an object of 0 and conditions BD-3) andBD-2) are satisfied (and so is BD-1), then). Example 2.23.In this example, denote for simplicity the index (G n: Gm) byhn,mand write hnfor (G : Gn); similarly, write gforg(G). In case the filtration with{Gpn}n>=0, 0, and the reader may keep this particular case in mind. Consider theD-double systemZ(G) (denoted simply Zif the filtered group G is as Z(G) for the canonical projection (we omit the indexes in pr to avoid notation ove rload); all components have trivial action of D0. Letn0>=1: define the shift Z[n0](G) =Z[n0]ofZas the double system whose components alln>=g+n0 0 for all n < g+n0 with transition morphisms pr for n>=n0, and the trivial maps that the requirement n>=g+n0ensures that We intend to show that, although Z[n0]is not isomorphic to Z(none of the components are, in fact, and since kernels and cokernels are computed component-wise in DSD, the systems cannot be difference lies in BDin a precise sense. Define a map i:Z[n0]-Zbyin= 0 ifn < g+n0andin=*pn0: (Z)nifn>=g+n0. One easily checks compatibility of inwith transition maps, so idefines an injection i:Z[n0]-Zin the category DSD. The cokernel of iis the double system of the cokernels, < g+n0 with transition < g+n0 Since the cokernel is non-trivial, the morphism iis not an isomorphism in DSD. Yet, the direct limit lim--(Cokeri) is trivial, because for all n>=g+n0and =pnx= 0. In particular, (^Cokeri)n= (Coker i)nforn>=n0and thus condition BD-1) is fulfilled, than considering the injection i:Z[n0]-Zone can look at the morphism ph:Z-Z [n0] defined component-wise by the projections ( (Z[n0])n, forn>=g+n0. One can verify that the double system (Ker ph,ph',p') satisfies lim--Kerph= 0 and ph'= id for all n0, showing that Ker phBDby condition BD-2). The following proposition provides a class of double systems belonging 2.24. LetX= a double system of that either phn,mis an isomorphism for m>=n0, orpm,nis an isomorphism for L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. that if phn,m(resp.pm,n) is eventually an isomorphism, then the orders |Xn|
are bounded independently of nand the direct limit phn(resp. the inverse limit pn) is also an isomorphism for n0. In particular^Xn= 0 (resp. ++Xn= 0) for n0 and condition BD-1) (resp. condition BD-2)) of Lemma 2.19 is satisfied, so XBD. /square Remark 2.25.Proposition 2.24 shows that, for a double system of finite Zp[D0]-modules, the con- dition of being in BDonly depends upon the underlying direct, or inverse, system. This w ill be useful for our arithmetic applications, especially at the end of the p roof of Theorem 3.8. We recall the following result concerning quotient categories, for w hich we refer to [Gab62, Ch. III, A full subcategory Cof an abelian category Ais called thick (' epaisse in French)if for every exact the object Xbelongs to Cif and only if both X'andX''belong to C. For every CAthere exists a quotient category A/C, which is abelian and comes with a full localising objects of A/Care the objects of A. Given two objects X,X'inAand a morphism f:X-X', its image (still denoted a monomorphism (resp. epimorphism, isomor- phism)if and only if If this is the case, we say that fis aC-monomorphism C-isomorphism ). The main technical result of this section is the following 2.26. The category BDis a thick subcategory of DSD. Proof.Let 0- X'- X - X''-0 be an exact sequence in DSD. For every nwe so the order|Xn|is bounded if and only if bounded. By Proposition 2.16- i), for every m>=n>=0, there are commutative diagrams 0 rows are exact, except possibly on the right. Suppose in BD, and fix c>=g(G) such that 0 for alln>=0. We claim that since X''BD, rowsof (2.15) areexact on the right for anyn>=0 large enough, BD-1) ensures that an isomorphism for all l>=n; we fixl>=n+c, so (G n: Gl)Xl=pl-nXl= 0. Let [ x]^X'' n. There exists [ [x] =p'' l,n[y] and ifyXlis a lift of [ y], = [x]. Moreover, phn(x) =phlphn,lpl,n(y) =phl(pl-ny) = 0, showing x^Xn. It follows surjective for all n0. In particular, (2.15) has exact rows and the snake lemma shows t hat since both isomorphisms, the same holds for pm,n. Hence, if bothX',X''are in BD, then alsoXis suppose that X BDand that n>=0 is such that pm,n:^Xm-^Xnis an isomorphism for all m>=n. Even when the rows in (2.15) are not exact on the right, the restr OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS injective. It follows that a non-increasing sequence of and thus eventually constant. As an injection of finite gro ups of the same order is an isomorphism, this shows X'BD. In order to show that X''BD, consider the diagram, analogous to of the rows follows from Proposition 2.16- i) and shows that ph'' n,mis surjective, since an isomorphism by BD-3). Therefore, the orders |++X'' n|are implies that to ++X'' nis actually an isomorphism for m>=n0, yielding that X''BD. /square A consequence of the above proposition is that it is possible to form t he quotient category DSD/BD, and to speak about double systems that are BD-isomorphic. For instance, the Example 2.23 are BD-isomorphic, two BD-isomorphisms being the maps ibid. To mark the difference between morphisms in DSDand morphisms in DSD/BD, we denote the latter by dashed arrows, thus a map in Iwasawa theory, whose sizes is eventually equal. Sinc e this notion is pivotal in our study, we single it out in the 2.27. We say that two sequences positive natural numbers are eventually proportional if there exists n0>=0 and a rational number cQ, independent of n, such that xn=cynfor alln>=n0. In this case we write xnyn. It is clear thatis an equivalence relation. We isolate the following easy consequence of Lemma 2.19. Corollary 2.28. LetXandX'be two double systems of which are BD- isomorphic, then there exists a morphism fHomDSD(X,X') such that both Ker( f) and Coker(f) are inBD. Lemma 2.19 implies that |Xn||X' n|. /square Example 2.29.A slight modification of Example 2.22 yields the following. Suppose, as ibid., that G is filtered by G n= Gpnfor alln>=0 and consider the double system X= (Z/p,0,0), where all components Xncoincide with Z/pand all transition morphisms are the 0 map. In lim--X= 0 and therefore Xn=^Xn=++Xn. It follows that non-zero, but the transition morphisms the zero map. Thus, neither of conditions BD-1) norBD-2) is satisfied, showing that Xis not an object in BD, and in particular it is not BD-isomorphic to the zero system O= (On= 0,0,0) (since BDis thick). Yet, their orders are eventually proportional, showing that being BD-isomorphic is a stronger notion than having eventually proportional orders.24 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO For the arithmetic applications relevant to this work, it is enough to r estrict to a certain sub- category of DSD, which we now define. Observe that every Mcan be decomposed as M=MdivMred, whereMdivis the maximal Zp-divisible submodule of Mand Mredis the maximal Zp-reduced submodule. This decomposition is in fact one of by automorphisms on the Zp-module underlying M. For a finite group H, the abelian category of Zp-torsion that Mredis finite and such that some lN. The finite modules (those with l= 0) is clearly a thick subcategory, so that the quotient category well-defined. When His the trivial group, we drop it from the notation and simply write 2.30. For a torsion Zp-module M, we set corkM= dim function cork is well-defined on objects of the quotient catego they coincide with objects of Moreover,using [Gab62, Ch. III, SS1, sees that it is multiplicative in short exact sequences because co rkM= 0 for every Min the thick subcategory Modfin Zp[D0]. We will refer at the number cork Mas thecorank of M. We can finally define the subcategory in the the following A) Every Xnis a finite group such that (G : G n)Xn= 0 for all n0; (co-f.g. B) lim--Xbelongs to Similarly, let Bco-f.g. Dbe the full subcategory of BDconsisting of objects satisfying (co-f.g. A). Observe that DSco-f.g. Dis an abelian category because it is an additive full subcategory of th e abelian category DSDwhich is closed under kernels and cokernels. Moreover, we claim that Bco-f.g. D is a thick subcategory of DSco-f.g. D. That every object in Bco-f.g. Dlies inDSco-f.g. Dis obvious, (co-f.g. A) holds by definition and condition (co-f.g. B) follo ws from condition BD-2) of Lemma 2.19 (which shows that the direct limit is actually finite). This implie s, in particular, that objects in Bco-f.g. Dcan equivalently be defined as those in DSco-f.g. Dwhich moreover satisfy either of the conditions of Lemma 2.19. The claim that it is thick is also immediate: g iven an exact A) is satisfied automatically by the requirement that the objects in the sequence be in thick because BDDSDis thick, and we can consider the quotient category which is again abelian. We now introduce the step-torsion functor As in Example 2.23, denote the index (G n: Gm) byhn,mand simply write hnfor (G : G n); similarly, write gfor g(G). Given a Zp-module MandnN, denote by M[hn] the submodule of Mconsisting of elements annihilated by hn. Define Sto be the functor that associates to every OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS system S(M) to every morphism u:M-M'the morphism S(u) = fact that Stakes values in DSco-f.g. Dis immediate: condition (co-f.g. A) in Definition 2.31 is satisfied by construction, and condition (co-f.g. B) follows by writin g lim--S(M) = lim--M[hn] is easy to see that Ssends the thick subcategory finite indeed, given a finite module MModfin Zp[D0], one has M[hn] =Mfor alln0, and therefore the transition morphisms phn,mare the identity id M:M-Mfor 2.24 shows S(M)BD, and since construction, we as claimed. It follows that Sinduces a functor between quotient categories, still denoted by the same symbol (2.17) to Sis the limit a double system and associating to it the direct limit of the unde rlying direct system: it takes values in definition of the category DSco-f.g. D. By composing it with S, we obtain the any object XinBco-f.g. D, the direct limit lim--Xis finitely generated and of finite exponent, by Lemma 2.19; it is therefore finite, and the direct limit functor fact ors as (2.18) [Gab62, Ch. III, SS1, Corollaire 2]). Combining (2.18) with (2.17) shows that Lextends to an endofunctor, still denoted by the same 2.32. LetXbe a double system in DSco-f.g. D, and suppose that X~=BDL(X). Then
|Xn|plXn, wherelXis the corank of lim--X. Moreover, given an exact double systems satisfying the above assumption, the rela observed in Corollary 2.28, the existence of a BD-isomorphism as in the On the other hand, the explicit structure of the direct limit of the groups an exact sequence as in the statement, [Gab62, Ch. III, SS1, Corollaire 1] yields an L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. that the diagram 0 /d47/d47 Y' /d47/d47
~=BD/d15/d15Y /d47/d47
~=BD/d15/d15Y'' /d47/d47
~=BD/d15/d150 0 /d47/d47 X' /d47/d47 X /d47/d47 X'' /d47/d47 0 commutes. It yields, again through Corollary 2.28, the chain of even tual the proof. /square We conclude this section by analysing the exactness of the functor L. Proposition 2.33. Given an exact the sequence (2.19) 0 exact in In particular, Lis an exact functor when regarded as L:DSco-f.g. D/Bco-f.g. D-- Proof.Observe first that Sis left exact, since so is the functor Mmapsto-M[hn] for all n>=0. Therefore we have an exact S(u)--0. We claim that Coker S(u)Bco-f.g. D: this will imply that (2.19) is right exact. FornN, the connecting homomorphism of the snake to multiplication by hn. The formation of the snake exact sequence being get commutative commutativity of (2.20) together with the exactness of the sn ake sequence shows that the cokernel Coker S(u) is a subobject of the double system X= we byassumption, M' redisfinite, thequotient projection pm,nis the identity. Thus, this system satisfies the assumptions of Prop osition 2.24, showing thatX BDand therefore Coker S(u)Bco-f.g. D. This concludes the proof of the exactness on the right of OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 27 The final assertion concerning from the previ- ous point, combined with exactness of /square Given any double system X= (Xn,phn,m,pm,n) inDSco-f.g. D, for each n>=0 the map through Ph =L(X)n. We claim that the commutative, and hence determine a morphism Ph X:X - L(X) of double systems. of the left square in (2.21) follows from the fact that the direct limit is taken with respect to the morphism phn,m. Concerning that on the right, let xXm: we need to show that, in the direct limit, the By definition of direct limit, this follows from the equality which is a consequence of the relation phm,n*pn,m=hn,m. The next corollary shows that this construction is 2.34. The collection Ph = (Ph a natural transformation Ph: endofunctors of the abelian category Proof.Letf:X-X'be a morphism of double systems. We need to prove the commutativit y by construction, L(X)n= (lim--X)[hn] and L(X')n= (lim--X')[hn]. Thus, commutativ- ity of (2.22) translates in the requirement that the following diagram commutes, for all is clear. /square Example 2.35.We show that the hypothesis of Corollary 2.32 holds for the double sy Example 2.23, where we fix n0>=1 in what follows. Since lim--Z=Qp/Zpand each component (Z)nis finite, the system Zactually lies in the subcategory DSco-f.g. D. We start by computing L(Z). By definition, L(Z) =Slim--Z, and we (Z)n28 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO with the obvious transition morphisms. In particular, the evaluation PhZof the natural transfor- mation Ph atZis actually an isomorphism in DSco-f.g. D, not only in ConcerningZ[n0]we have seen in Example 2.23 that Z[n0]~=BDZ, and clearlyZ[n0]is an well. By first applying Lto this isomorphism and then composing the with Ph Z, we that Ph Z[n0]is an isomorphism as well. Note, though, that this is not an isomorphism before taking the quotient by Bco-f.g. D. Indeed the direct limits lim--Zand lim--Z[n0]are both isomorphic to Qp/Zp, showing The double system of the cohomology of units 3.1. Arithmetic set-up. In this section, we apply the algebraic results from Section 2 to an arithmetic setting arising in Iwasawa theory. Fix a number field kand a finite normal extension F/k, and set D0= Gal(F/k). Consider a Zp-extension L/F, which is also normal over k: set D= Gal(L/k) and G = Gal( L/F), so that there is an exact sequence (2.1) 1 --G--D-- D0--1 as in Section 2.2. Endow G with the filtration G n= Gpnfor alln>=0, so that, with notation as inloc. cit.,g(G) = 0 and define the groups Denote by Lnthe by G n, so that [Lm:Ln] =pm-n. We refer the reader to [Tat67] and to [Ser67] for the global and lo cal class field theory results that we use. Consider the following commutative diagram of Galois mod ules with exact rows 1 1 Here we use the following notation for a number field M:Mxdenotes the group ( M{0})Zp, IdMis the group of fractional ideals tensored with Zp, PrMis the group of principal ideals the quotient Id M/PrM(i. e.thep-Sylow of the class group of M),Ax Mis the id` ele group tensored with Zp,CMis the quotient Ax M/Mx(i. e.the id` ele class group tensored with Zp), Ox Mis the group of units tensored with Zp,UMis the group of id` eles of valuation 0 at every finiteCOHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 29 place tensored with ZpandQMis defined by the exactness of the diagram. Every term in (3.1) belongs to aD-normic system, in the sense of Definition 2.2, where the transition m aps are induced by the the (arithmetic) collection of all diagrams (3.1) for n>=0 is a commutative diagram in the category NSD. All these normic systems satisfy (Inj), except for the system ( ALn). As for (Gal), it only holds for the four normic systems in the upper left square and for the id` ele c lass group. Together with the global objects introduced above, two local nor mic systems will be needed. For every prime pofF, fix a prime PinLabovep. This choice determines a decomposition group D(p)Das well as a decomposition group G( p) = GD(p)G. The prime PLnofLnwill be denoted Pnand its decomposition groups in Gnand inDnwill be denoted by Gn(p) When there are only finitely many primes above pinL(this will be the only case of interest to us), G( p) is isomorphic to Zpand we can endow ( Lx Pn) and (Ox LPn) with a structure of D(p)-normic system as follows (for a local field Ewe follow the same convention explained above, so Ex:= the groupofunits tensored with Zp). Endow G( p) with the G( this filtration satisfiesthe with wherepgis the (finite) number of primes in Labovep--in other words, Lg/Fis the maximal subextension in L/Fwherepsplits completely. The collections ( Lx Pn) and (Ox LPn), endowed with the natural extension and norm maps, denoted iPm/Pnand N Pm/Pn, systems. We denote these normic systems by Ox P*andLx P*, respectively. They satisfy both (Inj)and(Gal). Before passing to the analysis of double systems arising from Tate cohomology, we establish one lemma on the residual action on the coh omology of local units. First, we introduce the following 3.1. Given a number field M2and an extension M1/M2, denote by T( M1/M2) the set of primes of M2which ramify in M1/M2. Given any prime pOF, denote by pthe bypgpthe number of primes in Labove it. Finally, let denote the ramification index (resp. the inertia degree, the exte nsion degree) of LPm/LPn. To lighten the typesetting of some formulae we also introduce the no tationlto denote lnp(f) wherefis the inertia degree of pinL/F. When the prime pneeds to be specified, following general lemma will be useful to analyse the action of D0on the idelic units. Lemma 3.2. LetDbe a finite group and let G < H < D be subgroups of D. For every H-module Mand every iZ, there is an any Z[G]-module P, consider the Hom L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO SinceZ[D] isZ[H]-free, [Bou61, Chap.I, SS2, ndeg9, Proposition 10], shows that tis an Pis projective and finitely presented. Now let P*-Zbe resolution of the Zmade of finitely presented projective modules. isomorphism (3.2) is induced by tand (3.3) is an isomorphism because Z[D] isZ[H]-flat. In particular, we get an isomorphism of conclude the proof we argue inductively by backward dimension sh ifting. We start the induction ati= 1: we have just proved that for every Z[H]-module Nthere is a go from itoi-1, apply the functor -ZMto the augmentation map Z[H]-Z. We obtain an exact sequence of a suitable M', whereMZZ[H] is induced, hence cohomologically trivial. We deduce that there is an isomorphism a also have an exact sequence of an isomorphism of by the inductive hypothesis, obtain a the proof. /square Lemma 3.3. Fixn>=0. The with Shapiro's lemma induce isomorphisms of D0-modules (3.4) alliZ. In particular, there are 1,2 whereD0acts its action on the set OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 31 Proof.We start by analysing the cohomology of local units. Let pT(L/F) be a prime. Denoting by vPnthePn-adic valuation, we have an exact sequence of 0 cohomology of the sequence we get, through Hilbert Theore m 90, a similar result holds for i= 2: local class field theory shows that the cup-product with the fu nda- mental class induces a isomorphism restricts to a ( that (3.7) and (3.8) show that Dn(p) acts trivially on fori= 1,2. We now proceed with the proof of the lemma. For a prime pofF(resp. a prime pofk), the product is taken over the prime ideals of Lndividing p(resp. dividing p). and, since the local units in unramified extension are cohom ologically trivial, this induces an isomorphism of particular, to establish (3.4) it suffices to work component-wise, and we focus on a fixed prime pT(L/k) from now on. Note and this gives a =/circleplusdisplay p|p. Toanalysethe Dn-action, observethat Vp Lnis infact a Hn(p) the subgroup generated by GnandDn(p), In particular, Lemma 3.2 yields an isomorphism of Dn-modules
~=Z[Hn(p)]Z[Dn] =/circleplusdisplay p|p that coincides with (3.9).32 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO Now observe that Shapiro's isomorphism factors as =/circleplusdisplay L|p/hatwideHi(Gn(p),Ox L)prPn---- (see [Tat67, SS7.2]) and thus it is . Since Dn(p) acts trivially on in light of the discussion in the first part of the proof, the same holds for and therefore the whole Hn(p) acts trivially on . Hence we have Z[Hn(p)]Z[Dn] =ZZ[D0/D0(p)]~=ZZ[D0/D0(p)] asDn-modules, because This concludes the proof of the first assertion of the lemma. The existence of the isomorphisms (3.5) follows from (3.7) and (3.8). /square 3.2. Double systems of Tate cohomology. Given anyD-normic systemB= (BLn) as in SS2.2, we equivalently denote its direct (resp. inverse) limit as lim--Bor according to convenience. If (Inj)and(Gal)), then for all odd iZ(resp. all iZ) we can consider the isD-a double system in the language of SS2.3 by Proposition 2.14. Since any cohomology group of Gnis annihilated by pn, for everyD-normic (Inj)(resp. both (Inj) and(Gal)), condition (co-f.g. A) is satisfied for /hatwideHi(B) foriodd (resp. for all i). Moreover there are canonical for i>=1, where the limit is taken with respect to the maps Inf *j*. In particular, when i>=1, condi- tion (co-f.g. B) for /hatwideHi(B) is equivalent to the condition that Hi(G,BL) belong to when this is the case, the double system /hatwideHi(B) actually lies in DSco-f.g. Dand can be regarded as an object of the quotient category When considering a local normic the cohomology we consider is relative to the decomposition groups Gn(p). To stress this difference, we denote by a subscript pthe corresponding D(p)-double starting point of our study is the exact sequence of double sys tems (3.10) existence follows from Propositions 2.10 and 2.11. Let any of the normic systems occurring in (3.10). It is well-known that Hi(G,lim--B) belongs to 1,2 (see, for instance, [Iwa83, SS2]), so (3.10) is an exact sequence in DSco-f.g. D. We first analyse the D-double systems /hatwideHi(UL*), and we single out their relationship with the D(p)-double systems in the following OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 33 Proposition 3.4. For each prime pT(L/k), the sum/circleplustext p|pis aD-double system, with theD0-action discussed in Lemma 3.3. Moreover the isomorphisms (3.4)induce systems (3.11) /hatwideHi(UL*)~=/circleplusdisplay pT(L/k)/circleplusdisplay p|pfor alliZ. Proof.To prove the first assertion we need to show the relation (3.12) */hatwideHi(jn,m) = (G n: Gm) for all m>=n>=0 for the transition morphisms of the system/circleplustext p|p. Letnp trbe the first index above which any of the local Zp-extensions LP/Fp(for any p|p) is totally ramified. For every natural number n>=np tr, we have (G n: Gm) =pm-n= (G(p)n: G(p)m), and (3.12) is satisfied since every is aD(p)-double system. When n<=np tr, the group/circleplustext p|p vanishes because the cohomologyof local units in unramified extensionsis triv ial. Thereforein this case both are trivial endomorphisms and (3.12) is equivalent to saying that (G n: Gm) annihilates/circleplustext p|p This is obvious for/circleplustext p|p = 0. As for the groups at level m, observe that each is annihilated by |Gm,np tr(p)|= (G(p)np tr: G(p)m) =em/np tr=em/0: we have shown this in Lemma 3.3 for degrees 1 and 2, and periodicity of Tate co homology yields the same result for all iZ. Thus, since (G( p)np tr: G(p)m) divides (G n: Gm) because n<=np tr, it follows that (Gn: Gm) also acts as 0 established that the right-hand side of (3.11) is a D-double system, the fact that (3.11) is an isomorphism will be an immediate consequence of Lemma 3.3 once we prove that the iso- morphisms (3.4) are compatible with the ascending and descending mo rphisms, hence of double systems. Since both the ascending and desc ending morphisms are relative to the extension L/F(rather than L/k), we can and do fix a prime pOFand check for the relevant component. Given the explicit definition of Shapiro's lemma in Tate cohomology, the required compatibilities correspond to the commut ativity, for all iZ, of =/productdisplay l|p/hatwideHi(Gn(p),Ox l)prPn/d47/d47/hatwideHi(iPm/Pn)/d79/d79(3.13) 3We adopt the typesetting convention of denoting by Lthe generic prime dividing pinLmand denoting by l the generic prime dividing pinLn. We adopt the notation N L/landiL/lto denote the corresponding norm and extension maps.34 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. =/productdisplay l|p/hatwideHi(Gn(p),Ox l)prPn/d47/d47(3.14) All terms in the bottom lines of (3.13) and (3.14) vanish if n<=gp, and there is nothing to fromnowon, that m>=n>=gp. the cup-products defining /hatwideHi(j) and/hatwideHi(k) for arbitrary i. More = Res Res Gn(p)(kn) corresponds to the element of Hom( Gn(p),Qp/Zp) defined by (3.15) Res : Gn) = (G : G( p))/(G : Gn). On the other hand, by definition of /hatwideHi(j) and/hatwideHi(k) for the local system, they coincide with cup product with the class that corresponds to the element of Hom( by (3.16) : we have G n(p) = Gnso that (3.15) and (3.16) agree. Therefore it is enough to of both (3.13) and of (3.14) for i=-1 and for i= 0. Starting with i=-1, and By [AW67, Propo- sition 7], restriction in degree -1 is represented by multiplication by the algebraic norm, of the diagrams (3.13) and (3.14) are equivalent to th e (3.18) To check (3.17), suppose that xcan be represented by ( Thanks to the the restriction of Galois automorphisms induces a bijection betwee n the sets denote this bijection by a bar, writing sfor the generic element of Gm/Gm(p) that is the restriction of sGn/Gn(p). Then, with a slight abuse of notation consisting in OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 35 xwith the tuple of for(3.18) equality NPm/Pn*sfor allsGm/Gm(p) corresponding to sGn/Gn(p). The case i= 0 can be handled similarly. This time, restriction reduces to project ing a class mod- ulo Nm Gn(resp. modulo Nm Gm) to the class modulo Nm Gn(p)(resp. modulo Nm Gm(p)). Given an elementbmod Nm (resp. an element Bmod Nm commutativity of diagrams (3.13) and (3.14) can be written Nm Nm Nm Nm (3.20) Thanks to the assumption n>=gp, the in bijection; moreover, the index (G n: Gm) equals pm-n. Thus, writing b= (bl)l|p, the relation (3.19) reduces to the chain Nm /hatwideH0(iPm/Pn)/parenleftbig bPnmod Nm /parenleftbig iPm/Pnbpm-n Pnmod Nm Nm Nm Equation (3.20) can be checked similarly. /square We will use the above proposition to obtain an explicit description of th e double system of the cohomology of local units. First, we need a lemma. Lemma 3.5. LetpT(L/F)be a prime of Fand setE=Fp. For every sN, setEs=LPs and the fundamental class of Es/E. Then, for m>=n>=0, the36 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. where the map the canonical projection and dm/n=
[Em:En]is the degree of the local the first diagram, the proof is similar to that of Lemma 2.7 for i= 2, replacing kby the fundamental class and using = =dm/nuEm/E (see [Ser62, Ch. XI SS3], note that Serre's Inf is our Inf *i*
Em/En). To analyse the second diagram, let be the element introduced in (3.16) and fors>=0. As discussed in SS2.2.3, the relation (3.21) khp n(prm,ns) for all sGm(p)abZp=Gm(p) where is the surjective map induced by the restriction to En. Given aZp, sety= so that (3.22) ykp m= y, then it also represents by reciprocity map of local class field theory. Then, with notation as in [Ser62, Ch. [Ser62, Ch. XI, Proposition 2]) = [Ser62, p.178, (4)]) = (3.21)) [Ser62, Ch. XI, Proposition 2]) = (3.22)) = [Ser62, Ch. XI, SS3]) = inv E/bracketleftbig (amod|Gm(p)|)/bracketrightbig
= OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 37 where the last equality follows from the definition of the absolute inv Eas the limit, relative to inflation, of inv Eat finite levels. Since inv Eis injective, we conclude that the second diagram is commutative. /square Remark 3.6.Consider the normic system Then in the left (resp. in isinfact particular, the lemma can be reformulated as saying that the dou ble systems are isomorphic, an isomorphism being the cup-product with the fun damental 3.7. The isomorphisms (3.5)define isomorphisms of D-double systems (3.23) the double system introduced in Example 2.23 and whe reD0acts its action on the set T(L/F). In particular, there are 1,2. Proof.For a prime pT(L/k), the maps (3.5) arise from isomorphisms of D0-modules (3.24)/circleplusdisplay p|p~=/circleplusdisplay p|pZ/en/0 induced by (3.7) and (3.8). Considering the groups on the right-han d side as the terms of the D-double we are going to prove that (3.25)/circleplusdisplay p|p~=/circleplusdisplay p|pZ(G)[gp+l] asD-double systems: this is enough to prove the main assertion of the c orollary because, arguing as in Example 2.23, we see by conjugation on the set {p|p}. To prove (3.25), we need to check that isomorphisms (3.24) are com patible with the transition maps of the double systems. Since transition maps are defined comp onent-wise, we can perform this check on the components corresponding to a fixed prime pabovep. The sequences (3.6) induce a short exact sequence of D(p)-normic systems (3.26) 0 first two normic systems in (3.26) satisfy both (Inj)and(Gal), and the third satisfies (Inj). By applying Propositions 2.10 and 2.11 to (3.26) we obtain commutative L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO Note that the cohomological connecting homomorphisms are precis ely the maps inducing the iso- morphisms (3.7), so we have shown the required compatibility for i= 1. Concerning the case i= 2, the sequence (3.26) induces an injection of double systems. The isomorphisms (3.8) are the restriction to of the commute arbitrary m>=n>=0, which is precisely Lemma 3.5. The final statement concerning Lfollows from the first combined with Example 2.35. /square The following theorem is the main result of this section. Theorem 3.8. In the quotient category following sequence is exact (3.28) 0 applying the functor L=S*lim--, it gives rise to the exact there is a commutative diagram of exact sequences 0 /d47/d47 /d47/d47 /d47/d47 /d47/d47 /d47/d47 /d127 /d47/d47 /d47/d47 the sequence (3.10) is already exact in DSco-f.g. D, exactness of (3.28) amounts to (3.31) Ker/parenleftBig --/hatwideH1(UL*)/parenrightBig BD. To show this, observe that the ascending transition morphisms of t his system are the restriction 2.7, together with injectivity of inflation in degree 1, implies tha t/hatwideH1(j) is injective, be- causej*is the identity in this case. Moreover, for every n>=0, the kernel isomorphic to the capitulation kernel for instance, 2.2]), and therefore its order is constant for nlarge enough. It follows that the are isomorphisms for n0, and Proposition 2.24 yields (3.31). Since Lis an exact functor when restricted to Proposition 2.33, exactness of (3.29) follows. By 2.34 to (3.29), we find the commutative diagram (3.30), whe re the second and fifth verti- cal maps are isomorphisms by Corollary 3.7. What remains to be prove d is that the third of (3.30) is injective. To check this, recall that by Lemma 2 .7 the following OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS allm>=n>=0. In particular, Ker(j*,1 n,m), because inflation is injective in degree 1. Taking Gn-cohomology of the exact that Ker( j*,1 n,m) is a quotient of a submodule of QGm,n Lm/QLn. Taking direct limits, the natu- rality of the connecting homomorphism guarantees that in a quotient of a subsystem isomorphic to as shown in [Nuc10, isomorphism ibid. being the connecting homomorphism of the snake lemma. Again thes e isomorphisms give rise to an isomorphism of double to the naturality of the snake lemma. Hence, in order to pro ve thatj*,1= (j*,1 n,m) is it is enough to show that the double to BD. This follows from Proposition 2.24, because the norm is eventually an isomorphism on capitulation kernels as shown, for example, in [Oza95, Propositio n]. /square Remark 3.9.In the Introduction we mentioned that two morphisms in (3.30) beco me injective in the quotient category their kernels do not belong to the corresponding when regarded simply as direct (resp. inverse) sys tems. The morphisms in questions are/hatwideH1(QL*)-L/parenleftbig/hatwideH1(QL*)/parenrightbig and-/hatwideH1(UL*), respectively. This is the main reason that led us to introduce the notion of double systems. We now move forward to the study the global counterpart of Coro llary 3.7. Before, we need the following technical lemma: Lemma 3.10. LetA1,...,A 5,B1,...,B 5be objects of an abelian category and let f1,...,f 5be morphisms in the category making the following diagram with exact rows that f2is an isomorphism and f5is injective. Then there is an exact particular, if f3is injective, then f4is injective as well and f1is surjective.40 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. with 0 the rows of the diagram of the statement, we obta in cochain complexes, which we denote by satisfying Ai=AiandBi=Bifor 1<=i<=5. Thus we have a map f:A-Bof cochain complexes and we consider the cochain complexes K= Kerf, I= ImfandC= Coker f. We obtain two exact sequences of complexes (3.32) 0--K--A--I-0 and 0 exactness of the rows of the diagram in the statement can be r ecast as Hi(A) = 0 for 1,5 andHi(B) = 0 for all ie}atioslash= 5. In particular, the zig-zag lemma applied to the exact sequences in (3.32) yields and exact sequence of the statement can be obtained from the ex act sequence (3.34) 0 follows. The assumptions on f2andf5mean that K2=K5= 0 and C2= 0: in = 0 and (3.33) implies H4(K) = 0. Therefore the fourth term (3.34) is also trivial since it is isomorphic to H4(K), since K5= 0. Similarly, K2= 0 implies H3(K) and invoking again (3.33) we can rewrite (3.34) as 0--H1(C)--K3= Kerf3--K4= C1= Coker C2= 3.11. TheD-double systems for i= 1,2. Proof.Apply Lemma 3.10 to the commutative diagram (3.30) of Theorem 3.8: w e obtain a /axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisright /axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisrightL/parenleftbig/parenrightbig as well as an injection (3.36) morphism in (3.35) is clearly also injective (and therefore an isomo rphism), because so is the composition
/axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisrightL/parenleftbig/parenrightbig
/axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisrightL/parenleftbig/hatwideH1(UL*)/parenrightbig , as shown in Theorem 3.8. Passing to cohomology in degree 2, consider the morphisms, for definition of as = in (3.36) is equivalent to the claim that the double system Cwith components ( C)n=COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 41 Coker(tn) is inBD, or also that the image of t= (tn) in the quotient category DSD/BDis a surjective morphism. Consider the D-double the double subsystem of components are N By the structure theorem of units in number fields, one immediately see s toZrkZpOx Fand in particular belongs to DSco-f.g. D(and the same holds for NOx L*). We can therefore apply Proposition 2.33 and Corollary 2.34 to the tau tological exact /d47/d47 NOx L*/d47/d47 0 0 /d47/d47 0 Example 2.35 shows that the middle vertical map is an isomorphism. The snake lemma implies that the right vertical morphism is surjective, concluding the proof tha t (3.36) is an isomorphism. gygroups Hi(G,Ox L) up to finite groups, which becomes explicit under the assumption t hatFis totally real and that it satisfies Leopoldt conjecture (see [Iwa83, Proposition 5 and Sec tion 4]). His analysis is performed only at the limit, and conveys no information on the full double syste m (a notion which does not appear ibid.). One of our motivations for this work was to unravel the purely gr of his results so that it could be generalized to other settin gs and other normic systems. More precisely, to obtain an for the growthof the ordersof units from the description of the cohomology groups Hi(G,Ox L), one is naturally led to consider the morphisms lnandunof[Iwa83, p.199], groups Hi(G,Ox L)[pn] an Iwasawa-like formula, group) by Iwasawa's description. One can deduce from this that the cohom ology groups of units at finite levels also follows an if both kernels and cokerne ls oflnandunare Corollary 3.11 makes this precise. Formulae for the cohom ology groups of units at finite levels will be made explicit in the next section. 4. Fake Zp-extensions of dihedral type 4.1. Definitions. In the rest of the paper assume that p>=3 is odd, and that Dis pro-dihedral: by this, we mean that D0has order 2 and the split exact sequence (2.1) 1 --G--D-- D0--1 induces a non-trivial action of D0on G. Many results we obtain are likely to easily generalise to the case where D0is a finite group of order prime to pwhose characters are Zp-valued. The image of a fixed splitting D0-Dis a subgroup S 0D, which intersects each G ntrivially. It is hence isomorphic to its image S 0Dn, still denoted by the same symbol by a slight abuse of42 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO notation. For n<=, letKnbe the subfield of Lnfixed by S 0and write k=K0. The of fields is the collection of fields {Kn}n>=0share some similarities with a Zp-extension: indeed, each degree pand the only possible ramified primes lie above p, because so is for the extension L/F. Yet, a crucial difference is that none of the extension Kn+1/Kn, let alone the wholeK/k, is Galois. This motivates the 4.1. Assume that p>=3 is odd and consider the setting of diagram (4.1). The extension K/kis a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type, the field Lis the Galois closure of the fake Zp- extension and F/kis called the normalizing quadratic extension. IfBis aZp[D]-module, then it is uniquely 2-divisible. By restriction, it admits an actio n of S 0, which we can see as an action of D0via the splitting D0-D. Accordingly, it admits a B=B+B-where we denote by B+(resp.B-) the maximal submodule on which D0acts trivially (resp. as -1). Such decomposition is obtained by writing wheresgenerates D0. Then (4.2) applies in particular to Zp[Dn]-modules and their Gn-cohomology. In fact we can say a bit more in this case, as explained in the next proposition which is [CN20, P roposition 2.1] (the final statement about G-cohomology follows from the result at finite leve ls by taking direct 4.2. LetBbe a uniquely 2-divisible Dn-module. Then, for every iZ, functorial the Tate isomorphism In particular, for every iZ, there are OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 43 of abelian groups. In particular, given any D-normic systemB= (BLn), there are a systems /hatwideHi(B) where, an entirely analogous argument applies to the double system of the cohomology of a local normic system, inducing a decomposition /hatwideHi p(B) is An Iwasawa-like formula. In this section we state and prove Theorem 4.6, which is one of our main results. Fix a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type K/kand adopt the in SS4.1. For future reference, we add the following piece of notation to Notation 3.1: Notation 4.3. Denote by T( L/k)sT(L/k) the set of primes of kthat ramify in L/kand split inF/k. Also, denote by t(L/k) and by t(L/k)s, respectively, the number of primes in T(L/k) and in T( L/k)s. The first step is Corollary 4.4 below, which is a signed version of Corollar y 3.7 and of Corol- lary 3.11. Here,Z=Z(G) again denotes the double system introduced in Example 2.23. For a group Hand aH-module B, we denote by /hatwidehi(H,B) the order of /hatwideHi(H,B), whenever this group is 4.4. i)Fori= 1,2, there are BG-isomorphisms induce 1,2. ii)For each choice of a symbol *{,+-}and every iZ, there exists integers every iZthese invariants well as l(i,Ox L*) (4.8) In (4.9)44 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO Proof.i) Recall that Corollary 3.7 yields BD-isomorphisms 1,2 whereD0acts by permutation on the set T( L/F). We are thus reduced to analyse the Starting with the plus component, let (4.10) an element For primes Pabove a non-split prime in F/kwe have sP=P, while for primes in T( L/F) dividing a prime that splits in F/kwe have The into (4.11) xP=xsPfor every PT(L/F) dividing a split prime in F/k and no constraint on the coefficients xPwhenPlies above a non-split prime. Let pT(L/k) denote the prime below PT(L/F): the surjection sending xto the injective thanks to (4.11), so defines an Concerning the minus component, the same anelement xasin (4.10) satisfies sx=-x if and only if Plies above a non-split prime in a prime that splits in F/k. Therefore, the morphism sending the an This concludes the proof of the first part of i), and (4.3) follows by taking direct limits. ii) When*=, Corollaries 2.32 and 3.11 imply the statement for i= 1,2: the case for by periodicity of Tate cohomology. For the signed invariants, leti= 1,2 and take
+--parts for the action of D0on the isomorphism Corollary 3.11: 2.32 implies that there exist 1,2.COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 45 Combining Proposition4.2 with the periodicity ofTate cohomologyperm its to extend the definition to alliby setting (4.12) (mod (mod (mod (mod 4) iii) The equalities in (4.4) and (4.6) follow by (4.12). That in (4.5) is a direct consequence of =+-, while (4.7) follows from Proposi- tion 4.2. As for (4.8), it comes from the fact that the Herbrand quo tient of global units with the showninthe firstpartofthe proof. Thelastrelation (4.5) and (4.6). /square Remark 4.5.Observe that H2j+3(G,Ox L) = 0 for all j>=0 because G has strict 2. Nevertheless, l(2j+ 3,Ox L*) =l(1,Ox L*) is non-zero, in general, showing that between and L/parenleftbig/parenrightbig of Corollary 3.11 does not hold for i>=3. Recall now [CN20, Theorem 3.14] which, applied to the dihedral exte nsionLn/k, says that (4.13) every number field M, leteMbe thep-power of the order of the p-Sylow of its class group, so upon Corollary 4.4, we find the 4.6. LetK/kbe a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type with Galois closure quadratic extension F/k. There exist constants for alln0. Moreover, if we denote by uIw,lIwthe Iwasawa invariants of the Zp-extension L/F, as in Corollary 4.4-ii ).46 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO Proof.By taking p-adic valuation in (4.13) and rearranging terms we Iwasawa's theorem quoted in the Introduction, the growth of eLnis controlled by the three invariants uIw,lIw,nIw. Formula (4.14) follows from Corollary 4.4-(4.7). The only thing which is left to be checked is that lfakeis an integer: this follows by computing the difference eKn+1-eKnfor anynbig enough so that the (4.14) holds. We since ( p-1) is even we have ufakepn(p-1)Z, whence lfakeZ. /square Remark 4.7.Under the hypothesis that F/Qis an abelian extension such that Gal( F/Q) is killed by (p-1), and that L/Qis Galois, the above result is a particular case of [Jau81, Th' eor` eme 3]. In [CN20], explicit bounds for the ratio of class numbers are determin ed. Such bounds can be translated into bounds for lfake, as shown in the next corollary. For a number field M, ifMdoes not contain any primitive pth root of unity 1 4.8. The following inequalities [CN20, Corollary 3.15], we have (4.15) the p-adic valuation. When n0, using Theorem 4.6 we can write the central term of the above chain of inequalities as ( a constant independent of n. We deduce since these inequalities hold for every n0, we must and ( is equivalent to the statement. /square We end this section by showing that the constant in Corollary 4.4- ii) and in Theorem 4.6 has a more direct description in terms of arithmetic invariants of the extension L/k. In what follows, adopt the notation introduced in SS3.1 as well as those of Notation 4.3. Definition 4.9. For every nsuch that every ramified prime in L/Lnis totally ramified, denote by PLnALnthe subgroup generated by the classes of the through the set T( Ln/F). One sees immediately that P Lnis in fact a so that the plus and minus components P+- Lnare OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 47 According to the above definition, the subgroups P Lnare defined only for n0. This shall cause no harm to our arguments, because we will be interested in th e behaviour of their order for n-+: in particular, they do not directly give rise to a normic system, altho ugh the relations of Definition 2.2 are satisfied for 4.10. There exists lP,l+- PZ>=0such They are related to the invariants obtained in Corollary 4.4-ii )as =t(L/F)-lP, (Yn,phn,m,pm,n) be the cokernel of the first map in (3.10), so that, by Theorem 3.8, there is a short exact sequence (4.17) 0 /axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisright/axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisright/hatwideH1(UL*)/axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisrightY/axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisright0 in The first two terms satisfy ~=BDL/parenleftbig/parenrightbig and/hatwideH1(UL*)~=BD L/parenleftbig/hatwideH1(UL*)/parenrightbig , by Corollary 3.11 and by Corollary 3.7, respectively. Since the funct orLis exact, we Thanks to Corollary 2.32, there exists lYsuch 3.7 implies (4.18) l(1,Ox L*) given any D-double we the functor Lcommutes with the action of D0: hence, (4.18) admits the signed versions (4.19) conclude the proof we show that (4.20) all choices of a sign *{,+-}: one obtains the sought-for constant lPby setting l*
P=l*
Y. We give the proof of (4.20) for *=; the other cases follow since all morphisms considered in the proof are regular (resp. Tate) cohomology. For brevity, write to denote that, for all m>=n>=0, the where PLmdenotes the image of P LmH0(Gm,n,ALm) In particu- lar, [Nuc10, Proposition 2.1], yields an =d(0) n(PLn) for all n>=0. Therefore, to prove (4.20) we are left to show that constant order for nlarge enough. Let ntrbe the first index such that all ramified primes in L/Lntrare totally ramified and48 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO consider, for n>=ntr, the commutative compatibility of local and global class field theory shows that ais surjective: indeed, its image is the product of all inertia subgroups in Gn,ntr, and this is the whole totally ramified at all primes where it ramifies. It follows that injective and therefore, for Ker( d(0) n,ntr) = Nm Gn,ntr(ALn) and Ker( d(0) n,ntr)PLn= Nm totally ramified, the arithmetic norm is surjective on ideal class gro ups and we obtain (4.24) Nm Gn,ntr(ALn) order independently of n; the sameholds, Moreover,for m>=n>=ntr, = Nm Gm,ntr(ALm). It follows that, for all m>=nntr, the maps iLm/Lnare surjections between groups of bounded orders: they are therefore isomorphisms. In particular, throug h (4.23), they induce again, since the orders bounded, this shows that the extension maps are actually isomo allm>=nntr. Observe now that, for all n>=ntr, there is a commutative induces an inclusion This implies that independently of n, a bound being the order which is (4.25). Moreover, restricting the isomorphism in (4.25) to for m>=nntr, iLm/Ln: more, these are inclusions among groups of bounded order, a nd are therefore constant for nlarge enough. OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS weextractfromthe aboveproofthe fact t hat is of n(and actually eventually trivial, although we will not need this). Indee d, we have shown that injective for all n>=ntr, and the commutative an injection Ker( In particular, Ker( = 0 for all n>=ntr. 4.3. Formulae for l(0,Ox L*)+in special cases. In this section, we fix a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type K/kand we place ourselves in the setting introduced in SS4.1. The invariant lfake of Theorem 4.6 is explicitly related to the constants and we have provided an arithmetic description of the former in Proposition 4.10. In this section, we show that in some cases also the latter can be interpreted in more explicit arithm etic terms. In the write r1(k) andr2(k), respectively, for the number of real embeddings and of pairs of conjugate complex embeddings of k, 4.12. Suppose that one of the following conditions holds: (a)F/kis totally imaginary and kis totally real, so that Fis a CM field with kas totally either Qor an imaginary quadratic field; (c)pis totally split in F/Q, all primes of Fabovepramify in L/Fand the Leopoldt conjecture holds for F(andp). With the same notation introduced in Notation 4.3 and in Prop osition 4.10, we case(a) 0 in By [Was97, Theorem 4.12] we know (recall that all abelian groups un der consider- ation are Zp-modules) thatOx F=Ox k= (Ox F)+: it follows that 0, so 0. Corollary 4.4-(4.5) yields and Corollary 4.4-(4.8) The result follows from Proposition 4.10. (b) When kisQor imaginary quadratic the unit group Ox kis finite, so l(0,Ox L*)+= 0. (c) To prove the statement, we first define an ancillary normic system . For every n>=0, theZp-module of semi-local p-adic units of Ln. Clearly, this gives rise to a D-normic system Vwhosenth component is VLn. The diagonal embedding Ox Ln-VLninduces a morphism of normic gives rise, through (2.6), to a morphism /hatwideH0(Ox L*)u/axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisright/hatwideH0(VL*) in Consider now the D-double in (3.37) together50 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO with the semi-local diagonal embedding induces a morphism Ox F/(Ox F)p*v/axisshort/axisshort/arrowaxisrightVF/(VF)p*in The inclusions (VF)pnNLn/FVLn) give rise to a commutative diagram /d47/d47 Keru
/d15/d15 1 /d47/d47 NOx L*/d47/d47 w /d47/d47 u
/d15/d151 1 /d47/d47 NVL*/d47/d47 /hatwideH0(VL*) /d47/d47 N Ln/FVLn/(VF)pn. We now make the following claims: Claim A) When pis totally split in F/Qand all primes above pramify in L/F, the to BD; Claim B) Assuming the Leopoldt conjecture for Fandp, the morphism vis the claims, let us derive point ( c). Claim B) implies that Ker w= 0, so Claim A) we get an taking plus parts, (4.28) structure theorem of global units gives (c) follows, by combining Example 2.35 with Corollary 2.32. We are therefore left with t he proof of the Claim A), fix n0 such that all primes above pare totally ramified in L/Ln: for every p|pinFand every ln|pinLn, the extension Lln/Fpis a cyclic extension of Qp, degree as in Notation 3.1), and local class field theory implies that Nln/pOx ln= (Zx p)pn-lp . It follows OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 51 and thus the double system NVL*coincides with the constant double lies in BDby Proposition 2.24. Concerning Claim B), [Mik87, Lemma 2] shows that the Leopoldt conje cture is equivalent to the existence of n>=0 such alln > n or, equivalently, such that (4.29) alln > n. On the other hand, the nth component of Ker can be rewritten, using (4.29), alln > (Ox F)pn: thenNMare two finitely generated Zp-modules finite. It follows that they have the same rank, and this shows tha order bounded independently of n>=0. To conclude the proof, we show that the D-double system Ker vsatisfies condition BD-3), alln0. We need to compute the direct and inverse limits of the D-double both MandNare finitely generated Zp-modules, the inverse limit functor is exact 0. In 0 for all n>=0. On the other hand, the torsion submodule of Mis finite, say M[p] =M[pt]. It follows that the morphism injective for n>=t: to see this, suppose - xKer(phn) is represented by some xMpnand letx0Mbe such that x=xpn 0. To say that phn(-x) = 0 means that there exists m>=nsuch that phn,m(-x) = 0 or, equivalently, xpm-nNpm. Hence, that xpm 0=xpm-n=ypm: therefore x0=y*zfor some zM[p] this yields x=xpn 0=ypnNpn, so that - x= 0. In 0 for all BD-3), B). /square Before proceeding, we need a small digression concerning the Gros s conjecture. Retain the same notation as in the rest of the paper but suppose that Fis a CM number field4and write Lcyc for its cyclotomic extension. Denote by M0the maximal p-extension of Lcycwhich is unramified 4The Gross conjecture can actually be stated in greater gener ality, but we will not need this.52 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. and abelian over F, and by M' 0M0the maximal p-extension of Lcycwhich is totally split at every prime above pinLcycand abelian over F. Denote by k=F+the maximal totally real subfield of Fand bycthe non-trivial element of Gal( F/k). It acts upon Gal( M' 0/F), decomposing it as a direct sum Gal(M' 0/F) = Gross conjecture is Conjecture (Gross).The group finite. The original formulation of Gross conjecture as in [Gro81, Conject ure 1.15 and (1.21)] is proven to be equivalent to the above formulation5in [FG81, (6.6) and p. 457]. Lemma 4.13. LetFbe a CM field which is Galois over Qand which satisfies both the Leopoldt and the Gross conjectures. Suppose that L/Fis aZp-extension which is Galois over Qand is different from the cyclotomic Zp-extension Lcyc/F: the compositum Assume that a prime of Labovepis unramified in /tildewideL/L. Then every prime L'ofLabovepis infinite order in the group a prime of Labovepthat is unramified in /tildewideL/L, and let /tildewideLbe a prime of its restriction to its restriction to F. all the primes in Lcycabovep. The diagram of fields and primes is as follows: L F p Q The assumption that Lis Galois over Qimplies that Lis infinitely ramified because ramify at one, and hence at all primes above pinF. It also implies that /tildewideL/Qis Galois and therefore each prime L'ofLdividing pis unramified in /tildewideL/L, establishing the first part of the lemma. For the same reason, if we can prove that Frob( has infinite order, then the same is true for all other Frob( A similar argument shows that the splitting the same as that of Lcyc, for all 1<=i<=s. Suppose by Frob( L,/tildewideL/L) has finite order or, equivalently, that it is trivial in the group Gal( in particular, ( Lcyc)Lcyc(L)L= (L)Lor equivalently ( Lcyc)Lcyc (L)L. This means in particular that ( Lcyc)Lcyc= (L)Lsince Gal(( L)L/Fl)~=Zpdoes not 5We have made a small change of notation with respect to [FG81] : in particular, the field that we call cit. and the superscript ( -)c=-1is simply denoted ( -)-inloc. cit. These changes were forced by the fact that L0=Falready has a meaning in our work, and the ( -)--notation is normally used for than for OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 53 have any non-trivial quotient isomorphic to Zp. Then the extension totally split at Lcyc and hence, by the above considerations, it is totally split at each of t heL(i) cyc. This implies follow the same notation as in the above formulation of the Gross conjecture). By hypothesis, the totally real subfield kofFsatisfies the Leopoldt conjecture and hence admits so that Gal( = Gal(c=-1. The inclusion implies that Gal( M' 0/Lcyc)c=-1is infinite, because Gal( ~=Zp, violating the Gross conjecture. This provides the required contradiction and establishes the lemma. /square In the remainder of this section, we focus on some special cases to relate the invariant lfake appearing in Theorem 4.6 to the classical invariants lIw. Corollary 4.14. Suppose that k=Q, so that Fis an imaginary quadratic field and L/Fis Zp-extension of F. Then, with notation as in Proposition 0. In in F/Q lIw 2ifpdoes not split in F/Q and therefore lIwis odd if psplits in Fand it is even if pdoes not the formulae for l(0,Ox L*) andl(-1,Ox L*) are established, the formula for lfakeand the claim about its parity follow readily from Theorem 4.6. In the setting where k=QandFis imaginary quadratic, both conditions ( a) and (b) of Proposition 4.12 are satisfied. The equality l(0,Ox L*)+= 0 is proved Proposition 4.12-( b) and Proposition 4.12-( a) implies that (4.32) t(L/F) =lP+1. Assume first that pdoes not split in F/Q, sot(L/F) = 1. Then (4.32) reads 1 = lP+ 1, so lP=l+
P=l- P= 0 =t(L/Q)sand Proposition 4.10 gives 0, establishing the corollary in this case. Ifpsplits in F/Q, writepOF=pqand be the prime ideals of Lthat lie above p(resp. above q). LetLcycbe the cyclotomic SinceF/Qis abelian and totally imaginary, it satisfies the as- sumptions of Lemma 4.13 by [Gro81, Corollary 2.14] and [Was97, Coro llary 5.32]. Now, observe thatPis unramified in no totally ramified 4.13 implies that the global extension /tildewideL/Lis unramified everywhere, because it is clearly54 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. outside of p. Denoting by Mthe maximal abelian p-extension of Lwhich is unram- ified everywhere, we find the following diagram of fields and of Galois gr all 1<=j<=s, consider the Frobenius elements Frob( P(j),M/L) and Frob( Q(j),M/L) in X= Gal(M/L). conjugation: given 1 <=j<=s, for each tDand a lift ~ tGal(M/Q) we similarly when replacing P(j)byQ(j). On the one hand, this action becomes trivial on (mod H) and Frob( Q(j),M/L) (mod H) inY, because Gal( withDacting trivially on Y. On the other, the Dntr= Gal(Lntr/Q), one(and hence all) primes above p, because G ntracts trivially on all P(j),Q(j). Since Frob( P(j),M/L) (modH) = Frob( and similarly when replacing P(j)byQ(j), it follows that, in Y, the equality (4.33)/productdisplay jFrob(Frob(Q(j),/tildewideL/L) (mod H) = Frob( Having set this up, consider the 4.13 and (4.33) imply that x(modH) is the (2 s)th power of an element of infinite order, so it again has infinite order: in particular, xhas infinite order as element of X. Via the Artin map of global class field theory, xcorresponds to the inverse limit of the generators of P+
n: in particular, the be bounded, showing that l+
P>=1. Since t(L/F) = 2, (4.32) 1, and therefore we must have l+
P= 1, finishing the proof of the corollary. /square Remark 4.15.It has been shown in [HW18, Corollary 26] that, in some special cases ,uIw= 0 for the anticyclotomic extension of an field: in partic ular, in these cases, ufake= 0.COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 55 Finis and Hida (see [Fin06, Hid10] and the references therein) prove that, under mild anticyclotomic invariant uan Iwvanishes. As Hida and Tilouine observe in [HT94, SS1, Comment 4] the fact that their proof of the anticyclotomic main con jecture requires tensoring with Qprevents a direct comparison between uan IwanduIw. As it is clear from the proof of Corollary 4.14, the situation where pdoes not split in easier to consider. In particular, the full assumptions thatF/Qis imaginary quadratic is not needed, and we single out this case in the next 4.16. Suppose that Fis a CM field and that kis its totally real subfield. Assume that there is a unique prime above pinF/Q. thatlIwis even. Proof.By Proposition 4.12-( a), we have On the other hand, since there is a unique prime above pinF, the constant t(L/F) equals 1 and from the we 0. In particular, l- P= 0. Moreover, since the unique prime in kabovepdoes not split in F/k, we also have t(L/k)s= 0, so that Proposition 4.10 yields l(-1,Ox L*)+= 0. The result follows from Theorem 4.6. /square Remark 4.17.The parity result concerning the Iwasawa invariant lIwof the anticyclotomic Zp- extension of an imaginary quadratic field Fobtained in Corollary 4.14 is not new: it has already been found by Gillard in [Gil76, Th' eor` eme 2 and Th' eor` eme 1-Coro llaire], and by Carroll and Kisilevsky in [CK82, Theorem 5]. Moreover, Carroll and Kisilevsky obta inibid. a result similar to Corollary 4.16, which holds for more general semi-direct product s beyond the pro-dihedral case, although under the additional assumption that F/Qis abelian with Galois group of by ( FisaCMfield, 4.14 to more general number fields beyond the imaginary qu adratic case. As observed in Remark 4.19, its assumptions are satisfied when F/Qis 4.18. Suppose that F/Qis a CM field of degree 2d, and that kis its totally real subfield. Assume that psplits completely in F/Qand that L/Qis Galois. Then, with notation as in Proposition 4.10, (4.34) moreover, F/Qis Galois and satisfies both the Gross and the Leopoldt conjec tures, then hypotheses imply that t(L/F) = 2dandt(L/k)s= [k:Q] =d. ( a) of Proposition 4.12 is satisfied: we find (4.36) = 2d-lP-1.56 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO The formula of Theorem 4.6 becomes, through (4.36) and Propositio n the estimate (4.34) follows. Assume the Gross and the Leopoldt conjectures for Fand that F/Qis Galois: the estimate in case (c) of Proposition 4.12 reads l(0,Ox L*)+=d-1, which yields lP=dthrough (4.36). We now proceed to prove that l+
P>=1: this will imply both estimates l- P<=d-1 and (4.35). The proof goes along the same lines as those of Corollary 4.14. Denote by Gthe Galois group Gal( L/Q) and whereLcycis the cyclotomic Zp-extension of F. SinceF/Qis Galois, so is Lcyc/Q and the Galois group Gal( /tildewideL/Q) is the direct product GxGal(Lcyc/F). Write each prime qjis divided by the same number of primes in L/F, so its factorisation in L, for 1<=j<=2d. The localisations Fqjare all isomorphic to Qp, and hence admit no totally ramified Z2 p-extension, showing that in /tildewideL/Land so Lemma 4.13 guarantees that /tildewideLM, whereMis the of Lwhich is unramified everywhere. The diagram of fields is as groupGpermutes the ideals Q(i) jand acts trivially on Gal( /tildewideL/L), so the equivalent of (mod H) = Frob( as ibid.,Lntris such that L/Lntris totally ramified at all primes above p. The infinite order by Lemma 4.13 and corresponds, via the Artin map o f global class field theory, to an element in lim--P+
n. This shows lP+>=1, finishing the proof. /square Remark 4.19.In the proof of (4.34), the hypothesis that L/Qis Galois is only needed to ensure that all primes in Fabovepramify completely in L/Q, in order to apply Proposition 4.12-( c). In particular, the inequality holds also under this weaker assumption .COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 57 One condition that guarantees that all assumptions of Corollary 4.1 8 are satisfied is that the group Gal( F/Q) is abelian with exponent divisible by ( p-1): this is shown in [CK82, Theorem 1], together with the result that both the Gross and the Leopoldt con jectures hold for abelian The structure of the limits of class groups. As in the previous section, fix a fake Zp- extension of dihedral type K/kand adopt the conventions introduced in SS4.1. LetB= any of the five normic systems occurring either in the left column or in the bottom row of (3.1). As in SS3.2, setBL= lim--BKn, where the limit is taken with respect to iLm/Ln(resp. with respect to iKm/Kn). In this section we make no use of double systems: only direct and inve rse systems will appear. Indeed, the focus will be on the structure of direct and inverse limits, which are coarser one easily realises that the direct system of class group s with ideals extension as mor- phisms satisfies neither (Inj)nor(Gal), and the assumptions of Proposition 2.11 are not fulfilled, so itsGn-cohomology does not give rise to a double system fitting in a cohomolo gical long exact sequence. In fact, the analysis of the direct and inverse limits of cla ss groups relies on our previous work [CN20], and we need to consider morphisms between 0th Tate co homology groups which are different from the map defined in SS2.2.2, because of the factor pm-nappearing there. To define these morphisms, observe that, for m>=n0, NLm/Ln:ALm-ALnis surjective and so, by the arguments of Remark 2.8, we have and can therefore take direct limits with respect to these maps, and define the := and /hatwideH0(D,AL) := direct limits of finite D0-modules, these are s; moreover, via Propo- sition 4.2, they satisfy extending the isomorphisms ibid. fori>=1. More generally, in this section, we tacitly identify plus parts of all Gn-cohomology groups (resp. of all G-cohomology groups) with Dn-cohomology (resp. An Euler-Poincar' e formula for fake Zp-extensions of dihedral type. The main result of this section is Theorem 4.22, which can be seen as a relations hip between dihedral versions of Herbrand quotients of class groups and of units, at least in the lim it. This theorem will also be pivotal in the next section to interpret the invariant lfakeas the dimension of a Qp-vector the 4.20. There is an isomorphism of an exact the category Moreover, [NSW08, Definition I.1.9.3], the notation /hatwideH0(G,M) denotes a different construction, which we do not need, hence we allow ourselves this inconsistency.58 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO Proof.By Proposition 2.10, we have a commutative definition of given in Remark 2.8 makes it clear that (4.38) induces the commu- tative diagram
/hatwideH0(Dm,ALm)/hatwided(0)/d47/d47/hatwideH1(Dm,QLm)
/hatwideH0(Dn,ALn)/hatwided(0)/d47/d47/hatwideiLm/Ln/d79/d79
/hatwideH1(Dn,QLn)/d79/d79 From [CN20, Proposition 3.4], the rows of the above diagram are isomo rphisms, and so by taking limits we obtain the first statement of the as in the proof of [CN20, Proposition 3.4], we get an exact seq its plus Proposition 4.2, this exact sequence can be shortened as (4.39) is the morphism analysed in Remark 4.11. As shown ibid., is bounded independently of n, and taking direct limits of (4.39) we obtain the exact sequence of the final isomorphism, an argumentsimilar to the one use d to prove the commutativ- ity of the left-hand diagram of Lemma 3.5 shows that the direct syst em (/hatwideH2(Dn,CLn),) isisomorphicto( finishing the proof. /square Remark 4.21.The proof of the above proposition actually shows that there is an e xact the category Since we are only interested in comparing coranks of divisible Zp-modules, here and in what follows we content ourselves to work in We can now proceed to the proof of the main result of this section, t hat we regard as an Euler- Poincar' e formula: Theorem 4.22. Given a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type K/kwith normal closure L/k, = OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 59 Proof.Taking direct limits in (3.28) we obtain the exact sequence in construction, the rightmost morphism is the image, in the quotient category, of the direct limit of the morphisms It follows that we can complete the above sequence the final 0 is a consequence of G having strict cohomological d imension equal to 2. By taking plus parts we get, through Corollary = cork by Proposition = = cork the proof. /square 4.4.2. Interpretation of lfake.Let L = Zp[[G]] denote the Iwasawa algebra of the group G =
Gal(L/F). In this section we show that the invariant lfakeobtained in Theorem 4.6 is also the dimension of the Qp-vector space XfakeZpQp, where Xfake= lim--AKn, the inverse limit being taken with respect to norms. The analogous re sult for lfake) is well-known and comes from the structure theorem for finitely ge nerated together with a classical descent argument (see [Iwa73 ,SS1.2 and Theorem 7]). Since Xfakeis not stabilized by G, and hence it is not a L-submodule of XIw, we argue in a different way. Our approach is to work with direct, rather than inverse, limits beca use they are easier to analyse in our setting. We then recover the result about inverse limits via a pu rely algebraic argument due to the exact sequence [CN20, (3.1)] with Zp, we obtain (4.40) 1 the map enis defined via the formula en(c,c') for cAKn,c'AK'n. The explicit definition of enmakes it evident that, for m>=n, the relations (4.41) We can therefore take direct limits with respect to the extens ion maps to obtain an 1 lim--en.60 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO The first step of our strategy is to interpret, in Lemmas 4.23 and 4.2 4, Kereand Coker ein terms of the cohomology groups of AL. We then invoke Theorem 4.22 to compare their coranks. Lemma 4.23. The modules from [CN20, Proposition 3.2] the isomorphism, called thibid., is defined by sending ( Hence, the diagram for showing that (4.43) Ker e~=H0(D,AL). The definition of Tate cohomology groups gives another commutativ e diagram 0 /d47/d470 0 the exact groups Nm DnALnhave bounded order their direct limit is certainly a finite group. We conclude using (4.43). /square Lemma 4.24. The modules in the proof of [CN20, Proposition 3.2], Remark 3.1 ibid. yields the exact actually have commutative diagrams, for m>=n>=0, 0 /d47/d470 0 OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 61 By [CN20, (2.7)] and by definition of (see SS2.2.1), this can be rewritten as 0 /d47/d470 0 /d47/d47/hatwideH-1(Gn,ALn)-/d79/d79
/d47/d47CokereniLm/Ln/d79/d79 NmGn/d47/d47NmGn(ALn)/NmGn(Imen)pm-niLm/Ln/d79/d79
/d47/d470 Moreover, the cup product with kninduces an isomorphism and by definition of , together with Lemma 2.7, the diagram becomes 0 /d47/d470 0 groups on the right have bounded order since |NmGnALn|<=|AF|, by the same argument as at the end of the proof of Lemma 4.23. Taking direct limits we obtain th e statement. /square Combined with Theorem 4.22, the above lemmas yield the 4.25. We corkKer e-corkCoker the invariants defined in Corollary 4.4-ii ). Proof.From the exact sequence (4.42), we corkKer e-corkCoker e (Lemmas 4.23 and 4.24) = cork 4.22) = cork 2.32 and Corollary 4.4- ii) ) /square We are now in shape to relate the invariant lfaketo theZp-module structure of Xfake, but we first need a final lemma: Lemma 4.26. The dim QpXIwZpQpand corkAK= dim first equality can be deduced from [Iwa73, Theorem 11]. Here w e give an following that of [Yam84, Lemma 2], which also yields the second a finitely generated torsion L-module, we know, by the structure theorem of such modules, that there exists bNsuch that pbXIwis a finitely generated torsion L-module Since pbXIw= lim--pbALn, we deduce that the Zp-ranks of pbALnare bounded and thus so are those of pbAKn. As arithmetic norms are eventually surjective on ALn, to pbALnis also eventually surjective, and likewise when restrictingto pbAKn. Similarly,62 L. CAPUTO AND F. A. E. NUCCIO the kernel of the extension map restricted to pbALnhas bounded order and, again, the same holds when restricting to pbAKn. We can therefore apply [Yam84, Lemma 1] to obtain that cork(pbAL) = dim Qp(pbXIwZpQp) and cork( pbAK) = dim concludes the proofbecause, for every Zp-module M, dimQp(pbMZpQp) = dim Qp(MZpQp) and cork( pbM) = corkM. /square Finally, we obtain the main result of this section. Theorem 4.27. Given a fake Zp-extension of dihedral type K/k, we have lfake= dim the structure theorem of finitely generated L-modules, we kno w that (4.44) dim using Theorem 4.6, we 4.4-(4.9) and -(4.4)) = (4.44)) = dim 4.26) = cork 4.25) = 2cork AK (Lemma 4.26) = 2dim Atiyah, M.F. ;Wall, C.T.C. Cohomology of groups. Algebraic Number Theory (Proc. Instr uctional Conf., Brighton, 1965), (Thompson, Washington, D.C.1967) 94-115 . MR0219512 Zbl 1494.20079 3.2 [Bou61] Bourbaki, N. 'El' ements de math' ematique. Fascicule XXVII. Alg` ebre com mutative. Chapitre 1: Modules plats. Chapitre 2: Localisation. Actualit' es Scientifique s et Industrielles, No. 1290, (Herman, Paris 1961). MR0217051 Zbl 0108.04002 3.1 [CK82] Carroll, J. ;Kisilevsky, H. On Iwasawa's l-invariant for certain Zl-extensions. Acta Arith. 40(1) (1981/82) 1-8. MR0654019 Zbl 0517.12003 1, 4.17, 4.19 [CN20] Caputo, L. ;Nuccio Mortarino Majno di Capriglio, F.A.E. Class number formula for dihedral Math. J. 62(2) (2020) 323-353. MR4085046 Zbl 1450.11117 1, 1, 4.1, 4.2, 4.2, 4.2, 4.4, 4.4.1, 4.4.2, 4.4.2, 4.4.2 [FG81] Federer, L.J. ;Gross, B.H. Regulators and Iwasawa modules. Invent. Math. 62(3) (1981) Zbl 0468.12005 4.3, 5 [Fin06] Finis, T. Theu-invariant of anticyclotomic L-functions of imaginary quadratic fields. J. Reine Angew. Math. 596(2006) 131-152. MR2254809 Zbl 1111.11048 4.15 [Gab62] Gabriel, P. Des cat' egories ab' eliennes. Bull. Soc. Math. France 90(1962) 323-448. MR0232821 Zbl 0201.35602 2.3, 2.3, 2.3, 2.3 [Gil76] Gillard, R. Remarques sur certaines extensions prodi' edrales de corps de nombres. C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris S' er. A-B 282(1) (1976) A13-A15. MR0392910 Zbl 0335.12017 1, 4.17 [Gre73] Greenberg, R. On a certain l-adic representation. Invent. Math. 21(1973) 117-124. MR0335468 Zbl 0268.12004 1 [Gro57] Grothendieck, A. Sur quelques points d'alg` ebre homologique. T^ ohoku Math. J. (2) 9(1957) Zbl 0118.26104 2.2, 2.2, 2.3 [Gro81] Gross, B.H. p-adicL-series at s= 0.J. Fac. Sci. Univ. Tokyo Sect. IA Math. 28(3) (1981) 979-994 Zbl 0507.12010 4.3, 4.3 [Hid10] Hida, H. The Iwasawa u-invariant of p-adic Hecke L-functions. Ann. of Math. (2) 172(1) (2010) Zbl 1223.11131 4.15COHOMOLOGY OF NORMIC SYSTEMS AND FAKE Zp-EXTENSIONS 63 [HT94] Hida, H. ;Tilouine, J. On the anticyclotomic main conjecture for CM fields. Invent. Math. 117(1) (1994) 89-147. MR1269427 Zbl 0819.11047 4.15 [HW18] Hubbard, D. ;Washington, L.C. Iwasawa invariants of some non-cyclotomic Zp-extensions. J. 18-47. MR3778621 Zbl 1455.11147 4.15 [Iwa73] Iwasawa, K. OnZl-extensions of algebraic number fields. Ann. Math. (2) 98(1973) 246-326. MR0349627 Zbl 0285.12008 4.4.2, 4.4.2 [Iwa81] ----. Riemann-Hurwitz formula and p-adic Galois representations for number fields. Tohoku Math. J. (2) 33(1981) 263-288. MR0624610 Zbl 0468.12004 1 [Iwa83] ----. On cohomology groups of units for Zp-extensions. Amer. J. Math. 105(1) (1983) 189-200. MR0692110 Zbl 0525.12009 1, 3.2, 3.12 [Jau81] Jaulent, J.F. Th' eorie d'Iwasawa des tours m' etabeliennes. Seminar on Number Theory , 1980-1981, 21, 1-16, (Univ. Bordeaux I, Talence 1981) MR0644654 Zbl 0482.1 2007 1, 4.7 [Mik87] Miki, H. On the Leopoldt conjecture on the p-adic regulators. J. Number Theory 26(2) (1987) Zbl 0621.12009 4.3 [NSW08] Neukirch, J. ;Schmidt, A. ;Wingberg, K. Cohomology of number fields, Grundlehren der Mathe- matischen Wissenschaften , volume 323. Second edition, Berlin 200 8). MR2392026 Zbl 1136.11001 2.1, 2.2.3, 2.6, 2.6, 2.2.4, 6 [Nuc10] Nuccio Mortarino Majno di Capriglio, F.A.E. Cyclotomic units and class groups in Zp-extensions of real abelian fields. Math. Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 148(1) (2010) 93-106. MR2575375 Zbl 1279.11108 1, 3.2, 4.2 [Oza95] Ozaki, M. A note on the capitulation in Zp-extensions. Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A Math. Sci. 71(9) (1995) 218-219. MR1373385 Zbl 0857.11064 3.2 [Rot09] Rotman, J. An introduction to homological algebra. Universitext, sec ond edition, (Springer, New York 2009). MR2455920 Zbl 1157.18001 2.15 [Ser62] Serre, J.P. Corps locaux, Publications de l'Institut de Math' ematique de l'Universi t' e de Nancago 8. Actu- alit' es Scientifiques et Industrielles , volume 1296, (Hermann, Paris 1962). MR0150130 Zbl 0137.02 601 3.2, 3.2 [Ser67] ----. Local class field theory. Algebraic Number Theor y (Proc. Instructional Conf., Brighton, Washington, D.C. 1967) 128-161. MR0220701 Zbl 1 492.11158 3.1 [Tat67] Tate, J. Global class field theory. Algebraic Number Theory (Proc. In structional Conf., Brighton, Washington, D.C. 1967) 162-203. MR0220697 Zbl 1 179.11041 3.1, 3.1 [Vau09] Vauclair, D. Sur la dualit' e et la descente d'Iwasawa. Ann. Inst. Fourier 59(2) (2009) 691-767. MR2521434 Zbl 1254.11098 1, 2.2 [Was97] Washington, L.C. Introduction to cyclotomic fields, Graduate Texts in Mathematics , volume 83. Second edition, New York 1997). MR1421575 Zbl 0 966.11047 4.3, 4.3 [Wei59] Weiss, E. A deflation map. J. Math. Mech. 8(1959) 309-329. MR0132090 Zbl 0086.02303 1, 2.9 [Yam84] Yamashita, H. The second cohomology groups of the group of units of a Zp-extension. T^ ohoku Math. J. (2)36(1) (1984) 75-80. MR0733620 Zbl 0539.12006 1, 'e Jean Monnet Saint- 'Etienne, CNRS UMR 5208, Institut Camille Jordan, F-42023 Sain
|
0807.1135
|
Filippo Alberto Edoardo Nuccio Mortarino Majno di Capriglio
|
Luca Caputo, Filippo A. E. Nuccio
|
Cohomology of normic systems and fake Z_p extensions
|
55 pages. The original preprint has been split up in two articles,
the first being arXiv:1803.04064. This work is the second one, focusing on
fake $\mathbb{Z}_p$-extensions
|
New York Journal of Mathematics 29 (2023), 1196-1272
| null | null |
math.NT
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
|
We set up a general framework to study Tate cohomology groups of Galois
modules along $\mathbb{Z}_p$-extensions of number fields. Under suitable
assumptions on the Galois modules, we establish the existence of a five-term
exact sequence in a certain quotient category whose objects are simultaneously
direct and inverse systems, subject to some compatibility. The exact sequence
allows one, in particular, to control the behaviour of the Tate cohomology
groups of the units along $\mathbb{Z}_p$-extensions. As an application, we
study the growth of class numbers along what we call "fake
$\mathbb{Z}_p$-extensions of dihedral type". This study relies on a previous
work, where we established a class number formula for dihedral extensions in
terms of the cohomology groups of the units.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 7 Jul 2008 22:07:13 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Sun, 10 May 2009 12:48:34 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Thu, 18 Nov 2021 09:22:00 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Mon, 4 Dec 2023 14:03:47 GMT"
}
] | 2023-12-05T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Caputo",
"Luca",
""
],
[
"Nuccio",
"Filippo A. E.",
""
]
] |
- 2 - 1. the past 25 years, observations from IRAS,ISO, andSpitzerhave revealed sub- stantial mid-infrared (mid-IR) excesses associated with hundred s of normal main sequence stars (e.g., Backman & Paresce 1993; Habing et al. 2001; Rieke et al. 2005; Bryden et al. 2006; Mo' or et al. 2006; Rhee et al. 2007a). Current samples includ e stars with spectral types A-M and ages ~5 Myr to ~10 Gyr (e.g., Chen et al. 2005; Kim et al. 2005; Rieke et al. 2005; Beichman et al. 2006; Su et al. 2006; Hillenbrand et a l. 2008). et al. 2005;Su et al. 2006;Bryden e t al. 2006;Gorlova et al. 2006; Currie et al. 2007a; Siegler et al. 2007; Trilling et al. 2007), the frequency of excess emission declines from ~30%-40% for A-type stars (Su et al. 2006) to ~10%-20% for solar-type stars (Greaves & Wyatt 2003; Trilling et al. 2008; Meyer et al. 2008). Thus, this phenomenon is common among main sequence stars and may depe nd on stellar mass. High quality images demonstrate that dust orbiting the central sta r produces the ex- cesses (Smith & Terrile 1984; Brandeker et al. 2004; Stapelfeldt et al. 2004; Kalas 2005; Meyer et al. 2007). In bPic and AU Mic, the dust is in a geometrically thin, edge-on disk with an outer radius of a~200-1000 AU (Smith & Terrile 1984; Telesco et al. 1988; Golimowski et al. 1993; Kalas et al. 2004; Liu 2004; Augereau & Beust 2006). In these disks, the small scale height of the dust, H/a~0.1, is consistent with material in roughly circular orbits (e.g., Backman & Paresce 1993; Kalas et al. 2004, and references broad tori of dust are visible in many other systems (e.g. G reaves et al. 1998; Augereau et al. 1999;Holland et al. 2003;Kalas et al. 2006;Su et al. 2 006;Fitzgerald et et al. 1998; Schneider et al. 1999; Greaves et al. 2000; Telesco et al. 200 0; Kalas et al. 2005). For systems with face-onrings andtori, the total emission constr ains the scale height, H/a~
0.1. Thus, the dust in these systems is as highly flattened as the str uctures in bPic and spectral energy distributions constrain the luminosity , size, temperature, and total mass of the dust (Backman & Paresce 1993; Lagrange e t al. 2000; Dent et al. 2000; Wolf & Hillenbrand 2003). Some stars have excesses from gra ins plausibly associ- ated with the terrestrial zone (e.g., Beichman et al. 2005; Absil et a l. 2006; Currie et al. 2007b; Rhee et al. 2007b; Meyer et al. 2008; Lisse et al. 2007c). Op tically thin emission from cooler material with temperature T~20-150 K is more typical (e.g. Su et al. 2006; Trilling et al. 2008; Hillenbrand et al. 2008). For systems with submm ob servations, the measured fluxes suggest grainswithsizes ~0.01M (Liu et al. 2004; Najita & Williams 2005; Chen et al. 2006; Williams & Andrews 2006). The grains- 3 - have compositions similar to dust in the asteroid belt, comets, or the trans-Neptunian un et al. 1995;Brownlee et al. 1997;Lisse e t al. 2007a,b). Because the dust mass in these systems lies between the initial mass of solids in protostellar disks (~100-1000 M ; Natta et al. 2000; Andrews & Williams 2005) and the dust mass in the Solar System ( Hahn et al. 2002; Landgraf et al. 2002; Nesvorn' y et al. 2006), the dusty structures in these systems are often called 'debris disk s' (Backman & Paresce 1993; Lagrange et al. 2000). In addition to the dust properties, several other observations s uggest plausible links be- tween debris disks and the formationof planetary systems. Obser vations of A-type stars sug- gest a 'rise and fall' of debris disk emission (Currie et al. 2008a), with a clear increase in the typical 24 umexcess at5-10Myr, apeakat10-20Myr, andadeclinefor The rise in debris disk emission roughly coincides with the disappearance of optically thick emis- sion from protostellar disks (e.g. Haisch, Lada, & Lada 2001; Sicilia-A guilar et al. 2006; Hern' andez et al. 2006; Currie et al. 2007a,c). The broad plateau o ccurs at a time when ra- diometric dating (Yin et al. 2002) and theory (Chambers 2001; Keny on & Bromley 2006) suggest the Earth contained ~90% of its final mass. The decline of dusty debris around A- type stars is at roughly the same time as a gradual decrease in the c ratering rate of objects in the Solar System (Swindle 1993; Melosh, Vickery, & Tonks 1993; Wad hwa & Russell 2000; Koeberl 2003). These results suggest that the evolution of dust in debris disks parallels the evolution of larger solid objects in the Solar radiation removes 1-100 um grains on timescales shorter than the stellar age, some process replenishes the dust. To maintain the observed dust mass es for long stars must have a large reservoir, ~10-100 M , of unseen objects that at large velocities and fragment into smaller objects. Remnant material from planet formation satisfies both needs. The growth of 1000 km or larger pla nets in a disk of small grains naturally leaves behind an ensemble of 'leftover' 1-10 km 'plane tesimals' on eccentric orbits (Kenyon & Bromley 2004a, 2004b). For a mass of ~10-100 M in leftovers, ckman & Paresce 1993; Habing et al. 2001;Kenyon & Bromley 2004b). iscorrect, conclusive evidence for the formation of Pluto-mass or larg er planets around many, if not most, main sequence stars. In addition to these considerations, numerical calculations sugges t that an evolving swarm of 1-10 km planetesimals explains several observed trends in the properties of de- bris disks. Starting with an ensemble of /lessorsimilar1 km-sized planetesimals, Kenyon & Bromley (2002b, 2004a, b, 2005) show that collisions and mergers form 500 -1000 km-sized objects- 4 - in 1-50 Myr. These protoplanets stir up leftover planetesimals along their orbits. De- structive collisions among the leftovers then produce a collisional ca scade - where col- lisions gradually grind large objects into smaller ones - along with copiou s amounts of dust (see also Williams & Wetherill 1994; Durda & Dermott 1997; Quillen e t al. 2007). Dominik & Decin (2003), Wyatt et al. (2007a), and L ohne et al. (200 8) show that colli- sional evolution in a belt of high velocity planetesimals naturally produc es a dust luminosity that declines roughly inversely with time (see also Kenyon & Bromley 20 02a, 2004b, the observed time evolution - Ldt-n, withn0.5-1 - suggested by re- cent observations of A-type stars (e.g., Kalas 1998; Habing et al. 2 001; Decin et al. 2003; Greaves & Wyatt 2003; Rieke et al. 2005; Rhee et al. 2007a). To acc ount for the large ob- served range of IR excesses among stars of similar ages, Wyatt et al. (2007a) propose belts with a range of initial masses and semimajor axes, as suggested fro m submm observations of protostellar disks (Andrews & Williams 2005, 2007b). Here, we continue to explore the evolution of dusty debris arising fr om planet formation in a disk of icy planetesimals. Our suite of calculations for disks at 30-1 50 AU around 1- 3 Mstars yields robust predictions for the maximum sizes of icy planets a s a function of semimajor axis and stellar age. Results for the long-term evolution o f IR excesses account for many fundamental aspects of the data. These calculations ar e the first to explain the 'rise and fall of debris disks' around A-type stars (Currie et al. 2008a) and the apparent peak in the 70-160 um excesses of G-type stars with ages of ~100 Myr (Hillenbrand et al. between our models and current observations sugge st that the minimum stable grain size and the slope of the IR emissivity law are critical parameter s. The models suggest a set of further critical observations. Spatia lly resolved images of debris disks around A-type and solar-type stars can improve ou r understanding of the minimum stable grain size. Larger samples of debris disks with high qualit y submm data fromALMA, Herschel, and SOFIA can place better constraints on t he slope of the emissivity law. Together, these data can test our predictions for the time ev olution of debris disk emission around 1-3 M stars and provide input for more complete calculations that include the formation and dynamical evolution of giant SS2. SS3and the evolution of debris disks in SS4. After discussing several applications of our we conclude with a brief summary in SS6.- 5 - 2. THE MODEL Kenyon & Bromley (2001, 2002a, 2004a, 2004c) and Bromley & Keny on (2006) de- scribe our hybrid multiannulus numerical model for planetesimal gro wth. Kenyon & Luu (1998, 1999), Kenyon & Bromley (2001, 2002a), and Bromley & Ken yon (2006) compare results with analytical and numerical calculations. We adopt the Saf ronov (1969) ofplane tesimals inorbitaround a star of mass M(see also Spaute et al. 1991; Weidenschilling et al. 1997; Krivov et al. 2006; Th' ebault & Augereau 2007; L ohne et al. 2008). The model grid contains Ncon- centric annuli with widths daicentered at semimajor axes ai. Calculations begin with a differential mass distribution n(mik) of objects with horizontal and vertical velocities hik(t) andvik(t) relative to a circular orbit. The horizontal velocity is related to the orbital ec- centricity, e2 ik(t) = 1.6 ( hik(t)/VK,i)2, whereVK,iis the circular orbital velocity in annulus i. The orbital inclination depends on the vertical velocity, i2 ik(t) = mass andvelocity distributions evolve intimedue to inelastic collision s, dragforces, and gravitational forces. For inelastic collisions, we solve the coagu lation equations for a particle in mass batch kof annulus icolliding with another particle in mass batch (1) dMi'k'=dt (2) wheretis time,Mi'k'is the total mass in mass bin k'in annulus i',Aijklis the 1/2 fori=jandk=l, andoijkl= 1 any i,j. The terms in these equations represent (i) mergers of mikandmjlinto a body of mass loss of mi'k'through mergers with other objects, (iii) addition of mass from deb & Luu 1999),a & Luu 1998). Ineachequation, can produce debris but no merger (rebounds; see Davis et a l. 1985; Kenyon & Luu 1999, and references therein). The collision cross-section & Stewart 1993;Kenyon & Luu 1998), two interacting annuli, the average angular velocity, Vijklis the relative par- ticle velocity, Fg,ijklis the gravitational focusing factor, and rikandrjlare the particle radii.- 6 - We adopt the piecewise analytic approximation of Spaute et al. (1991 ) for the factor in the dispersion regime and the collisional cross-se ctions of Greenberg et al. (1991) in the shear-dominated regime (see also Greenzweig & Lissau er 1990, 1992). For more details of this algorithm, see Kenyon & Luu (1998), Kenyon & Br omley (2002a), Kenyon & Bromley (2004a), and Bromley & Kenyon (2006). To choose among possible collision outcomes, we use an energy-scalin g algorithm. If Q*
d is the collision energy needed to eject half the mass of a pair of colliding planetesimals and Qcis the center of mass collision energy, the mass of the ejecta is me,ijkl= 0.5 the masses of the colliding planetesimals. This approach allows us t o derive ejected masses for catastrophic collisions with Qc~Q*
dand cratering collisions with QcQ*
d(see also Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Stern & Colwell 1997; Kenyon & L uu with N-body simulations of collision outcomes (e.g., Benz & A sphaug 1999), (5) whererijklis the radius of a merged object with mass mik+mjl,rgis the mass density of a planetesimal, Qbrbbis the bulk component of the binding energy, and Qgrgrbgis the of the binding energy. Kenyon & Bromley (2005) and Kenyon et al. (2008) describe how collis ional on various choices for Q*
d. For icy objects, detailed numerical collision g erg cm3-bg g-2, andbg1-2 (e.g., Benz & Asphaug 1999; Leinhardt et al. 2008). Calculations for the breakup of comet Shoemaker-Levy 9 suggest a smaller compon ent of the bulk g-1(e.g., Asphaug & Benz 1996), which yields smaller disruption energies for smaller objects. Because nearly all models for collisional disrupt ion yield similar results for objects with km (e.g., Kenyon & Bromley 2004c; Kenyon et al. 2008), is relatively independent of these uncertainties as planete simals grow into larger objects. Thus, we choose standard values - Qg= 1.5 erg cm1.75g-2,rg= 1.5 g cm-3, and bg= 1.25 - for the gravity component of Q*
d. To check how the evolution of the depends on Q*
d, we consider a broad range in the bulk component of the strength, Qb= 1-105erg g-1withbb= 0 (Pan & Sari 2005; Kenyon & Bromley 2004c, 2005; Kenyon et al. 2008). To compute velocity evolution, we include collisional damping from inelas tic collisions, gas drag, and gravitational interactions. Our equations for the e volution of the velocity- 7 - dispersion the horizontal component the vertical component, where the subscripts refer to the c ontributions from ('in'), gas drag ('gd'), and long-range ('lr') and short-range ('sr') collisional damping, we and rjlis the volume density of planetesimals with mass mjlin annulus j(Ohtsuki 1992; Wetherill & Stewart 1993). In the second summation, also Kenyon & Luu 1998, 1999). We add a term, fijkl, to treat the overlap between adjacent zones; fijkl= 1 when i=jandfijkl<=1 j (Kenyon & Bromley 2001). The integrals IeandIiare elliptic integrals described in previous & Stewart 1993; Stewart & Ida 2000; Ohtsuki, Stewart , & Ida 2002). For velocity damping from gas drag, we follow Wetherill & Stewart (19 93) and (11) whereCD= 0.5 is the drag coefficient, the gas density, eis the relative gas velocity, and Vgas= the mean relative velocity of the gas (see Adachi et al. 1976; Weidenschilling 1977b; Wetherill & Stewart 1 993). For gravitational interactions, we compute long-range stirring fr om distant 1989) and short-range stirring from the swarm (Oh tsuki, Stewart, & Ida- 8 - 2002). The long-range stirring only has a horizontal continuum objects individual oligarchs, where xijklis the fraction of objects with mass mikin annulus i that approach no closer than 2.4 RHof the objects with mass mlin annulus 0.5 23.5, and C' lr,e= 5.9 (see also Kenyon & Bromley 2001). For short-range gravitational interactions, the stirring depend s on the ratio of the rela- tive collision velocity to the mutual Hill velocity, vH (14) In the high velocity regime, the collision velocity exceeds the Hill velocit y. Statistical solu- tions to the Fokker-Planck equation then yield accurate estimates for the stirring rates (e.g., Hornung et al. 1985; Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Stewart & Ida 2000 ; Kenyon & Bromley 2001). Atlowvelocities, WefollowOhtsuki, Stewa rt, & Ida (2002) and write the stirring as the sum of rates in the two Eq. (25)ofOhtsuki, Stewart, & & Ida 2000;K enyon & (17)- 9 fraction of objects with mass mikin annulus ithat approach within 2.4 RH of the objects with mass mjlin annulus jandChigh= In the expression for Chigh,AL= ln (L2+1) and L (h2 ik+h2 jl+ 1.25 (v2 ik+v2 jl)) (19) The functions He,Hz,Je, andJzare definite integrals defined in Stewart & Ida (2000). In the low velocity regime, the evolution equations are (Ohtsuki, Ste wart, & Ida (21) where the kh's are simple functions of the Hill (22) and the normalized eccentricity and inclination (Ohtsuki, Stewart, & Ida 2002, see also Ida 1990; Ida & Makino 1992). For the low velocity limit of the horizontal v elocity kh1= 73C1r4 H,ijkl (24) For the low velocity limit of the vertical velocity kh3= (25) and kh4= (26) Here,Clow= ~e2 ij= The constants C1,C2, andC3are identical to those in Eq. (26) of Ohtsuki, Stewart, & Ida (2002).- 10 - Several tests indicate that these expressions provide an accura te treatment of Figs. 5- 7ofOhtsuki, Stewart, & 1990;Ida & Makino 1992). Weidenschilling et al. (199 7)andKenyon & Goldreich, Lithwick, & Sari (2004) demonstrate that our numerical results agree with analyt ic estimates. To follow the evolution of the most massive objects more accurately , our code algorithm. When objects have masses exceeding a 'promotion mass'mpro, we promote them into an n-body code that directly solves their orbits. The n-body code incor- porates algorithms to allow collisions among n-bodies and interactions between n-bodies and coagulation particles. Bromley & Kenyon (2006) describe this code in detail. Because dy- namical interactions among large oligarchs are rare and occur at lat e stages in the evolution, we setmpro= 1026g. We describe several test calculations with smaller rgas, model with gas surface density S gas(a,t) = gas-to-solids ratio S gas,0(a)/S(a) =
100 - where S is the surface density of solids, and scale height Hgas(a) & Hartmann 1987). To approximate gas removal on a times caletgas, the gas density declines exponentially with time. We set tgas= 10 Myr. During the early stages of calculations at 30-150 AU, velocity damping is important for partic les m. However, particle losses fromgasdrag aresmall, ~1%or less ofthe initial mass. By thetime viscous stirring dominates the velocity evolution of small objects, t he gas disk has drift and velocity damping are then negligible (see also Wether ill & Stewart 1993). The initial conditions for these calculations are appropriate for a dis k with an age Myr (e.g. Dullemond & Dominik 2005; Nomura & Nakagawa 2006; Cies la 2007; Garaud 2007). We consider systems of Nannuli in disks with ai= 30-150 AU and dai/ai
= 0.025. The disk is composed of small planetesimals with radii of ~1-1000 m and an initial mass distribution ni(mik) in each annulus. The mass ratio between adjacent bins is d=mik+1/mik= 1.4-2. At the start of the calculations, each bin has the same tota l e0= 1-3x10-4, and inclination i0=e0/2. We assume a power law variation of the initial surface density of solid material with semimajor axis, Si= (27) wherexmis a scaling factor. For a 1 Mcentral star, models with S 00.1-0.2 g cm-2 ata0= 30 AU have a mass in icy solids comparable to the minimum mass solar neb ula (MMSN hereafter; Weidenschilling 1977a; Hayashi 1981). Consiste nt with observations of disks surrounding pre-main sequence stars (e.g., Natta et al. 2000 ; Scholz et al. 2006), we scale the reference surface density with the stellar mass, S 0(M) = 0.18 ( M/M) g cm-2.- 11 - Table1 liststhe rangesin Mandxmwe consider. The tablealso tms, defined as the time to reach core hydrogen exhaustion in the X= 0.71,Y=
0.27, and Z= 0.02 stellar evolution models of Demarque et al. (2004), where Xis the initial mass fraction of hydrogen, Yis the mass fraction of helium, and Zis the metallicity. For most of our calculations, the number of annuli in the disk is N= 64. To check these results, we also calculated models for disks with N= 32 around 1 Mstars. Because the growth of planets has large stochastic variations, we repeated the calculatio ns 5-12 times for each set of starting conditions, M,N,xm, andQb. Table 1 lists the number of calculations for each (M,xm) pair. Our calculations follow the time evolution of the mass and velocity distr ibutions of objects with a range of radii, The upper limit rmaxis always larger than the largest object in each annulus. To save computer time in ou r main calculation, we do not consider small objects which do not affect significantly the dy namics and growth of larger objects, rmin= 100 cm. Erosive collisions produce objects with rik< rminwhich are 'lost' to the model grid. Lost objects are more likely to be ground do wn into smaller objects than to collide with larger objects in the grid (see Kenyon & Bromley 20 02a, 2004a). To estimate the amount of dusty debris produced by planet format ion, we perform a second calculation. Each main calculation yields .Mi(t), the amount of mass lost to the grid per annulus per timestep, and Hi0(t), the scale height of the smallest particle ( r=rmin) in each annulus of the coagulation grid. Objects with sizes smaller than rmincontain a small fraction of the mass in each annulus; thus, the scale height for obj ects with r < Lithwick, & Sari 2004). The total amount of mass lost f rom the in each timestep is .M(t) The debris has a known size wherebis a constant (see Stern & Colwell 1997; Kenyon & Luu 1999, and references therein). The normalization constant n' i0depends only on band.M(t), which we derive at each timestep in the main calculation. To evolve the dust dist ribution in time, we use a simple collision algorithm that includes dr ag and The optical depth tof the dust follows from integrals over the size distribution in each annulus. The optical depth and a radiative transfer solution t hen yield the luminosity and radial surface brightness of the dust as a function of time. Ke nyon & Bromley (2004a) describe this calculation in more the text, we use simple scaling relations to show how our results depend on initial conditions and the properties of the grid. For each set of calc ulations (Table 1), we derive median results for the size distribution, the size of the larges t object as a function of a 1Because the collisional cascade begins after the gas disk dissipates , we ignore gas drag.- 12 - andt, and other physical variables. Substituting the inter-quartile ran ge for the dispersion, we then perform least-squares fits to relate these median results to input parameters (e.g., xm) and the properties of the grid (e.g., a). For parameters where analytic theory predicts a relation (e.g., the growth time as a function of a), we derive the best-fitting coefficient, test whether different fitting functions provide better fits to our resu lts, and keep the result that minimizes kh2per degree of freedom. When analytic theory provides no guidance , we derive fitting functions that yield the sensitivity of our results to all import ant physical variables. Thus, our fits test some aspects of analytic theory and guide othe r aspects. 3. PLANET FORMATION Icy Planet Formation in Disks around 1 MStars We begin with a discussion of planet formation in disks at 30-150 AU aro und a 1M star. For most disks around low mass stars, the timescale for plane t formation is shorter than the main sequence lifetime. Thus, the growth of planetesimals in to planets and the outcome of the collisional cascade depend more on the physics of so lid objects than on stellar physics. Here, we review the stages in planet growth and des cribe the outcome of the collisional cascade. For a suite of calculations of planet formatio n in disks of we derive basic relations for the growth time and the maximu m planet mass as a function of initial disk mass. We also show how the dust production ra te and the mass in small objects depend on initial disk mass and time. The next section compares these results with calculations for 1.5-3 Mstars. For disks around more massive stars, the planet formation timescale is compa rable to the main se- quence lifetime. Thus, the central star evolves off the main sequen ce before planet formation and the collisional cascade reach a natural end-state. During pos t-main sequence evolution, the star brightens considerably (e.g., Demarque et al. 2004) and de velops a powerful stellar wind (e.g., Knapp & Morris 1985, and references therein), melting icy objects in the inner disk and ejecting small grains throughout the disk. Thus, we halt ou r calculations when the star evolves off the main sequence. Here, we show how the physics o f main sequence stars changes the results derived for planet formation around 1 M stars. 3.1.1. Growth of Large Objects The formation of icy planets in the outer regions of a quiescent plane tesimal disk has three distinct stages (Kenyon & Luu 1999; Kenyon & Bromley 2004a ). Planetesimals with- 13 km grow slowly. As they grow, dynamical friction damps efor the largest objects; dy- namical friction and viscous stirring raise efor the smallest objects (e.g., Greenberg et al. 1984; Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Goldreich, Lithwick, & Sari 2004). After~0.1-1 focusing enhances the collision cross-sections by fa ctors of 10-100. Slow, or- derly growthends. Runaway growth begins. At theinner edge ofth e disk, thelargest objects take~3 Myr to grow to ~100 km and ~30 Myr to grow to ~1000 km. Throughout run- away growth, the gas disk dissipates. Thus, velocity damping by gas drag ceases; and viscous stirring increase efor the smallest objects. Stirring reduces factors, slowing the growth of the largest objects relat ive to one another and rel- ative to leftover planetesimals (Ida & Makino 1993; Wetherill & Stewa rt 1993). oligarchic growthbegins (Kokubo & Ida 1998; Rafikov 2003; Chambers 2006; Nagasawa et al. 2007). After 30-100 Myr, the largest objects - o ligarchs - grow slowly and contain an ever increasing fraction of the remaining mass in the disk. During the transition from runaway to oligarchic growth, collisions st art to produce copious amount of dust. Once oligarchs reach sizes ~500 km, collisions between 1-10 km objects produce debris instead of mergers (Kenyon et al. 2008, a nd references therein). Once fragmentation begins, continued stirring leads to a collisional c ascade, where are ground to dust. For dust grains with sizes the collision time is much shorter than the time to remove particles by gas drag (Adac hi et al. 1976) or by drag (Burns, Lamy, & Soter 1979). Thus , the cascade proceeds to particle sizes where radiation pressure removes material on the dynamical tim e scale (Burns, Lamy, & Soter 1979). Because runaway growth leav es most of the mass in 1-10 km objects, the collisional cascade effectively removes a signifi cant fraction of the solid material in the disk. Fig. 1 shows the time evolution of the eccentricity and the mass distr ibutions for objects in the innermost 8 annuli of a disk with initial mass distribution similar to t he MMSN. To minimize stochastic variations, these plots show median results for 1 5 calculations. During slow growth and the early stages of runaway growth, dynamical fr iction damps efor the largest objects and raises efor the smallest objects (Fig. 1; right panel, 10 Myr). The develops a pronounced shoulder from 10 km to ~300-500 km. As the growth concentrates more mass in the largest object s; stirring excites the orbits of the smallest objects. After 100 Myr, the collisional cascade rem oves mass efficiently from the smallest objects but leaves the mass distribution of the largest objects unchanged. By
~5-10 Gyr, almost all of the small objects have been removed. In these calculations, the rate of planet formation is very sensitive to semimajor axis (Fig. 2). For collisional processes, the growth time in the disk is tP/S, where Pis the or-- 14 alsoLissauer 1987;Kenyon & Luu 19 98;Goldreich, Lithwick, & Sari 2004). For Pa3/2and Sxma-3/2(Eq. (27)), the growth time is ta3x-1 m. Thus, although it takes only ~10 Myr for the largest planets to reach radii of 300-600 km at 30 AU, the largest objects at AU still have r~3-5 km. By 100 Myr, 100 km objects form at 75-80 AU. After 1 Gyr, 100 km objects form beyo nd 125 AU. By the end of the calculation at 10 Gyr, 1000 km objects form throughout the dis k. The formation rate also depends on the initial disk mass (Fig. 3). For an expected growth time ta3x-1 m, planets grow faster in more massive disks. At 100 AU, planets with r~2000 km form in a massive disk ( xm= 3) within 1 Gyr. In a low mass disk with xm~
1/3, the largest planet at 100 AU grows to r~300 km in 1 Gyr and r~2000 km in 10 Gyr. For all simulations of disks around 1 Mstars, the median timescale for the formation of the first 1000 km object (28) This relation fits our results for the median growth time to 5% fora= 30-150 AU and forxm= 1/3 to 3. For each initial disk mass, the inter-quartile range for th e formation time is~20%. Thus, there is a modest range of outcomes for identical star ting conditions. In equation 28, there is a small difference between the result expec ted from simple theory (tx-1 m) and the result derived in our calculations ( tx-1.15 m). We show in the Appendix how gas drag during runaway and oligarchic growth can mod ify the simple theory and explain the result of our the timescale to produce the first 1000 km object is a stro ng function of initial disk mass and semimajor axis, the evolution at late times is less sensitiv e to the To derive a simple relation for the median size rmaxof the largest object as a function of initial disk mass and semimajor axis, we adopt a simple func tion rmax(a) use an amoeba algorithm (Press et al. 1992) to derive the fitting parameters a0,r0, and aras a function of time. For stellar ages 1 Gyr Gyr, the ensemble of (30) for the radius of the largest (31)- 15 - for the scale length, and ar5-6 for the exponent. These relations match our results to
+-5%. The uncertainties are +-3% in the coefficients and +-5% in the exponents. These calculations produce relatively low mass icy planets with radii ~50% larger than the radius of Pluto (Young & Binzel 1994; Elliot et al. 2003, 2007). Alt hough these objects form relatively rapidly in the inner disk, they grow very slowly at late tim es. Between 1- 10 Gyr, most large object grow by ~10-20% in radius ( ~50% in mass). Because the size of the largest object depends weakly on the initial disk mass, nearly all disks form These objects stir leftover planetesimals effectively; thu s, nearly all disks develop a collisional cascade. Despite the general formation of Pluto-mass planets in any disk, th e lowest mass form Plutos inefficiently. The scale length, AU, derived from our calculations exceeds the outer radius of the disk. Thus, planet for mation does not proceed to completion at large afor the lowest mass disks. In these systems, the largest icy planet s at a125-150 AU are factors of 3-10 smaller than r0. The large exponent, ar~5-6, derived in our fits implies a rapid transition - ~10-20 AU - between disk regions where the largest objects are planets with rmaxr0and where the largest objects have km. In our calculations, the collisional cascade limits the size of the larges t objects. Once a few objects have radii km, they stir up leftover planetesimals to the When the collisional cascade begins, the timescale for 1 km p lanetesimals to oligarchstoaccrete. Thus, the growth of the largest objects stalls at ~1000-2000 km ( ~0.01- 0.02M). Occasionally, runaway and oligarchic growth produce a very large object with r~5000 km ( ~0.1M), but these objects form in only ~5-10% of the simulations. These objects form at random semimajor axes and tend to form in more ma ssive disks. The large radial variation in the formation time produces dramatic diff erences in the mass distribution as a function of semimajor axis (Fig. 4). In the inne r disk, rapid growth leads to many objects with 000 km (Table 2). With many large objects stirring the leftover planetesimals in the inner disk, the collisional cascade remov es most of the mass in small objects (Fig. 4, left panel). In the outer disk, slow growthre sults in a handful of Pluto- mass objects. A few large objects cannot stir leftover planetesim als efficiently. Thus, the collisional cascade is weak and leaves a substantial amount of mass in 1-10 km 4, right panel). The growth of objects as a function of semimajor axis and time is not sensitive to the size of the model grid (Fig. 5). For two sets of calculations with 3 2 annuli (cyan and magenta points), the median radius of the largest object in each an nulus is nearly identical- 16 - to results for calculations with 64 annuli (black points). The results for Eqs. (28-34) are also independent ofthegrid. Inprinciple, tsatsmall growth of objects at large a. Our results suggest that icy planet formation at large semimajor axes is not influenced by the formation of small icy planets at small conclude this discussion of the formation of large objects in a plan etesimal disk, we quote several simple relations for the amount of solid material in sma ll and large objects as a function of initial disk mass and semimajor axis for the ensemble of c alculations around a 1 Mstar. At 3-10 Gyr, the median fraction of solids remaining in the disk (32) For a MMSN with xm= 1, the amount of mass remaining in the disk at 3-10 Gyr ranges from 9% of the initial mass at 30 AU to roughly 50% of the initial mass at 150 AU. Thus, the inner disk is substantially depleted, while the outer disk contains a significant fraction of its initial mass. For each xm, the median fraction of the initial disk mass in 1000 km and larger obje cts is f1000= (33) The median fraction of the mass in 100 km and larger objects is rough ly 50% larger, f100= (34) For the ensemble of calculations, the typical inter-quartile range is ~0.1 Thus, the mass distributions in our calculations are top-heavy, wit h more mass in 1000+ km objects than in 100-1000 km objects. These relations demonstrate that planet formation at 30-150 AU is very inefficient. For all disk radii in this range, only ~6% or less of the initial population of 1 km objects Inthe cascade is very efficient at removing leftover 1-10 km obje cts. Thus, at 3-10 Gyr, the large objects contain most of the mass in the inner disk. In the o uter disk (100-150 AU), the collisional cascade does not have enough time to remove leftove r planetesimals. Thus, small objects with radii of 1-10 km contain most of the remaining mas s at 100-150 AU.- 17 - 3.1.2. Evolution of Dust At all semimajor axes, the collisional cascade converts a large frac tion of the initial planet current techniques, dust emission provides the sole observat ional diagnostic of the growth of icy planets at 30-150 AU around other stars. Here, we d escribe the evolution of these small particles and demonstrate that the collisional cascade is observable. Two physical processes set the visibility of dust grains in a debris disk . Once begins, collisions gradually grind the fragments to du st. When dust grains are small enough, radiative processes remove them from the disk. For disks at 30-150 AU, radiation pressure dominates mass loss for Gyr and removes 65% to 70% of the total mass loss. drag removes material at late time s and is responsible for 30% to 35% of the total mass loss. Because the gas density is negligib le once the begins, gas drag is unimportant. To describe our results, we divide dusty debris into 'large grains' with 1 'small grains' with 1 mm, and 'very small grains' with the evolution of large grains at all times. For Gyr, collisions dominate the evolution of small grains; drag then remo ves grains with radii of 1-100um on Gyr timescales. Radiation pressure removes very small grains o n the local dynamical timescale. Thus, radiation pressure produces a 'wind' of very small grains in the disk midplane. Fig. 6 shows the time evolution of the dust production rate for very small grains as dynam ical orbital eccentricities. Thus, collisions produce less and less de bris; the dust production rate declines with time. As oligarchs reach radii of ~500 km, they stir leftover their orbits. Dust production increases. Because oligarchs c ontinue to grow, they stir leftover planetesimals to larger and larger velocities. Collision energie s rapidly exceed the critical disruption energy; the dust production rate increases dr amatically (Eq. 4-5). toreach their maximum radiiintheinner disk (Eq. (29 )), thedust production rate peaks. As oligarchs grow at larger and larger disk radii, the dus t production rate the outer disk contains more mass, the global dust produ ction rate declines with time for two reasons. Large oligarchs form at late times in the ou ter disk (Fig. 2), but the smaller disk surface density and the longer orbital periods lead t o smaller collision rates. Smaller collision rates yield smaller dust production rates. Initially, collis ions dominate drag; thus, radiation pressure ejects the smallest grains on the local- 18 - orbital timescale (e.g., Krivov et al. 2000; Wyatt 2005). The dust pr oduction rate then declines roughly as t-1. At late times, the collision rates decline. drag then removes larger grains from the disk, which reduces the popula tion of very small grains from erosive collisions. The dust production rate then declines with e volution time as t-2 (see also Dominik & Decin 2003; Kenyon & Bromley 2004a, 2005; Wyatt 2005; Wyatt et al. 2007a,b). The time evolution of the collision rate in the disk yields a simple relation be tween the maximum dust production rate .Mmaxand the initial disk mass. For the complete set yr-1. (35) For a MMSN with xm= 1, the maximum rate is ~0.1Mevery million years. The collision rate scales with the square of the number density of objects; thu s, the dust production rate grows as the square of the initial disk mass (e.g., .Mmaxx2 m). The timescale for the peak in dust production is shorter than the tim escale for the production of 1000 km objects in the (36) This time corresponds roughly to the time of peak stirring of leftove r planetesimals by oligarchs growing in the inner disk, starting the collisional cascade. O ligarchs form faster in more massive disks; thus, the dust production rate peaks earlier in more massive disks. Fig. 7 shows the time evolution of the mass in small grains for disks with a range of initial masses. Initially, the dust production rates are small (Fig. 6) and the dust mass increases slowly with time. Once large oligarchs form in the inner disk, t he dust production rate - and thus the mass in small grains - grows rapidly. For all disks, it takes~5-10 Myr for the mass in small grains to grow from 10-6M(which is unobservable with to is observable). After this rapid rise, oligarchs form at larger and larger disk radii, leading to enhanced dust production f arther and farther out in the disk. The dust mass then rises slowly with time. Once oligarchs fo rm at the outer edge of the disk, the collisional cascade removes more and more solid material throughout the disk. The dust mass then begins to decline. The maximum mass in small grains scales with the initial disk (37) Because the derived size distributions are dominated by collisional pr ocesses, the maximum mass in large grains is roughly 40 times larger (e.g., Dohnanyi 1969; Willia ms & Wetherill- 19 - 1994; Kenyon & Bromley 2004c; Krivov et al. (38) In both cases, the larger collision rate in more massive disks leads to m ore dust. Although these dust masses are significant, they are small compared to the mass in objects with km. The typical mass in large grains is of the mass in 100 km and larger objects. The mass in small grains is of the mass in the largest objects. The timescale to reach the maximum dust mass is a function of the par ticle size. For the small (39) For the large (40) Several the collision timescale for all particle sizes is smaller than the timescale for P Thus, thecascade erodessmall particlesuntil radiationpre ssure ejectsthem. propagates out through the disk, collisions produce mor e and more small grains. Because the mass in grains is set by a balance between the collision time , which scales as x-1 m and the local dynamical time, which scales as x-1/2 m, the timescale to reach the maximum grain mass is proportional to x-1/2 m. As the collision rate declines, drag starts to remove mass from the disk. This drag removes smaller par ticles from the disk more effectively than it removes large particles. Thus, the mass in small gr ains peaks before the mass in larger grains. These results suggest that the mass in collisional debris is large, rou ghly a lunar mass in 0.001-1 mm grains, throughout the lifetime of a 1 Mstar. Although the Solar Sys- tem has much less dust (e.g., Landgraf et al. 2002; Nesvorn' y et al. 2006, and these large disk masses are comparable to the mass in dus t grains detected in many debris disks around other stars (e.g., Beichman et al. 2006; Tr illing et al. et al. 2007). Because our dust production rates are observable, the large range in dust masses as a function of initial disk mass and time implies a c range in the observable properties of debris disks, such as th e disk luminosity and the IR excess, at fixed stellar age. Because the dust production rate declines with time, we ex- pect the disk luminosity and IR excesses to decline with time. We derive detailed predictions for this evolution in SS4 and compare these results with observations in SS5.- 20 - 3.2. Icy Planet Formation in 1.5-3 MStars Stellar evolution is an important feature of icy planet formation at 30 -150 AU. Because the main sequence lifetime ( tmsM-n , withn3-3.5; e.g., Iben 1967; Demarque et al. 2004) is more sensitive to stellar mass than the timescale to produce large icy planets ( t M-3/2 ; see below), massive stars evolve off the main sequence before oliga rchic growth and the collisional cascade remove solid material in the outer disk. After a 1-3 M star evolves off the main sequence, it becomes more luminous (as a red giant) and h otter (as a post- AGB star). During this evolution, icy planetesimals and planets melt, d ecreasing collision rates and changing the outcome of the collisional cascade2. Short main sequence lifetimes of massive stars thus lead to clear differences in the amount of solid m aterial in large and small objects in the outer disk. The stellar mass also affects the outcome of icy planet formation. Th e timescale for planet formation scales with orbital period and the surface density ,tP/S (see the Ap- pendix). For a disk with S = S 0xma-3/2(Eq. (27)) and fixed S 0xm, the formation time is ta3M-1/2 . Thus, at fixed ain disks with identical surface density distributions, planets form faster around more massive stars. However, disk masses in t he youngest stars scale with stellar mass (e.g., MdM; Natta et al. 2000; Scholz et al. 2006). Thus, S 0scales with stellar mass, S 0MdM. Combining these relations leads to a formation time ta3M-3/2 . Thus, at fixed ain typical disks, icy planets form ~5 times faster around 3 Mstars than around 1 M stars. To illustrate how stellar mass and evolution affect planet formation, w e begin with the growth of large objects at 40 AU and at 100 AU (Fig. 8). For disks wit h identical initial surface density distributions, planets at the same ain disks around 3 M stars grow ~1.7 times faster than planets around 1 M stars. Fig. 8 also shows the clear scaling of growth time with semimajor axis, ta3for a disk with S a-3/2. The simple scaling of the growth time with disk mass and orbital period in our calculations leads to a gene ral relation for the median timescale for the formation of the first 1000 km object in disk s at 30-150 (41) For 1-3 M stars, this relation fits our results for the median growth time to 7% fora=
30-150 AU and for xm= 1/3 to 3. For all initial disk masses, the inter-quartile range for th e 2We assume that melting is accompanied by a loss of volatiles and an incre ase in the mass density of leftover planetesimals.- 21 - formation time is ~20%. Thus, there is a modest range of outcomes for identical star ting conditions around 1-3 M standard coagulation theory. As outlined in the Appendix, velo city damping from gas drag can speed up planet formation in more massive disks. Fig. 9 further shows how the growth time varies with aandMfor constant xm. At 100 Myr, icy planets are close to their maximum sizes at 30-50 AU in the inne r disk. At large disk radii ( a~100-150 AU), planet formation is clearly faster around more massiv e stars. For all stars with M= 1-3 M , thermax(a) relations have a similar morphology, consisting of a plateau at rmax1000-2000 km and a steep decline of rmaxwith increasing a. As in SS3.1.1, we fit our results to a simple relation between rmax,a, and time (Eq. (29)). For all of our calculations, we derive an exponent ar5-6 and a characteristic maximum (42) with the exponent b= 0.22+0.033M/M. The disk scale length (43) These results are valid for late times, t0.1-1tms. Eq. (42) shows that the maximum sizes of icy planets at 30-150 AU ar e to initial disk mass, stellar mass, or time. For disks with iden M stars, the largest icy planets around 3 M stars are only ~10%-20% larger than the largest icy planets around solar-type stars. This range is comp arable to the range in maximum sizes for planets formed in identical disks around stars of id entical mass ( SS3.1.1). Disks with a factor of 10 range in xmyield planets with a 20%-30% range in radii (a factor of~2 in mass). Thus, our calculations predict that the largest icy planet s at 30-150 AU around 1-3 M stars have masses comparable to Pluto and other large Kuiper belt o bjects in the Solar System beyond the orbit of the maximum sizes of planets are fairly independent of initial conditions, the number of Pluto-mass objects nPis sensitive to disk mass and stellar mass (Table 3). In the inner disk (30-60 AU), nPscales roughly with initial disk mass and stellar mass. In the outer disk (100-150 AU), the formation timescale for icy planet s is comparable to the main sequence lifetime. Thus, nPscales with initial disk mass and stellar mass only for the most massive disks. In lower mass disks, stars evolve off the main seq uence before disks can produce large numbers of Pluto-mass objects.- 22 a function of disk mass and stellar mass. For disks with identical init ial surface at a= 30-37 AU, the shape of the mass distribution is fairly independent o f stellar mass at 100 Myr (Fig. 10; left panel). Because large icy planet s form first in disks around more massive stars, disks of fixed age around 3 M stars have more mass in larger planets and are more collisionally depleted than disks around 1 M stars. For calculations in scaled MMSN (Fig. 10; right panel), growth is a stro nger function of stellar mass. As predicted by the simple scaling relations, disks aroun d 3 M stars have ~5 times more mass in large objects than 1 M stars. More mass in large objects produces more stirring, enhancing mass loss in the collisional cascade. Despite large difference in initial disk mass, the mass distributions of disks around 1-3 M stars are very similar for r <1 km at similar times. Although planet formation proceeds faster with increasing stellar m ass, stellar evolution halts the collisional cascade and the growth of planets in more massiv e stars (Fig. 11). Planets reach their maximum radii in the inner disks for all 1-3 M stars; however, the timescale for the collisional cascade to run to completion is long compa red to the main sequence lifetimes of 2-3 M stars. Thus, the collisional cascade removes a larger fraction of material from the inner disks around 1 M stars than from the inner disks of 2-3 M stars (Fig. 11; left panel). In the outer disk, the growth time for 1 000 km planets is large compared to the main sequence lifetime for 2-3 M stars. Thus, planets do not reach their maximum radii of ~1000-2000 km in the outer disks of 2-3 M stars (Fig. 11; right panel) To conclude our comparison of icy planet formation around stars of different masses, we consider the long-term evolution of all solids in the disk. For t= 0.3-1.0tms, the median fraction of solids remaining in the disk (44) for the ensemble of calculations for 1.5 M stars (45) for calculations for 2-3 M stars. At 30-50 AU, all stars lose roughly the same fraction of mass from the disk. At larger disk radii, more massive stars evolve off the main sequence before the collisional cascade removes most of the leftover 1-10 k m planetesimals. Thus, icy planet formation around lower mass stars converts a larger fract ion of the initial solid mass into dusty debris.- 23 - Although planet formationaround massive stars converts a smaller fraction of the initial mass into dusty debris, icy planet formation is equally efficient at prod ucing massive objects around all 1-3 M stars. For all disks in our calculations, the median fraction of the init ial disk mass in 1000 km and larger objects is f1000= (46) The median fraction of the mass in 100 km and larger objects is ~50% larger, f100= (47) Mass distributions for icy planets are top heavy for all 1-3 M stars. As for 1 M stars, the typical inter-quartile ranges are ~0.1 forfsand~20% Thus, identical starting conditions lead to a modest range of outc omes. 3.2.1. Evolution of Dust The evolution of dusty debris in disks around 1.5-3 M stars generally follows the evolution for 1 M stars. As oligarchs form, stirring leads to a collisional cascade that converts 10 km and smaller objects into small dust grains. Because planets form more rapidly around more massive stars, disks around massive stars pro duce dust sooner than disks around lower mass stars. In our calculations, the disk mass sc ales with the stellar mass. Thus, disks around massive stars also produce more dust th an disks around lower mass stars. However, massive stars do not live as long as lower mass stars, preventing the collisional cascade from removing all of the small objects from the d isk (Fig. 10). Over the lifetime of the star, disks around lower mass stars form more dust t han disks around more massive stars. To illustrate these points, Fig. 12 shows the time evolution of the dus t production rate for a scaled MMSN ( xm= 1) around 1 M , 2 M, and 3 M stars. During runaway collisions are rare; thus, the dust production rate de clines with time. As runaway growth ends, there are three distinct phases in dust production: (i) an exponential rise when runaway objects start to stir leftover planetesimals in the inner dis k, (ii) a long plateau as oligarchs form farther and farther out in the disk, and (iii) a long dec line in dust production as the collisional cascade depletes the disk of 1-10 km objects. Because planets grow more rapidly around more massive stars, the exponential growth in dust production occurs first around more massive stars. The tim escale for the onset of- 24 - dust production also scales inversely with disk mass; thus, more mas sive disks produce dust faster than low mass disks. When runaway growth ends and oligarchic growth begins, the dust p roduction rate reaches a clear plateau (Fig. 12). We define the onset of the platea u phase as the time of maximum dust production3. For our calculations, there is a simple relation between the timescale of maximum dust production and the masses of the disk and central (48) At this time, our simulations yield a simple relation between the maximum d ust production rate and the masses of the disk and the central yr-1. (49) Each of these scaling laws has a simple physical origin. The maximum dus t depends on the collision rate, the square of the disk mass divided by the orbital period. Thus, For disks where the surface density scales with stellar mass (Eq. (27)), S xmM. Thus, .Mmaxx2 mM5/2 . The timescale to reach this rate is the orbital period divided by the disk mass. Thus, oligarchs form in the outer disk, the dust production rate dec lines rapidly. sets the duration of this decline. In massive stars, the sh ort main sequence lifetime halts the evolution before the collisional cascade depletes the disk o f 1-10 km objects. Thus, the dust production rate declines by roughly an order of magnitude before the central star evolves off the main sequence. For lower mass stars, the long main se quence lifetime allows the collisional cascade to remove some material in the outer disk. Th us, the dust production rate declines by ~two orders of magnitude before the central star evolves into a re d giant. Weshow in SS4how ofthedust produces observable differences in the IR excesses of massiv e and low mass stars. Despite the large differences in dust production rates, there are s maller variations in the amount of dust as a function of disk mass and stellar mass. Fig. 1 3 shows the time evolution of the median mass in small grains for scaled MMSN around 1- 3 Mstars. Once the exponential rise in dust production begins, the dust masses ra pidly evolve to similar 3Because there are small fluctuations in the dust production rate d uring the plateau phase, we define the maximum dust production as the time when the derivative d.M(t)/dtfirst changes sign.- 25 - configurations with ~1026g in small grains. For our set of calculations, the maximum mass in small grains (50) The coefficient in this equation, 0 .026M, is roughly twice the mass of the Moon. The maximum mass in large particles (51) The timescale to reach the maximum dust mass is a function of the par ticle size. For the small (52) For the large (53) As described in SS3.1.2, the collision rate, the dynamical timescale, and Poynting-Robe rtson drag combine to produce the shorter timescale for smaller dust gra ins. 3.3. Limitations of the Calculations In previous papers, we have described limitations to multiannulus (Br omley & & Bromley leannulus(Kenyon & Luu 1998, 1999) coagulation calculations. Here, we review how several of these limitations affect results for the simulations described above. As long as the statistical assumptions underlying the formalism are m et, coagula- tion calculations provide a reasonable representation of real collisio n evolution (Wetherill 1980; Greenberg et al. 1984; Davis et al. 1985; Barge & Pellat 1991; Spaute et al. 1991; Lissauer & Stewart 1993;Wetherill & Stewart 1993;Stern & Colwell et al. 1997; Kenyon & Luu 1998; Inaba et al. 2001). For calculations at 30 -150 AU around 1- 3 Mstars, the spacing of mass bins in an annulus and the spacing of annu li in the disk limit the accuracy of the results. Our standard mass spacing, d= 2, lengthens the evolution time by 10% to 20% relative to more accurate calculations with (see Kenyon & Luu 1998, and references therein). The radial resolution, ai/ai= 0.025, also lengthens the evolution time. Compared to calculations described in Kenyon & Bromley (2004b ), improvements in our treatment of interactions among particles in neighboring annuli reduce lags by a factor- 26 - of two, from ~20% to~10%. Combining the lags for mass spacing and radial resolution, our evolution timescales are ~20% to 30% longer than the actual evolution times. This lag is comparable to the dispersion in timescales derived from multiple calcu lations with iden- tical starting conditions. Thus, improvements in resolution are unlik ely to alter our Dynamical interactions The coagulation algorithm begins to break down when (i) a few large ob jects contain most of mass in the grid and (ii) the gravity of these objects dominat es the stirring. km, the largest objects contain a small fraction of the m ass in an dynamical interactions are much smaller than the Fokker- Planck stirring rates. Thus, kinetic theory yields good estimates for collisions and stirring a mong small objects. As objects grow beyond ~1000 km, however, both assumptions of our statistical cascade removes leftover planetesima ls, increasing thefraction of mass in the largest objects and (ii) individual interactions among t he largest objects in an annulus can deflect large objects into neighboring annuli, raising c ollision and stirring rates significantly. With ~100-1000 Pluto-mass objects at 30-150 AU (see Tables among the largest objects could play a significant role in the late-time evolution of our interactions among an ensemble of Pluto-mass planets oc cur when the radial spacing is a~2 3rH, whererHis the Hill radius in Eq. (22). For planets with mass Mp~6x1024g andM= 1 M ,rH= 0.001a. Thus, dynamical interactions among the largest objects are inevitable when nP50-100 in a region with a radial extent a/a 0.2 (Goldreich, Lithwick, & Sari 2004; Kenyon & Bromley 2006). Many of our such large numbers of Pluto-mass objects. To save computer time, we did not calculate the typical long-term ev olution of hundreds of Plutos using our hybrid evolution code (Bromley & Kenyon 2006). H owever, we can infer the outcome from scaling the results of calculations for the format ion of the Earth at 1 AU (e.g., Chambers 2001; Bromley & Kenyon 2006; Kenyon & Bromley 200 6). At 0.4-2 AU, dynamical evolution of 100-200 lunar mass objects produces seve ral Earth-mass planets in 10-30 Myr. The spacing of lunar mass objects in these calculations is~70% of the critical spacing a~2 3rH, similar to the spacing of Pluto-mass objects at late times in our calculations at 30-150 AU. Scaling the evolution times by the ratio of orbital periods suggests that 100-200 Pluto mass objects collide to form planets w ith masses ~0.1 Mon 1-3 Gyr timescales (see also Levison & Stewart 2001; Goldreich, Lith wick, & Sari 2004).- 27 - This analysis suggests that dynamical interactions between large n umbers of Plutos at 30-150 AU are interesting only for low mass stars. For 2-3 M stars, the main are shorter than the time needed for Plutos to interact, t o collide, and to grow into Mars-mass planets. For lower mass stars, several test calcu lations with our hybrid code confirm that ensembles of 100-200 Plutos can grow into sever al Mars-mass planets on timescales of 2-5 Gyr4. Although this evolution leads to some extra stirring of leftover low mass planetesimals, there are only small changes in the dust produc tion rate and the total mass in small grains. Thus, dynamical interactions among Plutos hav e little impact on our general results. 3.3.2. Fragmentation another uncertainty inour calculations. We treat destructive collisions with an energy-scaling algorithm that uses (i) the ratio of the cente r of mass collision energy Qcto the critical disruption energy Q*
dand (ii) a simple power-law size distribution to apportion ejected material into lower mass bins. Although the ener gy-scaling algorithm yields a reasonable treatment of collisions in coagulation calculations, the disruption energy Q*
dsets the strength of the collisional cascade. Large Q*
dleads to a weak cascade with little debris; small Q*
dallows a strong cascade with significant debris. Because Q*
dand the of the ejecta set the amount of material in small grains , we now discuss how our choices for these input parameters affect our comparisons of various approaches suggest that the size distribution of the ejected mass has little impact on our results. For the large collision ra tes in our methods for dividing ejected mass among lower mass bins - including dividing the ejected mass equally among 2-3 lower mass bins - leads to a power-law mass dist ribution with a characteristic slope of dn/dm -0.8 (Dohnanyi 1969; Williams & Wetherill 1994). Thus, the adopted mass distribution for the ejecta is relatively unimporta nt. Kenyon & Bromley (2005) and Kenyon et al. (2008) describe how the form ofQ*
din Eq. (5) impacts collisional evolution of icy objects at 30-150 AU. Her e, we divide Q*
dinto a bulk component (the first term of Eq. (5)) and a gravity compone nt (the second term of Eq. (5)). Gravity provides nearly all of the binding energy for lar ge objects with km; the bulk component of Q*
dprovides most of the binding energy for small objects AU, the escape velocity of Mars-mass planets exceeds the orbit al velocity. Al- though dynamical interactions among Mars-mass objects can pro duce ejections in these Lithwick, & Sari 2004), damping by leftover planetesima ls limits ejections in our simulations.- 28 -10 km. For icy objects with maximum sizes rmax~2000 km, stirring never leads to orbital motions large enough to disrupt objects with 0-20 km. Thus, our choices for the gravity component of Q*
dhave little impact on our results. Although both components of the bulk strength - Qbandbb- contribute to Q*
d, quoted uncertainties in bbderived from theoretical simulations lead to unimportant variations in Q*
das a function of r. Thus, we concentrate on Qb. To quantify the impact of Qbon our results, we first consider the evolution of the dust production rate and the amount of material in large and small grains . During runaway growth, the dust production rates for models with Qb<=104erg g-1are 10%-20% larger than dust production rates for models with Qb>=105erg g-1. At the same time, the total mass in large and small grains is ~10 times larger for models with small Qbthan for models with large Qb. In both cases, models with the smallest initial disk mass have the larg est differences as a function of Qb. During oligarchic growth, these differences disappear. For models with Qb= 1-106erg g-1, the dispersion in dust production rates near the time of maximum dust production is ~5% or less for all disks around 1-3 M stars. Although the dispersion in the total mass in large and small grains is a factor of ~3 during the early stages of oligarchic growth, the dispersion in dust masses declines t o 10% or less at late times when the dust masses reach their maximum values (Kenyon & Bromley 2004b). The time variation in dust production rate and total dust mass as a f unction of Qbhas a simple physical origin (see also Kenyon et al. 2008). During runaway a nd oligarchic st Goldreich, Lithwick, & Sari 2004). Thus, small objects have lar ger and larger later and later evolution times. Because this feature of the evolu tion depends only on gravitational stirring, it is independent of Qb. Throughout the evolution, the mass ejected in a collision scales with Qc/Qb(Eq. (4)). Thus, calculations with small Qbeject more material at early times compared to models with large Qb, leading to a large dispersion in the dust production rate and total dust masses early in the evolu tion. At late times, all calculations produce objects with rmax1500-2000 km. These large objects stir all leftover small planetesimals to large random velocities, where the collision ener giesQcQ*
dfor all Qb. All collisions then lead to copious mass loss, which eliminates the disper sion in dust production rates and total dust masses at late times (see also Ken yon & Bromley 2004b). In addition to the small late-time dispersion in dust production rates and total dust masses, our results yield negligible differences in the late-time fractio ns of mass in large objects ( 00 km) as a function of Qb. The median radius of the largest object and the median number of Pluto mass objects are also independent of Qb. Thus, our that the fragmentation parameters have a small impact on observable quantities.- 29 - For low mass disks at Myr, destructive collisions between planetesimals with small Qb produce more dust than objects with large Qb. Although these differences are probably large enough to be observable, they disappear at late times when planets reach their Treatment of small particles Our algorithm for deriving the evolution of small particles with m is a in our calculations. To follow the evolution of sizes and or bits for largeobjects in a reasonable amount of computer time, we do not calculate the evolu tion of small Instead, we use the known production rate of small part icles from the .M(t), an adopted power-law size distribution, and a simple collision algorith m to evolve the small particle size distribution with time. Because we include and dr aginthissimple treat- ment of collisional evolution, our predicted size distributions consist of three distinct pieces. For particle sizes where the collisional timescale is shorter than the t imescale for drag, nr-0.8. For very small sizes where radiation pressure ejects grains, grains in a constant velocity outflowing wind (see the Appendix). For in- termediate sizes, drag can remove grains fa ster than collisions replenish them. Thus, the particle number n-0. To conserve mass, we solve a continuity equation to derive the number density of grains dominated by Poynting-Robe rtson drag. Although our solution for the evolution of small particles is efficient, it does not con- sider how fluctuations in the collision and fragmentation rates might m odify the size dis- tribution. Campo Bagatin et al. (1994) note that size-dependent fl uctuations can produce wavy size distributions for 0.1-10 mm particles. In their simulations of thebPic disk, Th' ebault, Augereau, & Beust (2003) derive steady-state size d istributions with substan- tial deficits of 0.1-10 mm particles compared to a standard nr-0.8power-law (see also Krivov et al. 2006; Th' ebault & Augereau 2007; L ohne et al. 2008) . If these deficits are typical, then our algorithm seriously overestimates the mass in small dust grains and thus the infrared fluxes of debris disks. To check for this possibility, we computed several models with a simple version of our multiannulus coagulation code. In these tests, we extracted a com plete disk model near the peak of the collisional cascade, extended the lower end of the size d istribution from rmin=
1 m to 1 um using a power law nr-a, and continued the calculation for ~100 Myr with collisions and drag but without our Fokker-Pla nck velocity evolution.- 30 - To estimate the range of errors in our simple algorithm, we varied the power law exponent for the size distribution, a0.6-1, the power law exponent for the fragmentation law, bb-0.5-0, and the magnitude of the bulk strength Qb= 1-105erg g-1. For a range of disk masses around a 2 M star, this approach provides a straightforward estimate for the accuracy of our results for small particles. These tests confirm that the simple collision algorithm yields results re asonably close to more detailed coagulation calculations. For models with g-1, anda0.6-1, the derived size distributions are within ~20% of those predicted by the simple model for all particles with r0.01-100 mm. Although calculations with g-1yield larger deviations from the simple model, these are small compare d to those quoted by Th' ebault & Augereau (2007). Because particles with sm allbbare harder to fragment, calculations with tend to produce smaller departures for a power law size distribution than those with in disks at 30-150 AU. Because icy planet formation is inefficie nt, the beginswhenmostoftheinitialdiskmassisin1-10kmplanetes imals. Fragmentation of the leftovers leads to a very large production rate of 1 m and sma ller objects. of these objects tends to wash out wavy size distr ibutions produced by a low mass cutoff (Campo Bagatin et al. 1994; Th' ebault, Augereau, & Beust 2003). In treatment of velocity evolution, leftover planetes imals are also in with larger protoplanets that are 'safe' from fragmenta tion. Thus, the dust production rate from the collisional cascade is well-matched to the d ynamical state of the system and tends to sustain a power-law size distribution for the sm allest objects. 3.4. Highlights of Icy Planet Formation Around 1-3 M Stars Starting with a disk of 1 km planetesimals, icy planet formation at 30-1 50 AU follows the same path for all 1-3 M stars. This evolution has six main features.
*It takes 5-30 Myr for runaway growth to produce an ensemble of o ligarchs with radii of 500-1000 km. Throughout runaway growth, oligarchs stir up th e orbits of . Myr to the main sequence turnoff, planets slowly grow to a charac teristic radius. For a broad range of input parameters, the maximum size of an icy planet is
~1750 km at 30-150 AU. Because the timescale for planet formation a t 100-150 AU- 31 - is similar to the main sequence lifetime of a 1-3 M star, the inner disk contains more 1500-2000 km planets than the outer imals todust. Early on, ejectsthesmallestgrainsinanoutflowingwin d. Later, drag also removes larger grains from the disk. In our ca lculations, removes roughly twice as much mass from the disk as Poyn The timescale for the collisional cascade to remove leftover p lanetesimals is close to the main sequence lifetime of the central star. Thus, the casca de removes more material from the inner disk than from the outer disk.
*Icy planet formation is inefficient. In our calculations, icy planets with radii exceeding 1000 km contain of the initial mass in solid material. Objects with radii ~
100-1000 km contain ~2-3% of the initial mass. Because short stellar lifetimes limit the growth of planets in the outer disk, the mass in large objects de clines linearly with increasing distance from the central star. Thus, the inner region of the disk contains many more Pluto-mass objects than the outer region.
*The dust produced by the collisional cascade is observable. For disk s around 1-3 M stars, dust umto1mmis This mass is comparable to the masses derived for the most luminous debris disks around A-type and G-type stars. The time evolution of the du st production rate and the mass in small dust grains suggest the dust luminosity declines with time.
*Dusty debris is a signature of the formation of a planetary system. This debris is present throughout the lifetime of the central star. 4. DEBRIS DISK EVOLUTION To convert our derived size distributions into observable quantities , we perform a radia- tive transfer calculation. For each evolution time t, we derive the luminosity Land Tof the central star from the Y2stellar evolution models (Demarque et al. 2004). We then compute the optical depth t(a) of each annulus in our model grid. The optical depth allows us to derive the fraction of the stellar luminosity Labsorbed by each annulus. For each grain size in each annulus, we derive an equilibrium gr ain and an emitted spectrum. Summing the emitted spectra over randayields the pre- dicted spectral energy distribution (SED) and the total dust lumin osityLdas a function of time. The Appendix describes this calculation in more detail (see also K enyon & Bromley 2004b).- 32 - In our calculation of observable quantities, the most important inpu t parameters are the smallest stable grain size r2(also known as the 'blowout' radius; see Backman & rthe minimum grainsize suggest r20.5-2M3 um for 1-3 M stars (e.g. Burns, Lamy, & Soter 1979; Artymowicz 1988; Backman & Paresce 1993; Kimura et al. 200 2), the coefficient and the scaling relation are sensitive to the composition, internal st ructure, and of the grains. Because observations allow few tests of this relation, we adopt r2=
1um for all stars. If more luminous stars have larger r2, our calculations overestimate Thus, submmexcesses. submm data suggest q0.6-1froma handful of debris disks (Najita & Williams 2005; Williams & Andrews 2006). To provide some balance for our likely u nderestimate of r2, we adopt q= 1. Grains with smaller qemit more efficiently at longer wavelengths; our models then underestimate mid-IR and submm excesses. To describe the evolution of observable quantities with time, we focu s on the dust luminosity Ldandtheexcesses Thefractionaldu a clear measure of the relative luminosity of the debris disk. For excesses at specific wavelengths, we quote the total emission of the disk and th e central star relative to the emission from the stellar photosphere, Fl/Fl,0. With this definition, disks that produce no excess have Fl/Fl,0= 1; disks where the excess emission is comparable to the emission from the central star have Fl/Fl,0= 2. We begin this section with a discussion of excess emission for 1 M stars. After of our results with observations, Tables 4-8 list result s for the fractional dust luminosity and excesses at 24-850 um. The paper version lists the first five lines of results forxm= 1/3, 1, and 3. The electronic version includes all results for these xm. 4.1. Evolution for 1 M stars Fig. 1 M star. Early in the evolution, collisions produce mergers instead of de bris. For an ensemble of growing planetesimals, the surface area per unit mass ( and hence the with time. Thus, Ld/Ldeclines with time. Less massive disks have smaller dust masses and smaller dust luminosities. As oligarchic growth begins, the dust luminosity rises rapidly and reaches a peak Ld/L2x10-3in 30-100 Myr. More massive disks reach larger peak luminosities earlier than less massive disks. At late times, a ll disks converge to the same dust luminosity, Ld/L10-4at~10 Gyr.- 33 - Despite their small fractional dust luminosities, these disks produc e large excesses at 70um (Fig. 15; left panel). For massive disks with xm= 2-3, the 70 um excess rises at 3 Myr to F70/F70,0~30-50 at 30 Myr. Lower mass disks with xm= 1/3 to 1/2 produce smaller peak excesses at later times, F70/F70,0~10 at~100 Myr. For all disk masses, the 70 um excess is close to its maximum value for a short period when planet formation peaks in the inner disk. The excess then declines with time. The rapid decline leads to modest excesses at late times, F70/F70,0~3-5 at~1 Gyr and F70/F70,0~2 at~
3-10 Gyr. The large excesses at 70 um are a simple consequence of blackbody radiation from small grains at 30-50 AU around a solar-type star. With typical tem peratures ~40-60 K, these grains emit most of their radiation at ~50-70um. The peak flux from a blackbody grain at temperature T is Fl,maxT5(Allen 1976). Setting the total disk At this wavelength, the stellar flux follows a Combining these relations and including a correction factor for ineffi cient radiation from small grains yields a simple relation for the 70 um flux from the disk and central (54) For the luminosities in Fig. 14, this relation accounts for the 70 um excesses in Fig. 15 at all times. At longer wavelengths, the disks in our calculations achieve larger pe ak excesses and stay close to the peak excess for longer periods of time (Fig. 15; rig ht panel). Disks reach their peak excesses at 850 um on timescales similar to those at 70 um,~30 Myr for disks withxm= 2-3 and ~100 Myr for disks with xm= 1/3. The fractional excesses at 850 um are a factor of ~2 larger than the excesses at 70 um. Because the emitting region evolves more slowly, these disks are luminous for ~1 Gyr and then decline with time. Despite the rapid decline, the excesses are significant at late times, with F850/F850,0~3-10 at~3-10 Gyr. The time variation of IR excess also depends on the outer radius of t he disk. For solar mass stars, grains at 30-50 AU in the inner disk produce most of the flux at 50-100 um. Thus, disks with outer radii of 70 AU and 150 AU produce similar 70 um excesses for Myr (Fig. 16; left panel). Once the smaller disk reaches peak emiss ion, the 70 um excess begins a dramatic decline. The larger disk maintains the peak excess f or~30 Myr and then declines more slowly with time. For Myr, the smaller disk is a factor of 2-3 fainter at 70um than the larger disk. The evolution of disks with different sizes is more dramatic at 850 um (Fig. 16; right- 34 - panel). For typical grain temperatures ~20-60 K, long wavelength emission from the disk follows the Rayleigh-Jeans tail of a set of blackbodies. The radiation from each disk annulus is thena2T. Because the outer disk produces more long wavelength emission th an the inner disk, the 850 um excess scales with the outer disk radius. For Gyr, we whereaoutis the outer radius of the disk and n3-4. Thus, doubling the outer disk radius increases the predicted 850 um excess by a factor of ~10 at late times. 4.2. Evolution for 1.5-3 M stars Several factors change the evolution of the dust luminosity and th e IR/submm excesses in stars more massive than 1 M . More massive stars are hotter; for the Y2stellar TM(Demarque et al. 2004). Thus, grains in the inner disks around mass ive stars are warmer, emit more short wavelength radiation, and prod uce bluer colors than disks around less massive stars. More massive stars also evolve faster, tmsM-3 . Because the evolutionary timescales for solids in the disk are much less sensitive to stellar mass, tM-1 , massive stars have more dust at the end of their main sequence lifet ime than low mass stars (e.g., Fig. 13). Thus, these systems have relatively large IR excess es when their central stars evolve off the main sequence. To compare the evolution of dust emission in debris disks around 1-3 M stars, we begin with the evolution of the dust luminosity (Fig. 17). Planets grow faster around more massive stars; thus, the dust luminosity rises earlier for more massive stars. Once the collisional cascade begins, the timescale to reach the peak luminosity depends only on the initial disk mass and the stellar (55) This timescale is similar to the timescale required to produce the first P luto-mass object in the inner disk (Eq. (41)). The peak luminosity depends only on the init ial disk (56) The luminosity remains close to the peak for ~10-30 Myr and then declines with time. Stellar evolution has a clear impact on the evolution of the dust luminos ity. For 1 M stars, the dust luminosity declines by a factor of ~20 before the star evolves off the main sequence (Fig. 14). For 3 M stars, the typical decline in Ld/Lis only a factor of ~4. Because debris disks have roughly the same peak luminosities, an ens emble of debris disks around middle-aged low mass stars should be systematically less lumino us than disks high mass stars.- 35 - Stellar physics also produces dramatic differences in the behavior of the 24um excess with stellar mass (Fig. 18; lower left panel). At 30-50 AU, the grain te mperatures range from~40-60 K for 1 M stars to~80-120 K for 3 M stars. For these at 24 um is on the Wien side of the blackbody peak and thus varies exponentia lly with temperature. Our calculations for 1 M stars produce very little 24 um radiation from material at 30-150 AU. However, the peak 24 um excesses reach F24/F24,0~20 for disks around 3 M stars. For all 1-3 M stars, our results (M-1M)+0.27 (M/M) logxm. (57) This maximum flux occurs at roughly the same time as the peak dust lum inosity. At longer wavelengths, theexcesses areless sensitive tostellar ma ss. Radiationat 70 um is at the blackbody peak for grains in the inner disk. Thus, the inner d isk produces most of the 70um excess. The peak excess is then independent of the stellar luminos ity and depends only on the total disk mass (Fig. 18; upper left (58) For grains at 30-150 AU, radiation at longer wavelengths is on the Ra yleigh-Jeans tail of the blackbody. Thus, observations at 160-850 um probe material throughout the disk. At 160um, extra emission from hotter grains in disks around more massive st ars is balanced by more flux from the hotter central star. Thus, the excess is ind ependent of stellar mass and depends only on xm(Fig. 18; upper right (59) At 850um, grains in disks around 1 M stars are closer to their blackbody peaks than grains in disks around more massive stars. Thus, the 850 um excesses are larger for 1 M stars (Fig. 18; lower right 1M 25x0.9 mM= 70-850 um, the time of peak excess is similar to the maximum in the dust luminosity . Thus, all excesses at 24-850 um peak at ~20-30 Myr for 1-3 M stars. Following the peak in the excess at 20-30 Myr, the relative disk luminos ity and the excesses at 24-850 um decrease monotonically with time. For this evolution, simple debris disk models predict a power law decline, Ld/Lt-nwithn1-2 (e.g. Dominik & Decin- 36 - 2003; Wyatt et al. 2007a,b). To compare our results for these predictions, we adopt fdLd/Lt-nd (62) and derive the power law exponents all of our calculations as a function of disk mass, stellar mass, and time. Throughout the evolution of all our debris disk models, ndchanges continuously with time. For collisions and radiation pressure dominate the removal of small gra ins. As collision rates slowly decline with time, the exponent increases slowly fromnd0 to nd1. When the central star approaches the end of its main sequence lifetime, drag starts to dominate collisions. The disk luminosity the n decreases rapidly; nd increasesfrom ~1to~2. ourcalculation s yield a typical the exponents nlfollow the evolution of nd. Because collision rates are larger in the warmer, inner disk than in the colder outer disk, nlincreases slowly with l. Thus, the typical n240.6-0.8 is smaller than the typical n8500.8-1.0. The exponents ndandnlare somewhat sensitive to the disk mass and the stellar mass. At fixed stellar mass, more massive disks evolve faster. Thus, ndchanges faster for more massive turnoff. Forfixeddis kmass, lower massstars livelongerandhavemoretimetoreachthedra Our results suggest a 0.1-0.2 range in ndandnlfor a factor of 10 range in xmand a factor of 3 range in stellar mass. In addition to excesses at specific wavelengths, the evolution of co lor excesses trends with stellar mass and time. Because the 24 um excess is sensitive to stellar mass, the [24]-[70] color cleanly distinguishes debris disks arou nd stars of different masses (Fig. 19). For 2-3 M stars, [24]-[70] rises rapidly to [24]-[70] 1-2 at~1 Myr and then rises slowly throughout the main sequence lifetime of the centr al star. For 1-1.5 M stars, the color rises later, reaches [24]-[70] 3-4 at 30-100 Myr, and then declines slowly. For disks at 30-150 AU, the variation of [24]-[70] with Mdepends solely on the prop- erties of the central star. Because more massive stars are hott er, their disks are warmer. Warmer disks produce bluer colors. Thus, the peak [24]-[70] scales w ithM. The mass-dependent color evolution of debris disks at 30-150 AU su ggests that color- color diagrams can discriminate masses of the central star. In Fig. 20, color-color tracks for- 37 - scaled MMSN around 1.5 M stars are clearly distinct from tracks for scaled MMSN around 2 Mand 3 M stars. In Fig. 21, tracks for a range of disks around 2 M stars define locus distinct from the tracks for 1.5 M and 3 M stars. To establish a triangular debris disk locus for each stellar mass, we de fine two a vertex, x 0,y0, the upper boundary of the locus is a vector connecting the verte x with an upper point, x u,yu. The lower boundary is a second vector connecting the vertex with a lower point, x l,yl. Table 9 lists our results for the vertex and the upper/lower points as a function of stellar mass. For each stellar mass, colors for debr is disks at 30-150 AU lie within the area defined by the two vectors. More massive disks pro duce redder colors. Within each locus, the initial disk mass scales with distance from the ve rtex. When dust inside ~30 AU produces a small IR excess, this color-color ofstellarmass. 1-3M stars, color is small, with [5.8]-[8] at all times. Predicted colors for terrestrial debris disks are much larger. For 3 M (1.5 M ) stars, we predict maximum colors [5.8]-[8] ~
0.5-1 (0.2-0.5) (e.g., Kenyon & Bromley 2004a, 2005). Thus, mid-IR c olor-color diagrams are useful diagnostics of the outer disk for [5.8]-[8] . 4.3. Summary Planet formation and stellar evolution combine to produce several r obust trends in the time evolution of the dust luminosity and IR/submm excesses from de bris disks around 1-3 Mstars. For scaled MMSN, the maximum dust luminosity is Ld,max~2x10-3. For an ensemble of debris disks, the range in the peak dust luminosity scales with the in itial mass of solid material in the disk. The dust luminosity reaches this peak at roughly the time when the first Pluto-mass objects form at 30-50 AU. Following this peak, the luminosity declines Because lower mass stars have longer main sequence lifetime s, debris disks around lower mass stars reach smaller fractional dust luminos ities at late times. The IR/submm excesses from debris disks at 30-150 AU are sensitiv e to the mass of the central star. At 24 um, disks around more massive stars produce larger excesses; disk s around stars with M/lessorsimilar1 Mproduce negligible excesses at 24 um. At 70 um, the excess is a simple function of the total dust luminosity, F70/F70,01 + 104Ld/L. At 850 um, debris disks around 1 M stars produce larger peak excesses than disks around more mass ive stars. At late times, however, the typical 850 um excess is fairly independent of stellar mass, for stars with ages t~tms.- 38 - Among stars with different masses, mid-IR colors provide a sensitive discriminant of debris disk evolution when the [5.8]-[8] color is small (Fig. 19-21). For 2 -3 Mstars, [24]- [70] slowly becomes redder with the age of the central star; for 1- 1.5 Mstars, [24]-[70] rises more rapidly, remains at peak color for 300 Myr to 1 Gyr, and then de clines rapidly with time. For all stars, [8]-[24] and [24]-[70] correlate with stellar mass. D ebris disks around 2-3 M (1-2 M ) stars have redder (bluer) [8]-[24] colors and bluer (redder) [24]-[7 0] colors. Thus, an [8]-[24] vs[24]-[70] color-color diagram provides a way to analyze debris disks around stars with different masses (Table 9). 5. APPLICATIONS To test whether our predictions provide a reasonable match to obs ervations, we now consider several applications of our models to real systems. For t hese calculations, the broad trends in the evolution of IR excesses and colors are sensitiv e to the physics of planet formation and the collisional cascade. Thus, our main goal is to comp are our results with observed trends of excesses and colors for large samples of main s equence stars observed In addition to long-term trends, the absolute level of the excesses depends on r2andq. Thus, our second goal is to learn whether our mid-IR and submm excesses similar to those observed. We begin with an analysis of Spitzerdata for the prototypical debris disk, Vega. that our models can explain the mid-IR fluxes and mor phology of Spitzer images for this system, we show that our predictions provide a good match to observations of mid-IR excesses for a sample of A-type stars (Rieke et al. 2005; Su et al. 2006) and a sample of solar-type stars (Beichman et al. 2006; Hillenbrand et al. 2 008). 5.1. The Vega of Vega with IRASfirst revealed a large excess of emission above the A- type photosphere for wavelengths exceeding 12 um (Aumann et al. 1984). The temperature blackbody to the IRASdata yields a temperature of ~85 K, a of to the central star, and a radius of ~150-200 AU for the emitting material. Because the lifetime for small grains at 150-20 0 AU is much shorter than the age of Vega, Aumann et al. (1984) concluded that the gra ins have sizes larger than 1 mm. Thus, Vega provided the first direct evidence for grain g rowth outside the Solar System.- 39 - Since the Aumann et al. (1984) discovery, Vega has become the pro totypical debris disk (e.g., Backman & Paresce 1993; Artymowicz 1997; Lagrange et al. 2000). The debris consists of a bright torus with small-scale clumps at 80-1000 AU from the central star (Holland et al. 1998; Wilner et al. 2002; Liu et al. 2004; Su et al. 2005) a nd a smaller disk of debris at ~1 AU from the central star (Absil et al. 2006). Dust in the small disk is hot (~1500 K), luminous ( Ld/L~5x10-4), and mostly confined to a narrow ring with a diameter of ~0.5-1 AU (Absil et al. 2006). This dust might be a result of larger objects at 1 AU or grains lost from icy comets at 80- 100 AU in the Su et al. (2005) analyzed high quality Spitzerimages at 24, 70, and 160 um. Their results demonstrate that the large-scale debris consists of a bright ring at 80-200 AU and a smooth 'halo' that extends to ~1000 AU at 160 um. The halo has an profile, consistent with a wind of small grains ejected by rad iation pressure. Fits to the radial surface brightness profiles and the spectral energ y distribution suggest the grains in the wind have sizes of 1-50 um and a total mass of Md,1-50~3x10-3M. The grains in the bright ring are larger, with typical sizes of ~240um, and have a total also Marsh et al. 2006). For an adopted residence time of
~103yr in the wind, the mass in small grains implies that larger grains in the rin g produce smaller dust particles at a rate of ~1015g s-1. To check whether our model predictions can match the MIPS data f or Vega, we make a simple comparison with median results from several calculations. In a ddition to the observed fluxes at 24, 70, 160, and 850 um (Su et al. 2005), we adopt published values for the age (200 Myr; Su et al. 2006), luminosity (37 L ; Aufdenberg et al. 2006), and mass (2.3 M ; Aufdenberg et al. 2006) of the central star. Su et al. (2005) sep arate the observed fluxes into contributions from the debris disk and the central star. The fi rst row of Table 10 lists these results, along with their derived values for the mass in 1-50 um dust grains and the dust production rate. The rest of Table 10 lists predictions for fou r of our debris disk models around 2-2.5 M stars. The comparison in Table 10 suggests a reasonable match to the data . Predictions for the total mass in 1-50 um dust grains and the fluxes at 160 um and at 850 um bracket the observed values. Our models also predict a bright ring in the 70-160 um dust emission at 80-130 AU, close to the observed position of the bright ring inferre d from Spitzer Su et al. 2005). The agrees with the mass in 240 um grains derived from the Spitzer data. However, our models overpredict the fluxes at 24 um and at 70 um by a factor of 2-10 and underpredict the dust production rate by a similar factor.- 40 - To understand possible origins for the mismatches between the dat a and the models, we consider the evolution of small grains in our calculations. When the collisional cascade starts removing material from the disk, the most destructive collis ions involve grains with comparable masses. These collisions gradually erode the parent obj ects and produce modest amounts of debris in smaller particles. Because (i) the collision timesca le is much shorter than the timescale for drag and (ii) the ratio o f the radiation force to the gravitational force is erosion continues until particles reach (Burns, Lamy, & Soter 1979). Particles with ejected. For simplicity, we assume r21um for all of our calculations. In this picture for the collisional cascade, the Su et al. (2005) resu lts provide a simple solution for the overprediction of the 24-70 um fluxes in our calculations. If grains with r21um are in the wind, our 'Vega models' underestimate the mass in the wind and overestimate the mass left behind in the disk. More mass at larger dis tances from the central star lowers the optical depth in the inner disk, reducing th e predicted fluxes at Thus, increasing our adopted r2for Vega models should provide a better match between observed and predicted fluxes at 24 um and at 70 um. For an adopted L= 60 L , Backman & Paresce (1993) estimated r2= 14um. Scaling this result for our adopted L=
37 L,r28.5um. Several test calculations with r2= 10um yield predicted 24 um and 70um fluxes close to the observed the estimated dust production rate with our predictions requires a more rigorous analysis of dust production and ejection in the Vega debris disk. To derive the dust production rate, Su et al. (2005) assume that (i) the 240 um grains in the bright ring are bound, with brad~0 and residence times 103yr, and (ii) the 1-50 um grains in the wind are unbound, with brad>=1 and residence times ~103yr. If the collisional cascade proceeds as a gradual erosion of larger objects into smaller objects, howev er, we expect a more from grains with brad~0 to grains with brad~1 (see also Burns, Lamy, & Soter 1979; Artymowicz 1988). Allowing the residence time to change grad ually from the bound 240um grains to the unbound 1 um grains provides a way to lower the apparent dust production rate and to resolve the mismatch between our models an d the observations. To provide an alternate estimate for the residence time of grains in t he Vega disk, we consider the collision times in the ring and the wind. We adopt the dust m asses derived from the Spitzer images ( and a typical particle size For a ring at a~150 AU with a width a~50 AU, the collision time for a single grain 1987;Wetherill & Stewart 1 993;Kenyon & Luu- 41 - 1998). Collision times in the wind are similar. For P~103yr at 150 AU, the collision times range from ~104yr for 1um grains to 2 -3x106yr for 240 um grains. If we assume that the residence times are comparable to the collision times, we can construct a self-consistent picture for the collisional cascade in t he Vega disk. Collisions in the bright ring gradually erode 200-300 um grains until they reach sizes when they become incorporated into the wind. Collisions in the wind gradually erode the smaller grains until they reach sizes ~1um, when they are ejected rapidly from the system. As long as the 200-300 um grains are replenished from a reservoir of larger grains, this cascade can remain in a quasi-steady state over the main sequence lifetime of Vega. The required mass for the reservoir of larger objects is ~100-1000 times the current mass in 240um grains, ~1-5 M . This mass is small compared to the initial mass of solid material in a torus at 80-200 AU in a scaled MMSN, ~50-100 M (Eq. (27)). Because the optical depth of this reservoir is small, it produces a small IR excess compar ed to the emission from smaller grains. This picture relies on two features of the collisional cascade. We nee d an in mass between the large grains in the ring and the small g rains in the wind. The Su et al. (2005) mass estimates support this feature. We also n eed a gradual change in grain lifetime from the ~106yr collision timescale of the large grains to the lifetime of the smallest grains. Otherwise, collisions in the br oad torus cannot occur fast enough to maintain the current smooth structure of t he wind for timescales Current theoretical analyses support this idea (Burns, Lamy , & Soter 1979; Artymowicz 1988; Takeuchi & Artymowicz 2001; Grigorieva e t al. 2007). of a collisional cascade with a careful treatment of the in teractions between the radiation field and the small grains could test this proposal in detail ( e.g., Grigorieva et al. 2007). We conclude that our calculations provide a reasonable match to obs ervations of Vega. If we adopt r2~10um, the data are consistent with a standard collisional cascade within a broad torus at 80-200 AU. The cascade feeds an outflowing wind of small grains with sizes 1-50um. If the grain lifetime changes smoothly from ~106yr for large grains to ~103-104 yr for small grains, the cascade can maintain the wind Debris Disks Around A-type Stars Since thediscovery ofthe Vegadebris disk, & P aresce 1993;Lagrange et al.- 42 - 2000; Rieke et al. 2005; Su et al. 2006). Like Vega, several of thes e disks are resolved and thus provide important information on the radial structure of the dusty disk (e.g., Smith & Terrile 1984; Stapelfeldt et al. 2004; Kalas 2005; Meyer et al. 2007; Su et al. 2008). Although most A-type stars with debris disks are unresolve d, the sample is large enough to probe the time evolution of debris around 1.5-3 M stars. We now consider whether our calculations can explain this evolution. To compare our model predictions with observations, we examine da ta for nearby A- type stars from Rieke et al. (2005) and Su et al. (2006). Rieke et al. (2005) combined 24-25um data from IRASandISOwith new 24 um photometry from Spitzerto investigate the decay of planetary debris disks around 266 A-type stars. Su e t al. (2006) analyze a sample of ~160 A-type stars with high quality 24 um and/or 70 um data acquired with MIPSon Spitzer. types B7-A6, and ages 5-850 Myr. From the Kenyon & Ha rtmann (1995) table of stellar effective temperatures and spectral types and the Dem arque et al. (2004) tracks, ~75% (~85%) of the stars in the Rieke et al. (2005) (Su et al. 2006) sample have masses of 1.7-2.5 M . Thus, we compare these data with our results for debris disk evolution around 2 M stars. The observed 24-70 um excesses of A-type stars show a clear trend with the age of the star (Fig. 22-23). Although the statistics are poor, the data sug gest a rise in the 24 um excess at 5-10 Myr. The larger sample of young stars with 70 um excesses provides better evidence for this rise. At both wavelengths, the excess has a broa d peak for stars with ages of 10-30 Myr. At later times, the excess declines with time as t-nwithn0.5-1 (see also Decin et al. 2003; Greaves & Wyatt 2003; Rieke et al. 2005; Rhee et a l. 2007a). To improve the statistics for24 umexcesses aroundyounger stars, Currie et al. et al. (2005)sample. This expanded set of data provides unambiguous evidence for a rise in the typical 2 4um excess at stellar ages of 5-10 Myr and a robust peak in the excess at stellar ages of 1 0-15 Myr. As in Fig. 22, the 24 um excesses for this larger sample of A-type stars decline with age fr om~20 Myr to 1 Gyr. In addition to the long-term time evolution of mid-IR excess, the dat a also indicate a large range in the 24-70 um excess at fixed stellar age (Rieke et al. 2005; Carpenter et al. 2006; Su et al. 2006; Currie et al. 2008a). Although younger stars are more likely to have mid-IR excesses than older stars, there are many stars without e xcesses at every age. Myr, stars are equally likely to have any excess between zero an d the maximum excess at that age. As stars age, they are less likely to have an exc ess close to the maximum excess at that age. Thus, the dispersion in the excess declines with time.- 43 - Our calculations provide a good match to the time evolution of the amp litude of the 24-70um excesses. At both wavelengths, the models explain the rise in the a mplitude at 5-10 Myr, the maximum at 10-20 Myr, and the slope of the power-law decline at late times. For models with xm= 1-3, the predicted excesses also agree with the maximum observe d excesses. Although there are a few stars with excesses larger th an the model than 99% of the A stars in this sample have excesses within the r ange predicted in calculations also provide a natural explanation for a large range in the observed 24- 70um excesses at fixed stellar age. At 70 um, the maximum excess is roughly proportional to the initial disk mass (Eq. (58)). Thus, a factor of ten range in init ial disk masses yields nearly a factor of ten range in the maximum excess at 70 um. For stars with ages 10- 300 Myr, the suggest a factor of ~100 range in the 70 um excess. If this range is set by the initial disk mass, our models suggest initial disk masses with in the initial disk radius can also produce a range in 24-70 um excesses at fixed stellar age (e.g., Fig. 16). For 2 M stars with ages ~400-800 Myr, our results suggest that a factor of three variation in the outer disk radius (e.g., 50-15 0 AU) yields a factor of two (five) variation in the amplitude of the 24 um (70um) excess. Although the observed range in the amplitude of the 24 um excess for older A stars agrees with this prediction, the range at 70 um is much larger. Thus, variations in the initial disk radius can explain so me of the observed range of excesses at 24-70 um. Observations of the youngest stars support a large range in initial disk masses and disk radii. Submillimeter observations of dusty disks in the nearby Ophiuch us and regions indicate a 2-3 ( ~1) order of magnitude range in the masses (radii) of disks surrounding young starswithtypical agesof ~1 Myr (e.g., Osterloh & Beckwith 1995; Motte & Andr' e 2001; Andrews & Williams 2005, 2007a,b). Our models w ithxm= 3 have disk masses a little smaller than the maximum dust masses derived from the Thus, the submillimeter data imply disks with initial masses 0 and initial disk radii 50 AU /lessorsimilaraou00 AU. Disks with this range of initial masses and outer radii can produce the range of 24-70 um excesses observed around nearby A-type in the initial surface density distribution can also lead to a r ange in the 24- 70um excess. In our calculations, we adopted a 'standard' surface de nsity relation with S a-3/2. Compared to this model, disks with shallower (steeper) surface de nsity relatively more (less) mass at large semimajor axes. The outer disk has cooler grains than the inner disk; thus, disks with shallower (steeper) surface d ensity distributions should produce more (less) flux at longer wavelengths than our standard models. Because the- 44 - relative fluxes at 24 um and at 70 um provide a measure of the relative disk masses at different semimajor axes, color indices provide a natural measure o f the gradient of the surface density 24 compares the predicted color evolution for disks around 2 M stars with data from Su et al. (2006). Although current observations do not prob e the evolution well at 1-10 Myr, disks have a large color range, [24]-[70] ~1-3, for stars with ages ~10 Myr. For older stars, the data suggest a slow rise in the maximum color from [24 ]-[70]~3 at 10 Myr to [24]-[70] ~3.5 at~100 Myr. After ~300 Myr, the maximum color declines. For all stars older than ~100 Myr, the range in color is ~3-4 mag. Our models match the observed color evolution. At all ages, the pre dicted colors Thepred icted colors also explain the slow rise in the maximum observed color for star s with ages of 10- 100 Myr. To explain the full range in observed colors for 100 Myr to 1 Gyr old stars, we require disks with initial masses xm0.01-3. This range is similar to the range required for the time evolution of the 24 um and 70 um suggeststhat thetypic al initial is reasonably close to our adopted S a-3/2. For disks with shallower gradi- ents, we expect redder colors at later times. A few stars lie above o ur model most stars have bluer colors than models with xm= 3. Thus, few disks in these samples require shallower surface density distributions. Disks with s teeper surface can produce stars with blue colors, [24]-[70] ~1, at late times. A large sample of A-type stars with [70]-[160] colors and spatially resolved observa tions of the radial of these stars would provide a constraint on the initial surface density our success in matching these observations, other physic al processes may be needed to explain the full diversity of debris disk properties for A st ars with similar ages In their analysis of the large debris disk surrounding gOph, Su et al. (2008) examine a dozen main sequence stars with A0-A3 spectral types, a ges of 150-400 Myr, and fractional disk luminosities Ld/L10-5to 10-4(see also Su et al. 2006). Although all of these stars have dust with T50-100 K, Fomalhaut has a bright torus of dust with weak or negligible emission from a wind of small grains, Vega has a bright toru s with a luminous wind of small grains, and gOph has an extended disk ( aout500 AU) of dust apparently bound to the star. Some A0-A3 stars have warm inner disks with dus t temperatures ~
100 K to K; other A stars have no obvious warm dust emission. Su et al. (2 008) conclude that collisional cascades in disks with a range of masses and other processes, such as the formation of giant planets or recent catastrophic collisions, combine to produce the wide range of observed properties in this sample.- 45 - In principle, our models can explain some of this diversity. The Su et al. (2008) sample contains A stars with a factor of five range in L. Thus, these stars probably have a factor of five range in the blowout radius r2(see also SS5.1; Artymowicz 1988; Backman & Paresce 1993). If the protostellar disks around these stars had propert ies similar to those observed in Taurus-Auriga (Andrews & Williams 2005, 2007a), they probably ha d a factor of ten range in initial disk mass, a factor of three range in initial disk radius, and a 50% range in the slope of the initial surface density distribution. Coupled with a s imilar dispersion in initial conditions for the terrestrial zones of these stars (Keny on & Bromley 2005), our results suggest that this range in initial conditions can produce a br oad diversity of debris disks. We have started a suite of calculations to address this issue. Larger samples of A stars with resolved disks will provide crucial tests of these calculat ions. Other aspects of planet formation are also important. If the core s of gas giant planets form before their parent stars reach the main sequence, we expe ct gas giants at 20-30 AU around 2-3 M stars (e.g., Kennedy & Kenyon 2008). Gas giants rapidly remove deb ris in the inner disk and impose structure in the debris beyond 30 AU (e.g., W ilner et al. 2002; Moro-Mart' in & Malhotra 2005). Because gas giants are common ar ound evolved A stars (Johnson et al. 2007), gas giants probably play a significant role in th e evolution of debris disks around A collisions may also produce diversity among A star debr is disks (e.g., Wyatt & Dent 2002; Su et al. 2005). Although debris from complete d isruption of col- liding planetesimals is unobservable in our simulations (see also Kenyon & Bromley 2005), dynamical events similar to those that produced the Late Heavy Bo mbardment in the Solar System probably are visible (e.g., Gomes et al. 2005). Testing this idea requires numeri- cal calculations that link the dynamics of massive planets with the collis ional evolution of smaller objects (e.g., Charnoz & Morbidelli 2003; Kenyon & Bromley 20 06). We conclude that our debris disk models can explain the overall time ev olution of the IR excesses and IR colors of A-type main sequence stars at 24 um and at 70 um. Our calculations for disks with xm= 1/3 to 3 around 2 M stars fit the overall level of the excesses and the trends with stellar age. Explaining the full range o f observed IR excesses and IR colors requires a set of disks with xm= 0.01-3, as suggested from observations of disks around the youngest stars. Matching other properties of t hese stars - including the relative amount of emission from a warm inner disk, an outflowing wind o f small grains, and a large outer disk - requires calculations that include a broader rang e of initial disk radii and gas giant and terrestrial planet formation at ai<30 AU (e.g., Kenyon & Bromley 2005; Nagasawa et al. 2007; Kennedy & Kenyon 2008; Ida & Lin 2008; Kret ke et al. 2008).- 46 - 5.3. Debris Disks Around Solar-type Stars Although most of the debris disks discovered with IRASandISOhave A-type central stars, 1-1.5M (Backman & Paresce 1993; Lagrange et al. 2000; Decin et al. 2003; Song et al. 2005; Rhe e et al. 2007a). More recent reveal debris disks around many solar-type stars ( Bryden et al. 2006; Beichman et al. 2006; Meyer et al. 2006; Trilling et al. 2008; Hillen brand et al. 2008). Although several Spitzerprograms concentrate on older solar-type stars as prepa- ration for detailed planet searches, the range of ages is large enou gh to provide an initial test of our predictions. To compare our model predictions with observations, we consider d ata for nearby solar- type stars from Beichman et al. (2006) and Hillenbrand et al. (2008) . Beichman et al. (2006) observed ~80 solar-type stars at 24 um and at 70 um using MIPS on et al. (2008)analyze ~30starswith70 umexcesses outofasample of328stars from the SpitzerLegacy Science Program, Formation and Evolution of Planetary Sy stems (Meyer et al. 2006). After eliminating K-type and M-type stars fro m the Beichman et al. (2006) study, the two programs contain ~80 stars with ages of ~10 Myr to ~10 Gyr. Most of these stars have masses of 0.8-1.5 M . Thus, we compare these data with our results for debris disk evolution around 1 M stars. The observed 70-160 um excesses of solar-type stars show trends similar to those ob- served in the evolution of A-type stars at 24-70 um (Fig. 25-26). Although the statistics for solar-type stars are poor for the youngest stars, the data suggest a rise in the 70-160 um excess at 10-100 Myr. The maximum in the 70 um excess is comparable in magnitude but a factor of ~10 later in time than the maximum 70 um excess for A-type stars. At 70 um and at 160um, the excess follows a roughly power-law decline with time for older st ars. Solar- type stars also have a large range in excess at all ages, with F70/F70,01-300 at 100 at 1-3 Gyr. For stars with similar ages, the range in the 70 um excess is larger for solar-type stars than for A-type stars. Our models match the observed trends for the IR excesses of sola r-type stars. At 70 um, 65%-75% of the observations lie within model predictions; at 160 um, more than half of the observations are within model predictions. For a range of initial disk masses (xm0.01-3) and outer radii ( aout70-150 AU), we predict a large range of excesses at all ages, as observed. These model also explain the larger 70 um excesses observed for solar-type stars relative to A-type stars, the apparent maximum in the 70-160 um excess at 30-100 Myr, and the general power-law decline in the excess flux for the oldest s tars. Despite this general success, however, the models underpredict the largest observed- 47 - excesses. At 70 um, the brightest disks are a factor of 5-10 brighter than disks with xm
= 3. At 160 um, the brightest systems are 3-5 times brighter than our most lumin ous disks. Although the sample of 160 um sources is small, our models underpredict the largest observed fluxes at all ages. Changing two assumptions in our models yields a better match to the o bserved fluxes at 70-160um. For realistic grain properties, Burns, Lamy, & Soter (1979) sho w that from the Sun cannot eject small grains from the Solar Sy stem. Reducing the minimum stable grain size from r2= 1um tor2= 0.1um increases our predicted 70 um (160um) fluxes by a factor of 2-3 (1.5-2). Submm observations of sever al debris disks imply q0.6-1 for the slope of the radiative emissivity. If we adopt q= 0.7 instead of q= 1, our predicted 70-160 um fluxes increase by factors of 2-4. Combining these two modificatio ns increase our predicted fluxes by a factor of ~5-10 at both observations could check whether these modifications of our standard model are reasonable. By analogy with the SpitzerVega data, detection of an outflowing wind of small grains in a debris disk around a solar-type star provides a clean meas urement of r2and a better constraint on our predicted IR excesses. Measurements ofqfor larger samples of debris disks allows a better assessment of our assumptions for the grain emissivity. 6. CONCLUSIONS Our calculations provide a robust picture for the formation of plane ts and debris disks from a disk of icy planetesimals and set the context for the evolution of dusty debris in a dynamic system of planets. The results of this study provide a fram ework for observations of debris disks around 1-3 M stars and suggest new of this picture. We describe a suite of numerical calculations of planets growing from ensembles of at 30-150 AU in disks around 1-3 M stars. Using our hybrid code, we solve for the evolution of sizes and orbits of ob jects with radii of ~1 m to km over the main sequence lifetime of the central star. These results allow us to constrain the growth of planets as a function of disk mass, stellar m ass, and semimajor axis. Debris disk formation is coincident with the formation of a planetary s ystem. All cal- culations of icy planet formation at 30-150 AU lead to a collisional casc ade which produces copious amounts of dust on timescales of 5-30 Myr. This dust is obse rvable throughout the lifetime of the central star. Because we consider a broad rang e of input parameters, we derive the time evolution of (i) dust produced in the collisional cascad e and (ii) the IR and- 48 - submm emission from this dust as a function of disk mass, stellar mass , and considerations , and (iii) observational tests. The theoretical consider ations build on the highlights of icy planet formation in SS3.4. Observable consequences of the calculations follow from the discussion in SS4. The observational tests of the models are described in SS5. 6.1. Theoretical planet formation at 30-150 AU is self-limiting. Starting with a swar m runaway growth produces a set of 100-500 km prot oplanets. As the protoplanets grow, they stir up leftover planetesimals along their o rbits. When the leftovers reach high e, collisions produce debris instead of mergers. Because proto- planets cannot accrete leftovers rapidly, a cascade of destruct ive collisions grinds the leftovers to dust. drag and radiation press ure then remove the dust from the disk.
*The maximum sizes of icy planets at 30-150 AU are remarkably indepen dent of initial disk mass, stellar mass, and stellar age. For disks with xm= 1/3 to 3 around 1- 3 Mstars with ages t= 0.1-1tms, the typical planet has rmax~1750 km and mmax~0.005 M . These objects contain of the initial disk mass. t hefinitemain of 1-3 M stars limits the formation of many large planets in the outer disk. Thus, the inner disk produces many more Pluto-mass planets than t he outer disk (Tables 2 and 3).
*For stars close to the main sequence turnoff, stellar lifetimes and th e collisional cascade limit the mass in solid objects at 30-150 AU. In the inner disk, the collisio nal cascade removes most of the leftover planetesimals before the central st ar evolves off the main sequence. Thus, the typical mass in small objects is ~10% of the initial mass at 30- 40 AU. In the outer disk, smaller collision rates produce a slower casc ade. Thus, the central star evolves off the main sequence with ~50% of the initial mass remaining in 1-10 km planetesimals at 125-150 AU.
*The collisional cascade produces copious amounts of dust. Dust be gins to form during the transition from runaway to oligarchic growth ( t= 5-10 Myr), peaks when the first objects reach their maximum sizes ( t= 10-30 Myr), and then slowly declines Myr). The peak mass in 0.001-1 mm (0.001-1 m) particles is ~1-2 lunar masses (~1 M). Disks with initial masses xm= 1/3 to 3 reach these peak masses when the- 49 - age of the star is ~10% to 20% of its main sequence lifetime. Because the timescale to form dust is short ( ~10-20 Myr), stars are surrounded by large disks of debris at 30-150 AU throughout their main sequence processes remove large amounts of mass from debris disk s. Radiation pres- sure produces a radial wind of small particles containing ~60% to 70% of the mass removed from the disk. drag pulls the rest of the lost mass into the inner disk. Because radiation pressure is more important than P when collision rates are large, we expect more wind (inner disk) e mission earlier (later) in the evolution. 6.2. Observable Consequences We derive clear observational consequences of the collisional casc ade.
*Thedusty Mstars, the maximum fractional dust luminosity of Ld/L~2x10-3is comparable to the maximum dust luminosities of known debris disks (Backman & Par esce 1993; Rieke et al. 2005; Su et al. 2006; Rhee et al. 2007a). The dust tempe rature at the inner edge of a 30-150 AU disk scales with the temperature of the ce ntral star; 24 umexcess isverysensitive tothestellar mass. At 70 um, scale roughly linearly with disk mass and stellar mass. The pr edicted 160- 850um excesses depend on the disk mass but are nearly independent of t he systems with little or no emission from terrestrial dust ([5.8]-[8] ), diagrams clearly distinguish debris disks around stars of different masses. In a [8]-[24] vs[24]-[70] diagram, 2-3 M (1-2 M ) stars have red (blue) [8]-[24] and blue (red) [24]-[70] (Fig 20). In both cases, the color scales with the initial disk mass (Fig 21). Optical colors and spectra generally provide good estimat es for stellar mass; thus, these diagrams provide good tests of our model predictions . 6.3. Observational Tests We compare our predictions with observations of A-type stars and solar-type stars.
*For A-type stars, our calculations are the first to explain the obse rved rise and fall of- 50 - debris disk fluxes at 24 um (Fig. 22; Currie et al. 2008a,b). In our picture, the rise small planetesimals produce larger protoplanets - to oligarchic gr owth - when the collisional cascade begins to grind leftover planetesimals into dust. W hen oligarchs in the inner disk are close to their maximum sizes of ~1750 km, the collisional cascade produces a maximum in debris disk emission. For a wide range of initial co nditions, this maximum occurs at 10-20 Myr. As the collisional cascade moves o ut through the disk, smaller collision rates produce less dust which emits at lower t the 24 um excess falls with time. The predicted rate of decline, is close to the observed rate ( n0.5-1; Greaves & Wyatt 2003; Rieke et al. 2005; Rhee et al. 2007a).
*At longer wavelengths, the maximum excess is larger and lasts longer than at 24 um. Predicted mid-IR colors also increase slowly with time. Although larger samples of A-type stars with 8 um photometry would provide a better test of our models, current data for the 70 um excess and the evolution of the [24]-[70] color agree with our predic - tions (Fig. 23-24). For 2-3 M stars near the main-sequence turnoff, our yield a clear maximum in the 850 um flux. Large surveys, such as the proposed JCMT Legacy Survey (Matthews et al. 2007) and submm observatio ns with ALMA, Herschel and SOFIA, can test this prediction.
*For solar-type stars, our models match observations of most sou rces. The of the 70-160 um excesses follows the observed rise at 10-100 Myr, the peak at~30-100 Myr, and the decline at Myr. Although ~70% (55%) of observed debris disks have fluxes that lie within model predictions, our models u for the brightest sources by a factor of 5-10. Fluxes for m odels with provide better matches to these observations. To guide our ch oices for r2 andq, we require spatially resolved images and submm fluxes for these obj ects.
*For 1-3 M stars with ages ~0.1-1 Gyr, current data suggest that solar-type stars have a larger range of far-IR excesses than A-type stars. In ou r models, faster debris disk evolution around A-type stars produces a smaller dispersion in f ar-IR excesses and colors for stars with ages of 100 Myr to 1 Gyr. Larger samples of de bris disks can test this prediction in more detail.
*We also consider observations of Vega, the prototypical debris dis k. If we adopt mod- els with a blowout radius r2= 10um, we can match observations with a cascade within a broad torus at 80-200 AU. If the torus c ontains~1-5 M in large objects with cm, the cascade can generate (i) the observed ensemble- 51 - of grains with r~200-300 um within the torus and (ii) an outflowing wind of small grains with r~1-50um. This conclusion differs from Su et al. (2006), who postulate a recent between two large objects as the source of the dusty Vega wind. Although the complete destruction of two large icy objects can produce a ma ssive outflowing wind, our results suggest that the dusty wind is short-lived and can not be by the observed population of larger objects. We show that a cascade can explain the Spitzerdata (see also Kenyon & Bromley 2005). If our interpretation is correct, sensitive observations at 1-10 m m should detect our proposed reservoir of larger Adding binary companions and giant planets provides wa ys to modify the evo- lution of the collisional cascade and to impose structure on rings and tori (e.g. Wilner et al. 2002; Moro-Mart' in & Malhotra 2005; Quillen 2006). Extending the c oagulation calcula- tions to smaller sizes allows studies of the formation of winds and othe r large these calculations have been prohibitively expensive in comp uting time, rapid ad- vances in computing technology will make these additions possible in th e next few years. Based on the results described here and in Kenyon & Bromley (2004b ), we conclude that debris disks are the inevitable outcome of icy planet formation in a disk of solid objects. The basic structures produced by this model - broadtori and nar row rings of dust that prop- agate out through the disk (Kenyon & Bromley 2004b) - are consist ent with Jayawardhana et al. 1998; Kalas 2005; Su et al. 2006; Fitzger ald et al. 2007). The model also explains the time evolution of mid-IR colors and fluxes for d ebris disks around A-type and solar-type stars. We acknowledge a generous allotment, ~1000 cpu days, of computer time on the 1024 cpu Dell Xeon cluster 'cosmos' at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory th rough funding from the NASA Offices of Mission to Planet Earth, Aeronautics, and Space Science. We thank M. Werner for his strong support of this project. We also acknowle dge use of ~250 cpu days on the CfA cluster 'hydra.' Advice and comments from T. Currie , M. Geller, G. Kennedy, M. Meyer, G. Rieke, K. Su, and an anonymous referee gr eatly improved Portions of this project were supported by the NASA Astrophysics Theory Program, the NASATPF Foundation Science Program, through grant NNG06GH25G, and the Spitzer Guest Observer Program, through grant 20132.- 52 - A. APPENDIX A.1. Growth rates In standard coagulation theory, protoplanets accrete material from a swarm of planetes- imals at a rate (e.g., Safronov 1969; Lissauer 1987; Wetherill & Stew art 1993) .MS (A1) whereris the radius of a planetesimal, ohm is the angular frequency of material in the disk, vis the random velocity of planetesimals, and vescis the escape velocity of the protoplanet. The 1+( vesc/v)2term is the gravitational focusing factor. To derive the accretion time, we set t=M/.Mand substitute the orbital period for the angular frequency, t(r r (A2) whereris the mass density of a planetesimal. Throughout runaway growth a nd the early stages of oligarchic growth vesc/v1. Because we are interested in the time to produce planets with the same randrin disks with different Pand S, we eliminate randr. Thus, the growth time is (A3) This equation sets the typical timescale for planet growth in a disk of planetesimals. (27)) and v/vesc~constant (Fig. 1; Wetherill & Stewart 1993; Goldreich, Lithwick, & Sari (A4) This result is close to the for the formation of the first 1000 km object in our calculations (e.g., Eq. (41)). To evaluate possible sources for the extra factor of x-0.15 min our derived accretion times, we consider the random velocity vof accreted planetesimals. Shorter growth times require smaller Thus, we consider processes that damp p lanetesimal velocities. In our calculations, collisions and gas drag can reduce v; dynamical friction and viscous At 30-150 AU, gas drag damps random velocities ~10-20 times more rapidly than collisions (Goldreich, Lithwick, & Sari 2004). Thus, we ignore co llisional damping and concentrate on gas drag. Rafikov (2004) investigated the dynamics of small planetesimals and growing proto- planets in a gaseous nebula. For the early stages of oligarchic growt h, the random velocity of planetesimals (A5)- 53 - Substituting this expression into Eq. (A4) and adopting a constant gas-to-dust ratio, S gas~
S, we (A6) withg2= 2g1+1. For typical conditions in planetesimal disks, Rafikov (2004) der ivedg1 1/6 to 1/5. Thus, g21.3 to 1.4, close to the exponent of 1 .15 derived in our treatment of gas drag probably reduces the exponent of xmin Eq. (A6) from the predicted 1 .3-1.4 to 1.15. In our simulations, we assume the gas density declines exponen- tially on a timescale tgas= 10 Myr. With typical growth times of 20-40 Myr, the gas density is~1% to 10% of its initial value when the first 1000 km objects form in the inner disk. Thus, gas drag cannot reduce planetesimal random velocities as effi ciently as predicted in Eq. A6. Reducing drag lowers the exponent. With gas depletion times cales~25% to 50%
of the growth time, we expect an exponent of g21.1 to 1.2, similar to the g2= 1.15 in Radiation from dust In the Appendix of Kenyon & Bromley (2004a), we briefly described o ur simple algo- rithm for the evolution of particles with sizes smaller than the smallest object - r~1 m - followed in the multiannulus coagulation code. This algorithm yields the o ptical depth in very small grains ejected from the system and the optical depth in larger grains evolving under the influence of collisions and drag. The optical depth in both grain populations allows us to derive the time evolution of the disk lumino sity and in bolometric units. Here, we describe the derivation of g rain temperature for these populations that yields the predicted time evolution of the bro adband spectral of debris disks. As in Kenyon & Bromley (2004a), we divide objects with sizes smaller th an~1 m into very small grains, small grains, and large grains. In each annulu skof our pressure ejects very small grains with radii between r1andr2. Ifrgis the mass density of these grains and .Mkis the production rate of very small grains in each annulus, the very small grains have an integrated optical (A7) whereab,kis the inner boundary of an annulus centered at ak,hkis the vertical scale height in units of the semimajor axis, and vK,kis the orbital velocity in annulus k.- 54 - For small ( r=r2to 1 mm) and large grains ( r= 1 mm to 1 m), we derive the each annulus. To derive the radial surface brightness and total disk luminosity, we follow Kenyon & Hartmann (1987) and derive the amount of stellar radiation absorbed by each annulus. We assume a spherical, limb-darkened star with rad iusR, luminosity L, and limb-darkening parameter o0= 0.6. For a point Pat the outer boundary of annulus k withheight hPabovethedisk midplane, raysfromthestar enter theannulus ata s (below) the midplane. We compute the length lof the path through the disk and derive the optical depth along this path as tp= (l/ak)tk, where akis the width of the annulus. The radiation absorbed along this path is e-tpI0, whereI0is the flux incident on the boundary of the annulus. Numerical integrations over the ste llar surface and the vertical extent of an annulus yield the amount of flux absorbed by each annu lus, which we convert to relative surface brightness. A final numerical integration over the radial extent of the disk yields the ratio of the disk luminosity to the stellar luminosity, wemakesev eralassumptions. Con- sistent with observations of scattered light from resolved debris d isks (Backman & Paresce 1993; Lagrange et al. 2000), we adopt a single albedo o= 0.25 for all grains. For all l, the luminosity in scattered light is then oLd/L; the thermal luminosity emitted by all grains is (1-o)Ld/L. In each annulus k, we assume grains emit at a temperature Ti,k, where the indexirefers to discrete bins in grain size. To derive equilibrium temperatur es for these grains, we assume the grains have an absorption efficiency oa(l/l0)pand radiative For most grains in our calculations, the grain size is larger than the peak wavelength of radiation emitted by the central star. Thus, t he grains efficiently absorb stellar photons and p= 0. Large grains with rlemit as blackbodies and have q= 0. Smaller grains radiate less efficiently and have O., et al. 2006, A&A, 452, 237 Adachi, I., Hayashi, C., & Nakazawa, K. 1976, Progress of Theoret ical Physics 56, 1756 Allen, C. W. 1976, Astrophysical Quantities, Athlone, London, p. 197 Andrews, S. M., & Williams, J. P. 2005, ApJ, 631, 1134 Andrews, S. M., & Williams, J. P. 2007a, ApJ, 659, 705 Andrews, S. M., & Williams, J. P. 2007b, ApJ, 671, 1800- 55 - Artymowicz, P. 1988, ApJ, 335, L79 Artymowicz, P. 1997, ARE&PS, 25, 175 Asphaug, E., & Benz, W. 1996, Icarus, 121, 225 Aufdenberg, J. P., et al. 2006, ApJ, 645, 664 Augereau, J.-C., & Beust, H. 2006, A&A, 455, 987 Augereau, J. C., Lagrange, A.-M., Mouillet, D., Papaloizou, J. C. B., & G rorod, P. A. 1999, A&A, 348, 557 Aumann, H. H., et al. 1984, ApJ, 278, L23 Backman, D. E., & Paresce, F. 1993, in Protostars and Planets III , eds. E. H. Levy & J. I. Lunine, Tucson, Univ of Arizona, p. 1253 Barge, P., & Pellat, R. 1991, Icarus, 93, 270 Beichman, C. A., et al. 2005, ApJ, 626, 1061 Beichman, C. A., et al. 2006, ApJ, 652, 1674 Benz, W., & Asphaug, E. 1999, Icarus, 142, 5 Brandeker, A., Liseau, R., Olofsson, G., & Fridlund, M. 2004, A&A, 41 3, 681 Bromley, B., & Kenyon, S. J. 2006, AJ, 131, 2737 Brownlee, D. E., et al. 1997, Meteoritics & Planetary Science, vol. 32 , page A22, 32, 22 Bryden, G., et al. 2006, ApJ, 636, 1098 Burns, J. A., Lamy, P. L., & Soter, S. 1979, Icarus, 40, 1 Campo Bagatin, A., Cellino, A., Davis, D. R., Farinella, P., & Paolicchi, P. 19 94 Carpenter, J. M., Mamajek, E. E., Hillenbrand, L. A., & Meyer, M. R. 2 006, ApJ, 651, L49 Chambers, J. E. 2001, Icarus, 152, 205 Chambers, J. 2006, Icarus, 180, 496 Charnoz, S., & Morbidelli, A. 2003, Icarus, 166, 141 Chen, C. H., et al. 2005, ApJ, 634, 1372- 56 - Chen, C. H., et al. 2006, ApJS, 166, 351 Ciesla, F. J. 2007, ApJ, 654, L159 Currie, T., et al. 2007, ApJ, 659, 599 Currie, T., Kenyon, S. J., Rieke, G., Balog, Z., & Bromley, B. C. 2007, A pJ, 663, L105 Currie, T., Kenyon, S. J., Balog, Z., Bragg, A., & Tokarz, S. 2007, Ap J, 669, L33 Currie, T., Kenyon, S. J., Balog, Z., Rieke, G., Bragg, A., & Bromley, B. 2008, ApJ, 672, 558 Currie, T., Plavchan, P., & Kenyon, S. J. 2008b, ApJ, submitted Davis, D. R., Chapman, C. R., Weidenschilling, S. J., & Greenberg, R. 19 85, Icarus, 62, 30 Decin, G., Dominik, C., Waters, L. B. F. M., & Waelkens, C. 2003, ApJ, 5 98, 636 Demarque, P., Woo, J.-H., Kim, Y.-C., & Yi, S. K. 2004, ApJS, 155, 667 Dent, W. R. F., Walker, H. J., Holland, W. S., & Greaves, J. S. 2000, MN RAS, 314, 702 Dohnanyi, J. W. 1969, J. Geophys. Res., 74, 2531 Dominik, C., & Decin, G. 2003, ApJ, 598, 626 Dullemond, C. P., & Dominik, C. 2005, A&A, 434, 971 Durda, D. D., & Dermott, S. F. 1997, Icarus, 130, 140 Elliot, J. L., Person, M. J., & Qu, S. 2003, AJ, 126, 1041 Elliot, J. L., et al. 2007, AJ, 134, 1 Fitzgerald, M. P., Kalas, P. G., & Graham, J. R. 2007, ApJ, 670, 557 Garaud, P. 2007, ApJ, 671, 2091 Goldreich, P., Lithwick, Y., & Sari, R. 2004, ARA&A, 42, 549 Golimowski, D. A., Durrance, S. T., & Clampin, M. 1993, ApJ, 411, L41 Gomes, R., Levison, H. F., Tsiganis, K., & Morbidelli, A. 2005, Nature, 4 35, 466 Gorlova, N., Balog, Z., Rieke, G. H., Muzerolle, J., Su, K. Y. L., Ivanov, V. D., & Young, E. T. 2007, ApJ, 670, 516- 57 - Gorlova, N., Rieke, G. H., Muzerolle, J., Stauffer, J. R., Siegler, N., You ng, E. T., & Stans- berry, J. H. 2006, ApJ, 649, 1028 Greaves, J. S. et al. 1998, ApJ, 506, L133 Greaves J. S., Mannings V. & Holland, W. S. 2000b, Icarus, 143, 155 Greaves, J. S., & Wyatt, M. C. 2003, MNRAS, 345, 1212 Greenberg, R., Weidenschilling, S. J., Chapman, C. R., & Davis, D. R. 19 84, Icarus, 59, 87 Greenberg, R., Bottke, W., Carusi, A., Valsecchi, G. B. 1991, Icaru s, 94, 98 Greenzweig, Y., & Lissauer, J. J. 1990, Icarus, 87, 40 Greenzweig, Y., & Lissauer, J. J. 1992, Icarus, 100, 440 Grigorieva, A., Artymowicz, P., & Th' ebault, P. 2007, A&A, 461, 537 Gr un, E., et al. 1995, Planet. Space Sci., 43, 971 Habing, H. J., et al. 2001, A&A, 365, 545 Hahn, J. M., Zook, H. A., Cooper, B., & Sunkara, B. 2002, Icarus, 1 58, 360 Haisch, K., Lada, E. A., & Lada, C. J. 2001, ApJ, 553, 153 Hayashi, C. 1981, Prog Theor Phys Suppl, 70, 35 Hern' andez, J., Brice~ no, C., Calvet, N., Hartmann, L., Muzerolle, J ., & Quintero, A. 2006, ApJ, 652, 472 Hillenbrand, L. A., et al. 2008, ArXiv e-prints, 801, W. S., et al. 1998, Nature, 392, 788 Holland, W. S., et al. 2003, ApJ, 582, 1141 Hornung, P., Pellat, R., & Barge, P. 1985, Icarus, 64, 295 Iben, I. Jr, 1967, ARA&A, 5, 571 Ida, S. 1990, Icarus, 88, 129 Ida, S., & Lin, D. N. C. 2008, ArXiv e-prints, 802, S., & Makino, J. 1992, Icarus, 96, 107- 58 - Ida, S., & Makino, J. 1993, Icarus, 106, 210 Inaba, S. H., Tanaka, H., Nakazawa, K., Wetherill, G. W., & Kokubo, E. 2001, Icarus, R. et al. 1998, ApJ, 503, L79 Johnson, J. A., et al. 2007, ApJ, 665, 785 Kalas, P. 1998, Earth, Moon, & Planets, 81, 27 Kalas, P. 2005, ApJ, 635, L169 Kalas, P., Graham, J. R., & Clampin, M. 2005, Nature, 435, 1067 Kalas, P., Graham, J. R., Clampin, M. C., & Fitzgerald, M. P. 2006, ApJ, 637, L57 Kalas, P., Liu, M. C., & Matthews, B. C. 2004, Science, 303, 1990 Kennedy, G. M., & Kenyon, S. J. 2008, ApJ, 673, 502 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C. 2001, AJ, 121, 538 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C. 2002a, AJ, 123, 1757 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C. 2002b, ApJ, 577, L35 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C., 2004a, AJ, 127, 513 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C., 2004b, ApJ, 602, L133 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C., 2004c, AJ, 128, 1916 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C. 2005, AJ, 130, 269 Kenyon, S. J., & Bromley, B. C. 2006, AJ, 131, 1837 Kenyon, S. J., Bromley, B. C., O'Brien, D. C., & Davis, D. R. 2008, to ap pear inThe Solar System Beyond Neptune, edited by A. Barucci, H. Boehnhardt, D. Cruikshank, & A. Morbidelli, Tucson, Univ. of Arizona Press, in press Kenyon, S. J., & Hartmann, L. 1987, ApJ, 323, 714 Kenyon, S. J., & Hartmann, L. W., 1995, ApJS, 101, 117- 59 - Kenyon, S. J., & Luu, J. X. 1998, AJ, 115, 2136 Kenyon, S. J., & Luu, J. X. 1999, AJ, 118, 1101 Kenyon, S. J., Wood, K., Whitney, B. A., & Wolff, M. 1999, ApJ, 524, L1 19 Kim, J. S., et al. 2005, ApJ, 632, 659 Kimura, H., Okamoto, H., & Mukai, T. 2002, Icarus, 157, 349 Knapp, G. R., & Morris, M. 1985, ApJ, 292, 640 Kobayashi, H., & Ida, S. 2001, Icarus, 153, 416 Koeberl, C. 2003, EM&P, 92, 79 Koerner, D. W., Ressler, M. E., Werner, M. W., & Backman, D. E. 1998 , ApJ, 503, L83 Koerner, D. W., Sargent, A. I., & Ostroff, N. A. 2001, ApJ, 560, L1 81 Kokubo, E., & Ida, S. 1998, Icarus, 131, 171 Kretke, K. A., Lin, D. N. C., Garaud, P., & Turner, N. J. 2008, ArXiv e -prints, A. V., Mann, I., & Krivova, N. A. 2000, A&A, 362, 1127 Krivov, A. V., L ohne, T., & SremV cevi' c, M. 2006, A&A, 455, 509 Kuchner, M. J., & Holman, M. J. 2003, ApJ, 588, 1110 Lada, C. J. 1999, in The Physics of Star Formation and Early Stellar Evolution, edited by C. J. Lada and N. Kylafis, Dordrecht, Kluwer, p. 143 Lagrange, A.-M., Backman, D., & Artymowicz, P. 2000, in Protostar s & Planets IV, eds. V. Mannings, A. P. Boss, & S. S. Russell, Tucson, Univ. of Arizona, in pr ess Landgraf, M., Liou, J.-C., Zook, H. A., & Gr un, E. 2002, AJ, 123, 28 57 Larwood, J. D. 1997, MNRAS, 290, 490 Larwood, J. D., & Kalas, P. G. 2001, MNRAS, 323, 402 Leinhardt, Z. M., Stewart, S. T., & Schultz, P. H. 2008, to appear in The Solar System Be- yond Neptune, edited by A. Barucci, H. Boehnhardt, D. Cruikshank, & A. Univ. of Arizona Press, in press (ArXiv e-prints, 705, arX iv:0705.3943)- 60 - Levison, H. F., & Stewart, G. R. 2001, Icarus, 153, 224 Lin, D. N. C., & Papaloizou, J. C. B. 1979, MNRAS, 186, 799 Lissauer, J. J. 1987, Icarus, 69, 249 Lissauer, J. J., & Stewart, G. R. 1993, In Protostars and Planets III, edited by E. H. Levy and J. I. Lunine, U. of Arizona Press, Tucson, 1061 Lisse, C. M., Beichman, C. A., Bryden, G., & Wyatt, M. C. 2007, ApJ, 6 58, 584 Lisse, C. M., Chen, C. H., Wyatt, M. C., & Morlok, A. 2007, ArXiv e-prin ts, C. M., Kraemer, K. E., Nuth, J. A., Li, A., & Joswiak, D. 2007, Ic arus, 191, 223 Liu, M. C. 2004, Science, 305, 1442 Liu, M. C., Matthews, B. C., Williams, J. P., & Kalas, P. G. 2004, ApJ, 608 , 526 Liu, W. M., et al. 2004, ApJ, 610, L125 L ohne, T., Krivov, A. V., & Rodmann, J. 2008, ApJ, 673, 1123 Marsh, K. A., Dowell, C. D., Velusamy, T., Grogan, K., & Beichman, C. A. 2006, ApJ, B. C., et al. 2007, PASP, 119, 842 Melosh, H. J., Vockery, A. M., & Tonks, W. B. 1993, in Protostars and Planets III , eds. E. H. Levy & J. I. Lunine, Tucson, Univ of Arizona, p. 1339 Meyer, M. R., Backman, D. E., Weinberger, A. J., & Wyatt, M. C. 2007 , Protostars and Planets V, 573 Meyer, M. R., et al. 2006, PASP, 118, 1690 Meyer, M. R., et al. 2008, ApJ, 673, L181 Mo' or, A., 'Abrah' am, P., Derekas, A., Kiss, C., Kiss, L. L., Apai, D., Grady, C., & H enning, T. 2006, ApJ, 644, 525 Moro-Mart' in, A., & Malhotra, R. 2005, ApJ, 633, 1150- 61 - Moro-Martin, A., Wyatt, M. C., Malhotra, R., & Trilling, D. E. 2007, ArX iv F., & Andr' e, P. 2001, A&A, 365, 440 Mouillet, D., Larwood, J. D., Papaloizou, J. C. B., & Lagrange, A.-M. 19 97, MNRAS, M., Thommes, E. W., Kenyon, S. J., Bromley, B. C., & Lin, D. N. C. 2007, Protostars and Planets V, 639 Najita, J., & Williams, J. P. 2005, ApJ, 635, 625 Natta, A., Grinin, V., & Mannings, V. 2000, Protostars and Planets I V, 559 Nesvorn' y, D., Vokrouhlick' y, D., Bottke, W. F., & Sykes, M. 2006, Icarus, 181, 107 Nomura, H., & Nakagawa, Y. 2006, ApJ, 640, 1099 Ohtsuki, K. 1992, Icarus, 98, 20 Ohtsuki, K., Stewart, G. R., & Ida, S. 2002, Icarus, 155, 436 Osterloh, M., & Beckwith, S. V. W. 1995, ApJ, 439, 288 Pan, M., & Sari, R. 2005, Icarus, 173, 342 Press, W. H., Flannery, B. P., Teukolsky, S. A., &Vetterling, W. T. 19 92,Numerical Recipes, The Art of Scientific Computing, Cambridge, A. C. 2006, MNRAS, 372, L14 Quillen, A. C., Morbidelli, A., & Moore, A. 2007, MNRAS, 380, 1642 Rafikov, R. R. 2003, AJ, 125, 942 Rafikov, R. R. 2004, AJ, 128, 1348 Rhee, J. H., Song, I., Zuckerman, B., & McElwain, M. 2007, ApJ, 660, 1556 Rhee, J. H., Song, I., & Zuckerman, B. 2007, ArXiv e-prints, 711, a G. H., Su, K. Y. L., Stansberry, J. A., Trilling, D., Bryden, G., Mu zerolle, J., White, B., Gorlova, N., Young, E. T., Beichman, C. A., Stapelfeldt, K. R., & hine s, D. C. 2005, ApJ, 620, 1010- 62 - Safronov, V. S. 1969, Evolution of the Protoplanetary Cloud and F ormation of the Earth and Planets, Nauka, Moscow [Translation 1972, NASA TT G., et al. 1999, ApJ, 513, L127 Scholz, A., Jayawardhana, R., & Wood, K. 2006, ApJ, 645, A., et al. 2006, ApJ, 638, 897 Siegler, N., Muzerolle, J., Young, E. T., Rieke, G. H., Mamajek, E. E., Tr illing, D. E., Gorlova, N., & Su, K. Y. L. 2007, ApJ, 654, 580 Smith, B. A., & Terrile, R. J. 1984, Science, 226, 1421 Song, I., Zuckerman, B., Weinberger, A. J., & Becklin, E. E. 2005, Na ture, 436, 363 Spaute, D., Weidenschilling, S. J., Davis, D. R., & Marzari, F. 1991, Ica rus, 92, 147 Stapelfeldt, K. R., et al. 2004, ApJS, 154, 458 Stauffer, J. R., et al. 2005, AJ, 130, 1834 Stern, S. A., & Colwell, J. E. 1997a, AJ, 114, 841 Stewart, G. R., & Ida, S. 2000, Icarus, 143, 28 Su, K. Y. L., et al. 2005, ApJ, 628, 487 Su, K. Y. L., et al. 2006, ApJ, 653, 675 Su, K. Y. L., Rieke, G. H., Stapelfeldt, K. R., Smith, P. S., Bryden, G., C hen, C. H., &
Trilling, D. E. 2008, ApJ, 679, L125 Swindle, T. D. 1993, in Protostars and Planets III , eds. E. H. Levy & J. I. Lunine, Tucson, Univ of Arizona, p. 867 Takeuchi, T., & Artymowicz, P. 2001, ApJ, 557, 990 Telesco, C. M., Decher, R., Becklin, E. E., & Wolstencroft, R. D. 1988 , Nature, 335, 51 Telesco, C. M., et al. 2000, ApJ, 530, 329 Th' ebault, P., & Augereau, J.-C. 2007, A&A, 472, 169- 63 - Th' ebault, P., Augereau, J. C., & Beust, H. 2003, A&A, 408, 775 Trilling, D. E., et al. 2007, ApJ, 658, 1289 Trilling, D. E., et al. 2008, ApJ, 674, 1086 Wadhwa, M., & Russell, S. S. 2000, in Protostars abd Planets IV , eds. V. Mannings, A. P. Boss, & S. S. Russell, Tucson, Univ. of Arizona, p. S. J. 1977a, Astrophys Sp Sci, 51, S. J. 1977b, MNRAS, 180, S. J. 1989, Icarus, 80, S. J., Spaute, D., Davis, D. R., Marzari, F., & Ohtsuki, K . 1997, Icarus, 128, 429 Wetherill, G. W. 1980, ARA&A, 18, 77 Wetherill, G. W., & Stewart, G. R. 1993, Icarus, 106, 190 Williams, D. R., & Wetherill, G. W. 1994, Icarus, 107, 117 Williams, J. P., & Andrews, S. M. 2006, ApJ, 653, 1480 Wilner, D. J., Holman, M. J., Kuchner, M. J., & Ho, P. T. P. 2002, ApJ, 5 69, 115 Wolf, S., & Hillenbrand, L. A. 2003, ApJ, 596, 603 Wood, K., Lada, C. J., Bjorkman, J. E., Kenyon, S. J., Whitney, B., Wo lff, M. J. 2002, ApJ, 567, 1183 Wyatt, M. C. 2003, ApJ, 598, 1321 Wyatt, M. C. 2005, A&A, 433, 1007 Wyatt, M. C., & Dent, W. R. F. 2002, MNRAS, 334, 589 Wyatt, M. C., Dent, W. R. F., & Greaves, J. S. 2003, MNRAS, 342, 86 7 Wyatt, M. C., Dermott, S. F., Telesco, C. M., Fisher, R. S., Grogan, K ., Holmes, E. K., &
Pi~ na, R. K. 1999, ApJ, 527, 918 Wyatt, M. C., Smith, R., Greaves, J. S., Beichman, C. A., Bryden, G., & Lisse, C. M. 2007, ApJ, 658, 569- 64 - Wyatt, M. C., Smith, R., Su, K. Y. L., Rieke, G. H., Greaves, J. S., Beich man, C. A., &
Bryden, G. 2007, ApJ, 663, 365 Yin, Q., Jacobsen, S. B., Yamashita, K., Blichert-Toft, J., T' elouk, P .; Albar` ede, F. 2002, Nature, 418, 949 Young, E. F., & Binzel, R. P. 1994, Icarus, 108, 219 Zuckerman, B. 2001, ARA&A, 39, 549 This preprint was prepared with the AAS L ATEX macros v5.2.- 65 - Table 1. Grid of Debris Disk Mass in M xm1.0b1.0c1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0.33 41 19 15 20 18 18 0.50 49 18 18 17 17 17 1.00 49 15 22 17 15 15 2.00 41 15 30 17 16 15 3.00 45 18 12 22 15 21 tmsd10.00 10.00 2.90 1.22 0.65 0.39 aNumber of independent calculations for each combina- tion ofM,xm b32 annulus models at 30-70 AU and at 70-150 AU c64 annulus models at 30-150 AU dMain sequence lifetime in Gyr Demarque et al. (2004)- 66 - Table 2. Median number of Plutos at t = tms/3 for disks around 1 M stars xm30-37 AU 37-45 AU 45-55 AU 55-67 AU 67-82 AU 82-100 AU 100-123 A U 123-146 AU 0.33 40 44 33 32 19 12 3 1 0.50 62 65 39 49 33 25 10 1 1.00 111 110 73 73 47 55 26 5 2.00 172 194 134 155 116 84 58 33 3.00 165 260 172 251 137 109 85 44- 67 - Table 3. Median number of Plutos at t = tms/3 for disks around 1.5-3 M stars xm30-37 AU 37-45 AU 45-55 AU 55-67 AU 67-82 AU 82-100 AU 100-123 A U 123-146 AU 1.5 M 0.33 46 46 45 28 16 3 1 1 0.50 69 85 68 48 53 25 2 1 1.00 102 136 128 101 98 67 28 2 2.00 158 243 240 261 211 123 169 47 3.00 201 239 301 295 381 165 198 97 2.0 M 0.33 55 51 48 30 2 1 1 3 0.50 115 87 85 51 20 10 1 2 1.00 172 187 231 123 82 50 1 3 2.00 261 230 366 236 324 204 77 5 3.00 259 262 398 264 446 295 171 48 2.5 M 0.33 105 92 63 55 19 1 5 2 0.50 152 139 123 100 53 10 5 5 1.00 164 174 234 198 125 90 7 6 2.00 223 230 278 243 158 108 10 8 3.00 353 434 490 495 477 615 313 157 3.0 M 0.33 133 121 62 36 6 5 1 1 0.50 127 153 129 103 50 2 2 1 1.00 199 230 239 258 171 66 6 5 2.00 224 353 376 392 342 265 173 5 3.00 428 598 479 657 570 756 578 272- 68 - Table 4. Predicted Excesses for Disks Around 1 M Starsa logt(yr) log 0.33 5.05 -4.57 0.000 0.053 0.145 0.090 5.15 -4.57 0.000 0.053 0.145 0.090 5.25 -4.63 0.000 0.047 0.131 0.082 5.35 -4.65 0.000 0.045 0.127 0.080 5.45 -4.67 0.000 0.043 0.123 0.077 xm= 1.0 5.05 -4.18 0.000 0.096 0.255 0.172 5.15 -4.18 0.000 0.096 0.255 0.172 5.25 -4.29 0.000 0.090 0.243 0.164 5.35 -4.31 0.000 0.088 0.238 0.161 5.45 -4.33 0.000 0.086 0.233 0.158 xm= 3.0 5.05 -4.02 0.000 0.162 0.464 0.357 5.15 -4.06 0.000 0.150 0.410 0.307 5.25 -4.10 0.000 0.138 0.355 0.257 5.35 -4.12 0.000 0.133 0.354 0.248 5.45 -4.14 0.000 0.127 0.332 0.238 aThe electronic version of this paper contains the complete version o f this Table.- 69 - Table 5. Predicted Excesses for Disks Around 1.5 M Starsa logt(yr) log 0.33 5.05 -4.40 0.001 0.100 0.202 0.110 5.15 -4.45 0.001 0.090 0.184 0.099 5.25 -4.51 0.001 0.078 0.163 0.088 5.35 -4.52 0.001 0.074 0.157 0.085 5.45 -4.53 0.001 0.070 0.151 0.082 xm= 1.0 5.05 -4.01 0.001 0.162 0.321 0.188 5.15 -4.19 0.001 0.148 0.299 0.178 5.25 -4.22 0.001 0.140 0.287 0.170 5.35 -4.24 0.001 0.133 0.275 0.163 5.45 -4.24 0.001 0.128 0.266 0.157 xm= 3.0 5.05 -3.73 0.002 0.206 0.406 0.261 5.15 -4.01 0.002 0.199 0.394 0.251 5.25 -4.04 0.002 0.192 0.382 0.242 5.35 -4.05 0.002 0.181 0.361 0.227 5.45 -4.08 0.002 0.167 0.339 0.211 aThe electronic version of this paper contains the complete version o f this Table.- 70 - Table 6. Predicted Excesses for Disks Around 2.0 M Starsa logt(yr) log 0.33 5.05 -4.28 0.002 0.128 0.215 0.109 5.15 -4.34 0.002 0.118 0.201 0.102 5.25 -4.41 0.002 0.108 0.191 0.096 5.35 -4.43 0.002 0.103 0.183 0.092 5.45 -4.46 0.002 0.098 0.175 0.087 xm= 1.0 5.05 -3.89 0.003 0.195 0.334 0.185 5.15 -4.00 0.003 0.186 0.320 0.177 5.25 4.11 0.003 0.177 0.309 0.170 5.35 -4.16 0.003 0.175 0.307 0.168 5.45 -4.18 0.003 0.161 0.286 0.156 xm= 3.0 5.05 -3.71 0.005 0.248 0.421 0.250 5.15 -3.98 0.005 0.239 0.409 0.240 5.25 -4.02 0.004 0.227 0.389 0.226 5.35 -4.02 0.004 0.207 0.358 0.205 5.45 -4.07 0.004 0.192 0.333 0.188 aThe electronic version of this paper contains the complete version o f this Table.- 71 - Table 7. Predicted Excesses for Disks Around 2.5 M Starsa logt(yr) log 0.33 5.05 -4.18 0.004 0.170 0.259 0.120 5.15 -4.22 0.004 0.153 0.233 0.108 5.25 -4.34 0.004 0.137 0.207 0.096 5.35 -4.36 0.004 0.130 0.197 0.093 5.45 -4.38 0.004 0.123 0.188 0.086 xm= 1.0 5.05 -3.97 0.008 0.237 0.352 0.181 5.15 -4.08 0.007 0.219 0.329 0.168 5.25 -4.09 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 5.35 -4.14 0.006 0.201 0.306 0.154 5.45 -4.14 0.005 0.187 0.287 0.144 xm= 3.0 5.05 -3.83 0.010 0.285 0.424 0.230 5.15 -3.95 0.009 0.270 0.403 0.217 5.25 -3.98 0.009 0.258 0.387 0.206 5.35 -4.03 0.009 0.248 0.372 0.197 5.45 -3.48 0.087 0.749 0.887 0.558 aThe electronic version of this paper contains the complete version o f this Table.- 72 - Table 8. Predicted Excesses for Disks Around 3.0 M Starsa logt(yr) log 0.33 5.05 -4.08 0.011 0.173 0.229 0.099 5.15 -4.11 0.010 0.164 0.213 0.091 5.25 -4.14 0.009 0.152 0.198 0.083 5.35 -4.16 0.008 0.140 0.183 0.076 5.45 -4.19 0.007 0.134 0.174 0.072 xm= 1.0 5.05 -3.96 0.015 0.254 0.326 0.150 5.15 -4.01 0.014 0.239 0.310 0.142 5.25 -4.04 0.013 0.227 0.297 0.135 5.35 -4.07 0.012 0.216 0.282 0.127 5.45 -4.10 0.011 0.204 0.269 0.120 xm= 3.0 5.05 -3.83 0.020 0.318 0.410 0.199 5.15 -3.88 0.019 0.301 0.390 0.189 5.25 -3.92 0.030 0.321 0.389 0.187 5.35 -3.38 0.113 0.661 0.740 0.416 5.45 -3.01 0.226 0.934 0.987 0.592 aThe electronic version of this paper contains the complete version o f this Table.- 73 - Table 9. Debris disk loci in color-color space M(M) x 0.00,0.0 4.0,0.1 5.00,0.00 1.5 1.50,0.0 4.0,1.5 4.50,0.25 2.0 1.25,0.0 2.5,2.5 3.50,0.50 2.5 1.00,0.0 2.0,4.0 3.00,1.00 3.0 1.00,0.0 1.5,5.0 2.25,1.75- 74 - Table 10. Vega Debris Disk Modela Source 7.2 0.8 0.16 0.006 1.5 7.0 4.0 0.091 3.0 30b Model 1c7.2 0.8 0.16 0.006 4.2 10.0 3.0 0.05 0.9 0.2 Model 2d7.2 0.8 0.16 0.006 7.2 23.0 8.0 0.11 3.8 0.6 Model 3e7.2 0.8 0.16 0.006 10.9 15.0 4.0 0.05 2.4 0.3 Model 4f7.2 0.8 0.16 0.006 15.5 23.0 5.0 0.07 4.8 0.8 aFluxes (F) are in units of Jy; dust mass in 1-50 um particles ( Md,1-50) is in units of 10-3M; dust production rate ( .M) is in units of 1021g yr-1. bDust production rate from Su et al. (2005). Our analysis suggests a smaller dust production yr-1. cDebris disk model with M= 2 M ,xm= 1/3,t= 200 Myr dAs in note (c) for M= 2 M ,xm= 1,t= 200 Myr eAs in note (c) for M= 2.5 M ,xm= 1/2,t= 200 Myr fAs in note (c) for M= 2.5 M ,xm= 1,t= 200 Myr- 75 - -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 log Radius Cumulative Mass (g)0 AU -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 log Radius 1.-- Evolution of a multiannulus coagulation model with S =
0.18(ai/30 AU)-3/2g cm-2at 30-37 AU around a 1 M star.Left: median cumu- lative mass distribution at times indicated in the legend. Right: median at t= 0 (light solid line), t= 10 Myr (filled circles), t= 100 Myr (open boxes), t= 1 Gyr (filled triangles), and t= 10 Gyr (open diamonds). As large objects grow in the disk, they stir up the leftover planetesimals to e~0.1. Disruptive collisions then deplete the population of 0.1-10 km planetesimals, which limits the growth of th e largest objects.- 76 - 25 50 75 100 125 150 Semimajor Axis Radius (km) 178910 Fig. 2.-- Evolution of the radius of the largest object in each annulus f or a MMSN disk around a 1 Mstar. The number to the right of each set of points indicates log tin yr from the start of the calculation. Large objects with r~1000 km form at the inner edge of the disk in 10-100 Myr, in the middle of the disk in 0.3-1 Gyr, and at the edge of the disk in 10 Gyr.- 77 - 25 50 75 100 125 150 Semimajor Axis Radius 3.-- Median radii of the largest objects at 1 Gyr for disks around a 1Mstar. The numbers to the right of each set of points indicate xm, the disk mass in units of the MMSN. Planets form earlier in the inner portions of the most massive disks. I cy planet at maximum radii r~1500 km.- 78 - -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 log Radius (km)262728log Cumulative Mass AU -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 log Radius (km)26272829log Cumulative Mass AU Fig. 4.-- Median cumulative mass distributions at 1 Gyr for annuli at 30- 37 AU (left panel) and at 123-146 AU (right panel) around a 1 M star. The legend indicates xm, the initial disk mass in units of the scaled MMSN. In the inner disk, many large plan ets form and the collisional cascade removes nearly all of the material in objects with km. In the outer disk, few large planets form; collisions are inefficient at removin g material in small objects.- 79 - 25 50 75 100 125 150 Semimajor Axis Radius (km)10 Myr100 Myr Fig. 5.-- Radius of the largest object in each annulus at 10 Myr and at 1 00 Myr for a MMSN disk around a 1 Mstar. The black points indicate results for calculations with 64 annuli; the magenta and cyan points show results for calculations wit h 32 annuli. The good agreement between the 32 annulus and 64 annulus calculations show s that planet formation is not sensitive to the size of the grid.- 80 - 6 7 8 9 10 log Time (yr)16182022log Dust Production Rate (g 6.-- Median production rate of 0.01-1 um objects as a function of time for 30-150 AU disks around a 1 M central star. The legend indicates xm, the initial disk mass in units of the scaled MMSN. As large objects grow during the early stages of t he evolution, the dust production ratedeclines. Once large objects start to stir upthe le ftover planetesimals, rises rapidly. After dust production peaks, the collision rate and dust slowly with time. For all stars, more massive disks eject more m aterial into a wind of small particles.- 81 - 6 7 8 9 10 log Time Dust Mass 7.-- Median mass in 0.001-1 mm objects as a function of time for 30- 150 AU disks around a 1 M central star. The legend indicates xm, the initial disk mass in units of the scaled MMSN. During runaway growth, the median dust mass is small a nd roughly constant in time. As planet formation propagates through the disk, the dust mass grows with time. Once planets form in the outer disk, collisions and Poynting-Roberts on drag removes small grains from the disk.- 82 - 5 6 7 8 9 10 log Time (yr)0123log Radius AU 100 AU Fig. 8.-- Time evolution of the radius of the largest object at 40 AU and at 100 AU for identical disks around 1 M (dot-dashed curves), 2 M (solid curves), and 3 M curves) stars. Planets grow faster around more ma ssive stars and in the inner disks of all stars.- 83 - 25 50 75 100 125 150 Semimajor Axis Radius Myr Fig. 9.-- Median radius of the largest object at 100 Myr in each annulus for a scaled MMSN disk (xm= 1) around 1-3 Mstars. The number to the right of each set of points indicates the stellar mass in M . At all disk radii, large objects form faster around more massive stars. At 30-60 AU, planet formation saturates at radii r~1000-2000 km on relatively short timescales, t~100 Myr (see also Eq. (41)). At larger disk radii, planets form more slowly and do not reach the maximum radius unless the formation time is shorter than the main sequence lifetime.- 84 - -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 log Radius (km)26272829log Cumulative Mass (g)0 Myr 1.0, 1 2.0, 1/2 3.0, 1/330-37 AU, 100 Myr -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 log Radius (km)26272829log Cumulative Mass (g)1.0, 1 2.0, 1 3.0, 130-37 AU, 100 Myr Fig. 30-37 AU around 1-3 M stars.Left: Results for models with S = 0 .18 (ai/30 AU)-3/2 g cm-2. The light solid line indicates the initial mass distribution. The dashed (1 M,xm
= 1), dot-dashed (2 M ,xm= 1/2), and heavy solid (3 M ,xm= 1/3) lines show median results for thesame initial conditions. Right: Results formodels with ascaled surface density (xm= 1), S = 0 .18 (ai/30 AU)-3/2(M/M) g cm-2, and different stellar masses (1 M : dashed line, 2 M : dot-dashed line, and 3 M : heavy solid line). Although more massive planets form around more massive stars, the collisional cascade lea ds to a small dispersion in total disk mass at late times.- 85 - -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 log Radius (km)262728log Cumulative Mass AU -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 log Radius (km)26272829log Cumulative Mass AU Fig. 11.-- Median cumulative mass distributions at t=tmsfor annuli at 30-37 AU (left panel) and at 123-146 AU (right panel) for identical disks (S = 0 .18 (ai/30 AU)-3/2g cm-2) around 1-3 M stars. The legend indicates the stellar mass in M . In the inner disk, many large planets form and the collisional cascade removes a large fract ion of the material in objects with km. In the outer disk, few large planets form; collisions are ineffi cient at removing material in small objects.- 86 - 6 7 8 9 10 log Time Dust Production Rate (g 12.-- Median production rate of 0.01-1 um objects at 30-150 AU as a function of time for scaled MMSN ( xm= 1) around 1-3 M central stars. The legend indicates the stellar mass in M . For scaled MMSN, disks around more massive stars eject much mor e material in very small grains at early times ( -100 Myr). In an ensemble of stars with a variety of disk masses, there is wide range of dust production rates.- 87 - 5 6 7 8 9 log Time Dust Mass 13.-- Median mass in 0.001-1 mm objects as a function of time for sc aled MMSN ( xm
= 1) at 30-150 AU around 1-3 M central stars. The legend indicates the stellar mass in M. For Myr, icy planet formation produces little dust. At 10-100 Myr, t he mass in small grains is ~1 lunar mass for most disks. At late times, the mass in small grains slowly declines to currently undetectable levels.- 88 - 6 7 8 9 10 log Time (yr)-5-4-3-2log Relative Disk 14.-- Time evolution of the median Ld/L(dust luminosity relative to the luminosity of the central star) for disks surrounding a 1 Mstar. The legend indicates the disk mass in units of the MMSN. More massive disks reach larger peak dust lumino sities earlier than less massive disks. The typical peak dust luminosity is comparable to t he dust luminosity of the most luminous debris disks associated with solar-type stars.- 89 - 6 7 8 9 10 log Time 7 8 9 10 log Time 15.-- As in Fig. 14 for the median 70 um excess (left panel) and the median 850 um excess (right panel). At both wavelengths, dust emission begins to increase at 5-10 Myr. Peak dust emission occurs at 30-100 Myr (70 um) and 100-300 Myr (850 um). When the central star evolves off the main sequence, the typical excess at 70um (850um) is~2-3 (3-10) times the flux from the central star.- 90 - 6 7 8 9 10 log Time (F70/F70,0) 150 AU 70 AU 6 7 8 9 10 log Time (F850/F850,0)150 AU 70 AU Fig. 16.-- Variation of dust excess with disk size. Left panel: time evolution of the median 70um excess for MMSN disks with outer radii of 70 AU (dashed line) and 15 0 AU (solid line). At late times, smaller disks produce smaller IR excesses. it Right panel: as in the left panel for the median 850 um excess.- 91 - 5 6 7 8 9 log Time (yr)-4-3-2log Relative Disk Luminosity2 6 7 8 9 log Time (yr)-4-3-2log Relative Disk Luminosity3 17.-- Time evolution of the median Ld/Lfor MMSN disks surrounding 2 Mstars (left panel) and 3 Mstars (right panel). The legend indicates the initial disk mass in units of the scaled MMSN. The typical maximum dust luminosity, Ld/L~10-3is comparable to the dust luminosity of the brightest debris disks around A-type s tars.- 92 - 6 7 8 9 10 log Time (F160/F160,0) 6 7 8 9 10 log Time 18.-- Time evolution of median IR excesses for MMSN disks around 1 -3Mstars. The legend in the lower left panel indicates the stellar mass in solar masses for each curve in all panels.Lower left panel: 24um excess. Upper left panel: 70um excess. Upper right panel: 160um excess. Lower right panel: 850um excess. At 24 um, the peak excess with the temperature of the central star. Thus, hot ter stars produce much larger 24 um excesses. At longer wavelengths, the magnitude of the excess is correlated with the mass of the central star. Roughly independent of stellar mass , the magnitude of the excess at 24-850 um peaks at 10-30 Myr as observed in debris disks around A-type sta rs (Currie et al. 2008a). At late times, the 160-850 um excesses for all stars are ~3-5 times the flux from the stellar photosphere.- 93 - 6 7 8 9 log Time (yr)01234[24] - 19.-- Time evolution of the median [24]-[70] color as a function of time for 1.5 M (dashed line), 2.0 M (solid line), and 3.0 (triple dot-dashed line) M stars. Debris disks around lower mass stars have redder [24]-[70] colors than disks aro und more massive stars( and then declines just before central star evolves off the m ain sequence. For lower mass stars, the [24]-[70] color reaches a broad maximum at 300 Myr t o 1 Gyr and then declines.- 94 - 0 1 2 3 4 [24] - [70]01234[8] - 30-150 AU, debris disks around massive stars are hotter than d ebris disks around less massive stars. Thus, debris disks around stars of different masse s occupy specific regions of the [8]-[24] vs[24]-[70] color-color diagram.- 95 - 0 1 2 3 4 [24] - [70]0123[8] - [24]2 M Fig. 21.-- As in Fig. 20 for disks with different initial masses around 2 M stars. Boxes: xm
= 1/3, filled circles: xm= 1, diamonds: xm= 3. Although more massive disks have redder [8]-[24] and [24]-[70], the shape of the color-color track is independen t of mass. Thus, the color-color diagram isolates stars of different masses.- 96 - 6 7 8 9 log Time (F24/F24,0) Fig. 22.-- Observations of the 24 um excess for nearby A-type stars with known ages (Rieke et al. 2005; Su et al. 2006). The lines show the predicted evolu tion of the excess for debris disk models around 2 M stars (dot-dashed line: xm= 1/3; solid line: xm= 1, triple dot-dashed line: xm= 3). Observations for all but four stars (including one 8 Myr old star with log F24/F24,02) fall within loci defined by our debris disk calculations. are also consistent with observational evidence for a p eak in the 24 um excess at 10-20 Myr (see also Currie et al. 2008a).- 97 - 6 7 8 9 log Time (F70/F70,0) Fig. 23.-- As in Fig. 22 for the 70 um excess. Observations for all but 2-3 stars fall within the loci defined by the model tracks. Consistent with model predic tions, the data suggest a peak in the 70 um excess at 10-20 Myr.- 98 - 6 7 8 9 log Time (yr)012345[24] - [70] Fig. 24.-- Observations of the [24] - [70] color for nearby A-type sta rs with known ages (Su et al. 2006). The lines show the predicted evolution of the exces s for debris disk models around 1.5 M stars (triple dot-dashed line: xm= 2) and for 2 M stars (dot-dashed line: xm= 1/3; solid line: xm= 1). Observations for all but 2-3 stars fall within the 99 - 7 8 9 10 log Time (F70/F70,0) Fig. 25.-- Observations of the 70 um excess for nearby solar-type stars with known ages (Beichman et al. 2006; Hillenbrand et al. 2008). The lines show the pre dicted evolution of the excess for debris disk models around 1 M stars (dot-dashed line: xm= 1/3; solid line:xm= 1, triple dot-dashed line: xm= 3). Most stars fall within the loci defined by but many stars are 3-10 times brighter than model pr edictions.- 100 - 7 8 9 10 log Time 26.-- As in Fig. 25 for the 160 um excess.
|
0807.1134
|
Scott J. Kenyon
|
Scott J. Kenyon and Benjamin C. Bromley
|
Variations on Debris Disks: Icy Planet Formation at 30-150 AU for 1-3
Solar Mass Main Sequence Stars
|
accepted by the Astrophysical Journal, 64 pages of text, 10 tables,
and 26 figures; corrected typos in tables
| null |
10.1086/591794
| null |
astro-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We describe calculations for the formation of icy planets and debris disks at
30-150 AU around 1-3 solar mass stars. Debris disk formation coincides with the
formation of planetary systems. As protoplanets grow, they stir leftover
planetesimals to large velocities. A cascade of collisions then grinds the
leftovers to dust, forming an observable debris disk. Stellar lifetimes and the
collisional cascade limit the growth of protoplanets. The maximum radius of icy
planets, roughly 1750 km, is remarkably independent of initial disk mass,
stellar mass, and stellar age. These objects contain no more than 3% to 4% of
the initial mass in solid material. Collisional cascades produce debris disks
with maximum luminosity of roughly 0.002 times the stellar luminosity. The peak
24 micron excess varies from roughly 1% of the stellar photospheric flux for 1
solar mass stars to roughly 50 times the stellar photospheric flux for 3 solar
mass stars. The peak 70-850 micron excesses are roughly 30-100 times the
stellar photospheric flux. For all stars, the 24-160 micron excesses rise at
stellar ages of 5-20 Myr, peak at 10-50 Myr, and then decline. The decline is
roughly a power law, with f propto t^{-n} and n = 0.6-1.0. This predicted
evolution agrees with published observations of A-type and solar-type stars.
The observed far-IR color evolution of A-type stars also matches model
predictions.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 8 Jul 2008 18:44:53 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Kenyon",
"Scott J.",
""
],
[
"Bromley",
"Benjamin C.",
""
]
] |
I. by the ideas that the Chern-Simons gauge theories withou t Yang-Mills kinetic terms may be used to describe N= 8 superconformal M2-brane world-volume theory [1, 2], Barger and Lambert [3, 4, 5], as well as Gustavasson (BLG) [6, 7] ha ve successfully con- structed N= 8 superconformal Chern-Simons gauge theory with mani- festSO(8) R-symmetry based on three algebra. And then there is intensiv e research on the world-volume action of multiple coincident M2-branes [8, 9, 10, 11, 12 , 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85]. Although the BLG theory is expected to describe any number of M2-branes, there is one and o nly one known example with gauge group SO(4) for the positive definite metric [16, 20, 21]. At the level one of the Chern-Simons gauge theory, the BLG SO(4) gauge theory des cribes two M2-branes [13, 14]. Thus, it is very important to generalize the BLG theo ry so that it can describe an arbitrary number of M2-branes. By relaxing the requirement of the positive definite metric on three a lgebra, three groups [24, 25, 26] proposed the so called BF membrane theory with arbitrary semi-simple Lie groups. However, the BF membrane theory has ghost fields and then the unitarity prob- lem in the classical theory due to the Lorenzian three algebra. To so lve these problems, the global shift symmetries for the bosonic and fermionic ghost fields wit h wrong-sign kinetic terms are gauged, which ensures the absence of the negative nor m states in the physical Hilbert space [40, 43]. However, this gauged BF membrane theory mig ht be equivalent to N= 8 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory [47] via a duality transforma- tion due to de Wit, Nicolai and Samtleben [86]. Very recently, Aharony, Bergman, Jafferis and Maldacena (ABJM) have constructed Chern-Simons theories with gauge groups U(N)xU(N) andSU(N)x SU(N) which have explicit N= 6 superconformal symmetry [44] (For Chern-Simons gauge theories with N= 3 and 4 supersymmetries, see Refs. [87, 88]). Using brane constr uctions they argued that the U(N)xU(N) theory at Chern-Simons level kdescribes the low-energy limit ofNM2-branes on a C4/Zkorbifold. In particular, for k= 1 and2, ABJM conjectured that their theory describes the NM2-branes respectively in the flat space and on a R8/Z2 orbifold, and then might have N= 8 supersymmetry. For N= 2, this theory has extra symmetries and is the same as the BLG theory onwhichthe and their dynamics is described by open string field theory [89]. The low-en ergy for D-branes can be obtained by calculating the string scatt ering amplitudes [90] 2or by using the T-duality [91]. As usual in string theory, there are hig where lsis the string length scale. For a single D-brane, the D-brane action, which includes all order corrections in the gauge field strength but n ot its derivatives, takes the (DBI) form [92]. For multiple coincident D-bra nes, Tseytlin assumed that all the commutator terms should be treated as covariant der ivative terms for gauge field strength, and thus should not be included in the effective action [90]. And he proposed that the action is the symmetrized trace of the direct non-Abelian g eneralization of the DBI action [90]. This non-Abelian DBI action gives the correct terms u p to the order F4that were completely determined previously [93, 94]. But it fails for th e higher order terms [95, 96]. Because the F3terms can always be written as the commutator terms, they are not interesting in the discussions of the D-brane effective actio n. With the multiple M2-brane and D2-brane theories, we can study the deep relation between them. As we know, the full effective action of a D2-brane c an be obtained by the reduction of the supermembrane action [97]. So , whether we can obtain the effective non-Abelian action for multiple D2-branes from the red uction of the BLG and ABJM theories is an interesting open question. Mukhi and Papageor gakis proposed a novel Higgs mechanism by giving vacuum expectation value (VEV) to a scalar field, which can promote the topological Chern-Simons gauge fields to dynamical ga uge fields [8]. And they indeed obtained the maximally supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory for t wo D2-branes from the BLG theory at the leading order. Also, there exists a series of h igh-order corrections weconsider ective M2-branes in the BLG and ABJM theories in details. Concentra ting on pure Yang- Mills fields, we show that the high-order F3andF4terms are commutator terms, and argue that all the high-order terms are also commutator terms. Thus, t hese high-order terms are irrelevant to the multiple D2-brane effective action. Note that the ( gauged) BF membrane theory does not have high-order terms, the BLG theory, the (ga uged) BF membrane theory, and the ABJM theory give the same D2-brane effective action. In or der to generate the non-trivial high-order F4terms, inspired by the derivation of a single D2-brane from a M2- brane [97], we consider the curved M2-branes and introduce an aux iliary field. In particular, the VEV of the scalar field in the novel Higgs mechanism depends on th e auxiliary field. Afterwe gaugefields we indeed in the D2-brane effective action from the BLG theory and the ABJM gauge group. However, we still can not obtain the correct F4terms in the generic ABJMtheories withgaugegroups U(N)xU(N) andSU(N)xSU(N) forN >2. The reason might be that the SU(2)xSU(2) gauge theory has N= 8 superconformal symmetry while the U(N)xU(N) andSU(N)xSU(N) gauge theories with N >2 may only have N= 6 superconformal symmetry [72]. We also 3briefly comment on the (gauged) BF membrane theory. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we briefly review the novel Higgs mechanism in the BLG theory and (gauged) BF membrane theory, an d study the novel Higgs mechanism in the ABJM theory. In Section III, we calculate the effective D2-brane action with the leading order F2, and high-order F3andF4terms from M2-branes. In Section IV, we generate the high-order F4terms by considering the curved M2-branes and introducing an auxiliary field. Our discussion and conclusions are given in Section V. II. NOVEL HIGGS MECHANISM In this Section, we briefly review the novel Higgs mechanism from M2- branes to D2- branes in the BLG theory and (gauged) BF membrane theory, and s tudy it in the ABJM theory. A. The BLG Theory and BF Membrane Theory In the Lagrangian for the BLG theory with gauge group SO(4) [4], we f=2p k, (1) wherekis the level of the Chern-Simons terms. We also make the following tra nsformation on the Yang-Mills (2) Then the Lagrangian for the BLG theory with gauge group SO(4) 1,2,3,4,I= 1,2,...,8, and V(X) (4) As we know, the strong coupling limit of Type IIA theory is M-theory, and the in Type IIA theory is related to the radius of the circle of t he eleventh dimension in M-theory. Thus, for D2-branes, the gauge coupling constant is a lso related to the radius of the circle of the eleventh dimension. And at the strong coupling limit th e D2-branes To derive the D2-branes from M2-branes via the nove l Higgs mechanism, we 4compactify the M-theory on the circle of the eleventh dimension by g iving VEV to a of the scalar fields XA(I)[8]. Because we have the SO(8) R-symmetry and SO(4) gaugesymmetry, we can always make the rotationso that on ly thecomponent a (5) where we split the index Ainto two sets a= 1,2,3 andph= 4. In addition, the gauge fields are splitted into (6) And then the Chern-Simons terms can be rewritten 4ounlBa unAla, we neglect the total derivative term. Combining these two te rms, the Aa u. Similarly, the kinetic terms for the scalar fields these back into the action and setting Xph(8)-Xph(8)+v, we obtain the terms involving Ba ufrom the scalar kinetic 1,2,...,7, and the new defined covariant derivative is Therefore, the relevant Lagrangian for pure Yang-Mills fields (13) 5Next, we would like to briefly review the result of the novel Higgs mech anism in the BF membrane theory [24, 25, 26]. Here, we follow the convention in Ref. [25] except that (14) In this theory, the equation of motion for ghost field XI -gives the constraint 2XI
+= 0. So, we can give a constant VEV to And then we obtain the for pure gauge (15) It should be noted that unlike the Lagrangian in Eq. (13) in the BLG th eory, there is no cubic term for Ba uin above Lagrangian. And this is one of the motivations of the work [4 7] which showed that the gauged BF membrane theory might be equivale nt to the Yang-Mills theory via a duality tr ansformation due to de Wit, Nicolai and Samtleben [86]. After gauging the shift symmetries for the ghost fields XI -and Ps -in the BF membrane theory [40, 43] by introducing new gauge fields, we could make the ga uge choice to decouple the ghost states. And the equation of motion for the new gauge fie lds gives the 0, which indicates that XI
+must be a constant. We emphasize that in this case the relevant Lagrangian for pure Yang-Mills fields is still given by Eq. (15) . B. The ABJM Theory Very recently, Aharony, Bergman, Jafferis and Maldacena (ABJM) have constructed U(N)xU(N) andSU(N)xSU(N) Chern-Simons gauge theories with N= 6 superconformal symmetry. From the brane constructions, t hey argued that the U(N)xU(N) theory at Chern-Simons level kdescribes the low-energy limit of NM2- branes probing a It was conjectured that for k= 1 and 2, the ABJM theory respectively describes NM2-branes in flat space and on a R8/Z2orbifold, and then may have N= 8 supersymmetry. For N= 2, this theory has additional symmetries and becomes identical to the BLG theory. In this subsection, we will stu dy the novel Higgs mechanism in the ABJM the convention in Ref. [46], we can write the explicit Lagrang ian in ABJM theory as follows L= (17) Z1=X1+iX5, Z2=X2+iX6, W1=X3++iX7+, to the bifundamental representation of U(N)xU(N) here we do not present the potential they are irrelevant in the following discussions. For our convention, we choose Tr(TaTb) =1 2dab,[Ta, Tb] =ifabcTc, the generators of the corresponding gauge group. Similar to the novel Higgs mechanism in the BLG theory, we give the diag onal VEV to X8as (20) whereINxNis theNbyNindentity matrix. Also, we (21) So we pure Yang-Mills Note that the BLG theory with SO(4) gauge group is the same as the ABJM theory with SU(2)xSU(2) gauge group, so we can obtain the Lagrangian in Eq. (13) from that in the above Eq. (23) by rescaling fabc. III. EFFECTIVE ACTION FOR THE PURE GAUGE FIELDS Because Ba uis massive, we will calculate the effective action for pure Yang-Mills field s by integrating it out. Due to the absence of the cubic term for Ba uin the (gauged) BF membrane theory, we do not have the high-order corrections in th e effective action of gauge fields. Thus, we will concentrate on the BLG theory and ABJM theor y. The s for pure gauge fields are the same for the BLG theory and the ABJM gauge symmetry, and the ABJM theory is more general. Thus, w e will use the Lagrangian in Eq. (23) in the following the Lagrangian in Eq. (23), we get the equation of motion for (24) We can solve the above equation by parametrizing the solution in 1 it back into Eq. (24), we . (26) Because we only know for sure the high-order terms up to the orde r ofF4in action [90, 95, 96], we only need to calculate the solution to E q. (24) up to the order of 1 /v10or (C10)u a. And the non-vanishing terms in the solution (28) Integrating Ba uout, we get the Lagrangian for pure Yang-Mills , (32) Using Eqs. (27) and (28), and the useful identities in the Appendix A , we the kinetic term for the gauge fields Au aand is the leading order of the su- persymmetric Yang-Mills effective action. Moreover, the gauge cou pling in the BLG (36) and the gauge coupling in the ABJM theory (37) So for very large v0andk, we can still keep the gauge coupling as a fixed constant. For D2-branes, the gauge coupling is related to the string coupling and t he string length as follows gYM= (gs ls)1 2. (38) And then for the fixed string coupling, we have g2 YMa-1/2. Therefore, 1 /vis proportional to respectively. In short, they are at the correct orders according to the have commutator terms, these high-order terms are covaria nt derivative terms and then do not contribute to the effective action for the D2-branes [90]. We conjecture that all the high-order terms obtained by this appr oach are the The point is that the equation of motion for Ba uin Eq. (24) can be rewritten (39) Because all the high-order terms originally come from the last term in the above equation which is a commutator term, all the high-order terms should be the c ommutator terms and then the covariant terms. Thus, moduloing the commutator terms or covariant we only have the kinetic term for the gauge fields Au afrom the BLG and ABJM theories, which is the leading order in the D2-brane effective action. And then the effective action for pure Yang-Mills fields from the BLG and ABJM theories is the same as that from the (gauged) BF membrane theory after we integrate Bu aout. Therefore, how to obtain the non-trivial F4terms in the D2-brane effective action from the BLG theory, the (g auged) BF membrane theory, and the ABJM theory is still a big problem. 9IV. D2-BRANES FROM THE CURVED M2-BRANES In spired by the derivation of a single D2-brane from a M2-brane [97 ], we would like to consider the multiple curved M2-branes. To employ the trick in Ref. [ 97], we only need to introduce gravity. For simplicity, we do not consider the dilaton, t he vector and scalar fields in the metric due to and R R fields, etc. And our ansatz for the Lagrangian of the curved M2-branes (40) whereb0is a positive constant like membrane tension, gunis the induced metric on the world-volume of multiple M2-branes, and LM2sis formally given in Eq. (3) for the BLG theory or in Eq. (16) for the ABJM theory. In LM2s, we need to replace respectively. Also, we replace will be covariant under coordinate transformation. This is a natural action for the multiple M2-branes in the curved space-time since it can come back to flat theory after we de couple the gravity. Similar to the discussions in Ref. [97], we introduce an auxiliary filed uand rewrite the above Lagrangian as (41) We can obtain the Lagrangian in Eq. (40) from Eq. (41) by integratin g out the match the convention in [90], we give the following VEV to the scalar fieldph
< ph >= (42) where we can take ph=X8(ph),K'= 1/f, andN= 1 in the BLG theory, take ph=X8
+, K'= 1 and N= 1 in the (gauged) BF membrane theory, and take ABJM theory. Thus, the relevant Lagrangian (43) Using the results of the novel Higgs mechanism in the Section III and neglecting the commutator terms for the Aa ufield strength, we (44) 10Moreover, we use the following identity for the 3 x3 matrices that is proved in the Appendix A Str det (g+2pa'F) = det( (45) where Str is the symmetrized trace that acts on the gauge grou p indices, and det acts on the world-volume coordinate indices. Integrating out the auxiliar y fieldu, we obtain the Lagrangian for multiple D2-brane effective det (g+2pa'F). (46) However, the well-known Lagrangian for the multiple D2-brane DBI a ction is (47) wherec0is a constant. Because in general the Lagrangian in Eq. (46) is not e quivalent to that in Eq. (47), we still can not get the correct F4terms for generic for gauge symmetry SU(2)xSU(2) in the BLG theory, or the (gauged) BF membrane theory, or the ABJM theory, we indeed can get the co rrectF4terms. Let us prove it in the following. From the Lagrangian in Eq. (46), we (48) Expandind theabove Lagrangian, we have the relevant Lagrangian forpure the Minkowski space-time (49) From the known effective action for multiple D2-branes, the relevan t Lagrangian for pure Yang-Mills fields up to the F4terms is For gauge group SU(2), we neglecting the commutator terms and rescaling the ga ugefields, we can show that the correct F4terms in the effective D2-brane action in Eq. (49) from the two M2-b ranes in the BLG and ABJM theories are equivalent to these in the known DBI a ction in Eq. (51). 11In short, we can generate the correct F4terms in the effective D2-brane action from the BLG theory and the ABJM theory with gauge group SU(2)xSU(2). However, we can not get the correct F4terms from the ABJM theory with U(N)xU(N) symmetries for N >2. It seems to us that the reasons are the following: the BLG the- ory and the ABJM theory with gauge group SU(2)xSU(2) have N= 8 superconformal symmetry while the ABJM theory with U(N)xU(N) symmetries for N >2 might only have N= 6 [72]. However, for the (gauged) BF membrane theory, a lthough the 0 is still satisfied, it might be equivalent to N= 8 super- symmetric Yang-Mills theory. In particular, for the (gauged) BF me mbrane theory with SU(2)xSU(2) gauge symmetry, we can generate the correct F4terms since it is similar to the corresponding BLG and ABJM theories. V. DISCUSSION AND the novel Higgs mechanism, we considered the derivation of th e multiple action for pure Yang-Mills fields from the multiple M2-branes in the BLG theory and the ABJM theory. We showed that the high-order F3andF4terms are and we argued that all the high-order terms are commutat or terms as well. Thus, these high-order terms do not contribute to the multiple D2-brane effective action. In order to generate the non-trivial high-order F4terms and inspired by the derivation of one D2- brane from one M2-brane, we considered the curved M2-branes a nd introduce an auxiliary field. In particular, the VEV of the scalar field in the novel Higgs mech anism depends on the auxiliary field. After we integrate out the massive gauge fields and auxiliary field, we obtain the correct high-order F4terms in the D2-brane effective action from the BLG theory and the ABJM theory with SU(2)xSU(2) gauge group. However, we still can not obtain the correct F4terms in the generic ABJM theory with gauge groups forN >2. This might be related to the possible fact that the SU(2)xSU(2) gauge theory has N= 8 superconformal symmetry andSU(N)xSU(N) gauge theories for N >2 might only have N= 6 superconformal symmetry. We also briefly comment on the (gau ged) BF membrane research was supported in part by the Colla boration in Theo- retical Cosmology (TL). APPENDIX A: MATHEMATICAL IDENTIFIES In this appendix we collect or prove the useful identities in this paper : (1) Two useful identities about oin Minkowski Let us prove the identity in Eq. (45) which is right for the Abelian a nd det(g+aF) = det( gun) Str det( gn l+aFn l)
= (detg) (detg) (detg) (A3) wherea= 2pa'. [1] J. H. Schwarz, JHEP 0411, 078 (2004). [2] A. Basu and J. A. Harvey, Nucl. Phys. B 713, 136 (2005). [3] J. Bagger and N. Lambert, Phys. Rev. D 75, 045020 (2007). [4] J. Bagger and N. Lambert, Phys. Rev. D 77, 065008 (2008). [5] J. Bagger and N. Lambert, JHEP 0802, 105 (2008). [6] A. Gustavsson, arXiv:0709.1260 [hep-th]. [7] A. Gustavsson, JHEP 0804, 083 (2008). [8] S. Mukhi and C. Papageorgakis, JHEP 0805, 085 (2008). [9] M. A. Bandres, A. E. Lipstein and J. H. Schwarz, JHEP 0805, 025 (2008). 13[10] D. S. Berman, L. C. Tadrowski and D. C. Thompson, arXiv:0 803.3611 [hep-th]. [11] M. Van Raamsdonk, arXiv:0803.3803 [hep-th]. [12] A. Morozov, arXiv:0804.0913 [hep-th]. [13] N. Lambert and D. Tong, arXiv:0804.1114 [hep-th]. [14] J. Distler, S. Mukhi, C. Papageorgakis and M. Van Raamsd onk, JHEP 0805, 038 (2008). [15] U. Gran, B. E. W. Nilsson and C. Petersson, arXiv:0804.1 784 [hep-th]. [16] P. M. Ho, R. C. Hou and Y. Matsuo, arXiv:0804.2110 [hep-t h]. [17] J. Gomis, A. J. Salim and F. Passerini, arXiv:0804.2186 [hep-th]. [18] E. A. Bergshoeff, M. de Roo and O. Hohm, arXiv:0804.2201 [h ep-th]. [19] K. Hosomichi, K. M. Lee and S. Lee, arXiv:0804.2519 [hep -th]. [20] G. Papadopoulos, JHEP 0805, 054 (2008). [21] J. P. Gauntlett and J. B. Gutowski, arXiv:0804.3078 [he p-th]. [22] G. Papadopoulos, arXiv:0804.3567 [hep-th]. [23] P. M. Ho and Y. Matsuo, arXiv:0804.3629 [hep-th]. [24] J. Gomis, G. Milanesi and J. G. Russo, arXiv:0805.1012 [ hep-th]. [25] S. Benvenuti, D. Rodriguez-Gomez, E. Tonni and H. Verli nde, arXiv:0805.1087 [hep-th]. [26] P. M. Ho, Y. Imamura and Y. Matsuo, arXiv:0805.1202 [hep -th]. [27] A. Morozov, arXiv:0805.1703 [hep-th]. [28] Y. Honma, S. Iso, Y. Sumitomo and S. Zhang, arXiv:0805.1 895 [hep-th]. [29] H. Fuji, S. Terashima and M. Yamazaki, arXiv:0805.1997 [hep-th]. [30] P. M. Ho, Y. Imamura, Y. Matsuo and S. Shiba, arXiv:0805. 2898 [hep-th]. [31] C. Krishnan and C. Maccaferri, arXiv:0805.3125 [hep-t h]. [32] Y. Song, arXiv:0805.3193 [hep-th]. [33] I. Jeon, J. Kim, N. Kim, S. W. Kim and J. H. Park, arXiv:080 5.3236 [hep-th]. [34] M. Li and T. Wang, arXiv:0805.3427 [hep-th]. [35] K. Hosomichi, K. M. Lee, S. Lee, S. Lee and J. Park, arXiv: 0805.3662 [hep-th]. [36] S. Banerjee and A. Sen, arXiv:0805.3930 [hep-th]. [37] H. Lin, arXiv:0805.4003 [hep-th]. [38] J. P. de Medeiros and E. Mendez-Es cobar, arXiv:0805.4363 [hep-th]. [39] A. Gustavsson, arXiv:0805.4443 [hep-th]. [40] M. A. Bandres, A. E. Lipstein and J. H. Schwarz, arXiv:08 06.0054 [hep-th]. [41] J. H. Park and C. Sochichiu, arXiv:0806.0335 [hep-th]. [42] F. Passerini, arXiv:0806.0363 [hep-th]. 14[43] J. Gomis, D. Rodriguez-Gomez, M. Van Raamsdonk and H. Ve rlinde, arXiv:0806.0738 [hep- th]. [44] O. Aharony, O. Bergman, D. L. Jafferis and J. Maldacena, ar Xiv:0806.1218 [hep-th]. [45] C. Ahn, arXiv:0806.1420 [hep-th]. [46] M. Benna, I. Klebanov, T. Klose and M. Smedback, arXiv:0 806.1519 [hep-th]. [47] B. Ezhuthachan, S. Mukhi and C. Papageorgakis, arXiv:0 806.1639 [hep-th]. [48] S. Cocetti and A. Sen arXiv:0806.1990 [hep-th]. [49] A. Mauri and A. C. Petkou, arXiv:0806.2270 [hep-th]. [50] E. A. Bergshoeff, M. de Roo, O. Hohm and D. Roest, arXiv:080 6.2584 [hep-th]. [51] P. de Medeiros, J. and E. Mendez-Es cobar, arXiv:0806.3242 [hep-th]. [52] M. Blau and M. O'Loughlin, arXiv:0806.3253 [hep-th]. [53] T. Nishioka and T. Takayanagi, arXiv:0806.3391 [hep-t h]. [54] Y. Honma, S. Iso, Y. Sumitomo and S. Zhang, arXiv:0806.3 498 [hep-th]. [55] C. Sochichiu, arXiv:0806.3520 [hep-th]. [56] Y. Imamura and K. Kimura, arXiv:0806.3727 [hep-th]. [57] J. A. Minahan and K. Zarembo, arXiv:0806.3951 [hep-th] . [58] T. a. Larsson, arXiv:0806.4039 [hep-th]. [59] K. Furuuchi, S. Y. Shih and T. Takimi, arXiv:0806.4044 [ hep-th]. [60] A. Armoni and A. Naqvi, arXiv:0806.4068 [hep-th]. [61] A. Agarwal, arXiv:0806.4292 [hep-th]. [62] D. Gaiotto, S. Giombi and X. Yin, arXiv:0806.4589 [hep- th]. [63] I. A. Bandos and P. K. Townsend, arXiv:0806.4777 [hep-t h]. [64] C. Ahn, arXiv:0806.4807 [hep-th]. [65] J. Bedford and D. Berman, arXiv:0806.4900 [hep-th]. [66] G. Arutyunov and S. Frolov, arXiv:0806.4940 [hep-th]. [67] B. j. Stefanski, arXiv:0806.4948 [hep-th]. [68] G. Grignani, T. Harmark and M. Orselli, arXiv:0806.495 9 [hep-th]. [69] K. Hosomichi, K. M. Lee, S. Lee, S. Lee and J. Park, arXiv: 0806.4977 [hep-th]. [70] P. Fre and P. A. Grassi, arXiv:0807.0044 [hep-th]. [71] K. Okuyama, arXiv:0807.0047 [hep-th]. [72] J. Bagger and N. Lambert, arXiv:0807.0163 [hep-th]. [73] S. Terashima, arXiv:0807.0197 [hep-th]. [74] G. Grignani, T. Harmark, M. Orselli and G. W. Semenoff, arX iv:0807.0205 [hep-th]. 15[75] S. Chakrabortty, A. Kumar and S. Jain, arXiv:0807.0284 [hep-th]. [76] S. Terashima and F. Yagi, arXiv:0807.0368 [hep-th]. [77] N. Gromov and P. Vieira, arXiv:0807.0437 [hep-th]. [78] C. Ahn and P. Bozhilov, arXiv:0807.0566 [hep-th]. [79] N. Gromov and P. Vieira, arXiv:0807.0777 [hep-th]. [80] B. Chen and J. B. Wu, arXiv:0807.0802 [hep-th]. [81] S. Cherkis and C. Saemann, arXiv:0807.0808 [hep-th]. [82] C. Chu, P. M. Ho, Y. Matsuo and S. Shiba, arXiv:0807.0812 [hep-th]. [83] M. A. Bandres, A. E. Lipstein and J. H. Schwarz, arXiv:08 07.0880 [hep-th]. [84] Y. Zhou, arXiv:0807.0890 [hep-th]. [85] J. Gomis, D. Rodriguez-Gomez, M. Van Raamsdonk and H. Ve rlinde, arXiv:0807.1074 [hep- th]. [86] B. de Wit, H. Nicolai and H. Samtleben, arXiv:hep-th/04 03014. [87] D. Gaiotto and X. Yin, JHEP 0708, 056 (2007). [88] D. Gaiotto and E. Witten, arXiv:0804.2907 [hep-th]. [89] J. Polchinski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4724 (1995). [90] A. A. Tseytlin, Nucl. Phys. B 501, 41 (1997). [91] R. C. Myers, JHEP 9912, 022 (1999). [92] R. G. Leigh, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 4, 2767 (1989). [93] A. A. Tseytlin, Nucl. Phys. B 276(1986) 391 [Erratum-ibid. B 291(1987) 876]. [94] D. J. Gross and E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B 277, 1 (1986). [95] A. Hashimoto and W. Taylor, Nucl. Phys. B 503, 193 (1997). [96] J. H. Schwarz, and the referenc es therein. [97] E. Bergshoeff and P. K. Townsend, Nucl. Phys. B 490, 145 (1997). 16
|
0807.1183
|
Tianjun Li
|
Tianjun Li, Yan Liu, Dan Xie
|
Multiple D2-Brane Action from M2-Branes
|
RevTex4, 16 pages
|
Int.J.Mod.Phys.A24:3039-3052,2009
|
10.1142/S0217751X09044590
|
MIFP-08-16
|
hep-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study the detail derivation of the multiple D2-brane effective action from
multiple M2-branes in the Bagger-Lambert-Gustavsson (BLG) theory and the
Aharony-Bergman-Jafferis-Maldacena (ABJM) theory by employing the novel Higgs
mechanism. We show explicitly that the high-order F^3 and F^4 terms are
commutator terms, and conjecture that all the high-order terms are commutator
terms. Because the commutator terms can be treated as the covariant derivative
terms, these high-order terms do not contribute to the multiple D2-brane
effective action. Inspired by the derivation of a single D2-brane from a
M2-brane, we consider the curved M2-branes and introduce an auxiliary field.
Integrating out the auxiliary field, we indeed obtain the correct high-order
F^4 terms in the D2-brane effective action from the BLG theory and the ABJM
theory with SU(2)\times SU(2) gauge symmetry, but we can not obtain the correct
high-order F^4 terms from the ABJM theory with U(N)\times U(N) and SU(N)\times
SU(N) gauge symmetries for N > 2. We also briefly comment on the (gauged) BF
membrane theory.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 8 Jul 2008 07:04:26 GMT"
}
] | 2009-07-22T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Li",
"Tianjun",
""
],
[
"Liu",
"Yan",
""
],
[
"Xie",
"Dan",
""
]
] |
2 two baths, which is required by the NEGF formalism. By doing this, we can also include the charge transfer effect between the leads and the molecule junction. In this setup, the system Hamiltonian can be written har- monic oscillators, uais a column vector consisting of all the mass normalised displacement variables in region a, and .uais the corresponding conjugate momentum. Kais the spring constant matrix in the and VLC= (VCL)Tis the coupling matrix of the left lead to the central region; similarly for VCR.Vn is the nonlinear interaction in the center, which cubic nonlinearality. We ignore the nonlinear interaction in this paper and only briefly discuss its effect in Sec. III. We study the phonon thermal conductance of ben- zene and alkane chains covalently bonded with two (6 ,0) SWCNTs via the amide group. This is relevant to a re- cent experimental setup20, where the SWCNT is molecular chains via the amide group. To get system, center and the leads using Gaussian03. For the cen- ter, at each side, which is terminated by hydrogen atoms at the outer boundaries. The cutting edges may be terminated by H or COOH group. We optimize the center at the level of b3lyp density functional method using the 6-31G basis set. We first relax the structure by constraining the leads to be coaxial to get an optimized distance be- tween the two leads. Then we fix the outer half period of the SWCNTs and the H atoms at both sides and allow all other atoms to move freely. The optimized struc- ture is used to get the dynamical matrix. The inset of Fig. 2 shows the optimized benzene structure terminated by the H and COOH groups at the cutting edges. For the lead, it is desirable to use periodic boundary condi- tion to compute the dynamical matrix, while this is out of the ability of Gaussian03. So we optimise 7 SWCNT periods and extract the force constant from the central period to minimize the finite size effect. To connect the molecule with the two leads, we remove the outer fixed atoms in the molecule and connect the remaining period of SWCNT with one semi-infinite SWCNT at each only include coupling between one period of SWCNT atoms in the center and one period in the leads. This is a good approximation so long as we include enough SWCNT atoms into the center molecule. In the NEGF method as describedin Refs. 10,11,12,13, 14, ofthe canbe calculated from the Landauer formula (- h= 1 throughoutthe the transmission coefficient T[o] = (3) f(o) is the Bose-Einstein distribution function. The re- tarded Green's function Gris obtained from Gr[o] the retarded self-energy of lead ais Sr a[o] =VCagr a[o]VaC, (5) and the lead surface Green's function gr a[o] can be cal- culated from the generalized eigenvalue method14, e.g., gr R[o] the diagonal and off-diagonal parts of the right lead dynamical matrix. Their sizes are deter- mined by the degrees of freedom Min each period of the lead. The matrix F+
R(s) translates to the right the displacement in the nth period to the ( n+s)th period u+
R(n+s) =F+
R(s)u+
R(n). eigen values and vectors of the generalized eigen value HereIis anMxMiden- tity matrix. The diagonal matrix Ls
+consists of all the eigen values |ls
+|<1, andE+
Rthe corresponding Note that M'may be less than M, in which case the matrix inverse A similar left-translation matrix F- R(s) can be constructed from Ls -andE- R, which include all the eigen values |ls -|>1 (excluding infinity) and eigen vectors. While the NEGF method is systematic and suitable to take into accountthe nonlinear interaction, the transmis- sion coefficient from it is the sum of all the eigen modes from the leads. Thus it is difficult to analyse the con- tribution from each mode. The mode-matching method provides another way to calculate the transmission co- efficient in the ballistic limit14,18,19. Single mode trans- mission and mode mixing effect can be studied by this method. The transmission matrix is given (8) and tRL= the group velocity of the mth right prop- agating mode for the lead a. While the mode indices mandnare only for propagating modes, the all the propagating and evanescent modes. The total transmission coefficient as in the Landauer for- mula isT[o] = Similar relations hold for waves incidented from the right lead and transmitted to the lefttLR nm. The NEGF and the mode-matching method are ex- actly equivalent in the ballistic case as show in Ref. 19. All the matrices needed by Eqs. (8-9) can be obtained by solving the generalized eigen value problem Eq. (7). It is interesting to note that by doing a singular value de- composition on the transmission matrix twe can get any other efforts, for which different methods have been developed in the electronic transport NUMERICAL RESULTS AND DISCUSSION We now present our numerical results. We begin with the simplest case where there is only one benzene ring at the center. We compare the thermal conductance of the molecular junction at different compression or by changing the distance between the two leads. The purpose of this study is twofold. Firstly, we want to study the effect of the compression or stretching on the thermal conductance. Secondly, our discussed in Sec. II can not ensure that we position of the outer C and H atoms at both sides. If the thermal conductance is not sensitive to the distance between the two leads, our results make sense even if we do not find the lowest energy configuration. As we can see in Fig. 1, this is indeed the case. In Fig. 1, from 1 to 5 the distance between the two carbon atoms connecting to the amide groupsis 10 .07, 10.21,10.38, 10.51, The inset shows the atom configuration of the five cases. In the compression states (10 .07 and 10 .21
@A), the relative position between the benzene ring and the SWCNT leads changes compared to the full and stretching (10 .51 and 10 .64@A) states (in- set of Fig. 1). Although the atom configurations change a lot, the ballistic thermal conductance of the molecu- lar junction only changes slightly in all the studied here. So we can conclude that the ballistic ofthe is notsen- sitive to small compression or stretching of the molecule. In a related experiment20, the cutting edge carbon atoms are expected to be saturated by the COOH group, not the H group shown in Fig. 1. In Ref. 22, the au- thors show that the electron transmission is largely af- fected by the terminating groups. It is also interesting to know how the terminating group affects the quantum thermal conductance. We still use the single benzene FIG. 1: Ballistic thermal conductance of the benzene juncti on terminated by H atoms at different configurations. 3 is the full relaxed structure. 1 -2 are in the compression state, and 3-4 are in the stretching state. FIG. 2: Ballistic thermal conductance of the benzene junc- tions terminated by H and COOH group. structure to study this problem. Figure 2 shows the ther- mal conductance of the two configurations. The full re- laxed structures are shown in the inset. The is mainly determined by the energy channel near the chemical potential, while the thermal conduc- tance is jointly contributed by many phonon modes. The terminating group only has a large influence on the high energy (short wavelength) optical phonon modes. The low energy (long wavelength) phonon modes are not sen- sitive to the local environment at the cutting edges. As a result, the thermal conductance only shows which becomes larger at high temperatures. We now compare the conductance of the benzene rings and that of the alkane chains, with the SWCNTs termi- nated by H atoms. We expect that the COOH terminat- ing structures show similar behavior. To ensure the two molecules have comparable length, we include two ben- zene rings for the benzene structure and 8 CH 2groups for the alkane chain. The total transmission probability and the thermal conductance are shown in Figs. 3 and 4,4 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 0.05 0.1 0.15 3: Phonon transmission probability as a function of en- ergy for the benzene and alkane chains. 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 200 400 600 800 1000conductance 4: Ballistic thermal conductance as a function of tem- perature for the benzene and alkane chains. The inset shows the crossing point of the thermal conductance at about 38 K. respectively. Since the nonlinear interaction is not con- sidered here, phonon modes with different energies are independent of each other. The transmission probabil- ity is nonzero only in the overlapped energy range of the SWCNT leads and the center molecule. Strong cou- pling with the leads gives rise to wide broadening and strong shifting of the discrete molecule phonon energy. It is hard to make a one-to-one correspondence between the transmission peaks and the isolated molecule phonon eigen frequencies. This is especially true for low energy phonon modes, which have relatively large spatial ex- tent. The high energy modes are highly localized and show sharp peaks in the transmission spectrum. Due to the these modes can hardly transfer energy. There is a wide zero transmission gap around 0 .07 eV for the gain further insight into the also study the single mode transmission using method. Figure 5 shows the transmis- sion of several important branches in SWCNT 0.02 0.03 0.02 0.03 5: Transmission probability of different phonon branches: (a) TA modes, (b) LA mode, (c) twisting mode, (d) lowest optical modes. spectrum: Two transverse acoustic (TA) phonon modes, one longitudinal acoustic (LA) mode, one twisting mode and the lowest two degenerate optical modes. These low frequency modes are expected to contribute much to the thermal conductance. The degenerate phonon modes of SWCNTs show different transmissionin both cases. This is consistent with the fact that the junction structure de- stroysthe degeneracyin At the en- ergy range below 0 .01 eV, the main contribution comes from the TA modes of the SWCNT. The alkane chain shows larger transmission than the benzene chain in this energy range. Above 0 .01 eV, the benzene chain shows larger transmission in most cases. The twisting mode shows the largest difference in two structures. While it can hardly be transmitted by the alkane chain, it has a large contribution in the benzene chain. The ofthe de- pends not only on the transmission coefficient, but also on the phonon occupation number, which is reflected as the Bose-Einstein distribution in the Landauer the analysis of the transmission spectrum, we may expect that the alkane chain has larger thermal con- ductance at low temperatures, while at higher tempera- tures the order reverses. This is confirmed in Fig. 4. The crossing temperature is about 38 K. The room tem- perature thermal conductance is about 0 .075 nW/K for alkane chains and 0 .125 nW/K for benzene chains. In a recent experiment5, the thermal conductance of alkane chain is found to be smaller than our theoretical value. This difference comes from the effect of the leads. We are using SWCNTs here, while in the experiment it is the bulk gold connected with the alkane chain via the sufur atom. At least two factors from the leads may ac- count for this decrease. The first is the smaller phonon spectrum overlapbetween gold and alkane chain, and the second is the weaker coupling between them. Some comments are worthwhile. The nonlinear inter- action may change the transmission spectrum, and lead5 to adecreaseofthe . of the single benzene structure shows that the roomtemperaturedropsabout30%
ofthe ballistic valueifweinclude the from Gaussion03. Mean-filed approximation in the NEGF formalism only works well for simple struc- tureswith It it is still a challenge to find a good approximation for the nonlinear self-energies in NEGF method. IV. CONCLUSIONS In this paper, we introduce a straightforward method to calculate the phononic thermal conductance of molec- ular junctions in the ballistic regime from force constant matrices are obtained from Gaus- sian03 quantum chemistry software. The phonon trans- missionandarecalculatedusingtheNEGF or mode-matching method. Further information can be obtained from the transmission spectrum of each single mode. Using this method we show that the ballis- tic thermal conductance of the benzene ring amide linked with SWCNTs is not sensitive to the distance between the two SWCNTs. The benzene rings show larger ther- mal conductance than the alkane chains. This method is general, and can be easily applied to other authors thank Nan Zeng for discussions. JTL is grateful to the hospitality of Prof. J. C. Cao at Shang- hai Institute of Microsystem and Information Technol- ogy, where this paper was finished. This work was sup- ported in part by a Faculty Research Grant of National University of address: Galperin, M. A. Ratner, and A. Nitzan, J. Phys.: Con- dens. Matter 19, 103201 (2007). 2B. Li, L. Wang, andG. Casati, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, W. Chang, D. Okawa, A. Majumdar, and A. Zettl, Sci- ence314, 1121 (2006). 4P. Reddy, S.-Y. Jang, R. Segalman, and A. 1568 (2007). 5Z. Wang, J. A. Carter, A. Lagutchev, Y. K. Koh, N.-H. Seong, D. G. Cahill, and D. D. Dlott, Science 317, 787 (2007). 6D. Segal, A. Nitzan, and P. H anggi, J. Chem. Phys. 119, 6840 (2003). 7A. Buldum, D. M. Leitner and S. Ciraci, Europhys. Lett. 47, 208 (1999). 8N. Mingo, D. A. Stewart, D. A. Broido, and D. Rev. B 77, 033418 (2008). 9M. J. Frisch and et al., gaussian 03, Revision C.02 (Gaus- sian Inc., Wallingford, 2004). 10J.-S. Wang, J. Wang, and N. Zeng, Phys. Rev. B 74, 033408 (2006). 11J.-S. Wang, N. Zeng, J. Wang, and C. K. Gan, Phys. Rev. E75, 061128 (2007).12N. Mingo, Phys. Rev. B 74, 125402 (2006). 13T. Yamamoto and K. Watanabe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 255503 (2006). 14J.-S. Wang, J. Wang, and J. T. L u, Eur. Phys. J. B 62, 381 (2008). 15J. Taylor, H. Guo, and J. Wang, Phys. Rev. B 63, Brandbyge, J.-L. Mozos, P. Ordej' on, J. Taylor, and K. Stokbro, Phys. Rev. B 65, 165401 (2002). 17P. S. Damle, A. W. Ghosh, and S. Datta, Phys. Rev. B 64, 201403 (2001). 18T. Ando, Phys. Rev. B 44, 8017 (1991). 19P. A. Khomyakov, G. Brocks, V. Karpan, M. Zwierzycki, and P. J. Kelly, Phys. Rev. B 72, 035450 (2005). 20X. Guo, J. P. Small, J. E. Klare, Y. Wang, M. S. Purewal, I. W. Tam, B. H. Hong, R. Caldwell, L. Huang, S. O'Brien, et al., Science 311, 356 (2006). 21J. E. Inglesfield, S. Crampin, and H. Ishida, Phys. Rev. B71, 155120 (2005), A. Bagrets, N. Papanikolaou, and I. Mertig, Phys. Rev. B 75, 235448 (2007), M. Paulsson and M. Brandbyge, Phys. Rev. B 76, 115117 (2007). 22W. Ren, J. Reimers, N. Hush, Y. Zhu, J. Wang, and H. Guo, J. Phys. Chem. C 111, 3700 (2007).
|
0807.1193
|
L\"u Jing Tao
|
J. T. L\"u and Jian-Sheng Wang
|
Quantum phonon transport of molecular junctions amide-linked with carbon
nanotubes: a first-principle study
|
5 pages, 5 figures
|
Phys. Rev. B {78}, 235436 (2008)
|
10.1103/PhysRevB.78.235436
| null |
cond-mat.mes-hall
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Quantum phonon transport through benzene and alkane chains amide-linked with
single wall carbon nanotubes (SWCNTs) is studied within the level of density
functional theory. The force constant matrices are obtained from standard
quantum chemistry software. The phonon transmission and thermal conductance are
from the nonequilibrium Green's function and the mode-matching method. We find
that the ballistic thermal conductance is not sensitive to the compression or
stretching of the molecular junction. The terminating groups of the SWCNTs at
the cutting edges only influence the thermal conductance quantitatively. The
conductance of the benzene and alkane chains shows large difference. Analysis
of the transmission spectrum shows that (i) the low temperature thermal
conductance is mainly contributed by the SWCNT transverse acoustic modes, (ii)
the degenerate phonon modes show different transmission probability due to the
presence of molecular junction, (iii) the SWCNT twisting mode can hardly be
transmitted by the alkane chain. As a result, the ballistic thermal conductance
of alkane chains is larger than that of benzene chains below 38 K, while it is
smaller at higher temperature.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 8 Jul 2008 08:57:42 GMT"
}
] | 2009-01-02T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Lü",
"J. T.",
""
],
[
"Wang",
"Jian-Sheng",
""
]
] |
2 JO ~AO ARA 'UJO AND CSABA SCHNEIDER f. LetPbe a partition of X; that is, P={P1,...,P m}whereP1,...,P andX=P1***Pm. The equivalence relation that corresponds to a partition Pis denoted ~P. The elements of T(X)that preserve the partition Pform a semigroup and is denoted by T(X,P). Using symbols, T(X,P) ={fT(X)|(Pi P)(Pj partition Pis called uniform if|Pi|=|Pj|for alli, j {1,...,m}. The main result of Huisheng's paper [17] is that for a uniform partiti onPthe rank of T(X,P) is at most 6, or smaller in some degenerate cases. Huisheng's proof relied on the observation that there is a strong relationship between ran kT(X,P)and the rank of the group Gof invertible transformations in T(X,P). He proved that the rank ofGis at most 4 (or smaller in some degenerate cases). In the pres ent paper, we are able to show, for that rank G= 2 (see Theorem 4.1). In order to facilitate the proof of our results, we use the concept of wreath product s of see Section 2. We can also consider the rank of some further interesting sem igroups related to a partition Pof a setX. Let us define S(X,P) ={fT(X)|x~Pyif and only if ={fT(X,P)|(Pi, Pj is routine to check that following theorem improves Huisheng's result and settl es the problem of determining the rank of T(X,P). It also gives the rank of S(X,P)andG(X,P). A partition of Xis said to be trivial if it has 1or|X|parts (that is, the trivial partitions are the identity and the universal 1.1. IfXis a finite set such that andPis a non-trivial of X, then rankT(X,P) = 4 andrankS(X,P) =rankG(X,P) = 3 . 2. W REATH PRODUCTS OF TRANSFORMATION SEMIGROUPS We define the wreath product of two transformation semigroup s following [25] (see also [21, Chapter 10]). The material of this section is w ell-known, however, we felt that it was necessary to present it in order to make the pa per self-contained and also to set our system of notation. Let SandRbe two transformation on the sets YandZ, respectively, and let Bdenote the set of functions f:Z-S. The underlying set of the wreath product SwrRis the BxRand to each element (f,r)BxR, we assign a transformation of the setYxZdefined by (1) (y,z)(f,r) = (yf(z),zr)for allyY, zZ, fB, rR. It is easy to see that this assignment is injective and that th e image of this assign- ment is closed under composition; that is, the image is a subs emigroup of T(YxZ). From now on we assume that the sets YandZare finite and that SandR are monoids, that is, they contain the identity transformat ionid. Let us assume without loss of generality that In this case, a function f:Z-Scan be represented as the m-tuple(s1,...,s m)wheref(i) =si for alli {1,...,m}. This defines a bijection between BxRandSmxR, and, in turn, between SwrRandSmxR. Therefore we may view an element of SwrRas a pair((s1,...,s mSandrR. The element ((s1,...,s m),r)RANK OF THE ENDOMORPHISM MONOID OF A PARTITION 3 will more briefly be denoted by (s1,...,s m)r. Setting s= (s1,...,s m)the same element can be written as sr. By (1), the action of (s1,...,s m)ron a pair (y,z) YxZis given by (2) (y,z)(s1,...,s m)r= transformation monoids as above. Then Sand Rcan naturally be embedded into the wreath product SwrR. Indeed, we may consider the following submonoids of SwrR: (3) Easy computation shows that the elements of Sileave the set Yiinvariant, and Si, considered as a on Yi, is isomorphic to the transformation monoid S. Let us further and R, considered as a transforma- tion monoid on Z, is isomorphic to R. we may consider SmandRas submonoids of SwrR. SinceRis assumed to be a transformation monoid on the set Z={1,...,m}, we may define a homomorphism m) = (s1r,...,s mr). We note that the action of End (Sm)onSmis a left-action. The useful for expressing the operation in SwrR. Indeed, let s1, s2Smand r1, r2R. Then, viewing s1r1ands2r2as elements of SwrR, easy that (5) (s1r1)(s2r2) = the wreath product SwrRcan also be viewed as the semidirect respect to the homomorphism th:R-End(Sm)(see [21, page 186]). In particular, if ris an invertible element of RandsSm, sandras elements of SwrR, equation (5) implies that (6) rsr-1= conjugation by an invertible element of and the conjugation action of Ris given by the homomorphism th. Indeed, from the last displayed line we obtain that sr=r-1sr= (r-1th)s. Note that the of the element ris actually given by the endomorphism r-1th. The reason for this is that we assumed that endomorphisms act on the left , while the usual definition makes the conjugation action a right-action. Fur ther, ifris an of Randi, j {1,...,m}such that ir=jthen (6) implies that a finite set X, the invertible elements of T(X)form the symmetric group S(X). IfPis a partition of Xthen setS(X,P) =T(X,P)S(X). The next lemma connects the semigroups related to a partition to wreath pro ducts. Lemma 2.1. setX=YxZ, and letPdenote the partition Then (i)T(X,P) =T(Y)wrT(Z);4 JO ~AO ARA 'UJO AND CSABA Since the proofs of these statements are very similar to each other, we only verify assertion (ii). Let assume that Setw= (t1,...,tm)s. We have, for i= 1,2, that (yi,zi)w= if thenz1=z2, and then z1s=z2s; hence, in Conversely, if using that sis a invertible, gives that z1=z2; therefore shows that wS(X,P), and now that xS(X,P). Then the defining property of a permutation on the set P. Since there is a one-to-one correspon- dence between PandZ={1,...,m}, we obtain that xinduces a permutation onZ. Let this permutation be s. Fori= 1,...,m , let us define a Letj {1,...,m}such that ix=j. Then, for all k some lk {1,...,n}such that (k,i)x= (lk,j). Lettibe the maps ktolkfor allk {1,...,n}. Then routine computation shows that x= (t1,...,tm)s, and soxT(Y)wrS(Z). and so T(Y)wrS(Z) = S(X,P) /square 3. R ELATIVE RANK OF a subset of a semigroup S. The relative rank ofSmodulo U, denoted by rank (S:U), is the minimum among the cardinalities of subsets VofS such that The relative rank was introduced in [13]. The next lemma shows that the rank of a transformation semigroup is related to its relative rank modulo the unit group. Lemma 3.1. LetSbe a finite transformation semigroup and let Gbe the group of units inS. IfUSsuch In particular, It suffices to show that and so suppose that gG. SinceUis a generating set of S, we obtain that g=u1u2***urwith some u1,...,u rU. Since gis invertible, we obtain that u1,...,u rmust also be invertible, and so u1,...,u r G. and hence the assertion follows. /square Next we determine the relative ranks of unit groups. Lemma 3.2. IfXis a finite set and Pis a uniform partition of X, then rank(T(X,P) :S(X,P)) = :S(X,P)) = rank(S(X,P) :S(X,P)) = 1. Proof. We may suppose without loss of generality that the partition RANK OF THE ENDOMORPHISM MONOID OF A PARTITION 5 By Lemma 2.1, T(X,P) =
S(Y)wrT(Z), andS(X,P) =S(Y)wrS(Z), and so it suffices to show that (7) rank (T(Y)wrT(Z) :S(Y)wrS(Z)) = 2 and (8) rank (T(Y)wrS(Z) :S(Y)wrS(Z)) = rank(S(Y)wrT(Z) :S(Y)wrS(Z)) = 1. Letadenote the transformation in T(Y)such that 1a= 2 andia=ifor all i {2,...,n}. ThenT(Y) [14, Exercise 1.9.7]). Set andb= (id,...,id)a. We claim that T(Y)wrS(Z) wrS(Z) (9) S(Y)wrT(Z) wrS(Z){b}/angbracketrightbig , (10) T(Y)wrT(Z) wrS(Z) (11) Fori {1,...,m}, let us define the following submonoids of component t,id,...,id)idT(Y)wrT(Z)|tT(Y)}, us first prove (9). As aT(Y)wrS(Z), we find SinceT(Y) we obtain that For all i {1,...,m}, there is some rS(Z) such that 1r=i, and, as discussed before Lemma 2.1, we obtain that r-1T1r=
Ti. Therefore = (T1x***xTm)S(Z), we obtain that T(Y)wrS(Z)/lessorequalslant/angbracketleftbig S(Y)wrS(Z) and so the required equality holds. Now we show that (10). As bS(Y)wrT(Z), we have
{b}/angbracketrightbig
/lessorequalslantS(Y)wrT(Z). AsT(Y) we obtain that T(Z) AsS(Y)wrT(Z) = (S1x***xSm)T(Z), we obtain that and so the claim is = (T1x *** xTm)T(Z), the arguments in the previous two paragraphs show that Asa, b T(Y)wrT(Z), we obtain a proper submonoid of each of the monoids equation (8) must be valid. In order to show (7), it suffices to prove that rank (T(Y)wrT(Z) :S(Y)wrS(Z))>1. Suppose {g}/angbracketrightbig
=T(Y)wrT(Z). Then there are g, g1,...,g kS(Y)wrS(Z), such that ggg1g***ggk=a. hence where we obtain that . Simi- larly, there exist h, h1,...,h kS(Y)wrS(Z)such that hgh1g***ghk=b, JO ~AO ARA 'UJO AND CSABA SCHNEIDER Hence, for some i {1,...,n}, we have ((1,1)g,(2,1)g) = ((i,1)h,(i,2)h), ((i,1),(i,2)). This, however, is a contradiction, the transformation gh-1preserves the equivalence relation ~P. Therefore we verified a proper submonoid of the wreath product T(Y)wrT(Z), which shows that equation (7) must hold. /square 4. T HERANK OFS(X,P) In this section we prove the following theorem. Theorem 4.1. IfXis a finite set such that a uniform partition of X thenS(X,P)is generated by two elements. In our terminology, the previous theorem gives that rank S(X,P) = 2 . We note that the rank of a transitive permutation group, such as S(X,P), is defined in permutation group theory as the number of orbits of a point-s tabilizer. Thus, in order to avoid possible confusion, we decided to state the th eorem above without using the notation rank S(X,P). Theorem 1.1 will follow from Lemmas 3.1 and 3.2 and Theorem 4. 1. Using the fact that S(X,P)is isomorphic to a wreath product S(Y)wrS(Z), it is not difficult to see that S(X,P)is generated by four elements. Indeed, con- sider the subgroups in (3) and (4). Since S(Y)wrS(Z) =
(S(Y)1x *** transitive by conjugation on the we obtain that S(Y)wrS(Z) 1,S(Z)/angbracketrightbig . full symmetric groups, they are generated by two element s, and so we generated by at most four elements. Essentially this is pr oved in [17, Theorem 2.6]. Before proving Theorem 4.1, we state two simple lemmas. LetGbe a permutation group acting on the set {1,...,n}and letFbe a the n-dimensional vector space over Fwith basis {e1,...,e n}. The groupGcan be thought of as a permutation group on the set {e1,...,e n}, and this defines an FG-module structure on Vas module Vis called the permutation module forGoverF. The following lemma is well-known; see, for instance, [18, L emma 5.3.4]. Lemma 4.1. IfX={1,...,n}, then the permutation module for S(X)over a field phas precisely two proper non-trivial n)|a1+***+an= 0}. Further, if otherwise V=U1U2. Suppose that G=G1x *** xGkwhere the Giare finite groups. For I
{G1,...,G k}the function the natural projection map. We also write ifor{Gi}. A subgroup XofGis said to be a strip if for each i= 1,...,k eitherXi= 1 orXi~=X. The set of Gisuch that 1 is called the support ofXand is denoted SuppX. Two strips A strip Xis said to be fullifXi=Gifor allGiSuppX,RANK OF THE ENDOMORPHISM MONOID OF A PARTITION 7 andXis called non-trivial A subgroup KofGis said to be alli. We recall a well-known lemma on finite simple groups which can be found in [23, page 328]. The proof of the lemma is elementary and doe s not use the finite simple group 4.2. LetMbe a direct product of finitely many non-abelian, finite simpl e groups and letHbe a subdirect subgroup of M. ThenHis the direct product of pairwise disjoint full strips of M. The wreath product of two transformation semigroups SandRwas defined in Section 2, and the definition can also be used to construct t he wreath product of two permutation groups GandH. Recall that the wreath product to GmHand a typical element of GwrHis denoted by (p1,...,p Setting p= (p1,...,p m), the same element can also be written as ps. The following lemma facilitates the calculations in GwrH. Lemma 4.3. Letps, p1s1, as above. particular the projection map :GwrH-Hdefined by ps/mapsto-sis a The assertion that is a homomorphism follows from (i). The rest can be verified using (5) and (6). /square Now we are ready to prove Theorem 4.1. Permutations of a finite set will be written as products of disjoint cycles. The proof of Theorem 4.1.By Lemma 2.1(iv), it suffices to show, for that the group W=S(Y)wrS(Z)is generated by two ele- ments whenever Since, for a finite set Y, the group S(Y)is generated by two elements, we may assume that LetA(Y)denote the group of even permutations of Y. ThenA(Y)is a normal subgroup of index two of we may consider the subgroups letAandSdenote these subgroups us eithernormis we claim that the natural projection map in Lemma 4.3. If either n ormis odd then otherwise obtain that M=S(Z). AsS= ker, in order to prove that M=W, it suffices to show that we claim that Ifn= 2, thenA= 1, and so we may First we suppose that n= 3. In this case A~=(C3)mand soA can be viewed as a W-module over F3, and, in particular, it can be viewed as a8 JO ~AO ARA 'UJO AND CSABA over the same field. In fact, Ais the natural permutation module for S(Z). SinceM=S(Z), the intersection AMis anS(Z)-submodule of A. Now y2= soy2AM, but, theny2is not an element of either of the two proper submodules listed in Le mma 4.1. Therefore AM=A, and when n= The case (n,m) = (3,2) can be checked using a computer algebra package such as GAP [8] or M AGMA [6]. Let us assume that n= 4, that is, Y={1,...,4}, and, as above, we may also assume without loss of generality that Note that A(Y)admits the decom- position A(Y) Ucan be considered as an irreducible V-module over F2. Letmbe odd and set z1= (xmy2)2. As xmy2= obtain that z1= (xmy2)2= AsM=S(Z), the subgroup Mhas an element of the form p(2,3)wherepS. Then set z=zp(2,3) 1 and compute that z=zp(2,3) 1= three- cycles in S(Y). Now set w1= (xm)y4xm= consider the element w=wz 1w1. Now, as the first component of zSis a non-trivial three cycle, the element wis of the form w= now that mis even and set z= (xm-1y2)4. Easy computation yields that z= (xm-1y2)4= that w= (xm-1)y4xm-1= irreducible on U, the computation above shows that the by wcoincides with Ux1x***x1ofmis odd, and even. Thus the former case, and the latter. As M=S(Z), we also obtain that the quotient be considered as a for S(Z)overF3, and we aS(Z)-submodule. However, the image of the element zabove is not in either of the proper submodules listed in Lemma 4.1, and so we shows that Hence we have shown that Assume now that In this caseA(Y)is a non-abelian finite simple group and so Ais a non-abelian simple group. SetQ=MS. Clearly, Let us show that Qis a subdirect sub- group of S=S(Y)m. Ifnormis odd then set z=xm= set z=xm-1= Further, y2= z, y2Q. Let2denote the second coordinate projection (1,2)Q2andy22= (1,2,...,n)Q2, we obtain that Q2=RANK OF THE ENDOMORPHISM MONOID OF A PARTITION 9 S(Y). Simple computation shows that if it follows that Qi=S(Y)for alli, and so Qis a subdirect sub- group of S=S(Y)m. Consider the commutator subgroup Q'. SinceS'=A, we obtain that Further, as Qi=S(Y), we also obtain, for all i, that Q'i=A(Y). Therefore Q'is a subdirect subgroup of A=A(Y)m. a subdirect subgroup, we obtain that so is R; that is, by Lemma 4.2, Ris a direct product of disjoint strips. LetSbe a strip in Rand letS {1,...,m}be the support of S. We claim that Sis a block for the action of S(Z). Indeed, if sS(Z)then there is some pS such that psM. ThenSpsis strip in Rand so either S=SpsorSSps= 1. The support of SpsisSs. Thus either Ss=SorSs S=, which shows that Sis a block, as required. Since S(Z)is primitive on 1 or S={1,...,m}. If the latter holds, then Qis a strip. This, however, is if m= 2 andnis odd, then set z=xy= ifm= 2 andnis even then set z=xy2= then set z=y2= Then in all cases z2R, butz2is not in a full strip (if m= 2andnis even then note that the first component of z2is of order n/2and the second is of order n-1). Thus|S|= 1, and so This completes the proof of the claim that that allnandm. Note that Ais a normal subgroup of Wand the natural homo- morphism W-W/A . the image HA/A ofH. We claim that Note that obtain that shows that aS(Z)-submodule of It is clear that /hatwideSis the natural permutation module for S(Z)overF2. Lemma 4.1 lists the submodules bothnandmare even then /hatwidexm-1= (0,1,...,1)and this element is not in eitherU1orU2. Hence If this is not the case, then /hatwidexm= that Ifnis even and mis odd then /hatwidey2= (1,1,0,...,0)and Therefore in this case that nis odd. If m= 2thenxy= not in either of the proper submodules listed in Lemma 4.1. Hence in this case. If then xy= (2,3,...,m)so thatxy=ps. As sm-1= 1, it follows from Lemma 4.3 of the form (id,p2,...,p m)where, for i= 2,...,m , the either that is, piis a cycle with lengthn-1. Asnis and so (0,1,1,...,1). Now if m is even then not an element of U1orU2, and so also in this case. If mis odd then this shows that and as we proved above it follows that 10 JO ~AO ARA 'UJO AND CSABA SCHNEIDER Thus we have shown that required. As explained above, M=W now follows. /square The main result of the paper can now be proved. The proof of Theorem 1.1.As usual, we assume without loss of generality that the partition
By Lemmas 2.1, 3.1, 3.2 and Theorem 4.1, rankT(X,P) =rank(T(X,P) :S(X,P))+ :S(Y)wrS(Z))+ rankS(Y)wrS(Z) = 4. The assertions concerning rank G(X,P)and rank S(X,P)can be proved very sim- ilarly. acknowledge with gratitude some conversations with John D. Dixon, Peter M. Neumann and Joseph J. Rotman. The first author was partially supported by FCT and FEDER, Pro ject of Centro de Algebra da Universidade de Lisboa, a nd by FCT and PID- DAC through the project second author is grateful to the Centro de 'Algebra da Universidade de Lis- boa for the invitation and the hospitality; he was also suppo rted by the Research Fund (OTKA) grant J. Ara ' ujo and J. D. Mitchell. Relative ranks in the monoi d of endomorphisms of an Monatsh. Math. , 151(1):1-10, 2007. [2] J. Ara ' ujo, J. D. Mitchell, and N. Silva. On generating co untable sets of endomorphisms. , 50(1):61-67, 2003. [3] S. Banach. Sur un theor` eme de M. Sierpi' nski. Fund. Math. , 25:5-6, 1935. [4] George Barnes and Inessa Levi. Ranks of semigroups gener ated by order-preserving with a fixed partition type. Comm. Algebra , 31(4):1753-1763, 2003. [5] George Barnes and Inessa Levi. On idempotent ranks of sem igroups of partial Forum , 70(1):81-96, 2005. [6] Wieb Bosma, John Cannon, and Catherine Playoust. The Mag ma algebra system I: The user lan- guage. J. Symbolic Comput. , 24(3-4):235-265, 1997. Computational algebra and number theory (Lon- don, 1993). [7] J. Cicho' n, J. D. Mitchell, and M. Morayne. Generating co ntinuous mappings with Lipschitz map- pings. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. , 359(5):2059-2074 (electronic), 2007. [8] The GAP Group. GAP - Groups, Algorithms, and Programming, Version 4.4.10 , 2007. [9] G. U. Garba. On the nilpotent ranks of certain semigroups of transformations. Glasgow Math. J. , 36(1):1-9, 1994. [10] Gracinda M. S. Gomes and John M. Howie. On the ranks of cer tain semigroups of Semigroup Forum , 45(3):272-282, 1992. [11] P . M. Higgins, J. M. Howie, J. D. Mitchell, and N. RuV skuc . Countable versus uncountable ranks in infinite semigroups of transformations and relations. Proc. Edinb. Math. Soc. (2) , P . M. Higgins, J. D. Mitchell, M. Morayne, and N. RuV skuc . Rank properties of endomorphisms of infinite partially ordered sets. Bull. London Math. Soc. , 38(2):177-191, 2006. [13] Peter M. Higgins, John M. Howie, and Nikola RuV skuc. Gen erators and factorisations of transfor- mation semigroups. Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A , 1998.RANK OF THE ENDOMORPHISM MONOID OF A PARTITION 11 [14] John M. Howie. Fundamentals of semigroup theory , volume 12 of London Mathematical Society Mono- graphs. New Series . The Clarendon Press Oxford University Press, New York, 199 5. Oxford John M. Howie and Robert B. McFadden. Idempotent rank in finite full transformation semi- groups. Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A , 1990. [16] John M. Howie, N. RuV skuc, and P . M. Higgins. On relative ranks of full transformation semi- groups. Comm. Algebra , 26(3):733-748, 1998. [17] Pei Huisheng. On the rank of the semigroup TE(X).Semigroup Forum , 70(1):107-117, 2005. [18] Peter Kleidman and Martin Liebeck. The subgroup structure of the finite classical groups , volume 129 ofLondon Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series . Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1990. [19] Inessa Levi. Nilpotent ranks of semigroups of partial t ransformations. Semigroup Forum , 72(3):459- 476, 2006. [20] Inessa Levi and Steve Seif. Combinatorial techniques f or determining rank and idempotent rank of certain finite semigroups. Proc. Edinb. Math. Soc. (2) , 45(3):617-630, 2002. [21] J. D. P . Meldrum. Wreath products of groups and semigroups , volume 74 of Pitman Monographs and Surveys in Pure and Applied Mathematics . Longman, Harlow, 1995. [22] Maria Isabel Marques Ribeiro. Rank properties in finite inverse semigroups. Proc. Edinburgh Math. Soc. (2) , 43(3):559-568, 2000. [23] Leonard L. Scott. Representations in characteristic p. InThe Santa Cruz Conference on Finite Groups (Univ. California, Santa Cruz, Calif., 1979) , volume 37 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math. , pages 319-331. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, R.I., 1980. [24] Wacl aw Sierpi' nski. Sur les suites infinies de fonction s d' efinies dans les ensembles Math. , 24:209-212, 1935. [25] Howard Straubing. The wreath product and its applicati ons. In Formal properties of finite au- tomata and applications (Ramatuelle, 1988) , volume 386 of Lecture Notes in Comput. Sci. , pages 15-24. Springer, Berlin, I NFORMATICS RESEARCH LABORATORY , COMPUTER AND AUTOMATION , 1518 B UDAPEST PF. 63, H UNGARY CENTRO DE 'ALGEBRA DA UNIVERSIDADE DE LISBOA , AV. PROF. GAMA PINTO 2, 1649-003 L ISBOA , PORTUGAL EMAIL :CSABA .SCHNEIDER @GMAIL .COM WWW: WWW .SZTAKI ' ujo) U NIVERSIDADE ABERTA , R. E SCOLA POLIT 'ECNICA 147, 1269-001 L ISBOA , PORTUGAL CENTRO DE 'ALGEBRA , UNIVERSIDADE DE LISBOA , 1649-003 L ISBOA , PORTUGAL EMAIL :JARAUJO @LMC .FC.UL.PT
|
0807.1214
|
Csaba Schneider
|
Joao Araujo and Csaba Schneider
|
The Rank of the Endomorphism Monoid of a Partition
|
11 pages
| null | null | null |
math.GR math.RA
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The rank of a semigroup is the cardinality of a smallest generating set. In
this paper we compute the rank of the endomorphism monoid of a non-trivial
uniform partition of a finite set, that is, the semigroup of those
transformations of a finite set that leave a non-trivial uniform partition
invariant. That involves proving that the rank of a wreath product of two
symmetric groups is two and then use the fact that the endomorphism monoid of a
partition is isomorphic to a wreath product of two full transformation
semigroups. The calculation of the rank of these semigroups solves an open
question.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 8 Jul 2008 11:33:16 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-09T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Araujo",
"Joao",
""
],
[
"Schneider",
"Csaba",
""
]
] |
2 introduced characteristic possesses the properties simil ar to these ones of the classical Nevanlinna begin consider meromorphic functions with two possible e ssential singu- larities. Up to a linear fractional transformation we have 0 and.That is, we consider meromorphic functions in the plane punctured at the origin. We will approach to both singularities by the annuli. Asr={z:s <|z|< r}.In other words, seems that consideration of annuli be more that there are essential differences between disks and annuli in the topoligal sence which are reflected in the theory of meromorp hic the fundamental (Poincr' e) group of a disk is trivi al, while for an annulus, we have a group isomorphic to the additive group Z.Secondly, the group of automorphisms of the unit disk is rich. It consists o f the M Therefore, the Poisson integral formula is an invariant form of the Gauss mean theorem and the Poisson-Jensen formula is a n invariant form of Jensen's formula. More over, all disks are conformal lyequivalent. isanother. The group of automorphism sof an annulusis poor. consists of rotationsonly. Annuli A1randA1ris iff r=r.Therefore, the theory of meromorphic functions on annuli is more complicated that this one in disks. But many results f or in Chave their counterparts for these ones in a punctured plane C*.For example, the Picard theorem may be reformulated in the fo rm. For every non-constant meromorphic function in C*there is a linear o(C*)f(C*). If both, oandf,are identical maps, we have the coincidence. In order to introduce a two-parameter characteristic we use the notion of3 index of a meromorphic function along a circle. 10.Index of falong a circle Lemma 1. Letfbe a function meromorphic on {z:|z|=t},non identical zero. Then n(t,f) an holomorphic on the zeroes on this circle then G( th) = a closed path, IndG(0). Taking the real parts of both sides we have n(t,f) = 2Ind G(0). As index of z= 0 with respect to G is an integer we obtain the in this case. Iffhas a unique simple zero a=teia,thenf(z) the transformation w=1 1-zmaps the unit circle on the straight line Rew= 1/2.Hence, in this case n(t,f) a simple pole on the considered circle, then we obtain the similar equality with - instead of +. The final conclusion in the g eneral case now follows by induction. The value n(t,f) is said to be index offalong the circle {z:|z|=t}. If a branch of log fmay by determined on the circle, then andn(t,f) is the increment of1 pargfalong 1 of Jensen's theorem Lemma 2. Letfbe a function meromorphic on the closure of the annulus Asr={z:s <|z|< r},and non identical zero. (2) Proof.Assume that there are neither zeroes nor poles of fon the s<=t<=r}.Then a branch of log fcan by determined on this interval, and we last equality is valid for all thfrom [0,2p] except for a finite number of th.The integration over the Fubini theorem and changing the order of integrati on we 2 of Jensen's theorem Suppose on the closure of the annulus Asrand non identical zero. Put in (2) r= 1, (3) Putting now in (2) s= 1 and subtracting (3) we (4) In order to obtain Version 2 of Jensen's theorem we are going t o connect the notion of index n(t,f) with the counting functions of zeroes and poles of f. LetTbe the unit circle and n(s,r;f) be the number of poles of finAsr.6 It follows from the argument principle =
= =
= (6) under the assumption that neither zeroes nor poles of flie on the (4) - (6) yield the following lemma. Lemma 3. Letfbe a meromorphic function on the closure of A1 trand non identical zero. of f Now we are able to introduce a two-parameter characteristic of in an annulus which possesses the properties like to its We follow the Cartan idea. Applying (7) to the f integrating over phon [0,2p] we course, if the last integral exists. We will show that and evaluate the integral. Letfbe a meromorphic function on E0 f={Tz:|f(z)|= 4. Letfbe a meromorphic function on the unit circle T, proof of Lemma 4 needs some auxiliary results. Lemma 5. For each function fmeromorphic on {z:|z|=t}, (9) follows immediately from (1) and the 6. Letfbe a meromorphic function on the unit circle T, /e}atioslash= 1,we is true for each for a finite number of last equality by if'dz fand taking the real parts we if zE- f. for each for a finite number of =eia(th).We will use the an open arc then dlog|f(z)|= 0 on this arc,9 because log |f(z)|= 0.By 0 on the closure of the arc. Thus, the intersection of E0 fwith the empty or consists of isolated points. Besides this, Redz z-f= relation (12) (11) and (13) yield (10). Proof of Lemma 4. Applying Lemma 5 we Lemma 6, which evaluates the last integral, and (1) we obtain the conclusion of Lemma 4 from is usual Nevanlinna's 1. Letfbe a meromorphic function on the closure of A1 tr, r>=1,. called the characteristic of f. A strange example. Let =T(t,r;z-m) that the introduced not only for me 1. Letf, a meromorphic function on the annulus As0r0, s0<1< r0.Then the function T(t,r;f)is non-negative, continuous, non- decreasing and convex with respect to logarithm of each vari able for1<=t <
1/s0,1<=r < r0, T(1,1;f)= 0and T(t,r;1 f) function fhas the meromorphic continuation at the origin and T(r,f)is its Nevanlinna characteristic, r>=1. (17)11 Proof.The indicated properties follow immediately from (8), Lemm a 4 and Lemma 3. Moreover, relation (8) the points of continuity of seems, that the last identity with some boundary conditio n can be a definition of T(t,r;f). Verify also the identity T(t,r;1/f) =T(t,r;f).It follows from Version 2 of Jensen's theorem (see (7)) and the =cf-c1 f. (18) Relation (17) is in [1]. 50.First Fundamental Theorem (FFT) FFT.Letfbe a non-constant meromorphic function in {0}.Then t>=1, r>=1 <=4 <=C, C is a constant. (20) Proof.As in classical Nevanlinna theory we apply Version 2 of Jense n's theo- rem (see (7)) for have, as (9) for z=awe obtain e2(a) the last integral is bounded as a function of athen (20) is Andriy Kondratyuk and and Ilpo Laine, Meromorphic functions in mul- tiply connected domains , Fourier series methods in complex arvi, 2005). Univ. Joensuu Dept. Math. Rep. Ser. No 10 (2006), pp. 9-111.
|
0807.1247
|
Andriy Kondratyuk Andriyovych
|
Andriy Kondratyuk
|
Meromorphic functions with several essential singularities
|
13 pages
| null | null | null |
math.CV math.AP
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
A two-parameter characteristic of functions meromorphic on annuli is
introduced and an extension of the Nevanlinna value distribution theory for
such functions is proposed.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 8 Jul 2008 13:51:22 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-09T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Kondratyuk",
"Andriy",
""
]
] |
1 work deals with almost sure stabilizationof adaptive control sys tems an unknown parameter process that is a hidden Markov chain. T he systems belong to the class of partially observed control systems. Naturally, one estimates the by using nonlinear filtering techniques and then uses the es timator in the systems in order to design adaptive control strategies. The motivation of o ur study stems of the following problem. Let us begin with a hybrid linear quadratic is a continuous-time Markov chain taking values in a finite set Mare matrices with compatible dimensions, and U(t) is the control process. upofLQproblems, AiandBiare both subject to random switching influence. At any given instan ce, these coefficient matrices are chosen from a set Mwith a finite number of candidates. The selection rule is dictated by the modulating switching process a(t) that jump changes from one state to another at random times. Such systems have enjoye d numerous applications in emerging application areas as financial engineering, wireless commu nications, as well as in existing applications. A particular important problem concerns the asymptotic behavior of such systems when they are in operations for a long time. Our inte rest lies in controls so that the resulting system will be almost surely s tabilized. An added difficulty is that the process X(t) can only be observed with an additive noise dX(t) = such partially observed systems, it is natural to use nonlinear fi ltering techniques. The associated filter is known as the Wonham filter [17], which is one of a ha ndful of filters in quadratic (LQ) regulators appear to present rather simple structures. Meanwhile, there are so many applications that can be described by such proce sses. We refer the reader to [1, 2, 6, 16] for some recent work on the associated control, es timation, and for hybrid systems. Emerging applications have also been f ound in in which a Markov chain is used to represent the capacity o f an unreliable machine, 2in wireless communication, in which a Markov chain is used to depict rand omly time varying signals or channels. In financial engineering, a geometric Brownian m otion model for a stock is frequently used. The traditional setup can be described by a linea r stochastic where both the appreciate rate and volatility are consta nt. However, it has been recognized that such a formulation is far from realistic. Very often , there are due to the variation of interest rates and other rand om environment factors. For example, the well-known Markowitz's mean-variance portfolio se lection is one of the LQ control problems. Some recent effort for mean-variance cont rol problems has been on obtaining optimal portfolio selections when both the appreciation ra te and volatility depend on a Markov chain. For all of the applications mentioned above, prac tical lead to deal with unobservable Markov chains. In many situat ion, the Markov chain Thus, ls, stability, such systems will have significant impact to many In [16], stabilization for robust controls of jump LQ control pro blems was investigated. In [6], both controllability and stabilizability of jump linear LQ systems we re under random perturbations of Markov chain type can be t raced back to the work [8]. This line of work has been substantially expanded to diffusion syste ms in [9, 11]. Re- cently, renewed interests have been shown to deal with switching d iffusions; see for example [10, 14, 15, 20] among others. In the literature, stabilization of continuous-time, adaptive contr ol systems with hidden Markov chains were considered in [3, 5]. In both of these reference s, averaging criteria were used for the purpose of stabilization. To be more precise, adaptive control strategies were developed in [5] to make both the system and the control have boun ded second moment in the adaptive controls were obtained in [3] to have the second m oments of the averages of both the system and control bounded in the comparisons with the aforementioned references, it is a worthw hile effort to examine the pathwise stabilization of the associated LQ problems under part ial observations. First, 3to be of any practical use in applications, the system resulting from an adaptive control law should not allow wild behavior in the sample paths. Secondly, owing to the use of adaptive control strategies, known results in stability and stabiliza tion in systems cannot be applied directly. As will be seen in later section, the controls render difficulty in analyzing the underlying system s. Certain with the diffusion matrix in fact grow faster than normally is allowed in the standard analysis. When averaged criteria are used, this kind of diffi culty will not show up since by taking expectation, we can easily average out the Brownian motion term. However, when pathwise criteria are the used, we can no longer use the argum ent based on Thus the consideration of pathwise stabilization is bo th practically necessary and theoretically interesting. To begin our quest of finding admissible controls that stabilize the sys tems almost surely, we answer the question if the controlled process is regular. By a pro cess being regular we mean that it does not have finite explosion time with probability one. We under feedback controls under linear growth conditions for the feedback controls. Then, we develop sufficient conditions and admissible adaptive contro ls under which the system is stabilizable. Moreover, as a by-product, we also establish positive recurrence of the underlying processes as a corollary of our stabilization result. F or a deterministic system given by a differential equation, if the solutions are ultimately uniform ly bounded, then it is Lagrange stable. For stochastic systems, almost sure boundedn ess excludes many cases (e.g., any systems perturbed by a white noise). Thus, in lieu of such a boun dedness, one seeks stability in certain weak sense. So a process is recurrent if it starts from a point outside a compact set, the process will return to the bounded set with prob ability one. We say the process is positive recurrent if the expected return time is finite. I n fact, positive recurrence is termed weak stability for diffusion processes in [18]. For a practical system, no finite explosion time is a must. In addition, starting from a point outside of a bounded set, the system should be able to return to the set infinitely often with proba bility one. Moreover, the average return time cannot be infinitely long otherwise the cont rolled system is useless. Thus, regularity and recurrence of adaptive control systems ca n be viewed as conditions. The rest of the paper is organised as follows. Section 2 presents th e formulation Section 3 investigates the regularity of the underlying process. Our conclusion 4is that, as long as the feedback controls have linear growth, the re sulting systems will be regular. Section 4 proceeds with the study of stabilization. We conc lude the paper with some additional remarks in Section 5. In order to preserve the flow of presentation, proofs of a couple of technical results are postponed to two appendices t o facilitate the reading. 2 Formulation and Preliminary 2.1 Problem s-algebras (Ft). Leta(t) be a continuous-time Markov chain with a finite state space M={1,...,m}
and transition rate matrix P = ( pij)Rmxm, andW(t) be a standard Rn-valued Brownian motion. In the above and hereafter, A'denotes the transpose of a matrix the trace norm of A, and|v|=
v'vis the usual Euclidean norm of a vector v. Assume throughout the paper that W(t) anda(t) are independent. Let the state and control processes, respectively. For i matrices with appropriate dimensions. Our main interest focuse s on the following regime-switching stochastic system dX(t) = (2.1) with square integrable initial condition X(0) =xAs in [3, 5], denoting the column vector of Rmof indicator functions by Ph(t) = (1I E, wemaypresent thedynamics of the Markov chain by dPh(t) = process M(t) is anRm-valued square integrable martingale with right continuous trajec- tories. The independence of a(t) andW(t) implies that of Ph( t) andW(t). In all the sequel, we also assume that x, Ph(t), andW(t) are mutually independent. Consider the quadratic cost the expectation with initial conditions X(0) =x,a(0) =a, and for eachi M,Qiis a symmetric positive semi-definite matrix, and Riis a symmetric matrix. One of the main features of the system considered here is that the Markov chain is a hidden one. As treated in [3, 5], the essence is that we are dealing with a system (2.1) with unknown mode that switches back and forth amo ng a finite set at random times. But different from previous consideration, we wish to establish the regularity of the process and to find conditions ensuring almost sure stabilizat ion. The almost poses new challenges and difficulties since we cannot aver age out the martingale term by means of taking expectations. Compared with the aforeme ntioned papers, are needed. Here the keystone is to find a suitable Lyap unov the paper, the process X(t) is assumed to be observable, but this is not the case for the switching process a(t). The problem belongs to the category of controls with partial observations. Observing a(t) through the adaptive control process with Gaussian white noise brings us to the framework of the setup of Wonham filter ing problems [17]. Denote by FX tthes-algebra generated by For the problem of interest, a control is said to be admissible if for each t>=0,U(t) We are now in position to state precisely the problem we wish to study. Problem statement. Under the setup presented so far, we aim to solve the We analyze (2.1) and obtain conditions under which the system will b e regular. Hence, our goal is to propose sufficient conditions ensuring the process will not have finite explosion time. We show that, as long as the feedback control U(as a function of x) has linear growth in x, the resulting adaptive control system will be regular. 2. We design admissible adaptive controls and provide sufficient condit ions that stabilize the closed-loop system almost surely (a.s.). Loosely, the sufficient c ondition ensures that for almost all sample points o(except a null set), the corresponding system will be stabilizable. The precise definition of almost sure stabilization will be provided in the next section. 62.2 Preliminary As in [3, 5], we convert this partially observed system to a control pr ocess with It entails to replace the hidden state Ph( t) by its estimator, namely the well- known Wonham filter /hatwidePh(t). Using feedback control U(t) we shall need the following = = = (diag( ph)-phph') = diag( ph1,...,ph m).(2.2) Denote also the innovation process by dV(t) the above notation, we can rewrite the converted completely observable system for the identity matrix of order n. Remark 2.1. Before proceeding further, we shall make a few remarks.
*The form C(X(t)) indicates the X(t)-dependence. When the feedback control U(t) is of linear form, it depends on X(t) linearly. This point will be used in what follows.
*The equivalent and completely observable system can be viewed as a c ontrolled diffu- sion, in which the usual diffusion term is replaced the driven Brownian motion is given by V(t).
*When linear feedback control is used, boththe drift anddiffusion gr owat most linearly, which is a useful is the probability conditioned on the observation, for each t>=0 and each i = 1. Denote the joint vector by Y(t) = In what follows, we often consider |Y(t)| >=rfor some r >0, where |Y|is the usual Euclidean norm. Denote by N(0;r)Rn+mthe neighborhood centered at 0 with radius r. Using the notation defined in (2.2) associated with the stochastic differential equation (2.3), w e define the For each sufficiently smooth real-valued function define Lh(y) the gradient and Hessian of h, respectively. 3 let us recall the definition of regularity. According to [9], the M arkov process Y(t) regular, if for any 0 < T 0. Roughly speaking, regularity ensures the process under consider ation will not have finite explosion time. For our adaptive control systems, we proceed to s how that under linear feedback control, the systems is regular. Theorem 3.1. Assume that the feedback control U(t) admissible and that it grows at most linearly in X(t). Then, the feedback control system (2.3)is regular. Remark 3.2. In fact, for our problem, we are mainly interested in linear (in controls. In this case, the linear growth condition is clear ly Th be an open set in Rn+mand (x,ph)'Th,ph= (ph1,...,ph m) satisfying phi>=0 fori first observe that both the drift and the diffusion coefficient give n in (2.3) satisfy the linear growth and Lipschitz condition in every open set in ORn+m. Thus, to prove the regularity, using the result in [9], we only need to show that there is a n onnegative function Uwhich is twice continuously differentiable in Or={yO,|y|> r}for some r >0 with y= (x,ph)'such asR- , (3.1) and that there is an g >0 (3.2) Thus, to verify the regularity of the process Y(t), all needed is to construct an function U. Note that we only need a Lyapunov function that is smooth and defined in the complement of a sphere. Equivalently, we only need the smoothness of the Lyapunov function to be in a deleted neighborhood of the origin. To t his end, take r= 1 and denote by O1the andph= (ph1,...,ph m) fori =|y|. It is easily checked that condition (3.1) holds. Moreover, we it follows from (2.4) that LU(x,ph) that the set that we are working with is O1defined in (3.3). In particular, the use ofO1yields that for any yO1,|ph|is always bounded. We also note that owing to the definition of C(x) and the linear growth feedback controls used, C(x) is a function grows at mostly linearly in x. To proceed, henceforth, use gas a generic positive constant with the convention that g+g=gandgg=gin an appropriate sense. It follows that for the terms on the third line from bottom of (3.4), for |(x,ph)'|large for the next two term, we the above estimates, we can deduce some g >0. Consequently, the second condition (3.2) is satisfied. Thus the r egularity of the feedback control is obtained. /square 4 Stabilization In this section, we establish conditions under which the system of int erest is stabilizable in the almost sure sense. We first present the definition and then pro ceed to find for 4.1. System (2.1) or equivalently (2.3) is said to be almost surely stabilizable if there is a feedback control law U(t) such that the resulting trajectories <=0 almost surely. (4.1) Note that the definition given in (4.1) is natural. When studying stabilit y of equations, especially for pathwise stability, one uses th e so-called some q >0. Here, roughly, we require that under the control law, the first -moment Lyapunov exponent is Auxiliary Results Before proceeding further, let us first recall a lemma, which is conc erned with the existence of the associated system of Riccati equations when quadratic cos t criteria are used. The proof of the lemma is given in [7]. Lemma 4.2. Consider the system of Riccati 0, i M, symmetric and positive semi-definite, and RRmxmis symmetric and positive definite. The system (4.2)has a solution if and only if for each i M, there is if Qis positive definite, so are Pifori M. To carry out the analysis, we need some auxiliary results on the boun ds of the process. Before getting the almost sure bounds, we exa mine the moment bounds for certain related martingales, which turn out to be interesting in t heir own right. The main ingredient is the use of properties of the associated Markov chain. 11Moment 4.3. Consider the stochastic differential = (4.4) and define the associate martingale N(t) (4.5) Suppose that the Markov chain a(t)is irreducible. Then, for some positive constant K independent of (4.6) Proof.The proof is given in Appendix A. /square Remark 4.4. It follows from the proof of Proposition 4.3 that the limit of the matrix S= finite. Clearly, this matrix is symmetric and positive semi definite. A m oment of reflect reveals that we can further prove the asymptotic normality. That in distribution to N(0,S) ast- . That is, a normalized sequence defined on the left-hand side above c onverges in distribution to a normal random vector with mean 0 and covariance S. Another ramification is that in lieu of considering the second-moment bounds, we can deal with qth-moment bounds. In fact, using the same techniques, we can sh ow that for any integerp as the solution (4.4) is given by
/hatwidePh(t) means that N(t) obtain for odd exponents and for any integer p>=1, it follows from H older's inequality we conclude that for any positive integer Sure Bounds For the almost sure stabilization, we need to show some K >0 independent of t. Proposition 4.5. Consider (4.4)and suppose that the Markov chain a(t)is the quadratic variation of the process some positive constant independent of t. = 0 a.s. (4.7) Proof.The proof is given in Appendix B. /square 4.2 4.6. Consider the set defined by (ph1,...,ph m)satisfying (4.8) 13For some th >0, letVth(x,ph) : = Then, we have LVth(x,ph) (P1,...,P m)', x'/tildewidePx= (P1x,...,P mx)Rnxm, x'/tildewideP= 0 mstands for a square matrix of order mwith all entries equal to zero. Consequently, it follows from (2.4) that LVth(x,ph) (In, immediately implies (4.9). /square For the purpose of stabilization, we also need an estimate on 4.7. Assume that equation (4.3)is satisfied and positive definite matrices for all (i,j) M2wherePifori Mare the solutions of the algebraic Riccati equations given by (4.2). Then, the infinitesimal generator of the with the feedback control law U(t) (4.11) satisfies for some constant g (4.12) Proof.We can deduce from Lemma 4.6 following exactly the same lines as in [5], we obtain completes the proof of Lemma 4.7. /square Theorem 4.8. Assume that the conditions of Lemma 4.7are satisfied. Then, the feedback control law defined in equation (4.11)stabilizes the system (2.3)almost surely. Proof.It follows from Ito's rule (4.13) with the initial condition X(0) =phand the martingale term M(t) can split the martingale M(t) into two terms, M(t) =N1(t)+N2(t) with N1(t) is easy to see N1(t)satisfies Consequently, wededuce from the strong law of large numbers for local martingales [12] = 0 a.s. (4.14) In view of Proposition 4.5, one can also find a positive constant K2, independent of t, also ensures = 0 a.s. (4.14) and (4.16) imply = 0 a.s. (4.17) Thus, we find from (4.13) a.s. Moreover, Vth(x,ph)/t=o(1) ast- a.s. By virtue of Lemma 4.7, it follows that for all th = one can observe that since P(ph) is , the minimal eigenvalue of P(ph) is positive. leads (4.19) Finally, we conclude from (4.18) and (4.19) that for all th <=g 2tha.s. We complete the proof of Theorem 4.8 by taking the limit as thtends to infinity. /square Remark 4.9. Normally, dealing with stochastic differential equations, to obtain th e almost sure bounds of the solutions, one often relies on the use of approp riate Lyapunov functions to have the diffusion term of the process be bounded after a trans formation. Here, we are dealing with a martingale term with some what faster rate of growth in x. to the second component of the diffusion (4.4), the probab ilistic meaning of us to work around the obstacle. To obtain the desired boun ds, an alternative is to obtain an almost sure central limit theorem. Here however, we take a different approach. The main point is the use of Proposition 4.5. Recall the notion of recurrence for the diffusion process ( starting at X(0) =ph. Consider an open set Owith compact closure, and let sx,ph O= >0,(O/bracerightBig bethefirstentrance O. If(isregular, respect to OifP{sx,ph O<}= 1 for any ( x,ph)Oc, whereOcis the complement ofO. A recurrent process with finite mean recurrence time for some se tO, is said to be positive recurrent with respect to O, otherwise, the process is null recurrent with respect to O. It has been proven in [9] that recurrence and positive recurrenc e are independent of the setOchosen. Thus, if it is recurrent (resp. positive recurrent) with re spect toD, then it is recurrent (resp. positive recurrent) with respect to any other open set Th in the domain of 17interest. Looking over the proof of the stabilization presented, w e could show that for the Lyapunov = can find g >0 such that for all ( -g. (4.20) In view of the known result of positive recurrence of diffusion proce sses [9], (4.20) is precisely a necessary and sufficient condition for positive recurrence. Thus , we obtain the following result as a 4.10 Under the conditions of Theorem 4.8, with the control law (4.11)used, the diffusion systems (2.3)is positive recurrent. We would like to add that the positive recurrence of the process is an important property. It has engineering implication for various applications. Essentially, it e nsures that starting from a point outside of a bounded set, the control laws enables the system to return to a compact set almost surely. This may be viewed as a practical stability condition. In fact, Wonham used the term weak stability for such a property in his paper [18]. 5 Further Remarks This paper has been concerned with stabilization in the almost sure se nse of an adaptive control system with linear dynamics modulated by an unknown Marko v chain. Under the framework of Wonham filtering, the underlying system is converted to a fully Using feedback control that is linear in the continuous sta te variable, we stabilization of the process. Along the way of our study, w e have also process. Inaddition, asacorollary, we control law, the resulting system is positive recurrent. T hese results pave a way for practical consideration of stabilization of adaptive controls of LQ systems with a hidden Markov chain. Several directions may be worthwhile for further st udy and our study, irreducibility of the Markov chain is used. We note that the irreducibil- ity ensures the spectrum gap condition or exponential decay in (A.6 ) and (A.9) of Proposition 4.3 to hold. It will be interesting to see if it is possible to rem ove Our initial thoughts are: Under certain conditions, this m ight be possible. For example, if the Markov chain has several irreducible classes suc h that the states in each class vary rapidly, and among different classes, they change s lowly. One may be able to use the different time scales to overcome the difficulty under t he framework of time-scale separation using a singular perturbation approach. How ever, the details on this need to be thoroughly worked out; they are in fact out of the s cope of the will be interesting to design admissible controls and find sufficient co nditions of LQ systems with a hidden Markov in our setup, the process X(t) represents the noisy Markov chain observed in white noise. A class of controlled regime-switching diffusio n systems pro- vides a somewhat more complex setup. In such a system, the dynam ics are represented by switching diffusions with a hidden Markov chain. The Markov chain is n ot observ- able but can only be observed in another Gaussian white noise. That is , let us consider the controlled system dY(t) = andX(t) are vector-valued processes with compatible dimensions repre- senting the state and observations, respectively, V(t) andW(t) are independent Brownian motions, and a(t) is the hidden Markov chain with a finite state space. As was alluded to in the introduction, one of the motivations is portfolio selections [19]. One may then pose similar sta bilization using regime-switching jump diffusions, which are switching diffusions with additional external jumps of a compound Poisson process, for mo deling surplus in in- surance risk has drawn much attention. A related problem in the ada ptive setup is a regime-switching jump diffusion system in which the hidden Markov ch ain is ob- served similar to the observation in (5.1). One may then proceed with the study of stabilization problems. 19*In the study of stabilization, positive definiteness of certain matric es is used (see Lemma 4.2). A challenging problem is to investigate the stabilization pro blem with the positive definiteness removed for the system given by (5.1). He re, the crucial point seems to rely on recent developments in LQ problems with indefinite co ntrol weights [4]. One needs to use the backward stochastic differential equation s from the toolbox of stochastic analysis. All of these problems deserve further study and A. This appendix is devoted to the proof of Proposition 4.3. It is divided in to several steps. Step 1. We already saw that the solution (4.4) is given by
/hatwidePh(t) (A.1) In view of (A.1), the probabilistic interpretation of /hatwidePh(t) implies that N(t) is a almost surely for each t >0. We proceed to obtain the moment bounds of N(t). Step 2. As P is the generator of the irreducible Markov chain a(t), its unique nsatisfies P'n= 0. Hence, it follows the one hand, we clearly have from (4.5) E[|N(t)|2] (A.2) On the other hand, we deduce from (A.1) the symmetric matrix G(r,s) = (gij(r,s)) can observe that gij(r,s) =i) -niP(a(s) also by the Fubini Theorem = 2g1(t). We have the =P(a(r) =i)P(a(s) =j|a(r) =i)-njP(a(r) =i). Before proceeding further, let us first note the following mixing pro perties regarding the Markov chain a(t). For all t>=0 ands<=t, denote p(t) = (P(a(t) = 1),...,P(a(t) =m))'Rm, P(t,s) = ((P(a(t) =j|a(s) =i), i,j M)Rmxm, which vector of theMarkov chaina(t), is irreducible, it is ergodic. Consequently, as tgoes to infinity, for the solution of 21the P'p(t) p(0) = 1, one can find two positive constants kandKsuch that <=Kexp(-kt) (A.6) By virtue of (A.6), it is easily seen l1(t) goes to zero as ttends to infinity. Next, we shall show that h1(t) is bounded. As before, the solution of the P'P(t,s) P(s,s) also satisfies for two positive constants landK,P(t,s)-1 1n'and
|P(t,s)-1 1n'| <=Kexp(-l(t-s)). (A.9) It follows from (A.9) =j|a(r) =j|a(r) h1(t) as well as g1(t) are bounded sequences which ensures that for some Kindependent of (A.10) Finally, (A.2) together with (A.3) and (A.10) imply (4.6) which completes the proof of Proposition 4.3. /square Appendix B. We shall now focus on the proof of Proposition 4.5. First of all, we kno w <=1 a.s. In addition, we also have |/hatwidePh(t)| <=1 a.s. Consequently, it follows from (A.1) that
|N(t)| <= (B.1) For each i M, denote Ni(t) theijth entry of the matrix stands thejth component of V(s). It follows from the well-known Doob's martingale inequality given for example in [13, Theorem 1.7.4, p. 44] that for each i Mand each we deduce from the Borel-Cantelli Lemma that for almost all oohm, there is a K1=K1(o)>1 such that for all last line above follows from (B.1). Dividing both sides of (B.3) by t, we obtain that the bound K3is independent of t. Consequently, for some positive constant Kindepen- dent oft, the quadratic variation of the martingale is bounded by Ktalmost surely. That is, (B.4) implies that Finally, we deduce from the strong law of large numbers for local martingales [12] = 0 a.s. which concludes the proof of Proposition 4.5. W. P. Blair and D. D. Sworder, Feedback control of a class o f linear discrete systems with jump parameters and quadratic cost criteria, Int. J. Control ,21(1986), 833-841. [2] P. E. Caines and H. F. Chen, Optimal adaptive LQG control f or systems with finite state process parameters, IEEE Trans. Automat. Control ,30(1985), 185-189. [3] P.E. Caines and J.-F. Zhang, On the adaptive control of ju mpparameter systems via SIAM J. Control Optim. ,33(1995), 1758-1777. [4] S. Chen, X. Li, and X.Y. Zhou, Stochastic linear quadrati c regulators with indefinite control weight costs, SIAM J. Control Optim. 36(1998), 1685-1702. [5] F. Dufour and P. Bertrand, Stabilizing control law for hy brid modes, IEEE Trans. 2354-2357. [6] Y. Ji and H.J. Chizeck, Controllability, stabilizabili ty, and continuous-time Markovian jump linear quadratic control, IEEE Trans. Automatic Control ,35(1990), 777-788. [7] H. Abou-Kandil, G. Greling, andG. Jank, Solutionandasy in jump linear systems, IEEE Trans. Automatic Control ,39(1994), 1631-1636. [8] I.Ia. Kac and N.N. Krasovskii, On the stability of system s with random parameters, J. Appl. Math. Mech. ,24(1960), 1225-1246. [9] R.Z.Khasminskii, Stochastic Stability of Differential Equations , Alphen aan den Rijn, Netherlands, 1980. [10] R.Z. Khasminskii, C. Zhu, and G. Yin, Stability of regim e-switcing diffusions, Stoachstic H.J. Kushner, Stochastic Stability and Control , Academic Press, New York, NY, 1967. [12] R. Liptser, A strong law of large numbers for local marti 3(1980), 217-228. [13] X. Mao, Stochastic Differential Equations and Applications , 2nd Ed., Horwood, Chichester, UK, 2007. [14] X. Mao, Stability of stochastic differential equations w ith Markovian switching, Appl. ,79(1999), 45-67. [15] X. Mao, G. Yin, and C. Yuan, Stabilization and destabili zation of hybrid systems of equations, Automatica ,43(2007), 264-273. [16] M. Mariton and P. Bertrand, Robust jump linear quadrati c control: A mode stabilizing solu- tion,IEEE Trans. Automat. Control ,AC-30(1985), 1145-1147. [17] W.M. Wonham, Some applications of stochastic differenti al equations to optimal SIAM J. Control ,2(1965), 347-369. [18] W.M. Wonham, Liapunov criteria for weak stochastic sta bility,J. Differential Eqs. X.Y. Zhou and G. Yin, Markowitz's mean-variance portfo lio selection with regime switching: A Continuous-time model, SIAM J. Control Optim ,42(2003), 1466-1482. [20] C. Zhu and G. Yin, Asymptotic properties of hybrid diffusi on systems, SIAM J. 1155-1179. 25
|
0807.1413
|
Bercu Bernard
|
Bernard Bercu, Francois Dufour, G. George Yin
|
Almost Sure Stabilization for Adaptive Controls of Regime-switching LQ
Systems with A Hidden Markov Chain
| null | null | null | null |
math.PR
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
This work is devoted to the almost sure stabilization of adaptive control
systems that involve an unknown Markov chain. The control system displays
continuous dynamics represented by differential equations and discrete events
given by a hidden Markov chain. Different from previous work on stabilization
of adaptive controlled systems with a hidden Markov chain, where average
criteria were considered, this work focuses on the almost sure stabilization or
sample path stabilization of the underlying processes. Under simple conditions,
it is shown that as long as the feedback controls have linear growth in the
continuous component, the resulting process is regular. Moreover, by
appropriate choice of the Lyapunov functions, it is shown that the adaptive
system is stabilizable almost surely. As a by-product, it is also established
that the controlled process is positive recurrent.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 9 Jul 2008 10:42:30 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-10T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Bercu",
"Bernard",
""
],
[
"Dufour",
"Francois",
""
],
[
"Yin",
"G. George",
""
]
] |
I. INTRODUCTION In the past few months, the study of M2-branes was revived1, initiated by Bagger and Lambert [2, 3, 4] and Gustavsson [5, 6], in which the world-volume th eory of two M2- branes was discovered. However, because theory [2, 3, 4, 5, 6] relies on a special form of 3-algebra, it is difficult to be ge neralized to arbitrary number of M2-branes [6, 7, 8, 9, 10]. Under certain conditions, th eA4algebra in the old BLG theory is unique and there is a no-go theorem [10]. One can get ar ound such a no- go theorem by relaxing the conditions [8, 11, 12]. Switching from Euclid ean 3-algebra to Lorentzian 3-algebra, three groups [13, 14, 15] showed a possible way for a month later, Aharony et al. [16] opened another possibilit y. Not restricted to 3-algebra, they turn to consider theories with aU(N)xU(N) or SU(N)xSU(N) gauge symmetry. In fact, the old BLG theory can be reformulate d into an SU(2)xSU(2) theory[7, 17, 18, 19, 20]. What is more, itwas shown longagotha t the plays an important role in the infrared limit of Ncoincident D3-branes at a conical singularity [21]. Therefore, an SU(N)xSU(N) Aharony-Bergman- (ABJM) theory, asa3-dimensional superconformal Ch theory, isavery attractive world-volume theoryof Ncoincident M2-branes. is difficult for generalization, although ABJM's N= 6 theories do not rely on 3-algebra, it is still appealing to recast them in terms of a certain 3-algebra, in hopes that it may told us how to better overcome the no-go theor em [10]. This was elegantly accomplished by Bagger and Lambert as reported in [22] r ecently, which we will call the new BL theory. In this little exercise, we reduce the N= 6U(N)xU(N) Chern-Simons gauge theories to U(N) Yang-Mills gauge theories. We find the resulting theories have N= 8 16 real supercharges. We will review ABJM theories in section II, and then in section III show the details of Higgs mechanism for the present case. Finally , in section IV, we will comment on how to apply our scheme to the new BL model generally an d conclude. II. REVIEW OF N= 6CHERN-SIMONS THEORIES In this section, following the neat work [23], we review ABJM's N= gauge theories [16]. We are interested in the special c ase with an SU(4) R- symmetry. In this case, the coefficients of the Chern-Simons actio n and the [23] are related by K= 1/L. Comparing with the old BLG theory, one 8p/kat level2k. We mainly take the notations and conventions of [23], but the 1For a recent review of membrane, please refer to [1]. Following the pio neer work [2]-[6], along this direction appears in the past half year. As a par tial list, see [7]-[52] and We are sorry for missing a lot of relevant work in our refere nce list. 2An example of Chern-Simons level quantization was shown in of U(N) algebra are different in =ifabcTc,(a,b,c= (1) in which we use the square bracket to denote commutators and the brace bracket to For convenience, we will raise and lower group in dices with a unit metric, so there is no distinction among upper and lower indices, their position being dictated by notational convenience. Nevertheless, as usual, repeated indice s imply summation. The gauge potential Auand~Auin [23] will be replaced by our notations, while the covariant derivative Duwill be replaced by ~Du, since we will use these notations for other purposes. After integrating out auxiliary fields and combining the SU(2) fields into an SU(4) (2) one can write down the total action of ABJM's N= 6,U(N)xU(N) Chern-Simons gauge theories as [22, the above action, the covariant derivative is defined (4) Note that the notation ~Duwith a tilde here is different from Duwhich will appear later. The Chern-Simons term is a potential like a Yukawa term, by which scalars and fermions are (6) The sextic potential of scalars takes the (7) 3III. REDUCTION TO YANG-MILLS THEORIES In this section, we reduce the U(N)xU(N) Chern-Siomons theories reviewed in the previous section into U(N) Yang-Mills theories. This process corresponds to recovering the world-volume theory of ND2-branes fromthat of NM2-branes. Our main scheme is exactly in accordance with [17]. Firstly recast the gauge fields (8) and then integrate out the auxiliary field Ba uusing its equation of motion. At the same time, take the vacuum expectation value to (9) and other components vanished. ~ vdenotes our choice of the vacuum expectation value (VEV). In the following, vdenotes the choice in [20]. We should stress here ~ vis real in spite of the fact that YA0is a complex variable. The Yang-Mills coupling is defined explained in [20]. As did in [17, 20], we have to rescale some of the comp onents ofY andpsas and keep only leading order terms with respect to ~ v-1. In other words, we have to take the limit k- , ~v- withgYMfixed. One of this limit is illustrated by Figure 1. 3In the early days of preparing this work, we found the choice (8) wa s also made by the reference [24], which partly overlapped with our plan. What is more, actually the scalin g limit taken in [24] is equivalent to the limit ~ v- in our scheme. Anyhow we decided to finish this little exercise to obtain more details. 4It was argued in [20] that gYM=v/
k. At first glance, it contradicts with the relation (10). However, this disagreement is understandable because the normalizations ar e different. By the replacement v- 4p~v/
2kN, one can change from their normalization to ours and recover (10) . In the last step of (10), we have used the quantization condition L= 8p/k. 4Figure 1: The left figure signifies the C4/Zk. In the rest of our paper, we will see that kg2 YMis a typical energy scale, below which our reduction is meaning ful. According to the definition Since in reference [20] v2is also related to physical mass scale, we see again that these two descriptions are equivalent. So tak ing the limit k- makes the cone become a fine cylinder. It is the usual picture that by compact ifying the x11, M-theory is reduced to the type IIA string theory. Many of the techniques employed here can be found in [17, 24]. In ref erence [24], a precise relation between ABJM model and Lorentzian BLG model was studied. Since the Lorentzian BLG model is intimately related to D2 branes, our will part ly overlap with the analysis there. In their analysis, they promoted the coupling co nstant to a vector and recovered the SO(8) invariance. Since our aim is to get the world- volume theory of D2-branes, we will take ~ vto be spacetime independent and get the of all, we decompose fields Au=Aa uTa. complex variables, ps0 Aandpsa Aare complex with two a real variable. Let us also (12) Making use (13) and conventions (1), one can rewrite the kinetic term of scalars in t he (14) 5while the kinetic term of fermions takes the (15) As for the Chern-Simons term, we (16) Although the gauge fields A(L,R) uare purely topological, after the recombination (8), one of the new fields Ba ubecomes an auxiliary field without derivatives, just as happened in [17 ]. We will eliminate this auxiliary field using its equation of motion, and obtain the kinetic term of the other gauge field Aa u. Namely,Aa uwill get dynamical if one integrates out Ba u. The potential term mixing scalars and fermions bosonic potential can be written (18) Choosing the vacuum expectation value given in (9), we can expand t he scalars and fermions near the VEV (19) In the limit ~ v- , the leading order terms in (3) can be obtained using the above results. In particular, the leading order kinetic terms in (14) and (1 5) (20) As we will show later, the cubic term in (16) is negligible in the limit ~ v- , so only the first term (21) The gauge potential Ba uappears only in derivatives. We can eliminate it using the equation of (22) When deriving this equation we have neglected the quadratic term in Buacoming from the cubic self-interaction as well as terms coming from higher interactio n with scalars. Because these terms will lead to higher order contributions which are suppre ssed in the limit ~ the above equation into the lagrangian, up to a total der ivative term, the kinetic and Chern-Simons terms turn out to (23) We find the kenetic terms of x8aexactly cancel out; hence they become non-dynamical. But a question may arise: where are the degrees of freedom newly turn ed on to compensate the disappeared x8a. The doubt can be resolved by observing that the gauge field Since in three dimensions, each massless vector field Aa uhas one dynamical degree of freedom as the scalar x8a, the total degrees of freedom are unchanged. From the Yang-Mills term, by requiring its coefficient to be -1/(4g2 YM), one can quickly read the Yang-Mills coupling constant as in (10). It is clear that BuaL/g2 YMright now. For a finitegYM, in the limit L-0, the first term in (16) is finite while the second term vanishes, as we have assumed. Since this limit is to keep the leading term in an expa nsion in powers of energy divided by ~ v2/k, this also tells us that the resulting U(N) gauge theory is valid only at a energy below On the other hand, since our derivation is to depict the weakly coupled limit of N D-branes, the theory is applicable only abo ve the energy scale g2 YMN. In the limit ~ v- ,L-0 while keeping L~vfinite, the potential terms for scalars and fermions reduce (25) In (17) and (24), we keep the notation Tr to remind the inner produ ct between two- component spinors. As one expected, the goldstones x8adisappear in (23-25) and hence in the total action. 8If we define the minimal spinor of SO(2,1)xSO(7) as, Ps (26) where each Psiis also a two-component Majorana spinor. Then the fermionic poten tial is actually the standard Yukawa (27) At this moment, it is easy to see that the fermionic potential term als o has last step is to rescale the scalars and spinor as ( Gath- ering the above results together, in the limit ~ v- with a fixed gYM, we (30) As one should have expected, at last we get a decoupled U(1) sector and a coupled SU(N) sector, which is nothing else but an N= 8 super Yang-Mills theory on the world-volume of Ncoincident D2-branes. The action (28) is valid in the energy range be and we have assumed Nkin the above procedure. IV. DISCUSSION OF NEW BL MODEL AND CONCLUSION In new BL models [22], in general the structure constant of 3-algeb ra does not have three totally anti-symmetric indices, so one cannot apply Mukhi and Papag eorgakis's method [17] in a naive way. This difficulty has been discussed in a newly appeared pap er [50], where Cherkis and Saemann also proposed a class of models similar to (but a lit tle different from) the new BL models. One viable extrapolation of Mukhi and Papageorgakis's method [17] is to decompose the 3-algebra into a couple of 2-algebras, say G1G2, just as did in it exactly recovers the ABJM theories, and the Higgs mechanism we discussed in the previous section exactly applies. More generally, if G1=G2is another Lie algebra instead of u(N), the mechanism is similar. Some key points are: 91. taking the VEV as (9), which has also been mentioned in [16]; 2. rearrange the gauge field as (8); 3. decompose four complex scalar (spinor) fields into eight real field s. The procedure shown in the previous section still works if only G1=G2, although that field theory would have less supersymmetries. It is easy to see that in ge neral the non-dynamical, at least they will disappear in the kinetic ter m. While the G1xG1 gauge symmetry is broken down to G1. The degrees of freedom of the goldstone bosons are transferred to the dynamical G1gauge fields. However, if the above scheme is helpless and things would be much trickier. As a conclusion, we can see that Mukhi and Papageorgakis's method , after a little ad- justment, is still powerful in deriving the world-volume action of ND2-branes from that of NM2-branes when Nis arbitrary. Note added : mphasis on the pure Yang-Mils terms. The interested readers are encoura ged to compare our results with that paper, especially the Yang-Mills coupling are grateful to Miao Li for many helpful comments. Also we would like to thank Wei He, Yushu Song and Gang Yang for discussions. This work was su pported by grants of CNSF and grants of USTC. [1] D. S. Berman, Phys. Rept. 456, 89 (2008) [arXiv:0710.1707 [hep-th]]. [2] J. Bagger and N. Lambert, Phys. Rev. D 75, 045020 (2007) J. Bagger and N. Lambert, Phys. Rev. D 77, 065008 (2008) [arXiv:0711.0955 [hep-th]]. [4] J. Bagger and N. Lambert, JHEP 0802, 105 (2008) [arXiv:0712.3738 [hep-th]]. [5] A. Gustavsson, arXiv:0709.1260 [hep-th]. [6] A. Gustavsson, JHEP 0804, 083 (2008) [arXiv:0802.3456 [hep-th]]. [7] M. A. Bandres, A. E. Lipstein and J. H. Schwarz, JHEP 0805, 025 (2008) P. M. Ho, R. C. Hou and Y. Matsuo, JHEP 0806, 020 (2008) [arXiv:0804.2110 [hep-th]]. [9] G. Papadopoulos, JHEP 0805, 054 (2008) [arXiv:0804.2662 [hep-th]]. [10] J. P. Gauntlett and J. B. Gutowski, arXiv:0804.3078 [he p-th]. [11] U. Gran, B. E. W. Nilsson and C. Petersson, arXiv:0804.1 784 [hep-th]. [12] H. Awata, M. Li, D. Minic and T. Yoneya, JHEP 0102, 013 (2001) J. Gomis, G. Milanesi and J. G. Russo, JHEP 0806, 075 (2008) [arXiv:0805.1012 [hep-th]]. [14] S. Benvenuti, D. Rodriguez-Gomez, E. Tonni and H. Verli nde, arXiv:0805.1087 [hep-th]. [15] P. M. Ho, Y. Imamura and Y. Matsuo, JHEP 0807, 003 (2008) [arXiv:0805.1202 [hep-th]]. [16] O. Aharony, O. Bergman, D. L. Jafferis and J. Maldacena, ar Xiv:0806.1218 [hep-th]. [17] S. Mukhi and C. Papageorgakis, JHEP 0805, 085 (2008) [arXiv:0803.3218 [hep-th]]. [18] M. Van Raamsdonk, JHEP 0805, 105 (2008) [arXiv:0803.3803 [hep-th]]. [19] D. S. Berman, L. C. Tadrowski and D. C. Thompson, arXiv:0 803.3611 [hep-th]. 10[20] J. Distler, S. Mukhi, C. Papageorgakis and M. Van Raamsd onk, JHEP 0805, 038 [hep-th]]. [21] I. R. Klebanov and E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B 536, 199 (1998) J. Bagger and N. Lambert, arXiv:0807.0163 [hep-th]. [23] M. Benna, I. Klebanov, T. Klose and M. Smedback, arXiv:0 806.1519 [hep-th]. [24] Y. Honma, S. Iso, Y. Sumitomo and S. Zhang, arXiv:0806.3 498 [hep-th]. [26] J. Gomis, A. J. Salim and F. Passerini, arXiv:0804.2186 [hep-th]. [26] J. Gomis, A. J. Salim and F. Passerini, arXiv:0804.2186 [hep-th]. [27] E. A. Bergshoeff, M. de Roo and O. Hohm, Class. Quant. Grav. 25, 142001 [hep-th]]. [28] Y. Honma, S. Iso, Y. Sumitomo and S. Zhang, arXiv:0805.1 895 [hep-th]. [29] H. Fuji, S. Terashima and M. Yamazaki, arXiv:0805.1997 [hep-th]. [30] Y. Song, arXiv:0805.3193 [hep-th]. [31] M. Li and T. Wang, arXiv:0805.3427 [hep-th]. [32] K. Hosomichi, K. M. Lee, S. Lee, S. Lee and J. Park, arXiv: 0805.3662 [hep-th]. [33] S. Banerjee and A. Sen, arXiv:0805.3930 [hep-th]. [34] H. Lin, arXiv:0805.4003 [hep-th]. [35] J. P. de Medeiros and E. Mendez-Es cobar, arXiv:0805.4363 [hep-th]. [36] M. A. Bandres, A. E. Lipstein and J. H. Schwarz, arXiv:08 06.0054 [hep-th]. [37] F. Passerini, arXiv:0806.0363 [hep-th]. [38] C. Ahn, arXiv:0806.1420 [hep-th]. [39] S. Cecotti and A. Sen, arXiv:0806.1990 [hep-th]. [40] E. A. Bergshoeff, M. de Roo, O. Hohm and D. Roest, arXiv:080 6.2584 [hep-th]. [41] P. de Medeiros, J. and E. Mendez-Es cobar, arXiv:0806.3242 [hep-th]. [42] T. Nishioka and T. Takayanagi, arXiv:0806.3391 [hep-t h]. [43] C. Ahn, arXiv:0806.4807 [hep-th]. [44] J. Bedford and D. Berman, arXiv:0806.4900 [hep-th]. [45] G. Grignani, T. Harmark and M. Orselli, arXiv:0806.495 9 [hep-th]. [46] K. Hosomichi, K. M. Lee, S. Lee, S. Lee and J. Park, arXiv: 0806.4977 [hep-th]. [47] S. Terashima, arXiv:0807.0197 [hep-th]. [48] B. Chen and J. B. Wu, arXiv:0807.0802 [hep-th]. [49] C. S. Chu, P. M. Ho, Y. Matsuo and S. Shiba, arXiv:0807.08 12 [hep-th]. [50] S. Cherkis and C. Saemann, arXiv:0807.0808 [hep-th]. [51] T. Li, Y. Liu and D. Xie, arXiv:0807.1183 [hep-th]. [52] Chethan Krishnan, Carlo Maccaferri , arXiv:0805.3125 [hep-th]. 11
|
0807.1444
|
Pang Yi
|
Yi Pang, Tower Wang
|
From N M2's to N D2's
|
11 pages, 1 printable figure, close to the version published in
PhysRevD
|
Phys.Rev.D78:125007,2008
|
10.1103/PhysRevD.78.125007
|
USTC-ICTS-08-12
|
hep-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this short note, we reduce the N=6, U(N)xU(N) Chern-Simons gauge theories
to N=8, U(N) Yang-Mills gauge theories. This process corresponds to recovering
the world-volume theory of N D2-branes from that of N M2-branes in an
intermediate energy range. The supersymmetries are enhanced because in this
limit the branes localize far away from the orbifold singularity. Our main
scheme is exactly in accordance with Mukhi and Papageorgakis's earlier work,
although the Higgs mechanism becomes trickier in the present case. We also
speculate on applying the scheme to a large class of new Bagger-Lambert models
more generally.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 9 Jul 2008 13:18:08 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 30 Jul 2008 06:37:09 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Sun, 31 Aug 2008 07:28:39 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Wed, 6 May 2009 15:14:12 GMT"
}
] | 2009-05-06T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Pang",
"Yi",
""
],
[
"Wang",
"Tower",
""
]
] |
2 of write the Hamiltonian of the interacting many-particle Bose system the normal-state single-particle energy, uthe chemical potential, Vkk'the pairing interaction matrix element, and a+
kandakare Bose operators for a single- particle state of wave-vector kin the normal state and satisfy the commutation rule [ ak,a+
k'] manner as in the BCS negationslash= 0 (2) in the superfluid state for a pair of ( k) and (-k) par- ticles (where the angle brackets a treat ( a-kak- as a small quantity so that terms bilinear in ( a-kak- can be ne- glected; define an energy gap (3) (because ofthe the presenttheory and the BCS theory of we will similarly refer to the quantity kas an energy gap parameter in this paper, although, as we will see below, it does not directly relate to an energy gap in the present theory); and apply a canonical new Bose operators for a single- particle excitation of wave-vector kin the and coefficients ukandvkare so determined as to diagonalize the Hamiltonian while maintaining the com- mutation rule [ ak,a+
k'] =dk,k'. The diagonalized Hamiltonian (6) xk=ok-u to chemical potential (8)the single-particle excitation energy in the Bose function (the number of single-particle excita- tions of wave-vector k). Coefficients (12) After the diagonalization of Hamiltonian ^H, Eq. (3) can be expressed (13) This is a self-consistency equation that must be satisfied by kas a function of wave-vector kand Critical temperature Tc Similar to that in the BCS theory of energy gap parameter kis an important quantity in the present theory. It is because of the existence of k that makes the superfluid state different from the nor- mal state. In this and the next subsections we of k. First, in the limit of T-Tc(because of the similar- ity between the present theory and the BCS theory of we are similarly using Tc, instead of Tl, to denote the critical temperature of the we have |k| -0 so that Eq. (13) can be linearized and we have an eigenvalue the value of chemical potential uat crit- ical temperature Tc, and we have used 1 + 2 temperature Tcand phase thk(as defined via k=|k|eithk) are determined by solving Eq. (14) for given interaction Vk,k', single-particle energy spectrum okand chemical potential u0.3 Note that it is not necessary to assume Vk,k'<0 in order for Eq. (14) to have a Tc>0 solution. There- fore, the viewthat particle pairing is incorrect. Here we also emphasize that the pairing of particles of opposite momenta, as ex- pressed by Eq. (2), is a kind of ordering in momentum space (this point agrees with London's view that state is an ordered state in mo- mentum space2,3); it does not mean that bound pairs of particles (due to an attractive interaction) are respect to determination of |k|, we note that the self-consistency equation, Eq. (13), can be 0 (15) by first operating /Ton Eq. (13), and then, multi- plying the resulting equation by k(1 + over k. Interaction (15), Tc, and the latter is involved through the condition |k(Tc)|= 0. From Eq. (15) we can see that the alone does not allow unique determination of
|k|, because, as one can see, Eq. (15) can have an infinite number of solutions. This property of equation is true for arbitrary because Eq. (15) is derived for arbitrary Vkk'. Actually, this property can also been seen di- rectly from Eq. (13) by noticing that the equation is linear with respect to eithk. [Even in the case of Vkk'=
-V, which leads to + cannot be uniquely determined, because phase thk'of k'in the summation over k'is measured rel- ative to phase thkof kon the left-hand side of the equation (it is relative phases that matter). This is more clearly seen if we re-write the equation as where cos( thk'-thk) = 1 or-1 depending on thk'-thk= 0 orp. We have |k|= =
k-independent only when but other solutions for |k|, are also possible. Similarly, for a separable interaction of the form Vkk'=-Vokok', the solution |k|= |ok|
corresponds to a solution with eithk= an and is only one of an infinite number of possible solutions.] On the other hand, we note that diagonalized i.e., both UkandEkin Eq. (5) are functions of temperature T, because of their de- pendence upon |k(T)|. Since diagonalized a set of independent excitations, and there is no transition between different single-particle states inthermodynamic equilibrium, we expect the thermal en- ergy and entropy associated with a single-particle state of wave-vector kto be ek=Uk+nkEk because of the T- dependence of ^H, when we calculate, for a single- particle state of wave-vector k, the partition function Zk= Tr(e-^Hk/kBT) (where entropy energy ek=Fk+TSk, we find that there are additional terms involving Uk/TandEk/Tin each of the expressions for ekandSk, as compared to Eqs. (16) and (17). By letting the sum of the additional terms in each of the expressions for ekandSkto be zero, we arrive at Uk T+nkEk T= 0. (18) This equation represents an additional of the theory, and must be consistent with Eq. (13). To see that this is indeed true, we substitute Eq. (6) into Eq. (18) to 0. (19) A solution of this equation is certainly also a solution of Eq. (15), and therefore also a solution of Eq. (13), and thus, we see that Eq. (18) is indeed consistent with (19) shows that there are two possible solu- tions for |k|for each single-particle state of wave-vector k: one is a trivial solution, |k|= 0 (corresponding to the normal state), and the other is a non-trivial solution (|k|>0, corresponding to the superfluid state) 0, (20) which is readily solved to for T<=Tc.(21) A consequence of Eq. (20), or (21), is that chemi- cal potential uin the superfluid state is is shown in Appendix A (where we discuss uand distribution the superfluid state). Then, by using 1 + 2 and the condition that |k|= 0 at T=Tc, we can express Eq. (21) c= 0.98(-u0/kBTc= 0.5) FIG. 1: Energy dependence of energy gap parameter 0.5 and different values of T/Tcas indicated on the (24) andu0being the value of uatT=Tc. It is shown in Appendix B (where we discuss the ground state energy of the superfluid state) that u0must be below a certain negative value in order for the super- fluid state to be energetically favorable as compared to the normal state. Equation (22) is an implicit solution for |k|(orEk) as afunction of okandTfor given Tcandu0. for kis therefore a combination of the solution of Eq. (22) for |k|/kBTcand the solutions of Eq. present analysis with respect to the determination of kis similar to that of Ref. 19 with respect to of the energy gap parameter in the BCS theory of solve Eq. (22) numerically by using an obtain |k|/kBTcas a function of given u0/kBTc. Figure 1 shows ok-dependence of and different values of Tas indicated on the curves. Figure 2 shows T-dependence of and different values of okas indicated on the curves. Figure 3 shows 0.5 and different values of Tas indicated on the curves. For comparison, normal-state single-particle excitation the Bose-Einstein conden- sation shown as the dotted curves in the figure. From Fig. 3 we can see the existence of an energy gapin Namely, minimum value EminofEk, which cok/kBTc= 0125 (-u0/kBTc= 0.5) FIG. 2: Temperature dependence of normalized energy gap parameter amplitude 0.5 and different values of ok/kBTcas indicated on the 0.5)# #
FIG. 3: Superfluid-state single-particle excitation energ yEk versus normal-state single-particle energy and different values of T/Tcas indicated on the curves (solid curves). The two dotted curves respectively single-particle excitation energy the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature as indicated on the curves. located at ok= 0, is greater than zero. According to Eq. (22), Emin= atT= 0, and increases monotonically to as shown in Appendix B, u0must be below a cer- tain negative value in the superfluid state, we see that Emin>0 in the superfluid state. Figure 4 shows T-dependence of Eminfor different indicated on the 4: Temperature dependence of minimum single-particle excitation energy 0.5 and 0.8, as indicated on the curves. C. Specific heat C(T) Having obtained |k(T)|, we can calculated thermo- dynamic quantities of the superfluid state. We consider the ground state energy of the superfluid in Appendix B. We calculate in this subsection the specific heat of the superfluid state, specific heat Cis given we have used Eq. (22), and have adopted a set of dimensionless units for the last expression, in which energies are measured in units of kBTcand temperature in units of Tc. In the normal state ( T/Tc>=1), the specific heat is given we have used the above-mentioned for the last 5 shows C/Nk BversusT/Tcfor different indicated on the curves, where Nis the total number of particles of the system, and is given B T/T c-u0/kBTc= 5: Temperature dependence of specific heat Cfor -u0/kBTc= 0.3, 0.5 and 0.8, as indicated on the curves. For clarity, the T/Tc>1 part of the -u0/kBTc= 0.5 curve is not shown. The horizontal dotted line shows the value of C/Nk B= 3/2 is the Bose function at T=Tc, and we have used the above-mentioned dimensionless units for the last C/Nk B, wehaveassumed ok= particle mass), and have made the The integrals involved are calculated by using the Simpson method.20The method for calculating uandu/Tfor the specific heat in the normal state is explained in Appendix A. As shown in Fig. 5, there exists a finite jump in the specific heat at the transition temperature, indicating a second-order phase transition. The magnitude of the jump is larger for a larger value of -u0/kBTc. In the limit ofT-0, we have C/T-0, because of the ex- istence of an energy gap in the single-particle the C-versus-Tcurve shows a l- shaped peak at the SUPERFLUIDITY We next consider the case where the superfluid is in a state of uniform flow with velocity vs. We write the Hamiltonian of the system is the same as the Hamiltonian of Eq. (1) for the case of vs= 0, except that wave-vector kin with the superfluid. We assume that particles ofop- posite momenta measured in the coordinate frame mov-6 ing with the superfluid. I.e., we negationslash= 0 k) that, since wave-vector kis measuredin the coor- dinate frame moving with the superfluid, if we use a free Bose gas as an example, a single-particle state of in the laboratoryframe, a of wave energy ok= -h2(k+q)2/2m, (32) Therefore, a pair of ( k) and (-k) particles have zero net momentum in the frame moving with the superfluid, but have a net momentum of 2- hq= 2mvsin the of Hamiltonian ^His the same as in the case of vs= 0, except that we now have 0. The results of the diagonalization are as follows. The diagonalized Hamiltonian (34) xk=ok-u; (37) is the symmetric part of Ek; Bose (41) The self-consistency equation for the energy gap pa- rameter 0, we have but we have -k= k, potential u, relative to which energies measured, is q-dependent, because each pair of particles in the superfluid state has a net h2q2/2m)duetothe we (43) whereu0is the superfluid-state chemical potential for q= 0, and the second term is the per-particle energy increase due to the flow of paired particles [see Appendix A for a detailed derivation of Eq. (43)]. For simplicity in presenting the theory, we will use the energyspectrum of a free Bose gas as given by Eq. (31) in the following. With the help of Eqs. (31) and (43), we (46) ando(0) kis the value of okforq= following equation is derived as an additional requirement of the independent of (21)tothecaseof vsnegationslash= 0. We present the details of the derivation of this equation in Appendix C.7 With the help of Eqs. (44) and (45) and by using 1+2nk= coth(Ek/2kBT) and the condition that |k|=
0 at (T,q) = (Tc,0), we can express Eq. (47) (49) zk= cosakwithakbeing the angle between kandq, and we have used a set of dimensionless units in which energies such as measured in units ofkBTc, temperature is measured in units of Tc, andq in units of q0, which is defined via - and the corresponding is vs0= (48) is an implicit solution for The variables ( k,T,q) for the in Eq. (48) in the forms where qzkis the component of qalongk. We solve Eq. (48) by using an iterative a function of given u0. Note that temperature Tck, defined as such that Eq. (48) has no |k|>0 solution for given is a function of o(0) kandqzk. Only for q= 0 is Tck=Tcthe same for all single-particle superfluid wave-vector qck, defined as such that Eq. (48) has no |k|>0 solution for given is a function of a function of 6(a) shows different values of qzk, and Fig. 6(b) shows different values of T;-u0/kBTc= 0.5 is assumed in both Fig. 6(a) and Fig. 6(b). Note that there is an upper bound for Tck, i.e.,Tck<=
Tc, but there is no upper bound for qck, i.e.,qck- foro(0) k- , zk= 0 for this case). The minimum values of are of particular importance. For T <
Tck,min(qzk) [orq < qck,min(T)], the system is in an all- paired state, in which |k|>0 for all particles. T < T c[orqck,min(T)< q], the system is in a partly-paired state, in which particles in states T[orqck(T)< q] become de-paired (hav- ing|k|= 0) while those in states having Tck(qzk)> T [orqck(T)> q] remain paired (having |k|>0). FIG. 6: (a) different values of on the curves; (b) different values of T/Tcas indicated on the curves; -u0/kBTc= 0.5 in both (a) and (b). T > T c, the system is in the normal state, in which
|k|= 0 for all particles. A finite viscosity should be observable in a partly- paired state, because of the existence of de-paired parti- cles, which are expected to behave as normal-state parti- cles. We therefore expect critical velocity vsc(T), defined as the superfluid velocity at the onset of an to be about the same as - hqck,min(T)/m. From the numerical results shown in Fig. 6(b), for example, which are obtained for the case of -u0/kBTc= 0.5, we cansee that qck,min(T) is afew tenth of q0, corresponding to a superfluid velocity of a few tenth of vs0= for4He, we see that the for4He in this case is about a few tens of cen- timeters per second (which is than the value by results for different val- ues ofTandqzkare shown in Fig. 7 [Figs. 7(a) and 7(b)]. Figure 7(a) shows an example of the case c= 0.5 ;qzk q0= c= 0.5 ;qzk q0= 7: different values of Tas indicated on the curves; qzk/q0= 0.2 and 0.4 in (a) and (b), 0.5 in both (a) and (b). 0< q < q ck,min(0). In this case, the for T= 0 is the same as in the case of q= 0 (which is shown in Fig. 1). As Tincreases, more strongly suppressed, and As Tincreases further so that T > T ck,min, has a |k|= 0 part for low ener- gies (except for o(0) k-0), for which Tck(qzk)< T[or qck(T)< q]. Figure 7(b) shows an example of the case ofq > qck,min(0). In this case, the a|k|= 0 part even at T= 0. Namely, at T= 0,
|k|= 0 for those single-particle states with qck(0)< q. The the both Fig. 7(a) and Fig. 7(b) indicate 8 and 9 show, respectively, the numerical re- sults for the T-dependence and qzk-dependence of |k|. As shown in the figures, |k|is a monotonic of Tandqzk, except that, at T= 0,|k|>0 is a constant for q < qck(0) (Fig. 9). The vertical drops in some of the curves shown in Figs. 8 and 9 co(0) k kBTc=0.4 /parenleftBig qzk q0= co(0) k kBTc=1 /parenleftBig qzk q0= 8: different val- ues ofo(0) k/kBTcas indicated on the curves; qzk/q0= 0.2 and 0.4 in (a) and (b), respectively; -u0/kBTc= 0.5 in both (a) and Superfluid particle density ns Particle current density jis the expectation value of particle current density operator (51) the particle field operator
^Ps 0.5,o(0) k kBTc= 0.5,o(0) k kBTc= 9: different values of T/Tcas indicated on the curves; o(0) k/kBTc= 0.5 and 2.0 in (a) and (b), respectively; -u0/kBTc= 0.5 in both (a) and (b). withphk(x) being the single-particle wave-function [given by Eq. (30)], and the velocity (53) A straightforward calculation the particle density and can be expressed as (see Appendix is the value of nkat (T,q) = (Tc,0). The first term on the right-handside ofEq. (54) contribution from single-particle excitations and de-paired particles, and tends to cancel the first term. When all particles are in the superfluid ground state (at T= 0 and for qbelow a threshold), the second term is zero. On the other hand, when |k|= 0 for all single- particle states, the two terms cancel each other so that j= 0. Since superfluid current density j= 0 without pairing, as shown above, according to standard quantum theory of many-particle systems, it is clear that from pairing of particles, not from (there is no microscopic theoretical viewthat superfluidity). Therefore, we believe that the super- fluid properties of liquid4He,3,13as well as the superfluid properties of ultra-cold atomic gases (such as the persistent flow of atoms in a toroidal trap22 and the vortices in rotating atomic gases23,24), are as- sociated with pairing of the atoms involved, not Bose- Einstein condensation. By using o(0) k= -h2k2/2mand making the we can rewrite Eq. (54) (57) wherensis the effective superfluid particle density, and, by using the above-introduced dimensionless units (in which energies are measured in units of kBTc, temper- atureTin units of Tcand superfluid wave-vector qin units ofq0), can be expressed as ns n= a function of u0and relates to n(i.e.,n~n), the limit of q-0, Eq. (58) becomes ns n= as a function of o(0) kandTfor given u0, is determined by Eq. (48) for q= c-u0/kBTc= 0.30.50.8 1-T/T c (q= 0)
FIG. 10: Temperature dependence of superfluid particle den- sitynsfor the case of q-0 for-u0/kBTc= 0.3, 0.5 and 0.8, as indicated on the curves. (The dotted curve shows a results for ns/nfor the case of q-0 as a function of Tare shown in Fig. 10 for different values of u0. Note that dns/dT-0 in the limit of T-0, because of the existence of an energy gap in the superfluid single- particle excitation finite q In Appendix A, chemical potential uin the superfluid state is determined based on the assumption that all par- ticles are paired in the superfluid state. For the case of finiteq, de-paired particles may exist. The result for exist. The question how to determine the chem- ical potential in a partly-paired state is not addressed in this paper. To proceed, we make the following ap- proximation with respect to n+-kin calculating nswhen de-paired particles exist. For paired particles (for which
|k|>0), weusethe sameresultfor n+-kasin the caseof an all-paired state; and for de-paired particles (for which
|k|= 0), we use the following dimensionless units) with o+-k= results for ns/nobtained based on approximation are shown in Fig. difference values of 11: (a) different values of q/q0 as indicated on the curves; (b) different values of T/Tc;-u0/kBTc= 0.5 in both (a) and (b). in Fig. 11(b) as difference val- ues ofT/Tc. In both Fig. 11(a) and Fig. 11(b), -u0/kBTc= 0.5 is assumed. C. Free energy density F From diagonalized Hamiltonian ^H[Eq. (33)], we de- rive the following expression for the free energy density in the superfluid (65) where the first term comes which is the usual statis- tical free energy the second term11 comes from n(u-u0), which is the energy increase due to the flow of the superfluid, and which is added to Fbecause single-particle energies in the expression for Hamiltonian ^Hare measured relative to u. For an isotropic system (such as liquid4He),Fis a function of Tandq=|q|, i.e.,F=F(T,q). As can be shown, superfluid current density jand effective super- fluid particle density nsare related to Fvia the [where Fis as given by Eq. (65)]. When
|k|= 0 for all single-particle states, as in the q-independent, and we have j= 0 and ns= 0. D. Spatially varying v s(x) The theory presentedso far is basedon the assumption that superfluid velocity vsis spatially constant. We velocity vs is spatially varying, by making an assumption that there exists a length lsuch that the following is true: Length lis large compared to inter-particle distance so that the properties of particles in volume l3are essentially those ofan infinite system, but small by that the volume can be regarded as a point ofthe system vary negligibly over the distance quantitiessuchas |k|,ns,j andFcan all be considered as local quantities, obtained with respect to particles in a volume l3around a andF=F(T,q(x)), where q(x) =mvs(x)/-his assumed to vary spatially with a length much larger than l. The theory presented so far for the case of vsnegationslash= 0 is similar to the theory presented in Ref. 25 for in the presence of a magnetic field. E. Hess-Fairbank effect Sincens>0 in the superfluid state, we see from Eq. (67) that we have F q>0, (68) which shows that a larger value of qis energetically less favorable in the superfluid state. This implies that a su- perfluid tends to expel superfluid wave-vector q(x), or,equivalently, superfluid velocity vs(x) = -hq(x)/m, from its interior so as to minimize the overall free energy of the system. This result qualitatively explains the Hess- Fairbank effect,13the reduction of moment of inertia of a rotating cylinder of liquid4He when it is cooled through the superfluid transition. Namely, when the liquid is in the superfluid state, because a motionless state is ener- getically more favorable, it stops rotating with the con- tainer, except in the immediate vicinity of the wall of the container where the liquid rotates with the container due to interaction between the liquid and the wall at the theory presented so far provides a qual- itative explanation for the Hess-Fairbank effect, it does not allow quantitative description of the Namely, the theory says that a superfluid tends to expel superfluid velocity vs(x), but it does not tell us howvs(x) can be determined for given boundary con- dition and temperature (in the case of a rotating cylin- der of liquid4He, for example, the boundary condition is determined by the angular speed and geometry of note that the Hess-Fairbank effect is analogous to the Meissner effect in superconductors, and the latter describable by combination of the the Ampere's law j= respectively, the elec- trical current density, superconducting electron density, vector potential and magnetic flux density, and a set of dimensionless units is used for the present discussion). Our Eq. (57) is analogous to the London equation, with vsplaying the role of a. What is missing for a superfluid is an equation analogous to the Ampere's law. We therefore speculate the existence of the (69) where o=xvs (70) is superfluid vorticity, and L a positive constant. Note that Eq. (69) applies only to particles (or atoms) in the superfluid state; i.e., here jandoare associated with the ofafluid, and to jsandosin a two-fluid (69) is clearly only a speculation based on the similarity between superfluidity and and thus, must derive its validity from of the consequences that it the common view that superfluid is irrota- tional (vorticity-free) (for which there is no justification), Eq. (69) shows that, analogous to that electrical current creates magnetic field, super- fluid current creates vorticity. As we will see below, an important consequence of Eq. (69) is the existence of a penetration depth that char- acterizes the typical distance to which superfluid veloc- ity and superfluid vorticity penetrate into a penetration depth is analogous to the London pen- etration depth2that characterizes the typical distance to which magnetic vector potential and magnetic field pen- etrate into a further speculate the existence of an additional term in the expression for free energy density F, (71) where the first two terms are the same as in Eq. (65), and the third term, which is analogous to the magnetic filed energy density in the case of superconductors, is the additional term whose existence is speculated. The rea- son for this speculation is as follows. We note that Eq. (57) is an equilibrium property of a superfluid, and thus, must also be derivable as a result of the variational prob- lem that, in the thermodynamic equilibrium, the overall free energy of the superfluid, given by the volume inte- gral of free energy density F, is stationary with respect to arbitrary variation of vs(x). This is true when Fis as given by Eq. (71), as can be shown with the help of of Eqs. (57) and (69) allows of the Hess-Fairbank effect. In the following we present two simple examples. 1. Superfluid in a rotating cylinder We consider a superfluid in a rotating cylinder. As- suming the length of the cylinder is much larger than its radiusR, and neglecting the bottom portion of the cylin- der, in terms of cylindrical coordinates ( r,ph,z) and unit vectors (^r,^ph,^z), we can write superfluid current superfluid velocity vs=vs(r)^phand o=o(r)^z, and we have Lo'(r) =ns(r)vs(r) (72) and v' s(r) =o(r)-vs(r) r, (73) where a prime indicates a derivative with respect to r, ns(r) =ns(vs(r)) is given by Eq. (58), the first equa- tion comes from combining Eqs. (57) and (69), and the second equation comes from Eq. (70). These behaviorofthe of the fluid. We will not consider in this paper the behavior of the normal-fluid component of the fluid. This is a second-order boundary value problem with the boundary conditions vs(0) = 0 (74)and vs(R) =Rohm0, (75) whereRis the inner radius of the cylindrical container and ohm 0the angular speed of the container. Here we have assumed that, in equilibrium, vs(R) is the same as the linear speed of the inner wall of the container, as oth- erwise there would be momentum transfer between the superfluid and the container. In this paper, we will not attempt to solve this bound- ary value problem for arbitrary Tandvs(R). Instead, for simplicity in presenting the main features of the the- ory, we will consider only the case where nsis spa- tially constant. As we can see from Fig. 11(b), that nsis spatially constant is true only at T= 0 independent of vsatT= 0 and is approximately true at for sufficiently low values of vs. For a spatially constant ns, the value problem can be solved analytically, and the solutions are: vs(r) (77) whereIn(x) is the modified Bessel function of the first kind of order (78) ForR/l1, by using the asymptotic wherex1, we have, near the inner wall of the (80) from which we see that superfluid velocity and super- fluid vorticity penetrate only a distance of the order of linto the superfluid; at a depth of little more than l, su- perfluid velocity and superfluid vorticity are and thus, lhas the meaning ofpenetration depth that characterizes the distance to which superfluid veloc- ity and superfluid vorticity penetrate into a to the London penetration depth2that char- acterizes the distance to which magnetic field penetrates into a by using the +O(x2) andI1(x)~x/2 +O(x3), where x1, (82) which are the same as the results for a rotating rigid body. 2. Flow of superfluid in a pipe We next consider the case where a superfluid Let the axis of the pipe be the z-axis, the inner radius of the pipe be R, and the total superfluid current beI. In terms of r,ph,z) and unit vectors (^r,^ph,^z), we can write superfluid current superfluid velocity vs=vs(r)^zand o=o(r)^ph, and we have o'(r) (83) and v' s(r) =-o(r), (84) where a prime indicates a derivative with respect to r, ns(r) =ns(vs(r)) is given by Eq. (58), the first (57)and(69), comes from Eq. (70). This is a second-order boundary value problem with the boundary conditions o(0) = 0 (85) and o(R) =-I 2pRL, (86) where the last condition comes from to that for the case of a superfluid in a ro- tating cylinder, discussed above, we consider only the case where nsis spatially constant. As mentioned above, thatnsis spatially constant is true only at T= 0 and is approximately true at for sufficiently low values of vs. In this case, the above-described boundary value problem can be solved analytically, and the solutions are: vs(r) (88) whereIn(x) is the modified Bessel function of the first kind of order n,26andlis as defined by Eq. (78).ForR/l1, by using the asymptotic wherex1, we have, near the inner wall of the (90) from which we see that superfluid flows mainly in the region near the wall of the pipe; at a distance of little more than laway from the wall, both superfluid velocity and superfluid vorticity are practically zero; and lhas the meaning of penetration depth that distance to which superfluid velocity and penetrate into a by using the +O(x2) andI1(x)~x/2 +O(x3), where x1, -I 2pR2Lr, in thiscase, the and superfluid vorticity is nearly linear in r. IV. SUMMARY We have presented a microscopic theory for superflu- idity in an interacting many-particle Bose system (such as liquid4He). The theory shows that, similar to in superconductors, superfluidity in a Bose system arises from pairing of particles of opposite mo- menta. In Sec. II, we presented the theory for the case where superfluid velocity vs= 0. The theory shows the exis- tence of an energy gap in single-particle excitation spec- trum, and the existence of a specific heat jump at Sec. III, we presented the theory for the case where superfluid velocity vsnegationslash= 0. We derived an equation that gives a relation between superfluid current density jand superfluid velocity vs(this equation is analogous to gives a relation between current density of and magnetic vector potential), and an expres- sion for superfluid particle density nsas a function of temperature Tand superfluid velocity vs. We showed that superfluid-state free energy density Fis an increas- ing function of vs(i.e.,F/v s>0), which indicates that a superfluid tends to expel superfluid velocity (i.e., a superfluid has a tendency to remain motionless); this14 result provides a qualitative explanation for the Hess- Fairbank effect (which is analogous to the Meissner ef- fect in We further speculated, based on the similarity between and super- fluidity, the existence of an equation [i.e., Eq. (69)] that specifies a relation between superfluid current density j and superfluid vorticity o(this equation is analogous to the Ampere's law). With the help of this equation, effect can be quantitatively A: CHEMICAL POTENTIAL DISTRIBUTION vs= 0 We consider in this Appendix chemical potential uin the superfluid state. We first consider the case where superfluid velocity vs= 0 in this potential uas a function of temperature T is so determined such that the number of particles of a Bose system is of particles Nis given (A1) which, in the normal state, (A2) This equation determines chemical potential uas a func- tion ofTfor given Nin the normal state. Here, we have assumed volume V= 1 (in arbitrary unit) so that Ncan also be considered as the particle density of the system. In the superfluid state, Eq. (A1) can be expressed using the results of the canonical transformation of Eq. (4) and according to Eq. (21), we see that particle conservation condition N/T= 0 implies that u/T= 0 in the superfluid state, which can also be expressed as u=u0forT<=Tc, (A4) whereu0is the value of the chemical potential at T=
Tc. Namely, chemical potential uisT-independent in the superfluid state. Equation (A3) can then be expressed 12: Temperature dependence of chemical potential u, calculated for -u0/kBTc= 0.5, assuming ok= a constant. The dotted curve shows normal state chemical potential u(n)forT < T c;u(n)= where T(BEC) cis the critical temperature of Bose-Einstein condensation; and T(BEC) c/Tc0.49 for -u0/kBTc= 12 shows the temperature dependence of chem- ical potential u, calculated for -u0/kBTc= 0.5. In cal- culating u, we have used the Runge-Kutta from Eq. (A2) and the condition N/T= 0, we drive an expression for u/T, which, together with a given value of u=u0atT/Tc= 1, allows us to nu- merically compute u(andu/T, which is required in calculating the normal-state specific heat in Sec. IIC) for arbitrary Tby using the Runge-Kutta method.20We have also assumed ok= -h2k2/2mand made the calculating u(T). The in the expression for u/Tare calculated by using the Simpson method.20 As shown in Fig. 12, for T > T c,uis a decreas- ing function of T. ForT<=Tc,u=u0is a con- stant. The dotted curve in Fig. 12 shows normal state chemical potential u(n)forT < T c;u(n)= 0 for T<=
T(BEC) c, for -u0/kBTc= 0.5. As shown in Appendix B, u0must be below a certain negative number in a superfluid state, which means Tc> TBEC c, as one can see from Fig. chemical potential u0is an impor- tant parameter in the present theory with respect to the properties of the superfluid state. For example, minimum single-particle excitation energy (or energy gap) Emindirectly relates to u0via the rela- tionEmin= according to Eq.15 (22). Generally, u0relates to the particle density of the Bose system, and, as one can see from Eq. (A5), a corresponds to a lower particle vs= 0 Thedistribution, in the normal state. This is no longer the case in the superfluid state. The fact that uisT-independent in the superfluid state im- plies that in the Namely, from Eqs. (21) and (A4) we can 0 forT<=Tc, (A7) which can also be expressed forT<=Tc. (A8) In other words, the distribution, becomes frozen at T=Tcwhen the Bose sys- tem is cooled through the superfluid transition. Note the difference between the particles described by operators a+
kandakand the particles described opera- torsa+
kandak:T-independent (in the T-dependent(forexample, -0 asT-0 -nk(Tc) asT-Tc). AtT=Tc, we shows that all particles in a single-particle state of wave-vector kexist as single-particle excitations. For 0< T < T c, we (A10) which shows that particles in a single-particle state of wave-vector kpartly exist as single-particle excitations and partly are in the superfluid condensate, but the sum of the particles remains the same as nk(Tc). AtT= 0, we (A11) which shows that all particles in a single-particle state of wave-vector kare in the superfluid 0 We consider in this subsection chemical potential uin the superfluid state for the case where superfluid 0.In this case, we given by Eqs. (35) and (37), any one of T,q1,q2andq3, whereqi (i= 1,2,3) are components of q=mvs/-h. Since in Nthequantity(1+ (47), and( xk+x-k)/2 using Eq. (31), the particle con- servation condition N/X= 0 leads 0, (A13) which is readily solved to (A14) whereu0is the value of uat (T,q) = (Tc,0), and which is the same as Eq. (43). Equation (A12) can then be expressed (A16) and the superscript (0) indicates q= 0. [Equation (A15) is the same as Eq. (A5), as it 0 When superfluid velocity vsnegationslash= 0, as can be shown, distribution the superfluid state (A17) forT < T ck(qzk) (i.e., for |k|>0), where n(0) k(Tc) is given by Eq. (A16), nkis given by Eq. (38), and qzk is the component of q=mvs/-halong wave-vector k(as discussed in Sec. IIIA). We 2n(0) k(Tc) have 0, where all par- ticles are paired [for q < qc,min(0)], and where nk= (A20) forT= 0. We have >0, The difference between andangbacketlefta+
-ka-kangbacketight contributes to the reduction in the effective density nsas one can see from the expression for ns, Eq. (58). APPENDIX B: GROUND STATE ENERGY U(0) 1.U(0)for vs= 0 The ground state energy of the superfluid state in the case where superfluid velocity vs= 0 is U(0) we have used Ek(0) according to Eq. (22). It is interesting to note that the right-hand-side of Eq. (B1) can be interpreted as the thermal energy of a Bose system of paired particles at T=Tchaving a pair exci- tation spectrum of 2 xk. Since the single-particle energy in the expression for Hamiltonian ^His we must add the term u0Nto the above expres- sion forU(0) when we compare U(0) with U(BEC)= 0, the energy of a Bose-Einstein condensate, which is the ground state of the normal in order to have a superfluid state, we must (B2) which shows that u0must be below a certain a superfluid state. Assuming ok= -h2k2/2m and making the we find [from the condition that U(0)+u0N= 0 -0.21. 2.U(0)for 0 When superfluid velocity vsnegationslash= 0, the ground state en- ergy is U(0) (B3)whereU(0)(0) is the ground state energy for vs= 0, as given by Eq. (B1), and the second term comes from (u-u0)N, which is the energy increase due to the flow of the superfluid (here uis the chemical potential in when vsnegationslash= 0,u0is the superfluid state when vs= 0, and - h2q2/2m=
mv2 s/2 is the per-particle energy increase due to the flow of the C: DERIVATION OF EQ. (47) We present in this Appendix the details of the deriva- tion of Eq. (47). For convenience, we the self-consistency equation, Eq. (42), can be rewritten (C2) When superfluid velocity vsnegationslash= 0, we expect kto be a function of temperature Tand superfluid LetXdenote any one of 1,2,3) are components of q. We operate
/Xon both sides of Eq. (C2) to that Vk,k'is assumed to be next multiply both sides of the above equation by Ck k, and then take summation over k, quantity inside the first pair of parentheses on the right-hand side of the above equation equals to k', according to Eq. (C2). Therefore, the second of the two terms on the right-hand side is the same as the term on the left-hand side. Thus, we 0. (C5) We want a |k|>0 solution. , (C6) which is Eq. (47) and satisfies Ck X= 0, (C7)17 is a solution of Eq. (C5). However, Eq. (C6) is not the only possible solution of Eq. (C5) [as one can see, Eq. (C5) actually can have an infinite number of solutions]. We therefore need to justify that Eq. (C6) is the only physical solution, which is done as Hamiltonian ^Hof Eq. (33) describes equilibrium, there is no transition quasi-particle states, except pairing we can calculate, for each pair of ( k,-k) ex- citations, the partition function Zk= free entropy Sk=-Fk/Tand expect entropy Skand thermal energy ekto (C8) and ek= 2Uk+nkEk+n-kE-k, because there are additional terms involving expressions for Skandekobtained from Fk, as com- pared to Eqs. (C8) and (C9). By letting the sum of the additional terms in each of the expressions for Skandek to be zero, we arrive at 2Uk T+ we expect the contribution from each pair of (k,-k) excitations to the particle current density of the superfluid to be jk= (nk-n-k)-h mk (C11) (where -hk/mis the velocity of an excitation in the state of wave-vector k). We further expect jk= -h-1Fk/q. However, as compared to Eq. (C11), the expression for additional terms involving By letting the sum of the additional terms in the expression for jkto be zero, we arrive at 2Uk q+ the expressionsfor UkandE(s) k[Eqs. (34) and (37)] into Eqs. (C10) and (C12), we obtain
|k|2Ck X= 0, (C13) and therefore, for |k|>0, Eq. (C6) [which is Eq. (47)]. The derivation of Eq. (47) presented in this Appendix is similar to that presented in Ref. 25 for a similar equa- tion in the theory for the in the pres- ence of a magnetic field. 1J. Bardeen, L. N. Cooper, and J. R. Schrieffer, Phys. Rev. 108, 1175 (1957). 2F. London, Superfluids , vol. 1, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1950. 3F. London, Superfluids , vol. 2, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1954. 4F. London, Nature 141, 643 (1938); Phys. Rev. 54, 947 (1938); 5L. Tisza, Nature 141, 913 (1938). 6L. D. Landau, J. Phys. (Moscow) 5, 71 (1941) (reprinted in I. M. Khalatnikov, An Introduction to the Theory of Su- perfluidity, translated by P. C. Hohenberg, Perseus Pub- lishing, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 2000). 7N. N. Bogoliubov, J. Phys. (Moscow) 11, 23 in D. Pines, The Many-Body Problem, W. A. Benjamin, New York, 1961). 8R. P. Feynman, Phys. Rev. 94, 262 (1954); in Progress in Low Temperature Physics (C. J. Gorter, ed.), Vol. I, Chap. II, North-Holland, Amsterdam, (1955). 9J. G. Valatin and D. Butler, NuovoCimento 10, 37 (1958). 10W. A. B. Evans and Y. Imry, Nuovo Cimento B 63, 155 (1969).11P. Nozi` eres and D. Saint James, J. Physique 43, S. Jeon, L. Yin, S. W. Rhee and D. J. Thouless, Phys. Rev. A66, 011603(R) (2002). 13G. B. Hess and W. M. Fairbank, Phys. Rev. Lett. 19, 216 (1967). 14N. N. Bogoliubov, NuovoCimento 7, 794 (1958); Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 34, 58 (1958) [Sov. Phys. JETP 7, 41 (1958)]. 15J. G. Valatin, Nuovo Cimento 7, 843 (1958). 16A. L. Fetter and J. D. Walecka, Quantum Theory of Many- Partcle Systems , McGraw-Hill, New York, 1971. 17K. Huang, Statistical Mechanics , Wiley, New York, 1963. 18R. P. Feynman, Statistical Mechanics , Benjamin, Reading, MA Hao, New interpretation for energy gap of the cut-off approximation in the BCS theory of D. Conte and C. de Boor, Elementary Numerical Anal- ysis: An Algorithmic Approach, 3rd edition, McGraw-Hill, New York (1980). 21M. J. Buckingham and W. M. Fairbank, The nature of the lambda transition, in Progress in Low J. Gorter, ed.), Vol. III, North-Holland, Ams- terdam, (1961). 22C. Ryu, M. F. Andersen, P. Clade, V. Natarajan, K. Helmerson andW. D. Phillips, Phys. Rev.Lett. 99, R. Abo-Shaeer, C. Raman, J. M. Vogels and W. Ket- terle, Science 292(5516), 476 (2001).24P. Engels, I. Coddington, P. C. Haljan, V. Schweikhard and E. A. Cornel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90(17), 170405 Hao, Theory for in a magnetic field: A local approximation approach, R. Piegel, Mathematical Handbook of Formulas and Ta- bles, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1968.
|
0807.1503
|
Zhidong Hao
|
Zhidong Hao
|
Theory for superfluidity in a Bose system
|
17 pages 12 figures; revised; and added quatitative description of
Hess-Fiarbank effect
| null | null | null |
cond-mat.supr-con
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We present a microscopic theory for superfluidity in an interacting
many-particle Bose system (such as liquid $^4$He). We show that, similar to
superconductivity in superconductors, superfluidity in a Bose system arises
from pairing of particles of opposite momenta. We show the existence of an
energy gap in single-particle excitation spectrum in the superfluid state and
the existence of a specific heat jump at the superfluid transition. We derive
an expression for superfluid particle density $n_s$ as a function of
temperature $T$ and superfluid velocity ${\bf v}_s$. We show that
superfluid-state free energy density $F$ is an increasing function of $v_s$
(i.e., $\partial F/\partial v_s > 0$), which indicates that a superfluid has a
tendency to remain motionless (this result qualitatively explains the
Hess-Fairbank effect, which is analogous to the Meissner effect in
superconductors). We further speculate the existence of the equation ${\bf
j}=-\Lambda\nabla\times \text{\boldmath $\omega$}$, where ${\bf j} = n_s{\bf
v}_s$ is the superfluid current density, $\text{\boldmath
$\omega$}=\nabla\times {\bf v}_s$ the superfluid vorticity, and $\Lambda$ a
positive constant (with the help of this equation, the Hess-Fairbank effect can
be quantitatively described).
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 9 Jul 2008 17:12:13 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 12 Mar 2009 03:21:15 GMT"
}
] | 2009-03-12T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Hao",
"Zhidong",
""
]
] |
2 relaxation, which is ineffective at low energies, and generation-reco mbination processes. There is a marked increase in the carrier population in the range of energies where the phonon an d radiative mechanisms of relaxation are The interband absorption saturation also affects t he energy distribution of carriers. The graphene dc conductivity as a function of the pumping intensity exhibits a pronou nced nonlinearity with a sub-linear region at fairly low intensities and a saturation at a strong pumping. It is also fo und that in a certain energy range of the pumping power the real part of the interband contribution to the d ynamic conductivity becomes negative, i.e. the negative absorption takes place. The paper is organized in the following way. The model under consider ation is described in Sec. II. In Sec. III, we present the nonequilibrium carrier distribution as function of pumpin g intensity for a few pumping frequencies. The results of calculations of the and the dynamic co nductivity, as a response on a weak dc electric field or a probe high-frequency field, are discussed in Sec. IV. The brief discussion of the assumptions used in calculations and concluding remarks are given in the last section. II. MODEL In order to obtain the energy distributions of the carriers in intrins ic graphene we use the quasiclassic kinetic equation derived and analytically analyzed previously [11] for the cas e of low intensity pumping. The kinetic equation under the to sc atteringon acousticphonons, the processes associated with thermal radiation, and t he far- or mid-IR pumping. We disregard the inter- carrier scattering since at low temperatures the carrier concent ration can be small even at relatively strong Since the scattering mechanisms in c- andv-bands are symmetric, the electron and hole distributions in the intrinsic material are identical and we consider below the carrier distribution function fp. Taking into account the abovementioned mechanisms, the kinetic equation under consid eration, which governs the distribution function fp, is presented in the following 0. (1) Here the collision integrals associated with the relaxation of carriers caused by the acous thete the interband transition due to the acoustic phonon scatter ing are forbidden (the sound velocity is weak in comparison to vW), the concentration balance equation takes = 0 (2) and it can be considered as the normalization condition for fp. Another condition for fpstreams from the so that any term in Eq. (1) is equal to zero at p- , i.e. the zero acoustic flow at high energies the quasielastic scattering of carriers on acoustic pho nons, one can use the Fokker-Planck form of JLA{fp}[12] and Eq. (1) can be presented as 0. HerepT=T/vWis the characteristic thermal momentum ( Tis the temperature in the energy units), the Planck distribution function, and the form-factor ( e) describes the broadening of So that pohm= -hohm/2vWis the momentum of just photogenerated carriers corresponding to the ohm and the broadeningis described by dpohmwhich is proportionalto pohmif the scattering rates are proportional to the density of states. It was assumed below that ( e) =p-1/2exp(-e2) anddpohm/pohm0.1 [13]. The gandGare the relative strength of the energy relaxation with respect to the and the characteristic value of the pumping intensity, res pectively. It is important below, that a on T, ohm and the pumping intensity, S, take place: gT , G S/(ohm3T), (4) so that the acoustic contribution increases with Twhile the excitation efficiency decreases with ohm and T. The of gandGcan be found in Ref. [11]. Using the typical parameters of graphene [14], atT=77 K At the same temperature at S=1W/cm2and -hohm=120 meV one can get G2.8. Numerical procedure for the problem described can be simplified if on e takes into account that the remains valid at p-0. The condition fp-0=1/2(it is the Fermi function at zeroenergy)can be considering that G{fp}vanishes at p-0 (ifpohmdpohm) and equations JLA{fp}= 0 and JR{fp}= 0 are satisfied by the equilibrium distribution. Taking this into account, one can write the boundary condition at p- , as the requirement that the factor {...}under derivative in the first term in the left-hand side of Eq. (3) tur ns to zero. As a consequence, for numerical solution of Eq. (2), one ca n use the following requirements as the for the distribution 0, (5) while the balance condition (2) should be used for checking of a numer ical results obtained. The numerical solution of Eq. (3) is performed below using a finite difference method and the pertinent iteration procedure.
/s48 /s50 /s52 /s54 /s56 /s53 /s49/s48 /s49/s53 1: (Color online) Distribution functions fpvs energy vWp(a) for the pumping intensities S=10-5, 10-4,..., 103W/cm2 (from left to right) at T= 4.2 K and (b) for S=10-2, 10-1,..., 103W/cm2at 77 K. Dotted curves correspond to the s. Vertical arrow corresponds to the energy eq ual to -hohm/2 at -hohm=12 meV. III. NONEQUILIBRIUM DISTRIBUTION We present here the results ofnumerical solution ofEq. (3) with co nditions (5) and discuss the obtained at different excitation conditions (frequency and intens ity of pumping) and temperature for the of graphene [14]. The variation of the sheet carrier co ncentration with varying excitation conditions is also considered. The obtained distribution functions under the far-IR pumping with t he photon energy - hohm =12 meV are shown in Fig. 1 with the one-order step in pumping intensities from 10-5W/cm2to 103W/cm2. First of all, one can see a visible modification of the carrier distributions at low intensities (up t K and for4
/s48 /s49/s48 /s50/s48 /s51/s48 /s49/s48 /s50/s48 /s51/s48 /s52/s48 2: (Color online) The same as in Fig. 1 under mid-IR pumpi ng with - hohm =60 meV.
/s48 /s50/s48 /s52/s48 /s54/s48 /s50/s48 /s52/s48 /s54/s48 3: (Color online) The same as in Fig. 1 under the CO 2laser pumping, - hohm =120 meV, with intensities (a) 105W/cm2(from left to right) and (b) for S=10-2, 10-1,..., K). Next, the peak of the distribution function shifts towards -hohm/2. Such a behavior is in agreement with the previous analytical consideration [11]. Further , at sufficiently strong pumping, fp~pohmtends also to the values close to 1 /2, so that plateau-like energy distibutions are formed. The range o f carrier energies, where fp1/2, widens with increasing pumping intensity starting K and S~0.1 W/cm2 atT=77 K. Since fpremains equilibrium at p-0 (all terms of Eq.(1) are equal zero separately), one can see a deepening of fpin the region vWp~T. Under mid-IR excitation, - hohm =60 meV, a similar character of the low-pumping regime of response takes place, see Fig. 2. With increased pumping intensity, a peak of distribution appea rs, moreover, the peak distribution function can markedly exceed 1 /2, i.e. the population inversion occurs if S K and S K. Further, in the pumping region when S >1 W/cm2atT=4.2 K (or S >10 W/cm2atT=77 K)fp~pohm tends to 1 /2, so that a plateau of fpis formed around the energy - hohm/2. AsSincreases and the plateau region widens, the peak amplitude below - hohm/2 somewhat decreases but a maximal value of fpexceeds 1/2. Since the is predetermined by Eqs. (3) and (5) at p-0, a non-monotonic distribution with a deepening at vWp<=T, a peak under the energy - hohm/2, and a plateau around - hohm/2 is character of distribution takes place as - hohm increases: the same peculiarities are shifted to higher to Eq. (5). In Figs. 3a and 3b we plot fpunder the CO 2laser pumping, - hohm =120 meV. One can see that the population inversion regime begins for S K (or for S >10-1W/cm2atT=77 K) and the saturation region around - hohm/2 takes place if S >103W/cm2atT=4.2 K and 77 K. These peculiarities are5 retained for higher intensities, up to 4: (Color online) Carrier concentration n2Dvs pumping intensity Sfor the excitation energies - hohm =12, 60, and 120 meV (solid, dashed, and dotted curves, respectively) at differe nt obtained distribution functions allows to calculate the sheet car rier concentration at different pumping condi- tions and temperatures according to the standard (6) Figure 4 demonstrates the dependences of the sheet concentra tion in graphene as a function of the pumping to the energy distributions shown in Figs. 1-3. As fo llows from the numerical calculation of the Sin The power dependence n2DSrwithr0.57 takes place at T= 4.2Kbetween S~10-6W/cm2and 0.5 W/cm2for the mid-IR pumping or between S~10-7W/cm2and 10-5W/cm2for the far-IR pumping (see Figs. 4a and 4b, respectively). Under mid-IR pumping at T=77 K, the concentration increases according to the same power law and saturates at the same pumping intensities. However, the no nlinear regime begins starting S~5 mW/cm2. This is because the equilibrium concentration is proportional to T2. Note that in the case of pumping by CO 2laser, the saturation occurs at n2D>1011cm-2. In this situation, the inter-carrier scattering might be important . IV. DC AND DYNAMIC we turn to the consideration of the response of the nonequilib rium carriers with the distribution above to a weak dc electric field or a probe radiation. Taking into account that the momentum relaxation of carriers is caused by elastic scattering mechanisms, one can use th e following formula for the dc conductivity (7) Herelcis the correlation length of static disorder scattering, Ps( z) =e-z2I1(z2)/z2, where I1(z2) the first order Bessel function of imaginary argument, and s0is the conductivity in the case of short-range disorder scattering , when lc= 0 [15]. According to Eq.(5) fp=0= 1/2, for the short-range scattering case, when plc/-h1 (pis the the dc conductivity sis determined by the low energy carriers so that sappears to be independent of optical pumping intensity despite a significant concentration of t he photogenerated carriers, ss0. For it was assumed that lc= 10, 20, and 30 nm.6
/s48 /s50 /s52 /s54 /s56 5: (Color online) Normalized dc conductivity s/sovs pumping intensity S: (a) for low pumping region and lc=20 nm at different temperatures and - hohm =12, 60, and 120 meV (solid, dashed, and dotted curves, resp ectively), (b) for mid-IR pumping at temperatures T= 4.2 K and 77 K (solid and dotted curves), and (c) for different lcand -hohm =60 meV at T= 4.2 K and 77 K (solid and dotted curves). Figure 5 shows the dependences of the dc conductivity snormalized by its characteristic value s0on the using Eq. (7) with the distribution functions obtained in Se c. III for T= 4.2 K and 77 K and different pumping energies - hohm. The dependences are markedly nonlinear beginning from rather lo w (see the pertinent curves in Fig. 5a). The nonlinearity of the dc conductivity at low S(<=1 mW/cm2) is particularly strong in the case T= 4.2 K and far-IR pumping, - hohm = 12 meV, but the variation of not exceed 5% and becomes saturated at S >5 mW/cm2. In the range of intermediate intensities of mid-IR pumping, see Fig. 5b, there is a power increase in the dc conductivity , which is followed by the saturation region. It is instructing that an increase in the pumping intensity by several or ders of magnitude leads to a modest increase in s/s0. In Fig. 5c, the normalized dc conductivity as a function of the pumpin g intensity calculated for different values of the correlation length of the disorder scattering, lc. One can see that the conductivity becomes more sensitive to the pumping when parameter lcincreases. If lctends to zero, a quenching of takes place. Sinc e the dc conductivity sdepends on plc/-h, it, as a function of the pumping intensity, saturatates at higher in tensities that the carrier concentration n2D(compare Figs. 5 and 4). As seen from Figs. 2 and 3, the distribution function fpcan be larger than 1 /2 in a certain energy range if the pumping power is sufficiently high. This corresponds to the population inversion of carriers and might be used for far7
/s48 /s49/s48 /s50/s48 /s51/s48 /s52/s48 /s47/s101/s50
/s41/s82/s101
/s32/s46/s48/s49 /s48/s46/s49 /s49 6: (Color online) (a) Spectral dependences of the real p art of the dynamic interband conductivity ResoatT= 4.2 K for -hohm=60 meV and pumping intensities: S= 10-3, 10-1, 101, and 103W/cm2(solid, dashed, dotted and dash-dotted (b) Regions of parameters (shaded by vertic al and horizontal lines for T=4.2 K and 77 K, respectively) for which the dynamic interband conductivity is negative if - hohm=60 meV. infrared lasing. The real part of the interband contribution to the dynamic conductivity which is given by (8) can be negative. Here introduced in a similar way to pohmanddpohmin Eq. (3).[13]. so<0, iffpo>1/2. Re so(normalized by factor e2/p-h) on the probe frequency oat different pumping intensities S. In contrast to the pumping scheme when the pumping energy - hohm exceeds the energy of optical photons, so that a cascade of optical phonons is emitted and the photogenerated electrons ( holes) are accumulated near the conduction band bottom (valence band top), the negative dynamic interband condu ctivity in the case under consideration corresponds to the interband transitions with relatively high energies - ho(compare with [16]). Figure 6 shows the regions (shaded) on the pumping intensity - probe frequency plane corresponding to the negative dynamic interband conductivity at different temperatures. The dependence of the real part of net dynamic conductivity on the probe frequency o, can be markedly modified by the contribution of the intraband transition s (which correspond to the Drude the latter contribution can be effective only in the range o f rather small frequencies o.[16] V. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS The main restriction the model used aboveis the neglect of the Coulo mb interaction of carriers, so that the obtained results are valid at their sufficiently low concentrations. As can be fo und from Fig. 4, in the case of an bythetemp eratures on the pumping intensity is fairly liberal. The latter is owing to th e effect of saturation of the associated with the Pauli principle. In our consideration we also disregarded more complex The mechanism included in the model describe the gener al features of the relaxation processes considered, so that their refinement should not lead to a qualitative change of th e pattern of the phenomena studied above. As for the photogeneration of carriers by incident far- or mid-infrared r adiation, only the single-photon interband processes were taken into account. Hence, possible nonlinear frequency mult iplication and the energy spectra were disregarded. Our estimates show that the latter correspon d to the limitations of the pumping intensity by the valuesS <0.5 MW/cm2(at -hohm = 12 meV) and 5 MW/cm2(at -hohm = 120 meV). The other assumptions of our model (the isotropic energy spectra of carriers, the valley degen eration, and exclusion of the interaction with optical phonons in the range of energy under consideration) appears to b e rather natural.8 In summary, we calculated the energy distributions of carriers in an intrinsic graphene at low temperatures under far- and mid-IR (- hohm = 12-120 meV) pumping in a wide range of its intensities (from zero to 102kW/cm2). It was shown that these distributions are determined by interplay bet ween weak energy relaxation on acoustic phonons and radiative processes as well as by th e effect of pumping saturation due to the Pauli principle. The obtained energy distributions at elevated pumping inte nsities can exhibit the plateau regions and the regions corresponding to the population inversion. The graphe ne dc conductivity as a function of the demonstrates a pronounced nonlinearity at fairly weak pu mping (particularly at helium temperature), a steep increase in a certain range of intermediate intensities, and a s aturation at sufficiently strong pumping. Due to this, the graphene dc conductivity varies through 1-2 orders of m agnitude when the pumping intensity is varied many orders. We showed that the alteration of the graphene dc conduc tivity with far- and mid-IR irradiation, i.e., the effect of the is sensitive to the correlation length of dis order scattering. To conclude, the obtained results, can be useful for the extract ion of the parameters determined the in graphene and for the estimation of a potential of nov el optoelectronic devices [16, 17, 18], in particular, in terahertz and far infrared lasers [16, authors(A. S. andV. R.) aregratefulto ProfessorT. Otsuj ifor by the Japan Science and Technology Agency, CREST, J apan. [1] C. Berger et al., J. Phys. Chem. 108, 19912 (2004); K.S. Novoselov, et al., Nature 438, 197 (2005). [2] F. Guinea and N.M. Peres, Physics World 1933 (2006); A.K. Geim and A.H. MacDonald, Physics Today 60, 35 (2007); A.H. Castro Neto et al., J.M. Dawlaty, et al., arXiv:0712.0119; T. Stauber et al., J.-C. Charlier et al., Topics Appl. Physics 111, 673 (2008). [5] J.M. Dawlaty et al., arXiv:0801.3303; D. Sun et al., arXiv:0803.2883, P.George et al., arXiv:0805.4647; S. Butscher et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 91, 203103 (2007). [6] Z. Jiang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 197403 (2007); R.S. Deacon et al., Phys. Rev. B 76, 081406(R) (2007). [7] E.M. Lifshitz, L.P. Pitaevskii, and V.B. Berestetskii, Quantum Electrodynamics, Oxfor d 1982); P.R. Wallace, Phys. Rev. 71, 622 (1947). [8] P. Plochocka, et al., A. B. Kuzmenko et al., arXiv:0712.0835; T.G. Pedersen, Phys. Rev. B 67, 113106 (2003). [10] L. A. Falkovsky and A. A. Varlamov, Eur. Phys. J. B 56, 281 (2007); L. A. Falkovsky, arXiv:0806.3663; V. P. Gusynin et al., Int. Jour. of Mod. Phys. B 21, 4611 (2007). [11] F.T. Vasko and V. Ryzhii, Phys. Rev. B 77, 195433 (2008). [12] E.M. Lifshitz and L.P. Pitaevskii, Physical Kinetics , (Pergamon, Oxford 1981); F.T. Vasko and O.E. Raichev, Quantum Kinetic Theory and Applications (Springer, N.Y. 2005). [13] vdpohm, sothat velocity vdwas introduced in Ref. 15 through the momentum relaxation time for the short -range scattering mechanism, - h/vdp. [14] The characteristic values of the energy relaxation and pumping, gandG, are introduced in Eq. (3) with the use of the energy relaxation, the , and the photoexcitation rates given by Eqs. (13), (10), and (7) of Re f. 11. Under numerical calculations we used the following paramey ers of graphene: the deformation potential 12 eV, the sheet density 7 *10-8g/cm2, the sound velocity 7.3 x105cm/s and the dielectric permittivity ~3.7 (SiO 2- graphene structure). [15] F.T. Vasko and V. Ryzhii, Phys. Rev. B 76, 233404 (2007). [16] V. Ryzhii, M. Ryzhii, and T. Otsuji, J. Appl. Phys. 101, 083114 (2007); Phys. Stat. Sol.(c) 5, 261 (2008). [17] F. Rana, IEEE Trans. Nanotechnology 7, 91 (2008). [18] V. Ryzhii et al., Appl. Phys. Express 1, 063002 (2008).
|
0807.1590
|
Fedir Vasko T
|
A. Satou, F.T. Vasko, and V. Ryzhii
|
Nonequilibrium carriers in an intrinsic graphene under interband
photoexcitation
|
8 pages, 6 figures
|
Physical Review B 78, 115431 (2008)
|
10.1103/PhysRevB.78.115431
| null |
cond-mat.mtrl-sci cond-mat.mes-hall
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study nonequilibrium carriers (electrons and holes) in an intrinsic
graphene at low temperatures under far- and mid-infrared (IR) radiation in a
wide range of its intensities. The energy distributions of carriers are
calculated using a quasiclassic kinetic equation which accounts for the energy
relaxation due to acoustic phonons and the radiative generation-recombination
processes associated with thermal radiation and the carrier photoexcitation by
incident radiation. It is found that the nonequilibrium distributions are
determined by an interplay between weak energy relaxation on acoustic phonons
and generation-recombination processes as well as by the effect of pumping
saturation. Due to the effect of saturation, the carrier distribution functions
can exhibit plateaus around the pumping region at elevated intensities. As
shown, at sufficiently strong mid-IR pumping, the population inversion can
occur below the pumping energy. The graphene dc conductivity as a function of
the pumping intensity exhibits a pronounced nonlinearity with a sub-linear
region at fairly low intensities and a saturation at a strong pumping. However,
an increase in the pumping intensity in very wide range leads only to a modest
increase in the carrier concentration and, particularly, the dc conductivity.
The graphene conductivity at mid-IR irradiation exhibit strong sensitivity to
mechanisms of carrier momentum relaxation.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 08:08:53 GMT"
}
] | 2010-06-29T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Satou",
"A.",
""
],
[
"Vasko",
"F. T.",
""
],
[
"Ryzhii",
"V.",
""
]
] |
2 Motivat ed by these question s we studie d the similarities and the differences between the models . A brief description of the models a nd their results is presented in section 2. A better approximation for one of the models is presented in section3. New model is used for investigating the soliton -potential interaction in 4 model and the results are compared with the results of the other model s in section 4. Some conclusion s and remarks will be presented in section 5. 2. Two models for 4 Solitons -potential system Model 1 : Consider a scalar field with the lagrangian L=1 2-U() (1) and the following potential U = x (2-1)2 (2) The equation of motion for the field becomes
+4 x 2-1 =0 (3) The effects of the potential are added to the equation of motion by using a suitable definition for x , like x =1+
v(x). For a constant value of parameter ( x =1) equation (2) has a solitary solution as following [6] x,t =+-tanh 2 x-x0-ut 1-u2 (4) in which x0 and u are solitary wave initial position and its initial velocity respectively. This equation is used as initial condition for solving (3) with a space dependent x when the potential v(x) is small . Model 2 : The potential also can be added to the lagrangian of the system , through the metric of background space - time. So the metric includes characteristics of the medium . The general form of the action in an arbitrary metric is: I= L(,) -gdnxdt (5) where g is the determinant of the metric )(x g . A suitable metric in the presence of a weak potential v(x) is [ 4, 5 and 6 ]: g x 1+v(x) 0 0-1 (6) The equation of motion for the field which is described by the lagrangian ( 1) in the action ( 5) is [4, 7]: 1 -g -g+ -g +U()
=0 (7) This equation of motion in the background space -time ( 6) becomes [6]: 1+v x 2 t2-2 x2-1 2 1+v x v x x x +U()
=0 (8) The field energy density is: H2=g00(x) 1 2g00 x 2+1 2 2+U() (9) The energy density is calculated by varying both the field and the metric (See page 643 equation (11.81) of [ 8]). If we look at the L(,) -g of action (5) as an effective lagrangial in a flat space -time, then the en ergy density becomes [6]
= g00(x) 1 2g00 x 2+1 2 2+U() (10) The above Hamiltonian density can be found by varying only the field in the effective lagrangian. This equation does not contain energy exchange between the field and the metric (therefore with the potential). This is an important point that makes some differences. Solution ( 4) can be used as initial condition for solving ( 8) when the potential v(x) is small. If we define the parameter x =1+v(x) in model 1 then it is possible to compare the results of two models. The potential v x = 0 x <p 0otherwise (10) has been chosen in [ 4] where 0 and ,,p are the potential strength and the potential width respectively . Scattering of a soliton with a potential barrier is nearly elastic. The soliton radiates a small amount of energy during the interaction. The r adiated energy during the interaction in model 2 is more than the energy radiation in the model 1 . The radiated energy become s larger when the height of the barrier or the speed of the soliton increases [4]. Both two models show that t here exist two different kinds of trajectories during the scattering of a soliton on a potential barrier depend ing on soliton initial velocity . Two kinds of trajectories are separate d by a critical velocity uc. At low velocities ( u<uc) soliton reflects back and reaches its initial place . A soliton with an initial velocity u>uc has enough energy to pass over t he potential. Note that model 2 is valid for slowly varying small potentials [4]. It means that we have to use smooth and small potentials in metric (6) , but a square -like potential i s not smooth. Some simulations have been set up with a smooth potential v x =a Exp -b(x-c)2 with using two models. Simulations show that the differences between the soliton behaviour in two models with using this potential decrease, but the differences do not vanish . Indeed the 3 simulations with this potential are in agre ement with the mentioned differences which we have been reported for a square -like potential in [4] . It means that the two models are really different in these cases. Is it possible to improve a model in order to get agreement with the other model? 3. Improved approximation It is possible to improve model 2 by using a better approximation for the metric of back ground space -time. The better metric is g x 1+v(x) 0 0-1 1+v(x) (11) The field equation of motion is derived from (7) using the metric (11) as follow s 1+v x (12) The e nergy density of the field in this improved model (which we call it ,,model 3) becomes H3=1 2(1+v x )2 2+1 2 2+ 1+v x U() (13) The potential is still a slowly varying and small function. The models can be compared using the energy of a soliton in three models. The energy density of a soliton in model 1 is H1=1 2 2+1 2 2+ 1+v x U() (14) The above energy density is related to the field only. Equations (9) and (13) are the energy density of soliton + metric in the model 2 and the new model3 respectively. Consider a static solitary wave located in the initial position X0. The energy density of the field is 1 2 2+ 1+v x U() in the models 1 and 3 while the model 2 predicts the static energy 1 2 1+v x 2+ 1+v x U() for this situation . The difference of the energy is DEstatic=Emodel 3-Emodel 1=1 2v x 2. This means that the models 1 and 3 have the same effective potential but the model 2 contains an extra term. This small extra term is positive for a potential barrier and it is negative for potential well. It can be concluded that the effective potential in the model 2 is stronger than the effective potential of models 1 and 3. Let us now look at the kinetic terms in the three models . The kinetic energy in the models 2 and 3 are the same and they are different with the kinetic energy in the model 1 . The diff erence kinetic energy in the first order approximation is DEkinetic=Emodel 3-Emodel 1v x 2. It is positive for potential barrier and negative for the potential well. This means that the effective mass in the model 1 is smaller than the effective mass of the soliton in the model s 2 and 3 for a potential barrier. These differences act on the dynamics of solitary waves in the opposite ways therefore the predictions of the model 3 will be something between the predictions of the other mo dels. The effects of these differences are studied in the next section. 4. Comparing the models Several simulations using three models have been performed with different types of potentials . A potential of the form v x =a Exp -b(x-c)2 has been used in the results which are presented below . This type of the potential is more suitable for the model 2 and 3 than a rectangular potential, because it is a smooth and slowly varying function. Figure 1 shows the shape of the potential barrier v x =0.5 Exp -4x2 as seen by the soliton in three models . The shape of this potential has been found by placing a static soliton at different position s and calculating its total energy. As we have seen, the static energy of the models 1 and 3 are equal while the static energy calculated using model 2 is different. Our calculations are not in agreement with the simulations of Ref. [6]. It is because of the difference in the way of calculat ing the Hamiltonian density . 4 Figure 1: The potential barrier v x =0.5 Exp -4x2 as seen by the soliton in three models. The c ritical velocity for the soliton to pass over the potential barrier has been demonstrated as a funct ion of the barrier height in figure 2 for three models. There are some differences between the results of the models. The results of model s 1 and 3 are more similar and they are different from the results of the model 2. Figure 2: Critical velocity as a function of the barrier height of the potential v x =a Exp -4x2 in three models. Figure 3 shows the critical velocity as a function of the potential width for three models. This figure shows a very good agreement between models 1 and 3 too. 5 Figure 3: Critical velocity as a function of the barrier width. The potential is v x =0.5 Exp -bx2 . It is mentioned that the static energy of a soliton calculated using the models 1 and 3 are less than the calculated energy in the model 2. Simulations also show that the static energy of the soliton at the peak of the barrier calculated with the models 1 and 3 is the same and they are less than the static energy calculated using model 2 (See figure 1). Figures 2 and 3 show that the critical velocity simulated using the models 1 and 3 are greater than the critical energy in the model 2. If we look at the soliton as a point particle, we can find the critical velocity with comparing the soliton energy in different positions. In this manner, we expect to find a g reater critical velocity using the model 2, because the static energy (rest mass) on top of the barrier calculated with the model 2 is greater than the static energy (rest mass) in the other models. But the critical velocity in the model 2 is smaller than the critical velocity of the other models (see figures 2 and 3). It is in contradiction with the results of the figure 1. Note that the figure 1 presents the energy of a static soliton while the critical velocity is a dynamic al parameter. An explanation in base of the effective mass has been presented in Ref. [4] . The reasoning can be completed if we inspect the problem by the collective coordinate approach which has been used for the sine -Gordon model previously [ 7]. The critical velocity is minimum required velocity for a soliton at the initial position of infinity in which the soliton be able to pass over the barrier after the interaction. The soliton energy in the position X t =x0-ut is E X t = H x,X t dx=M 1-u2+
- where M is the soliton rest mass. The Hamiltonian density of each model is calculated by inserting the solution 4 in the equations (9), (13) and (14) for the models 2, 3 and 1 respectively. Figure 4 presents the rest mass of the soliton as a functio n of the Barrier height. This f igure shows that the rest mass of the soliton in the model 2 is greater than the soliton rest mass in the model s 1 and 3. Also models 1 and 3 predict almost the same rest mass for the soliton. It is clear that a soliton with a greater rest mass needs smaller velocity to reach a potential peak. This is true for small potentials as we can find in the figure 2. But for greater potentials the differences between the models 1 and 3 become bigger. It is not surprising, because the m odels are different. But it is possible to fit the results of the models with the definition of an effective potential [7]. 6 Figure 4: Rest mass of a static soliton on top of the barrier v x =a Exp -4x2 as a function of the height of the barrier Scattering of topological Soliton s on a potential well is more interesting. Unlike a classical point particle which always transmits trough a potential well, a soliton may be trapped in a well if the potential well has enough depth. We have found from the figure s 1 and 4 that a soliton has not a fixed mass, so we can not look at the soliton as a point particle in some cases. Several simulations have been done for soliton -well system using three models. Like the potential barrier, the general behavi our of the system is almost the same for all three models. But there are some differences in the details of the interactions. Figure 5 presents a comparison between the shapes of the potential well v x =-0.5 Exp -4x2 as seen by the soliton in three mode ls. Models 1 and 3 provide very similar potential but the shape of the potential in model 2 is different. Figure 5: The shape of the potential well as seen by the soliton for the potential v x =-0.5 Exp(-4x2) . The differences in the effective pote ntial for the three models cause some differences in the character istics of the system . For example, the rest mass of the soliton is different when it is calculated using different models. Figure 6 demonstrates the rest mass of the soliton in three models as a function of the potential depth. Models 1 and 3 pr edict very similar values which are a little greater than the effective mass of the soliton in the model 2. 7 Figure 6: The rest mass of the soliton in the potential well calc ulated with three models. As the figure 5 shows, the effective potential in the models 1 and 3 are greater than the effective potential calculated with model 2 . On the other hand, the figure 6 indicates that the rest mass of the soliton in the model 2 i s less than the rest mass in the other models. Therefore it is expected that the critical velocity of a soliton in the model 2 becomes greater than the critical velocity in the models 1 and 3. Figure 7 presents the critical velocity of a soliton in the potent ial well as a function of the potential depth. However the potential in the models 1 and 3 is almost the same, but the critical velocity in these models are not equal. It is interesting to compare the soliton trajectory in three models. Figure 7: Critical velocity as a function of the depth of the potential well. Figure 8 presents the trajectory of a soliton with an initial velocity u=0.4 during the interaction with potential v x =-0.5 Exp(-4x2). The final velocity of the soliton in the model 2 is smaller than the other two models . This means that the energy radiation in the model 2 is very greater than the models 1 and 3. Figure 8 also show that the energy radiation in the model 3 is greater than the model 1. It is the main reason for the diff erences between the critical velocities in the figure 7. 8 Figure 8: Trajectory of a soliton with initial velocity u=0.4 during the interaction with the potential well v x =
-0.5 Exp(-4x2) in three models. The most interesting behaviour of a soliton during the scattering on a potential well is seen in some very narrow windows of initial velocit ies. At some velocities smaller than the uc the soliton may reflect back or transmit over the potential while one would expect that the soliton s hould trap in the potential well. These narrow windows can be found by scanning the soliton initial velocity with small steps. Figures 9 show this phenomenon in the model 1 and model 3. Figure 1 0a shows that a soliton with an initial velocity in the window reflects back during the interaction with potential v x =-0.2 Exp(-4x2) simulated using the model 3. Figure 1 0b presents the same phenomen on as in model 2 for the potential v x =-0.6 Exp(-4x2). Same situations have not been reported in [4] for the model 1. Models 2 and 3 are built by varying the lagrangian density with respect to both field and the metric. Therefore energy exchange between the field and the potential in these models is possible. Soliton ref lection in a potential well is a result of energy exchange between the soliton and the potential [1]. This phenomenon needs deeper investigations. Figure 9: (a) Soliton reflection from the potential well v x =-0.2 Exp(-4x2) in model 3. (b) Soliton reflection from the potential well v x =-0.6 Exp(-4x2) using the model 2 . 5. Conclusion and remarks The presented new model is compared with other two models. The r esults of the interaction of a soliton with potentials using three models are almost in agreement with each others. Model 1 adds the potential to the equation of motion by a different method from those are used in models 2 and 3. Model 3 has better approximation than the model 2. On the other hand model 3 predicts the character istics of the system very near to predictions of the model 1 . 9 Therefore it can be concluded that the results of the models are valid. The model 1 is easy to simu lation while t he model 3 is more analytic. All three models agree that the interaction of a solito n with a potential barrier is near ly elastic . At low velocit ies it reflects back but with a high velocity climbs the barrier and transmits over the potential. Soliton radiates some amounts of energy during the interaction with the potential. There exists a critical velocity which separates these two kinds of trajectories. Interaction of a soliton with potential well is more inelastic. It is possible that a soliton scatter on a potential well and reflect back from the potential . The models 2 and 3 predict this behaviour . The model 3 works better than the model 2. Therefore the constructed collecting coordinates using the model 3 may give us better information about the soliton dynamics. It is interesting to investigate scattering of solitons of other model s on defects using model 3. These studies help us to find better knowledge about the general behaviour of solitons. 6. REFERENCES [1] Kivshar Y S, Fei Z and Vasquez L 1991 Phys. Rev. Lett 67 1177 [2] Fei Z, Kivshar Y S and Vasquez L 1992 Phys. Rev. A46 5214 [3] Piette B.M.A.G and Zakrzewski W.J.2007 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40 No 2, 329 -346 [4] Javidan K and Sarbishaei M 2001 Indian J. Physics B75 (5) 413 -418 [5] Javidan K. 2006 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 39 10565 -10574 [6] Al-Alawi J. and Zakrzewski W.J. (2007) J. Phys. A 40, 11319 -1131 [7] Javidan K. 2008 Phys. Rev. E 78, 046607 [8] Felsager B. (1998) Geomrtry, Particles, and fields (New York: Springer -Verlag)
|
0807.1618
|
Kurosh Javidan
|
Ensieh Hakimi, Kurosh Javidan
|
Improved model for the topological soliton-potential interaction in
Phi^4 Model
|
8 pages, 11 figures
|
Phys. Rev. E 80, 016606 (2009)
|
10.1103/PhysRevE.80.016606
| null |
hep-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
An improved model for the soliton-potential interaction is presented. This
model is constructed with a better approximation for adding the potential to
the lagrangian through a space-time metric. The results of the model are
compared with other models and the differences are discussed.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 10:25:08 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 15 Jan 2009 03:23:09 GMT"
}
] | 2009-10-16T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Hakimi",
"Ensieh",
""
],
[
"Javidan",
"Kurosh",
""
]
] |
1. showed that if cycles in a set of cycles satisfy the 3 -path- condition , then there exists a polynomial time algorithm that finds a shortest cycle in this set[3]. As applications, he showed that the following types of shortest cycles may be found in polynomial time. (1) A shortest cycle in a P-embedded graph; (2) A shortest P-nonseparating cycle in a P-embedded graph; (3) A shortest P-onesided cycle in a P-embedded graph. But what about a family of cycles which do not satisfy the In their monograph[2, pp112], B.Mohar and C.Thomassen r aised the following open problems: (a) Isthere a sho in a P-embedded graph? (b) Isthere a asho cycle in a P-embedded graph? (c) Isthere a asho in a P-embedded graph? Here inthis paper we consider connected graphsandall the concep ts used are standard following from [1,2]. LetGbe a P-embedded graph and tree rooted at a vertex xofG. a fundamental cycle of T is the operation defined as AB= (A-B)(B-A) for A. The collectionCof cycles defined above satisfies the There exists a shortest P-twosided cycle (in a P-embedded graph ) in C; (b). Each shortest even cycle of a graph is contained in C; (c). If a shortest cycle of a graph is an odd cycle, then every s hortest odd cycle is contained in C1. 2Therefore, Theorem A implies the existence of a polynomially to find short cycles defined above. Theorem B. There exists a algorithmto find a short - estP-twosided cycle in a P-embedded graph and all the shortest even cycles in a graph. This solves problem (c). Since every possible two-sided cycle in an em- bedded graph in the projective plane is contractible, we have the fo There is a polynomially bounded algorithm to find a cycle in an embedded graph in the projective pl ane. This answers the problems (a)-(c) in the case of projective plane g raphs. 2. Proof of Main embedding scheme of a graph Gin a surface S is a set of a rotation systems with a mapping , We define P = ( p,l) as an embedding scheme for the graph G. A cycleCof an embedded graph Gia called P-twosided if Ccontains even number of edges with negative it is called P -onesided. For a vertex vV(G), we may change the clockwise ordering to an- ticlockwise, i.e., pvis replaced by its inverse p-1 v, andl(e) is replaced by -l(e) for each edge eincident with v. Therefore, we obtain another embed- ding scheme P'= (p',l'). It is clear that a cycle is P -twosided if and only if it is P'-twosided. Two of such embedding schemes are equivalent if and only if one can be changed into another by a sequence of such local changes . Thus, for any spanning tree Tof an embedded graph G, we may always assume that each edge eofThas signature l(e) = +1 for convenience. The key of the proof of Theorem A is the following classification of sho rt cycles according to the distance between two vertices on such cyc les. Let Cbe a shortest P-twosided cycle in an embedded graph G. one of the following dG(x,y. Remark: In the following, we will see that a cycle satisfying (2) may be written as a sum of two shorter cycles. Therefore, a shortest cy cle in a 3collection of cycles satisfying the 3-path-condition can't satisfy (2 ). Lemma 1. LetGandCbe as defined in Theorem A and Ca shortest P- twosided cycle in Gsatisfying (2). Then Ccontains a shortest P-twosided cycle ofG. Proof of Lemma 1. We assume that Chas a clockwise ( -C(- -C)and for any two vertices uandvofC,u- -Cv(u- -Cv) denotes the closed interval from utovalong- -C(- -C). Similarly, we may define a segment uPvas the closed interval from utovin a path P. Ifuis a vertex of C, thenu-(u+) is the predecessor ( successor) of ualong- -C. We consider two vertices x,yofCsuch that dG(x,y) is minimum subject to (2). Then for any shortest ( x-y) no inner vertex on C( since otherwise, there would be another two vertices (2) and DG(x1,y1)< dG(x,y)). LetTxbe a rooted at x. Then it contains a ( x-y) path P and each of the two cyclesPx- -CyandPx- -Cyis a P-onesided cycle shorter than that of C and satisfies (1) (since otherwise one of them may be written as a su m of oneisaP -twosided). -CyandPx- -Cyis a fundamental cycle of a rooted at a vertex on itself. This completes the proof of Lemm a 1. Now we turn to the cycles satisfying (1). Firstly, the following result is easy to be verified and we omit the proof of it. Lemma 2. LetCbe a shortest P-twosided cycle in a P-embedded graph G. Then for any three vertices =dc(x,v) = [|C|-1 2], any shortest (x-u)pathPandx- -Cvhas no inner vertex in common. Thus, for a shortest P -twosided cycle Csatisfying the conditions in Lemma 2 and the last common vertex a( calledbranched vertex ) contained in (x-u)pathP1and -P1a(=x- -P2a) has no inner vertex on x- -Cv(x- -Cu). Lemma 3. LetGandCbe as defined in Theorem A and Ca cycle in Gsatisfying (1). Then Ccontains a shortest P- twosided cycle ofG. 4Proof of Lemma 3. Case 1|C|= 2n, nN. Letxandybe two vertices of CwithdG(x,y) =nandTxa tree rooted at xwhose edges are all assigned signature l= a ( x-y)pathP, a (x-y-)pathP1, and a ( 1.1 may suppose that P1Pandl(y,y+) =-1 without generality. If Pis not contained in By Lemma 2, we may choose an index isuch that Ci=xi- -P xi+1xi- -Cxi+1is an even P-onesided cycle such that Phas no inner vertex on xi- -Cxi+1other than xi andxi+1. shortercycles. (1) and further, Ciis a fundamental cycle of a at some vertex of Ci. has a cycle in G. IfPC, thenP2can't be contained in C(sinceCis P-twosided). As we have reasoned above, there exists a segment xj- -Cxj+1ofCsuch that Cj=
xj- -Cxj+1xj- -P2xj+1is a fundamental cycle and so, a shortest P -twosided cycle in G. Subcase 1.2 = +1or l(y,y+) = +1, then contain a shortest P -twosided cycle. Assume further that l(y,y-) =
l(y,y+) =-1. Then contains a cycle in G. Case 2.|C|= 2n+1, =dC(x,y+) =nandTxbe a tree rooted at xwith all its edges been assigned l= +1. Then Txcontains a ( x-y)pathP1and a (x,y+)pathP2and a branched vertex aP1P2. Suppose that P1is not a part of Candl(y,y+) =-1. Then as we have shown in Case 1 there exists an index isuch that Ci=xi- -Cxi+1 xi- -P1xi+1is a fundamental cycle and thus a shortest P-twosided cycle in C. This completes the proof of Lemma 3 and so, finishes the proof of part (a) of Theorem A. 5As for the proof of parts (b) and (c) of Theorem A, it follows from t he proving procedure of (a) of Theorem A. Based on the above statement, Theorem A is J.A.Bondy and U.S.R.Murty, Graph theory with applications (1978). [2] B.Mohar and C.Thomassen, Graphs on Surfaces The Johns Hopkins Uni- versity Press,Baltimore and London, 2001. [3] of graphs with no short noncontract ible cy- cles,J. of Combin. Theory., Ser B 48
|
0807.1620
|
Ren Han
|
Han Ren, Ni Cao
|
Finding Short Cycles in an Embedded Graph in Polynomial Time
| null | null | null | null |
math.CO
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Let ${\cal{C}}_1$ be the set of fundamental cycles of breadth-first-search
trees in a graph $G$ and ${\cal{C}}_2$ the set of the sums of two cycles in
${\cal{C}}_1$. Then we show that $(1) {\cal{C}}={\cal{C}}_1\bigcup{\cal{C}}_2$
contains a shortest $\Pi$-twosided cycle in a $\Pi$-embedded graph $G$;$(2)$
$\cal{C}$ contains all the possible shortest even cycles in a graph $G$;$(3)$
If a shortest cycle in a graph $G$ is an odd cycle, then $\cal{C}$ contains all
the shortest odd cycles in $G$. This implies the existence of a polynomially
bounded algorithm to find a shortest $\Pi-$twosided cycle in an embedded graph
and thus solves an open problem of B.Mohar and C.Thomassen[2,pp112]
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 10:33:18 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-11T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Ren",
"Han",
""
],
[
"Cao",
"Ni",
""
]
] |
1 Introduction In theoretical models in which the accretion dynamics in plasmas are explored ,i.e. plasmas that obey at the various models ,with good approxima- tion, in Plasma Physics, like resistive model, Hall-model and others mixed and dominant models which include the we can see that the astrophysical plasmas develop them- selves around compact objects, like neutron stars and black holes usually; in such theoretical models in which the formations of anti- parallel plasma-jets are oftenexamined inthe context of their sing u- lar morphology, there are many references at well defined charac ter- istic mathematical structures that could explain the shape of inside the accretion and ejection plasma mechanics. These mathematical models result very interesting for both se an indiscutible mathematical link between the fundamental theory of the above astrophysical phenomena and the physical charate ris- tics of the singular plasma formations in the above star structures , without affecting the essential set of solutions in the base phisical models that explain very well yet the most considerable star dynam- ics in the astrophysical plasma - ten investigated because they match at several characteristic c inside the accretion disc and the plasma jets; these clus - ter formations are well localized physical structures, with magnet ic induction field Band electric field Etopologies that take place in the surrounding space and that donate, with the necessary hydr o- dynamical force fields, a precise shape at these formations, which are therefore confined in limited space areas in the curved space around the concerned compact object (this situation exist becau se the gravitational field densities near these astrophysical object s are relevant and a full relativistic treatment in any possible must be considered) and that show in many cases a peculiar space periodicity in a well defined global space configuration when the mechanics are in steady state condi- tion, or in an equilibrium state. These localized plasma formation are indentifiable, for example, in the space development of a plasma jet which derives from a com- pact star and it stretch itself from the central object to the far space areas by a series of quasi-spherical plasma structures named 'plas ma bubbles' [1],[2] (in this case the jet acquired a singular morphology known by the name of 'knotty structure') . In other cases, similar structures are localized in the accretion discs aroundsame compact stars, leading to the formationof relat a- 2pe is linked to the spiral motions in the disc, which response to a specifical equations set of equlibrium sta te that persist on a long time-scale, meaning in this way the configuration. In this regard, localized structure s in the dynamics of accretion discs in an astrophysical context have been identified analytically and by several numer- ical simulations, from Petviashvili et al. [3],[4]in the 80s as a solution to the problem of the Grad-Shafranov Equation (GSE), a funda- mental non-linear equilibrium equation in Plasma Physics, by the context of a general problem of two-dimensional dynamical the Grad-Shafranov Equation1is a 2nd-order elliptic PDE, from the mathematical point of view, which responds to a plasma equlibrium problem in a two-dimensional framework (x,y) [14] and it's derived by the Euler Equation (EE) in the ideal limit (ideal and the Ampere's Law (i.e. in the Maxwell's set equations) with neglect the 'displace- ment current', because the non-relativistic limit (v << c)or relativistic limit (it takes into account by a gravitational potential, like Paczynski-Wiita potential) of the gravity potential term in the Euler Equation, which derived for the concerned hydrodynamical problem (i.e. accretion disc or plasma jet in the astrophysical objects framework). This equation establish therefore a 'non-linear problem' for a certain scalar 'flux function' Pswhich defines the induction field B in the ordinary space (x,y,z)around the compact star and which have been yet analized from Petviashvili et al. [3]in an analytical theexistence of solitary toroidal structures in the validity framework of the the GSE for this flux function Psestablish the nec- essary conditions (i.e. a 'critic conditions') to which the and the free fields in the fluid equations must obey so that the equilibrium scenario is respected in the steady-state dynamics. At this point, it's indispensable to watch that in many of that usually develop some sets of expressions containing PDEs, like non linear wave equations, we are led to consider, by an appropriate choice of a function transforma - tionsset anda'reduction ofpotentials', anequivalent andmoregen- eral non-linear differential problem that represents the 'root diffe r- ential problem' for a more general category of non-linear problem s. From the point of view of this one, the more considerable that is present in many problems of regarding non-linear wave phenomena that involve PDEs is obvi- 1( H. Grad and H. Rubin (1958), V.D. Shafranov (1966) ) 3ously the well known ' Non-Linear Schr odinger Equation' (NLSE), an equation that is often present, for example, in non-linear optical problems [11]. You know the best known solution scenario of this is a ' solitonic solution ' or 'soliton solution ', where a 'soli- ton' is the well known special solitary wave solution of several non- linear dispersive wave equations; the main characteristics of this wave solution are its singular mathematical structure and its phys- ical behavior, which synthesize them primarily in their wave-structure . It seems therefore that the GSE, a non-linear (elliptic) equation, can be lead to the more general form of the NLSE for the station- ary case (steady-state for a plasma in an equlibrium state) by an appropriate choice of 'transformation functionals' for the free fi elds inside it; this consideration is furthermore reasoned by the fact th at the peculiar plasma knotsin the accretion discs and plasma jets cited above could be justified by an appropriate ' of these formations as periodic solitonic structures with conditions. At this point, if such appropriate choice of a transformations set exist and it is coherent from the mathematical point of view, there are no reasons for to refuse such a possibility. Such a choice for turning GSE in a NLSE with a specific cubic non-linearity, i.e. the NLSE for the Kerr effect in a non-linear optical mean, was made recently by G.Lapenta [8], who was demonstrated how it's possible to obtain a pair of appropriate transformations in a (x,y),like that in the equatorial plane of an accretion disc, which lead from a general GSE to a cubic NLSE by a two- dimensional Helmholtz Equation (2dHE) [7], which is important in the non-linear optical problems and it is related to many problems for steady-state oscillations (mechanical, acoustical, thermal, ele c- tromagnetic); but in the following year, by a purely idea was opposed by Throumoulopoulos G.N., Hizanidis K. and Tasso H. [9],whom criticized one of his pair of free fields because its supposed mathematical inconsistency. Th e authors proposed furthermore a new pair of correct transform ations for the same problem. In this work both Lapenta G. G.N. et al. po- sitions will be examined and a new and more general choice will be proposed by me, who will show that a 'critical condition' exist for the flux function Ps,so that this general choice be a both choices are not only mathematically coherent but the more general choice cited above include any possible set of rea- sonable transformations, leading in this way to a more form of the NLSE [6]. All the analytical considerations will be made for the case Lapenta'swork, therefore in the equatorial plane or in the (x,y)framework; in this case zis a negligible variable. A brief mention to the 'moment method' in general NLSE exam- ined in the paper of Garc' ia-Ripoll, J.J. and P' erez-Garc' ia, V.M. [6]will be done in the next paragraph. 2 From GSEs to a pseudo-general form of the NLSE - stationary tion functionals of the free fields in the GSEs which leads to a form of the NLSE in the stationary case (steady - state case), showing that this choice include both Lapenta G. G.N. et al. choices and putting in evidence that the same choices are compatible with one Equations set The GSEs set, in the more general form for a fully ionized plasma (ne=Zni), can be derive by both the Euler Equations in the ideal limit for the ions and the electrons in a two-fluid treatment and the Ampere's Law; in this respect, we take the two-fluid equations M.J. (2.2) whereMis the rate of loss of electron momentum, per unit volume, by collisions with ions; neglecting electrons and ions inertia ( (2.2), we lead to p=JxB (2.3) being the current this point the calculus is the same of Lapenta's work. Assuming a planeframework is madeonthe (2.4) The Ampere's Law lead by the (2.4) delivers, being za negligible (2.5) If we use the current density expression (2.5) and the solution (2.4 ) in (2.3), we obtain the (2.6) Observing that equation (2.6) is made of two parts linearly indepen- dent among them, from this one it follows the equations represents the ' equivalent GSEs set 0 (2.8) where the equation (2.7) derives = 0 (2.9) The equations (2.7) and (2.8) are the vectorial-scalar form system of the GSE for the ideal equilibria in framework and they lead to a fundamental 2nd- order PDEs system for searching the steady-state solution of th . 62.1.1 Canonical form of the GSE We can observe that the canonical form of the GSE derives from the system (2.7),(2.8) as it follows: by the equation (2.7) we (2.10) because PsxBzis on the zaxis; this one delivers a linear depen- dence between PsandBzas it follows Ps =a(Ps,Bz)Bz (2.11) where we suppose that ais a rational real functional of PsandBz defined in Dom(Ps)Dom(Bz); therefore we obtain by the (2.12) this one means that Bzandpare linearly dipendent among them, or they are co-axial vectors; furthermore, by applying Psxto this one, we (2.13) which means that Psandpare necessarily linearly dependent as in (2.10); thus determines Ps =b(Ps,p)p (2.14) where we suppose that bis a rational real functional of Psandp defined in Dom(Ps)Dom(p); now, we can observe that (2.14) lead to the differential (2.15) where we suppose that /hatwideDis a real differential functional general integral of (2.15) can be written (2.16) whereFbis a real functional dependent on bwhat is defined in wehave adifferential equa- tion equal (2.17) where we suppose, as above, that /tildewideDis a differential functional de- pendent on a;a general integral of (2.17) therefore can be (2.18) whereFais a real functional dependent on aand it's defined in ohma; now, -0is the unit vector for both Bzandp, from (2.12) it 0 which lead to 2Ps taking in account (2.16) and (2.18) in this one, we obtain finally the GSE in canonical form 2Ps which we can recognize an Helmholtz Equation. In this one we suppose 0 because the flux function Pshas not any pole inside the ohmaohmb. 2.2 A general choice in the complex plane for the free fields A pseudo-general form of the NLSE show at first view a more great complexity than an ordinary cubic NLSE cited in Lapenta's paper but on the other hand its mathematical morphology is affected by a more general set of solutions, which can represent a wide-spectr forthe research of explanations in thephysical fram e- work for the above equilibrium structures. Furthermore, the gen eral 8form of the NLSE cited below includes both Lapentachoice [8] et al. choice [9] (this last leads to a in this way, several specialized choices set for a same phys- ical problem can be put in a more general mathematical solving context from the point of view of the related non-linear problem. In this case, such a strategy therefore permits us to define a valid va y for to find a more general possible solving method for a GSEs set in object, working in the framework of the solitonic solutions as in the interesting idea of Lapenta. A pseudo-general form of the NLSE, in the time-dependent case, can be represented as it follows [6] iPs t= (2.21) wherePsis a complex function, 3is the Laplace operator in the (x,y,z)space framework and both gandsare supposed to be time- dependent potential complex functionals of |Ps|2.It's remarkable the fact that this equation is named 'pseudo-general' because the fun as is usually .However, it's clear that (2.21) can be put 'always' in a form in which gandslead to a pair of Indeed gPs+isPs = ( =
= obviously real functionals. In the stationary case, this equation leads to the steady-state = 0 (2.22) which is, as we see, a more general form of the Helmholtz Equation; it can be viewed as = 0 a complex-valued function. This non-linear PDE therefore repre- sents the fundamental link between the GSEand the pseudo-gene ral NLSE in the stationary case for a In the two-dimensional framework (x,y),that is the frame- work in which we analize the localized accretion plasma structures, we have therefore the differential = 0that is 2 2Ps (2.25) 9At this point, we observe that an appropriate choice for the free fields in the GSEs can permit the translating of such in a certain form of the NLSE, as the general stationary form (2.22), which could be an excellent solution for re-interpretat e localized structures in the accretion discs as 'solitonic as viewed by the Helmholtz Equation. Indeed we'll see that a general transformations set for the free fields pandBzcan lead from the equations (2.7) and (2.8) to the equation (2.25) by an appropriate expression for the 2function on the same to observe that the 'analiticity' of the complex function Psis not required for solving the Helmholtz Equation in general [7]. Furthermore ,I cite that the 'moment method' [6] can be used as a valid approximation analytical way for to solve a wide family of non-linear wave equations of NLSE type in its pseudo-general form ; this method have been developed for n-dimensional cases in genera l byGarc' ia-Ripoll, J.J. andP' erez-Garc' ia, V.M. . So, it's remarkable that by this mathematical approximation strategy it could be possible to identify a good set of physically coherent solutions of the GSE for the equilibrium problem, i.e. as we would like. 2.2.1 Connection between GSEs and a pseudo-general form of t replacing the free fields pandBzin the equation (2.8) with this relations we obtain Fb(Ps) =0 obviously for the linear dependence of delivers Fb(Ps) +Fa(Ps)Fa(Ps) =k(Ps)Ps =-2PsPs =0 (2.27) which is 2Ps+k(Ps) = 0 is exactly the Helmholtz Equation, in which we suppose that kis a generic functional of Ps; if we compare the second equation 10in (2.27) with the Helmholtz Equation (2.25) and we consider the expression (2.24), then we obtain indicates that kis a complex functional and Psis clearly a complex function by the equation (2.27), because by this one it derives 2Ps =-k(Ps) 0 (2.29) At this point, taking into account the Lapenta et al.'s works [8], [9] and starting from their fields choices, I found a well posed pair of transformation functionals like (2.31) wherePsis the complex conjugate function related to the complex flux function Psandaij,bijare complex constants ;we observe that (2.30) and (2.31) are respectively a term proportional to the mag- netic force density and the pure hydrodynamical pressure force den- sity, which are two 'real' physical variables; this is for me a funda- mental physical condition and it's important that it doesn't affect the complexity of the flux function Ps;we will explore this in the next section as a 'validity condition' for (2.30) and (2.31). From these transformations and the first equation in (2.26 ) it =k(Ps)Ps (2.32) which together with (2.28) delivers k(Ps) .30), (2.31) lead from equations (2.7),(2.8) to the pseudo-general form 11(2.25) of the NLSE in a space framework (x,y)by the of the second equation in (2.29), we will proof below that, ifPsis a complex be put in the both gandsaresupposed to becomplex functionals asabove. In this regard ,we consider the expression at left hand side of (2.34) in if we develop the sum, we obtain the next identities deliver a complex polynomial functional on |Ps|2i.Now, we 'impose' the complexity of the flux function Ps (Im(Ps) C)and we write (2.38) 12whereuandvaregenericreal-valuedfunctionsinthe (x,y);from this one and (2.36) we which we used the 'Newton binomial formula' and binomial coefficients. At this point, we fix the maximum level Nof the polynomial sum in (2.39) and we observe a new complex polynomial functional; from (2.40) therefore 'even'; in clear complex form this one (2.41), it delivers finally the next expressions for the are clearly two complex functionals on the square on the uandvfunctions; they are complex because the presence of the complex coefficients gilin the above expressions. If the level of the polynomial sum Nis odd, we have similarly the complex observe that in these expressions the maximum level of poly- nomial sum on i-index is not fixed, leaving in this way the choice of dependence of the above functionals on the even powers of the function |Ps|2completely free. Such a dependence can be imposed on the base of mathematical or physical criteria which are well defined if they are related to a specific physical 1 it's clear that the general choice (2.30),(2.31) and Throumoulopoulos et al. [9] choices; indeed for the first choice we have a00=a2 0, aij= 0i,j >0 bij= (1,1) (2.45b) while for the second choice we have a00=a2 0, aij= 0i,j >0 bij= (0,3) (2.46b) 3 Validity conditions in the mathematical and physical frameworks In this section we explore the validity conditions for the general choice (2.30),(2.31) from the physical and mathematical points of view. We observe that these conditions are named ' critical condi- tions' in the present paper because they are 'necessary' conditions for the acceptability, or internal coherence, of the proposed ma the- matical models, which are analized in respect of a related reasonable link between the mathematical framework and the physical the analysis of these theoretical positions will take into account necessary and sufficient conditions too for the valid- ity of unique solutions for the proposed. 3.1 On a critical condition for the general choice: mathe- matical aspects We consider the general choice for the free fields pandBzin the GSEs set (3.2) with aij,bijC and for to establish a validity condition for the internal mathemati- cal coherence of these transformation functionals, we apply the op- eratorxat the both sides of (3.1),(3.2), as in the al.work [9], taking into account that they are 'similar' except for the coefficients sets for this reason, it will be sufficient therefore to consider for both relations the appropriate, and to reduce in normal form (3.4) for to identify a validity condition which is unique for both At this point the calculus is quite simple: starting from the expression (3.4) we obtain for (3.1) and =0(x,y)ohmaohmb the 'scalar' functions pandB2 z.If we proceed in the calculus the linearity of vectorial product; taking in account the vecto -a) =ax- -a-- -axawithaas a scalar variable, we have therefore (we remember that Psis a scalar =0(x,y)ohmaohmb a complex polynomial functional of finite degree on Psand|Ps|2.As we can see, the equation (3.6) has the 0 (3.8a) PsxPs =0 (3.8b) The (3.8a) solution functional equation has no solutions for an 'ar- bitrary' flux function Ps,because the terms PsiPsjinside it are for this reason it derives, taking in account 0 this means that the functional equation (3.8a) cannot represent a necessary condition so the equation (3.5) is verified; at this point it's clear that the unique 'critical condition' for the of the general fields choice for an arbitrary flux funct ion Psis PsxPs if we impose the complexity of this function (Im(Ps)C)and we write therefore (see position (2.38)) Ps(x,y) we obtain, starting from the equation (3.8b), 0C=PsxPs =(u+iv)x(u-iv) = (u+iv)x(u-iv) 0C=0+i0); in this way, the condition (3.8b) is equivalent to the condition uxv=0,or PsxPs =0C= have therefore the 'critical condition' (which is a 'necessary con - dition') for both real and imaginary parts of (3.9) 17so the equation (3.6) is verified; an expansion in a (x,y)of theoperator finally leads to the critical PDE for the real functions the = 0(x,y)ohmaohmb (3.10) At this point, it's clear that the differential equation (3.10) is the unique necessary condition for an arbitrary complex flux function Ps so thegeneral freefields mathe mat- ical coherent choice for the equilibrium problem in object; further- more, it's remarkable that this condition doesn't imply the analitic- ity of the function Ps;indeed, if the analiticity is requested in functions uandvmust be C- differentiable in the domain L the Cauchy-Riemann conditions must be valid in L;these deliver for = 0(x,y)L (3.11) while for vwe have = 0(x,y)L (3.12) and it's clear that the differential equations (3.11) and (3.12) are specific cases which are included in the differential equation (3.10). Usefully ,we note that if the complex flux function Psis in the Gauss form Ps(x,y) (3.13) the critical condition (3.9) must (3.14) Let us observe that if we impose the analiticity of the flux function in the equilibria domain (ohmaohmb)*, the Helmholtz problem (2.27) 2Ps+k(Ps) = 0 the functional equations system 2Ps = 0 (3.14.1) k(Ps) = 0 (x,y)ohmaohmb (3.14.2) these equations destroy obviously the related NLSE-problem but they represents also a not-banal question from the closely funct ional point of view, because the equation (3.14.2) must be satisfied only in a 'sub-domain' ohmaohmbof the entire domain Dom(Ps);indeed these domains are subject to the free in this way the choice of the not-bound portion of means that a certain family of Ps functions which satisfy the equation (3.14.2) can be identified as
/tildewidePs =h(ohmaohmb) = it means also that this family must depend only on the pos- sible forms of the flux functions inside the complementary because the (3.14.1), we can note can be possible to define a family of this functions family is related obviously to the solutions set of the 0(x,y)ohmaohmb (3.14.3) At this point, it's remarkable that this equation necessarily deliv- ers the above not-trivial solution for Ps,because there is the (3.14.4) which can be justified by observing that the equilibria domain does not concern in general the entire framework of the equatorial pla ne in the accretion disc unlike Ps. Let us note that in our specific case the solutions set of the (3.14.3) is not trivial because the general equation scenario (3.14.3 ) assume the particular to the expressions (2.43a)-(2.44b). It's clear that this ca se is generally independent of the condition (3.14.4). It's important too, in conclusion, to observe that the canbepresent onlyinside asub-domain condition (3.14.4) is valid,giving sense in this way to the in the related space regions; hence, it's necessary that th fortheplasma differentia l Helmholtz = ohm, taking for this 2 The critical condition (3.9) is identically satisfied for th et al. transformations [9], while for the Lapenta [8] we have that the above condition remains vali d in its general form, leading to a free choice for the real flux functi onsu andv,which in this case are related only to the bond equation (3.10 ). This is because in the second choice is present a term equal to Ps, while this one there is not in the first choice. Such situation means that both choices represent coherent transformation model s but th et al. choice is mathematically more strong from this consideration clearly doesn't derive tha t the choice (2.45a),(2.45b) is less valid than the choice (2.46a ),(2.46b). It's important instead that this observation reconciles in this way the results of the above 3 One of the solutions for the equation (3.6) us note that this functional equation has not a trivial so lution if we consider an appropriate family of flux functions /hatwidePsas we did above in a similar problem; in this way, we could obtain anoth er valid critical condition on the Psfunction for the general fields . An idea is to study the character of the function al an appropriate choice of the constants set {cij}i,jN, cijC,tak- ing into account that it must On a reality condition for the free fields: physical as- pects In previous section we talked about a plausible physical for the general choice (3.1),(3.2), saying that the 'reality ' 20of the terms proportional to the magnetic force density and the p pressure force density inside it can be a fundamen condition doesn't affect the complexity of the flux function Ps; indeed these terms are the two 'real' vectorial physical variables, by the free fields (3.16) which must be for to determine this reality condition for the above force den - sities, we Im(p) =0 (3.18) and taking the polynomial functional (3.15) and (3.16) we obtain B2 z= (3.20) which are different only for a factor 2.At this point, for the valid- ity of both (3.18) relations, it's sufficient obviously to analyze (3.21) For this one, taking in account that Ps(x,y) let us calculate in clear complex form the have = =
21= =
= delivers for the condition (3.22) where the form of the functions sandgis derived by the it's clear that (3.22) represents a necessary an d suf- ficient condition for (3.21) and furthermore it leads to the 'new' critical (3.23) It's important to observe that this one is the same of the from the mathematical point of view, which can be found in (3.9); this means that the critical condition (3.23) ia a condition' for both the mathematical and physica l aspects of the coherence for the transformation functionals (3.15) ,(3.16). Now, if we note that the generic solution choosed in a plane framework (x,y)for the magnetic induction field is (by the reasonable to think that it must be for a complex Ps,as in the conditions (3.18), Im(B) =0(x,y)ohmaohmb (3.24) which delivers necessarily 0= = Im(/hatwidezxPs) = =
= (3.25) this condition leads to below vectorial differential equation by the expansion of the operator means v x=v y= 0 or v=0(x,y)ohmaohmb (3.26) 22At this point it's indispensable to observe that if the of the flux function Pshas a zero gradient in common condition (3.23) is identically verified; so, the only position which can respect a reality condition for all fields in the equilibrium problem, as viewed, is therefore a unique flux for which it must be Im(Ps(x,y)) =v(x,y) = cost (x,y)ohmaohmb (3.27) which delivers finally Ps(x,y) =u(x,y)+iA, AR,(x,y)ohmaohmb (3.28) 3.3 On a global critical condition for the GS : critical equations system Here we briefly explore a further validity condition for the accept- ability of the general choice (3.1),(3.2). This condition regards the equation (2.8), which leads to a final 'validity equation' if it's re- lated to the common critical condition (3.9) or to the flux (3.27), taking into account the relations (2.11) and (2.14) . If we start from the equation (2.8), we obtain by applying the operator xto both sides of this =0C (3.29) This further condition is obviously a necessary condition for equilibrium problem and it can be translate equationsset: if Ps(x,y) have 0C=2PsxPs =2(u+iv)x(u+iv) delivers the 'critical equations (3.30b) 23Now, if we consider the flux function condition (3.27), we have delivers the unique differential equation for all critical condi- tions 0(x,y)ohmaohmb (3.32) If we consider instead the common critical condition (3.9) obtain by the system (3.33) which delivers, as in (3.32), the differential 0(x,y)ohmaohmb (3.34) taking into account that the condition (3.9) a real functional on this point, it's clear that the conditioning equations (3.32) and (3.34) represent two global critical conditions for the equilibrium problem in the pseudo-general NLSE framework, for which obviously it's true that 0 == the bond equations system Comments In conclusion: we have seen in previous sections that for to ob- tain a pseudo-general form of the NLSE in the stationary case (se e (2.22) in the plane framework (x,y)) by the GSEs set (see the sys- tem (2.7),(2.8)) for a general plasma equilibrium problem in the equatorial plane of an accretion disc, = 0 a set of transformation relations (i.e. the general choice) of the f ree fields in the GSE is imposable in a general form and this the flux function in the solution (2.4) of the problem (2.3) and it's a complex function on the real variables xandy Ps(x,y) which is a solution for the Helmholtz problem (2.25) and it's defined in a specific local not-banal domain (in the accretion disc frame- work) as ohmaohmb;it's clear that the topology of this domain is a very fundamental characteristic of the equilibrium problem, because th e critical condition equation (3.10) must be verified for the mathe- matical coherence of the above fields transformations inside it, = in the vectorial form, therefore it's remarkable that the analiticity of the flux func- tion is not necessary for the validity of the general fields this equation represents a global critical condition for the equilibrium problem from the solitonic point of view, as showed in (3.35). We remember that the critical condition (3.10) is equal to the condition on Ps PsxPs clear at this point that the Throumoulopoulos et al. positions (see (2.45a-b) and (2.46a-b)) about a spec set for the free fields are cannot opposite, bec ause boththese choices satisfy the critical condition (3.8b), which is iden case because however it remains verified for an appropriat e choice of the uandvreal functions inside Bridle, A.H., Hough, D.H., Lonsdale, C.J., Burns, J.O., Laing, R.A., As- tron. J.,108, 766 (1994) [2] Bogoyavlenskij, O.I., Phys. Rev. Lett .,84, 1914 (2000) [3] Petviashvili, V.I. et al., Sov. Phys . JETP55,1056 (1982) [4] Petviashvili, V.I. et al., Sov. J. Plasma Phys . JETP12,545 (1986) [5] Shukla, P.K., Stenflo, L., Pokhotelov, O.A., Physica Scripta Garc' ia-Ripoll, J.J., P' erez-Garc' ia,V.M., 14 Apr 1999 [7] Boyer, C.P., Kalnins, E.G., Miller, W.Jr., Nagoya Math. J. 60,35 (1976) [8] Lapenta, G., Phys. Rev. Lett. 90,135005 (2003) [9] G.N. et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 92,2495001 (2004) [10] Lapenta, G., Phys. Rev. Lett. 92,2495002 (2004) [11] Okamoto, K., Fundamentals of Optical Waveguides (Academic Press, San Diego, 2000) [12] Finn, J.M., Manheimer, W.M., Ott, E., Phys. Fluids ,24, 1336 (1981) [13] Lighthill, M.J., Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London ,252, 397 (1960) [14] Shafranov, V.D., Rev. of Plasma Phys. ,2, 103 (1966) 26
|
0807.1629
|
Michele Romeo
|
Michele Romeo
|
From Grad-Shafranov equations set to a pseudo-general form of the
non-linear Schroedinger equation
|
This paper has been showed in the context of 5th Workshop on
Nonlinear Physics in Gallipoli (2008)
| null | null | null |
nlin.PS
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
In the year 2003 a paper by G. Lapenta demonstrated that there is a new class
of soliton-like solutions for the Grad-Shafranov Equations (GSE).The author
determined an appropriate pair of transformations of the free fields p (fluid
field of hydrodynamical pressure) and Bz (z- component of magnetic induction
field) that leads from the Helmholtz Equation to the Non-Linear Schroedinger
Equation (NLSE) with cubic non- linearity. In the following year (2004), the
work of Lapenta was opposed by G.N. Throumoulopoulos et al.,who criticized his
idea of the field transformations as a mathematically incoherent choice;
contextually the authors suggested a new point of view for this one. In his
response, in the same year, G. Lapenta carried out numerical simulations that
showed the existence of solitonic structures in a Magnetohydrodynamical (MHD)
plasma-context. In the present work I want to demonstrate a critical condition
for a complex poloidal flux function psi in a plane framework (x;y) that leads
to a class of pseudo-general NLSEs which establishes the validity of both
G.Lapenta and G.N. Throumoulopoulos et al. choices for the field transformation
functionals.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 12:51:42 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-11T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Romeo",
"Michele",
""
]
] |
1 Definitions and Notations The graph considered here is finite and undirected and, furthermo re, is con- nected unless it is stated otherwise. In general, multiple edges and lo ops are allowed. Terminology and notation without explicit explanation follows a s from denotedby S, wemeanacompact boundary. It is well known from elementary topology that s urfaces can be divided into two classes: orientable andnonorientable ones. An ori- entable surface can be viewed as a sphere attached hhandles, while a nonori- entable surface as a sphere attached kcrosscaps. The number horkis the surface. A cellular embedding of a graph Ginto a surface S is a continuous one-to-one mapping ph:G-Ssuch that each component of Gph(G) is homeomorphic to an open disc, called a faceofG( with respect to this embedding ph) andphis called a cellular embedding ( orembedding as some scholars called ). A cycle ( curve ) Cin an embedded graph in a called surface separating disconnected. In particular, an open disc, denoted by int( C), thenCis ), and int( C)+C=Int(C) is theinner part ofC. The other part called exterior of Cand is denoted by Ext( C). Recall that the maximum genus gM(G) of a graph Gis the largest integer ksuch that Ghas an embedding in an orientable surface with genus k. Since any graph Gembedded in a surface has at least one face, Euler's formula shows that gM(G)<= b(G) 2, whereb(G) =|E(G)|-|V(G)|+1 is known as Betti number ofG( which is equal to the cyclic number of G). A graph ifgM(G) =b(G) 2. LetGbe a graph and Tbe a spanning tree of G. It is clear that for a unique cycle of G, denoted by CT(e), which is called a fundamental cycle ofG( with respect to the spanning tree TofG). If a pair of edges e1ande2have a common end vertex in a graph G, then we say that the pair anadjacent-edge pair a pair of disjoint subgraphs of G. ThenE[G1,G2] is the set of edges with their ends in by x(G,T) the number of components of GE(T) with an odd number of edges. Then the Betti deficiency of Gdenoted by x(G) is defined as the value minTx(G,T), where the minimum is taken over all A spanning tree TofGis said to be an optimal spanning tree ifx(G,T) =x(G). In the following, the paper is organized as follows: in SS2 we give a (i.e., Theorems 1 and 2) of maximum genus; SS3 will con- centrate on the applications of Theorems 1 and 2 and their refined f orm;SS4 will show that finding the maximum genus of a graph Gis, in some to the problem of finding a maximum matching in a specific gra ph GMcalledthe fundamental intersecting graph ofGand presents an in finding the maximum genus of a graph. 2 A Good 1[6,9] LetGbe a graph, then (1)gM(G) upper embeddable if and only if x(G)<=1. Theorem 1. If a graph Gcontains a spanning tree Tsuch that there exist 2g fundamental cycles fori= be embedded in an orientable surface with genus at least as assumed and e1,e2,***,e2gbe edges in E(G)E(T) such that Ciis the unique cycle in may suppose further that Xuong's constructive proof of maximum genus formula[9]. Let G0=T, Then we have the following. Claim 1. x(G1)<=x(G0) see this, we observe that b(G0) =b(G1)-2, and so, x(G1) x(G0)(mod2 + 2, then we have one of the following situations: (1). Both e1ande2have, respectively, their ends in distinct even ( As shown in left hand side of Fig.1). (2). Both e1ande2have, respectively, their ends in the same even compo- nents inE(G0)E(T) ( As shown in center of oneof two ends in the same even components in E(G0)E(T) ( As shown in right hand side of Fig.1). Without loss of generality, we may suppose that e1e2=ph, and
e1s1 s2e2s3 s4 e1 e2s1 s2 Fig.1s1 s2 s3 e2e1 case e2E[s3,s4], andCibe the fundamental cycle in T+ei( 1<=i<=2 ). Subcase A. C1C2is a edgessuch that e' 1, Nowe' 1, in left hand side of Fig.2).Consider a new spanning tree T'=T+
{e1, e2}-{e' 1, e' 2}.
e2 e1P C1 C2 Subcase B. xe1orxe2, sayxe2. ( As shown in right hand side of Fig.2). If|E(P)| >=1 ,then we take edges e' 1C1E(T), xe' 1, e' 2E(P), x e' 2. We construct a new spanning tree T'=T+{e1, e2} - {e' 1, e' 2}. If|E(P)|= 0, then this may be a special case of A. LetT'be the spanning tree as defined in either subcase A or B. It is easy to see that E(G1)E(T') has at most x(G0) odd components . It is contradictory to our suppose. Therefore We may prove the claims in the cases of (2) and we get x(Gg)<=x(Gg-1)<= *** <=x(G0), 2. LetGbe a connected graph embedded in an orientable surface SgandTbe a spanning tree of G. Then there are at least cycles C1, C2,***,C2g, such that In particular, if Gis a graph in Sg, then for any span- ning tree TofG, there are 2gedges in GE(T)such that the cycles C1, We contract Tinto a single vertex vTand delete all the possible edges on distinct faces. Then we get a vertex-graph GTwith exactly one vertexvTand one face in Sg. There are two crossed loops , sayea, eb, such that the local rotation of semi-edges incident to shown in Fig.3). Furthermore, ebis the only possible edge crossing ea ( since otherwise GTwould have at least two faces! ) . Hence , all ( loop ) edges of GTmay be listed as follows: that 1,2,***,g. It is easy to see that fundamental cycles C2i-1andC2iwith a vertex in common. reb ea ea ebvT
Theorems 1 and 2 give a good characterization of maximum genus of a graph(i.e., they implies the existence of a polynomially bound ed algorithm to find the maximum genus of a 1<=i<=g, then we say cycle pairs (1<=i<=g). Ifgis chosen as the largest above condition, then we call gthemaximum number of cycle pairs ofT. Hence Theorem 2 implies the 3 Any two spanning trees T1andT2in a graph Ghave the same maximum number of adjacent fundamental cycle pairs. ( In fac t , this unique number is gM(G), the maximum genus of G). 5This generalizes a result of Fu et al[2] where they introduced the con graph which is determined by bases of cycle space of a graph to describe the maximum genus of a graph. In fact, our result stands for any spanning tree's fundamental 1 If a connected graph Ghas a spanning tree Tsuch that any two fundamental cycles have a vertex in common. Then Gis however, we need a refined form of Theorems 1 and 2 in pr ac- tice. The following result gives us a recursive relation between the ma ximum genera of a graph and its 4 LetGbe a connected graph and Tbe an arbitrary spanning tree inG. Ife1,e2are two edges not in Gand the two cycles a vertex in common. Then gM(G) =gM(G+e1+e2)-1. In particular, Gis upper-embeddable if and only if G+e1+e2is may easily see that this generalizes a recursive relation for maxim actical in use. 3 Applications Now in this section, we begin to apply Theorems 1 -2 to determine the maximum genus of some type of graphs. Let us recall that the essence of Xuong's method[9] consists of tw o parts: one is to find an optimal tree Tin a graph Ghaving the smallest number of odd components; the other is to organize edges of E(G)E(T) into adjacent pairs such as E(G)E(T) ={e1,e2,***, e2s}{f1, andCT(fi)CT(fj) =ph, for 1<=i m=x(G). Compared with the above 1 and 2 consider adjacent foundamental cycle pairs(ra ther than adjacent pairs of edges). We may construct large genus embeddin g from any spanning tree T, although it may have very large number of odd This greatly releases the conditions of Xuong. Of course, an optimal tree is also valid in our constructions. Hence, Theorems 1 an d 2 6generalize Xuong's characterization of maximum genus. Based on th is Takeaspecific spanning treeTin graph Gand first organize some non-tree edges into adjacent pairs ( as Xuong did ) and then match other possible non-tree edges into p airs such that their fundamental cycles also become adjacent fundam ental cycle pairs. It is easy for one to see that the second part of non-tree e dges may be chosen as an edge-cut of G. Therefor, Theorems 1 -2 may be useful in determination of a maximum genus of a graph Gwith a specific edge-cut. Now, the following result is easy to be 5 LetA={e1, e2,***, ek}be an edge-cut of Gsuch that G-Ahas exactly two components G1andG2. If both G1andG2are then gM(G)>= b(G) 2 -1. Furthermore,if Gsatisfies one of the following conditions , then Gis ) (2).|A| 1(mod2 ). The next result is due to Huang. As a consequence of the above res ults, we will give another proof. Theorem 6(Huang[5]) LetGbe a strongly embedded graph in an ori- entable surface Sg( i.e., all facial walks are cycles ). If the dual graph G*of Ghas a surface separating Hamiltonian cycle, then Gis will show the existence of a spanning tree conditions in Theorems 1 and 2. Let F={f1, f2,***fph}be the face-set of GandC*be a surface separating Hamiltonian cycle in G*. Let E(C*) ={e*
1, (fi,fi+1) for 1<=i<=ph. Leteibe the edge to e*
ifor the boundary of fi). Claim 2. G- {e1, e2,***eph-1}is a one-face embedded subgraph of Gin Sg, Furthermore, G-{e1, e2,***eph}has exactly two components G2] ={e1, e2,***eph}. the boundary cycle of fifor 1<=i<=ph. Then we may construct H0= G-{e1, G).Leteph= (a,b)withaV(G1), exactly two components H', 3. IfH1has a cycle C, thenCmust be a noncontractible cycle. 7This follows fromthefact that Sg-H0hasonly onecomponent. If H1has a cycleC1, then delete an edge e' 1C1and get a subgraph H2ofH1with V(H2) =V(H1). Repeat this procedure until we arrive at a connected =V(H1) andHkhas no cycle. Claim 4: T=H'Hk {eph}is a spanning tree of G, such that each fundamental cycle CT(ei) inT+eihas an edge ephin common for i= 1,2,***,ph-1 . To see this, we consider an edge ei= (xi,yi)[H', Hk][G1, G2], such thatxiH', yiHk. SinceH'(Hk) is connected, there is a path Pi(Qi) in H'(Hk) joining a(b) andxi(yi). Hence, CT(ei) ={eph}PiQi {ei}is a cycle containing ephfor 1<=i<=ph. Now we find a spanning tree TofGsuch that: (1). All the fundamental cycles CT(e1), CT(e2),***, CT(eph-1) has an edge in common; (2). By Theorems 1 and 2, and the fact that Tis also a spanning tree in G-
{e1, e2,***eph-1}, there are another group of fundamental ( cyclesC1, C2,***, C2gsuch that o for 1 <=i<=g. By theorem 1, Gis may readily see that a surface separating cycle may not be Hamil- tonian and the hosting surface on which a graph is embedded may not be orientable. Thus, Theorem 6 can be extended to a much more gener 7 LetGbe an embedded graph in a that the a surface separating cycle C*such that both of the left subgraph GL(C*)and right subgraph GR(C*)ofGare upper embeddable . Then gM(G)>= b(G) 2-1. In particular, if thenGis The term left( right ) subgraph follows from [7] Corollary 2 IfGis an embedded graph on the Klein bottle such that the dual graph G*has a surface separating Hamiltonian cycle. Hence practical use, our attentions need not to be restricted to gra phs with an edge-cut. Theorems 1-4 provide us a tool to evaluating large ge nus em- beddings in more extended range of graphs. The following results sh ow us 8how to do so ( we omit the proof of them ). Theorem 8. The following graphs are The cartisian product GxPnof a simple connected graph Gand a The composition of two disjoint Halin graphs H1andH2with them; (3). The n-cubeQnwhich is composed of two some edges joining the two copies of vertice in Qn-1. (4). The generalized Petersen graphs P(n,k)which is determined by vertices v1,v2,***,vnsuch that (i) each A graph G= (V, E) is aHalin graph ifGis obtained by joining the leaves(1-valent vertices) of a plane tree Twith a cycle in this orientation and the definition of cartisian product of two graphs may be fund in a nd textbook of graph theory. 4 A polynomially bounded algorithm In this section we shall present a polynomially bounded algorithm to fin d the maximum genus of a given graph. A basic fact is that Theorems 1 a nd 2 present a good characterization of maximum genus problem, i.e., we have the 9 To determine the maximum genus of a graph Gis equivalent to determine a maximum matching of the graph GM= (VM,EM), intersecting graph of G, whereVMis the set of of a spanning tree TofGand any two cycles in VMare adjacent if and only if they have at least a vertex in common. We observe that the fastest algorithm to find a maximum matching in a graphGis due to which will end in O(mn) steps, where mandnare, respectively, the number of edges and vertices of G. Based on this fact and Theorems 1 and 2 we may construct a new algorithm t o determine the maximum genus of a graph G. Fundamental cycle algorithm Step 1.Input the date of the graph Gand then searching for a span- 9ning tree Tand the set VMof fundamental cycles in G; Step 2. For cycles in VMwe build the graph GM; Step3 algorithm to finda maximum ma tch- ing inGMand then Since the number of fundamental cycles in a graph Gof ordernis (b(G)), this algorithmwill end inatmost and McGeoch had already construct the first polynomially bou this result is a new approach to do J.A. Bondy, U.S.R Murty, Graph Theory with Application , MacMillan, Lon- don, 1976. [2] Hung-Lin Fu, Hsinchu, M. Skoviera, Bratislava, and M.Ts ai, The maximum genus, matchings and the cycle space of a graph, Csechoslovak Math. M.L.Furst, Findinga maximum- genus 35(1988), 523 - 534. [4] R.Giles, Optimum matching forest I:Special weights, Ma 1 - 11. [5] Y. Huang, Maximum genus of a graph in term of its embedding Math. 262 (2003) 171 - 180. [6] Y.P.Liu The maximum orientable genus of a graph(Chinese with Scientia Sinica, Special Issue on Math.II, , 41-55 (1979) [7] B.Mohar, C.Thomassen. Graphs on Surface , Johns Hopkins University Press ,2001. [8] S.Micali, V.V.Vazirani, An algorithm for finding maximum matching in general graphs. In Proc.21th IEEE 17 - 27 [9] N.H. Xoung, How to determine the maximum genus of a graph, J.Combin. Theory Ser.B 26 (1979) 217 - 225. 10
|
0807.1652
|
Ren Han
|
Han Ren, Hongtao Zhao, Haoling Li
|
Fundamental Cycles and Graph Embeddings
| null | null |
10.1007/s11425-009-0041-7
| null |
math.CO
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this paper we present a new Good Characterization of maximum genus of a
graph which makes a common generalization of the works of Xuong, Liu, and Fu et
al. Based on this, we find a new polynomially bounded algorithm to find the
maximum genus of a graph.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 13:51:17 GMT"
}
] | 2015-05-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Ren",
"Han",
""
],
[
"Zhao",
"Hongtao",
""
],
[
"Li",
"Haoling",
""
]
] |
2 ALIEV N.A., ALIEV =phk(x1), k= 1,2;x1[a1,b1] is a bounded domain convex in the direction x2, the boundary G =-DD- is a Liapunov line, gk(x1),k= 1,2 are the equations of open lines G G), obtained from the boundary G of the domain Dby means of of this domain on the axis x1parallel to the axis x2and [a1, b1] =npx1G1=
npx1G2. In the given boundary conditions (17) ak(k= 1,2) are constants, phk(x1), k= 1,2;x1[a1, b1] are sufficiently smooth functions. Boundary conditions (17) are assumed to be linear independent . Fundamental the Fourier transform to equation (16) we get a fundamen tal solution in the form U(x-x) is a unique symmetric Heaviside function, from (3) we that (3) isa fundamental solutionof thecomposit e type equation (16), we get thatU(x-x) x2is a fundamental solution of the Cauchy-Riemann equation. changes in the fundamental solution of the Cauchy-Rieman n equation [8] we get a fundamental solution in the direction = 1, if none differentiation operation is produced on it, since each addend has a break and contribution of this break appears in d ifferentiation. Thus, for fundamental solution (3) of composite type equation (16) we g et: U(x-x) (6) i.e. it holds the following 1. lsolution in the direction x2is of the form (6).3 This means that if we differentiate U(x-x) twice with respect to x2and twice with respect to the mixed derivatives x1andx2, the Dirac delta function only in the derivative of second order with respect to x2. Necessary equation (16) by fundamental solution (6) and integratin g if in domain D, applying formula [8], we get formula similar to Gr een's second formula that after application of fundamentality properties of fun ction (6) get the xD, 1 2u(x), x I(7) The second expression in formula (7) is one of the necessary condit ions. This condition has the (8) In exactly the same way to [9] and [10], we get the following necessary ALIEV N.A., ALIEV we established the following 2. LetDbe a plane domain convex in the direction x2, the boundary G be Liapunov line, then each solution of equation (16) determined in the d necessary conditions (8)-(12), containing singular integrals b esides it was said above, necessary conditions (9)-(12) contain singula r (5), we x1))+i,k= 1,2, wheresk(x1, x1) is located between x1andx1. Then from (9) - (12) we the sum of non-singular addends are denoted by boundary conditions (17), from necessary conditions (8) for boundary values of the unknown function we get the following regular =u(x1, g2(x1)]U(x1-x1, g2(x1)-g1(x1)) g1(x1)]U(x1-x1, g1(x1)-g1(x1)) exactly the same way, from (13) we g1(x1)) g2(x1)) proceeding from (14) for boundary values of the unknown f unction we get the following regular relation is regular if we interchange the integrals contained in the right h and side of (15) and consider the singular integrals of unknown functions calculated in [11 ]. Thus we proved the following 3. When fulfilling the conditions of Theorem 2 if phk(x1),k= 1,2 are continuously differentiable functions vanishing at the end of the inte rval (a1, b1), then (15) are regular boundary conditions (17), the first necessary condit ion (8) not integrals leads to regular relation (14). Further, proceeding from boundary conditions, after regularizin g two necessary integrals, we getarelationt the form (15). It holds : Theorem 4. When fulfilling conditions of Theorem 3 boundary value problem (16)-( 17) is it is easy to get from (14) and (15) a system of Fredholm integ ral equations of second kind with respect to the unknown functions u(x1,gk(x1)),k= 1,2, in which a kernel may have only weak singularity.6 ALIEV N.A., ALIEV A.M. Unsolved problems. 1.The inverse problem in sense. Let's consider the 0, xD, =phk(x1), k= 1,2;x1[a1, b1],(17) with the following complementary g2(x1)) =ph3(x1), x1[a1, b1] where , , ph1(x1), ,k= 1,3,4 and are the known, u(x),xD ph2(x1) =a2(x1) - are the unknown inverse problem. The above mentioned boundary value problem (16),(17), is given pro videdak, phk(x1), k= u(x),xD g2(x1),x1[a1, b1] are the unknown Courant, R. and Hilbert, D. Methods of mathematical physics, 1 -2 Interscience, 1953 - 1962 2. Bitsadze, A.V. Boundary value problems for second order elliptic e quations, North - Holland, 1968 3. Hadamard, Tohoku, Math., J., vol. 37, pp. 133-150, 1933 4. Hadamard, L'Enseignement Math. Vol. 35, pp. 5 -42, 1936 5. Jurayev T.D On a boundary value problem for a composite type equ ation. DAN USSR, Aliev N.A., Aliev A.M. Investigation of solutions of boundary value pro blems for a composite type equation on abounded plane domain. Dep.AzNIINTI , N688-Az from 03.03.1987, 48 pp. 7. Aliev N. and Jahanshahi M. Sufficient conditions for reduction of t he BVP including a mixed PDE with non -local boundary conditions to Fredholm integral equations, INT. J.Math. Sci. Technol. 1997, vol. 28, N 3, 419-425 8. Vladimirov V.S. Equations of Mathematical Physics, Mir, 1984 9. Aliev N. and Jahanshahi M. Solation of Poisson's equation with globa l, local and non -local boundary conditions, Int. J. Math. Educ. Sci. Technol. 2002, vol.33, N2, 241-247 10. Aliev N., Hosseini S.M. An analysis of a parabolic problem with a gener al (non - local andglobal) supplementary linear conditions I, IIItalian Journa l of Pure and N12, 2002 (143-154), N13, 2003 (115-127) 11. Gakhov F.D. Boundary value problems, Pergamon 1966
|
0807.1697
|
Efendiev Rakib Feyruz
|
N. A. Aliev, A.M. Aliev
|
Investigation of solutions of boundary value problems for a composite
type equation with non-local boundary conditions
|
6 pages
| null | null | null |
math.AP
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Since the order of elliptic type model equation (Laplace equation) is two
[1], [2], then it is natural the order of composite type model equation must be
[3] [4] [5] three. At each point of the domain under consideration these
equations have both real and complex characteristics. Notice that a boundary
value problem for a composite type equation of second order first appeared in
the paper [6]. The method for investigating the Fredholm property of boundary
value problems is distinctive and belongs to one of the authors of the present
paper.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 16:33:25 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-11T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Aliev",
"N. A.",
""
],
[
"Aliev",
"A. M.",
""
]
] |
2 Dame and Thaddeus FIG. 1.-- diagram of CO 1 -0 emission at b= 0from Bitran et al. (1997); this survey is sampled every 7 150 elsewhere) with an 8 :80beam to an rms sensitivity of 0.14 K in 1 :3 km s-1channels. The dashed lines are linear fits to the inclined, parallel lanes of emission from the Near and Far 3-kpc Arms: for the Near Arm v = -53:1+4:16l, for the Far v = +56:0+4:08l. The insert is a schematic showing the approximate locations of the arms over the longitude ranges in which they can be followed clearly in CO. The dotted lines are the limits of the present -120 -80 -40 0 40 80 120 T > (K)MB LSR Velocity atl = 0deg FIG. 2.-- A composite CO spectrum for the Near and Far Arms obtained by averaging the emission in Fig. 1 in narrow linear strips running parallel to the arms, their essentially identical slopes with longitude determined by the linear fits in Fig. 1. The blended regions indicated in Fig. 3 were excluded from the averaging. At negative longitudes the Far Arm in HI is largely blended with emission from both distant gas beyond the solar circle and foreground gas in the inner disk; however, a segment of the Far Arm can be traced in the ATNF survey at l>354. As we required of the Far CO Arm in Figure 1, the Far HI Arm evident in Figure 6 of et al. should be narrow in latitude, and the HI b-v map in Figure 5a shows that indeed it is. Comparison of this map to the CO b-v map in Fig- ure 5b shows that the Far Arm has about the same thickness in both species (see also Table 1). In the positive longitude range included in Figure 5a, it is the Near Arm that is masked in HI by both distant gas beyond the solar circle and foreground gas in the inner disk. In contrast, the Near Arm is seen clearly in CO, because there is little CO beyond the solar circle and be-cause the cloud-cloud velocity dispersion of the CO is lower than that of the HI. To further quantify the properties of the two arms, distances are required. The Near 3-Kpc Arm derives its name from its Galactic radius as estimated by van Woerden et al. (1957) on the basis of an apparent southern tangent at l=-22and the Rvalue of 8.2 kpc then adopted. Subsequent work by Bania (1980), Cohen & Davies (1976), and others a possible northern tangent near l=+23:5. Al- though the locations and even the existence of both tangents are still in doubt, here we adopt tangent directions of 23for the Near Arm on the basis of careful study of our composite CO survey (Dame et al. 2001). With R = 8:5 kpc, these tan- gents imply a radius of 3.3 kpc for the Near Arm, and given its similarity in so many other respects, we assume the same radius for the Far Arm. Although the inclinations of the arms are unknown, here we assume for simplicity that the arm dis- tances vary little along their lengths; thus the Near Arm is at a distance of 5.2 kpc (R -Rarm) and the Far at 11.8 kpc (R +
Rarm). With these distances, H 2and HI masses for the arms can be computed directly from their integrated luminosities in CO and 21 cm. Although little is known about the value of the CO-to-H 2mass conversion factor in these unusual arms, it is reasonable to suppose that a similar value applies to both. Here we assume a fairly standard Galaxy-wide average value of N(H 2)/W CO= 1.8 x 1020cm-2K-1km-1s (Dame, Hart- mann, & Thaddeus 2001). Excluding the regions of blend- ing indicated in Figure 3, the longitude range considered here covers a 1.47-kpc length of the Near Arm and a 3.24-kpc length of the Far. Over these ranges we find that the two arms have H 2masses per unit length that differ by only 26% (TableThe Far 3-Kpc Arm 3 Galactic Longitude W (K km s-1) Galactic Longitude12deg 10deg 8deg 6deg 4deg 2deg 0deg -2deg -4deg -6deg -8deg -10deg -12deg 12deg 10deg 8deg 6deg 4deg 2deg 0deg -2deg -4deg -6deg -8deg -10deg -12deg(a) Far Arm (b) Near Latitude Galactic Latitude 5 10 15 20 25 CO FIG. 3.-- The CO intensity of the Near and Far 3-Kpc Arms. Emission was integrated over a 26 km s-1bin centered at each longitude on the arm velocity given by the linear fits in Fig. 1. Brackets indicate blended and other regions excluded in computing the physical properties of the two arms (see Table 1 and the captions to other figures). The color palette shown below is used in both maps. 0510 -2deg -1deg 0deg 1deg 2deg Galactic -1deg 0deg 1deg 2deg Galactic Latitude(a) Far Arm (b) Near Arm< WCO> (K km s )-1 < WCO> (K km s )-1 FIG. 4.-- Latitude profiles of the CO emission from (a) the Far and (b) Near 3-Kpc Arms, obtained by averaging the spatial maps in Fig. 3 over longitude. The blended regions and two vertical extensions marked in Fig. 3 were excluded. The dotted curves are Gaussian fits. Since the profile of the Far Arm shows high-latitude wings presumably from unrelated the fit for this arm was confined to points at jbj<0:5. 1). HI masses were similarly computed from the ATNF 21 cm survey using a well-defined 4segment of the Far Arm at positive longitudes and a comparable 9segment of the Near Arm at negative longitudes (Table 1). We find that both arms are primarily molecular, the H 2mass exceeding the HI mass in the Near Arm by a factor of 3 and in the Far Arm by a factor of 4 (a conclusion of course sensitive to the adopted CO-to-H 2 ratio). It is worth noting that the Near and Far Arms are found to have almost identical linear thicknesses in H 2and in HI (Table 1). We speculate that the similarity -50 0 50 100 150 200 LSR Velocity (km s -1)Galactic 0 50 100 150 200Galactic I CO(a) (b) LSR Velocity (km s -1)FIG. 5.-- (a) HI map integrated in lfrom 5to 9, a range in which the Far Arm is well separated in velocity from foreground 21 cm emission. Data are from et al. (2005). Colors represent log intensity (K-arcdeg) from gray (1.0) to white (2.5). (b) CO map integrated in lfrom 2to 8, a range in which both the Near and Far Arms are well defined and which overlaps that of the HI map in (a); two of the blended regions indicated in Fig. 3 were excluded from the represent log intensity (K-arcdeg) from gray (0.0) to white (0.8). of the thickness of the HI and CO in the two 3-Kpc Arms, versus the roughly 2:1 ratio found elsewhere in the Galaxy, is the result of the evident absence of star formation in these arms (Lockman 1980), activity that one expects would heat the gas and inflate the HI thickness. The idea that the Milky Way is a barred spiral galaxy can be traced back at least fifty years to Johnson (1957), de Vau- couleurs (1964), and others, and there is now fairly wide con- sensus that we are indeed located in a barred spiral (Binney et4 Dame and Thaddeus al. 1991; Blitz & Spergel 1991; Benjamin et al. 2005). Binney
& Tremaine (2008) in their text Galactic Dynamics state un- equivocally that Our Galaxy is the nearest barred spiral. The delineation here of the predicted two symmetric, expanding 3-Kpc Arms confirms beyond a reasonable doubt that we are located in such a galaxy; further study of these arms should permit better determination of the orientation, size, and other properties of the bar. Had it been possible to detect the Far Arm when van Woerden et al. (1957) discovered the Near Arm, it seems likely that attempts over 50 years to map the structure of the inner Galaxy would have proceeded more rapidly and the properties of the Far Arm are so close to those expected for a far-side counterpart of the expanding 3-Kpc Arm, it is natural to ask how the arm escaped notice for so long. Hints of the Far Arm are evident in even the first large- scale CO survey of the region (Bania 1977; see Fig. 1), but not at a level that would have allowed a convincing case to be made. On the contrary, Oort (1977) cited Bania's survey as evidence That there is no counterpart of the 3-kpc arm behind the center. This view hardened over decades as the so-called
+135 km s-1feature was widely adopted as the only pos- sible far-side counterpart of the expanding arm. The 21 cm surveys with angular resolution adequate to resolve the thin Far Arm have become available only in the past few years (ATNF: et al. 2005, VLA: Stil et al. 2006), and such data for the region within 5of the center have yet to be published. Among the factors that masked the Far Arm in molecular line surveys is the common practice of tracing spi- ral arms with l-v maps integrated over latitude (e.g., Fig. 3 of Dame et al. 2001), which leaves the Far Arm unresolved and confused with foreground emission, and the widespread use of contour maps in the past and color maps at present--both of which can sometimes mask weak, large-scale features. The two parallel lanes obvious in Figure 1 are less apparent in 21 cm data even at high angular resolution, because at the Far Arm is badly blended with emission fromthe outer and inner disks, and at positive longitudes the Near Arm is similarly of the Far 3-Kpc Arm immediately suggests many avenues for follow-up study with existing data, new ob- servations, and theoretical studies. Tracking both arms into the more confused regions outside the longitude range consid- ered here--perhaps to their origins at either end of the bar--is a high priority which we are pursuing. The Far Arm should be detectable in other existing spectral line surveys with adequate angular resolution; even those with relatively low reveal the arm in the manner of Figure 2. CO observa- tions with higher sensitivity and angular resolution are needed to better define the Far Arm, in particular, its angular scale height as a function of longitude, which could help constrain the arm's inclination to our line of sight. Since the Near Arm is known to be deficient in star formation, searches for star for- mation in the Far Arm are of interest. In addition, delineation of the Far Arm will provide a badly needed new constraint for the hydrodynamical models (e.g., Fux 1999; Bissantz, En- glmaier, & Gerhard 2003) that seek to understand the of the central bar and its influence on the gas. In contrast to the controversy that has long to determine the structure of the inner Galaxy, the 3-Kpc Arms together stand out clearly as an symmetric structure. Rougoor & Oort (1960), in one of their first papers on the expanding 3-Kpc Arm, noted that The arm is very well defined, and more homogeneous in density as well as velocity than any of the outer arms. That statement is even more true of the twofold larger structure that we can now trace in the inner Galaxy. We are indebted to T. Bania, R. Benjamin, J. Binney, A. Toomre, and S. Tremaine for highly informative discussions and N. for providing the ATNF 21 cm T. M. 1977, ApJ, 216, 381 Bania, T. M. 1980, ApJ, 242, 95 Benjamin, R. A. et al.2005, ApJ, 630, L149 Binney, J, Gerhard, O. E., Stark, A. A., Bally, J., & Uchida, K. I. 1991, MNRAS, 252, 210 Binney, J., & Tremaine, S. 2008, Galactic Dynamics (Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press), p. 529 Bissantz, N., Englmaier, P., & Gerhard, O. 2003, MNRAS, 340, 949 Bitran, M., Alvarez, H., Bronfman, L., May, J., & Thaddeus, P. 1997, A&AS, 125, 99 Blitz, L, & Spergel, D. N. 1991, ApJ, 379, 631 Cohen, R. J. & Davies, R. D. 1976, MNRAS, 175, 1 Dame, T. M., Hartmann, Dap, & Thaddeus, P. 2001, ApJ, 547, 792 de Vaucouleurs, G. 1964, IAU Symposium 20: The Galaxy and the Magellanic Clouds, ed. F. J. Kerr & A.W. Rodgers (Sydney: of Science), 195Fux, R. 1999, A&A, 345, 787 Johnson, H. M. 1957, AJ, 62, 19 Lockman, F. J. 1980, ApJ, 241, 200 , N. M., Dickey, J. M., Gaensler, B. M., Green, A. J., Haverkorn, M., & Strasser, S. 2005, ApJS, 158, 178 Oort, J. H. 1977, ARA&A, 15, 295 Rougoor, G. W., & Oort, J. H. 1960, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 46, 1 Sanders, R. H., & Prendergast, K. H. 1974, ApJ, 188, 489 Stil, J. M., et al.2006, AJ, 132, 1158 van der Kruit, P. C. 1971, A&A, 13, 405 van Woerden, Rougoor, G. W., & Oort, J. H. 1957, Comp. Rend., 244, 1691The Far 3-Kpc Arm 5 TABLE 1 COMPARISON OF NEAR AND FAR3-K PCARMS Arm d v lcHI dM/d ldz(H (km s-1) (km s-1deg-1) (km s-1) (106Mkpc-1) (106Mkpc-1) (pc) (pc) Near 5.2 -53.1 4.16 19.7 4.8 1.6 101 138 Far 11.8 +56.0 4.08 22.2 3.8 0.9 105 109 aVelocity at l= 0and velocity gradient with longitude from linear fits to Fig. 1 bMean velocity width (FWHM) from Gaussian fits to composite profiles in Fig. 2 cAveraged l=-12to 8, excluding blended regions: l=-1:5to 3:25for Near Arm, -1to 2, 2:75to 3:5, and 5 :25to 5:75for the Far Arm (see over the arm segments best defined in HI: the Near Arm and l= 5to 9for the Far eVertical linear thickness (FWHM); see Fig. 4 for H 2; HI profiles not shown
|
0807.1752
|
Thomas M. Dame
|
T. M. Dame and P. Thaddeus
|
A New Spiral Arm of the Galaxy: The Far 3-Kpc Arm
|
ApJ Letters, accepted 9 July 08
|
Astrophys.J.683:L143-L146,2008
|
10.1086/591669
| null |
astro-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We report the detection in CO of the far-side counterpart of the well-known
expanding 3-Kpc Arm in the central region of the Galaxy. In a CO
longitude-velocity map at b = 0 deg the Far 3-Kpc Arm can be followed over at
least 20 deg of Galactic longitude as a faint lane at positive velocities
running parallel to the Near Arm. The Far Arm crosses l = 0 deg at +56 km/s,
quite symmetric with the -53 km/s expansion velocity of the Near Arm. In
addition to their symmetry in longitude and velocity, we find that the two arms
have linewidths (~21 km/s), linear scale heights (~103 pc FWHM), and H2 masses
per unit length (~4.3 x 10^6 Mo/kpc) that agree to 26% or better. Guided by the
CO, we have also identified the Far Arm in high-resolution 21 cm data and find,
subject to the poorly known CO-to-H2 ratio in these objects, that both arms are
predominately molecular by a factor of 3-4. The detection of these symmetric
expanding arms provides strong support for the existence of a bar at the center
of our Galaxy and should allow better determination of the bar's physical
properties.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 22:53:38 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 23 Jul 2008 18:14:00 GMT"
}
] | 2011-02-11T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Dame",
"T. M.",
""
],
[
"Thaddeus",
"P.",
""
]
] |
2 is used, employing a Cartesian coordinate system. The background metric is denoted by eun, which is defined Heaviside non-rationalized units are used and c= 1 The completely defined such that o0123= 1. II. LIGHT CONE CONDITIONS A. Field equations for one-parameter strength tensor field F(a) unand the gauge field A(a) u are related the structure constant for a com- pact Lie group G. This tensor field can be in terms of the (non-Abelian) electric H(a) ufields the four-velocity of an observer at rest with respect to the laboratory. In Cartesian coor- dinates it is given by Vu=d0 u. In order to alleviate the notation, the 'color' indices in the upper brackets will be omitted in what follows. Let us assume the gauge invariant density of La- grangian as a general function of the Lorentz From the minimal action principle we get the equation of 0. (3) where a comma denotes partial derivatives with respect to the Cartesian coordinates. LFrepresents the deriva- tive ofLwith respect to the invariant F.LFFis the second derivative. Using the relation F,n= 2FabFab,n in equation (3) we 0. (4) The field strength Funmust satisfy the 0. (5) Let us now derive the expression for the light cone con- ditions for this class of theories. B. The propagation of the field disturbances In this section we analyze the propagation of waves as- sociated with the discontinuities of the field [18]. Let us consider a surface of discontinuity S defined by Z(xu) =
0. Whenever S is a global surface, it divides the space- time in two distinct regions U-andU+(Z<0 andZ>0, respectively). Given an arbitrary function of the coordinates, f(xu), we define its discontinuity on S as [f(xa)]S.= P-andPbelong to U+, U-and S respec- tively. Applying the conditions [18] for the tensor field Funand its derivative we set [Fab]S= 0 the discontinuities of field on the surface S and ku.= (o,/vectork) represents the components of the wave4-vector. yields, 0. (9) For the case where fabis the wave propagation tensor given by equation (7b), for which equation (9) applies, it follows (10) wheresis the strength of the wavelet and obrepresents the polarization vector. Working with Eqs. (8)-(10) we obtain the eigenvalue equation Zunon= 0, (11) where we The eigenvectors of Zunrepresent the dynamically allowed polarization modes ( e+,e-). The general solution for the eigenvalue equation is formally given by det|Zub|= 0, and results in the following light cone conditions [2, 4, 0, associated with the wave propagation [2]. The ex- istence of these two solutions shows that may appear, provided that 0. In the formalism of geometrical optics it is usually said that generally there will be two rays inside the medium, the ordinary ray ( o-ray) and the extraordinary ray ( e-ray). The former does not depend on the direction of wave propagation and its velocity is equal to the light velocity in the classical vacuum of electrodynamics. The latter presents an explicit dependence on the direction of prop- agation. The light cone conditions for can be obtained in the same lines. For fur- ther details see Refs. [2, 4].3 III. WAVE PROPAGATION IN THE YANG-MILS FIELD A. The effective Lagrangian The effective Lagrangian for QCD in terms of the pa- rameter background field Fcan be presented [11] in t.= the effective coupling - g(t) is implicitly given (16) withb(g) the Callan-Symanzik b-function and fact, there are many invariants of the Yang-Mills field with the number dependent on the specific gauge group [20]. The ansatz used to derive this effective La- grangian takes in consideration only the algebraic invari- antFand imposes consistency with the trace anomaly for the energy-momentum tensor [21]. For the present proposes the system described by Eq. (15) is assumed to satisfy the following requirements: 1. the volumetric spatial average of the color field strength is independent of direction; 2. it is equally probable that the products at any time, take positive or negative values; 3. there is no net flow of energy as measured by a observer at rest with respect to the system. The abovementioned ar- bitrary quantity Xfor a given instant of time tis defined as X.= andVostands for the time depen- dent volume of the whole space. Similar average solutions [22, 23, 24]. In terms of the color fields, these requirements imply that: Ei= 0,Hi= 0,EiHj-HiEj= (20) where we have defined above average procedure consists in an idealizationto deal with systems like a quark-gluon plasma. Nev- ertheless, it has adequate elements for our the point of view of a statistical ensemble, we can assume that the field average over the whole bulk is van- ishing comparing to the fluctuation, so it is isotropic as whole, while anisotropic for each local area. B. Application to the effective the special Lagrangian presented in Eq. (15), the factorgin Eq. (13) is given (21) where we have defined the phase velocity for the wave perturbation can be obtained from the dispersion relation as the index estands for the e-ray. The o-ray propa- gates with the light velocity, as determined by Eq. (14). Now using the previous results, we obtain v2 e= (24) In order to guarantee causality, the physical solutions must satisfy the requirement 0 <=ve<=1, which (25) From the analysis of the energy density for the effective action associated with this problem, it can be inferred that the case E2> H2leads to a metastability of the vaccum. The interpretation for this behavior is that if a regionin the system developsa large Efield, it will decay fastly to a configuration where H2> E2[11]. Therefore it is adopted here that H2> E2(which means Z2>1 andF >0) and the condition stated by Eq. (25) (26) Now we are going to examine two cases in which The first one is obtained when the regime of small coupling is taken in consideration, and the second one was previously proposed in [25] as a suggestion for the case of large coupling constant.4 For the case of small coupling the beta function can be expanded as [25, 26, 27, 28] b(g) constants. Now, taking the limit of large mean fields ( F- ) we obtain from Eq. (16) (28) Introducing these results in the effective Lagrangian we obtain [11, (29) For this case the function G(-g) results to be G(-g) =-1 21 t+1. (30) Sincet >1 at the large mean field regime we and there will be no propagation asso- ciated with the e-ray. The o-ray travels with the un- perturbed velocity v-= 1 and does not depend on the direction of propagation. The non-perturbative expression for the beta function is still unknown. Nevertheless, a suggestion about the strong coupling form of the beta function was presented long ago [25], and is given by b(g) =-a 2g, (31) withaa positive constant. If we assume this form for the beta function, we obtain from Eqs. (16) and (32) In terms of the parameter tit follows (33) Introducing these results in the effective Lagrangian (34) For this case the function G(-g) results in G(-g) =-1 2a. (35) Thus since a >0 we conclude that G(-g)<0, and again there will be no the e-ray. In the both cases, oncethe superluminal propagationis sup- pressed, the medium allows just one polarization mode to propagate. So it seems to behave like a polarizer.IV. OBSERVABLE FOR BIREFRINGENCE As shown in the previous section, birefringence effects can occur in the Yang-Mills fields. Nevertheless, due to confinement phenomenon, a direct measurement of these effects on gluons propagating in an external color field seems to be improbable. However, deconfined quark- gluon matter, also known as quark-gluon plasma (QGP), is expected to be produced in the Gold-Gold interaction at RHIC or Lead-Lead interaction at LHC. This provides an opportunity to investigate the issue of gluon propaga- tion in QGP systems. The different velocities in which the field disturbances can propagate are associated with different It can be simply understood as a quantum mea- surement on the gluon, by which the gluon fall onto the eigenstate of the polarization mode. In the special cases wherethe e-raygluonis the exter- nal field works like a polarizer, and only the o-ray gluon is allowed there. The polarization is assigned by the ex- ternal field. When one gluon propagates in a QGP, it is 'measured' time and time by the local field. Hence, the last polarization direction before its hadronization into hadrons is completely out of control. This will also de- stroy any global polarization information [35]. correlation will be very strong. A crucial same polarization. In order to explore this point let us consider, for simplicity, a 'gluon plasma'. When the hard parton propagates in the medium, it works as a source of small disturbances on the external field, and could lead to the emission of Cherenkov radiation. The o-gluon can exist within the Cherenkov cone, but the e- gluon must be outside. If the gluon is not confined it can be measured that the polarizations for two gluons inside the cone are parallel. More specifically ^ o1*^o2= 1. The experimental results depend not only on the from the gluon to a certain kind of hadron in hadronization process, but also on the identification of the Cherenkov cone. So, one suggestion is to measure the polarization correlation of two particles of the same kind (2vectormesons, 2 hyperons, etc.) with almostpar- allel momenta and within the same jet cone (when the jet can be identified, as expected in LHC). By studying the correlation dependent on the jet cone angle, one may have a way to measure the Cherenkov angle. One experimental observable for the polarization cor- relation can be suggested. This can be extracted from the ideal case of two L particles with the same the polarization rate. The conventional way to measure /vectorPof a single L is by measuring the direction vector (denoted as ^ p) of the mo- menta of the daughter particles, e.g., proton or pion from the L decay, at the rest frame of L. Then the 1+aPcosth, (36) can give the information on the polarization. Here ais the hyperon decay parameter. From this equation we see that if the direction of /vectorPis random, the averageofall L's gives zero, then Pis not able to be measured. However, for the two L'swith the same polarization, in the rest frame of , the direction vectors ^ p1and
^p2can be measured. Then we calculate the which results in P= (37) Because <^p1*^p2>is a SO(3) scalar, it does not depend on the direction ofpolarization. Thus, it can be averaged for all the jets of all the (QGP) events in order to get the scalar value of averaged polarization from Eq (37). In an experiment, the L pair of the same jet [36] are expected to have the same polarization with larger probability, as discussed above. V. THE EFFECTIVE GEOMETRY a possible way to understand confinement phenomena. One of the possible ways to investigate these in the construction of analogue models in would be related with an event horizon for- mation, as it occurs in the black hole physics. Such a interpretation was considered in [16, 30] (see also the ref- erences therein). The results discussed in this paper can be read in the context of the optical geometry. In this context some comments are in order. Eqs. (13)-(14) can be presented in the appealing form gun
+-kukn= 0, (38) where we defined the two symmetric contravariant (39) gun -=eun. (40) The inverse symmetric tensor gunis defined in such Therefore, for each propagation vec- torkn, the corresponding tensor gunplays the role of an effective metric tensor. Indeed, knis a light-like (or null) vector with respect to the associated metric tensor. Itcan be shown [34] that it also satisfies a geodesic equa- tion in terms of the Christoffel symbols this metric. In this way we can refer to knas a geodesic null vector with respect to the effective This geometric interpretation could be used in order to produce an analogue model for on the possible formation of an event horizon. In this case, the requirement of causal propagation would assume a nontrivial role. Inside the hadron, where disturbances would be expected to be smaller than 1. On the other hand, if the vacuum outside the hadron is described by the effective Lagrangian, the larger than 1 velocity could be interpreted as an indication of con- finement, since no physical observable could CONCLUSIONS In this paper the propagation of field disturbances was investigated in the context of the effective The general dispersion relations for one- parameter Lagrangians, Eqs. (13) and (14), were the method presented in [2, 4]. It was shown that birefringence phenomena can occur. Let us remark some points. First, it should be stressed that the method depends on the effective Lagrangian as L(F), so the conclusions are quite general. Second, the assumption of causal propagation of the signals sets non- trivial constraint when exploring specific solutions. Fi- nally, for the case of a deconfined quark gluon system, which naturally provides an effective external field, phenomena with gluons and its local po- larization effects are expected to be observed at RHIC and LHC by measuring the strong local spin correlations of various hadrons from QGP. The measurements of the spin correlations suggested here, at the same time, can be useful in assigning the details of the effective fields in QGP. These informations provide opportunities to de- velop the effective Lagrangian framework and hence the better understanding of work is partially supported by the Brazilian re- search agencies CNPq and FAPEMIG (V.A.D.L.); and National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) with grant No.10775090, and China Scholarship Council (CSC) (S.Y.L.). [1] See, e.g., L. Landau and E. Lifchitz, Electrodynamics of Continuous Media, (Ed. Elsevier, 1984).[2] Z. and I. Phys. Rev. D 2, 2341 (1970).6 [3] E. Iacopini and E. Zavattini, Phys. Lett. B 85, 151 (1979). [4] V. A. De Lorenci, R. Klippert, M. Novello and J. M. Salim,Phys. Lett. B 482, 134 (2000). [5] W. Heisenberg and H. Euler, Z. Physik 98, 714 (1936). [6] G. L. J. A. Rikken, and C. Rizzo, Phys. Rev. A 63, 012107 (2000). [7] S. L. Adler, J. Phys. A 40, F143 (2007). [8] S. Biswas and K. Melnikov, Phys. Rev. D 75, S. I. Kruglov, Phys. Rev. D 75, 117301 (2007). [10] G. K. Savvidy, Phys. Lett. B 71, 133 (1977). [11] H. Pagels and E. Tomboulis, Nucl. Phys. B 143, 485 (1978). [12] H. B. Nielsen and M. Ninomiya, Nucl. Phys. B 156, 1 (1979). [13] E. V. Shuryak, Nucl. Phys. B 203, 93 (1982). [14] J. Ambjorn and P. Olesen, Nucl. Phys. B 170, 60 (1980). [15] J. Ambjorn and P. Olesen, Nucl. Phys. B 170, 265 (1980). [16] P. Castorina, D. Kharzeev and H. Satz, Eur. Phys. J. C 52, 187 (2007). [17] J. C. Collins and M. J. Perry, Phys. Rev. Lett. 34, J. Hadamard, in Le, cons sur la propagation des ondes et les ' equations de l'hydrodynamique (Ed. Hermann, G. Boillat, J. Math. Phys. 11, 941 (1970). [20] R. Roskies, Phys. Rev. D 15, 1722 (1977). [21] J. C. Collins, A. Duncan, and S. D. Joglekar, Phys. Rev. D 16, 438 (1977). [22] R. C. Tolman and P. Ehrenfest, Phys. Rev. 15, V. A. De Lorenci, R. Klippert, M. Novello, and J. M.Salim,Phys. Rev. D 65, 063501 (2002). [24] K. E. Kunze, Phys. Rev. D 77, 023530 (2008). [25] D. J. Gross and F. Wilczek, Phys. Rev. Lett. 30, H. D. Politzer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 30, 1346 (1973). [27] D. R. T. Jones, Nucl. Phys. B 75, 531 (1974). [28] W. E. Caswell, Phys. Rev. Lett. 33, 244 (1974). [29] H. B. Nielsen, Phys. Lett. B 80, 133 (1978). [30] M. Novello, V.A. De Lorenci, and E. Elbaz, em Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 13, 4539 (1998). [31] see, e.g., Z. T. Liang and X. N. Wang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 102301 (2005). [32] B. I. Abelev et al. [STAR Collaboration], Phys. Rev. C 76, 024915 (2007). [33] B. I. Abelev et al. [STAR V. A. De Lorenci and R. Klippert, Phys. Rev. D 65, 064027 (2002). [35] One of the examples is that originated from the non- central interaction, as suggested by the Shandong Group [31]. Corresponding to those cases, the phenomenon sug- gested here appears as a 'local polarization'. Hence this local polarization destroys the information of the global one and itself is not measurable if we simply take the average in the experiment. The STAR Collaboration of RHIC has recently measured the global polarization ef- fect [32, 33]. From the above discussion, it seems very natural to adopt the negative results from STAR, still with confidence that both of the polarization effects can exist. [36] If the jet is not defined it can be considered the near- parallel pairs of the same kind of hyperon.
|
0807.1755
|
Shi-Yuan Li
|
V.A. De Lorenci and S.Y. Li
|
Propagation of field disturbances in the Yang-Mills theory
|
6 pages in revtex, version to appear in PRD
|
Phys.Rev.D78:034004,2008
|
10.1103/PhysRevD.78.034004
| null |
hep-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The propagation of field disturbances is examined in the context of the
effective Yang-Mills Lagrangian, which is intended to be applied to QCD
systems. It is shown that birefringence phenomena can occur in such systems
provided some restrictive conditions, as causality, are fulfilled. Possible
applications to phenomenology are addressed.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 10 Jul 2008 23:08:59 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"De Lorenci",
"V. A.",
""
],
[
"Li",
"S. Y.",
""
]
] |
2 Yasuo Y. Suzuki, Masayuki Tokita, Sada-atsu Mukai: Kinetics of water
ow through polymer gel gel 1. Experimental setting of water
ow measurements of gel and the water has been measured by
owing the water through the gel [4,5,6]. In this paper, we present experimental results on the water
ow through the gel, and show that the time evolu- tion of the water
ow through the gel is described satisfac- torily by the collective di usion model of polymer network with water friction. The information on the kinetics of wa- ter
ow in the gel will help the better use of them in Experiment 2.1 Water
ow measurements The experimental setting of the water
ow measurements is illustrated schematically in Figure 1. A thin circular slab gel of thickness, L, is set in a tube and the rim of the gel is glued to the tube. The surface of the gel at the lower reaches side is mechanically xed to the end plate through an O-ring. When the small pressure, P0, is applied to the water from the upper stream side of the gel, the water
ows through the gel deforming the polymer network of gel by the drag force. The macroscopic value of the of the gel, f, is determined from the velocity of the water
ows out of the gel in the equilibrium state, v1, as f=P0 v1L: (2) Even though the concept is simple, the of the friction coecient between the poly- mer network of gel and the water is not easy because the friction of the gel is huge. The diculty of evaluating the friction coecient measured from the water
ow through the gel is described in the reference [4]. In our experiments, the diculty is overcome by using a well calibrated homo- geneous glass capillary to amplify the velocity of water as shown in Figure 1. The position of the meniscus of water in the capillary is measured as a function of time after the pressure is applied to the water. Fig. 2. Apparatus for water
ow measurements: (a) the up- per photograph shows the external appearance, (b) the shows the inside of the end plates. The photographs of the apparatus used in this study are given in Figure 2. The essential structure of the appa- ratus is the same with the previous one but some points are improved for the precise measurements of the friction of the gel [4]. The right hand side of Figure 2 (a) is the upper stream side and is connected to a water column to apply the hydrostatic pressure. The glass capillary is set at the top of stainless steel pipe which can be seen at the left hand side of Figure 2 (a). Leak of water around the gel is prevented by setting O-rings inside the cell as shown in Figure 2 (b). All parts of the cell is made of stainless steel to avoid the mechanical deformation due to the The mechanical deformation of the apparatus is considerably reduced compared to the previous one. 2.2 Mechanical response measurements The mechanical response of the polymer gel relates the friction coecient to the collective di usion coecient of the polymer network as Dc==f Here,is the longitudinal modulus of the gel and K andare the bulk modulus and the shear modulus of the gel, respectively. We measure two elastic moduli of the and the longitudinal modulus of the gel is determined from them. The rod shape gel is elongated in water at a strain of about 10 % and the stress is measured. The size of the gel is observed by using a microscope during the to obtain the Young's modulus of the gel,Yasuo Y. Suzuki, Masayuki Tokita, Sada-atsu Mukai: Kinetics of water
ow through polymer gel 3 E, and the Poisson's ratio, . The longitudinal modulus of the gel,, is determined from the Young's modulus and the Poisson's ratio by and
=E=2(1 +). In this short time experiments, the water solvent nei- ther goes out nor comes into the gels. Thus we determine the mechanical response of the gel independently from the friction experiments by the water
ow. We use the results to analyze the kinetics of water
ow through the Sample The samples used in this paper are poly(acrylamide) gel that is obtained by the radical of the main-chain component, acrylamide, and the The concentration of the gel used in this measurement is 1 M. and are used as the initiator and the accelerator. All chemicals used here are of electrophoresis grade, purchased from BioRad and used without further purication. The gel for the fric- tion measurements is prepared in the circular gel mold, where the gel-bond lms (FMC) with circular opening are glued on the both sides. For the friction coecient mea- surements, the gel is prepared in the measurement cell and kept under water at a constant room temperature for overnight to reach the equilibrium state. For the elastic modulus measurements, the rod shaped gels are prepared in the capillary. The desired amounts of the main-chain component, the cross-linker, and the accelerator are dissolved into the distilled and which is prepared by a Mili-Q system. The pre- gel solution is de-gassed for 20 min, and then the desired amount of the initiator is added to the solution to initiate the reaction. The sample gels are taken out of the reaction bath and then washed by distilled and de-ionized and used in each measurement. 3 Experimental results 3.1 Friction coecient of gel The experimental results of the measurement of water
ow through the gel are shown in Figure 3. The position of the meniscus in the capillary of 10 lglass micro-pipette is plotted as a function of the time elapsed after the appli- cation of the pressure to the water. The slope of the
ow curve, thus obtained, represents the water velocity in The velocity of the
ow is high at rst. Then it eventually decreases with time and approaches to an equilibrium value. The equilibrium state is attained about 5 to 7103s after the pressure is applied to the water. The velocity of the meniscus in the equilibrium state is de- termined by the least-squares analysis of the linear portion of the
ow curve in Figure 3, typically in the time region more than 1104s, that yields to v0 1= 1:910 7m/s. The velocity of water
ow in the gel, v, is then 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 Time ( 10 s)4Position (mm) xFig. 3. Position of meniscus in capillary t by equation (19) withaandbas adjusted parameters. from the velocity of the meniscus, v0, with the ratio of the radius of the circular opening of the gel mold, R, and that of the capillary, r, asv=v0(r=R)2. The values of Rand rare measured as 1.745 mm and 0.268 mm, equilibirium velocity of water
ow in the gel is, thus, calculated as v1= 4:410 9m/s. The pressure applied to the water is P0= 2:9103N/m2, which corresponds to the height of water column of 30 cm, and the thickness of the gel is L= 1:010 3m. From these values, the friction coecient of the gel is calculated by equation (2) that yields to f= 6:61014N s/m4. This agrees with a typical value of the friction coecient of the gel evaluated by other experiments [4]. 3.2 Elastic modulus of gel In Figure 4, we show the concentration dependence of the Young's modulus and the Poisson's ratio of the gels used in our experiment. The least-squares analysis of the results yields that the concentration dependence of the Young's modulus of the gel is well described by a power law rela- tionship with a scaling exponent of 1.7, which is slightly smaller than the value expected from the scaling argument [21]. The Poisson's ratio is about 0.45 in the dilute gels. It decreases with the concentration of the gel and reaches to about 0.35 at higher concentration region. The values of the Poisson's ratio of the dilute gels are close to those of the incompressible materials. On the other hand, the val- ues of the Poisson's ratio of the dense gels are rather close to those of the metals and the glasses. The Young's mod- ulus and the Poisson's ratio of the gel at a concentration of 1 M is observed as E= 1:3104N/m2and= The longitudinal modulus is then calculated as= 4:1104N/m2for the gel at a concentration of 1 M. Our results are consistent with previously ratio of poly(acrylamide) gels and a theory [24, 25].4 Yasuo Y. Suzuki, Masayuki Tokita, Sada-atsu Mukai: Kinetics of water
ow through polymer gel 104105 0.7 1 2 3 5E ( N/m )2 0.30.40.5 0.7 1 2 3 5 Concentration (M)S Fig. 4. Concentration dependence of elastic moduli: (a) the upper graph shows Young's modulus, E, (b) the lower graph shows Poisson's ratio, . The di usion coecient of the polymer network is de- duced from equation (1) as Dc= 6:210 11m2/s, which agrees with a typical value of the di usion coecient of the transparent poly(acrylamide) gel evaluated by [8,20,22,23]. 4 Kinetics of water
ow through gel When the water
ows in the gel (polymer network) by the application of the mechanical pressure, the polymer network of gel deforms from the initial position by the drag force of the water
ow. We introduce a that represents the displacement of a point in the polymer network from its initial position at x. We assume uis always small compared to the characteristic size of the gel,L. Under the present denition, u(x;t) = 0 at t= 0. We also assume that the macroscopic velocity of the water in the polymer network, v(t), and coecient, f, are uniform in space.
@v
@x= 0: (3) Then, we write down the equation of motion of the poly- mer network and that of the water in the gel as
gu= f( _u v) +@2u
@x2; (4)
w_v=f( _u v) @P
@x; the density of the polymer network and that of the water, respectively; A dot over the variable denotes the time derivative; P(x;t) represents the pressure inside the region that the gel occupied. By neglecting the inertia terms in equations (4) and (5), we 0; (6)and f(v _u) = @P
@x: (7) A set of equations (3), (6), (7) corresponds to one dimen- sional case under a limit of small polymer volume fraction
!0 of a general description for 3 dimensional deforma- tion of gels[26,27]. In our experimental setup of water
ow measurement in Fig.1, we see P(x= 0;t) =P0andP(x=L;t) = 0. Taking a spacial average of equation (7) over the space the gel occupied, we (8) The time evolution of water
ow in the gel v(t) is deter- mined locally from u(x;t) by v= _u Dc@2u
@x2: (9) Here, we use the collective di usion coecient of the gel, Dc, dened in equation (1). The displacement of is, hence, determined by solving the (10) In the equilibrium state, _ u(x;t)!0 ast!1 . The restoring force due to the deformation of the polymer net- work is in balance with constant gradient of the pressure. In the equilibrium state, therefore, equations (3), (6), (7), (8) (11) The displacement, u(x;t), satises the following = 0; (12)
@u(0;1)
@x= 0: (13) Integration of equation (11) with respect to xwith the boundary conditons yields u(x;1) (14) Solving equation (10) under the above boundary con- ditions, we obtain the displacement, u(x;t), as (See (16) v1=P0 Lf: (17)Yasuo Y. Suzuki, Masayuki Tokita, Sada-atsu Mukai: Kinetics of water
ow through polymer gel 5 The velocity of the water
ow, v(t), is derived from equa- tion (7) as v=v1 1 + is the elliptic theta function. The position of meniscus is expressed (19) wherebis the initial position, and a=R r2 v1: (20) 5 Discussion Now we compare the experimental results with the the- oretical predictions by equations (18) and (19). The val- ues obtained by the experimental measurements are, L=
1:010 3m,= 4:1104N/m2, andf= 6:61014 Ns/m4, respectively. By applying these values into equation (16), we obtain the characteristic relaxation time = 1:6103s. The equilibrium velocity of water
ow in the gel observed by the experiments is, as is already given in the section 3, v1= 4:410 9m/s. From equation (14) the deformation of gel is estimated as 3.5% which is consistent with our assumption of small u. The time evolution of the water
ow is then calculated by equation (18) with above experimental values. The re- sults are given in Figure 5. The normalized velocity of the water
ow in the gel is also calculated from the slope of the
ow curve in Figure 3 and shown in Figure 5. We nd that the time evolution of the velocity of water
ow in the gel is well explained by the equation (18) with a relaxation time . However, there is a slight discrepancy in the time evo- lution curve of the velocity at a short time range ( <200s) between the theory and the experimental results as one can see in gure 3 and 5. The absolute value of the equilib- rium velocity determined from the short time data ( <200s) of the friction experiment is smaller than that determined by including the long time data. Figure 5 shows that the deference between those two values is roughly 20 %. It would be worth noting that the theory predicts that the water
ow creates a uni-axial deformation of polymer network, i.e., the one dimensional concentration gradient in the gel, proportional to
1 +P0x DcLf: (21) The compression of gel is the cause of the initial rapid water
ow. It is reported that the friction of the home- geneous gel depends on the polymer volume fraction, , 2000 1000 (s)Velocity (m/s)Fig. 5. Water
ow velocity in gel: (a) the solid line corresponds to the theoretical curve tting all the data, (b) the dotted line corresponds to the theoretical curve expected from the short time data ( The friction, therefore, is expected to increase according to the compression of the gel by the water
ow. The increment of the friction may explain the di erence between the short time data and long time data. The di erence between the estimated equilibrium water velocities corresponds to 14 % homogeneous compression of the sample slab gel, which is larger than the deforma- tion which the present theory estimates. cannot measure the deformation of the gel under the water
ow with the current experimental setup. 6 Conclusion The kinetics of the water solvent
ow through the poly- mer network of gel is measured experimentally and de- scribed by a simple phenomenological theory. The exper- iment shows that the equilibrium state is reached after long time and that the friction of the gel shows a large value. The time evolution of the velocity of the water
ow in the gel is calculated on the basis of the collective di u- sion model of the polymer network coupled with the water friction, assuming both the water velocity and the between the polymer network and the water are uniform in the gel. The theory reproduces the time evo- lution of the water
ow of the experiments for thin dilute gel fairly well with a single characteristic relaxation time. We are able to deduce the collective di usion coecient from the water
ow experiment on gels. However there is a di erence between of the equilibrium velocity and the value expected from the theoretical calculation by using parameters ob- tained from the short time
ow measurements and the6 Yasuo Y. Suzuki, Masayuki Tokita, Sada-atsu Mukai: Kinetics of water
ow through polymer gel mechanical measurements. It suggests that the inhomo- geneity of the friction and the concentration of the gel un- der the water
ow might be important for the kinetics of the water
ow. A better microscopic model is required for complete understanding of water
ow through gel beyond the phenomenological understanding presented in this pa- per. This work was rst suggested by the late Professor Toyoichi Tanaka in 1989 during the stay of Y.Y.S. and M.T. in Mas- sachusetts Institute of Technology. Y.Y.S. thanks CEA, IPhT and Takushoku University, RISE for the nancial support. M.T. thanks NEDO for the nancial A: Solution of the equation of motion We dene a function W(x;t) as a deviation from the equi- librium +u(x;1): (22) We obtain an equation for W(x;t) from equation (10) (23) By assuming W(x;t) =X(x)T(t), the equation (23) be- comes
_T(t) = 2DcT(t); (25) whereis a constant. The general solution for W(x;t) would be W(x;t) +A0x+B0: (26) The boundary conditions for W(x;t) 0; (28) u(L;t) = 0 !W(L;t) = Z vdt: (29) The boundary condition (27) +Bn(n1)] 0:This indicates Bn= 0. The boundary condition (28) indicates that the constant, 2 n, should be positive,
2 n>0 forn1 andA0=v(1). Finally, the (29) yields W(L;t) exp( 2 nDct) indicates CnA= cosnL. The following relation- ships forBn,2 n, andCnAare obtained: Bn= 0; (30)
2 n>0; (32) AndW(x;t) becomes W(x;t) of this solution (33) into equation exp( 2 nDct): (34) The rst term of the left handed member (LHM1) is writ- ten as follows: LHM1 second term of the left handed member (LHM2) is expressed as follows: LHM2 Y. Suzuki, Masayuki Tokita, Sada-atsu Mukai: Kinetics of water
ow through polymer gel 7 The rst term of LHM2 is expressed second term of LHM2 the equation (34) is reduced exp( 2 nDct) = 0: This = ( 1)n: (36) The solution, W(x;t), can be now written as W(x;t) the initial condition is W(x;0) (38) the coecients, An, are determined by the Fourier (40) The displacement, u(x;t), is now determined as u(x;t) and nare given (42) qn=n
L; T. Tanaka, Sci. Am. 244, 124 (1981) 2. A.H. Muhr, J.M.B. Blanshard, Polymer 23, 1012 (1982) 3. M. Tokita, T. Miyoshi, K. Takegoshi, K.Hikichi, Phys. Rev. E53, 1823 (1996) 4. M. Tokita, T. Tanaka, J. Chem. Phys. 95, 4613 (1991) 5. M. Tokita, T. Tanaka, Science 253, 1121 (1991) 6. M. Tokita, Adv. Polym. Sci. 110, 27 (1993) 7. T. Tanaka, S. Ishiwata, C. Ishimoto, Phys. Rev. Lett. 38, 771 (1977) 8. T. Tanaka, D.J. Fillmore, J. Chem. Phys. 70, 1214 (1979) 9. E.S. Matsuo, T. Tanaka, Nature 358, 482 (1992) 10. M. Tokita, S. Suzuki, K. Miyamoto, T. Komai, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 68, 330 (1999) 11. J. I. Maskawa, T. Takeuchi, K. Maki, K. Tsujii, T. Tanaka, J. Chem. Phys. 105, 1735 (1999) 12. T. Takigawa, K. Uchida, K. Takahashi, T. Masuda, J. Chem. Phys. 111, 2295 (1999) 13. M. Tokita, K. Miyamoto, T. Komai, J. Chem. Phys. 113, 1647 (2000) 14. T. Takigawa, T. Ikeda, Y. Takakura, T. Masuda, J. Chem. Phys. 117, 17306 (2002) 15. A. Boudaoud, S. Chaieb, Phys. Rev. E 68, 021801 (2003) 16. L. Urayama, S. Okada, S. Nosaka, H. Watanabe, K. Taki- gawa, J. Chem. Phys. 122, 024906 (2005) 17. S. Nosaka, S. Okada, Y. Takayama, K. Urayama, H. Watanabe, T. Takigawa, Polymer 46, 12607 (2005) 18. M. Yoshikawa, R. Ishii, J. Matsui, A. Suzuki, M. Tokita, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. Part 1 44, 8196 (2005) 19. A. Suzuki, M. Yoshikawa, J. Chem. Phys. 125, T. Tanaka, L.O. Hocker, G.B. Benedek, J. Chem. Phys. 59, 5151 (1973) 21. P-G. de Gennes, Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, London, 1979) 22. J.P. Munch, S. Candau, J. Hertz, G. Hild, J. Phys. (Paris) 38, 971 (1977) 23. J.P. Munch, P. Lemarechal, S. Candau, J. Phys. (Paris) 38, 1499 (1977) 24. T. Takigawa, K. Urayama, and T. Masuda, Polymer J. 26, 225 (1994) 25. T. Takkigawa, Y. Morino, K. Urayama, and T. Masuda, Polymer J. 28, 1012 (1996) 26. T. Yamaue, M. Doi, Phys. Rev. E69, 041402 (2004) 27. M. Doi, Dynamics and Patterns in Complex Fluids , edited by A. Onuki and K. Kawasaki (Springer, New York, 1990), p.100
|
0807.1789
|
Yasuo Y. Suzuki
|
Yasuo Y. Suzuki, Masayuki Tokita, Sata-atsu Mukai
|
Kinetics of water flow through polymer gel
|
7 pages, 5 figures, 27 references, Eqs added
| null |
10.1140/epje/i2009-10494-6
| null |
cond-mat.soft cond-mat.mtrl-sci
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The water flow through the poly(acrylamide) gel under a constant water
pressure is measured by newly designed apparatus. The time evolution of the
water flow in the gel, is calculated based on the collective diffusion model of
the polymer network coupled with the friction between the polymer network and
the water. The friction coefficient are determined from the equilibrium
velocity of water flow. The Young modulus and the Poisson's ratio of the rod
shape gels are measured by the uni-axial elongation experiments, which
determine the longitudinal modulus independently from the water flow
experiments. With the values of the longitudinal modulus and of the friction
determined by the experiments, the calculated results are compared with the
time evolution of the flow experiments. We find that the time evolution of the
water flow is well described by a single characteristic relaxation time
predicted by the collective diffusion model coupled with the water friction.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 11 Jul 2008 08:16:43 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 13 Nov 2008 13:19:23 GMT"
}
] | 2015-05-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Suzuki",
"Yasuo Y.",
""
],
[
"Tokita",
"Masayuki",
""
],
[
"Mukai",
"Sata-atsu",
""
]
] |
1 functions of the spin-1/2 XXZ spin chain have at tracted much attention in mathematical physics for more than a decade [1, 2, 3]. The mul tiple-integral of XXZ correlation functions were first derived in term s of the q-vertex operators [4]. Based on the algebraic Bethe ansatz method, the determi nant expressions [5] of the scalar products and the norms of Bethe ansatz eigenstates we re reconstructed in terms of theF-basis [6], and then the XXZ correlation functions are deriv ed under an field [7, 8]. The representatio ns at zero temperature have been extended into those at finite temperature [9]. Furthermore, dynamical structure factors have been evaluated by solving the Bethe ansatz equations nu merically [10, 11, 12, 13]. The Hamiltonian of the spin-1/2 XXZ chain under the periodic boundary conditions is given are the Pauli matrices defined on the jth site, and the XXZ coupling. By = ( q+q-1)/2 we define parameter q, which plays a significant role in the paper. We note that Ldenotes the number of the one-dimensional lattice sites. So generalizations of the XXX and XXZ chains have b een constructed by the fusion method in several references [14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19]. For instance, the Hamiltonian of the solvable spin- sXXX chain is given by the following operators of spin sacting on the jth site and Q2s(x) is a polynomial of degree 2s Q2s(x) (1.3) Herexl= [l(l+ 1)-2s(s+1)]/2. AtT= 0 in the critical regime, it is discussed that the low-excitation spectrum of the spin- sXXX chain is described in terms of the level- k SU(2) WZWN model where k= 2s[20]. In the present paper we derive exact expressions of scalar pr oducts and form factors for the integrable higher-spin XXZ spin chains. Here differen t spins can be mixed. We first show that the monodromy matrix of the XXZ spin chain has t he symmetry of the affine quantum group Then, we derive the exact expressions taking advantage of the quantum group symmetry. By a similarity transformati on [21], we transform the symmetric R-matrix into an asymmetric one, which is directly connected to the We derive projection operators from the asymmetric R-matrices [19], and construct integrable higher-spin XXZ spin chains by the fus ion method similarly as the case of the XXX spin chain [14]. Here we make an extensive use o f theq-analogues of Young's projection operators, which play a central role in t heq-analogue of the Schur- Weyl reciprocity of the quantum group Uq(sl2) [22, 23]. Hereafter, we call theR-matrix gauge transformations. After we construct integra ble higher-spin mod- els, applying the inverse transformation to them, we reduce the asymmetric into those of the symmetric L-operators constructed from the symmetric R- matrices, and thus obtain scalar products and form factors f or the integrable in the standard factors and correlation functions have been discussed for integrable higher-spin XXX models in previous researches [24, 25, 26, 27]. In the app roach of the so-called quan- tum inverse scattering problem for the integrable N-state models, one has to matrix in order to express local operators in term s of the However, it seems to be technically nontrivial t o construct the matrix for the integrable higher-spin systems (see a lso [28]). By the approach of the present paper, the calculational task is much reduced in to the minimal level. In fact, as a consequence of the q-analogue of the Schur-Weyl duality, the exact expressions of scalar products and form factors are derived from the formul as of the spin-1/2 XXZ chain by setting the inhomogeneous parameters in the form of comp and the most general results are obtained. The affine quantum-group invariance has another important co nsequence. In the XXZ case we can explicitly prove the forms of the algebraic Bethe-ansatz method through the quantum-g roup symmetry. Here we remark that the XXZ spin chain has no spin SU(2) symmetry. In t he the BandCoperators are expressed as sums of local spin operators by diagonal matrices, respectively, where each of the local spin operators s+- i are defined on one lattice-site, i.e. on the ith site. The forms of were conjectured in the algebraic Bethe-ansatz d erivation of the XXZ correlation functions [6, 7, 8]. In fact, the Boperators create the Bethe states are conjugate to them, and the ed forms play a central role in the calculation of the scalar products and the norms o f Bethe states. They are also fundamental in the quantum inverse scattering problem , by which local operators BandCoperators. an explicit derivation of the e d forms of the not been shown previously, yet. Thus, the explicit deriv ation in the paper completes the algebraic Bethe-ansatz formulation of the form factors and correlation functions of the integrable XXZ spin chains. Here we remark that for the XX X case (i.e. the isotropic case), the diagonalized forms have been shown by Maillet and Sanchez de Santos in Ref. [6] by making an explicit use of the rotational SU(2)-symmet ry. However, the method for the XXX case does not hold for the XXZ spin chain which has no SU (2) not only theoretically interesting but also practically useful for calculation. Here we remark that the symmetry, was realized for the infinite XXZ spin chain with the q-vertex operators [2, 4]. Thus, it should be an interesting o pen problem how the affine quantum-group symmetry of the finite XXZ spin chain can be re- lated to that of the infinite XXZ spin chain. Furthermore, the re are several advantages in 3the present formulation of the affine quantum-group symmetry . We derive the symmetry through gauge transformations. The transformed asymmetri cR-matrix is directly related to the quantum group Uq(sl2) so that we can systematically construct higher-spin repre - sentations of the R-matrices through the q-analogue of the Young symmetrizers. Here we should note that the gauge transformation connects the Rmatrix in the different gradings of The symmetric and asymmetric R-matrices are equivalent to that of the prin- cipal and homogeneous gradings, respectively (see for inst anceSS5.4 of [2]). Moreover, we thus avoid technical difficulties appearing when we directly derive the matrix representa- tion of the universal R-matrix of the affine quantum group, which is given by a product of infinite series of generators [30]. Although one can const ruct matrix representations of the modified universal R-matrix with its derivation ddropped [30, 22](see A.2 of [31]), it seems that the calculation is not quite straightforward w hen we construct results of the present paper should be useful for calcula ting exact expressions instance, the t2model in the N-dimensional nilpotent representation corresponds to the integrable spin-( N-1)/2 XXZ spin chain with qbeing a primitive Nth root of unity [32]. Here we remark that the t2model is closely related to the N-state Potts model. Furthermore, there are several possibl e physical applications, such as calculating form factors of quantum impurity models thro ugh the result in the case of mixed spins. As an illustrative example, we have calculat ed exact expressions for nchains, a subsequent paper. The content of the paper consists of the following: In sectio n 2, we introduce the symmetric R-matrix of the spin-1/2 XXZ spin chain, and define the monodro my matrix [33]. We also define the action of the symmetric group on produ cts ofR-matrices. In section 3 wederive thesymmetry of thequantumaffine algebra f orthe the XXZ spin chain. We introduce the asymmetric R-matrix and then derive it from the symmetriconeby a gauge transformation. We decomposeth easymmetric R-matrix in terms ofthegenerators algebra, ands how Wealso deriveit by asystematic methodfor expres singproductsof in definition 3. In fact, all the fundamental rela tions of the quantum problem can be derived much more simply without u sing the ^R-matrix of Ref. [6], Insection 4weconstructt heRmatrices of XXZ spin chains with projection operators of Uq(sl2) by the fusion method. We also discuss the case of mixed spins. In section 5 we formul ate an explicit derivation of the forms of the B-operators. We also show it for the C-operator in Appendix E. In section 6 we derive determinant expression s of scalar products for the higher-spin XXZ spin chains. In section 7, for the higher-sp in cases we show the method bywhich wecan expresslocal operators intermstheglobal op erators. We of the quantum inverse scattering problem for the h igher spin case. Finally, we derive some examples of form factors for the integrable high er-spin XXZ spin and L-operators 2.1 Symmetric R-matrix We shall introduce the R-matrix for the XXZ spin chain [33]. We consider two types of R-matrices, Rab(u) andRab(l,u). TheR-matrix with a single rapidity argument, Rab(u), acts on the tensor product of two vector spaces VaandVb, uis independentof VaorVb. TheR-matrix with two rapidity acts on the tensor product of vector spaces with parameter s,Va(l) us denote by ea,bsuch a matrix that has only one nonzero element equal to 1 at entry (a,b). We denote by Vthe two-dimensional vector space. We define the R-matrix acting on the tensor product VVby R(u) (2.1) Here matrix elements Rab cd(u) satisfy the charge conservation, i.e. Rab cd(u) = 0 unless a+b=c+d, and all the nonzero elements are given by the =R22 22(u) = 1, R12 12(u) =R21 21(u) =b(u), R12 21(u) =R21 12(u) =c(u), (2.2) where functions b(u) andc(u) are given by b(u) c(u) (2.3) Here, parameter eis related to qof = (q+q-1)/2 byq= exp(e). We now acting on the Lth power of tensor productof vector spaces with parameters, V(l1)*** V(lL). We generalize the notation of (2.1). Let us take a pair of integers jandksatisfying 1 <=j < k<=L. For a given set of matrix (a,b,c,d= 1,2) we define operators Aj,k(lj,lk) andAk,j(lk,lj) by Aj,k(lj,lk) the two-by-two unit matrix, and Ijandea,b jact on the jth vector space In terms of matrices we express operators Aj,kandAk,jforj < by the symbol [ j,k] we express that matrix element to and to us now introduce operators Rj,k(lj,lk) andRk,j(lk,lj) acting on the tensor product V(l1)***V(lL). We define them by putting Aab cd(lj,lk) =Rab cd(lj-lk) in (2.4). in(2.2). Forinstance, setting u=l1-l2, we have =
1 0 0 0 0b(u)c(u) 0 0c(u)b(u) 0 0 0 0 1
[1,2]. satisfy the Yang-Baxter (2.7) They also satisfy the inversion relations (unitarity condi =ILfor 1<=j,k<=L. the Lth power of tensor product of I. Hereafter we often abbreviate Rjk(lj,lk) simply by and the monodromy matrix Let us introduce parameters x1,x2,...,xL, which we call the inhomogeneous parameters. In the case of the monodromy matrix, we assumethat parameter sljof the tensor product V(l1) *** V(lL) are given by the inhomogeneous parameters, i.e. Let us denote by 0 the suffix for the auxiliary space. We define on the mth site for m= 1,2,...,L, by Lm(l,xm) =R0m(l,xm). (2.9) We define the monodromy matrix acting on the Llattice-sites in one dimension shall also denote it by inSS2.4. Hereafter we often suppress omymatrix as orT0(l). Let us consider two auxiliary spaces with suffices aandb. We define Ta(la) andTb(lb) similarly as (2.10) with 0 replaced by aandb, respectively. It is clear that they satisfy the following Yang-Baxter equati (2.11) Let us introduce operator Ajacting on the jth site (2.12) 6We express it in terms of the matrix notation as express the matrix elements of the monodromy matrix transfer matrix, t(u), is given by the trace of the monodromy matrix with respect t o the 0th = tr we note that the transfer matrix t(u) is nothing but the transfer matrix of the six-vertex model defined on the two-dimensional square latt ice [34]. Hereafter, we shall often denote byB(u;{xj}) orB(u), briefly. 2.3 Products of R-matrices and the symmetric group Let us consider the symmetric group Snofnintegers, 1 ,2,...,n. We denote by san element of Sn. Thensmapsjtos(j) forj= 1. Letpbe a sequence of nintegers, 1,2,...,n, andsan element of the symmetric group Sn. We define the action of sonpby s(p) = (2.16) Here we remark that ( sAsB)p=sB(sAp) forsA,sB Sn. We shall show it in Appendix A. Let us recall that 2. Letp= (p1,p2,...,pn)be a sequence of nintegers, 1,2,...,n. We (2.17) Forp= (1,2,...,n) we thus express the monodromy matrix as (2.19) Here we have assumed that lk=xkfork= 1,2,...,n. Let us express by sj= (j j+1) such a permutation that maps jtoj+1 andj+1 to jand does not change other 3. Letpbe a sequence of nintegers, 1,2,...,n. We define (2.20) For the unit element eofSn, we define Re pbyRe p= 1. For a given element sofSn, by the (2.21) We remark that every permutation sis expressed as a product of some sj= (jj+1) withj= 1,2,...,n-1. We thus obtain Rs pas a product of Rsjpfor some js. For an illustration, let us calculate R(123) (1,2,3). Noting (123) = (12)(23), we of the symmetricgroup Sn[35], we can show that definition 3 is well defined. The proof is given in proposition A.1 of Appe ndix A. Let us denote by scsuch a cyclic permutation that maps jtoj+1 forj= 1,...,n-1 andnto 1. We also express it as sc= (12***n). Noting (12 ***n) = (1 2) ***(n-1n) =
s1s2***sn-1, we can show the following lemma Lemma 4. Let us denote by pqthe sequence pq= (1,2,...,n). Forsc= (2.23) The proof of lemma 4 is given in lemma A.2 of Appendix and permutation operators Let us consider two-dimensional vector spaces VaandVb. We define permutation maps elements of VaVbto those of VbVaas vaVa, vbVb. (2.24) We define VRab(u) by VRab(u) = PabRab(u) (2.25) The operators VRabsatisfy the Yang-Baxter (2.26) The operator VRabgives a linear map from VaVbtoVbVa. IfVaandVbare equivalent, then we may regard VRabas a map from V2 atoV2 a. 8We add 0 to the nintegers. For a given element sof the symmetric group Sn+1, we define Psacting on integers 0 ,1,...,n, as follows. We first express sin terms of sj= (j j+1) such as s=sj1sj2***sjr, and then we define Ps= (2.27) Lemma 5. We have the following relation between R-matrices and operators VRab: R0,12***n= (2.28) 3 The quantum group invariance We shall show that the monodromy matrix, has the symmetry of the affine quantum group, 3.1 Quantum group Uq(sl2)and the asymmetric R-matrices The quantum algebra Uq(sl2) is an associative algebra over Cgenerated by X+-,K+-with the following relations: [31] KK-1=KK-1= 1, KX+-K-1=q+-2X+-, , [X+,X-] =K-K-1 q-q-1. (3.1) The algebra Uq(sl2) is also a Hopf algebra over Cwith =X+1+KX+,(X-) =X-K-1+1X-, (K) =KK, (3.2) and antipode: S(K) =K-1,S(X+) =-K-1X+,S(X-) =-X-K, and = 0 and o(K) = 1. In association with the quantum group, we define the q-integer of an integer nby [n]q= universal R-matrix, R, ofUq(sl2) satisfies the following relations: R(x) a permutation such that t now introduce some notation of a Hopf algebra. Let x(1),...,x(n) be elements of Hopf algebra A. For a given permutation sofSn, we define its action on the tensor product x(1)***x(n) as (3.4) We note that Ahas coassociativity: ( id)(x) = (id)(x) for any element xof A. We therefore denote it by (2)(x). We define (n)(x) recursively by (n)(x) forx A. (3.5) 9Let us now introduce the following asymmetric =
1 0 0 0 0b(u)c(u) 0 0c+-(u)b(u) 0 0 0 0 1 , are defined by c+-(u) (3.7) In the spin-1/2 representation of Uq(sl2), we have the following =t*(x)R+
12(u) for x=X+-,K . (3.8) Here we remark that spectral parameter uis arbitrary and independent of as in the symmetric case, we define the monodromy ma = P12R+(u). Lemma 6. The monodromy matrix expressed in terms of VR's commutes with the action of the quantum group = parameters l,x1,...,xLare independent of element xofUq(sl2). We shall show lemma 6 and eqs. (3.8) through the Temperley-Li eb algebra in SS3.2. Lemma 6 leads to the following symmetry relations of the mono dromy matrix R+
0,12***L with respect to the quantum group 7. Letscbe a cyclic permutation: sc= (01***L). Then we for all parameters l,x1,...,xLare independent of element use of lemma 6 we show (3.10) from (2.28) and the follow ing = Psc(L)(x) (Psc)-1. (3.11) 3.2 Derivation in terms of the Temperley-Lieb algebra Let us define U+- jforj= 0,1,...,L-1, by U+- j=
0 0 0 0 0q-1 0 0-1q+-0 0 0 0 0
[j,j+1]. (3.12) 10They satisfy the defining relations of the Temperley-Lieb al gebra: (3.13) Let us now show commutation relations (3.10), making use of t he Temperley-Lieb al- gebra. The operator VR+
j,j+1(u) is decomposed in terms of the generators of the Temperley- Lieb algebra as follows =I-b(u)U+
j. (3.14) Lemma 8. The monodromy matrix of the six-vertex model is expressed in t erms of the generators of the Temperley-Lieb algebra as (3.15) Lemma 9. The generators U+
jcommute with the generators of Uq(sl2). Forx=X+-,K and forj= 0,1,...,L-1, we have in the tensor-product 0. (3.16) Proof of proposition 7. From lemmas 8 and 9 we have lemma 6, which is equivalent to proposition 7. We now show that in the limit of taking uto-,^R+(u) is equivalent to the spin-1/2 matrix representation of the universal An explicit expression of Ris given expqxdenotes the following (3.18) Hereqis generic. We recall that [ n]qdenotes the q-integer of an integer n: Putting diag(q,q-1) in the series (3.17), we have the following matrix 0 0 0 0 q1/20 0 0 0 q-1/2 . (3.19) 11Thus, for arbitrary u, we have the we have R+(-) remark that some relations equivalent to (3.16) have been shown in association with the sl(2) loop algebra symmetry of the XXZ spin chain at roots of uni ty [37]. 3.3 Gauge us introduce operators Ph jwith arbitrary parameters phjforj= 0,1,...,Las (3.21) In terms of khjk= PhjPhk, we define a similarity transformation on the R-matrix the following two matrix elements are transfor (3.23) We now put phj=ljin eq. (3.21) for j= 0,1,...,L. Forj,k= 0,1,...,L, we = (khjk)1. (3.24) Thus, the asymmetric R-matrices R+- 12(l1,l2) are derived from the symmetric one through the gauge transformation khjk. For the monodromy matrix, in terms of the inhomogeneous para we putlj=xjforj= 1,...,L. We define Ph0Ph1***PhL. Then, the asymmetric monodromy matrices are transformed into the sym metric one as (3.25) We note that the asymmetric R-matrices VR+- j,j+1(u) are derived from the symmetric R- matrix through the gauge transformations, and they are rela ted to the Jones Affine quantum group symmetry The affine quantum algebra Uq(/hatwidersl2) is an associative algebra over Cgenerated by 0,1 with the following 1, 0 algebra Uq(/hatwidersl2) is also a Hopf algebra over Cwith =KiKi, (3.27) and antipode: S(Ki) =K-1 i,S(Xi) =-X- iKi. We now introduce evaluation representations for Uq(/hatwidersl2) [22]. For a given is a homomorphism of algebras such that pha(X+- 0) = exp( +-a)X, pha(K0) =K-1, pha(X+- 1) =X+-, pha(K1) =K. (3.28) We denote by ( p,V) a representation of an algebra Asuch that p(x) give linear maps on vector space Vforx A. For a given representation ( pV,V) ofUq(sl2) we have a representation ( pV(a),V(a)) pha, i.e.pV(a)(x) =pV(pha(x)) forx We call ( pV(a),V(a)) representation atheevaluation IfVis (2s+ 1)-dimensional, then we also denote it by V(2s)(a). Hereafter we express 2 sby an integer l. Similarly as (3.14), we have the following 0,1,...,L-1. (3.29) Lemma 10. Generators U- jcommute with X+- 0andK0in the Forj= 0,1,...,L- 1, we us denote by U-the 4x4 matrix given by the decomposition: VR(u) =I- b(u)U-. Throughan explicit calculation we show that = 0. (3.31) We derive (3.30) through (3.31). In the spin-1/2 representation of Uq(sl2), we thus have the following for we note that uis arbitrary and independent of as lemmas 8 and 9, we have from lemma 10 the quantum- group symmetry of the monodromy matrix 11. Letscbe a cyclic permutation: sc= (01***L). In the (3.28) we have, for x=X+- 0,K0, the parameters l,x1,...,xLare arbitrary and independent of x=X+- 0,K0. Let us now make a summary of the symmetry relations of R+
12. Here we recall For simplicity, we put a= 0 in (3.33). Combining (3.8) and (3.32) We have the following 0,1. (3.34) Let us now consider pha1pha2withaj= 2ljforj= 1,2. We relations (3.34) are now expressed as (3.36) all the parameters are now associated with the eval uation parameters of the tensor product V(2l1)V(2l2). Therefore, we conclude that the asymmetric satisfies the affine quantum-group symmetry. The fundamental commutation relations (3.10) and (3.33) ar e summarized as 12. Letscbe a cyclic permutation: sc= (01***L). The asymmetric the commutation relations for the affine-quantum gr for all x (3.37) Here the symbol (x)01***ndenotes the matrix representation of xin the tensor product of evaluation representations, Symmetry relations of all permutations Let usgeneralize relations (3.37). Making an extensive use of relations (3.36), wecan show commutation relations for Rs pfor all permutations s. In fact, we can prove (3.37) also by the method for showing proposition A.2. In Appendix A we shal l show in proposition A.2 how we generalize the symmetry relation of R12such as (3.36) into those of Rs pfor any permutation s. 14We now formulate the symmetry relations in terms of the symme tricR-matrices. Let us denote by - khthe inverse of the gauge transformation kh. We express 13. Letpqbe an increasing sequence of n+1integers: pq= permutation on n+ 1integers, 0,1,...,n. With the symmetric R-matrices, for all x(3.39) 4 Projection operators and the fusion procedure 4.1 Projection operators Let us recall that VR+
12(u) has been defined by VR+
12(u) = P12R+
12(u). We define operator (4.1) Explicitly we have P+
12=
1 0 0 0 0 1
[12]. (4.2) By making use of the matrix representation (4.2) it is easy to show that operator (4.3) Thus, we may consider that the operator P+
12is a projection operator. In fact, P+
12is nothing but the q-analogue of the Young operator which projects out the spin- 1 represen- tation of Uq(sl2) from of the tensor product of two spin-1/2 representations . It should be noticed that in the case of symmetric R-matrix, R(e)2is not equal to R(e). We now introduce projection operators for the spin- sirreducible representations of Uq(sl2). Hereafter we set l= 2s. We define projection operator on the tensor product V12***lof spin-1/2 representations V, i.e.V12***l=Vl, by the use of the Yang-Baxter equations (2.26) and through i nduction on lwe operator P(l) 12***lgives aprojection operator. Similarly, n operators acting on we shall abbreviate idempotency (4.5) and by the Yang-Baxter equations we c an show the following: Lemma 14. Suppose that inhomogeneous parameters given 1,2,...,lwith a constant z. Then, the monodromy the following (4.7) Making use of (2.28) we can express projection operators in t erms Fusion of monodromy matrices 4.2.1 The case of tensor product of spin- first consider the case of tensor product of spin- We set L=Nsl. We introduce a set of parameters, x(l) 1,x(l) 2, ...,x(l) L, as for j= 1,...l,andk= 1,...,N s.(4.9) Let us set inhomogeneous parameters x1,x2,...,xL, byxj=x(l) jforj= 1,2,...,L. We define the monodromy matrix acting on the tensor product of spin- use of properties of projection operators (4.5) and ( 4.7), we can show the Yang- Baxter equation [ ?, (4.11) 16Through the inverse of the gauge transformation, we derive t he symmetric spin- s monodromy matrix as we have defined the transformed projectors (4.13) 4.2.2 The case of mixed spins Let us consider the tensor product of representations with d ifferent spins, we introduce ljbylj= 2sjforj= 1,2,...,r, and we assume that l1+l2+***+lr=
L. @ Let us introduce a set of parameters, x(l) 1,x(l) 2, ...,x(l) L, as for j= 1,...lk,andk= on the tensor product representation is easy to show that they satisfy the Yang-Baxter equation Higher-spin L-operators We now define the basis vectors of the ( l+ 1)-dimensional irreducible representation 0,1,...,las follows. We define 1,2 denote the basis vectors of the spin-1/2 representation de fined on thejth position in the tensor product. We define (4.19) 17Then we is easy to show the (4.21) We define the conjugate vectors by the following (4.22) with the normalization condition: 1. Let us define the q-factorial, [ n]q!, by [n]q! = (4.23) For integers mandnsatisfying m>=nwe define the q-binomial coefficients as we have the following expression of the conjugate vecto projection operators are given explicitly as (4.26) We define the L-operator of the spin- l/2 XXZ model by L(l+)(l0) (4.27) and then by the inverse gauge transformation we have L(l)(l0) (4.28) Let us define their conjugates (4.29) The matrix elements of the L-operator are given 0,1,...,l. Choosing the normalization factors N(l,n), we can derive the fol- lowing symmetric expression of the in the ( l+1)-dimensional representation of Uq(sl2), andu=l-x1+
le/2 andz= expu. Explicitly they are given 0,1,...,l,. (4.32) 4.4 Algebraic Bethe-ansatz method for higher-spin cases We now discuss the eigenvalues of the transfer matrix of an in tegrable higher-spin XXZ spin chain constructed by the fusion method. We consider the case of mixed spins, where we define the transfer matrix on the tensor product of spin- for j=
1,2,...,r. We define A,B,C, andDoperators of the algebraic Bethe ansatz for by the following matrix elements of the monodromy matr terms of projection operators we operators A(l+)s of the asymmetric monodromy matrix R+
0,12***nare related to the symmetric ones A(l)s as follows from the Yang-Baxter equations (4.16) that the A,B,C,D operators in the higher-spin case also satisfy the standard commutation rel the inverse gauge transformation - khwe we derive Bethe ansatz eigenvectors of the highe r-spin transfer matrix by the same method as the case of spin-1/2. Let us denote by vacuum state where all spins are up. (4.38) it is easy to show the following andd(l)(l;{zk}) are given by a(l)(l;{zk}) = 1, d(l)(l;{zk}) the vector an eigenvector of the transfer with the following rapidities ~lj=lj+e/2 satisfy the Bethe ansatz of the Diagonalizing the The ized formsof the XXZ case, we briefly formulate some symbols and review some useful formulas shown in Ref. [6] in SS5.1. First, we introduce the F-basis . 20Definition 15. (Partial Fand total F) We define partial (5.1) We define total Frecursively with respect to (5.2) Lemma 16. (Cocycle the F-basis in terms of R-matrices through (5.1), we show that the cocycle conditions of the F-basis are reduced to those of the R-matrices, which are shown in Appendix B. From the cocycle conditions we have the following: Lemma (5.4) 5.1.2 Basic properties of the R-matrix Let us introduce some important properties of the R-matrix of the XXZ is invariant under the charge conjugation. For the s ymmetric R-matrix, we define the charge conjugation operator (5.5) For a given operator we define For instance, we define 18. The charge conjugation operator Ccommutes with the monodromy ma- trix of the symmetric R0,1***n] = 0 (5.7) We thus have -A1***n(l0) 19 (Crossing symmetry) .TheR-matrix has the crossing symmetry given the crossing symmetry is slightly different from [6]. Lemma 20. (Crossing symmetry of the monodromy (5.10) Let us introduce +operation. We shall use it when we e the 21. define n) (5.11) Here we note ( X+)+=X, and (XY)+=Y+X+. It is easy to show R+
12=R21. Lemma 22. Under the +operation the monodromy matrix is given by the (5.12) We define operators 23. Under the +operation the monodromy matrix is given The diagonalized forms of operators AandD Let us give the diagonalized forms of the AandDoperators [6]. The following criterion for the F-basis to be non-singular should be 24. The determinants of the partial and total Fmatrices are given 24 follows from lemma D.1 of Appendix D. We can show the diagonalized forms of operators AandDas follows [6]. Proposition 25 (Diagonalization of 26 (Diagonalization of derivation of the diagonalized forms and some useful for mulas are briefly reviewed in Appendix D. For a given operator we denote (5.20) For instance we have of the Boperator Let us recall that the matrix elements of the monodromy matri xR+
0,1***Lare related to the symmetric ones as from the quantum-group invariance (3.10) we have the f ollowing = generators of Uq(sl2), and (n-1)(X-) denote the tensor-product represen- tation of (n-1)(X-) acting on the nsites from the 1st to nth. We remark that more generally, we have commutation relations (3.39) for the affin e quantum group Inthis subsection weabbreviate thesuperscript+ for theas ymmetric monodromy ma- trix, for simplicity. In fact, the essential parts of formul as such as the fundamental com- mutation relations are invariant under gauge transformati ons if we express them in terms of the generators of the quantum affine algebra Uq(/hatwidersl2) in the evaluation Here we remark that the matrix representation of the evaluation representation can be changed through gauge us now introduce some 27. We define operators 0<=j < =
1 0 0 0 0b-1 kj0 0 1 0 b-1 jk0 1 0 0 1
[jk], We (5.25) We (5.26) Some useful formulas are given in Appendix D. Letusdenote in the tensor-product 28. LetX-denote the generator of the quantum group representation of X-acting on the jth site in the tensor product We use of (D.12) we show We we (5.29) Here we have made use of the = (n-2)(X-) thus obtain the case of nfrom (5.12). 24Lemma 29. In the tensor-product representation (V(1))nwe (5.32) Proof.We show it by induction on n. The case of n= 1 is trivial. Let us assume the case ofn-1. In eq. (5.27), the first term gives the following: Assuming (5.32) putting it into the second term of (5.27), we (5.33) Here we have made use of (5.18). Similarly, we (5.34) Thus, we have the case of nas =X- 1/hatwided1***n 1+(e11 1+e22 1)n/summationdisplay i=2X- 1/hatwided1***n i (5.35) From the fundamental commutation relation (5.22) we have th e following: Lemma 30. In the tensor product (V(1))nwe (5.36) Proof.We transform the both sides of the fundamental commutation r elation (5.22) by F1***n, and put (5.16) and (5.32) into it, we have the 1/parenrightigg [j] 31 ( of Boperator) .We = us denote b0i= andc0i= . Putting 1 -qb01=c- 0iin (5.36) we (5.39) After some calculation, we have making use of lemmas E.1, E.2 and E.3, we can show t he diagonalized form of operator C. Proposition 32. LetX+
idenote the spin-1/2 representation of X+acting on the ith site in the tensor product representation. We forms of the symmetric us show the forms of the BandCoperators of the symmet- ric monodromy matrix R0,1***n. Here we recall that expressions (5.38) and (5.40) respectively. They are matrix elements of the matrix We have the following applying the inverse gauge transformation - khto (5.38) and (5.40), we (5.43) Here we recall c0i= should remark that expressions (5.42) and (5.43) coincid e with eq. (2.29) and (2.30) of Ref. [7], Scalar products formulas 6.1 Formula for higher-spin scalar products Let us consider the case of tensor product of spin- We recall that l= 2s andL=lNs. We introduce parameters x(l;o) jforj= 1,2,...,L, as 1,...l;k= 1,...,N 1,2,...,l) are distinct and nonzero parameters, and ois an arbitrary small number. We also introduce the following P(l) we recall that Boperator acting on the tensor product of spin- isgivenby multiplied by the projection now define the scalar product for the spin- l/2 case as 33. Let{la}(a= 1,2,...,n) be a set of solutions of the Bethe ansatz equations and {uj}(j= 1,2,...,n) be arbitrary numbers. We define the scalar the the centers of lk-strings of the inhomogeneous parameters {xl k}. We calculate the scalar product for the higher-spin XXZ chai ns by the formula in the next 34. Let{la}satisfy the Bethe ansatz equations for the spin- l/2case. The scalar product of the spin- l/2XXZ spin chain is reduced into that of the spin-1/2 XXZ spin chain as = nowcalculate thescalar eq. (4.7) of lemma14as Moreover, wehave =|0/an}bracketri}ht. We thus evaluate the last line through the following limit of send ingoto (6.7) We evaluate the spin-1/2 scalar product taking the limit of s endingoto 0, so that we can make the determinant of FL***21being nonzero. Here we remark that the in the ation process of the BandCoperators, as shown in Section 5, and also that the determinant of FL***21vanishes at o= 0, when parameters xjare given by eq. (6.1). In fact, if we put some inhomogeneous p arameters xjin the form of a complete l-string [29], that is, for some integers l,mand a constant z, 1,2,...,l, then the determinant of FL***21vanishes. Here we also note that det 0 even at o= 0. Let us discuss the mixed spin case. We set the inhomogeneous p arameters as 1,...l;k= 1,...,r. (6.8) Let us define is easy to see the following:
12***L=/an}bracketle{t0|, P(l) 12***L|0/an}bracketri}ht=|0/an}bracketri}ht, P(l) (6.10) We now define the scalar product for the mixed spin case as foll andB(l)(la) abbreviate 35. Let{la}satisfy the Bethe ansatz equations for the mixed spin case. The scalar product of the mixed-spin XXZ spin chain is reduced into that of the spin-1/2 XXZ spin chain as = Determinant expressions of the scalar products Let us review the result of the spin-1/2 case [7]. Suppose tha tlafora= 1,2,...,n, are solutions of the Bethe ansatz equations with in homogene ous parameters the scalar product is defined 1,2,...,nare arbitrary. We note that has been denoted by in the last subsection. Then, the exact expression of the scalar product has been shown through the pseudo-diagon alized forms of the Band Coperators as follows [7]: (6.14) Here the matrix elements Tabfora,b= 1,...,n, are given = 1, d(u;{xj}) (6.17) Let us express the scalar product of the higher-spin case in t erms of the determinant of the matrix T. In the tensor product of spin- l/2 representations we (6.18) In the mixed-spin case we (6.19) 296.3 Norms of the Bethe states in the higher-spin case For two sets of nparameters, u1,...,u nandl1,...,l n, we define matrix elements us assume that l1,...,l nare solutions of the Bethe ansatz equations. We = us now take the limit of sending ujtoljfor each j. Then we = matrix elements Ph' abfora,b= 1,...,n, are given (6.23) Suppose that laforn= 1,2,...,nare solutions of the Bethe ansatz formula for the square of he norm of the Bethe state i s given by Nn({la};{xj}) (6.24) Let us define the norm of the Bethe state for the mixed spin case oflas (6.25) Then we = (6.26) 7 Form factors and the for the higher-spin case 7.1 Formulas of the quantum inverse scattering problem Let us briefly review the derivation of the fundamental lemma of the problem for the spin-1/2 XXZ spin chain [6]. It wi ll thus becomes clear how the ation of BandCare 36. Let us denote by pqsequence pq= (1,2,...,n). Recall the invariant under any permutation. We Sn. (7.1) We shall show (7.1) in Appendix B. The following lemma plays a central role in the quantum inver se-scattering 37. For arbitrary inhomogeneous parameters x1,x2,...,xLwe (7.2) Proof.For any operator x0defined on the auxiliary space, we i.e. now (7.3) 7.2 Quantum problem for thehigher-spi n operators Let us consider monodromy matrix T+
0,1***lNs. Here we recall L=lNs. For simplicity, we shall suppress the superscript '+' for through this subsection. We recall the following: (n-1)(K) =Knand (n-1)(X+) (7.4) It is useful to note that for i= 1,2,...,lN swe (7.5) 31In the tensor product of 2 Nsspin-1/2 we have 12(X-) thelth tensor product of spin-1/2 representations, V(1) 1***V(1) l, we = the tensor product of spin- l/2 representations, V(l) 1 *** V(l) Ns, we have for i=
1,2,...,N sthe following (7.8) Here we have made use of the =IlNs. (7.9) Similarly, we can express (7.10) K(l+) i= Useful formulas in the higher-spin case Let us denote by X+-(l)the matrix representations of generators X+-in the spin- of Uq(sl2). Here we recall that the matrix representations of by calculating the action of (l-1)(X+-) on the basis explicitly calculate the actions of the spin- l/2 representation. Multiplying projection operators to the m, we obtain the following we have for i= 1,2,...,N s, the following advantage of projection operators, we thus have show n that the summation over karising from the ( l-1)th comultiplication operation can be calculated by a sing le term. This reduces the calculational task very much. In the derivation of (7.13), we first (7.15) and then we show the shall show relations (7.12) in Appendix C. We now introduce useful formulas expressing any given opera tor in the spin- Let us take two sets of integers 1 <=i1<
***< im<=land 1<=j1<***< jn<=l, respectively. We can show the 1,i2= 2, ..., im=mandj1= 1,j2= 2, ..., jn=n, we have for m > form < us denote by Emn(l+)the unit matrices acting on spin- lrepresentation We now define Emn(l+) iby the unit matrices acting on the ith component of the tensor product ( V(l))Ns. Explicitly, we have Emn(l+) i= the ( l+ 1)x(l+ 1) identity matrix. Then, we derive the from (7.18), (7.19) and (7.20), respectively. For m > nwe (7.22) Form < nwe have Emn(l+) i (7.23) Form=nwe (7.24) Let us now discuss the derivation of formula (7.17). It is eas y to show the making use of expressions (4.20) and (4.25), we obtain (7.17). 347.4 Form factors for higher-spin operators Making use of the fundamental lemma of the quantum inverse-s cattering problem, lemma 37, together with the useful formulas given in SS7.3 such as (7.13) and (7.14), and (7.22), (7.23) and (7.24), we can systematically calculate form fac tors for the higher-spin cases. Here we note that the form factors associated with generator sS+-of the spin SU(2) have been derived for the higher-spin XXX chains [27]. They are de rived through the to (7.8) and (7.10) in the limit of q= 1. For an illustration, let us calculate the following form fac solutions of the Bethe ansatz equations. Putting (7.13) into (7.26) and making use of the fact that projector with the matrix we us define the form factor in the symmetric case as (7.28) Here we recall that {uj}and{lk}are solutions of the Bethe ansatz equations. Then, we obtain the following = (7.29) Let us define the form factor for we recall that {uj}and{lk}are solutions of the Bethe ansatz equations. Similarly, we can calculate as = the commutation relation between AandBand that between CandD, the vacuum expectation of the product of can be expressed in terms of the sum of scalar products. A Derivation of symmetry relations for Rs p Lemma A.1. Letpbe a sequence of nintegers, 1,2,...,n. For any sA,sB Snwe (A.1) Proof.Let us denote psAibyqifori= 1,2,...,n. We thus = (sAsB)p A.1. Definition 3 is well defined. That is, for relations hold: R(sAsB)sCp =RsA(sBsC) p 1forj= 1,2,...,n, (A.4) Rsisi+1sip =Rsi+1sisi+1p fori= 1,2,...,n-1. (A.5) Proof.We recall that in terms of generators sjthe defining relations of the given by 1,2,...,n-1 ands2 j= 1 It thus follows that definition 3 is well defined if and on ly if (A.4) and (A.5) hold. We now show them. Lemma A.1 leads to conditions (A.4) are derived from the inversion relations ( unitarity conditions) (2.8). Finally we show conditions (A.5) by the Yang-Baxter equatio ns. 36Lemma A.2. Letpbe a sequence of integers 1,2,...,n, 1,2,...,n. Forsc= (12***n)we (12 ***n) = (12)(23) ***(n-1n) =s1s2***sn-1. we A.2. LetAbe a Hopf algebra and Ris an element of A Asuch that R(x) =t*(x)Rfor allx A. Suppose that Ris given by A. We define An. the inversion relations and the Yang-Baxter equati (A.9) then we have the following symmetry A. (1,2,...,n), a sequence of nintegers, and we have defined Rs pqas in definition 3. Proof.Recall that any given permutation sis expressed as a product of generators sj=
(jj+1). We show symmetry relations (A.10) by induction on the nu mber of product gives permutation s. Suppose that (A.10) holds for s=sA. We now show that (A.10) holds for s=sAsj. Making use of eq. (2.21) in definition 3 we (n-1)(x) as (n-1)(x) we have sA*(n-1)(x) now follows from definition 3 that we have Let us denote sAj andsA(j+ 1) by aandb, respectively. Then we have 1. Assuming a < bwe (A.13) Here we note (A.14) since we (-x(j)) where -x(j)are defined by (n-2)(x) therefore (A.15) Symmetry relations similar to (A.10) hold for products of mo nodromy matrices. Let us consider mauxiliary spaces with suffices respectively. We denote the monodromy matrix simply by Ta(j). We denote by (m-1)(T) the following (A.16) Letsan element of Sm. We define the action of son (m-1)(T) by the (A.17) Here -sdenotes the inverse of s: -s=s-1. Then we have the A.3. Letpqbepq= (1,2,...,m). For any s Smwe productsof R-matrices and the F-basis Lemma B.1. ([6]) (i) Cocycle conditions hold for (B.1) (ii) The unitarity relations hold for conditions (B.1) are derived from the Yang-Baxter e n+1integers, 0 ,1,2,...,n, and we express it as ( p0,p) wherepdenotes the subsequence ( B.2. Letpbe a sequence of nintegers, 1,2,...,n. Forsj= (jj+1) (B.3) Proof.We first note Rsjp=Rpj,pj+1. We the Yang-Baxter equations B.1. Letpbe a sequence of nintegers, 1,2,...,n, andsa permutation of thenintegers. We permutation sas a product of generators sj, and applying (B.3) many times, we can show the symmetry relations. We define the action of son theF-basis as B.2. Letpbe a sequence of integers, 1,2,...,n. Fors Snwe (B.8) We also the F-basis in terms of the R-matrices we (B.10) We first show (B.9) with s=sjforj= 1,2,...,n-1, and then we derive it for all permutations s. Lemma B.3. The propagator given by the a cyclic permutation: sc= (12***L), andpqthe sequence pq=
(1,2,...,n). We hence we thus Formulas of the q-analogue Lemma C.1. For two integers landnsatisfying 0<=n<=lwe can show by induction on ltheq-binomial expansion as is now easy to show the (C.3) with (C.2) we obtain formula (C.1). Lemma C.2. The spin- lmatrix representations X+-(l+)of the generators X+-ofUq(sl2) are related to s+
lands- 1, respectively, as the projection operator (C.6) Making use of (C.1) we have
=[n+1] [l], (C.7) and then we obtain (C.4). Similarly, we can show (C.5). D Formulas of the F-basis useful for the us review some points of the diagonalization process of t heAandDoperators [6]. 41Lemma D.1. Operators AandDare upper- and lower-triangular matrices, the eigenvalues of operators AandDare given can show it by induction on n. Noting we show diag( D1***n= We can show (D.2) similarly. Lemma D.2. The partial expressed as (D.4) Proof.It is clear from definition 15 of the F-basis. Proof of propositions 25 and 26 For an illustration, we now derive the diagonalized form of t heDoperator. (D.5) We thus diag( (D.6) Therefore, by induction we have the diagonalized form of ope ratorD. Similarly, we can diagonalize A,A+] andD+. Lemma D.3. The diagonalized form of given by the use of (5.12) we have (D.7). Corollary D.1. The inverse of the total Fis given as (D.8) Proof.We show it by induction on n. Let us assume (D.8) for the case of n. We (D.7) we have which corresponds to (D.8) for the D.4. The dagger of total Fis given by the charge conjugation of transposed (D.9) Or equivalently we (D.10) Proof.We show it by induction on n. Let us assume (D.9) for the case of n-1. We use of the induction assumption we show F+
12***n= D.2. The inverse of total Fis given as we (D.12) Proof.It follows from (D.8) that From (D.10) we have (D.11). 43E Lemmas for Diagonalizing the Coperator Lemma E.1. LetX+be the generator of the quantum group of X+acting on the ith site. We E.2. The diagonalized form of (n-1)(X+)is expressed in terms of local (E.2) Lemma E.3. Operator C+in theF-basis is expressed in terms of operator D+andX+
i as authors would like to thank Prof. S. Miyashita for encour agement and keen interest in this work. One of the authors (C.M.) would like to thank Dr. K. Shigechi for his introduction to the mathematical physics of integrable mod els. This work is by Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research (C) No. 20 V.E. Korepin, N.M. Bogoliubov and A.G. Izergin, Quantum Inverse and Correlation Functions (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1993) [2] M. Jimbo and T. Miwa, Algebraic Analysis of Solvable Latt ice Models (AMS, Prov- idence, RI, 1995). [3] N. Kitanine, J. M. Maillet, N. A. Slavnov and V. Terras, On the algebraic Bethe ansatz approach to the correlation functions of the XXZ spin -1/2 Heisenberg M. Jimbo, K. Miki, T. Miwa and A. Nakayashiki, Correlatio n functions of the XXZ model for <-1, Phys. Lett. A 168(1992) 256-263. [5] N.A. Slavnov, Calculation of scalar products of wave fun ctions and form factors Theor.Math. Ph ys.79(1989) 502-508. 44[6] J.M. Maillet and J. Sanchez de Santos, Drinfel'd twists a nd algebraic Bethe ansatz, ed. M. Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. 201Ser. 2, Ameri. Math. Soc., 2000) pp. 137-178. [7] N. Kitanine, J.M. Maillet and V. Terras, Form factors of t he XXZ Heisenberg spin- 1/2 finite chain, Nucl. Phys. B 554[FS] (1999) 647-678 [8] N. Kitanine, J.M. Maillet and V. Terras, Correlation fun ctions of the XXZ Heisen- berg spin-1/2 chain in a magnetic field, Nucl. Phys. B 567[FS] (2000) 554-582. [9] F. G ohmann, A. Kl umper and A. Seel, Integral represent ations for correlation func- tions of the XXZ chain at finite temperature, J. Phys. A: Math. D. Biegel, M. Karbach, G. M uller and K. Wiele, Spectrum of transition rates of the XX chain analyzed via Bethe ansatz, Phys. Rev. B 69, 174404 (2004) . [11] J. Sato, M. Shiroishi and M. Takahashi, Evaluation of Dy namic Spin Structure Factor for the Spin-1/2 XXZ Chain in a Magnetic Field, J. Phys . Soc. Jpn. 73 (2004) 3008-3014. [12] J.-S. Caux and J. M. Maillet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 077201 (2005). [13] R.G. Pereira, J. Sirker, J.-S. Caux, R. Hagemans, J.M. M aillet, S.R. White, and I. Affleck, Dynamical structure factor at small qfor the XXZ spin-1/2 chain, J. Stat. Mech. (2007) P08022. [14] P.P. Kulish, N. Yu. Reshetikhin and E.K. Sklyanin, Yang -Baxter equation theory: I, Lett. Math. Phys. 5(1981) 393-403 [15] H.M. Babujan, Exact solution of the isotropic Heisenbe rg chain with arbutrary spins: thermodynamics of the model, Nucl. Phys. B 215[FS7] (1983) 317-336. [16] A.B. Zamolodchikov and V.A. Fateev, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 32(1980) 298. [17] K. Sogo, Y. Akutsu and T. Abe, Prog. Theor. Phys. 70(1983) 730; 739. [18] A. N. Kirillov and N. Yu. Reshetikhin, Exact solution of the integrable XXZ Heisen- berg model with arbitrary spin. I. the ground state and the ex citation spectrum, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 20(1987) 1565-1585. [19] T. Deguchi, M. Wadati and Y. Akutsu, Exactly Solvable Mo dels and New V. Yang-Baxter Operator and Braid-Monoid Alg ebra, J. Phys. 1905-1923. [20] J. Suzuki, Spinons in magnetic chains of arbitrary spin s at finite temperatures, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 32(1999) 2341-2359. [21] Y. Akutsu and M. Wadati, Exactly Solvable Models and New Link polynomials. I. N-State Vertex Models, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 56(1987) 3039-3051. [22] M. Jimbo, A q-Difference Analogue of U(calg) and the Yang-Baxter Equation, Lett. Math. Phys. 10(1985) 63-69. 45[23] M. Jimbo, A q-analogue of U(gl(N+1)), Hecke algebra and the Yang-Baxter equa- tion, Lett. Math. Phys. 11(1986) 247-252. [24] V. Terras, Drinfel'd Twists and Functional Bethe Ansat z, Lett. Math. Phys. 48 (1999) 263-276. [25] J.M. Maillet andV. Terras, scatt ering problem, Nucl. Phys. B575[FS] (2000) 627-644. [26] N. Kitanine, Correlation functions of thehigher spinX XX chains, J. Phys. A: 8151-8169. [27] O.A. Castro-Alvaredo and J.M. Maillet, Form factors of integrable spin chains, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 40(2007) 7451-7471. [28] C.S. Melo and M.J. Martins, Algebraic Bethe Ansatz for U(1) Invariant The Method and General Results, arXiv:0806.2404 [m ath-ph]. [29] K. Fabricius and B. M. McCoy, Evaluation Parameters and Bethe Roots for the Six-Vertex Model at Roots of Unity, in Progress in Mathemati cal Physics Vol. 23 (MathPhys Odyssey 2001 ), edited by M. Kashiwara and T. Miwa, (Birkh auser, Boston, 2002) 119-144. [30] V.G. Drinfeld, Quantum groups, Proc. ICM Berkeley 1986 , pp. 798-820. [31] M. Jimbo, Topics from representations of Uq(g)- An Introductory Guide to Physi- cists, in Nankai Lectures on Mathematical Physics (World Sc ientific, Singapore, 1992) pp. 1-61. [32] A. Nishino and T. Deguchi, The L(sl2) symmetry of the model associated with the superintegrable chiral Potts model, Ph ys. Lett. A L. Takhtajan and L. Faddeev, Spectrum and Scattering of Excitations in the One- Dimensional Isotropic Heisenberg Model, J. Sov. Math. 24(1984) 241-267. [34] R. J. Baxter, Exactly Solved Models in Statistical Mechanics (Academic Press, W. Magnus, A. Karrass and D. Solitar, Combinatorial Group Theory : Presentations of groups in terms of generators and relations, (Dover Publi cations Inc., 1976, New York). [36] R. Baxter, The Inversion Relation Method for Some Two-D imensional Exactly Solved Models in Lattice Statistics, J. Stat. Phys. 28(1982) 1-41. [37] T. Deguchi, K. Fabricius and B. M. McCoy, The sl2Loop Algebra Symmetry of the Six-Vertex Model at Roots of Unity, J. Stat. Phys. 102(2001) 701-736. 46
|
0807.1847
|
Tetsuo Deguchi
|
Tetsuo Deguchi and Chihiro Matsui
|
Form factors of integrable higher-spin XXZ chains and the affine
quantum-group symmetry
|
46 pages with no figure
|
Nucl.Phys.B814:405-438,2009; Erratum-ibid.B851:238-243,2011
|
10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2009.01.002 10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2011.05.013
| null |
cond-mat.stat-mech hep-th math-ph math.MP math.QA nlin.SI quant-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We derive exactly scalar products and form factors for integrable higher-spin
XXZ chains through the algebraic Bethe-ansatz method. Here spin values are
arbitrary and different spins can be mixed. We show the affine quantum-group
symmetry, $U_q(\hat{sl_2})$, for the monodromy matrix of the XXZ spin chain,
and then obtain the exact expressions. Furthermore, through the quantum-group
symmetry we explicitly derive the diagonalized forms of the $B$ and $C$
operators in the $F$-basis for the spin-1/2 XXZ spin chain, which was
conjectured in the algebraic Bethe-ansatz calculation of the XXZ correlation
functions. The results should be fundamental in studying form factors and
correlation functions systematically for various solvable models associated
with the integrable XXZ spin chains.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 11 Jul 2008 13:14:55 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 4 Sep 2008 07:30:07 GMT"
}
] | 2011-07-06T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Deguchi",
"Tetsuo",
""
],
[
"Matsui",
"Chihiro",
""
]
] |
Abstract We have studied the structure of4He droplets doped with magnesium atoms using theory. We have found that the solvation propert ies of this system strongly depend on the size of the4He droplet. For small drops, Mg resides in a deep surface stat e, whereas for large size drops it is fully solvated but radially delocalized in t heir interior. We have studied the 3 s3p 1P1-3s2 1S0transition of the dopant, and have compared our results with experimental data from laser induced fluorescence (LIF). Line broadening effect s due to the coupling of of the surrounding helium with the dipole exci tation of the impurity are explicitly taken into account. We show that the Mg radial delocalizatio n inside large droplets may help reconcile the apparently contradictory solvation propert ies of magnesium as provided by LIF ionization experiments. The structure of4He drops doped with two magnesium atoms is also studied and used to interpret the results of res onant (R2PI) and LIF experiments. We have found that the two solvated Mg at oms do not easily merge into a dimer, but rather form a weakly-bound state due to the presen ce of an energy barrier caused by the helium environment that keep them some 9 .5@A apart, preventing the formation of the Mg 2 molecule. From this observation, we suggest that Mg atoms in4He drops may form, under a soft foam-like aggregate rather than coale sce into a compact metallic cluster. Our findings are in qualitative agreement with recent R2PI exper imental evidences. We predict Mg atoms adsorbed in3He droplets do not form such metastable aggregates. PACS numbers: 36.40.-c, 32.30.Jc, 78.40.-q, 47.55.D-, 71.15.Mb, 67.40 .Yv 2I. investigations of atomic impurities in superfluid helium nanodro plets have are a very useful observable to determine the location of t he foreign atom attached to a helium drop.3In this context, the study of magnesium atoms attached to helium d rops has unraveled an interesting and somewhat unexpected solvation b ehaviour as a function of the number ( N) of helium atoms in the drop. Diffusion Monte Carlo (DMC) out for small drops containing a number of helium atoms up to N= 50 indicate that a Mg atom is not fully solvated in drops of sizes below N~30. More recent quantum Monte Carlo a surface Mg state for4He clusters with up to ~200 atoms. Density Functional Theory (DFT) doped with alkaline earth atoms have shown that Mg atoms are so lvated in their interior, in agreement with the analysis of Laser Induced Flou rescence (R2PI) experiments.9LIF experiments on the absorption and emission spectra of Mg atoms in liquid3He and4He have been reported and within a vibrating atomic bubble model, where full solvation of the impurity atom is assumed.10,11A more recent experiment13in which electron-impact ionization data from Mg doped4He drops with about 104atoms seems to indicate that magnesium is instead at the surface of the droplet, in disagreement with the above ment ioned LIF and is some ambiguity associated with the notion of solvation in a heliu m droplet. For not too small droplets, one may consider that Mg is fully solvated whe n its position inside the droplet is such that its solvation energy or atomic shift do not ap preciably differ from their asymptotic values in bulk liquid helium, as both quantities approac h such limit However, for very small drops the energy or atomic shif ts of an impurity atom at the center of the drop may still differ appreciably from the bulk liqu id values because there is not enough helium to saturate these quantities. This is the c ase, e.g., of Mg@4He50 studied in Ref. 4. Mella et al.4have discussed how the solvation properties of magnesium areaffec ted by the number of helium atoms in small4He drops. Since DMC calculations cannot be extended to the very large drops involved in LIF could not carry out a between their calculated atomic shifts and the experime nts. They also pointed out the sensitivity of the Mg solvation properties on apparently sma ll differences in the He-Mg pair potentials available in the literature. The aim of the present work is to re-examine the solvation of magnes ium in4He nan- odroplets from the DFT perspective, extending our previous calcu lations7down to drops withN~50 atoms and improving the DFT approach (i) by treating the dopant as a ofasanexternal field, into account thecoupling of the dipole excitation of the impurity with the dynamical deformations of the helium around the Mg atom. Our results confirm that full solvation of a Mg atom in4He drops requires a minimum number of helium atoms, and disclose some unusual results fo r small drops. We calculate the absorption spectrum of a Mg atom attached to small a nd large drops, finding a good agreement with the experiments for the latter. We discuss in a qualitative way the effect of the impurity angular momentum on the electron-impact ioniz ation yield and on the absorption spectrum. We also address the structure of a two -magnesium doped drop; the results are used to discuss the scenario proposed by Meiwes-B roer and collaborators to interpret their experimental results on R2PI.9 This work is organized as follows. In Sec. II we briefly present our de nsity as well as results for the structure of Mg@4HeNdrops. The method we have employed to obtain the atomic shifts is discussed in Sec. III, and app lied to the case of Mg- doped4He droplets in Sec. IV. In Sec. V we study how the presence of a sec ond magnesium atom in the droplet may alter both the helium drop structure and the calculated atomic shift. A summary is presented in Sec. VI, and some technical details of our calculations are described in the appendices. II. DFT DESCRIPTION OF HELIUM NANODROPLETS A. Theoretical approach In recent years, static and time-dependent density functional m popular to study inhomogeneous liquid helium systems bec ause they provide an excellent compromise between accuracy and computational effo rt, allowing to address problems inaccessible to more fundamental approaches. Although DFT cannot take into 4account the atomic, discrete nature of these systems, it can nev ertheless address helium systems at the the anisotropic by atomic dopants in helium drops (see Ref. 3 for a recent ov erview on the physics of helium starting point is the Orsay-Trento density with the Mg-He adiabatic ground-state potential X1S of Ref. 19, here denoted as VMg-He. To check the sensitivity of our results to the details of different available pair pote ntial describing the Mg-He interaction, we also use the sligthly less attractive potential computed in Ref. 20. For the sake of comparison, we plot both potentials in Fig. 1. Despite the apparently between these two potential curves, they cause ver y different solvation properties of Mg in small4He drops, as we will show in the following. The energy of the Mg-helium system is written as a functional of the Mg wave function Ph(r) and the4He order parameter Ps( r) wherer(r) is the4He atomic this expression, E(r) is the4He potential energy Eunder the constraints of a given Nand a normalized Mg wave function, yields the ground state of the drop-impurity complex. To address the solvation of the Mg atom , we have found it convenient to minimize Esubjected to the additional constraint of a fixed distance Z0 between the centers of mass of the helium moiety and of the impurity atom which, due to the symmetry of the problem, can both be taken on the zaxis. This is done following a method -borrowed from Nuclear Physics- similar to that used to de scribe the fission of rotating3He we minimize the 0]2, (2) whereZis the average distance between the impurity and the center of mas s of the (3) lCis an arbitrary constant. The value lC~1000 K@A-2has been used in our ensures that the desired Z0value is obtained within a 0.1 % accuracy. 5We have solved the Euler-Lagrange equations which result from the variations with re- spect to Ps*and Ph*of the constrained energy Eq. (2), =uPs 0)z}Ph =ePh, (5) whereuis the helium chemical potential and eis the lowest eigenvalue of the Schr odinger equation obeyed by the Mg atom. The above coupled equations have to be solved starting from an arbitrary but reasonable choice of the unknown functions Ps and Ph. The fields UHeandUMgare defined as UHe(r) (6) In spite of the axial symmetry of the problem, we have solved the ab ove equations (3D) cartesian coordinates. The main reason is that these to use fast Fourier transformation techniques22to efficiently compute the entering the definition of E(r), i.e. the mean field helium potential and the coarse- grained density needed to compute the correlation term in the He de nsity as the fields defined in Eq. (6). The differential operators in Eqs. (1,4,5) have been discretized usin g 13-point formulas for the derivatives. Eqs. (4-5) have been solved employing an imagin ary time method;23 some technical details of our procedure are given in Ref. 24. Typica l calculations have been performed using a spatial mesh step of 0.5 @A. We have checked the stability of the reasonable changes in the spatial mesh step. B. Structure and energetics of Mg-doped helium (4-5) have been solved for lC= 0 and several Nvalues, namely N= 30, 50, 100, 200, 300, 500, 1000, and 2000. This yields the ground sta te of the and will allow us to study the atomic shift for selected cluste r theenergy ofamagnesium atomina drop, defined ast heenergy (7) 6We compare in Fig. 2 the SN(Mg) values here obtained with those of Ref. 7, where the Mg atom was treated as an infinitely massive particle -i.e., as a fixed ext ernal field acting on the4He drop. The neglect of the quantum kinetic energy of the impurity o verestimates the impurity solvation energies by quite a large amount, about 19.7 K f orN= 50 and 18.8 K forN= 2000. The value we have found for S50(Mg),-18.4 K, compares well with the DMC result of Ref. 6 ( -21 K), showing that DFT performs quite well for small clusters,3 far from the regime for which it was parametrized. The DMC energy f ound for the same system is~-168.2 K,4whereas our DFT result is ~-157.0 K, and the asymptotic DMC value K, compares well with the DFT value, still far from the limit value corresponding to a very large helium drop (see Fig. byadelicate balancebetween the different energy terms -surface, bulk and helium-impurity- in Eq. (1 ), whose contribution is hard to disentangle and depends on the number of atoms in the dro p, as shown by DMC and DFT calculations. To gain more insight into the solvation process o f magnesium in small4He droplets, we have computed the energy of the doped droplet as a function of the impurity position Z0. The bottom panel in Fig. 3 shows E(Z0) forN= 50, as computed using the two different Mg-He pair interactions shown in Fig. 1 (the discussion of the top pan el is postponed until Sec. IV.A). It can be seen that E(Z0) in both cases displays two local minima. In one case (i.e. for the sligtly less attractive potential in Fig. 1) a surface st ate for the Mg atom is energetically preferred, while in the other case the impurity prefe rs to sit in the interior to the droplet (although not exactly at its center). These results are in agreement with the DMC calculations of Ref. 4, where it has been shown that a bimoda l distributions for the Mg radial probability density function with respect to the cente r-of-mass of the helium moiety appears for N<=30.4More recent DMC calculations carried out up to N~200 drops6seem to point out that Mg is always in a surface state, although some what beneath the drop surface. Our DFT calculations yield that Mg is already solvat ed forN= 200. For both pair potentials, the bottom panel of Fig. 3 shows that the two local minima inE(Z0) are separated by an energy barrier of about 1 K height, allowing th e impurity to temporarily visit, even at the experimental temperature T~0.4 K, the less site. This causes changes in the total energy of the syst em by less that 1 %, but has a large effect on the value of the atomic shift. We will address this impo rtant issue, and on the computed spectral properties of Mg@He Nin the next intsdisplayed inFig. 3, namely those corresponding to Z0= 0, 2, 4, and6 @A. Although the preference for the surface or the solvated state depends on the He-Mg pair potential used in t he calculations, similarly to the case of other alkali atoms,7this does not seem to be the case for the stationary points atZ0= 2 and 4 @A that are present in both curves. We have compared in Fig. 5 the de nsity profiles along the zaxis for theZ0= 2(4)@A configuration with the profile of the pure4He drop, finding that the appearence of these stationary points is re lated to the position of the density peak in the first helium solvation shell with respect to a maximu m(minimum) of the density of the pure drop. We see that a minimum(maximum) in the ener gy is associated with a interference in the oscillation pa ttern of the He density. We are lead to conclude that the interplay between the density oscillatio ns already present in pure drops, and the solvation shells generated by the impurity plays an important role in the solvation properties of the Mg atom. This effect is also present, although to a lesser extent, in Ca-doped4He for larger drops Mg becomes fully solvated. We have fou nd that this is the case whichever of these two potentials we use (see for instance th e bottom panel of Fig. 6). For this reason, the results we discuss in the following have been obt ained with the Mg-He pair potential of Ref. 19, unless differently stated. When the Mg atom is fully solvated, e.g. for N= 1000, we have found that E(Z0) as Z0increases (i.e. as the Mg atom approaches the droplet surface). T his is shown in the bottom panel of Fig. 6. To better understand how E(Z0) depends on N, we have plotted in the top panel of Fig. 6 the energy of the N= 1000 and 2000 doped drops, referred to their equilibrium value, as a function of the dista nce from the i.e. the radius R1/2at which the density of the pure drop equals rb/2,rbbeing the liquid density value ( R1/2=r0N1/3, withr0= 2.22@A). These radii are 22.2 and 28.0 @A for N= 1000 and 2000, top panel of Fig. 6 shows that most of the change in Etakes place in the 15
@A outer region of the drop, irrespective of its size. As a consequen ce of the flatness of E(Z0), the magnesium atom is very delocalized in the radial direction even in relatively small drops. This delocalization might affect the absorption spectru m of the attached Mg atom, and also must be explicitly considered in the interpretation of t he experiments.13We address this issue in Sec. IV. III. EXCITATION SPECTRUM OF A MG ATOM ATTACHED TO A4HE DROP Lax method26offers a realistic way to study the absorption spectrum of a foreign and it has been widely employed to study the absorption s pectrum of atomic dopants attached to4He drops, see e.g. Ref. 25 and references therein. The method is usually applied in conjunction with the theory,27which means that the atom-drop complex is treated as a diatomic molecule, where the h elium moiety plays a role of the other atom. In the original formalism, to obtain the line shape one has to carry ou t an average on the possible initial states of the system that may be thermally populated . Usually, this average is not needed for helium drops, astheir temperature, about 0 .4 K,12ismuch smaller excitation energies of the Mg atom in the mean field repre sented by the second of Eqs. (6). In small helium droplets thermal effects can show up in t he Mg due to the high mobility of the atom. For large drops, ther mal motion plays a minor role, as the Mg atom hardly gets close enough to the drop surf ace to have some effect on the line shape. In this case, however, dynamical deformations o f the cavity around the impurity may be line shape for electronic transitions from the ground state ( gs) to the excited state (ex) in a condensed phase system can be written (8) whereDgeis the matrix element of the electric dipole operator, the ground state of the system, and HgsandHexare the Hamiltonians that describe the ground and excited states of the system is evaluated using the Born-Oppenheimer approximation and the Fr whereby the heavy nuclei do not change their positions or momenta during the electronic transition. If the excited electron belongs to the impurit y, the helium cluster remains frozen, so that the relevant coordinate is the relative pos itionrbetween the cluster and the impurity. This principle amounts to assuming that Dgeis independent of the 9nuclear coordinates. Taking into account that projecting on eigenstates of the orbital angular momentum of the excited electr are the energy and the wave function of the ro-vibrational grou nd state of the frozen helium-impurity system, and Hex m(r,[a]) is the ro-vibrational with potential energy Vex m(r,[a]) determined by the electronic energy eigen- value, as obtained for a p-stransition. At this point, we have introduced the variables [ a] to represent the degrees of freedom needed to describe possible deformations of the to the zero point oscillations of the helium bubble arou nd the impurity. If this effect is neglected, the deformation parameters [ a] are dropped and the ground state wave function psgs Xcoincides with the Mg wavefunction Ph found by solving Eq. (5). If the relevant excited states for the transition have large quant um numbers, they can be treated as approximately classical using the averaged energy - which is independent of n. In this case we obtain the (10) where ohm m(o) is the surface defined by the equation 0. If the atom is in bulk liquid helium, or at the center of the drop, the problem has sph erical symmetry and the above equation reduces (11) whererm(o) is the root of the equation 0. In the we have evaluated I(o) using the first expression in Eq. (10). The potential energy surfaces Vex m(r,[a]) needed to carryout thecalculation of the atomic shifts have been obtained in the pairwise sum approximation, using th eVP(r) andVS(r) Mg- He adiabatic potentials from Ref. 4. In cartesian coordinates, and assuming that the He- impurity spin-orbit interaction is negligible for magnesium, the eigenva lues of the theVex m(r,[a]) potentials which define the potential energy surfaces (PES) as a function of the distance between the center-of-mass of the droplet and t hat of the impurity. For spherical geometries, Eq. (12) is diagonal with matrix elements (in spherical = this case, two of the PES are degenerate, namely l1(r,[a]) holds true for rne}ationslash= 0, and it is relevant when we take into account the delocalization of the impurity inside the bubble due to its quantum motion. Otherwise, s ince atr= 0 all the licoincide, they are threefold degenerate. IV. RESULTS FOR THE ABSORPTION SPECTRUM OF MAGNESIUM ATOMS The problem of obtaining the atomic shift of magnesium in a helium drop h as been thus reduced to that of the dopant in the 3D trapping potentials co rresponding to the ground state and Pexcited states. We consider first the [ a] = 0 case (i.e. no of the helium cavity hosting the impurity). The genera l situation, in particular the homogeneous width calculation, is presented later on in this Sect ion. If [a] = 0, the model is expected to yield at most the energies of the atom ic transitions, but not the line shapes since the impurity-droplet excitation interac tions as well as inho- mogeneous broadening resulting from droplet size distributions, las er line width and similar effects are not included. These limitations are often overcome by int roducing line shape functions or convoluting the calculated lines with some effective line pr ofiles.32,33We discuss here two illustrative examples, namely the atomic shift of magnesium in N= 50 and The homogeneous width is calculated in Subsection B f or theN= Mg@4He50, the calculated shifts at Z0= 0 (spherical configuration), 2 and 6 @A are 500, 450 and 281 cm-1, respectively (281.3, 281.7 and 283.0 nm wavelengths). information is available for such a small drop. Contrar ily, the of the 3 s3p1P1-3s2 1S0transition of Mg atoms attached to large helium drops has been a broad peak strongly blue-shifted from its position in the gas-phase. This spectrum is remarkably close to the one obtained b y Moriwaki and Morita10 in bulk liquid helium, and hence it has been concluded that Mg is in the inter ior of the4He droplet. We want to point out that, while the absorption line in liquid heliu m was attributed to a single broad peak of energy 281.5 nm (35524 cm-1), i.e., a shift of 474 cm-1,10in large drops a similar line profile34was fitted by two Gaussians centered at 35358 and 35693 cm-1 (282.8 and 280.2 nm wavelengths) respectively, i.e., shifted 307 cm-1and 642 cm-1from the gas-phase line.8The origin of the two peaks was attributed to the splitting of the deg enerate P state by dynamical quadrupole deformations of the cavity surro unding the dopant, since this argument hadqualitatively explained similar doubly-shaped D2excitation spectra ofRb and Cs atoms in liquid4He due to a quadrupole oscillation of the helium bubble effect).29 LIF experiments on the heavier alkaline earth Ca and Sr in large4He the existence of strong blue-shifted, broad peaks with n o apparent structure, al- though it cannot be discarded that this broad line could be a superpo sition of The same happens for Ba.36The surface location of Ca, Sr, and Ba in these drops has been further confirmed by DFT is also interesting to recall that LIF experiments on Ca atoms in liquid4He and3He have found a broad line in the region of the 4s4p1P1-4s2 1S0transition with no apparent to the case of Mg. Since Mg is fully solvated in the N= 1000 drop, the calculated atomic shift omay be sensibly compared with the experimental data where drops with Nin the 103-104range are studied. We have obtained o= 659.0 cm-1(280.0 nm wavelength); this peak to the Gaussian that takes most of the intensity of t he absorption line (about 87 %).8We have carried out a detailed analysis for this drop, determining the of Mg@4He1000as a function ofZ0, and have used it to evaluate o. The results are displayed in Table I, showing the actual sensitivity of the absorp tion spectrum to the Mg atom environment. The impurity-drop excitations will determine the homogeneous width of the spectral line, and the population of excited states may be relevant given the limit te mperature attained by the this context, the relevant excitation modes of the helium bubble 12are radial oscillations of monopole type (breathing modes), and mult ipole shape the equilibrium configuration, as well as displacements of the h elium bubble inside the droplet. We will address these issues in the following Subsections . A. Thermal motion and angular momentum effects To describe the displacement of the helium bubble inside the droplet, w e have fitted theE(Z0) curve of the Mg@4He1000system to a parabola, and have obtained the -hofor this 3D isotropic harmonic oscillator. The hydrodynamic mass of t he impurity atom has been estimated by its bulk liquid helium value, M*~40 a.u., obtained by the method outlined in Appendix A, Eq. (A23). We find - ho= 0.1 K, indicating that thermal motion, i.e., the population of the excited states of the mean field E(Z0) is important at the experimental temperature T= 0.4 K, and may produce observable effects in the absorption spectrum and the electron-impact ionization yield. To describe in more detail the delocalization of the Mg atom inside the d rop, we have used an effective Hamiltonian where we interpret Z0as the radial distance Rbetween the impurity and center of mass of the helium moiety, and E(Z0) as the potential energy V(R) associated with this new degree of freedom of the impurity in the dr op. (14) whereM*is the Mg hydrodynamic mass. In the canonical ensemble, the total Was a function of Rcan be written as W(R) the partition function is defined as being kBthe Boltzmann constant. The radial probability density wis w(R) (16) This expression has been evaluatedfor N= 50 and1000by solving the Schr odinger equation for the Hamiltonian Eq. (14) to obtain the orbitals phnland eigenenergies Enl. For we have used the semiclassical approximation where the effective potential is Veff(R) (17) Integrating pRin phase space, we obtain for the probability density w(R) the normalization a better choice, we have weighted any possible angular mome ntum value with the droplet during the pickup process may be kept in the impurity at om, resulting in a different angular momentum distribution than the Boltzmann one. Th is could yield that some Mg atoms are actually closer to the drop surface. If the angular momentum associated with the motion of the magnesiu m atom -whose radius is~5@A, see Fig. 1- is such that Mg can be some 10 @A beneath the drop surface, the shift of the absorption line would be hardly distinguishable from th at of the totally solvated case -as seen in Table I. At the same time, the electron-en ergy dependence of the Mg+yield observed in electron impact ionization which was considered as an evidence of a surface location of Mg atoms on4He droplets) could indeed be due to Penning ionization of the impurity in a collision with a metastable He*atom that occupies a surface bubble state in the drop, instead of being due to the tran sfer of a positive hole (He+) to the Mg atom, which is the primary ionization mechanism when the imp urity is very attractive and resides in the deep bulk of the droplet. We show in the top panel of Fig. 3 the probability densities w(R) atT= 0.4 K corre- sponding to the configurations displayed in the bottom the top panel of Fig. 6 shows that for Mg@4He1000and Mg@4He2000, if thermal motion is taken into account and the impurity retains some of the pick-up angular momentum, the maximum of Mg is at ~15@A beneath the drop surface in both cases. To obtain it, we have taken for M*the bulk value 40 a.u. As seen from Table I, the absorption line shift changes by a small 2% with respect to the R= 0 configuration. The values of the angular momentum corresponding to these maximum density probabilities are aN= 10000 drop,13whose radius is R1/2= 47.8@A, we inwards the Ecurves of the calculated N= 1000 and 2000 drops, and have obtained from it the probability distribution displayed in Fig. 6. Its max imum is at~18.5
@A beneath the surface, with using the effective potential of Eq. (17) we have determined that a Mg atom with l~24-h(44-h) is in an equilibrium position some 10 @A beneath the drop surface. For the N= 10000 drop, this value is l~148-h. These values look reasonable, and Mg atoms holding this angular momentum or large r might thus be the origin of the primary ionization yield by the Pennin g process, the conclusion drawn from LIF experiments that magne sium is fully solvated in 4He drops. B. Homogeneous width from shape deformations of the helium bubble We have shown that for large drops, the Mg atom is fully solvated and its thermal motion only produces small changes in the absorption shift. This allows us to decouple the effect of the translational motion of the helium bubble on the absorption line, f rom that of its Moreover, we can address shape fluctuations in the m uch simpler ground state, when magnesium is located at the center of the drop. To quantify the effect ofthese fluctuations, we have first used th e spherical the excitation energies of the helium bubble around the impu rity in liquid helium. To this end, we have fitted the VMg-Hepotential to a Lennard-Jones potential with depth e= 7 K at a minimum distance rmin= 5@A. Minimizing the total energy within this model yields a configuration with an equilibrium radius of R0= 0.97x2-1/6rmin, that we approximate by R0= 2-1/6rminto obtain the excitation of the4He around the Mg atom are modeled as43,44 R(ohm) (19) whereRis the radius of the bubble cavity hosting the solvated Mg atom, ohm rep resents the solid angle variables ( th,ph),Zlu(ohm) is a real spherical harmonic, and aluis the amplitude deformation. The condition ensures the con- servation of the number of particles up to second order in alu. The dipole mode amplitude a1uis absent since, for an incompressible fluid, it corresponds to a tran slation of the bubble, 15and this has been considered in the previous represents the bubble surface and sthe surface tension, the energy for a large drop can be written (20) whereC0= 8psR2 0(1+12lA) 2) + 6lA] are the stiffness pa- rameters, and the impurity-He solvation parameter.42The mass parameters are B0= the excitation energies are determined from - hol= yielding -ho0= 10.2 K for the breathing mode, and -ho2= 9.8 K for the quadrupole mode. Given the droplet temperature of 0.4 K , we conclude that only the ground state is populated. The mean amplitude of the s hape oscillations is estimated from the variance gl= givingg0= 0.03 andg2= 0.15. This model thus yields that the bubble can experience monopole oscillation s of~3% amplitude, and quadrupole deformations of amplitude. Amplitudes of this order have been determined within the atomic bubble model for Cesium atoms in liqu id effect in the absorption spectrum is expected to be relevant, we have undertanken a more refined calculation within DFT taking Mg@4He1000as a case study. For helium droplets, we have described bubble deformations in a way s imilar as in namely, if r0(r) is the helium spherical ground state density, deformations are introduced as r(r,t) =r0[R(r,t)]K-1, with R(r,t) (21) where the real spherical harmonics are normalized as conve- nience, and the normalization ensures particle number conserva- tion. If the Mg wave function follows adiabatically the helium density de formation, it can be shown that to second order in alu, the total energy of the system can be written ground state energy, M*
lthe hydrodynamic mass asociated with the second derivative of the total energy with respect to alu. This the Hamiltonian of a set of uncoupled harmonic oscillator s, whose a ground state to whose energy each mode contributes with elu=1 2-hol, and a ground state wave function ps([a]) Details are given in Appendix A. We have computed the hydrodynamic masses assuming that the dro p is large enough to use Eq. (A23). We have obtained M*
0= 15.0mHe+ 0.28mMg~66.7 a.u. and (A10), theenerg been numerically obtained by computing the total energy of th e system for different small values of a0anda2. This has been carried out by numerically introducing the desired deformation parameter into the ground state density and renormalizating it, solving next the Schr odinger equation for the Mg atom [Eq. (5)] to determine the ground state of the impurity, and computing the total energy of the syst em from Eq. (1). Fitting these curves to a parabola, we have obtained E(2) 0= 49.7 K@A-2andE(2) 2= 16.8 K@A-2. We have then calculated the ground state energies - hol/2 and deformation mean amplitudes gl, obtaining -ho0/2 = 10.6 K and -ho2/2 = 6.3 K, with mean amplitudes g0= 0.18@A (~3.7%) andg2= 0.42@A (~8.5%). To quantitatively determine the effect of these deformations on th e absorption spectrum, we have developed Eq. (10) to first order in the deformation param eters, and have explicitly shown that to this order, only the breathing and quadrupole modes affect the dipole ab- sorption spectrum. The details are given in Appendix B, where we sho w that the breathing mode affects the shift and shape of the line, whereas quadrupole mo des only affect the we restrict in Eq. (11) the deformation parameter s needed to the homogeneous broadening of the absorption dipole line, namely being Ph(r,a0) the wave function of the Mg atom for a givena0value, and compute the spectrum [a2] are the eigenvalues lm(r,[a]) of the excited potential matrix of Eq. (C4), and rm(o) is the root of the equation 0. Expression (24) has been integrated using a Monte Carlo method. W e have sorted M= 106sets of values [ the square of the wave function of Eq. (23) as probability density. Next, for each set we h ave found the of theUi,jmatrix that define the potential energy surfaces and have used a trapezoidal rule to evaluate the = a discretized representation of the delta we have obtained the spectrum (26) Figure 7 shows the absorption spectrum of one Mg atom attached t o4He1000in the vicinity of the 3 s3p1P1-3s2 1S0transition when homegeneous broadening is considered. We have decomposed the absorption line into its three components, the higher being the S one. The starred vertical line represents t he gas-phase transition, and the experimental curve, adapted from Ref. 8, has been vert ically offset for clarity. Also shown is the absorption spectrum obtained by neglecting homogene ous broadening This figure shows that the both the energy and width of th e absorption peak that takes most of the experimental intensity are correctly described by our calculations. V. TWO MAGNESIUM ATOMS ATTACHED TO A4HE DROP The attachment of magnesium atoms in4He droplets has been recently addressed using resonant .9In particular, the authors of Ref. 9 have obtained the absorption spectrum for drops doped with different, selected num bers of Mg atoms. From their measurements it appears that two main features contribute to the observed line shapes, one peaked at about 279 nm, and another at about 282 nm. This is in a greement with the results of Refs. 8,10 (we recall that actually, the two peaks were n ot resolved by the authors 18of the bulk liquid experiment). The structure at 282 nm, however, o nly appears if the droplet contains more than one Mg atom. Thus the two-peak struc ture cannot be due to the splitting of the absorption line due to dynamical quadrupole defo rmations of the helium bubble around the impurity, as previously believed. We have indeed sh own in the previous Section that this coupling only produces a broad peak, in good agree ment with the results of Ref. 9 for helium drops containing just one Mg atom. Another interesting observation reported in Ref. 9 is that their ex perimental results for multi-atom doped4He droplets are not consistent with the formation of compact, met allic Mg clusters inside the4He droplet. The magnesium atoms in the droplet appear instead to be relatively isolated from each other, showing only a weak interactio n and leading to the 282 nm shift in the observation. To confirm this scenario and find an explanation for the origin of the lo w energy com- ponent in the absorption peak, we have carried out DFT calculations to determine the structure of a two-magnesium doped4He drop. Our goal is to verify whether the helium density oscillation around a magnesium atom may result in an energy ba rrier preventing the Mg atoms from merging into a Mg 2dimer, as suggested by Przystawik et al.9To obtain the structure of two Mg atom in a4He drop, we have minimized the energy of the system written as E[Ps,Ph1,Ph2] is the Mg-Mg pair potential of Ref. 46, and the other ingredients have the same meaning as in Eq. (1). There are at least two additional effects which are not considered w hen modeling the expression. Thefirst is due to three-body (and higher) correlation effects involving the4He atoms surrounding the Mg pair: these should exert an additional, albeit small, screening e ffect due to He polarization, which is expected to reduce the absolute value of the d ispersion coefficients in the long-range part of the Mg-Mg interaction. The second is a poss ible reduction of the Mg 19atom polarizability due to the presence of the surrounding4He cavity which, because of the repulsive character of the electron-He interaction, should make t he electronic distribution of the impurity atom slightly stiffer, thus reducing further the va lues of the in the Mg-Mg pair interactions. Although in principle these effects might reduce the net interaction between a pair of Mg atoms embedded in liquid4He, in practice in the present system they are indeed very small. The correction to the le ading term of the long- range dispersion interaction, -C6/r6, due to three-body correlation effects can be written to first the static polarizability of the host fluid (aHe= 1.39a3 0). Such correction is of the order of only 1% in our case. To estimate the change in the Mg atomic polarizability due to the surrounding He, we co mputed, using ab- initio pseudopotential calculations, the (static) polarizability of a Mg atom in the presence of an effective (mainly repulsive) potential acting on the Mg valence e lectrons due to the presence of the surrounding He. The effective interaction is derive d from the of the4He bubble hosting the Mg atom, as predicted by our DFT calculations, and assuming a (local) electron-He interaction whic h was proposed by Cole et al.48We find a very small change in the static atomic polarizability aof Mg. Assuming that, roughly, C6a2we find a reduction of the C6coefficient of about 1-2%. The minimisation of the total energy functional written above unde r the constraint of a given number of helium atoms and normalized Mg ground state wave f unctions should in principle yield the equilibrium configuration of the system. In practic e, depending on the initial configuration, we have found several local minima, whose origin is again of the He solvation shells around the Mg atoms. We h ave found three such metastable configurations for we start the minimization procedure with one Mg atom near the center of the droplet, and the other plac ed off center, at some distance from the first. They are displayed in Fig. 8. The energy diffe rence between the innermost (Mg-Mg distance d= 9.3@A) and the outermost ( d= 18.5@A) configurations is 12.5 K. The energy of the d= 9.3@A configuration is sensibly that of the symmetric about the z= 0 plane (-5581.4 K) also shown in the figure. It is worth noticing that, since R1/2= 22.2@A and the radius of Mg is ~5@A, only the upper left corner configuration has the Mg impurity in a surface state. Figure 9 shows two density profiles of the symmetric configuration o btained along the z-axis (solidline) andthe line). It shows a relatively highdensity helium 20ring around the two-bubble waist, clearly visible in Fig. 8, where the loc al density is almost three times the bulk liquid4He density, and that prevents the collapse of the The Mg wave functions are peaked at ~+-4.75@A, and very narrow. This justifiesa posteriori the assumptions we have made to write the total energy of the sys tem, Eq. (27). Our results confirm the existence of the energy barrier suggeste d in Ref. 9, that prevents the two Mg atoms from coming closer than some 9 @A, and thus hindering, at least temporar- ily, the formation of the Mg 2dimer. This barrier is shown in Fig. 10 as a function of the Mg-Mg distance d, which is kept fixed in a constrained energy minimization. Note that th e energy of the Mg+Mg system increases as ddoes because the two Mg atoms in a drop form a state more bound than that of a pure drop with the impurities well a part. Since the height of the barrier is larger than the experimental temp solvated Mg atoms will not easily merge into a dimer, but rather fo rm of a drops might form a sparse, weakly-bound foam-like aggregat e rather than coalesce into a more tightly bound metallic cluster. Partial coagulation of impur ities was already invoked by Toennies and coworkers to explain their experimental fin dings for the of foreing atoms and molecules in helium clusters50(see also Ref. 51 for the case of bulk liquid helium). Very recently, a kind of quantum gel has been pre dicted to be formed in4He drops doped with neon atoms.52Although some degree of mutual isolation between foreign atoms is expected in the case of strongly attractive impurit ies (like those studied in the two cases mentioned above), where they are kept apart by th e presence a solid4He layer coating the impurity,51our calculations show that this effect is possible even for attractive impurities like Mg, where such solid-like4He layer is absent. One may estimate the mean life of the metastable state as t= a.u. is the hydrodynamic reduced mass of the Mg+Mg system and Uis the barrier height. From Fig. 10 we have that U''(deq)~40 K@A-2. This yields a mean life of a few nanoseconds, which is about five to six orders of ma gnitude smaller than the time needed for its experimental mean life becomes increasingly large 21as the relative angular momentum Ldeposited into the two Mg system increases. Writing E= E(L= (29) one obtains the L-dependent energy barriers displayed in Fig. 10. For L= 30 we have t~0.6us, and forL= 40,t~0.1 milliseconds. Thus, there is an angular momentum window that may yield mean lifes compatible with the experimental findin gs. Increasing L much further would produce too a distant Mg+Mg system which would correspond to a two independent Mg impurities in a drop. To check whether this foam-like structure of the Mg aggregate als o appears in3He drops, we have carried out calculations for the same density functional as in Ref. 49, and the method presented in this Section. Figure 11 sh ows the energy of as a function of d. For distances smaller than some 8.6 @A we have found that the system has a tendency to collapse into a dimer - physically unreachable from our starting point, Eq. (27). We are led to conclude that ther e is no barrier in the case of liquid3He. The configuration corresponding to the closest dwe have calculated is shown in Fig. 12. We are now in the position to determine the effect of these weakly-bo und systems on the LIF and R2PI experiments on4He droplets containing more than one Mg atom. Notice that the bottom right panel of Fig. 8 shows that the helium bubbles h ave a non-zero moment, whereas they are spherically symmetric for on e single Mg atom in the drop. It is precisely the existence of this static quadrupole mom ent that causes an additional separation between the S and P spectral components in the absorption spectra, which results, as a consequence of the broadening of each line, in an double-peak structure of the computed spectra, in agreement with the ex perimental data. Details of our calculation are given in Appendix C, see Eq. (C6). Figure 13 sho ws such two- peak structure corresponding to the specularly symmetric config uration displayed in Fig. 8, and indicates that the 282 nm structure observed in the experim ents may be attributed to the distortion produced by neighbour Mg bubbles; these bubbles contribute incoherently to the absorption spectrum, and the relative intensity of the 282 a nd 279 nm peaks might reflect the different population of drops doped with one and two Mg a toms, since those hosting a compact cluster (dimer, trimer, etc), would not yield an ab sorption signal in of the monomer 3 s3p1P1-3s2 1S0transition. Notice that a large of the helium bubble could also arise if the Mg atom were in a sh allow dimple at the drop surface, but Fig. 6 discards this possibility. We finally note that we have not considered in our work another sour ce for an of the spectral lines of a Mg atom in the field produced by a ne ighboring one, i.e. the resonant dipole-dipole interaction occurring during the elect ronic excitation. This effect could in principle lead to an additional (but probably small, compa red with the effect discussed here) splitting of the calculated lines. An accurate deter mination of the dipole moment is required for a proper inclusion of this effect, which is beyon d the scope of the present paper. VI. SUMMARY We have obtained, within DFT, the structure of4He droplets doped with Mg atoms and have discussed in detail the magnesium solvation properties. In agr eement with have foundthatMg isnot whereas it becomes fully solvated in large droplet. As a consequence of its interaction with the helium environment, it tu rns out that ionprovides away to reconcile two contradictory results on the solution of one Mg ato m in a4He drop, namely center localization (LIF and R2PI experiments8,9), and surface localization have calculated the absorption spectrum of magnesium in the vicin ity of the 3 s3p 1P1-3s2 1S0transition. For the large where Mg is fully solvated, we reproduce the more intense component of the absorption line fo und by LIF and R2PI experiments in large drops and in liquid helium. This agreement is only ach ieved when homegeneous broadening due to the coupling of the dipole excitation with the of the helium bubble are fully taken into account. This c oupling is in Quantum Monte Carlo simulations of the absorption spectr um,56,57whereby one takes advantage of the inherent fluctuations present in these sim ulations. These fluctuations are the full quantal equivalent of the dynamical distortions of the helium bubble we Analt would be interesting to adapt this method to the drop geometry, since it is not simple to handle dynamical bubble distortions in a non-spherical envir onment, or in3He drops. To explain the origin of the low energy peak in the absorption line and co nfirm the likely existence of soft, foam-like structure of Mg aggregates in4He drops as proposed by Przystawik et al,9we have addressed the properties of two Mg atoms in4He1000and have found that indeed, Mg atoms are kept apart by the presence of he lium atoms that prevent the formation of a compact Mg cluster. We have estimated that the height of the energy barrier for the formationof the Mg dimer in4He drops is~2-3 K, which should be enough, at the droplet experimental temperature of 0 .4 K, to guarantee a relatively long lifetime to these weakly-bound Mg aggregates. We predict that, contrarily, Mg atoms adsorbed in3He droplets do not form such metastable states. The presence of neighboring Mg atoms in these structures induces a static in the helium bubble accomodating a Mg atom. As a conseq uence, the line around the 3 s3p1P1-3s2 1S0transition splits. We attribute to this moment the origin of the low energy peak in the absorptio n line, and confirm the suggestion made by the Rostock group9that the splitting of the absorption line, rather than being due to a dynamical (Jahn-Teller) deformation of the heliu m bubble, is due to the presence of more than one magnesium atom in the same droplet. Our previous study on Ca doped helium drops25and the present work show that DFT is able to quantitatively address the dipole absorption of dopants in4He drops within the approach, provided the impurity-helium pair p otentials are accu- rately determined. However, we want to point out that, while we hav e a consistent scenario that explains the results of LIF and R2PI experiments, the unders tanding of the electron- impact ionization experiment reported in Ref. 13 still requires furth er analysis. Indeed, since Mg atoms may be in the bulk of the drop or just beneath the dro p surface, the exper- imental ion yield curve should reflect both possibilities, whereas appa rently it does not (see Fig. 2 of Ref. 13). One possible explanation may be that for electron -impact experiments, aN= 10000 drop is still small, so that the impurity is always close enough to the drop surface to make the Penning ionization process to prevail on the dir ect formation of a would like to thank Massimo Mella and Fausto Cargnoni for useful c omments and for providing us with their Mg-He excited pair potentials, and Marius Lewe renz, Vitaly Meiwes-Broer, Josef Tiggesb aumker, Andreas Przys tawik, Carlo Callegari and Kevin Lehmann for useful comments and discussions. This work has been performed under Grants No. FIS2005-01414 from DGI, Spain (FEDER), No. 2005SG R00343 from Gener- alitat de Catalunya, and under the HPC-EUROPA project (RII3-CT -2003-506079), with the support of the European Community - Research Infrastruct ure Action under the FP6 Structuring the European Research Area A In this Appendix we obtain the energy of the doped drop up to secon d order in the deformation parameters and the hydrodynamic mass of the he lium bubble. To this end, the helium order parameter and Mg wave function are express ed as Ps( r,t) and Ph( r,t) respectively. Neglecting the terms of the Orsay-Trento functional t hat mimic backflow effects,15 the total energy of the system is written (A1) where the functions r(|Ph|) andS(ph) fulfill the continuity =[r(r,t)S(r,t)] allow to identify S(r,t) andph(r,t) as velocity field potentials, and the first two terms in Eq. (A1) as a collective kinetic energy, whose density we denote as t[r,S,|Ph|,ph]. (A4) 25In the adiabatic approximation, the dynamics of the system require s the following steps: i) introduce a set of collective variables (or deformation parameter s) [a(t)]) that define r(r,t) =r(r,[a(t)]); a], Schr odinger equationobeyedby |Ph(r,[a])|; by computing the static energy for each configuration; iv) deter mine the velocity field potentials S(r,[a(t)]) andph(r,[a(t)]) by solving the continuity equations; v) compute the collective kinetic energy to obtain the hydrodynamic mass, and v i) solve the equation of motion associated with the effective Hamiltonian written as a funct ion the aim to describe harmonic deformations of a spherical helium bubble created by an impurity in the ground state, and have to determine the helium densit yr(r,[a(t)]) resulting from a change in the radial distance to the center of the spherical bubble induced by the [a(t)] (A5) where thel= 1 deformation is now introduced to allow for displacements of the bu bble. We recall that the real spherical harmonics have been normalized as = 1,Z10(/hatwider) = costh, etc. The breathing mode corresponds to l= 0, an infinitesimal translation to l= 1 (provided the fluid is incompressible), and a to l= 2. To first order, the density can be written (A6) where from now on, the prime will denote the derivative of the funct ion with respect to its argument. 1. Impurity wave function To first order, the wave function |Ph(r,[a])|is written (A7) 26The amplitudes Ph(1) lu(r) are determined in first order perturbation theory from the multip ole expansion of the impurity-helium pair (A8) which defines U(1) l(r). We (A9) that shows that actually, we have obtained the wave function, we can compute the ener gy we describe deformations around a spherically symmetric grou nd state, the first order term vanishes, and the derivative gl2v/alual'u'is also spherically symmetric. We can evaluate the second order contribution to the collective poten tial energy (A10) which defines E(2) l. The parameters [ a] are the dynamical variables that describe the evolu- tion of the system. 2. Velocity field the expansion where the dot denotes the continuity equation for the liquid helium is, to firs t (A12) Whenr-, the density vanishes for a drop, and approaches rbfor the liquid. In the later case, Eq. (A12) reduces to the radial part of the Laplace equatio n 0 (A13) whose general solution is
~Sl(r) =Alrl+Bl rl+1. (A14) We have solved Eq. (A12) adapting the method proposed in Ref. 59. Letribe the first point where r0(r) is significantly different from zero [ r0(r) = 0 forr<=ri]. At this point, Eq. (A12) implies (A15) which determines the boundary condition at (A16) For the liquid, the other boundary condition is that when r-, the solution behaves as in Eq. (A14) with Al= 0 to have a physically acceptable solution. If the bubble has a sharp surface of radius riand the liquid is uniform, ~Sl(r) is completely determined by Eq. (A14) and the velocity field potential that fulfills Eq. (A16) corresponds t o the coefficients Al= 0 Bl=rl+2 i l+1. (A17) To find the velocity field potential in a large drop, we have defined a ra dial distance rb, far from the bubble and from the drop surface at R1/2, around which on one may consider that the density is that of the liquid. Starting from r=rbwith the liquid solution fixed by the coefficients given in Eq. (A17), we have integrated inwards Eq . (A12), finding the solutions ~Sinh l(r) and~Sh l(r) that correspond, respectively, to the non-homegeneous and t o the homegeneous differential equation that results by setting to z ero the left hand side of Eq. (A12). The general solution that satisfy the boundary condit ion Eq. (A16) is (A19) The field phis analogously obtained after introducing the expansion ph(r,t) We have assumed that the wave function of the impurity in the ground state is a Gaussian Ph 0(r) =Aexp(-br2) whose shape has been determined by fit- ting it to the actual wave function, and have introduce a cutoff dist ancergsuch that safely Ph0(r) = 0 ifr>=rg. We then obtain the following differential equation to determine ~ (A20) The appropriate boundary conditions = 0, (A21) and the solution is analytical but very involved (we have found it by us ing the The dipole mode is the only exception; if l= 1 we have ~ ph1=-r. 3. Kinetic energy Once the velocity fields S(r,t) andph(r,t) have been determined, the collective kinetic energy can be easily calculated to second order in the collective para (A22) which defines the hydrodynamic mass M*
lfor the continuity equations and the Gauss theorem, one can find an alternative ex- pression for have checked that both expressions yield the same values for M*
l, which constitutes a test on the numerical accuracy of the method. It is easy to see fr om Eq. (A22) that in bulk liquid helium, the l= 1 hydrodynamic mass coincides with that given in Ref. 59. Using that ~ ph1=-r, it is also easy to check from the above expressions that the impurit y contribution to the l= 1 hydrodynamic mass is just the bare mass of the Mg atom. The sum of Eqs. (A10) and (A22) represents the Hamiltonian of a se t of oscillators whose frequency only depends on l. APPENDIX B In this Appendix we work out in detail the expressions we have used t o describe Weconsiderasphe rical a helium density r0(r) and impurity wave function Ph 0(r), both modified by the action of the breathing mode defined in Eq. (21), namely r(r,a0) =r0(r+a0)K-1, and Ph(r,a0). The computation of the spectra for a given a0can be carried out starting from Eq. (11) I(o,a0) = (B1) where -ho(a) =e(a0) is the impurity eigenenergy and Vex i(r,a0) are the PES defined by Eq. (13), where [ a] reduces to a0. Notice that a0is not introduced perturbatively; it is unnecessary since this modedoesnot breakthe spherical symmet ry. Next, the modes with l>=2 to first order; Eq. (B1) The first integral is zero due to the orthogonality of the spherical harmonics. To evalue the second integral, we expand oi lu(r) as a power series 30ofr. Taken into account that the PES have a stationary point at r= 0 due to the -the first order term is zero- we can safely stop the exp ansion at the zeroth order term, since the wave function Ph( r,a0) is very equation may be interpreted as the expansion to first order of a shift ino, so it can be written (B4) Thus the eigenvalues oi lu(0) are related to the diagonalization of the expansion of in Eq. (12). Writing this matrix equation as a function of the r eal spherical 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 to first order in [ a]l>=2, and evaluating the first order 0 we shows that, to first order, only quadrupolar deformations ar e coupled to the transition, and that its effect is a shift of the spectral lin e, as shown in Eq. (B4). 31At variance with the approach of Ref. 29, where the above matrix is approximated by its diagonal expression, implying that only the u= 0 and 2 components of the are considered, our approach incorporates all five c omponents. The relation between the eigenvalues li(r,[a]) ofU(r,[a]) and the coefficients oi lu(0) (B7) Finally, the total spectrum is written (B8) APPENDIX C In this Appendix we consider that the doped drop is cylindrically symme tric. We expand the helium density and ground state wave function into spherical ha rmonics with u= 0 r(r) and ~rl(r) with analogous defini- tions for ~Phlandgl. we can compute the line shape to first order inbl>0(gl>0); in analogy with Eq. (B2) we now by the potential 0 0 0-1 0 0 0 the shape deformations defined in Eq. (A5), to first o rder this matrix a2-12 3~a20 , (C4) where we have defined ~ a20a20+b2C, (C5) These equations show that the computation of the line shape for th is geometry is as in the spherical case but with a shift in the dipole absorption spectrum is finally obtained Stienkemeier and A. F. Vilesov, J. Chem. Phys. 115, 10119 (2001). 2F. Stienkemeier and K. K. Lehmann, J. Phys. B 39, R127 (2006). 3M. Barranco, R. Guardiola, S. Hern' andez, R. Mayol, and M. Pi , J. Low Temp. Phys. 142, 1 (2006). 4M. Mella, G. Calderoni, and F. Cargnoni, J. Chem. Phys. 123, 054328 (2005). 5M. Elhiyani and M. Lewerenz, contribution to the XXII Intern ational Symposium on Molecular Beams, University of Freiburg (2007). 6M. Elhiyani and M. Lewerenz, contribution to the 16th. Sympo sium on Atomic and Surface Physics and Related Topics, Innsbruck University Press (20 08). 7A. Hernando, R. Mayol, M. Pi, M. Barranco, F. Ancilotto, O. B unermann, and F. Stienkemeier, J. Phys. Chem. A 111, 7303 (2007). 8J. Reho, U. Merker, M. R. Radcliff, K. K. Lehmann, and G. Scoles, J. Chem. Phys. 112, Przystawik, S. G ode, J. Tiggesb aumker, and K-H. Meiwes -Broer, contribution to the Symposium on Molecular Beams, University of Freiburg (2007); A. Przystawik, S. G ode, T. D oppner, J. Tiggesb aumker, and K-H. Meiwes-Bro er, submitted to Phys. Rev. Moriwaki and N. Morita, Eur. Phys. J. D 5, 53 (1999). 11Y. Moriwaki, K. Inui, K. Kobayashi, F. Matsushima, and N. Mor ita, J. Mol. Struc. 786, 112 (2006). 12J. P. Toennies and A. F. Vilesov, Angew. Chem. Ind. Ed. 432622 (2004). 13Y. Ren and V. V. Kresin, Phys. Rev. A 76, 043204 (2007). 14J. Tiggesb aumker and F. Stienkemeier, Phys. Chem. Chem. Ph ys.9, 4748 (2007). 15F. Dalfovo, A. Lastri, L. Pricaupenko, S. Stringari, and J. T reiner, Phys. Rev. B 52, Giacomazzi, F. Toigo, and F. Ancilotto, Phys. Rev. B 67, 104501 (2003). 17L. Lehtovaara, T. Kiljunen, and J. Eloranta, J. of Comp. Phys .194, 78 (2004). 18F. Ancilotto, M. Barranco, F. Caupin, R. Mayol, and M. Pi, Phy s. Rev. B 72, 214522 (2005); F. Ancilotto, M. Pi, R. Mayol, M. Barranco, and K. K. Lehmann, J. Phys. Chem. A 111, J. Hinde, J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 36, 3119 (2003). 20H. Partridge, J. R. Stallcop, and E. Levin, J. Chem. Phys. 115, 6471 (2001). 21M. Guilleumas, F. Garcias, M. Barranco, M. Pi, and E. Suraud, Z. Phys. D 26, 385 (1993). 22M. Frigo and S. G. Johnson, Proc. IEEE 93(2), 216 (2005). 23W. H. Press, S. A. Teulosky, W. T. Vetterling, and B. P. Flanne ry,Numerical Recipes in Fortran 77: The Art of Scientific Computing (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1999). 24F. Ancilotto, D. G. Austing, M. Barranco, R. Mayol, K. Muraki , M. Pi, S. Sasaki, and S. Tarucha, Phys. Rev. B 67, 205311 (2003). 25A. Hernando, M. Barranco, R. Mayol, M. Pi, and M. Kro' snicki, Phys. Rev. B 77, 024513 (2008). 26M. Lax, J. Chem. Phys. 20, 1752 (1952). 27F. O. Ellison, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 85, 3540 (1963). 28P. B. Lerner, M. B. Chadwick, and I. M. Sokolov, J. Low Temp. Ph ys.90, 319 (1993). 29T. Kinoshita, K. Fukuda, and T. Yabuzaki, Phys. Rev. B 54, 6600 (1996). 30K. K. Lehmann and A. M. Dokter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 173401 (2004). 3431We have corrected here an obvious error made in Ref. 25. 32F. Stienkemeier, J. Higgins, C. Callegari, S. I. Kanorsky, W . E. Ernst, and G. Scoles, Z. Phys. D38, 253 (1996). 33O. B unermann, G. Droppelmann, A. Hernando, R. Mayol, and F. Stienkemeier, J. Phys. Chem. A111, 12684 (2007). 34The location of the two components of the broad line in liquid helium and in drops is sensibly the same, whereas the relative intensity of the components s eems as exchanged. 35F. Stienkemeier, F. Meier, and H. O. Lutz, J. Chem. Phys. 107, 10816 (1997). 36F. Stienkemeier, F. Meier, and H. O. Lutz, Eur. Phys. J. D 9, 313 (1999). 37Y. Moriwaki and N. Morita, Eur. Phys. J. D 33, 323 (2005). 38W. C. Martin and R. Zalubas, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 9, 1 (1980). 39D. M. Brink, S. Stringari, Z. Phys. D. 15, 257 (1990). 40Since the hydrodynamic mass depends on R, we have compute w(R) using several M*values between M*= 40 a.u., which corresponds to the mass in the bulk liquid, an d the free Mg mass M*= 24 a.u. This yields the band of w(R) values displayed in the figure. 41The mean calculated as approach, andas Ancilotto, P. B. Lerner, and M. W. Cole, J. Low Temp. Phys. 101, 5-6 (1995). 43L. Wilets, Theories of Nuclear Fission (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1964). 44P. Ring and P. Schuck, The Nuclear Many-Body Problem New York, 1980). 45W. B. Fowler and D. L. Dexter, Phys. Rev. 176, 337 (1968). 46H. Gu' erin, J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 25, 3371 (1992). 47M. J. Renne and B. R. A. Nijboer, J. Phys. C 6, L10 (1973). 48E. Cheng, M. W. Cole, and M. H. Cohen, Phys. Rev. B 50, 1136 (1994); Erratum ibid.50, 16134 (1994). 49F. Stienkemeier, O. B unermann, R. Mayol, F. Ancilotto, M. B arranco, and M. Pi, Phys. Rev. B70, 214509 (2004). 50M. Lewerenz, B. Schilling, and J.P. Toennies, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 8191 (1995). 51E.B. Gordon, Low Temp. Phys. 30, 756 (2004). 52J. Eloranta, Phys. Rev. B 77, 134301 (2008). 3553We note at this point that a quantitative estimation of the en ergy barrier height the collapse of two Mg atoms into a dimer is made di fficult by the fact that its actual value is determined by a delicate balance between the Mg-He i nteractions and the long-range part of the Mg-Mg interaction in vacuum, which is affected by so me uncertainty (see Refs. 46,54,55). Any small difference in the van der Waals tail of the Mg-Mg interaction at changeof theestimated barrierheig ht. Besides, wewant also to stress the difficulty to estimate the attempting frequency [inverse of the prefactor multiplying the exponential in Eq. (28)], in view of the kind of configurat ions appearing in this problem, see e.g. Fig. 9. 54E. Czuchaj, M. Kro' sniki, and H. Stoll, Theor. Chem. Acc, 107, 27 (2001). 55E. Tiesinga, S. Kotochigova, and P. S. Julienne, Phys. Rev. A 65, 042722 (2002). 56S. Ogata, J. of Phys. Soc. Jap. 68, 2153 (1999). 57M. Mella, M. C. Colombo, and F. G. Morosi, J. Chem. Phys. 117, 9695 (2002). 58T. Nakatsukasa, K. Yabana, and G. F. Bertsch, Phys. Rev. A 65, 032512 (2002). 59K. K. Lehmann, Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 145301 (2002). 36TABLE I: Atomic shift oof Mg@4He1000(R1/2= 22.2@A) as a function of the average distance between the magnesium atom and the center of mass of Also indicated is wavelength l. The value of the transition energy in the gas phase is 35051 c 280.0 10 642.1 280.2 14 615.8 280.4 18 520.3 281.1 22 492.5 281.4 373 4 5 6 78 9 10 11 12 r (A)-8-6-4-2024V 1: (Color online) X1S Mg-He pair potentials used in this work: squares connected with a solid line, from Ref. 19; circles connected with a dotted lin e, from Ref. 20. 380 500 1000 1500 (K)Mg@4HeN FIG. 2: Energy of the Mg atom as a function of the number of atom s in the drop, obtained using the Mg-He potential of Ref. 19 (squares). The values given in Ref. 7 are also displayed (dots). The lines are drawn to guide the eye. 390 1 2 3 4 5678 9 10 1 2 3 4 5678 9 10 11 Z0(A)012345E (K)Mg@4He50 FIG. 3: (Color online) Bottom panel: total energy (K) of Mg@4He50as a function of Z0(@A) obtained using the Mg-He potential of Ref. 19 (squares) and o f Ref. 20 (circles). The energies are referred to their equilibrium values, -157.0 K and -153.8 K, respectively. The vertical line locates the drop surface at R1/2=r0N1/3, withr0= 2.22@A. The horizontal line has been drawn 0.4 K above the equilibrium energy. Top panel: probability densi ties for the configurations displayed in the bottom panel; the single peak distribution corresponds to the Mg-He interaction of Ref. 20. 40/Minus10 4: (Color online) Helium density plots of the Mg@4He50droplet in the y= 0 plane obtained using the Mg-He potential of Ref. 19. From top to bottom and le ft to right, to the stationary points displayed in Fig. 3, nam ely 0, 2, 4, and 6 @A, respectively. The brighter regions are the higher density (A-3)Z0 = 2 A Z0 = 4 A FIG. 5: (Color online) Helium density profiles of the Mg@4He50droplet along the zaxis obtained using the Mg-He potential of Ref. 19. The Z0value is indicated in each panel. Dashed lines, pure drops; solid lines, doped - R1/2051015 E 6: (Color online) Bottom panel: total energy (K) of Mg@4He1000as a function using the Mg-He potential of Ref. 19 (squares) and o f Ref. 20 (circles). The energies are referred to their equilibrium values, -5482.0 K and -547 6.8 K, respectively. The vertical lines roughly delimit the drop surface region, conventionally de fined as the radial distance between the points wherethe density equals 0.1 rband 0.9rb, beingrb= 0.0218@A-3the bulk liquid density. The horizontal line has been drawn 0.4 K above the equilibrium en ergy. Top panel: total energy (K) of Mg@4HeNwithN= 1000 and 2000 (vertical right scale) as a function of Z0(@A) obtained using the Mg-He potential of Ref. 19. The energies are referred to t heir equilibrium values, -5482.0 K and-11629.8 K, respectively, and the distances (horizontal scale) are referred to the R1/2radius; also shown are the corresponding probability densities (ve rtical left scale): dot(dot-dash) line, N= 1000(2000). The solid line represents the probability den sity of the N= 10000 drop. 4335000 35500 36000 36500 o (cm-1)00.511.5I (arb. omattached the 3s3p1P1-3s2 1S0transition. The line has been decomposed into its two P and on e S components, the former one is the higher frequency transiti on. The starred vertical line represents the gas-phase transition. The experimental curve, adapted for Ref. 8, has been vertically offset for clarity. Also shown is the absorption spectrum obtained neglecting homogeneous 8: (Color online) From top to bottom and left to right, (M con- figurations for Mg-Mg interatomic distances d= 18.5@A, 12.9@A, and 9.3 @A, and total energies -5567.8 K, -5573.9 K, and -5580.3 K, respectively. The botto m right panel shows the configuration at d= 9.5@A with total energy -5581.4 K. The brigther regions are the higher density Mg-Mg Mg-Mg 9: (Color online) Helium density profiles of the (Mg+Mg) 9.5@A) along the z-axis (solid line) and the x- ory-axis (dashed line). 468 9 10 11 12 d (A)010203040E 10: (Color online) Energy (K) of the as a function of the Mg-Mg distance ( @A). The energies have been referred to that of the metastable equilibrium minimum)at L= 0. Thelineshave beenobtained l bottom to top, the curves correspond to L= 0 to 50- hin 10-hsteps. 478 9 10 11 12 13 14 d 11: (Color online) Energy (K) of the as a function of the Mg-Mg distance ( @A). The line has been drawn to guide the eye. 48-30 -20 -1001020 30 z 12: (Color online) Top panel: helium density profiles of the at d= 8.6@A along the z-axis (solid line) andthe x- ory-axis (dashed line). Bottom panel: corresponding to the same configuration. The brigther regions are the higher density ones. 4935000 35500 36000 36500 o (cm-1)00.511.5I (arb. 13: (Color online) Total absorption spectrum of one Mg a tom attached to4He1000in the vicinity of the 3 s3p1P1-3s2 1S0transition in the distorted environment created by the pres ence of another Mg atom. The line has been decomposed into its two P and one S components, the former one is the higher frequency transition. The starred v ertical line represents the The experimental curve, adapted for Ref. 8, has been vertically offset for clarity. Also shown is the absorption spectrum obtained neglecting homog eneous broadening (hatched region) 50
|
0807.1857
|
Alberto Hernando
|
Alberto Hernando, Manuel Barranco, Ricardo Mayol, Marti Pi and
Francesco Ancilotto
|
Magnesium doped helium nanodroplets
| null | null | null | null |
cond-mat.other
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We have studied the structure of $^4$He droplets doped with magnesium atoms
using density functional theory. We have found that the solvation properties of
this system strongly depend on the size of the $^4$He droplet. For small drops,
Mg resides in a deep surface state, whereas for large size drops it is fully
solvated but radially delocalized in their interior. We have studied the $3s3p$
$^1$P$_1 \leftarrow 3s^2$ $^1$S$_0$ transition of the dopant, and have compared
our results with experimental data from laser induced fluorescence (LIF). Line
broadening effects due to the coupling of dynamical deformations of the
surrounding helium with the dipole excitation of the impurity are explicitly
taken into account. We show that the Mg radial delocalization inside large
droplets may help reconcile the apparently contradictory solvation properties
of magnesium as provided by LIF and electron-impact ionization experiments. The
structure of $^4$He drops doped with two magnesium atoms is also studied and
used to interpret the results of resonant two-photon-ionization (R2PI) and LIF
experiments. We have found that the two solvated Mg atoms do not easily merge
into a dimer, but rather form a weakly-bound state due to the presence of an
energy barrier caused by the helium environment that keep them some 9.5 \AA{}
apart, preventing the formation of the Mg$_2$ molecule. From this observation,
we suggest that Mg atoms in $^4$He drops may form, under suitable conditions, a
soft ``foam''-like aggregate rather than coalesce into a compact metallic
cluster. Our findings are in qualitative agreement with recent R2PI
experimental evidences. We predict that, contrarily, Mg atoms adsorbed in
$^3$He droplets do not form such metastable aggregates.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 11 Jul 2008 14:00:19 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-14T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Hernando",
"Alberto",
""
],
[
"Barranco",
"Manuel",
""
],
[
"Mayol",
"Ricardo",
""
],
[
"Pi",
"Marti",
""
],
[
"Ancilotto",
"Francesco",
""
]
] |
I. progress made in epitaxial crystal growth techniques has led to the fabri- cation of novel semiconductor These moder n microstructuring techniques have made possible therealization ofa two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG)system in semi- conductor A 2DEG is a condensed matter sys tem where a number of novel phenomena have been observed over the years. One such phenom enon was the observation of commensurability oscillations in physical properties when the 2DEG in the presence of a magnetic field is subjected to electric modulation. The electric modu lation introduces an additional length scale in the system and the occurrence of these o scillations, commonly known as Weiss oscillations, is due to the commensurability of the elect ron cyclotron diam- eter at the Fermi energy and the period of the electric modulation. These oscillations were found to be periodic in the inverse magnetic field1-3. This type of electrical modulation of the 2D system can be carried out by depositing an array of parallel m etallic strips on the surface or through two interfering laser beams4,5. One of the important electronic properties of such a system is the c ollective Weiss oscillations in the magnetoplasmon spectrum of a 2 DEG has been the subject of continued interest6-9. Recently, the fabrication of crystalline graphene monolay- ers has generated a lot of interest. The study of this new material is not only of but there are serious efforts underway to investigate wh ether Graphene can serve as the basic material for a carbon-based electronics that might repla ce silicon. Graphene has a honeycomb lattice of carbon atoms. The quasiparticles in graphene have a band structure in which electron and hole bands touch at two points in the Brillouin zone . At these Dirac points the quasiparticles obey the massless Dirac equation. In othe r words, they behave as massless Dirac fermions leading to a linear dispersion relation ok=vk( with the charac- teristic velocity v106m/s). This difference between the nature of the quasiparticles in graphene and those in a conventional 2DEG has given rise to a host o f new and such as anomalous quantum Hall effects and a pBerry's phase10-15. These transport experiments have shown results in agreement with the p resence of Dirac fermions. The 2D Dirac-like spectrum was confirmed recently by cyclotron res onance measurements and also by angle resolved photoelectron spectroscopy (ARPES) m easurements in mono- layer graphene16,17. Recent theoretical work on graphene multilayers has also shown t he 2existence of Dirac electrons with a linear energy spectrum in monolay er graphene18. Plas- mons ingraphene were studied asearly asthe recently20-23. In thiswork, we investigate magnetoplasmons in a graphene monolayer when it is su bjected to at finite temperature. In a 2DEG system, as well as in gra phene, plasmons emerge as a result of interactions. In the pres ence of a magnetic field, these magnetoplasmons occur at frequencies that oscillate with th e magnetic field. When this system is subjected to an electric modulation, broadening of th e Landau levels occurs resulting in both inter- and intra- Landau band magnetoplasmons. T he former arise as a result of electronic transitions between different Landau bands, w hereas the latter are due to transitions within a single Landau band. A study of magnetoplasmo ns at zero temper- ature was carried out by us in earlier work24where we showed that the intra-Landau exhibit Weiss oscillations as a result of modulation. P resently, we extend our earlier work by taking into account the effects of temperature on the graphene. The motivation for the finite temperature calculation p resented here is that it allows us to account for SdH oscillations in addition to Weiss oscillations in the magne- toplasmon spectrum and the effects of temperature on them. While working on the dispersion relation for magnetoplasmons in graphene we realized that no calculation for a 2DEG9is available in the literature. In this work, therefore, we also determine the finite temperature dispersion relation for mag netoplasmons in an elec- trically asymptotic expressions arederived that allo w us to show that the magnetoplasmons in graphene are more robust again st temperature compared to those occurring in a conventional 2DEG realized in semiconductor In addition, the characteristic temperatures for damping of the mag netic oscillations (SdH and Weiss) are determined for both the graphene and 2DEG systems. T he experimental study of these should be as revealing as the enhanced magnetoconductiv ity prediction25and even more interesting, since it bears directly on the many-body propert ies of the as well as frequency dependent transport and optical response properties. 3II. TEMPERATURE EFFECTSON THE MAGNETOPLASMON SPECTRUM OF WEAKLY MODULATED GRAPHENE We consider two-dimensional Dirac electrons in graphene moving in th e (x-y)-plane. The magnetic field ( B) is applied along the z-direction perpendicular to the graphene plane. This system is subjected to weak electric modulation along the x-direction. We employ the Landau gaugeand write the vector potential as A= (0,Bx,0). Employing the it has been shown that the Dirac electrons, in the absenc e of the periodic potential and the magnetic field, obey the two dimensional Dirac-like The effect of the magnetic field can be included through the minimal coupling with the result that single electron, Dirac-like Hamiltonian in the Landau g auge the Pauli matrices and vcharacterizes the electron velocity. The complete Hamiltonian of our system is represented as H=H0+V(x) (2) whereH0is the unmodulated Hamiltonian and V(x) is the one-dimensional periodic mod- ulation potential along the x-direction modelled as V(x) =V0cos(Kx) (3) whereK= 2p/a,ais the period of modulation and V0is the constant modulation ampli- tude. Applying standard perturbation theory to determine the fir st order correction to the unmodulated energy eigenvalues in the presence of modulation, we o btain e(n,x0) =ogn+Fncos(Kx0) the cyclotron frequency of Dirac electrons in graphene, nis are Laguerre poly- nomials and the magnetic length. The Landau level spectrum for Dirac electrons in graphene ( en=nog) is significantly different from the spectrum for electrons in a conventional 2DEG, which is given as e(n) where ocis the plasmon spectrum is determined within the E (SCF) approach29. Following reference24the plasmon dispersion relation is given by solving 1 (5) foro, where I1(o) the two dimensional wave number, kis background dielectric constant and f[e(n,x0)] is the Fermi distribution function. This result was obtained previo usly in24where it was used to obtain the zero temperature dispersion relation. Her e we are interested in temperature effects to account for SdH oscillations, in addition to W eiss oscillations, in the magnetoplasmon spectrum. We proceed as follows to determine the finite relation. In the regime of weak modulation, the distributio n function f[e(n,x0)] can be expressed (7) wheref'(x) =d dxf(x). Substituting the above expression for f[e(n,x0)], the integral over x0may be written as I1(o) Ph n= There is also a term with cosines in the numerator, but the resulting integral is easily shown to be zero by symmetry around th=p 2. The first integral in (9) can be solved by rewriting it in terms of a contour integral arou nd a unit circle long as ohas an infinitesimal but non-zero imaginary part, such that one pole always remains inside and one outside the unit circle. If omust be real, however, both poles may 5be on the unit circle and their contributions cancel to leave a principa l value of zero. Either way we deduce that our problem has no real finite solutions for small o. In fact, it has no solution unless ois larger than all of the Ph n. However, this is not the integral we need as it will cancel in the expression I(o)+I(-o). The 2nd integral in (9) may be deduced from (10) (12) which reduces to 2 pforo2<Ph2 nif we use the principal value interpretation of (10). We note that this expression may be expanded in the this back into (5) and concentrating on intra-Landau level plasmons obtain 1 (15) We note, at this point that V0,Fnandoare of similar orders of magnitude (meV), but that, in the long wavelength (small qy) limitx' 0-0 (recall that x' 0=l2qy), Phno. We are therefore justified in taking the leading term in the expansion in (15) , which can be solved to give the intra-Landau band plasmon excitations frequency (~ o) This result will be valid except for low frequencies, where Gg may acquire an odependence and cease to exist before o= 0. The resulting physics can be made more transparent by considering the asymptotic expression for the intra-Landau spectrum, where analytic results can be obtained in terms of obtain an expression for the intra-Landau band plasmon spectr um we employ the following asymptotic expression for the Laguerre that the asymptotic results are valid when many Landau Levels are filled. We now take the continuum (18) Gg, which appears in the expression for ~ o2in equation (16) can be expressed = exp[ the number density, kh=
1 2K2l2= 1/KBT. Assuming that the temperature is sufficiently low that b-1eFand substituting e=eF+sb-1, we rewrite the above the the characteristic damping temperature of the Weiss the expression for Ggin equation(16), the asymptotic expression for the intra- Landau spectrum is the above expression is only valid at high temperature ( KBT >>og/2p2) it is not able to account for the SdH oscillations occurring in the magnetoplasmon spectrum. To take these into account we use the following expression for the density o f states at low magnetic fields in the absence of impurity scattering D(e) = 0. The sum can now be expressed in the continuum approximation the intra-Landau band magnetoplasmon dispersion re lation that takes into ac- count both Weiss and SdH oscillations is given the characteristic damping temperature of the SdH the same approach as given above for a graphene monolaye r, we can obtain the (24) wherem*is the standard electron mass, and Fn(C) =
V0e-kh/2Ln(kh) is the modulationwidth of the conventional 2DEG. The correspond ing asymp- 8totic result we can compare the exact results for the temperature depen dent magnetoplasmon in modulated graphene, as given in equation(23) in terms of the elemen tary functions32,33, with that of a conventional 2DEG derived in equation(25). The differenc es are:
*the standard electron energy eigenvalues scale linearly with the mag netic field whereas those for Dirac electrons in graphene sale as the square root.
*the temperature dependence of the Weiss oscillations, A(T/TW), is clearly different from that of the standard 2DEG, A(T/Tp W).
*the temperature dependence of SdH oscillations in is dif- ferent from that of standard density of states term that contains the cosine function resp onsible for the SdH oscillations has a different dependence in each of the systems: differences will give contrasting results for the temperatur e dependent magneto- plasmon spectrum, as we discuss in the next section. 91 2 3 4 5 6 7 1: plasma frequency as a function of inverse magnetic field in a graphene monolayer at T = 1 K (solid line) and T = 12 K (dashed line). III. DISCUSSION OF RESULTS The finite temperature intra-Landau band magnetoplasmon disper sion relation for elec- trically modulated graphene and 2DEG given by equations (23) and (2 5) are the central results of this work. These results allow us to see clearly the effects of temperature on the Weiss and SdH oscillations in the magnetoplasmon spectrum of the two systems. We find that these two types of oscillations have different characteristic d amping temperatures. This is easily understood if we realize that these oscillations have quite diffe rent origins. The SdH oscillations arise due to the discreteness of the Landau levels and th eir observation requires that the thermal energy KBTof the electrons at temperature Thas to be smaller than the separation between the levels. Weiss oscillations are related to the c ommensurability of two lengths: the size of the cyclotron orbit and the period of the modula tion. These be observed if the spread in the cyclotron diameter is smaller than the period of the modulation. To clarify the effects of temperature we present the m agnetoplasmon spectrum in graphene and 2DEG at two different temperatures in Figs. (1) and (2). In Fig.(1) we show the magnetoplasmon energy as a function of the in verse magnetic field in a graphene monolayer at two different temperatures: T= 1Kand 12K.The were employed for graphene20-25:k= 3,nD= 3.16x1016m-2,v= 106ms-1,a=
380nm and V0= 1.0meV. We also take qx= 0 and qy=.01kF, withkF= (2pnD)1/2. Weiss 101 2 3 4 5 6 7 2: plasma frequency as a function of inverse magnetic field in a convensional 2DEG at T = 0.3 K (solid line) and T = 3 K (dashed superimposed on the SdH oscillations can be clearly seen in b oth the curves. In Eq.(23) the terms containing the characteristic temperature f or Weiss oscillations TW are mainly responsible for Weiss oscillations whereas terms containing TSdHare responsible for the SdH oscillations. The plasmons have fre quencies comparable to the bandwidth and they occur as a result of the broadening of th e Landau levels due to the modulation in the system. This type of pla smons accompanied by regular oscillatory behavior (in 1 /B) of the SdH type was first predicted in34,35for a tunneling planar superlattice where the overlap of the electron wav efunction in adjacent quantum wells provides the mechanism for the broadening of the Lan dau levels. The SdH oscillations occur as a result of the emptying of electrons fromsucc essive Landau levels when they pass through the Fermi level as the magnetic field is increased . The amplitude of is a monotonic function of the magnetic field when the Land au bandwidth is independent of the band index n. In the density modulated case, the Landau as a function of the band index n, with the result that, in the plasmon spectrum of the intra-Landau band type, there is a new kind of oscillation name d Weiss is also periodic in 1 /Bbut with a different period and amplitude from the SdH type oscillation. At T= 12Kwe find that the SdH oscillations are washed out while the Weiss oscillations persist. From Eq.(23) we see that TWandTSdHset the temperatures at which these oscillations will be damped. For the 2DEG the magnetop lasmon energy as 11a function of inverse magnetic field is presented in Fig.(2) at two differ ent temperatures: T= 0.3K and 3K. For a conventional 2DEG (a 2DEG at a GaAs-AlGaAs heter ojunction) we use the following the electron mass), k= 12 and nD= 3.16x1015m-2with the modulation strength and the period as in the graphene system. In this case we find that the SdH oscillations in the magnetop lasmon spectrum die out atT= 3K, while they are present at a higher temperature (12K) in graph 3: plasma frequency as a function of inverse magnetic field: solid line at T= 5 K in a graphene monolayer; dashed (T = 5 K) and dotted (T = 1 K) in standard 2DEG. To compare the results for the two systems we show in Fig.(3) the ma as a function of inverse magnetic field (B' B=
Bea2, whereB'=
ea2= 0.0046Tesla) for both graphene (solid line at temperature 5K) and the 2DEG (dot ted and dashed line at temperature 1K and 5K respectively). The oscillations in the conv entional 2DEG have been damped out strongly at 5K but these are well resolved, signific ant and have large amplitude in graphene at the same temperature. This confirms that graphene oscillations are robust and enhanced against temperature compared to thos e in a conventional 2DEG. The magnetic oscillations, SdH and Weiss, have a greater amplitude in g raphene compared to a 2DEG. This can be attributed to the larger characteristic veloc in graphene compared to the Fermi velocity of standard electrons as well as the smaller constant characteristic temperatures for Weiss oscillations in the two sy ratio of the characteristic temperatures is equal to that of t he corresponding velocities at the Fermi surface25. For the parameters used in this work Tp W/TW~0.24, implying that Weiss oscillations are damped at a higher temperature in graphe ne compared to the 2DEG. Similarly, the damping of SdH oscillations can also be compared in t he two systems through their corresponding characteristic temperatures: for nD= it is ~0.74 fornD= 3.16x1016m-2. Hence SdH oscillations are damped at a higher temperature in graphene compared to a 2DE G. Furthermore, our results show that these oscillations in the magnetoplasmon spectru m differ in phase by pin the two systems, which is due to quasiparticles in graphene acquiring a Berry's phase of p as they move in the magnetic field12-15. IV. CONCLUSIONS We have determined the finite temperature intra-Landau band mag netoplasmon fre- quency for both electrically modulated graphene and for a 2DEG in th e presence of a magnetic field, by employing the SCF approach. We find that the magn etic and Weiss) in the magnetoplasmon spectrum in a graphene mono layer have a higher amplitude compared to the conventional 2DEG realized in semiconduc tor Moreover, these oscillations persist at a higher temperature in gra phene compared to the 2DEG. Hence they are more robust against temperature in graphe ne. Furthermore, the p Berry's phase acquired by the Dirac electrons leads to pphase shift in the ma in a graphene monolayer compared to a 2DEG. One of us (K. Sabeeh) would like to acknowledge the support of the H igher (HEC) of Pakistan through project No. 20-1484/R&D/ 09. M. Tahir would like to acknowledge the support of the Pakistan Higher Education Comm ission (HEC).
*E-mail: W. Winkler, J. P. Kotthaus, and K. Ploog, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 1177 (1989). 132P. Vasilopoulos and F. M. Peeters, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 2120 (1989). 3F. M. Peeters and P. Vasilopoulos, Phys. Rev. B 46, 4667 (1992). 4R. R. Gerhardts, D. Weiss, and K. v. Klitzing, Phys. Rev. Lett .62, 1173 (1989). 5D. Weiss, K. v. Klitzing, K. Ploog, and G. Weimann ,Europhys. Lett., 8, 179 (1989). 6O. G. Balev, N. Studart, P. Vasilopoulos, Phys. Rev. B 62, 15834 (2000). 7M.S. Kushwaha, Surface Science Reports 41,1 (2001) and references therein. 8M. S. Kushwaha and H. Sakaki, Phys. Rev. B 69, 155331 (2004). 9H. L. Cui, V. Fessatidis and N. J. M. Horing, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 2598 (1989). 10K. S. Novoselov, A. K. Geim, S. V. Morozov, D. Jiang, M. I. Kats nelson, I. V. Grigorieva, S. V. Dubonos, and A. A. Firsov, Nature 438,197 (2005). 11Y. Zhang, Y. W. Tan, H. L. Stormer, and P. Kim, Nature 438, 201 (2005). 12Y. Zheng and T. Ando, Phys. Rev. B 65, 245420 (2002). 13V. P. Gusynin and S. G. Sharapov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 146801 (2005). 14N. M. R. Perez, F. Guinea, and A. H. Castro Neto, Phys. Rev. B 73, 125411 (2006). 15M. I. Katsnelson, K. S. Novoselov, and A. K. Geim, Nat. Phys. 2, 620 (2006). 16R. S. Deacon, K-C. Chuang, R. J. Nicholas, K. S. Novoselov, an d A. K. Geim, Phys. Rev. B 76, 081406(R) (2007). 17S. Y. Zhou, G.-H. Gweon, J. Graf, A. V. Fedorov, C. D. Spataru, R. D. Diehl, Y. Kopelevich, D. H. Lee, S. G. Louie, and A. Lanzara, Nat. Phys. 2, 595 (2006). 18B. Partoens and F. M. Peeters, Phys. Rev. B 75, 193402 (2007). 19K. W. -K. Shung, Phys. Rev. B 34,979 (1986). 20M. -F. Lin, F. -L. Shyu, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 69, 607 (2000). 21V. Apalkov, X.-F. Wang and T. Chakraborty, Int. J. Mod. Phys. B21,1167 (2007). 22E. H. Hwang and S. Das Sarma, Phys. Rev. B 75, 205418 (2007). 23X.-F. Wang and T. Chakraborty, Phys. Rev. B 75, 033408 (2007). 24M. Tahir, K. Sabeeh, Phys. Rev. B 76, 195416 (2007). 25A. Matulis and F. M. Peeters, Phys. Rev. B 75, 125429 (2007). 26A. H. Castro Neto, F. Guinea, N. M. R. Peres, K. S. Novoselov an d A. K. Geim, Rev. Mod. Phys. 81, 109 (2009) and references V.Apalkovb; J.Berashevicha; K.Zieglerc Advances in Physics 59, 261 (2010) and references therein. 1428J. C. Slonczewski and P. R. Weiss, Phys. Rev. 109, 272 (1958). 29H. Ehrenreich and M. H. Cohen, Phys. Rev. 115, 786 (1959). 30V. P. Gusynin and S. G. Sharapov, Phys. Rev. B 71 125124 (2005) . 31S. G. Sharapov, V. P. Gusynin and H. Beck, Phys. Rev. B 69 07510 4 (2004). 32R. B. Dingle, Proc. R. Soc. A 211, Isihara and Ludvig Smrcka, J. Physics. C: Solid State P hys. 19, 6777 (1986). 34W. M. Que and G. Kirczenow, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62,1687 (1989). 35W. M. Que and G. Kirczenow, Phys. Rev. B 36, 6596 (1987). 15
|
0807.1894
|
Muhammad Tahir
|
M. Tahir, K. Sabeeh, and A. MacKinnon
|
Temperature effects on magnetoplasmon spectrum of a weakly modulated
graphene monolayer
|
11 pages, 3 figures, Accepted in J. Phys. Condensed matter
| null | null | null |
cond-mat.mes-hall
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this work, we determine the effects of temperature on the magnetoplasmon
spectrum of an electrically modulated graphene monolayer as well as the
two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG). The intra-Landau-band magnetoplasmon
spectrum within the Self Consistent Field (SCF) approach is investigated for
both the aforementioned systems. Results obtained not only exhibit Shubnikov-de
Hass (SdH) oscillations but also commensurability oscillations (Weiss
oscillations). These oscillations are periodic as a function of inverse
magnetic field. We find that both the magnetic oscillations, SdH and Weiss,
have a greater amplitude and are more robust against temperature in graphene
compared to conventional 2DEG. Furthermore, there is a $\pi$ phase shift
between the magnetoplasmon oscillations in the two systems which can be
attributed to Dirac electrons in graphene acquiring a Berry's phase as they
traverse a closed path in a magnetic field.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 11 Jul 2008 17:11:32 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 22 Sep 2011 13:02:26 GMT"
}
] | 2011-09-23T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Tahir",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Sabeeh",
"K.",
""
],
[
"MacKinnon",
"A.",
""
]
] |
change in the wavevector of the photon in th e scattering process a nd the other above the incident light frequency arisi ng from the preferred s cattering of an atom to an already occupied s tate of the BEC. Light scatteri ng from a weakly inte racting BEC has been considered by Graham and W alls [7]. They fou nd that at large detuning, light scattering shows two symm etrically placed p eaks whose in tensities are related by detailed b alance and their frequencies depend on the product of the scattering length and total num ber of atom s within the condensate. Th e weak coherent light scatteri ng off a BEC in the lim it of a very large trap ( 1 ,133
>> >>
aN aD Dwhere denotes total num ber of condensate atom s, is the resonance wavelength and is the size of the trap's ground state) have been considered in [8, 9]. It has been found that there exists a gap in the excitation spectrum , due to m ixing of the atom ic and photonic deg rees of freedom . Because of this g ap the resonant light will be strongly reflected ba ck from the sharp boundary of the condensate. Induced and spontaneous optical processes in a condensate of an ideal (noninteracting) Bose gas in the lim it of a sm all trap N D a )1 ,1 (33
>> <<
aN aD Dhave been discussed by Javanainen [10]. He found that , in the steady state regim e, a sm all num ber of atom s remain in the excited s tate and th e num ber of scattered photons has a Lorentzian line shape centered at the b are atom ic resona nce transition frequency. You and coworkers [11] have been dem onstrated th at in the interm ediate regim e )1 ,1 (33
aN aD Dthe resu lts are significantly m odified. They found that the line shape is non-Lore ntzian and in som e circum stanc es exhib its addition al interesting f eatures. Band [ 12] has bee n conside red the excitation spectrum of the BEC in a harm onic oscillato r potential and the ex ternal magnetic field. He found that the intensities of the scattering peaks depend strongly on temperature. The tem perature depen dence of the relative an d absolute intensities of the peaks is a strong indication of BEC. In Ref. [13], it has been pointed out that the lim iting of sm all number of atom s within the BEC co uld lead to sign ificant changes in the spectrum of light scattered from a BEC. The funda mental approach in the descrip tion of BEC is the Bogoliubov m ethod [14], in which the operators for cond ensate ato ms are rep laced by c-num bers. T his approxim ation breaks symm etry of the resultin g approxim ate Ham iltonian, i.e., the total number of atom s, may not be conserved. Gardiner [15] solved this problem by introducing the exciton operators which conserv e the total num ber of atom sand satisfy an -deform ed comm utation relation. As N N f -N the standard boso nic commutation relation is regain ed. Recently, the case of the finite n umber of atom s has been investigated [16]. It provides a physi cal and natural re alization of the -deformed boson [16] by using the Gardiner's phonon operators for the descripti on of BEC. In the last fe w years, there have attracted a gr eat deal of interest in quantum groups and their associated algebra, which are specific deform ations of Lie algebra. Algebraic m odels have been used very successfully in several research areas of physics and m athem atics such as exactly solvable s tatistical models [ 17], non commutative geom etry [18], nuclear quantum many body problem s [19] and rational conform al field theo ries [20]. Recent interest in quantum groups has le d to introduce the concept of -defor med boson oscillators [21, 22, 23] which are defor mations of standard bosonic harmonic oscillator f q 2algebra. The -deform ed boson oscillator has been in terpreted as a non linear oscillator with a very specific type of nonlinearity whic h classically correspon ds to an intensity dependence of the oscillator frequency [24]. In addition, a general type of nonline arity for which the intensity dep endence of frequency of oscillation s is describ ed by a generic function , the so-called -defor mation, has been introduced [ 25]. One of the m ost important properties of -defor med bosons is their relatio n to nonlinearity of a special type [26]. The relation between deform ed radiation field and nonlinear quantum optical processes has been s tudied [27]. Recently, n ew insight into d escrip tion of BEC has been obtained by understanding and applying the -defor med bos ons. The type of quantum nonlinearity introduced by -deformation provides a com pact description of physical effects in BEC. For exam ple, it has been revealed how -defor med BEC produces a correction to the Plank distribut ion for mula [24, 26]. In Ref. [26] it has been shown that the quantum nonlinearity introduced by -defor mation, changes the specific heat behavior. It is reasonable to expect that th e spectrum of light scattered from a BEC is modified in the presence of deform ations. In Ref. [13] it has been pointed out that intrinsic deform ation due to the number of condensate atom s, extensively chang es the spectrum of light scattered from a BEC. W e have been recently shown [28] that the collisions ef fect tra nsforms the standa rd harm onic oscillator m odel into an -deformed one. It is useful to ask how the results of Re f. [13] are m odified by considering the effect of collis ions between the atom s within the condensate as a sp ecial kind of - defor mation. q )^(nf this paper, we are inte nded to study the spectrum of light scattered from atoms within an -defor med BEC. The system under consideration is an -defor med BEC of a trapped atom ic gas com posed of two-leve l atom s, in which the Gardiner's phonon operators for BEC are defor med by an operator-valued function . By considering the effect of collis ions b etween the a toms with in the cond ensate as a sp ecial kind of- deformation , in which the collis ion rate f f )^(nf f k is rega rded as the def ormation param eter, we study the spectrum of li ght scattered from -deform ed BEC. Such a system offers extra degrees of flexibility f ),(Nk for the response of -deform ed BEC to the laser light. We show that the -deformed BEC exhibits non linea r cha racteristics, s uch tha t the nonlinea rity incre ases by adjus ting th e def ormation param etersf f ),(Nk and the nonlinea rity may lead to a deviation from the t ypical predicted spectrum 's shape. The present paper is organized as follows. In section 2 we present our model and we give an an alytical exp ression fo r the light sca ttered from the -deform ed BEC. W e use the deform ation algebra to st udy the condensate with large but finite num ber of atom s. Here the defor mation param eter is no longer phenom enologi cal and is defined by the total num ber of atom s. We show that the at omic collisions within the condensate can be regarded as an extra defor mation on the intrinsically defor med Gardiner's phonon operators for BEC. In th e presence of atom ic collisions within the condensate, we analyze the light scattering from the -deform ed BEC. Summ ary and conclusions are given in section 3 f f 3 2 The mod el and an alytical solut ion for spectrum of light scattered from an -deformed BEC f We consider a system consisting of w eakly interacting BEC of two-leve l atoms in a trap inte racting reson antly w ith a classical radiation fiel d. W e introdu ce the cre ation and annihilation operators and , resp ectively, for the a toms in th e exc ited (ground) state. The frequency of the laser field is denoted by)^(^++ab )^(^ab o. Moreover, we consider a reservo ir, beside the classical driving fiel d. The reservoir m ay be taken as any large colle ction of system s with m any degrees of freedom . We assum e that th e reservoir consists of m any phonon m odes w ith closely spaced frequencies and creation (annih ilation) opera tors . Therefore, under the rota ting wave approxim ation, the total Ham iltonian can be written as kohm )^(^k kcc+
],^^^ ^^^[)( ^^ ]^^)( ^^)([^^ ^ bac cabk cc batgabtg bb Hk k kkk kk++ + + +* + ++ +ohm+ + += x o h h h (1) where, )(kx is the coupling coefficient pertaining to the internal atom ic states and is given by , where is the coupling coef ficient for th e class ical field. )(tg ) exp( ti gohm- g It should be noted that in the a bove Ham iltonian the total number of atom s is conserved ( ). To deal with the dynam ics of BEC t he Bogoliubov approxim ation [14] is usually app lied, in which the crea tion and annihilation operato rs and of the ground sate are substituted byaabbN ^^^^ + ++= 0]^,^[=HN
+a^ a^cN, where is the num ber of initial condensate atom s. In this lim it, the Ham iltonian (1) can be written as cN ].^^ ^^[)( ^^ ]^)( ^)([ ^^ ^ bc cbk N cc btg btgN bb Hk k kc kk kk c+ + + *+ ++ +ohm++ += x o h h h (2) The fast frequency dependence of can be elim inated by tr ansfor ming to the slowly varying annihilation operator )(^tb .)(^)(~^ tietbtbohm= (3) The creatio n and ann ihilation op erators )(~^tb+and )(~^tbobey the bosonic commutation relation 1)](~^),(~^[ =+tbtb (4) We can therefore write the Heisenberg equation of m otion for the operator )(~^tb in the following form ),(~^)(^2 )(~^)(~^tb tb Nigtbi tbin c G-G+--=&
(5) where ohm-=o , the dam ping rate G is given by cNg=G [6] with g as the one-atom line width and is the vacuum noise operator, having the following correlation properties )(^tbin ). ( )(^)(^,0)(^)(^ )(^)(^
tt tbtbtbtb tbtb in inin in in in '-='=' ='
+++
d (6) 4 In steady -state reg ime, by usi ng sem iclassical approxim ation )(~^ )(~^
0 tb tb db+= , Eq. (5) can be solved and we get , (7) ).(^2)(~^ tbitbin+GG=d (8) Therefore we obtain the Fourie r com ponent of the operator )(~^tbd in the followin g form ).(^2)(~^ o odinbib+GG= (9) Now, we gi ve an analy tical exp ression for the spectrum of light scattered from the BEC. According to [6], the spectrum has been obt ained by calculating correlation functions for the m atter field operators. Hence in the steady -state regim e, the standard definition of the spectrum is ' '=+)(~^)(~^ )( ododoo b b d S . (10) By using Eqs. (6) and (10) we obtain 0)(=oS . This means that in the long tim e limit, only the equal tim e correlations survive. As pointed out before, to deal w ith the dynam ics of BEC the Bogoliubov approxim ation is usually applied. One conseque nce of this ap proxim ation is that the total number of atom s may not be conserved. To avoid this difficultly, the f ollowing Gardiner's phonon operators are introduced [15] .^^1^ ,^^1^ + + += = ba Nbba Nbq q (11) Gardiner's phonon operators obey th e deform ed commutation relation [] ,^^21^^21 ^,^ bb bbNbbq q+ + +-=-= e (12) with N1=e . When 0-e or-N , the standard (nondefor med) bosonic comm utation relation is r egained. In general the deform ed opera tor is related to nondeformed operator through an operator valued function as ^
1eee q bbfb b+= (13) In our particular case, w e have .)1^^(1 );^^(1 --=+ +
ee ee bb bbf ee (14) Here the defor mation param eter is no longer phenom enologi cal and is defined by the total num ber of atom s. For sm all defo rmation, the deform ed boson operators and could be expressed in term s of the standard bosonic operators and as +
qb^
qb^ +b^ b^)1]^,^([=+bb 5.^^^
21^ ^)]1^^(21[ ^
bbbNb b bb bbbbNb bb b b qq
++ ++ + ++ +
-=---=-- ee (15) Now, we consider the ef fect of collisions betwe en the atom s within the condensate as a special kind of -defor mation. For this purpose, w e remind the basic about -deform ed oscillators in the following subsection. f f 2-1 -Deformed oscillator algebra f The -deformed oscilla tor alg ebra is dete rmined by the following com mutation relations f or crea tion an d annihilation and the num ber operator N^
,^]^,^[ ^ ]^,^[+ += -= A AN A AN (16) and the nonlinear relations ],1^[ ^^ ]^[^^ += =+ +N AA N AA (17) where the n otation is defined as ][x , ][1-- --=qqq qxx x (18) and is the d eformation param eter. A four-par ameter generalized deform ed algebra has been introduced in Ref. [29] q .^]^,^[ ^ ]^,^[ ^^ ^^^ + + + + += -= =- A AN A AN qAAq AANba g (19) where ba,and g are real p arameters. Man'ko and co workers [25] introduced the - defor med oscillator operators, defined as a nonlinear expansion of the standard harmonic oscillato r operato rs and , ^),^(^^ aaNaNf ANfaA+ + *+ = = (20) The function is specific to each d eformed alge bra. This function d etermines the form of nonlinearities of the system under cons ideration and depends on four parameters )^(Nf gba,, and . As an exam ple, we consider the Hamiltonia n for the f ree -oscillator q f ].^)^( 20 0NNf N Nf AAAA NH +++ =+ =+ + o o h h (21) Using the algebra (19) and defor mation (20) we get . , , ^ )^( )1^(^ ab NN N qq qq q Nq Nf (22) By introducing new deform ation param eters we obtain , , , [ exp{
) sinh(^)^ sinh()^(2 -+ = N NNNf ubt tutu (23) and the H amiltonian of the f ree -oscilla tor (21 ) can be w ritten explic itly as f 6}.) sinh()^ sinh( ) sinh(])1^[ sinh({2^)^ ( 0 tutu tutu otu ubt NeNe HN - +++=h (24) We shall ap ply th ese res ults in the following su bsection to illustra te the atom ic collisions within the condensate as a specific kind of -deform ation. f 2-2 An example: the collisions effect As a pa rticular physic al ex ample, we c onsider the ato mic collis ions with in the condensate. The effectiv e inte raction Ham iltonian contain s a nonlinea r term proportional to [30, 31], 2)^^(aa+
2)^^(2^ aa HI+=kh, (25) where the collision r ate is denoted by k. From kinetic theory, the collision r ate is , where rmsva2rpk r is the density of the atom s, is the scattering length and is the roo t-mean square-speed of the atom s. By expanding the Ham iltonian (21) and considering sm all values ofarmsv u and we obtain 2u )],, ,( ,( 2 2 2 2 04 2 2 2 2 2 0 uuuu uuuuouuuu uuuo O NN N NO N N N NH
+- +++++= +++++ =
hh (26) where the in teraction Ham iltonian reads as 2 2 0N N NHI uuuo++ h (27) The Ha miltonian (27) reproduces th e Ham iltonian (25) by setting and02=u 02oku= . Thus, w e see tha t the atom ic collision s effect transform s the standard (non linear) harm onic oscillato r model into an -defor med one. Alternatively, we could set, ab initio in Eq. (2 1),f ) 1(^ )^( kk-+= N Nf to ob tain the Hamiltonian (25). Theref ore, the param eters of the gen eralized d eform ed al gebra are related to the rate of atom ic collisionsk. As an inter esting po int w e note th at w hen and uu 32-=
02 ouk= the Hamiltonian (26) reproduces the Kerr-like Ham iltonian, wh ere the m onochrom atic field Hamiltonian contains, to lowest or der, a nonlinear term proportional to )1 0-++ = NNkN N HKerroh (28) Therefore o ne can infer that up to the first order approxim ation th e non linea rity of the models under consideration due to the atom ic collisions w ithin the condensate m ay be describ ed as Kerr-typ e nonlinea rity. Subsequently, by considering th e effect of collis ions be tween the atom s within condensate, we can apply the extra defor mation on the intrinsically deform ed Gardiner's phonon operators for BEC by an operator-valued function ) 1(^ )^(2 kk-+= n nf of the particle num ber operator n. Here the n onlinea rity is rela ted to the collision s betw een th e ^
7atom s within condensate. The operator valued- function reduces to 1 as soon as )^(2nf .0-k It means tha t the def ormation incre ases with th e collision ratek. The defor med Gardiner's phonon operators and are related to the operators and thorough the operator valued-f unction as )^(2nf .^^ ^^,^)^( ),^(^ ^
2 2 qq qq q q q bb Nnbnf Bnfb B
+++ +
=== =
(29) Therefore th e deform ed version of th e Hamiltonian (2) c an be written as ].^^ ^^[)( ^^ ]^)( ^)([ ^^ ^ bc cbk N cc Btg BtgN BB Hk k kc kk kk c+ + + *+ ++ +ohm++ + = x o h h h (30) Note that, in the las t term of r.h.s of Eq. (30), the nonline ar char acter of has been neglected due to the weak-coupling assum ption with the reservoir. qB^
For sm all defor mation, we obtain .^)]^^1(21[^ )],^^1(21[^ ^++ + +--= --=q qq q qq q q bbb B bb b Bk k (31) By keeping only the lowest order of N1=e for very large total number of atom s and by keeping only the first-order term of the collision ra te N kfor very low tem perature w e get BbbbbNbb bbbNb B qq
++ + ++ + +++ + +
- ------ - kk (32) By assum ing all the ato ms are initially in the co ndensate ph ase we get and thus by using Eq. (32) the defor med Ham iltonian (30) can be expressed in term s of the nondefor med operators band as follows cNN=
^ +b^
.].. ^^[)( ^^ .]. ^^^)2)(([.]. ^)([ ^^^^) ( ^^ ^
cH cbk N cc cHbbb tgNcH btgN bbbb bb H k kkk kkeff
+ +ohm++-++ + -+=
+ + +++ ++ +
xekekoo h hh hh (33) Now, we consider the Heisenberg equations of motion f or the relevan t operato rs with the Hamiltonian (33) ),(^)( ))(^)(^)(^2)(2( )( )()(^)(^) (2)(^ ]^,^[^
22 tck Ni tbtbtb NtigNtigtbtb i tbi ---= -=
++
xekekooh&
(34) ).(^)( )(^ ]^,^[ ^ tbkNitci Hcickk eff k k x-ohm-= -=h& (35) The equation of m otion for the reservoir operator can be for mally integrated to yield )(^tck 8, )(^ )( )0(^)(^) ( 0tt it cti k kk ketbtdk Ni e ctc'-ohm- ohm-'' - = x (36) where, the first term describes the free evol ution of the reservoir m odes and the second term arise s from their in teraction w ith the harm onic oscilla tor. The re servoir operator can be rem oved by substituting the formal solution of into Eq. ( 34). By using the defin ition (3) we obtain )(^tck )(^tck , )(~^ )( )()~^~^~^2(2) (~^~^) (2)(~^ )(~^
) )( ( 02~2 2 tt it kbketbtdk NNtfbbb NigNig bb i tbi tb '-ohm-ohm-+ +
'' - ++--- ---=
xekeko&
(37) . )0(^)( )(^ ) (~ohm-ohm--=
kt i k bke ck i tf x (38) Here, is a n oise ope rator because it depends on the rese rvoir ope rator . The fluctuations in the exp ectation values i nvolving the harmonic os cillator operator will therefore depend on the evolution of the rese rvoir ope rators. The noise opera tor v aries rapidly due to the presence of all th e reservo ir frequencies. )(^tfb )0(^kc In view of the W eisskopf- Wigner approxim ation, the summation in Eq. (37) yields a s ) (tt'-d function and the integration can then be carried o ut. Therefore we obtain Ntb etbtdk Ntt it kk)(~^
21)(~^ )() )( ( 02s x '''-ohm-ohm- , (39) where, s is the dam ping consta nt and defined as Dxps (40) Here, the density of , with Vas the quantiz ation v olume, and cohmohmxx)( is the cou pling cons tant evaluated at ckohm= . It is possible to m ake the substitutions )(~^ )(~^
21tb NtbcG=s and )(^2 )(^~ tb Ntfin c bG= , so w e can rewrite Eq. (37 ) in the f ollowing form ).(~^ )(^2)~^~^~^2(2) (~^~^) (2)(~^ )(~^ 2 2 tb tbbbb NigNig bb i tbi + ekeko&
(41) As 0 ,-ek the linear equation (5) is recovered. In steady-state by using the semiclassical approxim ation, )(~^ )(~^ tb tb db+= we get 02) ( 2) (2 ) (22 2 2=G--------- bbekbekbbekob gNi gNi gNi i i (42) By solving the above equation, we get the steady -state value of the fi eld. The solution of the Eq. (42) reduces to E q. (7) as soo n as 0 ,-ek , as depicted in Figs 1 and 2. 9By keeping only the first orde r term of the fluctuation )(~^tbd the dynam ics of the sm all fluctuations is given by ),(^2 )(~^ )(~^ )(~^ tb tbBtbAtbinG+ +=+ddd&
(43) where .) (2 ) (,) (4) )( =--+- +G--=*
i gNiBi gNi i A (44) Therefore, the Fourier co mponent of the operator )(~^tbd reads )},(^ )(^] {[)(1)(~^ oo oood+ *+ - =in in bB bA iEb (45) where ). ( )(2 2 2 *+---= AAi B A E oo o (46) Finally, by using Eqs. (6) and (45) the spectrum of light scattered from the -deform ed BEC under consideration is obtained as f . )()(~^)(~^ )(22 oododoo EBb b d S =' '=+ (47) When the lim it 0 ,-ek is taken, the result of Eq. (10), ,0)(=oS is recovered. In Fig 3, we show the three-di mensional plot of the spectrum as a function of norm alized frequency S go/and total number of at oms in the absence of atom ic collisionsN ).0 (=k We see that the spectrum vanishes for S ) (0-- Ne . The spectrum shows a peak with decrea sing th e number of ato ms, since th e increas ing in deformation param eter S e results in large nonlinearity, which m ay lead to observable effects on th e spectrum of the s cattered light. To observe the co llisions effect, for a given number of atom s, we need to p lot the spectrum as a function of norm alized frequency S go/ and the co llision r atek. This is sh own in Fig 4. W e see that the sp ectrum incre ases w ith th e def ormation param eter S k. The reason is due to the fact that consider ing the ef fect of collisio ns betw een the atom s within the BEC requires a defor mation of the bosonic field [26]. Hen ce the pres ence of nonlinearity leads to a deviation from the usual predicted spectrum 's shape. In the absence of atom ic collisions the resu lts of Ref. [13] is recove red. 3 Summary and conclusions In summ ary, we have studied the sp ectrum of light scattered from an -deform ed BEC of a gas of two-level atom s in which the Gardiner's phonon operators are deform ed by an operator-valued function , of the par ticle-number opera tor . By c onsidering the ef fect of collision s betw een the atom s within the cond ensate, w e have applie d the extra deform ation on the intrinsically defo rmed Gardiner's phonon operators for BEC. We have found that the presence of defor mation param eters f )^(nf n^
e and kintrodu ce nonlinea rity, which m ay lead to observable effects on the sp ectrum of light scattered. Also, we have found that the deformation param eters e and kplay an importan t role in 10determ ining the sp ectrum of light scatter ed from the BEC. The scattering spectrum vanishes for 0 ,-ek . i. e., in the absence of deform ations the usual predic ted spectrum 's shape is reco vered. A s pointed ou t before, the co llision r ate is . Theref ore w e can adjus t the value o f the collis ion ratermsva2rpk k by changing the density of the BEC. For exam ple, lowering th e tem peratu re of the BEC increases th e condensate density r , hence increas es the collision rate k, leading to increasing of defor mation. The - defor med BEC exhibits nonlinea r characteristics and the non linearity leads to a deviation from the usual pred icted spectrum 's shape. f References [1] M. H. Anderson, J. R. Ensher, M. R. Ma tthews, C.E. W ieman and E. A. Cornell, Science 269, 198 (1995). [2] C. C. Bradley, C . A. Saskett, J. J. Toelle t and R . G. Hulet, Phys. R ev. Lett. 75, 1687 (1995). [3] K. B. Da vis, M. O. Mewes, M. R. Ander son, N. J. van Dur ten, D. S. Dur fee, D. M. Kurn and W . Ketterle, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 3969 (1995). [4] T. C. Killian, D. G. Fried, L. W illmann, D. Landhuis, S. C. Moss, T. J. Greytak an d D. Kleppner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 3807 (1998). [5] A. Robert, O. Sirjean, A. Browaeys, J. Poupard, S. Nowak, D. Boiron, C . I. Westbrook and A. Aspect, Science 292, 461 (2001). [6] J. Javanainen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1927 (1995). [7] R. Graham and D. F. W alls, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 1774 (1996). [8] B. Svistunov and G. Shlya pnikov, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 97, 821 (1990). [9] H. D. Politzer, Phys. Rev. A. 43, 6444 (1991). [10] J. Javanainen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 2375 (1994). [11] L. You, M. Lewnestein and J. C ooper, Phys. Rev. A 50, R3565 (1994). [12] Y. B. Band, Brazilian J. Phys. 27, 147 (1996). [13] S. Mancini and V. I. Man'ko, P hys. Lett. A 259 ,66 (1999). [14] N. N. Bogoliubov, J. Phys. (USSR) 11, 23 (1947). [15] C. W . Gardiner, Phys. Rev. A 56, 1414 (1997). [16] X. X. Liu, C. P. Sun, S. X. Yu a nd D. L. Zhou, Phys. Rev. A 63, 023802 (2001). 11 [17] V. Pasquier, H. Saleur, Nucl. Phys. B 330, 523 (1990). [18] J. W ess and B. Zumino, Nucl. Phys. B 18, 302 (1990). [19] K. D. Sviratcheva, C. Bahri, A. I. Georgieva and J. P. Dr aayer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 152501 (2004). [20] L. Alvarez-Gaum e, C. Gom ez and G. Sierra, Nucl. Phys. B 330, 347 (1990). [21] L. C. Biedenharn, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 22, L873 (1989). [22] A. J. Macfarlane, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 22, 4581 (1989). [23] M. Cha ichian and P. Kulish, Phys. Lett. B 234, 72 (1990). [24] V. I. Man'ko, G. Marm o, S. Sol imeno and F. Zaccaria, Int. J. Mod. P hys. A 8, 3577 (1993). [25] V. I. Man'ko, G. Marm o, S. Sol imeno and F. Zaccaria, P hys.Lett. A 176, 173 (1993). [26] V. I. Man'ko, G. Marm o, F. Zac caria and C. G. Sudarshan, Physica S cripta 55, 523 (1997). [27] M. H. Naderi, M. Soltanolkotabi a nd R. Roknizadeh, J. Phys. Soc. Japan , 73, 2413 (2004). [28] Z. Haghshenasfard, M. H. Naderi a nd M. S oltanolkotabi, ep rint quant-ph/ 0801. 2440. [29] V. V. Borzov, E. V. Da maskinsky and S .B. Yegorov, J. Math. Sci. 100, 2061 (2000). [30] T. W ong, M. J. Collett and D. F. W alls, Phys. Rev. A 54, R3718 (1996). [31] C. W . Gardiner, A. S. Par kins and P. Zoller, Phys. Rev. A 46, 4363 (1992). 12Figure captions Fig. 1. The quantity 0bb- as a f unction of the total n umber of atom s forNk=0 (no collision ) and , 0= 50 /,5.2 = = gog g and .2) arg() arg(0pbb == Fig. 2. The quantity 0bb- as a function of the collision rate k ,when the to tal number of atom s and the values of other param eters are the sam e as those in Fig. 1. 100=N Fig. 3. The spectrum )(oS of light scattered from BEC as a funct ion of the total num ber of atom s and the norm alized frequency N go/ in the c ase of no co llision (k=0). Other param eters are the sam e as those in Fig. 1. Fig. 4. The spectrum )(oS of light scatte red from BEC as a f unction of the c ollision r ate k and the norm alized frequency go/ when the tota l num ber of atom s . Other param eters are the sam e as those in Fig. 1. 100=N 13 14 15 16 17
|
0807.1910
|
Zahra Haghshenasfard
|
Z. Haghshenasfard, M. H. Naderi and M. Soltanolkotabi
|
Influence of atomic collisions on spectrum of light scattered from an
f-deformed Bose-Einstein condensate
|
17 pages, 4figures
| null |
10.1088/0953-4075/42/6/065505
| null |
quant-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this paper, we investigate the spectrum of light scattered from a
Bose-Einstein condensate in the framework of f-deformed boson. We use an
f-deformed quantum model in which the Gardiners phonon operators for BEC are
deformed by an operator-valued function, f(n), of the particle-number operator
n. We consider the collisions between the atoms as a special kind of
f-deformation. The collision rate k is regarded as the deformation parameter
and the spectrum of light scattered from the deformed BEC is analyzed. In
particular, we find that with increasing the values of deformation parameters k
and eta=1/N (N, total number of condensate atoms) the scattering spectrum shows
deviation from the spectrum associated with nondeformed Bose-Einstein
condensate.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 11 Jul 2008 18:50:28 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Haghshenasfard",
"Z.",
""
],
[
"Naderi",
"M. H.",
""
],
[
"Soltanolkotabi",
"M.",
""
]
] |
1 of gauge fields on domain walls which are supported by som gauge theories is discussed in the literature for a long time [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]. Elementary domain walls localize U(1) fields. As was explained by Polyakov [7], in 2+1 dimensions the U(1) gauge field is dual to a phase field sliving onS1. The U(1) gauge theory in 2+1 dimensions can exist in distinct regimes: (i) Coulomb, with the long-range interac tion lnrdue to the exchange of the gauge field; (ii) the gauge field is charges are screened, interaction due to the exchange o f the gauge field falls off exponentially; (iii) the gauge field acquires a mass through the Chern-Simons term, gauge symmetry is unbroken; and (iv) the dua l a mass term. This latter regime is quite peculiar. It might seem that the mass term of the sfield implies short-range interactions. In fact, it is the opposite! Electric charges (seen as the sfield vortices in the dual language) are connected by a flux line which plays the role of a confining string. Interaction between the electric charges grows linearly with the distance r. In terms of sthe string is a domain line very similar to the axion domain walls in 3+1 dimensions. The domain line endpoints are the sfield vortices. (For some reviews see Refs. [8, 9, 10].) The domain lines of the sfield are the essence of the Polyakov confine- ment [7]. Polyakov's model is 2+1 dimensional compact electrodynamic s. It represents the low-energy limit of SU(2) Yang-Mills theory with on e ad- joint Higgs field which develops a vacuum expectation value (VEV) bre aking SU(2) down to U(1). The mass term for the dual photon is generat ed by SU(2) instantons (in 2+1 dimensions, technically , they are identical to 't Hooft-Polyakov monopoles [11]). When the U(1) gauge field is dynamically localized on a wall occurring in 3+1 dimensional theory, whic h of the four regimes listed above is in fact implemented depends on det ails of the bulk theory. The first example of a U(1) gauge field localized on a wall, in a wasgivenin[4]. alU(1) symmetry of the bulk theory, spontaneously broken on the wall, gu of the 2+1 dimensional photon.2The U(1) theory on the wall is in the Coulomb regime. When the global U(1) symmetry is explicitly weak ly broken in the bulk, the sfield becomes quasi-Goldstone, a smass term is 2The dual photon sis the Goldstone implying confinement of the electric charges on the wall [5 ]. In a recent paper [6] a mechanism (developing a concept put forwar d in [1]) has been suggested that leads to confinement on domain walls. Un like themodels discussed in[4, 5], consideration of Ref. [6] wascarried ou t setting, althoughthe mechanism per seisgeneral and in a wide class of bulk theories, both supersymmetric or n The only requirements to these theories are: th ey should support both domain walls and (ANO) flux t ubes [12] and be minimal (in which sense minimal will be explained later). Far away from the wall the charged field condensate responsible for th e ANO flux tubes is large and squeezes the flux tube from all directions in plane. Now, if we place such tube inside the wall, where t he above condensate vanishes with an exponential accuracy, in the fi rst approx- imation the confining regime gives place to the Coulomb regime on the wa ll. The flux tube is still squeezed inside the wall in the direction perpendic ular to the wall; however, it swells in the directions parallel to the wall. In the next approximation one should take into account the fact th at there is a residual charged field condensate inside the wall. Although it is exponentially small, it still limits the swelling of the flux tube placed inside the wall in the directions parallel to the wall. The thickness of the flux tube in these directions is exponentially large, but finite. If we go to still lar ger distances along the wall, (magnetic) charges attached to the endp oints of such a tube experience linear confinement. The above description is phrased in terms of the charged field conde nsate and magnetic flux tubes. Needless to say, in actuality we keep in mind a dual picture, presented in Fig. 1: the monopole condensation leading to e lectric flux tubes. In what follows the dualization will be tacitly assumed. Thu s, when we speak of matter fields that condense, we will keep in mind tha t these local fields present an effective description of monopoles, mu ch in the same way as in the Seiberg-Witten construction [13]. The suggestion put forward in [6] is inspirational. At the same time, op - erational mode of this mechanism remained unclear, as well as its rela tion lized on the walls. Moreover, particular models considered in [6] suffer fr om instability. With these instabilities, working out quantitat ive details does not seem possible. The purpose of the present paper is to address these issues. We f ocus on investigation of how this mechanism actually works, and what deform ations 2or modifications lead to deconfinement. We suggest two stable mode l exam- ples: one at weak coupling and another using the Seiberg-Witten solu tion [13] at strong coupling. These models are demonstrated to be work ing exam- ples of confinement on the domain wall. En route, we will also clarify some aspect regarding localization of the gauge fields on the domain walls. To ensure stability of the model it is necessary to require that two v acua in which the matter fields condense are two distinctvacua. Let us call them Confining 1 and Confining 2 (Fig. 1).3If the monopole mass in the Coulomb phase ism, the condensate in the center of the wall is roughly ve-md/2where dis the wall thickness. If mdis large enough, the condensate inside the wall almost vanishes, and the gauge theory exists inside the wall in the (a lmost) Coulomb regime. Deviations of this almost Coulomb regime from the per fect Coulomb regime determine the thickness of the flux tube in the direct ions parallel to the wall. Confining 1 Confining 2 1: The condensate profile for the wall of the type Confining 1-Cou lomb- Confining ide the wall has a clear-cut interpretation in terms of the field s. Instead of being the modulus field, as in [4], it becomes a quasimodulus. We work ou t a method which allows one to calculate its mass directly from the bulk the ory. Moreover, introduction of the second matter field, as in [4], can re store the exact modulus status of s. 3In the dual language Confining 1 and Confining 2 read Higgs 1 and Higgs 2. 3The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2 we discuss some concep - tual aspects. Section 3 introduces a minimal model, the simplest ex ample which realizes the confinement mechanism discussed by Dvali et is given here to discussion of the localization mechanism for the gauge field and formation of the flux tubes in the wall. This example is qu a- siclassical (the model is weakly coupled) and is phrased in dual terms . The quark field condenses while the monopoles are confined by the Abriko string. Section 4 provides an example at strong coup ling in which condensation that occurs is that of the monopole field. This ex ample is an extension of N= 2 super-Yang-Mills theory (slightly broken to N= 1) considered by Seiberg and Witten. The Seiberg-Witten solution is an e ssen- tial ingredient which allows us to treat the theory at strong coupling . In Sect. 5 we consider a nonminimal theory with two flavors and explain why, in with the minimal model of Sect. 2, the gauge field on the wall remain massless despite the presence of a residual conden sate in the middle of the wall. The theory on the wall is in the Coulomb regime. The masslessness is backed up by the Goldstone theorem: in the bulk we h ave an exact global U(1) symmetry which is spontaneously Section 7 sum marizes our findings. 2 Conceptual aspects The basic idea of the gauge field localization suggested in [1] assumes t hat the bulk four-dimensional theory is in the confining regime while inside t wall we have less confinement (or no confinemen t at all). Then the chromoelectric flux coming from the bulk through a tube sp reads out inside the wall. The flux tube-wall junction plays the role of the co lor source inside the wall. In the dual formulation the bulk theory is Higgs ed while inside the wall it is less Higgsed (not Higgsed at all in the case of U(1)). The technical implementation of this idea is not quite straightforwar d. Indeed, say, in the U(1) case which has just been mentioned the ma gnetic charges are confined in the bulk. Thus, the magnetic flux from a dist ant magnetic monopole is squeezed into a tube, and when this tube hits th e wall, it spreads out inside the wall. To describe this phenomenon in term s of the standard 1+2-dimensional U(1) gauge theory onthe wall surface we have to use a duality transformation which converts the magnetic field ins ide the 4wall into a dual electric field of the effective theory on the wall surfa ce. The flux tube-wall junction acts as an electriccharge source in on the wall. This duality transformation is a crucial e lement of the construction. The relation between the gauge potential in t he bulk and that in the effective low-energy theory on the wall surface is no nlocal. In 1+2 dimensions the gauge field Auis dual to a phase field s[7]. If a U(1) symmetry is an exact symmetry of the bulk theory, spontan eously broken on the wall, occurrence of the Goldstone field slocalized on the wall is inevitable. Dualizing the above Goldstone field we get massless electr ody- namics on the wall. The electric flux from a charge source in the effect ive theory on the wall surface is spread according to the Coulomb law. I f, on the other hand, a global U(1) symmetry is only an approximate symm etry of the bulk theory [5], or even just an approximate symmetry of the domain wall solution [1], we should expect a pseudo-Goldstone mode localized on the wall, with a small mass term. With this pseudo-Goldstone mode we get e lec- trodynamics with confinement on the wall, ` a la Polyakov. The electric flux of the world-volume theory is, in its turn, squeezed on the wall, form ing a band of thickness inversely proportional to the pseudo-Goldston e mass. This thickness is exponentially larger than that of the bulk magnetic flux t ubes. These two scenarios are realized in two-flavor and one-flavor mode ls, The Simplest Example at Weak Coupling 3.1 Theoretical Setting To introduce the reader to the subject we will start with a toy mode l phenomenonwewan a U(1) gauge theory with a charged scalar field Q. Our task is to study a domain wall interpolating between va cua. The model is The simplest choice of the potent ial seems to be as (1) as suggested in [6]. However, there is a problem with (1), namely the H interpolation is a wall-antiwall configuration in this mode l, which isunstable. Ofcourse, theinstability small, but so are the effects we try to trace. 5To create a stable configuration we need at least an extra real neu tral field. Consider a system in the Higgs phase, with the U(1) gauge grou p, a scalar field Qwith charge +1, and an uncharged scalar a, with the , (2) with the (3) This model is but we can still consider it as an effe ctive theory in the infrared.4It is obvious then that we have two distinct If we keep mev, there is a large intermediate region inside the domain wall where the VEV of Qis almost zero (see Fig. 2). lewe immediately see that this inside region of the wall is almost in the Coulomb phase. In the limit m- the wall becomes infinitely thick, and the Higgs VEV in the wall center tends to zero. To see this we write down the equations of motion for our model. solutionweassume thatallfieldsare static and depend only on a single spatial coordinate z(the wall is perpendicular to thez-axis), and drop the gauge field. We have 2 za= 0. Qvanishes insidethewall. Then the first equation above gives for the neutral scalar a a2mz-z0 d, (5) 4This example can be embedded in supersymmetric QED (SQED) with the D-term, the in a vacuum with ~Q= 0. 6Figure 2: Domain wall in the toy model (2), (3). The profile of the a(z) field is presented by the solid line while that of Q(z) by dashed. The horizontal axis presents the direction zperpendicular to the wall. wherez0is the center of the wall, while dis its thickness, to be In Eq. (5) we take into account the a-field boundary conditions, a- +-matz- +-. Substituting (5) in the second equation in (4) we can write the following equation for the profile field Q, neglecting the (6) Below we will show that d~m/e2v2. Taking this into account, inside the wall, near its left (7) we can simplify the above equation by dropping the second term in the curly brackets and replacing z-z0-d/2 by-d. Then we (8) The solution of this equation obviously has the (9) where we use Eq. (7). 7Much in the same way, near the right edge of the wall at 1/ev (10) we derive from (11) Note that these quark profiles are similar to those obtained in [4] in su per- symmetric QED with two quark flavors, see Sect. 4. Let us estimate din the limit mev. In the inside region the VEV of Qalmost vanishes while ais linear in z. In order to estimate the thickness of this region (i.e. the wall thickness), let us first estimate the wall t ension as a function of dand then minimize it with respect to (12) The assumptions for this estimation are that for mevthe to the energy come from the potential and kinetic te rms of the afield. The minimum is achieved at d=2 2m e2v2, (13) whereevis the photon mass in the bulk. The tension of the wall is of the order of Twall~2 2mv2. (14) In what follows, we shall be interested in trapping gauge fields, inside this domain wall. Localization of gauge fields on topo log- ical objects is, generally speaking, a nontrivial task. Massless sca lars can be localized as Goldstone bosons of continuous symmetries spontaneo usly bro- ken on the given topological defects. Massless fermions can be loca lized and other index theorems [14] (see [15, 16]). We shall discuss this issue in more detail in Section 6. As discussed in Ref. [4], we can consider the following gauge invariant order (15) The difference with the 2-flavor model considered in [4], and discusse d in Section 5, is that the two scalar fields at the edges of the Wilson line ar e now 8the same. This implies that we do not have a strictly massless gauge fie ld localized on the wall. This is because the expectation value of the matt er field never exactly vanishes inside the wall. Let us denote the expectation value of the condensate |Q|in the wall center (z=z0) (16) In the limit in which mev, the domain wall is thick and v0is very small. A numerical fit in the range 0 .3v<m< 0.6vand 0.15<e<0.2 shows that to a very good (17) The mass of the gauge field in the bulk is ev; Higgsing inside the wall is exponentially weaker, so that the gauge field mass is ~ev0. To what ex- tent can we speak of localization? The answer depends on the range of the domain wall is an object with thickness da low-energy effec- tive action makes sense only up to energy scales ~1/d. At higher of the wall internal structure become important. Fluc tuations of the wall as a whole in the transverse direction (Goldstone modes o f symmetry) are massless. They always belong to the lo action. Other -- massive -- excitations can be considered a p art of the 2+1 dimensional effective action as long as their mass is much smalle r than 1/d. Physics changes in passing from one of the following regimes to another: (i) 1/dev0ev. In this regime the mass of the gauge field inside the wall is much larger t han 1/d. We can not speak about localization, physics of the wall is formula, strictly speaking, is valid in the range of parameters ind icated above. However, it is likely that it works also for larger d, although it is difficult to check this assumption because accurate numerical calculations are more diffic ult for larger values of d. 9This is the localization limit. Up to energies ~1/dthe gauge field can be considered as a field localized on the 2+1 dimensional world this case the gauge field is localized only up to energies ev. Due to leakage in the bulk no localization occurs at energies from ~evto 1/d. Focusing on the regimes (ii) and (iii) we ask ourselves whether or not a quasimoduli field lives on the wall in these cases. 3.2 Modulus or quasimodulus on the wall First, we need to explain why we expect a U(1) quasimodulus on the wa ll world volume. We begin by presenting the simplest solutions that desc of the gauge field: a constant magnetic field and a consta nt electric field. From now on we will always work in the gauge Az= 0. A constant magnetic field inside the wall is parallel to the wall surface . Let us assume the magnetic field to be aligned along the ^xis the unit vector along x. We can construct it in the following way. At negative zwe take the field Q=veikyand the gauge field A2=k(or, which is the same, Ay=-k. At positive zwe takeQ=vandAy= 0. In this way in two vacua, to the left and to the right of the wall, the fie ld configuration is pure gauge. Inside the wall, Aylinearly interpolates between -kand 0 on the interval of size d. The magnetic field is Bx=-zAy=k/d. The magnetic flux per unit length in the ydirection The magnetic field inside the wall is a vector on the wall since it can be orient ed either along ^ xor along ^y. The electric field inside the wall can only be perpendicular to the wall surface, aligned along ^ z. Thus, on the wall it must be interpreted as a pseudoscalar. To obtain such an electric field inside the wall consider Q=
veiotat negative zandAt=o. At positive zwe haveQ=vandAt= 0. Inside the wall Atlinearly interpolates between oand 0. The electric field inside the wall is Ez=-zAt=o/d. Of course, from the 2+1 dimensional point of view the picture must b e dualized, since in 2+1 dimensions it is the electric field F0iwhich is a vector while the magnetic field F12is a scalar. For example, In other u,n,r = 0,1,2. (18) Now we can further dualize F(2+1) un` a la Polyakov, expressing F(2+1) unin terms of a phase fields (19) Assembling everything together we have, with our gauge (22) Note that the angle field sexactly corresponds to the phase of Qat to that at positive z. We can use unitary gauge which ensures that Q=vin both vacua at z- +-. In this gauge the constant magnetic field inside the wall looks as follows. The gauge field Au= 0 in both vacua, while inside the A x=Ay= 0. (23) This gauge potential gives the magnetic field strength shown in equa before, onecanconsider order p arameter (15). The kinetic term for the gauge field, expressed as a function of thes modulus, takes the form (cf. (24) 3.3 Potential for the quasimodulus As was mentioned, in the model at hand, the phase field sis not an exact modulus. A potential V(s) is generated forcing s= 0 in the true vacuum 11which is unique. In the localization limit of large dwe can nevertheless speak of a 2+1 dimensional effective theory for s, since thesfield mass is much smaller than the excitation energy of the domain wall ~1/d. In the the sfield Lagrangian will be of the sine-Gordon is the difference between two tensions: the tension of the s= 0 wall and and that of the s=pwall. The mass of (26) Explicit calculations of the quasimodulus potential V(s) are not easy. The minimal tension domain wall corresponds to the lowest energy s= 0. Walls with s/negationslash= 0 are not static solutions of the equation of motion since they decay. To study such solutions of the equation of motion we ha ve to deal with more than one parameter. To explain what the last sentence means we consider the solution with a constant magnetic field in the ^ ydirection (see Fig. 3). Q=veikx, A x=kQ=v, A x,y,t= 0 z <0z xydz >0 Figure 3: An (almost) constant magnetic field inside the domain wall. F rom the point of view of the quasi modulus sit correspond to an almost linear The dots stand for small modulations. When s0, the wall is thinner and the magnetic field larger. At spthe magnetic field is smaller and the wall thicker. The amplitude of the oscillations in |/vectorB|and thickness depends on the mass of the quasimodulus. In the limit of vanishing mas s we recover the constant magnetic field solution. As a first approximation, we can choose <0, andQ=vandAx= 0 atz >0, similar to the discussion above. This gives 12a constant magnetic field By=k/dinside the wall. But it is clear that, due to a nonvanishing (albeit small) Qcondensate inside the wall, this is notthe exact solution. The latter requires modulations of k. One can understand this circumstance both from the bulk and from the brane point of vie w. The bulk explanation (see Fig. 3) is as follows. Due to topological reasons , the fieldQmust exactly vanish at some xandz0 each time the relative phase srotates by 2 p. The lines (in the ydirection) on which Qvanishes are the lines where the magnetic field reaches its maximum. We also expect the thickness of the wall to be a little bit larger around these lines. From the point of view of the 2 + 1 dimensional effective action (25) it is also clear that s(y) =kxwithkconstant is not a solution once the sine term is switched on. The derivative ds/dxwill be larger at the top of the potential (s=p) and smaller at the bottom ( s= 0). Figure 4: Left: the stable wall ( s= 0). Right: the unstable wall ( s=p). In this even though the Higgs VEV is not so small in the middle of the s table wall, there is just a 2% t difference between the tensions of the unstable and st able thequasimodulus. At corresponds to the maximum of the potential V(s). It is stationary but unstable. In this solution the Qfield vanishes exactly in the middle of thewall, at z= 0. Wecaneasily get the solutionifwe impose two conditions: (i) the field Qis real; (ii)Qchanges sign in passing from one side of the wall to the other, see Figs. 4 and 5. The difference between the tension s of the unstable and stable walls will determine in Eq. (25). The mass term for the sfield, is what induces confinement inside the domain wall. In Figure 3 we discussed how a constant magnetic field solu tion is deformed by the mass term. There are modulations of the thickne ss of the wall, and magnitude of the magnetic field. These modulations are noth ing 13Figure 5: Left: the energy density inside the stable wall (solid line) and the uns table wall (dashed line). In the center of the wall, the unstable wall has a lo wer energy density. On the other hand, the unstable wall is thicker and this make its tota l tension larger than that of the stable wall. Right: both domain walls in the ( a,Q) plane. but the flux tubes, all lined together. A single winding in the phase s, a kink ot the sine-Gordon model (25), is a domain line from the wall point of v iew. The mass term is what stabilizes the thickness of this kink, that othe rwise would spread to . These, from the point of view of the bulk theory, are the confining vortices bounded inside the domain wall. 3.4 A direct estimate of the smass term The Lagrangian of the model under consideration has no exact or a pproxi- mate global U(1) symmetry. However, the domain wall solution does have such anapproximate symmetry. Indeed, let us start fromthe limit m/(ev)- . In this limit the wall edges become infinitely sharp while the absolute value of the field Qinside the wall vanishes. Then the field consideration has two U(1) symmetries: Q(z >z0+d/2)-eiaQ(z >
z0+d/2) andQ(z < z 0-d/2)-eibQ(z < z 0-d/2), with The common U(1) symmetry, with a=b, is gauged. The U(1) phase rotation of Q(z >z0+d/2) relative to Q(z <z0-d/2) remains as an exact global U(1) symmetry. If we keep m/(ev) finite, then Q(z0) does not vanish and, because of continuity of the field Q, the above symmetry becomes approximate. This is due to the fact that now one must continuously evolve the phase of Qfrom zero atz=z0-d/2 up to a given satz=z0+d/2. With the zdependent phase inside the wall, the wall configuration no longer presents the e xact 14solution. The question is how to deal with such a situation. This isquite similar to thetreatment ofquasizero modes in theinstant background field. To deal with them one routinely us es sponding to the bottom of the valley and fixes the coordinate along this direct ion by hand. In the problem at hand the coordinate to be fixed can be defin ed as the phase sin the expression Q(z=z0+d/2) theAz= 0 gauge). For simplicity we will assume s(z=z0+d/2) to be small. Then, given the above boundary condition, minimization of th e energy functional gives that inside the (27) wheredis the size of the region inside the wall where phase sis changing, d < d. It is a free parameter and we estimate it below by for the ansatz for the scalar field inside the wall we choose the su m of the profile functions (9) and (11) at the left and right edges of the wall. is quite obvious that the only extra term in the energy functional (2), (3) comes from |zQ|2with the derivative acting on the phase, i.e. ( Qzs)2. Thus, the potential energy associated with s/negationslash= 0 (at small s) is V(s) this with respect to dwe (30) Assuming that ddwe (31) which confirms our assumption, since dfrom (31) to the potential (29) we (32) which shows that the potential for sis exponentially small and is determined by the value of the scalar field in the middle of the wall. Using more accur ate numerical estimate (16) for the value v0we finally (33) This estimate implies, in turn, (34) 3.5 A numerical check We have now two different estimations of ms. One of them (Eq. (26)) is given in term of , which is the difference in tension between the s=pand thes= 0 wall. The other one (Eq. (34)) is given in terms of the v0at the center of the domain wall. It is interesting to compare them for a cross check. m 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 1: Values of for v= 1 and different values of ( m,e). In Table 1 numerical results for are shown for some values of the parameters. In Table 2 the corresponding values of v0are presented. We can then use these values for a comparison the two independent estima tionsms,
~ms. The results are shown in Table 3. The proximity of the ratio ms/~ms to unity is obvious. The agreement is indeed quite good. We can also ve rify that the localization condition ev01/dis satisfied very well for 0.35 0.40 0.45 2: Values of v0forv= 1 and different values of ( Valuesof ms/~msforv= 1 and different valuesof( m,e).msis givenin Eq.(26) and ~msgiven by Eq. (34). 4 A Modified Seiberg-Witten framework 4.1 Theoretical Setting We now turn to a strong coupling example of the confinement phenom enon inside domain walls. The model we will dwell on below is a rather of the Seiberg-Witten (SW) model [13], which su pports both domain walls and strings. The theory of interest is N= 2 gauge theory, with the gauge group U(2) = SU(2) xU(1)/Z2, with no matter hypermultiplets. The which breaks the extended supersymmetry down toN= 1 is then we have three vacua, with phequal first andthe last vacua preserve the non-AbelianSU(2) gauge symmetry. Strong coupling effects ` a la Seiberg and Witten will then split each of t hem into two vacua (the monopole and dyon vacua). The vacuum in the mid dle preserves only the U(1) xU(1) gauge symmetry, and is not split. We, thus, expect in total five vacua, for generic values of x. If we setaat zero, the U(1) and SU(2) sectors get completely decoupled. Since there are no matter hypermultiplets, only a nonvanishing supe rpoten- tial can make the two sectors communicate with each other. Dynam ics of the U(1) sector is trivial, while the SU(2) sector is described by the S eiberg- Witten solution [13]. We parametrize the moduli space by Ph (37) The conventional SW solution is written in terms of the invariant u= 2a2 3. (38) In our case TrPh = 2a0,TrPh2= there is an invariant way to parameterize the moduli space [18, 19] by u1= TrPh, u 2=1 2TrPh2. (40) The trace of of Ph3can be expressed in terms of (41) This relation is not modified by quantum the superpotential (35) is switched on, the moduli space is lif ted. Five discrete vacua described above survive. This is a special case o f the set- up considered in Refs. [18, 19]. The positions of the vacua are the fo llowing 18(see Appendix 7 for more details). The value of u2isxfor all five vacua. It is not modified by quantum corrections. The Coulomb vacuum in the midd le is not modified by quantum correction either. It lies at u1= 0, u2=x. (42) The monopole-1 and dyon-1 vacua ph= diag(x,x) are at u1= u2=xandu1= The dyon-2 and monopole-2 vacua from ph= diag(-x,-x) are at u1=- u2=xandu1=- u2=x.(44) In the limitxL the Coulomb vacuum is such that the electric 6: Five vacua of the model in the limitxL. (In the plot we set L = 1, x= 4). The dashed line connects the monopole-1, Coulomb, and m onopole-2 vacua. This is the composite domain wall we will analyze in wh at follows. Note that all five vacua are aligned. is (45) The five vacua in this limit are depicted in Fig. and becomes of order L, the Coulomb vacuum enters a strong coupling regime. At the critical value x= L2the Coulomb vacuum lies exactly in the monopole singularity and coalesces with two monopole vacua. Around this critical value, the Coulomb vacuum is such that t he magnetic coupling is small, so we can use the same set of low-energy eff ec- tive variables to describe both the Coulomb and the confining vacua. In this section we will study (in the limit |x-L2| L2) the domain walls connect- ing the Coulomb and the confining vacua. It is convenient to introduc e a dimensionless (46) We will work in the limit |o| 1, but keeping three vacua separate is described by the following effective 7: Asxbecomes smaller, we reach a critical point where the Coulomb vacua lie s exactly on the monopole singularity. Around this point we can use the magnetic effective action to describe the wall. It remains weakly coupled in all three vacu a of interest (L = 1, x= 1.45 in this plot). 20where we can . (48) TheF-term part of the scalar potential theD-term part the monopole superfields. The vacuum expectation values in the confining vacua are (in the limit o1) A3D= 0, A 0=+-Lo, M ~M=+-4 2iL2ao. (51) The dual description is valid in these vacua provided that the monopo le condensate is L2implying |ao| 1. The Coulomb vacuum is defined by the following 0, A 0= 0, u(A3D) =x. (52) The VEV of A3Din the limit o1 is A3D=o2Li 2. (53) A nice feature of the limit o1 is that we can use the same weakly cou- pled effective description in all three vacua of interest (Coulomb, mo nopole-1 and monopole-2). This unified description is also valid for the domain wa ll interpolating between them. In this sense the situation drastically d iffers from the case considered in Ref. [20], where no unified description wa s pos- sible for the domain wall interpolating between the monopole and the d yon vacua considered in [20]. The kinetic terms the confining vacua the value of the coupling e3Dis determined by the monopole expression for (56) An effective coupling e3D(z) along the domain wall profile is a function of the field condensates inside the wall. It interpolates between the tw o values above, (55) and (56). If we choose a~o, thene2 3Dis approximately the leading terms in u(A3D) in the scalar potential, we (57) 4.2 Elementary and composite walls We look for the wall solution in the (58) which automatically guarantees vanishing of the Dterm. We will assume the phases of ~MandMto be constant constant in our wall solution. This assumption is to be checked a posteriori . Once the phases are constant, they can be chosen at will by virtue of a global gauge rotation. It is conve nient to choose
~M=iM. (59) The value of the superpotential in the two confining vacua, monopo le-1 and monopole-2, is W=+-4 3L3ao3. (60) 22In the Coulomb vacuum the superpotential vanishes. Hence, the t ension of the BPS wall interpolating between monopole-1 and monopole-2 vacu a, if it existed, would be twice the tension of the BPS wall interpolating betw een the Coulomb and confining vacua. The latter walls will be referred to a s elementary. The former wall can be called composite. For the elementary wall, we can take MandA0real andA3Dpure imag- inary. Then we can write the following BPS = 0. (61) The profile functions for the elementary wall interpolating between the con- fining and the Coulomb vacua, are shown if Fig. 8. In this theoretical set-up, Figure 8: Elementary wall at u= 0 (see Eq. (62)), dashes). no BPS wall interpolating between two confining vacua, monopole-1 a nd monopole-2, exists. In other words, a composite wall built of two ele mentary walls at a finite distance from each other, does not exist. Supersym metric 6Note that e3Dis a function of the fields M~M, a3D; this does not change the form of the BPS equations. Our choice aoguarantees constancy of e3Dto a very For simplicity, in the numerical calculations we keep correspond to viscous flows in the first-order equations , starting from monopole-1, following the profile ~Wand ending in monopole-2. It is not difficult to see that such flow cannot be realized in the case at han d. A field configuration interpolating between monopole-1 and monopole -2 is always time-dependent; it represents two elementary walls moving u nder the influence of a repulsive force between them (see Ref. [21] for a disc ussion sigma models). This force falls off exponentially with t he wall separation. 4.3 Composite wall stabilization In order to avoid the problem discussed in Sect. 4.2 and stabilize the c om- posite domain wall, an extra term is introduced in the (62) wherexis chosen as a real parameter, with x >L2, anduis a real mass parameter, u<oL. In the effective low-energy superpotential we theFterm takes the (64) The Coulomb vacuum remains intact when u/negationslash= 0 is switched on, and so is the value of the superpotential in the Coulomb vacuum. Both confi ning vacua have A3D= 0. The values of A0and the monopole field -4 3L3ao3 Figure 9: Superpotential values in three vacua, at nonvanishing u(in the complex ~W plane). The values of the superpotential in both confining vacua change (s ee Fig. 9), being shifted upwards in the complex tension of the BPS domain wall is given by the absolute value of the difference of the superpotentials at two vacua between which the g iven For this reason, if the composite BPS walls exist at u/negationslash= 0, the composite wall will be stable, see Fig. 9. In order to write the BPS equations for the elementary wall, we need complex profilefunctions foreach field, M,A3DandA0. Theansatz ~M=iM can still be used. Let us introduce a phase (see Ref. [22] for a deta (67) The BPS equations generalizing those in Eq. (61) to the case u/negationslash= 0 = 0. (68) Numerical solution for the profile functions of the elementary walls a 0 is displayed in Fig. 10. For the composite wall we again can use the ansa tz 25Figure 10: Elementary wall profile functions at nonvanishing u. Left: Re dashes), Im A3(short dashes), Re A3(dots). Right: Re M(solid) and Im The BPS equations are very similar to the ones for the The only difference is that for the composite wall o= 0 and the profiles of Im A0and ReA3Dare 0. (69) The BPS equations for the non-constant profile functions equations wededuce that thefollowing quantity remains =-23/2auL. (71) The corresponding profiles are shown in Fig. 11. The boundary cond itions are such that M() =-iM(-). Note that if we try to use the M() =iM(-), we get an unstable wall, whose tension is 26Figure 11: The profile functions of the stable composite wall profiles at nonvan ishingu Left: Re A0(solid), Im A0(long dashes), Im A3(short dashes). Right: Re M(solid) than twice the tension of the elementary wall. The tensions of the BPS walls are given by the central (72) implying that the composite wall is stable. Note also that the paramet ero is different for the composite and elementary walls. Two out of four s uper- charges will annihilate each domain wall; but they will be different for th e composite and elementary walls. On symmetry grounds one can state that the real and imaginary pa rts of theMcondensate in the wall center (i.e. at the point z= 0) are equal in absolute value. Using the fact that (Re M(z))(ImM(z)) is constant, it is straightforward to analytically calculate the monopole condensat e at the center of the composite domain wall. The expression for the conden sate in the wall center is very concise,
|ReM(z= 0)|=|ImM(z= 0)| (73) In the limit uoL the condensate outside the wall is
|ReM(z=+-)| ratio of the absolute values of the monopole condensates inside and outside the wall is proportional Confinement on the composite domain wall As in the toy model discussed in Sect. 3, we would like to understand t he localization of the (massive) gauge field on the wall as a quasimodulus s localized on the wall world volume. Previous consideration suggests u s to look for an opposite direction rotation of the U(1) phase of the mon opole field atz <0 andz >0, respectively. Our target is an exited domain to s=p) in which the charged field profile vanishes in the center of the wall (see Fig. 4 pertinent to the toy model of Sect. 3 ). There is an important difference between the toy model and that of Sect. 4. In the former case the Coulomb phase was not a true vacuum of the th eory, while in the latter it is. This implies that imposing the condition s=p we get, in fact, two elementary walls, with no binding energy, separa ted by infinite distance. Needless to say, the condition that typical energ ies in the low-energy theory must be 1/dcannot be met then. In this formulation it makes no sense to speak of localization and reduction to 2+1 dimensio ns. Coulomb Wall 1Wall 2 E Field 2 RConfining 2 Confining 1d Figure12: A sketch of an electric the middleof the co mposite wall. To discuss confinement and localization on the composite wall we must change the setting. Consider the field configuration shown in Fig. 12 , which displays a flux tube trapped in the middle of the composite wall. Let us c all Rthe radius of the region where the electric field is localized. The two-component wall is stabilized at a distance d0between the ele- mentary walls. To separate them will cost a finite amount of energy p er unit surface of the wall, to be referred to as dTw. In the model discussed in this section, at the first nonvanishing order in u, we have dTw= 6aoLu2. (75) 28Denote the electric flux of the vortex by f. An estimate for the tension of the flux tube (76) Minimizing with respect to Rwe arrive (77) This shows that R*is a finite quantity, and the flux is indeed squeezed into flux tubes inside the composite domain wall. This is, of course, applicab le provided that dTwis positive (i.e. the force between two elementary domain walls is attractive, which is the case in the model at hand). Now, let us consider the case of a constant electric flux per unit leng th of the wall in the perpendicular direction (analogous to the picture in Fig . 3) We will denote this quantity -- flux per unit length -- by the same letter f. This flux is trapped in the middle Coulomb vacuum. As a consequence, t here is a repulsive contribution to the potential between the two compon ents of the composite (78) In order to find the minimum of the overall potential, we have to add t his d. Atlargedistance Tw has just an exponential tail in d; therefore, the-long range force is repulsive, as follows from Eq. (78). If the flux fis small, however, the global minimum of the inter-wall potential is still at finite d. There is a critical value of f-- let us call it f0-- for which the elementary domain walls at the equilibrium will be separated by a infinite distance. A simple energy estimate can b e used to evaluate the value of (79) whered0is the domain wall separation at zero f. Thus, although the low-energy description in the Seiberg-Witten mo (25)),th low-energy description is still valid at |s| p: a mass term Two-Flavor Model 5.1N= 2SQED with two flavors At this point one is tempted to say that the fact that the gaugefield localized on the wall weakly confines is due to residual exponentially small VEV's of the Higgs field inside the wall. In this case, the absence of the Coulomb regime on the wall would be a universal phenomenon. In fact, we kno w alsothereview paper[8]). InRef. [4] N= 2SQED with two flavors was considered. This model has a domain wall with a ph on it. This field is a Goldstone of a spontaneously broken U(1) and, thus, remains exactly massless. Upon Polyakov's dualizat ion it represents a U(1) gauge field on the wall in the Coulomb regime. More over, in the same paper [4] it was shown that a magnetic flux tube coming fro m the bulk in the perpendicular to the wall direction ends on the wall cre ating a vortexofthe sfield. electric charge, a source of the electric field on the wall. Two such sources interact through the Coulomb potential at large distances (logarit hmic in 2+1 exponentially small VEV's of the Higgs field inside the wall are certainly important. For instance, in the toy model considered in Se ct. 3 the sfield turns out to be a quasimodulus only because the wall at hand is ve ry thick implying exponential suppression of the Higgs field inside the wall. If the wall was thin, swould be heavy, and the only light field on its world volume would be the translational modulus. In the two-flavor model we can introducesas a relative phase between q1on one side of the wall and q2 on the other side. Because these fields are different, there is no ne ed in az dependent interpolation of sinside the wall, as was the case in the This is the technical reason for its exactmodulifield sinN= 2 SQED with 2 flavors analyzing it in a regime somewhat different from tha t of Ref. [4]. This moduli field remains massless even in the limit of thin wall. Thus, the mode of implementation of 2+1 dimensional electrodynamic s on the wall world volume -- Coulomb vs. confinement -- is a dynamical issue. Consider N= follows: m1=m, m 2=-m,mm1-m22m. (80) 30We will introduce the Fayet-Iliopoulos term xthrough the the bosonic part of the action can be written the scalar potential is the sum of (82) This theory has two vacua, and a domain wall interpolating between t hem. It was fully analyzed in [4] in the limit of thick (83) when the overlap between two edges of the wall is exponentially small. Now we will discuss the same problem in the opposite limit of a thin wall, with a strong (84) This limit is usually referred to as the sigma-model limit. If mex, the photonic supermultiplet becomes heavy, since the photon ma ss in the bulk~ex. Therefore, it can be integrated out, leaving us with the theory of fields from the matter supermultiplets, nearly massless in the sca leex, which interact through a nonlinear sigma model with the K ahler term corre- sponding to the Eguchi-Hanson metric. The manifold parametrized b y these (nearly) massless fields is The two vacua of the mo del vacua lie at the base of this manifold. Therefore, in considering the d omain wall solutions in the sigma-model limit m-0 [23, 24, 25] one can use the ansatzq= ~q+and limit oneself to the base manifold, which is, in fact, sphere. In this way we arrive at the problem of the domain wall in the CP(1) model deformed by a twisted mass term (related to a non- vanishing m= 2m). In this formulation the problem was first addressed in [24]. 31In the sigma-model limit one can readily find explicitly the wall cose, (85) where e(z) = 2arctan(exp(2 mz)). (86) Note (87) for allz. The modulus sin Eq. (85) reflects the fact that the target space of the CP(1) model with the twisted mass has U(1) symmetry. It is s pon- taneously broken on each given wall solution. More details on kinks in t he CP(1) model with the twisted mass, which appear as domain walls in the problem at hand, can be found in [8]. Sincee2- in the sigma-model limit, in the bulk action we can neglect the contribution due to the gauge field strength tensor. The gaug e field then becomes non dynamical; it is expressible in terms of the matter (88) The scalar field kinetic term tends to zero too, (89) As usual, we promote sto a field on the wall world- volume. k= 1,2. (90) The field strength then takes the k= 1,2. (91) 32If we substitute these expressions back in the action, we the first term is due to the covariant derivative and the second term is due to the field strength tensor. The second term is negligible and c an be omitted. This shows that our approximation is self-consistent. K eeping only the first term and integrating over zgives us the normalization of the world-volume effective (93) Thesfield is strictly massless, the gauge field that dualizes sis in the Coulomb phase on the wall world the thin wall (sigma model) approximation is not However, itreveals theexistence ofamassle ss Moreover, itcanbeco thewall. The approximation is analytic at sufficiently large distances from the p oint of the wall-tube junction. The wall-tube junction solution in the sigma-model limit was found (in a different notation) in Refs. [25, 26]. For illustrative purposes we will r epro- duce it in our notation. The BPS equations for a vortex ending on the wall are (see Ref. 0, 0. (94) In the sigma-model limit only qk's are dynamical variables. Thus, we need to solve two equations in the second line in Eq. (94). This can be done u sing the following ansatz in the cylindrical coordinates q (95) 33Then the BPS equations can be written 2msinth. (96) The solution can be readily found, namely, th= (97) wherez0is an integration constant which parametrizes the zposition of the object. Now we can use Eqs. (88) and (89) to determine A (98) This solution is valid in the sigma-model limit ( mex) and at from the point of the wall-tube junction. We see that the gauge field is localized inside the wall and has the Coulomb 1 /rbehavior at large r. This shows that we do have the Coulomb phase on the wall - even in th e sigma model limit - and confirms that sis a strictly massless modulus. To conclude this section let us return to the gauge theory limit (83) o f the problem at hand studied in [4]. One might naively suspect that there a re two different moduli fields in the two-flavor model. One is the modulus swhich is exactly massless because it is related to the global U(1) symmetry broken by the wall solution. One might guess that this modulus has nothing to do with the bulk gauge field. Allegedly, the bulk gauge field localized on the wall through the same mechanism as was discussed in the one-flavor model is a quasimodulus ~ swhich is different from the modulus s, and ~sacquires a small mass due to exponentially small quark fields inside the wall, as in Se ct. 3. The solution for the wall-string junction foundin [4] shows that this naive picture is incorrect. In [4] it was shown that the string orthogonal to the domain wall can end on the wall, and the magnetic flux it carries penetr ates in the wall. The endpoint of the string plays the role of a vortex for th es field localized on the wall. In fact, the solution for the wall (far away f rom the string endpoint) is approximately given by the unperturbed dom ain wall solution with the collective coordinate sdetermined by [4] s=a, (99) 34whereais the polar angle on the wall plane. The endpoint of the string creates a vortex of the field s. This shows that in fact there is no extra field
~s. The gauge field localized on the wall is dual to swhich is strictly massless in the two-flavor model. 5.2 Further discussion of moduli vs. slessph on the domain wall. This is not related to model with a global U(1) symmetry, two distinct vacua in which th e global symmetry is unbroken, and a domain wall that spontaneously breaks this symmetry, automatically has a massless Goldstone boson localize d on the domain wall. In particular, the wall solution with s=phas the same tension as that with s= 0, in an obvious with the solution of the toy model discussed in Sect. 3. Note that in the latter case, in the s=pwall the matter field vanishes on the plane lying in the middle of the wall. No such zero-plane occurs in the former onthe wall in the two-flavor models, although the matter field condensate s do not exactly vanish inside the wall? Why the sfield remains massless in this case? A (partial) answer to this puzzling question is as follows. 3+1 dimension al physics inside the wall, between its edges, is not the only thing to cons ider. Existence vs. nonexistence of a massless modulus is a global effect. The boundary conditions at z=+-play a crucial role. In the two-flavor model we deal with four phases: q1(z=-), q2(z=-) andq1(z= +), q2(z= -0,|q1(z= +)| -0. (102) The massless modulus scorresponds to a rotation of q1(z=-) andq1(z=
+) in the same direction while q2(z=-) andq2(z= +) remain fixed. 35The would-be quasimodulus of Dvali et al.corresponds to a rotation of the phases of q1(z= +) andq2(z= +) in the same direction while q1(z=-) andq2(z=-) remain fixed. The would-be quasimodulus has a tachyonic direction and classically decays into the modulus s. Let us try to understand mechanisms responsible for this phenome non in more detail. Consider a string parallel to the domain wall (a grid of suc h strings is depicted in Fig. 13). If the distance between the wall and t he Magnetic Field
``Naked'' Zeros Figure13: tothedomainwall. At z of the q2field condensate. The line of zeroes of the q2field is surrounded by the magnetic field. At z= 0 the vortices lies in the middle of the wall. the zeroes of q2go toznegative while the magnetic field remains on the domain wall surface. In the limit where the zeroes are at -we recover the solution describing a constant magnetic field on the wall. is very large we have an ordinary ANO string with thickness ~1/(ex). As we move the string toward the wall, the quark condensate decreas es and, in the center of the wall, the thickness of the string (in the directions parallel to the wall) (103) wheredis the thickness of the wall. The thickness of the wall depends on the regime in which we find ourselves. In the limit m/(ex)1 the thickness is entirely determined by the matter field and is d~m/(e2x). In the (the sigma-model limit) the thickness is d~1/m. If we want to compare the thickness of the domain wall with that of t he string in the middle of the wall we should both sides by exwe can express everything in terms of a di- mensionless (104) Thus, we should two functions are plotted in Fig. 1 1.5 2 2.5 14: Comparison between the thickness of the domain wall, and the trans- verse size of the flux tube located inside the domain wall. In t he region limit, thetransversesiz e of thefluxtubeis much smaller than the wall thickness. In thex1 limit the thickness of the string is much larger than the thickness of the domain wall. This is qualitatively consistent with the ex - istence of a Coulomb phase in the middle of the wall. The opposite limit x1 is problematic. The thickness of the string is much smaller than the thickness of the wall. We are thus tempted to conclude that in this re gime the wall lives in a confining phase, which is clearly in contradiction with th e rigorous proof above of the existence of a massless modulus and, h ence, the Coulomb phase. 37The way out of this paradox is as follows. In the previous discussion w e have compared the thickness of the wall with that of the string in th emiddle of the wall. So we (erroneously) assumed that dynamics on the wall w orld volume isdirectly deducible of 3+1 dimensional dyn amics inside the wall, between its two edges. In the x0 limit this creates little problem. In this limit we have a thick region inside the wall in which the matter field condensate essentially vanishes. But in the x1 limit this way of thinking creates a paradox and, thus, reveal its inconsistency . In fact, the wall world-volume dynamics reflects not only what happ ens atz~0, but also what happens at z- +-. Consider z should remember that z >0 is the region where q2condenses while z <0 the region where q1condenses. Each flux tube has a line of zeroes for the q2field and a magnetic field surrounding this line of zeroes. We then move the grid of flux tubes toward the domain wall. We want to understand what happens to these flux tubes as we pass through the wall and then m ove toward negative infinity. At z= 0 the flux tube grid is in the middle of the wall; the thickness of each flux tube is larger. If we move on, someth ing new happens. The lines of zeroes go to znegative and get separated from their magnetic field. The magnetic field remains trapped inside the wall. In th e limit where the zeroes are at z- -, we recover the solution of field inside the domain wall. So, the q2flux tube, passing through the wall to the other side of the wall, does not become the q1flux tube. This is not in contradiction with the symmetries of the theory. The domain wall is symmetric under the Z2transformation z- The one-flavor case is different. The domain wall is symmetric under the parity transformation z- -zand theqflux tube passing through the wall to the other side of the wall preserves its identity remain ing theq flux tube. Of course, physically the line of the q2zeroes atz=-(more exactly, the plane of the q2zeroes7) is in fact not so far away. The q2quark has the exponential profile ~exp(-e2xz2) inside the wall and essentially becomes zero at distances of the order of 1 /ex. Thus, the plane of the q2zeroes separation of the order of thickness of the flux tube in the vacuum. This is in acc ord 7A flux tube has line of zeroes of a charged scalar inside it, while in order to have a Coulomb phase on the wall we need the whole plane of the qzeroes (parallel to our physical intuition. Here we arrive at a crucial distinction of the two-flavor model from the one-flavor model of Sect. 2. In the one-flavor model the empty domain wall (i.e. without magnetic field) has a nonvanishing Qfield everywhere. Inside the wall it becomes small, but still does not vanish. In order for a mag netic field to penetrate the wall we need to have zeroes of the Q-field. Clearly, it costs less energy to create a line of Q-zeroes in the ( x,y)-plane than the whole (x,y)-plane of the Q-zeroes. This qualitatively explains why we have confinement ( phase on the wall in the two-flavor model ( sis strictly massless). Now, let us discuss energetics of this process. First of all, consider the string grid when it is far away from the wall in the positive- zregion. Assume we deal with a homogeneous grid with density f, so that the flux per unit of length is 4 pf. The tension of this configuration is the sum of the wall tension plus the string (105) In the opposite position, when the zeroes are at negative z, far away from the wall, we can also easily compute the tension. It is just that of a do main wall with a constant magnetic flux inside it. An easy way to get the res ult is the thin-edge approximation (similar to that adopted in [27] for the Q-wall). The wall tension is now given by a sum of three terms, T(d) (106) Minimizing with respect to dwe (108) The expression in Eq. (108) can also be obtained from a more rigor- ous derivation using the Bogomol'nyi completion method (see Ref. [28 ]). The physical situation is very similar to the Q-kinks discussed in detail in Refs. [29] for 1+1 dimensional sigma models. Following [4] we (109) 39where we introduce a new complex field phA. The action then reduces Bogomol'nyi completion of the wall+tube energy functional can b e writ- ten (111) The BPS equations are obtained by putting to zero each of the first four lines of Eq. (111). In order to find an explicit solution, let us choose a gauge whereAz= 0; the following ansatz can then be a=a(z), A a particular linear combination of the BPS equations we can find t he value oflkand also that the profile for aand forfare =
2tanaa(z), l k=mktana. (113) The equations for the other profiles give the following first order sy = 0, = 0. 40Figure 15: Left: Domain wall without magnetic flux ( a= 0). Right: Domain wall with magnetic flux ( a=p/3). Due to the magnetic field, the domain wall thickness increases. The following numerical values were used: m= 0.3,e= 0.2,x= 1. A numerical solution is shown in Fig. 15. For the moment ais an arbitrary angle (this is a usual trick used in analyzing dyons or Q-kinks). The wall+tube boundary conditions are as follows. At z-+
ph1= 0, Ax= 4pf. (115) Atz- , ph2= 0, Ax= 0. (116) The decomposition (111) give the upper (117) Maximizing with respect to awe get exactly the expression in Eq. (108).] This presents a more quantitative proof of our assertion. The tothewall reaches theminimum oftheenergy when thelineof zeroes ofq2is atz- -, and thetension is given by (108). If, instead, we consider a set ofq1strings parallel to the wall, the minimum is reached when the line of zeroes of q1is atz-+. In both cases the energy is always localized inside the domain wall in the form of a constant magnetic field. The con stant magnetic field corresponds to the Coulomb phase on the wall world vo lume, with the massless modulus s=ky. We can also discuss a different system that will help us to further eluc i- date these issues. Consider a grid of flux tubes perpendicular to th e domain 41wall (Fig. 16). The flux tubes are aligned along the zaxis and the wall, ini- tially, is aligned in the plane x,y. We assume the flux tubes to be by intervals 1 /(2f). (We consider twice the density of the previous system for later convenience). Hence, 2 fis the linear density. The magnetic flux density is 8 pf. This simplification will allow us to make quickly. Simultaneously, this set-up still provides us with essen tial in- formation on physics of the flux tubes perpendicular to the wall sy stem. This flux tube grid, for sufficiently large density 2 f, can be considered as a surface with tension 4 pxfand linear flux 8 pf. When this surface intersects with thedomain wall we have a three-surface junction: the flux tub egridand two semi-planes into which the domain wall is divided. The angle thshown in Fig. 16 defines geometry of the junction. The magnetic flux carried by of q_2 zeros does not end Figure 16: A grid of strings perpendicular to the domain wall. The strin gs form a linear lattice with distance 1 /(2f) between them. The domain wall is deformed into the shape shown in this figure in order to balance the tens ion of the strings. Half flux of the flux tubes goes into each of two semi-planes int o which the wall is divided. The angle this determined in the text, see Eq. (118). It tends to 0 when the string density 2 fis very small. It tends to p/2 when the magnetic flux is tubes is divided exactly into two equal parts, so that each semi- plane carries linear flux 4 pf. The wall tension is given by The anglethis determined by a simple balance of (118) Note the angle that maximizes the BPS this simple example we can learn an important lesson. First of all the flux tube grid is a source of a constant magnetic field inside the wa ll. This means, as was already discussed, that the 2+1 dimensional the ory on the domain wall is in the Coulomb phase. Second, we can conclude that the wall with a constant magnetic field is 1 /4 BPS saturated. This follows from the fact that the flux tube perpendicular to the wall is known t o be 1/4 BPS (See [4] and Appendix B.) It is straightforward to verify that , if we take the BPS equations for a system of strings ending on the wall (w hich are in Eq. (94)) and rotate them by an angle aaround the xaxis, we recover the same equations as those that we get from the Bogomol'nyi comp letion in Eq. (111). 6 Peculiarities of the Gauge Field Localiza- tion. Can we uplift the problem to was mentioned in Sect. 2, localization of gauge fields on domain walls is not similar to that of, say, spinor field since dualization is important. T his makes the procedure non-local with respect to the gauge potent ials in the bulk and on the brane. The latter is not just a mode reduction of the former. Let us explain it in more detail. To begin with, consider the conventiona l localization mechanism on topological defects. The bulk theory is defi ned in space-time XMwhereM= 0,...,d-1. The soliton is a topological object extended in xuwhereu= 0,...,p. The transverse coordinates are sawith a=p+ 1,...,d-1. The theory has some bosonic fields ph(j)(x,s). The soliton is a topologically stable solution made of the bosonic fields ph(a)which are independent of x. The soliton is a p-brane spanned on the if we want to find the spectrum of a particular scalar field phin the soliton background we can separate (119) In the quadratic in phapproximation the Lagrangian takes the the following (linear) equations of motion for = 0. (121) Inserting here Eq. (119) we get two = 0, (123) where we used the fact that MM=uu+aa. The physical meaning of this formula is as follows. First we solve the transverse field equation (122) and we find the mass eigenvalues . longitudinal field ph/bardbl(x) is (generally speaking) a massive field in the longitudinal variables x. As long as ph(n) is normalizable on saand m(n)is much smaller than the inverse soliton thickness, we can keep field in the low-energy Lagrangian emerging on the so liton world volume. For this particle to be massless, the corresponding tr ansverse mode must be a zero mode of the equation (122). To write the effective Lagrangian for this localized field we use the bulk Lagrangian (120), expand in longitudinal and transverse fields, an d integrate over the the transverse norm of the perpendicular field factorizes out providing a norma lization for the parallel field. Only normalizable modes of (122) lead to let us return to gauge fields on 1+2-dimensional walls [4], try to follow the way outlined above and see that this is notthe right procedure to localize the gauge field. The bulk fields we start from are the gauge field AM, and two q1andq2. and q2. Ifwewant to parallelize the procedure outlined above we nominate Au(u= 0,1,2) as our fields and apply the standard =ph(z)Au(x) (125) (with normalizable phimplying that at z- +-). Then we note that ative with overz. The total magnetic flux inside the wall thus obviously vanishes. The mode decomposition (125) is suitable for massive vector fields on the wall. But there is no index theorem that can protect any zero en ergy solutions of equation (122). What is the actual procedure leading to the gauge field localization? W pproximate in the one flavor case). Spontaneous breaking of this symmetry loc alizes, through the Goldstone theorem, a phase field on the wall. Dualization of this field gives rise to QED on the wall world volume, with along the wall. At the same time, the flux insidethe wall (parallel to the wall) is that of the magnetic field of the original bulk theory. The necessity of dualization explains why in five- (and higher dimension s) it is so hard to localize gauge fields on the 1+3-dimensional wall within framework. (By field theory we mean here somethin g without gravity, roleinthe mechanism of localization.) Such mechanisms could be of enormous phenomenolog ical interest. Ideas as to how one could address this problem can be fou nd in the literature, see e.g. [3, 30, 31]. The construction discussed in the present paper cannot be uplifte d to higher dimensions. Let us discuss in more detail what happens if we ju st lift our four-dimensional models to five dimensions. In four-dimensiona l theory, what is localized on the 1+2-dimensional wall is a gauge the localized gauge potential. 45As we uplift the model to, say, five dimensions, we observe that wha t is localized here is not a gauge field but a 2-form, or the Kalb-Ramond file d
/tildewideHun. Indeed, C hargedunder this Kalb-Ramond field. We know that 2-forms couple naturally to str ings, or 1-branes, much in the same way 1-forms couple to particles. We h ave, in fact, a natural candidate for this string. This is the world sheet sp anned by the uplifted ANO vortices ending on the domain wall. The ANO vortices in five dimensions are 2-branes. This is because their codimension is fixe d to be 2 from the homotopy p1(U(1)). These ANO vortices (2-branes) end on the domain walls (3-branes), and the intersection between them is e xactly the string world sheet, the source of the localized Kalb-Ramond field . 7 we conclude that in certain models a string (flux tube) in side the domain wall is possible. These are the models which we called minimal: in particular, those in which the domain wall interpolates between two vacua where one and the same field condenses. The condensate is expone in the center of the domain wall. A string in the bulk paralle l to the domain wall is attracted to the wall. The lowest-energy configur ation is achieved when the zeroes of the field are at z= 0. Figure 17 illustrates this example. As a result, the U(1) filed trapped on the wall is in the confin ement regime. We compared this regime with that of the two-flavor model. The lowes t- energy configuration here is achieved when the zeroes are at z=-(the mirror reflected solution z- -zis also possible). Now, the Coulomb phase on the wall is energetically preferred to the confining phase (see Fig . 18). Underlying dynamics is not so transparent as in the minimal model, with the confinement on the wall regime. Technically the distinction is due to the fact that in the two-flavor model q1vanishes on one side of the wall and q2on the other, so there is no relative phase between, say, q1on the left of the wall and q1on the right of the wall. There is only a phase between q1on the left and q2on the right, and it is not zdependent. 46z0 state of Strings inside Wall Figure 17: The energy of a string parallel to the wall as a function of the distance in the one-flavor model of Sect. 2 (the minimal model). The str ing on one side of the wall is the same as the string on the other side. The matter field smaller in the center of the wall; that's why the tens ion of the string also reaches a minimum at this point. One finds a bound state of stri ng inside the wall. Constant magnetic field z0 z0Tension xm+ (2pf)2 Figure 18: In the two-flavor model discussed in Sect. 4, we consider a dom ain wall and a set of parallel flux tubes with density fplaced at a certain distance zform the wall. At large positive zthe tension of this configuration is given by the sum of the tensions of the wall and the grid of the flux tubes. The en ergy minimum is reached when the distance (defined as the position of the ze roes) is-. Then the configuration looks as the domain wall with a constant mag netic field on ment. The two-flavor model has a global U(1) in the bulk, which is spontane ously broken on the wall. The Goldstone boson of this breaking is the sfield. It is strictly massless. On the other hand, one can trace its connectio n to the photon of the bulk theory which is Higgsed in the bulk [4]. The mechanisms we discussed in this paper are quite general. We pre- sented two working examples: a toy minimal model in Sect. 3 and a str ong 47coupling example in Sect. 4. In both examples there is a condensate w hich does not vanish in two distinct vacua separated by the domain wall, an d a residual (suppressed) condensate in the middle of the wall. The qua nta of the fields which condense in both vacua are very heavy inside the wall; hence, one can view the residual condensate as a tunneling effect want to thank G. Dvali for correspondence and useful discuss ions. R.A. is grateful to FTPI for their hospitality in February 2008 when a par t of this work was done. S.B. wants to thank Ki-Myeong Lee and people at KIA S discussio ns. This paper was presented by S.B. at the conference CAQCD-08 in Minnea polis in May 2008. This work is supported by DOE grant The wor k of M.S. was supported in part by Chaire Internationalle de Recherche Blaise Pascalde l'Etat et de la R' egoin d'Ile-de-France, g' er' ee par la Fondation d e l'Ecole Normale Sup' erieure. The work of A.Y. was supported by FTPI , University of Minnesota, by RFBR Grant No. 09-02-00475a, and by Russian State Grant for Scientific Schools A. Vacuum tureofthe theory discussed in Sect. 4 using the technique developed in [19]. The U(2) N= 2 gauge theory, without hypermultiplets, has the following Seiberg - Witten curve y2= (A.1) The moduli space consists of the Coulomb branch parametrized by u1= The four roots of the curve (A.2) Since we have no hypermultiplets the singularity structure is very sim ple and consists (co-dimension2 0 (A.3) Now, let us break extended supersymmetry down to N= 1 by virtue of the we have the three vacua (36). The quantum solution goe s as follows. The Seiberg-Witten curve (A.5) wherenis the number of the unbroken U(1) factors in the low-energy theo ry. This factorization is then related to the superpotential paramete unknown parameters are the coefficients of fk-1, the coefficients of Vk-N andQN-n-1, and, finally nparameters of the U(1)nCoulomb moduli space. In totalk+n+ (k-N) + (N-n-1) = 2k-1, exactly the number of equations from the polynomial equality (A.6). In the case of interest N= 2,k= 2 andn= 1,2 depending on whether we deal with the confining vacua or the Coulomb one. The solutions ar e as follows. (i) Monopole We must lie in the monopole 0. On this surface the factorization equation is y2 m= solution is f1=4L2/radicalbig x-L2z+4L2x+3L4anda=u1=+-(A.8) where+-correspond to two classical non-Abelian vacua in Eq. (36). (ii) Coulomb The factorization in this case is very simple y2 m= (A.9) The solution is u1= 0,u2=xandf1=-L4. There is no change from the classical formula. (iii) Dyon We proceed in the same as above in the monopole case, but now we lie in the 0. The factorization is y2 m= (z2-x)2+f1= solution we have five vacua, in total. One is the Coulomb vacuum, whose position in the moduli space is not modified by quantum correct ions. Four others are two monopole and two dyon vacua. Their u2coordinate is not modified by quantum correction, but the u1coordinate is changed. This is why they are aligned in Fig. 6. At the critical value x= L2the two monopole vacua and the Coulomb vacuum coalesce together. In Sec t. 4 we performed our analysis near this critical value, in order to have a low action which is weakly coupled on the domain wall profile. Anot her critical value is at x=-L2were the dyon vacua coalesce with the B. Comments on supercharges In this appendix we will show, basing on the central charges, that in N= 2 SQED configurations with flux tubes parallel to the domain wall areno t BPS saturated. We will follow the formalism of Ref. [4]. The supersymmetry transformations in N= 2 SQED are given by the following expressions (where f,p= 1,2 are SU(2) (B.1) Dais the SU(2) Rtriplet D2=D3= 0, the matter us consider a BPS domain wall, oriented in the ( x,y) plane. The following supersymmetry transformations are left unbroken by th e (B.4) Let us consider a vortex parallel to the zaxis. The following are left -e2 .2. (B.5) It is possible then to find a 1 /4-BPS soliton corresponding to a to the wall, because Eqs. (B.4,B.5) are compatible in the sense that we can solve both constraints (B.6) and the -ogiven by Eq. (B.4). Let us then consider a vortex parallel to the yaxis. From a simple spinor rotation, we can find left (B.7) It is easy to check that it is not possible to find a non-trivial solution t o the constraints in Eqs. (B.4) and (B.7). This shows that the configurat ion with the flux tube parallel to the domain wall breaks all supersymmetries of the theory. Let us then consider a domain wall in the ( x,y) plane with some field along the xaxis. As discussed in Figure 16, the are the same of the system of a vortex ending ona w all (modulo a rotation by the angle in Eq. (118) along the G. R. Dvali and M. A. Shifman, Phys. Lett. B 396, 64 (1997) [Erratum- ibid. B407, 452 (1997)] B. S. Acharya and C. Vafa, S. L. Dubovsky and V. A. Rubakov, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 16, 4331 (2001) M. Shifman and A. Yung, Phys. Rev. D 67, 125007 R. Auzzi, M. Shifman and A. Yung, Phys. Rev. D 74, 045007 G. Dvali, H. B. Nielsen and N. Tetradis, Phys. Rev. D 77, 085005 [hep-th]]. [7] A. M. Polyakov, Nucl. Phys. B 120, 429 (1977). [8] M. Shifman and A. Yung, Rev. Mod. Phys. 79, 1139 D. Tong, M. Eto, Y. Isozumi, M. Nitta, K. Ohashi and N. Sakai, J. Phys. A 39 (2006) R315 G. 't Hooft, Nucl. Phys. B 79, 276 (1974); A. M. Polyakov, JETP Lett. 20, 194 (1974) [reprinted in Solitons and Particles , Eds. C. Rebbi and G. Soliani, (World Scientific, Singapore, 1985), p. 522]. [12] A. Abrikosov, Sov. Phys. JETP 321442 (1957) [Reprinted in Solitons and Particles , Eds. C. Rebbi and G. Soliani (World Scientific, Singa- pore, 1984), p. 356]; H. Nielsen and P. Olesen, Nucl. Phys. B6145 (1973) [Reprinted in Solitons and Particles , Eds. C. Rebbi and G. So- liani (World Scientific, Singapore, 1984), p. 365]. [13] N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B 426, 19 (1994) 485 (1994)] R. Jackiw and C. Rebbi, Phys. Rev. D 13, 3398 (1976). [15] J. E. Kiskis, Phys. Rev. D 15, 2329 (1977); M. M. Ansourian, Phys. Lett. B70, 301 (1977); N. K. Nielsen and B. Schroer, Nucl. Phys. B 120, 62 (1977); R. Jackiw and P. Rossi, Nucl. Phys. B 190, 681 (1981); E. J. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. D 24, 2669 (1981). [16] A. Gorsky, M. Shifman and A. Yung, Phys. Rev. D 75, 065032 I. I. Balitsky and A. V. Yung, Phys. Lett. B 168, 113 (1986). [18] F. Cachazo, M. R. Douglas, N. Seiberg and E. Witten, JHEP 0212 (2002) 071 F. Cachazo, N. Seiberg and E. Witten, JHEP 0302, 042 V. S. Kaplunovsky, J. Sonnenschein and S. Yankielowicz, Nucl. P hys. B 552(1999) 209 R. Portugues and P. K. Townsend, Phys. Lett. B 530, 227 B. Chibisov and M. A. Shifman, Phys. Rev. D 56(1997) 7990 [Erratum- ibid. D58(1998) 109901] J. P. Gauntlett, D. Tong and P. K. Townsend, Phys. Rev. D 64, 025010 (2001) D. Tong, Phys. Rev. D 66, 025013 (2002) J. P. Gauntlett, R. Portugues, D. Tong and P. K. Townsend, P hys. Rev. D63, 085002 (2001) Y. Isozumi, M. Nitta, K. Ohashi and N. Sakai, Phys. Rev. D 71, 065018 (2005) S. Bolognesi and M. Shifman, Phys. Rev. D 76, 125024 E. Bogomol'nyi, The stability of classical solutions, Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. 24, 449 (1976) [Reprinted in Solitons and Particles , Eds. C. Rebbi and G. Soliani (World Scientific, Singapore, 1984), p. 389]. [29] E. R. C. Abraham and P. K. Townsend, Phys. Lett. B 291(1992) 85; E. R. C. Abraham and P. K. Townsend, Phys. Lett. B 295(1992) 225. [30] S. L. Dubovsky, V. A. Rubakov and S. M. Sibiryakov, JHEP 0201, 037 (2002) Y. Isozumi, K. Ohashi and N. Sakai, JHEP 0311, 061 (2003) JHEP 0311, 060
|
0807.1908
|
Stefano Bolognesi
|
R. Auzzi, S. Bolognesi, M. Shifman and A. Yung
|
Confinement and Localization on Domain Walls
|
55 pp; v2: several remarks added
|
Phys.Rev.D79:045016,2009
|
10.1103/PhysRevD.79.045016
|
FTPI-MINN-08/24, UMN-TH-2703/08
|
hep-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We continue the studies of localization of the U(1) gauge fields on domain
walls. Depending on dynamics of the bulk theory the gauge field localized on
the domain wall can be either in the Coulomb phase or squeezed into flux tubes
implying (Abelian) confinement of probe charges on the wall along the wall
surface. First, we consider a simple toy model with one flavor in the bulk at
weak coupling (a minimal model) realizing the latter scenario. We then suggest
a model presenting an extension of the Seiberg--Witten theory which is at
strong coupling, but all theoretical constructions are under full control if we
base our analysis on a dual effective action. Finally, we compare our findings
with the wall in a "nonminimal" theory with two distinct quark flavors that had
been studied previously. In this case the U(1) gauge field trapped on the wall
is exactly massless because it is the Goldstone boson of a U(1) symmetry in the
bulk spontaneously broken on the wall. The theory on the wall is in the Coulomb
phase. We explain why the mechanism of confinement discussed in the first part
of the paper does not work in this case, and strings are not formed on the
walls.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 11 Jul 2008 19:02:16 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Fri, 19 Dec 2008 22:53:24 GMT"
}
] | 2010-05-27T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Auzzi",
"R.",
""
],
[
"Bolognesi",
"S.",
""
],
[
"Shifman",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Yung",
"A.",
""
]
] |
Do Quoc Tuan 1 Abstract In this paper, I present almost my works performed during my time a t VNU. I was interested in the composite Skyrme model proposedby H. Y. Cheun g andF. Gursey. The expanding for this model based on results obtained from the or iginal Skyrme model given by T. H. R. Skyrme in 1961 was general and interesting.Do Quoc Tuan want to show deep gratitude to my supervisor Dr. Pham Thuc Tuye n (De- partment of Theoretical Physics, College of Science (another nam e is Hanoi Uni- versity of Science), Vietnam National University) because of ever ything that he has been teaching and supporting me during a student's time! I also thank Department of Theoretical Physics and Faculty of Phy sics for giving me the best conditions to completing the thesis! Finally, and most of all, I want to give my thesis to my parent, my belove d as a special gift for the supports over a long period! Ha noi, 6/2007 Do Quoc Tuan1 1email: Why is the Skyrme model 4 1.1 The weak point of QCD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 1.2 The idea of Skyrme . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 2 The massless composite Skyrme model 9 2.1 The formalism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 2.2 Calculations for static quantities of baryon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 3 The composite Skyrme model with pion's mass 19 3.1 The term of pion'mass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 3.2 The field equation and numerical results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20 4 The supersymmetric composite Skyrme model 23 5 Appendix 30 5.1 Some notations for Chapter 2 and 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 5.2 Some notations for Chapter 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 3Chapter 1 Why is the Skyrme model 1.1 The weak point of we candivide thenaturein two types of particles: matt er particles and field particles. Matter particles interact together by fields conclud ing transfer inter- action particles. There are four fields corresponding four interac tions (four forces) and their particles. The graviton is a transfer interaction particle o f the photon is a transfer interaction particle of electromag netic force, W+-and Zoare transfer interaction particle of weak force, the gluon is trans fer of strong force. It is known well, quarks are interact toge ther by the strong force. In other word, the interaction of quarks is the exchange o f gluons. And the theory that describes quarks and their interaction is QCD(Quantum Chromo Dynamics ). In mathematically, Gell-Mann and Neuman proposed that quarks make up a multiple which represents the gauge SU(3) being the group of 3 x3 unitary matrices with determinant 1. Gell-Mann firstly gives generators of they are called Gell-Mann matrices l. They satisfy the Lie algebra [li,lj] = 2ifijklk, the structure constant. It is totally (1.2) To describe the interaction between quarks, we need using the gluo n fieldAa u . And now, the Lagrangian density is the Yang-Mills Lagrangian densit (1.3) Au=Aa ula, (1.5) 4Do Quoc Tuan 5 wheregis a constant of interaction. At the high energy scale ( >TeV),QCDis very good to use. But, when the energy lower (in GeV), it meets with some problems in which describe quantities of quarks and gluons. The main cause is the high value of g, it obstructs an expansion of interaction terms of hadron. To rep air this problem, t'Hooft proposed that 1 /Ncplays asg(Ncis color number in a gauge theory). And, he gave that in large- equivalent to an effective field theory of meson. 1.2 The idea of Skyrme In 1961, Skyrme gave the new model in which baryons may be obtaine d from the theory of meson [1]. He began with the Lagrangian density of pu/vector p-m2 2/vector p/vector p, (1.6) in whichp's make up a three dimensional isotopic space. After, he expanded t he isotopicSU(2) becomes a new group with the algebra [Vi,Vj] = 2ieijkVk, (1.7) [Ai,Aj] = 2ieijkVk, (1.8) [Vi,Aj] = 2ieijkAk, (1.9) where generators Viare vector charges, generators Aiare axial charges. And now, an isotopic space have four components {/vector p} - {/vector in a rule [Vi,phj] = 2ieijkphk, (1.10) [Vi,ph4] = 0, (1.11) [Ai,phj] =-2ieijph4, (1.12) [Ai,ph4] = 2iphi. (1.13) Particles described by phi(i= 1,2,3) are pseudo- scalars and making A particle described by ph4has a positive parity, a spin and an isotopic spin equals zero, and it is a vacuum. If (1.15) then obtaining a new algebraDo Quoc Tuan 6 [Li,Lj] =2ieijkLk =2ieijkRk =0. (1.18) This is an algebra of the chiral group SU(2)xSU(2). Thus, the expanding group is the chiral group SU(2)xSU(2). Continuously, he proposed that {/vector ph,ph4}
form a three dimensional sphere
/vector ph2+ph2 4= 1. (1.19) Recently, {/vector ph,ph4}are associated with 2 x2 unitaryU(x,t) matrix U(x,t) = expi/vector t/vector p(x,t) ,
= expi/vector t/vector p pp,Do Quoc Tuan 7
= cosp+i/vector t/vector p psinp, p2,t's are Pauli matrices. Pion fields now are associated with /vector (1.21)
/vector ph=/vector p psinp. 1. (1.23) The Lagrangian density proposed by Skyrme [1] anSU(2) matrix transforming as U-AUB-1under an chiral SU(2)x SU(2). He proved that the model has a soliton solution (called hedgeho g1solution) Uo= t/vector (1.25) whereF(r) is the chiral angle, baryons areobtained fromthe quantization of chapter 2). It is well known that in the large- Nlimit,QCDmay beregarded as the theory of effective meson fields. E. Witten argued that baryons may be reg arded as solitons of this effective meson theory without an further reference to th eir quark content [2]. We know that solitons have not a spin. But, by quantizing around s olitons, we obtain the special topological construct of these solitons which ma kes a spin. On the other hand, soliton solutions have a limited spatial distribution, t herefore, they are correlative to particles that have a limited spatial dimension [2,15]. 1firstly called by Polyakov, see at L. Ryder ,Quantum Field Theory (second edition), Cam- bridge University PressDo Quoc Tuan 8 Figure 1.1: The configuration of hedgehog, arrows on it are isotopic vectors of/vector cChapter 2 The massless composite Skyrme model 2.1 The formalism In 1983, G. S. Adkins, C. R. Nappi and E. Witten used the Skyrme's id ea to com- puted the static properties of baryons on the chiral group SU(2)xSU(2) and found that the model gives predictions that agree well with experiments [2 ]. However, this model has a problem in which the situation of particles at low energy ar e not in- terested but it regards that particles in free states, and this poin t can reduce the exactitude of theoretical datum. In 1989, this problem is treated by P. T. Tuyen and N. A. Viet [3]. They considered that at low energy particles are not fr ee but they would shrink together into the cluster. Therefore, the group tha t describes This model gives few datum better than the sigma model. In 1990, H. Y. Cheung, F. Gursey [4] gave the general mode l in which the sigma model and the V-Tmodel are two special cases corresponding with n= 1 andn= 2. They introduced a composite Vn=UPUP...PU , whereU(x,t)is theSU(2)matrix and P=po+i/vector t./vector pis the constant SU(2)matrix, and they proposed the composite Skyrme lagrangian the pion decay constant, eis a dimensionless parameter. Under the chiral group as as P-BPA+, and soVntransforms as Vn-AVnB+. In the limit P-I,Vn-Un, the lagrangian (2.1) becomes approximated by the Quoc Tuan 10 Now, U0(r) = are Pauli's matrices and ^ r=/vector r/r, the lagrangian density (2.2) ~r=eFpris the dimensionless variable. And the static energy of hedgehog is En=Fp eAn=Mn, equationof F(r)fromminimum condition of the hedgehog's energy dFEn= 0, -equation) 0.(2.8) To solve this equation we need boundary conditions for the F(r). The first condition of F(r)that relates to the limit of hedgehog's energy when r- is F() = 0. The second condition relating to the exist of baryonic number B is F(0) =p. This equation can not give us the analytic solution. So we will solve it by the numerical method. Now we will quantize the soliton by collective coordinates A(t) =ao(t) +
i/vector a(t)/vector twithau(t) (u= 0,1,2,3) are collective coordinates, A(t) isSU(2) matrix. From properties of SU(2) matrix, we have A(t)A+(t) = 1 a(t)/vector a(t)/vector t}= 1 , auau=1. (2.9) By time derivative, resulting au. au=0 (2.10)Do Quoc Tuan 11 Figure 2.1: The numerical solution of (2.8) for cases of n=2 and n=4 [2 2, 25]. By this way, solitons to be particles. Different quantization take diffe rent particles. Thus, it takes us to the new idea about the origin of partic les in nature in which they are made by a basic particle (called soliton). With the will transform as Un(x,t) and we put it into (2.2), the lagrangian now (2.13) The conjugate momenta are obtained from the derivative of lagran gian follow- ing Quoc Tuan 4Gn.au. (2.14) We go to the (2.15) Canonical quantizing momenta pu=-i aulet the hamiltonian (2.16) Now, we will define the isotopic vector /vector cfollowing the way .A+A= ,
= a+/vector t, note (2.10), we c/vector t, a+/vector (2.18) The square isotopic vector /vector cis
/vector c2= .a2 0/vector a,
= .a2 0/vector a./vectora)2,Do Quoc Tuan 13
= .au.au. the same direction, rotation in the co-ordinate space can mak e an isospin of particle, and we assume that a spin equals to an isospin. The canonica l momenta that correspond with collective coordinates are isospins. We can ho mogenize/vector c2with the square of a spin and an isospin
/vector (2.20) Thus, we a spin and /vectorTis an isospin. Eigenvalues of hamiltonian (2.21) the quantum number of spin. So, the nucleon ( J= 1/2) and the delta (J= 3/2) masses are given by MN=Mn+3 8Gn, (2.24) Note (2.12), (2.13), (2.23), (2.24) we (2.26) 2.2 Calculations for static quantities of baryon After constructing the formalism of massless composite model, we a pply to the baryon (nucleon). Since this model is constructed depend on some ideas of theory of topology then we can start at the topological current to calcula tions for of baryon [2, 3, 4, 15].Do Quoc Tuan 14 The topological current (a baryonic current) is 1 (totally we putUn(x,t) into (2.27), we will (2.29) Note (2.17) and (2.20), then (2.29) is (2.30) The baryonic number 1. (2.31) The iso-scalar electric square radius (2.32) The iso-scalar magnetic square radius (2.33) We have the time's component of vector current Quoc Tuan 15 note (2.35) The density of charge of nucleon is defined by Gell-Mann - we have rnu(r) we have the charge's densities of proton and neutron. After integrating, we obtain charges of a proton and a 1, 0. (2.40) The iso-vector electric square radius and the iso-vector magnetic square (2.41) However, intheexperiment the iso-vector electric radiusis 0.88, radius is 0.8. This is the weak point of the massless composite Skyrme model!Do Quoc Tuan 16 The iso-scalar magnetic moment is defined
/vector (2.42) and the result is
/vector (2.43) The connection between the spin and the magnetic moment is
/vector u=g 2MN/vectorJ. (2.44) Note (2.23, 2.24), we (2.45) The iso-vector magnetic moment is defined
/vector the vector current. After few calculations, the result is
/vector (2.47) And we also (2.48) Using (2.44) and (2.47), we can axial coupling is Quoc Tuan 17 Figure 2.2: Plots of density of neutron charge and proton charge f or a case of n= 2 [25]. Figure 2.3: Plots of density of neutron charge and proton charge f or a case of n= 4 [25].Do Quoc Tuan 18 NUMERICAL RESULTS TABLE FOR THE CASE OF N=4 [25] Quantity Prediction Experiment e 1.10 - Fp(MeV) 168 1.10 1.93 0.8 upro(mag) 2.55 2.79 uneu(mag) -0.66 3.86 1.46 gA 3.52 1.23Chapter 3 The composite Skyrme model with pion's mass 3.1 The term of pion'mass When Skyrme constructed a model from the theory of pi-meson, h e did not let the term of mass of pion because of its spontaneous symmetry breakin g. However, with n= 1,2,3,4, datum of prediction are not really exact. One of causes that we d o not let the term of pion's mass into the lagrangian [2, 3]. Therefore, w e will propose the composite lagrangian density with the pion's mass [22, 24]. The lagrangian density now (3.1) Now using the hedgehog form gave by Skyrme Uo(r) = exp[it.^rF(r)], where t's are Pauli's matrices and ^ r=/vector r
|/vector r|, the lagrangian density energy of hedgehog (3.4) 19Do Quoc Tuan (3.6)
~r=eFpris a dimensionless variable. After some steps of calculation as chapter 2 , we go to the a spin and /vectorTis an isospin. Eigenvalues of hamiltonian (3.7) (3.8) l= 2JandJis the quantum number of spin. So, the nucleon ( J= 1/2) and delta ( J= 3/2) masses are given (3.10) From (3.9) and (3.10), we The field equation and numerical results We obtain the nonlinear differential equation of F(r) from minimum condition of the hedgehog's 0, (3.13)Do Quoc Tuan 0(Euler-Lagrange -equation), (3.16) We see that (3.16) contains the constant of eandFpbut they are not known because they are must found after solving (3.15). Thus, we will solv e (3.15) by the way is taking the value of bin spite ofeandFpand raising it until it the bthat defined by (3.11, 3.12, 3.16). In this case n= 4, we need the value of bis 0.0025 [24]. Figure 3.1: Plots of numerical solution for a case of n= 4 [24].Do Quoc Tuan 22 Figure 3.2: Plots of density of neutron charge and proton charge f or a case of n= results that are obtained above by us ( chapter 2 ), quantities of baryon (proton and neutron) are described below [24] NUMERICAL RESULTS TABLE FOR THE CASE OF N=4 Quantity Prediction Experiment e 2.87 - Fp(MeV) 446.56 0.21 2.26 1.0 2.26 0.8 upro(mag) 1.64 2.79 uneu(mag) -1.57 1.04 1.46 gA 1.22 1.23Chapter 4 The supersymmetric composite Skyrme model The fundamental theories of particles consider that elementary p articles are points. They all have the spin half-one and combining them together will make particles which have the structural space. But, the model gave by Skyrme is quite otherwise. He consider that there are solitons. In these models, one consider that have the structural space and the spin zero. By quantiz ing these solitons, we obtain real particles that have the spin non-zero. Since working with solitons, these models are all nonlinear. There is an important point that thes e models work at the ideal case (a pion's mass is zero). That makes datum of p rediction are not really exact. Thus, we need to let the term of pion's mass in these models. But, with only pion, the models would not be exact, because we also ha ve other mesons. Must let all of mesons into the model. Thus, we extend the m odel onto the SU(3)group. But then will be an another cause that makes the model is no t really exact. In general we must consider the contributions of the part icle partners of the mesons. On the other hand, each meson has a superpartner (m ake up from When all of these contributions are counted in t he model, it may be exact R.I.Nepomachie, osedSkyrmion of four-dimensional supersymmetric non-linear sigma model [5]. The composite Skyrme model proposed by H. Y. Cheung and F. Gursey in 1990. It's the general model in which the sigma model and V-Tmodel are two special cases 1,2. Thus, we will calculate the composite model in the supersymmetry by the way proposed by E. A. Bergshoeff et al [26]. We recall the Lagrangian density of composite Skyrme Quoc Tuan 24 withfpis the pion decay constant, eis a dimensionless into covaria nt (4.2) the Lagrangian density (4.1) is is invariant under local U(1)Rand global (4.5) Really, we have (DuU-n)'= ,Do Quoc Tuan (4.9) The second term of Lagrangian is proved similarly. The gauge field Vu(r) is (4.10) We parameterize the SU(2) matrixUn(r) in terms of the complex scalars Ai Un(r) (4.11) with the unitary constraint U+U= 1. (4.12) Now, (4.2) (u-iVu)Ai, (4.14) Du-Ai= (u+iVu)-Ai. (4.15) The form of gauge field is Quoc Tuan 26
=Vu(r) =-i 2n-Ai- Ai. (4.16) With matrix Un(r) is defined in (4.11) and the gauge field is defined in (4.16), the supersymmetric Lagrangian density (4.3) is =uVn-nVu. (4.18) Really, we have
+The first (4.19)
+The second 1=uU-nUn+U-nuUn= 0, (4.21) (4.20) is now (4.20) (4.22)Do Quoc Tuan 27 The second term is now
= (4.23) We (4.27) From (4.23) and (4.27), we (4.28) To supersymmetrise this model, we extend Aito chiral scalar multiples ( 1,2) and the vector Vu(r) to real vector multiples ( Vu,la,D). Here, the fieldsFiare complex scalars, Dis real scalar, psai,laare Majorana to a left-handed chiral spinor, -psai= to a right-handed one. The supersymmetric Lagrangian density is give n (4.31) is invariant under supersymmetric (4.37)Do Quoc Tuan 28 The field equation and their supersymmetric transformations lead t o the fol- lowing constraints with -AiAi= 0, (4.38) -Aipsai= 0, (4.39) -AiFi= 0 (4.40) and following algebraic expressions 0, However, thereis the gauge covariant we may let it to the Lagrangian (4.47) Now, we recall the hedgehog ansatz Un(r) = t/vector r rsinnf(r). (4.48) From (4.11), we have A1= (4.50)Do Quoc Tuan 29 Inserting the hedgehog ansatz into the supersymmetric Lagrang ian density, we obtain the supersymmetric static energy E= (4.52) The Euler-Lagrange equation takes the field 0, the dimensionless variable and boundary conditions f(0) =p, (4.56) f() = 0. (4.57) Figure 4.1: Plots of supersymmetric numerical solution of f(x) for a case of a=
1,b= 0,n= 2,3 [26].Chapter 5 Appendix 5.1 Some notations for Chapter 2 and 3 There are some notations to calculations in chapter 2 and 3
xuu= (0,i) (5.2) iF(r) (5.3) Un o(r) = = t.^rsin{nF(r)}; (5.4) U-n o(r) = = t.^rsin{nF(r)}; (5.5) Some identities of Pauli matrices (5.6) (ti)2= 1; 2; (5.9) Tr(ti) = 0; (5.10) We will define uUn o(r) tu(^rsinnF) t ri/vector rsinnF+i/vector t/vector t/vector r riFcosnF, 30Do Quoc Tuan t/vector t/vector rF'xi r2cosnF; (5.11) uU-n o(r) tu(^rsinnF) t/vector t/vector rF'xi r2cosnF; (5.12) uUn o(r) tu(^rsinnF) t/vector t/vector rF'xi r2cosnF; (5.13) The first term of the Lagrangian density (2.2) is defined
= t/vector t/vector t/vector t/vector t/vector t/vector t/vector t/vector t/vector t/vector (5.14) To defined the second term of the Lagrangian density (2.2), we will g o to the intermediary step using the unitary condition of Un o U-n oUn o= 0. (5.15) The second term of Lagrangian density (2.2) is now
= (5.16) Note (5.11), (5.12) we can define L2 n= (5.17)Do Quoc Tuan 32 5.2 Some notations for Chapter 4 Dotted and undotted spinor indices run from 1 to 2 and are denoted by the Spinorindices 1 -1 (5.19) For (5.21) The product (5.22) In the special (5.23) The hermitian conjugates of the spinors psandkhare-psand -kh -ps.a= (psa)+, (5.24) -kh= (kha)+. (5.25) Their dotted indices are raised and lowered by the tensors equal to their undotted counterparts eabandeab. The product of them -kh.a-ps.a= -kh-ps. (5.26) In the special (5.27) The hermitian conjugates of the product khpsis (khps)+= -kh-ps. (5.28) The Pauli matrices sm a.bareDo Quoc Tuan 0 0 1 1 s2=/parenleftbigg 0-i is3=/parenleftbigg 1 (5.29) Other useful identities (5.33) Using these above notations, we can define -e.a-Fi, (5.37) d-l.a= permute together, dLsusyis T. H. R. Skyrme, Nucl. Phys. ,31(1962) 566. [2] G. S. Adkins, C. R. Nappi and E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. ,B228(1983) 552. G. S. Adkins, Nucl. Phys. ,B249(1985) 507. G.S. Adkins, C. R. Nappi, Nucl. Phys. , B233(1984) 109. E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. ,B223(1983) 422. E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. , B223(1983) 433. [3] N. A. Viet, P. T. Tuyen, J. Phys.,G15(July 1989) 937. [4] H. Y. Cheung, Feza Gursey, Modern Physics Letters A ,Vol.5 No.21 (1990) 1685 [5] E. A. Bergshoeff, R. I. Nepomachie, H. J. Schnitzer, Nucl. Phys. ,B249(1985) 93 [6] N. Shiiki, N. Sawado, S.Oryu, hep-th/0603069 (2006) [7] A. Acus, hep-ph/9901240 (1999) [8] C. Houghton, S. Magee, hep-th/0602227 (2006) [9] J. Wess, B. Zumino, Nucl. Phys. ,B70(1974) 39. J. Wess, B. Zumino, Nucl. Phys. , B78(1974) 1. [10] A. Salam, J. Strathdee, Nucl. Phys. ,B76(1974) 477. A. Salam, J. Strathdee, 499. [11] M. F. Sohnius, Physics Report ,128, Nos 2 and 3 , (1985), 39 - 204 [12] P. T. Tuyen, Quantum Mechanics ,in Vietnamese , College of Science, VNU, (2004) [13] P. T. Tuyen, Theory of Fundamental Particles ,in Vietnamese , College of Science, VNU, (2006) [14] P. T. Tuyen, Theory of Group ,in Vietnamese , College of Science, VNU, (2006) [15] L. Ryder, Quantum Field Theory ,second edition , Press, (1996) [16] S. Weinberg, The Quantum Theory of Fields ,vol I, II, III , Cambridge (1995) [17] M. E. Peskin, D. V. Shroeder, An Introduction to Quantum Field Theory , Westview Press, (1995) [18] H. Georgi, Lie Algebras in Particle Physics ,second edition , Perseus Books, (1999) [19] W. Greiner, J. Reinhardt, Field Quantization , Springer, (1996) [20] A. Bilal, hep-th/0101055 (2001) [21] K. Cahill, hep-ph/9907295 (1999) [22] D. Q. Tuan, P. T. Tuyen, J. Science. (Math - Phys) , VNU,T.XXII, No 2AP (2006) 194 34Do Quoc Tuan 35 [23] D. Q. Tuan, P. T. Tuyen, Phenomenal models of Baryon ,Talk in on Theoretical Physics 31 , Cua Lo, Nghe An, 2006 D. Q. Tuan, P. T. Tuyen, The composite Skyrme model with the mass of pion, (no-published) 2006 [25] D. Q. Tuan, P. T. Tuyen, The composite Skyrme model with N=4 , (no- published) 2006 [26] D. Q. Tuan, P. T. Tuyen, The supersymmetric composite skyrmion , (no- published) 2007 [27] Nikolaev V.A. , Tkachev O.G. , hep-ph/0109192 (2001) [28] O.V.Pavlovskii, hep-th/0312343 (2003) [29] R. A. Battye, P. M. Sutcliffe, hep-th/0602220 (2006) [30] D. Q. Tuan, P. T. Tuyen, The formalism of gravitational composite in National Conference on Theoretical Physics 32 , Nha Trang, Khanh Hoa, 2007 (no-published)
|
0807.1951
|
Tuan Do quoc
|
Do Quoc Tuan
|
Phenomenological models of baryon
|
36 pages, 7 figures
| null | null | null |
hep-ph nucl-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this paper, I present almost my works performed during my time at VNU. I
was interested in the composite Skyrme model proposed by H. Y. Cheung and F.
Gursey. The expanding for this model based on results obtained from the
original Skyrme model given by T. H. R. Skyrme in 1961 was general and
interesting.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sat, 12 Jul 2008 03:10:05 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-16T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Tuan",
"Do Quoc",
""
]
] |
scaffold mediated signaling whereby a model cascade assembles onto a scaffold. In modeling this scenario in itself, we hope to learn more about the functional and mechanistic consequences that these specific physical constraints, imposed by of a biochemical cascade onto a scaffold, confer to signaling pathways. In parsing these effects from the myriad othersthat are undoubtedly important, our hope is that our results can serve as a framework for understanding the extent to which these effects are important in specific biological contexts such as the Mitogen Activated Protein Kinase (MAPK) pathway. One theoretical analysis of scaffold mediated cell the presence of non mononotic behavior in signal output as a function of scaffold concentration [34]. If scaffolds are required for signaling, then too few scaffolds will be detrimental to signaling. On the other hand, if scaffolds are present in excess,signaling complexes become incompletely assembled and the signal output is attenuated. As a consequence of this scaffolds were shown to also differentially affect the kinetics of signaling. The observation that scaffolds can differentially affect leads to many questions. How do scaffold proteins control the time scales involved in signal propagation? Animportant metric of cell signaling is the time it takes for a downstream kinase to become active [35,36]. As signal transduc- tion is stochastic in nature, the more precise question is: what is the distribution of times characterizing the activation of a How do scaffolds affect this distribution, and what might be the biological consequences of changes in this distribution as a result of signaling on a scaffold? We compute first passage [37] using a stochastic computer simulation method to investigate these we use a kinetic Monte Carlo algorithm. We have previously used such methods to study a different the regulation of signal amplitude by scaffold proteins [33]. It is also possible that a differential equation model that considers mean-field kinetics could be used to study the firstpassage time distribution [37]. However, such an approach wouldrequire the imposition of absorbing boundary conditions that can make the numerical analysis difficult. Our simulation results suggest that, depending on scaffold proteins can allow kinase cascades to operatein different dynamical regimes that allow for large increases and decreases in the speed and characteristic time scale of Furthermore, and perhaps more are shown to influence the statistical properties of thetimes at which kinases are activated in complex ways. kinases cascades can allow for broadly distributed waiting times of kinase activation, whereas in the absence of a scaffold, thetime it takes for a kinase to be activated is effectively characterizedby a single time scale. These stochastic characteristics of kinase cascades are, to our knowledge, elucidated for the first time and may have diverse biological consequences thatpertain to how signal duration is regulated. It is also our hope thatour results provide a framework for achieving a deeper of how scaffolding proteins can regulate the dynamics of cell signaling and the statistical properties of of a Protein Kinase Cascade For our study, we considered a model three tiered protein kinase cascade such as the MAPK pathway [38]. Since our aim is to studythe effects of spatially localizing protein kinases on we considered a minimal description of a model kinase cascade. Many factors that are undoubtedly important in regulating signaling dynamics were not considered. These factorsinclude feedback regulation within the cascade, allosteric and orcatalytic functions provided by the scaffold, and the effects of multiple phosphorylations of each kinase our model, signal propagation occurs in a three fashion: an initial stimulus (S) activates a MAP3K (A) that in turn, activates a MAP2K (B), that subsequently can activate its MAPK (C) can deactivateeach activated species and this deactivation occurs regardless ofwhether or not the active kinase is bound to a scaffold. A schematic is presented in Figure 1A that illustrates the basic processes that are allowed in our model. A steady-state ensemble isconsidered. That is, simulations are allowed to first reach adynamic steady-state and once this state is reached, dynamics are studied. We do not consider dynamics from the starting time that requires propagation through a hierarchical cascade. Recent work has studied the statistical dynamics of that result from the hierarchical organization of a kinase cascade; in that study, it was shown that the hierarchical structure of the cascade gives rise to broad waiting time distributions ofcascade activation. In the regime that we study here, these effectsare absent since activation of the cascade requires that an inactive C protein encounter an active B protein; our motivation is thus to investigate how the dynamics of kinase activation can be affectedby assembling components of the cascade onto a that localizes single complexes. Therefore, we do not emphasize how the hierarchical structure of a signaling cascade effects signal propagation and instead focus on how assembly ofthe cascade onto a scaffold affects signaling dynamics. We alsounderscore the notion that in our approach, many effects such as the hierarchical structure of protein kinase cascades, the influence of feedback loops, mechanisms and allosteric control by scaffolds areneglected. Again, by excising these effects, we restrict our attention to a hypothetical scenario that aims only to investigate theAuthor Summary Signal transduction is the science of cellular communica- tion. Cells detect signals from their environment and usethem to make decisions such as whether or when toproliferate. Tight regulation of signal transduction is required for all healthy cells, and aberrant signaling leads to countless diseases such as cancer and diabetes. Forexample, in higher organisms such as mammals, that leads to cell proliferation is often guided by a scaffold protein. Scaffolding proteins direct the assembly of multiple proteins involved in cell signalingby providing a platform for these proteins to carry out efficient signal transmission. Although scaffolds are widely believed to have dramatic effects on how signal transduc-tion is carried out, the mechanisms that underlie are not well understood. Therefore, we used a computational approach that simulates the behavior of a model signal transduction module comprising a set ofproteins in the presence of a scaffold. The mechanisms for how scaffolds can the timing of cell signaling. Scaffolds allow for controlled levels of signal that are delivered inside the cellat appropriate times. Our findings support the possibility that these signaling dynamics regulated by scaffolds affect cell decision-making in many medically important intra-cellular Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 2 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | of assembling components of a cascade onto a scaffold protein. The key quantities computed and parameters used are discussed below in Table 1 and Figure 1B. Additional details are provided inthe Methods section.The Concentration of Scaffold Proteins Sets Time Scales for Signal Propagation Through a Kinase Cascade To set the context, consider the consequences of signaling in two limiting cases in our model. When the binding affinity of thekinases to the scaffold, E, is low (defined here to be close to thethermal energy, E,k BT; k Bis Boltzman's constant and T is the temperature) and kinases disassociate rapidly from the scaffold,few proteins on average are bound to a scaffold. dynamics corresponds to that of a kinase cascade insolution. For a very strong affinity, E&k BTall available binding sites to scaffold proteins are occupied by kinases (on average). Inthis case, signaling dynamics are controlled by the time requiredfor initial stimuli to encounter and interact with each fullyassembled we consider cases in which kinases can their scaffolds and exchange with unbound kinases on timescales pertinent to cell signaling processes. Such time scalescorrespond to disassociation constants ( K d) on the order of 1- 10mM and off rates, k off,1s21. Such K dvalues correspond to free energies of binding of roughly 7-9 kcal/mol, an energy scaletypical of protein-protein interactions in kinase cascades [41]. Wehave used 12 k BTas the binding energy in our simulations to ,7.2kcal/mol. We also discuss the robustness of our results with respect to changes in this value. has been identified as a key variable that canregulate the efficiency of signal propagation through a kinasecascade [2,5,34]. For the set of parameters used in the 1), signal output (defined as the average steady state valueof the final kinase in the cascade) has a dependence on the relative concentration of scaffolds f(f: 1/2Scaffold /C138 1/2MAP where [ Scaffold ] is the concentration of the Figure 1. A model to study dynamical properties of a scaffold mediated signaling cascade. (A) Schematic of the events considered in the scaffold mediated signaling cascade. Each kinase, if activated, can activate its downstream substrate when the two proteins are in close can bind and unbind to the scaffold and phosphatases can, upon encountering an active kinase, deactivate it. Activation potentially occursboth in solution and on a scaffold. Each forward and backward reaction is modeled as a elementary reactive collision with an energy barrier, E. Energybarriers, E, were taken to be zero so that all kinetics are diffusion limited (B) Key variables and the main quantities computed are shown. fis scaffold concentration. The concentration of scaffold proteins [ Scaffold ] is scaled to the density of the first kinase in the cascade [MAP 3K] 0(f: 1/2Scaffold /C138 1/2MAP 3K/C1380). The survival probability where s(t) is zero is a kinase has become active and one otherwise (brackets denote an ensemble average); S(t) is the probability that the final kinase has been activated given that it was inactive at t=0 where fAis the fraction of active kinases at steady state; R(t) is the integrated reactive flux of kinase activation. time scale of signal propagation tis defined by the relation 1. Notation and parameters used. Index i Species Type Index 0 Stimulus (S) j= 1 1 MAPKKK (A) j= 2 Unbound, active i= 2 MAPKK (B) j= 3 Bound, inactive i= 3 MAPK (C) j= 4 Bound, active i= 4 Phosphatase (P) Parameter Used Description Value Energy barrier for: E1,3,E2,4 Binding 0 kBT E3,1,E4,2 Unbinding 12 kBT E1,2,E3,4 Catalytic activation 0 kBT E2,1,E4,3 Catalytic deactivation 12 time scale time scale 10
*All other values of Ej,j' are taken to be Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 3 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e1000099scaffold and [ MAP 3K]0is the concentration of the first kinase in the cascade) and peaks at an optimal value of f= 1 [33,34]. To quantify signaling dynamics, we consider a S(t) (methods) that, as mentioned, can be viewed as a type of autocorrelation s(t) equals 0 or 1 depending upon the activity of the final kinase within the cascade (methods) and the brackets indicate an average over all kinases in the simulation averaged over manysimulations. This quantity gives the probability that the finalkinase in the cascade remains inactive at time t given that it wasinactive at time t= 0. Therefore, signaling dynamics can be monitored by observing the decay of this function with time. In Figure 2A, S(t) is computed for different values of the concentration, f. The intrinsic time of signal propagation, t, is the value at which S(t) decays to e 21of its original Upon increasing scaffold concentration, tincreases. At very high scaffold expression levels, signals propagate soslowly that cell signaling is not observed on time scales which we take to be in our Carlo (MC) steps; 1 MC step ,1ms assuming a lattice spacing of 10 nm and a diffusion coefficient of 10 mm2/s [42]. The increase in tspans several orders of magnitude as is observed in Figure 2B. Distinct stages are also observed in the behavior of t, and are separated by an inflection point past the optimal value of scaffold concentration ( f,1). This phenomenon suggests that different physical processes aredetermining the signaling dynamics at different ranges of results also suggest that the concentration of can in principle set an intrinsic time scale that determines the speed of signal propagation. Such an intrinsic time scale arises solely from changes in the concentration of scaffold proteins. Thistime scale can span several orders of magnitude for affinities and diffusion coefficients and increases mono-tonically with increasing scaffold that these calculations consider only the speed of signaling and do not necessarily imply that signaling is more efficient when t is small. To observe the total amount of integrated signal flux, the survival probability is conditioned with the probability that a kinase in the pool of signaling molecules is active in the steadystate. We compute R(t) defined as S(t) multiplied by the average number of (the final downstream) kinases active at fAis the fraction of active kinases at steady state. The time derivative, {d dtRtdTh, can be thought of as a flux of being produced. In Figure 2C, R(t) is plotted as a function of time. For low concentrations of scaffolds, the small amount of signal, albeit quickly propagating, is rapidly quenched. As increases, both the amplitude and duration of thesignal increase up to an optimal value. Past the optimal value,higher scaffold concentrations result in signals with smallamplitude but the duration of signaling is extended. The behavior of the integrated reactive flux is a direct consequence of the existence of an optimal scaffold concentration and ''bell curve since the area under these curves is proportional tothe average signal output [33,34].Scaffold Proteins Influence the Duration of Signaling by Controlling How Kinase Activation Is Distributed Over Time Figure 2 emphasizes how the characteristic time for is influenced by changes in the relative It also appears that the qualitative features of S(t) change as scaffold concentration is varied. The decay of appears highly concentrated at a particular time while the decay of other distributions appears more further investigate this observation, we plotted the as a function of the dimensionless time, t/t. If the decay of S(t) is purely exponential, then S(t/t) will have the form e 2t/t. Figure 3 shows S(t/t) for different values of and a decaying exponential function is given as areference. One notices that S(t/t) is exponential at concentrations. As scaffold concentration increases, thebehavior of S(t/t) deviates from a single exponential decay. Near f=1 , S(t/t) shows maximal deviation from purely As scaffold expression increases past this point, the shapeofS(t/t) reverts back to an exponential form. A deviation from exponential behavior can be quantified by considering a stretched exponential fitting S(t/t) to this form for different values of f. One desirable feature of the stretched exponential function is theminimal number of parameters, tandb, that are involved in fit; also, the values of these parameters can bephysically interpreted. tgives the characteristic time for one overall timescale of signal propagation, and bis a measure of how much the function, S(t), deviates from a single exponential and thus how broadly distributed are the signaling dynamics. Figure 3Bshows how bdepends on scaffold concentration. For b,1 for small and large values of scaffold concen- trations indicating exponential behavior. For intermediate values,bpeaks at a minimum of b,0.6, a significant deviation from purely exponential behavior. In the limits of small and large scaffold concentrations, the presence of a single exponential decay, b,1 indicates that , or the relaxation of S(t/t), occurs at one character- istic time scale. In the intermediate regime, bshows from one, thus allowing for a broadly distributed signal.When bis significantly less than one, signals can steadily propagate over several decades. In this regime, the waiting time a large tail and the activation of kinases is slowly maintained over many time scales. A Multistate Kinetic Mechanism Illustrates the Competition Between the Many Time Scales Involved Cell Signaling Why do we observe exponential and non-exponential behavior under different conditions? Signal transduction in our modeloccurs on a time scale that is much slower than the microscopictime scales associated with diffusion, and enzyme catalysis. We might therefore expect that some coarse- graining exists whereby events at these fast, ''microscopic'' Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 4 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e1000099scales interact with other relevant biophysical parameters (e.g. scaffold concentration) to give rise to emergent properties thatevolve on slower times scales. These processes are a manifestationof the collective dynamics of the many processes that occur on faster time scales. Understanding the factors that govern these emergent time scales would then provide insight into the origin ofthe different temporal characteristics that are revealed by order for a signal to propagate (i.e. for the last kinase in the cascade to become active), a hierarchical sequence of reactions among kinases must occur that leads to the final kinase in the cascade being activated by its upstream kinases. Theactivation process may occur either in solution or on a scaffold.Also, in the course of signaling, kinases can exchange from a scaffold. Some kinases are bound to a scaffold that contains an incomplete assembly of the necessary signaling molecules, and arenot signaling competent. Ultimately, an inactive kinase can exist inone of three states: in solution, bound to a complete complex, orbound to an incomplete complex. Figure 4A contains a diagram of such a minimal picture and arrows denote transitions between thefour states. This minimalist description clarifies the behavior in Figures 3A and 3B. For low scaffold concentrations ( f%1), kinases predom- inately exist in solution and signal transduction is dominated bythe time it takes for an upstream kinase to encounter its downstream enzyme. Since a steady-state ensemble is used, the rate limiting step for signal propagation is the diffusion limitedcollision between an active B* molecule with an inactive C molecule. For high scaffold concentrations ( f&1), exist in incomplete signaling complexes and is limited by a time scale that characterizes theturnover of a signaling incompetent complex to one that is able to signal. For intermediate concentrations, inactive kinases can exist in each of three states and transitions between these states alsooccur. Thus, the source of the nonexponential relaxation (i.e. b,1) arises from the mixing of many time scales that are relevant for Figure 2. The concentration of scaffold proteins sets time scales for signal propagation. (A)S(t) as a function of time for different values of relative scaffold concentration, f(f: 1/2Scaffold /C138 1/2MAP from 0.005 to 2 times the optimal value. (B) The characteristic time scale t(S(t=t)=e21)i s extracted from the curves in (A), and its variation with fis shown. Two regimes are observed and are separated by an inflection point. (C) flux R(t) for different values of Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 5 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | scaffold concentrations. Figure 4B illustrates this minimal picture of the kinetics of signal propagation derived fromthese physical note that the sensitivity of our results to changes in model parameters can be understood from this simple picture of scaffoldmediated signaling dynamics. For instance, changes in kinase andscaffold concentrations result in changes in the relative amount ofkinases existing in the three states in ways that have beenpreviously characterized [33,34]. Changes to other parameterssuch as the rates of activation and deactivation and theconcentration of phosphatases alter the rates of transitions betweenthese different states. For instance, if phosphatase very large, then activation in solution is very slow and on a scaffold. Also, slower rates of activation (andlarger rates of deactivation) result in a larger portion of from kinases that are bound to scaffolds. In general, when the activation of kinases originates more (less) a particular state in the minimal model, When multiple pathways to kinase activation contrib-ute with comparable time scales, bis small, and signaling is broadly distributed over many time scales. We have performedmany simulations with varying parameters to test the 3. Scaffold proteins allow for signals to be distributed over many time scales. Variation of the survival probability with time scaled to characteristic time scales, t. (A) S(t/t) (on a semi-logarithmic scale) for different values of f. Values of fare given in the legend. Large deviations of exponential decay are observed near the optimal value of f(f= 1, red). (B) Survival probabilities were fit to a stretched exponential Values of stretching exponent bas a function of scaffold density fare shown. Two cases are considered: (1) kinases can be activated only while bound to a scaffold (red) and (2) kinases can be activated while in solution and bound to a scaffold (blue). bdeviates most from a purely an exponential ( b= 1) at the optimal value of scaffold density ( f= 1) in both 4. Dynamics can be characterized by a multi-state kinetic mechanism. Important time scales in scaffold mediated signaling. (A) Graph of multi-state kinetic model whose dynamics are governed by 8 transitions. Each kinase can transition between four states denoted with foursubscripts: in solution (S), bound to a signaling competent complex (C), bound to a signaling incompetent complex (I), and activated (A). (B) how the various processes occurring at fast time scales couple with scaffold concentration fto give rise to collective behavior occurring at slower time Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 6 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e1000099and parameter sensitivity of our findings and find that that the qualitative behavior of our results follow this simple, insight can be gleaned from consideration of the power spectrum of S(t). The power computed in the frequency domain, resolves the time scale dependence of kinase activation. This approach has proven usefulin studying the dynamics of complex biochemical networks inmany contexts [43-45]. We first note that S(t) obtained from the simulations fits well to the functional form small). Thus, we use the parameters bandtthat were extracted from the fits at low ( f= 0.001), optimal ( f= 1.0), and high ( f= 3.5) s to compute P(v) for these three cases. In Figure 5, ( topt)22P(vtopt) is plotted versus vtoptwhere the time toptis the characteristic time scale tfor relaxation at the optimal f= 1scaffold concentration. That is, time is rescaled to units of topt. For each curve, at low vtopt%1 frequencies P(vtopt)i s constant ( P(vtR0)Rt2) signifying that kinase activation has become uncorrelated. At high vtopt&1 frequencies, is correlated and a power law decay is observed foreach curve P(vt opt),v22. As a reference, note that for an exponential decay, S(t)=e2t/t, the transition between these tworegimes occurs at vt,1 and is determined by the Figure 5, for high ( f= 3.5, blue) and low ( f= 0.001, green) scaffold concentrations power spectra closely resemble theLorentzian with the transition to occurring at different frequencies. At low f= 0.001 concentrations, the inverse time scale or corner frequency at which kinase is determined by the diffusion limited rates ofactivation and deactivation of the final kinase C*. The corner frequency can be estimated dTh ~OD N tota 1/2/C138 : k+and k2are diffusion limited rates of activation and deactivation and are given by a diffusion limited encounter rate that is on theorder of DN totawhere Dis the diffusion constant used in the simulation, Ntotis the number of proteins, and ais the size of a protein taken to be the size of a lattice site. Substitution of thenumbers used in the simulation (Table 1 and Methods) achieves avalue for the relaxation time that is commensurate with therelaxation time for f= 0.001 in Figure 2; i.e., t c,105mcsteps . Figure 5. Power spectra for kinase activation at high, low, and optimal scaffold concentrations. Plots StdTh~e{t=tdThb, are considered. Three cases are considered: low concentration ( f= 0.005, t= 1.96105 mcsteps ,b= 1.03), high concentration ( f= 3.5, t= 2.26107mcsteps ,b= 0.97), and optimal concentration ( f= 1.0, t= 3.06106mcsteps ,b= 0.60). On the x-axis, frequency is reported in units that are scaled to the characteristic time for the f= 1.0 case, topt= 3.06106mcsteps . The y-axis contains values Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 7 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e1000099At high f= 3.5 concentrations, the corner frequency is determined by rates of formation and disassociation of an intactsignaling complex. Furthermore, because of these many processthat comprise the relaxation rate in this case, a numerical estimateof the corner frequency is difficult. In the case of the optimal(f= 1.0, red) concentration, the transition from constant to occurs smoothly over many decades from vtopt,0.1 to vtopt,10.0. The plot in Figure 5 also resolves different frequency occurring in signal transduction. At high frequencies or short times, vtopt,10.0, kinase activation is limited by the diffusive motion of the kinases in the cascade. At intermediate activation is dominated by transitions between kinases assembled in competent, incompetent, and solution basedkinases. For low frequencies vt opt,0.1 or long times, decorrelates for each scaffold Between Signal Duration and Computed First Passage Time Statistics To illustrate how computed values of S(t) and the distribution of waiting times for kinase activation relate to conventional means ofdefining signal duration, we consider a differential equation for thetime evolution of the activated form of the final kinase within thecascade. In this picture, species become activated at rates derivedfrom the functional form that was fitted to the that were computed from the simulations. Thewaiting time or first-passage time distribution f(t) is used as a forward rate and the activated final kinase then can be degradedwith a kinetics of degradation characterized by a rate constant, k w. A kinetic equation describing this process is written the number of active species, tis the time constant of , and bis the stretching parameter that away from single exponential behavior. In this picture,x(t) represents the average response to a stimulus f(t) that is distributed temporally according subject to a first order decay with characteristic time 1/ kw. The equation for x(t) can be solved and using the x(0) = was integrated numerically and is shown for different values of bin Figure 6A. As seen in Figure 5A, decreasing values of bresult in the trajectories having longer tails and thus an extendedduration of signaling. Also, smaller values of bresult in the signal having a larger peak. This property directly follows from the decayofS(t) that was shown in Figure 3A for different values of b.A t early times, S(t) decays more quickly when bis smaller; as a consequence, more kinases are activated at these times, thusresulting in a larger peak. This concept of signal duration can be made more precise by considering a threshold amount of signal, T, that is required for the pathway to be considered active. With a chosen value of T, the signal duration, u, is defined as the time it takes for the signal to decay to some threshold value, T. That is, the satisfied. Figure 6B shows the signal duration, u, as a function b for values of branging from 0.5 to 1 for different values of T. For smaller values of T,b,1 (i.e., scaffolds are present) results in a large increase in signal duration compared to the case in whichb= 1. Therefore for a fixed value of t, the most broadly leads to the longest signal first showed that scaffold concentration is a key variable in regulating the speed of signal transduction. Moreover, we showedthat the concentration of a scaffold protein can influence by controlling the distribution of times over whichkinases become active. This type of regulation may have manyimportant consequences that are related to the influence of signalduration on cell decisions. Controlling the times over whichkinases are activated may also be useful in directing a specific,robust response in a number of ways. Thus, the itself provides another variable for specificity by controlling signal duration. This is consistentwith data from genetic studies involving KSR1 [9,10], where theauthors reported that the concentration of KSR1 can control a celldecision involving commitment to 6. Relation between first passage time statistics and signal duration. (A) Trajectories of x(t) on a semi-log plot. The time scaled by the characteristics time t. Trajectories for three values of bare shown: b= 0.06 (blue), b= 0.8 (green), and b= 1.0 (red). kw= 5 for each curve. Smaller values of bresult in larger values of x(t) at longer times. (B) Values of signal duration as a function of bfor different choices of threshold, T(defined in text); values of Tare provided in the legend. For small values of T,b,1 (i.e., the presence of scaffolds) markedly increases signal Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 8 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e1000099Our study focused solely on aspects of scaffold of signal transduction and we only considered the times at which kinases are active in the course of signal other factors also control signal duration. For example, ourstudy does not consider the negative feedback loops that are often associated with the upregulation of phosphatases [18,32]) or the role of receptor downregulation in controlling signal duration.Also we did not explicitly consider the role of positive versus negative feedback loops in shaping signal duration which is undoubtedly important [30]. It was our focus to study howspatially localizing kinases on a scaffold protein influences signalduration. We aimed to untangle this effect of scaffold proteins from other essential features of kinase cascades such as allostery and feedback regulation. Also, other theoretical studies haveinvestigated the first passage time statistics in signal and have found interesting dynamics that result from, in part, the sequential activation of multiple steps in a kinase cascade[35,36]. Our studies of signaling through scaffold these findings and, to our knowledge, provide the first study that shows how scaffolds affect the statistics of predictions from our model of how scaffolds dynamics can be tested. Measurements that monitor the time course of signaling for different scaffold concentrations couldpotentially resolve the differences in signaling dynamics that are predicted. Also, single molecule or fluorescence correlation methods [46-48] could potentially probe thestatistics of signaling dynamics inherent in kinase cascades andstudy how such statistics are related to reliable cell decisions. Such techniques can monitor the propagation of a signal, at the level of an individual molecule and thus directly measure how kinaseactivation within a single cell is distributed over Monte Carlo Simulations We simulate a model protein kinase cascade such as protein kinase (MAPK) cascade (Figure 1A) in the presence and absence of a scaffold with a kinetic Monte Carlo algorithm [49,50], which allows us to monitor the dynamics. Since we are investigating phenomena that occurs on the time scales of signal transduction, we course-grain the system so that proteins are represented as discrete a site on a lattice of dimensions 100 61006100 Scaffold proteins are modeled as rigid, immobile three binding sites that are each specific for a When bound to a scaffold, kinases are tethered in nearestneighbor positions that are proximal to their Allowing the scaffold and scaffold-bound species to move does not affect the qualitative results. Reflecting, no boundary conditions exist at each of the faces of thecubic lattice. The system is not periodically replicated since our simulation box is a size on the order a cell. Proteins can diffuse (i.e. translate on the lattice in random directions), bind and unbind,and undergo state transformations according to the network involving a three staged cascade of activation and deactivation events (Figures 1A and 1B). Protein motion issubject to excluded volume (steric) constraints in that no twoproteins can occupy the same site on the lattice. Chemical and binding events are modeled as processes with energy barriers for activation, inactiva-tion, binding and unbinding reactions. Parameters used are given in Table 1.We simulate the dynamics with a fixed time step Monte Carlo algorithm. In a Monte Carlo step, n trials are attempted, where nis the number of proteins in the simulation. For a given trial, aprotein is first chosen at random with uniform probability. Adisplacement move in a uniformly random direction is attemptedwith )~
1 2dDeffmin f1, exp ({E?)g where d is the dimensionality of the simulation box, Deffis the probability of attempting a diffusion move and sets an overall timescale to diffuse the length of a lattice site. Excluded volume is accounted for by imposition of an infinite energy barrier, E ', for hopping to sites containing other proteins; i.e. E?~0;site is empty ? ;site is considering all possible nearest neighbor moves, as determined by the network topology, are triedwith )~k effmin f1, exp ({Ej,j0)g where keffis the probability of attempting a reaction move; ( keffsets an overall reaction time scale), Ej,j9is the energy barrier for the j9Rjreaction scaled with respect to kbT(Boltzman's thermal energy). With this Monte Carlo move set, the simulations formally evolve the dynamics of the probability a chemical species si,jof type iand state jat position r?at time taccording to the Master the transition probability per unit time for a displacement from r!0to r!of species f1, exp the per unit time transition probability at r!for a species si,j9to change to Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 9 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | binding and unbinding reactions) and f1, exp ({Ej,j0)g, and constraint that binding and unbinding occurs only at specifiedbinding sites on the scaffolds at positions zero unless a scaffold is located at position r?~r? k; f1, exp ({Ej,j00)is the transition proba- bility per unit time for a species at r!0to facilitate (i.e. catalyze) at site r!; and zero unless the site at r!0is occupied by the appropriate catalyst (i.e. i9=i0)i n which case it is 1; each summation indicates a sum over Used The parameters used in the simulation were first constrained to typical literature values. Energies of disassociation were taken to of a disassociation constant Kdof roughly 1 mM. 200 stimulatory molecules, S, 200 molecules of kinase A and a 1:1:5ratio of A, B, and C kinases was used. If we assume a lattice spacing of10nm, a typical diameter of a protein, the concentration of kinases inour simulation box is roughly 1 mM for kinase A and kinase B and ,5mM for kinase C. In a physiological context, assuming the radius of the cell is about 10 mm, this approximately corresponds to ,10 5 molecules of kinases A and B and a copy number of ,56105for kinase C in our simulation. 600 generic phosphatases are also present.These relative numbers are commensurate with reported in Yeast and other systems [51,52]. Chemical kineticswere modeled in the simplest possible way by considering a singleelementary reactive collision; the asterisk (*) denotes an active species. For the purposes of our simulations, saturation effects were ignored and the kinetics weretaken to be in a linear regime. Such a model is reasonable whenreactions are not limited by the availability of the enzyme. However,relaxing this assumption does not affect the qualitative behavior ofour results provided that the times scales involved in the formation ofan enzyme-substrate complex and subsequent catalysis do notcompete with the diffusive processes in solution. If associated with enzyme catalysis dominate over diffusivemotion of the proteins or binding and unbinding to and from thescaffold, then these process would be observed in the and corresponding power spectrum. Given that catalysis would incorporate additional processes into the mechanism of such effects would serve to broaden the distribution at allscaffold concentrations as we have observed in our simulations (datanot shown). We did not explore this scenario in its entirety since ouraim was to solely investigate the effects of scaffolding a kinase cascade. As discussed in a previous study [33], an important variable that determines the role of scaffolding a kinase cascade is the amount oftime required ( t ec) for an active kinase to encounter its For simple diffusion, in three dimensions, Dis the diffusion constant and Cis a typical concentration of kinases. Experiments indicate that tecis on the order of 1024s- 100s [42]. Our studies focused on these experimentally values are reported. The system is first placed in a random configuration and simulations are allowed to ''equili-brate'' by letting the dynamics evolve to a time much larger than the time it takes for a kinase to diffuse the length of the simulation box. Kinases that are inactive at time t9are tagged and waiting times are observed at time t+t9(i.e. statistics are collected for the times at which the kinases become activated), and t9is chosen to be a time longer than the time required for equilibration of the MonteCarlo of Statistical dynamics can be defined microscopically as the distribution of times at which an individual kinase among of pool of available kinases becomes activated. Therefore, we dynamics by first considering the survival probability S(t). S(t) gives the probability that a particular kinase among the pool of signaling molecules has not been activated at time tprovided that it was inactive at time t=0 . S(t) is a two time point : StdTh~SstdThs0dThT, where the brackets denote an ensemble average and s(t) is a binary variable indicating the state of a kinase; is active 1;kinase remains survival probability is related to other for instance, it can be related to a waiting timeprobability density function or first passage time distribution, f(t), in the following f t is the complement of the cumulative probability distribution of the first passage time. S(t) is computed from the simulations by integrating f(t). Such a calculation is analogous to the data obtained from a single molecule experiment that measures thestatistics of enzyme dynamics [46]. This distribution of waitingtimes underlies the intrinsic duration of signal propagation in aprotein kinase cascade--the decay of such a quantity is a measureof how fast the signaling cascade responds to stimuli. Important tonote is that this quantity gives information only on the timing ofthe signal and not on its final magnitude. We also consider theproduct of the survival probability with the probability that akinase in the pool of signaling molecules is active in the fAis the fraction of active kinases at steady state. When normalized, R(t) is a measure of how the activity of the total pool of kinases is distributed over time, and can be thought of as an integrated flux of activated kinases. {d dtRtdThis seen as a reactive flux in provides a measure of the rate at which downstream Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 10 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e1000099are being activated. One can imagine that both quantities could be biologically relevant. If conditions dictate that a requires that a certain number of kinases remain activefor extended amounts of time, R(t) may be the more On the other hand if the cellular decision requires acount of kinases that become active over a specified time window,then S(t) could be the relevant quantity since it provides a measure of how the activation of individual kinases is distributed over time.Both quantities may be used to integrate signals in but since our study focuses on signaling dynamics weprimarily focus on the survival probability and its spectra were computed numerically. Real and imaginary parts of the Fourier transform were obtained from using the trapezoidal rule with a step size Dt= 0.001.P(v) is calculated by squaring the real and imaginary parts of 1/2/C1382: P(v) was sampled at N= 100 logarithmically spaced so that frequencies beginning at: v0~2p T, where Tis the total length of the autocorrelation function. Author and designed the experiments: JL. Performed the experiments: JL. Analyzed the data: JL. Contributed tools: JL. Wrote the paper: JL Pawson T, Scott JD (1997) Signaling through scaffold, anchoring, and Science 278: 2075-2080. 2. Burack WR, Shaw AS (2000) Signal transduction: hanging on a scaffold. Curr Opin Cell Biol 12: 211-216. 3. Morrison DK, Davis RJ (2003) Regulation of map kinase signaling modules by scaffold proteins in mammals. Ann Rev Cell Dev Biol 19: 91-118. 4. Dard N, Peter M (2006) Scaffold proteins in MAP kinase signaling: more than simple passive activating platforms. Bioessays 28: 146-156. 5. Kolch W (2005) Coordinating ERK/MAPK signalling through scaffolds and inhibitors. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 6: 827-837. 6. Pawson T (2007) Dynamic control of signaling by modular adaptor proteins. Curr Opin Cell Biol 19: 112-116. 7. Dodge-Kafka KL, Soughayer J, Pare GC, Michel JJC, Langeberg LK, et al. (2005) The protein kinase A anchoring protein mAKAP coordinates twointegrated cAMP effector pathways. Nature 437: 574-578. 8. Nguyen A, Burack WR, Stock JL, Kortum R, Chaika OV, et al. (2002) of Ras (KSR) is a scaffold which facilitates proteinkinase activation in vivo. Mol Cell Biol 22: 3035-3045. 9. Kortum RL, Lewis RE (2004) The molecular scaffold KSR1 regulates and oncogenic potential of cells. Mol Cell Biol 24: 4407-4416. 10. Kortum RL, Costanzo DL, Haferbier J, Schreiner SJ, Razidlo GL, et al. (2005) The molecular scaffold kinase suppr essor of Ras 1 (KSR1) Mol Cell Biol 25: 7592-7604. 11. Bhattacharyya RP, Remenyi A, Good MC, Bashor CJ, Falick AM, et al. (2006) The Ste5 scaffold allosterically modulates signaling output of the yeast matingpathway. Science 311: 822-826. 12. Park SH, Zarrinpar A, Lim WA (2003) Rewiring MAP kinase pathways scaffold assembly mechanisms. Science 299: 1061-1064. 13. Scott K, Zuker CS (1998) Assembly of the Drosophila into a signalling complex shapes elementary responses. Nature 395:805-808. 14. Smith FD, Langeberg LK, Scott JD (2006) The where's and when's of Trends Biochem Sci 31: 316-323. 15. Bashor CJ, Helman NC, Yan S, Lim WA (2008) Using Engineered to Reshape MAP Kinase Pathway Signaling Dynamics. Science 319: 1539-1543. 16. Heinrich R, Neel BG, Rapoport TA (2002) Mathematical models of protein kinase signal transduction. Mol Cell 9: 957-970. 17. Marshall CJ (1995) Specificity of Receptor Tyrosine Kinase Signaling - Transient Versus Sustained Extracellular Signal-Regulated Kinase Activation.Cell 80: 179-185. 18. Murphy LO, Blenis J (2006) MAPK signal specificity: the right place at the right time. Trends Biochem Sci 31: 268-275. 19. Murphy LO, Smith S, Chen RH, Fingar DC, Blenis J (2002) of ERK signal duration by immediate early gene products. Nat Cell Biol 4: 556-564. 20. Dolmetsch RE, Lewis RS, Goodnow CC, Healy JI (1997) Differential activation of transcription factors induced by Ca2 +response amplitude and duration. Nature 386: 855-858. 21. Chen LF, Fischle W, Verdin E, Greene WC (2001) Duration of nuclear NF- kappa B action regulated by reversible acetylation. Science 293: 1653-1657. 22. Paul S, Nairn AC, Wang P, Lombroso PJ (2003) NMDA-mediated activation of the tyrosine phosphatase STEP regulates the duration of ERK signaling. 6: 34-42. 23. Chen YR, Wang XP, Templeton D, Davis RJ, Tan TH (1996) The role of c-Jun N-terminal kinase (JNK) in apoptosis induced by ultraviolet C and gammaradiation - Duration of JNK activation may determine cell death J Biol Chem 271: 31929-31936.24. Daniels MA, Teixeiro E, Gill J, Hausmann B, Roubaty D, et al. (2006) Thymic selection threshold defined by of Ras/MAPK 444: 724-729. 25. Sasagawa S, Ozaki Y, Fujita K, Kuroda S (2005) Prediction and validation of the distinct dynamics of transient and sustained ERK activation. Nat Cell Biol 7: 365-U331. 26. Schoeberl B, Eichler-Jonsson C, Gilles ED, Muller G (2002) of the dynamics of the MAP kinase cascade activated by surface and internalized EGF receptors. Nat Biotechnol 20: 370-375. 27. Kao SC, Jaiswal RK, Kolch W, Landreth GE (2001) Identification of the mechanisms regulating the differential activation of the MAPK cascade by epidermal growth factor and nerve growth factor in PC12 cells. J Biol Chem 276: 18169-18177. 28. Boykevisch S, Zhao C, Sondermann H, Philippidou P, Halegoua S, et al. of Ras signaling dynamics by Sos-mediated positive feedback. Curr Biol 16: 2173-2179. 29. Locasale JW (2008) Allovalency revisited: An analysis of multisite and substrate rebinding. J Chem Phys 128. 30. Santos SDM, Verveer PJ, Bastiaens PIH (2007) Growth factor-induced MAPK network topology shapes Erk response determining PC-12 cell fate. Nat Cell Biol9: 324-U139. 31. Kiyatkin A, Aksamitiene E, Markevich NI, Borisov NM, Hoek JB, et al. protein Grb2-associated binder 1 sustains epidermal growth factor-induced mitogenic and survival signaling by multiple positive feedback loops. J Biol Chem 281: 19925-19938. 32. Kholodenko BN (2006) Cell-signalling dynamics in time and space. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 7: 165-176. 33. Locasale JW, Shaw AS, Chakraborty AK (2007) Scaffold Proteins Confer Diverse Regulatory Properties to Protein Kinase Cascades. Proc Natl AcadSci U S A 104: 13307-13312. 34. Levchenko A, Bruck J, Sternberg PW (2000) Scaffold proteins may the levels of protein kinase signaling and reduce itsthreshold properties. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 97: 5818-5823. 35. Lu T, Shen TY, Zong CH, Hasty J, Wolynes PG (2006) Statistics of cellular signal transduction as a race to the nucleus by multiple random walkers space. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Lan YH, Papoian GA (2007) Stochastic resonant signaling in enzyme cascades. Phys Rev Lett 98. 37. Redner S (2001) A Guide To First Passage Processes: Cambridge Chang LF, Karin M (2001) Mammalian MAP kinase signalling cascades. Nature 410: 37-40. 39. Burack WR, Sturgill TW (1997) The activating dual phosphorylation of MAPK by MEK is nonprocessive. Biochemistry 36: 5929-5933. 40. Kholodenko BN (2000) Negative feedback and ultrasensitivity can bring in the protein kinase cascades. Eur J Biochem Lauffenburger DA, Linderman JA (1993) Receptors: Models for and Signaling. Oxford University Press. 42. Arrio-Dupont M, Foucault G, Vacher M, Devaux PF, Cribier S diffusion of globular proteins in the cytoplasm of cultured muscle cells. Biophys J 78: 901-907. 43. Tanase-Nicola S, Warren PB, ten Wolde PR (2006) Signal and the correlation between extrinsic and intrinsic noise in biochemical networks. Phys Rev Lett 97. 44. van Zon JS, Morelli MJ, Tanase-Nicola S, ten Wolde PR (2006) Diffusion of transcription factors can drastically enhance the noise in gene J 91: Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 11 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e100009945. Warren PB, Tanase-Nicola S, ten Wolde PR (2006) Exact results for noise power spectra in linear biochemical reaction networks. J Chem Phys 125: 144904. 46. Lu HP, Xun LY, Xie XS (1998) Single-molecule enzymatic dynamics. Science 282: 1877-1882. 47. Yu J, Xiao J, Ren XJ, Lao KQ, Xie XS (2006) Probing gene expression in live cells, one protein molecule at a time. Science 311: 1600-1603. 48. Slaughter BD, Schwartz JW, Li R (2007) Mapping dynamic protein interactions in MAP kinase signaling using live-cell fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy and imaging. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104: 20320-20325.49. Chandler D (1987) Introduction to Modern Statistical Mechanics. New York, NY: Oxford University Press. 50. Frenkel DSB (2002) Understanding Molecular Simulation. From Algorithms to Applications. Boston: Academic Press. 51. Ghaemmaghami S, Huh W, Bower K, Howson RW, Belle A, et al. (2003) Global analysis of protein expression in yeast. Nature 425: 737-741. 52. Ferrell JE (1996) Tripping the switch fantastic: How a protein kinase cascade can convert graded inputs into switch-like outputs. Trends Biochem Sci 21: Signaling Dynamics PLoS Computational Biology | 12 June 2008 | Volume 4 | Issue 6 | e1000099
|
0807.2008
|
Jason Locasale W
|
Jason W. Locasale, Arup K. Chakraborty
|
Regulation of signal duration and the statistical dynamics of kinase
activation by scaffold proteins
|
12 pages, 6 figures
|
PLoS Comput Biol. 2008 Jun 27;4(6):e1000099
|
10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000099
| null |
q-bio.SC q-bio.MN
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Scaffolding proteins that direct the assembly of multiple kinases into a
spatially localized signaling complex are often essential for the maintenance
of an appropriate biological response. Although scaffolds are widely believed
to have dramatic effects on the dynamics of signal propagation, the mechanisms
that underlie these consequences are not well understood. Here, Monte Carlo
simulations of a model kinase cascade are used to investigate how the temporal
characteristics of signaling cascades can be influenced by the presence of
scaffold proteins. Specifically, we examine the effects of spatially localizing
kinase components on a scaffold on signaling dynamics. The simulations indicate
that a major effect that scaffolds exert on the dynamics of cell signaling is
to control how the activation of protein kinases is distributed over time.
Scaffolds can influence the timing of kinase activation by allowing for kinases
to become activated over a broad range of times, thus allowing for signaling at
both early and late times. Scaffold concentrations that result in optimal
signal amplitude also result in the broadest distributions of times over which
kinases are activated. These calculations provide insights into one mechanism
that describes how the duration of a signal can potentially be regulated in a
scaffold mediated protein kinase cascade. Our results illustrate another
complexity in the broad array of control properties that emerge from the
physical effects of spatially localizing components of kinase cascades on
scaffold proteins.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 13 Jul 2008 01:58:02 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 29 Oct 2008 03:06:08 GMT"
}
] | 2015-05-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Locasale",
"Jason W.",
""
],
[
"Chakraborty",
"Arup K.",
""
]
] |
ohmthat is determined by Handg(see 3.1): if g: [0,t)-ohmis the unique (projected) a point qohmtop=g(t)that does not intersect Sing, thenu(p) =g(q)+t. The can be thought of as a way to extend the classical sol ution to the whole ohm. LetSing be the closure of the singular set of the viscosity solution uto the above problem. Sing has a key property: any point in ohmSing can be joined to ohmby a unique that does not intersect Sing. A set with this property is said to splitohm. Once s are known, if we replace Singby any set Sthat splits ohm, we can still apply the formula in the last paragraph to obtain another function with some rese mblance to the viscosity solution (see definition 2.4). The setSing has an extra property: it is a balanced split locus . This notion, introduced in [AG] and inspired originally by the paper [IT], is related to the notion of semiconcave functions that is now common in the study of Hamilton-Jacobi equations (see section 2.1). Our goal in this paper is to determine whether there is a unique balanced spli t locus. In the cases when this is not true, we also give an interpretation of the multiple balance d split loci. Finally, we recall that the distance function to the boundar y in Riemannian and Finsler ge- ometry is the viscosity solution of a Hamilton-Jacobi equat ion ([MM]), and the cut locus is the closure of the singular set of the distance function to the bo undary ([LN]). Thus, our results also apply to cut loci in Finsler geometry. 1.1 Outline In section 2 we state our results, give examples, and comment on possible extensions. Section 3 gathers some of the results from the literature we will need, and includes a few new lemmas that we use later. Section 4 contains our proof that the distance to a balanced split locus anddistance to thek-th conjugate point are Lipschitz. Section 5 contains the proof of the main theor ems, modulo a result that is proved in section 6. This last section also fea tures detailed descriptions of a balanced split set at each of the points in the classification introduc ed in [AG]. 1.2 authors express their gratitude to Ireneo Peral, Yanyan Li, Luc Nguyen, Marco Fontelos and Juan Carlos Alvarez for interesting conversations about th is problem. The paper also from the referee's input, and the authors want to tha nk him for it. Both authors were partially supported during the preparation of this work by g rants MTM2007-61982 and MTM2008- 02686 of the MEC and the MCINN respectively. 2 Statement of results. 2.1 Setting We study a Hamilton-Jacobi equation given by (1.1) and (1.2) in aCcompact manifold with boundary ohm.His smooth and strictly convex in the second argument and the b oundary data gis smooth and satisfies (1.3). The solution by characteristics gives the characteristic vector field onohm, which we write as a mapG :ohm-Tohmthat is a section of the projection map p:Tohm-ohmof the tangent to ohm. curves are the integral curves of the geodes ic vector field in Tohmwith initial The projected characteristics are the projection to ohmof the characteristics. vector field is smooth and points inwards (se e 3.1). LetPhbe the geodesic flow in Tohm, andD(Ph)its domain. We introduce the set VRxohm: V={x= (2.1) Vhas coordinates given by zohmandtR. We set F:V-ohmto be the map given by following the projected characteristic with initial value G(z)a timet: F(t,z) =p(Ph(t,G(z))) (2.2) The vector rgiven as tin the above coordinates maps under Fto the tangent to the 2.1. For a set Sohm, letA(S)Vbe the set of all x= (t,z)Vsuch < t. We say that a set to a bijection Ssplitsohm, we can define a vector field RpinohmSto bedFx(rx)for the unique xin A(S)such that F(x) =p. Definition 2.2. For a point aS, we define the limit set Raas the set of vectors in Taohmthat are limits of sequences of the vectors Rpdefined above at points 2.3. IfSsplitsohm, we also define a set following relation holds between the sets :xQp}
Definition 2.4. IfSsplitsohm, we can define a real-valued function hinohmSby setting: h(p) the unique point in A(S)withF(t,z) =p. If we start with the viscosity solution uto the Hamilton-Jacobi equations, and let S=Singbe the closure of the set where uis notC1, thenSsplitsohm. If we follow the above definition involving A(S)to get a new function h, then we find h=u. Definition 2.5. A setSthat splits ohmis a split locus role of this condition is to restrict Sto itsessential part. A set that merely splits ohmcould be too big: actually ohmitself splits ohm. The following lemma may clarify this condition. Lemma 2.6. A setSthat splits ohmis a split locus if and only if Sis closed and it has no proper closed subsets that split ohm. 3Proof. The only if part is trivial, so we will only prove the other imp lication. Assume Sis a split locus and let S'Sbe a closed set splitting ohm. LetqSS'a point with #Rq>=2. SinceS' is closed, there is a neighborhood of qaway from S'; so, ifg1is a segment of a geodesic in there is a point q1ing1lying beyond q. Furthermore, we can choose the point q1not lying in S, so there is a second geodesic g2contained in As qS, we seeg2is necessarily different from g1, which is a contradiction if S'is split. Therefore we learn S' {pS:#Rp>=2}, soS={pS:#Rp>=2} S'. Finally, we introduce the following more restrictive condi tion (see 3.3 for the definition of vp(q), thevector from ptoq, and 3.2 for the Finsler dual of a 2.7. We say a split locus Sohmisbalanced for given ohm,Handg(or simply that it is balanced if there is no risk of confusion) iff for all pS, all sequences and any sequence of vectors XiRpi-XRp, then w(v) = max{w(v), wis dual to some RRp}
wherewis the dual of X. Remark. We proved in [AG] that the cut locus of a submanifold in a Finsl er manifold and the closure of the singular locus of the solution to (1.1) and (1. 2) are always balanced split loci. The proof (and the definition of balanced itself) was inspired by the paper [IT], and consists basically of an application of the first variation formula. We give now another proof that relates the balanced conditio n to the notion of which is now common in the study of Hamilton-Jaco bi equations. More precisely, we simply translate theorem 3.3.15 in the book [CS] to our langu age to get the following lemma: Lemma 2.8. The closure of the singular set of the viscosity solution to ( 1.1) and (1.2) is a balanced split locus. Proof. Letube the viscosity solution to (1.1) and (1.2), and let Singbe the closure of its singular set. We leave to the reader the proof that Singis a split locus (otherwise, see [AG]). It is well known that uis semiconcave (see for example [CS, 5.3.7]). The superdiffe the convex hull of the set of limits of differentials of uat points where uisC1 (see [CS, 3.3.6]). At a point where uisC1, the dual of the speed vector of a characteristic is the differential of u. Thus, the at pis the convex hull of the duals to the vectors in Rp. We wis dual to some RRp}= andvTpohm, theexposed face ofD+u(p)in the direction vis given by: D+(p,v) ={~wD+u(p) : balanced condition can be rephrased in these terms as: Letpi-pSbe a sequence with vpi(p)-vTpohm, and let wiD+u(pi)be a sequence converging to is exactly the statement of theorem [CS, 3.3.15], with two minor remarks: 1. The condition is restricted to points pS. At points in ohmS, the balanced condition is trivial. 2. In the balanced condition, we use the vectors vpi(p)frompitop, contrary to the reference [CS]. Thus the minus sign in the statement. In the light of this new proof, we can regard the balanced cond ition as a differential version of the semiconcavity condition. A semiconcave function that i s a solution to (1.1) is also a (see [CS, 5.3.1]). This papers tries to recover the same result under the balanced condition. 2.2 the conditions stated earlier, there is always a t least one balanced split locus, namely the singular set of the solution of (1.1) and (1.2). In general, there might be more than one balanced split loci, depending on the topology ofohm. Our first theorem covers a situation where there is uniquenes s. Theorem 2.9. Assumeohmis simply connected and ohmis connected. Then there is a unique balanced split locus, which is the sing ular locus of the solution of (1.1) and (1.2). The next theorem removes the assumption that ohmis connected, at the price of losing 2.10. Assumeohmis simply connected and ohmhas several connected components. Let Sohmbe a balanced split locus. ThenSis the singular locus of the solution of (1.1) and (1.2) with b oundary data g+awhere the function ais constant at each connected component of ohm. The above theorem describes precisely all the balanced spli t loci in a situation where there is non-uniqueness. If ohmis not simply connected, the balanced split loci are more com plicated to describe. We provide a somewhat involved procedure using th e universal cover of the the final answer is very natural in light of the examp les. Theorem 2.11. There exists a bijection between balanced split loci for giv enohm,Handgand an open subset of the homology space zero. In fact, this theorem follows immediately from the next, whe re we construct such 2.12. the universal cover of ohm, and lift both an assignment of a constant to each connected component of is equivariant for the action of the automorphism group of the c overing and such that /tildewideg(z) +a(z) satisfies the compatibility condition (1.3) in /tildewideohm. Then the singular locus /tildewideSof the solution = invariant by the automorphism group of the covering, and i ts quotient is a set Sthat is a balanced split locus for ohm,Handg. Furthermore: 51. The procedure above yields a bijection between balanced s plit loci for given compatible functions a: Among the set of equivariant functions a: can be identified naturally those compatible correspond to an open subset of H1(ohm,ohm)that contains 0. Remark. The space H1(ohm,ohm)is dual to Hn-1(ohm)by Lefschetz theorem. The proof of the above theorems rely on the construction from Sof current TSthat is shown to be closed and thus represents a cohomology class in Hn-1(ohm). The proof of the above theorem also shows that the map sending Sto the homology class of TSis a bijection from the set of balanced split loci onto a subset of Hn-1(ohm). In order to prove the above we will make heavy use of some struc ture results for balanced split loci. To begin with, we use the results of [AG], which were sta ted for a balanced split locus with this paper in mind. In the last section, we improve the descri ption of the cut locus near each of these types of points. We also study some very important functions for the study of t he cut locus. Recall the in Vgiven by zohmandtR. Letlj(z)be the value of tat which the itsj-th conjugate point (counting multiplicities), or if there is no such the minimum tsuch that F(t,z)S. Lemma 2.13. All functions lj:ohm-Rare Lipschitz 2.14. The function rS:ohm-Ris Lipschitz continuous if Sis balanced. Both results were proven in [IT] for Riemannian manifolds, a nd the second one was given in [LN]. Thus, our results are not new for a cut locus, but the pro of is different from the previous ones and may be of interest. We have recently known of another proof that randl1are Examples Take asohmany ring in a euclidean n-space bounded by two concentric spheres. Solve the Hamilto n- Jacobi equations with H(x,p) =|p|andg= 0. The solution is the distance to the spheres, and the cut locus is the sphere concentric to the other two and equidi stant from each of them. However, any sphere concentric to the other two and lying between them is a balanced split set, so there is a one parameter family of split balanced sets. When n >2, this situation is a typical application of 2.10. In the n= 2case, there is also only one free parameter, which is in accor d with 2.12, as the rank of the H1homology space of the ring is one. For a more interesting example, we study balanced split sets with respect to a point in a euclidean torus. We take as a model the unit square in the eucl idean plane with its It is equivalent to study the distance with respe ct to a point in this euclidean torus, or the solution to Hamilton-Jacobi equations with respect to a small distance sphere centered at the point with the Hamiltonian H(p) =|p|andg= 0. A branch of cleave points (see 3.5) must keep constant the diff erence of the distances from either sides (recall prop 7.2 in [AG], or read the beginning o f section 5). Moving to the covering plane of the torus, we see they must be segments of hyperbolas . A balanced split locus is the union of the cleave segments and a few triple or quadruple points. T he set of all balanced split loci is a 2-parameter family, as predicted by our theorem 2.12. 6Figure 1: Balanced split set in a torus 2.4 Extensions The techniques in this paper could be applied to other first or der PDEs, or systems of PDEs. In particular, we can mention the Cauchy problem with a Hamilto nian dependent on t, and both Cauchy and Dirichlet problems with a Hamiltonian dependent onu. Characteristic curves are well behaved on those cases (though some extra hypothesis are nee ded for a Hamiltonian particular, we believe our proofs of 2.13 and 2.14 are more easily extensible to other settings than the previous ones in the literature. This may simplify t he task of proving that the singular locus for other PDEs have locally finite n-1Hausdorff measure. In this paper and its predecessor [AG] strong regularity ass umptions were assumed. There are powerful reasons to weaken the regularity assumptions when studying Hamilton-Jacobi equations. The definition of a balanced split locus itself does not requi re strong regularity. Less regular data, though, could produce qualitatively different behavior. In the structure result 3.5, the dimensions of the sets of points of each type may become higher, as a conse quence of the general theorem (see [F]). Also, if gis notC1, we can expect non-trivial intersections between the singular set and ohm, orrarefaction waves . 3 3.1. LetvTpohmbe a tangent vector at pin a Finsler manifold (ohm,ph). The Rieman- nian metric at(p,v)is given by: g(p,v)(X,Y) 3.2. Thedual one form to a vector XTpohmwith respect to a Finsler metric phis the unique one form wT*
pohmsuch that w(X) =ph(X)2andw|H= 0, whereHis the to the level =ph(X)}
7atX. It coincides with the usual definition of dual one form in Rie mannian geometry. For a vector field, the dual differential one-form is obtained by applying the above construction at every point. We will often use the notation /hatwideXfor the dual one-form to the vector X. In coordinates, the dual one form wto the vector Xis given also, in terms of the Riemannian metric at (p,X): w(*) this notion of dual form, we can restate the usual equati ons for the characteristic vector field at points pohm: php(Xp) = inwards (3.1) Definition 3.3. Whenever there is a unique unit speed minimizing geodesic gjoining the we define, following [IT], vp(q) = .g(0) (3.2) For fixed pohm, then any qsufficiently close to pis joined to pby a unique unit speed so vp(q)is well 3.4. Letzohmandx= (t,z)V. We sayxisconjugate iffFis not a local diffeomorphism at x. The orderof conjugacy is the dimension of the kernel of dF. We sayxisa first conjugate vector iff no point (s,x)fors < tis conjugate. We recall from [AG] a result on the structure of balanced spli t loci (in that paper, conjugate points are called focal points): Theorem 3.5. A balanced split locus consists of the following types of poi nts:
*Cleave points: Points at which Rpconsists of two non-conjugate vectors. The set of cleave points is a smooth points: Points at which Rpconsists of exactly one conjugate vector of order 1. This is a set of Hausdorff dimension at most n-2;
*Degenerate cleave points: Points at which Rpconsists of two vectors, such that one of them is conjugate of order 1, and the other may be non-conjuga te or conjugate of order 1. This is a set of Hausdorff dimension at most n-2;
*Crossing points: Points at which Rpconsists of non-conjugate and conjugate vectors of order 1, and R*
pspans an affine subspace of dimension 2(R*
pis the set of duals to vectors in Rp). This is a rectifiable set of dimension n-2;
*Remainder: A set of Hausdorff dimension at most n-3; 83.2 Special coordinates In [AG], we used only a few properties of the exponential map e ssentially introduced in [W]. Those properties, stated in proposition 8.3 of [AG], were sh own enough to guarantee the existence of special coordinates for Fnear a conjugate point of order k(see the paragraph on before theorem 6.3 of [AG]). Near a point x0Vand its image F(x0)ohm, we can find coordinates such that x0has coordinates 0, andFis written as F(x1,...,x n) = (x1,...,x n(x)) =rx0 3.3 Lagrangian submanifolds of T*ohm LetDbe the homeomorphism between by the Finsler metric as in definition 3.2 (Dis actually a Cdiffeomorphism away from the zero section). We define a map: (t,z) =D(Ph(t,G(z))) (3.4) and a subset of T*ohm: Th = (V) (3.5) wherePhis the geodesic flow in Tohm. This is a smooth n-submanifold of T*ohmwith boundary. It is a standard fact that, for a function u: ohm-R, the graph of its differential duis a Lagrangian submanifold of T*ohm. The subset of Thcorresponding to small tis the graph of the differential of the solution uto the HJ equations by characteristics. Indeed, all of This a of T*ohm(see [D]). We can also carry over the geodesic vector field from the zero sections). This vector field in T*ohmis tangent to Th. Then, as we follow an integral curve g(t)withinTh, the tangent space to Thdescribes a curve l(t)in the bundle Gof lagrangian subspaces of T*ohm. It is a standard fact that the vector subspace the vertical subspace of T*
g(t)ohmin a non-trivial subspace for a discrete set of times. We will rev iew this fact, in elementary terms, and prove a lemma that will be important for the proof of lemma 2.1 4. Lete(t)be an integral curve of rwithx0=e(0)a conjugate point of order k. In near x0, fortclose to0, the differential of Falongehas the form: dF(e(t)) eand|E|< e, withE= 0ifg(0) unit vectors in the kernel of dFfort1< t2close to0. It follows that both vandware spanned by the last kcoordinates. We then find: 0 it follows (for some t1< t*< t2): (t2-t1)w*v <3e (3.6) This also shows that the set of t's such that dF(e(t))is singular is discrete. Say the point x0= (z0,t0)is thej-th conjugate point along the integral curve of and recall that it is of order kas conjugate point. As zmoves towards z0, all j+k(z)converge to t0. Letzibe a sequence of points converging to z0such that the integral curve through zimeets its kconjugate points near z0atMlinear subspaces (e.g. lj(zi) =***=lj+k2(zi); =***=lj+kM(zi)). we get the following theorem (see also lemma 1.1 in [IT]): Lemma 3.6. The subspaces 1,...,M converge to orthogonal subspaces for the standard inner product in the special coordinates a t the point (lj(z0),z0). 3.4 A useful lemma Lemma 3.7. LetUbe an open set in Rn,AUa proper open set, C+an open cone, VUan arbitrary open set and e >0such that at any point qAV, we have a Lipschitz hypersurface. Moreover, for any vector XC+, take coordinates so thatX=
x1. ThenAVis a graph a Lipschitz function h. Proof. Choose the vector XC+and coordinate system in the statement. Assume Xhas norm 1, so that q+tXq+Btfor small positive t. Take any point pAV. We notice that t < e belong to A, and all points p+t x1for-e < t <0belongs to UA. Indeed, there cannot be a point p+t x1Afor-e < t <0because the set an open neighborhood of p, which contains points not in A. In particular, there is at most one point of AVin each line with direction vector x1. Take two points close and consider the lines Assume there is a t1such that (t1,q1)belongs to A. If there is no point of AinL2then either all points of L2belong to Aor they belong to UA. Both of these options lead to a contradiction if condition is equivalent to K|q1-q2|< efor a constant Kthat depends on C+and the choice of XC+and the there is a point (t2,q2)A. For the constant Kabove and t>=t1+K|q1-q2|, the point (t,q2)lies in the set (t1,q1)+C+, so we have t2< t1+K|q1-q2|
The points q1andq2are arbitrary, and the lemma follows. 3.5 Some generalities on HJ equations. Lemma 3.8. For fixed ohmandH, two functions g,g':ohm-Rhave the same characteristic vector field inohmiffg'can be obtained from gby addition of a constant at each connected component of ohm. 10Proof. It follows from (3.1) that gandg'have the same characteristic vector field at all points if and only dg=dg'at all points. For our next definition, observe that given ohm,Handg, we can define a map ~u:V-Rby
~u(t,z) 3.9. We say that a function u: ohm-Rismade from characteristics be written as u(p) = ~u*sfor a (not necessarily discontinuous) section In the paper [Me], the same idea is expressed in different term s: all used to build a multi-valued solution, and then some crit erion is used to select a The criterion used there is to select the characte ristic with the minimum value of ~u. Lemma 3.10. The viscosity solution to (1.1) and (1.2) is the unique conti nuous function that is made from Lethbe a function made from characteristics, and ube the function given by formula (1.5). LetSingbe the closure of the singular set of u. Take a point zohm. Define: t*
z= sup{t>=0 :h(F(t,z)) =u(F(t,z))0<=t < t}
Claim :t*
z< discontinuous at F(t*
z,z). Proof of the claim : Assume that t*
z< rSing(z)andhis continuous at F(t*
z,z)for rSing(z)< l1(z), there is an open neighborhood Oof(t*
z,z)such that F|Ois a diffeomorphism onto a neighborhood of p=F(t*
z,z). By hypothesis, there is a sequence that Ashis built from characteristics using a section s, we have h(pn) = ~u(s(pn)) = ~u((sn,yn)) (tn,z). Fornbig enough, the point (sn,yn)does not belong to O, as(tn,z)is the only preimage of pnin O. Ash(pn)-h(p), andohmis compact, we deduce the snare bounded. We can take a to So we have p=F(t*
z,z) =F(s,y). we deduce that limn-h(pn) = ~u(s,y)> h(p) =u(p) = ~u(t*
z,z), sohis discontinuous at p. Using the claim, we conclude the proof: if his continuous, then allzohm, andu=h, as any point in ohmcan be expressed as F(t,z)for some z, and some t<=rSing(z). We will need later the following version of the same principl e: Lemma 3.11. LetSbe a split locus, and hbe the function associated to Sas in definition 2.4. If rSis continuous, and hcan be extended to ohmso that it is continuous except for a set of null Hn-1 measure, then S=Sing. Proof. Define Y0={zohm some the claim in the previous lemma, Y0is contained in: Y={zohm :hdiscontinuous at F(t,z)for some the set in definition 2.1. The map Frestricts to a diffeomorphism The set Ycan be expressed at p})) and thus by the hypothesis has null Hn-1measure. Therefore, ohmY0is dense in ohm. We claim now that SSing. To see this, let pSSing. a unique (t*,z*)A. It follows rS(z*)<=t*< rSing(z*). AsrSis continuous, rS(z)< rSing(z)holds for all zin a neighborhood of z*inohmand, in particular, for some zohmY0. This is a for rS(z)< t < r = (t,z), andt < = =u(F(t,z)), forcing zY0. We deduce S=Singusing lemma 2.6 and the fact that Singis a split locus. 4rSis Lipschitz In this section we study the functions rSandljdefined earlier. The fact that rSis Lipschitz will be of great importance later. The definitions and the gen eral approach in this section follow [IT], but our proofs are shorter, provide no precise quantit ative bounds, use no constructions from Riemannian or Finsler geometry, and work for Finsler manifo lds, thus providing a new and shorter proof for the main result in [LN]. The proof that ljare Lipschitz functions was new for when we published the first version of the preprint of this paper. Since then, another preprint has appeared which shows that l1is actually of 2.13. It is immediate to see that the functions ljare continuous, since this is property (R3) of Warner (see [W, pp. 577-578 and Theorem 4.5 ]). Near a conjugate point x0of orderk, we can take special coordinates as in 3.2: F(x1,...,x n) = (x1,...,x n-k,Fn-k+1,...,F n) Conjugate points near xare the solutions of d(x1,...,x n) =det(dF) 0
>From the properties of the special coordinates, we deduce t hat: Dad(0) = 0 |a|< k 1 We can use the preparation theorem of Malgrange (see [GG]) to find real valued functions q andliin an open neighborhood Uofxsuch that 0and: q(x1,...,x n)d(x1,...,x n) n) and we deduce from (4.1) that Dali(0) = 0 |a|< i (4.2) 12which any conjugate point (x1,...,x n), we have q(x) = 0, n) and this and (4.3), we get an inequality for |x1|at any conjugate point (x1,...,x n), where the constant Cultimately depends on bounds for the first few derivatives of F:
|x1|k< (4.4) We notice that In is the statement that all conjugate points near xlie in a cone of fixed width containing the hyperplane x1= 0. Thus all functions ljtolj+kare Lipschitz at (x2...,xn)with a of x. Remark. A proof of lemma 2.13 in the lines of section 3.3 seems possibl e: letL(ohm) be the bundle of Lagrangian submanifolds of the symplectic linear spacesT*
pohmand letS(ohm) be the union of the Maslov cycles within each Lp(ohm). Define l:V-L(ohm) wherel(x)is the tangent to 3.5). The graphs of the functions lkare the preimage of the Maslov cycle S(ohm). The geodesic vector field (transported to T*ohm), is transversal to the Maslov cycle. With some effort, the angle (in an arbitrary metric) between this vecto r field and the Maslov cycle at points of intersection can be bounded from below. This is sufficient t o show that the lkare Lipschitz. Lemma 4.1. For any split locus Sand point yohm, there are no conjugate points in the < rS(y). In other words, rS<=l1. Proof. Assume there is xwithrS(x)-e > l1(x). By [W, 3.4], the map Fis not injective in any neighborhood of (x,t). There are points not split ohm). Taking limits, we see F(x,t)is inSfor some t < rS(x)-e, which contradicts the definition of rS(x).
>From now on and for the rest of the paper, Swill always be a balanced split locus: Lemma 4.2. LetEohmbe an open subset whose closure is compact and has a neighborh ood wherer < l1. ThenrSis Lipschitz in E. Proof. The map an embedding of VintoTM. There is a constant csuch that >=cmin{|x-y|,1} (4.5) Recall the exponential map is a local diffeomorphism before t he first conjugate point. a set Rpconsisting of the vector dF(z,r(z))(r), and vectors Choose one such point p, and a neighborhood Uofp. The above inequality shows that there is a constant msuch >=m forx= By the balanced condition 2.7, any unit vector vtangent to Ssatisfies some such yand so:
<1-e Thus for any vector wtangent to Eboth vectors in a cone of fixed amplitude around the kernel of hyperplane tangent to the indicatrix at x). Application of lemma 3.7 shows that ris Lipschitz. Lemma 4.3. Letz0ohmbe a point such that r(z0) =l1(z0). Then there is a neighborhood Eof z0and a constant Csuch that for all zinEwithr(z)< l1(z),ris Lipschitz near zwith C. Proof. LetObe a compact neighborhood of (z0,l1(z0))where special coordinates apply. Let x= (z,r(z))Obe such that r(z)< l1(z). We can apply the previous lemma and find ris Lipschitz near z. We just need to estimate the Lipschitz constant uniformly. Vectors in RF(x)that are of the form dFy(r)foryVO, are separated from dFx(r)as in the previous lemma and pose no trouble, but now there might be other vectors dFy(r)foryO. Fix the metric matrix in special coordinates is the identity. Any tan gent for some yOQF(x). A uniform Lipschitz constant for ris found if we bound from below the angle in the metric randdxF-1(v)for any vectorvwith this property. Fix a point yOwithF(x) =F(y), We need to bound from below the angle between rand the hyperplane kera. Our goal is equivalent to proving that there is e1>0independent of xsuch e1 which is equivalent the norm to first that XandYbelong to the indicatrix at F(x) =F(y), which is strictly convex. By this and (4.5), we see that for some it is sufficient to show that for some C1independent of a Taylor expansion ofph xjin the second entry, we see the form F*
xacan be written argument goes as follows: we need the inequality so we want to bound the bilinear map g(p,X)evaluated at X-Yand the vector dF(v). The bound on the norm is achieved when dF(v)is proportional to X-Y. The map dxFis invertible, so for we we constants C2andC3, and it is enough to show there is e3independent of xandysuch e3 (4.6) LetG(x) =dxF(r). We it is equivalent to show the of xandy. Assume that (r(z0),z0)is conjugate of order k, so that r(z0) =l1(z0) =***=lk(z0). Thanks to Lemma 2.13 and reducing to a smaller O, we can assume that a1= (l1(z),z)toak= (lk(z),z) all lie within O(some of them may coincide). Let di=li(z)-r(z)be the distance from xto theai. At each of the aithere is a vector wikerdaiFsuch that all the wispan Recall from section 3.3 that we can choose wiforming an almost orthonormal subset for the above metric, in the sense that kernel of dyFis contained in allyO, and thus Then we have x1 wiF(a) =zi+Ri(a), eandaO. We deduce wiF(x) e. By the form of the special coordinates, x-yK. Since|wi|is almost 1, there is an index i0such that We have the identity: 0 =F(y)-F(x) the above by +-zj, we deduce which leads to the point x, the image by dxFof the unit ball BxVinTxVis contained in a radius 2di. We use the can assume the distance between the vectors smaller than1 4n. In particular, looking at the i0coordinate chosen above, we see that the vector to be rescaled at least by the amount 8ndiin order to fit within the image of the unit which is the desired of Lemma 2.14. We prove that ris Lipschitz close to a point z0. LetEbe a that l1has Lipschitz constant L, andrhas Lipschitz constant Kfor l(z). Letz1,z2Ebe such that r(z1)< r(z2). Ifr(z1) =l1(z1)we can l(z2)-l(z1)< a Lipschitz constant take a linear path with unit speed x: letabe the supremum of all ssuch that r(x(s))< l(x(s)). second term can be we can bound the first term l(z2)-l(x(a))< L|t-a|
while ifr(z2)< r(x(a)), we in all cases, the following Proof of the main theorems. Take the function hassociated to Sas in definition 2.4. At a cleave point xthere are two from ohm; each one yields a value of hby evaluation of ~u. The balanced condition the speed vectors X1andX2of the characteristics reaching xand to S. Furthermore, /hatwideXis exactly dh, so the difference of the values of hfrom either side is constant in every connected component of the c leave locus. We define an (n-1)-currentTin this way: Fix an orientation Oinohm. For every smooth form ph, restrict it to the set of cleave points C(including degenerate cleave points). In every component CjofCcompute the following i= 1,2 the component Cjwith the orientation induced by Oand the incoming vector Vi, and hifori= 1,2are the limit values of hfrom each side of Cj. We define the current T(ph)to be the sum: T(ph) (5.2) The function his bounded and the Hn-1measure of Cis finite (thanks to lemma 2.14) so that Tis a real flat current that represents integrals of test funct ions against the difference between the values of hfrom both sides. IfT= 0, we can apply lemma 3.11 and find u=h. We will prove later that the boundary of Tas a current is zero. Assume for the moment thatT= 0. It defines an element of the homology space Hn-1(ohm)of dimension n-1with real coefficients. We can study this space using the long exact sequence of homology with for the pair (5.3) 5.1 Proof of Theorem 2.9. We prove that under the hypothesis of 2.9, the space Hn-1(ohm)is zero, and then we deduce that T= 0. Asohmis open,Hn(ohm)0. Asohmis simply connected, it is orientable, so we can apply Lefsch etz duality with real coefficients ([Ha, 3.43]) which = 0 Asohmis connected, we deduce Hn-1(ohm)has rank 0, andT=Pfor some n-dimensional flat currentP. The flat top-dimensional current Pcan be represented by a density fLn(ohm)(see [F, p 376, 4.1.18]): P(o) o Ln(ohm) (5.4) We deduce from (5.2) that the restriction of Pto any open set disjoint with Sis closed, so f is a constant in such open set. As ohmSis open and connected, fis constant a.e., andT= 0. 5.2 Proof of Theorem 2.10. Assume now that ohmhaskconnected components Gi. We look at (5.3), and recall the induced by inclusion. We know by Poincare duality that to the linear combinations of the fundamental cl asses of the connected components of 17ohmwith real coefficients. We deduce that Hn-1(ohm)is generated by the fundamental classes of the connected components of ohm, and that it is isomorphic to the quotient of all linear combi nations by the subspace of those linear combinations with equal coeffi cients. the cycle to which Tis homologous (the orientation of Giis such that, together with the inwards pointing vector, yields the ambient orientation). If we define a(x) =ai,xGi, solve the HJ equations with boundary data g-aand compute the corresponding current /hatwideT, we see that /hatwideT=T-j#R, wherejis the retraction jofohmontoS that fixes points of Sand follows characteristics otherwise. Then the homology c lass of/hatwideTis zero, and we can prove /hatwideT= 0as before. It follows that Sis the singular set to the solution of equations with boundary data g-a. 5.3 Proof of Theorem 2.12. For this result we cannot simply use the sequence (5.3). We fir st give a procedure for split loci in ohmother than the cut locus. A function a: assigns a real number to each connected component of iff for any automorphism of the cover phthere is a real number c(ph)such function a: the compatibility condition (1.3). An equivariant function ayields a group homomorphism from this (5.5) wheres: [0,1]-ohmis a path with endpoints in any lift to/tildewideohm. The result is independent of the lift because ais equivariant. On the other hand, choosing an arbitrary com a constant a0=a([G]), the any path (5.6) assigns an equivariant function ato an element to addition of a global constant, these two maps are invers e of one another, so there is a one-to-one correspondence between elements of H1(ohm,ohm)and equivariant functions with afor any constant c). The compatible equivariant functions up to addition of a global constant can be identified with an open subset of H1(ohm,ohm)that contains the zero cohomology class. the universal cover of ohm. We can lift the Hamiltonian Hto a function the function gto a function ~gdefined on /tildewideohm. The preimage of a balanced split locus for ohm,Handgis a balanced split locus for is invariant by the automorphism group of the cover, and conversely, a balanced split locus /tildewideSin is invariant by the of the cover descends to a balanced split locus on ohm. Any function athat is both equivariant and compatible can be used to solve t he Hamilton- Jacobi problem = 1 Ifp1(ohm)is not not be compact, but this is not a problem (see remark 5.5 in page 12 5 of [L]). The singular set is a balanced split locus that is invariant under the action of p1(ohm)and hence it yields a balanced split locus inohm. We write S[a]for this set. It is not hard to see that the map a-S[a]is a balanced split locus in ohmlifts to a balanced split locus The reader may check that the current T/tildewideSis the lift of TS, and in particular it is closed. As in the proof of Theorem 2.10, we have = 0 , and we the connected components of class is the lift of the class of THn-1(ohm)and thus it is invariant under the action of the group of automorphisms of the cover. Equivalently, the map d efined in (5.5) is a equivariant. Similar arguments as before show that S=S[a]. Thus the map a-S[a]is also surjective, which completes the proof that there is a equivariant compatible functions a: balanced split loci. 6 Proof that T= 0 It is enough to show that T= 0at all points of ohmexcept for a set of zero measure. This is clear for points not in S. Due to the structure result 3.5, we need to show the same at cleave points (including degenerate ones ), edge points and crossing points. Along the proof, we will learn more about the structure of Snear those kinds of this section, we assume n=dim(ohm)>2. This is only to simplify notation, but the casen= 2is covered too. We shall comment on the necessary changes to c over the case n= 2, but do not bother with the simple case n= 1. 6.1 Conjugate points of order 1. We now take a closer look at points of A(S)that are also conjugate points of order 1. of 3.5 we do not need to deal with higher order conjuga te points. In a neighborhood Oof a pointx0of order1, in the special coordinates of section 3.2, we have x0= 0andFlooks n) = (x1,x2,...,F n(x1,...,x n)) the boundary of A(S), but without the points (0,z)forzohm. It follows from 2.14 a Lipschitz graph on coordinates given by the vector field It is not hard to see that it is also a Lipschitz g n)in the xi, possibly after restricting to a smaller open set. Because of Lemma 4.1, we know x0is a first conjugate point, so we can assume that Ois a coordinate and that Fis a diffeomorphism when restricted to {x1=s}for s 6.1. A setOVisunivocal iff for any have
~u(x1) = ~u(x2). Remark. The most common case of univocal set is a set Osuch that F|Ois injective. Lemma 6.2. Letx0Vbe a conjugate point of order 1. Then x0has an univocal LetO1andU1be neighborhoods of x0andF(x0)where the special coordinates (6.1) hold; letxibe the coordinates in O1andyibe those in U1. Choose smaller that we can assume that if a point x'VO1 maps to a point in U, then for the vector Z=dFx'(r)we (6.2) for also
^Y( y1)>1-k (6.3) for some k >0sufficiently small and all The hypothesis =F(x2), for all j < n . Let us write aj=x1 j=x2 jforj < n Fix a2,...,a n-1and consider the 2,...,n-1}
Its image by Fis a subset of a plane in the of O1not inHamap to other planes. If n= 2, we keep the same notation, but the meaning is is e >0such that for t <-e/2, the line {x1=t} Hamaps to
{y1=t}La. Due to the comments at the beginning of this section, /tildewideSis given as a Lipschitz graph x1=
~t(x2,...,x n). The identity a1=~t(a2,...,a n-1,si)holds for i= We define a curves: = (~t(a2,...,a n-1,s),a2,...,a n-1,s). The image of sbyFstays in S, describing a closed loop based at q; we will establish the lemma by examining the variation 1,2, letei: (-ei,a1]-Hagiven by ei(t) = (t,a2,...,a n-1,si)be the segments parallel to thex1direction that end at xi, defined from the first point in the segment that is in O. We can assume that the intersection of Owith any line parallel to x1is connected, and that the intersection of Uwith any line parallel to y1is connected too. We can also assume ei< e. LetDbe the closed subset of Hadelimited by the Lipschitz curves e1,e2ands, and let Ebe the closed subset of Ladelimited by the image of e1ande2. We claim Dis mapped onto E. First, no point in int(D)can map to the image of the two lines, cause this contradicts either r<=l1, or the fact that r(a2,...,a n-1,si)is the first time that the line parallel to the x1direction hits /tildewideS, for either i= 1ori= 2. We deduce Dis mapped into E. Now assume G=EF(D)is nonempty, and contains a point p= (p1,...,p n). IfQpcontains a pointxO1F(D), following the curve t-(t,x2,...,x n)backwards from x= (x1,x2,...,x n), we must hit either a point in the image of is a contradiction with the fact n)fort < x1and(t,a2,...,a n-1,si)fort < a1are inA(S); see definition 2.1), or the pointq(which contradicts (6.3)). Thus for any point pG, we have QpVO1. 20Now take a point pG, and pick up a sequence approaching it from within Gand contained in a line with speed vector y1. By the above, the set Qfor points in this sequence is contained in VO1. We can take a subsequence carrying a convergent sequence of vectors, and thus Rphas a vector of the form dFx*(r)forx*DO. This violates the balanced condition, because of (6.2). This implies G=, thusG=becauseEis connected and we claim there are no vectors coming from The argument is as above, but we now approach a point with a vector from with speed - y1. The approaching sequence may be chosen so that it carries a c of vectors from F(D), and again (6.2) gives a contradiction with the balanced con dition. We now (6.4) The curve F*sruns through points of S. IfF(s(s))is a cleave point, then F*sis a smooth curve near s. We show that cleave points are the only contributors to the a bove integral. If a point is not cleave, either it is the image of a conjugate vector, or has more than 2incoming into int(E), all vectors in RF(s(s))come from O. LetNbe the set of ssuch that s(s)is conjugate. We notice that s(s)is not an A2 point forsN. This is proposition 6.2 in [AG], and is a standard result for cut loci in This means that at those points the kernel of dFis contained in the tangent to /tildewideS. The intersection of /tildewideSwith the plane Hais the image of the curve s. Thus, for sNthe tangent to the curve l1is the kernel of ds(s)F. Ifsis differentiable at a point swe deduce, thanks to 4.1, that the tangent to the curve l1is the kernel of ds(s)F. We now use a variation of length argument to get a variant of the Finsler Gauss lemma. Let c= (l,w)be a tangent vector to VRxohmat the point x= (t,z), and assume dxF(c) = 0. We show that this implies d~u(c) = 0. Letgsbe a variation through geodesics with initial the characteristic vector field at z(s)as the initial speed vector, such that
sz(s) =w, and with total length t+sl. By the first variation formula and the equation for the characteristic vector field at ohm, the variation of the length of the curve and by the definition of gs, it is also l. We deduce l=-dg(w), and thus d~u(c) =l+dg(w) = 0. It follows that ds(s)F(s'(s)) = 0 at points sNwheresis differentiable. As sis Lipschitz, the set of swhere it is not differentiable has measure 0, and we = 0 Nis contained in the set of points where d(F*s)vanishes. Thus, by the Sard-Federer theorem, the image of Nhas Hausdorff dimension 0. LetS2be the set of points in Lawith more than 2incoming geodesics. From the proof of [AG, 7.3], we see that the tangent to S2has dimension 0and thus S2has Hausdorff dimension 0. AsFis non-singular at points in [s1,s2], the set of to a point in S2Nhas measure we see that the integral (6.4) can be restricted to the set Cofsmapping to a cleave point. Cis an open set and thus can be expressed as the disjoint union o f a countable amount of intervals. Let A1be one of those intervals. It is mapped by F*s onto a smooth curve c0of cleave points contained in La. Points of the form (t,a2,...,a n-1,s)for t <~t(a2,...,a n-1,s)map through Fto a half open ball in E. There must be points of Dmapping 21to the other side of c0. Because of all the above, c0is also the image of other points in [s1,s2]. As cis made of cleave points, it must be the image of another compo nent ofC, which we call B1, also mapping onto c0. Choose a new component A2, which is matched to B2, different from the above, and so on, till the AiandBiare all the components of C. We can write the integral on Bias an integral on Ai(we add a minus sign, because the curve is traversed in opposite the values of d~ucomputed from both sides. The balanced condition and thus the above integral vanishes. The integral (6.4) is absolutely convergent by Lemma 2.14, and the proof follows. Remark. The above proof took some inspiration from [H, 5.2]. The read er may be interested in James Hebda's tree-like curves . 6.2 Structure of S near cleave and crossing points In this section we prove some more results about the structur e of a balanced split locus near degenerate cleave and crossing points. Besides their impor tance for proving that T= 0, we believe they are interesting in their own sake. Lemma 6.3. LetpSbe a (possibly degenerate) cleave point, and let are disjoint univocal neighborhoods and a neighborhood Uofp such that for any qU,Qqis contained in if we that 1,2, thenA1A2is the graph of a Lipschitz function, for adequate coordinat es inU. Proof. The points x1andx2are at most of first order, so we can take univocal neighborhoo By definition of Qpand the compactness of ohm, we can achieve the first property, reducing Uif necessary. We know different from For fixed arbitrary coordinates in U, we can assume that be separated by a hyperplane from reducing U,O1,O2if necessary. Therefore, there is a vector Z0Tpohmand a number d >0 such x'O2 (6.5) for any unit vector Zin a neighborhood GofZ0. LetC+={tZ:t >0,ZG}be a one-sided cone containing Z. We write q+C+for the cone displaced to have a vertex in q. ChooseqA1A2, andZG. >0}be a ray contained in (q+C+)U. We claim R A1A2. For two points R, we sayq1< q2if and only t1< t2. the infimum of all points p >0inRA2, for the above order in R. not), we can approach q0with a sequence of points qn=F(xn)> q0carrying The limit point of this sequence is q0, and the limit vector is but the incoming vector is in -G, which contradicts the balanced condition by then approaching q0with points q < qn=F(xn)< q0, we get a new the balanced property. The only possibility is R A1A2. As the vector Zis arbitrary, we have indeed coordinates in U, and let e=1 2dist(p,U). LetBebe the ball of radius ecentered at p. By the above, the hypothesis of lemma 3.7 are satisfied, for A=A1A2, the cone C+, the number e, andV=Be. Thus, we learn from lemma 3.7 that A1A2Beis the graph of a Lipschitz function along the direction Z0from any hyperplane transversal to Z0. The following three lemmas contain more detailed informati on about the structure of a balanced split locus near a crossing point. The following is stated fo r the case n >2, but it holds too if n= 2, though then Lreduces to a single point {a}. Definition 6.4. Thenormal to a subset XT*
pohmis the set of vectors ZinTpohmsuch that o(Z) is the same number for all oX. Lemma 6.5. LetpSbe a crossing point. Let BT*
pohmbe the affine plane spanned by R*
p. Let Lbe the normal to B, which by hypothesis is a linear space of dimension n-2, and let Cbe a (double-sided) cone of small amplitude around L. There are disjoint univocal open sets O1,...,O NVand an open neighborhood Uofpsuch thatQq iOifor define sets Aias in lemma 6.3, and call part ofS. DefineS =i,j,kAiAjAkand letC=S S. (1) At every qS, there is e >0such that is contained in p+C. The next lemma describes the intersection of Swith2-planes transversal to L. Lemma 6.6. LetpSbe a crossing point as above. Let PTpohmbe a2-plane intersecting C only at the origin, and let Pa=P+abe a2-plane parallel to PforaL. 1. If|a|< e1, the intersection of S, the plane Pa, andUis a connected Lipschitz tree. 2. The intersection of S, the plane Pa, and the annulus of inner radius c*|a|and outer ={qU:c|a|<|q|< e2}
is the union of NLipschitz arcs separating the sets Ai. Remark. We cannot say much about what happens inside PaB(P,c|a|). The segments meet together, yielding a connected tree, but this can h appen in ways (see figure 2). Finally, we can describe the connected components of C=S SwithinU: Lemma 6.7. Under the same hypothesis, for every i= 1,...,N there is a coordinate system in U such that: 23Figure 2: Two possible intersections of a plane PawithS
*The setAiis the graph of a Lipschitz function hi, its domain delimited by two flandfr, t < f r(a)}
*A connected component C0ofCcontained in Aiadmits the following expression, for f1andf2, t < f 2(a)}
Corollary 6.8. Hn-2(S)<. Proof of corollary. We apply the general area-coarea formula (see [F, 3.2.22]), with W= S,Z=L, andfthe projection from UontoLparallel to P, andm=u=n=n-2, to Jf|Sis bounded from below, so if we can bound we get a bound for Hn-2(S). The setC PaUis a simplicial complex of dimension 1, and a standard result in homology theory states that the number of edges minus the number of ver tices is the same as the the homology numbers of the complex: h1-h0. The graph is connected and so this last number is -1. The vertices of C PaUconsist of Nvertices of degree 1lying atUand the interior vertices having degree at least 3. The handshaking lemma states that the sum of the degrees of the vertices of a graph is twice t he number of edges, so we get the inequality 2e>=N+3-vfor the number eof edges and the number -vof interior vertices. Adding this to the previous equality e-(N+-v) =-1, we get-v<=N-2. We have thus bounded -v=H0(SPa) with a bound valid for all a. 24Proof of 6.5. This lemma can be proven in a way similar to 6.3, but we will tak e some extra steps to help us with the proof of the other lemmas. First, recall the map defined in (3.4). Each point xin-1(R*
p)has a univocal neighborhood Ox. only of covectors of norm 1. Letgbe the curve obtained as intersection of Band the covectors of norm 1. Instead of taking the neighborhoods Oxright away, which would be sufficient for this lemma, we cover R*
pwith open sets of the form (Ox)g. By standard results in topology, we can extract a finite refine ment of the covering of R*
pgby the of disjoint non-empty intervals I1,...,I N. Let~Iibe the set of and choose a linear space M0of dimension Define the sets of our covering: Oi= the ball of radius arbitrary, and small). We can assume that Qq iOifor allqinUby reducing Uand theOifurther if necessary, hence we only need to prove the two extra properties to conclu de the theorem. The approximate tangent to Sat a point qSUis contained in the normal to R*
q(see the definition of approximate tangent in [AG] and use the proof of proposition 7.3 there, or merely use the balanced property). If R*
qis contained in a sufficiently small neighborhood of gand contains points from at least three different Ii, its normal must be close to L. Thus if we chose e1ande2 small enough, the approximate tangent to SUat a point qSis contained in C. If property (1) did not hold for any eat a point q, we could find a sequence of points converging to from qwould remain outside C, violating the above the second property holds if we replace UbyUBe, for the number ethat appears when we apply property (1) to p. Proof of 6.6. Just like in 6.3, we can assume that each set be separated from the others by a hyperplane (e.g., a direction Zi), such x'Oj, (6.6) for some d >0and any unit vector Zin a neighborhood GiofZi. Thanks to the care we took in the proof of the previous lemma, we can assume all Zibelong to the plane Pin the statement of this lemma: indeed the intervals Iican be separated by vectors in any plane transversal to L, and the sets(Oi)are contained in neighborhoods of the Ii. Define the one-sided cones C+
i={tZ:t >0,ZGi}. The above implies that the intersection of eachC+
iwithPis a nontrivial cone in Pthat consists of rays from the vertex. By the same arguments in 6.3, we can be sure that whenever qAi, implies that Aiis the graph of a Lipschitz function along the direction Zifrom any to Zi. We notice Aiis (Lipschitz) transversal to P, so for any aL,AiPis a Lipschitz curve. As the cone Cis transversal to P, and the tangent to Sis contained in C, we see SPaconsists of isolated points. ThusS Pais a Lipschitz graph and SPais the set of its vertices. If it were not a tree, there would be a bounded open subset of PaUSwith boundary contained in S. An to some Ak. Then the cone q+C+
kis contained in Ak, but on the other hand its intersection with Pacontains a ray that must necessarily intersect S, which is a notice Pa(p+C+
i)Ai. This set is a cone in Pa(e.g. a circular sector) with vertex at most a distance c1|a|fromp+a, wherec1>0depends on the amplitude of the different Ci. 25Figure 3: Snear a crossing point Ifa= 0, theNsegments departing from pwith speeds Zibelong to each Airespectively. Let us assume that the intervals Iiappearing in the last proof are met in the usual order I1,I2...,IN when we run along gfollowing a particular orientation, and call Pithe region delimited by the rays frompwith speeds of ZN+1).If there is a point qPiAkB(e2) for sufficiently small e2, intersect either and yield a contradiction if kis notiori+1. ThusPiAiAi+1. Clearly there must be some point qin PiAiAi+1, to which we can apply lemma 6.3. AiAi+1is a Lipschitz curve near toZi+1), and it cannot turn back. The curve does not meet S, and it cannot intersect the rays from pwith speeds ZiandZi+1, so it must continue up to pitself. For any qAiAi+1, the cone q+C+
iis contained in Ai, and the cone q+C+
i+1is contained in Ai+1. This implies there cannot be any other branch of is all we need to describe S PB(e2): it consists of NLipschitz segments starting at p and finishing in PB(e2). The only multiple point is p. For small positive |a|, we know by condition (2) of the previous lemma that some c2>0. Similarly as above, define regions the rays from awith directions ZiandZi+1, and the boundary of the ring A(c|a|,e2), for a constant c >max(c1,c2). Takecbig enough so that for any qPi aand any either The same argument as above shows We conclude there must be a Lipschitz curve of points of AiAi+1, which starts in the inner boundary of A(c|a|,e2), and ends up in the outer boundary. Proof of 6.7. First we assume Uhas a product form U=L*xP*for open discs L*Land 26Figure 4: A neighborhood of a crossing point (this view is rot ated with respect to figure the graph of a Lipschitz function along the direction Zifrom any to Zi. LetHi=L+Wbe one such hyperplane that contains the subspace Land the vector line WP, and construct coordinates LxWx< Zi>. It follows from the previous lemma that AiP*
ais a connected Lipschitz curve. In these coordinates Aiis the graph of a Lipschitz function hi. Its domain, for fixed a, is a connected interval, delimited by two Condition (1) of lemma 6.5 assures they are Lipschitz. A connected component C0ofCis contained in only one AiAj. We can express it in the coordinates defined above for Ai. The intersection of C0with each plane Pais either empty or a connected Lipschitz curve. The second part follows as befor e. 6.3 Conclusion Using lemma 6.2, we show without much effort that Tvanishes near edge points. Using the structure results from the previous section, we show also th at it vanishes at cleave points ones) and crossing 6.9. LetpSbe an edgepoint. Then the boundary of Tvanishes near p. Proof. Letpbe an edge point with Qp={x}. LetObe a univocal neighborhood of x. It follows by a contradiction argument that there is an open neighborho odUofpsuch that QqOfor all qU. Recall the definition of T: T(ph) any cleave point = ~u(xi). By the above, both x1andx2 are inO. AsOis univocal, we see h1=h2atq. The integrand of Tvanishes near p, and thus T= 0. Proposition 6.10. LetpSbe a (possibly degenerate) cleave point. Then Tvanishes near p. Proof. Use the sets U,A1andA2of lemma 6.3. Whenever phis an-1differential form with support contained in U, we can compute: T(ph) components of cleave points inside either A1orA2do not contribute to the integral, for the same reasons as in the previous lemma. Recall the definition o fT, for a differential n-2forms: T(s) =T(ds) can apply a version of Stokes theorem that allows for Lipsc hitz functions. We will for this later: T(ds) balanced condition imposes that for any vector vtangent to A1A2at a point =^X2(v) for the incoming vectors Xi=dxiF(r). Recall that Hn-1-almost all points are cleave, and dhiis dual to the incoming vector Xi, soT(ds) = 0. Proposition 6.11. LetpSbe acrossing point. Then the boundary of the current T(defined in 5.2) vanishes near p. Proof. We use lemma 6.7 to describe the structure of connected compo nents ofCnearp. LetST, the set of higher order points , be the set of those points such that R*
qspans an affine subspace of T*
qohmof dimension greater than 2. Take any connected component C0ofCcontained in Ai.C0decomposes into several parts:
*The regular boundary, consisting of two parts that fl(a)< f1(a)< that f1(a)< f2(a)< fr(a)}
*The points of higher order, or C0ST.
*The singular boundary, or those points q= (a1,...,a =
f2(a)andRqis contained in an affine plane.
*A subset of U. 28Using a version of Stokes theorem that allows for Lipschitz f unctions, we see any function vandn-2formswith compact support inside U. Indeed, the last coordinate of the parametrization of C0is given by a Lipschitz function, so we can rewrite the integr al as one over a subset of LxW, and only Gauss-Green theorem is needed. We can apply the ver sion in [F, 4.5.5], whose only hypothesis is that the current Hn-1C0must be representable by [F, 4.5.15] we find that it is indeed, because its suppor t is contained in a rectifiable set Here we are assuming that D1is oriented as the boundary of C0, whileD2is oriented in the opposite way, to match the orientation of D1. Notice we have discarded several parts of C0:
*A subset of C0insideUdoes not contribute to the integral because no contribute because it has Hausdorff dimension at most n-3.
*The singular boundary does not contribute either, because t he normal to/tildewideC0at a point of the singular boundary does not exist (see [F, 4.5.5]). We now prove that T= 0. For a form sof dimension n-2and compact support inside U: T(ds) the two parts of the regular boundary of Ci. The first summand is zero and the remaining terms can be reorde red (the sum is because his bounded and Hn-2(S)is every point qSSThas a set I(q)consisting of those iandj= 1,2such that qis in the boundary part Djof the component Ci. The integrand at point qis the value of ~u(x)coming from the side lof component Ciand boundary part Dj. By the structure lemma 3.5, we can restrict the integral to cr ossing points. Let O1,...,O N be the disjoint univocal sets that appear when we apply 6.5 to p. For a crossing point q,I(q)is in correspondence with the set of indices ksuch that Indeed, the intersection of S with the plane Pacontaining qis a Lipschitz tree, and qis a vertex, and belongs to the regular boundary of the components that intersect Pain an edge. The hi,j,lin the sum appear in pairs: one is the value from the left coming from one component Ciand the value from the right of Ci'. Each one comes from a different side, so they carry opposite s igns, and they cancel. The integrand at qvanishes altogether, so T= P. Angulo, L. Guijarro, Cut and singular loci up to codimension 3 D. Bao, S. S. Chern, Z. Shen, An introduction to Riemann-Finsler geometry , Graduate Texts in Mathematics, 200, Springer. [CS] P. Cannarsa, C. Sinestrari, Semiconcave Functions, Hamilton-Jacobi Equations, and Op timal Control , Progress in Nonlinear Differential Equations and Their App lications, 58, Birkhauser [CR] M. Castelpietra, L. Rifford, Regularity properties of the distance functions to conjuga te and cut loci for viscosity solutions of Hamilton-Jacobi equati ons and applications in (2008) [D] J. J. Duistermaat, Fourier Integral Operators , Birkhauser, Boston, Progress in H. Federer, Geometric measure theory , Springer-Verlag New York Inc., New York, 153(1969). [GG] M. Golubitsky, V. Guillemin Stable Mappings and their Singularities Graduate Texts in Mathematics, A. Hatcher. Algebraic topology. Cambridge University ~hatcher [H] J. Hebda, Parallel translation of curvature along geodesics , Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., Vol. 299, No 2 (Feb., 1987), 559-572. [IT] J. Itoh, M. Tanaka. The Lipschitz continuity of the distance function to the cut locus. Trans- actions of the A.M.S. 353(2000), no. 1, 21-40 [LN] YY.Li, L. Nirenberg, The distance function to the boundary, Finsler geometry, an d the sin- gular set of viscosity solutions of some Hamilton-Jacobi eq uations . Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 58(2005), no. 1, 85-146. [L] P. L. Lions, Generalized solutions of Hamilton-Jacobi equations Research Notes in Mathematics 69, Pitman, London (1982). [MM] C. Mantegazza, A. C. Mennucci, Hamilton-Jacobi Equations and Distance Functions on Riemannian Manifolds Appl. Math. Optim. 47(2003), pp.1-25 [Me] A. C. Mennucci, Regularity And Variationality Of Solutions To Hamilton-Ja cobi Equations. Part I: Regularity (2nd Edition) , ESAIM Control Optim. Calc. Var. 13(2007), no. 2, 413-417 [W] F.W.Warner, The conjugate locus of a Riemannian manifold , Amer.J. of Math. MR 34:8344 30
|
0807.2046
|
Pablo Angulo Ardoy
|
Pablo Angulo Ardoy, Luis Guijarro
|
Balanced split sets and Hamilton-Jacobi equations
|
30 pages, 4 figures. Accepted for publication at "Calculus of
Variations and Partial Differential Equations"
| null | null | null |
math.AP math.DG
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study the singular locus of solutions to Hamilton-Jacobi equations with a
Hamiltonian independent of $u$. In a previous paper, we proved that the
singular locus is what we call a balanced split locus. In this paper, we find
and classify all balanced split sets, identifying the cases where the only
balanced split locus is the singular locus, and the cases where this doesn't
hold. This clarifies the relationship between viscosity solutions and the more
classical approach of characteristics and shocks.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Sun, 13 Jul 2008 18:04:30 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Fri, 27 Feb 2009 18:28:38 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Fri, 8 May 2009 14:38:55 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Fri, 28 May 2010 13:54:24 GMT"
}
] | 2010-05-31T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Ardoy",
"Pablo Angulo",
""
],
[
"Guijarro",
"Luis",
""
]
] |
of Eg~f(T) to T=0 but again it should be remembered that E g~f(T) also has a small contribution from change in volume with temperature. Th erefore we should distinguish between effects of the average atomic mass (w hich imply the virtual crystal approximation - VCA) and effects of the mass fl superimposed onto the virtual crystal. In this communication we report the first results of the quantitativ e study the dependence offree exciton's binding energyon isotope massas well ason the temperature in LiH xD1-xmixed crystals. We'll show that the exciton binding energy increase by 10 +-1 meV from7LiH to7LiD. Moreover, the dependence of Eb~f(x) is nonlinear. The last effect, as will be shown below, is caused by the of LiH xD1-xmixed crystals. Briefly part of these results have been published in melt using the modified Bridgman - Stockbarger method (see, a lso [22]). This technique is described many times early (see, e.g. [18, 2]). To impr ove composition with respect to hydrogen (deuterium), the crystals grown were additionally annealed in an atmosphere of hydrogen or de uterium at a gas pressure of 3 to 5 atm. and a temperature 500 to 5500C (melting point is 961 and 964 K for LiH and LiD, respectively). For some crystals the time of heat treatment was as long as 20 days (for more details see [2,7]). Given the high reactivity of freshly cleaved LiH crystals in the atmosp here, we had to develop a procedure of cleaving which would not only ensure an initially clean surface, but also allow us to keep it fresh for a few hours (the time taken to complete an experiment). These requirements are satisfi ed by the well- known method of cleaving directly in the helium chamber of the optical cryostat under liquid or superfluid helium, first tried in Ref. [23]. We did not notice any changes in the spectra of reflection or luminescence while working fo r 10 t0 16 hours with surface prepared in this way. The device for cleaving the crystals had three degrees of freedom and rotated through 900, which greatly helped in carryingout the experiments. As a rule, specimens for experiment s werecleaved off bulk high - quality crystals. The experimental setup for measurin g the low - temperature reflection and luminescence spectra has been descr ibed more than once(see, e.g. [7,18])and gratingorprism monoc hromators, an immersion helium cryostat, and a photovoltaic detector (in photo n counting mode). The results presented in this paper were obtained from a cle an crystal surface cleaved, as described above, directly in the bath of helium c ryostat. The spectra of mirror reflection were measured using an the angle o f incidence of 450. For our studies we selected specimens which exhibited low dependen ce of exciton spectra of reflection and luminescence on surface feat ures. As demonstrated earlier (see, e.g. [7]) most low-energy electron ex citations in LiH (LiD) crystals are large-radius excitons. The spectrum of exc iton of LiH crystals cleaved in liquid helium consists of a narr ow (in the best crystals, its half-width is the E phononless emission line and its broader phonon repetitions, which arise due to radiative ann ihilation of excitons with the production of one to five longitudinal (LO) phonon s (see, Fig. 1). The phononless emission line coincides in an almost resonant way wit h the 2reflection line (see, insert Fig. 1) of the exciton ground state which is of direct electron transition (X 1- X4[2]). The lines of phonon repli- cas form an equidistant series biased toward lower energies from th e line of excitons. The energy difference between these lines is about 140 meV, which is close to the calculated energy of the LO phonon in th e mid- dle of the Brillouin zone [21] and measured in [19]. The isotopic shift of th e zero-phonon emission line of LiH crystals equals that in reflection spe ctra, 103 meV (see, also, insert in Fig.1). As the deuterium concentrations inc reases, the width of the long-wave maximum in reflection (and the width of the pho non- less line in luminescence) spectra broadens and maximum shifts towar ds the shorter wavelengths. As can clearly see in Fig. 1, all spectra exhibit a structure. This circumstance allows us to attribute this structure to the excitation of the ground (1s) and the first excited (2s) excito n states [2]. Three effects are distinctly shown in the reflection spectra by an inc rease in deuterium The shortwavelength shift of the reflection (as luminescence) s pectrum as a whole; 2. The different velocity shift of the exciton maximum of the ground a nd the first excited states on the temperature (see, Fig. 2); 3. Broadening of the long-wavelength maximum due to excitation of t he ground exciton state. By the way we should note that the first excited exciton state is ver y clearly seen in the luminescence spectra too (see Fig. 3). Although two dist inct contri- bution to E g(and respectively E b) are present that due to the effect of the vibration on the lattice constant and the direct effect of the electr [19, 20] for the present task of the dependence of th e exciton bind- ing energy on the isotope mass it will be considered only the mechanism interaction. In accordance with the second effect in reflection spectra (see ab ove point 2), as is to be expected, there is nonlinear dependence of the excit on binding energy (E b= 4/3 12) on the isotope concentration. Displayed curve in Fig. 4 is the Wannier - Mott exciton binding energy value which are determin ed by the hydrogenlike expression E for this E 1and E 2values from the reflection and luminescence spectra (see Figs. 1 and 3). T he nonlinear nature of this dependence is similar to the theoretical results [25] , where the influence of the chemical disorder of the crystal lattice on the Wan nier - Mott exciton binding energy was seen and obtained a qualitative (not quan with experimental results on the GaAs xP1-x[26] mixed crystals. Before the comparisonof our experimental results with the theor y developed by Elliott and Kanehisa [25], it would be prudent to briefly review main pro p- erties of their theoretical model. One of the principal result of pap er [25] is the nonlinear dependence of exciton binding energy E bon the concentration. As a consequence, the binding energy at half-and-half concentration s is less than the value derived from the crystal virtual model. According to Ref. [25 ] this model considers an exciton with a direct gap of a semiconductor alloy. Such a system 3consists of an electron (particle 1) in the conduction band (c) with m ass mcand a hole (particle 2) in the valence band (v) with mass m v. The problem of the exciton in disordered systems is to solve the Hamiltonian H =- -p2/2mc+- -p2/2mv+ u(- -r1-- -r2) + Vc(- -r1) + Vv(- -r2), (1) with both the Coulomb interaction u and the potential V vdue to disorder (n= c,v). Reference [25] neglected disorder - induced interband mixing . As it is well known, in place of the electron-hole coordinates, (- -r1,- -p1) and (- -r2, - -p2), one may introduce the center-of-mass and relative coordinate s, (- -R,- -P) and (- -r ,- -p) to rewrite (1) as H =- -p2/2ur+ u(- -r ) +- -P2/2M + V c(- -R + m v- -r /M) + V v(- -R - m c- -r M are the reduced and total masses of excitons, respectively . Because of the random potential, the translational and relative de grees of free- dom cannot be decoupled. This is essentially difficult when considering t he two- body problem in a disorderedsystem (see [25] and references ther ein). However, when the exciton state in question is well separated from other sta tes so that the energy spacing is much larger than the translational width and d isorder, one can forget about the relative motion (H r=- -p2 2mr+ u(- -r)) and just apply any single-particle alloy theory solely to their translational motion. F or each exciton state the translational part of Hamiltonian in this case is Ht=- -P2/2M +-Vc(- -R) +-Vv(-R) averages of V cand V vwith respect to the relative state ph, for example: Vc(- -R) -r|ph(- -r)|2Vc[- -R+mv M- -r] (4). This approach is very similar to the Born-Oppenheimer adiabatic appr oxi- mation. Such situations hold in some mixed alkali halide crystals and pro On the contrary, when the exciton binding energy is comp a- rable to the disorder energy, the adiabatic approximation breaks d own, and it is essential to take into account the effect of disorder on both th e transla- tional and relative motions. This is the case with the Wannier-Mott ex citon in A3B5alloys, for which the Elliott and Kanehisa model was developed. In this case the solution task is to start from the independent electro n and hole by neglecting u in (2) and then to take into consideration the Coulomb int eraction between the average electron and average hole. A further simplifie d approach adopted in the literature (see, for example [27] and references th erein) in solving the Bethe-Salpeter equation [28] is to suppose a e one particle Green's function with a built-in width to allow for the random potential due to disorder. In the cited theoretical model [25], the average (or vir tual crystal) gap is given by Evc g(x) = E 0+ (dc-dv)(x - 1/2), (5) whereE 0isaveragegap, dc,dvarethe valuesofthe fluctuation broadeningof the conduction and valence bands, respectively. Reference [25] a lso assumed the Hubbard density ofstatesfor both the conductionand valence ba nds with width Wcand W v, respectively, as well as similar dispersion in both bands. With this 4assumption the exciton binding energy has been calculated accordin g to the coherent potential approximation CPA model. As is well-known, the m ain idea of the coherent potential methods in the introduction of an auxiliar y medium with a regular , i.e., spatially periodic potential. By definition in the model this potential is also complex. The formalism of the coherent potent ial for performing calculation and does not include fitting pa of using of the density of phonon states from virtual cry stal model which used virtual crystal approximation (VCA). It should be adde d here the key feature of the model developed in Ref. 25 is the short-range n ature of the Coulomb potential (for details, see e.g. [7, 29]). The data from Fig. 1 and other published sources [2, 7, 21] were use d for plotting the energy E bas a function of isotopic concentration x in Fig. 4. The binding energy (defined as the band edge minus the exciton energy) is given U0+W 2U0+ W (6). In the last relation U 0is the coupling constant at the total exciton momen- tum- -q= 0. Theoretical description of the binding energy of Wannier- Mott exc itons as a function of concentration x was based on the polynomial derived b y Elliott and cowokers [25]: Eb= Ecrys b- Eeff, (7) Eeff= x (1-x)dcdv W, (8) where W = W c+ Wv, and W cand W vare the widths of the conduction band and the valence band which are equal to 21 eV [30] and 6 eV [31, 3 2] respectively. Here E bowis the curvature parameter found from the function E g f(x) (E bow= 0.046 eV [7]); dcanddvare the magnitudes of the of the valence band and the conduction band edges , dc= 0.103 eV anddv= - 0.331 eV. As follows from Fig. 4, these values of the parameters g ive a good enough description of the nonlinear dependence of the bindin g energy isotope-mixed crystalsL iHxD1-x. This agreement between theory and experiment once again proves the of the model proposed by Kanehisa and Elliott, since th e affects the short-range part of the interaction pot ential. In this way, the ofthe ier-Mott exciton is caused by isotopic disordering of the crystal lattice. As is seen from Fig. 4 the exciton binding energy decreasing (relative linear law (VCA) - see dashed line in Fig. 4) in the vicinity of the middle meaning concentration r eally calls out the fluctuated broadening of the edge of the conduction a nd valence bands. In accordance with the theoretical model the last reason gives rise to the reduced E gand there by the shallowing of the exciton levels and, reduction of E b. As follows from Fig. 1, the addition of deuterium leads not only to the short-wave shift of the entire exciton structure (with different r ates for 1s and 2s states), but also to a significant broadening of the long-wave ex citon reflec- tion line. This line is broadened 1.5 - 3-fold upon transition from pure LiH to 5pure LiD. The measure of broadening was the halfwidth of the line mea sured in the standard way (see e.g. [33]) as the distance between the maximu m and the minimum in the dispersion gap of the reflection spectrum, taken at ha lf-height. The concentration dependence of the halfwidth (ER) of the long-wave band in the exciton reflection spectrum at 2 K is shown in Fig. 5. Despite the large spread and the very limited number of concentrations used, one imm the nonlinear growth of ERwith decreasing x. A similar concen- tration dependence of ERin the low-temperature reflection spectra of solid solutions of semiconductor compounds A 2B6and A 3B5has been reported more than once (see e.g. the review of Elliott and Ipatova [34] and refere nces therein). The observed broadeningof exciton lines is caused by the interactio n of excitons with the potential of large-scale fluctuations in the composition of t he solid so- lution. Efros and colleagues (see e.g. [35]) used the Lifshitz method o f [36] to express the formula for the concentration dep endence of the broadening of exciton reflection lines: ER= (9) where N - the concentration of sublattices nodes where the isotop e substi- tutes are placed, a= dEg/ dx; r exis the exciton radius which varies from 47 The g to Eq. (9) are shown in Fig. 5 by a full curve. The experimental results lie much closer to this curve than to the st raight line plotted from the virtual crystal model. At the same time it is clear that there is only qualitative agreement between theory and experiment at even this qualitative analysis clearly points to the non linear de- pendence of broadening on the concentration of isotopes, and he nce to the iso- topic disordering. Since isotopic substitution only affects the energ y of optical phonon for the first time, and, as a consequence, the constant o f excit (in the first place, the Fr ohlich interaction g2 F), the nonlinearity of functions E bf(x), ERf(x) is mainly related to the nonlinear behavior of g2 Ff(x) . In this way, the experimental study of the concentration d ependence of the exciton-phonon interaction constant may throw light on the nature and mechanism of the large-scale fluctuations of electron potential in is to the results of Fig. 2, let us add that the different temp of exciton peaks of n = 1s and 2s exciton states leads t o the temperature dependence of the binding energies of Wannier - Mott excitons Eb~f (T) (10). This problem has not received any adequate treatment. More spec ifically, the energy of the exciton binding E bin LiH crystals (as well as in mixed crys- tals LiH xF1-x(LiDxF1-x)) decreases with increasing temperature, whereas E b increases for excitons of the green and yellow series in Cu 2O crystals [34]. A linear approximation of the exciton binding energy in LiD 0.995F0.005(see curve 3, Fig. 2) representing E bat T=0 K gives E b(0)~=55 meV. From this value we can see that renormalization of the binding energy by the zero-poin t approximately 10 % from this value, that is, on the other hand, com- 6poses only half of renormalized exciton binding energy by isotope effe ct (10 meV, see above). It is not excluded that the other part of renorm alized exciton binding energy is caused by exciton-polar phonon interaction. In conclusion, the exciton luminescence and reflection spectra are used in a quantitative study of the isotopic and temperature effects in LiH with a clean surface. It was shown that the short-range character of the potential of a disordered crystal lattice with isotope substitution is responsible for the broadening of the valence and conduction bands. Nonlinear dependence of the exciton binding energy on the isotope mass E b~f(x) is due the of LiH xD1-xmixed crystals. Temperature dependence of ex- citon binding energy is briefly discussed. The extrapolation of the as ymptotic linear behavior of the exciton maximum energy to T = 0 K enables to est imate the zero - point renormalization of the exciton binding I would like to express my deep thanks to Prof. K. Wadler for improving my F.I. Kreingold, K.F. Lider, L.E. Solov'ev, Sov. Phys. JETP Let., 23 (1976) 624. 2. V.G. Plekhanov, T.A. Betenekova, V.A. Pustovarov, Sov. Phys. 1422; V.G. Plekhanov, Physics - Uspekhi 40(1997) 553. 3. V.F. Agekyan, V.M. Asnin, A.M. Kryukov, Sov. Phys. Solid State 31 (1989) 2082. 4. A.T. Collins, S.C. Lawson, G. Davies and H. Kanba, Phys. Rev. Lett . 65(1990) 891. 5. T.R. Anthony, W.F. Banholzer, J.F. Fleisher, L.-H Wei, P.K. Kuo, Phy s. Rev.B42(1990) 1104. 6. H.D. Fuchs, C.H. Grein, C. Thomsen, M. Cardona, Phys. Rev. B43 (1991) 4835. 7. V.G. Plekhanov, Isotope Effects in Solid State Physics, Academic P ress, New York, 2001. 8. M. Cardona, Phys. Stat. Solidi (b) 220(2000) 5; Phys. Stat. Solidi (a) 188(2001) 1209. 9. E.E. Haller, J. Appl. Phys. 77(1995) 2857; Solid State Commun. 133 (2005) 693. 10. M.L.W. Thewalt, Solid State Commun. 133(2005) 715. 11. D. Karaiskaj,M.L.W. Thewalt, T. Ruf, M. Cardona, M. Konuma, So lid State Commun. 123(2002) 87; M. Cardona and M.L.W. Thewalt, Rev. Mod. Phys.77, (2005) 1173. 12. D. Karaiskaj, T.A. Meyer, M.L.W. Thewalt and M. Cardona, 121201 (R). 13. S. Tsoi, H. Alawadhi, X. Lu, J.W. Ager III, C.Y. Liao, H. Rieman, Ph 193201. 714. H. Kim, S. Rodriguez, T.R. Anthony, Solid State Commun. M. Cardona, Solid State Commun. 121(2002) 7. 16. A.A. Klochikhin and V.G. Plekhanov, Sov. Phys. Solid State 22(1980) 342; V.G. Plekhanov, Fiz. Tverd. Tela 38(1996) 1159 (in Russian). 17. F.I. Kreingold, Fiz. Tverd. Tela 20(1978) 3138 (in Russian). 18. V.G. Plekhanov, Progress in Materials Science 51(2006) 287. 19. V.G. Plekhanov, Phys. Solid State (St-Petersburg) 35(1993) 1493; J. Nuclear Science and Technology 43(2006) 375. 20. S. Zollner, M. Cardona and S. Gopalan, Phys. Rev. B45(1992) 3376. 21. V.G. Plekhanov, Progr. Solid State Chem. 29(2001) 77. 22. O.I. Tytyunnik, V.I. Tyutyunnik, B.V. Shulgin, F.F. Gavrilov, and G .I. Pilipenko, J. Crystal Growth, 68(1984) 741. 23. V.G. Plekhanov, A.V. Emelyanenko, A.U. Grinfelds, Phys. Lett. A101 (1984) 291. 24. J.L. Verble, J.L. Warren, J.L. Yarnell, Phys. Rev. 168(1968) 980. 25. M.A. Kanehisa and R.J. Elliott, Phys. Rev. B35(1987) 2228. 26. R.J. Nelson, in Excitons, ed. by E.I. Rashba and M.D. Sturge (Nor th- Holland, Amsterdam, 1982), 319. 27. A.A. Klochikhin, Sov. Phys. Solid State 22(1980) 1690. 28. H.A. Bethe, E. Salpiter, Quantum theory of one and two electro n atoms, AQcademic Press, New York, 1957. 29. R.J. Elliott, J.A. Krumhansl, P.L. Leath, Rev. Mod. Phys. J. Kama and N. Kawakami, Phys. Lett. A126(1988) 348. 31. T.A. Betenekova, I.M. Shabanova, F.F. Gavrilov, Sov. Phys. So lid State 20(1978) 820. 32. K. Ichikawa, N. Susuki, K. Tsutsumi, J. Phys. Soc. Japan N.N. Ablyazov, A.G. Areshkin, V.G. Melekhin, L.G. Suslina and D.L. Fedorov, Phys. Stat. Solidi (b) 135(1986) 217. 34. R.J. Elliott and I.P. Ipatova (Eds), Optical Properties of Mixed C Amsterdam, 1988). 35. A.L. Efros and M.E. Raikh, in [34] Chapter 5. 36. I.M. Lifshitz, Selected works, Science, Moscow, 1987 (in Russia n). 37. T. Itoh, S.J. Narita, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 39(1975) 132. Figure captions. 1. Fig. 1. Luminescence spectra of free excitons at 2 K in LiH and LiD crystals cleaved in liquid helium. In insert: mirror reflection spectra o f crystals. Curve 1: LiH; curve 2: LiH xD1-xand curve 3: LiD. Curve 4 is the light source without crystals. 2. Fig. 2. Temperature dependence of the distance between the lo - LiH; 2 - LiD; 3 - LiD 0.995F0.005. 83. Fig. 3. The reflection (1) and luminescence (2) spectra of LiD cry stal at 2 K. 4. Fig. 4. Concentration dependence of the binding energy of a Wan nier - Mott exciton at 2 K in LiH xD1-xmixed crystals: 1 - VCA 2 - calculation according to equation (8); experimental point s indicated by triangles. 5. Fig. 5. Concentration dependence of the half-width of the grou nd state line of the exciton in the mirror reflection spectrum at 2 K. 1 - VCA app rox- imation model; 2 - calculation according to equation (9); experimenta l points are indicated by crosses. 9
|
0807.2130
|
Vladimir Plekhanov
|
V.G. Plekhanov
|
Direct observation of the e3ffect of isotope-induced disorder on the
exciton binding energy in LiHxD1-x mixed crystals
|
9 pages, 5 figures
|
J.Phys:Condens. Matter Vol 19 (No8) (2007) 9pp
|
10.1088/0953-8984/19/8/086221
| null |
cond-mat.mtrl-sci cond-mat.dis-nn
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The results of a quantitative study of the renormalization of the binding
energy of the Wannier-Mott exciton by the isotope effect are presented.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 11:14:14 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-15T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Plekhanov",
"V. G.",
""
]
] |
exhibit a similar long-wave structure. This allows us to attribute this s tructure to the excitation of the ground (1s) and the first excited (2s) exc iton states. The energy values of exciton maxima for pure and mixed crystals at 2 K are presented in Table I. The binding energies of excitons E b, calculated by formula, and the energies of interband transitions E g(details see [4]) are also given in Table I. The ionization energy, found from the temperature quenching of t he peak of reflection spectrum [4] of the 2s state in LiD is 12 meV. This value agre es fairly well with the value of E 2scalculated by the hydrogen-like formula. Moreover, Eb= 52 meV for LiD agrees well with the energy of activation for therma l quenching of free-exciton luminescence in these crystals [2]. At the weak scattering potential the mean-square vibrational am plitude
<u2>of an atom dependes on the phonon frequencies and the eigenvect ors, the atomic masses (at low temperatures), as well as the temperat ure (at Isotope substitution results in a slightly different v (epecially at low temperature) and phonon frequencies a nd in equivalent to changing the temperature (see also [5]) . The mass dependence of <u2>becomes vanishingly small at temperature on the order or higher than the Debye temperature. Changes in either the isoto pe masses or temperature thus lead to changes in the band gap (see above Fig . 1) via the electron-phonon interaction, even at zero temperature in th e case of mass changes. In general, the band gap [4] and its result from a complicated interplay of 1) first- and sec interactions that contribute to the energy of c onduction and valence bands; 2) changes due to thermal or isotopic lattice expan sion, and 3) changes in the phonon occupation numbers (see [5] and reference s therein). The dependence of the band gap energy on isotopic composition has already been observed for insulators and lowest gap of d ifferent semi- conductors (see also [6]). It has been shown to result primarily from the effect of the average isotopic mass on the electron-phonon interaction, with a from the change in lattice constant. This simplest appr oximation, in which crystals of mixed isotopic composition are treated as crysta ls of iden- tical atoms having the average isotopic mass is reffered to as virtua l crystal ap- proximation (VCA) [7]. Going beyond the VCA, in isotopically mixed cryst als one would also expect local fluctuations in the band gap energy from in local isotopic composition within some effective volume, such as that of an exciton. As follows from Fig. 1 excitons in LiH xD1-xcrystals display a unimodal character, which facilitates the interpretation of their Fig. 2 shows the concentration dependence of the e nergy of inter- band transition E g. As can be seen from Fig. 2 VCA method cannot experimental results. As will shown below this deviation fr om linear low (VCA approximation) is connected with r in isotope mixed crystals LiH pEg(T,Mi) can be described by average Bose-Einsteinm statistical factor n an average phonon frequency thias (see also [5; 8] 2Eg(T,Mi) = Ebar- ar(Mnat Mi)1/2[1 + 2n B], (1) where n B= and E barand arthe unrenormalized (bare) gap and the renormalization parameter, respectively. In the low-temp erature limit, T<<thi, equation (1) reduces Eg(T,Mi) = Ebar- i)1/2, whereas a risthe energy difference between the unrenormalized gap (M i- ) and the renormalized value [5]. In the high-temperature limit, T >>thiand Eq. (1) can be written as Eg(T,Mi) = Ebar- 2Tar th, (3) and E g(T,Mi) is independent of M i[5]. The extrapolation of Eq. (3) to T = 0K can be used to determine the unrenormalized gap energy E bar, i.e., the value that corresponds to atoms in fixed lattice position without lattice [4]), from the measured temperature dependence of Eg(T) in (i.e. linear in T) region. Using Eq. (2) it can be written the difference in energy E gbetween a given energy gap in isotopically pure material (LiH) and its isotope analogue (LiD) Eg= Eg(Mi) - Eg(Mnat) = (4) As can be seen from Table 1 and results of [5] E gat 2K equals E g=
0.103 eV and E g(LiH, T = 0K) =5.004 eV (linear approximation and E g(LiH, T = 300K) = 4.905 eV then using Eq. (3) we obtain a r= 0.196 eV. This magnitude is very close (approximately 84%) to the value of 0.235 eV o f zero vibration renormalization of the energy band gap in LiH crystals (det ails see [4;5]). Using Eq. (4) we obtain E g(theor) = 0.134 eV that is very close, the isotopic lattice expansion to the band gap single-mode nature of the exciton reflection spectra of mixed c qualitatively with the results obtained with the virtual cryst al model (see, e.g. [7; 9]), being at the same time its extreme realization , since the difference between ionization potentials ( z) for this compounds is zero. Ac- cording to the virtual crystal model, z= 0 implies that E g= 0, which in contradiction with the experimental results for LiH xD1-xcrystals (details see, also [6]). In the light of obtained dependence E g= f(T, M i) for LiH xD1-xit is very interested to study such dependence for different materials . Although the details of the renormalization process of E gare not known, observation of the isotope renormalization of E gfor many materials force to pay a great attention on this effect. By now the change in E gcaused by isotopic substitution has been observed for many broad-gap and narrow-gap compounds. Below we briefly d iscuss the variation of the electronic gap (E g) of different crystals with its isotopic com- position. In the last decade the whole row of different semiconductin g crystals was grown. These crystals are diamond [10], copper halides [11; 12], g Si [8] and GaAs [15]. All enumerated crystals show the depend ence of 3the electronic gap on the isotope masses. It should be noted that t he indicated effect (the variation of E gand E b, see Table I and II) have maximum values in LiH crystals, although this effect in other crystals with isotopic comp osition are currently being reliably measured and investigated well. All numerate d crystals show the dependence of the electronic gap on the isotope masses. Before we complete the analysis of these results we should mention t hat before these investigations, studies were carried out on the isoto pic effect on exciton states for a whole range of crystals by Kreingol' dand coworkers [16- 21]. First of all we should name the classic crystals Cu 2O [17-19] with the substitution O16-O18and Cu63-Cu65. Moreover, there have been some detailed investigations of the isotopic effect on ZnO crystals [6] wher e Egwas seen to increase by 55 cm-1(O16-O18) and 12 cm-1( at In the paper of Kreingol'd and coworkers [21] it was shown tha t a decrease in the exciton Rydberg constant (E b). More detailed investigationsof the exciton reflectance spectrum in CdS crys- tals were done by Zhang et al [22]. Zhang et al to directly determine t he binding energy (E b) and the corresponding band gaps ( Eg) from a hydrogenlike model. In +-0.02meV and 26.8 +-0.02 meV in112CdS andnatCdS, respectively. The gaps E g(G7c- G9v) are 2.5806(2) eV and 2.5809(2) eV, respectively. In the case of B excitons, these values are E b= 27.1+-0.2 meV (27.1 +-0.2 meV) and E g(G7c- G7v) = 2.5964(2) [2 .5963(2)eV] for the112CdS [natCdS] the n =2 excited states of the A and B excitons cou ld not be observed in other isotopic CdS samples. Better samples are require d for GaAs or ZnSe, isotope substituents of either type should lead t o shifts of the E0gap which have been calculated to be 430 (420) and 310 (300) ueV/amu for cation (anion) mass replacement, respectively [15;23]. These va lues are E0/MGa= 390 (60) ueV/amu ] and preliminary results for isotopic ZnSe obtained by Zhang et al [22] based measurements of the bound exciton (neutral acceptor I 1) [E/MSe= 140+-40ueV/amu and E/MZn= behavior, however, is not found in wurtzite CdS. A previous re flectivity and study ofnatCd32S andnatCd34S shows [21] that for anion isotope substitution the ground state (n = 1) energies of bot h A and B excitons have a positive energy shift with the large rate of E/MS= E/MCd obtained by Zhang et al [22]. Several groups have conducted low-temperature studies of the direct and indirect band gaps of natural and isotopically controlled Ge single cry stals. For the first time Agekyan et al [13] used , infrared absorption, and Raman spectroscopy with a Ge crystals of natural composition and a crys- tals with 85 %76Ge and 15%74Ge. They found an indirect band-gap change Eg= 0.9 meV and a direct band-gap change E g= 1.25 meV with an error of+-0.05 meV. Etchegoin et al [24] and Davies et al [25] reported photolu mi- 4nescence studies of natural and several highly enriched , high qua lity single crystals of Ge. Measurement of the energies of impurity-bound ex citons per- mits by Davies et al the direct determination of band-gap shifts with the crystal isotope mass because the radiative recombination does not require phonon par- ticipation. As may be expected from the very large Bohr orbit of the excitons (see Davies et al [25] and reference therein), their binding energy only depends on the average isotope mass and not on the isotopic disorder (see, however [4]). The rate of band-gap energy change with isotope mass as determin ed by Davies et al is dE IG/dA = dE NP/dA = 0.35 +-0.02 meV/amu. Etchegoin et al [24] obtained a very similar value. Zollner et al.[25] have performed a numerical calculation of the electr onic bands using an empirical pseudopotential method including the nece ssary lat- tice dynamics. They found for Ge (dE IG/dA)e-p= 0.41 meV. The total cal- culated shift of the indirect band-gap energy with isotope mass add s up 0.48 meV. This result compares favorably with the experi- mental values stated above by Davies et al and by Etchegoin et al w ho 0.37+-0.01 of the direct band gap at the G point ( /vectork= 0) in the Brillouin zone have also been performed. Though the direct band gap is tech nologically less important than the minimum indirect band gap, determing the dep endence of this gap on isotope mass is of the same fundamental significance a s the Davieset al [27]used of very thin samples of Ge single crystals with natura l composi- tion and three different, highly enriched isotopes. They found dE/d A = 0.49
+-0.03 meV/amu for the temperature extrapolated to zero. Parks e t al [28] have used piezo- and photomodulated reflectivity spectra of four monoisotopic and one natural Ge crystals. These techniques do not require the extreme sam- ple thinning which is necessary for measurement s and the derivative nature of the spectra emphasizes the small changes. T he noise ratio and the superb spectral resolution allowed a v ery accu- rate determination of the dependence of E DGon isotopic mass. At very low temperatures an inverse square-root dependence accurately d escribes E DG= as a linear dependence for the small range of isotopic masse s, Parks et al find dE DG/dA = 0.49 meV/amu, in perfect agreement with the results of Davies et al [27]. Parks et al also determined the isotope mass depen dence of the sum of the direct gap and the split-off valence band ( 0) and find d(E DG
+ 0)/dA = 0.74 meV/amu. The experimental results can be compared to the Zollner et al [26] calculations which are found to be of the correc t order of magnitude. The theoretical estimates for the contributions of th e linear isotope shifts of the minimum, indirect gaps which are caused by electron-ph onon in- teraction, are too large by a factor of ~1.7 and for the smallest direct gap they are too large by a factor of Ga70on the Ga76increases the band gap in GaAs [23] on 510.5 cm-1. The interested results were communicated in papers of Cardona a nd coworkers [15; 12], where it was studied the dependence of E gon the isotope effect in CuCl crystals. When the Cu64on the Cu65is substituted the value of Egin CuCl crystals decreased on 1.24 cm-1, e.g. the isotope effect on the electronic excitation has an opposite GaAs, ZnSe, CuBr, forexample,the3 dstatesof the first constituent play an increasing role in determining the band s tructure. In Ge these states can be considered as localized core states (ato mic energy level-30 eV). Already, however, in GaAs they have moved up in energy by 10 eV, and their hybridization with the top of the valence band affect s the gap . Proceeding further in the series, this effect becomes more import ant, and in CuBr and Cu 3d states even overlap in energy with halogen p-state s, with which they strongly hybridize. Therefore, we cannot exclude that the main reason for the opposite sign of the isotopic effect in these compoun ds may be connected to the different character of the interactions in these semiconductors [6]. Analogous investigations of the direct absorption edge of Si (E g= 3.562 inCsH(CsH -CsD) gave the value Eg/M = 60 meV/amu [29]. The change of the indirect gap of diamond between pure C12and C13has been determined by Collins et al [10], using for this purpose the spectra of diamon d. From the results of Collins et al it was concluded that the dominant contributio n arises from electron-phonon coupling, and that there is a smaller contribu tion due to a change in volume of the unit cell produced by changing the isotope. These two terms were calculated as 13.5 +-2.0 and 3.0 +-1.3 meV respectively (details see, also [30]). All ofthese in Table II, wherethe variation ofEgand Eg/M are shown at the isotope effect. We should highlighted here that th e most prominent isotope effect is observed in LiH crystals, where the dependence of Eb= f (C H) is also observed and investigated (see, also [2]). Using the least- squares method it was found the empirical dependence of ln is depicted on Fig. 3. As can be seen the indicated dependence h as a parabolic = 6.105(lnE g)2- 7.870(lnE g) + 0.565. (5) From this figure it can be concluded also that the small variation of th e nuclear mass causes the small changes in E galso. When the nuclear mass increases it causes the large changes in E g(C; LiH; CsH) [30]. Moreover as can be seen from Fig. 3 in last case the empirical dependence ln Eg/M~f(lnEg) is very close to the linear one and in ordinary coordinate system it has a E 6.105 g(Eg/M= E3.0525 g).By the way it should be noted that at the largechangesE gresult in the changesof the force constants at the isotope effect from the large variation of nuclear mass. Obse rvable in Fig. 3 rather large scattering data in the rate of change E gon the isotope mass in the first step cause the different degree of the isotope-induced- disorder. The 6last effect, as is well-known (see e.g.[4]), due the different magnitude o f the scattering potential at the isotope substitution. We conclude the discussion of the band-gap shifts with isotope mass by ob- serving that the effects are exceedingly small in the most cases (se e Table 2) and most likely will not have any consequences any semiconductors t echnolog- ical applications. However, this exercise is an excellent demonstrat ion of the advanced state of our quantative theoretical understanding of the subtle effects of temperature, pressure and isotope mass on the electronic ban d are due to Dr. M. Segall for a critical reading of the manusc ript. 1.0.2 References 1. G. Herzberg, Molecular Spectra and Molecular Structure. I. Dia tomic Molecules (Van Nos Reinhold, NY) 1939. 2. V.G. Plekhanov, T.A. Betenekova, V.A. Pustovarov, Sov. Phys. Solid State 18, 1422 (1976); V.G. Plekhanov, Physics-Uspekhi (Mosco w) 40, 553 (1997). 3. A.F. Kapustinsky, L.M. Shamovsky and K.S. Baushkina, Physicoch im. (USSR) 7, 799 (1937). 4. V.G. Plekhanov, Phys. Rev. B54, 3869 (1996). 5. V.G. Plekhanov, Phys. Solid State (St-Petersburg) 35, 1493 (1 993). 6. V.G. Plekhanov, Isotope Effects in Solid State Physics, Academic P ress, NY - London 2001. 7. Y. Onodera and Y. Toyozawa, J. Phys. Soc. Japan 24, 341 (196 8). 8. L.F. T. Ruf, M. Konuma, M. Cardona, Phys. Rev. B61, 12946 (2000). 9. R.J. Elliott, J.A. Krumhansl and P.L. Leath, Rev. Mod. Phys. 46, 4 65 (1974). 10. A.T. Collins, S.C. Lawson, G. Davies and H. Kanda, Phys. Rev. Let t. 65, 891 (1990). 11. N. Garro, A. Cantarrero, M. Cardona, T. Ruf, Phys. Rev. B5 4, 4732 (1996). 12. A. Gobel, T. Ruf, Ch. Lin, M. Cardona, Phys. Rev. B56, 210 (19 97). 13. V.F. Agekyan, V.M. Asnin, A.M. Kryukov, Fiz. Tverd. Tela 31, 101 (1989) (in Russian). 14. E.E. Haller, J. Appl. Phys. 77, 2857 (1995). 15. N. Garro, A. Cantarrero, M. Cardona, T. Ruf, Solid State Com mun. 98, 27 (1996). 16. F.I. Kreingol'd, Fiz. Tverd. Tela 20, 3138 (1978) (in Russian). 17. F.I. Kreingol'd, ibid, 27, 2839 (1985) (in Russian). 18. F.I. Kreingol'd, K.F. Lider, and L.E. Solov'ev, JETP Lett. 23, 679 (1976) (in Russian). 19. F.I. Kreingol'd, K.F. Lider, and V.F. Sapega, Fiz. Tverd. Tela 19, 3 158 (1977) (in Russian). 20. F. I. Kreingol'd and B.S. Kulinkin, ibid 28, 3164 (1986) (in Russian). 721. F.I. Kreingol'd, K.F. Lider, and M.B. Shabaeva, ibid 26, 3940 (1984 ) J.M. Zhang, T. Ruf, R. Lauck and M. Cardona, Phys. Rev. B57, 9716 (1998). 23. N. Garro, A. Cantarero, M. Cardona, Phys. Rev. B54, 4732 ( 1996). 24. P. Etchegoin, J. Weber, M. Cardona, Solid State Commun. 83, 8 43 (1992). 25. G. Davies, E.C. Lightowlerst, K. Itoh, E.E. Haller, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 7, 1271 (1992). 26. S. Zollner, M. Cardona and S. Gopalan, Phys. Rev. B45, 3376 (1 992). 27. G. Davies, E.C. Lightowlerst, E. E. Haller, Semicond. Sci. Techno l. 8, 2201 (1993). 28. C. Parks, A.K. Ramdas, S. Rodriguez, E.E. Haller, Phys. Rev. B4 9, 14244 (1994). 29. K. Ghanehari, H. Luo, A.L. Ruoff, Solid State, Commun. 95, 385( 1995); 100, 777 (1996). 30. V.G. Plekhanov, Rep. Prog. Phys. 61, 1045 (1998). 1.0.3 Figure Captions. Fig. 1. Mirror reflection spectra of crystals: LiH, curve 1; LiH xD1-x, curve 2; and LiD, curve 3 at 4.2 K. Light source without crystal, curve 4. S of instrument indicated in the diagram. All curves have th e same energy scale. Fig. 2. ginmixedLiH xD1-x crystals on the hydrogen concentration x. The stright dashed line is the E g= f(x) in the virtual crystal model. The solid line corresponds to calculations using the polynom of second degree [2] Points derived from re- flection spectra indicated by crosses, and those from luminescenc e spectra 3. The dependence of ln( Eg/M)~f(lnEg); points are from Table 2 and continuous line - calculation on the fotmulae (5) . Table 1 .Values of the energy of maxima in exciton reflection spectra o f pure and mixed crystals at 2K, and energies of exciton binding E E g. Energy, meV (78K) E1s4950 4967 5003 5043 4939 E2s4982 5001 5039 5082 4970 Eb 42 45 48 52 41 Eg 4992 5012 5051 5095 4980 Table 2. Values of the coefficients E/M (meV) and energies 0f the band- to-band transitions E g(eV) according to indicated Eg/M (meV) E g(eV) 13C-12C 14.6 [10] 5.4125 [10] 7LiH-7LiD 103 [2,4] 4.992 -5.095 [2,4] 7LiH-6LIH 12 [5] 4.980 [2,4] CsD-CsH 60 [29] 4.440 [29] 30Si-28Si 2 [8] 3.652 [8] 68ZnO-64ZnO 0.372 [16,20] 3.400 3.533 [16,20] 3.400 -0.076 [11,12] 3.220 0.364 [11,12] 3.220 0.370 [21] 2.580 0.040 /0.068 [22] 2.580 1.116 [17-19] 2.151 0.39 [15] 1.53 [15] 76Ge-72Ge 0.225 [13] 1.53 [13] 76-73-70Ge 0.37 [24-28] 0.74 [24-28] 9
|
0807.2152
|
Vladimir Plekhanov
|
V.G. Plekhanov, N.V. Plekhanov
|
Isotope dependence of band-gap energy
|
7 pages, 3 figures
|
Physics Letters Vol. A313 (2003) 231-237
|
10.1016/S0375-9601(03)00760-6
| null |
cond-mat.mtrl-sci cond-mat.dis-nn
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The results of the quantitative investigations of the renormalization of the
absorption edge of different compounds by the isotope effect are described.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 12:52:49 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Plekhanov",
"V. G.",
""
],
[
"Plekhanov",
"N. V.",
""
]
] |
2 observables, parametrizedby z. IfPe|zis the distribution for the outcomes when this system is measured with the observable z, then the distribution of an ideal secret 2-NsPe|z. Usually, the real secret key gener- ated by PA is not guaranteed to be an ideal secret key 2-NsPe|z. In general, PA constitutes a sub-routine within crypto- graphic protocols, which use secret key as an ingredient (an example being the encryption of messages). It is desirable that the result obtained when any of these pro- tocols is fed with the real secret key , is the same as if fed with an ideal secret key , with arbitrarily high probabil- ity. If this is the case, then we say that PA is because it is secure in any context. Clearly, this happens if the keys are most general strategyfor distinguishing the bipar- tite states Pk,e|z(the real key) and 2-NsPe|z(the ideal key) consists of performing joint measurements on the key and Eve's system. The no signaling formalism alone does not say anything about joint measurements. How- ever, the key is a classical system which can be observed without disturbing the global state. Therefore, the most general strategy is to read kand chose an observable z depending on its value. It is well known that the proba- bility of guessing correctly with the optimal strategy that the maximization on zdepends on k. When (4) is close to 1 /2, the optimal strategyfor realfromthe is the security condition that we consider. Inkey distribution from Bell-violating correlations, Al- ice hasNsystems, Bob has Nsystems and, without loss of generality, Eve has one big system, jointly symbols correspond to bit-string variables.] It is usually assumed that this is a (2 N+1)-partite nonsignal- ing distribution [6] ( i.e.the marginals only depend on their corresponding observables), however, we are able to proceed with a weaker assumption. If the secret key is a function of Alice's string k=h(a), then Bob's Nsys- tems can be considered as a single big system, that is, no-signaling within Bob's systems is not required in our proof. We refer to this assumption as ( N+2)-partite no signaling. According to [14], the even weaker assump- tion of 3-partite no signaling (where Alice's Nsystems are also considered as single one) is insufficient to war- rant security. Of these Npairs of systems, Nr(Nr< N) are used for generating the raw key, and the rest are used to estimate how much nonlocality is shared by Alice and Bob [6]. In the large- Nlimit,Nris equal to Nup to terms sublinear in N--this is denoted by NrN.The following result establishes the security of Al- ice's key k=h(a) whenais generated by measuring Nrof Alice's systems with the observable x= 0. Of course, it is necessary that the correlations shared by Al- ice and Bob Pa,b|x,yhave a sufficiently small value or in other words, are However, the goal of key distribution is that both, Alice and Bob, hold the secret key k. Later we address this problem. Main result For almost all functions any ( Nr+2)-partite nonsignaling the random variable k=h(a) the zero have a particular property if when randomly picking a function hwith uniform distribution over all functions h:{0,1}Nr- {0,1}Nsthen the not have that particular property is lower than 2exp(5 Nr-2Nr/4). The above result is also true for but for simplicity we only consider the casex=0, which is sufficient for key the given correlations Pa,b|x,yare generated by measuring quantum systems Cirel'son's bound which prevents the right-hand side of (5) to be small. Hence, this simple scheme does not work with quantum correlations. This problem is solved by the BHK protocol, which yields large secure secret keys. The BHK protocol is analyzed below. Now, we proceed to prove the main result, and start by stating two lemmas which are proven in the Appendix. Lemma 1 For any ( Nr+ 1)-partite nonsignaling dis- tribution Pa,b|x,ywe have 5 5 1-3 1 1-35 1 5 51-3 -3 15 1 1 5-3 1 -3 11 5. Lemma 2 For any given function any k {0,1}Ns, defineAk=h-1(k) Almost all functions wherethesymbol R16Nrhas all entries equal to one.3 Proof of the main result Lethbe any of the functions which satisfies (6), and for each k, the vector defined in Lemma 2. Using the convexity of the absolute-value function, the inequality (6), andthe we (7) which is precisely (5). /square Error correction and public communication It is usu- ally the case that the given distribution Pa,b|x,ydoes not provide perfect aandb. Hence, if a is the raw key, Bob has to correct the errors in bbefore applying the hash function h. This can be done by Alice publishing some information about a, and Bob using it for correcting his errors. This is a standard procedure in quantum key distribution, which is detailed in [6] or [16]. Other procedures within the key distribution pro- tocol may also require public communication. Let the Nc-bit string cbe all the information about athat Alice has published during the protocol. Because cis a func- tion ofa, we can still use the main result (5) in this new setting if we let both, kandc, to be the outcomes of the function h:{0,1}Nr- {0,1}Ncx{0,1}Ns. However, roles: kis the secretkeyand cis part of the information owned by Eve. Hence, the extension of the security condition (5) to the present setting here and in the rest, the conditioning on x=0is implicit. This inequality is obtained by taking (5) The secret key is secure if the right-hand side of (8) can be made arbitrarily small (as Nrgrows). This happens when the length of the final key to sub-linear terms. Parameter estimation In the the honest parties are given Npairs of systems in a completely unknown global distribution. To perform a key distribution protocol, and in particular to set the numbers NsandNc, they need to bound some quantities, like for instance In order to do so, they invest some of the given pairs to obtain informationabout the distribution Pa,b|x,yof theNrremaining pairs. More precisely, they compute the bounds for Ns,Ncfor another distribution P' a,b,e|x,y,z, which is warranted to be close to the real (unknown) one <=ofor allx,y). This is explained with full detail in [6]. It is shown in [15] securitybound forthe in terms of properties of any o-close BHK protocol introduced in [2] and analyzed in [5, 6] givesarate ofone secretbit per singlet ( is remarkable that this protocol, where the adversary is only constrained by no signaling, gives the same rate as if the adversary is constrained by no signaling plus quantum mechanics. The essential novelty of the BHK protocol is to measure each system with m>=2 observ- ables,x {1,...m}. In this case, instead of the CHSH, we use the Braunstein-Caves Bell inequality [17], which can be expressed as >=
2, 1a 1a a1,(11) wherea= that for m= 2 this is equivalent to the CHSH inequality (2). Following the same methods as above, one can analogousto (5), (8), (10), and obtain a key rate as in (9) but with the rate formula can be improved by modifying following way: take the expression (11) and The security of this rate will be proven somewhere else. If Alice and Bob share singlets or something close to it, in the estimation process they measure them with all the observables corresponding to points in the equator of the block sphere (see [2, 5, 6] for details), the have 1/
2, for large m. The rawkeys measuringall systems with the same observable x= 0, then (12) tells that the secret key rate is one secret bit per singlet :NsNr. This rate cannot be improved because it is also the optimal rate achievable against a much weaker (quantum) We show, for the first time, that key distribution from Bell-violating correlations is secure ac- cording to the strongest notion of security, the so security. This provides the pos- sibility of implementing secure cryptographic protocols with untrusted quantum devices [3, 18]. In this model, Alice and Bob have to trust some of their computers and the random number generator), but can distrust the devices for preparing and measur- ing the quantum systems sent through the channel. The efficiency rate is slightly lower than the one obtained in standard quantum key distribution, where trusting the quantum devices is in our scheme, Bell-inequality violation plays the same role as the min entropy [16] does in stan- dard quantum key distribution. Specifically, equations (5) and (9) have a quantum counterpart, obtained with the schemeis that equivalently PA, can be performed with a constant hash function. This contrasts with previous methods for extracting randomness (two-universal hashing [12], ex- tractors, etc.), which need random functions. However, we still lack an explicit construction for one of such The author is grateful to This work is supported by Caixa Manresa, the spanish FIS2007-60182, Consolider QOIT), and the EU-IP programme SCALA. [1] J. S. Bell; Physics 1(3), 195 (1964). [2] J. Barrett, L. Hardy, A. Kent; Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 010503 (2005). [3] A. Acin, N. Gisin, Ll. Masanes; Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 120405 (2006). [4] V. Scarani, N. Gisin, N. Brunner, Ll. Masanes, S. Pino, A. Acin; Phys. Rev. A 74, 042339 (2006). [5] A. Acin, S. Massar, S. Pironio; New J. Phys. 8, 126 (2006). [6] Ll. Masanes, R. Renner, A. Winter, J. Barrett, M. Chri- standl; R.Canetti; Proc. 42nd IEEE Symposium onFoundations of Computer Science (FOCS), 136 (2001).[8] Ll. Masanes, A. Ac' in, N. Gisin; Phys. Rev. A 73, J. F. Clauser, M. A. Horne, A. Shimony, R. A. Holt; Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 880 (1969). [10] S. Popescu, D. Rohrlich; Found. Phys. 24, 379 (1994). [11] B. Cirel'son; Lett. Math. Phys. 4, 93 (1980). [12] C. H. Bennett, G. Brassard, C. Cr' epeau, U. M. Maurer; IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory, vol. 41, no. 6 (1995). [13] T. M. Cover, J. A. Thomas; Elements on John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (2006). [14] E. H anggi, R. Renner, S. Wolf; in Ll. Masanes; R. Renner; Security of Quantum Key Distribution , PhD thesis, S. Braunstein, C. Caves; Ann. Phys. 202, p. 22 (1990). [18] A Ac' in, N. Brunner, N. Gisin, S. Massar, S. Pironio, V. Scarani; Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 230501 we show the two lemmas stated above. Proof of Lemma 1. Here we use the same tools as in the proof of Lemma 16 from [6]. By definition we can 10 0 0 00 0 0 00 0 0 00 00 0 1 10 0 0 00 0 0 00 0 . The fact that Bob (when considered as a single system) cannot signal to Alice can be expressed as any y,y'. This implies that 2 2 2 0 0 0 0 -1-11 1 1 0 0 0 2 2 2 2 1 1-1-1 -1-11 1 . The fact that each of the NrAlice's systems cannot sig- nal to the rest, together with Bob's systems, implies the statement of the lemma. /square Proof of Lemma 2 Within this proof, the R16Nrare labeled as Ph( a,b,x,y). Also, for any pair of bit-strings x,y: (i) the string x*yis the bit- wise product, (ii) the string xyis the bit-wise xor, and (iii) the integer the numberofonesin x. = Next we prove inequality (6) for a given kand a given LetVa= 1 if the string abelongs to Ak, andVa= 0 otherwise. If we pick a random function hwith uniform distribution over the set of all functions, then the random variables Vaare independent and dis- tributed according to Prob {Va= 1}= 2-Ns, for all a. Letua= and note that |ua| <=5M8-Nrfor alla. Following for any Jandb>=0 we in (14) we need |b5M8-Nr| <=1. In this step wehave used the expansion ex<=1+x+x2, which holds if x<=1. With a little work one Substituting this two ex- pressions, J= that the chosen value for bsatisfies the The expression obtained when replacing >=
with <= above, can be derived in a similar way. (15) holds with probability 2 e-2Nr/4. However, we want this to not hold for all kand all entries ( a,b,x,y). The number of different values of kis 2Ns, and the number thenthe true is upper-bounded by 2exp(5
|
0807.2158
|
Lluis Masanes
|
Lluis Masanes
|
Universally-composable privacy amplification from causality constraints
|
4 pages
|
Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 140501 (2009)
|
10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.140501
| null |
quant-ph cs.CR cs.IT math.IT
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We consider schemes for secret key distribution which use as a resource
correlations that violate Bell inequalities. We provide the first security
proof for such schemes, according to the strongest notion of security, the so
called universally-composable security. Our security proof does not rely on the
validity of quantum mechanics, it solely relies on the impossibility of
arbitrarily-fast signaling between separate physical systems. This allows for
secret communication in situations where the participants distrust their
quantum devices.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 13:39:16 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Sat, 9 Aug 2008 08:43:35 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Sun, 15 Mar 2009 19:15:07 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Tue, 19 May 2009 16:41:11 GMT"
}
] | 2013-05-29T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Masanes",
"Lluis",
""
]
] |
1. Introduction As it is known, modern magnetostatics is based on the following differential equations: A rot HG G 01 m= , (1) 0=AdivG , (2) where AG - vector potential, HG - tension of the magnetic field, 0m- magnetic constant. In textbooks on electrodynamics it is usually said that vector potential has no physical meaning and is used as auxiliary function but condition (2) is entered to disambigue this function. According to condition (2), the lines of the vector must be locked-in, and it means that the field of this vector is rota- tional. As it is known, the vector potentia l satisfies the equation of Poi sson. We shall calculate the vec- tor potential of the field of infi nitely long rectilinear current J, directed along axis z: () () () () . z z z y x z z lnJz z z y xdz Jz , y , x A 0 02 2 2 000 2 2 20 22 GG G
'- +'+'+'- ==
'- +'+'=' ' ' pmpm (3) When computing this formula it is necessary to define the value of AG when () -'-z z , that is to say the condition of vector pot ential is required. As such c ondition the following is taken: 0=AG . (4) Then ()0 2 2 0 2z y x lnJy , x AG G '+' - =' ' pm. (5) It is not difficult to show that divergency of th e vector expressed by form ula (5) equals zero, so condition (2) is executed in this instance. Condition (4) has pr ovided locking-in of vector AG lines, but execution of the condition (2) is due to th e use of condition (4). After calculating ArotG , we shall get the known formula for induction of the magnetic field, created by rectilinear endless current. The argument of the logarithm in formula (5) cha nges from zero ad infinitum, at the same time the sign of the function also changes: if the value of the argument is less than one, fu nction (5) is posi- tive, but if value of the argument is greater than one, it is negative. Consequently, vector AG is di- rected on current if it is near a cond uctor, and it is directed against the current if it is far from a con- ductor. Locking-in of vector AG lines occurs at infinity, that confirms fairness o the condition (4). Ac- cording to (1) the rotati onal field of vector f AG generates vector magnetic field VG . At determination of the magnetic field of separate locked-in current sidebar, the characteristics of vector potential turn out to be the same, i. e. corresponding to equations (1) and (2). Usually the study of vector potential characterist ics is limited to the above. However the theory built on such basis, does not explain many electrodynamic phenomena and results of experiments that are to ld about in publications [3-9]. 22. Starting positions and consequences We shall calculate the vector potential of the magnetic field created in free point by rectilinear current ( z , y , x M' ' ') J, flowing along the conductor of defined length. Certainly, we get principle question about justification of such statement of the problem. Usually it is considered that constant currents are locked-in, and on this base th e currents of defined length, that are not locked-in, are not considered. However, if we present the locked-in current sidebar as electromechanic system, there arises the question about the interaction between its parts at the account of internal powers. Such approach requires consideration of separate current lengths, and interactions between them by means of the fields they create. If we link beginning of coordinate system with one of the ends of the current segment, axis z we shall direct along the current (fig. 1) , so we shall get the following: ()()0 2 2 22 2 0 4z z z y xz L y x z - LlnJz , y , x A2G G
'-'+'+''- +'+'+'=' ' ' pm. (6) We notice that it was not necessary to en ter any conditions. Mark the positive values: ()2 2 2 22 2 2 1 z L y x r ; z y x r'- +'+'='+'+'= . (7) They are the modules of radius -vectors, called on to the point ()z , y , x M''' from beginning and end of the current segment accordingly. Comparing the nu merator and denominator of the expression under the logarithm sign in (6), it is not difficult to see that ()1 2 2 22 2
>
'-'+'+''- +'+'+' z z y xz L y x z - L2 , because the sum of lengths of the two sides of the triangle showed in fig. 1 is always more than its third side: ()2 2 2 2 2z y x z L y x L2'+'+'>'- +'+'+ , or 1 2r r L>+ . ()z , y , x M''' 1rG 2rG 0r 1a 2a x O L z y Fig. 1 So, according to (6), the lines of vector potential have one direction in this case. Therefore there should exist the sources and drai ns of the field of vector AG . 3In publications of Nikolaev G.V. [5-6] the hypot hesis of magnetic field component existence, which is not taken into account in Maxwell's electrodyna ic magnm s, is prove d. Really, the identification of a etic field with the help of ir on sawdust, arisen in the earliest stage of studying magnetism, is not reasoned. Is it possible to describe electromagnetic interaction in a ll cases using only knowledge about magnetic field lines? Such question was not put in due time. It also has resulted in limited nature of modern electrodynamics. Austrian professor S. Marinov from reasons of the basis of field theory ha s offered [7-8] to de- termine*H function throug h vector potential as follows: A div HG 0m, (8) where - scalar function. At the suggestion o netic field (SMF) which is described by this function is introduced. Thus, it is suggested to use two mholz) : if di e rotor of a field (in this case * 1- =
() z , y , x H*' ' ' f Nikolaev G.V., the concept of scalar mag- functions for the description of fu ll magnetostatics field: vector () z , y , x H' ' 'G and scalar () z , y , x H*' ' '. Indeed according to the basic theorem of the field theory (Stox-Hel v rgency and AG ), turning to zero at infinit y, are determined in each point rG of some area, the field of vector ()rAGG may be presented as a sum of po tential and solenoidal fields every- where in this area. Thus, the correlation (8) cancels artificial calibration (2), and allows to work out generalized magnetostatic It is clear that the vector potential s. AG introduced this way has other pr operties, than in usual First of all, fro AG m (8) it follows that the field of vector has sources and drains which are in SMF. Sources of the field of vector AG are in negative SMF, and dr ains are in positive SMF. Fig. 2 Fig. 2 conventionally represents the field of vector potential AG , Including rotational OAG and po- ential A t -G components, and also vector magnetic field NG and calar magnetic field s*N, created by rectil inear current segment of certain length. As a result of calculation of the function divergency (6), we have: () 2 11 2 0 4 r rr r J zAA divz -='=pm G . (9) As at any values of and , size of 1r2r 0AdivG , that SMF in this case is created: y z 0 L HG-AG OA *
GH+ *H- OAG x 4()()()2a asin sinJ rz , y , x H - =2 1 0 2 11 4 4 p p r r rrJ* -=' ' ' , (10) We research function (10). Fig. 3 shows the diagram of dependence , that is this function is determined in the points laying on axis z, thus () z', 0 , 0*H z L r , z r'-='=2 1 the diagram, function . Apparently from ()z H', 0 , 0* is sign-variable and on ent AB has disrup- ()*
that SMF gradient gradH ' directed along the current flow- ing in it. It is possible to formula l rule: if to look from the midpoint of the segment in the direction of the curr positive SMF is created ahead, and negative SMF is created behind. the ends of current segm tions. Distribution of function ', 0 , 0 sorresponds to SMF presented in fig. 2. It is noticeable
*0 0 appears along a conductor, it is te the genera ent flowing in it, Fig.3 The above said leads to an important conclusion: the vector potential generally has vortical and l components: z H ()z , , ()z , ,*H'0 0 A B z/
0,5 L L potentia - O+ =A A AGGG . (11) Thus formulas (1) and (8) can be put accordingly as follows : O= = A rot A rot VGG G , (12) div A div B* -A- = - =GG . (13)
*H and induction *B Taking into account substance propertie s, the connection between intensity of SMF is represented by the following correlation: Concerning dimensionality of SMF characteristics the f eristics of a vector magnetic field is observed: * *H B0m m'= . (14) ull analogy to the corresponding charac-
*H*B is measured in A/m , t is measured in Tl. In his monographies Nikolaev G.V. [5-6] gives the equations which are suggested as fundamen- tal to generalized magnetostatics: 0=HdivG , (15) j*gradH H rotG G+
=. (16) 5It is follows from the equation (16) that the curr ent of con al) magnetic field, except for a usual vector (solenoidal) magnetic fiel at e ductivity derivates also a scalar (poten- d. Let's pay attention to the fact ti th quation (16) also correspond s to Stox-Helmholz theorem with re ference to a field of currents ()r j. Having substituted in (16) equations (1) and (8), we shall receive: GG j A graddiv A rotrotGG G 0m m'= - . In the result we have equation of Poisson: j AG G 0m m'- = D . (17) Thus, the vector potential at such approach, as well as in tion of Poisson, however, at its computing the condition (2 traditional magnetostatics, satisfies the equa- ) was not required. As one of the most important conclusions at th is investigation phase we shall note, that both components of a magnetic field (vector and scalar) ar e determined by means of vector electrodynamic poten tial. Consequently, vector electrodynamic potential is necessary to recogn ize as the basic char- acteristic of full m agnetostatic field. The question about conditions of creation SMF by complete current system seems very impor- tant. At its solution it is necessary to rely on the pr operties of vector potential [3-4]. Let's consider rec- tangu lar current contour. In any point of space there are imposed magn etic fields from four current segments forming it. In any point of space, except for the point of diagonal crossing of rectangular O, vector AG is other than zero. The configuration of the vector magnetic field created by the rectangular contour is known. L s choose any point of space and make in it radi us-vectors from all four corners, having desig- nated them accordingly r , r , r , r (fig. 4). et' It is not difficult to see, that 4 3 2 1 Fig.4 () 041 41 4 4 34 3 3 23 2 2 12 1=
-+-+-r+-=' ' ' r rr r r rr r r rr r rr r Jz ,*
p. Thus, SMF is not created by rectangular locked-in cu rrent contour in any points of space. Really, for the locked-in contoury , x H 0=AdivG , therefore 0*=H . Obviously, it is possible to make a more general e locked-in current does not create SMF at any form of a contour in which it flows. This conclusion agrees to th nal theory. Now we shall consider the system of two identi cal rectangular current contours located in one plane (fig. 5). It is clear that in any point of space, chosen accidentally, the components from all eight current segments are imposed. It is not dif ficult to show, that in the point M, located on the axis of symmetry of electric system Ox, the vector potentials of current segments AD and D1A1 and also SV B C A D 3rK 4r 1rK 2rK O K 6and S1V1 are in pairs compensated. The vector potentials of currents AV and A 1V1 are directed to the right side, and currents of CD and C 1D1 - to the left. Let's make it a po int that the sum of the two first potentials, undoubtedly, is more than the sum of tw o second ones. It is obvious, that the resulting vec- tor potential in point M is other than zero, and it is directed to the right. It is possible to show that on axis Ox 0=ArotG , consequently, the vector magnetic field on the axis of symmetry is missing. It is easy to verify that after consider ing the picture of the magnetic fiel d lines modelling a usual magnetic field. Having calculated all rece e expression for intensity of MF in any point on axis Ox : Fig. 5 the divergence of vecto y D1 C 1 A1 B 1 O M AG x -H* +H* A B D C r potential, we sh iv S ()()() -+-=' 4 34 3 2 12 1 20r rr r r rr r J, xp, (18) where - modules of radius-vectors which have been carried out accordingly from points A (or ) and V (or ) to point M. - modules of radius-vectors drawn accordingly from points (or D (or me there is no SMF: It is very important in examining any current syst em to determine a special point in which SMF is qual to zero. Knowing the di rection of vector potential *H 2 1,r r 1 1 4 3 S S) and 1D) to point M. We investigate function (18). In th e centre of the current system sym- try in point O () 0 0 0=,*H . A V r , r 1 AG e in relation to this point , it is possible to de- termine the sign of SMF, according to the rule: SMF has a positive sign where vector potential AG is directed away from the special point, and a negative sign where vector AG is directed towards special point. Having applied this rule it is easy to see that in the right part of the gap between the elec- tric contours SMF has a positive sign, while in left - negative. These areas are represented in fig. 5. Once again we shall emphasize, that the initial char acteristic of the full magnetic field created by a current system, is the vector pote ntial. Such approach allows to avoid the erroneous decision: if the the scala tatic system creating a magnetic field in which a vector and scalar components are pr magnetic field is not created by a separate contour so the resulting fi eld from two contours is also equal to zero. The contours represented in fig. 5 are formed in diametrical secti on of a toroid. The toroid repre- sents the ideal divided: the vector field is completely inside the toroid, and scalar - outside (fig. 6). The intensity of SMF on an ax is of a toroid is determin ed by the following formula: 7 ()()()
4 3 2 1 2 r r r r p where n- quantity of pair coils of a toroid. If to accept the height of a toroid as equal to 2h designate its internal and external radiuses ac- ordingly , it is convenient to present the segments which are included in the formula (19) as: -+-='4 3 2 10r r r r Jn , x*H , (19) Fig. 6 , and to c t t )R , r ( () () () . h x R r , h x R r , h x r r , h r r2 2 2 2 2 2 2+ + = - + = - + = + = x t 4 t 3t2 t2 1+
It is not difficult to sho MF. Vector potential of semiannular current with radius possible to lock-in a w, that the locked-in ring current does not create S R (fig. 7) is calculated by the formula (10) as it is contour by rectilinear segment of 2R length. Thus it is convenient to use polar coordinates, then in (10): ph ph ' ' -'+ = ' ' +'+ = cos r R r R r , cos r R r R r 2 22 2 22 2 1 . SMF may be created by constant magnets. For the first time it was noticed by Nikolaev G.V. who has created a special magnet. Magnet of Nikolaev (MN) represents a cylindrical magnet sawn on di- amete In the left part the vector potential is directed to point O, consequently, SMF ha s the negative sign r in two parts which are turn ed against each other half-way ( 180 degrees) (fig. 8). Magnetic field created by such magnet is modelled by semiannular a nd radial currents. The theory developed above allows to represent SMF in this figure taking into consideration function signs. From considerations of symmetry it is not difficult to gue ss that there is a special point O in the centre of the current system. Fig. 7 x M *
*H-H+ O 1rG 2rG 3rG 4rG y y J R y ' M r 1G'r 2rG ph/ N O 1 N x 2 x' 8here, and in the right part vector AG is directed from point O, consequently, positive SMF is created here. Fig. 8 For creation of SMF it is possible to use a pair of flat magnets connected wy ith their lateral sides. d by the current conto s shown in fig. 5. ents, in particular about using a magnet of Ni- kolae the ends ssible to base on analogies in the description of two compo- nentsThus magnetostatic system is formed, which is of SMF is proved by numerous experimur v [5-6, 9]. It is shown, that the force directed along a current or against it, depending on the sign of SMF, operates on a current placed in SMF. Th ere is also observed a boom erang effect when on of the conductor making longitu dinal movement in SMF, EMF indu ction is induced. Generator of new type [ 9 ] operates on this principle. Accordingly, there is a basis to consider Maxwell's electrodynamics as a restricted theory. Let's undertake an attempt to develop generalized electr odynamics on the basis of general properties of vec- tor potential. Thus to some extent it is po of a magnetic field. It is known, that the non- stationary vector magnetic field generates vortical electric field. By analogy: non-stationary SMF gene rates potential electric field. This hypothesis has the strict proof and is conf irmed experimentally [9]. 3. Theoretical analysis Let us assume that in some volume t non-unif orm and non-stationary SMF is cre- . Presence of sources and drains of a each point as follows from the put forwa() t , z , y , x B*
ated potential el ectric field in rd hypothesis, is char acterized by a derivative tB . In elementary volume *
td pres ence of sources and drains of an electric field is determined by product tdt*
and for all allocated defined B volume we have:
= PhtdB*
*. (20) tt On the other hand the same value represents the flux of vector EG through surface S limiting allocated volume: sing Ghauss theorem, from (20) and (21) it is possible to write down:
= Phn*dS E. (21) S UO
*H+*H- N S x 9 =t ttt td E div dB* G , and this leads to the primary correlation pres ented without a conclu onograph of G.V. Ni- kolaev [5-6]: sion in the m E divB t*G
=. (22) Let's formulate the prototype law of electr omagnetic induction in the differential form: a point of space in which the non-stationary scalar magnetic field Consequently, one of the equations of generalized electrodynamics looks like: has been created, is a source or a drain of an electric field. tBD div*
'+ =0e e rG , (23) where DG e' - relative dielectric permeability of a medium, r - vector of electric field induction, - electric charge density. As a result of the research carried out above it is possible to wr ite down the full system of the two consti tuents of electric fields (vorti cal and potential). The known system electrodynamic equations that take into account the two constituents of magnetic fields (vortical and potential), as well as the of M axwell's equations does not reflect this symmetry of electr odynamics and consequently is not full. The system of generalized electrodynamics looks as follows [4]: tDj gradH H rot*
+ = +GG G , (24) tBE rot- =GG , (25) tBD div*
'+ =0e e rG , (26) 0=HdivG . It appears from the equation ( 24), that conduction current (27) jG creates both vector and scalar mag- netic field. Generally both these components of th e one mag hift of an induction of vector magnetic field netic field are non-stationary. Due to the VG s , as is known, the vortical elect ric field (25) is formed. The s hift of SMF induction along with electric charges generates sources and drains of a potential elec- tric field (26). Thus, the electric field generally includes potential and vortical components. Therefore when calculating derivative tD G there emerge vortical and potential (scalar) components of a mag- netic field (25). That is displ acement currents, as well as conduc tion currents, generate both compo- nents of a magnetic field: vector and scalar. The equation (27) spec ifies the absence of sources and drains of a vortical magnetic field. It is necessary to take on the Ohm law in the differential form to the equations (24) - (27). Ohm's law should be written down under condition of immovability of medium: E jGGs= , (28) 10where s- of medium, vector EG - the sum of the intensities of both constituents of an electric field: vo rtical and potential. The equations (24) - (28) ar e correct at the following assu 1) all bodies present in an electr omagnetic field amptions: re motionless, sme , ,' ' 2) units are the functions of coordinates and do not depend on time and the of an electromagnetic field. It is not difficult to show, that the equation of indissolubility of g tainenera lized electrodynamics con- s an additional member: 00 = +'+j divB t2*
2tGe er. (29) non-stationary SMF is nece ssarily created, besides Thus in the point which is a source (drain) of an electric current ther e is a variable electric charge; and 022
tB*
. Let' erential equation (29) refer to one point of space. It is important to bear in mind when it is used to- right and left parts refer accordingly to various points of space located extremely close to each other. s note that all the values in the dif- f gether with the basic differential equations of elec trodynamics (24)-(25) in which the variables in the In traditional electrodynamics, as is known, Lorenz antecedent is used: 00 0='+tA divphee m mG , (30) whereph - scalar potential. It is introdu ced artificially and a physical mean ing is not given to it. If we write down: ()tA div t , z , y , x H*
-'- =' ' 'pheem m01G , (31) 0 then we get up its real existence. Let'an opportunity to take into account a scalar component of the magnetic fi eld and to check s note that in a stationa ry situation for vacuum (31) coincides with (8). It is not difficult to sh ow with the help of the equation (25) , that in expressing full intensity of an elect ric field by means of full electrodyn amic and scalar potentials re- ain correct: generalized electrodynamics m ph gradAE-- =tGG . (32) Having substituted expressions (12) and (31) in (2 4) with the account of (32) we shall receive:
t t +'- ='-'-'OAgrad jtgrad A graddiv A rotrotGG G ph e ephe em m m m0 0 01. 1 0 We come to Dalamber equation for full vector potential: jtAAGGG 0 22 0 0 m m m m e e '- =' '- D . (33) eceive the wave equation for scalar potential: Similarly having transformed the equation (26) we shall r 022 0 0e er phe e m m ph'- =' '- Dt. (34) 11Consequently the process of radiation of elect romagnetic waves in generalized electrodynamics, as well as in traditional one, is described by the two wave equation tor and scalar potentials. But in contrast to the known limited theory these equations describe occur- ences written down accordingly for vec- r of an electromagnetic field at the account of a conduction current. The field consists of two magnetic components (vortical and potential), and also two electri c components (vor tical and poten- tial). That is there is observed a certain symmetry between magnetic and electric fields that form one electromagnetic field. It is possible to tell that AG and ph form one four-dimensional vector - poten- tial, whose properties describe all macroscopic electrodynamic phenomena. At this phase of investigation it becomes clear that the use of antecedent (2) in magnetostatics and Lorenz antecedent (30) in electrodynamics as res lted in restriction of the theory and exclu- sion from the consideration of the potential magn etic component, and, cons equently, all phenomena connected to it. h u We shall receive the wave equations for an electromagnetic field w ith sources on the basis of the equations (24)-(27). Having applied operator t to the equation (24), taking into account (24) and (25), after transfo rmations we have: r m e e m m gradj EE0 22 0 01+ ' '- De emt t0''=G GG . (35) As the potential electric field is gene rated by electric charges, and the vortical fiel d is connected to the locked-in electric currents, it is possible to split (35) into two independent equations: re ee e m m gradtEE 02 0 01 '=' '- D- -G2 G , (36) tj tEE'=' '- DO OG GG 0 22 0 0 m m e e m m . (37) Having calculated a time derivative from the equati on (25) with provision for (24) we shall re- ceive the wave equation for vector HG : j rottHHGG G 2 Similarly, having transformed (26) with provision for (24) we shall receive th e wave equation for sca- lar function - =' '- D2 0 0m m e e . (38)
*H: j divt tHH*
*G+=' '- Dm m e e2 0 0 . (39) r2 That is, if in some point of the medium there is a shift of an electric charge, this medium is a source or a drain of an electric field (current) whic h of the environment. Let's note that in the given wave equation the va lues on the right part and at the eft pa generates SMF in adjacent points l rt refer to various points of space; therefore if we use the gene ralized equation of continuity (29), we receive from (39): ()() () 22 0 22 0 0tt , z , y , x V tt , z , y , x Ht , z , y , x H* *
*
'- =' ' ' ' '-' ' ' D e e m m e e . (40) The second mem ber of the left part is not compensated by the right member, as the functions contained in them refer to various points of space. From ( 40) it follows: non-sta tionary SMF created in some point of the electroconduc tive medium with coordinates z , y ,x generates in sa me point sources 12(drain aves tors s) of an electric current which results in the occurrence of non-stationary SMF in the neighboring point of space () z , y , x' ' '. Consequently, in the general case two electromagnetic w are formed: one of them is de- termined by voG And rtical vec OE HG , and another - by potential vector -EG and scalar func-
*tion H. The first type of waves is known in electr odynamics for a long time, their properties are well researched. In particular it is s own, tha far apart from the source of radiation lane wave) vectors OEG and h t (p HG are arranged perpendicularly to the directi on of electromagnetic wa v ropagation; there- fore these waves are referred to as transversal. The second type of waves is scarcely investigated, though there are a lot of publications about longitudi nal electromagnetic waves. The term longitudinal troma etic waves in classi cal electrodynamics stands for some component of a non-plane wave determined by vortical vectors OEG and e p elec gn HG . Longitudinal constituents of usual electromagnetic waves are formed, for example, when it is propagated through conducting guides. This phenomenon does not exceed the limits of traditional electrodynamics. In originating generalized electrodynamics there is also the need to use the term ' longitudinal electromagnetic waves' to define the second type of waves, however its meaning differs from the concept used in the traditional theory. It is suggested to deter- mine as 'longitudinal electromagnetic waves' the waves formed as a result of the shift of potential vector -EG and scalar intensity *H, and extending in the direction of vector -EG (E-waves). Let's note that the speeds of spreading transv ersal and longitudinal el ectromagnetic waves are identical: 0 0 01 c m e m m e e' '=' '= =V V|| , 0 01 m e=c where - velocity of light in vacuum. Here lies indissoluble connection of all the constitu- ents of the electromagnetic process and impossibil ity of their complete positional separation in the gitudinal E -wave, and vice versa. The theory of longitudinal elec tromagnetic waves demands sepa rate consideration. Here we only, that it is well coo [5-6] with two- planimetric aerials, one of which serves as oscillator, eiver of longitudinal case. Moreover, it is possibl e to show that a transversal electromagnetic wave derivates a lon- 4. Discussion of the results rdinated to known experiments of Nikolaev G.V. another - as the recshall note etic waves. This theory also explains the results of very exciting experiments described by C. Monstein and J. P. Wesley [10]. Their first experiment shows the transfer of energy at th e account of longitudinal waves between the plates of the condenser which have been moved apart farthe r than the length of the wave . In addition the filter absorbing transversal wave s is installed between the plates. In the second experiment there were used the s pherical aerials installed from 10 to 1000 mm apart. Variable electric charge being created on the radiating aerial, the reception aerial registered a signal fading proportion- ally as the square of distance from the source of radiation. Such dependence is explained by the fol- lowing: a non-directional radiating aerial was used. C. Monstein and J. P. Wesley do not use the con- cept of SMF and do not aim at going beyond classical electrodynamics, therefore their approach to a problem turned out unilateral: their explanation is based only on Poisson equation for scalar electric potential and they investigate only the shift of potential vector -EG . Nevertheless, C. Monstein and J. P. Wesley's experiments are extremely important for understanding of the re searched phenomenon, as 13they show the limitation of the received view of the electromagnetic field and allow us to make a link to generalized electrodynamics. A rather detailed analysis of the given problem is made by Enshin A.V. and Iliodorov V.A. [11- 12]. The authors experimentally established ...that , when the paramagnetic gas medium is exposed to laser radiation with special spectral structure, there occurs the polarization of spins of molecules or at- oms contained. Under the resonant influence of pondemotor forces of laser radiation there occurs the formation of quazicrystal spin-polarized structure w ith clear-cut ferromagnetic properties. That is in spin-polarized medium the appearan ce of macroscopical quant um effects is possible. In spin-polarized structure of paramagnetic gas take s place the transformation of laser radiation to longitudinal waves (research was carried out with the mo lecular gases with not compensated electronic or nuclear spin and some other substan ces). That is the waves where vector of an electric field coincides with the direction of a wave vector. Such tran sformation becomes possible because the radiation is accomplished not by separate electrons that really can radiate only transversal electromagnetic waves, but the aggregate of external electrons combined by exchange interaction a nd behaving as a quantum liquid. Longitudinal electromagnetic waves generated by spin-polarized structure have much higher orientation and coherence than the initial laser radi ation. And we mean higher not by percent or times, but exponents. The section of absorption of longitudina l radiation is also much less than transversal. As Enshin A.V. and Iliodorov V.A investigate the quantum phenomena in their works it's nota- ble that the problem of longitudina l electromagnetic waves for the firs t time arose in quantum in the 30-s of the last century, since th e 4-dimensional mathematical apparatus demanded their introduction. However, in order to satisfy Ma xwell's theory special ca librating antecedents ex- cluding longitudinal electromagnetic waves were intr oduced, and the longitudinal waves were declared non-physical. Only in the 90-s this problem wa s risen again by Hvorostenko N.P. [13]. Since quan- tum electrodynamics operates with 4-dimensional vectors, vector HG and some scalar function are used for the characteristic of a magnetic fi eld; electric field is characterized by vector EG and an addi- tional scalar function. The last scal ar function is characteristic onl y for quantum interaction (spinory it is not necessary to be introduced when cons idering only macroscopical phenom- ena (conduction currents). Thus, the quantum theory is the most general case of generalized it presents the complete symmetry in the desc ription of an electromagnetic field. On the basis of quantum electrodynamics' apparatus Hvorostenko N.P . has shown that three are three possible modes of electromagnetic waves: one transversal and two longitudinal ( E -waves and N -waves). Four differential wave e quations are received by Hvorostenko N.P: two of them are vector equa- tions, two more - scalar. Three of these equations (taking into consid eration difference in designations witho ut the account of the quantum phenomena) coincide with the equations (35) received by us, (38) and (39). The fourth equation is sp ecific to quantum electrodynamics and we haven't considered it. Hvorostenko N.P. erroneously applied the usual equation of continuity (without an additional member) to (39), thus the right part of the equation (39) resulted in ze ro, and the author drew a conclu- sion o n the absence of material sources stimulating longitudinal E -waves and declared them non- physical. The inaccuracy of this co nclusion deprived all the further E-waves research of a theoretical basis; as a result, they have not been acknowledged by the offi cial science until no w, despite the ex- perimental facts confirming their real existence. The longitudinal H-waves are acknowledged by the quantum theory, they are created by spin-magnetic axial currents. The results of research of Enshin A.V. and I liodorov V.A. are apparently explained on the basis of a complex of the phenomena of all the three types of electromagnetic waves. Transversal laser ra- diatio n results in establishing in the substance of el ectronic quantum structures of toroidal type with a certain orientation of their axes. These structures, as we showed, are capable of generating longitudinal E-waves. At the quantum level the formation of H-waves is possible, they are compensated on mac- rolevel. 5. Conclusion Rel ying on the results of the above mentioned pub lications and our research, it is possible to raw the conclusion that all three types of electr omagnetic waves are physica lly real, moreover in the d 14most general case all of them are interconne ch other forming one electromagnetic proce . Tamm I. E. The Fundamentals of the Theory of Electricity. - Moscow, <<Nauka>>, p. 1976.- 616 (published in Russian) . Edward M. Purcell. Electricity and magne tism. Berkeley Physics cource, volume 2. tional symposium on el ectromagnetic compatibility and electromagnetic cted, derivate ea ss. Theoretical and expe rimental study of properties of longitudinal electromagnetic E -waves will allow us to understand the essence of the electromagnetic phenomena deeper and to substantially expand the area of their practical use. Generalized electrodynamics (the macr oscopical theory) which was developed with the account of all the properties of 4-dimensional electrodyna mic potential is ca- pable to explain numerous paradoxes of modern elect rodynamics and to take a new look at the fun- damental concepts of physics. References: 1 2 3. Tomilin A.K. The analysis of problems of elect rodynamics and possible ways of their decision // Works of 7-th Interna ecology. St.-Petersburg, June, 26-29, 2007. p. 214-217. (published in Russian) 4. Tomilin A.K. Nikolayev G.V. Consistent electrodynamics. Theories, experiments, paradoxes. Tomsk, 1997. (published in Russian) 5. icality. / Nikolayev G.V. - 7. Way of Trut h. Part IY, EST-OVEST, Austria. 9. /9087.html 6. Nikolayev G.V. Modern electrodynamics and the r easons of its paradox Tomsk: Tverdynya, p. 2003.- 149. (published in Russian) Marinov S. The Thorny 8. Marinov S. Divine East-West. Austria. Tomilin A.K. (2002). rties of paramagnetic gases. Patent No. ion of biharmonic d in Russian) 10. C. Monstein i J. P. Wesley. Euro physics Letters, 59 (4), pp. 514-520 11. Yenshin A.V., Iliodorov V.A. Way of change of prope 2094775 from 27.10.97 (published in Russian) 12. Yenshin A.V., Iliodorov V.A. Generation of longit udinal light waves at di spers laser radiation on magnon and rotary polaritones in the atmosphere. (in the collection Horizons of a science of the 21 centur y , 2002. (publishe 13. Khvorostenko N.P. Longitudinal electromagnetic waves//News of high schools. Physics. - No. 3, 1992.- p.24-29. (published in Russian) 15
|
0807.2172
|
Alexander Tomilin K.
|
A. K. Tomilin
|
The Fundamentals of Generalized Electrodynamics
|
15 pages, 8 figures
| null | null | null |
physics.gen-ph physics.class-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The article presents an alternative approach to the definition of vector
electrodynamic potential and its properties. It is shown that generally it has
vortical and potential components. The system of differential equations of
generalized electrodynamics (the macroscopical theory) is written down; and on
the basis of these equations the mechanism of occurrence of the electromagnetic
waves spreading in the direction of vector (longitudinal E-waves) is explained.
It is demonstrated that the new macroscopical theory is in accordance with
quantum electrodynamics. The author investigates the issue of physical
pithiness of longitudinal electromagnetic E-waves and specifies the references
to the experimental researches confirming the new theory.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 14:43:31 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 27 Aug 2008 13:30:37 GMT"
}
] | 2009-09-29T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Tomilin",
"A. K.",
""
]
] |
model famous in 1974, when they showed that this system possesses equilibrium states which appear to possess magnetic charge. Here I will mainly use the notation of Hasenfratz and 'tHooft[3] in describing the system. Unfortunately, I cannot provide a decisive answer to this question at the present time. I hope that true experts in real analysis will be able to follow up. Section 2 will discuss the importance of the question to mathematics and dynamical systems. Section 3 will discuss th e importance to physics, and the possible path to the larger goal of proving existen ce for a physically plausible model. Section 4 will discuss what I can say about the questi on itself, and various subquestions which cry out for further investigation. Finally, the appe ndix will specify a new family of numerical methods which may be used in these studies , or on a broader class of 1-D problems. 2. Mathematical Importance of the Question Do stable solitons exist for any system of partial differential equations defined by a Lagrangian L(ph (xm), tph(xm), ph(xm)), where ph is a set of n continuous functions or fields over Rn, functions of points x m in Minkowski space? This is a very fundamental question, for which the answer is not yet known. Note that ph here is a vector in the mathematical sense, not necessarily a covariant vector in the sense of rela tivity; in effect, it is shorthand for a bunch of stuff, which could be a combin ation of scalars, vectors, tensors, and spinors, etc., but not unitary matrices U( x), because the components of U( x) are not free to vary over all of Rn. If we can prove that the tP model, or a slight modification of it, possesses stable solitons, then we can answer the question a bove as yes. It would be a case of proof by example. The most complete discussion of th is question to date is in the book by Makhankov, Rybakov and Sanyuk (MRS)[4]. MRS provide stability arguments for the Skyrme model, which relies on unitary matrices U( x). Theories which allow the field components to range over all of Rn are what they call topologically trivial. They propose a Generalized Hobart-Derrick Theore m, which asserts that stable solitons cannot possibly exist in such theories. If Bogomolnyi's arguments could be translated into a rigorous proof of stabilit y, this would disprove the claim of MRS, or at least force a restatement of the claim; however , this has not yet been done. Before trying to prove that stable solit ons exist in this dynamical system, we need to define what we mean by a stable soliton. Unfortunately, the word soliton has been used to refer to different things in physics and mathematics. In this paper, I will use the word soliton to refer an e quilibrium state which meets th e requirements to be chaotic soliton or chaoiton as de fined in a previous paper [5]. This basically means that the equilibrium state is stable with respect to sm all perturbations, except that they may move the state a small distance or even impart some velocity or angular momentum to it. For a state of positive energy, in a theory with posi tive definite energy near the vacuum state, it is enough that the state be a local mini mum of energy , over all possible small perturbations. The well-known Hobart-Derrick Theorem (discussed by MRS [5]) implies that solitons are impossible in any quasilinear PDE system over Minkowski space. It is proven very simply[5] by considering perturbations in which ph(x) is replaced by ph(lx), 2where l is close to one. It is encouraging that this argument does not go through directly for the tP model. 3. Importance of the Question for Physics The problem statement by Jaffe and Witten[6] for the Clay Mathematics Institute states: ...one does not yet have a mathematically co mplete example of a quantum gauge theory in four-dimensional theory in four-dim ensional space-time, for even a precise definition... Existence theorems that put QFTs on a solid mathematical footing are needed ..it is a great challenge for mathema ticians to understand the physical principles that have been so important and productive throughout the twentieth century. The most recent evaluation of the status of th is challenge from the Clay Institute [7] states: Perhaps the most basic mathematical question here is to specify a class of initial conditions for which we can guarantee existence and uniqueness of solutions. These challenges in turn are basically just a steppingstone to the larger cha llenge of finding a physically plausible quantum field theory for which one ca n guarantee existence of solutions. Since no one has met any of these challeng es as yet, there is no proven strategy for meeting them. Here I woul d like to suggest the following plausible multi-stage strategy: (1) First prove soliton stability (soliton ex istence) for the tP model, or a slightly modified version of it - as discus sed in section 4 and the Appendix. (2) Use the insights from this stability proof to deduce bounds on the fields in this system - in effect, to understand why it doe s not blow up into discontinuous states; (3) Based on these bounds, prove the existe nce of solutions for the classical PDE, using the same general approach which has worked for the Yang-Mills system by itself [8]; (4) Use the generalized P mapping of coherence theory[9-11] to map the energy density of the tP model into the equivalent no rmal form Hamiltonian H. This is possible, because Qa and Ama are both bosonic fields. Within Fock-Hilbert space, use the P-mapped version of the classical distance metric instead of the usual L2 metric. (This avoids the difficulties which come when a soliton plus a photon of epsilon energy are treated as something very far away from the soliton.) Exploit the results from (3) and the P equivalence relations to prove existence of solutions for the many worlds dynamical system: Ps =iHps& ( 4 ) for this choice of H. (5) Having met a key part of the Clay chal lenge, then move on to a more realistic model, perhaps by replacing A ma by the vector bosons of electroweak theories, as previously proposed[12], or perhaps by introducing a s econd topology term to fix electric charge, or both. Of course, with a multi-stage strategy, we would always want to be ready to make midcourse corrections as we learn more at each stage. A few additional comments are in order for stages 4 and 5, even though they are not the main topic of this paper. With regard to stage 4 - there are ma ny possible forms of quantum field theory, none of which have met the Clay challenge as yet. I am proposing that we try for a many-worlds theory, in part because it allows the use of strategy proposed here, and in part 3because many worlds theories do better so fa r in confronting empirical reality in the world of engineering based on quantum Appendix B gives some thoughts about how to make the connection from the classical fields to the quantum fields - but the initial challenge here is how to better establish th e properties of the classical field theories themselves. With regard to stage 5, the goal is ba sically to derive a bosonic standard model[14,15]. It is important to remember that the ultimate field equations need not include separate components for each possible ty pe of particle. With a relatively few truly stable solitons, it is possible to have bound st ates (like hadrons) a nd even bound states of bound states, and very complex and esoteric em ergent behavior. But before we can settle on the right theory, we need a wider class of theories to choose from, and before that we need to have at least one example. It is also important to remember that th ere is no requirement in mathematics that a valid dynamical system must be renormalizable . In fact, it is even possible to be finite without being renormalizab le! It is well-known[16] that the masses predicted by the Feynman path quantization of the tP model are in fact finite, to a ll orders of quantum correction; infinite mass corrections thr ough renormalization are not needed. Methods like WKB can work even in cases where the usual perturbation about the vacuum state do not [16]; it is an act of incredible hubris to assume that nature can only possibly be governed by dynamics which fit with the firs t approximation scheme we happen to try on it. Furthermore, the usual sorts of variati onal (energy minimization) methods used in atomic and molecular physics, to calculate energy levels, could also be applied to the prediction of the masses of the hadrons, an important empirical issue where well-defined quantum field theory has not yet been able to do as well as phenomenological models[12], as in the work of Paolo Pa lazzi and of MacGregor. After one has a bosonic standard model, it should be possible again to exploit equivalence, and directly use the metrificati on procedure given by Carmelli[17] in order to unify that mo del with general relativity. 4. Reassessing Stability of Solitons in the tP Dynamical System 4.1 Summary of Bogomol'nyi's Analysis Bogomol'nyi's classic paper[18] is the primary source for what is known about the stability of magnetic monopole solutions in th e tP system. (Relevant work by Striet and Bais[19,20] and Affouf[21] will be discussed in section 4.2.) Bogomol'nyi discusses the issue of stability for equilibrium states for which A 0a=0 in the tP system. He defines stability as being a state of minimum energy (not necessarily a unique minimum) considering only the energies of other states of the same total magnetic charge. For any equilibrium state with A 0a=0 everywhere, he states that the total energy equals: 4
+
+ - = ) (8 2) (412 3Q VQ D GQ D G x d Ea pa mnmnp a p mnpa mnl ee (5), where I have introduced the function V(Q) to represent the usual Higgs term in the model. Equation 5 corresponds to Bogomol'nyi's equation 5.3. His version of the Higgs term varies somewhat from equation to equati on in his paper, but does not affect his arguments. Going back to 'tHooft[3], I will assume: 2 2 2) ( ) (F Q Q V- = ( 6 ) He then deduces that the integral of the term in square brackets is actually constant for all field states which have th e same magnetic charge; thus it is enough to show that we can find a global minimum for
+ - = ) (8) (41'2 3Q V Q D G x d Ea p mnpa mnle ( 7 ) over states of the desired magnetic charge. He then argues that we can find solutions of the desired magnetic charge which obey: a p mnpa mn Q D Ge= ( 8 ) Equation 8 is so important that it deserves a name; I will call it the adiabatic potential equation. Bogolmonyi then shows how we may find solutions of the adiabatic potential equation by inserting a normalized version of 'tHooft's ansatz [3]: ) (r Q r Qaa= ( 9 ) ) (r W r Al iala ie= ( 1 0 ) 00=aA ( 1 1 ) which leads to a set of coupled ordinary differential equations. In the limit as l goes to zero, he argues that this sets equation 7 to zero. Since equation 7 is nonnegative, a value of E' of zero must be a global minimum, and therefore a stable state of the system in three dimensions. 4.2 Reassessment of the Analysis If the argument in section 4.1 could be elevated to being a theorem, it would be enough by itself to fulfill the goal of this paper (goal number 1 in the list in section 3). But is it possible? Most of the steps should be easy enough to formalize. For solutions where Q has interesting topology (magnetic charge) in the limit as r -, it is necessary to prove that small perturbations cannot change that ma gnetic charge. This seems straightforward enough. 5 As a pedestrian exercise, I have gone ahead and inserted e quations 9 through 11 myself into equation 9, and ve rified that it does yield two coupled equations similar to (and presumably equivalent to) Bogmol'nyi's, if I exploit the identity: - = - ll mnl a mna l mal ln ll nal m r r r r r re e e e ( 1 2 ) Existence of smooth solutions to the two coupled equations (first order ODE) should be easy enough to prove. (At any point in space x, the three-dimension vector of r a (as a=1,2,3) is just the vector x/r = x/|x|.) But then comes the problem. Because we can set the first term in E' to zero (its global minimum), Bogomolnyi asserts that this constitutes a global minimum in the limit as l goes to zero. That is as far as the argumen t goes. Others have cited this argument in the limit as a reason to believe that we always have stability in this system. Furthermore, it is well known in ma thematics that a system can ha ve bounded, well-defined behavior for any value of a parameter l>0, but radically different behavior when l actually equals zero; things may ofte n go to infinity as l goes to zero. Here, wher e the very existence of the soliton depends on the strength of the Higgs term, we should actually expect a qualitative change in be havior in the case where l=0. Thus there is strong reason to reconsider the analysis. For the case where l>0, let us look again a second time at the adia batic potential equation, equation 8. For the case of solutions which obey the 'tHooft ansatz, we do not have much freedom in solving this equation. But in the general case, in three dimensions, even if Q a obeys equation 9, would it be possi ble to find values of the fields A ma which solve equation 8 for any choice of Q(r) whic h meets the boundary conditions (and a few reasonable smoothness conditions)? St arting from field values at all points at some radius r, equation 8 would appear to be a well-pos ed system for finding field values for A ma at larger radii r which can accommodate Q(r), even though these field values would not fit equation 10. More precisely, if we substitute the definitions from equations 2 and 3 into equation 8, and (like Bogomolnyi) consider only solutions where A i0=0, then the adiabatic potential equation becomes: ( )c b p abca p mnpc nb m abca m na n m Q A e Q A A e A A e e e + = + - (13) Formally, this is a system of 27 equations (f or all choices of m, n and a from 1,2,3); however, for any choice of a, th ere are really only three equa tions present, because when m=n the equation is always true, and because an interchange of m and n yields equivalent equations. In summary, we have a system of only nine equations; it should be possible to develop a path for the nine variables A na to satisfy these nine equations, for any smooth enough source function Qa(r). Let us define the adiabatic potential hypothesis as the hypothesis that this is indeed the case. If the adiabatic potent ial hypothesis is true , then for l>0 the Bogomol'nyi solution is not a solution of minimum energy (since V Q>0). It that case, there exists a family of states which goes to E'=0 in a limit of the family, but the limit of the family is not a smooth solution. To define that family, we attach Qa to its asymptotic limit, where V(Q)=0, for all points r outside some small radius r 0>0, while still keeping Qa(0)=0 for 6r<r0. As we make r 0 closer and closer to 0, we bring E' closer and closer to its true global minimum. The problem is that the limit of th is series is not a smooth function, but a singular function. This proves th at equation 5 and equation 7 do not in fact have a global minimum within the (open) set of smooth, differentiable functions, if l>0 and if equation 8 has these more general solutions. In summary, it is not at all clear as yet whether a stable solution really does exist for the tP system for the case where l>0. A recent careful study[19,20] of Alice Electrodynamics (a close relative of and of string theory) has shown nu merically that the usual radially symmetric soliton solutions are in fact uns table. They argue, on intuitive grounds, that lower energy solutions with a more comple x topology may be stable; however, based on the argument above, that is not at all obvious, at least for the 'tH ooft-Polyakov model and its relatives. Their main finding is that the usual solutions are unstable with respect to perturbations which are not within the usual ansatz (equations 9-11) . Good numerical solutions are indeed an im portant tool in proving instability of a proposed soliton state. Fortunately, there probably is an easy fix here, if this pr oblem turns out to be real. It may not be esthetically appealing to t hose who insist that the universe must be completely beautiful, but it does appear to work. We can simply modify the Lagrangian of the 'tHooft-Polyakov mode l by adding a small term - e(mQa)2, which changes the energy to
+
+ - = ), ( '8 2) (412 3Q VQ D GQ D G x d Ea pa mnmnp a p mnpa mnl ee (14a) where: (14b) 2) ( ) ( ) ( 'Q Q V Q V + =e If eis extremely small, this could have vanishingly small large-scale observable consequences. But when we minimize V', instead of minimizing V, the e term makes this minimization task equivalent to the fa miliar task of solving the simple Schrodinger equation of elementary quantum mechanics, for a spherically symmetric potential. Bogmol'nyi's arguments would still go thr ough, except that my extension of those arguments results in a smooth minimi zer of energy. In the limit as e-0, this approaches the singular soliton of th e 'tHooft-Polyakov model proper, but for any e>0 it is still finite. Of course, this procedure could be a pplied to other models in the same family, such as those discussed in section 3. In the end, taking the limit as e-0 may lead us to something very similar to the usual standard model in its behavior. Yet it would have the exciting property of concentrating charge in an extremely sma ll region of space, without requiring a huge negative energy in that region to cancel out the positive energy in the electromagnetic field outside of that region. This co uld be seen as just another way to do regularization. But in this case, each value of e>0 is in itself a finite theory, for which we can probably prove rigorous existence theore ms. It is a major step towards the larger goal of getting back to reality. 7 4.3. Some additional comments on stability To prove stability against all small perturbations, we need to consider perturbations which may not be spherically symmetric. But the change in energy, d2E or d2H (discussed at length in previous papers[4,22]), obeys something very similar to the Schrodinger equation of elementary quantum mechanics, in which the static field values determine the potential well for the pertur bation. When the energy operator is simple enough, there is a separation of coordinates, exactly like what we see in atomic physics; thus the lowest energy perturbations are in fact radially symmetric, and it is enough to consider stability against perturbations which are radially symmetric. The problem here is that we do know of a nontrivial perturbation which will always have zero energy. Consider a small translation of the soliton in 3-D space! This corresponds to perturbati on of the form f sin th, which is not radially symmetric; it is part of the first spherical harmonic space of functions. Because of this mode, we can automatically deduce that any field theory which obeys such a simple separation of coordinates must posses perturbations of negative energy, and therefore not allow stable solitons. (Or at least not spherically symmetric ones.) Intuitively, the obvious way to overcome this obstacle is to couple spin with isospin, such that the separati on of coordinates results in let ting us continue to work in the Q a(r) ansatz. That's essentially what the gaug e invariant part of the tP model buys us, and why this works. The comments in this subsection do not override the analysis of section 4.2. Rather, they are intended to provide some in tuitive explanation of why it works, and to suggest the possibility of mo re general mathematical resu lts in future research. Rajaraman [16] has cited important papers whic h provide additional ideas for how to consider solutions and issues beyond the usual sphericall y symmetric case. If the adiabatic potent ial hypothesis is true, then of course the e term in equation 14 plays an essential role in establishing the bounds which make it possible to prove the existence of solutions. If not, then we still do not know whether the known solutions to the original tP model (with l>0) are stable or not. Numerical work can also be of value in helping us to find out. References 1. G. tHooft. Magnetic monopoles in unified gauge theories. Nucl. Phys. , B79:276-284, 1974. 2. A.M. Polyakov. Particle spectrum in quantum field theory. JETP Lett., 20:194-194, 1974. 3. P. Hasenfratz & G. 't Hooft, Fermion-boson puzzle in a gauge theory, Phys Rev Lett , Vol. 36, p. 1119-1122 (10 May, 1976) 4. V.G.Makhankov, Yu.P.Rybakov and V.I.Sanyuk, The Skyrme Model , Springer-Verlag, 1994. 8 5. P.Werbos, Chaotic solitons in cons ervative systems: can they exist?, Chaos, Solitons and Fractals , Vol. 3, No.3, p.321-326,1993. 6. Jaffe and E. Witten , Quantum Yang-Mills Theory, in The Millennium Prize Problems, J. Carlson, A. Jaffe, and A. Wiles, Editors, pages 129--152, American Mathematical Society, Providence, 2006 7. Michael R. Douglas, Report on the Stat us of the Yang-Mills Millennium Prize Problem, April 2004, 8. Walter A. Strauss, Nonlinear Wave Equations , CBMS Regional Conference Series in Mathematics Number 73, American Mathematical Society, 1989 9. K.E. Cahill and R.J. Glauber, Ordered expansions in boson amplitude operators, Phys. Rev. Vol. 177 p. 1857 (1969) 10. L. Mandel and E. Wolf, Optical Coherence and Quantum Optics. Cambridge U. Press (1995), chapter 11. 11. P. Werbos, Classical ODE and PDE Which Obey Quantum Dynamics, Int'l J. Bifurcation and Chaos , Vol. 12, No. 10 (October 2002), p. 2031-2049. Slightly updated as quant-ph 0309031. 12. P. Werbos, Schwinger's magnetic model of ma tter - can it help us with grand unification , revised January 2008, arXiv:0707.2520 13. P. Werbos, Bell's Theorem, Many Worlds and Backwards-Time Physics: Not Just a Matter of Interpretation, Int'l J Theoretical Physics , April 2, 2008 (epub date), arXiv: 0801.1234. 14. Tanmay Vachaspati, On a dual standard model. Hep-ph 0204106. 15 Levon Pogosian, Daniele A. Steer, Tanm ay Vachaspati, Trip lication of SU(5) monopoles . Phys.Rev.Lett . 90 (2003) 061801 16 R. Rajaraman, Solitons and Instantons: An Introducti on to Solitons and Instantons in Quantum Field Theory. Elsevier, 2 nd edition, 1989. 17. M. Carmelli, Classical Fields: General Relativity and Gauge Theory . Wiley (1982), section 3.3 18 E.B. Bogomolnyi, The stability of classical solutions. Sov. J. Nucl. Phys. , Vol. 24, No. 4, October 1976, p. 449-454 9 19. F.A. Bais and J. Striet. On a core in stability of 'tHooft Polyakov type monopoles. Phys. Lett. , B540:319-323, 2002. 20. J. Striet and F.A.Bais, More on core in stabilities of magnetic monopoles. arXiv: June 2003. 21. M. Affouf, Numerical sc heme of magnetic monopoles. Proc. WSEAS Int'l Conf. on Applied Mathematics, Dallas, Texas, 2007. 22 . P.Werbos, New Approaches to Soliton Quantization and Existence for Particle Physics, 23. B. Julia and A. Zee, Phys. Rev. D 11, 2227 (1975) 24. Tai Tsun Wu and Chen Ni ng Yang, Some solutions of the classical isotopic gauge field equations. In Properties of Matter Under Unusual Conditions, H. Mark and S Fernbach eds., Wiley Interscience 1968. 25. M.K. Prasad and C.H. Sommerfeld, Phys. Rev. Lett ., 35, p.760, 1975. 26. M.H. MacGregor, A Muon Mass Tree with a-quantized Lepton, Quak and Hadron Masses . arXiv: hep-ph/0607233 27. Malcolm H. MacGregor, Power of a: Electron Elementary Particle Generation With a-quantized Lifetimes and... , World Scientific, 2007 28. Paolo Palazzi, Particles and Shell. arXi v: physics/0301074. Appendix A. Numerical Approac hes to Testing Stability One way to follow up on the analysis of this pa per is to do some numerical experiments. Of course, it is much easier to do numeri cal experiments on fields which vary as a function of one spatial coordina te, r, than functions which vary as a function of r and z (as in Striet and Bais [19,20]) or as a function of x 1, x2, and x 3. The initial work by 'tHooft, Polyakov and Bogomol'nyi all focused on partic ular static solutions. More precisely, 'tHooft[3] proposed an ansatz, a particular family of possible solutions for Qa and Aa m based on functions Q(r) and W(r), shown in equations 9-11. Julia and Zee[23] performed numerical experiments based on a more generalized ansatz using three functions H(r), J(r) and K(r), based on earlier work[24] by Wu and Yang (whose collaborations with Mills and Lee are very well-known). In the notati on used by Prasad and Ju, this ansatz is: 2)) ( 1 ( err K xAj aij a i-=e ( 1 5 ) a axerr JA2 0) (= ( 1 6 ) 10a a axerr HQ2) () (= =ph ( 1 7 ) Note that xa refers to the a-th c oordinate of the vector x, and that equation 17 is telling us the proposed value of Qa(x), which is 'tHooft's notation for what Julia and Zee would call pha(x). Thus one way to follow up on the analysis above is to use the H/J/K ansatz to construct solutions to the tP model, and then test them to see whether they truly are local minima with respect to small perturbations of the functions H, J and K. If they are not, this by itself would prove that they are not stable. If they are truly local minima with respect to these perturbations, it would not prove stability, but it w ould at least open the door to that possibility. It would be a first st ep towards a test of stability against more general perturbations. The first step in doing that work is to construct solu tions to H(r), J(r) and K(r) numerically. Following the elegant pres entation of Prasad and Sommerfeld[25], this means finding values of these functions which minimize:
+ --'+ +-'- --+' =
02 24 2 2 22 22 2 22 22 2 22 2 2 24 2 2) ( 2) ( 2) 1 ( 4 r eH H rH H r rK H rJ J r rK J rKK dreEl m p ( 1 8 ) For my proposed modified model, we would add the following term to the integrand: 2 21
-''+r rHe ( 1 9 ) Following Julia and Zee, we may substitute b2=e2/l and assume m=1; thus the solutions here depend only on the choice of b (and on e') and on the boundary conditions. Like Julia and Zee, we may use the boundary conditions: ( 2 0 ) 0 1 ) 0 ( ) 0 ( ) 0 (= - = = K H J But we still face several ques tions before we begin here: (1) What should we use as boundary conditions for the side where r -? (2) How do we cope with a need for wide ly varying step sizes , particularly with the modified model (and low-energy states of the unmodified model) where we need much more detail in a small region near the origin, and with the requirement[12] that (3) How do we make sure of reasonable numerical accuracy? (4) How do we get accuracy both in the function values and in their derivatives, so that we can get a reasonable approximation to the Hessian for use in analysis of the stability of the solutions? For the boundary condition on H, a comparison of Prasad and Sommerfeld [25] with Hasenfratz and 'tHooft[3] shows that they are both calling for: Frr H-) ( as r-, ( 2 1 ) 11where we may take H( ) and F both as positive without loss of generali ty. A careful analysis of Julia and Zee[24] shows that we may use: as r- ( 2 2 ) 0 ) (-r K as r- ( 2 3 ) b r J-) ( where b is any constant we may choose, re presenting the charge of the solution. For monopole solutions, we may simply pick b=0. (J ulia and Zee also allow for a term Mr, where M represents the voltage A 0 of the vacuum field at r= ; we may treat it as zero, without loss of ge nerality.) To address the second question, we may build a numerical procedure or subroutine which inputs an enti re array of user-specified stepsizes deltar(1:N), where N+1 is the number of grid points that we want to represent explicitly. For algebraic convenience, we may denote deltar(k) as Drk. Thus on each iteration, the numerical routine could update its estimates of H(r k), J(r k), K(r k), H'(r k), J'(r k) and K'(r k) for all k from 0 to N, where : 0 ( 2 4 ) 0=r for k = 1 to N (25) k k k r r rD + =-1 However , for the sake of numerical accuracy near zero and near infinity, it is better to use a slightly different representation of the functions in the computer, still using the same ansatz. For all choices of k below some choice k 0 (perhaps N/2 or perhaps based on a subroutine input r 0), we may borrow an idea from Affouf[21], by actually updating the functions h(r), j(r) and k(r) defined by: ( 2 6 ) ) ( ) (r rh r H=
( 2 7 ) ) ( ) (r rj r J=
( 2 8 ) ) ( 1 ) (r rk r K+ =
More precisely, we may update both these functions and their derivatives with respect to r, on each iteration. It is easy enough to s ubstitute equations 26 through 28 (and their r derivatives) into the energy term in equation 18, to see how to do this. Likewise, a modified representation allows greater accuracy for the upper half of the grid. The boundary conditions 21-23 suggest that we should represent the functions H, J and K as h(r), J(r) and K(r) for k >=k0, and represent them as f unctions of (1/r) instead of r. This does not mean altering equations 24 or 25, or the locations of the grid point; however, it would be more convenient to update the derivatives of h, J and K with respect to 1/r, for k>k 0. More important, it affects how we will address question four. For the third question, we may again follow Affouf[21]. Affouf notes that Julia and Zee used a simple explicit forwards integration method from r=0 to r= . Methods of that type are well-know n to have problems with numerical instability. As an alte rnative, Affouf used a kind of Newton's method (using a sparse matrix solver) to minimize this function of the grid estimates. A few details require some explanation. Fi rst, of course, Affouf used a different mapping from grid estimates to an estimate of e 2E/4p; he did not need to consider variable step sizes or the accuracy of deri vatives as such. Second, Affouf proved the stability of his numerical method, but this is not the same as proving stability of the 12soliton itself. Third, Affouf did comment th at prior numerical experiments with the Georgi-Glashow system were less rigorous and reliable numerically. After finding solutions in this way, it is natural to assume that one has performed a minimization, and that the solutions themselves must be stable. However, it is well-known that solutions of the Lagrange-Euler equation may be minima, maxima, or saddle points. A key test is to look more closely at the (large, sparse, block-diagonal) Hessian matrix from the final stage of iteration, and simply run it through a sp arse matrix solver for the lowest eigenvalue and corresponding eigenvector. If that eigenvalue is negative, one may even test the corresponding eigenvector as a perturbation to see that it does in fact reduce the energy of the system. Given a candidate solution, it is possible to test for stability more quickly by simply using dynamic programming along the line from r=0 to r=
. However, because we want to find a reliable solution to start fr om in any case, it should be easy enough to just run the Hessian through an eigenanalysi s; this costs more computer time than dynamic programming, but may reduce the cost in terms of human labor. Finally, for the sake of stability analysis, it is especially important that we seek accuracy both in the function values and in their derivatives with respect to r. In order to achieve this, we may use a cubic spline interpolation to interpolate the functions h, j and k as functions of r between grid points r k-1 and r k, for k<=k0. Likewise, we may use a cubic spline interpolation to interpolate the functions H, J and K as functions of 1/r, for values of r between grid points r k and r k+1 for k>=k0. More precisely, before we do any computational work, we simply substitute these interpolations into equation 18, and work out what the integral equals between grid points r k and r k+1. For the final grid interval, from r N to , we may extrapolate h(r)-h( ), J(r)-J() and K(r) as an exponential decay; note, for example, we only need to know K(r n) and K'(r n) in order to fit a and b in the formula a*exp(-br). We use the Newton's me thod to minimize the sum of the resulting algebraic expressions, over all N+1 grid intervals. For the case where the correction term in equation 19 is added, and where our Newton's method package is truly capable of minimization, the method may be further refined as follows. The values of r k calculated from equations 24 and 25 can be used as initial values for the grid point location. Then on each iteration, r k itself can be included, along with the three function estimates and thre e derivative estimates, as part of what is being estimated and optimized. This should work, because the algebraic expression we are minimizing is the exact integral of (e2/4p)E for the stepwise-cubic function being assumed. When we minimize this w ith respect to the choices of r k, we are simply searching for the function values of mini mum energy, throughout the entire space of piecewise-cubic functions with no more than N pieces. After this kind of initial analysis, a logical next step is to modify equation 18 to account for spherical harmonics, so as to span the entire space of smooth perturbations. We may work out d2E algebraically for equation 5, for the general case, and then insert the usual ansatz only for Qa and Ama, while allowing for more ge neral possibilities for the perturbations. After consideri ng perturbations within the usua l ansatz (as a bove), the next obvious class of perturbations to check would be those of the form: ) ( r Q r Qaad d= ( 2 9 ) 13) ( cosr w r Al iala i th e d = ( 3 0 ) From the discussion above, these are probably the perturbations most likely to expose instabilities here. If the ad iabatic potential hypothesis is true, stable solitons in the modified tP model are likely to spi ral in from the asymptotic boundaries, and require the use of spherical harmonics for an efficient, convergent numerical approximation. As with complex calculations in electronics, it may even be necessary to use adaptive basis functions and neural netw orks, in order to maximize accuracy subject to a constraint on the use of computer time. Appendix B: P transforms and well -posedness of quantum field theory How can mappings 9,10,11 assist us in findi ng out whether specific quantum field theories are well-posed dynamical systems? To begin with, they can play a crucia l role in defining what it means to be a well- posed dynamical system. According to the many-worlds version of quantum field theory13, the state of the universe is defined by a wave function Ps which obeys: Ps =iHps& ( 3 1 ) But what does it mean for this to be a well-posed dynamical system? For technical reasons, it is more conven ient here to express quantum field theory in terms of the usual density matrix r, which leads13 to the usual dynamical equation: []rr ,H i=& ( 3 2 ) We may then ask: when is equati on 32 a well-posed dynamical system. Even with classical PDE, there is no universal definiti on of what it means to be well-posed. However, it often possible to prove that a set of PDE, started out at time 0 with field values in the Sobolev space W k,p, will have unique solutions which remain in this space for all times t. Here, I would propose that we consider the Sobolev spaces PWk,p, which are simply the spaces spanned by the density matrices P({ p,ph}) for field states {p,ph} which are in Wk,p. We may attempt to answer the following question: for various Hamiltonian operators H, and initial values of r in PWk,p, when can we be sure that there will exist a unique solution for r at later times, also within PWk,p? The P mapping only works for bosonic field th eories, like those discussed in this paper. (To address the case of mixed Fermi- Bose quantum field theories, I propose that we represent such theories as a limiting case of bosonic field theories12; for example, as e-0 in section 4.2, the limiting case of the so litons may be particles with their charge concentrated at a point, and with half-integral spin3,12.) It would be interesting enough at this stage in our knowledge to prove well- posedness of equation 32, for bosonic field theories in which the Hamiltonian H is ju st the P-mapped version of the classical Hamiltonian. More precisely, we may quantize the tP model as follows. First, express the classical Lagrangian in the Lorentz gauge, as was done in the initial quantization of 14 decades ago. Next, write out the classical Hamiltonian density H(ph,p,ph) for this system. Third, insert the usual field operators, mapping the multiplication between fields into the normal product of the corresponding field operators. The well-known results on P mappings then tell us that the resulting Hamiltonian operator H has th e property that Tr(H P( ph,p)) equals the classical energy H of the original field state { ph,p}. This equivalence may be of great use in characterizing properties of density matrices r=P(ph,p) by reference to properti es of the corresponding classical fields. Of course, we may th en augment the Hamiltonian by adding the e(mQa)2 term to the Lagrangian, as described in section 4.2, and redoing this. It should be noted that the evolution of the probability distributions for {
ph,p} in forwards time will not in general match equation 32. However, according to the backwards time theory of physics13, this is not the correct way to deduce the probabilities for what we actually observe at the macros copic level. Equilibrium states and even scattering states should in principl e be deduced from the quantum Boltzmann distribution, exp(-kH), which is exactly th e same for the quantized model and for the original classical model, so long as we limit consideration to states in PWk,p and in W k,p, respectively. (For scatteri ng states, we may use the old machinery of considering statistics within a periodic space of vo lume V, and looking for the limit as V -.) If the classical PDE are well-posed, and we deve lop methods to perform the spectral and scattering calculations, we will still have a well-posed model of physics, even if 31 and 32 should not be well-posed.
|
0807.2182
|
Dr. Paul J. Werbos
|
Paul J. Werbos
|
Stability Theory and the Foundations of Physics: A Challenge to Real
Analysis and Numerical Calculation
|
More detail on the gap in Bogomolnyi's stability argument. A new
appendix describes how the existence issue for classical PDE maps into a
formulation of the existence issue for bosonic quantum field theory
| null | null | null |
physics.gen-ph physics.class-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
At present, there exists no physically plausible example of a quantum field
theory for which the existence of solutions has been proven mathematically. The
Clay Mathematics Institute has offered a prize for proving existence for a
class of Yang-Mills theories defined by Jaffe and Witten. This paper proposes a
multi-stage strategy for proving existence for a quantum version of the
"'tHooft Polyakov" (tP) field theory, and argues that this theory, while not
renormalizable or physically plausible as it stands, opens up a clear path to a
physically plausible well-defined theory. The key initial challenge is to first
prove stability for a classical version of this theory, in the spirit of Walter
Strauss. The stability results of Bogomolnyi for classical PDE systems are
widely cited as a foundation of string theory, but they leave key questions
unaddressed, and may even call for small modifications of the tP model itself.
This paper calls attention to the questions which require more attention, and
proposes some partial possible answers. It also specifies a new numerical
method to check for stability for the usual "hedgehog" types of solution, a
method which may have broader potential uses for any ODE problems where
accuracy in derivatives is as important as accuracy in function values.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 15:41:32 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Wed, 23 Jul 2008 21:11:35 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Mon, 11 Aug 2008 12:41:41 GMT"
}
] | 2008-08-11T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Werbos",
"Paul J.",
""
]
] |
product ( in)g2(ei1,...,e in), (*,*)n. Let us show that if let eg=ei1...ein, and let g(eg) denote ( in). We to the finite dimensional case [ 11], for elements fLm(H) and gLn(H),m > n, one can define the element by the formula ( (f,gh)n, which holds for all hLm-n(H). Let us show that the operation /rightangleseis well defined for fLm(H) we have to show that (geg)(eg') g gg' wheree(s) is the permutation parity of s. Also, we used here the definition of the exterior multiplication [ 2]. Taking into account the latter relation, letXbe a locally convex space, and the Hilbert space Hbe a vector subspace of X. Definition 1.A mapping f:X-Ln(H)is called a differential form of degreen(or differential n-form) on X. Note that every differential form fcan be presented as: real-valued functions. The operations of exterior and are defined for differential forms a differential form of degree n. Definition 2.We say that fpossesses a differential if its differentiable in each direction epforp /g, and for all The differential called the differential of f. Definition 3.We say that fpossesses a codifferential if its differentiable in each direction epforpg, and for all The differential called the codifferential of f. 3LetBXbe thes-algebra of Borel subsets of the space X. A measure on Xmeans a s-additive Hilbert space valued function on BX. Definition 4.As-additive Ln(H)-valued measure on Xis called a differ- ential form of codegree n. Every differential form oof codegree ncan be decomposed as: real-valued s-additive 5.Letgbe a bounded differential form of degree m,obe a differential form of codegree is a measure of bounded variation. The differential form goof codegree n-mdefined as (go)(A) called the exterior product of gando. The differential form gois well defined. Indeed, the differential form ocan be presented in the form o=f* |o|(see [3]), where |o|denotes the variation of o, andfis a differential form of degree nsuch that 1 for|o|-almost all x. We have (go)(A) 6.We say that the differential form oof codegree npossesses a differential if its coefficients ogare differentiable in all directions allABX. The codegree n-1defined by do= called the differential of differential forms of degree mand codegree both possess differentials. Further let gandobe such that g anddgare bounded, oanddoare of bounded variation. Then the a differential, and d(go) =gdo+(-1)ndgo. (1) The equality ( 1) can be easily obtained. Indeed, one should use the def- initions of differentials for gando, the definition of the operation , and compare the coefficients at each eg. 2. The operator adjoint to the differential Now we compute the operator adjoint to the operator dfor differential forms of a Sobolev-type class relative to a real- or complex-valued s-additive Weassumethat ep[1], and for all wherebu(x) uinthedirection ep[1,9]. Further let the numbers p >1 andq >1 be such that 1 /p+1/q= 1. By ohmn p, we denote the vector space of differential the Define a norm on elements we define the bilinear (2) 5The integral on the right-hand side exists by H older's inequality and by the definition of ohmn p. By the definition of the scalar product ( *,*)nand by Lebesgue's theorem, we rewrite ( the vector subspace of ohmn p, consisting of differential forms fpos- sessing the codifferential dfohmn-1 p, satisfying the (3) and such that the following condition (i) is fulfilled. Condition (i): for ev ery gG(n), there exists a d >0 and non-negative functions gg(x),g1g(x), and g2g(x), such that gg(x) p and for all p /g, for|t|< g2g(x). OnAn pwe define the let Bn qbe the vector subspace of ohmn qconsisting of differential forms o possessing the differential doohmn+1 qand satisfying the following condition (ii). Condition (ii): for every gG(n) there exists a d >0 and such that for all qg, g2 1g(x) andg2 2g(x) areu-summable, and for all qg, for|t|< g2g(x). OnBn qwe define the is clear that a linear continuous operator. Conditions (i) and (ii) are necessary to satisfy the assumptions of the integratio n by parts formula proved in [ 1] which we apply to compute the operator d*. Theorem 1.Foreverypair of elements 1, the element to ohmn p, the adjoint operator represented by the We this and ( 3) it follows that By the number of pin the sequence g1. Applying the integration by parts formula [ 1] (one can easily verify the conditions under which this formula holds), we changed the order of summation and integration when passing to the lat- ter expression in ( 5), and applied Lebesgue's theorem. Clearly, the sequence of partial sums under the last integral sign in ( 5) is majorized by an inte- grable function. This follows from the definition of the spaces inequality, and from the ine was proved, in fact, together with the estimate ( 4). By the same argu- ment, all the series in ( 5) converge absolutely, and hence the order of sum- mation of these series can be chosen arbitrary. We rewrite the exp and ( 5) imply the statement of the theorem. 3. The Stokes formula 3.1 Assumtions and notation As before, let Xbe a locally convex space, Hbe its vector subspace which is a Hilbert space relative to the scalar product ( *,*), and let {en}
n=1be an orthonormal basis of H. We assume that His dense in Xand the of HintoXis continuous. Let Ks n,nN, denote the vector space of bounded differential forms of degree ndifferentiable along Hand possessing bounded differentials. Let Sndenote the space of differential forms of codegree nwhich are Radon measures differentiable along H. Also, formsfrom oflinear continuous functionals onKs Ks nas dense subsets. In addition to that, we assume that the mapping d: Ks0-Ks1can be extended to a continuous mapping -Ks0--Ks1, and the mapping d:S1-S0, to a continuous mapping -S1--S0. Further we assume that for every measure nS0, the mapping Ks 1-S1, f/masto-fncan be extended to a -Ks1--S1, and the mapping Ks to a continuous mapping -Ks1x-S1--S0. We denote the extended mappings by the same symbols. When the functional f-S1acts on the element gKs1, we write Further let us assume that every sequence of elements from Ksn,n= 1,2, converging pointwise to an element from -Ksn, converges to this element also with respect to the a domain in Xsuch that its boundary Vcan be covered with a finite number of surfaces Uiof codimension 1. Everywhere below, a surface of codimension 1 is the object defined in [ 6], p. 552. We assume that the indicator IVof the domain Vis an element of the space -Ks0. Let the sets Uicovering Vand their intersections possess the property ( *) formulated in [6], p. 559. In what follows, we will use the notations introduced in [ 6]. Here we briefly repeat their meaning: nV:V-His the normal vector (with respect to the H-topology) to V; letBVbe a Borel subset, xB,|t|< e}is thee-layer of B;eb is the maximal number for which eb-layers are well defined; neis a =n(Be) 2e;PV: the projector of e-layers to the surface; nVis the surface measure generated by the measure n([12], [6]). Rigorous definitions of these objects as well as lemmas proving their existence are given in [ 6]. Note that by Theorem 2 of [6], lime-0ne(V) =nV(V). 3.2 A connection between a measure and the generated surface measure in terms of differential forms Theorem 2.LetnS0. ThendIV*nis anH-valued Radon measure on X concentrated on V. Moreover, nV*nV-S1, and the measures nandnV are related through the (6) 9Note that by assumption, (-eb,eb)-[0,1],e < eb, he(t) ift(-eb,-e), 0, ift(e,eb), be C-smooth functions such that on the intervals ( -e,-(e-e2)) and (e- e2,e), the absolute values of their derivatives change monotonically fro m 0 to1 2e, and from1 2eto 0, respectively. For e < e b, we define the yV, /V(V)eb.(7) Let us andxV. Iftis sufficiently small, then such (8) LetnVpbe coordinates of the vector nVin the basis {ep}
p=1. Subtracting xt from the both sides of ( 8), and multiplying by nV(x), we (9) Note that xt=PV(x+tnV(x) +tep). We can prove that the with respect to the H-topology similarly to how it was done in the proof of Lemma 6 of [ 6]. From the results of [ 6] (Lemmas 1 and 2), H-topology 10as well. Taking into account this, we show 0. The latter identity is obvious andnV(x) is orthogonal to Hx, whereHxis the intersection of the tangent space at xVwithH(see [6]). Further we have: 0 andfrom( 9), it follows Taking into =-tt 2e+1 2, we obtain that depfe(x+tnV(x)) =
-nVp(x) 2e, and =-nV(x) 2e. (10) Fortwhich belongs to one of the intervals ( -e,-(e-e2)) or (e-e2,e), the differential dfe(x+tnV(x)) can be calculated in the same way. =he(tt), = (he)'(t)nV(x). (11) This implies allxX. Note that as and hence with respect to the -Ks0- topology. By assumption, dfe-dIVin Let gKs1. The function [0 By assumption, ghas a bounded derivative, say by a constant 11M, alongH. For allxV,t(-e,e), we < Me, wheret0< t. Define a function ~ g: (V)eb-Hin the following way: ~g(x+tnV(x)) =g(x).Then, taking intoaccount the above sequence of inequalities, formulas ( 10), (11), and the definition of he, for allx(V)ewe obtain we fix an arbitrary s >0, and let s'=s 2(M+nV(V)). SincenVis a Radon measure (see [ 12], [14]), then there exists a compact KsV, s'. For each point x0Kswe fix a neighborhood Ux0, which is contained in one of Ui, possesses the property ( *) formulated in [ 6], and such that for the function ph(x) = (nV(x),g(x)), the inequality |ph(x)- ph(x0)|< s'holds forall xUx0. Wechoose a finitenumber covering Ks(let them be neighborhoods Uiof points xi), and denote their union by Os. It is clear that s', and by the construction of Os, there exists the limit lim e-0ne(Os) =nV(Os). Hence the limit lim exists too. Further let andphs:Os-Rbe such that It is clear s'. We = the definition of where the sum contains a finite number of terms. We observe that for every set Bi, lime-0ne(Bi) =nV(Bi) by the construction of Biand by Theorem 2 of [ 6]. Hence lim The limit of the second termin (13) exists by the existence ofthe two other limits. Wecontinue ( us estimate the last three terms. We to the limit as e-0 in the both sides of this inequality, and taking 13into account that the limit on the left-hand side exists, we we prove the two other s'nV(V). From this it follows s. Sinces >0 was chosen arbitrary, we conclude with ( 12) this implies is equivalent to ( 6). The theorem is where oVpare the surface measures generated by the measures op. ThennV-Ks1, and the measures oandoVare related through the us prove that nV-Ks1. Indeed, nVoriginally defined on V can be extended to Xby setting nV(x) = 0 for x /V. Let us consider the functions fedefined by ( 7). By to nVpointwise, and hence with respect to the -Ks1-topology by assumption. Note that by assumption, the operation can be extended from Ks 1xS1to-Ks1x-S1so a continuous mapping -Ks1x-S1--S0. Applying Theorem 2 to each pair of real-valued measures opandoVpwe Derivation of the Stokes We define the integral of oover the surface Vby the 3 (The Stokes formula) .LetoS1andoV-S1, 1and Definition usconsider fedefined by ( 7). Weproved that fe-IV pointwise and in the -Ks0-topology, and that dfe-dIVin By Lemma 1, 0 =d(feo)(X) = lim e-0(fedo)(X) theorem is V. I.; Smolyanov, O. G.; Fomin, S. V. , Generalized functions and differential equations in linear spaces. I: Differentiable measure s. (Russian) Tr. Mosk. Mat. Obshch. 24, 133-174 H. , Differential forms, (English) Paris: Hermann, Publishers in Arts and Science; London: Kershaw Publishing Company, Ltd., J., Uhl, Jr., J. J. , Vector measures. Mathematical Surveys. No. 15. Providence, R.I.: American Mathematical Society. XIII, 32 2 R.; Smolyanov, O. G.; Weizs acker, H. v. , Algebraic proper- ties differential formsoffinite codegree, (R ussian, English) Dokl. Math. 60, No.3, 412-415 (1999); translation from Do kl. Akad. Nauk, Ross. Akad. Nauk 369, No.6, 727-731 N. N. , Some formulas for the calculus of differential forms of finite codegree on a locally convex space. (Russian) Vestnik Mosk ov. Univ. Ser. I Mat. Mekh. 1996, , no. 2, 26-33, 103-104; translatio n in Moscow Univ. Math. Bull. 51, no. 2, 23-28 E. Yu. , Approximation of surface measures in a locally con- vex space, (Russian, English), Math. Notes 72, No. 4, 551-568 (2 from Mat. Zametki 72, No. 4, 597-616 I. space, J. Math. Kyoto Univ. ,vol. 26, 191-202 O. G. , De Rham currents and Stokes' formula in a Hilbert space, (Russian, English) Sov. Math., Dokl. 33, 140-144 (1986); t ransla- tion from Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 286, 554-558 G., Weizs acker,H. v. of Functional Analysis, vol.118, no. 2, p. 455-476 (1993) . [10]Smolyanov, O. G., Weizs acker, H. v. , Differential forms on spaces and an axiomatic approach to the Stokes formu la, (Russian, English) Dokl. Math. 60, No.1, 22-25 (1999); translation from Dol. Akad. Nauk, Ross. Akad. Nauk 367, No.2, 151-154 S. , Lectures on differential geometry. Prentice-Hall, Engle- wood Cliffs, N. J. A. V. , Surface integrals in linear topological spaces. Dokl. Math. 52, No.2, 227-230 (1995); translation from Do kl. Akad. Nauk, Ross. Akad. Nauk 344, No.4, 450-453 A. V. , Surface integrals in a Banach space, (English) Math. USSR, Sb. 38, 175-199 A. V. , Integration on surfaces and its ap- plications, 496. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 262 p., V. Yu. , Surface measures on surfaces of finite codimension in a Banach space, (Russian, English) Math. Notes 47, No.4, 414-42 1 (1990); translation from Mat. Zametki 47, No.4, 147-156 (1990) . 17
|
0807.2200
|
Evelina Shamarova
|
Evelina Shamarova
|
Differential forms on locally convex spaces and the Stokes formula
| null | null | null | null |
math.FA
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We prove a version of the Stokes formula for differential forms on locally
convex spaces. The main tool used for proving this formula is the surface layer
theorem proved in another paper by the author. Moreover, for differential forms
of a Sobolev-type class relative to a differentiable measure, we compute the
operator adjoint to the exterior differential in terms of standard operations
of calculus of differential forms and the logarithmic derivative. Previously,
this connection was established under essentially stronger assumptions.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 16:45:56 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Mon, 21 Jul 2008 18:55:09 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-21T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Shamarova",
"Evelina",
""
]
] |
regime. At short distances--or, equivalently, high energie s--the QCD coupling is small enough that perturbation theory can again be used. For example, the cross section for an pair to annihilate and produce a quark-antiquark p air can be reliably computed as a power series in as. The quark and antiquark each fragment into a jet of hadrons-- mostly pions, but some protons and neutrons, too--and general prope rties such as the energy flow and angular distributions of these jets can be traced back to the quark and antiquark. In this way, the experiments can measure quark properties, and these are found to agree with (4). QCD and the electroweak theory form the foundation of the Sta ndard Model of Theyaresowell establishedthat manyparticle p electroweak gauge symmetries, and the associated quant um-number assignments of the quarks and leptons, to be laws of nature. We cannot conceive o f a more comprehensive theory that does not encompass them. But there is more to the Standar d Model. We know that something must spontaneously break the electroweak symmet ry and that something (perhaps the same thing) must generate masses for the quarks and lepto ns. The Standard Model contains interactions that modelthese phenomena. The model interactions are consistent wit h observations yet also incomplete. It is hoped that insights obtained with the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), to commence operations at CERN later this ye ar, will enable particle physicists to solve many of the puzzles raised by the Standard Model. The purpose of this paper is to cover QCD, particularly in the strong-coupling regime theory is insufficient. It is worth bearing in mi nd, however, that there is a close connection between many of the results discussed below and s ome of the big questions in A simple example is the masses of the quarks. To dete rmine the quark masses (which because of confinement cannot be measured), we have to calcul ate the relation between quark masses and measurable quantities, such as hadron masses. Qu ark masses are interesting for many reasons, the most unsettling of which is as follows. The mass of the top quark is larger than that of the bottom quark; see figure 2. Similarly, the mas s of the charmed quark is larger than that of the strange quark. If this simple pattern held wi th the up and down quarks--the ones that make up proton and neutrons--then the up quark would be more massive than the down. But then protons would decay to neutrons, positrons, a nd neutrinos ( p-ne+n). The positrons would find electrons and annihilate to photons. This universe would consist of neutron stars surrounded by a swarm photons and neutrinos, and nothing else. Our universe is not at all like this, becaus e neutrons are more massive than (a)0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000 r aem(r) (b)0.001 0.01 0.1 1 r 1. Running of (a) the QED and (b) the QCD coupling with distance. For QCD the red curve shows the perturbative result, and the (higher) blue s how the effect of confining forces.protons. The allowed decay reaction is n-pe--n, leading to an abundance of protons and electrons, and making possible chemistry and biochemistry . With QCD we trace the neutron- proton mass difference back to the down-up quark masses and the n to the deeper origin of quark masses. The pattern of quark masses is necessarily not simple, and the search for of a messy pattern occupies many particle theor ists. Below we give QCD is essential for working out the mysteries of parti cle physics. QCD is also the cornerstone of modern nuclear physics. The si mplest nucleus is nothing but the proton, a boundstate of two upquarks and one down quark. T heneutron is a boundstate of two down quarks and one up quark. The confining force is very, v ery strong. By comparison, the force traditionally called the strong nuclear force is a res idue of the fundamental This is similar to van der Waals forces among molecule s, which are between neutral objects with structure leading to a d istribution of electric charge. Some basic problems are, therefore, to understand nucleon struc ture directly from QCD, to study the excitation spectrum of nucleons (and their cousins with str angeness and other flavors), and to see how few-nucleon (or, more generally, few-hadron) syste ms active area of research in nuclear QCD is the propert ies of quark matter at high temperature and density. This regime is important to cosmol ogy, because an epoch of the early universe consisted of hot quark matter, and to astrophysics , because, for example, neutron stars are composed of dense quark matter. In the laboratory, nuclear physicists create hot, dense quark matter by colliding heavy ions, at present with B rookhaven's RHIC, soon with (the heavy-ion mode of) CERN's LHC, and someday with GSI's FAIR. At strong coupling it is necessary to go beyond perturbation theory. In a relativistic quantum field theory, such as QCD, this is not easy. An important obsta cle is that a quantum field associates one (or perhaps a few) degrees of freedom with eve ry point in space-time. Hence, the number of degrees of freedom is uncountably infinite. Fur thermore, the fluctuations at short distances, if added up naively, contribute an ultravi olet divergence to anything of interest. These fluctuations are treated by a set of ideas known as renormalization (5). In short, one must find a tool that (correctly) handles both strongly coupl ed fields and the short-distance tool is lattice field theory or, for gauge theories like Q CD, lattice gauge theory. The idea, which goes back at least as far as Heisenberg, is to repl ace continuous space (or, in with a discrete grid, or lattice. Then the numbe r of degrees of freedom is countable. If the lattice is of finite extent, it occupies a finite physica l volume, and, moreover, the number of degrees of freedom is finite. In 1974, Kenneth Wilson showed h ow to maintain gauge symmetry with a discrete lattice (6). In this and subsequent work, he a nd others elaborated how the (7). The functional integral for quantum fields on a finite lattice is a familiar object, a integral, that can be evaluated on a computer. B efore downloading some code (8) and trying to run it on a laptop, let us paus e to contemplate how many variables of integration are reasonable (for physics). One wants to have the spacing between Quark flavors in the Standard mdmc> msmt> mb !!! What explains the pattern of masses?Figure 2. The six flavorsof quarks come the three generations with a doublet in each generation. electroweak interactions. For example, the upper (lower) entries have electric charge +2 /3 (-1/3).sites on the lattice small enough to resolve hadron structur e, and one wants the volume large enough that the boundary conditions do not modify the struct ure. If one supposes that the ratio of these two lengths is 32, then the dimensions of the in tegrals of interest are gluon d.o.f.= 8x4x323x128>108, (2) because gluons come in 8 colors with 4 polarization states ea ch. The factor 128 presumes a space-time lattice with a time extent long (in relativistic units) compared to the spatial extent; this is common practice. To cope with integrals of such large dimension, the only prac tical technique is Monte with importance sampling. The weight guiding t he importance sampling is e-S, whereSis the classical action for the random sample of gluon variab les. In functional for quantum mechanics, the expression for the ac tion is the defining equation of the physical system. The development of algorithms to generate these samples is a vibrant subject, covered in part by B' alint Jo' o's poster here at the SciDAC co nference. This paper will not dwell on algorithms, but it is important to mention one more compli fermions and, as such, must satisfy the Pauli excl usion principle. In the formalism, this is handled by introducing anticom muting Grassmann variables for fermions. Theintegration )integration Berezin integration. To make a long story short, in la ttice QCD we always can and do carry out the Berezin integration by hand. The outcome is tha t the weight for the becomes det Mexp(-Sgluons), where Mis a sparse matrix with space-time indices. The matrix MisNxN, where N=quark (3) The quark field represents nfflavors with 3 colors and 2 spin states of quark and antiquark f or every flavor and color. The matrix Mis sparse because it is a lattice version of a the Dirac operator (generalized to QCD). Incorpo rating det Minto the weight demanding, increasing by two or three orde rs of magnitude the amount operations needed to generate a new configura tion of gluons. The lattice is a helpful device mathematically and computat ionally, but it is not physical. To obtain a real result of the chromodynamics of continuum sp acetime, one must work out the integrals for a sequence of lattices, and take the limit a-0 in a way that Taking asmaller and smaller increases the computing burden as onero usly asa-(4+z). The exponent zdepends on the algorithm and is typically around 1 or 2. The 4 i QCDrequ available. No algorithm can reduce it, because i t is the dimension of space-time. Most lattice-QCD calculations are carried out in two steps. The first is to generate an ensemble of gluon fields, with a certain lattice spacing and q uark masses. This requires super-demanding det M. To generate an ensemble of useful size, one needs several hundred, perhaps even a few thousand, samples of the gluon field. Computers of the highest available capability are needed for this step. In re cent years, lattice gauge theorists have carried out this step with the special-purpose compute r QCDOC, large clusters of PCs, and, more recently, leadership-class machines constructe d under the auspices of the DOE's Office of Advanced Scientific Computing Research (ASCR). Thes e ensembles of gluon fields are valuable: within the U.S. they are generated by and for parti cle and nuclear physicists and shared under various agreements. File-sharing is facilita ted by formats and software developed by the International Lattice Data Grid (9). The second step is to mine these ensembles for physics. A simp le example is to compute the quantum mechanical amplitude for a proton to propagate f rom one point to another, andstudy the behavior of the amplitude as the separation varies : this is what one does to compute the proton mass, in fact. The key ingredients are a few rows of the inverse of the matrix M, introduced above. With the same ensemble one can study proto ns, pions, and more uncommon hadrons such as the charmed strange pseudoscalar meson (or Dsfor short). Different rows ofM-1(i.e., different flavors, colors, spins, and space-time separ ations) are combined in various ways to obtain the quantum numbers of the hadrons in the probl em at hand. Because each problem is different, and there are so many of them, we must atta ck this problem with the highest capacity computers. The job mix here is heterogeneo us, with many users whose job streams range from many large jobs to extremely many medium- sized jobs. The challenge is to develop systems that scale well (for the large jobs), while m aintaining the flexibility needed to handle the heterogeneity. The USQCD Collaboration has desi gned clusters of PCs that deliver this capacity in a cost-effective way (10). The remainder of this paper focuses on physics. It is organiz ed according to four principal themes of lattice gauge of fundamental parameters of the Standard Mo del of particle physics
*Study of nucleon structure, the hadron spectrum, and hadron of the thermodynamic properties of QCD at nonzer o temperature and density
*Lattice gauge theories beyond QCD, such as those appearing i n models of breaking Roughly speaking, the first and last are particle physics, an d the second and third are nuclear physics. But the lines are blurry: for example, some of the si mplest calculations of proton structure (the second item) may play a role more accurate cal culations of ppscattering cross sections at the LHC. The way that scientific goals drive the co mputing needs of lattice s, (8). 2. Standard Model particle physics In quantum electrodynamics, the fundamental parameters ar e the masses of electrically and the fine structure constant a. Similarly, in quantum chromodynamics, the fundamental parameters are the masses of colored particles (the quarks) and the strong coupling as. Just as acan be determined in many ways (2), ascan be determined at high energies from jet cross sections with perturbative QCD, and at low energies from the hadron spectrum with lattice QCD. Two recent results are (evaluate d at distance r= perturbative QCD jet shapes Ref. lattice QCD hadrons Ref. (12), (4) where both error bars reflect experimental and theoretical u ncertainties. The first result is determined at high energies, around 100 GeV, in the regime wh ere quarks can be treated as nearly free. The second is determined at low energies, of a few GeV and lower, where quarks are confined. Both are linked soundly to the defining eq uations of QCD. The the richness and broad validity of QCD and shou ld make any enthusiastic scientist say Wow! A straightforward application of lattice QCD is to work out h ow hadron masses depend on quark masses. Quark masses are interesting for several reas ons. As fundamental constants of nature, they are interesting in their own right. As discusse d in the introduction, the pattern of quark masses is puzzling and, hence, a motivation to searc h for extensions of the Standard Model that would contain a simple flavors of quarks--top, bottom, and charm--have masses l arge enough to influence some high-energy scattering and decay processes. Their mas ses can be determined QCD as well as lattice QCD. (The results agree ( 13).) The other three quarks-- up, down, and strange--have masses so small that the full boun d-state problem must be considered. Lattice QCD, therefore, provides the best info rmation. Some recent results are the following (14; 15): mu= 1.9+-0.2 MeV/c2, (5) md= 4.6+-0.3 MeV/c2, (6) ms= 88+-5 MeV/c2. of these results is that the strange qu ark's mass is somewhatsmaller than had been thought on the basis of less reliable techniques for attacking strongly-coupled QCD. This point is, perhaps, of interest mostly to particle physi cists, but a further one is of ofproton sandneutronsand, thus, small, withinan orderof magnitudeof theel ectron mass(0 .511 MeV /c2). Only about1-2% of theproton mass (938 .3 MeV/c2) or neutron mass (939 .6 MeV/c2) is accounted for by the quark masses. Consequently, most of their masses--and the mass of everyday matter-- arises from confinement, namely, the binding energy of the gl uons and the (relativistic) kinetic energy of bound quarks. This is a stunning insight, to be revi sited in Section 5. The caption of figure 2 states that the pairings of quarks in ea ch doublet stem from the electroweak interactions. That is not the full story. There is no reason for the eigenstates of mass to be the eigenstates of the interaction term with Wgauge bosons. The two are related by a unitary transformation, VCKM, ; two generations, and Kobayashi and Maskawa were the first to study the ramifications for three generations. The left-hand side of the first equation denotes the electrow eak basis. The labels on the elements of VCKMare the weak isopartner and the mass eigenstate, because the for W--bu, for example, is proportional to Vub. The study of physical to VCKMis called flavor physics, because the central issues are to un derstand why there are several flavors of quarks and what lends them their separa te identities. As a unitary matrix, VCKMcontains complex entries. Some of the phases can be absorbed into unobservable phases of the quark wave functions. For on ly two generations, one remains, and it is real. For three generations, as in nature, three physical parameters are real and one phase remains. The complex couplings impart ed by the phase lead to that proceed at different rates for particles and th e corresponding antiparticles. Such reactions are needed to explain the abundance of matter and t he dearth of antimatter in the universe. Among particle physicists, this phenomenon is ca lledCPviolation. It is to know whether the CPviolation of the CKM matrix is enough to account for the asymmetry of the universe. Accordin g to present measurements and theoretical understanding, it is insufficient, so one would l ike to know what other the Standard Model, there is a scalar boson called the Higg s boson. Section 5 will explain more about it. For now let us note that both the quark masses an d the CKM matrix have theirTable 1. Decay constants fPof pseudoscalar mesons (here P {p,K,D,D s}). Values in determinations assume a suitable element of t he CKM matrix element consistent with all flavor data. Meson MILC (15) FNAL (23) HPQCD (24) Experiment (Ref.) Devia tion p128+-3 - 132 +-2 130 .7+-0.4 (13) 0 .4s K154+-3 - 157 +-2 159 .8+-1.5 (13) 1 .7s D+- 201 +-19 207 +-4 206 +-9 (33) 0 .1s Ds - 249 +-17 241 +-3 277 +-9 (34) 3 .8s origin in matrices of couplings between quark fields and the H iggs field. Therefore, the and the pattern of the quark masses are tied togeth er by the Standard Model. To make progress in flavor physics, lattice-QCD calculation s are needed to interpret the experimental measurements. In a schematic form the rate G is given by G (9) where the known factor consists of well-measured physica l constants and numerical factors like 4p. The paradigm is to measure as many flavor-changing processe s as possible, and use the Standard-Model formulae to over-determine the CKM matr ix. If all the determinations are consistent, then one can set limits on non-Standard sources of flavor and CPviolation. To do so, the QCD factor must be computed, and often the only way to d o so is with lattice QCD. There are dozens of relevant measurements, but because the C KM matrix is unitary, the elements of the CKM matrix must satisfy constraints. A parti cular vivid one is the that stems from the orthogonality of columns of a un itary 0, (10) which traces out a triangle in the complex plane. The triangl e and the present various constraints is shown in figure 3, dividing each s ide byV*
cdVcb. Except for the wedge labelled sin bthe uncertainties can be reduced with lattice calculations of the QCD nt the past few years, and further improvements are under w ay. These include calculations of properties of strange kaons (15; 17; 18; 19; 20; 21), charmed DandDsmesons (22; 23; 24), and beautiful BandBsmesons (25; 26; 27; 28; 29; 30). For recent reviews, includin g references to work in Asia, Australia, and Europe, see (31; 32). The past several months witnessed an unexpected developmen t in flavor physics, in the field of leptonic decays of pseudoscalar mesons. (Pseudoscalar b osonshave spin0 andnegative parity; the most common examples are the pion and kaon.) One can consi der the measured decay rates to determine a QCD matrix element called the decay constant, and denoted fp(for the pion), fK(for the kaon), and so on. Table 1 shows the results of some Sci DAC-supported calculations of decay constants and the corresponding measurements. The calculations agree very well with the measurements, except in the case of the charmed strange p seudoscalar meson easiest forthe Ds. propagators of light quarks slow down as the quark mass mqis decreased. As a of hadrons containing up or down quarks are reach ed via a (controlled) This introduces a source of uncertainty that is absent for t heDs, which, as the lightest bound state of a charmed quark and a strange antiquark, can be computed by working directly at the physical quark -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 & mdsin 2b sol. w/ cos 2b < 0 (excl. at CL > 0.95)a b g re excluded area has CL > 0.95 CKM f i t t e -0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 & mdsin 2b sol. w/ cos 2b < 0 (excl. at CL > 0.95)a b g re excluded area has CL > 0.95 CKM f i t t e r package Figure 3. Constraints on the CKM unitarity triangle from experiments and QCD those where lattice QCD plays a role. The upper panel shows the current status, and the lower a forecast of how the uncertainties can be reduc ed with lattice QCD (16). In the lower panel, one can envision tension between the lime-gree n hyperbola and the blue wedge, depending on how the central values evolve and measurements and lattice-QCD The current status of the angles aandgis omitted, because better measurements are needed; they are expected from LHC b.Thereis noobvious explanation for this discrepancy within theStandard Model. Unless there is a real blunder somewhere, the discrepancy points to a non- Standard particle mediating thereby changing the interpretation of the measured fDs. It turns out to be rather easy to devise models of such interacti ons (34). Given the agreement of CLEO's new measurement of fD+(33), new W'bosons and charged Higgs bosons seem unlikely, making with baryon and lepton numbe r--are the most plausible agents of decay. 3. Nucleon structure and nuclear physics Let us turn now to nuclear physics, where the importance of la ttice QCD is difficult to overstate. Many nuclear laboratories, such as Jefferson Labo ratory in the U.S., have turned their attention to the structure of the proton (the simplest nucleus!) (35), the of baryons (36), and processes that may produce glu eballs. On the theoretical side, the previous decade witnessed dramatic growth in the applic ation of effective field theories interactions (37). Thesetechniques co nnect a wealth of nuclear andhadronic data to the QCD Lagrangian. Lattice QCD is an irreplaceable t ool to interpret the new lo w-energy constants (38). A topic at the interface between nuclear and particle physic s concerns the distributions of partons (a generic term for quarks and gluons) inside the pro ton. In high-energy collisions of p-p(at the Tevatron) or pp(at the LHC), the transverse motion of partons can be neglect ed. To compute cross sections (to produce, say, a Higgs boson), t he key property needed is the distribution of the longitudinal momentum. From a nuclear p erspective, this is also one of the most basic aspects of proton structure. Usually one stud ies parton distributions qas a function of the fraction xof longitudinal momentum carried by a parton, 0 < x <1. Fits to scattering data can determine q(x) only over a range, xmin< x < x max, limited by kinematics and statistics. Lattice QCD can compute moments of Clearly the two kinds of information are complementary. The experimental r ange can be extended with ad hoc functions possessing the right asymptotic forms at the endp oints, and in this way an Ansatz- guided experimental determination of possible. One finds good agreement with (39). To explore nucleon structure further, t he next step is to probe the and compute the so-called generalized parton dis tributions (39). The axial charge of the nucleon is another topic of keen inter est, because it appears in the description of bdecay. It is also related to the relative spin polarization o f up and down quarks in the proton. Some recent results with lattice QCD Ref. (40) 1.20+-0.07 Ref. (41), (11) showing good agreement with experiment ( gA= 1.269+-0.003). Work is under way to reduce the theoretical fieldsofphysics, underlying phenomena of interest. In nuclear and hadron ic physics, therefore, an important area of investigation is the excitation spectrum of hadrons , particularly baryons. Excited states present additional challenges for lattice QCD, but the tool s needed are available and have to work (42; 43). This subject extends to inclu de topics such as the intriguing Roper resonance (44) and electromagnetic transitions of th e formgN-N*, whereN*is an excited nucleon (45). Because the gluons couple to each other, it is conceivable th at there are hadrons of gluons, with no valence quarks. (Virtual qua rk-antiquark pairs appear in allhadrons.) The most persuasive evidence that glueballs do in deed exist come from lattice- QCD calculations. In an approximation omitting virtual qua rk pairs, the evidence is clear that stable gluon-only bound states arise (46; 47). There ar e two challenges with glueballs. One, obviously, is to extend the lattice calculations to ful l QCD with virtual The other is to identify them unambiguously in the lab oratory (48). Experiments are expected to produce such states and are plann ed at the 12 GeV upgrade of CEBAF, the accelerator at Jefferson Lab. To plan this program i t is essential to know of the mesons (exotic or not). It is possible to compute these photocouplings in lattice QCD, as has been demonstrated for charmonium (- ccmesons) (49). An extension of this work to light mesons, including exotics and glueballs, is un der way. A long-term goal of nuclear physics is to compute many-body i nteractions from QCD. In addition to providing a better understanding of the nucleus , these calculations are relevant to mesonic atoms, namely, those containing a positively and ne gatively charged meson, and to strangeness in neutron stars. Although in some cases lattic e QCD results can be compared to measurements, the more interesting situation is where this cannot be done. The aim here is to gain confidence in the reliability of these difficult calculat ions, so that one can use them (with robust uncertainty estimates) in applications where it is o therwise impossible to acquire the needed information any other way. An interesting example is the lattice calculation of the pKscattering lengths, of which there are two, a1/2anda3/2, depending on whether the pKsystem has isospin I=1 2or3 2. A calculation finds (50) a1/2mpc/-h= dimensionless units. Theseareinrough, butn ot spectacular, agreement using chiral perturbation theory or the Roy -Steiner equations. For example, an analysis based on the Roy-Steiner method (51) +0.224+-0.022, (15) employing an extrapolation from high energies down to the th reshold (where the is defined); see (38) for more discussion. A more direc t experimental determination is proposed by the DiRAC Collaboration, which would form p-K+atoms (52). In this sense, Eqs. (12) and (13) represent something exciting: a theoreti cal prediction awaiting rch, pp(53), KK(54), and even states with as many as twelve pions (55). Once m ethods have been vetted in mesonic systems, the next step is to consider nucleon-nuc leon (56) and nucleon-hyperon (57) systems. This is more difficult, because the signal-to-noise ratio in the Monte Carlo estimate of baryonic correlation functions is worse. Here the method s of effective field theories can be used to extend feasible lattice-QCD calculations to a wider range of nuclear phenomena. interaction is of interest, because there is speculation that the large Fermi energy may make it energetically favorable for some nucleon s to transmute to hyperons (58). 4. QCD sco but does not explain why, the spacetime lattice usuall y has a time extent much longer thanFigure 4. Phase diagram of QCD, Accelerator experiments at RHIC and LHC probe small chemical the crossover regime. At the planned Facility for Antiproton and Ion Research (FAIR) experiments can reach larger chemical potential. Image from the (60). the spatial dimension, for example, 323x128. The reason is that the functional integral a grand canonical ensemble (in the sense of thermo dynamics) at temperature T, kBT= -hc/Nta, (16) whereNtis the number of sites in the time direction, ais the lattice spacing, and kBis Boltzmann's constant. In the applications to particle and n uclear physics discussed in Sections 2 and 3, one wants T= 0 and, hence, takes Ntlarge enough for the Boltzmann eliminate thermal effects, where mis a hadron mass. There are, however, many areas of research where a nonzero te mperature and a nonzero chemical potential arise. For nonzero temperature, one sim ply makes Ntsmaller, in current work. Such lattices take somewhat less memory, but not less computing because thermodynamics obviously requires calc ulations at several temperatures. It is conceptually easy to introduce a nonzero chemical potent ial into lattice gauge theory, but the conceptually clean approach is computationally beyond pre sent resources. For small several approaches are available and efficient (5 9). The physical phenomena of interest are summarized by the pha se diagram in figure 4. The key feature is a phase transition from hadronic matter to a su bstance called the The transition is expected to be first order and end at a critical point at u/ne}ationslash= 0. Between the critical point and the u= 0 axis the transition is a rapid crossover. Lattice-QCD calculations, as well as measureme nts of heavy-ion collisions at RHIC and LHC, probe the crossover, which is relevant to the coolin g of the early universe. Neutron stars appear at high baryonic density, namely, high u. At even higher densities, several phases with color are thought to exist. Apart fr om heavy-ion collisions (so far at smallu) much of this phase diagram is unexplored, and lattice gauge theory offers the only ab initio, quantitative, theoretical tool to see if it really reflects QCD. The central concept in QCD thermodynamics is the equation of state (EoS), namely, the relationship between the pressure pand energy density oas the temperature Tand uare varied. The EoS reveals the relevant degrees of freedom. In QCD, are they hadrons? Or quarks and gluons? At low temperatures, hadrons are clearly present, models of hadron gases can describe QCD th ermodynamics. At very perturbation theory can be used. But near the methods are needed. The first step is to find the transition temperature, which has now been done with 2+1 flavors of realistic sea quarks (61; 62). The different physics below, near, and above the Tcalso has ramifications for controling systematic errors. Di scretization effects from the lattice, for example, depend on the basic degrees of freedom. (For a crossover it is, strictly speaking, incorrect to speak of a critical tempera ture. But the critical point in the phase diagram is close enough to the u= 0 axis that thermodynamic variables change rapidly at Tc.)The next step is to map out the thermal contribution to the tra ce of the trTh = o-3p. From as the entropy density, can be worked out. This also has n ow been done with 2+1 flavors of realistic sea quarks (63; 64), including at small u(65). As the system is heated, even to 2 Tc, the behavior of o-3pshows that the system does not turn rapidly into weakly inter acting quarks and gluons. To make contact with heavy-ion collisions, the last step wou ld be to take the output of lattice QCD as input to hydrodynamic models. With these mode ls one would then observables, such as elliptic flow and quarkon ium suppression. With resources, the EoS has been pinned down with 20-25 % accuracy. To make a big impact on hydrodynamic modeling, however, it will be necess ary to reduce the error to 5%. This is conceptually straightforward to achieve, but it wil l be computationally challenging. Part of the strategy is to reduce discretization effects, which sca le asa2(ais the lattice spacing), while the net cost scales as a-11. 5. Non-Standard particle physics As mentioned above, particle physics awaits a new era when th e LHC starts producing physics results. Commencing later this year, the LHC will collide tw o beams of 7 TeV (TeV protons. (Amusingly, some particle phy sicists now call this energy scale the terascale, deliberately alluding to terascale computing. It would be unkind to tell them that in computing we are moving on to the petascale.) In particular, the LHC will address the central problem of particle physics, which is the origin of the WandZboson masses. The fact that these masses do not vanish demonstrates that some mechanism breaks the electroweak gauge symmetry spontaneously. Spontaneous symmetry breaking means simply that, although the equations of motion are symmetric, the solution chosen is no t symmetric. For example, in the Standard Model a scalar field breaks electroweak symmetry, v ia a technique invented by between the Higgs field and the fermions also ge nerate (in the Standard Model) the quark and charged lepton masses and the CKM matrix. Therefor e, flavor physics will in the LHC era, and the physics program discusse d in Section 2 will need to be continued and extended. In this section, however, I would like to consider applicati ons of lattice gauge theory to understanding the mechanism of electroweak symmetry break ing. Since we suspect that the Standard Higgs sector is far from the full story, it is possib le (some would say likely) that strongly coupled fields are involved. For example, instead o f being an elementary field, the Higgs boson (and its siblings, the longitudinal polarizati on states of the WandZbosons) could be composite. The constituents would then form a whole spect rum of states, just as quarks bind into many different hadrons. Even if the Higgs is elementary at the terascale, other agents of electroweak symmetry breaking could be strongly work on theoretical bounds on the Higgs mass are a l ong-standing topic in lattice field theory (66; 67). The issue is that the Higgs mass is propo rtional to its self-coupling, which runs at short distances in a way similar to ain QED; see figure 1. The perturbative running becomes invalid once the coupling is too large, and nonpertu rbative methods are required. A subtle relation arises between the Higgs mass and a scale wh ere new phenomena imply that the Standard Model breaks down. To make a long story short, on e can in this way bound the Higgs mass from above. A similar analysis applied to the Yuka wa coupling between the Higgs field and the top quark leads to a lower bound on the Higgs mass, as discussed in a analysis (68). A popular class of non-Standard models is to replace the Higg s sector with a sector that is, in some respects at least, analo gous to QCD. In fact, absent a stronger source of symmetry breaking, the pions of QCD would break the electroweak symmetry, around 100 MeV. What one needs, then, is a new quantum n umber, and a gauge force to bind the corresponding par ticles, called techniquarks, together. These dynamics are posited to take place at terascale energi es and, by analogy with QCD, generate vector boson masses around 100 GeV, as observed. Th e earliest models of way around the experimental constraints is to assume tha t the coupling evolves more slowly than in QCD. This is called walking (i.e., slower than runn ing) technicolor. For a wide range of scales below the confining scale, the coupling is too stron g for perturbation theory to be relied on, so nonperturbative work with lattice gauge theor y is called for. In the past year, the walking hypothesis has indeed been tested, by examining the scaling behavior of the technipion mass, the vector meson mass, and the technipion decay consta nt (69). Even more recently, the evolution of asin (a TeV-scale version of) QCD with several flavors has been c omputed (70), to see how many flavors are needed to having a walking coupling , and how a walking coupling changes the physics. The most popular way to relieve the theoretical problems of t he Standard Model is to introduce supersymmetry, a symmetry that transforms fermi ons into bosons, and vice versa. In these models, every known particle (quarks, leptons, gau ge bosons) comes with another state known as a superpartner. In the minimal l, the Higgs sector contains three neutral bosons, a charged pair, and their superpartners. No superpartner has been observed, so at the terascale and below supersymmetry must be broken some how. Usually are conceived of as weakly coupled, but, since they ar e gauge theories, strong coupling is not to be dismissed out of hand. It is therefore of great int erest to formulate and gauge theories on a spacetime lattice. This has been an extremely field during the past several years (71; 72), and now first numerical simulations are being carried out (73; 74). This rapid development yields ho pe that nonperturbative studies models will be possible, including studies of supersymmetry breaking. 6. now and then one hears the question, How much computin g would it really take to solve QCD on a computer? The questioner is (usually) well meaning , but most experts would agree that the question is not well conceived. The calculations fo r some of the simplest are finally becoming mature, with analyses that f orthrightly address all sources of uncertainty. This class of observable, sometimes called g old-plated (75), consists of masses of particles that are stable (with respect to the strong intera ctions), not too close to thresholds, and of hadronic transition matrix elements with one or zero o f these stable hadrons in the final and initial states. Many, but not all, aspects flavor physics (Section 2), and some aspects of hadronic structure (Section 3), lie in this class, and the fir st solid round of serious computation is nearing its end. But this is the end of the beginning. In these nearly mature fie lds, it turns out that precision is important, at least for the foreseeable future. For examp le, to gain persuasive evidence of new phenomena in flavor physics, 5-25% accuracy is not enough . A better target (given the stakes and the quality of the corresponding experiments) is 1-3%. If the history of kaon physics is a guide, it will eventually be important to go further. Hap pily, the need for and clear path to precision has persuaded the particle-physics community that the resources needed for lattice flavor physics are worth the cost. Even a quick glance at Section 3 reveals that the large majori ty of interesting problems in nuclear physics require much more computing resources th an gold-plated observables. By definition the excited hadrons are not stable under the stron g interaction. They will be harder to pin down, and it is possible that we will not know how hard un til the work currently under way reaches some of its milestones. The calculations of scat tering lengths, while impressive,must be repeated with several values of the physical volume t o ensure that the used to extract them works as it should. Given the i mportance of nuclear lattice QCD in guiding nuclear experimentation, one would hope for f ull support from the needed computing resources. The how much? question should be rephrased. It is really a c lass of questions, How much computing would it take to compute my favorite observab le? Of course, the answer depends on your observable and its wider context. It should b e clear, however, that physics with either precision and complexity leads to questions who se answers will need one or two orders of magnitude more computing than what is available no w. Another reason the how much? question is ill-conceived is that it often overlooks job mix needed to attack many problems in latt ice QCD. It is not enough to generate huge ensembles of lattice gauge fields, with ever sm aller lattice spacing and ever smaller quark masses, on the world's computer. This step is necessary, creating a gold mine of information. It is not enough, however, merely t o open a mine; the gold must be extracted and, here, we need a large capacity of computing th at is flexible in every way (while having significant capability of its own). We do not know how broad the future of lattice gauge theory wil l be. If the LHC discovers a strongly interacting sector beyond the Standard Model, it is likely that chiral fermions play a role. This is simply because, at the terascale, we already k now that left-handed fermions and right-handed fermions are different fields. But chiral fer mions possess some conceptual challenges not found in QCD. A strongly coupl ed terascale will bring many more particle theorists to lattice gauge theory, and this larger community will clamor for computing that is up to the work has been supported in part by the United States Nati onal Science Foundation and the Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). Softw are development and within the USQCD Collaboration are supported b y SciDAC. Fermilab is operated by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC, under Contract DE-AC02-07 CH11359 with the US Schwinger J (ed) 1958 Selected Papers in Quantum Electrodynamics (New York: Dover) ISBN Kinoshita T 1996 Rept. Prog. Phys. 591459-1492 [3] Alcaraz J et al.(LEP) 2007 Precision electroweak measurements and constra ints on the Standard Model ( Preprint ) [4] Dixon L J 2007 Hard QCD processes at colliders, in 23rd International Symposium on Lepton-Photon Interactions at High Energy (Preprint ) [5] Lepage G P 1989 What is renormalization? in From Actions to Answers ed DeGrand T and Toussaint D (Singapore: World Scientific) ( Preprint ) [6] Wilson K G 1974 Phys. Rev. D102445-2459 [7] Glimm J and Jaffe A M 1987 Quantum Physics: A Functional Integral Point of View (New York: Springer) ISBN USQCD Collaboration URL Detar C E (ILDG) 2006 PoSLATTICE2007 009 (Preprint ) [10] Holmgren D J 2005 Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 140183-189 ( )[11] Becher T and Schwartz M D 2008 A precise determination of asfrom LEP thrust data using effective field theory ( Preprint ) [12] Mason Q et al. (HPQCD) 2005 Phys. Rev. Lett. 95052002 ( ) [13] Yao W M et al.(Particle Data Group) 2006 J. Phys. G331-1232 [14] Mason Q, Trottier H D, Horgan R, Davies C T H and Lepage G P ( HPQCD) 2006 (Preprint ) [15] Bernard C et al. (MILC) 2006 PoSLATTICE2007 090 ) [16] Van de Water R S (USQCD) 2007 J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 78012079 [17] Aubin C et al.(MILC) 2004 Phys. Rev. D70114501 (Preprint ) [18] Beane S R, Bedaque P F, Orginos K and Savage M J (NPLQCD) 20 07Phys. Rev. D75 094501 (Preprint ) [19] GamizE et al.(HPQCD)2006 Phys. Rev. D73114502 (Preprint ) [20] Antonio D J et al.(RBC and UKQCD) 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 100032001 ( ) [21] Boyle P A et al.(RBC and UKQCD) 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 100141601 ( ) [22] Aubin C et al.(Fermilab Lattice and MILC) 2005 Phys. Rev. Lett. 94011601 ( ) [23] Aubin C et al.(Fermilab Lattice and MILC) 2005 Phys. Rev. Lett. 95122002 ( ) [24] Follana E, Davies C T H, Lepage G P and Shigemitsu J (HPQCD ) 2008Phys. Rev. Lett. 100062002 (Preprint ) [25] Okamoto M et al.(Fermilab Lattice and MILC) 2005 Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 140 461-463 ( Preprint ) [26] Dalgic E et al.(HPQCD) 2006 Phys. Rev. D73074502 (Preprint ) [27] Gray A et al. (HPQCD) 2005 Phys. Rev. Lett. 95212001 ( ) [28] Bernard C et al.(Fermilab Lattice and MILC) 2006 PoSLAT2006 094 [29] Dalgic E et al.(HPQCD) 2007 Phys. Rev. D76011501 (Preprint ) [30] Laiho J (Fermilab Lattice and MILC) 2006 PoSLATTICE2007 358 ) [31] Della Morte M 2007 PoSLATTICE2007 008 (Preprint ) [32] J uttner A 2007 PoSLATTICE2007 014 (Preprint ) [33] Eisenstein B I et al.(CLEO) 2008 Precision measurement of B(D+-u+n) and the pseudoscalar decay constant fD+(Preprint ) [34] Dobrescu B A and Kronfeld A S 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 100241802 ( ) [35] H agler P 2007 PoSLATTICE2007 013 (Preprint ) [36] McNeile C 2007 PoSLATTICE2007 019 (Preprint ) [37] Kaplan D B 2007 Effective field theory as the bridge between lattice QCD and nuclear physics, in Quark Confinement And The Hadron Spectrum 7 ed Ribeiro J et al.(New York: AIP) (Preprint )[38] Beane S R, Orginos K and Savage M J (NPLQCD) 2008 Hadronic interactions from lattice QCD (Preprint ) [39] H agler P et al. (LHPC) 2008 Phys. Rev. D77094502 ( ) [40] Edwards R G et al. (LHPC) 2006 Phys. Rev. Lett. 96052001 ( ) [41] Yamazaki T et al.(RBC and UKQCD) 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 100171602 ( ) [42] Sasaki S, Blum T and Ohta S 2002 Phys. Rev. D65074503 ( ) [43] Basak S et al. (LHPC) 2007 Phys. Rev. D76074504 ( ) [44] Mathur N et al.2005Phys. Lett. B605137-143 ( Preprint ) [45] Lin H W, Cohen S D, Edwards R G and Richards D G 2008 First la ttice study of the N-P11(1440) transition form factors ( Preprint ) [46] Vaccarino A and Weingarten D 1999 Phys. Rev. D60114501 ( ) [47] Morningstar C J and Peardon M J 1999 Phys. Rev. D60034509 ( ) [48] Sexton J, Vaccarino A and Weingarten D 1995 Phys. Rev. Lett. 754563-4566 ( ) [49] Dudek J J, Edwards R G and Richards D G 2006 Phys. Rev. D73074507 ( ) [50] Beane S R et al. (NPLQCD) 2006 Phys. Rev. D74114503 ( ) [51] Buettiker P, Descotes-Genon S and Moussallam B 2004 Eur. Phys. J. ) [52] Dimeson Relativistic Atom Complex Collaboration (DiR AC) Beane S R et al. (NPLQCD) 2008 Phys. Rev. D77014505 ( ) [54] Beane S R et al. (NPLQCD) 2008 Phys. Rev. D77094507 ( ) [55] Detmold W et States inLattice QCDandtheCharg ( Preprint ) [56] Beane S R, Bedaque P F, Orginos K and Savage M J (NPLQCD) 20 06Phys. Rev. Lett. 97 012001 (Preprint ) [57] Beane S R et al. (NPLQCD) 2007 Nucl. Phys. A79462-72 ( ) [58] Kaplan D B and Nelson A E 1986 Phys. Lett. B17557-63 [59] Schmidt C 2006 PoSLAT2006 021 (Preprint ) [60] Compressed Baryonic Matter Collaboration (CBM) Bernard C et al.(MILC) 2005 Phys. Rev. D71034504 (Preprint )[62] Cheng M et al.(RBC and Bielefeld) 2006 Phys. Rev. D74054507 ( ) [63] Bernard C et al.(MILC) 2007 Phys. Rev. D75094505 (Preprint ) [64] Cheng M et al.(RBC and Bielefeld) 2008 Phys. Rev. D77014511 ( ) [65] Bernard C et al. (MILC) 2008 Phys. Rev. D77014503 ( ) [66] Dashen R F and Neuberger H 1983 Phys. Rev. Lett. 501897 [67] Heller U M, Klomfass M, Neuberger H and Vranas P M 1993 Nucl. Phys. ) [68] Fodor Z, Holland K, Kuti J, Nogradi D and Schroeder C 2007 PoSLATTICE2007 056 (Preprint ) [69] Catterall S and Sannino F 2007 Phys. Rev. D76034504 ( ) [70] Appelquist T, Fleming G T and Neil E T 2008 Phys. Rev. Lett. 100171607 ( ) [71] Kaplan D B 2004 Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 129109-120 ( ) [72] Giedt J 2006 PoSLAT2006 008 (Preprint ) [73] Catterall S and Wiseman T 2007 JHEP12104 (Preprint ) [74] Catterall S and Wiseman T 2008 Black hole thermodynamic s from simulations of theory ( Preprint ) [75] Davies C T H et al.(HPQCD, MILC, and Fermilab Lattice) 2004 Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 022001 (Preprint )
|
0807.2220
|
Andreas S. Kronfeld
|
Andreas S. Kronfeld
|
Quantum chromodynamics with advanced computing
|
17 pp. Featured presentation at Scientific Discovery with Advanced
Computing, July 13-17, Seattle
|
J.Phys.Conf.Ser.125:012067,2008
|
10.1088/1742-6596/125/1/012067
|
FERMILAB-CONF-08-208-T
|
physics.comp-ph hep-lat hep-ph nucl-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We survey results in lattice quantum chromodynamics from groups in the USQCD
Collaboration. The main focus is on physics, but many aspects of the discussion
are aimed at an audience of computational physicists.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Mon, 14 Jul 2008 17:58:00 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Kronfeld",
"Andreas S.",
""
]
] |
are thus the natural objects to be considered in a semiclassical ap proach to these theories at finite temperature. They smoothly interpolate b etween in- stantons andBPSmonopoles atzero respec tively a very interesting link between them. One of the required in gredi- ents for such semiclassical analysis is the knowledge of fermionic zer o modes in the background of the caloron field. Although those in the fundam ental rep- resentation of the gauge group have been known for quite some tim e [6]-[10], this is not the case for the gluino zero modes. They have been derive d only recently by two of the present authors [11], and just for the cas e of conditions in S1. These are the relevant modes for supersymmet- ric but not what is needed when studying N= 1 SUSY Yang-Mills fields at finite temperature. Antiperiodicity in thermal-time has to be required in that case. The goal of this letter is to obtain analytic e xpres- sions for the antiperiodic solutions, derived here for the first time e ven for the trivial holonomy, case. This requires a differ ent approach than the one employed in [11] which was based on the relation between zero modes and self-dual deformations of the gauge field, providing only paper is organized as follows. In section 2 we will describe the str ategy followed to obtain the antiperiodic zero modes and present the analy tic ex- pressions for the solutions. In section 3 we analyze their propertie s in several relevant limits, paying particular attention to the one in which the calo rondis- sociates into a pair of static BPS constituent monopoles. The trivial- holonomy HS zero mode solution andthe equal mass constituent monopole cas es are also discussed in some detail. Conclusions and a brief summary of results a re pre- sented in section 4. 2 Formalism As mentioned previously, our goal is that of solving the massless cov ariant Dirac equation in the adjoint representation of the = 0 (1) in the background field of a Q=1 caloron [2]-[4]. This problem has been p ar- tially addressed in Ref. [11]. The approach that was followed inthat pa per was based on the well-known relation between self-dual deformations o f the gauge field and the zero-modes of the Dirac operator in the adjoint repre the solutions obtained in this way are periodic in thermal-tim e with the same period b(to be taken equal to 1 in what follows) as the gauge field itself. Thus, a different strategy has to be set up to derive the ant iperiodic 2modes relevant for finite temperature. In what follows we will prese nt the ba- sic idea behind our procedure and the results obtained with it. In all t echnical aspects we will rely strongly in the notation and derivations done in Re f. [11]. The observation that leads to our solution is the fact that antiperio dic solu- tions turn out to be periodic in the double period. Thus, the method o f attack developed in Ref. [11] for periodic zero-modes can be carried over if the whole problem is seen as living in this duplicated space-time. This replica trick has been used by some of the authors in other works [12,13] and is an imp ortant source of information when dealing with periodic gauge fields. In our c ase, the problem becomes that of finding self-dual deformations of the Q= 2 caloron obtained by the replica procedure. Notice that the topological cha rge is 2 in this case, so we expect 4 (CP-pairs) of self-dual deformations. S ince the gauge field is periodic in the original period, they can be split into those which a rmerwere studied in our previous paper and correspond to the ordinary defo rmations of theQ= 1 caloron. Since there are 2 pairs of those, which are periodic in the smalltorus, we expect to find two pairs of antiperiodic zero-modes. Unf ortu- nately, although some particular solutions are known [14], there is no analytic general expression for the Q= 2 caloron which would reduce the study of deformations to the differentiation of the general solution with res pect to the parameters of the moduli space. In this paper we will thus follow an a lterna- tive strategy. Incidentally our results could well prove useful in ac hieving the goal of obtaining the most general Q= 2 caloron solution. The general formula relating deformations to zero-modes in the ad joint rep- resentation is: Ps , (2) with the + or -sign depending onwhether the solution is self-dual or an arbitrary constant spinor and hence, the zero-modes that w e complexvector sp aces. These spaces are generated by any solution Ps and its euclidean CP transfo (3) Our formula can easily be shown to satisfy the Dirac equation provide d the deformation satisfies the background Lorentz gauge 0. (4) Using the general ADHM construction one can obtain formulas for t he self- dual deformations in terms of those for the Nahm-ADHM data. The for SU(2) tells us that a self-dual gauge field can be c onstructed as [15] Au(x) =i F(u+uu)', (5) whereuis a vector in quaternions, F= 1 +u+u, and the prime denotes the traceless part. The vector uis obtained as the solution of the (6) where the quaternionic the vector qare x-independent. We have introduced the Weyl matrix su= (I,i/vector t) whose adjoints are su(/vector tare the Pauli matrices). In the proof of self-duality one must demand t hat the following (7) is real and invertible. For our purpose it is interesting to write down t he ex- pression of the adjoint zero-modes in terms of the deformations o f the (8) whereo=R-1q. To guarantee that the deformations self-dual deformation dAusatisfying the background field gauge condition, one must impose certain conditions. These are best expressed in te rms of the matrix with quaternionic entries F M+dM Fusu, whereM+= The condition then reduces to the hermiticity of Fu(Fu=F+
u). The previous formulas apply for Q= 1 calorons by extending the vector q to become a delta-like functional over the periodic functions in one- variable z, while 2pi/tildewideAis a covariant Weyl operator with respect to a gauge field ^Au(z), the Nahm-dual gauge field. After suitable and gauge transformations the caloron Nahm data ca n be taken to be [2,3] q(0)(z) (9) whereP+-= for 0 and1 2. Without loss of generality we will assume in what In the previous formula the delta functions have to be taken as periodic functions in zwith unit period. The Nahm-dual gauge field of the caloron is given by
^A(0) u(z) (10) whereXa 3is the position of the ath constituent monopole on the z-axis. They can be obtained from the relations m1X1 3+m2X2 3= 0, 4pdaare proportional to the constituent monopole masses. the characteristic function of the interval [ -d1,d1] andkh2that of its (7) implies that the Nahm-dual gauge field is self-dual at all but a finite number of points. Eq. (6) is then the solution of the Weyl equation e xcept at those isolated points. As we will see later the conditions on the defor enter Eq. (8), are precisely equivalent to requiring that d^Auis again a self-dual deformation satisfying the background gauge condition . Thus, they can be obtained as the solution of the adjoint Weyl equation of the N ahm-dual field, up to delta functions. Now we should apply this scheme to the replicated caloron taken as a s in the double torus with period 2 b(remember bis fixed to 1). Since this caloron now has charge Q= 2 its corresponding Nahm-dual gauge field is now a matrix. Using the general construction of Nahm-dual replic as given in [12] we obtain
^AR u(z) is the Nahm data of the ordinary caloron, and ^AR u(z) is the Nahm data of the replicated caloron. One may now wonder which is the corresponding qfor such a replica solution. We will argue that the solution is actually given by qR(z) (12) Notice that each of the components of qand^Aare periodic with unit period, but the whole set is periodic with period 1 /2 with a twist matrix given by t1:
^AR u(z+1 2) =t1^AR u(z)t1. (13) 5The quantity qtransforms by periodicity as =t1qR(z). (14) From here it is possible to use the general formulas of the ADHM cons truction to verify that indeed we obtain a replicated solution. In particular we have thatuR(z) is given by: uR(z) (15) Now FR-1 (16) which coincides with F-1 for the caloron. The replicated gauge from AR u(x) (17) One might wonder whether the choice of qand^AR uare consistent with the condition of self-duality in Nahm-dual space, namely that R=M+Mcom- mutes with the quaternions. To verify that this is so, one must realiz e that the condition of self-duality should hold only in the domain of these operat ors. These are two-component vectors ps(z) =t1ps(z). (18) Thus, they should be of the form ps(z) on this vector (20) 6The imaginary part of the upper component coincides (21) which is what is needed to cancel the self-duality violation. Now we proceed to study the self-dual deformations of this replica ted the background field condition. We will make use of our gen eral formula Eq. (8). The conditions following that equation when transla ted to our case = The quantities dqR nare vector whose elements are linear combinations of delta funct ions with complex coefficients. The holonomy fixes that the argument of the d elta func- tions must be Notice that, as anticipated previously, up to the delta functions in the right-hand side, the equation adopts t he form of the Weyl equation for adjoint zero-modes in Nahm dual space. Our next step will then be that of finding the solution of Eq. (22). No tice the unknowns. Without much effort one can demonstrate that given a solution one can obtainother solutions by the withQanarbitrary constant quaternion. is associated to the double degeneracy of adjoint zero-modes. We must also point out certain subtleties necessary to understand Eq. (22) and their solutions. The main idea is that the equation must be unders tood as one relating two operators acting on the space two-component functions of the form Eq. (19). The right-hand side of Eq. (22) acts by multip lication. Thus, the left-hand side must be equivalent, when acting over our s pace of functions, to the multiplication by a linear combination of delta functio ns. This imposes non-trivial conditions on the form of dqR. In what follows we will give the possible values for dqRthat follow from the previous analysis, as well as the resulting form for the equation for psR, skipping all the details of the showing the equations, we recall that psRis a 2x2 matrix in (Nahm- dual) colour space psR(z) (23) The boundary conditions specify that it is enough to know the formo other components can be obtained by translating in zby 1/2). The 7equations for ps11coincide with those for the Q= 1 caloron, and therefore can be associated with deformations that are periodic in time. Thus, our zero-modes should follow from the (24) where the function ^Ais given = arbitrary quaternion Qreflects the degeneracy of solutions Keeping that in mind one only needs to solve the equation for Q= 0 andQ= 1. A particular solution is all that is needed, since the general solu- tion can be obtained by linear combinations of these ones with quater The counting matches the predictions of the index the orem. As for the periodic case there are essentially two CP-pairs of zero-mo des. After these considerations we proceed to show the two particular solutions that we will need. The first one corresponds to the inhomogeneous equation (Q= 1) and is given by ps12= (26) The value of dqRassociated to it expressions can now be introduced into the general formula Eq. (8) to obtain the first quantities uandoare the ones associated to the Q= 1 caloron. The analytic expressions needed to do the calculation were explicitly given in our previous paper [11]. 8Now we investigate the other solution, associated to dqR= 0. One has to solve the homogeneous equation (24) for vanishing right hand side. A par ticular solution is given by ps12(z) = phs(z)-t3pha(z). (29) Since ^A(z') is constant at intervals, the integral in the exponent is trivial to perform. We leave the explicit form of phs(z) andpha(z) to the reader. It is interesting to point out nonetheless, that phs(z) is periodic in zwith the previous expression we can compute the corresponding s using Eq. (8). The result is given (30) Again, the integration over zcan be performed analytically using the formulas of our previous paper [11]. We have arrived to the general solution our problem. The adjoint ze ro-modes of the (self-dual) caloron which are antiperiodic in time are Ps (31) whereVaare arbitrary constant spinors and dA(a) uare given in is interesting to mention that the general investigation of the po ssible values ofdqRhas led to another solution having a fairly simple form. The expression of the left-handed Weyl spinor, Ps(3)Ps(3) ata, , a colour component, saacts on the spin indices and Vdenotes an arbitrary constant 2-spinor. The functions Tadepend on the colour The function khis essentially the function with the same name given in Ref. [2,3]. Curiously this solutio n interpolates between the periodic adjoint ze ro-mode for m1= 0 (d1= 0) and one of our antiperiodic solutions (Eq. (28)) for m1=m2 (d1= 1/4). Using the formulas of the next section it can be proven that the solution is neither periodic non antiperiodic for other values of the ma ssm1. 93 Properties of the solutions In this section we will investigate the general properties of the solu tions found in the previous section. 3.1 Periodicity in time Here we will explicitly verify therequired antiperiodicity intime ofour ge neral solution. In our gauge the caloron vector potential (33) Thus, the required antiperiodicity of the adjoint zero-modes amou nts to: Ps(x0+1) (34) This property follows easily from the form of our solutions and the pe of u: u(z,x0+1) (35) and an identical relation for oandq. 3.2 Far-field limit and reader might question whether our general solution Eq. (31) is nor- malizable. One can investigate the behaviour at points whose distanc e to the location of the constituent monopoles ( r1andr2) is much larger that band thatpr2. For the unequal mass case the zero-mode density goes to zero exponentially as e-(m2-m1)r2. The equal mass case ( m1=m2=p) is more subtle since both solutions decay in power-like fashion. The no n- homogeneous solution Eq. (28) coincides with the additional solution Eq. (32) in this case. In the limit under consideration khgoes to zero exponentially and F= Thus the density behaves as 1 /r4. An alternative approach to normalizability of the solutions is to compu te the norm of the solutions. In fact there exist a general formula [2,19] w hich allows one to compute the norm and the scalar products of the solutions in terms of Nahm-data directly. This is also useful in checking if the real dimensio nality of 10the space of solutions is 8 (4 complex dimensions, 2 quaternionic dimen sions), as indicated by the index theorem. Using this formula we cosh(4p2r2d1), (38) 3.3 Profile of the zero-mode density In this subsection we will describe the qualitative properties of the z For that purpose we developed two independent progra ms to draw these profiles. Both programs give matching results. In Fig. 1 we giv e the contour plot in a z-y plane of the solution dA(2) u(top) and an (bottom) for r= 1 (giving an intermediate size caloron separation) and two representative values of the masses. The zaxis is the line joining the constituent monopoles and is represented horizontally. The ve rtical axis denotes the yaxis (the density is axially symmetric). For the equal mass case ( m1=m2=p) the mode following from Eq. (30) has an approximately constant higher density along the line joining both c alorons (top left). This can be interpreted as a string. In contrast, the o ther to Eq. (28) has a region of small density located along th e line joining the two monopoles (bottom left). As the masses become une qual, the most massive monopole dominates the densities. The right contour p lots show the situation for d1= 0.23. 3.4 Limiting cases The caloron is an interesting solution which interpolates between the gauge potential of an instanton and that of a BPS monopole. It is interest ing then to see how our antiperiodic zero-modes behave in these extreme ca ses. We will first concentrate in the situation corresponding to the trivial h olonomy, caloron: d1= 0. In that case one of the is massless and pushed to infinity. The rparameter of the so- lution does no longer control the separation between the monopole s but is still a free parameter. For small rthe HS caloron approaches an ordinary, zero temperature, instanton. From our general formulas, it is ea sy to check that in that limit and close to the center of the caloron the time period icity becomes irrelevant and the two zero mode CP-pairs approach the p eriodic 11-4 -2 0 2 4-4-2024 zy -4 -2 0 2 4-4-2024 zy -4 -2 0 2 4-4-2024 zy -4 -2 0 2 4-4-2024 zy 0 0.5 1 Fig. 1. Contour plots of the density of the two antiperiodic z ero modes in the y-z plane. Constituent monopoles are localized at y= 0 and separated along the z axis which is drawn horizontally. Left: For m1=m2=pandr= 1. Right: For d1= 0.23 andr= 1. zero modes of the instanton. In the opposite, r- , limit the HS caloron becomes a BPS monopole with time independent action density. Despit e the time independence of the background there are still 4 non-trivial a They can be easily derived from Eqs. (28) and (30) by taking the appropriate d1= 0 andr- limits. Up to a gauge transformation directly derived from Eq. (30) and dA(1)' uis the combination of Eqs. (28) and (30) orthogonal to dA(2) u. In the expression above, Ebps ais the 12electric field of the BPS (41) and we have introduced the time independent quantity:
~Ea(x) =u/sinh(u),g'(u) its derivative with respect to u, ^n=xiti/r. The antiperiodicity of the solution is encoded in the time dependent quaternions - e2 1and -e2 2defined (43) For non-trivial holonomy there is also an interesting limit in which the ca loron solution tends to the BPS monopole. It corresponds to making the s eparation of the constituent monopoles tend to infinity ( r- ). Our adjoint zero- modes lead to those of the BPS monopole if the appropriate limit is take n (r1<< pr2,r >>1). For example, for the equal mass case ( m1=m2=p) the first solution Eq. (28) follows quite simply by applying the appropr iate limit to Eq. (32). Computing the density we is the derivative of h(u)ucoth(u). This profile has axial sym- metry depending explicitly on the azimuthal angle th. Notice also that the solution is Comparison with numerical results We have crosschecked our results with a direct evaluation of adjoin t zero- modes on the torus obtained by lattice methods using Neuberger's o verlap operator [17] in the adjoint representation. One expects that th e spatial pro- file of the torus solutions approaches our analytical formulas as th e box size becomes much larger than all scales of the problem ( bandpr2). To make a quantitative comparison we computed the zero-mode density inte grated in time along the line x=y= 0 joining both constituent monopoles. It is not possible a priori to construct numerical zero-modes with a prescr ibed value of randd1, although some tuning is possible [18]. For the numerical in Fig. 2 we slightly tuned by hand these parameters to impro ve the 13 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 zAnalitic 1 Analitic 2 Numerical 1 Numerical 2 Fig. 2. Comparison between numerical (circles) and analyti c (lines) zero modes for r= 0.79 andd1= 0.172. We display the density of the zero modes, integrated in time, along the line joining the two ( r= 0.79,d1= 0.172). A technical point which one has to address is how to guarantee that the same linear combinations are selected f or the numerical and analytical data. We chose to define the two linearly ind epen- dent modes by imposing that at the center of mass ( x=y=z= 0) one has maximal and the other minimal density (integrated over time). 4 Conclusions In this paper we have obtained analytic formulas for the zero-mode s of the Dirac equation for gluinos in the background field of Q=1 SU(2) caloro ns boundary conditions in thermal-time. Our formulas are v alid nandinclude as a limiting case those of BPS monopoles. The solutions have finite nor m and decay exponentially with distance if the masses of the constituent m onopoles differ. Their density profile contrasts with the case of periodic zero -modes. For example, as the monopoles are pulled apart the density does not dec ouple into independent lumps centered at the monopoles, but rather describ es a string joining the monopoles. Nonetheless, the number of normalizable zer o-modes matches in both cases. Our work interest since our approachis applicab le to other cases including the extension to SU(N), and might be instrumental in finding formulas for calorons of higher charge. From a physical viewpoint o ur work provides a first step towards a semiclassical study of N=1 SUSY Yan g-Mills at finite temperature. There are interesting issues at stake such as that of supersymmetry breaking at finite temperature, which has been a s ubject of debate since early times [20]-[26]. It is our intention to address these questions in future would like to thank Falk Bruckmann for discussions at the initial sta ges of this work. We acknowledge financial support from Comunidad Aut ' onoma de Madrid under the program HEPHACOS P-ESP-00346. A.S. is suppo rted by an FPU fellowship of Spanish Research Ministry (MEC). M.G.P. and A.G-A acknowledge financial support from grants from CICYT FPA2 006- 05807, FPA2006-05485 and FPA2006-05423 . The authors partic ipate in 2010 CPAN (CSD2007-00042). We acknowledge the use of the IFT cluster for part of our numerical B. J. Harrington and H. K. Shepard, Phys. Rev. D 17, 2122 (1978). Phys. Rev. D18(1978) 2990. [2] T. C. Kraan and P. van Baal, Nucl. Phys. B 533(1998) T. C. Kraan and P. van Baal, Phys. Lett. B 428(1998) T. C. Kraan and P. van Baal, Phys. L ett. B435(1998) 389 K. M. Lee, Phys. Lett. B 426(1998) 323 K. M. Lee and C. h. Lu, Phys. Rev. D 58, 025011 (1998) P. Rossi, Phys. Rept. 86(1982) 317. [6] B. Grossman, Phys. Lett. A 61(1977) 86 [7] N. Bilic, Phys. Lett. B 97(1980) 107. [8] A. Gonzalez-Arroyo and Yu. A. Simonov, Nucl. Phys. B 460(1996) M. Garc' ia P' erez, A. Gonz' alez-Arroyo, C. Pena and P. va n Baal, Phys. Rev. D 60(1999) 031901 M. N. Chernodub, T. C. Kraan and P. van Baal, Nucl. Phys. P roc. Suppl. 83(2000) 556 F. Bruckmann, D. Nogr adi and P. van Baal, Nucl. Phys. B 666(2003) 197 M. Garc' ia P' erez and A. Gonz' alez-Arroyo, JHEP 0611(2006) A. Gonz' alez-Arroyo, Nucl. Phys. B 548(1999) 626 A. Gonz' alez-Arroyo and C. Pena, JHEP 9809 (1998) M. Garc' ia P' erez, A. Gonz' alez- Arroyo, C. Pena and P. van Baal, Nucl. Phys. B 564(2000) 159 F. Bruckmann and P. van Baal, Nucl. Phys. B 645, 105 F. Bruckmann, D. Nogradi and P. va n Baal, Nucl. Phys. B 698(2004) 233 M. F. Atiyah, N. J. Hitchin, V. G. Drinfeld and Y. I. Manin , Phys. Lett. A 65 (1978) 185. [16] W. Nahm, Phys. Lett. B 90(1980) 413; All Selfdual Multi - Monopoles For Arbitrary Gauge Groups, CERN-TH-3172 Presented at Int. Summer Inst. on Theoretical Physics, Freiburg, West Germany, Aug 31 - Sep 11, 1981 [17] H. Neuberger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81(1998) 4060 Phys. Lett. B427(1998) 353 Phys. Lett. B 417(1998) M. Garc' ia P' erez, A. Gonz' alez-Arroyo, A. Montero and P. van Baal, JHEP 9906 (1999) 001 T. C. Kraan, Commun. Math. Phys. 212(2000) 503 A. K. Das and M. Kaku, Phys. Rev. D 18(1978) 4540. [21] L. Girardello, M. T. Grisaru and P. Salomonson, Nucl. Ph ys. B178(1981) 331. [22] L. Van Hove, Nucl. Phys. B 207(1982) 15. [23] H. Aoyama and D. Boyanovsky, Phys. Rev. D 30(1984) 1356. [24] D. Boyanovsky, Phys. Rev. D 29(1984) 743. [25] H. Matsumoto, M. Nakahara, Y. Nakano and H. Umezawa, Phy s. Lett. B 140 (1984) 53; Phys. Rev. D 29(1984) 2838. [26] D. Buchholz and I. Ojima, Nucl. Phys. B 498(1997)
|
0807.2285
|
Antonio Gonzalez-Arroyo
|
Margarita Garcia Perez, Antonio Gonzalez-Arroyo and Alfonso Sastre
|
Gluino zero-modes for calorons at finite temperature
|
Latex, 16 pages, 2 figures
|
Phys.Lett.B668:340-345,2008
|
10.1016/j.physletb.2008.08.071
|
IFT-UAM/CSIC-08-30 and FTUAM-08-09
|
hep-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study the solutions of the Dirac equation in the adjoint
representation(gluinos) in the background field of SU(2) unit charge calorons.
Our solutions are forced to be antiperiodic in thermal time and would occur
naturally in a semiclassical approach to N=1 Super-symmetric Yang-Mills theory
at finite temperature.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 15 Jul 2008 00:08:23 GMT"
}
] | 2008-11-26T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Perez",
"Margarita Garcia",
""
],
[
"Gonzalez-Arroyo",
"Antonio",
""
],
[
"Sastre",
"Alfonso",
""
]
] |
Continuing the analogy with thermodynamics one can say that ( -Tlnsn)/nis Then with help of observed free (1) isquiet general. Itcanbeused bothforhadron-h both for low and high energies, both for boiling media of co loured partons and colorless hadrons. Definition (1) is model free and operates on ly with measurable parameters. The single indispensable condition: we work in the VHM region. We will discuss in the paper the chance of experimental measuremen t ofu(n,s) defined by (1), what kind uncertainties hides it from experimental point of view noting the the cross sections in VHM domain are small. The correction to (1) are not essential in the VHM region but nevertheless the definition o f chemical potential in using Wigner functions formalism [4] will be published, see also [3]. II. It is necessary to remind main steps toward (1) to understand hidd en uncertainties. The starting point [2] was the generating fun ction r(z,s) r(1,s) = 1, sn= 0 atn > nmax=s/m, (2) wheremis the hadron mass. One may use inverse Mellin (3) to findsnifr(z,s) is known. One may calculate integral (3) by saddle point method. The equation (of (4) defines mostly essential value z=z(n,s). Therefore, only z < zmax=z(nmax,s) (5) have the physical meaning. One may write r(z,s) in the form: r(z,s) = (6) where the Mayer group coefficient blcan be expressed through correlators ck(s): bl(s) us assume now that we have Poisson distribution, i.e. if in the sum: lnr(z,s) (7) one may leave first term, then it is easy to see that z(n,s) =n/c1(s), c1(s)-n(s), (8) 2Notice that one may consider nas the multiplicity in the experimentally observable range of essential and in the VHM region: lnsn(s) in considered case with ck= 0, k >1,exist following asymptotic estimation forn >>1: lnsn -nlnz(n,s), (10) i.e.snis defined in VHM region mainly by the solution of Eq.(4) and the correct ion can not change this conclusion. It will be shown that that kind estima tion is hold for arbitrary asymptotics of sn. The definition (1) based on this observation. If we understand snas the partition function in the VHM region then zis defined trough z: u=Tlnz. (11) Combining this definition with estimation (10) we define snthrough u. does not depend from asymptotics of snovern, i.e. if it has general meaning, then it can be used for definition of u(n,s) through sn(s) andT(n,s) atn >>1. Just this formal idea is realized in (1): it can be shown in Sec.III that (1) is c orrect at the asymptotical value of n. III. Now we will make the important step. To put in a good order our intuitio n it is useful to consider r(z,s) as the nontrivial function of z. In statistical physics limit isconsidered forthispurpose. Inourcaseth efiniteness ofenergysand of the hadron mass mput obstacles on this way since the system of necessarily belongs to the energy-momentum surface3. But we can s nto the range n > nmaxand consider r(z,s) as the nontrivial function of z. This step hides the assumption that nothing new appear at n > nmax, i.e. the VHM interval -n << n < n maxis sufficiently wide to represent main physical processes. Let us consider the analog generating function which has the first n < n maxcoeffi- cient of expansion over zequal to snand higher coefficients for n>=nmaxare deduced from continuation of theoretical value of snton>=nmax. Then the inverse (3) gives a good estimation of snthrough this generating function if the fluctuations near z(n,s) are Gaussian or, it is the same, (12) Notice that if the estimation (10) is generally rightful then one can e asily find that l.h.s. of (12) is ~1/n1/2. Therefore, one may consider r(z,s) as the nontrivial function of z considering z(n,s)< zmaxif -n << n < n max. Then it is easily deduce that the asymptotics of sn(s) is defined by the leftmost sin- gularity, zc, of function r(z,s) since, as it follows from Eq.(4), the singularity attracts the solution z(n,s)in the VHM region . In result we may classify asymptotics of snin the VHM region if (12) is hold. Our problem isreduced to thedefinition ofpossible locationof leftmos t singularity of r(z,s) overz >04. It must be stressed that the character of singularity is not impor tant 3It must be noted that the canonical thermodynamic system belong s to the energy-momentum shell because of the energy exchange, i.e. interaction, with thermosta t. The width of the shell is defined by the temperature. But in particle physics there is no thermostat an d the physical system to the energy momentum surface. 4The singularities in complex zplane will not be considered since they lead only to oscillations in multiplicity definition of u(n,s) in the VHM region at least with O(1/lnn) accuracy. One may consider only three possibility at n- : (I)z(n,s)-zc= 1; (II) (III)z(n,s)-zc=. The structure of complex zplane is much more complicate but for our purpose the above described picture is suffic O(e-n); (II)sn=O(e-n). Such asymptotics is typical for hard processes with large transverse momenta, like for jets [3]; (III) sn< O(e-n). That is typical for kinematics, where the long itudinal momenta of produced particles are noticeably higher than the transverse o nes [3]. Therefore the case (I) is the best candidate for phase transition since in this case the cross sections are comparatively large in the VHM region, i.e. particle s in that case. Notice that if (I) is not realized in nature the n the (II) kind processes would dominate in the VHM region. Let us consider now the estimation (1). It follows from (3) that, up to the preexpo- nential factor, lns(n,s) (13) We want to show that, in a vide range of nfrom VHM (14) Let as consider now the mostly characteristic at z= 1. The physical meaning of singularity at z= 1 may be illustrated by the droplet model [6]. The Mayer's group coefficient, se e (6), for >>1, the dimension. Therefore, if d >1 the series over lin (6) diverges at z= 1. This case was considered in [2] in details. In the used lattice gas appro lnsn -n-4=-nlnz(n)(1 +O(1/n)).Notice that the simplest droplet model predicts unphysical asymptotics: sn-constin the VHM at 1< zc<. Let us consider one jet contribution: ln r(z,s) In this case z(n,s) =zc(1-g/n), n >> g, and at z=. ForkPomeron exchange: ln r(z,s) =ck(s)(z-1)k. In this case z(n) = (n/kck)1/k>>1 and lnsn can conclude: (i) The definition (1) in the VHM region is rightful since the correction falls down withn. On this stage we can give only the qualitative estimation of correctio ns. Nev- ertheless (1) gives the correct ndependence in the VHM region. (ii) Activity z(n,s) tends to zcfrom the right in the case (I) and from the left if we have the case (II) or (III). (iii) The accuracy of estimation of the chemical potential (1) increa se from (III) Tisthenext problem. (KMS) periodic boundary conditions. But t his way assumes from the very beginning that the system (a) is equilibrium and (b) is su rrounded by thermostat through which the temperature is determined. The fir st condition (a) we take as the simplification which gives the equilibrium state. The second one (b) is the problem since there is no thermostat in par ticle physics. For this reason we introduce the temperature as the Lagrange mu ltiplierb= 1/T of energy conservation law [3]. In such approach the condition that the system is in 4equilibrium with thermostat replaced by the condition that the fluctu ations in vicinity ofbare Gaussian. The interesting for us r(z,s) we define through inverse Laplace transform of r(z,b): r(z,s) (15) It is known that if the interaction radii is finite, i.e. the hadron mass is finite, then the equation (of (16) have real positive solution b(n,s) atz=z(n,s). We will assume that the are Gaussian. This means that the inequality Therefore, we prepare the formalismto findthermod ynamic description is hold5. I want to underline that our thermal equilibrium condition (17) have a bsolute mean- ing: if it is not satisfied then b(n,s) loses every sense since the expansion in leads to the asymptotic series. In this case only the dynamical des cription of S-matrix can be used. It is not hard to see [3] e >)>n,s (18) is thel-point energy correlator, where < ... > n,smeans averaging over all events with given multiplicity and energy. Therefore (17) means relaxation of l-point correlations, l >2, measured in units of the dispersion of energy fluctuations, l= 2. One can note here the difference of our definition of thermal equilibrium from ther modynamical one [5]. V. We may conclude that: (i) The definition of chemical potential (1) was discussed. This impor tant observable can be measured on the experiment directly. Chemical potential, u(n,s), must decrease in the VHM region if the first order phase transition occur, case (I) , and it rise in opposite case, see (II) and (III), see Sec.III. (ii) We are forced to assume that the energy and the multiplicity are s i.e. the experimental value zexp(n,s) is sufficiently close to zc= 1. In opposite case the leading leftmost singularity over zwould not be seen on experiment and the production processes constitutes from the complicated mixture o f The cross section snfalls down rapidly with nand for this reason the VHM events are hardly observable. One may avoid this problem considerin g the finite en- ergy heavy ion collisions as the most candidates of processes descr ibed by methods and zcis easier reachable in this of b(n,s) allows to describe the system of large number of degrees of freed om in terms of single parameter b(n,s), i.e. it is nothing but the useful trick. It is no way for this reason to 1 /b(n,s) with thermodynamic temperature where it has the self-contained physical path-integral representation of r(b,z) defined from S-matrix coincides with Feynman- Kac representation of grand partition function [3] if (17) is hold. I t must be noted also that the energy spectrum of produced particle in this case have Boltzmann form, e-be. 5(iv) One can define z(n,s) also directly from (19) using experimental values sexp n(s). But comparing (19) with definition (10), nlnz -lnsexp n(s), (20) it seems that last one gives more definite value of zexp(n,s) than the integral since thestatistical to Eq.(20) are small, the results we conclude: if the energy is sufficiently large, i.e. if close to zc= 1, if the multiplicity is sufficiently large, so that (17) is sat be sufficiently close to zc, then one may have confident answer on the question: observable or not the first order phase transition in hadron/ion collisions. The heavy ion collisions are favorable to observe the phase tran would like to thank participants of 7-th International Workshop o n the Very High Multiplicity Physics (JINR, Dubna) for stimulating discussions. I am grateful to V.Priezzhev, A.Sissakian, A.Sorin and V.Kekelidze for valuable attentio BNL Report, Hunting the Quark Gluon Plasma , BNL-73847-2005; C.Alt et al., The NA-49 Collaboration, M.Creutz, Phys. Rev., D1 5 (1977) and M.I.Gorenstein, Acta Physica Polonica, B 30, 2705, ( 1999) [2] J.Manjavidze and A.Sissakian, Proc. VHM Physics Workshops , (World J.Manjavidze and A.Sissakian, Phys. Rep., 346 (2001) 1, hep-ph/ 0105245 [4] J.Manjavidze, Phys.Part.Nucl. 30 (1999) 49, N.N.Bogolyubov, Studies in Statistical Mechanics, (North-Holland Publ. Co., Am- sterdam, 1962) [6] T.D.Lee and C.N.Yang, Phys.Rev., 87 (1952) 404, 410; J.S.Langer, A nn.Phys., 41 (1967) 108 6
|
0807.2322
|
Joseph Manjavidze
|
J. Manjavidze
|
On phase transition signal in inelastic collision
|
6 pages, no figures, LaTex
| null | null | null |
hep-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The paper is devoted to retrieval of the first order phase transition signal
in the inelastic collisions. The primary intent is to show that the
experimentally observable signal exist iff the multiplicity is sufficiently
large. We discuss corresponding phenomenology from point of view of the
experiment.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 15 Jul 2008 08:56:34 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 17 Jul 2008 09:36:27 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-17T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Manjavidze",
"J.",
""
]
] |
ph -1 0 1 2 3 4 5)ph assoc p Ttrigger p total-charge correlation error net-charge errors) STAR Preliminary FIG. 1: Background subtracted azimuthal correlations of ne t-charge (data points) and total-charge in 12% central Au+Au collisions at 200 GeV. The tr igger and associated pTranges are 3-4 GeV/cand 1-3 GeV/ c, respectively. Errors shown for the data points are statist ical only. The is scaled by 1/15 to compare with the net-charge resul t. The dashed histograms show the on the total-charge result, obtained from backgroun d subtraction using the modified and the 4-particle cumulant v2[5]. III. RESULTS AND 1 shows the background subtracted results. We find the co rrelation shapes are similar between total-charge and net-charge. The net-charge correla tion shows a significant (double-peak structure), similar to previously observ ed in total-charge [1]. We of the correlated yields by dividing the data into four as sociated pTbins. In different pTbins, the correlation shapes are also found to be similar between tot al-charge obtain associated particle pTspectra by integrating over the near-side ( |ph|<1) and the away-side ( |ph|>1). The obtained spectra are shown in Fig. 2. For comparison, we als o show the inclusive charged hadron pTspectrum (i.e. without requirement of a high pTtrigger particle). We fit the spectra by an exponential function: e-pT/T, whereTis the inverse slope parameter. The fit results are listed in Table I. TABLE I: Inverse slope parameter Tin GeV/cfrom exponential fit to the pTspectra. Errors are 0.312+-0.001 As seen from the extracted values of the inverse slope parameter , the shapes of net-charge on and the y areboth harderthan the The away-side spectrum seem s to be harder than the neither is much harder than the inclusive one.Tp1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 net-charge STAR Preliminary FIG. 2: pTspectra of net-charge (triangles) and total-charge (squar es) correlated with a high (3 < pT<4 GeV/c) on both near-side (filled symbols) and away-side (open symb ols) in AuAu central collisions at 200GeV. Errors shown are systematic e rrors. The inclusive (roundpoints) pTspectrum is also shown for comparison. Tp1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 3ratio of ratio near-side ratio inclusive ratio STAR Preliminary FIG. 3: Ratios of correlated yields of net-charge over total -charge on away-side (squares) and in 12% central Au+Au collisions at 200 GeV. The t riggerpTrange is from 3-4 GeV/ c. Vertical bars are statistical errors. Horizontal bars are the pTbin size. The curve shows the inclusive ratio where the shaded area is statitical uncertainty (the data a tpT<2.5 GeV/ care from TOF measurement, and the pT>2.5 GeV/ cdata are from TPC measurement) [2]. The inclusive bayon to meson ratio is strongly enhanced at intermedia tepTas mentioned earlier. We want to study the bayon/meson ratio of the correlated hadron s with high pTtrigger particles. We take the ratio of the pTspectra on near- and away-side separately. The obtained results areshown in Fig. 3, and compared with the inclusive ratio. The ratio of the correlated net-charge to total-charge yields on away-side is larger than that on the near-sid e. The away-side ratio is similar to the inclusive ratio, with an average difference of 0 .34s. The near-side ratio seems smaller than the inclusive ratio with an average difference of 0 .80s. Figure 3 shows that the near-side ratio is independent of pT. A fit of the near-side ratio to a constant yields 0 with a kh2/ndf= 1.7/3. This is to be compared to the inclusive ratio of 0 .050+-0.001. On the other hand, the away-side ratio appears to increase w ith pT, similar to the inclusives. A constant fit yields 0 with a significantly larger kh2/ndf= 5.4/3. IV. SUMMARY We have presented results on azimuthal correlation of net-charg e with high pTtrigger particles. The net-charge correlation shape is found to be similar to that of to tal-charge. We studied the associate pTspectraof,and the net-chargeto tota l-chargeratio. Onthe near- side, net-charge and total-charge spectra have similar shape; th e ratio is constant over pT. However, they are both harder than the inclusives, suggesting j et nature for the correlated particles. On the away-side, the correlated spect ra are not much harder than the inclusives, suggesting partial equilibration of the correlated hadro ns with the medium. The ratio increases with pTand is similar to J. Adams et al., STAR Collaboration, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 152301 (2005). [2] B.I. Abelev et al., STAR collaboration, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 152301 (2006). [3] B.I. Abelev et al., STAR collaboration, Phys. Lett. B 655, 104 (2007). [4] J. Adams et al. STAR Collaboration, Phys. Rev. C 72, 014904 (2005). [5] C. Adler et al. STAR Collaboration, Phys. Rev. C 66, 034904 (2002).
|
0807.2407
|
Quan Wang
|
Quan Wang
|
First Result of Net-Charge Jet-Correlations from STAR
| null |
Indian J.Phys.85:1181-1184,2011
|
10.1007/s12648-011-0122-7
| null |
hep-ex
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We presented results on azimuthal correlation of net-charge with high $p_T$
trigger particles. It is found that the net-charge correlation shape is similar
to that of total-charge. On the near-side, the net-charge and total-charge
$p_T$ spectra have similar shape and both are harder than the inclusives. On
the away-side, the correlated spectra are not much harder than the inclusives,
and the net-charge/total-charge ratio increases with $p_T$ and is similar to
the inclusive ratio.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 15 Jul 2008 16:04:54 GMT"
}
] | 2011-08-11T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Wang",
"Quan",
""
]
] |
2 medium affects the propagationof light pulses in such a waythat they appear to travel superluminally. In a pioneering paper [26], Icsevgi and Lamb performed a theoretical investigatio n of the propagation of intense laser pulses through a laser amplifier. Apparent superluminal light propagation has been r eported in gain-assisted systems [27, 28, 29] as well as in birefringent crystals [30, 31, 32], composite media and ph otonic crystals [33, 34] and dispersive media [35, 36]. There have also been claims of evidence of superluminal propagation in free space [37, 38] and during in frustrated total internal reflection (FTIR) configurations [39 , 40, 41, 42]. Optical tunneling has been studied by several authors, both theoretically and experimentally [43, 44, 45, 46, 47]. Some of the observed results are still subject of debatable interpretation [13] and do not close t he subject of whether there are possibilities for superluminal transmission of information in such systems. We have t herefore chosen to address this subject in way that leads to straightforward interpretation of the results while r esorting only to classical electromagnetic theory. We claim that although some results may appearto indicate superluminal propagation, there is no real of information. In this paper we analyze mathematically the propagation of a pulse ac ross a vacuum gap separating opposite flat parallel faces of two transparent dielectrics by means of an explicit ly causal and retarded propagator from the free-space wave equation. Our results yield indee d an apparent superluminal propagation corre- sponding to the but they showexplicitly that it is c onsistent with both casualityand with Our example shows superluminality effects inheren t to light pulse propagation in free space which therefore does not depend on the particulars of light-matter inte raction. The illusionof superluminality consists of transmitted pulses arriving to the far side of the gap in synchron y with the crossing of the front surface by the incident pulse. We explain this illusion of superluminal behavior in terms o f a causal, subluminal propagation, taking into account the spatial extent of the incident pulse along its trans verse as well as its longitudinal directions and we propose experiments to demonstrate the retarded nature of propagation in FTIR. Nevertheless, we find that for constrained pulses fully made up of evanescent Fourier component s, subluminal and superluminal propagation in FTIR experiments are paper is organized as follows. We first introduce a propagator t hat will allow the analyzis of propagation across a vacuum gap (Section II). This propaga tor is both casual and retarded and complies with the classical electromagnetic theory. We then study the propaga tion across the gap of pulses that arrive as plane waves with well defined angles of incidence. In Section III we study t he case of subcritical angles, yielding non- evanescent transmitted waves. In Section IV we study the case o f hypercritical angles, yielding evanescent waves. We conclude that the propagation of a light pulse in a FTIR configuration may appear superluminal and acausal but that it is actually subluminal and that propagation has to account ne cessarily for the lateral wings of the incident pulse. In Section V we suggest experiments that might demonstrat e the actual causal and subluminal nature of the apparent superluminal behavior by using sharp opaque screen s that block parts of the incident wave so that its extent becomes finite along both its propagation and its transvers e directions. Nevertheless, as the borders of these screens produce propagating diffracted waves, in Section VI we elim inate them and we study incident pulses that are finite along several spatial directions but that have a smooth p rofile. We obtain that if they are comprised of evanescent Fourier components only, they appear to propagate superluminally through the vacuum gap, even though their behavior is determined by our causal retarded propagator. In Section VII we construct an alternative it to the appliedto fully evanescent finite pulses. Thus, for such constrained pulses, it is impossible to distinguish causal subluminal from acausaland superluminal propagation; the illusion appearsto be not onlya maybe alsopresentinthe descriptionofth We present our conclusions in Section VIII. II. two transparent dielectrics occupying the regions z<=0 andz>=d. In this section we obtain the causal and retarded propagator that describes the motion of a pulse across a vacuum gap 0 <z<dspanning from the interface atz= 0 to that at z=d(Fig. 1). As we want to consider explicitly the angle of incidence onto t he interface z= 0, we cannot treat the problem beforehand as if it were 1D. For simplicit y, we will assume full translational symmetry along theydirection, so that our problem becomes 2D. Thus, we start with the scalar wave 1: Pulse with arbitrary profile incident at an angle thi< thconto the surface z= 0 of a dielectric with index of refraction n= 2. The pulse is transmitted into a vacuum gap and into a secon d dielectric at z=d. The speed of propagation within are indicated, as well as the speed of propagation of the wav efronts along the interfaces v/bardbl. with a unit singular point source fired at time t'at position ( x',z'), which is solved by the explicitly causal and retarded free space Green's function (2) where Th(...) is the Heaviside unit step function. Using image theory we can const ruct a Green's function that obeys Dirichlet boundary conditions at the surface z= (3) In the half-space z >0 Green's theorem yields the solution [48] ph(t,x,z) (4) of the homogeneous scalar wave equation that is outgoing as z- and is null in the remote past, where its previous values on the boundary z= 0+, (5) is the causal retarded propagator of the problem. We may identify the fieldphwith the component Eyof the the case of a TE or spolarized incoming wave, and with the component Byof the magnetic field /vectorBin the case of TM or ppolarization. The propagator(5) does not account for the prese nce of the two dielectrics bounding the air gap. Thus, the field (4) has no information about the multiple refle ctions at the boundary of the gap. In principle, these can be incorporated by reflecting the field at the interfaces z= 0,dusing the appropriate Fresnel coefficient and propagating it back and forth across the gap with the propagator (5) for the z= 0 surface and a similar one for the z=dsurface. The total field would then be the sum of all the multiply refle cted fields and would have the electromagnetic properties of the reflecting surfaces . In this paper we will restrict ourselves to an analysis of the first crossing of the air gap 0+-d-, and thus our results will be unrelated to the nature of the boundin Eq. (2) into (3) and (5) we (6) The fieldphcan then be written in terms of an ancillary =- zps(t,x,z), (8) plays the role ofa potential and the integrationis performed within t he Clearly, the procedure above yields a causal (sub)luminal propagation from th ez= 0+plane to any point in the z>0 vacuum. III. NON-EVANESCENT WAVE TRANSMISSION We consider now that an arbitrarily shaped pulse impinges at a well defined angle thion the inside surface z= 0-of a homogeneous non-dispersive dielectric with index of refraction n(Fig. 1). The incident pulse is therefore described by an arbitrary function phi(t,x,z) r] of a single variable r, where is a unit vector pointing along the angle of incidence thiand/vector r(x,z). Notice that in this case the incident wavefronts have an infinite extension in the direction normal to ^ ni. Atz= 0+and after being transmitted into vacuum, the outgoing field can therefore be written as ph(t,x,0+) (9) whereftis related to the arbitrary function fiand the Fresnel amplitude for transmission from the dielectric into vacuum. As we are concerned only with propagation across the vac uum gap, we will take ftas given and we will disregard its relation with fi, which would involve the dielectric properties of the incident medium. The pulsewith the interface z= 0is thereforeseento travelalong xwith velocity to be confused with the parallel component of the incident velo city ^nic/n). For incidence angles smaller than the critical angle th < thc= cand we have normal transmission, while for th > thc,v/bardbl< cand total internal reflection ensues. In order to set up a reference with which to compare the evanesce nt case, in this section we employ our propagator to study a non-evanescent plane pulse. Thus, we consider here th e caseth<thcand we substitute Eq. (9) into Eq. (8) to obtain ps(t,x,z) changing integration variables from The integration (10) has to be performed over Thus,t''has an upper and for each value of t''<tm,x'is bounded by the ehelpofFig. 2. Consideranevent E= (ct,x,z) defined by the observation of the field at a given position ( x,z) withz >0 and at a given time t. Causality requires that only events within the past light-cone of Eare able to influence it. Notice that a given value of t''denotes a point that moves along xkeeping a fixed position with respect to the intersection of the incide nt pulse with the z= 0 interface. In Fig. 2 we show the world lines ( ct',x',0) of a few such points. Since each of them moves with 2: Contributions to the non-evanescent wave observed a t an event E= (t,x,z). Some world lines ( source points labeled by fixed values of t''and thus moving on the z= 0 plane along with the incident pulse are shown. The positions x'
+-denote the intersections of the past light cone of Ewith one of the world lines plotted. We consider the case v/bardbl> c. The coordinate and time axes are most of its world line lies outside the past light cone of E. Only ift''<tmcan it actually cross the light cone, entering and leaving at positions the change of variables from (13) Eq. (10) simplifies to ps(t,x,z) (14) The integration over eis immediate, so that substituting Eq. (14 in Eq.(7) we obtain r/c). (15) where ^nt= (u,n). Thus, as illustrated in Fig. 1, the transmitted wave is a pulse with th e same profile as the incident field and propagating with speed cat the well defined angle tht= sin-1u= cos-1n, in accordance with Snell's law as could have been expected. IV. EVANESCENT WAVE TRANSMISSION We consider now the case thi>thc, for which v/bardbl<cand the transmitted wave becomes evanescent. In this case we substitute Eq. (9) into Eq. (8) to obtain ps(t,x,z) (16) after introducing the variables As shown in Fig. 3, for any observation event Eand any value of t'', there is exactly one intersection x'' -between the past light cone of Eand the world where now and we introduced the definitions We have assumed that v/bardbl>0. As the world line leaves the past light cone at x'' -, in Eq. (16) the integration over t''is unconstrained and that over x''extends from -tox'' -. Another change of variable, (18)6 x'' 3: Contributions to the evanescent wave observed at an e ventE= (ct,x,z) as in Fig. 2, but for v/bardbl< c. The position x'' - denotes the intersections of the past light cone of Ewith one of the world lines corresponding to t''. The integrals over x''and overein Eqs. (16) and (18) respectively yield an infinite value for ps. This divergence is not unlike that commonly found for the electromagnetic potentials produced by infinitely extended sources. For example, when calculating the electric field produced by a uniformly ch arged plane one cannot simply obtain potential by integrating the Coulomb kernel over t he whole surface. However, in that case the electric field may be obtained either by deriving the Coulomb kernel first and in tegrating afterwards or else, by truncating the integrations at a finite distance, deriving the resulting potential to obtain the field and afterwards taking the limit of an infinite surface. Here we follow the later procedure. Thus, we se t a finite lower integration limit x'' Lin Eq. to a lowest point eLin Eq. (18), and we take the limit x'' L- -,eL- -after obtaining the on zonly through eL, substituting Eq. (18) in (7) we obtain ph(t,x,z) (19) In the limit x'' L- -we (20) and we obtain (21) Taking the absolute value of v/bardblin the numerator of Eq. (21) allows its use also for v/bardbl<0. To grasp the meaning of Eq. (21) we evaluate it for an infinitely sharp into Eq. (21) yields ph(t,x,z) at any time tthe pulse transmitted at a distance zfrom the interface is given by a Lorentzian of in front of the actual position x=v/bardbltof the incident pulse on the z= 0 surface (Fig. 4). Thus, the propagation seems to be instantaneous in the direction normal to t he surface, and actually, part of the pulse seems to travel backwards in time [39, 47], as at a position ( x,z) it becomes appreciable at times t <x/v /bardbl, that is, before the incoming pulse reaches the corresponding position ( x,0). However, our deduction of Eq. (22) shows that it is completely consistent with a causal and retarded propagation, an d that the field at a ( x,z) at timetis not by the incoming field at ( x,0), but arises from previously excited positions ( x',0) 4: Infinitely sharp wavefront (heavy solid line) incide nt at an angle th= 34.5*> thcupon the surface of a dielectric with index of refraction n= 2. The pulse widens and diminishes as it is transmitted acro ss an air gap and into a second dielectric. The thin lines indicate the nominal pulse width and the dashe d line its center. It is interesting to note that, according to Eq. (23), the height of the transmitted pulse is inversely proportional to the distance zfrom the surface, instead of decaying exponentially as usually foun d for evanescent waves. However, Eq. (23) describes the propagation into vacuum of a single infinitely s harp incident wavefront. In a wavetrain made up of a succession of incident pulses, the regions excited by neighbo ring pulses overlap each other, as the width of each transmitted pulse increases in proportion to z, and therefore their corresponding fields interfere. This interfe rence is at the origin of the exponential decay of periodic waves, as can be v erified by choosing ft(t) =Ae-iot(24) and substituting into Eq. (21), which yields ph(t,x,z) (25) A simple contour integration closing the integration path with an infinit e semicircle on the lower half complex t'' plane yields the familiar result ph(t,x,z) =Aei(Qx-ot)-kz, the parallel component of the wave vector and 1/l the inverse of the decay length l. Asoincreases, the distance along xbetween successive maxima and yielding larger interference effects and a shorter dec ay length. V. SCREENS The results of the previous section suggest an experiment that co uld confirm that propagation of evanescent waves in the FTIR geometry is not superluminal nor acausal. The experimen t could be performed simply by the surface of the first interface with a couple of opaque screens as shown in Fig. 5. If transmission were indeed superluminal, we would expect a non-null transmitted field ph(t,xa,d) across the gap in front of the edge xa of the first screen Saas soon as the leading wavefront Fof the incident pulse reaches xa. Similarly, we would expect that the field ph(t,xb,d) would be modified as soon as Freaches the edge xbof the second screen Sb. To calculate the field corresponding to Fig. 5 we go back to Eq. (16). The screens confine the integration region to the interval xa< x'=x+x''< xb. This inequality has to be obeyed together with the previous constr 5: Pulse as in Fig. 1 but impinging on the surface of the fir st dielectric at an angle thi> thc. The surface is covered by semi-infinite opaque screens SaandSbwith edges at xaandxb. The leading wavefront of the incoming pulse is about to reac h xa.Fdenotes the foremost These conditions can only be satisfied by those wavefronts which h ave reached xaand left behind the first screen before t-Ta, whereTi= is the minimum time required to reach ( x,z) from (xi,0) moving at speed c. Thus, only those points on the wavefront labeled by t''>T'' acan contribute to i=a,b. (27) For those wavefronts which have left Saby timeTabut have not reached Sbat timeTb, namely, those with the integral over x''in Eq. (16) has to be performed from x'' a=x+xaup tox'' -. Finally, for those wavefronts which have already been blocked by Sbby timeTb, namely, those with t''<T'' b, the upper limit of integration has to be replaced by x'' b=x+xb. we used the change of variables (17) and substituted x''-x+xiin it to define the limits ei. Notice that ps depends on zonly through the integration limits ei, so that substituting Eq. (28) in (7) we obtain ps(t,x,z) (30) xLis given by Eq. (20)and ziz(x'' i,t'') with z(x'',t'') Eqs. (17) and (30) in (29) we finally obtain ph(t,x,z) (ct/d) Position (x/d)tata FIG. 6: Field isolines of ph(t,x,d) produced by an unit delta function input pulse that propaga tes along the z= 0 surface and is blocked at x < x a=-3dandx > x b= 3dby opaque screens (shaded regions). The world line x=v/bardblt of the incident pulse is indicated by a dashed line. The times taandtbwhen the incident pulse cross the edges of each screen are indicated by the horizontal dot-dashed lines. The singu larities of the transmitted field are indicated by the thick s = (33) Notice that the field phin the presence of screens (Eq. (32)) is given by an expression simila r to that corresponding to the field in the absence of screens (Eq. (21)) but with a correct ion termCdue to the diffraction by the screen. As in the previous section, we consider again the case of a sharp incid ent pulse Eq. (22). Substituting in (32) ifct<x ifct>x otherwise .(34) We remark that the field is zero until the time xa/v/bardblwhen the incident pulse shows up from behind the screen Sa, and this information has had enough time (1 propagate from the screen's edge ( xa,0) to the observation point ( x,z). Similarly, the information that the pulse has hidden behind screen Sbdoes not reach the observation point until the time The field has singularities due to the passage of the incident pulse through the screen edges, that propagate at spee dcfrom the events ( xa/b,xa,0) and that z(xi-x,0)-1 asx- . Thus, if we follow the incident pulse, i.e., we take xv/bardblt, after the pulse hides behind Sb. Furthermore, if the screens are very far apart we recover the field (23) between the screens. The features above are illustrated in Fig. 6 which show the transmitt ed field at the plane z=d. Notice the delay d/cafter the incident pulse crosses a non-null field first appears across the gap at ( xa,d), and a similar delay after the incident pulse crosses the field starts to be extinguished at ( notice that for some time the field penetrates a sma ll distance dbeyondxbas if there were no screen. The field is singular at the hyperbolas with vertices at x=xa,t=ta+d/cand by the intersection of the ( ct,x,d) hyperplane and the future light cone of the events ( cta,xa,0), (ctb,xb,0). Thus, we have shown observable consequences of the fact that evanesce nt waves in FTIR do not propagate superluminally nor acausally in the direction normal to the interface s, but with retardation and obliquely. A to the results of this section and an animation illustrating t hem may be found in Refs. 40 and Ref. A SMOOTH TRANSVERSE opaque screens such as those considered in the previou s section introduce sharp discontinuities in the pulse atz= 0. The truncated pulse no longer has a well defined propagation dir ectionthibut may still be represented by a superposition of pulses with varying propagation directions. A shar p truncation leads to the presence of angles thi<thc, and therefore to the presence of both, evanescent and non-e vanescent transmitted fields. It has been argued [41] that the retardation effects discussed in the pre vious section may be due only to the known to be subluminal. The comparatively slow sublum inal contributions would be unable to affect the arrival of the superluminal signals if the later were actually pres ent. However, any small non-evanescent wave would dominate the transmitted signal after a wide enough gap. Thu s, it is interesting to study the propagation of pulses with a finite transverse extension but with a smooth lateral c utoff and built up completely from explore the propagation of the smoothly truncated pulses discu ssed above, we consider an incoming field given by a Fourier (35) wherefoQis the amplitude for each parallel component of the wave vector Qand frequency o. We can variable from Qto the parallel velocity vo/Q, ph(t,x,0+) (36) where we introduced the velocity dependent amplitude fov(o/v2)fo,o/v. The incident field (36) will give rise to evanescent waves exclusively as long as all non-null components fovhavev<c. At this point we could integrate first Eq. (36) with respect to o, obtaining thus a superposition of plane pulses, each of which may be propagated across the air gap according to Eq. (21). Alternatively, we may propagate each monochromatic component using Eq. (26) and afterward perform the integrations in Eq. (36). We follow the la ter approach and write ph(t,x,z) (37) whereg= in Sec. IV. For simplicity we assume that we may factor fov=fofvinto frequency and velocity dependent amplitudes, focontrols the time duration of the pulse, or equivalently, its longitudinal extent, while fvcontrols its We further assume a narrowGau ssian velocity distribution of width varound a nominal velocity (38) whereuv-v0. We assume vis small enough that the non-evanescent contributions to the field may be neglected and the exponent in Eq. (37) may be linearized in u. Thus, the transmitted field (39) whereg0= The integration over uis immediate and yields ph(t,x,z) (40) In Fig. 7 we illustrate the results of applying Eq. (40) to a pulse with a G aussian frequency (41) of areaAand width ocentered at o0(o0= 16c/d, o= 2c/d,v0= 0.7c, v= 0.15c). The pulse is seen to form on thez= 0 surface at x -5dand at time t7d/c, it propagates along the xv0tline for a while, peaks at x= 0 at timet= 0 and disappears at x5d,t7d/c. Its maximum duration tand sizeLarectLdfor a fixed position and fixed observation time respectively, and it contains alto gether about six ( ct/d) -5 0 5 -5 0 5 Position ( x/d) FIG. 7: Intensity of a Gaussian pulse localized in both space and time ( xandt) incident on the front face of an air gap of widthd(left) and after after crossing it (right). The nominal velo city along xisv0= 0.7cwith width v= 0.15c. The is o0= 16c/dwith width o= after crossing the gap, the pulse looks essentially the same! It appears at the back z=dface of the air gap at roughly the same time and the same position as at the front z= 0 face. It also peaks at the origin at t= 0 and disappears from the back surface in concordance to the inc ident pulse on the front face. Thus, it truly appears to propagate instantaneously. The main difference betwe en the incident and transmitted pulse is that the intensity of the later is suppressed by 12 orders of magnitude. Ano ther interesting difference is that the number of visible nodes in the transmitted pulse has decreased to about 4. This is a consequence of the fact that in FTIR, the Fourier components with higher frequencies are more damped t han those with lower frequencies. Finally, a more subtle difference is that the speed of propagation along the back fa ce is slightly but noticeably larger than that on the front face. This is due to the fact that plane waves incident at a ngles closer to thchave a larger penetration length than waves incident at larger angles. Thus, the angle of propagatio n of the transmitted pulse is smaller than that of the incident wave [46]. In Sec. IV we have argued that the transmission of evanescent pla ne pulses acrossan air gap under FTIR uedirections. showing that there is a delay before a perturbation, such as bloc king part of the incident wavefront, can produce an effect on the pulse transmitted across the gap. Furthermore, by truncating an incident plane pulse producing an abrupt transverse profile, we showed that the transmitted pu lse is shifted along the surface in the direction of propagation. However, in Sec. VI we showed through an example th at if the pulse has a smooth transverse profile, such that all its Fourier components are evanescent, it is transmit ted as if it were indeed superluminal. To understand this result, in Fig. 8 we show schematically a pulse smoothly truncated along its transverse direction, built from narrow plane components propagating along well defined directions th > thc. The incident field peaks at the regions where the directional components add in phase, indicated in the figu re by elliptical regions around the crossing point of the different incident wavefronts. As each of the components c rosses the gap, it is widened according to Eq. (23). The peak of the transmitted pulse appears in the regions of largest overlap between the different widened i.e., at the regions where their centers coincide. The p eak of the transmitted pulse at the back face of the air gap is seen to appear at the same time as the peak of the incident p ulse reaches the front surface. Thus, it would seem as if the peak tunneled instantaneously in the direction normal to the gap. However, in the previous sections we have shown that each of the transmitted components of the tran smitted wave originates causally from regions in the lateral wings of the incident pulse. Thus, the peak of the transmitt ed field does not actually originate from the peak of the incident field; it is formed by contributions from the lateral win gs of the incident field, which reach the front face of the air gap first. The lateral wings of each component have enough time to cross the gap traveling at speed cand combine to form the relatively small transmitted peak right at th e time when the larger incident peak reaches the front surface. Similarly, the different components of the field p roduced by the peak of the incident pulse get out of step as they cross the air gap and, therefore, do not contribu te to the peak of the transmitted pulse, but rather, to its lateral wing. This is illustrated by the dashed arrows in Fig. 8. Th us, it seems that the physical and causal) can not be distinguished from the nonphysic al propagation (superluminal and non-causal) as long as we only consider smooth incident pulses which contain only prop agation directions above the critical angle12 FIG. 8: Evanescent transmission of a smoothly truncated pul se made up initially of a superposition of narrow plane wavef ronts (heavy solid lines) with a distribution of angles above thc. As it crosses the gap, each wavefront widens (shaded bands a round dashed lines, as in Fig. 4). The ellipses represent schemati cally the contour levels of the pulse and are centered at the r egion where the different contributions add coherently in phase, i .e., the regions where the centers of each component coincid e. Snapshots are taken at three different times. The solid arrow s illustrate the nominal propagation of the peak. The heavy arrow indicates the apparent instantaneous tunneling acro ss the air gap. The dashed arrows illustrate the actual (sub) 41]. VII. EVANESCENT PROPAGATOR In Sec. VI we found that a particular pulse made up of only evanesce nt components seemed to propagate across the air gap, in contrast to the abruptly truncat ed pulses considered in Sec. V for which haveobservable consequences. This wasexplained graphic allyin Fig. 8 for incident pulses built up from components, each of which is widened as it is transmitted across the gap. To show that this behavior is generic, we start from the Fourier decomposition of an arbitrary fi eld ph(t,x,z) (43) The condition that ph(t,x,z) is made up exclusively of evanescent waves is equivalent to stating t hat the in Eq. (35) is given by |o|<|Q|c, i.e.,pho,Q= 0 if|o|>|Q|c. Using Eq. (26) we propagate each from z= 0+toz >0 as pho,Q(z) =e-kzpho,Q(0+), Thus, we can combine Eqs. (42), (43) and (44) to obtain ph(t,x,z) the integration region is given by |o|<|Q|c. Comparing Eq. (45) with (4) we find that P'is a propagator that can be used in the same way as the propagator Pdefined in Eq. (6) to find the value of the field at z >0 given its values at z= 0+, provided the field is built up of evanescent components only, as in th e examples of the two previous sections. We remark that our original causal, retarded a nd subluminal propagator Pwas able to propagate any arbitrary outgoing field. However, by adding constrains to the field, we gain freedom in our choice of propagator, as we can chose arbitrarily its effect on fields that do not obey the co nstrain. Thus, if we can find any function P'' such = 0, (47) for an arbitrary flat pulse fmoving along xwith any velocity -c < v < c , then we could employ P''instead ofP to propagate an arbitrary evanescent pulse. P'above is just one of the many possible choices of a propagator for evanescent pulses. To proceed, we make a change of variable o-Qvto write Eq. (46) as P'(t,x,z) (48) whereg= we perform the integration over Q, P'(t,x,z) (49) Notice that is symmetric under the interchange x- -xand also under the interchange t- =P'(t,x',z;t',x) =P'(t',x,z;t,x') Thus, the evanescent propagator and acausal . To finish the calculation of P'we make another change of integration variable v=csinato write P'(t,x) (50) and we perform the the spatial distance from the source to the observation point an ds2=r2-c2t2is the interval. This expression may be simplified to P'(t,x) (52) The evanescent propagator is displayed in Fig. 9. The figure shows e xplicitly the temporal and spatial symmetry, and thus the superluminality and non-causality of P'. Notice that P'has singularities at the projected which converge at the origin x=x',t=t'. Thus, propagation is largest for in the direction normal to the air gap. We have found that the propagation of evanescent pulses can be d escribed with either the exact propagator Pof the problem, which is causal, retarded and subluminal, or with an evanescent propagator P'which is superluminal and non-causal. Both yield exactly the same transmitted pulse when the incident pulse contains only Thus, it seems to be impossible to distinguish superlumin al from subluminal propagationin with purely evanescent pulses [41]. An explanation for the curious conclusion found in this section can be obtained by going back to Eq. (42) which we rewrite as ph(t,x,z) 9: Propagator normalized to c/d2as a function of the displacement x-x'and the delay t-t'. Distance is measured in units of dand time in units of d/c. For aid in visualization, the height of the propagator was t runcated at P'= 0.1c/d2. Notice that for each finite wavevector Q, the time dependent Fourier component phQ(t,z) has a strictly finite Thus,phQ(t,z) is an analytical function of twith no singularities and can be analytically continued to an arbitrary time t2from its values in an arbitrarily small neighborhood of any other arbit rary timet1. is perfectly predictable in principle. Using antropomorphic language, we may say that at time t1the system knowsfrom the present values of ph(tt1,x,0+) what its future values will be, and thus it canusethat knowledge to build subluminally a transmitted pulse ph(tt2,x,z) that will mimic the impression that superluminal transmission has taken place at timet2. The validity of the argument above in the presence of thermal or quantum noise has to be investigated . VIII. CONCLUSIONS To study the propagation of a light pulse through a vacuum gap betw een two parallel dielectrics in a the it can only account for causal, (sub)luminal propagation of light pulses. However, when this propagator is used to study the propagation of wave packets through the gap , we find apparent superluminal behavior, that is, a wave packet might appear on the far side of the gap at the same tim e that the incident packet reaches the front one. Therefore this illusion of superluminality, present within classica l electromagnetic theory even in vacuum, is fully consistent with relativistic causality. We showedexplicitly that propa gationin FTIR the lateral wings of the incident pulse and the central pea k of the transmitted pulse, and we proposed that could verify this statement. Thus, although FTI R has many similitudes to 1D tunneling, its correct physical interpretation requires a 2D or 3D analysis. On the other h and, we constructed an explicitly superluminal and acausal propagatorthat yields identical results as the retar ded causal one when applied to smooth pulses made up of evanescent contributions only. Thus, there is a class of pulses f or which superluminal and subluminal be acknowledge partial support from UBACYT and CONICET (VLB) a nd from DGAPA-UNAM under project IN111306 (WLM). VLB is a member of CONICET. [1] Zhi-Yong Wang and Cai-Dong Xiong, Phys. Rev. A 75, 042105 (2007). [2] H. G. Winful, Phys. Rev. A 76, 057803 (2007). [3] P. Pereyra and H.P. Simanjuntak, Phys. Rev. E 75, 056604 (2007). [4] A. Ranfagni, G. Viliani, C. Ranfagni, R. Mignani, R. Rugg eri and A.M. Ricci, Phys. Lett. A 370, 370 (2007). [5] H. G. Winful, Phys. Rev. E 72, 046608 (2005). [6] H. G. Winful, Phys. Rev. Lett 90(2), 23901 (2003). [7] M. Buttiker and S. Washburn, Nature 422, 271 (2003). [8] Herbert G. Winful, Nature 424, 628 (2003). [9] M. Buttiker and S. Washburn, Nature 424, 638 (2003). [10] H. G. Winful, Phys. Rev. E 68, 016615 (2003). [11] A. Peres and D. Terno, Rev. Mod. Phys. 76, 93 (2004). [12] T. De Angelis, E. Nagali, F. Sciarrino and F. De Martini, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 193601 (2007). [13] H. G. Winful, Physics Reports 436, 1 (2006). [14] R. W. Boyd and D.J. Gauthier, Progress in Optics, Vol. 43, E. Wolf (ed.) (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2002). [15] J. C. Garrison, M. W. Mitchell, R. Y. Chiao and E. L. Bolda , Phys. Lett. A 245, 19 (1998). [16] Mark Ya. Azbel', Solid State Commun. 91(6), 439 (1994). [17] J. D. Jackson, Classical Electrodynamics (Wiley, New York, 1975), 2nd. ed. [18] A. Sommerfeld, Ann. Physik 44, 177 (1914). English translation available in Chap. II of [1 9]. [19] L. Brillouin, Wave Propagtion and Group Velocity (Academic Press, New York, 1960). [20] G. Diener, Phys. Lett. A 223, 327 (1996). [21] G. Diener, Phys. Lett. A 235, 118 (1997). [22] A. Kuzmich, A. Dogariu, L.J. Wang, P.W. Milonni and R.Y. Chiao, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 3925 (2001). [23] M.D. Stenner, D.J. Gauthier and M.A. Neifeld, Nature 425, 695 (2003). [24] M.D. Stenner, D.J. Gauthier and M.A. Neifeld, Phys. Rev . Lett.94, 053902 (2005). [25] A. Ranfagni, P. Fabeni, G.P. Pazzi, A.M. Ricci, R. Trinc i, R. Mignani, R. Ruggeri and F. Cardone, Phys. Lett. A 352, 473 (2006). [26] A. Icsevgi and W.E. Lamb, Phys. Rev. 185(2), 517 (1969). [27] L.J. Wang, A. Kuzmich and A. Dogariu, Nature (London) 406, 277 (2000). [28] M. Janowicz and J. Mostowski, Phys. Rev. E 73, 046613 (2006). [29] G. Huang, Ch. Hang and L. Deng, Phys. Rev. A 77, 011803(R) (2008). [30] D.R. Solli, C.F. McCormick, C. Ropers, J.J. Morehead, R .Y. Chiao and J.M. Hickmann, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, N. Brunner, V. Scarani, M. Wegm uller, M. Legr' e and N. G isin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 203902 (2004). [32] T.G. Halvorsen and J.M. Leinaas, Phys. Rev. A 77, 023808 (2008). [33] M. Kulkarni, N. Seshadri, V.S.C. Manga Rao and S. Dutta G upta, J. Mod. Opt. 51, 549 (2004). [34] R. Safian, C.D. Sarris and M. Mojahedi, Phys. Rev. E 73, 066602 (2006). [35] M.S. Bigelow, N.N. Lepeshkin, H. Shin and R.W. Boyd, J. P hys.: Condens. Matter 18, 3117 (2006). [36] A.I. Talukder, T. Haruta and M. Tomita, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 223901 (2005). [37] D. Mugnai, A. Ranfagni and R. Ruggeri, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 4830 (2000). [38] D. Mugnai and I. Mochi, Phys. Rev. E 73, 016606 (2006). [39] J. J. Carey, J. Zawadzka, D. A. Jaroszynski and K. Wynne, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1431 (2000). [40] W.L. Moch' an and V.L. Brudny, Phys.Rev.Lett 87, 119101 (2001). [41] J. J. Carey, J. Zawadzka, D. A. Jaroszynski and K. Wynne, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 119102 (2001). [42] A. M. Shaarawi, B. H. Tawfik and I. M. Besieris, Phys. Rev. E.66, 046626 (2002). [43] V.L. Brudny and W.L. Moch' an, Optics Express A. P. Barbero H. E. Hern' andez-Figueroa and E. Recami, P hys. Rev. E 62(6), 8628 (2000). [45] M. T. Reiten D. Grischkowsky and R. A. Cheville, Phys. Re v. E64, 036604 (2001). [46] Ph. Balcou and L. Dutriaux, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78(5), 851 (1997). [47] K.J. Resch, J.S. Lundeen and A.M. Steinberg, IEEE J. Qua ntum Electron. 37(6), 794 (2001). [48] Phillip M. Morse and Herman Feshbach, Methods of Theoretical Physics (Mc.Graw-Hill, New York, 1953).
|
0807.2422
|
Luis Moch\'an
|
Vera L. Brudny and W. Luis Moch\'an
|
Frustrated total internal reflection and the illusion of superluminal
propagation
|
15 pages, 9 figures
| null | null | null |
physics.optics quant-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We analyze the propagation of a pulse across a vacuum gap separating opposite
flat parallel faces of two transparent dielectrics by means of an explicitly
causal and retarded propagator constructed directly from the free-space wave
equation. Nevertheless, our approach yields apparently superluminal propagation
for the case of frustrated total internal reflection (FTIR), that is, a
transmitted wave packet appears on the far side of the gap at the same time
that the corresponding incident packet crosses the front one. Thus, in this
example superluminality is just an illusion, being consistent with both
casuality and classical electrodynamics. We study the origin of the apparent
superluminality in this case, which is inherent to light pulse propagation in
free space and does not depend on the particulars of light-matter interaction,
and find that it is due to propagation from the lateral wings of the incident
pulse to the central part of the transmitted pulse. Thus, notwithstanding their
similarities, FTIR is not equivalent to 1D tunneling. We propose experiments to
test our explanation of superluminality using opaque screens to block part of
the wavefront, although we demonstrate that the propagation of smooth finite
pulses constrained to be made up completely of evanescent Fourier components is
indistinguishable from truly superluminal propagation, i.e., it may be
completely accounted for using an explicitely superluminal and acausal
propagator as well as the causal subluminal one.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 15 Jul 2008 18:09:41 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-17T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Brudny",
"Vera L.",
""
],
[
"Mochán",
"W. Luis",
""
]
] |
Contents 1. Introduction 1 2. Warm-up with the Abelian Theory 6 3. Non-Abelian Theory 9 3.1 Moduli Space 12 3.2 Quantum Dynamics on the Coulomb Branch 14 3.3 Classical and Quantum rVacua 16 4. The First Examples of Quantum Coincidence 20 5. General Case 27 6. MQCD 35 7. Conclusion 38 1. Introduction In this paper, we want to discuss a problem of supersymmetry b reaking, from N= 2 to N= 1. An issue, which is not completely understood in the liter ature, is how to flow from N= 2 super-QCD to pure N= 1 super-QCD [1]. We shall explain the problem, why it is still unresolved, and propose a solution for it. N= 1 the gauge vector multiplet Wafor the gauge group SU( of massless quarks Qin the fundamental representation and /tildewideQin the representation. N= 2 super-QCD is an extension of the previous one. We must add a chiral adjoint multiplet Ph that together with Waforms aN= 2 gauge The quarks together to form an N= 2 matter hypermultiplet. An opportune superpotential also be added. At the classical level, both theories have a moduli space of v acua. The N= 2 moduli space is divided into two distinct parts: the Coulomb branch and the Higgs branch. On the Coulomb branch, phne}ationslash= 0 and q,/tildewideq= 0. The rank of the gauge group is preserved. On the Higgs branch, some of the quarks q's and/tildewideq's develop an expectation value. The Higgs branches develop out of various singular sub-manifolds of t he Coulomb branch where the quarks become effectively massless. For what we are intereste d now, we can just consider the origin of the moduli space, ph= 0,q,/tildewideq= 0, which is the meeting point between the Coulomb branch and the maximal Higgs branch. - 1 -TheN= 1 moduli space is different. First of all, there is no Coulomb b ranch, since there is no ph. Second, the Higgs branch is bigger than the one of N= 2. Now only the D-term determines the expectation value of qand/tildewideq. TheF-term constraint /tildewideqq= 0 is now absent. The simplest way to break N= 2 supersymmetry, while preserving N= 1, is to add a mass term in the superpotential for the adjoint chiral field :uTrPh2/2. The effect of toliftall fromth eoriginwith its maximal Higgs branch attached. Another effect happens as ubecomes very, very large. The potential for the coming from the F-term of N= 2, becomes more and more shallow and vanishes in the limit u- . In this limit, the full Higgs branch of N= 1 is thus branchHiggs branchu= 0 u- unegationslash= 0 Figure 1: Classical supersymmetry breaking from N= 2 toN= 1 super-QCD. The breaking is obtained by a mass parameter ufor the field Ph. At u= 0, we have the N= 2 theory that has a Coulomb branch and a maximal Higgs branch that develops from the o rigin of the moduli space ph= 0,q,/tildewideq= 0. The mass term lifts the Coulomb branch leaving only the Higgs bran ch. Asugoes to infinity, the Higgs branch is enhanced by other flat directions, 0, and we recover the full moduli space of N= 1. Higgs branches Coulomb branchr= 2: The notion of origin of the moduli space does not exist anymore for t he quantum version of SU(nc) super-QCD. There are various points of maximal singularity labeled by an integer rthat runs [nf/2]. Higgs branches of increasing size (quaternionic r(nf-r)) develop from these mechanically, it is a completely different story. The metric of the Coulomb branch of N= 2 is modified, and the origin of the moduli space, strictly sp eaking, does not exist anymore. It is instead split in many different points out of which various Higgs - 2 -branches develop (Figure 2). These singularities are label ed by an integer rthat runs [nf/2].1Adding a mass perturbation uTrPh2/2, we lift all the Coulomb branch with the exception of these singular points and their Higgs branches. Every one of these points gives a particular N= 1 theory, but noneof them flows to pure N= 1 super-QCD in the u- limit. The mechanism to flow from N= 2 super-QCD to N= 1 super-QCD, which is very simple in classical theory, does not work in quantum theory. In this paper, we shall present a proposal to make this mechanism work. This will certainly o pen new possibilities in the study of the N= 1 dynamics and its rich dualities.
* * *
The ideas we shall present originate, in part, from some rece nt developments in the theory of the Abelian and non-Abelian heterotic vortex-string. It is good to say a few words about this subject since it could help to understand better what fo llows. U(nc)N= 2 theories with quark hypermultiplets with mass m, can be put in a weak Higgs phase with a suitable Fayet-Iliopoulos (FI) term for t he U(1) gauge field. This term does not break N= 2 supersymmetry; it only breaks the SU(2) Rsymmetry. There is a supersymmetric vacuum where ph=m, so that the quarks are effectively massless and can develop a condensate. At the Higgs breaking energy scale, th e dynamics are to the 1+1 action of the non-Abelian vortex. Bei ng the vortex half-BPS, the 1+1 effective action has N= (2,2) supersymmetries on its worldsheet. The tension of the vortex is proportional to the central charge T= 4px, wherexis the FI term. A superpotential for the adjoint field Ph can be added in order t o break to N= 1, for example, the single trace of an holomorphic function W= TrW(Ph). The vacuum structure is not changed, but now the string has te nsion loses its BPS properties. W'(m) is the value of the superpotential evaluated at the mass of the quarks [6]. Something very special happens when a zero of W'coincides with the mass m. In this case, the tension is back to the central charge T= 4px, and the vortex effective theory re- acquires part of the supersymmetries. The vortex is half-BP S, and the worldsheet theory has aN= (2,0) supersymmetries inherited by the bulk N= 1. Additional studies show that the strong dynamics on the 1+1 theory dynamically break supersymmetry [3, 4, 5]. These studies, up to now, leave an unresolved important ques tion:is the W'(m) = meaningful? To explain the question better, let us call aone of the roots of W'. Classically we can choose to fine tune the parameters so thatais exactly equal to m. The non-trivial question is if this fine tuning is stable or not under quantum corrections. Note that both aandmare in general renormalized by instanton corrections. The quantum stability of this coi ncidence condition becomes a non-trivial question in the non-Abelian theory. The heterotic string gives an ambiguous answer to these ques tions. On one hand, there is the enhancement of supersymmetry in the particular casea=m. Symmetry 1By [nf/2], here and in the rest of the paper, we mean the integer part o fnf/2. - 3 -enhancement is in general what protects from quantum correc tions. On the other hand, from the analysis of the strong dynamics of the worldsheet th eory, we know that N= is dynamically broken. But this, for the pres ent paper, is not our concern.
* * *
Now back to the main subject of the paper, the 4 ddynamics withoutthe FI term. The present paper originates from the question we previously as ked, but for the present work, we shall restrict ourselves to the case of zero Fayet-Iliopo ulos term. We thus want to answer these questions: 1) Is the coincidence condition W'(m) = meaningful? 2) And if it is so, how to express this coincidenc e condition in the shall see that the solution of this coincidence problem wi ll give us the right vacuum and superpotential to flow from N= 2 super-QCD to N= 1 super-QCD. The previous digression about the heterotic vortex-string gives us the first clue on how to solve the problem. First of all, SU( nc) is not the right environment in which to search; we should extend the theory to U( nc). The only price we pay is the loss of for the global U(1). But this is not a big problem. We c an always think that the theory is embedded in a bigger and finite theory (for example, a bigger SU( Nc) theory) that at a certain energy scale is broken to U( nc). TheN= 2 U(nc) has, with respect to SU( nc), one more dimension in the Coulomb branch, namely the coordinate u1= Trph. We have already said that in the Coulomb branch of SU( nc) there is no remnant of the classical origin of the moduli spa ce. There are instead various points labeled by an integer [nf/2]. Things are the moduli space with one more dimension, Tr ph. It is in this bigger environment that we shall find the quantum analogs of the origin of the modu li space; actually we shall find 2nc-nfof them. Ourgoal is now to findthe quantum generalization of the coinc idence points definedby W'(m) = 0. In other terms, when a root aofW'coincides with the mass of the quarks m. Whenaandmare generic, we have two kinds of vacua. One is a Coulomb vacuu m, with ph=a, and the quark has effective mass a-m. The other is a Higgs vacuum where locking), and the quarks condense: In the case of coincidence, we have ph=m=a. The quarks are massless and do not mechanically, the quark condensate, in a generic rvacuum, is given (1.1) Where the terms in the square root are given by the factorizat ion of the case r=encis an exception to this rule. Here there is an extra massless p article, and the dual-quark can thus have zero condensate. - 4 containing thedoubleroots correspondin gtoparticles that become massless. The rest is contained in W'(z)2+f(z) whereWis the classical is the quantum modification. The effect of f(z) is to split the roots, of W'(z)2. For the vacua we are interested in, the rvacua, the degree k= 2. So quantum mechanically the roots of W'(z) are split in two. To find a generalization of the coincidence points, we should take on e of these zeros and, moving in the Trphdirection, make it collide with the bunch of zeros at z=mcorresponding to the quark singularity (Figure 3). Coincidence vacuumr vacuum Figure 3: In a generic rvacuum (in the example we have the nc,nf= 6,6 andr= 3), all the roots of the Seiberg-Witten curve are paired, apart from two of t hem. These two roots correspond to the polynomial W'(z)2+f(z) in the curve factorization. To obtain the coincidence point, we need to move one of these two unpaired roots and make it coincide wit h the bunch of roots at the quark mass. We can achieve this changing the value of the coordinat e Trphin the moduli space. In Section 5, we shall find the precise factorization of the curve in the se coincidence vacua. Doing this, we get something else for free: all thervacua go to the same This is one of the strongest indications that tells us that t hese 2nc-nfpoints are the quantum generalization of the origin of the moduli space in classical theory. Every rvacuum is a point in which the curve has a multiple root z2rcorresponding to massless quarks and all the other roots, except two, are doubled. We th en change the Tr phcoor- dinate, keeping all the pairing of the roots, and we move unti l one of the unpaired roots collides with the bunch of quark zeros z2r. We can do the same for all the rvacua. They all intersect in the coincidence points, and the Higgs branches are all included in the maximal one (Figure 4).
* * *
We organize the paper as follows. In Section 2, we discuss the simple example of super- QED. Now there is no strong dynamics in the infrared, and ever ything works out smoothly. - 5 -Trph= 0r= 4: Moving away from the Tr ph= 0 section of the moduli space, it is possible to make all thervacua to collide in the coincidence points. The Higgs branch that eman ates from these points is the maximal one, and all the other Higgs branches are incorporat ed into it. There are 2 nc-nf of these points and are situated at Tr ph= Section 3, we introduce the non-Abelian U( nc) theories. We provide the needed infor- mation for the rest of the paper. In Section 4 we describe the q uantum coincidence in the first non-trivial examples, starting from 2 colors and 2 flavo rs. In Section 5, we describe the coincidence points in the general case. An explicit form ula shall be found for them and for the superpotential that select them. In Section 6, we take a look from the We conclude in Section 7 with discussion about the renormalization group (RG) flow and summarize the arguments in favor of our claim. 2. Warm-up with the Abelian Theory A good place to start, in explaining the notion of coincidenc e points, is the U(1) Abelian theory. We shall now introduce these three theories: N= 2 super-QED, broken N= 2 super-QED by a mass term, and pure N= 1 super-QED. These theories are infrared free, so there is nostrong dynamics that could chance theclassica l vacuum notion of coincidence point and its quantum stability ar e thus action for N= 2 super-QED, expressed in N= 1 superfields notation, is a sum of the Kahler term plus a superpotential , (2.1) - 6 (2.2) The potential for the scalar fields is the sum of Fterms and the Dterm V= index irepresents the flavor and runs from 1 to nf. The moduli space consists of a Coulomb branch and a Higgs branch. The Coulomb branch is par ameterized by the expectation value of ph, and the quark condensate instead vanishes. When ph=m, the effective quark mass vanishes and a Higgs branch develops from the Coulomb one. The Higgs branch is a manifold parameterized by the following al gebraic 0. (2.4) Fornf= 1 there is no Higgs branch. For greater nf, it is a manifold of complex dimension 2nf-2. Higgs branches, in N= 2 theories, are conic hyper-Kahler manifolds (in N= 1 theories are only Kahler). Now we break N= 2 toN= 1 by means of the superpotential W(Ph) that is a holomorphic function of (2.5) The potential for the scalar fields is now modified into V= are now two kinds of vacua. One is when the value of phis equal to some zero of the derivative of the superpotential. We denote ajthese roots so that W'(z) is the degree of the superpotential. There are kvacua where ph=ai. These are Coulomb vacua because the expectation values of zero. Then there is a Higgs vacuum where phis locked to the hypermultiplet mass m. an expectation q=/tildewideq*. (2.7) The number of vacua is thus k+1. They all preserve are different when one root of W', saya1, is exactly equal to the From here on, we shall use the word coincidence to indicate this particular circum- stance. In this coincidence case, we have only kvacua instead of k+1.k-1 of them are Coulomb vacua, and as before, they arise when ph=ajforj= 2,...k. The last vacuum is when ph=m=a1. It is a kind of hybrid between the Higgs and the Coulomb vacua previously described. The phase is Coulomb, because the exp ectation value of the quark condensate vanishes. But it is a Coulomb phase of a different na ture from the previous one. In the previous case, the quark hypermultiplet was mass ive, with effective mass equal - 7 -toa1-m. So at low energy we had only a gauge vector multiplet (and bei ng U(1) the gauge coupling is finite and the theory is free). In the coinci dence case, the effective quark mass isa1-m= 0, so at low energy the U(1) vector multiplet is coupled to a m assless quark (and being U(1) the gauge coupling runs to zero in the in frared). Now what about the quantum stability? In principle, we can always tune the p arameters of the bare La- grangian so that we have a coincidence between the mass and a r oot of the question is if this tuning is stable or not underquantum c orrections. Parameters in like the roots ajand the mass m, are subject to the and thus unchanged by perturbative quantum correct ion. They could be modified by the non-perturbative dynamics (that will be the case in th e following part of the paper), but for the Abelian case we do not have to worry about that. Thi s implies the of this coincidence. We now consider the quadratic (2.8) so that the derivative is the linear polynomial W'(z) = 2u(z-m), and we choose the root to coincide exactly with the quark mass. Integrating out the superfield Ph, we get Ph , (2.9) and the effective (2.10) The potential for the scalar fields (2.11) With a gauge and flavor transformation, we can always bring a g eneric solution into the form q= (0,k,0,...,0), kR+. (2.12) At this point, the potential for the field . (2.13) In theu- , we have an enhancement of the moduli space because the Fterm 0 loses progressively its weight. The direction 0, which is generically lifted by the potential (2.11), becomes more and more shallow and final ly flat in the u- limit. Note that at the origin of the Higgs branch (where it touches t he Coulomb branch), the - 8 always massless, but the is still lifted by the higher order in the meson field. PureN= 1 super-QED has the following , (2.14) and the potential for the scalar fields is given just by the (2.15) With a gauge and flavor transformation, we can bring a solutio n into the form q= (2.16) So to summarize here what happens to the moduli space for vari ous values of u:
*TheN= 2 theory ( u= 0) has a Coulomb branch with complex dimension, by ph. A Higgs branch with complex dimension 2 nf-2 develops from the origin ph= 0.
*Switching on the mass u, the Coulomb branch is lifted, and only the origin ph= 0 survives with its Higgs branch attached.
*In theu- limit, the 0 is no more effective due to the 1 /u suppression. The Higgs branch is enhanced and becomes 2 nf-1 dimensional. We thus smoothly recover the moduli space of N= 1 SQED. 3. Non-Abelian Theory The non-Abelian U( nc) super QCD has the following , (3.1) where the superpotential (3.2) - 9 nc nf 0 1
/tildewideQ - nc - nf 0 1 Phadj 1 2 0 L2nc-nf N= 2 1 1 2(2nc-nf) 0 Table 1: Fields, symmetries, and charges for N= 2 SQCD. andmiare the masses for the flavors with the index i= 1,...,n f. The charges and symmetries of the fields are given in Table 1. The gauge group i s U(nc) = SU( nc)x U(1)/Znc. At a very high energy scale, which we call L cutoff, the gauge couplings for the Abelian U(1) and for the non-Abelian SU( nc) are the same.4Then the gauge couplings run in opposite directions. The non-Abelian running is give n by 1 e2 SU(nc)= (3.3) and becomes strong in the infrared. The U(1) Rsymmetry is anomalous and broken to Z2nc-nfby instanton zero modes. This fact, as usual, can be elegantl y incorporated giving a U(1) Rcharge to the dynamical scale L N= 2as in Table 1. We then break supersymmetry adding a superpotential W(Ph) for the adjoint field Ph. The superpotential term (3.4) where W(z) W'(z) (3.5) The adjoint scalar field ph, from the Dterm, is a matrix that can thus be diagonalized. The eigenvalues follow the same rule e xplained for the Abelian case. In the supersymmetric vacua, the diagonal elements of the ad joint field must be equal to a flavor mass mi(the color-flavor locking case) or to a root ajofW'. There can also be some degeneracy in the eigenvalues. A generic solution (3.6) The adjoint field breaks the gauge group The quarks locked to the adjoint field are effectively massless and condense after t he perturbation of W(Ph). The 3All the time we use Tr in the paper, we mean a trace in the color s pace. 4At this scale, the theory becomes part of a bigger, asymptoti cally free, theory. An example could be an SU(nc+1) gauge theory that is broken to U( nc) at the scale L cutoff. - 10 -quark condensate W'(mi) breaks the residual gauge In the low-energy, we are thus left with super-Yang-Mills theory without quarks. In the case of coincidence, we have to consider also another p ossibility; the is not exhaustive. We call hthe number of coincidences. So we choose the last h roots ofW'to be equal to the last l= 1,...,h . (3.7) The other roots ajforj= 1,...,k-hand the other masses mifori= 1,...,n Now theeigenvalues of phcanbeequal tosome slwithl= 1,...,h, or toajwithj= 1,...,k-hor tomiwithi= 1,...,n f-h. The generic structure is (3.8) and the gauge group is broken (3.9) The various residual gauge groups have different fate accordi ng to the three cases. In the first case, we have at low energy U( nl) SQCD with a certain number of massless flavors. The second case leaves U( nj) pure SYM, which has njdiscrete supersymmetric vacua where the gauge group is in the confinement phase. In the third case, the quarks acquire an expectation value The gauge group is thus in the Higgs phase. The fact that the first case has a completely different phase struct ure is an indication that the coincidence we talking about should be taken quantum mechan ically seriously. We now break to N= 1 supersymmetry by turning on a bare mass ufor the Ph. In the microscopic theory, this corresponds to anN= 1 theory with (3.10) ForuLN= 2we can integrate Ph out in a weak-coupling approximation, obt aining an effective quartic in the limit u-this superpotential becomes negligible, and we find N= wecan not say that since (3.11) is a relevant operator and in general, a s we shall see more in detail, makes the theory to flow away from the right coincidence point . - 11 -PureN= 1 SQCD has no adjoint field Ph, and the Lagrangian . (3.12) Fields and charges are given in Table 2. Note that now the non- Abelian flavor nc nf 1 0
/tildewideQ - nc 1 - n f 0 L3nc-nf N= 1 1 1 1 (3nc-nf) Table 2: Fields, symmetries and charges for N= 1 SQCD. is enhanced to SU( nf)LxSU(nf)R. Left and right quarks can be rotated running of the non-Abelian gauge coupling, due to the abs ence of the field ph, is now a little bit (3.13) The U(1) Rsymmetry is anomalous and broken to Z3nc-nf. The matching of the dynamical scales between the N= 2 and the N= 1 theory is given by L3nc-nf N= 1=uncL2nc-nf N= 2. (3.14) This can be inferred by the running of the coupling constants and by the U(1) * *
In the next subsection we review some basic information that shall be needed in the rest of the paper. In Subsection 3.1, we introduce the moduli space, and in particular the Higgs branches for the various theories. In Subsection 3.2, we rec all the Seiberg-Witten solution for the dynamic on Coulomb branch. In Subsection 3.3, we desc ribe the particular case of thervacua and the formula for the quark condensate. 3.1 Moduli Space The moduli space of vacua is defined by the D-term = 0, (3.15) and theF-term 0, phb aqi b= 0. (3.16) - 12 -From now on, we shall choose all the masses mito be equal to zero. The moduli space can be divided into two different branches. Th e first is the Coulomb branch where the quarks condensate vanishes and the gauge gr oup preserves its rank. From the first of (3.15), it follows that the adjoint field phcan be diagonalized by a The Coulomb branch has complex dimension ncand can be parameterized by the gauge invariant j= 1,...,n c. (3.17) The Coulomb branch is a Kahler manifold and develops singula rities where some multiplets or matter hypermultiplets, become massl ess. The metric is modified by quantum correction, and the solution is encoded in the Seibe rg-Witten curve. Higgs branches are conic hyper-Kahler manifolds that devel op from some of the singu- larities of the Coulomb branch where two or more flavors of qua rks become massless. Two are the important properties of the Higgs branches: 1)the metric does not have any de- pendence on ph;2)the metric does not receive quantum corrections. Quantum co rrections can only change the point on the Coulomb branch where the Higg s branch develops and the pattern of intersections between the various branches; they cannot modify the Higgs branch itself [1]. There is no baryonic branch since we are working in U( nc) rather than SU( nc). There are non-baryonic branches and they develop where ph= nc). (3.18) After a gauge and flavor rotation, the quarks can be brought in the form q=
k10 k10 ......... 0 kr , kiR+, These non-baryonic rbranches are the ones that develop from the sub-manifold (3.18) of the Coulomb branch. The rHiggs branch preserves a U( nf-r) subgroup of the flavor symmetry. Part of the flat directions of the Higgs branch are given by the Goldstone bosons of the broken global symmetries. The complex dimension of the branch is 2 r(nf-r). Note that a Higgs branch can contain, as a sub-manifold, al l the other branches with smaller r. For the moduli space of pure N= 1 super-QCD, there is only the 0. (3.20) - 13 -Up to gauge and global transformation, the quarks can be brou ght in the form5 q=
k1 0 k2... ... . (3.21) The complex dimension is 2 ncnf-n2 c. Note that now there is also a baryonic branch that was absent in the N= 2 case. As in the Abelian case, we can break N= 2 with a mass term uTrPh2/2 and flow from N= 2 to pure N= 1. So to summarize here what happens, this time only classically , to the moduli space;
*TheN= 2 theory has a Coulomb branch with complex dimension ncand an equal number of massless vector multiplets. Non-baryonic Higgs b ranches labeled by r develop from singularities of the Coulomb branch. They are h yper-Kahler manifolds. In particular at the origin ph= 0, the maximal Higgs branch r= [nf/2] develops. It is given by the quark expectation values qand/tildewideq, minus the Fphconditions, divided by the complexified gauge group 0}/Gc. (3.22) The quaternionic dimension of the maximal Higgs branch is [ mass term uTrPh2/2 in the superpotential lifts all the Coulomb branch with the exception of the origin Ph = 0 and the maximal Higgs branch atta ched to it.
*Atu- theFphconditions loses its effectiveness. The Higgs branch is thus p aram- eterized by C2ncnf/Gc. (3.23) The Higgs branch is enhanced to the 2 ncnf-n2 ccomplex dimensional space. We thus smoothly recover the moduli space of pure N= 1 SQCD. 3.2 Quantum Dynamics on the Coulomb Branch We now recall some basic properties of the quantum solution o f the Coulomb branch given by the Seiberg-Witten curve [8]. First we consider SU( nc) withnfflavors. The curve SN= 2is the Riemann (3.24) 5See [7] for a complete review. - 14 -double cover of the zplane with genus g=nc-1. At low energy, one has nc-1 U(1) and we call their scalar components ai, wherei= 1,...,n c-1. The moduli space is a nc-1 dimensional complex manifold MSU(nc), parameterized by the gauge invariant coordinates ujgiven in (3.17). The SW solution is expressed as the function of the coordinates sk6given by Pnc(z) (3.25) s0= 1, s1= 0, sk= kphi1...phik. (3.26) Since S N= 2is a genus nc-1 Riemann surface, we can choose nc-1 independents holo- morphic j= 2,...,n c. to an aicycle on S N=2, while its dual aDjcorresponds to a bjcycle chosen in such a way that the intersection is The SW solution is given by the period (3.28) Now we studytheU( nc) theory with nfflavors, andwe will seethat thesolution can be easily incorporated into theprevious ones, with afew modifi cations. Thelow-energy theory has one more U(1) factor that comes from the decomposition U( nc) = we denote its scalar component with anc. This factor has no strong dynamics: in thenf= 0 case, it is completely free, while in the nfne}ationslash= 0 case, it is infrared free. The moduli space MU(nc)has one dimension more and is parameterized by u1in (3.17). The Riemann surface is the same given in (3.24), but here phcan have non-zero trace and S N= 2 also depends on the modulus u1. To complete our task, we must find the cycle to ancand the differential l1that corresponds to s1. The cycle ancis the one that encircles all the cuts in the zplane. Note that this is a trivial cycle, and only a meromorphic differential can be different from zero when it is in tegrated around it. The differential that corresponds to (3.29) and is meromorphic because it has a pole at . With these modifications, the solution is encoded in (3.28). The U(nc) theory can also be considered as part of a bigger, asymptoti cally free gauge theory. For example, we can take a SU( nc+1)N= 2 and break it to SU( nc)xU(1)/Znc at a certain energy scale. This can be achieved simply by choo sing one diagonal element of phvery distant from the others and fix it. We have thus a sub-mani fold of the SU( nc+1) moduli space, which is exactly like the one of U( nc). What we achieve with this is that 6The relationship between ujandsk, important in what follows, is encoded in a single one: Pnc(z) whereby ( ) +we mean that we discard the negative power expansion. - 15 -now we can display also the magnetic cycle bnc. This is important if we want to compute the monodromies around the singularities and consequently the charges of the on these singularities. We shall use this t rick in the next section. 3.3 Classical and Quantum rVacua We now review the physics of color-flavor locked vacua or, as w e like to call them, rvacua. The adjoint field phhasrcldiagonal elements locked to the hypermultiplet mass (3.30) and the remaining diagonal blocks are divided between thero ots We use rclto denote the classical value and 0 <=rcl<=nf. The gauge group is broken to U( Ifrcolors and flavors are locked at the same eigenvalue, then in the low energy we also have a massless hypermultiplet in the fundamental of U( r), that we denote as q. Apart from these perturbative objects, there are also non- Abelian and Abelian monopoles, each carrying magnetic charge under two of the unbroken and the Dterm together yield the potential for the quark (3.31) The non-Abelian quarks develop thus a (3.32) The non-Abelian group U( r) is Higgsed, non-Abelian vortices are formed, and non-Abel ian monopoles confined [17]. Quantum mechanically, is a little bit different. One difference is that in the strong coupling region, where mis of order of the dynamical scale, the massless quarks are co n- tinuously transformed into magnetic degrees of freedom, du al-quarks. Another difference is that (3.32) is modified by quantum corrections. We are now g oing to compute these quantum corrections as in [2]. The quantum parameter ris given by r= min(rcl,nf-rcl). (3.33) There are various reasons for the ap-SU(nf) SU(r) U(1) 0 Table 3: Low energy in parameter r. We saw from the classical discussion of the moduli space that the hyper-Kahler dimension of the r Higgs branch is r(nf-r). The gauge theory is, classically, N= 2 SU(r) withnfquarks. - 16 -Only for r<=[nf/2], this is not strong in the infrared, and we can conclude tha t it re- mains as a low-energy effective description. Branches which c lassically have rclgreater than [nf/2], quantum mechanically falls into the rvacua classification with r=nf-rcl. The factorization of the S N= 2curve is [9, (3.34) It is easy to see, from the curve (3.24), that the factor z2rcan be pulled out only if r<=[nf/2]. In the low energy, we have a N= 2 theory with hypermultiplet charges given in Table 3. The low-energy superpotentia l (3.35) where the effective superpotential that breaks to N= 1 nc-r). (3.36) We choose a superpotential with k=nc-r, so that all the possible points in the rsub- manifold can in principle be selected. A's are the chiral superfields of the N= 2 Aris one of the SU( r) gauge multiplet, and A0is one of the U(1) to the dual quarks. To compute the quantum condensate /tildewidedd, it is more convenient to split the flavors' masses a little bit and use the Abelianized theory so obtaine d. Then we simply make the limit of coincident masses for the result so obtained. We hav erflavors with masses mj withj= 1,...,r. In the limit if coincident masses mj-m,jand we recover the r vacuum. The chiral superfields that we previously called ArandA0, are now described by rAbelian fields that we denote as A(0,j)withj= 1,...,r. Each U(1) (0,j)is locked to The low-energy superpotential is (0,r);A1,...,A our computation, we need to consider only the FAterms of the j = 1,...,r , FAs= s = 1,...,n c-r . (3.38) The first ones give the condensates, while the second gives th e stationary condition neces- sary to compute the position in the moduli j = 1,...,r , 0 =Weff as, s = 1,...,n c-r . (3.39) - 17 -We can write a matrix equation like (3.39) where the coupling s vector is [g] = (3.40) and the tension vector (3.41) With these conventions, the equation (3.39) ==[g] (3.42) where in the last we have simply multiplied by the inverse mat rix. The last version is the one that we shall find more convenient for computing the conde nsates. Let us begin with the simplest example: the r= 1 vacuum of the ( nc,nf) = (2,2) theory. The superpotential is quadratic W(z) =g0z+g1 2z2, (3.43) and the factorization of S N= (3.44) The cycle a0is the one that encircles the double roots z=m. The crucial ingredient for the following computation is the residue around the cycle (3.45) In this case, the relationship between sanducoordinates is: s1=-u1, s 2=-u2+u12 2. (3.46) For our proof, we will need to calculate (3.47) First, we observe that the solution (3.28) and the residue (3 .45) (3.48) 7The proper normalization of the holomorphic differential ha s been chosen to reproduce the result - 18 -Then, writing the equations (3.39) in the matrix form sugges ted in (3.42), we (3.49) The simple passage of multiplying by the inverse matrix has s implified our work a lot be- cause now(3.49) is expressedas afunctionof ai/uj, known through(3.28). the ones obtained by an integral around the collided roots, are the others are multiplied by zero. From (3.49), we ne ed only the second , (3.50) that, using (3.48), gives the (3.51) We give another example U(3) with two flavors of mass m1and two flavors of mass m2(see Figure 5 for the roots and cycles). The superpotential i s still (3.43), while 5: Cycles in U(3) Displayed are the electric anda1. Two flavors at the poles m1andm2are massless and charged with respect to U(1) (0,1)and U(1) (0,2). In the limit m1-m2-m, we recover the r= 2 vacuum by gives S N= (3.52) The relationship between sanduin this case is given by (3.46) (3.53) - 19 -By using the trick explained before, we write the last of (3.4 2) for this particular (3.54) Now, as in the previous case, we need to calculate only the res idues around last equation of (3.54) is 0 =/tildewided1d1 (3.55) using also the second equation of (3.54). (3.56) the second equation of (3.54) leads to another independent e quation 1 =/tildewided1d1 (3.57) This equation together with (3.55) are enough to establish t he (3.58) Thus we obtain, in the limit of coincident masses m1=m2=m, the little formula for the dual-quark (3.59) This is the quantum generalization of (3.32). The crucial in gredient for the computation has been the residue around the mass poles. We have for simpli city restricted ourselves to the specific case of n=k=nc-r, but the formula (3.59) still holds in the generic case. We refer to [2] for more details about the derivation. In Sect ion 6, we shall re-derive it a simpler way in the MQCD setup. 4. The First Examples of Quantum Coincidence We now describe the first example of coincidence vacua. We beg in with the easiest case, nc= 2. After diagonalization, wehave ph= diag(ph1,ph2). coordinates of the moduli space are u1= The SW we write L without any subscript, we always mean L N= 2. - 20 -The last passage can be done only for nfeven. We start now with the specific case of nf= 2. Thanks to the factorization (4.1), we can now can explicitly compute the four roots of the polynomi al. We call them respectively, for the left and right factors. Their value i (4.2) It is good to begin to study the problem in different sections of the modulispace. First, at Trph= 0, where it corresponds to the SU(2) moduli space. The curve (4.3) There are two singular points. One is u2= 0 where z- 1,2= 2L,0 andz+
1,2= 0,-2L (Figure 6). This is the root of the r= 1 branch. The other singularity is at L,L andz+
1,2=-L,-L (Figure 7). This is the root of the r= 0 branch (this is what is called root of the baryonic branch in [1]). Note tha t the singularity is doubled, and looking at the complete moduli space, it will be clear why 0 1 0 1 6: Roots near the r= 1 vacuum: u1= 0,u2=.16.Figure 7: Roots near the r= 0 vacuum: u1= 0,u2=-1.006. Now we take a section where Tr ph=ML. One singularity is at ph= diag(0 ,M), where one quark becomes massless. It corresponds to u2=M2. The curve (4.4) - 21 -The other singularities are near ph= diag(M/2,M/2) and are strong coupling singulari- ties of a pure SU(2) gauge theory. They correspond to, respec tively, to the coincidence and the coincidence of are the usual monopole and dyon singularity of pure SU(2 8: The Imu1= 0 section of the moduli space. The lines are the co-dimension two sin gu- larities. The four points are the r= 0,1 vacua at u1= 0, and the two coincidence points. We can now draw a picture with the singularities (Figure 8). T he space u1,u2is two complex dimensional. Singularities are one complex dim ensional surfaces, objects of co-dimension one, where two roots of the SW curve coincide. W e draw only three real dimensions, the plane u2and the real part of u1. In this plot, the singularities are lines (real co-dimension two). The three singular curves (4.5) u2=u2 1 2. (4.6) There are three special points where the curves intersect, a nd there are more coincidences of roots. One has already been discussed and is the root of r= 0 branch at u1= 0. The other two special points intersections are at u1=+-2L andu2= 2L2. Where the curve is y2=z3(z+-4L). (4.7) Clearly something special happens in these two singulariti es (see Figures 9 and 10 for the roots in these vacua). These are the coincidence poin ts. To understand what is - 22 0 2 0 2 9: Roots near the first u1= 1.9,u2= 1.68.Figure 10: Roots near the second coinci- dence vacuum: u1=-1.9,u2= 1.68. happening, it is good to start from the r= 1 vacuum at u1= 0 of Figure 6. Here we have two roots in zero, and they correspond to a massless quark. Th e other two roots are in
+-2L. A mass perturbation W=uTrPh2/2 selects this r= 1 vacuum, and the two unpaired roots correspond to the polynomial W'(z)2+f(z). The splitting is due to the quantum effect of f(z). We can now change the u1coordinate, while remaining on the and so change the position of the unpaired roots. To achiev e this, we can use a generic quadratic (4.8) The parameter adetermines the level of u1that this superpotential selects. It selects all the maximal singularity points at the level u1=a.9Changing a, we can thus move along u1while staying on the singular lines. In this way, the two unpa ired roots change their position while the two at the quark singularity remain fixed. When we reach u1= 2L, with the quark roots, and thus we have the coinciden ce point, exactly as was anticipated inFigure3. At u1=-2L isz- 1that coincides with thequarkroots, at u1=
+2L isz+
2that coincides with the quark roots. So we have that the two su respectively the two coincidence vacua. Now we discuss the low-energy effective action in these variou s vacua. First the two u1= 0 cases. The root of the r= 1 non-baryonic Higgs branch (see Table 4) has a flavor doublet dual-quark) charged under only one of the U(1)'s factor s. , (4.10) The Higgs branch emanating from it is exactly the non-baryon ic branch r= 0. (4.11) 9Consider the quark singularity u2=u2 1/2. If we want to select a generic point on this singularity the n W=u(u2-au1) =u(u2 1/2-au1). The vacuum selected will be thus at 23 -This correctly reproduces the r= 1 non-baryonic Higgs branch. The low-energy after the mass perturbation W=uTrPh2/2, (4.12) The dual quark develops a condensate, the U(1) 1is Higgsed, and the only thing that remains in the infrared is the free U(1) 1 0U(1)1xU(1)2 E11 0 E20 1 Table 4: Low energy in the r= 1 vacuum. Table 5: Low energy in the r= 0 vacuum. Then we have the r= 0 vacuum whose particles and charges are given in Table 5. Th e low-energy effective action (4.13) Thereis noHiggs branch emanating from it. This point is agai n selected by W=uTrPh2/2, and the low-energy effective action (4.14) Both hypermultiplets condense, and thus we have a mass gap. We finally come to the coincidence points. In these vacua, mut ual non-local particles become massless at the same time. We have to determine exactl y the charges of these particles with respect to a common basis (note that the previ ous two Tables 4 and 5 were not in the same basis). First of all, we choose a basis of cycle s as in Figure 11. Note that we displayed the roots to the first coincidence point. There are other two roots in the figure; we need to embed the theory in SU(3) -SU(2)xU(1) in order to show the magnetic cycle b2. Cycle a1winds around the roots z- 2andz+
1. Its dual b1winds around the roots z- 2andz+
2. Cycle a2winds around all the four roots, and its dual b2 winds around z- 1, and passes through the two extra roots. This is the choice of basis more convenient 1ele 0 B -1mag 1 Table 6: Particles and charges in the coincidence point.ther= 1 vacuum. A monodromy around the gives the charge of the dual quark /tildewideD, D: a doublet of the flavor group and under the U(1) 1. To get the charge of the other the singularity (4.5). Choosing the vector of cycles like ( a1,a2|b1,b2), the monodromy 1-1 1 1 1-1 1 (4.15) - 24 /Minus1 0 1 11: Our choice of cycles the first coincidence point (Figure 9). This particle, which we call B, is a singlet with respect to the color, magnetically charge d with respect to U(1) 1, and electrically charged with respect to U(1) 2(see Table 6). This is nothing but one of the two particles of Table 5 that are mass less in the r= 0 vacuum. But due to the change of basis, it is now a magnetic object. This is a particular kind of Argyres-Douglas singularity [1 1, 12, 13]. The consists of a non-local, strongly interacting sup erconformal field theory. s (4.9) select, respectively, these two coi ncidence points breaking N= 2 down to N= 1. No condensate is developed, and this means that the theor y in the infrared still remains claim is that in these points there is an interpolation between N= 2 super-QCD and pure N= 1 super-QCD. We shall come back at the end of the next section, after the generalization to ar bitrarync,nf, for the discussion and interpretation of this important issue. For the moment, let us keep in mind the lessons that we learn from this example:
*We have 2 nc-nf(2 in this case) coincidence points symmetric under the Z2nc-nf remnant of the U(1) Rsymmetry.
*The coincidence vacua lie at the intersections between the rvacua non-local particles become massless in these vacua. They are particular cases of Argyres-Douglas fact that the condensate vanishes in this particular poi nt has also been previously noted in [14]. - 25 -Let us now consider a few more specific examples.
* * *
Another example is still nc= 2 but now with nf= 3. This belongs to a special class nf= 2nc-1. The number 2 nc-nfis particularly important due to the discrete R symmetry. The number of coincidence points is in fact equal t o 2nc-nfsince break this discrete symmetry. The previous e xample had two This example has only one coincidence point, and it l ies in the u1= 0 section of the moduli space. The SW curve (4.16) Now we cannot use the last passage of (4.1) and there is no easy expression for the roots. But the maximal singularity is nevertheless easy to detect. The singularity is only one and is in the center of the moduli space at u1= 0,u2= 0. The curve factorizes (4.17) So in this case the classical notion of the origin of the modul i space persists. It can be seen that of three singularities of co-dimension two meet at this point. The superpotential that leaves this point is simply W(Ph) fully computable example, with different 2 nc-nffrom the previous ones, isnc= 4, and nf= 4. Now 2 nc-nf= 4 and we expect four coincidence points. The non-baryonic branch with r= 2 has the following four extra-roots (4.19) Two must collide, and one of the other two, the split ones, mus t be at the mass value zero. One choice (4.20) - 26 -whose solution is u1=+-4L andu2= 6L2. The other (4.21) whose solution is u1=+-i4L andu2=-6L2. We thus find exactly four points as expected. They are related by the Z2nc-nfsymmetry, which in this case is Z4. Again, with these four points, there is a collision with the four singularity ( r= 0,1,2) that departs from u1= 0. The su W(Ph) the four coincidence vacua.11 For the case u1= 4L, and u2= 6L2, the roots are all real, and the factorization of the curve (4.23) Note that 2 = We keep in mind this for the generalization we are going to do in the coming section. 5. General Case We now consider the case of generic ncandnf. The Seiberg-Witten curve (5.1) where we have defined for convenience the polynomial P(nc,nf)(z). The quark labeled by an integer rthat runsfrom /tildewidencto [nf/2]. Along these singular curve has a 2 rzero at the hypermultiplet mass. We consider m= 0 here for simplicity. The curve is thus factorized as (5.2) where what remains is the curve for a gauge group The adjoint scalar is ph= diag(0 nc), (5.3) where the first rdiagonal elements are locked to the mass m= 0 and the other nc-r coordinates span the singular sub-manifold of the Coulomb b ranch. This manifold is a root of arnon-baryonic Higgs the singularity u2=u2 1/4-2L. If we want to select a generic point on this singularity, t hen W=u(u2-au1) The vacuum selected will be thus at u1= 2aandu2=a2-2L. - 27 -Let's consider, to begin with, the maximal case r= [nf/2]. Let us restrict also for simplicity to the case nfeven. Along this nf/2 sub-manifold, the SW curve is factorized as (5.4) What remains after extracting the znffactor is the curve of pure U( nc-nf/2) without matter fields. The maximal singularity points for P(nc-nf/2,0)(z) are given by the solution of Douglas and Shenker [15]. There are nc-nf/2 of these maximal singularity points. They arise when the nc-nf/2 cuts are lined up, and all the roots, apart from two of them, are doubled. Thesimplest solution is when all the roots are o n the real axis. The others Inthereal, casewehave ph= diag(ph1,...,ph nc-nf/2) andphj= The curve factorization is obtained by using properties of the Chebyshev In order to factorize the curve, we have used the important = 1. (5.6) The Douglas-Shenker solution provides the exact position o f the maximal all the U(1) low-energy factors have their own monopol e (or dyon) massless. These discrete areselected bythemasspert urbationinthe case of r=nf/2 is particularly simple due to the existence of this exact an alytic solution. The Douglas-Shenker solution will become partic ularly useful at the end of the section when we shall describe the exact location of the coin cidence points. Now let us describe the low-energy dynamics in a generic rvacuum. We already said that likeEq.(5.2) An SU( r)xU(1)0gauge group with nfflavors in the fundamental in the low-energy spectrum. The non-Abelian gauge group is infrared free if the condition r < nf/2 is satisfied. It becomes superconformal for the maximal cas er=nf/2. The other nc-rdimensions of the Coulomb branch represent U(1) jvector runs from 1 to nc-r. We are then interested in the points of where all the U(1) gauge groups, except one of th em, have their own In these discrete points, the low-energy p hysics can thus be summarized in Table 7 containing the gauge groups and corresponding cha rged hypermultiplets where we have chosen a convenient basis for the cycles in the SW curv e so that the charges are all diagonal. It is easy to check that the Higgs branch emanating from this special vacuum is - 28 *** r 1 E1 1 ...... Enc-r-1 1 Table 7: Low-energy particles and charges in a generic rvacuum with /tildewidenc< to the baryonic Higgs branch determined in the cla ssical theory. These rvacua, where all the particles can be put in a diagonal and local form , are the complete list of the critical points located at u1= 0 that survive after the perturbation by a mass term uTrPh2/2. Let us call Arthe adjoint chiral superfield of the N= 2 SU(r) vector 0,...,n c-rthe real chiral superfield for the U(1) jvector multiplets, chiral superfields of the matter hypermultiplets. The N= 2 simply follows from the information provided in Table 7. After breaking to N= 1 with the mass term uTrPh2/2 in the microscopic theory, the low-energy nc-r) .(5.7) All the matter fields a condensate due to the vanishing condition for the corresponding FArandFAjterms. All the gauge groups, except from the last one U(1)nc-r, are then Higgsed at an energy scale ~uL. The theory in the IR thus loses completely the information about the non-Abelian nature of the microscopic theory. We now come to the minimal case when r=/tildewidenc. It is better to consider this case separately due to some peculiarities that shall soon be evid ent. The curve in the factorizes (5.8) What emerges is the curve for gauge group U(2 nc-nf) with a number of flavors 2 nc-nf. There is now a particularly nice solution for the points of ma ximal singularity. They actually consist of a single vacuum, that is invariant under of the theory. The location of this point is given by ph= the (2nc-nf)'th root of unity. The factorization of the curve is given by the following algebraic (5.10) - 29 -Note the peculiarity that all the roots are now doubled. That is what makes the from the other generic rvacua. Away from u1= 0, the singularity splints branches. As an example, consider 2 nc-nf= 2 where two lines depart from as in Figure critical point, called the root of the baryonic bran ch in [1]12, is a single point, invariant under the discrete global Z2nc-nfsymmetry of the theory part of the classical U(1) R-symmetry). The pe culiarity with respect to the previously discussed rvacua is that now there is an extra degeneracy. The curve give n by (5.8) and (5.10) has in fact no unpaired roots. This means t hat now every U(1) factor in the low energy has its own low-energy massless hypermulti plet. Table 7 must now be supplemented with an additional hypermultiplet. By an appr opriate choice of basis for the U(1)'s, the charges can be taken to be as in Table *** 1 E1 1 E2nc-nf 1 Table 8: Low-energy particles and charges in the let us examine the breaking of the effective theory at the point. In this case, the superpotential (5.11) The important difference with the generic rvacua is that now there is an hypermultiplet Ej for each U(1) and the dual-quarks /tildewideD,Dare now relieved from the duty of role of W'2+fis now played by two roots in zero. All the U(1) factors are the n Higgsed and can be integrated out. The low-energy theory is t hus a non-Abelian SU( theory with the effective (5.12) Aris also massive and can be integrated out. We are thus left wit h 1 super- QCD with we are now working in U( nc) and not SU( nc), there is no baryonic branch, only a branch. 13Since we are in U( nc) and not SU( nc), we can choose a basis so that all the charges are diagonal, e ven in this maximal singularity case. - 30 -Thiscannotbe the infrared of pure N= 1 SQCD. According to the Seiberg duality, the IR of pure N= 1 SQCD is described by SU( /tildewidenc) gauge theory with nfflavors plus a mesonMj iand an opportune superpotential We have the right gauge group and the right dual-quark, but the meson Mj iis missing. Note that Arcannot be identified with the meson of Seiberg duality. First of all, Arhas no flavor charge. Second, from (5.12) we can see that it becomes massive after the ubreaking. Thus, it should be integrated out to get the infrared conformal fixed point. The cases nf=nc+1 and nf=ncrequire special attention. In these cases, there is no non-Abelian group SU( /tildewidenc). Fornf=nc+ 1, we can still use Table 8 and just delete the SU(/tildewidenc) column. For nf=nf, there is no more a flavor charged particle, and we should also delete the U(1) 0column and the flavored particle nfxD.
* * *
Now we are going to find the general solution for the coinciden ce vacua. We need to generalize the findings of Section 4. The task seems apparent ly difficult, but using a trick, and the help of the Doulgas-Shenker solution, we shall findqu ite easily the general solution. First of all, we have to take a look at the example we already fo und in the previous section and guess from the particular case. Then we shall prove that t he guess is right. Consider, for the moment, another theory with double the num ber of colors and flavors Nc= 2nc, N f= 2nf. (5.13) Then take the maximal r=Nf/2 vacua for this theory. We already discussed at the beginning of the section the exact solution for maximal rvacua, when the number of flavors is even. The curve is given (5.14) and we have the Nc-Nf/2 Douglas-Shenker solutions, as in called Ph the adjoint scalar field for the theory ( Nc,Nf). The Coulomb moduli space has dimension Ncand is parameterized by the (5.16) Now note that the roots of the curve (5.15) are symmetric if we exchange simultaneously the sign of the roots. We can thus combine the roots with the same modulus and opposite sign and rewrite the curve in th e following way, for 31 -and in the following for Nf/2 that this looks quite similar to the coincidence points we found in Section 4. To consolidate this guess, note that for the maximal r=Nf/2 vacua we can certainly say that the odd part of the moduli space coordinates vanishe s Uodd= 0. (5.19) We can thus focus our attention on the sub-moduli space of Ueventhat has exactly the same dimension of the moduli space for the ( nc,nf) theory. We finally make the between the ( Nc,Nf) theory and the original ( nc,nf): Z2=z ,2= L. (5.20) And between the moduli spaces: U2k=uk. (5.21) Now is just a matter of rewriting (5.17) and (5.18) with the ne w coordinates, and we get the following factorization of the SW is the coincidence vacuum we were looking for. This is va lid for both nfeven or odd. At the end, everything still follows from the identity (5.6) .14We thus have the with 2[ nf/2] + 1 roots in zeros and all the others, except one, doubled. T he coordinate Tr phof this coincidence vacuum is given (2nc-nf)L, (5.23) with the exception u1= 0 for 2 nc-nf= 1. The coordinate Tr ph2/2 of this is given (5.24) 14The use of the theory( Nc,Nf) has been only amathematical trickto get the solution for th passing through Douglas-Shenker. But maybe there is s omething physical behind this bigger theory. To pursue this idea, certainly a cubic superpotential shoul d be used. - 32 -with the exceptions u2= 0,2 for 2nc-nf= 1,2. The other coincidence vacua are just obtained with a To select these vacua, we need then to use the following k= 1,...,2nc-nf, (5.25) where the index kcorresponds to the various coincidence vacua. As in the nc= 2,nf= 2 example, theory. We are also now ready to understand the multiple collision an ticipated in Figure 4. At the level Tr ph= 0 of the moduli space, there are multiple discrete rvacua where the curve is factorized similar to Eq. (5.2), and the residual part P(nc-r,nf-2r)(z) is further factorized so that all roots are doubled with the exception of two of them . These two unpaired roots correspond the roots of W'(z)2, split by the quantum effect of the polynomial f(z). We want to start from any one of these rvacua and leave the u1= 0 plane, but remaining in this maximal singularity sub-manifold (that is, all the roo ts paired except two of them). One complex parameter, u1, can thus be adjusted in order to bring one of the unpaired roots anywhere we want in the complex plane. To have a coincid ence, we need one of these unpaired roots to collide with the bunch of zeros z2rrepresenting the quark singularity. So it seems that starting from any one of the rvacua, and tuning the coordinate u1, we can create a different coincidence vacuum. The fact is that the y all end up in the same coincidence point, as described by Figure 4. The reason is th e following: an odd number of zeros r2h+1is not possible unless h= [nf/2]. That means that if we start from any r vacuum and we tune u1to bring an extra root in zero, that automatically brings oth of roots also in zero. This is exactly what happens in Figure 8 for (nc,nf) = (2,2). Let us check the previous claim. In the generic rsingularity, the curve factorizes (5.26) It is clear that, if nf-2r >1, is not possible to bring another unpaired root in zero. Sin also vanish, they always come in pairs. When nf-2r= 0 ornf-2r= 1, it then is possible to bring a single unpaired root in zero. We can understand better the intersections of the rbranches by considering only the maximal [ nf/2]. Consider also for simplicity nfeven. We have one ity, that is, the intersection of 2 nc-nfdifferent singularity co-dimension two surfaces at the level u1= 0. Then the maximal r=nf/2 non-baryonic roots, which are nc-nf/2 vacua previously described. Each one of the nc-nf/2 roots collide with two of the surfaces emanating from the baryonic branch. For exam ple in the nc,nf= 2,2 case the singularity that departs from the r= 1 vacuum intersects with the two depart from the r= 0 vacuum (Figure 8). The same thing happens in the general case. Every singularity that departs from an nf/2 vacuum (there are nc-nf/2 of them) intersects with two singularities of the 2 nc-nfthat depart from the 33 -So we can finally try to summarize and conjecture how the pure N= 1 from these coincidence points. We can consider the s implest example where nf=
2nc-2. In this case, we have only two vacua at u1= 0: and the [ nf/2] vacuum. The situation is completely analogous to the exampl enc=nf= 2 discussed in Section 4. We can thus refer to Figure 8 to understand what is h appening. The low-energy dynamics summarized in Table 8 while the [ nf/2] vacuum is summarized in Table 7. The two non-Abelian multiplets are non-local bet ween them. Let's use D,/tildewideD to denote the and Q,/tildewideQto denote the [ nf/2] low-energy hypermultiplet. We can suspect that in the u- limit the forming a mesonic This is now local with the dual quarks Dand/tildewideD. This is probably the way Seiberg duality is obtained in the u- limit. It is good to add more comments about this last, crucial point . The infrared theory at the coincidence point is a superconformal fixed point where m any non-local degrees of free- dom are entangled together. Since it is not possible to write an effective local Lagrangian, the study of this theory becomes difficult. Our approach has be en to consider the theory at the various rvacua, where a low-energy description is available, and pro gressively move toward this coincidence point. In these rvacua, there is a N= 2, SU( with a dual-quark in the fundamental of flavor nfand in the fundamental of gauge nf. The beta function for the non-Abelian gauge coupling is pro portional to 2 r-nf. This is always infrared free (except for the case the maximal bran chr=nf/2 whennfeven). The lowest case the maximal case r= [nf/2] are particularly important. As we already mentioned, the first one provides the SU( /tildewidenc) and the dual-quarks /tildewideD,D, which are essential degrees of freedom in the Seiberg duality. The las tr= [nf/2] is also it gives the maximal non-baryonic branch r= [nf/2], which is crucial if we want to recover N= 1 SQCD in the u- limit. Note that the beta functions for the SU( SU([ nf/2]) are, respectively, the lowest and the highest. When the various rvacua collide in the coincidence point, all the degrees of fr eedom are merged in this superconformal field theory. We cannot wri te an explicit theory since they are mutually non-local. But we can nevertheless say tha t these degrees of freedom are there. The weakest SU( /tildewidenc) and the strongest SU([ nf/2]) play an essential role. As we breakN= 2 with the opportune superpotential (5.25), we select this coincidence point, and we give mass to all the adjoint scalar fields Ar. The dual-quarks do not condense, and so there is noHiggs effect. In the u- , we have to computeagain thebeta now 3 r-nf. In the maximal case, the beta function is proportional to 3[ nf/2]-nfand is now strong in the infrared. It is the strongest one among th e various r. This supports the previous claim that the dual-quarks of the maximal branc h condense and provide essential in the Seiberg dual 1 and nf=nc, there is no non-Abelian group SU( /tildewidenc). But still the minimal rvacuum ( r= 1 for the first case and r= 0 for the second) provides an for the phase of low-energy N= 1 SQCD: the baryon. In the nf=nc+ 1, it is fundamental in flavor (see Table 8 without the SU( /tildewidenc) column) while for the nc=nf case is flavor neutral (see Table 8 without the SU( /tildewidenc) and U(1) 0columns). So the minimal r= 1,0 vacuum provides the baryon while the maximal r= [nf/2] vacuum provides the - 34 -meson. 6. MQCD Super-QCD can be ncD4NS5 Figure 12: Classical brane configuration whose low energy spectrum in R3,1coincide with and a set of orthogonal NS5 and D4 branes. Using the we have the displacement of branes summarized in Table 9 and Figure 12. This is just the coupling effects, the NS5 branes are logarithmically bended due to the pulling of the D4 branes. This log-bending corresponds to th e running of the in the low-energy action. Othe r strong coupling effects are re- lated to the junctions between the D4 branes and the NS5 brane s. A way to resolve provides a window into the strong coupling of the four-dimensional theory. One way to study non-perturbative effects is to lift type IIA st ring theory to M-theory [18, 19]. Now the D4 and NS5 branes are all described by the sam e object, an M5 n in the N= 1 case. We thus obtain a beautiful geometric interpretatio n of many field theoretical quantities, mostly the chiral and topolog ical ones. The goal for this section is to describe the rvacua and the coincidence vacua in the MQCD framework. The MQ CD curve shall provide further evidence for why the coincidenc e points are so special. After the M-theory lifting, the internal space is now Y=R6xS1, which we param- eterize with three complex coordinates v, wands, and one real coordinate the R5R6xS1while the complex coordinate the remaining RxS1.x10is a periodic coordinate parameterizing the M-theory circle. Weakly coupled type IIA string is recovered when the compactification radius is very small. We define the exponential mapping t= exp(s), which is valued in * * 0 0 0 ncD4 * 0 * 0 0 NS5'* * L6 uv 0 nfD4 * 0 * 0 0 Table 9: Brane setup in type IIA string theory whose low energy on R3,1coincide with N= 2 and N= 1 SQCD. - 35 -The brane setup of Figure 12, now becomes a unique M5 brane ext ended along R3,1 times a Riemann surface S embedded in Y. This embedding S Ycontains some about the quantum field theory of interest. The s urface S is what finally is related to the Seiberg-Witten data of the original QFT (we ha ve to use the change of coordinates t=y+Pnc(v)). In the N= 2 case, the M5 brane embedding is the by the 0, (6.1) combined with w= 0. The solutions to this equation (6.2) In the square root, we have exactly the Seiberg-Witten curve . These two branches corre- spond, asymptotically, to the two NS5 branes. The Riemann su rface S is thus a double cover of the vplane. The solutions at v- are t1~vnc, t 2~vnf-nc. (6.3) and correspond to the NS5 and NS5'branes. The flavor branes correspond to an expansion around zero. In a generic point of the moduli space, where 0, the flavor brane is attached to the second sheet t1~Pnc(0), t 2~vnf. (6.4) These correspond to the nfflavor D4 branes attached to the NS5'brane. So far for the N= 2 theory. The breaking to N= 1 by mean of the correspond in this setting to a deformation of the NS5'brane into the wplane [20]. From the MQCD perspective, we have to supplement Eq. (6 .1) with a second equation that provides the information about the embedding in the = 0, (6.5) where the polynomial f(v) captures the quantum corrections to the superpotential. T he two branches of the solutions without f(v), we have w= 0 that corresponds to the NS5 brane and w=
2W'(v) that corresponds to the NS5'brane deformation in the wplane. Without the superpotential the N= 2, curve (6.1) enjoys a moduli space of the solutions parameterized by the nccoefficients contained in the polynomial Pnc(v). But things are more complicated when a superpotential is introd uced and we have to deal also with Eq. (6.5). The equations (6.2) and (6.6) are both two bra nches that cover the v plane. Passages from one branch to another are determined by what is inside the square root: the Seiberg-Witten curve in the first case and the N= 1 curve in the second. For a - 36 -generic value of Pnc, we have a total of four branches connected together. So noth ing that resembles the classical picture. Only for a particular disc rete set of solutions, exactly when the factorization (1.2) is satisfied, can we separate the fou r branches into two with t2,w2, andt1,w2together with t2,w1. And this is the MQCD explanation for the N= 1 factorization of the Seiberg-Witten curve. For the generic rvacuum, the curve is given 0, w2-2uvw-1 = 0. (6.7) Flavor branesare separated into two groupsof randnf-runits (seeFigure 13). to two different spikes of the M5 brane separated in thewplane by a (remember the two solutions in Eq. (6.6)). This in fact corr esponds to the dual-quark condensate (3.59). The is an exception. Now the curve is 13: MQCD curve corresponding to a generic rvacuum.Figure 14: MQCD curve for the 0, w2-2uvw= 0. (6.8) In this case, there is an extra massless particle, and the MQC D becomes divided into two distinct pieces. The two planes meet only at x6- . The reason can be seen from the factorization of the SW curve (5.10). All the roots are no w paired and positioned at Loj 2nc-nf. The cuts are in a closed polygonal shape with 2 nc-nfsides; they the interior and the exterior of the polygon in the c omplexvplane. A to nf-ncD4 branes departs from the NS5'branes and joins at x6- with a spike of ncD4 branes departed from the left NS5 branes (see Figure 14). T here is no asymptotic separation in the wplane and that means no condensation of the dual quark. Note also that the topology of the curve is different. It consists of two that join only at x6- (see Figure 14). We have thus seen that none of the singularities at Tr ph= 0 have the right MQCD curve to describe N= 1 SQCD at u- . In all cases, there is a mass gap and nothing in the low energy. In the baryonic root, the quarks have zero e xpectation value, but the - 37 - NS5 15: MQCD curve for a coincidence point. topology of the curve is changed. The coincidence points are instead very special. The condensate of the quark is zero, and there is no change of topo logy. The curve is given 0, w2-2uvw-v= 0. (6.9) Good things happen in this circumstance. First of all, the fla vor branes correspond to a unique spike of the M5 brane. There is no asymptotic separat ion in the wplane and that means no condensation. Furthermore, despite what happ ened for , the Riemann surface preserves its topology. The curve is still a double cover of the vplane (Figure 15). 7. Conclusion In the paper, we addressed a problem of extended supersymmet ry breaking, from N= 2 to N= 1. Generically, thisisachieved adjoint scalarfield phofthe N= 2 gauge supermultiplet. Classically, this works perfectl y fine, with or without When quarks fields are present, some of the flat directions of the N= 1 theory are already present in the N= 2 theory. Others are recovered as mass proportional to 1/u, that become massless in the u- limit. In quantum theory, there are new subtleties that spoil this b reaking pattern. First of all, the notion of the origin of the moduli space does not hold anymore. What was the classical origin of the moduli space is in some sense split in to various vacua labeled by an integerr. A mass term for the adjoint scalar field phselects any one of these vacua, but none of them, in the u- limit, flows exactly to pure N= 1 super-QCD. The reason is quantum mechanical and must be traced back to th e operator that is generated after integrating out the field ph. This , (7.1) - 38 /u, its effects become negligible in the u- limit. But quantum mechanically it leads to an operator of dimension dgenerally smaller than three. In N= 1 SQCD, the dimension of the meson operator is D(/tildewideQQ) = = 3(nf-nc)/nf. So (7.1) leads generally to an operator of = 6nf-nc nc, (7.2) for very large u. Fornf= 2ncthis is exactly marginal.15It is thus a relevant operator, and it grows as ( o/o0)d-3as the energy scale of the renormalization group flow ogoes to zero. No matter how small the coefficient in front of it is, it will alw ays blow up for energies of the RG flow and force the theory to flow to anot her IR fixed point. Most of the time, like in the cases /tildewidenc< r<=[nf/2], the theory flows to nothing, and there is a mass gap for the gauge degrees of freedom. There is a special case, the minimal where the theory flows to SU( /tildewidenc) Although very near to what we should expect in pure N= 1 SQCD, still there is a missing piece: the meson Mj iand its superpotential interaction with /tildewideD,D. We can interpret this missing piece as damage still caused by the relevant operator (7.1). We can th us conclude that for generic SU(nc) SQCD there is no possibility to flow exactly from N= 2 toN= 1 (Figure 16). But the classical analysis comes IRUV Relevant operator u Relevant operator 1/uN= 2 SQCDN
= 1 SQCD Figure 16: RG flow for various values of u. The five corners are fixed points of the RG flow.back as a source of inspiration. As we saw from the prototype model, super-QED with hypermultiplets of massmand superpotential flowtopure N= 1super- QED as the superpotential goes to infinity. There are Coulomb vacua wherephis equal to the root of and the quarks are massive. and the gauge group is W'(m). Fi- nally, there are the coincidence vacua that arise under th e very particular circumstance in which a root aofW'precisely coincides with a hypermultiplet mass m. Choosing ph=m=a, we get a particular vacuum in which the quarks are massless, but they do not condense. These are the right vacua in which to flow from N= 2 toN= 1 super-QED with massless from SU(nc) to U(nc). U(nc)N= 2 super-QCD has, with respect to SU( nc), one bythecoordinate u1= Trph. the non-triviality of that. The N= 1 is in general not sensitive to the equality nf= 2ncwhich is instead very important for the N= 2 theory. - 39 -is crucial. The quantum effects, as already said, erase the not ion of the origin of the moduli space and split it into various rvacua (in the Tr ph= 0 section). None of these vacua can be considered as the right generalization of the classical n otion of coincidence vacua. None flows toN= 1 super-QCD after the mass breaking term is sent to infinity. But extending the search to the u1dimension we find a nice surprise. We find 2 nc-nfpoints that, by all rights, can be considered as the quantum generalizati on of the classical notion of coincidence vacua. With a suitable k= 1,...,2nc-nf, (7.3) we can select any one of these vacua. And each one is a good coin cidence is thus that these coincidence points are the right ones to flo w from N= 2 super-QCD to N= 1 super-QCD. They are the points in which the effects of the relevant operator (7.1) are minimized and the theory flows as close as possible to N= 1 super-QCD. Let us summarize the arguments we presented in th e paper.
*The formula for the quark condensate, is the starting point in the search for the generalization of the classical notion of coincidence. the roots of W'(z)2are in general split by the polynomial f(z). For the quark condensate to vanish, we need to send one of these ro ots near the bunch of zeros at the mass m. This guiding principle gives us the location of the coincid ence points and the factorization of the Seiberg-Witten curve in these vacua.
*Having done this, we achieve also another, a priori not requi red, result. These coinci- dence points are located at the intersection between singul arities that depart from all thervacua, [nf/2] (the collision of Figure 4). We thus recover the notion of the origin of the moduli space that in the Tr ph= 0 section of the moduli space was lost. The Higgs branch emanating from these vacua is equa l to the branch for r= [nf/2]. But the theory at the root of the branch is much richer than the original r= [nf/2] vacuum at Tr ph= 0. It is a non-local theory, a particular kind of Argyres-Douglas s ingularity.
*The MQCD approach provides an interesting point of view, giv ing some about what is going on. The classical brane setup c onsists of NS5 branes and perpendicular D4 branes. Some quantum effects, such as the and the factorization due to the superpotential, can b e analyzed by lifting to M-theory where the branes are described by a single M5-bra ne with a proper embedding in the v,t,wspace. In ordinary rvacua, the flavor D4-branes are divided into two sets, randnf-r, separated by a wdistance This is the signal of quark condensation. For the particular case r=/tildewidenc, the flavor branes are not separated in the wplane (the quarks do not condense). But in this particular case the M5 brane gets divided into two separated curves that meet only at v-+. Only for the coincidence vacua we have are the quarks D4-bran es non-separated and the topology of the curve does not change. This is certainly w hat is closer to the - 40 -classical realization of a rotation of the NS5'brane while keeping the D4 gauge and flavor branes all allineated.
*We said that the vacua at u1= 0 are not the right coincidence ones because of the relevant operator (7.1). In u- , the coefficient in front of the operator goes to zero, but the operator itself always goes to infinity for suffic iently small energies of the RG flow. This is a relevant perturbation that makes the the ory flow down from the pure N= 1 super-QCD infrared fixed point. In general, we cannot pred ict where the theory will end, but one thing we can certainly say: it is something smaller than the pure N= 1vacuum. We should not underestimate this piece of information. are trivial examples, since the theory flows to nothing . interesting case. From N= 1 SU(/tildewidenc) the meson Mj i(the IR of pure N= 1 SQCD), we flow to the same theory, just without the meson. The coincidence points, as part of the r=ity, contain the degrees of freedom of the gauge group SU( /tildewidenc) and the dual-quark /tildewideD,D. Since they are also part of the other rsingularities, they contain many more degrees of freedom. I t is hard to imagine that there is something different where the the ory could flow, lower than pure N= 1 and higher than the one at the What is missing is just the meson, and, as we saw, the coincidence vacua are ce rtainly capable of providing it. The conclusion is that these particularnf< ncuLN= 2-- nf=ncuLN= 2--L2 N= 1 nf> ncuLN= 2--0 Table 10: Scaling of uLN= 2asu- .coincidence points should be considered ofcoincidence Although the quark condensate van- ishes, it is plausible that the Higgs moduli space will be modified by the uLN= 2term. In Table 10, we have the uLN= as uis sent to infinity (remember the relationship (3.14) betwee n the two scales). This is probably related to the fact that the moduli space for N= 1 SQCD is quantum modified for nf=ncand not modified from the classical one for nf> nc. Note that, at the contrary of color-flavor locked vacua, coin cidence vacua can also exist fornf< nc. Since the color branes are locked to a root of W', there is no lower bound on the number of flavors we can attach to the color branes. Alth ough we have focused our attention on nf>=nc, many things go unchanged for nfsmaller. In particular, there are still points in the moduli space and their position an d curve are still described by the findings of Section 5. It is known that N= 1 SQCD for nf< nchas an instanton generated run-away potential. This could be prob ably related to the scaling of uLN= 2of Table 10. We are left with challenging questions for the future. One qu estion is what happens to the operator (7.1) in the coincidence vacua. Another ques tion regards the utransition from 0 to . The superconformal field theory at the coincidence vacua is like a boiling - 41 -soup, with many non-local degrees of freedom. We have conjec tured how the dual-quark and the meson of the Seiberg duality emerge out of it in the u- limit. Certainly, a more detailed understanding of this transition is needed. I n particular, we do not know if, in the IR fixed point, this transition is sharp or if it is a m arginal deformation from the superconformal N= 2 to the infrared of the Seiberg duality. The completion of t his program should eventually be considered the field theoretic al proof of the Seiberg duality that was initiated in want to thank M. Shifman and A. Yung for useful discussions a bout susy-QCD, and in particular the heterotic vortex problem. I am grateful to M. Shifman for his help and support. I want to thank K. Konishi for discussions in the pas t regarding the susy-QCD moduli space and the APS paper. I want also to thank various co llaborators who helped me in the past in the study of related problems: R. Auzzi, J. Ev slin and M. Matone. I want to thank Ki-Myeong Lee and people at KIAS for their hospi tality in early June 2008. I want also to thank A. Vainshtein for recent discussions. Th is work is supported by DOE grant P. C. Argyres, M. R. Plesser and N. Seiberg, The Moduli Space o f N=2 SUSY QCD and Duality in N=1 SUSY QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 471, 159 (1996) S. Bolognesi, The holomorphic tension of vortices, JHEP 0501, 044 Bolognesi, The holomorphic tension of nonabelian vortices, Nucl. Phys. B 719, 67 (2005) M. Shifman and A. Yung, Non-abelian flux tubes in SQCD: Supersiz ing Phys. Rev. D 72, 085017 (2005) M. Edalati and D. Tong, Heterotic vortex strings, JHEP 0705, 005 Tong, The quantum dynamics of heterotic vortex strings, JHE P0709, 022 M. Shifman and A. Yung, Heterotic Flux Tubes in N=2 SQCD with N=1 arXiv:0803.0158 [hep-th]. M. Shifman and A. Yung, Large-N Solution of the Heterotic N=(0,2) Model, arXiv:0803.0698 [hep-th]. [6] R. Auzzi, S. Bolognesi and J. Evslin, Monopoles can be confined b y 0, 1 or 2 046 (2005) Bolognesi and J. Evslin, Stable vs unstable vortices in SQCD, JHE P0603, 023 K. A. Intriligator and N. Seiberg, Lectures on supersymmetric gauge theories duality, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 45BC, 1 (1996) 42 -[8] N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Electric - magnetic duality, monopole co ndensation, and confinement in N=2 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory, Nucl. Phys. B 426, 19 B 430, 485 (1994)] Seiberg and E. Witten, Monopoles, duality and chiral symmetry b reaking in QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 431, 484 (1994) F. Cachazo, M. R. Douglas, N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Chiral ring s and anomalies gauge theory, JHEP 0212, 071 (2002) Cachazo, N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Phases of N = 1 supersymme tric gauge theories and matrices, JHEP 0302, 042 (2003) F. Cachazo, N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Chiral rings and phases of supersymmetric gauge theories, JHEP 0304, 018 (2003) P. C. Argyres and M. R. Douglas, New phenomena in SU(3) supe rsymmetric gauge theory, Nucl. Phys. B 448, 93 (1995) P. C. Argyres, M. Ronen Plesser, N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Ne w N=2 Superconformal Field Theories in Four Dimensions, Nucl. Phys. B 461, 71 (1996) T. Eguchi, K. Hori, K. Ito and S. K. Yang, Study of N= 2 Superconformal Field Theories in 4 Dimensions, Nucl. Phys. B 471, 430 (1996) A. Gorsky, A. I. Vainshtein and A. Yung, Deconfinement at th e Argyres-Douglas point in SU(2) gauge theory with broken N = 2 supersymmetry, Nucl. Phys. B584, 197 M. R. Douglas and S. H. Shenker, Dynamics of SU(N) supersym metric gauge theory, Nucl. Phys. B 447, 271 (1995) N. Seiberg, Electric - magnetic duality in supersymmetric nonAb elian gauge theories, Nucl. Phys. B 435, 129 (1995) Seiberg, Exact Results On The Space Of Vacua Of Four-Dimensio nal Susy Gauge Theories, Phys. Rev. D 49, 6857 (1994) R. Auzzi, S. Bolognesi, J. Evslin, K. Konishi and A. Yung, Nonab elian and confinement in N = 2 SQCD, Nucl. Phys. B 673, 187 Bolognesi and K. Konishi, Non-Abelian magnetic monopoles and dy namics of confinement, Nucl. Phys. B 645, 337 (2002) Carlino, K. Konishi and H. Murayama, Dynamical symmetry brea king SU(n(c)) and USp(2n(c)) gauge theories, Nucl. Phys. B 590, 37 E. Witten, Solutions of four-dimensional field theories via M-th eory, Nucl. Phys. B 500, 3 (1997) Witten, Branes and the dynamics of QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 507, 658 A. Giveon and D. Kutasov, Brane dynamics and gauge theory, Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 983 (1999) 43 -[20] J. de Boer and S. de Haro, The off-shell M5-brane and non-pe rturbative gauge theory, Nucl. Phys. B 696, 174 (2004) de Boer and Y. Oz, Monopole condensation and confining phase o f N = 1 gauge theories via M-theory fivebrane, Nucl. Phys. B 511, 155 (1998) 44 -
|
0807.2456
|
Stefano Bolognesi
|
Stefano Bolognesi
|
A Coincidence Problem: How to Flow from N=2 SQCD to N=1 SQCD
|
45 pp. v2: typos corrected. v3,v4: other minor corrections
|
JHEP 0811:029,2008
|
10.1088/1126-6708/2008/11/029
|
FTPI-MINN-08/26; UMN-TH-2705/08
|
hep-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We discuss, and propose a solution for, a still unresolved problem regarding
the breaking from $\N=2$ super-QCD to $\N=1$ super-QCD. A mass term $W=\mu \Tr
\Phi^2 / 2$ for the adjoint field, which classically does the required breaking
perfectly, quantum mechanically leads to a relevant operator that, in the
infrared, makes the theory flow away from pure $\N=1$ SQCD. To avoid this
problem, we first need to extend the theory from $\SU (n_c)$ to $\U (n_c)$. We
then look for the quantum generalization of the condition $W^{\prime}(m)=0$,
that is, the coincidence between a root of the derivative of the superpotential
$W(\phi)$ and the mass $m$ of the quarks. There are $2n_c -n_f$ of such points
in the moduli space. We suggest that with an opportune choice of
superpotential, that selects one of these coincidence vacua in the moduli
space, it is possible to flow from $\N=2$ SQCD to $\N=1$ SQCD. Various
arguments support this claim. In particular, we shall determine the exact
location in the moduli space of these coincidence vacua and the precise
factorization of the SW curve.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 16 Jul 2008 19:27:56 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Sat, 6 Sep 2008 09:59:58 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Mon, 6 Oct 2008 19:00:10 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Sun, 9 Nov 2008 02:48:02 GMT"
}
] | 2011-08-03T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Bolognesi",
"Stefano",
""
]
] |
2 Marko A. Rodriguez1, Vadas Gintautas1, and Alberto Pepe2 Steal Your Face icon in Figure 1 that was released as the album cover art to the live 1976 Steal Your Face album [10]. Fig. 1. The Grateful Dead Steal Your Face icon. The history of the Grateful Dead's album releases (13 studio albums and 77 live albums) further reinforces the band's emphasis on concerts. More live albums are released regularly as high quality recordings of good performances are discovered in the Grateful Dead concert archive. For the band and for the fans, the performances of the Grateful Dead were all about diversity in the live music experience. In any given show, the concert set list, the improvisations, and the mood of the band all varied. In concert, all of these factors came together to create a for their fans each and every time. Perhaps even more astounding than their prolic concert performances is the dedication that their fans (known as deadheads) had to their music [13, 1, 17, 16]. The typical deadhead was not a passive consumer of recorded studio albums, but an active concert goer that traveled with the band from concert to concert, city to city, and country to country. Some 10 years after the Grateful Dead disbanded, the band's music is still heavily listened to as evinced by from the popular online music service known as last.fm.3The last.fm is recommendation software that works with popular computer music players such as iTunes or Winamp. Whenever a song is played using, say, iTunes, the plug-in reports this activity to the last.fm server where it is aggregated. From August 2005 to October 2007, there were over 2.5 million Grateful Dead song usages recorded by last.fm. With 72% of the users of last.fm under the age of 354, the popularity of the Grateful Dead, a generation of fans later and 10 years after the band's dissolution, is still very strong. This article presents an analysis of the Grateful Dead's concert behavior and exposes a rela- tionship between the concert song patterns from 1972 to 1995 and the last.fm listening statistics of the band's songs from August 2005 to October 2007. First the available set list data is sum- marized and presented with an analysis of the concert behavior of the band. Next the usage data from last.fm is presented with an analysis of the listening behavior of last.fm members. Finally, a comparative analysis of the concert and listening behavior of the Grateful Dead is is available at: last.fm internal web statistics, courtesy Anil Bawa-Cavia.A Grateful Dead Analysis: The Relationship Between Concert and Listening Behavior 3 2 The Grateful Dead Concert Behavior Concert set lists provide the raw data from which to study the concert behavior of the data gathered include 1,590 set lists for concerts from 1972 to 1995, with song plays. A typical, unmodied set list is presented Arena, San Francisco, CA (12/31/77) Music Never Jed Funiculi Funicula Me and My Uncle Loser Jack Straw Friend of the Devil Lazy Magnolia Scarlet Begonias Fire on the Rat drums Not Fade Away Around and Around One More Saturday Night Casey Jones Blank lines divide the set list into 4 components. The rst component is the concert venue and location along with the date that the concert was played. The second component is the rst set list in the sequence in which the songs were played. For example, Friend of the Devil was after Jack Straw in the above example. The third component is the second set list of the concert. The second set of the Grateful Dead is known for fewer songs and sessions. Furthermore, the second set of a Grateful Dead concert is known for its lending of songs in which there exist fewer pauses between the end of one song and the beginning of the next; that is, the second set was often a large medley of sorts. Second set medleys often featured pairs of songs that were almost always played together. For example, China Cat Sun
ower almost always preceded Know You Rider, but never in the opposite order. Also, China Cat Sun
ower was very rarely played with a di erent song following.6The fourth and 5Set list data obtained from . The data were cleaned to remedy various typographical alterations (e.g. Trucking and Truckin' are the same song), to x various spelling errors (e.g. Warf Rat and Wharf Rat are the same song), and to x various abbreviations (e.g. China Cat and China Cat Sun
ower are the same song). 6A similar pattern exists for other song pairs such as Scarlet Begonias and Fire on the of Circumstance and Lost Sailor, and Cryptic Envelopment and The Other One.4 Marko A. Rodriguez1, Vadas Gintautas1, and Alberto Pepe2 last component, which is usually the shortest, is the encore set list. The Grateful Dead were known to typically play their concerts in this 3 set form. A basic measure, calculated using many concert set lists, is to simply count the number of times a given song is played over all concerts. This ranked list of songs is a rudimentary greatest hits list of sorts, but also a histogram of concert plays sheds light on the distribution of these counts. Did most songs get approximately the same number of concert plays, or did the band play a small set of favorite songs interspersed with less popular songs to provide variety? Table 2 shows the raw counts for the 15 most played songs. Note that of the 1,590 concerts analyzed, 1,386 of those concerts included the Drums improvisational rhythm sequence, which in the second set of most concerts. The Grateful Dead very often used Drums in the second set to bridge two songs that would not otherwise be simple to link as a medley. Figure 3 presents a histogram denoting the number of songs that were played a given number of times. In summary, many songs were played only a few times and few songs were played many times. song times played Drums 1386 Playing in the Band 651 Sugar Magnolia 494 ot Fade Away 486 The Other One 438 Jack Straw 437 Trucking 427 Me and My Uncle 412 Looks Like Rain 407 Promised Land 407 Know You Rider 406 China Cat Sun
ower 403 ew Minglewood Blues 398 Around and Around 395 Tennessee Jed 390 Fig. 2. The top 15 Grateful Dead songs played in concert from 1972 to 1995. times 3. A histogram of the number of times a song was played in concert. Most songs were played only a few times and very few songs were played many times. (The vertical axis was trimmed from its maximum of 150 in order to preserve The Grateful Dead Usage Statistics The online music service last.fm tracks how registered members enjoy music by what songs they play on Internet radio or through a computer music player plug-in. The last.fm service maintainsA Grateful Dead Analysis: The Relationship Between Concert and Listening Behavior 5 a database of the listening behavior of its registered members. From this database, the last.fm service is able to recommend songs and artists to its members based on the listening behavior of similar members. This service is analogous to Amazon.com using historical purchasing behavior to recommend products to customers. Table 4 lists the top 15 Grateful Dead songs listened to by last.fm members. These data were gathered from August 2005 to October 2007 and unique listening events. Figure 5 presents a histogram of the listening counts of songs. In summary, similar to the concert behavior of the Grateful Dead, many songs were listened to a few times and a few songs were listened to many times. song times used Friend of the Devil 143988 Sugar Magnolia 122877 Casey Jones 102449 Box of Rain 88340 ncle John's Band 82431 Ripple 80629 Touch of Grey 71270 Brokedown Palace 54675 Candyman 54344 Fire on the Mountain Tower 45404 Scarlet Begonias 42137 Dark Star 39953 China Cat Sun
ower 36479 Fig. 4. The top 15 downloads of Grateful Dead songs on last.fm from August 2005 to 5. A histogram of times a song was lis- tened to, from last.fm data. (The vertical axis was trimmed from its maximum of 200 in order to pre- serve diagram clarity.) 4 The Relationship Between Concert and Usage Behavior The last.fm music service records listening behavior of songs that have appeared in some published form, such as studio albums, singles, and recordings of live concerts. The Grateful Dead deviated from the standard model of releasing studio albums, in that their primary revenue stream was through concert performances, even from the start. The Grateful Dead produced 13 studio albums and 77 live albums. The band's rst live album, Live/Dead, was released in 1969 [6]. With respect to the in
uence of live recordings on the present generation of listeners, nearly all live albums were a direct re
ection of a particular live concert performance and as such, respected that concert set list's song sequence. Thus, if a last.fm listener were to listen to any one of the many live albums, he or she is, in fact, replaying concert history and contributing proportionately to the number6 Marko A. Rodriguez1, Vadas Gintautas1, and Alberto Pepe2 of songs listened to as times played in concert. This notion is further accentuated by fans that created digital renditions of their favorite concert tapes.7Given that there are currently 5 times more live albums than studio albums, one may expect that last.fm users would primarily listen to recordings of concerts and that the usage data would be directly correlated with that of the set list data. However, as shown in this section, there are signicant deviations from a Reasons for these deviations may include the fact that listeners can replay only their favorite songs from live albums, may prefer studio albums to recordings of live shows, and are able to make compilations of tracks (playlists) that di er from the live and studio 6 plots each song in a two-dimensional space. Each song is provided a coordinate in this space, where the horizontal coordinate is the number of times the song was played in concert and the vertical coordinate is the number of times the song was listened to by last.fm members. Given that each song has two associated values (horizontal and vertical coordinates), it is possible to form two vectors of these numbers and to measure the correlation of these vectors to determine how strongly their values are related. The analysis reveals that the listening behavior of last.fm members is strongly correlated with the concert behavior of the Grateful Dead (a of 0 :763 where 0 is uncorrelated and 1 is perfectly the data are not perfectly correlated, it is valuable to examine songs which are exceptions to this trend. The solid curved line in Figure 6 shows regions for which songs display a strong two dashed lines represent the 40th-quantile and 75th-quantile of concert plays. These quantiles were subjectively chosen in order to provide a discussion of songs that are from the trend. Finally, the two closed polygons labeled AandBrepresent the songs. Polygon Aencapsulates songs that were heavily listened to by last.fm members, but played few times in concert by the Grateful Dead. On the other hand, Bencapsulates songs that were heavily played by the Grateful Dead, but less listened to (and possibly overlooked) by last.fm Aencapsulates those songs that were heavily listened to by last.fm users but not heavily played by the Grateful Dead in concert. Many of the songs in polygon Aare old classics that did not persist due to either changes in the band or to the band's extremely prolic period of songwriting in the early 1970s. For example, although the song Mister Charlie was played for the last time in concert on May 26, 1972 at the Strand Lyceum in London, England, it was featured on the Europe `72 album [7]. This album reached a peak spot of 24 on the Billboard pop albums chart in 1973. Thus, while not being played much in concert during the band's lifetime, 7Prior to the advent of the Internet and the easy distribution of digital audio les, Grateful Dead concert tape trading was an extremely popular way of disseminating the Grateful Dead's live experience. In fact, the band encouraged this [5]. Many tapes have now been digitized and shared online by fans. 8A Spearman rank-order correlation reveals a correlation of = 0:763 with a is inversely related, = 0 is unrelated, and = 1 is correlated. The p-value indicates the probability of such a correlation occurring randomly; the pvalue for this correlation indicates that, at random, this correlation would occur 5 times out of the line represents a linear regression model that predicts usage in terms of concert plays. The data were t to a line; the line appears curved because the values on both axes are plotted on logarithmic (base-10) scale to preserve diagram clarity. 10A random sample of songs were removed from this diagram to preserve clarity as to ensure that song labels did not overlap. Furthermore, while AandBoccupy regions outside of their this is to ensure that song labels were encapsulated.A Grateful Dead Analysis: The Relationship Between Concert and Listening Behavior 7 Mister Charlie remains a fan treasure by virtue of securing a place on a much Similar arguments can be made for Sage and Spirit and Blues for Allah which, dicult and therefore generally avoided in concert, are songs that were released on theBlues ForAllah LP [9] which reached spot 12 on the Billboard charts for pop album in 1975. Good Morning Little School Girl was primarily sung by Ron McKernan, whose untimely death in 1973 caused the song to be removed from the Grateful Dead concert play list except for a few special appearances in the late 80s and early 90s.11However, Good Morning Little School Girl is the opening track of the Two from theVault album [3] that contains a live recording of the August 24, 1968 Shrine Exhibit Hall performance of the Grateful Dead. Although Jerry Garcia was the primary singer of Death Don't Have No Mercy, the song had a similar concert fate as Good Morning Little School Girl and was also released on the Two from theVault live album. Two from theVault reached position 119 in 1992 on the Billboard to Handle, like Good Morning Little School Girl was a Ron McKernan specialty that was dropped after his death, except for being played during the New Year's Eve show of 1982 in Oakland, California. Finally, Cryptic Envelopment provided a medley prelude to the popular The Other One and only later in the bands life was The Other One separated from and preceded by Drums. It is worth noting that 28 of the 77 live albums of the Grateful Dead include The Other One while only 7 include Cryptic Bencapsulates those songs that were heavily played in concert throughout the Grate- ful Dead's career, but for various reasons, were less frequently listened to by last.fm members. Drums is perhaps the most salient of this collection of songs at the extreme of the bound- ary. Drums is an all-drum improvisational piece that usually appeared in the second set of a Grateful Dead concert. Usually appearing with Drums was the full sonic spectrum improvisa- tion of Space which included all band members. Both Drums and Space found a stable home on the Infrared Roses album [11], but unfortunately, due to the esoteric nature of Infrared Roses has been less well received by the general public and thus received no popular awards and did not make it on any music charts. Furthermore, to compound the situation, the Grateful Dead provided unique names for Infrared Roses tracks and thus, when played by last.fm users, are not associated with the typical Drums and Space songs of the concert set lists. It is interesting to note the songs Saint of Circumstance, When I Paint My Masterpiece, Victim or the Crime, Lost Sailor, and Greatest Story in the bottom left of polygon B. All of these songs were created by the song writing duo of Barlow and Weir and sung in concert often by Bob Weir. While these songs were played extensively in concert, they little attention from last.fm users. Finally, the extreme upper right of this plot is important as Trucking and Sugar not only the most popular songs in terms of times played in concert, but in terms of times listened to on last.fm. Trucking is on 25 of the 90 released Grateful Dead albums and Sugar Magnolia is on 32 of those albums. Both Trucking and Sugar Magnolia were also well received publicly. Trucking reached position 64 in 1971 and Sugar Magnolia reached position 91 in 1973 on the Billboard pop singles charts. Also in this area is Touch of Grey. Touch of Grey was the only Grateful Dead song with an accompanying music video and in 1987, reached 11It is worth noting that Mister Charlie was also primarily sung by Ron McKernan and thus, didn't last with the Grateful Dead past his lifetime. 12The Eleven and Cryptic Envelopment are also on Two from theVault.8 Marko A. Rodriguez1, Vadas Gintautas1, and Alberto Pepe2 the top 10 Billboard single's chart. By comparison to produced greatest hits albums, Table 1 lists the songs that were released on the 2003 Very Best oftheGrateful Dead compilation. Of these songs, 12 out of the 17 songs are in the top right quadrant (these songs are marked with anin Table 1), meaning that they were both played and listened to heavily by the Grateful Dead and their fans, respectively.13A similar situation exists with the Skeletons from theCloset greatest hits album for which 8 out of 11 songs are in the top right quadrant [8] (Table 2 presents the songs on the album).14Of particular importance is Box of Rain (on Very Best by Phil Lesh and Robert Hunter. This song, written after the death of Phil Lesh's father, is not only the last song ever played by the Grateful Dead in concert15, but also unique in that it is one of the few songs for which Phil Lesh was the primary singer. In summary, the upper right hand quadrant of this diagram is ripe for creating compilation and greatest hits albums as it re
ects both what the band as well as present day fans appreciate.
# Track name 1 Trucking
2 Touch of Grey
3 Sugar Magnolia
4 Casey Jones
5 ncle John's Band
6 Friend of the Devil
7 Franklin's Tower
8 Estimated Prophet
9 Eyes of the World
10 Box of Rain
11 .S. Blues 12 The Golden Road to Ultimate Devotion 13 One More Saturday Night
14 Fire on the Mountain
15 The Music Never Stopped 16 Hell in a Bucket 17 Ripple Table 1. The tracks of the Very Best ofthe Grateful Dead greatest hits album [12]. Upper right quadrant songs in Figure 6 are marked with
.# Track name 1 The Golden Road to Ultimate Devotion 2 Trucking
3 Rosemary 4 Sugar Magnolia
5 St. Stephen 6 ncle John's Band
7 Casey Jones
8 Mexicali Blues
9 Turn on Your Love Light
10 One More Saturday Night
11 Friend of the Devil
Table 2. The tracks of the Skeletons hits album [8]. Upper right quadrant songs in Figure 6 are marked with. 13Eyes of the World and Estimated Prophet are not displayed as they were randomly removed to preserve diagram Blues is not displayed as it was randomly removed to preserve diagram clarity. 15The nal Grateful Dead performance took place at Soldier Field on July 9, 1995 in Chicago. Jerry Garcia died exactly one month later on August 9, 1995.A Grateful Dead Analysis: The Relationship Between Concert and Listening Behavior 9 5 Conclusion The Grateful Dead were an American music phenomenon that in
uenced multiple generations of music lovers. For 30 years, the Grateful Dead made a career out of an unrelenting tour schedule that took them around the world, and, unlike typical bands, took their fans with them. It is now 43 years since the band started and with the use of online music providers and services, it is possible to track the listening behavior of the many Grateful Dead fans in the world today. This article presented an analysis comparing the popularity of Grateful Dead songs as identied by both how many times they were played in concert and how many times they were listened to by members of the last.fm online music service. The correlation between concert plays and fan listens is strong, but not perfect. Those songs that existed as outliers to a perfect correlation were analyzed to understand what made these songs deviate from the model. These deviations can be understood by changes in the band, by live performance album releases, and by the very nature of the songs is much to be learned about American concert tour culture and the bands that bring this culture to fruition [2]. Perhaps more than any other band, there exists large amounts of Grateful Dead data that go beyond set lists to include lyrics, chord progressions, concert reviews, and history. Many books have been published about the Grateful Dead and albums continue to be released 13 years after their nal concert in 1995. Without a doubt, the Grateful Dead have made a profound impact on that which is American rock authors would like to thank Anil Bawa-Cavia of last.fm for providing the Grateful Dead raw usage data, Jerry Stratton for providing the set list data, and the Grateful Dead for doing what they do Rebecca G. Adams. Inciting sociological thought by studying the deadhead community: Engaging publics in dialogue. Social Forces , 77(1):1{25, 1998. 2. Grant C. Black, Mark A. Fox, and Paul Kochanowski. Concert tour success in North America: An examination of the top 100 tours from 1997 to 2005. Popular Music and Society , Grateful Dead. Two from theVault. Music Album, May 1992. 4. David Dobb. The Complete Annotated Grateful Dead Lyrics . Free Press, 2007. 5. John R. Dwork and Michael Getz, editors. The Deadhead's Taping Compendium: An In-Depth Guide to the Music of the Grateful Dead on Tape . Holt, New York, NY, 1998. 6. Grateful Dead. Live/Dead. Music Album, November 1969. 7. Grateful Dead. Europe `72. Music Album, November 1972. 8. Grateful Dead. Skeletons from theCloset: TheBest ofGrateful Dead. Music Album, February 1974. 9. Grateful Dead. Blues forAllah. Music Album, September 1975. 10. Grateful Dead. Steal Your Face. Music Album, June 1976. 11. Grateful Dead. Infrared Roses. Music Album, November 1991.10 Marko A. Rodriguez1, Vadas Gintautas1, and Alberto Pepe2 12. Grateful Dead. TheVery Best oftheGrateful Dead. Music Album, September 2003. 13. Paul Grushkin, Cynthia Bassett, and Jonas Grushkin. Grateful Dead: The Ocial Book of the Dead Heads . Harper Paperbacks, 1983. 14. Madhu Lundquist. The SetList Program: Grateful Dead Setlists and Listener Experiences. Dennis McNally. A Long Strange Trip: The Inside History of the Grateful Dead . Broadway Books, 2002. 16. Melissa McCray Pattacini. Deadheads yesterday and today: An audience study. Popular Music and Society , 24, 2000. 17. Robert Sardiello. Youth Culture: Identity in a Postmodern World , chapter Identity and in Deadhead Subculture. Blackwell Publishers, 1998. 18. David J. Sheskin. Parametric and nonparametric statistical procedures . Chapman and HallCRC, New York, NY, 2004.A Grateful Dead Analysis: The Relationship Between Concert and Listening Behavior plays (log 10)last.fm usage (log FADE COMES SUNSHINEBLACK THROATED WINDME AND MY UNCLEPLAYING IN THE BAND BIG RIVER WEATHER REPORT SUITEEL PASOCHINA CAT AND BOBBY MCGEE GREATEST STORYAROUND AND AROUNDTHROWING STONES WANG DANG OR THE CRIMESAINT OF IN THE RAINCUMBERLAND BLUES THE SAME THINGITS ALL OVER NOW ETERNITYBOX OF RAIN TOMORROW IS STRAWROW JIMMYBIG RAILROAD FINGERS MIDNIGHT HOURIKO IKOHIGH TIMEHELL IN A BUCKET VISIONS OF JOHANNASHIP OF FOOLSI NEED A MIRACLEDONT EASE ME INUNCLE JOHNS BAND COLD RAIN AND SNOWSCARLET STREET THE WEIGHTTOUCH OF GREYDARK STARTERRAPIN STATIONSTELLA BLUEDRUMS MY BROTHER ESAUIT MUST HAVE BEEN THE ROSESLET IT GROWTHE MUSIC NEVER STOPPEDFRIEND OF THE DEVIL ON THE ROAD AGAINMAMA TRIED SMOKESTACK LIGHTNINGONE MORE SATURDAY NIGHT WHEN I PAINT MY MASTERPIECELAZY LIGHTNINGCASEY JONES MORNING DEWCHINA DOLLWHARF RAT HEY JUDESUNSHINE DAYDREAMTHE WHEELDEATH DONT HAVE NO MERCY SO MANY ROADSATTICS OF MY LIFE COMES A TIMECAUTIONTHE OTHER ONE SPANISH JAM HEY POCKY WAYSUGAR TOWER WE BID YOU GOODNIGHT BLUES FOR ALLAHHARD TO HANDLETURN ON YOUR LOVE LIGHT JOHNNY B GOODEBUILT TO LASTFIRE ON THE MOUNTAINNEW SPEEDWAY BOOGIE UNBROKEN CHAINCOSMIC CHARLIE DEEP ELEM BLUESLOST SAILOR BABA ORILEYSPACEI KNOW YOU RIDER EASY TO LOVE YOU WEST LA FADEAWAYJACK A ROEPEGGY OUS AND THE ENGINEERDARK HOLLOW OH BABE IT AINT NO LIEKNOCKING ON HEAVENS DOORMISTER CHARLIENEXT TIME YOU SEE ME DAY OF LONDONHELP ON THE WAYSAGE AND SPIRIT LITTLE SADIERIPPLE TONS OF STEEL ROSALIE HALF-STEP THATS ALRIGHT MAMAMAN OF PEACEBALLAD OF A THIN MANTAKE ME TO THE RIVERBEEN ALL AROUND THIS WORLDCRYPTICAL ENVELOPMENTTHE BEEGOOD MORNING LITTLE SCHOOL GIRL MISSION IN THE RAINMIND LEFT BODY JAMNOBODYS FAULT BUT MINE LET IT ROCKAB Fig. 6. Grateful Dead concert plays vs. last.fm usage. Unfortunately, not all song names could be displayed due to severe overlapping of the labels. In order to remedy this situation, in the more dense regions, song labels were randomly removed.
|
0807.2466
|
Marko A. Rodriguez
|
Marko A. Rodriguez and Vadas Gintautas and Alberto Pepe
|
A Grateful Dead Analysis: The Relationship Between Concert and Listening
Behavior
| null |
First Monday, volume 14, number 1, ISSN:1396-0466, University of
Illinois at Chicago Library, January 2009.
| null |
LA-UR-08-04421
|
cs.CY cs.GL
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
The Grateful Dead were an American band that was born out of the San
Francisco, California psychedelic movement of the 1960s. The band played music
together from 1965 to 1995 and is well known for concert performances
containing extended improvisations and long and unique set lists. This article
presents a comparative analysis between 1,590 of the Grateful Dead's concert
set lists from 1972 to 1995 and 2,616,990 last.fm Grateful Dead listening
events from August 2005 to October 2007. While there is a strong correlation
between how songs were played in concert and how they are listened to by
last.fm members, the outlying songs in this trend identify interesting aspects
of the band and their fans 10 years after the band's dissolution.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Tue, 15 Jul 2008 21:31:36 GMT"
}
] | 2009-01-07T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Rodriguez",
"Marko A.",
""
],
[
"Gintautas",
"Vadas",
""
],
[
"Pepe",
"Alberto",
""
]
] |
The rapid neutron capture ( r-) process is introduced more than 50 years ago to ( p-) process [1]. It is responsible for the synthesis of about half of th e nuclei beyond the iron group. The recent observations [2] of extremely metal-po or ([Fe/H] ([Ba/Eu] <0)stars, showaconsistent elemental indicate that the r-process abundance patterns are most possibly produced only by a single or at most a few r-process events for the heavier elements with Z>=56, i.e., there may be only one or a few r-process sites in the early Galaxy. However, the exact astrophysical site where the r-process proceeds has not been un- ambiguously identified, despite decades of work. This research is co mplicated by the re- quired knowledge of both the astrophysical environments and the nuclear properties of nuclei. Previous phenomenological studies indicate th at ther-process occurs at temperatures around T ~109K and at extreme neutron fluxes with neutron number densities nn>1020cm-3[3, 4, 5]. Moreover, the r-process should be a dynamical process with changing conditions and paths [4]. On the other hand, the determined astrophysical condition for th er-process site relies on the extrapolation of theoretical nuclear models for the terra incognita. Among the required nuclear properties, the key one is the nuclear mass, from which one can the one-neutron separation energy, shell gap and also the beta-decay energy. As discussed in Ref. [5], though various nuclear mass models agree quite well with the known data, towardsthevery neutron -richside, wherethe Asaresult, conditionfort vary for different model predictions distinguish the astrophysical uncertainty fromthenuc lear physics uncertainty. In thisletter, and assuming the same astrophysical conditions, the impa ct of different mass models on ther-process calculation will be investigated. Other mass models used inc lude the finite- range droplet model (FRDM) [7], extended Thomas-Fermi plus Str utinsky integral with quenched shell (ETFSI-Q) [8] and the recent Hartree-Fock-Bog olyubov (HFB-13) model [9]. The RMF approach has made lots of successes in describing the nucle ar properties far away from the b-stability line as reviewed, for example in Ref. [10]. The first systema tic calculation of the nuclear ground state properties including nuclear masses, radii and de- formations has been done recently for all the nuclei lying between t he proton drip line and the neutron drip line [6]. A good agreement with the available data is fou nd. The shows that the predictions of nuclear masses in the RMF are generally with respect to the experimental data. However, consider ing the factor that with less than 10 parameters obtained from fitting several doubly magic nuc lei, the RMF almost the same prediction power ( ~0.65 MeV) for one neutron separation energy Sn[11] as those highly parameterized mass models [7, 8, 9], thus it is very interesting to see to what extent the solar r-abundances can be reproduced using this new table. We adopt a site-independent r-process calculation as in Ref. [5], where a configuration of 16r-process components is chosen as a reasonable approximation to t he The seed-nuclei iron are irradiated by neutron sources of hig h and continuous T~109 K). The neutron captures proceed in (n, g)-(g, n) equilibrium, and the abundance flow from one isotopic chain to the next is governed by b-decays. Roughly, the r-process Fig. 1. Similar to the classical s-process [12], these different r-process components are assumed to satisfy a simply exponential formula, i.e., o(nn) =na n,t(nn) =bxnc n, where o(nn) andt(nn) are the corresponding weighting factor and neutron irradiation t ime for the component with a neutron density nn. The parameters a, b and c are determined from the least-square fit to the solar r-process abundances. The best simulation using the new RMF mass table is presented in Fig. 1. In this simulation, the b-decay properties are taken from the recent calculation [13]. Fur thermore, the available experimental results [11, 14] have been included. The corresponding The distribution, ingeneral, can be well reproduced. However, the predicted large shell towar ds the neutron drip line in the RMF model leads to a large gap before the second and third abu ndance peaks. Previous investigations [4, 15] showed that a quenched shell could avoid the jump in the r-process path and thus result in a better simulation to the observa tion. Nevertheless, it is still unclear whether there is a shell quenching effect or to what ex tent it is towards the neutron drip line, since the present experimental results are still in debate. One example is the shell gap at the critical waiting point130Cd. It is firstly suggested to be a quenched shell in Ref. [16]. However, a recent experiment result [17], interpreted b y the shell-model calculations, shows no evidence of shell quench we have done the r-process calculations using respectively FRDM [7], ETFSI- Q [8] and HFB-13 [9] mass inputs while keeping the same b-decay properties. All the calculations have used the same astrophysical condition, i.e., the be st case obtained using the RMF masses. Along with the observation [12], the abundance dist ributions around the third peak are compared with the RMF result in Fig. 2. It shows th at the the neutron shells N= 126 strongly depends onthe mass models applied. Before the 3abundance peak, the RMF simulation shows a broad dip around A= 170, while the ETFSI- Q and HFB-13 simulations have a dip towards a large mass number ( ~180). Differences also exist after the abundance peak. The different deficiencies in reproducing the solar r-process abund ances can be mainly traced back to two aspects. First, different nuclear mass models p redict quite different shell evolution towards the neutron drip line. The shell gap energy at N= 126 in the RMF model is about 2 MeV larger than that in other models. A stronger sh ell structure will result in more nuclear matter accumulated in nuclides with a neutron m agic number and less in nuclides around, which is reflected by dips on both sides of the a bundance peak in the calculated r-process abundance. Second, different models assign different locations of the shape transition before the shell closures. The predicted r-proc ess paths pass through ranges before going to the magic numbers N= 82 and 126. The first oblate nuclides for Z= 60-63 are in the mass number of 172-177 for the RMF predictions, while in the HFB-13 model the corresponding mass numbers are 178-179. One neutron for these nuclides at the shape-transition point will deviat e from the dependence of the mass number as predicted by a classical liqu id droplet mass model, and eventually affect the r-process path. Together, both aspec ts result in a direct jump in the r-process path from169Pr to185Pr (15 mass units) in the RMF simulation (see Fig. in the nuclides with the mass number 170-177, therefo re a better reproduction of the solar r-process abundances at A ~170, however a worse reproduction at A ~180. The gap around the N= 126 shell also exist in other simulations though varying in magnitude and mass number. In the same astrophysical environment, the r-process path in the RMF simulation runs about 1-2 mass units towards the neutron drip line th an those of the present investigation, it is shown that the nature of the r-process is complicated due to the interplay between the nuclear physics and the astrophy sical environment. Since it is still not accessible to measure most of the nuclei masses along th e r-process path in the near future, further theoretical development aiming at the d escription of the know and unknown masses simultaneously is badly needed. If the astrophysic al conditions for the r-process are identified precisely, this may serve as a constraint fo r the nuclear mass if nuclear masses are known in a good precision, it can be used to constraint the potential site for the r-process as well. In the present letter, we have shown that the r-process calculation is quit sensitive to the nuclear mass inputs. Precise mass measurement of neutron-rich n uclides with an accuracy less than 100 keV are needed to decisively determine the shell evolut ion atN= 82 and 126 towards the neutron drip line, as well as the locations of the sha pe transition before 4these shell closures. These experimental results will offer a primar yconstraint to theexisting mass models and a strong motivation for further exploration of the oretical mass models, and furthermore, Meanwhile, as there is no clear evidence to accept or reject any mass model me ntioned above, it is necessary to take different mass models into account in the r-process study. [1] Burbidge E M, Burbidge G R, Fowler W A and Hoyle F 1957 Rev. Mod. Phys. 29547 [2] Cowan J J and Snden C 2006 Cowan J J, Thieleman F K and Truran J W 1991 Phys. Rep. 208267 [4] Kratz K L, Bitouzet J P, Thielemann F K, M oller P and Pfeiffe r B 1993 ASTROPHYS. J. 403216 [5] Sun B, Montes F, Geng L S, Gessel H, Litvinov Yu A and Meng J, submitted to Phys. Rev. C [6] Geng L S, Toki H and Meng J 2005 Prog. Theor. Phys. 113785 [7] M oller P, Nix J R, Myers W D and Swiatecki W J 1995 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 59185 [8] Pearson J M, Nayak R C and Goriely S 1996 Phys. Lett. B 387455 [9] Goriely S, Samyn M and Pearson J M 2006 Nucl. Phys. A 773279 [10] Meng J, Toki H, Zhou S G, Zhang S Q, Long W H and Geng L S 2006 Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 57470 [11] Audi G, Wapstra A H and Thibault C 2003 Nucl. Phys. A 729337 [12] K appeler F, Berr H and Wisshak K 1989 Rep. Prog. Phys. 52945 [13] M oller P, Nix J R and Kratz K L 1997 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 66131; M oller P, Pfeiffer B and Kratz K L 2003 Phys. Rev. C 67055802 [14] National Nuclear Data Center, Pfeiffer B, Kratz K L and Thielemann F K 1997 Z. Phys. A 357235 [16] Dillmann I et al 2003 Phys. Rev. Lett. 91162503 [17] Jungclaus A et al 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 99132501 5FIG. 1: Features of the r-process calculated using the new RMF mass table. Black squa res denote b-stable nuclei, and magic proton and neutron numbers are ind icated by pairs of parallel lines. The region in the main graph shows the calculated average one neutron separation energy ( S2n/2). The solid line denotes the border of nuclides with known mass es in the neutron-rich side. The dark grey squares show the r-process path when using the RMF mass predictions and the FRD M half-lives. The observed and calculated solar r-process abundance curves are plotted versus the mass number A in the inset, whose x-axis is curved slightly to follow the r-process path. 6160 170 180 190 200 210 220 Mass Number A10-3Log10N.HFB 13-ETFSI 2: Comparison of observed solar r-process abundances (filled circles) with theoretical abun - dance after b-decays calculated using RMF, FRDM, ETFSI-Q and HFB-13 mass models. The calculated abundances have been scaled to the solar r-process abundance at A= 130. 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 Neutron Number 3: The corresponding r-process pathes of Fig. 2 for the RMF and HFB-13 mass models. Shown are those isotopes with more than 10% population of eac h isotopic chain. For comparison the stable nuclei are labeled by black squares. 7
|
0807.2509
|
Baohua Sun
|
Sun Baohua and Meng Jie
|
Challenge on the Astrophysical R-process Calculation with Nuclear Mass
Models
|
3 pages, 3 figures
|
Chin. Phys. Lett. 25 (2008) 2429
|
10.1088/0256-307X/25/7/027
| null |
nucl-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Our understanding of the rapid neutron capture nucleosynthesis process in
universe depends on the reliability of nuclear mass predictions. Initiated by
the newly developed mass table in the relativistic mean field theory (RMF), in
this paper the influence of mass models on the $r$-process calculations is
investigated assuming the same astrophysical conditions. The different model
predictions on the so far unreachable nuclei lead to significant deviations in
the calculated r-process abundances.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 16 Jul 2008 07:42:07 GMT"
}
] | 2017-05-12T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Baohua",
"Sun",
""
],
[
"Jie",
"Meng",
""
]
] |
1 Introduction A number of theoretical models have been proposed in the recent t imes to study the nonlinear dynamics of Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) molecule to understand the conservation and transformation of genetic info rmation (see for e.g [1,2]). These models are based on longitudinal, transverse, ro tational and stretching motions of bases. Among these different possible mo tions, rota- tional motion of bases is found to contribute more towards the ope ning of base pairs and to the nonlinear dynamics of DNA. The first contribution to wards nonlinear dynamics of DNA was made by Englander and his co-workers [3] and they studied the base pair opening in DNA by taking into account t he ro- tational motion. Yomosa [4,5] proposed a plane base rotator model by taking into account the rotational motion of bases in a plane normal to the helical axis, and Takeno and Homma generalized the same [6,7,8]. Later using t his model, several authors found solitons to govern the fluctuation o f DNA dou- ble helix between an open state and its equilibrium states [9,10,11,12,13,1 4]. Peyrard and Bishop [15,16] and Christiansen and his collegues [17] stu died the process of base pair opening by taking into account the transv erse and longitudinal motions of bases in DNA. Very recently, there have bee n exten- sions of the radial model of Bishop and Peyrard [18,19], composite mo dels for DNA torsion dynamics [20] and models interplaying between radial and tor- sional dynamics [21,22,23,24]. In all the above studies, homogeneous strands and hydrogen bonds have been considered for the ofdifferent sites alongthestran coding, terminator, etc., each of which has a specific seque nce of bases is related to a particular function and thus making the strands site- dependent or inhomogeneous [25,26]. Also, the presence of abasic sites leads to inhomo- geneity in stacking [27]. In this context, in a recent paper the prese nt authors [28] studied the nonlinear molecular excitations in DNA with site-depen dent stacking energy along the strands based on the plane base rotato r model. The nonlinear dynamics of DNA in this case was found to be governed b y a perturbed sine-Gordon (s-G) equation. The perturbed kink and antikink soliton solutions of the perturbed s-G equation represented an op en state con- figuration of base pairs with small fluctuation. The perturbation in t his case introduces small fluctuations in the localized region of the soliton ret aining the overall shape of the soliton. However, the width of the soliton r emains constant and the velocity changes for different inhomogeneities. T he results indicate that the presence of inhomogeneity in stacking changes th e number of base pairs that participate in the open state configuration and m odifies the speed with which the open state configuration travels along the dou ble heli- cal chain. In reality, the presence of site-dependent strands in D NA changes the nature of hydrogen bonds between adjacent base pairs and t he presence of abasic sites leads to absence of hydrogen bonds. Thus, when th e strands are site-dependent in stacking, naturally the hydrogen bonds tha t connect the bases between the strands are also site-dependent. Hence, it has to consider inhomogeneity in hydrogen bonds also in the s tudy of nonlinear dynamics of DNA. In the present paper, we study the dyn amics of DNA with inhomogeneity both in stacking and in hydrogen bonds using t he plane base rotator model. The paper is organized as follows. In sect ion 2, we present the Hamiltonian of our model and derive the associated dyn amical equation for the inhomogeneous DNA. The effect of stacking and hy drogen bond inhomogeneity on base-pair opening is studied by solving the dyn amical equations using a multiple scale soliton perturbation theory in section 3. The results are concluded in section 4. 2 Hamiltonian and the dynamical equation We consider the B-form of a DNA double helix with site-dependent str ands as well as base-pair sequence and study the nonlinear molecular excita tions by considering nted asketch of the DNA double helix. Here, SandS'represent the two in the DNA double helix and each arrow represents the direc tion of the base attached to the strand and the dots between arrows re present the net hydrogen bonding effect between the complementary bases. T he z-axis is chosen along the helical axis of the DNA. Fig. (1b) represents a ho of the nthbase pair in the xy-plane. In this figure points where the bases in the nthbase pair are attached to the strands we are looking for opening of base pairs in DNA which is related to im- portant DNA functions such as replication and transcription, we co nsider the rotational motion of bases (due to its importance among other mot ions) in a plane normal to the helical axis (z-direction) represented by the thenthsite of the base pair. The stacking and hydrogen bonding energies arethe major components ofthe energy ina DNAdouble he lix. Inthe case of a homogeneous DNA system, Yomosa [4,5] expressed the Ha these energies in terms of the rotational angles phnandph' nunder the plane base rotator model which was later modified by the present au thors [28] in the case of site-dependent stacking. When both the stacking an d hydrogen bonds are site-dependent, the Hamiltonian for our plane base rota tor model of DNA double helix is written in terms of the rotational angles (1) The first two terms in the Hamiltonian (1) represent the kinetic ener gies of the rotational motion of the nthnucleotide bases with Itheir moments of inertia and the remaining terms represent the potential energy due to stacking and hydrogen bonds. While Janderepresent a measure of stack- 5ing and hydrogen bonding energies respectively, fnandgnindicate the character of stacking and hydroge n bonds Hamilton's equations of motion corresponding to Hamiltonian (1) is writ- ten (2b) It is expected that the difference in the angular rotation of neighbo uring bases along the two strands in the case of B-form of DNA double helix is small [6,7]. Therefore under small angle approximation, in the continuum limit Eqs . (2a) and (2b) are written (3b) While writing Eqs. (3a) and (3b) we have chosen e=-Ja2 2and rescaled the time variable as Now, adding and subtracting Eqs.(3a) and (3b) and by choosing ph=-ph', we = o[A(s(z)Psz)z-B h(z)sinPs], (4) 6where Ps = 2 ph. Further, as the contribution due to inhomogeneity is small compared tohomogeneous stacking andhydrogen bonding energie s while writ- ing Eq.(4), the inhomogeneity in stacking and hydrogen bonding ener gies are expressed in terms of a small parameter oasf(z) = 1 + o As(z) and g(z) = 1+o Bh(z), where AandBare arbitrary constants. When o= 0,Eq. (4) reduces to the completely integrable sine-Gordon(s-G) equat ion which ad- mits N-soliton solutions in the form of kink and antikink [29]. Hence, we c all Eq. (4) as a perturbed sine-Gordon equation. For instance, the o ne soliton solution of the integrable s-G equation obtained through Inverse S (IST) method is written as, Ps(z,^t) = 4arctanexp [+-m0(z-v0^t)], real parameters that represent the velocity and width of the soliton respectively. In Eq.(5) while the upper sign correspon ds to the kink soliton, the lower sign represents the antikink soliton. In Figs. ( 2a) and (2b) the one soliton kink-antikink solutions (Eq.(5)) are plotted by c hoosing v0= 0.4. The kink-antikink soliton solution of the integrable describes an open state configuration in the DNA double he lix. In Figure (2c), we present a sketch of how the base pairs open locally in the form of kink-antikink structure in each strand and propagate along the direction of the helical axis. 7The base pair opening will help in the process of replication that duplica messenger RNA.H 0, the inhomogeneity in stacking and hydrogen bonds may affect the base-pair opening through a perturbation on the kink-antikink solitons of the s-G equation. Therefore in the next section, we solve the pert urbed s-G equation (4) using a multiple-scale soliton perturbation theory [30,31 ,32] (as has been carried out in the case corresponding to B= 0 [28]) to understand the effect of stacking and hydrogen bond inhomogeneities on the ba se pair opening. 3 Effect of stacking and hydrogen bonding inhomogeneities on the open state Multiple-scale soliton perturbation theory In order to study the effect of inhomogeneity in stacking and hydro gen bonds on the base pair opening in the form of kink-antikink soliton by treatin g them as a perturbation, the time variable ^tis transformed into several variables small parameter [30,31,32]. Inview of this, the time derivative and Ps in Eq. (4) are replaced by the expan Ps = then equate the coefficients of different powers of oand obtain the following equations. At O(o(0)) we obtain the integrable sine-Gordon 0, (6) for which the one soliton solution takes the form as given in Eq.(5) with ^t replaced by t0. Due to perturbation, the soliton parameters namely mand x(x=v^t) are now treated as functions of the slow time variables mis treated as independent of t0. The equation at O(o(1)) takes = writing the above equation we have used the transformation ^z=m(z- vt0) and^t0=t0to represent everything in a co-ordinate frame moving with the soliton. Then, we have used another set of transformations g iven our later convenience. We have also replaced sinPs(0) by 2atanhz sechz, wherea=+-1. The solution of Eq. (7) is searched by assuming Ps(1)(z,t) =X(z)T(t) andF(1)(z,t) above in Eq. (7) and simplifying we (9) Tt-l0T=H(t), oliton at this moment turns out to be solving Eqs. (9) and (10) by constru cting and finding the eigen values [28,32]. It may be noted that Eq.(9) differs from the normal eigen value prob lem, with Xzin the right hand side instead of X. Hence, before actually solving the eigen value equation (9), we first consider it in a more general form g iven by L1X=l~X, L 1=zz+2sech2z-1, (11) wherelis the eigen value. To find the adjoint eigen function to X, we consider another eigen value problem L2~X=lX, (12) whereL2is to be determined. Combining the two eigen value problems we get L2L1X=l2X, L 1L2~X=l2~X. (13) From the above equations we conclude that the operator L1L2is the also Xand~Xare expected to be adjoint eigen functions. Hence, we can find the eigenfunction by solving Eqs.(11) and (12). However , even- thoughL1is known as given in Eq.(11), the operator L2is still unknown. So, by experience we choose L2=zz+ 6sech2z-1, and solve the eigen value equations by choosing the eigen functions as 10X(z,k) =q(z,k)eikz, (14) wherekis the propagation constant. Further, as the operator L2L1is self- adjoint, non-negative and satisfying a regular eigenvalue problem, the sine- Gordon soliton is expected to be stable. On substituting Eqs. (14) in Eqs.(11) and (12) in the asymptotic limit, we obtain the eigen value as l=-(1+k2). Now, in order to find the eigen functions we expand p(z,k) andq(z,k) ktobedetermined. (14), (15a) and (15b) in Eqs. (11) and (12) and collecting the coefficients of we get a set of simultaneous equations. On solving those equations we obtain the following eigen functions (17) The higher order coefficients may be noted that Eq.(10) is a linear inhomogeneous differential eq uation and can be solved using known procedures. The solution reads 11T(t,k) The first order correction to the soliton can be computed using the following (19) Here the continuous eigenfunctions X(z,k) andT(t,k) are already known as given in Eqs. (16) and (18). However, the discrete eigen states unknown. The two discrete eigenstates to the discrete eigen value l= 0 can be found using the completeness of the continuous eigenfunctions as X0(z)=sechz, X 1(z) =zsechz. (20) In order to find T0andT1, we substitute Eq.(19) in Eq.(7) and multiply by X0(z) andX1(z) separately and use the orthonormal relations to given in Eq.(8) does not contain the time variable texplicitly, the right hand side of Eqs. (21a) and (21b) also should be independe nt of 12time, and hence we write the nonsecularity conditions 0, 0. hestability of soliton [33] under perturbation through an understanding of th e evolution of soliton parameters such as width and velocity. Substituting the a bove equa- tions in Eqs. (21a) and (21b), we choose T1(t) = 0 and find T0(t) =Cwhich has to be determined. For this, we substitute T1(t) = 0 in Eq. (21b) and integrate to zF(1)(z,t)X1(z). (23) Inorder states T(t,k) andT0(t) explicitly for which we have to find the explicit form ofF(1)(z,t) which contains unknown quantities like mt1, xt1, s(z) y conditions given in Eqs. (22a) and (22b) and evaluate the integrals to the time variation of the inverse of the width and velocity of the soliton Variation of soliton parameters In order to find the variation of the width and velocity of the soliton w hile propagating along the inhomogeneous DNA chain, we assume that th e soliton with a width of m-1 0is travelling with a speed of v0(xt0) when the perturbation is switched on. In other words, the problem now boils down to unders tand the propagation of the kink-antikink soliton in an inhomogeneous DNA chain and to measure the change of the soliton parameters due to inhomo geneity. To find the variation of the soliton parameters explicitly and to const ruct the perturbed soliton solution we have to evaluate the integrals fou nd in the right hand sides of Eqs. (24a) and (24b) which can be carried out on ly on supplying specific formsof we consider inhomogeneity assumethat the inhomogeneity in the stacking and in the hydrogen bonds are equ al. The localized inhomogeneity represents the intercalation of a compound base pairs or the presence of defect or the presenc e of abasic site in the DNA double helical chain. The periodic nature of inhomogeneity m ay represent a periodic repetition of similar base pairs along the helical c hain. 143.2.1 Localized inhomogeneity To understand the effect of localized inhomogeneity in stacking and h ydrogen bonds on the width and velocity of the soliton during propagation, we substi- tutes(z) =h(z) =sechzin Eqs.(24a) and (24b). On evaluating the integrals, we obtain mt1= 0, which can be written in terms of the original time variable ^tby using the expansions (25) where 1/m0is the width and v0is the velocity of the soliton in the absence of inhomogeneity. The first of Eq.(25) says that when the inhomoge neities in stacking and in hydrogen bonds are in the form s(z) =h(z) =sechz, the width of the soliton remains constant, thereby showing that the nu mber of base pairs participating in the opening process remain constant dur ing prop- agation. However, from the second of Eq.(25), we find that the ve locity of the soliton gets a correction. The nature of correction in the velocity d epends on the value of ' a' which takes +1 or -1 and also on the nature of AandBwhich can be either positive or negative. When AandBare greater than zero, will correspond to an energetic barrier and on the ot her less than zero, the inhomogeneity will correspond to apo- tential well. First, we consider the case corresponding to a= +1. In this case 15when (2A+B)>0, the velocity of the soliton gets a positive correction and it may propagate along the chain without formation of a bound state . On the other hand, when (2 A+B)<0, the inhomogeneities slow down the when (2 A+B) = 0, that iswhen the inhomogeneities in the hydrogen bonding suitably balance each other, the velocit y of the soliton remains unaltered. Finally, the soliton stops when the original the condition In all the above cases, the stability of the soliton is guaranteed. A similar argument can be made in the case w hen a=-1 with (2 A+B) replaced by (2 A-B). It may also be noted that similar results have been obtained in the case of resonant kink-impurity int eraction and kink scattering in a perturbed sine-Gordon model by Zhang Fei et al [34], say that the kink will pass the impurity and escape to the positive infin ity when the initial velocity of kink soliton is larger than the critical value. In a similar context Yakushevich et al [35] while studying the interaction b etween soliton and the point defect in DNA chain showed numerically, that the soli- tons are stable. At this point it is also worth mentioning that Dandoloff and Saxena [36] realized that in the case of an XY-coupled spin chain mode l which is identifiable with our plane-base rotator model of DNA, the ansatz favours the deformation of spin chain. 163.2.2 Periodic inhomogeneity We then choose the periodic inhomogeneity in the form s(z) =h(z) = cosz and substitute the same in Eqs. (24a) and (24b). On evaluating the integrals, we getmt1= 0, can be written in terms of the original time variable ^tas m=m0, (26) From Eq.(26), we observe that the width of the soliton remains cons tant case of localized inhomogeneity. The only difference between the two cases is the quantum of correction added to soliton velocity. Normally in DNA s, inhomogeneity in hydrogen bonds is expected to be dominant and the refore one would expect that B > A. One can verify that it is possible to obtain the above condition from the velocity corrections in Eqs. (25) and ( 26) +1. The above condition indicates that the correction in velocity in the case of periodic inhomogeneity is larger than that in the case of localized inhomogeneity. This is because in this case, the inhomogeneity occurs periodically in the entire length of the DNA c hain. In a recent paper, Yakushevich et al [35] studied numerically the dy namics of topological solitons describing open states in an inhomogeneous D NA close analogy with the results of our perturbation analysis. It was shown that the soliton can easily propagate along the DNA chain without for ming a bound state thus showing that soliton moving with sufficiently large ve locity along the DNA chain is stable with respect to defect or inhomogeneity . 3.3 First order perturbed soliton Having understood the variation of the width and velocity of the solit on in a slow time scale due to perturbation, we now construct the first o rder perturbed soliton by substituting the values of the basis functions {X} in Eqs. (16), (20), (18), (23) with T1(t) = 0 in Eq.(19), we (27) While writing the above, we have also used It may be noted that majority of the poles that lie within the contour in Eq. (27 ), are purely imaginary giving rise to exponentially localized residues and henc e do not give rise to any radiation thus will lead to stable form of soliton [37]. 183.3.1 Localized we explicitly construct the first order perturbation correct ion to the one soliton in the case of the localized inhomogeneity (i.e) when s(z) =h(z) thecorresponding valuesof (27). The resultant integrals are then evaluated using standard residue theorem [38] which involves very lengthy algebra and at the end we (28) Finally, the perturbed one soliton solution, that is Ps( z,t0) = Ps(0)(z,t0) +
Ps(1)(z,t0) (choosing o= 1) is written in terms of the original variables (29) Knowing Ps, the angle of rotation of bases ph(z,t0) can be immediately written down by using the relation ph=Ps 2. In Figs. 3(a,b) we have plotted ph(z,t0), the rotation of bases under the perturbation g(z) =h(z) =sechzby choosing a=A=B= 1 and v0= 0.4. From the figures we observe that there in the form of a train of pulses closely resembling the shap e of the inhomogeneity profile in the width of the soliton as time progresse s. But, there is no change in the topological character and no fluctuations appear in the asymptotic region of the soliton. In Figs. (4a) and (4b), we hav e plotted the perturbed kink and antikink solitons respectively correspondin g to the case when the hydrogen bond inhomogeneity is absent (B=0) for co mparison. From Figs. (3) and (4), we observe that the fluctuation in the form of a train of pulses appear in both the cases. Eventhough the perturbed so litons in both the cases appear qualitatively the same, the inhomogeneity in hydro gen bonds adds more fluctuation in the width of the soliton. 3.3.2 Periodic inhomogeneity We then repeat the procedure for constructing the perturbed o ne soliton solu- tion Ps(z,t0) in the case of periodic inhomogeneity by choosing s(z) =h(z) =
cosz, and obtain the perturbed soliton solution andd=p2 8m0v. In Figs. 5(a,b), we plot the angle of rotation of bases ph(=Ps 2), using the perturbed soliton given in Eq.(30) for the same parametric choices as in the case of localized inhomogen eity. We observe from the figures that, the fluctuation appears in the w idth of 20the soliton without any change in its topological character asympto tically. In order to compare the results with that of the case when the hydro gen is absent as also found in [28](see Figs. (6a,b)), we plot the perturbed soliton found in (30) when B= 0. As in the previous case, here also we observe that fluctuation appears in the width of the soliton in boththe cases and the inhomogeneity in hydrogen bonds introduces more flu ctuation. 4 Conclusions In this paper, we studied the nonlinear dynamics of a completely inhom oge- neous (inhomogeneity in both stacking and hydrogen bonding) DNA d ouble helix by considering the dynamical plane-base rotator model. The dy namics of this model in the continuum limit gives rise to a perturbed sine-Gordon equa- tion, which was derived from the Hamiltonian consisting of site-depen dent stacking and hydrogen bonding energies. In the unperturbed limit, the dy- namics is governed by the kink-antikink soliton of the integrable sine- Gordon equation which represents the opening of base pairs in a homogeneo us DNA. In order to understand the effect of inhomogeneity in stacking and hydrogen bonds on the base pair opening, we carried out a perturbation analy sis soliton perturbation theory. The perturbation not o nly modi- fies the shape of the soliton but also introduces change in the velocit y of the soliton. From the results, we observe that when the inhomogeneity is in a lo- 21calized or periodic form, the width of the soliton remains constant. H owever, the velocity of the soliton increases, decreases or remains uniform and even the soliton stops, depending on the values of inhomogeneity repres ented by A andB. The soliton in all the cases are found to be stable. From the results of the perturbed soliton we observe that the inhomogeneity in stac king and hydrogen bonds in both the cases (localized and periodic forms) intr in the form of pulses in the width of the soliton. However, there is no change in the topological character of the soliton in the asympt otic stacking and hydrogen bonds) are present, wh ereas it is less in the case of homogeneous hydrogen bonds and site-dependent st acking. Hence, we conclude that, the addition of inhomogeneity in hydrogen bonds d oes not introduce big changes in the soliton parameters and shape except a correction in the velocity of the soliton and fluctuation. The above dynamical be haviour may act as energetic activators of the RNA-polymerase transpor t process dur- ing transcription in DNA. In the case of short DNA chains the discret eness effect assumes importance and hence we will analyse the discrete dy (2) and the results will be published elsewhere. 225 work of M. D forms part of a major DST project. V. V thanks SB I for financial L. V. Yakushevich, Physica D 79 (1994) 77. [2] L. V. Yakushevich, Nonlinear Physics of DNA ( Wiley-VCH, Berlin, 2004). [3] S. W. Englander, N. R. Kallenbanch, A. J. Heeger, J. A. Kru mhansl and S. Litwin, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A 77 (1980) 7222. [4] S. Yomosa, Phys. Rev. A 27 (1983) 2120. [5] S. Yomosa, Phys. Rev. A 30 (1984) 474. [6] S. Takeno and S. Homma, Prog. Theor. Phys. 70 (1983) 308. [7] S. Takeno and S. Homma, Prog. Theor. Phys. 72 (1984) 679. [8] S. Takeno, Phys. Letts. A 339 (2005) 352. [9] P. Jensen, M. V. Jaric and K. H. Bannenmann, Phys. Letts. A 95 (1983) 204. [10] A. Khan, D. Bhaumik and B. Dutta-Roy, Bull. Math. Biol. 4 7 (1985) 783. [11] V. K. Fedyanin and V. Lisy, Studia Biophys. 116 (1986) 65 . [12] R. V. Polozov and L. V. Yakushevich, J. Theor. Biol. 130 ( 1988) 423. 23[13] J. A. Gonzalez and M. M. Landrove, Phys. Letts. A 292 (200 2) 256. [14] L. V. Yakushevich, Nanobiology 1 (1992) 343 . [15] M. Peyrard and A. R. Bishop, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 (1989) 27 55. [16] G. Kalosakas, K. Q. Rasmussen and A. R. Bishop, Syntheti c Metals, 141 (2004) 93. [17] P. L. Christiansen, P. C. Lomdahl and V. Muto, Nonlinear ity 4 (1991) 477. [18] T. Dauxios , Phys. Lett. A, 159 (1991) 390. [19] C. B. Tabi, A. Mohamdou and T. C. Kofane, Phys. Scr. 77 (20 08) 045002. [20] M. Cadoni and R. De Leo, Phys . Rev. E, 021919 (2007). [21] M. Barbi, S. Cocco and M. Peyrard, Phys. Letts. A, 253 (19 99) 358. [22] M. Barbi, S. Cocco , M. Peyrard and N. Phys. Rev. E, 68 (2003) 061909. [23] S. Cocco and R. Manasson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83 (1999) 5178 . [24] A. Campa, Phys. Rev. E , 63 (2001) 021901. [25] J. Ladik and J. Cizek, Int. J. Quantum Chem. 26 (1984) 955 . [26] E. Cubero, E. C. Sherer, F. J. Luque, M. Orozco and C. A. La ughton, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121 (1999) 8653 . [27] M. Hisakado and M. Wadati, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 64 (1995) 10 98. [28] M. Daniel and V. Vasumathi, Physica D 231 (2007) 10. 24[29] M. J. Ablowitz, D. J. Kaup, A. C. Newell, and H. Segur, Stu d. Appl. Math. 53 (1974) 249. [30] J. Yan and Y. Tang, Phys. Rev. E 54 (1996) 6816. [31] Y. Tang and W. Wang, Phys. Rev. E 62 (2000) 8842. [32] J. Yan, Y. Tang, G. Zhou and Z. Chen, Phys. Rev. E 58 (1998) 1064. [33] Y. Matsuno, J. Math. Phys. 41 (2000) 7061. [34] F. Zhang, Y. S. Kivshar and L. Vazquez, Phys. Rev. A 45 (19 92) 6019. [35] L. V. Yakushevich, A. V. Savin and L. I. Manevitch, Phys. Rev. E 66 R. Dandoloff and A. Saxena, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 9 (1 997) L667. [37] A. Sanchez, A. R. Bishop and F. Dominguez-Adame, Phys. R ev. E 49 E. Kreyszig, Advanced Engineering Mathematics (John- Wiley, New (a) A schematic structure of the B-form DNA double helix. (b) A hor- izontal projection of the nthbase pair in the xy-plane. Fig.2. (a) Kink and (b) antikink soliton solutions of the sine-Gordon eq uation (Eq.(4) when o= 0 ) with v0= 0.4. (c) A sketch of the formation of open state configuration in terms of kink-antikink soliton in DNA double helix . Fig.3.(a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikink -soliton for the inhomogeneity g(z) =h(z) =sechzwithA=B= 1 and v0= 0.4. Fig.4. (a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikin k-soliton for the inhomogeneity s(z) =sechz,h(z) = 0 with A= 1 and v0= 0.4. Fig.5.(a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikink -soliton for the inhomogeneity g(z) =h(z) = coszwithA=B= 1 and v0= 0.4. Fig.6.(a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikink -soliton for the inhomogeneity g(z) = cosz,h(z) = 0 with A= 1 and v0= phn xy PnS S lz (a) (b) Fig. 1. (a) A schematic structure of the B-form DNA double hel ix. (b) A ho of the nthbase pair in the xy-plane. ^
t ps ps ^
t z Base pair Kink Antikink Kink Antikink-10 0 0 1012345 -10 0 0 1012345 (a) (b) (c) Fig. 2. (a) Kink and (b) antikink soliton solutions of the sin e-Gordon equation (Eq.(4) when o= 0 ) with v0= 0.4. (c) A sketch of the formation of open in terms of kink-antikink soliton in DNA doubl e helix. 27(b)z zt0t0 ph ph (a)-20 -10 0 10 -10 0 10 2012345 -10 0 10 0 10 2012345 Fig. 3. (a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikink-soliton for the inhomogeneity g(z) =h(z) =sechzwithA=B= 1 and v0= 0.4. (b)z zt0 t0 ph ph -10 0 10 0 10 2012345 -20 -10 0 10 -10 0 10 2012345 (a) Fig. 4. (a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikink-soliton for the inhomogeneity s(z) =sechz,h(z) = 0 with A= 1 and v0= -10 0 10 -10 0 10 2012345 -10 0 10 0 10 2012345 Fig. 5. (a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikink-soliton for the inhomogeneity g(z) =h(z) = coszwithA=B= 1 and v0= 0.4. 28(a) -10 0 10 20 -10 0 10 20 3012345 -20 -10 0 10 20 -10 0 10 20 3012345 t0 Fig. 6. (a) The perturbed kink-soliton and (b) the perturbed antikink-soliton for the inhomogeneity g(z) = cosz,h(z) = 0 with A= 1 and v0= 0.4. 29
|
0807.2506
|
Vasumathi Velachi
|
M. Daniel and V. Vasumathi
|
Nonlinear molecular excitations in a completely inhomogeneous DNA chain
| null |
Phys. Lett. A 372 (2008) 5144-5151
|
10.1016/j.physleta.2008.05.063
| null |
nlin.PS cond-mat.soft
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We study the nonlinear dynamics of a completely inhomogeneous DNA chain which
is governed by a perturbed sine-Gordon equation. A multiple scale perturbation
analysis provides perturbed kink-antikink solitons to represent open state
configuration with small fluctuation. The perturbation due to inhomogeneities
changes the velocity of the soliton. However, the width of the soliton remains
constant.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 16 Jul 2008 07:22:43 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-17T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Daniel",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Vasumathi",
"V.",
""
]
] |
isotopic mass fluctuations about the average These fluctuations perturb the translational in- variance of a crystal and lift, at least in part, k- The ofthis type is observed in the thermal conductivity which has a maximum at a temperature T M<<ThD(here Th Dis Debye temperature, T M= 80 K for diamond, T M=
20 K for silicon (see, also Figs. 64 - 66 in [3]). Reduc- tionofthe 99% of12C) by a factor of ten increases the thermal conductivity of diamond by about a factor of two, a fact that leads to amplifications in situations where a large amount of generated heat has to be driven away (e.g. as substrates for high power elec- tronic devices [5]). As is well-known this transition from boundary scattering to the phonon unklapp scattering regime and its value Kmis determined by the isotopic fluctuation param- eter g (mass (4) the larger g - the smaller K m[6]. It is known that materials having a are characterized by the triply statesin the G - point ofthe Brillouinzone ( k
=0). (RS) spectra, but not in the IR absorption ones (see, e.g. [7]). First - order Raman light - in diamond crystals includes one line with the maximum at oLTO(G) = 1332.5 cm-1. In Fig. 1a, the first-order scattering spectrum in diamond crystals with different isotope concentration is shown [8]. As was shown, the maximum and the width of the in of isotopes x (see also [7]). The maximum shift of this line is 52.3 cm-1, corresponding to the limiting values of x = 0 and x = 1. Fig. 1bdemonstrates the dependence of the shape and position of the first-order line of optical phonons in germanium crystal on the isotope composition at liquid nitrogen temperatures [9]. The coordinate of the center of the scattering line is proportional to the square root of the reduced mass of the unit cell, i.e. M-1/2. It is precisely this dependence that is expected in the harmonic approximation (detailssee [3]). An additional frequency shift of the line is observed for the natural and enriched and is equal, as shown in Refs. [7, 9] to 0.34+-0.04and 1.06 +-0.04cm-1, respectively(see also Fig. 7 in Chap. 4 of Ref. [10]). Detailed shape ofthe lines in RS performed by Spitzer et al. [11]. In their pa- per a quantitative agreement with the on diamond and germanium has been the half-widths of the scattering lines in first-order RS in diamond and germanium (see Fig. 1), it is easy to see that the observed line broadening due to isotopic disorder in diamond is much greater than that in germanium. The reason for this is that thek= 0 point is not the highest point in the di- amond dispersion curve (see Fig. 10bin Ref. [7]), whereas in the case of germanium it is the highest point [12]. This shift of the maximum from the G - point (k= 0) leads to a much larger density of states in the vicinity of oLTOin comparison with the nor- mal one calculated by the more details see Ref. [12]). The density of states in diamond is asymmetric with respect to oLTO, shapeofthe scatter- ing line [7]. This asymmetry also leads to the asym- metric concentration dependence of the half-width of the scattering line. As was shown early (see, e.g. [3] and references therein), in the case of a weak does not depend on q(- phonon is precisely the situation observed for C and Ge. Indeed, if we express the mass fluctuation M/ M (M is the mean mass of all isotopes) in the form of the variation of the phonon band width o0= 12 cm-1 atq= 0 and compare it with the width of the band of optical phonons in Ge equals to 100 cm-1, we will see that the variations very small. Under this conditions the localization of optical phonons in Ge is naturally, absent, and as observed in experiment, they stay delocalized (see below, however opposite case in LiH xD1-xcrystals). Moreover, direct mea- surements of the phonon lifetime in Ge show that, in the case of anharmonic decay, it is two orders of mag- nitude shorter than the lifetime that is due to the Therefore, the contribution of anharmonic- ity to the half-width of the first-order light scattering line in Ge is two orders of magnitude greater than that caused by the isotopic disorder in crystal lattice. In conclusion of this part of our report we should mention that analogous structure of first-order RS and their dependence on isotope composition has by now been observed many times, not only in elemen- tary Si and a-Sn, but also in compound CuCl, CuBr, ZnSe, GaN semiconductors (details see Ref. [3]). In Fig. 2 (curve 1) the spectrum of Inspiteof the fact, according to the states [14], the crystal studied should be considered to be pure, its RS spectrum containsa around 1850cm-1. The observedpeak does not have an analogue in RS of pure LiH (Fig. 2, curve 4) and has already been observed earlier in the second- order RS and has been interpreted (see [7] and ref- erences therein) as a local vibration of the hydrogen in LiD crystals. Further we note that as the con- centration grows further (x >0.15) one observes in the spectra a decreasing intensity in the maximum of 2LO(G) phonons in LiD crystal with a simulta- neous growth in intensity of the highest frequency peak in mixed LiH xD1-xcrystals (Fig. 2, curve 3). The origin of the last one is in the LO(G) vibrations in mixed crystals [7]. Compar- ison of the structure of RS spectra (curves 1 and 2 in Fig. 2) allows us, therefore, to conclude that in the concentration range of 0.1 <x<0.45 the RS spectra simultaneously contain peaks of the LO(G) phonon of pure LiD and the LO(G) phonon of the mixed LiH xD1-xcrystal. Thus, the second-order RS spectra ofLiH and for LO(G) phonons, and also contain a con- tribution from the local excitation at small values of x. Moreover, we should add that an additional struc- ture in RS spectra on the short-side of the 2LO(G) peak (see Fig. 21 in Ref. [7]) was observed relatively ago in mixed LiH xD1-xcrystals and, very (details see [3, 11]). These effects caused by isotopic disorder in the crystal lattice of isotopi- cally mixed crystals [3]. The observation of two-mode behavior of the LO(G) phonons in RS spectra of LiH xD1-xcrystals contradicts the prediction ofthe CPA [15], according to which the width W of band should be smaller than the frequency shift () of transverse optical phonon. However, as was shown early (see, e.g. [7] and references therein) in LiH xD1-xmixed crystals, the reverse inequality is valid, i.e. W >||. According [16], this discrep- ancy between experimental results and theory based on CPA [15] is mainly explained by the strong po- tential of scattering of phonons, caused by a large change in the mass upon substitution of deuterium for hydrogen. Once more reason of the theory and results of the experiment may be connected with not taking into account in the- ory the change of the force-constant at the of the smaller in size D by H ion. We should stress once more that among the various pos- sible isotope substitution, by far the most important in vibrational spectroscopy is the substitution of hy- drogen by deuterium. As is well-known, in the limit of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation the force- constant calculated at the minimum of the total en- ergy depends upon the electronic structure and not upon the mass of the atoms. It is usually assumed that the theoretical values of the phonon frequen- cies depend upon the force-constants determined at the minimum of the adiabatic potential energy sur- face. This leads to a theoretical ratio o(H)/o(D )of the phonon frequencies that always exceed the ex- perimental data. Very often anharmonicity has been proposed to be responsible for lower value of this ra- tio. In isotope effect two different species of the same atom will have different vibrational frequencies only because of the difference in isotopic masses. The ra- tio p of the optical phonon frequencies for LiH and LiD crystals is given in harmonic approximation by: p =o(H) o(D (6) while the experimental value (which includes an- harmonic effects) is 1.396 /1.288 (see Table in Ref. [17]). In this Table there are the experimental and theoretical values of p according to formula (6), as well as the deviation d=PTheory - pexp ptheoryof these val- ues from theoretical ones. Using the least squares method it was found the empirical formula of ln( d%) 3~f(ln[E M]) which is depicted on Fig.3. As can be seen the indicated dependence has in the first ap- proximation a linear = -7.5 + 2ln(E M). (7) From the results of Fig. 3, it can be concluded that only hydrogen compounds (and its isotope ana- log - deuterium) need to take into account the force- constant changes in isotope effect. It is also seen that for semiconductor compounds (on Fig. 3 - points, which is below of Ox line) the isotope effect has only the changes of the isotope mass (details see [3, 7]). The dependence ofthe band (via mechanism of electron-phonon in- teraction) has already been observed for insulators (Fig. 4) and lowest (indirect - direct) gap of dif- ferent semiconductors ([3] and references therein). It has been shown to result primarily from the ef- fect of the average isotopic mass on the electron- phonon interaction, with a smaller contribution from the change in lattice constant. It was the first pa- per [19] where the exciton binding energy E Bwas found to depend on the isotopic composition. It was shown further that this change in E Bwas LO phonons) (see, also [3]). At present time such depen- dence of E B~f(x) (x- isotope concentration) was found for different bound excitons in - 21]. The simplest approximation, in which of identical atoms having the average isotopic mass is referred to as virtual crystal [15]. Going beyond the VCA, in crystals one would also expect local fluctua- tions in the band-gap energy from statistical fluctu- ations in local isotopic composition within some ef- fective volume, such as that of an exciton (see, e.g. Fig. 2 of Ref. [18]). Using the least-squares method it was found the empirical dependence of is presented on Fig. 5. As can be seen the mentioned dependence has a parabolic 6.105(lnE g)2- 7.870(lnE g) + 0.565. (8) From this figure it can be concluded also that the small variation of the nuclear mass the small changes in E galso. When the nu-clear mass increases it causes the large changes in Eg(C, LiH, CsH, etc.) (details, see [18, 3]). Detail analyze the process of self-diffusion in iso- tope pure materials and was done in [5]. Interest in diffusion in solids is as old as metal- lurgy or ceramics, but the scientific study of the phe- nomenon may probably be dated some ago. As is well-known, the measured diffu- sion coefficients depends on the chemistry and struc- ture of the sample on which it is measured. In cited paper [5] it was shown to use the stable isotopes for the study of diffusion process in different semicon- ducting structures (bulk, etc.). Chapter 6 indicated book [5] describes the new reactor technology - neutron transmutative doping (NTD). Capture of thermal neutrons by isotope nu- clei in a very number of possibilities for doping of solids. The importance of NTD technology for studies of the semiconductor doping as well as metal-insulator transitions and neutral im- purity scattering process is underlined. The low- temperature mobility of free carriers in semiconduc- tors is mainly determined by ionized- and scattering. The ionized-impurity has been extensively studied (see e.g. [5] and references therein), and various aspects of this process are now quite well understood. Scattering by neutral impurities is much less than by ionized cen- ters, i.e., low compensation and at very low most of the free carriers are frozen on the im- purity sites. The availability of highly enriched iso- topes of Ge which can be purified to residual provided the first opportu- nity to measure neutral impurity scattering over a wide temperature range. In paper [22] three Ge iso- topes transmute into shallow acceptors (Ga), shallow donors (As) and double donors (Se) (see also above): 70 32Ge + +ne, 74 32Ge + 82.2min)-75 32As +b-
+ -ne, 76 32Ge + 11.3h)-b-+ 38.8h)-77 32Se +b-+ -ne. (9) The isotopes72Ge and73Ge are transmuted into 4the stable73Ge and74Ge respectively. Controlling the ratio of70Ge and74Ge in bulk Ge crystals al- lows fine tuning of the majority-as well as the minor- ity carrier concentration. Currently, this is the best method to vary the free-carrier concentration inde- pendently from compensation ratio. As opposed to other doping methods, NTD yields a very homoge- neous, perfectly random distribution of the dopants down to the atomic levels [5]. Thus isotopically con- trolled crystalsoffer a unique possibility to study sys- tematically the scattering mechanism of the charge carriers in semiconductors. Extensive Hall-effect and to 4.2K yielded very accurate free-carrier con- centrations and mobilities as a function of tempera- ture and doping level were done in paper [5]. Itoh et al. [22] have performed measurements on four different p-type and 6). Fig. strength of the scattering from the ionized and the neutral impurities. There is only a dominates. This rangeextends to higher temperatures as the free-carrier concentra- tion is increased. The calculated transition temper- atures above which the ionized impurities are the main scattering centres compare very well with ex- perimental results of Itoh et al [22] (see also Fig. 6.31 in Ref. [5]). In order to demonstrate the importance of the homogeneous dopant distribution, Itoh et al. have performed the same study on samples cut from Ge : the method, where Ga impurities were introduced to Ge melt during the crystal growth. These authors observed deviations of the measured mobility inhomogeneous Ga impurity distributions in melt- doped Ge. Only the use ofNTD distributed dopants allows for an accurate test of the neutral models (de- tails, see [5]). Another application of isotope pure and possibility of using an isotopically mixed medium (e.g. LiH as an oscillator of coherent radiation in the ultraviolet spectral range.To achieve this, the use of indirect electron transi- tions involving, say, LO phonons was planned [23]. The detection of LO phonon replicas of free - in wide - gap insulators attracted [10; 23]). At the same time it is allowed one to pose a where no solid state sourcesfor coherent radiation exist yet. In the first place this related to the emitters The last one provides the high of the coherent emission per unit volume of this part we will discuss the investigation re- sults of the influence of the excitation light density on the resonant secondary emission spectra of the free - exciton in the wide - gap insulator LiH xD1-x (LiH1-xFx) crystals. The cubic LiH crystals are typ- ical wide - gap ionic insulator with E g= 4.992 eV [10] with relatively weak exciton - phonon interac- tion however: E B/-hoLO= 0.29 where E Band -hoLO are exciton binding energy and longitudinal optical phonon's energy , respectively. Besides it might be pointed out that the analogous relation for CdS, di- amond and NaI is 0.73; 0.45 and 12.7, respectively . In the insert of Fig. 7 depicts the luminescence of 1LO and 2LO phonon replicas in LiH crystals. An increase in the density of the exciting light causes a burst of the radiation energy in the long-wave wing of the emission of the 1LO and 2LO repetitions (see Fig. 7) at a rate is higher for the 1LO replica line [23]. A detailed dependence of the luminescence in- tensity and the shape of the 2LO phonon replica line are presented in Fig. 7. The further intensity at the beginning a certain narrowing can be observed, followed by widening of the line of 2LO phonon replica with a simultaneous in Ref. [5]). From this Fig. it can be seen that the coupling between longwavelength lumines- cence intensity and excitation light intensity is not only linear, but, in fact, of a threshold character as in case of other crystals . A proximity of the CdS (ZnO) out the interpretation of the density effects in LiH on the analogy with these semiconducting com- pounds. Coming from this in the paper [23] it was shown that for the observed experimental picture on LiH crystals to suppose the exciton-phonon mecha- nism of light generation [5] is enough the excitons density about 1015cm-3. This is reasonable value, if the high quality of the resonator mirrow - the crystal cleavage in situ and relatively large exciton radius (r = 40@A [10] )is taken into account. To this of the LO phonon energy (- hoLO= 140 meV ) . Owing to this the radiative transition is being real- ized in the spectral region with a small value of the absorption coefficient, and thus with a small losses in resonator (details see [5]). In conclusion of this section we should underlined that if the observable mode structure is really caused by the laser generation it may be smoothly tuned in the region of energies 4.5 +-5.1 eV owing to smooth transition of the line emission energy in LiDxF1-x) mixed crystals as well as in the range 5.35 - 5.10 eV crystals (see also our report we should be paid your at- tention to the reports of Professors Schoven, Weston, Wendt as well as Dr. Chai of our conference which are devoted in the first step of radioactive Captions. Fig. 1. a) First-orderRaman with different isotope compositions. The labels A,B, C, D, E and F correspond to x = 0.989; 0.90; 0.60; 0.50; 0.30 and 0.01 respectively. The b)First- order Raman scattering spectra in Ge with contents (after [13]). Fig. 2. Second-order Raman spectra of LiH xD1-x crystals at room temperature: (1); (2); (3) and (4) x
= 0; 0.42; 0.76 and 1, respectively (after [7]). Fig. 3. The dependence of ln( are experimental values and continuous line - calculation on the formula (7) (after [17]). Fig. 4. Mirror reflection spectra of crystals: LiH, curve 1; LiH xD1-x, curve 2 and LiD, curve 3 at 4.2K. Light source without crystals, curve 4 (after [18]). Fig. 5. The dependence of are experimental date and continuous line - calculation on the formula (8) (after [18]). Fig. 6. Temperature dependence ofthe of a) p - type and b) n - type NTD Ge crystals. c) Temperature dependence of relative contributions to the mobility. Note that the mobility is dominated by neutral impurity scattering below 20 K (70Ge:Ga
#2 crystal) (after [22]). Fig. 7. The dependence of the intensity in the maximum (1) and on the long-wavelength side (2) of 2LO replica emission line of LiH crystals on the exci- tation light intensity. In insert: luminescence spectra of free excitons in LiH crystals in the region of the emission lines of 1LO and 2LO phonon repetitions at 4.2 K for low (1) and high (2) density of excitations of 4.99 eV photons (after I.M. Lifshitz, Physics of Real Crystals and Disordered Systems , Selected Works (Eds. M.I. Kaganov, A.M. Kosevich, Science, Moscow, A.A. Maradudin, E.W. Montroll, G.H. Weiss and I.P. Ipatova, Theory of Lattice Dynamics in the Harmonic Approximation , Solid State Physics, Vol.3, (Eds. F. Seitz, D. Turnbull and H. Ehrenreich, Aca- demic, New York, 1971). 3. V.G. Plekhanov, Elementary Excitations in Isotope-Mixed Crystals, Physics Reports ,410[1-3] 1 (2005). 4. J.P. Franck, in: Physical Properties of High T (ed. D.M. Ginsberg, Vol. 4., Singapore, 1984) p. 189. 5. For a review, see, V.G. Plekhanov, Applications of the Isotopic Effect in Solids , Springer, Berlin- Hei- delberg, 2004. 6. See, for example, R. Berman, Thermal Con- duction of Solids (Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1976); T.M. Tritt, Thermal Conductivity (Springer, Berlin - Heidelberg, 2005). 7. V.G. Plekhanov, Isotopic Effects in Physics - Uspekhi (Moscow) 46 [7] 689 (2003). 68. H. Hanzawa, N. Umemura, Y. Nisida et al., Disorder Effects of Nitrogen Impurities, Irradiation - Induced Defects, and13C Isotope Composition on the Raman Spectrum in Synthetic IbDiamond, Phys. Rev.B54[6] 3793 (1996). 9.M. Cardona, Semiconductor Crystals with Tailor - Made Isotopic Compositions, in: in Solid State Physics (ed. R. Helbig, Vieweg, Braunschweig, Wiesbaden, Vol. 34, 1994) p. 35. 10. V.G. Plekhanov, Isotope Effects in Solid New York, 2001). 11. J. Spitzer, P. Etchegoin, M. Cardona et al., Isotopic - Disorder Induced Raman Scattering in Di- amond,Solid State Commun. 88[6] 509 (1993). 12. M. Cardona, Isotopic Effects in the Phonon and Electron Dispersion Relations of Crystals, Phys. Stat. Sol. (b)220[1] 5 (2000). 13. M. Cardona, P. Etchegoin, H.D. Fuchs et Vibronic Properties of Three-, Two- and One - Dimensional Solids, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 5[1] A61 (1993). 14. V.G. Plekhanov, Phonon renormalization of Interband Transition Energy in the Mixed Crystals, Solid State Commun. 76[1] 51 (1990). 15. R.J. Elliott, J.A. Krumhansl and P.L. Leath, The Theory and Properties of Randomly and Related Physical Systems, Rev. Mod. Phys.46[3] 465 (1974). 16. V.G. Plekhanov, Experimental Evidence of Strong Phonon Scattering in Isotope Disordered Sys- tems: The Case of LiH xD1-x,Phys. Rev. B51[14] 8874 (1995). 17. V.G. Plekhanov (unpublished results, 2004) 18. V.G. Plekhanov, N.V. Plekhanov, Isotope De- pendence of Band - Gap Energy, Phys. Lett. ,A313 [3] 231 (2003). 19. Pusto- varov, Excitons and Peculiarities of in LiH and LiD, Sov. Phys. Solid State 18[8] 1422 (1976). 20. M. ofthe of Boron in Diamond on Isotopic Mass, Solid State Commun. 121[1] 7 (2002).21. D. Karaiskaj, T.A. Meyer, M.L.W. Thewalt et al., Dependence of the Ionization Energy of Shallow Donors and Acceptors in Silicon on the Host Rev. B68[2] 121201 (2003). 22. H.D. Fuchs, K.M. Itoh and E.E. Haller, Iso- topically Controlled Germanium: A New Medium for the Study of Carrier Scattering by Neutral Mag. B70[2] 662 (1994); K.M. Itoh, E.E. Haller, V.I. Ozogin, Neutral - Impurity Scatter- ing in Isotopically Engineering Ge, Phys. Rev. B50 [23] 16995 (1994). 23. V.G. Plekhanov, Wide-Gap Insulators Exci- tonic Nonlinearity and Its Potential Applications in Solid State Lasers, in: Proc. Int. Conf. Advances Solid State Lasers , USA, SOQUE, 1990. Table. Values of the coefficients dE/dM (mev, cm-1) for the optical phonons and the experimental and theoretical values of p as well as deviation d% of these values from theoretical ones. Substances Frequencies p exp ptheory d% =ptheory- 1.288-1.346 2 = 1.414 4.8 - 8.9 SiH4/SiD4 1.399 2 = 1.414 1.5 12C/13C 1.041 0.001 70Ge/76Ge 1.042 0.096 28Si/30Si 1.035 1.029 1.052 0.30 Ga14N/Ga15N 1.035 1.022 0.59 7
|
0807.2521
|
Vladimir Plekhanov
|
V.G. Plekhanov
|
Fundamentals and applications of isotope effect in modern technology
|
7 pages, 7 figures
|
Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology Vol 43 No 4 (2006)
375-381
| null | null |
cond-mat.mtrl-sci cond-mat.dis-nn
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
In this short review I discuss the effect of isotopic mass and isotopic
disorder on the properties (vibrational, elastic, thermal and optical) of
different crystals.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 16 Jul 2008 09:15:25 GMT"
}
] | 2009-06-01T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Plekhanov",
"V. G.",
""
]
] |
2Thermotunnel refrigeration at room temperat ure is widely discussed in literature 1- 5. Analysis of such systems shows that they have advantages over traditional thermoelectric refrigerators. Efficiency could be as high as 20-30 %. Besides it cooling power of 100 W/cm2 could be achieved at room temperature1. Attempts of practical realization of such system underlined some problems 2, 5, 6. Major problem is short circuit between the electrodes. Thermotunnel refrigerator contains two conductive elec trodes separated by vacuum gap of width of ~10 nm. Driven by a pplied electric field, electrons tunnel from emitter to collector carrying heat energy. Mirr or forces and external electric field reduce the potential energy barrier. Tunne ling electrons are distributed in wide range of initial kinetic energies. For efficient cooling it is necessary that electr ons tunnel from high energy levels. We offer to coat collector with thin 3-5 nm layer of insulator. Insulator magnifies the electric field inside the vacuum gap. It changes the profile of the potential barrier so that high en ergy electrons tunnel troug h barrier of less height and less width. At the same time low energy electrons t unnel through barrier of more width. Potential of the electron be tween the conductive electrodes, with respect to image forces, has following form. V(x) = F1/q-V 1x th(d1-x)/d 1- th(x-d 1)[(F1-F2)/q+V 1+V 2(x-d 1)/d2]+ 0nn ii jPn,i,j ki {[th(x-d ] +
+ kth(d1-x)[(d 1-x+a)-1-2(d 1+a)-1+(x+d 2+a)-1]+ + k th(x-d 1)[2(d 2+a)-1-(x-d 1+a)-1-(2d-d 2-x+a)-1]/e} (1) 3Where x - is distance from the emitter, d 1 - is thickness of vacuum gap between emitter and insulator layer, d 2 - is thickness of the insulator layer, d=d 1+d2, q - is electron charge, F1 - work function of the emitter, F2 - work function of the collector, e - high frequency dielectric consta nt of the insulator, V 1= ed1V0/(d2+ed1) - potential drop inside the vacuum gap, V 2=d2V0/(d2+ed1) - potential drop inside the dielectric layer, V 0 - is external voltage applied to the electrodes, P n,i,j=(-1)(i-j) k=(1- e)/(1+e), a =(i-j)d 1+jd 2+(n-i)d, and th(x) - is step like function. Electron energy is given relative to Fermi energy of the emitter. Fig. 1 shows potential profiles for the cases d 2=0, d 2=30A and d 2=50A. Potential barrier height and width redu ce in the presence of insulator coating of the collector. Values of work functions and applied voltage are F1=F2=1eV, V 0=1V, e=10 for all three profiles. Integral tunneling current density contains electrons emitted from all energy levels up to potential barrier height - H J tun=
-qH N(E x)Dtun(Ex)d E x . (2) Where N(E x)= mk x/kBT)] is number of electrons emitted from unit area during unit time having kine tic energy in the range of [E x, Ekh+dEkh] and D tun(Ex) is the probability of tunneling of electron through potential barrier. Fig. 1 shows that near the border of insu lator and vacuum potential changes rapidly. Because of it, using the WKB method in th at range will reduce the accuracy of 4calculation. Actually there is si ngularity in the potential profile at the border of insulator and vacuum. It is due to zero width of su rface charge region. To avoid singularity we assume that mirror forces act only for distance that is more than some critical value. We choose critical value of 6 A, because in pr actice the surface of insu lator is not ideally plain but has roughness of the order of 5-10 A. Formally we divide the distance between the emitter and collector in three parts. Vac uum gap, potential well and insulator layer. Inside the vacuum gap and insulator layer potential changes slowly and we use WKB approximation for tunneling probability calcula tions. Inside the potential well region we use formulas 3: D2(Ex)=[1+H 02sin2( ) (2 0HEm x- L/h)/4E x(Ex-H0)]-1 H0< Ex<H (3.1) D2(Ex)=[1+H 02sh2( ) (2 0 xE Hm- L/h)/4E x(H0- Ex)]-1 E x <H 0 , (3.2) where H 0 is the depth of the well. In the near proximity of the potential well, we have very rapid change of potential due to imag e force singularity. It should be analyzed carefully because it corresponds to the infinite electric field, that is Physically impossible. We used following criteria to define the sh ape of the well. Surface roughness of the real insulator films is approximately 5 A. Therefor e, in reality, the border between two medias is defined within maximum 5 A accuracy. We chose value of 6 A for the well width because even number was convenient for in terval separation. Besides it, we made calculations using 4 A and 2 A wide wells and confirmed that results do not change considerably. 5 Inside the vacuum gap, in the region x= 0 / (d 1-4A), and inside the dielectric in the region (d 1 +2A) / d 2 we use formula h-2 1) )((2x xxEqxVm dx] , (4) for tunneling probability calculation 1. In Eq. (4), x 1 and x 2 are the solutions of equation V(x)q-E x=0, where V(x) is inserted from Eq. (1). Total tunneling probability will be the product of tunneling proba bilities for each of three regions: D tun(Ex)= D 1(Ex) D 2(Ex) D 3(Ex). Heat density carried by tunneling electrons will be Q tun =
-qH (KBT+ E x)N(E x)Dtun(Ex)dE x . (5) Here K BT is mean kinetic energy of electron is x direction. Electrons with energy E x>H create thermionic current J R which we calculate using Richardson Equation. Heat density tran sferred by thermionic flow is Q R=(Hq+2k BT)J R. Fig.2 shows cooling power Q tot=Q tun+Q R as function of electric field applied to the emitter. Thicknesses of insulator layers are: d 2=30A and d 2=50A. This curves are compared to the curve d 2=0. All curves are calculated for F1=F2=1 eV, V 0=1V, Te=300K. Fig. 2 shows that introducing of insu lator layer reduces the cooling power. Fig.3 shows dependence of useful cooli ng coefficient on applied field. Cooling coefficient was calculated as e=Q tot/ JtotV0. Here J tot=Jtun+JR is total current. Comparison 6of curves shows that introduc tion of insulator layer increase the cooling coefficient considerably. Cooling coefficient increase when thickness of the insulator layer increase. Besides it cooling coefficient becomes less fiel d dependent, in the case of presence of the insulator. Thermotunneling was realized using surface replication method, allowing preparation of conformal electrodes 7. Second electrode was gr own on the first electrode and was conformal to it. Electrodes were prepared on the base of Si substrate. Thin films of Ti and Ag and Cs were grown on Si. Elect rodes were separated using method or adhesion regulation between th e thin films. Distan ce between electrodes was regulated using piezoelectric cylinder. Tunneling area of 1/10 mm2 was obtained in our experiments. To get considerable cooling effect it is necessary to introduce Ag-O-Cs electrodes 8, having work function 0.8 /1.1 eV. Ag -O-Cs electrodes are very reactive and require high vacuum environment. Coating of the collector electrode by insulator layer will help to solve the problem of work function stability. Another possibility of reduction of the electrode work function is utilizing of the quantum inte rference effect in thin metal films 9, 10. It's main advantage is that it do not ne cessarily uses reactive materials like Cs. There always will be heat backflow from hot to cold electrode. Heat conductivity of vacuum is formally zero. Backflow through thermal radiation 1 is less than 0.1 W/cm2 at room temperature and is negligible. Backflow through housing depends on particular design and value as low as 0.1 W/cm2 for DT=30 K could be obtai ned in practice. To summarize, we introduce insulator la yer in the vacuum gap of thermotunnel refrigerator as coating of the collector. Insu lator modifies potential profile in such manner that tunneling probability is increased for high energy el ectrons. As result cooling 7coefficient increases ~by 20-30% and reaches the value of 40-50%. At the same time cooling power reduce, but not drama tically. Cooling power of 1-3 W/cm2, which is enough for most applications, is maintained fo r emitter electric fields of ~2 MV/cm with cooling coefficient of ~40 %. Both cooli ng power and cooling coefficient become less dependent on emitter electric field. In pract ice insulator layer will prevent electrodes from short circuit and damage. Fabrication of large area vacuum gap tunnel junction is quite problematic. Solving problem of short circuit makes possible new designs and will lead to increase of number of experiments in this direction. The work was financed and supported by Bo realis Technical Limited, assignee of corresponding patents (US 6,281,139; US 6,417,060; US 6,720,704; US 6,774,003; US 6,869,855; US 6,876,123; US 6,971,165). 8References 1 Y. Hishinuma, T. H. Geballe, B. Y. M oyzhes, and T. W. Kenny, Appl. Phys. Lett. 78, 2572 (2001). 2 Y. Hishinuma, T. H. Geballe, B. Y. Moyzhes, and T. W. Kenny, J. Appl. Phys. 94, 4690 (2003). 3 T. Zeng, Appl. Phys. Lett. 88, 153104 (2006). 4 Y. V. Vorobiev, J. Sol. Energy Eng. 128, 258 (2006). 5 Kucherov Yan R. and Hagelstein Peter L. US 6,946,596 Sept. 20 (2005) 6 A. Tavkhelidze, G. Skhiladze, A. Bibilashvi li, L. Tsakadze, L. Jangadze, Z. Taliashvili, I. Cox, and Z. Berishvili, Proc. XXI Inte rnational Conf. on Thermoelectric, August 26-29 IEEE, New York, pp. 435-438 (2002) 7 See EPAPS Document No. E-JVTAD6 -26-002801 for methods for obtaining conformal surfaces of electrodes, interel ectrode distance regulation, experimental I-V and experimental data on a dhesion, vacuum gap width, tunneling currents, and resistivity and capacitance of tunnel junctions. This document can be reached through a direct link in the online article's TML referen ce section or via the EPAPS homepage 8 A. H. Sommer, Photoemissive materials (Krieger, New York, 1980) 9 A. Tavkhelidze, A. Bibilashvili, L. Jangidze, A. Shimkunas, P. Mauger, G.F. Rempfer, L. Almaraz, T. Dixon, M.E. Kordesch, N. Katan, and H. Walitzki, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 24, 1413 (2006). 10 A. Tavkhelidze, V. Svanidze and I. Noselidze, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B, 25, p. 1270, (2007). 9 Figure Captions Fig.1. Dependence of potential energy of electron on distance from emitter. (a) d 2=0, (b) d2= 30 A and (c) d 2= 50 A. Barrier heights H and H 0 are shown for curve (c). Fig.2. Dependence of heat flux between the el ectrodes on emitter elec tric field. (a) d 2=0, (b) d 2= 30 A and (c) d 2= 50 A. Fig.3. Dependence of cooling coeffici ent on emitter electric field. (a) d 2=0, (b) d 2= 30 A and (c) d 2= 50 A. 10 0 2 04 06 08 0 1 0 Vx [V] d Fig.1 11 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 Qtot [W/cm2] E [MV/cm](a) (b) (c) Fig. 2 12 1.6 1.8 2.0 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8 E [MV/cm](c) (a) Fig. 3
|
0807.2527
|
Avto Tavkhelidze
|
Avto Tavkhelidze, Vasiko Svanidze and Leri Tsakadze
|
Thermotunnel refrigerator with vacuum/insulator tunnel barrier: A
theoretical analysis
|
9 pages, 3 figures
|
J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A, v. 26, p. 5, (2008)
|
10.1116/1.2803717
| null |
cond-mat.mes-hall
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The authors use two insulator layers in thermotunnel refrigerator to modify
the shape of the tunneling barrier so that electrons with high kinetic energy
pass it with increased probability. Theoretical analysis show that the overall
tunneling current between the electrodes contains an increased number of high
kinetic energy electrons and a reduced number of low energy ones, leading to
high efficiency. The particular case of vacuum gap and solid insulator layer is
calculated using digital methods. Efficiency remains high in the wide range of
the emitter electric field. The cooling coefficient is found to be as high as
40%-50% in the wide range of the emitter electric field.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 16 Jul 2008 09:49:58 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-17T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Tavkhelidze",
"Avto",
""
],
[
"Svanidze",
"Vasiko",
""
],
[
"Tsakadze",
"Leri",
""
]
] |
2 complex plane C, mapping the point zsinto the point (5) wherea= 1/Tandb=R*/T*. When no light is incident from the substrate, zs= 0and thenza=R. Equation (5) is a bilinear(orM Onecancheckthatt ari- ant under (5). This unit disk is then a model for in which a line is represented as an arc of a circle that meets the boundary of the disk at right angles to it (and diameters are also permitted). In this model, we have three different kinds of lines: intersecting, parallel (they int ersect at infinity, which is precisely the boundary of the disk) k out the fixed points of the transfer function; that is, the fiel d configurations such that za=zszfin Eq. (5), action is elliptic and it has only one fixed pointinside the unit disk. Since in the a rotation is characterized for having only one invaria nt point, this action can be a hyperbolic action is hyperbolic and it has two fixed points, both on the boundary of the unit disk. The geodesic line joining these two fixed points remainsinvaria nt and thus, by analogy with the Euclidean case, this action is calleda when [Tr(M)]2= 4the action is parabolic and it has only one (double)fixed point on the boundaryof the unit disk. Asit iswell known,SU(1,1)is isomorphicto thegroupof real SL(2, R), which allows us to trans- late the geometrical structure defined in the unit disk to the complex upper semiplane, recovering in this way an alterna- tive model of the hyperbolic geometry that is useful in notion of periodicity is intimately connected with tes- sellations, i.e., tilings by identical replicas of a unit ce ll (or fundamental domain) that fill the plane with no overlaps and nogaps. ll is a regular polygon with a finite area [23]. In the Euclidean plane, the associated regular tessellation is generically noted
{p,q}, wherepis the number of polygon edges and qis the number of polygons that meet at a vertex. We recall that ge- ometrical constraints limit the possible regular tilings {p,q}
to those verifying (p-2)(q-2) = 4. This includes the classical tilings {4,4}(tiling by squares) and {6,3}(tiling by hexagons), plus a third one, the tiling {3,6}by {6,3}).FIG.1: (coloronline). (7). The external layers (in blue) are made of cryolite (Na 3AlF6), while the central medium (in brown) is zinc selenide (ZnSe). The wavelength in vacuum is l= 610nm and normal incidence (from left to right) has been assumed. The corresponding thicknes ses are expressed innanometers. On the contrary,in the hyperbolicdisk regular tilings exis t provided (p-2)(q-2)>4, which now leads to an infinite number of possibilities. An essential ingredient is the way to obtain fundamental polygons. These polygonsare directl y connectedto the discrete subgroupsof isometries(or congr u- ent mappings). Such groups are called Fuchsian groups [24] and play for the a role similar to that tessellation of the hyperbolic plane by regular poly- gonshas a is generatedby isk. These geodesics correspond to edges or axes of symmetry of thepolygons. unit disk one just has to built one tile and to duplicate it by by triangleswith verticesin the unit circle, alt hough the treatment can be extended to other polygons. The key idea is to consider the Fuchsian group generated by an ellip- tic fixed point is the middle of an edge of the triangle and a parabolic one with its fixed point in 1/
3 1/
3 fixed point of Ais-i; while for Bthe fixed point in InFig.1we showa materials in optics. Note that, in physical terms, the inverses must be constructed as independent systems, al - though in our case only A-1must be considered, since the actionof B-1coincideswith thatof B. InFig. 2 we haveshownthe tessellation the fundamental triangle with the Fuchsian group3 FIG. 2: (color online). Tiling of the unit disk with the matri ces (7). The marked points are the barycenters of the triangles in the tessel- lation and all of them are the transformed of the origin by a ma trix that have as reflection coefficient the complex number that li nks center of the Thistri- angle is equilateral with vertices at the points ,with anareap. edthe dual graph of the tessellation), which turns out to be a Farey tree [26]. In fact, each line connecting two of these barycen - ters representthe actionof a word (with alphabet , we proceed as follows. First, we arbitrarily assign the num- ber 0 to the upper side of the while the other two sides are clockwise numberedas 1 and2. It is easy to convinceoneself that this assignment fixes once for all th e numbering for the sides of the other triangles in the tessell a- tion. However, these triangles can be distinguished by thei r orientation (as seen from the corresponding barycenter): t he clockwise oriented are filled in red, while the counterclock - TABLE I: Explicit rules to obtain the barycenter zn+1from thezn. Wehave transformations, whic hdepend onthe color jumps and the sides crossedby going from yellow -red Side Trans An+1Bn+1 TransAn+1 Bn+1 0BnBnAnBnBn AnBnA-1 nFIG. 3: (color online). Normalized structure factor for the word (made of 60 letters) connecting the origin with the point z8in the zig-zagpath shown inFig. 2. wise are filled in yellow. In short, we have determineda [27]. To obtain one barycenter zn+1from the previous one Next,thema- trix that take on the numbering of the side (0, 1, or 2) onemust cross, and appearin the Trans in Table I. The next generation is AnandBnmust be replaced by An+1andBn+1, respectively, as indicated in the Table. originis d e- noted asz0and the matrices A0andB0coincide with Aand B. With this rule, one can constructanyword - tial words. In fact, one can show that given an arbitrary sequence of nonzero integers {k1,k2,...,k r}, the word represented r) d in this Letter, the sequences obtained must play a key role in the theory and practice of QP systems. Of course, to put for- ward the relevant physical features of these sequences, the re are a number of quantities one can look at. Perhaps one of the most appropriate ones to assess the performance of Fora word we define a numerical sequence fnby ande-2pi/3to the letters B,A, andA-1, respec- tively. fthe4 sequence (10) wherek= 0,1,..L-1. The structure factor (or powerspec- trum) is just |Fk|2. In Fig. 3 we have plotted this structure factor in terms of kfor the word connecting the origin with the point z8in the zig-zag path of Fig. 2. The peaks reveal a rich behavior: a full analysis of these questionsis outside of the hyperbolic disk by the Fuchsian group a 2-orbifoldof genus0, with a two and a cusp. Each word as given in Eq. (9) repre- sents a hyperbolic transformation of the disk, and the axis o ch anorbifold. summary, we expect to have presented new schemes to generate QP sequences based on hyperbolic tessellations of theunitdisk. authors wish to express their warmest gratitude to E. Maci' a and J. M. Montesinos for their help and interest in E.Maci' a, Rep. Prog.Phys. 69, 397 (2006). [2] S.OstlundandR. Pandit,Phys.Rev. B 29, 1394 (1984). [3] M.Kohmoto, .58, 2436 (1987). [4] M. Kohmoto, L. P. Kadanoff, and C. Tang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50, 1870 (1983). [5] A.S ut o,J. Stat.Phys. 56, 525 (1989).[6] J. Bellissard, B. Iochum, E. Scoppola, and D. Testard, Co mm. Math. Phys. 125, 527 (1989). [7] R. Merlin, K. Bajema, R. Clarke, F. Y. Juang, and P. K. Bhat - tacharya, Phys.Rev. Lett. 55, 1768 (1985). [8] R. Merlin, K. Bajema, J. Nagle, and K. Ploog, J. Phys. Coll oq. 48, C5503 (1987). [9] V. R. Velasco and F. Garc' ia-Moliner, Prog. Surf. Sci. 74, 343 (2003). [10] S.Tamura and F.Nori,Phys. Rev. B 40, 9790 (1989). [11] M. S. Vasconcelos and E. L. Albuquerque, Phys. Rev. B 59, 11128 (1999). [12] D. Lusk, I. Abdulhalim, and F. Placido, Opt. Commun. 198, 273 (2001). [13] A. G. Barriuso, J. J. Monz' on, L. L. S' anchez-Soto, and A . Fe- lipe, Opt.Express 13, 3913 (2005). [14] E.Maci' a, Phys.Rev. B 63, 205421 (2001). [15] Z.Cheng and 60, 383 (1990). [16] V. W.Spinadel, Nonlinear Anal. 36, 721 (1999). [17] E. Maci' a and R. Rodr' iguez-Oliveros, Phys. Rev. B 74, H. S. M. Coxeter, Non-Euclidean Geometry (University of Toronto Press,Toronto, 1968). [19] T. Yonte, J. J. Monz' on, L. L. S' anchez-Soto, J. F.Cari~ nena, and C. L' opez-Lacasta, J.Opt. Soc.Am. A 19, 603 (2002). [20] J. J. Monz' on, T. Yonte, L. L. S' anchez-Soto, and J. F. Ca ri~ nena, J. Opt.Soc. Am.A 19, 985 (2002). [21] on,andL.L.S' anchez-Soto,O pt.Lett. 28, 1501 (2003). [22] H. S.M.Coxeter, Math. Intell. 18, 42(1996). [23] H. Zieschang, E. Vogt, and H. D. Coldeway, Surfaces and planar discontinuous groups , vol. 835 of Lect. Not. Math. (Springer, L. R. Ford, Automorphic functions (Chelsea Publising Com- pany, New York, 1972). [25] A. F. Beardon, The geometry of discrete groups 1983). [26] M.R.Schr oder, New York, 2006), 4thed. [27] B. Gr unbaum and G. C. Shepard, Tilings and Patterns (Free- man, New York, 1987).
|
0807.2619
|
Luis L. Sanchez. Soto
|
A. G. Barriuso, J. J. Monzon, L. L. Sanchez-Soto, and A. F. Costa
|
Escherlike quasiperiodic heterostructures
|
4 pages. 3 color-eps figures. Comments welcome
| null | null | null |
cond-mat.stat-mech cond-mat.mes-hall math.MG
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We propose quasiperiodic heterostructures associated with the tessellations
of the unit disk by regular hyperbolic triangles. We present explicit
construction rules and explore some of the properties exhibited by these
geometric-based systems.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 16 Jul 2008 17:42:04 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-17T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Barriuso",
"A. G.",
""
],
[
"Monzon",
"J. J.",
""
],
[
"Sanchez-Soto",
"L. L.",
""
],
[
"Costa",
"A. F.",
""
]
] |
one is thirty years old before this comes about. It is a protracted p eriod and there are many fallen and discouraged and inde ed lost along the way. The professional mathematician spends his life thinking about proble ms that he cannot solve, and learning from his (repeated and often ma That he can very occasionally pull the fat out of the fire a nd make something worthwhile of it is in fact a small miracle. And even when he ca n pull off such a feat, what are the chances that his peers in the comm unity will toss their hats in the air and proclaim him a hail fellow well met? Slim to none at best. In the end we learn to do mathematics because of its intrinsic beauty , and its enduring value, and for the personal satisfaction it gives us . It is an important, worthwhile, dignified way to spend one's time, and it bea ts almost any other avocation that I can think of. But it has its frustr ations. There are few outside of the mathematical community who have eve n the vaguest notion of what we do, or how we spend our time. Surely they have no sense of what a theorem is, or how one proves a theorem, or why one would want to.2How could one spend a year or two studying other people's work, only so that one can spend yet several more years to develo p one's own work? Were it not for tenure, how could any mathematics ever get d one? We in the mathematics community expect (as we should) the state leg is- lature to provide funds for the universities (to pay our salaries, fo r instance). We expect the members of Congress to allocate funds for the Natio nal Sci- ence Foundation and other agencies to subvent our research. We expect the White House Science Advisor to speak well of academics, and of math emati- cians in particular, so that we can live our lives and enjoy the fruits of our labors. But what do these people know of our values and our goals? H ow can we hope that, when they do the obvious and necessary ranking of p riorities that must be a part of their jobs, we will somehow get sorted near t he top 2From my solipsistic perspective as a mathematician, this is truly tragic . For math- ematical thinking is at the very basis of human thought. It is the key to an the list? This last paragraph explains in part why we as a profession can be ag- gravated and demoralized, and why we endure periods of frustrat ion We are not by nature at prese nting our case to those who do not speak our language--and we pay a price for We tend to be solipsistic and focused on our scientific a ctivi- ties, and trust that the value of our results will speak for themselv es. When competing with the Wiiand theiPod, we are bound therefore to be daunted. 2 Life in the Big City The aboutthose matters as to which there is no good evidence either way. --Bertrand Russell If you have ever been Chair of your department, put in the position of explaining to the Dean what the department's needs are, you know h ow hard it is to explain our mission to the great unwashed. You waltz into the De an's office and start telling him how we must have someone in Ricci flows, we certainly need a worker in mirror symmetry, and what about that ho t new stuff about the distribution of primes using additive combinatorics? T he Dean, probably a chemist, has no idea what you are talking about. Of course the person who had the previous appointment with the De efully shy ofpeople inradiochemistry Andanextra physical chemist or two would be nice as well. The Dean said sure, he underst ood immediately. It was a real shift of gears then for the Dean to have t o figure out what in the world you (from the Mathematics Department) are t alking about. How do you put your case in words that the Dean will underst and? 3How do you sell yourself (and your department) to him?3 Certainly we have the same problem with society at large. People un- derstand, just because of their social milieu, why medicine is importa nt and useful. Computers and their offspring make good sense; we all enco unter computers every day and have at least a heuristic sense of what th ey are good for. Even certain parts of engineering resonate with the ave rage biomedical engineering, civil engineering). But, aft er getting out of school, most people have little or no use for mathematics. Mos t fi- nancial transactions are handled by machines. Most of us bring our taxes to professionals for preparation. Most of us farm out construct ion projects around the house to contractors. If any mathematics, or even a rithmetic, is required in the workplace it is probably handled by software. One of my wife's uncles, a farmer, once said to me--thinking himself to be in a puckish mood--that we obviously no longer need we have computers. I gave him a patient look and said yes, a nd we obviously no longer need farmers because we have vending machin es. He was not amused. But the analogy is a good one. Computers are gr eat for manipulating data, but not for thinking. Vending machines are gr eat that someone else has produced in the had a hard time understanding what Picasso's art was about-- or even Andy Warhol'sart--but theyhada visceral sense thatit was int eresting and important. The fact that people would spend millions of dollars for the paintings gave the activity a certain gravitas, but there is something in the nature of art that makes it resonate with our collective unconsciou s. people spend their lives coming to grips with what was like ly inschool, reinforced byuninspiring teachers a If you are at a cocktail party and announce that you don't like art, or don't like music, people are liable to conclude that you are some 3It is arguable that a mathematics department is better off with a Dea n who is a musicologist or perhaps a philologist. Such a scholar is not hampered b y lab science dynamics, and can perhaps think imaginatively about wh at our goals are. 4kind of philistine. If instead you announce that you don't like mathema tics, people conclude that you are a regular guy. [If you choose to annou nce that youdolike mathematics, people are liable to get up and walk away.] To the uninitiated, mathematics is cold and austere and unforgiving. It is diffi cult to get even an intuitive sense of what the typical mathematician is up to. Unlike physicists and biologists (who have been successfully communic ating with the press and the public for more than fifty years), we are not good at telling half-truths so that we can paint a picture of our meaning and g et our point across. We are too wedded to the mathematical method. We t hink in terms of definitions and axioms and theorems. 3 Living the Good a reason. I've found mathematical truths that are true for no reason at all. These mathematical truths are beyond the power of mathematical reasoning be- cause they are accidental and random. --G. J. Chaitin The life of a mathematician is a wonderful experience. It is an exhilara t- ing, blissful existence for those who are prone to enjoy it. One get s to spend one's time with like-minded people who are in pursuit of a holy grail that is part of an important and valuable larger picture that we are all bou nd to. One gets to travel, and spend time with friends all over the world , and hang out in hotels, and eat exotic foods, and drink lovely drinks. One gets to teach bright students and engage in the marketplace of ideas, and actually to develop new ones. What could be better? There is hardly a more rewa rding way to be professionally engaged. 5It is a special privilege to be able to spend one's time--and be paid for it--thinking original (and occasionally profound) thoughts and deve loping new programs and ideas. One actually feels that he is changing the fa bric of the cosmos, helping people to see things that they have not seen people's lives.4Teaching can and probably should be a part of this process. For surely bringing along the next generation, training a n ew flank of scholars, is one of the more enlightened and certainly important p ursuits. Also interacting with young minds is a beautiful way to stay vibrant an d plugged in, and to keep in touch with the development of new ideas. Of course there are different types of teaching. The teaching of r udi- mentary calculus to freshmen has different rewards from teaching your latest research ideas to graduate students. But both are important, a nd both yield palpable results. What is more, this is an activity that others understand and appreciate . If the public does not think of us in any other way, surely they think of us as teachers. And better that weshould have to do it. After all, it is our bailiwick. The hard fact of the matter is that the powers that be in the univer - sity also appreciate our teaching rather more than they do our man y After all, mathematics is a key part of the core curriculum . A university could hardly survive without mathematics. Other majors could not function, could not advance their students, could not build the ir curric- ula, without a basis in mathematics. So our teaching role at the institu tion is both fundamental and essential. Our research role is less well und because we do not by instinct communicate naturally with scholars in other departments . This is actually a key point. We all recall the crisis at the University of Rochester thirteen years ago, when the Dean shut down the gr aduate program in mathematics. His reasoning, quite simply, was that he felt that the mathematics department was isolated, did not interact produc tively passionately the life of the scientist, and how he can feel that h e is altering and influencing the world around him. 6other units on campus, did not carry its own weight. The event at Ro be leveled at any of us. Institutions like Princeton or Harvard a re truly ivory towers, and unlikely to suffer the sort of indignity being describ ed here. But if you work at a public institution then look out. I work at a rDean, he sometimes brought up Rochester. And he did notdo so in an effort to be friendly. He was in fact threatening me. Some departments, like Earth & Planetary Science or Biomedical Eng i- neering, interact very naturally with other subjects. Their mater ial is intrin- sically It makes perfect sense for these people to curricula and joint majors with other departmen ts. It is very obvious and sensible for them to apply for grants with people fr om departments even outside of their School. A faculty member of suc h a de- partment will speak several languages fluently. It is different for mathematics. It is a challenge just to speak the on e language of mathematics, and to speak it well. Most of us do a pretty good job at it, and those outside of mathematics cannot do it at all. So the re is a natural barrier to communication and collaboration. In meetings wit h from physics and engineering--we find difficulty identify ing a common vocabulary. We find that we have widely disparate goals, and very different means of achieving them. Also our value systems are different. Our methods for gauging succ ess vary dramatically. Our reward systems deviate markedly. Once you become a full Professor you will serve on tenure and promotion committees for This experience is a real eye-opener, for you will fin d that the 7criteria used in English and History and Geography are quite different from what we are accustomed to.5Even our views of truth can be The Why and the Wherefore The lofty light of the a priori outshines the dim light of the world and makes for us incontrovertible truths because of their clearness and e Descartes A mathematician typically goes through most of his early life as a flaming success at everything he does. One excels in grade school, one exc els in high school, one excels in college. Even in graduate school one can do quit e well if one is willing to put forth the effort. Put in slightly different terms: One can get a long way in the basic material just by being smart. Not so much effort or discipline is requir ed. And this may explain why so many truly brilliant people get left in the dust . They reach a point where some real Sitzfleisch and true effort are required, and they are simply not up to it. They have never had to expend such disciplined study before, so why start now? While thereisno question thatbeing smart th ere comes a point--for all of us--where it becomes clear that a capacity for hard work can really make a difference. Most professional mathematician s put in at leastten hours per day, at leastsix days per week. There are many who do much more. And we tend to enjoy it. The great thing about mathema tics is 5I still recall serving on the committee for promotion to Professor o f a candidate in Geography. One of his published writings was called A Walk Through China Town . It described the experience of walking down Grant Avenue in San Franc isco and smelling the wontonsoup. What would be the analogueof this in a case for promot ionin it does not fight you. It will not sneak behind your back and bite you. It is always satisfying and always rewarding. Doing mathematics is notlike laying bricks or mowing the grass. The quantity of end product is not a linear function of the time expended . Far from it. As Charles Fefferman, Fields Medalist, once said, a good math e- matician throws 90% of his work in the trash. Of course one learns fr om all that work, and it makes one stronger for the next sortie. But one often, at the end of six months or a year, does not have much to show. On the other hand, one can be blessed with extraordinary periods o f productivity. The accumulated skills and insights of many years of st udy suddenly begin to pay off, and one finds that he has plenty to say. An d Certainly worth writing up and sharing with others and publishing. This is what makes life rewarding, and this is what we live for. Economists like to use professors as a model, because they run con trary to many of the truisms of elementary economic theory. For example , if you pay a Professor of Mathematics twice as much, that does not mean that he will be able to prove twice as many theorems, or produce twice as man y graduate students. The truth is that he is probably already workin g to his capacity. There are only so many hours in the day. What more could h e do? It is difficult to say what a Professor of Mathematics should be compe nsated, because we do not fit the classical economic model. Flipped on its head, we could also note that if you give a Professor of Mathematics twice as much to do, it does not follow that he will have a nervous breakdown, or quit, or go into open rebellion. Many of us no w have a teaching load of two courses per semester. But sixty years ago the norm--even at the very best universities in the United States--was t hree courses (or more!) per semester. Also, in those days, there was v ery help. Professors did a lot of the drudgery themselves . There were also no NSF grants, and very little discretionary departmental mon ey, so travel was often subvented from one's own pocket. Today life is mu ch better for everyone. 9The fact is that a Professor of Mathematics has a good deal of slac k built into his schedule. If you double his teaching load, it means that he has less time to go to seminars, or to talk to his colleagues, or just to sit and think. But he will still get through the day. Just with considerab ly less enthusiasm. And notably less creativity. Universities are holding faculty much moreaccountable fortheir time these days. Total QualityMan agement is one of many insidious ideas from the business world that is starting t o get a grip at our institutions of higher learning. In twenty years we may fi nd that we are much more like teachers (in the way that we spend our tim e) and much less like scholars. Sad to say, the Dean or the Provost has only the vaguest sense of what our scholarly activities are. When they think of the math departmen t at all, they think of us as those guys who teach calculus. They certainly do not think of us as those guys who proved the Bieberbach conjecture . Such a statement would have little meaning for the typical university adminis trator. Of course they are pleased when the faculty garners kudos and aw ards, but the awards that Louis de Branges received for his achievement wer e fairly low key.6They probably would not even raise an eyebrow among the Board of theDeanwascon that he thought of us as a gang of incompetent, fairly uncooper ative boobs. One of his very favorite Chairs at that time was the Head of Earth & Planetary Sciences. This man was in fact the leader of the Mars space probe team, and he actually designed the vehicle that was being used to explore Mars. Well, you can imagine the kind of p resentations that this guy could give--lots of animated graphics, lots of panoramic vista s, lots of lots of stories about other-worldly adventures. His t alks were given in the biggest auditoriums on campus, and they were always packed. The D ean was front and center, everytime; thats if I were to prove the Riemann Hypothesis, it would pale by compa rison. 105 Such is sin as it has in are very much like oboe players. They do something quite difficult that nobody else understands. That is fine, but it come s with a price. We take it for granted that we work in a rarified stratum of the unive rse that nobody else will understand. We do not expect to be able to com mu- nicate with others. When we meet someone at a cocktail party and s ay, I am a mathematician, we expect to be snubbed, or perhaps greeted with a witty rejoinder like, I was never any good in math. Or, I was good a t math until we got to that stuff with the letters--like algebra. When I meet a brain surgeon I never say, I was never any good at brain surgery. Those lobotomies always got me down. When I meet a proctologist, I am never tempted to say, I was never any good at .... Why do we mathematicians elicit such foolish behavior from people? One friend of mine suggested that what people are really saying to us , when they make a statement of the sort just indicated, is that the y spent their college years screwing around. They never buckled down and s tudied anything serious. So now they are apologizing for it. This is perhaps t oo simplistic. For taxi drivers say these foolish things too. And so do ma ilmen and butchers. Perhaps what people are telling us is that they knowthat they should understand and appreciate mathematics, but they do not. So instead they are resentful. There is a real disconnect when it comes to mathematics. Most peop le, by the time that they get to college, have had enough mathematics s o that 11they can be pretty sure they do not like it. They certainly do not wan t to major in the subject, and their preference is to avoid it as much as p for many of these folks, their major may require a of math (not so much because the subject area actually but rather because the people who run the department se em to want to use mathematics as a filter). And also unfortunately it happens, much more often than it should, that people end up changing their majors to psychology or physics to media studies) simply becaus e they cannot hack the math. In recent years I have been collaborating with plastic surgeons, an d I find that this is a wonderful device for cutting through the sort of con that we have been describing. Everyone , at least everyone past a certain age, is quite interested in plastic surgery. People want to un derstand it, they want to know what it entails, they want to know what are the guarantees of success. When they learn that there are connect ions between plastic surgery and mathematics then that is a hint of a human side of math. It gives me an entree that I never enjoyed in the past. I also once wrote a paper with a picture of the space shuttle in it. Tha t did not prove to be quite so salubrious for casual conversation; af ter all, engineering piled on top of mathematics does not make the mathemat ics any more palatable. But at least it was an indication that I could speak sev that is certainly a point worth pondering if we want to fit into a social milieu. Speaking many tongues is a distinct advantage, and give s one a wedge for making real contact with people. It provides another w ay of looking at things, a new point of contact. Trying to talk to people ,in the language of mathematics ,using the logic of mathematics is not going to get you very far. It will not work with newspaper repo rters and it also will not work with ordinary folks that you are going to meet in the course of your life. 126 Mathematics and Art It takes a long time to understand Dahlberg Even in the times of ancient Greece there was an understanding tha t mathematics and art were related. Both disciplines entail symmetry , and intricate relationships among the components. T he golden mean is but one of many artifacts of this putative symbiosis. M. C. Escher spent a good deal of time at the Moorish castle the Alha m- bra, studying the very mathematical artwork displayed there. Th is served to inspire his later studies (which are considered to be a very remark able synthesis of mathematics and art). Today there is more formal recognition of the of m athe- matics and art. No less an eminence than Louis Vuitton offers a subst antial prize each year for innovative work on the interface of mathematic s and art. Benoit Mandelbrot has received this prize (for his work on frac and so has David Hoffman for his work with Jim Hoffman and Bill Meeks on embedded minimal surfaces (see andart make a wonderful andfecund pairing for, asw e , and perhaps even lifeless. By contrast, art is warm, human, in spiring, even divine. If I had to give an after-dinner talk about what I do, I w ould not get very far trying to discuss the automorphism groups of pse ematics in the art of M. C. Escher, or the art that led to the mathematical w ork of Celso Costa on minimal surfaces. Of course we as mathematicians perceive our craft to be an art for m. Those among us who can see--and actually prove!--profound new the orems are held in the greatest reverence, much as artists. We see the pr ocess of 13divining a new result and then determining how to verify it much like the process of eking out a new artwork. It would be inour best interest to convey this view of what we do to the world at large. Whatever the merits of f ractal geometry may be, Benoit Mandelbrot has done a wonderful job of c onveying both the art and the excitement of mathematics to the public. Those who wish to do so may seek mathematics exhibited in art throug h- out the ages. Examples attrib uted to Paolo Uccello, in the floor of the San Marco Basilica in da Vinci's outstanding diagrams of regular polyhedra draw n as illustrations for Luca Pacioli's book The Divine Proportion .
*A glass in Jacopo de' Barbari's portrait of Pa ci- oli, painted in s)which feature in Albrecht D urer's engraving Melancholia I.
*Salvador Dal' i's painting The Last Supper in which Christ and his dis- ciples are pictured inside a giant Helaman Ferguson [FER] has made sculptures in various mat e- rials of a wide range of complex surfaces and other topological obje cts. His work is motivated specifically by the desire to create visual represe ntations of mathematical objects. There are many artists today who conceiv e of them- selves, and indeed advertise themselves, as mathematical artists . There are probably rather fewer mathematicians who conceive of themselves as and music have a longstanding and deeply developed rela - tionship. Abstract algebra and number theory can be used to unde rstand musical structure. There is even a well-defined subject of musical set theory (although it is used primarily to describe atonal pieces). Pythagore an tuning 14is based on the perfect consonances. Many mathematicians are mu sicians, and take great comfort and joy from musical pastimes. Music can b e an opportunity for mathematicians to interact meaningfully with a broa d cross section of our world. Mathematicians Noam Elkies and David Wright hav e developed wonderful full courses--about t he mathematics and can learn a lot from art, especially from the way that ar t reaches out to humanity. Part of art is the interface between the artist and the observer. Mathematics is like that too, but typically the observ er is another mathematician. We would do well, as a profession, to think ab out how to expand our pool of observers. 7 Mathematics vs. Physics I do still believe that rigor is a relative notion, not an absolute one. It depends on the background readers have and are expected to use in their judgment. --Ren' e Thom Certainly versus is the wrong word here. Ever since the time of Is aac Newton, mathematics and physics have been closely allied. After all, I saac Newton virtually invented physics as we know it today. And mathemat ics in his day was a free-for-all. So the field was open for Newton to crea te any synthesis that he chose. But mathematics and physics are divided by a common goal, which is to understand the world around us. Physicists perceive that wor ld by observing tha tworld by looking within themselves (but see the next section on Platonism vs thus arises a difference in styles. The physicist thinks of himself as an observer, and is often content to describe what he sees. Th e mathe- matician is neverso content. Even when he sees with utmost clarity, wants to confirm that vision with a proof. This fact ma kes us precise and austere and exacting, but it also sets us apart and m akes us mysterious and difficult to deal with. I once heard Fields Medalist Charles Fefferman give a lecture (to a mixe d audience of mathematicians and physicists) about the existence of matter. In those days Fefferman's goal was to prove the existence of matt er from an axiomatic fashion. I thought that this was a fascinat ing quest, and I think that some of the other mathematicians in the aud ience agreed with me. But at some point during the talk a frustrated phys icist raised his hand and shouted, Why do you need to do this? All you hav e to do is look out the window to see that matter exists! Isn't it wonderful? Different people have different value systems and different ways to view the very same scientific facts. If there is a sc hism between the way that mathematicians view themselves and the way t hat physicists see us, then there is little surprise that there is such a schism between our view of ourselves and the way that non-scientists see us. Most laymen are content to accept the world is what it is. Certainly it is not the average person's job to try to dope out why th ings are the way they are, or who made them that way. This all borders o n theology, and that is a distinctly painful topic. Better to go have a b eer and watch a sporting event on the large-screen TV. This is notthe view that a mathematician takes. The world of the mathematician is a world that we have built for our- selves. And it makes good sense that we have done so, for we need t in order to pursue the truths that we care about . But the nature of our subject also sets us apart from others--even from close allies like the physicists. We not only have a divergence of points of view, bu t also an impasse in communication. We often cannot find the words to enun ciate 16what we are seeing, or what we are thinking. In fact it has taken more than 2500 years for the modern mathema tical mode of discourse to evolve. Although the history of proof is rathe r obscure, we know that the efforts of Thales and Protagoras and Hippocrate s and Theaetetus and Plato and Pythagoras and Aristotle, culminating in E Elements , have given us the axiomatic method and the language of proof. In modern times, the work of David Hilbert and Nicolas Bour baki have helped us to sharpen our focus and nail down a universal langu age and methodology for mathematics (see [KRA] for a detailed history o f these matters and for many relevant references). The idea of mathema tical proof is still changing and evolving, but it is definitely part of who we are and w hat we believe. The discussion of Platonism and Kantianism in the next section sheds further light on these issues. 8 Plato vs. Kant It is by logicwe prove, it isby intuitionthat we invent. --Henri Poincar' e A debate has been festering in the mathematics profession for a go od time now, and it seems to have heated up in the past few years (see, for instance [DAV]). And the debate says quite a lot about who we are and how we endeavor to think of ourselves. It is the question of whether ou r subject is Platonic or Kantian. The Platonic view of the world is that mathematical facts have an inde - pendent existence--very discovers those facts--very much like Amerigo Vespucci dis- covered America, or Jonas Salk discovered his polio vaccine. But it sh ould 17be clearly understood that, in the Platonic view, mathematical ideas exist in somehigher realmthat isindependent ofthephysical world, andcer tainly in- dependent of any particular person. Also independent of time. The Platonic view poses the notion that a theorem can be true before it is prov ed. The Kantian view of the world is that the mathematician creates the subject from within himself. The idea of set, the idea of group, the id ea are all products of the human mind. They do not exist out there in nature. We (the mathematical community) have createdthem. My own view is that both these paradigms are valid, and both play a Onatypical day, oesto his office and sits down and thinks. He will certainly examine mathematic al ideas that already exist, and can be found in some paper penned by s ome other mathematician. But he will also cook things up from whole cloth. Maybe create a new axiom system, or define a new concept, or form ulate a new hypothesis. These two activities are by no means mutually exclus ive, and they both contribute to the rich broth that is mathematics. Of course the Kantian position raises interesting epistemological qu es- tions. Do we think of mathematics as being created by each individual? If that is so, then there are hundreds if not thousands of distinct ind mathematics from within. How can they communicate and sh are their ideas? Or perhaps the Kantian position is that mathematics is cr e- ated by some shared consciousness of the aggregate humanity of And then is it up to each individual to discover what the aggr has been creating? Which is starting to sound awfully Pla- tonic. Saunders MacLane [MAC] argues cogently that mathematica l ideas are elicited or abstracted from the world around is. This is perhaps a middle path between the two points of view. The Platonic view of reality seems to border on theism. For if mathe- matical truths have an independent out there in the who created those truths? And by what means? Is it some 18higher power, with whom we would be well-advised to become better ac - quainted? The Platonic view makes usmore like physicists. It would not make much sense for a physicist to study his subject by simply making things up. Or cooking them up through pure cogitation. For the physicist is suppo sed to be describing the world around him. A physicist like Stephen Hawking, w ho is very creative and filled with imagination, is certainly capable of cookin g up ideas like black hole and supergravity and wormholes, but t hese are all intended to help explain how the universe works. They are not a fairy tale. There are philosophical consequences for the thoughts express ed in the last paragraph. Physicists do not feel honor-bound to prove the claims made in their research papers. They frequently use other modes of disc ourse, rang- ing from description to analogy to experiment to calculation. If we ma the- maticians are Platonists, describing a world that is already out ther e, then why cannot we use the same discourse that the physicists use? Why do we need to be so wedded to proofs? One can hardly imagine an English Professor trying to decide whether his discipline is Platonic or Kantian. Nor would a physicist ever waste his time on such a quest. People in those disciplines know where the grist o f their mill lives, and what they are about. The questions do not really m ake sense for them. We are somewhat alone in this quandary, and it is our job to take possession of it. If we can. It appears that literary critics and physicists are certainly Platonis ts. What else could they be?7It is unimaginable that they would cook up their subject from within themselves. Certainly philosophers can and do e ngage in this discussion, and they would also be well-equipped (from a perspective) to engage in the Platonic vs. Kantian deba te. But they have other concerns. This does not seem to be their primary b eat. 7Although a physicist may put a finer point on it and assert that he has no care for a Platonic realm of ideas. Rather, he wishes to run experiments and ask questions article [MAZ] sheds new and profound light on the questions being considered here. This is a discussion that will last a long time, and prob ably will never come to any clear resolution. Once again the Platonic vs. Kantian debate illustrates the remove th have from the ordinary current of social discours e. How can the layman identify with these questions? How can the layman even ca re about them? If I were a real estate salesman or a dental technicia n, what would these questions mean to me? 9 Seeking the Truth In what we really understand, we reason but are good at solving problems. But we have recognize d for a long time that we have a problem with communicating with laymen, with the public at large, with the press, and with government agencie s. We have made little progress in solving this particular problem. What is of the problem is that we are not well-motivated. It is not entire ly clear what the rewards would be for solving this problem. But it is also n ot clear what the methodology should be. Standard mathematical arg ot will not turn the trick. Proceeding from definitions to axioms to theore ms will, in this context, fall on deaf ears. We must learn a new modus operandi , and we must learn how to implement it. This is not something that anyone is particularly good at, and we math - ematicians have little practice in the matter. We have all concentrat ed our lives in learning how to communicate with each other . And such activity cer- tainly has its own rewards. But it tends to make us blind to broader iss ues. 20It tends to make us not listen, and not perceive, and not process t he infor- mation that we are given. Even when useful information trickles thr ough, we are not sure what to do with it. It does not fit into the usual infrast ructure of our ideas. We are not comfortable processing the data. This is our own fault. This is how we have trained ourselves, and it is how we train our students. We are not by nature open and outreac hing. We are rather parochial and closed. We are more comfortable sticking close to home. And, to repeat a tired adage, we pay a price for this isolation. 10 Brave New World For most wearers of white coats, philosophy is to sci- ence as pornography is to sex: it is cheaper, easier, and some people seem, bafflingly, to prefer it. Outside of psychology it plays almost no part in the functions of the research machine. --Steve Jones For the past 2,000 years, mathematicians have enjoyed a sense of keeping to themselves, and playing their own tune.8It has given us the freedom to think our own thoughts and to pursue our own truths. By not be ing answerable to anyone except ourselves, we have been able to keep our subject pure and insulated from untoward influences. But the world has changed around us. Because of the rise of compu ters, because of the infusion of engineering ideas into all aspects of life, b ecause of the changing nature of research funding, we find ourselves not on ly isolated but actually cut off from many of the things that we need in order to p rosper and grow. 8Although it would be remiss not to note that Archimedes, Newton, an d Gauss were public figures, and very much a part of society. 21So it may be time to re-assess our goals, and our milieu, and indeed our verylingua franca , and think about how to fit in morenaturally with the flow oflife. Everymedical student ethics. Pe graduate student should take a course on communica tion. This would include not only goodlanguage skills, but how to use electronic me dia, how to talk to people with varying backgrounds , how to seek the right level for a presentation, how to select a topic, and m any of the other details that make for effective verbal and visual skills. Doing s o would strengthen us as individuals, and it would strengthen our professio n. We would be able to get along more effectively as members of the universit y, and also as members of society at large. Surely the benefits would outwe igh andaggravation, andwe would likely learn something fr omthe process. But we must train ourselves (in some instances re-train ourselves) to be welcoming to new points of view, to new perspectives, to new va lue systems. These different value systems need not be perceived as in imical to our own. Rather they are complementary, and we can grow by inter is one of the oldest avenues of human intellectual ende avor and discourse. It has a long and glorious history, and in many ways it r ep- resents the best of what we as a species are capable of doing. We, t he mathematics profession, are the vessels in which the subject lives. It is up to us to nurture it and to ensure that it grows and prospers. We can n o longer do this in isolation. We must become part of the growing and diversifyin g process that is human development, and we must learn to communica te with all parts of our culture. It is in our best interest, and it is in everyon e else's best interest as B. Davies, Let Platonism die, Newsletter of the European Mathe- matical Society 64(1007), 24-25. 22[DYS]F. Dyson, Disturbing the Universe , Basic Books, New York, 2001. [FER]H. Ferguson, Sculpture . [HOF]D. Hoffman, The computer-aided discovery of new embedded Math. Intelligencer 9(1987), 8-21. [KRA]S. Krantz, The Proof is in the Pudding: A Look at the Changing Nature of Mathematical Proof , Springer Publishing, to appear. [MAC] S. MacLane, Mathematical models: a sketch for the philosophy of mathematics, American Mathematical Monthly 88(1981), 462-472. [MAN] B. Mandelbrot, The Fractal Geometry of Nature , Freeman, New Mazur, Mathematical Platonism and its . Department of Mathematics, Washington University in St. Louis, St . Louis, Missouri
|
0807.2656
|
Steven G. Krantz
|
Steven G. Krantz
|
Through a Glass Darkly
| null | null | null | null |
math.HO
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We consider the question of how mathematicians view themselves and how
non-mathematicians view us. What is our role in society? Is it effective? Is it
rewarding? How could it be improved? This paper will be part of a forthcoming
volume on this circle of questions.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Wed, 16 Jul 2008 20:39:55 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-18T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Krantz",
"Steven G.",
""
]
] |
2 one may naively expect that the entropy of all CFTs that have an AdS-dual description is given as the form (7). However, AdS black holes do not always satisfy formula (see, e.g., [17, 26]). Therefore, one intriguing question is whether this formula is valid for Taub-NUT-(A)dS at high temper- ature. In this Letter, we will endeavor to do this. II. BLACK HOLE When the total number of dimension of the spacetime is even, ( d+1) = u, the of the arbitrary metric, for a U(1) fibration overa series of the space M2as the base is given by [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33] (for the generalized versions of the issue, see, e.g., [34, a NUT charge for the Euclidean sec- tion, and the metric function f(r) has the general form f(r) a cosmological parameter land a geometric f(r)|r=Nthe NUT solution occurs. Then for AdS spacetime the inverseofthe temperature barises from imposed condition in order to ensure regularity in the Euclidean time tEand radial coordinate r[27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, (10) wherebis the period of tE. Hereqis a positive inte- ger, which originates from removing Misner string sin- gularities. Using counter term subtraction method the regularized action is given as [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, thermal relation E=bIthe total energycan also be written (12) and the entropy is given as [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, (13) by the Gibbs-Duhem relation the conserved ( 10), (12), and (13) into (6), one gets the Casimir energy (15) From now on, for convenience we use l/zinstead of the universe radius Rin (7) since the AdS metric is taken to be (16) where the r=is put to z= 0, and the roman to boundary coordinates. When 1 /
abin the formula ( 7) is taken to be 2 the CFT entropy is given [x] is the Gauss number (greatest integer less than or equal to x). Here it seems that the difference from the standard Cardy-Verlinde formula ( 7) is due to the dis- tinctive nature of NUT solution in AdS space like N-0, leading term in the entropy ofCFT can be expressed (18)3 This result shows that the entropy of the Taub-NUT- AdS space suffices to be the generalized ( 5) for all even u(d+ 1 = 2 u+ 2). This is reasonable because the Taub-NUT-AdS metric has stable range depending on the mag- nitude of the NUT charge i.e. any NUT solution in AdS space for all odd uis unstable in the Bolt solution occurs. In Taub-Bolt-AdS metric, the in- verse of the temperature, the total energy, and the en- tropy are The CFT entropy is written (22) where 1/
abis fixed to 1 /2u2u-1. In the high formula as the that the higher dimensional Taub-Bolt-AdS space follows the generalized Cardy-Verlinde formula ( 5) even if Taub-Bolt-AdS 4space (u= 1) exactly satisfies formula ( 7) [20]. III. TAUB-NUT/BOLT-DS BLACK HOLE Taub-NUT-dS metric is obtained from the Taub-NUT- AdS metric by replacing l2- -l2, and one has [37, is given as g(r) parallel way as in the previous case, the inverse of the temperature, the total energy, the entropy, and the Casimir energy are (29) Inthiscase, 1 /
abin(7) isfixedto2 the entropy in boundary CFT is expressed high temperature limit, leading term in the entropy of the CFT for all even uis precisely matched with that in the entropy of the Taub-NUT-dS space as the (31)4 For the Bolt solution in dS space, the inverse of the temperature, the total energy, and the entropy are The CFT entropy is given (35) where 1/
abis fixed to 1 /2u2u-1. As the NUT charge goes to 0, the CFT entropy shows that no entropy of the Taub-Bolt-dS metric satisfies the Cardy-Verlinde formula. This means that any Bolt solution in dS space is un- stable at high temperature limit. IV. CONCLUSION We have considered that the in general even dimension, and have checked that its metric suffices to be the the Cardy-Verlinde formula. In the limit of high temperature, we showed that space well follows the generalized Cardy- Verlinde formula ( 7) rather than the Cardy-Verlinde for- mula (5). It seems that the modification of the stan- dard Cardy-Verlinde formula ( 5) is due to the of the Taub-NUT solution such as the ALAdS metric. It was proven that the leading term of the CFT entropyat the boundary for all even uis that of the entropy in the Taub-NUT-(A)dS space by using the generalized Cardy-Verlinde formula at Thermal stability of the for all odd uand Taub-Bolt-dS solution for all uis determined by the magnitude of the NUT charge so that the negative entropy occurs as the NUT charge goes to 0. Finally, the the breaking of Cardy-Verlinde formula in the Taub-Bolt-dS metric seems to reflect the fact that there is no Bolt solution in dS space due to the absence of hyperbolic NUT in AdS space are grateful to Cristian Stelea for useful comments. This work was supported by the BK 21 project of the Ministry of Education and Human Resources Develop- ment, Korea (C.O.L.). [1]G. 't Hooft, Nucl. Phys. B 72, 461 (1974). [2]J. M. Maldacena, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 231 (1998) [Int. J. Theor. Phys. 38, 1113 ]; [3]S. S. Gubser, I. R. Klebanov and A. M. Polyakov, Phys. Lett. B428, 105 (1998) [ ]; [4]E. Witten, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 253 ]; [5]O. Aharony, S. S. Gubser, J. M. Maldacena, H. Ooguri and Y. Oz, Phys. Rept. 323, 183 ]. [6]E. D'Hoker and D. Z. Freedman, [ ]. [7]J. D. Brown and J. W. York, Phys. Rev. D 47, Balasubramanian and P. Kraus, Commun. Math. Phys.208, 413 (1999) [ ]. [9]R. Emparan, C. V. Johnson and R. C. Myers, Phys. Rev.D60, 104001 (1999) [ ]. [10]P. Kraus, F. Larsen and R. Siebelink, Nucl. Phys. B 563, 259 (1999) [ ]. [11]J. L. Cardy, Nucl. Phys. B 270, 186 (1986). [12]E. P. Verlinde, . [13]S. Nojiri, S. D. Odintsov and S. Ogushi, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 16, 5085 (2001) [ ]. [14]S. Nojiri, S. D. Odintsov and S. Ogushi, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 17, 4809 (2002) [ ]. [15]J. E. Lidsey, S. Nojiri, S. D. Odintsov and S. Ogushi, Phys. Lett. B 544, 337 (2002) [ ]. [16]R. G. Cai, Phys. Lett. B 525, 331 ]. [17]R. G. Cai, Phys. Rev. D 63, 124018 ]. [18]R. G. Cai, Nucl. Phys. B 628, 375 ].5 [19]D. Klemm, A. C. Petkou and G. Siopsis, Nucl. Phys. B 601, 380 (2001) [ ]. [20]D. Birmingham and S. Mokhtari, Phys. Lett. B 508, 365 (2001) ]. [21]B. Wang, E. Abdalla and R. K. Su, Phys. Lett. B 503, 394 (2001) [ ]. [22]B. Wang, E. Abdalla and R. K. Su, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 17, 23 (2002) [ ]. [23]M. R. Setare, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 17, 2089 ]. [24]M. R. Setare and R. Mansouri, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 18, 4443 (2003) [ ]. [25]M. R.Setare andE. C. Vagenas, Phys.Rev.D 68, 064014 (2003) ]. [26]G. W. Gibbons, M. J. Perry and C. N. Pope, Phys. Rev. D72, 084028 (2005) [ ]. [27]A. Chamblin, R. Emparan, C. V. Johnson and R. C. Myers, Phys. Rev. D 59, 064010 ]. [28]S. W. Hawking, C. J. Hunter and D. N. Page, Phys. Rev. D59, 044033 (1999) [ ]. [29]R. B. Mann, Phys. Rev. D 61, 084013 ].[30]A. Awad and A. Chamblin, Class. Quant. Grav. 19, 2051 (2002) ]. [31]R. Clarkson, L. Fatibene and R. B. Mann, Nucl. Phys. B 652, 348 (2003) [ ]. [32]D. Astefanesei, R. B. Mann and E. Radu, Phys. Lett. B 620, 1 (2005) [ ]. [33]D. Astefanesei, R. B. Mann and E. Radu, JHEP 0501, 049 (2005) [ ]. [34]R. B. Mann and C. Stelea, Class. Quant. Grav. 21, 2937 (2004) ]. [35]R. B. Mann and C. Stelea, Phys. Lett. B 634, 448 ]. [36]C. Fefferman and C. Robin Graham, The of Elie Cartan (Lyon, 1984). Asterisque 1985, Numero Hors Serie, 95-116. [37]R. Clarkson, A. M. Ghezelbash and R. B. Mann, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 061301 (2003) [ ]. [38]R. Clarkson, A. M. Ghezelbash and R. B. Mann, Nucl. Phys. B 674, 329 (2003) [ ]. [39]R. B. Mann and C. Stelea, Phys. Rev. D 72, 084032 (2005) ].
|
0807.2685
|
Chongoh Lee
|
Chong OH Lee
|
Cardy-Verlinde Formula in Taub-NUT/Bolt-(A)dS space
|
Revtex4, 5 pages, typos corrected, version to appear in PLB
|
Phys.Lett.B670:146-149,2008
|
10.1016/j.physletb.2008.10.042
| null |
hep-th
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/publicdomain/
|
We consider a finite action for a higher dimensional Taub-NUT/Bolt-(A)dS
space via the so-called counter term subtraction method. In the limit of high
temperature, we show that the Cardy-Verlinde formula holds for the
Taub-Bolt-AdS metric and for the specific dimensional Taub-NUT-(A)dS metric,
except for the Taub-Bolt-dS metric.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 17 Jul 2008 02:28:59 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Thu, 31 Jul 2008 01:51:24 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Fri, 14 Nov 2008 07:05:43 GMT"
}
] | 2008-12-18T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Lee",
"Chong OH",
""
]
] |
I. INTRODUCTION The recent successful preparation of monolayer graphene has g enerated a lot of interest in the physics community and efforts are underway to study the elec tronic properties of graphene [1]. The nature of quasiparticles called Dirac electrons in th ese isvery different two-dime nsional in semiconductor Graphene has a hon eycomb lattice of carbon atoms. The quasiparticles in graphene have a band structure in whic h electron and hole bands touch at two points in the Brillouin zone. At these Dirac points t he the massless Dirac equation. In other words, they behave as massless Dirac to a linear dispersion relation ok=vk( with the characteristic velocity v106m/s). This difference in the nature of the quasiparticles in graphene from c onventional 2DEG has given rise to a host of new and unusual phenomena such as anomalou s quantum Hall effects and apBerry phase[1][2]. Among the electronic properties of interest is the interaction of electrons with artificially created periodic potentials. It has been observed that if con- ventional 2DEG is subjected to artificially created periodic potentia ls in the it leads to the appearance of Weiss oscillations in the magnetor esistance. This type of electrical modulation of the 2D system can be carried out by deposit ing an array of strips on the surface or through two interfering laser beam s [3, 4, 5]. Besides the fundamental interest in understanding the electronic properties of graphene there is also serious suggestions that it can serve as the building block for nanoe lectronic devices 2DEGsystems, ce has continued to be an active area of research [7, 8, 9]. Recently, in graphene monolayer in the presence of electrical mod ulation was considered and theoretical predictions made [10]. We have also carried out a study o f graphene monolayer is subjected to magnetic modulation alone [11]. Along the same lines, in this work we investigate low temperature magnetotranspor t of Dirac electrons in a graphene monolayer subjected to both electric and magnetic mod ulations with the same period. From a practical point of view, this is important to consider a s magnetic stripe in turn act as electrical gates that induce electric modulation. The relative phase of the two modulations can have important consequences for magnet otransport in the system 2as was seen in conventional 2DEG. Therefore in this work we investig ate Weiss oscillations in syyin a graphene monolayer for both the cases when the electric and magnetic modulations are in-phase and when they are out of pha se. II. ENERGY SPECTRUM AND BANDWIDTH We consider two-dimensional Dirac electrons in graphene moving in th ex-y-plane. The magnetic filed ( B) is applied along the z-direction perpendicular to the graphene plane. We consider the perpendicular magnetic field Bmodulated weakly and one direction such that B= (B+B0cos(Kx))z. HereB0is the strength of the magnetic modulation and K= 2p/awithabeing the modulation period. We consider the modulation to be weak such that B0<< B. We use the Landau gauge for vector potential A= (0,Bx,0). In effective mass approximation the one electron Hamiltonian is H=
v- -s low energy excitations are described by the two-dimensional (2 D) Dirac like Hamiltonian [1, 2, 10] H=v- -s -s={- -sx,- -sy}are the Pauli matrices and vcharacterizes the electron velocity. We employ the Landau gauge a nd write the vector potential as A= The Hamiltonian canbe written the unmodulated Hamiltonian given as -s .+ev- -syBx andH'=ev- Landau level energy eigenvalues without modulation are given by e(n) (1) wherenis an integer and has been pointed out [10] the Landau level spectrum for Dirac electrons is significantly different from the spec trum for electrons in conventional 2DEG which is given as e(n) where oc=eB/mis the eigenfunctions without modulation are given by Psn,ky(r) are the normalized harmonic the magnetic length, x0=l2ky, Lyis they-dimension of the graphene layer and Hn(x) are the Hermite we are considering weak modulation B0<< B, we can apply stan- dard perturbation theory to determine the first order correctio ns to the unmodu- lated energy eigenvalues in the presence of modulation with the resu lt andLn(u) are Hence theenergy eigenvalues inthe presenc e oftheperiodic are e(n,x0) =e(n)+en,ky+o0cos(Kx0)Gn (3) withGn(u) We observe that the degeneracy of the Landau level spectrum of the unmodulated system with respect to kyis lifted in the presence of modulation with the explicit presence of kyinx0.Then= 0 landau level is different from the rest as the energy of this level is zero and electrons in this level do not contribute to diffusive conductivity calculated in the next section. The rest of the Landau levels broaden into bands. The Landau bandwidths ~Gnoscillates as a function of nsinceLn(u) are oscillatory functions of the index n. Since we are interested in electron transport in the presence of bo th electric and s, we consider an additional weak electric modulation pote ntial given as V(x) =
V0cos(Kx) on the system. Here V0is the amplitude of modulation. We can determine the energy eigenvalues in the presence of weak electric modulation wher e we take Voto be an order of magnitude smaller than the Fermi Energy the magnitude of Fermi wave vector with nebeing the electron concentration. Hence we can apply standard first order perturbation theory to determine the energy eigenvalues in the presence of modulation. The first order correction in the energy e igenvalues when is present is given as e(n,x0) andLn-1(u) are energy eigenvalues of Dirac electrons in the presence of both m odulations can be expressed as e(n,ky) +o0cos(Kx0)Gn+V0Fncos(Kx0). (5) To better appreciate the modulation effects on the Landau levels we determine the asymp- totic expression for the bandwidth () next. The width of the nth Landau level in the 4presence of periodic electric and magnetic modulation is given as = B+E,where E is width of the electric modulation and Bis the width of the magnetic modulation: B= 2|Gn|= (6) The asymptotic expression of bandwidth can be obtained by using th e following for the Laguerre polynomials by taking the large limit the result that the asymptotic expression for (7) Similarly, for electric modulation, the bandwidth Eis given as E= the asymptotic expression for (8) Therefore the bandwidth in the presence of both electric and magn etic modulations can be expressed as (9) In Fig.(1) we present the bandwidths as a function of the magnetic fi eld for temperature T= 6K, electron density ne= 3x1011cm-2,the period of modulation a= of the electric modulation V0= 0.2meVwhere as B0= 0.004Twhich 0.2meVwith theresult that have equal strengths. I nthe same figure we have also shown the bandwidths when either the magnetic o r electric modulation alone is present. We observe that electric and magnetic bandwidths are out of phase while the positions of the extrema of combined bandwidth are shifted with respect to electric and magnetic bandwidths. The combined bandwidth when both modulation s are present will affect the conductivity and that is considered in the next section. 5III. WITH PERIODIC ELECTRIC AND MAG- NETIC MODULATION: IN-PHASE To calculate the electrical conductivity in the presence of weak elec tric and s we use Kubo formula to calculate the linear response to a pplied external fields. In a magnetic field, the main contribution to Weiss oscillations comes fr om the migration of the Larmor circle center. This is diffusive conduc tivity and we shall determine it following the approach in [7, 10, 11, 12] where it was show n that the of conductivity syycan be calculated by the following expression in the case of quasielastic scattering of are the dimensions of the layer, b=1 kBTis the inverse temperature with kBthe Boltzmann constant, f(E) is the Fermi Dirac distribution function, t(E) is the and zdenotes thequantum numbers of the electron eigenstate. The dia hence it carries the effects of modulation in which we are primarily in terested in not contribute as the component of velocity in the x-direction is zero here. The collisional contribution due to impurities is not taken into account in this work. The summation in Eq.(10) over the quantum numbers zcan be written component of velocity required in Eq.(10) can be calculated from the following the expression for e(n,ky) obtained in Eq.(5) into Eq.(12) a result uz y,the corresponding velocity given by Eq.(13) contains the contribut ion from both the modulations (electric and magnetic) obtained in Eq.(5) comp ared to one term in 6velocity component for each[10, 11]. This term ( uz y) has important consequences for the quantum transport phenomena in modulated systems. With the results obtained in Eqs.(11), (12) and (13) we can express the diffusive contri- bution to the conductivity given by Eq.(10) as syy=A0ph given = exp[b(e-eF] andeFis the Fermi energy. In Fig.(2) we show the in-phase conductivity (the magnetic and the e lectric modulations are in-phase) syygiven by Eqs(14,15,16) as a function of the inverse magnetic field for temperature T= 6K, electron density ne= 3x1011cm-2,the period of modulation a=
350nm.The dimensionless magnetic fieldB' Bis introduced where B'=
ea2= strength of the electric modulation V0= 0.2meVwhere as B0= to o0= 0.2meVwiththe result that have equal strengths. In the same figure we have also shown the conductivity when either t he magnetic or alone is present. Thep 2phase difference in the bandwidths results in the same phase difference appearing in the conductivity for electric and magn etic modulations as can be seen in the figure. To better understand the effects of in-p hase modulations on the conductivity we consider the asymptotic expression of the quantit yphgiven by Eq.(16) that appears in the syy. The asymptotic results are valid when applied magnetic field is weak such that many Landau levels are filled. The asym ptotic expression is obtained in the next section. IV. ASYMPTOTIC EXPRESSIONS: IN-PHASE MODULATIONS To get a better understanding of the results of the previous sect ion we will consider ofconductivity be obtained following [7, 10, 11]. The asymptotic expression of phcan be obtained by employing the following asymptotic expression for the Laguerre poly nomials which is valid in the limit of large nwhen many landau levels are filled (17) with the result that the in-phase bandwidth can be written as (in-phase) the ratio between the two modulation strengths tan(Ph) .The flat band condition from the above equation is 2nu-p 4+ Ph =ipwhereiis an integer. This condition can also be expressed highest Fermi integer. We see that the flat band condition in this case depends on the relative strength of the two modulations. We now take the continuu m (18) to express phin Eq.(16) as the following (19) whereu= assuming that the temperature is low such that b-1eFand replacing e=
eF+sb-1, we rewrite the above integral the dimensionless Fermi momentum of the electron. To obtain an analytic solution we have also replaced ebyeFin the above integral except in the sine term in the integrand. 8The above expression can be written (21) The above integration can be performed by using the following identit y the 2xe-x. From the asymptotic expression of phgiven by Eq.(23), we observe that the effect of the in-phase electric and magnetic modulations is the appearance of a phase factor Ph in the conductivity. The shift in the Weiss oscillations when in-phase elec tric and s are present can be seen in Fig.(3). The phase factor Ph d epends on the of the two modulations. How the Weiss oscillations are affec ted as Ph as well as the magnetic field is varied can be seen in Fig.(3). The results shown are fo r a fixed of strength o0= 0.2meVand the electric modulation is varied. The change in V0results in a corresponding change in both dand Ph. From Fig.(3), we observe that the position of the extrema in as a function of the inverse magnetic field depends on the relative strength of the be better appreciated if we consider the asymptotic expressio n forphin this case. This is taken up in the next section. 9V. WITH PERIODIC ELECTRIC AND MAG- NETIC MODULATION: OUT-OF-PHASE In this section, we calculate phwhen electric and magnetic modulations are out of phase byp/2.We consider magnetic modulation out of phase with the electric one: W e take the electric modulation to have the same phase as given in the previous se ction with the p/2 phase difference incorporated in the magnetic field. The energy eige nvalues are e(n,ky) +o0sin(Kx0)Gn+V0Fncos(Kxo), (24) and the bandwidth is (out of phase) term responsible for Weiss oscillations is the under the square root which can be readily seen by considering the large nlimit of the bandwidth. Therefore for d=+-1 Weiss oscillations are no longer present in the bandwidth. The velocit y component uyis given given asymptotic expression for phin the presence of both electric and magnetic modulations that are out of phase is obtained by substituting the asymptotic ex pressions for the and converting the sum into integration with the the expression of the out-of-phase bandwidth given by Eq.(2 5) we find that in the bandwidth are absent for relative modulation stren gthd=+-1, the same is reflected in phas the term responsible for Weiss oscillations as can be seen from the above equation. Therefore the magneto not exhibit Weiss oscillations when the relative modulation streng as a function of magnetic field when the electric and mag netic modulations are out-of-phase is shown in Fig.(4). The results shown are for a fixed m agnetic modulation of strength o0= 0.2meVand the electric modulation V0is allowed to vary between positive and negative values. The other parameters are the same as in Figs.( 1,2,3). As V0is varied there is a corresponding change in d.We find that the positions of the extrema of syyas a function of the inverse magnetic field do not change as dis varied since the phase factor Ph does not appear in the expression of conductivity when the two mo dulations are out of phase. It is also observed in Fig.(4) that there is ap 2phase difference between the curves ford>=1 andd <1.The same behavior is observed in the bandwidth which is reflected in the . In this work we have considered Weiss o scillations and have not taken pure Shubnikov de Hass (SdH) oscillations into account bu t SdH oscillations do appear superimposed on Weiss oscillations in the region of strong mag netic field as can been seen in all of our figures. In addition, since this work was motivated b y[7], it is important to compare the results obtained here for graphene monolayer with th ose presented for standard 2DEG. In contrast to the work presented here, in [7] SdH are exp licitly taken into account but we find that our principal expressions Eq.(23), (28) reduce to the expressions there when the terms contributing to SdH oscillations are ignored. In the end, we would also like to mention relevance of this work in exper imental studies of transport in graphene. Experiments on graphene monolayer in t he presence of have notbeenrealized yet, thistheoret ical experimental work. We expect that modulation effects predicte d here can be observed in graphene employing established techniques that were used for the two-dimensional electron gas systems found in semiconductor heterostructures [14]. In co nventional modulation of the potential seen by electrons can be pro duced by molecular beam epitaxy, chemical vapor deposition as well as sputtering technique s [15]. In graphene, we expect that modulation effects can be introduced by adsorbing ada toms on graphene surface using similar techniques, by positioning and aligning impurities with scann ing tunneling mi- croscopy or by applying top gates to graphene. Epitaxial growth o f graphene on a is also possible [16]. In conclusion, we have determined the effects of both the electric a nd magnetic modula- tionsonthe Appea syyis themain focusof thiswork. These oscillations are affected 11by the relative phase of the two modulations and position of the oscilla tions depends on the relative strength of the two modulations. We find complete suppres sion of Weiss oscillations for particular relative strength of the modulations when the modula tions are gratefully acknowledge F. M. Peeters for suggesting the proble m and for comments on the manuscript. One of us (K.S.) would like to acknowledge the supp ort of the Pakistan Science Foundation (PSF) through project No. C-QU/Phys (129) . M. T. would like to acknowledge the support of the Pakistan Higher Education Commiss ion of Physics, Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College Lo ndon, South Kensington Campus, London SW7 2AZ, United Kingdom.; Electronic ad address: om [1] K. S. Novoselov ,A. K. Geim, S. V. Morozov, D. Jiang, M. I. Katsnelson, I. V. Gri gorieva, S. V. Dubonos, and A. A. Firsov, Nature 438,197 (2005); Y. Zhang, Y. W. Tan, H. L. Stormer, and P. Kim, 438, 201 (2005). [2] Y. Zheng and T. Ando, Phys. Rev. B 65, 245420 (2002); V. P. Gusynin and S. G. Sharapov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 146801 (2005); N. M. R. Perez F. Guinea, and A. H. Castro Neto , Phys. Rev. B73, 125411 (2006); M. I. Katsnelson , K. S. Novoselov, and A. K. G eim, Nat. Phys. 2, 620 (2006); K. S. Novoselov, E. McCann, S. V. Morozov, V. I. F al'ko, M. I. Katsnelson, U. Zeitler, D. Jiang, F. Schedin, and A. K. Geim, Nat. Phys. 2, 177 (2006). [3] D. Weiss, K. v. Klitzing, K. Ploog, and G. Weimann ,Europhys. Lett., 8, 179 (1989) [4] R. W. Winkler, J. P. Kotthaus, and K. Ploog, Phys. Rev. Let t.62, 1177 (1989). [5] R. R. Gerhardts, D. Weiss, and K. v. Klitzing, Phys. Rev. L ett.62, 1173 (1989). [6] C. Berger, et.al, Science 312, 1191 (2006). [7] F. M. Peeters and P. Vasilopoulos, Phys. Rev. B 47, 1466 (1993) [8] F. M. Peeters and P. Vasilopoulos, Phys. Rev. B 46, 4667 (1992); A. Manolescu, R. R. Gerhardts, Phys. Rev. B 56, 9707 (1997); R. R. Gerhardts, Phys. Rev. B 53, 11064 (1996); 12R. Menne, R. R. Gerhardts, Phys. Rev. B 57, 1707 (1998); U. J. Gossmann, A. Manolescu, R. R. Gerhardts, Phys. Rev. B 57, 1680 (1998); J. Shi and F. M. Peeters, K. W. Edmonds and B. L. Gallagher, Phys. Rev. B 66, 035328 (2002); P. De Ye, D. Weiss, R. R. Gerhardts, M. Seeger, K. v. Klitzing, K. Eberl and H. Nickel, Phys. Rev. L ett.74, 3013 (1995); J. H. Ho, Y. H. Lai, Y. H. Chui and M. F. Lin, Nanotechnology 19, 035712 (2008); [9] P. Vasilopoulos, F. M. Peeters, Superlattices and Micro structures 7, 393 (1990); F. M. Peeters and A. Matulis, Phys. Rev. B 48, 15166 (1993); F. M. Peeters, P. Vasilopoulos and Jirong Shi , J. Phys. : Condens. Matter 14, 8803 (2002); X. F. Wang and P. Vasilopoulos, F. M. Peeters, Phys. Rev. B 71, 125301 (2005); X. F. Wang, P. Vasilopoulos and F. M. Peeters , Phys. Rev. B69, 035331 (2004); D. P. Xue and G. Xiao, Phys. Rev. B 45, 5986 (1992). [10] A. Matulis and F. M. Peeters, Phys. Rev. B 75, 125429 (2007). [11] M. Tahir, K. Sabeeh, Phys. Rev. B 77, 195421 (2008). [12] M. Charbonneau ,K. M. Van Vliet and P. Vasilopoulos, J. Math. Phys. 23, 318 (1982). [13] I. S. Gradshteyn and I. M. Ryzhik, Table of Integrals, Series and Products (Academic Press, New York, 1980). [14] H. A. Carmona, et.al, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3009 (1995); K. W. Edmonds, et.al, Phys. Rev. B 64, 041303 (2001); P. De Ye, D. Weiss, R. R. Gerhardts, M. Seeger , K. v. Klitzing, K. Eberl and H. Nickel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3013 (1995). [15] R. Tsu, Superlattice to Nanoelectronics (Elsevier, Oxford, UK, 2005); M. G. Cottam, D. R. Tilley, Introduction to Surface and Superlattice Excitations (Cambridge Univ. Press, UK, 1989). [16] C- H Park, et.al, Nat. Phys. 4,213 (2008). 13
|
0807.2746
|
Muhammad Tahir
|
M. Tahir and K. Sabeeh
|
Suppression of Weiss oscillations in the magnetoconductivity of
modulated graphene monolayer
|
14 pages, 4 figures, Published in International journal of Modern
Physics B
|
International Journal of Modern Physics B (IJMPB), Year: 2009 Vol:
23 Issue: 16 (30 June 2009) Page: 3445 - 3457
|
10.1142/S0217979209052613
| null |
cond-mat.mes-hall
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We have investigated the electrical transport properties of Dirac electrons
in a monolayer graphene sheet in the presence of both electric and magnetic
modulations. The effects of the modulations on quantum transport when they are
in phase and out of phase are considered. We present the energy spectrum and
the bandwidth of the Dirac electrons in the presence of both the modulations.
We determine the $\sigma_{yy}$ component of the magnetoconductivity tensor for
this system which is shown to exhibit Weiss oscillations.Asymptotic expressions
for $\sigma_{yy}$ are also calculated to better illustrate the effects of
in-phase and out-of-phase modulations.We find that the position of the
oscillations in magnetoconductivity depends on the relative strength of the two
modulations. When the two modulations are out-of-phase there is complete
suppression of Weiss oscillations for particular relative strength of the
modulations.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 17 Jul 2008 10:11:51 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Tue, 16 Sep 2008 13:17:36 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Thu, 16 Jul 2009 10:40:55 GMT"
}
] | 2009-07-16T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Tahir",
"M.",
""
],
[
"Sabeeh",
"K.",
""
]
] |
2 20 30 40 50 60 7000 epoxy(c) ~ c-axis // rotation axis (00 l)Intensity (arbitrary unit) 2th (a) random powder ~ ab-plane // Ba (hk0) (h + k = 2n) FIG. 2: Powder X-ray diffraction patterns 0.85F0.15. (a) random powder, (b) ab-plane aligned along B a, (c)c-axis aligned along rotation axis (Ba). tion study, the B awill c-axis to align along the rotation axis. The X-ray diffraction patterns 0.85F0.15random powder, aligned along B a, and partially c-axis aligned along the rotation axis are shown collectively in Fig. 2. The unaligned random powder diffraction pattern gives a slightly larger tetragonal lattice parameters of a=
0.3936(3) nm and c= 0.8495(8) nm with 5% La doping than SmFeAsO 0.85F0.15[5]. At least 10% impurities were observed as marked by asterisk in the For ab-plane aligned along B a, enhanced ( hk0) diffraction lines ( h+k= 2n) were observed. The lack of forbidden line (210) is consistent with the space group P4/nmm. For c-axis aligned along the rotation axis, enhanced (00 l) diffraction lines were observed. The imperfect alignment (80-90 %) with the appearance of major (102) line may be due to intrinsic weak low aligned field (0.9 T), imperfect or alignment procedure. The for SmFeAsO powder gives similar result with ab-plane aligned along B a. The field-rotation alignment method at room temper- ature is based on magnetic anisotropy due to the spin- orbital related anisotropic exchange coupling. There are two major contributions of magnetic moment at room temperature kh~kh(Fe) +kh(Sm). The large Sm3+
(4f55s25p6, S=5/2,L=5, in the insulating (Sm layer has weak anisotropic exchange coupling. On the other hand, the Fe2+(3d6) itinerant moment in the metallic FeAs layer is rather small from powder neutron diffrac- tion data and band structure calculation. The Fe2+
feels the distorted FeAs 4tetrahedral crystal field with three low-lying manifold and two up-lying manifold (d xz0 20 40 60 80 100-3-2-101 0 100 200 < khmol (cm3/mol)aligned powder in epoxy Ba= 10 G Tc= 52 Temperature T (K)Tc = 52 K khab < khc at 10 FIG. 3: Anisotropic low-field FC and ZFC and khc(T) for aligned Sm 0.95La0.05FeAsO 0.85F0.15. and dyz). The six 3 delectrons are distributed in three quasi-2D hole-like bands and two electron-like bands with Fermi surfaces from five 3 dorbitals. coupling (magnetic fluctuation) occurs from strong Fe-As 3d xz,yz-4p hybridization and Fe-Fe 3d xy- 3dxydirect electron hopping between neighboring Fe atoms in the tetragonal basal ab-plane [6, 10, 11]. In the aligned magnetic field, anisotropic Fe orbitals are tied to the spin direction, and a strong spin-orbital re- lated anisotropic exchange coupling at 300 K should dominate the magnetic alignment. Due to the quasi- 2D FeAs layer structure, anisotropic Fe magnetic sus- ceptibility khab(Fe)> khc(Fe) is expected to be the dom- inant factor for ab-plane alignment along B aat 300 K. Indeed, anisotropic room temperature magnetization weak magnetic anisotropy ratio khab/khc~1.2 up to 7 T. In the low field region, a cross-over from high field with nonlinear behavior may be caused by the magnetic and magnetic susceptibility data were collected with a Quantum Design 1-T u-metal shielded MPMS 2or a 7-T MPMS superconducting quantum in- terference device (SQUID) magnetometer from 2 K to 300 K. The anisotropic temperature dependence of mo- lar magnetic susceptibility khab(T) and khc(T) for aligned powder Sm 0.95La0.05FeAsO 0.85F0.15with applied field along the ab-plane and c-axis are shown collectively in Fig. 3. For aligned dispersed microcrystalline in low applied field of 10 G, both (ZFC) and field-cooled (FC) data revealed a sharp temperature T cof 52 K, which is identical to the measuredT Large ZFC intragrain Meissner shielding signals were observed with an almost constant khc= -2.72 cm3/mol and khab=
-1.13 cm3/mol up to 20 K. The anisotropic g=khc/khabof 2.4 was deduced for aligned mi-3 0.0 0.5 1.0 K 10 K 5 K T = 2 K u0Hc c1 = 200 G (5 K) khc(linear) ~ -2.7 cm3/mol 20 K 25 K 30 K 35 K 40 K 45 Ku0Hc(peak) = 850 G(a) Ba // Mc (102 magnetic field Ba u0H (kG) 0.0 0.5 1.0 K 10 K 5 K T = 2 K khab(linear) ~ -1.1 85 G (5 K) 20 K 25 K 30 K 35 K 40 K 45 Ku0Hab(peak) = 1250 G(b) Ba // Mab (102 G.cm3/mol) Applied magnetic field Ba u0H (kG) FIG. 4: Temperature variation of (a) c-axis initial magnetization M c(Ba) and (b) ab-plane initial magnetization M ab(Ba) for The FC flux-trapped signal gavethe gof2.4. factor (80-90%), a larger anisotropic diamag- netic parameter g= 2.4 + 0.6 was derived. For temper- ature above T c, normal state paramagnetic 1.3 was observed in 10 G at 300 K, which is consistent with low field magnetization at 300 K behavior was observed in the normal state. The temperature variation of superconducting curves with applied field B aalongc- axis, M c(Ba,T), and ab-plane, M ab(Ba,T), for 0.85F0.15powder from 2 K to 45 K are shown in Fig. 4(a) and 4(b), respectively. For ex- ample, at T = 5 K, the maximum diamagnetic signal was observed at magnetization peak field u0Hc(peak) of 850 G for M cand a larger u0Hab(peak) of 1250 G for Mab, indicating anisotropic pinning for different applied field directions. The peak field corresponds to the field that magnetic flux penetrates into the center of forming a vortex glasswhere vortexare mainly pinned by impurities and imper- fections. At the low-field region, linear variation of both directions[13]. The initial magnetization are consistent with the low-field (Ba= 10 G) susceptibility as measured in Fig. 3. Since the lower critical field u0Hc1is the field flux start to pen- etrate into the superconductor forming mixed state , M(B a) deviates from the linear response of Meissner state. Using 10-G/5-K linear magnetic sus- ceptibility khc= -2.7 cm3/mol and khab= -1.1 cm3/mol in Fig. 3, lower critical field u0Hc c1of 200 G and u0Hab c1of 85 G were deduced from the linear susceptibility extrap- olation lines. The low temperature, low magnetic field diagram for aligned Sm 0.95La0.05FeAsO 0.85F0.15 powder is shown in Fig. 5(a). The zero critical field u0Hc c1(0) of 230 G and u0Hab c1(0) of 95 G were extrapolated. The temperature dependence of anisotropic penetration depth lab(T) and lc(T) are shown in Fig. 5(b), using the anisotropic formula u0Hc c1
= Ph0/2plablc, where Ph 0is the flux quantum. The zero temperature penetration depths lc(0) = 280 nm and lab(0) = 120 nm were values reflect the quasi-2D FeAs layer structure and are smaller than the microcrystalline grain size of ~
1-10um. The anisotropy parameter gderived from the penetration depth ratio lc(0)/lab(0) of 2.33 is smaller than the reported value from single crystal by penetra- tion depth ( ~4) [12] or u0Hc2(~4.34-4.9) [9]. How- ever, the differences of anisotropy parameter gmay be attributed to the different demagnetization field in slab- shaped single crystal with different applied field direc- tions when the geometric shape is considered, i.e. the slab shape of single crystals and the sphere-like shape of the aligned microcrystalline in this work. Since the band structure calculations suggested quasi- 2D nature of the Fermi surface [10, 11] in the layered the was expected to provide more intrinsic The low temperature (2-25 K) can be roughly fitted by a BCS-type law with a much smaller 0/kBTcof 0.4 than typi- cal value of 1.76, indicating that isotropic s-wave model may not be a good one for this new high-T although a BCS-like gap is reported for SmFeAsO 0.85F0.15from Andreev spectra [7]. However, the low temperature lab(T) can also be well fitted with a simple indicating existence excitation, possibly d-wave or extended s- wave pairing in nature [11]. A triplet p-wave pairing4 0 10 20 30 40 50 glassvortex glass Meissner state(a) Phase = 52 K Temperature T (K)Applied field Ba = u0H (G) 0 10 20 30 40 50 Penetration depth Tc = 52 T (K)Penetration depth l (nm) FIG. 5: (a) Low field anisotropic phase diagram u0H(T) for aligned Sm 0.95La0.05FeAsO 0.85F0.15powder. (b) Tempera- ture dependence of anisotropic penetration depth lab(T) and lc(T). model with strong ferromagnetic fluctuation and degen- erate electron Fermi surfaces was also proposed from band structure consideration [10]. In the powder align- ment procedure, Fe anisotropic mag- netic fluctuation is needed at 300 K. However, we can not distinguish whether the magnetic fluctuation is fer- romagnetic or in origin. The +-7T) isothermal hysteresis loops M-B aat 5 K (Fig. 6) maximum applied field of 7 T with very coherence lengths xabandxc. Moreover, hys- teresis loops with large paramagnetic background indi- cate the large contribution. In conclusion, due to Fe short- range anisotropic exchange interaction khab(Fe)> khc(Fe) at 300 K, Sm 0.95La0.05FeAsO can be aligned using the field-rotation alignment method where ab-plane is parallel to the aligned is parallel to the rotation axis. Rather small superconducting anisotropy parameter g~2.4 both susceptibility and lowercrit--7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 G 850 GT = 5 K < Tc = 52 Magnetization Mmol (103 G.cm3/mol) Applied magnetic field Ba u0H (T) FIG. 6: Anisotropic high-field superconducting hystere- sis loop M c(Ba) and M ab(Ba) at 5 K for field). The magnetic fluctuation used for of at lower work was supported by and address: Y. Kamihara, T. Watanabe, M. Hirano, and H. Hosono, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 130, 3296 (2008). [2] H. Takahashi, K. Igawa, K. Arii, Y. Kamihara, M. Hi- rano, and H. Hosono, Nature 453, 376 (2008). [3] T. A. Ren, G. C. Che, X. L. Dong, J. Yang, W. Lu, W. Yi, X. L. Shen, Z. C. Li, L. L. Sun, F. Zhou, and Z. X. Zhao, Europhys. Lett. 83, 17002 (2008). [4] H. H. Wen, G. Mu, L. Fang, H. Yang, and X. Zhu, Eu- rophys. Lett. 83, 17009 (2008). [5] X. H. Chen, T. Wu, G. Wu, R. H. Liu, H. Chen, and D. F. Fang, Nature 453, 761 (2008). [6] C. delaCruz, Q.Huang, J. W.Lynn,J. Y.Li, W.Ratcliff II, J. L. Zarestky, H. A. Mook, G. F. Chen, J. L. Luo, N. L. Wang, P. C. Dai, Nature 453, 899 (2008). [7] T. Y. Chen, Z. Tesanovic, R. H. Liu, X. H. Chen, and C. L. Chien, Nature 453, 1224 (2008). [8] G. F. Chen, Z. Li, D. Wu, G. Li, W. Z. Hu, J. Dong, P. Zheng, J. L. Luo, and N. L. Wang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 247002 (2008). [9] Y. Jia, P. Cheng, L. Fang, H. Q. Luo, H. Yang, C. Ren, L. Shan, C. Z. Gu, and H. H. Wen, (2008). [10] G. Xu, W. Ming, Y. Yao, X. Dai, S. C. Zhang, and Z. Fang, Europhys. Lett. 82, 67002 (2008). [11] X. Dai, Z. Fang, Y. Zhou, and F. C. Zhang, (2008). [12] C. Martin, R. T. Gordon, M. A. Tanatar, M. D. Van- nette, M. E. Tillman, E. D. Mun, P. C. Canfield, V. G. Kogan, G. D. Samolyuk, J. Schmalian, and R. (2008). [13] X. G. Li, X. F. Sun, Y. H. Toh, Y. Y. Hsu, and H. C.Ku, Phys. Rev. B 58, 1000 (1998).
|
0807.2833
|
Huan-Chiu Ku
|
B. C. Chang, C. H. Hsu, Y. Y. Hsu, Z. Wei, K. Q. Ruan, X. G. Li, and
H. C. Ku
|
Anisotropic superconducting properties of aligned
Sm$_{0.95}$La$_{0.05}$FeAsO$_{0.85}$F$_{0.15}$ microcrystalline powder
|
4 pages, 6 figures
| null |
10.1209/0295-5075/84/67014
| null |
cond-mat.supr-con cond-mat.str-el
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
The Sm$_{0.95}$La$_{0.05}$FeAsO$_{0.85}$F$_{0.15}$ compound is a quasi-2D
layered superconductor with a superconducting transition temperature T$_c$ = 52
K. Due to the Fe spin-orbital related anisotropic exchange coupling
(antiferromagnetic or ferromagnetic fluctuation), the tetragonal
microcrystalline powder can be aligned at room temperature using the
field-rotation method where the tetragonal $\it{ab}$-plane is parallel to the
aligned magnetic field B$_{a}$ and $\it{c}$-axis along the rotation axis.
Anisotropic superconducting properties with anisotropic diamagnetic ratio
$\chi_{c}/\chi_{ab}\sim$ 2.4 + 0.6 was observed from low field susceptibility
$\chi$(T) and magnetization M(B$_{a}$). The anisotropic low-field phase diagram
with the variation of lower critical field gives a zero-temperature penetration
depth $\lambda_{c}$(0) = 280 nm and $\lambda_{ab}$(0) = 120 nm. The magnetic
fluctuation used for powder alignment at 300 K may be related with the pairing
mechanism of superconductivity at lower temperature.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Thu, 17 Jul 2008 16:57:13 GMT"
}
] | 2009-11-13T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Chang",
"B. C.",
""
],
[
"Hsu",
"C. H.",
""
],
[
"Hsu",
"Y. Y.",
""
],
[
"Wei",
"Z.",
""
],
[
"Ruan",
"K. Q.",
""
],
[
"Li",
"X. G.",
""
],
[
"Ku",
"H. C.",
""
]
] |
2 MOHARRAM AGHAPOURNAHR AND LEIF MELKERSSON In section 2, in view of Grothendieck's conjecture and [7, Theorem 6.3.9], we first study finiteness properties of the kernel and the co kernel of the natural homomorphism f: certain conditions, using the technique introduced by the se cond author in [14]. We will find some relations between finiteness of the associated primes of Extn R(R/a,M) and Hn a(M) that will give us a generalization of [13, Proposition 1.1 part (b)], [2, Lemma 2.5 part (c) ] and [4, Proposition 2.2]. Also we show that under certain is artinian if and only if Hn a(M) is. One of our main results of this paper is Corollary = 0for allj < n, thenfis = 0for allj < n, thenfis = 0fort=n,n+1and for all j < n, then fis an isomorphism. In section 3 we will study the asymptotic behaviour of the kernel an d the cokernel of the above mentioned natural map in the graded ca se. 2.Associated primes and LetRbe a noetherianring, aanideal of Let nbe a non-negative integer and Sbe a Serre subcategory of the category of R-modules i.e. it is closed under taking and extensions. Consider the natural homomorphi sm f: to Sfor allj < n, particular if finite for all j < n, then Kerfis to Sfor allj < n, to S.(In particular if finite for all j < n, thenCokerfis to Sfort=n,n+1and for all j < belong to S. and only if to S.(In particular finite for t=n,n+ 1and for all j < are finite, thus Extn R(R/a,M)is finite if and only finite. (See also[7, Theorem 6.3.9])) . Proof.By the exact sequence 0 we obtain the exact sequence ( *) below:LOCAL COHOMOLOGY have the commutative that -his an isomorphism. Let g=-h-1*-f. Thusf=g*hand we obtain the exact of (a): Forn= 0, since thus Ker f=
0 and the result is clear. For n>=1 by hypothesis and the exact sequence ( *), Kerhbelongs to S. Therefore it is enough to show that Kergbelongs to S. We prove this by induction on n. Forn= 1 since -his an isomorphism, hence Ker g= Ker-fbut-fis an isomorphism by [14, Lemma 7.9]. Assume n >1 and the case n-1 is settled. Let E be the injective hull of M/Ga(M) and set N=E/(M/Ga(M)). = 0, we have Hom R(R/a,E) = 0 and G a(E) = 0. Thus we get the alli>=0. addition, for all j < n-1 the S. to S. But Ker f'= Kerg, so Kergbelongs to S. Proof of(b): The proof is similar to (a).4 MOHARRAM AGHAPOURNAHR AND LEIF MELKERSSON Proof of(c): It is clear by (a) and (b). /square The following corollary is one of our main results of this paper. It is well-known by using a spectral sequence argument as in [13, Propo si- tion 1.1 (b)] or another method as in [2, Lemma 2.5 (b)] to prove that , (whenMis a finite module and n= depthaM) or more generally when the local cohomology vanishes below n, for example use [15, Theorem 11.3], then the natural map f: an isomorphism. In the following corollary we show that without any condition on Mit is not necessary that these local are zero in order that the natural map is an = 0for allj < n, thenfis = 0for allj < n, thenfis = 0fort=n,n+1and for all j < n, then fis an proposition 2.1 set S={0}. 2.3. IfHi a(M) = 0for alli < n(in particular, when Mis finite and n= 2.4. artinian for t=n,n+1and for allj < n, artinian if and only if is immediate by using 2.1 (c) and [5, Theorem 7.1.2]. = 0for allj < n, = 0for allj < n, = 0fort=n,n+1and for all j < n, = Ass COHOMOLOGY 5 Lemma 2.6. For any exact sequence and R-homomorphisms we thenNp= 0, soLp~=Tp. sopAssR(L). and Mafi introduced in [9] weakly Laskerian Mis weakly Laskerian if for any submodule NofM the quotient M/Nhas finitely many associated primes. The weakly Laskerian modules form a Serre subcategory of the category of R- modules. In fact it is the largest Serre subcategory such that eac h module in it has just finitely many associated prime ideals. In the following corollary we give some conditions for the finiteness of the sets of associated primes of Extn R(R/a,M) and Hn a(M) a finite set and weakly Laskerian for all j < n(in particular if Hj a(M)is weakly Laskerian for allj < n), a finite set. (See also [7, Corollary < nare weakly Laskerian (inparticular if MandHj a(M)for allj < nare a finite set. (Compare with [9, that Ass R(Hn a(M)) = Ass We use the exact By 2.1 (a), Ker fis weakly Laskerian. (b) By 2.1 (b), Coker fis weakly that a homogeneous graded noetherian a graded R-module. The module Mis said to have (a) the property of asymptotic stablity of associated primes if there exists an integer n0such that Ass R0(Mn) = Ass R0(Mn0) for alln<=n0. (b) the property of asymptotic stablity of supports if there exists an integern0such that SuppR0(Mn) = SuppR0(Mn0) for alln<=n0.6 MOHARRAM AGHAPOURNAHR AND LEIF MELKERSSON (c) the property of tameness ifMi= 0 for all i <<0 or else 0 for alli <<0. Note that if Mhas the property of (a) then Mhas the property of (b) and if Mhas the property of (b) then Mis tame i.e. has the property of (c). Letsbe a non-negative integer. In order to refine and complete [6, Theorem 4.4] we study the asymptotic behaviour of the kernel a nd cokernel of the natural homomorphism between the graded modu and Hom For more information see also [3]. Definition 3.1. A graded module Mover a homogeneous graded ring Ris called asymptotically zero if Mi= 0 for all i <<0. All finite graded R-modules are asymptotically zero. Theorem 3.2. Assume that Mis a graded R-module and let sbe a fixed non-negative integer such that the < s are asymptotically zero (e.g. they might be finite ). Then the kernel and the cokernel of the natural homomorphism f: asymptotically zero. Therefore one of the properties of (a),(b)and(c)if and only if that the class of asymptotically zero graded modules is Serre subcategory of the category of graded R-modules and use 2.1 (c). J. Asadollahi, K. Khashyarmanesh, Sh. Salarian, A generalization of the cofiniteness problem in local cohomology modules , J. Aust. Math. Soc. 75 (2003), 313-324 2. J. Asadollahi and P. Schenzel, Some results on associated primes of local coho- mology modules , Japan. J. Math. 29(2003), 285-296. 3. M.P. Brodmann, Asymptotic behavior of cohomology : tameness, supports and associated primes, to appear in Contemporary Mathematics: Proceedings of the international conference in Mathematics, Bangalore / India , M.P. Brodmann, Ch. Rotthaus, R.Y. Sharp, On annihilators and of local cohomology modules . J. Pure Appl. Algebra 153(2000), 197- 227.LOCAL COHOMOLOGY 7 5. M.P. Brodmann, R.Y Sharp, Local cohomology: an algebraic introduction with geometric applications , Cambridge University Press, 1998. 6. M.T. Dibaei, A. Nazari, Graded local cohomology: attached and , asymptotic behaviors , Comm.Alg. 35(2007), 1567-1576. 7. M.T. Dibaei, S. Yassemi, Associated primes of the local cohomology modules . Abelian groups, rings, modules, and homological algebra, 49-56, Ch apman and Hall/CRC, 2006. 8. M.T . Dibaei, S. Yassemi, Associated primes and cofiniteness of local cohomol- ogy modules , manuscripta math, 117(2005), 199-205. 9. K. Divaani-Aazar, A. Mafi, Associated primes of local cohomology modules , Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 133(2005), 199-205. 10. A. Grothendieck, Cohomologie locale des faisceaux coh 'erents et th 'eor`emes de Lefschetz locaux et globaux (SGA 2) , North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1968. 11. R.Hartshorne, Affine duality and cofiniteness , Invent.Math. C.Huneke, Problems on local cohomology and algebraic geometry, (Sundance, UT, 1990), 93-108, Jon es and T. Marley, The associated primes of local cohomology modules over ring s of small dimension , manuscripta math. 104(2001), 519-525 14. L. Melkersson, Modules cofinite with respect to an ideal , J. Algebra. J. Rotman, An introduction to homological algebra , Academic Press, 1979. Moharram Aghapournahr, Faculty of Mathematical Sciences, Teacher Training University, 599 Taleghani Avenue, Tehran 15614, I ran. E-mail address Melkersson, Department of Mathematics, Link oping Univer- sity, S-581 83 Link oping, Sweden. E-mail address
|
0807.2967
|
Moharram Aghapournahr
|
Moharram Aghapournahr and Leif Melkersson
|
Local cohomology: Associated primes, artinianness and asymptotic
behaviour
|
7 pages
| null | null | null |
math.AC math.AG
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
Let $R$ be a noetherian ring, $\fa$ an ideal of $R$, $M$ an $R$--module and
$n$ a non-negative integer.
In this paper we first will study the finiteness properties of the kernel and
the cokernel of the natural map $f:\Ext^n_{R}(R/\fa,M)\lo
\Hom_{R}(R/\fa,\lc^{n}_{\fa}(M))$. Then we will get some corollaries about the
associated primes and artinianness of local cohomology modules. Finally we will
study the asymptotic behaviour of the kernel and the cokernel of this natural
map in the graded case.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 18 Jul 2008 13:01:16 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Mon, 21 Jul 2008 07:45:11 GMT"
}
] | 2008-07-21T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Aghapournahr",
"Moharram",
""
],
[
"Melkersson",
"Leif",
""
]
] |
2 G.G. In the literature, it is said that the problem of massive sta rs about 8-10M, the star's h alt any furtherin-fall of matter onto the protostar (Larson &Starfield1971; Kahn1974; Wolfire cumulatedmass 8-10M for anystar in the maybefortun ately)thisis not what we observe.It there- fore means that some process(es) responsible for the format ion of stars beyond the work.A solutionto theproblemmust besoughtbecau exists. If this is the case, i.e.the radiation problemreally did exist as stated above,and o ur formationmodelthatovercomesthe problemwhile star to form (accumulate all of its mass) before it exhaus ts its nuclear fuel. Two such have been set-forth: ( 1) the Accelerated Accretion Model (AAM) (Yorke 2002,2004) and, (Bonnellet al. Bonnell&Bate 2002). The latter scenario, the CM, is born out of the observational fact that massive stars are generally found in the centers of dense clusters (see e.g.Hillenbrand 1997; Clarke et al. 2000). In these probabilityof the CM. This modeleasilyby-passestheproblemand, date has confirmed it (directly or indirectly), it [CM] app ears1to be the most natural mechanism by which massive stars form given the said observational fact a bout massive stars and their AAM is just a scaled up version of the accepted accretion p aradigm applicable to Low accretion cannot take place at the same steady rate as in t he case of LMSs ( M <=3M) but must be accelerated and significantly higher. While there exists many examplesof massive stars surrounded by accretiondisks, oneof the chief obstaclesin verifyingt hisparadigmis that examplesofHMSs tend to be relatively distant ( >1kpc), deeply embedded, and confused with other emission sou rces (see e.g.Mathews et al. 2007). Additionally, HMSs evolve rapidly, and by the time an unob structed view of the young star emerges, the disk and outflow structures may have been destroyed. ed(e.g.Mathewset al. kaphysicalmechanismthatovercomes theproblemashasbeenconductedbythea toRayle Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities allow fingers of dense ga s to break into the evacuated bubbles and reach the stellar surface while in addition, outflows from ma ssive stars create optically thin cavities in the accreting envelope.These fromt he bulk of the gas andreduce the final size of massive stars and accretion will proceed, al beit at much higher rates. Amongst others, the model by the al. ( 2005,2009) is ad hoc rather than natural, in that Naturehas to makea suc ha way thatmassive starshavea wayof starting their normal stellar processes. Does there not exi st a smooth and natural way to bring on the assumption that our understanding of grav itation and radiation transport is complete.The RadiationProblem ofMassive StarsRevisited 3 In this reading, we redefine the radiation problem (for the sp herically symmetric case) and we do thisviaa subtle and in the analysis lead ingto the radiation surely, this is clearly not true. The researchers Yorke 2002; Yorke&Sonnhalter 2002; Zinnecker &Yorke2007; thatfroma is stronger than the gravitational field for massive sta rs hence the in-fall process of material tr. In practice, stars are found embedded inside a significant ma ss of gas and dust. The radiation inthe studyoft thus,it od. Having taken into considerationthe circumstellar materia l, we find that at ~8-10M, the radi- ation field will not reverse the radial in-fall of matter but r ather a stalemate between the radiation field will be achieved, where in-fall is halte d but not reversed. Certainly, this picture is not at all congruent (or somewhere near there) to the common p icture that is accepted in the where at ~8-10M, all the circumstellar material, from the surface of the sta r right up to the edge of the molecular cloud core, is expected to be swep t away by the powerful radiation field. This finding is not a complete but rather a partial solution to the radiation problem in that beyond 8-10Mlimit. A to note is that this is for a sphericall where field only has the radial dependence and is exa ctly described by Newton's inverse square law. In a different reading, Nyambuya ( 2010a), an Azimuthally Symmetric Theory of was set-up and thereby a thesis was set-forth to the ef fect that: ( 1) for a non-spinning star, its gravitational field is spherically symmetric, so it depe nds on the radial distance from the central body; (2) for a spinning gravitating body, the gravitational field of the body in question is In a Nyambuya( 2010b), it has beenshown that the ASTG of a spinning gravitating body, gravity will c hannel matter onto the spinning nascent star viathe spin-equatorial disk without radiation having to rever se this inflow, thus allowing stars mass the ASTG proves itself, then the present reading together with Nyambuya ( 2010a,2010b) com- prise (in our view) a solution to the radiation problem. Give n that the solution to this problem has been sought viasophisticated computer simulations and lengthy numerical solutions, and perhaps this reading presents not only my misunder standing of the problem, but also of the approach to the problem. But more on the optimistic side of th ings, I believe the radiation problem much that we hold the objective view that to they [i.e. othe r researchers] that seek a solution to THERADIATION (1)4 G.G. Nyambuya wherec= 2.99792458 x108ms-1is the speed oflight in a vacuum, G= Newton's universal constant of gravitation, keffis the effective opacity which is the measure of the gas' state of being opaque or a measure of the gas' impervious ness to light rays and is measured in m2kg-1. This analysis by Yorke ( 2002), which is also reproduced in Zinnecker &Yorke (2007), is assumesspherical symmetryand,at the same time, it phenomenon(see e.g.reviewsby Zinnecker &Yorke2007; but this simple calculation suffices in as far as defining the curtain-region of 8-10Mwhen is expectedto becomea significant playe r in the star's formation.What will be shallmakeou rcase basedonthe this calculation by Yorke ( 2002) and Zinnecker &Yorke (2007), proceeds as fol- lows: the inequality ( 1), sets a maximum condition for accretion of material, namel in solar units. Given that, Lstar(t) =L(Mstar(t)/M)3, (3) Now, given that the dusty Interstellar Medium's (ISM) avera ged opacity is measured to be and using this (as an estimate to setting the minimum critic al mass, see Yorke2002; Zinnecker &Yorke2007), we find that this sets a minimum upper mass limit for stars the molecular cloud material is what sets the critical mas s, thus a cloud of lower opacity will have a higher critical mass. It is expected that the opacity insid e the cloud will be lower than in the ISM. keff= 2002;Zinnecker set a minimum lower bound for massive stars. Dust and gas op acities are significantly expectedto lfield. As can be found in Yorke ( 2002), the AAM finds some of its ground around the alteration of the opacity.For example,if the opacityinside the gascloudis s than the ISM one of the its options that optical and Ultra-Violet (UV) r adiation inside the accreting material is shifted from the optical/UV into the far Infrared (IR) and al so that the opacity may be lower than opacity,or findinga ph opacity to values lower than the ISM, is a viable solution to the radia tion problem. The above mechanism onment. Now that we have presented the radiation problem as it is comm only understood, we are ready equalityisfieldintensityforagravitatingbodyinempt of this same star in empty space. From this, clearly, we a re actually comparing the radiation fieldintensityofastarinemptyspace,where thisverysimpl istic, RadiationProblem ofMassive StarsRevisited thandsideof( ( 1987) among others, have performedthis calculation where they h ave taken into account the circumstellar material and reached similar con clusions (as e.g.those of Yorke 2002). We reach a different conclusion to that of Wolfire &Cassinelli ( 1987) because, unlike these researchers, we use the observational fact that molecular clouds and mole cular cores are found exhibiting a rr-ar, andfromthis, we calculate a generalmass distribution( M trengthsatpoint RADIATION AND THECIRCUMSTELLAR thermal, magnetic effects, turbulence and any o ther forces (as will be shown latter in this section, these forces do not change the essence of our argume nt, hence we do not need to worry about them here) and considering only the gravitational and radia tion field from the nascent star, we assume here that a star is formed from a gravitationally bound syste m of material enclosed in a volume space of radius Rcore(t)and we shall call this system of material the core and further assume that this core shall havea Mcoreat all times. Now,aslongasthe the sphe re ofradius r <Rcore(t)is (4) then, radiation pressure will not exceed the gravitational force in the region r <Rcore(t), thus timetenclosed in the region stretching from the surface of the sta r to the radius r, then,M(r,t) =
Mcsl(r,t) +Mstar(t). Hence, the difference between ( 4) and (1) is that in ( 4) we have included (5) which basically says as long as the amount of matter enclosed in the regionof sphere radius r. In fact, (5) is the Eddingtonlimit applied to the region of radius r. This is identical to equation ( 10) ( 1987). In their work, Wolfire &Cassinelli ( 1987) solve numericallythe problem to determine the effective opacity at the o uter edge of the massive star forming ( probetheconditio &Cassinelli( to study the radiation problemwhere sophisticated com used. Ours is a simple and na ive approach needing no comp uter simulations nor numerical codes. We shall insert M(r,t) main thrust is to seek valuesof rin the satisfy it. We shall do this by fin ding a formfor doing this, let us apply ( 5) to the entire core, that is r=Rcore. This must give us the condition when the star's radiation field is strong enough to sweep away all the circumstellar material from the surface of the star right up to the outer edge of the co re. In doing so, one finds that the G.G. to increase until the star reaches a critical lumin osity determined by the mass of the core. luminosityby L*
core. Fromtheabove,it (8) With radiationfield to globally lfield,the luminosityofth ivenbyLstar(t) Lstar(t) =L*
corewill (10) Giventhis andtaking keff= pluggingthese and the (11) where we have set Mstar=Mmax. As we already said, using keff= 20.0m2kg-1gives us the minimum lower bound. What this means is that the mass of the co re from which a star is formed may very well be crucial in deciding the final mass of the star beca use the mass of the core determines andratherna cane rateofabout ofabout 0.1%.A104Mcoreis basicallya produ not form stars. In reality, some of the material in this 104Mcore will form many other a 100Mstar will form in a GMC of mass about 107M. The above deductions, that high mass stars will need to form in clouds of mass >=104M, is in resonance with the that massive stars are not found in isolation ( e.g.Hillenbrand 1997; Clarke et al. 2000) since opulation of stars is related to the total mass of the parentcloud fromw hich the stellar populationhas beenborn. That is to say, if Mclis the mass of a molecular cloud and Mmaxis the maximum stellar mass of RadiationProblem ofMassive StarsRevisited 7 whereM0= 13.2MandaL= 0.430. This law was obtained from a sample of molecular clouds whose masses are in the range Larson's Law is thoughtto be a result of statistical sampling but we are not persuaded to think tha t this is the case; such a coincidence is, betrue.We believe Larson'sLawis researchers; it is telling us something about the underla ying dynamics of star formation. This have a deviation of about 33%and the constant M0has a similar deviation of about 33%. ideal situation where we have considered not the other for ces, such as the magnetic, thermal forces etc, but also we formationasa spherically which it is not,and this may also be a source of correction to this result in order to bring it into agreement with llthematerialtoasinglepointbutratheraid thein must writeInequality( (14) wheremis the averagemass ofthe molecularspecies ofthe materialc (15) andwriting M'(r,t) =r2|Fother|/m,we will (16) From this, it is clear that the other forces will act in a manne r as to reduce the critical luminosity of the core. Thus our result ( 11), when compared to natural reality where these other forces are present, is expected to show that deviation from the real observation s must occur. As stated in the opening of this section, the inclusion of the magnetic and thermal forc es,etc, will not change the essence of our argument, hence the above argument justifies why we did not ha ve to worry about these other forces because the essence of our result still stands. The situatio n is only critical when these other the same result as ( 5). Additionally and more importantly, we are able to compute the boundaries where the radiation field will be strong enough to overcometh e gravitational field. Among other onfield MASS DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION First, we compute the enclosed mass M(r,t). We know that stellar systems such as molecular y: r(r,t) time aris the sbare8 G.G. Nyambuya form, the power law ( 17) as it stands implies an infinite density at r= 0. In general, power laws have this property. Obviously, one has to deal with this. The usua l or typical way is to impose a minimum valuefor so it will betime density function( 17) into the aboveintegraland then evaluatingthe resultant i (19) and this formula does not apply to the case ar= 3. This is valid for 0<=ar<3. The case ar= 3 is described by a special MDF which is M(r,t) We shall will ument. Now, what we shall do here is to constrain arand show that: 0<=ar<3. This exercise is being conducted to define the domain in which our result has physica l significance. First we shall we shall doby usingthe methodof proofby contradict ion.Let (r2> r1). M(r2)>M(r1)] one would expect to have more matter in a bigger sphere of radius r2than that enclosed in a smaller sphere of radius r1. Therefore, our condition is: [ r2> r1== M(r2)- M(r1)>=0]. Using equation( 19), a so doing,we will have: and this implies r3-ar 2< r2. (21) Thisisa lcondition[ r2> r1== M(r2)>M(r1)] as this is saying [ r2< r1== M(r2)>M(r1)] which is certainly wrong. From a purely we are therefore forced to conclude that ar<3if the condition [ r2> r1== M(r2)>
M(r1)]is tohold- unphysical because gravity is an attractive inverse dist ance law and thus will always pack more and more material in the center than in the outer regions. Hence, the only material configuration that can emergefrom this setting is one in which the averagedensity o f material decreasesas one zoomsout of the cloud. This implies 3-ar<=3which leads to ar>=0. Thus combining the two results, we are goingtohave: ofile. Now we have to normalize the MDF by imposing some boundary con ditions. The usual or M(rmin,t) = the mass of the central star, hence rmin(t) =Rstar(t). Thus whatwe havedoneis thecavitywhi ourMDF as:The RadiationProblem ofMassive StarsRevisited 9 M(r,t) Rstar(t)<=r<= Rcore(t). Now, if the mass enclosed inside the core remains constant th roughout, then we must have at r=Rcore(t)the boundary condition M(Rcore,t) =Mcore. We know that the sum total of all Mcsl(t) =Mcore-Mstar(t). Combiningall =Circumstellar Material in Region Radius of the nascent sta/bracehtipdownright Mstar(t)forr>= Rstar(t).(24) We shall take this as the final form of our mass distribution fu nction. If the reader accepts this, then what followsis a straight leads to what we believe is a significant step forwardin the resolution of the radiation problem. The reader may want to query that we have overstretched let us consider a serene molecular core long before a s tar begins to form at the center. We know that the density is not a fundamental physical quantity but a physical quantity derived from quantitieswhich are mass and volume, i.e., must a quantity derived from two fundamental quantities, sug gests that at any given time the mass that that mass has a radial dependency.The relati we must have M(r,t) M(0,t) = M(Rcore,t) must),thenwe will have >0. (25) Now, if the density profile is to fall off as rincreases as is the case in Nature, then (a-3<=0) which implies ( a<=3). Combining this with ( a>=0) we will have ( 0<=a<=3). Comparingthis with the profile ( rr-ar), we have: ( -ar=a-3) and substituting this into ( 0<=a<=3), one From (3-ar<=3), we have ( ar>=0), and from ( 0<=3-ar), we have ( in this serene molecular cloud, a small lamp begins to fo rm; let this lamp have a mass Mlamp. I shall pose a question: do we expect this lamp to cause any fu the mass distribution M(r,t) =ara+b? I think not. If this is the case, then our mass nowbe defined up to the radiusof the lamp, M(Rlamp,t) =Mlampand this Rlamp(t). (26)10 G.G. Nyambuya where we have substituted a= 3-ar. Now inserting the condition that M(Rcore,t) =Mcore, we will Rlamp(t). willhave: M(r,t) =Mcore-Mlamp(t). Comparison of the above with ( 24) shows that the lamp in in( 24). We are certain that the reader will have no problem with ( 28) because the lamp does not disrupt the mass distribution since it has no radiation. Hence, we wo uld expect a continuous distribution of mass right up to the surface of the lamp as material will be flow ing into the lamp. However, this same lamp is a protostar and at somepointit must switch on to becom e a star. At this moment,assuming the correctness of the thesis that at 8-10M, the radiation field begins to push material away from the nascent star, we could from logic expect that the mass distri bution must be continuousup till that time when disruption starts at 8-10M. During the time when the lamp's (or protostar's) mass is in t he range0<= Mlamp(t)<8-10M, the MDF ( 28) must hold. From this, we have just justified the formula ( 24) for the mass range: 0<= Mstar(t)<8-10M. When the radiation field begins to shall haveto star,will =Circumstellar /bracehtipdownright/parenleftbiggGMstar(t) r2/parenrightbigg
^r.(29) Clearly, we have been able to separate the gravitation due to the star from that due to the RADIATION CAVITY The inequality ( 5) gives us a condition that must be met before the radiation fie ld is powerful enough that it can push away (all) the circumstellar material insid e the shell of radius r. Beyond this radius, the radiation field is not at all powerful enough to overcomet he gravitational field. radius rfrom(5). Theinequality( 30), as does( 5) and (30) tells usthe conditionsto be met beforethe radiationfield is powerfulenoughto halt in -fall. In additionto this, ( 30) yields 5)becausein( deducethat will createa cavityin th e thiscavity, ismuchstrongerthanthegravitationalfi bea RadiationProblem ofMassive StarsRevisited in-fall is not reversed but only halted) becau se when the radiation field tries to create a cavity in which process the star is separated from it s accretion source which is thereexistsno otherchannel(s) viawhichits mass feeds.Shouldthe star's mass fall below ~8-10M, the circumstellar material will fall onto the nascent star until its mass is restored to its previous value of ~8-10M. In order for the radiation field to start pushing the circumstellar material, its mass must exc eed~8-10M. Since there is no way to do this, in-fall is only halted and not reversed. Hen ce, the star's mass for a non- spinning star stays constant at ~8-10M. As urged in Nyambuya ( 2010b), this scenario is different for a spinning star because the ASGF (which come s about due the spin of the nascent star) allows matter to continue accreting viathe equatorial disk inside the cavity as illustrated above. The accretion disk will exist inside the radiation cavity and, according nascentstar right-upto thesurfaceofthe star vity.Tosee that( write( the radius of the cavity. Now that there is a cavity, let us p ause so that we can revise theMDF. st Rcav(t).(32)12 G.G. time thecavityat time r <Rcav(t)wherewillreverse the radially in-falling material and in the region r >Rcav(t), for material therein, the radiation state whereit ld. that regionhas not been achieved. This region [ i.e.r <Rcav(t)] grows with time thus the radiation field slowly Rcav(t) The condition when the critical core luminosity has been sh own earlier leads to ( 12) which is cordofthebattleofforcesbetweengravitation and. By saying that the nascent massive star will create a cavity, we have made a tacit and growwhile in the cavity. However,ho w can this be since the cavity star from the circumstellar matter? The nascent sta r now does not have a channel to feed its mass, so there can be no growth in its mass unless there exists a channel viawhich its mass feeds. readingsNyambuya Nyambuya ( 2010a), as already said in the introductory section, we set-up the ASTG such (to be specific, it only depends on the radial dista nce from the central body); ( 2) that, for of the bo dyin questionis i.e., it depends on the radial distance ( r) from the central body and the azimuthal angle ( th). In a a purely gravitational phenomenon ( i.e., a repulsive gravitational phenomenon) and also that; ( 2) along the spin-equator (defined Nyambuya 2010b) of a spinning gravitating body, gravity will wing stars beyond the critical mass 8-10Mto form and begin their stellar processes. It should be (ASGF). The accretion of matter beyond the 8-10Mlimit must only be possible for a spinning star because it possesses the ASGF that is needed to continue the c hannelingof matter onto the star viathe accretion disk - see the illustration in figure ( 1). For a non-spinning core, the nascent stars's accretion cannot proceed beyond 8-10M. It is halted because the moment the radiation field tries to c reate a cavity, when the mass is 8-10M, the that very moment becomes separated from the surrounding circumstellar mate rial. This means the (non-spinning) star's mass accretion is halted because its mass can no longer grow s ince there exists no other channel(s) via which its mass feeds. Should the (non-spinning) star's mass fall below 8-10M, the will fall onto the nascent unt il its mass is restored to its previous value the above paragraphs, this scenario is different for a spi nning star because the ASGF (which comes about due to the spin of the nascent star) allows matter to con tinue accreting viathe equatorial disk. The accretion disk will exist inside the radiation cavity an d this disk should according to the ASTG (Nyambuya 2010b), channel mass right up to the surface of the star without rad iation hindrances. suddenly the radiation is so powerful that it reverses any f urther in-fall. It is beyond the 8-10Mlimit must form with no hindrance, form the radiation field an d the only limit RadiationProblem ofMassive StarsRevisited 13 6 DISCUSSION contribution coupled with Nyambuya ( 2010b) seem to strongly point to the possibility that the radiation problemof massive stars may not exist as previous ly thought.In the present reading,we find that beginningat the time when Mstar(t)8-10M, the radiation field will create a cavity inside the star formingcore andthe the region Rcav(t)< r<= Rcore(t)is going to be pushed gradually (in particular, not blown away) as the radiation field from the star grows until a point is reached when the cavity is the size of the core itsel f. At this point, complete in-fall reversal is attained. If the radiation field of the star is to grow, its m ass must grow, thus, the cavity must is created, the mass of the nascent will, for a spinnin g massive star; feed viathe accretion disk and this disk is not affected by the radiation field. By saying the disk is not affected by the awaybyasitpushes the other material away because the azimuthally symmetric g ravitational field of the star is powerful enough along this plane to overcome the radiation field. This has been shown or argued in Nyambuya (2010b) to the ASTG, have the potential to grow to higher ma sses. This means massive stars should start their stellar processes because of their spin which br ings about the much needed ASGF. A non- spinning star will have no ASGF, hence there will be no disk ar ound it to channel material once the radiation field begins taking its toll. In this case of a non-s pinning star, once the star has reached the critical mass ~8-10M, its mass cannot grow any further because at the moment it tri es to etowhich,inthiscase,is strongerthanthe.Inthisevent,anyfur fact, means that as long as there is circumstellar materia l, the mass of a non-spinning star will stay constant at ~8-10Mbecause, the moment it falls slightly below ~8-10M, gravity becomes more powerful,thus accreting only enoughmass to restore it to its previousvalue of ~8-10M. In thiscase,we gravit importantand subtle present work and that of Kahn1974; Wolfire &Cassinelli 1987; Yorke&Sonnhalter 2003) is that we have seized on the observational fact that molecu lar clouds and cores are found exhibiting well defined density pr ofiles. From this we computed the MDF which enabled us to exactly find the physical boundaries wher e the gravitational field is expected to be much stronger than the radiation field once the star exceed the critical mass. Additionally and more importantly is that from Nyambuya ( 2010b) we have been able to argue that even after the cavity has been created mass will be channeled on to the star viathe accretion disk. Without the ideas presented in Nyambuya ( 2010b), we would have been stuck because we where going to find ourse lves without ca have pointed out a real problem in Yorke ( 2002), Yorke&Sonnhalter ( 2003) and Zinnecker &Yorke (2007), namely that these researchers have neglected the treatme nt of the used law which clearly applies to a non-rotatingmass in emptyspace, so the inequality ( 4) applies only for a star in empty space. In empty space, it is c orrect to say that the radiation field for a star of mass 10Mand beyond,will exceed the gravitational field everywhere i n space beyond the nascent star's surface, but the same is not t rue for a star submerged in a pool of forthestarsthat important outcome is that it appears Larson's Laws m ay well be a signature and fossil record of the battle of forces between the radiation and grav itational fields. At present, it is thought of as being a result of statistical sampling. Thusthe present b ringsus to start rethinkingthis view. We are not persuaded to think this is a result of statistical sampli ng. This view finds support from Weidner et al. (2009)'s most recent and excitingwork.In this work,these resear cherspresenta of the most-massive stars in several young star cluste rs in order to assess whether or not star14 G.G. are populated from the stellar initial mass functi on (IMF) by random sampling over the mass range (0.01M<= Mstar<=150M) without being constrained by the cluster mass. Their data reveal a partition of the sample into lowest mass objects ( Mcl<=100M), moderate mass clusters (100M<= Mcl<=1000M) and rich clusters above ( Mcl>=1000M) whereMclis the mass closing, allow us to say that we do not claim to have solved t he radiation problem but merely believe that what we have presented herein, together with th e readings Nyambuya ( 2010b,2010a), is work that may very well be a significant step forward in the e ndeavor to resolve this massive :I am gratefulto my brother,Baba vaPanashe,and his wife, Amai kind hospitality they offered while working on this re ading and to Mr. Isak D. Davids &Ms. grammar,spellin I am very grateful to my Professor, D. Johan van der Wal t, and Professor Pienaar Kobus, for I. A.,BateM., Zinnecker H., 1998, MNRAS, 298,93 Bonnell I. A.,Clarke C.J.,Bate M.R.,Pringle J.E., 2001, MNRAS, 324,573 Bonnell I. A.,BateM. R., 2002, MNRAS, 336,659 Bonnell I. R., 2004, MNRAS, 349,735 Bonnell I. A.,Clarke C.J.,Bate M.R., 2006, MNRAS, I. A., Larson, R. B., & Zinnecker, H. 2007, Protosta rs and Planets V, ed. V. B. Reipurth, D. Jewitt, & K. Keil(Tucson, AZ:Univ. Arizona Press),149 (arXiv:0603447 ) Clarke C.J.,Bonnell I.A.,Hillenbrand L.A., 2000, Protostarsand PlanetsIV, 151 Hillenbrand L.A., 1997, C.F.et al., 2005, Science, 323,754 Krumholz M. R., Klein R. I., McKee C. F., Offner S. S. R., Cunni ngham A. J., 2005, Protostars and Planets F.D., 1974, 1972, MNRAS,156, 437 LarsonR.B., 1982, MNRAS, &StarrfieldS., 1971, A.,Behrend R., 2002, ASPConf. Ser., 267,179 Matthews L.D., Goddi C.,Greenhill L. J.,Chandler C. J.,Rei d M. J.&Humphreys E. M. L., 2007, and (IAU Symp. 242), ed. J.M. Chapman Kluwer), 130 McKee 2007, G.G., 2010a,MNRAS,403, Issue 3,1381. Nyambuya G.G., 1993, 1977, Bulletinof the Amer. Astron.Soc., 8,547 ShuF.H., 1977, H. W., 2002, ASPConf. Series, Bourke (Dordrecht: Kluwer), 141The RadiationProblem ofMassive StarsRevisited 15 Yorke H. W. &Kr ugel,1977, A&A,54,183 Yorke H. W.,Sonnhalter, 2002, C.,Kroupa P.,Bonnell I.A. D., 2009, MNRAS,401, 275. WolfireM. G.,CassinelliJ. P., 1987, H.& Yorke H. W., 2007, was prepared with the RAA L ATEX macro v1.2.
|
0807.3035
|
Golden Gadzirayi Nyambuya Mr.
|
G. G. Nyambuya
|
On the Radiation Problem of High Mass Stars
|
Published: Research in Astron. Astrophys. 2010 Vol. 10 No. 11,
1137-1150 (14 pages, 1 figure)
| null | null | null |
physics.gen-ph
|
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
|
We use the Azimuthally Symmetric Theory of Gravitation (set-forth in
arXiv:0912.2966 and further advanced in viXra:0911.0025) to argue that massive
stars must be able to form via the accretion disk without much problems.
|
[
{
"version": "v1",
"created": "Fri, 18 Jul 2008 19:24:42 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v2",
"created": "Mon, 17 Nov 2008 15:54:26 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v3",
"created": "Thu, 28 Jan 2010 00:04:13 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v4",
"created": "Wed, 10 Mar 2010 14:59:19 GMT"
},
{
"version": "v5",
"created": "Mon, 18 Oct 2010 06:53:41 GMT"
}
] | 2010-10-19T00:00:00 |
[
[
"Nyambuya",
"G. G.",
""
]
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.