id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00378v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00378v2 | An Empirical Study on the Transferability of Transformer Modules in Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2023-02-01T11:20:18 | 2023-02-22T16:56:58 | Mohammad Akbar-Tajari, Sara Rajaee, Mohammad Taher Pilehvar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning approaches have recently garnered a lot of
attention. Having considerably lower number of trainable weights, these methods
can bring about scalability and computational effectiveness. In this paper, we
look for optimal sub-networks and investigate the capability of different
transformer modules in transferring knowledge from a pre-trained model to a
downstream task. Our empirical results suggest that every transformer module in
BERT can act as a winning ticket: fine-tuning each specific module while
keeping the rest of the network frozen can lead to comparable performance to
the full fine-tuning. Among different modules, LayerNorms exhibit the best
capacity for knowledge transfer with limited trainable weights, to the extent
that, with only 0.003% of all parameters in the layer-wise analysis, they show
acceptable performance on various target tasks. On the reasons behind their
effectiveness, we argue that their notable performance could be attributed to
their high-magnitude weights compared to that of the other modules in the
pre-trained BERT. | [
0.0093266582,
0.0177949686,
-0.0133009627,
0.0278039761,
-0.001502606,
0.0076574828,
0.0270869043,
-0.0370752327,
-0.0588846132,
-0.0105883777,
-0.0651040897,
0.0316848829,
-0.019900959,
0.0148907593,
0.0501364507,
-0.0651126951,
0.0215955433,
0.0017899002,
-0.0349706449,
-0.0137582878,
-0.0232141744,
-0.0368543863,
-0.0006691493,
0.0467316508,
0.0196615979,
0.0447294116,
-0.0335717909,
0.0268955175,
0.0573223978,
0.0351105481,
0.0330090038,
0.0503063016,
-0.0002316356,
0.0118944962,
0.0000019699,
0.0017710647,
-0.0287413783,
0.0002470413,
-0.0058612493,
0.0317567587,
-0.0094052544,
0.0218152553,
-0.0152447717,
0.0058402433,
-0.0116327554,
0.0105459215,
0.0752689019,
0.0639645606,
0.0674495175,
0.0922561586,
-0.0092062475,
-0.0138405403,
0.0254931804,
-0.0266383365,
-0.0301852133,
-0.0524412654,
0.0394541658,
-0.0371703319,
-0.0345826671,
-0.0589176416,
-0.0222997405,
0.0160216466,
0.0104449308,
0.0192990787,
0.0373096392,
0.0107405446,
-0.0800644308,
0.0012238341,
-0.0180360451,
0.0553704016,
-0.0963049084,
0.0066488869,
-0.0052909846,
-0.0164831113,
-0.0093658688,
0.0261347368,
-0.020432774,
-0.0295189265,
0.0026672736,
0.0177475214,
-0.0438533053,
-0.0370504707,
0.0305380952,
-0.0033789356,
-0.0750122964,
0.0320652351,
0.0241174512,
-0.0014395595,
0.0053802826,
-0.0125610596,
-0.0422700159,
-0.0306627303,
0.0261486024,
0.0293218065,
0.013231203,
-0.0358022526,
-0.0512692742,
-0.0292827506,
-0.0371962413,
-0.0169488806,
0.0731441155,
0.0172911026,
-0.0245173927,
0.0216343403,
-0.0931606293,
0.0460860059,
-0.0321920402,
0.0567533635,
-0.0266024973,
-0.0278976895,
-0.0605064817,
0.0351763703,
-0.0928135365,
0.0496830977,
0.002492575,
-0.0189798605,
-0.0496577471,
0.0184785705,
0.0002323075,
-0.0314559229,
0.0085338419,
0.0089132302,
-0.0307881236,
-0.0098117841,
0.014302629,
0.0571583137,
-0.014387018,
0.0361630321,
0.0001579973,
0.0031757159,
-0.0077471687,
-0.0013118688,
0.0230450183,
-0.0105693098,
0.0515866652,
0.0454513282,
-0.0306023918,
-0.0412595533,
-0.0455874056,
0.0379647315,
0.0070019914,
-0.0258698743,
0.0309861582,
-0.0209301412,
-0.0036084522,
0.0023458742,
0.0109735373,
0.0211357549,
-0.0097500663,
-0.052102834,
-0.0415992737,
0.0426217951,
0.0129977455,
0.0002786033,
0.0133316126,
-0.0009206788,
-0.0570626929,
0.0411404595,
0.0471913666,
0.0500382967,
-0.0197853222,
-0.0685558841,
-0.0141607374,
0.0387767591,
0.0189981703,
0.0048505049,
-0.0148303797,
-0.0416377597,
-0.0043200762,
-0.008004793,
0.0031421238,
-0.0149775958,
-0.05136149,
0.0182204749,
0.080197826,
0.0046166196,
0.0732591674,
0.0729423985,
-0.0013295443,
-0.0389863029,
0.0266477261,
0.0027323777,
-0.0444571711,
0.049187813,
-0.0356435291,
-0.0454391688,
-0.022384122,
0.0563392974,
-0.0472755283,
-0.0020564282,
0.0342309996,
-0.0041409801,
-0.0104887784,
-0.026817577,
0.0539221615,
0.0104537867,
-0.0641419813,
0.0995012671,
0.0072761513,
-0.0108200787,
-0.0085770385,
-0.0817737356,
-0.0329916626,
0.0198998637,
0.0049929614,
-0.0325842761,
-0.0856823102,
0.0223609302,
0.0242330059,
-0.0132665718,
0.0370910428,
0.027934866,
0.0406197757,
-0.0351642556,
-0.0314905383,
-0.0166429337,
0.0027861495,
0.032545872,
-0.0130990855,
-0.0108459042,
-0.0019776099,
-0.0110693723,
-0.0038404514,
0.0016076837,
0.0076203388,
-0.0155334603,
0.0061546694,
0.0316753052,
0.0319912508,
-0.0267819464,
-0.0402050801,
-0.0361401662,
-0.0024769935,
-0.0325721204,
-0.0141208712,
-0.000858868,
-0.016092902,
0.0207804926,
-0.0088364268,
-0.0630615577,
0.0374011509,
0.0641388223,
-0.0407412462,
-0.0530691072,
0.0176296178,
-0.0323820151,
0.0439665392,
-0.0188659132,
0.0180539973,
-0.0336089544,
-0.0131058432,
-0.0113517931,
0.0168146864,
0.0057989322,
-0.0302981865,
0.0103989383,
0.0071222493,
0.0076485281,
-0.0079269502,
-0.0189757943,
-0.0021879463,
-0.0100139296,
0.0167229231,
0.0226916,
-0.0092665199,
0.0048406878,
-0.0778823793,
-0.0753447264,
0.0257602315,
-0.0290396158,
0.045217704,
0.0281433817,
0.0137207583,
0.0083018914,
0.0198952612,
-0.0125675024,
0.0497523919,
-0.0442162305,
-0.0218481738,
0.0202503353,
0.0114555666,
-0.0435658805,
-0.0367696621,
-0.018990485,
0.0268693306,
0.0398887806,
-0.005182968,
0.0108678024,
-0.0308009628,
-0.0504652895,
0.0004322886,
0.0373141468,
-0.0066024065,
-0.1002112851,
-0.0299896579,
-0.0121719744,
0.0014402597,
0.0759107843,
0.0042171339,
-0.0161086954,
0.0090973713,
-0.0076398496,
-0.0241442118,
0.0409598947,
-0.0565331951,
-0.0179981142,
-0.0570744723,
0.0341015793,
0.0085359635,
0.0744547024,
-0.0339639448,
-0.0167352371,
-0.0719875693,
0.0083680507,
0.0352267809,
-0.0015076846,
0.0193308294,
-0.0125748748,
0.0065881857,
-0.0188050382,
-0.0339334719,
-0.032025937,
0.0452186391,
-0.0127751082,
0.0055508832,
-0.0185252633,
-0.0319998302,
-0.006075691,
-0.0199100059,
0.0188225582,
0.0362587795,
-0.015620118,
-0.0066627231,
-0.0587340333,
-0.0057679084,
0.0389871486,
-0.0028351578,
0.0225210693,
0.0081358394,
-0.0050021852,
-0.0210675262,
-0.0459374562,
-0.0119454907,
0.0232861321,
0.009503982,
0.0632578209,
0.0551973656,
-0.0617050193,
-0.0923204869,
0.0274354201,
0.0178493001,
0.0415550619,
-0.0378199145,
-0.0057916008,
-0.0259779673,
0.0056028948,
0.0019428683,
0.040666081,
0.0436956435,
-0.012197596,
0.0154398466,
-0.0196030531,
0.0147769293,
0.0088028777,
-0.0906214118,
0.0295881424,
-0.0132812345,
-0.0426691435,
-0.0303424094,
-0.004928201,
0.0657361597,
-0.0436195135,
0.0027707231,
0.0507414266,
-0.0103860293,
0.022213066,
0.0006957624,
0.017597001,
-0.0160832182,
-0.0022389735,
0.0497839414,
-0.0151903527,
-0.0296844523,
0.022121923,
0.0518600531,
-0.0064793983,
-0.0240040589,
0.0337006673,
-0.0533384867,
0.0369454771,
0.0161796995,
-0.0257762372,
-0.0329695232,
0.0030508484,
0.0058552204,
-0.0262823794,
-0.0115031302,
0.0014728913,
-0.0106968414,
-0.0445398465,
0.0467606038,
0.0199307986,
-0.0468601622,
0.0115035055,
-0.0588182174,
0.0111228004,
0.0355048291,
-0.0049788626,
-0.0191436838,
-0.0607818812,
0.0598132461,
-0.0222408008,
0.0257696174,
0.0049677868,
0.0268849991,
0.0115736676,
-0.0457549393,
0.019864222,
0.0197212119,
0.001200374,
-0.0072406954,
-0.0251461659,
0.045999106,
-0.014326361,
-0.0183320809,
-0.0007448,
-0.0194449257,
-0.006845688,
0.0434952006,
0.0333186351,
-0.024400888,
-0.019848397,
0.0067517404,
-0.021212589,
-0.0620282516,
0.0068879547,
0.0184742007,
-0.0450911932,
-0.0462244935,
-0.0535737723,
0.0391745418,
0.0276104696,
0.0582986884,
0.0224602968,
-0.0648406968,
0.0503579453,
0.0308121946,
-0.0268118624,
0.0213141385,
-0.0016361733,
-0.0197797548,
-0.0654665008,
-0.0428644046,
0.0645277873,
-0.0393029936,
-0.0130351968,
-0.0318217799,
-0.054828871,
-0.0247396994,
0.0277722143,
0.0871367007,
0.0179886092,
0.029696852,
-0.0203838069,
-0.0692653283,
0.072153829,
0.0646810532,
-0.01381661,
0.0053513627,
0.0758152232,
-0.0425114743,
-0.0296316911,
0.0168545935,
-0.0701953843,
0.0553431585,
0.0630977377,
-0.0146383047,
-0.009767279,
-0.0340919271,
-0.0108588878,
0.0087441215,
0.0521068089,
0.0402420536,
-0.0104285395,
-0.0341288447,
0.0628535151,
0.0381014943,
0.0300889276,
-0.0775739923,
-0.0291108135,
0.0116541572,
0.0420345478,
0.0089841932,
0.0139924381,
0.0536662452,
0.0174735766,
-0.0437120982,
0.0511012152,
-0.015309562,
0.0231101401,
0.0224123541,
0.0134268068,
-0.0008538706,
0.0141883101,
0.0606657863,
0.0049791206,
-0.0184012,
0.009742518,
0.0585330613,
0.0298601687,
-0.0775448233,
0.0262391046,
-0.0674982071,
-0.0896265805,
-0.0357262418,
0.0167200696,
0.0632694364,
0.0207193494,
0.0031916078,
-0.0047604521,
-0.0218538865,
0.00302622,
0.0182386339,
0.020066971,
0.0540865958,
0.0348155648,
0.018681366,
0.0305821691,
-0.0013613902,
0.0274747256,
-0.0147854583,
0.0876849741,
-0.0278640036,
-0.0031961408,
-0.0279763751,
-0.0110076433,
0.0478638299,
0.0091498084,
-0.007258133,
0.0152886361,
-0.0000600047,
-0.0198857803,
0.0197010171,
-0.0316097476,
0.0317744575,
-0.028088823,
0.0369244777,
0.0377932936,
-0.004704454,
-0.0321601443,
0.032866817,
-0.0618217885,
0.0165643841,
0.0429924466,
0.0533430651,
-6.427224013e-33,
-0.0293187052,
0.0264001861,
0.0122062778,
0.0317884535,
-0.0020454302,
0.0069987755,
-0.0145021509,
-0.0064238175,
-0.0152757205,
0.0056130406,
-0.0127398735,
-0.0188501049,
0.0046257591,
0.0075889383,
-0.0251631346,
-0.0084982896,
0.0823194832,
-0.0029996769,
-0.0424583852,
0.0244221967,
-0.0032016258,
0.0647909567,
0.0619875491,
-0.0081153549,
-0.0862281695,
0.0329780206,
-0.0364787281,
0.0235857368,
-0.0138032353,
0.0252068564,
0.0228365324,
-0.0167188458,
-0.0219768062,
-0.0493177474,
-0.0202728566,
-0.004473439,
-0.041873239,
-0.0373591818,
0.0077651204,
0.0047243652,
-0.005638998,
-0.0355540477,
0.1123367548,
0.0245228969,
-0.0022847774,
-0.0116905412,
0.0225034785,
-0.0208844673,
-0.0041868365,
-0.0661873296,
-0.0490168445,
0.0169321913,
-0.0115277041,
-0.0475588143,
0.0114872139,
0.0109770652,
-0.0265734475,
-0.0145606324,
-0.0462669916,
-0.0368022136,
0.0869008079,
0.0246969238,
0.0082675889,
0.048574362,
-0.0085022617,
0.0223259348,
0.0469142757,
0.0296812057,
0.0082416311,
-0.0314663872,
0.0564740784,
0.1113306209,
0.0658904314,
-0.0607299805,
0.0083611971,
0.0015251597,
-0.0765054449,
0.0251774024,
-0.0240911227,
0.0329811685,
0.0057620732,
0.0328447334,
0.0245165396,
0.0087940842,
-0.0264056697,
-0.0283756889,
-0.0183529779,
0.0152863087,
0.0079061771,
0.0088784005,
-0.0458635539,
0.0116610704,
0.0445164517,
-0.0330049023,
0.0682279319,
-0.0049130572,
-0.0086512845,
0.0247426517,
0.007664233,
0.0095271477,
-0.058897309,
-0.0763382167,
0.0329542086,
-0.0018692173,
0.0275776442,
-0.0024771513,
0.0389736444,
0.0850329548,
-0.035695646,
-0.0180002823,
-0.0341626443,
0.0149110518,
0.0133225201,
0.0800384134,
0.0123012643,
0.0004293131,
0.0016608479,
-0.0137751261,
-0.0271574948,
-0.0126398262,
0.001522052,
0.0598747209,
0.0545697398,
0.0251177326,
-0.0195548739,
-0.0061287968,
-0.058685232,
0.0133567872,
-0.0031197942,
-0.0560378656,
-0.0357539207,
0.0280852318,
2.881e-7,
0.0280575361,
0.0393733494,
-0.0016118328,
-0.0358930491,
0.0216104109,
0.0312165283,
-0.0470078476,
0.0218872074,
0.0313657671,
0.0408138819,
0.0401073284,
0.0454937257,
0.0226259343,
-0.0189185552,
-0.0422755815,
-0.0320243239,
-0.042337779,
0.0314370207,
-0.0132311266,
-0.0082829976,
0.0058035734,
0.061156977,
0.0380542763,
-0.0107447738,
0.0519696921,
-0.0307044964,
0.0245944895,
-0.035408102,
0.0429988652,
0.0418040752,
0.0340347923,
0.0559793897,
-0.0595847815,
0.031635724,
-0.0022963716,
0.0614659004,
-0.0069449157,
0.060197901,
-0.0091112973,
-0.0228723679,
0.0274173785,
0.0128366994,
0.0122942152,
-0.0418505557,
0.0468907356,
-0.1058443785,
-0.0370949879,
0.0082209576,
-0.0254854672,
-0.0308651552,
-0.0015427284,
-0.0357085317,
0.0230227467,
0.0113324644,
-0.0003400072,
-0.0150292497,
-0.0493891872,
-0.0712591484,
0.035896644,
0.0447543263,
-0.031221997,
-0.0699519366,
-0.0520305708,
-0.0504243895,
0.0698875785,
-0.0356472991,
0.0083851814,
2.660283535e-34,
0.0014055031,
-0.0601264164,
0.0195354298,
0.0042112437,
0.0185820572,
0.0083765378,
-0.0052059884,
-0.013110565,
0.0029100794,
-0.0742649511,
-0.0303766187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00340v1 | Attention Link: An Efficient Attention-Based Low Resource Machine Translation Architecture | 2023-02-01T09:52:36 | 2023-02-01T09:52:36 | Zeping Min | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformers have achieved great success in machine translation, but
transformer-based NMT models often require millions of bilingual parallel
corpus for training. In this paper, we propose a novel architecture named as
attention link (AL) to help improve transformer models' performance, especially
in low training resources. We theoretically demonstrate the superiority of our
attention link architecture in low training resources. Besides, we have done a
large number of experiments, including en-de, de-en, en-fr, en-it, it-en, en-ro
translation tasks on the IWSLT14 dataset as well as real low resources scene on
bn-gu and gu-ta translation tasks on the CVIT PIB dataset. All the experiment
results show our attention link is powerful and can lead to a significant
improvement. In addition, we achieve a 37.9 BLEU score, a new sota, on the
IWSLT14 de-en task by combining our attention link and other advanced methods. | [
0.0057501164,
0.0202373974,
-0.0042037112,
0.038336888,
-0.0454983115,
0.0040884996,
0.0291123725,
-0.0240721796,
-0.024665501,
0.008822877,
-0.0705440566,
-0.0347857662,
0.0345025659,
-0.070853591,
0.0425077267,
-0.0426316112,
0.010900992,
0.0002939779,
-0.034639962,
0.0013011057,
-0.0141004203,
0.0060460446,
0.0147830108,
0.0167022105,
0.0060693868,
0.0062967194,
0.0064513227,
0.0185180474,
0.048975274,
-0.0259673819,
-0.0044838712,
0.0343729369,
-0.0091715036,
0.0384989232,
0.0000022335,
0.0013301966,
-0.0145386253,
0.0210512485,
0.0063554882,
-0.0060668127,
0.0573912263,
-0.0524378158,
-0.0203256868,
0.0514103808,
0.0175000243,
-0.0174669866,
0.0734506547,
0.0576222688,
0.0468333662,
0.0586521104,
-0.0235924646,
-0.0347576626,
0.0127372239,
-0.0813365355,
-0.0139372256,
-0.0332288966,
-0.0192318633,
-0.0292354003,
-0.0269074626,
0.0151925823,
-0.0243158173,
0.0756225362,
0.0443121344,
0.016504338,
-0.0366315357,
0.0095242383,
-0.0578652322,
-0.0235632714,
-0.0118038496,
0.0493807159,
-0.0863628834,
-0.0221174285,
-0.0102729825,
0.0270018,
-0.016369991,
-0.0367011949,
-0.0537949353,
0.0145812426,
-0.008488548,
-0.0086767366,
0.045175381,
0.0522689298,
0.0390332155,
-0.0269407723,
-0.039580524,
-0.0180378836,
0.0419325307,
-0.0376018547,
0.0002950467,
0.0271770619,
0.0032310353,
0.0054990742,
0.027280353,
-0.0001877111,
0.0171503294,
0.0167923309,
-0.0426269881,
-0.0537290238,
-0.006279225,
-0.0557419248,
-0.0027959985,
0.0580849797,
-0.0226447247,
0.0268277731,
-0.0263068322,
0.0511911809,
-0.0408728346,
-0.007878813,
-0.0623637922,
-0.0492879562,
0.009011317,
0.0448506065,
-0.069536373,
-0.0385296121,
-0.0657701343,
0.0003245593,
0.0020617242,
0.0118781999,
0.025580477,
-0.0266795512,
0.0551375523,
-0.021436315,
-0.069163546,
-0.0071300883,
0.0085331015,
0.0810319409,
0.0225258712,
-0.0590256043,
-0.0103881154,
-0.0765091032,
-0.0514014363,
0.0373785794,
-0.007385652,
-0.0584062785,
-0.0020407473,
0.0993375182,
-0.0269922353,
-0.064879097,
-0.0301614869,
0.0296734981,
-0.0083113797,
-0.0685576126,
0.0205247775,
-0.0553350933,
0.0649742782,
0.0082784006,
0.0222700518,
0.017219061,
0.0028331724,
0.0287224129,
-0.0087600183,
0.0456940867,
0.0447273441,
-0.0238660015,
0.0153699331,
0.0026403726,
0.0198092256,
0.0472694114,
0.0084747961,
0.0173299424,
-0.0180758517,
-0.0186113715,
-0.0335497558,
0.054128211,
0.0350930989,
0.0359154977,
0.0037393966,
0.0110247163,
-0.0169993434,
0.0108464286,
0.0596688464,
0.0649346337,
-0.0218151938,
-0.008436773,
0.0807966441,
0.011482982,
0.0512616262,
0.0860080048,
0.0372077711,
0.0314056017,
-0.0286433361,
-0.0165446904,
-0.0434586406,
0.0953446254,
0.0035148745,
-0.0011883653,
0.0366656631,
0.0607645176,
-0.0378416404,
-0.0030369249,
0.0127486018,
-0.0123777129,
-0.0214034189,
-0.0050151185,
0.0305486321,
0.0235218406,
-0.0458438657,
0.1224397644,
0.0046479888,
-0.0383783467,
-0.0100950273,
-0.0256409086,
-0.0592600629,
0.0337107442,
0.0344118811,
0.0335794799,
-0.0273180194,
-0.0368616469,
0.0017303926,
0.0662902072,
0.0430781692,
0.0514470339,
0.0023357957,
-0.0614218712,
0.0153573146,
0.0181464683,
-0.0025815624,
0.0295410473,
-0.0046235877,
0.0356696062,
0.0364414528,
-0.0311123095,
-0.0194616094,
-0.0062755621,
0.0052353442,
-0.0044276221,
0.0089129051,
0.0244296733,
0.018201692,
0.0065983753,
-0.0020125376,
0.0028336004,
0.0194820631,
-0.0434272923,
-0.0069062277,
0.0514282808,
-0.035732463,
-0.0464707315,
0.0137320543,
-0.0596345477,
0.0036743614,
0.039422784,
-0.014346296,
-0.0596075058,
0.0181028042,
-0.0851816386,
0.0163928363,
-0.0185811073,
0.0269955415,
0.0135068763,
0.0174930859,
-0.0463926159,
0.0333269276,
-0.0371983796,
0.0216822941,
0.0305766687,
0.0026706585,
0.0279379487,
-0.0608795434,
-0.0201668274,
0.0370916501,
0.0051737288,
0.0374333002,
0.0199820995,
0.0110456087,
0.0224227216,
-0.0518983714,
-0.0350977704,
0.0188371167,
-0.0334109403,
0.0463453457,
0.0483629219,
0.0570074543,
0.0074365758,
0.0035949799,
-0.0142599763,
0.0305413809,
-0.0129482355,
-0.003646841,
-0.0043548946,
-0.0318405181,
0.0181709826,
-0.0056009199,
-0.0170661137,
0.0340601131,
0.0163343772,
-0.0016284428,
-0.0349372178,
-0.069548808,
-0.0285762697,
0.0091299135,
0.0116907014,
-0.0088935643,
-0.0835266262,
-0.003623771,
-0.0010815456,
0.0890204906,
0.0459123589,
-0.0010677539,
-0.0351006687,
0.0253881477,
0.0031216841,
-0.0376300178,
0.0404171422,
0.0001340272,
-0.0144223617,
-0.0316062719,
-0.0458969474,
0.0100670289,
0.071900107,
-0.0057678944,
0.0098382337,
-0.077833809,
-0.0398753174,
0.0125259543,
0.0203077812,
0.0176186785,
0.0732743889,
-0.0187254008,
-0.0289469119,
-0.0381629765,
-0.0397098102,
0.0235002674,
-0.0464202836,
-0.0275864322,
-0.1083242372,
0.0141089419,
-0.0217531826,
0.0144340275,
-0.0046424121,
0.0218488574,
-0.0405082032,
-0.0412460715,
-0.018826358,
0.0731582791,
-0.0122328103,
-0.0067629782,
0.1006769165,
0.0016182056,
-0.0096591869,
-0.0447185077,
-0.0240945797,
-0.0179885123,
0.0193250366,
-0.0245224033,
-0.0010174541,
0.0420882367,
-0.0321789123,
-0.0620943271,
0.0336611122,
0.0526678525,
0.0801589713,
-0.0126408935,
0.0086318823,
-0.0014137296,
0.0267803371,
-0.0048986403,
0.0083526522,
0.0301402714,
-0.0238927193,
0.0021675562,
0.0297547225,
-0.0011558499,
-0.0286651216,
-0.0262925792,
-0.0494585112,
0.0208077841,
0.0085124522,
-0.0244088974,
-0.0330589898,
0.0310070142,
-0.0549305193,
-0.0329343788,
0.0826183781,
0.0038945638,
-0.0530039221,
-0.00035553,
0.0016231958,
0.0441748351,
0.0138987834,
0.0288913213,
-0.0562107712,
-0.0379020832,
-0.0122738108,
0.0469720811,
0.0322354436,
0.0161827616,
-0.0333979204,
-0.0754401013,
0.0112551302,
0.0341315456,
-0.0587718822,
-0.0673524439,
-0.0023701123,
-0.0260892138,
-0.0524149537,
0.0103601133,
0.008210673,
0.0336865,
-0.0124177625,
-0.0024253833,
0.0565586612,
-0.0537525713,
-0.0129588805,
-0.0290133599,
0.0065193386,
0.0076103359,
0.0209212322,
-0.0143155828,
-0.0706227049,
0.0300311502,
-0.0520740338,
0.0019662727,
-0.0157628469,
0.0391390808,
0.004572019,
-0.0393711701,
-0.0239214431,
-0.0101156542,
-0.0307838898,
0.0289607067,
0.0106824925,
0.0799133703,
-0.0177269503,
0.0120001566,
0.0252582226,
-0.0212573595,
0.0068179867,
0.0408476442,
0.0295480844,
-0.061734762,
0.0030575222,
0.0025614761,
-0.0135891931,
-0.0890381709,
-0.003255313,
-0.0024731592,
-0.0261126664,
-0.0654869527,
-0.057163585,
-0.0525470823,
-0.0277306996,
0.0501722395,
0.0014045334,
-0.0392650403,
0.0255171601,
0.0055333227,
-0.0226284135,
0.0492860228,
-0.0376781933,
0.0066846367,
-0.0754533112,
-0.0028156715,
0.0351082161,
-0.0286924876,
0.0192890856,
0.0357423536,
-0.1107452214,
-0.0321591757,
-0.0159787275,
0.0729464889,
0.0133552793,
0.0289372373,
-0.0578580759,
-0.0197436698,
-0.0011238026,
-0.0012002829,
-0.0176392812,
0.0035871421,
0.0177038088,
-0.0158312358,
0.0009535043,
0.0423091426,
0.0063726096,
0.0200760122,
0.0090684909,
0.0543441847,
0.0000782753,
-0.0280322134,
0.0118102459,
0.0160601083,
0.0385285653,
-0.0136579359,
0.0442487523,
-0.0068636429,
0.0492816269,
0.0137098096,
0.0049515674,
-0.0466994606,
-0.027224049,
0.0427091233,
-0.000514921,
-0.0034492847,
0.0088466015,
0.0208206922,
-0.0523850769,
0.003581871,
0.0281693321,
-0.0400630757,
0.0211889632,
0.0127093131,
0.0217529256,
-0.0189109277,
-0.0286195129,
0.0286012851,
0.0211403053,
-0.0335716642,
0.0570032895,
0.010733054,
0.0071733282,
-0.0003259248,
0.0357519798,
0.0055173482,
0.0042532971,
-0.0056434991,
-0.0090608113,
0.0826263204,
-0.0158867892,
0.1094969586,
-0.0046921591,
-0.0177718382,
-0.0118182302,
0.0352283567,
-0.0074366839,
-0.0077115679,
0.0033828767,
-0.0104613546,
0.0210600812,
-0.0009096973,
0.0473875739,
-0.0598024167,
-0.0173763521,
0.0053722528,
0.0073961262,
-0.0333842039,
-0.0153157376,
-0.0329160579,
-0.040976353,
-0.013532782,
-0.0035110814,
-0.0142403916,
-0.0371217728,
-0.0078383274,
-0.0298328549,
0.0092087388,
-0.0290560722,
0.0192888044,
0.0460885055,
-0.0258784611,
-0.0361946374,
-0.0131247593,
0.0069644758,
-0.0158936102,
-0.020534765,
-0.0245309174,
-6.523375778e-33,
-0.0215777475,
0.008408336,
0.0276253335,
-0.0316535346,
-0.0359118059,
0.0163411926,
-0.0368867889,
-0.0319433771,
-0.0170881972,
-0.0010199776,
-0.006805643,
0.0015276545,
0.0158451218,
0.0240529012,
0.0105238454,
0.0139248883,
0.0624749176,
0.0108754421,
-0.0315081812,
0.0334294811,
0.01386574,
0.0080086337,
0.0907555446,
-0.0295570549,
-0.0484589674,
-0.0051067276,
0.0056916722,
0.0056781583,
-0.0130665582,
0.0235022511,
0.0264374763,
0.028107604,
0.0183855481,
-0.065754272,
-0.0318389013,
0.0160747617,
-0.0847163573,
-0.0104358094,
0.0016277566,
0.0465283357,
-0.0087418649,
-0.046079196,
0.0548799112,
-0.0178016908,
0.0291992519,
-0.0548453182,
-0.0241974667,
-0.0224377401,
-0.0311546568,
0.0199619476,
-0.0436926037,
0.0392339081,
0.0235340875,
-0.0141365454,
0.0181779414,
0.0749420077,
-0.0336746536,
-0.0155228889,
-0.1103562713,
-0.0278697591,
0.0070066517,
0.0555119403,
0.0626875609,
0.0070070229,
-0.0147891855,
-0.0251227617,
0.0394821875,
-0.0040802811,
0.0475558005,
0.0349243395,
0.0348051786,
-0.0104080318,
0.0930491835,
0.0026554277,
0.0122454911,
-0.0000846534,
-0.0447170883,
0.0019445269,
-0.0156304892,
0.0542302616,
0.0283075441,
0.0224860907,
-0.0218569692,
0.0127971759,
-0.0086905677,
-0.0374874771,
-0.0179876257,
-0.0225865562,
0.0071708472,
0.0315462053,
-0.0206709858,
-0.0061941049,
0.0844932869,
0.0038197921,
0.0623966232,
0.0168859698,
-0.0037344329,
0.0219415184,
-0.0210813303,
0.0253917631,
-0.0812410563,
-0.0051494767,
-0.0078782393,
0.0468380041,
-0.0089145545,
0.0070542288,
0.0397433005,
0.0303453282,
-0.0697374344,
-0.0198585428,
-0.0645493492,
0.0211542007,
-0.0212366134,
0.0522642173,
0.0146204,
-0.0200127289,
0.0112256119,
0.051344689,
0.019058736,
-0.0187979061,
-0.0026991896,
0.0374455303,
0.0346535966,
0.0201199539,
-0.0283593256,
0.0504660755,
-0.0420141779,
0.0277334638,
0.0120774927,
-0.0702601895,
-0.0359746851,
0.031873405,
2.986e-7,
0.039009925,
0.0404220745,
0.0049574459,
0.0178448167,
0.0284852721,
-0.0102303624,
-0.0086521227,
0.0392820835,
-0.0003110511,
0.0689050034,
0.0265969988,
-0.0042203618,
0.0633098856,
0.013876752,
-0.1072993577,
-0.0506884493,
-0.0210534725,
0.0199522898,
-0.0167670902,
-0.0258524455,
0.0208011866,
0.1059184,
-0.0131949084,
0.0095095783,
0.0198296886,
-0.0242064986,
0.0450779982,
0.0339694694,
-0.0209396314,
-0.0107875569,
0.057980381,
0.0384890623,
-0.0651617423,
0.002133406,
-0.0297007412,
0.0143873375,
0.004581247,
0.076391317,
0.0002928071,
-0.0426152758,
0.0492481999,
-0.0180797279,
-0.0333492681,
-0.0480986387,
0.0334008411,
-0.0642987937,
-0.0074534696,
0.0316406377,
-0.0125207808,
0.0231056102,
-0.0057835868,
-0.0134311104,
-0.036030788,
0.0049635638,
0.048070468,
-0.034490183,
-0.0166927762,
-0.0428741425,
-0.0127497334,
0.0216807425,
-0.0257331859,
-0.038604483,
-0.0459636599,
-0.0379266702,
0.0043863612,
0.0237156469,
-0.0362205878,
2.529413821e-34,
0.011775936,
-0.0327287056,
0.0218107197,
-0.0062061609,
0.0105703603,
-0.0374671854,
-0.0153846461,
-0.0199441724,
-0.0059014168,
-0.0383371115,
-0.0368715636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00326v1 | Evaluating TCFD Reporting: A New Application of Zero-Shot Analysis to Climate-Related Financial Disclosures | 2023-02-01T09:11:05 | 2023-02-01T09:11:05 | Alix Auzepy, Elena Tönjes, David Lenz, Christoph Funk | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | We examine climate-related disclosures in a large sample of reports published
by banks that officially endorsed the recommendations of the Task Force for
Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). In doing so, we introduce a new
application of the zero-shot text classification. By developing a set of
fine-grained TCFD labels, we show that zero-shot analysis is a useful tool for
classifying climate-related disclosures without further model training.
Overall, our findings indicate that corporate climate-related disclosures grew
dynamically after the launch of the TCFD recommendations. However, there are
marked differences in the extent of reporting by recommended disclosure topic,
suggesting that some recommendations have not yet been fully met. Our findings
yield important conclusions for the design of climate-related disclosure
frameworks. | [
-0.0237665717,
0.0341761559,
-0.006135928,
0.0284677446,
-0.0290120188,
0.0074594477,
0.0557966307,
0.0374014415,
0.0118115265,
-0.0819139332,
0.0188748576,
0.0371398292,
0.0010975946,
0.0263238214,
0.0136942985,
-0.0285176598,
0.0404906496,
0.020807879,
0.016787054,
-0.0037537708,
0.0056251967,
-0.0232772268,
0.024148263,
-0.0031853961,
0.0086162146,
-0.0435321815,
-0.0006212619,
-0.0242957771,
0.0196207333,
-0.0181940086,
0.0170549136,
0.0319039449,
0.0314820148,
0.02314266,
0.0000018696,
-0.0355275385,
-0.046620328,
0.0154910702,
0.0321115367,
0.0408551991,
0.0628502965,
-0.0687626526,
0.0448218659,
-0.0057780468,
-0.016606003,
-0.0330831707,
0.054726854,
0.0354790986,
0.020796923,
0.0145522552,
0.0058243885,
-0.0109041305,
-0.01386212,
-0.0034948271,
-0.0031875207,
0.0024894071,
0.0070394049,
-0.0409094766,
-0.0148712052,
-0.0150499558,
-0.0157228243,
0.0716145113,
-0.0031858638,
-0.0000784781,
0.0474690348,
0.0253113713,
-0.0268029179,
0.0016483194,
-0.0233992767,
0.0278263316,
0.0543737896,
0.0153890345,
-0.00267467,
-0.0131875975,
0.0438820869,
-0.045517195,
-0.0074444721,
0.0347194187,
-0.0148970969,
-0.0187308062,
0.0167817865,
0.0452014953,
-0.0167106465,
0.0516903847,
0.0147445733,
0.0366321094,
-0.0549547896,
-0.0451861359,
-0.0037894186,
-0.0272589456,
0.0436032675,
-0.0564268194,
-0.0275541116,
0.0007429958,
0.0439513549,
0.0136338053,
-0.0126801869,
-0.0158060789,
0.0260972902,
-0.0655645952,
0.0332227424,
-0.009535674,
-0.0090129348,
0.0419521928,
0.028809268,
0.0463263281,
0.0552515872,
0.0179513954,
-0.0062286551,
0.0351247601,
-0.0251790676,
-0.0032121153,
0.0332228318,
0.0725534111,
-0.0163076334,
0.0295787901,
-0.0346341208,
-0.0095579894,
-0.0438420177,
0.025322428,
-0.0128168724,
-0.0045962674,
0.0227165166,
-0.0020887214,
0.0081392769,
0.0147644626,
-0.0426906906,
0.0054259249,
-0.0026807955,
0.0388135165,
-0.0008193619,
0.0186296217,
0.0172696318,
0.0101187462,
-0.0040610568,
0.0510878861,
0.0380155593,
-0.0255455542,
-0.0078513958,
-0.0125621958,
-0.0203432031,
-0.0522503033,
-0.0406588428,
0.0114515917,
-0.0340740345,
-0.0145367905,
0.0193309169,
-0.0112747755,
-0.040478982,
-0.0360792577,
-0.0025002321,
0.0638794079,
-0.0455022529,
-0.0559256375,
0.026276812,
0.0148124145,
0.0095871594,
0.0502761789,
0.0151316151,
0.0122439843,
0.0261300262,
-0.0206734575,
0.0111390874,
-0.0227233078,
0.0233440865,
0.013815593,
0.0040509361,
0.0266505331,
-0.0030603688,
-0.0335767195,
0.0165235233,
-0.0458629616,
-0.0299286675,
-0.0227726754,
0.0388586186,
0.0195460692,
0.0081909513,
-0.0071648923,
-0.0364353321,
0.0311425496,
-0.0374108851,
0.016150916,
0.036481902,
0.0056903604,
-0.0647336468,
0.0030852165,
0.0154903997,
-0.0368694477,
-0.0636312515,
-0.0566644371,
-0.0244800746,
-0.0047813552,
-0.040681053,
-0.0247637723,
-0.0049489313,
0.0153148891,
-0.0127917416,
0.0344138555,
0.0299301166,
-0.024916634,
-0.0183166303,
-0.0290765017,
0.046910122,
0.0466589592,
-0.0295393858,
-0.0226699077,
0.0237761531,
-0.0392363481,
0.0111338906,
-0.0077254386,
0.0420483463,
0.0274595171,
-0.0316899829,
0.0008172678,
-0.0259772576,
-0.0206687972,
0.0446685217,
0.0217669457,
-0.0550729781,
-0.0003151149,
-0.0095423665,
-0.0052253692,
-0.0037161524,
0.0385727845,
0.0633327588,
-0.0646707863,
0.0630069673,
0.0079556154,
0.0150328279,
-0.0185584147,
-0.001852568,
-0.001687002,
0.0187194906,
0.0168241151,
-0.0544845425,
0.0129217776,
0.0302819051,
0.0241898205,
-0.030872304,
-0.0009874207,
0.0063452213,
0.0065739742,
-0.0316614211,
0.0357901864,
0.0191107094,
0.0464405529,
-0.0113275517,
-0.028412519,
-0.0322416611,
0.0061410628,
-0.0010381719,
0.0004024491,
0.0869171843,
-0.0049843513,
0.0287129637,
-0.0688018277,
-0.0608364902,
0.0132417968,
-0.0489600562,
0.064253673,
-0.001365,
-0.0761723816,
0.0196539648,
0.0253956672,
0.0043507284,
0.0053672465,
-0.0059155966,
-0.0557878688,
0.0237401146,
0.0084621841,
-0.0017545705,
-0.0145705128,
-0.0356663018,
-0.0359333009,
0.0107333511,
-0.0059753102,
-0.0594812706,
-0.038104672,
0.0337376334,
0.0465482995,
0.0114353839,
-0.0145413689,
0.0120910769,
-0.0131207285,
-0.0135717271,
0.0880706087,
0.0725203082,
-0.0676915199,
-0.0221246444,
0.0608881004,
-0.016322298,
-0.0160840563,
-0.0009867336,
0.0159212928,
-0.0206569657,
0.0150858285,
-0.0662550554,
0.0415997133,
0.0350436121,
0.0882534832,
-0.0389743187,
0.0298126265,
-0.0479386486,
0.0209565684,
-0.0095610823,
-0.0087938001,
0.0265540443,
0.0045389268,
0.0430989973,
-0.0067077498,
-0.0473533608,
-0.0135005256,
-0.0255339202,
0.0517589003,
-0.0359365717,
-0.0162506308,
-0.0417150222,
-0.0354218036,
0.0109877419,
0.059689492,
-0.0080569107,
-0.0904991254,
0.0187272541,
0.005600397,
-0.0069523072,
-0.0500938632,
-0.0087857414,
-0.0358912237,
0.0682537407,
-0.0340196118,
-0.0025148764,
0.1024574712,
0.0055914167,
0.0334559195,
-0.0662179962,
0.0544400923,
0.0045645074,
-0.0157158319,
0.0123768486,
0.0330054946,
-0.0209523402,
-0.0241875146,
0.0020759152,
-0.0920136496,
0.0211570393,
0.0430543013,
-0.0111385239,
-0.0202290248,
-0.1185327321,
0.031550955,
0.0093906932,
0.014314984,
-0.0169585887,
-0.0333705321,
0.0300512947,
-0.0225224402,
-0.0149985822,
-0.0500946864,
0.0207899399,
-0.0443879329,
-0.0048748534,
0.0046396698,
0.0269578882,
0.0682973564,
0.0095692519,
-0.0150510548,
-0.0251440294,
-0.0127533078,
-0.0083406335,
-0.0058667846,
-0.0296886843,
-0.052828677,
0.0166308917,
0.053420797,
0.0139093045,
-0.0065840702,
-0.002411677,
0.0373207331,
0.0374940298,
-0.0110109709,
0.0189637151,
-0.1084466949,
0.0077810343,
-0.0335285217,
0.0086390832,
-0.0460804217,
-0.0668917298,
-0.045200482,
-0.0486922674,
0.0688418821,
0.0234202575,
-0.0201452728,
-0.0112028793,
-0.0718656033,
0.0061067413,
-0.0326735601,
-0.063946411,
-0.0672109649,
-0.0039014895,
-0.035560824,
0.0422901958,
-0.1037340537,
-0.0291652512,
0.0027638911,
0.0220319033,
-0.052294597,
0.0562772565,
0.0256563686,
-0.0422270782,
-0.0184523761,
-0.0028657594,
-0.0376887992,
-0.02265306,
-0.0107514383,
0.071100764,
-0.0302469525,
-0.0024004776,
0.0224364158,
0.0300864782,
-0.0004466093,
0.0438376255,
0.004675373,
0.0462908112,
0.0184976421,
-0.0240938738,
0.0487745143,
0.0315074362,
0.010005177,
0.0559145361,
-0.0167220347,
-0.0051056156,
-0.0230916496,
-0.0624019727,
-0.0139453523,
-0.0449697226,
0.041158542,
-0.0334844142,
-0.0374377109,
-0.0352872796,
-0.0231291167,
-0.0515200682,
0.0333546177,
0.015912462,
-0.0114599764,
0.0197339263,
0.0272745527,
0.005262142,
-0.0219594538,
-0.0000484005,
-0.019426195,
0.0512605309,
-0.0027980364,
-0.0178223886,
0.0145160714,
0.0855592713,
-0.0372188315,
0.0387541279,
-0.0357366316,
-0.0438210331,
-0.0119294301,
0.0024956714,
0.0254368335,
-0.0387147069,
-0.0072995899,
0.0026218586,
0.0528488718,
0.1632466018,
-0.0664203316,
0.0054727844,
0.0714317039,
-0.0197143313,
-0.0148495995,
0.0000137593,
0.0190268271,
-0.0016280172,
-0.0082012014,
-0.0240468942,
-0.0211444348,
0.0380456708,
0.0020249691,
-0.0224270709,
0.0089045167,
0.0032959345,
-0.0471921116,
-0.0263582487,
-0.0058646724,
-0.0064926897,
-0.0160382092,
-0.0203320868,
-0.0187138636,
0.0248287357,
0.0047492725,
-0.0203055628,
0.1058823839,
-0.068432048,
0.0199395437,
-0.0766754821,
0.0748357773,
0.0409937687,
0.0454632603,
-0.0434270687,
-0.0062072272,
-0.0152200563,
-0.04740569,
0.0453293696,
-0.0155616719,
0.0185968094,
-0.0054216292,
0.0050042886,
0.0795076489,
-0.0374843478,
0.0009569172,
-0.0312690251,
0.0186192058,
-0.000500285,
0.050069537,
-0.0362653844,
0.0453537107,
-0.0311509371,
-0.0369300172,
-0.012678274,
0.0126323914,
0.051630497,
0.0300094038,
-0.0404606052,
0.058484152,
0.0128789246,
-0.0706388429,
-0.0307410415,
0.0351433493,
0.0553863719,
0.0132557154,
-0.0455734581,
-0.0135333827,
-0.0265697204,
-0.0229614098,
0.0393678397,
-0.0135614546,
0.0598772839,
0.0197377019,
-0.1193595976,
-0.0068502612,
0.0884612426,
-0.0561456159,
0.0074929255,
-0.0071985754,
-0.0352238864,
0.0286710616,
0.0186065771,
-0.0575585067,
-0.0057947049,
0.0025558874,
-0.0152003933,
-0.0210106391,
-0.0553865246,
-5.74298418e-33,
-0.0289270878,
-0.0311870892,
-0.031480886,
0.0245041773,
0.0206280332,
0.0700727329,
0.021627184,
0.0040898342,
-0.0039490778,
0.0211596694,
-0.004466868,
-0.0021146024,
0.0248111524,
-0.0108977687,
-0.0029446804,
-0.0109066144,
-0.0019589749,
-0.05352097,
-0.0196946412,
-0.0248873588,
0.0006601836,
0.0078118215,
0.00199417,
-0.0621260032,
0.0647858828,
-0.0128586739,
-0.0772480369,
-0.0270202141,
0.041950576,
0.0467571616,
-0.0068605938,
0.0209590849,
0.0262584742,
-0.0474612787,
-0.0098814275,
0.0406519808,
-0.0700607076,
-0.0264976937,
0.0131790712,
-0.0378900468,
0.0279480126,
0.003094865,
-0.0314717665,
0.0361061879,
0.0020503292,
-0.056695547,
0.0319302566,
-0.0175360348,
-0.0391399078,
-0.0751593187,
-0.0240074601,
0.0570827164,
-0.0027082108,
0.0749302208,
-0.0094896052,
0.0895371661,
-0.0165214725,
0.0622765012,
-0.0424698517,
-0.0004925878,
0.0860940069,
0.0000843227,
0.0235532355,
0.0402083099,
0.0133422548,
0.0401400216,
-0.0159384385,
0.0808941871,
-0.0317557566,
-0.0214747638,
0.0546110012,
-0.0196064096,
-0.018123474,
0.0779440627,
0.0442425646,
-0.0593541339,
-0.0886302218,
0.0241643637,
0.00662782,
0.0051106922,
0.0503784344,
-0.0316475295,
-0.0427598655,
-0.0515885204,
-0.018828189,
-0.0091626029,
-0.0259026401,
0.0420171246,
0.0448256917,
0.0194815751,
-0.0248619113,
0.0473594517,
0.0219634846,
-0.0134748621,
-0.0315949209,
0.0059795026,
0.0199594703,
0.0429581441,
0.0362736955,
-0.000574594,
-0.0496711396,
-0.0442195311,
-0.0135830594,
0.0923730209,
0.0166399144,
-0.0191925317,
0.1065212861,
0.0039235936,
-0.0371221006,
0.0010030974,
0.0014482832,
0.0037529429,
0.0065674558,
0.0131688407,
-0.0460449681,
0.0172236282,
0.0110678123,
-0.00055995,
-0.0038041892,
0.0043720668,
0.0083330302,
0.0106784301,
-0.0525974371,
0.040864449,
0.0216632746,
-0.0106431963,
0.033527866,
-0.0059620319,
0.0600144863,
-0.014220261,
-0.0001305192,
0.0170903243,
2.574e-7,
0.0483629666,
-0.0155333336,
-0.0518128239,
-0.0327963307,
0.0112752616,
0.0605179183,
0.0049152509,
0.0495769083,
-0.0030756313,
-0.0196653996,
-0.0100691551,
-0.036986459,
0.0152322548,
0.0151175465,
-0.0260954257,
-0.0414496288,
-0.0184648763,
-0.0108347125,
-0.0744508579,
0.0034707359,
0.0159150288,
0.0318545625,
0.0243284199,
0.01241202,
0.004365175,
-0.0233649872,
0.0708739012,
-0.0724287257,
-0.0219656248,
-0.0042681498,
0.0185367931,
-0.0298064854,
0.0073876493,
0.0176082905,
-0.0282738153,
-0.0121057909,
-0.0116296606,
0.0208290592,
0.0297305584,
-0.0111860353,
0.0111165345,
-0.0051959581,
-0.0267296098,
-0.0429089069,
0.0356407836,
-0.0268848147,
-0.0235448368,
-0.0327095501,
-0.0181936026,
0.0596648529,
0.038634602,
-0.0104452679,
-0.0177928489,
0.027423149,
-0.005528748,
-0.0311981011,
0.0260062851,
-0.0000913492,
0.0035420761,
-0.0140775796,
-0.0061824895,
0.0361954458,
0.0205934588,
-0.0003174019,
0.0570750497,
-0.0352962837,
0.0478103869,
2.376551571e-34,
0.0346260443,
-0.051748652,
-0.0541157089,
-0.0508889891,
0.0560811572,
0.035380628,
-0.0056065004,
0.0233613197,
0.01986387,
-0.0452504121,
0.0214329269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00321v1 | An Evaluation of Persian-English Machine Translation Datasets with Transformers | 2023-02-01T08:55:08 | 2023-02-01T08:55:08 | Amir Sartipi, Meghdad Dehghan, Afsaneh Fatemi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Nowadays, many researchers are focusing their attention on the subject of
machine translation (MT). However, Persian machine translation has remained
unexplored despite a vast amount of research being conducted in languages with
high resources, such as English. Moreover, while a substantial amount of
research has been undertaken in statistical machine translation for some
datasets in Persian, there is currently no standard baseline for
transformer-based text2text models on each corpus. This study collected and
analysed the most popular and valuable parallel corpora, which were used for
Persian-English translation. Furthermore, we fine-tuned and evaluated two
state-of-the-art attention-based seq2seq models on each dataset separately (48
results). We hope this paper will assist researchers in comparing their Persian
to English and vice versa machine translation results to a standard baseline. | [
0.0341639891,
0.0358666629,
-0.0294780061,
0.0328889824,
-0.0591949411,
0.0149396043,
0.0199994892,
0.0082636587,
-0.0370976813,
-0.0295243859,
-0.0297749545,
-0.0495274626,
0.0426783897,
-0.032957647,
0.0322418474,
-0.0338643491,
0.0195015483,
-0.0128645767,
-0.0247075502,
0.0421316735,
0.0390040055,
0.0063684597,
0.0223340243,
0.0257288739,
-0.0144995078,
0.0147174979,
0.0128748911,
0.024362281,
0.0395798385,
0.0043064672,
-0.0054311962,
0.0479695983,
0.0061078276,
0.0576279424,
0.0000017498,
-0.0327841453,
-0.0322355442,
-0.001543756,
0.0653984547,
-0.0088705039,
0.0521101505,
-0.0497179963,
-0.0347330458,
0.0534402542,
0.011679939,
-0.0207883362,
0.1026408449,
0.0090166563,
0.0571893938,
0.0463319682,
-0.0349872187,
-0.0981311649,
0.0007876141,
-0.0311689246,
-0.0122086927,
-0.036323417,
0.0148632908,
-0.0565424524,
-0.0522394776,
0.022803802,
-0.0145724174,
0.0338977091,
-0.0094760386,
-0.0206327215,
-0.0128888283,
-0.0130447373,
-0.0794534907,
-0.0288495421,
0.0390739106,
0.0377341174,
-0.0338490158,
-0.0358276553,
-0.0241350085,
0.0310896356,
-0.0266792178,
0.0308413636,
-0.0452030115,
0.0369761288,
-0.0397485569,
0.0006736303,
0.054649964,
0.0398538783,
-0.0153593747,
-0.0390165932,
-0.0771939307,
-0.0263817124,
0.0464658737,
-0.0253446829,
0.0065829116,
-0.0237107389,
-0.0693754479,
0.0073978566,
0.0337872207,
-0.0171510689,
-0.0218943562,
0.0198740438,
-0.0216398221,
-0.0917851105,
-0.0012014349,
-0.0690636113,
0.0467128567,
0.078936398,
0.0367619656,
0.0174550842,
-0.0186896138,
0.0325962603,
0.0206662007,
0.0094291028,
-0.0825554132,
-0.0367597938,
-0.0002052225,
0.0462669283,
-0.0683870539,
-0.0388402194,
-0.0402707122,
-0.0097989403,
-0.0319307372,
0.0135211386,
0.0385994352,
-0.006433398,
0.0387745574,
-0.0453129262,
-0.0603775419,
0.0262770448,
-0.0017435687,
0.0276830178,
0.0136053273,
0.0105517935,
-0.0326913744,
-0.0562329032,
-0.0215225257,
0.048435159,
-0.0213651098,
-0.0216221772,
-0.0395086855,
0.0459942296,
-0.000625214,
-0.0539298467,
0.008063212,
0.059450116,
-0.0175288878,
-0.0414385758,
-0.0202021208,
-0.0490266457,
0.0630102009,
0.0370698683,
-0.0026056606,
-0.004044672,
0.0179449897,
0.0423087552,
-0.014818633,
0.0659346208,
0.0466984026,
0.0307435282,
0.0134682991,
-0.0093096998,
0.0029487549,
0.0414015017,
0.0538509972,
0.0070575308,
0.022598641,
-0.0263267271,
-0.0087477788,
0.0381873511,
-0.0158309564,
0.022179123,
-0.0069747176,
0.0231073219,
0.0001877757,
0.0318007581,
-0.0146828573,
0.0790816918,
-0.0176561624,
0.0234958977,
0.0339334346,
0.0326176025,
0.040082816,
0.0596031882,
0.0148547813,
0.0076389876,
0.0099870749,
0.0042451471,
-0.0009526314,
0.015247738,
0.0832315907,
0.0522007421,
0.0302426089,
0.0298866592,
-0.0153703643,
-0.0248653665,
-0.0183409434,
-0.0228689611,
0.0183765441,
-0.0496119745,
0.079231143,
0.0097417329,
-0.0788519233,
0.0747743472,
0.005055869,
-0.0614272431,
-0.0098216236,
-0.0553836226,
-0.0380810685,
0.0391053446,
0.0260275211,
-0.0085693486,
0.0087211281,
-0.0114095481,
-0.0089696255,
0.0275468286,
0.0055522188,
0.0163855981,
-0.0058240197,
-0.0452406593,
0.0031120332,
0.0216339957,
0.0315423794,
-0.0086508486,
-0.0142865404,
0.0311317202,
0.0368394852,
0.0053111203,
-0.0454542674,
0.021923881,
-0.0267591309,
0.0119230403,
0.0003679437,
-0.007925503,
0.0037338531,
-0.0074695605,
-0.0103191491,
0.0358899534,
0.0579230003,
-0.0414672457,
0.0090156626,
0.0516690575,
0.0014075624,
-0.0293943286,
0.0098710982,
-0.1075660884,
0.0308239087,
0.067441158,
-0.0248054396,
-0.051246196,
0.0094841812,
-0.080761686,
0.0026509501,
-0.0265540201,
0.0725641027,
-0.014174846,
0.0218821801,
-0.0395846069,
0.0091808848,
-0.0298018958,
0.010191475,
0.0179219954,
-0.0399359614,
0.0317932963,
0.0176412258,
-0.0056232694,
0.0333649367,
0.0297461208,
0.0085350126,
0.0612015612,
-0.0188411679,
-0.0135712475,
-0.0453270711,
-0.0284451731,
0.0061300346,
-0.0318624116,
0.0540951975,
0.0350254402,
0.0530615598,
0.0257700086,
0.0198806133,
-0.0088506956,
-0.0315273032,
0.005657312,
-0.0011240346,
0.0489121787,
-0.0453728363,
-0.0021126529,
-0.0410006046,
-0.032710962,
0.0205281004,
0.0334725268,
0.0185925681,
-0.03328095,
-0.0438079312,
0.031805858,
0.0244155265,
-0.006603587,
-0.007090312,
-0.0601903796,
-0.0015253111,
-0.0252685938,
0.0677733198,
0.0275403708,
0.01221269,
-0.0490157492,
0.0155019555,
0.0133199943,
-0.0008034781,
-0.0192866102,
-0.0349797159,
-0.0507157631,
-0.0267699752,
-0.0938907042,
0.0062102289,
0.0595445298,
-0.0363475978,
-0.0202698447,
-0.0662294552,
-0.0365196355,
-0.0038760884,
0.0582049415,
0.0517235808,
0.0428673811,
-0.0139690889,
0.0536515154,
-0.0221711416,
-0.0347466879,
0.0268721003,
-0.0240942873,
-0.0002923924,
-0.069777675,
0.0407652035,
-0.0588027276,
0.019999966,
-0.0121541629,
-0.0110151833,
-0.0489665121,
-0.0306669138,
-0.0306057334,
0.0179643594,
0.0037875425,
-0.0204596836,
0.0372936465,
-0.0020137832,
-0.0002756291,
-0.0423579551,
0.0300994795,
-0.0235703494,
-0.0064776805,
-0.003412785,
-0.0141712073,
0.1058815047,
-0.0301533788,
-0.0384750441,
0.0446310602,
-0.016191477,
0.0533723123,
-0.0145640019,
0.0135313366,
0.0013393291,
-0.002297088,
0.0227230247,
0.0025328244,
0.0160518419,
-0.0401815027,
0.0426425822,
0.0416002758,
0.0133984815,
-0.0168285109,
-0.0181295108,
-0.0597528554,
0.0369824506,
-0.0471273698,
-0.016866954,
-0.0508723855,
-0.0208756868,
-0.0259816535,
-0.026581496,
0.0901233479,
0.0114036007,
-0.0153173264,
-0.0019184918,
-0.0004344664,
-0.0279882625,
0.0296952836,
-0.0100785708,
-0.0639419928,
-0.0160773974,
0.0159680583,
0.0222572051,
0.0364004448,
0.0348945856,
0.009963694,
-0.0539765842,
-0.0277067106,
0.0042080944,
-0.0739762038,
-0.0565594733,
-0.0143030761,
0.0005237274,
-0.0326809622,
-0.0230369698,
-0.017643718,
-0.0274955556,
0.0313704833,
0.0226618052,
0.0292259566,
-0.0547201596,
-0.0348259769,
-0.0518303886,
-0.0387620851,
0.0454682223,
0.031520199,
-0.0204843432,
-0.0643019155,
-0.0068830964,
-0.0487565659,
-0.0549348705,
0.0077625359,
0.0068327324,
-0.0157274269,
0.001245396,
-0.0181460809,
-0.0127491411,
-0.0347214006,
0.055747401,
0.0012335174,
0.0275235809,
0.0114407688,
-0.0034616068,
0.0171152968,
0.0105663724,
-0.000772314,
0.0229316112,
0.002208906,
-0.0275505856,
-0.0149298385,
0.0203031283,
-0.0212738644,
-0.0661931187,
-0.018650325,
0.0052053202,
0.0010957019,
-0.0735260472,
-0.0729553774,
-0.042499084,
0.0019175721,
0.0100231711,
0.0166130364,
0.0367819779,
0.0032687758,
0.002809542,
-0.0100809233,
-0.0025753314,
0.0237616096,
0.0286299139,
-0.0520266257,
0.0028057953,
0.0294693988,
-0.0271550249,
0.0170013905,
0.0094211036,
-0.1042555496,
-0.0319008753,
0.0348210782,
0.0365941674,
0.0166898314,
-0.0292985402,
-0.0291203391,
-0.0054853205,
-0.0169967338,
0.0141345933,
-0.0512974933,
-0.0061638714,
0.0085470863,
-0.0035276457,
-0.0200178642,
0.0562754758,
0.0153530752,
0.0026671262,
-0.0181299206,
0.0333266482,
0.006140681,
-0.0976939872,
0.0096881799,
-0.0010050727,
0.0394872464,
-0.0203863028,
0.0048226081,
0.0070175705,
0.0442576855,
-0.0289086811,
0.0140738068,
-0.0396206491,
-0.0120974956,
0.0493038148,
0.0192266274,
-0.0334820189,
0.0199538115,
-0.0358839333,
-0.0540306233,
-0.0065755188,
0.0410109498,
-0.0007464383,
0.042740047,
0.007381537,
0.0097112535,
-0.0169387497,
-0.0718300715,
0.0033035104,
0.0142762857,
-0.0190311521,
0.0253114477,
0.0109984865,
0.0074580736,
0.0433896445,
0.0772654563,
-0.004413194,
-0.0200458728,
0.0232847407,
-0.0190507844,
0.0550389662,
-0.018222522,
0.0991685987,
0.0106015047,
0.0114472872,
-0.0280194748,
0.0667235181,
0.0256226137,
0.0213319454,
-0.0271647032,
-0.0499115922,
-0.0031572781,
0.0375143737,
0.0456724092,
-0.0105001898,
-0.0470442697,
-0.0035311878,
-0.0370211229,
-0.0070371516,
-0.0026078867,
-0.0494386032,
-0.0406528674,
-0.0408044793,
-0.0420621373,
-0.0472317226,
-0.0727537945,
0.0136750545,
-0.0077304714,
0.0156593267,
-0.0273879059,
0.0162860658,
0.0558235161,
0.0007635336,
-0.0109720137,
-0.0596743226,
0.0359428823,
-0.0295476355,
-0.03282414,
-0.0444088355,
-5.262089809e-33,
0.002002246,
0.0140394168,
-0.0189708695,
-0.0111449249,
-0.0172243323,
-0.0151265319,
-0.0312825926,
-0.0187752452,
-0.0043975743,
0.0011360727,
-0.0325479917,
0.0258212015,
0.0180163514,
-0.0045996103,
0.0339548141,
0.0081178751,
0.0468678102,
0.0093496088,
-0.0306943543,
0.0399484299,
0.0497130714,
0.0285578407,
0.1093055904,
-0.0118722152,
0.0192884263,
-0.0710184351,
0.012655938,
0.0105899889,
-0.0056199944,
0.0316337571,
0.0384417959,
0.0276294183,
-0.0001693444,
-0.07242167,
-0.0274633672,
0.0021537775,
-0.0719086006,
0.033683978,
0.0116511583,
0.0508536138,
-0.0017457637,
-0.0235753227,
0.01419775,
-0.0310527552,
-0.0169301927,
-0.0169621035,
0.0200349037,
-0.0024427339,
-0.0084032426,
-0.0202783123,
-0.0599124804,
0.0190059263,
-0.0094911885,
-0.0078051277,
0.010391132,
0.1006303206,
-0.0054107835,
0.050363034,
-0.0526344404,
0.0049576107,
-0.013963527,
0.0432896018,
0.0608608574,
-0.0034629875,
-0.0220602155,
-0.0294071566,
-0.015254044,
0.0007597649,
0.0505356528,
0.0077614961,
0.0129478043,
-0.0116282012,
0.0397093669,
0.0193859711,
0.0297184568,
-0.0535428561,
-0.078768909,
0.0446067005,
-0.041779127,
0.0953224152,
0.0232329033,
-0.0197794344,
-0.0279636718,
-0.0058524823,
0.0032835945,
-0.0016030777,
0.0088929329,
-0.004443367,
-0.0035694027,
0.0123419687,
-0.0282316208,
0.0383666791,
0.0531565808,
-0.0289562456,
0.0559581667,
-0.0014148257,
-0.0607408881,
0.0219715405,
-0.0398523398,
0.0477637425,
-0.0460515879,
-0.0205535702,
0.0262984503,
0.0522057265,
-0.0002336821,
0.0009959752,
0.0155600887,
0.026562633,
-0.0664485693,
0.00374129,
-0.0511989929,
0.0206525214,
-0.0565351434,
0.0569087863,
0.0005922054,
0.0228629243,
-0.0086572133,
0.0347129442,
0.0323073864,
0.0036078151,
-0.0399489775,
0.0077477512,
0.0416338854,
-0.0060132369,
-0.0058281347,
0.036161378,
-0.0549396984,
0.0275276266,
0.0283956584,
-0.044145301,
-0.0309535693,
-0.0078673344,
2.507e-7,
0.0765455142,
0.0282567125,
-0.0036252392,
0.0272983331,
0.0152140781,
0.0024071818,
-0.0256103687,
0.0583052337,
0.0172515195,
0.1001606956,
0.0297464542,
-0.0013451724,
0.0528753661,
-0.0229794178,
-0.0744537488,
-0.063601166,
-0.0584450103,
0.0476260036,
-0.0334988609,
0.0170000512,
0.0329641886,
0.1176782697,
-0.0395109318,
0.0323286057,
-0.009449333,
0.0049162158,
0.0575393438,
-0.0198029764,
-0.003194344,
0.0464123413,
0.0280850995,
-0.0079250047,
-0.037538968,
0.0065521281,
-0.0324328989,
0.030327959,
0.0472570546,
0.0874769241,
0.0055634384,
-0.0074187205,
0.0164400619,
-0.0033293974,
0.0199998897,
-0.0484459251,
0.041388806,
-0.0157876965,
-0.0153464582,
0.0118672065,
-0.0329177827,
0.0561663471,
0.0267749261,
0.0044966983,
-0.0058729262,
0.0169519912,
0.0377361961,
-0.0288261138,
-0.0078132628,
-0.0217221472,
-0.0203391593,
-0.0368311964,
0.0129426802,
-0.0646159798,
-0.0045085712,
-0.0320961811,
-0.0016734859,
0.0419244096,
-0.0209221803,
1.892826577e-34,
0.0498295911,
-0.0137951653,
-0.0041707088,
0.0001207707,
0.0276441686,
-0.066203028,
0.0150081608,
0.0280412734,
0.0033401938,
-0.0529385917,
-0.0495063029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00239v1 | Filtering Context Mitigates Scarcity and Selection Bias in Political Ideology Prediction | 2023-02-01T04:34:48 | 2023-02-01T04:34:48 | Chen Chen, Dylan Walker, Venkatesh Saligrama | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | We propose a novel supervised learning approach for political ideology
prediction (PIP) that is capable of predicting out-of-distribution inputs. This
problem is motivated by the fact that manual data-labeling is expensive, while
self-reported labels are often scarce and exhibit significant selection bias.
We propose a novel statistical model that decomposes the document embeddings
into a linear superposition of two vectors; a latent neutral \emph{context}
vector independent of ideology, and a latent \emph{position} vector aligned
with ideology. We train an end-to-end model that has intermediate contextual
and positional vectors as outputs. At deployment time, our model predicts
labels for input documents by exclusively leveraging the predicted positional
vectors. On two benchmark datasets we show that our model is capable of
outputting predictions even when trained with as little as 5\% biased data, and
is significantly more accurate than the state-of-the-art. Through
crowd-sourcing we validate the neutrality of contextual vectors, and show that
context filtering results in ideological concentration, allowing for prediction
on out-of-distribution examples. | [
0.0041119386,
0.059225738,
0.0206280928,
0.0250308849,
0.0139474245,
-0.0096064229,
0.0209736507,
-0.032840725,
0.0154983196,
-0.0373290442,
-0.0079868026,
0.0079904543,
-0.0280489028,
-0.0054101008,
-0.0100774523,
-0.0588071123,
0.050601054,
0.0557729229,
0.0533923581,
-0.065952234,
0.0332335532,
0.0152543215,
0.0032084947,
0.0406081043,
-0.0448502302,
-0.0145295821,
-0.0070404471,
-0.0078917313,
0.0690391213,
0.0018505756,
0.038038101,
0.01326185,
-0.0024490545,
-0.0082246587,
0.0000020164,
-0.0059790323,
-0.0523220077,
-0.0416872725,
0.021254167,
-0.0414511785,
0.0536025576,
-0.0077097458,
-0.0142433736,
0.0291555598,
-0.0282046646,
0.0401391722,
0.0401127152,
0.0668411106,
0.0486534424,
0.0064104078,
-0.0243819393,
-0.0127048083,
-0.0209119227,
-0.0163617171,
0.0344501883,
-0.0312442295,
0.0419667698,
-0.0420191213,
-0.0613007285,
0.0633631796,
-0.0361813605,
0.0064445608,
0.0123407859,
0.0195757225,
0.0114293098,
0.0393392071,
0.0168317519,
-0.0208200142,
-0.0015307368,
0.0519835874,
0.0089457827,
-0.0240814965,
0.0417935885,
-0.0360551514,
-0.0041868398,
0.0219935253,
-0.0168168191,
-0.012494117,
-0.0363081954,
0.0528670326,
0.0804668888,
0.0320923217,
0.0234051291,
0.0449491255,
-0.0173112601,
0.0563241951,
-0.0467534699,
-0.0260960106,
0.0383856259,
-0.0205685347,
0.004369501,
-0.0289618783,
0.0186175909,
-0.0492900684,
0.0212495085,
0.0176775604,
-0.064090386,
-0.0004091875,
0.0025210516,
-0.0549859777,
-0.0267634988,
0.0055218213,
0.0200511776,
0.1034252644,
0.0594436266,
-0.0453075208,
-0.0281142928,
0.0394855477,
-0.0193955209,
-0.0208908413,
-0.0179532561,
0.0123181893,
0.0101061761,
0.0236073434,
0.0114451265,
-0.0133229271,
-0.0373813324,
-0.0104550952,
-0.0488553829,
0.0035264324,
-0.0268769301,
0.0557233915,
-0.0226828083,
-0.0280717183,
-0.0301871505,
0.0215597972,
-0.0225550961,
0.0097058248,
-0.0398768708,
0.0098711029,
0.0191851053,
0.0599226728,
-0.0146851558,
-0.0243234355,
0.015384784,
0.0379774161,
0.0275899488,
0.0161967091,
-0.0067936587,
-0.0007713555,
-0.0106540583,
-0.0144538935,
0.0383224264,
-0.0438456871,
0.0199128687,
-0.0040997071,
0.0054447791,
-0.0767198578,
0.0012821786,
0.0302152056,
-0.0455313064,
0.0840776861,
0.0472870618,
-0.0160680637,
0.0548129492,
0.030032387,
-0.0001511561,
0.0832465887,
-0.0072741485,
0.0468415879,
0.0444853306,
-0.0264721699,
0.0153321521,
0.0224455539,
0.0364936665,
0.049442187,
-0.0402459241,
0.0191100389,
-0.0133584356,
-0.0267761834,
0.0300528537,
0.008631343,
0.0405423008,
-0.0698709339,
0.049671948,
0.0150963031,
-0.0105215069,
-0.0106355241,
-0.0139133912,
0.0336523615,
-0.0242394302,
-0.023757698,
-0.0182462335,
0.0623100586,
0.0018917888,
-0.0413280725,
0.0640006885,
0.0162233692,
-0.0268925633,
-0.0337837078,
-0.0323733836,
0.0068580583,
-0.0047373059,
0.0001325348,
0.0235340297,
-0.0627789944,
-0.0414489768,
0.0131271258,
0.0531097539,
-0.013927198,
-0.0071404949,
-0.0105538983,
0.0576873049,
0.0268498156,
0.018598007,
-0.0740467906,
0.004476164,
-0.0435093045,
0.05945215,
0.0240771789,
0.0765710846,
-0.0414332598,
-0.0218071099,
-0.0190526824,
-0.0374760255,
0.020716602,
0.0083305249,
0.0497138612,
0.0290777311,
0.0287721716,
0.0081302999,
-0.027782023,
0.0215353761,
0.0356045738,
-0.015219111,
-0.0473756604,
0.0338226147,
0.0364195555,
0.0571289696,
0.0337957963,
0.0020344551,
-0.0474845096,
0.0597625151,
-0.0103939446,
-0.0335870162,
-0.0117221642,
-0.0439682715,
0.017081229,
0.0036053471,
-0.055053059,
-0.0019328664,
0.0318128876,
-0.006863167,
-0.0004603584,
0.0312959515,
-0.0112041198,
-0.0048728748,
-0.0352200195,
-0.0657604411,
-0.0279621072,
-0.0035507635,
-0.0635541826,
0.0799250007,
-0.014847314,
0.0034627153,
0.0030974138,
-0.0407863557,
0.0281218234,
0.0147103481,
-0.0101317884,
-0.0470298566,
0.0223747659,
0.0321381837,
0.0450041406,
-0.0667451844,
-0.004866262,
-0.0453302599,
-0.0257303417,
-0.0092998352,
-0.0081462394,
0.0141232964,
0.0102294143,
-0.0344490707,
0.0107468478,
0.0196521059,
-0.0500488877,
-0.0182587523,
-0.0448938683,
0.0144129395,
0.0319961645,
-0.0040017092,
0.0141518414,
-0.0241299942,
0.006548027,
-0.009612618,
0.0286275931,
0.0352447629,
-0.0397654399,
0.0187786929,
-0.0166850649,
-0.0373242386,
0.0066912724,
-0.0598123856,
0.0042973515,
-0.0077199941,
-0.0270444229,
-0.0210101455,
0.0217886027,
0.0251709074,
0.0513060726,
0.0231382102,
0.0472931005,
-0.0529671609,
-0.0434977375,
-0.060468968,
0.0468583442,
-0.0304473508,
0.0122700203,
0.01719952,
0.0740792677,
0.0332616344,
-0.0029635797,
-0.0587963909,
0.0700907484,
-0.0147483582,
-0.0267453957,
-0.0320096239,
-0.0067297998,
0.007987991,
0.0008870885,
-0.0136679932,
-0.0470437109,
0.0573978536,
0.0360769331,
0.0469446704,
-0.0044850977,
-0.0347996019,
-0.0136573184,
-0.0015531745,
-0.0079416595,
-0.0073486916,
-0.0096587604,
0.0432927907,
-0.0343219899,
-0.0132329147,
0.027963765,
-0.0322464183,
0.0041317977,
0.000019317,
0.0291821267,
-0.0170673728,
-0.0379101299,
-0.059406288,
-0.0943751708,
0.0369423702,
-0.0064043477,
0.0251377914,
-0.0106518073,
-0.0236144662,
-0.0179401692,
0.0256297085,
-0.024387259,
0.0163669661,
-0.0214263722,
0.0338972509,
0.006637875,
-0.0137227112,
-0.0421313457,
0.0177551489,
-0.0127451587,
-0.0426611044,
0.0293196402,
0.0255240854,
0.0319692679,
-0.0290867686,
-0.0377538875,
0.006744389,
-0.0010707567,
-0.0289304443,
-0.0277212672,
-0.0142045263,
-0.0088172769,
0.0465507321,
0.0542072579,
0.0295798834,
-0.0706795454,
-0.0121834697,
0.0370827876,
-0.0143306851,
0.0405308157,
0.0118490383,
-0.0806512684,
0.0041806796,
0.0127471536,
0.0290110279,
-0.0151308859,
-0.0458636619,
-0.0056671342,
-0.0907301158,
0.0119052194,
0.0000136531,
-0.0235915314,
-0.045269262,
-0.0620427653,
0.0431070179,
-0.0406604819,
-0.0766141936,
-0.0352988094,
0.0159616731,
0.0442130119,
0.0074032419,
-0.0654836968,
-0.0429648943,
0.0274071861,
0.0019107418,
0.0168038178,
-0.0015279519,
0.0500061885,
-0.0138735482,
-0.0478627235,
0.0636776239,
-0.0587336123,
-0.0295034032,
0.0044092182,
0.0669657812,
-0.0555687696,
-0.0193430893,
-0.0026375146,
0.0747455657,
0.019720789,
-0.0023127527,
-0.0192251652,
0.0504744574,
-0.0292537883,
-0.0138033414,
-0.0062252609,
0.0126626417,
0.0709672868,
0.0640620813,
-0.0034947658,
-0.0596044399,
0.0132595878,
-0.0548289865,
0.0290275477,
-0.034278892,
0.0177415758,
-0.0154777048,
-0.0478707403,
-0.0135061564,
-0.0370046757,
-0.0447010621,
0.0041527376,
0.0157361217,
0.0037895844,
0.0021468706,
-0.0351407267,
-0.0164903272,
-0.0236507468,
0.004639959,
0.0097644236,
0.0200617388,
0.0232056119,
-0.0446504951,
-0.0074129207,
-0.0253209956,
-0.0609045699,
0.0072701913,
-0.0008163471,
-0.0462230444,
0.0436350778,
0.0200095102,
0.0093378033,
0.0580779575,
-0.0158858635,
0.00334012,
0.0946701616,
0.0919235125,
-0.0118924081,
0.0070505561,
0.0560576208,
0.0251787733,
0.0209645461,
0.0235398021,
-0.0385958478,
0.0521149598,
0.0582035407,
-0.1057002544,
-0.085052833,
-0.019464232,
-0.0082401242,
-0.0319341347,
0.0682578459,
-0.0084493896,
-0.04422969,
-0.0591568127,
-0.0033615257,
0.0288543403,
-0.0482461378,
0.037655104,
-0.0251813903,
0.0310857054,
-0.0692149624,
-0.0252224542,
0.0410668664,
0.0259535965,
0.0331385955,
-0.0117345992,
0.0301269274,
0.000280689,
0.0165944248,
0.0131263947,
0.0242861137,
0.0025765153,
0.0229366161,
0.0034701745,
0.0381803773,
-0.0094140358,
0.0013668322,
0.0246387552,
0.0265860166,
0.0406842716,
-0.0485984087,
-0.0338802971,
-0.0055418634,
-0.0295989066,
0.0298587028,
-0.0052174539,
-0.0128330644,
-0.0138512664,
-0.004908808,
-0.0278229397,
-0.0290898699,
0.0172792934,
-0.0003511114,
-0.0500551835,
0.0368602797,
0.0069901394,
-0.0361672491,
0.0270755719,
0.0383477509,
0.0313724466,
0.0304678101,
0.016171027,
-0.0334812626,
-0.0478657521,
0.0326304324,
0.0034866321,
0.0260849576,
-0.0202261079,
0.0146425553,
-0.0450779758,
-0.0262614954,
0.0377612747,
0.0232160594,
-0.0035938963,
0.0195776634,
0.0121541834,
0.0661708638,
-0.0109276697,
0.0649940968,
-0.0657828972,
0.0190815944,
-0.0712265745,
-0.0280293878,
0.0043802569,
-6.457516503e-33,
-0.008799335,
-0.0351371281,
-0.0062996349,
0.0079795467,
0.0172292665,
0.007741089,
-0.0088780764,
-0.0072238315,
-0.0001621061,
0.0358634256,
0.0044068201,
0.0231341608,
-0.0035575447,
0.0211709738,
-0.0102769481,
-0.0297749229,
-0.0019355535,
0.0009128801,
-0.0121976649,
0.0352276079,
0.0549673587,
0.0116077447,
0.0359780677,
-0.1144709289,
0.0173849817,
-0.0009229963,
0.0106518269,
-0.0559988804,
-0.0033357188,
0.0359532833,
-0.0033799855,
0.0197537355,
0.046140682,
-0.0411893465,
0.0047148531,
0.0644222945,
-0.0275866091,
-0.0335508436,
-0.0402838886,
-0.0179545134,
-0.0073009632,
-0.0139928367,
0.0085531808,
0.022808155,
-0.0239388589,
-0.0442659073,
0.0856084451,
-0.000473325,
-0.0187949203,
-0.0433183648,
0.0013168661,
0.035269428,
-0.0257592835,
0.0182986539,
-0.0247636791,
0.060740903,
0.0918429121,
0.0831011981,
-0.0890731439,
0.0238701981,
-0.0637715086,
-0.0000200532,
-0.0088905953,
-0.0221142191,
0.0112360576,
0.1043125987,
0.0107714683,
0.0353886038,
-0.0585189313,
-0.0483732037,
0.0142867789,
-0.0089376532,
0.0453927852,
0.0456457622,
0.0479728319,
-0.0728087947,
-0.07847175,
0.0287661683,
0.0290698223,
-0.0417758971,
0.0071552983,
-0.0067137089,
-0.0089225136,
-0.0234877039,
-0.0233192705,
-0.0825827643,
-0.0300448146,
0.0126920082,
-0.0002683644,
0.0301285703,
-0.0526170693,
0.0542029962,
0.0178637262,
-0.030051427,
-0.0173640884,
0.0561489239,
-0.0296823326,
-0.0049083671,
-0.0134079559,
-0.0027524405,
-0.0763072968,
0.0127991093,
-0.0278027784,
-0.0047381129,
0.0290108081,
-0.0189456791,
0.0483326688,
0.0078270761,
-0.0750211403,
-0.0238231681,
-0.0338752382,
0.0297000874,
-0.0058126445,
0.0540227853,
0.0405507907,
0.0387257263,
0.0154817039,
-0.0077767475,
0.0072921733,
0.038169235,
0.0189131685,
-0.0424209684,
-0.0511679985,
-0.0040753633,
-0.0251864176,
-0.0473896936,
-0.0163854063,
0.0609130934,
0.0318444408,
-0.0585867204,
-0.0116986213,
-0.0053292592,
2.694e-7,
0.0331657976,
0.0421399027,
-0.0164705813,
-0.0417208262,
-0.0013268329,
0.0579045862,
0.0288680531,
0.0473910384,
-0.0962442458,
-0.0761954188,
-0.0285146534,
0.0397186093,
0.0335832462,
0.0303314142,
-0.080263555,
-0.0041070348,
-0.0166497361,
0.0547647551,
-0.0485391021,
0.0250710845,
-0.0117225079,
0.0519810021,
0.0826252326,
-0.0136545897,
0.0043612574,
0.0199418347,
0.0474221818,
-0.0132961897,
-0.0067841322,
0.0000525644,
0.0182787552,
-0.0390476137,
-0.0045665861,
0.0168628506,
-0.0218221303,
-0.0150703844,
-0.0140723838,
0.0539213978,
-0.0095796008,
0.0054148966,
-0.000007406,
0.0209600292,
-0.0066396315,
-0.0045970636,
0.0824689493,
-0.0405468903,
0.0151141807,
-0.0747112408,
-0.0517490618,
0.0135663068,
0.0431053601,
0.0233724099,
0.0129610933,
-0.0074437731,
-0.0313982144,
-0.0184955299,
0.0057577509,
-0.0713234842,
0.0018353735,
-0.0160838868,
-0.0522534139,
-0.0134331314,
0.0324005112,
0.0449835919,
0.0595728569,
-0.0231425092,
0.0097895367,
2.277060668e-34,
0.0242567696,
-0.0216633584,
-0.0297017116,
-0.0613693818,
0.0345815346,
-0.0225682799,
-0.001685224,
-0.0022981109,
0.0266353115,
-0.0104464805,
0.0108034881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00200v1 | A Transaction Represented with Weighted Finite-State Transducers | 2023-02-01T03:05:14 | 2023-02-01T03:05:14 | J. Nathaniel Holmes, Homayoon Beigi | cs.FL | cs.FL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, math.RA | Not all contracts are good, but all good contracts can be expressed as a
finite-state transition system ("State-Transition Contracts"). Contracts that
can be represented as State-Transition Contracts discretize fat-tailed risk to
foreseeable, managed risk, define the boundary of relevant events governed by
the relationship, and eliminate the potential of inconsistent contractual
provisions. Additionally, State-Transition Contracts reap the substantial
benefit of being able to be analyzed under the rules governing the science of
the theory of computation. Simple State-Transition Contracts can be represented
as discrete finite automata; more complicated State-Transition Contracts, such
as those that have downstream effects on other agreements or complicated
pathways of performance, benefit from representation as weighted finite-state
transducers, with weights assigned as costs, penalties, or probabilities of
transitions. This research paper (the "Research" or "Paper") presents a complex
legal transaction represented as weighted finite-state transducers.
Furthermore, we show that the mathematics/algorithms permitted by the algebraic
structure of weighted finite-state transducers provides actionable, legal
insight into the transaction. | [
0.0065533323,
0.0640631393,
-0.0105864955,
-0.0482343957,
-0.0270720217,
-0.0354953334,
0.0186481513,
0.020416813,
-0.0323801599,
-0.0299445055,
0.0540509075,
0.0231167115,
0.012005982,
0.0402447022,
0.0161442496,
-0.0419865549,
0.0188363958,
-0.0424903855,
-0.018208351,
0.0215079226,
0.0149286352,
-0.0447572544,
-0.0236034989,
-0.0007529446,
-0.0303018652,
-0.0223532561,
-0.0085876435,
-0.022831345,
0.0107260784,
-0.0298667271,
-0.031173896,
-0.0005793919,
-0.0078874156,
0.039929837,
0.000002235,
-0.0424224995,
-0.0466793254,
0.0250439439,
0.0097598732,
0.0587921552,
-0.0733821988,
-0.0491605662,
-0.0254650842,
0.0150371296,
-0.0034735301,
0.04822978,
0.0603270568,
-0.0043446599,
0.0209907722,
0.0261287168,
0.0012299931,
-0.0262277499,
0.0188244469,
-0.0008545346,
-0.0535573028,
-0.1336921304,
0.0425107107,
-0.015655037,
0.0273469854,
-0.0892596096,
-0.0289150421,
-0.0076609887,
-0.0054502641,
-0.081058532,
0.0109297568,
-0.0001421118,
0.0160866696,
0.0143993804,
-0.0702255145,
-0.0035919945,
0.08961007,
0.0037058704,
0.029196443,
0.0065488978,
-0.0045866012,
-0.0296260491,
0.0030485597,
0.0450022928,
0.0001619788,
0.0067859632,
0.0106331529,
0.0636492521,
0.0134172691,
-0.0080184015,
-0.0514203869,
0.078397356,
0.0060868454,
-0.0337162428,
-0.0075628585,
0.0174903441,
0.0573545843,
-0.042510815,
0.074619852,
0.0574911498,
-0.0199139416,
0.0175944921,
-0.0114339981,
-0.0031435541,
0.0197145808,
-0.0338816084,
0.0292497184,
-0.0050052367,
0.0143924886,
0.0437109955,
0.0170155596,
0.0091406582,
-0.0503508747,
-0.0451331176,
0.0157018527,
0.0525061041,
0.0105393408,
-0.009579557,
-0.0602858812,
0.0527933687,
0.0247082449,
0.0236872677,
-0.0385401361,
0.0318207815,
-0.0624726303,
0.039268557,
-0.0027259851,
-0.0482259877,
-0.0191871338,
-0.0425480753,
-0.0383952484,
-0.0303950571,
-0.0032195314,
0.0260149967,
0.0046413536,
0.0527874157,
0.0138223348,
-0.0330256298,
0.0054968442,
0.0063526453,
-0.0402606018,
0.095021598,
0.021293655,
0.016497409,
0.0016364857,
-0.0441753305,
0.0351607688,
-0.0217076503,
-0.0634718165,
0.0074997027,
-0.0238991007,
-0.0429876745,
-0.019202916,
-0.0035569158,
-0.0261726417,
0.0269472729,
0.0306341723,
0.018566696,
-0.0081721656,
0.009955084,
-0.1060602367,
-0.0129920002,
0.0301113334,
-0.0232264251,
0.0286314953,
-0.0107531426,
0.0188266635,
-0.0223358553,
0.0591984801,
0.0192287937,
-0.0071466127,
0.0289630685,
-0.0113215419,
-0.0219119545,
0.0316641852,
-0.0444215499,
-0.0485199876,
0.0299459789,
-0.0153703503,
0.0194909461,
-0.0029769163,
0.0071271281,
0.0142768305,
0.0259748064,
-0.0132161984,
-0.0136149311,
-0.006431892,
0.0248226542,
-0.0001097382,
0.0305151474,
-0.0519041419,
-0.022371646,
-0.0574667752,
0.0092942482,
-0.0345396698,
-0.0300481245,
0.0477969088,
-0.005525521,
0.0544825867,
-0.0147722866,
0.0064961798,
0.0007270254,
0.0073307175,
0.023375487,
-0.026770575,
0.0272333678,
0.0062964819,
-0.0443744212,
-0.0080540748,
0.0134187043,
0.0177529044,
-0.0410649665,
0.0228729602,
-0.0244146585,
-0.0319087207,
0.0385672972,
0.001917723,
0.0055939178,
-0.0122975474,
0.0300505497,
0.0009286113,
0.1086577252,
0.0450151227,
0.031111585,
-0.0890242755,
-0.0048004179,
-0.0303427633,
0.0066711111,
0.0435620733,
-0.0080646276,
0.0467117839,
-0.0518374518,
0.0228693765,
0.0162152164,
0.0229128227,
-0.0007087435,
0.0320214555,
0.0350896232,
0.0147118447,
0.053673923,
-0.0324647017,
0.0448852405,
-0.0272533037,
0.088856779,
0.0208288599,
-0.0241998751,
-0.0085217301,
-0.0517904386,
-0.0021232204,
-0.0247411728,
0.0074924482,
-0.0321423858,
-0.0168087147,
0.0132583613,
0.0413928032,
0.0159845073,
0.0050059864,
0.0257646404,
-0.0236353204,
0.0126149841,
-0.0262385029,
-0.0556089729,
-0.0973577574,
0.0290206503,
0.0190863218,
0.0144085269,
0.0406079367,
-0.051766403,
-0.0160066169,
0.0258578137,
0.0036778979,
0.0495095327,
-0.0049791969,
-0.0099230325,
0.0335509516,
0.0038801243,
0.0280886907,
-0.0076492145,
0.0092327883,
-0.0026394604,
-0.0127327023,
-0.0174320564,
-0.0087715583,
-0.0249865912,
-0.0373676084,
-0.0056347284,
0.0029176576,
-0.1050418988,
0.0214612279,
-0.0454591438,
-0.0480616279,
-0.0232852455,
0.0019692024,
-0.0452772975,
-0.1055951938,
0.0303283129,
0.0078404872,
-0.0294809323,
-0.0083131967,
0.0205647871,
-0.0052208663,
0.0240101777,
-0.039674975,
0.0184330996,
-0.0003362574,
0.0505055636,
0.0203751121,
-0.0621678904,
0.0114975404,
-0.0312336665,
0.0090301381,
-0.0076950979,
-0.0545698218,
0.0193629283,
0.0466763899,
0.0060918881,
-0.0205026474,
-0.0165331308,
-0.0468433686,
-0.023255026,
-0.0205288921,
0.0295526423,
0.0207770038,
-0.0567947328,
-0.0257593431,
0.0817876011,
0.0226012524,
-0.0069039701,
0.0424808785,
0.0021504394,
0.051595252,
-0.0274284817,
-0.0057203509,
-0.0447905101,
0.0460491478,
-0.0150702149,
0.0069029951,
0.0111051388,
-0.0284963921,
0.0119289123,
-0.0142340688,
0.071089305,
-0.000176875,
0.0194323696,
-0.0092947083,
0.0159551576,
-0.0223723501,
-0.0096662715,
0.0446133018,
0.0147470906,
0.0064592827,
0.0472906418,
0.0214707181,
0.0409410112,
0.0356559604,
0.018419005,
0.0059870896,
0.0086546,
0.0170567613,
-0.0027780901,
-0.0330558717,
-0.0309972502,
-0.0315446556,
-0.0559179187,
0.0355802029,
-0.0267424248,
0.0127896974,
-0.0103015108,
0.0112092011,
-0.003445884,
0.0328176767,
0.0065159374,
0.0177616198,
-0.036908526,
0.0229903888,
0.0505892262,
-0.0281246416,
-0.0273455456,
-0.0046293493,
-0.0197917968,
0.0116178794,
0.03074109,
0.0672442392,
0.0018881712,
-0.009319393,
-0.0031132898,
0.03112562,
-0.150561884,
0.0913196132,
-0.0282899085,
-0.0081422264,
-0.042078428,
-0.0202960577,
-0.021956699,
0.012998729,
0.0545896292,
0.0059143985,
0.0072756368,
-0.0100279115,
0.010261545,
-0.0034839485,
0.0014840064,
-0.0559107959,
-0.015017054,
-0.0226151347,
-0.015599668,
0.0426736251,
0.0178602673,
0.0722412542,
-0.0054816669,
0.0410329811,
-0.0076901196,
0.0609547682,
0.0089206211,
-0.0202231035,
0.0033226772,
0.0109038288,
-0.0241434742,
-0.0185271502,
0.0246541202,
-0.0319515243,
0.0575339273,
0.0020019505,
-0.0387559682,
0.0136270477,
0.047999464,
-0.0267259385,
0.0346512869,
0.0795118585,
0.0068151704,
-0.0388316065,
-0.0037771696,
-0.0857239887,
0.0325532034,
-0.0044275085,
-0.0524914823,
0.0045762919,
-0.0800053999,
-0.0267851315,
-0.0453971922,
-0.0210278612,
-0.0055327234,
-0.0662590042,
-0.0119019086,
-0.0112543395,
-0.0123690702,
-0.0182373617,
-0.0277742967,
0.0390090644,
0.0153663438,
0.0147277545,
0.153401345,
-0.0078776944,
-0.0163684338,
-0.0479589216,
-0.0533183888,
0.0590329506,
0.0145790894,
0.0232462455,
-0.0325514972,
0.0770892426,
-0.0344942994,
-0.0563863255,
0.0050844755,
0.0077416096,
-0.0175206736,
0.0400276817,
0.0313623212,
-0.1209488586,
-0.0379324146,
0.0048666378,
-0.0157906674,
-0.0175742581,
-0.0244297814,
-0.0055598072,
0.0550956056,
-0.0458697937,
-0.004335728,
-0.0245356876,
-0.0005323392,
-0.0147800352,
-0.0083604138,
0.0131356185,
0.0005832264,
-0.0248990767,
0.0149818389,
0.0630386993,
-0.0885783583,
0.002021367,
0.0307058245,
0.0250976086,
0.024835607,
-0.0227534287,
0.0350056477,
-0.0350306369,
0.0246281587,
0.0331783332,
-0.0145895733,
-0.0446280353,
0.0015004029,
0.0268744603,
-0.0413286574,
0.0508323684,
0.0646734387,
0.0177409798,
-0.0337918773,
0.0453899316,
-0.0426769778,
0.0292053055,
0.0274643935,
0.0444054753,
0.0142879272,
-0.0024370858,
-0.0035631231,
0.0340490229,
0.0086582368,
-0.0100517552,
0.0122682853,
0.0210869182,
-0.0553818643,
0.0274177585,
0.0186193306,
0.0068219709,
0.0514010899,
-0.0083318474,
-0.064223595,
0.0309489761,
0.0148142884,
0.0083054472,
-0.0278340336,
-0.0304147247,
-0.013797137,
0.045551464,
0.0620535128,
0.0642140135,
0.0410340689,
-0.02009142,
0.0489107072,
-0.0976422802,
0.0066913818,
-0.0156172225,
-0.0612505339,
-0.0493777283,
-0.0161566436,
0.002700971,
-0.0451406911,
-0.0819022655,
-0.0385052748,
0.0124125089,
-0.0419019386,
0.0544431433,
-0.0200334098,
-0.0269998182,
-0.0501994714,
0.0163315404,
0.0313457251,
-0.0195338167,
-0.0174519271,
0.0520735718,
-0.0352112502,
0.0061226375,
-6.169247819e-33,
-0.0089834221,
-0.0091099804,
0.0152825229,
0.0271749999,
-0.0043771672,
-0.0724188015,
-0.0560515188,
0.0185626354,
0.0840946063,
0.007631111,
-0.0184093975,
0.003807755,
0.0362274423,
-0.0051924251,
-0.0063613565,
0.005654057,
0.0101745371,
-0.0370231122,
-0.0120516922,
-0.033919502,
-0.0605808757,
-0.0199650731,
0.0182188451,
-0.0220429637,
0.0425690822,
0.0422670431,
-0.069449015,
0.0067426017,
-0.056001652,
0.0244971681,
-0.0104600666,
-0.0075859055,
-0.0027709196,
-0.0520895645,
0.0097291376,
0.0289501604,
-0.0001631593,
0.0035978882,
-0.013495489,
0.0062672384,
0.0231796727,
-0.029690301,
0.0130388718,
-0.004807251,
-0.0552437864,
-0.0057732374,
0.0182749592,
-0.0225250255,
0.0111675858,
-0.083557114,
-0.0929296017,
0.0244625825,
-0.0350444242,
0.0407694988,
0.0379424617,
-0.013560853,
-0.0055711903,
-0.0960034803,
0.0140925366,
-0.0037892458,
-0.0141873127,
0.0102257961,
-0.0207424108,
-0.0737242252,
0.0388731286,
-0.023315886,
-0.0419612937,
0.0248521231,
-0.0205741711,
-0.017693527,
-0.0232444238,
0.0357361957,
-0.0015324043,
-0.0085614016,
-0.0052141361,
-0.011166974,
-0.0635314062,
0.0274947975,
0.0140441488,
0.0365091674,
-0.0067256098,
0.0255132671,
0.0019012226,
-0.0083795544,
-0.0235832576,
-0.004068966,
-0.0050910241,
0.0294990372,
-0.0005623431,
-0.0193640757,
0.0153074171,
0.0389040858,
0.0318573862,
-0.0161305591,
-0.1267285347,
-0.0145379556,
0.0868469998,
0.020662874,
-0.0156155424,
0.0023177988,
-0.0128730526,
-0.0132102771,
-0.0086192135,
-0.0157666337,
0.0358570926,
0.0341357216,
0.0394835062,
0.0246784613,
-0.0378240235,
0.0304337237,
-0.0015812276,
0.0262072235,
0.0639153421,
0.0382379033,
0.0087023433,
-0.0151288677,
-0.0219888948,
0.0096777305,
0.0078886114,
-0.0401671603,
-0.0111648757,
0.0774295703,
-0.0088725537,
0.0363382958,
0.0048387726,
-0.0110828355,
0.0296267048,
0.038126342,
0.0326186791,
-0.0280121807,
0.017428454,
0.0077476855,
3.036e-7,
-0.0168951508,
0.0026330482,
0.0220441967,
0.0374181159,
0.0133888284,
0.0406044386,
0.0096119475,
0.005197804,
0.0183693916,
-0.0058984738,
0.0102193812,
-0.041703701,
0.0056551383,
-0.0110160643,
0.0244858805,
-0.0354522914,
0.0287097525,
-0.0214879345,
-0.0211429242,
-0.0594490692,
0.0482179895,
-0.0219780896,
0.0499944799,
-0.0018245326,
0.0224275235,
0.0289006121,
0.0166895408,
0.0079790773,
0.0367478207,
-0.0073723248,
0.0361941457,
-0.0225855261,
0.0117133008,
0.0416498668,
0.0180863701,
0.0567400232,
-0.014093522,
0.0848993585,
0.008919456,
0.0241858307,
-0.0201467685,
-0.0744965076,
-0.0027110144,
0.04436047,
0.0100948215,
0.0121153323,
-0.0207484569,
-0.0255128853,
-0.0396972261,
-0.0178934969,
-0.0200327653,
0.0717658103,
0.0436113179,
0.0077695092,
-0.0194790773,
0.0435827114,
0.0427166969,
-0.0167084672,
-0.0106435483,
0.0369946435,
0.0218614731,
0.0017104071,
-0.0006177641,
0.072946392,
-0.0067948624,
-0.1009744257,
-0.0152458772,
2.667478617e-34,
-0.0083362525,
-0.0717393532,
0.0509158,
0.0464126579,
0.0151544102,
0.0287700761,
-0.0137926219,
0.0093061719,
0.0572773442,
-0.0456474125,
-0.0431382582
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.12038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.12038v1 | Grading Conversational Responses Of Chatbots | 2023-02-01T02:54:43 | 2023-02-01T02:54:43 | Grant Rosario, David Noever | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Chatbots have long been capable of answering basic questions and even
responding to obscure prompts, but recently their improvements have been far
more significant. Modern chatbots like Open AIs ChatGPT3 not only have the
ability to answer basic questions but can write code and movie scripts and
imitate well-known people. In this paper, we analyze ChatGPTs' responses to
various questions from a dataset of queries from the popular Quora forum. We
submitted sixty questions to ChatGPT and scored the answers based on three
industry-standard metrics for grading machine translation: BLEU, METEOR, and
ROUGE. These metrics allow us to compare the machine responses with the most
upvoted human answer to the same question to assess ChatGPT's ability to submit
a humanistic reply. The results showed that while the responses and translation
abilities of ChatGPT are remarkable, they still fall short of what a typical
human reaction would be. | [
0.0597581752,
0.030608492,
-0.0283152442,
-0.0133961318,
-0.0059260763,
0.0103719281,
-0.0309307836,
0.0120230289,
0.027046727,
-0.0330801681,
-0.025106024,
0.0041666669,
-0.0012792364,
0.0539392903,
-0.0012167061,
-0.0413308367,
-0.0108135343,
0.005072304,
0.0191258416,
-0.0180426389,
0.0218216795,
0.018506106,
-0.0176925119,
0.0700415224,
-0.0084739057,
-0.0161955487,
-0.0028747038,
0.0322275311,
0.0261760484,
0.0244699121,
0.0153544201,
0.038097579,
-0.0024426605,
0.0624625273,
0.0000017571,
-0.0384109132,
0.0196001325,
-0.0015716898,
-0.0177550726,
-0.0352116488,
0.044711519,
-0.0056408183,
0.0017350561,
0.0403013304,
-0.0857129842,
0.0008374801,
0.0582432486,
-0.0053493939,
0.0743800849,
0.0612987578,
-0.0160655603,
0.0088293171,
0.0173682813,
0.0191700701,
0.0103799477,
-0.0555287302,
-0.0324543305,
0.0609057806,
0.0270874389,
0.0082051344,
-0.0250979941,
0.046111159,
0.0283292439,
-0.048158627,
0.0233579651,
0.009609051,
-0.0238266643,
-0.0417682081,
0.0014139068,
0.0895382762,
0.0139828334,
-0.0079768635,
-0.0197765175,
0.0304131899,
0.0112357959,
-0.0387237146,
-0.0545501187,
0.0097129066,
0.0062026144,
-0.0252840556,
-0.0400263369,
0.0071421233,
-0.0120587181,
-0.0057301181,
0.0071897241,
0.0021021713,
0.0123435566,
-0.0018454477,
-0.0229400322,
0.0138292117,
0.0079664839,
-0.0608974658,
0.0320125781,
0.0691493079,
-0.0419596545,
-0.0188610964,
-0.0216530357,
0.0036043655,
0.0298081506,
-0.0378271975,
-0.0174876563,
0.0651324987,
0.0007391305,
0.0570014194,
-0.0088940328,
0.0790227354,
0.0046491888,
0.0236621834,
-0.0437811948,
-0.0218289234,
-0.0692335591,
0.0008990644,
-0.0022495524,
0.0052717174,
0.0208060294,
0.023061242,
-0.014637813,
0.0460483059,
-0.0124259964,
-0.0025385895,
0.0047564269,
0.0277304612,
-0.0301169232,
-0.0175108686,
-0.0418574437,
0.0281717926,
-0.0749559477,
0.0100513184,
0.0174264647,
-0.0975911245,
0.0013684345,
0.0197796468,
0.0236456245,
-0.0027950157,
0.0245077778,
0.0732565895,
0.0029636156,
-0.0115863895,
0.0791734308,
-0.0005566238,
0.0059491387,
-0.0493144281,
-0.0141512631,
-0.0418910347,
0.0622529499,
0.027703831,
-0.0301035848,
0.0231852327,
0.0154553317,
0.0358729288,
-0.0036365178,
0.0378662348,
-0.0227374472,
0.0128270555,
0.0351758115,
0.0112687182,
-0.0676832348,
0.013459268,
0.0260647777,
0.0547560565,
0.0419190079,
-0.0229615606,
0.0546944812,
0.0183302667,
-0.0262039769,
-0.0054866695,
0.0127415396,
0.0598277561,
-0.0032029876,
0.0388871022,
0.0467165336,
0.0489298925,
-0.0260388665,
-0.0252934135,
0.0714437366,
0.0508666523,
-0.0532015488,
0.0337069593,
0.0243360437,
0.016184438,
0.030432146,
0.0174436271,
-0.0310404934,
0.0428618193,
-0.0350793563,
-0.0472622663,
0.0254756771,
-0.0094063086,
-0.0012668455,
-0.053470958,
0.0232922789,
-0.0098269721,
0.0564702414,
-0.0116788661,
0.0036480406,
0.0058643925,
-0.0189412329,
-0.0313850157,
-0.0175990202,
-0.0470709354,
-0.0080234725,
-0.075249128,
0.0137880696,
0.0666232854,
0.0699205622,
-0.0102544231,
-0.004491406,
-0.0321290269,
0.0071681812,
0.0479249544,
0.0729225576,
-0.0170187447,
-0.0049758884,
-0.0025222562,
0.0134797329,
-0.0031852466,
-0.0192982294,
0.0119685149,
0.0007480201,
0.0488628484,
-0.0217407979,
-0.0266848169,
-0.0393307842,
0.017166594,
0.0198432412,
-0.0000830434,
0.0014430532,
-0.0045487317,
0.0218585823,
0.0347842015,
-0.0116473511,
0.0083321016,
0.0220126398,
-0.0122254761,
-0.0667408407,
0.0067717098,
-0.0132604074,
-0.0204258319,
0.0296738781,
-0.0618989728,
-0.0472465605,
0.063959606,
-0.0211939961,
-0.0090004504,
0.0096409433,
-0.079595767,
-0.0025294081,
-0.0345570371,
-0.0015724062,
-0.0191935785,
0.0309440959,
-0.0285249334,
0.0249563362,
0.0059351241,
0.0114856604,
0.0026003425,
-0.0062343227,
0.0010603904,
-0.020995276,
-0.0067537422,
0.024835486,
-0.008611965,
0.0448395908,
0.049667377,
0.020347653,
-0.0689564273,
-0.0319464728,
-0.1091767475,
-0.0198263582,
-0.0100812502,
0.0115437945,
0.0487075076,
0.0020485721,
0.0204913747,
-0.0171846692,
-0.0880142301,
0.04658705,
0.0239333138,
0.0210908093,
0.0659094453,
0.0097222291,
-0.0231220946,
-0.0561566912,
0.0055810334,
-0.0141001437,
-0.0068146223,
0.03943903,
0.0248532519,
-0.0209881496,
0.0071715731,
-0.0635753497,
-0.0120557919,
-0.0101687098,
-0.0973237678,
0.0478095785,
-0.0243455227,
0.0111653255,
0.0853194743,
0.0512942262,
0.0099955229,
0.0141239045,
0.0428466611,
-0.0506582223,
-0.0182225741,
-0.0071141678,
-0.0383858234,
-0.0225990862,
-0.0678690895,
0.0090920655,
0.0023617344,
0.0037711768,
0.0325294659,
-0.0689027682,
0.0608694889,
0.0165146515,
-0.0646529198,
-0.0237299073,
0.0262361709,
0.001559183,
0.0458198413,
0.0049031083,
-0.036092326,
0.0671974346,
-0.0126862423,
-0.0233966969,
-0.0104364986,
-0.0167197715,
-0.0215826351,
0.0594819859,
-0.0143709853,
0.0309110284,
-0.0521351136,
-0.0271315016,
-0.0432671942,
-0.0002915552,
0.0119572971,
-0.0654088035,
-0.0101541746,
-0.0091046253,
-0.0091879722,
-0.009148444,
-0.0320199989,
-0.0285690557,
-0.0265969057,
-0.0174662396,
0.0084290681,
0.0323987752,
-0.0510776937,
-0.0312280636,
-0.0208850857,
0.0193891823,
0.0000824857,
-0.0103172688,
-0.0253338832,
-0.0147408508,
0.0203306228,
0.0377413705,
0.0722355023,
0.0449494794,
-0.0109169511,
0.035063751,
0.049826242,
0.0290408358,
0.0116955033,
0.0003956794,
-0.0588823594,
0.0226779431,
0.0219613388,
0.0121169537,
-0.0210803822,
0.0605593212,
-0.0243489873,
-0.0088277142,
0.0961986855,
0.0118422322,
-0.051166404,
0.013718605,
-0.0555851273,
0.0218610615,
0.024115853,
0.0416027494,
-0.0913258865,
-0.0252788588,
-0.0064699026,
0.0300241914,
-0.0181868225,
-0.026789004,
-0.0115425251,
-0.0832735077,
0.0158702731,
-0.0183229614,
-0.0471487232,
-0.0721935779,
-0.0145888748,
-0.0044362652,
-0.0189992804,
-0.0043453942,
-0.0047791684,
0.0042554475,
0.0050608227,
-0.0068120132,
-0.019915808,
0.0140436227,
0.0674458817,
-0.0361396484,
0.0601482615,
0.0831945091,
0.0773076937,
-0.0177140832,
0.0017231598,
-0.0226910301,
0.0125155263,
0.0020079284,
0.0134344753,
0.0432870202,
-0.0124108279,
-0.0092152786,
-0.0275823977,
0.0041227266,
-0.0254436377,
0.0242492873,
0.0213760026,
0.0357361138,
-0.0147802625,
-0.0241664294,
-0.016160015,
0.0265915152,
0.0106839174,
0.0537499227,
0.0526803322,
-0.0520999581,
-0.0427575931,
-0.0506013185,
-0.0064304844,
-0.0191029627,
-0.0381011702,
-0.028733233,
0.0144207031,
-0.047544945,
-0.125991255,
-0.085625574,
0.0229957048,
0.0133961458,
-0.0111883581,
-0.0496059582,
0.0040672268,
0.0401588231,
-0.0003341097,
0.0159807503,
-0.0396644771,
0.0032873144,
-0.0359060019,
-0.0167696495,
0.0075832577,
-0.035761226,
-0.0195062235,
0.0021722938,
-0.0292696618,
-0.0122140273,
0.0113216564,
0.0868807063,
0.0265455227,
-0.0204721056,
-0.0436163768,
-0.0266826786,
0.0038753219,
0.0516290478,
-0.0391176678,
-0.0012868035,
0.0444014706,
0.0353908576,
-0.022407949,
0.0365335867,
-0.0336159021,
0.0061622798,
-0.0374706686,
0.0237902738,
-0.0039567281,
-0.0623706505,
0.0280796792,
0.03715837,
-0.0278063621,
0.0347406156,
-0.0075114341,
0.0052340748,
-0.0075426879,
-0.0173942875,
0.0198987927,
-0.0396079794,
-0.0314394422,
0.0182114411,
-0.0059132595,
0.0121212248,
0.0025470844,
-0.0671680495,
0.0027345715,
-0.0231237635,
-0.0133682704,
0.0056792051,
0.0328218937,
0.0060905959,
-0.0043586683,
-0.0328806788,
0.0213199817,
0.0156963244,
0.042996861,
-0.0041364734,
0.0627496168,
0.0038751778,
-0.0101805329,
0.0487464555,
0.0565655269,
-0.0862122625,
-0.1009897217,
0.0125270663,
0.0163321048,
0.0437539555,
0.0554435365,
0.0793531612,
0.0059690708,
-0.0053525385,
-0.0238480158,
0.0208726581,
0.0283179376,
-0.0253261309,
0.0042883111,
0.002498711,
-0.0223027952,
0.0138627831,
0.0510615744,
-0.0592600629,
0.0007856548,
0.0080177113,
-0.012407749,
-0.0252495874,
-0.0281138327,
0.003750517,
-0.020604413,
0.0202482715,
-0.0026346303,
-0.0166995171,
-0.0608186834,
-0.033336021,
0.0282325167,
-0.0017468008,
-0.0347037204,
0.0103061823,
0.0614022724,
0.0014813931,
-0.005149811,
-0.0765511766,
0.0366121605,
-0.0496618375,
-0.0132680759,
-0.0237406474,
-6.139414507e-33,
-0.0005792413,
-0.05293056,
-0.009608373,
0.0093645314,
-0.0076185591,
-0.0237393938,
-0.0528279804,
0.003205765,
-0.0501016825,
0.0276290644,
-0.0277030356,
0.0313238911,
0.0011047825,
-0.022608934,
0.0062053856,
-0.0664068535,
0.0428007692,
-0.0085545545,
-0.0442833342,
0.0714647248,
0.0174829867,
0.017497886,
0.0355560295,
-0.0606867485,
0.0379982106,
-0.0413985848,
-0.0406249538,
0.0202940498,
0.0164178442,
0.035010621,
-0.0130503885,
0.062776871,
0.0371944942,
0.0263194311,
0.002407775,
0.0323709957,
-0.017756775,
0.0096730823,
-0.0024815314,
0.0249661468,
-0.051352907,
-0.024293825,
0.0275851525,
-0.0471699871,
-0.0193919297,
-0.0178270936,
0.0458293371,
-0.0242082048,
0.0344403684,
-0.0078065186,
-0.0516224429,
-0.0170992818,
-0.0341002308,
-0.064434655,
-0.0419053733,
0.0888051391,
0.0080133919,
0.0386774801,
-0.0540653877,
0.027693389,
-0.0397928059,
0.0051769889,
0.0511913672,
-0.0444140248,
0.0196338203,
0.0652773604,
0.0595841371,
0.0254607499,
-0.0253982078,
-0.0205298569,
0.0107970042,
0.0176269636,
0.0756617114,
0.0532969534,
0.0067723496,
-0.0175705235,
-0.030747002,
0.0589479767,
0.0555040315,
0.0219391715,
0.011817812,
0.0048568184,
-0.0499000475,
0.0298705641,
-0.0279491954,
-0.0102442037,
-0.0386327729,
-0.0577354282,
-0.0102452207,
-0.0173232183,
-0.0236127991,
-0.0800748467,
0.0427797772,
-0.0824927539,
0.024551956,
0.0100644827,
-0.0467784032,
-0.0003011073,
0.0205278527,
0.0297142249,
0.0196898617,
0.0143054016,
0.0508862585,
0.0044949725,
0.0529972613,
0.0069932709,
0.0026228488,
0.0203436129,
-0.035374742,
-0.0246780533,
-0.0389930606,
0.0097262179,
-0.0444631726,
-0.0018874933,
-0.007477249,
0.0093130106,
-0.0102542033,
0.0225013997,
0.0028848238,
0.0571997315,
-0.061067909,
-0.0086278338,
-0.0056622443,
-0.0047739833,
-0.0791844204,
-0.0125475805,
-0.0440087877,
0.0051998645,
-0.0159545559,
-0.0509132594,
-0.0384079665,
-0.0207177028,
2.48e-7,
0.02586817,
0.0502125621,
0.0026911157,
0.0335130431,
0.0319363587,
0.0629440993,
0.0061553414,
0.0662553981,
0.029435426,
-0.0251041409,
0.0077339658,
0.0314425305,
0.051780995,
0.0246193539,
-0.0847380087,
-0.0341164172,
-0.0877130702,
-0.0134333251,
-0.0151053052,
0.0092629222,
0.0840793625,
0.0618155338,
-0.0185268801,
-0.0022292729,
0.0000429404,
-0.0183678325,
0.0397636928,
-0.0083057573,
-0.0362098627,
0.015656,
0.0183732379,
0.0024745462,
0.0128232436,
0.0119436299,
0.0183914118,
-0.0221951101,
0.0702091157,
0.0656899288,
-0.0028917531,
-0.0531521589,
0.0011144461,
-0.0159188863,
0.0341718867,
-0.0646846294,
0.048620075,
-0.0156612825,
-0.0701481029,
-0.0331068709,
-0.0180952456,
-0.027894685,
0.0600556508,
-0.039856866,
-0.0497712456,
0.0317606144,
0.0086089596,
0.0247376189,
0.0044192132,
-0.0202369448,
0.0081935069,
-0.0312756933,
-0.0419622883,
-0.0981901884,
-0.008610338,
0.0162871722,
0.0126814535,
-0.0031340474,
0.0247076992,
1.724408542e-34,
0.0366416536,
0.0027773022,
0.0165386312,
0.0219642743,
0.0725947469,
0.0226927549,
0.030909216,
-0.0191394351,
0.0354486406,
-0.0633514524,
-0.0102380272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00189v2 | Detecting Lexical Borrowings from Dominant Languages in Multilingual Wordlists | 2023-02-01T02:44:28 | 2023-02-21T08:13:54 | John E. Miller, Johann-Mattis List | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language contact is a pervasive phenomenon reflected in the borrowing of
words from donor to recipient languages. Most computational approaches to
borrowing detection treat all languages under study as equally important, even
though dominant languages have a stronger impact on heritage languages than
vice versa. We test new methods for lexical borrowing detection in contact
situations where dominant languages play an important role, applying two
classical sequence comparison methods and one machine learning method to a
sample of seven Latin American languages which have all borrowed extensively
from Spanish. All methods perform well, with the supervised machine learning
system outperforming the classical systems. A review of detection errors shows
that borrowing detection could be substantially improved by taking into account
donor words with divergent meanings from recipient words. | [
0.0152717968,
0.0579218008,
-0.0524742305,
0.0806262046,
-0.0709289834,
0.0097193522,
-0.073295027,
-0.0038990832,
0.0060569807,
0.0004195091,
-0.0163860098,
-0.0345847048,
0.0681627318,
-0.0526485965,
0.0053386195,
0.0317637585,
0.0490883961,
0.0186061803,
-0.0381697714,
-0.0042279889,
0.0090722535,
0.0232660118,
0.0353542976,
0.0032158662,
-0.00788619,
0.0245201439,
0.0421288498,
-0.0615575165,
0.0364279151,
-0.0112794377,
-0.0213019978,
0.0790863335,
-0.0485294536,
0.096366398,
0.0000016716,
-0.0719711632,
-0.0351340845,
-0.0245872755,
0.0245087184,
-0.0090689771,
0.044365786,
0.0056803166,
0.0293730926,
-0.0207749773,
-0.0720937401,
-0.0121127721,
0.0166089106,
-0.0503283031,
0.0086436812,
-0.0057364074,
-0.0105724363,
-0.0046780007,
-0.026440803,
-0.028346302,
0.0203536451,
-0.0107590556,
0.0457376465,
-0.0194086041,
0.0346335359,
-0.0775892958,
-0.0146458009,
0.050808046,
-0.050684914,
-0.0040798401,
-0.0510808006,
-0.021223532,
-0.0125323273,
-0.014341413,
0.0321837403,
0.0140987951,
-0.0490632243,
-0.07114546,
0.0252369437,
-0.0095981089,
0.0256238971,
0.0375497863,
0.0115409624,
-0.007261287,
-0.0194997117,
0.0146253305,
0.0629677325,
-0.0164406262,
0.0237873495,
0.0101906359,
-0.0376332775,
0.0381727368,
0.051948376,
-0.0529510193,
-0.0123369852,
0.0281817894,
0.0553405695,
-0.0460501388,
0.0514325127,
-0.0218761191,
-0.0112440772,
0.0094253067,
0.0059103426,
-0.0278726425,
0.0186209325,
-0.0270133615,
0.0304766297,
-0.0140914535,
-0.0438373126,
-0.0108019002,
-0.0183787812,
0.0088476073,
0.0035087091,
-0.0525062159,
-0.0345471092,
-0.0076370779,
-0.0558423549,
-0.0005709854,
-0.0102862557,
0.0139264874,
0.0095340721,
0.0181149393,
-0.0310317222,
-0.0156298634,
-0.001235672,
-0.0036113237,
-0.0620672852,
-0.0324968025,
0.0254196767,
0.0534381792,
0.0139810154,
-0.0283568017,
-0.0285585467,
0.0041037537,
-0.038303718,
-0.0801074058,
0.0130612487,
0.0148198148,
0.0209783129,
-0.0303164534,
-0.0037235511,
0.0540422313,
0.0014725272,
-0.0410153456,
0.0023696541,
-0.0517666265,
-0.0208102725,
-0.0148240058,
-0.0254798662,
-0.0702399239,
0.0555463545,
-0.0362149589,
0.0001157307,
-0.0495249964,
-0.000504757,
0.0206202231,
-0.0682783499,
0.0515501127,
-0.0034703754,
-0.0150976721,
0.0026037905,
-0.0173733216,
-0.0108421212,
-0.0002702411,
-0.0163943172,
-0.017254062,
0.0908683613,
-0.0097788414,
0.0023449042,
0.031509269,
-0.0076699159,
-0.0155693572,
0.0112214666,
-0.0462242998,
0.0459734946,
0.026437778,
0.0112851551,
0.0393270925,
-0.0050651086,
-0.0419128612,
0.0255031846,
0.0603167079,
-0.0296149328,
0.0265754331,
0.0374843217,
0.007297033,
-0.0293029752,
0.0640693903,
0.0054062628,
-0.0823853463,
0.0022846709,
-0.0251663439,
-0.0107300933,
0.0481344797,
0.0111003518,
0.039984785,
-0.0239642654,
-0.0075634671,
0.017544426,
-0.0430880971,
0.020214064,
0.0116749741,
-0.0292542763,
0.0476266369,
0.0117281619,
-0.0265306123,
-0.0058292411,
-0.0114450157,
0.041889444,
0.0140574835,
0.0098257698,
-0.000697598,
0.0545773432,
0.0317939483,
-0.0298984461,
0.0145356869,
-0.0038994758,
-0.01658573,
0.0207333993,
-0.0054194904,
0.014417232,
0.0706646144,
-0.0004713706,
0.0599710159,
-0.0178116038,
0.0524498634,
0.0348981246,
-0.004217512,
-0.0501290523,
0.0451257192,
-0.0399926156,
-0.0224269088,
0.0116580855,
-0.0082388669,
0.0205258057,
0.0405675322,
-0.0062549077,
0.0081456676,
0.0186717547,
-0.02828761,
-0.0128752533,
0.0343658626,
-0.0591580458,
-0.0081558498,
0.0839983001,
-0.0226110574,
0.0022677314,
-0.0213604365,
-0.0127076069,
-0.003168483,
0.0349535942,
-0.034709543,
0.0557705164,
-0.0512351356,
0.0562441647,
-0.059591651,
0.0717944279,
-0.0379169397,
0.0231194291,
-0.0103806984,
0.0416264273,
0.0198470056,
-0.0539995767,
0.0360577926,
-0.0045769881,
-0.0133863715,
0.0298055653,
0.0050048046,
-0.0263265334,
0.0129707139,
-0.0097049065,
-0.0092881182,
0.0136410212,
-0.0231941938,
-0.0221324153,
-0.0026405265,
0.0465409905,
-0.0169657245,
0.0117026716,
-0.0089355111,
0.0105949054,
0.0277961399,
0.0062732198,
0.005489626,
0.0242275745,
0.0225332249,
-0.000597832,
-0.0384903252,
-0.0599996485,
0.0208180789,
0.0212052222,
0.0560804904,
-0.0014254896,
-0.0749179199,
-0.0447024368,
-0.0984096155,
-0.0711232275,
0.0209106971,
0.0080025848,
-0.0133958617,
-0.0078998096,
0.0030519513,
0.0102958465,
0.0022355861,
-0.0071244836,
-0.0477235988,
0.0684867874,
-0.0314495377,
0.0072386265,
-0.0748879239,
-0.021643959,
0.0028530178,
-0.020916054,
-0.0211946424,
0.0377180763,
0.0570091605,
0.0079172421,
0.0002111217,
0.0101551265,
-0.0163752344,
-0.016678134,
-0.0289786868,
0.0350337289,
-0.0199961849,
-0.0645847395,
0.0491898768,
0.0068104542,
-0.032348372,
0.0409394056,
-0.0483465791,
0.0122638494,
-0.0359406434,
-0.0092541743,
-0.0096351635,
0.006721756,
0.0147550814,
0.0107236812,
-0.0142736733,
-0.0267943181,
-0.0058602933,
-0.0137561839,
0.0741047561,
-0.0275766719,
0.0137135889,
-0.0510553904,
0.0090059005,
0.0135484897,
-0.0039518317,
-0.0279444195,
0.0196033996,
0.0090684853,
-0.022186581,
0.0377496555,
-0.0128396666,
0.039365489,
0.013650992,
-0.0237665307,
0.0470412783,
0.0287895724,
0.0145744365,
0.0033098299,
0.0761232451,
-0.0206868332,
-0.0447570644,
0.0168309528,
0.0009783991,
-0.020348385,
-0.0057321987,
0.0077638165,
-0.0018705991,
0.0177119952,
0.0258804988,
0.0601769239,
-0.0500436239,
-0.0418760069,
0.0095870877,
-0.0383800678,
0.0109668132,
0.0109118782,
0.0727247447,
0.0554081537,
-0.0251603052,
0.047971949,
-0.0677675828,
0.0081995176,
0.0103648929,
0.0172780976,
-0.0812939033,
-0.0014673168,
0.0163089186,
-0.0108090146,
-0.0165563785,
-0.0355486721,
-0.0258480646,
-0.1563271135,
-0.0210233219,
-0.0073051099,
-0.0458635874,
-0.0242255032,
-0.0128690079,
-0.0112624429,
-0.028139025,
-0.0682334453,
0.0106632421,
-0.0295979176,
-0.0097737666,
0.017991947,
-0.0204872172,
-0.0260890443,
-0.0313974768,
-0.0162862372,
-0.0492030941,
0.0329535455,
0.0530762635,
-0.0255870484,
-0.0330603048,
0.050395418,
-0.0477981195,
-0.0098322071,
-0.0459008962,
-0.0102377469,
0.0263286028,
0.0023603251,
0.0105246976,
-0.0296085943,
-0.0159228649,
-0.0235760286,
0.0629910082,
0.1003172919,
0.0040492169,
-0.0322018713,
0.0473748185,
-0.0028913615,
0.0241323318,
0.003885726,
0.0430900455,
0.0025258088,
0.0261673629,
0.027066838,
-0.0122068739,
0.0329977348,
-0.0083942255,
0.0009265209,
-0.054187905,
-0.0806627497,
-0.1274381131,
-0.0297268499,
-0.0518077277,
0.0047507342,
0.0643497184,
0.0478600971,
-0.0110272439,
-0.0275070071,
-0.0370825492,
-0.0366451554,
-0.0050957631,
0.0147483302,
-0.0053101042,
0.0068727536,
-0.0147048384,
0.0255795792,
-0.0155471321,
0.008960315,
-0.0707052648,
-0.0572322831,
0.0035784573,
0.0227900855,
0.0222260561,
0.0381032601,
0.000039572,
0.003805364,
-0.0305318721,
0.0433204956,
0.0264031924,
0.0081644086,
0.0276715346,
-0.0880336091,
-0.0014366471,
0.0290468801,
0.0020471322,
-0.0115687521,
-0.0004123663,
0.0055809412,
-0.0391314887,
-0.0393678285,
0.0241864808,
0.0160784088,
0.034874808,
-0.06700854,
-0.0448639505,
-0.0278714299,
-0.0073939022,
0.0173545592,
0.0038502635,
0.0097628627,
-0.0050575952,
0.0030701847,
0.0377792008,
0.0024485353,
-0.011073634,
-0.052889917,
0.0276872758,
-0.0160835851,
0.0544712059,
0.0573048964,
0.066011399,
0.0054106805,
0.0217906814,
0.0142492251,
0.0541398004,
-0.0065985871,
0.0678128526,
-0.0530550294,
0.0114935432,
-0.0119897481,
0.0264994856,
0.0265793446,
0.0477102883,
0.0202627536,
-0.024824081,
-0.0084282914,
0.0172687434,
0.1005457267,
-0.0756401718,
0.0595130548,
0.0055650468,
-0.0089845657,
0.0036152657,
0.0242307838,
-0.0380704217,
-0.0368279517,
-0.0318521075,
-0.0125115318,
-0.0396200493,
0.0440561697,
0.0692486987,
-0.0572546534,
0.0202765968,
-0.0114630256,
-0.0609941483,
0.019331716,
-0.0307474006,
0.0675708503,
-0.0293531138,
-0.0254723001,
-0.0298138205,
-0.0641646683,
-0.0627672151,
0.0011167958,
-0.0197318252,
0.0231158417,
0.0459979922,
0.044494018,
0.0745100975,
0.0124298371,
0.0556810573,
-0.0362826772,
0.032674171,
-0.0250515472,
-0.0222957116,
0.0024213404,
-5.189549317e-33,
0.024182599,
-0.0590473935,
-0.0232150536,
-0.0002206308,
-0.0211064275,
0.0228559412,
-0.0192002077,
-0.0141247343,
-0.0001789427,
-0.0120917941,
0.0185766183,
-0.0317647643,
0.0300029218,
-0.0577238761,
0.0386149734,
0.0257230923,
0.0055001681,
0.0636349767,
-0.0037887946,
-0.0402631648,
0.0221451707,
0.0293948185,
0.0664687753,
-0.0498371758,
0.0366754942,
-0.0109444456,
0.0317794867,
0.0112386225,
0.0113471579,
-0.0076656863,
-0.0152099337,
0.0153969098,
-0.0099387886,
-0.0458783843,
-0.0024416752,
-0.0052568102,
0.0002548859,
-0.0622011311,
0.0707554743,
0.0016388325,
0.0468376428,
0.0047677625,
-0.0013714842,
-0.0036951383,
-0.0446248502,
0.06478367,
0.0553176738,
-0.0040359776,
-0.0606573001,
0.0206057765,
-0.0815429017,
0.0429834463,
0.0382632613,
0.0489503071,
0.0689887553,
0.0662115738,
-0.0121042384,
-0.019023722,
-0.0144738881,
0.0306352247,
-0.0091758342,
0.0480750501,
0.0749419257,
0.0134409955,
-0.0029225326,
0.0271538068,
0.045821704,
-0.0589823239,
0.1190330237,
0.0370646901,
0.0024401774,
0.0187240876,
-0.0096495617,
0.0801292807,
0.0462459251,
-0.0274542775,
0.0374756232,
-0.0022959805,
0.0233557895,
-0.0162533857,
-0.0267484989,
-0.0083463453,
0.0137258256,
-0.0179913901,
-0.0141785806,
-0.0495599024,
0.002091181,
-0.022280328,
0.032157328,
-0.0350740477,
0.0053889565,
0.054781653,
0.0213629045,
-0.0103856158,
-0.0725989863,
0.0015365904,
-0.0377620682,
-0.0254474971,
0.0030190649,
0.0205731578,
-0.0331432074,
-0.0343853943,
-0.0301278103,
-0.0318405852,
0.0553539358,
-0.0037567639,
0.0373028778,
-0.0274391752,
-0.016981449,
0.0140870102,
-0.0230550617,
-0.0027758691,
-0.0420625769,
0.0349197239,
0.0387475565,
0.0078723906,
0.0000627838,
-0.0204410125,
0.0780184716,
-0.0115075903,
-0.0135543067,
-0.0381320007,
-0.0161275938,
0.0111819739,
-0.0489752442,
-0.0105664991,
0.004150338,
0.0763267651,
0.0077507384,
-0.0130691119,
-0.0188864749,
-0.0397429727,
2.558e-7,
0.0109445592,
0.0396081768,
0.0315137431,
-0.0179314204,
-0.0098762503,
-0.0068129571,
-0.0463493653,
0.0453458838,
-0.051853098,
0.0423351452,
0.0239969771,
-0.0302240998,
0.065705575,
0.0695405826,
-0.066847682,
-0.0272173285,
-0.0637243539,
-0.0236473959,
-0.0765625536,
-0.0289383698,
0.0168669373,
0.059763819,
0.0299879909,
-0.0462354794,
-0.0446577035,
-0.0526877902,
0.0005190555,
-0.0343614258,
-0.0069039618,
-0.0299951863,
0.0106334919,
-0.0341890939,
0.0190388877,
0.0303825159,
-0.0346025117,
0.0201485474,
0.0337513201,
-0.052070871,
-0.011610264,
0.0428469628,
0.0197929274,
-0.0427503772,
-0.0228183568,
-0.0393764861,
0.0163758807,
0.0677424222,
0.0020600196,
-0.0223561209,
-0.0188409053,
0.0207889806,
0.0239834078,
0.0145091508,
-0.0092797689,
0.0371164046,
0.0341232046,
0.0373674445,
-0.0512344912,
-0.0271317475,
0.0070193098,
0.0303261168,
0.0068039959,
-0.008885189,
-0.0008685924,
-0.0116731338,
-0.0170209128,
-0.0039418046,
0.0305192098,
1.912226481e-34,
-0.0194488727,
-0.0112687293,
0.0390616357,
0.0267827902,
0.0366801545,
0.0207303055,
0.0256759152,
0.0705042109,
-0.0164353419,
0.0166310761,
0.0297896918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00178v1 | Program Generation from Diverse Video Demonstrations | 2023-02-01T01:51:45 | 2023-02-01T01:51:45 | Anthony Manchin, Jamie Sherrah, Qi Wu, Anton van den Hengel | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The ability to use inductive reasoning to extract general rules from multiple
observations is a vital indicator of intelligence. As humans, we use this
ability to not only interpret the world around us, but also to predict the
outcomes of the various interactions we experience. Generalising over multiple
observations is a task that has historically presented difficulties for
machines to grasp, especially when requiring computer vision. In this paper, we
propose a model that can extract general rules from video demonstrations by
simultaneously performing summarisation and translation. Our approach differs
from prior works by framing the problem as a multi-sequence-to-sequence task,
wherein summarisation is learnt by the model. This allows our model to utilise
edge cases that would otherwise be suppressed or discarded by traditional
summarisation techniques. Additionally, we show that our approach can handle
noisy specifications without the need for additional filtering methods. We
evaluate our model by synthesising programs from video demonstrations in the
Vizdoom environment achieving state-of-the-art results with a relative increase
of 11.75% program accuracy on prior works | [
-0.0091815107,
0.032339897,
0.0010116748,
0.0032982402,
0.0222267359,
-0.0005726729,
-0.0461523868,
-0.0024291789,
-0.0120291049,
-0.0318239406,
0.0427294075,
0.0119529665,
0.0364763439,
0.029869562,
0.0363415405,
-0.1159869954,
-0.0009277294,
-0.0501608513,
-0.031118907,
0.0073404559,
-0.00772268,
-0.0104868626,
-0.025223637,
0.0487223007,
-0.044108253,
0.013028807,
-0.0386700556,
-0.0138820251,
0.0372387916,
-0.029376654,
-0.040828567,
0.004526,
0.0725698769,
-0.0162323136,
0.0000019754,
-0.0197018385,
0.008091663,
-0.0401866026,
0.0286833234,
-0.0048327558,
-0.0145402392,
-0.0375109278,
0.0270467531,
0.0144878319,
-0.0388897248,
-0.0350854881,
0.0451965928,
-0.0364001282,
0.0957873017,
0.0559595376,
-0.0066373101,
-0.0399954468,
0.0090720169,
0.0086311279,
0.0238301996,
-0.0077520907,
-0.0045854221,
0.0400153175,
0.0500851572,
-0.0771849528,
-0.0237415247,
0.0225871261,
0.0493506528,
-0.0079835346,
-0.0272730812,
0.0263409242,
-0.0270597413,
-0.0584309921,
-0.0143913263,
0.025075119,
-0.0331796929,
0.0091288574,
0.0326552056,
0.0124255614,
0.0499967262,
-0.0095279096,
-0.0721288621,
0.0802487731,
-0.0154869203,
-0.0088712862,
-0.0326865725,
0.0238721836,
-0.0064897332,
-0.0354356766,
-0.0426171757,
-0.0019388781,
-0.0056282501,
0.0091734407,
-0.0388330221,
0.0143176019,
-0.0023622778,
-0.0667550638,
0.0103047062,
0.0580665022,
-0.0373195857,
-0.0064276066,
-0.0406927913,
-0.0059311208,
-0.0481132567,
-0.0172441136,
0.0682130083,
0.0518936142,
0.0306402612,
0.0369791575,
-0.0197798274,
0.0698501468,
-0.0054408275,
0.0482228808,
-0.0409291536,
0.0272265077,
-0.0811300948,
0.0146805486,
-0.0226761419,
0.0551818758,
-0.014840574,
0.0052567259,
-0.0014557081,
0.0458836183,
-0.0287939142,
0.0449118577,
-0.0441571996,
0.0285905022,
-0.0310369004,
-0.0029429714,
-0.009759347,
-0.0406868793,
-0.0390200391,
-0.0237322208,
0.0324445739,
-0.0077241855,
-0.0371392742,
0.0074968203,
0.0091090994,
0.0321819149,
0.0089809075,
0.087895751,
-0.012087713,
-0.0126345661,
-0.0301873777,
-0.0390645266,
0.0338439122,
-0.0296244733,
0.0502431653,
-0.0799393952,
0.0297914036,
-0.0362478569,
-0.0173773337,
-0.027775012,
0.011559804,
0.0131468438,
-0.0005659232,
0.0489900485,
0.0059752171,
0.0274494048,
-0.0057041915,
0.0307782982,
-0.031536255,
0.0544454902,
0.0501338281,
0.0354190096,
0.0123589542,
0.0246369094,
0.0787552595,
0.0533376075,
-0.0148302373,
0.0062626326,
-0.0406999886,
-0.0169090051,
-0.0014193116,
0.0329322405,
-0.0166717526,
0.0259280372,
-0.0220222622,
0.0411433615,
0.0255562123,
0.0348683037,
-0.0389765836,
-0.0276293904,
0.1139054596,
0.0056625111,
0.0202393029,
0.0427453183,
-0.0417281687,
0.0834503919,
0.0021386817,
0.0505885296,
-0.0228665657,
0.036776118,
-0.0280183367,
-0.0780652314,
0.0137401251,
0.0126178404,
0.0312831216,
0.0049098507,
0.0361984372,
0.0256232414,
-0.0747534782,
0.0086817397,
-0.0065644728,
-0.0485656559,
0.0110005466,
-0.0526942201,
0.0169544332,
0.0398876965,
-0.0091851186,
-0.0330084264,
-0.0137499422,
-0.0147967814,
0.046121072,
-0.0063003753,
0.0184500124,
-0.0338022187,
0.0307192393,
-0.0177286528,
-0.0298041683,
-0.0197507963,
0.0328618847,
0.0314306058,
0.0124194799,
-0.0447445773,
0.005584558,
0.0245925169,
-0.0369909927,
0.0747976154,
-0.0143208401,
-0.0217474066,
-0.003512904,
-0.0131385876,
0.0213664733,
-0.0174710415,
-0.0020725993,
-0.0076770498,
0.0250786915,
-0.0210479498,
0.0164015703,
0.0161613058,
-0.0049715154,
-0.0677306429,
0.0392850786,
-0.0922059268,
-0.0564634055,
0.0297374614,
-0.0489763543,
-0.0158915427,
0.029584622,
-0.0174484197,
0.0104871923,
0.0195131283,
0.0099538453,
0.0397488996,
-0.0548785143,
0.0349006243,
0.0319304168,
-0.0436684862,
-0.0229346287,
0.0669030398,
-0.0114305373,
-0.0145603949,
-0.0480456799,
0.0333551466,
-0.0033623446,
-0.0190088935,
0.0203030705,
0.0324227624,
0.0479392558,
-0.0330358855,
-0.0122672878,
-0.0574261993,
0.0124741653,
-0.0256075393,
-0.0148453061,
-0.0129276644,
-0.025117144,
-0.0015681401,
-0.0113212811,
0.0080537256,
-0.0151849212,
-0.0165320039,
-0.0337817147,
0.0130910818,
0.0344386175,
-0.0497066677,
-0.0148038575,
-0.0104064085,
-0.0146678733,
0.0638369173,
-0.0014250283,
-0.0087712742,
-0.0240932032,
-0.0115009733,
0.012997672,
0.0272528213,
-0.0272098184,
0.0238772891,
0.0599115379,
-0.0229310188,
-0.0189846363,
0.0674148947,
0.0193577204,
0.0327078775,
0.0337300934,
-0.0283584092,
-0.007492898,
0.0282396991,
0.0022264356,
-0.0030431387,
0.0048793741,
-0.0399765186,
0.0123407496,
0.0291012824,
-0.040719986,
0.0220948942,
-0.0896264538,
0.0500969253,
0.042860359,
-0.0314869583,
-0.0498523004,
-0.0326097906,
-0.0213992428,
0.0069524054,
-0.0315474346,
-0.0401980095,
0.0542068966,
-0.0087581426,
0.0007455821,
0.0283757076,
0.006897422,
0.0215870794,
0.0920787528,
0.0435270146,
0.018836176,
-0.0393711105,
0.0040557664,
-0.0719137788,
-0.002065839,
0.0129037937,
0.0005866284,
0.0685816854,
-0.1190849915,
-0.0245457347,
0.0097748963,
0.0008017883,
-0.0348205902,
0.0511018671,
0.0009322561,
0.0116873486,
-0.02048482,
-0.0101927631,
-0.0387449004,
-0.0113875773,
0.0291324779,
0.0225424822,
0.0045223376,
-0.0290636718,
-0.0353575386,
-0.0499818102,
0.0327909179,
-0.0027113268,
-0.0528085902,
-0.0856589675,
0.0033631718,
0.0230736509,
0.0554716326,
-0.0244199894,
-0.0462327786,
0.0049163708,
-0.0044825962,
-0.0152013348,
-0.0064385603,
0.0769061893,
0.0511583574,
-0.0649990812,
0.0177856293,
0.0513826944,
-0.0034143464,
0.0108012808,
0.0271901805,
0.0363636054,
-0.0066882991,
0.0429521278,
0.0484122187,
-0.0661655813,
-0.0316556543,
0.0021016337,
0.0392410122,
0.0163924024,
-0.0036417977,
-0.0291730985,
-0.0945637226,
0.0482128859,
0.0451429933,
-0.089371264,
-0.063860774,
0.0239970647,
-0.0377527326,
-0.024686642,
-0.0417910255,
0.0410266221,
-0.0065564658,
0.011003104,
0.0290588066,
-0.0109159257,
0.0096162399,
-0.0023343496,
-0.021013638,
-0.003052756,
0.0395302474,
-0.0143528301,
-0.0110464916,
-0.0311921369,
0.0029095884,
0.0414799154,
0.0290287491,
-0.0053187776,
0.0168117136,
-0.0205203258,
0.0021955636,
0.0595895238,
0.0485989936,
-0.0090037007,
-0.0496948622,
0.0460121483,
0.0276193358,
-0.0036387935,
-0.0448375791,
-0.0474635363,
-0.0090123769,
0.0014511305,
0.0244011916,
0.0067522,
-0.0041680727,
-0.009847017,
-0.0613544956,
-0.0548917577,
-0.0765306577,
-0.0547865368,
-0.0499597564,
0.0040137921,
-0.035410013,
-0.0567533225,
-0.0047259503,
0.0504356287,
0.0881739557,
-0.0198214129,
-0.0816184804,
0.0234591365,
0.049010776,
-0.0385919809,
0.0303830635,
0.0119261062,
-0.0215208102,
-0.0103336172,
-0.0081151891,
-0.0087568071,
-0.0493478216,
-0.0244485978,
0.0539388359,
-0.0241182484,
-0.038900923,
-0.0327812284,
0.1504389495,
0.0190853011,
0.0707436502,
0.0254833438,
0.0459781885,
0.0330722407,
0.0352610946,
0.0700057149,
0.0165721998,
0.0391918868,
-0.0491554998,
-0.0158376396,
-0.0062028477,
-0.064864099,
0.0061391206,
-0.0146827139,
0.0381833389,
-0.0565563887,
9.575e-7,
0.0439208187,
-0.0141855096,
0.0282550417,
-0.037951041,
-0.0348306336,
-0.0114735775,
-0.0280548967,
0.0041877138,
-0.0173899066,
-0.0947248116,
0.0418052077,
-0.0188418236,
0.0276504979,
0.0357607231,
-0.0190843381,
-0.0000759069,
-0.0184992515,
-0.0107925814,
-0.0282473452,
-0.0114083355,
-0.0021389527,
0.0096671991,
0.0097382544,
0.0027622851,
0.0455158912,
-0.0273742955,
0.0326342136,
0.0270171966,
0.0293392222,
0.0432117581,
0.0484856404,
0.0199758802,
0.0153894648,
-0.0263129771,
-0.0295821577,
-0.0645133108,
0.0550975464,
0.0774546489,
0.0082512572,
-0.020338539,
-0.0294883121,
0.0205301028,
-0.0031132193,
0.0417491607,
0.012403734,
-0.0703777596,
-0.0077910302,
0.0511440523,
0.0228948053,
-0.0403054878,
0.0965042338,
-0.0480691157,
0.030217221,
-0.0057464382,
0.0039544557,
-0.0493680164,
-0.0514863916,
0.0527423806,
0.0234097838,
-0.0080274548,
-0.0281254984,
-0.0248173568,
-0.0398552828,
-0.0559503287,
0.0652248561,
0.038780462,
-0.0059835101,
0.0545259789,
0.0225499719,
-0.0147054838,
-0.0255262088,
0.0161882062,
-0.069673419,
-0.000765796,
-0.0174626298,
0.0002136268,
-5.234906869e-33,
-0.054536581,
-0.023169579,
0.0451147892,
0.021936778,
0.0003766621,
-0.0397933014,
-0.0393020622,
0.0048823962,
0.0112620099,
0.0094830533,
0.0324938111,
-0.0078728683,
-0.0102676181,
-0.0160947125,
0.0695655718,
0.0126015702,
0.0495382175,
0.0036688065,
-0.0639051646,
0.0054211975,
-0.0064105056,
0.0011665826,
0.0224911459,
-0.0446346067,
-0.0001765698,
-0.0029276817,
-0.0474369377,
0.0316894501,
-0.0199464858,
0.0134277381,
0.0303950906,
-0.0411210842,
-0.0099738771,
-0.0438983329,
-0.0521731973,
-0.0038951302,
-0.0042010727,
-0.0158485305,
0.0099303517,
-0.007093023,
-0.0678527057,
-0.0366453417,
0.0558189675,
-0.0134984795,
-0.0096125854,
-0.0338464379,
0.0619589277,
-0.0320235379,
0.0118065113,
-0.0238226634,
-0.0453040339,
-0.0061827158,
-0.0375718549,
-0.0918357819,
0.0121334242,
0.010609665,
0.0225989576,
-0.0372839645,
-0.0035934066,
0.0478682332,
0.0300865527,
0.0103656733,
0.0691156685,
0.0060284827,
0.0435411818,
0.0484111942,
0.0033652815,
-0.0417818166,
-0.0174867269,
-0.0118638761,
-0.0065217391,
0.0665986538,
0.0347256027,
0.0013109636,
0.0620523505,
0.0296209883,
-0.0401045717,
0.0424965285,
-0.051788114,
0.0538112409,
-0.0258168057,
0.014237958,
-0.0094369072,
0.0182903726,
0.0038340951,
0.0172216315,
0.0250359178,
-0.0252570212,
0.0173663329,
0.0455373377,
-0.0145432185,
-0.0203732178,
0.0281760413,
-0.0304898601,
0.044460278,
-0.0173897725,
-0.0419614539,
0.0392830148,
-0.0023263772,
-0.0074532987,
-0.0091688475,
-0.0690184385,
0.0407242328,
-0.0053922511,
0.0434441194,
0.03722094,
0.0312863737,
0.0699105114,
0.0196816586,
-0.0113312472,
-0.0213520192,
0.0001345592,
0.0196944438,
-0.0281894412,
0.021789927,
0.0182332844,
-0.0301604755,
0.0131003782,
-0.0240770932,
-0.0637569055,
-0.0049626366,
0.0075657065,
-0.0090636779,
0.0270617977,
-0.0277771279,
-0.0044262023,
-0.0386929475,
0.0068477169,
0.0024192194,
-0.0040595527,
-0.0329174474,
0.0347826816,
2.656e-7,
-0.0215840824,
0.0171104465,
0.0115929227,
0.0340051875,
-0.0281150565,
0.0451470092,
-0.0439786911,
0.0267930906,
0.0133925863,
-0.0322898477,
0.0383135192,
0.0684652999,
0.0128263673,
-0.0042600031,
-0.0813740864,
-0.0610510036,
-0.0062385476,
-0.023670692,
-0.0301375799,
-0.0299479999,
0.0405337624,
0.0610091165,
0.0049583311,
0.0156018315,
0.0507394001,
-0.0560550392,
0.0368049033,
0.0042338083,
-0.013891357,
0.0011892692,
-0.0043838769,
0.0074824989,
-0.0381684192,
0.0269440413,
-0.0251178481,
-0.0175929163,
0.0354452655,
0.0431411751,
-0.0301032327,
0.0480155721,
0.0310650859,
0.0077058137,
0.0088504869,
0.0087619517,
0.0249794535,
-0.0733500943,
0.0257028323,
0.012505983,
-0.0285568312,
-0.0000943599,
-0.04621014,
0.0198589806,
0.0173132084,
0.0025614512,
0.0005197658,
-0.0003696913,
0.0108776744,
-0.0491443798,
-0.0236612838,
-0.0084335078,
-0.0063338582,
-0.0248858612,
-0.0023025773,
0.0238067433,
-0.0157898795,
-0.0128550846,
-0.0505845957,
2.22644232e-34,
0.0296448506,
0.0002254826,
-0.0123188663,
-0.0229376834,
0.0439224876,
-0.0277819298,
-0.0465883687,
0.0282929856,
0.0261755772,
0.023746172,
-0.0499844998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00129v1 | Universal Topological Regularities of Syntactic Structures: Decoupling Efficiency from Optimization | 2023-01-31T22:35:11 | 2023-01-31T22:35:11 | Fermín Moscoso del Prado Martín | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Human syntactic structures are usually represented as graphs. Much research
has focused on the mapping between such graphs and linguistic sequences, but
less attention has been paid to the shapes of the graphs themselves: their
topologies. This study investigates how the topologies of syntactic graphs
reveal traces of the processes that led to their emergence. I report a new
universal regularity in syntactic structures: Their topology is communicatively
efficient above chance. The pattern holds, without exception, for all 124
languages studied, across linguistic families and modalities (spoken, written,
and signed). This pattern can arise from a process optimizing for communicative
efficiency or, alternatively, by construction, as a by-effect of a sublinear
preferential attachment process reflecting language production mechanisms known
from psycholinguistics. This dual explanation shows how communicative
efficiency, per se, does not require optimization. Among the two options,
efficiency without optimization offers the better explanation for the new
pattern. | [
0.0287627,
0.0387150049,
-0.0732297972,
0.0182533748,
-0.0756576955,
-0.0203398392,
-0.0546052232,
0.0254654214,
0.0206547882,
0.0160143934,
-0.0499909855,
-0.0648027584,
0.0540458411,
0.0250852238,
0.0709999502,
-0.0670095831,
0.0247110706,
-0.0165731125,
-0.0264809709,
0.0145874862,
0.003771282,
-0.0271272939,
0.0118360547,
0.0127735725,
-0.0089709507,
0.0330843255,
-0.0198468901,
-0.0384036601,
-0.0018200148,
-0.022400856,
-0.0037708434,
0.0142228771,
-0.0388703868,
-0.0025959378,
0.0000018114,
-0.0304459427,
0.0531209148,
-0.0274498742,
-0.0208170917,
0.0236173626,
0.023529822,
-0.0340547636,
0.0035842226,
-0.0133346897,
-0.0184210856,
-0.0176267177,
0.0534377843,
-0.0307779852,
-0.0441444293,
0.0313783661,
-0.0238807406,
-0.0369452983,
0.0244327243,
-0.0168542396,
-0.0325621925,
0.0194007214,
0.0114797596,
-0.0115705645,
0.041879911,
-0.0477863848,
-0.0519748405,
-0.0234804768,
-0.0062794802,
0.0034826293,
-0.0020573135,
0.0068578064,
0.0186540093,
-0.0499416851,
0.0168023352,
0.0474023335,
0.018817788,
-0.0383777805,
0.0190334395,
0.0162726026,
-0.0311621688,
0.0046656397,
-0.0373255871,
0.0232554469,
0.0093770856,
0.0370255597,
0.0396606661,
-0.0193614345,
-0.0149994157,
-0.0117688598,
-0.0118807266,
0.1178419068,
0.009722488,
-0.0110829072,
0.0367649347,
0.0141003039,
-0.0164059289,
-0.0873804837,
0.0147765437,
-0.0048140115,
0.0175557062,
-0.0046042255,
-0.0006299295,
-0.0123151857,
-0.0063330904,
0.0232015923,
0.0548744947,
-0.0011326497,
0.0281443484,
-0.0114225075,
0.0043015168,
-0.0011295299,
-0.02510898,
0.0100182062,
-0.0334221944,
0.0580819584,
-0.0223383959,
-0.0184021257,
-0.0154820215,
0.0309309661,
0.004594102,
-0.0172982775,
-0.027575044,
0.0493315198,
-0.0067526023,
-0.0579776913,
-0.0526004322,
-0.0050841677,
-0.0099715553,
0.0225992426,
-0.0293950401,
-0.0165844578,
-0.0544701889,
0.0384987928,
-0.0428221263,
-0.0186012182,
0.0251721982,
0.0521646328,
0.0241044629,
-0.0016601105,
-0.032202594,
0.0285440106,
0.0093778372,
0.0118761696,
0.0085576102,
-0.035659872,
-0.0257905256,
-0.0247313492,
0.0071006394,
-0.0054915114,
-0.0112644825,
0.0229867622,
-0.0329793729,
-0.035939794,
-0.0372945145,
-0.0393651202,
-0.0445481315,
-0.0268827751,
-0.027732743,
0.0358747356,
-0.0079076802,
-0.0382293053,
0.0013653176,
-0.0413721837,
0.0406956933,
-0.0006884793,
0.0289083514,
-0.036321871,
-0.0063136695,
0.0249916874,
0.0136188278,
-0.0147402128,
-0.0216696505,
-0.023685446,
-0.0308567546,
0.0208431147,
0.0403288379,
0.0768854395,
-0.0416361764,
-0.0493531972,
0.0263991226,
0.0530386306,
0.0259055365,
0.0117490524,
-0.0030491108,
0.0518553071,
-0.0063378746,
0.0814697519,
0.0097807795,
-0.015261868,
-0.0106349001,
-0.0204767622,
-0.0193874277,
-0.02544556,
0.0156558119,
-0.0130030839,
-0.0225000642,
-0.0156890079,
0.0555771515,
-0.0322648399,
-0.0126814162,
0.0177253671,
-0.0189160164,
-0.0089767016,
0.0205461942,
-0.0186125841,
-0.019375233,
-0.0155952871,
0.0110061904,
-0.0040619913,
-0.0351451524,
0.0418538786,
0.0008005397,
0.0386607051,
-0.0092437845,
0.0440275557,
-0.0054262416,
-0.0019915844,
-0.0028106933,
-0.0141079528,
0.0224283114,
0.0066337269,
-0.0186402537,
0.0243047494,
-0.0753641576,
0.0072260215,
-0.03841573,
-0.0231931675,
0.0148703558,
0.0089585334,
0.0301051084,
0.0133269476,
0.0013070639,
0.0164985992,
0.0265923962,
-0.0072093764,
-0.0172777642,
0.0598278083,
0.0414742194,
-0.0357279293,
0.0254479721,
0.0681822523,
-0.065025419,
0.0265778732,
-0.0015517749,
-0.0318352617,
0.0437447391,
0.0352945887,
0.0671280175,
-0.0264346953,
0.0710386336,
-0.093280822,
0.0954558849,
0.0100222602,
0.0196836665,
-0.0184244495,
0.0385842174,
-0.0193495415,
0.0390347578,
0.0194003694,
0.0223050658,
0.0033690652,
-0.0271845181,
0.042201139,
-0.0074065072,
0.0380692929,
0.0236673336,
-0.0218549557,
-0.0094645629,
0.0603538342,
-0.0019706585,
-0.0294721331,
-0.0344361924,
-0.0561801158,
-0.0512990505,
0.0182452668,
0.0699891299,
0.0192165375,
-0.0128122894,
0.0114556998,
0.0243998393,
-0.0089748958,
0.0580006763,
0.023957165,
0.0327997282,
0.0774803311,
0.0129936188,
-0.0868416205,
-0.0405283682,
-0.0195516255,
-0.0154550392,
0.0112627149,
-0.0304257143,
-0.0224420968,
-0.0265821535,
0.0275795832,
-0.0080196941,
-0.0213459227,
-0.0075736307,
-0.0489933565,
0.0276540089,
0.0603093468,
0.0573398694,
0.0311435666,
-0.0281438995,
0.0242300667,
-0.0094296001,
0.0025072333,
-0.0272426009,
-0.0361653864,
-0.0194257796,
0.0209921077,
-0.071566157,
-0.0398750529,
-0.0001090668,
0.1078242213,
0.0156925358,
-0.018707037,
-0.0208573453,
0.0228782296,
-0.0516192839,
-0.006124848,
0.0033392366,
-0.0923906267,
-0.0532581843,
0.079737246,
-0.0197305959,
-0.0335047767,
0.0244595762,
0.0364680961,
-0.024445815,
0.0167553388,
-0.0298512019,
-0.0202466529,
0.0996720046,
0.0563208312,
0.0149920089,
0.0384583436,
-0.0894457921,
-0.0759352073,
-0.0268475804,
0.0219863374,
0.0414639935,
-0.0109171653,
-0.0561039373,
-0.0041960464,
-0.0008401834,
-0.0709056556,
0.0120380735,
-0.0029412103,
-0.0030019113,
0.005113774,
0.0513448492,
-0.0279397853,
0.0484188646,
0.0162348934,
-0.0034288645,
-0.0083777588,
-0.0136521049,
0.0154082859,
-0.0072404169,
0.0389182307,
0.0037613749,
0.016795231,
-0.0126151266,
0.013134432,
-0.0747266933,
0.0477816164,
0.0187856816,
0.0863418505,
0.0246470645,
0.0077076983,
0.0364407636,
0.0147215147,
-0.1176567748,
0.0075204526,
0.0398939811,
-0.0034912629,
0.0355563536,
0.0247496068,
0.0070917485,
0.0149401119,
0.0900782421,
-0.0162764844,
0.089856416,
0.0057005612,
-0.0080588087,
-0.0604528897,
0.0390831232,
-0.0062269289,
-0.0342121534,
-0.0489854701,
-0.0221884474,
0.0200662035,
-0.0534711927,
-0.004020683,
0.0019570584,
-0.0735585317,
0.0142575335,
-0.0110796066,
0.0181075018,
0.0520537384,
-0.0127949081,
0.0349043049,
-0.0083815427,
0.0097997738,
0.0520304739,
-0.0641806051,
-0.0035254911,
-0.0563826673,
-0.0252082534,
0.0029866686,
-0.039430771,
0.0668519884,
-0.0225927662,
-0.0479005836,
0.0569079928,
0.0364741981,
0.0356829092,
-0.001343303,
-0.0232568476,
0.0784197226,
0.0018984769,
-0.0758509338,
0.0348228998,
-0.0336063206,
0.0007085547,
-0.0214110408,
0.0654313862,
-0.0212529171,
-0.0521664619,
0.0169136636,
0.0202032067,
-0.0157047175,
0.0049748137,
0.014742109,
-0.0609045029,
-0.0184524059,
-0.0040763426,
0.0389667712,
0.0021855275,
-0.101423569,
-0.0038256848,
0.0112544475,
-0.1073883548,
-0.0845279098,
-0.0681175292,
-0.0026845932,
0.0463139042,
0.0165937115,
-0.0451917723,
0.0132292295,
-0.0530779064,
0.0028554203,
-0.0150956716,
-0.0143210208,
0.0120493323,
-0.0365257226,
-0.0416043252,
-0.0212975945,
-0.0010674505,
-0.014644349,
-0.0482278392,
-0.0105208568,
-0.0784448087,
0.029315332,
-0.0036659651,
0.0214135703,
-0.018633889,
0.0643478185,
-0.0687998161,
-0.0326592028,
0.0072968053,
-0.0204656757,
0.0746951327,
0.0236084759,
-0.0821533501,
0.0303661525,
0.0264690481,
0.0226006769,
-0.0034071503,
-0.0096900146,
-0.0022276421,
-0.0351374634,
-0.0612322129,
0.0381131433,
0.0204348452,
0.0306327809,
-0.0092107663,
-0.0116851041,
-0.0086568361,
-0.0176931061,
-0.023686748,
0.00409977,
-0.0105858045,
-0.0140875541,
0.0316007845,
0.0733010471,
-0.0483320914,
-0.0496555194,
-0.0281862412,
0.0620108843,
0.0575361587,
0.0129261976,
0.0156572927,
0.0185731091,
0.040413551,
0.0654067919,
0.0091506075,
0.0574291162,
-0.0470854566,
0.0570990182,
-0.0354969613,
-0.0458373912,
0.0095605254,
-0.0141046932,
0.0116760526,
-0.0141447857,
0.0001770625,
-0.0273950193,
0.0357523486,
-0.0398116298,
0.0396687649,
-0.0221608914,
0.053062059,
-0.062906675,
0.0217606723,
-0.0068733529,
-0.0046653892,
-0.0286570489,
-0.0592597425,
0.0021122305,
0.0169932693,
-0.02846458,
0.0121867945,
0.0587818399,
-0.0304518044,
-0.000467917,
-0.0147675965,
0.0100051397,
-0.0166058484,
0.0068097836,
0.0287047289,
0.0385097004,
0.0271932501,
0.014139601,
-0.059713643,
-0.0439386554,
0.0293579269,
-0.0110195503,
0.0411697403,
-0.0548436083,
0.0508351848,
0.0207161605,
0.0011355379,
-0.0403771475,
-0.0316675678,
0.0131237227,
0.0063154777,
0.0278045125,
-0.0009887008,
-6.080682401e-33,
0.0291541908,
-0.0489383563,
-0.0380194001,
0.0525780618,
-0.0318014957,
-0.0244597681,
-0.0107753361,
0.0659729242,
-0.0101531995,
0.017837014,
-0.0260568745,
-0.0072354828,
0.0128389942,
0.013566969,
0.0210630279,
0.0362970382,
-0.0059757,
-0.0394378118,
0.0049536601,
-0.0271532163,
0.0144347539,
-0.0365476757,
0.0438784994,
-0.0662277564,
0.0153449336,
0.0008044877,
-0.0077062221,
0.0106339082,
0.0197534673,
0.0082202768,
-0.0257135648,
0.0255710203,
0.025107611,
0.0190223102,
-0.0011944112,
0.0333501995,
0.0312495213,
-0.0612134263,
0.0480284765,
0.0168199763,
-0.0534676574,
-0.036846526,
0.0252112299,
-0.0352213643,
-0.039210014,
0.0212814324,
0.0169416927,
0.0396886691,
-0.02659088,
0.0497182533,
-0.0492838696,
0.0083545865,
-0.0088607762,
0.0006353339,
-0.0179864261,
-0.008338891,
-0.0295696612,
-0.083562769,
-0.0076956861,
0.0526327007,
-0.0507852249,
0.0614058487,
-0.0031275833,
-0.0305688325,
0.01343132,
0.0133649437,
0.1006906927,
0.0644778982,
0.0484526977,
0.0410903171,
0.0442046821,
0.0681059733,
-0.0173976347,
0.0233957935,
0.0230512545,
-0.0297560636,
-0.0157882534,
-0.0321594551,
0.0674610063,
-0.0185723174,
-0.0583440326,
0.0700479969,
-0.0089598317,
-0.0487597473,
-0.0239089355,
0.0148375696,
0.0030797219,
-0.0242786519,
-0.025511831,
-0.0379648544,
0.0411323421,
0.0220504142,
0.0155202067,
-0.0236849263,
-0.0656134188,
-0.0222876761,
-0.0383503959,
0.0486866422,
0.0188377891,
0.0230020378,
-0.0321017019,
-0.0174615681,
-0.0644135848,
0.0109564839,
0.0567918569,
0.0446474105,
-0.0054530944,
0.0233047456,
-0.0368327014,
-0.0159761626,
-0.0058545787,
-0.0326021649,
0.0091534788,
-0.0768592358,
0.0565237775,
0.0298502967,
0.0061455807,
0.0678224862,
0.0278740637,
0.0166929048,
-0.0537483357,
0.0054386216,
-0.0236538798,
0.026758166,
-0.0283211861,
-0.0391693078,
-0.008868943,
0.0273353327,
0.0626177788,
-0.0264130272,
-0.0226195119,
-0.0228048488,
2.853e-7,
0.0262533035,
0.0465076193,
0.0444976203,
0.0478695892,
0.0391453654,
0.0018686366,
0.0124773132,
0.0075603686,
-0.0288550984,
0.0158314109,
0.0107037881,
-0.041509226,
0.011480554,
0.0277453419,
-0.0343201496,
0.0479764082,
-0.0342584997,
-0.034704119,
0.0010792328,
0.0191832669,
0.0155323213,
0.0206629299,
-0.0324385129,
-0.0035112565,
-0.0573330745,
-0.0324169882,
0.0225798562,
-0.0163709819,
0.0030773988,
0.0272143539,
0.0057026176,
-0.0551637635,
0.0076562683,
0.0123234289,
0.0101697491,
0.0151060466,
-0.012893402,
-0.0088995388,
-0.006832595,
0.0288380068,
0.0276045911,
-0.0285589676,
-0.0339711234,
0.0205706675,
0.0220318157,
-0.0524714403,
-0.0629783049,
0.0367690474,
0.0197989754,
0.015245134,
0.0000994125,
-0.0014990735,
-0.00964534,
0.0376622938,
0.0266765263,
-0.0436392389,
0.0176545363,
-0.0109884748,
-0.0300121177,
0.0829228908,
-0.0074036228,
-0.0251754876,
0.013596422,
0.0357336923,
0.0495976172,
0.0205657091,
-0.045970507,
2.381669793e-34,
0.0044263466,
-0.0235710405,
0.0692856163,
-0.0271493793,
0.035433419,
-0.022622373,
0.0184974652,
0.0652985722,
0.0503525734,
-0.0369432196,
-0.0556993335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00119v1 | Machine Translation Impact in E-commerce Multilingual Search | 2023-01-31T21:59:35 | 2023-01-31T21:59:35 | Bryan Zhang, Amita Misra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Previous work suggests that performance of cross-lingual information
retrieval correlates highly with the quality of Machine Translation. However,
there may be a threshold beyond which improving query translation quality
yields little or no benefit to further improve the retrieval performance. This
threshold may depend upon multiple factors including the source and target
languages, the existing MT system quality and the search pipeline. In order to
identify the benefit of improving an MT system for a given search pipeline, we
investigate the sensitivity of retrieval quality to the presence of different
levels of MT quality using experimental datasets collected from actual traffic.
We systematically improve the performance of our MT systems quality on language
pairs as measured by MT evaluation metrics including Bleu and Chrf to determine
their impact on search precision metrics and extract signals that help to guide
the improvement strategies. Using this information we develop techniques to
compare query translations for multiple language pairs and identify the most
promising language pairs to invest and improve. | [
0.0343023576,
-0.002935909,
-0.0463226587,
0.0278096329,
-0.0260146242,
-0.0180027355,
0.0196401495,
0.0435940288,
-0.0421524756,
-0.0178193878,
-0.050404571,
-0.057121411,
0.0115324091,
0.0416819826,
0.0010026749,
-0.0087216152,
0.0181299523,
0.0281086974,
-0.0420902967,
0.0149978735,
0.012088811,
0.0303377584,
0.0510825515,
0.0156864431,
0.0535600483,
0.0471698232,
0.0236805174,
0.0390189104,
0.0079513956,
-0.0127985151,
0.001315716,
-0.0171375275,
-0.0171023235,
0.0741064176,
0.0000016764,
-0.0695054531,
-0.0517959706,
0.0162351746,
-0.0204687156,
0.022350071,
0.042794928,
-0.0305005442,
0.0286362004,
0.0544116944,
-0.0090195918,
0.0320979953,
0.0191299524,
0.0055766334,
0.0028769346,
0.0521334223,
-0.001445223,
0.0190111399,
-0.0309916195,
0.0045400728,
0.0118156374,
-0.0610217229,
-0.0263645798,
-0.0155202458,
0.0080700247,
0.0385821499,
0.0089742104,
0.0391411334,
-0.0158390701,
-0.0020199944,
-0.0060709277,
-0.0111359069,
-0.0579231121,
-0.0000571019,
0.0113979327,
0.0239060502,
0.0004314933,
-0.0034292098,
-0.0222409014,
0.0035278373,
-0.0220320374,
0.0051062494,
-0.0149184866,
-0.0094392439,
-0.0079019628,
-0.0062288791,
-0.027872093,
0.002641507,
0.0372941419,
0.0217887349,
-0.0643180236,
0.0394157246,
0.0143159125,
-0.0447431132,
0.0092275664,
-0.0023745592,
0.0050311694,
0.024122173,
0.074414365,
-0.043594081,
-0.0495312437,
-0.0004958382,
0.0256730579,
-0.0082140826,
0.0175077319,
-0.0793647245,
0.0086924229,
0.0670918971,
-0.0323079303,
0.0269723739,
-0.0265236534,
0.0645186529,
-0.0230441932,
-0.0076513952,
-0.0959172249,
-0.0412634201,
-0.0291523747,
-0.0006451873,
-0.0046258741,
-0.0345141776,
-0.0220160112,
0.0037231701,
-0.050109107,
0.0309263375,
0.0374015868,
-0.0303836185,
0.0047286302,
-0.0437036976,
-0.0431368984,
-0.0150403772,
-0.0467897281,
0.0408796817,
-0.0179980677,
-0.0379213318,
0.0065432945,
-0.0429164097,
0.0227820054,
0.0348854177,
-0.0031707361,
-0.0505067185,
0.0256759245,
0.0562094264,
0.0196216386,
-0.0074749803,
-0.025414126,
-0.0351677984,
-0.0096404916,
-0.0145003051,
0.0026703118,
0.0032907629,
0.0302523542,
0.01954896,
-0.0038396989,
0.0164078269,
-0.0139831854,
0.007561903,
-0.0207976289,
0.0529177636,
0.0174250808,
0.0001091155,
0.007373909,
-0.0353453159,
-0.0042825784,
0.0640840381,
0.0034179681,
0.0409105122,
0.0879320651,
-0.0042802026,
-0.0227314625,
0.031101292,
-0.020533694,
0.026068287,
0.0032987252,
0.0320817232,
-0.0121490629,
0.0128502036,
0.0378137156,
0.0468654893,
-0.0403139964,
0.0165462866,
0.0337037407,
0.0032313869,
0.0412813276,
-0.0029960598,
0.0245288294,
0.0115483822,
-0.0377318487,
-0.0345559791,
0.0196609516,
-0.0299750064,
-0.0207929295,
-0.0050443504,
0.063519612,
0.0298166033,
-0.0179494992,
-0.0171638075,
-0.0005173255,
0.0076725706,
-0.0004611719,
0.0204394199,
0.0592490509,
-0.0438325182,
-0.0259060301,
0.0384494811,
-0.0384939387,
-0.0449393354,
0.0341002867,
-0.0262046475,
-0.0490419865,
0.0955462158,
0.0585947484,
-0.0026013437,
0.0117221037,
-0.011217922,
-0.0531061441,
0.0258617718,
0.0345178805,
0.0146966949,
0.02001228,
-0.0368041545,
-0.0430972837,
0.0403707474,
0.0065814271,
-0.0006972314,
0.0138354087,
0.0502402857,
0.0502291024,
-0.0638669878,
-0.0046234867,
0.0005874126,
0.0175898504,
0.0208800416,
0.0332966894,
0.0197487921,
0.0111016324,
0.0249860734,
-0.0139688533,
-0.0083603254,
-0.0078022811,
0.0031642232,
-0.0469759479,
0.0306152925,
0.0455469303,
0.0496018939,
0.0277492385,
-0.0207472574,
0.0271959454,
0.0041989502,
0.0137549201,
-0.0181300361,
-0.033232145,
-0.0588514283,
0.0189359598,
-0.0290379096,
0.057006821,
-0.0492812544,
-0.0056164144,
-0.0567096621,
-0.001098449,
0.0051649981,
0.0414825603,
0.0012720923,
-0.0543810837,
0.0316240788,
-0.0321177207,
0.0142568592,
0.0501287915,
0.0147849368,
0.0638757795,
0.0771797299,
0.0093955938,
-0.0540957376,
0.0000624845,
-0.0594593063,
0.0028658269,
-0.0142563246,
0.0481236577,
0.0352535956,
0.0465184599,
0.0068289656,
0.0167796649,
-0.0024850585,
-0.0166045278,
0.0220145546,
0.0440775715,
0.0211056117,
0.0160978567,
-0.0210284125,
-0.0192704685,
-0.0441899821,
0.0254803207,
0.0290790685,
0.0013181438,
-0.0424729213,
-0.0722669363,
0.0320887715,
-0.0348376632,
-0.0310141258,
-0.0107552689,
-0.0267025512,
-0.0147264162,
-0.0306943562,
0.0008231341,
0.0194892734,
0.0042302692,
-0.050947316,
0.0196651518,
-0.0342600532,
-0.062369056,
-0.0175569393,
-0.0144157885,
-0.0240275506,
0.0046715573,
-0.05951472,
0.062090233,
-0.0198599324,
-0.0508771166,
0.0003413609,
-0.0242968425,
-0.0321005285,
-0.0330945477,
-0.0256598517,
-0.0491064601,
0.0555374846,
0.0101260375,
0.1085517555,
-0.0071452758,
-0.0620538332,
0.0282283686,
-0.0127319461,
0.0128926439,
-0.0670284033,
0.0060715149,
-0.0331207104,
-0.005204516,
-0.0325752199,
0.036799904,
-0.084029384,
-0.0668904036,
0.0084187221,
0.0453491174,
0.073314175,
-0.035037607,
0.01460669,
-0.0066295601,
-0.0067476984,
-0.0092472127,
-0.025134299,
-0.0093543166,
0.0107653085,
0.0240019634,
-0.0210682172,
0.0733980536,
-0.0399151966,
-0.0835293457,
0.057065405,
0.0221080445,
0.0148537913,
0.0092990026,
-0.0581075922,
0.0215468332,
-0.0037406192,
-0.0180918854,
-0.0154301533,
0.0255436525,
-0.024519017,
-0.019387221,
-0.0074751498,
0.0172441248,
-0.0611828528,
0.0167644285,
-0.0410523117,
0.0572550558,
-0.0318040475,
-0.0326246955,
0.0259679444,
-0.0110219484,
-0.0300974827,
-0.0024352779,
0.044519864,
0.031115884,
-0.0251111183,
-0.0426459275,
-0.0216663182,
0.0125926649,
0.0209870711,
0.0566423461,
-0.0690721795,
0.0240063928,
0.0321843438,
0.0550360903,
0.0134732714,
0.0211143382,
-0.0056855264,
-0.0898444876,
0.020080125,
-0.0099790804,
-0.0473043844,
-0.0732035488,
-0.0700406358,
-0.0292861871,
-0.0451444499,
0.0888345316,
0.0136723258,
0.0140955569,
-0.0027764197,
-0.0090414556,
0.0103533613,
-0.0754663944,
-0.0156142749,
-0.0477015451,
-0.035547521,
0.0468186997,
0.0223203413,
-0.0131845912,
-0.0080365054,
-0.0088923378,
-0.0148767279,
-0.0072101792,
-0.0215747897,
0.0396569371,
0.0000487211,
-0.0100042336,
0.006720074,
-0.0926647261,
0.0143514806,
0.0498334914,
-0.0089906119,
0.0226426478,
-0.016883878,
0.0227017142,
0.0109956171,
-0.0421246476,
-0.0406245627,
0.0425720215,
-0.0158317685,
-0.0345572196,
-0.0065303673,
-0.0403846167,
-0.0220600571,
-0.0351013243,
-0.0116091492,
0.0460284203,
-0.052336555,
-0.0307884533,
-0.0689946637,
-0.0726537481,
-0.0315448828,
0.020877054,
0.0085554253,
0.0210903846,
-0.0365196466,
0.0126512041,
-0.0206169337,
0.0220186729,
-0.0425930247,
0.0399672203,
-0.050516475,
0.0980638936,
-0.0130469687,
-0.044199042,
-0.0136736371,
-0.0311571658,
-0.0213731658,
-0.0510729067,
-0.0577118322,
0.021657791,
0.0193049982,
0.0054300474,
-0.0189779531,
-0.0308294334,
-0.0224376451,
0.0195932221,
-0.0334078521,
-0.0584545396,
0.0484359041,
-0.017198341,
-0.0420849621,
0.0177033916,
-0.0443992615,
-0.0258329194,
-0.040288955,
0.0508712418,
0.0304017775,
-0.0496412963,
0.0722536072,
0.0732352808,
0.0445815139,
-0.0326215588,
0.0023613633,
-0.0091411145,
0.0134354141,
-0.011952891,
-0.0104756625,
-0.0177870672,
-0.0258152802,
0.0581466183,
0.0023317838,
0.0173080266,
0.0598200485,
-0.030147085,
-0.0497663468,
-0.0153425401,
0.0221900158,
-0.051169429,
0.0328072533,
0.0288934931,
0.0100844642,
-0.007389212,
-0.0136032915,
0.0309461448,
0.0388253182,
-0.0612602532,
0.0248341896,
0.0054105539,
-0.0090668797,
0.005994766,
0.0494758263,
-0.0342458449,
-0.0175890066,
-0.031920813,
-0.0514875948,
0.0822610632,
-0.0166871976,
0.0987334251,
0.0155837834,
-0.0110501284,
-0.0078009265,
0.0039452179,
0.0352164395,
0.0481373928,
-0.0319035575,
0.0021822741,
-0.0214295592,
0.0367033258,
0.0482457392,
-0.06389267,
-0.0099771898,
-0.050430011,
-0.0493395105,
-0.0142768463,
-0.006949197,
0.0283490252,
-0.0043580122,
-0.0358222015,
-0.0604285188,
-0.0008290887,
-0.0196312629,
0.0210745893,
-0.0066005671,
0.0416987762,
-0.0183684584,
0.0157425292,
0.147762984,
0.0183537789,
0.0312128123,
-0.0387146287,
-0.037695013,
-0.0079072695,
0.0359898657,
-0.0230229404,
-5.891690093e-33,
0.0391164161,
0.0011374776,
-0.0196720399,
-0.0255468059,
0.009021461,
0.0134213157,
-0.0091444394,
-0.0040083169,
-0.0080029415,
-0.0172183048,
-0.0239589866,
0.0132980971,
0.0431134962,
-0.0146092204,
0.020460695,
0.0142275561,
0.0210596733,
0.0250984039,
-0.0617866293,
-0.0028719306,
0.0416092984,
0.0284776147,
0.0671986789,
-0.0273071155,
0.045324862,
-0.0187612828,
-0.0155473026,
0.0339470245,
0.0362566747,
0.0565559864,
0.0327643938,
0.0415273309,
0.0266871229,
-0.0476004742,
-0.0086989924,
-0.0630931333,
-0.0341172032,
0.0373215079,
0.0197639782,
0.0605072863,
0.0188359264,
-0.0026215843,
0.0232486818,
-0.0381590761,
-0.0164973661,
0.0308692176,
0.0167245846,
-0.0329825692,
-0.0489397123,
-0.071649529,
-0.0257572327,
0.023510363,
-0.0147355134,
0.0374013074,
0.0658370703,
0.1174163073,
-0.0196034517,
0.034262538,
-0.0348859914,
0.0478394814,
-0.0730568543,
0.0303431712,
0.0706714019,
0.0092794504,
-0.0262872912,
-0.0080028269,
0.0166053027,
0.017395122,
0.0813035667,
0.0014518931,
0.0484022275,
-0.0024766559,
0.0497104786,
0.0661726147,
0.0266846679,
-0.0134674348,
-0.0164503157,
0.0685007572,
0.0076399967,
0.0192840844,
0.0093995985,
0.0437302329,
-0.0589549281,
-0.0376826972,
-0.0215554927,
-0.0045235911,
-0.0464579388,
-0.0317190178,
0.03999421,
0.0252842568,
-0.0282237418,
-0.0280264802,
0.0721124262,
-0.027733719,
-0.0260697566,
-0.0300686657,
-0.0313555673,
-0.0215674359,
0.0063803494,
0.0433413424,
-0.0027949365,
-0.0459859855,
-0.0325180702,
-0.0086311586,
-0.0546269566,
-0.0490978137,
0.0226003304,
-0.0142006287,
-0.0531620383,
0.0291490294,
0.0005570949,
-0.0191630833,
-0.0236831065,
-0.0155443493,
0.014718866,
-0.0159212425,
0.0056486716,
0.0138195474,
0.08385887,
0.0169900581,
-0.0408912525,
-0.0271468684,
0.0196050294,
0.0357525498,
-0.0140781496,
0.0204588473,
-0.035191521,
0.0524738394,
0.0195842236,
-0.0439449325,
-0.0500820242,
-0.0019948119,
2.585e-7,
0.0753840283,
0.0767760128,
-0.0316167586,
0.0583879761,
-0.0275583994,
0.0137729393,
-0.0047532562,
0.0068700863,
0.0174459927,
0.0265316535,
0.0398086347,
-0.0214929469,
0.0621730909,
0.0406701565,
-0.0272545964,
-0.0447816513,
-0.0385800526,
0.0035550529,
-0.0502413996,
0.0041334014,
0.0157808736,
0.0857918039,
-0.0269437581,
-0.0003325232,
-0.0096056676,
-0.0787844509,
0.0325751863,
-0.0592490472,
-0.0263437517,
0.0023348788,
0.0680965483,
0.0286963377,
-0.0264048353,
-0.0208525769,
-0.0065227193,
0.0214877855,
0.0559374914,
0.0191162582,
0.0347535796,
0.0151380086,
0.0091675157,
-0.0463787802,
0.0058008684,
-0.040475674,
0.028239375,
0.0320174918,
0.0119551904,
0.0098246224,
-0.0074149822,
0.0022968969,
0.0854804516,
-0.0500276387,
-0.0533045977,
0.0300660245,
0.0355735235,
0.0205108356,
-0.0150940083,
-0.0301211253,
0.0105741499,
-0.0100389188,
-0.0022337716,
-0.0369775183,
-0.0011207223,
0.0143401036,
0.0021939462,
0.0257519614,
0.0137684513,
2.178965894e-34,
0.0840922147,
-0.0074773617,
0.0260870978,
-0.0101358611,
0.0594696701,
-0.0129936328,
-0.0192339942,
-0.0107430173,
-0.0165217929,
-0.0585165769,
-0.0159130208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00102v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00102v3 | Towards Detecting Harmful Agendas in News Articles | 2023-01-31T21:08:58 | 2023-08-02T17:16:48 | Melanie Subbiah, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Yilun Hua, Tharindu Kumarage, Huan Liu, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Manipulated news online is a growing problem which necessitates the use of
automated systems to curtail its spread. We argue that while misinformation and
disinformation detection have been studied, there has been a lack of investment
in the important open challenge of detecting harmful agendas in news articles;
identifying harmful agendas is critical to flag news campaigns with the
greatest potential for real world harm. Moreover, due to real concerns around
censorship, harmful agenda detectors must be interpretable to be effective. In
this work, we propose this new task and release a dataset, NewsAgendas, of
annotated news articles for agenda identification. We show how interpretable
systems can be effective on this task and demonstrate that they can perform
comparably to black-box models. | [
0.0157615766,
0.0083278995,
-0.0192736499,
0.0457635149,
-0.0226022266,
0.0336896926,
0.0177116673,
-0.0067099305,
0.0279068872,
-0.0273025688,
-0.0188397802,
0.0241081566,
-0.0183727592,
0.0793765113,
-0.0251583066,
-0.0189689323,
0.047863014,
0.0305924453,
0.0455083326,
0.0060361624,
0.0507522337,
0.0541941375,
-0.0160259902,
0.0513959005,
0.0017778346,
-0.0518861338,
0.0051397095,
-0.0023410199,
0.0274581406,
0.0136362771,
-0.0283213239,
0.0316480584,
0.0009200711,
0.0985370949,
0.0000017545,
0.0168515183,
-0.0513408072,
-0.0291310139,
-0.0370744169,
-0.0169812962,
0.0727010518,
-0.0706756637,
0.0072911135,
-0.0001002727,
-0.0125917336,
0.0101578161,
0.0284852255,
0.0419627875,
0.1108995751,
0.0788373202,
-0.0126066888,
0.0115064643,
0.0206561089,
0.0195156615,
0.0283988584,
-0.0310764369,
0.0480948724,
-0.0405278243,
-0.0759830475,
0.0385328233,
0.0052203941,
0.0026333169,
0.0245825313,
-0.0054294602,
-0.0486464202,
-0.0685457066,
-0.0032661054,
-0.0387690663,
0.0015456228,
0.0540179983,
-0.0076346598,
-0.0343470126,
0.0340842977,
-0.0108058387,
-0.0145426467,
0.0283226334,
-0.0299334787,
0.003419434,
-0.0235874895,
0.015665235,
0.0613100305,
-0.0328920372,
0.0284421537,
0.0548711643,
0.0152434679,
0.0770091191,
-0.0374998003,
-0.0003673559,
0.0001903546,
-0.0224105828,
0.0160565041,
-0.0143596875,
0.0478930213,
-0.0517997108,
-0.007209681,
0.0385934412,
-0.0540534593,
-0.0467527322,
-0.0022640305,
-0.0808460489,
-0.0505938046,
-0.0073912162,
-0.0272936858,
0.0748393685,
0.0274934843,
-0.0366668403,
-0.0440408811,
0.063028127,
-0.0143955033,
0.012780034,
-0.0039392617,
0.0144324228,
-0.0042872485,
0.0133671919,
-0.0093293041,
0.0213700458,
-0.0408821218,
-0.0042534187,
-0.0376874581,
0.0121695064,
-0.0281937364,
-0.0213574078,
-0.0112033542,
-0.0358413048,
0.0074708816,
0.0399500579,
-0.0164989326,
0.051419083,
-0.0138804307,
-0.0101472065,
-0.0130284969,
0.0492463224,
-0.0106501952,
-0.0101257749,
-0.021903336,
0.0352004282,
0.0400483049,
0.0074262186,
-0.0384047367,
-0.0733484253,
-0.0148105118,
-0.0015575005,
0.0392173603,
-0.0019226925,
-0.0018775513,
-0.013634217,
-0.0033036415,
-0.0548288152,
-0.0091910865,
0.012551765,
-0.0292260312,
0.0596418269,
0.036544688,
-0.0310112368,
0.0242492612,
0.0454263762,
-0.0432217866,
0.090777494,
0.0028552334,
0.135126248,
0.0809943452,
-0.0082312953,
-0.0174956135,
0.026034791,
0.0480016544,
0.0386267602,
-0.0056849774,
0.0151309604,
-0.0169589277,
-0.0252240412,
-0.0158608165,
-0.0242462624,
-0.0037039823,
-0.0738743544,
0.0682700649,
-0.0074863122,
-0.040109735,
-0.0099307504,
0.0317608006,
0.0127416151,
-0.03464064,
-0.0014147436,
-0.042270299,
0.0014765697,
-0.0314498097,
-0.0826042965,
-0.0304421708,
0.0290811565,
-0.0045598801,
-0.0218476132,
0.0068590562,
0.0093588959,
0.0319826901,
-0.0310680754,
0.0352586396,
-0.0009382862,
-0.0433076695,
-0.006391969,
0.0214230325,
0.0078209816,
0.0404228307,
-0.0503753982,
0.053060513,
0.0123066045,
0.0428004451,
-0.0358564258,
-0.0084756706,
-0.0576372109,
0.0497234873,
0.0070679211,
0.0189403407,
-0.0388418697,
-0.0278308038,
-0.0047081434,
-0.0295955818,
0.0112006543,
0.0231183674,
0.0367701128,
0.0082455417,
0.0073132413,
-0.0031667245,
-0.0140722962,
-0.035920687,
0.0199014638,
0.0202247109,
-0.0359195992,
-0.0154254343,
0.0312921815,
0.0512342229,
0.035466902,
0.0185749233,
-0.0295727756,
0.0436253026,
0.0036331024,
-0.0383430533,
-0.0100346822,
0.0058331136,
0.020330729,
-0.0211345106,
-0.0473369732,
-0.0247134697,
0.0824764147,
-0.0213791616,
0.0128678288,
0.0393535905,
-0.0344854593,
-0.0163480379,
-0.0194946751,
-0.0381520167,
-0.0407646671,
0.0186109282,
0.0058623138,
0.0529784635,
-0.0328449495,
-0.0473839827,
0.0022775731,
-0.0832255334,
-0.0074676196,
0.0106736841,
0.0261892918,
-0.0155509105,
0.0020205339,
-0.0044018179,
0.0300629996,
-0.0365463309,
-0.0300959405,
-0.0005712113,
-0.011094342,
0.0022713027,
-0.0333347768,
0.0196648911,
0.0547612384,
0.0021176322,
0.0245597512,
0.0280728843,
-0.0189318322,
0.0151391085,
-0.0174308326,
0.0383407399,
-0.0112313218,
-0.0066225906,
-0.0238048881,
-0.0073822644,
0.0043183523,
-0.0457615107,
0.0456906222,
0.0301798806,
-0.0338679925,
-0.0118378941,
-0.0305369291,
-0.0104070017,
-0.034487728,
-0.0423903652,
-0.0187768135,
-0.0110759214,
-0.0124939401,
-0.1101403609,
0.060596697,
0.0253636055,
0.1225704178,
0.008121294,
0.0560145229,
-0.0299848523,
-0.0590225235,
-0.0626044422,
0.0713188648,
-0.0349217802,
-0.0561946183,
0.0456000902,
0.0607222766,
0.028901251,
0.0166027844,
-0.0191629864,
0.0539999343,
-0.0302481018,
-0.0423007272,
-0.0244177207,
-0.0498227365,
0.0244680773,
0.0299836323,
-0.0227967314,
-0.0492353328,
0.0642998144,
0.0087809041,
0.0312211625,
-0.011819182,
-0.0367592201,
-0.0317589417,
0.0038458458,
-0.0132855447,
0.0177124012,
0.0060419394,
-0.0076799542,
-0.0040274882,
-0.0149113284,
0.0439456627,
-0.0229107123,
0.0167095494,
-0.0365457945,
0.0160195492,
0.037961524,
-0.0053781243,
-0.0500522405,
-0.0864202753,
0.0241680294,
-0.0257918071,
0.017721964,
0.0059019253,
-0.0799792781,
0.023179993,
0.0333175883,
0.0060979407,
-0.0135062151,
0.0177374408,
-0.0176537316,
0.0084514646,
0.0282400772,
-0.0714407191,
0.0560283586,
0.0065754401,
-0.003218574,
0.0469113588,
-0.0043349192,
0.0062384042,
-0.0182052273,
0.0017821051,
0.0044709868,
-0.0403465182,
0.0107657155,
-0.0543534644,
0.0076004146,
-0.0560082309,
0.0337128006,
0.0677617416,
0.0163337737,
-0.0409952328,
0.0038151005,
0.0220890716,
-0.0447669849,
-0.0019315708,
-0.0251217503,
-0.0831346139,
0.0054032407,
0.0203209706,
0.0475678518,
-0.0452482104,
-0.0660570711,
-0.0152659602,
-0.02591029,
-0.0104688415,
0.0117769139,
-0.0145361526,
-0.0210755151,
-0.085886322,
-0.0289399978,
-0.0713081956,
-0.0037193212,
-0.0055111945,
0.0481237695,
-0.003084626,
-0.0318164155,
-0.0181301199,
-0.0213234071,
0.0088403625,
0.0251278542,
0.0199123397,
0.0315252878,
0.0302977711,
-0.0273631141,
0.0055626691,
0.0323279947,
0.0164894946,
-0.0576450378,
-0.0303051826,
0.0714006945,
-0.0558312498,
-0.0291940421,
-0.0105347522,
0.0771880299,
-0.0061519602,
-0.0087596225,
0.0142123615,
0.0440915227,
-0.0040683914,
-0.0388642028,
-0.0147408014,
0.0031368686,
0.0803717598,
0.0566855483,
0.024608789,
-0.0113216676,
0.0261444412,
-0.0617851429,
0.0164386947,
-0.0155754425,
-0.0305124316,
0.0079251733,
-0.0180475507,
-0.025152443,
-0.0377491526,
-0.0262672678,
-0.0004075469,
0.0218842663,
0.0021962747,
-0.023440592,
0.0256861281,
-0.0152784865,
-0.0192148611,
0.0137560926,
0.0055266856,
-0.0007536717,
0.0137443412,
-0.0525732338,
-0.0276673939,
0.0076529738,
-0.0570822842,
0.0397503003,
-0.0613195375,
-0.0041435608,
0.031781625,
0.0173129775,
0.0226099938,
0.0261243526,
-0.0127598662,
0.0158245377,
0.0239699297,
-0.0047073481,
-0.034057986,
-0.0218286365,
0.0264855623,
0.0004444194,
0.0369342752,
0.0215016603,
-0.0188055374,
0.0386956297,
0.0179150458,
-0.0686894953,
-0.0942777768,
0.0333690457,
0.0091554103,
0.0118844854,
0.0439710915,
0.0232637729,
-0.0434624888,
-0.0657983869,
-0.0161038153,
-0.032758303,
-0.0195478573,
0.0114169279,
0.0138458712,
0.0355618633,
-0.0400015675,
-0.02487709,
0.0310427137,
-0.0387983844,
-0.0179748107,
-0.0433930866,
0.0406252183,
0.0022514886,
0.0386918411,
0.0036578369,
-0.0078363083,
-0.0332487151,
0.0500317477,
-0.0059186704,
0.0351332836,
-0.0126851406,
0.0165239405,
0.0180845372,
0.0035764556,
0.0421505496,
-0.0161109045,
-0.0379449502,
-0.0040651308,
-0.0039049017,
0.0342349671,
-0.0249323808,
-0.0158287268,
0.0186510608,
0.0057323957,
-0.0249860585,
-0.0005838485,
0.0295280349,
0.0240356233,
-0.0362327322,
-0.0022648796,
0.0233367644,
-0.0273133777,
0.018657282,
0.042001076,
-0.0120640267,
0.0521489978,
0.0600575469,
-0.0649645701,
-0.0472771041,
-0.0183884911,
0.0150989443,
0.0396308415,
-0.0061034397,
0.0054881894,
-0.054671865,
-0.028440645,
0.0460463166,
-0.0396542065,
0.0244187415,
0.0173879266,
-0.0477794446,
0.0723928586,
0.0118931411,
-0.0004550193,
-0.0366755463,
0.0143471481,
-0.1061583385,
-0.0338253565,
0.0175303128,
-5.345520887e-33,
-0.0106225014,
-0.054570917,
-0.0447508581,
0.0010531474,
0.0320609696,
0.0191293322,
0.0172896869,
-0.0572301298,
-0.0127483122,
0.0219638385,
0.0501750857,
0.0550666861,
0.0104360087,
0.0035783297,
-0.048577968,
-0.0523763746,
0.0347120576,
-0.0109680621,
-0.0166026205,
0.0273889992,
0.0826614574,
0.0010005201,
0.0160027463,
-0.0638966933,
0.0701492131,
0.0034709908,
-0.0368389525,
-0.0102631031,
0.0047297096,
0.0464392006,
0.0030991312,
0.0341999754,
0.0457470492,
-0.0738432333,
0.0081096543,
0.0699790344,
-0.0122814318,
-0.0055142166,
0.0377464518,
0.0220075939,
0.0060216328,
0.0073533105,
0.0301165562,
0.0087318001,
-0.0000319978,
-0.0230527371,
0.0330745615,
-0.0486644208,
0.0137238689,
0.0459712036,
-0.0498790853,
0.010784856,
-0.062141303,
0.0183748342,
-0.0001275339,
0.0599685982,
0.0677534863,
0.0427124947,
-0.0555935912,
0.0068768729,
-0.0466391966,
0.011388313,
0.0343059525,
-0.0278268028,
-0.0190876983,
0.0742665529,
0.0248946771,
0.0166189242,
-0.0406390131,
0.0437171645,
0.003676835,
0.0371961184,
0.0556140952,
0.0659411997,
-0.017545348,
-0.0337866284,
-0.0889323056,
0.0380607136,
0.0348801278,
0.0075818347,
0.0187824797,
-0.0324511416,
-0.0351269245,
0.0247154832,
-0.0250765719,
-0.0636368319,
-0.0317672268,
-0.0163380783,
-0.002280422,
-0.0019207054,
-0.0720501244,
0.0711996481,
0.0153008699,
-0.0505791903,
0.0373202004,
0.0716369972,
-0.0049962103,
-0.0065180287,
0.0077529475,
0.033772517,
-0.0446452461,
-0.0202995744,
0.0200544298,
-0.0101315612,
0.0580722466,
-0.017817555,
0.0650273114,
-0.0061643431,
-0.0246423334,
-0.0074652429,
-0.027141951,
0.0294211358,
-0.0133077679,
0.0368878469,
0.0633622557,
0.0012889019,
-0.0091737146,
0.0010824619,
-0.0051302556,
0.0237268675,
0.0364050418,
-0.0437712818,
-0.041117955,
0.0258435719,
-0.0533485599,
-0.0439241752,
0.0302816126,
0.0062506138,
0.0115572112,
-0.0682290867,
0.0134254154,
-0.0732290894,
2.422e-7,
0.0283902418,
0.0636361986,
0.0216742083,
0.0165248141,
0.0402216688,
0.0471002497,
0.0314636491,
0.0412482508,
-0.0697003081,
-0.0890790373,
0.0084159458,
0.0248271171,
0.0239308421,
0.0344303474,
-0.0466491804,
0.0104373237,
-0.0209422298,
0.03113156,
-0.0654509589,
0.0340087004,
0.0292231627,
0.058932133,
0.0506636128,
-0.0109049054,
0.0112273535,
0.0096687144,
0.0175936632,
-0.0220076554,
-0.0284504276,
0.0015049424,
0.0103725428,
-0.0119931027,
0.0020470417,
0.0088457167,
-0.020653354,
0.0035077378,
-0.0109850867,
0.0700792596,
0.0087456331,
0.0037174285,
-0.0267953947,
-0.0371309556,
0.0066637974,
-0.0494881831,
0.0836855397,
-0.0201957095,
-0.0371395014,
-0.0654224381,
-0.0328345075,
-0.015721187,
0.0094771059,
-0.007059013,
0.0299701672,
0.01661372,
-0.0280810278,
-0.0075193387,
0.0375020765,
-0.0342873186,
0.0387035906,
-0.0075226873,
-0.0424175002,
-0.0223932844,
-0.0210007299,
-0.0079671824,
0.028466763,
-0.0451712385,
0.0119519904,
2.060820906e-34,
0.0254558846,
-0.0113205919,
-0.0164983179,
-0.0076911389,
0.031638518,
-0.0119417422,
-0.0595782511,
-0.0127864797,
0.0122805312,
-0.0441104025,
0.0145527562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00093v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00093v3 | Large Language Models Can Be Easily Distracted by Irrelevant Context | 2023-01-31T20:48:57 | 2023-06-06T08:36:20 | Freda Shi, Xinyun Chen, Kanishka Misra, Nathan Scales, David Dohan, Ed Chi, Nathanael Schärli, Denny Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have achieved impressive performance on various natural
language processing tasks. However, so far they have been evaluated primarily
on benchmarks where all information in the input context is relevant for
solving the task. In this work, we investigate the distractibility of large
language models, i.e., how the model problem-solving accuracy can be influenced
by irrelevant context. In particular, we introduce Grade-School Math with
Irrelevant Context (GSM-IC), an arithmetic reasoning dataset with irrelevant
information in the problem description. We use this benchmark to measure the
distractibility of cutting-edge prompting techniques for large language models,
and find that the model performance is dramatically decreased when irrelevant
information is included. We also identify several approaches for mitigating
this deficiency, such as decoding with self-consistency and adding to the
prompt an instruction that tells the language model to ignore the irrelevant
information. | [
0.0071935961,
0.0719897524,
0.0015740973,
0.0514777824,
-0.0340986401,
0.0192408245,
0.0512859039,
-0.0161655452,
-0.0230295938,
-0.0467055216,
-0.0249780286,
-0.0270521361,
0.0125665003,
-0.0010521977,
0.0008989644,
-0.0404645763,
0.0596733615,
-0.0707637146,
0.0319654979,
-0.0153622832,
-0.0513044707,
-0.0338004269,
-0.0082458649,
0.0176232401,
-0.0024024895,
-0.0701432973,
0.0087418742,
-0.0222647693,
-0.0131098488,
-0.0401108377,
-0.0039587617,
0.0698156282,
-0.0240339972,
0.0439136997,
0.0000021188,
-0.0683462098,
0.0159974303,
-0.0174921192,
-0.0946139544,
0.0421077758,
0.0089652417,
0.0118737975,
-0.0160923842,
0.0044095218,
-0.0367635749,
0.0183915477,
0.0399470739,
0.059381023,
0.0562477186,
0.0470810495,
0.00509805,
0.0016977615,
-0.0021970004,
-0.0207731985,
0.0685746223,
-0.0765879974,
0.0197106637,
0.0189702008,
0.0071629714,
0.0365394019,
-0.0437316895,
0.0535561591,
0.0500007905,
0.0103539824,
-0.0205260124,
0.0345173851,
-0.0363901071,
0.0122003043,
-0.0035650644,
0.0750316978,
-0.0068946001,
-0.0027037596,
-0.0117831277,
-0.0127424113,
0.0150974346,
-0.0189802069,
-0.0656805485,
0.0334263891,
0.0108788786,
0.0065661045,
0.0355800502,
0.0047331862,
0.028464118,
0.0177392196,
-0.0288228486,
0.0788485184,
0.0093073696,
-0.0320416652,
0.0074842507,
0.0234384928,
-0.044408679,
-0.0722672641,
0.0018458236,
0.03440696,
-0.0617185757,
0.0253595412,
-0.0597064532,
-0.026621867,
-0.0064807585,
-0.0295313615,
-0.0150759146,
0.0813313276,
-0.0173266511,
0.0822305158,
-0.0025888865,
0.0622399636,
-0.0270246062,
0.0095889689,
-0.0094021587,
0.0232660845,
0.0132117318,
-0.0050944779,
-0.0437966473,
0.0224324148,
-0.0395222791,
-0.011116338,
-0.005217622,
0.0435076095,
-0.0166678708,
0.0305733979,
0.0002310355,
-0.0024289882,
-0.0254893191,
-0.0291170888,
-0.0160014462,
0.025369307,
-0.0541659705,
0.0142186973,
0.0134971542,
-0.0729753822,
-0.0375141613,
-0.0136647206,
0.0095584122,
-0.0479198024,
-0.0044456013,
0.0644351393,
0.0035690281,
-0.0337189026,
-0.0212086476,
-0.0022607103,
0.0202095378,
-0.0708205923,
-0.0179976057,
-0.054780677,
0.018922044,
0.0412939563,
-0.0035197998,
-0.0519927554,
0.0014488721,
0.0321428962,
-0.0115304589,
0.0770758614,
0.0163185634,
-0.0046508745,
0.0150063131,
0.0126605593,
-0.0240549091,
0.0640057325,
0.0143409129,
-0.0303981658,
0.0380707197,
-0.0379803181,
0.0023480705,
0.0394944437,
-0.0015683962,
-0.0102053182,
-0.0155360829,
0.0056588524,
0.0251577385,
0.020755155,
0.0203256477,
0.0453223176,
-0.0096438332,
-0.0206414852,
0.0686966553,
0.0454196446,
-0.0292907134,
0.0020006634,
-0.0064920736,
0.0161453076,
0.0153552387,
0.0275443532,
-0.1259168237,
0.0208787937,
-0.0433455519,
0.0218446422,
0.0336738229,
-0.0020311784,
-0.0281247627,
-0.0559466183,
-0.0082842195,
0.0040197945,
0.0099406699,
0.0464700013,
0.0695113391,
0.0100928219,
-0.0187360905,
0.0277328826,
0.0084361788,
-0.0288904812,
-0.0064023333,
-0.029981859,
0.0573465899,
0.043838162,
0.0592462607,
-0.0397322215,
-0.0250801612,
0.0000459962,
0.0175691564,
0.0227586012,
0.0375603177,
0.0039247046,
0.0271918401,
-0.0339150839,
-0.0380808152,
-0.0177959409,
0.0328152999,
-0.0407087728,
0.0456270762,
0.0013637492,
0.0075980127,
-0.0094448999,
0.0030611886,
0.0341169909,
-0.0460763164,
-0.0880384222,
-0.0010421099,
-0.0007559499,
-0.010325009,
-0.0021258364,
0.0137163457,
0.0330529064,
0.0230609458,
-0.0138101457,
0.0348453969,
-0.0262671448,
-0.1036863402,
-0.0385977179,
0.0227318853,
-0.0124596665,
-0.0483258851,
0.0184647441,
-0.029548049,
-0.0257339943,
0.0424888469,
-0.0374677293,
0.0418716781,
0.0208688769,
0.0436415821,
0.0120443283,
0.0042331163,
-0.0210558772,
0.0931226462,
0.0087479241,
0.0367200226,
0.0562550388,
0.050336834,
-0.0038733578,
-0.0416659489,
-0.0112127019,
-0.0041910927,
-0.0187739115,
-0.0041149142,
-0.0161575042,
-0.0083238119,
-0.056691125,
-0.007569151,
-0.0457804538,
-0.0146476114,
-0.0230957307,
0.0325764939,
0.0141157275,
0.0148006547,
-0.0127933705,
-0.0482568331,
-0.0308203623,
-0.0198492147,
-0.0061326004,
0.0255427659,
0.0090239597,
0.0045357626,
0.0077990806,
-0.0332607999,
-0.0316880718,
-0.007436356,
0.0428596772,
0.0050276197,
-0.0020237977,
-0.0565972365,
0.0521103889,
-0.0047682761,
0.0432515442,
-0.0077304449,
0.0552365892,
0.0257609878,
-0.0283400789,
0.0699838698,
0.1011767164,
-0.0263460949,
0.0123121897,
0.0647888556,
-0.0134849511,
-0.0743125975,
0.0145608373,
-0.0147431009,
-0.0146615719,
0.0071482463,
-0.0465131886,
-0.0092298044,
0.0994266421,
-0.0173486099,
-0.0025956766,
-0.0364603251,
0.0355287194,
-0.0245103687,
-0.0148051968,
-0.0706202313,
-0.0042430693,
-0.0303716678,
0.061202798,
-0.0234511569,
-0.0405027084,
0.0558787733,
-0.0005477651,
-0.0110756066,
-0.0340920351,
0.0236264877,
-0.0290925354,
0.0571492128,
-0.0182869863,
-0.025772268,
0.0151777351,
-0.0442558825,
-0.0304190479,
0.0141663384,
0.0084457276,
-0.0397701301,
0.0689972416,
-0.0634691492,
0.0144160669,
-0.0073222117,
-0.0523683317,
-0.0830126852,
-0.0336017981,
-0.0430527478,
0.0036863852,
-0.0170319844,
-0.0171457604,
-0.0260819737,
-0.0348308906,
0.0509433746,
0.0759850219,
-0.0181172062,
-0.0126435095,
-0.0297094099,
0.0300709847,
0.0300347414,
0.0333594382,
0.0438021235,
-0.0252181552,
0.045581121,
0.0468726382,
0.0590830371,
0.0124732088,
0.0046809078,
0.027076995,
0.0349974036,
-0.0035328413,
-0.0261786394,
0.0559940115,
0.0568714328,
-0.0890148208,
-0.0441212542,
0.119314827,
0.0492850207,
-0.0356591009,
0.0072441548,
-0.0556318611,
0.0070657101,
0.0338053331,
-0.0054717511,
-0.0568812564,
-0.0453377441,
0.0509761684,
0.0146963522,
0.0051835026,
-0.0387868248,
-0.0160698984,
-0.1125453636,
0.0207746737,
0.0018025967,
-0.0351302102,
-0.0310553294,
-0.0635279119,
0.0102645699,
-0.0080388924,
0.025339609,
0.011999947,
-0.0096533122,
-0.0124207418,
-0.0120317796,
0.0062954384,
-0.0608962625,
0.0393940024,
-0.0113801211,
0.0424686261,
0.0474698357,
-0.0313414894,
-0.0075441152,
-0.0494920947,
0.0658498928,
-0.0081271417,
-0.0273930393,
0.0012628402,
0.0369833782,
-0.0048583518,
-0.0265468843,
-0.0202908963,
0.0276404284,
-0.042973496,
-0.0373873711,
0.0374776982,
0.0924934223,
-0.0150766252,
-0.0110399937,
0.008008684,
-0.0182281286,
0.0103365686,
0.1142840385,
0.039131742,
-0.0554227233,
-0.0161881633,
-0.0658315867,
-0.0129996827,
-0.0098320292,
-0.0159957521,
0.0389352813,
0.0214617494,
-0.0428050645,
-0.0285401288,
-0.0376108289,
0.0613027737,
-0.0008203351,
0.0109238876,
0.0043005673,
0.0083172219,
-0.0101115368,
-0.0167696159,
0.0683260933,
-0.0434459858,
0.0178564005,
-0.0667722821,
0.0282729659,
-0.0365862958,
-0.0245070811,
-0.0068113399,
0.031642478,
-0.0781927556,
-0.0492758974,
0.0259839911,
0.0079185469,
0.0293456968,
0.0403659903,
-0.0167559572,
-0.046905268,
-0.0357474424,
0.0026734977,
-0.0397980362,
0.0219123345,
0.0106082298,
-0.0190541204,
0.0178969037,
0.0283908918,
-0.0337540917,
0.0141765708,
0.0315994509,
0.051292222,
-0.0642609522,
0.0093362248,
0.040718995,
0.0179843064,
0.0214340892,
0.0138949705,
0.0236934703,
-0.0276610982,
0.0220206622,
-0.0288792793,
-0.0215681382,
-0.0163800996,
-0.0094419168,
0.016862087,
-0.009170047,
0.0191722959,
-0.0265250858,
-0.0205442868,
0.0094918879,
-0.0233752821,
0.0264662653,
-0.0011921282,
0.0349017866,
0.0485779643,
-0.0170093868,
-0.0309534725,
0.027891906,
0.0025540227,
0.0363880731,
0.0012703862,
0.0589613989,
0.0224933438,
-0.007883261,
-0.0256269388,
-0.0214192215,
-0.0707271323,
-0.0368390568,
0.0149133708,
0.0237107445,
0.0030499832,
-0.0390009247,
-0.0034052248,
-0.0327301808,
-0.0025511747,
-0.0346631482,
0.0140046459,
0.0625084862,
-0.0321237408,
0.0355141349,
0.0411638655,
0.0211079121,
-0.0151554355,
0.0444356948,
-0.0196430907,
0.0315326639,
0.0119991796,
0.0149742365,
-0.0289498381,
-0.0121342288,
0.0043762638,
0.0375720151,
-0.0368141048,
0.0380667523,
-0.0648821667,
-0.0716798529,
-0.0406533033,
-0.003757796,
0.00294556,
-0.0580712631,
0.0359771997,
0.0490243509,
-0.0174405333,
-0.0264993608,
0.0047909073,
0.0538901165,
-0.0227678139,
-0.0267590508,
-0.0641104877,
-6.511226309e-33,
-0.01496178,
-0.036429882,
0.0199558679,
-0.0090796482,
0.023122903,
0.0181615204,
-0.0693983734,
0.0439637564,
-0.032589063,
-0.0113588916,
-0.0436130576,
0.0304518361,
0.0175715275,
0.0239435155,
-0.0030470667,
-0.0241544954,
0.0289501157,
-0.0122464644,
-0.039298676,
-0.0044741617,
0.0194731988,
-0.0131283524,
0.0497463755,
-0.0731826499,
0.0773196295,
-0.0115943374,
0.014631209,
0.0127706872,
-0.0276922956,
0.043972183,
-0.051798258,
0.0589974038,
0.0322338156,
-0.0530941002,
-0.0326109678,
0.062601462,
-0.0674245581,
-0.0462035313,
0.0256172754,
0.019450387,
-0.0673074871,
-0.0419334397,
0.0360999554,
-0.0009649795,
-0.0408430286,
-0.0179453939,
0.0045678648,
-0.0284725633,
-0.0377510749,
0.0458263233,
-0.0625889599,
0.0287845228,
-0.0191791635,
-0.0211849529,
0.0498578176,
0.0627353415,
-0.0153335799,
0.0271244664,
-0.0240614787,
0.030808026,
0.0575496331,
0.0226469506,
0.0492466018,
0.0101947151,
-0.0035360788,
0.0418422297,
0.0273125321,
-0.0071147871,
-0.023800103,
-0.0490536019,
0.0127427001,
0.0284987874,
0.0549088195,
-0.0112381196,
0.0789876729,
0.0113584278,
-0.0504902937,
-0.017766729,
-0.0189315416,
0.0109141255,
0.0269740932,
-0.0205095951,
-0.0701640993,
-0.0334478877,
-0.0414677113,
-0.0009281822,
-0.0619413182,
0.00689433,
0.0536308065,
-0.008847082,
0.0141401878,
0.0045784209,
0.01760686,
-0.0221980996,
-0.0091702053,
0.0312549882,
0.0167240053,
0.0222702976,
-0.0001385444,
0.0177939627,
-0.0381246172,
0.0085046738,
0.0069388975,
-0.0023204267,
0.0175087024,
0.0236020386,
0.0170404501,
-0.0115666883,
-0.0687559098,
-0.0209182613,
-0.0425971635,
0.0292052478,
0.0288016498,
0.0223534703,
0.062334571,
-0.0092509147,
-0.0059267324,
0.0447317101,
-0.0082078353,
-0.0312664658,
-0.0273707956,
0.0163007081,
-0.0139241861,
0.0250516646,
-0.0196611732,
-0.0265641343,
-0.0325444192,
0.0376574881,
0.0480551273,
-0.024269307,
-0.0124045871,
-0.0000031386,
2.671e-7,
0.0366381556,
0.0355267115,
0.0158917364,
0.024855312,
0.0154755106,
0.0467871912,
-0.0258624852,
-0.002018282,
0.0172905698,
-0.012910381,
-0.0101186046,
0.0464477278,
0.0228312314,
-0.0081102215,
-0.0652448386,
0.006851472,
-0.0236704834,
0.0112826796,
-0.0444851108,
0.0364754051,
0.0442634784,
0.0940678418,
0.0070975991,
-0.0017094691,
0.0002389165,
-0.0236288514,
0.021786727,
-0.0462125205,
0.0210665595,
-0.0041648177,
-0.0097245742,
0.0033919155,
0.0098537784,
0.0140219498,
-0.0046249912,
0.0008136487,
0.0158889834,
0.079131335,
0.0137469266,
0.0182475001,
-0.0356838629,
-0.0041681845,
-0.0094222259,
-0.0537627824,
0.0866776854,
-0.0459393449,
-0.0248709656,
-0.0064428346,
-0.0066297264,
-0.0100920973,
0.0045964178,
0.0217159297,
-0.0087143481,
-0.0477790646,
0.0257515796,
-0.0260546543,
-0.0096135018,
-0.0553460792,
-0.0422047861,
-0.0029619229,
-0.0420362502,
-0.0411288515,
-0.0510738976,
0.0058588851,
0.0421757959,
-0.0347719267,
0.009646209,
2.417543952e-34,
0.0354168192,
-0.0058325385,
0.0612049438,
0.0352545381,
-0.0004786841,
-0.0047756247,
-0.0065538655,
0.0248268731,
0.0479581244,
-0.0703565627,
-0.0125345839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00083v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00083v3 | In-Context Retrieval-Augmented Language Models | 2023-01-31T20:26:16 | 2023-08-01T12:10:15 | Ori Ram, Yoav Levine, Itay Dalmedigos, Dor Muhlgay, Amnon Shashua, Kevin Leyton-Brown, Yoav Shoham | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval-Augmented Language Modeling (RALM) methods, which condition a
language model (LM) on relevant documents from a grounding corpus during
generation, were shown to significantly improve language modeling performance.
In addition, they can mitigate the problem of factually inaccurate text
generation and provide natural source attribution mechanism. Existing RALM
approaches focus on modifying the LM architecture in order to facilitate the
incorporation of external information, significantly complicating deployment.
This paper considers a simple alternative, which we dub In-Context RALM:
leaving the LM architecture unchanged and prepending grounding documents to the
input, without any further training of the LM. We show that In-Context RALM
that builds on off-the-shelf general purpose retrievers provides surprisingly
large LM gains across model sizes and diverse corpora. We also demonstrate that
the document retrieval and ranking mechanism can be specialized to the RALM
setting to further boost performance. We conclude that In-Context RALM has
considerable potential to increase the prevalence of LM grounding, particularly
in settings where a pretrained LM must be used without modification or even via
API access. | [
0.0640586391,
0.033508867,
0.0121548241,
0.0109491916,
-0.026594881,
-0.0138649233,
0.0063163769,
-0.0045889686,
0.012152845,
-0.0792445242,
-0.0286415648,
0.001957386,
-0.0030273378,
-0.0024473174,
0.0169534534,
0.0241823066,
0.0190969817,
0.025186196,
-0.0124775749,
0.0222339388,
0.0081981188,
0.0448115766,
0.0608929843,
0.0275245365,
0.0154241361,
0.023303289,
0.004709356,
0.0381617248,
0.0023811099,
-0.0268362835,
0.03152401,
0.0112267463,
0.0404234231,
0.027622303,
0.0000021655,
-0.0320120268,
-0.0584862046,
0.0267376732,
0.0073885531,
0.0028419606,
0.0471380353,
0.0020661142,
0.0182425696,
0.041581165,
-0.0603887066,
0.0004798938,
0.0118527459,
0.0152450986,
0.043698784,
0.088899605,
-0.0166826732,
-0.0134351673,
0.0045873616,
-0.0305185001,
-0.0047136066,
-0.0084869377,
0.0094114346,
-0.004818934,
0.0390589237,
0.0682006851,
0.0258432068,
0.037393216,
0.008172282,
0.010219194,
0.0510429069,
0.0099480096,
-0.0626232028,
0.0075296713,
0.0181270912,
0.0398641303,
0.0267976597,
-0.0822410882,
0.0259025581,
0.0040894765,
-0.012128979,
0.0176370032,
-0.0285900813,
0.047879681,
-0.0180202257,
0.0073362109,
0.0340476669,
-0.0154196629,
0.0483112596,
0.0477436818,
-0.0102078822,
0.0722402036,
0.0327996649,
-0.0350791961,
-0.0219401307,
0.0091038244,
-0.0072180708,
-0.0203228276,
0.0264179725,
0.0121251121,
-0.005888443,
0.0369020887,
-0.0407706834,
-0.0311172642,
0.0350496881,
-0.0350182392,
0.0170393344,
0.0433956124,
-0.0330486894,
0.029187955,
-0.0415953547,
0.0187943447,
0.0037764641,
-0.0252860226,
-0.0434025936,
-0.0166347455,
-0.0166325364,
-0.022384325,
-0.0556578524,
0.0131999506,
-0.0571004599,
-0.023755841,
-0.0305440966,
0.0444288068,
0.0016556265,
-0.0344485156,
-0.0153593663,
0.018368246,
-0.0766874105,
-0.001520247,
0.0031341964,
0.0015435043,
0.0182654411,
0.0071262261,
0.0249581914,
-0.0691075623,
0.0027221839,
0.0063164919,
0.0211913045,
-0.0196957141,
0.0195278432,
0.0058093057,
0.0104063097,
-0.0614321306,
-0.0531842448,
-0.0403202698,
0.0087392526,
-0.0362951756,
-0.0150889885,
-0.0886791199,
-0.007077869,
0.0418868847,
-0.0106401592,
-0.0395198502,
0.0126985852,
0.0628702193,
-0.0258225091,
0.014018897,
-0.0208474025,
0.0079263402,
0.0547182895,
0.0023663547,
-0.0024808249,
0.0583515018,
0.0033893923,
0.0206579268,
0.0502268635,
0.0356824249,
0.0053990209,
0.0161438212,
0.0379271917,
0.0381903611,
-0.0279258508,
0.001349566,
-0.0205432028,
-0.0172048174,
0.0129760224,
0.0217824094,
-0.0232296046,
0.0310837254,
0.0489608757,
0.0252161827,
0.0220140629,
-0.0101930192,
0.0421142019,
0.0215002913,
-0.0240109582,
-0.0196646694,
-0.0249239877,
0.0138556259,
-0.073634401,
0.0193359386,
0.0333845653,
0.0576851964,
-0.015807068,
-0.0298287012,
-0.0085741067,
-0.0120719122,
-0.0029843627,
0.0233823918,
0.0409729555,
0.0125241298,
-0.0430178829,
0.0438695401,
0.0413996279,
-0.0724633262,
0.0246589333,
-0.0408714265,
-0.0099571878,
0.0410479605,
0.1019026041,
-0.0051352968,
0.0034929153,
0.0045615928,
0.0284383073,
0.0431379639,
0.0050523486,
-0.0083986204,
0.0001630584,
-0.0468061604,
-0.0350390263,
-0.0164592415,
0.022311924,
0.0323270075,
0.0467203259,
0.0262301229,
0.0787540898,
-0.0566655137,
-0.0392090417,
0.030563822,
-0.0520932414,
-0.0349203795,
0.0277272332,
0.001067557,
-0.0058915205,
0.021218054,
-0.0204463918,
0.0058049946,
0.0420829132,
-0.019183008,
-0.0250333641,
0.0098922029,
-0.0406694598,
0.0131900357,
0.0202478096,
0.0097413696,
0.0583357066,
0.0202838928,
-0.0222880691,
-0.0429364406,
0.0053109261,
-0.0078800898,
0.0706399083,
-0.0706551969,
0.0153900245,
0.0007157919,
-0.0020427138,
-0.0637712777,
0.0507666431,
0.0202825703,
0.035568811,
0.0283048227,
0.0324044339,
0.0146236904,
-0.0282659959,
-0.0357222334,
-0.0114273764,
-0.0057227393,
0.0351584814,
0.0749317557,
0.0092343595,
-0.0101476535,
0.0020573931,
-0.0984439999,
0.0069656549,
-0.0478727892,
-0.0334211774,
0.0297549311,
0.058876019,
-0.0087017985,
-0.0223521609,
-0.0224914514,
-0.0387910306,
0.0513495095,
0.0393902361,
-0.0019904845,
0.0159020592,
0.0151779931,
-0.0411869772,
-0.0055658086,
0.0398429148,
0.0334048122,
0.0205647629,
0.0031857572,
-0.0626803786,
0.0346566401,
-0.0588895604,
0.0207376983,
-0.031855721,
0.0033538176,
-0.0140030524,
-0.0432206206,
0.0079719368,
0.0188568085,
0.0062037385,
-0.0096468562,
0.052347783,
0.0167328212,
-0.0839426294,
-0.0092812236,
-0.0106215412,
-0.0255656354,
0.0352749527,
-0.0175578482,
0.0130037284,
0.0072683441,
-0.0091411518,
-0.0241029244,
-0.0104369698,
0.0081297262,
-0.0253239479,
-0.021408448,
-0.0575049892,
-0.0344668254,
0.0088121975,
0.0488538034,
-0.0205202512,
-0.0886817276,
0.0678657293,
-0.0501051173,
-0.0036136771,
-0.0912891701,
-0.0277425125,
-0.0429991968,
0.0106844986,
0.0157773197,
0.0180537831,
-0.007813585,
0.0118221985,
-0.0236648638,
0.0163006857,
0.0224893559,
-0.0466684327,
0.0652981997,
-0.0326031037,
0.0597294644,
-0.0013665359,
-0.0381519943,
-0.0682834238,
-0.0428338535,
0.0195340589,
-0.0072260955,
-0.0169069748,
-0.008480846,
-0.0291373283,
-0.0025771481,
0.066007711,
0.0642164797,
-0.0288224835,
-0.032336466,
-0.0062846234,
0.0100823315,
0.0501623973,
-0.0336796194,
-0.0050677252,
-0.0023005386,
-0.0309261773,
0.0233367234,
0.0815065801,
-0.0393153913,
-0.0168486983,
-0.0101460516,
0.041228842,
-0.0095677208,
-0.0296047889,
0.0345149972,
0.012450912,
-0.050904382,
-0.0530251637,
0.0915699899,
0.0553572662,
-0.066772677,
-0.0350829959,
-0.0222604629,
0.0234731659,
0.0355314091,
0.0570351444,
-0.0658771098,
0.003241135,
0.0285657495,
0.0719945207,
0.007935063,
0.0187832657,
-0.030812487,
-0.1342559755,
0.0477898568,
0.0162593964,
-0.0274976082,
-0.0295246802,
-0.0647627935,
-0.0177051648,
0.0190032832,
-0.0093451552,
0.0336036384,
-0.0105712917,
0.0158371311,
0.0029388722,
0.0160755273,
-0.0563381463,
-0.0262704063,
-0.0377496481,
-0.0015884901,
0.0758747458,
0.007503829,
0.0210591573,
-0.0116067054,
0.0093881572,
-0.0229922608,
0.010631036,
-0.0362205058,
0.0165107641,
-0.0246829577,
0.0165561456,
-0.008868604,
0.0079307193,
-0.0107326955,
-0.0040140897,
-0.0115563879,
0.0434838869,
-0.0136026731,
0.0507037602,
-0.0339196101,
-0.0152047453,
0.0473424792,
0.0800098851,
0.008242812,
-0.0283568706,
0.0029105232,
-0.0207511373,
0.0341381952,
-0.007000172,
0.0063395323,
0.0146485437,
-0.0268173106,
-0.021019537,
-0.0937735066,
-0.0547777712,
-0.0345518589,
0.0332945287,
0.0222737286,
0.0346795171,
-0.0244716499,
-0.0265591647,
-0.0596957766,
0.0423133448,
-0.0317768231,
-0.0033596531,
-0.0206077881,
-0.0040191528,
0.0671831891,
-0.0703623369,
-0.0039094221,
0.0118101537,
0.0059091765,
-0.0610855632,
0.0020580394,
0.023135487,
0.0226979349,
0.0745888948,
-0.0159908738,
-0.0375837386,
0.0694491789,
0.0483005606,
-0.0510836728,
0.0394185819,
0.0007275332,
-0.0130808959,
-0.0200310051,
0.0295938123,
-0.1040238217,
0.0268450938,
-0.0138988029,
0.0426547192,
0.0182354879,
-0.0243387185,
0.0399350822,
0.0103906365,
0.0317168012,
-0.0260419268,
0.0113571109,
-0.0517900027,
0.0192344189,
-0.0472090431,
-0.0422451645,
-0.0452779084,
0.033084631,
0.0015067555,
0.0130839823,
-0.0054474836,
0.0424176268,
-0.0002246743,
0.1019163132,
-0.0260623638,
-0.0044816481,
-0.0304211937,
0.0184672605,
0.0095646502,
0.0156227415,
-0.0292709451,
0.0047189891,
-0.0209147744,
0.0405211784,
-0.066010721,
0.0531055406,
0.0191778243,
-0.0168610439,
-0.010969473,
0.0266126376,
-0.0915920362,
0.0027914532,
-0.0366771221,
0.009584167,
0.0667694509,
-0.0410224237,
0.1035486534,
-0.0375236832,
-0.0117096184,
-0.0361238867,
0.0109069552,
0.0460191555,
-0.0610377863,
-0.0209563188,
0.0063106306,
-0.0462944843,
0.057313893,
0.0523266196,
0.0238847695,
0.0246148184,
-0.0281264968,
-0.02494484,
-0.0179362204,
-0.0184979495,
0.0051987292,
0.0364708975,
-0.027169602,
-0.0155468881,
-0.0406454653,
-0.0730742216,
-0.0013977259,
-0.0012773869,
-0.0286822338,
-0.047059726,
0.0202741157,
0.1172029376,
0.0084626684,
0.0099863783,
-0.0608345084,
0.0138671286,
-0.0661719665,
-0.0308063552,
-0.0298241638,
-6.975193195e-33,
-0.0399873666,
-0.027586408,
0.0237844754,
-0.03825441,
0.0243571531,
0.0360066444,
-0.0384705476,
-0.0243659783,
-0.002921327,
-0.0316844471,
-0.0345839113,
0.0233719014,
0.0042291586,
0.0511587225,
-0.0174490269,
0.0453294292,
0.0303362012,
0.0068864617,
-0.0334450006,
0.0321158879,
0.0660285577,
0.0363078825,
0.0206749067,
-0.0649301335,
0.0147757893,
-0.0392272621,
0.0046193274,
-0.0235026181,
-0.0033368499,
0.0377270617,
0.0044280677,
0.0268593878,
0.0221309625,
-0.0194554236,
-0.0113957431,
0.0107657984,
-0.0659510717,
0.0073324363,
0.001035765,
-0.0223781131,
0.0048627085,
-0.0037691791,
0.0510040112,
-0.0197614022,
-0.0011002547,
0.0243067909,
0.0511454567,
-0.0195006263,
-0.0468818434,
-0.059591759,
-0.0431212895,
0.0313779823,
0.0380479135,
0.0083227763,
-0.0067758937,
0.0618400835,
0.0075125699,
0.052560471,
-0.0754144564,
0.0055703023,
-0.0376893394,
0.0330281109,
0.0633958206,
0.0219815671,
0.0005455802,
0.0365577303,
-0.0268874504,
-0.0117609473,
0.0126866708,
-0.054664202,
0.0339938104,
0.0079625603,
0.0074603674,
0.0498884842,
0.0266099516,
-0.0139884586,
-0.0821617469,
0.0541760102,
-0.006057885,
-0.01040354,
0.0446879864,
0.0109458631,
-0.0609426163,
-0.0345272049,
-0.0140364841,
-0.0056575923,
-0.055872526,
-0.0406394079,
0.054081589,
0.0530573167,
-0.0317140147,
-0.0025841871,
0.0320290141,
-0.0290961172,
-0.0211257506,
0.0755522773,
-0.0445792601,
-0.0210749488,
-0.0150306998,
0.0424317867,
-0.0456406027,
-0.0068955002,
0.014698864,
0.0120726041,
-0.0451390855,
0.0051423539,
0.0195862669,
0.0220572036,
-0.0583266616,
0.0340967104,
-0.0273790378,
0.0467103533,
-0.0134743005,
0.0099953925,
0.0306063779,
0.0179850534,
0.002580771,
0.0530393757,
0.0372256599,
0.0133123752,
-0.0345178843,
-0.0717475042,
-0.0019902594,
0.010104822,
-0.0273636188,
0.0295815151,
-0.0033900349,
0.0488708094,
0.0499100238,
-0.0297368616,
-0.0100373253,
-0.0201151744,
3.043e-7,
0.0271511115,
0.0207167212,
0.0139228636,
-0.0160153359,
-0.0090517337,
0.0170703251,
-0.0050811097,
0.0538996905,
0.0464730561,
-0.0078097763,
-0.0069584753,
0.012462046,
0.0476761349,
0.0145219341,
-0.0667289421,
0.0159457996,
-0.0837712362,
-0.0002924293,
-0.0444468707,
-0.0217093974,
-0.0080395406,
0.0644851327,
-0.003257252,
-0.0184707213,
-0.033382006,
-0.0663907602,
0.0793363973,
0.0001599357,
-0.0318254083,
-0.0111478623,
0.0417419747,
0.0626453459,
-0.0259933434,
-0.0466013961,
-0.051282756,
0.0515648462,
-0.0032803912,
0.0373422056,
-0.0035497085,
-0.0388038941,
0.0014285037,
0.0023351233,
-0.002699066,
-0.0453540534,
0.0599633716,
-0.005034795,
0.0181478206,
-0.029327983,
-0.0402083881,
0.000686636,
-0.0308834929,
-0.012928036,
-0.0464495011,
0.0349715054,
-0.0146071902,
-0.0078741806,
-0.0304754023,
-0.0925403386,
-0.0502217114,
-0.0031876464,
-0.0130925672,
-0.0377123877,
-0.0448324047,
0.0107941898,
-0.0095542949,
-0.0405551307,
0.0411620066,
3.175084858e-34,
0.0264252163,
-0.0053157336,
-0.0012035388,
-0.0030883306,
0.028512435,
0.0033233119,
-0.0193884484,
0.0232223682,
-0.0046089976,
-0.0654560551,
-0.0100455973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13868v1 | PADL: Language-Directed Physics-Based Character Control | 2023-01-31T18:59:22 | 2023-01-31T18:59:22 | Jordan Juravsky, Yunrong Guo, Sanja Fidler, Xue Bin Peng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR | Developing systems that can synthesize natural and life-like motions for
simulated characters has long been a focus for computer animation. But in order
for these systems to be useful for downstream applications, they need not only
produce high-quality motions, but must also provide an accessible and versatile
interface through which users can direct a character's behaviors. Natural
language provides a simple-to-use and expressive medium for specifying a user's
intent. Recent breakthroughs in natural language processing (NLP) have
demonstrated effective use of language-based interfaces for applications such
as image generation and program synthesis. In this work, we present PADL, which
leverages recent innovations in NLP in order to take steps towards developing
language-directed controllers for physics-based character animation. PADL
allows users to issue natural language commands for specifying both high-level
tasks and low-level skills that a character should perform. We present an
adversarial imitation learning approach for training policies to map high-level
language commands to low-level controls that enable a character to perform the
desired task and skill specified by a user's commands. Furthermore, we propose
a multi-task aggregation method that leverages a language-based multiple-choice
question-answering approach to determine high-level task objectives from
language commands. We show that our framework can be applied to effectively
direct a simulated humanoid character to perform a diverse array of complex
motor skills. | [
0.0319596715,
0.0737066641,
0.0089717573,
0.0025467579,
-0.0023899064,
-0.0059846914,
0.0266826767,
-0.0015632632,
0.0073482017,
0.0169974659,
-0.0190619528,
-0.0388157889,
-0.0037429081,
0.0302710515,
0.0658643171,
-0.0953803882,
0.0182653498,
-0.0396705866,
0.0023258047,
0.0007092672,
0.0165976305,
0.0329239443,
-0.0386132449,
0.0402968116,
-0.0111880349,
0.0178963859,
-0.0460216664,
-0.0113354493,
0.0455607735,
-0.0262214784,
0.0154359723,
-0.0008278417,
0.0583249405,
0.0133362673,
0.0000020848,
-0.0490291752,
0.0155986147,
-0.0025685283,
0.0063294619,
-0.0151055325,
0.0592172965,
0.0165101718,
-0.0182627738,
0.0298473649,
-0.027139917,
-0.0022746255,
0.0732423738,
0.0219810698,
0.1065220833,
0.0501696579,
-0.0013443116,
-0.0350153744,
-0.0230791625,
0.0038844079,
0.0378912911,
-0.0443462729,
-0.0038416679,
0.0227468368,
0.0867346898,
-0.0048618172,
-0.0267546978,
-0.0035121632,
0.0460059121,
-0.0229689386,
-0.0121723479,
0.0512475446,
0.0407672785,
-0.021508811,
-0.0038644639,
0.0502323546,
-0.0616181642,
-0.0055939797,
0.006166643,
0.0012947284,
0.0406461544,
0.0600426421,
-0.0284770615,
0.020369662,
-0.0098008579,
-0.0150941703,
-0.0409853868,
-0.0093187736,
-0.0159330126,
-0.0244640056,
-0.0290514454,
0.030476423,
0.0298020691,
-0.0066185575,
0.0160452798,
-0.0140068168,
0.0168015845,
-0.0703090504,
0.0331935473,
0.0294059981,
-0.0300737787,
0.0006861835,
-0.0803782716,
-0.0185124613,
-0.0194949638,
-0.0131280776,
0.0832229629,
0.0291716065,
0.0159888417,
0.0217555203,
-0.0208810549,
0.0684649497,
-0.0212002676,
0.0170850195,
-0.0192155428,
0.0271300972,
-0.0329863243,
-0.0245392229,
-0.0429871231,
0.0060209739,
-0.079538025,
0.0097321384,
-0.0202253591,
0.027542159,
-0.0336504243,
-0.0049313884,
-0.0298264101,
0.0729125366,
-0.028447289,
0.0103131542,
-0.0619252436,
-0.0198957324,
-0.0422993191,
0.0586624891,
0.0076151579,
0.0002429663,
-0.0411643386,
0.0249308813,
0.0096938396,
0.0043004369,
0.0395153128,
0.1131372079,
-0.0455878712,
0.0322069675,
0.0410032608,
-0.0137064373,
-0.003169561,
-0.0422163941,
0.0288209673,
-0.0432835221,
0.0270492807,
-0.0335879214,
-0.0059225331,
-0.0574490204,
0.0006403397,
0.0360996984,
0.0029897741,
0.0581113435,
0.0446109585,
0.008967801,
0.0320042521,
-0.0195692871,
-0.0279303063,
0.0163463987,
0.040553432,
0.0259042662,
-0.0480455384,
0.0036015604,
0.0293155126,
0.0414946079,
0.0066019017,
0.0041564619,
-0.0079762749,
-0.0466006882,
0.0165345017,
0.0565480813,
0.0359353274,
0.0320435464,
-0.042379614,
0.0287367515,
0.0158524774,
0.0284747873,
-0.0298712142,
0.0233284924,
0.0651251748,
0.0148799624,
0.0063034329,
-0.0328079984,
-0.0215590857,
0.0794129372,
0.0178399943,
-0.012762201,
-0.0233543012,
0.0124507919,
-0.0341881849,
-0.0372111797,
0.0352486148,
0.0031302245,
0.0473709777,
0.0257461835,
0.0370078348,
0.0695544705,
-0.0516460426,
-0.0477999412,
-0.0168983638,
-0.081192553,
0.020220045,
-0.0220288299,
-0.0231856108,
0.0370865948,
-0.0143815558,
-0.0238324516,
-0.0152763212,
-0.0023777857,
0.0303816795,
0.073604539,
-0.0256374013,
-0.0187962595,
0.0355893672,
0.0104608415,
0.0091335569,
-0.0154235214,
0.0015026754,
0.0569963418,
-0.0258485526,
-0.0105604194,
-0.0338630266,
0.0300105717,
-0.0380150452,
0.055925101,
-0.0666382089,
0.00459141,
0.017145915,
0.0085257133,
0.0355349332,
-0.0029555953,
-0.0302462876,
-0.0048776218,
0.0170737263,
-0.0451100282,
-0.0295420457,
0.0118219275,
0.0013734088,
-0.0054924907,
0.0460010506,
-0.0719058588,
-0.0430504009,
0.0335081182,
0.0036655623,
-0.0318097807,
0.0323926844,
-0.0423072129,
-0.0049147089,
0.0130708236,
-0.0294029806,
0.0405997969,
-0.0290123485,
-0.0419216715,
0.0206247941,
-0.0055714799,
-0.0028865372,
0.0378722325,
0.0213535931,
-0.010312451,
-0.0341909453,
-0.0290200487,
0.0540824383,
-0.0108089279,
0.015800273,
0.0526867695,
0.0500612631,
-0.0144084645,
-0.0086512025,
-0.0299127474,
-0.024486756,
0.0062613278,
-0.0305407345,
0.0051703937,
-0.0084104734,
-0.0247641597,
-0.0128231207,
-0.0434067808,
-0.0077539305,
0.0074383751,
-0.0528779961,
0.0520119332,
0.0201596562,
-0.0154561969,
-0.0451223776,
0.0127691422,
-0.0239215512,
0.0081303343,
0.0378128663,
0.0399668291,
-0.0184085816,
0.011285644,
-0.0366316028,
0.0537143238,
-0.0181384496,
-0.059566807,
0.0542953983,
-0.0383775979,
-0.006929771,
0.0717448592,
-0.0415671691,
0.0130933346,
0.0707336292,
-0.0163514297,
-0.0521490909,
0.0555453897,
0.0133889746,
0.0101528717,
0.0003653194,
0.0138401771,
0.0738660023,
0.0609888621,
0.0419032462,
0.0054283002,
-0.0817864537,
0.0215760097,
-0.0136215128,
-0.0615294538,
-0.0154876979,
0.0151134068,
-0.047044266,
-0.0175565518,
-0.0309587177,
-0.0143859377,
0.0706583858,
-0.0047571124,
-0.0660950169,
0.0122015234,
0.0208751839,
0.0287413076,
0.0707420111,
0.0336866826,
0.0306629334,
-0.0112358509,
0.0038769718,
-0.0345896147,
0.0383906066,
0.0294866152,
-0.0152207408,
0.016769927,
-0.0902661905,
0.0030500242,
-0.0084300376,
-0.0096266782,
-0.0380797535,
0.0021104121,
-0.0033430355,
-0.0002855197,
-0.0103568258,
-0.0834658667,
-0.04101317,
-0.051095143,
0.0106881717,
0.0300548524,
-0.0302809719,
-0.004322838,
-0.0387679636,
-0.0299824532,
0.0732877851,
0.0581053086,
-0.0740544945,
-0.0192904957,
0.0163674243,
0.0291264895,
0.0235202443,
-0.017199209,
-0.0372753218,
0.0122576663,
0.0254098624,
-0.0146658616,
0.0459547862,
0.0414250083,
0.0656820983,
-0.0154335909,
-0.0106721949,
0.0790853873,
0.0296169706,
0.0555871166,
0.0017539209,
0.0195676107,
0.0579350367,
0.012194301,
0.0252764653,
-0.0496069156,
-0.0296941418,
-0.0253709741,
0.0389440171,
0.023859648,
-0.0233577378,
-0.0209693406,
-0.113781929,
0.0081629232,
0.0095280334,
-0.0971279442,
-0.0787555277,
-0.0104625355,
0.016935451,
-0.0238993932,
-0.0099337753,
-0.0155058978,
0.0495477915,
0.0105287069,
0.0055230199,
-0.0193216391,
-0.0494793691,
0.0055153915,
-0.0275083017,
0.0537167862,
0.0624190569,
0.0728740618,
-0.0511378124,
-0.0098672835,
-0.0104117468,
0.0242678467,
-0.0000978678,
-0.0065014139,
-0.0088126492,
0.000486795,
-0.0252965353,
-0.0175566804,
0.0839394107,
-0.028734237,
-0.0360806994,
-0.0047762184,
0.0461313426,
-0.0295974445,
-0.0197692476,
-0.0495301038,
-0.0077369981,
0.0347817987,
0.0592029914,
-0.0131161036,
-0.0838704556,
-0.0247485731,
-0.0604849122,
-0.0474504493,
-0.0517475791,
-0.0706822798,
-0.0210695323,
-0.0033795731,
-0.0056228475,
-0.0882742703,
-0.0134049561,
0.0994149595,
0.0487440415,
-0.0153803369,
-0.0483513474,
0.0045802277,
0.0213790927,
-0.0335493907,
-0.0223572534,
-0.0156481601,
0.023702547,
0.0101407599,
-0.0637554228,
0.0139992414,
-0.0216778312,
-0.0141141666,
0.0367632024,
-0.011555749,
-0.0795837492,
-0.0054518357,
0.0573011152,
0.0152439317,
0.0152915027,
-0.0349036492,
-0.0334767252,
0.0296780635,
0.0432717502,
-0.0233045202,
0.0153076677,
0.0138055757,
-0.0161151439,
0.0100038378,
0.0011392991,
-0.0420251526,
0.0130478032,
-0.0316387303,
-0.011109611,
-0.0257385653,
-0.0423429124,
0.0482034683,
0.0127537539,
0.0054568443,
-0.0402967148,
0.0000696457,
-0.0401861928,
-0.0458207615,
-0.0131453415,
-0.008593387,
-0.0702551231,
-0.0117283287,
0.0429639556,
0.0130544631,
0.0344642028,
-0.0055294191,
0.0225078557,
-0.0060531287,
-0.0125237741,
0.0133864405,
0.032139644,
0.0932516456,
-0.0106676966,
0.0280398298,
0.0320834592,
-0.0052277562,
-0.0619893968,
0.053955134,
0.011612704,
0.034276437,
0.010791122,
-0.0003236775,
0.0120235486,
0.0307633672,
-0.0541416965,
-0.0547128804,
-0.0112138074,
0.0046026916,
0.0523728952,
-0.0064069722,
0.0493986756,
-0.0604223944,
0.0142801655,
0.0088771349,
0.0104788393,
0.0058193114,
-0.0338635519,
0.0330849104,
0.0075577106,
0.0126464842,
-0.0480409265,
0.0325082913,
0.0114878071,
0.0494102724,
-0.0120558608,
0.0171986725,
-0.0644488633,
-0.0510520898,
0.0069926567,
0.0030325805,
0.0016547373,
-0.0098333238,
-0.0265405588,
-0.0536854416,
-0.025888117,
0.0557799414,
-0.0171117969,
-0.0213962011,
0.0869639069,
-0.0046771732,
-0.0297310799,
0.0225529112,
0.001671508,
-0.005068073,
-0.002203783,
-0.0550638996,
-0.0401031487,
-5.265090993e-33,
-0.0391085111,
-0.0157882217,
0.0190502852,
-0.0357909985,
-0.0240201652,
-0.0254740808,
-0.0597297177,
-0.0038424407,
0.0023729675,
0.014412865,
0.0186167825,
-0.0250224676,
-0.0241449103,
0.0226386357,
0.0231685005,
-0.0150093613,
0.0364042334,
-0.0001598468,
-0.0315608382,
0.0261161458,
0.0292626712,
-0.0112494742,
0.0193018839,
-0.0348566398,
0.0244579557,
0.0036144299,
-0.0633127168,
-0.0057844394,
-0.0100493804,
0.0242137481,
-0.014849917,
-0.0019913237,
-0.0105582606,
-0.0101176221,
-0.02798976,
0.0385987423,
-0.0531107821,
-0.0690518841,
-0.0308805183,
0.0033990992,
-0.0931552276,
-0.0073111681,
0.0141719729,
-0.0060763345,
-0.0136893336,
-0.0013305115,
0.0477152653,
0.0027202943,
0.0551427864,
0.0023047021,
-0.0507036224,
-0.0165269747,
-0.0432942919,
-0.0718511641,
-0.0307867546,
0.063369751,
-0.0035686151,
-0.0505214594,
0.0023262354,
0.0130120292,
-0.0302373935,
-0.0122002512,
0.020417925,
0.0408015996,
0.0333107784,
0.0714315474,
-0.0218588095,
-0.035424158,
-0.0159499198,
0.0376484133,
0.0456664078,
0.0474689566,
0.0617623627,
0.0691161975,
0.0541116185,
-0.0024609952,
-0.0162907634,
0.077410318,
0.0092084324,
0.0798706636,
-0.0349750444,
0.0460509881,
-0.0278631095,
0.0010981705,
-0.018127976,
-0.0034928136,
0.0266327728,
-0.0353580639,
0.0373262241,
0.0015108924,
-0.0094726337,
-0.0724662691,
0.0349383913,
-0.0130700991,
0.0048402073,
0.0122253988,
-0.0320678949,
0.0271106455,
0.0091417264,
0.0022056962,
-0.0292933695,
-0.0214473326,
0.0443397164,
-0.0087563032,
0.016700061,
0.0409217142,
-0.0337184034,
0.0779146925,
-0.033865992,
-0.010129475,
-0.0258170385,
0.0147806266,
0.0490574986,
0.0291353744,
0.0451340303,
-0.0132139307,
-0.034707617,
0.01331448,
-0.0315766856,
-0.0724738687,
-0.050887309,
0.035311088,
-0.0291908924,
-0.0290874615,
-0.0611513034,
-0.0231003016,
-0.0227492601,
0.0132111926,
-0.003741083,
-0.1108377054,
-0.0190712512,
0.0125029106,
2.779e-7,
-0.0167456549,
0.0185653809,
0.0322345197,
0.0534397289,
0.010379184,
0.0252878461,
-0.0231767129,
0.0645485595,
-0.008675456,
-0.0331442058,
-0.0043947534,
0.0365897156,
0.0080265244,
-0.016422743,
-0.0888901949,
0.0054796501,
0.0110662747,
0.0055259429,
-0.0243156645,
-0.002939594,
0.0481190868,
0.0694620609,
0.0227812659,
-0.000178281,
0.0417446308,
-0.0088956691,
0.0350069255,
-0.0062435218,
0.0245981365,
-0.0338266008,
-0.0139916176,
0.0074574603,
-0.0198876709,
-0.0066661267,
-0.0243004672,
0.0204353146,
0.0364548005,
0.0396951064,
-0.0278875455,
0.0003838535,
-0.0084044049,
0.035940785,
-0.0023823353,
-0.0144767361,
0.0619650334,
-0.0437382273,
0.0114396792,
-0.0401486345,
0.0286777709,
0.0202875361,
-0.0053638793,
-0.0223180074,
-0.0396858864,
0.0065445416,
0.0089967437,
-0.0057567614,
0.0120517602,
-0.0354960598,
-0.0119017549,
0.0162180644,
-0.0622973889,
-0.0003359837,
-0.0384259559,
0.0042898576,
-0.007954157,
-0.0100842025,
-0.0117935138,
2.191828374e-34,
-0.0459888242,
0.0064870319,
0.021960821,
-0.014314617,
0.0464335494,
0.0298403185,
0.0133141903,
0.0728440955,
0.0641601756,
-0.0467227846,
-0.0437036604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13867v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13867v2 | Mathematical Capabilities of ChatGPT | 2023-01-31T18:59:03 | 2023-07-20T17:59:14 | Simon Frieder, Luca Pinchetti, Alexis Chevalier, Ryan-Rhys Griffiths, Tommaso Salvatori, Thomas Lukasiewicz, Philipp Christian Petersen, Julius Berner | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We investigate the mathematical capabilities of two iterations of ChatGPT
(released 9-January-2023 and 30-January-2023) and of GPT-4 by testing them on
publicly available datasets, as well as hand-crafted ones, using a novel
methodology. In contrast to formal mathematics, where large databases of formal
proofs are available (e.g., the Lean Mathematical Library), current datasets of
natural-language mathematics, used to benchmark language models, either cover
only elementary mathematics or are very small. We address this by publicly
releasing two new datasets: GHOSTS and miniGHOSTS. These are the first
natural-language datasets curated by working researchers in mathematics that
(1) aim to cover graduate-level mathematics, (2) provide a holistic overview of
the mathematical capabilities of language models, and (3) distinguish multiple
dimensions of mathematical reasoning. These datasets also test whether ChatGPT
and GPT-4 can be helpful assistants to professional mathematicians by emulating
use cases that arise in the daily professional activities of mathematicians. We
benchmark the models on a range of fine-grained performance metrics. For
advanced mathematics, this is the most detailed evaluation effort to date. We
find that ChatGPT can be used most successfully as a mathematical assistant for
querying facts, acting as a mathematical search engine and knowledge base
interface. GPT-4 can additionally be used for undergraduate-level mathematics
but fails on graduate-level difficulty. Contrary to many positive reports in
the media about GPT-4 and ChatGPT's exam-solving abilities (a potential case of
selection bias), their overall mathematical performance is well below the level
of a graduate student. Hence, if your goal is to use ChatGPT to pass a
graduate-level math exam, you would be better off copying from your average
peer! | [
-0.0482426547,
0.098416619,
-0.0163890012,
0.0467281081,
-0.0863520056,
0.0066557168,
-0.0207489599,
0.0148641681,
-0.0138087031,
-0.0254495535,
0.0046570222,
-0.0132401036,
-0.0120600518,
0.0351788364,
0.0314369909,
-0.0534994826,
0.0190235227,
-0.0218221694,
0.0278421566,
-0.0116723189,
-0.016005028,
-0.0151400631,
-0.0472675338,
0.0194620322,
-0.0357415192,
-0.060770683,
0.0151738636,
-0.0618222915,
-0.0228202865,
-0.0313408785,
-0.0151663832,
0.033211492,
-0.0131538985,
0.0761253387,
0.0000021956,
-0.0356732756,
-0.0150153674,
0.0390554518,
-0.0499173142,
0.008464667,
0.0017629232,
0.0262553468,
0.0175015554,
0.0158116631,
-0.086114049,
0.0117566567,
0.0349939018,
-0.0172891263,
0.0609619729,
0.0693930462,
-0.0135573102,
-0.0640232787,
0.0525598675,
-0.0102927666,
0.0643809363,
-0.053059455,
-0.0024742689,
0.0016043917,
0.043749202,
0.0258064456,
-0.0146361943,
0.0446446389,
0.0454533473,
-0.0035497728,
-0.009176814,
0.0129540525,
-0.0963102579,
0.0255661048,
0.0169033054,
0.0171633027,
0.0067189708,
-0.0403753668,
0.0039428733,
0.0236147251,
-0.0182215646,
0.0434350595,
-0.0685052872,
0.0027206566,
-0.0436607301,
-0.0121022286,
-0.0225568116,
-0.0037969961,
0.0194490198,
0.0181130059,
0.0164109189,
0.0792440176,
0.0446438678,
-0.0367186219,
-0.0102490112,
-0.0017558493,
-0.0833875388,
-0.0285379402,
0.0328112505,
0.0160222109,
0.0330557153,
-0.0033295418,
-0.0024454754,
-0.0295278486,
-0.0257949475,
-0.010813849,
-0.0169534646,
0.0801076442,
0.0137756756,
0.0285398643,
0.0149346897,
0.0444967821,
0.0196255539,
0.0523594134,
-0.0143966433,
0.0296431594,
-0.0473906919,
-0.0095317159,
-0.0507028364,
0.0480890609,
0.0298268516,
0.039981775,
-0.057227008,
-0.0004856719,
-0.0494938157,
0.0196933877,
-0.0142797204,
-0.0498000868,
-0.0073878379,
-0.0136619685,
-0.0405253917,
-0.0483625159,
-0.0336581357,
-0.0197118651,
-0.007082935,
-0.0514402241,
-0.0179181024,
0.0094520776,
-0.0139972931,
-0.0319024846,
0.0130035589,
0.0745134503,
0.0470942333,
0.0025408429,
0.0321155265,
0.0050062644,
0.0378158614,
-0.0545666888,
0.0012918805,
-0.079174459,
0.0734737441,
0.016838938,
-0.0298080835,
-0.0020192845,
-0.0178735834,
0.022668086,
0.0436532199,
0.0561600924,
-0.0113263438,
-0.0121891685,
0.0245398991,
0.0022187657,
-0.0365880691,
0.0104599493,
0.0093602538,
-0.0191802327,
0.0419353135,
-0.0274139363,
0.0243373569,
0.0265741404,
0.030811768,
-0.0184966084,
0.0423801653,
0.0425294042,
0.0312556736,
0.0474265665,
-0.0860334337,
0.0707813352,
-0.0462018326,
-0.0396469831,
0.0063554957,
0.0871288031,
-0.0025517491,
0.0306480527,
-0.0028267945,
0.0347985998,
0.0753277987,
-0.0009612626,
-0.0629955605,
0.0113905156,
-0.0525130741,
0.0190658849,
0.0140566975,
-0.0168475639,
0.0078071402,
-0.0772051066,
-0.0137178181,
0.0166892577,
-0.0286885332,
-0.0149786752,
0.0613060743,
-0.0418802835,
0.0252786502,
0.032493405,
-0.0023898762,
-0.0309241042,
-0.0134585304,
-0.0457068011,
0.0101118479,
-0.0484603196,
0.0662062988,
-0.0738211796,
-0.0253288355,
-0.0183485113,
0.0272324272,
0.0459925979,
0.0228720102,
0.0127656627,
-0.0319517739,
-0.0073634908,
0.0280930363,
-0.0082364688,
0.029529037,
-0.0256583486,
0.042951636,
0.023921242,
0.0040997416,
-0.0386350974,
0.0115300231,
0.0061304923,
-0.0177523103,
-0.0306326058,
-0.0016669641,
-0.0174765494,
0.0037651062,
0.0088783801,
0.0085375067,
0.0448948592,
0.0082065463,
-0.0082541257,
-0.0011406326,
-0.0077996771,
-0.0192560535,
-0.0203815252,
0.0597474538,
-0.087522611,
-0.0012313838,
0.0230922271,
-0.0481871851,
-0.0134700257,
0.0518545508,
-0.0457028858,
0.0360026956,
-0.0039303484,
-0.0007464994,
-0.0013676508,
-0.027606206,
0.0108476011,
0.0679249614,
0.0535496213,
0.0405812301,
-0.0097383112,
-0.0125178946,
0.0443141796,
-0.0230374765,
-0.0085475426,
-0.0103703542,
-0.0226229522,
0.0350367799,
0.0199537911,
0.0202183612,
-0.0122962557,
0.0189885851,
-0.0137747144,
0.0213682167,
-0.0159584284,
0.0736965388,
0.0223079715,
-0.0516988412,
-0.017029481,
-0.0006719826,
-0.0319742113,
-0.0198566522,
-0.0022749112,
-0.0310589727,
0.0387372039,
0.007650082,
-0.0147771398,
-0.0477665961,
-0.0465164743,
-0.0537262186,
0.0046717669,
0.0265111402,
0.0275580846,
0.0407481305,
0.0287335105,
-0.0377392881,
-0.007020507,
-0.020809466,
0.0190293025,
0.0513034984,
-0.0335651226,
0.0287920367,
0.0138585735,
-0.0001246795,
0.0299737975,
-0.0395421721,
-0.0311780479,
-0.0195584949,
0.0056606755,
-0.0290132686,
-0.0047581326,
-0.0012250212,
0.0002564925,
0.0022356522,
0.0248890556,
-0.0302773416,
-0.0419656374,
-0.0540084243,
0.075928174,
-0.048679892,
0.0509284325,
-0.0576860271,
0.0585784465,
0.0028653324,
0.0166376736,
-0.0200072099,
-0.0404035896,
0.0199499764,
-0.0154519025,
-0.0374808013,
-0.0774749517,
0.0023899802,
-0.0759280175,
0.048970934,
0.0264062583,
-0.0214400608,
-0.0167860631,
0.001818426,
-0.004466868,
0.0026943265,
0.0644454435,
-0.0339978486,
0.0236969441,
-0.0274050981,
0.0315200537,
-0.0229210276,
-0.0387624279,
-0.0004701117,
0.0178381484,
0.0225506648,
0.0080340719,
0.0172681436,
-0.0448809564,
-0.0261408892,
0.0047876653,
0.0089356368,
0.0111308889,
-0.0246254448,
-0.0332352184,
-0.0020407287,
-0.0303572472,
0.0089309383,
0.0168629866,
0.0417558067,
-0.0222283844,
-0.0183709785,
0.0478577279,
0.0466075651,
0.0062503414,
0.0227791313,
0.0135087902,
-0.0200851504,
-0.0700428039,
-0.0617714785,
0.0177059248,
-0.0304500218,
-0.0621541888,
0.0006001599,
0.0844771713,
0.0244253576,
0.0003096411,
-0.0058549843,
-0.0593524799,
0.0054162527,
0.0170609988,
-0.0111320782,
-0.1187567413,
0.0107746366,
-0.0011244629,
0.0091671683,
0.0074993419,
-0.0186094809,
-0.0110344952,
-0.0860662311,
0.0149580939,
0.019629702,
-0.0402272604,
0.0325786769,
-0.0325237811,
0.0045201099,
-0.0260780565,
-0.0236095749,
0.0028434966,
-0.0240768641,
0.0535078868,
0.0210657436,
-0.0667526796,
-0.0337407552,
0.0055304463,
-0.0242763218,
-0.0422116891,
-0.0454682373,
0.0601839423,
-0.0629252493,
-0.0810220242,
0.0083043249,
0.0596413128,
-0.0434688665,
0.0115191331,
0.0123501271,
-0.0244447291,
-0.0025976368,
-0.0445764251,
0.0355925523,
-0.0521971472,
-0.0239242818,
0.050229799,
0.0911449566,
0.0030890089,
0.0021846376,
-0.0314089432,
0.0014689362,
-0.0409364216,
0.0615479127,
-0.0042365738,
0.0396619365,
-0.0443566814,
-0.039630495,
0.0264692586,
-0.0200519767,
-0.0495361686,
-0.0111852325,
0.0621474236,
-0.0149387429,
0.0036625843,
-0.0266914275,
0.0351618342,
0.0199448746,
-0.0052413172,
0.0141890552,
0.0150674153,
0.0100477953,
-0.0212612022,
0.0400902815,
-0.0345445126,
0.0217319205,
-0.0463231094,
0.010914932,
0.0021197433,
0.0103166299,
-0.0575517379,
0.0109744035,
-0.081156455,
-0.0258862879,
-0.0039198669,
0.0296332501,
0.0272422358,
-0.0236453507,
-0.011437472,
0.0275529288,
-0.0187126789,
0.0571519248,
-0.0712053999,
0.0037229466,
0.0521339774,
-0.0132697532,
0.0074693491,
0.0074254447,
0.0233185589,
-0.0118614677,
-0.0348091163,
0.032798782,
0.0137113649,
-0.0049233064,
0.0249882396,
0.0797325,
-0.0000955848,
0.0558997169,
0.0195181146,
0.0299595948,
-0.0018115035,
-0.0418924168,
0.0087189162,
-0.0492962115,
-0.018886324,
0.0085366303,
0.0077328994,
-0.0353070162,
-0.0286800694,
0.0057622744,
0.0516351946,
0.0027863041,
0.0683996975,
-0.0293603428,
0.0201598406,
0.0515894927,
-0.054994788,
0.0313480049,
-0.0230425932,
-0.0427226387,
0.0678644851,
-0.0400601551,
0.0165752862,
0.0411590748,
0.0059153009,
0.0426733904,
0.0047241361,
-0.0334204175,
-0.1052735001,
-0.0017437757,
0.0576620251,
0.0505562425,
0.0326589718,
-0.0034505215,
-0.0696690157,
-0.0009646639,
-0.013297108,
0.0130750053,
0.0181477405,
-0.0235817693,
-0.0007773794,
0.0248656198,
0.0028680179,
-0.0489435904,
0.049796544,
-0.0387837514,
0.0125309546,
0.0514285639,
0.0141121531,
-0.0228963066,
-0.019721467,
-0.0154588735,
0.0269924551,
0.0365316682,
0.0050164866,
-0.0888758153,
-0.0758919567,
0.0070824749,
0.0075506433,
-0.0301795471,
-0.0000232245,
0.0580940545,
0.0743687153,
-0.0262533203,
-0.0162209366,
0.0319285057,
0.0456785597,
-0.0654630214,
-0.024756629,
0.0048184297,
-5.502038328e-33,
-0.0267373957,
-0.0270697605,
0.0467310734,
0.0470746271,
0.025480831,
-0.0421840586,
0.0046093538,
0.0284895748,
0.0011060424,
0.0122137535,
-0.0302336011,
0.0591216162,
0.0009860259,
0.0068319491,
-0.0235259198,
-0.0137713077,
-0.0017097413,
-0.0298876651,
-0.0312099755,
-0.0060995347,
-0.0153347794,
-0.0167024489,
0.1028410047,
-0.0565185025,
0.0164920278,
-0.0117457518,
0.0161560327,
-0.0011367813,
-0.054312624,
0.071663186,
-0.0025065504,
0.0333172902,
-0.0062115602,
0.0008705308,
-0.0008040424,
-0.018137984,
-0.0295962896,
-0.0705455393,
0.022221297,
0.0312830396,
-0.0348983668,
-0.0331535563,
0.0123103335,
-0.007448507,
-0.0613036416,
-0.0154367089,
0.0297410786,
-0.0170651544,
-0.0203336105,
0.0287592225,
0.000675349,
0.0490579382,
-0.0340088606,
0.0316029489,
0.0151580106,
0.003622662,
-0.0233296975,
-0.0560249574,
0.0038807113,
0.0083553335,
-0.0032073958,
0.0369351543,
0.0086700432,
-0.0916590542,
0.0240169577,
0.027157113,
0.0573641956,
-0.0182653386,
0.018782936,
-0.0108201634,
0.0565762147,
0.0475250483,
0.0703110918,
0.0144701907,
0.0619228519,
0.0304059517,
-0.0366222523,
0.0120616583,
0.0087403804,
0.0166499969,
0.0126439212,
0.0068760077,
-0.0675512478,
-0.0058088987,
-0.0091867326,
0.0346819386,
-0.0310459193,
-0.0302164126,
0.0028898653,
-0.0476129651,
-0.0062984768,
0.0337834507,
0.0045333756,
-0.0366732515,
-0.0325069502,
0.000499689,
0.0018292727,
0.0121332044,
0.0052236151,
0.0449974313,
-0.0523166098,
0.0027965207,
-0.0335482471,
0.0184394699,
0.0333859287,
-0.0007354187,
-0.0306644663,
0.0385547578,
-0.0142831551,
-0.017418012,
-0.0249212794,
0.008314007,
0.0324759074,
0.0117621981,
0.0399315171,
0.0521969944,
0.0204385519,
0.0285075419,
-0.0074666515,
0.0065338532,
-0.0539244972,
0.0414472967,
-0.0177387446,
-0.013693206,
0.0248040706,
-0.0266631134,
-0.0271158572,
-0.0329726934,
0.0507836901,
-0.0746690258,
0.0104800723,
0.0022562994,
2.907e-7,
0.0656388998,
0.0560256131,
0.048052799,
0.0623318776,
0.0046398574,
-0.0024031708,
-0.0324083529,
-0.0390245654,
0.0120967934,
0.0107595166,
0.0110992035,
0.0431870483,
0.0236860197,
0.0471322685,
-0.0640694574,
0.0123430081,
-0.0436719097,
-0.0517524108,
-0.0651564896,
0.0331552476,
0.0884756371,
0.0545125343,
0.0482817627,
0.0245783012,
-0.0271779411,
-0.0643087476,
0.0613767914,
-0.0140308775,
-0.0213698074,
0.0330691151,
0.0359739624,
0.0051544979,
0.0262137074,
0.0008816629,
0.0005523991,
0.0139808478,
0.0379114673,
0.0429971144,
0.0329294614,
0.0319329984,
-0.0342696384,
-0.0520512201,
-0.0120802149,
-0.0244972222,
0.0621516109,
-0.043851357,
-0.0620489083,
0.0063973097,
-0.0410773605,
-0.0398920812,
0.0376682803,
0.011819805,
-0.0131965093,
-0.0219845921,
0.0378051326,
-0.0126065984,
0.0066443775,
-0.0239229538,
0.0023486465,
0.0366349258,
-0.0522178635,
-0.0476285964,
-0.0722298995,
0.024925651,
0.023174433,
-0.0178368781,
-0.034038987,
3.0218757e-34,
0.0647471622,
-0.0087935561,
0.0519298241,
0.013162368,
0.0334329791,
0.0178535879,
0.0321599469,
0.0043205577,
0.0075703226,
-0.0308374912,
-0.0069936174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13848v1 | Benchmarking Large Language Models for News Summarization | 2023-01-31T18:46:19 | 2023-01-31T18:46:19 | Tianyi Zhang, Faisal Ladhak, Esin Durmus, Percy Liang, Kathleen McKeown, Tatsunori B. Hashimoto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promise for automatic summarization
but the reasons behind their successes are poorly understood. By conducting a
human evaluation on ten LLMs across different pretraining methods, prompts, and
model scales, we make two important observations. First, we find instruction
tuning, and not model size, is the key to the LLM's zero-shot summarization
capability. Second, existing studies have been limited by low-quality
references, leading to underestimates of human performance and lower few-shot
and finetuning performance. To better evaluate LLMs, we perform human
evaluation over high-quality summaries we collect from freelance writers.
Despite major stylistic differences such as the amount of paraphrasing, we find
that LMM summaries are judged to be on par with human written summaries. | [
0.0505454242,
0.024866689,
0.0479255691,
-0.0057450952,
-0.0094354786,
0.0167819392,
0.0066123586,
-0.0198408701,
-0.0271005835,
-0.0706711933,
-0.0155292936,
-0.0192516595,
-0.0066644168,
-0.026789451,
0.0031396323,
-0.0904006436,
-0.0084696021,
-0.0582006723,
0.0141666746,
-0.0079996195,
0.0335516296,
0.0167692043,
0.0246387608,
0.0308661405,
0.0224482287,
-0.0049295141,
0.0136486776,
0.0176860727,
0.0278267022,
-0.0104782945,
-0.0276298784,
0.0292207226,
0.0293628648,
0.0041531678,
0.0000017868,
-0.0536635183,
0.0049969563,
-0.0129688773,
0.0049803439,
0.0743933916,
0.0488139801,
-0.0801087916,
0.001579411,
0.0092311939,
0.0165248588,
-0.0125862546,
-0.0116309486,
0.0299115218,
0.1005935222,
0.0769288987,
-0.0020172843,
-0.0403336175,
0.0246867407,
-0.029516371,
-0.0543896109,
-0.0322634578,
0.0247449651,
0.0152458306,
0.0195326712,
-0.0036547007,
0.0274283011,
0.0462761782,
0.009836412,
-0.0177032184,
-0.0121995099,
0.0274304543,
-0.0458697379,
-0.0000262898,
0.0051938919,
0.0479280427,
0.0060206745,
0.0094219167,
0.0071997149,
0.0108982362,
-0.0033339926,
0.0060542044,
-0.0884673893,
0.0803682804,
-0.0219707005,
0.0053604781,
-0.0130597483,
0.0224971008,
-0.0151755,
0.0358962901,
-0.0122558102,
0.0090807015,
0.0130722588,
-0.0006850282,
-0.0141909663,
0.033764191,
-0.0060733389,
-0.0659236833,
0.0174080264,
0.0442218855,
-0.0206853822,
-0.016685484,
-0.0616210774,
-0.0353312194,
0.0167742018,
-0.0556220561,
0.0330035649,
-0.0034164016,
0.0128775947,
0.0532904603,
-0.0173472799,
0.012623312,
0.0206626952,
0.0153222065,
-0.0527342707,
0.0116366483,
-0.0421961471,
-0.0071717282,
-0.0507396124,
0.0309023596,
-0.0138759213,
-0.0450774282,
-0.0274848752,
0.0038225958,
0.0377665423,
0.0013240358,
-0.0075641237,
-0.0055550104,
0.0012831558,
-0.0170642231,
0.0061689224,
0.0401016548,
-0.0314700492,
-0.0306828506,
0.0279213842,
-0.0157643091,
-0.0139604378,
0.0271106753,
-0.0039620539,
-0.0009945435,
0.0013002772,
0.0155301392,
-0.0542664267,
-0.0386438817,
-0.0143805128,
-0.0101433285,
0.0023140211,
-0.0682772473,
-0.0119540114,
-0.0747263655,
-0.0165839493,
0.0119927786,
-0.0004554084,
-0.0064021577,
-0.0136362119,
0.0366651602,
-0.0670763403,
-0.0000156145,
-0.004471757,
0.0411911346,
0.0333343484,
0.0077534486,
0.032729134,
0.0807178766,
0.0515201651,
0.0758276954,
0.0295179971,
0.0159222055,
0.0210238919,
0.032095138,
-0.0196734313,
0.0174026079,
-0.0229977407,
-0.0099490872,
-0.0275821257,
0.0235544406,
0.0641760901,
0.0811458901,
-0.0460761376,
0.0481368527,
0.1016379744,
0.0464298502,
0.010053399,
0.0044761617,
0.0691125318,
0.0426744819,
0.0761931911,
0.0514390171,
-0.0229993612,
0.0169307087,
-0.0311420895,
0.0762990564,
0.0727476776,
0.04909743,
-0.0332986265,
-0.0182336662,
-0.0117082838,
-0.0042775585,
-0.0069517037,
0.0083753765,
0.0278511196,
-0.0051336433,
-0.0526448376,
0.0365531072,
0.0109479045,
-0.0257842205,
0.0037164495,
-0.0289323609,
0.0098138172,
0.0635965019,
0.0494843163,
0.0017159954,
0.0089398185,
-0.012551846,
0.047806628,
0.0341667272,
0.0501630194,
-0.0042113741,
-0.0210872889,
-0.0248580407,
-0.0109348251,
-0.0219047833,
0.0217955653,
-0.0065670963,
0.0013966234,
-0.0108053284,
0.0244902577,
0.0086313812,
-0.1015498564,
0.0288335998,
-0.0214823801,
-0.0406669602,
-0.0393821597,
-0.0141831329,
-0.0158146806,
0.0305821653,
-0.0319986269,
0.0138435606,
-0.0097594233,
-0.032470461,
0.003801282,
0.0139281275,
-0.041022677,
-0.0120860906,
0.0091103455,
-0.0493119322,
-0.0048699863,
0.0065550455,
-0.0267724916,
-0.0438984521,
-0.0002388728,
-0.0346667916,
-0.0045715054,
-0.0467944369,
0.0276235081,
0.0068276012,
-0.0099899359,
-0.0272179451,
0.0625188127,
0.02149795,
-0.009028581,
0.0601353683,
-0.025225196,
-0.0160757899,
-0.0322401635,
-0.03246966,
0.0089021344,
0.0324266292,
0.0239611845,
0.0230830275,
0.0203767084,
-0.0128680933,
-0.0420580544,
-0.1026999205,
0.0261426456,
-0.0296228267,
0.0011554094,
0.0403449982,
-0.0073204744,
-0.0256888382,
0.0063002123,
-0.0026784141,
-0.0453203954,
0.0286963601,
0.0316808559,
0.0329983607,
0.031591285,
0.0271668211,
-0.0645659044,
-0.0088323168,
-0.0015814005,
0.0594410598,
0.0205878559,
-0.010557876,
-0.0625182241,
0.0426108986,
-0.0059635267,
-0.0550726503,
0.0075149238,
-0.0361146703,
-0.0047534471,
-0.0098456172,
0.0371136479,
0.1066200361,
0.0394838154,
0.0253440049,
0.0444791652,
0.0016306966,
-0.02274484,
-0.0117395539,
0.0060814046,
-0.0247257948,
-0.0206565093,
-0.0300508346,
0.0143406661,
0.0494717844,
-0.0009015549,
0.0283522252,
-0.0268462151,
0.0515874848,
-0.0298883971,
-2.091e-7,
-0.034955468,
-0.0253812559,
-0.0018164373,
0.0305406824,
-0.0307489093,
0.010620188,
0.0501021259,
-0.0277661625,
0.0153270243,
-0.0341774262,
-0.0071357652,
-0.0662295669,
0.0074039949,
0.0028893698,
0.0384655036,
-0.0212927796,
-0.0198741257,
-0.0318085738,
-0.0338516831,
0.0408919975,
0.0041997605,
0.083346352,
-0.0477839597,
0.0231066197,
-0.03462217,
-0.0156839937,
-0.0016003092,
-0.0663681477,
-0.0742853731,
0.0304317996,
0.0320226066,
-0.001900457,
-0.0318592526,
0.0500459112,
0.0672797635,
0.040678665,
-0.0512633994,
-0.0156748816,
-0.0065792911,
0.0471715815,
0.0696224049,
-0.0000128496,
0.0063161864,
-0.0686642453,
0.0549983084,
-0.0024962206,
0.0245180111,
0.0268528722,
-0.0060406076,
-0.0149787068,
0.0011975288,
-0.083545655,
-0.0010061538,
-0.0035913945,
0.0846740752,
-0.0433225855,
-0.0002789033,
0.1218491942,
0.0159612913,
-0.0358446054,
-0.0198857076,
0.0202734433,
0.0134223998,
-0.0002163938,
0.013534951,
-0.0499201752,
-0.0256208144,
-0.0063772574,
0.0274610519,
0.0271763857,
-0.0052079256,
-0.0145600345,
-0.0915666893,
0.0130307097,
0.0202127118,
-0.0530903339,
-0.0210988931,
-0.0287352502,
-0.003194832,
-0.0106536802,
0.0222132653,
0.0315152556,
-0.0771972239,
0.0130334981,
0.0023788062,
-0.0657216012,
-0.0379035845,
-0.0129434643,
-0.0410071872,
0.0167559646,
0.0549612567,
0.0092503401,
-0.0198518839,
0.048173923,
0.0286052357,
-0.0208064914,
0.0121544721,
-0.0013533715,
0.0803832039,
-0.0341562927,
0.0145521434,
-0.0353642069,
0.0289642978,
0.0361609086,
0.0059544374,
0.016890781,
-0.0163815916,
0.0219282974,
-0.029209746,
-0.0271270145,
0.0463139638,
-0.0404656418,
0.0756427571,
0.0687504783,
-0.0376785919,
-0.0364561453,
-0.026336778,
-0.0292357057,
-0.0700927153,
-0.0590699874,
0.0223713052,
-0.0478827059,
-0.0200484581,
-0.0652915761,
-0.0753643587,
0.0344116502,
0.0031089948,
0.0139515558,
-0.0040297993,
-0.0207285043,
0.0146215614,
-0.0004827446,
0.0182227548,
-0.0323891453,
-0.0096800141,
-0.0650266856,
-0.0099822953,
0.0666296259,
-0.0148891676,
-0.0189695433,
-0.0050443066,
-0.0833496228,
-0.0307094976,
-0.0210770443,
0.0566988364,
0.0269948598,
0.0423898995,
0.0095970072,
-0.0483610742,
0.055238042,
0.0240471344,
0.025420228,
0.0418979786,
-0.0070352987,
0.0399733558,
-0.0189445503,
0.0196591821,
-0.0359609015,
0.0508647375,
-0.0180048421,
0.0286100283,
-0.0370301157,
-0.0493480191,
-0.000491131,
0.035492111,
-0.0092195626,
-0.0208080821,
0.0087673925,
-0.0130763082,
-0.0400140733,
-0.0398797393,
-0.0069399253,
-0.0345200822,
0.0147430636,
0.0084858788,
0.0087507535,
-0.014006163,
0.053928826,
-0.0126711698,
0.0359292142,
-0.0593393445,
0.0140673062,
-0.031803105,
-0.0285576582,
-0.0370045714,
-0.0088753868,
-0.0712720826,
-0.0090420479,
-0.0459813587,
0.0091665918,
0.0025454233,
0.0105885202,
0.0196474195,
-0.0046971687,
0.0083492948,
0.0383397937,
-0.0963080004,
-0.0367211625,
-0.0382511839,
0.0451427847,
0.0802706406,
-0.0566443652,
0.089152649,
-0.0031898536,
-0.0050052069,
-0.0203680992,
0.0151340161,
0.0299723223,
0.0024018926,
-0.021542456,
0.0316856019,
0.0177521668,
0.0079570906,
0.1124847904,
0.0074911783,
0.0087704761,
0.0375395752,
-0.0258817375,
-0.0396698676,
-0.0214448366,
0.000379847,
0.0052922815,
0.0021248448,
-0.0333502442,
-0.0587094165,
0.0103267217,
0.0086349268,
0.0092251664,
0.0042286841,
-0.0524943173,
0.0116553782,
0.0279905591,
0.0185394138,
0.0044909022,
-0.0623004809,
-0.0084204404,
-0.0060183839,
-0.0096389297,
0.0111649325,
-6.019868201e-33,
-0.0532609224,
0.0247381926,
-0.0054618414,
-0.0120750554,
-0.0475789905,
0.0224904306,
-0.0575155504,
-0.0157114826,
0.0059512197,
0.0010942545,
-0.0407181941,
-0.0265374891,
0.0165010151,
0.024223011,
0.0210460108,
0.021116076,
0.0618023835,
-0.0098152794,
-0.0578441471,
0.0114890831,
-0.0080834581,
0.0142078055,
0.0195089225,
-0.0004121337,
0.0086887069,
-0.0442563035,
-0.0308568794,
-0.0123354439,
0.0823269412,
0.0242489763,
-0.0011430662,
-0.0129885683,
0.0360063016,
-0.0506902561,
-0.0510363653,
0.0115800928,
-0.0557684861,
0.0067290412,
0.0563206859,
-0.0174558032,
-0.0129166767,
-0.0411619693,
0.0394350588,
-0.0339316688,
0.0109974733,
-0.0345768146,
0.0531260893,
-0.0563996956,
-0.0373579226,
-0.050023701,
-0.044225134,
0.0179071259,
-0.0200220048,
-0.033879336,
0.0237208232,
0.0400326848,
-0.0290041175,
0.0433949679,
-0.0291527435,
0.0073727071,
0.0388917625,
0.0482428856,
0.0441874638,
0.0128737669,
-0.0071987831,
0.0508721732,
-0.0109817144,
-0.0012751281,
-0.0267414749,
0.0208660364,
0.0145274987,
0.007370926,
-0.0007471194,
0.0429354049,
0.0403918661,
0.0365837105,
-0.0358593538,
0.0686907545,
-0.0038026997,
0.0279585849,
0.0368494727,
0.0017282882,
-0.0012480981,
-0.0197712947,
-0.0249017868,
-0.0148534179,
-0.009981975,
-0.023776412,
0.0055675684,
0.0125075486,
-0.0528392009,
-0.0070161317,
0.0423351713,
-0.0256692618,
-0.0000650234,
0.0139434366,
-0.0414755978,
0.0572767854,
-0.0253190715,
-0.0107941385,
-0.0725202784,
0.0246107206,
0.0050451048,
0.0444463938,
-0.0003227926,
0.0060147727,
0.0624146983,
-0.0019895746,
-0.0490952395,
0.0041058543,
0.0156486891,
0.01259463,
-0.041429434,
0.0162213799,
0.0151791554,
0.0082742218,
0.0116643924,
0.0346518196,
-0.017741669,
-0.0458750986,
0.003407344,
0.002547225,
0.0262006093,
0.028995486,
-0.0125318449,
0.0520427786,
-0.0085280538,
0.0197418109,
0.0240275655,
-0.0329075344,
-0.0212181769,
-0.0019256115,
2.384e-7,
0.0255712867,
0.0616250411,
0.0438809469,
0.0382768996,
-0.0196100362,
0.0299352873,
-0.0231808927,
0.0227506571,
0.0388148576,
0.0033469873,
0.0454633869,
0.0680529997,
0.0605326891,
0.0071721445,
-0.1133490875,
-0.020502679,
-0.096957162,
-0.0051152389,
-0.0620450862,
-0.065896146,
0.043670997,
0.0222780909,
-0.0379163325,
-0.0060015158,
-0.0091954712,
-0.0678665936,
0.053940028,
-0.0162207559,
-0.0600139126,
0.0207379851,
0.0562651977,
0.0380055569,
-0.025556596,
-0.0132448589,
0.0039020092,
-0.0244219638,
0.0557048284,
0.0755102932,
0.018358523,
0.0041640247,
0.0128460564,
-0.0055937176,
0.016629098,
-0.0077479882,
0.0597878173,
-0.0664497912,
0.0022503703,
-0.0437437631,
-0.0528736822,
-0.0277747307,
-0.0055492972,
-0.0221552085,
-0.0292673893,
0.063385807,
0.0061346334,
-0.0208225697,
0.0121452548,
-0.0561371744,
-0.0534895435,
0.0234664101,
0.0067240526,
-0.0232023951,
-0.0149178552,
-0.0253658108,
-0.0252894443,
-0.0766976252,
-0.0082879979,
2.080434672e-34,
0.1093675718,
0.0006477611,
-0.0051062978,
0.0190030821,
0.0213173386,
0.0207081921,
-0.0381543711,
-0.0206473991,
-0.0059025735,
-0.0763474852,
0.0175429136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13844v1 | Do Multi-Document Summarization Models Synthesize? | 2023-01-31T18:40:46 | 2023-01-31T18:40:46 | Jay DeYoung, Stephanie C. Martinez, Iain J. Marshall, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-document summarization entails producing concise synopses of
collections of inputs. For some applications, the synopsis should accurately
\emph{synthesize} inputs with respect to a key property or aspect. For example,
a synopsis of film reviews all written about a particular movie should reflect
the average critic consensus. As a more consequential example, consider
narrative summaries that accompany biomedical \emph{systematic reviews} of
clinical trial results. These narratives should fairly summarize the
potentially conflicting results from individual trials.
In this paper we ask: To what extent do modern multi-document summarization
models implicitly perform this type of synthesis? To assess this we perform a
suite of experiments that probe the degree to which conditional generation
models trained for summarization using standard methods yield outputs that
appropriately synthesize inputs. We find that existing models do partially
perform synthesis, but do so imperfectly. In particular, they are
over-sensitive to changes in input ordering and under-sensitive to changes in
input compositions (e.g., the ratio of positive to negative movie reviews). We
propose a simple, general method for improving model synthesis capabilities by
generating an explicitly diverse set of candidate outputs, and then selecting
from these the string best aligned with the expected aggregate measure for the
inputs, or \emph{abstaining} when the model produces no good candidate. This
approach improves model synthesis performance. We hope highlighting the need
for synthesis (in some summarization settings), motivates further research into
multi-document summarization methods and learning objectives that explicitly
account for the need to synthesize. | [
0.0458954163,
0.032736171,
0.0169830602,
-0.0188939199,
-0.0072872909,
0.0012815805,
-0.017553132,
0.0046555968,
-0.0485814773,
-0.0537249744,
0.0096801296,
-0.0423332267,
0.0092463186,
0.0165887233,
0.0116331493,
-0.0875859112,
0.0170938466,
0.0035741164,
-0.0216096435,
0.0185335893,
0.0026963565,
0.0319898725,
0.0263121538,
0.0457517914,
0.0089502288,
0.0044273091,
0.0229935832,
0.012817394,
0.0522634573,
-0.0078342035,
-0.030976221,
0.0242069699,
-0.0013811807,
-0.0308276024,
0.0000017099,
-0.0279640835,
-0.0227427948,
-0.0010613519,
0.0401290134,
0.017029576,
0.0722184256,
-0.0584461354,
0.0224705916,
0.0205477476,
-0.0039578769,
-0.0175873693,
0.0048555806,
0.040381778,
0.0616850182,
0.0706945807,
-0.0205282588,
-0.0396038927,
-0.0009959195,
-0.0319639109,
-0.018527437,
0.0236618109,
-0.0071609532,
0.0176243652,
0.0036282022,
-0.0054112175,
0.0139781078,
-0.0037247434,
0.0050846324,
-0.0051805908,
0.0124948937,
0.0479327329,
-0.0171762444,
-0.0385837294,
0.0220276266,
0.0680154487,
-0.0128791574,
-0.0003165675,
0.0393582992,
-0.0169523768,
0.0284784492,
0.0178424716,
-0.0741013512,
0.0560728796,
-0.0425739773,
0.0244677663,
0.0119000217,
0.0518109947,
0.0015477194,
-0.003427705,
-0.0037563618,
-0.0230596587,
0.0152218193,
-0.0062849694,
-0.0441074595,
0.0079747215,
-0.032155104,
-0.0507766828,
-0.0100434031,
0.0089923404,
-0.0010167939,
-0.0066979383,
-0.0642903447,
-0.0549324229,
0.0424464792,
-0.0444880016,
0.0313729756,
-0.0009995541,
0.0234969761,
0.0212903451,
-0.0098861493,
-0.0083603133,
0.0075540696,
0.0102488725,
-0.0805519298,
0.0088414587,
-0.032380119,
0.0132464506,
-0.0120797679,
0.059117645,
-0.0195670836,
-0.0254751183,
-0.0623708293,
0.0206456855,
-0.0052147028,
0.0043673776,
-0.0135729937,
0.0333057716,
-0.0218014847,
-0.0188858397,
-0.0030259984,
0.0191831961,
-0.0354945064,
-0.0073770857,
0.043198064,
0.0264254995,
-0.01320385,
0.0221278295,
0.0022588009,
0.0325726308,
-0.0088265389,
0.0532829873,
-0.0261811092,
0.0024691345,
-0.0129336771,
-0.0636046678,
-0.030473955,
-0.0539275892,
0.0295743085,
-0.0702494755,
0.024989767,
0.0107115544,
-0.0122677432,
-0.017404696,
-0.0031924001,
0.0108092446,
-0.0440735258,
0.0140121859,
0.0061540781,
-0.0155408345,
0.0106551945,
0.0144901127,
-0.002913831,
0.0633594245,
0.0469028987,
0.0475072265,
0.0191988405,
-0.0000485465,
0.0332272612,
-0.001159408,
0.0071672969,
0.0128458589,
-0.0105341598,
-0.03352293,
-0.0148587441,
-0.0047106245,
0.0235916954,
0.0728050396,
-0.0536587983,
0.0194926597,
0.0309978109,
0.0220605675,
0.0166099593,
0.0284374338,
0.0767472982,
-0.0037543699,
0.0138139334,
0.104376711,
0.0073798806,
0.0207386203,
-0.0166635271,
0.0672906935,
0.0654475391,
0.0454920046,
-0.0228267256,
-0.0713926405,
-0.0100449165,
-0.0149361929,
-0.0140209571,
-0.0274151526,
0.0311620589,
0.0456580818,
-0.0544748828,
0.0379337631,
0.0290223714,
-0.0806812569,
0.0454449058,
-0.0233211536,
0.031572178,
0.0467343405,
0.0478710085,
-0.009579191,
-0.015248484,
0.0007812107,
-0.0345413685,
0.019913042,
0.0625823066,
-0.0337810479,
0.0054014851,
-0.0385406986,
-0.0071501201,
-0.0380741283,
0.034143731,
0.0250180289,
-0.0370749533,
-0.0328370854,
0.0384898521,
-0.0281596687,
-0.0564937666,
0.0340318233,
-0.0035877128,
-0.0074978108,
0.0140031958,
-0.043772921,
0.018170597,
0.0380663052,
-0.0263748001,
0.039470721,
0.033511024,
-0.0253003072,
-0.0427571051,
0.0098104049,
-0.0400360003,
-0.0610512272,
-0.0013534168,
-0.0708988383,
0.0171804931,
0.0028026502,
-0.0503512323,
-0.0643128455,
0.0368916914,
-0.0519431233,
0.0029311597,
-0.0110825561,
0.0125501929,
0.0516307391,
-0.0156698897,
-0.0136458799,
0.0576611347,
-0.0111801568,
-0.0038720735,
0.041528061,
-0.0555736087,
-0.0053395256,
-0.025670765,
0.0088988496,
0.0053169806,
0.0060826959,
0.0159147363,
0.0660693422,
-0.0043549491,
-0.0066566765,
-0.0581715219,
-0.0888566747,
0.0068982779,
-0.0189143773,
-0.0097923959,
0.0578166582,
0.0031465329,
0.0087622544,
0.0011511474,
-0.0303431433,
-0.0315887183,
0.0432147533,
0.0245055351,
0.0238745697,
0.0394547433,
0.0169188268,
-0.054844331,
-0.028993614,
-0.0152857583,
0.0979880244,
0.0187090635,
-0.0043752333,
-0.0244503412,
0.0151117323,
-0.0285924431,
-0.0396332107,
-0.0039512711,
0.0133517925,
0.0104477266,
0.0060509676,
0.0310393963,
0.0216081105,
0.0478188358,
0.028615633,
0.0657214224,
0.018902095,
-0.0363865979,
-0.0067914259,
-0.0542260967,
0.0272962749,
0.0008228088,
-0.0690299422,
0.0313699134,
0.0402697735,
0.0455478318,
0.0136674289,
-0.0544589683,
0.0322574414,
-0.0198775232,
-0.0215596445,
-0.0228720605,
-0.0542059019,
0.0055970587,
0.0266709607,
0.0047405143,
-0.0132838385,
0.0523956418,
-0.0254449677,
0.0436373688,
-0.0616898909,
0.0096737947,
-0.0422634967,
0.0281959753,
0.0182358418,
0.0468282849,
0.0317983702,
0.017094804,
-0.0542278253,
-0.0232760161,
0.0401267074,
-0.0007889774,
0.0738363862,
-0.0371029973,
0.0021566616,
-0.0216894969,
-0.0175615735,
-0.0089095179,
-0.0419211835,
0.0135606714,
0.024679279,
0.0428638831,
0.0038021374,
-0.0388547033,
0.0314216688,
0.0093333907,
0.0543046743,
-0.0181325413,
-0.0169993117,
0.0084935222,
0.0574885681,
0.07577952,
-0.0359096602,
0.0124722365,
-0.0741079375,
0.0235313736,
0.0532036461,
0.0359057523,
0.0082616638,
-0.0064453213,
-0.0377283096,
-0.0275973026,
-0.0560278296,
-0.0015707141,
-0.0052344496,
0.0268707182,
-0.0397078209,
0.0401964188,
0.0932670608,
0.011576484,
-0.0344796292,
0.0013192588,
0.046367567,
0.0273993239,
-0.0008756516,
-0.013050938,
-0.0585694611,
-0.002050102,
-0.0278325137,
0.0264557917,
-0.0047693336,
-0.0026634373,
-0.0266184621,
-0.0683740526,
0.0269324817,
0.02597172,
-0.0374288298,
-0.020460261,
-0.0253234059,
-0.0078374892,
-0.0317533128,
-0.0127980281,
0.0229127854,
-0.0506143272,
0.0182783455,
0.0124355769,
-0.0658962727,
-0.0168999583,
-0.0450121649,
-0.038703613,
-0.0021459286,
0.0498156101,
0.0270611458,
-0.0005347411,
0.0423565842,
0.0456540436,
-0.0351164155,
0.0040902505,
0.0132611468,
0.0952272192,
-0.00906868,
0.0382622443,
0.0042229132,
0.0355837345,
0.0143259745,
-0.0261757933,
-0.0025254034,
-0.0098300213,
0.0014908246,
-0.0598774627,
-0.082833834,
0.073043935,
-0.0345351398,
0.0784317777,
0.0446161106,
-0.0183846466,
-0.0211882256,
-0.0253475234,
0.0026395158,
-0.0635806993,
0.0173458029,
-0.0165782813,
-0.0364002027,
-0.0327280648,
-0.0905651823,
-0.0821620896,
0.0018908607,
0.0169432852,
-0.0107808914,
-0.0186606385,
0.0050113034,
-0.0013452595,
0.010648841,
0.0159349721,
0.0300770085,
-0.0502655059,
-0.0013531079,
-0.0232187565,
0.061375577,
-0.0313099511,
-0.0206759907,
0.0172756612,
-0.0552278236,
-0.0523139574,
-0.0282359626,
0.0501204282,
0.0284305029,
0.0615619011,
0.0325426087,
0.0185903553,
0.0566547476,
0.035114117,
0.0238232818,
0.0320025273,
0.0199820101,
0.017122265,
-0.0378923342,
-0.007869564,
-0.0674275458,
0.0533977635,
-0.0374529324,
0.0368682072,
-0.0281799659,
-0.0461852327,
0.0250144973,
0.0097282166,
-0.0079155583,
-0.071263276,
0.0265152454,
-0.0418681577,
-0.021566771,
-0.0291160829,
-0.0228783097,
-0.0538479239,
0.0421923473,
0.010872324,
0.0155437756,
-0.0234013777,
0.0508782454,
-0.039922256,
0.0715874359,
-0.0557222292,
-0.0239995345,
-0.0067231492,
-0.0527518243,
-0.0148744145,
-0.0361546203,
-0.0528398976,
0.0142530259,
-0.040908955,
-0.0137938187,
-0.0198552124,
0.0064957896,
0.0308788195,
0.018463267,
-0.0450889803,
0.023043558,
-0.0813731849,
0.0083337212,
-0.0997351706,
0.0173224825,
0.0141690336,
-0.0154624041,
0.0762831122,
-0.0309097376,
-0.002809148,
-0.0174960829,
0.0331256799,
0.0444616601,
-0.0018785611,
-0.0191966482,
0.0210259315,
0.0038865102,
-0.0284422301,
0.0976380557,
-0.0360089764,
0.0271840282,
-0.0100661758,
-0.0363379531,
-0.0403349884,
-0.0444732681,
-0.0164277721,
0.0128463963,
0.0064285928,
-0.0259829778,
-0.0824782476,
-0.0037053577,
0.0541342162,
0.0230345055,
0.0445952192,
-0.0187703092,
0.0319004282,
0.0433530323,
0.015344114,
0.0155782178,
-0.042637229,
-0.0342198946,
-0.0264114104,
0.0051170769,
-0.0162355565,
-5.397834427e-33,
-0.042159427,
0.0005121086,
-0.0226892661,
-0.0014787616,
-0.0181866325,
-0.0166990217,
-0.0483807549,
-0.0174749773,
0.0415193364,
0.0138732074,
-0.0053274543,
0.0007712333,
0.011995283,
0.024315875,
0.0181046426,
0.01295029,
0.0783925205,
-0.00454068,
-0.0714400858,
0.0448304936,
0.0322692208,
-0.0184114724,
0.0299196914,
-0.0210971572,
0.0226760171,
-0.0096240621,
-0.0440993682,
-0.0517078638,
0.0153679568,
0.0461945496,
0.0078115477,
0.0188259352,
0.0434146635,
-0.0300384909,
-0.051561553,
0.0074044643,
-0.0427410007,
-0.0202880166,
0.0526403673,
-0.0691122413,
-0.0463869683,
-0.0429482274,
0.0443135314,
-0.0178269334,
0.0090270946,
-0.0442014895,
0.0627689362,
-0.033039216,
-0.0242172871,
-0.105532743,
-0.0375544764,
0.0209612902,
-0.0166199114,
-0.0086854715,
-0.0324315727,
0.0734968036,
-0.0009764792,
0.0258113611,
-0.0007836591,
0.0540267229,
0.0555026941,
0.0555985533,
0.0209913887,
0.0034425291,
-0.0226920061,
0.0705749169,
0.0062423632,
-0.0026509238,
-0.0433474444,
0.0074064629,
-0.0319846682,
0.0012086332,
0.0245215837,
0.055734098,
0.0452421121,
0.0234162845,
-0.0393090211,
0.0864663348,
-0.0293276943,
-0.0153738223,
0.0554744154,
-0.0186711401,
0.0129528893,
-0.0109794354,
-0.047247991,
-0.0152693503,
-0.0045612627,
-0.0064534694,
-0.0137946419,
0.0446212552,
-0.0584481657,
-0.0166555718,
0.0246655662,
-0.0073718154,
0.0206418857,
0.0260898601,
-0.0664648712,
0.035189271,
0.0053051859,
-0.0298342854,
-0.0129986145,
0.0089903371,
0.0646058694,
0.0075033335,
-0.0022380634,
0.0238482244,
0.0630871058,
0.0152633926,
-0.0375300944,
0.0080894846,
-0.000315845,
0.018885389,
-0.0302039068,
-0.0037443186,
0.0149793029,
0.0336481035,
-0.0202809721,
0.0125375194,
-0.024319876,
0.0233839173,
-0.005646233,
0.0233573057,
0.0182495192,
0.0428113788,
-0.0027057121,
0.0227820706,
-0.0039525074,
-0.005902255,
0.0658046082,
-0.023902718,
-0.033249259,
0.0276450403,
2.308e-7,
0.0660559833,
-0.0067426707,
0.045818571,
-0.0131040206,
-0.0102219926,
0.0416235588,
-0.0008244772,
0.0433404036,
0.019380467,
-0.0022245219,
0.0385304764,
0.0128189977,
0.0098753152,
0.0503866151,
-0.0684627295,
0.0033520791,
-0.0851595253,
-0.0390158258,
-0.0294628423,
-0.0223531779,
0.0454357378,
0.0590991601,
-0.0399291292,
-0.0040787985,
-0.0198900942,
-0.0229377933,
0.0678976923,
-0.0187593102,
-0.0644976944,
0.0420334376,
0.0759793445,
-0.0373786986,
-0.0127512291,
0.0025219223,
-0.0229111817,
-0.0137972478,
0.0433984511,
0.0504558422,
0.0206458997,
-0.0044778208,
0.0435475037,
0.0009238954,
0.0280725975,
0.0116373952,
0.0242884886,
-0.0641819164,
0.0038326988,
-0.0506736115,
-0.0522546731,
0.0431824401,
-0.0029574421,
-0.0187162217,
-0.0265980922,
0.0723210946,
-0.0195668358,
0.0135966009,
0.0105510186,
-0.0438559167,
-0.0515783466,
0.0478983968,
-0.0215403866,
-0.0568145886,
0.0119147152,
-0.0092768129,
0.0074596014,
-0.100990437,
-0.0332492441,
2.453995068e-34,
0.1077042893,
0.0029975935,
-0.0385127515,
-0.025413882,
0.0181087479,
-0.0257218741,
-0.046880465,
0.0083456738,
-0.0002843791,
-0.0598123334,
-0.0256634858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13823v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13823v4 | Grounding Language Models to Images for Multimodal Inputs and Outputs | 2023-01-31T18:33:44 | 2023-06-13T21:54:58 | Jing Yu Koh, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Daniel Fried | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | We propose an efficient method to ground pretrained text-only language models
to the visual domain, enabling them to process arbitrarily interleaved
image-and-text data, and generate text interleaved with retrieved images. Our
method leverages the abilities of language models learnt from large scale
text-only pretraining, such as in-context learning and free-form text
generation. We keep the language model frozen, and finetune input and output
linear layers to enable cross-modality interactions. This allows our model to
process arbitrarily interleaved image-and-text inputs, and generate free-form
text interleaved with retrieved images. We achieve strong zero-shot performance
on grounded tasks such as contextual image retrieval and multimodal dialogue,
and showcase compelling interactive abilities. Our approach works with any
off-the-shelf language model and paves the way towards an effective, general
solution for leveraging pretrained language models in visually grounded
settings. | [
-0.0047570844,
0.0520698465,
0.0204316601,
0.0527641401,
0.0030767585,
0.0060531693,
0.0531664938,
0.0165216494,
-0.0127529418,
-0.09518677,
-0.0689242855,
-0.0230035856,
0.000586856,
0.0605628602,
0.029829992,
-0.0594633259,
-0.0116473883,
-0.0382030047,
-0.0310369805,
0.005716031,
0.0568315722,
0.0244002156,
-0.0212050043,
0.0342879333,
-0.0517567843,
-0.0161910634,
-0.0236796085,
0.0398259722,
-0.0070847548,
-0.0149425762,
-0.0080577256,
0.0447509438,
0.0733148754,
0.040128354,
0.0000018115,
0.016992202,
0.0286742784,
-0.0146850422,
0.0300273504,
-0.0246549919,
0.044570338,
-0.0304914378,
-0.0007561686,
-0.0007839216,
-0.0384861641,
-0.0199907031,
0.0739345327,
0.0591845587,
0.0863003135,
0.0389211588,
-0.0369943194,
-0.0207507163,
-0.0088233752,
-0.0198338684,
0.0320529267,
-0.0006019897,
-0.0126045933,
0.0117946779,
-0.0111871073,
0.0227763504,
-0.0321963355,
0.0458454899,
0.0324675068,
-0.030177325,
-0.005406315,
0.0719631836,
-0.0033671488,
-0.0385452248,
-0.043123126,
0.1135464013,
-0.0418360643,
-0.0291490722,
-0.0194499996,
-0.0161560979,
-0.0087565249,
-0.0172526147,
-0.0388024971,
0.0383173078,
0.0122174881,
0.0260953046,
-0.077394329,
0.0079567945,
0.0019746502,
0.0063369446,
-0.0133689065,
0.0060883276,
0.0275686551,
0.021921372,
-0.0127940141,
0.0368617661,
-0.0232289135,
-0.0674311221,
0.0102410885,
0.029610632,
0.0035136356,
0.0178596452,
-0.0595852919,
-0.0228216518,
-0.0172420535,
-0.0335388482,
0.041253712,
0.0262580439,
-0.0787581205,
0.0409920365,
-0.0230875574,
0.0211491436,
-0.0256333761,
0.02498281,
-0.0076907068,
0.0071677994,
-0.004684112,
-0.031075025,
-0.0580484755,
0.0032811856,
-0.0972723588,
-0.0663578436,
0.0087226871,
0.0239899047,
0.0055024032,
-0.0185964517,
0.0088053551,
0.0275174826,
-0.0521429181,
-0.0202515069,
-0.0055773607,
0.0401291065,
0.0117937503,
0.0383431055,
0.0146444431,
-0.0484819636,
-0.0001826083,
0.0290883891,
0.047322128,
-0.0201359745,
-0.0280049331,
0.0615082867,
-0.0727646574,
-0.035432145,
-0.0210171714,
-0.0318253264,
-0.0241846163,
-0.05545054,
0.0227609631,
-0.0424693972,
0.0272137355,
-0.0044098427,
0.0109698651,
-0.0384102352,
0.0185238682,
0.0236913413,
-0.0051082294,
0.1136641651,
-0.006663627,
-0.0199807528,
0.0370686799,
0.0191349741,
0.0380839743,
0.0742593855,
0.0270507764,
0.0505651049,
0.0049493178,
0.014475476,
0.0238277148,
0.0527214184,
0.0123786265,
0.0087865368,
-0.0599075183,
-0.0217988938,
0.0051593781,
0.0122709228,
0.0339489542,
0.0549262874,
-0.05041999,
0.0230945926,
0.0863776654,
0.0483136065,
-0.0084758829,
-0.0066560879,
0.0618646219,
0.0030508286,
-0.0315962061,
-0.0056086713,
-0.0546246134,
0.0572426207,
0.009682361,
0.0106083164,
0.0185789149,
0.0108760279,
-0.0578150116,
-0.0379177742,
0.0104949065,
-0.0254555941,
0.0421539284,
-0.0015511329,
0.0315192007,
0.0466659702,
-0.0642336532,
0.0389999002,
0.0026143726,
-0.0689201057,
0.016148366,
0.0099056633,
-0.0067513203,
0.0614085235,
0.0009568661,
0.0259865895,
0.0162200537,
-0.0000719389,
0.0875357613,
0.0892438591,
-0.0219099782,
0.0030911304,
0.0541398525,
-0.0687180012,
-0.0281368755,
-0.0201601963,
0.0056203427,
0.0117932316,
-0.0063242144,
0.0289061759,
0.0333165936,
-0.013043059,
0.0118152043,
0.0474700779,
0.0004850174,
-0.0162676852,
-0.0214867294,
0.0315086879,
-0.0237279143,
-0.012520764,
-0.0346191712,
0.0128922323,
0.0193239208,
-0.0309003498,
-0.0138823567,
0.0452139564,
-0.044839859,
-0.0335570499,
0.0005950037,
-0.0310545806,
0.0296887513,
-0.0254260413,
-0.0094027426,
-0.023998959,
0.012117262,
-0.0081830127,
0.0259230658,
-0.0633805543,
-0.0096213883,
0.0416652262,
0.0190659519,
-0.0250664912,
0.0203452297,
-0.0004141692,
-0.0106782941,
-0.0060667209,
0.031515643,
0.0120063713,
-0.0257894527,
-0.0363887548,
0.0120148696,
0.0083136987,
0.0339216404,
0.0106474571,
0.0430848114,
-0.0217392519,
0.0007030125,
-0.1024971455,
-0.0474935286,
-0.0345030203,
-0.0335279927,
0.0153861679,
0.0175954048,
0.0166989528,
-0.0595444441,
-0.0254226383,
0.0413641967,
0.0437945016,
0.0130443657,
0.0261620916,
0.034827482,
0.0320166498,
-0.0416322351,
-0.0035130107,
0.0414876863,
0.0735979155,
-0.0033269557,
-0.0086322203,
-0.0246386807,
0.0179986022,
-0.0465113558,
0.062162362,
-0.0149178896,
-0.0320436507,
0.0448562764,
-0.0343551785,
0.0246743858,
0.0599383004,
0.0058941734,
0.0317953713,
0.006736035,
-0.0178144798,
-0.0453589186,
-0.0033358173,
0.0083915098,
-0.0204450916,
0.0020853817,
0.030075131,
-0.0100694485,
0.0716284364,
-0.0059720301,
0.0325917676,
-0.0702035129,
0.0073388801,
-0.000918992,
-0.0448001511,
-0.0695655569,
0.0175135527,
-0.006996063,
0.0450019836,
-0.0676325262,
-0.0748634785,
0.024021484,
-0.0560902692,
-0.0407065228,
0.029755326,
0.0124304891,
0.0030497671,
0.0721039921,
0.0127759082,
0.0319929346,
-0.0054619676,
-0.0042540249,
-0.0213882867,
-0.0052365526,
-0.0081768921,
0.0000817359,
0.0573728196,
-0.0499964356,
0.0350033268,
-0.0219252408,
-0.0460951366,
-0.0208855718,
-0.0247743819,
-0.0282862876,
-0.0364319012,
-0.0540472344,
-0.0198403653,
0.0086507183,
0.0252656378,
0.0274403412,
0.050802663,
-0.0017732813,
-0.0089257248,
-0.0422091149,
0.0284482632,
0.0443265997,
-0.0077204849,
-0.0741742104,
-0.0440533198,
0.0153933587,
0.0344085656,
0.0249608941,
-0.0089215981,
-0.0470160805,
0.0340804048,
0.0223732889,
0.0714452788,
-0.0155857941,
0.0395394489,
0.0537537821,
-0.0296192728,
-0.0389489569,
0.068597436,
0.0110894069,
-0.036572054,
-0.0235898197,
0.0276741926,
0.0372373462,
0.032603506,
0.009793709,
-0.0895649418,
-0.0545086488,
-0.0135551523,
-0.040623989,
0.065816924,
0.0086814938,
-0.0369211361,
-0.0891326964,
0.0181422606,
0.0104231602,
-0.0178303476,
-0.0294110067,
0.0278192218,
-0.005839901,
0.0344321132,
-0.0230234507,
-0.0034820437,
-0.003047769,
-0.0048435251,
0.0020719054,
0.0715951845,
-0.03758616,
-0.0119080683,
-0.0150855249,
-0.0057130395,
0.0446324423,
0.0176648572,
-0.0033593003,
-0.0609275699,
0.0441339388,
0.0160687231,
-0.0021379327,
-0.0152481766,
0.0346505903,
-0.021923922,
-0.0436569415,
0.0216805451,
0.0295979939,
-0.0059620771,
-0.0272867698,
-0.0329550207,
0.0061393315,
-0.0280107837,
0.005813472,
0.0064846012,
0.012287722,
0.0476393476,
0.0212648474,
0.0278113484,
-0.0617809854,
-0.0378170833,
-0.0385133848,
0.0159408171,
-0.059276823,
-0.0422754474,
0.0001615403,
-0.0061809397,
-0.0010088674,
-0.0612930022,
-0.0155274244,
0.0294163208,
0.0737971365,
-0.0043482161,
-0.0198804457,
-0.007959526,
0.019810142,
-0.0368172675,
0.0580540672,
-0.0271774344,
0.0423074588,
-0.0541993752,
0.0008492692,
0.0223995615,
-0.0598746538,
-0.0095752953,
0.0186815541,
-0.0686387122,
-0.0516949855,
-0.0400183089,
0.0693842545,
0.0124733755,
0.0402358659,
0.0063634533,
-0.0518164746,
0.0422119759,
0.0255127046,
-0.0140220812,
0.0172991529,
0.0168117099,
-0.0037639935,
-0.0022759573,
0.0199810844,
-0.0386901982,
0.0413680747,
0.0205137841,
0.0110381003,
-0.0205388162,
-0.0489111468,
0.0105181774,
-0.0372419544,
0.0359148122,
-0.026400065,
0.0154957408,
-0.0515014604,
-0.004322784,
-0.0265943203,
-0.0183263887,
-0.1060113609,
-0.000262577,
-0.0112054897,
0.0180345308,
-0.0048478716,
-0.0139654893,
0.0067761885,
0.0740794763,
-0.0164697785,
-0.0105679575,
0.0088535855,
0.0105876634,
0.0279987324,
0.0229620822,
0.0046291058,
0.0309622362,
-0.0385854803,
0.0173736755,
-0.0240207631,
0.0719905123,
0.0245448407,
-0.0324018188,
-0.0403778218,
0.0473630689,
-0.0100798681,
0.0067331791,
-0.0512484498,
0.0250095278,
0.042706266,
0.0236432999,
0.0252538007,
-0.0175932087,
-0.0226014648,
-0.0102316914,
0.0668218881,
0.0182742309,
-0.0746689588,
0.0436825193,
0.0084256884,
-0.0074746958,
-0.0052306657,
0.0522101223,
0.019769378,
0.0170945972,
-0.0053966506,
0.0179276001,
-0.0292569306,
-0.0166407321,
0.0136653641,
0.0151656717,
0.0087565323,
0.035999313,
0.0033883629,
-0.0693607405,
-0.0090269893,
0.0468362682,
-0.0423628613,
0.0216235016,
0.0567310415,
0.0380169004,
0.0186007563,
0.0372763388,
-0.0165528283,
0.0065840776,
0.0070118811,
-0.0172321163,
-0.0371795297,
-5.467917767e-33,
-0.0705529377,
-0.0461213849,
0.0526489057,
-0.0141662732,
-0.0242662337,
0.0271955878,
-0.0371917374,
0.0296955556,
0.0126988096,
0.0023251476,
0.0082027884,
-0.0007245434,
0.0055901562,
0.061185196,
-0.0373629592,
0.019788079,
0.0354696959,
-0.0205255672,
0.0002694765,
0.0199793279,
0.0249435473,
0.0221442971,
0.0332313813,
-0.0526342131,
-0.0195443872,
0.0022143708,
-0.0519980378,
0.0273114573,
0.0273091383,
0.0433214717,
-0.0378750376,
0.0126108266,
-0.001116653,
-0.0116075613,
-0.0250198785,
0.0708196387,
-0.0588464104,
0.0108482186,
0.0068060774,
0.0360771604,
-0.0628860667,
0.0066860132,
0.0333681032,
-0.0573758297,
0.0062809559,
-0.0021900346,
0.0281008556,
0.0116184829,
0.0010147693,
0.007236917,
-0.0813903362,
-0.0123096593,
0.0063353833,
-0.0558329076,
0.0362817384,
0.0274436995,
0.0276813414,
0.0166366547,
-0.0543040447,
0.0290344227,
-0.0277058966,
0.0168427546,
0.0596836135,
0.0676512495,
0.0065025357,
0.0611117631,
-0.0020058039,
-0.0274810139,
-0.0354175866,
-0.0054353857,
0.0563013367,
0.0395401828,
0.0053234501,
0.0736313313,
0.0051696328,
-0.0108399261,
-0.0329199545,
0.0088602034,
-0.0333500765,
0.0056275013,
0.003377876,
0.0280177854,
0.0182387698,
-0.0040676598,
-0.0507965237,
-0.0178932119,
-0.0390097238,
-0.0320325531,
0.0560849644,
0.0559451431,
0.0011438115,
0.007366477,
0.0937476158,
-0.0067744697,
-0.0439982414,
0.0205779765,
-0.031528946,
0.056870237,
-0.0130924722,
0.0255787857,
-0.0246439259,
-0.0366892293,
0.0680590123,
0.0070875352,
0.0003129969,
0.0167617276,
0.0444053039,
0.0308443084,
-0.0486471429,
-0.0055299615,
-0.0490421914,
0.0139634693,
0.0255458169,
0.0633495152,
0.0276812036,
0.0140071847,
-0.0732052475,
0.0266295299,
-0.033898402,
-0.0439645797,
-0.0125856418,
-0.080515489,
-0.0035731629,
0.0353584327,
-0.0568001419,
0.0214441288,
-0.0467801616,
-0.0112558221,
0.0557351075,
-0.0569464155,
-0.0183380283,
0.0439955443,
2.411e-7,
0.0253151879,
-0.0184196271,
0.0088145938,
0.0101222005,
0.0189460963,
0.0399498343,
-0.0277628768,
0.0295216944,
-0.0041757165,
-0.0438309386,
-0.0245479736,
0.0460653491,
0.0410485417,
-0.0140151503,
-0.0317595527,
0.0164249204,
-0.0446091481,
0.0043303049,
-0.0500813313,
-0.023272926,
0.0166799612,
0.0648088157,
-0.0272554904,
-0.0062436005,
0.046140451,
-0.0361755043,
0.095609121,
-0.0137505746,
0.0011664164,
-0.0442865789,
-0.0093009798,
0.0096787242,
-0.0352732912,
-0.007986038,
-0.0141735971,
-0.0220746323,
0.0584636591,
0.0361214876,
-0.043274425,
-0.0417119972,
-0.0238643494,
0.0113434168,
-0.0447373092,
-0.0204700436,
0.0557275601,
-0.0333365016,
0.0106729828,
-0.0357250571,
0.0015187965,
-0.010295786,
0.005430493,
-0.038285125,
-0.0701785088,
0.0219938233,
0.0691853687,
-0.0147953853,
-0.0190192461,
-0.0744854212,
-0.0589878745,
-0.0245628152,
-0.0432198942,
-0.0014395808,
-0.0891647115,
-0.0277904179,
0.0100397719,
-0.0195473656,
-0.0281678606,
1.897135499e-34,
-0.0062785195,
0.0053294981,
0.0313373208,
0.010456671,
0.0114738876,
0.0163285993,
0.0071607232,
0.0023432735,
-0.0052807471,
-0.0583260395,
-0.0250705369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13826v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13826v2 | Attend-and-Excite: Attention-Based Semantic Guidance for Text-to-Image Diffusion Models | 2023-01-31T18:10:38 | 2023-05-31T15:42:00 | Hila Chefer, Yuval Alaluf, Yael Vinker, Lior Wolf, Daniel Cohen-Or | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | Recent text-to-image generative models have demonstrated an unparalleled
ability to generate diverse and creative imagery guided by a target text
prompt. While revolutionary, current state-of-the-art diffusion models may
still fail in generating images that fully convey the semantics in the given
text prompt. We analyze the publicly available Stable Diffusion model and
assess the existence of catastrophic neglect, where the model fails to generate
one or more of the subjects from the input prompt. Moreover, we find that in
some cases the model also fails to correctly bind attributes (e.g., colors) to
their corresponding subjects. To help mitigate these failure cases, we
introduce the concept of Generative Semantic Nursing (GSN), where we seek to
intervene in the generative process on the fly during inference time to improve
the faithfulness of the generated images. Using an attention-based formulation
of GSN, dubbed Attend-and-Excite, we guide the model to refine the
cross-attention units to attend to all subject tokens in the text prompt and
strengthen - or excite - their activations, encouraging the model to generate
all subjects described in the text prompt. We compare our approach to
alternative approaches and demonstrate that it conveys the desired concepts
more faithfully across a range of text prompts. | [
0.0153023461,
0.0557809211,
0.0014102483,
0.0049782479,
-0.0024892716,
0.0092350235,
0.0326334164,
0.0064752395,
-0.0126666781,
-0.0005877232,
0.0117551638,
-0.0569163412,
-0.0025256106,
0.0326473601,
0.0417963788,
-0.0956140906,
0.015124877,
0.0050524236,
-0.0445180945,
-0.0105164507,
-0.0143251065,
0.009489635,
0.0085369423,
0.0174091477,
-0.0521262474,
-0.0347609408,
-0.0076646744,
0.0187216792,
0.0325130299,
-0.0315560326,
-0.0328898802,
0.0448878966,
0.0068084043,
-0.0305036213,
0.0000023769,
-0.0148919113,
0.0163587537,
-0.0027282985,
0.0426742397,
-0.0421042629,
0.097246781,
-0.0250337888,
-0.0120391222,
-0.0298074987,
-0.0102251973,
0.0433650278,
0.0785573199,
0.0686451197,
0.0777310207,
0.0300712194,
-0.0219536889,
-0.0031272485,
-0.014039373,
-0.0495244153,
0.0699533746,
-0.0260890462,
0.0240784436,
-0.0229542498,
0.0150745595,
-0.0011352999,
-0.0780581757,
0.0712590069,
0.0336625092,
0.0152364559,
0.0725952312,
0.0787692741,
0.0457690917,
-0.031679973,
-0.026309099,
0.0501249135,
-0.0426745042,
0.0229918268,
0.0057616998,
-0.0210424624,
-0.0088119721,
0.0321056843,
-0.0290971622,
-0.0129444906,
0.0078873252,
0.0255534612,
-0.0414893664,
0.0285323709,
0.0138861528,
-0.0150132924,
0.0278648734,
-0.0517429598,
0.0339887366,
0.0063167233,
-0.0102781374,
0.0312515274,
-0.0301533751,
-0.0810070783,
0.0562397987,
0.0179991759,
0.0254861321,
0.0351920016,
-0.0464942604,
-0.0553986207,
0.0223336797,
-0.0185396522,
0.0337495171,
0.0020115634,
-0.0490643382,
0.0517717078,
-0.0065138624,
-0.0238010492,
-0.0422642641,
-0.0014755091,
-0.0566365384,
0.0319199339,
0.0071145101,
-0.0188751798,
-0.0629368871,
-0.0249226708,
-0.0476811677,
-0.0446516573,
-0.0418856964,
-0.0129579417,
-0.0089032194,
-0.0201119203,
0.0227624532,
0.0768779069,
-0.0855094045,
-0.01381189,
-0.044642359,
0.0083540706,
-0.0210418142,
0.004898102,
0.0172492713,
0.0055453894,
-0.0337279849,
0.0065112258,
0.0262709763,
-0.0209167115,
-0.0207751151,
0.0724581555,
-0.0333593935,
-0.0130663076,
-0.0283110682,
-0.0211305171,
-0.0201886222,
-0.030942956,
0.0605302267,
-0.0441880859,
0.0341043994,
-0.0271626655,
0.0081581995,
-0.0742710382,
0.0223431792,
0.0193887744,
-0.035504397,
0.0412306264,
-0.0104427971,
-0.0096146129,
0.0094573488,
0.0264538787,
0.0045450632,
0.0298854224,
0.051114887,
0.0554766208,
-0.0526979119,
-0.0197226387,
0.0102031818,
-0.0006260728,
0.059062466,
0.0229090806,
0.0075106318,
-0.0208484326,
-0.0007077128,
0.060796909,
0.0438801646,
0.0661439225,
-0.0248521231,
-0.0256610885,
0.0720455572,
0.0531709716,
-0.0176188163,
0.0194369815,
0.0646872967,
-0.0194434747,
-0.0613967329,
0.0069930889,
-0.012640384,
0.0604229979,
0.0512866788,
-0.0081692496,
0.0329016969,
0.032630112,
-0.0385545939,
-0.0377279259,
0.0201845132,
-0.0223856755,
0.0054107644,
-0.0084728897,
0.0298645291,
0.062069606,
-0.0620324127,
0.0058172382,
0.0187602732,
-0.0548216812,
0.0161819216,
-0.0440642983,
0.0202860683,
0.0920654088,
0.0134453475,
0.0172162727,
0.0042015016,
-0.0158888735,
0.0716265142,
0.0687532723,
-0.0297750439,
0.0630521774,
0.0086669037,
-0.0244293418,
-0.0007454198,
-0.0033277073,
0.0033107414,
0.028838953,
-0.0596043803,
0.03103921,
-0.0239965003,
0.016685484,
-0.0350800753,
0.0448952168,
-0.0102185775,
-0.0208281875,
-0.0117755979,
0.0021125434,
-0.0015465542,
-0.0018635704,
-0.0057998067,
0.0163930301,
0.0024470123,
-0.0258102044,
-0.0125833573,
0.0158910006,
-0.055015903,
-0.0310223382,
-0.0518018715,
-0.0848280191,
-0.0481890105,
-0.04635242,
-0.0098466035,
-0.0220775921,
0.0391116589,
-0.0423919484,
0.0267828982,
-0.0262430217,
-0.0194737073,
0.0468905158,
0.0092501752,
0.0001698247,
0.0752107576,
-0.0549892597,
-0.0130957561,
-0.0156168593,
0.0434969626,
-0.054427065,
-0.037603993,
0.007793651,
-0.0439346842,
0.0242767427,
0.0100432541,
-0.033615727,
0.0179086775,
-0.068736352,
-0.0243244767,
-0.0349428393,
-0.0097639551,
-0.000894112,
-0.0475647561,
0.0076690898,
0.0154371681,
-0.0075597609,
0.0069064,
-0.0233681276,
0.0335226767,
-0.0172799174,
0.0031358053,
0.0172328632,
-0.0169798881,
0.0158329271,
-0.0298294034,
0.0035643026,
0.0140478592,
0.0477180034,
0.0545749553,
-0.0213041976,
-0.0390761681,
0.0392723233,
-0.0220937729,
-0.004563503,
-0.0129266316,
-0.003501948,
0.0026337446,
-0.0033681497,
0.056937322,
0.086498566,
0.0183638893,
0.0139605505,
0.0118457321,
-0.0326629803,
-0.0239681751,
0.0251697041,
-0.0412900858,
0.0078270631,
0.0488863587,
-0.0402324907,
0.015089401,
0.069998838,
0.0310890619,
-0.0029365963,
-0.071306318,
0.0391082391,
-0.0038883875,
-0.044562947,
-0.0320984498,
0.014141174,
-0.011925322,
-0.0227890518,
-0.0548715107,
-0.0558614619,
0.0662812665,
-0.000322051,
-0.0011718032,
-0.0357855186,
0.0253928993,
0.0206524637,
-0.0026308708,
-0.0054428363,
0.0345335044,
0.0454166904,
0.0218850039,
-0.0206103586,
0.0171964727,
-0.0300056674,
-0.0117348349,
0.0530555062,
0.0002963655,
-0.0060948986,
0.0026900005,
0.0014563388,
-0.0406170338,
-0.0351943746,
0.0162175689,
-0.0358906761,
-0.0156291686,
0.0430006608,
-0.0128590697,
0.0155782076,
0.0072399145,
-0.0151816597,
0.0071034217,
-0.0283634458,
-0.0127371214,
0.0096406853,
0.0468377173,
-0.0311576761,
-0.0392109938,
-0.0703803226,
-0.0212961119,
0.0646321923,
-0.0340513848,
-0.0151514644,
-0.0376641154,
0.0353717506,
-0.0130183594,
0.0527639501,
0.0090311458,
0.0250896793,
0.1059585512,
-0.0596147925,
-0.0291647594,
0.0359276794,
0.0141257914,
-0.0269774999,
0.0110830907,
0.0101524144,
0.0344545655,
-0.0250546709,
0.0028367385,
-0.0485600978,
-0.0213558692,
-0.0278153457,
0.0012580884,
0.0103099495,
-0.0121887457,
-0.0089164404,
-0.0460598432,
0.0735923126,
0.0165743753,
-0.0265808236,
0.0205676965,
-0.0040864735,
0.0334856361,
0.0325905308,
-0.0000036907,
-0.024778612,
0.0193924885,
0.0026172281,
0.0004992774,
0.1023556441,
-0.0337349698,
-0.0130084669,
-0.0207261816,
0.0001611515,
0.0836885348,
0.0229161177,
0.0295002051,
-0.1008605883,
-0.0032482538,
0.0116204238,
0.0282002091,
-0.0030201694,
0.0671627671,
0.0045529944,
0.0071863751,
-0.0265406463,
0.0508500487,
-0.012025821,
-0.0357941501,
-0.001368667,
0.0582377277,
-0.0088084154,
-0.0589125194,
-0.0823484585,
0.0340171605,
0.0518017858,
0.0433723293,
0.0494025946,
-0.0724538863,
-0.0420597494,
-0.0381811596,
0.0653226376,
-0.041293662,
-0.0629595891,
-0.0088172788,
-0.0442845821,
-0.0614304505,
-0.0712855831,
-0.0288468655,
0.0209614336,
0.0389435105,
-0.005262698,
-0.0311170481,
0.005718187,
-0.0288689081,
-0.0075272173,
0.07257846,
-0.0201221835,
-0.0102813961,
-0.0029266719,
-0.0517553873,
0.0063916538,
-0.0332499743,
-0.0187198967,
0.0346432105,
-0.0878443047,
-0.0118920496,
0.0181568395,
0.0540924929,
0.0165881552,
0.0005777332,
-0.0161631424,
-0.0458465405,
0.0585286804,
0.0640130937,
0.0221557356,
0.0247924216,
-0.039535895,
0.0172658712,
0.0128846308,
0.0005422571,
-0.0260805245,
0.075093098,
0.0272920337,
0.0315092131,
0.0089013567,
0.0582664274,
0.0004875564,
-0.0653761402,
0.0295564402,
-0.0363618173,
0.0173044708,
-0.0321999379,
-0.0121911047,
0.0037334689,
-0.0009303451,
-0.0577926151,
-0.0108845374,
0.0202012677,
0.0244413726,
-0.0080727199,
-0.0332931168,
0.0022999085,
-0.0024792789,
-0.0518630482,
-0.023182556,
0.0335284621,
0.0150544494,
0.0115450602,
0.0160878915,
-0.0104019074,
0.0122621693,
-0.0546915419,
0.0306423474,
0.0158163533,
0.048637066,
0.0142139941,
-0.0312950462,
-0.0328427479,
0.034315262,
-0.0298737697,
-0.0111930752,
-0.0305901859,
0.0482070073,
0.0437689498,
-0.0045969184,
0.0305403639,
-0.013686101,
0.001743335,
0.0077821314,
0.0090169813,
0.0098206904,
-0.0378643572,
0.0311076175,
0.0039918739,
0.0406822748,
-0.0436652564,
0.0408612564,
-0.0647588074,
0.0382539891,
-0.0095522935,
-0.0119711868,
-0.0212219581,
-0.0095672766,
-0.0067941961,
-0.0258464888,
0.0266833343,
0.042820897,
-0.0530367307,
-0.0772837251,
0.0303804688,
0.0109794913,
-0.0124387452,
0.0100536728,
0.073608987,
0.011271554,
-0.0208914801,
-0.0302030928,
0.0081909094,
0.0339128524,
-0.0097330827,
-0.0323263891,
-0.0073580197,
-6.619296117e-33,
-0.0456821918,
-0.0203103796,
0.0181943905,
-0.0147621538,
-0.0301111918,
-0.0138304653,
-0.0665915236,
-0.0143689616,
0.0426809192,
0.0444176421,
0.003899494,
0.0039439709,
0.0011884733,
0.0463246815,
-0.0112782735,
0.0016187575,
0.0362578146,
0.0111871548,
-0.0328652225,
0.0408081189,
0.0167153385,
0.0150365839,
0.0443967991,
-0.0558944643,
0.0013904334,
0.0066673225,
0.0051487144,
-0.0255918466,
0.0335393734,
0.0285550375,
-0.039597515,
0.0311465263,
0.0179345757,
0.0005311948,
-0.0561415032,
0.0341133662,
-0.0402950048,
-0.0426915959,
-0.0087513551,
-0.0634043589,
-0.1503343731,
-0.0481360592,
0.0750442073,
0.004096467,
-0.0114753004,
-0.0174455866,
0.0611565262,
-0.0238189325,
0.0024900991,
0.0115974424,
-0.050540179,
-0.0015378516,
-0.0145578114,
-0.0188277289,
-0.0225213617,
-0.0067377216,
0.0074734595,
0.026625013,
-0.063996844,
0.0207947064,
0.0217362586,
-0.0043424079,
0.0418434963,
0.029884886,
0.0151496977,
0.0337719694,
0.027772218,
0.032629922,
-0.0372011214,
0.0331116468,
-0.0147936409,
0.0372196101,
0.0541139841,
0.0284853838,
0.0293195639,
0.000204241,
-0.0355633311,
0.0200770926,
-0.1088685691,
0.0279021356,
0.0508447476,
0.0081985202,
-0.0013713634,
-0.0037535005,
-0.0182363931,
-0.0199925136,
-0.0239353683,
-0.0390554816,
0.0223768372,
0.0069725201,
-0.0207608677,
0.0181416441,
0.0158753805,
0.034322653,
0.0032085611,
-0.042033311,
0.0191055536,
0.0319815688,
0.0045062872,
-0.0099188583,
-0.0204731617,
-0.0129193431,
0.0554002374,
0.0426026881,
0.0148011446,
0.0175796244,
0.0016020923,
-0.0406184942,
-0.035110034,
-0.0213369224,
-0.0362175889,
0.0238546636,
0.0101525662,
-0.0561573729,
0.0299147088,
-0.0029920854,
-0.0462353639,
0.0304799341,
0.0193466023,
-0.0014420957,
-0.0280587673,
-0.0010387845,
-0.0131964004,
0.0037018021,
-0.0546830036,
0.0209047385,
-0.0406848863,
0.0248326436,
0.0825151652,
-0.0933485329,
-0.036253836,
0.0468894877,
3.055e-7,
0.0461989455,
0.0055183279,
0.0095107798,
0.026614422,
0.0172811486,
0.0008004158,
-0.0208606068,
0.0619179569,
0.0342861712,
-0.0649747103,
0.000657213,
0.0505247451,
0.0220970474,
0.0035814054,
-0.0566938035,
0.0067162612,
-0.0136562968,
0.0499612466,
-0.0165784806,
-0.0218059849,
0.0537036844,
0.0383530185,
-0.0000237383,
-0.0023154507,
0.041803807,
-0.0047974992,
0.0969975144,
-0.0264561046,
0.0299259629,
-0.0168612115,
-0.0340877436,
-0.0241373684,
-0.0099186851,
-0.005009769,
-0.0127194393,
-0.0134573774,
0.0616007298,
0.0382496119,
-0.0495982878,
-0.016634535,
-0.0074071581,
0.0299049392,
0.0126497522,
-0.03001469,
0.0595134981,
-0.0936824083,
-0.0181022473,
0.0058774925,
-0.021810744,
0.0218392741,
0.0503559932,
-0.0107123833,
-0.0584143363,
-0.0069517614,
0.0196916331,
0.0270318221,
-0.0264108032,
-0.0613962188,
-0.0138877118,
-0.0176348761,
-0.0412387922,
-0.0531356931,
-0.0452404618,
0.0274314843,
-0.0157834496,
-0.0412668325,
-0.0536998548,
2.492026213e-34,
0.0156332683,
-0.0212510489,
0.0390508845,
-0.0101426644,
0.0069125001,
0.0004351544,
-0.001261516,
-0.001491274,
0.041749239,
-0.0627360791,
-0.0327210948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13816v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13816v4 | Execution-based Code Generation using Deep Reinforcement Learning | 2023-01-31T18:02:26 | 2023-07-19T19:55:31 | Parshin Shojaee, Aneesh Jain, Sindhu Tipirneni, Chandan K. Reddy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL | The utilization of programming language (PL) models, pre-trained on
large-scale code corpora, as a means of automating software engineering
processes has demonstrated considerable potential in streamlining various code
generation tasks such as code completion, code translation, and program
synthesis. However, current approaches mainly rely on supervised fine-tuning
objectives borrowed from text generation, neglecting unique sequence-level
characteristics of code, including but not limited to compilability as well as
syntactic and functional correctness. To address this limitation, we propose
PPOCoder, a new framework for code generation that synergistically combines
pre-trained PL models with Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) which is a widely
used deep reinforcement learning technique. By utilizing non-differentiable
feedback from code execution and structure alignment, PPOCoder seamlessly
integrates external code-specific knowledge into the model optimization
process. It's important to note that PPOCoder is a task-agnostic and
model-agnostic framework that can be used across different code generation
tasks and PLs. Extensive experiments on three code generation tasks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our proposed approach compared to SOTA methods, achieving
significant improvements in compilation success rates and functional
correctness across different PLs. | [
-0.0086332774,
0.0613998137,
-0.0018757009,
-0.0170543101,
0.0030741773,
-0.0067026573,
-0.0380383097,
-0.0142709129,
-0.0339719206,
0.0548017919,
-0.0187806971,
-0.0025308572,
0.0010004147,
0.0596642531,
0.0322224423,
-0.0428614467,
0.0094071385,
-0.0309880525,
0.0199619401,
-0.0098540941,
0.0067994962,
0.0010712636,
0.0020160491,
0.058400549,
0.0313730277,
-0.0132925631,
-0.0139835486,
0.0624828078,
0.0289541669,
-0.0341507457,
0.058877863,
0.0267258994,
0.0190501511,
-0.0178888235,
0.0000022524,
-0.0272677895,
0.0153882839,
0.0010077977,
0.0467403866,
0.0107512232,
-0.0029298472,
0.0096045909,
-0.0106725553,
0.0260202382,
-0.0148054594,
-0.0301634707,
0.0677658394,
0.0000948545,
0.0630554557,
0.0590661317,
0.0246676356,
-0.0188283455,
0.0129715428,
-0.0351022854,
0.0399816856,
-0.0160009712,
-0.0103694135,
0.012042203,
-0.0045737759,
-0.0405892283,
-0.0219461843,
-0.0058157216,
0.0463729426,
0.0041041542,
-0.023912888,
0.0510977507,
0.016925795,
-0.055469811,
-0.016387172,
0.0536598079,
-0.1041050479,
-0.0208957717,
0.031523291,
-0.0408051684,
-0.01926779,
-0.072850883,
0.0332019553,
0.0155118704,
-0.0011682903,
0.0148407556,
0.0270892177,
-0.0198902842,
0.0107647032,
0.0041889884,
-0.0447856039,
0.034372177,
0.0068081603,
-0.013060756,
-0.0099941622,
0.0083058225,
0.0088324407,
-0.020703258,
-0.0117907496,
0.0234633815,
-0.0694383532,
-0.0107865511,
-0.0669600368,
-0.0006426203,
-0.0124151884,
-0.0156217506,
0.0403119475,
0.0776694119,
0.0189099554,
-0.0053343945,
-0.0380917825,
0.0779974684,
-0.054655008,
-0.0196294151,
-0.0101944003,
0.0385430939,
-0.04956159,
0.0272944365,
-0.0001300419,
0.0778878331,
-0.0460579395,
0.0139032565,
-0.0524747707,
0.0321834981,
-0.0176426321,
0.0760349631,
-0.0132920817,
0.0338760838,
-0.0754320696,
-0.0032153048,
-0.0038302306,
0.0111104706,
-0.047500208,
-0.0422477424,
-0.0152662499,
-0.0294475555,
-0.001217777,
0.0371319652,
-0.0217551701,
-0.0257143397,
0.0364182144,
0.0906218067,
-0.050545644,
0.0437737405,
-0.0224206876,
-0.0505118519,
0.0303853452,
-0.046370782,
-0.0020276874,
-0.0883271247,
-0.0224473365,
-0.0121845929,
-0.0332020819,
-0.0743551105,
0.028135052,
-0.0183753781,
0.0225551426,
0.0297765955,
-0.0149017526,
-0.0176969841,
0.0054453476,
0.00462658,
-0.0197956301,
0.0483014807,
0.058779642,
0.035294801,
-0.0422717333,
-0.0306445044,
0.000306051,
0.0303848181,
0.0195932724,
0.0038099876,
0.0065690624,
0.0212869961,
0.0037099749,
-0.0158463642,
0.0511162318,
0.0034927989,
0.0045907493,
0.0460003614,
-0.0205888655,
0.0022542083,
-0.0015431731,
0.0488053076,
0.0600401461,
0.0259809121,
-0.0415564254,
-0.0190853123,
-0.0434525609,
0.0685615838,
0.0214423686,
0.034650024,
0.0022987246,
0.0593874902,
-0.0263516214,
-0.0654276833,
0.0611407943,
-0.0392433628,
-0.0255436208,
0.0304376036,
0.0011189304,
-0.0064062444,
-0.0660690069,
-0.0121481912,
-0.0015223195,
-0.0399133787,
-0.0114779649,
-0.0051317844,
0.0170935765,
0.0331743993,
-0.0030483273,
-0.0600792691,
-0.0231243819,
-0.0098257102,
-0.0208912585,
0.0044935513,
0.0021000605,
-0.0111910189,
0.0263380483,
-0.0509022735,
-0.0345028453,
-0.0294029154,
-0.0142708616,
0.0557173155,
0.0357859358,
-0.0140183326,
0.0332571864,
0.0324372649,
-0.0498842113,
0.0369305313,
-0.0274052396,
-0.042297598,
0.060685996,
0.0029590211,
0.0345416032,
-0.0409934036,
-0.0481729209,
0.0052583637,
0.0217490625,
-0.0301815309,
0.0140102506,
-0.0336534008,
-0.0600813217,
-0.0452495217,
0.0284461509,
-0.0571472347,
-0.0064379633,
0.0216287896,
-0.0560191832,
-0.0363369547,
0.0455981977,
-0.0118132802,
0.0070015681,
0.0246977918,
-0.0035469083,
0.0038765797,
0.0059376694,
-0.0266778953,
0.0366707444,
0.0057130088,
0.0167188719,
0.0390176028,
0.0820514485,
0.0136943059,
-0.0026651449,
0.0089060236,
-0.0153665245,
-0.0558023378,
0.0254367143,
0.0640102848,
0.0862369537,
-0.0116786165,
-0.0489712432,
-0.0178070739,
0.0804420784,
-0.0384825617,
0.0174187534,
0.0297840592,
0.048841279,
-0.0031712644,
-0.0529503264,
-0.034406811,
0.0208568536,
-0.0047094626,
-0.0175399315,
0.0143546658,
-0.009518709,
-0.0378838703,
-0.0455520339,
-0.0196707454,
0.0077799261,
-0.0070884256,
-0.0428157449,
0.0187015962,
-0.0381156653,
0.0584489517,
-0.010176952,
0.0420133322,
-0.0021305529,
-0.0531050712,
0.0107232034,
-0.0419627391,
0.0578801446,
0.061762739,
-0.0180987976,
0.0136009306,
0.0232627783,
0.0320126526,
-0.0880229548,
0.0472928211,
-0.0277703181,
-0.053798724,
-0.0281356275,
-0.0237845797,
0.0252184104,
0.0608860217,
0.018015299,
-0.0069670998,
-0.0805867389,
-0.0026271064,
0.0372533537,
-0.0455775075,
0.0437040068,
0.027056152,
-0.0321065187,
0.0281728525,
-0.053874094,
-0.0736690238,
0.0715511441,
0.0130407494,
-0.0233745668,
-0.0262668524,
-0.0292219725,
-0.0210134182,
0.0077514295,
0.0309220999,
0.0218904149,
-0.0722262189,
-0.0726797879,
-0.0595055744,
-0.0056984532,
-0.006315934,
-0.0152770886,
0.0354533456,
-0.0305250194,
0.0096175224,
-0.0073786532,
-0.0482238643,
-0.051352039,
-0.0000479088,
0.0073301122,
0.0093119722,
0.016106857,
-0.0209957883,
0.0539033562,
-0.0196331255,
0.0243844893,
0.0330955014,
0.0248859636,
-0.0390061066,
-0.0457654409,
-0.0562726259,
-0.0022228737,
-0.0432769731,
-0.0453988239,
-0.0152960485,
-0.0394939631,
-0.0186755806,
0.0337042175,
0.0032488033,
-0.0672608837,
0.0274347849,
0.0286072902,
-0.0215694793,
-0.0099352896,
0.0791435987,
0.0464591607,
-0.0534391068,
-0.0434660539,
0.0681006163,
0.0223665964,
-0.0352074318,
0.004944725,
0.0233774744,
0.1066471562,
0.0640016347,
0.0470486805,
-0.058967229,
-0.040979702,
-0.0222720709,
0.0764458999,
0.0146865025,
0.0028729222,
-0.0153332772,
-0.0896079466,
-0.0230929982,
-0.0055770548,
-0.0190112703,
-0.0474989675,
-0.0102600614,
-0.015202417,
-0.0073744855,
-0.0543173961,
0.0467034504,
0.0192157477,
0.0234988313,
0.0067140972,
-0.015353865,
-0.0044497191,
0.0149672125,
-0.0502638929,
0.0042573209,
0.1573431492,
-0.0106180012,
-0.00203232,
0.0093914233,
0.0036539969,
-0.0014497599,
-0.0210394934,
-0.0197562408,
-0.0109730205,
0.0104690837,
-0.0173393581,
0.028297089,
0.0470909066,
-0.0544891432,
-0.0117137367,
0.041889783,
0.038028717,
0.0063075027,
-0.0347734392,
0.0002581011,
-0.0016911941,
0.0437925085,
-0.0081647672,
0.005070217,
-0.0246113874,
-0.0569216534,
-0.0681608096,
-0.0000953198,
-0.1065208986,
0.0326995291,
-0.0565633327,
0.0140266418,
0.0050860527,
-0.0106346235,
0.0178973787,
-0.0038350306,
0.0335191004,
0.0239340663,
-0.0627885982,
0.0381335244,
-0.0134582063,
-0.085357599,
-0.0258193333,
0.006027482,
0.0012240697,
-0.0166841913,
-0.0103187989,
0.0030015707,
-0.0181898661,
-0.0015608754,
-0.0103154061,
-0.0526954532,
-0.053971082,
-0.0491107702,
0.0899501219,
0.0007890797,
0.0423155352,
-0.0261337589,
-0.0496735126,
0.0402512886,
0.0424762815,
-0.0264164973,
-0.0078971013,
0.0352789387,
-0.0312137492,
0.0262130294,
-0.0060663526,
-0.0684001669,
-0.0142400293,
0.0295395255,
-0.0034742872,
0.038484104,
-0.0045018401,
0.0247730948,
-0.0124542015,
-0.0150831109,
-0.0035270671,
-0.0377205797,
0.0012242328,
-0.015959762,
0.0440966263,
-0.0110590821,
-0.0267548636,
0.0140213817,
0.0338064693,
0.0026914638,
0.057093285,
0.0324592739,
0.0204986874,
0.0472673066,
0.0381071791,
0.0414312407,
0.0164663345,
0.0561478846,
0.0855907276,
0.0124287521,
-0.005838403,
0.0521711819,
0.0086009167,
0.0343980417,
-0.033065632,
0.0196875911,
0.0405910574,
0.0693314821,
0.0225486811,
-0.0094650174,
-0.0296511892,
-0.0483580828,
-0.0174862985,
-0.0094320904,
0.0536890067,
0.0342930444,
0.001541056,
-0.0408679955,
0.0143079413,
0.0020701089,
0.0548431575,
-0.0531925149,
-0.0141654629,
0.0029949055,
0.0200723186,
0.0206779111,
-0.0403887331,
0.1048087925,
0.0223716013,
-0.0009228569,
-0.0217783041,
0.0223365258,
-0.0301877558,
-0.0141007146,
0.0251081735,
0.0287323985,
-0.0190766416,
-0.0292336512,
0.0469498932,
-0.0355952233,
-0.0182369351,
0.0494386367,
0.0086678192,
0.0051631588,
0.0530878752,
0.0485725626,
-0.0318012051,
0.011325432,
-0.014346689,
0.0199399516,
0.01523754,
-0.0272256248,
-0.0413819961,
-6.318093322e-33,
-0.0183110777,
-0.0350290872,
0.009558904,
0.0053466223,
-0.0246274509,
-0.042550195,
-0.0503682382,
-0.007903154,
0.0217692629,
-0.021176748,
0.0340001807,
0.0212173201,
-0.0093748877,
0.0231663547,
0.04565138,
0.0129277064,
0.0653163567,
0.0199059695,
-0.056701865,
0.0451544188,
-0.0452269204,
0.0351395756,
-0.0122759668,
-0.0265839584,
-0.0141284838,
0.0292278267,
0.0233393889,
0.0072691021,
0.0208443757,
0.026688464,
0.0358964875,
-0.0092198849,
-0.0242258254,
-0.0094891284,
-0.0481013879,
0.0084538301,
-0.0459003337,
-0.0837469399,
0.0097085591,
-0.0104688685,
-0.0371231697,
-0.0713715926,
0.0751233026,
0.0087498361,
-0.0382921696,
0.0083183469,
0.0260347351,
0.0216593575,
0.0161069892,
-0.0414497256,
-0.078137897,
-0.0004128621,
-0.0353754908,
0.0028428456,
0.0153122284,
-0.0348896869,
-0.013492832,
0.0437337384,
0.0017371449,
-0.0091502406,
-0.0018975729,
0.0806480274,
0.0839895383,
0.0715791285,
0.0223824196,
-0.0350079834,
0.0257466249,
0.0096352166,
-0.0327360146,
0.0155303646,
0.0481280386,
0.0376445539,
0.005257715,
0.0460473485,
0.0019249331,
-0.0012104288,
-0.0487040579,
-0.0126554323,
-0.0186780114,
0.0206253696,
0.0154060144,
0.0185413733,
-0.0282248799,
-0.0130782137,
-0.0628058165,
-0.0111200614,
-0.0147257084,
-0.0455582924,
0.0159784406,
0.0262208413,
-0.0062251491,
0.0124323247,
0.0136610596,
-0.0155781219,
0.0103360442,
-0.0015321265,
-0.0493673235,
0.0012932721,
0.0005889591,
0.0286414847,
-0.046406623,
-0.045902621,
-0.0135270851,
-0.0377199911,
0.0538275503,
0.0319730528,
-0.0064225034,
0.0317563601,
-0.0577294715,
0.0267997924,
-0.05007153,
0.0217998549,
0.0194269251,
0.0390426517,
-0.0096203536,
-0.0053881751,
0.0077212704,
0.0746555179,
-0.0008394641,
-0.0253609754,
-0.0223508161,
-0.0247821268,
0.0213632379,
0.0425287336,
-0.0489624962,
-0.0032784808,
-0.0637339354,
0.0566624291,
-0.0197263788,
-0.037882179,
-0.0575896576,
0.022117896,
2.866e-7,
-0.0101636639,
0.0154994158,
0.02349733,
0.0687996,
-0.0177584887,
0.0574446246,
-0.0030609095,
0.0182314124,
-0.0160516743,
0.003321684,
0.0118243052,
0.0126256933,
0.0206598919,
0.0024157306,
-0.0440346152,
0.0440454409,
-0.0015624623,
0.0349466428,
-0.0582265519,
-0.0012033408,
0.0127058281,
0.0749609545,
-0.0060619349,
0.0124653475,
0.0507467464,
0.0262616426,
0.0233331602,
0.0118722543,
0.0102681611,
0.0168574341,
-0.0593026839,
0.0209985245,
-0.0301693678,
-0.016786037,
-0.0182618592,
0.0042664502,
-0.0189616363,
0.0512139499,
0.0102118347,
0.0033119835,
0.0334305279,
-0.0077449447,
0.017202165,
-0.0454129986,
0.0451165214,
-0.0436631404,
0.0201821439,
0.0311711524,
-0.0220415238,
0.0100387465,
0.0014051328,
-0.0552789941,
0.0049419706,
-0.0265251044,
0.0046638865,
0.006125872,
-0.0535150655,
0.0098188883,
-0.0241187681,
0.01816261,
0.0117708901,
-0.0236518439,
-0.0685652196,
0.0514233634,
0.0084518678,
-0.0185202546,
0.023024179,
2.860513386e-34,
0.0136417234,
-0.0515977144,
0.004675963,
-0.0523895398,
0.0229392741,
-0.0151417311,
-0.039741192,
0.0321623981,
0.0358339474,
0.0038335104,
-0.0598939881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13808v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13808v3 | Large Language Models are Versatile Decomposers: Decompose Evidence and Questions for Table-based Reasoning | 2023-01-31T17:51:45 | 2023-04-27T11:24:10 | Yunhu Ye, Binyuan Hui, Min Yang, Binhua Li, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table-based reasoning has shown remarkable progress in combining deep models
with discrete reasoning, which requires reasoning over both free-form natural
language (NL) questions and structured tabular data. However, previous
table-based reasoning solutions usually suffer from significant performance
degradation on huge evidence (tables). In addition, most existing methods
struggle to reason over complex questions since the required information is
scattered in different places. To alleviate the above challenges, we exploit
large language models (LLMs) as decomposers for effective table-based
reasoning, which (i) decompose huge evidence (a huge table) into sub-evidence
(a small table) to mitigate the interference of useless information for table
reasoning; and (ii) decompose complex questions into simpler sub-questions for
text reasoning. Specifically, we first use the LLMs to break down the evidence
(tables) involved in the current question, retaining the relevant evidence and
excluding the remaining irrelevant evidence from the huge table. In addition,
we propose a "parsing-execution-filling" strategy to alleviate the
hallucination dilemma of the chain of thought by decoupling logic and numerical
computation in each step. Extensive experiments show that our method can
effectively leverage decomposed evidence and questions and outperforms the
strong baselines on TabFact, WikiTableQuestion, and FetaQA datasets. Notably,
our model outperforms human performance for the first time on the TabFact
dataset. | [
0.0225591045,
0.098262839,
-0.0012782064,
0.0246634241,
-0.0679781064,
0.0547646694,
0.0028201446,
-0.0042754062,
0.0041077607,
-0.0319696143,
0.0152039519,
-0.0221619997,
-0.0102616865,
0.0224269107,
0.00325193,
0.0128318407,
0.0342885256,
-0.0499341637,
-0.0100045269,
0.0192193743,
-0.0128666405,
-0.0050062528,
-0.027246343,
0.0014082951,
-0.0146592129,
-0.0257823076,
-0.0420859158,
-0.0188247673,
-0.0223274883,
0.0203055423,
-0.0055729332,
0.065939568,
0.0321412385,
0.0332734808,
0.0000019833,
0.0198897962,
-0.0234580748,
-0.0085693058,
-0.0612085015,
-0.0062510492,
0.0149796894,
0.0043004528,
0.0029364987,
-0.0076541654,
-0.042756021,
-0.0436150096,
0.0066912826,
0.0736704543,
0.0608199053,
0.044957269,
0.0074954303,
-0.0673944056,
0.0030352867,
0.0098632202,
0.0569512211,
-0.0269576311,
0.021004729,
0.0182639919,
0.0085414965,
-0.0174123161,
0.0282786675,
0.031294819,
0.065618664,
-0.0119102597,
-0.020421138,
0.0381458886,
-0.0461802594,
-0.0023950192,
0.0212034117,
0.0988428071,
-0.0017202479,
-0.0267230198,
0.02598303,
0.0055997693,
0.0364410654,
-0.0072941496,
-0.0255476143,
0.0439115316,
-0.0052647227,
0.0006660009,
0.0468021967,
-0.0132107856,
0.0357531756,
-0.0009814937,
-0.0666298345,
0.1067201272,
-0.0157751497,
-0.0316498838,
0.0425301753,
-0.0211116448,
-0.026090363,
-0.0423340015,
0.0260084625,
0.0473188236,
-0.0420131348,
0.0211515427,
0.0094544934,
-0.0019928028,
0.0092527382,
-0.0463381521,
0.0155279161,
0.0397961624,
-0.0028526776,
0.0587260798,
-0.0437909998,
-0.0032570146,
-0.0532333478,
0.0198676866,
-0.0394474566,
-0.0433660932,
-0.0443491638,
-0.0008033242,
-0.0236029588,
0.045210287,
-0.0842965543,
-0.0109256338,
0.0502854213,
-0.0099954344,
-0.0221244805,
0.0457193628,
0.0286765415,
0.0522862226,
0.0011193237,
-0.0097578205,
-0.0505362265,
0.0182452779,
-0.0426165089,
0.0236635152,
0.0190927759,
-0.0527283028,
-0.0227763094,
-0.020903999,
0.0177173503,
-0.0325305313,
0.0577800535,
0.0215868186,
-0.0361199155,
0.0288282577,
-0.0423016064,
-0.0450410619,
-0.0288588796,
-0.082031779,
0.0189393349,
-0.0707303062,
0.0558300838,
0.0139048565,
-0.025262963,
-0.0583117306,
0.0187279377,
0.0704650283,
-0.0275842417,
0.0748217702,
0.0474649332,
0.0097497692,
0.0176287461,
-0.0049616192,
-0.024915373,
0.0526438244,
0.0063754269,
0.0394495875,
-0.0579087138,
-0.0158838015,
-0.0222112257,
0.0159990452,
0.0263039172,
-0.0174414311,
-0.0256695691,
0.0472383723,
0.0067500412,
0.0323893465,
-0.0074252537,
0.0428387076,
-0.018935794,
0.0238106623,
0.0181678385,
0.0298462138,
-0.0041668862,
0.0508043766,
0.0232061669,
-0.0044693882,
0.0170278437,
0.0152779324,
-0.0600949973,
0.0186589416,
0.0023155217,
-0.0056886245,
0.0226299074,
0.0131748198,
-0.016845677,
-0.0686411411,
0.0076329596,
0.0060854834,
0.0237954035,
0.0343421102,
0.0204933621,
0.0167900473,
-0.0659303889,
0.0253225565,
0.0164998863,
-0.0251604971,
-0.020706648,
-0.0097276848,
0.0414946154,
0.0479472578,
0.0289528817,
-0.0639751181,
-0.0047410717,
-0.0038907302,
0.0337850899,
-0.0092867119,
0.0211684275,
-0.0278835651,
0.0022567129,
-0.0134376986,
-0.0149596035,
0.0071318252,
0.0321835913,
-0.0246234331,
-0.0036423348,
-0.0253381822,
-0.0076882611,
-0.0295131449,
-0.0244369414,
0.0061850715,
0.0240331199,
-0.0129267117,
-0.0081537208,
0.0005323384,
0.0275329407,
0.0089283297,
0.0176258329,
0.0323303416,
0.0341861285,
-0.0532256141,
-0.0221242588,
-0.0258850176,
-0.0508900732,
-0.0471798852,
0.0351712592,
0.0087766098,
-0.0715583786,
0.0019495272,
-0.0439710468,
-0.0291200895,
-0.0005828306,
-0.0314748324,
-0.0066586873,
-0.013692352,
0.004275945,
0.0187457222,
0.0031948546,
0.0036542332,
0.1168805659,
-0.0338914581,
0.0061681364,
0.0071411603,
-0.0697023571,
0.0027857656,
-0.0053341677,
0.0224942677,
-0.0040366631,
-0.0245857816,
0.0143712275,
-0.0018668834,
0.006705509,
-0.0746374279,
-0.0056065866,
-0.0870849788,
0.0507319123,
-0.0398266651,
0.0050003477,
0.0059138588,
-0.0116853705,
0.0259005148,
-0.0038115231,
-0.0629617274,
-0.0129529648,
0.0152778924,
0.0035068861,
0.0525587536,
-0.0039179688,
0.0082948478,
-0.0081617637,
-0.0344980694,
-0.0432809032,
0.0392106026,
-0.0373209789,
-0.0040623699,
0.0061665387,
0.0076714172,
-0.0131021757,
0.0325460397,
0.0075042886,
-0.0006307355,
0.007697152,
-0.0480547547,
0.0270149373,
0.0899840966,
-0.0628444701,
0.0196343176,
0.0385281369,
-0.0230502617,
-0.0474422723,
0.0312558524,
-0.011297008,
0.0583615601,
-0.0043725381,
-0.0505659617,
0.0015766973,
0.0537908599,
-0.0173452962,
0.0104658771,
-0.037520092,
0.0363020599,
0.0153757911,
-0.0080761015,
-0.0535187088,
0.0448003784,
0.0223378371,
0.0263068434,
-0.0419494472,
0.0171732381,
0.0340029411,
-0.0128637105,
0.0184312835,
-0.052902434,
0.0198186692,
-0.039986942,
0.0712513998,
0.0079355352,
-0.0213253777,
-0.0141722877,
-0.017981058,
-0.0329194367,
-0.0106851673,
-0.0032057746,
-0.0396316461,
0.0794419646,
-0.061127536,
-0.0016353446,
-0.0021897641,
-0.0205604341,
-0.0314445794,
-0.0501850061,
-0.033571519,
0.0167845078,
0.0058144941,
-0.0026921218,
-0.0469610542,
-0.0302057136,
0.0301299784,
0.0317982771,
-0.0068116584,
-0.002529237,
-0.0462295935,
0.032339517,
0.0317989066,
0.0185172427,
-0.0138215981,
0.0008731147,
0.0622450896,
0.0664252341,
0.0195831358,
0.0041723745,
-0.0264753196,
0.0565323941,
0.0217154399,
0.0079190796,
-0.0015840362,
0.0331543945,
-0.0030239355,
-0.0813437402,
-0.0120696742,
0.0991091207,
0.0444498323,
0.009771294,
-0.0233204383,
-0.027820332,
0.0374040157,
0.0029517864,
0.0305511001,
-0.0715091601,
-0.0609044433,
0.0329922996,
-0.0631678775,
0.0229326077,
-0.0562852733,
0.004255496,
-0.0983145609,
0.0388529822,
-0.0206629466,
0.0009750807,
-0.0592885055,
-0.0329303071,
0.0016175022,
-0.0119962441,
0.0134123266,
0.0424835235,
0.0099521009,
0.0000237153,
0.0064726514,
-0.0278205741,
-0.0291443747,
0.0242641214,
-0.0504561961,
0.0203745123,
0.0336024314,
0.0370993018,
-0.0046309959,
-0.0404219367,
-0.0044306093,
-0.0092024719,
-0.0117426645,
-0.0052625178,
0.0377620533,
0.0330175459,
0.0115137296,
-0.0291121211,
0.0413851254,
-0.0612859055,
-0.0132728508,
0.0067201885,
0.0933321789,
-0.04681658,
-0.0246869475,
0.0234098155,
-0.0066989362,
-0.0145840105,
0.0992931426,
0.0267342348,
0.0056299642,
-0.0696928948,
-0.0385207608,
-0.0621181503,
-0.0526464097,
0.0077259243,
0.0508020408,
0.0513974056,
0.0067205895,
-0.03395693,
-0.0063721891,
0.0772240534,
0.0254148282,
-0.0125748804,
0.0392164662,
-0.0041988818,
-0.0271363053,
-0.0479070283,
0.0268561691,
-0.0425375104,
0.0152671766,
0.0114018582,
-0.013884034,
-0.0141272312,
-0.0291694999,
-0.0180742592,
0.027871104,
-0.0685451105,
-0.0142743401,
0.0042466549,
0.0137262763,
0.0247205254,
0.0327925384,
-0.0130858459,
-0.0281815585,
-0.0268120747,
-0.0219976529,
-0.0442905538,
-0.0273073912,
0.0323625095,
-0.043976862,
0.0269883238,
0.0381979495,
-0.0064259414,
0.000991986,
-0.0013975117,
0.042089574,
-0.0261117946,
0.0465947725,
0.0515750758,
0.0064081661,
-0.0133804502,
0.0569558814,
-0.0537787788,
-0.0144129666,
0.0243589375,
-0.0484708808,
-0.0578341968,
-0.0133816712,
0.0213558525,
0.0523763783,
0.0084625315,
-0.0042952169,
-0.012302543,
0.0243395027,
0.0190335773,
-0.014524309,
-0.018189244,
0.0597768165,
-0.0134624047,
0.0410412997,
-0.0342873782,
-0.0099284938,
-0.0118262898,
-0.005568427,
0.0384829603,
-0.0276549943,
0.0286498498,
0.0279416032,
-0.0403776169,
-0.0561617762,
0.0132037587,
-0.0652310699,
-0.0852552056,
0.0299816709,
-0.0069730179,
0.0074794847,
-0.0021799661,
-0.015153287,
-0.021591438,
-0.0236231703,
0.0308885295,
0.0114857005,
0.056338612,
-0.0025291166,
0.0342383645,
0.0239164494,
-0.0261346623,
-0.0265331212,
0.0442397706,
0.0224042051,
0.0264094602,
0.0128472364,
-0.0168098211,
-0.0565395318,
-0.0377023928,
-0.0409982726,
0.0159210283,
-0.0356347784,
-0.0010894893,
-0.0322532915,
-0.0403267629,
0.0075784517,
0.0105948597,
-0.0331364423,
0.003563632,
0.0072657908,
0.0534565002,
0.0409261547,
-0.0257308148,
-0.0321435295,
0.0700001344,
-0.011849218,
-0.0498521104,
-0.0350309201,
-6.345494095e-33,
0.0065748408,
0.0033521014,
0.033363685,
-0.0608386472,
-0.0158118643,
-0.0183377825,
-0.0376197994,
-0.0251855124,
-0.0240535177,
0.0321144722,
-0.024984017,
0.0629570335,
0.0194953214,
0.0273330398,
-0.0002646346,
-0.0761936828,
0.0158582944,
0.0003639823,
-0.0133133847,
0.0200387221,
0.0119363507,
0.0157080721,
-0.0180678889,
-0.012717925,
0.0376584306,
-0.0032001769,
0.0067901588,
0.0246697105,
-0.0467342325,
0.012868396,
-0.056165982,
0.0192483813,
0.0283053704,
-0.0688067973,
-0.0112990253,
0.0504606366,
-0.1441243291,
-0.0098091504,
0.014046127,
0.0074924091,
-0.045788642,
-0.0582740344,
0.0214264393,
0.0310291965,
0.0307924133,
-0.0256765299,
0.004675101,
-0.0385908782,
0.0212370474,
0.0351374969,
-0.0068420088,
0.0042702612,
-0.0224812571,
-0.0085712718,
0.0443783402,
0.0419696383,
-0.0013616523,
-0.0039370265,
-0.0507762842,
-0.0011267363,
-0.0136970915,
0.0150252162,
0.0413782559,
-0.0528682992,
0.0098989811,
0.0402350202,
0.0137565043,
0.0169169251,
-0.0753769279,
0.0078893537,
-0.0434467196,
0.1056769788,
0.0526408963,
-0.0023377717,
0.0760765597,
0.0173093677,
-0.072768338,
0.0252664965,
-0.0122187724,
0.0358101577,
0.003491194,
-0.0201088581,
-0.0293897502,
-0.030515546,
-0.0470323861,
0.0204614792,
-0.0394910313,
0.021461457,
0.006622206,
-0.0256204642,
0.0067432062,
-0.01338688,
0.0347609818,
-0.0111131389,
0.0049100197,
0.0599108748,
0.0147323068,
0.0061765215,
0.0190118011,
0.0393656343,
-0.015294034,
-0.0187539514,
0.0044530374,
-0.0267728716,
0.0379647017,
0.0468968265,
0.048525095,
0.0102799786,
-0.032536339,
-0.0241048522,
-0.0766524896,
0.0457676835,
-0.0126617523,
0.0491628833,
0.0281649828,
0.0560303964,
-0.0064139334,
0.0292167421,
0.0178061202,
0.0237879045,
-0.023258606,
0.0100286575,
0.0056300382,
-0.0086523639,
0.0207424629,
-0.0132817086,
-0.0589024313,
-0.0008424128,
0.0178082082,
-0.0500637889,
0.0227815993,
0.0328185633,
2.547e-7,
0.0505158715,
0.0096301762,
0.0360672735,
0.0205775425,
0.0055218861,
0.0308454633,
0.0056038299,
-0.0348994508,
-0.0135740573,
-0.0585179143,
0.0165770072,
0.0410169661,
0.0672403648,
0.0311382525,
-0.0461247116,
-0.0315182246,
-0.0497888625,
-0.0357019119,
-0.0545858592,
-0.0144819953,
0.0455481112,
0.0974764377,
-0.0098720221,
-0.0391468443,
0.0105548957,
-0.0008729357,
0.0259719901,
-0.0358371139,
0.0320153721,
0.0092762364,
0.0458497591,
-0.034335535,
0.0053793737,
0.0701550916,
-0.0187764913,
-0.0054063811,
-0.017700756,
0.0630950481,
0.0201889407,
0.02949965,
-0.0391702093,
-0.0853632018,
0.0284160525,
-0.0568897538,
0.1323314011,
-0.0578629822,
-0.025124101,
0.0634461641,
-0.0146843381,
0.004606524,
-0.0122606773,
0.0416080765,
0.0180597119,
-0.0012016593,
0.0130427536,
-0.0182639845,
0.0211694743,
-0.0761372298,
-0.0215825289,
0.0221860614,
-0.0393346772,
0.0014029939,
-0.01988855,
-0.0333237611,
0.024625821,
-0.0782958865,
-0.0265728589,
2.525011227e-34,
0.036964234,
0.0143910535,
0.0440883972,
0.0345448069,
0.068615824,
-0.015925318,
0.0121134482,
-0.004008411,
0.008203974,
-0.1086296365,
-0.0115558328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13771v1 | The Touché23-ValueEval Dataset for Identifying Human Values behind Arguments | 2023-01-31T17:15:33 | 2023-01-31T17:15:33 | Nailia Mirzakhmedova, Johannes Kiesel, Milad Alshomary, Maximilian Heinrich, Nicolas Handke, Xiaoni Cai, Barriere Valentin, Doratossadat Dastgheib, Omid Ghahroodi, Mohammad Ali Sadraei, Ehsaneddin Asgari, Lea Kawaletz, Henning Wachsmuth, Benno Stein | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Touch\'e23-ValueEval Dataset for Identifying Human Values
behind Arguments. To investigate approaches for the automated detection of
human values behind arguments, we collected 9324 arguments from 6 diverse
sources, covering religious texts, political discussions, free-text arguments,
newspaper editorials, and online democracy platforms. Each argument was
annotated by 3 crowdworkers for 54 values. The Touch\'e23-ValueEval dataset
extends the Webis-ArgValues-22. In comparison to the previous dataset, the
effectiveness of a 1-Baseline decreases, but that of an out-of-the-box BERT
model increases. Therefore, though the classification difficulty increased as
per the label distribution, the larger dataset allows for training better
models. | [
0.0171561558,
0.0578372255,
0.0037500921,
0.063072525,
-0.0206360556,
0.0293592922,
-0.0066290093,
-0.0327966772,
-0.0364509523,
-0.0221269652,
0.0299489051,
-0.008919457,
-0.0086961258,
-0.052087605,
-0.026104439,
-0.091033414,
0.0245044027,
0.0617921092,
0.0728002787,
-0.0121242516,
0.0154632321,
0.0328639485,
-0.0124541475,
0.0426569507,
-0.022541564,
-0.0092704743,
-0.0448063873,
0.001990143,
0.1240018234,
-0.0123314662,
0.0125118876,
0.0331616476,
0.0063430392,
-0.0242695864,
0.0000018797,
-0.0192226823,
-0.0016089978,
-0.0428238101,
-0.0106041497,
0.0054124221,
0.076985985,
0.0352538787,
-0.0172890797,
0.0143230623,
-0.0225954894,
0.0227888245,
0.0152449617,
0.0921766609,
0.056082733,
0.0801125988,
0.0000455719,
-0.0185177661,
0.011499865,
0.0033115183,
0.0049727545,
-0.0178621933,
0.0172847845,
-0.0096674599,
-0.0405317433,
0.0645186976,
0.0296795852,
-0.0013657433,
0.0265931766,
-0.00430403,
-0.0601638556,
-0.026335869,
-0.083851032,
-0.0290664453,
0.0027201329,
0.0456915088,
0.0394633487,
-0.0406145379,
0.0496370941,
-0.0201166049,
0.0021726168,
0.0189903639,
0.0116743017,
0.0332269147,
-0.0350006558,
0.0177550726,
0.0613035336,
0.0173374619,
0.0036623783,
0.0262565184,
0.0125222476,
-0.0078481846,
-0.0124965627,
0.0147495512,
0.044527404,
-0.0022313653,
-0.0672338307,
-0.020826906,
0.032950107,
0.0133205038,
0.0580260493,
0.0192646217,
-0.0504048839,
-0.0178617314,
0.0104415976,
-0.1141519472,
0.0129895033,
0.0227811262,
-0.0372303389,
0.0462559424,
0.0300944559,
-0.0217568632,
-0.0008487837,
0.0050677215,
0.0187673811,
-0.0011901422,
-0.0286956709,
0.0207535289,
-0.0489982888,
0.0121778985,
0.0025638628,
0.0222890992,
-0.0414267145,
-0.0292612836,
-0.0461420044,
0.0018746975,
-0.0199860167,
-0.0041194074,
0.0123136658,
-0.02880284,
-0.0049620708,
0.0688125342,
-0.0734461918,
-0.0005364894,
-0.0271460656,
-0.0416892357,
0.0190826785,
0.0014645443,
0.034903992,
-0.0141577376,
0.0188921597,
0.0033343644,
0.0196194276,
0.0007835841,
-0.0528555214,
-0.0248065945,
-0.006240678,
-0.0068197637,
-0.0125977928,
-0.0265113264,
0.0214433577,
-0.037685588,
-0.0019057072,
-0.0553371236,
0.0152386529,
0.0624264292,
0.0047236593,
0.028466681,
0.0265259594,
-0.0167900622,
0.0456189886,
0.0185282808,
-0.0276625138,
0.0245577041,
-0.0022367544,
0.0364160351,
0.0598364398,
-0.01306492,
-0.0265097246,
0.0070332773,
0.0305668991,
-0.0145437056,
-0.0109677063,
0.0189010818,
-0.042431701,
0.0218191501,
-0.0299754012,
0.0259222798,
-0.023418963,
-0.0724975467,
0.0184402857,
0.0660708249,
-0.0072408877,
-0.0078723077,
-0.017068835,
0.0401935875,
0.0831278116,
-0.0442511588,
0.0080299135,
0.0031712509,
-0.0060035288,
-0.056917686,
-0.0088523431,
0.0241525378,
-0.0122665875,
-0.0377066396,
-0.0309939142,
-0.009435215,
-0.0002896991,
-0.0468462296,
0.0270509794,
-0.0214241911,
-0.0008133028,
-0.0314422399,
0.05635456,
-0.0709917918,
-0.0351715609,
-0.0076960507,
0.0396918766,
0.0134490915,
0.0102925776,
-0.0218683816,
-0.0147315599,
-0.0314174108,
0.0736602172,
0.0631960854,
0.0679408833,
-0.0510140881,
-0.0066297255,
-0.0457949601,
-0.0203434601,
0.0031303144,
-0.0141547415,
0.0234811418,
0.0098121697,
0.0089729792,
0.0167403519,
-0.023105545,
-0.0079183122,
0.0457438268,
0.0396877117,
-0.0004506686,
-0.022892043,
0.0470547639,
0.0381307751,
0.0374756455,
0.004537839,
-0.0508152917,
-0.00208498,
-0.0202478357,
0.0093836403,
0.017088918,
-0.0274312384,
0.0056753056,
0.0226034466,
-0.0598898567,
-0.0232401565,
0.0341181308,
-0.0283346195,
0.0291658975,
-0.0047457572,
-0.0332006849,
-0.017912833,
-0.0184067041,
-0.0344112776,
-0.0195759553,
-0.0099578919,
-0.0068693063,
0.0766600668,
0.0127772242,
0.0015782757,
-0.0446894765,
-0.0060724118,
0.0832281411,
-0.0407986008,
-0.0195161104,
-0.0511433184,
-0.0054401974,
0.0488468297,
0.047663983,
-0.0252229944,
-0.0083833132,
-0.0061323997,
-0.0729751661,
-0.0333178602,
-0.012834332,
0.0353790782,
0.0040931255,
-0.043823529,
0.0207962729,
0.0330201238,
-0.0321293473,
-0.0335755125,
-0.0561924167,
-0.0061495551,
0.0532325245,
-0.0279189348,
0.0354538672,
-0.0117465956,
-0.0026448923,
-0.0427999906,
0.0245072152,
0.0315039568,
0.0315127932,
-0.0052116169,
-0.0572722256,
-0.0307300743,
-0.0102100568,
-0.0039549405,
-0.0520679317,
0.0197270662,
0.0341844074,
-0.0131024597,
0.0650976077,
0.0776087791,
0.0691803321,
-0.0525596254,
0.0615179129,
-0.0561599508,
-0.0218597036,
-0.011655041,
0.0387985632,
-0.0020123597,
-0.0065606842,
0.0237622764,
0.0842045248,
-0.0037650899,
0.0303413887,
-0.0874207392,
0.0761574432,
-0.0141134299,
-0.0084222686,
-0.0066224793,
-0.0013628085,
-0.0186220445,
0.0362136886,
-0.0169440862,
-0.0066090869,
0.0567422099,
0.0253927093,
0.0460906811,
-0.0365480669,
0.0102891298,
-0.0179332886,
0.007989645,
-0.0310829692,
0.0257197246,
0.0058650253,
-0.0027732407,
0.0109721692,
0.002544391,
0.0537995808,
-0.0508249626,
0.0107396524,
0.0032349438,
-0.0094411848,
-0.0193857625,
-0.0247648656,
-0.0209992547,
-0.0183533244,
-0.0330002196,
-0.0352587849,
0.0092194909,
-0.0147793945,
0.0041588261,
-0.0557959005,
-0.0056663821,
-0.0198504105,
0.0270406082,
-0.0063672652,
0.0237923134,
-0.0085849538,
-0.0236415807,
-0.0055430927,
0.0144330366,
0.0046836971,
-0.0111991335,
0.0623442233,
0.0080871973,
-0.0290225651,
-0.0601873957,
-0.025313938,
-0.0019533886,
-0.0217182226,
0.0062326193,
-0.0290160533,
0.0371836461,
-0.030210143,
0.0385943204,
0.077725105,
0.0014835724,
-0.010013896,
-0.0043306514,
-0.0611180849,
-0.0138715561,
-0.0165552218,
-0.0019959025,
-0.1235583276,
-0.0190837272,
-0.0251392778,
0.0319255218,
-0.0325727947,
-0.0406362638,
0.0410428233,
-0.0539721213,
0.0353273898,
0.0003547746,
0.0238350648,
0.0030927111,
-0.0303084869,
0.0200742185,
-0.0366909988,
-0.0247926582,
-0.0010135868,
0.0139095197,
0.0136027718,
0.026394004,
0.0107192453,
-0.0124482019,
0.0620660223,
-0.02197171,
0.0079113627,
0.0181132201,
0.0895428881,
-0.0025311166,
-0.0808218718,
0.0167075191,
-0.0221431963,
-0.0242499132,
0.0087573212,
0.0323383547,
-0.0323708504,
-0.032541424,
-0.0397928208,
0.0660849139,
0.0109941717,
-0.0502588488,
-0.0021760224,
0.0363666713,
-0.023069296,
-0.0056524938,
-0.0174531378,
0.0244887732,
-0.0115132276,
0.0644529313,
0.0337904841,
-0.0438538827,
-0.0037185168,
-0.0401863642,
0.0043762093,
-0.0669995248,
-0.061152786,
-0.0072423317,
-0.0047025871,
-0.0186134651,
-0.0784406736,
-0.041059617,
-0.0293162055,
0.0608344115,
0.0078681419,
-0.081700325,
0.0217888001,
0.0495171472,
-0.0547205918,
0.0408220403,
0.0176049378,
0.0065371399,
-0.0176026989,
0.0077546081,
0.004234585,
-0.038273707,
-0.0463698804,
-0.0082216077,
0.0044322242,
-0.0537939593,
0.0344623476,
0.0252685249,
0.0180280469,
0.0310955551,
0.0176172033,
-0.0185747016,
0.0494796373,
0.0211808402,
0.0213537253,
-0.0134670725,
0.0605060123,
0.0603588223,
-0.0198109094,
-0.0007741257,
0.0206052717,
0.038557712,
-0.0138250403,
-0.0161315259,
-0.0435399078,
-0.0150697008,
-0.009364198,
-0.0089063747,
0.0260606222,
0.0548551679,
-0.078047663,
-0.0385245606,
0.00332304,
-0.0331040211,
-0.0070003434,
-0.0244148634,
0.0120935887,
-0.009995657,
-0.0442089848,
-0.0417906046,
-0.0362141877,
0.0004853176,
0.0240511857,
0.0006525149,
0.0468721204,
0.02612078,
0.0827527419,
-0.0522351339,
-0.0144156339,
-0.030995978,
0.0215874296,
-0.0094425594,
0.0613831244,
-0.0292280484,
0.0787372366,
0.0461047366,
0.0106534045,
0.079523325,
-0.0053240326,
-0.0138090178,
-0.0558800772,
-0.0574952699,
-0.047599446,
-0.0345413387,
0.0137721682,
0.021972701,
-0.0187574588,
-0.0309784561,
-0.0071383421,
0.0321165882,
-0.0244743936,
-0.0201377831,
0.0119730094,
0.0211513452,
-0.0299223159,
-0.036944177,
0.0056620548,
-0.0384641252,
0.0438800156,
0.0370109864,
-0.024967391,
-0.0472998805,
-0.0011333993,
0.0024199169,
-0.0330636464,
-0.006069256,
0.0017836548,
-0.0429149345,
0.0071527218,
0.0143398801,
0.057223022,
0.0043452224,
0.0178685449,
0.009394398,
0.0521644019,
-0.0350671858,
0.0252236407,
-0.0279643629,
0.0291550793,
-0.0646775067,
0.0113439877,
-0.0222411901,
-5.805368033e-33,
-0.0183314327,
0.0150697408,
-0.0274255965,
0.042019859,
0.0095085204,
-0.0107547492,
-0.014347787,
0.0399173833,
-0.0665026531,
0.1039331481,
0.0245052725,
0.0018843602,
0.0112495273,
0.0123804398,
0.0108676674,
-0.0394797474,
0.0036047688,
-0.0099095209,
-0.0424475931,
0.0336936042,
0.0475351475,
-0.0372794718,
0.0834023729,
-0.0924419388,
0.011858087,
0.0515201613,
-0.0089515392,
0.0018082445,
0.0486919992,
0.0397530906,
0.0255572274,
0.0402774736,
0.0112161068,
0.0015685648,
0.0359503105,
0.0572643094,
-0.0590171553,
-0.0425473936,
0.0144175673,
0.0005636463,
-0.0287537649,
-0.0375771224,
0.0025586146,
0.0010776661,
-0.0272733942,
-0.0136842839,
0.0458292738,
-0.0181981642,
0.0185989682,
-0.0759318694,
-0.0516219474,
0.048920054,
-0.037619289,
-0.0250081141,
-0.0403677113,
0.0352412052,
0.0156685188,
0.0731053948,
-0.068538107,
-0.0120984754,
-0.0466157123,
-0.0295787323,
-0.0489086211,
-0.0505167432,
0.0182626583,
0.0824042186,
-0.012492232,
0.0201805439,
-0.0519427471,
0.0091878418,
0.0214049015,
0.0334513746,
0.0705097765,
0.0741165355,
0.0080550043,
-0.0011884136,
-0.0323184729,
0.0225178599,
0.0641506314,
0.0196807496,
0.010678038,
-0.0256392397,
-0.0264747236,
0.0266202521,
-0.0041929116,
-0.1107124463,
-0.0139726242,
-0.015086404,
-0.0263905842,
-0.0228356756,
-0.0371031091,
0.0450818315,
0.0203855596,
-0.0152093554,
0.0268534441,
0.0434258655,
-0.0074317884,
0.02180361,
-0.0090041328,
-0.0063498714,
-0.0382182896,
-0.0209418572,
0.0003906397,
0.0063500321,
0.0851999447,
-0.0252528805,
0.0414521545,
-0.0287586804,
-0.0282631014,
-0.0403831862,
-0.0078017171,
0.0248510242,
-0.0534548387,
0.0514386781,
0.0451442152,
0.0285836644,
0.0127220675,
0.0289692841,
-0.0212446935,
0.0049241199,
-0.0177900754,
-0.026379399,
0.0233850386,
0.0064988285,
-0.0166779943,
-0.0179133713,
-0.0169329308,
0.0000879722,
0.0160883795,
-0.0657333359,
0.0111653628,
-0.0007312704,
2.517e-7,
0.0413088128,
0.0297601689,
0.0486782826,
-0.0339934938,
-0.0242572483,
0.071004346,
0.044008363,
0.0169431809,
-0.0049041016,
-0.0629082546,
-0.0052205133,
-0.0171011966,
0.1042554453,
0.0011758242,
-0.0592509247,
-0.0594230667,
-0.0293479469,
-0.023415491,
-0.0176820159,
0.0301449392,
0.0646953732,
0.0376553088,
0.0478591733,
-0.0047982926,
0.0184380766,
0.0907095596,
0.0521097928,
-0.0257006604,
-0.0037602647,
0.0019486244,
0.0264763813,
-0.0611565895,
0.0091699129,
0.0031767287,
-0.0288269185,
0.0052555464,
0.0180231165,
0.0749155283,
-0.0119608268,
-0.0314916261,
-0.0106804036,
-0.0367231928,
-0.0300549325,
-0.0240047853,
0.0239818767,
-0.0797499418,
-0.0351166874,
-0.020389365,
-0.0688163564,
0.0181648787,
-0.0106582679,
0.0211107004,
0.0029248288,
-0.0016760486,
0.0168632008,
-0.0318830982,
0.0257261544,
-0.0858980641,
-0.0096725216,
0.0088475421,
-0.0177061632,
-0.004100529,
0.0294084232,
0.0000326229,
0.0341375433,
-0.0174625479,
-0.0227011815,
1.687657354e-34,
0.0291948114,
-0.0385739543,
0.003342313,
-0.0122281862,
0.0647983626,
0.0439076461,
0.0104160262,
-0.0236257017,
0.03317881,
0.0032402226,
0.0013515502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13753v1 | Dynamic Scheduled Sampling with Imitation Loss for Neural Text Generation | 2023-01-31T16:41:06 | 2023-01-31T16:41:06 | Xiang Lin, Prathyusha Jwalapuram, Shafiq Joty | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art neural text generation models are typically trained to
maximize the likelihood of each token in the ground-truth sequence conditioned
on the previous target tokens. However, during inference, the model needs to
make a prediction conditioned on the tokens generated by itself. This
train-test discrepancy is referred to as exposure bias. Scheduled sampling is a
curriculum learning strategy that gradually exposes the model to its own
predictions during training to mitigate this bias. Most of the proposed
approaches design a scheduler based on training steps, which generally requires
careful tuning depending on the training setup. In this work, we introduce
Dynamic Scheduled Sampling with Imitation Loss (DySI), which maintains the
schedule based solely on the training time accuracy, while enhancing the
curriculum learning by introducing an imitation loss, which attempts to make
the behavior of the decoder indistinguishable from the behavior of a
teacher-forced decoder. DySI is universally applicable across training setups
with minimal tuning. Extensive experiments and analysis show that DySI not only
achieves notable improvements on standard machine translation benchmarks, but
also significantly improves the robustness of other text generation models. | [
0.0184932444,
0.0431229584,
-0.0071054781,
-0.0226457436,
-0.0081864661,
0.0017810713,
0.0455422886,
-0.0179763306,
-0.041771479,
-0.0238399487,
-0.0211648419,
-0.0316197574,
0.0015990949,
0.0067410129,
0.0404517204,
-0.0560510978,
0.0175581668,
-0.0154152904,
-0.0325284824,
0.0073540001,
-0.0114783552,
0.0340184085,
-0.0107170222,
0.0368766785,
-0.0102094477,
-0.0070369793,
-0.0197120979,
0.0190681014,
0.0323726013,
-0.0277937762,
0.0284458045,
0.0275283251,
0.0349605158,
0.0360977538,
0.0000021045,
0.0032372708,
-0.0135215279,
-0.0126279509,
0.0017520931,
-0.0017816874,
0.0569939166,
-0.0027241644,
-0.0016072693,
0.0532170497,
-0.0074341358,
0.0221651308,
0.0323531628,
0.0011427079,
0.0403453112,
0.0477829985,
0.0119668962,
0.0306611955,
-0.0168913081,
-0.0387824103,
-0.0020156717,
0.0035704931,
-0.0112447105,
0.0170637611,
-0.0125489272,
-0.0259853154,
-0.0102811605,
0.0201467089,
0.0588575043,
-0.0239028726,
0.0065593151,
0.0419550277,
-0.0059865592,
-0.0216388386,
-0.026810661,
0.0300475545,
-0.0375030115,
-0.0261289272,
0.0186118577,
-0.0369746126,
-0.011475957,
-0.0682845041,
-0.0265180785,
0.06101707,
-0.0099447705,
0.0363680907,
0.038282793,
0.0425775424,
-0.000542775,
0.0335450582,
-0.0093780644,
-0.0252831709,
-0.0015839057,
-0.0250269528,
-0.022342151,
0.0491828434,
0.0132654766,
-0.0476303361,
0.0382641219,
0.0475111008,
-0.0319798961,
0.0213060696,
-0.1031250581,
-0.0625659525,
0.0116381207,
0.0314147435,
0.0319421105,
0.0656512454,
0.0085714068,
-0.0261549074,
-0.0110872556,
0.0714471787,
0.008022815,
0.0625924021,
-0.0247374456,
0.0740984976,
-0.0159571245,
-0.0272637084,
-0.0554613322,
0.0291597284,
-0.0449105427,
-0.013762814,
-0.0309636686,
0.0044900407,
-0.0151552828,
-0.0015916099,
0.0399576724,
0.0185308643,
-0.1289323121,
0.0159275401,
0.0087056905,
-0.0066479477,
-0.0196353607,
0.0109879244,
0.0595531948,
-0.0504206978,
-0.0532115698,
0.003921451,
0.0166200735,
-0.0259047151,
-0.0104326187,
0.0716670156,
-0.0559558161,
-0.025640985,
-0.0276304558,
-0.0861539245,
-0.0357209966,
-0.0405651703,
0.0166537352,
-0.0432523564,
0.0175253171,
-0.0401736237,
-0.0159569178,
0.0249879789,
0.0104613183,
0.0196640398,
0.0621544868,
-0.0211497135,
0.0185505729,
-0.0243736915,
0.0425248407,
0.0185981337,
0.0218823273,
0.061091911,
0.0336229876,
0.0784369856,
-0.0276689529,
0.0837850869,
-0.0141745629,
0.0251202602,
0.0847223327,
0.0079405289,
-0.0092700347,
-0.0338014551,
-0.0114339385,
0.0584464408,
0.0786834732,
0.0397830792,
-0.058639776,
0.0327950753,
0.0647424757,
-0.0321035758,
-0.0401134752,
0.0172058325,
0.0706823021,
0.0155951213,
-0.012156588,
0.024397647,
-0.009339259,
0.0340876952,
0.0502001829,
0.0357896648,
0.0337201804,
0.0354677178,
-0.0136419302,
-0.0617525876,
0.041294761,
-0.0117692687,
-0.0234173778,
-0.026972143,
0.0090763411,
0.0598055273,
-0.0631606802,
0.0313400812,
0.012787167,
-0.0055520795,
0.0647765547,
-0.0325948708,
-0.0063590999,
0.0474086627,
0.0464557596,
-0.0336088464,
-0.0231758431,
-0.0224120617,
0.0257368088,
0.0933367535,
0.0224781483,
-0.0030620154,
0.0264270175,
-0.0487115718,
-0.0069156396,
-0.0399389751,
0.0182399061,
0.0340637676,
0.0100866398,
0.0683637783,
0.0219773203,
-0.015628228,
-0.0578678474,
0.0567953959,
-0.0631371886,
-0.0668825507,
0.0213450585,
-0.0073998719,
0.0139961438,
-0.017804699,
-0.0179847572,
0.0060292142,
-0.0026033972,
-0.0532288551,
-0.0012662678,
0.0000800608,
-0.1130754873,
-0.0908278748,
0.0121089844,
-0.0500614718,
0.0038674716,
0.0133953709,
-0.0260121208,
-0.0351957977,
0.0064294632,
-0.0213634521,
0.0328338519,
-0.0262629595,
0.0194659457,
0.0400479287,
-0.0023919237,
-0.0430758372,
0.010454772,
-0.0385052003,
-0.033419989,
0.0543369502,
0.0060395217,
-0.0291750282,
-0.0714776143,
0.0043146363,
-0.0068766158,
-0.0128190164,
0.0079806373,
0.0193188749,
0.0320143476,
-0.0395190455,
-0.0497066826,
-0.0167609695,
-0.0063327556,
-0.0147364046,
0.0157284252,
0.0307526384,
0.0093435952,
0.0125084687,
-0.0031138381,
-0.0560053773,
-0.0231853202,
-0.0083312541,
-0.0366423763,
0.0439346321,
0.0137380315,
0.0403364412,
-0.0170460325,
-0.0003110688,
0.0059539787,
0.0084952181,
0.0073511354,
0.0238506217,
-0.0553275906,
0.0100168744,
0.0105652949,
-0.0102770627,
0.0038920739,
-0.0305477027,
0.0142383436,
0.0102263251,
0.0014969741,
0.06537655,
0.0189146399,
0.0110844048,
0.0061998833,
0.0222583115,
-0.0709199458,
0.0272397548,
-0.0185257569,
0.017173212,
0.0008500903,
-0.0418293066,
0.0122639416,
0.0443636738,
0.0500711277,
0.0289595779,
-0.0685451701,
0.0370268896,
-0.0150049971,
-0.0726257339,
0.0195458625,
0.0042469916,
-0.0176351462,
-0.0449141189,
-0.0578913689,
-0.0378434546,
0.0490245707,
-0.0094538545,
0.0128216352,
-0.0414321646,
0.038950488,
0.0057987459,
0.0161618646,
0.0092191352,
0.0307177752,
0.0269148331,
-0.0423944592,
-0.0706363991,
0.0021350479,
0.0234112479,
-0.0296065919,
-0.0133761456,
-0.0376134813,
-0.0269641113,
-0.0247972608,
-0.037176244,
-0.0466093905,
0.0111899832,
0.0016732897,
0.000390659,
0.0058726347,
-0.0166196227,
0.0050661303,
-0.0502473563,
-0.0155064519,
0.0686962456,
-0.0428757928,
-0.0157684553,
-0.0374551974,
0.023426488,
0.047078114,
0.0151886875,
-0.007200744,
-0.0556336455,
0.0322719254,
0.0568907,
0.067803666,
0.0260477699,
-0.0218187254,
0.0071774959,
0.0116513642,
0.0248939767,
0.0332208611,
0.0253478847,
0.0424763933,
-0.0563508384,
-0.05801595,
0.0732378364,
0.0053634313,
-0.0357983261,
0.0172985997,
0.0098154265,
0.0975184739,
-0.0182828624,
0.025301354,
-0.0744144693,
-0.0189881176,
0.001623968,
0.066822812,
-0.0284216758,
-0.0041201604,
-0.0132469926,
-0.0942694545,
-0.0032819409,
0.0270362385,
-0.0547424182,
0.0053226012,
0.0140004335,
-0.0519205816,
-0.0278581772,
0.0550057814,
0.0045430893,
0.0032403884,
0.0344618224,
0.0714731142,
0.011462409,
-0.0480470508,
-0.0166076571,
-0.0162909292,
0.0456056483,
0.0589357205,
0.0278810412,
0.0105647044,
0.008802888,
0.0115897804,
0.0134252608,
-0.0138685638,
0.0059276908,
0.0277145356,
-0.0145671591,
-0.0119540561,
0.0096551031,
0.0638319999,
-0.0122116674,
0.0297213439,
0.0082410472,
0.053019613,
0.013711758,
-0.0101233572,
-0.0051364796,
-0.012777362,
0.0633245707,
0.0437455475,
0.0271259807,
-0.0527266487,
-0.0202739704,
-0.0071737655,
0.0234929174,
-0.1537338942,
-0.0170669444,
0.0038387361,
-0.0098833553,
-0.0398229808,
-0.1229735464,
-0.029565502,
-0.009553683,
0.090843752,
0.0000957897,
-0.0341538228,
0.015128755,
-0.0173660498,
-0.0364060439,
-0.0153048597,
-0.0122484704,
0.0026532379,
-0.028665375,
-0.02954196,
-0.0357094109,
-0.0686856508,
0.0013177221,
0.0379330255,
-0.1370706558,
-0.0618095398,
0.0126041798,
0.0689318776,
0.0114289587,
0.0822303519,
0.0068919314,
-0.0172593966,
0.0905851275,
0.040621791,
0.0203857962,
0.0177802425,
0.0370304286,
-0.0105370488,
-0.0120373061,
0.0342994183,
-0.0281796139,
0.0056485366,
0.0306784064,
0.0408517309,
0.0081050629,
0.0585729405,
0.0313316882,
-0.0215498097,
-0.0270363837,
-0.0529586188,
-0.0002519813,
-0.0421641394,
0.0106525356,
-0.0163698867,
0.0120964516,
-0.0605287701,
0.0306125619,
0.0221302044,
0.0138862077,
-0.0102445381,
-0.0526266545,
0.0262954105,
0.0170003213,
-0.001029338,
-0.0238838568,
-0.0518167354,
0.0522286929,
0.0064281537,
0.0091763809,
-0.037178427,
0.0066184062,
-0.028523339,
0.0312518142,
-0.0251274817,
0.0204004031,
0.0403532982,
0.0188243631,
0.0159621127,
-0.0055417493,
-0.0217349008,
0.0224369597,
-0.0828310326,
-0.0167466011,
-0.0067709223,
-0.0233864412,
0.043675717,
-0.029655274,
0.0113969725,
0.0307219215,
0.0167869516,
-0.0156344809,
-0.02933136,
0.0009739856,
-0.004187454,
0.026173234,
-0.0390201323,
0.0670202076,
-0.0010857523,
0.0344211571,
0.0064498056,
0.0402804017,
-0.0253169388,
-0.0196481124,
0.0015860236,
-0.0077335248,
0.023052156,
-0.0198160317,
0.0012952904,
-0.0327481441,
0.0165250599,
0.0370598175,
0.0088317366,
-0.0185443908,
0.0413782522,
-0.0015480404,
-0.0515440218,
-0.0144841708,
-0.0229307804,
0.0364019275,
0.035107173,
-0.0204174444,
-0.037813101,
-6.195731707e-33,
-0.0409701318,
-0.0065647787,
0.0275341738,
-0.0451098047,
-0.0642228276,
0.0238271393,
-0.0332628563,
-0.0311486106,
0.019603936,
0.0051888083,
-0.0117236031,
-0.0099628028,
0.0254179109,
0.0671447068,
0.0055132732,
0.0054405518,
0.0520383716,
-0.0351985991,
-0.0538939722,
0.069224827,
0.0415334664,
0.0257669371,
0.0307975132,
0.0062094978,
-0.0214100555,
0.0129883597,
-0.0114344694,
-0.0220401976,
-0.0185787138,
0.035571564,
-0.0092222188,
-0.0009428855,
0.0039716838,
-0.0255751833,
-0.0424885973,
0.0051157656,
-0.0681837723,
-0.0554535985,
-0.0507454313,
0.0109760929,
-0.0296274014,
-0.0601702631,
0.0189463031,
-0.0222297516,
-0.0018294114,
0.0163714234,
0.0062756296,
-0.0175768659,
-0.0431976579,
-0.0282862894,
-0.0537358858,
0.0075673088,
-0.0054429667,
-0.0200705938,
-0.0164712537,
0.0453791469,
-0.0136665506,
-0.0110029485,
-0.0385424308,
0.0115303015,
-0.0001231595,
0.0481610075,
0.0123778386,
0.0501246229,
0.0084935492,
0.0617667176,
0.0020364919,
0.0103660338,
0.0046854038,
0.0413879603,
0.0264877677,
0.0005469497,
-0.005412932,
0.023931006,
0.0564204454,
-0.0133056864,
-0.0119202444,
0.0245289952,
0.0233156458,
-0.006048697,
0.0613744743,
-0.0274404306,
0.0152859008,
-0.0001574222,
-0.017608922,
-0.0277837981,
-0.001727151,
0.0141414059,
0.033381138,
0.0937868655,
-0.047042571,
-0.009159442,
0.030258799,
-0.0096855341,
0.0209379513,
0.0075015351,
-0.0497949347,
-0.0017642826,
-0.0348496661,
-0.0009894114,
-0.0733527094,
-0.0543777905,
0.0303099435,
0.0321230777,
0.0121552264,
0.0273620784,
0.0588501096,
0.0378359295,
-0.0265680216,
0.0071943388,
-0.0650648773,
0.0676333532,
0.061503049,
0.0050304709,
0.0356509276,
-0.0470428728,
-0.02098451,
0.0053497991,
0.0184794776,
-0.0697042271,
-0.0225435123,
0.018417621,
0.014713794,
0.0378672965,
-0.0530344322,
0.0013739166,
-0.0240231119,
-0.0087793553,
-0.0080912383,
-0.0936448276,
-0.0207416806,
-0.0077293376,
2.714e-7,
-0.0172439069,
0.0031862885,
0.0322420895,
0.0047545535,
0.0086255139,
-0.0247757453,
0.0034804044,
0.074114874,
-0.0221140794,
0.0239289403,
0.0187567063,
0.0008297077,
0.0464018546,
0.0067777238,
-0.0664932057,
0.0349835381,
-0.0531239957,
0.0673927367,
-0.0417428724,
-0.0511360839,
0.0014551968,
0.0348945372,
-0.0203944817,
-0.0238634329,
0.0282818209,
-0.0049790484,
0.0434045009,
0.0658461824,
0.0277439561,
-0.0076356614,
0.0452456027,
0.0023852359,
-0.0218414925,
-0.009072925,
-0.0419981442,
-0.0053701722,
-0.0116751054,
0.0218257792,
0.0181608163,
-0.0414824262,
0.0376439914,
-0.0110635227,
0.0075890105,
-0.0049211094,
0.0193636157,
-0.0501136482,
0.0232328083,
0.0042429403,
-0.0136547433,
-0.0062205996,
-0.021315366,
-0.0448869318,
-0.0373631828,
0.0326798372,
0.0189057626,
0.0173442867,
0.0134271849,
-0.0479705371,
-0.0047012689,
-0.0437553711,
-0.0434612967,
-0.0283385031,
-0.0830372423,
0.0349361263,
-0.0242900047,
-0.0465531908,
-0.0184247941,
2.45169344e-34,
0.0430824012,
-0.0435109846,
-0.0052582016,
0.0012186634,
0.004722748,
-0.0003321044,
0.0460331216,
0.0033548975,
0.0254646521,
-0.0189763531,
-0.0592662655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13741v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13741v3 | UPop: Unified and Progressive Pruning for Compressing Vision-Language Transformers | 2023-01-31T16:18:52 | 2023-06-30T03:25:27 | Dachuan Shi, Chaofan Tao, Ying Jin, Zhendong Yang, Chun Yuan, Jiaqi Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Real-world data contains a vast amount of multimodal information, among which
vision and language are the two most representative modalities. Moreover,
increasingly heavier models, \textit{e}.\textit{g}., Transformers, have
attracted the attention of researchers to model compression. However, how to
compress multimodal models, especially vison-language Transformers, is still
under-explored. This paper proposes the \textbf{U}nified and
\textbf{P}r\textbf{o}gressive \textbf{P}runing (\textbf{\emph{UPop}}) as a
universal vison-language Transformer compression framework, which incorporates
1) unifiedly searching multimodal subnets in a continuous optimization space
from the original model, which enables automatic assignment of pruning ratios
among compressible modalities and structures; 2) progressively searching and
retraining the subnet, which maintains convergence between the search and
retrain to attain higher compression ratios. Experiments on various tasks,
datasets, and model architectures demonstrate the effectiveness and versatility
of the proposed UPop framework. The code is available at
https://github.com/sdc17/UPop. | [
-0.0331950672,
0.0695202947,
-0.0056947893,
0.0356428027,
-0.0254826937,
-0.001471996,
-0.0284798443,
0.0439333059,
-0.0871708393,
-0.0192715265,
-0.0328231081,
-0.0027928739,
0.0347457305,
0.0057287719,
0.0262214821,
-0.0890682042,
0.009337741,
-0.005963678,
-0.0676348433,
0.0050127991,
0.000155267,
-0.011673687,
0.0043302029,
0.058854904,
0.0014503452,
0.0004444775,
-0.0117330207,
0.004973812,
-0.0152638694,
0.0369029678,
-0.0145416688,
0.0316759907,
0.0504213423,
-0.0065493663,
0.0000022388,
0.0024307792,
0.0156284999,
0.0213319492,
0.0015091929,
-0.0068486673,
0.0774371773,
-0.0690391362,
-0.00871104,
0.0144747002,
0.0164751634,
-0.0558588803,
0.0691140816,
0.0212942418,
0.0659838915,
0.0144159477,
-0.0115629574,
-0.036395967,
-0.0048125987,
-0.0180975813,
-0.0483591184,
0.0200897306,
0.0129181221,
0.0159841198,
-0.0388052464,
-0.0191273075,
-0.0464718044,
0.0356815569,
0.0185850058,
0.0117996456,
-0.0354195908,
-0.0107428282,
-0.0059494083,
-0.0650123507,
-0.0250036828,
0.0292296465,
-0.065807797,
-0.0162999686,
-0.0191031341,
0.01919006,
-0.0161389671,
-0.0159325544,
-0.0472143926,
0.0448146313,
0.0114451656,
0.013982947,
-0.0741988868,
0.016938651,
-0.0094576487,
-0.0442217998,
-0.0283595417,
-0.0036460105,
0.0188129954,
0.0424939841,
0.0021446452,
-0.0376806147,
-0.0077664456,
-0.0442511812,
0.0173139069,
0.0213763043,
0.0142060909,
-0.0433541052,
-0.0592138506,
-0.0439943299,
-0.0010426212,
-0.0242090374,
0.0850171745,
0.0441597924,
-0.00180888,
-0.006889686,
-0.0188520905,
0.0489551388,
-0.0578056872,
0.0384088196,
-0.0498109944,
-0.0332095027,
0.003856367,
-0.0152938506,
-0.0455352142,
-0.0177072324,
-0.0493272059,
-0.0060709422,
-0.0280185267,
0.0088813789,
0.0362547114,
-0.0660769343,
0.0239551999,
-0.0190495402,
-0.0550423637,
0.0132676233,
-0.0098667527,
0.0502880216,
0.0250399224,
-0.0013622892,
-0.0376070067,
-0.0284788311,
-0.0105224773,
0.0730218217,
-0.0128470268,
-0.0180457793,
0.0016155096,
0.072601743,
-0.0227018427,
-0.022541292,
-0.0019372946,
0.0011125511,
0.01465989,
-0.0233512316,
0.0280048065,
-0.0338375792,
0.0186894797,
-0.0448956564,
0.0075140451,
-0.0175187215,
-0.0065135374,
0.0271486007,
-0.0107421055,
0.0353811644,
0.0045214118,
0.0154803172,
0.0015333841,
-0.0169556886,
0.052305609,
0.0699988008,
0.0242383052,
0.0194061715,
-0.0282568596,
-0.0407379977,
-0.0024455737,
0.0653014779,
0.0366594568,
0.0204687025,
-0.0650604516,
-0.0489893407,
0.021498397,
-0.0011778004,
0.050788708,
0.0740153417,
-0.0561035164,
-0.0642748848,
0.0309582464,
0.002019013,
0.0739445612,
0.0566150397,
0.012371745,
-0.002215249,
-0.0126762399,
0.0062756157,
0.0036670784,
0.0459789485,
-0.0464602895,
-0.0160865337,
-0.0313276984,
0.0492340364,
-0.0363052934,
-0.0342159756,
-0.0193503462,
-0.0224893894,
0.040302109,
-0.0065482548,
0.030170979,
0.025669802,
-0.0452548042,
0.0672782734,
-0.004648509,
-0.0782304928,
-0.038979724,
-0.0628751069,
-0.0708600432,
-0.0161217842,
0.0301469658,
0.0302614663,
-0.0135473032,
-0.0017607451,
-0.0197441503,
0.004819538,
-0.0263344161,
0.0083051138,
0.0616283305,
-0.0426266678,
-0.0254306085,
0.045393344,
-0.0105654402,
-0.0092879385,
-0.0258704815,
-0.0128871193,
-0.0121462168,
-0.0171143003,
0.0386075117,
0.0552960671,
-0.0013349615,
0.0515105613,
-0.0046774563,
0.0144845266,
0.0224634428,
-0.0395366028,
-0.0169368945,
-0.0294370782,
0.0623143241,
-0.0675420016,
0.0006904519,
0.0043303501,
-0.0276469216,
-0.0191826001,
0.0531942993,
-0.0535524152,
0.0540502928,
0.0457448065,
-0.0187439006,
-0.0058722994,
-0.009739886,
-0.0728263631,
0.0186608117,
-0.0484762564,
-0.0024119068,
-0.0266898368,
0.0573428199,
-0.0076709054,
0.02693679,
-0.0613401793,
-0.0136384545,
0.038144201,
-0.0353941917,
0.0180778746,
-0.0036457407,
-0.0174821205,
0.0357024632,
-0.0293128844,
0.0011033469,
0.0555744544,
0.0088790515,
0.0520796068,
-0.047970172,
-0.0603685938,
0.0095863473,
-0.0213009715,
0.0022548882,
0.0028250264,
0.0303220451,
0.0168408826,
-0.0103666605,
0.0190206561,
0.0821106881,
0.0089766067,
0.0022577182,
0.0148698501,
0.0011242665,
-0.0171600226,
0.0220646001,
-0.0537339896,
0.0270386711,
0.0639364272,
-0.0403918475,
-0.0507314317,
-0.0514224321,
0.0710631013,
-0.0105861789,
0.0328186788,
-0.0183860194,
-0.0781446099,
-0.0282842964,
0.0220932197,
0.043376103,
0.0586192273,
0.031674657,
0.0421100855,
0.0536065213,
-0.001012841,
-0.0053516552,
0.0139009934,
-0.0433603302,
-0.0632927194,
-0.0298366174,
-0.0229463521,
-0.0241472293,
0.0589274727,
-0.0176021475,
0.0157510471,
-0.0740472749,
-0.0454359315,
0.0064998558,
-0.0550958253,
-0.0038692022,
-0.0030020396,
-0.0124497451,
0.0157977585,
0.0016309534,
-0.0248220135,
-0.010152461,
-0.0337694548,
-0.0051339259,
0.0144660939,
0.0185587741,
-0.0273582172,
0.0610187761,
0.0526759773,
0.0302635171,
0.0106210308,
0.0113203824,
-0.0606780946,
0.0127955312,
-0.0076423585,
-0.0225335136,
0.0221667513,
-0.0119330287,
0.0028064721,
-0.0460844412,
-0.0357204415,
-0.0041964455,
0.0091053592,
0.0168638099,
0.0043030595,
0.0024739758,
-0.0256501529,
-0.0692302585,
0.0481554903,
0.0075736884,
0.0400238223,
0.0275763031,
-0.0205735825,
0.0102689508,
-0.0031837076,
0.0075294608,
0.075524807,
0.0295402538,
-0.0122208362,
-0.0409687124,
0.0610902943,
0.0009519984,
0.0222233348,
-0.0720983967,
0.0018093158,
0.0540017821,
0.0679383278,
-0.0290467199,
0.0094040232,
0.0241336394,
-0.0445140824,
0.0259681139,
0.0154561829,
-0.0002369591,
-0.0282550585,
0.0139912376,
0.0076346789,
0.0791053623,
0.0401911028,
0.0355013944,
-0.0551588349,
-0.0337703042,
0.0268627964,
-0.0010191104,
0.031682428,
-0.002107305,
-0.0110585298,
-0.0572316162,
0.0608026423,
0.019883316,
0.0256060641,
-0.0077877264,
-0.0067934222,
0.0157262348,
-0.0384032428,
-0.0107797058,
0.0102155628,
-0.0324890576,
-0.001895992,
0.0285540055,
0.0102017997,
-0.0220912322,
-0.0279080067,
0.0065958886,
-0.0292079709,
0.043052122,
0.0308528263,
0.0166965444,
-0.0645836219,
0.0267884135,
-0.0051379316,
0.0112380646,
-0.0429604724,
0.0502383299,
0.0100769075,
-0.0066563012,
-0.0096851597,
0.0362971388,
-0.0395407118,
-0.0150022823,
-0.0526437908,
0.0257912446,
0.0082892654,
-0.0094385203,
-0.0569637455,
-0.0309352893,
-0.0410958901,
0.0266107935,
0.0020892455,
-0.0074763065,
-0.0215708073,
-0.0176641289,
0.0252646152,
-0.0050143953,
-0.0847572982,
0.0226669069,
0.0405032262,
-0.0749974698,
-0.0206016097,
0.0628471896,
-0.0004289428,
0.0683367103,
-0.0199815128,
-0.0784492642,
0.0090471553,
0.0413318165,
-0.0949516073,
0.0000632067,
-0.0166434702,
0.0233672373,
-0.0590028875,
0.0320254564,
0.024642799,
-0.0168705992,
-0.0205865335,
0.0194789171,
-0.0910548419,
-0.0024960754,
0.0105500659,
0.0801116303,
0.0241348557,
0.0411242619,
0.0329414718,
-0.0307231527,
0.0476957485,
0.0567376763,
-0.014577982,
0.0972040221,
0.0310100242,
-0.086178042,
0.019999437,
0.0197366402,
-0.028145127,
0.0277568419,
-0.0226106886,
0.0103222039,
0.0253043808,
-0.0248383097,
0.0344730467,
0.0188652687,
0.0225006081,
-0.0076312092,
0.0174454562,
0.011999418,
0.0218925737,
0.0095719751,
0.0254708249,
-0.0813805312,
0.040579468,
-0.0011842478,
-0.0068548196,
0.0480132028,
0.0321595706,
0.0669447556,
-0.0077166511,
0.0176486112,
0.0282281414,
0.010672194,
-0.035554219,
0.0250521842,
0.0592625886,
0.0176551472,
-0.0023391647,
0.0023693342,
0.0365718529,
-0.046536725,
0.0191997439,
0.0158799905,
0.0331754088,
-0.0505159386,
0.0411493108,
0.0258181337,
-0.0320277065,
-0.0660120621,
0.0154406363,
-0.0179558899,
0.0333520547,
0.0221420433,
-0.0426587537,
0.0171498675,
-0.0467874408,
0.0291356966,
0.0016304486,
-0.007022907,
0.038471289,
-0.0276695509,
-0.0254767593,
-0.034885738,
0.0742804036,
-0.0199950822,
0.0419989042,
-0.0238073226,
-0.0058896723,
-0.0563175678,
-0.0514284186,
-0.0087281857,
-0.0167637281,
0.0283108354,
-0.0086754179,
-0.0166436583,
-0.036501307,
-0.0241148174,
0.0179163646,
0.020368332,
0.0032822026,
0.0690803006,
0.0315882042,
-0.0026769547,
-0.0174023658,
0.0018476343,
-0.0469253547,
0.0019823581,
0.0048268582,
0.0707312226,
-5.944222201e-33,
-0.0486055352,
0.0221731625,
0.014891753,
-0.0166872535,
-0.0587170608,
0.0195185281,
-0.0110598123,
0.0052067963,
-0.0090228589,
-0.0168293864,
0.0125727402,
-0.0237166025,
-0.0048319609,
0.027686419,
-0.0353498682,
0.0309183989,
0.0599292442,
-0.0209857579,
-0.0295728315,
-0.0006771503,
0.0476023741,
-0.0069092247,
0.0414580889,
-0.0416161008,
-0.1000734866,
0.0425257944,
-0.0455012284,
0.0321224071,
0.0182483178,
0.0642131567,
-0.0557261221,
0.0042961366,
-0.0000411612,
-0.0038488,
-0.01915434,
0.0344962142,
-0.0629574284,
0.0009316452,
-0.0096161617,
0.0467028916,
-0.1010589004,
-0.0137291718,
0.0619109757,
0.0014400426,
-0.0388256386,
-0.0443583392,
-0.0008859568,
-0.0463861749,
-0.0162497032,
-0.0130533753,
-0.0361946821,
0.0001742557,
0.0062424163,
-0.0607171468,
0.0734657422,
0.0518716648,
-0.0098092789,
0.0072468459,
-0.0354987979,
0.0110795414,
0.007025341,
0.0638537332,
0.0717113018,
0.0051582404,
0.0313105397,
0.0460076667,
-0.0048151915,
-0.0703396648,
-0.0135217402,
-0.0232128873,
0.0611541457,
0.0332064703,
0.0335015282,
0.0536122732,
0.0330689177,
-0.0413541012,
-0.0291104745,
0.0178256817,
-0.0122529501,
0.0728074014,
0.0254291799,
0.0385549292,
0.0254536923,
-0.0118006058,
-0.0343369655,
-0.0299596786,
-0.0004467966,
-0.0250440314,
0.0192918591,
0.0400084965,
-0.0300300866,
-0.0081453631,
0.0774042457,
-0.0501927286,
0.0054057641,
0.0121240653,
-0.0373214073,
0.0559707247,
0.0129302992,
0.0214049648,
-0.0047153058,
0.0103006009,
0.0351048708,
-0.0220034923,
0.0304153319,
-0.0156874303,
-0.0131121501,
0.099799484,
-0.0320074372,
-0.0081052175,
-0.0228522643,
-0.0174270552,
0.0194109716,
0.0582904257,
0.0477320477,
0.0103012174,
-0.0183970332,
0.0297090616,
-0.0010020933,
-0.0334717073,
-0.0461620577,
-0.0174686015,
0.0774246678,
0.0483483523,
-0.0091739856,
-0.0076273684,
-0.0501591228,
-0.0166013893,
0.0391704105,
-0.0577602722,
-0.036821112,
0.0806026161,
2.811e-7,
0.0388105921,
0.036939092,
0.0127350027,
-0.0464754812,
0.0200153906,
0.0395027734,
0.0243723541,
-0.0010394905,
-0.0269558281,
-0.0478055812,
0.0050720572,
0.0133573599,
0.0307970606,
-0.0025607822,
-0.018383218,
0.0194977224,
-0.0113215167,
-0.0353512578,
-0.0040585957,
-0.0194397606,
0.0354671329,
0.1121870279,
-0.0159472264,
-0.0240919217,
0.0085015381,
0.0141139962,
0.0447972678,
-0.0267444234,
0.0210638177,
-0.0051938584,
-0.0196201615,
0.0050773267,
-0.0104730353,
-0.0166765619,
0.0086900182,
-0.0046986742,
0.0252566896,
0.0193040203,
-0.031061992,
-0.0226175264,
0.0369629003,
0.0343478248,
-0.0789851621,
-0.039645914,
0.0439947061,
-0.0375723355,
-0.0059374948,
-0.0475417227,
-0.0051764827,
0.0353908837,
-0.001643172,
-0.0138768265,
0.0141593879,
0.0421679765,
0.0302689131,
0.0143820783,
-0.0535240769,
-0.0318826735,
0.0082330406,
-0.0346033797,
-0.0708049983,
0.0011477674,
-0.0443856567,
0.0012002999,
0.0370605327,
-0.0078260554,
-0.060640268,
2.952231792e-34,
-0.0079612508,
0.0021170981,
0.0083850324,
0.0049629919,
-0.0309379734,
-0.0309387054,
0.0074814046,
0.0194614623,
-0.0623053685,
-0.0480599776,
-0.0422712639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13720v1 | Zero-shot cross-lingual transfer language selection using linguistic similarity | 2023-01-31T15:56:40 | 2023-01-31T15:56:40 | Juuso Eronen, Michal Ptaszynski, Fumito Masui | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study the selection of transfer languages for different Natural Language
Processing tasks, specifically sentiment analysis, named entity recognition and
dependency parsing. In order to select an optimal transfer language, we propose
to utilize different linguistic similarity metrics to measure the distance
between languages and make the choice of transfer language based on this
information instead of relying on intuition. We demonstrate that linguistic
similarity correlates with cross-lingual transfer performance for all of the
proposed tasks. We also show that there is a statistically significant
difference in choosing the optimal language as the transfer source instead of
English. This allows us to select a more suitable transfer language which can
be used to better leverage knowledge from high-resource languages in order to
improve the performance of language applications lacking data. For the study,
we used datasets from eight different languages from three language families. | [
-0.0010188966,
0.0548364632,
-0.0098894788,
0.0499033779,
-0.0713116899,
0.045951955,
-0.010069401,
0.0153809534,
0.009447922,
-0.046449665,
-0.0218796637,
-0.0143021047,
-0.0008484964,
-0.027510725,
-0.0057982416,
-0.0537328534,
0.0276369918,
0.0017833636,
-0.0037014715,
-0.0013784033,
-0.0000712826,
0.0214334913,
0.0028297815,
-0.0134530943,
0.0120391091,
0.036283195,
0.0335621126,
-0.0153277935,
0.0082834344,
-0.0411192439,
-0.0184742827,
0.0127385138,
-0.0142098758,
0.0126056131,
0.0000019037,
-0.0622757338,
-0.0582051724,
-0.0019334466,
0.0379937217,
-0.0536255799,
0.0707005933,
-0.0823668465,
-0.0085039083,
0.0002086224,
-0.0207628664,
-0.0632648021,
0.0773748681,
0.0198144913,
0.0165068861,
0.0840075165,
-0.0437678769,
-0.0302755125,
-0.0059874654,
0.0077117477,
-0.0028817658,
-0.0380039662,
0.003214445,
0.0087074712,
0.0005312066,
-0.0017384021,
-0.0141965933,
0.0134839443,
-0.0393972471,
-0.0012907182,
-0.011891081,
0.0013970794,
-0.0448743477,
0.0093664173,
0.0081566554,
0.0430526994,
-0.0330165289,
-0.0273040663,
0.0193682201,
-0.003227425,
-0.032958664,
0.0064514778,
-0.0382728092,
-0.0023217786,
0.0080059161,
0.0595245324,
0.0832630917,
0.0316169038,
-0.0116931098,
-0.0128254425,
-0.0245140512,
0.0657232776,
0.0216866415,
-0.0181113873,
0.0533604436,
0.0732585117,
0.0365182571,
-0.0447347946,
0.0128161162,
-0.0293577295,
0.0062075797,
0.0277576186,
-0.0453350693,
-0.0152629558,
-0.017288154,
-0.0566145889,
0.0048963106,
0.0520526171,
-0.0008923468,
0.0504350103,
-0.0700875819,
0.0081049502,
0.0284408163,
-0.0355068631,
-0.023740856,
-0.0640805811,
-0.1012248546,
0.0374693908,
-0.000501534,
0.0372991487,
-0.018368626,
0.0039565242,
-0.0255278759,
-0.0092586484,
-0.0116564101,
0.0036773353,
0.0267731827,
-0.0578485616,
-0.007423149,
0.0074131265,
-0.0397587121,
0.0758868903,
-0.0080516282,
-0.0047489572,
-0.0505857356,
-0.0588987134,
0.016690135,
0.0371471457,
0.0086895078,
-0.0660353005,
0.0138585642,
0.06940981,
0.0123930434,
-0.0092924144,
-0.0868885592,
0.0369293839,
0.0097721564,
-0.0510982759,
0.0218282435,
-0.0804245695,
0.0443448611,
0.0308156628,
0.0247963779,
-0.0253109746,
0.0052913884,
-0.0103305662,
-0.0504834764,
0.043208845,
-0.0351015441,
-0.0049599907,
-0.0032008863,
-0.049015265,
-0.0147859911,
0.0812461078,
-0.0132879307,
-0.0241924617,
0.0611161403,
-0.0449620374,
-0.0509862714,
0.0082558617,
-0.0166956726,
0.0201330557,
-0.0379991718,
-0.0149676576,
-0.0157651789,
-0.0366223864,
0.0388611741,
0.0070831999,
-0.0040266393,
0.0215744264,
0.0100577371,
0.0589789748,
-0.0077755298,
0.020524092,
0.0127121946,
-0.0013721463,
-0.0470731147,
-0.0012852169,
-0.0096781282,
0.0468050949,
0.0091507165,
-0.0214598309,
-0.0141639132,
0.0304153934,
-0.0167878717,
0.004572703,
0.0152833611,
-0.0496849194,
0.0091977147,
-0.009541003,
0.0550195351,
0.0126108639,
-0.0348646976,
0.0664270073,
0.0734587163,
-0.0380872004,
0.0003003605,
0.0117843747,
0.0053575779,
0.0752771422,
-0.0206096023,
-0.0008989542,
-0.0009027412,
-0.0075166384,
0.0165577047,
0.0264229029,
0.0520603247,
-0.0115555367,
0.0245404299,
-0.0383161306,
-0.0213413332,
0.0277665239,
0.0054257368,
0.0295776781,
-0.0402124375,
0.0822623,
0.0012642252,
-0.0100464728,
-0.0440866686,
0.0123634934,
-0.0256338958,
-0.0162270237,
0.0506647229,
0.0175489765,
0.0329567604,
0.033545699,
-0.0099218907,
-0.0191104226,
-0.038545616,
-0.0646169037,
-0.0252144821,
0.0364648476,
0.004445842,
-0.0404272303,
-0.0035553065,
-0.0609861203,
0.0140257226,
0.0160108581,
-0.0287952647,
-0.0420146734,
0.0241371039,
-0.0017970814,
0.0658187345,
-0.0105374716,
0.0356405191,
-0.0263745412,
0.0232689772,
-0.0103594521,
0.0541504584,
0.0371125601,
0.0456057377,
-0.0241963957,
-0.0553013496,
0.0446439683,
-0.0060143145,
-0.0321352147,
0.0573625006,
-0.0039262986,
-0.0291033387,
0.0405375212,
0.0088392058,
-0.0284592621,
0.0090802563,
-0.0918134749,
0.0089360392,
-0.0034631374,
0.0671374351,
0.0254529901,
0.0274429861,
-0.004544016,
-0.0056047449,
-0.0231533367,
0.0148319062,
-0.0145635717,
0.0297631323,
0.0362472646,
-0.0145900222,
0.0256402902,
-0.0339393467,
-0.0008523869,
0.0218547191,
0.0348144062,
-0.0015563529,
-0.053112112,
-0.0283482615,
0.0769850388,
-0.0412999466,
0.0000216975,
0.0342989899,
-0.0203919411,
-0.0197029449,
-0.0221718736,
-0.0167816542,
-0.0039543249,
-0.0334221907,
-0.037164852,
0.0290299691,
-0.0318768807,
-0.0539352596,
-0.0168789681,
-0.0293892417,
0.0380465761,
-0.0214046966,
-0.0534329414,
0.0260230657,
0.0402673185,
-0.0135295605,
-0.0161666349,
-0.0469888486,
-0.0229592677,
-0.058961425,
0.035140954,
0.0202939026,
0.0648652688,
0.0486001372,
0.0302819479,
0.0155063644,
0.0178245548,
0.0499608181,
-0.0223847218,
0.0258458499,
-0.0770817474,
-0.0056501362,
-0.0337341018,
0.0200360734,
-0.01269673,
0.0081613855,
-0.0182089023,
-0.0295195561,
0.0207139906,
0.0129728541,
0.0480433255,
0.0224828199,
0.0236324519,
-0.02948769,
0.0346533917,
-0.0046690023,
-0.0280407257,
0.0108389985,
0.0128583014,
-0.0357405543,
0.0038082821,
0.0160162617,
-0.0015846188,
-0.0086991116,
0.0142308818,
0.0093100304,
0.0116809951,
0.0216374788,
-0.0094630327,
0.0143696498,
0.0144887734,
0.0100183329,
-0.0113997143,
-0.0069001326,
0.0236660019,
0.0177111812,
-0.0031292953,
0.0225593112,
0.0057426225,
-0.0182349011,
0.0060059945,
0.0345623828,
-0.028406065,
-0.0581362173,
-0.0395597033,
0.0339734554,
-0.0150596835,
0.0289014205,
0.1033435464,
0.0093508037,
-0.0408942662,
-0.0073568239,
-0.024463715,
-0.0078373505,
0.030261958,
0.0329957381,
-0.0576215461,
-0.0384402871,
-0.0100572696,
0.0175716039,
-0.0074666091,
-0.0557502247,
0.006589782,
-0.1438192874,
0.0049985223,
-0.016500691,
-0.0682569668,
-0.0326530971,
-0.065523006,
0.017721694,
-0.0517298058,
-0.0079144686,
-0.0693787783,
-0.0044794045,
0.0017999936,
0.0086696772,
-0.0257303491,
-0.0738569126,
0.0052518779,
-0.0057282471,
0.0304398667,
0.0189145599,
0.0643700585,
-0.0316391699,
0.0037148041,
0.0062544905,
-0.0431690104,
-0.0339795537,
-0.0414538756,
0.0654606149,
0.0380783975,
-0.0331473611,
0.0215380564,
-0.0099792806,
-0.0347780921,
0.0353806354,
0.0273965634,
0.0917429924,
0.0141393282,
-0.0294447988,
0.0455826186,
-0.028230004,
0.0544838682,
0.071429193,
-0.0025007608,
-0.0447693095,
-0.0329168104,
0.012345491,
-0.0198069531,
-0.059802033,
-0.0128188292,
0.0116752079,
-0.0610739216,
-0.0639372095,
-0.0835026205,
-0.0288430639,
0.0364383608,
0.017834004,
0.0159133244,
0.0389585644,
0.0507084578,
-0.024411764,
0.0012176961,
0.0039316593,
0.0118149705,
0.0142132752,
-0.0329793617,
-0.0294697713,
0.0274215359,
0.0099996645,
-0.0165509228,
-0.0640705153,
-0.0328537747,
-0.043305736,
-0.0139244096,
0.0237907134,
0.0025453432,
0.0278976541,
0.0031572061,
-0.0487888232,
-0.0168061722,
0.0379561447,
-0.0459756441,
-0.0388269164,
0.05094558,
0.0256603826,
0.0019890398,
0.0610401407,
-0.0128081879,
0.0158415996,
0.0218177047,
0.038043905,
-0.0122018596,
0.0055106441,
0.0125917085,
0.0500497445,
0.0267744698,
-0.0098265195,
-0.0188063104,
-0.0366790928,
0.0059960005,
-0.0181538686,
0.0080054421,
-0.0395870209,
-0.0355599411,
0.0416967683,
0.0141216144,
-0.005944374,
0.0161311515,
-0.0266373884,
-0.018651519,
-0.0195234176,
0.0738451555,
0.0359026939,
0.0826086551,
0.0275305621,
0.0209638067,
-0.0164283663,
-0.0252447929,
0.059910845,
0.026608618,
-0.0853965506,
0.0038753725,
0.0176090691,
0.028055951,
0.0391701348,
-0.0176875331,
0.0131646991,
-0.0053249961,
0.0235613585,
0.0143234218,
0.0635878593,
-0.0817708597,
0.1255230308,
-0.0124950893,
-0.0022006535,
-0.0068427734,
0.0373708867,
-0.0022567513,
-0.0073357988,
-0.0018365956,
-0.0034336131,
-0.0195778552,
0.0192896016,
0.0745635405,
-0.0621903203,
0.00341127,
-0.0035020125,
0.0085657174,
-0.0117796063,
-0.0023108742,
0.0443745479,
-0.0241389219,
-0.001004313,
0.0309829358,
-0.0250116568,
-0.0717654005,
0.0104639148,
-0.079791598,
-0.041014567,
0.019947974,
0.0313586704,
0.045229651,
0.014869174,
0.0523355938,
-0.0462227575,
0.0016354785,
-0.008486093,
-0.0224249344,
-0.0250462331,
-6.107783791e-33,
0.0008798872,
0.0044784429,
-0.0143729951,
0.0478952155,
0.0144259576,
-0.0092438683,
-0.0386395045,
-0.0026794462,
-0.0215778761,
0.0125017725,
-0.0000854713,
-0.0311159715,
0.0322261788,
0.053085465,
0.0230133887,
-0.0051938938,
-0.0064279209,
0.0019606645,
-0.0008715377,
0.0188675784,
0.0732997209,
0.0472549424,
0.0946100801,
-0.0906897262,
0.0394922197,
0.0396474041,
0.0364454277,
0.0122400373,
0.1028560922,
0.0247854944,
0.005109611,
0.0350735113,
0.0225851797,
-0.067303963,
0.0080138911,
-0.0181590971,
-0.0556662716,
-0.0892716944,
0.0207953807,
0.0366735198,
0.0293604806,
-0.0097035998,
-0.0109431176,
-0.0163615216,
0.0120143676,
0.0069901058,
0.0248724651,
-0.0440454893,
-0.0000133367,
-0.0251072589,
-0.1087391526,
0.0316412449,
-0.0068972888,
0.0668253377,
0.0911821425,
0.0711022764,
-0.004251786,
0.0037795613,
-0.0432187952,
0.0218247939,
-0.0811197087,
0.0265544839,
0.0670589283,
-0.0444568917,
-0.0100428937,
0.0322279781,
0.0185720921,
-0.0346612521,
0.0415720455,
0.0697548538,
0.0271794498,
0.0144372806,
0.0080976393,
0.045323398,
0.0219876785,
-0.0488603152,
-0.0642567873,
0.0112766512,
0.0387368649,
-0.0175255984,
-0.0027847921,
0.0217715204,
-0.0350530483,
-0.0336374789,
0.0125927627,
-0.0302013978,
-0.0154463965,
-0.0522034876,
0.0019362402,
-0.0445873439,
-0.0308907237,
-0.0036862479,
0.0522772148,
-0.0284071714,
-0.0755599737,
-0.0013026968,
-0.0353862122,
0.0152476318,
0.0107387872,
0.0148567306,
-0.073847115,
-0.0565645657,
-0.0356396735,
-0.0061976407,
0.0392104611,
-0.0078790318,
0.0421812274,
0.0155560672,
-0.0585927591,
0.0013929046,
-0.0288474187,
0.0194499828,
-0.0120405955,
0.0694028139,
-0.023331074,
0.0008779833,
-0.0067474772,
0.017278811,
0.0476570427,
-0.011401454,
0.0120852878,
-0.0126353437,
0.0018497974,
-0.0037319453,
-0.0421616398,
-0.023320239,
-0.011551749,
0.0041912533,
0.0010551678,
-0.0296692401,
-0.0421117432,
0.0143017406,
2.745e-7,
0.0394415148,
0.0259421524,
-0.0481399149,
-0.0257862397,
-0.005325627,
0.0162544753,
-0.028063098,
0.0364925936,
0.0057705827,
0.0071762698,
-0.0256275628,
-0.0153574478,
0.0532298982,
0.0725842044,
-0.0979284644,
-0.0017503272,
0.021457037,
-0.0248390585,
-0.017234711,
0.0326268338,
0.0528300367,
0.060500592,
0.0048966589,
0.0027042462,
-0.0219311919,
-0.0080012744,
0.0160519145,
-0.0491185188,
-0.0033097912,
0.0259186197,
-0.0116625531,
0.0228152275,
-0.0481699221,
0.0332203656,
-0.0371734239,
0.021916138,
0.0397689529,
0.0113001475,
0.017766092,
-0.0205180794,
0.0010517843,
-0.0065519488,
0.0031506927,
-0.0351299755,
0.0753595084,
-0.0461786054,
-0.0365422927,
-0.0132811246,
-0.0033132578,
0.0255777538,
0.0071901572,
0.0039650695,
-0.0427044593,
0.017860407,
0.0606543235,
-0.0195542499,
-0.0835222229,
0.0119479289,
0.026360523,
0.0249876492,
0.0165001675,
-0.0101871481,
0.0260995962,
0.0153069934,
0.0308516268,
0.0097709475,
0.052782394,
2.172062849e-34,
-0.0024873777,
0.0156694502,
0.0052841636,
-0.0199467894,
0.0070281196,
-0.0133198826,
-0.0573403426,
0.0165914875,
-0.037051443,
-0.0226014312,
0.0183954146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13714v1 | Recursive Neural Networks with Bottlenecks Diagnose (Non-)Compositionality | 2023-01-31T15:46:39 | 2023-01-31T15:46:39 | Verna Dankers, Ivan Titov | cs.CL | cs.CL | A recent line of work in NLP focuses on the (dis)ability of models to
generalise compositionally for artificial languages. However, when considering
natural language tasks, the data involved is not strictly, or locally,
compositional. Quantifying the compositionality of data is a challenging task,
which has been investigated primarily for short utterances. We use recursive
neural models (Tree-LSTMs) with bottlenecks that limit the transfer of
information between nodes. We illustrate that comparing data's representations
in models with and without the bottleneck can be used to produce a
compositionality metric. The procedure is applied to the evaluation of
arithmetic expressions using synthetic data, and sentiment classification using
natural language data. We demonstrate that compression through a bottleneck
impacts non-compositional examples disproportionately and then use the
bottleneck compositionality metric (BCM) to distinguish compositional from
non-compositional samples, yielding a compositionality ranking over a dataset. | [
-0.0048341048,
0.0933958665,
-0.004989936,
0.0173811521,
-0.0374753401,
0.0138985971,
-0.015478136,
0.0050106766,
-0.0603982955,
-0.0391988307,
-0.0197340418,
-0.0701102465,
0.0630216449,
0.0099924551,
0.0029554216,
-0.011691126,
0.0236847438,
0.0162701383,
0.003337689,
0.0030098062,
-0.0033926228,
-0.002418896,
0.0090360558,
0.0304933265,
-0.0244813263,
-0.0096411053,
0.0106263598,
-0.014578294,
-0.0248538293,
0.0206705872,
0.0062987525,
0.0290976632,
0.007319795,
0.0532578267,
0.0000017159,
-0.020107938,
0.0318629555,
-0.0101936143,
-0.0480267368,
-0.0088284835,
0.0662109777,
-0.0083625717,
0.0018776027,
0.0047603459,
-0.0384293199,
-0.0177242644,
0.0669968724,
0.0230198652,
0.0437567234,
0.0916683674,
0.0038576261,
-0.0480010733,
-0.01341209,
-0.0144125726,
0.0217117537,
0.0218682773,
0.0107737435,
-0.0269435141,
-0.0078837257,
-0.0519176759,
-0.0463593565,
0.0093960064,
0.0575429238,
0.0093238847,
0.0270538926,
0.0206332766,
-0.0066333413,
0.0325669125,
0.0174357332,
0.0664195865,
0.0025957869,
-0.0180712026,
0.0100586452,
-0.0033497487,
-0.0078173699,
-0.0458179004,
-0.0260349568,
0.0341525227,
0.000918497,
0.013977902,
-0.0305942576,
0.0218995996,
0.0706625655,
-0.0005507512,
-0.0236482285,
0.0426002145,
0.0006760134,
-0.0524360053,
0.0142938737,
-0.013112898,
0.0386119299,
-0.0392191522,
-0.0129432185,
0.0303032994,
0.000125966,
0.0091372933,
-0.0035211397,
-0.0289011709,
-0.0031016958,
-0.0458959192,
0.0464408137,
0.0193620659,
0.0269787237,
0.0273035765,
-0.0260261949,
0.0478725992,
-0.00449774,
0.0018173484,
-0.0405481905,
-0.0026653041,
-0.0752650872,
-0.0361968912,
0.0093415193,
0.0791648477,
-0.0065517714,
-0.0352151804,
-0.0601506792,
-0.0052675866,
-0.0623054393,
0.0032811277,
0.0171289053,
-0.001653436,
-0.0048577981,
0.0179453883,
-0.0111838924,
0.0299363844,
-0.0227573197,
0.0238837935,
-0.0073561915,
-0.0189216211,
-0.004490369,
0.0228209086,
-0.0245221481,
0.0040942552,
-0.0066740108,
0.0503828712,
0.0357750729,
0.0028695292,
0.0022809536,
-0.0191960894,
-0.0374207161,
-0.0673853308,
0.032893803,
-0.0814219639,
0.0295210294,
-0.0178878754,
0.006694925,
-0.032302279,
-0.0007086638,
0.0181082319,
-0.0031641026,
0.0751344711,
0.0373095796,
0.0050213202,
-0.0312795788,
-0.0148269134,
0.0276113413,
0.0737820044,
0.0736418217,
0.003272309,
0.0150441388,
-0.0327597074,
-0.0044303969,
-0.0153451208,
-0.0051679071,
-0.0221583415,
-0.0452082977,
-0.0326811075,
-0.0549674407,
0.0331547,
0.0072270241,
0.0639344007,
-0.0424672142,
-0.0549943745,
0.0248787049,
0.0069260621,
0.0623607859,
0.0193100274,
0.0564058013,
-0.0066125328,
-0.0005698594,
0.0699763969,
-0.0435099155,
0.0224409606,
-0.0265037902,
0.0224449392,
0.0363939889,
-0.006669133,
-0.0227009729,
-0.0605158284,
-0.0305356607,
-0.0348060802,
0.0630707815,
-0.0473720729,
0.0358764529,
0.0369989239,
0.0020082886,
0.0307156444,
-0.0092937369,
-0.0765328929,
0.0117490068,
-0.0091187377,
0.0111784153,
0.0388004966,
0.0053095496,
-0.0307701919,
0.0327281766,
-0.0075852363,
-0.005410614,
0.0297564995,
0.0112177283,
-0.0021390242,
0.0406573191,
-0.0514148772,
0.0086468691,
-0.0320378952,
0.0416093469,
0.0072219502,
-0.0166961048,
-0.0146111082,
0.0203272868,
-0.0541784167,
0.008591041,
0.0026917947,
0.0390398763,
-0.000837282,
0.0575944073,
0.0226437822,
0.0286626536,
0.0074858153,
-0.0053482275,
0.0579276681,
0.0100611951,
-0.0341634713,
-0.0948446393,
0.0004770354,
-0.0646482632,
-0.0353289172,
0.0074381507,
-0.0820451826,
-0.0087295156,
0.0167210996,
-0.037730813,
-0.0574713014,
0.0862364024,
-0.0874108076,
0.0176023506,
-0.0346143879,
0.0043435865,
-0.0011186078,
0.011733464,
-0.0011967815,
0.0580529012,
-0.0019760334,
0.0406178497,
-0.0011075328,
-0.0394823365,
0.028560238,
-0.0025405362,
-0.0464297645,
-0.0122015188,
-0.0220463388,
0.0103246933,
0.0077308239,
-0.0121748345,
-0.0301178545,
-0.0423262343,
-0.0654098988,
-0.0087541994,
-0.0329077356,
0.0542902052,
0.0062170946,
0.0192051362,
0.0415025465,
0.0263181441,
-0.0421670228,
-0.0220433511,
-0.0070429742,
0.0588751175,
0.061385449,
0.0079626171,
-0.0171324629,
-0.0190359913,
-0.0490563773,
-0.0472648405,
0.0614772849,
-0.0292161945,
-0.0164782014,
-0.0044543995,
-0.0238900967,
-0.0086809993,
-0.0074972673,
0.0062887529,
-0.0437588952,
0.00156713,
0.0009725288,
0.0394529551,
0.0700112954,
-0.0185612012,
0.0087038996,
0.0541231595,
-0.0099601233,
-0.0189140439,
0.0165222157,
-0.0357328691,
0.036846377,
-0.0005802706,
-0.0155832144,
0.0098894518,
0.0761431754,
0.0072773192,
-0.0204320233,
-0.038233038,
0.0403533764,
-0.0381727368,
0.0247938037,
-0.0337308198,
-0.0363549031,
-0.015148947,
0.0117265033,
-0.0055139652,
-0.0297057685,
0.059135668,
-0.0179421138,
0.0001151691,
-0.0041177152,
-0.0007873456,
-0.0925450623,
0.0399326012,
0.020888783,
-0.0261733085,
0.0028540893,
-0.0260765851,
-0.0245118309,
0.0366323553,
0.0186317638,
-0.004930554,
0.0256391726,
-0.0068244687,
0.0029992249,
-0.0245345403,
-0.055688668,
0.0142878555,
0.0067902328,
0.0267587174,
0.0286276396,
0.0488194413,
-0.0379536189,
0.0011391109,
-0.0054747392,
0.0015754083,
0.0010801512,
-0.0208878405,
0.0044714608,
0.0100532072,
0.0352075323,
0.0001139384,
0.05767617,
0.0664010271,
-0.0096677225,
0.0297510903,
0.0025652258,
0.0097678835,
0.0524063371,
-0.0516371168,
0.0141366767,
-0.027155295,
-0.0198339578,
-0.0314387009,
0.0433346108,
-0.0013092865,
-0.0921154544,
-0.0044283592,
0.0958896726,
0.0069188131,
-0.0370565355,
0.0029212274,
0.0081968587,
-0.0104741836,
0.0262767673,
-0.0162580311,
-0.0700030997,
-0.0234954357,
0.0122510362,
-0.0382536985,
-0.0398630574,
-0.0346587114,
-0.0124340514,
-0.1239692196,
-0.0077851871,
0.0085221184,
-0.0731421411,
-0.0438848063,
-0.0179483704,
-0.0111746704,
-0.0109205758,
-0.0142170778,
-0.0087400991,
-0.0323424637,
-0.0086478936,
-0.0026086087,
-0.1145102084,
-0.0316766724,
0.011897116,
0.0035285729,
0.0200404674,
0.0383923501,
0.0395037383,
-0.0254826471,
-0.0257994346,
0.0427661203,
-0.0501343012,
-0.0185157768,
0.0095408764,
0.0075358259,
-0.0012114194,
-0.0066304826,
0.0467533059,
0.012027909,
-0.0501132756,
0.051896587,
-0.0399120897,
0.0730142444,
0.0054984968,
-0.054840032,
-0.0274700075,
0.0336945504,
0.0214603189,
0.0903415829,
0.1006624699,
-0.0163786523,
-0.0504804365,
-0.0204002634,
-0.0258437246,
-0.0525892191,
0.0130536901,
0.0528056137,
0.0815538317,
0.019858567,
-0.0822823569,
-0.0515707396,
-0.0230580438,
-0.0047713332,
-0.0250683036,
0.0199412685,
-0.0145674217,
-0.0322222672,
-0.0559850782,
-0.025119653,
0.0002471427,
0.039901223,
-0.0361079983,
0.0374952704,
0.0009640825,
0.0090103699,
-0.0307208709,
-0.0424650051,
-0.1265451312,
-0.0434962958,
-0.0339506678,
0.004372682,
0.0207498726,
-0.0026616815,
-0.0195153151,
-0.0658757389,
0.0013160058,
0.0538608134,
-0.03739715,
0.0162084177,
0.0683402568,
-0.0055089118,
0.0307564288,
0.047393892,
-0.0424834341,
0.0200173929,
0.0098716058,
0.0106975315,
0.0184279922,
0.0050052097,
0.004747611,
-0.0156505741,
0.0140530253,
0.0478781126,
0.015928207,
0.0100840051,
0.0052171564,
-0.0284395106,
-0.0242922436,
-0.0509773754,
-0.0292372592,
-0.0041344953,
0.0370207019,
-0.0281071234,
-0.0112814913,
0.0231629219,
0.0244952906,
0.0004657371,
0.0355580039,
0.046042148,
-0.054419294,
-0.0186388083,
0.0181594733,
-0.0130591653,
0.0247525554,
-0.0008442744,
-0.012652236,
0.0201198775,
-0.0034662972,
0.0182632487,
0.0572115257,
-0.035267435,
0.0111831166,
-0.0450791754,
0.0171149392,
-0.0167383943,
-0.0229815356,
0.0249872021,
-0.0346369185,
0.0012874162,
-0.0092241969,
0.0220324956,
-0.0434766151,
0.0228206813,
0.0085335914,
-0.0127526857,
0.0461995006,
0.0409320742,
-0.0314215533,
0.0135105802,
0.0789485425,
0.0014990706,
0.01843502,
0.0264794733,
0.0417460389,
-0.0018965561,
-0.0475958548,
-0.0029762012,
0.0381026529,
0.0329495147,
-0.0051633548,
-0.0739031509,
-0.0468751863,
0.032039199,
0.0162033029,
0.0474486575,
-0.0076051611,
0.0585859455,
0.0279374942,
-0.0137484157,
0.0168118346,
0.005389655,
-0.0425647721,
-0.0007785835,
-0.0046079028,
-0.0219290145,
-5.874241349e-33,
-0.0041966611,
-0.0371727198,
-0.0132895093,
0.0144650647,
-0.0403593779,
0.052767124,
-0.0143135507,
-0.0044925488,
-0.0123821013,
0.0390647352,
-0.0109045831,
0.0248249564,
0.0008129241,
0.0299573056,
0.0224055033,
0.004302796,
0.0373043902,
0.0104810745,
-0.0347137824,
0.0011530508,
0.0417869166,
-0.0081938189,
0.0618485399,
-0.0207060501,
0.0038698644,
0.0488215834,
-0.0184390079,
0.0099721458,
-0.0158391241,
0.0865571722,
0.0030406804,
0.0871329978,
0.0458899066,
-0.0514362231,
-0.0239542499,
0.0406749211,
-0.0180471279,
-0.0674443841,
0.0090057338,
-0.0141514735,
-0.0604243241,
-0.0373842567,
0.1124879643,
-0.003529547,
-0.0114053171,
-0.0679249465,
0.0287256967,
-0.0023359212,
-0.0205624178,
-0.0865559652,
-0.0598086789,
0.0301478133,
-0.0093280198,
0.0117221028,
0.0136929406,
0.0002811808,
-0.0421754457,
0.021072492,
-0.0779736191,
0.0288731661,
-0.0239874199,
0.0677532926,
0.0062351855,
-0.0450933762,
0.0116529316,
0.0306984019,
0.0200871453,
0.0358255208,
-0.0332023241,
0.0329769962,
0.0281894207,
0.0312529206,
0.0891720504,
0.0317331068,
0.0953837708,
0.0168847628,
-0.0303900987,
-0.0209588725,
-0.0059881145,
0.037289951,
0.0059593692,
-0.015889015,
-0.041817911,
-0.0292364229,
-0.0541614778,
-0.0087119257,
-0.0373297818,
-0.0289624333,
0.0116701601,
-0.0121965539,
0.0325209908,
-0.0251786411,
0.0012226326,
-0.0590017326,
-0.0001401139,
0.0361066908,
-0.0062577967,
0.031790182,
0.0452554077,
0.0053284476,
-0.0374311171,
-0.0005225503,
0.0012853111,
0.0549886599,
0.0246908478,
-0.0048588826,
0.0514133982,
0.031180596,
-0.0612139069,
-0.0404241607,
0.0040358515,
-0.0110976072,
-0.0486277193,
0.0273401272,
0.0622372702,
0.0320410654,
-0.0171084981,
0.0545199551,
-0.0263074562,
0.0320971273,
-0.0281476919,
-0.0215051956,
-0.000909407,
0.0206228103,
-0.0156990085,
-0.0487755165,
-0.003569707,
-0.0022171899,
0.0512680262,
-0.0281450339,
-0.0002402058,
0.0103738494,
2.589e-7,
0.0318035521,
0.0275030714,
0.0273260362,
0.0097673768,
0.0634551048,
0.0045207846,
-0.0198972151,
0.0086402381,
-0.0728269219,
-0.0490237139,
0.0292376336,
-0.0036748175,
0.070741035,
0.0022687721,
-0.0950930715,
0.0498981476,
-0.1111143902,
0.0067348415,
-0.0134357205,
-0.0106305154,
0.0244413968,
0.0944010764,
0.0085770739,
0.002331672,
-0.0095758475,
-0.0118765766,
0.0456763655,
-0.0031543954,
0.0161881559,
-0.0075163594,
0.0357453302,
-0.0104729328,
0.0262919571,
0.00408766,
-0.0046551051,
0.0481605493,
0.0041772113,
0.0303216446,
0.0134155573,
-0.0176513493,
0.0085422378,
-0.0212610494,
-0.0179688521,
0.0097735943,
0.0382500403,
-0.0616641641,
-0.0456548855,
-0.0491431057,
0.0175115336,
-0.0041986355,
0.0785323232,
0.0189530887,
0.0009017066,
0.0203567035,
0.0090220859,
-0.0251734946,
0.0112888552,
-0.0858010128,
-0.0155526157,
-0.0155602507,
-0.0453881733,
0.0171753634,
-0.0395452194,
0.0124298716,
0.0540856794,
-0.0389934145,
-0.0367418304,
2.425614915e-34,
0.0783054978,
-0.0466273092,
0.03867165,
0.0077413255,
0.0354755223,
-0.0056488952,
-0.0578497574,
0.0038349398,
0.019254081,
-0.0742187276,
-0.0206219442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13688v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13688v2 | The Flan Collection: Designing Data and Methods for Effective Instruction Tuning | 2023-01-31T15:03:44 | 2023-02-14T16:33:33 | Shayne Longpre, Le Hou, Tu Vu, Albert Webson, Hyung Won Chung, Yi Tay, Denny Zhou, Quoc V. Le, Barret Zoph, Jason Wei, Adam Roberts | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We study the design decisions of publicly available instruction tuning
methods, and break down the development of Flan 2022 (Chung et al., 2022).
Through careful ablation studies on the Flan Collection of tasks and methods,
we tease apart the effect of design decisions which enable Flan-T5 to
outperform prior work by 3-17%+ across evaluation settings. We find task
balancing and enrichment techniques are overlooked but critical to effective
instruction tuning, and in particular, training with mixed prompt settings
(zero-shot, few-shot, and chain-of-thought) actually yields stronger (2%+)
performance in all settings. In further experiments, we show Flan-T5 requires
less finetuning to converge higher and faster than T5 on single downstream
tasks, motivating instruction-tuned models as more computationally-efficient
starting checkpoints for new tasks. Finally, to accelerate research on
instruction tuning, we make the Flan 2022 collection of datasets, templates,
and methods publicly available at
https://github.com/google-research/FLAN/tree/main/flan/v2. | [
0.0126647474,
0.0040798495,
0.0038698509,
0.0165661909,
-0.007107697,
0.0394859798,
0.050855767,
-0.0488541387,
-0.0473681018,
-0.0063434462,
-0.0629844069,
-0.0234353449,
-0.0022576542,
0.0007048204,
-0.0134758987,
-0.0925326124,
0.0554232188,
-0.0071021044,
-0.0126510393,
0.011588648,
-0.0143035594,
-0.0038892762,
-0.0483046025,
0.033860568,
0.0260416623,
-0.0374197029,
-0.0193748306,
0.039485842,
0.0348913148,
-0.0252862126,
0.0330923498,
0.042740982,
0.0240845196,
0.0188672282,
0.0000021971,
-0.0271035954,
0.0033549597,
-0.0155671593,
-0.0337227508,
0.0387586243,
0.0328684077,
0.0097632818,
0.0093683358,
0.0333865657,
0.0069195288,
-0.0052463934,
0.0524495654,
0.0061166123,
0.0552858636,
0.0615530051,
0.0156745277,
-0.0231350958,
-0.0233012103,
-0.0276595615,
0.0159706287,
-0.0504917018,
-0.0009302184,
-0.0515967719,
0.0230676327,
0.0088418871,
-0.0468547903,
-0.0066758995,
0.0472927094,
0.036305476,
0.0175080653,
0.0434503444,
-0.0393479057,
-0.0179962832,
-0.0568147041,
0.0457686558,
-0.0302671418,
-0.0033773305,
-0.0304782968,
-0.035416957,
0.012714291,
-0.0345579423,
-0.028087765,
0.0272082128,
-0.0227197669,
0.0001753095,
0.027361257,
-0.0228053406,
0.0049606282,
-0.00508093,
0.0270182211,
0.0234047808,
-0.0092821661,
-0.0339050181,
0.0141293854,
0.0169574302,
-0.0098091215,
-0.0444263555,
-0.0168844201,
0.038043458,
-0.0414965376,
-0.0151870875,
-0.0372814499,
-0.010613557,
-0.0102078738,
0.0277781598,
0.1134007722,
0.0595352761,
-0.0432626866,
0.0171636734,
-0.0072747665,
0.0339938253,
0.0107818609,
0.0348488018,
-0.038149029,
0.0443053395,
-0.090061307,
0.0519794151,
-0.0373810306,
0.0028392526,
-0.0295254346,
0.0231937841,
-0.054554496,
0.0392531827,
0.0047091995,
-0.0253451988,
-0.0002403518,
0.0151432939,
-0.0670485422,
0.0562401377,
-0.0178444926,
0.0490041524,
-0.0683419481,
0.0436978638,
0.0339227915,
-0.0382351764,
-0.0479459912,
0.0035219488,
-0.0267647076,
-0.05919737,
0.0518374443,
0.0111624617,
-0.0245691985,
-0.0284036435,
-0.0273620281,
0.0014352604,
0.0249790084,
-0.0925485492,
0.0334452726,
-0.026666332,
0.0266421959,
-0.0196630452,
0.00541694,
0.0424202904,
-0.0091287,
0.0086285947,
-0.0039656507,
0.0414381884,
0.017734969,
-0.0069210888,
0.0007545395,
0.0031380171,
-0.0446929671,
0.0826475471,
0.0061754179,
0.0353739038,
0.0021862483,
0.0068774046,
-0.010468821,
0.0155955665,
-0.0007483074,
-0.016684154,
0.0473271422,
-0.0096868835,
0.0102167679,
0.021841716,
0.0489578471,
-0.0026706054,
-0.0227464121,
0.013153878,
0.0424913242,
0.0233191475,
0.0252092984,
-0.0342531092,
0.0759367198,
-0.0015678704,
0.0139225191,
0.0355827399,
-0.0853451714,
0.0557204634,
-0.0046469974,
0.0121081667,
-0.0054986523,
0.0448475443,
-0.0693751425,
-0.0338928476,
0.0100047365,
0.012250022,
-0.0268477928,
0.0152768344,
0.0337587185,
-0.0190278683,
-0.0399213806,
-0.0015155921,
0.0298018474,
-0.0124976486,
-0.0251687728,
-0.0436883792,
-0.0108409878,
0.0507463776,
0.022470234,
-0.021592252,
-0.0731871426,
-0.011362399,
0.0796839818,
0.0201378837,
0.0416522473,
-0.0121329771,
0.0573913306,
-0.0594262145,
-0.0454818085,
-0.0569148213,
0.0138352998,
0.007897431,
0.0263260063,
-0.0076145944,
-0.0220081843,
0.0067693158,
-0.0599434189,
0.0396112539,
-0.0136578931,
-0.0414856784,
0.0094666099,
0.0165702738,
0.0095614158,
0.0001779775,
-0.0257442761,
-0.0086958883,
0.039388895,
0.0056861746,
0.065395765,
-0.015606028,
-0.0648326725,
-0.0015914768,
0.0240893904,
-0.0196043681,
-0.003894595,
0.0338903666,
-0.0649225861,
-0.0421300791,
0.0055168085,
0.0072894408,
-0.0112287458,
0.0299200304,
0.0364901945,
-0.0379147679,
0.0133184055,
-0.0288668312,
0.0456566215,
-0.0178188086,
-0.0116198203,
0.0049228165,
0.0244931169,
-0.0267630685,
-0.0418046713,
0.0023849453,
-0.0319616534,
0.0078727994,
0.0032830953,
0.007056531,
0.0742229596,
-0.0504207686,
-0.0268075969,
-0.0763491392,
0.0592517518,
-0.0395241082,
0.0267854612,
0.0401128791,
0.0035720211,
-0.0073422673,
0.0056654895,
0.0069376691,
0.0184263699,
-0.0120168962,
0.0473099239,
0.0064634867,
0.0311584771,
-0.0390381888,
-0.036512278,
-0.0242726114,
-0.0171239842,
-0.0260511506,
0.0140483379,
-0.0006629825,
-0.0134253064,
0.0358411558,
0.013566629,
0.0111197,
-0.0135054439,
-0.0398151055,
0.0281244088,
0.009216141,
0.0180363283,
0.1155637428,
-0.0092418538,
0.0382140726,
0.0331376791,
0.0091030868,
-0.0280416626,
0.0510029122,
-0.0201311,
-0.0587854423,
-0.0033457431,
-0.0070909476,
-0.0099598328,
0.0695930123,
-0.0201864,
0.0185202602,
-0.0783134326,
0.0062140594,
-0.0030075815,
-0.0210871324,
0.0143030277,
0.0270051006,
-0.0239166711,
-0.0061402386,
-0.0653180033,
-0.0376238078,
0.065105781,
0.0208623931,
-0.0131002339,
-0.0747703612,
0.000044087,
-0.0186693575,
0.0054020016,
0.0055234879,
-0.0056394949,
0.0268947836,
0.0107152387,
-0.0789100081,
0.0234478489,
0.0253017191,
0.026597416,
0.0455689318,
-0.0282577816,
-0.0311853923,
-0.039827697,
-0.0575104356,
-0.0272187032,
-0.0040928461,
0.0276143588,
0.0199074578,
0.018486483,
-0.0370302573,
-0.0441255011,
-0.0517696701,
0.0407335386,
0.0477387868,
-0.0425418541,
-0.012310815,
-0.0361587591,
0.0024372227,
0.0330247469,
-0.0197951905,
0.0238100253,
-0.0571414344,
0.0275152605,
0.029988287,
0.0975618884,
-0.0286008362,
-0.0004721348,
0.0286183078,
0.0163277499,
-0.0538469404,
-0.0124487942,
0.072075069,
0.113742128,
-0.0618127286,
-0.037447203,
0.0778710842,
0.0178266522,
-0.0456220955,
-0.0080698598,
0.029938465,
0.0217232313,
0.0371072553,
0.0151089551,
-0.0745524615,
-0.0373513326,
-0.0096520428,
0.0783094019,
-0.0135774296,
-0.0011122937,
0.0126332277,
-0.0886579081,
0.0426921062,
0.009470813,
-0.0591259524,
-0.003407262,
-0.031629689,
-0.012165606,
-0.0301988106,
0.0160830077,
0.0248794761,
-0.0369581878,
0.0372866876,
0.062379308,
0.0264220517,
-0.0940715447,
0.0584627949,
-0.0592450835,
0.0497450642,
0.0593246333,
-0.0341264009,
-0.0005820674,
-0.0555026978,
0.0262170434,
-0.0212262776,
0.0121587291,
-0.0022180013,
0.0542314686,
-0.0318434983,
0.0125744045,
-0.012329991,
0.0363605842,
-0.0083784284,
0.0059295865,
0.0218333937,
0.0656982586,
-0.0120121771,
0.005698029,
-0.0262330789,
-0.0071802512,
0.0247242544,
0.0421664082,
0.0476440005,
-0.0702907443,
-0.0443508513,
-0.0511698648,
-0.0293884166,
-0.1025650725,
0.0059046638,
0.0123913307,
-0.0247634444,
-0.0283251647,
-0.0329617113,
-0.0770532042,
0.0244940538,
0.0412014313,
0.0122225974,
-0.0340724438,
-0.0286540762,
0.0094265565,
-0.0519117899,
0.0541326702,
-0.0131398663,
0.0161759462,
-0.0927913859,
-0.0690933317,
0.0142188966,
0.0050763404,
0.0098492429,
0.0469687916,
-0.0893572718,
-0.0492352322,
0.0142371617,
0.0905689895,
0.0152046075,
0.0455480702,
-0.0105427178,
-0.0111167086,
0.0218725801,
0.0252392925,
-0.0218236558,
0.0262834318,
0.0528314598,
-0.0432922356,
0.0021718533,
0.0016760196,
-0.0517583974,
0.0123519534,
0.0607240275,
0.0296016876,
0.0018002751,
0.026867833,
0.0123830196,
-0.0198955815,
0.039474234,
-0.0144547857,
-0.0278298892,
-0.0163674131,
0.0044931308,
0.003461929,
0.0042663375,
-0.0400405116,
-0.0237249453,
0.0080781225,
0.0106163407,
0.0056333118,
0.02531478,
0.0332469419,
0.0220533367,
-0.0596768819,
0.018526813,
-0.0011302473,
0.0449578539,
-0.005983335,
0.0382751115,
-0.0326818451,
0.0084767919,
0.022540208,
0.0490919836,
0.0076091401,
0.0799476653,
0.0300508533,
0.0552309528,
-0.0368443355,
0.0525607653,
-0.0757408515,
-0.0316074565,
-0.0713874847,
-0.0419007726,
0.0794978291,
-0.025725672,
0.0195374694,
0.0036673488,
-0.0010770942,
-0.0350385159,
0.0023997354,
-0.0250199176,
-0.0307321493,
-0.0395182669,
0.0348069333,
0.0204140693,
-0.0350880809,
0.0670433864,
-0.0192546286,
0.0881670117,
0.0192024242,
0.0304253176,
-0.0290490855,
-0.0095406845,
0.0036276709,
0.0390734561,
0.0040407404,
-0.0032505796,
-0.0227356348,
-0.0238465928,
-0.0039927075,
0.0134462686,
0.0272871237,
0.0064774104,
0.0615436584,
-0.0040267771,
-0.0235617794,
-0.0547160245,
-0.0127403047,
-0.0279833637,
0.0238896012,
-0.0152885215,
-0.025641581,
-6.355498287e-33,
-0.0408177301,
0.0459867716,
0.0321839675,
0.0143950135,
-0.0161256194,
-0.0060039009,
-0.0474631004,
0.0079985801,
-0.0496652313,
0.0028745933,
-0.0143659078,
0.0096781217,
0.0201118458,
-0.0014718213,
0.0652592033,
-0.0177382827,
0.0478541926,
-0.041994065,
-0.0616234466,
0.041049365,
0.0365595222,
0.0004714641,
0.0548292063,
-0.0139489351,
-0.0314749032,
0.0210612658,
0.0016808368,
-0.0043140147,
-0.0367680974,
0.041845534,
0.00375526,
0.0237405077,
0.0167467333,
-0.0429999717,
-0.0415011346,
-0.0389003195,
-0.066841796,
-0.049478434,
-0.0043336973,
0.0159536526,
-0.0455484428,
-0.0512085706,
0.0143676968,
0.0081458613,
-0.0479840897,
-0.034499649,
0.0178226382,
-0.0118246051,
0.0203919187,
-0.0007288745,
-0.0303315297,
-0.0281259287,
-0.0106244134,
-0.0571386665,
0.0015877988,
0.0471139103,
0.0006732702,
-0.019751668,
-0.0685972199,
0.0158016309,
0.0416615717,
0.0547563285,
0.0433691181,
0.051252123,
0.0292544495,
0.0164253898,
0.0492775775,
0.0181503072,
-0.005105542,
0.0118957954,
0.0465898812,
0.028931018,
0.0190348197,
-0.0191665906,
0.0298514292,
0.0050514704,
-0.0806175768,
0.0338956416,
0.0242479686,
0.0607886389,
-0.0047524101,
0.0045433687,
-0.050769899,
-0.0152501408,
-0.0206625797,
-0.0218686238,
-0.0284607988,
-0.0099689579,
0.046307303,
0.0288210213,
0.0010191073,
-0.0360926874,
0.0492644608,
-0.0132840006,
0.0427867994,
0.0094472356,
-0.0143867359,
0.0473600589,
0.031397447,
-0.0127461767,
-0.0990941226,
-0.0364088044,
0.0366714597,
0.0147855505,
0.049960129,
0.0218993723,
0.0408693589,
0.0313187726,
-0.0165621862,
-0.0067830272,
-0.0654639304,
0.038040556,
0.0336069949,
0.0135392537,
0.0221518818,
0.005540167,
-0.0131889014,
0.0544035956,
-0.0190339237,
-0.0344188474,
-0.0346742831,
-0.0104505019,
0.0065020709,
0.0332318321,
-0.0115247723,
0.029077379,
-0.0517807417,
0.0152768083,
-0.0252522379,
-0.0481171012,
-0.0381923839,
0.0229950808,
2.807e-7,
-0.015867196,
0.0276032202,
0.0200580563,
0.0234712437,
0.0100702923,
0.0295874141,
-0.0407406241,
0.0111863837,
0.0027351077,
-0.0068630762,
0.0104719885,
0.0452736206,
0.033762496,
0.0132086938,
-0.0393045731,
-0.0224869773,
-0.0192066655,
0.0663931593,
-0.0442545041,
-0.00878812,
0.0038682434,
0.0677763745,
0.0315638706,
0.0142016364,
0.0322862118,
0.0367518328,
0.0160935298,
0.005578496,
0.0065045287,
0.0132084759,
-0.0316750184,
0.0222772248,
-0.0161005035,
0.0195548143,
-0.0332260616,
0.0148429153,
-0.0543255135,
0.0521699749,
-0.006704052,
-0.0384491459,
0.0109038372,
0.0329023264,
-0.0184697025,
-0.041309379,
0.0599445961,
-0.0520695001,
0.0016154243,
0.0113079417,
-0.0060940213,
0.0045872214,
0.0260176454,
-0.0168277007,
-0.0010188274,
0.0057884874,
0.0050117807,
0.0147332586,
-0.0461276099,
-0.0643501878,
-0.0050893668,
0.0716103911,
-0.0184923988,
-0.0341731794,
-0.0715627447,
0.0025944568,
-0.0013405336,
-0.0584409758,
-0.0544976443,
2.788137143e-34,
0.0005550897,
-0.0557985045,
0.0659900084,
0.0108533576,
-0.0005011708,
-0.0019991798,
-0.0534257554,
-0.0085072853,
0.0211881623,
-0.0511642843,
-0.0388679057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13683v1 | Friend-training: Learning from Models of Different but Related Tasks | 2023-01-31T15:00:56 | 2023-01-31T15:00:56 | Mian Zhang, Lifeng Jin, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Xiabing Zhou, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current self-training methods such as standard self-training, co-training,
tri-training, and others often focus on improving model performance on a single
task, utilizing differences in input features, model architectures, and
training processes. However, many tasks in natural language processing are
about different but related aspects of language, and models trained for one
task can be great teachers for other related tasks. In this work, we propose
friend-training, a cross-task self-training framework, where models trained to
do different tasks are used in an iterative training, pseudo-labeling, and
retraining process to help each other for better selection of pseudo-labels.
With two dialogue understanding tasks, conversational semantic role labeling
and dialogue rewriting, chosen for a case study, we show that the models
trained with the friend-training framework achieve the best performance
compared to strong baselines. | [
0.0853120536,
-0.0050257393,
-0.0043298593,
0.0355980694,
-0.0305690169,
0.0361800641,
0.0209260322,
-0.0385080986,
0.0315257534,
-0.0553168394,
-0.1129245833,
-0.0253192037,
-0.0567393377,
0.01408921,
0.0050091255,
-0.0484183021,
0.0673250556,
0.0276672374,
0.0415158123,
0.0196950175,
-0.0129701104,
0.0158352125,
-0.0145684807,
0.0120773269,
-0.0262801312,
-0.0309377462,
0.0107349576,
-0.0183949284,
0.0061628497,
-0.0207830723,
0.0445383638,
0.0180267338,
0.0319576822,
0.0385970697,
0.0000014538,
-0.0482116565,
-0.0382457636,
-0.0143834176,
-0.0446620584,
-0.0229200143,
0.0314389952,
-0.001595027,
0.0154725639,
0.0109569347,
-0.0517367534,
-0.0548098907,
0.0317447856,
0.1131864861,
0.0596595481,
0.1087254509,
0.0002410106,
-0.0314984322,
-0.0228225533,
-0.0586791486,
-0.0046436279,
-0.0594967455,
-0.0030326711,
0.0503168963,
-0.0107174544,
0.0179587118,
0.0137565425,
0.0097074863,
0.0301372092,
-0.0273395274,
0.0301137604,
0.0235905331,
-0.0111624561,
-0.0143563095,
-0.0219088197,
0.086115934,
-0.0287123043,
0.0098526506,
0.0137688322,
0.015897477,
-0.0035896022,
0.0038582694,
0.0057212287,
-0.0305081122,
0.0029849692,
0.0058577373,
0.055465769,
0.0168999527,
0.0194802023,
0.0210056808,
0.0068058935,
0.0844484642,
-0.0313723125,
-0.049870979,
0.0490145907,
0.0192293599,
-0.024160672,
-0.0398876853,
0.0233390406,
-0.0065700244,
-0.0571868047,
0.0425307937,
-0.061219614,
0.0352444127,
0.0003594612,
-0.0244507883,
0.0275228675,
-0.0063040964,
-0.0212442968,
0.0547013693,
-0.0179489441,
0.0106600551,
0.0207035542,
0.0572766699,
-0.0510649048,
0.022657169,
-0.1062316,
-0.0093679298,
-0.0958530456,
0.0520371944,
-0.0151489666,
-0.0318005085,
-0.0327133089,
0.022356838,
-0.0095671769,
-0.0030003258,
0.0696504414,
0.007314119,
-0.0688650832,
0.0019713761,
0.0071639158,
0.0374311171,
-0.005983599,
0.0345694572,
-0.0066961912,
-0.0311229993,
-0.0194270741,
-0.0066949958,
0.0145248072,
-0.0592633933,
-0.0174257495,
0.0399819501,
-0.0469554514,
-0.0337270051,
-0.014228317,
-0.0163509678,
-0.0228174012,
-0.0760240853,
0.0054521598,
0.0097784176,
0.036384888,
-0.0395080224,
0.0081377588,
-0.0211673416,
0.0063876626,
-0.0180935245,
-0.0048009851,
0.09734606,
-0.0234423205,
-0.0080301752,
0.0336409025,
0.0323234908,
0.0085630612,
0.0699295625,
0.024063129,
-0.0189574696,
0.0547946021,
-0.004107696,
0.004240673,
0.0108017195,
-0.0013660368,
-0.010720171,
0.0148612326,
0.005464294,
0.0263101626,
0.0395136699,
0.0274419989,
-0.0006380093,
-0.050540369,
-0.0252682082,
0.0426092222,
0.0226164311,
0.0292475969,
0.0379210375,
0.0394949503,
0.0668373927,
0.0027813346,
0.0490141287,
-0.068456836,
0.0206002966,
0.0261570197,
-0.0100679863,
-0.0492232665,
-0.036865253,
-0.0467515513,
-0.0346056372,
0.0225253385,
-0.0158866607,
0.0106007699,
-0.0250063539,
0.0177217461,
0.0763572231,
-0.027204087,
0.0244024992,
0.0230048671,
-0.0363741405,
0.0152076958,
-0.021603886,
-0.0117643354,
0.0454821065,
0.0052222176,
-0.0936529413,
-0.0515894145,
-0.0355651528,
0.0298424028,
-0.0073284614,
0.07391458,
-0.0606494136,
0.038778916,
-0.0340300277,
-0.0259667486,
-0.0229149982,
0.020477403,
-0.0050112559,
0.0080826739,
-0.035289824,
0.0192816202,
-0.035914056,
-0.0161779597,
0.0515095182,
-0.0218944512,
-0.0127619291,
0.0399918184,
0.0216124877,
0.0458546504,
0.0206306614,
-0.0300511401,
-0.0228277687,
0.0131693156,
-0.0323397554,
-0.0125697628,
0.0434009433,
-0.0545258373,
-0.0667983815,
0.0492190272,
0.0199489724,
-0.031336233,
0.0502825305,
-0.073396787,
-0.0332066864,
0.0291355271,
-0.037045002,
0.0418405719,
-0.0400992967,
-0.005141804,
0.0208470486,
-0.0260428917,
-0.0197998527,
0.0294599272,
0.0293283258,
-0.0079095038,
-0.038709335,
0.0037663912,
-0.0020456384,
-0.0309613403,
0.0104326634,
0.0243777465,
-0.0141991116,
-0.0176542327,
0.0047333045,
0.0117649632,
-0.0757204965,
-0.0412051268,
-0.0920721814,
-0.0091781132,
-0.0326967537,
0.006862062,
0.0500298962,
-0.0146889398,
0.0124131832,
-0.0503064096,
-0.0445705727,
-0.0066248509,
-0.0147688715,
-0.0016475632,
0.0329734199,
0.0088561038,
0.0195117649,
-0.0369973928,
0.0155556044,
0.0085674627,
0.014984238,
0.0002252379,
-0.0046307491,
-0.0464240164,
0.0110920416,
-0.009565332,
0.0349216536,
-0.0004156718,
-0.0194904488,
-0.0454567224,
0.0461403094,
-0.0139222592,
0.0555059426,
-0.0037863958,
0.045834776,
0.0090452451,
-0.0051221596,
-0.0364896134,
0.0251579285,
-0.0154204667,
-0.0097654797,
-0.036331743,
-0.0170452911,
-0.008797694,
0.0618954897,
-0.0132149281,
0.0039513684,
-0.0190808475,
-0.0111968499,
-0.0213528946,
-0.065671213,
0.0195875987,
-0.006924063,
0.008732032,
-0.0313047729,
-0.06578812,
-0.0098453043,
0.0692386925,
0.0056047984,
-0.0427759737,
-0.0731103867,
-0.0427787974,
-0.0285447277,
0.0788275525,
-0.0022723004,
0.010439367,
0.0585904755,
-0.0445463844,
-0.0076488541,
-0.0206676349,
0.035147205,
-0.006985134,
0.0021793689,
-0.016295407,
0.015266493,
0.0204684194,
-0.0295686536,
-0.022354234,
-0.0722183585,
-0.0214228462,
0.0007250048,
-0.0904311091,
0.0143403541,
-0.0284936726,
-0.0161136631,
-0.0335598402,
0.0789034516,
-0.0103125982,
0.0116036627,
-0.0235379729,
0.0578957088,
0.0187736489,
0.0074538481,
-0.0479277372,
-0.0202871338,
0.044813361,
0.0147895413,
0.0186083037,
-0.0150946816,
-0.0166316684,
0.0193544216,
-0.0107875941,
-0.0448720157,
-0.0405400321,
-0.0067082909,
0.0519662052,
-0.0481657274,
-0.0340019241,
0.0915540978,
0.0222643279,
-0.0296550766,
0.0049473234,
0.0194272511,
0.0186151061,
0.0657314584,
0.0235856958,
-0.0397951193,
-0.0355730392,
-0.0012588023,
0.0044253711,
0.0019718702,
-0.0248282943,
-0.0230080355,
-0.0908713788,
0.0349481329,
-0.0137919923,
-0.0172492452,
0.0094643729,
-0.043730434,
0.0240708012,
-0.0498431288,
0.0074155116,
-0.0290414281,
-0.0028597699,
-0.0229742061,
0.0388303772,
0.0090076989,
-0.0617170781,
-0.0046994751,
-0.0415574908,
0.0541576147,
0.0633795708,
0.028874319,
0.0183091965,
0.0050046388,
0.0066052512,
0.0331298523,
0.0185282379,
-0.0286506843,
0.0897181332,
-0.0258528572,
-0.0046221563,
0.0480649918,
0.0236680694,
-0.0362983681,
-0.0167479496,
0.0029594554,
0.0228677113,
-0.0035024595,
-0.0005461377,
0.0549348854,
0.02574642,
0.0550221056,
0.0535380915,
0.0146549242,
0.0019683882,
-0.0058166534,
0.0174412485,
0.05174274,
-0.0445386879,
0.003736462,
-0.0047662044,
-0.0491258129,
-0.020892214,
-0.0337273963,
-0.0560855381,
0.0493191667,
0.0353308283,
0.0186909847,
0.0050999443,
0.0607513487,
0.0073705451,
-0.0557260923,
0.0172514059,
-0.0419660248,
0.0004374773,
0.0147067057,
-0.0286081955,
0.0450182408,
-0.0101348078,
-0.0013122041,
-0.0245880149,
-0.055684071,
-0.0373087302,
0.0006078694,
0.0548022911,
0.0196015891,
0.0870538577,
-0.0063058352,
-0.0611528046,
-0.045178771,
0.0188300647,
-0.0439538695,
-0.002942628,
0.0411495157,
-0.0229631402,
0.0088587049,
0.0370951667,
-0.0005281795,
0.0318112858,
0.0497916639,
-0.0026076699,
-0.0496920049,
-0.0368891172,
0.0286724214,
-0.0149417603,
0.0338858664,
0.0444711857,
0.044334434,
-0.059799891,
0.0398698635,
-0.010603508,
-0.0484964065,
-0.050666362,
0.02041227,
0.0245244838,
-0.0067819697,
0.0083784387,
-0.0010072839,
-0.0316748433,
0.0414639041,
-0.0654537007,
-0.0089095272,
-0.0177994091,
-0.0172735434,
-0.0286308303,
0.018169906,
-0.0218018852,
0.0205419846,
0.0616289154,
0.0355056748,
0.0090027209,
0.0310689509,
0.012907858,
-0.0014754587,
0.0054786182,
0.0268109255,
-0.063346386,
-0.019296838,
-0.0516412184,
0.0349867754,
0.0545900986,
-0.0458983257,
0.0236019026,
-0.0139543554,
-0.0049111941,
-0.0026064571,
0.0376866236,
-0.0272113141,
-0.0202260576,
-0.0031886026,
0.0068514142,
-0.0280962139,
0.020094879,
0.089608483,
0.0070095379,
0.0529978275,
0.0191820376,
-0.0131017687,
-0.0618798696,
-0.0454089493,
0.01491284,
0.058711119,
-0.0109887766,
0.0235904735,
-0.0111657772,
-0.047243461,
0.0281665139,
-0.0168722458,
-0.0060783122,
0.0282357167,
0.0343489312,
0.0476093926,
-0.01453734,
-0.0082378183,
-0.0396248549,
-0.0355139971,
0.0614650436,
-0.0114501286,
-0.0249662194,
-5.08066401e-33,
-0.0498265922,
0.0128424289,
0.0080367941,
-0.0218380317,
-0.0499609746,
0.0394839495,
-0.0313067921,
-0.00150554,
0.0302384328,
0.0486141555,
-0.0198382325,
0.0265728869,
0.0340619572,
0.0042374153,
-0.0133701796,
-0.0292014759,
0.076105386,
-0.0305860024,
0.0081085609,
-0.0067033926,
-0.002022753,
0.0368029661,
0.0940524265,
-0.1066675261,
0.0018923663,
0.0352361053,
0.0028621564,
0.0536267757,
0.0182745699,
0.0273682009,
0.0113309026,
0.0144367116,
0.0457750149,
-0.0424518622,
-0.0007270355,
0.0352446958,
-0.1140947267,
-0.0333623029,
0.0401774161,
0.0236538593,
-0.046221476,
-0.021108225,
0.0217095967,
-0.0325433649,
0.0331459977,
-0.0190783143,
0.015785018,
-0.0246841628,
-0.0187597014,
0.0222760905,
-0.0613617077,
0.003939901,
-0.0119321281,
-0.0717769116,
0.0285063628,
0.074632585,
0.0013576826,
-0.0308842156,
-0.0448200218,
-0.0112055801,
-0.0687116086,
0.0433220826,
-0.0065076682,
0.0346818082,
-0.024929639,
0.0483978167,
0.0166471284,
0.023183981,
-0.0089482274,
-0.0445489809,
-0.0075241784,
0.0656499043,
-0.0184391756,
0.0242590792,
0.0031962353,
-0.010742221,
-0.0463305824,
0.0030016743,
0.0349206701,
-0.0198104009,
-0.0167354774,
0.0095823389,
-0.0022365868,
-0.007896781,
-0.0372000523,
-0.009819326,
-0.0068935975,
-0.0202600583,
0.0125911552,
0.0321304947,
-0.0221078712,
0.0818268955,
0.0043988051,
-0.0511380509,
-0.0116129573,
-0.0073149232,
0.0196324941,
0.0109837763,
-0.0065004169,
0.0115856649,
-0.0667406321,
-0.0594887063,
0.0231207069,
0.0217488203,
0.0347700976,
-0.0313814357,
0.0893017352,
-0.0023637651,
-0.019623762,
-0.0037492341,
-0.0124696344,
0.0345273316,
0.001258568,
0.0847295746,
0.0064660623,
0.0482161343,
-0.0414130539,
0.0376176946,
0.0334645435,
-0.0442478471,
-0.0461480655,
0.0046155867,
-0.0009536766,
0.0411169529,
0.0139002008,
-0.0282791629,
-0.0108092269,
-0.0214206409,
-0.0008605298,
-0.0437029004,
0.0036017268,
0.0116538396,
2.261e-7,
0.0141092399,
0.0368186124,
0.0408574305,
-0.0041473769,
0.0365652815,
0.04860368,
-0.0249953512,
0.0700254217,
0.0319692455,
-0.0446148291,
0.0271533895,
0.0335388184,
0.0402179547,
0.0218504667,
-0.0561742969,
-0.0345813856,
-0.0711049736,
-0.0170565918,
-0.0205160361,
-0.0146493325,
0.0171860699,
0.09072835,
0.0459485352,
-0.0399815328,
-0.0196067523,
-0.0382375196,
0.0422841944,
-0.0186054464,
-0.0193693358,
0.0446419306,
-0.0036946444,
0.0396320894,
-0.015358693,
0.0649432316,
-0.018613318,
0.0190968085,
-0.0010460754,
0.060489852,
-0.015979005,
-0.0075870291,
-0.0215593819,
0.0451875664,
0.0033527154,
-0.0074467212,
0.0500445925,
-0.0955826715,
-0.0279573202,
0.0018661545,
-0.0124133229,
0.0127729997,
0.0038698039,
-0.0008149895,
-0.0012403806,
0.0524725392,
0.0378871039,
0.0017086886,
-0.0272973273,
-0.054833509,
0.0025543699,
0.009809928,
-0.0243318304,
0.0062939152,
0.0063832453,
-0.0290781762,
0.018162813,
-0.0478131548,
0.0236351229,
1.533121403e-34,
-0.0141244661,
0.0090997471,
0.0087020062,
0.0488174744,
0.0069744354,
-0.0168007817,
-0.0376766771,
-0.0155973043,
-0.0188311059,
-0.009077372,
0.0151432976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13668v1 | Automated Sentiment and Hate Speech Analysis of Facebook Data by Employing Multilingual Transformer Models | 2023-01-31T14:37:04 | 2023-01-31T14:37:04 | Ritumbra Manuvie, Saikat Chatterjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In recent years, there has been a heightened consensus within academia and in
the public discourse that Social Media Platforms (SMPs), amplify the spread of
hateful and negative sentiment content. Researchers have identified how hateful
content, political propaganda, and targeted messaging contributed to real-world
harms including insurrections against democratically elected governments,
genocide, and breakdown of social cohesion due to heightened negative discourse
towards certain communities in parts of the world. To counter these issues,
SMPs have created semi-automated systems that can help identify toxic speech.
In this paper we analyse the statistical distribution of hateful and negative
sentiment contents within a representative Facebook dataset (n= 604,703)
scrapped through 648 public Facebook pages which identify themselves as
proponents (and followers) of far-right Hindutva actors. These pages were
identified manually using keyword searches on Facebook and on CrowdTangleand
classified as far-right Hindutva pages based on page names, page descriptions,
and discourses shared on these pages. We employ state-of-the-art, open-source
XLM-T multilingual transformer-based language models to perform sentiment and
hate speech analysis of the textual contents shared on these pages over a
period of 5.5 years. The result shows the statistical distributions of the
predicted sentiment and the hate speech labels; top actors, and top page
categories. We further discuss the benchmark performances and limitations of
these pre-trained language models. | [
0.0532007515,
0.0679012239,
-0.0299002808,
0.0381514691,
-0.027400624,
0.0039377683,
0.0067321234,
-0.0087375408,
0.0145082874,
-0.0523324721,
0.0000688996,
-0.0458976887,
0.001183005,
0.0243564732,
-0.0248079635,
-0.0251051113,
0.0262652487,
0.0239077732,
0.0160966553,
-0.0135837374,
0.0194412246,
0.025328692,
0.010513437,
0.0205950812,
-0.0543045588,
0.0118399262,
0.0395240113,
-0.004537724,
0.035757944,
-0.0065829591,
0.0194257628,
0.0345251262,
-0.0069801561,
0.0528587364,
0.0000017123,
-0.0364824422,
-0.0188770853,
-0.0066733188,
0.0452979803,
-0.0426792875,
0.0860039443,
-0.0691751242,
-0.0214008782,
0.0422647297,
-0.0507135689,
-0.0021798413,
0.0651202798,
0.0578045473,
0.0684954748,
0.0902610198,
-0.0242605098,
-0.0636617169,
0.027756026,
0.0483522676,
-0.00718104,
0.0303836595,
0.0347876661,
-0.0369487628,
-0.0507684164,
-0.0009672131,
-0.0252113622,
0.0055179028,
0.0065917154,
0.0108712548,
-0.0146009875,
-0.0457121469,
-0.0215102062,
-0.0620018579,
0.0128325829,
0.0365588591,
-0.045151636,
-0.0305836983,
0.0188379064,
-0.0011715509,
-0.0376514383,
0.0271359906,
-0.0269510727,
0.0449286886,
-0.0437393151,
0.0380404852,
0.0462775901,
0.0100325597,
0.0308906343,
0.0529886037,
0.0022794502,
0.0353989787,
-0.035506174,
-0.0274593141,
0.0069470517,
-0.0093577476,
-0.0218083188,
0.0411117971,
0.0319369361,
-0.0006782091,
-0.001470542,
0.037680842,
-0.0473956503,
-0.0794085041,
0.0019941851,
-0.1172834262,
0.0026508365,
0.0475897826,
-0.0203760024,
0.0125735831,
-0.0027115999,
0.0056270468,
0.0038617763,
0.0220697615,
0.0153119471,
-0.016079586,
-0.0061461059,
0.0163569972,
0.0185977612,
-0.0093216393,
0.012988505,
0.0464090444,
-0.0590160899,
-0.0039413376,
-0.0545954816,
-0.0364849605,
0.010888461,
-0.0032892118,
0.0246676523,
-0.0001676959,
-0.0093897739,
0.0457335301,
-0.020308543,
0.0102491705,
-0.0694288537,
-0.0724645779,
0.0424204469,
0.0541879348,
-0.0184340794,
-0.0088408189,
0.0168410353,
0.0794387087,
0.0230262186,
-0.0183862578,
-0.037543714,
-0.0005835071,
-0.0260462742,
-0.0306092147,
0.0138057489,
-0.0538482144,
0.0583443679,
0.0338100791,
-0.029338263,
-0.0521767735,
0.0299587175,
0.0391858295,
-0.0751411617,
0.0791324526,
0.04482878,
0.0325622708,
0.0533399321,
0.0235633049,
0.0137499012,
0.0409880243,
0.0114639439,
0.028804386,
0.0613456145,
-0.0227007437,
0.0241506398,
0.0676297545,
0.0190741401,
-0.0030933097,
-0.0481477343,
0.0112976069,
-0.0392055623,
-0.0568673275,
-0.0144952163,
0.0570903271,
0.0271167699,
-0.0302451756,
0.0245918389,
0.0390920825,
-0.0552109554,
0.0303600468,
0.0389191471,
0.0138675654,
-0.0277852621,
-0.0219987165,
-0.0466048382,
-0.0105302511,
-0.0155612687,
-0.0659338981,
0.0226555616,
0.0770905986,
0.0086565064,
-0.0196450632,
-0.0113360099,
-0.030940149,
0.0823322982,
-0.0520682521,
0.0477929674,
0.0081540337,
-0.0272489004,
0.0288608931,
0.0610399432,
-0.0525533743,
0.0079346923,
-0.0494438,
0.0150331873,
0.0315585695,
0.0006762644,
-0.0102084884,
0.0041899425,
-0.0529887006,
-0.0134413019,
0.0319503807,
0.022977788,
0.0108479857,
-0.0456390977,
-0.0066235675,
0.0058530453,
0.0492890067,
0.0035688858,
0.0148768192,
0.0579600744,
0.0387732498,
0.0067387577,
0.0314688459,
-0.0543465726,
0.0091122435,
0.0175355542,
0.003374829,
-0.0003775967,
0.0330987833,
0.0374054015,
0.0355435088,
-0.0191106033,
-0.0478524566,
0.03276686,
-0.0013004361,
-0.0660406873,
0.002654749,
0.0060387379,
0.0184215344,
0.0011334996,
-0.0549370795,
0.0009527522,
0.0687902346,
-0.0079012113,
0.0130915483,
0.0919003263,
0.0015164707,
-0.0098319836,
0.0019127093,
-0.0004274448,
-0.0753050968,
0.0240097214,
0.000174281,
0.0586033985,
-0.0225021485,
0.0106299333,
-0.0053810766,
-0.069025971,
0.045739159,
0.0591261424,
-0.0418012515,
-0.0172478538,
-0.026270384,
0.0400897376,
0.0131762316,
-0.0170384869,
0.0061924323,
-0.017667491,
-0.0682942495,
-0.0265567303,
-0.0191586334,
-0.0128255719,
0.0245021712,
0.0307364911,
-0.0056039477,
0.0373483263,
-0.0046341796,
-0.0112165762,
0.0578810573,
0.0245448872,
0.0270998515,
-0.0613135472,
0.0137981037,
-0.0200948846,
-0.0112541094,
-0.0331652835,
0.0302323457,
0.0268593971,
-0.0982614607,
0.0473853946,
0.0111372303,
-0.0597717538,
0.009014966,
-0.0357400477,
-0.0681562498,
0.0082144262,
0.0076593659,
0.0010307007,
0.0476815365,
0.0578652546,
0.0773843825,
0.0149379158,
0.0259571169,
-0.0255877357,
-0.0243586618,
-0.0384435281,
-0.0095066475,
-0.028621424,
-0.0209901594,
-0.0023180433,
0.0417406037,
0.0596323311,
-0.0087586874,
-0.0419053659,
0.0086753564,
-0.0711318702,
-0.0205450244,
0.0040127183,
-0.0338035338,
0.0045287446,
0.0095089534,
-0.0113354512,
-0.0422463194,
0.0399845131,
-0.0017099803,
0.0438041054,
0.0043119639,
-0.0380913615,
-0.0142118745,
0.0120207826,
0.0092437388,
0.0397639498,
-0.0551606491,
0.0154207144,
-0.0082888585,
-0.0126221711,
0.0096408715,
-0.0426683389,
0.0070234677,
-0.0041911835,
0.0181188025,
0.0001129081,
-0.0263544209,
-0.0333859771,
-0.0733263195,
-0.0283206683,
-0.0482067131,
0.0097584156,
-0.0176114943,
-0.009055974,
0.0570807718,
0.0328348242,
-0.0519881211,
-0.0080128945,
0.0066110697,
0.0444161817,
-0.0209274646,
0.0066954521,
-0.0568460375,
0.0467133261,
-0.003642156,
-0.0444287807,
0.0241196677,
-0.0310608726,
0.0183433332,
0.0048409705,
-0.0232457574,
0.0117135281,
0.0101849521,
0.0009043831,
-0.043955896,
0.0279796813,
-0.0006397813,
0.0387572907,
0.0791187361,
-0.0008913556,
-0.012579862,
-0.0094281528,
-0.0196038466,
-0.0452640355,
0.0044924458,
0.0064679333,
-0.0997623205,
0.0273083039,
-0.0383840129,
0.02306474,
-0.0591268241,
-0.0363608263,
0.0266872887,
-0.0820233077,
-0.016803069,
-0.0071573625,
-0.0249954499,
-0.019565573,
-0.023238143,
-0.0031578473,
-0.0380434617,
0.0127574615,
-0.0462320708,
0.0199168548,
-0.0016983103,
-0.0141254142,
-0.0794168711,
-0.0054173106,
0.0190427639,
-0.025260821,
0.0153890103,
0.0064533567,
0.0499074124,
-0.0566727072,
-0.0260191448,
0.0425999314,
0.0065017184,
-0.0192171521,
-0.0483648218,
0.0511302389,
-0.0028939492,
-0.0519875586,
-0.0212377422,
0.0331171341,
-0.0096728047,
-0.0079043256,
-0.000220096,
0.0593839474,
0.0337557793,
-0.0451742597,
-0.0326853059,
0.0314884372,
0.020167686,
0.0480048023,
-0.0109499386,
-0.0554399081,
0.0175793227,
-0.069993481,
0.0016873623,
-0.0189341586,
-0.0930650905,
-0.0227168463,
-0.0340091512,
-0.0652903393,
-0.0197915882,
-0.0261479262,
0.0211431831,
0.0112636322,
0.0247776005,
-0.0171214193,
0.0449517593,
-0.0111064743,
-0.0513548031,
0.0045615626,
0.0130103212,
0.0443048887,
-0.0119995559,
-0.0130866496,
0.0165231209,
0.0188722014,
-0.0136216525,
-0.0163820721,
-0.0094456039,
-0.0493023731,
0.0522860512,
0.039317023,
0.012425744,
0.0235369895,
-0.0073549948,
-0.0205529407,
0.0607013255,
0.0584760793,
-0.0170985255,
-0.0066969488,
0.0295521524,
0.0326168202,
0.0114331739,
0.0173893403,
0.000695453,
0.0173535701,
0.0284857396,
-0.0616354272,
-0.0578787699,
-0.0173660759,
-0.0249173436,
-0.004167614,
0.0638503134,
0.0066783032,
-0.0197434705,
-0.0312674828,
-0.0318895988,
-0.0125482818,
-0.0386312306,
-0.0102490904,
-0.01133304,
0.0369065814,
0.0195249673,
-0.046824526,
-0.0307945255,
-0.041836638,
0.0102950111,
-0.0357458778,
0.0533583611,
0.0408832245,
0.0474895984,
0.0289885607,
-0.0035308595,
0.0128057711,
0.0274794232,
0.0072739203,
-0.0157979261,
-0.0376054198,
0.0170207918,
-0.0179156885,
0.0395673215,
0.0646479651,
-0.0003990458,
0.0270013381,
-0.0438080318,
-0.0527607799,
-0.053825371,
-0.0266343076,
-0.0102219284,
0.0699108988,
0.0255580395,
-0.0103509706,
-0.0138615277,
0.0272757113,
-0.0176720917,
-0.0296231192,
0.0057144905,
0.0123042902,
-0.0359197408,
0.0054569817,
0.030729698,
-0.0363257676,
0.0411985032,
0.0820766017,
-0.0479846857,
-0.0141569581,
-0.0065570548,
0.0307501704,
-0.0123423254,
0.0223401934,
0.0085822418,
-0.0472444221,
-0.0262789279,
0.0452150069,
-0.0507067963,
-0.0013042244,
-0.0282282587,
-0.0216024239,
0.0739813596,
0.0206722636,
0.0804053694,
-0.0647882894,
0.0122415051,
-0.0217496976,
-0.0565267429,
0.0146421706,
-5.425463687e-33,
-0.0227723587,
-0.0223517474,
-0.0243054219,
0.008650735,
-0.0101750921,
-0.0337403789,
0.0146876574,
0.0230219457,
-0.0312335975,
0.0294892304,
-0.0004846143,
0.0141360546,
0.0079722041,
0.0113855507,
0.0124537535,
-0.0388715267,
0.008767725,
0.0073231352,
-0.0051408,
0.002785878,
0.0798659921,
0.002213944,
0.052826751,
-0.0746315941,
0.0391237959,
-0.0051316679,
-0.0223586131,
-0.0033872917,
0.0342157148,
0.0282144509,
0.0112873027,
0.0751319975,
0.0497522876,
-0.0106942039,
0.017008651,
0.0585919507,
-0.033518143,
0.0106188161,
0.0230240654,
0.0373167172,
0.0422226042,
0.0341423675,
0.0387123935,
-0.0185644776,
-0.0455368087,
0.0068091163,
0.0374352857,
-0.0086638536,
0.0308909118,
-0.0507740751,
-0.0884593278,
0.0147518469,
-0.0277373791,
0.0231878441,
-0.022287067,
0.0701996312,
0.0312289484,
0.0278454907,
-0.0721015483,
0.0380935371,
-0.0337067246,
-0.0268274378,
-0.0028793185,
0.0059160669,
0.0024702617,
0.0432136543,
0.0011462909,
0.009267305,
-0.0425147973,
0.0392813534,
0.0323567018,
0.0230625644,
0.0255708825,
0.0767169967,
-0.015845729,
-0.1145822704,
-0.0304916706,
0.0131319994,
0.0479370132,
-0.0099098729,
0.016197484,
-0.0416318364,
-0.0273265317,
-0.0520862788,
0.0146784727,
-0.0692589581,
-0.0294850413,
-0.0188921094,
-0.0073803733,
-0.0389613733,
-0.0644362047,
-0.0079759145,
0.0236940067,
-0.0587482043,
-0.00807459,
0.0721276551,
-0.047060933,
0.0245880987,
-0.0085691186,
0.0293086562,
-0.0278901011,
-0.0300080646,
-0.0408020839,
-0.0058935285,
0.0433022715,
0.0100434665,
0.0458003394,
0.0287531409,
-0.0732775256,
0.000514022,
0.0089893201,
0.0476846844,
-0.0184002388,
0.0810511783,
-0.0012262135,
0.0457162112,
-0.0246139988,
-0.0408158377,
0.0334382653,
0.0210423321,
0.0157985389,
-0.0036848441,
-0.0121620959,
-0.0195511617,
-0.0378397107,
-0.0273773186,
-0.0338726379,
0.0079483548,
0.0231181551,
-0.1031389982,
0.0143290292,
-0.0437345169,
2.487e-7,
0.0471234322,
0.071265243,
-0.0225154571,
0.0068083042,
0.0086503485,
0.0409900732,
0.0460385568,
0.0040432862,
-0.0135224294,
-0.0137541406,
-0.0268213674,
0.0431362279,
0.0037130539,
0.0533934645,
-0.0175845027,
-0.0082910908,
-0.086410597,
-0.0055282735,
-0.0626173019,
0.0426220633,
-0.0271256194,
0.0659033209,
0.052446451,
-0.0405500792,
-0.0612768978,
0.0097925579,
0.032543283,
-0.0194281004,
-0.0426118262,
0.0057851649,
0.0148362527,
0.0152704716,
0.0093515795,
-0.0317508839,
-0.003474863,
0.0219432898,
0.0306876283,
0.032903906,
0.0301311519,
0.0096829766,
0.0252920426,
-0.0241388883,
0.0010453141,
-0.0359534025,
0.066653192,
-0.0208770446,
-0.0382142775,
-0.0683790222,
-0.0229890533,
0.0107811494,
0.0449470691,
-0.0187109727,
-0.0042022988,
0.0231953003,
0.0267980192,
0.0009559834,
-0.0061889295,
-0.0287327673,
-0.0030832526,
-0.0067111035,
-0.0090522971,
-0.0311317462,
0.0015119682,
0.0110793896,
0.0325971134,
0.0538467579,
0.0511264354,
1.952562697e-34,
0.0536356978,
-0.0051984619,
-0.0122536281,
-0.070229888,
0.0283479746,
0.0207639486,
-0.0064234352,
0.0107929418,
-0.0059890603,
-0.0385650322,
0.0003723642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13631v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13631v2 | TopoBERT: Plug and Play Toponym Recognition Module Harnessing Fine-tuned BERT | 2023-01-31T13:44:34 | 2023-02-03T17:45:11 | Bing Zhou, Lei Zou, Yingjie Hu, Yi Qiang, Daniel Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Extracting precise geographical information from textual contents is crucial
in a plethora of applications. For example, during hazardous events, a robust
and unbiased toponym extraction framework can provide an avenue to tie the
location concerned to the topic discussed by news media posts and pinpoint
humanitarian help requests or damage reports from social media. Early studies
have leveraged rule-based, gazetteer-based, deep learning, and hybrid
approaches to address this problem. However, the performance of existing tools
is deficient in supporting operations like emergency rescue, which relies on
fine-grained, accurate geographic information. The emerging pretrained language
models can better capture the underlying characteristics of text information,
including place names, offering a promising pathway to optimize toponym
recognition to underpin practical applications. In this paper, TopoBERT, a
toponym recognition module based on a one dimensional Convolutional Neural
Network (CNN1D) and Bidirectional Encoder Representation from Transformers
(BERT), is proposed and fine-tuned. Three datasets (CoNLL2003-Train,
Wikipedia3000, WNUT2017) are leveraged to tune the hyperparameters, discover
the best training strategy, and train the model. Another two datasets
(CoNLL2003-Test and Harvey2017) are used to evaluate the performance. Three
distinguished classifiers, linear, multi-layer perceptron, and CNN1D, are
benchmarked to determine the optimal model architecture. TopoBERT achieves
state-of-the-art performance (f1-score=0.865) compared to the other five
baseline models and can be applied to diverse toponym recognition tasks without
additional training. | [
0.0508330278,
0.0433466583,
0.0058805053,
0.0390980765,
-0.0147675388,
0.0224596597,
0.028598791,
0.003941773,
0.0268983487,
-0.0516896546,
0.0031355759,
-0.0042457683,
-0.0241588634,
0.0321655981,
0.0154745085,
-0.0413851887,
0.0262356885,
-0.0133506097,
0.0172107909,
-0.0031805413,
-0.0131042404,
0.024877958,
-0.0033203468,
0.0241728444,
0.0067750826,
0.0474937148,
0.0113220206,
0.0108841006,
0.039421998,
-0.0388564058,
0.0557937734,
0.0165175013,
0.0148089603,
0.0820029601,
0.0000021592,
-0.0017863679,
-0.0347900279,
-0.014009974,
-0.0129052848,
-0.0287396312,
-0.0410112739,
-0.0317188911,
-0.0221107639,
-0.0275530312,
-0.0089522712,
-0.0345239379,
0.0775685757,
0.0546613932,
0.0348612033,
0.0662676841,
-0.0052525341,
-0.0393777527,
0.0331701115,
0.0150992768,
-0.0402801335,
0.0025111334,
0.0305450112,
-0.0649331957,
-0.0313314311,
-0.0001995285,
0.0247159638,
0.0215862077,
-0.0269042272,
0.0275760759,
-0.0218385551,
0.0614879355,
-0.0743732378,
0.0141921407,
0.0024453502,
0.0705944374,
-0.0578394681,
-0.0200102031,
0.0455781482,
0.022890754,
-0.0536771193,
0.0242331121,
-0.0010488027,
-0.0149835441,
-0.0208715107,
0.0022165023,
-0.0453146696,
0.0117876474,
0.03910321,
0.0717794746,
-0.037878722,
0.0220893957,
-0.0025685066,
-0.0207159612,
-0.0205742326,
-0.0058491672,
-0.0153457271,
-0.0602114238,
0.0625914931,
0.0234595183,
-0.0062336372,
-0.0175897591,
-0.0332126729,
-0.0244852323,
0.0150096035,
-0.0813978612,
-0.0072395848,
-0.0126228007,
-0.0094106253,
0.0233404301,
-0.0324238092,
0.0079621458,
-0.0278651677,
0.0705148727,
0.0101797543,
-0.0401405841,
-0.0503286272,
-0.0011593864,
-0.0209497735,
0.0359515436,
0.0050041932,
0.0302908644,
-0.01389331,
-0.002251497,
0.013657691,
-0.0031497176,
-0.0301171411,
0.0262100361,
-0.0293954406,
-0.0154633541,
0.0080648093,
0.0116297156,
-0.0121457968,
0.0217593145,
-0.0312357116,
0.0160809774,
0.0218376052,
0.0003566756,
0.0678350925,
-0.0060387012,
0.0167998578,
0.0528370254,
0.0192908235,
-0.0786972269,
-0.0439495631,
0.0177304447,
0.018759042,
0.0132560711,
0.0420898162,
-0.0548262782,
0.0047321655,
-0.0081590423,
-0.0136880092,
-0.0345991664,
0.0128455739,
-0.0192090049,
-0.0681395456,
0.0682100356,
-0.0563621931,
-0.0046255346,
0.0834096745,
-0.0062817773,
0.0131132612,
0.0236013997,
0.0726262182,
0.0936997756,
0.0323794149,
0.0010471061,
-0.0244100094,
0.0290762167,
0.0029819678,
-0.0244677607,
-0.0285146311,
0.0003677724,
-0.0351385288,
0.017452145,
0.010829635,
0.0194435883,
0.0234059263,
0.0071529332,
0.061559584,
0.0590929091,
-0.0209033675,
-0.0175574291,
0.0117142275,
0.0663887486,
-0.0454058163,
-0.0783912838,
-0.0396718159,
-0.0405223183,
-0.0175261311,
-0.0006621569,
-0.0028343445,
0.065182291,
-0.0034620252,
0.0187504552,
-0.0172773581,
-0.0017711343,
-0.0173466913,
-0.0006820628,
0.050557442,
-0.0433272496,
-0.0198038686,
0.0898351297,
0.0124160713,
0.0136976829,
0.0345965214,
-0.0120173022,
-0.051357124,
0.0662788227,
0.0346829183,
-0.0078577232,
-0.0108375903,
-0.049904637,
0.0454017818,
0.0353912227,
-0.0149629144,
0.0239860322,
0.0316439755,
-0.0599476844,
-0.0311518814,
0.0513966642,
-0.0029915683,
0.0373736061,
0.0493299328,
0.0383807868,
0.0295304023,
-0.0370970704,
-0.01397797,
0.0166388825,
0.0028507039,
-0.0237131901,
-0.0060494905,
0.0262745097,
-0.0167163536,
0.0224990901,
-0.0378374867,
-0.0426778719,
0.0398064293,
-0.0339458473,
-0.0100161498,
-0.015539987,
0.01608859,
0.0089267818,
0.0120836282,
-0.0712727159,
-0.0030293134,
0.0579522029,
-0.0277605392,
-0.0163662713,
-0.0129035553,
-0.0406925641,
0.0516491681,
-0.0248130336,
0.0112625668,
-0.0123859486,
0.039664764,
-0.0374958515,
0.0764011592,
-0.0371981487,
0.0101026027,
-0.0052382122,
-0.0233812295,
-0.0068472736,
0.0349272676,
-0.033842165,
-0.0295999479,
-0.0522115603,
0.0151963178,
-0.0140776224,
0.010822,
0.009083923,
-0.0578082912,
-0.0585766584,
-0.017674638,
-0.0366368927,
0.005566732,
-0.0080049802,
0.0164600629,
-0.0337653086,
-0.0066409409,
0.0058209151,
-0.0492808819,
-0.0405570455,
0.0048852689,
0.0279638898,
-0.0147887738,
-0.0263450872,
-0.0059339255,
-0.0288146194,
-0.0163103305,
0.031523183,
-0.004882074,
-0.0708393678,
-0.0054045003,
-0.0195945073,
-0.0212794859,
0.0190030839,
-0.0087748701,
-0.0592394732,
-0.0088041937,
0.0280976929,
0.0157332253,
-0.0038680802,
0.046989508,
0.012587646,
-0.0045052259,
-0.0085971523,
-0.0230866745,
0.0074218619,
-0.0473517179,
0.0028556082,
0.0002031875,
-0.0074591571,
-0.0042040846,
-0.0020995017,
-0.0210812371,
0.0409941785,
0.0060502831,
-0.0284227952,
0.0014728977,
-0.0187912229,
-0.0403322987,
-0.0174129196,
-0.0211335141,
0.0235146303,
-0.0241363421,
0.0019870233,
0.030522028,
-0.031533666,
0.021177141,
0.0183283668,
-0.0220253859,
0.0076616658,
0.0234967545,
0.0162074249,
0.0519985333,
0.0097833648,
-0.081324935,
0.0623240992,
-0.0188458506,
-0.0361150503,
-0.0437850058,
-0.0135549922,
0.012773593,
0.0041142013,
0.009221822,
-0.0257801302,
-0.0321772955,
-0.0402261429,
0.0050151288,
0.0008746557,
0.0031035074,
-0.0442369394,
0.0107218577,
0.0551547334,
0.0184985753,
0.0424195863,
0.0124336118,
0.0206754655,
-0.0355414934,
0.0874021128,
0.0272341203,
-0.0006537925,
0.0177467763,
0.0436472222,
-0.0754922628,
0.006879081,
-0.0008059001,
0.0139790941,
0.0105981436,
0.0083296439,
0.0154012414,
-0.0793026611,
-0.0159337036,
-0.0228690282,
0.0293675885,
-0.019787645,
-0.0347355567,
0.0767896697,
0.0283654053,
-0.0555712469,
0.0065837102,
0.0353833772,
-0.0296417046,
0.0033014237,
-0.0085935565,
-0.0164979436,
0.0062525813,
0.0141591718,
-0.0058750226,
-0.0225135982,
-0.0846104547,
0.0190082826,
-0.0445135124,
-0.0062169153,
-0.025333235,
-0.0532085337,
-0.0269241631,
-0.0608505085,
0.0009153782,
0.0184050854,
-0.0075642494,
-0.0437617749,
-0.0192526858,
-0.0327436067,
0.0384364501,
-0.040367458,
-0.0788284764,
0.0122772092,
-0.0994738787,
0.0507382788,
0.0249730852,
0.0361695662,
-0.0520396642,
-0.0143770706,
-0.0401950441,
0.0358459875,
-0.0126875686,
-0.0053962534,
0.0553252473,
-0.0384693965,
-0.0393994674,
0.001794907,
-0.0187527984,
-0.0338005573,
-0.0145032844,
-0.0287516192,
0.0293299351,
-0.0106967138,
0.0473965444,
-0.0248985942,
0.0047190101,
0.0301156957,
0.019115353,
-0.0001012137,
0.0236255135,
-0.0019986227,
-0.0174792334,
0.0227275975,
-0.0639416203,
-0.0435777567,
0.0311806612,
-0.0372489057,
-0.1104542837,
-0.0104464227,
-0.029225925,
0.0139925517,
0.0065886392,
0.0035104288,
-0.0295561478,
0.054186251,
-0.0075720176,
-0.1123573259,
0.0434979908,
-0.0129489927,
0.0218574572,
-0.02999934,
0.0105212042,
0.0574833788,
0.0161532871,
-0.0340391137,
0.0555858649,
-0.053784769,
-0.0275802612,
0.0609227419,
0.0067508332,
0.011980623,
-0.0065871957,
-0.0539552085,
-0.0232908912,
0.0686010048,
0.0579519644,
-0.0006003437,
-0.0454215705,
0.0141942231,
-0.0288936626,
-0.0013907532,
0.0049481909,
-0.0420321636,
0.0669818074,
0.0315000452,
-0.0267315432,
-0.0465424918,
0.0259072538,
-0.020401489,
-0.0015417256,
0.1188126206,
-0.0295805838,
-0.0334657952,
-0.0166512933,
-0.0064495774,
-0.0124895824,
0.0377296619,
0.0222404338,
0.0151310591,
0.0313423611,
0.0097617777,
-0.0288369581,
0.0346364602,
0.0367891006,
-0.0186817031,
-0.0371304862,
-0.0151142152,
-0.0135150701,
0.053707201,
0.0113555202,
0.0012430937,
-0.0361455902,
0.0431207269,
0.0354221389,
0.0300378669,
-0.036757119,
-0.0470077209,
0.0119940331,
0.0142212315,
-0.0302200932,
0.0501778424,
-0.0353147872,
-0.0202372074,
-0.0768446326,
0.0197665598,
0.0778652951,
0.007169134,
0.0151892509,
-0.0020636227,
0.0028660153,
0.0194376241,
-0.0183813665,
-0.0089077996,
-0.0563782454,
0.0021897587,
0.0141959656,
-0.0247327033,
0.0381218456,
0.0242070165,
0.0464643538,
0.0552246124,
0.0313901454,
-0.0395532176,
-0.0189059861,
-0.0156590827,
0.0054933308,
0.038563624,
-0.0251543671,
-0.0000843757,
-0.0311186407,
-0.0341096669,
0.0418103598,
-0.0334540568,
0.0000888218,
0.0264848769,
0.0112942597,
0.04399845,
0.0157017857,
-0.0085953325,
-0.0269338973,
0.0127601214,
0.0200362187,
-0.0588885248,
-0.0004108602,
-6.693826867e-33,
-0.0040143048,
-0.0635627359,
0.0150178876,
-0.0092893466,
-0.0365059488,
0.0521234125,
-0.0139544019,
-0.0085247364,
-0.0345891491,
-0.0127913719,
-0.0127835833,
-0.0128631201,
0.0234835837,
0.0440256335,
-0.0309915673,
-0.0267323609,
0.0069790846,
0.0426377393,
-0.0099435197,
-0.0024988782,
0.0760170594,
0.0517746322,
0.0996424705,
-0.1167855486,
-0.0052928352,
0.0190362353,
-0.024778055,
0.0081946533,
0.0752418563,
0.0448788851,
-0.0548281632,
0.0390475392,
0.0151772788,
-0.0111371698,
0.0170366149,
0.0081307665,
-0.0616738163,
0.0013229059,
-0.0137161855,
0.0332197472,
0.0480396673,
-0.0434913673,
0.0797069818,
0.0185273066,
-0.0122148115,
0.0283257607,
0.0377954058,
0.0159872584,
-0.0484837107,
-0.0169831179,
-0.0589301027,
0.0095151216,
-0.009889435,
-0.0087276269,
0.0061930879,
-0.0036899031,
0.0579992048,
0.0249572564,
-0.0963218287,
-0.0068620993,
0.0367322043,
0.0066303611,
0.0581702925,
0.0084545314,
-0.0295669474,
0.0909515396,
0.00280227,
-0.0254443437,
-0.0279812273,
-0.0291928183,
0.0597672649,
0.0465784855,
0.0145512177,
0.0646297634,
-0.0115783708,
-0.0541186817,
-0.0524530448,
0.0422089025,
0.0088402824,
-0.0345333628,
0.0380555429,
-0.0364097618,
-0.0623294488,
0.0063115689,
0.0022962478,
-0.0464187786,
-0.009005758,
-0.003141671,
0.0218638368,
-0.0073017636,
-0.0319291838,
0.1142618209,
0.0055471375,
-0.012936105,
-0.0022689837,
0.0096178195,
0.0511232466,
0.0482072532,
-0.0080300625,
0.0489529818,
-0.0419330895,
-0.0257837083,
-0.0193001945,
0.0121704964,
-0.0166564547,
0.0170052126,
0.013968356,
0.0440659486,
-0.0416384898,
0.0203001257,
0.0073712044,
-0.0039489344,
-0.0168051198,
0.0106920274,
0.0061395299,
-0.0252554007,
0.0206141435,
-0.0187281147,
0.0710129365,
0.0127735259,
0.0353528783,
-0.0214066003,
-0.0132851675,
0.0515670739,
0.0156408306,
-0.0029912973,
-0.0345390737,
0.0179003458,
0.0081087165,
-0.0525736921,
0.0001715728,
-0.0222061332,
2.951e-7,
0.0465913936,
0.0755906701,
0.0392511673,
-0.0006823064,
-0.0417035185,
0.0153725697,
0.0662154704,
0.0742400065,
-0.0343610421,
0.0025517812,
0.006527029,
0.0364014171,
0.0093897013,
0.0256395247,
-0.1107585728,
-0.0068411231,
-0.0894801468,
0.005847963,
-0.0930211321,
-0.0016286975,
0.0382271074,
0.0876066983,
0.060009554,
-0.0452331342,
-0.00948592,
-0.0261204205,
0.004732993,
-0.0598907173,
-0.0189961288,
0.0268548913,
0.02371989,
0.0185729824,
-0.0164645575,
0.0001945789,
-0.0037295592,
0.0020887728,
0.0284075066,
0.0443351567,
-0.0428744443,
0.0199839547,
-0.0360296704,
-0.1032487899,
0.0173750762,
-0.0716194585,
0.0455695428,
0.0025502262,
-0.0300940368,
0.0039272541,
-0.0180547237,
-0.0007258074,
0.0360449813,
-0.0405962802,
-0.0445171259,
0.0205123052,
0.0243322719,
-0.0034461559,
-0.0336702317,
-0.0910745859,
0.032635089,
-0.0194713101,
-0.0013857152,
0.0074059241,
-0.0112463832,
-0.0441126972,
0.037492644,
-0.0201383531,
0.0198702887,
2.59689064e-34,
-0.0304118954,
0.0236158818,
-0.0333771706,
0.0401221663,
0.0213287063,
0.0348865949,
0.0392525718,
-0.0076908949,
-0.0529891178,
-0.0325743556,
0.0298946444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13479v1 | Archive TimeLine Summarization (ATLS): Conceptual Framework for Timeline Generation over Historical Document Collections | 2023-01-31T08:58:47 | 2023-01-31T08:58:47 | Nicolas Gutehrlé, Antoine Doucet, Adam Jatowt | cs.CL | cs.CL | Archive collections are nowadays mostly available through search engines
interfaces, which allow a user to retrieve documents by issuing queries. The
study of these collections may be, however, impaired by some aspects of search
engines, such as the overwhelming number of documents returned or the lack of
contextual knowledge provided. New methods that could work independently or in
combination with search engines are then required to access these collections.
In this position paper, we propose to extend TimeLine Summarization (TLS)
methods on archive collections to assist in their studies. We provide an
overview of existing TLS methods and we describe a conceptual framework for an
Archive TimeLine Summarization (ATLS) system, which aims to generate
informative, readable and interpretable timelines. | [
0.0345907733,
0.0527232289,
-0.0024494883,
-0.0005518036,
-0.0386083946,
0.0284978207,
-0.0069048768,
0.0074101593,
-0.0084352735,
0.0004855745,
0.0598179176,
0.0227896366,
0.0012204574,
0.0079416987,
-0.0854494125,
-0.1032874063,
0.0250302516,
0.0427728891,
0.0272853374,
0.0006428315,
0.0052070417,
0.0218806192,
-0.022348756,
-0.0146877132,
0.0531381182,
0.0012935736,
-0.0455215052,
-0.0057367175,
0.0039908709,
-0.0445370078,
-0.02980447,
-0.0165558178,
0.0340634063,
0.0445567667,
0.000001742,
-0.0645019561,
-0.0461286902,
-0.0100561632,
-0.0124036064,
0.0464984402,
0.0308698621,
0.0184205063,
-0.0015796322,
-0.0357186981,
-0.0065632435,
-0.0111823808,
-0.0152363498,
0.0177050196,
0.0274482798,
0.0128056612,
0.0108476076,
-0.0267897099,
0.0263360515,
0.0128745362,
0.0237394124,
-0.0444362015,
-0.0311821327,
0.0236848816,
0.0664278194,
0.0191972647,
0.0111087039,
0.0664437264,
-0.0284651499,
-0.0314201601,
-0.0069237063,
0.0325690955,
-0.0255699791,
-0.0037207487,
-0.0083054444,
-0.0333241709,
0.0795553848,
-0.0011510368,
0.0442111753,
0.048199527,
-0.054799024,
0.0366950221,
-0.1091337577,
0.0598337874,
-0.0356699936,
-0.0067342264,
0.0074246777,
0.0413270295,
-0.0210078489,
0.0374295264,
-0.0167841874,
0.0142692132,
-0.0013882822,
0.0001840282,
-0.0445278473,
-0.0206497032,
0.0785946995,
-0.0325709321,
0.0156737268,
0.063011989,
0.0361609943,
-0.0111576635,
0.0215130541,
-0.0039262665,
0.0429523997,
-0.0218143128,
-0.0428972095,
-0.0188034214,
0.0030079456,
0.0716143399,
0.0346466713,
0.0301852692,
-0.0051230434,
-0.0784880221,
-0.0112488568,
0.0082934899,
-0.0210796148,
0.0002528607,
-0.0148903364,
0.0010886284,
-0.0377784111,
0.0205783043,
-0.0109258965,
0.0472017936,
0.0422275029,
-0.0181688834,
-0.0288479663,
-0.0089728981,
-0.007256459,
-0.0116298925,
-0.0523224995,
-0.0300482046,
-0.0313609354,
-0.02952688,
-0.0215247776,
-0.0431094356,
0.0062066382,
0.0103511484,
0.0488538593,
-0.0030532742,
-0.0367757827,
-0.0245727208,
-0.0320294425,
-0.0017773373,
-0.074327752,
-0.0710595921,
0.0273065604,
0.0252341144,
-0.0004884757,
-0.0419386327,
0.0103534684,
0.0097913761,
-0.0079001719,
0.0435919762,
-0.0252557695,
-0.0208971202,
-0.0581957288,
0.0032145018,
-0.0235039126,
0.0165200215,
0.0705519691,
-0.0047925822,
0.0259024799,
-0.0062693683,
0.0408207215,
0.0370694399,
0.0534528717,
0.0494244657,
-0.0186484456,
-0.0053709205,
0.0059078163,
-0.0001751965,
-0.0313896611,
-0.001119133,
-0.0446997769,
-0.0100763021,
-0.016299298,
-0.0040847659,
-0.0293456689,
0.0157889966,
0.0223138165,
0.0186444875,
0.0453601554,
0.046761971,
0.0319370404,
0.0093518132,
0.0618050657,
0.0231081694,
0.036206577,
0.0135003198,
0.0080148224,
0.022144055,
-0.0278167762,
-0.0045580999,
-0.0033131931,
-0.0338582881,
0.0367372744,
0.0462114699,
0.010937986,
-0.0150518669,
0.013155465,
-0.0001251529,
-0.0004185438,
-0.0083844587,
-0.0224480387,
-0.0510331169,
0.0773622394,
0.0203615203,
0.0037589162,
0.0656166077,
0.083289206,
-0.0462793745,
-0.0071389508,
-0.0153161744,
0.0275203567,
0.0160073861,
0.0397045054,
-0.0324261971,
-0.0067491294,
-0.0388779305,
-0.0855175629,
0.0010796401,
0.0110938055,
-0.0072803046,
-0.0064626178,
0.0059632622,
0.0338663831,
-0.0477802157,
0.0270071905,
0.0184855945,
-0.0381613262,
-0.0089421989,
-0.0278546344,
0.0076559708,
-0.0247764289,
0.061436832,
0.0021169607,
0.0027782449,
0.0351061672,
-0.0002495145,
0.0217200164,
0.0469550304,
0.030327294,
0.0230444651,
0.01108984,
-0.0486913584,
0.0246642437,
0.0100606661,
-0.0174238142,
-0.0792417303,
-0.0014033355,
-0.0310721193,
0.0293683317,
-0.0086998865,
-0.0038175883,
-0.0265053958,
-0.0052349162,
-0.0512691401,
0.0917684063,
0.0124251861,
-0.0095310155,
0.0740763843,
-0.0379481502,
0.0138746155,
-0.017847605,
0.0003531419,
0.0090635614,
0.0038395049,
-0.0242102072,
0.0877711102,
-0.0232210681,
-0.0500364341,
0.0087295268,
-0.1061472893,
-0.0221068859,
-0.0179666206,
0.0370056406,
0.0247054938,
0.0203973055,
-0.0270189717,
-0.0301442146,
0.0167614929,
-0.0490321182,
-0.0321442112,
-0.0209806375,
0.0533019416,
0.0765799209,
-0.0033130157,
-0.0375830084,
-0.0266858321,
-0.0094251381,
0.0113523034,
0.071770452,
-0.0896044374,
0.0252723284,
0.0103283189,
-0.0029445796,
-0.0224345047,
-0.0224465448,
0.0422709808,
0.0145752495,
-0.0244652685,
0.0159627199,
0.0276965704,
0.0535524301,
0.0287615024,
0.0244776737,
-0.0572500899,
-0.0255127195,
-0.007915061,
-0.0457137376,
0.0321157537,
0.0388508067,
-0.021934934,
0.0225819405,
-0.0448694751,
0.0086793955,
0.0438988134,
-0.0113383997,
-0.0459695607,
-0.0209442377,
0.0387898013,
-0.0564357862,
-0.0331613459,
-0.0058825351,
0.035441678,
-0.001985986,
-0.0183457434,
-0.0198861137,
0.0297361352,
0.0235922653,
-0.0157351829,
-0.013285148,
-0.0646424964,
0.0982274786,
0.0097043561,
0.0148661099,
0.0205070954,
-0.041484721,
-0.0128859533,
0.0216165073,
0.0560032837,
-0.0422368161,
-0.0023616625,
-0.0338054597,
-0.0265552867,
-0.0048263306,
0.0495275632,
-0.033049874,
-0.0439479575,
0.0310065523,
-0.0084511945,
-0.0221018419,
0.0136229433,
-0.0721660033,
0.0044045765,
0.0412081704,
0.0773364455,
-0.0124731511,
-0.0284134038,
0.0020987398,
0.0766403377,
0.0192139857,
-0.051568348,
0.0171236098,
0.0388683304,
0.0138485078,
-0.0064635798,
0.0656896457,
-0.0055225007,
0.012906638,
-0.0034399508,
-0.0221355911,
-0.0769555867,
-0.0149361026,
0.0040645711,
-0.0584167615,
-0.0250254162,
0.0157213621,
0.0746263638,
0.0694720373,
-0.0562669486,
-0.0397492424,
0.016562311,
-0.0528798029,
-0.0073227747,
-0.0226588622,
-0.0325528979,
0.0780036524,
-0.0302144177,
0.0123603633,
-0.0178207103,
-0.0243079551,
-0.0337318666,
-0.0218271203,
0.0144675393,
0.0131984437,
-0.014912595,
0.0349597,
-0.064466849,
-0.0081069367,
-0.0030055013,
-0.0835181996,
0.0283415113,
-0.0413799956,
0.0033224425,
0.0130305961,
-0.0643692762,
0.0010928579,
-0.0139736403,
0.0357357673,
-0.0200986825,
0.0139640803,
0.0572723076,
-0.0213597734,
0.0402836166,
0.0228484441,
0.0064844228,
0.0051795808,
-0.0331283994,
0.0629628822,
0.0192307271,
0.0186276324,
-0.0315310881,
0.0220856424,
0.0625974238,
0.0346960649,
0.0025519803,
0.0384748243,
-0.0317730866,
0.0269882958,
-0.0511042178,
-0.026828466,
0.0011249617,
-0.009877217,
0.0100382678,
0.028655665,
-0.0051606116,
-0.0049886275,
0.0427477024,
-0.0456481092,
0.0077874339,
-0.0476713441,
-0.0710346177,
-0.0350653343,
-0.0475529246,
-0.0539277159,
-0.0700952336,
-0.0173012968,
-0.0168072358,
0.0143522481,
-0.0185737405,
-0.0035493483,
-0.0595099144,
-0.0137514081,
-0.0076197824,
0.0053779576,
-0.002254039,
-0.0223380011,
0.0164083205,
-0.0022634408,
-0.0166689418,
0.0416275412,
-0.0167321786,
-0.0097625637,
0.0381762721,
-0.021510886,
0.0194215309,
0.0312697813,
0.0064277961,
-0.0003830401,
0.05679892,
0.0319177918,
0.0212370027,
-0.0549055189,
-0.0396670401,
0.0003443863,
-0.0565458238,
0.0031644849,
-0.0803495049,
0.0158180017,
-0.1141188145,
0.0145047698,
-0.0607659891,
-0.038925156,
-0.0206658952,
0.0223479196,
0.0257343724,
-0.0251904167,
-0.031052934,
0.0424337499,
-0.0145173799,
-0.043003384,
-0.015409125,
0.0348624028,
0.0417028591,
-0.0364267342,
-0.0209714025,
-0.0029608824,
0.0979981571,
-0.0032969625,
0.0237019751,
-0.0589675121,
0.0393568166,
-0.0129468851,
0.0310301539,
-0.0549512319,
0.0326964557,
-0.0265501756,
-0.0158541612,
0.0019911465,
0.0160936099,
0.0165923294,
-0.0164164677,
0.0051448988,
0.0395996757,
-0.0319227614,
-0.0166299269,
-0.1188892052,
0.0454666428,
0.0069982763,
-0.0200397279,
0.0640148446,
-0.0384276509,
0.0588086173,
-0.0196250472,
-0.0100756325,
0.0011822971,
0.0155939562,
0.0738004074,
0.0157709029,
-0.0502535254,
0.0192515031,
0.0079423012,
0.0328517668,
0.0359704085,
-0.0255256332,
-0.0025639136,
0.0117014553,
-0.0393267386,
-0.022376772,
-0.0283741858,
-0.0370656624,
0.0051764073,
-0.008888172,
-0.045186989,
-0.0435799398,
0.0450396873,
0.0586837158,
0.0260720085,
0.0350902267,
-0.0199619066,
0.0114976028,
0.02064256,
0.0293071829,
0.011170404,
-0.0390237048,
0.061459817,
-0.0427663513,
0.0212854333,
-0.043924842,
-5.374927715e-33,
-0.0025910947,
-0.0382431075,
-0.0038236377,
0.0094982898,
-0.0568868592,
-0.005091683,
-0.0317731239,
-0.0553064905,
-0.0046890625,
-0.0305208601,
-0.0268203281,
0.0319069624,
0.0281428453,
-0.052364368,
0.0236594696,
0.0511118993,
0.0351226777,
0.0049588447,
-0.0360048562,
0.0429432131,
0.070840627,
-0.0044999034,
-0.0050185318,
-0.0252512693,
0.0752904639,
-0.027445998,
0.0096433479,
-0.0101964194,
0.103562139,
0.0228415504,
0.0207241345,
-0.0506741181,
0.0202982463,
-0.0402755253,
-0.032577116,
0.0072236359,
-0.0937409103,
-0.0178566966,
0.0510133132,
0.0074530989,
0.0745357126,
-0.0181064401,
0.0044842735,
-0.0035494841,
-0.0038880769,
-0.0221866909,
0.0524524003,
-0.0201711301,
-0.0441182069,
-0.0862029642,
0.017230235,
0.0443373434,
-0.0593066663,
0.0107244747,
0.0746667385,
0.0091523295,
0.0434868149,
0.0134119047,
0.018297229,
0.0447079353,
-0.0274338238,
0.0025397537,
0.0199229885,
0.0004360691,
0.0158992335,
0.0101602953,
-0.0556727052,
0.0139889522,
-0.0132539654,
0.0550637841,
-0.0177778378,
-0.0404338837,
-0.0340080298,
-0.0231934953,
0.0109042339,
0.0377866738,
-0.0044851257,
0.0883693323,
0.0397401042,
0.0523705892,
-0.0052130688,
0.0143156992,
0.0024226939,
0.0449191183,
0.0060362252,
0.0128593063,
0.0003457315,
0.0039763381,
-0.0401129201,
0.0054776603,
-0.0347117893,
-0.0018528949,
-0.0020471078,
-0.019404199,
-0.0066873478,
0.0685584247,
-0.0191230886,
0.0513083786,
-0.0077564847,
-0.0389278494,
0.0017747474,
0.0287338905,
-0.0025518134,
0.0344463624,
-0.0259076059,
-0.0374243408,
0.0129843922,
0.0167459212,
-0.0050603831,
-0.0231819898,
0.0432885587,
-0.03228499,
-0.0350330323,
-0.0654454455,
-0.0025776087,
0.0048028138,
0.0122248046,
-0.0023144688,
0.0116040017,
0.0571608171,
0.0218103509,
-0.0311000962,
0.0008261162,
0.0025299005,
0.0240940042,
-0.0151548795,
-0.0047804527,
0.0463873744,
-0.0023205597,
0.0007087686,
-0.0194956679,
0.0132160364,
2.451e-7,
0.0430216752,
0.0327234715,
0.1089526936,
0.0742525533,
-0.0184017457,
-0.048263859,
-0.0127121946,
-0.0009115846,
-0.0507543273,
0.0238863919,
0.0353521369,
-0.0117254527,
0.0183345862,
0.049494978,
-0.0084334332,
-0.0715570077,
-0.0539159179,
-0.0314519815,
-0.044634115,
0.013348789,
0.0875713378,
-0.0144702187,
0.0103063164,
-0.0008910843,
-0.0074792756,
-0.0027169425,
0.0164816976,
-0.0152088618,
-0.0669495165,
0.0223167539,
0.0422680378,
-0.0175869334,
-0.0221576598,
-0.0351679325,
-0.0157312136,
0.0144665772,
-0.0167721175,
0.024945939,
0.02370633,
0.0152946878,
0.0023867744,
-0.0390958339,
0.0095660258,
0.0226923376,
0.0355798379,
0.0716697201,
0.0319558829,
0.0200458225,
-0.0309308805,
0.0626471043,
-0.0223312452,
0.018952366,
-0.0571524501,
0.0273230709,
-0.0571136065,
-0.0033696564,
0.035476584,
-0.0736600831,
-0.0127752628,
0.024551142,
-0.0069868518,
-0.0241518673,
-0.0050931638,
0.0063995789,
-0.0303650815,
0.0299470611,
0.0377397686,
1.912361824e-34,
0.0654061958,
0.0108095631,
-0.0644140542,
-0.0448970944,
0.0136564616,
-0.0459721051,
-0.0128449881,
0.0238517039,
0.0558759458,
-0.0281316955,
-0.0138635729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13455v1 | ZhichunRoad at Amazon KDD Cup 2022: MultiTask Pre-Training for E-Commerce Product Search | 2023-01-31T07:31:34 | 2023-01-31T07:31:34 | Xuange Cui, Wei Xiong, Songlin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a robust multilingual model to improve the quality
of search results. Our model not only leverage the processed class-balanced
dataset, but also benefit from multitask pre-training that leads to more
general representations. In pre-training stage, we adopt mlm task,
classification task and contrastive learning task to achieve considerably
performance. In fine-tuning stage, we use confident learning, exponential
moving average method (EMA), adversarial training (FGM) and regularized dropout
strategy (R-Drop) to improve the model's generalization and robustness.
Moreover, we use a multi-granular semantic unit to discover the queries and
products textual metadata for enhancing the representation of the model. Our
approach obtained competitive results and ranked top-8 in three tasks. We
release the source code and pre-trained models associated with this work. | [
0.0265101045,
0.0434101298,
-0.0286822747,
0.0413159691,
0.0144444183,
-0.0107238488,
0.0004400842,
-0.0336431414,
-0.0173752978,
-0.0883609802,
-0.0538245663,
-0.0449187979,
-0.048122365,
0.0616772696,
0.0135516459,
-0.0594580248,
0.0177930593,
0.0041071745,
-0.0521170497,
0.0005420704,
0.0429052077,
0.0332793333,
0.0324692577,
-0.0214625895,
0.0221516024,
-0.010280977,
-0.0129126497,
0.0141940024,
0.0191338267,
-0.0361400209,
0.069043681,
0.0199678764,
0.003197534,
0.0316560678,
0.0000024186,
-0.051371187,
-0.0297349766,
-0.0238876753,
-0.0174402744,
-0.0032693981,
0.0329974964,
0.0103553841,
0.0327537842,
0.0186630934,
-0.0247687493,
-0.0077251,
0.0069075297,
0.0918125808,
0.0002374045,
0.0558700748,
-0.0184129458,
-0.0176584441,
0.0075317868,
-0.0362688154,
-0.0030855637,
-0.0554148965,
0.0149370227,
-0.0241390914,
-0.0055191759,
-0.0034758868,
0.004152366,
0.0138049377,
0.0041860631,
0.0232259054,
-0.013453695,
0.0237897746,
-0.0016176071,
0.0190101769,
-0.0016848224,
0.0841251686,
-0.0655377284,
-0.006279326,
-0.0122259585,
-0.0146665731,
-0.005098334,
-0.0175459869,
-0.0165224131,
-0.0144871483,
-0.0039570802,
0.0181120764,
-0.0263989493,
0.0152399009,
0.0207087062,
0.0378175192,
-0.0070482916,
0.0422018729,
-0.0048898896,
-0.0362317711,
0.0263362713,
0.0255584717,
-0.0262771305,
0.0034936583,
0.0402924605,
-0.0155690815,
-0.0257015917,
-0.0082066935,
-0.018798491,
-0.0534436367,
0.0164297931,
-0.0666103885,
-0.0116350213,
-0.003223568,
-0.0314849727,
0.0469266847,
-0.0204387996,
0.0026621437,
0.0308156237,
0.0168850664,
-0.0827489942,
-0.0222694892,
-0.0218452122,
-0.0148622701,
-0.0184497405,
0.0416872501,
-0.0075191213,
0.0177458543,
-0.0547872297,
-0.0042548021,
-0.0087158913,
-0.0329339691,
0.0166344196,
0.0202345345,
-0.0525728241,
-0.0093252175,
-0.0050994921,
-0.0085018659,
-0.0188746732,
0.0359901488,
-0.0299123898,
-0.03825083,
0.0133164059,
0.0531655177,
-0.0015664264,
-0.0449276939,
0.0206307024,
0.0348247252,
-0.0089205895,
-0.0296323095,
-0.0915217921,
-0.0118994489,
0.0252045617,
-0.0368047059,
-0.0194708481,
-0.0135035785,
0.0300327465,
-0.0240046699,
0.0030336997,
0.0100157401,
-0.0229476187,
0.0029583564,
0.0123105263,
0.0956529379,
0.0156420004,
-0.0391754173,
0.0423974879,
-0.0142736621,
0.0039375233,
0.0579780079,
-0.0224797744,
0.044139158,
0.0716853291,
0.0017891929,
0.0066280924,
0.0499696881,
-0.0242572241,
-0.0593092889,
0.0122099174,
0.0307485759,
-0.0115399389,
-0.0090207113,
0.0651072264,
0.0328444541,
-0.0250642858,
-0.020047877,
0.0504022837,
-0.0037313658,
0.0119552538,
0.014462702,
0.0024969028,
0.0017312503,
-0.0251279511,
-0.0158170946,
-0.0208385233,
-0.0144087067,
-0.0415946618,
-0.0115934946,
-0.0029766846,
0.040615689,
-0.0531574488,
-0.0149387876,
0.0342711806,
-0.0342393816,
0.0221972894,
0.0301063675,
0.0443304591,
-0.0299273245,
-0.0154891117,
0.0086265216,
0.0182547979,
-0.0093688983,
0.0188689437,
-0.0262483098,
0.0078665838,
0.0776160657,
0.0282805655,
-0.060486,
-0.0036046184,
-0.0413036793,
0.0136358291,
0.0301859863,
0.0175289381,
-0.0268703345,
0.0298523139,
-0.0727659538,
-0.056140583,
-0.0267600548,
-0.0033037278,
0.0390211865,
-0.018600354,
0.0352576487,
0.0558955669,
-0.0219758134,
-0.0011060772,
0.0166931506,
-0.0031745839,
-0.0238658171,
0.0302300416,
0.0306358337,
-0.0058278041,
0.0031188931,
-0.015914781,
-0.0034745212,
0.0383270271,
-0.0307719987,
-0.0255839992,
0.0091337459,
0.0233589187,
-0.0029970263,
0.0494729578,
-0.0150242951,
0.0001560542,
0.0569705144,
-0.0204230156,
-0.039474491,
-0.0323070884,
0.0140610524,
0.0500484295,
-0.0177027453,
0.002581818,
-0.0089552458,
0.0381234586,
-0.039152544,
0.0477899909,
0.0168719012,
0.0131779956,
-0.0262919907,
-0.0256338697,
0.0164934676,
-0.0359351486,
-0.0310432818,
0.0511720665,
0.0043330593,
0.0562101714,
0.027008459,
0.0079290457,
-0.0366620757,
0.0276861209,
-0.044757776,
0.0034303039,
-0.0157232322,
0.0457740538,
0.0034765801,
-0.0082790572,
-0.0076226462,
-0.0374838747,
-0.0498675853,
0.0308208596,
-0.0297491066,
0.0149403829,
0.0229677577,
0.0127683748,
0.042067226,
-0.0109420223,
-0.0103871366,
0.026024783,
0.0297025833,
-0.0063131647,
-0.022120025,
-0.035763327,
0.032379847,
-0.0162435714,
0.0147724645,
-0.0200767163,
0.0121805565,
-0.0553845912,
-0.0292170942,
-0.0047677364,
0.0607471168,
0.0018646151,
-0.0415555015,
0.0248793419,
-0.0139521547,
-0.0429500975,
0.0096322829,
0.0090108979,
0.0431450605,
0.0039947988,
-0.0060656909,
-0.0017171212,
0.0397659317,
-0.0320574231,
0.0014653261,
-0.0011011936,
-0.0699745566,
0.0075921812,
-0.054029908,
-0.0572538041,
0.0474135466,
-0.0014889708,
0.0224329941,
-0.0317981876,
-0.0652727559,
0.054249905,
0.0430763625,
0.0100762155,
-0.055435773,
-0.0293558575,
-0.0141094774,
0.0296217129,
-0.0184452403,
0.0348726548,
-0.0322275311,
-0.0299725719,
-0.0515820906,
0.0164422765,
0.0161912777,
-0.0288374927,
0.0170648899,
0.0236288179,
0.0015688869,
-0.0141780544,
-0.0643690825,
-0.0224915482,
-0.038700439,
-0.0124307554,
-0.0152619323,
0.0486526005,
0.0057339058,
-0.0974362046,
0.0271651223,
-0.0214183405,
0.0376194045,
0.0013148306,
-0.0243454445,
0.0185511503,
0.0368384793,
0.0759045854,
0.0014690585,
-0.0276934374,
-0.0359663777,
0.0134860352,
0.0548211485,
0.014443351,
-0.0639951602,
-0.0149381254,
-0.0245499983,
0.0480998047,
-0.0408291705,
-0.01958449,
0.0053923107,
-0.0560093373,
-0.0097826924,
0.0406037569,
0.0712040216,
-0.0097579751,
-0.0479703508,
-0.0076900106,
-0.019656213,
-0.0104710171,
0.0206681341,
0.0540744253,
-0.0547469668,
-0.0265995357,
-0.013625497,
0.0411344506,
0.0540909357,
-0.0071151336,
0.0228696764,
-0.1194379106,
-0.0205914285,
-0.0189533997,
-0.0276316553,
-0.0336394496,
-0.0455966145,
-0.0117377322,
-0.0831918716,
0.077991806,
-0.0140639562,
-0.0035454661,
0.0093904668,
0.034847293,
0.0469567925,
-0.0612039641,
0.0239776094,
-0.0610736683,
-0.0240803417,
0.0522217751,
0.0159170721,
-0.0368389003,
0.0196038671,
0.0082426611,
-0.0218425952,
-0.0093586668,
0.006451474,
0.0614621565,
-0.0613751672,
0.0048710634,
0.0207672752,
-0.0062848805,
-0.0315031819,
-0.0049160998,
0.0090596834,
0.0496140085,
-0.004622208,
-0.0160043128,
-0.0390555374,
-0.0565404445,
-0.0175313149,
0.0547040068,
-0.051970873,
-0.058337301,
-0.0136649609,
-0.0674620792,
0.0051133488,
-0.0178853683,
0.0047415043,
0.0450384989,
-0.0077552744,
-0.0335732698,
-0.031143656,
-0.080281809,
0.0264452677,
0.0118252244,
0.0249163527,
0.0059567061,
-0.0418680869,
0.0157969929,
-0.0412364006,
0.002508665,
0.0009860781,
0.0616546273,
-0.0373231322,
0.0348958522,
0.0543811359,
-0.0626725629,
-0.0225704592,
-0.0046975906,
-0.0488292947,
-0.0619602911,
-0.0308043659,
0.0646887943,
0.0061302092,
0.0355349556,
-0.0257205907,
-0.099936381,
0.0111960573,
0.0754298568,
-0.0327039771,
-0.0428425893,
0.058637891,
0.0017613223,
-0.0102290688,
0.0281590316,
-0.051535517,
0.0292464625,
0.0005426585,
0.0353754088,
-0.0161080044,
-0.0316388868,
0.0306818169,
0.0162076894,
0.0696163177,
-0.0118919304,
0.0182041284,
-0.0623982511,
0.0288937334,
0.0279737525,
-0.0294197313,
-0.0240238961,
0.0378661156,
0.0266206861,
-0.0098550934,
-0.0187083632,
0.0619802512,
0.0344914086,
-0.0299693011,
-0.0628281981,
-0.0109274965,
-0.0084555037,
0.0196206998,
-0.0062844688,
0.0269808155,
0.0261108298,
0.0128551498,
0.0467316061,
0.0185849871,
-0.0217880961,
-0.011036749,
0.0257637259,
-0.0002990979,
-0.0334158167,
0.0244993065,
-0.0195839331,
0.0054399013,
-0.068928495,
-0.0149741713,
0.0773249939,
-0.0540742092,
0.0063538179,
-0.0037498956,
-0.0065787099,
-0.0386919565,
0.0225586686,
0.0083104093,
0.0236262195,
0.0079777194,
0.0195155237,
-0.0289759971,
0.0406359397,
0.0985362455,
-0.024609847,
0.0374056399,
0.0138965342,
-0.0361974128,
-0.0594083816,
-0.0051353043,
0.083713159,
0.0488383956,
-0.059720505,
-0.0010035377,
0.0151742855,
-0.0517657287,
-0.0066714194,
-0.0331731811,
0.0244640112,
0.0097815618,
0.0760189891,
0.1103353426,
0.0161492657,
0.0524673015,
-0.0217125956,
-0.0266498644,
-0.0062490785,
0.0196880382,
-0.0029885557,
-6.937134361e-33,
0.0571261682,
0.0006770932,
-0.0364226401,
0.00220935,
0.0380276777,
0.0090211043,
-0.0050223167,
-0.0101267537,
-0.0226600431,
-0.0053021242,
-0.0044073374,
0.0144558456,
0.0160280466,
0.0373081341,
0.0179993659,
-0.0195549093,
0.0432128049,
0.0116015682,
-0.0080550797,
0.0233266689,
0.0235727318,
0.1108188927,
0.0989524871,
-0.0607352294,
0.0288779642,
-0.0169635955,
-0.0381313637,
0.0029929618,
0.0132738752,
0.0755837932,
-0.0319499932,
0.0949525759,
0.028868068,
-0.0256844014,
0.0007889725,
-0.0285654441,
-0.045252461,
-0.0022062466,
-0.0063903271,
0.0408616029,
-0.0166713744,
0.0100962333,
0.0371725,
-0.0235132799,
0.0180442855,
0.0422408432,
0.0801326036,
-0.0171990562,
-0.056398347,
-0.0702104643,
-0.014379845,
0.0203513913,
-0.0192666482,
-0.0227058344,
0.0740615726,
0.0869286433,
0.0285354834,
0.0446054339,
-0.0561079904,
0.0338076614,
-0.0380258001,
0.0160227474,
0.0545966849,
0.0255805254,
-0.029299723,
0.0559613295,
-0.0013567681,
0.0413925648,
0.0385820642,
0.0143314898,
-0.0116873458,
0.0353700705,
0.0153013654,
0.0486559048,
0.051688239,
-0.0126381069,
-0.0558469705,
0.0441284627,
0.0247846395,
0.0316579901,
-0.0167325586,
0.0441294052,
-0.0583024807,
-0.0206932612,
-0.0050262022,
-0.040704675,
-0.0337202065,
-0.0184457917,
0.0261136256,
0.0198305473,
-0.0479235351,
0.022356322,
-0.0032008924,
-0.0432335809,
-0.0654861853,
0.0008817686,
-0.0149857765,
-0.0142142726,
0.0170153528,
0.0051749018,
-0.0343608335,
-0.0553942211,
-0.0207079165,
-0.0616749786,
-0.0321212336,
0.0105079152,
0.0286400411,
0.0302572902,
-0.0327199139,
0.0179848056,
0.0101343011,
-0.0371869095,
0.031631697,
0.0529806316,
0.0249273069,
-0.003002034,
-0.0025521624,
0.0621343963,
0.0568108298,
0.0000995019,
-0.0240460429,
-0.0553484038,
0.0405095518,
-0.0040023415,
0.0086402269,
-0.0103843948,
-0.027888706,
-0.0468846858,
0.0400670432,
-0.0990936533,
-0.0126392581,
-0.0074868402,
3.131e-7,
0.0442086533,
0.030521214,
-0.0492858402,
0.009879658,
-0.0052832207,
0.0410149395,
-0.019167548,
0.0605535805,
-0.0116247991,
0.010582122,
0.0244983938,
-0.0164770875,
0.0502910167,
0.0149350613,
-0.0769946501,
-0.0428368822,
-0.0252924059,
0.0053705224,
-0.0285246857,
0.0107161645,
0.0284106769,
0.1647332907,
0.014879534,
-0.0136663541,
0.0158306099,
-0.0571388379,
0.0466292165,
-0.0431508012,
0.013832381,
0.0140270926,
0.0461433195,
0.052929651,
-0.039764639,
0.0042978954,
-0.0484696068,
0.02611956,
0.0917661488,
0.0286297649,
0.0126932077,
0.0105194803,
0.0122399228,
-0.032075882,
-0.0159730893,
-0.0400346555,
0.0628808066,
-0.0049784053,
-0.0085612675,
0.0211466271,
-0.0187602043,
-0.0059604226,
0.0555448122,
-0.0444027558,
-0.0225407239,
-0.0196829569,
0.0194519013,
-0.0183387659,
-0.0517624095,
-0.0515767671,
-0.0222277343,
-0.0172744002,
-0.0279989224,
-0.0071682613,
-0.0090579772,
-0.0178729258,
0.0246133935,
-0.0275307857,
0.0265867002,
2.627495049e-34,
0.0778601542,
0.0029474818,
-0.0004645351,
0.0286468677,
0.0024846601,
-0.0185512211,
-0.0245604292,
-0.0201390535,
0.010639987,
-0.0715834349,
-0.0494783819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13382v1 | Numeracy from Literacy: Data Science as an Emergent Skill from Large Language Models | 2023-01-31T03:14:57 | 2023-01-31T03:14:57 | David Noever, Forrest McKee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLM) such as OpenAI's ChatGPT and GPT-3 offer unique
testbeds for exploring the translation challenges of turning literacy into
numeracy. Previous publicly-available transformer models from eighteen months
prior and 1000 times smaller failed to provide basic arithmetic. The
statistical analysis of four complex datasets described here combines
arithmetic manipulations that cannot be memorized or encoded by simple rules.
The work examines whether next-token prediction succeeds from sentence
completion into the realm of actual numerical understanding. For example, the
work highlights cases for descriptive statistics on in-memory datasets that the
LLM initially loads from memory or generates randomly using python libraries.
The resulting exploratory data analysis showcases the model's capabilities to
group by or pivot categorical sums, infer feature importance, derive
correlations, and predict unseen test cases using linear regression. To extend
the model's testable range, the research deletes and appends random rows such
that recall alone cannot explain emergent numeracy. | [
-0.0007250889,
0.0853959322,
-0.0379281528,
0.0196918361,
-0.0472566299,
0.0344689041,
0.0298389513,
-0.0214511696,
-0.0313340276,
-0.029999923,
0.0137540335,
-0.036893107,
0.0653996915,
0.0357831456,
0.0494310372,
-0.0255854409,
0.0389713906,
-0.0466430113,
0.0086499406,
0.0316452459,
-0.0491815284,
0.002922649,
-0.0351718888,
0.0389378145,
-0.0214768648,
-0.0095236916,
-0.0000724994,
-0.0810440183,
-0.0335012153,
0.0026162516,
0.001439204,
0.0624070354,
0.0318516083,
0.0644433722,
0.0000021538,
-0.0657218844,
0.0017490465,
-0.0026631253,
-0.035016492,
0.0049134078,
0.0421624817,
-0.0501147397,
0.0012036897,
0.0207638647,
-0.0551794842,
-0.00803567,
0.0394839682,
-0.002713491,
0.0126939947,
0.0584593937,
-0.0092447978,
-0.0447049178,
0.0728198215,
-0.0069759381,
0.0308601875,
0.0269270428,
0.0009516944,
0.0324339271,
-0.0184014104,
0.0148192039,
-0.0423533134,
0.0236566123,
0.0557073466,
0.022792263,
-0.0095928861,
0.0383033045,
-0.034494523,
-0.0182355344,
0.0226220209,
0.0307756308,
0.0001859369,
-0.0402094498,
0.004415256,
0.0067972546,
0.0107640009,
0.0039501814,
-0.0866170377,
0.0425409041,
0.0368105397,
0.0151742948,
0.0313798338,
-0.0266620517,
0.0118365493,
0.0024946043,
-0.0349381715,
0.0271489229,
0.0210128389,
-0.0182263032,
-0.0085092532,
0.0099075511,
-0.0176737737,
-0.0275419578,
-0.0102777965,
0.0336202867,
0.0067252629,
0.0312952474,
-0.0111220945,
-0.0485515706,
0.0042420998,
-0.0681091398,
0.0336173214,
0.1031288207,
-0.0297890566,
-0.0021750424,
-0.0249456353,
0.0552632511,
0.0316178389,
0.0366034545,
-0.0382022858,
0.0278855711,
-0.0063722664,
-0.0384222902,
-0.0320666768,
0.0324798338,
-0.0103867901,
0.0192107931,
-0.0564606823,
0.0203304775,
0.0272011161,
-0.0238366779,
0.0256747901,
-0.0249206182,
-0.0218669772,
0.007297704,
-0.0418605395,
0.0560804978,
-0.0344004147,
0.0116494605,
-0.0199557282,
-0.0711218193,
-0.0207986832,
-0.008799579,
-0.0310107041,
-0.0230182689,
0.0148903569,
0.0549142845,
-0.0313082635,
-0.0197206512,
-0.0390326269,
-0.0244908128,
-0.0001715134,
-0.0522397645,
0.0337732024,
-0.0933686122,
0.0088964822,
0.0683418587,
0.0136855487,
-0.0443618111,
-0.0027591039,
0.0232472252,
-0.0116590131,
0.0419114269,
0.0449642986,
0.0149682723,
-0.0015783608,
-0.0112301409,
0.0574131235,
0.0767849088,
0.0795757398,
-0.0314936116,
0.0168340709,
-0.0383066796,
0.0052947723,
0.0476099476,
0.0250874087,
0.0152212661,
-0.0356864147,
-0.0222419687,
0.0060689123,
0.0027311328,
0.0193920806,
0.0161262341,
-0.0042974898,
-0.0071453247,
0.0704963654,
0.0725529492,
0.0059074932,
0.0393346697,
0.0298129078,
-0.0339200348,
0.031733714,
0.0194635671,
-0.0465544425,
0.0401730761,
-0.011196048,
0.0312432181,
0.0327030718,
0.0268111844,
-0.0121140247,
-0.0669812337,
0.0159370247,
-0.0026977784,
0.027487617,
-0.0185612421,
0.05485994,
-0.0000148337,
-0.0148174493,
0.0450402796,
0.010226246,
-0.0638288036,
-0.0083916374,
-0.0506715216,
0.0218352899,
0.0169488844,
0.0407803804,
-0.0113177132,
-0.0190900415,
0.0206898432,
0.0090976283,
0.0133438585,
0.0171189532,
-0.0237764977,
0.0037091714,
-0.0353073925,
0.0264853258,
0.000679546,
0.0322426297,
-0.0259085577,
-0.0139402561,
0.0130044268,
0.0066645532,
-0.0570828803,
-0.0033745975,
0.0285900533,
-0.0916832015,
-0.0374946706,
-0.0233040433,
-0.0075199399,
-0.0082935207,
-0.0036828103,
0.0264613982,
0.0368699953,
0.0235217605,
0.0016560741,
0.0240608435,
0.0070331953,
-0.0433179401,
-0.0416683033,
0.0432645269,
-0.0252019037,
-0.0105952714,
0.0325546488,
-0.0182962567,
-0.0328929164,
0.0614394248,
-0.0525731929,
0.0501015484,
-0.0169759281,
0.0281440727,
-0.0036106571,
0.0136071863,
0.0039995718,
0.0698184371,
-0.0230852161,
0.0424316116,
-0.0353147984,
-0.0388363078,
0.0341816097,
0.0081975991,
0.0079376353,
-0.0209071878,
0.0006414436,
0.0159399193,
-0.0015912735,
-0.0172486492,
-0.0599330366,
-0.0036041699,
-0.0885509253,
-0.011857722,
-0.0227137152,
0.0507650264,
0.0111455461,
0.0064627142,
0.0021032314,
-0.0159955211,
-0.0198111869,
-0.0120632444,
0.0250236578,
0.016653819,
0.0392507799,
-0.0171680581,
-0.0075231092,
-0.0235165432,
-0.0258760657,
-0.0667744428,
0.0459254906,
0.0373468623,
0.0252718423,
-0.0220767017,
0.0141406395,
-0.0140123637,
0.0036559762,
-0.0214648172,
-0.007333484,
0.0378876887,
-0.0143976919,
0.0640849099,
0.0204299837,
-0.0128606334,
0.0518921614,
0.0176651627,
-0.0458365418,
0.0010197763,
-0.0143023236,
-0.0456227064,
-0.0139111001,
-0.020193072,
-0.041845195,
-0.0468130894,
0.0745652243,
0.0227782298,
-0.0358115807,
-0.0269893464,
0.0266343001,
-0.0163797196,
0.0007741406,
-0.0345902294,
0.0611738898,
-0.0124928374,
0.0457646288,
-0.0013799734,
-0.0398678407,
0.0363501273,
0.0194271374,
-0.0144568011,
-0.0736236572,
0.0190262701,
-0.0337629467,
0.0736644119,
0.048344221,
-0.0376469232,
-0.0180872027,
-0.0182894617,
-0.0899567902,
0.0263466835,
-0.0224511344,
-0.03032046,
0.1186866313,
-0.0604191944,
0.0032400009,
0.0106804147,
-0.0129099721,
-0.0318189375,
-0.0035648269,
-0.0056786314,
0.0436859392,
0.0142989121,
-0.0465481505,
-0.0439876392,
-0.0421803482,
0.054530669,
0.0693401247,
-0.0173680633,
-0.0217094384,
-0.0133962668,
0.00229479,
0.0332957357,
-0.0029970284,
0.0116375377,
-0.0544063151,
0.0150042651,
0.0469128676,
0.0257862806,
0.0014998203,
-0.0221016891,
0.0104357423,
0.0283561144,
-0.0398560278,
-0.0000761381,
0.065046005,
0.004356978,
-0.0609519072,
-0.0265366584,
0.0988751799,
0.0424863361,
-0.0041493913,
0.0257223584,
-0.054006625,
0.0194564257,
0.0189278182,
0.0162078831,
-0.0985737443,
0.0042654881,
-0.0028116419,
-0.0051523969,
-0.0276619364,
-0.0511281602,
-0.0091870287,
-0.1432488859,
0.0177269541,
0.0082284333,
-0.1028212532,
-0.0229206383,
-0.0453031398,
-0.0079764407,
-0.0022308244,
0.0309727006,
0.0273396447,
-0.0297856778,
0.045011472,
0.0038892736,
-0.034190014,
-0.028126251,
0.0286359433,
0.0210869014,
0.0215008948,
0.0261835251,
0.0418275371,
-0.0591381826,
-0.0156763457,
0.0160782561,
-0.0013489493,
-0.0260291509,
0.0150806652,
0.071234338,
0.0379689746,
-0.0028066612,
-0.037093468,
0.017138388,
-0.0569229275,
-0.0070482814,
0.0005477853,
0.0873350352,
-0.0204508491,
-0.0030925109,
0.0135139562,
-0.0096779829,
-0.0157896299,
0.049667187,
0.0386421159,
-0.0203345995,
-0.0065081106,
-0.057537511,
-0.0040610493,
-0.0224312618,
-0.0629809722,
-0.0172543935,
0.020497568,
-0.06838274,
-0.058448337,
-0.0624841377,
0.0630834475,
0.0041708383,
0.0198570509,
-0.0049091843,
0.0432677902,
-0.0141496072,
-0.0418868139,
-0.0001904297,
-0.0204592086,
0.0197164137,
-0.0889281332,
-0.0131380064,
0.0047262185,
-0.03875909,
-0.0279048141,
-0.0021414848,
-0.1242963523,
-0.0443507731,
0.0081675891,
0.0596281067,
0.034262456,
-0.0277509596,
0.029009169,
-0.0230601802,
0.0290905032,
0.0393596478,
-0.050675232,
0.0252963137,
-0.006200172,
-0.0096300915,
0.0249108281,
0.0010446957,
0.0093209874,
-0.003090363,
-0.0064910958,
0.0384313017,
-0.0554584414,
0.0232224707,
0.0431508236,
0.0148502532,
0.0482070111,
0.0149329975,
0.0035251942,
-0.0330484584,
0.0137138357,
-0.047328569,
0.0048533781,
-0.0298434626,
-0.0175725855,
0.0241116397,
0.0739287511,
-0.0401182175,
-0.0458552614,
0.0002666496,
0.0178746004,
-0.0034735524,
0.0247959625,
0.0169473402,
0.0588198379,
0.0138703119,
-0.0283656586,
0.0094846655,
-0.0339313038,
-0.022141017,
0.065589942,
0.0107743135,
0.0326316059,
-0.013717046,
0.011629614,
-0.0145544391,
0.0084250886,
-0.0156909265,
-0.0533931591,
-0.002000707,
0.009532406,
-0.0099238828,
-0.0306211561,
0.023230454,
-0.0630519092,
0.0166848209,
-0.034808863,
0.0150684481,
0.0014404488,
-0.0107075563,
-0.028282281,
0.0068650292,
-0.0109906774,
-0.0381629579,
0.0733245984,
-0.0322364978,
0.0179031827,
0.0272787008,
-0.0137301553,
0.0146897053,
-0.0266814698,
0.0049042888,
-0.0096545657,
-0.0217326153,
0.0078331959,
-0.0652946085,
-0.1042438596,
-0.0284609478,
0.0227214992,
0.0197709836,
-0.025523955,
0.0226658657,
0.051396668,
-0.0510619283,
0.0136869242,
-0.0606104732,
0.0250834562,
-0.0180871207,
-0.036532633,
-0.03989207,
-6.410800888e-33,
-0.0173338875,
-0.0456748195,
0.0463581234,
0.0120105958,
0.0379165672,
-0.0379591212,
-0.0594037734,
0.0584566742,
-0.0254556015,
0.001721036,
-0.0282087419,
0.023202626,
0.013870866,
0.025270788,
0.0484763943,
-0.015767986,
0.0018757361,
-0.020633528,
-0.0233798232,
-0.0060406914,
0.0724126995,
0.0032944565,
0.1134405062,
-0.0335061438,
0.0612095222,
-0.0035001936,
0.0226942617,
-0.0025555305,
-0.0332798809,
0.0397451445,
0.0100744125,
0.068993561,
0.031494461,
-0.0603538901,
-0.0286696665,
0.0068897922,
-0.0522516444,
-0.0774724036,
0.0577227101,
0.040589042,
0.0089570535,
-0.0154050766,
0.0322930329,
-0.0247120913,
-0.0362094454,
-0.0316363946,
0.0286058206,
-0.0443718992,
-0.0075125289,
0.0034376241,
-0.0711753592,
-0.0091299731,
-0.0013719104,
-0.0069065094,
0.017536765,
0.0312053412,
-0.0249491055,
-0.0195973162,
-0.0556432344,
0.0502871536,
0.0460507274,
0.0583709702,
0.0270537362,
-0.0098085767,
0.0150029818,
0.0148666315,
0.0471115671,
-0.0271292999,
-0.0348922759,
0.0109317554,
0.073101297,
-0.0024578234,
0.037919566,
-0.0043722,
0.084064737,
-0.0037751866,
-0.0580773279,
0.0226299372,
0.046925202,
0.016395485,
0.001679051,
-0.0345630199,
-0.0404179804,
-0.0357046574,
-0.0053017982,
0.028028395,
-0.0412881225,
-0.0358067267,
0.0109174503,
-0.035787832,
0.0516817346,
0.0096193273,
0.0361635089,
-0.0323948935,
-0.0266361125,
0.0316738486,
-0.0105880508,
0.0557378978,
-0.0054382603,
0.0080264695,
-0.0480785556,
-0.0321289152,
-0.0079022851,
0.0038477618,
0.0349694565,
0.0406452753,
0.0328118354,
0.0382251367,
-0.0707184374,
-0.0230294149,
-0.0215064008,
-0.0268791467,
0.0508499332,
0.0225436594,
0.0249434859,
0.0107783768,
-0.0112217208,
-0.0144396471,
-0.0130798807,
-0.0252865143,
-0.0502723195,
0.0195805673,
-0.038089335,
-0.0091940043,
-0.0189900994,
-0.0471933633,
-0.0451144949,
0.0139438286,
0.0287206601,
-0.0355682969,
-0.0108333221,
0.0026578431,
2.917e-7,
0.0626765564,
0.0618493855,
-0.0085574826,
0.0069081937,
-0.0109308036,
-0.0055446974,
-0.0191320647,
0.011406987,
0.0365302712,
-0.0089472104,
0.0366635136,
0.0013925472,
0.0358718634,
0.0113111511,
-0.0670128018,
0.0156031018,
-0.0065748226,
0.0132901361,
-0.0370606109,
0.0363288634,
-0.0071934257,
0.0963756219,
0.0262377653,
0.0055060522,
-0.0097998558,
-0.0102119744,
0.0362174027,
-0.0183193311,
-0.0111755589,
-0.0012939246,
0.0389148258,
0.0109569198,
0.0131858448,
0.0266276523,
-0.0319190733,
0.0117636062,
0.0208493154,
0.0548426546,
0.0124035999,
0.0383441672,
0.004497271,
-0.0355321877,
-0.0335591249,
-0.0385554545,
0.0518177226,
-0.0555961616,
-0.0395639911,
0.041895818,
0.0093828263,
0.0403638408,
-0.0052920831,
0.0134807359,
0.0053265234,
0.0047200285,
0.0350142531,
-0.0176380463,
0.0338349417,
-0.0060678017,
-0.0165623818,
0.035544496,
-0.0245669857,
-0.0929747149,
-0.0255115032,
-0.0111046191,
0.0188595541,
-0.0242735967,
0.0056047635,
2.981238263e-34,
0.0447047725,
-0.0054778648,
0.0388188995,
0.0021740175,
0.0229758844,
-0.048761718,
0.041242186,
0.0548128486,
0.0477639548,
-0.0729308501,
-0.0414204113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13379v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13379v3 | Faithful Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2023-01-31T03:04:26 | 2023-09-20T22:19:30 | Qing Lyu, Shreya Havaldar, Adam Stein, Li Zhang, Delip Rao, Eric Wong, Marianna Apidianaki, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | While Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting boosts Language Models' (LM)
performance on a gamut of complex reasoning tasks, the generated reasoning
chain does not necessarily reflect how the model arrives at the answer (aka.
faithfulness). We propose Faithful CoT, a reasoning framework involving two
stages: Translation (Natural Language query $\rightarrow$ symbolic reasoning
chain) and Problem Solving (reasoning chain $\rightarrow$ answer), using an LM
and a deterministic solver respectively. This guarantees that the reasoning
chain provides a faithful explanation of the final answer. Aside from
interpretability, Faithful CoT also improves empirical performance: it
outperforms standard CoT on 9 of 10 benchmarks from 4 diverse domains, with a
relative accuracy gain of 6.3% on Math Word Problems (MWP), 3.4% on Planning,
5.5% on Multi-hop Question Answering (QA), and 21.4% on Relational Inference.
Furthermore, with GPT-4 and Codex, it sets the new state-of-the-art few-shot
performance on 7 datasets (with 95.0+ accuracy on 6 of them), showing a strong
synergy between faithfulness and accuracy. | [
0.0274839886,
0.0772108883,
0.0042355792,
0.0277115274,
-0.0741437972,
0.0278533734,
0.0155878207,
-0.026115384,
0.0028773313,
-0.0248853434,
0.008046018,
-0.0024245034,
-0.0026150336,
0.0150880329,
0.016163215,
-0.0509015135,
0.0368569382,
-0.0453603417,
0.0078520114,
-0.0211222321,
-0.016693769,
0.0337743983,
-0.0397344418,
0.021667419,
-0.0126313297,
-0.0270030722,
-0.0511246622,
-0.0080032814,
0.0343058892,
-0.0222332012,
-0.0052745687,
0.0512015335,
0.0508654788,
0.0516844019,
0.0000025194,
-0.0610628054,
-0.0149545474,
0.0039336649,
-0.0419404656,
-0.0425668061,
-0.0573011898,
-0.0067678778,
0.0397628509,
0.0400607139,
-0.0342209116,
0.0389998592,
0.0057051727,
0.0584362485,
0.0483738817,
0.0426285751,
-0.0027318599,
-0.0472229198,
-0.0020218187,
-0.0111085484,
0.0181990471,
-0.0697366521,
-0.0122125503,
0.0628585145,
0.0241917018,
0.0271369163,
-0.0199089814,
0.0374195315,
0.0523987412,
0.0009285606,
-0.0321831331,
0.0309661534,
-0.0324727111,
-0.0132640656,
0.0008350995,
0.057524953,
-0.0017473538,
-0.0417346358,
-0.0069799945,
0.0043765423,
-0.0201334823,
0.015241446,
-0.0336083658,
0.0394196995,
-0.0265295822,
0.0074096788,
0.0033789342,
-0.0033320028,
0.0272891466,
0.0133777335,
-0.0424235985,
0.093465291,
-0.0132033983,
-0.0323655307,
0.0189466644,
0.0291621741,
-0.0247220602,
-0.0736798793,
0.0026407193,
0.0520340502,
-0.0368770286,
0.0459758453,
-0.010815125,
0.0096404152,
-0.0077496031,
-0.012976571,
0.008387519,
0.0800275803,
-0.0019512121,
0.0487103276,
-0.0338028558,
0.0496917851,
-0.01273017,
0.0160081182,
-0.0346797556,
-0.038347818,
-0.0778522864,
-0.0211960487,
-0.0434534661,
0.0540256239,
-0.0125928633,
-0.0186995678,
-0.0000407545,
0.0293795727,
0.0091111995,
0.0184474196,
0.0236863922,
0.0154504683,
0.0056224111,
-0.0350701734,
-0.0664041638,
0.0461639725,
-0.0777119994,
0.0296589173,
0.0263854079,
-0.0369388051,
-0.0171286594,
-0.0216937829,
-0.0103316177,
-0.0264492556,
0.0404770374,
0.0673747808,
-0.0256052651,
0.0095047327,
-0.0340497792,
-0.0427046046,
0.0051908158,
-0.0968000665,
-0.0058524697,
-0.0747620463,
0.0552519001,
0.0386308916,
-0.0155701861,
-0.0124014998,
0.0073454157,
0.0431434512,
-0.0316448659,
0.0768108219,
0.0181731004,
0.0038739734,
0.0020662455,
0.0185315963,
-0.0437386669,
0.060277909,
0.03366445,
0.0220944062,
0.0118319271,
0.0257787909,
-0.0126312105,
0.0013263344,
0.0284792446,
-0.0100746499,
-0.0022321062,
0.0390265025,
-0.0140836434,
0.0286253486,
0.0061785835,
0.0350977816,
-0.0101326024,
0.0212611388,
0.0434616394,
0.0467238203,
0.0128478967,
0.0088124098,
0.0443496667,
0.0030211338,
0.0016086603,
0.0034189741,
-0.0959440395,
0.0603719912,
-0.0340470783,
-0.0029300379,
-0.001497257,
0.0113220513,
-0.0195707921,
-0.045509506,
-0.0153626474,
0.0380886458,
-0.0151952775,
0.0453588814,
0.0414847694,
-0.0067707254,
-0.0190305561,
0.0560839847,
0.0148582719,
-0.0073108762,
-0.0252760053,
-0.0425126627,
0.0243142899,
0.0468070954,
0.0410658605,
0.0114759831,
-0.0411039516,
-0.0175714716,
0.029794598,
0.0248261876,
0.0134967938,
0.0103019839,
0.0079640066,
-0.0283370335,
-0.036539536,
-0.0130504956,
-0.0022564193,
0.0263058767,
0.0191706307,
0.0399772115,
0.0020959529,
-0.0340442657,
0.0328225307,
0.0206798762,
-0.0161864888,
-0.010524136,
-0.007042875,
0.0270564314,
0.0052224039,
0.0135608045,
0.012687793,
0.0134979244,
-0.0167835746,
-0.0281071439,
-0.0496129654,
0.0230605826,
-0.0711178631,
-0.0329061933,
0.0210661441,
-0.0428050458,
-0.0452101752,
0.0143356491,
-0.0566120557,
-0.0471287295,
0.0396487005,
-0.0179878306,
-0.0073579261,
-0.0340002328,
-0.0003249893,
0.0121155018,
-0.0212843977,
-0.0110368757,
0.1115373075,
-0.0115738008,
-0.0007301238,
0.0227921661,
0.0214155223,
0.0375545435,
-0.0144591695,
0.014479354,
-0.0001822235,
0.0075406102,
-0.0205761716,
0.0099040866,
0.0367982425,
-0.0505338088,
0.0008587274,
-0.0501995645,
0.0084305992,
-0.0224877279,
0.0289151501,
0.0120912027,
0.0125091719,
0.0027060627,
-0.0201224927,
-0.0709139332,
0.0141863776,
0.0210673995,
-0.0119996779,
0.0363074914,
-0.0125179971,
-0.0045312927,
-0.0131648583,
0.0039173374,
-0.047928296,
0.0200986844,
-0.005780485,
-0.0238258541,
-0.0331837386,
0.0330122076,
-0.0793942958,
0.0331424065,
-0.0103648771,
0.0089690499,
0.0430847183,
0.0032910698,
0.0364508554,
0.0512378439,
-0.0070929015,
-0.0410436094,
0.0534746833,
-0.0086350339,
-0.0755496472,
0.0445332937,
-0.0141556822,
-0.0105325012,
0.0118785929,
-0.0292049684,
-0.0274811741,
0.0670482069,
0.0192696713,
0.0030389512,
-0.0699642822,
0.0114004537,
0.013583554,
0.0064841127,
-0.0585204661,
-0.0042620795,
0.021437332,
0.074684456,
-0.0037268328,
-0.0275412165,
0.0973782241,
-0.0151351998,
0.0111552468,
-0.0563300438,
0.0054287384,
-0.0361189768,
0.086869359,
-0.0053739245,
-0.0017022574,
-0.00587916,
-0.0015584193,
-0.0583672896,
-0.0168930236,
0.0410080142,
-0.0205002259,
0.0523055792,
-0.0811798647,
0.0120256776,
-0.0124963131,
-0.0447521955,
-0.0540561378,
0.0142545011,
-0.0675696433,
0.0075259572,
-0.0260868073,
-0.0061010611,
-0.0078543741,
-0.0067134839,
0.0496824197,
0.0250650663,
-0.0163057391,
-0.0307893269,
-0.0197510384,
0.0196436998,
0.0619006306,
0.0115165757,
0.0446872376,
0.0055006691,
0.0377525948,
0.0551130101,
0.0292878486,
-0.0089590391,
-0.0171387773,
0.0216453355,
-0.0195863415,
0.0184189565,
-0.0276085027,
0.0117930621,
0.0290939603,
-0.0630523488,
-0.0314345397,
0.1185753271,
0.0491926409,
-0.0392027497,
0.0002585761,
-0.0825244412,
0.0647085607,
0.0263413526,
0.0369765945,
-0.1080480069,
-0.0656972975,
0.03909529,
0.0109623037,
0.0080134505,
-0.0587374121,
-0.0213960279,
-0.0832271352,
0.0097718714,
-0.0229638461,
-0.024260167,
-0.0243547689,
-0.0478430055,
-0.0039445851,
0.020990083,
-0.0075715519,
0.0216430202,
0.0359225385,
0.024038069,
0.0078884121,
-0.0087894127,
0.0013814034,
0.06953758,
-0.0305356998,
-0.0104818558,
0.0510276519,
0.015931759,
0.0371563844,
-0.0595410839,
0.0350609273,
-0.0126829855,
0.0013103781,
-0.0311423484,
-0.0001694437,
-0.0075974273,
-0.004248932,
-0.0386216268,
0.0437085927,
-0.0438998677,
-0.002356115,
0.0471353307,
0.1027367786,
-0.0392107964,
-0.0221375264,
-0.0166191887,
0.0103220027,
-0.0341224633,
0.0883011147,
0.0171598941,
-0.0105394945,
-0.049563054,
-0.0358670801,
-0.0330605991,
-0.0294593442,
-0.0270468667,
0.0142736863,
0.0406413227,
0.0337906927,
-0.0403604954,
-0.0529942624,
0.0349631533,
0.0636184961,
-0.0144402506,
0.0057013212,
-0.0181522947,
0.0244846195,
-0.009310103,
0.0185367484,
-0.0526918359,
0.0165757798,
-0.0032938526,
0.0098449048,
-0.0089217555,
-0.0295903366,
-0.0219651405,
0.0278969724,
-0.0933968723,
-0.0307261944,
-0.0517505221,
0.0435107015,
0.0287997872,
0.059316352,
-0.0092658782,
-0.0019843492,
-0.024865156,
-0.0027105312,
-0.0290765073,
0.0107658086,
0.0047256285,
0.0350833088,
0.0271405671,
0.0506815128,
-0.0499022827,
0.0140328109,
-0.0222638883,
0.074503012,
0.000699601,
-0.0131339794,
0.0429018848,
0.0059498651,
0.0056918082,
0.0048669423,
-0.0036757493,
-0.0035991124,
0.0512365252,
-0.0329731591,
-0.0351978913,
-0.0403729863,
0.0336065404,
0.0031605412,
-0.0196461212,
-0.0065103178,
-0.0596446246,
0.0083167283,
0.0069914684,
-0.0093707088,
-0.0134341298,
0.037331745,
0.0401627123,
0.0224866979,
-0.0221817754,
-0.0193366352,
-0.0118433526,
0.0085110692,
0.0704563111,
-0.0360284857,
0.0931159481,
0.0552674606,
-0.025475353,
-0.0347772241,
-0.0078846263,
-0.0828517303,
-0.0845943242,
0.0350862071,
-0.0280900821,
0.0335861519,
-0.0009355799,
0.0135674365,
-0.0558121651,
0.0058362731,
0.04057879,
0.0274109542,
0.0454477444,
-0.0324784219,
0.0273582805,
0.0164684709,
0.0160607342,
-0.0113933133,
0.0445965268,
-0.0334674418,
0.0243650023,
0.0093875863,
-0.0128026912,
-0.0326017663,
-0.0222865418,
-0.0387422889,
0.0115423379,
0.0110963192,
-0.0013717833,
-0.0670116618,
-0.0782608688,
-0.0393022262,
-0.0058734985,
-0.0004235019,
-0.0024664968,
0.0457333401,
0.0772369653,
0.0187747888,
-0.0460455604,
-0.0024522603,
0.0231848154,
0.0194749814,
-0.0241397899,
-0.0262324549,
-6.993978329e-33,
-0.0094769979,
-0.0281098783,
0.0516436435,
-0.026680883,
0.0016785258,
-0.0189255606,
-0.0724837184,
-0.0040177964,
-0.0495222844,
0.020068258,
-0.0324222147,
0.0084913699,
0.0028799761,
0.0182857756,
0.0220160838,
-0.0295474716,
-0.0080376286,
-0.0009295815,
-0.0363082737,
-0.0013203658,
0.0528122373,
-0.000851544,
0.0352884568,
-0.0371905155,
0.0122542307,
-0.0035808038,
0.0021524287,
0.0458329171,
-0.0355386101,
0.0141740292,
-0.0024257265,
-0.0006300107,
0.0335285887,
-0.0296263658,
0.0127097201,
-0.0011385691,
-0.1027495787,
-0.040814884,
0.0434568971,
0.0028445423,
-0.0831038505,
-0.0055542663,
0.0025987478,
-0.0034039104,
0.0015481574,
-0.0588238649,
0.0072308527,
-0.0112479404,
0.0102816047,
-0.000001596,
-0.0473083742,
0.0032412584,
-0.0266489424,
-0.0340789855,
0.0041119773,
0.0855124369,
-0.0193176158,
0.012621277,
-0.0329545252,
-0.0123437904,
-0.0176254995,
0.0006130653,
0.0836238787,
-0.0340626948,
-0.0010698261,
0.0466920324,
0.01733068,
-0.0481888503,
-0.0818543136,
0.0118768318,
0.0022360771,
0.0353526808,
0.0800325498,
0.0034245311,
0.031236697,
0.0468639955,
-0.1031551883,
0.0231585838,
0.0057124789,
0.0526445545,
0.0251076315,
-0.004623469,
-0.0482002646,
-0.0141501632,
-0.0538671501,
0.0027491464,
-0.0554795936,
-0.0313238241,
0.0406163894,
-0.0038202975,
-0.0260090809,
-0.0438543223,
0.0488892309,
-0.0261357334,
-0.0061525903,
0.0545970984,
-0.0157449003,
-0.0004953748,
0.0051864893,
0.0556726344,
-0.0220811646,
0.0159957726,
0.0005367938,
0.0418828428,
0.0247616302,
0.0050721397,
0.0242284015,
0.003513732,
-0.0323322378,
-0.0081502385,
-0.0936152637,
0.0271757022,
-0.0126892682,
-0.0090280324,
0.0368774347,
0.015020472,
-0.0110506956,
0.0476498194,
-0.0083009768,
-0.0333048999,
-0.0141624883,
0.0578302182,
-0.0244822539,
0.0164686814,
-0.0331834853,
0.0056089801,
-0.0205663852,
-0.0062735109,
0.0102893328,
-0.0709637478,
-0.0140298251,
0.0604905151,
3.114e-7,
0.0268092584,
0.0409686752,
0.0202006865,
0.0345993266,
0.0151787102,
0.0292565525,
-0.0065156897,
-0.0033584901,
0.0121963006,
-0.049135197,
-0.0057144314,
0.0592979863,
0.0299126729,
0.0495594479,
-0.0613627546,
-0.0034829287,
-0.0559765473,
-0.0272660218,
-0.0426272303,
0.0018610035,
0.0694875047,
0.074011147,
-0.0003701624,
-0.0204152595,
0.0108153597,
-0.0093012685,
0.0216227025,
0.0040608188,
0.0310207028,
-0.0307195317,
-0.0029990943,
-0.0138975605,
0.0221232567,
0.0299254488,
-0.0029238458,
0.0185018815,
-0.0107015427,
0.0382627659,
0.0101338327,
-0.0366098061,
-0.0479616113,
-0.0601746552,
0.024437055,
-0.0988085866,
0.1078043133,
-0.0332052149,
-0.0333390795,
0.0260119084,
-0.0049147564,
-0.0280683767,
-0.0092951832,
0.0325367674,
-0.0123926876,
0.0270171762,
0.0215184465,
0.0079199383,
0.0078807399,
-0.0737867579,
-0.0341257602,
-0.0048542987,
-0.0209333301,
-0.0047083758,
-0.0396422558,
0.0070619103,
0.037197873,
-0.0171961598,
-0.032257881,
2.95848533e-34,
0.0080866925,
-0.0165666081,
0.0321216211,
0.0183670148,
0.0524196438,
-0.0054174298,
-0.0093099913,
-0.0000407082,
0.0423881337,
-0.088870503,
-0.0399317965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13372v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13372v1 | Improving Open-Domain Dialogue Evaluation with a Causal Inference Model | 2023-01-31T02:31:42 | 2023-01-31T02:31:42 | Cat P. Le, Luke Dai, Michael Johnston, Yang Liu, Marilyn Walker, Reza Ghanadan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Effective evaluation methods remain a significant challenge for research on
open-domain conversational dialogue systems. Explicit satisfaction ratings can
be elicited from users, but users often do not provide ratings when asked, and
those they give can be highly subjective. Post-hoc ratings by experts are an
alternative, but these can be both expensive and complex to collect. Here, we
explore the creation of automated methods for predicting both expert and user
ratings of open-domain dialogues. We compare four different approaches. First,
we train a baseline model using an end-to-end transformer to predict ratings
directly from the raw dialogue text. The other three methods are variants of a
two-stage approach in which we first extract interpretable features at the turn
level that capture, among other aspects, user dialogue behaviors indicating
contradiction, repetition, disinterest, compliments, or criticism. We project
these features to the dialogue level and train a dialogue-level MLP regression
model, a dialogue-level LSTM, and a novel causal inference model called
counterfactual-LSTM (CF-LSTM) to predict ratings. The proposed CF-LSTM is a
sequential model over turn-level features which predicts ratings using multiple
regressors depending on hypotheses derived from the turn-level features. As a
causal inference model, CF-LSTM aims to learn the underlying causes of a
specific event, such as a low rating. We also bin the user ratings and perform
classification experiments with all four models. In evaluation experiments on
conversational data from the Alexa Prize SocialBot, we show that the CF-LSTM
achieves the best performance for predicting dialogue ratings and
classification. | [
0.0701812208,
0.0522080399,
-0.0112505984,
0.0280931424,
-0.0280873012,
0.0219146181,
0.0191926919,
-0.0020155774,
0.0355660729,
-0.074902162,
-0.0498815477,
-0.0273215082,
-0.0164969638,
0.084696278,
-0.0245240852,
-0.0389502123,
0.0080495412,
0.0095290747,
0.0569430739,
0.0075274473,
0.0195036773,
0.025952559,
-0.0245656595,
0.0530942604,
-0.0229993146,
0.0039217053,
-0.0163036454,
0.0074947211,
0.0061085853,
0.0144099742,
0.0296418518,
0.0562014915,
0.001162508,
0.024808161,
0.0000018587,
-0.0144431656,
-0.0202905405,
-0.0262469426,
-0.0311907511,
-0.0492045842,
0.0360366441,
0.032330364,
0.0258013736,
0.0548438802,
-0.0649190396,
0.0130177708,
0.036986921,
0.0820920467,
0.0930054933,
0.0656053796,
-0.0175736733,
-0.054718852,
-0.0081631597,
-0.002134867,
0.0035812526,
-0.0437899381,
-0.015177886,
0.0230812691,
-0.0266403072,
0.0141392266,
0.0038537201,
0.0113811735,
0.0310336817,
-0.0364306867,
0.0435167402,
-0.0025465994,
-0.0076238667,
-0.0231549963,
0.0056717223,
0.1048352793,
0.0412631221,
0.0074829352,
-0.007873727,
0.0011377389,
0.0047608041,
-0.0051063159,
-0.0257018227,
-0.0014866813,
0.0237496775,
0.0139065273,
-0.0274905581,
0.056237068,
0.0046056542,
0.027770007,
0.0002399574,
0.0390282385,
-0.0065962933,
-0.0378299616,
-0.0155135999,
0.0348087586,
-0.0010336124,
-0.0472407565,
0.0196310095,
0.0012027394,
-0.0497792363,
0.0146692144,
0.0008231229,
0.0082062352,
-0.0085364068,
-0.0356298499,
0.0273420513,
0.0182256475,
-0.0160325542,
0.0496044606,
-0.0006694471,
0.0537695028,
-0.0109909642,
0.0133477356,
-0.0187974982,
-0.0077558625,
-0.0750715733,
-0.0063815024,
0.011017574,
0.0218726154,
-0.0341638289,
0.014196638,
-0.0311892238,
0.0103885895,
-0.041836217,
-0.0094504924,
0.0163768344,
0.0510654151,
0.0034505033,
0.0148024578,
-0.0652377233,
0.068561025,
-0.0460144132,
0.0416835919,
-0.01969756,
-0.03553221,
-0.0029634282,
0.041131258,
0.0325100459,
0.0042897528,
0.0061374512,
0.0677202195,
0.0067593534,
-0.0175597016,
0.0109024355,
-0.0399757512,
-0.0272734724,
-0.0608339608,
-0.0121019464,
-0.0148669444,
0.0323465019,
0.0204325188,
-0.0342094712,
-0.0047389464,
0.0146221202,
0.0155118555,
-0.0200724099,
0.052828487,
-0.0050914888,
-0.0171200167,
0.0053306995,
0.0171487182,
-0.0042057373,
0.0303290728,
0.0461144708,
0.0481204018,
0.023379324,
-0.0084071979,
0.065396145,
0.0003826696,
0.0236131642,
-0.006391054,
0.0014850327,
0.0268008504,
-0.0305033308,
0.0277863946,
-0.007006078,
0.0495096892,
-0.0211048983,
-0.0281172022,
0.059958972,
0.0055148704,
-0.0031240522,
0.0493354499,
0.0427376367,
0.0339025818,
-0.0071767741,
0.0045208312,
-0.0384667516,
0.0387140587,
-0.0062698782,
-0.033395689,
0.0270587392,
-0.0337299407,
-0.0217986964,
-0.0858997852,
0.010709825,
-0.0187158715,
0.0464940295,
-0.0073569268,
0.0292508174,
0.0203911867,
-0.0666809678,
0.0322541408,
0.0021338684,
-0.0624770336,
-0.017912196,
-0.0678922534,
0.0183689035,
0.07902807,
0.0276413355,
-0.0127850203,
-0.0315170921,
-0.0606333204,
-0.0233878121,
0.0213527679,
0.0197487399,
-0.0157566071,
0.019788811,
-0.0461467281,
-0.0240539424,
-0.0150525263,
-0.0201118793,
0.0340623297,
-0.028963862,
-0.0050325883,
0.0028503796,
0.0004397263,
-0.012523897,
-0.0153875751,
0.0044987048,
-0.0126840547,
0.0370110646,
0.0194227677,
0.057433106,
0.0519507676,
0.0211658925,
-0.0102464994,
0.0346175171,
0.0013191097,
-0.0833049715,
0.0333989076,
-0.0380804129,
-0.0688556582,
-0.0041788025,
-0.0114462208,
-0.0140099833,
0.0683503449,
-0.0471217893,
-0.0449279323,
0.0705804527,
-0.0278851744,
0.0383803844,
-0.0317786112,
-0.0006431925,
0.0266842395,
-0.0085965749,
-0.0234784782,
0.0171711426,
-0.0004824531,
0.0103946021,
0.0192711893,
-0.03441732,
0.0194782801,
-0.016893154,
-0.0203981027,
-0.0140829077,
0.0143094137,
0.0172315352,
0.0274064466,
0.0099102128,
-0.0445850678,
-0.0364871137,
-0.1232465655,
-0.0253050271,
-0.0248128399,
0.0001118531,
0.0221460722,
-0.0101759033,
0.0397028178,
-0.0223975778,
-0.0585183203,
-0.0349919498,
0.0543412492,
-0.0099567706,
0.0500752591,
0.0303748399,
-0.012277077,
-0.0510688126,
0.0065183742,
-0.0272520985,
0.0551627018,
0.0042350423,
0.0252893027,
-0.0180184394,
-0.0231788512,
-0.0450078286,
0.0292388182,
-0.0133065414,
-0.0499879792,
0.0092918361,
0.0073449747,
-0.0026441191,
0.0297150221,
0.0446556918,
0.0344346873,
-0.0033355865,
-0.0169649627,
-0.0648904592,
0.0220732559,
-0.0422265157,
0.0067209229,
-0.0211743973,
-0.0137750832,
-0.0016478848,
0.0320026055,
0.0371228345,
0.0322768912,
-0.0723518655,
0.0048425253,
0.0103809256,
-0.0355604514,
0.0090261037,
-0.0054006544,
0.0005154982,
0.0343134888,
0.0136236716,
-0.0464637764,
0.0816133246,
-0.0125020193,
-0.024288021,
-0.0371212289,
-0.0077809519,
-0.0487032793,
0.0575438067,
-0.0158687476,
0.0045458023,
0.0095199244,
-0.009597308,
-0.0068007647,
-0.0007504965,
0.0187548064,
-0.0415588766,
-0.0095006358,
-0.0217305701,
-0.0087653333,
0.0239046235,
-0.0522048958,
-0.0473780595,
-0.0853664503,
-0.0189404022,
-0.0279642269,
0.0149682881,
-0.0197076071,
-0.0245478805,
0.013416349,
-0.0354181044,
-0.0209181942,
-0.0388220027,
0.0070682652,
0.0078267781,
0.029396899,
0.0429844372,
0.0390040316,
-0.0050452696,
-0.0169605128,
0.0239054076,
0.0218501948,
-0.0094797602,
-0.0197054353,
-0.0378671996,
-0.0249954313,
0.0021626852,
0.0181804802,
-0.010611291,
-0.0286862347,
0.043905016,
-0.037891522,
0.0115851611,
0.1509162635,
0.0234156605,
-0.0251276866,
-0.0256261826,
0.0091359019,
-0.0025593296,
0.0047920854,
0.0070932475,
-0.0953021124,
-0.0409054756,
-0.0377451777,
0.0363277532,
-0.0096812667,
-0.0340032503,
0.0087950882,
-0.1001923457,
0.0060733575,
-0.0413417853,
-0.0121365702,
-0.0407503694,
0.0016712832,
-0.0188386757,
-0.0480016507,
0.0046114763,
-0.0145095708,
0.0121430112,
0.0187214054,
-0.0144723188,
-0.0354890116,
0.0052483734,
0.0685378239,
-0.0113713993,
0.0833198354,
0.0777248219,
0.0737550333,
0.0188660305,
-0.0051819086,
-0.0138418367,
0.0084011611,
0.0177088995,
-0.0097095724,
0.0879121795,
-0.0254168361,
-0.0006229851,
-0.0275889747,
-0.0009492125,
-0.028656723,
0.0050998339,
-0.0215409826,
0.0194182992,
-0.0495148338,
-0.0165487491,
-0.0091030989,
0.0760847628,
0.0410841405,
0.0854160562,
0.0013974848,
-0.0572247952,
-0.0426749624,
-0.0180420876,
-0.0283595547,
-0.0094824377,
-0.0295879263,
-0.0357490405,
0.0297549255,
-0.0048894724,
-0.0797197372,
-0.0507578962,
0.0024847358,
-0.0027579032,
-0.0362310484,
-0.026632579,
-0.0120553449,
0.0226714406,
-0.0005414946,
0.0228513386,
0.0160201993,
0.0219392292,
-0.0373339392,
-0.0183626227,
0.0805311874,
-0.052570045,
-0.0165506173,
0.0073721288,
-0.0600958243,
-0.0220335461,
-0.0149720404,
0.0839715973,
0.0200706925,
0.040899016,
-0.0120732337,
-0.033468239,
-0.0061250106,
0.0013810772,
-0.04451368,
-0.0256878883,
0.0780020505,
0.0856297314,
-0.0040482734,
0.0354757607,
-0.0255948994,
0.0237084553,
-0.0004439865,
-0.0123386476,
-0.0645391941,
-0.0795427039,
-0.0066983169,
-0.0378450118,
0.069237791,
0.0331187695,
-0.0187699348,
-0.0217801109,
0.002059873,
-0.0295637138,
-0.0171921439,
-0.0743646249,
0.0252533928,
-0.0045457645,
-0.0051701921,
-0.0366570391,
-0.0281280074,
-0.0510064363,
0.0186476149,
-0.0634952858,
0.0218167063,
0.0354021601,
-0.0263934936,
-0.0242044143,
-0.0123130148,
-0.0278757159,
0.0016010865,
0.0433624797,
-0.0026825031,
0.0203277823,
0.0784196779,
0.000649453,
0.018804254,
0.002691909,
0.0477032103,
-0.0780730247,
-0.0185911059,
-0.0201170184,
-0.0026570216,
0.0018616867,
0.0126474323,
0.0458931513,
-0.0191035792,
0.0305182822,
0.0141098294,
0.0811203197,
-0.0058844532,
-0.014718987,
0.0452081896,
0.01599795,
-0.028324388,
0.0097608985,
0.0305718351,
-0.007751686,
-0.002221609,
-0.0089343535,
-0.0358144455,
-0.0425651968,
-0.0078926217,
-0.0089449957,
0.0037700038,
0.0179690178,
0.0200545602,
-0.0506857671,
-0.0416079871,
0.0300278533,
-0.0243219212,
0.0297892187,
-0.0159533825,
0.0568254404,
0.0446420461,
0.0002690582,
0.0245249029,
-0.0570056848,
-0.0310396217,
0.0214565005,
-0.0270337071,
-0.053523723,
-6.008356438e-33,
0.0011579468,
-0.0442743413,
-0.0087639689,
0.0400827155,
-0.0196942482,
-0.0214946978,
-0.0335654989,
0.0307183117,
-0.0162714347,
0.0288168509,
-0.0007110282,
0.0337843448,
0.006754701,
0.0235553049,
0.0152338063,
-0.0481121428,
0.061481446,
-0.0148638124,
0.0051677013,
0.05566011,
0.06064393,
0.0207222868,
0.0622524247,
-0.1451045126,
0.042400416,
-0.0161635354,
-0.0348305292,
0.016813755,
0.0142138144,
0.044344794,
0.0039976514,
0.0499126762,
0.034035448,
-0.0826712251,
0.0206586104,
0.0010429418,
-0.0199098811,
0.0088495472,
-0.0110706706,
0.0023027852,
-0.0464587808,
0.0091958372,
0.0142364381,
-0.0005135111,
-0.02362982,
-0.0119098751,
0.0389961898,
-0.0020171402,
0.060593579,
-0.0478670225,
-0.0491548777,
0.0087658288,
-0.0355258062,
-0.0767386556,
-0.0264688674,
0.0507214814,
0.0091482103,
0.0027814594,
-0.0173636712,
0.0323488601,
-0.0176928136,
-0.009609621,
0.0241685361,
-0.0068409666,
-0.0267165434,
0.0610709116,
0.007461431,
0.0210974403,
-0.0292931776,
-0.0232992433,
-0.0189435109,
0.0562140718,
0.0599907786,
0.069795154,
0.0181459319,
-0.0213686265,
-0.0296408106,
0.016044477,
0.0227218345,
0.0261852369,
0.0179664157,
-0.0116055114,
-0.026595071,
-0.0031746791,
-0.0194753241,
-0.0195992254,
-0.0333287716,
-0.0363195576,
0.0046128496,
0.0177025627,
-0.0184873864,
-0.0254487321,
0.0316367447,
-0.0551217943,
0.0120555554,
0.0516733825,
-0.0492109507,
-0.0040253378,
-0.0002857279,
-0.0170589741,
-0.0370398797,
0.0056010191,
0.0331274606,
0.0100366184,
0.0210328437,
0.0041458379,
-0.0034794344,
0.035108164,
-0.0336430594,
0.0091662472,
0.0040219165,
0.0339942649,
-0.0503992066,
0.0609444231,
-0.0006097701,
0.0185906477,
-0.0409815945,
0.1007563844,
-0.0459810235,
0.0609752387,
-0.067475304,
-0.0309602823,
0.0557261258,
-0.0284977015,
-0.0605318546,
-0.0309087057,
0.0073984014,
-0.0343629979,
-0.0347444713,
-0.0424692929,
-0.013303211,
-0.0075152027,
2.611e-7,
0.0235986896,
0.0492025465,
0.0083568897,
0.0003849965,
0.0295962188,
0.0714624375,
0.0423806421,
0.0074206465,
0.0400582738,
-0.0045736656,
0.0495314896,
-0.0001139813,
0.0519678593,
0.0306748655,
-0.1018975154,
-0.0290220324,
-0.072925359,
-0.0442333445,
-0.0009962681,
-0.0133985793,
0.1050084606,
0.094566457,
0.028173266,
0.0048300768,
-0.0034195527,
-0.0000349957,
0.0528806485,
-0.0157165229,
-0.0214845557,
-0.0352796502,
0.0319440477,
-0.0319482386,
-0.0017061048,
0.0141364811,
-0.0177159104,
0.0320425965,
0.0078937532,
0.0507331304,
-0.0090571716,
-0.1002451032,
-0.0004833967,
0.0207156893,
0.0107833166,
-0.014670046,
0.0273133349,
-0.0399137586,
-0.0345484503,
-0.0030764684,
-0.0131095499,
-0.0105273155,
0.0506815724,
-0.0142481849,
-0.0359670185,
0.0306891073,
-0.0002944949,
-0.0220466275,
0.0092764581,
-0.0857516676,
0.0101924827,
-0.0161382295,
-0.0603202432,
-0.0546201356,
0.0052995156,
-0.0119804526,
0.0277649742,
-0.0096808067,
0.0012811556,
2.216766991e-34,
0.0570762977,
0.0085825957,
0.0217995867,
0.0242800917,
0.0441779979,
0.0304872319,
-0.01909752,
-0.0037115377,
0.0689083189,
-0.063102074,
-0.0183457471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10307v1 | ViewCo: Discovering Text-Supervised Segmentation Masks via Multi-View Semantic Consistency | 2023-01-31T01:57:52 | 2023-01-31T01:57:52 | Pengzhen Ren, Changlin Li, Hang Xu, Yi Zhu, Guangrun Wang, Jianzhuang Liu, Xiaojun Chang, Xiaodan Liang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, great success has been made in learning visual representations from
text supervision, facilitating the emergence of text-supervised semantic
segmentation. However, existing works focus on pixel grouping and cross-modal
semantic alignment, while ignoring the correspondence among multiple augmented
views of the same image. To overcome such limitation, we propose
multi-\textbf{View} \textbf{Co}nsistent learning (ViewCo) for text-supervised
semantic segmentation. Specifically, we first propose text-to-views consistency
modeling to learn correspondence for multiple views of the same input image.
Additionally, we propose cross-view segmentation consistency modeling to
address the ambiguity issue of text supervision by contrasting the segment
features of Siamese visual encoders. The text-to-views consistency benefits the
dense assignment of the visual features by encouraging different crops to align
with the same text, while the cross-view segmentation consistency modeling
provides additional self-supervision, overcoming the limitation of ambiguous
text supervision for segmentation masks. Trained with large-scale image-text
data, our model can directly segment objects of arbitrary categories in a
zero-shot manner. Extensive experiments show that ViewCo outperforms
state-of-the-art methods on average by up to 2.9\%, 1.6\%, and 2.4\% mIoU on
PASCAL VOC2012, PASCAL Context, and COCO, respectively. | [
0.0117244404,
0.0322776176,
0.066840671,
0.0724969804,
-0.0315948464,
0.0089898426,
0.032913696,
0.0022781242,
-0.0235858411,
-0.0291665103,
0.017767936,
0.0002800572,
-0.0008615656,
0.0025080894,
-0.0355388336,
-0.051839672,
-0.0141248796,
-0.0164247286,
-0.0410231538,
0.0066561289,
0.0361985192,
0.0021255349,
-0.0127640963,
-0.0251361653,
-0.0689974278,
-0.0351314656,
-0.0106386449,
0.0131862722,
0.0320022628,
-0.0531612113,
0.0319371708,
0.0060643596,
0.0050336495,
0.0267240498,
0.0000021345,
-0.029966766,
-0.0378230363,
0.0362209342,
0.0035850564,
-0.0137494439,
0.0350994319,
-0.090919964,
0.0198034886,
-0.0735595748,
0.0148220081,
0.0753653124,
0.0546663105,
0.0836166739,
0.0519187972,
0.0463480502,
-0.0404539183,
-0.0531880595,
0.0002690713,
-0.0327676684,
0.0299142431,
-0.0215503722,
0.0145682003,
0.012125303,
-0.0936659724,
0.0397318937,
-0.0287291091,
0.0380999148,
0.0540752448,
0.0058576642,
-0.0154163009,
0.0357847065,
0.0107388273,
-0.0491045192,
-0.0098874047,
0.0365046225,
-0.0506592318,
-0.0038946522,
-0.0110515319,
-0.0254230108,
-0.0342247859,
-0.0037543816,
-0.0201449674,
0.0123235853,
-0.0182790477,
0.0185617562,
-0.0273328796,
0.0682460815,
-0.0047015976,
-0.017418433,
-0.0057999147,
-0.0222856421,
0.0022834663,
0.0067906822,
0.0030245166,
0.0388776399,
-0.0281772353,
-0.0135392193,
0.0523099117,
0.0169759169,
0.0150263784,
-0.0030153797,
-0.062810123,
-0.0137390364,
-0.0059409789,
-0.0375002101,
-0.0386677086,
-0.0095442832,
-0.0563449673,
0.0752865374,
-0.0468773581,
0.0264925677,
-0.0212678686,
0.098034516,
-0.0327704698,
-0.0625023022,
-0.0182654168,
-0.0173616167,
-0.010801387,
0.0037402075,
-0.0193900336,
-0.0234635435,
-0.0100849699,
-0.0213846304,
-0.0194797069,
0.0558221303,
0.0247045588,
0.000139864,
-0.063061595,
-0.0186264608,
0.0185849741,
-0.0100593967,
-0.0274737217,
0.0008924109,
-0.0248834342,
-0.0029795859,
-0.0098830275,
0.0468557626,
0.0207800157,
-0.0313807391,
0.0186339617,
0.0153924571,
-0.0871370435,
-0.0355565697,
-0.0193910822,
-0.0493294001,
-0.0761201233,
-0.0293997563,
0.0261217486,
-0.0290612504,
0.0040896093,
-0.0166322999,
0.0229811314,
-0.0289679505,
-0.0225033518,
-0.00221887,
-0.0094019603,
0.075211294,
0.0163047798,
-0.0252870861,
0.0212682635,
0.0500303097,
0.0491531305,
0.059668038,
0.0241531581,
0.0448002405,
0.0101348646,
0.0503763035,
0.0131347971,
0.0383320227,
-0.0244148821,
-0.0116433762,
-0.0819779485,
-0.0093812505,
0.0262871571,
0.0106944581,
0.0051758182,
0.0241806507,
-0.0271890424,
-0.0757991225,
0.0364403985,
0.0174558274,
0.0074429824,
0.0089316508,
0.0201862454,
0.019336164,
-0.0103955995,
-0.0065313219,
0.0051149698,
0.0200747978,
0.006054691,
0.0129183801,
-0.0005641686,
-0.024402177,
-0.039247483,
-0.0517483018,
0.0143298972,
0.0071548177,
-0.0265119914,
-0.0119968383,
0.0799813941,
0.0157970451,
-0.0036237761,
-0.0272835791,
-0.0135796666,
-0.0716124102,
-0.0198323615,
0.0039543798,
0.0456891134,
0.0481739156,
0.0311647169,
-0.0456776693,
-0.0424610265,
0.0442741103,
0.0499808937,
0.0934225544,
-0.0065150266,
-0.0206207857,
0.0295744799,
-0.0605992377,
-0.038147077,
-0.02090987,
-0.0191929508,
-0.0246284734,
-0.002778722,
0.0599760041,
0.0346160419,
-0.0278966241,
0.0403745249,
0.0692109317,
0.0138587812,
0.0018996932,
-0.0424111448,
0.0144237252,
-0.047038991,
0.0056702518,
-0.0098055452,
-0.0397322923,
0.0177316461,
-0.0348887071,
0.0425416008,
-0.0060123294,
-0.0791858956,
-0.0625912324,
-0.0038898038,
-0.0429116562,
-0.040192686,
0.0344444513,
-0.031164933,
-0.0225891117,
-0.0146861244,
0.0264963452,
-0.0000264188,
-0.0382321663,
-0.0035400491,
-0.0142354369,
0.0058820774,
0.0009974487,
0.0352849811,
-0.0140434774,
-0.0140233422,
0.0252962448,
-0.0119861104,
0.0235374048,
0.0144913699,
0.0174494162,
-0.0161846615,
-0.0047527719,
0.0098290788,
0.0004465059,
0.0178091023,
-0.0289733857,
-0.0442753173,
-0.0471783914,
-0.0132649988,
-0.040916454,
-0.0196486376,
0.0183647741,
-0.04529256,
0.0150734466,
-0.074389644,
-0.0313354768,
0.0285887346,
-0.046652209,
-0.0181429703,
0.0390961058,
-0.0338222831,
0.0094146524,
-0.025070142,
-0.0018519548,
0.0099706147,
0.0489916615,
0.0533887483,
-0.0838700905,
-0.050245285,
0.0039211037,
0.0071582883,
0.0022593583,
-0.0242378656,
0.0545672923,
-0.005886856,
-0.0142158167,
-0.021557143,
0.0864705667,
0.0068693529,
0.0483201817,
-0.0197428372,
-0.0053232419,
-0.0197224859,
-0.0047194306,
0.0027295286,
0.0055728289,
-0.0006661179,
-0.0122260153,
-0.0044244737,
0.0707387924,
-0.0365680717,
0.0064711496,
-0.0240955353,
-0.0554643311,
-0.0123063782,
-0.0462070107,
-0.0568724908,
0.0006106435,
0.0233851448,
-0.0230368879,
-0.0301451087,
-0.0297235567,
0.032563407,
-0.0664321929,
-0.0337138213,
-0.029224325,
-0.0029541072,
-0.0132362824,
0.0609822124,
0.0489888005,
0.0342937075,
0.0101681845,
-0.0009016757,
-0.0507166013,
-0.0129748089,
-0.0086744819,
0.0225166418,
0.0194471739,
-0.023415288,
0.0227496438,
-0.0208243262,
-0.0151682151,
-0.0005435168,
-0.032209076,
-0.0207238961,
0.0560784787,
0.0072972798,
-0.000396087,
-0.0432302393,
0.0197339226,
0.0203714054,
0.1092330366,
0.0270623546,
-0.0527585782,
-0.0267188977,
0.0470840894,
0.0383224115,
0.0099324863,
-0.0463634543,
-0.0604686886,
0.010131578,
0.0725274608,
0.0124358404,
-0.0167283788,
-0.021213308,
0.02893335,
0.0032941757,
0.0094857011,
0.0503051132,
0.0064800549,
0.0810271427,
-0.0422786064,
-0.0492635891,
0.0477412641,
0.0417196974,
-0.0357712172,
-0.0597504899,
0.0011487628,
0.0322708488,
0.026210364,
-0.0226699281,
-0.043748036,
-0.0773363188,
-0.0235908683,
-0.011481354,
0.0489766374,
0.0348261371,
-0.0343615897,
-0.0259206183,
0.0251314156,
-0.0200960953,
-0.0523868315,
0.0297344923,
-0.0020080369,
0.0390726589,
-0.0486182086,
-0.0427037887,
-0.0256503094,
0.0064155106,
-0.0422885902,
0.0305099152,
0.0013123415,
0.0578827113,
-0.0053267283,
-0.0392113924,
-0.0441723578,
0.032892812,
-0.0011036844,
-0.000421478,
-0.0450727381,
0.0694623068,
-0.0163384546,
0.0044196877,
0.0106118703,
0.0885914266,
-0.0560867898,
0.009720156,
-0.0006034485,
0.0366370119,
-0.0121818343,
-0.0515514538,
0.0074439836,
0.0008644554,
0.0350783654,
-0.0252352189,
-0.0440316163,
0.0019852945,
-0.0241894573,
0.0270722751,
-0.0146562783,
-0.0454434603,
-0.0583713949,
-0.0222968906,
0.0289825182,
-0.0314696059,
0.015274669,
0.0087643461,
-0.0355152451,
-0.0452057496,
-0.0263256468,
-0.0218572337,
0.053234186,
0.0489579327,
0.0092874514,
-0.0426587649,
0.020815419,
-0.0396382958,
-0.0448214188,
0.0104597406,
-0.0546851605,
0.0124461036,
-0.0499467999,
0.0166029204,
0.0480412245,
-0.0509749837,
-0.022396192,
0.0126003418,
-0.0758612305,
-0.0101714572,
-0.0123607079,
0.0291127563,
0.0043307678,
0.0730303302,
-0.0025125493,
-0.0272150189,
0.0942324474,
0.0503958091,
0.0068021063,
0.0367213525,
-0.0006095781,
0.0000955342,
-0.0185398031,
-0.0085352696,
-0.0381409228,
0.0228807908,
0.0248865187,
-0.0025136815,
-0.0279361065,
0.0055525219,
0.0114280116,
-0.0405973308,
0.0596847944,
0.0108918212,
0.0545662716,
-0.0563067906,
0.045216158,
0.0147695346,
-0.0246551447,
-0.0284972284,
0.0380779766,
-0.0269301739,
0.013773731,
-0.0019032665,
0.074160628,
0.0531151369,
0.0371653326,
-0.0565598905,
-0.038647756,
-0.0013820119,
0.0373102985,
-0.0242321752,
0.016960524,
0.0116829444,
0.0040306738,
-0.0064046606,
0.0629193708,
-0.0054273261,
0.076073207,
0.0483008064,
0.0045500244,
-0.0512467511,
0.0583648868,
-0.035988275,
0.0294614863,
-0.0765064433,
0.0183321033,
-0.0147418175,
-0.0320082977,
0.0533379167,
-0.0077599809,
-0.0173612889,
-0.0040793959,
0.007965276,
0.0169155374,
-0.030763099,
0.017215414,
-0.0078043384,
-0.0041322494,
-0.0156960208,
0.0261366479,
0.0005054135,
0.0168784801,
0.0001143903,
-0.0038258596,
-0.0323284306,
-0.001871499,
0.0554664433,
0.0185918566,
-0.00912615,
-0.0048993495,
0.0124736624,
0.0135111539,
0.0411332548,
-0.0096654017,
-0.0067607011,
0.0774189159,
0.0163723547,
0.0419067629,
0.0095791705,
-0.0384752527,
0.0227406211,
-0.0409843214,
0.0354866609,
-0.0098627955,
0.0385474823,
-6.26861603e-33,
-0.0207657088,
-0.0231506359,
0.0014414948,
-0.0004889223,
-0.007273274,
0.0165013708,
-0.01996902,
0.0124228168,
0.0006393478,
0.0471176393,
0.018953722,
0.0162369348,
0.0453547798,
0.0697039291,
0.0114787454,
-0.027810635,
0.0549480058,
0.0257113948,
-0.0016439953,
0.0078740558,
0.0335997008,
-0.0122372033,
0.0748263076,
-0.071946986,
0.0224336833,
0.0175732616,
-0.0127219399,
-0.0053057023,
0.0448973253,
0.0211048853,
-0.0036359238,
-0.017547369,
0.034769699,
-0.0344111472,
-0.021170292,
0.0110222138,
-0.0560949743,
-0.0238327831,
-0.0531547144,
0.0348786935,
-0.1014031917,
-0.003957076,
0.0353018381,
0.0001474438,
0.0346582346,
-0.0274499245,
0.0590599552,
-0.0118097737,
0.0022566442,
-0.0139914043,
-0.0491816401,
0.0199300181,
-0.0493344218,
-0.0443310365,
0.0837281793,
0.0096227452,
0.0659245253,
0.0497918427,
-0.0666182935,
-0.0048682918,
-0.0282057691,
0.0036628353,
0.077430293,
0.0792898238,
-0.0332792215,
0.0671334714,
0.0228233449,
-0.0593490228,
-0.0085446965,
-0.0132704992,
-0.007492411,
0.0627835616,
0.063771151,
0.033056207,
0.0329643115,
0.0107614202,
-0.058505144,
0.0760690272,
-0.0710352659,
-0.0293357112,
0.0076575219,
0.0224333853,
-0.0231815223,
0.0007154159,
-0.0065243277,
-0.0227990095,
-0.0562757067,
0.0535367951,
0.0507290363,
0.04237229,
-0.0115510011,
0.0839946046,
0.0416910499,
0.0213160627,
-0.0002217908,
0.0010647977,
-0.0427092426,
0.0640800595,
-0.0212049242,
0.0035919826,
-0.0483143963,
-0.0498158149,
0.0356801301,
0.020217577,
0.017322639,
0.0024240592,
0.1062803045,
-0.0201801676,
-0.0472472906,
-0.0051970743,
-0.0116945449,
-0.018942181,
-0.013616683,
0.0348681845,
-0.0005521848,
-0.0031325519,
-0.0329684913,
0.0681266412,
0.0338681415,
-0.0293750651,
-0.0131968381,
0.0015426602,
-0.0145778833,
-0.0085394038,
0.0111418301,
0.0166517273,
0.0091821039,
-0.0433441512,
0.0666661859,
-0.0429232568,
0.0065402305,
0.0338948891,
2.531e-7,
0.0164168999,
0.0030023891,
0.0406129248,
-0.0565760583,
-0.0144600272,
0.0670202076,
-0.0077284728,
0.029333774,
-0.0741301626,
-0.0673004687,
0.001800342,
0.0478025638,
0.073831223,
0.0336920619,
0.0080439979,
0.0144266924,
-0.0197344683,
-0.020090932,
-0.0550787225,
0.0027130542,
0.0513071381,
0.0416229665,
-0.0179417059,
-0.0103195291,
0.0238342304,
-0.0277737379,
0.0370773301,
-0.0100988997,
0.050121896,
0.0177655425,
-0.0226298869,
0.0016189581,
-0.0210367367,
0.0100866603,
0.0168000404,
-0.013419454,
0.0896707773,
0.0452917069,
-0.0154223852,
0.015287512,
-0.0015397384,
0.0303838216,
-0.0000197169,
-0.0277036615,
0.061685048,
-0.0384439565,
0.0083627114,
0.0085051646,
0.0099035185,
0.0300226957,
0.0181957632,
0.0053717308,
-0.0047004814,
0.0456391275,
0.0245546475,
0.0146670816,
-0.0440591164,
-0.0357439965,
-0.0397697203,
-0.0604576916,
-0.019362973,
-0.0044066119,
-0.0320117958,
0.0250659697,
0.0005937741,
-0.0415433757,
-0.0394439586,
1.785189521e-34,
-0.0147058247,
0.0016117879,
-0.0268726274,
-0.0045779818,
0.0227890946,
0.0034573514,
-0.062371064,
-0.031982787,
-0.0656158924,
-0.017834641,
-0.019570535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13352v1 | Sentence Identification with BOS and EOS Label Combinations | 2023-01-31T01:03:07 | 2023-01-31T01:03:07 | Takuma Udagawa, Hiroshi Kanayama, Issei Yoshida | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The sentence is a fundamental unit in many NLP applications. Sentence
segmentation is widely used as the first preprocessing task, where an input
text is split into consecutive sentences considering the end of the sentence
(EOS) as their boundaries. This task formulation relies on a strong assumption
that the input text consists only of sentences, or what we call the sentential
units (SUs). However, real-world texts often contain non-sentential units
(NSUs) such as metadata, sentence fragments, nonlinguistic markers, etc. which
are unreasonable or undesirable to be treated as a part of an SU. To tackle
this issue, we formulate a novel task of sentence identification, where the
goal is to identify SUs while excluding NSUs in a given text. To conduct
sentence identification, we propose a simple yet effective method which
combines the beginning of the sentence (BOS) and EOS labels to determine the
most probable SUs and NSUs based on dynamic programming. To evaluate this task,
we design an automatic, language-independent procedure to convert the Universal
Dependencies corpora into sentence identification benchmarks. Finally, our
experiments on the sentence identification task demonstrate that our proposed
method generally outperforms sentence segmentation baselines which only utilize
EOS labels. | [
0.025892796,
0.0020003358,
0.0130705899,
0.0044460222,
-0.0544428006,
0.027640922,
-0.0020777355,
-0.0267135929,
-0.0284963921,
-0.0821061879,
0.0253268983,
-0.0142648006,
-0.0321703218,
0.0070428778,
-0.0081865964,
-0.0657477379,
0.049860999,
0.015419405,
0.0025490026,
0.0498480126,
0.062156029,
-0.023247065,
-0.0083805239,
-0.0025916819,
-0.0575881563,
-0.0317115709,
0.0059713065,
0.0185058713,
0.0292429738,
-0.0399426706,
0.0668747053,
0.0451839752,
-0.0327102467,
-0.0080161653,
0.0000016919,
-0.063612029,
-0.1031524688,
-0.0398697071,
-0.0314212181,
-0.0101079075,
0.0494672321,
-0.0158837885,
0.000549587,
0.0146646043,
0.008516754,
0.0211086813,
0.039759364,
0.0262675192,
0.0129601546,
0.0734369606,
-0.035704881,
-0.0271244757,
-0.0276790839,
0.0582074672,
-0.0055731945,
-0.0133452965,
0.019556243,
-0.0197580811,
0.0014764364,
-0.0115902396,
0.0242226087,
0.0137583334,
-0.0226488039,
0.0220322665,
0.0069706924,
-0.0071186321,
-0.0277267024,
0.0032771844,
-0.0422386341,
0.0404011942,
0.01466446,
-0.016010059,
0.0425600447,
0.0071394183,
-0.0205171071,
-0.044137165,
-0.0191612914,
0.0205929875,
-0.0291892663,
0.0106962416,
0.0382393189,
0.0682300851,
-0.0083588185,
0.0088399351,
-0.0047989744,
0.0951154828,
0.0173406079,
-0.0543659367,
0.0109424395,
0.0151898572,
-0.0353239663,
-0.0367013067,
0.0475454777,
-0.0136379302,
-0.0045437468,
0.0074854461,
-0.031841252,
-0.057806775,
-0.0254546907,
-0.0465484001,
-0.0027188719,
-0.0172027852,
-0.0107471319,
0.0331671126,
0.0071604354,
0.0137044685,
0.0253595859,
-0.0261826869,
-0.0393870249,
0.0038359736,
-0.0474901795,
-0.0128481993,
-0.0519731492,
0.0591037571,
-0.018349573,
-0.0466422401,
-0.0359207317,
-0.0070490506,
0.0129543403,
-0.0023598326,
-0.0258661192,
-0.0241120886,
0.0121299736,
0.0321338437,
0.0313928835,
-0.0095799109,
-0.0698396936,
-0.0018046778,
-0.00341328,
-0.0354783945,
-0.0153616164,
0.0616861619,
0.0492849685,
-0.0197731405,
0.0033665085,
0.0012724572,
-0.0083226599,
-0.0502218865,
-0.0470585413,
-0.0474845693,
-0.029743176,
-0.0321877375,
0.0101578031,
-0.0273438767,
-0.0262215082,
0.0153195504,
-0.0035656479,
0.0257690493,
0.0078256661,
0.0047089816,
0.0059535569,
0.0505320206,
0.0180759039,
-0.0045810691,
-0.0628042072,
-0.0310744084,
0.0821389258,
0.0586441383,
0.0089986064,
0.0493273251,
0.0861908346,
0.0336528271,
-0.0037251583,
0.0430591926,
-0.0563502274,
0.0175992418,
-0.0481038727,
-0.0220544804,
0.0495534018,
-0.0098580066,
-0.0470409133,
0.021734817,
0.0042317705,
0.0396775715,
0.0101253958,
0.012928349,
-0.0156306606,
0.0049397685,
0.0450881086,
0.0059833843,
0.0137710664,
0.0534532294,
0.0022325374,
-0.0474469699,
-0.0236775894,
0.0261362605,
-0.0012251047,
-0.0010283971,
-0.0182213467,
-0.0240022726,
-0.0707306787,
-0.0309805777,
-0.0229105819,
-0.0357268006,
0.0273551084,
0.0337723382,
-0.0380736478,
0.0668769553,
-0.027251631,
-0.0654496029,
-0.0192594249,
0.0563147627,
-0.0229525194,
0.0310563762,
0.0652178973,
-0.0923721269,
-0.018431792,
0.0071123466,
0.0507776588,
0.0785695761,
-0.0011617993,
-0.0278264098,
0.0310468953,
-0.0451719388,
-0.0006239274,
-0.0077646598,
0.0256201457,
-0.0047941902,
0.0200101454,
-0.0124381753,
0.0053049047,
-0.0451495424,
-0.0045078578,
0.0748573467,
0.0317773633,
-0.0388554782,
0.0294450279,
0.0125939893,
0.0088349823,
0.0404216573,
-0.0053715385,
-0.0032097662,
-0.010907473,
-0.0525595024,
0.0008372857,
0.0293450337,
-0.049192667,
-0.0759374648,
0.0197621491,
-0.026188245,
-0.0646103323,
0.0393209308,
-0.0455473363,
-0.0391506962,
-0.0052403668,
-0.0059167361,
-0.0323555544,
-0.0372267179,
0.0307364725,
0.0205092728,
0.0235317256,
-0.0352021605,
0.0551881865,
0.0212576538,
0.014704816,
-0.0380686708,
-0.0552960299,
0.0496566892,
-0.020106433,
-0.0107750781,
-0.0650832132,
-0.0375624038,
-0.0275305528,
0.0247233175,
0.007528841,
-0.0579389781,
-0.0100910803,
-0.0641574189,
0.0441587269,
-0.038300354,
0.0412834361,
0.0591766723,
0.0240192581,
-0.0249865446,
-0.0398591422,
-0.0006662257,
-0.0252479613,
0.0043377681,
-0.0200953763,
0.0600010492,
-0.0012775819,
-0.0245335884,
-0.0269627925,
0.0115518318,
-0.0600137711,
0.037426766,
0.00337038,
-0.0491989404,
-0.0245312992,
0.0416700207,
0.0100092236,
0.0177017972,
0.0646158904,
-0.0280904435,
-0.0127505371,
0.0034914147,
0.0454273894,
0.045282837,
0.0099601727,
0.0218083076,
0.0206685979,
-0.023397686,
0.0373249575,
0.0009580565,
-0.0469420776,
0.1059065387,
0.0260576941,
-0.0321828201,
0.0924931318,
0.074672915,
0.0044718506,
0.0140118739,
0.0256511439,
-0.0249747802,
-0.0197780523,
-0.0065229153,
-0.024183074,
0.0147682987,
-0.0418971628,
0.0048537795,
-0.0100245792,
0.0106345499,
0.0335126519,
-0.0433616042,
-0.0246372502,
-0.095922105,
0.0157051496,
-0.0315314941,
0.0086131105,
0.0383597314,
0.0109904809,
0.0329837687,
-0.02721164,
0.0057932511,
0.0253090914,
0.0262340326,
0.0148912938,
-0.029545486,
-0.0412969328,
0.0063454537,
-0.0130474921,
-0.0260193553,
-0.0267964453,
-0.0010341166,
-0.0167088937,
0.0323178619,
0.0025179372,
0.0356558561,
-0.0343693681,
0.0225271061,
0.0243984833,
0.0839234218,
-0.0331971496,
0.0285141729,
-0.0451020412,
0.1146207899,
0.0356115289,
-0.0352038257,
-0.0136789344,
-0.0337274931,
0.0340630449,
-0.0005306578,
0.0575267076,
0.007946155,
0.0102523742,
-0.0189779401,
-0.0034633947,
-0.0928318128,
0.0186395571,
0.0230351258,
0.0358415544,
-0.0309500955,
-0.039940767,
0.1337652802,
0.0601126887,
-0.0069231601,
-0.0334937088,
0.0306734554,
-0.0015992846,
0.0245771762,
-0.0045095012,
-0.0608464703,
-0.0579352267,
0.0290704332,
0.0021944924,
-0.0519081578,
-0.0265781786,
-0.0291964002,
-0.0698456392,
0.0100817969,
-0.0147556793,
-0.0262127351,
0.0424935296,
0.0053511639,
0.0258693136,
0.0297803693,
-0.0270421598,
-0.0378035121,
-0.0476672947,
0.0110240858,
0.0190218315,
-0.0866874233,
-0.0085730543,
-0.0164896715,
-0.0208332147,
-0.0371435396,
0.0495510101,
0.0037920617,
-0.0249592569,
0.0284924693,
0.0964450687,
-0.0466527306,
-0.0270035136,
0.0052386229,
0.0663075224,
-0.0520107336,
0.018191006,
-0.0166349579,
0.0217783619,
-0.0325975306,
-0.0334269889,
0.034330301,
0.0382889919,
-0.001397604,
0.0021709807,
-0.0140546467,
-0.0036983564,
0.0136511894,
0.0735679269,
0.0297978409,
-0.0574179851,
-0.0661355853,
-0.0141214943,
0.0438387357,
-0.0675032511,
0.0086872103,
0.0244695749,
-0.0298723411,
-0.029383542,
-0.0839525163,
-0.0522527173,
0.0230110623,
0.0250818226,
0.0223732106,
0.0193134956,
-0.0003587567,
-0.0112519115,
-0.0389688686,
-0.0280011687,
-0.0324883983,
-0.0026343437,
-0.0745022073,
0.0119909626,
0.0062232837,
0.0089670932,
-0.022230532,
-0.0015956374,
-0.0699238479,
-0.0471010581,
0.0507896282,
-0.004780618,
0.0110034477,
-0.0104886089,
-0.0154361278,
0.0113527616,
-0.004347505,
0.0519747362,
0.0134085352,
0.0091852862,
0.033455234,
0.0072914697,
-0.0213547777,
0.017366346,
-0.0046773646,
0.047924798,
0.0404654518,
0.0446512625,
0.0048279627,
-0.0094742542,
0.041860804,
0.057407584,
0.0797876641,
-0.0226933844,
-0.0032092659,
-0.0220993143,
-0.0099299075,
-0.0059210882,
-0.0177408718,
-0.0036827677,
0.0615842789,
-0.0013299157,
0.0601922013,
-0.0104324296,
0.0829639211,
-0.011602615,
0.0140300971,
0.0117102247,
0.0173111185,
0.0220732,
0.0210900865,
-0.0355338864,
-0.0296309888,
0.0145359589,
0.0430320762,
0.0211641751,
0.0290808547,
-0.0091675501,
0.04230728,
0.0347215794,
-0.0148467105,
-0.0584196188,
0.0351878516,
-0.0200958159,
0.0785524994,
-0.0410665274,
0.0241504982,
0.0129985614,
-0.0606559962,
0.0265891701,
-0.0211453792,
-0.003677567,
-0.0335676372,
0.0547846779,
0.0254109837,
-0.0250282977,
-0.0391657054,
0.0101165306,
-0.0424281508,
0.0233604293,
0.0650418922,
-0.0043256981,
0.0085611567,
0.0151945166,
-0.0481855497,
-0.0516913012,
0.0086615495,
-0.014192692,
-0.009768921,
-0.0204777531,
0.0277889129,
-0.0482181199,
-0.0049038799,
0.0671914443,
-0.0167986844,
0.0531441607,
0.0106259091,
0.0317793153,
0.0148956412,
-0.0056294543,
-0.0016653268,
-0.019561341,
0.0134429056,
0.0121920593,
-0.0316038765,
0.0026071616,
-5.516090628e-33,
0.0119191604,
-0.0156205809,
-0.0628799796,
0.0325305276,
0.0036767747,
-0.0052707302,
-0.0355384536,
-0.0002522892,
0.0744594261,
0.0108932322,
-0.0046824701,
-0.0128638642,
0.0458268113,
0.0263452902,
0.001655612,
-0.0050293258,
0.04783329,
-0.0211322196,
-0.0612882897,
-0.035151504,
0.0612304173,
0.0430461876,
0.0488848798,
-0.0138837155,
0.0244420432,
-0.0395513698,
-0.0104397489,
0.020583557,
0.0732215196,
0.0345206372,
-0.0066148629,
-0.0060745184,
0.0386809781,
-0.0324659348,
-0.0032161046,
0.0600797646,
-0.068530567,
-0.05076731,
-0.0255255532,
0.0322707519,
-0.0475619696,
-0.0660547912,
-0.0143132536,
-0.0259996131,
-0.0200744569,
0.0127844261,
0.0489341654,
-0.016923584,
0.0270296093,
-0.034633927,
-0.100999102,
0.0342243128,
-0.0113635743,
0.0252178349,
0.0646136627,
0.0411289781,
-0.0125846555,
0.008979666,
0.0235562231,
0.0094422325,
0.002495737,
0.0398825295,
-0.0123403575,
0.0237345323,
-0.0093791503,
0.029889429,
0.0285839736,
-0.0350478441,
0.0071288534,
0.0053436672,
0.0113397911,
-0.0327395163,
0.0500850603,
0.0504698791,
0.0598386601,
0.0111425081,
-0.0562272258,
0.0230759773,
0.047778856,
-0.0352879241,
0.0107458634,
-0.0127307959,
-0.051254645,
0.01285371,
-0.0031943957,
-0.0196720343,
-0.0155281369,
0.0024489779,
0.0695722625,
0.0020469038,
-0.0311789904,
-0.0312129129,
0.037869893,
-0.0357232206,
0.0362210087,
-0.0408035778,
0.003386023,
0.0496238098,
-0.0101137785,
-0.0108393207,
-0.0597023331,
-0.054822661,
0.0211650878,
0.0049761413,
0.0224819724,
-0.0149995089,
0.065708071,
-0.0097383019,
-0.0113114947,
0.0386979878,
0.0157554299,
0.0136950128,
-0.0466720089,
0.0409122631,
0.0201520622,
-0.0053153955,
-0.0056392499,
0.0313707814,
0.034873303,
0.0188642554,
-0.0233633127,
-0.0165026207,
-0.0171455853,
0.057431303,
-0.0325870328,
-0.021307135,
-0.0037299329,
0.0094809607,
-0.019713698,
-0.0138860913,
0.0319579393,
0.0151363276,
2.468e-7,
0.0130841779,
0.0469587483,
0.0891428068,
-0.0232837126,
0.0170164872,
0.019058561,
-0.0238200296,
0.0227956697,
-0.0500927977,
-0.0187575277,
0.0300584454,
-0.0448063016,
0.0567340925,
-0.0103822146,
-0.1380391121,
0.0167485867,
0.0059249462,
-0.0298747532,
-0.0462378375,
0.0282286238,
0.0180606972,
0.0473225117,
0.0126435803,
0.0317267142,
-0.0547251701,
-0.0554703772,
0.0118082156,
0.0095373103,
0.0151330978,
0.027720511,
0.0074865418,
-0.0417920277,
-0.0236040261,
0.0037153247,
-0.0094408467,
0.0387315303,
0.0218550507,
0.0457735099,
0.0079843448,
0.003156421,
0.0205251724,
0.0229220726,
0.0121199237,
-0.0009878626,
0.0532306954,
-0.0175584275,
-0.0005272993,
-0.006970102,
0.0003281586,
0.0112954741,
-0.0367421657,
0.0287124924,
-0.0437034816,
0.034628015,
0.0115861315,
-0.0170733705,
-0.0234683398,
-0.0528464615,
-0.0374960266,
0.0096246945,
-0.0111420536,
0.0241690222,
-0.0139538608,
0.0299248006,
0.0050733322,
-0.1021721661,
-0.0396514758,
2.579310112e-34,
0.0251449365,
-0.0097053088,
-0.0328421295,
0.03382973,
0.0114833452,
-0.0392493196,
-0.0759059414,
0.0087686954,
-0.0273983255,
-0.0551222861,
0.0145047484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13345v1 | Differentiable Entailment for Parameter Efficient Few Shot Learning | 2023-01-31T00:31:11 | 2023-01-31T00:31:11 | Ethan Kim, Jerry Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot learning allows pre-trained language models to adapt to downstream
tasks while using a limited number of training examples. However, practical
applications are limited when all model parameters must be optimized. In this
work we apply a new technique for parameter efficient few shot learning while
adopting a strict definition of parameter efficiency. Our training method
combines 1) intermediate training by reformulating natural language tasks as
entailment tasks \cite{wang_entailment_2021} and 2) differentiable optimization
of template and label tokens \cite{zhang_differentiable_2021}. We quantify the
tradeoff between parameter efficiency and performance in the few-shot regime
and propose a simple model agnostic approach that can be extended to any task
By achieving competitive performance while only optimizing 3\% of a model's
parameters and allowing for batched inference, we allow for more efficient
practical deployment of models. | [
0.0335268565,
0.0503764637,
0.0017947498,
0.0419829115,
-0.0185073782,
0.052190572,
0.0171361137,
-0.0045595649,
-0.0339373685,
-0.0542782992,
-0.0121900924,
0.0310318787,
-0.0335634798,
-0.0254316516,
0.0199809447,
-0.0345120952,
0.0781870037,
0.0074567995,
0.0245460104,
0.0069592819,
-0.0041284473,
0.0068555647,
-0.0179173704,
0.0040894002,
0.0081039565,
-0.0061699823,
0.0147230821,
0.0138249751,
0.0228957757,
0.0099631473,
0.0108338362,
0.0262999516,
0.0419854447,
0.0105965082,
0.0000020078,
-0.0443378873,
-0.0232885666,
0.0030746721,
-0.0795364156,
-0.0034224731,
0.0227873996,
-0.0342241973,
0.043647334,
0.0026472709,
0.0067164078,
-0.055330772,
0.0557639487,
0.0272159968,
0.0528030917,
0.093102023,
-0.0037465964,
-0.0556010231,
-0.037389949,
-0.033137735,
0.0418342426,
-0.0391470231,
0.0116350949,
-0.0263205245,
-0.0133274961,
-0.0194509067,
-0.0154877584,
0.046449393,
0.0275225155,
0.057036534,
-0.0117060924,
0.0536449626,
-0.0355227664,
-0.0369840451,
0.0248905234,
0.077446945,
-0.0683849454,
-0.0632587597,
0.0054830303,
-0.0602759868,
-0.014528757,
0.0011582708,
-0.0216746721,
-0.0107633425,
-0.0095801195,
0.0279391184,
0.0383216739,
0.0075118938,
0.0317131691,
0.0121215722,
-0.0350320488,
0.0252382122,
0.0176594947,
-0.0005729586,
0.0072032213,
0.0060773129,
-0.0447406434,
-0.045452971,
-0.0394498184,
0.0186052769,
-0.0072126272,
0.0210634917,
-0.0452763662,
-0.0594051592,
0.0037027763,
-0.0219604447,
0.0527875908,
0.0431664027,
0.0319121331,
0.0737954304,
-0.0616271272,
0.021752974,
-0.0052908291,
0.025971571,
-0.0383956693,
-0.0401296541,
-0.0416384824,
-0.0050331838,
-0.0768029466,
0.0408407636,
0.0179965515,
-0.017230738,
-0.0266219191,
0.0186196677,
0.0055419523,
0.0280143451,
0.0096739698,
-0.0282761529,
-0.0271469597,
-0.0469189361,
0.0140844993,
0.0019109796,
-0.0847671479,
0.0392523296,
-0.0139879147,
-0.0179968867,
-0.0210828632,
0.0264191683,
0.048685845,
-0.0453776009,
0.0341584943,
0.0554790385,
0.0154098123,
-0.0244080499,
-0.0410528108,
-0.0108999815,
-0.0040598731,
-0.0771614611,
-0.0022235259,
-0.065999724,
0.0456430838,
-0.0055171987,
0.0012934022,
-0.013678682,
-0.0111207105,
0.0132618733,
-0.0474520177,
0.0700530186,
-0.0051593482,
-0.0053793206,
-0.0046393988,
-0.0055641932,
-0.0231466703,
0.1040975824,
0.0115632843,
0.02282634,
0.0343681201,
-0.0013005686,
0.017875161,
0.0025429174,
0.0409929231,
0.0242276136,
-0.0036573522,
0.0262107272,
0.0466250516,
0.0147021674,
0.0047903415,
0.0037662166,
-0.069360882,
-0.0303450264,
0.0327651761,
0.0030066038,
0.0432534814,
-0.0666679144,
0.0533088185,
0.0099397507,
-0.0140095465,
-0.0175453294,
-0.0741241202,
0.0212766025,
-0.0216764342,
-0.0142187951,
0.0179832801,
-0.0165312011,
-0.0595378391,
-0.0228309967,
-0.0022561159,
-0.018240843,
-0.0390029401,
0.0089025265,
0.0305637512,
0.0410573892,
-0.0058156755,
0.0424829759,
0.0462471321,
-0.0242709145,
-0.0197166987,
-0.0062743099,
0.0399817303,
0.011722791,
0.0042193094,
-0.0102706803,
-0.060843531,
0.0082450304,
0.0416463315,
0.0350885913,
0.0147440583,
-0.0043336092,
0.0832882896,
-0.0247982107,
0.0001004893,
-0.0526870787,
0.0528925471,
0.0107563697,
-0.0020610408,
0.0210560784,
0.0273396857,
-0.0539814495,
-0.000497532,
0.0536069386,
0.0052763121,
-0.0638602301,
0.0431729034,
0.0467191264,
0.0284437053,
-0.039811261,
-0.0172504969,
0.0093843872,
-0.0116383163,
-0.0366963632,
0.0039536473,
0.0054487512,
-0.0203818846,
-0.1170237437,
-0.0171060506,
-0.0157004502,
0.0038167881,
-0.0135963764,
-0.0713267103,
-0.0274503846,
0.0004660943,
0.0020543577,
0.0389616005,
-0.0123792654,
-0.0106218457,
-0.0058953715,
0.0000771484,
-0.0232776068,
0.0458827838,
0.0314137265,
0.035478346,
-0.0432862714,
0.0069362158,
0.0286241155,
0.00143439,
-0.0301181637,
-0.0180075951,
-0.0033883271,
-0.0163675565,
0.0234668944,
0.0126397731,
-0.0382641442,
-0.00998847,
-0.0904565379,
0.0396619588,
-0.0183998253,
0.0081712045,
0.0085273972,
-0.0049398979,
-0.001052832,
-0.0228924807,
-0.0090776626,
0.0166213419,
-0.0214553382,
0.0424957462,
0.0375339948,
0.0154946642,
-0.0198765788,
-0.0313562118,
-0.0035650083,
-0.0015927299,
0.0440291092,
-0.0174331069,
-0.0255972873,
-0.0264964979,
-0.004120768,
-0.0302924477,
0.0185224786,
0.0116489222,
-0.0226560459,
-0.0153054968,
-0.0196231976,
0.0127594462,
0.0643787459,
-0.0244331285,
0.000658558,
0.0141993705,
0.0179963242,
-0.0481164418,
0.0284640323,
-0.0431442745,
-0.0218119975,
0.0094245626,
0.0163362175,
0.0110181067,
0.0634465665,
-0.0117627075,
-0.0100630363,
-0.0750619322,
0.048727788,
-0.0015931947,
-0.0315277763,
-0.0405884311,
0.0297918655,
0.0091205481,
0.008605333,
-0.0130042676,
-0.013997674,
0.0522365533,
-0.0044433912,
-0.0237383805,
-0.0145608382,
-0.0269518774,
-0.0165446792,
0.0505862571,
0.0414655879,
0.0067023584,
0.0578400791,
0.0076504657,
-0.0471231937,
0.0106841782,
0.0555881336,
0.0319584347,
0.0046878043,
-0.0041745896,
0.0250289366,
-0.041009102,
-0.0399454758,
-0.0262659024,
-0.0749421269,
-0.014928259,
0.0075607677,
-0.0526104942,
0.0314000584,
-0.023803778,
0.0001871813,
0.0056412825,
0.0543091744,
-0.0211021174,
-0.0094264373,
-0.0331013054,
0.0165411402,
0.0516572967,
-0.0448460542,
-0.0324847922,
-0.0235814322,
0.0435540266,
0.0323935188,
0.0344611295,
0.0331453495,
-0.0340348035,
0.0149689447,
0.0106196031,
-0.0198337696,
-0.0458820835,
0.0114099933,
0.0422983803,
-0.0528607592,
-0.0029018386,
0.1104113311,
-0.0087599317,
-0.0268937908,
0.0075949207,
0.0214802008,
0.0314801186,
0.0145876873,
0.0269978177,
-0.0993545428,
-0.0653267279,
-0.0098165423,
-0.0102654221,
-0.0164041072,
-0.0187440012,
-0.0245901719,
-0.1041800007,
0.0414556153,
-0.001975849,
-0.0136396866,
0.0149945002,
-0.055234015,
0.0002648503,
-0.026808776,
-0.0036288567,
0.0050995676,
0.0103663662,
0.0016519075,
0.0192193016,
0.0151913604,
-0.0215449538,
0.0396154597,
-0.0612797476,
0.0027114043,
-0.0112947747,
0.0252501313,
0.0023479306,
-0.0201609991,
-0.0071565588,
-0.0355651081,
-0.023139976,
-0.0008208374,
0.0430881828,
-0.0517851003,
-0.0340236798,
0.0317361578,
0.0221546274,
-0.0278170165,
0.0011220393,
0.0180324651,
0.0808118209,
-0.0149907591,
-0.037295606,
-0.0098216208,
-0.0236166902,
-0.0036774299,
0.0793901235,
0.0241479371,
-0.0404557101,
-0.0313365832,
0.0140563361,
-0.0375161283,
-0.0489954427,
0.0052397787,
-0.0264995024,
-0.0489315912,
-0.0418987162,
-0.0766557008,
-0.0217027403,
0.0531633906,
0.0848173648,
-0.0439786837,
0.0163241476,
-0.0161275826,
0.0115655549,
-0.0082780616,
-0.0136458511,
-0.0528857335,
-0.0016758192,
-0.0280621387,
0.0144996755,
0.0604641475,
0.0381060131,
-0.0291259736,
-0.0075777443,
-0.0969033316,
-0.0536948927,
-0.0204639118,
0.0484650694,
0.0098322416,
0.0717259869,
-0.0451361835,
-0.0152987214,
0.047891546,
0.0436248109,
-0.0043369769,
0.0178818759,
0.0621181168,
-0.021445496,
0.0104156006,
0.0505265705,
-0.055797074,
0.0159807652,
0.0571395494,
0.0040492546,
-0.0266090389,
0.0306552052,
0.0320730284,
0.0077141663,
0.0668973699,
-0.0103169531,
-0.0460432507,
-0.0041456451,
0.0333066061,
-0.0278899707,
-0.0463924482,
-0.0389713086,
0.0154811479,
0.009934824,
0.0332311019,
-0.0210718513,
0.000717275,
0.0377031602,
0.0560503714,
-0.0187615324,
-0.0381732471,
0.0124675566,
0.0082119033,
-0.0113621615,
-0.0082426192,
-0.062734969,
0.0348576941,
-0.0169126205,
0.0077659497,
-0.0724031255,
0.026694607,
0.045939073,
0.0353312977,
-0.0509123504,
0.0008427419,
-0.0437367223,
-0.0242000166,
-0.0311913546,
0.0405306853,
0.0575444624,
-0.0122860987,
-0.0007005346,
-0.0200452954,
-0.0211416762,
-0.0048094913,
0.0441353284,
-0.0246604346,
-0.0261982661,
0.0141158262,
0.0400068127,
-0.0045933449,
-0.0152017493,
0.0726428777,
0.048883386,
0.0710771531,
0.0318206251,
0.0525701232,
-0.0508678518,
-0.0031451492,
0.0056279227,
0.0261110533,
0.0198332611,
0.0466038473,
-0.0088157803,
-0.0498453751,
0.0182017237,
-0.0120922979,
-0.0445672497,
0.0416715071,
0.0332889594,
0.0467808545,
0.0131657543,
-0.0472921245,
-0.0563344508,
-0.0228882376,
0.0140358694,
0.0146083999,
0.020454349,
-6.816538191e-33,
-0.033403337,
0.0393497981,
0.0269362684,
-0.017040506,
0.0220774859,
-0.0302796531,
0.0044346349,
-0.0110797836,
-0.0448314846,
0.0175103191,
0.0119653549,
0.0162316505,
0.0113914879,
0.0176165905,
0.0126029849,
-0.0230725985,
0.0213619936,
0.0058948165,
-0.0341964103,
-0.0011313999,
0.0491097905,
-0.0002563705,
0.068965748,
0.0202208068,
-0.0309173912,
0.0099603543,
-0.0149893519,
0.0518119708,
-0.0252216756,
0.0301424004,
0.0059131137,
0.0125227962,
0.0207121242,
-0.0137634519,
0.0017150638,
0.0041113417,
-0.1019614935,
-0.1035642177,
0.0449266322,
0.0178626161,
-0.0354479775,
-0.0377667136,
0.0253306627,
-0.0041609579,
0.0279863123,
-0.0113330157,
-0.0059862151,
-0.0086851604,
-0.0221998058,
-0.0446375199,
-0.075058125,
0.0257785153,
0.0244143754,
-0.0159408487,
0.0100242961,
0.056456998,
-0.0003990933,
0.0371222571,
-0.0400834642,
-0.0406963676,
-0.0085272184,
0.0325902253,
0.0220231321,
0.017575331,
0.0116710197,
0.0433304831,
0.0050866632,
-0.0211868808,
-0.0254659224,
0.0237911642,
0.0515918359,
0.062643446,
0.0413873084,
0.0517433472,
0.0581296496,
0.0265327636,
-0.0888423845,
-0.0053859218,
0.0038713017,
0.0666934997,
0.0007795239,
0.0207361151,
-0.0236907993,
-0.0303985327,
-0.0583252721,
-0.016555639,
-0.0353051834,
-0.0012507592,
0.0209173374,
0.02840022,
-0.035543289,
0.0136437966,
0.059971042,
-0.0225851443,
0.0308290496,
0.0232217889,
-0.0138194282,
-0.0358368978,
0.0135853775,
0.0317307375,
-0.0719812512,
-0.044623293,
-0.0000765177,
0.0049259658,
0.0314233229,
-0.0089749089,
0.0676059425,
0.0047999024,
-0.0618349835,
-0.0336109549,
-0.0211829077,
-0.0219787937,
-0.0198746677,
0.015814729,
0.051146701,
0.0314548053,
-0.0057981089,
0.0413976312,
0.0119176488,
-0.0589557514,
-0.0171890985,
0.0306526404,
-0.0230459794,
0.0311152786,
-0.02725848,
-0.0007343765,
-0.020457644,
-0.0328895189,
0.0357871242,
-0.0712823644,
-0.0075491499,
0.0297173038,
2.773e-7,
0.0353380851,
0.0306375008,
-0.0211056378,
0.0253948905,
-0.007398902,
0.0435226299,
-0.0185582805,
0.0234496258,
-0.0051159984,
-0.020762993,
0.0411123857,
0.0167329591,
0.0388579071,
0.0384086296,
-0.0760188028,
0.0579893924,
-0.0729307011,
0.0026477815,
-0.0104944855,
-0.0081124045,
0.0507883504,
0.1160987318,
0.0581777357,
0.0035471732,
-0.0066496078,
-0.0487231426,
0.0747499615,
-0.0190994591,
-0.0042681252,
0.0205664933,
-0.0157109033,
0.0411437638,
0.015011169,
0.0338899232,
-0.0139213353,
0.0509783328,
-0.0124327149,
0.0946541056,
-0.0116243456,
-0.0053338357,
-0.0507047735,
-0.0319858044,
0.0092222365,
-0.0501006097,
0.1233451292,
-0.1006948724,
-0.0177391153,
-0.0407468081,
-0.031029813,
0.032530047,
0.0268312413,
-0.0020907354,
-0.035262011,
-0.0048583844,
0.0470598228,
-0.0078770667,
-0.0446696021,
-0.0931731388,
-0.0155054983,
0.0431524329,
-0.0005143366,
-0.0262122545,
0.0081730178,
-0.0230057333,
0.0450319722,
-0.0748877972,
-0.0171755701,
2.275571555e-34,
0.016215859,
-0.0283401348,
0.0222669225,
0.0271926876,
-0.0057686837,
-0.0119842822,
-0.0584977418,
-0.0182174928,
0.041863896,
-0.0602646805,
-0.0019959053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.00003v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.00003v1 | The Power of External Memory in Increasing Predictive Model Capacity | 2023-01-31T00:29:39 | 2023-01-31T00:29:39 | Cenk Baykal, Dylan J Cutler, Nishanth Dikkala, Nikhil Ghosh, Rina Panigrahy, Xin Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | One way of introducing sparsity into deep networks is by attaching an
external table of parameters that is sparsely looked up at different layers of
the network. By storing the bulk of the parameters in the external table, one
can increase the capacity of the model without necessarily increasing the
inference time. Two crucial questions in this setting are then: what is the
lookup function for accessing the table and how are the contents of the table
consumed? Prominent methods for accessing the table include 1) using
words/wordpieces token-ids as table indices, 2) LSH hashing the token vector in
each layer into a table of buckets, and 3) learnable softmax style routing to a
table entry. The ways to consume the contents include adding/concatenating to
input representation, and using the contents as expert networks that specialize
to different inputs. In this work, we conduct rigorous experimental evaluations
of existing ideas and their combinations. We also introduce a new method,
alternating updates, that enables access to an increased token dimension
without increasing the computation time, and demonstrate its effectiveness in
language modeling. | [
0.0175438542,
0.0604207143,
-0.0132574439,
0.0018792192,
-0.0278650168,
-0.0120508056,
0.0188476369,
-0.0084592924,
-0.026735181,
-0.0048798141,
-0.0367338993,
-0.0498399697,
-0.0270253122,
0.086632356,
0.0353740305,
0.0150168054,
0.0377265699,
-0.0411482565,
-0.0129349744,
-0.0046025184,
0.0080732144,
-0.0251268782,
0.0266322885,
0.0327032246,
-0.0210325737,
0.0422472879,
-0.0561058894,
-0.0023595847,
-0.0230436921,
-6.833e-7,
0.0129361246,
0.0460774861,
0.0317350104,
0.0203484409,
0.000002075,
0.0074821734,
-0.0318323635,
-0.0144340303,
-0.0432234332,
0.0166667737,
0.0034344401,
-0.023255948,
0.0042417999,
-0.0283746682,
0.0099310586,
-0.0548933409,
0.0855206177,
0.0591167845,
0.0243088175,
0.0730026141,
-0.0139058623,
-0.0256905816,
0.0557571277,
-0.0361067764,
0.0363611467,
-0.0313275158,
0.029207442,
-0.0413705073,
-0.036651779,
0.0002604186,
-0.0113311978,
0.041937314,
0.0692272559,
0.0104270522,
0.0569028631,
0.0582613312,
0.0095681557,
0.0135986824,
0.0049456568,
0.0457514524,
-0.0511861593,
-0.0244059991,
-0.0016605261,
-0.005346572,
-0.0052635279,
-0.0047890339,
-0.0156316105,
-0.0135223698,
0.0243564304,
-0.0154563617,
0.0183494836,
0.0145893162,
0.0591590628,
0.0377020463,
-0.0433012247,
-0.0053789034,
0.0259209126,
0.0012814398,
-0.0094271889,
-0.0178354811,
-0.0096691428,
-0.0226204265,
0.0138230287,
0.0224413835,
0.0151465107,
0.01753328,
-0.0165587869,
-0.0280073434,
0.0114208488,
-0.0852636546,
0.0665128678,
0.0509258695,
-0.029480936,
0.0117917452,
-0.0752337351,
-0.0122747067,
-0.042769663,
0.0320556425,
-0.0413502641,
-0.0156192323,
-0.0143740168,
-0.0161700659,
-0.0645991787,
0.0650688857,
0.0116673727,
-0.0373415872,
-0.0364032052,
0.0089292703,
-0.0341956541,
0.0021148766,
0.0019913267,
0.0242484286,
-0.0424548648,
-0.0039499463,
-0.0155850425,
0.0078579281,
-0.0719976649,
0.0137133459,
-0.0020230613,
-0.0526506715,
-0.0176838171,
-0.0092455233,
0.0214651208,
0.0034357521,
0.0420859829,
0.0757535547,
-0.0195154306,
-0.0147255072,
-0.0454608798,
-0.028628435,
-0.0115296571,
-0.0440399982,
0.021445062,
-0.0727623031,
0.0463816933,
-0.0062738867,
0.0009187212,
-0.0705099329,
-0.0015089362,
0.0330008641,
-0.0253760684,
0.0480790697,
0.019327525,
-0.051550027,
0.038882263,
0.0198197216,
0.0144206407,
0.0613479614,
0.015023794,
0.0419504531,
0.0043225004,
-0.0207069647,
-0.0153115578,
0.020478012,
0.0699468181,
-0.010646998,
-0.0524309352,
0.0177000407,
0.0389276147,
0.0461967587,
0.0051877568,
0.0370161794,
-0.0572636873,
-0.0356776901,
0.0141412131,
0.044735983,
0.0111725545,
0.068550311,
0.0334120318,
-0.0585011095,
0.002340673,
-0.0082413694,
0.0069976491,
0.07508111,
0.0310885403,
-0.0122870812,
0.0794707462,
-0.0066981148,
-0.056360893,
-0.0453259125,
0.0144422883,
0.0024739876,
0.0167729761,
-0.0093189543,
0.0508371592,
0.0071587618,
-0.0224266723,
0.0842909738,
0.0194361769,
-0.0252374504,
-0.0014351568,
-0.0548180938,
-0.0132224411,
0.0661112443,
-0.0075331298,
-0.0260135811,
-0.0113247298,
0.0147548541,
0.0057111476,
-0.0233350992,
0.0259012282,
-0.0071269805,
0.0271217432,
-0.0511461385,
-0.0008731159,
0.000796094,
0.0017251367,
0.0546920896,
-0.0029806609,
0.0119319931,
0.0544683412,
0.0127070695,
-0.0254918151,
-0.0096109696,
-0.0273488127,
0.0015384773,
0.0478507467,
0.0141504398,
0.0362547226,
0.0087812338,
-0.0108587639,
0.040291775,
0.0358061194,
-0.0466344804,
-0.0222037304,
-0.0565646738,
-0.081468001,
0.0373406895,
0.0206070524,
0.0167109612,
0.0491486378,
-0.0138103813,
-0.0086250016,
-0.0535967052,
0.0486941338,
-0.0789834708,
0.0175217651,
-0.0536818653,
-0.0283760671,
0.0317928083,
0.0346436352,
0.005764931,
0.0412447378,
-0.0340997502,
0.0245597735,
-0.0050429842,
-0.0163402129,
0.0134400614,
-0.0336822607,
-0.0139836287,
0.0127182687,
-0.021196831,
0.0251298957,
0.0237790365,
-0.0448327996,
-0.0315429121,
-0.0285401288,
-0.0833348334,
0.0010453783,
-0.031253811,
-0.0435472056,
-0.0156428553,
0.0227513108,
0.0421716608,
-0.0129339369,
-0.0498050451,
-0.0090755867,
-0.0230652951,
0.0328923911,
-0.0237427931,
0.0593691915,
-0.0402587466,
-0.022920467,
-0.0834502056,
0.0055068322,
0.0521416105,
-0.0605121218,
-0.0576691888,
0.0212854929,
-0.0577164888,
-0.015978504,
0.0259523876,
-0.014870855,
-0.0398910269,
-0.0240266547,
-0.0543385781,
0.0144432709,
0.022737911,
-0.0188253373,
0.0088132136,
0.0385968909,
-0.0089953532,
-0.0322714522,
0.0176353604,
-0.0264861286,
0.0155979432,
-0.0063350629,
-0.0110373423,
-0.0383224972,
0.0156055866,
-0.0055729593,
-0.0132581135,
-0.0537284203,
0.0261786524,
0.0251404699,
-0.0498409867,
-0.0351283476,
-0.0031804508,
0.0103974892,
-0.0056730402,
-0.0258312672,
-0.0313152224,
0.0472145937,
-0.0189107209,
0.0127120782,
0.0104932077,
-0.0495081767,
-0.0389053412,
0.0272747222,
0.0318543911,
0.0244705398,
-0.0568524376,
-0.0097384052,
-0.0165250245,
0.0094376188,
-0.0180505794,
-0.0204630122,
0.0715849027,
-0.0017695134,
0.0282404013,
0.0202497579,
-0.0398048535,
-0.0198789518,
-0.0286481362,
0.0003820512,
0.0517087914,
0.0695832148,
-0.0305569973,
-0.0284598358,
-0.0025530027,
0.0170140471,
0.0949055552,
-0.0180820096,
0.0200809296,
-0.0006161271,
0.0011030238,
0.0255201217,
0.0108993156,
-0.019135952,
-0.0228590462,
0.0270572882,
0.0343097635,
0.0174564477,
-0.0341561325,
-0.0644243881,
0.0418128558,
0.0090613058,
0.0086525008,
-0.0035162687,
0.0096652955,
-0.0082945088,
-0.0601891242,
-0.0271149836,
0.0646079779,
-0.010358341,
-0.0601858459,
0.0156114018,
0.0073793526,
0.018451415,
0.0228330567,
0.031314414,
-0.0167931784,
-0.0046164091,
0.0062189661,
-0.0247388165,
-0.025460178,
-0.0478238352,
0.002214669,
-0.0825127363,
-0.0070948577,
-0.0054911575,
-0.0279536527,
-0.0457973033,
-0.0276403073,
-0.0223192126,
0.0372112617,
-0.0034795012,
-0.0225250777,
0.0241286419,
-0.0442834459,
0.0394477695,
0.0076672058,
-0.004672376,
-0.0059720245,
-0.0421993919,
0.0313208029,
0.0093232021,
-0.0309801437,
-0.0122504793,
-0.0022688438,
0.0348286889,
-0.0208771862,
0.019325465,
-0.0125048766,
0.0542962737,
-0.0163494032,
-0.0074772183,
0.0279245786,
0.0268820059,
0.0232343078,
0.0107641472,
-0.0426166132,
0.0686240494,
-0.0273352899,
0.0016904527,
-0.0252043474,
-0.0267676972,
-0.0055402755,
0.0391695686,
0.0157982279,
-0.0109796328,
0.0249237884,
-0.0047402419,
-0.0512504913,
-0.0486546829,
-0.0102008153,
0.019809451,
0.0192886852,
-0.0428498797,
-0.0121863429,
0.0057698512,
0.0337250009,
0.0730302036,
-0.0085543729,
0.0472806431,
-0.0418075733,
0.024970429,
-0.0553970486,
0.0178871378,
-0.0133480886,
0.0072648586,
-0.0174498707,
-0.0304532815,
0.0400702655,
-0.013490174,
-0.0280252118,
0.0526085198,
-0.0658569559,
-0.048024904,
0.0024400807,
0.0404408127,
0.0154657308,
0.0412632041,
0.0292824004,
-0.0641307086,
0.0842755735,
0.0036933569,
-0.0909187421,
0.0026375346,
0.0244455282,
-0.0312367864,
0.0059726178,
0.0409342311,
-0.0592211224,
0.0177194458,
0.0182507243,
0.0103395674,
-0.0177124646,
0.0143678719,
-0.0115465801,
-0.0150730098,
0.0244565997,
0.0449894406,
0.0044624349,
-0.024774855,
0.0549661741,
-0.0249142647,
-0.0007127559,
-0.0196727142,
0.0013413433,
0.0312123299,
0.0072879032,
-0.024930818,
-0.0219261255,
0.0794113204,
-0.0056747766,
0.032244876,
-0.0009380528,
0.0468419269,
-0.018644169,
0.0237942897,
0.0128892781,
-0.053933613,
-0.0111839138,
0.0166550707,
0.0132102305,
-0.0570435785,
-0.019763181,
0.0492307842,
0.0126615185,
-0.0537729897,
0.0153953396,
-0.0813583136,
-0.0885699168,
-0.0524623021,
0.0257550441,
-0.000553029,
-0.0145099927,
-0.043139834,
-0.028581949,
-0.0112256547,
-0.007176761,
-0.019527683,
0.0083483495,
-0.0318303965,
0.031460166,
0.0479027145,
0.0013888095,
0.0035116342,
0.042281881,
0.0594804175,
0.0257056002,
0.0054105637,
0.0154277869,
-0.0366789661,
0.0294760391,
0.0060504624,
0.0662632436,
-0.006065622,
0.0088259969,
0.0206167027,
-0.0590947941,
0.0141492421,
-0.0056805359,
-0.0026482029,
0.0174943116,
0.0374238156,
0.0417677425,
0.0114260726,
0.0027212987,
0.0084366631,
0.017641725,
-0.0061342781,
-0.0291812867,
0.0131642632,
-6.701280236e-33,
-0.0080076605,
-0.0110688936,
0.0180685073,
-0.0666397586,
0.0064212671,
0.0491559468,
-0.0335505754,
-0.0063650212,
-0.0193041656,
0.0119062476,
-0.033383932,
0.0206431467,
0.0267692301,
0.0212280024,
0.0312542915,
-0.0523093343,
0.0757970586,
-0.0083493227,
0.0379426144,
0.0504903011,
0.0257310513,
0.0228028931,
0.0737220868,
-0.0148609066,
-0.0094435737,
0.0323053412,
-0.0038697661,
0.0373861305,
0.0203747805,
0.0552165881,
-0.0266459174,
0.0450348407,
0.0089465482,
-0.075533703,
-0.0081137056,
-0.0126025686,
-0.0902875215,
-0.0460215397,
0.0156253632,
-0.015001934,
-0.0147433346,
-0.0499840602,
0.0360729545,
0.0257672817,
0.0170270391,
-0.0314835273,
0.0017372994,
-0.0044152951,
-0.038809143,
-0.0363409482,
-0.0150836166,
0.0349373445,
0.0105552031,
0.0252363011,
0.0362823121,
-0.0033547007,
-0.0050381892,
-0.0378284976,
-0.0421724096,
-0.0255426392,
-0.0070554442,
0.0827063471,
0.0164427683,
0.0382354334,
-0.0168977603,
0.0462558083,
0.0617541485,
0.0062889191,
-0.0551919751,
-0.0132895121,
0.0364911705,
0.0350757353,
0.0661132708,
-0.0263685901,
0.0773212388,
-0.0115081947,
-0.0615088381,
-0.0135239894,
0.0402704105,
0.0492842048,
0.063967593,
-0.0002860856,
-0.0537179336,
-0.029815577,
-0.0298739225,
-0.0116047943,
-0.0532471947,
-0.0311574433,
0.0089377286,
0.0524868369,
0.0056471382,
0.0179775935,
0.0516397953,
-0.0038338506,
0.0038247695,
0.0749513581,
0.0128551526,
0.0056149485,
0.0133191161,
0.0130219711,
-0.0512557551,
-0.0658930913,
-0.0106165102,
-0.0070995931,
0.0201632176,
0.0034739145,
0.0190985706,
0.0400911793,
-0.0712648481,
-0.0460307375,
-0.0211409573,
0.0223694593,
0.0078687789,
0.0488378182,
0.0392434858,
0.0256807599,
-0.0079100421,
0.0514576063,
-0.0021681485,
0.0191577189,
0.0202476475,
-0.0252434537,
0.0478181243,
0.0258280709,
-0.0300388541,
0.0017379113,
-0.0577226393,
-0.0573749058,
0.0713693649,
-0.0758905336,
0.0011994184,
0.030564189,
2.91e-7,
-0.0171149224,
0.0036230427,
0.0209951773,
-0.0212941468,
0.0065304204,
-0.0103369877,
0.0141323898,
0.0186589379,
-0.0127595961,
-0.026251927,
0.0533049591,
0.0210669339,
0.0189553238,
0.0275194421,
-0.1075622588,
-0.0284539815,
-0.0839273259,
0.0467939824,
-0.02911691,
0.008568895,
-0.0107357716,
0.1764517426,
-0.0186852179,
-0.0088048549,
0.0067879776,
-0.0445061699,
0.0102313943,
-0.0425925702,
0.025740739,
0.0012958257,
0.0934948698,
0.0198164005,
-0.0231547114,
0.0278514121,
-0.0241771527,
0.0398831852,
0.0065161088,
0.041789636,
-0.0181503166,
-0.0587876029,
-0.0053481949,
-0.031926509,
-0.0075195101,
-0.0219830777,
0.0527280308,
-0.0393092521,
-0.0286042243,
0.0018190023,
0.0292293634,
-0.0012041505,
-0.0048203142,
0.020459203,
-0.0024073306,
0.0313563123,
0.0323945247,
-0.0230001248,
0.0112338522,
-0.1042323336,
0.0111474162,
0.0221215859,
-0.0550142676,
-0.0091086263,
-0.0748957992,
-0.0187266003,
0.0638481081,
-0.0419582911,
-0.007893133,
2.75644655e-34,
0.089391917,
-0.0185359176,
0.0178196095,
0.031206185,
0.0331584476,
-0.0336958691,
-0.0094366064,
0.0180549026,
0.0251210555,
-0.1268900484,
-0.0782165676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13318v1 | Proxy-based Zero-Shot Entity Linking by Effective Candidate Retrieval | 2023-01-30T22:43:21 | 2023-01-30T22:43:21 | Maciej Wiatrak, Eirini Arvaniti, Angus Brayne, Jonas Vetterle, Aaron Sim | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | A recent advancement in the domain of biomedical Entity Linking is the
development of powerful two-stage algorithms, an initial candidate retrieval
stage that generates a shortlist of entities for each mention, followed by a
candidate ranking stage. However, the effectiveness of both stages are
inextricably dependent on computationally expensive components. Specifically,
in candidate retrieval via dense representation retrieval it is important to
have hard negative samples, which require repeated forward passes and nearest
neighbour searches across the entire entity label set throughout training. In
this work, we show that pairing a proxy-based metric learning loss with an
adversarial regularizer provides an efficient alternative to hard negative
sampling in the candidate retrieval stage. In particular, we show competitive
performance on the recall@1 metric, thereby providing the option to leave out
the expensive candidate ranking step. Finally, we demonstrate how the model can
be used in a zero-shot setting to discover out of knowledge base biomedical
entities. | [
0.0097504323,
0.0219315551,
0.0040318929,
-0.0399107598,
0.0449934043,
0.0057796012,
-0.0035772058,
0.0412837788,
0.0358745605,
-0.0115862601,
-0.0285150055,
-0.0316305943,
-0.0207872763,
-0.0250718556,
0.0706960633,
-0.0297232494,
0.0450974256,
0.0621817745,
-0.0144863371,
-0.0084324153,
-0.053625524,
-0.0046488536,
-0.0011080954,
0.0057356125,
0.0203552749,
0.0202393327,
0.0004062976,
0.0385447852,
0.0414990485,
-0.0831290111,
-0.022245124,
0.0020910802,
0.0066607515,
0.0326152034,
0.000001971,
-0.0507158376,
-0.0199988689,
0.0334089175,
-0.0700896084,
-0.0202512611,
-0.0191372074,
-0.0229987875,
0.030531399,
-0.0297080036,
0.0011051589,
-0.0701673254,
0.0424290895,
0.0422079638,
0.0285516288,
0.0617205501,
0.0058863983,
-0.004399267,
0.0103219403,
-0.068043828,
0.0060689021,
-0.0649863109,
0.053254433,
-0.0701580867,
0.0284003429,
0.0247630719,
0.0105366148,
0.0259568319,
0.0015474475,
0.0445433259,
0.0393640399,
0.0679727718,
-0.0040599522,
0.0126693826,
0.0376949683,
0.1025841385,
-0.0063232686,
-0.0143913412,
0.0310932882,
0.0304328837,
-0.0001670615,
-0.0150935529,
-0.0463190228,
-0.0473642386,
0.0006320123,
-0.0106491698,
-0.0613576993,
-0.0034716681,
0.0804548189,
-0.0053997817,
-0.0198987424,
-0.0290561747,
-0.0109610977,
-0.0188789628,
0.0258690659,
0.0047152531,
-0.0386802368,
-0.0114371572,
0.030588774,
-0.006358698,
-0.0155773861,
-0.0055976552,
0.0218558535,
-0.0119997878,
0.038525369,
-0.0122107863,
-0.0258369986,
-0.0273005962,
0.0143319322,
0.0681161508,
-0.0589097477,
-0.0180102326,
-0.0578019656,
0.0569086783,
0.0089221839,
-0.0245502684,
-0.0439709984,
-0.0233398601,
-0.0247860514,
0.0571517274,
0.0274888165,
0.0339572206,
-0.0332067646,
-0.0637086555,
-0.0479391254,
0.0422601253,
0.0028489626,
0.0417713523,
-0.014088179,
-0.0171412583,
-0.018652657,
0.0406062789,
-0.0353184491,
-0.0230602827,
-0.028328903,
0.0164674781,
-0.0365060568,
0.0160059426,
-0.0124436822,
-0.0390358865,
0.0187281929,
0.0907643065,
0.0375940576,
-0.0232817102,
-0.0211939123,
-0.0317863002,
0.0293472335,
-0.0685603321,
-0.0264710505,
-0.0107969241,
0.0124902222,
0.0027128069,
0.0157549586,
-0.0989690572,
0.0112841865,
0.0152610838,
-0.0487864427,
0.0467031412,
-0.024230862,
-0.0731503218,
0.00393192,
0.0341024771,
0.0021548923,
0.0286574662,
-0.0134906517,
0.0051874924,
-0.0081090182,
0.0627535284,
-0.0554269664,
-0.0149243753,
0.1006131917,
-0.0199675802,
0.0065759402,
0.0140280602,
0.0120946905,
0.0812291279,
0.023344364,
0.0267384201,
-0.0669135526,
-0.0843362734,
-0.0301125031,
-0.0124499453,
0.0617238022,
-0.0363687165,
0.0242730193,
0.0139856953,
-0.0421402119,
-0.0423851497,
-0.0181819238,
0.0480817072,
0.0173353665,
-0.0240543429,
0.0090246452,
0.0212621409,
-0.0435846224,
0.0186898801,
0.023546977,
-0.0107705481,
-0.0384527892,
-0.0045561576,
0.0869374573,
0.0329836272,
-0.0275406912,
0.0691499412,
0.0289502926,
0.0179433282,
-0.0129420301,
-0.0073891566,
-0.0062129139,
-0.003880267,
0.056276001,
-0.0589784421,
-0.0021486341,
-0.0422657058,
-0.0114530046,
-0.0295288377,
0.0046327873,
-0.0314961448,
0.0248976965,
-0.0242678579,
-0.0058243,
0.0027659321,
0.0142716272,
0.0252648536,
0.0113664968,
0.058416944,
0.0460448675,
-0.0599053055,
0.0493391491,
0.0178677719,
-0.0206080992,
-0.0323844925,
0.0246474277,
0.0427235663,
-0.0049953461,
0.0296499245,
0.0099762892,
0.0127806403,
0.0447611548,
-0.0427974574,
-0.0300848279,
-0.0702022985,
0.0103994478,
-0.0427247323,
0.0328705087,
-0.0333941132,
0.0357862785,
-0.0138688395,
-0.0108074779,
-0.0300587341,
0.0367330462,
0.0181880686,
0.0377179869,
0.0150162335,
-0.0146363676,
0.0232238919,
0.0021505426,
-0.0487849936,
0.0720222518,
-0.0047285426,
0.0415561981,
0.0146811297,
-0.0175135806,
0.0391957425,
-0.0554845408,
-0.065927729,
0.0223137513,
-0.0168204699,
0.0014270046,
-0.0093088225,
-0.0531888567,
-0.0611971095,
0.0006384652,
-0.0348597318,
0.0416045971,
0.0031224964,
-0.0055976626,
-0.0285138134,
0.0143376477,
0.0233201925,
-0.0490899794,
-0.0094472868,
-0.0476858839,
-0.0515694134,
0.0116942143,
0.0190446749,
0.0541122705,
0.004479256,
-0.0227441415,
-0.0366648771,
-0.0087054558,
0.0575990565,
-0.0401335321,
-0.0271750707,
0.0035507749,
0.0282034762,
-0.0381678455,
-0.0129929688,
-0.0123783499,
0.0200180355,
0.0148534589,
0.0223332234,
-0.0441030152,
0.0813767314,
-0.0397886261,
0.0287341662,
-0.0005306837,
0.046326343,
-0.0486570783,
0.0094709722,
-0.0169007927,
0.0133998031,
0.0004299848,
0.0100934487,
-0.0361301377,
0.0188207813,
-0.021007631,
-0.0111978706,
-0.0311151929,
0.0362560488,
0.0225938167,
-0.0184440091,
-0.0415643193,
0.049206391,
0.0196245834,
-0.0051091891,
-0.0286672749,
-0.026541492,
0.0387363061,
0.0057813935,
0.0093578016,
0.0341255926,
-0.0126718795,
0.0078896815,
0.0043806406,
0.0117569249,
0.0213202052,
0.0061421138,
-0.0069665085,
-0.0408608951,
0.0317376815,
0.0254324526,
-0.0236558933,
-0.0147774043,
0.0344814248,
0.0299275182,
-0.0062408005,
-0.0453496724,
-0.0202022698,
-0.0007036355,
0.008883574,
0.0224047415,
-0.0757511854,
0.0134504009,
-0.0759137794,
0.0169101134,
0.0256792847,
0.0205926038,
0.0131864557,
-0.0128864814,
0.0063664177,
0.0352315418,
0.0362494253,
-0.0610120706,
0.0245825816,
-0.0068138004,
0.0421244577,
0.0848294795,
0.0549072437,
-0.0089307334,
0.0287108235,
-0.0286652427,
-0.0060233432,
-0.0273245834,
-0.0469432883,
0.0013201018,
0.0115004554,
-0.0138160288,
-0.0072319158,
0.0593053028,
0.0407233015,
-0.0625286251,
0.0121598979,
0.0453808866,
0.0350712277,
0.0314730182,
0.0076258699,
-0.0790474117,
-0.0165337194,
0.0017082217,
0.0340116583,
-0.0037662464,
-0.0734491348,
0.0161050763,
-0.0665532425,
-0.0005763352,
-0.0001753375,
-0.026787715,
-0.0042517949,
-0.0603822432,
0.0109212045,
-0.0449927263,
-0.0114788683,
0.0019797641,
0.0237941816,
0.0119422041,
0.017109191,
0.0752034113,
-0.0399564616,
0.0114332102,
-0.0609998889,
0.0400867611,
0.0294766445,
0.0349897556,
0.0378163345,
0.0203985013,
-0.0311599001,
-0.0730242357,
-0.0356833898,
-0.0069554956,
0.0973808542,
-0.0290159341,
-0.0205820091,
-0.0197674427,
0.0136060137,
-0.0190424379,
-0.0070783659,
-0.0538442098,
0.0533025935,
0.0065473015,
0.0338017307,
-0.0152763193,
-0.0542925745,
0.0025457169,
0.0337098129,
-0.0246702749,
-0.0045696874,
0.0146452468,
0.0156735703,
0.0779731646,
0.0154798385,
-0.0133934664,
0.0072598471,
-0.0543956533,
-0.0270952731,
-0.039498698,
-0.0367719494,
0.026227653,
0.0948885754,
-0.0363007449,
0.0227550101,
-0.0467688665,
-0.0289755352,
-0.053125836,
0.0413062535,
-0.0109500075,
0.0472360365,
-0.011523501,
-0.0485498458,
0.0777370557,
0.0030801871,
-0.0385574996,
-0.011782784,
-0.0344305411,
-0.0292009432,
-0.0481521301,
0.0121406019,
0.0144270752,
0.0084829181,
-0.024954943,
-0.0424696691,
0.0498790666,
0.0770036876,
-0.027978437,
0.0064211553,
0.0187926628,
-0.0471910611,
-0.0185349267,
0.0416732617,
-0.033378914,
-0.0178967696,
0.035484124,
0.0353332087,
-0.0301269796,
-0.0112534501,
0.0009000697,
0.018455781,
0.0545055196,
-0.0054452331,
0.0133457165,
-0.0093278028,
0.0210331883,
0.014337251,
0.0012821399,
-0.0093081398,
-0.015375644,
0.0342758968,
0.0330456533,
-0.0237416625,
-0.0067281853,
0.01155804,
0.0427067131,
-0.0270186551,
-0.0061562103,
0.0181998704,
0.0188973863,
0.028888803,
0.0026722758,
-0.0045694332,
0.0039489139,
0.0479098,
0.0503597893,
-0.0606424734,
-0.0285681784,
0.0305721238,
0.0398386754,
-0.0197957512,
0.0139460741,
-0.0309480149,
0.0157740042,
0.0017779554,
0.026518181,
0.0570196062,
0.0042417133,
0.0385609567,
0.0436814278,
-0.0281473529,
-0.0116933482,
-0.0163165405,
-0.0343325287,
-0.0237689242,
0.0385476798,
0.0202304684,
0.0192148406,
0.0514583699,
0.0856315494,
0.012766757,
0.0724185407,
-0.0286800489,
-0.0243498776,
-0.0274743363,
-0.0110643301,
0.0135402121,
0.0438816808,
0.0148236603,
-0.0003975017,
-0.0399445593,
-0.0540669672,
0.0458137132,
-0.0745206252,
-0.064658232,
0.0207553785,
0.0540225431,
-0.0187962484,
0.0119980555,
-0.0314881057,
-0.0013921354,
-0.0218419451,
0.0210024361,
-0.0511107966,
0.0136939837,
-6.125938199e-33,
-0.0454522073,
-0.0260242354,
0.0055507082,
-0.0841219053,
-0.0428121425,
-0.0035531081,
-0.0095759388,
-0.0388562009,
-0.0341113135,
0.0096934717,
0.0048218598,
-0.0041616182,
-0.0191034526,
0.0125637967,
-0.0504344963,
-0.0514070876,
0.0360556059,
0.0149272429,
0.0196734406,
0.0166216642,
0.0407858044,
0.0577572472,
0.028478004,
-0.0738414899,
-0.000757242,
0.0209293421,
0.013155045,
0.0082836272,
0.0567154177,
0.0400013663,
0.0061763423,
0.0285796169,
-0.005399548,
-0.0279288348,
0.0151727647,
-0.0617028214,
-0.1337177306,
0.0042720311,
-0.0362345688,
-0.0124349371,
0.0464779735,
-0.0335757062,
0.0266677178,
-0.0063069467,
0.0534809828,
-0.0269691702,
0.0138929775,
-0.0130922431,
-0.0899165869,
-0.0338546261,
0.0004883608,
0.0478636809,
-0.0115221739,
0.0451974571,
0.0024532692,
0.0061761066,
-0.0024761364,
0.0410739109,
-0.042264685,
-0.0271588601,
-0.0426903181,
0.0287926067,
-0.0169862602,
0.0014800705,
0.0303321406,
0.0507364422,
0.0656676367,
-0.025015153,
-0.01742181,
-0.0040213508,
0.0046508359,
-0.0262364466,
0.0071051819,
0.0614764988,
0.0412174091,
-0.0331478864,
-0.1174874976,
0.0135045368,
-0.0508513004,
0.0316024423,
-0.0251814388,
0.0572759658,
-0.0293090325,
-0.0232533179,
-0.0321880393,
-0.0626907051,
-0.0069193654,
-0.0431806482,
0.0035033091,
0.0303465072,
-0.0364803784,
0.0679597035,
-0.0119260503,
-0.0253867712,
-0.0395871624,
0.0338388681,
0.0353649072,
0.0096064722,
-0.0021717013,
-0.0134423319,
-0.0712451786,
0.0069419676,
0.0649174079,
0.0135060344,
0.0227787718,
0.0246846415,
0.0465243123,
-0.02775985,
-0.0629370287,
-0.0245208591,
-0.0173378903,
-0.0016097265,
-0.0170792155,
-0.0144834025,
-0.0091864523,
0.0291807726,
0.0041536968,
0.0634318367,
0.0689732805,
0.0025078594,
-0.0139813991,
0.0412853099,
0.0199075714,
-0.0032712407,
-0.0440064333,
-0.006172508,
-0.0046513961,
0.0333360471,
0.0549998991,
-0.119664371,
-0.0148852747,
-0.0339237414,
2.782e-7,
0.0122303786,
-0.0228880253,
0.0032543656,
-0.0282922704,
-0.0192285609,
0.0162193775,
0.038459219,
0.0332888737,
-0.0326355621,
0.0014659624,
0.0236218162,
0.0232799444,
-0.0132171437,
0.0140047409,
-0.1029030606,
0.0549279265,
-0.0339384004,
0.0055016298,
-0.0293933172,
-0.0373799428,
-0.017964188,
0.0915688127,
0.0249699224,
0.0077013345,
0.0393991023,
-0.032172367,
0.0646840483,
-0.0106812092,
0.0397438258,
0.0057088044,
0.0458964221,
0.0277094096,
0.0002319017,
0.0206771269,
-0.0095853247,
0.02574265,
0.0526787452,
0.0020479693,
-0.0270803925,
-0.0567640103,
0.0121516995,
-0.0274657719,
0.001258873,
0.0284001715,
0.0734818056,
-0.0367675312,
-0.0537780337,
0.0450136773,
-0.0468648896,
0.0144091686,
0.0228260662,
0.0079131043,
-0.0164611191,
0.0357069299,
0.0099436892,
0.0165601335,
0.0163802821,
-0.0766751617,
0.0121318726,
0.0256304406,
-0.0024191709,
-0.029693054,
0.0058738892,
0.0075533986,
-0.0143417539,
-0.0241774712,
-0.010374154,
2.474652085e-34,
0.0095440578,
-0.0080950083,
-0.0183175914,
0.0125841768,
0.0293366965,
-0.0481455214,
-0.0049460693,
-0.0177704785,
0.0339202955,
-0.0500731729,
-0.0042869435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13310v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13310v2 | Alternating Updates for Efficient Transformers | 2023-01-30T22:06:05 | 2023-10-03T21:40:41 | Cenk Baykal, Dylan Cutler, Nishanth Dikkala, Nikhil Ghosh, Rina Panigrahy, Xin Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | It has been well established that increasing scale in deep transformer
networks leads to improved quality and performance. However, this increase in
scale often comes with prohibitive increases in compute cost and inference
latency. We introduce Alternating Updates (AltUp), a simple-to-implement method
to increase a model's capacity without the computational burden. AltUp enables
the widening of the learned representation, i.e., the token embedding, while
only incurring a negligible increase in latency. AltUp achieves this by working
on a subblock of the widened representation at each layer and using a
predict-and-correct mechanism to update the inactivated blocks. We present
extensions of AltUp, such as its applicability to the sequence dimension, and
demonstrate how AltUp can be synergistically combined with existing approaches,
such as Sparse Mixture-of-Experts models, to obtain efficient models with even
higher capacity. Our experiments on benchmark transformer models and language
tasks demonstrate the consistent effectiveness of AltUp on a diverse set of
scenarios. Notably, on SuperGLUE and SQuAD benchmarks, AltUp enables up to
$87\%$ speedup relative to the dense baselines at the same accuracy. | [
-0.00790348,
0.0878703967,
0.0156130837,
0.0005768746,
-0.0397374295,
-0.0149012003,
0.0299934037,
-0.0254362207,
-0.0237475783,
0.0059128124,
0.0014235927,
-0.0472913049,
0.0003439901,
0.0352408774,
0.0275455322,
-0.050658837,
0.0281744879,
-0.0028525596,
-0.0359757841,
-0.0124790696,
0.00054118,
-0.012169281,
-0.0336860828,
0.0674532503,
-0.0232848078,
-0.0052553909,
-0.0455206968,
-0.0189018678,
0.0357271284,
0.0095231505,
0.0150694912,
0.0861978382,
0.0477245003,
0.0483124033,
0.0000022158,
0.0100875562,
-0.0147605538,
-0.0176632069,
-0.0388228633,
0.0137298191,
-0.0059322459,
-0.0261006132,
-0.0119378092,
0.0006706053,
-0.0190245602,
-0.0597022139,
0.0629672706,
0.0618796684,
0.0490639433,
0.0715294704,
-0.0177890081,
-0.0151696801,
0.0502718613,
-0.0552440956,
-0.0155573972,
-0.0209014751,
-0.0025152338,
-0.0485778153,
-0.0239112377,
-0.0007701709,
-0.0179517195,
0.0384703502,
0.0900467783,
-0.0011171089,
0.0188997816,
0.0435072407,
-0.0287203398,
-0.0332530215,
0.0084399572,
0.0231697634,
-0.0732237622,
-0.000468986,
-0.0392171554,
-0.0013017862,
0.0091512669,
-0.0210237354,
-0.033483468,
-0.0022991949,
0.0403755642,
0.0067183911,
-0.0143219307,
0.0067291525,
0.063343145,
0.0168198552,
-0.0870538056,
-0.0082703726,
0.0233591553,
0.0036648279,
-0.0301337522,
0.0044552987,
-0.0489740856,
-0.0313733183,
0.0156156626,
0.0374476351,
-0.0630202591,
-0.0134243583,
-0.0188826136,
-0.0408006832,
0.0009785704,
0.0214569774,
0.0391257107,
0.0604833253,
-0.0531944185,
0.0175760221,
-0.0377614498,
0.0483130999,
-0.0450535938,
0.0253909975,
-0.0181284565,
0.0010682691,
-0.0116953002,
-0.0309807844,
-0.0222852565,
0.0209322292,
-0.0226795413,
-0.0242219865,
-0.0332382098,
0.0227932557,
-0.0225285646,
-0.0141457347,
0.0235510804,
0.0343599543,
-0.0611762702,
-0.0007418637,
0.0213956907,
0.0685555339,
-0.0223359223,
0.0254577361,
0.0386202671,
-0.0672599971,
-0.0503539965,
0.0070523256,
0.0294753108,
-0.0067576868,
0.0279193874,
0.0476687811,
-0.0501743779,
-0.0520756431,
-0.0047264853,
0.0113502704,
-0.0258695669,
-0.0460139476,
-0.0091686007,
-0.0609692782,
0.023968827,
-0.0130784977,
0.0235071573,
-0.0306861717,
0.0073300903,
0.0165092964,
0.0276186708,
0.0431155004,
-0.0057970039,
-0.0392265283,
-0.0133658135,
0.0281264298,
-0.0452244468,
0.0350215361,
0.0108868219,
0.0412642583,
-0.0120009435,
-0.0310777389,
0.0260950048,
0.0523008257,
0.0158355795,
-0.0066816942,
-0.0162533149,
-0.0488004386,
-0.0032705036,
0.0346236713,
0.028771095,
0.0478643104,
-0.0421704389,
-0.060855519,
0.0599327199,
-0.0015914838,
0.0094807781,
0.0599829219,
0.0340483375,
-0.0066597145,
-0.0352714434,
0.0180527512,
-0.0346172601,
0.054283943,
0.043808002,
-0.0037873655,
0.0067795701,
0.063619256,
-0.0558381341,
-0.0129397502,
0.0087159071,
0.0014452336,
-0.0013757499,
-0.0010843356,
0.0267839227,
0.0227328148,
-0.0522147603,
0.1205271557,
0.0141438823,
-0.0330666229,
0.0061731837,
-0.0451636016,
-0.0292930715,
0.0539516285,
0.0063863979,
-0.0051879012,
-0.0685829446,
-0.0214917604,
0.0022501708,
0.0205088779,
-0.0129074659,
0.0071620359,
0.0472434722,
-0.0572008453,
-0.0316925868,
0.0215419196,
0.0043529077,
0.0380661339,
0.0396929719,
-0.0274083372,
0.0397576652,
-0.0229229424,
0.0313007943,
0.021899011,
-0.0511954837,
0.0042452156,
0.0466873683,
0.0225081276,
0.0092675993,
0.0148403859,
0.0078900019,
-0.0225494709,
0.0517088622,
-0.0577077977,
-0.0506967157,
0.0168467071,
-0.1175549701,
-0.0018367288,
0.0360782407,
0.0067038755,
0.0001881849,
0.0671702772,
-0.0284367632,
-0.0290816985,
-0.0030603977,
-0.0628054291,
0.0279247798,
-0.0298442822,
-0.0071579199,
0.0275892187,
0.0351811126,
-0.0131742572,
0.0234527569,
-0.0527197756,
-0.0079751005,
0.0387708507,
0.0070095388,
-0.0291655324,
-0.019705398,
-0.0220098794,
0.0083545707,
-0.0309725646,
-0.0042747227,
0.0294682477,
-0.0280332062,
-0.0025051709,
-0.0569694787,
-0.0601125881,
-0.0406302288,
-0.0498231389,
-0.0113543663,
-0.0143671511,
0.0540605076,
0.0338243321,
-0.0033754138,
-0.0345771089,
-0.015259725,
-0.0112931347,
0.0230782498,
-0.019742623,
0.0101293195,
-0.0128103122,
-0.0107249003,
-0.0354939401,
0.0372753069,
0.0465696529,
-0.0347076133,
-0.0113639673,
-0.0325581767,
-0.0540032685,
0.0008079009,
0.0153964804,
-0.0224759299,
-0.0566624999,
0.0026499275,
-0.0359687619,
0.0765258372,
0.0224822983,
0.0181272719,
0.0125001762,
0.0148667088,
0.0164223053,
-0.0410661548,
0.0144076291,
-0.0590286776,
0.0141820898,
-0.057577759,
0.0023728621,
-0.0295417607,
0.0697887242,
-0.0391519405,
-0.0072067771,
-0.0621347353,
-0.033617232,
0.0231108759,
-0.0322822109,
0.0267273765,
0.0117710028,
-0.0220380537,
-0.0263190046,
-0.0143849738,
-0.0349946022,
0.0659424365,
0.0014565126,
-0.0250744671,
-0.0130587127,
-0.0365761481,
-0.0190081317,
0.0491380803,
0.0328559354,
0.0090961196,
-0.0374898724,
-0.0431453325,
-0.0613725521,
0.0389966927,
-0.0356656909,
-0.0179513637,
0.0689104199,
-0.0172155444,
-0.0104341907,
-0.010842815,
-0.0562278964,
-0.0666248947,
-0.0165658537,
-0.0185580738,
0.0448662452,
0.0591837391,
-0.0603671074,
-0.1233313978,
-0.0008744926,
0.0211831909,
0.0875548497,
-0.0126338191,
0.0174044874,
-0.0162157938,
0.023190381,
0.0088023646,
0.0783424526,
0.0202246364,
-0.0072593521,
0.032813549,
0.086067684,
0.0476162955,
-0.011844038,
-0.0838638246,
0.0108213248,
0.0335226841,
0.0050321184,
-0.005713155,
-0.0066100946,
0.0302357022,
-0.0457809828,
0.0043028239,
0.0789578483,
-0.0093491897,
-0.0645749122,
0.0212133117,
0.037117295,
0.0602392145,
0.0316349007,
0.0107618086,
-0.0698585734,
-0.0370843038,
0.0186173618,
0.0109276548,
0.0189923141,
-0.0159372501,
0.0179040041,
-0.0569610782,
0.0226929076,
-0.0090784989,
-0.0162378363,
-0.0119152647,
-0.0458959155,
-0.0089498935,
-0.032944493,
0.0239282995,
0.0146075217,
0.0124782221,
-0.0547461435,
0.0536601543,
-0.0022472313,
-0.0628221035,
0.0062961183,
-0.0329161771,
-0.0040693791,
0.0185092967,
-0.038632229,
-0.0043545822,
-0.0575115643,
0.0233519953,
0.0172908902,
0.0061009866,
0.0069702915,
0.0209538583,
0.010266074,
-0.0341400877,
0.0184035748,
0.0306887347,
-0.0170617122,
-0.0285107102,
-0.0457706153,
0.0773893669,
0.0124866739,
0.0085036466,
-0.008696951,
-0.0089077819,
-0.0053621968,
0.0357735939,
0.0056111873,
-0.0241631847,
0.0431093872,
0.0028436352,
0.0365232825,
-0.0435338579,
-0.0305377245,
0.0055098226,
0.048182115,
-0.0657224432,
-0.0230267867,
0.0122541552,
0.0112246498,
0.0520377718,
0.0020621531,
-0.048568517,
-0.0046685911,
0.02913104,
-0.0636917874,
0.0116951615,
0.0118188299,
0.0192888528,
-0.050309293,
0.0075630103,
0.0333497524,
-0.0038263912,
-0.0199814551,
0.0075043002,
-0.1102423072,
-0.0375292338,
0.0495325476,
0.0582007281,
0.0093332147,
0.0524012633,
0.0306881182,
-0.0331011713,
0.0612712465,
0.0579790622,
-0.0485775732,
0.0315026045,
0.035684783,
-0.087350592,
-0.0224116221,
0.0235963203,
-0.0276236497,
0.0391909778,
0.0097348243,
0.0489578471,
-0.0283486154,
-0.0102623357,
0.0163434539,
-0.059694007,
0.0242764,
-0.0013389125,
0.0604018457,
0.0012872939,
0.0519532822,
0.0240222309,
0.0070046396,
-0.0329571553,
-0.0002756951,
0.0129347108,
-0.0005902236,
0.0140225962,
0.0348729901,
0.0330390595,
0.0276945662,
-0.0150290132,
0.0117113637,
-0.0169039257,
-0.0380774215,
0.005798039,
0.0299217924,
-0.0251958966,
-0.0267241746,
0.021206487,
-0.0072641657,
-0.0306230243,
-0.0029507908,
0.0410311073,
0.0265839286,
-0.0257524885,
0.0174316,
-0.074979566,
-0.0262845382,
-0.0236476455,
-0.0092398422,
0.0329436064,
-0.002435545,
-0.0107238889,
-0.017640898,
-0.0148137286,
-0.0234252717,
-0.0090240613,
-0.0109557668,
-0.014237253,
0.0165694356,
0.0511109233,
0.0279194005,
0.0045218468,
0.0639898181,
-0.0097333472,
0.0315246247,
-0.0064436547,
0.0165141672,
-0.0479444936,
-0.050137572,
0.005342368,
0.0280238092,
-0.0044486495,
-0.0078244191,
-0.0053947526,
-0.0579338819,
0.038469594,
-0.0273029674,
0.0323917978,
-0.0145092532,
0.0341451354,
0.0495196655,
-0.0025505116,
-0.0160681736,
0.0202616677,
0.0187701751,
0.0498968028,
-0.0191083048,
0.0181818083,
-6.93753109e-33,
0.018399762,
-0.0013860182,
0.0205297749,
-0.0526597127,
-0.0349626988,
0.0430050567,
-0.0217506345,
0.0104791075,
-0.0186907724,
0.0297852401,
-0.0197716001,
0.0126898708,
0.0045330743,
0.0612588748,
0.0145888552,
-0.0253736805,
0.1046486571,
0.0317462943,
-0.0001436039,
0.0245955046,
0.0147172781,
0.0243190527,
0.0825516433,
-0.0156474318,
-0.0441405177,
0.0167727582,
-0.008082631,
0.0185567774,
-0.0104594519,
0.0540889651,
-0.0099953134,
0.0281991586,
0.0010688427,
-0.0980311111,
-0.0115325972,
-0.0353248641,
-0.0918847173,
0.0009120773,
-0.0541160069,
0.0309775658,
-0.0475518666,
-0.0208158772,
0.0418884866,
0.0038598673,
-0.0051482334,
-0.0426340178,
0.0133380806,
-0.007407845,
-0.0334413201,
-0.0213628411,
-0.0316739157,
0.0392237045,
-0.0104220575,
-0.0248505734,
0.01215229,
0.0584247783,
0.0101018585,
-0.0004240484,
-0.0927224308,
-0.0176947434,
0.0146663617,
0.0887516513,
0.0228520073,
0.0384910703,
-0.0295719299,
0.033167135,
0.0193222556,
-0.0196215622,
-0.0243191104,
-0.0087948805,
0.0545455366,
0.0265441611,
0.0710202828,
-0.0107052475,
0.0675566792,
0.0076901307,
-0.0467188209,
-0.010174023,
0.0069019678,
0.070936352,
0.036569383,
0.0217963941,
0.0079245912,
-0.0071326438,
-0.0124712167,
0.0003641461,
-0.0322834775,
-0.0200105309,
-0.0055960161,
0.0639211088,
-0.0171697736,
0.0357099697,
0.0533727296,
-0.0003002625,
0.0232369788,
0.0217626095,
-0.0007136224,
0.0155923143,
-0.0007397687,
0.0034948976,
-0.0261145625,
-0.0202840045,
0.0360617563,
0.0301209111,
-0.0055432729,
-0.0141649302,
0.0510623716,
0.0610588454,
-0.0638825372,
-0.0424150266,
-0.0311421119,
0.0295360945,
-0.0074420115,
0.0204304326,
0.0556887016,
-0.0053716628,
-0.0106955934,
0.0478722937,
-0.0206841175,
-0.0049487632,
0.007808099,
0.0145685561,
0.0447278917,
0.0356313735,
-0.0191612616,
0.0084827449,
-0.0460665487,
-0.0232583564,
-0.0144172059,
-0.0900278911,
-0.0264335889,
0.0124647673,
2.988e-7,
-0.0014193594,
0.0074499352,
0.0319615118,
-0.0214181393,
0.0182744637,
0.0102587072,
-0.0093473308,
0.0254343487,
-0.0084301354,
0.0081527643,
0.0304381996,
0.0313275121,
0.037750084,
0.0210605543,
-0.1115002707,
-0.0085092792,
-0.1012561247,
0.0386745334,
-0.0358755514,
-0.0150246387,
0.026016077,
0.1245024502,
0.0103129623,
-0.047246106,
0.0430760793,
0.0169066619,
0.0259653628,
0.0080342162,
0.0235574171,
-0.0224446822,
0.0555054359,
0.0524182655,
0.0150017543,
-0.006361797,
-0.0318543129,
0.0125413332,
0.0162628479,
0.0373266339,
-0.0052114404,
-0.0238737017,
0.0270597711,
0.0317194499,
-0.0049798768,
-0.0221647322,
0.0416163988,
-0.0610759184,
-0.0124784522,
-0.025070224,
-0.0577906109,
-0.0108320536,
-0.0011778778,
-0.0015877928,
-0.0220508389,
0.0458695553,
0.0314422697,
-0.0074075498,
-0.0275263209,
-0.0900672376,
0.0034595779,
-0.0082050292,
-0.0760501847,
-0.006623222,
-0.064622812,
-0.0355545245,
0.035117913,
0.0001845201,
-0.0169313028,
2.887318331e-34,
0.0350497477,
0.0158644002,
-0.0024916406,
0.0535729341,
0.0082225632,
-0.0446836576,
0.0112366443,
-0.0084972465,
-0.0021044835,
-0.0750038698,
-0.0532779694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13298v1 | LongEval: Guidelines for Human Evaluation of Faithfulness in Long-form Summarization | 2023-01-30T21:31:48 | 2023-01-30T21:31:48 | Kalpesh Krishna, Erin Bransom, Bailey Kuehl, Mohit Iyyer, Pradeep Dasigi, Arman Cohan, Kyle Lo | cs.CL | cs.CL | While human evaluation remains best practice for accurately judging the
faithfulness of automatically-generated summaries, few solutions exist to
address the increased difficulty and workload when evaluating long-form
summaries. Through a survey of 162 papers on long-form summarization, we first
shed light on current human evaluation practices surrounding long-form
summaries. We find that 73% of these papers do not perform any human evaluation
on model-generated summaries, while other works face new difficulties that
manifest when dealing with long documents (e.g., low inter-annotator
agreement). Motivated by our survey, we present LongEval, a set of guidelines
for human evaluation of faithfulness in long-form summaries that addresses the
following challenges: (1) How can we achieve high inter-annotator agreement on
faithfulness scores? (2) How can we minimize annotator workload while
maintaining accurate faithfulness scores? and (3) Do humans benefit from
automated alignment between summary and source snippets? We deploy LongEval in
annotation studies on two long-form summarization datasets in different domains
(SQuALITY and PubMed), and we find that switching to a finer granularity of
judgment (e.g., clause-level) reduces inter-annotator variance in faithfulness
scores (e.g., std-dev from 18.5 to 6.8). We also show that scores from a
partial annotation of fine-grained units highly correlates with scores from a
full annotation workload (0.89 Kendall's tau using 50% judgments). We release
our human judgments, annotation templates, and our software as a Python library
for future research. | [
0.0440279022,
0.0311367754,
0.0304533523,
-0.0235720389,
-0.0015616813,
0.0280850902,
0.0039989464,
-0.0380688459,
-0.0124983173,
-0.0491142608,
0.0008740046,
0.0197343081,
0.0386819132,
-0.002173881,
0.0334458537,
-0.0783405751,
0.0249075554,
0.0145214275,
0.0103556868,
0.0136895226,
0.0387643836,
-0.0269453935,
0.0056379731,
0.0448328219,
0.0105252629,
-0.0177293513,
0.0165164452,
-0.0019261964,
0.0482476093,
-0.0437080823,
-0.0040282859,
0.0452437252,
-0.0122330366,
0.0421311967,
0.0000018591,
-0.0701948553,
-0.0163695011,
0.0576895513,
-0.0052636587,
0.0755631104,
0.0172142573,
-0.0505535603,
0.0151536455,
-0.018613562,
-0.005629567,
0.0057923151,
0.0287985597,
0.0234140623,
0.0751493275,
0.0432293527,
-0.0056053759,
-0.0110851387,
0.0380808711,
-0.0119427722,
-0.0107140169,
0.00026872,
-0.0029669818,
0.0523182228,
0.0318897255,
0.0002074062,
0.0335813425,
0.0296610836,
0.000175903,
-0.0270630531,
0.0165365301,
-0.0061589936,
-0.0662668869,
-0.0207598805,
0.0435109586,
0.0357559621,
0.0882336274,
-0.002101629,
0.0374052115,
0.0086419666,
0.0017174319,
0.0461526141,
-0.0940089822,
0.0503397249,
-0.0212886911,
-0.0251225866,
-0.0100207562,
0.022966316,
-0.0115938261,
-0.0046290848,
-0.0232531931,
0.0198372081,
-0.0114580439,
-0.0153414197,
-0.00852824,
0.0144781368,
-0.0486244187,
-0.0794572532,
-0.0091135334,
0.0176097546,
0.0086332494,
-0.0523327552,
-0.020575352,
-0.0700539798,
0.080523029,
-0.0398192704,
-0.0092407716,
-0.0071440046,
0.0024814724,
0.0050134193,
0.0203118306,
-0.0022187501,
0.0073414915,
0.030505687,
-0.0176383331,
0.0232558157,
-0.0209636763,
0.0131063368,
-0.0131809376,
0.017765766,
0.0032226956,
-0.0154486755,
-0.0675753802,
0.0016143234,
-0.0128440652,
0.0314884335,
-0.0249200668,
-0.0183130968,
-0.0080100736,
0.0118767973,
0.003018976,
0.0289994255,
-0.0482080244,
-0.018894041,
0.0274730287,
-0.0060204593,
-0.0142685408,
0.0416750275,
0.0080468887,
-0.0045978711,
-0.0106347222,
0.0232517477,
0.0110842017,
-0.0039663538,
0.0144468537,
-0.0743305907,
-0.0197137725,
-0.0468444042,
0.0136893,
-0.069044061,
0.0056335693,
0.0229766518,
-0.0032228623,
-0.0324017145,
-0.0130701168,
0.0225731656,
-0.0354159996,
0.0012625214,
-0.0574291497,
-0.0162591655,
0.0049530929,
-0.0148357004,
-0.0026381116,
0.0148043334,
0.0586393699,
0.0207186565,
0.0364335515,
0.0037477359,
0.0191353038,
-0.0017040891,
0.0182180647,
0.0158461798,
0.0433758125,
0.0139602367,
0.0052807191,
0.0180224311,
0.0262296665,
0.0533902273,
-0.0434652232,
0.0280771423,
0.0315059386,
0.0510114171,
0.0210700668,
0.0051666121,
0.0251873601,
0.0306971464,
0.054321453,
0.0696564093,
-0.0232132208,
0.0405079089,
-0.0167591348,
0.0734570026,
0.0742667168,
0.015475654,
0.0115695009,
-0.0427890234,
-0.031104438,
0.0222143531,
-0.0084797312,
-0.0108332597,
0.007772597,
0.0023377817,
0.0081750872,
0.0435538441,
0.0177307911,
-0.0653960556,
-0.004061223,
0.0110224551,
0.0346929766,
0.0027199194,
0.0374594964,
-0.0271268841,
-0.0165556222,
-0.0324277133,
0.007461274,
0.0311442725,
0.0420850553,
-0.0215367954,
-0.0347049758,
-0.0220563784,
-0.0331418402,
-0.0199183617,
0.0187194142,
-0.0337114483,
-0.0107842963,
-0.043507494,
0.0300587639,
-0.0235054661,
-0.0744282752,
0.0406861454,
-0.0216250978,
-0.0019384344,
-0.053842105,
-0.0209421832,
0.0436239615,
0.0392464027,
-0.0297457483,
0.0480005145,
0.0077420613,
0.0067828898,
0.0091196718,
0.0023553369,
0.0109873246,
0.00429984,
0.0321108811,
-0.0751552656,
-0.0091937575,
-0.0129103577,
-0.0040937853,
-0.0355863497,
-0.0199792292,
-0.0738031864,
-0.035788767,
-0.0167130306,
0.0012958326,
0.0113380784,
0.0012702734,
-0.0217286833,
0.0227168053,
0.0143004572,
-0.0017454342,
0.0403024442,
-0.0798413008,
0.0384277813,
-0.028064277,
-0.0133391162,
-0.0039210087,
0.0149909724,
0.0038859409,
0.0764653683,
0.0017847315,
-0.0382369161,
-0.0161482692,
-0.1019213796,
0.0088023078,
-0.0132489093,
0.0198731534,
0.0215875078,
-0.0169690475,
0.0014440572,
0.0090321545,
-0.0157533083,
-0.0673367605,
-0.009425289,
0.0329412371,
0.0492669456,
0.014817914,
0.0338141136,
-0.0733858645,
-0.0222627204,
-0.0285303965,
0.0515931547,
0.0724596977,
-0.0459003896,
-0.0261433311,
0.01596581,
-0.0247180574,
-0.0503145009,
0.0252938867,
0.006435011,
0.0173111949,
0.0332573056,
0.008645487,
0.0440942831,
0.0394969881,
-0.0153732449,
0.05760739,
0.0206797719,
-0.0328063034,
-0.0176561754,
-0.0223192051,
0.0156127699,
0.0356300212,
-0.0367550254,
0.0544051304,
0.041557882,
-0.0077366345,
0.01432533,
-0.0106314616,
0.0089977188,
-0.0312813073,
0.004667799,
-0.0065116123,
-0.023872789,
-0.00845447,
0.0575996004,
0.0122210877,
-0.0261657797,
0.067634657,
-0.0490770601,
0.0278599449,
-0.0343738198,
0.0372583009,
-0.0553820953,
0.0104660327,
-0.0014207386,
-0.0079022674,
0.0023520382,
0.0161984973,
-0.0249878578,
-0.0073307604,
0.0698026419,
-0.0077758413,
0.0750183463,
-0.0373128615,
0.0342818722,
-0.0375799239,
0.0021025522,
0.0135520734,
-0.0173851047,
-0.0539660677,
0.0297604166,
0.0169911068,
-0.0257720463,
-0.0367742814,
0.0138124861,
0.072473526,
0.0438048318,
-0.0385990441,
-0.019635465,
-0.0037418816,
0.0067659151,
0.0629770532,
0.0160419475,
0.0510229841,
-0.0634987578,
0.0222206898,
0.0514030904,
-0.0219003167,
0.0395319425,
-0.0006045228,
-0.0440099649,
-0.0333445556,
-0.0826388523,
-0.0116927149,
0.0064666676,
0.0654897019,
-0.0522508919,
0.019354118,
0.0877812505,
0.002082356,
-0.0166246369,
-0.0096235378,
-0.0191182047,
0.0543241166,
-0.0060749315,
-0.0046928055,
-0.0862853304,
-0.0097471504,
0.0019243293,
0.0584360063,
0.014181261,
-0.0550164171,
0.0151174981,
-0.0328864269,
0.0489242598,
0.0324169137,
-0.07904879,
0.0012141434,
-0.0536732413,
0.0176880248,
-0.0287973303,
0.0097435676,
0.0397189148,
-0.0360883139,
0.0240843054,
0.0156124672,
-0.0964970291,
0.0199636407,
-0.0256088302,
-0.0716295168,
0.0116534298,
0.0386819094,
0.0376438238,
0.0058511002,
0.0082476679,
0.0377759524,
0.0038285872,
-0.0156338457,
0.0218956787,
0.1010549515,
-0.0045404956,
0.0323256254,
-0.0366437249,
0.0279594548,
0.0189924408,
-0.0221584234,
0.0270235259,
0.0412811376,
-0.009342405,
-0.0043338099,
-0.0875651911,
0.0542670302,
-0.0620420203,
0.0620516129,
0.077964589,
0.0047422042,
-0.0354632176,
-0.0202641599,
-0.0001770212,
-0.0511997901,
-0.0387441218,
0.0112681091,
-0.0675672963,
-0.0032317007,
-0.0769787878,
-0.0978106186,
0.0229061078,
-0.0268225614,
0.0106587624,
-0.0014761509,
0.0123954713,
-0.0037136432,
-0.0377307944,
0.023978442,
-0.0064835488,
-0.0082399761,
-0.0016302409,
-0.0080213314,
0.0320763998,
0.0135241086,
-0.0064385058,
0.0345535353,
-0.0494812205,
-0.0130630303,
0.0020220154,
0.0306294523,
0.0236704219,
0.0404251702,
0.0305116568,
-0.0091601452,
0.0208551362,
0.0375322253,
0.0060574487,
0.0172874145,
0.0041178162,
0.0275116358,
-0.0268859193,
-0.0243780073,
-0.0529077686,
-0.000817803,
-0.0317685269,
0.0419555195,
0.0089403875,
-0.0510780104,
0.0281756576,
0.0744569153,
0.0007293099,
-0.0291738678,
0.0060583036,
-0.0009451349,
-0.0288507883,
-0.0250014048,
-0.0202997811,
-0.0340795144,
0.0421005189,
-0.0480714999,
0.0109233344,
-0.0000017453,
0.1045320854,
-0.0346474387,
0.0379852057,
-0.0712030008,
0.0290108696,
-0.0240585655,
-0.0011933056,
-0.042830538,
-0.0278825685,
-0.0598811805,
-0.0339098312,
-0.0372369327,
0.0289683584,
0.0042650294,
-0.0059130271,
0.0287638754,
0.0084845182,
-0.0082677193,
0.0243524741,
-0.0953093618,
0.0017270076,
-0.053578455,
0.0140078086,
0.0109924646,
-0.0295811817,
0.101156868,
-0.0239693951,
-0.0062260493,
-0.0299872551,
0.0600482523,
0.0221748799,
0.0352668464,
-0.0456240363,
0.022586558,
-0.0147629911,
-0.0308367796,
0.0545944795,
-0.0180109162,
-0.0101043954,
-0.0194810908,
-0.0587814339,
-0.0381967053,
-0.0595280491,
-0.048407197,
0.0085009467,
-0.0021237112,
-0.0740971267,
-0.0970715657,
-0.0220532734,
0.0217568744,
0.036978703,
-0.0086203227,
-0.0089465482,
-0.0002446422,
0.0160267688,
-0.012309216,
-0.0441506617,
-0.0322019607,
0.0179090556,
-0.0119407447,
-0.006134816,
-0.0034017502,
-5.323536572e-33,
-0.0224743988,
-0.0136836302,
-0.0247726366,
0.0080220522,
-0.048549369,
-0.0032206373,
-0.0756846815,
-0.0066555641,
0.0308051538,
0.0451684892,
-0.0307432264,
-0.0090765944,
0.006679635,
-0.0068641063,
0.0421874151,
0.0197825767,
0.0418100543,
0.0140886409,
-0.0544131547,
0.0277669672,
0.0284088645,
-0.0266351271,
0.0289937686,
-0.0589455031,
0.0969038233,
-0.008985471,
-0.0085466364,
-0.0562759079,
0.0148026804,
0.0510380566,
-0.0008603609,
-0.0312198754,
0.0375699773,
-0.0296035223,
-0.058859352,
-0.0119038736,
-0.0706761032,
0.0206140671,
0.0249720234,
-0.0416130722,
-0.0764346644,
-0.0339812115,
0.0605292656,
-0.0349419601,
-0.0347890966,
-0.0587423965,
0.0708269551,
-0.0411160663,
-0.0331450291,
-0.0848406926,
-0.0387149267,
0.0433179475,
-0.0218734629,
-0.0042165299,
0.0043862043,
0.0468640812,
0.0077958168,
0.0401173308,
-0.0109153176,
0.0265117344,
0.0289634708,
0.0188278686,
0.0076474263,
-0.022663692,
0.0258029886,
0.0665723607,
0.0006894445,
0.0165892951,
-0.0132779293,
0.0186998937,
-0.002315976,
0.0079574678,
0.0497512929,
0.0454428494,
0.0487891473,
0.0505513772,
-0.0583492853,
0.0976345167,
-0.057330735,
0.0317486376,
-0.0075129932,
-0.0297798645,
-0.0090457508,
-0.0159185715,
-0.0331691727,
-0.0122236926,
0.0085582994,
-0.0011099394,
-0.0309123881,
-0.0167542771,
-0.0565434061,
0.0039756484,
0.0097215576,
-0.0232562255,
0.0068660639,
-0.0045821504,
-0.0212176424,
0.0453023203,
0.0118936067,
-0.0371165499,
-0.0063618585,
0.0349645913,
0.0069575487,
0.0142645175,
0.0544498898,
-0.0034902613,
0.0923504978,
0.0025154878,
-0.0255297162,
-0.0186629035,
0.002052227,
-0.0101357689,
-0.0322881304,
-0.0394952148,
0.0085045826,
0.0269370116,
0.016414769,
0.0355535075,
-0.0102575431,
0.0184012912,
-0.0235982612,
0.035861142,
0.0238347407,
0.0260525737,
0.0046141436,
0.0088390158,
0.0043262546,
0.0222022422,
0.0205616336,
-0.0268322527,
-0.0040731523,
-0.0198706686,
2.406e-7,
0.0754815415,
0.0409791395,
0.0726935863,
-0.038127955,
-0.0139273116,
0.0170983877,
-0.0160241164,
0.024435848,
-0.0016393724,
-0.0163215697,
0.0458633304,
-0.0148506034,
0.0327902064,
0.0412070863,
-0.0751086548,
-0.0350366868,
-0.1011684015,
-0.0494209938,
-0.0334113389,
-0.0143134659,
0.0380288735,
0.0031394253,
-0.0444949903,
0.0052093938,
0.0067556812,
-0.0130090481,
0.0275128577,
-0.0149985598,
-0.0257471558,
0.0600923523,
0.0527063645,
-0.0472691245,
0.0171475131,
-0.0109139727,
-0.0156095652,
-0.0142598813,
0.0648529232,
0.055408664,
0.0423510969,
0.0227958374,
-0.0055071576,
-0.0359252952,
0.0667949617,
-0.0052014296,
0.0069002835,
-0.0565343611,
-0.0323623158,
-0.0540362373,
-0.0524674766,
0.002592755,
0.0340400524,
0.0283071287,
0.0055616526,
0.0665097013,
-0.0174952392,
0.0015475904,
-0.0011733709,
-0.0324748233,
-0.0672263801,
0.0421342775,
-0.0069293273,
-0.0443141349,
0.0055012126,
-0.0400370993,
-0.0136230541,
-0.0781074986,
-0.0242968891,
2.395210019e-34,
0.0905231014,
-0.0324202739,
-0.012910529,
-0.0054434063,
0.0481689237,
-0.0315623917,
0.0035449213,
0.013286612,
0.033494737,
-0.0581552945,
-0.0018836142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13294v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13294v3 | Adaptive Machine Translation with Large Language Models | 2023-01-30T21:17:15 | 2023-05-09T11:04:43 | Yasmin Moslem, Rejwanul Haque, John D. Kelleher, Andy Way | cs.CL | cs.CL | Consistency is a key requirement of high-quality translation. It is
especially important to adhere to pre-approved terminology and adapt to
corrected translations in domain-specific projects. Machine translation (MT)
has achieved significant progress in the area of domain adaptation. However,
real-time adaptation remains challenging. Large-scale language models (LLMs)
have recently shown interesting capabilities of in-context learning, where they
learn to replicate certain input-output text generation patterns, without
further fine-tuning. By feeding an LLM at inference time with a prompt that
consists of a list of translation pairs, it can then simulate the domain and
style characteristics. This work aims to investigate how we can utilize
in-context learning to improve real-time adaptive MT. Our extensive experiments
show promising results at translation time. For example, LLMs can adapt to a
set of in-domain sentence pairs and/or terminology while translating a new
sentence. We observe that the translation quality with few-shot in-context
learning can surpass that of strong encoder-decoder MT systems, especially for
high-resource languages. Moreover, we investigate whether we can combine MT
from strong encoder-decoder models with fuzzy matches, which can further
improve translation quality, especially for less supported languages. We
conduct our experiments across five diverse language pairs, namely
English-to-Arabic (EN-AR), English-to-Chinese (EN-ZH), English-to-French
(EN-FR), English-to-Kinyarwanda (EN-RW), and English-to-Spanish (EN-ES). | [
0.0192377977,
0.0433792025,
-0.0134882843,
0.0355861709,
-0.0196311474,
0.019279018,
0.0064504812,
0.0069245063,
-0.0708795115,
-0.0419660322,
-0.0326941386,
-0.0525596477,
0.0215035267,
0.0025566167,
0.0460100509,
-0.0426952168,
-0.007802282,
-0.0264863558,
-0.0210584961,
-0.0122525301,
0.0272295251,
0.0494688302,
0.0194881447,
0.0373740047,
0.0307651013,
-0.0002950677,
-0.0008578597,
0.0493455343,
0.0310537685,
0.0040637841,
0.0111973127,
0.0089756437,
0.0285884012,
0.0317275971,
0.000002172,
-0.0442312621,
-0.0336331651,
-0.0250994824,
0.0278655943,
0.0228530839,
0.0657335222,
-0.0680933073,
-0.025307741,
0.0244704857,
-0.0213741586,
0.0116646029,
0.0608594939,
-0.0065843626,
0.0615874454,
0.0689195693,
-0.0136671374,
-0.0313005596,
-0.0169623885,
-0.0474423133,
-0.0172341187,
-0.0630717874,
-0.0116303172,
-0.0245949645,
-0.0143430466,
0.0099816564,
0.00786993,
0.0298291128,
0.0073424396,
-0.0020066076,
-0.0111572864,
-0.0170959756,
-0.0239866059,
-0.009948533,
0.0000185606,
0.0781832039,
-0.0579655059,
-0.0388388,
-0.0116468463,
-0.0183937978,
-0.0104652317,
-0.0062162359,
-0.0408403948,
0.0163152441,
-0.0302749593,
0.0267350711,
0.0200535879,
0.0374455862,
0.0223115906,
0.0005188795,
-0.0501675382,
-0.0145047987,
0.0312495716,
-0.0208596829,
-0.0332547463,
0.0142974099,
-0.0512150712,
-0.0284482483,
0.0270767249,
0.0118138846,
-0.0256105866,
0.0047497214,
-0.0795364752,
-0.0323052965,
0.0097456733,
-0.0626053065,
0.030654056,
0.0758771077,
0.0222102497,
0.0276245791,
-0.0321096517,
0.0663139448,
-0.0286367107,
-0.0086990353,
-0.0902188942,
-0.0318039656,
-0.0391727798,
0.0304046348,
-0.0405769758,
-0.0208256338,
-0.0582191125,
-0.0066948137,
-0.0336563475,
0.0405693129,
0.017409537,
0.0434222333,
-0.0026035495,
-0.0403912514,
-0.0933285654,
-0.053923782,
-0.0071149669,
0.0420698933,
0.0048783994,
-0.017353246,
0.0050396305,
-0.0299446788,
-0.0087687112,
0.0070191105,
0.0188108291,
-0.0141084716,
-0.0149605842,
0.059608575,
-0.0403017625,
-0.0116198091,
-0.0100074522,
0.0010499571,
-0.0022271308,
-0.0215848591,
-0.0238139611,
-0.0476525798,
0.0192749221,
0.0323550627,
0.0094682733,
-0.0628588274,
0.0124223623,
0.001730188,
0.015475749,
0.0365218334,
0.0280934125,
0.0075829094,
0.0512108468,
-0.0125416582,
-0.0000399821,
0.0944202989,
0.0439336337,
0.0410593301,
0.020408215,
0.0185462404,
0.006330261,
0.0821224824,
0.0189429969,
0.052609317,
-0.0545721874,
-0.0049876622,
0.0324424207,
0.0524636731,
0.0379509591,
0.0363152362,
-0.0106047308,
0.0647741556,
0.0966239795,
-0.0183852687,
0.016365042,
0.0552647859,
0.0636435375,
0.0136407847,
-0.0165661164,
-0.0037109521,
0.0019038363,
0.0126561671,
-0.0005385284,
0.0332091711,
0.0337172337,
0.0678971112,
-0.0402226709,
-0.0311155934,
0.0050458428,
-0.0200405642,
-0.0042140754,
-0.0102701047,
0.0465229079,
0.0424444675,
-0.0753412396,
0.0046226773,
0.0098002395,
-0.0181483924,
0.0291621704,
-0.0203238484,
-0.0318812691,
0.0911049843,
0.0516124889,
0.0063190837,
-0.0335508063,
-0.0190825015,
0.0018507212,
0.0626539439,
0.0415625647,
-0.007503605,
0.0198429525,
-0.0638805479,
-0.0274784993,
0.0089615416,
-0.0009454102,
0.0001491918,
-0.0026321935,
0.0700285286,
0.0325841159,
-0.0235133041,
-0.0644000694,
0.026910916,
-0.065814279,
-0.0392062888,
0.0422562063,
0.0093263984,
0.0141880475,
-0.0147403209,
-0.038578216,
-0.0138001675,
-0.0004447517,
-0.0506454445,
-0.0182251073,
0.051587116,
-0.0687677041,
-0.0544925369,
0.0040783705,
-0.0087160645,
-0.010436981,
-0.0281046759,
-0.0396093503,
-0.0202347133,
-0.0251409374,
-0.033686135,
0.0116151422,
-0.0288317874,
0.0706358403,
-0.02796649,
0.0184488371,
-0.048939947,
0.0199038722,
0.0197574031,
-0.0360036157,
0.0091609536,
0.0120917624,
-0.0145756993,
-0.0007424845,
0.0106513333,
0.0082069784,
0.0117175151,
0.0255005732,
0.0450947732,
0.0300633125,
0.0042493958,
-0.0307371262,
-0.0410538688,
0.0203837641,
-0.0255567394,
0.0190485679,
0.0381808467,
0.0394957736,
-0.0014994105,
0.003252401,
-0.0018017578,
0.0126624061,
0.0167319197,
0.0040439744,
0.0290546641,
-0.0087038353,
-0.0031682362,
-0.0061678984,
0.0291696042,
0.0318349525,
0.050730776,
0.0223570298,
-0.0194895137,
-0.0875220969,
0.0287773907,
-0.0180508588,
-0.004727751,
0.0142016029,
-0.0456991196,
-0.0164626203,
-0.0037589835,
0.0394886658,
0.0578287393,
0.031856522,
0.0032712345,
0.0342218578,
0.01444712,
-0.053941451,
-0.0058945278,
-0.0070681162,
-0.0548595376,
-0.0379974581,
-0.0341094397,
0.0277451538,
0.0130308829,
0.0047506141,
0.00995412,
-0.0570693165,
0.0139010018,
-0.0004147396,
-0.0294568874,
-0.0044171,
-0.0011029131,
0.00577896,
0.0661924705,
-0.0025056461,
-0.0287098885,
0.0756637454,
-0.026497893,
-0.0109592425,
-0.0484721214,
-0.0065940986,
-0.0291343145,
0.0109009203,
-0.0119415047,
0.0369931795,
-0.0067457645,
-0.0090297237,
-0.0474464223,
0.0055588041,
0.0471584015,
-0.0254974607,
0.0234338176,
-0.0692534819,
-0.0117315529,
-0.0286020655,
-0.0466058925,
-0.0467651822,
-0.0003476916,
-0.0167449955,
-0.0076295375,
-0.0051949969,
-0.0124457311,
-0.0226592571,
0.0290109012,
0.0147677446,
0.0737621114,
-0.0126644494,
-0.0170563292,
-0.0394321494,
0.0290391501,
0.0315322578,
0.0074509047,
-0.0329595655,
-0.0670133755,
0.0279004686,
0.0082515208,
-0.0071850331,
-0.0326869525,
-0.0377814509,
-0.0268506836,
0.0552816316,
0.0011551466,
-0.0079059973,
0.0171104074,
0.0456917435,
-0.0497557819,
-0.0266902633,
0.1055180654,
0.0233144984,
-0.062667951,
-0.0120620904,
-0.0150769688,
0.0345077068,
0.00933412,
0.0215362161,
-0.0986345708,
-0.0506965294,
0.0285870824,
0.0153844338,
0.0275928359,
0.0349635147,
-0.0103490939,
-0.1256949902,
0.0040049497,
0.0552946776,
-0.079861775,
-0.063669607,
0.0052835247,
-0.0073868772,
-0.0176603608,
0.0285388604,
-0.0053946781,
0.0175353698,
0.0056373999,
0.0080694268,
0.0523868799,
-0.0818415657,
-0.0176076144,
-0.0759087279,
0.0296496321,
0.0875208005,
0.0185121577,
0.0225164723,
-0.0145291099,
0.0382245257,
-0.0268953145,
-0.0121865747,
0.0067542475,
-0.0238072071,
0.0067143552,
0.0026480644,
0.027810948,
0.0135382023,
-0.0312089026,
0.030009022,
0.0590503104,
0.0505612083,
-0.0236640647,
0.0161181483,
-0.0055183982,
-0.0378779173,
0.0172509067,
0.0305276532,
0.0201636609,
-0.0909337252,
-0.0112699047,
-0.0380066931,
-0.0140040154,
-0.0475533791,
-0.0195725188,
-0.0136364941,
-0.0773986354,
-0.020801723,
-0.1167441905,
-0.0115083205,
-0.0140806148,
0.0392100923,
0.0383583419,
-0.0047343015,
0.0342854187,
0.0059132176,
-0.0199867506,
-0.0205297004,
-0.011058447,
0.014125579,
-0.0458268523,
0.0205992945,
0.0392153859,
-0.0776101276,
0.0214935187,
0.041661676,
-0.0495384559,
-0.0639349446,
-0.0253500901,
0.0142091475,
0.0110897627,
0.0638416782,
-0.0147228613,
-0.0515993312,
0.04085996,
0.0492184646,
0.0042730607,
0.0029705148,
0.017379066,
0.0329600759,
-0.0196873955,
0.0533819646,
-0.0373268165,
0.0148946075,
-0.0089540873,
0.0308953449,
0.0011765375,
-0.0921103582,
0.0168188214,
-0.0048530968,
0.0021353401,
-0.0348314643,
-0.0436012894,
-0.0027804698,
0.0239095669,
-0.0050697387,
-0.0344849862,
-0.0404544882,
-0.0083011491,
0.034483891,
0.0056621153,
0.0222766437,
0.0053783758,
0.0263239816,
0.0118305366,
-0.0049004457,
-0.0318920016,
-0.0587888882,
0.052072715,
0.019195592,
0.0322157852,
-0.0196800996,
0.0108854529,
0.0026430264,
0.035902597,
-0.0682858527,
0.0425008871,
0.0181760229,
0.0209755432,
-0.0073429635,
0.0348817706,
-0.0177180953,
-0.0006041488,
-0.0636733249,
0.0242539812,
0.0912057757,
-0.0022011288,
0.1002974063,
-0.0180641506,
-0.0142619703,
-0.022124419,
0.055353865,
-0.0031795031,
-0.0158248264,
-0.0061140293,
-0.0110233268,
-0.0068810224,
0.0109574022,
0.0577942021,
0.0148408115,
-0.00897526,
0.0105912834,
-0.002858354,
-0.0039177951,
0.0227494817,
0.0106733423,
-0.0320996195,
0.0003689858,
0.0112744402,
-0.0105806012,
-0.0374434963,
0.0114485156,
-0.0134351291,
-0.012444335,
-0.0338476822,
0.0109122926,
0.0669663474,
-0.0363798812,
0.0162877701,
-0.0393767916,
0.0295552127,
0.009085929,
-0.0157544632,
-0.0283291526,
-6.23262974e-33,
-0.0237893481,
-0.0258789677,
0.0097302767,
-0.0342368931,
-0.0145111773,
-0.0412259027,
-0.0296695307,
-0.0504784361,
0.0152225792,
-0.005513736,
-0.0219137948,
-0.0108703608,
0.0134192798,
0.0218232479,
0.0103441253,
0.0325344875,
0.0735231265,
0.0111173345,
-0.0427651331,
0.0470101051,
0.0380481221,
0.0071380897,
0.0451286212,
-0.0300931036,
-0.0145380711,
-0.0369260497,
-0.030495692,
0.01798792,
0.0292990115,
0.0340041928,
0.0112393955,
0.0211940855,
0.0047481149,
-0.0416160934,
-0.0212263782,
-0.0295824949,
-0.0710668415,
0.0321128368,
-0.0203451589,
0.028612351,
0.0262558255,
-0.0630819052,
0.0545673482,
-0.0264099389,
-0.0405103788,
0.0123720486,
0.0226160642,
-0.0704635754,
-0.0238229297,
-0.0372159034,
-0.0833618119,
0.0280884672,
-0.0110267671,
-0.0172489509,
0.0074031167,
0.0610209368,
0.0025928062,
0.0297869109,
-0.0623316504,
0.0182514787,
-0.0272822417,
0.052602686,
0.0846949667,
0.0086108595,
-0.017955564,
0.0059508882,
-0.0427818894,
0.0142845651,
0.0340087451,
-0.0082733417,
0.0190921798,
0.0052502328,
0.0219734572,
0.107848905,
0.0525284559,
-0.0440697558,
-0.0386997089,
0.0723399073,
0.0060642757,
0.0060997372,
0.0472940691,
0.032998465,
-0.0193008222,
0.0032182559,
-0.0439205989,
0.0122885872,
-0.0307488199,
-0.0098685035,
0.0067310375,
0.0321421735,
-0.0281394236,
0.0093616759,
0.0760487467,
-0.0104713254,
0.0160046779,
-0.0089794612,
-0.0809534714,
-0.0172085222,
-0.0125332642,
0.0617575124,
-0.0013894918,
-0.0692719594,
0.0108867772,
0.0260944441,
-0.0131994253,
-0.0171601735,
0.0369016677,
0.0291202068,
-0.0657975376,
0.0408477224,
-0.0273403991,
0.0041721123,
-0.0049677854,
0.0069176005,
0.010573958,
-0.020877948,
-0.0187007207,
0.0382662788,
0.0268731527,
-0.0622872077,
-0.0194531064,
-0.0165495295,
0.0106884632,
0.015812397,
-0.0573959909,
0.0244691521,
-0.0446842425,
0.0067013111,
0.0286017861,
-0.0701310709,
-0.0409133881,
-0.028797416,
2.96e-7,
0.0150394198,
0.0557221211,
-0.0085674319,
0.0264066346,
0.0290314816,
0.0477778539,
-0.0315972641,
0.0509092249,
0.0206602849,
0.0541910194,
0.0325495154,
0.0050964509,
0.0863545537,
0.0290949438,
-0.0621411055,
-0.031051429,
-0.0420385115,
0.0470024571,
-0.049580656,
0.0074576642,
0.0201938879,
0.0923393145,
-0.0197410602,
0.0046938006,
0.0182754658,
-0.0610711463,
0.1015643105,
0.020568369,
-0.0119233662,
0.0203703288,
0.0014306578,
-0.0069352547,
-0.0532975793,
-0.0208375454,
-0.02819,
0.0173774026,
0.0334914364,
0.0821933299,
0.0328267664,
0.0119517427,
0.0253542252,
-0.0008523671,
0.0045704697,
-0.0627267882,
0.0483332686,
-0.057656657,
-0.004676945,
-0.0068609985,
-0.0043631154,
-0.0097414022,
0.0151124494,
-0.0316465013,
-0.0360846743,
0.0294041391,
0.0519743003,
0.0393467695,
-0.0372230485,
-0.0257612765,
-0.0258679911,
-0.0316812322,
-0.0148351444,
-0.035573855,
-0.0205999091,
0.022671314,
0.0206526425,
-0.0279144794,
0.0343581997,
2.778791504e-34,
0.0402098857,
-0.0216630809,
-0.0020570932,
0.0301751755,
0.033512488,
-0.0328782648,
-0.0323950984,
0.0284989532,
0.0262578633,
-0.0421349108,
-0.0201956686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13268v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13268v2 | Contextual Dynamic Prompting for Response Generation in Task-oriented Dialog Systems | 2023-01-30T20:26:02 | 2023-02-10T23:16:02 | Sandesh Swamy, Narges Tabari, Chacha Chen, Rashmi Gangadharaiah | cs.CL | cs.CL | Response generation is one of the critical components in task-oriented dialog
systems. Existing studies have shown that large pre-trained language models can
be adapted to this task. The typical paradigm of adapting such extremely large
language models would be by fine-tuning on the downstream tasks which is not
only time-consuming but also involves significant resources and access to
fine-tuning data. Prompting (Schick and Sch\"utze, 2020) has been an
alternative to fine-tuning in many NLP tasks. In our work, we explore the idea
of using prompting for response generation in task-oriented dialog systems.
Specifically, we propose an approach that performs contextual dynamic prompting
where the prompts are learnt from dialog contexts. We aim to distill useful
prompting signals from the dialog context. On experiments with MultiWOZ 2.2
dataset (Zang et al., 2020), we show that contextual dynamic prompts improve
response generation in terms of combined score (Mehri et al., 2019) by 3
absolute points, and a massive 20 points when dialog states are incorporated.
Furthermore, human annotation on these conversations found that agents which
incorporate context were preferred over agents with vanilla prefix-tuning. | [
0.0710630044,
0.0047848118,
-0.0067226076,
0.0089991074,
-0.0116106197,
0.010517017,
0.0233796854,
-0.0192195717,
0.0054394095,
-0.0598008744,
-0.0587662198,
-0.0384005904,
-0.0319744796,
0.0590849221,
0.0140183428,
-0.057222683,
0.0572214499,
-0.0302585717,
0.0414597876,
-0.0025205843,
0.0090055391,
-0.0014675055,
-0.0229930561,
0.0667911544,
-0.019690644,
-0.0181061234,
-0.0500698611,
0.0024005957,
-0.002408365,
-0.0306673627,
0.0501567833,
0.0668238923,
0.001041321,
0.0248775259,
0.0000018703,
-0.0704138726,
0.0143253235,
-0.0361859836,
-0.0450651236,
-0.0219610464,
0.0335754938,
0.0191081818,
0.0039707581,
0.0233662352,
-0.0701989159,
-0.0092086932,
0.0308303218,
0.056757737,
0.0577161796,
0.0851714835,
-0.008510353,
0.0213294607,
0.006301654,
-0.0360223204,
0.0057538468,
-0.0366946682,
-0.0215180162,
-0.008555742,
0.0204590671,
0.0681218877,
0.0069185747,
0.0080679702,
0.0145420963,
-0.0405100845,
-0.0194656011,
0.0189016592,
-0.0121939136,
-0.0355155952,
-0.0515287556,
0.1117893159,
0.0275769439,
0.0091480929,
0.0040917909,
-0.0170765221,
0.012176062,
-0.0199335236,
-0.0460628048,
0.0273983125,
0.0019703698,
-0.0032167099,
0.0216600671,
0.0237810314,
-0.0400876962,
0.0004766415,
-0.0020607596,
0.0443438925,
0.003432181,
-0.0219856612,
-0.0160733629,
0.0057932008,
0.0030935919,
-0.0932727084,
-0.022419177,
0.0356609225,
-0.101664871,
-0.0009559746,
-0.0504700392,
0.0001867155,
0.0334982648,
-0.0033661763,
0.026212519,
0.0352688916,
-0.031973239,
0.0026144229,
-0.00906133,
0.0381497853,
0.0034916666,
0.0016445667,
-0.0316508487,
-0.0098748989,
-0.0403300598,
-0.0113951117,
-0.0519904941,
0.0237694606,
-0.0880911872,
-0.0316622443,
-0.0316848271,
0.0547408499,
-0.0148553737,
-0.0164954644,
-0.0122943623,
0.0365617573,
-0.0561116971,
0.0040956796,
-0.0345107913,
0.0005657188,
-0.054143358,
0.0414745472,
0.0540837459,
-0.053936258,
-0.0128523661,
0.0291142482,
0.0241338853,
-0.0204092879,
-0.0157458149,
0.0327624269,
-0.0106570926,
-0.0195553545,
0.0165072344,
-0.0399023145,
-0.0383035317,
-0.0423327088,
-0.0423221104,
-0.0232920386,
0.0181098394,
0.0111368066,
-0.0357820503,
0.0242292304,
0.0264594592,
0.0244727693,
-0.0094679175,
0.0373059213,
-0.018979717,
-0.0040231668,
0.0071163015,
0.0015373066,
-0.0360627137,
0.0348976329,
0.0260164142,
0.0118647404,
0.0292219464,
0.0207540542,
-0.0002249705,
0.0012455051,
0.018887179,
0.0078483159,
0.0434926786,
0.032965634,
0.0032064612,
0.0028976665,
0.0246167723,
0.0445576459,
-0.0341508761,
0.0116868112,
0.0530910827,
0.0428596884,
0.0076202676,
-0.0123183653,
0.0472517945,
0.0291921739,
-0.0199029222,
-0.0030034033,
-0.0465030968,
0.0226615537,
-0.0300288144,
0.0070140315,
0.0537497699,
0.0150064174,
-0.0466703884,
-0.0455332361,
0.0382870995,
0.0074839648,
0.0078556072,
0.0146906273,
0.0142347645,
0.0487249568,
-0.0516785271,
-0.0097350776,
0.0065063592,
-0.0539975055,
-0.0171110742,
-0.0631784424,
0.047455512,
0.0577787086,
0.0341705829,
-0.0199934524,
-0.0537399091,
-0.0309292916,
0.0363124534,
0.0515974052,
0.0487608165,
-0.0388793834,
0.0524555556,
-0.0221282151,
-0.0153531749,
-0.006822004,
-0.00478474,
0.026039565,
-0.0051170681,
-0.0159729477,
0.0253279507,
0.0422727242,
-0.0153251681,
0.0051874709,
0.0073641092,
-0.0236590169,
0.0468982495,
0.0058519924,
0.0259713717,
0.0455298461,
-0.0042930138,
0.0162641834,
0.0178351589,
-0.0251608286,
0.0036428412,
0.0106804548,
-0.079611294,
-0.0812005624,
0.0023046155,
0.0296258926,
0.0218388848,
-0.0124551672,
-0.020081155,
-0.0797665194,
0.0038555744,
-0.0035774545,
0.0136131356,
-0.0494075641,
0.0027936844,
0.0519054942,
0.0216699354,
-0.0474892668,
0.0419848636,
0.0328677483,
0.0150562981,
0.0817312449,
0.0691957548,
0.0088780811,
-0.0543503128,
-0.0078349449,
0.000340101,
-0.0274111275,
0.0055957986,
0.0575673133,
0.039620813,
-0.0603613704,
-0.0005673889,
-0.105392471,
0.0111089051,
-0.0362719484,
0.0075254519,
0.0193590671,
0.0180031098,
-0.0079069976,
-0.0305649005,
-0.0607601702,
0.0216392577,
0.0756039992,
0.0159483459,
0.0426237546,
0.0213427301,
-0.0085679907,
-0.0671352893,
0.0128142163,
0.0131778065,
0.0116245253,
0.0185122788,
0.0021904926,
-0.0496550649,
0.029792672,
-0.0052074003,
0.0337292627,
-0.0022498309,
-0.0266963299,
0.0521941036,
-0.0086015435,
0.0839847773,
0.0504749119,
0.0388952009,
0.0174921639,
-0.0140949953,
-0.0268569887,
-0.0857630149,
0.037894018,
-0.05702338,
-0.0194941647,
-0.0193941072,
-0.0078022168,
0.0539864935,
0.058624424,
0.0109763537,
-0.0158093553,
-0.0506227314,
0.0248208158,
0.019265607,
-0.032171011,
-0.0041489084,
-0.0328951739,
-0.0411628187,
0.0659519881,
-0.0186959133,
-0.0362120047,
0.0528610535,
0.003648744,
-0.019443417,
-0.0483136028,
0.0024870657,
-0.0189935192,
0.068013005,
-0.0120744109,
0.0187598355,
0.0537849739,
-0.0322027542,
-0.0536348186,
-0.0081519308,
0.0068599442,
-0.0245645177,
0.0347801372,
-0.0150752096,
0.0169196986,
-0.0223212242,
-0.060118515,
-0.0749413967,
-0.0386538878,
0.0074571157,
0.0126302196,
0.001425055,
-0.0126051735,
0.0247475188,
0.009367276,
0.0115298619,
0.0530922636,
-0.0090688337,
-0.0057169236,
-0.0389151536,
0.0550397411,
0.0621781647,
0.0568493791,
0.0145636145,
-0.0284409635,
0.0687325522,
0.0331046544,
0.0728162825,
0.0068932166,
-0.0078820325,
-0.019382678,
0.0401814282,
-0.0060306164,
-0.0159583334,
0.0293864068,
0.0800442249,
-0.0335860476,
-0.0320335813,
0.1253694445,
0.0306612179,
-0.0356989317,
-0.002453398,
-0.0213842764,
0.0236272179,
0.016915381,
0.0296579711,
-0.0793353468,
-0.0476072766,
-0.0057191034,
-0.0045400113,
-0.0186517052,
-0.0227519665,
-0.0079469411,
-0.1169400439,
0.0398213193,
-0.0207167156,
-0.0085636191,
-0.0089250114,
0.0031243828,
0.0108510247,
0.0208536983,
0.0210724678,
0.021837214,
0.0094279181,
-0.0045362036,
0.0320531614,
0.017691372,
-0.0271062329,
0.0146871936,
-0.0458156765,
0.0897336826,
0.0674259886,
0.0302151851,
0.0341753177,
0.0153754149,
0.0315024927,
-0.0173064973,
0.0132942973,
-0.0054585091,
0.023918869,
-0.0062227789,
-0.0079040835,
-0.0397272371,
0.0279162731,
-0.0284758043,
-0.0358092189,
0.0269352347,
0.0188354738,
-0.0616388619,
0.0240732264,
-0.0250018481,
0.0403839536,
0.0625543967,
0.0665267557,
0.0319660231,
-0.0745568573,
-0.0279477909,
-0.0187249668,
0.0179263577,
-0.0535234399,
0.0102715679,
-0.0227023549,
-0.0060889493,
0.0236045755,
-0.1019698381,
-0.0709218383,
0.0170754287,
0.0308616441,
0.0109192031,
-0.0066296402,
-0.0101723084,
-0.0117523633,
-0.0115703139,
0.0277356729,
-0.0095063429,
0.0105386199,
-0.0686341748,
-0.0313697234,
0.0356032439,
-0.0395588614,
-0.0133101176,
0.0142716384,
-0.0685114488,
-0.0576084256,
-0.0416712277,
0.0907649696,
0.0210566074,
0.0301409941,
0.009579258,
-0.0177868456,
-0.0092978571,
0.0270120949,
-0.0461551659,
-0.0271111839,
0.0407853797,
0.0543388315,
-0.0183138307,
0.0407691151,
-0.0407766886,
0.0487518795,
0.0032140515,
0.0595815256,
-0.0187355243,
-0.085702993,
0.0016799994,
-0.0012882137,
0.0309915598,
0.0176155213,
-0.0252846628,
-0.0462891571,
0.0160922073,
-0.0162119567,
-0.0151721947,
-0.0569201484,
0.0176038481,
-0.0285604596,
-0.0204841811,
0.0203917194,
-0.0142908795,
-0.0520600639,
0.0423658602,
-0.0426847823,
0.0012861795,
0.0094884112,
0.0120659797,
0.0230237264,
-0.0049331505,
-0.0303341597,
0.0134848552,
0.0355035216,
0.0274283364,
0.0013437351,
0.0876240283,
0.0270382632,
-0.0339350663,
0.0073382589,
0.0291955471,
-0.0759605169,
-0.0238503758,
0.0105005307,
0.0284249745,
0.0094377836,
0.0297245346,
0.0376675949,
-0.0157897826,
0.0181233529,
-0.0209240485,
0.0688670725,
0.0221991669,
-0.0242162049,
0.0189468078,
0.0096333632,
-0.0291683991,
0.0256094821,
0.0661955178,
-0.0395327248,
-0.0027259833,
0.0174410157,
0.0333340801,
-0.0565506183,
-0.0109170089,
-0.0062823691,
0.0280884337,
-0.0243768096,
0.0539428256,
-0.0296113547,
-0.0300811958,
-0.0033478839,
0.0064342781,
-0.0126599474,
-0.0270776786,
0.0350772738,
0.0344506539,
0.0095407441,
-0.0169466119,
-0.0455743223,
0.0003545789,
-0.0200024974,
-0.0429218672,
-0.0371876396,
-6.030069655e-33,
-0.034679886,
-0.0324707218,
0.0334154107,
-0.0149594266,
-0.022139376,
-0.0068214089,
-0.045437932,
0.0043703122,
-0.022353733,
-0.0024495705,
-0.0385010354,
-0.0076387194,
0.0022018307,
0.0550494418,
-0.0052539557,
-0.0142118586,
0.0503229424,
-0.008137973,
-0.023455983,
0.0565434471,
0.0352965817,
0.019809369,
-0.0021863098,
-0.0174807496,
0.0560285375,
-0.0224245135,
-0.0141565911,
0.0284954458,
0.0079681361,
0.0529384539,
-0.0368794426,
0.0432694405,
0.0190400817,
-0.0298991613,
-0.0210777037,
0.0865850821,
-0.0663737804,
-0.0479402915,
0.0099233398,
-0.0280231461,
-0.0508223996,
-0.012185216,
-0.0133538907,
-0.0126078036,
-0.0144508593,
0.0401240736,
0.0049837762,
-0.0076499013,
-0.027888082,
-0.0297720581,
-0.087447077,
-0.0038428342,
-0.0021932914,
-0.0634243339,
-0.0236713886,
0.0912161916,
-0.0108496016,
-0.0217112713,
-0.0119933635,
0.0099013932,
0.0191461742,
0.0080642626,
0.0089168446,
0.0455628,
0.001551532,
0.0528848693,
0.031822823,
0.04521228,
-0.0118285725,
-0.0222601257,
-0.0230312217,
0.0428057984,
-0.0182100106,
0.0538410544,
0.0037631954,
-0.002662644,
-0.0405835696,
0.0398771502,
0.0479730703,
-0.0105991205,
0.044351507,
-0.029242998,
-0.0152401105,
-0.0117376279,
-0.0305266436,
0.0120502952,
-0.0345464163,
-0.0191727616,
0.0514080338,
0.0476754159,
-0.007138256,
-0.0372519717,
0.0452110618,
-0.0277622864,
0.0129808467,
0.0088536115,
-0.0257910043,
-0.0133294752,
-0.0159630999,
0.0078984965,
-0.037371289,
-0.0430557728,
0.057830397,
-0.004986953,
-0.0142451171,
0.024868127,
0.0096764397,
-0.0012650352,
-0.0679719076,
0.0121486466,
-0.0357638113,
0.094762519,
-0.0431724824,
0.0293317139,
0.0095435763,
0.005200583,
-0.0221265722,
0.0779317841,
-0.0121436948,
-0.0319916122,
-0.0393783152,
-0.0302217808,
0.0067528873,
0.0215543266,
-0.0432740562,
0.0162376016,
-0.0026748539,
0.0159686059,
-0.0144426739,
-0.02438315,
-0.02386209,
-0.0020976071,
2.499e-7,
-0.0040318947,
0.0287050493,
0.0323582776,
0.0295694172,
0.013802778,
0.0481203049,
0.0205773506,
0.0423662849,
0.0275407862,
0.0130328704,
0.0041817669,
-0.0035649489,
0.0375590622,
-0.0021439653,
-0.0894997492,
-0.0330467969,
-0.0570251085,
-0.0092478823,
-0.0388892293,
-0.0036632468,
0.0836578533,
0.0700372532,
-0.0314443484,
-0.0122726625,
0.006228047,
-0.0232689548,
0.0430122577,
-0.0404007137,
-0.001922784,
0.0344166048,
0.0340251923,
-0.0260170419,
0.0133238006,
0.0105588287,
0.0032098375,
0.0314910263,
-0.0264838692,
0.0536053255,
0.0194231551,
-0.0802077651,
0.0044754683,
-0.0133285448,
0.0416758321,
-0.032989718,
0.0577346534,
-0.0757702589,
-0.026613595,
-0.0510353781,
-0.0075415242,
-0.0159508288,
-0.0266719013,
-0.0450040475,
-0.0100990664,
0.0138390167,
0.0092114164,
0.0149891963,
0.0085829822,
-0.0855349898,
-0.0057350639,
0.0163648352,
-0.0312457886,
-0.0601630323,
-0.033717826,
-0.0063272547,
0.0090270434,
-0.0068115001,
0.0027377484,
2.020367829e-34,
0.0364507474,
-0.0125521692,
0.0129012372,
0.0675389692,
0.0028193549,
0.0017890494,
-0.0384687856,
-0.0229745787,
0.0809652954,
-0.0750583857,
-0.0484856814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13267v1 | ArchiSound: Audio Generation with Diffusion | 2023-01-30T20:23:26 | 2023-01-30T20:23:26 | Flavio Schneider | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | The recent surge in popularity of diffusion models for image generation has
brought new attention to the potential of these models in other areas of media
generation. One area that has yet to be fully explored is the application of
diffusion models to audio generation. Audio generation requires an
understanding of multiple aspects, such as the temporal dimension, long term
structure, multiple layers of overlapping sounds, and the nuances that only
trained listeners can detect. In this work, we investigate the potential of
diffusion models for audio generation. We propose a set of models to tackle
multiple aspects, including a new method for text-conditional latent audio
diffusion with stacked 1D U-Nets, that can generate multiple minutes of music
from a textual description. For each model, we make an effort to maintain
reasonable inference speed, targeting real-time on a single consumer GPU. In
addition to trained models, we provide a collection of open source libraries
with the hope of simplifying future work in the field. Samples can be found at
https://bit.ly/audio-diffusion. Codes are at
https://github.com/archinetai/audio-diffusion-pytorch. | [
-0.0332476161,
0.0358484499,
0.0121333469,
0.0099260742,
-0.0128206192,
-0.0347183123,
0.0637277067,
-0.0515989624,
-0.0930387154,
0.0218903963,
-0.0019181449,
-0.0484597087,
-0.0096950755,
0.0258955639,
0.0141766025,
-0.0730672032,
-0.0191486254,
-0.0311574526,
-0.0410512313,
-0.0209558383,
-0.0230336003,
-0.0019439451,
-0.0257160626,
-0.0005101294,
-0.0127793346,
-0.0183628406,
-0.0368583724,
0.0079634236,
0.0203557145,
-0.0137383528,
-0.0321363211,
0.0473404489,
0.0495688468,
0.0029642056,
0.0000021603,
0.0284764208,
0.0055231028,
0.0179641061,
0.0639057681,
0.0231330991,
0.0399320498,
0.0194201004,
-0.04813914,
-0.0047845473,
-0.0027697959,
0.010361108,
0.0251666028,
0.0139974775,
0.0577239357,
0.0184810907,
-0.0186047722,
-0.0731866658,
-0.0273146089,
-0.0499948002,
0.0606672019,
-0.0106928265,
0.0126211783,
-0.0101808868,
0.0225043297,
-0.0245916843,
-0.0212289225,
0.037128821,
0.0515880138,
0.0270553976,
0.0776957646,
0.0865039229,
0.004903045,
-0.0478168987,
-0.0015034153,
0.0691211894,
0.0134048816,
0.0030667444,
0.027858004,
-0.0041524624,
-0.0098591559,
0.0022931511,
-0.0319760442,
0.0048776413,
-0.0040981728,
0.0093005328,
-0.0730545223,
-0.0000333868,
0.0537077077,
-0.0289756749,
0.0278586186,
0.000894479,
0.0485336296,
-0.015312748,
-0.0175486989,
-0.0114696985,
0.0202836394,
-0.062341176,
0.0429065116,
0.0134917805,
0.0262934677,
-0.0310440622,
-0.0437372997,
-0.0472513959,
-0.0102314074,
-0.0011054283,
0.0424086675,
0.0012461275,
-0.0003172136,
0.0679357722,
-0.0375794917,
-0.0306311622,
-0.059931878,
-0.0672305971,
-0.0380556732,
0.0225224532,
0.0041689989,
0.0045111841,
-0.0364137478,
-0.0093165133,
0.0154534131,
-0.0479883291,
-0.0465663187,
-0.0128068905,
-0.0217598304,
0.0077094678,
0.017528234,
0.0581589155,
-0.0479685962,
-0.0120926667,
0.033346232,
0.0116133327,
-0.037262395,
0.04786928,
0.0418324806,
0.0409501418,
-0.0394561961,
0.0202745646,
0.0533518419,
-0.0097076409,
0.0477133989,
0.0234588683,
-0.0201504119,
0.0190639943,
-0.0197907388,
-0.0297883172,
-0.0279876292,
-0.0400552936,
0.0018059104,
-0.1197300255,
0.0120746642,
-0.0533815399,
-0.0144356405,
0.0232039262,
0.0034699636,
0.0141425347,
0.019462537,
0.0089702858,
0.0030011067,
0.0498270206,
0.0439348705,
0.0182640608,
0.008350227,
0.002663689,
0.0768293664,
0.0634839833,
-0.0157109909,
-0.0243717004,
-0.0119382907,
0.0327688456,
0.0483060367,
0.0184819382,
-0.0274615306,
-0.071673125,
-0.0681051686,
0.0860686675,
0.069523789,
0.0526621677,
-0.0336767919,
-0.0287913568,
0.0634838492,
0.0192065034,
-0.007736525,
0.0369889513,
0.1041992381,
0.0158050247,
-0.0407321677,
0.0128970575,
0.0759045929,
0.0657669231,
0.0545396358,
0.0235107113,
0.0813103765,
0.0227157157,
-0.0365710445,
-0.0224294476,
0.0448483154,
-0.0384819098,
0.03294589,
-0.0182570443,
0.0388695113,
0.0604728758,
-0.0426788107,
0.0412056893,
-0.0169162676,
-0.0638774931,
0.0000114082,
-0.0044398676,
0.0642499998,
0.071068421,
0.0308257025,
-0.0164279267,
0.0334931351,
-0.0185483303,
0.0019736046,
0.0515688695,
-0.0130319651,
-0.0142357768,
0.0336944759,
-0.0277308878,
0.0067956573,
-0.0076297862,
-0.0068554888,
0.0463186167,
-0.0296989698,
0.0323568732,
0.004326636,
-0.0276437309,
0.0120346891,
-0.0059595862,
-0.0707053542,
-0.0070022,
0.0413107909,
0.0081290202,
0.0266373139,
0.0094986781,
-0.0322324224,
0.0154554723,
0.0049188244,
-0.0402449891,
-0.0334740132,
0.0046840045,
-0.0642852485,
0.0012264163,
0.0020312206,
-0.0439801924,
0.0215815473,
0.0113040665,
0.0051492499,
-0.0257728063,
0.0869463235,
0.0160580762,
0.004566303,
-0.0005649669,
-0.0103716189,
0.0338126533,
0.0195458569,
0.0254104715,
0.0301312562,
0.0032017217,
0.0057174983,
-0.0079953074,
0.024697924,
0.0092325034,
-0.0117511135,
-0.0010522539,
0.0077682505,
-0.0070255795,
-0.0262818299,
-0.0327307954,
-0.0364721231,
-0.0430162624,
-0.0184395742,
-0.0595206358,
0.0274511073,
-0.0259481762,
-0.0200969651,
0.0094674733,
-0.0022342047,
-0.0065464065,
0.0147501919,
-0.0199127011,
-0.0101302667,
-0.0101478109,
-0.0001417605,
-0.0390458629,
-0.0028785733,
-0.0323821269,
-0.0221565682,
-0.0213386659,
0.0441111326,
-0.0011545977,
-0.017488569,
-0.0431398451,
0.0251887981,
-0.0035592117,
-0.0108589008,
0.0131533947,
-0.0085169934,
0.0176620577,
-0.0084641939,
0.0264249798,
0.0884983018,
0.0392635502,
0.0099927168,
0.0260262135,
0.0333768651,
-0.0333902463,
0.0321411155,
0.0167437624,
-0.0107902149,
0.0681791455,
-0.0262478013,
0.0008443099,
-0.0456395969,
0.0279548578,
0.084400475,
-0.0197457504,
0.0004271457,
-0.0130022904,
-0.0304006096,
-0.0261108093,
0.0122245681,
-0.0480179861,
0.0122529389,
0.0169037934,
-0.020013826,
-0.0477312915,
0.0469769873,
-0.0392195471,
-0.0186118484,
-0.0223332159,
-0.0857788026,
-0.0220967978,
0.0214754157,
-0.0027286531,
0.0338493921,
-0.0132394657,
-0.0058063804,
-0.0323648453,
0.0352975726,
0.0450677797,
-0.0616454296,
-0.0299777165,
-0.0231072176,
-0.0050523425,
-0.0076252995,
-0.0095333206,
-0.0246644523,
-0.0413164869,
0.0313931964,
-0.0038962362,
-0.0589785278,
-0.0183449183,
-0.0005114502,
0.012005928,
0.0105409054,
0.0457121693,
0.0012212511,
-0.0061343946,
-0.0219257772,
0.0703628734,
0.0405352488,
-0.0361738764,
-0.0360568427,
-0.0734485313,
0.040568307,
0.0261644796,
0.0112395501,
0.0084095001,
-0.0699770898,
0.0158805139,
-0.0290234052,
0.0099781612,
-0.0242469143,
0.0440839492,
0.0495839305,
-0.0583050922,
-0.0002923715,
0.0633324236,
0.0114759011,
-0.0196492411,
0.0266078543,
0.043900121,
0.0546567068,
-0.0039783893,
-0.0295521952,
-0.0338639691,
-0.0019364208,
0.0216787532,
0.0330931097,
0.0246924162,
-0.0021822855,
-0.0132188434,
-0.0217463579,
0.0911193341,
0.0367341079,
-0.0111266291,
0.004664361,
-0.0258879047,
-0.0179814026,
0.0325632989,
-0.0040546423,
-0.0134582492,
0.0221566819,
0.0285732411,
0.0271461159,
0.0099646812,
-0.0306474995,
-0.008538302,
-0.0567244999,
0.0154628726,
0.0707913265,
0.0475383848,
-0.047282014,
-0.0739150047,
0.0105810054,
0.0242600124,
-0.0132557331,
0.0416002832,
0.0284975227,
0.0317407735,
0.0221360568,
0.006836276,
0.0584794655,
-0.0316017568,
-0.0202954467,
0.0218331087,
0.0248477776,
-0.0116239823,
-0.0529051162,
-0.0432559252,
0.0527740531,
0.0473693758,
0.0439947918,
0.0292192288,
-0.046658434,
-0.0285699628,
-0.002177676,
0.0088506304,
-0.0562636442,
-0.0323239639,
-0.0200538673,
0.0235937368,
-0.0826116949,
-0.04740059,
0.0001471388,
-0.0373148136,
0.0323867723,
-0.0018074814,
0.0413005613,
0.0052048555,
-0.0552163273,
-0.0704989508,
0.0060463487,
0.0127532445,
0.0491773225,
-0.0064085787,
-0.0428992659,
0.0014101568,
-0.0409947447,
-0.0284851324,
0.0483038388,
-0.1430759877,
-0.0265866071,
-0.0372834317,
-0.0219309945,
0.0173118208,
0.0404510498,
-0.0017989947,
-0.0047842683,
0.0712099075,
-0.0108230691,
0.0437741056,
0.0634785518,
0.0155985439,
-0.0399725735,
0.0087496387,
-0.0009381809,
-0.0603750944,
0.0724277645,
-0.0372671187,
0.0262688734,
0.0248899795,
0.0145374853,
0.0121957064,
-0.0935877562,
0.005473698,
-0.0114750611,
0.0531018823,
-0.0728494301,
-0.0167352464,
-0.0117387129,
0.0031893947,
-0.0484683104,
-0.0027424281,
0.0733883008,
0.0302833356,
-0.0322447456,
-0.0169548374,
0.0676317513,
-0.00493972,
-0.0291893464,
0.0074268491,
0.020787647,
-0.0442183688,
0.0210657045,
-0.0327044688,
0.0504269227,
-0.0259393714,
-0.0283711255,
0.0094430624,
0.0333063491,
0.0080936253,
0.0108996825,
0.0061945268,
-0.005029053,
-0.0011465194,
-0.0422188267,
-0.0072177779,
-0.0456320308,
0.0179861691,
0.0557739548,
-0.0045708586,
0.0487844944,
0.0030814272,
0.0043165963,
-0.0272702705,
0.0391605273,
-0.0249556284,
-0.0359833241,
0.0187364537,
-0.0002960583,
-0.0028270085,
0.0368593484,
0.0632091761,
-0.0356884077,
0.0128451837,
-0.0099742087,
0.0015899335,
0.0032609068,
-0.0072209095,
-0.074483417,
0.0037287539,
0.0173965488,
0.0228741579,
0.0029810451,
-0.0486405268,
-0.0085329227,
0.0122961365,
0.0101808254,
-0.0030215436,
0.048123125,
0.0459807105,
-0.0229544658,
0.0399840623,
-0.0107077435,
-0.0087317806,
-0.0315257013,
-0.0405105427,
0.0031564815,
-5.991750009e-33,
-0.0368380137,
-0.0104509313,
0.0132836765,
-0.0234918743,
-0.054551214,
-0.0329784192,
-0.0584208965,
-0.0082014026,
0.0253141746,
0.0215030704,
0.0204996821,
0.0597470514,
0.0011225438,
0.0368688181,
-0.0002695821,
0.0153449681,
0.0724726319,
-0.0179396011,
-0.0167214684,
0.0508944616,
0.0322267748,
0.0330715775,
-0.0125408098,
-0.0268959533,
-0.0555361062,
-0.0302547514,
-0.0238162782,
-0.0377109051,
0.000131473,
-0.0045719375,
-0.0390750431,
-0.0110174492,
-0.0214385986,
-0.0086347163,
-0.019961454,
0.0096225701,
-0.0479210094,
-0.0109526403,
-0.0297026988,
-0.013091282,
-0.0874954388,
-0.0314845555,
0.0789717063,
0.028588172,
-0.0069804639,
0.0043852562,
0.0628889427,
-0.0093108406,
-0.0295075681,
-0.0830361694,
-0.0549698584,
0.0307902135,
-0.0343536995,
-0.0369199999,
0.030400157,
0.0251366049,
-0.0131081603,
0.0193587691,
-0.0766442269,
0.0484686084,
-0.0035762428,
0.0429977104,
0.0692912117,
-0.0043133139,
0.0151888374,
0.0611259528,
0.037171986,
-0.036723569,
0.0025249526,
0.0328214951,
-0.0174228363,
0.0549842417,
-0.0141637437,
-0.0557099469,
0.0464828536,
-0.0378685817,
-0.0313796364,
0.0198551565,
-0.0445151702,
-0.0342288166,
0.0579247773,
0.070511274,
-0.0019402034,
0.0109561402,
-0.0262118578,
-0.017925648,
-0.0096346913,
-0.0409758165,
0.0238258131,
0.0202898011,
0.0253751595,
-0.0562243424,
-0.0018570618,
0.0087616667,
0.0055378317,
-0.0224503707,
-0.0645893738,
0.0258049145,
0.0228020605,
-0.0086628953,
-0.0205229111,
0.0138138877,
0.0652621463,
0.003333376,
0.0147806825,
0.0268576462,
-0.0205315389,
0.0791075975,
-0.0274175219,
-0.0132960696,
-0.0168983079,
0.0261417553,
0.025810726,
0.0440787487,
0.0172124337,
-0.0029791594,
-0.0491136089,
0.0405695289,
-0.0346310996,
0.029733628,
-0.0223452151,
-0.0135936616,
-0.0373164676,
0.0041715237,
-0.0476618521,
0.0265686996,
-0.0278059356,
0.0190336686,
0.0734706447,
-0.0471255556,
-0.0567504093,
0.0425606072,
2.988e-7,
-0.0403424501,
-0.0041232347,
-0.0150536662,
0.0067922133,
0.0357029513,
0.007052761,
-0.0541357324,
-0.000173634,
-0.0199584588,
-0.0392046422,
0.0483728647,
0.0191587862,
0.0556692854,
0.0378247723,
-0.1026945338,
0.0070541785,
-0.0645129383,
0.0102355853,
-0.0050047948,
-0.0473239943,
0.0048363502,
0.0528235734,
0.0247810688,
-0.0399506576,
0.0721838996,
0.0022804651,
0.0652395487,
0.0227604471,
0.0195913408,
-0.0678817853,
0.0161578059,
-0.0270274691,
-0.0065112314,
-0.0244736355,
-0.0256176163,
0.0044055851,
0.0688687712,
0.0264239162,
0.0028258541,
-0.0553563759,
0.0009657659,
0.0309605952,
-0.0024265612,
-0.0023134511,
0.0481113419,
0.0156148318,
-0.0406542271,
-0.0546938963,
-0.0492748693,
0.0228447206,
0.0021184722,
0.0232030395,
-0.0063758637,
-0.0502017215,
0.0201927163,
0.0127100637,
-0.0073431786,
-0.0311243869,
0.0062273103,
0.0174241643,
-0.0587439947,
-0.045018848,
-0.0463419631,
0.0037520698,
-0.0009302628,
-0.0143487183,
-0.039063938,
2.216224014e-34,
0.0498426668,
-0.0436081551,
0.0019834694,
-0.0315409005,
-0.0034306445,
0.0147877494,
-0.0339277163,
-0.0298983213,
-0.0216353294,
-0.0252572671,
-0.0585227571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13155v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13155v2 | Advancing Radiograph Representation Learning with Masked Record Modeling | 2023-01-30T18:33:32 | 2023-02-15T07:33:35 | Hong-Yu Zhou, Chenyu Lian, Liansheng Wang, Yizhou Yu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Modern studies in radiograph representation learning rely on either
self-supervision to encode invariant semantics or associated radiology reports
to incorporate medical expertise, while the complementarity between them is
barely noticed. To explore this, we formulate the self- and report-completion
as two complementary objectives and present a unified framework based on masked
record modeling (MRM). In practice, MRM reconstructs masked image patches and
masked report tokens following a multi-task scheme to learn knowledge-enhanced
semantic representations. With MRM pre-training, we obtain pre-trained models
that can be well transferred to various radiography tasks. Specifically, we
find that MRM offers superior performance in label-efficient fine-tuning. For
instance, MRM achieves 88.5% mean AUC on CheXpert using 1% labeled data,
outperforming previous R$^2$L methods with 100% labels. On NIH ChestX-ray, MRM
outperforms the best performing counterpart by about 3% under small labeling
ratios. Besides, MRM surpasses self- and report-supervised pre-training in
identifying the pneumonia type and the pneumothorax area, sometimes by large
margins. | [
0.0054712272,
0.0530443192,
0.0188784264,
-0.0084417555,
0.0040447423,
0.0300740991,
0.019225724,
0.024378296,
0.003340937,
-0.0204658322,
-0.0463525765,
-0.01543009,
-0.019358255,
0.0436235927,
0.0087704733,
-0.07620994,
0.0326262675,
0.0000759941,
0.0158300381,
-0.0040471186,
-0.0326270536,
-0.0022071353,
-0.0043077366,
0.0322688445,
-0.048912473,
-0.0084045716,
0.027428817,
0.0124384072,
0.0274227709,
-0.0325033814,
0.0179981999,
0.0547058545,
0.0290141813,
0.0058633522,
0.0000022437,
-0.0283657108,
-0.0248222332,
0.0332477428,
-0.0388422571,
-0.0126145147,
0.0591625534,
-0.0504667759,
0.0229778532,
-0.0316267386,
-0.0369626842,
-0.0758596882,
0.0423501991,
0.079387024,
0.0695855841,
0.0461795926,
-0.0183416847,
0.0284611713,
-0.0255869869,
-0.0719405338,
0.0249516945,
-0.0407932326,
0.0296962112,
-0.0033332468,
-0.0367764272,
0.0078038778,
-0.047891058,
0.0622720793,
0.0071158013,
0.0223764889,
0.0449345261,
0.0584520362,
0.0200027302,
0.012956881,
0.0152209345,
0.0194105022,
-0.0644784495,
0.0057828496,
-0.0207676124,
-0.0119018732,
-0.0194756463,
-0.00446284,
-0.0104591995,
-0.0190784298,
0.0144942477,
-0.0055292733,
-0.0589386746,
0.0196646769,
0.0186685901,
-0.0119784409,
-0.0198651757,
-0.0332750492,
-0.0309329033,
0.0295519903,
0.0154233724,
0.0126186442,
-0.0342036858,
-0.0256013349,
0.0139158899,
0.0216048714,
-0.0314078964,
0.0064622555,
-0.0190318618,
-0.0149883078,
0.0428399742,
0.0168267656,
-0.0264078602,
-0.0265342407,
-0.0702619553,
0.0843228474,
-0.0292516947,
0.0237750728,
-0.0357007831,
0.1049008369,
-0.0180549826,
-0.0032916858,
-0.0190877523,
-0.0120654441,
-0.0412039421,
0.0637424737,
0.0391026624,
0.0029575008,
-0.0543381348,
-0.0263188276,
-0.0360945538,
0.0308734365,
0.0523282513,
0.0503635257,
-0.0901860371,
0.0072647985,
-0.0075176442,
0.0250774994,
0.023463171,
-0.0004355304,
-0.019609509,
0.0579447374,
-0.0166359134,
-0.0014592936,
0.0134190125,
0.0036210965,
0.0180951711,
0.0171172861,
-0.0068188887,
-0.0069176327,
0.0199654158,
-0.0399615914,
-0.0257909764,
-0.0220690351,
0.0344749838,
-0.0572767816,
0.0471953824,
-0.0034112006,
0.0398876332,
-0.0419292748,
-0.0121030882,
-0.0395649336,
-0.0267926734,
0.094948113,
-0.0212369338,
-0.0310021508,
0.0194521584,
0.0625485852,
-0.021180734,
0.0043738936,
0.0123839919,
0.0068656523,
-0.0179550461,
0.0002576887,
0.0137619507,
-0.0141819119,
0.0322134979,
-0.0514095686,
0.0306097921,
-0.0200995803,
0.0470128059,
0.0347558483,
0.0393179357,
0.0109751802,
-0.0046778349,
-0.0843404382,
0.0147023639,
-0.0115158176,
0.0287406426,
-0.0220667757,
0.0137273986,
0.0023878105,
-0.0195285715,
0.0332509503,
-0.014503181,
0.0590531118,
0.0418247394,
-0.0151314279,
-0.0273782331,
-0.0264938418,
-0.0656384379,
-0.0463403612,
0.0090430202,
-0.0180561207,
-0.0236779787,
0.0149656869,
0.0448221005,
0.0213051252,
-0.0186592676,
0.014171211,
0.0451059081,
0.0382551998,
-0.0050471472,
-0.0789536685,
-0.0159081593,
0.0239930861,
0.0343777686,
-0.0575916432,
-0.0232187659,
-0.0331575572,
0.0355289131,
-0.0135111315,
0.0090379259,
0.0014675409,
0.0671672076,
-0.036601048,
-0.0502087027,
-0.045087643,
0.0155268675,
0.0179038327,
-0.0063144141,
-0.0240454171,
0.0019610354,
-0.0527501889,
0.0236935895,
0.0306178704,
-0.0099924309,
-0.0578534789,
-0.011829867,
0.0470236801,
0.0162070021,
-0.0202314556,
-0.0237505678,
-0.0152539071,
0.0059295185,
-0.0127033591,
-0.0364015587,
-0.024768997,
-0.0788464621,
-0.0364758074,
0.0163764376,
-0.0636674911,
-0.0286286548,
0.0382087491,
-0.0442067608,
-0.0216464121,
-0.0300188065,
-0.0083468519,
0.013609794,
-0.018347742,
-0.010002994,
0.0518178158,
0.0070558619,
0.0098543577,
0.053530857,
-0.0141618326,
-0.0017093488,
-0.0042338134,
-0.0288663954,
-0.005924202,
-0.017448809,
-0.0334353447,
-0.0255033337,
-0.0064714104,
0.007254479,
0.0126501154,
0.0034175443,
0.0109433588,
-0.0046348111,
-0.0285782181,
-0.00994555,
0.0067693652,
-0.0747580528,
0.027231425,
0.0048332564,
0.0196373891,
-0.0556415878,
-0.0288347043,
-0.0517952107,
0.0163624585,
0.0166315567,
0.0354380496,
0.0403458253,
0.0153988563,
-0.0199315436,
-0.0063708513,
0.0156134479,
-0.0209010746,
0.0124340076,
-0.0548774078,
0.0126184439,
0.0242515076,
-0.004089294,
0.0257030874,
-0.0299088433,
-0.0177867841,
-0.0031501302,
-0.0490034781,
-0.0463846587,
0.0451970659,
-0.0362939276,
0.0278378595,
0.0359514132,
0.0077304291,
-0.0360126384,
0.024363298,
-0.0354738906,
-0.0541668423,
0.0158611517,
-0.0398079902,
-0.0149587877,
0.0415608026,
-0.0080073066,
0.0005777585,
-0.0330307968,
-0.0503129959,
-0.0182223506,
-0.0223999936,
-0.0634245574,
0.0168461595,
0.0141310319,
0.0017978086,
-0.0501647927,
-0.0387605131,
0.0849696174,
0.0206237119,
-0.0084616803,
-0.040039245,
-0.0132057685,
-0.0175269097,
0.046137508,
0.0273373406,
0.0556679107,
0.041631937,
-0.0292857569,
-0.0470841192,
0.0008704559,
0.0353922099,
-0.065097712,
-0.0317446813,
0.0045702644,
0.004324778,
0.0025968438,
-0.0310516749,
-0.0088927932,
-0.0462700166,
0.0259007104,
0.0114343036,
-0.0336094163,
0.0317929946,
-0.0415236913,
0.0397051163,
-0.0047783442,
0.0461478084,
0.0231289342,
-0.0154323699,
-0.0060364832,
0.0173959322,
0.0441007689,
0.0130346222,
-0.0439428054,
-0.0099612679,
0.0134309875,
0.0758639202,
0.0145229306,
0.04606824,
-0.0200108085,
0.0372926369,
-0.0151518313,
0.0185990762,
0.0106302965,
0.0170662217,
0.0388026275,
-0.0215824377,
0.0068156971,
0.0484722257,
0.020570077,
-0.0226508435,
-0.0415664501,
0.0319104828,
-0.0292539224,
0.0087026358,
-0.0035560774,
-0.0279551018,
0.0031379133,
-0.0103625469,
0.0224840976,
0.0079536196,
-0.0077655721,
0.0161012635,
-0.0334863253,
0.0768093243,
0.008126663,
-0.045745749,
-0.0285839178,
-0.0514540896,
0.0207317285,
-0.023808213,
-0.0309110861,
-0.0522158928,
0.0026583467,
-0.0392730236,
0.030675292,
-0.0124503328,
-0.044196412,
0.0244975872,
-0.0610010996,
-0.0115028787,
0.0112285353,
0.0063716765,
-0.0175934508,
-0.0405407548,
-0.0301152002,
0.0813825205,
0.0035543395,
0.008920772,
0.1278201044,
-0.0344047397,
-0.0219838396,
-0.0306868162,
0.0172594097,
0.0147377746,
-0.02769465,
-0.0430290364,
0.0551993102,
0.004023429,
0.0010412192,
-0.0578326695,
0.0216332767,
0.0432099029,
0.0217712019,
-0.0196383893,
0.0323101506,
-0.0296238754,
0.0067264205,
0.1301885396,
-0.0335387625,
-0.0107734129,
0.0787189454,
-0.0723419487,
-0.0504705012,
-0.0178799704,
0.0034019423,
0.0378400199,
0.0195385143,
-0.0066747651,
-0.0002579557,
-0.0140235685,
-0.0391328782,
-0.1042992249,
0.0198918954,
-0.0357548781,
-0.0171754416,
-0.0202673767,
-0.0715255439,
0.0533469282,
-0.0058694072,
-0.0040135905,
0.023163205,
-0.0416091569,
0.0174900647,
0.0167753957,
0.0730609074,
0.0166687593,
0.042261526,
0.0046349373,
-0.016166484,
0.0889899358,
0.0305953845,
-0.072823301,
0.0083071114,
0.0300043654,
-0.0847539827,
-0.0630113259,
0.0136813046,
-0.0322562903,
0.0519344956,
0.0250245966,
0.0117395483,
-0.0350599587,
0.0012473767,
0.0402640887,
-0.0084943715,
0.060575515,
-0.0237152074,
0.0360665955,
-0.0356842726,
0.0024221179,
-0.005158707,
0.0166064557,
-0.0139395269,
0.0023801248,
0.0355150774,
0.0152832866,
-0.0115500791,
0.0636570528,
-0.0244898405,
0.0364533514,
-0.0366023257,
-0.0246166326,
-0.0386115611,
-0.0320163295,
0.0205163732,
0.0252561141,
-0.0243566893,
-0.0179081652,
0.0772313252,
0.0015188636,
0.0282737743,
0.0150744049,
0.0280105416,
0.0781832561,
-0.0546582974,
0.0085846893,
-0.0353278629,
-0.05082139,
-0.0431960635,
0.0021110424,
0.0514847636,
-0.0151607739,
-0.0347018354,
-0.0298781805,
-0.0191018116,
-0.0037184951,
0.0442913435,
0.0032348889,
0.0183432177,
0.0859141126,
-0.0035157786,
0.0342972092,
0.0142715909,
0.0851035491,
0.0228097122,
0.0517259687,
-0.0347983092,
-0.0397567339,
-0.0681697428,
-0.0147696007,
0.02575491,
0.0373474881,
-0.0203606077,
0.0183111504,
-0.0169067252,
-0.0648806766,
0.010092156,
-0.0380177014,
-0.0263255667,
-0.0063601057,
0.0393282361,
0.035537824,
0.0295673106,
-0.0565164872,
-0.0120977815,
0.0265891422,
0.0325355045,
0.0195011776,
0.0548849776,
-6.29864036e-33,
-0.0236628354,
-0.008391791,
0.0292893276,
-0.0246045031,
0.0474873632,
0.0550604798,
-0.0240724403,
-0.0309431162,
0.0039754654,
0.0257760808,
-0.0190676097,
-0.0084844762,
0.0143645722,
0.0190014411,
-0.0058741276,
-0.0051457193,
0.077505514,
-0.016615469,
0.0089939907,
0.0174175538,
-0.0230553392,
0.0118702855,
0.0280561,
-0.1350264549,
-0.047598362,
0.0201761276,
0.0016973064,
-0.0230900366,
-0.0035955084,
0.0448683091,
-0.0437407605,
0.0019595074,
0.0278654788,
-0.0661764815,
-0.0201625377,
0.0222819317,
-0.1460505277,
-0.0246966146,
-0.0257333852,
0.0088528572,
-0.0571622849,
-0.0145745138,
0.0106219202,
0.0015282714,
0.051260598,
-0.0584485903,
0.0359290652,
0.0106458329,
-0.002625417,
-0.0149813993,
-0.0045154886,
0.041378364,
0.003133439,
-0.0349061303,
0.0374620482,
-0.0306933224,
0.0130641367,
0.0234530848,
-0.083031565,
-0.0229282435,
0.0165640805,
0.0328651294,
0.0100261997,
0.019070195,
-0.0349143296,
0.0493673533,
0.0705141053,
-0.0049591172,
0.0105697559,
0.0316438563,
-0.0159354303,
0.0626204163,
0.0071255071,
0.0176634975,
0.0450536869,
-0.018310219,
-0.0715018809,
0.0210970212,
-0.0845322683,
0.053044457,
-0.0002040718,
0.0154732047,
-0.0267487541,
-0.0202991832,
-0.0087740887,
0.0240481906,
-0.0185552761,
0.0027269474,
0.0312148929,
0.0557377115,
-0.0280787982,
0.0888783932,
0.010780111,
0.0089026969,
-0.0081035858,
-0.0499644168,
0.0491676182,
0.0181292892,
-0.0243608449,
0.0173942037,
0.0014371887,
-0.0277288929,
0.074424997,
0.0030976622,
0.0388520211,
0.0190552417,
0.0708017275,
0.0322971418,
-0.0517292246,
-0.0150222229,
-0.0152030056,
0.0125614442,
-0.0096787028,
-0.0240718145,
0.031565167,
0.0235361457,
-0.017269481,
0.0384474136,
-0.0259012561,
0.0055226525,
-0.0214865617,
0.0008398002,
-0.0148634827,
0.0197200999,
-0.0262825359,
-0.0235714614,
-0.031746719,
-0.041968178,
0.0930803865,
-0.0234979801,
-0.0400599875,
0.007145009,
2.916e-7,
0.0567112677,
-0.0128389569,
0.0332473591,
-0.0106456932,
-0.0147727672,
0.0156554393,
-0.0472601652,
0.0349369869,
0.0378353596,
-0.0282110292,
0.024857359,
0.0230245013,
-0.0149371792,
0.0440461114,
-0.0545839705,
-0.0263786633,
0.0132905953,
0.030563511,
-0.0126212407,
0.004016709,
0.0669000968,
0.0650605932,
0.0035265626,
-0.0348685943,
0.0128036058,
-0.0146501446,
0.0615016967,
-0.032980565,
0.0361403488,
0.0099852597,
-0.0070359861,
0.0633925721,
-0.0023225902,
0.0579410531,
-0.0030373882,
-0.0238982625,
0.0692879111,
0.07905633,
-0.0400475115,
-0.0295399837,
-0.0104429796,
0.0346711986,
0.00022816,
-0.010012174,
0.0489635542,
-0.0617696717,
-0.0148295546,
-0.0094083287,
-0.0647565648,
0.0441393144,
0.0445933267,
-0.0282645766,
-0.0078435009,
0.0325455032,
0.0286412835,
0.0433680154,
-0.055046387,
-0.1001194939,
-0.0191346016,
0.0201391391,
-0.0146826813,
0.0054980367,
0.0226503853,
-0.0220510364,
0.0158661325,
-0.0814470053,
-0.0213076491,
2.320777349e-34,
0.0063844272,
0.0021976957,
-0.0097330837,
-0.0155408438,
-0.0018420181,
-0.0219935123,
-0.0122826966,
0.0236970596,
0.0151882758,
-0.0050058737,
-0.0335804857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13154v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13154v2 | Protein Representation Learning via Knowledge Enhanced Primary Structure Modeling | 2023-01-30T18:33:15 | 2023-02-15T07:26:47 | Hong-Yu Zhou, Yunxiang Fu, Zhicheng Zhang, Cheng Bian, Yizhou Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.MM | Protein representation learning has primarily benefited from the remarkable
development of language models (LMs). Accordingly, pre-trained protein models
also suffer from a problem in LMs: a lack of factual knowledge. The recent
solution models the relationships between protein and associated knowledge
terms as the knowledge encoding objective. However, it fails to explore the
relationships at a more granular level, i.e., the token level. To mitigate
this, we propose Knowledge-exploited Auto-encoder for Protein (KeAP), which
performs token-level knowledge graph exploration for protein representation
learning. In practice, non-masked amino acids iteratively query the associated
knowledge tokens to extract and integrate helpful information for restoring
masked amino acids via attention. We show that KeAP can consistently outperform
the previous counterpart on 9 representative downstream applications, sometimes
surpassing it by large margins. These results suggest that KeAP provides an
alternative yet effective way to perform knowledge enhanced protein
representation learning. | [
0.0411720909,
0.0355025008,
0.0153810475,
-0.0014884153,
0.0008289295,
-0.0050206832,
0.0058472641,
-0.0013655503,
0.0318535417,
-0.0369585082,
0.0049554338,
-0.0188561566,
-0.0011826751,
0.0933091268,
0.0127874753,
0.0179233644,
0.0218182914,
0.0204073414,
0.0277568195,
-0.0163304191,
-0.0128860679,
-0.0001912208,
0.0490714684,
0.0057568704,
-0.0036875119,
0.0020374095,
-0.030827513,
-0.0320049785,
0.0114671588,
-0.0279436149,
-0.0037002731,
0.0177219324,
0.0220205169,
-0.0042024595,
0.0000018896,
-0.0176126212,
-0.0165503286,
-0.0037753605,
-0.0635080785,
0.0325890779,
-0.0312952958,
-0.0339768007,
0.0317819826,
-0.0422523692,
0.0047737886,
0.016126452,
0.0830592662,
0.024495041,
0.0280814059,
0.0359770283,
-0.0024310218,
-0.0549122579,
0.0313466266,
-0.0333771482,
0.0416340828,
-0.0187309962,
0.0689607933,
0.0026254368,
-0.0504112542,
0.0036904567,
-0.0116965594,
0.0509034842,
-0.0122918691,
-0.0073624849,
0.0798766091,
0.0356581137,
-0.0157058649,
-0.0590594523,
0.0174887534,
0.089334622,
-0.0418763235,
-0.0172415525,
-0.0574641116,
-0.0244578421,
-0.0059661218,
-0.0022403877,
-0.0027773061,
-0.0300590098,
0.0122019248,
0.0530445389,
-0.009776785,
0.0011610307,
0.0492327437,
-0.0422455296,
-0.0507955588,
0.0190806631,
-0.0268401094,
-0.000421951,
-0.036669109,
-0.0433679484,
-0.0638452619,
-0.0024357983,
0.0307693705,
0.0221558399,
0.085529834,
0.0150831752,
0.0477029346,
-0.0453869477,
0.0293976385,
-0.0389825515,
-0.0057811523,
0.0317890868,
-0.0287184361,
0.0285910312,
-0.04933732,
0.0333387516,
0.01028594,
0.0462107956,
-0.0244862735,
0.0030474688,
-0.0636455342,
-0.0243464056,
-0.0481231473,
0.0457924493,
-0.021526562,
-0.0073346309,
-0.0162147004,
0.0174503196,
-0.0262607038,
-0.0005048147,
0.0013756043,
0.030788824,
-0.0066376459,
0.0295659099,
-0.0391488522,
0.0344323665,
0.0186702739,
-0.0376817696,
-0.010866899,
-0.023411762,
-0.0242543835,
-0.033763323,
0.0258200224,
-0.0106012542,
0.0006604905,
0.0981924161,
-0.0076016434,
-0.053727448,
-0.0025144899,
-0.0335122533,
-0.0302741826,
-0.0019278832,
-0.0106327441,
-0.0258994997,
0.0939274058,
0.0146906301,
-0.0049050902,
-0.0559329018,
0.0323341191,
-0.0367693678,
-0.0620555617,
0.1038095057,
-0.044463031,
-0.0370336473,
0.0168443117,
0.0248842016,
-0.0340995826,
-0.0199774485,
-0.0206927527,
0.0291753728,
-0.0337401107,
-0.0026261578,
-0.0123456931,
-0.023106819,
0.0545326993,
-0.0383132361,
0.030294396,
0.0113317259,
0.0407523438,
0.0153084639,
-0.0032300588,
-0.0196049567,
-0.0044048862,
-0.0217213761,
0.0267292131,
0.0477361418,
0.0183803327,
0.028930841,
-0.0002997928,
0.0574432835,
0.0044486145,
-0.0065862979,
-0.0365496799,
0.0285853799,
-0.0391485728,
0.0436339006,
0.0224633776,
-0.0158135928,
-0.0057188785,
-0.0181766525,
-0.0083529511,
-0.0001234985,
0.0200818982,
-0.0208647829,
0.0361358114,
0.004144148,
-0.0537745096,
0.0521529056,
0.0435522161,
-0.0109469071,
0.0162430927,
-0.0325832926,
0.0270532556,
0.0480585583,
0.0421551466,
-0.0987828448,
-0.009172312,
0.0260901749,
-0.0429325663,
0.0222253632,
-0.0027936238,
-0.0113071855,
0.0148205487,
-0.019614758,
-0.0216107611,
-0.0531875044,
0.0148131363,
0.0084341532,
-0.0543567277,
-0.0054324274,
0.0317156725,
-0.0254685972,
-0.0369920917,
0.0007268827,
0.0294644367,
-0.0422146581,
-0.0041837795,
0.0382663868,
0.0113479802,
0.0088112494,
0.0234505571,
0.049492158,
0.0480010808,
-0.0519259125,
-0.0061412165,
-0.039519418,
-0.0252191182,
-0.0596987531,
0.0602995157,
0.0057940055,
-0.0184312463,
-0.0097237751,
-0.0387711376,
-0.0442883596,
0.0471785627,
0.0158315264,
0.1113650501,
-0.009223897,
-0.015238666,
0.0107251536,
0.0364622287,
-0.0268262662,
0.0601299331,
-0.0041196756,
-0.000795479,
0.0015603836,
-0.0647772178,
0.0350579172,
-0.0074684024,
0.0242445488,
-0.0009643875,
0.0166389961,
0.0192915052,
0.0363578349,
-0.0300090481,
0.0107189016,
0.0146553656,
-0.0206925794,
-0.0316670649,
0.0071889833,
0.0150352307,
-0.004579802,
-0.0064012245,
0.0093462793,
-0.011785238,
-0.0620978288,
-0.0041841553,
-0.0747666582,
0.0037468257,
0.0274082441,
0.0300970469,
-0.0149394469,
-0.0313114338,
-0.0224975031,
-0.0387744717,
0.0845015272,
-0.0025774813,
-0.0740955025,
0.0459943973,
-0.0169943608,
-0.0102150645,
0.017178461,
-0.0158358719,
-0.0310690831,
-0.0098887123,
-0.0051257215,
-0.013936447,
-0.0152659724,
-0.0141853113,
0.0350872949,
0.0715556368,
0.0196345374,
-0.0181317199,
0.0122779766,
-0.0455120839,
0.0218880959,
-0.0021491575,
-0.0109421993,
0.0255346503,
0.0648383275,
0.0147185326,
-0.003008893,
-0.0624218993,
-0.0147239519,
0.0440249778,
-0.0183636304,
-0.0804961398,
-0.0121172098,
0.0100814234,
0.0169456396,
-0.0085134674,
-0.0175788384,
0.077580221,
-0.0164123327,
0.0338582955,
0.0044667628,
0.0413280651,
-0.0134405904,
0.0291665718,
0.0289163571,
0.0618821047,
0.0374828428,
-0.023052698,
0.0421176478,
0.0339842662,
0.0187522322,
-0.0380579084,
0.0016462998,
0.018814547,
-0.0217807814,
0.0240583047,
-0.0110162348,
-0.0091013694,
0.0715008527,
-0.0333534218,
0.055375278,
0.0550367273,
-0.025752252,
-0.0366443247,
0.0427258238,
-0.0113410605,
0.0108064283,
0.0185508467,
0.0173444487,
-0.0370065235,
0.0023369896,
-0.00419517,
-0.0425030291,
0.0143566402,
-0.0038028401,
0.0224483609,
0.0425144173,
-0.0255631134,
-0.0111764651,
0.0106600123,
0.0288279634,
-0.0019214601,
-0.0247618333,
0.0160512403,
-0.0029386994,
-0.0188480448,
-0.0261883847,
0.0047855321,
0.0670030639,
0.0425582752,
-0.0634525493,
0.0037558097,
-0.0054551796,
-0.0439550951,
-0.0059726601,
0.021000158,
-0.1135537997,
-0.0326803289,
-0.0349303782,
0.0349605717,
0.0079486035,
-0.0289541353,
0.0110815885,
-0.0115728583,
0.0384058543,
0.0377623215,
-0.048979748,
-0.0811171085,
-0.0841814801,
-0.041459918,
-0.0225839335,
0.0011966374,
0.0229043011,
0.0075163697,
0.0202283785,
0.0045373822,
-0.0074258321,
-0.0424102955,
0.0211011395,
-0.0165858101,
0.0116454139,
0.0557088777,
0.0361746922,
0.0366599001,
-0.0383372717,
-0.0050672474,
0.0197882,
0.0379555449,
-0.0057266173,
0.0522637032,
-0.0062110494,
-0.0451987721,
-0.0211053789,
-0.0051907725,
-0.0682171956,
-0.0648913682,
-0.0531457067,
0.0994099602,
0.0134532992,
-0.0028798967,
-0.03778781,
-0.0566594899,
-0.022928929,
0.0524615794,
0.0694723353,
0.0220566671,
-0.0372406319,
-0.0509639829,
0.0284780487,
-0.0277971011,
0.0135293612,
0.0239183698,
-0.0125084426,
-0.0060990551,
-0.0461629145,
0.0041992553,
0.064423807,
0.001389239,
-0.0134542277,
0.0019291479,
0.0199084207,
-0.0529106595,
-0.0980018377,
0.017795058,
0.0090260049,
-0.030693762,
-0.0357964933,
-0.0615974925,
0.0463320278,
-0.0297970492,
-0.0500271618,
0.0356988125,
0.0034103484,
-0.0830921754,
-0.0315935761,
0.057969287,
0.014622868,
0.0599081032,
-0.0103364997,
-0.0069282968,
0.0971139446,
0.0494302846,
-0.0107873091,
-0.0429614484,
0.0211324748,
-0.032564763,
-0.0329327807,
0.0129767405,
-0.0333699249,
-0.000681858,
-0.0024432281,
0.0344422087,
0.0289765149,
-0.0197695661,
0.0987623855,
0.0464801006,
0.0641911402,
0.0227952059,
0.0035191737,
-0.0369186066,
0.0116997063,
0.0107358405,
-0.0126207536,
-0.0220769979,
-0.0066555352,
0.0364288948,
-0.0331687741,
0.0069047809,
0.0106209824,
0.0012721377,
0.0210752226,
-0.0004683264,
-0.014969958,
0.0195802711,
-0.020734584,
0.0513207801,
-0.0476401038,
-0.0022117798,
0.0125434902,
-0.0195859242,
-0.000507846,
-0.0188302118,
-0.0486684628,
0.013210468,
0.0532080643,
-0.0662231073,
0.0108639421,
-0.0127742877,
-0.0534733273,
-0.0625891909,
-0.0350753032,
0.0478407592,
-0.0198799465,
0.0082974955,
-0.0013271824,
-0.0267522391,
-0.0074157352,
0.0199681837,
-0.0096398927,
-0.0362508483,
0.0643145666,
0.0199669544,
-0.0423538983,
-0.0333984718,
0.0964284763,
0.0389030389,
0.0653328076,
-0.0382235795,
-0.0697149336,
-0.0078941155,
0.0043112813,
-0.0281366315,
0.0608072057,
-0.0489784628,
0.0000105983,
-0.0395826362,
-0.0440468639,
0.0227500852,
-0.0310753882,
-0.0213297904,
0.0431523211,
0.0219774731,
0.0196446497,
0.0600743555,
-0.079399921,
-0.0176600534,
0.0346616544,
0.0126378303,
-0.0054525333,
0.0384387225,
-6.325162451e-33,
-0.0075436607,
-0.0139867449,
-0.0410514213,
0.0148404418,
0.0273477063,
0.0410845801,
-0.0643249452,
-0.0389295779,
0.0135156829,
0.0562958717,
0.0183131173,
-0.0231137518,
-0.0034738514,
-0.0383291729,
-0.0010054605,
0.0048901658,
0.0348514803,
0.0497316904,
0.0193548594,
0.0168628655,
0.0369312242,
0.04198239,
0.0696247295,
-0.002154845,
-0.0082323672,
0.0442651175,
0.0271199327,
-0.0289688706,
0.0079797776,
0.0184024982,
-0.0567649528,
0.0552769899,
-0.0087568965,
-0.0081210956,
-0.0399465375,
-0.0412508212,
-0.0875125006,
0.0016231209,
-0.0017119119,
-0.0072622811,
-0.0040693525,
-0.04119578,
0.0241856873,
0.0079785399,
0.0343785882,
0.0042779678,
0.0445132889,
-0.027270101,
-0.0626001507,
-0.0211910345,
-0.0270934124,
0.0151311131,
0.005864894,
0.0254789945,
0.0585321337,
-0.0122013008,
0.0519101098,
-0.0064457781,
-0.0495094508,
0.017565012,
0.0484751873,
0.0243774373,
0.0583153106,
0.0254661962,
0.0381656736,
0.0639066547,
-0.0003338832,
-0.0123512028,
-0.0126609234,
0.0307575837,
0.0140090883,
0.0541450419,
0.0211567022,
-0.0406369567,
0.0218160208,
-0.0499153733,
-0.0843855441,
0.0030455212,
-0.0587347299,
0.0119947977,
-0.029315047,
0.0415032879,
-0.0190248992,
-0.0352497809,
-0.0260972865,
-0.0099011548,
-0.0358148217,
-0.0264663529,
-0.0147082899,
-0.0253817663,
-0.0439316183,
0.0513812341,
-0.0105516864,
-0.0326432995,
-0.0258329008,
0.0579372384,
0.0020367454,
0.0185938701,
-0.0120781297,
0.0012389005,
-0.0499866195,
-0.0387491584,
0.0293748844,
-0.0515666045,
0.0047638407,
0.0012608113,
0.0398499519,
0.0358834192,
0.0015813273,
-0.0006140287,
-0.0808261707,
-0.0114427991,
0.0386301242,
0.0489333309,
0.0141137261,
0.0371969938,
-0.0124144498,
0.047776781,
0.0114617487,
-0.0051908274,
0.0054366048,
0.0880482346,
0.0202021524,
0.0505090393,
-0.0752076507,
-0.0405425653,
-0.039069172,
-0.001577328,
0.0443008058,
-0.0498585291,
-0.0469210856,
0.0173927806,
2.681e-7,
0.0784992874,
0.0347894281,
0.0505964011,
-0.0010777133,
-0.0206306949,
0.0441335663,
-0.0032628367,
0.0354797058,
-0.0360159837,
-0.0218158178,
0.0287492387,
-0.0103994319,
-0.0366247371,
0.0165935699,
-0.040651001,
-0.007760461,
-0.0289101116,
-0.0399801806,
-0.0429860391,
0.004776021,
0.0040298919,
0.0763261467,
0.0055673374,
0.0261565875,
0.0470704734,
-0.0576376356,
0.0489682704,
0.0120033203,
0.0339053199,
0.0287722927,
-0.0137155447,
0.0361542106,
-0.02502786,
0.0097084651,
-0.0502215922,
-0.0128866043,
0.0104933875,
0.0156605393,
-0.0602995902,
-0.0384318978,
0.0358540788,
-0.002904501,
0.0110339988,
-0.0289464369,
0.0366582237,
-0.0674591586,
-0.0153903076,
0.0134480391,
-0.0659310892,
0.006504802,
-0.0154266013,
0.0054019084,
0.0239140019,
0.0482596569,
-0.0105056548,
0.0148907341,
0.024535533,
-0.0681422725,
-0.0258051381,
-0.0130550237,
-0.0115504432,
0.0660771802,
-0.0570784248,
-0.0282271933,
0.0444949642,
-0.053268332,
-0.0093024876,
2.365129072e-34,
0.0559163988,
-0.0282350443,
-0.0243355334,
0.0730484352,
0.0074438159,
-0.0333230682,
-0.0151920142,
0.0163384452,
-0.0341608226,
-0.0524166115,
-0.0334942229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13126v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13126v3 | LEXTREME: A Multi-Lingual and Multi-Task Benchmark for the Legal Domain | 2023-01-30T18:05:08 | 2024-01-08T10:08:40 | Joel Niklaus, Veton Matoshi, Pooja Rani, Andrea Galassi, Matthias Stürmer, Ilias Chalkidis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2 | Lately, propelled by the phenomenal advances around the transformer
architecture, the legal NLP field has enjoyed spectacular growth. To measure
progress, well curated and challenging benchmarks are crucial. However, most
benchmarks are English only and in legal NLP specifically there is no
multilingual benchmark available yet. Additionally, many benchmarks are
saturated, with the best models clearly outperforming the best humans and
achieving near perfect scores. We survey the legal NLP literature and select 11
datasets covering 24 languages, creating LEXTREME. To provide a fair
comparison, we propose two aggregate scores, one based on the datasets and one
on the languages. The best baseline (XLM-R large) achieves both a dataset
aggregate score a language aggregate score of 61.3. This indicates that
LEXTREME is still very challenging and leaves ample room for improvement. To
make it easy for researchers and practitioners to use, we release LEXTREME on
huggingface together with all the code required to evaluate models and a public
Weights and Biases project with all the runs. | [
0.0383220427,
0.0595119596,
-0.0156716481,
0.0339204967,
-0.0614379011,
0.0104402499,
0.0175298452,
0.0234988108,
-0.0016993117,
-0.0657778084,
-0.044904273,
-0.0339583121,
-0.0193161741,
0.0034227837,
0.0115547674,
-0.0260421485,
0.0250129346,
0.0004966964,
0.0187256262,
-0.0074885543,
0.0148880119,
0.0144824162,
0.0000843856,
0.0358035043,
-0.0437888205,
-0.0029252346,
0.0326640606,
-0.0070741763,
0.0224321466,
0.0110759996,
0.0183822233,
0.0881638527,
-0.017995514,
0.0397102274,
0.0000017639,
-0.0680736378,
0.0069167116,
0.0056130192,
0.0050576064,
0.0032996766,
0.0501019023,
-0.0750449821,
-0.0415125638,
-0.0027671068,
-0.0548182949,
0.0001077811,
0.0166574772,
0.0508652478,
0.0391907319,
0.1064993963,
-0.0179100521,
-0.0521949269,
0.0681134462,
-0.0607315302,
-0.0386133082,
-0.0576320216,
0.0034668911,
0.0110010225,
0.0049646948,
-0.0310975462,
0.0090840459,
0.0316218399,
0.0505840108,
-0.0462382622,
-0.0436224453,
-0.0291713756,
-0.0526340827,
-0.0004605669,
-0.0244109277,
0.0480844416,
0.0100669414,
-0.017313052,
-0.0059302719,
0.0116612194,
0.0332909338,
0.0017205054,
-0.0204106215,
0.106874153,
0.0040376447,
0.0113993455,
0.0290262271,
0.0265965536,
0.0163828339,
0.0175333954,
-0.0050130594,
0.0470831469,
0.0289918687,
-0.0240637604,
0.0343431942,
0.0154058756,
-0.0009380252,
-0.0284185745,
0.0374589972,
0.0140188551,
-0.0560157187,
0.0255806334,
-0.0390156582,
-0.0345398411,
0.0634534433,
-0.0693190396,
0.0358169861,
0.0053156009,
-0.0211219639,
0.0728993714,
-0.0683405474,
0.0589017123,
-0.0069182226,
0.0073646796,
0.014012822,
-0.058042381,
-0.0288349222,
-0.0021752401,
-0.0444693454,
0.0446067825,
-0.0887279212,
0.0150938202,
-0.0362352207,
-0.0127202645,
-0.0333819054,
0.0147474874,
0.0356917605,
-0.0128373317,
-0.0145522961,
-0.0066802027,
-0.034958262,
-0.031628307,
-0.0467546359,
0.0239483509,
-0.0009113892,
-0.0384185687,
0.01798754,
0.00763939,
-0.0293200798,
-0.0383750275,
0.0052450798,
0.1124572232,
-0.0193647332,
-0.032236442,
-0.0038279726,
-0.0461348779,
-0.0287400465,
-0.0881888568,
-0.0159015171,
-0.071626544,
0.0272352733,
-0.0171554964,
0.0057960907,
-0.0570204929,
0.0098135211,
0.0416959263,
-0.0071623358,
0.0723175108,
0.0279837344,
-0.0319937542,
-0.0569535978,
0.0203890279,
0.0028087876,
0.0459278636,
0.008393473,
-0.0022067048,
0.051717788,
-0.0040465416,
0.0122102983,
0.0749450251,
-0.0053342716,
0.0233278386,
0.0193858799,
0.0080113495,
0.008191512,
0.0264584683,
0.0070107314,
0.0720539317,
-0.001899404,
-0.0240639597,
0.0258162916,
0.0521631837,
0.0288314205,
0.0257354062,
-0.0071715475,
-0.035004735,
0.0252729263,
-0.022393493,
-0.0556132309,
0.0181659758,
-0.0220450927,
-0.0012425455,
-0.076307103,
0.0361896008,
-0.0069686803,
-0.0367784202,
-0.0295756105,
-0.014988726,
0.01387267,
-0.0383892432,
0.0277262963,
0.0384956673,
-0.0184191428,
0.090023689,
0.0068581626,
-0.0743040964,
-0.0229671746,
-0.0029479661,
-0.0326150507,
0.0016310062,
0.0493873693,
-0.0244959164,
-0.0433417,
-0.038414184,
-0.0174957886,
0.0875995457,
0.0480256118,
-0.0135012111,
0.0137678478,
-0.0342102647,
-0.0189312343,
-0.0024476293,
0.0343527943,
-0.0093764514,
0.02724085,
0.0189331528,
0.0385814942,
-0.0652756244,
-0.0157497134,
0.0448222458,
-0.05021118,
-0.0171134882,
0.0259653181,
-0.0124370679,
0.0393871367,
0.0172301847,
-0.0010648951,
-0.0188344624,
0.0330807045,
-0.0374701321,
-0.0073528099,
0.0454984903,
0.0074469689,
-0.0365109257,
0.0665021539,
-0.0632815138,
-0.0339795947,
0.0425434522,
-0.032155741,
-0.0234857518,
-0.0276053119,
-0.0090583917,
0.0135086831,
-0.0515060052,
0.0101708518,
-0.0048787151,
0.0051883413,
-0.0221703146,
0.0480727479,
0.0079469215,
0.0068088705,
0.0153273959,
-0.0216755904,
0.0535616353,
-0.0118964352,
-0.0441588722,
-0.0012627827,
-0.040139623,
0.0081616221,
0.032117188,
0.035587661,
-0.0475896932,
-0.0484172739,
-0.0495478697,
0.0145222126,
-0.0399321578,
0.0128235305,
0.0076969909,
-0.0275496244,
0.0050347634,
-0.0059806705,
-0.0338698626,
-0.0086085293,
0.014887332,
-0.015425235,
0.0209906027,
-0.0431207865,
-0.0087111127,
-0.0231418349,
-0.0107227555,
-0.0155389952,
0.0161139891,
-0.0048365588,
-0.0308854077,
-0.0213838313,
0.0617981665,
0.0066068848,
-0.0015789653,
-0.0329527706,
-0.0083111813,
-0.0125730112,
0.0379512571,
0.0262507275,
0.02128442,
0.0192721281,
0.0059633222,
0.0068698963,
-0.011091521,
-0.0530560091,
-0.0052767615,
0.0138512477,
0.0019390115,
-0.0742023587,
-0.010973433,
0.0292279031,
0.032717403,
-0.0242226589,
-0.0049582771,
-0.0211657211,
-0.0085717868,
-0.032394737,
-0.0152437864,
0.001648866,
0.0186844133,
-0.0372932404,
0.0341157354,
-0.007048903,
-0.0388331525,
0.0429314189,
-0.0041888882,
0.0368197635,
-0.0385336056,
0.017264165,
-0.0520389788,
0.0907891244,
-0.0056840363,
0.0135568967,
-0.0164874215,
-0.0444530323,
0.0151328864,
0.0081894835,
0.0646722466,
-0.0328520499,
0.0963515565,
-0.0284316,
0.0495005175,
-0.0508054309,
-0.0634791553,
-0.0275699627,
-0.0323864073,
-0.0040681683,
0.0616102144,
0.0255929213,
-0.012382512,
-0.0448254608,
-0.0276352819,
-0.0168591943,
0.0101319728,
0.0187302232,
-0.0067054271,
-0.0200076606,
0.029942384,
0.0117436638,
0.0131684411,
0.0189593602,
-0.0113939233,
-0.0020704311,
0.0242373291,
0.0020463283,
0.0071410211,
0.0219150465,
0.0085518714,
0.0386094116,
-0.0645282865,
-0.0194152184,
0.0082602883,
0.0391096361,
-0.0299544819,
0.0177847259,
0.086085096,
0.0147553012,
-0.0130890524,
-0.0018657828,
0.0220391899,
0.0138666108,
0.0479623787,
0.0217477884,
-0.130354166,
-0.0123193292,
-0.0092889871,
-0.0344500616,
-0.0014793093,
-0.0230988488,
0.0067911055,
-0.0927393734,
0.0602957308,
-0.005663102,
-0.0378764682,
-0.0083575882,
-0.0149762807,
-0.0130336927,
-0.0493114404,
0.0488279238,
-0.0219706446,
-0.0299142525,
-0.0315165073,
-0.0070038624,
-0.0162138697,
-0.003751463,
0.0293028131,
-0.0779524967,
0.0539855137,
0.0244105253,
0.0392006524,
-0.0298764706,
-0.0340308547,
0.0168261435,
0.0268750302,
-0.0104809981,
-0.0019488062,
0.0315246396,
0.0255782362,
-0.0100304782,
-0.0413964055,
0.0287586171,
-0.0385649912,
-0.0335687585,
0.0161901023,
0.062192291,
0.0016349371,
0.0037341029,
0.0101552932,
-0.0182735156,
-0.0328506008,
0.058868818,
-0.0171707869,
0.0086884582,
-0.0322178267,
-0.0342866778,
-0.0295536593,
-0.0668146685,
-0.0517524406,
0.0074974811,
-0.0172846448,
-0.0177537873,
-0.0746483281,
-0.0374170765,
-0.0025506206,
0.061459437,
0.0273253452,
0.0172245968,
0.0278264619,
-0.045747932,
-0.051018998,
0.0277163647,
-0.0315086395,
0.0258522201,
-0.0330103561,
0.0253538042,
0.0162508115,
0.0355050564,
-0.0108835371,
0.0161292106,
-0.0292090587,
-0.0355224237,
0.0064417743,
0.0345905535,
0.0167572275,
-0.0202482641,
-0.0603665225,
-0.040238373,
0.0384001844,
0.045892328,
-0.0195415914,
-0.0118693216,
0.0656825453,
-0.0463333651,
-0.0232096035,
0.0240007062,
-0.0026786812,
-0.0020437003,
0.0385936201,
0.0431388803,
0.0023740754,
-0.008860941,
0.0274353679,
0.0562666394,
0.0151024815,
-0.02605295,
-0.0097570308,
-0.0182110723,
-0.0159162395,
-0.0413003154,
-0.017665647,
-0.0267361142,
-0.0019609844,
0.0417141877,
-0.0046463828,
-0.0311783683,
0.113717325,
-0.0145771615,
0.0016417202,
-0.060365282,
0.0517021976,
0.040693976,
-0.015853731,
-0.0002903978,
-0.0052943253,
0.0132795144,
0.0058053257,
0.0001778861,
0.0748580843,
-0.0224796385,
0.0312587209,
0.0107219229,
-0.0015418463,
0.0112555167,
0.035082493,
-0.0187988393,
0.0205263719,
0.0073993504,
0.0120332567,
0.079955101,
-0.0096165817,
0.060847152,
-0.0320880041,
-0.0089214714,
-0.0012857012,
0.0190709382,
0.0022786222,
-0.027844172,
0.0391862914,
-0.0018769853,
-0.0012461519,
0.0248390213,
0.0564742051,
-0.0178508926,
0.026996959,
0.0244638324,
0.0100172916,
-0.0412476659,
-0.047639668,
0.0082882307,
-0.0252008289,
-0.0327316262,
-0.0488917902,
-0.073084332,
-0.0401215367,
0.0096918466,
0.0011614183,
0.011622048,
0.014673504,
-0.0090812268,
0.0513929315,
0.0369872563,
-0.0197051782,
-0.0441499054,
0.002715175,
0.0062067201,
-0.0101691252,
-0.0251302905,
-5.768611059e-33,
-0.0273110569,
-0.0329900756,
0.0088462355,
0.0089709628,
-0.0087443283,
-0.0066397884,
0.0031625037,
-0.0005124273,
-0.0230450742,
0.0420808494,
-0.0263943877,
0.0105896974,
0.0250045992,
0.008615111,
0.0161951389,
-0.0193995312,
0.0020437241,
0.0131171113,
-0.0237109624,
-0.0043970076,
-0.0063807978,
0.0157761052,
0.0689374059,
-0.0813348591,
0.052310653,
0.0747570023,
-0.0297587924,
-0.0014081462,
-0.0688062385,
0.0779311284,
-0.0072778119,
0.0598545521,
0.0181734189,
-0.0850628689,
-0.0050913501,
0.0057024648,
-0.0827021971,
0.01455497,
0.0447908416,
0.020394817,
0.0206698962,
-0.0353030674,
0.0295466315,
-0.0137831159,
-0.0444975831,
-0.0154959764,
0.0307176188,
-0.0277348943,
-0.0184105858,
-0.0701807365,
-0.1134816408,
0.0535360575,
0.0015901297,
0.0290188398,
0.0388704538,
0.0154823978,
-0.0146998251,
0.0314152092,
-0.0736100748,
-0.0102048134,
-0.0419106819,
0.0060557234,
0.0570976436,
-0.0623365939,
-0.0224637445,
0.0656981319,
-0.0073573031,
0.0336145833,
-0.0160493217,
0.0038748553,
0.0359732732,
0.1126714125,
0.0765101016,
0.081857428,
0.0239214636,
0.0119758137,
-0.0549876727,
-0.0008193405,
0.0467800796,
0.0352603905,
-0.0007541088,
-0.0244088899,
-0.0219915137,
-0.0202351138,
-0.0612043552,
-0.0268761143,
-0.008715665,
0.0087223332,
0.0252788477,
0.0143321194,
0.033036828,
-0.0072276313,
-0.0121548465,
-0.0621547624,
-0.0101867607,
0.0224264674,
0.002934258,
0.0262761917,
-0.0211865027,
0.0485482998,
-0.0536613092,
-0.0260780975,
0.0135594141,
0.0242556352,
0.0280516837,
-0.034595497,
0.0783333853,
-0.0059858323,
-0.0764322057,
0.0046760356,
-0.0101215756,
0.0439734906,
0.0045246985,
0.0509132221,
0.0170992799,
0.0130540645,
0.0021332805,
0.003777581,
0.0240490846,
-0.0406274945,
-0.0239002183,
0.0117796976,
0.0290527698,
-0.0080684042,
0.0043791053,
0.0128691113,
-0.018480029,
0.0531104542,
0.0448872,
-0.0064962287,
0.0128959287,
0.0314761437,
2.418e-7,
0.0718140826,
0.0445065722,
0.0113976058,
0.0182166509,
-0.0247615408,
0.0259355195,
-0.0070552877,
0.0399693362,
-0.0093790526,
0.0020167078,
-0.0428403951,
-0.016881004,
0.0851575434,
0.0490213074,
-0.0707835555,
-0.0314588472,
-0.0483956411,
-0.0284682624,
-0.035796307,
0.0224851575,
0.0244842023,
0.0884697586,
0.0091664568,
-0.0295224413,
-0.0138713187,
-0.0228863098,
0.0544483401,
-0.0525651835,
-0.0373731405,
-0.0044296226,
0.0674001947,
-0.0157922804,
0.0221645422,
0.0275904052,
-0.0305953678,
0.054357551,
-0.0322624892,
0.0757112801,
0.0163923856,
0.0031995405,
-0.0072840052,
-0.0605812334,
-0.0046363045,
-0.017912684,
0.0518179573,
-0.0030132357,
-0.0224141832,
-0.0171593037,
-0.0400361754,
-0.0068073068,
0.0088377148,
-0.0007142184,
-0.0235141702,
0.0024461669,
0.068814449,
-0.010025016,
-0.0146581624,
-0.0815375373,
-0.032025069,
0.0296652261,
0.0073370207,
0.0088801356,
-0.0171435289,
-0.0001995457,
0.021018438,
-0.071298562,
0.0098967897,
2.150486559e-34,
0.0337433852,
-0.0082202861,
0.0370686762,
0.0279241297,
0.0316418409,
0.0255819913,
-0.0158323534,
0.0077818986,
-0.0352094807,
-0.0623453707,
0.0368425213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13089v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13089v1 | Can an AI Win Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz? An AI Grand Challenge for Education | 2023-01-30T17:28:33 | 2023-01-30T17:28:33 | George Boateng, Victor Kumbol, Elsie Effah Kaufmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | There is a lack of enough qualified teachers across Africa which hampers
efforts to provide adequate learning support such as educational question
answering (EQA) to students. An AI system that can enable students to ask
questions via text or voice and get instant answers will make high-quality
education accessible. Despite advances in the field of AI, there exists no
robust benchmark or challenge to enable building such an (EQA) AI within the
African context. Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz competition (NSMQ) is
the perfect competition to evaluate the potential of such an AI due to its wide
coverage of scientific fields, variety of question types, highly competitive
nature, and live, real-world format. The NSMQ is a Jeopardy-style annual live
quiz competition in which 3 teams of 2 students compete by answering questions
across biology, chemistry, physics, and math in 5 rounds over 5 progressive
stages until a winning team is crowned for that year. In this position paper,
we propose the NSMQ AI Grand Challenge, an AI Grand Challenge for Education
using Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz competition (NSMQ) as a case
study. Our proposed grand challenge is to "Build an AI to compete live in
Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz (NSMQ) competition and win - performing
better than the best contestants in all rounds and stages of the competition."
We describe the competition, and key technical challenges to address along with
ideas from recent advances in machine learning that could be leveraged to solve
this challenge. This position paper is a first step towards conquering such a
challenge and importantly, making advances in AI for education in the African
context towards democratizing high-quality education across Africa. | [
0.0626950264,
0.0399633013,
-0.0480857864,
0.0103274621,
-0.012102141,
0.0048430315,
0.0082907528,
-0.0413857885,
0.0151433777,
-0.0133215804,
0.0016314274,
-0.0468971692,
-0.0078100152,
0.0370652229,
0.0321222581,
-0.0722955242,
0.0056821113,
-0.0429099537,
0.0155639742,
-0.0181372017,
-0.0327415653,
0.0058968663,
-0.0545974113,
0.0038028588,
0.009009283,
0.0064695748,
-0.036663074,
-0.0539987348,
0.0013843047,
-0.0460883193,
-0.0093400469,
0.0293442085,
-0.0234893057,
0.010294361,
0.0000020377,
-0.0922875032,
0.005626129,
-0.0126137594,
-0.0832889527,
0.0127369249,
-0.0321413837,
0.0964094102,
-0.0065455241,
0.035330642,
-0.0913169906,
0.0541270413,
0.0565052517,
-0.0646086112,
0.0594829693,
0.0344802402,
0.0186944697,
-0.0128328186,
0.0672775581,
0.0063080988,
0.028745722,
-0.066924125,
0.0122519815,
0.013251801,
0.0301069207,
-0.0001585062,
-0.0189751349,
0.0420065373,
0.0180215817,
-0.0193304773,
-0.0025538143,
0.0071776826,
-0.0523237213,
-0.0285039973,
-0.0232290234,
0.0607690327,
0.0477490164,
0.0101808263,
0.0061674849,
0.0106591955,
0.0189598463,
0.017623473,
-0.0790994391,
0.0345341153,
0.0008393272,
-0.0201684628,
0.0053652665,
0.0193742085,
-0.0122779813,
0.050014399,
-0.016876176,
0.0699119344,
-0.0107921073,
-0.0122854942,
0.0145139825,
0.0326506272,
-0.0050970931,
-0.025143424,
0.0178907216,
0.0471277274,
-0.019245455,
0.0002983709,
0.0259112939,
-0.0571658202,
0.0140567394,
-0.0255037919,
0.0438548997,
0.0093603795,
0.0340722464,
0.0536398776,
0.0437570661,
0.0793930441,
-0.004822698,
0.0282745026,
-0.0337325186,
-0.0060776877,
-0.0387947336,
-0.0248835552,
0.0028597075,
0.0488453098,
-0.0112148291,
0.0445399769,
-0.0376403108,
-0.0092118699,
-0.0257715583,
0.0274110138,
-0.0180543438,
0.0417622328,
0.0045858268,
-0.0147940191,
-0.036721129,
0.0057974248,
-0.0450581424,
-0.0020882587,
0.0006499616,
-0.0372958407,
0.020853769,
-0.0010579983,
-0.0061810887,
0.019040823,
0.0562757552,
0.0599034242,
-0.006869256,
-0.0062549803,
-0.0186847262,
-0.0383846052,
0.0441349372,
-0.0527092181,
0.0164993871,
-0.0447052345,
0.0397525467,
0.0008261947,
-0.00480658,
0.0098684877,
0.0093148332,
-0.0078127533,
0.0628736094,
0.045400288,
0.001120713,
-0.0257488471,
0.1002105996,
0.0297252797,
-0.0021426256,
0.0123263067,
0.0324798413,
-0.0026737403,
0.0401941799,
-0.0138485925,
0.0126595236,
0.0174506735,
0.038295269,
-0.0250840876,
0.0497943759,
0.0374442041,
0.0081867548,
0.0624977723,
-0.0802396014,
0.0256102532,
0.0382891409,
-0.0041428409,
0.0174301527,
0.0782166794,
-0.0258898884,
0.0183377508,
-0.0062235296,
-0.0252404585,
0.0674048439,
-0.0038666108,
-0.0226836279,
0.0435517617,
-0.0318914354,
-0.0147411367,
0.0357765071,
0.0584946908,
-0.0218869802,
-0.0921516865,
0.0001706342,
0.0068496927,
-0.0032938772,
0.0666370019,
0.0478287973,
-0.0428485386,
0.0058286935,
-0.0714873075,
-0.0009768544,
-0.0265747122,
0.00640467,
-0.093148686,
0.0698018447,
-0.0108276652,
0.0599585213,
-0.0431508198,
-0.055013191,
-0.0053229313,
0.0166006032,
0.0266992804,
0.0194496419,
-0.043686498,
0.0057011391,
-0.0023878491,
-0.0279814675,
-0.0016993162,
-0.0291942488,
0.003505351,
0.035779234,
0.0649695098,
-0.0149608236,
-0.0068942923,
0.0282758363,
0.0274339542,
-0.0560765117,
-0.0538750999,
0.0018686202,
0.0218027122,
0.0497036465,
0.0290275104,
0.0090777287,
0.009649382,
-0.0016522185,
-0.0111808777,
-0.0264253952,
-0.0483296812,
-0.0381640606,
-0.0085063418,
0.0456767343,
-0.0892492458,
-0.0005342154,
0.0749561414,
-0.0009516038,
-0.012568132,
0.02838278,
-0.0276322328,
-0.0349572189,
0.0125665059,
0.0159018151,
-0.0247891229,
-0.0287986863,
-0.0245649498,
0.0249259863,
0.046212934,
0.0136704491,
0.0127221365,
0.0011470068,
0.0578949451,
-0.026424678,
-0.0211481042,
0.0125674866,
-0.007466048,
0.0027468465,
0.009478366,
-0.0321023464,
-0.0606534369,
0.0282764602,
-0.0490807854,
0.0088908076,
0.0469816923,
0.022910988,
0.0002087585,
0.0020823278,
0.0151867205,
0.0130373258,
-0.0466892757,
0.0006303265,
0.026928138,
-0.0265697837,
0.0133220162,
0.0131755229,
0.0076733176,
-0.0487164147,
-0.01291609,
-0.0432053171,
0.0546237938,
0.0787314773,
0.0272768345,
-0.0052581602,
-0.030200012,
-0.0502966754,
0.0229113679,
0.0310516804,
0.0045457906,
0.025634177,
-0.036587391,
-0.0497114733,
0.0895675123,
0.0290135797,
-0.0142068341,
0.0228638556,
0.0078939572,
-0.0357128009,
0.0264244471,
0.0042529758,
0.0374450684,
0.002780559,
-0.0066466876,
0.0215496626,
0.0362007059,
0.018051656,
-0.0144547382,
0.0200092252,
0.1008076221,
-0.0324571691,
-0.0466490649,
-0.0781849548,
-0.0109365936,
0.001005545,
0.0161223542,
0.001305134,
-0.0111275818,
0.1089447886,
0.0086213751,
0.0013388606,
-0.0619656444,
0.0086163068,
-0.0175508354,
0.0451404899,
-0.0540216304,
0.0040521566,
0.0004391485,
-0.0036716878,
-0.0523289591,
-0.0154121211,
0.0444950946,
-0.052987162,
-0.0278219245,
-0.0481921136,
-0.0112443464,
0.0058691534,
-0.0789294615,
-0.0259205438,
0.0068890452,
-0.0130807497,
0.0160299409,
0.0247812048,
-0.0297518615,
-0.0215624813,
-0.0108235469,
0.051419124,
-0.0070529236,
-0.0083545186,
-0.0315795131,
0.0257217679,
0.094227694,
0.0327628031,
0.0335236825,
0.0238297917,
-0.0373996347,
0.0441394113,
0.0571110807,
0.056930311,
0.0008910524,
0.0314495824,
-0.0058534304,
0.0215752665,
-0.0440158546,
-0.0328498073,
0.0282327719,
0.0057599773,
-0.0482620597,
-0.0198565088,
0.0770924613,
0.0480493978,
0.0004085751,
-0.007874704,
-0.0385698229,
-0.0487861931,
-0.0117485141,
0.0556426831,
-0.0973566547,
-0.0072669606,
-0.03282056,
0.0139508685,
-0.0293280147,
-0.0184028484,
0.001614602,
-0.0953297243,
0.0246137232,
0.0148574309,
-0.0212722216,
-0.0202964805,
-0.0368202738,
-0.0622232966,
-0.0041048094,
-0.0186797455,
-0.0117541719,
0.0338994265,
0.0224218704,
0.0398781747,
-0.0191265289,
-0.0008405353,
0.0348773189,
-0.027794145,
0.0405217782,
0.0713594779,
0.0296378229,
-0.0154422382,
-0.0651315674,
-0.0546561107,
-0.0203578919,
-0.0100319693,
-0.0133793373,
0.0110365134,
0.0192783885,
-0.0156065049,
-0.0510355122,
0.0457513928,
-0.0180502404,
0.0341763645,
0.0677508786,
0.1249640808,
-0.0310210306,
-0.0103104375,
-0.0792663023,
-0.0394907258,
0.005396178,
0.0347072519,
0.0159858055,
-0.0624343082,
-0.0362941995,
-0.0268492699,
0.0378911681,
-0.0756447464,
-0.0242793988,
-0.0004781671,
0.0423838496,
0.0204036068,
-0.0465179831,
-0.041711688,
0.0675143301,
0.0006651561,
0.0079693142,
-0.0314320065,
0.0100839827,
0.0428440347,
-0.036238838,
-0.0177145321,
-0.0295408163,
0.0279115904,
-0.0555849634,
-0.0179834608,
0.0257714558,
-0.0102429399,
-0.0308056623,
-0.0056763892,
-0.0473212413,
-0.0508952327,
0.004522338,
0.0683194101,
0.0137714092,
-0.0410818718,
0.0179240387,
-0.0311864633,
0.039315749,
-0.0109916776,
0.0180536788,
0.0301699564,
-0.0173189659,
0.0022131493,
-0.0014529915,
-0.0354760736,
-0.0033826425,
0.0071495064,
0.0067523797,
0.0216170009,
-0.0385449901,
-0.0215891264,
0.0130526535,
0.0383049473,
0.0421609245,
0.0217846744,
-0.0611900501,
-0.0114835547,
0.0219351985,
0.0327129662,
-0.0144510893,
-0.0095474916,
-0.0541671626,
-0.0002405504,
0.0094508613,
0.0248948336,
-0.0051753074,
-0.0216753129,
-0.0170368087,
-0.0376285315,
0.0778614283,
0.0625903532,
0.051964324,
-0.0125970487,
0.0153255574,
0.0058235037,
0.0283292793,
0.0309192147,
0.0822414607,
0.0033917518,
0.0384446681,
0.0102910344,
-0.007519769,
0.0143134091,
-0.0038952827,
-0.0406993367,
-0.0307889581,
-0.0393508375,
0.0587541014,
0.0309133641,
0.0552124195,
-0.0608938113,
0.0211841334,
0.0076112002,
0.0054353941,
-0.0378099605,
-0.0196914524,
-0.0233292766,
0.0298160445,
0.0206062943,
0.0410024039,
0.027197836,
0.0409950316,
0.0020749541,
0.0232799109,
0.0240082052,
0.0137581676,
-0.019402191,
-0.0272238348,
-0.0015871676,
-0.0017679215,
0.0010608902,
0.0315529965,
-0.0309336595,
-0.0155342929,
0.0086271651,
0.0350056663,
0.016397357,
-0.0094311647,
0.0524643958,
0.0199025013,
-0.0197209548,
-0.0413625389,
-0.0087500587,
0.0474374965,
-0.07823015,
-0.0540056191,
0.0079654334,
-5.9901495e-33,
-0.0071703098,
-0.0531069785,
0.0226473045,
0.0065425723,
-0.0033215729,
-0.0125323357,
-0.040700376,
0.0275464039,
-0.0675128773,
-0.0019137003,
-0.0370878987,
0.012564051,
0.0007576781,
0.0340137519,
0.0341882631,
0.0050744354,
0.0103331627,
-0.0174786448,
-0.0322542563,
0.0173125044,
0.0072296015,
0.0190119836,
0.0296859387,
-0.0250803586,
0.0233606547,
-0.0195898693,
0.0054221782,
-0.0031162461,
-0.0410356745,
0.0218691025,
-0.0018216528,
0.0312983096,
0.0125833107,
-0.0547098555,
0.0202923939,
0.0318393745,
-0.0407716818,
-0.0620810315,
-0.0281395596,
-0.0112200454,
-0.0359716937,
-0.0479712337,
0.0399613194,
0.0173398778,
-0.0419578701,
-0.0239848513,
0.0573485307,
-0.0224381033,
0.0207978152,
-0.0396503955,
-0.0146195097,
-0.0012721271,
-0.057257764,
-0.0078434311,
-0.0228644647,
0.0491752177,
-0.023753494,
-0.0464452244,
-0.0079314532,
0.0637396276,
0.0522363111,
0.0331373177,
0.0203343146,
0.0238266923,
-0.0356013067,
0.0192936435,
0.043948438,
-0.0534576625,
-0.0270172097,
-0.0346751548,
0.0007230425,
-0.0415144339,
0.1287779361,
0.0594008155,
0.0282707866,
0.0056506223,
-0.0942002162,
0.0811193511,
0.051812131,
0.0033602926,
-0.0546103679,
-0.0380202122,
-0.0534002297,
-0.0000518321,
-0.0425349846,
0.0381241329,
-0.0251453184,
-0.0223381761,
0.0562080517,
-0.0949745402,
-0.0298285,
0.0239788536,
0.005706104,
-0.0258261599,
0.0044532083,
0.0011037852,
0.0711679906,
0.0670608878,
-0.0004041289,
-0.0151505759,
-0.0389421321,
-0.0026950522,
-0.0290483125,
0.0240274686,
0.0239882562,
0.0062371087,
-0.0531562567,
0.0167502854,
-0.010075449,
-0.0070741791,
-0.0143891918,
-0.0220047422,
0.0520059168,
-0.0135507882,
-0.012777118,
-0.0099020023,
0.0195681825,
0.0093600396,
-0.0051761642,
0.0032433015,
-0.0144505575,
-0.0256901085,
-0.0077900682,
-0.0044834302,
-0.047004737,
-0.0319849066,
-0.0784776956,
0.0104918815,
-0.0714676529,
-0.0550153069,
0.0042758961,
-0.0104112737,
2.711e-7,
-0.0045262547,
0.0490187556,
0.0314072371,
-0.0236975048,
-0.0380037986,
0.0192177594,
0.0172830001,
-0.0250425898,
-0.0010199609,
0.040401116,
0.024017144,
0.0078971311,
0.008750068,
0.0386616029,
-0.0944194719,
-0.0253210142,
-0.0316539928,
0.0111571308,
-0.0738399997,
0.0191423334,
0.0222414341,
0.0500105135,
0.0323803425,
-0.032705266,
-0.04373632,
-0.0481442511,
0.0133830924,
0.0182613991,
0.0171221271,
0.0159762502,
-0.0351565629,
0.008785394,
0.0111761605,
0.0300051011,
-0.0343884639,
-0.0165180825,
0.012151923,
0.0164290871,
0.0113536809,
-0.0027124428,
0.0069471477,
0.0272944532,
0.0060127908,
-0.0378779583,
0.0729877278,
-0.0239001531,
-0.04998523,
-0.0033994871,
-0.0247317161,
-0.0342856906,
-0.0076446119,
-0.0334025659,
-0.0082457568,
-0.0429170467,
-0.0056297975,
-0.0316400863,
0.0231389105,
-0.0089143887,
0.0037568368,
-0.0120908571,
0.009187228,
-0.0284179337,
-0.0367551856,
-0.0006272036,
-0.0091841258,
-0.0274611264,
0.0040201275,
2.125798193e-34,
0.0079356041,
-0.0280876234,
0.063788414,
0.0164790973,
0.0006962875,
0.028186297,
0.0170878302,
-0.0170130301,
0.0704435781,
-0.0367522947,
-0.0048235273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13083v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13083v2 | Communication Drives the Emergence of Language Universals in Neural Agents: Evidence from the Word-order/Case-marking Trade-off | 2023-01-30T17:22:33 | 2023-06-01T03:54:09 | Yuchen Lian, Arianna Bisazza, Tessa Verhoef | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Artificial learners often behave differently from human learners in the
context of neural agent-based simulations of language emergence and change. A
common explanation is the lack of appropriate cognitive biases in these
learners. However, it has also been proposed that more naturalistic settings of
language learning and use could lead to more human-like results. We investigate
this latter account focusing on the word-order/case-marking trade-off, a widely
attested language universal that has proven particularly hard to simulate. We
propose a new Neural-agent Language Learning and Communication framework
(NeLLCom) where pairs of speaking and listening agents first learn a miniature
language via supervised learning, and then optimize it for communication via
reinforcement learning. Following closely the setup of earlier human
experiments, we succeed in replicating the trade-off with the new framework
without hard-coding specific biases in the agents. We see this as an essential
step towards the investigation of language universals with neural learners. | [
0.0206140056,
0.0563952513,
-0.0575712398,
0.0112491082,
-0.0282982513,
0.0289969333,
-0.0157535393,
-0.0362191647,
-0.0135722319,
0.0233081244,
-0.0127056409,
-0.0249314662,
0.0095270835,
-0.0106690181,
0.0412453339,
-0.0109608462,
0.0722425282,
-0.0227960534,
0.0268563814,
-0.032711193,
-0.0173812024,
-0.0446191952,
-0.0311875269,
0.0319229811,
-0.0137251401,
0.0350053087,
-0.0543152392,
-0.040361926,
-0.0160227083,
-0.0157414991,
0.0018111208,
0.0173202325,
0.048403006,
0.0738623515,
0.0000016471,
-0.04456475,
0.0609806031,
-0.0356305763,
-0.0162941813,
-0.0450541154,
0.0657263547,
0.0127842976,
-0.0413265638,
-0.0287028924,
-0.0528743826,
-0.0276538152,
0.0560912378,
-0.0211473368,
0.0025654626,
0.0361911543,
0.0063438788,
-0.0041583278,
-0.0126037654,
-0.0130790798,
0.0012140338,
-0.036838457,
0.0095493486,
-0.0436876155,
0.0332848765,
-0.0406947359,
-0.0369555093,
0.000931451,
0.0393541902,
-0.0042530871,
-0.0350029841,
0.0478598624,
-0.008486812,
-0.0597284026,
-0.0258628093,
0.0509514511,
0.0165705178,
-0.0299535803,
-0.0097793993,
0.0235364828,
0.0660601929,
-0.0045287935,
0.0121659152,
0.0245506931,
0.0421155356,
0.0591420047,
0.0391325168,
-0.0335455909,
0.0073821214,
0.0139267463,
-0.0071253977,
0.0893235579,
-0.0063789389,
-0.0242757201,
0.0178387668,
0.0100319292,
0.0590634644,
-0.0516818687,
0.0104059372,
0.0175972562,
-0.0180683844,
0.021197876,
-0.0264737848,
0.001490698,
-0.003648442,
-0.0737425908,
0.0523356833,
0.0268410705,
0.0189356469,
0.0231170859,
-0.0415693633,
0.0425207764,
0.0220089257,
0.0435759127,
-0.0038741059,
0.0302192587,
-0.0244142339,
-0.0361205451,
-0.0304742455,
0.0247213934,
-0.0039789262,
0.0107068606,
-0.0280235652,
0.010366885,
-0.0169422049,
-0.007978484,
-0.0235617552,
-0.0244079735,
-0.0400185399,
0.0315688998,
-0.0741857663,
-0.0131316772,
-0.0852167383,
0.044740282,
0.0299584512,
-0.0409069955,
-0.0196047239,
-0.0138233388,
-0.0188416373,
0.0031733462,
-0.006144383,
0.117298834,
-0.0325390138,
-0.0319668911,
-0.015859358,
0.0423575714,
-0.010919339,
-0.0129265711,
0.0207793508,
-0.03186737,
0.0509016663,
-0.0092298221,
-0.0302461442,
-0.0834859312,
-0.0013870945,
-0.0306659788,
-0.0324471332,
0.0618303865,
0.0012265053,
0.0166033525,
0.0179837365,
-0.0196364969,
-0.0011371786,
0.042596288,
0.0548989847,
-0.0243900921,
-0.0036142673,
-0.0115771145,
0.0216573868,
0.0336641893,
0.0260115787,
0.0040448927,
-0.00888093,
-0.0506314263,
0.0046239602,
0.0750524774,
0.066236876,
0.0290333014,
-0.0583566874,
-0.0481501408,
0.0752029121,
0.0469881631,
0.0050667748,
0.0084861936,
0.0629224852,
0.0212974958,
-0.0151313702,
0.02165333,
-0.0346614644,
0.0250872802,
-0.003279523,
0.0066117239,
-0.0139671741,
0.0135924034,
-0.0508482866,
-0.0362557955,
0.0461487994,
-0.0279293489,
0.0648366213,
-0.0151892388,
-0.0057922057,
0.0521492921,
-0.0204572212,
0.0108918818,
0.076464057,
-0.0172309689,
0.0154638374,
-0.0546916537,
0.0245272107,
0.0244710259,
-0.0212582313,
-0.0248933807,
-0.002320824,
0.0417824686,
-0.0320656225,
0.0984832495,
0.0299435556,
-0.0190005302,
0.0198892634,
-0.0180798452,
0.0265225973,
-0.0043860306,
-0.0208775941,
0.0327960812,
-0.0162240937,
0.013991111,
-0.0341448635,
0.0097592343,
-0.0516619198,
0.048945874,
-0.0384839848,
-0.0433939099,
-0.0080511644,
0.0114197833,
0.0454660989,
-0.0370549299,
-0.0202667639,
0.0201429706,
0.0057420814,
0.0055591413,
-0.0153234852,
0.0322617032,
-0.0668981373,
-0.0513294563,
0.0341719314,
-0.0189531296,
0.0097701261,
0.033025872,
0.015498803,
-0.0030130346,
0.0697537661,
-0.0141218016,
0.056391567,
-0.008060107,
0.0110551314,
-0.0196481645,
0.0095400698,
-0.0269943755,
0.0336765647,
0.0087986616,
-0.0416471101,
0.0028405858,
-0.0075605917,
-0.0333386399,
-0.0516276583,
-0.0205882955,
0.0278795231,
-0.0052271006,
0.0387635492,
0.0201223213,
0.0194570199,
-0.0357355699,
-0.0323150568,
-0.0185790323,
-0.052555535,
0.0183508229,
-0.0063673249,
-0.0117238602,
-0.0143707329,
-0.0157449916,
-0.0261223223,
-0.0407514498,
0.0530972667,
0.0011168823,
0.0406701118,
0.0482990742,
0.0064869383,
-0.0452763885,
-0.0779436827,
-0.0233947765,
-0.017536426,
0.0165146124,
0.0198033527,
0.0249169208,
-0.0703389645,
0.0170676056,
-0.0400290303,
0.0290835798,
-0.0152985714,
-0.0602866523,
0.0359856784,
-0.0000758708,
-0.0083481884,
0.0898724794,
-0.0017410404,
0.0408671796,
0.0525267571,
0.021316262,
-0.0642250851,
0.0027521029,
-0.0477531813,
-0.0244961157,
-0.0707045943,
-0.0106361136,
-0.0266448781,
0.1196727157,
-0.0135592436,
-0.0136010516,
-0.0207887292,
0.0528465956,
-0.0223965682,
-0.088032648,
-0.0040174369,
-0.0372581035,
-0.0475128293,
0.0431817584,
-0.0331741944,
-0.0218934193,
0.0945488587,
0.02981163,
-0.0136688063,
-0.055376593,
-0.0186155941,
-0.0172582828,
0.0264146011,
0.0337704942,
0.0034978357,
-0.0367430747,
-0.0477730408,
-0.1056965068,
-0.016060032,
0.030300146,
0.0302749146,
-0.0014049477,
-0.0428365171,
-0.0007517001,
0.0056091347,
-0.0479941331,
-0.025092883,
0.0173686985,
-0.0050553493,
0.0274765827,
0.01126891,
0.0027326192,
0.0045063682,
-0.0212972872,
0.0350897908,
0.0280143842,
0.0057032546,
0.0045824116,
-0.0517088324,
-0.0141393598,
-0.0031079066,
0.042183239,
0.033403527,
-0.0330470316,
0.042034708,
0.0026433587,
0.0596349016,
0.0320617706,
-0.0193540659,
0.0139001552,
0.0380608439,
-0.0130194481,
0.016746344,
0.0309088845,
0.0023248857,
-0.0104881404,
-0.0206357501,
0.0592645966,
0.0247480553,
-0.0680583268,
0.0416706912,
-0.0264007859,
0.0342112705,
0.0272625759,
0.0537438169,
-0.0373061486,
0.0018187364,
0.0099216197,
-0.0008788629,
-0.0013719555,
-0.0431833528,
0.0253298227,
-0.0726586878,
-0.0088881366,
0.0241939314,
-0.058007516,
0.0319202207,
-0.019834172,
-0.0043451693,
0.0037915274,
0.0537261888,
0.0326052532,
0.0206326544,
-0.0097040534,
-0.0156596545,
0.0332884006,
-0.0173454508,
0.0058090822,
-0.0712941661,
0.0647816956,
0.0629927963,
0.017223388,
-0.0417874083,
-0.0199673697,
0.0181118567,
0.0458055176,
0.0010516362,
0.022980934,
0.0156763103,
0.0165748708,
-0.0183702763,
-0.0177277382,
0.0165968463,
0.0089566223,
0.0012400319,
-0.0005195266,
0.0457092673,
0.0259900931,
-0.052686125,
0.0371335931,
0.0282534845,
0.0148035772,
0.0327932201,
0.0619338229,
-0.0911368653,
-0.0330807418,
-0.0283355955,
-0.0160891004,
-0.0096597755,
-0.081256859,
0.0325678997,
0.0161473509,
-0.0589101091,
-0.0784280002,
-0.0601398274,
0.0254015028,
0.0369375162,
0.0489558354,
-0.044864431,
0.0486928523,
-0.0256522708,
-0.0090000285,
-0.0186062064,
-0.0041059945,
-0.0003422117,
-0.0573340207,
-0.0367571712,
0.0359965637,
-0.0659869239,
-0.007661378,
0.0137229702,
0.0016794405,
-0.1069151908,
0.0506914221,
0.0534050651,
0.0213732012,
0.0387029685,
0.0242485013,
-0.0463696122,
0.0326333642,
0.0233449098,
-0.033087872,
0.0275836457,
0.0064329328,
0.0016705364,
0.0042127017,
0.0358849801,
-0.0209691562,
0.0140808029,
-0.0167463329,
0.0314188935,
-0.0301504582,
0.0263690744,
0.0485962331,
-0.0392617583,
-0.0009122701,
-0.0135433171,
0.0133400923,
-0.0526376255,
-0.0152711999,
-0.0079194577,
-0.0038533125,
-0.0116529185,
-0.0448635183,
0.0156730209,
0.0787136108,
0.0370536968,
-0.0469719656,
0.0336172208,
0.0380949602,
0.0588682629,
0.0012563864,
0.0333312638,
0.083291322,
0.0137810512,
0.048333481,
0.0246629734,
0.072901547,
-0.0401043072,
0.0451631136,
-0.0042763455,
0.0237201694,
0.0236089751,
-0.0096501512,
-0.0264704004,
0.0174275804,
-0.0555027686,
-0.0664986894,
0.0587221906,
-0.0033339888,
0.0338940546,
-0.0030931025,
0.0125019299,
-0.060521625,
0.0220421571,
0.0144675365,
-0.0040123304,
-0.0296058226,
-0.0556375273,
0.0074325269,
0.0271536522,
-0.0052814214,
-0.0103940619,
0.0493305922,
0.0067714113,
0.0044766366,
-0.0477326177,
0.0603209697,
-0.0134485951,
-0.0056587113,
0.0089122485,
-0.0089322692,
-0.0269515328,
0.0101256585,
-0.0450020321,
-0.0472021848,
-0.0648948178,
0.055111669,
-0.0033457102,
-0.0278137084,
0.0494717322,
0.0111618042,
-0.0135404523,
0.0132827442,
-0.0390069373,
-0.0041314005,
0.0185744613,
-0.0274728462,
-0.0026089884,
-5.339887331e-33,
-0.0525204055,
-0.0019737997,
0.0227701664,
0.0463725254,
0.0127529921,
-0.0320709944,
-0.0291527715,
0.0237412062,
-0.0194251724,
0.0052944035,
-0.0042391261,
0.0117602013,
0.0226042457,
-0.0272581019,
0.0344974399,
-0.0096314941,
0.0037082136,
-0.0545886867,
-0.0027417708,
-0.0159463864,
-0.0122632375,
0.0175213609,
0.0438651852,
-0.0284469239,
0.0108786728,
0.0488380529,
0.0413423665,
0.0090806875,
-0.0303030144,
-0.0005767446,
-0.0096695814,
-0.0069302912,
-0.0004696635,
-0.0031395126,
-0.0143727856,
-0.0095954975,
-0.0509035662,
-0.038370233,
0.0153518412,
-0.0035801185,
-0.0673731118,
-0.0393418185,
0.0355209112,
-0.0456985682,
-0.0663220808,
0.0472137593,
0.0066725975,
0.0081487214,
-0.0236902423,
0.0416442379,
-0.0924948379,
-0.0339496359,
0.0081615467,
-0.005106952,
0.0145683168,
-0.0283409152,
-0.0402890965,
-0.0213667098,
-0.0661365315,
0.0712220371,
0.0149895903,
0.0041866358,
0.040414311,
0.0153340716,
0.0323367119,
0.0719582289,
0.1272937208,
0.0503480323,
-0.0022482988,
-0.046518337,
0.0608195662,
-0.0238216408,
0.0154048735,
0.0560521781,
0.0029407979,
-0.0179459061,
-0.0162871238,
-0.0414480083,
0.101387687,
0.0013043061,
-0.0080762953,
0.0175256114,
-0.0337742493,
-0.0365029052,
-0.0444531627,
-0.0328443795,
-0.0172749627,
-0.0490075871,
0.0098558441,
0.0128783984,
0.0375480205,
-0.0903912038,
-0.0007599876,
-0.0322701745,
-0.0089771897,
-0.0442972109,
0.0113151642,
0.0170855243,
0.0273593199,
-0.004569394,
-0.0751996115,
-0.0293822829,
-0.0370702744,
0.0140142757,
0.0317193717,
0.0476490669,
0.0145689892,
0.0254617222,
0.0090817977,
0.012523409,
-0.0212944318,
-0.0059084911,
0.073849149,
-0.0649032071,
-0.0016477772,
-0.0091673341,
-0.0289027821,
-0.0246344209,
0.0380245745,
-0.0392773226,
-0.0126569234,
0.013750013,
-0.0168768428,
0.0590037853,
-0.0361089893,
-0.0200463682,
-0.0716092363,
0.0990154743,
0.0376053937,
-0.0569421686,
-0.0127751194,
-0.0035853449,
2.589e-7,
-0.0193066522,
0.0336890854,
0.0389003381,
0.0296940338,
0.0525570624,
0.0146446871,
-0.0570483431,
0.0196073316,
0.0012333501,
0.010797089,
0.0036971646,
0.0361684225,
0.0180246998,
0.0172117371,
-0.0870788097,
0.0011561577,
-0.019839881,
0.0279680826,
-0.0197261479,
-0.0132370414,
-0.0133614074,
0.0447866209,
-0.0012098355,
-0.0015203485,
-0.0210879035,
-0.0421666615,
0.0358818844,
-0.0251091328,
0.0252705831,
-0.004606178,
-0.0487432182,
-0.0319167897,
-0.0039984174,
0.0094465017,
0.0262019131,
0.0297479499,
-0.0126775755,
-0.0114110801,
-0.0223628003,
-0.0307939015,
0.0263117403,
0.0127672004,
-0.0204780437,
-0.0358295478,
-0.0039786207,
-0.0930501074,
-0.0498367921,
0.0345381685,
0.0065514734,
0.0044383784,
-0.0104990471,
-0.0236874856,
-0.027577525,
-0.0104093552,
-0.0052903583,
0.0256581269,
0.0205376595,
-0.0247501023,
0.0167212132,
0.0333804488,
-0.0058680288,
-0.0389752463,
-0.0115114935,
0.0039179982,
0.0197168402,
-0.0101233637,
0.018812295,
1.463436628e-34,
0.0083032679,
0.0057219737,
0.0593176894,
0.0330560096,
0.0347534493,
-0.0112101045,
-0.0232203603,
0.0242650639,
0.0715193748,
-0.0192831121,
-0.045987539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13066v2 | A Human Word Association based model for topic detection in social networks | 2023-01-30T17:10:34 | 2023-07-18T11:39:22 | Mehrdad Ranjbar Khadivi, Shahin Akbarpour, Mohammad-Reza Feizi-Derakhshi, Babak Anari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the widespread use of social networks, detecting the topics discussed in
these networks has become a significant challenge. The current works are mainly
based on frequent pattern mining or semantic relations, and the language
structure is not considered. The meaning of language structural methods is to
discover the relationship between words and how humans understand them.
Therefore, this paper uses the Concept of the Imitation of the Mental Ability
of Word Association to propose a topic detection framework in social networks.
This framework is based on the Human Word Association method. A special
extraction algorithm has also been designed for this purpose. The performance
of this method is evaluated on the FA-CUP dataset. It is a benchmark dataset in
the field of topic detection. The results show that the proposed method is a
good improvement compared to other methods, based on the Topic-recall and the
keyword F1 measure. Also, most of the previous works in the field of topic
detection are limited to the English language, and the Persian language,
especially microblogs written in this language, is considered a low-resource
language. Therefore, a data set of Telegram posts in the Farsi language has
been collected. Applying the proposed method to this dataset also shows that
this method works better than other topic detection methods. | [
0.0514984764,
-0.0091527039,
-0.0243984684,
0.0308794454,
-0.0545732342,
0.0347451121,
-0.0296077784,
-0.0030352455,
0.0227348153,
-0.0111334361,
0.0198871456,
-0.0413672179,
0.0142281009,
0.0237237997,
-0.0210461859,
-0.0100201732,
0.0493911318,
0.011297687,
0.0105447825,
0.0193761382,
0.026303323,
-0.0010342048,
-0.0252947174,
-0.0490251519,
0.012843878,
0.0416685864,
0.0012407738,
-0.0558925979,
-0.0000839589,
-0.0226629488,
0.0190665424,
0.0775425807,
-0.0385988429,
0.0185846165,
0.0000018027,
-0.0598904826,
-0.044022847,
-0.075335592,
0.0642941371,
-0.028002115,
0.0601417013,
-0.0231772289,
-0.0096889017,
0.0596054979,
-0.04758114,
0.0314345136,
0.0158247072,
0.0804307982,
0.0225139316,
0.0661982894,
-0.0301981736,
-0.0373766124,
0.0186741166,
0.017889753,
0.0146059887,
-0.0607160069,
0.0537989624,
-0.0215469953,
-0.0022397467,
0.0063817063,
0.0241868198,
-0.0227877628,
-0.0394897759,
0.0070246039,
0.0303384718,
0.0177096296,
-0.0453692488,
-0.0284983292,
-0.0099633029,
0.0431399345,
0.0196244121,
-0.0386355035,
0.1009287015,
0.0231907126,
-0.0334960259,
0.077980265,
-0.0283383913,
-0.0068059945,
-0.0616269894,
0.0117042623,
0.064485155,
-0.0023851926,
-0.0345923454,
0.0364144295,
0.0090809613,
0.0418208241,
0.0053654551,
-0.0234301817,
-0.015775796,
0.0220430885,
-0.0004919389,
-0.012407898,
0.0721195489,
0.016060181,
0.0008261169,
0.0340609513,
-0.0374572016,
-0.0554151498,
0.0275794659,
-0.1098111942,
-0.0767935142,
-0.0126531683,
0.019703541,
0.0491944812,
-0.0334674381,
-0.0269083865,
-0.0069524623,
-0.0296332613,
-0.0093544815,
-0.0061293342,
-0.0394548811,
0.0406308621,
-0.019339731,
0.0015709822,
0.0153331505,
-0.0104505643,
-0.0604401864,
0.0464534163,
0.0329856053,
-0.0357080586,
-0.0667479038,
-0.0112718092,
0.024380127,
0.0219846182,
-0.0041168965,
-0.0110469572,
-0.0383716822,
0.0356344208,
-0.0482175052,
0.0234926343,
0.0202177335,
-0.0046219267,
0.0865020901,
0.0162288193,
-0.0240538251,
0.006118983,
-0.0030686483,
-0.0745879263,
-0.057615336,
-0.0083259307,
0.0279676151,
0.0322611965,
0.0525340587,
-0.0817672312,
0.0262707938,
0.047467526,
-0.0286500603,
0.0625927448,
0.0128337555,
0.051840242,
-0.0571231917,
0.0103401085,
-0.0502863862,
0.0430976041,
0.0891373456,
0.0206283741,
0.0385990255,
0.0485396795,
-0.0088026179,
0.10622482,
0.0594312586,
0.0275850352,
-0.0108363461,
0.0036104424,
-0.0123724025,
0.0193785168,
0.0394148491,
-0.0104338406,
-0.0139854504,
-0.0416060463,
-0.0163377523,
0.0506318174,
-0.0213857386,
-0.0119934632,
-0.0015261329,
0.0626438856,
0.0185550191,
0.0383557603,
-0.0541245937,
0.056338042,
0.0653372854,
0.0013973919,
0.050613232,
-0.0056239148,
-0.0381770954,
-0.0038004355,
0.0357210375,
0.0241626184,
-0.0478389822,
-0.0016228019,
-0.022752,
-0.0162190478,
0.0411585234,
-0.0641797408,
0.0750883743,
-0.0059521669,
0.0100231664,
0.0124080377,
0.0819580555,
0.0327207223,
-0.0050790929,
-0.0261119977,
0.03503583,
0.0305819325,
0.0045240768,
-0.0098676439,
0.0376723707,
-0.011148518,
0.0107825575,
0.007832312,
0.0072046714,
-0.0307316259,
-0.0670921952,
-0.0187108535,
0.0031510766,
0.079277195,
0.0010409242,
0.0012768731,
0.0079850685,
0.0224766936,
0.0005822961,
0.0085132783,
0.0182878338,
0.0327497423,
0.0146722365,
0.0609155074,
0.0017166602,
0.0026522065,
0.0002212736,
0.0491980948,
0.0019961176,
-0.0156885423,
0.0229205545,
-0.0260673761,
-0.0253987052,
-0.0032746221,
0.0009369708,
0.0129780173,
0.0153063275,
-0.0501735955,
-0.0196579639,
0.0193714127,
0.0018512709,
-0.0481760129,
0.0727974623,
-0.0539977215,
0.0394007936,
-0.0384253711,
0.0037709617,
-0.058581885,
0.0097267218,
0.0030532407,
0.093757093,
-0.0180073325,
0.0125591746,
-0.0379327871,
-0.0358875729,
0.0331924558,
-0.0106493607,
0.016053943,
0.0192168057,
-0.0086507257,
0.0049039912,
0.0678859353,
-0.0063545611,
-0.0576884523,
-0.0162557531,
-0.0913692042,
0.0130433384,
-0.0176024754,
0.0203885902,
0.0135928812,
0.0045033335,
-0.021073984,
-0.0061798794,
-0.0010310829,
0.0276805423,
-0.0132858902,
0.0214002132,
0.0288316272,
-0.0343185179,
0.0002289078,
-0.0338860154,
-0.0193080436,
-0.052796524,
0.0103463791,
0.0682111606,
-0.09882918,
0.0159695242,
0.0156318005,
-0.0141970236,
-0.0183194522,
-0.0061960956,
-0.0191503558,
-0.01603158,
0.0062793996,
0.0482135862,
-0.017204674,
0.0617690794,
0.0249149445,
0.0213992,
0.0436004475,
0.0261920504,
-0.0392058045,
-0.0260979012,
0.0339576378,
0.0200772956,
-0.0605340935,
0.027294293,
0.0367226079,
0.0067471727,
0.0395997278,
-0.0003931563,
-0.0148905078,
-0.0280405395,
0.0333036073,
-0.0330718979,
0.0078980858,
-0.0007279594,
0.012680498,
-0.0076961606,
-0.0158098023,
0.0305398349,
0.0353342518,
0.0586157106,
-0.0717613623,
-0.0641250983,
-0.028974073,
-0.0002540326,
0.0062726228,
0.0285327863,
-0.0229371339,
-0.0234933402,
0.0215084609,
0.0018013035,
0.0321387425,
-0.0188599825,
0.0229153298,
0.0140070105,
0.009543879,
0.0142200831,
0.0260032341,
-0.0241783932,
-0.0650939047,
-0.0497651957,
-0.0016132779,
0.004415242,
-0.0277168136,
-0.0117267836,
0.0091414796,
0.0256704893,
-0.023744883,
-0.0063494202,
0.0036114613,
0.0149966851,
0.0542719252,
0.0637862831,
-0.1169453561,
-0.0086286413,
-0.0240207445,
0.0145504288,
0.0304728113,
0.0508545078,
-0.0193114094,
-0.0142944278,
-0.0212979466,
-0.007945328,
-0.0159294363,
0.0074255248,
-0.0118162232,
0.0048808926,
0.0131054306,
0.0203163829,
0.0837912112,
0.0554729477,
-0.03474655,
-0.0064710202,
0.0118839042,
-0.0376606733,
0.0026359004,
0.0211598333,
-0.048375573,
0.0025834246,
-0.0302599519,
0.004920166,
-0.0093426909,
-0.0586543195,
0.004163906,
-0.0327970348,
-0.0155370682,
-0.0022486893,
-0.0100358231,
-0.0276379436,
-0.1209498867,
0.0256513022,
-0.0069101918,
-0.0506054834,
-0.0162836798,
-0.0272455551,
0.0180232134,
0.039805185,
-0.0383089744,
-0.0209966674,
-0.018760683,
-0.0222342946,
0.0299528353,
-0.0187604669,
0.030036889,
-0.045522254,
0.0077263848,
-0.0250020809,
-0.0111748427,
-0.0088836029,
0.0045444458,
0.0085653588,
0.0014383357,
0.009872701,
-0.0432878099,
-0.0370690785,
-0.0360749029,
-0.0283101741,
0.0236625411,
0.0524377935,
-0.0213471185,
-0.0174506009,
-0.009335693,
-0.0070910305,
-0.0038549257,
0.0400538258,
-0.0002530517,
-0.0043815593,
0.0246221051,
0.0038523634,
-0.0120302765,
0.0239616912,
-0.0035879163,
-0.0354781225,
-0.030109534,
-0.0576463304,
-0.0917546079,
-0.0172398947,
0.0060451119,
0.0211763922,
-0.0306361411,
0.0277943052,
0.0640457124,
-0.0105202366,
-0.0520591512,
0.0007256235,
0.0212011449,
0.0016173098,
-0.0297684781,
-0.0434178747,
0.0309652947,
-0.045587413,
0.0045406828,
0.0046125581,
-0.0815629214,
-0.0460239016,
0.0391804837,
-0.0967187881,
0.0085905436,
-0.0101354867,
-0.035857711,
-0.0454556085,
0.0163007993,
0.0173408538,
-0.0513926297,
0.0005907069,
-0.0196233466,
0.0217038933,
-0.0022244812,
0.0024641445,
-0.0045672054,
0.0400756039,
0.0036192806,
-0.0249796342,
-0.0678094774,
0.0102453995,
0.0136996321,
0.024351703,
0.0491963699,
0.0147463977,
-0.0450527593,
-0.0693705156,
-0.0583851896,
-0.0097032702,
0.0029400375,
0.0384528823,
-0.0241516065,
-0.0180830788,
-0.0096928086,
-0.0385111831,
-0.0476212837,
-0.0279279761,
0.0028227374,
0.0300221499,
0.024487298,
-0.0333790593,
0.0302031823,
-0.0293124523,
0.0024583344,
0.0273248721,
-0.0166468415,
0.0132001722,
0.0055447971,
-0.0258040372,
0.0523260906,
-0.0266262293,
-0.075100556,
0.0125222271,
0.0298439674,
-0.0536344983,
0.0186380371,
0.013849332,
0.0590869151,
0.0459675081,
-0.0797256976,
-0.00536296,
-0.0158682466,
0.0144319581,
-0.0054746731,
0.0450071767,
-0.080501996,
-0.0097096236,
0.0025297732,
0.0056558158,
-0.0150771262,
0.0479667224,
0.0380420238,
-0.0110674929,
-0.0396956019,
0.0265386906,
-0.0646011233,
0.0138801951,
0.0601337254,
0.0228974223,
0.0427090898,
-0.0421006046,
0.0480119959,
-0.0228750668,
-0.0056959018,
0.0305814222,
-0.0664953068,
0.02338464,
0.0321707428,
0.0533787012,
0.0682576671,
-0.0168831497,
0.0493699014,
-0.0872513726,
-0.0003160868,
-0.0088165198,
-0.0364731178,
-0.0280126166,
-6.719747252e-33,
0.0276770871,
-0.0580583066,
-0.0118727824,
0.0205200706,
0.0212104358,
0.0004642534,
-0.031431552,
0.0109388614,
-0.0014353024,
0.0140459985,
-0.0274225343,
0.0469125062,
0.0114954412,
-0.0371575244,
-0.0080749625,
-0.0198082011,
0.0077246577,
0.0029606514,
0.0175723732,
0.0303895772,
0.0481305383,
0.0186050553,
0.0135224592,
-0.0804287568,
0.004958801,
-0.0482208952,
0.0237786826,
0.0260541253,
0.1360506415,
0.0360699147,
-0.0169981085,
0.0181956403,
0.0496790372,
-0.0113300737,
0.0398706794,
0.0527082197,
-0.0523634031,
-0.0758105963,
0.0007137584,
-0.0052096103,
-0.007004349,
0.0229353346,
0.001651959,
-0.0059201499,
-0.0039801802,
0.0651058331,
0.0698113739,
0.0135020278,
-0.0122907441,
-0.017820498,
-0.0346108079,
0.0629598126,
-0.00092498,
0.0130793462,
0.016335845,
-0.0265404042,
0.0031060283,
-0.0335925445,
-0.0133568114,
0.0542160869,
-0.0307176933,
-0.0322856717,
-0.0003798512,
0.0162013713,
0.0000196635,
0.0632212013,
0.0077835205,
0.0484423675,
0.054242149,
0.0049997317,
-0.0216751844,
-0.020194225,
-0.0174256042,
-0.0075108898,
0.0072351284,
-0.0370236002,
-0.0322326422,
0.0443976112,
0.0663177297,
0.0133930286,
0.0028256387,
0.0016739683,
-0.0790342763,
-0.0210440755,
0.0302664489,
0.0165965129,
-0.0353715084,
-0.029139597,
-0.0567078181,
0.0137776574,
-0.0293554012,
-0.0147137307,
-0.0191399064,
-0.028619146,
0.0246401168,
0.0249430165,
-0.009889381,
0.0438743606,
-0.0083789434,
0.0233491343,
-0.0995664895,
-0.0674899444,
-0.0221182927,
0.0338682607,
0.0100696506,
0.0049746316,
-0.0258323606,
-0.0339972451,
-0.0454674736,
-0.0043884236,
0.00917916,
-0.0408731215,
-0.0117600476,
-0.0517481305,
0.0072213104,
0.0287841,
-0.0280374642,
0.0603503101,
0.0563347638,
0.0335981399,
-0.0019848282,
-0.0315036662,
-0.0644969866,
0.0076958942,
-0.0201793313,
0.000047115,
-0.0157879032,
0.0387549996,
0.0437391624,
-0.0482277982,
-0.0022838942,
-0.0392737575,
2.745e-7,
0.0067634657,
0.0622047447,
-0.0290678218,
-0.0275031738,
0.0212562624,
0.0217477605,
0.000161565,
0.0418613665,
0.0061667021,
0.0197845474,
0.0333121307,
0.0304136593,
-0.0080976337,
0.0476396866,
-0.0352566279,
0.0405041389,
-0.0536881573,
-0.0258340966,
-0.0489084423,
0.0355017111,
-0.0153023489,
0.0347463824,
0.0340783484,
0.007942779,
-0.0986970589,
-0.0393703207,
0.0158273485,
0.0027701776,
-0.0584269986,
0.0039971191,
0.053426031,
0.030192107,
-0.0133503368,
0.0056226235,
-0.0378771797,
0.0285748038,
0.0549836457,
-0.014876279,
-0.0195042789,
0.0379115455,
0.0163666029,
-0.0470869988,
0.0068319752,
-0.0008992252,
0.0396516137,
-0.0383400656,
-0.0538599566,
-0.0469694138,
0.0407294594,
0.0194833763,
-0.0207256526,
0.0267146304,
-0.0417566635,
0.0328020789,
-0.021033667,
-0.0179442987,
0.0185754672,
-0.0122970985,
0.0287695061,
0.0228953864,
0.0097335055,
-0.0212040991,
-0.0156586878,
0.0093209222,
0.0437699854,
0.0126234023,
0.0488879122,
1.491913438e-34,
0.0193604045,
-0.0051348023,
-0.0695545673,
0.0066925962,
0.0083218524,
-0.0236404333,
-0.0374984518,
0.0547956452,
0.0268921368,
-0.0444738157,
0.0267365538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13042v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13042v1 | The Secret of Metaphor on Expressing Stronger Emotion | 2023-01-30T16:36:02 | 2023-01-30T16:36:02 | Yucheng Li, Frank Guerin, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Metaphors are proven to have stronger emotional impact than literal
expressions. Although this conclusion is shown to be promising in benefiting
various NLP applications, the reasons behind this phenomenon are not well
studied. This paper conducts the first study in exploring how metaphors convey
stronger emotion than their literal counterparts. We find that metaphors are
generally more specific than literal expressions. The more specific property of
metaphor can be one of the reasons for metaphors' superiority in emotion
expression. When we compare metaphors with literal expressions with the same
specificity level, the gap of emotion expressing ability between both reduces
significantly. In addition, we observe specificity is crucial in literal
language as well, as literal language can express stronger emotion by making it
more specific. | [
0.0616880506,
0.0102393702,
-0.0274704844,
-0.0042416905,
-0.007962212,
-0.0016922092,
-0.0267206002,
0.0182770155,
0.0261453241,
-0.061534211,
-0.0127512868,
0.0367466062,
0.0033275892,
-0.033858262,
0.0230489597,
-0.1313000768,
0.0038381526,
0.0593004376,
0.0469686165,
-0.0264369603,
0.0003568223,
0.0436755419,
-0.0102693886,
0.0461487547,
-0.0467767976,
0.0041588475,
0.0152562158,
0.0308012199,
0.0185731798,
-0.056269791,
-0.0226315558,
0.0079734577,
0.0349138156,
-0.0783604681,
0.0000020064,
-0.0351459645,
0.0144804185,
-0.00566631,
0.0375223346,
0.0189571548,
0.1012632251,
-0.0132420138,
0.0225176159,
-0.0200322084,
0.0030673954,
-0.0138568524,
0.0388797373,
0.0862395242,
0.0038635295,
0.0359987691,
-0.0349979624,
-0.0184020065,
-0.0424504466,
0.011171829,
-0.0162677187,
0.0254881456,
-0.0184566379,
0.0289926603,
0.0379366092,
-0.0608160682,
-0.048369538,
-0.0029505671,
0.0019465457,
0.069642894,
-0.0172359236,
0.0211918205,
-0.0177213959,
0.0140766399,
-0.009785383,
0.0217127334,
0.0290928371,
0.0076968712,
-0.0238157306,
-0.0045018997,
0.0024427362,
0.0494946055,
-0.0147222225,
0.0164899807,
0.0215203743,
0.0442005806,
-0.0012620966,
0.0376472659,
-0.0281675234,
0.0509070717,
-0.0055249576,
-0.0150175607,
-0.0190141536,
-0.0000569682,
0.0429778919,
-0.0575023554,
-0.0345357023,
-0.0280662291,
-0.0139269782,
-0.0099360012,
0.0303424112,
0.0133576682,
-0.0274503436,
0.0052955905,
-0.0180640053,
-0.1006137207,
0.0464261509,
0.0356696546,
-0.0294112135,
0.001955762,
-0.0153169557,
0.0285318382,
0.0129017718,
0.0768870935,
-0.0290488452,
-0.0016948209,
-0.0685396641,
-0.0159760695,
-0.0413444005,
0.039994251,
-0.0237801168,
-0.0368962511,
-0.0675750896,
-0.0389697105,
-0.0415178351,
-0.0269637387,
-0.075867489,
0.0424585827,
-0.0379811637,
0.004490565,
-0.0506939255,
-0.0350607187,
-0.1003340036,
0.0534284078,
-0.047193706,
-0.0811918676,
0.0556180999,
0.0180498231,
0.0105649708,
-0.0239630714,
0.0299438238,
0.0725776851,
0.0067538866,
-0.0065811244,
-0.0006414439,
-0.0274523217,
0.0244723465,
-0.0240080152,
-0.0675509796,
-0.0029116271,
0.017224472,
0.0290769469,
0.0535094179,
-0.0417337343,
0.0225933678,
-0.0174895562,
-0.0392000824,
0.0449705273,
-0.0059482418,
0.0058809426,
-0.0329002365,
0.0042361538,
-0.0612316616,
0.0139812045,
0.017073743,
0.0387616269,
0.0283656344,
-0.0233217664,
-0.0022448984,
-0.0412074067,
-0.0408530235,
-0.0148221189,
-0.0589469001,
0.000568312,
-0.0231364742,
0.0608515143,
0.0077413688,
0.0486582965,
-0.0386064053,
0.0471685827,
0.0304291509,
0.067406714,
0.007527051,
0.0303620752,
-0.0062635387,
0.041303087,
0.0473872088,
0.003599003,
0.0004676831,
-0.005075179,
0.0405869,
-0.0018367209,
-0.0150427986,
0.0093756709,
0.0032147074,
0.0084945858,
-0.0730394572,
0.0128128678,
-0.0178275667,
-0.0123078655,
0.0032342591,
0.0085876388,
-0.0055989684,
0.0319011323,
0.0511891395,
-0.0350759998,
-0.0308996215,
-0.007577464,
-0.0398942009,
0.0338800326,
-0.0007192644,
0.001695693,
0.0423238985,
-0.0004581777,
-0.0321971364,
0.0416624695,
-0.0152444337,
0.0518090986,
-0.021954678,
-0.0187819786,
0.059704762,
-0.0415519699,
0.0026422977,
0.0173778255,
-0.0135171693,
0.08439181,
-0.0068910508,
0.0169695485,
-0.0211747475,
0.0334426984,
0.0264275465,
-0.0087729944,
-0.0442962162,
0.0051315394,
0.0012460402,
-0.0173154548,
-0.0282055978,
-0.0054787141,
0.0074394564,
-0.0334979668,
-0.0465902835,
0.1105673015,
-0.0111014415,
0.0264617763,
0.0177096575,
-0.1039546505,
-0.0050356109,
0.003297891,
0.0035833695,
0.0136923594,
0.0288492404,
-0.0376560912,
0.0752012283,
-0.0158178508,
-0.0185498316,
-0.0457623228,
0.0410025455,
0.0279254187,
0.0247231945,
0.020335624,
0.024599893,
-0.0099936165,
-0.0002766803,
-0.0149617027,
0.0469079576,
-0.0184885673,
0.0251337644,
0.0204837378,
0.0087561309,
-0.0085933693,
-0.0576447174,
-0.0668754503,
-0.0328555591,
-0.0565448403,
-0.0021707376,
0.0226889439,
-0.0357348956,
0.0103844507,
-0.049115818,
-0.0319649279,
0.0252831932,
0.0085284077,
-0.00393266,
-0.0392419249,
-0.0117940782,
0.0084218346,
-0.0131187318,
0.0227848012,
-0.046045918,
0.0363940634,
-0.0354078636,
0.0232003313,
0.0220821016,
0.0147074256,
0.0531464219,
0.0057393443,
-0.0497860983,
-0.0162438359,
0.0007633921,
-0.0669750869,
0.0271378551,
0.0194736682,
0.0400057659,
-0.0184800401,
-0.0018294078,
0.0700359941,
0.023542488,
-0.0024280879,
-0.0368821248,
0.0209502541,
-0.0011468215,
0.0014641412,
-0.0443181582,
-0.0605289228,
-0.0123792533,
0.0099011511,
0.0659380555,
0.0063017467,
0.0045502321,
0.0357143134,
-0.0171779413,
-0.0260806214,
0.0146746458,
-0.0186331142,
-0.0035721157,
0.0058713891,
0.0291272812,
-0.0240937006,
0.0168942474,
0.0501805134,
-0.0104851313,
-0.0060684085,
0.0261943582,
-0.0162595678,
0.0943780541,
-0.0561961308,
0.0075548496,
-0.0060269348,
0.01928211,
0.0023266554,
-0.082020089,
-0.0125036305,
-0.026352901,
0.0325566381,
0.0090875607,
-0.0407691039,
0.0116019687,
-0.0303477701,
0.0023174267,
-0.0231695697,
-0.0419155471,
0.0186201781,
0.0322957672,
-0.0036199554,
-0.0385030657,
-0.0423262976,
0.0275098085,
-0.0726259127,
-0.0051232902,
-0.0414898992,
-0.0191562083,
-0.0315929502,
0.0067872489,
0.0075228857,
0.0139554488,
0.0243156161,
0.0337977372,
0.051888749,
0.0010606692,
0.0090517169,
-0.037998274,
0.0360286087,
-0.0022915322,
-0.0276687685,
-0.0007428683,
-0.0345045701,
0.0276078228,
0.0307604913,
0.0392075144,
0.0611808263,
0.0286628474,
0.0694996044,
0.0449265242,
-0.0345862806,
-0.0046217027,
0.0402232297,
0.0115848565,
-0.02057085,
-0.0308150463,
0.017800441,
-0.0132687334,
-0.0353334919,
0.0120947054,
-0.0137876151,
-0.0729611069,
-0.0058997436,
-0.0094829248,
0.0083758468,
-0.0067615444,
0.005100884,
0.0010256529,
0.0191765465,
-0.0001664225,
-0.0299586076,
-0.0249884035,
0.0217228737,
0.0345815085,
0.0102099143,
-0.0098910565,
-0.0129937716,
-0.0296479817,
-0.003403543,
-0.0677905381,
0.1095855683,
-0.0529566854,
0.009703191,
-0.027346259,
0.0471106246,
0.0335637219,
0.0063510868,
-0.0064957906,
-0.0041697896,
0.0117061501,
-0.0462216698,
-0.0087840166,
-0.0069708358,
-0.0033188162,
-0.0102935182,
0.0325482376,
-0.0216210205,
-0.0192580763,
-0.0329440571,
0.0016036608,
-0.0240531191,
0.0612042136,
0.023505969,
-0.0327413343,
0.0103707463,
-0.0050960854,
0.024189407,
0.0234306287,
-0.053351406,
-0.0369384959,
-0.0560610071,
-0.0157685783,
-0.0693376511,
-0.0391827673,
0.0032381266,
0.0548829958,
0.0207782015,
-0.0338217504,
-0.0782011747,
-0.0181787722,
-0.0367182046,
0.0508618653,
0.0222618692,
0.0125014829,
0.0254885685,
-0.0151531668,
0.0467419177,
-0.0026224442,
-0.0074904189,
0.017648777,
0.0256634876,
-0.0583772548,
0.0197009072,
-0.0068732239,
0.0145905903,
-0.0414231643,
0.0334365517,
-0.0345148258,
0.0376932882,
0.0517830513,
-0.01295505,
0.0253083557,
0.014036851,
0.0097315321,
0.0204756763,
0.0116080353,
0.0253474806,
0.0366507284,
0.0156504568,
0.0145928981,
0.0379394852,
0.0401532203,
0.0235643294,
0.0426222645,
-0.0084856274,
0.0024524753,
-0.0786612555,
-0.0003300775,
-0.0554292202,
-0.0207061674,
-0.0477627479,
-0.0039707245,
-0.0173848346,
0.0100250952,
0.0744625553,
-0.0633871928,
-0.0956828892,
-0.0130779715,
0.0120377624,
0.0511359796,
0.0334595293,
0.0558950417,
0.0035960707,
-0.0296707954,
0.0416047759,
-0.0274736136,
-0.0269372407,
-0.0467151776,
0.0181764904,
-0.0321713425,
-0.0271474365,
0.0460062139,
-0.0239549018,
-0.0328346454,
-0.0110385772,
0.0244752131,
-0.0614989474,
0.0329573862,
0.0298482832,
-0.0021087821,
-0.0411742926,
0.0110868374,
-0.0908005834,
0.0354072005,
0.0170375034,
0.0151047576,
0.0202250164,
-0.0321777835,
0.0275578089,
-0.0197247677,
-0.0207419191,
-0.0069517964,
-0.048966825,
-0.1067291498,
0.0516435206,
-0.0041114134,
-0.0419114269,
-0.0096688755,
0.0200591683,
0.057266742,
-0.0128997928,
0.0524842106,
0.0626338273,
-0.0891048238,
-0.0218591113,
0.0799815282,
-0.0615079887,
0.0063975072,
-0.0345870107,
0.0351484418,
0.0309337694,
0.0584507287,
-0.0066501461,
-0.0490991585,
0.0276615303,
-0.0681323409,
0.0261613317,
-0.0172509104,
-6.060708181e-33,
0.0059217606,
0.0058588726,
-0.0675217062,
-0.057339862,
-0.0489635468,
0.0349264257,
-0.0189559832,
0.0263796598,
-0.0070271669,
0.0606495775,
-0.0317008682,
-0.0157264862,
-0.0003718261,
-0.0319862626,
0.0245302375,
0.0258630943,
-0.0020325959,
0.0318240598,
-0.0300668925,
-0.061402861,
0.0815790296,
0.0129634347,
0.074395746,
-0.022232689,
0.0181759894,
0.0362073593,
-0.0213243291,
-0.0595815852,
0.0743548572,
0.015189412,
0.015537383,
0.0675148368,
0.0145355975,
0.0225351974,
0.0044745132,
-0.00618017,
0.0349041112,
-0.0344357155,
0.0394104831,
0.0020740356,
-0.0064792545,
-0.0062127314,
0.0302313697,
-0.0047872984,
-0.0349355489,
-0.0248771794,
0.0452301912,
0.0112472279,
0.0097022755,
-0.0463663228,
-0.0482683927,
-0.0070856689,
-0.0098831886,
0.0278368983,
-0.0104602259,
0.0039195721,
-0.0245429892,
0.071080409,
-0.0451309606,
0.0040363208,
-0.0171631183,
0.0001561305,
-0.0351446904,
-0.0208850279,
0.0066352184,
0.0775405169,
0.0181006826,
0.0197172407,
-0.0123897549,
0.0694836751,
0.0259855893,
0.0474590659,
0.0388460606,
0.0506399609,
0.0984850973,
-0.0498316474,
0.0400563739,
-0.0047166194,
0.0237436704,
0.0374302827,
0.0704379603,
0.0284840912,
-0.0563545153,
0.0297231805,
-0.0421199352,
0.0222556833,
-0.005941791,
-0.04328724,
0.0042420179,
-0.0348164178,
-0.0027812775,
0.0112060206,
-0.0361511186,
0.006282439,
-0.0358822197,
-0.0318048187,
-0.0318166874,
0.0653504804,
-0.0273559336,
-0.0121055646,
0.0152635733,
-0.0268703345,
-0.001988698,
0.0136728454,
0.080707632,
0.0002115835,
0.0026349209,
0.0223339554,
-0.0687347203,
-0.0087981969,
-0.0049119634,
-0.0395936668,
-0.0038789373,
-0.1131326929,
-0.0293475762,
0.0232845657,
-0.018507421,
-0.0459190458,
0.0246551391,
-0.0027720691,
-0.007121243,
0.0303906258,
-0.0326656476,
0.0242314413,
-0.0532095954,
0.0012214987,
-0.0367754176,
-0.0663330927,
0.0157550331,
-0.040929012,
-0.0383483134,
-0.0112536531,
2.779e-7,
-0.0133295581,
0.0475319251,
0.025863938,
0.0080159558,
-0.0207423605,
0.036264047,
0.0087871226,
0.015558809,
0.0041419151,
-0.0080650002,
-0.017030675,
0.0171340592,
0.0187297277,
0.0119056357,
-0.0868945867,
0.0567951649,
-0.0207996108,
0.0116022946,
-0.0188695882,
0.0322746374,
0.0727577955,
0.033569701,
0.0637385622,
0.0149775967,
0.0085052671,
-0.0061841849,
0.015032379,
-0.0937824026,
0.0574548878,
0.0341232382,
0.0153903123,
0.0042811567,
-0.0041113924,
0.0006271953,
0.0267600194,
-0.0306762587,
0.0370089002,
-0.0203819424,
-0.0193760376,
0.0006785893,
0.0141059309,
-0.027030997,
-0.0408557467,
-0.0351135023,
0.0225452427,
-0.0622876957,
-0.054828722,
0.0029249657,
-0.0088712052,
0.0102852844,
0.047191903,
-0.0118237389,
-0.0711290985,
0.0364058316,
0.0043628891,
0.0041567995,
-0.0173129011,
-0.0661635175,
-0.0002694427,
0.0049951244,
-0.0111457566,
-0.0180290975,
0.0115510225,
0.0328646488,
0.0312455967,
-0.0573332235,
-0.0252454598,
1.697023427e-34,
0.0063603092,
0.0098974118,
0.0213642251,
0.0453219414,
0.0712105557,
0.0295187458,
0.0174568109,
-0.0047930218,
0.0210278854,
-0.0191371348,
0.0019119931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13039v1 | Representation biases in sentence transformers | 2023-01-30T16:35:23 | 2023-01-30T16:35:23 | Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL | Variants of the BERT architecture specialised for producing full-sentence
representations often achieve better performance on downstream tasks than
sentence embeddings extracted from vanilla BERT. However, there is still little
understanding of what properties of inputs determine the properties of such
representations. In this study, we construct several sets of sentences with
pre-defined lexical and syntactic structures and show that SOTA sentence
transformers have a strong nominal-participant-set bias: cosine similarities
between pairs of sentences are more strongly determined by the overlap in the
set of their noun participants than by having the same predicates, lengthy
nominal modifiers, or adjuncts. At the same time, the precise
syntactic-thematic functions of the participants are largely irrelevant. | [
0.0233117994,
0.0148108443,
-0.034105774,
0.0524598323,
-0.0370907933,
0.0147343734,
-0.004547595,
-0.0273949616,
-0.0240711085,
-0.069041349,
-0.0339424983,
0.0018634496,
-0.0290629379,
-0.0357423425,
0.0389600545,
-0.0531234369,
0.045709908,
0.0360761993,
-0.0177868903,
-0.0091935331,
0.0401531681,
-0.0022767684,
0.0162115302,
0.0498335958,
-0.0260006078,
-0.0028197819,
0.0090634916,
-0.0047187479,
0.0099578574,
0.0015750632,
0.0385343879,
0.0225009397,
0.0148266079,
0.0127948085,
0.0000013759,
-0.0567989647,
0.0129758082,
-0.008601998,
0.0160511564,
0.0328702144,
-0.0200062245,
-0.0040748343,
0.0077645439,
0.0217581578,
0.0013641227,
-0.0032658949,
0.0412651561,
0.0566711389,
0.0610080436,
0.0592023842,
-0.0340634137,
-0.0224054791,
-0.0026288202,
-0.0008323846,
-0.0151603408,
0.0370230526,
0.0060899113,
-0.0473783426,
0.0185741987,
-0.0055871899,
-0.0105078109,
-0.0024837111,
-0.0010345523,
0.0250880569,
0.0027172107,
0.0270483363,
-0.1182101294,
-0.0132952994,
0.0003161344,
0.0324794315,
0.0455779545,
-0.0198221784,
0.0067470656,
0.0222494751,
0.0125028882,
0.0394718908,
-0.0198534261,
0.042342674,
-0.003379978,
0.0502676032,
0.0468295962,
0.0344724134,
-0.0248227697,
-0.0214245189,
-0.0266693737,
0.0124797439,
0.0520921238,
-0.073248595,
-0.0316184983,
0.0574832894,
-0.0366866551,
-0.0388091467,
0.0443824269,
-0.0380707085,
-0.0340172574,
0.0000339073,
-0.0454581752,
-0.0585092679,
0.0102057541,
-0.0456731617,
0.0625310987,
0.0450577103,
-0.0393748395,
0.007920539,
-0.0393013991,
0.0809059143,
-0.0447784699,
0.0513792783,
-0.0620964244,
-0.0218972303,
-0.0472248495,
-0.0351399705,
-0.0726678148,
0.0573699772,
0.0134712271,
-0.026028771,
-0.0376694985,
0.0336547084,
0.0229340773,
-0.0047832341,
0.0314259827,
0.0170883518,
-0.059436474,
0.0292193647,
-0.0305704083,
0.0484053828,
-0.0557492077,
0.0242629182,
-0.0117836604,
-0.0230714288,
-0.0032518043,
0.0233006105,
0.0397182219,
-0.0735812187,
-0.0086416164,
0.0304724053,
-0.0001724883,
-0.052832216,
-0.0019349261,
0.0163321029,
-0.0312355701,
-0.0386541151,
0.0057279412,
-0.0195325781,
0.0403733253,
0.026659077,
0.0067119049,
0.0353863649,
0.006284609,
0.0272636786,
-0.0215042066,
0.0625689104,
0.0488938205,
-0.005151642,
-0.039565891,
-0.0216559116,
0.0310372524,
0.0416767225,
0.020843694,
0.024355825,
0.0317874327,
-0.0006812653,
-0.0350594483,
0.0176973324,
-0.0110795256,
-0.0191802923,
-0.011029019,
0.0164572019,
-0.0022627616,
0.0604026988,
0.0176573992,
0.056381464,
-0.0377923064,
0.031388171,
0.0620238148,
0.0553198382,
0.0013906831,
0.053628739,
0.0333921015,
-0.0090056872,
0.0049676243,
0.0718998834,
-0.0517773293,
-0.0053318301,
0.0273203012,
-0.0063852035,
-0.0232161246,
0.0285064392,
-0.0346025042,
0.0026113752,
-0.0328256935,
-0.0160627794,
-0.0239398181,
-0.0501448177,
0.0181546975,
0.024157729,
-0.0414289758,
0.0966206267,
-0.0065964982,
-0.1057267115,
-0.0086567933,
0.0052354122,
-0.0172394328,
0.038137652,
0.0369535983,
-0.031480141,
-0.0239822511,
0.0132672982,
-0.0092311697,
0.0748479441,
0.038116917,
0.0141765252,
0.0034523797,
-0.0282706916,
-0.0122774914,
-0.0468214974,
0.0186209418,
0.013343282,
0.0072729886,
-0.0021487947,
0.0116931545,
-0.0480413586,
0.0351703987,
0.0530424602,
0.0164153501,
-0.0045075645,
-0.007416659,
0.0295703523,
0.0439045094,
0.0211852174,
-0.0101509895,
0.0325979181,
0.008668948,
-0.0640501976,
-0.0334072001,
0.0429497249,
-0.0433928557,
-0.0962891206,
-0.0032062107,
-0.0701553449,
-0.0445138328,
0.078397736,
-0.0132000763,
-0.0026258179,
0.0053718085,
-0.0808886811,
0.0685795695,
-0.0551518127,
0.0035369915,
0.0138829872,
0.0173967797,
-0.0416972637,
0.0638776869,
0.0332966,
0.0057716458,
-0.0231468901,
-0.0393506959,
0.0450605787,
-0.0308002066,
-0.0200578347,
-0.0283661224,
-0.0064454796,
-0.0028454985,
0.0531218201,
-0.0340180993,
-0.0016560251,
-0.0544175319,
-0.1081600264,
-0.0034130465,
-0.0285215396,
0.0399648286,
0.0462473258,
0.0260263439,
0.0076811351,
0.0267439019,
-0.0234858617,
-0.0275433939,
-0.0125109414,
0.0455991141,
0.0561964139,
-0.0322901867,
-0.0366391428,
-0.0227293428,
-0.0037483983,
-0.0654145256,
0.0675413311,
-0.007535832,
-0.0281036291,
-0.0470340103,
-0.0000157871,
-0.0029624607,
-0.0216894001,
0.0233843978,
-0.0569130778,
0.035572499,
0.0316289105,
0.0798738152,
0.0477771908,
0.0203126911,
0.0465745516,
0.0310320091,
-0.0101067284,
-0.0163386054,
0.0235316344,
-0.031481009,
-0.0007574287,
-0.0502696782,
-0.0125634717,
0.0543211438,
0.0735085532,
0.027396502,
-0.0173990112,
-0.0505460799,
-0.0331460685,
-0.0068460167,
0.0163159706,
-0.0074692825,
-0.0560604744,
-0.0307632107,
-0.0131269973,
-0.0290467869,
0.0092250546,
0.0564237684,
-0.0137723386,
-0.0112217963,
-0.0781132504,
0.0059681796,
-0.0532657243,
0.0445401967,
0.0349752121,
0.0193058122,
0.0384940393,
-0.0321233943,
-0.0593933649,
0.0153625738,
0.0419504233,
0.0091055585,
0.0041214894,
0.0272315945,
0.0120351668,
-0.0050348486,
-0.0681753606,
-0.0211404078,
-0.0507470779,
0.0022969553,
0.0241293982,
0.0194632523,
-0.0080767274,
-0.0170232207,
-0.0236604512,
-0.0019553518,
-0.0004945658,
0.0023255493,
0.0052563776,
-0.0503244065,
0.0879677609,
0.0059251734,
0.0311210304,
-0.0110082095,
-0.0148211066,
-0.0157680716,
0.0294622537,
0.0125496052,
0.0060881441,
-0.0408736467,
-0.0010856984,
0.0167732127,
-0.0611370914,
-0.0547457561,
-0.0208967142,
0.0794843808,
0.0029094317,
-0.0177735277,
0.0989416465,
0.0423641689,
0.0067618,
0.0298614148,
0.0011934816,
0.045192942,
0.0177587811,
0.0153381499,
-0.0598004684,
-0.0424823947,
0.0162060484,
-0.0281769913,
-0.01428736,
-0.0123167122,
-0.00281952,
-0.1010053903,
0.0234546587,
-0.0199167076,
-0.0152093554,
-0.0246663298,
-0.0263197757,
0.0118886167,
-0.0104311462,
0.0238780826,
-0.0137470709,
-0.0197860021,
0.0084918495,
0.0000416848,
-0.0170096345,
-0.0125244707,
0.0028335988,
-0.0639527589,
0.0079276171,
0.0660207942,
0.0448270813,
-0.0007900004,
0.007074886,
0.0323129594,
-0.0994463563,
0.0139739532,
0.0428034998,
0.0494838133,
-0.0329564512,
-0.0266893823,
-0.035899125,
0.0207495373,
-0.0321015194,
-0.0162704363,
-0.0062218215,
0.0707451329,
0.0066144085,
-0.0279011857,
-0.0172842052,
-0.0324949697,
-0.0254233014,
0.0891254693,
0.0698507801,
-0.0061488594,
-0.045971144,
0.0023994606,
0.0180653837,
-0.008980847,
-0.00883862,
-0.0076914201,
-0.0199816376,
-0.0099324929,
-0.0657097474,
-0.0729304776,
-0.0046770866,
-0.034909986,
-0.0146641741,
-0.010299338,
0.0049471878,
-0.0121630114,
-0.0210072529,
0.0356847495,
0.0019960126,
0.0158037152,
-0.0006642017,
-0.028482249,
0.036483936,
0.0267654974,
-0.0281648468,
-0.0534079,
-0.0494052619,
-0.0496796705,
0.0261133779,
-0.0040739551,
0.0044948841,
0.0008815743,
0.0093051214,
-0.0143877063,
0.0565609299,
0.0578696355,
-0.0284768492,
0.0334291533,
0.0355967432,
-0.0184796024,
0.0175047014,
0.051221218,
-0.0191562958,
0.0139660789,
-0.0199438278,
0.0762704164,
-0.0028360516,
-0.0066360272,
0.0470156297,
0.0195072107,
0.0750595778,
-0.0009036497,
0.0543130673,
-0.0257566646,
0.0119816205,
-0.0609756596,
-0.0114300773,
-0.0427604914,
-0.0304281507,
0.0069989362,
0.0416782759,
-0.0261045583,
0.0492508411,
-0.0354012735,
0.0363616273,
-0.0310454164,
0.0342776477,
-0.0092794839,
0.00109003,
-0.0167132188,
0.0115940031,
-0.0037326892,
0.0153642967,
-0.000145558,
-0.0086641237,
-0.0292569976,
-0.0227264725,
0.020488156,
0.0170930885,
-0.0400013737,
0.039365869,
-0.0767758563,
0.036489699,
-0.0240826216,
0.0314486362,
0.0167567749,
-0.0513506234,
0.0445242114,
-0.0495291241,
-0.0026204381,
0.0337171629,
0.0262432825,
-0.0124136992,
-0.013347649,
0.0335874557,
-0.0066393446,
-0.0199685059,
-0.0637540519,
0.0846178159,
-0.0122162029,
0.0590581447,
-0.0131332558,
-0.0324735567,
-0.0399542786,
-0.0637699962,
0.0586279109,
-0.0340587161,
-0.0219530985,
-0.014435973,
-0.0218736585,
-0.0342817307,
0.0239214599,
-0.0337171592,
0.0122124534,
-0.0305866264,
0.0427324399,
0.04246388,
0.0002245986,
-0.0328600816,
0.017370021,
-0.0000509675,
-0.0263438001,
-0.0202300791,
-0.0308555644,
-5.532687506e-33,
-0.0318493471,
0.0430128351,
-0.022857599,
-0.0136867492,
-0.0334878638,
0.0311528072,
-0.0289733745,
-0.0013137402,
0.0218337998,
0.0328102894,
-0.0078042881,
0.020766912,
0.0159906205,
0.021599466,
0.0007147469,
-0.040971797,
0.0394527055,
-0.0110664852,
-0.024501415,
-0.0283144563,
0.0135199493,
0.0110275187,
0.0643113181,
-0.0268293973,
-0.0316707417,
-0.0021475519,
0.0184315052,
0.0031209858,
0.0125405956,
0.0687601864,
-0.006258992,
0.0679867864,
0.0280655324,
0.0014027539,
-0.0193162002,
0.0718507394,
-0.0385567248,
-0.0774014294,
0.0260765906,
0.0153639978,
-0.0242710877,
-0.0353164151,
0.0279229339,
-0.0333158486,
-0.026825875,
-0.0009854985,
0.0476524681,
0.0132522294,
0.0181581136,
-0.0188266225,
-0.0666166246,
-0.0299848113,
-0.0120279025,
0.0336726606,
-0.0060384506,
0.0501838736,
-0.0041549155,
0.0356317051,
0.0177021381,
0.0328075327,
-0.0153186442,
0.056765005,
-0.0099131018,
-0.0182462838,
0.0100394851,
0.0583349541,
0.0423747152,
0.003371106,
-0.0465286896,
-0.017318204,
0.0038547206,
0.0296869539,
0.0295230523,
0.0696766078,
0.034810666,
0.0409495346,
-0.0625950545,
0.0069643338,
0.0210613906,
0.0201633032,
0.0242505353,
0.0021931003,
-0.0242270604,
-0.0314515531,
-0.0158589985,
0.0070747174,
-0.0148205385,
-0.0174129475,
0.0510785878,
-0.0122169629,
0.0042457394,
0.0152721703,
0.008333141,
-0.0331646539,
-0.0081307078,
-0.02248713,
-0.0219329614,
0.000952413,
0.008751235,
0.00752998,
-0.0754470825,
-0.0671317726,
0.0057806442,
0.0242592618,
0.008087921,
0.0181192644,
0.0525262393,
0.0078295916,
-0.0340660773,
0.0052762963,
-0.0267832894,
-0.0664892644,
-0.0785766691,
-0.0264257938,
0.0320765264,
0.0306477994,
-0.0091587109,
-0.0068620946,
0.0279363096,
0.0114117181,
-0.0498369597,
-0.017454898,
0.012284725,
0.0428752825,
0.0137630375,
0.0104711577,
-0.0815949142,
0.0347821228,
0.0205243602,
-0.0525346696,
-0.0160592031,
-0.03517811,
2.314e-7,
0.0353976674,
0.0498904325,
0.0687005073,
-0.0080221519,
0.0090997815,
0.0173510574,
0.0181660503,
0.0956269279,
-0.0056242719,
0.0054938062,
0.0360696688,
0.0132532297,
-0.0009476192,
0.0225557759,
-0.0817291439,
0.0278757643,
-0.0589698739,
-0.0029405169,
-0.080062665,
0.032086961,
0.0957299694,
0.063505128,
0.0148273241,
0.0134489033,
-0.0113977948,
-0.0393908992,
0.0772447512,
-0.0173430722,
-0.0242131092,
0.0216835644,
-0.0402290262,
-0.0132333003,
0.012162772,
0.0462533832,
0.0131224049,
0.0206930786,
0.0186344702,
-0.0222140551,
-0.0030577129,
-0.0284404587,
-0.0121284453,
-0.0203636438,
-0.0342559852,
-0.0216522124,
0.0475281365,
-0.0938563049,
-0.0393019691,
0.016216971,
-0.0323451012,
0.0113148233,
0.0249724481,
0.0298353992,
-0.0492812321,
0.0050557354,
0.0470701493,
0.0061494559,
-0.021323096,
-0.0706866533,
-0.0412209816,
-0.0040856381,
-0.0591375753,
-0.0532521158,
-0.0529011786,
0.021286292,
0.0556556173,
-0.0541943684,
-0.0021147244,
2.280150933e-34,
0.0070697991,
0.0387857705,
0.0563883036,
0.003323531,
0.0134031279,
-0.0335195884,
0.0403095186,
-0.000296862,
0.0211142208,
-0.044498343,
0.0001835109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13003v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13003v2 | Knowledge Transfer from Pre-trained Language Models to Cif-based Speech Recognizers via Hierarchical Distillation | 2023-01-30T15:44:55 | 2023-05-28T16:13:52 | Minglun Han, Feilong Chen, Jing Shi, Shuang Xu, Bo Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large-scale pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown great potential in
natural language processing tasks. Leveraging the capabilities of PLMs to
enhance automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems has also emerged as a
promising research direction. However, previous works may be limited by the
inflexible structures of PLMs and the insufficient utilization of PLMs. To
alleviate these problems, we propose the hierarchical knowledge distillation
(HKD) on the continuous integrate-and-fire (CIF) based ASR models. To transfer
knowledge from PLMs to the ASR models, HKD employs cross-modal knowledge
distillation with contrastive loss at the acoustic level and knowledge
distillation with regression loss at the linguistic level. Compared with the
original CIF-based model, our method achieves 15% and 9% relative error rate
reduction on the AISHELL-1 and LibriSpeech datasets, respectively. | [
-0.028215982,
0.0828897879,
0.0091097802,
0.0438220575,
-0.0277150981,
0.0270514246,
0.0290006958,
-0.0217945315,
-0.0211521331,
-0.0512860231,
-0.0728402659,
-0.0384622999,
0.0431623384,
0.0418081097,
0.009386451,
-0.0203512628,
0.0318168923,
-0.093026191,
0.0107280388,
-0.0195995681,
0.0180410147,
-0.004669535,
-0.0116568208,
-0.0196043849,
0.0129018035,
-0.0102226203,
-0.0225411449,
-0.0111212702,
0.0338634402,
-0.0150494454,
-0.0018997003,
0.0334653109,
0.0518734679,
0.0362857059,
0.0000022356,
-0.0289757531,
-0.0174114779,
0.0119866626,
-0.0563330911,
0.0122719333,
0.0495657437,
0.0095918914,
0.0250324365,
0.0251012854,
-0.0198152773,
-0.0277109686,
0.0181912351,
0.0310682692,
0.0551001616,
0.0502464287,
0.011726955,
-0.082198076,
0.055859901,
0.0018412524,
-0.036408022,
-0.0177223124,
0.0193168838,
0.0236716159,
-0.0413998775,
-0.026365228,
-0.0272054169,
0.0746061429,
0.0065744254,
0.0155899348,
-0.0000300857,
-0.0279460754,
-0.0359430648,
-0.0080935545,
-0.0280697104,
0.0577059239,
-0.0112223634,
-0.0340698101,
0.0000448789,
0.0080856225,
-0.0749608278,
-0.0030946885,
-0.0442327186,
-0.0194567982,
0.0004863304,
0.0097021796,
-0.0020304869,
0.010179189,
0.029333951,
-0.0050964439,
-0.0653401241,
0.0149276452,
0.019103352,
-0.0306654647,
0.0427663662,
-0.0667602941,
-0.0148183694,
-0.008634734,
0.0442550667,
0.008316461,
0.0064113457,
0.0154137565,
-0.0470980331,
-0.0010066604,
-0.0071443915,
-0.031570293,
0.039460402,
0.0392731763,
-0.0271374136,
0.0207828917,
-0.0289451815,
0.0768498033,
0.0088478411,
0.0321733542,
-0.0467679016,
-0.0197453443,
-0.0812107921,
-0.0058958326,
-0.0365884416,
0.0317791104,
0.0020384963,
-0.0372176096,
-0.0271130223,
0.0020891041,
-0.0073541608,
-0.0290876683,
0.0232938323,
-0.0100105153,
-0.0344643518,
-0.032618057,
-0.001289861,
0.0814932212,
0.0607845448,
0.0474390648,
0.003667807,
-0.0237213355,
-0.0049367375,
0.0074341637,
0.0297127906,
0.0267820805,
0.0170948338,
0.0310789086,
-0.0120434677,
-0.0648347437,
-0.0540230423,
0.0046367431,
-0.008982351,
-0.0684963018,
0.0090565113,
-0.0536003448,
0.0571653731,
-0.0266968627,
0.0200457796,
-0.056274429,
0.008141336,
-0.0315424353,
-0.0248236172,
0.0966042653,
-0.0402805842,
0.019724343,
0.0163267888,
0.0076025603,
-0.0014657973,
0.0541961156,
0.036783129,
-0.0118935863,
-0.0085748052,
-0.0266230386,
-0.0114214448,
0.0341687426,
0.0122546162,
0.0280442145,
-0.0376893729,
-0.0121665187,
-0.0270231254,
-0.0343048833,
0.0652932972,
0.054107435,
-0.0181455221,
0.0223782305,
0.072012797,
0.0281970557,
0.0633280724,
0.019076582,
0.035535194,
0.0135463886,
0.0228773113,
-0.0093180127,
-0.0133732632,
-0.0494346954,
-0.0355148874,
0.0116594424,
0.0803920254,
0.0549177006,
-0.045976907,
-0.0300195981,
0.0260577705,
-0.0178613327,
-0.0111247785,
0.0439554714,
0.0631938726,
0.0173576903,
-0.0100994026,
0.0260227714,
0.0501310006,
-0.0203394424,
0.051095821,
-0.0300964918,
-0.016886849,
0.0535240322,
0.0182609875,
-0.0517791063,
0.0001767491,
-0.0011704913,
0.0079294238,
0.0029547452,
-0.0141928522,
-0.0119025344,
0.0678075552,
-0.0437880009,
-0.0434841663,
0.0705371276,
-0.0010908659,
0.026643198,
-0.0198827758,
0.0227874164,
0.042274259,
-0.0245442409,
-0.0072930683,
-0.0015589538,
-0.0339427441,
-0.0349919684,
-0.0221097451,
0.0125652738,
0.03889855,
0.013349426,
-0.0261544008,
0.0019642184,
0.0240744948,
-0.0337326825,
-0.0207473971,
0.0070209699,
-0.0537136197,
-0.0841322914,
0.0603479855,
0.0144915693,
0.0519022718,
-0.0135466531,
-0.0250396729,
-0.0625805035,
0.0290899966,
0.0126013421,
0.0713740662,
-0.0286729727,
0.0637207851,
0.0472228751,
-0.0178765096,
-0.0029276372,
0.0184779726,
-0.0295681451,
-0.0206974465,
-0.0206248723,
0.0013768526,
-0.0265146941,
-0.0226787329,
-0.0239178073,
0.0236714222,
-0.0370302647,
0.0313793421,
-0.0173961148,
0.0071566096,
-0.008804312,
0.0335787125,
-0.0766297653,
-0.0171733219,
-0.0297291689,
0.0343562029,
0.0068595,
0.0376158506,
-0.0063248612,
0.0023777545,
-0.0151290633,
-0.0058917576,
-0.0079025971,
0.0182756502,
-0.0390653349,
-0.0040286952,
-0.0168063417,
-0.0330868885,
-0.0070400741,
0.0112913167,
0.0601789132,
-0.0678249523,
-0.0115341432,
-0.0337555446,
0.0566358082,
0.0131185269,
0.0458903648,
-0.0288221836,
-0.0220397878,
-0.0331539176,
-0.0299380776,
-0.0051052049,
-0.0151487757,
-0.004644949,
-0.012033348,
0.0090323109,
-0.0537875146,
-0.0444320589,
0.0076305578,
-0.028848296,
0.0083166966,
-0.0125929862,
0.0196337868,
-0.0010433102,
0.0630398542,
0.0056764721,
0.0281377807,
0.0077462941,
-0.0463993028,
0.0054545901,
-0.0323660187,
-0.0379715972,
-0.0284493491,
-0.0225620139,
-0.0074946084,
-0.0134078981,
-0.0439557396,
0.0129747596,
-0.1177543253,
-0.0038759515,
-0.0580083132,
-0.0439299718,
-0.016770605,
0.0369484723,
-0.003387833,
0.0068391138,
0.01828219,
0.0017117754,
-0.0374904759,
0.0116186533,
0.0098063787,
-0.050072249,
0.0322389528,
-0.0496526547,
0.0127235055,
0.0137967505,
-0.0090958485,
-0.0268270075,
-0.0414735638,
-0.014151644,
0.0279320199,
0.0142568564,
0.0017931863,
-0.0077770352,
0.0489494577,
0.0296295155,
0.0641117021,
0.0170266554,
0.0126785059,
-0.0468553565,
0.0942877457,
0.0265367106,
0.0057176398,
0.000956617,
-0.007160346,
0.0454411283,
0.0136638097,
0.0672668517,
-0.0411353782,
-0.0437044166,
0.0035857297,
0.0343928896,
0.0170086995,
-0.0142108621,
-0.0151843475,
0.0311130416,
-0.0756393149,
0.0062840153,
0.0941788033,
-0.0045554456,
-0.0243236851,
-0.0211670212,
0.0500994027,
0.0288508572,
0.0020266657,
-0.0136107989,
-0.0588348433,
-0.034773387,
0.0361162238,
0.0103164464,
0.012396073,
0.0209444594,
-0.01451346,
-0.100095883,
0.0063804951,
0.0404019654,
-0.0063221264,
-0.0837957487,
-0.0279965475,
-0.0204595178,
0.0209054835,
-0.0133795692,
0.0093189264,
-0.0340706296,
-0.0247853305,
0.0518144034,
-0.0542137958,
-0.0680954978,
-0.015304124,
-0.0439613834,
0.0645803511,
0.046644792,
0.0011406278,
0.0040736198,
-0.0151191354,
0.0232215654,
-0.0421376564,
-0.0100443009,
-0.0321400985,
0.0046498468,
-0.0045501916,
0.0144055011,
0.0552092195,
0.0201281272,
-0.0388259552,
-0.0396756344,
-0.0000623289,
0.0448247977,
-0.0339099765,
-0.0167150516,
0.0056009712,
0.0006179755,
0.016746711,
0.0669386685,
0.0149547756,
0.0066868835,
0.0111897169,
0.0107002323,
-0.0143599538,
0.0319360122,
0.0111401742,
0.0234387573,
-0.0280254818,
-0.0152013255,
-0.0252459086,
0.0040007387,
0.0168316569,
0.0459705219,
0.0023872522,
0.0096067749,
0.0114025539,
0.0403081365,
-0.0256723091,
0.0097281225,
-0.0297882967,
0.0125893932,
-0.0402290523,
0.0006290652,
0.020480575,
-0.0562582947,
-0.0581158362,
0.0161270164,
-0.0961146504,
-0.0658826753,
-0.0071316035,
0.0350060835,
0.0190767311,
0.0587104373,
-0.0307257809,
-0.0434289537,
0.1308155507,
-0.0022914633,
-0.0304371994,
0.0223472025,
0.0359774977,
-0.0103580328,
0.0081824474,
0.0154326707,
-0.0206702556,
0.0243139565,
0.0118192863,
0.0428242274,
-0.0363138318,
-0.0616557747,
-0.0046527325,
0.0167026334,
0.0789157972,
0.0189230032,
0.0065081855,
-0.028716458,
0.0514189564,
0.0361421295,
0.0151392668,
-0.0516624115,
-0.0149767268,
0.0298744813,
0.0335505642,
-0.0131438058,
-0.0062180222,
0.0455900021,
-0.0157985538,
0.0120211737,
0.0305544324,
0.0508007407,
0.0046777511,
0.025302384,
0.0000650153,
-0.0084734131,
0.0656290278,
0.0219126754,
-0.0168121364,
-0.0368462726,
0.0470858254,
-0.0166668631,
-0.0071437089,
-0.0484890267,
0.0268617384,
-0.0656582043,
-0.0595447309,
-0.0423859395,
0.0155089404,
0.042593427,
0.0089616766,
0.0433472581,
0.0110350549,
0.0108533399,
-0.0534381494,
0.0196595509,
0.0017084435,
0.0418987237,
0.043152146,
0.0238114465,
-0.0104981456,
0.0296539459,
0.0862675682,
0.0347506143,
0.0431646444,
-0.0220642537,
-0.0041431529,
-0.0106795477,
-0.0275686756,
0.0318874642,
0.0430422127,
-0.0463679396,
0.0025941022,
-0.0385712758,
-0.0720006749,
0.0426925719,
-0.0238365345,
0.0301900227,
-0.0215181671,
0.0398987606,
0.0066587431,
-0.0358540602,
0.0061218548,
0.0079020672,
-0.0184755065,
0.0060093147,
-0.0187427644,
0.0256764814,
-6.906689792e-33,
-0.0413756631,
0.0517516546,
0.0007317839,
0.020643305,
-0.0555776954,
-0.003060153,
-0.0105079468,
-0.0016174334,
0.0172823649,
-0.0063206446,
-0.0116887633,
-0.005547652,
0.0418321863,
0.0213553552,
-0.0185815264,
-0.0183750186,
0.0920723751,
-0.013648646,
0.0453239791,
0.013129754,
0.0415033251,
0.0670843348,
0.0280582216,
-0.0431423895,
-0.058975935,
0.0142792407,
-0.0010005712,
0.031934604,
0.01683544,
0.0157047231,
-0.0544630438,
0.0366100743,
-0.0033879539,
-0.0029701223,
-0.0380944274,
0.0386745483,
-0.0868424028,
0.0278028585,
0.0258640982,
0.0017465546,
0.0075731962,
-0.0139890248,
0.0607758127,
0.0242049061,
0.0326881818,
-0.0320209973,
-0.0006462553,
-0.0323011354,
-0.0202321839,
-0.0816323832,
-0.0606469959,
0.0440894179,
-0.0019672287,
-0.0415745936,
0.0851182118,
0.0107315173,
-0.0170804113,
0.0244413801,
-0.0770079419,
0.0041644592,
0.0266831461,
0.0631088316,
0.0518795326,
0.0435126685,
-0.0312035792,
0.0423346981,
0.0044462224,
-0.0617450885,
0.0178919416,
-0.0147066657,
0.0632823557,
0.0853950754,
-0.0270284396,
0.0338775925,
0.0365879051,
-0.0278812181,
-0.0341794565,
-0.0227336995,
-0.0313436389,
0.0362042747,
-0.0107744727,
0.0358669311,
-0.0109560108,
-0.0221923217,
-0.0722527057,
-0.0439951345,
-0.0375213698,
0.0129273161,
0.0369685702,
0.0143858744,
-0.0120766712,
-0.0234082751,
0.0523406044,
-0.0493288822,
0.0101788109,
0.0115158241,
0.0000913583,
0.0102062169,
-0.0227859449,
0.0524822921,
-0.0852033198,
-0.0582569465,
-0.0171321966,
0.0060421075,
-0.0056547546,
-0.0511922836,
0.0225609876,
0.0623988323,
-0.0495901853,
-0.0262142196,
-0.0198284891,
-0.034010116,
0.0457599834,
0.0511500724,
0.0465525016,
0.0039928523,
-0.0126091521,
0.0148800183,
-0.0101284692,
-0.0266868994,
-0.0130553171,
0.0047591268,
0.022982331,
0.041666545,
-0.008636253,
-0.0253414121,
-0.0161205847,
-0.0418076217,
0.0074232533,
-0.0423876084,
-0.0136434715,
0.0160585716,
3.062e-7,
0.0005822742,
0.0083419411,
-0.0004348816,
-0.0303392466,
0.0302327406,
0.0184609592,
-0.0099963294,
0.0079953782,
0.0221277867,
-0.0197811369,
0.0388743132,
0.0169593915,
0.0903786793,
0.0247460417,
-0.0655924082,
-0.0500625335,
-0.0208774488,
-0.0187325645,
-0.0021603657,
-0.0378235057,
0.0452180356,
0.0761462152,
0.0199390408,
-0.0441675261,
-0.0009723016,
-0.0243777316,
0.0444040336,
0.032039132,
0.0106806839,
0.0188184101,
-0.023445271,
-0.0306861792,
-0.0287170876,
0.0799099654,
-0.0103418175,
0.0448026136,
0.0278787054,
0.0530694425,
-0.0015998675,
-0.0421894044,
-0.0147833619,
0.0471375883,
-0.0125541966,
-0.0464100838,
0.0748806521,
-0.0478305854,
0.0316482261,
-0.031436462,
-0.0550655127,
-0.0346440449,
-0.0061453846,
0.0015027056,
0.0092207892,
0.0288808532,
-0.0076916586,
-0.0201350059,
-0.0559998304,
-0.078382194,
0.0112665538,
0.0420917235,
-0.0629987568,
-0.0446358249,
-0.042910438,
-0.0158492271,
0.0523958467,
-0.0137282116,
0.0232455656,
2.763860429e-34,
0.0312606432,
-0.0109489365,
-0.0044377274,
0.0094154831,
-0.0049122255,
-0.0318617038,
-0.0427739397,
0.0164303277,
-0.0011280359,
-0.1249783188,
0.0035085175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12971v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12971v2 | Quantifying Context Mixing in Transformers | 2023-01-30T15:19:02 | 2023-02-08T10:46:38 | Hosein Mohebbi, Willem Zuidema, Grzegorz Chrupała, Afra Alishahi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Self-attention weights and their transformed variants have been the main
source of information for analyzing token-to-token interactions in
Transformer-based models. But despite their ease of interpretation, these
weights are not faithful to the models' decisions as they are only one part of
an encoder, and other components in the encoder layer can have considerable
impact on information mixing in the output representations. In this work, by
expanding the scope of analysis to the whole encoder block, we propose Value
Zeroing, a novel context mixing score customized for Transformers that provides
us with a deeper understanding of how information is mixed at each encoder
layer. We demonstrate the superiority of our context mixing score over other
analysis methods through a series of complementary evaluations with different
viewpoints based on linguistically informed rationales, probing, and
faithfulness analysis. | [
-0.035224162,
0.0000618755,
0.013011829,
0.034598764,
-0.0084781116,
-0.0033258104,
0.0298969373,
-0.0202519484,
-0.1006307527,
-0.0357370935,
-0.0649514422,
-0.0129132168,
0.0290376544,
0.0250197519,
0.0326832198,
-0.031747181,
0.0250745174,
0.0237427596,
-0.0666998327,
-0.0173006207,
-0.0165587068,
-0.0249737054,
0.0351633281,
0.0734762773,
-0.0151036885,
-0.0300578717,
0.0017658403,
0.0300958026,
0.0599451661,
0.0145349177,
-0.0043251007,
0.0142531144,
0.0046367645,
0.0419775844,
0.0000019522,
-0.0370544083,
-0.0150668845,
0.0089990767,
-0.0153476894,
0.0189481042,
0.0195973404,
-0.0098851575,
-0.0364591181,
-0.0244980305,
0.0139870774,
0.0178206451,
0.1114778295,
0.0600553118,
0.0582211167,
0.043965973,
-0.0160218813,
-0.0305476971,
0.0006638398,
-0.0108293304,
0.0199984666,
0.0137375202,
0.0178742465,
-0.0288357083,
-0.0536191426,
-0.0186842512,
-0.0562655106,
0.0205029398,
0.0499136224,
-0.0120536936,
0.0140410597,
0.0156786814,
-0.0203657951,
-0.0155708445,
-0.0075361505,
0.0214383863,
-0.0499585047,
-0.0044674166,
-0.0279504266,
-0.0164707843,
-0.0232663285,
-0.0112275453,
-0.0355640575,
-0.0043000588,
0.0320910327,
0.0105441073,
-0.0323486291,
0.0717067868,
0.0243354011,
-0.0628546998,
-0.0562075749,
0.0733192042,
0.0322319567,
-0.022909116,
-0.0503530093,
-0.0145473927,
0.0255057272,
-0.0510019735,
0.0150502604,
0.0247382298,
0.0226115771,
-0.0314749032,
-0.0135781411,
-0.0246463567,
-0.0199836753,
-0.030749524,
0.0196016431,
0.0598586388,
-0.0673119798,
0.0032305734,
-0.0191225316,
0.0712246224,
-0.0569088683,
0.0839795098,
-0.0355042405,
0.0047107376,
0.0260469001,
-0.0185580626,
-0.0216236636,
0.0120274285,
-0.0373900011,
-0.0327690654,
-0.0452212244,
0.0275553446,
-0.0294663459,
-0.0156485941,
0.0057170182,
0.0209072363,
-0.051719062,
0.0235920921,
0.004370912,
0.0645571426,
-0.0045065745,
-0.0318318717,
0.0301955324,
-0.0361638032,
-0.0317408517,
-0.0012110308,
-0.0011493099,
-0.0534311011,
-0.0016330947,
0.1180195361,
-0.009438226,
-0.0142754307,
0.0509281158,
0.005278449,
-0.0199681707,
-0.0057240152,
0.0331793837,
-0.0216637831,
0.0057603163,
0.023277998,
0.0133566083,
-0.0125885652,
-0.0012979632,
0.0082072997,
0.040932551,
0.0575767346,
0.0332726985,
-0.0351219475,
-0.0125969192,
-0.0043883147,
-0.0239208546,
0.0605271459,
0.0240016822,
0.0418373086,
-0.003977207,
-0.0252104327,
0.0342721231,
0.0124381315,
-0.0086772675,
-0.0152065782,
-0.0325910933,
-0.0395478494,
0.0178381447,
-0.0143487668,
0.067831628,
0.020859614,
-0.0372074842,
-0.0351133533,
0.0500560701,
0.0271005146,
0.0605354719,
0.0119942734,
0.0208454672,
-0.0154185621,
-0.0232383031,
0.046455767,
-0.034936294,
0.0903824791,
0.0060383431,
0.0243365541,
0.0165308546,
0.0770876557,
-0.022356743,
-0.0350655615,
-0.0175642855,
0.0097712055,
0.0161000267,
-0.0206554886,
0.0225190166,
0.0331538543,
-0.0366906747,
0.1039539203,
-0.0167343337,
-0.0733205378,
0.0075424723,
-0.059669707,
-0.0164268836,
0.0247533377,
0.0409185365,
-0.0092683742,
0.0135043086,
0.0157734174,
-0.0525195934,
0.0430098176,
-0.0337072015,
0.0065154154,
0.0323083065,
-0.0170336477,
-0.0494127981,
-0.0427677482,
0.0262416434,
0.0168120079,
-0.0439403541,
-0.0161248632,
0.0128966235,
-0.0329089314,
0.031441059,
0.0015950513,
0.0429354012,
-0.006883258,
0.0031349787,
0.0179061107,
0.0166381244,
0.0089177815,
-0.0177545212,
0.0251442231,
0.0346463844,
-0.0206731316,
-0.0269122962,
0.0494931154,
-0.0822270811,
0.0207529515,
0.0304084793,
-0.0540746599,
0.0248886775,
0.0141404783,
-0.0070264842,
-0.0396788158,
0.0275066048,
-0.0385723524,
0.0842865631,
-0.0145502184,
0.0408282466,
-0.0176877622,
0.040150214,
-0.0185895152,
0.0402949452,
0.0067950413,
-0.0062174057,
-0.0001894154,
0.0307399649,
0.0236538257,
-0.0255386382,
-0.0207486786,
0.0088265752,
-0.0425424203,
0.0082932673,
0.0285313856,
-0.0320900232,
-0.0061550396,
-0.0255026259,
-0.0486275889,
-0.0297079962,
-0.0306098219,
0.0142139103,
0.0358542241,
0.0208160374,
0.0330519266,
0.0232875217,
-0.00864245,
-0.0339590348,
-0.0417201221,
0.0196037553,
0.0220488515,
-0.0153457252,
-0.0424289927,
-0.0174781699,
-0.0480859578,
-0.0126923136,
0.0753875226,
-0.0101813702,
-0.0029393258,
-0.0594200604,
-0.0315337442,
0.0155474916,
-0.0128405625,
-0.012737738,
-0.044640597,
0.0305630174,
0.0393557288,
0.0322309434,
0.0724606588,
0.0210922901,
0.0466245674,
0.044505842,
-0.0083832191,
-0.0312343631,
0.0018760571,
-0.0229779333,
-0.0098888865,
-0.0405269638,
-0.0082201883,
0.0003525653,
0.0765721872,
-0.0320680253,
0.0041598761,
-0.0787040144,
-0.0061692903,
-0.0052331807,
-0.048865445,
0.0195813533,
-0.0440520011,
-0.0258423071,
0.0640695989,
-0.0141027253,
-0.0118240565,
0.0552646779,
-0.0408549123,
-0.0004340713,
0.0023150682,
0.0294217244,
-0.0382577851,
0.0217893235,
-0.0118816597,
0.0286362004,
0.0224215612,
-0.0332406238,
-0.0359887183,
0.0312114134,
0.0167586692,
-0.0127070611,
0.0663934201,
0.0258928295,
-0.0285775885,
-0.0050006239,
-0.0231309887,
-0.0358038992,
0.0606979914,
-0.0005569688,
0.0316840932,
0.0647080913,
-0.0483436808,
-0.0640133843,
0.0448492505,
0.0201212019,
0.0418695621,
-0.0073498641,
-0.0228593536,
-0.0437301323,
0.0072560147,
-0.0113534909,
0.0414130427,
0.0676257014,
-0.0250438973,
0.0135874599,
0.0209949762,
0.0148897944,
0.0029831801,
-0.0613623634,
0.0187875144,
0.0379297473,
0.0062270933,
0.0312272403,
0.018532658,
0.0636579245,
-0.0499541312,
-0.0341402218,
0.0524691753,
-0.0065101692,
-0.0698811784,
0.0341347679,
-0.070083864,
-0.0030881264,
0.0380224586,
0.0227988325,
-0.0672527924,
-0.0226236824,
-0.0083905188,
0.0062208301,
-0.0030362511,
0.0173807777,
0.0340001471,
-0.0687066168,
0.0341390669,
0.0054188259,
-0.0496574752,
-0.0705747902,
-0.0307642333,
0.0055627986,
-0.0560715497,
0.058146704,
0.0034829874,
-0.0231626984,
-0.0286906417,
0.0159453563,
0.0222803727,
-0.0596697964,
0.0121965278,
-0.0069205165,
0.027383931,
0.0833459049,
-0.012141306,
0.0002707021,
-0.0807198361,
0.0094979117,
-0.0279481448,
0.012497141,
0.0219432134,
0.0230174419,
0.0056038606,
-0.0405095071,
-0.0166019406,
-0.0255428869,
0.003679214,
-0.0377523303,
-0.096094586,
0.0332369097,
-0.0015966299,
-0.0200630669,
-0.0271122437,
-0.0177820455,
-0.0427641273,
0.0466301776,
0.0542159341,
-0.016171027,
-0.0228759795,
-0.0530604199,
0.0247909725,
-0.025773881,
-0.0448325016,
0.0050074267,
0.0446070284,
-0.121811837,
-0.0274349395,
0.0130976252,
-0.0300224964,
0.0356448032,
0.0066458466,
-0.0642471388,
0.0135899987,
-0.0083484743,
-0.0533519462,
0.0180277899,
0.0128982225,
0.0326283872,
-0.0610470064,
0.0217027385,
0.0197446104,
-0.0098967822,
-0.0442251861,
0.0182065833,
-0.0780142099,
-0.0706221536,
0.0451914482,
0.0358485803,
0.025008725,
0.0216042269,
0.0074708303,
-0.0147946626,
0.0566897094,
0.0437493436,
-0.009754221,
0.0462408923,
0.0662202835,
-0.0298700463,
-0.0390363708,
-0.0007532571,
-0.0558451116,
0.0229478031,
0.0302592702,
0.037322741,
-0.0119536621,
-0.0188118163,
0.0402582921,
-0.0401770957,
0.0610250011,
-0.0140895499,
0.0285073239,
0.0173596591,
0.0389184393,
-0.0356399193,
0.0130202277,
-0.0481236652,
-0.0663965493,
0.002399293,
-0.0060689268,
0.0306738019,
0.0686135441,
0.0040558642,
-0.0074851671,
-0.0018011816,
0.0297141746,
-0.0302583333,
0.0067999256,
-0.0180545114,
0.0033479971,
-0.0069671036,
-0.0142036369,
0.007168178,
0.0432403758,
0.0138400346,
0.0035375741,
0.0370233133,
0.0302212834,
-0.0271098129,
0.0577686876,
-0.0462441742,
0.0029739018,
-0.0620021783,
-0.0490350537,
0.0148412194,
-0.0103916852,
0.0659763962,
0.0240056291,
-0.0025845426,
-0.0106525896,
0.0108387582,
-0.0065190182,
-0.0183249246,
0.0219240021,
0.0135027105,
0.0150252264,
-0.0424254723,
0.0274225418,
-0.0563098229,
0.009238991,
-0.0900555551,
0.0114102429,
0.0157218967,
-0.0247835536,
0.0005667521,
-0.0030302198,
-0.0120259728,
-0.0507687107,
-0.0733973384,
-0.0758364946,
0.0320052952,
0.0168655179,
0.0319117419,
-0.0178912804,
0.0455147177,
0.0296953209,
0.0095886756,
-0.0506709293,
0.0455752872,
-0.0501340814,
0.0407438204,
0.0248283949,
0.003318443,
-6.554785722e-33,
-0.0413964018,
-0.0119004091,
-0.0073917797,
-0.0083324434,
-0.0291115809,
0.0179822836,
-0.0477956757,
-0.0260279048,
0.0087130582,
0.001886855,
0.0059737833,
0.0134245837,
0.0138347419,
0.0141598461,
0.0140295401,
-0.0454731323,
0.0661494732,
0.0415967815,
-0.0474556796,
0.0090135364,
0.0333909392,
-0.0140567999,
0.0681423694,
-0.0405203514,
-0.0060573346,
0.0386438742,
-0.0048424914,
-0.0220888965,
-0.0078512328,
0.0455034263,
-0.0115263723,
0.007185312,
-0.010199056,
-0.0878899768,
-0.008007085,
0.0113472678,
-0.0373399071,
-0.0099724652,
0.0008039748,
0.0145700043,
-0.0257094111,
-0.0621383265,
0.0556053258,
0.0299221873,
-0.0595816821,
-0.0709168911,
0.0301926266,
0.0212344564,
-0.0022624114,
-0.0238836985,
-0.0581111312,
0.0037359097,
-0.027627293,
-0.0081617776,
0.0511354841,
0.0360273197,
0.0100367898,
0.0528509505,
-0.0874165967,
0.0176813472,
-0.0106054926,
0.0377324931,
0.0953384265,
0.0665625259,
0.0321819894,
0.047378473,
0.0279153436,
-0.0168437622,
-0.0258589592,
-0.0259096343,
0.0327435359,
0.0319973044,
0.051823698,
-0.030457329,
0.0379745997,
0.0200379193,
-0.0108686946,
0.0248606764,
-0.0463137254,
0.0514761657,
0.0330656581,
0.048440136,
-0.0037296328,
-0.0001610744,
-0.0196530912,
-0.0345147438,
-0.0197610073,
-0.03630035,
0.0056906026,
-0.008202984,
-0.0303780362,
0.0208881181,
0.057463076,
-0.0361154824,
0.0262276754,
-0.0081005804,
-0.0123823984,
0.0645624474,
-0.0031909002,
-0.0073617566,
0.0178681128,
-0.004618004,
0.0632318631,
0.0290423911,
0.0349014252,
-0.0176455621,
0.0146808345,
0.0564610362,
-0.030680703,
-0.0276559982,
-0.0280256663,
-0.0176304784,
-0.0138445469,
0.0133297304,
0.0167503599,
0.0383140743,
-0.0190626681,
0.0006048036,
-0.019292092,
0.0186495092,
-0.0334921293,
0.0414425842,
0.0094385864,
0.0495786704,
-0.0451071449,
0.0071683023,
-0.0629813969,
0.0357056633,
0.0465463623,
-0.0587417521,
-0.0685782731,
0.0202133656,
2.726e-7,
0.0608835369,
0.0294352826,
0.0303430557,
0.0278060175,
0.0171839204,
0.0366609581,
0.015512648,
0.0505743511,
0.0338113569,
-0.0460802317,
-0.007806099,
0.0077376654,
0.0096852342,
0.0040771118,
-0.0248996355,
-0.0017586068,
-0.0825253725,
0.0172196142,
0.0056595514,
-0.0004237268,
0.0327567197,
0.0796806812,
-0.0164642893,
0.0085835047,
0.032811854,
0.0463062339,
0.0405021682,
0.004347818,
0.0572945885,
0.0329716131,
-0.0267559215,
-0.0372838415,
0.0065675206,
0.0253046062,
-0.0200078562,
0.0158076771,
0.0299524646,
0.0089770257,
-0.052677501,
-0.0853981599,
-0.0222658552,
0.0295943376,
-0.008287712,
-0.0529223941,
0.0390315615,
-0.0776509792,
-0.0317754149,
-0.0401393771,
-0.0489018634,
0.0158389471,
0.0083856639,
0.0067235124,
-0.0198813528,
0.0183543395,
0.0043717669,
0.0160611589,
-0.006099754,
-0.0745405108,
-0.0301099978,
-0.0275914371,
-0.0481873862,
-0.0124818552,
-0.0745144933,
-0.0360445045,
0.0557333156,
0.026753217,
-0.0368591063,
2.599095151e-34,
0.0226391219,
-0.0112184435,
0.0138763115,
0.0238227341,
0.015423785,
-0.0386664495,
0.0046799802,
0.0244458448,
-0.0118873734,
-0.0393695869,
-0.0469527245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12969v1 | Using n-aksaras to model Sanskrit and Sanskrit-adjacent texts | 2023-01-30T15:17:06 | 2023-01-30T15:17:06 | Charles Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite -- or perhaps because of -- their simplicity, n-grams, or contiguous
sequences of tokens, have been used with great success in computational
linguistics since their introduction in the late 20th century. Recast as
k-mers, or contiguous sequences of monomers, they have also found applications
in computational biology. When applied to the analysis of texts, n-grams
usually take the form of sequences of words. But if we try to apply this model
to the analysis of Sanskrit texts, we are faced with the arduous task of,
firstly, resolving sandhi to split a phrase into words, and, secondly,
splitting long compounds into their components. This paper presents a simpler
method of tokenizing a Sanskrit text for n-grams, by using n-aksaras, or
contiguous sequences of aksaras. This model reduces the need for sandhi
resolution, making it much easier to use on raw text. It is also possible to
use this model on Sanskrit-adjacent texts, e.g., a Tamil commentary on a
Sanskrit text. As a test case, the commentaries on Amarakosa 1.0.1 have been
modelled as n-aksaras, showing patterns of text reuse across ten centuries and
nine languages. Some initial observations are made concerning Buddhist
commentarial practices. | [
0.0527351536,
0.0157765485,
-0.0547982864,
0.0481249541,
-0.0430954434,
-0.016198907,
-0.0102062682,
0.0414668322,
-0.0000471428,
-0.0447316691,
0.0393226966,
-0.0440025032,
0.0327790193,
-0.017381113,
0.0319104008,
-0.0532971844,
0.0456129387,
-0.0168717895,
0.0013576271,
0.0573983639,
0.0504643619,
-0.0021932572,
0.0071716197,
0.0246380605,
-0.0299511272,
-0.0310929772,
-0.0011433979,
-0.0599902533,
0.0220640134,
-0.0145140681,
-0.0404077023,
0.0245856252,
-0.0186189339,
0.0422072262,
0.0000015356,
-0.043461781,
-0.0306167733,
-0.0154274236,
0.0107848849,
0.035127677,
0.0665876716,
0.0261045247,
0.000742936,
-0.0028087941,
-0.0146971447,
0.0706247389,
0.0709494501,
0.0046034763,
0.031400539,
0.0603369549,
-0.0229463894,
-0.0784341171,
0.0336358137,
0.0088448804,
-0.0217051469,
0.0265031904,
0.0413251817,
-0.0079880916,
0.0248037018,
0.0289644115,
-0.0405468531,
0.0243855529,
-0.0243946612,
-0.02788743,
0.0001725493,
-0.0098772002,
-0.0205834974,
0.0081151035,
0.0503062718,
-0.0181460064,
0.0148634221,
-0.034990482,
0.0321544446,
0.008978663,
-0.0462376289,
-0.0307462346,
-0.0304653067,
0.0199340545,
-0.0636119097,
0.0547192022,
0.1142526269,
0.0209706966,
-0.0294133071,
0.0123955542,
0.0142879039,
-0.0086210882,
0.0243565645,
-0.0340684131,
-0.0281686019,
-0.022466287,
-0.0635469109,
-0.0439401157,
0.0013118933,
0.0303504039,
-0.0155550083,
0.0587791689,
0.0053610359,
-0.0925003141,
0.0188490283,
-0.0246962346,
0.0105101531,
0.0272065643,
0.0030356536,
-0.012441651,
0.0239462703,
0.0148197031,
0.0207518768,
-0.0304808989,
-0.0175876562,
0.0197700076,
0.0196729954,
-0.0597359426,
-0.0547222421,
0.0288368035,
-0.0369155072,
-0.0018358753,
-0.0495792106,
0.0104901595,
0.0062259072,
-0.0580525808,
-0.0339261405,
-0.0539028384,
0.001785764,
-0.0075131343,
0.0341071598,
-0.0098495856,
-0.0327775292,
0.0062994398,
-0.0224655662,
-0.0306791961,
0.0092429807,
0.0257990714,
-0.0141238458,
-0.0194941312,
-0.0596869104,
-0.0040869545,
-0.0008150002,
-0.0120502571,
0.007748358,
-0.0126269851,
-0.0588894971,
-0.0323832147,
-0.0550205708,
-0.051711414,
0.03066919,
0.0099799363,
-0.0301529933,
-0.0297011379,
0.019519208,
0.002951348,
-0.0227919128,
0.0504730083,
-0.0252768677,
0.0110473307,
-0.0094654262,
0.027409941,
0.0833291337,
-0.0091707986,
-0.0067836298,
0.0207096282,
0.0737620518,
-0.0278126393,
0.0061048893,
0.0205432568,
-0.0185235683,
-0.0131572755,
-0.0425652713,
-0.0145273525,
0.0063326885,
-0.009089591,
-0.0534901172,
0.0796334296,
-0.0212227628,
0.019309625,
-0.0351698808,
0.0810218155,
-0.0240386799,
0.1046499088,
0.0077467253,
0.0113523677,
0.0585924201,
0.0409207679,
0.0355674736,
-0.0192178078,
0.027749965,
0.0055373074,
0.0393897854,
-0.0099834986,
0.0313758515,
-0.0137095936,
-0.0418933704,
-0.0254445337,
-0.0121903559,
-0.0944242701,
0.0254132506,
-0.0243306458,
-0.0367364213,
0.0115141673,
0.032393802,
-0.0709822625,
0.0448971614,
-0.0254901405,
0.0680785924,
0.0357766785,
0.0392490327,
-0.0532898381,
0.058843717,
0.0542971864,
0.0109801143,
0.0571124926,
-0.0372496359,
-0.0162861571,
-0.018165648,
-0.0347195938,
0.0269368291,
0.0182364043,
0.0058948789,
0.0274282116,
-0.0365638435,
0.042375274,
0.0071959347,
0.0227930788,
0.0304811299,
0.0382479616,
0.0054177232,
0.0042607151,
-0.0396267101,
-0.0086891111,
0.0844198987,
0.0194298159,
-0.0021774522,
0.049623739,
0.0404989533,
-0.0379095525,
-0.0384048335,
0.0172852054,
0.0338001922,
0.0254992731,
0.0244342815,
-0.0329125561,
0.033785902,
0.0121365553,
0.0154465884,
-0.050418485,
0.0193010308,
-0.0233330354,
0.048676949,
-0.0185096432,
0.0390622988,
-0.001893191,
0.00466114,
-0.0309485514,
0.0451484136,
0.0329333954,
0.0605404712,
-0.01207502,
-0.0678523108,
0.0588962547,
-0.0210002102,
-0.0272853915,
-0.0308511034,
0.0288234316,
-0.0310286041,
0.0066793938,
-0.0240967479,
-0.0223831981,
-0.0668323934,
-0.1067455858,
-0.0446949378,
0.0096835168,
0.0489144064,
-0.0200570785,
0.0085197613,
-0.003682605,
0.019287711,
0.0185480528,
-0.0258763414,
0.0523893274,
0.0057853688,
0.0428915843,
-0.0314289741,
-0.0065980321,
-0.0416141935,
-0.0245216247,
-0.0201246198,
0.0401332043,
0.0117153693,
-0.1013238952,
-0.0619835034,
-0.0151162846,
-0.0408402383,
0.0149233146,
-0.0196709372,
-0.0418606512,
0.002740751,
-0.0160743538,
0.0292853173,
0.015442078,
0.0310900528,
-0.0001184472,
-0.0167335272,
-0.0391485058,
0.050609611,
-0.0519938581,
0.0087018227,
0.0284673814,
-0.0001234763,
-0.010776205,
0.0228392035,
0.0489260815,
0.0068146135,
-0.0241280105,
-0.0007994731,
-0.0020619864,
-0.0544292815,
0.0561794862,
0.0321996622,
-0.0588995516,
-0.0626960918,
0.0354831256,
0.001858064,
-0.0287342779,
0.040427655,
-0.0273157209,
0.0084844623,
-0.0791205615,
0.0516582094,
-0.0334129892,
0.049517218,
0.0010458915,
-0.0042357645,
0.0322073326,
-0.0097852889,
0.0099802604,
0.022537116,
-0.0268450584,
-0.0118659912,
0.0423923656,
-0.0239763372,
0.020521516,
-0.0279685333,
-0.0006615375,
0.0100884419,
-0.0411163718,
0.0062523335,
-0.0111296559,
0.0742302835,
0.0392645411,
0.0200528037,
0.1105536595,
-0.0379707217,
-0.0548749156,
-0.0185073502,
0.057059031,
-0.0122098969,
0.0347546972,
0.0191927198,
-0.0301777627,
-0.0126527539,
0.011041929,
0.0228390042,
0.0358396247,
0.0028810869,
-0.0150602786,
0.0265348889,
-0.0171096213,
0.0067831222,
-0.0308550559,
-0.0325310864,
0.0055318102,
-0.0115658259,
-0.0033921611,
0.0118332729,
0.0638654009,
0.0565610789,
0.0176510159,
0.0307545997,
-0.0728574693,
-0.0440866612,
-0.0145459948,
-0.0032557799,
-0.1066323891,
0.0244181007,
0.0141693233,
-0.0390181132,
0.0135237817,
-0.0358010419,
0.018544063,
-0.0763539672,
0.0005952866,
0.0051852674,
-0.0917919204,
0.0093053533,
0.0179542191,
-0.0137817059,
-0.0137799112,
-0.0370649695,
0.0615636967,
-0.0450123809,
0.0417540222,
0.0368353538,
-0.0040137847,
0.0236616898,
-0.0530378409,
-0.0247137584,
-0.0208493099,
-0.0159407724,
0.0270099826,
-0.0116913691,
-0.0055222749,
0.0345339365,
-0.0481130444,
-0.0037327888,
-0.0083864359,
0.0195450969,
0.0235539563,
-0.0134235229,
-0.0230607092,
-0.0057576341,
-0.0264655259,
-0.054220546,
0.0514670387,
0.0553226396,
0.0133989872,
-0.0071266904,
-0.0018090497,
0.0044909664,
-0.0113927536,
0.0031051519,
0.0150446445,
0.0097790426,
-0.0199434776,
-0.0102596488,
0.0359625444,
0.0129458532,
-0.0626869649,
-0.0353080966,
-0.0689442158,
-0.0419915058,
-0.078667894,
-0.0494677946,
-0.024487311,
0.0400894582,
0.0584092587,
0.0740795508,
0.0245382171,
-0.0304206107,
-0.0361874774,
-0.0670882165,
-0.0216917302,
0.0331426337,
-0.0348049141,
0.0256950986,
0.0251776744,
0.0421616249,
-0.0131900664,
-0.0210170113,
-0.0276499614,
-0.0635174513,
0.0214349888,
0.014548908,
0.0295647178,
-0.0450217277,
-0.0194252692,
-0.0343249254,
-0.0442692861,
0.023199806,
0.0228315983,
0.0225045402,
-0.018805014,
-0.0020198557,
-0.0227196123,
0.0223229621,
0.0123837423,
0.0127894888,
-0.0069880304,
0.0075089312,
-0.014565628,
0.0004880108,
0.0258276071,
0.0438942909,
-0.0076663587,
-0.0462854356,
0.0190143809,
0.0058095739,
-0.0166113935,
-0.0616943799,
-0.0138590196,
-0.0260259006,
0.0180519503,
0.0016559227,
0.0421256386,
-0.0485878475,
0.0013155311,
-0.0337659158,
0.0359403528,
0.0298950169,
0.0347159281,
0.0275372695,
0.0675931871,
-0.0182109997,
0.0058552823,
0.0123261334,
-0.0384243391,
-0.0626808032,
-0.0041428902,
-0.0398163423,
0.0054495484,
0.0105338776,
0.0320158154,
0.0048197517,
0.0237923898,
0.049749501,
-0.0025684407,
0.0070350347,
-0.0161483791,
0.0316866003,
-0.0120245237,
0.0528713465,
-0.032021787,
-0.017479023,
-0.0004967508,
0.0400076993,
0.0169584006,
0.0163961593,
-0.0167988893,
0.0288750045,
-0.016834341,
-0.0256894417,
0.0741361454,
-0.0429961495,
-0.0084267156,
0.0485452637,
-0.0735087097,
-0.0097399447,
-0.0557000227,
-0.0648546666,
-0.0041567599,
0.0436958075,
-0.0284223072,
-0.0685290471,
-0.0259290785,
-0.0087472694,
0.0191030744,
0.01775226,
-0.0161711983,
0.0292005017,
0.0558750406,
0.0658587366,
0.0087165795,
-0.0240347888,
0.0738552064,
-0.0626730919,
-0.0347046144,
0.0222457573,
-4.778017929e-33,
-0.0328305513,
-0.005091791,
-0.0118416641,
0.0260469504,
-0.0488398299,
-0.0108685307,
-0.0656564012,
0.0035851314,
0.0477959067,
0.0112254051,
-0.0224774685,
0.0014662694,
0.0161895622,
-0.0471152999,
0.0447869338,
0.0476539098,
-0.0011495657,
0.019708151,
-0.010388853,
-0.0212983135,
0.0784980282,
-0.0175203383,
0.0468666553,
-0.0101438379,
0.0627471134,
-0.0415580273,
-0.0173444916,
0.0258313958,
-0.0331944712,
0.0301880147,
-0.0241619125,
0.0153580774,
0.0415319093,
0.0059273914,
-0.0104665468,
0.0184661075,
-0.0540107563,
-0.0142414719,
0.0805315822,
0.0202190671,
0.0084757907,
-0.0369919017,
0.0176939983,
-0.0225161482,
-0.0141249737,
0.0713924989,
0.0354092382,
-0.0362068787,
-0.0484501161,
-0.0325117335,
-0.0717624202,
0.0108252373,
-0.0173120331,
0.0365540348,
0.0150927221,
-0.0129707269,
0.0151069565,
-0.003086125,
-0.0085119782,
0.0275417417,
0.0531001948,
0.0619591251,
-0.0355631113,
-0.0074196183,
-0.0297539905,
-0.0094382809,
0.0341325104,
-0.0608905591,
0.0022405351,
0.062407624,
-0.0198896453,
0.036431741,
0.0593509898,
0.0170554705,
0.0776125565,
-0.0574416332,
-0.0255687702,
-0.0119570233,
-0.0158321951,
0.0511748604,
0.0108254254,
-0.0004064239,
-0.042361889,
-0.0499098115,
0.0422157049,
-0.081196323,
-0.0067840088,
-0.011882415,
0.0091684926,
-0.0209097397,
-0.0176120736,
0.0517047681,
0.0007546411,
-0.0481391586,
0.0214958563,
0.0231572893,
-0.0203202032,
0.0618081503,
-0.0238878857,
-0.0149800647,
-0.0441662408,
-0.0553509183,
0.0051214038,
0.0065420321,
0.0053357421,
-0.0359693952,
0.0059125475,
0.0027064029,
-0.0626433492,
0.0067535103,
0.0161694083,
0.0387978032,
-0.0047416361,
0.0483956449,
0.0285836663,
0.0131515758,
0.043072056,
-0.0185792632,
0.0416218527,
-0.0116516817,
-0.0163132437,
0.0237848125,
0.0193168558,
-0.0223269686,
0.0125120608,
0.0178924873,
-0.0038189271,
0.0497232415,
0.0526906699,
-0.0281596519,
-0.0072792065,
0.0115539758,
2.431e-7,
0.0167859253,
0.023763258,
0.0531470291,
-0.0656661391,
0.0328773484,
0.0023262382,
-0.0620839745,
-0.0082921404,
-0.0612528324,
0.0343002602,
0.0244874395,
-0.0198065229,
0.0365899093,
0.0384432599,
-0.0613290258,
0.0229809452,
-0.0855594873,
-0.0591081381,
-0.0645096749,
0.0017201019,
-0.0293354653,
0.0542040467,
0.0129068075,
-0.0167190824,
-0.0351070054,
-0.008197071,
0.0261911564,
0.0368042737,
-0.0002080607,
0.0363427177,
0.0163446385,
-0.0724758878,
0.0087846685,
-0.010566351,
0.0085131153,
0.0251169521,
0.0516834073,
0.0693931058,
0.0001915013,
0.0768188834,
0.0419051647,
-0.0239058454,
0.0051163146,
-0.0013605835,
0.0156479925,
0.0609705299,
-0.0104357833,
-0.0247143768,
-0.0113655394,
0.0146737099,
-0.0221655108,
0.0344009735,
-0.0223655179,
0.0234303847,
0.0047375076,
-0.0311750155,
0.0030866757,
-0.0522052646,
-0.0196641702,
0.0024772491,
-0.0277439635,
-0.021971155,
-0.0028114575,
0.0079576429,
0.0289012361,
-0.0717921108,
-0.0309519693,
2.184787346e-34,
0.0672892705,
-0.0360464007,
0.0288576614,
0.0272157602,
0.0073848241,
0.0056227366,
0.0161155295,
0.0801368058,
-0.0066196998,
-0.0598387308,
-0.0285636764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12920v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12920v4 | Active Learning for Multilingual Semantic Parser | 2023-01-30T14:19:29 | 2023-10-11T04:08:26 | Zhuang Li, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Current multilingual semantic parsing (MSP) datasets are almost all collected
by translating the utterances in the existing datasets from the resource-rich
language to the target language. However, manual translation is costly. To
reduce the translation effort, this paper proposes the first active learning
procedure for MSP (AL-MSP). AL-MSP selects only a subset from the existing
datasets to be translated. We also propose a novel selection method that
prioritizes the examples diversifying the logical form structures with more
lexical choices, and a novel hyperparameter tuning method that needs no extra
annotation cost. Our experiments show that AL-MSP significantly reduces
translation costs with ideal selection methods. Our selection method with
proper hyperparameters yields better parsing performance than the other
baselines on two multilingual datasets. | [
0.0107010575,
0.0030809732,
-0.0034683228,
0.0262649637,
-0.0204311907,
0.0368186273,
0.0136215053,
-0.0126184952,
-0.0212594401,
-0.068508625,
-0.0006577301,
0.0151308402,
-0.0337246545,
0.0040345388,
0.0032203321,
-0.0307267401,
0.0610939078,
-0.003259924,
0.0381430462,
0.0148635162,
-0.0043695071,
0.0684277117,
-0.0182245113,
0.0156610217,
-0.050864663,
0.0240113698,
0.0186439436,
0.0137148444,
0.0083500836,
-0.0498970971,
-0.0038168102,
0.0007299703,
-0.0011277094,
0.0028114035,
0.0000019618,
-0.0591971241,
-0.0762370825,
0.0033061875,
-0.0016030093,
-0.0271055605,
0.0281565282,
-0.0470600389,
0.0228267573,
-0.0340084955,
-0.0458798818,
-0.0461044014,
0.0386799537,
0.0157509111,
0.0430455655,
0.0382129811,
-0.0328528211,
-0.0086099533,
-0.001141549,
-0.002780129,
-0.0048140958,
-0.0753076077,
-0.0038798049,
0.0195179954,
-0.0434475541,
-0.0258024838,
0.0087527595,
0.018620519,
-0.0139453271,
-0.0194557905,
-0.023892343,
-0.0196308736,
-0.059828978,
-0.0544139594,
0.0182868764,
0.0592437722,
-0.029388791,
0.0010963585,
0.0197058301,
-0.0529119112,
-0.0078866407,
0.0055582337,
-0.0204661563,
0.0347247347,
-0.0409302376,
0.0508912317,
0.0648311526,
0.0046873614,
0.0100246742,
0.0315775648,
-0.0020958653,
0.074220255,
-0.0047012768,
-0.0287542362,
0.0628303885,
0.0295972973,
-0.0529591143,
0.0129502295,
0.0519522801,
-0.0194748379,
-0.0705151334,
0.0178507995,
-0.0263241809,
-0.037144389,
0.0201539621,
-0.0527583361,
-0.0082977656,
0.0482664183,
0.0061080181,
0.0577079728,
-0.0127430819,
-0.0033089821,
0.0134569509,
0.0240988508,
-0.0450775214,
-0.0303012356,
-0.0486110263,
-0.0004635503,
-0.0612063147,
0.0466785282,
-0.0608345643,
-0.0215140991,
-0.0245482046,
0.0094754342,
-0.0000612445,
0.0138095925,
0.032458216,
-0.0321728177,
-0.0478078388,
0.0342577025,
-0.0099959997,
0.0378600098,
-0.0172612444,
-0.0206541549,
-0.0239036474,
-0.0522441864,
0.0061890511,
0.0271307603,
0.0138845611,
-0.0627757013,
-0.0214464758,
0.0808732659,
-0.0097277388,
0.0078394562,
-0.0195107087,
-0.0127173224,
0.0439812429,
0.0090041561,
-0.0022451524,
-0.0355586186,
0.0438005328,
-0.0189791042,
0.0414364412,
-0.0354381315,
-0.0037972147,
-0.0058616512,
0.0121896341,
0.0232860781,
0.0067777238,
-0.0375877582,
0.0133506646,
-0.0555206537,
-0.0195840318,
0.1011599824,
0.0046930905,
-0.0101472633,
0.0728050768,
0.008412756,
-0.0873977318,
0.0212411564,
0.0083474871,
-0.0335862301,
-0.0070110448,
0.0300023183,
-0.0105392402,
-0.012486143,
-0.0374242216,
-0.0093573928,
-0.0449871346,
0.0349243395,
-0.0518886186,
-0.0212985035,
-0.0426765047,
-0.0084930025,
0.0779757425,
0.0111968173,
-0.0109223584,
-0.0314377993,
-0.0191057902,
-0.0178137664,
0.0326996408,
-0.0043216259,
-0.0560547076,
0.039016556,
-0.0001457656,
-0.0274091512,
-0.0155042661,
-0.028020598,
0.0140511338,
0.0264594425,
0.016325146,
0.0248156339,
-0.01731194,
0.132730186,
0.0345130004,
-0.0362054221,
-0.0099122468,
0.0021663285,
-0.0114093041,
0.0151434978,
-0.0035175006,
-0.0815518275,
-0.0535196066,
-0.0164635852,
0.0354994908,
0.0106398528,
0.0457155071,
-0.0319802538,
0.0376086384,
-0.0875227526,
-0.0271826256,
-0.0013116451,
0.0161419678,
0.0119401291,
-0.0570787229,
-0.0032431444,
0.0028829344,
-0.0069727642,
-0.0290754046,
0.0405486934,
0.0038505543,
0.0034521017,
0.0279771332,
-0.0079655843,
0.0550485738,
0.0272655878,
0.0315169469,
-0.0091183418,
-0.0105735781,
-0.0379331373,
-0.0090178698,
0.0441027395,
-0.0165213346,
-0.0402885042,
0.024302803,
-0.0368567072,
-0.0820969865,
-0.0268625785,
-0.0749187693,
-0.0210639071,
-0.0501827523,
-0.0115751494,
-0.0202563815,
-0.0246987864,
0.0202866327,
-0.0096197873,
0.0149319842,
-0.0628364459,
0.0824621841,
0.0057631237,
0.0134571372,
0.0213840343,
-0.031691961,
0.0368631408,
-0.0391563475,
-0.0018051174,
0.0406828895,
-0.0160667095,
-0.0429198593,
0.0056475382,
0.0472549833,
-0.0367598571,
-0.007423419,
-0.0184711087,
0.008091283,
-0.0128409658,
0.0375339203,
0.0466571748,
0.0476857722,
0.0281505883,
-0.0138565227,
0.0005776719,
0.0192386135,
0.0051824362,
0.0027368036,
0.0210576989,
0.0103535485,
0.0359954052,
-0.0323173627,
-0.0274616703,
-0.0037595467,
0.0288263038,
0.0388163291,
-0.0135928737,
0.0136620887,
-0.0007036686,
-0.0373218991,
-0.0005122574,
0.0403853916,
-0.0035327515,
-0.0187346619,
-0.0712949261,
-0.0714481995,
0.0545148514,
-0.0245472342,
0.0105498172,
0.0151153235,
-0.0228899736,
-0.0538281351,
0.04261766,
-0.0097028548,
0.0400203019,
-0.0768075585,
-0.0399748012,
0.0234184042,
0.0096422955,
-0.014730284,
0.0022552013,
-0.0312423222,
-0.008169869,
-0.0568494387,
-0.0612377673,
-0.0012976894,
0.0419249758,
0.0198318101,
0.0693149194,
-0.012877075,
0.0116790188,
0.0839436874,
0.0101297731,
-0.0312392842,
-0.092183359,
0.0240891781,
-0.0482002385,
0.0191293042,
-0.0161013678,
0.0113623971,
-0.0452770665,
-0.0430273786,
0.0068890778,
-0.0554883778,
0.0666509196,
0.0247865971,
0.0140630091,
-0.0423041955,
0.0075952788,
-0.0132171027,
-0.0226275697,
0.0004791811,
-0.0106409527,
-0.0276074558,
0.014012848,
-0.0072245798,
0.0375596508,
-0.0082289344,
-0.0174713358,
-0.0233420432,
0.0260000248,
0.0246089604,
0.0035036088,
-0.0312810801,
-0.032499209,
0.0165122468,
0.0061821565,
-0.0215422623,
0.0055470308,
0.0324193649,
0.0013454552,
-0.0206934735,
-0.0397947915,
0.0092301415,
0.0382596329,
0.0427140668,
-0.0074687861,
-0.0348455645,
-0.0327200256,
0.0093863271,
-0.0349624306,
0.0043779328,
0.1058796197,
0.0497392863,
-0.0127087701,
-0.0002771712,
-0.0381507427,
-0.0133026019,
0.0161230266,
0.0365150757,
-0.0533226542,
-0.0363631099,
0.004648597,
0.0055656745,
0.0102397138,
-0.0413637273,
0.0339077227,
-0.0807447508,
0.0029435384,
-0.0033580516,
-0.0290533826,
0.0353348739,
-0.012579103,
-0.044648353,
-0.1061234623,
0.025990108,
-0.031157352,
0.0060895565,
0.0092367996,
0.0084203379,
0.0084004309,
-0.0259735715,
0.0130579332,
-0.0079244189,
-0.0369246714,
0.0328933038,
0.0526850335,
-0.032887049,
-0.0143446904,
0.063603811,
0.0000194632,
-0.002485916,
-0.0682054162,
-0.0063057207,
0.0283865836,
-0.0213854332,
0.0065698391,
-0.0113155441,
-0.0398611352,
-0.0011768469,
0.0335148573,
0.0625967309,
-0.0159984976,
0.0672033727,
0.0337945707,
-0.0231471937,
0.0090666525,
0.0201181881,
-0.0331930593,
0.0259555597,
-0.0324622728,
-0.0444909558,
-0.0324239805,
-0.0760357901,
0.0321707539,
0.0724580958,
-0.077244319,
-0.0591520071,
-0.059228614,
-0.0416952111,
0.0700393096,
0.07266552,
-0.0059018764,
0.0220668595,
0.0379353091,
0.0042460021,
0.0265747625,
0.0294054411,
0.0171798114,
0.0089903213,
0.0132069299,
-0.0290780738,
0.0241247863,
-0.0076049105,
-0.0368404388,
0.0051518916,
0.0126071805,
-0.0591429695,
0.0228646547,
0.0542839728,
0.0091307638,
0.0673583001,
-0.0458214805,
-0.0028933713,
-0.041346848,
-0.0070314193,
-0.0270098839,
-0.0208073221,
0.0607808828,
0.0034178032,
0.0044905385,
0.0325904526,
-0.0301679801,
0.0275256895,
0.0142055387,
0.0693126321,
-0.0185156073,
-0.0173948389,
0.0549567305,
0.070930928,
0.0320757106,
-0.0164686665,
-0.0054071555,
-0.0041681277,
0.0357131995,
-0.0299695544,
-0.0319253281,
-0.0567113236,
0.070197016,
0.0123728132,
-0.0009403167,
0.0153798331,
0.0010794192,
-0.0027280571,
0.0436943136,
-0.0132333012,
0.0499788821,
0.031750422,
0.0118569983,
-0.0010230556,
-0.0007038114,
-0.0369217768,
0.0134720309,
0.0045991698,
0.0272934008,
-0.0305253062,
0.019994691,
0.0253811423,
0.0459554531,
-0.0367574766,
-0.0137705663,
-0.0013603769,
-0.0125135556,
0.0393104218,
-0.0091057168,
0.0920345783,
-0.042692475,
0.1321274638,
0.0132891741,
-0.0204306971,
0.0368210226,
0.0470777154,
0.0694829226,
-0.064528808,
0.0283986479,
0.0029930603,
-0.0185020007,
-0.0663265288,
0.0497551784,
-0.0420323052,
0.0419102944,
-0.014840032,
-0.0122575788,
-0.049021598,
-0.033618331,
0.0028374584,
0.0106052468,
-0.026165206,
-0.0059320256,
0.0152904456,
-0.0308842286,
-0.0103362678,
-0.0251135398,
-0.021862857,
0.0003365772,
0.0614252687,
0.0790390521,
0.0419559032,
-0.0318768919,
-0.0347736329,
-0.0249320175,
-0.0084781339,
0.003618259,
-0.0206599738,
-5.716249398e-33,
-0.0048570652,
0.0473318994,
0.0067432313,
0.0053211446,
-0.0002170737,
0.0042540808,
-0.0274474509,
-0.045256976,
0.001005683,
0.0262748711,
0.0140280249,
-0.0181469284,
0.0539212078,
0.0496106632,
0.0344575942,
-0.035351336,
0.0330134556,
0.016119713,
0.0039619366,
-0.0037753899,
0.0767255425,
0.0263514277,
0.0503406078,
-0.0650746375,
0.0180628709,
0.0433105379,
-0.0143452603,
0.0510249101,
-0.0016396727,
0.0470545553,
0.0527974442,
-0.0026340194,
0.0090348842,
-0.0263195876,
-0.0270764846,
-0.0591398291,
-0.0799424499,
-0.029037023,
0.0375981517,
0.0626024678,
-0.0162479263,
-0.0265912544,
-0.0162535775,
-0.0301413611,
0.0420629978,
0.0149734765,
0.0125327837,
-0.044979278,
-0.0462509729,
-0.0337036513,
-0.0601421073,
0.0482177474,
-0.0450771414,
0.0730071515,
0.0494306944,
0.0422791243,
-0.0225599948,
-0.020603558,
-0.0005938855,
0.0046615559,
-0.0676419586,
0.0075609018,
0.0186750144,
-0.0082359603,
0.0259747226,
0.0218568482,
0.0169359222,
-0.0218385682,
0.0425951928,
0.1051343456,
-0.0314589553,
0.0414038785,
-0.0250759479,
0.0395250022,
-0.0117873503,
-0.0230199806,
-0.0675427243,
-0.0183205288,
0.0690088421,
0.0328177959,
0.0006185265,
-0.0014520759,
-0.0142922262,
-0.0023402327,
-0.0045381631,
0.0521947891,
0.0056428015,
-0.0366886966,
0.0056394129,
-0.0234609656,
-0.0505157523,
0.0379011966,
0.0469256006,
0.0143461134,
-0.0125185978,
0.0133893266,
0.0155957695,
-0.0216419008,
-0.0157680232,
0.0141950706,
0.0101005128,
-0.1138086766,
-0.0030053933,
-0.0131670358,
0.0368593112,
0.0157599878,
0.0381952077,
0.0012291211,
-0.001563322,
0.0466317981,
-0.0338134058,
0.002289623,
-0.0352016985,
0.0884386674,
-0.0019339576,
-0.0197745785,
-0.0279788952,
0.0421664082,
0.0215175562,
-0.0526249222,
-0.011457229,
-0.0240427982,
0.015335042,
0.0313646309,
-0.0488873385,
-0.0276032779,
-0.0166597925,
-0.0540552884,
0.0302803684,
-0.0432343259,
-0.0072526312,
0.016128514,
2.725e-7,
0.0490538813,
0.0289120208,
-0.0374324359,
0.0177622344,
0.0050204317,
0.0206178557,
0.0070758183,
0.0213079769,
-0.001664869,
0.0633244663,
-0.016252948,
-0.0243244395,
0.0155495685,
0.0637693331,
-0.1101215035,
-0.0577706248,
-0.0218396652,
-0.0295310058,
-0.0303834975,
0.0286622141,
0.0525989458,
0.0916465223,
-0.0122573078,
-0.0016521208,
-0.0283802263,
-0.0594336912,
-0.0119030541,
0.0069329049,
0.0052698143,
0.0178910848,
-0.0135106798,
-0.0181788728,
-0.0094956784,
0.02879549,
-0.0441645719,
0.0064228191,
0.0533488356,
0.104348816,
0.0020647352,
0.0047698468,
0.0205935277,
-0.0314037129,
0.0229523517,
-0.0009212644,
0.0741487592,
-0.0282321405,
-0.0223580077,
0.0541918874,
-0.0152206067,
0.0098277582,
-0.0132632768,
-0.0116858939,
-0.002805419,
0.0292315278,
0.0400689878,
-0.0060501294,
-0.0446316563,
-0.0396179482,
-0.0329357721,
-0.0240561292,
-0.007736438,
-0.0255318787,
0.0199089665,
0.0478709266,
0.0133007644,
0.0043454906,
-0.015148689,
2.276305092e-34,
0.0424077772,
0.0062596458,
0.0232611913,
0.0209331773,
0.0372596718,
0.0106914574,
-0.0005345505,
0.052646108,
-0.0187993627,
-0.0345584042,
0.0099641494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12868v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12868v3 | On Robustness of Prompt-based Semantic Parsing with Large Pre-trained Language Model: An Empirical Study on Codex | 2023-01-30T13:21:00 | 2023-03-09T11:01:02 | Terry Yue Zhuo, Zhuang Li, Yujin Huang, Fatemeh Shiri, Weiqing Wang, Gholamreza Haffari, Yuan-Fang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Semantic parsing is a technique aimed at constructing a structured
representation of the meaning of a natural-language question. Recent
advancements in few-shot language models trained on code have demonstrated
superior performance in generating these representations compared to
traditional unimodal language models, which are trained on downstream tasks.
Despite these advancements, existing fine-tuned neural semantic parsers are
susceptible to adversarial attacks on natural-language inputs. While it has
been established that the robustness of smaller semantic parsers can be
enhanced through adversarial training, this approach is not feasible for large
language models in real-world scenarios, as it requires both substantial
computational resources and expensive human annotation on in-domain semantic
parsing data. This paper presents the first empirical study on the adversarial
robustness of a large prompt-based language model of code, \codex. Our results
demonstrate that the state-of-the-art (SOTA) code-language models are
vulnerable to carefully crafted adversarial examples. To address this
challenge, we propose methods for improving robustness without the need for
significant amounts of labeled data or heavy computational resources. | [
0.0138053391,
0.0548758917,
-0.0377145447,
0.0482276417,
0.0056136204,
0.0084982598,
0.002734002,
-0.018391259,
0.0053272895,
-0.0452705845,
-0.029378606,
0.0318036675,
-0.0094656162,
0.0168656576,
0.0792114362,
-0.0216568839,
0.0600948557,
-0.0323168486,
-0.0071656313,
0.0221251287,
0.0087247407,
0.0120024728,
0.0203217212,
0.0369786881,
-0.0004837418,
-0.0593663789,
-0.0001531352,
0.0212475825,
-0.0318331048,
-0.0492625758,
0.0185095817,
0.0370809399,
-0.0060992292,
0.0556919239,
0.0000020757,
-0.0183435027,
-0.0270964243,
0.0130129242,
-0.0525455996,
0.031304244,
0.0347295851,
-0.0561459251,
-0.0286043268,
-0.0106139304,
-0.0537839048,
-0.056118805,
0.0301457439,
-0.0038193131,
0.0893640071,
0.0857481733,
0.0046513388,
-0.0208669901,
0.0553043038,
-0.0394051671,
-0.0208332501,
-0.0736296177,
-0.0050887675,
0.0177459959,
0.0041976725,
0.0168464109,
-0.030728789,
0.0106429756,
0.0415125452,
-0.0040540756,
-0.029632885,
0.0292881597,
-0.0336867161,
0.0027760912,
-0.0154416496,
0.0801549777,
-0.0627359226,
-0.0191493109,
-0.0190348923,
-0.0299473107,
0.0083498545,
-0.0493094102,
-0.0261414926,
0.0278155543,
0.0053073759,
0.0259847902,
0.0013507974,
0.0041337027,
0.0343613103,
0.0030030545,
-0.0112083722,
0.040716283,
0.0117588602,
-0.0227571502,
0.0027185979,
-0.0281187333,
-0.052010525,
-0.0510227382,
-0.0107464325,
0.0277604535,
-0.0211888794,
0.0194142293,
-0.0816025436,
-0.062921606,
0.0207643434,
-0.0173020177,
0.0343120433,
0.0298978947,
-0.0415652506,
0.0380224176,
-0.0243219752,
0.0643278658,
-0.025984386,
0.0676212534,
-0.0385134444,
0.0178751051,
-0.016512353,
-0.0248905215,
-0.050568793,
0.0294340365,
-0.0609770864,
0.0264803134,
-0.0053663906,
0.0438954383,
-0.0006895461,
0.0422232635,
-0.0226691961,
0.0046731401,
-0.0532218553,
0.0249281246,
0.0323260836,
-0.0164555814,
-0.0352516808,
-0.032663282,
0.0077018775,
-0.1057614163,
-0.0329166129,
0.0124954898,
-0.0436831638,
-0.0638511628,
-0.0220063291,
0.0778446868,
0.0316032954,
-0.0070115039,
-0.0298587531,
-0.0561990291,
-0.0294549912,
-0.0225880854,
-0.0005653531,
-0.0565472245,
-0.0086594764,
-0.0196508709,
0.0027841539,
-0.1094119549,
-0.006376083,
0.0125451069,
-0.0040089879,
0.0961321369,
-0.0378060602,
-0.0431851298,
0.0140796313,
0.0115639111,
-0.0136958063,
0.0351806805,
0.0170727875,
0.0316074267,
0.0282243025,
-0.0185403898,
-0.0171062965,
0.0286224,
0.0166439638,
-0.0292150564,
-0.021818405,
0.0402722247,
0.0419037864,
0.0099624153,
0.0082485024,
0.058542341,
-0.0200689826,
-0.0479661487,
0.0203408897,
0.0155281266,
-0.0432371534,
0.0157996677,
0.0597474463,
0.0130934203,
0.0123038422,
-0.0248280186,
-0.1041916609,
0.006957138,
-0.0115420017,
-0.0247196443,
-0.0262090638,
-0.0162735973,
-0.0156744979,
-0.0341939293,
0.0070089675,
-0.0057756538,
-0.0015117945,
-0.0181892533,
0.017442951,
0.0405255966,
-0.0213293191,
0.0138711678,
0.0229829773,
-0.0013051857,
0.0029562037,
-0.058030311,
0.023523692,
0.0159679744,
0.0624319203,
-0.0783403739,
-0.0089227604,
-0.0233946368,
0.0386652239,
0.0005997128,
0.0408108756,
-0.0040091714,
0.0242047533,
-0.012362577,
0.0187554751,
-0.0737638697,
0.0144167412,
0.0350677073,
-0.0036272286,
-0.0292870663,
0.017197717,
0.0114599653,
-0.0290889833,
0.0690221637,
0.0075692469,
-0.0519761331,
-0.0016478315,
0.0100606363,
0.0188170448,
-0.0058466657,
-0.039692279,
0.034301687,
0.026150493,
-0.0269569065,
0.0124477306,
-0.0442843027,
-0.0491381176,
-0.0836550519,
0.0100527098,
0.0004259284,
-0.0435531139,
0.0515186824,
-0.0593508631,
0.0089807063,
0.0327880681,
-0.0213243831,
0.0206927657,
-0.0101600643,
-0.0268155355,
0.0207099933,
0.0305956807,
-0.073957786,
0.0534859262,
-0.0084746443,
-0.0175097995,
-0.0214175601,
0.0899321958,
0.0151637439,
-0.0216372497,
-0.0497533344,
0.0486711338,
-0.0374425985,
-0.0134886671,
-0.0241622031,
0.0153820971,
-0.0190068129,
-0.0201574322,
-0.0403780006,
0.0101743527,
-0.0332992077,
0.0082584675,
0.0373412259,
0.0046992637,
0.0079378299,
-0.0266390722,
-0.0079544261,
-0.0024770091,
-0.0257817544,
0.0203173794,
0.0252962206,
0.0286690313,
-0.0109368535,
-0.0405899212,
-0.01945653,
-0.044825267,
0.0631137937,
-0.0032138296,
-0.0031647549,
-0.0315908156,
0.0419593938,
0.0037010575,
0.059445858,
-0.0135167716,
-0.0474165566,
0.0379503816,
-0.0288920719,
-0.0080563268,
0.1172723621,
-0.0200145487,
0.0262328386,
0.0417131819,
0.0079684099,
-0.0329717211,
0.0222739186,
0.0537484698,
-0.040545661,
-0.0301566459,
0.0105291074,
0.0377842598,
0.0621236339,
0.0437274538,
0.015544231,
-0.036492195,
0.0504601449,
-0.0360237323,
-0.045358777,
-0.019051075,
-0.0321185701,
-0.0376654044,
0.0239706468,
-0.0498804413,
-0.049643293,
0.0716355219,
-0.038124349,
-0.0337424353,
-0.0129342815,
-0.0171191953,
-0.0032132138,
0.072664395,
0.0229511634,
0.0121518858,
0.031601619,
-0.0458490811,
-0.0550927334,
-0.0309440792,
-0.0032276742,
-0.0046692849,
0.0192667842,
-0.0373996794,
-0.0083637098,
0.0007039741,
-0.0386757888,
-0.0586262941,
-0.0698054805,
-0.0304843076,
0.0349528939,
0.0125703821,
0.0495107137,
0.0462395698,
-0.0244411565,
-0.0329929776,
0.0314944573,
-0.008542561,
-0.0068633435,
-0.0531312563,
0.0227064863,
0.0185618848,
-0.0385045744,
0.0202169735,
0.0017740813,
0.0403033569,
0.0545253642,
0.0137761775,
0.0360407345,
-0.0761340111,
0.014046805,
-0.0040873918,
-0.0140534826,
-0.0196817182,
0.0281111952,
0.0388457961,
-0.0537114292,
-0.013790207,
0.0800980404,
0.037503127,
0.0082910899,
0.0360757783,
0.0059100646,
0.029102888,
0.0335305743,
0.0233133808,
-0.0534351654,
-0.0493936427,
0.0026597478,
0.0283489004,
0.0090578496,
-0.0373887941,
-0.0149046984,
-0.1003738493,
-0.0132505428,
0.0030956841,
-0.0383530222,
-0.0092721125,
0.0140636079,
-0.0271848477,
-0.030549299,
0.0302392542,
0.0214403253,
0.0180387646,
0.0232017282,
0.0006624167,
0.0144870738,
0.0218139384,
0.0363529474,
-0.0536733679,
0.043361038,
0.1268922091,
0.0019409865,
-0.02888331,
0.0372851081,
0.0827629045,
-0.0128816757,
0.0238957815,
0.0024093711,
0.0431661047,
-0.0235369671,
-0.0149131585,
0.0416083969,
0.0393622704,
-0.0397693627,
-0.016170688,
0.02929339,
0.0286391694,
0.0004142017,
0.0163688008,
-0.0087666167,
-0.0206452589,
-0.0043010912,
0.0525287949,
0.0504379831,
-0.0328260139,
-0.0557432994,
-0.0817095488,
0.0100776134,
-0.0533329956,
-0.0359055214,
0.0241537169,
0.0529729016,
-0.0135398479,
-0.0638536066,
-0.062634103,
0.0026103721,
0.017980108,
-0.01426565,
-0.0274662133,
0.0048914859,
0.0074439063,
-0.004012065,
0.0240876954,
-0.0309831891,
0.0316819288,
-0.0352568887,
0.0151120182,
0.0356681459,
-0.0098851118,
-0.0366091467,
-0.006012714,
-0.0935982242,
-0.0517369956,
0.0261293706,
0.0833733231,
0.0111874267,
0.0281945169,
-0.0809576511,
-0.0499394648,
0.0075329021,
0.0258401129,
-0.0687858984,
0.0171081983,
0.0517688543,
-0.0022258852,
0.0298527926,
0.0452902429,
-0.04594706,
0.0136819528,
0.0610654503,
0.0077865236,
-0.0133957881,
0.0090473648,
0.0470790341,
0.0422258973,
0.0702443868,
0.0267755575,
0.0084543014,
0.0289055631,
0.0143205244,
-0.0274481792,
-0.0262896083,
-0.0303096492,
0.0083776303,
0.0101398788,
-0.0159123875,
0.0147205135,
0.0044485168,
0.0027004732,
0.0828989595,
-0.0248581842,
0.0169364568,
0.0351497941,
0.0513552986,
0.026645992,
0.0351701975,
-0.0151966112,
0.0468125194,
-0.0264666583,
0.033037629,
-0.0189502407,
0.0309179313,
0.0130009158,
-0.0001208813,
-0.0057338215,
0.0218611248,
-0.0670096576,
-0.0167791583,
0.0221759453,
-0.0141419051,
0.0175635647,
0.0170579925,
-0.0148375118,
0.0045257467,
0.0005388569,
-0.0243508611,
0.017449243,
0.0286490694,
-0.0370211005,
0.0599271283,
0.0207642727,
-0.0000393248,
-0.0478916131,
0.0715365186,
0.0024416652,
0.0461458452,
0.0303966738,
-0.0031762416,
-0.0608425476,
-0.0192976408,
0.0291896388,
0.0060138772,
-0.0217747446,
0.0052610058,
-0.0369243808,
-0.0637982264,
-0.0212797616,
0.0318996459,
0.004208813,
0.0010810029,
0.020137025,
0.0613633171,
-0.0066177053,
0.0014151528,
-0.0255421586,
0.0344730876,
0.0204498824,
-0.0733927488,
-0.0233801641,
-5.622439071e-33,
-0.0239879284,
0.0023867467,
-0.0118307304,
-0.0070372447,
-0.0106695676,
-0.0100557646,
-0.0619500913,
-0.0114700003,
-0.0391086601,
-0.0388585962,
-0.0044705602,
0.0179626569,
-0.0090670669,
0.002291312,
-0.0063309227,
-0.0558714159,
0.0359888859,
-0.0104035782,
-0.0289030503,
0.0185705591,
-0.0121174548,
0.0338017754,
-0.0072653205,
-0.0296915863,
0.0352665186,
0.0019802265,
-0.0222279932,
0.0021787197,
-0.0078162057,
0.0573405251,
0.0146191781,
0.008389785,
0.0039272732,
-0.0115731144,
-0.0301625077,
0.0032166471,
-0.0527760051,
-0.0215414967,
0.0009568174,
0.0274911057,
-0.0232679378,
-0.0579171591,
0.0342644192,
-0.0441826209,
0.0285735,
0.0132278958,
0.003233504,
0.0019630874,
0.0028103557,
-0.0034109838,
-0.0302549694,
0.0280813575,
-0.0283983815,
-0.0008974951,
-0.0019743296,
0.0366521701,
0.029445,
0.0764525682,
-0.0248723663,
-0.031154735,
-0.0092723966,
0.0502206981,
0.0240992866,
0.0024993552,
0.0087192692,
0.0517918393,
0.0474115163,
-0.0225192644,
-0.0161161665,
0.0280335564,
0.0393699706,
0.017264789,
0.0544182248,
0.0877966136,
0.0380209237,
0.0120575102,
-0.0613140948,
-0.0173900519,
-0.0054333927,
0.0460405499,
-0.0028428815,
0.0482701957,
-0.047956951,
0.0154496124,
-0.0285533071,
-0.0687808171,
-0.0340524055,
-0.0318038426,
0.0475909226,
-0.0282802749,
-0.022153642,
0.0093636531,
0.0044182981,
-0.0679492652,
0.0372955836,
0.0243500005,
-0.012261875,
-0.0056560105,
-0.0037196497,
0.0576365404,
-0.0075694355,
-0.0089490172,
0.0377088301,
-0.0290773455,
0.0663494244,
0.0133527014,
0.0672738925,
0.0110994149,
-0.0454863682,
-0.0066040354,
-0.0221128017,
0.0023286538,
0.0108624399,
0.0361811817,
0.0455903448,
0.0073608304,
-0.0018177658,
0.0176811703,
0.0162639339,
-0.0366717204,
-0.0467581041,
0.0038555944,
-0.008647792,
-0.0017964223,
-0.0540759973,
-0.0591726899,
0.0084598297,
0.0557499193,
0.0348120257,
-0.0802716687,
-0.0177049674,
0.0010959037,
2.653e-7,
0.048183918,
0.0335386209,
0.0276382286,
0.0020588993,
0.0406902544,
0.0426502675,
-0.0197280962,
0.0714886338,
-0.0170539301,
-0.0486795343,
-0.0356251262,
0.0000758761,
0.0435129441,
0.042322319,
-0.0707416981,
0.0198458135,
-0.0399189666,
0.0201532189,
-0.0461975224,
0.0017568008,
0.0697911903,
0.1455708742,
0.0078120651,
0.0150408251,
0.0076502245,
-0.0651199073,
-0.0042104851,
0.0044405796,
0.0221577939,
0.0079909926,
-0.0546736047,
0.0248911884,
0.0033297262,
0.0012529374,
-0.0015721126,
-0.0124956816,
0.0346932821,
0.0716662928,
-0.017682638,
0.0186447557,
-0.0157403722,
-0.0294162165,
-0.0015669607,
-0.066991806,
0.0889164135,
-0.06532453,
0.0081507685,
0.0178637337,
-0.0167139359,
-0.0038733967,
-0.0041499841,
-0.0255024508,
-0.0049415622,
0.0041333018,
0.0242658444,
-0.0275960341,
-0.0008947139,
-0.0475707091,
-0.0376362205,
-0.0124083357,
-0.0081756897,
-0.0329384059,
-0.0315663628,
0.0143566951,
0.0240608659,
-0.0492131114,
0.0096253846,
2.390142765e-34,
0.0259529948,
-0.0247598551,
0.0343971774,
-0.0205295701,
0.0514287315,
0.0131463287,
0.0085871769,
0.0047438554,
0.0256104898,
-0.0542421415,
-0.0413230211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12867v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12867v4 | Red teaming ChatGPT via Jailbreaking: Bias, Robustness, Reliability and Toxicity | 2023-01-30T13:20:48 | 2023-05-29T17:46:54 | Terry Yue Zhuo, Yujin Huang, Chunyang Chen, Zhenchang Xing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Recent breakthroughs in natural language processing (NLP) have permitted the
synthesis and comprehension of coherent text in an open-ended way, therefore
translating the theoretical algorithms into practical applications. The large
language models (LLMs) have significantly impacted businesses such as report
summarization software and copywriters. Observations indicate, however, that
LLMs may exhibit social prejudice and toxicity, posing ethical and societal
dangers of consequences resulting from irresponsibility. Large-scale benchmarks
for accountable LLMs should consequently be developed. Although several
empirical investigations reveal the existence of a few ethical difficulties in
advanced LLMs, there is little systematic examination and user study of the
risks and harmful behaviors of current LLM usage. To further educate future
efforts on constructing ethical LLMs responsibly, we perform a qualitative
research method called ``red teaming'' on OpenAI's ChatGPT\footnote{In this
paper, ChatGPT refers to the version released on Dec 15th.} to better
understand the practical features of ethical dangers in recent LLMs. We analyze
ChatGPT comprehensively from four perspectives: 1) \textit{Bias} 2)
\textit{Reliability} 3) \textit{Robustness} 4) \textit{Toxicity}. In accordance
with our stated viewpoints, we empirically benchmark ChatGPT on multiple sample
datasets. We find that a significant number of ethical risks cannot be
addressed by existing benchmarks, and hence illustrate them via additional case
studies. In addition, we examine the implications of our findings on AI ethics
and harmal behaviors of ChatGPT, as well as future problems and practical
design considerations for responsible LLMs. We believe that our findings may
give light on future efforts to determine and mitigate the ethical hazards
posed by machines in LLM applications. | [
0.0737237483,
0.0912398249,
-0.0189370774,
0.0200789981,
-0.078266941,
-0.0028441108,
0.0185924806,
-0.009167701,
0.0635136589,
-0.064528726,
-0.022487713,
0.0163053256,
0.0280776005,
0.0195121206,
-0.0261050258,
-0.0291471481,
0.0366902538,
0.0100056669,
0.0119264824,
-0.0004666867,
0.0286109187,
0.0326081812,
0.053632196,
0.0680382624,
-0.0097003439,
-0.0129475165,
0.0157178901,
-0.0140514048,
0.0238307603,
0.0017489889,
-0.0107754404,
0.0487383828,
-0.0117482757,
0.0699502677,
0.0000021853,
-0.0626027733,
-0.0291997865,
0.0294100419,
0.0218683537,
0.0155657576,
0.0880137533,
-0.0147354947,
-0.009369432,
0.0230858363,
-0.0487485193,
0.039461609,
0.0431505702,
0.043056123,
0.0706795529,
0.0479350835,
-0.0146698551,
0.0059046592,
0.047574196,
0.0088750226,
-0.0292640235,
-0.0549593531,
0.0324924029,
-0.0083170757,
-0.0117903473,
-0.0010884269,
0.0112816812,
0.053152293,
0.016828049,
0.0002438033,
-0.0290431511,
-0.0047792126,
-0.0543627702,
-0.0569714308,
-0.014178955,
0.068118073,
0.0085396348,
0.0043850378,
0.0190509316,
0.0155857829,
0.0237040501,
0.0043593463,
-0.0209174603,
0.0883407891,
-0.0373092107,
0.020367559,
0.0159863941,
0.0241961479,
0.0066691735,
0.049288284,
0.0365781151,
0.0112294508,
-0.0317433849,
-0.0385842361,
0.0045663775,
0.0243182685,
-0.0342900902,
-0.0410521515,
0.0117610041,
0.0159318745,
-0.0094116814,
0.0385683291,
-0.0543807819,
-0.0388035662,
0.0470842235,
-0.0810818225,
-0.0173540227,
0.0186054055,
0.0160704311,
0.0122445961,
0.0201545395,
-0.0040823487,
0.0061456668,
0.0588961691,
-0.0340238214,
0.0039195423,
0.0008966633,
-0.0319964662,
-0.0152297011,
0.0425292961,
-0.0475476608,
-0.0031547793,
-0.0230027065,
0.0135910828,
-0.0458957814,
0.0119631756,
-0.0038858065,
0.0277743433,
-0.0136578986,
0.0090526454,
-0.0181834511,
-0.0355485007,
-0.038768854,
-0.0003107412,
0.0101946257,
-0.0663972646,
0.0100053716,
-0.008222172,
-0.0479540378,
0.0073785828,
-0.0025165435,
0.1170084402,
0.0034773545,
-0.0280354023,
-0.0498129614,
-0.0622554496,
-0.0316386335,
-0.0647572652,
-0.0172729343,
-0.0524331219,
0.0063315844,
0.0064834212,
-0.0333040245,
-0.06342078,
0.0133824674,
0.0297263879,
-0.0845098644,
0.0430506542,
-0.0261429809,
0.0101755522,
0.0086498167,
0.0541684516,
0.0054740999,
0.0863477141,
0.0558200516,
0.0494069159,
0.0809595287,
0.0014841687,
0.0305720065,
0.0346424803,
-0.0126015767,
-0.0038245439,
-0.0269752517,
0.0015207933,
-0.0387012362,
-0.0052225487,
-0.0084181894,
0.0881460533,
-0.0084839826,
-0.0062764706,
0.0755997822,
0.100766018,
-0.0339070447,
0.0451880768,
-0.017480297,
0.0029385264,
0.0095927585,
0.0309053902,
-0.0452898964,
0.013303047,
-0.0479028039,
-0.0096413167,
-0.0131960716,
0.060146559,
0.0060064751,
-0.0366485566,
-0.0131229721,
-0.017413862,
0.03061001,
0.0086188996,
-0.010351955,
0.0061155139,
-0.0324295536,
-0.0046924772,
0.0315711387,
-0.0791961849,
-0.0173624195,
-0.071228914,
0.0261779968,
0.0717870444,
0.0745212808,
-0.0228578076,
0.0399479754,
-0.0289087985,
-0.048858583,
0.0309879389,
0.0459554382,
-0.013272793,
-0.0223272946,
-0.0341626517,
-0.0325880051,
0.0165618174,
0.0014773651,
0.0030075249,
0.0280053969,
0.0045455848,
0.0041089021,
-0.0086369738,
-0.0721842051,
0.0330104083,
0.0053213681,
0.0029622011,
-0.0266994312,
0.0103122992,
0.0180514697,
0.0158451106,
-0.0313377753,
0.0097314296,
0.0271155648,
0.0143466787,
-0.0202263668,
0.0240470003,
-0.0235239808,
-0.0024375285,
-0.0009609092,
-0.0850958601,
-0.0247844644,
0.0639207736,
-0.0204322394,
0.0054820548,
0.0122112939,
-0.0089738332,
0.0110638384,
-0.0388472229,
-0.0041340371,
-0.047546912,
0.0035058691,
-0.0597945191,
0.0652708411,
-0.0131811099,
-0.0293846,
-0.0089483028,
-0.0453219153,
0.0006382039,
0.0031515167,
-0.0367252827,
0.0406957716,
-0.0017885803,
0.0418054387,
0.0411508344,
0.0169137008,
-0.0180954393,
-0.0299479216,
-0.0859864727,
0.0005911199,
-0.0078471741,
0.0049762577,
0.0084443465,
0.0092100063,
-0.0259440914,
0.017099971,
-0.0139358621,
-0.0405826531,
0.0208986253,
0.033364553,
0.0243382175,
-0.0156614482,
0.0052974909,
-0.0192756262,
0.0055364836,
-0.013788389,
0.0285373777,
0.0498315617,
-0.0510684699,
-0.0269621182,
0.0294717886,
-0.0422818288,
-0.0000225847,
0.0020209225,
-0.0113781178,
0.0067621437,
0.0262335222,
-0.0058069373,
0.0781055838,
0.0363296047,
0.0579147041,
0.0510939769,
0.0462597944,
-0.0276076868,
-0.0182014517,
0.0088277562,
-0.022238642,
0.0213061161,
-0.0512899496,
0.0215962697,
0.0261004698,
0.0055993148,
-0.0128275985,
-0.035231974,
0.0409966186,
-0.0585142113,
-0.0618006401,
0.0147379832,
-0.0654124171,
-0.029991487,
0.009383481,
-0.0262138881,
-0.0678299516,
0.058511883,
0.0021525037,
0.03480272,
-0.0483453348,
-0.002755234,
-0.0442347713,
0.0760525167,
-0.0017420453,
0.0341012217,
0.024954265,
-0.0158123188,
-0.0257929862,
-0.0072434647,
0.0423659012,
-0.0453789867,
0.0593326576,
-0.060655389,
0.0223611072,
-0.0309636053,
-0.0409682579,
-0.0251934975,
-0.0541720167,
-0.0126081388,
-0.006516105,
0.0639913306,
0.0175205301,
-0.0178110059,
0.0190985706,
0.0448105596,
0.0052735289,
-0.0065653729,
-0.0078076343,
-0.0030043228,
0.0087553514,
0.0338837281,
-0.0496531092,
0.0713266879,
0.0208021738,
0.0395293646,
0.0884167328,
0.0331590213,
0.0097272946,
0.0298300497,
0.0086359922,
0.0079658879,
-0.0222189445,
0.0126652755,
0.0271858443,
0.0508051105,
-0.025950348,
0.0193059146,
0.0680792332,
0.0260137618,
-0.0563553423,
0.0172722265,
0.0287303906,
-0.0040314989,
0.0003783915,
0.0088520059,
-0.0969188586,
-0.0113357315,
0.0046461606,
0.0643670782,
-0.0816552192,
-0.0768850073,
-0.0124890897,
-0.1116771847,
0.0408515148,
0.0046777301,
-0.0379360653,
-0.0037176588,
-0.0354032926,
-0.0297656581,
-0.0291089453,
0.0419910811,
-0.0154456003,
-0.02477259,
-0.0250266548,
0.0171300881,
-0.070146285,
0.0106048947,
0.0146697592,
-0.0378099121,
0.0460258387,
0.0917004868,
0.0219147801,
-0.0434622169,
0.0425228514,
0.0105597097,
0.0189589206,
0.0022477221,
0.0114455689,
0.0446503833,
-0.019865049,
-0.0009302694,
-0.0591402538,
0.023108812,
0.0017787827,
-0.0099797752,
0.0266884938,
0.0338269509,
0.0106119858,
-0.055384025,
-0.0439969487,
0.0033626347,
-0.0091026705,
0.0708170533,
-0.0086446051,
-0.0190556571,
-0.0472339913,
-0.0288205855,
-0.0227292422,
-0.0445481725,
-0.0439732336,
-0.0037632824,
-0.0100441165,
-0.0189406164,
-0.0815145597,
-0.0731429234,
-0.0043394221,
-0.0062397467,
0.0441853479,
-0.0241948701,
0.0165470168,
0.0301975962,
0.0008114086,
0.0036999793,
-0.0141495429,
0.0098598301,
-0.0082271406,
0.0264256448,
-0.0104494514,
-0.0048240335,
0.0226465259,
0.0344916694,
-0.0240792483,
-0.0547956713,
0.0303481612,
0.0505214222,
0.0350310504,
0.0264090132,
0.0005749051,
-0.0146339647,
0.0097673154,
0.1134164408,
-0.0338865258,
0.0436737575,
0.0219590347,
0.0122587681,
0.0028890362,
0.0127530424,
-0.0313563235,
-0.000909224,
0.013080202,
0.01383706,
-0.0390971117,
-0.0128832282,
0.032362368,
0.0480559506,
-0.0279918127,
-0.0476323217,
0.0307348277,
-0.0256420188,
-0.0323796347,
-0.024644943,
-0.0398852341,
-0.04275297,
0.0114790825,
0.0134954574,
0.0025020691,
-0.012273171,
0.042894695,
-0.0490057394,
0.0076674982,
-0.0242006332,
0.0416046977,
-0.0127705364,
0.0377927236,
-0.0012588984,
0.0013989139,
-0.0519577079,
0.0235776585,
-0.049574405,
0.0352107771,
0.0014447581,
0.0480424054,
0.0165611636,
0.003856465,
0.0248624962,
0.0622565411,
-0.0711726919,
-0.057840921,
-0.013670465,
0.0840547755,
-0.0095962249,
0.0103612263,
0.0288968794,
-0.0301857367,
0.0057881107,
-0.0018978062,
-0.0065829786,
0.00859477,
-0.058262378,
-0.0270290487,
0.0070160115,
-0.0391114615,
0.0022896314,
0.0898541063,
-0.0183927473,
0.0440818109,
-0.0086372513,
-0.0306928921,
-0.0027653505,
-0.0725906268,
0.0564359911,
-0.0321817845,
-0.0122248959,
-0.0566142835,
-0.1042822301,
-0.0574648157,
-0.0312961638,
0.0008918904,
0.0565776676,
-0.0395674706,
-0.0085584391,
0.044248905,
0.0170448199,
0.0039000225,
-0.0463726819,
-0.0093185445,
-0.0574095845,
-0.0039828056,
0.0011309974,
-6.10240921e-33,
0.0069262702,
-0.0479374528,
-0.0400438383,
0.0064156312,
-0.028996421,
-0.0085982997,
-0.0184785016,
0.0109521318,
-0.0255503468,
-0.0183370952,
-0.0336801745,
-0.0121716484,
0.0066949157,
-0.0041410238,
0.0007769041,
-0.0420377031,
-0.0014424766,
-0.0192516502,
-0.0329944305,
0.0020742998,
0.0016889928,
-0.0026227953,
0.0183559768,
-0.0634602532,
0.0734737441,
-0.019256236,
-0.036797367,
-0.0001267921,
-0.0323216096,
0.0377116986,
0.0182618257,
0.0456262827,
0.0255155265,
-0.0236842949,
0.0047574751,
0.0573497862,
-0.0294007771,
0.0074175331,
0.0268127359,
-0.0034784442,
-0.031836573,
-0.0214123633,
0.0582635701,
-0.0169736054,
-0.0339928642,
-0.0143025434,
0.0313136093,
-0.0334300064,
-0.0390445776,
-0.0200186688,
-0.0389692858,
0.0009711937,
-0.0334986001,
0.0021067834,
-0.0213137027,
0.030502269,
-0.0092626028,
0.0203546416,
-0.0273756441,
0.0075914664,
0.0188224725,
-0.062963672,
0.0553773083,
-0.0225283839,
0.0265585631,
0.0776397809,
0.0031368493,
0.0295476522,
-0.0487091579,
-0.0415824316,
-0.0176599771,
0.0355808362,
0.0399561003,
0.057417471,
0.0250512529,
-0.0407834612,
-0.0380692296,
0.0311860647,
0.050357841,
0.015250071,
0.0222642347,
-0.026315378,
-0.0603436083,
-0.028915368,
-0.0116756726,
-0.0266335905,
-0.0251557399,
-0.0197169092,
0.0275174566,
-0.0127583565,
-0.0433920063,
-0.0086295931,
0.0106294891,
-0.0749714375,
0.0301287659,
-0.0154806981,
0.0051868642,
0.0051350375,
-0.0136792231,
0.0075528803,
-0.0600943044,
0.0215773191,
0.0022412967,
0.0134443706,
0.0407282412,
0.0026545781,
0.0435884036,
0.0177297741,
-0.015395782,
0.0255472381,
-0.0052654161,
0.0706340894,
0.0312445778,
-0.0086931093,
0.029667899,
-0.0080552492,
0.0031033573,
-0.0130747491,
0.0397681408,
0.0323486067,
-0.0571408495,
0.0095530134,
-0.0245889984,
-0.0089545548,
-0.0253318995,
-0.0024960793,
-0.0079150014,
0.0190285314,
0.0620567687,
-0.0569059849,
-0.0207357015,
-0.009814919,
2.908e-7,
0.0126713654,
0.0052033775,
0.0358452834,
0.0001441243,
-0.0206931066,
0.0541162826,
0.0193169769,
0.0766756982,
0.0056720707,
0.0000533142,
0.0281270444,
0.0051635611,
0.057579089,
0.0563717261,
-0.0501316264,
-0.0220807381,
-0.0805970803,
-0.0132778641,
-0.0653623641,
0.0173996128,
0.060368605,
0.0410955995,
-0.0079190498,
-0.0256317947,
-0.020414941,
-0.0413908586,
0.0366868116,
-0.0277796872,
0.0036095087,
0.0088594155,
0.025262123,
0.0391805172,
-0.0046750344,
0.0092346529,
0.0244241375,
-0.0334720612,
0.0468435697,
0.0599182248,
-0.0102931838,
-0.0216363855,
-0.0082338508,
-0.0792861208,
0.0226630736,
-0.0283969771,
0.0783929601,
-0.0157994851,
-0.0179607198,
-0.0493890271,
0.0278742425,
-0.0431758761,
0.017879162,
0.0015612582,
-0.0029228907,
0.0300181024,
-0.0086099338,
0.0115229301,
0.0230486505,
-0.0709217861,
-0.0159839876,
-0.0467222072,
0.0065966542,
-0.070697099,
0.0012400547,
0.0613269694,
0.0076307817,
-0.0514121056,
0.0186255593,
2.899909666e-34,
0.0149146942,
-0.0496353209,
-0.0048661241,
0.0048037916,
0.0483892858,
0.035797257,
0.0074493643,
0.0060727624,
-0.0121198129,
-0.0293072853,
-0.0211671703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12866v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12866v2 | N-Gram Nearest Neighbor Machine Translation | 2023-01-30T13:19:19 | 2023-02-07T14:15:26 | Rui Lv, Junliang Guo, Rui Wang, Xu Tan, Qi Liu, Tao Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Nearest neighbor machine translation augments the Autoregressive
Translation~(AT) with $k$-nearest-neighbor retrieval, by comparing the
similarity between the token-level context representations of the target tokens
in the query and the datastore. However, the token-level representation may
introduce noise when translating ambiguous words, or fail to provide accurate
retrieval results when the representation generated by the model contains
indistinguishable context information, e.g., Non-Autoregressive
Translation~(NAT) models. In this paper, we propose a novel $n$-gram nearest
neighbor retrieval method that is model agnostic and applicable to both AT and
NAT models. Specifically, we concatenate the adjacent $n$-gram hidden
representations as the key, while the tuple of corresponding target tokens is
the value. In inference, we propose tailored decoding algorithms for AT and NAT
models respectively. We demonstrate that the proposed method consistently
outperforms the token-level method on both AT and NAT models as well on general
as on domain adaptation translation tasks. On domain adaptation, the proposed
method brings $1.03$ and $2.76$ improvements regarding the average BLEU score
on AT and NAT models respectively. | [
0.0310440101,
0.0398932621,
0.0059178555,
0.0209418889,
-0.0547522828,
0.0255839452,
0.0570603348,
0.0187061355,
-0.0304904785,
-0.031363152,
-0.0401203781,
-0.0233464278,
0.0156929214,
0.010890808,
0.0370321684,
0.0166175719,
0.0411641635,
-0.0076358193,
-0.0092491768,
0.0010895006,
-0.0339987613,
0.0282669701,
0.0086267041,
0.0494568981,
0.0050386884,
0.0121382903,
0.0232727453,
0.0399739146,
0.017768329,
-0.0357977264,
-0.0136354072,
0.0235707778,
0.027274562,
0.0488934331,
0.0000019653,
-0.0280151498,
-0.0857542604,
0.0182416048,
-0.0108885234,
-0.0412340127,
0.1025430784,
-0.0379924849,
0.0276576094,
0.0389308631,
-0.0244533028,
-0.0693816766,
0.0762673542,
0.0227179192,
0.0298954062,
0.0678237751,
-0.0155592663,
-0.0467319563,
-0.0260458924,
-0.0380529389,
0.0037110969,
-0.0864013061,
0.0106467661,
-0.0295697879,
-0.0414943919,
0.031525325,
-0.0142308567,
0.0769045725,
-0.0212002546,
0.0088878665,
0.0063445671,
0.0252275728,
0.0090248445,
0.0044139642,
0.0033713363,
0.029870864,
-0.0297636073,
-0.0317520127,
-0.0022205594,
0.0272338539,
-0.0080874208,
0.013316595,
-0.0462642126,
-0.0041628843,
0.0074319504,
0.0072436342,
0.0196933467,
0.0639065579,
0.0231217761,
0.007296232,
-0.0719342083,
-0.009409559,
0.0330172479,
-0.01381825,
-0.0290780738,
0.000901008,
-0.0071071456,
0.0087491684,
0.0785685778,
-0.0259844139,
0.0138389589,
0.018211022,
-0.0014550935,
-0.0500893295,
-0.0129995979,
-0.0323454589,
0.0172805041,
0.0787677243,
-0.024558574,
0.046619501,
-0.0665853024,
0.0578798801,
0.0010384837,
-0.019666791,
-0.0606529452,
-0.0507741198,
-0.0415769033,
0.0026684706,
-0.0566874295,
0.0262985323,
-0.0813180283,
-0.0178101752,
0.0055678496,
0.0168109052,
0.0384448804,
-0.0400158949,
0.0226418525,
0.0156234279,
-0.080459781,
-0.0264125615,
0.011308887,
0.0414921381,
-0.0190311968,
0.003768546,
0.0149739757,
-0.0526593179,
-0.0435636602,
-0.0015429716,
0.0308851339,
-0.0501392186,
-0.0090413783,
0.0616155267,
0.0039607664,
-0.0119974781,
-0.0023887092,
-0.0118626468,
-0.0255531501,
0.0094098467,
0.0050499481,
-0.0442140549,
0.0807092935,
0.0095483046,
0.0193699356,
-0.0680528879,
-0.0237990674,
-0.0029975332,
-0.0305326618,
0.0754582137,
0.0246655196,
-0.0088243615,
0.0350838192,
-0.0232172217,
0.0146782435,
0.0617776029,
-0.0037367409,
0.0344522297,
0.025762083,
0.0100385547,
-0.0602089837,
-0.0025519743,
0.0323586091,
0.023551438,
-0.0361835025,
0.0144855129,
0.0478982702,
0.0113562411,
0.0082098488,
0.022264462,
-0.0376730897,
-0.0352898948,
-0.0000442037,
0.0649730191,
0.0279337,
0.0283135828,
-0.0014804803,
0.0087962458,
-0.0629689917,
-0.0438282341,
-0.0266127344,
0.0437905975,
-0.0278771445,
0.0019799843,
0.0714576393,
0.0624645203,
-0.0096449386,
-0.0247309115,
0.0171645824,
-0.010411026,
-0.0159736052,
0.0074002771,
0.0413291715,
0.0179549493,
-0.0326212272,
0.0627502352,
-0.0108913071,
-0.0329979621,
0.0137509285,
-0.0291117709,
-0.0173508618,
0.0150232194,
0.0497477762,
-0.016046647,
-0.0285315607,
-0.0095010577,
-0.0098288935,
0.039362032,
0.0050884071,
0.0226739049,
0.0354489982,
-0.046931643,
-0.0437936597,
0.0118295047,
0.0267267972,
0.0492242016,
-0.0170589499,
0.0425960124,
0.069574587,
-0.0837210491,
-0.0117549952,
0.0180264283,
-0.003488244,
-0.0260522719,
0.0606606044,
0.0371878557,
-0.0008867416,
0.0530934148,
-0.0055172998,
0.0151478117,
-0.0022429584,
-0.0634465441,
0.0068305274,
0.0102106854,
-0.042522382,
-0.0913158879,
0.0071471813,
0.0000511068,
0.0295035243,
0.0001927554,
-0.0334562249,
-0.0332892723,
0.020506449,
-0.0212127082,
0.0319940858,
-0.0447927006,
0.020099232,
0.0038962765,
-0.0023025556,
-0.0496813692,
0.0335656591,
-0.0055826199,
0.0097115925,
0.0007264534,
-0.0136349313,
0.0335114896,
-0.0134341586,
-0.0056437179,
0.0195303485,
-0.0176506117,
-0.0211070422,
0.0522879846,
0.0120604793,
-0.0080345245,
-0.0402828902,
-0.0480328798,
-0.0039366987,
-0.0324003883,
0.0435074791,
0.0272886995,
0.0857534409,
0.0074088043,
-0.0238798261,
-0.0284361597,
-0.0000847965,
-0.0109992418,
0.0260415599,
-0.0068018353,
0.0071240943,
-0.0027414428,
-0.0271852687,
-0.0264279153,
0.0008767396,
0.0563734919,
-0.0452777185,
-0.0805431455,
-0.0528054871,
0.048977837,
-0.0578935556,
0.0034720115,
0.00755359,
-0.0325111933,
-0.0014430644,
-0.0588684306,
0.0101449834,
0.0329903215,
-0.0044532795,
-0.0172734372,
0.0080172615,
-0.0255907457,
-0.1005149037,
0.003680239,
-0.0427967571,
-0.03504223,
0.001245234,
-0.0308159012,
0.0328908004,
0.0150061958,
0.0135973757,
-0.0107721807,
-0.0581257008,
0.0239819475,
-0.0134015307,
-0.0279773287,
-0.047843352,
0.0611491166,
0.0286764018,
0.0193729047,
-0.0239773057,
-0.0318628997,
0.0755141601,
-0.0240818895,
0.0117827887,
-0.0564390197,
-0.0100792404,
-0.0277269483,
0.0551428683,
-0.0503787473,
0.0461261608,
-0.0234957263,
-0.0861456096,
-0.0006625325,
0.0384219773,
0.0055074175,
-0.0350221731,
0.0282237846,
-0.0133489929,
0.0106802424,
0.0078418478,
-0.0109668905,
-0.0010419202,
-0.0062312516,
0.0120785497,
-0.0285081659,
-0.0110071655,
-0.0032791321,
-0.0525084585,
0.0547584482,
-0.0050781737,
0.0466301404,
-0.0113846492,
0.0093652476,
-0.0096159568,
0.0135264182,
0.0136931827,
-0.0096050482,
0.0048666485,
0.0122320559,
0.0229712222,
0.0190287624,
0.0219793934,
-0.0484185144,
-0.0196377486,
0.0007201456,
0.0423879363,
0.0370214917,
-0.0224269368,
-0.0010341048,
0.0035654469,
-0.0222407486,
-0.0516031198,
0.1113112271,
0.0225555822,
-0.0428877696,
-0.0246087089,
-0.0355517045,
0.0201415997,
0.0198572297,
0.0309275258,
-0.0511018559,
-0.0341882966,
-0.0044557359,
0.0466894619,
0.0514440089,
-0.011228974,
-0.0124581344,
-0.0884625465,
0.0188989006,
0.0569604002,
-0.0732376128,
-0.0717478395,
-0.0257227942,
-0.0258787312,
-0.0296407491,
0.0161158685,
0.0149441818,
0.0363182575,
0.0036571303,
0.01120394,
0.0193375684,
-0.0637339875,
-0.0063928133,
-0.0374523401,
0.028643921,
0.056942001,
0.0113534564,
0.0356333479,
-0.0105118221,
-0.0103530753,
0.0024218694,
0.046959281,
-0.0373761766,
0.0017783433,
-0.030070724,
-0.0090636704,
0.0283916071,
-0.0346543379,
-0.0578596815,
0.0279053096,
-0.0145996129,
0.048899103,
-0.0276820473,
0.0312879495,
-0.0120227169,
-0.0564147234,
0.0251697749,
0.0655535981,
-0.00304428,
0.0202943888,
0.0021403544,
-0.0134904077,
0.013280388,
-0.0147056021,
0.0095550809,
-0.0095268674,
-0.0538388938,
-0.0510026366,
-0.0692007169,
-0.027451925,
0.0240857098,
0.0666790456,
-0.0094262371,
0.0506306663,
0.0035813989,
-0.0145649286,
-0.0290022902,
0.0014520969,
-0.0500358082,
0.0099118268,
-0.013725454,
0.0276502538,
0.052074559,
-0.0061280201,
-0.0242364369,
-0.0098536815,
-0.065779984,
-0.050444115,
-0.0093704564,
0.0134305404,
0.0169219822,
0.0296598691,
-0.047038205,
-0.0227229055,
0.0164056625,
0.0497718789,
-0.0679071769,
-0.0157378726,
0.0206342023,
-0.0016947766,
-0.0209521931,
0.0486456715,
-0.079111591,
0.0018567477,
-0.0107512809,
0.0795562044,
0.0309487339,
-0.0239516255,
0.0258344002,
0.0156900156,
0.0713942498,
-0.0024427744,
-0.0463413671,
-0.0229453351,
0.0252431389,
-0.0211544372,
-0.0051766271,
-0.0245540943,
0.0111861723,
0.0364875868,
-0.0097383717,
0.016609177,
0.0104936659,
0.0053569032,
0.0359249897,
-0.0230015647,
0.0015306926,
-0.0225906968,
0.0441678353,
-0.0090208631,
0.0294110589,
-0.0409712121,
-0.0231104828,
0.036594294,
0.0027053528,
-0.0828062594,
0.0080412691,
-0.0002417497,
0.0179122202,
-0.0457885899,
0.0522047952,
-0.0573993623,
0.0158291329,
-0.0421443954,
-0.0334190354,
0.0354094878,
-0.0170885418,
0.0472125523,
0.0043858988,
0.0104401158,
-0.0366637409,
0.0214336459,
0.043513298,
-0.0091981003,
0.0167663712,
-0.0121246343,
-0.0014854312,
0.0143442862,
0.0649944842,
-0.0153663866,
0.0119719617,
-0.0075290133,
-0.0220161881,
-0.0170017052,
-0.011738102,
0.0014279995,
0.0183296576,
-0.0327710547,
-0.0118415495,
0.0116540873,
-0.0500423647,
0.0204024203,
-0.039177224,
-0.0393803455,
0.005956111,
0.0128203165,
0.0742749795,
-0.0006226055,
-0.0038819951,
-0.0220212024,
0.0246248171,
-0.0076902825,
-0.0289890245,
-0.0049670883,
-6.584506627e-33,
-0.0238407068,
-0.0047455626,
-0.018606009,
-0.0816520452,
-0.0193989668,
0.0073489035,
-0.0330952518,
-0.0295279268,
0.0034996881,
-0.0178542864,
-0.0054035899,
0.0279776976,
0.0410883613,
0.0001947717,
0.0095020821,
-0.0166450795,
0.061399933,
0.004283838,
-0.0002035833,
0.0327238329,
0.0374539644,
0.0611518174,
0.0673512071,
-0.085612379,
0.0329801887,
0.0139399162,
0.0228378344,
-0.0028524925,
0.0654338226,
0.032712087,
0.0002875144,
0.0256319474,
0.0110581042,
-0.0552450679,
-0.052339755,
-0.0426929481,
-0.1108851358,
-0.0405171663,
-0.0027724518,
0.0169115011,
0.0214937143,
-0.0392357893,
0.015814865,
0.0001459896,
-0.0076804603,
-0.0067342329,
-0.0213094149,
-0.0539349169,
-0.0557412133,
-0.0419686809,
-0.0135097811,
0.0242580008,
-0.0038189823,
0.0460145772,
0.0652512833,
0.0356690101,
0.0050135083,
-0.0036626358,
-0.0687183738,
0.0252821892,
-0.0292600226,
0.0764719769,
0.0657664388,
0.0194896553,
0.0222822987,
-0.0061395834,
0.0569682419,
-0.0460264534,
0.0099555934,
0.0018761454,
0.0250098966,
0.0097744921,
0.0290829148,
0.0411812514,
0.0399044491,
-0.0472658612,
-0.0403733328,
0.0456472971,
-0.0107498541,
0.0429961793,
0.0362986177,
0.0477210544,
-0.0559427142,
-0.0083105303,
-0.0264707115,
-0.0170132611,
-0.0645376667,
-0.0247647557,
0.0475773625,
0.0295015089,
-0.037398804,
-0.0061013689,
0.0892046988,
-0.0137808872,
-0.0111676678,
0.0235606879,
0.0454094186,
-0.0239330865,
-0.0267719161,
0.0429275259,
0.0185326971,
-0.0516639575,
0.0355085246,
0.002781641,
-0.0009215719,
-0.0241792444,
-0.0067175152,
0.0263626315,
-0.0835172758,
-0.0198613703,
-0.0253935214,
-0.0391294658,
-0.012184062,
-0.0151070422,
0.0080864299,
-0.0103649003,
0.0341853313,
0.0692935064,
0.0302378871,
-0.009146153,
0.0046091224,
0.0125286831,
0.0399251729,
-0.0080551747,
-0.0557291582,
0.0079674041,
-0.0116728451,
0.0054551973,
0.054499507,
0.0046778941,
-0.0319877528,
0.0378622301,
2.814e-7,
0.0595775284,
0.0422722138,
0.0403449237,
-0.0089578172,
-0.0337933861,
0.0190617051,
-0.0036179575,
0.0436482094,
0.0516206101,
0.0189641733,
0.0132010849,
-0.0262764469,
0.0657493919,
0.0271652229,
-0.0845494494,
0.0329763331,
-0.0132302325,
0.0393053852,
-0.0511417724,
-0.0011020199,
0.067193836,
0.1151323691,
-0.0371075198,
0.0211397745,
-0.0221044831,
-0.0685139373,
0.0368271843,
-0.0275665373,
-0.0097259386,
-0.0375891104,
0.0384102054,
0.0164951757,
0.0079246135,
-0.0283075217,
-0.0076491507,
0.0460812263,
0.0637578443,
0.0454209708,
-0.013135924,
-0.0598607808,
0.0039542643,
-0.0296329502,
0.0173991229,
-0.0430854,
0.0649775937,
-0.0177820958,
0.006215442,
0.0326871835,
0.0021021867,
0.0423081443,
-0.0174624696,
-0.0084615564,
-0.0466142371,
0.0256648138,
0.0549281351,
0.0176636763,
-0.0195733272,
-0.0906565785,
-0.0231445972,
-0.0557594337,
-0.0025613683,
-0.0065297736,
-0.0250579733,
0.0575972348,
0.0220169593,
0.0141128581,
0.0023131745,
2.813966106e-34,
0.0312198289,
0.0114541566,
0.0079457266,
0.0252616815,
0.0531777889,
-0.0431417301,
-0.002779322,
0.0448748916,
-0.0119458837,
-0.1160368696,
-0.0550419651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12855v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12855v1 | How Far Can It Go?: On Intrinsic Gender Bias Mitigation for Text Classification | 2023-01-30T13:05:48 | 2023-01-30T13:05:48 | Ewoenam Tokpo, Pieter Delobelle, Bettina Berendt, Toon Calders | cs.CL | cs.CL | To mitigate gender bias in contextualized language models, different
intrinsic mitigation strategies have been proposed, alongside many bias
metrics. Considering that the end use of these language models is for
downstream tasks like text classification, it is important to understand how
these intrinsic bias mitigation strategies actually translate to fairness in
downstream tasks and the extent of this. In this work, we design a probe to
investigate the effects that some of the major intrinsic gender bias mitigation
strategies have on downstream text classification tasks. We discover that
instead of resolving gender bias, intrinsic mitigation techniques and metrics
are able to hide it in such a way that significant gender information is
retained in the embeddings. Furthermore, we show that each mitigation technique
is able to hide the bias from some of the intrinsic bias measures but not all,
and each intrinsic bias measure can be fooled by some mitigation techniques,
but not all. We confirm experimentally, that none of the intrinsic mitigation
techniques used without any other fairness intervention is able to consistently
impact extrinsic bias. We recommend that intrinsic bias mitigation techniques
should be combined with other fairness interventions for downstream tasks. | [
0.0528467372,
0.0604196042,
-0.0305069126,
0.0395688601,
-0.0070682052,
0.0387627892,
0.0416580401,
-0.0117908735,
-0.0024008527,
-0.086358279,
-0.0165009163,
-0.0166642088,
0.0293310322,
-0.0121638142,
0.0292148013,
-0.0137325842,
0.0231693443,
0.0264429506,
0.0486527681,
-0.0402329452,
0.0246250369,
0.0030369139,
0.0379500873,
0.0486974642,
0.0185560472,
-0.0189233329,
0.0698574781,
0.0043453532,
-0.0199334156,
-0.0072578192,
0.0696274936,
0.0713578165,
-0.0145660471,
0.0293447953,
0.0000017509,
-0.0619896352,
0.0204411782,
0.0447639935,
-0.0110000856,
0.0199837405,
0.0488204844,
-0.0335552879,
-0.0098212557,
0.0330784731,
-0.0148229133,
-0.0082747964,
0.0163715668,
0.0404564105,
0.0104026515,
0.0210592784,
-0.0133895073,
0.0207559522,
-0.0514560491,
-0.0386161692,
-0.009271414,
0.0093237339,
0.0384619944,
-0.0458774008,
-0.058521688,
0.0376275368,
-0.0352768824,
0.0059302817,
0.0045196493,
-0.0054856539,
0.0276656579,
0.0505420789,
-0.0143312262,
-0.0318156481,
0.0204362851,
0.0264861621,
0.0034176651,
-0.0127108423,
0.0040749866,
-0.0014779925,
0.0381823704,
-0.0009282568,
-0.0329278708,
0.013418234,
0.0018552728,
-0.0043435241,
0.0093232878,
0.021612728,
0.0510619693,
0.0593776591,
0.0125458604,
0.0578804277,
0.0161423646,
-0.0387207419,
0.0001308776,
0.0286629479,
0.0103624444,
-0.0494294316,
0.0025566632,
-0.0255941283,
0.0471317358,
-0.0075790854,
-0.0190179702,
-0.0117099043,
0.0384550989,
-0.0799326226,
-0.0230593756,
0.0356811062,
0.0164236259,
0.0156434402,
-0.0552417375,
0.014673817,
0.0089384411,
0.0477086566,
-0.0047152089,
-0.0173716601,
-0.0141479317,
-0.017206559,
-0.0032962642,
0.0060616196,
-0.0245675389,
0.0225161202,
-0.0177522376,
0.0220963173,
-0.0530074202,
-0.0245258771,
0.0176564604,
0.0365143232,
-0.0088498648,
0.025373511,
0.0022078152,
-0.026809603,
-0.0430773683,
0.0311380625,
-0.0633395165,
-0.0666070729,
-0.0210690666,
0.0132791176,
-0.0096169822,
-0.0410697237,
-0.0080357706,
0.0127843134,
0.0208792854,
-0.045834288,
-0.0035692856,
0.0046494114,
-0.0319481753,
-0.0418551564,
-0.0095493346,
-0.040466208,
-0.0018471209,
0.044988893,
0.0140217328,
-0.0355158113,
-0.0241635349,
0.0125548383,
-0.0551732816,
0.0555409454,
0.0919677764,
-0.0242607743,
0.0705887899,
0.0189790707,
-0.0024550087,
0.1039794683,
0.0387671515,
-0.0137390876,
0.0524449758,
0.0208001342,
-0.0253333263,
0.0301857311,
0.0590820201,
0.0414596684,
-0.0400719456,
0.0264323018,
-0.013176593,
0.0223105885,
0.0751352012,
-0.015891619,
0.012798246,
-0.0284740608,
0.0519102477,
0.0807972252,
0.0354335643,
0.0343470424,
0.0098557202,
-0.0341826379,
-0.028050296,
0.0281715374,
-0.0919492543,
-0.0038815083,
-0.0090792729,
-0.0686569288,
0.0111169238,
0.0123199485,
-0.0320411026,
-0.0282289181,
-0.0111309998,
0.0195539519,
0.0270898938,
0.0034769427,
0.01420552,
0.013387342,
0.0160805192,
0.049102135,
0.033002317,
-0.0467689261,
0.0378709175,
-0.0571432747,
0.0244211759,
0.0065344688,
0.0105691748,
-0.0432881899,
0.0310882665,
-0.0266855638,
-0.0286516119,
0.017965911,
0.0706270859,
-0.004226875,
0.0067597735,
-0.0322894491,
-0.0408470854,
-0.0070573078,
0.0573924296,
-0.0039456049,
0.0318116657,
0.0348517857,
0.0190950707,
-0.0552420504,
-0.0353267007,
0.0471781678,
-0.0031242105,
-0.0427027047,
0.044461485,
-0.0085034324,
-0.006963423,
0.0171304196,
-0.0308603421,
0.0126470039,
-0.0070169647,
0.0016952676,
-0.0174465887,
0.0049689207,
-0.0343148671,
-0.0189262237,
-0.0122570051,
-0.0389059484,
-0.0394063555,
0.0233488288,
-0.0065224678,
0.0093340976,
0.0519654639,
-0.003465859,
0.0231156573,
-0.0239526294,
-0.0009790709,
-0.041614607,
0.0487169698,
-0.0325606577,
0.0204171371,
-0.0275422968,
-0.0252288859,
0.0025395616,
-0.0330156125,
0.0004222171,
-0.0473156236,
-0.0360613689,
0.010664369,
0.020731302,
0.0078189876,
0.0534104705,
-0.0508497246,
-0.0094650164,
-0.0307523757,
-0.0791304782,
0.0036257461,
-0.0239391718,
-0.000689008,
0.0135025093,
0.02291549,
-0.0095756194,
-0.0129821617,
-0.0110772867,
-0.0620585606,
-0.0149948969,
0.036535304,
0.0176138822,
-0.0261749495,
0.0378403813,
-0.02393144,
-0.0363629274,
-0.0454558805,
0.0943614095,
0.028057754,
0.0202051159,
-0.0527812131,
-0.0207342729,
-0.0067438637,
0.0213081241,
-0.013491136,
-0.0064243311,
-0.0162544791,
0.0325794928,
0.0015024052,
0.0861652941,
0.0280710086,
0.02646471,
0.0587229505,
0.0413095653,
-0.0735709146,
-0.0243024509,
0.024162855,
0.0484950505,
0.0110384626,
-0.0338848867,
-0.0015210395,
0.0278154053,
0.008154979,
-0.0488161035,
-0.0480499864,
0.0670738593,
-0.0517063402,
-0.0345430374,
-0.0363876335,
-0.035208337,
0.0173300225,
-0.0042543933,
-0.0469688587,
-0.0605581999,
0.0406460017,
-0.0282005239,
0.0200035609,
-0.0385281071,
-0.0078755543,
-0.0630451143,
0.0202413611,
-0.0279567149,
0.0173640996,
0.0280237049,
-0.0059369849,
-0.0660845414,
-0.0300294515,
0.0310560782,
-0.025832545,
0.0260839853,
-0.0085294601,
0.025514029,
-0.0156979617,
-0.03942094,
-0.0470672287,
-0.0631136447,
0.0268701557,
0.0173994005,
0.0091980407,
0.0045284457,
-0.0049521602,
0.0355922803,
-0.0077498248,
0.0413820259,
-0.0386681855,
-0.0122080101,
-0.0057463427,
0.0102428095,
0.0086609516,
-0.0073162834,
0.0227871817,
-0.0117835691,
0.001788305,
0.0329102613,
0.0017640202,
0.029358089,
0.0143096801,
0.0210099071,
0.0416666083,
-0.0562929548,
-0.0304773655,
-0.0381763317,
0.0183751341,
-0.0544464327,
-0.0062102079,
0.0941437483,
0.0200330913,
-0.1165129766,
0.0026878056,
-0.0157475565,
0.0266554412,
0.0406247005,
-0.0092871226,
-0.0448942631,
0.0115891751,
0.0455346592,
-0.006204511,
-0.0342734717,
-0.0364477634,
-0.0211973395,
-0.1101392806,
-0.0054780715,
0.0159402899,
-0.0394945964,
-0.0291958191,
-0.0286604799,
0.0165216718,
-0.0131421909,
0.0499709249,
-0.0162322223,
0.013434656,
0.0283301864,
0.0167489257,
-0.0213395972,
-0.0345169641,
0.0154714482,
-0.0596308336,
0.044026494,
0.0279602017,
0.0539352112,
-0.0021667527,
0.0208964609,
0.0397985652,
-0.0515061617,
-0.0040570414,
-0.0309809465,
0.034385588,
-0.0542349555,
-0.0009147525,
-0.0228319708,
0.0418203473,
0.0513444096,
0.0230379775,
-0.0197270773,
0.0183460508,
0.029942438,
-0.0131298443,
-0.0742871538,
-0.0530368537,
0.0023307984,
0.0749365315,
0.0013819758,
-0.0542632677,
-0.0441838726,
-0.0739832148,
0.0074248477,
0.0008909255,
-0.0562184863,
-0.000122935,
0.0476031862,
-0.038291391,
-0.0261206273,
-0.0539080501,
-0.0252363812,
-0.0131704332,
0.008705561,
-0.0363741033,
-0.0203353595,
-0.0042767148,
-0.0631497353,
0.0213635359,
-0.0294495877,
0.028658947,
0.0253454857,
0.0176992808,
-0.0244506169,
-0.0429054648,
-0.0293226801,
0.0051389351,
-0.0347141661,
-0.0472468548,
0.0103414748,
0.0152274249,
0.0156350359,
0.0691776648,
-0.0149739468,
-0.0826480761,
0.0892442986,
0.0246619973,
-0.0434220992,
0.0424523577,
0.0506519675,
0.0014417304,
0.0207127649,
0.0508146919,
-0.0508291796,
0.0061764773,
0.0101026315,
0.0153714232,
0.0308850501,
-0.0066229342,
-0.0152518721,
-0.0081602996,
0.0270976033,
-0.0314738378,
0.0029393565,
-0.0263756439,
0.0032895335,
-0.005846851,
-0.0576214418,
0.0056833681,
-0.0112136425,
0.0349773429,
0.0442998521,
-0.0416006707,
0.0299165081,
-0.0111225136,
0.0218373239,
-0.0186418071,
0.0033086811,
0.0115118334,
0.0561260879,
-0.0146799609,
0.038099952,
-0.006802897,
-0.0211289916,
-0.0320733376,
0.0238655247,
-0.0237768199,
-0.0145290857,
0.0197310243,
0.026014803,
-0.057039801,
0.0106228776,
-0.0687356368,
0.0490811057,
0.0033307311,
0.0077934135,
0.0152239753,
-0.0389582142,
0.0327028595,
0.0198755302,
-0.0289015509,
0.0153555013,
-0.0359771699,
0.0032460671,
0.0163002238,
0.0108343186,
0.0063234172,
0.0025814213,
0.0047033788,
0.0478163585,
0.0357525647,
0.0607783645,
-0.0370401666,
-0.0475886613,
-0.0129011422,
-0.0083593009,
0.0305784475,
-0.0051886956,
-0.0177639071,
0.0082479063,
-0.08696457,
-0.0460119322,
-0.0121567091,
-0.0318121053,
0.028995594,
-0.0317114741,
-0.0401082709,
0.0496808477,
-0.0196463838,
-0.0513271429,
-0.0423063301,
-0.0185269713,
-0.0060005067,
-0.0105595654,
-0.0316364616,
-5.689046989e-33,
-0.0050667133,
-0.0314384848,
-0.0327820182,
-0.0212260708,
-0.0042237043,
0.0260341559,
0.0056175827,
-0.0264040027,
-0.0008474232,
0.0183311347,
-0.0128425444,
0.0600931048,
-0.0025043692,
-0.0004848447,
-0.0065434678,
-0.0054389429,
0.0618485585,
0.0046070581,
-0.0465260893,
-0.0227425303,
-0.0207209531,
0.0158505682,
0.0035980877,
-0.0579340532,
0.1213903949,
0.0168201663,
0.0026491049,
0.0124597829,
-0.0202496238,
0.0466653965,
-0.0277587101,
0.0610866323,
0.0316015407,
-0.0147952018,
0.0091761583,
0.0855589807,
-0.0805831328,
-0.0380395651,
0.0059498898,
0.0237739962,
0.0384160541,
-0.0217972081,
0.0375459827,
0.037337184,
-0.0480428077,
-0.0626051873,
0.0612862855,
0.0267719515,
0.0183716249,
0.0458516777,
-0.0274403766,
0.0276830141,
-0.0298786014,
0.0238387641,
0.0410095043,
-0.0050968896,
0.0216280986,
0.0386896171,
-0.0620901845,
0.0107003842,
-0.0547829941,
-0.0126393726,
0.002061537,
0.0046531237,
0.0247263387,
0.0452880897,
0.0616154373,
0.0528406985,
-0.0500447303,
-0.080162093,
0.0463483781,
-0.0548476577,
0.0358243771,
0.0679687411,
0.0568564944,
0.0021075848,
-0.0842072442,
-0.0259700119,
0.0294254273,
-0.0051049236,
0.050034266,
-0.0067385975,
-0.0761196092,
-0.0506162159,
-0.0575887822,
-0.0905426964,
-0.0359190665,
-0.0036125542,
0.0138421003,
0.0220449362,
-0.0452897921,
-0.0033271795,
-0.03020427,
-0.0850388035,
-0.0432394259,
0.046233248,
-0.000380247,
-0.0279529151,
0.0500211492,
0.0003138402,
-0.0356631652,
0.0249598827,
0.0103246933,
0.0173122007,
0.0089696795,
-0.0071532829,
0.0211670753,
0.0187377539,
-0.0600690134,
-0.0204710364,
-0.0442378893,
0.0030666078,
-0.0010793549,
0.0313780308,
0.0048823254,
0.0489224456,
0.0035118612,
0.0125631364,
0.0820803121,
0.0277218167,
-0.0258566774,
-0.0072693429,
0.0144778173,
0.037251845,
-0.0026646352,
-0.0372947454,
0.0361989364,
0.0256852414,
0.0463942587,
-0.060635414,
-0.006331,
-0.0394905657,
2.394e-7,
0.0088047329,
0.0378797725,
0.015544273,
-0.0131133823,
0.0500207357,
0.0432287566,
0.0216721818,
0.0627470985,
0.0392201953,
0.0149075417,
-0.0366061404,
0.0417542979,
-0.0109444708,
0.0144467093,
-0.0346485637,
0.0145648774,
-0.0807539895,
0.0420779362,
0.0409432985,
0.0027587716,
-0.0164270923,
0.0502596907,
0.0483148172,
0.00794587,
-0.0189635642,
-0.0427211784,
0.0448276624,
-0.0172596723,
0.0361485444,
0.0166446809,
-0.013218578,
0.0139727676,
0.0434345379,
0.0251044687,
-0.0012411934,
0.0439176932,
0.0009901293,
0.0272918995,
-0.0297036655,
0.004064267,
-0.054541178,
-0.0199575145,
-0.0050236932,
-0.0772427619,
0.0700663626,
0.0121045001,
-0.0477461442,
-0.0649851859,
-0.0017125688,
-0.0024418957,
0.0830233544,
0.0194798,
-0.0275953505,
0.0197846647,
0.0225797929,
0.0339410864,
-0.0078478623,
-0.1149372607,
-0.0576707758,
-0.0139398836,
-0.0372179188,
-0.0370377824,
-0.0003816056,
0.0450572632,
0.0526305586,
-0.0423893407,
0.0495882258,
2.030278027e-34,
-0.0040848656,
0.0189119279,
0.0170745589,
-0.0087395171,
0.0029549897,
-0.0213559493,
0.0112239979,
-0.0065409411,
0.0888267457,
-0.0070180316,
-0.0107529657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12850v1 | GE-Blender: Graph-Based Knowledge Enhancement for Blender | 2023-01-30T13:00:20 | 2023-01-30T13:00:20 | Xiaolei Lian, Xunzhu Tang, Yue Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although the great success of open-domain dialogue generation, unseen
entities can have a large impact on the dialogue generation task. It leads to
performance degradation of the model in the dialog generation. Previous
researches used retrieved knowledge of seen entities as the auxiliary data to
enhance the representation of the model. Nevertheless, logical explanation of
unseen entities remains unexplored, such as possible co-occurrence or
semantically similar words of them and their entity category. In this work, we
propose an approach to address the challenge above. We construct a graph by
extracting entity nodes in them, enhancing the representation of the context of
the unseen entity with the entity's 1-hop surrounding nodes. Furthermore, We
added the named entity tag prediction task to apply the problem that the unseen
entity does not exist in the graph. We conduct our experiments on an open
dataset Wizard of Wikipedia and the empirical results indicate that our
approach outperforms the state-of-the-art approaches on Wizard of Wikipedia. | [
0.0340213515,
0.0288673528,
0.0071104374,
0.0794111565,
0.0198488366,
0.0194344595,
-0.0037608298,
0.0236572791,
0.0790290162,
-0.0304661896,
0.0043389052,
0.0064175394,
0.0089223869,
0.0352803916,
0.0200046357,
-0.0782819763,
0.0051592975,
-0.0219467394,
0.0150884865,
0.0099679884,
-0.0012310878,
0.0312225986,
-0.0575020723,
0.0475497134,
-0.0457323603,
-0.0343541093,
-0.052983921,
0.0235270094,
0.0260587968,
-0.0485934019,
-0.0273174271,
0.0278042611,
0.0095967129,
0.0303084515,
0.0000020715,
-0.0288300086,
-0.0094465986,
-0.0186489858,
-0.0369028561,
-0.0334788151,
-0.0478019491,
0.0063579013,
0.0026912598,
-0.0200632531,
-0.0192548148,
-0.0015771496,
0.0601562001,
0.0414953828,
0.0469641462,
0.0302382745,
-0.0240487866,
-0.0095129889,
-0.0437192731,
0.0107033039,
0.0568538308,
-0.0091589186,
-0.0184335504,
0.0137897767,
0.0045620543,
-0.0037034908,
-0.0097455652,
0.0275780335,
-0.0073251179,
-0.0378464125,
0.0715354905,
0.0524187386,
0.0050120852,
-0.019943364,
0.0225195661,
0.1277320683,
0.0474206507,
0.0177443046,
0.0366886929,
-0.0269457269,
0.0080758361,
0.0481702425,
-0.0363350809,
-0.0087478478,
-0.0522465669,
-0.0233076923,
-0.0262618531,
-0.0023225618,
0.0028031706,
-0.0276208129,
-0.0080486257,
0.0611126423,
0.0140416231,
0.0037089931,
-0.0206003804,
0.0076351385,
-0.0451327823,
-0.0750827044,
-0.0094007049,
0.034147121,
-0.0565906949,
0.0343300402,
-0.0465367325,
0.0090150572,
0.0094639398,
-0.0165188406,
0.0025402482,
0.024610607,
0.0227537975,
0.0557672754,
-0.0194011126,
0.0229845773,
0.0051515261,
-0.0232385918,
-0.011927397,
0.007765383,
-0.0735776722,
-0.0405926779,
-0.0637850091,
0.0527661592,
-0.0758565366,
-0.0206613932,
0.0041032317,
0.0358708054,
-0.0149036953,
0.021490233,
0.0330585092,
0.0350290015,
-0.0207043178,
0.0092481524,
-0.0702977329,
-0.0094576003,
-0.0440330617,
-0.0279652067,
0.0128837181,
-0.025745431,
-0.0294750798,
0.0196055602,
0.0471254401,
0.004957071,
-0.032333158,
0.0764635056,
0.0153795118,
0.0148309981,
-0.0139001664,
-0.0879912153,
-0.0172808971,
-0.010988093,
-0.0178232677,
-0.0451224446,
0.0098628346,
0.0216944981,
0.0005775786,
-0.058076445,
0.0356659852,
0.0056846039,
-0.0411246233,
0.0609673299,
-0.0905801803,
0.0286971238,
0.0443720035,
0.0172092505,
-0.028228227,
0.0547598787,
0.0231745057,
-0.0144491391,
0.0361353382,
0.0268051904,
-0.0109606246,
0.0113551803,
0.0255931523,
-0.0095888749,
0.0016545723,
-0.0108736865,
-0.0404519439,
0.0550607592,
-0.0097907679,
0.0223685596,
-0.0359092951,
-0.0084487908,
0.0142195616,
0.0145591823,
-0.005424527,
0.018672213,
0.0665811002,
0.0294845793,
-0.0240768902,
0.0251657497,
0.0017891723,
0.0277379323,
0.0246611014,
0.0271623097,
0.0126144178,
-0.0028576874,
-0.004281933,
-0.0093842,
0.0263002012,
0.0114481961,
0.0380174369,
-0.0323141366,
0.0465936661,
0.0372382514,
-0.0857575685,
0.0535316281,
0.0318546332,
-0.0447957888,
-0.0367899686,
-0.0139703741,
0.0226874575,
0.0842459276,
0.0611187555,
0.0006565117,
-0.0905447155,
0.0004028643,
-0.0108798128,
0.0544112585,
0.0101826638,
-0.0575034805,
0.0214344226,
-0.0212726817,
-0.037417192,
-0.0465488806,
-0.0016638942,
0.0709115267,
0.0077587492,
0.015666835,
0.0622220039,
-0.057666935,
-0.0038032192,
-0.0052970974,
-0.0117704906,
0.0028600767,
-0.0150722619,
0.0376669616,
-0.0275873952,
0.0393475033,
-0.0200058781,
0.0095516564,
0.020085603,
-0.0243946183,
-0.0084327245,
0.0185509119,
-0.0363528654,
-0.0621502101,
0.0397391617,
-0.0281332172,
-0.0106489314,
-0.02552508,
0.0099920025,
-0.0576138198,
0.018476624,
-0.037321467,
0.0548583418,
0.0080423634,
0.0091164494,
0.0130824586,
-0.0282176957,
-0.0357963108,
0.0863822997,
0.0284363125,
0.0038095834,
0.0672644675,
0.0301238969,
0.0441294722,
-0.037400838,
0.0107341623,
0.0328034125,
0.0181132741,
-0.0122857857,
0.0145265115,
-0.0408858061,
-0.0689289495,
0.0214515068,
-0.1154097244,
-0.0186749082,
0.0156801119,
0.0078937355,
0.001626563,
0.002244567,
-0.0202948302,
-0.0221198574,
-0.0208559074,
0.0739080459,
0.0232778452,
-0.022712484,
0.0346594676,
0.0147224087,
-0.0194074102,
-0.0066116946,
0.0020954455,
-0.0206104983,
0.0678292885,
0.0723161921,
-0.0477653071,
-0.0186663643,
0.0598729253,
-0.0778018534,
-0.0069698668,
0.0226129685,
-0.0027886552,
0.0381436907,
0.0028231672,
0.048066806,
0.0052016689,
-0.0132235363,
0.0337768011,
-0.0065286956,
-0.0781075954,
-0.0565998033,
0.0037929066,
-0.0058637927,
0.0278524868,
0.0053107655,
0.0155931227,
0.0080537964,
0.0649444833,
0.0147414114,
0.0027820533,
-0.0440336913,
0.0474411473,
0.0174701493,
-0.005176493,
-0.0264094844,
-0.0486725159,
0.0230402462,
0.0234542005,
-0.0237827785,
0.0067960974,
0.0714458302,
-0.0260470994,
0.0065276176,
0.0280630849,
0.0267995317,
-0.0230484959,
0.0733733326,
0.0021852984,
0.0335578471,
0.0323914662,
-0.024819959,
-0.0378506444,
0.0497531816,
0.0308348797,
-0.0081605362,
0.00323937,
-0.0408705398,
-0.0031279495,
0.0073725996,
0.0055525671,
-0.0489132889,
0.0103891892,
-0.0197520182,
-0.0182990469,
0.0274434369,
-0.0208987221,
0.0119251655,
0.0219437815,
-0.0215507057,
0.0208982825,
0.0014557213,
-0.0167787019,
-0.0289028864,
0.0298012588,
0.0381087996,
0.0106861945,
-0.0163328517,
-0.0413500629,
0.0673009232,
0.0456074327,
0.0013987429,
-0.0634397417,
-0.0297941491,
-0.0050862907,
-0.0169828665,
-0.0164886676,
-0.0374288559,
-0.0042468291,
0.0219656117,
-0.0510369651,
-0.0055967947,
0.0916168839,
0.0480616912,
0.0003721651,
-0.0103301257,
-0.0059516635,
0.0746022984,
0.0274339989,
0.0019611237,
-0.0763213262,
-0.0164369941,
-0.0291331708,
0.0228604097,
0.0003828013,
-0.0751421601,
0.0035331037,
-0.1209759191,
0.0438445359,
-0.0106444051,
0.0096534453,
-0.0227503739,
-0.007186282,
0.0015656638,
0.0312458128,
-0.0755286217,
0.001421386,
0.0162643529,
0.0285437685,
0.0148057509,
0.0127381105,
-0.0001406674,
-0.0177935679,
-0.0147493947,
0.038937524,
0.0164801758,
0.0534922928,
0.0539570935,
-0.0027714458,
0.0076733804,
-0.0069861729,
0.0242749285,
-0.0155372638,
0.0815195739,
-0.0044003301,
-0.0243292674,
-0.046898149,
-0.0097203953,
-0.0206537545,
-0.0709996819,
0.0139421849,
0.0576907992,
-0.0219712835,
0.007321985,
-0.0130854379,
0.0091804713,
0.0493496209,
0.038703002,
0.0647043437,
0.0077456925,
-0.0321753845,
-0.0350660346,
0.0347164497,
-0.0471436679,
0.0071599516,
-0.0098882131,
0.0141148707,
-0.0255621411,
-0.0964304581,
-0.0223162994,
0.0364382379,
0.0652697235,
0.0168077778,
-0.000565201,
0.0029772462,
0.006125614,
-0.0548133329,
0.0116384178,
-0.0127641344,
-0.0041283756,
-0.0089107323,
-0.0431677364,
0.0286800805,
-0.0239641573,
-0.0347576067,
0.038544558,
-0.0335010849,
-0.0683405623,
-0.0555056706,
0.0180929843,
0.0235749185,
0.078959316,
-0.0223358013,
-0.0248733535,
0.049287308,
0.052083578,
-0.0531174541,
-0.0087380046,
-0.0199575182,
0.0485892929,
0.0023396702,
0.0185694695,
-0.0347322486,
-0.0115650874,
-0.032584101,
0.0314323343,
-0.0510663614,
-0.0760763139,
0.0159016103,
0.0600181073,
0.0015709747,
0.0067289709,
0.0218644366,
-0.0596384183,
0.0192768276,
-0.028251851,
-0.0243556313,
-0.0388922207,
0.0266909059,
-0.0116708279,
-0.0511908121,
0.0179652851,
-0.0191020072,
-0.0298455954,
0.0566417687,
-0.0264650565,
-0.0344893374,
0.0059976801,
-0.0336963162,
0.043369662,
0.0034082262,
0.0168512594,
-0.0003301511,
-0.0022384701,
0.0477439836,
-0.0115751075,
0.0854304433,
0.0210315678,
-0.0401661694,
0.0070447852,
0.008315119,
-0.030519994,
-0.0453962386,
-0.0072414125,
0.0116930529,
0.0140317986,
0.0132899825,
0.0630758479,
-0.0075108116,
0.0084808972,
0.0216817968,
0.0567723997,
0.0124753313,
-0.066373609,
0.0232394617,
0.040282581,
-0.0163140353,
-0.008546182,
0.0741756335,
-0.0121211121,
0.0261897445,
0.0081286505,
-0.0310647711,
-0.0551477335,
-0.0225108191,
0.0016831327,
0.0193594452,
0.004828278,
0.0179832745,
-0.0490203612,
-0.0568581335,
-0.0062058698,
0.0221980996,
-0.0136004211,
0.0139889978,
0.0587148629,
0.0276652873,
0.0330989137,
-0.024714753,
-0.0355252065,
0.0291196052,
-0.0378984436,
-0.0021157365,
-0.0131968195,
-5.550752283e-33,
-0.0920155421,
-0.0999011397,
0.0087769516,
0.0116676111,
-0.0373689607,
-0.0218461473,
-0.0786087811,
0.0299807042,
0.0233211145,
0.0207210165,
0.032692153,
0.0095774624,
0.0005686313,
-0.0005375752,
-0.0200208947,
-0.0275404919,
0.0422758348,
0.0390222594,
-0.0208113249,
0.0709471479,
0.0410062224,
0.0243425556,
0.0207412653,
-0.0733573958,
0.029628126,
-0.0100725563,
0.0216061976,
-0.0073209433,
0.0606549233,
0.0581312329,
-0.033651866,
0.0371310413,
0.0026830295,
-0.0293607898,
-0.0105150351,
-0.0152883846,
-0.0511014387,
-0.025182981,
-0.0099036973,
0.0062503745,
-0.0045403149,
-0.03668705,
0.0083279721,
0.0190760717,
0.0487230085,
-0.0302956812,
0.0434386246,
-0.0013059238,
-0.0206616744,
0.0250705238,
-0.058291845,
0.0425242893,
-0.0774876699,
-0.0163458623,
0.0199142732,
0.043117661,
0.0480995439,
-0.0396196432,
-0.0446096808,
0.0281958655,
0.0004615502,
-0.0464881361,
0.0608044602,
0.0159526896,
-0.0010572074,
0.0968515649,
0.0239317529,
0.0042320951,
-0.098711729,
0.0223583002,
-0.0291964505,
0.0731737465,
-0.0291755218,
0.0426170491,
-0.0032188224,
-0.0171231497,
-0.0659018829,
0.0605850853,
-0.0809377432,
0.0176084302,
-0.0068357955,
-0.0159538463,
-0.0210291781,
-0.022692712,
-0.0162884332,
-0.0234122816,
-0.0366679206,
-0.0528907217,
0.0136532653,
-0.0227028653,
-0.033410877,
-0.0191663429,
0.0026780439,
-0.0375157148,
0.0140650403,
0.0402587317,
-0.035359066,
0.0276656803,
-0.0286959335,
-0.0085259043,
-0.0087033464,
-0.0375414677,
0.0539402999,
0.0259098317,
0.0523311347,
0.0349519476,
-0.023334587,
0.0135617321,
-0.0472061187,
0.0112015987,
-0.0702796206,
-0.0193825606,
-0.0528042614,
0.0037731698,
0.0227866955,
-0.0124946889,
-0.0452385955,
0.0215558931,
0.0135660674,
-0.0062635858,
-0.0089878812,
-0.0286872592,
0.0089440541,
-0.004324439,
-0.0299303737,
-0.0177641269,
0.0220850725,
-0.0386837274,
0.0211942438,
-0.0314687937,
-0.0221082587,
-0.0268030949,
2.784e-7,
0.0018479252,
0.0074047791,
0.0468539186,
0.0462794118,
0.0016962702,
0.0364054739,
0.0129281478,
0.0192586482,
0.0026674285,
-0.0616031773,
0.0150844026,
0.020070415,
-0.0000622731,
0.0258088596,
-0.0969986171,
-0.0150885871,
-0.0009946813,
-0.0375731401,
-0.0777719319,
0.012679928,
0.0835242718,
-0.0118993456,
0.0019802393,
-0.0057158293,
0.0045853755,
-0.0216461662,
0.0333086513,
-0.0190025941,
0.001396714,
0.0183477066,
0.0511009917,
0.0191007536,
-0.0152153214,
0.0506773293,
-0.024087986,
0.0186613128,
0.03073835,
0.009318281,
-0.0256929584,
0.0062349467,
0.0230322294,
-0.0366819277,
0.0384731591,
-0.0375689156,
0.0419018939,
0.0000862085,
-0.0349404775,
0.0368588716,
-0.0421622843,
-0.0309603158,
-0.0346206687,
-0.0321340188,
0.0013458846,
-0.0132750161,
-0.0260976348,
-0.0227117091,
0.0179886278,
-0.0329900682,
-0.0208429489,
-0.00352391,
-0.0483643673,
-0.0513186827,
-0.0143452808,
-0.0170463286,
0.0196084213,
0.0044411961,
-0.0022936752,
2.503993296e-34,
-0.0159297679,
0.0366342813,
-0.019416865,
0.0330534577,
0.0760238767,
-0.0293961372,
-0.0142834755,
0.0020774326,
0.0431320481,
-0.0827151686,
-0.0277260318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12847v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12847v1 | Finding the Law: Enhancing Statutory Article Retrieval via Graph Neural Networks | 2023-01-30T12:59:09 | 2023-01-30T12:59:09 | Antoine Louis, Gijs van Dijck, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Statutory article retrieval (SAR), the task of retrieving statute law
articles relevant to a legal question, is a promising application of legal text
processing. In particular, high-quality SAR systems can improve the work
efficiency of legal professionals and provide basic legal assistance to
citizens in need at no cost. Unlike traditional ad-hoc information retrieval,
where each document is considered a complete source of information, SAR deals
with texts whose full sense depends on complementary information from the
topological organization of statute law. While existing works ignore these
domain-specific dependencies, we propose a novel graph-augmented dense statute
retriever (G-DSR) model that incorporates the structure of legislation via a
graph neural network to improve dense retrieval performance. Experimental
results show that our approach outperforms strong retrieval baselines on a
real-world expert-annotated SAR dataset. | [
0.0460705236,
0.0213531889,
0.0024321587,
0.0074685356,
-0.0568900816,
-0.0029583643,
0.0118530188,
0.0440200083,
0.0555539727,
-0.0100845089,
-0.0033112555,
-0.0119425366,
-0.0246193111,
0.0484142452,
-0.0146152116,
-0.0034137587,
0.0291544124,
0.0387753509,
0.0472190455,
-0.0046399431,
-0.0027682516,
0.0166065916,
0.0341892429,
-0.005216314,
-0.0237262156,
0.0289359242,
-0.0336047933,
0.0497534014,
-0.0317700133,
-0.0253870413,
0.0223278794,
0.0181501079,
0.03256239,
0.0333901942,
0.0000014979,
0.0156867243,
-0.0038942406,
0.0188674275,
-0.0004508148,
0.0304550529,
0.0480228178,
-0.0444847345,
0.0000018039,
-0.0282627288,
-0.0443873778,
0.0050978358,
0.0069300593,
-0.0183009263,
0.0205540769,
0.1021926627,
-0.0223760381,
-0.0651928782,
0.0480041355,
-0.0705581084,
0.0030864943,
-0.0692647547,
0.0293997414,
0.0092067653,
0.0124293128,
-0.000642806,
0.0028795323,
0.0257381201,
0.0176694188,
-0.0234071035,
0.0326282643,
-0.0016612698,
0.0068316744,
0.0313169509,
0.031304393,
0.0517556667,
0.040369112,
-0.0161986686,
0.0425615236,
0.001677991,
0.0237450562,
0.0549883507,
-0.0566640645,
0.0321354344,
-0.0441177748,
-0.0136908004,
-0.0144046862,
-0.0117483009,
0.0376855284,
0.0232668817,
-0.0359957255,
0.0817834139,
-0.0223053191,
-0.0312962197,
0.0082919532,
-0.009567216,
0.0018595638,
-0.0001741231,
0.0685342103,
0.0252483524,
-0.0185611565,
0.0142286038,
0.032129284,
-0.0262041762,
0.0417041518,
-0.0537568331,
0.0155677879,
-0.0229051951,
-0.0235369969,
0.0883481055,
-0.0065049217,
0.0072079063,
-0.0217456557,
0.0478055216,
0.0059792749,
-0.0311085172,
-0.0400726497,
-0.0149566885,
-0.0502373725,
0.0633558407,
-0.067623958,
-0.0081075244,
-0.0090655293,
0.0254737344,
-0.0237255227,
-0.0097703319,
0.0164169185,
0.040311005,
0.0005029787,
-0.046559792,
-0.0250588562,
-0.0330801345,
-0.0143384794,
0.0213096477,
-0.0015664691,
0.0458294004,
0.0177107882,
0.0032491509,
0.050713636,
0.0205498226,
0.0205107797,
0.0314256251,
0.0191156156,
-0.0481512435,
-0.0346882194,
-0.051962696,
-0.0133446855,
-0.021265436,
0.012388763,
-0.0645729527,
0.0177277569,
-0.0431237258,
-0.0282565076,
-0.0706442222,
-0.0052215569,
0.0333075672,
-0.0539399795,
0.0138132628,
-0.0277549475,
-0.0028390475,
-0.0170372836,
0.0057963678,
0.0288605336,
-0.0302627981,
0.0028365275,
0.0547445901,
0.0416295789,
0.037528906,
-0.0090662735,
-0.014910222,
0.0473059528,
-0.0072788396,
0.0109678591,
0.0197337549,
-0.1138286442,
0.0123113887,
0.0157431103,
0.035486076,
-0.0413698629,
-0.0508184955,
-0.0091607515,
0.0759661943,
0.0154539216,
0.0395473279,
-0.0037216127,
0.0214964394,
-0.0036650642,
0.009657843,
-0.0368568189,
-0.0008189002,
-0.011737803,
0.0018657147,
-0.0577231199,
-0.0406397432,
-0.0201466102,
-0.0450631082,
0.0069319657,
0.0293071158,
0.046361059,
-0.0062957299,
0.0707882941,
0.0111617958,
-0.0240829512,
-0.0073034395,
0.0244709104,
-0.0195286907,
-0.011608813,
-0.0106901638,
-0.0308239032,
0.0412108824,
0.0539174192,
-0.0295519363,
-0.0601631217,
0.0417270996,
0.0162681602,
0.0236078519,
-0.0075735943,
-0.0337775089,
-0.0096988128,
-0.0448329635,
-0.0501256362,
-0.000490069,
0.0176179372,
0.0374749713,
0.0097822919,
-0.0097184721,
0.0420942008,
-0.0729946867,
-0.0110927327,
0.0126935635,
-0.0132142482,
-0.0007248838,
0.0212145541,
0.0102724582,
0.0064118342,
0.0379616097,
-0.0020813856,
-0.0031020709,
0.0530926436,
0.017659571,
-0.0165578164,
-0.0409746356,
-0.0219009351,
0.0038095021,
0.0308160577,
-0.0341061726,
-0.0167249683,
0.0025487049,
-0.0430798233,
-0.0120552238,
0.0057176552,
-0.0255590957,
0.0090659941,
-0.0504726507,
-0.0437775403,
-0.0121532641,
-0.0299586561,
-0.0408694297,
0.0248659998,
-0.0160531085,
-0.015266872,
0.0064049806,
-0.0018810491,
0.0440605544,
-0.0427518524,
-0.0002848891,
-0.0143877454,
-0.0381340981,
0.0281274728,
0.0410530642,
-0.0108844684,
-0.0328184813,
-0.0203741211,
-0.0568993464,
0.0088186627,
-0.0241693109,
0.0042860741,
-0.0101017356,
-0.0294856373,
0.0128226811,
-0.046865657,
-0.0436662696,
0.0219184197,
-0.0174801573,
-0.0261972174,
0.0267409161,
-0.015798267,
-0.0338439271,
-0.0244842507,
-0.0902162641,
-0.0267118122,
0.0397000685,
0.0329253972,
-0.0479390956,
0.0416372456,
0.0599068403,
-0.0208780263,
0.002424313,
-0.0498995557,
0.0204371717,
0.0134634292,
-0.0213335529,
-0.0365922675,
0.0468631908,
0.0009512239,
0.0057543516,
0.0170620568,
-0.0108503839,
-0.0554834343,
-0.0068843612,
-0.0507853776,
0.0574356988,
-0.0447438098,
0.0121129546,
0.0351140052,
-0.0313237533,
0.0070527676,
0.0003302029,
-0.017490577,
-0.0060738442,
-0.0000198744,
0.0210930258,
-0.0468935296,
-0.0081404392,
0.0243727174,
0.0237462558,
-0.0147262039,
-0.0342478119,
0.0318382718,
0.0529590696,
0.0586898215,
0.0122181652,
0.0078631155,
-0.0675036609,
0.1009814143,
0.0308593865,
0.0129439663,
-0.0275327414,
-0.0659687743,
-0.0049884738,
0.0071558757,
0.0702779144,
-0.0497862436,
0.0348825082,
0.0255628414,
0.062159922,
0.0013144622,
-0.0685018525,
0.0036542367,
-0.0048753419,
0.0542840399,
0.0639021471,
-0.0308723822,
-0.0322610848,
-0.0289902743,
0.01279316,
-0.026134083,
0.0532200858,
-0.0038702884,
-0.0229325555,
-0.0418179482,
0.0655081943,
0.0140511673,
-0.0633541942,
-0.0008040834,
0.0013123103,
-0.0401738957,
0.0150531782,
-0.0300716385,
0.0046188631,
-0.0009412779,
0.00360699,
-0.0067320284,
-0.0543099716,
0.0031711906,
-0.0029105009,
-0.0373207405,
-0.0614824928,
0.0181005914,
0.0344891362,
0.0145393517,
-0.0617353022,
-0.0346243605,
0.0035052809,
0.0042517739,
0.0526814535,
0.0029865482,
-0.0947937965,
0.0483968072,
0.0011186413,
0.0071428944,
0.0074966783,
-0.0332598947,
0.0145262592,
-0.0319186375,
0.08286044,
0.0311369859,
0.0051046629,
-0.0515295938,
-0.0359630696,
0.0093746483,
-0.001367771,
-0.000233302,
0.0067635248,
-0.0444190502,
-0.0321532004,
0.0129959276,
-0.0257736854,
0.0238123257,
-0.0102421679,
-0.0476060547,
0.005788465,
-0.0213099141,
0.0544203855,
-0.0068817637,
0.0185193252,
0.0443041995,
0.046060238,
-0.015046305,
0.008069844,
0.0429625586,
0.0220191348,
0.0402585156,
-0.0629176274,
-0.0091675585,
-0.0025719318,
-0.0033631898,
-0.0006034865,
0.0404341109,
-0.0152085973,
0.0009294908,
-0.0414427035,
-0.045007769,
-0.0442875214,
-0.0162979402,
-0.005482344,
0.0520657077,
-0.0508951768,
-0.029187277,
0.0194244627,
-0.0659848973,
-0.0371081792,
0.0421197452,
-0.0357311554,
0.0024658106,
-0.0395692885,
-0.0153131085,
-0.0402135663,
0.0411952548,
-0.0111559853,
0.0261558443,
0.0700872838,
-0.0602031536,
-0.0883689523,
0.0082023358,
-0.0491737872,
-0.0119551225,
-0.0113600651,
0.0159875564,
-0.0145087522,
0.0265828036,
-0.0440832675,
-0.02249787,
0.013726986,
-0.0352782905,
-0.0094503341,
-0.0334180743,
0.0109298695,
0.0386021398,
-0.0612226538,
-0.0535902977,
0.091109097,
0.065227665,
-0.0092832027,
-0.0290758293,
0.0443274155,
-0.0624186993,
-0.0552289635,
0.0100952033,
-0.0350609943,
0.046837613,
0.0189047325,
0.0080000274,
-0.000757408,
0.0020204131,
-0.0041810176,
0.0579038486,
0.039558582,
0.0372212119,
-0.0121370293,
-0.049465172,
-0.0059980974,
-0.0058584721,
0.0173616949,
0.0121797677,
-0.0195647851,
0.0204693694,
-0.0153298294,
-0.042207621,
0.057864707,
0.0419673882,
0.0613158979,
-0.0816437677,
-0.0216881577,
0.0257090684,
0.001089335,
0.0199489836,
-0.0250200387,
-0.0210815109,
0.040353097,
-0.0166370776,
0.0490878187,
-0.0275459941,
-0.0012919948,
0.0258754771,
-0.0040687649,
-0.0610461235,
0.015164447,
-0.0611440614,
-0.0347550176,
-0.0432499945,
0.0081460439,
0.082365945,
0.0387934707,
-0.000513326,
-0.0166240819,
-0.0133034671,
-0.0043518753,
0.0049586156,
-0.0034214745,
-0.0293140132,
0.019188134,
0.0241296701,
-0.0010761068,
0.0665064603,
0.0136567438,
0.0702365488,
0.0070298105,
0.007095309,
-0.0542933866,
-0.0025576837,
-0.0363431275,
-0.023883976,
0.0564376041,
-0.0357886963,
-0.0464148521,
-0.037807852,
-0.0138150249,
0.0154110119,
0.0231192205,
0.009171892,
0.0197942834,
0.0121911624,
0.0456061922,
0.039949663,
-0.0351604447,
-0.031843286,
0.0077069197,
-0.0400898866,
-0.0076367958,
-0.0009592349,
-5.510695476e-33,
-0.0180866625,
-0.0536688082,
0.0206853878,
0.0504999124,
-0.0509969182,
0.0178486649,
-0.0492122434,
-0.0390127674,
-0.0534640029,
0.0395716652,
-0.0483318083,
0.0699160546,
0.0239016395,
-0.0067017167,
0.0042520626,
0.001142498,
0.0216768719,
0.0131444391,
0.0318006091,
0.0279845297,
0.0091232052,
0.0452845134,
0.0057210075,
-0.0694765896,
0.0359486602,
0.0490193292,
0.0305277742,
-0.0265958756,
-0.0128448,
0.071524471,
0.0173482466,
0.0326728299,
0.04815102,
0.0194164701,
0.0024593554,
0.0386934541,
-0.1209548861,
0.0030632364,
-0.0477879643,
-0.0230295621,
0.0037174332,
-0.0189884715,
0.044558581,
-0.00965204,
0.0066668028,
-0.0160616785,
0.0447677039,
0.0097931679,
-0.0942542851,
-0.0820158496,
-0.0567075945,
0.0633128658,
0.0136292791,
0.0611768328,
0.0341306962,
-0.0246125627,
0.0198651403,
0.0256386586,
-0.0389083363,
0.0024282045,
-0.1054401547,
0.0073487228,
-0.030243909,
-0.0387223326,
-0.00115463,
0.0415503643,
0.0044041579,
0.0299979597,
-0.0477211103,
0.008951718,
0.0418144874,
0.07705383,
0.0143705765,
0.0202127267,
0.0577307567,
-0.0584817193,
-0.1158575639,
-0.0171106271,
0.0449467003,
0.0487679243,
0.0328638628,
0.0138596129,
-0.0195977557,
-0.0124456203,
0.0021197819,
-0.0706117526,
-0.0020262587,
-0.0114122536,
0.0013509471,
0.0327516831,
0.0497686416,
0.0023467583,
-0.013222063,
-0.0508821756,
0.0154944491,
0.0776246786,
0.0098146824,
0.0335358381,
-0.0168742165,
0.0397221632,
-0.0579825081,
-0.0436809249,
-0.011763379,
0.0056318068,
-0.0134657053,
0.0013580269,
0.0516942181,
-0.0144289369,
-0.0297532771,
-0.0182814561,
0.0026891769,
-0.0212105289,
0.0010592151,
0.014324883,
0.0359380543,
0.0441413708,
0.0320282653,
0.0615387447,
0.0304641798,
0.0249503832,
-0.0161472,
0.0274222307,
0.0099845696,
0.0077130497,
0.0042905593,
0.0023310834,
-0.0272474606,
0.003017517,
0.030514393,
-0.0105633494,
0.0137336543,
0.0743364915,
2.409e-7,
0.0675285086,
0.0453207083,
0.029305093,
0.0124679059,
-0.0163961761,
-0.018812526,
0.0161309764,
0.0300559476,
-0.0408141427,
-0.0318589211,
0.0610060841,
0.0126515748,
0.0020915759,
0.041395016,
-0.0987165719,
-0.0142396251,
-0.0616294257,
-0.0452009737,
-0.0251598284,
0.0162254218,
-0.0092690745,
0.044366993,
0.014856372,
-0.0291203354,
0.0061982945,
-0.0489972718,
0.048636768,
0.0327445231,
-0.0006447553,
-0.020085182,
0.0776279271,
-0.0153960725,
-0.0375955626,
-0.0033622512,
0.0194094069,
0.0937519297,
-0.0246446766,
0.0725434721,
-0.02341385,
0.0494215228,
-0.0044910638,
-0.0797062218,
0.0141091384,
0.0178068373,
0.0259687044,
-0.011117504,
0.0097172223,
0.0083770026,
-0.0497217551,
-0.0016890479,
0.0209527332,
0.021378668,
-0.0102908444,
-0.025547618,
0.03827985,
-0.0190004501,
0.0511310324,
-0.0988117158,
0.0586333871,
0.0490454361,
0.0076884599,
0.0397196673,
-0.0053948588,
0.0412290283,
0.0339505225,
-0.0329196118,
0.0098970244,
1.933279539e-34,
0.0436905287,
0.0045749303,
-0.0002022353,
-0.0049650529,
0.011093244,
0.0082636038,
-0.065359816,
0.018323306,
-0.0163499881,
-0.0769926384,
0.0127206184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12810v1 | Crawling the Internal Knowledge-Base of Language Models | 2023-01-30T12:03:36 | 2023-01-30T12:03:36 | Roi Cohen, Mor Geva, Jonathan Berant, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models are trained on large volumes of text, and as a result their
parameters might contain a significant body of factual knowledge. Any
downstream task performed by these models implicitly builds on these facts, and
thus it is highly desirable to have means for representing this body of
knowledge in an interpretable way. However, there is currently no mechanism for
such a representation. Here, we propose to address this goal by extracting a
knowledge-graph of facts from a given language model. We describe a procedure
for ``crawling'' the internal knowledge-base of a language model. Specifically,
given a seed entity, we expand a knowledge-graph around it. The crawling
procedure is decomposed into sub-tasks, realized through specially designed
prompts that control for both precision (i.e., that no wrong facts are
generated) and recall (i.e., the number of facts generated). We evaluate our
approach on graphs crawled starting from dozens of seed entities, and show it
yields high precision graphs (82-92%), while emitting a reasonable number of
facts per entity. | [
0.0520431176,
0.0191675648,
-0.0159323588,
0.053646706,
-0.0353479311,
0.0185993873,
-0.0306685641,
0.0184829962,
0.0402687937,
-0.0539741777,
0.0164182745,
-0.0186999254,
-0.016592646,
0.0613215938,
0.0212794878,
-0.0190166999,
0.0212711152,
-0.0288382005,
0.0486249328,
-0.0154966088,
-0.0132762026,
0.0138227874,
0.0085411221,
0.0180127472,
-0.0408803262,
-0.0039775348,
-0.046851892,
-0.0026424164,
-0.0064561144,
-0.0064952089,
-0.0290102437,
0.0234637,
0.0027901225,
0.0538245402,
0.0000019754,
-0.0372969173,
-0.0327129997,
-0.002494592,
-0.0838719383,
0.0094365468,
0.0221017394,
-0.0125804367,
-0.0120753543,
0.0046142652,
-0.0369845629,
-0.0458187722,
0.0505721569,
0.0366611108,
0.0463128723,
0.070974566,
0.0030146372,
-0.0112328706,
0.0051220576,
0.016301306,
-0.03154153,
-0.025705792,
0.0292060282,
0.038445916,
-0.00799172,
0.0385458544,
-0.0313920677,
0.0239282362,
0.0153774051,
-0.0310998689,
0.0269432385,
0.0327797048,
0.0189553853,
-0.0201522801,
0.0340295322,
0.0681348294,
-0.007401186,
-0.025945209,
0.0099670542,
-0.0101986742,
0.0092554474,
0.0134466877,
-0.0486612245,
0.0183119886,
-0.0168892462,
0.0274928194,
0.0052530915,
-0.0584115572,
0.0442301035,
-0.0269912872,
-0.0248826239,
0.0555211827,
-0.0077998135,
-0.0183053426,
0.0167017411,
0.001117221,
0.0262177177,
-0.0561902002,
0.0016945674,
0.0485780947,
-0.0106298188,
0.0661086887,
-0.0127118956,
0.0183223281,
0.0283142366,
-0.0377520323,
0.0197359286,
0.0188325159,
-0.0377684198,
0.0486526527,
-0.0270993989,
0.0500009917,
-0.0069850986,
0.021082228,
-0.0234849099,
-0.0329401381,
-0.0359123386,
-0.0075483117,
-0.0492173173,
0.0340710394,
0.015415485,
0.0012850011,
-0.012366212,
0.0289548282,
-0.0200812351,
0.0388852023,
0.003092044,
-0.0067160996,
0.0046515292,
-0.0101981964,
-0.039809823,
-0.0056875232,
-0.0210696496,
-0.0324997976,
-0.0309092943,
-0.0515308492,
-0.0125623876,
-0.0341560394,
0.0254656058,
0.0092231007,
-0.0222994704,
0.0638353005,
0.0368571691,
-0.0092684096,
-0.0564123057,
-0.0467933901,
0.0010572933,
-0.0393660069,
-0.0162306949,
-0.0827913955,
0.0318827145,
0.012010226,
-0.0177710317,
-0.0625735447,
0.0113167027,
0.0120915659,
-0.0393680632,
0.0405612439,
-0.0476081334,
0.0194344614,
-0.0093673626,
-0.006937732,
-0.0149544179,
0.0795944631,
0.0097321821,
0.0311168768,
0.0611062124,
0.0092052715,
-0.0156550035,
0.0306133088,
0.0638228357,
0.0144379353,
0.0230179708,
-0.0025344857,
0.010806324,
0.0055621518,
0.0021182075,
0.035557203,
-0.0239260737,
-0.0289658848,
0.0282337647,
0.0263414495,
0.0264076199,
0.0278454591,
0.0713118091,
0.0104988404,
0.0416956879,
0.0103279585,
-0.0415794291,
-0.0148815187,
-0.0228126217,
0.0099501098,
-0.010481731,
0.0080846846,
0.0050398903,
-0.0190614779,
-0.023473274,
0.0044483268,
0.0270148069,
0.0278454032,
0.0835275576,
0.0177663341,
-0.0085684154,
0.0615793243,
0.0566122308,
-0.0287801474,
0.01568917,
-0.0346573368,
0.0013830797,
0.0762506351,
0.0422786102,
-0.0279652532,
-0.0437501296,
0.0344269983,
-0.0268570017,
0.0373848043,
0.0432788208,
-0.0554012954,
-0.0085303066,
-0.028834736,
-0.0310156345,
-0.0058919783,
0.0184422564,
0.0174340326,
0.0146736521,
-0.0003196082,
0.0091329981,
-0.0687440932,
-0.0437747389,
0.0237594023,
-0.0384311229,
0.0020002034,
-0.0106091816,
0.0134419017,
-0.0081412131,
0.0492278561,
0.0034537716,
0.016818421,
0.0333582498,
-0.0074434257,
-0.025964329,
-0.0042094574,
0.0124133741,
-0.0331396759,
0.0582235418,
-0.0018636672,
-0.015747983,
-0.0183336716,
-0.0280667357,
-0.0452800132,
-0.0067272773,
-0.0566867925,
0.0780113637,
-0.0130850235,
0.0120518785,
-0.0219164472,
-0.0415796302,
-0.0011627976,
0.0863558203,
0.0009618153,
0.0331569314,
0.0279172976,
-0.0055242656,
0.0328583531,
-0.0475671254,
-0.021165235,
0.0059728217,
0.022579411,
0.022100402,
0.0541171432,
-0.0201918688,
-0.0486439727,
0.0083352821,
-0.1138604656,
-0.0204489958,
-0.0016994982,
-0.00172535,
0.0432953611,
-0.016403066,
-0.0020449557,
-0.0358063243,
-0.0433426052,
0.0129140373,
0.0035151937,
0.0119509669,
0.0354699232,
0.016778253,
-0.0224008318,
-0.0185391214,
-0.0139710698,
-0.0337236524,
0.0350263156,
0.0229588076,
0.0219212677,
-0.0650247261,
0.0403484069,
-0.0527062938,
0.0376309082,
-0.013821193,
-0.0159245897,
0.0081928326,
-0.0263290592,
0.0088502001,
0.0472768731,
0.0016438465,
0.0996244326,
0.0687048435,
-0.0301557127,
-0.0765540004,
-0.0138067268,
-0.0458428785,
0.0415231399,
-0.0338709801,
-0.0314695239,
-0.0017260027,
0.0685100779,
0.0350584015,
-0.0258406978,
-0.0606357791,
0.0366167091,
-0.0254185367,
0.007423779,
-0.0422080122,
0.0074047684,
0.0074592228,
0.056647405,
-0.0349210426,
-0.0332312025,
0.0925759524,
-0.0304797124,
0.0233057085,
0.0174970422,
-0.029556118,
-0.0225894302,
0.0995858982,
0.0321258418,
0.0203587133,
0.0196540002,
-0.0241332017,
-0.0466710813,
0.0476366393,
0.051432766,
-0.0537284613,
0.0424121283,
-0.0412948281,
0.0241505187,
0.0265867095,
-0.0026866556,
-0.061984621,
-0.015209307,
-0.0227561872,
0.0263574049,
0.0122362738,
-0.0537801161,
-0.0217784364,
-0.0326221399,
0.0350146368,
0.0192120243,
0.0065648332,
0.0001073821,
-0.0103563061,
-0.0075979456,
0.0539437421,
0.002567414,
0.0305806156,
-0.0197673403,
0.0227808487,
0.0525228605,
0.0106545445,
-0.023577068,
-0.0075311605,
-0.0065024393,
0.0188199021,
-0.0411548875,
-0.0427289866,
-0.0099539272,
0.00890142,
-0.0407726318,
-0.0311538521,
0.1221862957,
0.0287941452,
-0.0263825487,
0.0148579758,
-0.0192394909,
0.0026097994,
0.0325436443,
0.0264758728,
-0.0876349732,
0.0117496336,
0.0067157578,
0.0017720798,
-0.0076293861,
-0.0529341288,
-0.0293399282,
-0.1346271634,
0.022772206,
-0.0206749141,
-0.0274148174,
-0.0538664311,
-0.044170104,
-0.0048132529,
-0.0049367235,
-0.0455441326,
0.0083967121,
-0.0084746098,
-0.0012111517,
-0.0006246742,
0.0043572527,
-0.0463088788,
0.0448209941,
-0.0122852605,
0.0459253155,
-0.0079579568,
0.0474510081,
0.0126930764,
0.0134880496,
-0.016573716,
0.0014517207,
-0.0104203606,
-0.0013290332,
0.0632164255,
0.0028954346,
-0.0135468822,
-0.0068192403,
-0.0188997798,
-0.0183927454,
0.0005648396,
-0.0173946097,
0.0919805691,
-0.0267755501,
-0.0203683656,
0.0187883507,
-0.030021539,
0.0136313038,
0.0803383067,
0.0341116004,
-0.0011323785,
0.0098712724,
-0.0705011338,
0.0264011696,
-0.007400963,
-0.0652269274,
0.037700031,
-0.0375976153,
-0.0282013901,
-0.086393021,
-0.0269120336,
0.0283421762,
0.0501558445,
0.0262692925,
-0.0278850049,
0.0709265992,
-0.0130141852,
-0.0585517175,
0.0096662734,
-0.0461830832,
-0.0165802725,
-0.0118286256,
-0.0585510805,
0.0256653577,
-0.0135487989,
-0.0309781246,
0.0157483574,
-0.0539716743,
-0.0749105737,
0.0203584768,
0.0209524706,
0.0278613996,
0.0678104535,
-0.0486495718,
-0.0025484972,
0.061138697,
0.0013249402,
-0.0922743753,
-0.0349372104,
0.0133890565,
-0.0318394974,
0.0048110294,
0.0501183532,
-0.0949932411,
0.013197816,
-0.0100733964,
0.0406356044,
-0.0733557418,
-0.071673736,
0.0563417301,
0.0613358989,
0.0183786321,
0.0087099187,
-0.0417091027,
-0.066795595,
-0.0029606216,
-0.0489401221,
-0.0318380818,
-0.0427949131,
0.0327420421,
-0.0088798562,
-0.0337448418,
0.0159897767,
-0.0109552173,
-0.0042575346,
0.0256662369,
-0.0082113948,
-0.0541001894,
0.0226498786,
0.025688231,
0.0563265681,
-0.0160866193,
-0.0193827916,
0.0156473778,
0.0091900034,
0.0253601372,
-0.0313547887,
0.0367259644,
0.0432457551,
-0.0309313834,
-0.0253796279,
-0.0137688508,
-0.049819231,
-0.0552939847,
-0.0036190925,
0.0419015028,
0.0583170243,
-0.0010097937,
0.0573670492,
-0.0621130466,
-0.0066531799,
-0.0007124693,
0.0275489464,
0.0317844301,
-0.0489648283,
0.0328674391,
0.0349029936,
-0.0150727713,
-0.0019077084,
0.0700524524,
0.003598308,
0.0824733526,
-0.010627836,
-0.0317118727,
-0.0440857485,
-0.0280345697,
-0.02158577,
0.0079736346,
-0.0176505838,
0.0296630524,
-0.0810442716,
-0.0834432915,
-0.0025982987,
0.027551461,
-0.021780014,
-0.007859922,
0.05017066,
0.0535370186,
0.0395293795,
-0.0063120397,
-0.0664610937,
0.0569483414,
-0.0349305309,
-0.0126977703,
-0.0001039165,
-6.258738939e-33,
-0.057519041,
-0.0649328455,
0.0120004769,
0.0222283825,
-0.0059135095,
0.0131347077,
-0.04039976,
0.0203428157,
-0.054498896,
0.0438940674,
0.002067172,
0.018975541,
0.0039087646,
-0.0133887082,
-0.0035121448,
-0.0155546116,
0.0443032421,
-0.0114790145,
-0.0232246518,
0.0405935198,
0.1038862243,
0.0325760208,
0.0670767576,
-0.0417818353,
0.0708792359,
-0.00896837,
0.0158889405,
0.0577683859,
-0.0009750761,
0.0659274459,
-0.0231637321,
0.0528996736,
0.0195938684,
-0.0607456118,
-0.0188448261,
-0.0355751105,
-0.0857848525,
-0.0515955277,
0.0403605364,
0.0300192069,
-0.0083772214,
-0.0054503409,
0.0248690788,
-0.021241216,
0.0467198417,
-0.0038249462,
0.0551078916,
-0.0207263585,
-0.025028374,
-0.0067402571,
-0.0344731621,
0.02631763,
-0.0027704311,
-0.0061475299,
0.0149680357,
-0.0103621492,
0.028788412,
-0.0130962618,
-0.0451380238,
0.01570829,
0.0126889329,
0.0191671159,
0.0435286462,
-0.0006861719,
0.0261162259,
0.0688866451,
-0.0465438142,
0.0064514629,
-0.0615739152,
0.0272678658,
0.0491616577,
0.0339048095,
-0.0234296732,
0.0280616209,
0.0054796613,
-0.0055581187,
-0.0556335412,
0.0035060558,
0.0318682007,
0.0316650234,
-0.0092896912,
-0.023973681,
-0.0381747074,
-0.0289588869,
-0.0359045267,
0.0028583477,
-0.0328566208,
-0.0374374874,
-0.0012810342,
-0.0097416313,
-0.0383254513,
-0.0433175117,
-0.014694972,
-0.0328547359,
-0.0088635264,
0.0712210685,
-0.0113051236,
0.0130299851,
-0.0107888421,
0.0170364305,
-0.0370441005,
-0.0428700112,
-0.0063037868,
0.0013657949,
0.0081571899,
0.0512155816,
0.016969271,
0.0268680323,
-0.0410532877,
0.0149982292,
-0.0565853268,
0.003007351,
-0.0124673909,
-0.0187832043,
0.0253377631,
0.0300971828,
-0.0098469453,
0.022261709,
0.0578108393,
0.0377193168,
-0.0065228855,
0.0426795296,
0.0152481589,
0.0164051633,
-0.0313847363,
-0.0341989435,
-0.0305070691,
0.0164830461,
0.0280856751,
-0.0107344361,
0.0186163969,
0.013568393,
2.619e-7,
0.0304237306,
0.0325027592,
0.0387533419,
0.0600587465,
0.0136784911,
0.0298921224,
0.00484769,
-0.0125569543,
0.001249399,
-0.0665151775,
-0.0156587772,
0.0399954244,
0.0025279198,
0.0636324808,
-0.105883278,
0.0357653908,
-0.0084527936,
-0.0516100116,
-0.0082416385,
0.0173250306,
0.0262909308,
0.0790756494,
0.0408699028,
0.0075894017,
-0.0202166084,
-0.038828928,
0.0512758978,
0.0038194133,
-0.0272640362,
0.0093226507,
0.0692318156,
0.0365555808,
-0.0132037494,
0.032711599,
-0.0042416956,
0.0174581073,
-0.0184308458,
0.0398165323,
0.0051928908,
0.0214440189,
-0.0262155756,
-0.0644715056,
-0.0048631495,
-0.0467130728,
0.040182393,
-0.0203583781,
-0.0262637399,
-0.0412815474,
0.0225536656,
-0.0191562809,
-0.0448990948,
-0.0403989106,
-0.0196396895,
0.0089776339,
-0.0059140516,
-0.0383189544,
0.0445806794,
-0.0520562045,
-0.0334521569,
0.0343002379,
-0.0078266403,
-0.0627281815,
0.011413292,
-0.0451481491,
0.0018668503,
-0.0609662049,
0.04504795,
2.326619694e-34,
0.0288915485,
0.0151617462,
-0.0182307027,
0.0092133302,
0.0293374378,
-0.032785736,
-0.0180893447,
0.0050069476,
0.0301227309,
-0.0613462739,
-0.0413903929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12729v1 | Response-act Guided Reinforced Dialogue Generation for Mental Health Counseling | 2023-01-30T08:53:35 | 2023-01-30T08:53:35 | Aseem Srivastava, Ishan Pandey, Md. Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Virtual Mental Health Assistants (VMHAs) have become a prevalent method for
receiving mental health counseling in the digital healthcare space. An
assistive counseling conversation commences with natural open-ended topics to
familiarize the client with the environment and later converges into more
fine-grained domain-specific topics. Unlike other conversational systems, which
are categorized as open-domain or task-oriented systems, VMHAs possess a hybrid
conversational flow. These counseling bots need to comprehend various aspects
of the conversation, such as dialogue-acts, intents, etc., to engage the client
in an effective conversation. Although the surge in digital health research
highlights applications of many general-purpose response generation systems,
they are barely suitable in the mental health domain -- the prime reason is the
lack of understanding in mental health counseling. Moreover, in general,
dialogue-act guided response generators are either limited to a template-based
paradigm or lack appropriate semantics. To this end, we propose READER -- a
REsponse-Act guided reinforced Dialogue genERation model for the mental health
counseling conversations. READER is built on transformer to jointly predict a
potential dialogue-act d(t+1) for the next utterance (aka response-act) and to
generate an appropriate response u(t+1). Through the
transformer-reinforcement-learning (TRL) with Proximal Policy Optimization
(PPO), we guide the response generator to abide by d(t+1) and ensure the
semantic richness of the responses via BERTScore in our reward computation. We
evaluate READER on HOPE, a benchmark counseling conversation dataset and
observe that it outperforms several baselines across several evaluation metrics
-- METEOR, ROUGE, and BERTScore. We also furnish extensive qualitative and
quantitative analyses on results, including error analysis, human evaluation,
etc. | [
0.0827450454,
0.0212769639,
-0.0272280239,
-0.0290301573,
-0.0105618564,
0.0151745062,
0.0225194152,
-0.0105686095,
0.0184262265,
-0.0297604539,
-0.0292295013,
-0.0251519028,
-0.0152873844,
0.059631642,
-0.0229161549,
-0.1018984988,
0.0169165321,
0.0256096814,
0.0540107638,
-0.0010506985,
0.0054229824,
0.0077650528,
-0.0584669076,
0.0806047618,
0.0013774009,
-0.0131874615,
-0.0143224606,
0.0287889987,
0.0583814345,
-0.0661111996,
0.0499481186,
0.0171558242,
0.0083497334,
0.0147530427,
0.0000021194,
-0.0269008428,
-0.0141571052,
0.0002520878,
0.0120110288,
-0.0873384252,
0.0035181583,
-0.048731599,
0.0023459753,
0.0442759618,
-0.0327984728,
-0.0241273679,
0.0419948399,
0.1059180349,
0.0688417107,
0.1049379557,
-0.0178069118,
-0.0247481093,
0.0194542091,
-0.0125328638,
-0.0065125511,
-0.0288602915,
-0.016825825,
0.0241164491,
0.027475439,
-0.0083344923,
-0.0185063388,
0.0058451318,
0.004751564,
-0.0030390951,
-0.0164080746,
0.0285809301,
0.0057624094,
-0.0412217081,
-0.0372374877,
0.0902881473,
0.0446999297,
0.046107918,
0.0191649497,
-0.0225264244,
0.0125691602,
0.0002065724,
-0.0294500552,
0.0125873918,
-0.0111899478,
0.0018375153,
0.001862693,
0.0164890755,
-0.0042916504,
-0.001144959,
0.0071928333,
0.0065984153,
-0.0134718884,
-0.0352610499,
0.0037667132,
0.0082992446,
-0.0223868415,
-0.0614845268,
0.0113566481,
0.0569038354,
-0.1027140245,
-0.0039800098,
-0.027108822,
-0.0499789789,
-0.0000567706,
0.0253947452,
0.0610714853,
0.0577592142,
-0.002700415,
-0.0475292727,
0.0413432047,
0.0463274866,
0.0028907477,
0.0248921886,
-0.0208820403,
0.0334289074,
-0.0638322383,
-0.0093288608,
-0.0595498271,
0.0493500382,
-0.0513369627,
-0.0516052619,
-0.0610829107,
0.0355398059,
-0.0285431314,
0.0089957584,
-0.0141293127,
0.0216265358,
-0.0380976386,
0.0136158867,
-0.0425623246,
0.032086052,
-0.0410122313,
-0.0029148487,
0.0503477454,
-0.0546566173,
0.0056772665,
0.0092476439,
-0.0109166335,
-0.0154110398,
-0.0028830632,
0.076280795,
-0.034909986,
-0.0281443819,
-0.0058693364,
-0.0379918441,
-0.0387420431,
-0.0573913828,
0.0150132021,
-0.0253699925,
0.0143352635,
0.0143342083,
-0.0060386737,
0.0117741181,
0.0447066836,
0.0006314108,
-0.0342984535,
0.0471982323,
-0.0148665337,
-0.0102564516,
0.0400581583,
0.0394735225,
-0.0305699706,
0.053127747,
0.0193031058,
0.020359613,
0.0075791106,
0.0016599776,
0.0067175035,
-0.0287334286,
0.0196836982,
-0.0385401547,
0.0299039334,
0.004857888,
-0.0367234871,
0.0581762977,
-0.0055289837,
0.0417129099,
-0.0474344157,
0.0258000009,
0.0263092183,
0.0311436802,
-0.0037083693,
0.0364494957,
0.039831955,
0.0439754426,
-0.0197579134,
-0.0096773217,
-0.0401194878,
0.0315808803,
0.0031479977,
-0.0163259506,
0.0086452775,
0.0087615531,
-0.036149472,
-0.0617961995,
0.0190054346,
-0.0273737554,
-0.0102186911,
0.0031909689,
-0.0082946839,
0.0282970667,
-0.0640274063,
0.0331128798,
0.0065447488,
-0.0087135714,
-0.0548252314,
-0.0608705729,
0.0446440652,
0.0720592737,
0.060621798,
-0.0392757133,
-0.059653379,
-0.0342146382,
-0.0246165004,
0.0687838793,
0.029778773,
-0.0037688154,
0.0245327167,
-0.0419635102,
-0.0228805952,
-0.0047676605,
-0.0032864278,
0.029476665,
0.0018159023,
0.0274577327,
-0.0026046725,
0.0709394962,
0.002510472,
0.0269984156,
0.0087462729,
-0.0080465181,
0.0466647893,
-0.0019946559,
0.0631283671,
0.0252261646,
0.0048612882,
0.0172632411,
0.0213511493,
-0.0280829407,
-0.0499446727,
0.0235199183,
-0.0580989271,
-0.0781759396,
0.0074967667,
-0.0254568737,
0.0008076429,
0.0335139111,
-0.0241271574,
-0.0335356221,
0.0279746484,
-0.0752339363,
0.0476265699,
-0.0211639497,
0.016515689,
0.0480538569,
0.0002014739,
-0.0178416166,
0.0137312515,
-0.024020331,
0.024912132,
0.0357944295,
0.008651848,
-0.025650369,
-0.0386338383,
0.0248729382,
0.0032525018,
-0.0438075066,
0.0000975105,
0.0342762917,
0.0483091585,
-0.04387502,
-0.042104926,
-0.1060086936,
0.01164502,
-0.02908911,
-0.0046730638,
0.021635754,
0.0070939921,
-0.0067630708,
-0.0299370624,
-0.047578793,
0.0413938276,
0.0553102754,
0.0188297834,
0.040101029,
0.0354989469,
-0.0103524281,
-0.029259773,
0.024334956,
0.0126601774,
0.002045115,
-0.0117496336,
0.0266220942,
-0.0308633596,
-0.0135411229,
-0.0474748388,
0.0000316562,
-0.0287150573,
-0.0568387024,
0.0360527337,
0.0020148125,
0.0682811216,
0.0012784317,
0.0555390902,
0.0543158241,
-0.0116395997,
0.0091278004,
-0.0784116015,
0.0489946492,
-0.0494216941,
-0.0324433893,
-0.0381133407,
-0.0370578095,
0.0258869603,
0.048505649,
0.0232204646,
0.0324081108,
-0.0639315099,
-0.0093242256,
0.0331054665,
-0.0059552989,
0.0194355324,
0.0384288169,
-0.0113611277,
0.0067955088,
-0.0173619799,
-0.0339497589,
0.0634030551,
0.0272820499,
-0.0183146149,
-0.0768782645,
-0.01506502,
-0.019622907,
-0.0015904036,
-0.0035547928,
0.0395448692,
-0.0217972174,
-0.0376503691,
0.0021748708,
-0.0441318192,
0.0009622707,
-0.0437497906,
0.0293616783,
-0.0222927555,
0.0035986127,
0.0096394215,
-0.0346508399,
-0.073961176,
-0.0267847776,
-0.0175233893,
-0.0149369165,
0.000184618,
-0.0194187164,
-0.0644579455,
-0.0392582752,
0.0397260413,
0.0504964888,
-0.0202039722,
-0.0497928932,
-0.0139227556,
0.034903083,
0.0521365739,
0.0087513141,
0.0200050846,
-0.0204544924,
0.0418845378,
0.0421236679,
0.0043054209,
-0.0113598779,
0.0014389548,
-0.0091739967,
-0.0016885721,
-0.0003434572,
0.0203421097,
0.0330321155,
0.0758222044,
-0.0172553323,
-0.0437558591,
0.0932736546,
0.0275651906,
-0.0125749772,
0.0167557187,
-0.0524312854,
0.0235997904,
-0.0106494967,
0.0017148172,
-0.0450512096,
-0.0280132852,
-0.0254568029,
0.0674142465,
-0.0396444723,
-0.0192415211,
0.0056298045,
-0.0555264652,
0.0337033644,
-0.0167194586,
-0.0018275951,
-0.0305250213,
0.0107371546,
0.0080297468,
0.030777663,
0.0020816086,
-0.0296907611,
0.0076119262,
0.002123161,
0.0030400811,
-0.001045168,
-0.0022283935,
0.0060265488,
0.0022666065,
0.0691194534,
0.0706561059,
0.0556520186,
0.0256762728,
-0.0163833927,
-0.0330196507,
0.0380114168,
0.0068168454,
-0.0046232697,
0.0502543189,
0.0087927701,
0.0170152299,
-0.0293744504,
0.0491023473,
-0.022051638,
-0.0518026613,
0.0209207702,
0.0403569527,
-0.0628903434,
-0.0228090938,
-0.040228039,
0.0722108558,
0.0823114067,
0.0470682271,
0.0037132194,
-0.0322476104,
-0.0415512212,
0.0072760228,
0.0288435034,
-0.0359945893,
0.008447092,
-0.0264249239,
-0.0116236517,
0.0022723961,
-0.0741953775,
-0.0654177889,
0.0039093974,
0.0025485139,
-0.0459440984,
-0.0712569878,
0.0101348516,
0.0296151936,
-0.0399442799,
0.0043913913,
0.0018330751,
0.0188541263,
-0.0471833348,
-0.034291286,
0.0138588222,
-0.0445225947,
-0.0076787476,
0.0331133604,
-0.0367017649,
-0.0168908369,
-0.0136496909,
0.0746398866,
0.0129476739,
0.0225892421,
0.0274407156,
0.0053475029,
0.0390170626,
0.0643401444,
-0.0525033623,
-0.0363654047,
0.0596395098,
0.0977996439,
-0.0092569571,
0.0283457674,
-0.0106531121,
0.0362347215,
0.0130337747,
0.0535551123,
0.0147709521,
-0.0381311178,
-0.0030111887,
-0.0006430782,
0.0244229101,
-0.0099719744,
-0.0105610257,
0.0079392362,
-0.0025475393,
-0.0185958073,
0.0196668673,
-0.0550300889,
-0.0058835242,
0.0108420989,
-0.0374356322,
0.0111170858,
-0.0171429645,
-0.0666377172,
0.0074394173,
-0.0343295261,
-0.0022967334,
0.0106674917,
0.0043075504,
0.0121981893,
-0.0149879763,
-0.0000043064,
0.0169159416,
0.0326231308,
0.0199879482,
-0.0101125939,
0.1294479519,
0.0311356857,
-0.0003666972,
0.0327702761,
0.0265780836,
-0.0644028559,
-0.0816447809,
-0.0198912192,
0.0294581242,
0.0189486556,
0.0670148507,
0.03806841,
-0.0359460078,
0.024235595,
-0.0028320777,
0.0626100376,
-0.0132932914,
-0.0328512378,
0.0281591415,
0.0033296826,
-0.0104715033,
-0.0141783468,
0.048116114,
-0.0622566007,
0.0248234496,
0.0025439623,
-0.013257145,
-0.0659577996,
-0.0287850425,
0.0051697986,
0.0512055196,
0.0032705991,
0.0076886695,
-0.0391367003,
-0.0337678306,
0.028543001,
-0.0154732075,
-0.0338498205,
-0.0377143249,
0.0396401174,
0.0080494806,
-0.007101988,
-0.036480546,
-0.0684386119,
0.0594831631,
-0.0293833893,
-0.0113899885,
-0.0525913723,
-5.8966257e-33,
-0.0078953831,
-0.0277398154,
0.0138526661,
0.0041247206,
-0.0406068228,
-0.0121756233,
-0.0544041991,
0.0052990052,
0.0082927393,
0.0261289682,
0.0182627849,
0.034225475,
-0.0022712506,
0.0741232783,
-0.01992983,
-0.0232792646,
0.0420754626,
-0.0119673107,
-0.0419318527,
0.065499939,
-0.0014838411,
0.0482716188,
0.010866778,
-0.0863132551,
0.0017854379,
-0.0047182385,
-0.0095380964,
0.0181416161,
0.0241679363,
0.0340407714,
-0.024357561,
0.0333667509,
0.0270979404,
-0.0310369637,
-0.0046439902,
0.0376946591,
-0.0642670989,
-0.0460523367,
-0.0056723063,
-0.0212885644,
-0.1107162461,
-0.0200211499,
-0.0043201772,
-0.018529715,
0.0002908818,
-0.010869612,
-0.0034751361,
-0.0177880749,
0.0010691936,
-0.0228247102,
-0.0501940325,
-0.021771336,
-0.0282545127,
-0.0548318289,
-0.0368303582,
0.0828641504,
-0.0103031108,
0.0101201059,
-0.0274669509,
0.0128673846,
0.0083666453,
-0.0181261953,
0.0180435646,
-0.0064751902,
-0.0252246596,
0.0224137157,
0.0061729173,
-0.0170634594,
-0.0498137549,
-0.0105948234,
-0.0271385685,
0.0438698642,
0.0113140726,
0.0421618745,
-0.0041846097,
-0.0088933343,
-0.0376755707,
0.0433194786,
0.0312485825,
0.0383156314,
0.031527292,
-0.0075419643,
-0.0218636077,
0.0055768015,
-0.0221236199,
-0.032472536,
-0.0004054713,
-0.0416057371,
0.0347638056,
0.0414282568,
-0.0026682692,
-0.0144141698,
-0.0009705115,
-0.0388018191,
0.0229907297,
0.0276539959,
-0.0275810212,
-0.0018011223,
-0.019052757,
-0.0066145491,
-0.0539445356,
-0.0278424602,
0.0568673164,
0.0081641227,
0.0137864687,
0.0160449203,
0.0134528494,
-0.0081335716,
-0.0465143621,
-0.0057319882,
-0.0167115256,
0.1120611429,
-0.0274234228,
0.0445842184,
-0.0355694816,
0.0019809727,
-0.0429994427,
0.0834783986,
-0.0104674166,
0.0120918946,
-0.0481614359,
-0.0058287401,
0.0149459019,
0.0141052799,
-0.0453822948,
0.0098689236,
-0.0331614763,
0.0365795493,
0.0072957966,
-0.0468495265,
-0.0132887792,
-0.0022062694,
2.848e-7,
-0.0105379894,
0.0440085344,
0.0291002654,
0.0335804895,
0.0309432838,
0.0524878539,
0.0363473482,
0.0582773164,
0.0251741949,
-0.0294395629,
0.0229924563,
0.011237218,
0.0385223106,
0.0254855361,
-0.0203158781,
-0.0306528471,
-0.0731847361,
-0.0510742106,
-0.0375004411,
0.0074954121,
0.1072175503,
0.0456666276,
-0.0063776341,
-0.0319723487,
0.0259043742,
0.0610557161,
0.0553786382,
-0.0235844832,
-0.0124030616,
0.0202028435,
0.0314630829,
-0.007240281,
0.0303412471,
-0.0166189913,
-0.0077167838,
0.0380636044,
-0.0304790977,
0.0791657194,
-0.0071959118,
-0.0784022659,
0.0082752118,
0.0291137379,
0.034146063,
-0.0137954652,
0.0187513176,
-0.1147673279,
-0.0411582962,
0.010351819,
-0.0340921544,
-0.0297720265,
0.0258690473,
-0.0389361568,
-0.0473623462,
0.0507773831,
0.0112915775,
0.0159106087,
0.0247748438,
-0.061975006,
0.0031411597,
0.0023257853,
-0.0719564036,
-0.0174016673,
-0.0348941833,
-0.0060185627,
-0.0221746508,
-0.0647327527,
-0.0091574248,
2.412900979e-34,
0.0170458816,
0.0103787733,
-0.0047118044,
0.0080602607,
0.0170333367,
0.0301583968,
0.0262484383,
0.0307806302,
0.035067454,
-0.0616668202,
-0.0266624521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12726v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12726v1 | Specializing Smaller Language Models towards Multi-Step Reasoning | 2023-01-30T08:51:19 | 2023-01-30T08:51:19 | Yao Fu, Hao Peng, Litu Ou, Ashish Sabharwal, Tushar Khot | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The surprising ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to perform well on
complex reasoning with only few-shot chain-of-thought prompts is believed to
emerge only in very large-scale models (100+ billion parameters). We show that
such abilities can, in fact, be distilled down from GPT-3.5 ($\ge$ 175B) to T5
variants ($\le$ 11B). We propose model specialization, to specialize the
model's ability towards a target task. The hypothesis is that large models
(commonly viewed as larger than 100B) have strong modeling power, but are
spread on a large spectrum of tasks. Small models (commonly viewed as smaller
than 10B) have limited model capacity, but if we concentrate their capacity on
a specific target task, the model can achieve a decent improved performance. We
use multi-step math reasoning as our testbed because it is a very typical
emergent ability. We show two important aspects of model abilities: (1). there
exists a very complex balance/ tradeoff between language models'
multi-dimensional abilities; (2). by paying the price of decreased generic
ability, we can clearly lift up the scaling curve of models smaller than 10B
towards a specialized multi-step math reasoning ability. We further give
comprehensive discussions about important design choices for better
generalization, including the tuning data format, the start model checkpoint,
and a new model selection method. We hope our practice and discoveries can
serve as an important attempt towards specialized smaller models in the new
research paradigm set by LLMs. | [
0.0089536561,
0.0632849932,
-0.004242511,
0.0216653198,
-0.0352538973,
0.0313763991,
0.0345110968,
-0.0035437725,
-0.0393488482,
-0.0462834537,
-0.0189694017,
-0.0348985232,
-0.020760227,
0.0304019712,
0.0321774259,
-0.0713311955,
0.0431690067,
-0.0865033269,
0.0158935152,
-0.0292863138,
-0.0394294336,
-0.0203936212,
-0.0028118533,
0.0135323731,
0.018584758,
-0.0184175838,
-0.0066936389,
-0.0400611348,
-0.0017113045,
-0.0066295359,
-0.0225075558,
0.0581884012,
0.0479565449,
0.044003468,
0.0000022043,
-0.0460964069,
-0.0029081616,
0.008378638,
-0.0611668639,
0.0112568587,
-0.0233702399,
-0.003653825,
0.0077555785,
0.0196878836,
-0.0259137526,
-0.0012936865,
0.0395655744,
0.0274053756,
0.0358569808,
0.061020229,
0.0121907927,
-0.0651386529,
0.0266044009,
-0.0224190876,
0.0142057426,
-0.0600456707,
0.0165376291,
0.0477024168,
0.0561417118,
0.0239825994,
-0.0165403374,
0.0110759642,
0.0519456975,
0.0301879458,
-0.0322182216,
0.0267917514,
-0.0041159997,
0.0034949996,
0.0169327371,
0.0272570755,
-0.03388533,
-0.0208561718,
-0.019646205,
-0.017905036,
0.0111428015,
-0.0002728385,
-0.0916087702,
0.0357346311,
-0.0061270585,
0.0080288667,
0.0294744186,
-0.0189976171,
0.0468656458,
0.0185821615,
-0.065730609,
0.1001081541,
0.0125866579,
-0.0133718206,
0.0112418253,
-0.0068782815,
-0.066092521,
-0.0347356051,
-0.0113592204,
0.0469748788,
-0.0163845979,
0.0038521832,
0.0021748981,
0.0048693521,
-0.0140509065,
-0.008789965,
0.063086845,
0.0770469606,
0.0312850624,
0.0555270948,
-0.0277240463,
0.0544166528,
-0.0590121113,
0.0132330554,
-0.0243699811,
-0.0014716409,
-0.0467007756,
-0.0152268857,
-0.0463297069,
0.0340159014,
0.0025728152,
0.001028356,
-0.0364898108,
0.0196761061,
-0.0083831307,
0.0085272668,
0.0208677985,
-0.0323547386,
0.0045309579,
-0.0629410371,
-0.0207492486,
0.0193932913,
-0.0715400651,
0.0206885841,
0.0187878646,
-0.0390689597,
-0.027840903,
-0.0337706506,
-0.0012126692,
-0.0450935438,
0.0307299104,
0.0373863503,
-0.006734591,
-0.0111784693,
-0.0445402898,
-0.0248937067,
0.0053296122,
-0.1144339442,
0.0403851233,
-0.0688316077,
0.0273033269,
0.0411284901,
-0.0238412619,
-0.0208452139,
-0.0090666451,
0.0030003067,
-0.0322798453,
0.0574063845,
0.045966994,
0.0114107952,
0.0041136933,
0.0026685805,
-0.053389404,
0.0689236298,
0.0201532952,
-0.0161103476,
-0.001385488,
-0.0131040588,
-0.0070964005,
0.0391958877,
-0.0037384229,
-0.0021585338,
-0.0110876029,
0.0235702526,
-0.0002040816,
0.0188245215,
-0.0034428898,
0.0328172892,
-0.0447691083,
-0.0065463451,
0.0291039534,
0.0570868813,
0.0191124287,
0.0427414253,
0.071801126,
-0.0104337437,
0.0254755709,
-0.0076644421,
-0.0906069279,
0.0310846306,
-0.0565746352,
0.0168691818,
-0.0104388874,
0.0255782269,
-0.0365753546,
-0.0397825129,
-0.0345128365,
0.0288073998,
-0.0115714902,
0.0183564182,
0.0703671351,
-0.0344401151,
-0.0026131226,
0.0693485364,
0.0091571212,
-0.034612868,
-0.0473900549,
-0.0762865543,
0.0235697422,
0.0147852702,
0.0194365401,
-0.0378970504,
-0.0210208297,
-0.0073822881,
0.0130114984,
0.0049389703,
0.0602021962,
0.0147161018,
-0.0228196234,
-0.0430945754,
-0.0172434822,
-0.0433424041,
0.0305421744,
-0.0005573422,
0.0260306299,
-0.0046662618,
-0.0012806975,
-0.0279690716,
0.0456319153,
-0.0026544863,
-0.0511880592,
-0.011779977,
-0.026897721,
0.0025738326,
0.0244539306,
-0.004561421,
0.0151064545,
0.0275853761,
-0.0031103748,
-0.0164321493,
-0.0180563331,
-0.0061101601,
-0.0588070042,
-0.0188417993,
0.0208214503,
0.0235141497,
0.0096806418,
0.0032207288,
-0.0280706119,
-0.0417651497,
0.0487651452,
-0.0125074405,
0.0146850264,
-0.0094291419,
0.0386196785,
-0.0074604717,
0.0104514146,
-0.0123279272,
0.1039870381,
-0.0284860283,
0.0240811501,
0.0147313578,
0.0154987257,
0.015037749,
-0.0347428955,
-0.015557725,
0.022062242,
-0.0053974683,
0.0204845704,
-0.0061885216,
-0.0004184544,
-0.0270767193,
-0.0468838401,
-0.0304661095,
0.0119205089,
-0.0262585375,
0.0287036691,
-0.004260194,
-0.0104893912,
0.0113516133,
0.016820401,
-0.0217197873,
0.0091383364,
0.0177679528,
0.0334933624,
0.0003265245,
0.0129408063,
-0.0369260497,
-0.0045560971,
-0.0372394025,
-0.0286769532,
0.0570733845,
-0.0052677663,
0.0108119128,
-0.0380540676,
0.0294893701,
-0.0328483805,
0.0183520894,
-0.0198147763,
-0.0033529962,
0.0312075391,
-0.0384002291,
0.0260351468,
0.0874147415,
-0.0520505458,
0.026738992,
0.0391905718,
-0.016419068,
-0.0148454448,
0.0395436063,
-0.0025905201,
-0.013880779,
-0.0079825968,
0.0143862292,
-0.0453902669,
0.0646666512,
-0.0236731544,
-0.0124941068,
-0.0556166619,
0.0448567644,
0.0061659692,
0.0054306835,
-0.0134585714,
0.0155666284,
-0.0083219185,
0.0642253682,
-0.0189043526,
-0.0170161631,
0.0310554877,
0.0163983814,
-0.0255419519,
-0.0266566277,
0.0077343713,
-0.0477273948,
0.0852501392,
0.0112990364,
0.0019136864,
-0.0019403187,
0.01466743,
-0.0522660129,
-0.0117194122,
0.0225811154,
0.0001894948,
0.0664218366,
-0.0456080101,
0.0212474931,
-0.0234930124,
-0.0770486966,
-0.0290838834,
0.0217297431,
-0.0511476174,
0.0647402778,
-0.0178070236,
-0.0445947833,
-0.0390277021,
0.0051609371,
0.0333621651,
0.0511808991,
-0.033962518,
-0.0085701011,
-0.0128192855,
0.0025208045,
0.0067085754,
0.0294980314,
0.0474003218,
-0.0524396077,
0.0594034493,
0.0093614254,
0.0516201667,
-0.019204542,
-0.0139787104,
0.0374030732,
0.022264529,
-0.0301624071,
-0.0652142614,
0.0415080711,
0.0472645313,
-0.0830473825,
-0.0141393747,
0.1155382693,
0.0160252284,
0.0048730029,
0.0108633228,
-0.0599689744,
0.0325210281,
0.0318771899,
0.0201251302,
-0.0583756492,
-0.0286642034,
0.0198274907,
-0.0353144072,
-0.0167402476,
-0.0323003381,
-0.0108149778,
-0.1057291105,
0.0416576527,
0.0377836488,
-0.0232485086,
0.0060111489,
-0.0072318204,
-0.0015320157,
-0.0019960795,
0.0076067955,
0.0365920551,
-0.0022217629,
0.0005396063,
-0.0055552665,
0.0284082368,
-0.0477201641,
0.077907443,
-0.0103462441,
0.0027875702,
-0.0153680965,
-0.004830067,
-0.0154444184,
-0.0446740687,
0.04309012,
0.0342704318,
0.000344101,
-0.005812387,
0.0030360268,
0.0285338908,
-0.0088194571,
-0.005200028,
0.0495739058,
-0.0256865919,
-0.0276478939,
-0.0104531189,
0.1239625886,
-0.023868667,
-0.0356700048,
0.0138482926,
-0.0149396304,
-0.0708457679,
0.0777074471,
0.0202508532,
-0.0341406278,
-0.0636047497,
-0.0445993245,
-0.072320424,
-0.0294347368,
-0.035888698,
0.026853919,
0.0546892211,
-0.0069971373,
-0.0150877479,
-0.0019845755,
0.0373424888,
0.0448106565,
-0.0186949018,
0.0113316989,
0.0077232565,
0.0148319509,
-0.0042671552,
0.0275878776,
-0.0328299664,
0.0127913337,
-0.0671921968,
0.0151281022,
0.0234645437,
-0.0388135165,
-0.0381857157,
0.0108553022,
-0.1198051125,
-0.0557713695,
-0.0075897323,
0.0300022885,
0.0333740599,
0.0254865754,
0.00726393,
-0.0433120541,
0.0154600935,
-0.0199131072,
-0.0095262975,
0.0222980641,
0.051120095,
0.0130802142,
0.0090935407,
0.0519714244,
-0.0189682804,
0.0292110853,
0.0355407931,
0.0304514132,
-0.0388513319,
0.0013321507,
0.018944649,
0.0150704719,
-0.0103730103,
0.0299504939,
0.0064685815,
-0.0160379354,
0.0234880671,
-0.0395666398,
-0.0113490215,
-0.0502824821,
0.0070678769,
0.0156899188,
-0.0191037767,
0.0001569812,
-0.0536744483,
0.0439063497,
0.035132654,
-0.0224190485,
0.0078264559,
-0.0114357527,
0.0186195299,
0.0438944474,
-0.0248713996,
-0.0173626058,
0.0118318228,
-0.021211518,
0.0184700433,
-0.0292409528,
0.0993464068,
0.0055935765,
-0.0065509416,
-0.0706459731,
-0.0057500335,
-0.0923592523,
-0.1098417863,
0.0044716191,
0.0230472106,
0.0475755855,
0.0215012021,
-0.0051253606,
-0.0548228547,
-0.0335626863,
-0.0107849082,
0.0254419949,
0.0514012203,
-0.0302198362,
0.0228474438,
0.0477878787,
0.0022865175,
-0.0259335544,
0.0425385386,
0.0118797794,
0.049873814,
0.0149944229,
0.0082954532,
-0.0292309448,
-0.0487454981,
-0.0457181744,
0.0141661363,
0.0190563351,
0.0377886519,
-0.0901700333,
-0.0667963624,
-0.0375917964,
0.0004817181,
-0.0195956696,
-0.0182477683,
0.0374591388,
0.0681465864,
-0.0464858375,
-0.0402929187,
0.0103072254,
-0.0049628271,
0.0099924793,
-0.0052562226,
-0.020378584,
-6.231959708e-33,
-0.005765446,
0.0188825801,
0.0653930679,
-0.0206799433,
0.0194342416,
-0.041442439,
-0.0250906721,
0.0252265446,
-0.0533671565,
0.002212168,
-0.0198972579,
-0.009360495,
0.0001934141,
0.0112570701,
0.0135405995,
0.0021680698,
0.0308137741,
-0.008518043,
-0.020771509,
0.0106287766,
0.0323619992,
-0.0138855316,
0.0670218393,
-0.0116691804,
-0.0145000732,
0.0021517063,
-0.0189367998,
0.0391691998,
-0.0740740597,
0.0694761351,
-0.0082007004,
0.0063723749,
0.0386440903,
-0.0654743463,
-0.022320902,
-0.0225995593,
-0.0293333102,
-0.0209298469,
0.0352163389,
-0.0116322711,
-0.0182702877,
-0.048517596,
0.0376550555,
0.0105607053,
-0.0308276247,
-0.059740968,
-0.0166246928,
-0.0421186164,
-0.0004301631,
0.0296514742,
-0.0424292684,
0.0232465118,
0.0055362796,
-0.0026026142,
0.0013792134,
0.0325423032,
-0.0507662445,
0.0175193325,
0.0141173713,
-0.0027840454,
0.0623397641,
0.0081684208,
0.0426632427,
0.0211664569,
0.0032542411,
0.020191865,
0.0192890894,
0.002921008,
-0.0163861047,
-0.034064997,
0.0011964939,
0.0865247771,
0.0601605363,
-0.0035518371,
0.0294176154,
0.0436086096,
-0.0711793751,
-0.0459850691,
0.0307068303,
0.0643643066,
0.0454348847,
0.011634415,
-0.0389031097,
-0.0215675142,
-0.0478580967,
-0.0335059017,
-0.0581420474,
-0.0071496479,
0.0415695459,
-0.0113909775,
0.0126829268,
-0.0143341096,
0.0519727841,
-0.0306477379,
-0.0056006215,
0.059767399,
-0.0266798735,
0.0377684794,
0.0039164596,
0.0328202397,
-0.0299660228,
-0.0225766581,
-0.0268245824,
-0.0044565112,
-0.0033902351,
0.0053743888,
0.0081646005,
0.033989232,
-0.0559757575,
-0.0213203467,
-0.0623696521,
-0.014085399,
0.0336328,
0.0469240136,
0.0584198758,
-0.0003697608,
0.0120678935,
0.0438658372,
-0.0177434012,
-0.045583766,
-0.0063262251,
0.0327496529,
-0.0125705106,
0.04511052,
0.0007386312,
-0.0002493373,
-0.030600315,
-0.0121091167,
0.0516780093,
-0.0374927483,
-0.01928645,
0.0470759757,
2.906e-7,
0.0214244947,
0.0537136346,
-0.0284528658,
0.0176097695,
0.0405748747,
0.0436206125,
-0.0290708169,
-0.0205956511,
0.0077914484,
-0.0060490719,
-0.0001706385,
0.0544146597,
0.0255249962,
0.009117011,
-0.0391881913,
0.0008428697,
-0.0371436216,
0.0111101568,
-0.0391160622,
-0.0017701705,
0.0291717444,
0.1167846471,
0.0330236778,
-0.0047843931,
0.0077579306,
-0.052792374,
0.0633905381,
-0.0188984834,
-0.0075248918,
0.0151535552,
-0.0134578869,
0.0203934051,
0.0167080462,
0.0292146504,
0.0258567259,
0.0486511812,
0.0004467937,
0.114588432,
0.0086738011,
0.0379870124,
-0.0084729008,
-0.03998987,
-0.0143812578,
-0.0731418505,
0.1019893885,
-0.0609231293,
-0.0446054712,
0.0122911623,
0.0283303298,
-0.032373596,
0.0064958758,
-0.013875071,
0.0213528331,
0.0001786917,
-0.0046973578,
-0.0132618137,
0.0176416244,
-0.0720836073,
-0.020175701,
0.0353678875,
-0.0707465336,
-0.0474320054,
-0.0432123207,
-0.0289375111,
0.0615580864,
-0.0389357321,
-0.0241983347,
3.207105829e-34,
0.0463591069,
-0.0336079597,
0.04931169,
0.021812357,
0.0275569204,
-0.0077452459,
-0.0255012251,
0.0271112323,
0.0490047298,
-0.1033924744,
-0.0356924981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13852v1 | ChatGPT or Human? Detect and Explain. Explaining Decisions of Machine Learning Model for Detecting Short ChatGPT-generated Text | 2023-01-30T08:06:08 | 2023-01-30T08:06:08 | Sandra Mitrović, Davide Andreoletti, Omran Ayoub | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT has the ability to generate grammatically flawless and
seemingly-human replies to different types of questions from various domains.
The number of its users and of its applications is growing at an unprecedented
rate. Unfortunately, use and abuse come hand in hand. In this paper, we study
whether a machine learning model can be effectively trained to accurately
distinguish between original human and seemingly human (that is,
ChatGPT-generated) text, especially when this text is short. Furthermore, we
employ an explainable artificial intelligence framework to gain insight into
the reasoning behind the model trained to differentiate between
ChatGPT-generated and human-generated text. The goal is to analyze model's
decisions and determine if any specific patterns or characteristics can be
identified. Our study focuses on short online reviews, conducting two
experiments comparing human-generated and ChatGPT-generated text. The first
experiment involves ChatGPT text generated from custom queries, while the
second experiment involves text generated by rephrasing original
human-generated reviews. We fine-tune a Transformer-based model and use it to
make predictions, which are then explained using SHAP. We compare our model
with a perplexity score-based approach and find that disambiguation between
human and ChatGPT-generated reviews is more challenging for the ML model when
using rephrased text. However, our proposed approach still achieves an accuracy
of 79%. Using explainability, we observe that ChatGPT's writing is polite,
without specific details, using fancy and atypical vocabulary, impersonal, and
typically it does not express feelings. | [
0.085293591,
0.0207018424,
-0.0249557793,
0.0298400912,
-0.0376547389,
0.0194424056,
-0.0043707625,
0.0238307249,
0.0060528251,
-0.0496017709,
0.019552676,
-0.0022355055,
-0.0127218096,
0.0489971116,
0.0155676035,
-0.0478132032,
0.0055527454,
0.0363601856,
0.026774874,
0.0441461541,
0.0445179865,
0.0452499464,
0.0190655291,
0.0648436174,
-0.0089673819,
-0.0335350409,
-0.0194294322,
0.0242719054,
-0.0081595164,
0.0297444966,
0.0276945233,
0.0570492335,
-0.0386283733,
0.0557190962,
0.0000016263,
-0.0432130061,
-0.005513052,
0.0047532581,
-0.0314554498,
-0.0189276878,
0.0715800524,
0.0020763834,
-0.0033793158,
0.0570368879,
-0.0489143692,
0.0184840672,
0.044073578,
0.0979632586,
0.08848387,
0.0808516294,
-0.0242442731,
-0.0229015928,
0.0088413004,
0.0198628828,
0.026609689,
-0.0147064673,
-0.0078331335,
-0.0051689367,
-0.0243927743,
0.0191243384,
0.0181373898,
0.0162485074,
0.0066856481,
-0.0722450987,
0.0229150299,
-0.0309118312,
-0.0202502515,
-0.0220906604,
0.0065056998,
0.0479009636,
-0.0348224938,
-0.0827020928,
0.0354968123,
0.0138072539,
0.0144576663,
0.0261774659,
-0.0113259889,
-0.0011997399,
-0.0046692262,
0.0033535182,
-0.0179823488,
0.008837943,
0.0216038283,
0.033512421,
0.0109199956,
0.0087336944,
-0.0107099582,
-0.0169245955,
-0.0333860256,
0.0252202507,
0.0217866395,
-0.0499010608,
0.0333367027,
0.0492195934,
-0.0151501652,
0.0118329609,
-0.0230140518,
-0.0283655692,
0.0220872834,
-0.0609332435,
-0.0136956563,
-0.0004164058,
0.0165774878,
0.0427754298,
-0.0443931893,
0.0400702469,
0.004183596,
0.0270170253,
-0.0242029354,
-0.0004787327,
-0.0982454345,
-0.0386629142,
-0.0254591387,
0.0149511853,
-0.0307222642,
0.0066321976,
-0.0572082475,
0.0181957074,
-0.0081897806,
-0.0027834733,
0.0268823151,
0.0235800706,
-0.0211641695,
0.0052611018,
-0.0300662071,
0.005984867,
-0.0408688933,
0.0095950868,
0.0021060584,
-0.0531196706,
0.0138444072,
0.0413752459,
0.0284452997,
-0.0004784855,
-0.0105785737,
0.062366914,
-0.012479011,
-0.0128113255,
-0.0028679396,
-0.0597463548,
-0.017513277,
-0.0388171338,
-0.0258764885,
-0.0304712187,
0.0039259098,
0.0121495081,
-0.030711269,
-0.0078958208,
-0.0169905294,
0.0409027636,
-0.0291049723,
0.0775904804,
-0.0349800363,
0.0246985164,
0.01455775,
0.0104611441,
-0.0175038297,
0.0238400511,
0.0154628372,
0.0250352472,
0.0680195019,
-0.0278942399,
0.0664792731,
-0.0099473577,
-0.003718856,
-0.0264810771,
0.0221891981,
-0.0171730351,
-0.0790353119,
0.0063115843,
0.0078130374,
0.0672535524,
-0.0046594008,
-0.013260169,
0.0508559272,
0.0479314066,
0.0112646073,
0.054666996,
0.0517746396,
0.0866367295,
0.0065478529,
0.070537284,
-0.0324007459,
-0.0004805676,
-0.0187379569,
0.0014758329,
-0.024992533,
-0.0223569348,
-0.013737835,
-0.0597956628,
-0.0067447741,
-0.0392355025,
0.0358416475,
-0.022836959,
0.0406444892,
0.0511830002,
-0.0402786024,
0.0232619792,
0.017039299,
-0.0601133369,
-0.0010007285,
-0.0770170763,
0.0225991625,
0.0877306163,
0.0316558592,
0.0182343237,
0.0197202284,
-0.0498073809,
-0.0222654585,
0.0469834507,
0.0312157217,
-0.0044240444,
-0.0015012884,
-0.0112242019,
0.0085825929,
0.0099778259,
0.0074069062,
-0.0397928841,
0.0344897583,
-0.0316443741,
0.033248648,
-0.0413907543,
-0.0586125553,
0.0354186557,
0.0060668653,
-0.0078173634,
0.0009684649,
0.000218865,
0.0187606923,
0.0298367664,
0.0164493397,
0.0112755392,
-0.0034947344,
0.0074990746,
-0.0457996577,
0.024828434,
-0.0105945487,
-0.035271652,
0.0044403533,
-0.0525242053,
-0.0209485348,
0.0263165161,
-0.0333530977,
-0.0342771523,
-0.0094562154,
-0.057063885,
0.0531722531,
-0.0520897284,
0.0203930736,
-0.0203858893,
-0.0110771935,
-0.0395260416,
0.0407820866,
0.0209529418,
0.0134839779,
-0.0385413915,
-0.0475424714,
0.0080703748,
0.0004076186,
-0.0026049961,
-0.0238652136,
-0.03802431,
0.020653991,
0.0423061661,
0.0245968401,
-0.0367091596,
-0.0415412709,
-0.0867310241,
-0.0372021087,
-0.0212376118,
0.024996886,
0.0536249429,
-0.0116054984,
0.0203340482,
0.0020024274,
-0.0546948053,
-0.000139544,
0.0241158996,
-0.0082993796,
0.0713898018,
-0.0121003371,
-0.0046724882,
-0.0440578051,
-0.0060076369,
-0.0424056537,
0.0587039888,
0.0441505089,
-0.0292796772,
-0.0738465562,
0.0364122465,
-0.0078595327,
-0.0314859711,
0.0061285505,
-0.0907562003,
0.0274935476,
0.0240730289,
0.0124687534,
0.0324777514,
0.0587813482,
0.0557064675,
-0.023416739,
0.0568158664,
-0.0190128926,
-0.0177545603,
-0.032769002,
-0.005608723,
-0.029515747,
-0.0628275648,
0.0369439125,
0.0449237637,
-0.0079714358,
0.001675371,
-0.0453522392,
0.0407461114,
-0.0041672438,
-0.0386726148,
-0.0068743364,
-0.0319422148,
-0.008684638,
0.0357023031,
-0.0136452774,
-0.0432029627,
0.0891012922,
-0.0199355315,
-0.0021320041,
-0.0357809514,
-0.0206848048,
-0.0256032255,
0.0433296934,
-0.0095940791,
0.0419040397,
-0.0030211734,
-0.0266210847,
-0.0230531562,
-0.0243955236,
0.0617927462,
-0.0078234673,
0.0156543758,
-0.0017686924,
0.0110195773,
0.0359655991,
-0.0340512767,
-0.043659661,
-0.0743177831,
-0.024501089,
-0.0268055405,
0.0594010465,
-0.0568552576,
-0.0015337631,
0.0392987914,
-0.0070618596,
-0.0002480685,
-0.0359678268,
-0.0192348417,
-0.0168891195,
0.0286210105,
0.0473588109,
0.0180364698,
0.0481578968,
-0.0206208546,
0.0408014022,
0.0523848794,
0.0008283235,
-0.0217270106,
-0.0109745385,
-0.053042721,
-0.0340757221,
-0.0481054708,
-0.0251275375,
-0.0081079397,
0.0576053858,
-0.0539590046,
0.0074934647,
0.1204743385,
0.0335406363,
-0.049712155,
0.0017572346,
-0.0026790225,
0.0098931957,
-0.0099269785,
0.0447640643,
-0.0464477129,
-0.0327043384,
-0.005470952,
0.0218785815,
-0.0230328813,
0.000524319,
-0.0117441555,
-0.0779575855,
0.0166166462,
-0.0239817537,
-0.028986413,
-0.0303594396,
-0.0216348395,
-0.0355044268,
-0.0020923512,
0.0222928356,
-0.0254909936,
-0.039083302,
0.0180474333,
-0.0030957281,
-0.0618118234,
-0.0293082017,
0.0042905421,
-0.0305518229,
0.0437256321,
0.0731362775,
0.0528958626,
-0.0004736214,
0.0021656554,
0.0089167375,
-0.0071838978,
0.0259448998,
0.0059245853,
0.0920074135,
0.0127960034,
0.0033174981,
-0.0767202973,
0.0240841098,
-0.0400558412,
0.0115242116,
-0.0125835435,
0.0158164222,
-0.0243057217,
-0.0405935645,
0.0077402187,
0.0228367373,
0.0193580315,
0.0894928947,
0.0490615107,
-0.0330283232,
-0.0975144953,
-0.0292576328,
0.0029958936,
-0.0372778885,
-0.0445681103,
-0.015189467,
-0.0108171226,
-0.0358128585,
-0.0950827301,
-0.0552167743,
-0.0228903424,
0.0309238583,
0.0121174436,
0.0034923046,
0.0343203843,
0.0133778714,
-0.0257884171,
0.0070520216,
0.0010749904,
0.0065238187,
-0.0393367335,
-0.0166659318,
0.0084366305,
-0.0425406061,
0.0160702337,
-0.0367151015,
-0.0337528698,
-0.0122961095,
-0.0020900674,
0.0212718397,
0.0359939262,
0.0402504914,
-0.0457684472,
-0.0613070913,
-0.0228292923,
0.0274631549,
-0.0429229476,
-0.0179843847,
0.0458172895,
0.0302689355,
-0.0076999217,
0.0445002243,
-0.0071083033,
0.0129163591,
-0.0138065824,
-0.0317817032,
-0.0514389351,
0.0003690895,
0.0296636932,
0.0246769283,
0.0099309748,
0.0138727827,
0.0278235506,
-0.027417006,
-0.0383749343,
-0.0327568129,
0.0056764046,
-0.0379124731,
0.0039418694,
-0.002034385,
0.0112481061,
-0.0167295355,
-0.0139737204,
-0.0714492574,
0.0156799648,
-0.025220925,
0.0047601154,
-0.0206202418,
0.0007745672,
-0.0230474304,
0.0071089691,
-0.0099125858,
0.0381112322,
0.0254355315,
0.0391176939,
0.0223443769,
0.0492643416,
0.0186382085,
-0.0059213163,
-0.0038824475,
0.0365618616,
-0.0578503273,
-0.0120606525,
-0.0031310411,
0.0174296442,
0.019507682,
-0.0269080587,
0.081769079,
-0.014477198,
0.0013622702,
-0.0080350973,
0.0934786946,
0.0109013813,
-0.0124135232,
-0.0184096806,
0.0038844924,
-0.0489039309,
-0.0094992407,
0.077111192,
0.0074267741,
-0.0299554262,
0.0224693753,
-0.0802900344,
-0.0377692841,
-0.0060203592,
-0.0165375322,
0.0104044052,
0.0208538473,
0.0087821847,
-0.0514774472,
-0.0663471743,
-0.0308467932,
-0.0093116695,
0.0515935384,
-0.0122326948,
0.0179709289,
0.0834468901,
-0.011926448,
-0.0160984974,
-0.0898536593,
-0.0080641424,
0.0066989339,
-0.0160192344,
-0.0109793572,
-5.300739328e-33,
0.0340938233,
-0.0939073488,
-0.0439483561,
0.0150553361,
-0.0016803673,
0.0011036351,
-0.0521269254,
-0.0024921854,
-0.015476983,
0.0697560906,
-0.0233323853,
0.0485203937,
0.0101109585,
0.0184952356,
-0.0133774811,
-0.0318897292,
0.0733954459,
0.007606335,
-0.0029499095,
0.0550075509,
0.0369028375,
0.0186969284,
0.0156313926,
-0.0728593096,
0.0426602699,
-0.0304726977,
-0.0422030687,
0.0165493526,
0.0104201538,
0.0717584789,
-0.007398589,
0.0333521031,
0.0561134294,
0.0126356911,
-0.0066482136,
0.0366182104,
-0.0700756833,
0.0161933992,
0.0145013258,
0.0169884451,
-0.0377800092,
-0.0356395207,
0.0666779578,
-0.0495804697,
-0.0204075594,
0.0119378045,
0.0760621727,
0.0028255845,
0.0279901475,
-0.0457928143,
-0.045784466,
0.0198647901,
-0.0234785452,
-0.0334755965,
-0.0040685479,
0.0431192555,
-0.0234843139,
0.0183543824,
-0.0278497245,
-0.0046966416,
0.0015629889,
0.0147093842,
0.0376684256,
-0.0094523039,
-0.0276495665,
0.0535591505,
0.018580135,
0.0382337347,
-0.0333454236,
-0.0023697987,
-0.0134021537,
0.0292629357,
0.0971936062,
0.0596178845,
0.0307585932,
-0.0478137024,
-0.038504649,
0.0191745497,
0.0481736325,
0.0225972235,
0.0391951576,
-0.0339195691,
-0.0740645081,
-0.025390137,
0.0165464953,
-0.030691186,
-0.0205971915,
-0.049528379,
-0.0078992145,
-0.0033000766,
-0.0499596223,
-0.0461370312,
-0.0028793307,
-0.086134918,
0.0223838985,
-0.005919206,
-0.0425146297,
0.0066388473,
0.0176292583,
-0.0045337174,
0.0283810385,
0.0058619934,
0.0192104112,
0.0125423623,
0.0197047256,
0.0019042869,
0.0644889474,
-0.0000977517,
-0.0471978001,
0.0136482837,
-0.0093104718,
0.0218322705,
-0.0235272124,
0.0092241615,
0.0105675478,
0.0238693189,
-0.0280784052,
0.0287445914,
0.0216107052,
0.0327109136,
-0.0282309223,
-0.024566222,
-0.0047563799,
-0.0065718959,
-0.0454662964,
-0.0237976462,
-0.0395165421,
0.0031799949,
0.024969684,
-0.0775846839,
-0.0014828481,
-0.0101147806,
2.36e-7,
0.0559035949,
0.061595954,
0.0292571597,
-0.0400236808,
0.0409846604,
0.0524482019,
0.0690797791,
0.000151671,
-0.0185585115,
-0.0117447507,
0.0213051643,
-0.002736235,
0.0667004064,
0.0000784175,
-0.0813591555,
-0.0117631191,
-0.0905368403,
-0.024675129,
-0.0340189561,
0.0282740016,
0.0935594887,
0.054763332,
0.01993105,
-0.0090997266,
0.0035177779,
-0.0447441749,
0.026931623,
-0.018763423,
-0.0202828925,
0.0305848196,
0.0849916339,
-0.0377551764,
0.0345761329,
0.017866645,
-0.0391296521,
-0.0339769758,
0.0051823668,
0.0622611344,
-0.0019876384,
-0.0086669577,
0.0179737434,
-0.0385342985,
0.0360574238,
-0.0594651401,
0.0538299121,
-0.0406677872,
-0.0345443785,
-0.0283463635,
-0.0164357666,
-0.0630653203,
-0.0080713909,
0.004434397,
-0.0400806703,
0.0565829016,
0.0007369308,
-0.0301276762,
0.0080529843,
-0.0647272915,
-0.0200681854,
0.005904919,
-0.008916541,
0.0063755056,
-0.0078475922,
-0.0245322771,
0.0677821711,
-0.0172084142,
0.0177944675,
2.251568282e-34,
0.051813148,
0.0069307499,
0.0140089225,
0.016554296,
0.0609801114,
0.0547049306,
0.0123653151,
0.019550873,
0.0379274525,
-0.0302235652,
0.0158674791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12715v1 | Fine-Tuning Deteriorates General Textual Out-of-Distribution Detection by Distorting Task-Agnostic Features | 2023-01-30T08:01:13 | 2023-01-30T08:01:13 | Sishuo Chen, Wenkai Yang, Xiaohan Bi, Xu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting out-of-distribution (OOD) inputs is crucial for the safe deployment
of natural language processing (NLP) models. Though existing methods,
especially those based on the statistics in the feature space of fine-tuned
pre-trained language models (PLMs), are claimed to be effective, their
effectiveness on different types of distribution shifts remains underexplored.
In this work, we take the first step to comprehensively evaluate the mainstream
textual OOD detection methods for detecting semantic and non-semantic shifts.
We find that: (1) no existing method behaves well in both settings; (2)
fine-tuning PLMs on in-distribution data benefits detecting semantic shifts but
severely deteriorates detecting non-semantic shifts, which can be attributed to
the distortion of task-agnostic features. To alleviate the issue, we present a
simple yet effective general OOD score named GNOME that integrates the
confidence scores derived from the task-agnostic and task-specific
representations. Experiments show that GNOME works well in both semantic and
non-semantic shift scenarios, and further brings significant improvement on two
cross-task benchmarks where both kinds of shifts simultaneously take place. Our
code is available at https://github.com/lancopku/GNOME. | [
0.0326886736,
0.0172006506,
0.0020861262,
0.0469925702,
-0.0245881602,
0.0100061847,
-0.0517513119,
0.0153400749,
-0.0450032279,
-0.0680631101,
-0.0008286689,
-0.0057956711,
0.0288734064,
0.0226993542,
0.0186367296,
-0.0058220504,
0.0729314461,
-0.0250465777,
-0.0119730029,
0.0431853011,
0.0087533155,
0.0201752521,
-0.0056331344,
0.0374921076,
0.0070265359,
-0.0619752407,
0.0196511112,
0.0516181886,
0.0127846226,
-0.0052314997,
0.0024464924,
0.0140848197,
-0.0123517606,
0.017666433,
0.0000019646,
-0.0486069657,
-0.0349070691,
0.0035596814,
0.0086395647,
0.0206263084,
0.0689912066,
-0.0368793793,
-0.038316492,
0.0199907385,
-0.0262092352,
0.0027153071,
0.0661276653,
0.0258322041,
0.0160150509,
0.120722726,
-0.0219145007,
0.0516892411,
0.0044781044,
-0.0021133565,
-0.0282234885,
-0.0346070454,
0.0177239683,
-0.0529339053,
-0.042489592,
-0.0165049471,
-0.0184888765,
0.0219645631,
-0.0387443937,
0.025402613,
-0.0154104568,
0.0090592476,
-0.0372091644,
0.0004001805,
-0.0455974564,
0.0507065468,
-0.0911378786,
-0.0346827358,
0.0103429388,
-0.0430907607,
0.0202287305,
0.0269470401,
-0.0112597262,
0.0124849705,
-0.0095621198,
0.0267947689,
0.0053410889,
0.0160627346,
0.0308501963,
0.0199617352,
-0.039073918,
0.0767311007,
0.0050422531,
-0.0233464353,
-0.0063612037,
-0.0051509133,
-0.0773433149,
-0.0248875972,
0.0328857638,
-0.0105959801,
-0.0050400659,
0.0192315336,
-0.077225931,
-0.0543361902,
0.0188118871,
-0.045858372,
0.0565423556,
0.0206504483,
-0.0663818046,
0.0195190925,
-0.0073699933,
0.0661002398,
-0.0073739034,
0.0293038618,
-0.0097789001,
0.0094084982,
-0.0331268199,
0.0017515596,
-0.0183321424,
0.0161962081,
-0.0253797323,
-0.0481998287,
0.0090604145,
0.0460275374,
-0.0006279966,
-0.0209489409,
0.0229855888,
0.0314772017,
-0.0390748605,
0.014887468,
0.0132734394,
0.0462325029,
0.0069357608,
0.0138631016,
-0.0116309384,
-0.0663758367,
-0.0427820906,
0.0586325414,
-0.0105950013,
-0.0051612547,
-0.0222123619,
0.0887940899,
0.0181567892,
-0.0307227597,
-0.0383392945,
-0.0105600106,
-0.0480997302,
-0.0234470554,
-0.0055022808,
-0.0593075529,
-0.0569435246,
0.0165522881,
0.0239625443,
-0.0574943386,
0.0178912003,
0.0480150543,
-0.056494642,
0.0301117282,
-0.0292606279,
0.0284521896,
-0.014670277,
-0.0281722564,
-0.0016835434,
0.1125228032,
0.0352178477,
0.0058959411,
0.0871720091,
0.007743502,
0.0350839496,
0.0686633587,
-0.0361513421,
0.0279198103,
0.000678746,
-0.0198874511,
0.0059772325,
-0.005385024,
0.0630563498,
0.0272396654,
0.0099041974,
-0.0062347483,
0.06299977,
0.0451083295,
0.012346385,
-0.0206833743,
-0.0070938375,
0.043524541,
-0.0535202883,
0.0257096589,
-0.0526580662,
-0.0206467919,
-0.041303955,
-0.0160960332,
-0.0028312213,
0.0369286612,
0.006423593,
-0.0075594764,
-0.0352129564,
-0.0034363654,
-0.008188555,
-0.0246390067,
0.0452401526,
0.0450481512,
-0.0290394053,
0.0653269589,
0.0290190373,
-0.0237898342,
-0.0021494359,
-0.0408831537,
-0.028279392,
0.0360419378,
0.0610332154,
-0.0514157712,
0.0088401865,
-0.0099796914,
0.0125434417,
0.0422584824,
0.0078922631,
0.0151654547,
0.0358615778,
-0.0507375747,
-0.0249703042,
0.000020002,
0.041955471,
-0.0286479071,
0.0340173692,
0.0223273076,
0.0291382056,
-0.0945431441,
-0.0329578668,
0.062287163,
0.0320395641,
-0.0124547482,
0.0221494976,
-0.0049921628,
0.010271972,
-0.0064473394,
-0.0281774756,
0.0082410257,
0.0051577226,
0.0040392247,
0.0115864119,
0.0038874468,
-0.0357512981,
-0.0388891362,
0.0220008139,
-0.0121920649,
0.0272473171,
0.0358575508,
-0.0538797788,
-0.0019378058,
0.0083398419,
-0.0377763957,
0.0144385779,
-0.0309078693,
0.0494097583,
-0.0259665158,
0.0356605165,
-0.0523273684,
0.0502342954,
-0.0050174603,
-0.0155614,
-0.0071116267,
-0.0005239919,
0.0412926488,
-0.0022494302,
-0.0055996655,
0.0201943181,
-0.0387401357,
0.0155823044,
0.0047149216,
0.005244398,
-0.0352448449,
-0.0179099981,
-0.0756000802,
0.041802872,
-0.0500695705,
0.0384024642,
0.0803776085,
0.0060067354,
-0.0325469188,
-0.0246478654,
0.0018836628,
-0.0089633781,
0.0023891209,
0.0108358152,
0.0263546016,
-0.0369430929,
0.0225914922,
-0.0193072446,
0.0112920124,
-0.0234821197,
0.0593161546,
-0.0379255898,
-0.0584368668,
-0.0970661119,
0.0495672151,
-0.0083154868,
0.0186961405,
0.012200648,
-0.0255315583,
-0.0370551459,
0.0139840282,
0.0515313148,
0.041120816,
0.0208576359,
-0.0183179192,
0.0632880777,
-0.0149740549,
-0.0323377587,
-0.024680132,
0.0030419263,
-0.0101835225,
-0.0151943164,
0.0199341085,
0.0554788448,
0.0298466869,
0.0204458684,
-0.0173774119,
-0.031333182,
-0.0419640727,
-0.0610672608,
-0.0260420814,
0.009992904,
-0.0091912048,
-0.0469317473,
0.0143473931,
-0.0289479289,
-0.0515692048,
0.0411064886,
-0.0495638214,
0.0187061001,
-0.1094075367,
-0.0208692756,
-0.0304094274,
0.0175621081,
-0.0136502646,
0.0062163998,
0.0411373489,
-0.0633482486,
-0.0491549559,
-0.0089500416,
0.0017352251,
-0.0189992413,
0.0694066435,
-0.0596703775,
-0.0023979663,
0.0019262384,
0.0032106983,
-0.0246039294,
-0.1312817782,
0.0093903458,
-0.0087918704,
-0.0133084841,
-0.0244804379,
-0.0124072433,
0.0220360719,
-0.0257747751,
0.0720408708,
-0.0385172553,
0.0071094204,
-0.0315250792,
0.0468984954,
0.0547614954,
-0.0096467389,
0.0142927431,
-0.0139158498,
-0.0353659838,
0.0546576492,
0.0154399471,
-0.015600414,
-0.013569532,
-0.0015425019,
0.0287724156,
-0.0315666609,
-0.0428565741,
0.0505077355,
0.0664205998,
-0.0484827347,
-0.0125895338,
0.0829296336,
0.042379871,
-0.0483425111,
0.020537097,
-0.0064581404,
0.0532436483,
0.0453404337,
-0.033512868,
-0.0819287524,
-0.0594023541,
0.0228198562,
0.0241264105,
-0.0112152193,
0.0002264526,
-0.0001648778,
-0.1041646302,
0.007072791,
0.0051118783,
-0.0364098661,
-0.009436762,
-0.0303815529,
0.0363472104,
-0.0083245076,
0.00773418,
-0.0405696407,
-0.0378965065,
0.006209055,
0.0124098044,
-0.0510712713,
-0.0659313425,
0.0119537311,
-0.0467483103,
0.0153931724,
0.107771419,
0.0186822396,
-0.0191677138,
-0.0170554109,
0.0566969216,
-0.0459480882,
0.0228306763,
-0.0061664334,
0.0691076741,
-0.012081584,
0.0011722044,
0.025301896,
-0.0097692786,
-0.0539089665,
0.0019972099,
0.0211392045,
0.0637839064,
-0.0213702247,
-0.0329803191,
-0.0267322771,
0.0001245169,
0.0469372831,
0.0579876974,
0.0106267463,
-0.0225857086,
-0.052203346,
-0.014928,
0.0058754208,
0.0109641952,
0.0029347835,
0.0278401114,
0.0100475848,
-0.0749542266,
-0.1038349718,
-0.0064774156,
-0.0113209123,
0.0205004308,
0.0370855257,
0.0111443745,
-0.0101125427,
0.0100540761,
-0.0545916744,
0.0238241591,
-0.023867825,
0.0232762359,
-0.0358043127,
0.0277057085,
0.0325320512,
0.0359185562,
-0.0154082086,
0.0317771435,
-0.0905665085,
-0.0695002899,
0.0066922884,
-0.0080480296,
0.0219441317,
0.0172746982,
-0.046819713,
-0.0340144075,
0.0915179625,
0.0626068413,
-0.0507846363,
0.0454162061,
0.0302023869,
-0.0672543049,
-0.0014457073,
0.0392017923,
-0.0113600129,
-0.0182945933,
-0.0003035905,
0.0001233747,
0.0054594912,
-0.0511198565,
-0.0078485226,
-0.0184119064,
0.0807046294,
0.0010211803,
-0.0431642011,
-0.0215496421,
-0.0008307024,
0.0052218195,
-0.027566243,
-0.0178087819,
0.0240821466,
0.0228996854,
0.0047673383,
-0.0098580215,
0.0885531381,
-0.0286514461,
0.039251782,
-0.0402437262,
-0.0080422051,
0.0311957225,
0.0126947034,
0.0048670541,
0.0381935351,
-0.0161742922,
0.0007953683,
-0.0168519318,
0.0081608901,
-0.0215713233,
0.0600137673,
0.0056023146,
-0.0027623454,
-0.0095247617,
0.0530094206,
-0.0568234324,
0.0083452119,
-0.0276814848,
0.0139075778,
0.0428665504,
-0.0420248844,
0.0757701099,
0.0094600329,
0.0001762422,
-0.0398892947,
0.0292701162,
-0.0135078551,
-0.0027816237,
-0.0092608603,
0.0005298098,
-0.0433223955,
0.0045159045,
0.0848758593,
0.0199846774,
0.026070971,
0.0114132054,
-0.017200483,
-0.0119687272,
0.0125466436,
0.019151859,
0.0385259911,
-0.0069498797,
0.0065636104,
-0.0333877616,
-0.0560375787,
0.0062429477,
-0.023219103,
0.0202064477,
-0.0207864325,
0.0260728821,
0.0991268754,
-0.0086763073,
-0.0037391833,
-0.0310431067,
-0.0472272933,
0.0145346494,
0.0032114901,
-0.0486629494,
-6.000765683e-33,
-0.0096520921,
-0.0201221444,
-0.0399472937,
-0.0160062313,
0.0104526542,
0.0031566492,
-0.0275644809,
0.0052748504,
-0.0106860967,
-0.0015026117,
-0.0070113172,
0.0489005819,
0.029546449,
0.0058508748,
-0.0198279712,
-0.0148063684,
0.0531156473,
-0.0154974656,
-0.0467677377,
-0.0032541491,
0.0480505936,
0.0227306504,
0.0693747029,
-0.05689428,
0.0050031468,
0.0181018077,
-0.0222734939,
-0.0186297409,
0.0152308652,
0.0333907306,
0.0066879061,
0.0819889307,
0.0323023163,
-0.0120084491,
-0.0358867049,
0.029417865,
-0.0377635434,
-0.0242643319,
0.0302533526,
0.0091760503,
0.0180495251,
-0.0199399125,
0.0501213707,
-0.004310187,
-0.005475916,
-0.0216548964,
0.0602530055,
-0.046283666,
-0.0160560161,
-0.0217844453,
-0.0779796019,
0.0375128202,
-0.0007185896,
-0.0167815667,
0.0205638651,
0.0106581915,
0.0159789752,
-0.0001294847,
-0.0161136631,
-0.0078673763,
0.0024543845,
0.0513603836,
0.0411144011,
0.0275643338,
-0.0262459498,
0.0615811199,
-0.0557891093,
0.0197999161,
0.0011351592,
-0.0332093723,
0.0530486181,
0.0204898641,
0.0159151275,
0.032413803,
0.0575077236,
-0.0163025744,
-0.0633278266,
0.0143024568,
-0.0080987085,
-0.0133279655,
0.0196588077,
0.0222150274,
-0.068674691,
-0.0331660733,
-0.023601763,
-0.0091070831,
-0.0237851366,
-0.0309477374,
0.046826575,
-0.0004663397,
0.0009178912,
0.0416317917,
0.0021222052,
-0.0459535122,
0.0332282558,
0.0231436919,
-0.0434969701,
-0.00179068,
-0.0106671546,
0.0198506992,
-0.034490265,
-0.0254875142,
0.033426214,
0.015943436,
0.0299554877,
-0.009820885,
0.0364519358,
0.0265834574,
-0.0746330768,
0.0121281976,
-0.0076117706,
0.015732415,
-0.0248620175,
0.1013975069,
0.0126912342,
-0.0202950351,
-0.0227597822,
0.0494198464,
0.0296693239,
-0.0102454415,
-0.0244785119,
0.0205940232,
-0.0227600578,
0.0223043077,
-0.0504093803,
-0.0008750928,
-0.0069936104,
0.0090363212,
0.0312823243,
-0.0419008732,
-0.017513575,
-0.0057578487,
2.607e-7,
0.0692308471,
0.0450421423,
0.0244084336,
-0.0137265399,
0.0011427758,
0.025625594,
-0.0182985123,
0.0462789424,
0.0039630025,
-0.0476769768,
-0.0124910912,
0.0131501351,
0.0399299711,
0.0290677417,
-0.0885583982,
0.0297400504,
-0.0355363898,
0.0280896686,
-0.062480934,
-0.0244552605,
0.0448769815,
0.0991855189,
0.0164247137,
-0.0175933503,
-0.0144637786,
-0.0538791008,
0.0231375769,
-0.0118444311,
0.016824618,
0.004849419,
-0.0006566418,
0.0263198111,
0.0248797499,
0.0422397777,
-0.0129626421,
0.0271606091,
0.0308175832,
0.0321376733,
-0.0264165383,
-0.0341281258,
-0.0375484079,
-0.0049882471,
0.0031583596,
-0.0566881262,
0.0875648037,
-0.0193296168,
-0.0243085977,
-0.0418128744,
-0.025145242,
-0.0108180195,
0.0084208399,
-0.005941777,
-0.0066763754,
0.0180981196,
0.0432623141,
0.0321977213,
-0.0663869753,
-0.0907225311,
-0.0511643663,
0.0216668956,
-0.0090862261,
-0.0451788977,
-0.0171009228,
0.019193776,
0.0202265885,
-0.0811416283,
0.0461971164,
2.816859153e-34,
0.0350773893,
0.0052696858,
-0.0003604237,
-0.0250120312,
0.0276627205,
0.0004306678,
0.0104439603,
-0.0216456689,
-0.0172713902,
-0.0356945507,
0.00995031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12711v2 | UzbekTagger: The rule-based POS tagger for Uzbek language | 2023-01-30T07:40:45 | 2023-03-01T14:31:12 | Maksud Sharipov, Elmurod Kuriyozov, Ollabergan Yuldashev, Ogabek Sobirov | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research paper presents a part-of-speech (POS) annotated dataset and
tagger tool for the low-resource Uzbek language. The dataset includes 12 tags,
which were used to develop a rule-based POS-tagger tool. The corpus text used
in the annotation process was made sure to be balanced over 20 different fields
in order to ensure its representativeness. Uzbek being an agglutinative
language so the most of the words in an Uzbek sentence are formed by adding
suffixes. This nature of it makes the POS-tagging task difficult to find the
stems of words and the right part-of-speech they belong to. The methodology
proposed in this research is the stemming of the words with an affix/suffix
stripping approach including database of the stem forms of the words in the
Uzbek language. The tagger tool was tested on the annotated dataset and showed
high accuracy in identifying and tagging parts of speech in Uzbek text. This
newly presented dataset and tagger tool can be used for a variety of natural
language processing tasks such as language modeling, machine translation, and
text-to-speech synthesis. The presented dataset is the first of its kind to be
made publicly available for Uzbek, and the POS-tagger tool created can also be
used as a pivot to use as a base for other closely-related Turkic languages. | [
0.0454695635,
-0.0192027371,
0.0009177979,
0.0086127482,
-0.0485910848,
0.0219612457,
0.0023575821,
0.0121484203,
0.0072471602,
-0.0111500034,
0.0222504884,
-0.033371266,
0.0329382271,
-0.0202573389,
0.0130783906,
-0.0561519153,
0.0584604479,
-0.0232095346,
0.026175255,
0.0409604944,
0.0503329784,
0.0407282375,
-0.045748584,
0.0022181314,
-0.0777846277,
0.034978576,
0.0102172,
-0.0210996661,
0.0019986031,
-0.0097271986,
-0.022275826,
0.0117993662,
-0.0424846858,
0.0376205593,
0.0000017407,
-0.0889187828,
-0.0819001421,
-0.004705762,
0.0147616304,
-0.0345085077,
0.0590651333,
0.0167813152,
-0.0593588687,
0.0543288253,
-0.0078166761,
0.00764023,
0.0568561852,
0.0231177323,
0.0456845984,
0.0705509111,
-0.0176625066,
-0.0756608248,
0.0054821437,
0.0389441848,
-0.0204224307,
-0.0245089401,
-0.0054296576,
-0.0017238237,
0.0090708947,
-0.0157448985,
-0.0052650901,
0.0027235295,
-0.0593726374,
-0.0359989777,
-0.0160655286,
-0.0124911917,
-0.0610927008,
-0.0659149662,
0.0517461896,
0.0105152642,
0.0027397033,
-0.0355025679,
0.0533704013,
0.0210272502,
0.0031749702,
0.0081960112,
-0.0196938515,
-0.0008470186,
-0.0481454395,
0.0201570801,
0.0771529749,
0.0394798629,
-0.0166315213,
-0.0054581705,
-0.0081672464,
0.062842235,
0.0426737182,
-0.0309032165,
-0.0151386112,
-0.0454812087,
0.0009917082,
-0.0069321138,
0.0353753716,
-0.0067820684,
-0.0149473902,
0.012801352,
-0.0499026515,
-0.0794336572,
-0.0113300802,
-0.0424128212,
-0.0383113287,
0.0276409928,
0.0212198626,
0.0294432323,
-0.0236943346,
-0.0482231714,
0.0554003641,
-0.046168033,
-0.0590332188,
-0.053519804,
-0.0568476878,
0.0167761371,
-0.0891543701,
0.0216206145,
-0.0235236753,
0.026853906,
-0.0704337135,
-0.0354924686,
-0.0000568148,
0.0062278579,
-0.0090173483,
-0.0547622815,
0.0282719154,
-0.0063436893,
0.0031652239,
0.0191198885,
-0.0305977929,
-0.0046960628,
-0.0461485088,
-0.0506238602,
0.0278906897,
0.0571706258,
0.027039621,
0.0140527273,
0.006286941,
0.0159498435,
-0.0026803515,
-0.036773175,
-0.0445624292,
-0.0433269404,
-0.0038652986,
-0.0245652664,
-0.0482149348,
-0.0592494048,
0.0086027868,
0.0093549816,
-0.0432804488,
-0.0597639605,
0.0016720095,
0.0109926118,
-0.0023378124,
0.0491023995,
-0.0329656973,
0.0164386649,
0.0287588686,
-0.0135161271,
0.0596837997,
0.0180000532,
0.0303877536,
0.0412089564,
0.0785212889,
-0.0189122744,
0.0383144394,
0.0510412119,
-0.0257829446,
-0.0424071252,
0.0022893373,
-0.0097098984,
0.0340137482,
0.0089293737,
0.0300653577,
0.0656679869,
0.0145012457,
0.0432448275,
0.005310561,
0.0497473776,
0.0321475603,
0.0642021447,
0.009706866,
0.0332214423,
0.0290422775,
0.0024340374,
0.0383188538,
-0.0587455444,
-0.0296910293,
0.0057158265,
0.0028527065,
0.0168224145,
-0.0152448351,
-0.0248997174,
-0.0429956019,
-0.0241754185,
0.0146442177,
-0.0516372882,
0.0917903408,
0.00506526,
-0.0478021801,
0.0211814679,
0.0310490374,
-0.045916833,
0.0388744213,
-0.029394269,
0.0000347643,
0.0392533392,
0.0581889413,
-0.0800263956,
0.0344130732,
-0.0060091782,
-0.0256190468,
0.0034031693,
-0.0034819229,
-0.0402602516,
-0.0204233583,
-0.057923995,
0.032124646,
0.0556102395,
-0.0090728058,
-0.0161652938,
-0.0132777458,
0.0452917106,
0.0111789349,
-0.0427403487,
0.0193887018,
0.0515305772,
-0.0028684763,
-0.0097259171,
-0.0171337109,
-0.0237489864,
0.0137598133,
0.0692621544,
-0.017140843,
0.0519144312,
0.0097671077,
0.0020472864,
0.0554560423,
0.0229143668,
0.0510313958,
0.0009861059,
0.0414602309,
-0.0291382112,
-0.0328972042,
-0.0359001458,
0.0064240089,
-0.0620283447,
0.0694605857,
0.0132208997,
0.0094919959,
-0.0269226525,
0.0565433428,
0.0111810844,
0.0468635932,
-0.018097274,
0.0125481887,
0.0338802375,
0.0072199795,
0.00406862,
-0.0502886772,
0.0442781411,
0.0221091434,
-0.0050419685,
0.0285080839,
-0.0158640705,
-0.0383333117,
-0.0067024101,
-0.0325209759,
-0.015721174,
0.030027695,
-0.0526696071,
0.0032885759,
0.0003693602,
0.0782211646,
-0.0172973741,
0.0631673932,
-0.012673582,
0.0077964058,
0.0112568187,
-0.0397182815,
0.0506188907,
-0.0417110138,
0.0071315812,
-0.0259454995,
-0.0113647496,
-0.0267748889,
0.0272624604,
0.0148010701,
-0.0133704497,
-0.002249514,
-0.1021907628,
-0.0319242254,
-0.0163906757,
0.003048264,
0.0583038442,
0.028000975,
-0.0532551743,
-0.0170176215,
0.0033728222,
0.0351371169,
-0.0086015956,
-0.028049415,
-0.0307615958,
0.0254285056,
-0.0391252637,
0.0397673734,
-0.0614361279,
-0.0299357343,
0.055991929,
0.0193058681,
0.0014626946,
0.0091131767,
0.0299709365,
0.0002018818,
-0.0090604126,
0.0338735282,
-0.0530230887,
-0.0613485277,
0.0050012679,
-0.0107262321,
0.0180481337,
-0.0421126857,
0.0526038185,
0.0362291262,
-0.0020032942,
0.0360568054,
-0.053887777,
-0.0145531148,
-0.0682089925,
-0.0107275043,
-0.037406452,
0.0232696719,
0.0158421788,
-0.0031471609,
-0.0066000074,
-0.033733353,
0.0156423356,
-0.0040662941,
0.0506810397,
-0.0179551039,
-0.0607385412,
-0.0679151714,
0.0096423011,
-0.0215364806,
0.0516288728,
-0.0040734489,
-0.03104995,
-0.007284693,
0.0379055329,
0.0298501123,
0.0154485209,
0.0535512418,
0.055153951,
0.0040228292,
0.028373735,
0.016442664,
0.0457196236,
0.0105377929,
0.065854542,
0.0042293342,
-0.0427763946,
-0.0183524564,
0.0411665328,
0.0167763773,
0.0289057326,
-0.0237391312,
-0.0641816333,
0.0091565121,
-0.0485418029,
0.0220976193,
-0.0484053008,
-0.0195551403,
-0.0137237776,
-0.0402804017,
-0.0362633206,
0.0063723256,
0.0664474666,
0.0477120206,
0.0786520243,
0.0024072251,
-0.0042591835,
-0.006594528,
-0.0083169006,
0.0233050641,
-0.0781537294,
-0.0021613222,
0.0553490818,
0.0253201332,
-0.0134632513,
0.0033474686,
0.0419045277,
-0.1106531695,
0.0031811742,
-0.0025777002,
-0.0201244168,
-0.0129014309,
-0.0140394559,
-0.029689705,
-0.0126259448,
-0.0733968616,
0.0276290048,
-0.0204888508,
0.0185972489,
0.0659787282,
-0.0931221694,
-0.0637092292,
-0.0403096564,
-0.0648371801,
0.0406816676,
0.0601655319,
0.0283955093,
-0.0286729075,
-0.0125347525,
0.0448254123,
0.0098853856,
-0.0371276401,
-0.0255000535,
-0.006429384,
0.0050245239,
-0.0040687108,
-0.0216700491,
0.0011572706,
0.0067770807,
-0.026184367,
0.0222521182,
0.049002517,
-0.021046279,
0.0535836667,
0.0069082077,
0.017500313,
0.0019629295,
0.0145621952,
-0.0101637645,
0.0261491314,
-0.0215140749,
0.0192124378,
-0.002196755,
-0.0238516945,
-0.0084134722,
0.0372253135,
-0.087094903,
-0.0671560839,
-0.0947418511,
-0.0216269009,
0.0555850826,
0.0346196778,
0.0163957532,
0.0574076623,
0.0120971622,
0.0401472338,
-0.0249747951,
-0.0143361911,
0.0029127556,
0.0055256588,
-0.0558004528,
-0.0276765078,
0.0307168793,
-0.0375894159,
0.0051901937,
0.0338035822,
0.0465920009,
-0.0321819484,
0.080823794,
-0.0031609188,
0.0262455586,
-0.002591535,
-0.0111654028,
-0.0344252177,
-0.0117910029,
-0.0012476027,
-0.0110212388,
0.0029410785,
0.0167476609,
0.0155268461,
-0.0155323306,
-0.0092166113,
0.0258054212,
0.0278103203,
-0.0188119821,
-0.0365254693,
-0.0057077901,
-0.0057348879,
-0.0142492559,
0.0179534927,
0.0528162569,
-0.0460957289,
-0.0086384472,
-0.0516776256,
0.0056669302,
-0.0286784377,
-0.0190731902,
-0.004227737,
0.008674955,
0.0192032512,
0.0139686102,
-0.0285781547,
0.0039349748,
-0.0496961959,
-0.0102914665,
0.0268043242,
0.0516734384,
-0.0014422596,
0.028587386,
-0.0276740808,
-0.0098656844,
0.0173425209,
0.0136468988,
-0.0179747231,
0.0025668058,
-0.0342509262,
-0.0310424119,
-0.0201697983,
0.0076015908,
0.0109431017,
0.0263045598,
0.0394632295,
0.0531577505,
-0.031342335,
0.0290683545,
0.0340059102,
-0.0163259935,
0.0557797477,
-0.0197700188,
-0.0094657,
0.0172558613,
0.073308073,
-0.0073780757,
-0.0284219272,
-0.0366674587,
-0.039977558,
-0.059983559,
-0.0054721925,
0.0172973126,
0.0111901443,
0.0087360535,
0.031797979,
-0.0544931255,
-0.0010162781,
-0.009774209,
-0.021729555,
-0.0166110154,
-0.0410385355,
-0.0075875856,
-0.0833010599,
-0.0103919823,
-0.0620036647,
0.0422941335,
-0.0083788345,
-0.0115572419,
0.0657749772,
-0.0067006489,
0.0297491364,
0.0310121011,
-0.0328127444,
-0.0043035732,
-0.0103327893,
-0.0272281338,
0.0110980924,
-5.38408151e-33,
-0.0397817753,
-0.0104669724,
0.0056283423,
-0.005960458,
-0.0151674738,
-0.0575263798,
0.0155969802,
-0.0035456773,
0.006512085,
-0.0173425768,
-0.018434681,
-0.020234447,
0.0409272052,
-0.0188805945,
0.0230271928,
0.0174595211,
0.0604272,
0.0000862215,
0.0110347345,
-0.0234510228,
0.1001475379,
0.0293471348,
0.0975470468,
-0.0510404296,
-0.0023061321,
-0.0359568819,
-0.0521489121,
0.0279101226,
0.0400170907,
0.0149825355,
0.0033791238,
0.0187643282,
-0.0161265191,
-0.0118827261,
-0.0087899938,
0.0114948358,
-0.0966262147,
0.0048315297,
0.0351322256,
0.0486132205,
0.0304062609,
0.0065828781,
-0.0112223281,
-0.0166122392,
-0.0079842061,
0.0862186253,
0.0125531452,
-0.0371749215,
0.0055643911,
-0.0226595998,
-0.11946702,
0.0503395125,
0.0066873622,
0.001140731,
0.0922973976,
0.01418838,
0.0045934482,
-0.0468265675,
-0.0520291626,
0.0045998329,
-0.0009525068,
0.0714189783,
0.0680214092,
-0.0168201141,
-0.0350069962,
0.0109290183,
0.0074440585,
-0.0604713671,
0.0352665335,
0.0269393586,
0.0159224793,
0.0220297351,
0.0330321155,
0.0210677516,
0.0613646954,
-0.0960655734,
-0.0419853218,
0.0326734409,
0.0432099067,
0.0361601338,
-0.0350435749,
0.0063194525,
-0.0536571965,
-0.0319730043,
0.047708258,
-0.0358568728,
-0.0134709328,
-0.0219127648,
0.0045814859,
0.0036097588,
-0.0186413322,
0.0196094923,
0.0217961594,
0.0112985764,
0.0398139693,
-0.0497362055,
-0.0233517531,
0.0342082717,
-0.0522597842,
0.0153879803,
-0.0399903618,
-0.1068421602,
0.0307555497,
-0.0265052896,
0.0255350303,
-0.0121618714,
0.0171353482,
0.0192021634,
-0.0463738702,
0.0368770137,
-0.0120807672,
0.0861316547,
-0.0242280997,
0.0314790905,
0.0065258755,
0.0134712104,
-0.0010443376,
-0.0144169498,
0.0500180162,
0.0025669623,
0.0060215993,
-0.0065481137,
0.0144720189,
-0.0394522026,
-0.0198931415,
0.060552571,
0.0124508478,
0.0158668924,
0.0296809934,
0.0140677849,
0.0034849474,
0.018406067,
2.633e-7,
0.0454272255,
0.0542345569,
0.0229713265,
-0.0354681537,
0.014913152,
-0.010018318,
-0.005758536,
0.0131095825,
-0.0118413903,
0.0449875668,
0.0139837675,
-0.082885921,
0.0505239964,
0.0387368761,
-0.091434218,
-0.0317938253,
0.0189345758,
-0.02237821,
-0.0473582931,
0.0280623063,
0.0332032181,
0.0694282427,
0.0200425871,
-0.0113349129,
-0.0469602793,
0.0218143407,
0.0066875732,
-0.0077270772,
-0.0277942941,
-0.002916489,
0.0565917343,
0.0189481974,
0.015556871,
-0.007213877,
-0.0653202385,
0.0339662805,
0.0150751909,
0.0178142469,
-0.0172682852,
0.0355694965,
0.0398960747,
-0.0368499085,
-0.0206559282,
-0.0302452836,
0.0669071004,
0.0275653917,
-0.0392591991,
-0.0323376879,
0.001765765,
0.0376060493,
-0.0429981761,
-0.007390745,
-0.0207325537,
0.0220117066,
0.0405744426,
-0.0278246608,
-0.0524231307,
-0.0150651326,
-0.0058853547,
-0.0052655865,
0.0019015217,
-0.0499910526,
0.0362336002,
0.0422652848,
0.0004519139,
0.0123264501,
-0.0270329081,
2.358708164e-34,
0.0237391554,
-0.0090465229,
-0.0293976106,
0.0086233988,
0.037441127,
-0.0133191282,
-0.0069722249,
0.0665161088,
-0.0125074433,
-0.0083056418,
-0.021687882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12699v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12699v1 | KG-BERTScore: Incorporating Knowledge Graph into BERTScore for Reference-Free Machine Translation Evaluation | 2023-01-30T07:12:15 | 2023-01-30T07:12:15 | Zhanglin Wu, Min Zhang, Ming Zhu, Yinglu Li, Ting Zhu, Hao Yang, Song Peng, Ying Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | BERTScore is an effective and robust automatic metric for referencebased
machine translation evaluation. In this paper, we incorporate multilingual
knowledge graph into BERTScore and propose a metric named KG-BERTScore, which
linearly combines the results of BERTScore and bilingual named entity matching
for reference-free machine translation evaluation. From the experimental
results on WMT19 QE as a metric without references shared tasks, our metric
KG-BERTScore gets higher overall correlation with human judgements than the
current state-of-the-art metrics for reference-free machine translation
evaluation.1 Moreover, the pre-trained multilingual model used by KG-BERTScore
and the parameter for linear combination are also studied in this paper. | [
0.0226706192,
-0.0019761994,
0.0237293206,
0.03642096,
-0.0291520227,
0.0292184334,
-0.0247160345,
0.0532083064,
0.0241346993,
-0.0297900978,
-0.0612531416,
-0.0082810055,
0.0263526235,
-0.056444414,
0.0249654017,
-0.029277835,
0.0196641274,
0.0415157862,
-0.0191334113,
0.0049992534,
0.0011605871,
0.0220709238,
-0.0174813196,
0.0238561351,
0.0113919415,
0.0199056547,
0.0655716211,
0.0573171228,
0.0676129758,
0.0024659529,
0.0062290044,
0.0253365934,
-0.0379418209,
0.0652057752,
0.000001689,
-0.0767975748,
-0.0473786592,
0.019419387,
0.0313495845,
-0.0042673685,
-0.0260251369,
-0.0113018351,
-0.0099775577,
0.020258544,
-0.0220073685,
-0.0122732278,
0.0493027866,
0.033517126,
0.0543794259,
0.0794125274,
-0.0129179005,
-0.0181841608,
0.0073635881,
-0.018757239,
-0.0038617162,
-0.0687166676,
-0.0168870836,
0.0148763005,
-0.038222909,
-0.0048140953,
0.0048995623,
0.0364907011,
-0.0300287902,
-0.0137699367,
0.0237289537,
-0.0266806837,
-0.068290703,
-0.0044035343,
0.0262319744,
0.0972253755,
-0.0234182831,
-0.0186136365,
0.0205064826,
0.0087002115,
-0.0078504775,
0.0136559987,
-0.0227062441,
-0.0357269123,
-0.0213156156,
-0.0010368568,
-0.0158546027,
0.0160954613,
0.0459729321,
-0.0254636724,
-0.0079409806,
0.0287243817,
0.0640945807,
-0.0477775261,
0.0190587677,
0.0303417351,
-0.0259401165,
-0.0524188653,
0.0445468538,
0.0022247368,
-0.0152242044,
-0.0060949922,
-0.0409746803,
-0.042531658,
0.0045845821,
-0.0982710123,
-0.0027490284,
0.0558615588,
-0.00526061,
0.0504889935,
-0.0675313994,
0.1077657416,
-0.0157407895,
-0.0189917125,
-0.0655991361,
-0.0647190809,
-0.0722016543,
0.0637223348,
-0.0429159142,
-0.0138176745,
-0.0293086339,
-0.0141839543,
-0.0509818681,
0.0073353895,
0.0045637679,
0.0324953943,
0.0625264123,
-0.0331439786,
0.001577594,
0.0042051733,
-0.0441292301,
0.061926268,
-0.0233380254,
-0.042264197,
-0.0500216186,
-0.0048160935,
-0.0043063071,
0.0198338833,
0.026952019,
-0.0672020093,
0.0180227533,
0.0775301009,
-0.0007382677,
-0.0185978003,
-0.0102940127,
0.0088693025,
-0.0064907833,
-0.0499713719,
0.0213893112,
-0.0599726252,
0.0693555251,
0.0112818526,
0.0185387824,
-0.0077162646,
0.0105109578,
-0.0042043114,
-0.0555979945,
0.0375260636,
-0.0105951894,
-0.0149818109,
0.0131877121,
-0.0111106867,
-0.0211298466,
0.0550690517,
0.051075656,
-0.0289257038,
0.0480149239,
0.0186197404,
-0.0490071289,
0.0504828654,
0.0123121114,
0.0403717086,
-0.0152875083,
0.0294229519,
0.0021674822,
0.0283876229,
0.0371233486,
0.0529450253,
-0.0325867087,
0.0017669381,
0.0161333382,
0.032886941,
0.0243925806,
0.0176130179,
0.0433567613,
0.0105505232,
0.0158733875,
0.0137329558,
-0.0060425522,
0.0251446795,
-0.0179598387,
-0.0014305486,
0.0633399785,
0.0105364854,
-0.0097313467,
0.0039375164,
0.0027638867,
-0.028558543,
0.0159588847,
-0.0293734949,
0.006428041,
0.0153415687,
-0.0748468488,
0.0888686404,
-0.0077060447,
-0.0641732141,
0.0227427669,
-0.0199045315,
-0.0380655229,
0.0649094582,
0.0501870923,
0.0182338245,
-0.0686982572,
-0.0034874068,
-0.0362315662,
0.0462842435,
0.0492780432,
0.0108171515,
0.0134934578,
-0.0593195781,
-0.0702831224,
-0.002496463,
0.0042989491,
0.026234135,
0.0317699164,
0.0495269559,
0.0410278998,
-0.1043079272,
-0.0520236529,
0.0088482937,
0.0199047141,
-0.0111889346,
0.0106464932,
0.0357140191,
0.0143757062,
0.0395155996,
-0.0180092808,
0.0186288264,
-0.0001573095,
-0.0229449254,
-0.0257504638,
0.0331268683,
0.0059629302,
-0.060592372,
0.0160596296,
-0.0561539605,
-0.0188134871,
-0.0036547286,
-0.0199907906,
-0.0773450136,
-0.0336327851,
-0.0253578834,
0.0352191962,
-0.00192502,
0.0519142859,
-0.0184153114,
-0.031788826,
-0.0188288949,
0.0454347581,
0.0112084728,
0.0459803455,
0.0169546697,
-0.0040755216,
0.0736389309,
-0.0051082112,
-0.0424149893,
-0.0058954065,
0.041401118,
0.0405747816,
0.0601872988,
0.0190948118,
-0.0245377459,
-0.0483463556,
-0.0805416033,
0.0369613245,
-0.024579959,
0.0498289056,
0.0379275158,
0.0407909825,
0.0098670395,
-0.0144871799,
0.0050567039,
-0.0040407837,
0.0224344395,
0.0170361549,
0.0198598132,
-0.0139123667,
0.0266181994,
-0.0278649777,
-0.005186527,
-0.0024833535,
0.0647021309,
0.0265744887,
-0.0018913987,
-0.0413362645,
0.0178161245,
-0.080237858,
0.005433362,
0.0131012667,
-0.0513020419,
0.0137959812,
0.0434864499,
0.0560486689,
0.0188008714,
-0.0061969729,
-0.043716684,
0.0193287265,
-0.0182867553,
-0.0451237075,
0.0090632373,
0.0107419537,
-0.0289020315,
-0.0095982747,
-0.0505319312,
0.0354819708,
0.0170882531,
-0.000165023,
-0.0212367959,
-0.0755118504,
-0.0328033939,
0.0005599904,
0.0035832752,
-0.0085142674,
0.0024302064,
0.0163787324,
-0.0151473107,
-0.033140298,
-0.0000381841,
0.0750354901,
-0.0691252723,
0.0135002052,
-0.0447473228,
0.0289090835,
-0.0269860197,
0.0153484503,
-0.0167152956,
0.0252576955,
-0.0594411939,
-0.0141975032,
-0.0111911828,
0.0112710809,
0.0271172747,
-0.0206193123,
0.0232143514,
-0.0255448278,
0.0165268313,
-0.009227721,
0.0122802071,
-0.0276455749,
0.0665820837,
-0.0147899846,
0.0228840727,
0.0320001654,
-0.0314178728,
-0.0377520584,
0.0374449566,
0.0554409139,
0.0479232259,
0.0100655314,
0.0009621341,
-0.0114991339,
0.0306519475,
0.0144021548,
-0.02449283,
0.0103065632,
-0.0129927862,
-0.0270722844,
-0.0140598621,
0.0378447399,
-0.0290096924,
0.0149790794,
-0.0154216234,
0.0246470869,
-0.0491583794,
-0.0389105789,
-0.0267678797,
0.0494282916,
0.0093011837,
0.0147641711,
0.1081247702,
0.0148273101,
-0.0156188523,
-0.0426373072,
-0.0261385255,
-0.012592216,
0.0287810024,
0.0199271254,
-0.0684670433,
-0.0100702178,
-0.0202014931,
0.0050233146,
0.0327295773,
-0.0388913713,
-0.0214615483,
-0.075326331,
-0.035109017,
0.0249045603,
-0.033765804,
-0.0601995736,
-0.0312677249,
-0.0008968884,
-0.0338986777,
-0.009294739,
-0.0296495929,
0.0272600073,
-0.0046715126,
0.0007687142,
0.0108718183,
-0.0398136973,
0.0238588527,
-0.1143385768,
0.0122547103,
0.072863169,
0.0935644135,
0.0015025162,
-0.0473208688,
-0.0316669643,
-0.0410387516,
-0.0231867936,
0.0087817162,
-0.0040683034,
-0.0128163975,
-0.022349095,
0.0012589067,
-0.0609178506,
0.0030300505,
0.0525063723,
0.0333835073,
0.0372261517,
0.000138589,
0.0113684749,
0.0303359181,
-0.0243056808,
0.0054371129,
0.0580920838,
0.0109378202,
-0.0135549223,
0.0136422571,
0.0030869835,
-0.0067270002,
-0.0774963126,
0.0107067721,
0.0088736527,
-0.0989623144,
-0.0194508582,
-0.1092735529,
-0.0269836932,
0.0006733483,
0.0185607243,
0.0089255273,
0.0243616868,
0.0258549303,
-0.0120838722,
-0.0214934777,
0.0434056483,
-0.0213293284,
0.0103309099,
-0.0658667833,
0.0043579363,
0.0055914093,
0.0115788477,
-0.0070315572,
0.0311371777,
-0.0200420115,
-0.0605241619,
-0.0657561645,
0.0421513133,
0.0164166018,
0.0209742151,
-0.0601628572,
-0.008819879,
0.0304277353,
0.0025556195,
-0.0059730005,
0.0132644819,
0.0300795436,
0.0129425582,
-0.028822232,
0.0427805185,
-0.046321068,
-0.0224782024,
0.0061207102,
0.0761856511,
-0.0065110652,
-0.0647679642,
-0.0054500899,
0.0349264145,
0.0239279121,
-0.0332414731,
-0.0056362813,
-0.0364856757,
0.0023379235,
0.0086315013,
-0.0009710066,
-0.0566082001,
-0.0052086962,
0.0395183302,
-0.0229031779,
-0.0090509728,
0.0341393575,
-0.033074338,
-0.0167745482,
-0.0135800606,
-0.0154746426,
-0.0129811941,
0.0344076827,
0.0270154309,
-0.0128627401,
-0.018842753,
0.0005899923,
0.0223559812,
-0.0176455807,
-0.0336737186,
0.0059449696,
0.0086269723,
0.0086357789,
0.0506478548,
0.0247903597,
-0.0002210612,
0.0247196089,
-0.0282833464,
0.0493254364,
0.104460746,
-0.000076101,
0.152075693,
0.0167611483,
-0.0199537035,
-0.0098059122,
0.0271428283,
0.0019352585,
0.012799724,
0.0008485909,
-0.0007502204,
0.0218059123,
0.0405601822,
0.0709935576,
0.0117064295,
0.03619425,
-0.0149854906,
-0.0385613218,
-0.0133834118,
-0.0237548277,
0.0046610944,
-0.0382625461,
-0.0189902075,
-0.0064223902,
0.0017168748,
-0.0715259686,
0.0496224873,
0.0150327124,
-0.0308563337,
0.0065889782,
0.0201320443,
0.0746880248,
-0.0174049363,
0.0058632283,
-0.0146700535,
-0.0142923677,
0.0015377887,
-0.0166303925,
-0.0268081427,
-5.704936734e-33,
-0.0349709094,
-0.0426028743,
0.0046480801,
-0.0649060011,
-0.0101229521,
-0.0016313378,
-0.0278463084,
-0.046757549,
-0.0140177459,
-0.002855778,
0.008035888,
0.0118960682,
0.0232892074,
-0.0395795368,
-0.0213790257,
0.0007675012,
0.0295223128,
0.0372802056,
-0.0499821901,
0.0186897069,
0.0264619235,
0.013826292,
0.1099999547,
-0.0579740368,
0.0537101515,
-0.0257905908,
0.0036322169,
0.0093107205,
0.0525974482,
0.040707428,
0.0103279166,
0.0133342715,
0.0084131099,
-0.0048941392,
-0.0048734206,
-0.0290168095,
-0.0947623402,
-0.0529141687,
0.0429346003,
0.0242003798,
-0.0035073247,
-0.0189301688,
0.0536510535,
-0.025717346,
-0.0033716448,
0.022503797,
0.025759805,
-0.0336079113,
-0.0059064873,
-0.0463023521,
-0.0213392694,
0.0259675626,
-0.0038014161,
0.0035620078,
0.0036174827,
0.033709351,
-0.0114662405,
-0.0502160415,
-0.0850978717,
-0.0039278846,
-0.0349097885,
0.0187239256,
0.0558273569,
-0.0203975942,
-0.0000910235,
-0.0104861958,
-0.0239697527,
-0.0049599526,
0.0365655683,
-0.019731747,
0.0173808895,
0.0205130111,
0.0479632132,
0.0564535297,
-0.0208155569,
-0.0107532423,
-0.0762929171,
0.0937060267,
-0.0074297795,
0.0149519946,
-0.0310913548,
0.0031270508,
-0.0042439159,
-0.0020698679,
-0.0486707725,
-0.0198548157,
-0.0494181141,
-0.0288237948,
0.0096141817,
-0.0008312343,
-0.0258823987,
0.0061877421,
0.0375793315,
-0.0040579103,
0.0110127525,
0.0272534154,
-0.0222168863,
-0.0042984807,
-0.0094206231,
0.0427212343,
-0.027219465,
-0.0342275351,
0.0445027426,
0.0078837806,
0.0170005523,
-0.0129075777,
0.0315618999,
0.0051751281,
-0.0385070071,
0.0093719587,
-0.035658624,
-0.0319152847,
-0.0445481874,
-0.0200830903,
-0.001746284,
-0.0045644455,
0.019108085,
-0.0005123198,
0.0354955345,
0.0097054886,
0.0016245636,
0.0053813634,
0.0498857088,
0.0584258363,
-0.0487127714,
0.0347820334,
-0.0220887214,
0.0379315875,
0.0066403067,
-0.0477870591,
-0.0224757846,
-0.0187584907,
2.566e-7,
0.0254280791,
0.0369655713,
0.0116787683,
0.0116072353,
-0.0253514647,
0.0057358281,
-0.017486643,
0.0690841451,
0.0060223322,
0.0412099399,
0.0272026844,
-0.012920998,
0.0237987656,
0.0422114283,
-0.0684458464,
-0.0473960638,
-0.0755987242,
-0.0170651563,
-0.0531272665,
0.0173224285,
-0.0024363657,
0.0168864708,
0.0214522127,
0.0242514778,
-0.04740851,
-0.0295445323,
0.0877557918,
0.0007227876,
-0.0272484738,
0.0265056882,
0.0852399841,
0.0112414528,
-0.0236636121,
0.0603885949,
-0.041040089,
0.0449260809,
0.0854283869,
0.0601119399,
0.0011839629,
-0.0157691222,
0.0087059392,
-0.0776602179,
0.0090320529,
-0.0261486098,
0.0619777329,
0.0000217361,
0.0112865437,
0.0658832192,
-0.0398374274,
0.0054087252,
0.040568836,
-0.0153492764,
-0.0656356066,
0.0197679438,
0.0499968156,
0.0173362587,
-0.0063599879,
-0.029906841,
-0.0347531177,
0.0037922014,
0.0264993142,
-0.0473254211,
-0.0020483248,
-0.0352798514,
0.0025975602,
-0.0325027481,
0.0373146646,
2.243247298e-34,
0.0146477176,
-0.0083869277,
0.0001799711,
-0.0773285478,
0.0612460561,
-0.0388586707,
-0.0366259441,
-0.0036207719,
-0.0196736325,
-0.0347091332,
-0.0151955718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12660v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12660v2 | Zero-shot Clarifying Question Generation for Conversational Search | 2023-01-30T04:43:02 | 2023-02-10T17:05:21 | Zhenduo Wang, Yuancheng Tu, Corby Rosset, Nick Craswell, Ming Wu, Qingyao Ai | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | A long-standing challenge for search and conversational assistants is query
intention detection in ambiguous queries. Asking clarifying questions in
conversational search has been widely studied and considered an effective
solution to resolve query ambiguity. Existing work have explored various
approaches for clarifying question ranking and generation. However, due to the
lack of real conversational search data, they have to use artificial datasets
for training, which limits their generalizability to real-world search
scenarios. As a result, the industry has shown reluctance to implement them in
reality, further suspending the availability of real conversational search
interaction data. The above dilemma can be formulated as a cold start problem
of clarifying question generation and conversational search in general.
Furthermore, even if we do have large-scale conversational logs, it is not
realistic to gather training data that can comprehensively cover all possible
queries and topics in open-domain search scenarios. The risk of fitting bias
when training a clarifying question retrieval/generation model on
incomprehensive dataset is thus another important challenge.
In this work, we innovatively explore generating clarifying questions in a
zero-shot setting to overcome the cold start problem and we propose a
constrained clarifying question generation system which uses both question
templates and query facets to guide the effective and precise question
generation. The experiment results show that our method outperforms existing
state-of-the-art zero-shot baselines by a large margin. Human annotations to
our model outputs also indicate our method generates 25.2\% more natural
questions, 18.1\% more useful questions, 6.1\% less unnatural and 4\% less
useless questions. | [
0.0590247512,
0.0140044438,
-0.0156818796,
0.0158854481,
0.0035094779,
-0.0041138567,
0.0158343837,
0.0187583975,
-0.0117552131,
-0.0358697362,
0.009084045,
-0.0537787825,
-0.0438810438,
0.0316892266,
0.0349295177,
-0.0513434149,
0.0307674855,
0.0264304411,
-0.0193210132,
0.0414011814,
0.0428348631,
0.0009991444,
-0.0051117321,
0.0298031643,
-0.0068441108,
0.0009940325,
-0.0719068646,
0.0551677011,
-0.0152758174,
-0.0256679133,
0.0287960153,
0.0482634194,
0.0384965129,
0.0477219224,
0.0000017006,
-0.0471096076,
-0.0238421001,
-0.0192076955,
-0.0470357276,
-0.0528581366,
0.0119314725,
0.0159959644,
0.0431552902,
0.0595353134,
-0.0562128872,
0.0083618602,
0.0362552404,
0.0260953605,
0.0556348637,
0.0761741996,
-0.0085671386,
-0.0250394735,
-0.0239832569,
-0.0155364797,
0.0929543301,
-0.0412936397,
-0.0179410838,
0.0026378331,
0.0165224299,
0.0270395167,
0.0185467321,
0.0166519172,
0.0172222275,
-0.0390462279,
0.0300862715,
0.026078349,
-0.0582403205,
-0.0587666444,
0.002303137,
0.1130712107,
0.0018966949,
-0.0265982095,
0.0123641249,
-0.0133244516,
0.0172116775,
-0.0082690781,
-0.0522391461,
0.0062813503,
0.0005701393,
-0.0442262813,
-0.0294192899,
0.0135749048,
0.006465029,
0.0279279817,
-0.0164119955,
0.0408461988,
0.0111725833,
-0.0460757986,
-0.0187458694,
-0.0087140491,
-0.0122824516,
-0.0646600649,
-0.0053281309,
0.0520457625,
-0.069415018,
0.0355696194,
-0.028980244,
-0.0188051779,
0.0218028165,
0.0137904324,
-0.0193841532,
0.0380002968,
0.007127949,
0.0350059532,
0.014606053,
0.0293431617,
0.0230205096,
-0.0019354564,
-0.0796154514,
-0.0158620216,
-0.0251747109,
-0.0288292877,
-0.0644097105,
0.0151756033,
-0.0487339944,
-0.0174418967,
-0.0238226112,
0.0534388609,
0.0538654588,
-0.0150387008,
-0.0104378443,
0.053499449,
-0.0697670951,
-0.0000344948,
-0.0136906076,
0.0089155911,
-0.065107882,
0.0257112533,
0.0610425957,
-0.0786331668,
-0.0247656964,
0.0586328842,
0.0555400737,
-0.0028984584,
-0.0188015718,
-0.013904403,
-0.015948927,
-0.0454187021,
-0.0150589813,
-0.080925338,
0.0128336297,
-0.0207305942,
-0.0022708257,
0.0036095968,
0.0446504168,
-0.0023918911,
-0.0282297004,
0.0311098099,
0.0109773083,
0.0574607179,
0.0159211662,
0.0496726893,
-0.0285852924,
0.0183146466,
0.0454764292,
0.0240745917,
-0.0069050309,
0.0664267242,
0.0148369335,
0.0494105332,
0.0519610494,
0.031900607,
0.0302985236,
-0.0226474572,
0.0375426039,
0.0095117968,
0.0018442601,
0.0503402315,
-0.0492275842,
0.0482905209,
0.0002952262,
0.0433909707,
-0.0472027436,
0.010591873,
0.0297664218,
0.0085096415,
0.005991986,
-0.0190239437,
0.0581098795,
0.0498968475,
-0.038553752,
0.010417847,
-0.0267567262,
0.0313369334,
-0.024717221,
-0.0020783346,
0.0282253455,
-0.0365624689,
-0.0553495437,
-0.0102070505,
0.0308193713,
0.0434184149,
-0.0253820624,
0.0162170418,
-0.0145437773,
0.0302697252,
-0.0482936166,
0.0382748097,
-0.0273233503,
-0.0614623018,
0.0128337238,
-0.018324621,
0.0545563623,
0.0181700643,
0.0721850246,
-0.0300890058,
-0.0851107165,
-0.004307861,
0.0193954725,
0.0371914767,
0.023994131,
-0.0149191115,
0.040290162,
-0.0765952393,
-0.0243470874,
-0.0056135533,
0.0150523586,
-0.023626687,
0.0066119386,
0.0055948175,
0.0772165805,
-0.0628474206,
0.0106529184,
0.0294730142,
-0.0113342339,
-0.0282431711,
0.0429083519,
0.0030605637,
-0.0280404426,
0.032923907,
0.0147141768,
0.0176455341,
0.0211539045,
0.0109441141,
-0.0359391309,
0.0234864578,
-0.0479937941,
-0.0347277112,
-0.0140073542,
-0.035477031,
0.0131213572,
-0.0050411476,
-0.0431305133,
-0.0634266287,
-0.0148458201,
-0.0280771535,
0.027608797,
-0.0674997047,
-0.0109257074,
0.0275750477,
-0.0016235231,
-0.0541853718,
0.0420369878,
0.0177095458,
-0.0028502624,
0.0141658187,
-0.0032091269,
0.0226716343,
-0.0717080012,
-0.0041496698,
-0.0102930535,
-0.0397822671,
-0.0087862862,
0.0353794768,
0.0292254426,
-0.0999431983,
0.0036399853,
-0.1165764257,
0.0493958741,
-0.0499203876,
-0.0015040721,
0.0479750782,
0.0578855053,
-0.0108620021,
-0.0262847859,
-0.1003447846,
0.0031926082,
0.0245183408,
0.0026422408,
0.0586930141,
0.0350032859,
0.0165774934,
-0.0286454353,
0.0170535967,
-0.0029532679,
-0.0052494514,
0.0350826755,
0.0232106335,
-0.0382731855,
0.0580016263,
-0.0580385961,
-0.0091296462,
-0.0016123581,
-0.0096103465,
0.0286948066,
-0.03650387,
-0.0071519483,
0.041247949,
0.0273130145,
0.0002382079,
-0.0090801679,
0.0188177321,
-0.0410466939,
0.032335829,
-0.0405991636,
0.0213485863,
0.0174827948,
-0.0370907001,
0.0197467301,
-0.0071812072,
-0.0089643011,
0.0089177052,
-0.0572020188,
0.0411033221,
0.0035418577,
-0.0249735769,
-0.0752146468,
0.0326574333,
-0.0012088744,
0.0633896589,
-0.0201357529,
-0.0224417206,
0.0437096879,
0.0098542757,
-0.028189851,
-0.0563442744,
0.0275542215,
-0.0404042639,
0.0493500084,
-0.0058534867,
0.0177764334,
0.0412183478,
-0.0368002616,
-0.0791960508,
-0.004933049,
0.0395077951,
-0.0269951895,
0.0091231987,
-0.049021244,
0.0026657442,
0.0003214502,
-0.0271012876,
-0.0576045401,
-0.0707970411,
0.0101025766,
0.0072769681,
0.0063480427,
-0.0186209306,
-0.0326194279,
0.0050717322,
0.0051852376,
0.0424676538,
-0.0330774114,
-0.0425445996,
-0.0188674703,
0.0724788532,
0.0861661434,
0.0331320986,
0.0141487001,
-0.0175178517,
0.0373570137,
0.0247500204,
0.0433507599,
0.0048374501,
0.0083406884,
-0.0174822584,
0.0110831577,
-0.0142018907,
-0.0006372434,
0.0194314159,
0.0686345324,
0.0018840169,
-0.049994532,
0.1086288169,
0.0727012455,
-0.0392948538,
-0.0108978897,
-0.0189981889,
0.0577468984,
0.0223309118,
0.0359942392,
-0.0821216851,
-0.0500970222,
0.0016751944,
0.0558992699,
-0.0409432352,
-0.0392187573,
-0.036057774,
-0.1124944985,
0.0175551102,
-0.0290843602,
-0.0382843688,
0.0349847823,
-0.0120230298,
-0.0142209046,
-0.011897915,
0.012717844,
0.013324541,
-0.0028081413,
0.0209310595,
0.011863308,
0.0213145539,
-0.0609241873,
-0.0078622745,
-0.0310074817,
0.0143201714,
0.0560232177,
0.0297876447,
0.0384836607,
0.0257411767,
0.0165352263,
-0.0256125014,
0.0044341423,
-0.0133823603,
0.037387155,
-0.0170187093,
-0.0021956896,
-0.0398077443,
0.0405292138,
-0.0278015714,
0.0324087329,
0.0109061114,
0.0014334756,
-0.0402653776,
0.0229158346,
-0.0297718886,
0.014579216,
0.0101873092,
0.0732476562,
0.0402758345,
0.012020017,
-0.0181213003,
-0.0197080392,
0.0375537761,
-0.0540286936,
0.0152704548,
-0.0100370878,
0.0059477221,
0.0233240444,
-0.0793404356,
-0.0678219497,
0.0209870934,
0.0552444309,
-0.0134530524,
-0.0216165539,
-0.0071089356,
0.005002914,
-0.0169765353,
-0.0022687318,
-0.0119485464,
-0.0103668487,
-0.0291449372,
0.0002863004,
0.0301236268,
-0.0375092924,
-0.0080127642,
0.0112095932,
-0.0667465553,
-0.0373644084,
-0.0290348642,
0.0474056341,
0.0290025175,
0.0214369148,
-0.0377000421,
-0.0445794389,
-0.0107767982,
0.0628300607,
-0.0077945935,
-0.0317477211,
-0.0207297411,
0.0165094789,
-0.0017188495,
0.0517570265,
-0.0649623722,
-0.0197788198,
-0.0337554105,
0.0528500974,
-0.0537155643,
-0.0490616709,
0.0520701297,
0.0325527526,
0.0025505861,
0.0072248052,
0.0391943865,
-0.0072014113,
0.0342904106,
-0.0477042012,
-0.0288335979,
-0.0425032638,
0.0199575536,
-0.0016272587,
-0.0094926152,
0.0048712906,
0.0258039925,
-0.0967911482,
0.0547316447,
-0.0465049185,
-0.0481461473,
-0.0024333587,
0.0032047175,
0.0050848536,
-0.0255647879,
-0.0125915539,
0.0498915575,
0.0144729251,
0.0617234148,
-0.0008775941,
0.0797217339,
0.0177266952,
0.0028576679,
-0.0151140746,
0.0499490835,
-0.080278717,
-0.0511599854,
-0.0178159121,
-0.0015196727,
0.0107778655,
-0.0196294375,
0.0014358766,
-0.00905859,
0.0177098867,
0.0066621723,
0.0546054691,
0.0144073498,
-0.0529433861,
0.0363412052,
0.0385301821,
-0.0112501588,
0.0028256979,
0.0491744094,
-0.0109027978,
0.0307117403,
0.0058195097,
-0.0151136834,
-0.0427759811,
-0.0000175988,
0.0566373877,
0.0411243252,
0.0044854502,
0.0259072594,
-0.0612457879,
-0.0269166846,
-0.0085351374,
-0.0440383852,
0.0223528259,
-0.008946076,
0.0771658719,
0.0796154365,
-0.0316657424,
-0.0217782557,
-0.0390070751,
0.0009805426,
-0.0716717169,
-0.026172515,
-0.0421857499,
-6.162589011e-33,
0.0112299761,
-0.0197489783,
0.0303472802,
-0.0596881546,
-0.0450107083,
-0.0064256936,
-0.0532833636,
-0.0062655164,
-0.0399450772,
-0.018803155,
-0.0263404492,
0.0457614399,
0.0095978649,
0.0219552852,
-0.0342129655,
-0.0510574877,
0.0409291908,
-0.0152554577,
-0.0281401426,
0.0551355295,
0.0453579463,
0.026535878,
-0.0337993577,
-0.0061159632,
0.011481761,
-0.0491429828,
-0.0293515716,
0.0751742572,
0.0151201785,
0.0355883911,
-0.009918265,
0.0105520207,
0.0415522233,
-0.0071242205,
0.019510068,
0.006356271,
-0.0020712214,
-0.0424271971,
-0.0001209004,
-0.0202823356,
-0.0529471599,
-0.0005036892,
0.0249597635,
-0.0402545109,
0.0294383317,
0.0310353246,
0.0129281459,
0.0319926701,
-0.0322121792,
-0.0343553796,
-0.0183832571,
-0.0012899337,
-0.0268397909,
-0.0691528246,
-0.0227700379,
0.1154681295,
0.0215306971,
0.0092159361,
0.0141116055,
0.0315204188,
0.0069093476,
0.021629557,
0.0368402749,
0.0319972113,
-0.0271726083,
0.0169704948,
0.016263729,
0.0139713157,
-0.011849056,
-0.0141655989,
-0.0066247759,
0.0412964262,
0.0125474911,
0.0603638738,
0.0336907655,
0.0265330821,
-0.0319460183,
0.0575925633,
-0.0094194477,
0.0278929211,
-0.0302547943,
-0.008532308,
-0.0399057157,
-0.0101694185,
-0.0348660462,
-0.0002621336,
-0.0650494844,
0.0014995794,
0.054007899,
0.0293668285,
-0.0447153598,
-0.024649702,
0.0216333959,
0.0005917008,
0.0475717634,
0.0061552096,
-0.0369111486,
-0.0075208801,
0.0119024785,
0.0083888834,
-0.0391717665,
0.0043802713,
0.0607443042,
0.0222923737,
-0.0232081413,
0.0430962667,
-0.0048999437,
0.0070381947,
0.0084402151,
-0.0207692105,
-0.0247095637,
0.0164184198,
-0.0627700537,
0.0024956614,
0.0018173376,
0.0524829403,
-0.0357642062,
0.0440022349,
0.03303691,
0.0301287863,
-0.0281848758,
-0.0450252853,
0.0004745029,
0.0260509867,
-0.0267309342,
-0.0023801599,
0.009157679,
-0.0168117769,
0.0171553046,
-0.0583348162,
-0.0182572547,
-0.0133356359,
2.499e-7,
0.0131662227,
0.0244947225,
0.0102997152,
0.0632965416,
-0.0050207507,
0.0479145609,
0.0306978505,
0.0410913005,
0.0128516182,
-0.0341733769,
0.0448973961,
-0.0164972357,
0.0128859524,
-0.0128161497,
-0.0968473628,
-0.0267763771,
-0.03462198,
-0.0195318088,
-0.032472901,
-0.0145759648,
0.0941237882,
0.0896948278,
-0.0224919561,
0.0033008209,
0.0208503548,
-0.0274856426,
0.0287559088,
0.0375102982,
-0.0165587012,
0.0239513256,
0.0435455665,
0.026425723,
0.0058927834,
-0.008681979,
-0.0326241069,
0.0059455899,
0.0115225594,
0.0184958056,
-0.008516483,
-0.0443150401,
-0.0102667883,
-0.0000543478,
0.0291916505,
-0.0803383291,
0.0677820146,
-0.0301777702,
-0.000245648,
0.0191680267,
-0.0412076786,
0.0205614492,
0.0169760194,
-0.0284383185,
-0.0420449264,
-0.0019154653,
0.0172079597,
0.0113229947,
0.0144445244,
-0.058113955,
-0.0019139204,
-0.0526332781,
-0.0289894976,
-0.0262962729,
-0.0518680103,
-0.0077008284,
-0.0188446548,
-0.0196288489,
-0.0022390024,
2.052577981e-34,
0.0390391164,
0.0221195109,
-0.0005936773,
0.0035762384,
0.0226878915,
0.0015048155,
-0.0137931881,
-0.0087959329,
0.0449224301,
-0.0765404254,
-0.002541618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12652v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12652v4 | REPLUG: Retrieval-Augmented Black-Box Language Models | 2023-01-30T04:18:09 | 2023-05-24T05:08:07 | Weijia Shi, Sewon Min, Michihiro Yasunaga, Minjoon Seo, Rich James, Mike Lewis, Luke Zettlemoyer, Wen-tau Yih | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce REPLUG, a retrieval-augmented language modeling framework that
treats the language model (LM) as a black box and augments it with a tuneable
retrieval model. Unlike prior retrieval-augmented LMs that train language
models with special cross attention mechanisms to encode the retrieved text,
REPLUG simply prepends retrieved documents to the input for the frozen
black-box LM. This simple design can be easily applied to any existing
retrieval and language models. Furthermore, we show that the LM can be used to
supervise the retrieval model, which can then find documents that help the LM
make better predictions. Our experiments demonstrate that REPLUG with the tuned
retriever significantly improves the performance of GPT-3 (175B) on language
modeling by 6.3%, as well as the performance of Codex on five-shot MMLU by
5.1%. | [
0.0524697341,
0.0321255736,
0.0149799716,
0.0344379395,
-0.0121969152,
-0.0090206908,
-0.0005360131,
0.023497019,
0.0023414833,
-0.0506957732,
-0.0538828224,
-0.0244545005,
-0.0263742171,
0.0375062414,
0.0134631619,
-0.0250900872,
0.0600066744,
0.0101134498,
0.0082644979,
0.0178161673,
0.0042093066,
0.0352738574,
0.0457908921,
0.0385774374,
0.0278474092,
-0.0028034914,
-0.0000617288,
0.0271316413,
-0.0141130919,
-0.023422569,
0.046572227,
0.0440823361,
0.0354302898,
0.065656811,
0.0000020095,
-0.0135440845,
-0.0651563779,
-0.0031041913,
-0.0072575724,
0.0123324841,
0.0486974232,
-0.0322473086,
0.0287439562,
0.0168493073,
-0.0303898808,
-0.0281198192,
0.0112175178,
0.0355629548,
0.0343888849,
0.0934627652,
-0.0031421005,
-0.0213459209,
0.0450480655,
-0.0670673773,
0.0387611538,
-0.0676368549,
0.0112672457,
0.0347218663,
0.0257789511,
0.0667182282,
0.0089864545,
0.0728781298,
0.0219952893,
0.0047395313,
0.0194081776,
0.0306871645,
-0.0440969877,
-0.0048041628,
-0.0022245583,
0.0422385596,
-0.0085681733,
-0.0526389256,
-0.0219658203,
0.0108073233,
0.0035038043,
-0.0143571924,
-0.0684776157,
-0.0213612691,
-0.0088757696,
-0.0096470742,
-0.0012901598,
-0.0353161134,
0.0408079363,
0.0076571405,
0.0041985884,
0.0693125799,
0.0267975666,
-0.0305420384,
-0.0226645581,
0.0014481086,
0.020448206,
-0.0032994582,
0.0327515751,
0.0264679529,
-0.0067999903,
0.0023089475,
-0.023422515,
-0.0527348332,
0.03446519,
-0.0192625429,
0.0522739775,
0.0436820798,
-0.0334678963,
0.0646808147,
-0.0228455942,
0.0308924336,
-0.0386394113,
0.0307535585,
-0.0719908997,
-0.0238225497,
-0.0388610736,
-0.0480201691,
-0.0827742144,
0.012398907,
-0.0070446902,
-0.0103340726,
-0.0151585443,
0.0018588168,
0.0081028361,
-0.0392750204,
-0.0151643855,
0.0124953603,
-0.0701438189,
-0.0409621261,
-0.0018715925,
0.0309737306,
-0.0108813327,
-0.0014354654,
0.0108414274,
-0.0565624051,
-0.0376313925,
-0.0095589329,
0.0065712393,
-0.0537952967,
0.0257642735,
0.0181940589,
-0.0283729099,
-0.0646000728,
0.0022917523,
-0.0217156429,
-0.0096520502,
-0.0515597984,
0.002475349,
-0.0435210466,
0.0232899394,
-0.0171060227,
-0.018274134,
-0.0372348726,
0.0042346832,
0.0323477164,
-0.0273654796,
0.0453302301,
0.0333867185,
-0.0496290326,
0.0475751944,
0.0083372258,
0.0063573085,
0.0626285002,
-0.0172484368,
0.047025267,
0.0293364674,
0.0072977585,
0.0218030289,
0.0361792631,
0.0580935925,
0.0290452428,
-0.0500344671,
0.019004019,
-0.0059743593,
0.007675041,
0.0297962166,
0.0209366158,
-0.0447578877,
-0.0316622332,
0.0356801189,
0.0543603599,
0.0418439694,
0.0025620968,
0.014940599,
-0.0052811224,
-0.0360661894,
-0.0112376474,
-0.0254607182,
0.0593933314,
-0.0493365265,
-0.003441978,
0.0318258218,
0.0222608242,
-0.0282599144,
-0.0414943397,
-0.0007688833,
0.0103928568,
0.006294094,
0.0187328085,
0.057923805,
-0.0062425626,
-0.0452033952,
0.0720970705,
0.017946152,
-0.0462788269,
-0.0005324238,
-0.052224528,
0.0231641568,
0.0631030127,
0.0822080821,
-0.0260984879,
-0.0339619741,
-0.014519657,
-0.0076234965,
0.0360359028,
0.0496941991,
0.034146715,
-0.0099476976,
-0.0698964596,
-0.0321006179,
-0.0214632191,
0.018040631,
0.0561994724,
0.0230370238,
0.0146329589,
0.059324421,
-0.0156883392,
-0.0086290017,
0.029978035,
-0.0240627751,
-0.0506920815,
-0.0230519492,
-0.0339215584,
0.0204051435,
-0.0198099129,
0.0046538166,
0.0219222177,
0.0445020385,
-0.0204299111,
-0.0258547012,
-0.0291781016,
-0.0184738152,
-0.0143120764,
0.0278122127,
0.0061744489,
0.0432413779,
0.0474458113,
-0.0122725805,
-0.0321018137,
0.0429054126,
-0.0077873659,
0.0708357021,
-0.0589669049,
0.0005546793,
-0.0033492974,
0.0185438003,
-0.0613624752,
0.0337021276,
-0.0126041919,
0.02153413,
-0.011341746,
-0.0062852278,
0.018711362,
-0.0525451452,
-0.0096342126,
0.0173698664,
-0.0118029369,
0.0473340526,
0.0545993336,
0.0040136832,
-0.0306195728,
-0.0356713012,
-0.0576849245,
0.0275665633,
-0.0538755842,
-0.0252884962,
0.014460342,
0.0365220532,
-0.009652948,
-0.0333859511,
0.006524581,
-0.0102165323,
0.0152255315,
0.0151686417,
-0.0192616489,
0.0138176512,
0.029056685,
-0.0577371605,
-0.0489073731,
0.0236211997,
0.0429782607,
-0.0239916779,
-0.009714053,
-0.0228769612,
0.0231614206,
-0.0419147089,
0.0308935903,
-0.0453278981,
-0.0417665131,
0.009532528,
-0.0724032968,
-0.0236467086,
0.0886734575,
0.0049974304,
0.0029765214,
0.03779364,
-0.0038522587,
-0.1023473293,
0.0324814618,
-0.019147411,
-0.0562498942,
0.0134939337,
0.0060566682,
0.0125523387,
0.0314416736,
-0.0161843337,
0.0226686224,
-0.0554894172,
0.0095762732,
0.0209899116,
-0.0151786879,
-0.0539323948,
0.0094000008,
-0.0231705885,
0.010495767,
-0.0436452739,
-0.0534856208,
0.0645017028,
-0.0299344175,
-0.0202524625,
-0.0231982395,
0.0001121912,
-0.0449079536,
0.0363758244,
0.0079804724,
-0.0043517873,
-0.0354398862,
0.0026554884,
-0.0290221311,
-0.0258586276,
0.0097963065,
-0.0529324971,
0.0239351653,
0.0234254859,
0.0432268232,
-0.0088977152,
-0.0316744372,
-0.0260990169,
-0.0077497065,
-0.0253799222,
-0.0017542152,
-0.0185083244,
-0.0004365183,
-0.0866823345,
0.0270449072,
0.039487116,
0.058150541,
-0.038265802,
-0.0131775439,
-0.0175052192,
0.0010531202,
0.0743304044,
-0.0444245189,
-0.0372326113,
-0.0283575617,
-0.029291695,
0.0416974463,
0.0260220077,
0.0108119408,
-0.0051802308,
-0.0031207947,
0.0516290516,
0.0054282551,
-0.0384574719,
0.0012957806,
-0.0241698865,
-0.1043233648,
-0.0421933457,
0.081090644,
0.0259088986,
-0.0812690184,
-0.0682110786,
-0.0468247086,
0.0395158306,
0.0232128557,
0.0460680872,
-0.0316639468,
-0.0399255864,
0.0103412857,
0.0433240421,
0.0396545753,
0.0341208577,
-0.0130744958,
-0.1121348366,
0.0288283676,
0.0428502634,
-0.0287066065,
-0.0435865447,
-0.0309276823,
-0.0107946368,
-0.0042736875,
0.0238766,
0.0675468296,
-0.0024872799,
0.0018063221,
0.0121227112,
0.0265969019,
-0.0255286414,
0.0045970031,
0.0005759152,
-0.0120664993,
0.0822491124,
-0.0135273049,
-0.0125555107,
-0.0436954834,
0.0254700556,
0.0013728383,
-0.0057175867,
-0.0078743221,
0.0702832788,
-0.0458478481,
0.0098039312,
0.0003936486,
-0.0102703823,
-0.0132261682,
0.0038815103,
-0.0187476445,
0.0525309891,
-0.0191806108,
0.0067636259,
-0.0393724777,
-0.0179382749,
-0.0098799737,
0.0681533664,
0.0076431432,
-0.0074899811,
-0.0228702798,
-0.035380803,
0.0245240759,
-0.0746016502,
-0.0174871534,
0.0314848833,
-0.007843392,
-0.0170046799,
-0.0365594178,
-0.048107326,
-0.0127115231,
0.0353480056,
-0.0163841881,
0.037752565,
-0.0269215256,
-0.0303436406,
-0.0502921715,
0.062723875,
-0.0437506437,
-0.0093510635,
-0.0604281761,
0.0119227329,
0.0369540974,
-0.0429486334,
-0.024436431,
0.0157334171,
-0.0536798574,
-0.0445793048,
-0.0016790172,
0.0508743711,
0.0246272851,
0.0593420528,
-0.0182159264,
-0.0600854978,
0.0334364139,
0.0236546919,
-0.0360035263,
0.0104482817,
-0.0004511575,
-0.0340418182,
-0.0155869443,
0.0238593798,
-0.0882990435,
0.0181002636,
0.0091786608,
0.0229498651,
-0.0206578504,
-0.0167551581,
0.0139520941,
0.0114878733,
0.0473061278,
0.0141357072,
0.0035351634,
-0.0242671426,
0.0263826307,
-0.0113000404,
-0.0159318745,
-0.0416354313,
0.0189353619,
0.0416985564,
-0.0489241071,
-0.0020868082,
-0.0152182719,
-0.0025655071,
0.045741424,
-0.0777706131,
-0.0081407698,
-0.0009765086,
-0.0113478424,
0.0316164382,
-0.0065189046,
-0.0141202407,
0.0507817417,
-0.020718988,
0.0744796768,
-0.0424031094,
0.0341041982,
0.0257192403,
-0.0116568226,
-0.040915776,
0.0210256185,
-0.089236781,
-0.0310363155,
-0.0306419283,
0.0009571625,
0.0586921051,
-0.0195307955,
0.0533259027,
-0.0162247084,
-0.0420628078,
-0.0207265113,
0.0054186615,
0.0350948945,
-0.0282784272,
0.0164639894,
0.0221778639,
-0.0132860988,
0.029152995,
0.0444118194,
0.0133190295,
0.0285428185,
-0.0137040177,
-0.0229218472,
-0.0237795059,
-0.0059094052,
0.0168232284,
0.0317904577,
0.0036232676,
0.0036533785,
-0.0186964478,
-0.0489916652,
0.0281315912,
0.0008127558,
-0.0583360158,
-0.0143583659,
0.0225819629,
0.0941737518,
-0.0059151035,
-0.0216486044,
-0.034948837,
0.0192578025,
-0.0311699715,
-0.0449168235,
-0.0245102216,
-6.774323985e-33,
-0.0497831814,
-0.0052770427,
0.0107497228,
-0.0306269992,
-0.0252174325,
0.0264025442,
-0.0097862594,
-0.0172018092,
-0.0183842033,
-0.0036628416,
-0.0206561927,
0.0356946476,
0.0093188901,
0.0185365435,
0.0139607918,
0.0097239437,
0.0272411741,
0.0005448527,
-0.0294707119,
0.0123577891,
0.062230207,
0.0870372206,
0.053065896,
-0.0073805703,
0.02073537,
-0.0243429821,
0.0186572913,
0.0081668543,
-0.0123937111,
0.0738497078,
-0.0069978619,
0.0119286207,
0.0149914678,
-0.0185157545,
-0.0161317568,
0.0096088201,
-0.0513961278,
0.0028698847,
-0.0019104084,
-0.0034203585,
-0.0088932803,
-0.0293444581,
0.0575108118,
-0.0213605035,
0.0258437954,
-0.0275350139,
0.0292527918,
-0.0166632421,
-0.0658104792,
-0.0067771515,
-0.0209329315,
0.0228259675,
0.0097371982,
0.0022229627,
0.0402647369,
0.0528919697,
0.0174903926,
0.068792969,
-0.0345438235,
-0.0317461565,
-0.0297638085,
0.0699684396,
0.0411514379,
0.0451856107,
-0.0064131953,
0.0492144786,
-0.0061662071,
-0.0126742749,
-0.0291581284,
-0.0724848732,
0.0614834949,
0.0104844188,
0.0426522903,
0.0390247665,
0.0336911418,
-0.0387335792,
-0.0536748767,
0.0397695638,
-0.007029376,
0.0690641776,
0.0677132383,
0.0521585084,
-0.050244797,
-0.0087980488,
-0.0064162612,
-0.0322629735,
-0.0552027188,
-0.0252327975,
0.0470296629,
0.0422949232,
-0.0054048146,
-0.0485779345,
0.0719433799,
-0.0092324419,
0.0407832488,
0.0592269376,
-0.0260504205,
-0.0062815128,
-0.0093829529,
0.0683838949,
-0.0318750814,
-0.0146172438,
0.026767524,
0.0024646225,
-0.0340126418,
0.0095129311,
0.0260433778,
-0.0141281346,
-0.0669559538,
-0.0096619166,
-0.0362082049,
0.0170128755,
-0.0111701069,
0.0097865863,
0.0255206544,
0.0168181099,
0.0127622373,
0.0490316525,
0.03779139,
-0.0180826187,
-0.0192572828,
-0.0446259305,
0.0086614005,
0.0024118123,
-0.0222446211,
0.0463045053,
-0.025358161,
0.0381512344,
0.0457729548,
-0.0206378233,
0.0069106789,
0.0297397003,
2.742e-7,
0.0810652003,
0.0327818282,
0.0067658364,
0.00685057,
0.0028256094,
0.0309979934,
-0.0269464031,
0.0421962216,
0.0690512061,
0.0232736487,
0.0137956217,
0.0262636375,
0.0827691182,
0.0111991419,
-0.0675272122,
0.0033382939,
-0.1040772572,
0.0068092826,
-0.0353515819,
-0.0594971813,
0.0009834067,
0.0970619991,
0.0270315614,
0.0043897252,
0.001975802,
-0.0851577222,
0.0903289393,
-0.0244585555,
-0.0426298641,
0.0086007006,
0.0411362536,
0.0846284926,
-0.0237786658,
-0.0435985886,
-0.0036846057,
0.0333035402,
0.025419319,
0.0523621738,
-0.0402618945,
-0.0618704669,
0.0103905993,
0.013804757,
-0.0155550437,
-0.0565934703,
0.0592171811,
-0.0110807782,
0.0268159714,
-0.0328786001,
-0.0432323851,
0.0123067759,
0.0326708443,
-0.0124959238,
-0.0372718945,
0.03330376,
0.0060027195,
-0.0000472981,
-0.0070193456,
-0.0969936028,
-0.0576205999,
0.02735308,
-0.0229068846,
0.0037244824,
-0.0562474877,
-0.0121892504,
-0.0332501158,
-0.0424147584,
0.0138688302,
2.555538035e-34,
0.0551787317,
-0.0102471197,
0.0102801938,
0.0141119696,
0.033220835,
-0.0091608735,
-0.0123469569,
0.0276468787,
0.0069168112,
-0.0972728878,
-0.0116620623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12642v1 | Exploring the Constructicon: Linguistic Analysis of a Computational CxG | 2023-01-30T03:51:08 | 2023-01-30T03:51:08 | Jonathan Dunn | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has formulated the task for computational construction grammar as
producing a constructicon given a corpus of usage. Previous work has evaluated
these unsupervised grammars using both internal metrics (for example, Minimum
Description Length) and external metrics (for example, performance on a
dialectology task). This paper instead takes a linguistic approach to
evaluation, first learning a constructicon and then analyzing its contents from
a linguistic perspective. This analysis shows that a learned constructicon can
be divided into nine major types of constructions, of which Verbal and Nominal
are the most common. The paper also shows that both the token and type
frequency of constructions can be used to model variation across registers and
dialects. | [
0.0220813677,
0.0536639094,
-0.0402086042,
0.0238566585,
-0.0529660173,
0.0092869764,
-0.0245303474,
-0.0103944838,
-0.0672205761,
-0.0353292413,
-0.0094336672,
-0.0700242892,
0.0223050155,
-0.0075590252,
0.0311766602,
-0.0019235134,
0.0398851894,
0.0091358237,
-0.0024124575,
0.0055023949,
0.0133820288,
-0.0149299176,
-0.0131020276,
0.0370769985,
-0.103621006,
-0.0161602423,
-0.0392838791,
-0.0152759021,
-0.0224882383,
-0.028471576,
0.0019899923,
0.0226490051,
-0.0394640006,
0.0096439552,
0.000001703,
-0.0753768086,
0.0023513252,
-0.0073757623,
-0.000658452,
0.0089449687,
0.090726465,
0.0209505372,
-0.0505050085,
-0.0069114985,
-0.0344316289,
-0.0135549307,
0.0604932979,
0.0192867033,
0.0122737158,
0.0691785067,
-0.0175283179,
-0.0312332306,
-0.0269978233,
0.0085592903,
-0.0775096342,
0.0498478524,
-0.0015081336,
0.0015638281,
0.0406366028,
-0.0036512676,
-0.0208025891,
0.0159102231,
-0.0064672395,
-0.0224172845,
-0.0194384288,
-0.0212928262,
-0.0264388435,
-0.0043322477,
-0.0033394368,
0.0097642355,
0.0565520748,
-0.0307605807,
0.0357840694,
0.013090211,
0.0408878103,
-0.0750103742,
-0.0412433632,
0.009338893,
-0.027846517,
0.0223639421,
0.0820439458,
-0.0394368917,
-0.0355344787,
-0.0317478739,
0.0263595972,
0.0727067441,
0.0199468154,
-0.0071258894,
-0.0394399837,
0.0187885873,
-0.0013562532,
-0.0677716881,
-0.0245190915,
0.0463817306,
-0.0541242249,
0.0152128153,
0.0068045477,
-0.0383022726,
0.0250133947,
-0.0386487953,
0.0493546091,
0.0100669721,
0.0118745314,
0.0088700401,
-0.0207510069,
0.0467471704,
0.0191380493,
-0.0045199175,
-0.0815186724,
0.0108370865,
-0.0571170188,
-0.0207576621,
-0.0757433325,
0.039510794,
0.0071803117,
-0.0000461461,
-0.0572885089,
0.0042691152,
0.009671703,
0.0197498668,
0.0189284999,
-0.0017099299,
-0.0563545711,
0.0363675468,
-0.0049530966,
-0.0157640409,
-0.0407760255,
0.0020217977,
-0.0185904913,
-0.0331985541,
0.0260915067,
0.0498878472,
0.0095508117,
0.0070448681,
-0.037216384,
-0.0283292979,
-0.0131144617,
0.0206163879,
-0.0179420765,
-0.0343259126,
-0.0657147169,
-0.0411215387,
-0.0084630251,
-0.0630029589,
-0.0044111516,
-0.0017159749,
-0.0037262854,
-0.0153949531,
-0.0034207324,
-0.036374148,
0.0515468083,
-0.021432722,
-0.0011936239,
0.005946584,
-0.0105686672,
-0.0552710854,
0.0197956655,
0.0832212493,
0.0396380872,
-0.0111910161,
0.0320624411,
-0.0249747019,
-0.0002018908,
0.0498031899,
-0.0393434353,
-0.0216750335,
-0.0545307845,
-0.0183696691,
0.0159343164,
0.0045565567,
0.002749952,
0.0732677355,
-0.0017765446,
0.0258123502,
-0.0006737117,
0.0078328773,
0.0613348819,
-0.0204297267,
0.0887754336,
0.0232500173,
0.0199986026,
0.0269211382,
0.0288261343,
-0.0490980558,
0.0026399971,
0.0122649204,
-0.0960057378,
0.0284274016,
0.0062339157,
-0.0665834695,
-0.0127823353,
-0.0285827201,
0.0221524201,
-0.0589334145,
0.0531824492,
0.0489697494,
0.012700282,
-0.0150634088,
0.0219741557,
-0.0378432125,
-0.0241118204,
-0.0435896143,
0.0241622981,
-0.0394874252,
0.0122357905,
0.0190589949,
0.002819082,
0.0332433246,
-0.0086628431,
0.0399660133,
0.0534018315,
-0.0365834907,
-0.0304442085,
-0.0224446151,
0.0079515893,
0.0056985337,
0.0500574745,
-0.0106051313,
-0.044005502,
0.0033631339,
-0.0254829302,
-0.0078734895,
-0.0056998576,
0.0164764337,
0.0888593942,
0.0036146254,
-0.0056749182,
0.0032299904,
0.0243205298,
0.0132729756,
-0.0053420169,
0.0681190789,
0.0009924953,
-0.0385203734,
-0.0128800981,
0.0563435256,
-0.0332629792,
-0.0117567508,
0.0288243666,
-0.0541314892,
0.017448077,
-0.0683573112,
0.0365087576,
-0.0432990044,
0.0714644939,
-0.1150336936,
0.1277835369,
-0.0256794058,
0.0518359095,
-0.0245519392,
-0.0284349192,
-0.0512848087,
0.072612904,
0.0591150038,
0.0052544111,
0.017892912,
0.011225732,
0.0557299107,
-0.0443269201,
-0.0050404235,
-0.0157605447,
-0.0500229932,
-0.0203032419,
0.0178101975,
-0.0159809031,
-0.0315326005,
-0.0536352172,
-0.1010645181,
-0.0321602598,
-0.0302351397,
0.0441689901,
0.0419537388,
-0.0253384896,
-0.0008504768,
0.0107433703,
-0.0047126901,
0.0194962192,
0.020732522,
-0.0035663201,
0.0511082299,
0.0021692144,
-0.0547644384,
-0.033739429,
-0.0036203153,
-0.0328981206,
0.0298505221,
0.0227729902,
-0.0259160586,
-0.0542910621,
0.0438457951,
-0.0003032488,
-0.0239481796,
0.0127447667,
-0.0644448772,
0.0426678509,
0.0250161476,
0.0680786818,
0.0119423419,
0.0087585729,
0.0071722674,
0.0243976135,
-0.0481203087,
-0.0217633545,
-0.0068579982,
-0.037016511,
-0.0352448858,
-0.0517486818,
-0.0199991316,
0.0377931483,
0.1012822986,
0.0346986614,
-0.0135160405,
-0.0321212336,
0.0146208601,
-0.0761400238,
-0.0119492216,
-0.014896933,
-0.0315920897,
-0.0176556297,
0.0286310092,
0.0134697733,
-0.0043684253,
0.0278006867,
-0.0502879694,
-0.0125123728,
-0.0387242548,
-0.0125923203,
-0.0426096208,
0.0234119706,
0.0587207489,
0.0279640965,
0.0921098813,
-0.0373320468,
-0.0266196467,
0.0217036698,
0.0163216218,
0.0036411299,
-0.0216457173,
-0.0716020241,
-0.0267913621,
0.0081737284,
-0.0570846386,
-0.0214653388,
0.0023840324,
-0.0195556656,
0.0063263201,
0.0986737236,
0.0012427396,
0.0248354543,
0.016673997,
-0.0295317322,
-0.0083701257,
-0.0160992704,
0.0145515148,
-0.0047041094,
0.0274698883,
0.023919696,
0.0868410468,
-0.0212356914,
0.0667240173,
-0.019391384,
0.0634821728,
-0.0295334011,
0.0466946922,
-0.0335175321,
0.0181362107,
-0.0009908215,
-0.0099805128,
-0.0889065787,
0.0130605856,
0.0607925057,
-0.0362955108,
-0.0136926686,
0.0485358685,
0.0248201378,
0.0146142244,
0.0478517823,
-0.0339983217,
0.0262431204,
0.0270627458,
0.0010867047,
-0.0638118461,
0.0227463711,
0.0289914887,
-0.0079349624,
-0.0567029268,
0.0271565821,
-0.0160682388,
-0.0842551291,
0.0572668426,
0.002771185,
-0.0250705872,
0.0521224067,
-0.0297394451,
0.0004361534,
-0.0117630027,
-0.0823138505,
0.0611563027,
-0.0190773122,
0.0210815333,
0.0411452726,
-0.0682460889,
-0.0204239562,
-0.0623139478,
-0.0169969518,
0.0315099061,
-0.0146537693,
0.0164348967,
-0.0009534144,
-0.0396741591,
0.0095944805,
-0.0717401356,
0.0488924012,
0.0020118265,
-0.0065466794,
0.0520627461,
-0.0359740108,
-0.0574949086,
0.0342416354,
-0.0133464383,
0.0073950216,
0.0118561685,
0.0662509277,
-0.0228520092,
-0.0007859022,
-0.0183119085,
-0.0032243477,
-0.0096319085,
0.0195957851,
0.0513701737,
-0.0385818854,
-0.0236507691,
-0.0572067089,
-0.0014988176,
-0.0481421612,
-0.020857783,
0.0219436921,
0.011167408,
-0.0128914528,
-0.0857429355,
-0.0401569717,
0.0346807688,
0.0472325943,
0.0166778937,
-0.0200500581,
0.0178707782,
-0.037628904,
-0.0431382768,
0.0070748571,
0.0277620181,
0.0216469578,
-0.0720566362,
-0.0243979525,
0.0594223626,
0.0083809225,
-0.0255045872,
-0.0474323183,
-0.0118023083,
-0.0682928711,
0.0345050879,
0.0293920953,
0.0182600915,
-0.0203328431,
-0.0274500474,
0.0057822135,
-0.0379504748,
0.0082887737,
0.0175923649,
0.0449159592,
0.0200679787,
-0.0589317456,
0.0012354971,
0.0014972832,
-0.0015217633,
0.0316919871,
0.0003587368,
0.0429569334,
-0.0775596201,
0.0197321232,
0.0481176339,
0.0479321778,
-0.0126033416,
-0.0451770388,
0.0278235376,
-0.0067066709,
-0.0204633512,
-0.0341461673,
-0.0209441166,
-0.0257719979,
0.0040720305,
-0.0196694285,
0.0155412201,
0.0038716458,
-0.0179754887,
-0.0683610812,
0.0561747402,
0.0511890054,
0.0433137789,
0.0341321677,
-0.0120760677,
-0.0246947967,
0.0243387781,
0.0107071893,
0.0375838131,
-0.0039313142,
0.0444393493,
-0.0408320203,
-0.0009518976,
0.0069883848,
-0.0093046753,
-0.0243547168,
0.0067116059,
0.0523883626,
0.0652453974,
-0.0245917737,
-0.0053151539,
0.0601353757,
-0.0102733504,
0.0421196185,
-0.034885183,
0.0077093979,
-0.0103997188,
0.0534471273,
0.0077194283,
-0.043299906,
0.034603782,
0.0144931516,
-0.0414520763,
-0.0757639185,
0.0640168414,
-0.0232539866,
-0.005683139,
0.0010508172,
0.0458159596,
-0.0403493717,
-0.0130698457,
0.0098707415,
-0.0016863373,
-0.0077631031,
0.0096709728,
-0.0426068343,
-0.0495146401,
-0.0052361218,
0.0346119292,
0.0289745163,
-0.0458574183,
0.0622257739,
0.0126122357,
0.0021670023,
-0.0450219437,
-0.0346788168,
-0.0131957317,
0.0412963815,
0.0331167802,
0.0061668805,
-5.67071442e-33,
-0.033894632,
-0.009124429,
-0.0097113783,
0.0199071299,
-0.0000114512,
-0.0121384487,
-0.017425606,
0.086969167,
0.028231632,
0.0107499519,
-0.0162598602,
-0.0272188522,
0.0073787263,
0.010789196,
0.0552950352,
0.0584768802,
0.0317586549,
-0.0224531721,
-0.0055623311,
-0.0204433706,
0.0271777343,
-0.0175168347,
0.0662509724,
-0.0625135303,
0.0346346051,
0.004731419,
-0.0076686637,
0.0242176708,
0.0138604501,
0.0855273902,
0.0020995159,
0.0355272256,
0.0142709576,
0.0129861524,
-0.0119463531,
0.0006428451,
-0.0249457937,
-0.0563939735,
0.0309570227,
0.0430342928,
-0.0059650703,
-0.0670659021,
-0.0026173047,
-0.0145793464,
-0.0553832725,
0.0353708975,
0.0281220675,
-0.0183941126,
0.0391146764,
0.0030070175,
-0.0533866212,
0.0055731321,
-0.0357199647,
0.0443435758,
0.0559057742,
0.0028054731,
-0.0187186357,
-0.0290355273,
-0.0190293007,
0.0503878482,
-0.0094282553,
0.0397600047,
0.0769075751,
-0.00166752,
-0.005708952,
-0.0074654785,
0.0247351583,
0.000167124,
-0.0231046677,
0.0545366928,
0.0122362245,
0.0411853716,
0.0167569183,
0.0884910971,
0.0646682158,
-0.0218407251,
-0.0340217762,
0.0027957421,
0.0387931839,
0.0420020968,
-0.0521563701,
0.0040778923,
-0.0406200811,
-0.0402686447,
-0.0356040709,
-0.0165509749,
0.0118035283,
-0.0267708953,
0.022191897,
-0.0051045339,
-0.0222640187,
-0.0410144515,
-0.0023113687,
-0.0130089121,
-0.0364026055,
-0.037778087,
0.0103847776,
0.0530964956,
0.0037618014,
0.0044725752,
-0.004631978,
-0.0233381353,
0.0035905545,
0.0513287224,
0.0663779154,
0.0080928998,
0.0139682135,
0.0142568359,
-0.0215568542,
0.0164841246,
0.0146498708,
-0.0064949356,
-0.0480595753,
-0.0380237661,
-0.0054636896,
0.0107922545,
-0.0173583943,
-0.0109293908,
0.0091096945,
0.0231040493,
-0.0400533117,
-0.0325884037,
-0.0022553243,
0.0348617993,
0.0037388736,
-0.0189881716,
-0.0029897701,
0.0594882146,
0.0956283584,
-0.032394357,
-0.0096436432,
0.0128930975,
2.6e-7,
0.0452611372,
0.0445187688,
0.0096290084,
0.04341124,
0.043340791,
0.0171443764,
-0.030761594,
-0.0158085078,
-0.0155000631,
-0.0279452726,
-0.0027360001,
-0.0252407771,
0.0168888047,
0.0168601684,
-0.0680970997,
0.0083139436,
-0.0178503487,
-0.0122054908,
-0.057686422,
0.0317537747,
0.0358951278,
0.0569444224,
-0.0362411328,
0.0137172025,
-0.0321930349,
-0.03103338,
0.0136429965,
0.0051153931,
-0.0197173692,
0.0824452862,
0.0284775235,
0.0102670696,
0.0215022694,
0.0248182733,
0.0198755749,
0.0113554243,
0.0113638556,
0.0072109159,
0.0009930509,
0.0459342897,
0.0455752797,
-0.0096415179,
-0.017096132,
-0.0071498393,
0.0267958641,
-0.0617549233,
0.0037899558,
-0.0120876729,
0.0056733792,
0.0413761064,
-0.0257371366,
-0.009939177,
0.0130896354,
-0.0057894858,
0.0483796932,
-0.0274845455,
0.0066633401,
-0.021349702,
-0.0335831642,
0.0679675937,
-0.013587255,
-0.061654076,
0.0240839478,
0.0484232679,
0.0133771291,
-0.0084785437,
0.0140649835,
1.825464093e-34,
0.0197858158,
-0.0205692798,
0.0559110008,
0.0179180931,
0.0323289186,
-0.0057892143,
0.0093426974,
0.0199652333,
-0.0150459316,
-0.0492948033,
-0.0113397967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12609v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12609v4 | Knowledge Distillation $\approx$ Label Smoothing: Fact or Fallacy? | 2023-01-30T02:05:24 | 2023-10-25T03:10:01 | Md Arafat Sultan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Originally proposed as a method for knowledge transfer from one model to
another, some recent studies have suggested that knowledge distillation (KD) is
in fact a form of regularization. Perhaps the strongest argument of all for
this new perspective comes from its apparent similarities with label smoothing
(LS). Here we re-examine this stated equivalence between the two methods by
comparing the predictive confidences of the models they train. Experiments on
four text classification tasks involving models of different sizes show that:
(a) In most settings, KD and LS drive model confidence in completely opposite
directions, and (b) In KD, the student inherits not only its knowledge but also
its confidence from the teacher, reinforcing the classical knowledge transfer
view. | [
0.0194198731,
0.052918911,
-0.0111135403,
0.0186860468,
-0.0183881819,
0.0050201528,
-0.0055786157,
0.0086569805,
-0.0029800218,
-0.0058613499,
-0.0095861163,
0.0245999042,
-0.0199584644,
0.0002277662,
0.0092816213,
-0.0648952052,
0.0139478622,
-0.0037395223,
0.0163326263,
-0.026689874,
-0.0123908706,
-0.0484607033,
0.0115430485,
-0.0002292928,
0.0180639569,
-0.0207079649,
0.0145749422,
0.0041693021,
0.0097453427,
0.02073282,
0.0323621556,
0.0494777784,
0.0163072236,
0.0052006734,
0.0000020006,
-0.0391503982,
-0.0137132956,
0.0037878545,
-0.0551982857,
0.0164327789,
0.027874006,
0.0092558498,
0.0741195083,
-0.0284126848,
-0.005788933,
0.0131192487,
0.0131456433,
0.0639482588,
0.0131642623,
-0.0005577657,
-0.0079983175,
-0.0319503807,
0.032089293,
-0.0100661078,
0.0328749008,
-0.0734958649,
0.0574202649,
0.0197832473,
-0.0455293991,
0.0247338396,
-0.0394924022,
0.0584064797,
-0.0097839935,
0.0028418929,
0.0702794045,
0.022022726,
0.0118078496,
-0.0034562112,
0.0130356438,
0.0182887763,
0.0122577958,
-0.0143732009,
-0.0274478346,
0.0298499037,
0.0501548424,
0.0603569262,
-0.077351734,
-0.0482750274,
-0.0229229033,
0.0048962897,
-0.0064018196,
-0.0344389267,
0.0232339334,
0.002292922,
0.0092969546,
0.061062213,
-0.0050940593,
-0.0720610097,
0.0746975243,
0.0530127063,
0.0122472588,
-0.0365947895,
0.0036274304,
0.025698239,
0.0815824345,
0.0095316684,
-0.0262509137,
0.0056939009,
-0.0153360534,
0.0319238007,
0.0023309041,
-0.0177753903,
-0.0332324393,
0.0128565039,
-0.0161203947,
0.0301884655,
0.0606252365,
0.0889079869,
-0.0341669284,
0.036865972,
-0.0998694599,
0.0112958215,
-0.0041678613,
0.0503652766,
0.0497124009,
0.0179109853,
-0.0538542978,
-0.0419007689,
-0.0270202495,
-0.0146349473,
0.0081237359,
0.019612778,
0.0018336683,
0.0275797825,
-0.043963816,
0.0660073385,
0.0031909354,
0.0248472299,
-0.0159397367,
0.0109844385,
-0.0075797513,
-0.0285128839,
0.0127020795,
0.0168732256,
-0.0069570048,
-0.0084868399,
-0.0505152121,
-0.0092579322,
-0.0531928763,
-0.0104247918,
-0.0415313318,
-0.0481453612,
0.0009853964,
-0.0454705432,
0.0071382527,
0.0040064757,
0.0283949003,
-0.0733842552,
-0.0186841954,
-0.0349175297,
-0.0450695157,
0.0381071307,
-0.025223257,
0.0137545224,
0.0324345343,
0.0494058542,
-0.0354465619,
0.0254855007,
-0.0164935719,
0.0111453552,
0.0349169932,
-0.0054063126,
0.0175351277,
-0.001907627,
0.0262088459,
0.0406586342,
-0.0358567983,
-0.0323527865,
0.0080645513,
-0.0307677202,
0.0245178565,
0.0112324515,
-0.0475628078,
0.0270536151,
0.0848064125,
0.0114407996,
0.0362037234,
0.0018190425,
-0.0080873622,
0.0110171903,
0.0291819181,
0.0982762352,
-0.0042478507,
-0.0185288992,
-0.0253806133,
-0.0245789643,
0.0233435649,
-0.0228494629,
-0.0197912399,
-0.0465382263,
0.0278070942,
0.016091207,
-0.0076908059,
0.0319636241,
0.0638183579,
0.0288167819,
0.0546210855,
0.0334689282,
0.0572332963,
0.0015989182,
0.0405842811,
-0.0647470355,
0.0174080823,
-0.0059574689,
-0.0081590544,
-0.0250387676,
0.0039157122,
-0.0132478233,
0.0137945386,
-0.0398589782,
0.0691739544,
-0.0500546433,
0.0013085838,
-0.0084754648,
-0.0402402505,
0.008931879,
0.0472088121,
-0.0057824724,
-0.0009778724,
0.0315619148,
0.0200768579,
-0.0881608576,
-0.0490057766,
0.0403319411,
-0.0107428357,
-0.0736184418,
-0.0240173303,
0.0041828924,
0.0084640095,
-0.0153549742,
-0.0134351682,
-0.0349218287,
0.0022092503,
0.0013985459,
-0.0345348455,
-0.0180069674,
-0.0052158018,
-0.025325682,
0.04003888,
-0.0004287033,
0.0222735852,
0.0154511975,
-0.0290044714,
-0.0394246206,
-0.0114550432,
0.0454998724,
0.0119226864,
0.0090512009,
0.0407363698,
-0.0393730476,
-0.0054338477,
-0.0453411639,
0.0366197601,
0.0214287639,
0.0216193516,
-0.0444068797,
-0.0760854781,
0.0213132501,
0.0833048224,
-0.0060264505,
-0.0017985471,
-0.0142797818,
0.0257948413,
0.0186551102,
-0.0305769984,
-0.0499678515,
0.0025038298,
-0.0006477305,
-0.0091881845,
-0.0059145987,
0.0012890077,
0.0035957764,
-0.0138291167,
0.0103539061,
0.0039284923,
-0.023761861,
-0.0182362776,
-0.0444636159,
0.0167150311,
-0.02038146,
0.028484527,
0.0086851362,
-0.0077494229,
-0.0108817993,
0.002961834,
0.0513303988,
0.0053928262,
-0.0050319512,
-0.0212019309,
0.0442282706,
-0.0497261472,
-0.0108592277,
-0.0102187274,
-0.0155640189,
-0.0259949118,
-0.0171347614,
-0.0535655729,
0.0280572511,
-0.0238805879,
0.0249314439,
0.0494924523,
0.0223410334,
-0.0445900261,
0.0047379984,
-0.0328694731,
-0.0722309947,
-0.0557386577,
-0.0476537012,
-0.0058555054,
0.0461464226,
-0.0045528132,
-0.046005778,
-0.0176352318,
-0.0213114936,
-0.0237662811,
-0.020464398,
-0.0510816909,
0.0135760289,
0.0163277332,
0.0228454266,
-0.0168661438,
-0.0629821867,
0.0467580743,
0.0186043102,
0.0230300315,
-0.0276185926,
-0.0458520092,
0.0326969884,
0.0199754983,
0.0024711087,
0.0051825121,
0.0160003249,
0.0197487343,
-0.0679347739,
-0.025459554,
0.0319861025,
-0.0141101414,
0.0299800206,
-0.0658876672,
-0.0100905346,
0.0147180632,
-0.0226644129,
-0.0252444055,
0.0008106613,
-0.0124119185,
0.0181018412,
0.0231582243,
-0.0157250538,
-0.0393482894,
-0.0228189919,
0.0196715966,
0.0190638192,
-0.0288274772,
-0.0458316617,
0.0402401686,
0.040688321,
0.0226101149,
-0.0499375202,
-0.0181790851,
-0.0604283661,
0.0378882922,
0.0420732759,
0.0372381695,
0.0111834519,
0.0003757652,
0.0036270323,
0.0352094918,
-0.0067426241,
-0.0286649652,
0.0198756102,
0.035813868,
-0.0265040975,
0.0052767345,
0.0781098977,
0.0001518091,
-0.0397450812,
-0.0264875013,
-0.0219756551,
0.0554739013,
0.0392650105,
-0.0024807604,
-0.0344924703,
-0.0264446028,
-0.0072568394,
0.0437069014,
-0.0049447301,
-0.0580187328,
0.0105260899,
-0.0107853077,
0.0131018581,
0.0178330932,
-0.0465344153,
-0.0111883162,
-0.0252585635,
0.0427589826,
0.0067160856,
-0.0464958921,
-0.0208787099,
-0.0222072806,
0.0311135612,
0.0706224069,
-0.0300967563,
-0.0588623025,
-0.0224469695,
-0.0163644124,
-0.0159529764,
0.0024967354,
0.0367272906,
-0.0382094383,
-0.0559512191,
-0.0120640332,
0.0301077031,
0.0153691657,
0.0108320909,
0.1156008542,
0.0031491802,
0.0134769678,
0.0284919348,
0.0221263412,
-0.0112265162,
0.0138254315,
0.0291657485,
0.0403528363,
0.0319710746,
-0.0966295451,
-0.0114666959,
-0.0368271284,
0.0210697465,
0.0413301066,
0.0252637565,
-0.0124321412,
-0.0039348323,
-0.0259231757,
0.0147677399,
0.0254158732,
-0.0341246389,
0.0901329592,
-0.0537387431,
-0.0605321303,
-0.0379715003,
0.0006302773,
0.0219241288,
0.0361163393,
0.0324479751,
0.0338348784,
-0.0064135715,
-0.0050596991,
-0.0232135355,
-0.0117951119,
-0.0301599484,
-0.0022634517,
0.0224537421,
-0.0218862146,
-0.0001614825,
-0.0135387136,
-0.0508603081,
-0.0209634099,
-0.1102337912,
-0.0607484654,
0.0122721251,
0.0296957418,
0.0195735004,
0.0483087637,
0.0226128586,
-0.0638813078,
0.0698077604,
0.0325425975,
0.0247775503,
0.0026203606,
0.0325559489,
-0.0628721192,
-0.0021382894,
0.0027286054,
-0.0100348219,
0.0236067008,
0.046871502,
-0.0251865704,
-0.0289357379,
-0.0409722403,
-0.0013688366,
0.0292133894,
0.0712708682,
0.0052585932,
-0.0256767608,
0.0017075031,
0.0168214887,
0.0653177351,
-0.0194111541,
-0.0116941351,
-0.0340801291,
0.0704973117,
0.0536615327,
-0.0243985355,
0.0204128157,
0.0106491121,
0.0277097952,
-0.0356221274,
-0.0345479771,
-0.00344642,
0.0191755947,
0.0663418919,
0.0016062701,
-0.0132722529,
-0.0181343891,
0.0576155223,
0.0180389937,
0.0074141435,
0.0174150039,
0.0335825346,
0.0492117554,
0.0184012633,
-0.0696086064,
-0.1275748461,
-0.09017919,
-0.0333487317,
-0.008625377,
0.0367791764,
-0.0196936838,
0.0032755078,
-0.0037425063,
-0.0246167574,
-0.0257355962,
-0.0310721584,
-0.0089226812,
0.0125056319,
0.0283888299,
0.0065165041,
0.0200989489,
0.0332479514,
0.0790609792,
0.0069619594,
0.051510781,
-0.0556714609,
-0.0449692048,
-0.0128105264,
-0.0046900059,
0.0546885729,
0.0640513375,
0.0598840155,
-0.0056316704,
-0.0194879733,
-0.0740447566,
0.0587852634,
-0.0640704185,
0.0384294987,
-0.0320725143,
0.0117264865,
0.0503575429,
-0.0292894952,
-0.0197349489,
-0.0186302159,
-0.0319270715,
0.0281193536,
0.0059260991,
0.0150721641,
-6.086532322e-33,
0.0464879051,
0.0134144211,
-0.049606055,
0.0274794716,
-0.0210508108,
-0.0432861038,
0.0286076535,
-0.0164699275,
0.0073214164,
0.0815182999,
-0.026334051,
0.0161803048,
0.0107958289,
0.0291012377,
0.0394878238,
-0.0162610915,
0.082697995,
0.0028616774,
0.0254389942,
0.0165687762,
-0.0061373077,
0.0570084825,
0.0702677742,
-0.1246801689,
0.0318735279,
0.0304720085,
0.0239338893,
-0.0341986753,
-0.0008669628,
-0.0230035894,
0.0039548953,
0.0716664642,
0.0218806807,
-0.053188052,
-0.0096142571,
-0.0235392544,
-0.0602788329,
-0.0371369794,
-0.0118435528,
-0.0104843816,
-0.0045175683,
-0.0209487658,
0.0352315418,
0.0193034187,
0.0119644497,
-0.0381865725,
0.060233742,
-0.0245447122,
-0.0510572679,
-0.0490015931,
-0.0299530253,
-0.0166431982,
-0.0239394642,
-0.0172067955,
0.0348811783,
0.020692898,
0.0028209086,
0.0116729159,
-0.0368951634,
-0.0104682548,
0.0326407626,
0.0434602574,
0.0114907222,
0.0431434587,
-0.0397022441,
0.0342188552,
0.0163534954,
0.0293720625,
-0.0079888981,
-0.038629055,
0.0316221118,
0.0495827161,
0.0039030074,
0.0478029139,
0.0805918276,
-0.0703956336,
-0.0652979985,
0.0278477333,
-0.0456948504,
0.0060890955,
-0.0217685215,
-0.0037784313,
-0.0174798425,
-0.0582832396,
-0.0887948126,
-0.0302384216,
-0.0073015429,
0.0327438042,
-0.0103791403,
0.0198166389,
-0.0160618927,
0.0244690403,
-0.0332086273,
-0.0520708002,
-0.0654616803,
-0.0045018704,
-0.02150576,
0.0365099013,
0.0047253459,
-0.0414118282,
-0.0670626312,
-0.0126486821,
0.0067405947,
0.0322272331,
0.0321506113,
0.0069983276,
0.1070033088,
0.0037150767,
-0.0266289636,
-0.0235900786,
-0.0398771912,
-0.0180289093,
0.0887156278,
0.0080521153,
0.0092208423,
0.0167307314,
-0.0097064264,
0.0263113603,
0.0289972257,
-0.0022305301,
0.0057801534,
-0.012211333,
0.023517279,
-0.0245653745,
-0.0081984354,
-0.0516054519,
0.0037976352,
-0.0403596312,
0.0238372721,
-0.0488421395,
-0.0243891068,
-0.0102714468,
2.675e-7,
0.0148719223,
0.0174751673,
-0.0357642621,
-0.064736858,
0.0083032176,
0.0386901647,
-0.0282077678,
0.0002649092,
0.0505293608,
-0.0733901337,
-0.0047511542,
0.0175383892,
0.0671218857,
0.0483666509,
-0.0687166303,
-0.1038333103,
0.0140865818,
-0.0298117846,
0.0046222964,
-0.0005031314,
0.0491235368,
-0.0118072554,
0.0519398265,
-0.0423842408,
0.0156188617,
-0.0395584852,
0.0349394083,
-0.0009103281,
0.0809660777,
0.055584304,
0.0646383315,
-0.0067422492,
0.0076020663,
0.1015299484,
-0.031354811,
-0.0157137047,
0.0108558023,
0.0419475995,
-0.0230974499,
0.0457022861,
-0.0336487181,
0.0336959809,
0.0260876119,
-0.055360347,
0.0317009166,
-0.0489753857,
0.019893568,
0.0019974578,
-0.0380602069,
-0.0234889928,
0.036644049,
0.0057187616,
0.0385831296,
0.0264698006,
-0.0148158558,
0.0238292832,
-0.0551088415,
-0.0680481344,
0.0146796079,
0.0304748248,
-0.0235497877,
-0.0591979846,
0.0185942054,
-0.043422468,
-0.0037622645,
-0.0587789863,
0.0462654158,
1.959910915e-34,
0.0178110413,
0.0216233004,
0.0379877575,
-0.0171913672,
0.0039280988,
-0.0524983816,
-0.0085829068,
-0.0125577636,
-0.008214605,
-0.0417740494,
0.018280305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12608v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12608v2 | Evaluating Neuron Interpretation Methods of NLP Models | 2023-01-30T02:04:35 | 2023-11-05T12:57:27 | Yimin Fan, Fahim Dalvi, Nadir Durrani, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neuron Interpretation has gained traction in the field of interpretability,
and have provided fine-grained insights into what a model learns and how
language knowledge is distributed amongst its different components. However,
the lack of evaluation benchmark and metrics have led to siloed progress within
these various methods, with very little work comparing them and highlighting
their strengths and weaknesses. The reason for this discrepancy is the
difficulty of creating ground truth datasets, for example, many neurons within
a given model may learn the same phenomena, and hence there may not be one
correct answer. Moreover, a learned phenomenon may spread across several
neurons that work together -- surfacing these to create a gold standard
challenging. In this work, we propose an evaluation framework that measures the
compatibility of a neuron analysis method with other methods. We hypothesize
that the more compatible a method is with the majority of the methods, the more
confident one can be about its performance. We systematically evaluate our
proposed framework and present a comparative analysis of a large set of neuron
interpretation methods. We make the evaluation framework available to the
community. It enables the evaluation of any new method using 20 concepts and
across three pre-trained models.The code is released at
https://github.com/fdalvi/neuron-comparative-analysis | [
0.0217054654,
0.0615504049,
-0.0080253985,
0.0464159399,
-0.0353927985,
-0.0115896026,
-0.0063212826,
-0.0052251159,
-0.0363339372,
-0.0356980339,
-0.0791966394,
-0.0209154692,
0.0239865202,
0.0386819392,
0.0167003889,
-0.0077570351,
0.0515639745,
0.0164864361,
-0.0018233471,
0.0429020189,
-0.0135968449,
-0.0035027799,
-0.0123386346,
0.0684294701,
0.0050665964,
-0.0355553664,
-0.0225805715,
-0.0325872637,
-0.0032385865,
-0.0246377941,
-0.0130350366,
0.0622030012,
0.0017387351,
0.0959506631,
0.0000020521,
-0.0179541092,
0.0040038722,
-0.0043124948,
-0.0514703877,
0.0272893775,
0.0443893522,
-0.0550854467,
0.0233699325,
-0.0402594358,
-0.0415299945,
-0.0213337969,
0.0619399436,
0.0417415611,
0.0271591097,
0.0416142531,
0.0139329433,
-0.041172076,
0.0120636765,
0.0020381284,
0.0075067203,
-0.0076658721,
0.0055620861,
-0.0146232303,
-0.0319294222,
-0.0043583591,
-0.0319855921,
0.0104808072,
0.0567032062,
-0.0045643137,
0.0416994803,
0.0423929207,
-0.0207552649,
-0.0256755985,
-0.0461548381,
0.063603811,
-0.0425070971,
0.0020996309,
-0.035076119,
-0.0218024515,
-0.0127080074,
-0.0274908133,
-0.0472524501,
-0.0215741228,
0.0352442451,
0.0506098159,
0.0178892557,
0.0239419509,
0.0625616536,
0.0157469977,
-0.0249476023,
0.071558699,
-0.0099644437,
0.0026928647,
0.0053937221,
0.0170414373,
0.0009507386,
0.0014688361,
0.0230116583,
0.0192636568,
0.0325252526,
0.0355888382,
0.0117543275,
-0.003123451,
0.0470937528,
-0.0448313691,
0.1051169857,
0.047838252,
-0.0255054962,
0.0316088684,
-0.0618047342,
0.0228870604,
-0.0066613886,
0.0266732108,
0.0151577275,
0.0050371881,
-0.0840753838,
-0.0149474377,
0.0245666988,
0.0251068249,
-0.0348591134,
-0.0523489714,
-0.0352296829,
-0.0093113938,
-0.0162842441,
-0.0251266286,
0.0116989799,
0.0294345133,
-0.0164182615,
0.0615221411,
-0.0415764451,
0.0497589447,
-0.0482983775,
0.0189218502,
-0.0171462577,
-0.03141509,
-0.0497884266,
0.0060074786,
-0.0170893855,
-0.0357467718,
0.0034712923,
0.060887903,
0.0292712003,
-0.0551000722,
-0.0521272905,
-0.0171541087,
-0.0264261868,
-0.0100721922,
0.0190746207,
-0.0609254539,
0.0596946403,
-0.0243563522,
-0.0078593045,
-0.0484966598,
-0.0049122372,
-0.0142122442,
-0.0125875147,
0.0797658563,
-0.046734985,
-0.0046898178,
-0.0328989886,
0.0359480903,
-0.0266679376,
0.0573867001,
0.0086993268,
0.0212732852,
0.0049521411,
0.0103483852,
0.0031269901,
0.0095984982,
0.0504414588,
-0.023479294,
-0.0112320613,
-0.0262476709,
-0.0348343179,
0.0162328687,
0.0530743748,
0.0084432932,
-0.0458903797,
-0.0475945994,
0.0518027768,
0.0387163125,
0.0106102275,
-0.0139914202,
0.0487461239,
-0.0217837058,
0.0556305945,
-0.0124693112,
-0.0753401518,
-0.0012495721,
-0.008790073,
-0.0136999609,
-0.0216765031,
0.0354250036,
0.0005682761,
-0.0477301665,
-0.0049031135,
-0.0143054891,
0.0331637897,
-0.0252297632,
0.0587366484,
0.0331142172,
0.0145812649,
0.0339828245,
0.0421952382,
-0.0031424551,
0.0076743914,
-0.0379908532,
0.0047817733,
0.031897407,
0.0230701733,
-0.0338935703,
-0.0217900481,
0.0095051955,
-0.0537821241,
0.0294655822,
0.0031598781,
0.0048808977,
0.089655593,
-0.0107761519,
0.0049915635,
-0.0634950697,
0.0395284481,
0.0224111918,
-0.0009365946,
-0.0438184738,
-0.0063619022,
-0.0401405767,
-0.0388496816,
0.0616691969,
0.0005208329,
-0.0128525468,
-0.0202610083,
0.0035133776,
0.0285407379,
0.0254933015,
0.0153878219,
0.0235680304,
0.007928649,
-0.0214696787,
-0.0061537838,
0.0034420511,
-0.0717127472,
-0.0665082559,
0.0510342345,
-0.0240052268,
-0.0376651697,
0.0298859589,
-0.051205609,
0.0011731865,
0.0219883621,
-0.0214643199,
0.034014266,
-0.0387269482,
-0.0213986021,
-0.0174746122,
0.0266728438,
-0.0174042992,
0.0540872961,
-0.0243514944,
-0.0052966075,
0.0126939844,
0.0218906105,
0.0300622415,
-0.0064679403,
-0.0518911295,
0.0189688932,
-0.0163656753,
-0.0102780964,
-0.0216599498,
0.0112803299,
-0.063854821,
0.0201653708,
-0.0628261343,
0.0112334704,
0.010256879,
0.0293277856,
0.0560581386,
-0.0328535177,
0.0264885016,
0.0260599181,
0.0072130822,
0.0012023908,
0.0043867091,
0.0275695696,
0.0380561836,
0.0020975126,
-0.0124498205,
-0.056607008,
-0.0489752032,
-0.0498348959,
0.1157264933,
-0.0210114587,
0.010177806,
-0.0057663103,
0.0155074969,
-0.0315204673,
-0.0127243726,
-0.0037229476,
-0.0578294136,
0.0314244479,
0.0050162114,
-0.0535264276,
0.0433679298,
-0.0508915298,
0.0810292065,
0.01603196,
0.0034480228,
-0.0679366589,
-0.0437222682,
-0.0265587214,
0.0463824831,
-0.0337125175,
-0.0196472611,
-0.0071924366,
0.1178746223,
0.0345529206,
-0.021644827,
-0.024596341,
0.0273875296,
-0.0455334075,
-0.0513750762,
-0.0366921127,
-0.0078653721,
0.007362246,
0.0619856156,
-0.047506243,
-0.0633809566,
0.0852686465,
-0.0230581518,
-0.0247860663,
-0.047068581,
-0.0278645419,
-0.0244627073,
0.0953945592,
0.0076693762,
0.0021546283,
0.0209319275,
-0.0286521018,
-0.0189054366,
-0.0049718367,
-0.0094482163,
0.0012635954,
0.0406883359,
-0.0186232161,
-0.0306282975,
0.0130503317,
0.0003366673,
-0.0352175236,
-0.0029243256,
-0.0152824763,
0.0501090735,
0.0158369225,
-0.0176246259,
-0.0054595657,
0.0124018192,
-0.0073671122,
0.0122347437,
-0.0368533507,
-0.0212997384,
-0.0433428809,
0.0246110801,
-0.0104321418,
-0.0042789667,
0.0627668351,
-0.0067809997,
-0.0045091272,
0.0663777962,
0.0092676375,
0.0338398926,
-0.0965269729,
0.0672829077,
-0.0275421776,
-0.0369923674,
-0.0092472536,
-0.0075560915,
0.028247986,
-0.1027712151,
-0.0075057368,
0.1047948003,
0.0304270778,
-0.0376219489,
0.047114633,
0.0058644852,
-0.0037182448,
0.0193830524,
0.017614685,
-0.048951786,
-0.0401731469,
-0.0157495141,
0.0247773156,
0.0113480808,
-0.0300614759,
0.0246803202,
-0.0816171467,
0.0159548856,
0.0161297414,
-0.0269906968,
0.0058263545,
-0.0490303338,
0.0049782461,
-0.022022523,
-0.0174719803,
0.0147590553,
0.015636025,
0.0286159646,
-0.0247540046,
0.00631689,
-0.0310696941,
0.0481434353,
-0.0376273133,
0.0569306761,
0.0410881788,
0.0465600006,
-0.026387563,
-0.0210346058,
0.0139626255,
-0.0375169069,
0.0439286418,
-0.0246328712,
0.0487486497,
0.0180450324,
0.0039688605,
-0.0185018145,
0.0183655657,
-0.0415269397,
-0.04684937,
-0.0431461781,
0.0588358417,
-0.0205299482,
-0.0579450168,
-0.0147607336,
0.0076076412,
0.0185444131,
0.0845150128,
0.0760554299,
-0.006153312,
-0.0744678155,
0.0234354436,
-0.0110692456,
-0.0294043478,
-0.0395924635,
0.01796804,
0.0426252894,
-0.0268389825,
-0.0099528953,
-0.0641354918,
-0.0004556393,
-0.0047817687,
0.0062289885,
-0.0109514287,
0.0006057388,
-0.058393456,
-0.0390813351,
0.0666229874,
0.0093158279,
-0.0079716463,
-0.0348539688,
-0.0315775536,
0.0054559293,
0.0135418614,
-0.0434899852,
0.0052114474,
-0.0493508205,
-0.0316956453,
0.0237687994,
0.0401834399,
0.0227542724,
0.0171770509,
-0.019950347,
-0.0100437766,
0.0181436855,
0.0201057792,
-0.0151851187,
0.0128146224,
0.0282220691,
0.0105268881,
0.0094003314,
-0.005746081,
0.0011792054,
0.0410403013,
0.0186779909,
0.051052697,
-0.0011128987,
-0.0177252013,
0.0223172903,
-0.0204369705,
0.0478566922,
0.0224458762,
-0.0062861694,
-0.0269398484,
-0.0524717942,
0.0215196647,
0.0024196112,
-0.0462061614,
-0.0200023521,
0.0311254449,
0.0199019257,
-0.0225645006,
-0.008089602,
0.0070372685,
0.0239365231,
-0.0276455078,
-0.0103552639,
0.0532315187,
0.0096709142,
-0.0670102388,
-0.0017444412,
-0.0273551568,
0.0076044872,
-0.0242730994,
0.0375875123,
0.0109230047,
0.0305002537,
0.0153311612,
-0.0057550441,
-0.0390778966,
0.0620576814,
-0.0841519237,
-0.0197599865,
0.0024971471,
-0.0126616219,
0.0316164531,
-0.0077969586,
0.0535967946,
-0.0445547327,
0.0097463103,
-0.0061794636,
0.0455824472,
0.0019796353,
-0.0045801322,
0.0264678877,
0.009671404,
-0.0046574976,
-0.0602872595,
0.0363765992,
-0.0189702082,
0.0342607312,
-0.0192122478,
-0.0159198269,
-0.0255543161,
-0.0250375289,
-0.0035788664,
0.0024817893,
-0.0489479266,
0.0238379929,
-0.0594432503,
-0.0525596403,
0.0411905125,
0.0463758707,
0.0220772289,
0.0157463681,
0.0223211963,
0.0494910106,
0.0166544914,
-0.0241372567,
-0.0027066614,
-0.0128269428,
-0.0099400552,
-0.0095275408,
-0.0320050903,
-6.148977154e-33,
-0.0294631291,
-0.0299353879,
-0.0031603891,
-0.0484959073,
-0.0171976518,
0.0197054967,
-0.0487923846,
-0.020629121,
-0.0105579896,
0.0179564524,
0.0265803002,
0.025066046,
0.0137930084,
0.0128619168,
0.0126905963,
-0.0543767661,
0.0260465834,
0.0088398922,
-0.0292210765,
-0.0084208883,
0.024786273,
0.0494704321,
0.0817297027,
-0.0763401464,
0.0597629808,
0.055614315,
0.0106284106,
0.013151438,
-0.0314139985,
0.0602762066,
-0.032189399,
0.0103117628,
0.0484228283,
-0.0524747744,
-0.0195466373,
-0.0343829505,
-0.0564734936,
-0.049518168,
0.0407967418,
0.0255301706,
-0.0639775693,
0.001778208,
0.0779381022,
-0.0116241509,
0.0164704807,
-0.010626602,
0.0166027937,
-0.0138609381,
0.013825886,
0.0176781993,
-0.0973545164,
0.0100894626,
-0.0035742379,
-0.0248094313,
0.0231281668,
0.0136196623,
-0.0207293406,
0.029175343,
-0.1183653027,
-0.0470595844,
0.0072411401,
0.0428766422,
0.0479697734,
0.0091724871,
0.0149541209,
0.0849802941,
0.0382387228,
-0.0679622367,
-0.0619664229,
-0.0164067633,
0.0596519038,
0.0578820258,
0.0349620283,
0.0018091941,
0.0501454584,
0.0271983612,
-0.0653439164,
0.0207950398,
0.0297277309,
0.0531530045,
0.008937357,
0.0008037292,
-0.0029904707,
0.0064486726,
-0.0366331153,
-0.0616233908,
-0.0340011194,
-0.0294191204,
0.0321724154,
-0.0552380532,
-0.0414351597,
0.0120359259,
0.0308222603,
-0.0504303053,
-0.0243663397,
0.0569387041,
0.030804541,
0.0142948152,
0.0416407622,
0.0084641892,
-0.0277415384,
-0.0268859528,
-0.0153089808,
0.0049955868,
0.0638207197,
-0.0229919162,
0.0374114476,
0.0102700433,
0.0184213072,
0.0110654468,
-0.0406591929,
-0.0350463539,
0.0236801486,
0.0404736549,
0.0305746961,
0.0002688632,
-0.0337123945,
0.0109316353,
0.0525205098,
0.0197722167,
-0.0301437322,
0.0375542194,
0.0203177929,
0.0382136703,
-0.0374424271,
-0.012985344,
-0.0570468381,
-0.0021220793,
0.008248521,
-0.0414768085,
-0.016026251,
0.0365757868,
2.647e-7,
0.0894623548,
0.0188597459,
0.0103052901,
0.0283395685,
0.048201412,
0.0392319486,
-0.0220005792,
-0.0015713033,
-0.0131168989,
-0.0401855893,
-0.0325233303,
0.0450684689,
0.0395505689,
0.0052284384,
-0.0124075664,
-0.0025088482,
-0.0640607178,
0.0035011778,
-0.0469083153,
0.0004492941,
0.0573023595,
0.0962052345,
0.0075591747,
-0.008434426,
0.0435636118,
-0.0057210824,
0.0747646466,
0.0013397974,
0.0381027311,
0.0025659865,
0.0148381367,
-0.0185094494,
0.0287200753,
-0.0167881213,
0.0345091596,
0.0252787527,
0.0037343758,
0.0517095439,
-0.0305921752,
-0.0244590193,
-0.0153805604,
-0.0396442562,
0.0186102092,
-0.0789480805,
0.042074915,
-0.0573043711,
-0.0554637648,
-0.043585822,
0.0228374116,
-0.0245060697,
0.0638431981,
-0.0078637237,
-0.0065668919,
0.0122566596,
-0.0196948815,
-0.0203259755,
-0.0562770255,
-0.062368311,
-0.0626503453,
-0.0246065389,
-0.004681773,
0.0002433389,
-0.0497404188,
-0.0327711552,
0.0274756029,
-0.0645822957,
-0.046185948,
2.301605082e-34,
-0.0087045506,
0.0109531069,
0.0353300869,
0.0544455387,
0.0179663356,
0.009607641,
0.0069585377,
-0.0146530401,
-0.0126105566,
-0.0573569685,
-0.0235632602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12596v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12596v3 | Learning to Speak from Text: Zero-Shot Multilingual Text-to-Speech with Unsupervised Text Pretraining | 2023-01-30T00:53:50 | 2023-05-27T15:15:39 | Takaaki Saeki, Soumi Maiti, Xinjian Li, Shinji Watanabe, Shinnosuke Takamichi, Hiroshi Saruwatari | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | While neural text-to-speech (TTS) has achieved human-like natural synthetic
speech, multilingual TTS systems are limited to resource-rich languages due to
the need for paired text and studio-quality audio data. This paper proposes a
method for zero-shot multilingual TTS using text-only data for the target
language. The use of text-only data allows the development of TTS systems for
low-resource languages for which only textual resources are available, making
TTS accessible to thousands of languages. Inspired by the strong cross-lingual
transferability of multilingual language models, our framework first performs
masked language model pretraining with multilingual text-only data. Then we
train this model with a paired data in a supervised manner, while freezing a
language-aware embedding layer. This allows inference even for languages not
included in the paired data but present in the text-only data. Evaluation
results demonstrate highly intelligible zero-shot TTS with a character error
rate of less than 12% for an unseen language. | [
-0.0505165532,
0.0619478896,
0.0270274766,
0.0493994467,
-0.0017289992,
-0.0094812158,
0.0671242326,
0.0149594415,
-0.011776411,
-0.0229624212,
-0.0786698088,
-0.0218493771,
0.0161471926,
0.0398258381,
0.0584587418,
-0.0469881594,
0.0243235659,
-0.0461098701,
-0.0206351765,
0.000398347,
0.0145810479,
0.0379923619,
-0.0480005853,
-0.0080990884,
-0.0289278794,
0.0017019756,
-0.0141985379,
0.0035359785,
0.0363705903,
-0.018741034,
-0.0548162796,
0.0054171924,
0.0363992751,
0.0499471761,
0.000001906,
-0.0313125215,
-0.0045210384,
-0.0026229636,
-0.0394115113,
-0.0334874876,
0.03237959,
-0.0333415046,
-0.0246002376,
0.0122648422,
-0.0124445492,
-0.0189051777,
0.0547881573,
0.029538909,
0.0409604721,
0.078769803,
-0.0526875369,
-0.028244229,
-0.0091471216,
-0.0169768278,
0.0066063902,
0.0101102609,
-0.0396661833,
-0.0540751852,
-0.0053369841,
-0.0073131006,
-0.0241343901,
0.0498682447,
0.0159777906,
0.0089282915,
-0.0257490892,
0.0301157441,
-0.0260651335,
-0.0449566282,
-0.0052457349,
0.139296189,
-0.0560218208,
-0.0297244973,
0.0203605313,
-0.0167868268,
-0.0325613581,
-0.0707267225,
0.0058131847,
0.0383750126,
0.0602391586,
0.0167554133,
-0.0143489502,
0.0450115353,
0.0439920574,
-0.0290204231,
-0.0323773883,
0.0122776274,
0.0196069255,
-0.0188519266,
0.0055628018,
-0.0138458833,
0.0241505038,
-0.0323436745,
0.0234847534,
0.0334605463,
0.0026254083,
0.0122449007,
-0.065928705,
-0.0756705701,
-0.0403480865,
-0.0104340194,
0.0370903052,
0.0565691777,
-0.0343532003,
0.0290558673,
-0.0476970673,
-0.014733823,
0.0144154234,
0.0142577328,
-0.0219723824,
-0.0351134464,
0.0014082236,
0.0123714926,
-0.029648006,
0.0299631152,
-0.0809421316,
-0.0169924423,
0.012362401,
-0.029411789,
-0.0345087871,
0.0104533471,
0.0083073126,
-0.0097916378,
-0.0513602011,
-0.0370996483,
0.0381301045,
0.0260682683,
0.0097620841,
0.0356982984,
-0.0131823048,
-0.0740086362,
-0.029342873,
0.0295532718,
0.0501665026,
-0.0008488502,
0.0296615157,
0.0575229339,
-0.0455672517,
-0.0324092992,
-0.0209373739,
0.006190686,
0.012113749,
-0.0450619571,
0.0148335518,
-0.0611120276,
0.0656022653,
-0.0298493579,
0.0330335088,
-0.0316686258,
-0.0046550236,
-0.0110883722,
-0.0087206932,
0.0810998157,
-0.0261117574,
-0.0126241259,
0.0025842206,
0.0000452502,
0.0382865593,
0.0779198334,
0.0583182871,
-0.0275647659,
0.0036781963,
0.0011431023,
0.0052168602,
0.0713439584,
0.0478660166,
0.0340509005,
-0.0117268153,
-0.0245837104,
0.0154290171,
-0.0093780588,
0.0522241704,
0.0208555274,
-0.037525516,
0.0060315044,
0.0463804379,
0.0423072614,
0.0456650294,
0.0219368376,
0.075507693,
0.0276598129,
-0.0259341747,
-0.0301896818,
0.0186907332,
0.0287292413,
0.0022817696,
0.0273164269,
0.0129699837,
0.0200595185,
-0.0697885007,
0.0005689551,
0.0377273038,
-0.0424414836,
-0.0024798589,
0.0082031442,
0.0371811353,
0.0445245318,
-0.0752786919,
0.0308436807,
0.0227098055,
-0.0641962141,
0.055696141,
0.0106057478,
0.0078257611,
0.0314774886,
-0.0234134719,
-0.0138039645,
-0.0175308492,
-0.0201444551,
0.004850389,
0.0690215454,
-0.0157228839,
0.0098179737,
0.1210885346,
-0.0673294291,
0.0163555741,
-0.0040316032,
-0.0009911453,
0.0595979095,
-0.0895994306,
0.0860620439,
-0.0005046554,
0.0088824444,
0.0507661626,
0.0079255477,
-0.0609897412,
-0.0337671079,
0.028331738,
0.0174750183,
0.03077434,
0.0301892497,
-0.0418239683,
0.0079233367,
0.0068279402,
-0.0512444451,
-0.0050654723,
0.0205055065,
-0.0696295798,
-0.0647616833,
0.0103462096,
-0.0534049757,
0.0204715896,
0.0449799486,
0.0020725506,
-0.0793614462,
0.0378389843,
0.027011618,
0.017946614,
-0.0206609815,
-0.0198346134,
0.027214,
0.0214412846,
0.0533745289,
-0.0229782313,
0.0383502506,
0.0112227853,
0.0327619798,
0.0025190904,
0.0385891125,
-0.0504129976,
-0.0301164165,
0.0171634238,
0.0045700646,
0.0303855706,
-0.0244369563,
0.0318202078,
-0.0051784981,
0.0360126309,
-0.0751118883,
0.0029122818,
0.0047505544,
0.022204645,
0.0182376262,
0.0242111459,
-0.0053533395,
-0.0328738019,
-0.0536421612,
-0.026302712,
0.0332261696,
-0.0368435793,
0.0112464605,
-0.0066946917,
0.0218196381,
-0.0087106442,
-0.0022441021,
0.0164395645,
0.0297259409,
-0.0283643659,
-0.0272902306,
-0.0201885756,
0.0496995784,
-0.0187568739,
0.0465946309,
0.0178340357,
-0.0332169086,
0.0024832049,
0.0057984446,
0.0145023353,
0.0260651205,
-0.0592537075,
-0.0360095836,
0.0454173051,
-0.0111249182,
-0.0461453199,
-0.0052294373,
0.0168490093,
0.0342708714,
-0.0212354511,
0.0246067792,
-0.0139924232,
0.0540523715,
0.0071076495,
-0.0090064136,
-0.0674415007,
0.0016126137,
0.0088776955,
-0.0437800586,
-0.0257560685,
0.0345765464,
-0.0094720637,
0.0137547767,
-0.0176381916,
0.0099019408,
0.0325553082,
-0.0829877928,
-0.0642256215,
-0.0389036946,
-0.0145047512,
-0.0074297739,
-0.0275242161,
0.0002187624,
0.0468582772,
-0.0286032278,
-0.0131314946,
-0.047580827,
0.0076860557,
-0.0087087508,
-0.0172313843,
-0.0074543115,
-0.0129693011,
0.0040327897,
-0.023648398,
-0.017348934,
-0.0089803794,
-0.0177881811,
-0.0456892103,
0.0354436375,
0.0022464236,
-0.0159087926,
-0.019490201,
-0.0181053393,
0.0514299497,
0.0872385055,
0.0367174223,
0.0175496414,
-0.0415260904,
0.0501988232,
0.0266696941,
-0.023932742,
-0.0173686165,
-0.0366432928,
0.0663917214,
0.0015631171,
0.0476346835,
0.0170671586,
-0.0372274593,
0.0107732015,
0.0255744699,
0.0535480939,
-0.0125789233,
0.0103844814,
0.0124176107,
-0.0105810165,
0.0111150108,
0.0872818232,
-0.0264630616,
-0.0172369834,
-0.0159474183,
0.0076924525,
0.0215404257,
-0.00378542,
0.0183518976,
-0.1058209762,
-0.0422493741,
0.0178039558,
0.0007833014,
0.0006744312,
0.0070085851,
-0.0547736026,
-0.1383232921,
-0.0081517436,
0.0402381159,
-0.0634790882,
-0.0286936983,
-0.0200839899,
-0.0221691653,
-0.0088807782,
0.0039168391,
-0.0078207767,
0.021094447,
-0.0258143675,
0.0099075446,
-0.0201013666,
-0.0713668019,
0.0144374082,
-0.0189441312,
0.0748719499,
0.0139952395,
0.051400885,
-0.0187866483,
-0.0143110808,
0.0010535168,
-0.0048081875,
-0.036477726,
-0.0101138847,
0.0484423041,
-0.020241905,
-0.0350626707,
0.0342247114,
0.0466098934,
-0.0115605621,
0.0038605155,
-0.0032080456,
0.0572326742,
0.0412033983,
-0.0165591761,
0.0274825953,
0.0197744314,
0.0198992342,
0.0489805117,
0.0022681961,
-0.0605455488,
-0.0060109654,
-0.0070982082,
-0.0079143979,
-0.0945829153,
-0.0424186029,
0.0287098289,
-0.0151013155,
-0.0312520601,
-0.0420660339,
-0.0375217423,
0.0261976048,
0.0776048899,
0.0212778803,
-0.028764097,
0.011536954,
0.0110887233,
-0.0006201265,
0.0032679236,
-0.0459218808,
0.0370857418,
-0.0415153839,
0.0080113923,
0.0020360099,
-0.0555150844,
-0.0055352338,
0.0014658417,
-0.0398344137,
-0.0525606833,
-0.0434275307,
0.0443463065,
0.010090813,
0.0529438332,
-0.0322250947,
-0.0326311998,
0.1139486581,
0.0449017324,
-0.0521550998,
0.004354422,
0.0939234495,
0.0122670569,
0.0183326863,
0.0176958889,
-0.0328279436,
0.0419366248,
0.0246919449,
0.0066945534,
-0.0379734822,
0.0162862483,
-0.0217266325,
0.0000698003,
0.0105303917,
-0.014600927,
0.0576117821,
-0.0666616336,
-0.0163985826,
-0.0562650114,
0.0270641651,
-0.0750824884,
0.0116283745,
0.0357651003,
0.0110713029,
-0.0039596329,
-0.0023297712,
-0.023198491,
0.0100784339,
0.0104388651,
0.0090246573,
0.0753145739,
0.0233781319,
-0.0043856944,
0.006709727,
0.0034782691,
0.0239114445,
-0.0380143113,
0.0211593583,
-0.0181114003,
-0.0065472065,
0.0111100869,
-0.0236544684,
-0.0069877547,
0.010760325,
-0.0015216363,
0.0030597944,
-0.0165290851,
-0.0280752294,
0.0504662395,
0.0098795528,
0.0908633024,
0.0083147855,
0.0166465119,
-0.0038601421,
0.0460793786,
-0.0357856266,
-0.0291528385,
-0.0119226743,
-0.0061799195,
-0.0018535195,
0.0263699237,
0.0564691536,
0.0243671387,
0.0158801377,
-0.0113046877,
0.0729609057,
-0.0189471152,
0.0136016672,
0.004667155,
0.0217575096,
-0.0260456856,
-0.0015805529,
-0.0319649391,
-0.0885163322,
0.0189411659,
0.006497853,
-0.0146982698,
-0.0090636462,
0.0101108188,
-0.0344220363,
-0.0070347278,
0.0187188387,
-0.0161423683,
-0.0149821937,
0.0304938219,
-0.0230859779,
0.0007237992,
-5.891021898e-33,
-0.0186267365,
0.0146255493,
0.0001770908,
-0.0146374088,
-0.0083532687,
-0.0054061529,
-0.0445690528,
-0.0057573654,
-0.0330486223,
0.0011249104,
-0.0197342727,
0.0083475998,
0.0139793046,
0.0574352108,
-0.0305750612,
0.0081233755,
0.0514521897,
-0.0290196016,
0.0191653408,
0.0361232311,
0.0450193956,
0.0600652099,
0.0705702901,
-0.0466256849,
-0.0049923849,
-0.0378252342,
-0.0219376031,
0.0005700472,
0.0460522324,
0.0094230836,
-0.0197157841,
0.019751681,
-0.0164034497,
-0.0377371199,
-0.0376705565,
0.0198254045,
-0.065847747,
-0.0172261056,
-0.0097905137,
0.0284490362,
-0.0413977318,
-0.0027235704,
-0.0028781118,
-0.0206124932,
0.016220782,
-0.0226784945,
0.0120822117,
-0.0253145173,
0.0107498989,
-0.0434990786,
-0.0638350174,
0.012499501,
-0.0209305156,
-0.0416503474,
0.0831719562,
0.0994052291,
-0.0348695703,
-0.0012441713,
-0.0997027829,
0.0397646055,
-0.0439891368,
0.0049660131,
0.0763774887,
0.0261441637,
-0.0055796285,
0.0221401174,
0.0297668669,
-0.0399541631,
-0.0017452842,
0.0327197425,
0.0645106062,
0.0100843841,
0.041448392,
0.0686796308,
0.0372101441,
-0.021153992,
-0.0697305426,
-0.017216146,
-0.0163911078,
-0.0466104224,
0.0024270383,
0.0112666264,
0.0102129439,
-0.0097870966,
-0.0525479726,
-0.0672076046,
-0.0307254102,
-0.0032282383,
0.0409194455,
0.0032249081,
0.0078292312,
0.0006828605,
0.0898380727,
-0.0168589093,
-0.0169913229,
0.0178173836,
-0.0102934074,
0.0081154415,
-0.0013229746,
0.0457312055,
-0.1064856946,
-0.0459155552,
0.0507918447,
0.0544110127,
0.034704119,
0.0006600112,
0.0335293785,
0.0426129289,
-0.046317786,
-0.0133342734,
-0.0182939358,
0.0146358507,
0.0170051046,
0.0445327088,
0.0191328134,
-0.0092380773,
-0.0209471155,
0.0497694686,
-0.0151807824,
-0.0278309509,
0.0233233757,
0.0052573672,
-0.0192650259,
0.0291757938,
-0.0491598174,
0.0029790103,
-0.0147097372,
-0.0074011139,
0.0693753734,
-0.0357398167,
0.0013709542,
0.009880417,
2.65e-7,
-0.0229556896,
-0.0407962501,
-0.0185322836,
-0.0135105532,
0.0240480751,
0.0617956035,
-0.038753666,
0.042936407,
-0.0343695693,
0.0103568025,
-0.0181900728,
0.0104087265,
0.0852739066,
0.0219864193,
-0.067898646,
-0.0301559046,
-0.0276313722,
0.014332138,
-0.0359010547,
-0.0209948272,
0.0025080021,
0.0755205601,
-0.0020745369,
-0.0034124525,
0.020551119,
-0.0229706876,
0.0483557917,
0.00000803,
-0.0039320928,
-0.0500178114,
0.0064199665,
-0.010306254,
-0.0490647256,
-0.0240828246,
-0.0494092479,
0.0361690857,
0.0305666309,
0.0380786732,
-0.0045887562,
-0.0345028006,
0.0184670817,
0.0337782912,
-0.0806409791,
0.0260612164,
0.0646760538,
-0.0255999882,
-0.0182693433,
0.0180835221,
-0.0178597085,
0.0312699974,
0.0080394968,
-0.0319668762,
-0.0405313075,
0.023171952,
0.069291383,
-0.0048372797,
-0.0181105174,
-0.027314391,
-0.0280208252,
-0.0035993464,
-0.0307568014,
-0.0041042669,
-0.0191584639,
-0.0047767134,
0.0440355316,
-0.0320545882,
0.0035797986,
1.861365802e-34,
0.008530464,
-0.043334797,
0.0431752205,
-0.0335290283,
-0.0228109099,
-0.0281683858,
0.0224402957,
-0.0141834011,
0.0346517339,
-0.0434828214,
-0.0388639756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12586v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12586v2 | Unifying Molecular and Textual Representations via Multi-task Language Modelling | 2023-01-29T23:56:45 | 2023-05-18T00:37:00 | Dimitrios Christofidellis, Giorgio Giannone, Jannis Born, Ole Winther, Teodoro Laino, Matteo Manica | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The recent advances in neural language models have also been successfully
applied to the field of chemistry, offering generative solutions for classical
problems in molecular design and synthesis planning. These new methods have the
potential to fuel a new era of data-driven automation in scientific discovery.
However, specialized models are still typically required for each task, leading
to the need for problem-specific fine-tuning and neglecting task
interrelations. The main obstacle in this field is the lack of a unified
representation between natural language and chemical representations,
complicating and limiting human-machine interaction. Here, we propose the first
multi-domain, multi-task language model that can solve a wide range of tasks in
both the chemical and natural language domains. Our model can handle chemical
and natural language concurrently, without requiring expensive pre-training on
single domains or task-specific models. Interestingly, sharing weights across
domains remarkably improves our model when benchmarked against state-of-the-art
baselines on single-domain and cross-domain tasks. In particular, sharing
information across domains and tasks gives rise to large improvements in
cross-domain tasks, the magnitude of which increase with scale, as measured by
more than a dozen of relevant metrics. Our work suggests that such models can
robustly and efficiently accelerate discovery in physical sciences by
superseding problem-specific fine-tuning and enhancing human-model
interactions. | [
0.0308602862,
0.0541394465,
0.0115544042,
0.008207541,
-0.0104866168,
0.0102835735,
0.0430160053,
-0.005644307,
0.0272763018,
-0.0323971249,
-0.0576658435,
-0.0402488485,
-0.0249889027,
0.0555425882,
0.0332615748,
0.0009700056,
0.0131396297,
-0.0330367349,
0.01394617,
-0.0219016336,
0.0165718514,
0.0166065581,
0.0206409264,
0.0265508052,
0.0195394792,
-0.0323453695,
-0.0005928567,
0.0010246008,
0.0229670554,
-0.0086014923,
0.0112345954,
0.0665538386,
0.0607957691,
0.0516663939,
0.0000017913,
-0.0345047452,
0.006238251,
0.0253445618,
-0.0055353064,
-0.0162421148,
0.0486846864,
-0.0457033403,
0.0046965983,
-0.0136840167,
-0.0525469147,
0.0117264548,
0.0837580115,
0.0244498495,
0.0068731625,
0.0239550695,
0.0025084815,
-0.0150064919,
0.0278261136,
-0.0489762835,
0.0345599949,
-0.0296973791,
0.0530820861,
0.0350935198,
0.0364165679,
0.0259805992,
-0.0128979003,
0.0393404588,
-0.0072229868,
-0.0271066781,
0.0166164432,
0.0143253524,
-0.0010692629,
-0.010164924,
-0.0006468032,
0.0963732526,
-0.0414867699,
-0.0368340649,
-0.031956505,
-0.0019970017,
-0.0366889611,
0.0208750926,
-0.0513876416,
-0.0015915983,
0.015838474,
0.0191577934,
0.0015122284,
-0.0217473023,
0.0501969047,
0.0273593906,
0.0297690462,
0.0487470254,
0.0068197818,
-0.0038223439,
0.0098259468,
0.0227182694,
-0.0634333044,
-0.0146602551,
0.0252655316,
-0.0142594669,
0.0004599764,
0.0049759294,
0.0032949264,
-0.059131898,
0.02694951,
-0.02298248,
0.0533047654,
0.0174911916,
-0.0120889898,
0.0332591645,
-0.003824586,
0.0030118555,
-0.0279089045,
0.0106291315,
-0.0340809636,
-0.0130686397,
-0.095385164,
-0.0195274577,
-0.0087152207,
0.0189787187,
-0.0421756655,
-0.0182606466,
-0.0403965898,
0.0176029615,
0.0012401805,
-0.0530213751,
0.0571557097,
0.0530549809,
-0.0560703911,
0.0022152017,
-0.023472093,
0.0404282287,
-0.0175777078,
0.0311934967,
0.0048107798,
-0.0207340289,
-0.0575498678,
-0.0005159469,
-0.0295807179,
-0.0465215631,
0.0196734294,
0.1067202389,
-0.0112157958,
-0.000101901,
0.0088324677,
-0.0602208488,
-0.0136320135,
-0.0623703822,
0.0352671854,
-0.0427724868,
0.0893006921,
0.0310300849,
0.0022093758,
-0.0833576843,
0.0044305176,
-0.0270483885,
-0.0466428287,
0.1131127402,
0.01829293,
-0.0683942288,
0.02179645,
0.0223702472,
-0.0073179943,
0.0242299903,
0.0294917524,
-0.0199303478,
-0.0225064494,
0.0364662297,
-0.0161022637,
-0.0023443601,
0.0089714536,
-0.0419306085,
0.0264494494,
-0.0245035868,
0.0050106784,
0.0652309582,
0.0269573107,
0.0094045838,
-0.0131832268,
-0.0022391791,
0.0393491313,
0.0323241726,
0.0224132799,
0.0335235298,
0.0347739905,
0.0185189061,
-0.0063282927,
-0.013457912,
-0.0205940455,
0.0628709719,
-0.0238916874,
-0.0057628411,
0.0472213104,
0.046185296,
-0.0236384086,
-0.0233596452,
0.0227897074,
-0.0157789141,
0.0317222774,
-0.0340402462,
0.0507627204,
-0.0285876598,
-0.0816204771,
0.029895125,
0.0499619655,
-0.0339449756,
0.0204248615,
-0.0144647658,
-0.0014400703,
0.0625759885,
0.0398826376,
-0.0710613877,
-0.0117924884,
0.0096542183,
0.0151382256,
0.0309169795,
0.0095625399,
-0.0152533902,
0.0267829802,
-0.0284332838,
-0.0382446796,
-0.0638707876,
-0.0007377525,
-0.0239312202,
-0.0163061451,
-0.0171464328,
0.0051285513,
-0.0286582727,
-0.0353126526,
0.0241352692,
-0.0230819434,
-0.0144685805,
0.0089633493,
-0.0313802175,
0.021226503,
0.0129624149,
-0.011125925,
0.0458041653,
0.0631551221,
-0.0599756204,
-0.0303123016,
-0.028143201,
0.0091830464,
-0.0486253351,
0.0371638834,
-0.0506406538,
0.014691757,
0.017409144,
-0.0390302762,
-0.0381987877,
0.0654616058,
0.0083430009,
-0.0294278041,
0.0001926406,
-0.0133722927,
0.013917665,
0.0599086359,
-0.0529508591,
0.0552980863,
0.0160658639,
-0.0052554272,
-0.0035040122,
-0.0092981923,
0.0123671982,
-0.0240161587,
0.0032276649,
-0.0392643809,
0.0508962981,
0.0422602929,
0.0444418453,
-0.031252034,
-0.0025140096,
-0.0082150977,
-0.0453493446,
-0.0061758673,
-0.0071312832,
0.0022968955,
0.0094033405,
0.0036875412,
0.025637392,
0.0032417064,
-0.0122806784,
-0.0065447018,
-0.0337195434,
-0.0089225192,
0.045140285,
0.0044326684,
-0.012754702,
-0.0729831383,
-0.0497931205,
-0.0569427609,
0.0492293388,
0.0121923871,
-0.0448635109,
-0.0217886157,
-0.0030403179,
-0.0020744789,
0.0388953015,
0.0085499296,
0.0061007706,
0.0150986956,
-0.0131230345,
0.0364388525,
0.0562550165,
-0.0260029212,
0.0224493947,
0.0917928442,
0.0247349404,
-0.03080865,
0.0149732316,
-0.0256310888,
0.0175176691,
0.0314282626,
0.0221014395,
0.0141339852,
0.0657420009,
-0.022372596,
-0.0253932197,
-0.0356915854,
0.0410126336,
0.011579426,
-0.0431590751,
-0.0174884629,
-0.010270454,
0.01389076,
0.0005268375,
-0.0036664342,
-0.0487474203,
0.0901790336,
0.0061195018,
0.0145412283,
-0.0686945319,
-0.0085097346,
0.0012495655,
0.0283340085,
0.0017855661,
0.0256430805,
0.0541629083,
0.0318710506,
-0.0346559733,
-0.0027400334,
0.005455452,
0.0071514207,
0.0269177668,
-0.078425996,
0.0263367537,
0.0077923341,
-0.0629090518,
0.0094186831,
0.0194918066,
-0.0405392647,
0.07114923,
0.027137164,
-0.0498945974,
-0.0454984382,
-0.0063388194,
0.0414033569,
-0.0030760111,
-0.028220024,
-0.0030055149,
-0.0499846265,
0.0096193217,
0.0393405445,
-0.0287800021,
0.00789758,
-0.0401425064,
0.015779553,
0.0285677388,
0.003624748,
0.0105012814,
-0.0005206111,
0.0084602013,
0.027459044,
0.0075474842,
-0.0236010812,
0.0098380726,
0.0174454395,
-0.0342472121,
-0.0288581755,
0.0795019269,
0.0159511399,
-0.0412797071,
0.0189722199,
0.0036950284,
-0.019491503,
-0.0037437354,
0.0604622737,
-0.08655563,
-0.0607246682,
-0.0440520383,
-0.0069669904,
0.0253694002,
-0.0173588358,
-0.0161190219,
-0.0467371084,
0.0146906143,
0.0319034904,
-0.0259886961,
-0.0327632949,
-0.0519574694,
-0.0449714996,
-0.0424912088,
0.004303128,
0.0002639683,
0.0305007361,
-0.018208636,
0.0301322546,
0.0287818126,
-0.0712728575,
0.0332806557,
-0.0331057012,
-0.0121719241,
0.0786361247,
0.0132855242,
0.025456233,
-0.0238612108,
0.0135642095,
0.0359436721,
0.0222818926,
-0.0143220751,
0.034150701,
0.0229923278,
-0.0231282189,
-0.0237087272,
0.0497910418,
-0.074333258,
-0.0398466438,
-0.0464275666,
0.1275330335,
-0.0109677259,
0.0001678631,
-0.0504833311,
0.0043045511,
0.0187876839,
0.0673584342,
-0.0139576625,
-0.0535857864,
-0.0917123854,
-0.029040765,
0.003362623,
-0.068102017,
-0.0310905669,
-0.0253406987,
-0.0119919768,
0.0170226023,
-0.0344436057,
-0.0097613335,
0.0466931164,
-0.0072117904,
-0.0032982021,
0.0197766777,
0.0189048629,
-0.0495696887,
-0.0488360487,
0.0395859368,
-0.0071407123,
0.0248417147,
-0.0480072871,
-0.0573488772,
0.0557986535,
-0.023212092,
-0.0204355083,
0.0736538917,
-0.0749770552,
-0.076898098,
-0.0342848934,
0.0188348368,
0.0194277447,
0.0078713754,
-0.0074605728,
-0.0829226673,
0.0514774099,
0.0402102582,
-0.0135817835,
-0.0225613564,
0.0012633433,
-0.0116877854,
-0.0331436098,
0.0161341652,
-0.0258426219,
0.0296479259,
0.0145759536,
0.0378055237,
-0.0090729222,
-0.0307137724,
0.0270929858,
0.0009909119,
0.0800610706,
0.0158958677,
0.0078208009,
-0.0263141915,
-0.0503798351,
0.0173545741,
-0.0149460379,
-0.0545196533,
-0.0006375494,
0.0339496657,
-0.0245303139,
-0.0056855869,
0.0244005006,
0.0008647616,
0.0146541903,
-0.041058965,
-0.0044307718,
-0.0031254096,
0.0069509083,
0.056834884,
-0.0106330095,
0.012846115,
0.0100388583,
-0.0373743214,
0.012997793,
-0.0171453953,
0.0009689428,
0.0179843549,
0.0664725676,
-0.0555999577,
0.0469928198,
-0.0544930436,
-0.0458036773,
-0.0625341088,
-0.0014170547,
0.053109739,
0.0026635977,
0.0463161618,
-0.0194773581,
-0.0342594944,
-0.0429674312,
0.0447025225,
0.0211699996,
0.0069628074,
0.075574249,
0.0292317122,
-0.0263590198,
-0.0407244116,
0.1044325903,
0.0221828949,
0.040563345,
-0.0167059731,
-0.0400161445,
-0.0134323472,
-0.0413670242,
-0.0353909396,
0.0103775188,
-0.0254323762,
-0.0061888695,
-0.0399771817,
-0.037186034,
0.0346987247,
0.0254898071,
-0.0132444762,
0.006161538,
0.0610155836,
0.0347636342,
0.0026547781,
-0.0586277321,
-0.0023603775,
0.0069693835,
0.0213558227,
-0.0607529208,
-0.0191390831,
-5.605327179e-33,
0.000017222,
0.0061939787,
-0.0069214627,
0.0073619359,
0.0100502074,
-0.0043291673,
-0.0894953907,
-0.0066839918,
0.0048277443,
0.079187572,
0.0065624984,
0.0020182992,
0.0033571031,
-0.0269998778,
0.0191357769,
0.0151169347,
0.0348370485,
-0.0008161626,
-0.0053584664,
0.0326391272,
0.0757118091,
0.0546031483,
0.0428239517,
-0.0471458361,
0.0224140603,
0.0491470248,
0.0096005285,
0.0030425775,
-0.0331743844,
0.0450837463,
-0.0490712114,
0.0591384433,
-0.0143316658,
-0.0537094064,
-0.0696909577,
0.0155159952,
-0.0731454119,
-0.0086904988,
0.0284728389,
-0.0367291346,
-0.0310647339,
-0.0275308155,
0.0297941789,
0.0231665634,
-0.0318737179,
-0.0362940356,
0.0378056541,
-0.0081651295,
-0.0076474627,
-0.038277518,
-0.0883125812,
-0.0177920163,
0.0093665393,
-0.0157146286,
0.037083894,
0.0088304719,
0.0088898754,
0.0341370255,
-0.0365750864,
0.0379321612,
-0.0333517902,
0.028488297,
0.056604743,
0.0187222343,
-0.0016497248,
0.0394753665,
-0.0179405119,
-0.0013361623,
-0.0178852882,
-0.0111134704,
0.0156808253,
0.0538048558,
0.0380850136,
0.0139332647,
0.0178891644,
0.0327269174,
-0.1367102861,
-0.0015929028,
-0.0090352204,
0.0123666013,
0.0130194835,
0.051349625,
0.0282511152,
-0.0605418868,
-0.0288453624,
0.0330695659,
-0.0207595099,
-0.0156738777,
-0.039348457,
-0.041986458,
-0.0444549471,
0.0134270852,
0.011767,
-0.058140371,
-0.0208822899,
0.0527188145,
-0.0018830622,
0.0110108638,
0.0192047078,
0.0089433817,
-0.0582374446,
-0.0339588374,
0.026643293,
-0.0014904188,
0.0195763018,
-0.0108269937,
0.0150838755,
0.0268435255,
-0.0009907951,
-0.0099806553,
-0.0750513747,
-0.0042067757,
0.0681403577,
0.0587703213,
0.0016234703,
0.0330713801,
-0.0019188421,
0.0339395218,
0.0185573846,
-0.0382335,
0.030575797,
0.0519036129,
0.0252158437,
0.0349468999,
-0.0534560867,
-0.0323347226,
-0.0534700789,
-0.004846849,
0.0567999966,
-0.0714989305,
-0.0462933145,
-0.0028986537,
2.552e-7,
0.0824010074,
0.0300487783,
0.0443063043,
-0.0013650609,
0.000609285,
0.040218506,
-0.0003887975,
0.0571947619,
-0.045110032,
-0.022075342,
-0.004897804,
0.0142036863,
0.0220138878,
-0.003201599,
-0.0445300639,
0.0127581954,
-0.0231121946,
-0.0113584278,
-0.0480165556,
-0.008844276,
-0.0079780528,
0.0728850588,
0.0098518804,
-0.0062639327,
0.0205612052,
-0.0169637501,
0.0820940435,
-0.0251117833,
0.0279563908,
0.0649437681,
-0.0414661281,
-0.0266183335,
-0.0256464593,
0.0696067512,
-0.0370654613,
-0.0144914435,
0.0336330235,
0.0558019504,
-0.0332243815,
-0.0136324028,
0.0362645015,
-0.0082429964,
0.0322898291,
0.017460214,
0.0126838405,
-0.0639940947,
-0.0296544824,
0.0019541411,
0.0278170872,
0.0214455947,
0.019835256,
-0.0090343477,
0.0184040461,
0.0243908502,
-0.0084936954,
0.0233033337,
-0.0033527585,
-0.0730116218,
-0.0532976873,
0.0253188182,
-0.0452814028,
0.0090231942,
-0.0297198035,
-0.0266895518,
0.036033351,
-0.046187479,
0.0137540065,
2.186910583e-34,
0.0601610988,
-0.003769753,
0.0100347763,
0.0097404001,
0.0465524904,
-0.0174315032,
-0.0356242023,
0.0069249677,
0.0093140136,
-0.0945489183,
-0.0381889194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12568v1 | Schema-Guided Semantic Accuracy: Faithfulness in Task-Oriented Dialogue Response Generation | 2023-01-29T22:32:48 | 2023-01-29T22:32:48 | Jinghong Chen, Weizhe Lin, Bill Byrne | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ensuring that generated utterances are faithful to dialogue actions is
crucial for Task-Oriented Dialogue Response Generation. Slot Error Rate (SER)
only partially measures generation quality in that it solely assesses
utterances generated from non-categorical slots whose values are expected to be
reproduced exactly. Utterances generated from categorical slots, which are more
variable, are not assessed by SER. We propose Schema-Guided Semantic Accuracy
(SGSAcc) to evaluate utterances generated from both categorical and
non-categorical slots by recognizing textual entailment. We show that SGSAcc
can be applied to evaluate utterances generated from a wide range of dialogue
actions in the Schema Guided Dialogue (SGD) dataset with good agreement with
human judgment. We also identify a previously overlooked weakness in generating
faithful utterances from categorical slots in unseen domains. We show that
prefix tuning applied to T5 generation can address this problem. We further
build an ensemble of prefix-tuning and fine-tuning models that achieves the
lowest SER reported and high SGSAcc on the SGD dataset. | [
0.0595283881,
0.0361595526,
-0.0056269905,
0.0380207077,
-0.0054036672,
-0.0266180821,
-0.0074798455,
-0.0149257686,
-0.0197159126,
-0.0624741316,
-0.0389277712,
-0.0400576144,
0.0191805921,
0.0362852886,
0.0009330854,
-0.0342142582,
0.0588894002,
0.0203317069,
-0.0108377971,
0.0179005507,
0.0010636454,
-0.0004639916,
-0.0450623147,
0.0662328973,
-0.0170013271,
0.0106171975,
-0.0192246549,
0.0401170552,
0.0128987608,
-0.0111223226,
0.0397077873,
0.0718597323,
-0.0115685472,
0.0190871265,
0.0000020239,
-0.0701017082,
0.0114940032,
-0.0516254231,
-0.0221204292,
-0.0127470745,
-0.0357818268,
0.0253829081,
0.0145993084,
0.0203761533,
-0.0445827022,
0.0037576049,
0.0740874633,
0.0538908467,
0.0734258369,
0.0856295303,
-0.001093308,
0.0082743196,
-0.012279124,
-0.0168239083,
-0.0017233533,
-0.0262868386,
-0.0253192987,
0.0458807796,
-0.0214026868,
0.0251285434,
-0.0057175383,
-0.0120811751,
-0.0055313976,
-0.0260430742,
0.011023907,
-0.0093987873,
-0.0260455105,
-0.0330595076,
-0.0166476928,
0.0620402917,
0.0431904793,
0.0050765737,
-0.0097809397,
-0.0275573544,
-0.0084469747,
-0.0083152074,
-0.0128528513,
0.0202383064,
-0.033260826,
-0.0063636932,
0.0148616005,
0.0610469878,
-0.0481783114,
-0.0058968347,
0.0089935577,
0.0435789898,
-0.0084318276,
-0.0358750783,
-0.0403059497,
0.0137060611,
-0.0190633517,
-0.0633460283,
-0.0119611453,
0.0015605675,
-0.0821970031,
0.029200526,
-0.0742533654,
-0.0212073717,
0.0447888002,
-0.0086526582,
0.0647155941,
0.067125164,
-0.0088179158,
-0.0428670347,
0.0266803429,
0.095741421,
-0.0146558573,
-0.0019311679,
-0.0564905964,
0.0059314254,
-0.0339034311,
-0.0010143698,
-0.0423634052,
0.022461785,
-0.0931843221,
-0.0357065722,
-0.0783005655,
0.0413379744,
0.0025428806,
0.000785784,
0.002873376,
0.0311825685,
-0.0453962497,
0.0066419123,
-0.0649906695,
-0.0035931133,
-0.0088540604,
0.0315466523,
0.010764054,
-0.0405456051,
-0.012678043,
0.0418218337,
0.0104554724,
-0.0274020508,
-0.0114390217,
0.0530069247,
-0.0227712877,
0.008727341,
-0.0272446498,
-0.0805540606,
-0.0621839911,
-0.0616848841,
-0.0368023291,
-0.0303992461,
0.0239774268,
0.0032083285,
-0.0331311114,
-0.0021823996,
0.0104117095,
0.0314949937,
-0.0032930854,
0.0225928817,
-0.0076322746,
0.0109016933,
-0.0000966193,
0.0123340264,
-0.0414899699,
0.0304116905,
0.0318262577,
0.0399870463,
0.0209165756,
-0.0002914146,
-0.0153333284,
-0.022276165,
0.0322361439,
-0.0024631941,
0.0302035902,
0.0411685966,
0.0149803692,
0.0174972117,
0.0435729288,
0.0508427136,
-0.0390932038,
-0.003991846,
0.0655112267,
0.039468307,
0.0148486132,
-0.0169065744,
0.0319737457,
0.0409554578,
-0.0078586433,
0.0373443291,
-0.028814096,
0.0231440235,
-0.0283288676,
0.0184744298,
0.0622564554,
0.0039258413,
-0.0160199869,
-0.0559440292,
-0.0181560963,
0.0245339908,
-0.0136357546,
-0.0238645095,
-0.0261304453,
0.0161237922,
-0.061778117,
0.0519420579,
0.0038997391,
-0.09464176,
-0.0392100736,
-0.0303202812,
0.0303197298,
0.0752846152,
0.0417000949,
0.0047998228,
-0.0904885083,
0.0018505774,
0.0021419504,
0.1016276181,
0.0252762903,
-0.0225140769,
0.0303239133,
-0.0440217704,
-0.0093259243,
-0.0115482593,
-0.0033232688,
0.0075599267,
0.0168874525,
-0.0099548353,
0.046852652,
0.0149675757,
0.0232499484,
0.0209941957,
-0.0005337247,
-0.0062291166,
0.0230132397,
0.0123764891,
0.0641682297,
0.0149963638,
-0.0067136749,
0.0090835756,
-0.008755099,
-0.001277259,
-0.026028052,
0.0085011162,
-0.0948662683,
-0.048093807,
0.0139502743,
-0.0097547472,
0.0097465441,
-0.0054244883,
-0.0101618543,
-0.0566685423,
0.0005787333,
-0.0439906344,
-0.0300008934,
-0.0903768316,
0.0103056896,
0.0320300497,
0.0316027403,
-0.0384590887,
0.0560158044,
0.0088153658,
0.0201952942,
0.0562273152,
-0.0096343402,
0.0383473113,
-0.0506466068,
0.0257795341,
-0.0005567052,
-0.0333915763,
0.0292757824,
0.0532719046,
0.0286055785,
-0.0775322169,
-0.0234214235,
-0.1185059845,
0.0281112287,
-0.002992372,
0.0176989026,
0.0165792555,
0.0027493993,
-0.0118510853,
0.0031803118,
-0.0538351126,
-0.0349215418,
0.0557492264,
-0.0047668819,
0.0328694694,
-0.0000038539,
-0.0303948056,
-0.0467823297,
0.0450701192,
0.0160033572,
0.0248285588,
-0.0012989554,
0.007282678,
-0.0339700691,
0.0430396385,
-0.0278254915,
0.0064510722,
0.0099808602,
-0.0418735743,
0.0316055454,
0.0614703,
0.0161523819,
0.0082207248,
0.0531234704,
0.0171675496,
-0.0154672619,
-0.0432066023,
-0.0426468402,
0.0351531766,
-0.0222424436,
-0.0072205211,
-0.0129385032,
-0.0304668248,
0.0427094772,
0.042714905,
0.068022415,
0.0372397378,
-0.0675956234,
0.0022538756,
0.0220057145,
-0.0541759916,
0.0113289477,
-0.0421391502,
-0.0403132588,
0.0476068743,
-0.0201094281,
-0.0249106251,
0.0375972316,
-0.0546050929,
-0.0083332788,
-0.0615731329,
0.0010945215,
-0.0206888244,
0.0666254684,
-0.0408291891,
0.0379480571,
0.0806549937,
-0.0317846946,
-0.0266397875,
-0.0286124218,
0.0217422564,
-0.025445234,
0.0881805345,
-0.0264283847,
0.0175161306,
-0.0266625974,
-0.0323717967,
-0.0908016562,
-0.0242499597,
0.0159226935,
-0.0021757374,
0.0153153632,
-0.0483690277,
0.0334944464,
0.0259305742,
0.003236305,
0.0409352146,
-0.0140199466,
-0.0085943546,
-0.0199324656,
0.0535931326,
0.0293046739,
0.0474021696,
-0.0341107547,
-0.0069103409,
0.0357839391,
0.0336949304,
-0.0030163291,
0.0143754659,
-0.0298226569,
-0.0012376909,
-0.0015390083,
-0.0129499519,
-0.0059453882,
0.0316263884,
0.0606874898,
-0.0020734179,
-0.0129992235,
0.1098809317,
0.0202253517,
0.0477080159,
0.0070233191,
-0.015662495,
0.0343549438,
-0.0017092988,
0.0060340129,
-0.110127598,
-0.0560120605,
0.0048689097,
-0.0000201516,
-0.0384875312,
-0.0248506144,
-0.0362407155,
-0.1236177087,
0.0762133747,
0.0144342016,
-0.075306356,
-0.0366411097,
0.0275653992,
0.0287012234,
0.0251209941,
0.0509078801,
0.0252365172,
0.0084747234,
-0.0102969194,
0.0404312462,
-0.0021453148,
-0.0338290557,
0.0234270152,
-0.0387880281,
0.0650212765,
0.0075436817,
0.031847056,
0.0477223881,
0.0057959631,
-0.0122745587,
-0.0187338796,
0.0144296614,
0.0112215159,
0.038486518,
-0.0086603928,
0.0122566959,
-0.0076360507,
0.0252136998,
-0.0087718554,
-0.013631193,
0.0052075037,
0.0349341854,
-0.0742418543,
0.0278739296,
-0.0353836305,
0.0415601619,
0.035616871,
0.0669331327,
0.042634394,
-0.0274313334,
-0.0077449083,
0.0270834044,
-0.0046823584,
-0.0781319961,
0.0208749566,
0.0143117141,
-0.0011242437,
0.0056451065,
-0.1035939828,
-0.0522116609,
0.0048758113,
0.0233023483,
-0.0239147935,
-0.0052439747,
-0.0120689441,
0.0037227229,
-0.0346564539,
0.0034616608,
-0.0354310535,
0.0067224097,
-0.0488194712,
-0.0236786827,
0.0352891348,
-0.0452957787,
-0.0129891727,
0.0568420999,
-0.0822899193,
-0.0455857888,
-0.0391448364,
0.0298220254,
0.0271241944,
0.0237365924,
0.0423233956,
0.0450932272,
0.0035130805,
0.0542383417,
-0.0369083136,
0.0231578909,
0.0400417894,
0.0017581451,
-0.0136023415,
0.031814076,
-0.0081797587,
0.0476600006,
-0.0053124945,
0.0667418912,
0.0384770297,
-0.0990751162,
0.0359593853,
0.0252741408,
-0.0082044965,
-0.0012481324,
-0.0205655657,
-0.0324977003,
0.0475720875,
-0.008671836,
-0.0285485573,
-0.0419708192,
-0.0065968893,
-0.02002999,
-0.0145079829,
0.0148064839,
-0.0387332328,
-0.0766328499,
0.0576137677,
-0.0082481727,
-0.0226788931,
-0.0106303915,
0.0176807586,
-0.0000218815,
-0.0013440041,
-0.0577097461,
-0.0091976048,
0.0157646183,
0.0478222966,
0.0184854753,
0.0591314957,
0.0078670606,
-0.0102397995,
-0.0129171116,
0.0369428992,
-0.021944901,
-0.032014735,
-0.0454101078,
-0.0109794484,
0.0330358557,
0.0146785742,
0.0324101299,
-0.0383014679,
0.0480404235,
-0.0023301593,
0.0640933812,
0.018074492,
-0.0036614719,
0.025236154,
-0.0148201184,
-0.0329139717,
0.0040119765,
0.0635673702,
-0.0117607741,
0.0007524745,
-0.0050256136,
0.0022774898,
-0.0648276657,
-0.0694882572,
0.0131615447,
0.0105845602,
-0.0105738202,
-0.0123041375,
-0.0451766625,
-0.036138352,
0.0408172235,
0.0158810094,
0.024137659,
-0.0002045284,
0.0292468425,
0.0497672968,
0.0043687988,
-0.0151350684,
-0.0114800092,
-0.0265698731,
-0.0326752625,
0.0119795743,
-0.075824976,
-6.095373509e-33,
-0.0598256961,
-0.0407226719,
0.0306925531,
0.0146577731,
-0.0167345982,
-0.0083621209,
-0.0535122082,
0.013557313,
0.0084067453,
-0.0115172537,
0.0111616524,
-0.0331334434,
0.0192787554,
0.0542211421,
-0.0130445035,
-0.0062349644,
0.0242388807,
0.0194352735,
-0.0474684797,
0.0154256318,
0.0514813736,
-0.0222659428,
0.035087727,
-0.0500499979,
0.0091336155,
0.0132609475,
-0.0384413265,
0.0074250163,
0.0076474492,
0.0583722405,
-0.016281601,
0.0426301993,
0.021663934,
-0.0404924378,
-0.0130149461,
0.0535752214,
-0.0371989682,
-0.0380675867,
0.0642475262,
-0.0231302474,
-0.0260274671,
-0.0036217305,
-0.0090652946,
-0.0054483768,
-0.0595743135,
0.0144346366,
-0.0090468423,
-0.033239767,
0.0164542049,
-0.0490311719,
-0.0966305733,
0.0049665985,
0.023458058,
-0.0766423047,
-0.0603141412,
0.0848744139,
-0.0012064273,
-0.031597577,
0.0082946476,
0.022628719,
0.0025928598,
0.0170466844,
0.0117937308,
0.0460036173,
-0.0278519187,
0.0887824669,
0.0278486293,
-0.0006223187,
0.0161554404,
-0.0076964763,
-0.0170591101,
0.0408241041,
0.0055179787,
0.0359027386,
-0.0079382733,
0.0095226904,
-0.0233741552,
0.0443461686,
0.0091147898,
-0.0095348069,
0.0542944074,
0.000908842,
-0.0418565944,
-0.0060718539,
-0.023064632,
0.0403986759,
-0.0336888656,
-0.0389661156,
0.0487197898,
0.0082594631,
0.0032961564,
0.0034228079,
0.0653329492,
-0.0124893235,
0.046520941,
0.0326470621,
-0.0507941395,
0.0012063156,
-0.0342948698,
-0.0073811426,
-0.0194096379,
-0.0426643379,
0.0748044774,
0.0131000774,
-0.005567438,
0.0135163544,
-0.0009809767,
0.013724396,
-0.0403899066,
0.0286840443,
-0.0289761834,
0.0508334264,
-0.0641465932,
0.0232131351,
-0.0064716218,
0.002204384,
-0.050934542,
0.0645334199,
-0.0363335311,
-0.0185185224,
-0.0406899117,
-0.0141009549,
0.0024070463,
0.0342990644,
-0.0232522171,
0.0333876945,
-0.0107665677,
-0.053872142,
-0.0352318659,
-0.022416126,
-0.0013287375,
-0.0174498465,
2.82e-7,
-0.0180636365,
0.0213684905,
0.0356366262,
0.0467375517,
-0.0169602334,
0.0523640588,
0.0408162959,
0.0542242005,
0.0252010431,
-0.0272605103,
0.0388559364,
-0.042597875,
0.041778937,
0.0166672226,
-0.0714187399,
0.0032384209,
-0.0790157542,
-0.0160817821,
-0.011096511,
0.0285390634,
0.0677051395,
0.0556765459,
-0.0133449649,
-0.020872917,
0.0122918244,
-0.0191469789,
0.048234351,
-0.0152258342,
-0.0351306349,
0.0481142551,
-0.0052645826,
-0.0049609169,
0.0261241701,
0.0341157466,
0.006583753,
0.0138066746,
-0.003662314,
0.0280542951,
-0.0048380452,
-0.0592066795,
-0.0368060805,
-0.0051390082,
0.0234201755,
-0.0326286778,
-0.00437079,
-0.0254644435,
-0.0058657266,
-0.0039769444,
-0.0293745492,
0.0099244863,
-0.0074321511,
-0.0183442067,
-0.0168898478,
0.0187709965,
0.0285853222,
0.0237603486,
-0.0119384266,
-0.0574862361,
-0.040797554,
0.0070513748,
-0.0434039198,
-0.0443598889,
0.0113705071,
-0.0290665161,
0.001242279,
-0.0438699201,
-0.019098632,
2.783016855e-34,
0.0418350324,
0.0184466839,
0.0285624154,
0.0210206844,
0.0446550101,
0.0074319015,
0.0047228513,
0.0042592641,
0.0403198712,
-0.020937724,
-0.0340475775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12566v1 | Improving Cross-lingual Information Retrieval on Low-Resource Languages via Optimal Transport Distillation | 2023-01-29T22:30:36 | 2023-01-29T22:30:36 | Zhiqi Huang, Puxuan Yu, James Allan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Benefiting from transformer-based pre-trained language models, neural ranking
models have made significant progress. More recently, the advent of
multilingual pre-trained language models provides great support for designing
neural cross-lingual retrieval models. However, due to unbalanced pre-training
data in different languages, multilingual language models have already shown a
performance gap between high and low-resource languages in many downstream
tasks. And cross-lingual retrieval models built on such pre-trained models can
inherit language bias, leading to suboptimal result for low-resource languages.
Moreover, unlike the English-to-English retrieval task, where large-scale
training collections for document ranking such as MS MARCO are available, the
lack of cross-lingual retrieval data for low-resource language makes it more
challenging for training cross-lingual retrieval models. In this work, we
propose OPTICAL: Optimal Transport distillation for low-resource Cross-lingual
information retrieval. To transfer a model from high to low resource languages,
OPTICAL forms the cross-lingual token alignment task as an optimal transport
problem to learn from a well-trained monolingual retrieval model. By separating
the cross-lingual knowledge from knowledge of query document matching, OPTICAL
only needs bitext data for distillation training, which is more feasible for
low-resource languages. Experimental results show that, with minimal training
data, OPTICAL significantly outperforms strong baselines on low-resource
languages, including neural machine translation. | [
0.0236902907,
0.0541953035,
0.0069619529,
0.0455614291,
-0.0114723984,
-0.0150608281,
-0.0077166413,
-0.0027953696,
-0.0273264665,
-0.0029302698,
-0.0558506809,
-0.0321008824,
-0.020887848,
-0.0135073792,
0.0053898375,
-0.0257169623,
0.0539575219,
-0.0036970244,
-0.0436756909,
-0.0171316322,
-0.0007590857,
0.0132109085,
0.0237164069,
-0.0108337868,
0.031678807,
-0.0019730187,
-0.0028641457,
0.0151146455,
-0.0003551576,
0.0003449687,
0.0166540314,
0.0197156612,
0.0473390482,
0.044123143,
0.000001725,
-0.0266692042,
-0.0437646993,
0.0053266366,
0.0008057595,
-0.032333836,
0.0256421305,
-0.0280565824,
0.0369248949,
0.0102696139,
-0.0021856772,
-0.0296217985,
0.0499030203,
0.0442267545,
0.0654003248,
0.0827473775,
-0.0015788724,
-0.0125648482,
0.0351517797,
-0.0333913714,
0.0135310758,
-0.0369651392,
-0.0041038636,
0.0013145308,
-0.0313122161,
0.0745197758,
-0.0239220299,
0.0355705842,
-0.0069314199,
0.009114827,
-0.004576514,
0.0122527797,
-0.0729299858,
0.0084237438,
0.0143561251,
0.0956301242,
-0.0423951149,
-0.018240964,
-0.0237375069,
0.0404628776,
-0.0227511935,
-0.015534373,
-0.044771973,
-0.0064831856,
0.0144519238,
0.0124198683,
0.0310860202,
0.0093264086,
0.0357194543,
0.0171424486,
-0.0494271815,
0.0558570959,
0.0280829929,
-0.0257909913,
0.0266315117,
0.0023039696,
0.0291041788,
-0.0060168407,
0.0451564118,
-0.0127717098,
-0.0098088598,
-0.0114301899,
-0.015079652,
-0.0400521606,
0.0009890811,
-0.0386165231,
-0.0094053978,
0.0675411299,
-0.0435039327,
0.0506828353,
-0.0559328832,
0.080455333,
-0.0340952501,
0.039882917,
-0.0607026815,
-0.0583179146,
-0.0029366529,
-0.0121916542,
-0.035432633,
0.0266634617,
-0.0752303973,
0.004669507,
-0.0333304182,
-0.0050072907,
0.0106626675,
-0.0388484932,
0.0379744358,
-0.0162434671,
-0.0502073579,
-0.0164694674,
-0.0351901576,
0.0813456401,
0.0019195343,
-0.0197778754,
-0.022786811,
-0.0080117332,
-0.0159668159,
0.0261259731,
-0.0000376323,
-0.0615099296,
0.0169958118,
0.0565673187,
-0.0408809036,
-0.00940709,
-0.0053672013,
0.0092037097,
0.0284182932,
-0.0498103127,
0.0291725695,
-0.0599073432,
0.0577455424,
0.0229812805,
0.0384179428,
-0.0293664038,
0.0119135445,
0.0154429739,
-0.0491664596,
0.0454993322,
0.0307358652,
-0.0088190995,
0.0178087223,
-0.019386353,
0.0202832241,
0.0494561903,
-0.0166022461,
0.0167923048,
0.0453164317,
0.0116334045,
-0.0446612649,
0.0286319349,
0.038799271,
0.0167561825,
-0.0042367312,
0.0066187335,
-0.0059533473,
0.0243982766,
0.0912292153,
0.0463804342,
-0.0625979677,
-0.0166211203,
0.027669616,
0.0150704365,
0.0615281798,
-0.0042990288,
0.0136962272,
-0.0139005166,
-0.080722034,
0.0040347395,
-0.0052306494,
0.045539394,
0.0391640961,
-0.0078042601,
0.0654112622,
0.0605514869,
-0.0605023839,
-0.0090670306,
0.0455377251,
0.0050767981,
-0.0335591175,
-0.0095048128,
0.0669672787,
0.0015168136,
-0.014339406,
0.1147072986,
0.0236290563,
-0.0495243147,
0.0342538208,
-0.0318465941,
-0.0454493128,
0.0432128906,
0.0170383789,
-0.0042705005,
-0.000916735,
0.012418652,
0.0480205752,
0.0113944532,
0.0508980006,
-0.0036664703,
0.0278666224,
-0.0556381457,
-0.0339247994,
-0.0084466003,
-0.009495127,
0.0171884447,
-0.0070293327,
0.0496535189,
0.0636119395,
-0.0945738256,
-0.0408736356,
0.0176734477,
-0.0423758142,
-0.0281058941,
0.0133253196,
0.0451651886,
0.0059686708,
-0.0026992257,
0.0009117607,
0.0022895373,
0.0165230744,
-0.0282266382,
0.0165257268,
-0.0219054185,
-0.0331870541,
-0.0240834039,
0.0404513031,
-0.0407719575,
0.0392849073,
0.0537647381,
-0.0367115624,
-0.0326492041,
0.014351015,
0.0217418987,
0.0159639101,
-0.035399016,
0.0456832685,
0.0133004831,
0.008721862,
-0.032994885,
0.0334588215,
0.0123286583,
0.0671201572,
-0.015712712,
-0.0414951742,
0.0489339493,
-0.0349837989,
-0.039837651,
0.0041828933,
-0.0167158339,
0.0334837995,
0.0477837473,
0.0123790083,
0.001494221,
0.0029906631,
-0.0773341954,
0.0160465054,
-0.0397398062,
0.0047104671,
0.0101867113,
0.0561564788,
0.0244024713,
-0.0278691109,
-0.0576302372,
-0.0052968287,
0.0125499209,
0.0241399873,
0.026860049,
-0.0030622722,
0.0473025888,
-0.0439649001,
-0.0555381551,
0.0054257219,
0.0291109718,
-0.0551898852,
-0.0229725875,
-0.0333256572,
0.0248143803,
-0.0518678986,
0.0409659371,
-0.0259450525,
-0.0352837108,
-0.0272933207,
-0.0176606402,
0.0123797925,
0.0285078697,
0.0010802264,
-0.0798188671,
0.0393851958,
-0.0188049078,
-0.0839145482,
0.0216570981,
-0.0294572096,
0.0201704595,
-0.0097333156,
-0.0331859253,
0.0099791316,
0.0345000327,
-0.0537664816,
-0.0203162599,
-0.0219110679,
-0.0355722718,
-0.0099765379,
0.0120953172,
-0.0485948883,
0.0176079758,
0.0221683662,
0.0180740952,
-0.0549096987,
-0.006126577,
0.0631693229,
-0.0261199977,
0.0095630158,
-0.0530273579,
0.0137467822,
-0.0600859411,
0.0143480776,
-0.0141213033,
0.0589741655,
-0.0519772545,
-0.017672848,
-0.0483626314,
0.0180331301,
0.0024632553,
-0.0202551931,
0.0233066455,
0.0029691674,
0.0168342926,
-0.0308352876,
-0.0912213773,
-0.0135738719,
-0.0330813527,
0.0253800806,
0.011806149,
0.0360871889,
-0.0058306782,
-0.0793431699,
0.0467552692,
0.0231262073,
0.0755216628,
-0.0186421368,
-0.0015797812,
-0.016563708,
0.0437243469,
0.0385164693,
-0.0193455461,
-0.0160884839,
-0.0192389134,
0.0009416749,
0.023883326,
0.0582759902,
-0.0556423627,
0.0018538327,
0.0034455371,
0.0699867979,
0.0000709038,
-0.0470076874,
-0.0626033023,
0.0298049115,
0.0104503939,
-0.032026086,
0.0555232987,
0.0071795029,
-0.0570028424,
-0.0373115093,
-0.0220972411,
0.0221696161,
0.026491059,
0.065543212,
-0.0757112503,
0.0028427485,
0.0057527996,
0.0106863454,
0.0538405627,
0.0096910698,
-0.0022012126,
-0.0968878791,
-0.0049999016,
0.0047779088,
-0.0336528234,
-0.0466438644,
-0.0516749546,
-0.0206905138,
-0.0438239314,
0.0400643423,
0.0126587767,
0.0083475681,
-0.0193846785,
0.0029303788,
0.0612793714,
-0.0236623921,
-0.0099294139,
-0.0667672679,
-0.0184710398,
0.0363275371,
0.0443833135,
-0.0160915516,
-0.0399958976,
0.0418618172,
-0.014949427,
-0.0253317468,
-0.0067806616,
0.0574494116,
-0.0173291638,
-0.0225720368,
0.0037264957,
-0.0201053899,
-0.0309754666,
0.0255280063,
-0.0356307775,
0.0358847044,
0.0193455145,
0.0331505425,
-0.0051477356,
-0.0283171777,
-0.0151023967,
0.0402439013,
-0.0386046246,
0.0008090368,
-0.016730627,
-0.0201073922,
0.051094193,
-0.0354542062,
-0.0096315127,
0.0088819265,
-0.0382701494,
-0.0086017372,
-0.0649969801,
-0.0270142201,
-0.0291917771,
0.0408242494,
0.0036759491,
0.018052252,
-0.0377490036,
-0.0314405933,
-0.0298858043,
0.0470133461,
-0.0321508273,
0.0043856818,
-0.052740559,
0.0402333438,
0.0339165442,
-0.0370674059,
-0.0250390396,
-0.058113195,
-0.0255746413,
-0.0546300933,
-0.0375180542,
0.053204529,
0.0112844845,
0.0437735058,
-0.0325846076,
-0.030458279,
0.0446940027,
0.0281615462,
-0.0446778983,
-0.0201185979,
0.010809605,
-0.0581568219,
-0.0318375267,
0.0277926773,
-0.0505249836,
0.0006231869,
0.0027799911,
0.066310674,
-0.0118165081,
-0.0110494941,
0.0470773913,
0.0254410803,
0.0788013116,
0.016302146,
0.0541842543,
-0.0716099218,
0.0516307168,
0.0004160984,
-0.0298004113,
-0.0211044569,
-0.0071149846,
0.067206189,
0.007777229,
0.0099775949,
0.0326557197,
0.0290031843,
-0.0058718272,
-0.0317632779,
-0.0267337058,
-0.0017578993,
0.0160519332,
0.0170415547,
0.022779014,
-0.0146740582,
-0.0021875487,
0.0286283772,
0.0609093085,
-0.0788821802,
-0.0026871671,
0.0316387229,
0.0177694317,
-0.0310041364,
0.0319516063,
-0.0400530361,
-0.0397262685,
-0.0271497741,
-0.0347331651,
0.0823711008,
-0.0348752737,
0.0347280242,
0.0296589639,
-0.0249947887,
-0.0108147953,
-0.041100014,
0.0078704376,
0.0304629039,
-0.0071397559,
0.0276715346,
0.0150433807,
0.035524901,
0.0903590992,
-0.0014721534,
0.0103684254,
-0.0264954939,
-0.0184595641,
-0.007024297,
0.01189542,
0.0188627262,
0.0119461752,
-0.0220371168,
-0.0305717308,
0.0065291808,
-0.055115588,
0.0035758666,
0.0038939307,
-0.0317194238,
-0.0036025122,
0.0376594812,
0.1175949201,
-0.0018978484,
-0.0158381686,
-0.0430521145,
-0.0473857932,
0.0190474838,
-0.024480015,
0.0085418727,
-5.928045195e-33,
-0.003070185,
0.045637548,
0.0281053428,
-0.035613779,
-0.0187295396,
0.0053637559,
-0.0042187874,
-0.0524870679,
-0.0711508021,
0.022229597,
-0.0195695776,
0.0170792099,
0.0200558081,
0.0197174065,
0.0004835199,
0.0349040255,
0.0500168167,
0.0055313818,
-0.0289219338,
0.0150292544,
0.0563357249,
0.0473055318,
0.0407375805,
-0.0374743864,
0.0188662317,
-0.014866679,
0.0302468687,
0.0384589694,
0.0427126959,
0.0452476032,
-0.0000679864,
0.0139904618,
0.0253883041,
-0.0203842968,
0.0189789422,
0.0074704848,
-0.1110620275,
-0.0468730107,
0.0109454878,
-0.0039457078,
-0.0058696228,
-0.0136110857,
0.0243833195,
-0.0207137968,
0.0133037092,
0.0208066497,
0.0335865542,
0.0096794767,
-0.0269515701,
-0.0341543891,
-0.0425475575,
-0.0000510482,
0.0095594628,
-0.0059417323,
0.0455334075,
0.0952783078,
0.0002667418,
0.0509099625,
-0.0621531829,
0.0464489013,
-0.0845869035,
0.0829033777,
0.0441871658,
0.0100477934,
-0.0459175594,
0.0240805335,
0.0194120985,
-0.012170394,
0.0861821622,
-0.0133172432,
0.0481177531,
0.0085788891,
0.0084663471,
0.0275436882,
0.0116427895,
-0.0262623839,
-0.0785226449,
0.0425308011,
-0.0427528843,
0.0378176495,
0.0054491847,
0.0256241485,
-0.017368637,
-0.0217323843,
-0.0542576797,
-0.0406096838,
-0.050695803,
-0.0287209749,
0.0032807165,
0.0388666764,
-0.0139373764,
-0.0294924639,
0.0721114874,
-0.0296418127,
-0.0445542149,
0.0281962547,
-0.0064646825,
-0.0258545838,
-0.0086467331,
0.0524302647,
-0.0619317703,
-0.050765425,
-0.0164892022,
-0.0031348115,
-0.0206073113,
0.0188558586,
0.0637204871,
-0.0010153858,
-0.0384693481,
0.0036816821,
-0.0381759256,
-0.0356377624,
-0.022961434,
0.0660409331,
0.0080804499,
0.0247915965,
-0.0023035256,
0.0461856425,
0.0616544485,
-0.005410396,
-0.0148083372,
-0.0531510264,
0.0300201233,
0.0429821908,
-0.0054655555,
0.0089133643,
-0.031411726,
0.0693906322,
0.0006031354,
-0.068496123,
-0.0193496048,
0.0413482599,
2.579e-7,
0.0534242131,
0.0101324013,
-0.0042464621,
0.000494614,
-0.0467194952,
-0.0128220879,
-0.0264036264,
0.0361201279,
0.0297916736,
-0.0010265097,
0.0154870674,
0.0120988879,
0.0255614948,
0.0060184188,
-0.0984777138,
-0.0012461578,
-0.0347661041,
-0.043554388,
-0.0314142033,
-0.0485479049,
-0.0180945937,
0.1029578075,
-0.0218962692,
0.011906934,
-0.0216758363,
-0.0570764616,
0.0726942644,
-0.0187956151,
-0.027596442,
0.0265796203,
0.0275238957,
0.0042185555,
-0.0285431761,
-0.0165058952,
-0.0351424366,
0.0512577668,
0.0537386239,
0.026210513,
-0.0304189734,
-0.0418758504,
0.019387858,
0.0033831978,
-0.0106738135,
-0.0599253476,
0.0351120941,
-0.0250284486,
0.0191938523,
0.0178707428,
-0.0515337922,
0.0359266363,
0.0548246466,
-0.0152152181,
-0.0438415632,
0.0330065936,
0.0420378111,
0.0125370929,
-0.0215678811,
-0.0489686616,
-0.0090843076,
0.0056472388,
-0.0003645072,
-0.0279873125,
-0.0039335443,
-0.0252589863,
0.0104373721,
0.0289330203,
0.0174448602,
2.063519721e-34,
0.0490400344,
0.0028076868,
-0.0048427917,
-0.016256649,
0.0208401848,
-0.0328356996,
-0.0429373272,
0.0057964562,
-0.0205767695,
-0.0433401428,
-0.0128651261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12564v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12564v2 | A Discerning Several Thousand Judgments: GPT-3 Rates the Article + Adjective + Numeral + Noun Construction | 2023-01-29T22:29:55 | 2023-02-03T19:48:52 | Kyle Mahowald | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge of syntax includes knowledge of rare, idiosyncratic constructions.
LLMs must overcome frequency biases in order to master such constructions. In
this study, I prompt GPT-3 to give acceptability judgments on the
English-language Article + Adjective + Numeral + Noun construction (e.g., "a
lovely five days"). I validate the prompt using the CoLA corpus of
acceptability judgments and then zero in on the AANN construction. I compare
GPT- 3's judgments to crowdsourced human judgments on a subset of sentences.
GPT-3's judgments are broadly similar to human judgments and generally align
with proposed constraints in the literature but, in some cases, GPT-3's
judgments and human judgments diverge from the literature and from each other. | [
0.0628413484,
0.0500110053,
-0.0368086956,
0.05035666,
-0.0377343222,
0.0090667987,
-0.0260388292,
-0.023566043,
-0.0400223769,
-0.0432573743,
-0.0480643846,
-0.0244118851,
0.026527591,
-0.0354962014,
0.0311615746,
-0.0081597799,
0.0190574378,
0.0188236441,
0.0244365744,
0.0071037225,
0.0430265516,
0.0164329056,
-0.0186722651,
0.0147256739,
-0.0279835146,
0.0040716287,
0.0060088425,
-0.0256132707,
-0.0284496043,
-0.0426735766,
0.009977363,
0.0539794602,
-0.006927161,
0.0035093203,
0.0000019165,
-0.0610175505,
0.044928994,
-0.0429034419,
-0.0103056952,
0.03522183,
0.0282238852,
0.0375709496,
0.018936811,
-0.0369567573,
-0.0415490977,
0.0162512008,
0.0377105325,
0.0408517681,
0.0029195147,
0.0536027327,
-0.0090162493,
-0.0240996014,
-0.0292022116,
0.0011329234,
0.0154174007,
-0.000583561,
-0.0014072558,
-0.0390024409,
0.025526233,
0.0082557807,
0.013863164,
-0.0046525216,
0.029575007,
-0.0081279287,
0.0112566371,
0.0171981007,
-0.0276474115,
-0.038010139,
-0.0039870292,
0.0144289332,
0.0781280473,
-0.0228582192,
-0.0192933995,
-0.0046138801,
0.0288684536,
0.0169040766,
-0.0491104946,
0.0260864813,
0.0051448196,
0.0308592822,
0.004771451,
-0.053985469,
-0.0150228096,
0.0112719778,
0.0566242523,
0.0845679045,
-0.0033688257,
-0.02769069,
0.0242017824,
0.0670886338,
-0.0142299151,
-0.040416535,
0.0150172152,
-0.0167932026,
-0.000480198,
0.0105222156,
0.0230946522,
-0.003362488,
0.0333952866,
-0.0438290425,
0.051389426,
-0.0060432632,
-0.0436348394,
0.0250487272,
-0.0047454559,
0.0392179452,
0.0113194827,
-0.0279328842,
-0.0328085534,
0.0659678727,
-0.0556089096,
-0.0127046471,
-0.0127036693,
0.0123211564,
0.0478022546,
0.0329235271,
-0.0682503879,
-0.0383173563,
0.0048351586,
0.0115777599,
0.0012101616,
0.01364002,
-0.0159539804,
0.0340679362,
-0.0472159833,
0.000532922,
-0.0654298291,
0.0784862489,
-0.0186530855,
-0.0632376745,
0.0039349138,
0.0092471959,
0.0064380891,
-0.0317057222,
-0.0133998273,
0.0224722065,
-0.0087018292,
0.0079336734,
-0.0180398319,
-0.0266876146,
-0.0610640943,
-0.0372046307,
-0.0060050106,
-0.070125185,
-0.0310976952,
0.0107623301,
-0.0060924543,
-0.0440625362,
0.0045771659,
0.0159967057,
-0.0057028215,
0.0233988892,
0.0088252742,
0.0192601569,
-0.0375757441,
-0.0069329995,
0.0065207272,
0.0435675383,
0.0435053781,
0.0373447649,
0.0371157937,
-0.0151582249,
0.0228595249,
0.0326428711,
-0.0434707478,
-0.0220351983,
0.0172598921,
0.0024480203,
-0.0662124157,
0.0409516171,
0.0396260992,
0.0829147026,
-0.0024731541,
-0.0382059067,
0.0846152082,
0.0149396174,
-0.0226772912,
0.0225207321,
0.0470435135,
0.00396526,
0.045762632,
0.0456834137,
-0.0385658257,
0.0224287827,
-0.0013934198,
0.0114684543,
-0.0394898318,
0.0313380845,
0.0091633648,
-0.0860272348,
-0.0640113577,
0.0289203115,
0.0069003883,
-0.0227094386,
-0.0088770408,
0.0195728913,
-0.0022572931,
-0.0231315661,
0.0250854623,
-0.0810276121,
0.0108069954,
-0.0107813412,
0.0319864862,
0.0148396129,
0.0081732757,
0.0316612981,
0.0127108227,
0.0007379505,
-0.0288098026,
0.0382099114,
0.0562263392,
-0.0001056606,
-0.012957314,
-0.0295241978,
0.0146033373,
-0.0227979254,
0.0117415925,
-0.0332834981,
-0.0294508282,
0.036074236,
-0.00571843,
-0.0659696683,
-0.017001912,
0.0242807176,
0.051651638,
-0.0516172945,
-0.0623426288,
0.0168191828,
0.0330818556,
0.0182260554,
0.0359834246,
0.0182119571,
-0.0014677143,
0.0089175813,
0.0064916485,
0.0397881418,
-0.0570854694,
0.002860693,
0.024212949,
-0.0679373294,
-0.0464972742,
-0.0123639386,
0.013982825,
-0.0270891879,
0.0095498171,
-0.0676226169,
0.0241552368,
-0.0392848626,
0.0005197664,
0.0001377583,
0.0050270525,
-0.0442852639,
0.0367799625,
-0.0079511041,
0.0474019274,
-0.0318297744,
-0.0729665086,
0.0309563726,
-0.0043126945,
-0.0664936751,
-0.0050664409,
0.0123717086,
-0.0039914604,
0.0207083784,
0.0233889967,
-0.0936070532,
-0.0338249914,
-0.0683141202,
-0.0248129442,
-0.0123380637,
0.0717362463,
0.005383037,
-0.0426949114,
-0.0218492374,
0.0271970257,
-0.0197711401,
-0.0031996057,
-0.0325661786,
0.0354024917,
0.0818070769,
0.0082202964,
-0.0310143791,
-0.0367220342,
0.0005919072,
-0.0397507362,
0.0001865223,
0.0255775191,
-0.0176628623,
-0.0095752692,
0.0706694052,
-0.0203816779,
-0.060721606,
0.0349044837,
-0.0670799464,
0.0337218232,
0.0354486629,
0.0569489226,
0.0221987311,
-0.0401821136,
0.0272415075,
0.0553664826,
-0.0302436519,
-0.0061508594,
-0.0361123607,
0.0002625785,
-0.0372891985,
-0.019835785,
-0.0472844951,
0.0251330938,
0.0721062869,
0.0501409359,
-0.0350787267,
0.0206277072,
0.0772975981,
-0.049147021,
-0.0338498279,
0.0061162226,
-0.0254844129,
-0.0333514698,
0.0568607114,
0.0000010778,
-0.0181129128,
0.0861547217,
-0.019072691,
-0.0462202169,
-0.0304339714,
0.0058166245,
-0.0305882432,
0.0067657623,
0.0324074924,
-0.015402968,
0.0557550415,
-0.0562997907,
-0.0610503107,
0.0136659294,
0.0421154387,
0.0111189056,
0.0700574443,
-0.0492099226,
-0.0088430848,
0.021673128,
-0.0458097532,
0.0023619176,
-0.013902518,
-0.0463418514,
-0.0006167981,
0.0042221639,
0.020517407,
-0.0026293672,
-0.0443292074,
0.0108009372,
-0.0130780376,
-0.0072435974,
-0.0186225083,
-0.0152710145,
0.0393079966,
0.0056033768,
0.0565607771,
0.0224306621,
0.0051270062,
-0.0437426679,
0.0651722774,
0.0006813863,
0.0711851418,
-0.0269165523,
0.0525270849,
0.0403993353,
-0.0250272918,
-0.0574249886,
0.0271440409,
0.0399227925,
-0.0487558842,
-0.0094880788,
0.0783945993,
0.0241104309,
-0.0470154881,
0.0353484191,
-0.0531796329,
0.0184907559,
0.0011414416,
0.0033955064,
-0.0760667026,
-0.004631307,
0.0148113547,
-0.0165404901,
-0.0318969637,
-0.006298298,
0.0042604748,
-0.0698466823,
0.0496306084,
-0.0042187124,
0.0147441393,
0.0050794194,
-0.0242649522,
0.0370806754,
-0.0053120926,
0.0318343528,
0.0270654839,
-0.0304753743,
0.0466070734,
0.0134007325,
-0.0018744246,
-0.0555894598,
0.0265599098,
0.0103740087,
0.0389644466,
0.0068773106,
0.025881689,
-0.0604637302,
-0.0629771724,
0.0208526645,
0.023226101,
0.0088843759,
-0.0116608692,
-0.0115450891,
0.0181006417,
0.001029182,
-0.0802962631,
0.0219294429,
-0.0168630928,
-0.01302124,
0.0145410243,
0.1033219025,
-0.0017441794,
-0.0665911883,
-0.003951415,
0.0054980377,
-0.0068737189,
0.0602776036,
0.0745455399,
-0.0066182385,
0.03244555,
-0.0192168262,
-0.0164355747,
-0.0183069203,
-0.0582820363,
0.0425548553,
-0.0273582321,
-0.0325193293,
-0.0898954421,
-0.0718760118,
0.0346351899,
0.0044556218,
0.0315130092,
-0.0449355654,
0.032559257,
-0.0135356896,
-0.0016896223,
0.0201319903,
0.0218579788,
-0.0048508197,
-0.0522391424,
0.0043621594,
0.0235989485,
0.0178146549,
-0.0329447351,
-0.0153875286,
-0.0056381025,
-0.0347493626,
0.0608752817,
0.0171143319,
0.0314345472,
-0.068859525,
0.0291201249,
-0.0600301661,
-0.0521816313,
0.0321683735,
0.0249781739,
0.0480616577,
-0.007748947,
-0.0236910488,
0.0384398587,
0.0219633859,
0.0048478027,
0.0412949771,
0.0158130061,
0.0126584433,
-0.0154099055,
-0.0140182646,
0.0495952293,
0.0421727784,
0.02044826,
-0.0091974856,
0.0723614022,
-0.0547720194,
-0.0270277895,
-0.0299485009,
-0.0111886207,
-0.0268134382,
-0.0213485695,
-0.0066020587,
0.0473083258,
-0.0743587986,
-0.0094834156,
-0.0304543041,
0.0336527936,
-0.0348076783,
0.0318030007,
0.0853188857,
-0.0241997689,
-0.0382921845,
0.0088817263,
-0.0140482532,
0.0087581985,
-0.0403597131,
0.027209308,
0.0094891014,
0.019754786,
0.0099637788,
-0.016003238,
-0.0042002867,
-0.0110008279,
0.0083177639,
0.0411301069,
0.0071380171,
-0.0024115071,
0.0229513105,
-0.0728580132,
0.0549692437,
-0.0432833545,
0.0311147925,
-0.0104617812,
-0.0001631441,
-0.0096035432,
-0.0163930524,
0.0299374554,
0.0197153948,
-0.0309544075,
-0.0627039745,
0.0548254997,
-0.0388369858,
-0.0333448611,
0.036849428,
-0.0239332393,
-0.0143296802,
-0.0183916241,
-0.0485612005,
-0.0315080434,
0.024570534,
-0.0223147217,
-0.0709072277,
-0.0468417257,
-0.0168417301,
0.0273970589,
0.0381298438,
-0.0411699712,
0.0032843465,
0.0757134259,
0.0117010521,
-0.0587153099,
-0.0137372948,
0.0170570519,
-0.0044757705,
0.007785032,
-0.0565619804,
-6.442686172e-33,
-0.0128947813,
-0.033356972,
-0.029998593,
0.0185927879,
-0.0314925499,
-0.0090273153,
-0.0198581722,
0.0634266436,
0.004024432,
0.0565141551,
-0.0410833731,
0.0042109308,
0.0247899089,
-0.0161490794,
0.0955943093,
0.0192871336,
0.0148072867,
-0.0197890569,
-0.0403593592,
-0.0559473261,
0.0214969069,
-0.0243178979,
0.1151843071,
-0.0125212371,
0.0828293115,
0.0034753524,
-0.0087982323,
-0.020609675,
-0.0015051413,
0.0481602326,
0.0306308456,
0.0671286806,
0.0454056673,
0.0039757667,
-0.0261857081,
-0.0121542793,
-0.0290709678,
-0.0587819666,
0.1021601632,
0.027425047,
0.0018813737,
-0.0528927147,
0.0589547157,
-0.0469909012,
-0.0433681607,
0.0335744843,
0.0438062027,
-0.0145111457,
0.0493972041,
-0.0064891055,
-0.027089294,
-0.0130665805,
0.0057660146,
0.037676204,
0.0044699665,
-0.0613781996,
-0.0193706304,
0.0240945611,
-0.055249799,
0.0263056178,
-0.0525755137,
0.0730050504,
0.0251784828,
-0.0921147913,
-0.0149774728,
0.0494300611,
0.0230297986,
0.0346127972,
-0.0439031869,
0.0262099709,
0.0311499964,
0.0442915633,
0.0464097112,
0.0629366785,
0.0805358887,
-0.0227807444,
-0.0193174798,
-0.0151044652,
0.0470893048,
0.0743226334,
0.0152849806,
0.0128169972,
-0.0813676715,
-0.0373078808,
0.0053336406,
-0.0108822305,
-0.0462597534,
-0.0383698493,
0.0264366996,
-0.0609896295,
0.0348847508,
-0.0121804196,
-0.0169026516,
0.0117106531,
-0.0418772362,
-0.0072177732,
-0.025460599,
0.0480602384,
-0.0009282046,
0.0199561268,
-0.0505212061,
0.040301919,
-0.0317696035,
0.0419647731,
0.047767058,
0.0289047193,
0.0193055402,
0.010285777,
-0.0558526069,
-0.0171232689,
-0.0317670479,
-0.0224137884,
-0.0080397725,
-0.0134899197,
0.0259940773,
0.0165025573,
-0.0064320872,
0.0127308955,
-0.0038427596,
-0.0107087111,
-0.0700124204,
-0.0231535863,
-0.0275132582,
0.0170586649,
-0.0194424372,
-0.0355276763,
-0.0223344117,
-0.0092246924,
0.0461018197,
-0.0004048469,
0.0070531094,
0.0071889684,
2.817e-7,
0.0434778705,
0.080333516,
-0.0182917528,
0.0188153945,
0.0055056624,
0.0148493424,
-0.0348866768,
0.0112141464,
0.033693742,
-0.0064222133,
0.0132130068,
0.002214863,
0.0020169641,
0.0431084335,
-0.0636052489,
0.0190019496,
-0.0187039729,
0.0223328248,
-0.0151621755,
-0.0051379646,
0.0543742888,
0.002825585,
0.0087737441,
0.0014744466,
-0.0408605523,
-0.0615334325,
0.0009204654,
-0.0346887857,
-0.0393318348,
0.0305396467,
0.085727185,
0.019456327,
0.0305405073,
0.0176244173,
0.0141586438,
-0.0146733234,
0.0371538363,
0.0447499193,
0.0263467561,
0.028221814,
-0.0005073559,
-0.0197233539,
-0.0211768094,
-0.0308025405,
0.0275621954,
-0.0363968052,
-0.0386907905,
-0.0049194712,
-0.0283604637,
-0.0229265783,
-0.0018443441,
0.0113194305,
-0.0369347669,
0.0210273843,
0.0204761233,
-0.0334049724,
-0.0049150707,
-0.0241504349,
-0.0392814651,
0.0315389931,
-0.0003891905,
-0.0758429021,
-0.0065478212,
-0.0201366078,
-0.0270242579,
-0.0457244143,
-0.0279768817,
2.011061679e-34,
0.0401722342,
-0.0355441235,
0.0921431184,
0.0202948526,
0.0173948519,
0.0199385639,
0.0331813432,
0.0310180318,
-0.0001182117,
-0.0438313559,
-0.0151307378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12534v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12534v4 | Vicarious Offense and Noise Audit of Offensive Speech Classifiers: Unifying Human and Machine Disagreement on What is Offensive | 2023-01-29T20:39:21 | 2023-11-09T13:46:40 | Tharindu Cyril Weerasooriya, Sujan Dutta, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri, Christopher M. Homan, Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Offensive speech detection is a key component of content moderation. However,
what is offensive can be highly subjective. This paper investigates how machine
and human moderators disagree on what is offensive when it comes to real-world
social web political discourse. We show that (1) there is extensive
disagreement among the moderators (humans and machines); and (2) human and
large-language-model classifiers are unable to predict how other human raters
will respond, based on their political leanings. For (1), we conduct a noise
audit at an unprecedented scale that combines both machine and human responses.
For (2), we introduce a first-of-its-kind dataset of vicarious offense. Our
noise audit reveals that moderation outcomes vary wildly across different
machine moderators. Our experiments with human moderators suggest that
political leanings combined with sensitive issues affect both first-person and
vicarious offense. The dataset is available through
https://github.com/Homan-Lab/voiced. | [
0.0813807547,
0.0980115905,
-0.0205090344,
-0.011308223,
0.0007323183,
0.0267439224,
0.0340071134,
0.0112892129,
-0.0058809645,
-0.0518530421,
-0.0553366542,
-0.0130135547,
0.0043448871,
0.0162944496,
0.0126260547,
-0.0164473224,
0.0190321133,
0.0303451177,
0.0396947041,
-0.0280275289,
0.0761087909,
-0.0101214135,
0.0060232948,
0.0416589603,
-0.0229679737,
-0.0079968581,
0.0141618475,
0.0108903507,
0.0255689062,
0.0248189345,
0.039789252,
0.0467413887,
0.0219533928,
0.0743529052,
0.0000013747,
-0.0255016461,
0.0180649478,
-0.0037586845,
0.0231409762,
-0.0174893513,
0.0865089521,
0.0135370651,
-0.0362705998,
0.0544125438,
-0.0109810857,
0.0151421493,
0.0446468405,
0.0422787368,
0.0565946437,
0.0580528826,
-0.0083930306,
-0.0127365058,
-0.0289297029,
-0.0046339347,
-0.0368793681,
-0.0033168013,
0.0271029882,
-0.058193326,
-0.0805476978,
-0.0259345677,
-0.0032489011,
-0.0256712716,
0.0149702532,
-0.0039718677,
-0.0262065604,
-0.012448607,
-0.0107934698,
-0.0285439026,
0.0132673876,
0.0596082956,
0.0457692482,
-0.0301775336,
0.0124509782,
0.0118873725,
0.0336512774,
0.0190502573,
-0.0198862366,
0.027120946,
-0.0104699219,
0.0206432696,
-0.0070726075,
0.0064464509,
0.0379648544,
0.0891076103,
0.0873813704,
0.0042553763,
-0.0355300196,
-0.0422056392,
0.0146039324,
0.0183239803,
0.0435311124,
-0.0020611226,
0.0429855026,
-0.0038374511,
-0.0500079468,
-0.0032220378,
-0.0412014425,
-0.0052667656,
0.0469930694,
-0.0719740018,
0.0272036772,
0.0235707182,
-0.0538094155,
0.0385077186,
0.0416791141,
0.0249189027,
-0.011993235,
0.0437242575,
0.0075087608,
0.0011592811,
-0.0192051847,
0.0334526636,
0.0359527469,
-0.0061111557,
0.0044279238,
0.0358504727,
-0.0197804477,
-0.0113835288,
-0.086342901,
-0.0097969323,
-0.0150278797,
0.0079292534,
-0.0142113324,
0.017447181,
-0.0445412062,
0.0118004605,
-0.057336621,
0.0437258407,
-0.0136675676,
-0.0296468232,
0.0053701731,
0.009996823,
-0.013761472,
0.0017731001,
0.0516744591,
0.0447517782,
0.0526045114,
0.0256443098,
0.0296559166,
-0.0345730297,
-0.0173073616,
-0.0380089469,
-0.0080996985,
-0.0427070893,
0.0475366153,
-0.0067170039,
-0.0315792449,
-0.0605859905,
0.0144229354,
0.0199161097,
-0.0155063728,
0.0661561564,
0.021635104,
-0.0093811126,
0.0180594921,
0.0339774825,
-0.0100391163,
0.0493373089,
0.003067951,
0.0176895242,
0.0525019877,
0.0007551233,
0.0121138738,
0.0228904448,
0.0123425974,
0.0041767475,
-0.0394932553,
0.0008958799,
-0.0634554252,
-0.0325606763,
0.0366341397,
0.0699362531,
0.0002253653,
-0.0737282559,
0.0828775987,
0.0374604054,
-0.0703497082,
0.0503774434,
0.0191954039,
0.0060087522,
-0.0146783898,
0.0194256566,
-0.040020626,
-0.0105105005,
-0.0441129208,
-0.0603603087,
0.0406272188,
0.0439119153,
-0.0304923747,
-0.058004953,
-0.0004657772,
-0.0096577108,
0.0702715293,
-0.0246498585,
0.0171169303,
-0.0094989901,
-0.0065624751,
-0.0331746638,
0.0614865199,
-0.0285330769,
0.0153481252,
-0.0480761714,
0.0469355211,
0.0571022816,
0.0200608186,
-0.0259725265,
0.0245239213,
-0.0826274231,
0.0382716842,
0.0493693389,
0.0833995193,
-0.0451105982,
-0.0400712676,
-0.0149865197,
-0.0297915079,
0.0414270908,
-0.0025503938,
0.0392103307,
0.0404120125,
-0.0030004196,
-0.0293809306,
0.0353890322,
-0.0462089218,
0.0248643626,
0.0367263071,
-0.0204524957,
-0.0312275477,
0.0062851724,
0.0779447332,
0.0085430276,
-0.0455182157,
-0.038279742,
0.0157686044,
0.020363396,
-0.0405156501,
-0.0140588731,
0.0003853943,
0.0471021235,
0.0288764574,
-0.0207314696,
-0.0238614716,
0.0424130186,
0.0077622002,
0.0442344844,
0.0403001644,
-0.0072702966,
-0.0558845773,
-0.0331132896,
-0.0402252302,
-0.0809915066,
0.0103256302,
-0.0146887107,
0.0334540494,
-0.0068838927,
0.0113418698,
0.0099185575,
-0.0668287203,
-0.0028879885,
0.0184641872,
-0.0540151447,
-0.0140416734,
-0.0173748769,
0.0489035174,
0.0286858603,
-0.0300087389,
-0.044527106,
-0.0266804025,
-0.0477503873,
-0.0426644385,
-0.0190279093,
0.0100942189,
0.0281819999,
-0.0296149589,
0.0280286018,
0.0282122586,
-0.0179485194,
-0.0573570393,
-0.0087567214,
0.0437713228,
0.005832226,
-0.0594973825,
-0.0515699834,
-0.0243693646,
0.0050781034,
-0.0354168117,
0.0167027432,
0.0158351585,
-0.0237362012,
0.0239078049,
-0.0055623027,
-0.0562975258,
0.0035264657,
-0.0185763463,
-0.0695827007,
0.0371037088,
0.0404640324,
-0.0018788668,
0.0650136769,
0.0721465275,
0.089148961,
0.035181988,
0.0361670256,
-0.0370626822,
-0.0209635701,
0.0041061658,
0.0112550147,
-0.0467734858,
-0.0043385811,
0.0019675454,
0.0688730627,
0.010633762,
0.0146368127,
-0.0346781127,
0.0719732568,
-0.0468509868,
-0.0638815016,
-0.0175463874,
-0.0533772819,
-0.0259078909,
0.0177185293,
-0.0118885869,
-0.0531019941,
0.0896850154,
0.018992506,
0.0242416877,
-0.0007183909,
-0.0226612911,
0.0083130207,
0.0234899521,
-0.0232912749,
0.0175362397,
-0.0233721919,
0.0074176369,
-0.0135397753,
-0.0435303189,
0.0899055302,
-0.0609993376,
-0.0338111967,
-0.0291075949,
0.0121933157,
0.009803677,
-0.0715654194,
-0.0469897389,
-0.0478520244,
-0.0393387005,
-0.0192133337,
-0.0029042652,
-0.0008696642,
-0.0037860614,
0.0270634014,
0.0315959863,
-0.0719411075,
0.0175877269,
-0.0073164818,
0.0487891734,
-0.0166517776,
0.0095062489,
0.0432578996,
0.0253823809,
0.0079683475,
-0.0076436908,
0.0591162331,
0.0254755467,
0.0177034736,
0.0259989724,
-0.0044706925,
0.011434434,
0.0211110525,
0.0156588536,
-0.0020670826,
0.0406368673,
-0.0186790898,
0.011840974,
0.0551882572,
0.0221852586,
-0.0396502167,
-0.0229793079,
0.004984912,
-0.018552348,
0.0218594968,
-0.0161689017,
-0.0446013734,
0.0006708349,
0.009366041,
0.0339632593,
-0.0970135778,
-0.0261590946,
0.0061395378,
-0.0729954764,
0.0134603325,
-0.014346567,
-0.0383314863,
-0.0471523218,
-0.0271847434,
0.0287042875,
-0.0220829416,
0.0329011045,
-0.0165718552,
0.0662961155,
-0.0050464631,
0.0100105098,
-0.0360772014,
-0.0174881276,
0.0218263827,
-0.0297489055,
0.0681920275,
0.0391079821,
0.0665559545,
-0.0410875119,
-0.0321382806,
0.056013491,
0.0036840599,
-0.0323982313,
-0.0159805585,
0.0604067557,
0.0049476204,
-0.0226141531,
-0.0385645665,
0.0433884747,
0.0008667328,
0.0071705105,
-0.0201751161,
0.0309256744,
0.0338012911,
-0.0121525377,
-0.0415252112,
0.0443415269,
0.0223766305,
0.043283172,
0.0343016349,
-0.0938529298,
-0.0105182966,
-0.0564343594,
-0.0201794524,
-0.0147528118,
-0.0895431414,
-0.026233498,
0.0123711219,
-0.03797777,
-0.0548431985,
-0.0384434834,
-0.0308171511,
0.0118480753,
0.0306575298,
-0.0363607928,
0.0025801542,
-0.0114581781,
0.0059461338,
-0.0006281871,
-0.0083768256,
0.0334523506,
-0.0277313534,
-0.0261378307,
0.0029294973,
-0.0046147085,
-0.0516210049,
0.0278186947,
-0.0146956937,
-0.0451366454,
0.0641864613,
0.0290241539,
0.0159179829,
0.0230322871,
-0.0265332516,
-0.030075714,
0.0316438861,
0.0908088461,
-0.0437843464,
0.0011866724,
0.0721235499,
0.0178850703,
0.0019724821,
0.0035238173,
-0.0235800855,
0.0235224143,
0.0698137879,
-0.0649832711,
-0.0264998078,
-0.046333842,
-0.0041630869,
-0.0027534661,
0.0172092039,
0.0110662309,
-0.0536589622,
-0.0364671312,
-0.0553198159,
0.0211938526,
-0.0404642336,
0.0019385248,
-0.017648207,
0.0145364748,
-0.0259416364,
-0.0467717871,
0.0104329996,
-0.0488082543,
0.0376414843,
-0.0460257418,
0.0201810263,
0.0298210811,
0.0475300588,
-0.0013710037,
-0.0175753105,
-0.0248939171,
0.0140777789,
0.0354238525,
-0.0033458304,
0.0009279803,
0.0225576069,
0.0090841446,
0.0255468786,
0.0172325782,
-0.028018862,
-0.03515625,
-0.0001971308,
-0.013526299,
0.0068940227,
-0.0261202808,
0.0058272593,
0.013962416,
0.0334162265,
-0.0231933668,
-0.0099111134,
0.01430621,
-0.0172011778,
-0.0110430084,
0.0263951514,
0.0451631248,
-0.0423843004,
0.026342418,
0.0318436958,
-0.0194690581,
0.0133807817,
0.0059228772,
-0.0565162785,
-0.0139713055,
-0.0151901841,
-0.0054731122,
0.0195202362,
0.0050811348,
0.005463005,
-0.0481985137,
-0.0169724412,
-0.0152315516,
-0.0193670392,
0.0570606031,
-0.0467053838,
-0.0448492393,
0.0611571334,
-0.0184700042,
0.0709878802,
-0.0158202983,
-0.0152147617,
-0.0083214883,
-0.0394533426,
-0.0328710862,
-5.030328975e-33,
0.006370862,
-0.0301257689,
-0.037689466,
0.0419141203,
0.0135632828,
-0.0054225167,
0.0292347036,
0.013208623,
-0.0148130665,
0.0050057508,
-0.0014470238,
0.0244301632,
0.0045186705,
-0.0359333232,
0.0140503757,
-0.0670978576,
0.0527277701,
-0.0637718961,
-0.0379696563,
0.0146854529,
0.0237927735,
-0.02252548,
-0.0064970674,
-0.1188254505,
0.0462131016,
0.0188990869,
-0.0342338793,
-0.0114062587,
-0.0106437756,
0.0652392134,
-0.0015678277,
0.0722803921,
0.0178114083,
0.0009853081,
0.0252891053,
0.0358102843,
-0.0557447113,
0.0124688623,
0.0051100552,
0.0077614947,
0.0160003919,
0.0022903492,
0.0414357148,
0.0066156844,
-0.0459648557,
-0.0360542312,
0.0302016884,
-0.0153386835,
0.0237099081,
-0.0771593004,
-0.0130496649,
-0.0068126591,
-0.0357147753,
-0.0498656705,
-0.0228138939,
0.0455035008,
0.0058772801,
0.0308740102,
-0.0651373044,
0.048430454,
-0.0291507058,
-0.0274270978,
-0.0135516403,
-0.0252830386,
0.0131092155,
0.0792239979,
0.0622614995,
0.0747956932,
-0.032220386,
0.005697933,
0.0034510067,
0.0262843948,
0.034937676,
0.0688057542,
0.027745815,
-0.1024147645,
-0.0482232049,
0.0035736365,
0.0606770441,
0.0003461998,
0.0519574136,
-0.0175015368,
-0.0369248614,
-0.030981537,
-0.0250523426,
-0.1047635153,
-0.0429353639,
0.007744289,
0.0045819292,
0.0120317033,
-0.0219168514,
-0.0593871623,
0.0134795308,
-0.0612010919,
0.0079287775,
0.0348176919,
-0.0174396951,
-0.0252784267,
0.0277342126,
-0.0287128966,
-0.0326475464,
-0.0276184324,
0.0065626521,
-0.0228642784,
0.039981313,
-0.0404824801,
0.0641599596,
0.0467412099,
-0.0515338928,
0.0086044902,
-0.019954687,
0.0467740521,
0.001519951,
0.0526038446,
0.0302286875,
0.0382267907,
-0.0050194138,
-0.0390704088,
0.015644636,
0.0208481699,
-0.0218225643,
-0.0054048863,
-0.0590907149,
0.002817302,
-0.0307467766,
-0.0275461953,
-0.0150039447,
0.0019388678,
0.0047687171,
-0.0409510508,
0.0103498334,
-0.0667581111,
2.207e-7,
-0.0248538088,
0.050247252,
0.0221779794,
-0.0091775572,
0.0521669351,
0.043413654,
0.0254536215,
0.0384390429,
0.0121392999,
-0.02197171,
-0.003667281,
0.0126363579,
0.0425938815,
0.059769135,
-0.0264831446,
-0.0262477938,
-0.0825137496,
0.0311936531,
-0.0119262971,
0.0233973339,
-0.0047175242,
0.0456247963,
0.061161384,
-0.0364171118,
-0.0105944742,
-0.0315638892,
0.038658306,
-0.0519068688,
-0.0002255738,
-0.0307944175,
0.0426368192,
-0.0212130416,
0.0050086593,
0.0215731245,
0.013502025,
0.0035342737,
0.0091642039,
0.0320466496,
0.0383265056,
-0.0102676749,
0.0064625135,
0.010367481,
0.0169186927,
0.0310179796,
0.0327538326,
0.0019140788,
-0.0139250001,
-0.0588170364,
-0.0052078082,
-0.0496811792,
0.0558185391,
-0.0069029308,
-0.0181007478,
-0.0230433103,
-0.0097157117,
0.0185425226,
0.0117365448,
-0.027643403,
-0.0053769648,
-0.0276134983,
-0.0443628766,
-0.0883561969,
0.0173339676,
-0.0086934883,
0.0092936726,
0.0324502997,
0.0401744954,
1.493856677e-34,
0.0485021956,
-0.031849239,
-0.0116641242,
-0.0422744527,
0.0431109145,
0.0394006148,
0.0165451895,
-0.0244297367,
0.0459599122,
-0.0080059981,
-0.0119325127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12520v1 | Producing Usable Taxonomies Cheaply and Rapidly at Pinterest Using Discovered Dynamic $μ$-Topics | 2023-01-29T19:27:08 | 2023-01-29T19:27:08 | Abhijit Mahabal, Jiyun Luo, Rui Huang, Michael Ellsworth, Rui Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating a taxonomy of interests is expensive and human-effort intensive: not
only do we need to identify nodes and interconnect them, in order to use the
taxonomy, we must also connect the nodes to relevant entities such as users,
pins, and queries. Connecting to entities is challenging because of ambiguities
inherent to language but also because individual interests are dynamic and
evolve. Here, we offer an alternative approach that begins with bottom-up
discovery of $\mu$-topics called pincepts. The discovery process itself
connects these $\mu$-topics dynamically with relevant queries, pins, and users
at high precision, automatically adapting to shifting interests. Pincepts cover
all areas of user interest and automatically adjust to the specificity of user
interests and are thus suitable for the creation of various kinds of
taxonomies. Human experts associate taxonomy nodes with $\mu$-topics (on
average, 3 $\mu$-topics per node), and the $\mu$-topics offer a high-level data
layer that allows quick definition, immediate inspection, and easy
modification. Even more powerfully, $\mu$-topics allow easy exploration of
nearby semantic space, enabling curators to spot and fill gaps. Curators'
domain knowledge is heavily leveraged and we thus don't need untrained
mechanical Turks, allowing further cost reduction. These $\mu$-topics thus
offer a satisfactory "symbolic" stratum over which to define taxonomies. We
have successfully applied this technique for very rapidly iterating on and
launching the home decor and fashion styles taxonomy for style-based
personalization, prominently featured at the top of Pinterest search results,
at 94% precision, improving search success rate by 34.8% as well as boosting
long clicks and pin saves. | [
0.0317613259,
0.0199426543,
-0.0375558436,
0.0135703171,
-0.0003549515,
-0.056069389,
-0.0040412028,
0.0214706715,
-0.0426232256,
-0.0334517621,
-0.0542083606,
0.027466584,
-0.0300716795,
0.0835346431,
-0.0172837563,
-0.0302080177,
-0.0185404476,
-0.0146547649,
-0.0200416353,
-0.0020511912,
0.0487944372,
0.0418888256,
0.0012298143,
0.0009684156,
0.0105721364,
-0.0094205141,
-0.0240617432,
0.0299094152,
-0.0358432494,
-0.0233228877,
0.0516353212,
0.0359754674,
0.0058534639,
0.0425335616,
0.0000020016,
-0.0106272269,
-0.057656914,
-0.0763128996,
0.0320458338,
-0.0260449052,
0.0934860036,
0.0420471951,
0.0339462161,
-0.0261201747,
-0.0109464182,
0.0105851647,
0.0357549414,
0.0365432203,
-0.0098609738,
-0.0194337945,
-0.0104507683,
-0.0326197669,
-0.0090612154,
-0.0155950123,
0.0659469962,
0.0199551433,
0.01488085,
-0.013527954,
0.0549205393,
0.0438757278,
-0.0148438755,
0.0187776554,
-0.0419543795,
0.0221157596,
0.0460270829,
0.0308089741,
-0.009039971,
-0.0317808837,
-0.0158483107,
0.0560861528,
0.0075252778,
-0.0024885759,
0.0205341037,
-0.0130331824,
-0.012195929,
0.0344926752,
-0.0667023584,
-0.0274962056,
-0.0237307902,
-0.0047704447,
-0.0043578041,
0.0044698101,
-0.0059551578,
0.0359670147,
0.0539841391,
0.0438765697,
0.0121591883,
-0.0018087493,
-0.0410096534,
-0.0241991654,
0.0169737712,
-0.0522843599,
-0.0016623724,
-0.0630614087,
-0.0019160298,
0.0153323915,
0.0185256731,
0.0583643466,
0.0385155901,
0.0348833837,
-0.0304533746,
0.0326699428,
0.0038348059,
0.0359134823,
0.0747551173,
-0.0095646884,
-0.0538151599,
-0.0112363659,
-0.0266551208,
0.00217876,
-0.0760225505,
-0.0190027803,
0.0019860752,
0.0283616036,
-0.017901348,
-0.0117811868,
-0.0160961896,
0.0097066779,
-0.032905627,
0.0084533123,
-0.0522858016,
0.031602215,
-0.0315089449,
-0.0091575775,
-0.0159934983,
-0.0194123611,
-0.0400153957,
0.0027527483,
0.0019733137,
0.0443562828,
0.0333117433,
0.0249861591,
0.0724478438,
-0.0059446339,
0.0066383043,
-0.0591134727,
-0.0098339356,
-0.0320646167,
-0.0063577574,
-0.0818297192,
0.0254847798,
0.0436193943,
0.0278716926,
-0.0511685759,
0.0108219339,
-0.0024946411,
-0.0005816086,
-0.0261850022,
-0.0091839973,
0.0192425326,
-0.0439335667,
0.0516099744,
-0.0332608186,
-0.0107243173,
0.0440637842,
0.0301254019,
-0.0305369683,
0.032857094,
-0.0297472253,
0.1020636782,
0.0753042474,
0.0202290174,
-0.0045987074,
0.0096614277,
-0.0167283919,
-0.0030235599,
0.0000932634,
-0.0055404981,
-0.0116210934,
0.0010567345,
0.0125153558,
-0.0061643454,
-0.023849681,
0.0400102288,
0.0418687128,
0.0538137108,
0.017061444,
0.080102019,
0.0042736377,
0.0318306535,
-0.0393622555,
-0.0319674052,
0.0210489687,
0.0244514029,
-0.0136686806,
-0.0493075997,
0.000653696,
-0.0357864536,
-0.0371228643,
-0.0094597721,
0.0177524574,
-0.0057465024,
0.0315616503,
0.0135577675,
0.0219867658,
-0.0053456197,
0.030844748,
0.0434082709,
-0.0255904794,
-0.0122534875,
-0.0081679374,
-0.0427846499,
0.052858036,
0.1704625934,
0.0287703183,
-0.0296844728,
-0.0246562753,
0.0275834277,
0.0866383538,
0.0210711565,
0.0054716575,
-0.0432909876,
-0.0191461872,
-0.0084969597,
-0.0162363872,
-0.0237836447,
0.0237839259,
0.0073175109,
-0.0116728051,
-0.0109258061,
-0.0069497842,
-0.0358000621,
0.0657418147,
-0.0429714173,
0.0537420772,
0.0160484891,
-0.0029480401,
-0.0064371242,
-0.0103801824,
0.0568761565,
0.0506504104,
-0.0200587902,
0.0226300564,
-0.0300504193,
-0.025297286,
0.0136345839,
0.0354758091,
0.1204942986,
0.0296245739,
-0.0179090668,
-0.0146519365,
-0.0164231192,
0.0053718425,
-0.0239626206,
0.0210252199,
-0.0109613603,
0.0348237045,
0.0147120301,
-0.023949936,
-0.0237205457,
-0.0162280686,
-0.0064037479,
0.0552911498,
0.01058657,
0.0139839817,
-0.0288942624,
-0.008146856,
0.0190320108,
-0.0224427469,
0.0131198484,
-0.0187917892,
0.0093067754,
0.0458482616,
0.0379376784,
-0.0171955526,
-0.0478093587,
0.0237593912,
-0.077256009,
-0.0067770067,
-0.0003667522,
0.024645783,
0.0014311421,
0.0276623908,
-0.0082990602,
-0.007738485,
-0.0077585895,
0.0814261734,
-0.049059771,
0.0291180294,
0.0214487351,
0.030956015,
-0.0477479994,
-0.0319217332,
-0.0214937516,
-0.0257852487,
0.0211281981,
0.0425123721,
0.0118618654,
0.0081007127,
-0.0966185629,
-0.0190529171,
-0.0366951637,
0.0204748567,
0.0095442701,
0.0090879677,
-0.0747901872,
0.0288201291,
-0.0508157127,
-0.0022389032,
-0.0172515232,
0.0071956781,
-0.0319437757,
-0.0268925615,
-0.0330665186,
-0.0169014148,
0.0296569001,
0.027747428,
-0.0192493405,
0.0229441263,
-0.008718539,
-0.0508922972,
0.0047901878,
-0.0039274478,
0.0754052475,
0.0450331867,
0.0241465475,
-0.0599181466,
0.0096940389,
0.0395093113,
0.0980652943,
-0.0083866753,
-0.0135876378,
0.0129455104,
0.0223988481,
0.0234995652,
0.0235411786,
-0.0498496555,
-0.0192912929,
0.0419063754,
-0.0110653611,
0.0334511138,
-0.0231686868,
-0.0289136283,
0.0034197916,
0.047341466,
0.021454772,
-0.0522559956,
0.0252926257,
-0.0181504097,
-0.0291280802,
0.0216862001,
-0.0275956169,
-0.0052501145,
-0.0275294259,
-0.0213512685,
-0.0190033559,
0.0137155904,
-0.0226020534,
0.0221837536,
-0.0040959567,
-0.0435916372,
0.02319373,
0.0430676937,
-0.0346504003,
-0.0086262822,
0.045642294,
0.0129560875,
-0.0075218738,
-0.1216274127,
0.042330917,
-0.0765026957,
0.0562922694,
0.0241534859,
-0.0448908694,
-0.0369188078,
0.023958236,
0.0548675992,
-0.0496306047,
-0.0467812568,
0.0006420971,
-0.0459917411,
0.0079659158,
-0.0111737251,
0.0630500317,
0.0580353104,
-0.0662838817,
-0.0176319238,
0.0115239127,
-0.0075667407,
0.0162699353,
0.0173871908,
-0.0589756668,
0.0081683062,
-0.0255045053,
0.0454077348,
0.0228957441,
-0.0355627835,
-0.0221453551,
-0.0237108171,
-0.004269449,
0.0129021062,
-0.0759778246,
-0.0236136243,
-0.0315737762,
0.0053965766,
-0.0035059783,
-0.0605440959,
-0.0175385904,
-0.03573291,
0.026966,
-0.0175916273,
-0.0143837035,
-0.0378526971,
0.0465456024,
-0.0171154533,
-0.000175977,
0.0223560333,
0.0524970219,
0.0142718535,
-0.0529236794,
0.0164673235,
0.0216444097,
-0.0388729386,
-0.0261945296,
0.003782144,
-0.0285401158,
0.043497771,
0.0070043392,
0.0241850801,
-0.0247197766,
-0.0268066805,
-0.0131086661,
0.0407997631,
-0.0061984458,
0.029013969,
-0.0549188405,
-0.0530232824,
0.0473786257,
0.0064908336,
-0.0001892019,
-0.0742356405,
0.0217454936,
-0.0967461392,
0.0263579171,
0.0285384227,
-0.0179503784,
-0.0185080804,
-0.0422752388,
-0.0528530292,
-0.0369660109,
0.0001787918,
0.0174419768,
0.0302104764,
-0.0029789519,
-0.0186025985,
-0.0139561081,
0.0381902345,
-0.0968695357,
-0.0269072708,
-0.0106391236,
-0.0236395169,
0.0270366576,
-0.0389919691,
0.0329623558,
-0.0285019893,
-0.0120159257,
0.0054864627,
-0.0427396782,
0.019587446,
0.0171752591,
0.0047879433,
0.0239312705,
-0.0181657225,
-0.0213417672,
-0.0798373744,
0.0038105478,
0.0545251518,
0.0326162204,
-0.0430392548,
-0.0016627399,
0.0289266966,
0.0246800631,
0.0371995717,
-0.0532098226,
0.0162332114,
-0.0245301016,
0.0383015722,
-0.0401836783,
0.0019960615,
0.0054559293,
0.0124386568,
0.0192830861,
-0.0135031231,
0.0081876498,
0.008433653,
-0.0020553789,
0.0587356165,
-0.0373613872,
0.0025081993,
-0.0198566336,
-0.0046758014,
-0.0212520026,
-0.0243438538,
-0.0189661719,
-0.003057339,
0.024870038,
-0.0903374553,
-0.0497760139,
-0.0521681309,
0.0140089178,
-0.0000277345,
-0.0105516268,
0.0026528363,
0.0447940789,
-0.0132434387,
0.0253860466,
-0.0553613603,
0.0122118937,
0.0003194057,
-0.0220092516,
-0.0414738692,
0.0525680967,
0.0155688152,
-0.0505999029,
0.0205758382,
0.0347815566,
0.0194774661,
0.0183261316,
-0.0070760702,
-0.0177353285,
-0.0259396546,
0.0173774827,
0.0151817808,
0.0090442328,
-0.051196184,
-0.0284990221,
0.0548902676,
0.0287998002,
-0.0067593963,
0.0488835163,
-0.0109207695,
-0.0192279331,
0.000985082,
-0.0693328232,
-0.027152136,
0.0335293338,
-0.0441085733,
0.0426480472,
-0.0183350574,
0.0158700887,
-0.046685826,
-0.0083962996,
0.0680822134,
-0.0124348402,
0.0135899503,
0.0523652844,
0.0828003883,
0.0647336096,
-0.0043543857,
-0.0132758645,
-0.0127129704,
-0.0056907623,
-0.0554898866,
0.0160092991,
0.0228031091,
-6.368699088e-33,
0.0149412323,
-0.0814517587,
0.0043524685,
0.0816660449,
0.0273673087,
-0.0398024842,
-0.003118901,
0.0113201886,
0.0564488322,
-0.0171572268,
-0.0168095827,
0.0073980205,
0.0040848744,
-0.0083765201,
0.0774464682,
-0.0200230926,
0.060930375,
0.0368568078,
-0.0365504138,
0.0384470709,
0.0214389209,
0.0247949567,
-0.0268396214,
-0.089898549,
0.0066500185,
-0.0087797903,
-0.0163318217,
0.0391565524,
0.0636663139,
0.0329876021,
-0.0335612185,
0.0479128212,
-0.0081467619,
0.0054046186,
0.0230917782,
-0.0244610216,
-0.0583063886,
-0.0188852679,
-0.0064531756,
0.0050475695,
0.0469016097,
-0.0350925885,
0.007503646,
0.0135449208,
0.0107798269,
0.0473438054,
0.0201699156,
0.0044591012,
-0.0144844381,
0.0316754058,
0.0209173467,
0.0103759002,
0.0299139358,
0.0377960019,
0.0629218221,
-0.0623045415,
0.0374238156,
0.0249386951,
-0.0797852576,
0.0703233257,
-0.0307850745,
-0.0379577205,
0.0338516347,
-0.017316442,
-0.0070378752,
0.0351631567,
0.0079974793,
0.0724537522,
0.0363460667,
0.0168854911,
-0.0392980725,
0.0477375239,
0.0021597575,
-0.0048476686,
0.0664155334,
0.0168277491,
0.0171270557,
0.0208940692,
-0.0058605857,
-0.0096206982,
-0.0052983155,
0.0812044814,
-0.017506307,
-0.0138476016,
0.038265992,
0.0066332016,
-0.0668974146,
-0.0229189601,
-0.0105845556,
0.0473918281,
-0.0605667941,
0.075516142,
-0.0356125943,
0.0115395281,
-0.0523596667,
-0.0283470768,
0.0024797784,
-0.0160703361,
-0.0132032624,
-0.0175606348,
0.0062251328,
-0.0484217554,
0.0054658721,
-0.033802487,
-0.0054094228,
0.001035929,
0.0040799961,
0.0353381485,
-0.0328090265,
-0.0167027004,
0.0421602391,
-0.0759021267,
-0.030689748,
-0.1015008092,
0.0490403883,
0.0291944277,
-0.033849746,
-0.0098102931,
0.0858258978,
0.0678613707,
-0.0057724519,
-0.0694966391,
-0.0378807932,
-0.0416448042,
-0.002188741,
-0.0390857607,
-0.0128006134,
-0.038979739,
-0.0078891842,
-0.064446561,
-0.0270601418,
-0.034354426,
2.794e-7,
0.0253135487,
0.0497178361,
-0.0311869029,
0.0355028622,
0.0319919623,
-0.0117099546,
-0.0058982866,
0.0422456563,
-0.0603650101,
-0.0254843477,
0.0211302321,
0.0072134193,
0.0002289078,
0.0677799508,
-0.0642324537,
-0.0273775198,
0.0723427981,
0.0323599875,
-0.0826438442,
0.0510427803,
0.0009375896,
-0.0149089964,
0.0277385712,
0.017389087,
0.01841118,
-0.0419936217,
0.023750281,
-0.0141949002,
0.0390904322,
0.0115254326,
0.0636849776,
0.0684379414,
-0.0365696326,
-0.0568442829,
-0.0421054587,
0.0270521697,
0.0389505476,
-0.0167213846,
-0.0104033165,
0.0003860829,
0.0095473342,
-0.0301718041,
0.006779768,
-0.0184295475,
-0.0049170195,
-0.0174707863,
0.0276805703,
0.0338811055,
-0.0029650079,
0.0050645224,
-0.0344677493,
-0.0414789096,
-0.0501473621,
-0.0265639983,
-0.0199526958,
0.0061195991,
-0.0168039128,
-0.081537351,
0.0127321398,
0.0110598579,
-0.0540295318,
-0.042294208,
-0.0499467216,
0.0435572416,
-0.0074471766,
0.0419179425,
0.0000479196,
2.187237288e-34,
0.0379057527,
0.0068042181,
-0.0475046821,
0.0293309055,
0.0179097354,
-0.0290128365,
0.0154030612,
-0.0139491102,
0.0477226339,
-0.0417222753,
-0.005818516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.13609v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.13609v1 | Physarum Inspired Bicycle Lane Network Design in a Congested Mega City | 2023-01-29T16:55:49 | 2023-01-29T16:55:49 | Md. Ahsan Habib, M. A. H. Akhand | physics.soc-ph | physics.soc-ph, cs.CL | Mobility is a key factor in urban life and transport network plays a vital
role in mobility. Worse transport network having less mobility is one of the
key reasons to decline the living standard in any unplanned mega city.
Transport mobility enhancement in an unplanned mega city is always challenging
due to various constraints including complex design and high cost involvement.
The aim of this thesis is to enhance transport mobility in a megacity
introducing a bicycle lane. To design the bicycle lane natural Physarum,
brainless single celled multi-nucleated protist, is studied and modified for
better optimization. Recently Physarum inspired techniques are drawn
significant attention to the construction of effective networks. Exiting
Physarum inspired models effectively and efficiently solves different problems
including transport network design and modification and implication for bicycle
lane is the unique contribution of this study. Central area of Dhaka, the
capital city of Bangladesh, is considered to analyze and design the bicycle
lane network bypassing primary roads. | [
0.0347947814,
0.0136827286,
-0.0290764049,
-0.0196753908,
-0.0455412827,
-0.0541911423,
0.0626096651,
-0.0430274233,
-0.0386910103,
0.0212763492,
0.0085899523,
0.0311414097,
-0.0200609919,
0.0355971679,
0.0312426761,
-0.0182615444,
-0.0104788821,
0.0179955941,
-0.0240260027,
-0.0016140419,
-0.0027089147,
-0.0372096226,
0.0352973342,
0.0325887837,
0.0239696223,
0.0067565124,
-0.0239137243,
0.0286538955,
0.0511640646,
-0.0720792413,
0.0091302572,
0.0118088806,
0.0222507715,
0.0425163731,
0.0000019015,
0.0179703385,
-0.0304066669,
-0.0075318255,
0.0592973083,
-0.0108016767,
0.0469785035,
0.0285096541,
0.0193147659,
-0.0286921673,
0.0533545054,
0.0092486851,
-0.0126033686,
0.0784504861,
0.0038629572,
0.0275184307,
-0.0065192147,
-0.0081260577,
0.0233155787,
-0.0125012472,
-0.0151953623,
0.0439058207,
0.0053808196,
-0.0401092991,
0.0464748256,
0.0157760791,
-0.0383912772,
-0.0447307453,
0.0322765261,
-0.0224541947,
0.0298575442,
-0.036512237,
0.0823799521,
-0.0060601039,
0.0199588444,
0.0569071844,
-0.0910823867,
-0.0063598505,
0.0511060506,
-0.0066102347,
-0.0044936985,
-0.015534726,
-0.0366187096,
-0.015410305,
0.0256019942,
0.0063672205,
-0.0317001343,
-0.0019275977,
0.0144783761,
0.01449404,
0.0193011742,
0.0104752602,
0.0389236212,
-0.002734931,
-0.0309750587,
-0.0269415677,
0.0168780163,
0.0295616947,
0.0617754348,
0.0279175211,
0.0469757468,
-0.0604067855,
0.0819210857,
0.0298398118,
0.0087991506,
-0.0308181271,
0.0856026486,
0.021176165,
0.0385515168,
0.012816445,
-0.0048510958,
-0.0632106364,
-0.0959164575,
0.0262425914,
-0.0158673171,
0.0391175039,
-0.0181373395,
0.007518603,
0.0039409739,
0.0608473867,
0.0101841614,
0.0310440511,
0.0031916972,
0.0575448126,
-0.0018623507,
-0.0877178237,
-0.000790879,
0.0269103236,
0.0966384709,
-0.0321702585,
0.0009971312,
-0.0293786637,
-0.0436180793,
-0.0208923221,
-0.0043906677,
0.0668702573,
-0.0127162663,
-0.0050523784,
0.0008236365,
0.003546844,
-0.0440798625,
0.057730183,
-0.0105876056,
-0.0297316853,
-0.0143689997,
-0.0478235744,
0.0165209919,
-0.0213311575,
-0.0275790766,
-0.0308048017,
-0.0013445665,
-0.0116537055,
-0.033059366,
0.0296493191,
0.0109533928,
-0.0121122682,
-0.0275292322,
-0.0241518766,
-0.0551048368,
0.0358234383,
0.0251335651,
0.0145002203,
0.0769739151,
-0.0188243389,
0.0005840812,
0.0210699905,
-0.0111751566,
-0.0253292676,
0.0307105202,
-0.0418458432,
0.0352317728,
-0.0155696645,
0.0415493436,
-0.0212732907,
-0.0081171272,
-0.0028306365,
0.0237617884,
-0.0093477136,
-0.0634319857,
0.0399404801,
-0.0331835225,
-0.0398636274,
0.0279547032,
0.0811185539,
-0.0593762472,
0.0106417071,
0.0105620446,
-0.0137553634,
0.0039286427,
0.0500094928,
-0.0613074191,
-0.0049437182,
-0.0047172527,
0.0299307965,
-0.0094344383,
0.0117807863,
0.0893459395,
-0.0701624081,
0.0587127954,
-0.0533933379,
0.0203693658,
-0.0299979877,
-0.0021025222,
0.0223071836,
0.030693233,
-0.0019831941,
-0.0007454461,
-0.0339337587,
0.0285387728,
-0.0345724002,
0.019349819,
0.0033511422,
-0.0419017337,
0.0003106699,
-0.0616748407,
-0.0054180939,
0.0067745163,
0.013806738,
-0.0733696669,
-0.0114473226,
0.0139388377,
0.0568131618,
0.0406533517,
-0.0723933503,
-0.0383809172,
0.0472341813,
0.0465129688,
0.0086958399,
0.013240343,
-0.0174523573,
0.0426222049,
0.0941525921,
-0.0230984576,
-0.0162705872,
-0.0040620537,
-0.0021510404,
-0.0273265336,
0.0100011481,
0.0124078309,
-0.0089486586,
-0.020857811,
-0.0009944227,
0.014866678,
0.081784524,
-0.0027067536,
-0.0106536122,
-0.0001893831,
0.08172483,
0.0224997215,
-0.0080880607,
-0.0139864702,
-0.009814214,
-0.0403396599,
0.0253243241,
0.0602997057,
0.0141959554,
-0.0007509319,
0.0209899936,
-0.0085662073,
0.0741694048,
0.0145321991,
0.0192491431,
0.0505087487,
0.0777251571,
-0.0164930504,
0.0065844269,
0.0146882869,
0.0302774087,
0.0031429355,
-0.0141513506,
0.0196941942,
-0.0082579758,
-0.0107491333,
-0.0318048,
-0.0277253948,
0.0341978595,
-0.0031922217,
-0.0208608508,
-0.0257566907,
-0.004590082,
0.0274474639,
0.0166100822,
0.1189589649,
-0.0158248357,
-0.068567194,
0.0368545987,
-0.0891778246,
-0.0665200204,
-0.0368512683,
0.022989668,
-0.0375883169,
0.036489822,
0.0477074608,
-0.0056550009,
0.0388481766,
-0.0252410974,
-0.0278343242,
0.0037616522,
0.0099824881,
-0.0564884841,
-0.04619148,
0.0238030925,
0.0374910459,
-0.0108598908,
0.0292902291,
-0.0953695998,
0.0115789324,
-0.0153439771,
-0.0287219826,
0.0341068842,
-0.0505445041,
0.0433078669,
-0.0252806675,
-0.0292405691,
-0.0089878505,
0.0338608772,
0.0029807007,
-0.0178251844,
0.0136030326,
0.0051884744,
0.0198124237,
0.0131998695,
0.000294223,
0.039969217,
0.034860719,
0.0790970773,
0.0076236473,
0.0325852297,
0.0489351414,
0.0178945679,
0.0248689,
0.0082591344,
0.0438662022,
0.0066759824,
0.0050938791,
0.0497245304,
0.0340570807,
-0.000995029,
0.0583855473,
0.0380546935,
0.0383527279,
-0.0716173798,
-0.0004703273,
-0.0501983315,
0.0189123731,
-0.0067497105,
-0.0291608237,
-0.0585356168,
-0.0010130656,
0.0367379002,
-0.0055874996,
-0.0124335187,
-0.0096732005,
-0.0359390154,
0.0178779159,
0.0341036953,
0.042290207,
-0.0048112497,
-0.0597602166,
0.0425312743,
-0.0016004561,
0.0109892916,
0.0507293381,
0.0787310079,
0.037613377,
0.0478403792,
0.0030556915,
0.0247603022,
-0.0345993303,
0.0286148395,
0.0141156809,
0.052538503,
-0.033102423,
0.0027669035,
-0.029656684,
0.003620672,
-0.0111115118,
-0.0217164345,
-0.0518914983,
0.0330960378,
-0.0168866683,
-0.055193454,
0.0258882139,
-0.0837892219,
-0.0532156117,
-0.0409232341,
0.0048478879,
0.0124273859,
0.0105303023,
-0.0418972,
-0.0577478595,
-0.0217031073,
-0.0169692673,
0.0455003195,
-0.0105198864,
-0.0192696527,
-0.0063590365,
-0.0564428233,
-0.035096392,
-0.0606146306,
-0.0526780263,
0.0066331285,
-0.0344713628,
0.0219739247,
0.0233678445,
0.0209571831,
-0.0113516813,
-0.0423633419,
0.0148631688,
-0.0302966908,
0.0096549103,
0.0633039027,
0.0029209279,
0.0247188229,
0.0328535251,
-0.0239885841,
0.020541681,
-0.0106684808,
0.0181439389,
-0.0317167379,
-0.0436960422,
0.0370835178,
-0.0173272733,
-0.0370605364,
-0.0347692668,
-0.0589273721,
0.0051565948,
0.0523848273,
0.0042998539,
0.0264023449,
0.0159411747,
-0.0740948096,
0.0163817182,
-0.0265497304,
-0.0194239747,
-0.0028042726,
-0.0270775296,
-0.0315540172,
-0.0529262871,
-0.0619073249,
-0.0788030773,
-0.0786705762,
-0.0515325852,
-0.0168252159,
0.0019047098,
-0.0487346984,
-0.0143141979,
-0.0153221693,
0.050224036,
0.0043839565,
-0.0006214772,
0.0887464061,
-0.0700662285,
-0.0488761887,
-0.0606102981,
-0.0179309938,
-0.0180939473,
-0.0276977979,
0.0159570631,
0.01619827,
0.0209140219,
-0.0460407399,
-0.0221570022,
0.0241144784,
-0.0327164717,
0.043698173,
0.0022345698,
0.0274412353,
-0.0610208698,
-0.0257860906,
0.0053830929,
0.0556466356,
-0.0161118023,
0.0319740511,
-0.0152187226,
-0.0060908389,
-0.0004879792,
-0.0170257501,
-0.0041869516,
0.0228938423,
0.0644575283,
0.0465903766,
0.0130036511,
-0.0329593159,
0.0613589212,
0.0090689985,
0.0180384628,
0.0568453744,
0.047970444,
0.0248105153,
0.0277413838,
-0.0010716207,
-0.004311312,
0.0173564199,
-0.0054808729,
-0.0213935263,
0.0114219394,
0.0303271227,
-0.0032822464,
-0.0180606171,
0.0583345667,
-0.0588709489,
0.0650682077,
-0.0008116257,
0.0156341288,
0.0114172734,
-0.0390240103,
-0.0277863462,
0.0001079748,
-0.0261024181,
-0.0201309789,
-0.0182880778,
0.0058947643,
-0.0360996202,
0.0136467991,
0.0109565007,
-0.0262483694,
0.013218075,
0.0167006385,
0.0242078975,
-0.0140014654,
0.0596867278,
0.0559126064,
0.0801909715,
-0.008716993,
0.005543441,
-0.0232039541,
0.0022563855,
-0.0189342629,
0.0044972021,
0.034083046,
0.0350587927,
0.0186996777,
-0.050729312,
-0.0659671798,
0.0347669423,
0.0060940366,
-0.0167269744,
0.0003043812,
0.0184619091,
-0.0038328839,
0.041053772,
-0.0429657996,
-0.0160447657,
0.0114844786,
-0.0183977857,
-0.0042604632,
0.004596211,
0.0277451873,
0.0295632873,
0.0555324964,
0.0135134114,
0.0010979787,
-0.0898482874,
0.0085174898,
-0.0608829744,
0.0549372919,
-0.0051510897,
-0.0391611643,
0.0136222793,
-0.0115838619,
-6.078927609e-33,
0.0462882891,
-0.07215143,
0.0012511966,
-0.0022718993,
-0.0642332882,
-0.0479589216,
-0.0491011105,
0.0127505492,
-0.0387370288,
-0.0207595732,
-0.0311947111,
-0.0148670273,
-0.0009933444,
0.018921759,
0.0125543047,
0.0282296445,
-0.0110568944,
0.0489399917,
-0.0269221514,
0.0022194579,
-0.0503866896,
0.0074274871,
-0.0322731212,
0.040023379,
-0.0253456086,
-0.0657084882,
-0.0073235054,
0.0080456212,
-0.0511149205,
0.0206220262,
0.0060556834,
0.03431141,
-0.0222165659,
-0.0007359237,
0.0009763,
0.0294197202,
0.0098386761,
0.0082911244,
0.0187805761,
0.0534627736,
-0.0811699405,
-0.0731633902,
0.0299510285,
-0.0137861902,
-0.0125953956,
0.0778485537,
0.0112158619,
-0.0248849653,
0.0059722536,
0.0455678739,
-0.0256163813,
-0.0187553614,
-0.0348230265,
0.0592355244,
0.0300638322,
-0.0653634444,
0.0262423865,
-0.024525471,
-0.0328668542,
0.0251031797,
-0.0020786836,
0.0158026163,
-0.0220266934,
-0.0023970387,
0.0241827033,
-0.031137852,
0.024666667,
-0.0289101992,
-0.0325734951,
0.0051793209,
0.0039444743,
-0.0074363006,
0.0335858352,
-0.0286841672,
0.0130133759,
-0.0445411131,
-0.033165548,
-0.0203952752,
0.0524202175,
-0.0628294423,
0.0222724322,
0.0137424069,
-0.0307483003,
-0.0247745272,
0.0479205623,
-0.0098147765,
-0.0278293956,
-0.0550969914,
-0.0740635619,
-0.0378561094,
-0.0484381914,
0.0076422142,
-0.0368418172,
-0.0209683012,
0.0130531369,
0.021065345,
0.0119726975,
0.0141918072,
0.0140879182,
0.0027961314,
-0.0400943048,
-0.0475117266,
-0.0849931315,
0.0019069427,
0.0043564201,
0.0258547757,
-0.0632482842,
-0.0023685747,
0.0002530431,
0.0280063264,
-0.0013675658,
-0.036246866,
0.0674628615,
-0.0252950396,
-0.0341045037,
-0.0437045395,
-0.0272455905,
-0.0537428558,
0.016766116,
-0.0022311434,
-0.0251982324,
0.1149631366,
-0.0272339005,
0.0531890318,
0.0110046333,
-0.0103504062,
0.0148564987,
0.0140284467,
-0.0377714634,
-0.0587836467,
-0.039255064,
-0.0123575823,
2.814e-7,
-0.0229940545,
0.0419046283,
-0.0403306857,
0.0188478138,
0.0262710433,
0.0096982224,
-0.0138788586,
-0.0278294291,
-0.0219603796,
-0.0003477748,
0.0010662203,
0.0432292074,
-0.0196302664,
-0.0292328559,
-0.0452796407,
0.093859598,
-0.0271387435,
0.042159453,
0.040405266,
0.0344968587,
0.0064463015,
0.0290995594,
0.0510294512,
0.0288779009,
0.0018565761,
0.0294379275,
-0.0575362518,
-0.0099622933,
0.0407825597,
0.0448662899,
0.0033129056,
0.0477189794,
-0.0361338966,
-0.0088892477,
0.0599260293,
-0.0399934277,
-0.0137762241,
0.0101014245,
0.0305535626,
0.0325217657,
0.039781902,
-0.0312729366,
0.0208480023,
0.0070729787,
-0.0040744203,
0.0060635172,
-0.0561066866,
-0.0038615209,
0.0212019701,
-0.0292393472,
0.0251284465,
0.035565652,
0.005240107,
-0.0468413457,
-0.0655358583,
0.0102853496,
0.0158150345,
0.0118309231,
0.0250799153,
0.0341827385,
-0.0077275857,
-0.0621177517,
-0.0082685566,
0.0387867019,
0.1031674221,
-0.0257111285,
-0.0137286996,
2.048494975e-34,
0.0508734658,
-0.0240438934,
-0.0025074563,
-0.0458457768,
0.0105171548,
0.0223029256,
-0.0189505741,
-0.0760789812,
-0.0447522812,
0.0083306255,
-0.0757593289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12473v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12473v2 | Large Language Models for Biomedical Knowledge Graph Construction: Information extraction from EMR notes | 2023-01-29T15:52:33 | 2023-12-09T17:31:49 | Vahan Arsenyan, Spartak Bughdaryan, Fadi Shaya, Kent Small, Davit Shahnazaryan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The automatic construction of knowledge graphs (KGs) is an important research
area in medicine, with far-reaching applications spanning drug discovery and
clinical trial design. These applications hinge on the accurate identification
of interactions among medical and biological entities. In this study, we
propose an end-to-end machine learning solution based on large language models
(LLMs) that utilize electronic medical record notes to construct KGs. The
entities used in the KG construction process are diseases, factors, treatments,
as well as manifestations that coexist with the patient while experiencing the
disease. Given the critical need for high-quality performance in medical
applications, we embark on a comprehensive assessment of 12 LLMs of various
architectures, evaluating their performance and safety attributes. To gauge the
quantitative efficacy of our approach by assessing both precision and recall,
we manually annotate a dataset provided by the Macula and Retina Institute. We
also assess the qualitative performance of LLMs, such as the ability to
generate structured outputs or the tendency to hallucinate. The results
illustrate that in contrast to encoder-only and encoder-decoder, decoder-only
LLMs require further investigation. Additionally, we provide guided prompt
design to utilize such LLMs. The application of the proposed methodology is
demonstrated on age-related macular degeneration. | [
0.0352545604,
0.0346001014,
0.0183901563,
0.0038469017,
-0.0021491391,
0.0256160256,
-0.0117430398,
0.0340916626,
0.0775317475,
0.0067792539,
0.0554489158,
-0.0128084058,
0.0071252356,
0.0546846911,
0.0004089538,
-0.0211538486,
0.0016406648,
0.0038841355,
0.0342763253,
-0.0215757992,
-0.0343835577,
0.0077960733,
0.0024613442,
0.0156499054,
0.0099004349,
-0.0269355029,
0.0235803053,
-0.0189259965,
0.021094013,
-0.0508664064,
-0.0428194478,
0.0009117867,
-0.0311281309,
-0.0193382613,
0.0000020572,
-0.0569727533,
-0.0190190244,
0.0384633206,
-0.0439245515,
-0.0234919488,
0.0302611385,
-0.0870766789,
0.0149938446,
-0.016617436,
-0.0082156733,
-0.074974604,
0.0417894498,
0.0249485541,
0.0282099582,
0.0720836297,
-0.0259110555,
-0.0061886101,
0.0908101276,
-0.0286514312,
0.039375741,
-0.0158805121,
0.0966893286,
0.0397039466,
0.0068559824,
-0.0438887887,
0.0138018364,
0.0537912399,
-0.0091171283,
0.011340037,
0.0695417821,
0.0429218598,
0.0130647002,
-0.0258571915,
-0.0124066416,
0.0505438261,
0.0163159575,
0.0138469562,
0.0202247165,
0.0101083368,
-0.0195246413,
0.0352377109,
-0.0202739611,
-0.0060051051,
-0.0569045506,
0.0089016249,
0.011489586,
-0.0480037369,
0.0393463373,
-0.0291724578,
-0.0455845706,
0.0148585271,
0.0103943832,
-0.0380304232,
0.0521648526,
-0.0175885931,
0.0102473097,
-0.0431039482,
0.026813319,
0.0434285775,
-0.0169033986,
0.0204770621,
-0.0122704851,
-0.01369901,
0.0552773587,
-0.0790855214,
0.0169007163,
-0.0217080452,
0.0242230035,
0.0602681451,
-0.0433565043,
0.0019770542,
-0.0362734348,
0.0183165371,
-0.0308007579,
-0.0148216588,
-0.0495650284,
-0.0027044425,
0.0015292485,
0.0572590195,
-0.0162397306,
-0.0337482467,
-0.0894992501,
0.045711305,
0.0007068558,
0.0500649698,
0.0200942606,
0.0167858973,
0.0255457964,
-0.0008424272,
-0.0446157567,
0.00781688,
0.0133832386,
-0.0097188596,
-0.035125643,
-0.0287826899,
0.033118248,
0.0163322929,
0.0126903476,
-0.0133597339,
0.0231023636,
0.1005055606,
0.0269777607,
-0.0234970655,
-0.0210137255,
-0.0309745669,
-0.0370204374,
-0.0272498522,
0.0250128489,
-0.0527565964,
0.051205311,
0.0364608653,
-0.0105191339,
-0.06171811,
0.0145868259,
0.0000323352,
-0.0709256455,
0.0495274588,
-0.0992934555,
-0.0054371273,
0.0193609577,
-0.0038983563,
-0.0183830895,
0.0137268249,
0.0439648405,
-0.0202105455,
0.0110953059,
-0.0214230828,
0.0177732836,
0.027995456,
0.0152587034,
-0.0552037321,
-0.0066983309,
0.0005660419,
0.0108712027,
0.055481039,
-0.0325234793,
0.0668269247,
0.0061261025,
-0.0143531617,
0.0215889961,
0.0327785313,
0.0475782007,
0.03389192,
0.0005673046,
-0.0408910103,
0.0216007847,
-0.0338053331,
0.027481975,
-0.0051521445,
-0.0189908519,
0.0169978701,
-0.017067736,
0.0083424179,
-0.0200852714,
-0.0117368307,
-0.0290644094,
-0.0211088415,
0.0148503361,
-0.00813042,
0.0769030303,
-0.0264639128,
-0.0357446,
0.0283237305,
0.0446545146,
-0.000543334,
-0.0122885592,
-0.032121107,
-0.0229267497,
0.0878349319,
0.0291922782,
-0.0294577852,
-0.0022606491,
-0.0023193592,
-0.0458655059,
-0.0089317132,
-0.0012480268,
-0.0321673192,
0.0085866703,
-0.0382024832,
0.0061386093,
0.0260564052,
-0.0044367458,
-0.0177957229,
-0.0336050428,
0.0209199507,
-0.024631869,
-0.0369633511,
-0.0238287933,
0.0325981975,
-0.0458959118,
-0.0234942641,
0.0008627695,
-0.0030521713,
0.0159767102,
0.0376064032,
-0.008243504,
0.0250209551,
0.0524049364,
-0.0774258077,
-0.0164664779,
-0.0149941398,
-0.0228637289,
-0.0406780504,
0.0263385531,
-0.0210117847,
-0.0124335149,
-0.0647885501,
-0.0343484208,
-0.0228199419,
-0.0223049987,
-0.027687801,
0.0525266044,
0.0006681624,
0.0239528008,
0.0335386992,
-0.0325073935,
-0.0410650335,
0.0630825162,
-0.0109042544,
-0.0238068011,
0.0233871993,
-0.0928153247,
0.0220073331,
-0.0274415147,
-0.0179292485,
0.0283592176,
0.0181071889,
-0.0024790994,
0.0032138696,
-0.0289667882,
-0.0086767599,
-0.0305382293,
-0.1247237846,
-0.0089683039,
0.0177866314,
0.0249713697,
0.0032708342,
0.0077869683,
0.020596521,
-0.0184251424,
-0.0277354419,
0.0250966381,
-0.0052043074,
0.0149824731,
0.0298618227,
0.051888518,
-0.0511131845,
-0.000907823,
-0.0302368179,
-0.0546069629,
0.0782387629,
0.0375824422,
-0.0475456789,
-0.0236858614,
0.040398851,
-0.020012429,
0.018248627,
-0.0101164337,
0.0420785956,
0.0148560191,
0.0038125992,
0.0282813013,
0.045233652,
-0.0241970271,
0.0841933265,
0.0244399589,
-0.010543271,
0.0090563456,
-0.0119462674,
-0.058047425,
-0.0123013295,
-0.0398696922,
-0.0462272428,
-0.01048367,
0.0221218169,
0.0215536188,
0.0344867408,
-0.0393609367,
0.0114199845,
0.0014910676,
0.0094300034,
-0.0661080331,
0.0011102664,
-0.0234207902,
0.010812222,
-0.0219279137,
-0.0297106896,
0.1013971791,
0.0094991801,
0.0461950749,
-0.0172864627,
-0.0073257755,
-0.0086057205,
0.0341104046,
0.0192014687,
0.0267794244,
-0.0049766717,
-0.0119323647,
0.0101015456,
0.0174246766,
0.0063719461,
-0.0419277512,
0.0732779056,
-0.0274915621,
0.0360474959,
0.0322692506,
-0.0159919597,
-0.0587094016,
0.0424528383,
-0.0172044076,
0.0203941222,
-0.004961689,
0.0160853881,
-0.0313727185,
0.0399100035,
-0.0055913143,
0.0281480867,
0.0202768985,
-0.0079307128,
-0.0037770064,
0.0112707829,
0.0389939211,
-0.0620983317,
-0.019572977,
-0.0380488671,
0.0402503423,
0.0426574834,
-0.0199625678,
0.0125572719,
-0.0263433754,
0.0143709099,
-0.0068051703,
-0.0366751216,
0.0147786774,
0.0272060037,
0.0060574138,
-0.042364195,
0.0259644873,
0.0958899483,
0.0145163722,
-0.0846895128,
0.0158260316,
0.0386423282,
-0.0483964868,
-0.0210903399,
0.0059573962,
-0.1069475412,
-0.0080196708,
-0.0357123166,
0.029365642,
0.0087578585,
-0.0593262427,
0.0340345167,
-0.0554540306,
0.022309728,
0.0135460915,
-0.0408647358,
-0.0646381527,
-0.0664054826,
-0.0262615997,
-0.031945847,
-0.0157262944,
0.0054780068,
-0.0236205757,
-0.032917928,
0.0189557951,
-0.0467450395,
-0.0825859085,
0.013504263,
-0.0197931081,
0.0631051138,
0.0563551262,
0.0164974816,
0.0080862902,
-0.0275770109,
-0.0287340302,
0.00597667,
0.0082697039,
-0.0013694791,
0.0756585374,
0.0132032493,
-0.018519979,
-0.0693316758,
0.0264806785,
-0.0375092775,
0.0034973526,
-0.0052681342,
0.0791437998,
-0.0478735045,
-0.0359016247,
-0.0132096615,
-0.0448177904,
0.0062490613,
0.0538268797,
0.0060237874,
-0.0105177984,
-0.044632405,
0.0077235787,
0.0465781912,
-0.0018874854,
0.0110167656,
0.0488855802,
-0.0388550125,
-0.0253797825,
-0.0333052389,
-0.0255009606,
0.0540431105,
-0.0212543532,
0.0214004833,
0.0255992897,
0.0909814611,
-0.0212947316,
-0.0654180497,
0.0297427755,
0.0387778729,
-0.0023736181,
-0.0447764508,
-0.0523102432,
0.0075765015,
0.0058960817,
-0.0058671734,
-0.0146377152,
-0.0276700538,
-0.0395929031,
-0.0008556102,
0.0610931255,
0.021564519,
0.0274859797,
0.0047110394,
-0.0205511898,
0.0408841781,
0.0416564085,
-0.0219886824,
-0.0180683974,
-0.0466814898,
-0.0202870946,
-0.0158958454,
-0.0107692061,
-0.0352319889,
0.0173693169,
0.0017932199,
0.007219654,
-0.0288342144,
-0.0176286977,
0.0424822681,
0.079087548,
0.0355906114,
0.0007937216,
-0.0399734862,
-0.0154159134,
0.0420726165,
-0.0372096188,
0.0245774332,
-0.0414616391,
-0.0054935948,
0.025284281,
0.0095070209,
0.0002682951,
-0.0361735113,
-0.0064088837,
-0.040410649,
-0.0576073192,
0.0502217002,
-0.0214199405,
0.0070841732,
0.0926700756,
-0.0201420002,
-0.0124099907,
0.0551967397,
-0.0055590253,
0.000763148,
-0.0137842372,
0.0528319851,
0.0151139013,
0.0357384458,
-0.0143062295,
0.0226376746,
0.0124038197,
-0.0252049249,
-0.0224160086,
0.027363861,
0.0648979917,
0.034423247,
0.0649990812,
-0.0337277539,
0.0049854424,
-0.0549268089,
0.0212189611,
-0.0104941316,
0.0193654522,
0.0388825759,
0.0303726606,
-0.0346299857,
-0.0369338132,
0.0797888339,
-0.0009156325,
0.0354127213,
0.0022794809,
-0.0630498901,
-0.0351148285,
-0.0139861647,
0.0329743475,
-0.0384188741,
-0.0729464516,
-0.0018412331,
-0.0583630279,
-0.065063566,
0.0388256535,
-0.0099136438,
-0.0028456191,
0.009688274,
0.0333621539,
0.0271950867,
0.0266063381,
-0.0277510658,
-0.0211051721,
0.0302365627,
-0.0544983074,
-0.0466198176,
0.0042186785,
-6.307889296e-33,
0.0218785107,
-0.017146064,
0.0293374453,
0.0107580619,
0.0131642651,
0.0242141485,
-0.0451324061,
-0.0171445627,
0.0146473674,
0.0601529256,
0.0090791937,
-0.024633076,
0.0060255416,
0.0286092758,
-0.0105113508,
-0.0253811982,
0.0324455686,
0.0086326571,
0.025767304,
0.0067480924,
0.0198787879,
0.0431901552,
0.0024607179,
-0.1054923832,
0.005598519,
0.0061245398,
0.037044391,
-0.000072932,
-0.0048266295,
0.059784703,
-0.0376203842,
0.0609368272,
0.0224750843,
-0.006603112,
0.0112834563,
-0.008678345,
-0.1130756736,
0.0064763948,
-0.0024491837,
-0.0237120483,
-0.0327816568,
-0.0350466296,
0.0350067019,
0.0022710555,
-0.0169080347,
0.0123645831,
0.0382659584,
-0.032286413,
-0.0698221549,
-0.0502978675,
-0.0109886816,
0.0391109772,
0.0241738912,
0.0198584627,
0.0222312845,
-0.0323928483,
-0.0179768242,
-0.0006342366,
-0.0515538752,
-0.0035358486,
0.0326250084,
-0.0098303035,
-0.0030548871,
-0.0039891042,
0.0324586779,
0.0704967231,
0.0187571719,
0.0038189737,
-0.0305410251,
0.0238032509,
-0.0442467928,
0.0588255301,
0.0112188114,
-0.0260776691,
0.0086723734,
-0.0141038233,
-0.1432375461,
0.0018719038,
-0.0497103706,
0.0392082259,
0.027878236,
-0.0190023687,
-0.0223788917,
-0.0302286372,
-0.0122712431,
0.035757374,
-0.0404106118,
-0.0336967334,
0.0122160725,
-0.0037588652,
0.00514994,
0.0284922384,
0.0112044662,
-0.0442551933,
-0.0136588058,
0.0051048649,
0.0335881561,
0.0110941017,
-0.0365423411,
0.0064959582,
-0.0525999069,
-0.043952696,
0.0145666162,
-0.0382296294,
0.0467382967,
0.0318017527,
-0.0109409597,
-0.0373719446,
-0.053987667,
-0.0046375152,
-0.0045292922,
-0.0157493129,
0.0114035485,
0.021840129,
0.0299671665,
0.0338466354,
0.0085766362,
0.070304513,
0.0185659565,
-0.0035784172,
-0.0183542874,
-0.0274331048,
0.0404521748,
0.0052194921,
-0.0111272195,
-0.0027510175,
-0.0419768244,
0.0343484357,
0.0298185609,
-0.0245949943,
-0.0074121528,
0.0161802117,
2.928e-7,
0.0848022029,
0.0877020657,
0.0242769402,
0.0280158166,
0.0253370609,
0.004169961,
0.0056602028,
0.0083216839,
0.0072656968,
-0.023738578,
0.0421997644,
0.0115495529,
0.029103253,
0.0217695609,
-0.0551152453,
-0.0158635378,
-0.0561939254,
-0.0399670638,
-0.0285104867,
0.0226025563,
0.0768990293,
0.0360942557,
-0.030334089,
-0.0093590356,
0.0530592762,
-0.0216638446,
0.0249658525,
-0.0328377895,
0.0103503354,
0.035536889,
0.0126739275,
-0.0216539446,
0.0058683008,
0.1224258989,
0.0065144543,
-0.0463738069,
-0.0088447882,
0.0760665312,
-0.0816947296,
0.0246066079,
0.0590497926,
0.0025213696,
0.0322355293,
-0.0090734037,
0.0319724791,
-0.056745436,
-0.0494808704,
0.0272805281,
-0.0096099013,
-0.0231360048,
0.0416379124,
-0.0174898487,
0.0091389176,
0.0067001982,
0.0267302506,
0.0298701935,
-0.0092532644,
-0.058860898,
0.0194848198,
0.0484160036,
-0.0084326239,
-0.0455135368,
0.0246445742,
-0.043774195,
0.0151444105,
-0.0714978799,
0.0204829071,
2.762537998e-34,
0.0377207063,
0.0158329736,
-0.0155419614,
0.0317693539,
0.0260948241,
-0.0519312471,
-0.0128124384,
0.0005973215,
-0.0365644917,
-0.1187019274,
-0.0148708494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12463v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12463v2 | Linguistic Analysis using Paninian System of Sounds and Finite State Machines | 2023-01-29T15:22:10 | 2024-04-16T14:19:58 | Shreekanth M Prabhu, Abhisek Midye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | The study of spoken languages comprises phonology, morphology, and grammar.
Analysis of a language can be based on its syntax, semantics, and pragmatics.
The languages can be classified as root languages, inflectional languages, and
stem languages. All these factors lead to the formation of vocabulary which has
commonality/similarity as well as distinct and subtle differences across
languages. In this paper, we make use of Paninian system of sounds to construct
a phonetic map and then words are represented as state transitions on the
phonetic map. Each group of related words that cut across languages is
represented by a m-language (morphological language). Morphological Finite
Automata (MFA) are defined that accept the words belonging to a given
m-language. This exercise can enable us to better understand the
inter-relationships between words in spoken languages in both language-agnostic
and language-cognizant manner. Based on our study and analysis, we propose an
Ecosystem Model for Linguistic Development with Sanskrit at the core, in place
of the widely accepted family tree model. | [
-0.0081392219,
-0.0129019199,
-0.0820133314,
0.0542089008,
-0.0546063073,
-0.0255344957,
-0.0560524464,
0.0028339953,
-0.0546013042,
-0.0308355726,
-0.043022424,
-0.0462079421,
0.0469636209,
-0.0009383248,
0.0239862334,
-0.0696610585,
0.0430320948,
-0.0416861176,
-0.0036428762,
0.0207074583,
0.0416726805,
-0.0089943884,
-0.0133783128,
0.0274429917,
-0.035966482,
-0.0060510151,
-0.0301158559,
-0.0283731595,
0.0223408323,
-0.0350623764,
-0.0765687972,
-0.0205575638,
0.0056331498,
0.0358459726,
0.000001401,
-0.0639121309,
-0.0083975792,
-0.0259387046,
0.0242156442,
-0.0254492592,
0.0344341435,
0.0243591499,
-0.0428985246,
-0.0013662213,
0.0029776036,
-0.0080499453,
0.0817108378,
-0.0458727367,
0.0196749773,
0.0472598225,
-0.0286342483,
-0.099507302,
0.0342876613,
-0.0014004004,
-0.051110331,
-0.0060404567,
0.0506033264,
-0.0083722537,
0.0435644239,
-0.070035629,
-0.0622457638,
-0.0071944706,
-0.0460194647,
-0.0099053811,
0.0068211998,
-0.0002794256,
0.0231490731,
-0.0545958355,
0.01691279,
0.0118793789,
0.0018782481,
-0.0305744745,
0.0049381587,
-0.0011153549,
-0.0600505508,
-0.0065358402,
0.0026291779,
0.0065124519,
-0.0090599209,
0.0737343878,
0.1006019786,
0.0067716939,
-0.0271441285,
-0.0207507927,
0.0158610586,
0.0694029778,
0.0306635406,
-0.0352114253,
-0.051868245,
-0.0451685488,
0.0567352809,
-0.0408066958,
0.0320704132,
0.070502989,
-0.0182310697,
0.0654689148,
0.0109016811,
-0.0581281297,
0.0310267136,
-0.0360240191,
-0.0038719568,
-0.0004987683,
0.0005649708,
-0.0001815713,
0.0143069644,
0.019060066,
0.0362064615,
-0.0470750071,
-0.0376379974,
-0.0115439519,
-0.0095544523,
-0.047310248,
-0.0540159419,
0.0056266431,
0.0273712669,
0.0131565053,
-0.0177290402,
0.0388969891,
0.0286270846,
-0.0360115059,
-0.0166547,
-0.0494118668,
-0.0261987336,
0.0133256279,
0.0128911929,
0.0372228585,
-0.0283789001,
0.0278764293,
-0.0395540223,
-0.001886628,
0.0417193025,
0.0391438194,
0.0092017893,
0.0421909429,
-0.0465013981,
0.0602040477,
0.033116553,
-0.027119603,
-0.0219011661,
0.0403334945,
-0.0122561138,
-0.0321914777,
-0.0191689115,
-0.0265240278,
0.0196375214,
-0.0092414189,
-0.019689532,
0.0270894803,
0.0030282205,
-0.0019951009,
0.0053794584,
0.0156327467,
-0.025999248,
0.0237466078,
0.0041397712,
0.0018915026,
0.0992921591,
0.0075087803,
0.0493141301,
-0.022748908,
0.0565095805,
-0.0509809479,
0.0049840114,
0.0273622479,
-0.0415029302,
-0.0107509233,
-0.0424336232,
-0.0396676771,
-0.0200069286,
0.0095688086,
-0.0297455564,
0.0759699568,
0.0051206159,
0.0132639762,
-0.0323156528,
0.1089448705,
0.0176218301,
0.0537514277,
0.0166794434,
0.0023598575,
0.0168009493,
0.0443066098,
0.066990234,
-0.0291755442,
-0.0067748637,
-0.001332417,
-0.0251799636,
0.0112724276,
-0.003506267,
-0.0054338402,
-0.0294523295,
-0.0324827842,
-0.0495431498,
-0.0667079464,
0.0534925386,
0.0188590419,
-0.0276562516,
-0.0019091031,
0.0287217479,
-0.0388672054,
0.0618798323,
-0.0112745576,
0.078226231,
0.0351579636,
0.0017484411,
-0.0641709343,
0.0059140534,
0.050640028,
-0.0429528095,
0.0725918636,
-0.063900888,
-0.0216127373,
-0.0141341789,
-0.0186252482,
0.0286956374,
0.088645108,
0.0032718403,
0.0451143607,
-0.0957922414,
0.0138275232,
-0.0225774627,
-0.0065610497,
0.0407945067,
0.0165417828,
-0.0063897069,
0.032705497,
0.0046058572,
-0.0073591927,
0.0559309013,
0.0111395,
-0.0143989744,
0.0467864498,
0.0388961248,
-0.014581888,
0.0123065477,
0.0446057916,
-0.0089965351,
0.0357682481,
0.0202028267,
-0.0666378066,
0.0375956409,
-0.0275323186,
0.0201962423,
-0.0723227039,
0.0447604731,
-0.0598458759,
0.0876690149,
-0.0231391676,
0.0587102249,
-0.0103309723,
0.0309971031,
0.0022623767,
0.0289690699,
0.020033244,
0.0056207511,
-0.0767579153,
-0.0192562528,
0.0629588515,
-0.0418417007,
-0.0163252279,
0.0546579398,
-0.0191168953,
-0.0417981409,
-0.0106119486,
-0.0343336239,
-0.029175641,
-0.0164990965,
-0.0912669078,
-0.0463931859,
0.0175300315,
0.0636464432,
-0.0112101212,
0.0175682195,
-0.0138967931,
0.0140607525,
-0.005321194,
0.0875882208,
0.0653213561,
-0.0083420593,
0.0005759092,
-0.0173801966,
-0.0801111013,
-0.063071534,
-0.0177132804,
-0.0139549002,
0.0083385231,
0.0165631678,
-0.0965907574,
-0.0395201072,
-0.0464416221,
-0.0445148386,
0.0273295417,
-0.0137745757,
-0.0041278894,
-0.0024482165,
0.0160406735,
0.0449104048,
-0.0386333838,
0.0091290642,
-0.0075425357,
0.0380149707,
-0.0417054407,
0.0282477327,
-0.029673392,
0.0099732131,
0.0527050681,
-0.0447859503,
0.0138224773,
0.0177542642,
0.0452928729,
0.0125593068,
-0.0118621588,
0.0070049474,
-0.0050514303,
-0.0588432923,
0.0454875268,
0.0245303679,
-0.0534700453,
-0.0798432082,
0.051781442,
-0.0040543531,
-0.0477498882,
0.0498440526,
-0.0784882307,
0.013579444,
-0.0355734117,
0.0140477456,
-0.0429677404,
0.0588948168,
0.0222173277,
-0.0103363097,
0.0535821728,
-0.0365253948,
-0.0106207412,
0.0060926084,
-0.003872152,
-0.0057070963,
0.0139047941,
-0.0640230924,
0.0213326197,
-0.0240224879,
0.0007008968,
-0.0078496663,
0.0394150466,
-0.0008877501,
0.0409336761,
0.023790665,
0.012828867,
0.0649226606,
0.0644818023,
-0.0366059132,
-0.0351584554,
0.0075388257,
0.0333277136,
-0.0095570879,
0.0328624509,
0.0150119653,
0.0121634388,
-0.044075761,
0.0506816059,
0.0258175228,
-0.0492432863,
0.0419506915,
0.0469630212,
0.0244328249,
-0.0135133481,
0.0289673377,
-0.0012052542,
-0.052966997,
0.0132968314,
-0.064581342,
0.0351253003,
-0.0056376439,
0.0377082974,
0.0401867367,
0.003297803,
0.0669316202,
-0.0515269227,
-0.0344916247,
0.012123988,
0.0306213014,
-0.0643111616,
0.0470466167,
0.0230082422,
-0.0386954211,
0.0149163688,
-0.0050097867,
-0.0057614786,
-0.0630989149,
-0.0232819207,
-0.007926885,
-0.0894451961,
-0.011299883,
-0.0122739123,
0.0256867241,
0.0162343513,
-0.0240667127,
0.0384830125,
-0.0288795549,
-0.0307550542,
0.0329020098,
0.0009286426,
-0.0335895941,
-0.0147666177,
-0.0104902973,
0.0172809083,
0.0360949039,
0.0465516523,
-0.0532703772,
-0.0292401742,
0.0312012862,
-0.0139066707,
-0.0166825633,
-0.0234303679,
-0.0669457689,
0.0254091993,
-0.0064102835,
-0.0099328915,
-0.0248973351,
0.0032010898,
-0.0132136829,
0.0080547584,
0.0994077623,
-0.0052866139,
-0.0165881496,
0.0045705163,
-0.0018309122,
-0.0140964082,
-0.0078401351,
0.0051127062,
-0.0100511648,
-0.007310403,
-0.0249645729,
-0.0034073172,
0.0528599098,
-0.0562886372,
-0.0293571819,
-0.0110196453,
-0.0730361864,
-0.0683854669,
-0.0107041914,
-0.0042146309,
0.035182219,
0.0503903031,
0.0373004116,
0.0570232235,
0.0067561842,
0.0031980765,
-0.0662979484,
-0.0043407949,
0.0278570578,
-0.0326212533,
-0.0365148708,
0.0639838204,
0.040664468,
-0.0268015228,
-0.0367727019,
0.0248662475,
-0.0338733569,
0.0365523212,
0.0032321294,
0.0211220998,
-0.0594479553,
-0.0347366631,
-0.0468569063,
-0.003559421,
-0.0035025578,
-0.023906149,
0.0377659164,
0.0420242734,
-0.0251567829,
-0.0001771288,
0.0329602957,
0.0041523864,
0.0276706219,
-0.0130107142,
0.0151566053,
0.0097443648,
-0.0123724965,
0.0035906814,
0.0066158818,
0.0420599021,
-0.0379026309,
-0.0298941899,
-0.0119475732,
-0.0194775909,
-0.027220279,
0.0000686866,
0.0056262743,
-0.0074503557,
0.0148396855,
0.0410778746,
-0.0349920727,
-0.0736707449,
-0.0225553121,
-0.0277336724,
0.1108142138,
0.0669466481,
0.0742534101,
0.0534742549,
-0.0359801054,
0.0124969585,
-0.003254628,
-0.0048015988,
-0.0452201851,
-0.0086903954,
-0.0426792689,
-0.00087081,
-0.0375731252,
0.0118730441,
0.0194170307,
0.0225447323,
0.087478891,
0.0089611616,
0.011115646,
0.0110475458,
0.0759307593,
-0.0102758128,
0.0084713511,
-0.0492384881,
0.0519555882,
-0.0174259283,
0.0008138862,
-0.0362008549,
-0.0288909543,
0.0354878232,
0.0203948114,
0.0007972405,
0.0039622849,
0.043951191,
-0.0100964652,
0.0043296018,
-0.0054239356,
0.0018111533,
-0.0121496329,
-0.0234259516,
-0.0391220301,
0.0046067764,
0.0015811502,
0.0056790118,
-0.0751596615,
-0.0550979376,
-0.0092861243,
0.0091210194,
0.0564266592,
0.0091159791,
0.0458022505,
0.008810509,
0.0295482725,
0.027846545,
-0.0180222504,
0.0224733241,
-0.0198163334,
-0.0128769241,
0.0170509424,
-4.896279273e-33,
-0.0487582162,
-0.0223522056,
-0.0034752188,
0.0366881378,
-0.0159904175,
-0.0198847707,
-0.0534300767,
0.0128334519,
0.0002805105,
-0.0138098728,
0.0029685157,
0.0169595014,
0.0093263406,
-0.0060536875,
0.012876289,
0.0144270854,
-0.0217895787,
-0.017333895,
0.0335485339,
-0.0226257537,
0.0478425473,
-0.0027139576,
0.0782646015,
-0.0255213827,
0.0092385588,
-0.0174143855,
-0.0295950659,
0.0472848378,
-0.0411728024,
-0.0007759229,
-0.0476547368,
0.0615805723,
0.0288589187,
-0.0082686245,
-0.0072160438,
0.0074494672,
-0.0139950449,
-0.057219632,
0.0656770021,
0.0073046265,
0.0253987685,
-0.000315389,
0.0170308985,
0.0006707282,
-0.0132675441,
0.0787682906,
0.0228301715,
-0.0164181218,
-0.0169926174,
-0.0065517253,
-0.0897971615,
0.0257343892,
0.0054209935,
0.0342048928,
0.0362436026,
-0.011310406,
-0.0077914968,
-0.0534227453,
0.0346035771,
0.0542388819,
0.0452860743,
0.0512269959,
0.02810679,
0.0264922231,
-0.0045452411,
0.0027275814,
0.0600336082,
-0.0566072948,
0.0372750908,
0.0299323909,
0.0262142755,
0.0287612714,
0.0116619542,
-0.0255039558,
-0.0051900884,
-0.0335799195,
-0.0073236036,
-0.0202826988,
0.0278170574,
0.0443079025,
-0.031883128,
0.0242355298,
-0.0139263924,
-0.030416524,
0.0192910377,
-0.03815265,
0.0092350049,
0.029556822,
-0.0099690696,
-0.0351542793,
0.0108874924,
0.008487083,
0.0079002716,
-0.0105960732,
-0.0154166417,
0.0179945547,
0.0150940195,
0.0372162648,
-0.024654055,
0.0152906748,
-0.038663622,
-0.0545214936,
-0.0131853996,
0.0081183324,
0.0155673986,
-0.0199098717,
-0.0428029299,
0.0208632518,
-0.0397534594,
-0.0064795176,
0.0254615974,
-0.0334275775,
-0.0036548546,
0.0359008573,
0.015568546,
0.0146142282,
-0.008544351,
-0.0207587797,
0.0571670048,
0.0044464385,
-0.0319069065,
0.0115245143,
-0.0366262533,
0.0090034381,
-0.0035140649,
-0.000908715,
-0.0296338629,
0.0353519768,
0.0558758676,
-0.0159299579,
0.0099950125,
0.018586481,
2.507e-7,
0.0024256213,
0.0219861176,
0.0545476563,
-0.0327240564,
0.0686080381,
-0.0259006787,
-0.0499081127,
-0.0065355543,
-0.0228949077,
0.0225726254,
0.0158409383,
-0.0357145406,
-0.0032123222,
0.064809233,
-0.0795468464,
0.0380460285,
-0.068929553,
-0.0099036032,
-0.055050198,
0.0059389202,
-0.0249433108,
0.0851079449,
0.0189619232,
-0.0202164911,
-0.0416690707,
0.0138093708,
0.0109364996,
0.025796758,
0.0698982179,
-0.0073506078,
-0.0137154544,
-0.0573480874,
0.0064584394,
0.0032604851,
0.0144534484,
0.0751749873,
-0.014900079,
0.0113675501,
-0.0179183874,
0.0184611268,
0.0665643737,
0.0334322937,
-0.0221927352,
-0.0025071416,
0.0082134157,
0.0140843606,
-0.0171752311,
-0.007840137,
0.0067968802,
0.0730323792,
-0.0432528593,
0.0230694134,
-0.0460025668,
0.0151341138,
-0.006681799,
-0.0552884303,
-0.0220358968,
-0.0166772213,
0.0099593624,
0.0265546441,
-0.0571052209,
-0.035677474,
0.0100355437,
0.0126645919,
0.0167085584,
0.0009699123,
-0.0018077109,
1.762504546e-34,
0.0184772089,
-0.0313936472,
0.0242345035,
0.0001754398,
-0.0270667635,
0.0120295119,
0.0202186201,
0.0703833327,
0.0115444548,
-0.0647450015,
-0.0515265092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12417v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12417v1 | Syrupy Mouthfeel and Hints of Chocolate -- Predicting Coffee Review Scores using Text Based Sentiment | 2023-01-29T10:55:36 | 2023-01-29T10:55:36 | Christopher Lohse, Jeroen Lemsom, Athanasios Kalogiratos | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper uses textual data contained in certified (q-graded) coffee reviews
to predict corresponding scores on a scale from 0-100. By transforming this
highly specialized and standardized textual data in a predictor space, we
construct regression models which accurately capture the patterns in
corresponding coffee bean scores. | [
0.0509388037,
0.0646886602,
-0.0321796015,
0.0081141274,
-0.0148382522,
-0.0176189709,
-0.0226264503,
-0.0047059646,
0.0043146214,
-0.0230890065,
0.0310557708,
0.026211476,
-0.0067498507,
0.0754747838,
-0.0309805721,
-0.0085825427,
0.0199235994,
0.0218205824,
0.0454760715,
0.0293578245,
0.0164871179,
0.0065811235,
0.0279312842,
0.0085654231,
-0.0398763418,
0.0041370196,
0.0233408343,
-0.0434811302,
-0.0006564287,
-0.0370516777,
0.041698467,
0.0488130152,
-0.0722849667,
-0.022205947,
0.0000014968,
-0.0047159628,
-0.0051112804,
-0.0124005759,
0.0345607214,
-0.0138707664,
0.047772672,
0.013317016,
0.0335836932,
0.0325157605,
-0.0558771864,
0.0074480991,
0.0155565599,
0.0380549729,
0.0360039398,
0.022944726,
-0.0278299097,
-0.0892767012,
-0.068360582,
-0.001578646,
0.0462672412,
0.0072011803,
0.0147238458,
0.0277016889,
-0.0336829238,
0.0188694019,
0.0068810554,
0.0103775179,
-0.0131659703,
0.0058111907,
0.0482248403,
0.0120868087,
0.0014389044,
-0.0025940861,
0.0101394271,
0.0240718238,
-0.0073429202,
-0.0083354665,
-0.0191652887,
0.0170971174,
0.0157346074,
-0.0044285241,
-0.0102064032,
-0.0469428673,
-0.0127704218,
0.0373632088,
-0.0213014744,
0.0578258187,
-0.0037071435,
0.0155625315,
0.0408864021,
0.0176011045,
-0.0355197452,
-0.0376472026,
0.0538705662,
0.0339312404,
0.0102342796,
0.0130821578,
-0.0086604729,
-0.0381335132,
0.0140292607,
0.0025668507,
0.0417974442,
0.0284456331,
0.0478257462,
-0.0554189049,
0.0026312391,
0.0024495465,
0.0064889868,
0.0169548281,
-0.0651952997,
0.0192733407,
0.0453413837,
-0.0248564444,
-0.0665012896,
0.0366778634,
-0.0957559347,
-0.0285271294,
0.0054843151,
0.0517317168,
0.0019748399,
0.026510587,
-0.0708177835,
-0.0117174517,
-0.0247609653,
-0.0294556003,
0.0561385527,
0.0512940772,
0.0069729574,
0.0457003601,
-0.067879945,
0.0502848104,
-0.0430618376,
0.057713788,
-0.0669012666,
0.0712190419,
0.0292631537,
-0.0060728844,
0.0206344556,
0.0634103492,
0.0176126547,
0.0396811068,
0.020587977,
-0.0134700499,
-0.0138705485,
-0.0393669046,
-0.0368918031,
-0.0512849763,
-0.0252453163,
-0.0206988193,
0.0032171065,
0.0146572068,
0.0112939104,
0.002146014,
0.015858531,
0.0166870132,
-0.0140237743,
0.0281112529,
0.0325807445,
-0.0015847804,
-0.0081419749,
-0.0151324691,
-0.0249881204,
0.0327145942,
-0.0042173644,
0.0507538207,
-0.0000714778,
-0.0245781671,
0.0125621008,
-0.0064322385,
-0.0243591256,
-0.0201743487,
-0.0335460044,
0.0097552137,
-0.0001372166,
-0.0196087044,
-0.0474162586,
0.0295191742,
0.0419151634,
0.0246628076,
0.0975410566,
0.0525098331,
-0.0035262723,
0.0465747342,
0.0006877898,
-0.0056029726,
-0.0298214629,
-0.0492917262,
0.0309278201,
-0.0184215028,
-0.0593076944,
0.00170505,
-0.0091415662,
-0.0145906461,
-0.0255329162,
-0.0779134855,
-0.0137628978,
0.0056538964,
-0.0029305047,
-0.0460008234,
0.0513855815,
-0.0344330147,
-0.0318000838,
-0.0431380756,
0.0080796648,
-0.0606136881,
0.0015045146,
-0.0264549181,
0.0914427936,
0.1017155871,
-0.0338157378,
-0.0110305203,
0.0762324482,
-0.0351295061,
-0.0247448385,
-0.0304977372,
0.0009851874,
-0.0396530442,
-0.0486810952,
0.0085492861,
-0.0042899013,
0.0230178721,
0.0162714552,
-0.0220473558,
-0.0673908815,
0.0748347938,
-0.0232339762,
0.0246456023,
-0.0254381839,
-0.0118391253,
0.044683408,
-0.0098872893,
0.041802071,
0.000727505,
0.0351406075,
0.0503572375,
0.0164347701,
-0.0047102161,
0.0613310076,
-0.0193043966,
-0.0725387931,
0.0487563349,
0.028594749,
-0.0152378017,
-0.0273372587,
-0.0490634628,
0.0256085433,
-0.0107766315,
-0.02344767,
-0.0162313581,
0.0117415385,
-0.0103303073,
0.003930259,
0.001498377,
-0.010940942,
-0.0361636207,
-0.045574706,
-0.0174626168,
0.0450482927,
-0.0223089624,
0.0314453244,
-0.0962933153,
-0.0615659691,
-0.0082825031,
0.0488846414,
-0.0055984668,
-0.0203492623,
0.0294371992,
0.0326315761,
0.013031356,
0.0030809469,
-0.0067593446,
-0.038459219,
-0.088255614,
-0.0104392311,
0.0087550879,
-0.0275487155,
0.0393390395,
-0.0189973116,
0.0157928299,
-0.0068989568,
-0.0171564408,
0.0399786346,
0.0176968873,
-0.0181367081,
0.0289379247,
0.043054942,
0.0225234441,
-0.0368949026,
-0.0073396536,
-0.0294468738,
0.0494226962,
0.0225563385,
-0.0390235931,
-0.0255109202,
0.052902665,
-0.009831449,
-0.0059374738,
0.0020610727,
-0.0172144026,
-0.0385469608,
-0.0030676036,
-0.0285761412,
0.0240202211,
0.0368787609,
-0.0001132687,
0.0446614474,
-0.0048892433,
-0.0259378571,
-0.0074109314,
-0.0683599934,
0.0234988239,
0.0184489656,
-0.0409959666,
0.0157006048,
0.0712187961,
0.005130603,
0.0095293205,
-0.0208736882,
0.0497090183,
-0.0090850852,
-0.0017764554,
-0.0468321666,
-0.0081517696,
0.0256117992,
0.048774492,
0.0236695744,
-0.0595363006,
0.0416248403,
0.0143126706,
0.0359052829,
-0.0939661488,
0.0085818721,
0.0282269716,
0.0416556448,
-0.0375719927,
0.006789193,
-0.003392692,
0.0711256415,
0.0237739328,
-0.0213228036,
-0.0164748672,
-0.0287894923,
0.0358393528,
-0.0357905738,
-0.0033935709,
0.0152522763,
-0.0366405919,
-0.0073405067,
-0.0632769465,
-0.0509985276,
-0.0267630462,
0.0280392542,
0.0397009254,
-0.0564959943,
0.0572104491,
-0.0383519977,
-0.0451980568,
-0.0529340878,
-0.0460825749,
0.0251732226,
-0.0267117545,
0.0447878018,
-0.0580507293,
-0.0111734224,
-0.021302741,
0.0188197754,
0.0182739422,
-0.0563584529,
-0.0050898404,
0.0000664832,
-0.0156606678,
0.0001688571,
0.0222355835,
0.0293331333,
-0.0340816155,
-0.0044691153,
-0.0063359332,
-0.0062878039,
0.0759040117,
0.0452632159,
-0.0280370302,
-0.0139188506,
0.0503208674,
-0.0035662495,
0.0187933538,
0.0072981147,
-0.0321208164,
0.0075035528,
-0.0192773547,
0.0127084525,
-0.0520994999,
0.0095256893,
-0.0270584915,
-0.1015550494,
-0.0011755961,
-0.0101450551,
-0.0309293997,
-0.0364399143,
-0.0310157929,
-0.0246121623,
-0.0368675329,
0.0021168066,
-0.0460539684,
-0.0278700404,
0.0417488441,
0.0255821459,
-0.0556123592,
-0.0357734673,
0.0416399688,
0.0203712806,
-0.0112320175,
0.0474043004,
0.0160939936,
-0.0115061561,
-0.0085300812,
-0.0381152593,
-0.0094737802,
0.0137786344,
-0.0103901001,
0.0864420682,
-0.0423772,
-0.013955377,
-0.0394159295,
0.0192374662,
-0.042371612,
0.0571344793,
0.0364710316,
0.011800386,
0.0511380248,
-0.0620270036,
-0.0193745848,
0.0424033329,
0.0349964723,
0.0334576927,
-0.0141424676,
-0.0712910667,
-0.0186591931,
-0.0391785018,
-0.0589254126,
-0.0004271163,
-0.0110224541,
0.0094787488,
-0.032764636,
-0.0514037125,
-0.0487090051,
-0.0320902243,
0.013296051,
0.0091299051,
0.0127199497,
0.0342275836,
0.029074708,
0.0079393433,
0.0168638881,
0.0116657512,
0.0472804904,
-0.0037678797,
-0.0359231718,
0.021148365,
0.1034882963,
0.0060822982,
-0.0469347797,
-0.0808445439,
-0.0483978689,
-0.0255869683,
0.0127251614,
0.1162357032,
0.0203561522,
-0.0067589246,
-0.0162908398,
-0.0210920256,
0.0224078223,
0.0421779118,
-0.0877117142,
-0.0045690751,
-0.014945522,
0.0163379461,
0.0535549521,
0.0016043342,
-0.0111237774,
0.0406989045,
-0.009085997,
-0.0338879898,
-0.0275986604,
-0.0205308422,
0.0086874114,
-0.082464397,
0.0502154976,
0.0455874167,
0.0225944351,
-0.009269733,
0.026096696,
-0.0145504419,
-0.03501096,
-0.0188493785,
-0.0143271377,
0.0132763498,
0.0349544026,
-0.0608831421,
-0.0559893362,
-0.0698225573,
0.0290328059,
-0.0573277697,
0.0200243387,
0.0167714097,
0.0488688648,
0.0112668518,
0.0191828515,
0.0154668381,
-0.0516983755,
0.0256698113,
-0.0128096584,
-0.0187267773,
0.0435647778,
0.0204220451,
0.0548359491,
-0.0511196405,
0.037849769,
-0.0269569047,
0.0407553166,
-0.0359864533,
-0.0512312911,
-0.025538234,
-0.0626350045,
0.0438240878,
0.0082537821,
0.0047635976,
-0.0251390021,
0.0282140989,
-0.0016986568,
0.033908844,
0.07420858,
-0.0118747586,
-0.0146065103,
0.0057039768,
0.0569144599,
-0.0517428443,
-0.0304910336,
0.0248335693,
-0.0429445095,
-0.0065386179,
0.0507551096,
0.0423666723,
-0.012636791,
0.0166873075,
-0.0261091441,
-0.0614420697,
-0.0314848721,
0.0812077001,
-0.0087140538,
0.0686536357,
-0.004993421,
-0.0126310904,
0.0672531947,
0.0403332338,
0.0450482965,
-0.0504167639,
-0.0090898508,
-0.0294783488,
-0.0238833707,
-0.0191056412,
-5.286845352e-33,
-0.0167084858,
-0.0289563313,
-0.0558798797,
0.0428503752,
0.037358053,
0.0043975371,
0.0262785889,
0.0091954945,
0.0480612814,
0.0262002889,
0.006893327,
-0.0057559437,
0.0097530037,
-0.0120185353,
0.1000958607,
-0.0442329422,
0.0470402353,
0.0018314754,
0.019560948,
0.0144916764,
0.0226619374,
0.0126332147,
-0.0036862942,
-0.0980885774,
0.067733258,
-0.0226543602,
-0.0413694009,
-0.0349678583,
0.0580181144,
0.0481569059,
-0.0353773832,
0.0846421495,
0.0425357781,
0.0308042634,
0.0057248566,
0.0291302055,
-0.0160065517,
0.017579684,
-0.0135347033,
-0.0153128617,
0.0320620127,
0.0159096885,
0.0160741713,
0.0254007075,
-0.0316747911,
0.0259970706,
0.0661712885,
-0.0097466521,
0.023704933,
-0.0642515421,
-0.0250141695,
-0.0130888019,
-0.0061648539,
0.0253237691,
0.0117323576,
0.0861094147,
0.0209708046,
0.0243676621,
0.0442817062,
0.0413426124,
-0.0348671675,
0.0240611956,
-0.0007677028,
0.0151231065,
-0.0240325686,
0.0669001564,
-0.0176081602,
-0.002421523,
0.0235723834,
0.0292068869,
0.0214567594,
-0.0126327947,
0.0628075078,
0.0602456406,
0.048040621,
-0.0731027871,
-0.0705725551,
0.0390331857,
-0.0072634304,
-0.0400220715,
0.0438586511,
-0.0303951129,
-0.0187422894,
-0.02459432,
0.022375701,
-0.0075380411,
-0.0283570271,
-0.0267949421,
0.0108178332,
-0.0033977365,
-0.0191023257,
-0.0176384728,
-0.0172592886,
-0.0161345918,
-0.0438615866,
-0.0214551501,
-0.0465535708,
0.0424868539,
0.00135024,
0.0065399632,
-0.0432899073,
0.0020671247,
-0.0541627854,
0.0843844339,
0.000091453,
-0.0325595886,
0.0320160165,
0.0180089381,
-0.0822099522,
-0.015020486,
0.02813581,
-0.0217030514,
0.0127402581,
0.0456319302,
-0.0165134147,
-0.0158874411,
0.0094445655,
0.0728694871,
-0.0416995473,
0.0168888364,
0.0032114438,
-0.0555029809,
0.0350001939,
-0.0277736783,
-0.007549793,
-0.0530562215,
0.007115718,
-0.0036365413,
-0.0128051937,
-0.0388651118,
0.0070293378,
-0.0249537695,
2.376e-7,
0.0799007863,
0.0506750867,
-0.0522856563,
-0.0352338143,
-0.0189474635,
0.0208603013,
-0.0017280419,
0.0345603526,
0.0479098,
0.0054294327,
0.0226569716,
-0.0431555212,
-0.0279122405,
0.0630548969,
-0.1032875329,
-0.035577219,
-0.0365497023,
-0.0593540147,
-0.0334135555,
0.0076874215,
0.0752970055,
0.0343041904,
0.0161052216,
0.0062447097,
-0.0290176068,
-0.0019570228,
0.0204296093,
-0.0701111704,
-0.0096402159,
-0.023981994,
0.0211668815,
-0.0080758147,
-0.0066324505,
0.001214237,
-0.0244291443,
0.0287594665,
0.0027656755,
0.0092213182,
-0.0023026818,
-0.0192856416,
0.0347910784,
0.0157947186,
0.0066799782,
-0.0201517772,
0.0326656885,
-0.0207558814,
-0.0181924514,
-0.025895251,
0.0041262326,
-0.0057749739,
0.0445968509,
-0.028734684,
-0.0202928446,
0.038529966,
-0.0128116589,
-0.0046459083,
0.0069541098,
-0.0035135287,
0.0195978694,
-0.003237372,
0.018193176,
-0.0378905088,
0.0366960242,
0.0382506624,
-0.0166902747,
-0.0184034016,
0.0380375944,
1.753811743e-34,
0.0674222484,
-0.0153753804,
0.0102198087,
-0.0417384952,
0.0142981075,
0.005279806,
-0.0248802472,
0.0027969324,
0.0330788344,
-0.0518602878,
-0.0030580389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12376v1 | Enhancing Dialogue Summarization with Topic-Aware Global- and Local- Level Centrality | 2023-01-29T06:41:55 | 2023-01-29T06:41:55 | Xinnian Liang, Shuangzhi Wu, Chenhao Cui, Jiaqi Bai, Chao Bian, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue summarization aims to condense a given dialogue into a simple and
focused summary text. Typically, both the roles' viewpoints and conversational
topics change in the dialogue stream. Thus how to effectively handle the
shifting topics and select the most salient utterance becomes one of the major
challenges of this task. In this paper, we propose a novel topic-aware
Global-Local Centrality (GLC) model to help select the salient context from all
sub-topics. The centralities are constructed at both the global and local
levels. The global one aims to identify vital sub-topics in the dialogue and
the local one aims to select the most important context in each sub-topic.
Specifically, the GLC collects sub-topic based on the utterance
representations. And each utterance is aligned with one sub-topic. Based on the
sub-topics, the GLC calculates global- and local-level centralities. Finally,
we combine the two to guide the model to capture both salient context and
sub-topics when generating summaries. Experimental results show that our model
outperforms strong baselines on three public dialogue summarization datasets:
CSDS, MC, and SAMSUM. Further analysis demonstrates that our GLC can exactly
identify vital contents from
sub-topics.~\footnote{\url{https://github.com/xnliang98/bart-glc}} | [
0.0497520491,
-0.0004464529,
0.0219535641,
0.0252216328,
-0.0161207244,
0.0018398617,
-0.0435681902,
-0.0410219468,
-0.0239785369,
-0.021860132,
0.0011030111,
-0.0442776382,
0.0038647808,
0.0108174589,
-0.0140578477,
-0.1128956303,
0.0300741736,
-0.0016300891,
0.0353987999,
0.0007173831,
0.0502713621,
0.0063877986,
-0.0074505601,
0.0260260254,
0.0027877549,
0.000773832,
-0.0038540466,
0.012766188,
0.0761790052,
0.0165937841,
0.0103445807,
0.0197821073,
0.0375143066,
-0.0224936046,
0.000001777,
-0.0280468818,
-0.034031719,
-0.0525039993,
0.0217967648,
0.0087320311,
0.0357068069,
-0.0192288328,
0.0080440678,
0.024184471,
-0.0360958315,
0.0345309786,
0.0200798064,
0.0719965175,
0.063714169,
0.0599463806,
-0.0243522339,
-0.0325078033,
-0.0090714209,
-0.0059855129,
-0.0363421962,
-0.0621953346,
-0.0243981127,
0.066472739,
-0.0228813291,
0.0091929156,
0.0035035575,
0.0220640209,
-0.0194081236,
-0.0539701432,
0.0253617633,
0.0089368401,
-0.0530056693,
0.0050086477,
0.0239292197,
0.105124481,
0.0246327538,
0.0247916449,
0.0321515575,
0.0152917998,
0.0088856993,
-0.0426994339,
-0.0879110694,
0.0411510095,
0.0180520955,
0.0309553742,
0.0094077718,
0.0649594739,
-0.0419011191,
0.0137749482,
-0.0125717726,
-0.0121686487,
-0.0039290586,
-0.0140205221,
-0.0599774979,
-0.015615046,
-0.0292877983,
-0.0446546599,
0.0350023657,
0.0226574168,
-0.0443154573,
0.0069810636,
-0.0170555003,
0.0135122612,
-0.0162868202,
-0.0291305818,
-0.011475198,
-0.0017908984,
-0.0018028057,
0.0488036983,
0.0303443391,
0.0482522547,
0.0112542948,
0.0040418576,
-0.0660292804,
-0.0447857678,
-0.016280055,
0.0279471911,
-0.0306714363,
0.0375838764,
-0.062944442,
-0.0515641496,
-0.0364999734,
0.0249696001,
0.0204629488,
-0.0215387456,
-0.014322862,
0.0305427406,
-0.001377709,
-0.0110724848,
0.0528488941,
0.0560136214,
-0.0340603143,
-0.0243907031,
0.0361206569,
0.0194919892,
-0.010579248,
0.054301206,
0.0457796827,
0.0153913284,
-0.0445719175,
0.015840536,
-0.0441950895,
-0.0441877991,
0.001424558,
-0.0168797895,
-0.0501989052,
-0.0014086233,
-0.0314676985,
-0.0313785225,
0.0080069769,
-0.0210983902,
-0.0205638632,
0.0043792143,
-0.0054840227,
-0.0093967346,
-0.0150850359,
0.0044265999,
0.0056694262,
0.0183868557,
0.0569989271,
0.0169583391,
0.0568191037,
0.0330458209,
0.0279592145,
0.0342725776,
0.07814987,
0.0198515225,
-0.012490904,
0.0033470858,
-0.0076118871,
0.0261622407,
0.0407301821,
-0.0095035173,
-0.0578156747,
-0.0185559113,
0.0313017927,
0.0445599258,
-0.0377347209,
0.0056345188,
0.0779654533,
0.0978778973,
-0.0272747017,
-0.0089990236,
-0.0088769021,
0.0913561657,
0.0013282382,
0.0663307086,
0.0042278953,
0.0309275519,
-0.0257575624,
0.0324276239,
0.0993224755,
0.014195377,
-0.0436189845,
-0.0319064334,
0.0150566055,
-0.0111204702,
-0.0018535656,
-0.0009116526,
0.0054222341,
0.0258415397,
-0.0386005454,
0.0509802774,
-0.001596026,
-0.084067978,
0.003912142,
0.0049652075,
0.0132201919,
0.02457482,
0.0194934364,
-0.0308248643,
-0.040136639,
-0.0291045085,
0.0403371938,
0.0509018824,
0.0179045778,
-0.0334058069,
0.020825902,
-0.0529294312,
-0.0130837793,
0.0080251377,
-0.0018154623,
-0.0165106133,
-0.0122043453,
-0.0500012226,
0.0298559424,
0.0049732141,
0.0004297631,
-0.0169490781,
0.0248851962,
0.0203417558,
0.0003336461,
-0.0012795037,
0.0355931669,
0.0569113009,
-0.0202211943,
-0.0155766448,
0.0331349708,
-0.0234335549,
-0.0451026112,
0.0506690443,
-0.075282298,
-0.0326352492,
0.02409265,
-0.0607662499,
-0.0081207352,
0.0020288336,
-0.0356043763,
-0.0695345998,
0.0288862959,
-0.0626550838,
0.0039926092,
-0.0272072423,
0.0051576449,
0.0162372682,
0.0131609887,
-0.0374486633,
0.0403920412,
-0.0150281321,
-0.0493408665,
0.0664852187,
-0.0051252111,
0.0015731758,
-0.0811520368,
0.0237719975,
-0.0014381011,
-0.0187022425,
-0.0087441569,
0.0622900873,
0.0051572272,
-0.0248592664,
-0.0065652924,
-0.1151376292,
0.0022476737,
-0.027792722,
-0.0064936425,
0.0686034709,
0.0441009142,
-0.0078840787,
-0.0052152262,
-0.0517807826,
-0.0273658819,
0.0383968875,
-0.0145768374,
0.0222759414,
0.0049342522,
0.0518177375,
-0.0602543168,
0.0116071589,
0.0228035487,
0.0432818197,
-0.0082435431,
-0.0103193726,
-0.0026941327,
0.0017685137,
-0.0191033427,
-0.0163032208,
-0.0061906301,
-0.0072225374,
-0.0397635736,
0.0049845199,
0.0439793207,
0.0333082862,
0.0749179646,
0.0046631373,
-0.024564404,
-0.042970378,
-0.0256828517,
-0.0101798316,
-0.005394395,
0.0310366601,
0.0083030285,
-0.0325455293,
0.0510444269,
0.0593827702,
0.056852486,
0.0290613156,
-0.0114764571,
-0.0061241454,
-0.0092439298,
-0.0048567294,
-0.0230372883,
-0.0095487498,
-0.028353598,
0.0113267573,
-0.0481491536,
-0.0143386573,
0.0620129667,
-0.0313631222,
-0.0076208049,
-0.0549239703,
-0.0210076887,
-0.0647538081,
0.0244031474,
-0.0324919224,
0.037560381,
-0.0232780483,
-0.051841218,
-0.0289201681,
-0.0270524789,
0.0432554223,
-0.007434946,
0.083520472,
-0.0334882811,
-0.0041066711,
-0.0206808317,
-0.0133815277,
-0.0225465,
-0.0244819894,
-0.024470482,
0.0422140807,
0.0514347628,
-0.0169723835,
-0.03364392,
0.0334331915,
0.0264253281,
0.0412112959,
-0.019434562,
0.0196460616,
-0.0179064423,
0.0877470076,
0.0463948436,
0.0173860863,
0.0005762178,
-0.0212008581,
0.0558444038,
0.0384646095,
0.019114783,
-0.0377246067,
0.0043359725,
-0.0234785769,
-0.0056772339,
-0.0360801145,
0.0170373525,
-0.0388351493,
0.0903548673,
0.003393013,
0.0117019163,
0.1242565364,
0.0225342214,
-0.0323544592,
-0.0199256893,
-0.0118532274,
-0.0115166167,
0.0024613102,
-0.0021077006,
-0.0419288576,
-0.0309859216,
-0.004471649,
0.0059529459,
0.0185059421,
-0.0400308892,
-0.0268741809,
-0.0327710025,
0.0294253957,
0.014287292,
-0.0722629651,
-0.0254982114,
-0.0047312565,
0.014500876,
-0.0360206999,
0.0272434298,
0.0175789986,
-0.018293418,
-0.0289891027,
-0.0017980412,
-0.0790556744,
0.0172159076,
0.0013676054,
-0.0049621752,
0.0066569396,
0.0428961925,
0.0514091998,
0.0472026877,
0.0864347368,
0.0298593286,
-0.0436965153,
-0.0025103423,
0.0155248689,
0.0484853275,
-0.0106624877,
-0.0017697216,
-0.0364144631,
0.043097809,
0.0214160308,
-0.0208840352,
0.0268914755,
-0.0287035797,
-0.0048327567,
0.0202023294,
-0.0302324407,
0.0771915093,
-0.0112762181,
0.0619035289,
0.0387840495,
-0.0007964113,
-0.002408904,
-0.025135871,
-0.0035288748,
-0.03995068,
-0.025175117,
-0.0258769151,
-0.0095828865,
0.0131460736,
-0.0819269046,
-0.0237667598,
0.0137321698,
-0.0286960006,
-0.0278968085,
-0.0283414479,
0.014122325,
0.0046878923,
-0.0287688896,
-0.0154913981,
-0.0473842658,
-0.0252456535,
-0.0338536501,
-0.0165678523,
0.0797253922,
-0.0241901539,
-0.014077073,
0.0410642214,
-0.0570201427,
-0.0543043427,
-0.0571629368,
0.0343971215,
0.0132469153,
0.0467080399,
0.0023184537,
-0.0346668959,
0.0143054556,
-0.0221051201,
-0.0123481918,
0.0228215512,
0.0257894732,
0.0489704683,
-0.0197522212,
0.0393115766,
-0.0348218642,
0.0505225174,
-0.0285728425,
0.0400897786,
-0.0465237759,
-0.0454033874,
-0.0130191231,
0.0135046756,
0.0133141195,
0.0270924941,
0.0000241888,
-0.0418032855,
-0.0035971703,
-0.0352293104,
-0.0217077136,
-0.025971368,
0.0540216677,
-0.0217046216,
-0.0138832424,
0.0145032248,
0.0467659235,
-0.0523009673,
0.005001823,
-0.0358982943,
-0.0170639567,
-0.0063675158,
-0.0381678231,
-0.0425659306,
-0.0052535525,
-0.0341910906,
0.023752233,
-0.0167486593,
0.006855404,
0.0080017652,
0.0422625244,
-0.0302787386,
-0.0309583247,
0.0073268325,
0.0397319831,
-0.107469365,
-0.0070404233,
-0.0378617682,
0.0450357869,
0.0487287715,
-0.0397464484,
0.0828142762,
0.0274877753,
0.0231427494,
-0.036781583,
0.0620161258,
0.0011401661,
-0.0353239961,
-0.0505489856,
0.015704779,
0.0156134311,
0.0691392794,
0.0819392279,
-0.0487384647,
-0.0380288847,
0.0182887875,
-0.0047231354,
-0.0615399554,
-0.0243233163,
0.005146509,
0.0711254552,
-0.0035688286,
0.0173682757,
-0.0468577519,
-0.0085894112,
0.0470774695,
-0.0295166411,
0.0161291119,
0.0066684536,
0.0483415946,
0.0254394934,
-0.0154231982,
0.0056600189,
-0.0417478681,
-0.0168675352,
-0.0164730214,
0.0204211939,
-0.0169014223,
-5.889630406e-33,
-0.0361402035,
-0.0281771142,
-0.0404913984,
0.0443926677,
-0.0422865599,
0.0394332372,
-0.0707847476,
0.0059087314,
0.0147490855,
-0.0011864597,
-0.0097580831,
0.0379187204,
0.0178209282,
0.062902607,
-0.0445983186,
-0.0095463544,
0.0441193171,
0.0088893073,
-0.0447211452,
0.0775679946,
0.0351922438,
0.0049397768,
0.0374091156,
-0.0652315617,
0.0030844586,
-0.030597901,
-0.0139113944,
0.0172053017,
0.0834898725,
0.0457612239,
0.0089239907,
0.039069932,
0.0258438401,
-0.0375495329,
-0.0551614575,
0.0247029383,
-0.0355855413,
-0.002848384,
0.0037097335,
-0.0410933904,
-0.0329421908,
-0.0237202272,
0.0017287618,
-0.0229059961,
0.0344016254,
-0.0486243069,
0.0544083454,
-0.0400617868,
-0.0218917038,
-0.0481500961,
-0.0319759063,
0.0290294327,
-0.0808733106,
-0.0538306907,
0.0028669925,
0.0440738201,
0.0272460859,
-0.0119885718,
0.0278844386,
0.0926590264,
0.0039896346,
0.0043058014,
0.0469838977,
0.0139881307,
-0.0105089499,
0.077375479,
-0.0046628476,
0.0042494824,
-0.0023714472,
-0.0393119864,
-0.0521244667,
0.0216729566,
-0.0072322767,
0.0588777028,
-0.0288879275,
0.0501794219,
-0.0472719669,
0.0566236898,
0.0449583046,
0.0019746067,
0.0053069824,
0.0257237293,
0.0118336082,
-0.0058507756,
-0.0136899389,
-0.0074505433,
-0.0029719882,
-0.0022106988,
-0.0223670732,
0.0182134993,
-0.0380267613,
-0.020686863,
0.0519404262,
-0.0297464784,
0.0531521663,
0.048890315,
-0.0103564505,
-0.0025690703,
-0.0017783848,
-0.0248959232,
-0.026449183,
-0.0026636343,
0.0369621255,
-0.0107768504,
-0.0151295466,
0.0074152402,
0.0126179969,
-0.0171431657,
-0.0065037305,
0.0110072922,
0.0265972521,
0.0213289913,
-0.0886982903,
0.0517105795,
-0.026621595,
-0.0106943846,
-0.0097702788,
0.0777444094,
0.0006881922,
0.0418966673,
0.000210123,
-0.0291299839,
0.0035099986,
0.0222205222,
-0.0233122073,
0.0283459239,
0.01049178,
0.0015170338,
0.0018101353,
-0.0334591195,
-0.0245564505,
-0.0281637553,
2.364e-7,
0.0203046054,
0.0365739465,
0.0704819933,
-0.0356164277,
0.012343456,
0.0226560142,
0.0083418433,
0.0421629995,
0.0410233997,
-0.0191881135,
0.0418333523,
0.0398047045,
0.0497812554,
-0.0054805549,
-0.1302083582,
0.0007328922,
-0.0811353996,
-0.0760909021,
-0.0066434043,
-0.0045521627,
0.0242470037,
0.0514170341,
-0.0160048287,
0.0046945135,
-0.0169436727,
-0.0167638827,
0.0349234939,
-0.0299284235,
-0.0508117005,
0.0361066684,
0.0064587095,
0.0116757806,
-0.0323772617,
-0.021958435,
0.0074307877,
0.0178648848,
0.058489807,
0.059127301,
0.0168031566,
-0.0707520097,
-0.0134638185,
0.0087633869,
0.0104108769,
0.0052886386,
0.028689364,
-0.0815808028,
0.0001449653,
-0.031626571,
-0.0313412063,
0.0231303181,
-0.0152219692,
-0.0081980499,
-0.0517985448,
0.0385810025,
-0.0182242766,
0.0098091019,
-0.0082677426,
-0.0841059759,
-0.0346550159,
-0.0021257326,
-0.0059534214,
-0.0315476321,
0.0148798674,
-0.0232137945,
0.0055539915,
-0.0036147607,
0.0072167427,
1.991518626e-34,
0.0813401118,
0.005362561,
-0.0429054573,
0.0196645148,
0.0104797948,
-0.0389885679,
-0.0444022305,
-0.0412027985,
0.0190809332,
-0.0577059016,
-0.0056578596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12343v1 | Achieving Timestamp Prediction While Recognizing with Non-Autoregressive End-to-End ASR Model | 2023-01-29T03:47:59 | 2023-01-29T03:47:59 | Xian Shi, Yanni Chen, Shiliang Zhang, Zhijie Yan | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Conventional ASR systems use frame-level phoneme posterior to conduct
force-alignment~(FA) and provide timestamps, while end-to-end ASR systems
especially AED based ones are short of such ability. This paper proposes to
perform timestamp prediction~(TP) while recognizing by utilizing continuous
integrate-and-fire~(CIF) mechanism in non-autoregressive ASR model -
Paraformer. Foucing on the fire place bias issue of CIF, we conduct
post-processing strategies including fire-delay and silence insertion. Besides,
we propose to use scaled-CIF to smooth the weights of CIF output, which is
proved beneficial for both ASR and TP task. Accumulated averaging shift~(AAS)
and diarization error rate~(DER) are adopted to measure the quality of
timestamps and we compare these metrics of proposed system and conventional
hybrid force-alignment system. The experiment results over manually-marked
timestamps testset show that the proposed optimization methods significantly
improve the accuracy of CIF timestamps, reducing 66.7\% and 82.1\% of AAS and
DER respectively. Comparing to Kaldi force-alignment trained with the same
data, optimized CIF timestamps achieved 12.3\% relative AAS reduction. | [
-0.0360244736,
0.0322966203,
0.0267885383,
0.0008149786,
0.0213132929,
0.0315757245,
0.0738278031,
0.014284052,
-0.0475349985,
-0.0131223947,
-0.0103568677,
-0.0641899258,
0.0487103872,
0.0096041141,
-0.0028025729,
0.0013174101,
0.0201565959,
-0.0061219484,
0.0146402,
0.0219794419,
0.0400344618,
-0.0376501419,
-0.0451968126,
0.0262985714,
-0.0709452704,
-0.0034829141,
-0.0438760743,
-0.0321541578,
0.0836326927,
-0.0352539085,
-0.0315951332,
0.012601993,
0.0074769258,
0.0903563052,
0.0000021008,
-0.0362946577,
-0.0298848506,
0.012055913,
-0.0724661797,
-0.0250644032,
0.010468686,
0.0238040518,
-0.0430215672,
0.044051297,
-0.0268204603,
-0.018895369,
0.0779241398,
-0.0019844102,
0.0041170139,
0.057603471,
-0.0030235082,
-0.0812145099,
0.0319021605,
-0.0098029012,
-0.0149264503,
0.0133245187,
-0.0087431148,
-0.0130907129,
-0.020767644,
-0.0224986635,
0.0064805378,
0.0577989444,
-0.0032962761,
-0.0430504493,
0.0365205593,
-0.0048678648,
-0.0623996593,
-0.0102252718,
-0.0211972166,
0.0330533981,
-0.010733298,
-0.0613342375,
0.0109515805,
-0.0085110534,
-0.0543106943,
-0.0262704678,
-0.0283041615,
-0.016771581,
-0.0011582643,
0.0136428634,
-0.0371118002,
0.086666733,
0.0239601005,
-0.0589053258,
0.0254821088,
0.0000063234,
0.0016455832,
-0.0265881121,
-0.00044716,
-0.0519357547,
0.018114781,
-0.0181094073,
0.0416811071,
0.0158691462,
0.0080824718,
-0.0190906487,
-0.0573275685,
-0.0523216762,
-0.0257676989,
-0.0834711939,
0.0198604483,
0.0437736623,
-0.0436048582,
-0.0168338045,
-0.050200019,
0.0965729132,
0.0123817138,
-0.0135848382,
-0.0317155384,
0.0221155677,
-0.0165973399,
0.0024833935,
-0.0132993497,
0.0004502941,
0.0269510597,
-0.0267336611,
-0.0657339692,
-0.0131344469,
-0.0096665472,
0.0003513229,
0.011243877,
0.0008975854,
-0.0324543528,
-0.0280613899,
-0.0128330523,
0.026207881,
0.0295146387,
-0.0000304664,
-0.0131898522,
-0.0233159922,
-0.0187372752,
0.0108175892,
0.0546807274,
0.002110797,
0.0094589191,
-0.0015011183,
-0.0206211135,
-0.0000674937,
-0.0584957376,
0.030985469,
-0.0349349231,
0.0228717104,
0.0040646992,
-0.0458443388,
0.0403874479,
-0.0046732761,
-0.0126641272,
0.0160444453,
0.0006003398,
-0.0003459082,
0.0517838411,
0.0769259706,
0.0004532861,
0.0147720119,
0.0076048723,
-0.0530392937,
-0.0032040444,
0.0274187326,
0.0533804558,
-0.0433292873,
-0.0050077289,
0.0164888948,
-0.0026411428,
0.0307390075,
-0.016156178,
-0.0177120622,
-0.0510991998,
-0.0257236529,
0.0543985479,
0.0212858301,
0.0481006391,
-0.01868142,
0.0423586182,
-0.0409994163,
0.036199633,
-0.0098031918,
-0.0012074485,
-0.016553903,
0.0372404233,
-0.0180688798,
0.0074169985,
0.0107642924,
0.0058182036,
0.0221572984,
-0.0353043452,
0.0209523346,
0.0329261497,
0.0319946222,
-0.0265070107,
-0.019600492,
-0.0217743516,
-0.0282878745,
-0.0145417713,
0.0326923281,
0.0050268397,
-0.026522126,
-0.035407573,
0.0385307856,
-0.0091075925,
0.0113874068,
-0.0188873317,
-0.0233211126,
-0.0311514679,
-0.0173278842,
0.0070157452,
-0.0561523139,
-0.0520980768,
-0.0402987041,
0.0217129793,
0.0255187675,
-0.0130788721,
0.0058542197,
0.0180727318,
-0.0627409145,
-0.0247609336,
0.0782796443,
-0.0374216847,
0.0311659705,
-0.0284065139,
0.038038563,
0.0286240261,
0.0701108724,
-0.0106077157,
-0.0046585985,
0.0024402733,
-0.0601453632,
-0.0685368255,
0.043041341,
0.0387146696,
0.0559709556,
-0.0007477555,
-0.0102894688,
0.0373647735,
-0.0383987725,
0.0415468477,
0.0773584619,
-0.0783596486,
-0.0181811526,
0.0868864357,
0.0636422932,
0.0039752815,
0.0332452133,
0.0226907935,
-0.0758282542,
-0.0086184908,
0.0066142096,
0.0531018153,
-0.0234887321,
0.109991841,
0.062078815,
-0.0259841587,
0.0033859177,
0.003277411,
0.014075635,
-0.0020473804,
-0.0296781398,
0.0361730531,
0.0420365371,
-0.0781836584,
-0.023497995,
0.0378215089,
-0.0394677818,
-0.0124977594,
0.0570620783,
-0.0381410457,
-0.0051534772,
0.0011781456,
-0.0431436673,
-0.059768565,
0.0044062794,
0.0082976678,
-0.0394012518,
0.0143885054,
0.0068538762,
-0.0320586078,
-0.0219235178,
-0.0418864936,
-0.0143829286,
-0.04766009,
-0.0043605589,
0.0267338492,
-0.025126677,
-0.0247314144,
0.0131616453,
-0.011950097,
0.0082425186,
-0.0089619374,
-0.0940281823,
-0.0407651961,
0.0211287662,
0.0269518085,
0.0408380218,
-0.0019850626,
-0.0320867524,
0.0057812831,
0.0393980518,
-0.020178847,
0.0447167866,
-0.0075269672,
-0.0207086112,
-0.0138220266,
0.0073617101,
-0.0332405046,
0.0460222848,
0.009459733,
0.0397509485,
0.0045250263,
0.0679040551,
-0.0621004812,
0.0366139561,
0.0044588768,
0.0439374149,
-0.0583534166,
-0.0098361978,
0.0078766355,
-0.0415276699,
-0.0013889301,
-0.0409624279,
-0.0782126635,
-0.0450475924,
-0.0435030237,
-0.0252292957,
-0.003414314,
-0.0783956423,
-0.0462857708,
0.0170476045,
-0.0284183249,
-0.0014788217,
0.0248983596,
0.0259327628,
0.0004549966,
0.0534831509,
-0.032441318,
-0.0302664135,
0.0119309071,
-0.0005392315,
-0.0507038571,
0.0053371945,
0.0370206647,
0.0106904553,
-0.0195140112,
0.0001612234,
-0.0243857726,
0.0013291432,
-0.0328327678,
0.0138737503,
-0.0686390027,
-0.0403057113,
-0.0121448934,
0.0568367168,
0.0079849772,
0.0333497599,
-0.0148013812,
0.0323339626,
-0.067559287,
0.0444940329,
0.0609004758,
0.0120902611,
-0.0265539195,
0.0276903529,
0.0448826663,
-0.027180627,
0.0929430947,
-0.0091929175,
-0.0988788679,
-0.032789506,
0.0169351529,
-0.0003624429,
-0.0007890469,
-0.0262694955,
0.0018442512,
-0.0097988965,
0.0690203905,
0.0611774959,
0.0065336172,
-0.0201804005,
-0.0170015078,
0.013338306,
-0.0276133046,
0.0140726846,
-0.0253961608,
-0.0315905474,
-0.0014941063,
0.0378593057,
-0.0090653617,
0.0007267552,
0.04043594,
-0.0039175008,
-0.0830853656,
0.0242886655,
0.0458224341,
-0.0014294211,
-0.0580143742,
0.0022806774,
-0.0059987339,
0.0051588756,
0.0519332364,
0.0190779418,
-0.01059327,
-0.0198973343,
0.0931746289,
-0.060807094,
-0.0257602688,
-0.0100271236,
-0.0279515721,
0.0844912007,
0.05484014,
0.0384441614,
0.0125145502,
-0.0694412589,
0.0151099022,
0.0311269108,
0.0231890697,
-0.0022040957,
-0.0198059995,
0.0085164411,
-0.0060568592,
0.0306592155,
0.0185461622,
0.0466417372,
-0.0114570213,
-0.0339425579,
0.0641465336,
-0.0416713357,
0.026030669,
0.0109670637,
-0.018040916,
-0.035253901,
0.0047925208,
-0.012715946,
0.0187743269,
0.0127831046,
0.0356088765,
0.0736688077,
-0.0275848806,
0.0026832656,
0.0187982526,
-0.0122344494,
-0.0736072287,
-0.0097697852,
-0.0261595603,
-0.0229798723,
0.0791325644,
-0.0019514428,
0.0061130039,
-0.0152970348,
0.0476530902,
-0.008228668,
-0.0012037585,
-0.0024449814,
0.023036968,
-0.0630781874,
0.0165261533,
-0.0186057054,
-0.0236916505,
-0.0036745863,
0.0349364318,
-0.0423208475,
-0.0508405529,
0.0460228585,
-0.0408631638,
0.0205815081,
0.0699612945,
-0.0209230538,
-0.0268634129,
0.0785757899,
-0.0178621542,
0.0276178271,
0.0183068663,
0.0336987153,
-0.0243587289,
-0.005656234,
-0.018385658,
-0.0612843335,
0.0197185446,
-0.0303310342,
0.0119088134,
-0.0445155948,
-0.0342250355,
0.0212284643,
0.0414560661,
0.0756593347,
-0.0043747425,
0.0085688671,
-0.0077119092,
0.0393279754,
-0.0098510887,
0.0765479207,
-0.0377687104,
-0.0032987122,
-0.0226021614,
0.0562630929,
0.0041656066,
-0.0034349407,
-0.0095228124,
-0.0486335792,
0.0214428157,
0.0305237751,
-0.0037581255,
0.0535784103,
-0.0348470658,
0.0153284268,
0.0070172627,
0.0579510033,
0.0445650108,
-0.0069694496,
0.0114977071,
0.0253752489,
-0.0004977173,
0.0051530818,
-0.0104017304,
0.0319879688,
-0.0403756052,
0.0502639152,
-0.0411434621,
-0.0280031208,
0.0527551174,
-0.0532338992,
0.0144270835,
0.0307849441,
0.0188152567,
-0.0167179573,
0.0535779372,
0.0082629211,
0.0325222723,
0.0193889458,
0.0073505607,
-0.0391674079,
0.0345644504,
0.0140690515,
-0.0390307084,
0.0335655361,
-0.0114481458,
-0.0047693965,
0.0031551772,
-0.0198997576,
-0.0110371402,
-0.0478172898,
-0.064075835,
-0.0345262066,
-0.0083263973,
-0.0420510471,
0.0750558898,
-0.0110709323,
0.0374001078,
-0.0087797185,
-0.0009859443,
-0.0380356461,
-0.0099883853,
-0.0227857176,
0.0437436551,
-0.0458181351,
0.0157247484,
-0.0011110476,
-0.0294340458,
-6.184735692e-33,
-0.0270799585,
0.0454545021,
-0.0198935773,
0.0121692,
-0.0575943105,
0.0545628294,
0.0122430297,
0.0169586055,
0.0204538032,
-0.0169783402,
-0.0202181321,
-0.0185297988,
0.0369881988,
-0.0467200987,
-0.020754993,
-0.019515004,
0.0813199431,
-0.0485690646,
0.0278810803,
-0.0554997921,
0.060485553,
0.0400906391,
0.016942909,
-0.0271126404,
-0.0358511209,
0.0567701757,
-0.0097016403,
-0.0121466629,
0.0322507098,
0.0278123058,
0.0166210495,
-0.000923869,
-0.0294813197,
-0.0307540782,
0.0036786315,
0.0436023735,
-0.0767456964,
0.000370535,
-0.0220199935,
0.0611095764,
0.0789389461,
-0.0360598676,
0.0256891791,
-0.0032571345,
-0.0657336935,
-0.0264554713,
0.0183184501,
-0.034050446,
0.0039884341,
-0.0587556884,
-0.0095384642,
0.0301601607,
0.0003723731,
-0.004961797,
0.0923743397,
0.0493604355,
0.023196809,
-0.0223826412,
-0.0778197944,
-0.0100465547,
0.025734514,
0.0620620511,
0.0261219013,
0.0461408757,
0.0151066976,
0.0372648202,
0.0154425967,
-0.0549756736,
0.0328815468,
0.0118348533,
0.0241580904,
0.0191715416,
0.0029851403,
0.005939126,
0.061392948,
-0.0412035137,
0.0035451401,
0.0193466991,
0.0196359586,
0.0259294119,
-0.002823503,
0.0616512559,
-0.0761196762,
0.0300486404,
-0.005428141,
0.0062388675,
-0.0065365708,
-0.042121131,
0.0207399409,
0.011975091,
0.0364088342,
0.0332982838,
0.0689272732,
-0.0151033467,
0.0732538775,
-0.0478730649,
0.0058931829,
0.0203786362,
0.0104913507,
0.017242562,
-0.028833339,
-0.0291929767,
0.0614709072,
0.0066797398,
0.0363118686,
-0.0660108402,
0.0049697314,
0.1013402641,
-0.0444659144,
-0.0158020929,
0.0137989037,
-0.0130787808,
0.0446418673,
-0.0327187032,
0.0597795397,
0.000527248,
0.0053436621,
0.0353455655,
-0.0289543178,
-0.0016283478,
-0.0075984909,
0.0216664057,
0.0251894966,
0.0290120766,
-0.0436030664,
0.0212534033,
0.0293341745,
-0.000457076,
-0.0170022622,
-0.0202612597,
-0.0373390615,
-0.0110563869,
2.93e-7,
-0.0476215035,
-0.018029632,
0.0660102069,
0.026021257,
-0.0103889341,
0.0027432709,
0.0078075989,
0.0211316366,
0.0297335591,
0.0270821806,
0.0090883411,
-0.0463120118,
0.0697931349,
-0.0143019306,
-0.0679329112,
-0.0340703353,
-0.0661471486,
0.0298601836,
0.0144873699,
0.0308345798,
0.0130822249,
0.0491294004,
0.0212019794,
-0.0095713474,
0.0174441654,
-0.0198595393,
0.0112605859,
0.040228691,
-0.0142887542,
-0.0212006439,
0.0487296209,
-0.0513485558,
-0.0689388514,
0.0196953528,
-0.0235714242,
0.0167338252,
0.0187634453,
-0.0154688936,
-0.0780669898,
-0.0546272732,
-0.0197829977,
0.0705522224,
-0.0273019858,
-0.0440376326,
0.0446199775,
0.044359684,
-0.0084744645,
-0.0533311702,
-0.0741525218,
0.0214598905,
-0.0487774387,
0.0261836145,
0.0247077774,
-0.0002235175,
0.0051318714,
-0.016247103,
-0.0230049342,
-0.0428374261,
-0.0416826345,
0.0339946263,
-0.0103488648,
-0.0149616115,
-0.0231059827,
-0.0347957276,
0.0368371569,
-0.006419376,
-0.026277313,
2.544726471e-34,
-0.0067164726,
-0.0001032729,
0.0071998173,
-0.0016889829,
-0.0048040845,
-0.0290560685,
0.0246200264,
0.0517024025,
0.0128122773,
-0.0368583389,
-0.060709551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12331v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12331v2 | Time out of Mind: Generating Rate of Speech conditioned on emotion and speaker | 2023-01-29T02:58:01 | 2023-01-31T05:30:55 | Navjot Kaur, Paige Tuttosi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Voice synthesis has seen significant improvements in the past decade
resulting in highly intelligible voices. Further investigations have resulted
in models that can produce variable speech, including conditional emotional
expression. The problem lies, however, in a focus on phrase-level modifications
and prosodic vocal features. Using the CREMA-D dataset we have trained a GAN
conditioned on emotion to generate worth lengths for a given input text. These
word lengths are relative to neutral speech and can be provided, through speech
synthesis markup language (SSML) to a text-to-speech (TTS) system to generate
more expressive speech. Additionally, a generative model is also trained using
implicit maximum likelihood estimation (IMLE) and a comparative analysis with
GANs is included. We were able to achieve better performances on objective
measures for neutral speech, and better time alignment for happy speech when
compared to an out-of-box model. However, further investigation of subjective
evaluation is required. | [
-0.0170764141,
0.0887761638,
0.0101278415,
-0.0413854793,
-0.0087821605,
-0.0283505972,
0.0294933096,
-0.03075267,
-0.0410555042,
0.0181538612,
-0.0612900481,
-0.039942883,
-0.0178885553,
0.0354133472,
0.0457101874,
-0.0965309665,
0.0075515923,
0.0263043214,
0.0586958379,
-0.0351283401,
0.0263372846,
0.0310887117,
-0.03763289,
0.0364336073,
-0.0512623712,
-0.0137206819,
-0.0260127503,
-0.0006837094,
0.0559413135,
0.0007851939,
-0.0399292968,
0.0061799567,
0.0019428972,
-0.0072829826,
0.0000020139,
-0.0543526858,
-0.0102021564,
0.0192118231,
-0.0304580424,
0.0356122404,
0.0804781094,
0.0495195016,
-0.0399634875,
0.0495180301,
-0.0275584441,
-0.0590950027,
0.0364296883,
0.035071712,
0.0338723212,
0.0964798853,
-0.0400380343,
-0.0181650892,
-0.0016410167,
-0.0612847358,
0.0185837112,
-0.040794339,
-0.0312963873,
-0.027272597,
0.0157426633,
-0.0913888514,
-0.0281628799,
0.0394016244,
-0.0060738921,
-0.0216671713,
0.0415747277,
0.0154545549,
-0.0165682174,
-0.0196872465,
-0.0318328626,
0.031321615,
-0.0131391622,
0.0638999939,
0.0142319323,
-0.0121105639,
0.007659737,
-0.0454015583,
0.0250684004,
-0.0035505891,
0.0315086804,
-0.0001370251,
-0.0400299951,
0.0599697195,
-0.0190241933,
-0.0404471084,
0.0099844653,
-0.0059609995,
0.0141735151,
-0.0274236202,
0.0183621887,
-0.0218092632,
-0.0315013118,
-0.0149490908,
0.012178516,
0.0328824855,
0.025057625,
0.0172006935,
-0.0686247051,
0.0018313042,
-0.0333965197,
-0.0240298882,
-0.0320607461,
0.0040873098,
-0.0096056638,
-0.0459713079,
0.0106920386,
0.0268981718,
0.0025930738,
-0.0510765687,
-0.0453654341,
-0.0128560616,
0.0164024364,
0.0151441079,
-0.0291289948,
-0.0052384087,
-0.0429543257,
-0.0308238976,
-0.1136016995,
-0.0192791298,
-0.0233377125,
0.0111600095,
-0.0015088273,
0.0244212486,
-0.0429512337,
-0.0153178442,
-0.0144090531,
0.025245836,
-0.0289673842,
0.0510987975,
0.0251468234,
-0.0746529624,
0.0270949304,
0.0219419468,
0.0170688089,
0.0068183742,
0.0445643328,
0.0934237018,
-0.0210537929,
0.0102350367,
-0.0524815358,
-0.0220935103,
-0.0433803573,
-0.0592902936,
-0.0054062936,
-0.0560000725,
-0.0180800352,
-0.0382853076,
-0.0189292114,
-0.0387623236,
-0.0091332067,
-0.0453724787,
0.0622991323,
-0.0105555644,
0.0127617475,
0.0249752998,
0.0289547518,
-0.0226332694,
0.0395487733,
0.0185753424,
0.0647995099,
0.0036644253,
-0.0137122544,
-0.0407317504,
0.037035998,
0.0483967811,
-0.0052542384,
0.0018445546,
-0.0521073826,
-0.0266515035,
0.0001660387,
0.0536899269,
0.0758104622,
0.0335189886,
0.0045897723,
-0.0117341839,
0.0712583512,
0.0197946113,
0.066451326,
0.0243437998,
0.0156815238,
0.0624122545,
0.0091614453,
-0.0136499861,
0.0023100202,
0.0589478649,
-0.0244237371,
0.0219403859,
0.0330886394,
0.0823710486,
-0.0183592904,
-0.0521725565,
-0.0013172921,
-0.0164311137,
-0.0451610424,
0.0070931977,
0.0106954351,
0.0185449794,
-0.0404730886,
-0.0312497932,
0.0116832387,
-0.0780488253,
0.0209941454,
0.0225903671,
0.0111376466,
0.0456129946,
-0.0032475591,
0.0330183655,
-0.002639597,
-0.0414526835,
-0.078970924,
0.0552561283,
-0.0129669448,
-0.0084615881,
0.0627770945,
-0.0757513717,
0.0195199605,
0.0093692522,
-0.0146987587,
0.0249041468,
-0.0246811267,
0.0447898619,
0.0124214655,
0.0030360401,
0.0483082682,
-0.00358617,
-0.0219879542,
-0.041086223,
0.0110251708,
-0.0064544464,
0.0398006886,
0.0079814261,
-0.052219145,
0.0117096528,
-0.011749872,
0.017478561,
-0.0298146475,
0.0520562343,
-0.0272087269,
-0.0512653068,
0.007494445,
-0.0608684383,
0.0001536525,
-0.0075500486,
-0.0071870163,
-0.0620411895,
0.0672907531,
-0.0325269848,
0.0255583245,
-0.0250550881,
0.0307561103,
0.0073271142,
0.0204216596,
0.0207622647,
-0.016014019,
0.0002000995,
-0.0295357946,
0.051303748,
0.0361865833,
0.004912402,
-0.0790467709,
0.0021655192,
0.0161801428,
0.0031968821,
0.0083872434,
-0.0337804221,
-0.0223884489,
-0.0442612171,
-0.044887837,
-0.0627425238,
0.0003943271,
0.0596930124,
-0.0078406837,
0.0056407154,
0.0126261879,
-0.0269939732,
0.011825419,
-0.0818049014,
-0.0121473018,
0.0296326969,
-0.0621954091,
-0.019939892,
-0.0216287449,
-0.0021514182,
-0.049932722,
0.0232339613,
-0.0041839811,
0.0001835294,
0.0015010403,
-0.0084880181,
0.0079245567,
0.0381424204,
-0.0196344443,
0.029533742,
0.0127997566,
-0.0737794414,
-0.0094587458,
0.0383824222,
0.1081761047,
0.0291708242,
0.0361990407,
-0.0084264502,
0.0045067389,
-0.0045301719,
-0.0245924257,
0.0262770727,
-0.0080597261,
0.0302331019,
-0.0290941224,
-0.0297482815,
0.0070855729,
0.0346947834,
0.0715644062,
0.032873325,
-0.0573208332,
0.0384670198,
0.0069949985,
-0.0664711669,
0.0426014885,
0.0344004631,
-0.0218568239,
-0.0051713255,
-0.0048856298,
-0.0670286715,
0.0219492521,
-0.0404944345,
-0.0784585848,
-0.0283183195,
-0.0087011764,
-0.0025971916,
0.0123969065,
-0.035932418,
0.0079047978,
0.0411289111,
0.0071244701,
-0.0499415807,
0.0074316384,
-0.0127969952,
-0.046503894,
0.0113153476,
0.0203553773,
-0.0424120687,
0.014749649,
0.0207249559,
-0.016377598,
-0.0254587326,
0.0265079308,
0.000330159,
0.0508454442,
-0.0311697833,
0.0344605595,
-0.0148622217,
0.0025095097,
-0.0015471946,
-0.0303125195,
-0.0084335245,
0.0064582308,
0.0373099931,
0.0667831227,
-0.0109172696,
-0.0229752138,
-0.000366919,
0.0162046589,
-0.0233409032,
0.0173836816,
0.0557726361,
-0.0320780315,
0.0113818469,
-0.0328938738,
0.0534723736,
0.0342365131,
0.0282981861,
0.0373747535,
0.0183132645,
0.0434645899,
0.0741531327,
-0.0268163458,
-0.0083432775,
0.0149994623,
0.0088363811,
0.0197385717,
0.0201234221,
0.0116760153,
-0.0166877899,
-0.0076014907,
0.0346703827,
0.0643805638,
-0.0358376391,
0.0455222502,
-0.0267118327,
-0.0980328768,
0.0633295104,
0.0344307721,
0.0235518217,
0.0311724283,
0.0174623057,
-0.0158969946,
-0.0028944022,
0.0116050532,
0.0194720291,
0.0054626111,
0.0013771426,
0.0762146339,
-0.0468361899,
-0.0686833262,
0.0031391736,
-0.020215638,
0.1277280003,
0.0373794027,
0.0558770783,
-0.0064904834,
-0.0703765005,
-0.0081258202,
0.0570545197,
0.0036543682,
0.0111252209,
0.0520590357,
0.020281896,
-0.0199482031,
-0.0215169583,
0.0819559395,
0.0355741568,
0.066500701,
0.0413352773,
0.0330655389,
-0.0057697599,
-0.0017706074,
-0.0390073732,
0.0463116989,
0.0158840623,
0.0281467736,
0.0142286839,
-0.0695217997,
-0.0046951952,
0.0362464003,
0.0394917503,
-0.0557497852,
-0.0647157207,
0.0118847108,
-0.0094431136,
-0.0621877983,
-0.0588319525,
-0.0381137766,
-0.0046833209,
0.079637818,
0.0106734568,
-0.0480689742,
-0.0204895586,
0.0217747297,
-0.032256294,
-0.0022485696,
0.052098684,
0.0249008238,
-0.0097401533,
-0.0476535223,
-0.0011455039,
-0.0384052135,
-0.0178437624,
0.0286907814,
-0.0118773924,
-0.0587133728,
0.0282610264,
0.0144912461,
0.0207682084,
0.0309874993,
0.0159301385,
0.0023517935,
0.0378961153,
0.0047439113,
0.0027334769,
0.0337752514,
0.0672961175,
0.0844368413,
-0.0043954579,
-0.0090092542,
-0.0110870432,
0.0683110729,
-0.0102939261,
-0.0012858189,
0.0379790515,
-0.0310826283,
-0.0239754338,
0.0296938438,
-0.0183691438,
-0.0178643931,
0.0293812137,
-0.0637249723,
-0.0062214467,
-0.0535961203,
0.0486776382,
-0.0675750226,
-0.0455117673,
0.0536932163,
0.0598117188,
0.0008235244,
-0.0342580825,
-0.0335619636,
-0.0254562013,
-0.032454174,
0.030946143,
-0.0042077401,
0.0201451164,
-0.0013587541,
0.0332394093,
-0.0030035533,
-0.0078643998,
-0.0195109323,
-0.0190338474,
0.007300437,
0.0078678187,
0.0085010454,
-0.0138138067,
0.0059018247,
0.0045392164,
0.0015248765,
0.0032025191,
-0.0365641676,
-0.0458317325,
0.0039520366,
-0.0008480374,
0.0693986714,
-0.0322869383,
0.0676515102,
-0.0221775435,
0.0043421718,
-0.0186653808,
-0.0316297635,
-0.0121108172,
-0.0392549932,
-0.0253718868,
-0.0387665071,
0.0397807583,
-0.0101125529,
0.0188503023,
-0.0609712005,
0.0178608932,
-0.0469668061,
-0.0346082561,
0.0039351927,
-0.0701532885,
0.0058119046,
-0.0084210206,
-0.0659120157,
-0.0225572791,
0.0055247834,
-0.0153115829,
0.0186255891,
-0.0617150739,
0.0429885983,
-0.0087955529,
-0.037983194,
0.0083916616,
0.0025231135,
-0.0210140515,
-0.0284252279,
0.0008064769,
-0.0116657745,
-6.276972325e-33,
-0.0216038488,
0.0383824557,
-0.0134967333,
-0.004976253,
-0.080890663,
0.010645655,
-0.0331861824,
0.0155147472,
0.0313134566,
-0.0014890641,
-0.0267777648,
0.0067112134,
0.0108851548,
0.0314243436,
-0.0042628078,
0.0285315737,
0.067147851,
-0.0155115733,
-0.0312626027,
0.0311899427,
0.0227492619,
0.0327198803,
0.0334757417,
-0.0434827879,
0.0095486129,
0.0363054909,
-0.0293372739,
-0.0416258089,
0.0555965267,
0.0043741949,
-0.0026043446,
0.0550459512,
-0.0237884969,
-0.0318702646,
-0.0370638072,
-0.017604189,
-0.0217346158,
-0.004132532,
0.0201399457,
0.0169514865,
-0.0387938209,
-0.0152838891,
0.019584002,
0.0104700504,
-0.0589950047,
-0.0338374525,
0.0285313036,
-0.0139644202,
0.0123710735,
-0.1116771027,
-0.0516628176,
0.0168654863,
-0.0162338261,
-0.039489571,
0.025078306,
0.0566662513,
-0.0217422023,
-0.037110582,
0.0236857869,
0.0084259296,
0.0107136648,
0.044738017,
0.0151196886,
0.0175464917,
0.0273092333,
0.0386352241,
0.0777876675,
-0.0467143618,
-0.0220316164,
0.0228000563,
0.0488452241,
0.0054479376,
0.0699260086,
0.0091181016,
0.0238567274,
-0.0406046845,
-0.0048711034,
0.0429152809,
0.0541395769,
-0.0040660705,
0.0212660078,
0.0574991815,
0.0030643458,
0.0117140748,
-0.0255050436,
-0.0731530637,
0.0014886307,
-0.0234642085,
0.0416533425,
-0.0002113319,
0.0209832098,
-0.0586808436,
0.0347306617,
0.0360524505,
0.0280571524,
0.0051662456,
-0.053314507,
0.0303001087,
0.0128464252,
-0.028950315,
-0.0146745062,
0.0251316503,
0.092790626,
0.0684685707,
0.0521140248,
-0.0157394428,
-0.0548857637,
0.0619346201,
-0.0449726693,
-0.0054076049,
-0.0372659564,
0.0615340807,
-0.0164850745,
-0.0153589016,
-0.0158189554,
-0.0270392541,
-0.0009677964,
-0.0218122359,
-0.0280266888,
0.0400610231,
0.014777652,
-0.0123396721,
0.0351914465,
0.0171381291,
-0.0615549572,
0.0263971761,
0.0250388961,
-0.0240727756,
0.0503086783,
-0.0371148922,
0.0018971588,
0.0061257766,
2.931e-7,
-0.0507226475,
-0.0185877867,
0.0709668174,
0.0128478482,
0.0389224477,
0.0224963631,
-0.0213539544,
0.0191621762,
0.00797942,
0.0501905121,
0.014014109,
-0.0443213955,
0.0844477043,
0.0048321374,
-0.0521097295,
0.0143696368,
-0.0313771293,
0.0377962887,
-0.0285828896,
0.0078195892,
0.0398724303,
0.025532078,
-0.0038937868,
-0.0256262161,
0.026071582,
0.0362961106,
0.0034908741,
-0.0250354726,
0.0043463861,
-0.0161987506,
0.0437453799,
-0.0176515747,
-0.0143613433,
-0.0311971419,
-0.0461525656,
0.0317443907,
-0.0035793856,
0.0552791134,
0.0076703564,
-0.0556097664,
0.0171608515,
0.0571996942,
-0.0616464987,
0.0438777991,
0.0252807867,
-0.0352682918,
-0.0371995941,
-0.010096251,
-0.0305204131,
0.0157754123,
0.016198134,
-0.009090513,
-0.0385442786,
0.0009501915,
0.0232527498,
-0.0010099347,
-0.0029259284,
-0.018109953,
-0.0282313824,
0.017413957,
-0.0711276382,
-0.0416420363,
-0.0442444757,
0.0514353886,
-0.0057106437,
-0.0229931045,
-0.0336691588,
2.012878874e-34,
0.0188117102,
-0.0120936679,
0.0087898532,
-0.0042907745,
0.0036066468,
-0.0152695449,
0.0271295216,
0.0206960235,
0.0282693319,
-0.0463708304,
-0.0495186597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12314v1 | Progressive Prompts: Continual Learning for Language Models | 2023-01-29T00:17:38 | 2023-01-29T00:17:38 | Anastasia Razdaibiedina, Yuning Mao, Rui Hou, Madian Khabsa, Mike Lewis, Amjad Almahairi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce Progressive Prompts - a simple and efficient approach for
continual learning in language models. Our method allows forward transfer and
resists catastrophic forgetting, without relying on data replay or a large
number of task-specific parameters. Progressive Prompts learns a new soft
prompt for each task and sequentially concatenates it with the previously
learned prompts, while keeping the base model frozen. Experiments on standard
continual learning benchmarks show that our approach outperforms
state-of-the-art methods, with an improvement >20% in average test accuracy
over the previous best-preforming method on T5 model. We also explore a more
challenging continual learning setup with longer sequences of tasks and show
that Progressive Prompts significantly outperforms prior methods. | [
0.0000063936,
0.0495963655,
-0.0223135296,
0.0122780558,
-0.0312540457,
0.0167693123,
0.0118274232,
-0.0584252663,
-0.0276057366,
-0.0101862401,
-0.0111928023,
-0.0428400598,
0.0012640278,
0.0470468104,
0.0153214522,
-0.0472583883,
0.0654637143,
-0.0669548288,
-0.0194154959,
-0.0251869429,
-0.0013159602,
-0.0175928194,
-0.0267920531,
0.0379808582,
-0.0048002694,
-0.0465117507,
-0.0352083445,
-0.043309845,
-0.0065607936,
-0.037565425,
0.0256673321,
0.0719395205,
0.0312717818,
0.0145343617,
0.0000021926,
-0.0419878922,
-0.0247984696,
-0.029227132,
-0.060293451,
-0.0061600409,
0.0390012302,
0.019462537,
-0.0252787415,
0.0285494886,
-0.0288801789,
-0.0187392924,
0.0728407204,
0.0037610154,
0.082879521,
0.03231325,
0.0052072331,
0.0159192402,
0.0303064696,
-0.0332489051,
0.0143520571,
-0.0375629067,
0.0327395312,
-0.0339639336,
-0.0032367706,
0.0019940385,
-0.0133200604,
0.0605017878,
0.0381868035,
-0.0205221102,
-0.0050273105,
0.0435045958,
0.0340213254,
-0.0294136666,
-0.0312140901,
0.0548953563,
-0.0271880869,
-0.0268112011,
0.0072747255,
0.0107378075,
-0.0228450876,
-0.0137835238,
-0.0779743865,
0.0190183185,
0.0331879482,
0.0126322471,
0.0182498302,
-0.0325519517,
0.008890965,
-0.0019547306,
-0.0322020836,
0.0028384298,
0.0361407995,
-0.0283649899,
0.0001378984,
0.0084780473,
0.0017416792,
-0.0193322916,
0.015812926,
0.0328992493,
-0.0573684759,
0.0232620034,
-0.0563099198,
-0.0036439239,
0.0252125729,
-0.0032525705,
0.0628610924,
0.0318820179,
-0.0509639159,
0.0520603843,
-0.0525250584,
0.0606541708,
0.048742529,
0.019803213,
-0.0171547104,
0.0189722963,
-0.0750215352,
0.0003272584,
-0.0341432728,
0.0399808101,
0.0382953584,
-0.0284971576,
-0.0002619079,
0.0479426347,
-0.004523268,
0.0232761186,
0.0035399417,
-0.0161116738,
-0.081381537,
0.0008868368,
0.0083954334,
0.0532889701,
-0.0109851612,
0.0293118469,
0.0182732157,
-0.0394664891,
-0.0468195863,
-0.0145062525,
-0.0016954177,
-0.0211707316,
-0.0025320214,
0.0257188641,
-0.0364460386,
-0.0262576528,
-0.0169667713,
0.0190687757,
0.0006685712,
-0.0473939441,
-0.0116994921,
-0.0445028581,
0.0272943787,
-0.0182833876,
0.001230594,
-0.0321859755,
0.0108540226,
0.0242772158,
-0.0155979097,
0.087959595,
0.0165998954,
0.0163447708,
0.0254909564,
0.0038902308,
-0.0111018205,
0.0597439148,
0.0043521416,
0.0122005837,
0.0134570347,
0.0116875963,
0.019868033,
0.049298957,
0.0362504832,
0.0422814377,
-0.0389681198,
-0.0239466541,
0.07876499,
-0.0017716083,
0.0162619893,
0.0345305279,
0.0063228398,
0.01806386,
0.0870101154,
0.0275382567,
-0.0159140676,
0.0148867927,
0.0375531539,
-0.0028894909,
0.000774053,
-0.0091433907,
-0.0815789625,
0.0215025414,
-0.0086030392,
0.0264020767,
-0.0056674583,
0.0143438419,
-0.0263038948,
-0.0089605218,
0.0236467812,
-0.0098144487,
0.0066589629,
0.034868326,
0.0483959876,
0.0223248042,
-0.055224251,
0.0609291419,
0.02509371,
-0.0419111326,
0.0014313976,
-0.0506543405,
0.06125357,
0.0769863203,
-0.0037755945,
-0.0135082835,
-0.0714454949,
-0.0285748411,
0.0371142142,
0.0127224121,
0.0452720784,
-0.0185112394,
0.035219647,
-0.0502445474,
-0.0240575224,
0.0298591591,
0.0195961874,
0.0311292578,
-0.0027240526,
0.0368096121,
0.0033223657,
0.0179934017,
-0.0208714604,
0.0370014571,
-0.0687757656,
-0.0074043032,
0.0092276195,
-0.0176010281,
-0.0223259702,
-0.0168379005,
-0.0060229786,
0.0084845051,
0.0465872549,
-0.0400720276,
0.022749003,
0.0158327147,
-0.1052842066,
-0.030187944,
0.0518231802,
0.0575589351,
0.0108788181,
0.0027288278,
-0.0196152814,
-0.0371490046,
-0.0060878927,
0.0044441572,
0.0183876678,
-0.0295995809,
0.052380994,
-0.0200841893,
0.0274843369,
-0.0395176411,
0.0215072446,
-0.0057900161,
0.0055119349,
0.0545881428,
0.0327276774,
-0.0326704346,
-0.0979609191,
-0.0294042788,
0.0383946896,
-0.015594732,
-0.0006218855,
-0.0117750587,
0.0254804175,
-0.0366662554,
-0.0223235209,
-0.0980981067,
0.0199985504,
-0.0148975048,
-0.0235598125,
0.0030066753,
0.0112134628,
-0.0221373513,
-0.0499297976,
-0.0236234684,
0.0003019319,
-0.0151680289,
0.0318010375,
-0.0097532542,
0.0100828726,
-0.0242506042,
-0.0495944731,
-0.0228142533,
0.0120232552,
0.0373714231,
-0.0427732281,
-0.0206182189,
-0.0529545285,
-0.001425431,
-0.0115637863,
0.0318502598,
0.0034867337,
-0.0096268542,
-0.012148831,
-0.0412803404,
0.051959835,
0.0581544191,
0.0156143075,
0.0094265277,
0.0512249209,
-0.0436081365,
-0.0643940568,
0.017033698,
-0.0436096787,
-0.0401916616,
0.0160042718,
-0.0058815442,
-0.0177211314,
0.0623366125,
0.0033743342,
-0.0021916421,
-0.041284427,
0.0170592237,
-0.0431451611,
-0.0087146424,
-0.0519705527,
0.0217827857,
-0.0455942601,
-0.0058336039,
-0.025505418,
-0.0544362105,
0.0618924275,
-0.0289661437,
-0.0106501887,
-0.0442251563,
-0.0217069145,
0.0206521433,
0.0717139766,
-0.0085868081,
-0.0056284713,
0.0422002114,
-0.039115075,
-0.0435257666,
0.0080721602,
0.0307137687,
-0.0352741368,
0.0508426577,
-0.0536176264,
0.0079162512,
-0.0070752418,
-0.0408936515,
-0.0757716149,
-0.0367410555,
-0.0116115026,
0.0262471698,
-0.0332846306,
-0.0004074592,
-0.0079232948,
-0.0108183948,
0.0285832994,
0.0675765872,
-0.0252588484,
0.0082084257,
-0.0309081562,
0.0011649106,
0.067306973,
0.0544870645,
-0.0172842648,
-0.0568710156,
0.051516477,
0.0170564894,
0.0717665553,
0.0301552452,
-0.0272169821,
0.0192561634,
0.0301643461,
-0.0127860978,
-0.0096882805,
0.0327871218,
0.021466773,
-0.0821610764,
-0.0408817306,
0.1057673246,
0.0103039769,
-0.0645915568,
-0.0003722049,
0.0027073775,
0.0448912382,
0.0153433876,
0.0356848463,
-0.0547016226,
-0.0284117125,
0.0599190444,
0.0310183987,
0.0257215146,
-0.0313261822,
-0.0280563775,
-0.0876652598,
0.0087223947,
0.0183849521,
-0.026534019,
0.0218981616,
-0.0516164452,
-0.0119355554,
0.0091145057,
0.0174818225,
0.0277732778,
-0.0114637455,
0.001081147,
0.0194381867,
0.0035723811,
-0.0397726893,
0.062536791,
-0.0212224126,
0.0767493919,
0.0805759281,
-0.0015327178,
0.0050442968,
-0.0465169214,
0.0750408545,
-0.0022385402,
-0.0280281901,
0.0040726392,
0.0249687862,
0.0194116086,
-0.0253849532,
0.0388920866,
0.0285615139,
-0.0082174353,
-0.0257302802,
0.0389485918,
0.0774773359,
0.0114276754,
-0.0196449906,
0.0234468877,
-0.0235303752,
0.0342737511,
0.0658173859,
0.0088644745,
-0.0600674525,
-0.0182090215,
-0.0217942018,
-0.0148791196,
-0.0348714031,
-0.0094048399,
0.0077243797,
-0.0397615656,
-0.0201492365,
-0.0651874915,
-0.0160636771,
0.016814243,
0.042102363,
0.0402473211,
0.0176994167,
-0.0028500834,
0.0181619637,
-0.0583127178,
0.0116527826,
-0.0206607096,
0.0287833549,
-0.0871350393,
-0.020829292,
0.042514421,
-0.0144275147,
-0.008300609,
-0.0058426154,
-0.0943169296,
-0.060418535,
0.0156897157,
0.0519183353,
0.014930537,
0.0634473339,
-0.0218952112,
-0.0317926928,
0.0403154492,
0.0036516364,
-0.0349376798,
0.0128393341,
0.0396133773,
-0.0357575789,
0.0177718494,
0.0406824499,
-0.0507588908,
-0.0091572134,
0.0091134878,
0.0468172543,
0.01583861,
-0.0151232025,
0.0251408163,
-0.0128201144,
0.0389691107,
0.0092400191,
-0.0308273491,
-0.0572675876,
0.0233410876,
0.0199263282,
-0.0045502116,
-0.0526118837,
0.0452127196,
0.0184763987,
0.0050352132,
0.0349195972,
-0.0254980642,
0.0356849208,
0.0303874128,
-0.0367732085,
-0.0055651972,
0.0027396982,
0.007293012,
0.0499532148,
0.0154739395,
-0.0508037098,
0.0092847878,
-0.0021088286,
0.032430362,
-0.0428773761,
0.0535169914,
0.0245220661,
-0.00131629,
-0.0282435678,
0.0234927796,
-0.0460899919,
-0.0921138972,
-0.0395690203,
0.0186949074,
0.0658418015,
0.0124917645,
0.0549669191,
-0.0238358099,
0.0018434984,
-0.0343591236,
0.0285236705,
-0.0046160039,
-0.0354957841,
0.0012265323,
0.0258488469,
0.0179291125,
0.0356715843,
0.0658410415,
-0.0402007736,
0.0270646065,
-0.0061887833,
0.0311328098,
-0.0410442688,
0.006841945,
0.0078615258,
0.0086875753,
-0.0179923847,
0.0151320901,
0.0261362717,
-0.0652029142,
0.0188032258,
-0.0078212284,
0.0005470228,
-0.0060325144,
0.0243125185,
0.045389533,
-0.0246171206,
0.0097805057,
-0.0509800985,
0.0272132885,
0.0713542029,
-0.0296089705,
-0.0253571998,
-6.558761097e-33,
-0.032329876,
0.0218446646,
0.0419895127,
-0.0134090213,
-0.0693842322,
-0.0145202661,
-0.0623145401,
0.0178727452,
0.0042385575,
0.0011215752,
-0.0260464214,
-0.0124319457,
0.0288673621,
0.0273495987,
0.0380045511,
-0.0223889127,
0.0626889542,
-0.0001397727,
-0.0153218675,
0.0472069681,
0.0411768742,
0.0594743341,
0.0291231312,
-0.0211432129,
0.0297405105,
0.0338491462,
-0.0178477541,
0.0179407988,
-0.0014721142,
0.0543681532,
-0.0242254734,
0.0048143766,
0.0027487986,
-0.0671140999,
-0.0724277422,
0.0149019938,
-0.0812087879,
-0.0356842652,
-0.0092304135,
0.0043010949,
-0.0342826098,
-0.0212915186,
0.007033105,
-0.037210308,
0.0108801629,
0.0022593699,
0.019116357,
-0.0416289605,
-0.0630244911,
0.0118955337,
-0.0588929355,
-0.01659742,
-0.0080993623,
-0.0370052159,
0.0351658724,
0.0043857032,
-0.0220540557,
-0.0329746269,
-0.062848255,
0.0101979207,
0.0074762534,
0.0676746219,
0.052568838,
0.04417523,
0.0183779188,
0.047472693,
0.0277280547,
-0.0249805488,
0.0113320462,
0.0053356434,
0.0782881826,
-0.0046152859,
0.0291261002,
-0.0484071374,
0.0287772454,
-0.0430179797,
0.0088366317,
-0.0194473825,
0.0873424634,
0.0315858275,
0.0507276356,
0.0011871931,
-0.0003864942,
-0.0494538248,
-0.0670001134,
0.0165623613,
-0.039168641,
-0.0170020815,
0.0708428398,
0.0306304637,
-0.0165951736,
-0.0486911833,
0.0706760138,
-0.0161332414,
-0.0314096883,
0.032175038,
-0.0248431265,
0.0106827393,
-0.0034894226,
0.0286870264,
-0.0442007631,
-0.0285524242,
-0.0166357998,
-0.0166505221,
0.0103363972,
0.0058242334,
0.0292807575,
0.0742869452,
-0.0547627434,
-0.0143281147,
-0.0287744962,
0.0274755079,
0.0511240959,
0.0484310053,
0.0301792119,
-0.0114270998,
-0.0088381264,
0.0561631396,
0.0157348271,
-0.0530855209,
-0.0436775722,
0.0201507378,
0.0159271341,
0.0338004827,
-0.0386901349,
-0.0142405853,
-0.0605795458,
0.0366145112,
0.0094541507,
-0.066285111,
0.0023514971,
0.00693308,
2.708e-7,
-0.0450374261,
0.0222505312,
-0.0126323681,
-0.0013555837,
0.0092433328,
0.0157578029,
-0.0493418239,
0.0255319234,
0.018668754,
0.0422623605,
-0.0267005842,
0.0172181036,
0.0507464893,
0.0113615934,
-0.1071934775,
-0.0134897754,
-0.0667600408,
0.0368793085,
-0.0652317628,
-0.0108812843,
0.0082547069,
0.0972291529,
0.0248993933,
0.0090300571,
0.0255896635,
-0.0389344655,
0.0412613638,
-0.0090149697,
0.0199028999,
0.0021391292,
-0.0064864238,
0.0083319517,
-0.0117195379,
0.0114818281,
-0.0349445976,
0.0019089876,
-0.0115641747,
0.0492782891,
0.0144786593,
-0.0438571237,
0.0101657594,
0.0069437711,
0.0038378441,
-0.0336403735,
0.0696065724,
-0.0587828755,
0.0237992555,
-0.0176439956,
0.028264083,
-0.0222820267,
0.0019519447,
-0.019482052,
-0.0362948105,
0.018732775,
0.0270519983,
0.0308332127,
-0.0249826014,
-0.0743366182,
-0.0116459699,
0.0180213284,
-0.0605403408,
-0.0430272669,
-0.0485793799,
-0.0242048204,
-0.0147321001,
-0.0604561716,
0.0391757227,
2.734042821e-34,
0.0277909823,
-0.0333530381,
0.0296808016,
0.0652798936,
-0.0119367624,
-0.0284945946,
0.0673492625,
0.0234996527,
0.0216450579,
-0.0694773495,
-0.0577763729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12307v2 | MQAG: Multiple-choice Question Answering and Generation for Assessing Information Consistency in Summarization | 2023-01-28T23:08:25 | 2023-09-07T18:20:40 | Potsawee Manakul, Adian Liusie, Mark J. F. Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art summarization systems can generate highly fluent summaries.
These summaries, however, may contain factual inconsistencies and/or
information not present in the source. Hence, an important component of
assessing the quality of summaries is to determine whether there is information
consistency between the source and the summary. Existing approaches are
typically based on lexical matching or representation-based methods. In this
work, we introduce an alternative scheme based on standard
information-theoretic measures in which the information present in the source
and summary is directly compared. We propose a Multiple-choice Question
Answering and Generation framework, MQAG, which approximates the information
consistency by computing the expected statistical distance between summary and
source answer distributions over automatically generated multiple-choice
questions. This approach exploits multiple-choice answer probabilities, as
predicted answer distributions can be compared. We conduct experiments on four
summary evaluation datasets: QAG-CNNDM/XSum, XSum-Hallucination, Podcast
Assessment, and SummEval. Experiments show that MQAG, using models trained on
SQuAD or RACE, outperforms existing evaluation methods on the majority of
tasks. | [
0.0188732184,
0.0210823864,
0.0201309472,
-0.0044806278,
-0.037167456,
0.0101855509,
-0.0213236753,
-0.0126528461,
-0.046008043,
-0.0259522889,
0.0165406018,
-0.0388927758,
0.0264148228,
-0.0412701555,
0.015809305,
-0.044210609,
0.0396743193,
-0.0070065144,
-0.0264014173,
-0.02109419,
0.0201285239,
0.0030644371,
-0.0313599259,
0.025279304,
0.0002432728,
0.0134909349,
-0.0119813746,
-0.0172605366,
0.0507906787,
-0.0133994604,
-0.0098564876,
0.0420292392,
-0.0033704471,
-0.0036524541,
0.0000017294,
-0.0656721368,
-0.0285211578,
-0.0183636211,
0.0165662561,
0.0075884718,
-0.0037547762,
0.0181022212,
0.0349667817,
0.0174743086,
-0.0045665693,
0.0120342039,
0.0399384648,
0.0159383267,
0.1046164632,
0.031630706,
0.0120865637,
-0.0143460017,
0.0054670204,
0.0099536497,
0.0142374691,
-0.0134936841,
-0.0198278781,
0.0771437213,
0.0050258185,
-0.0315257013,
0.0015192175,
0.0426314436,
-0.0008666922,
0.0294330642,
0.0106858211,
0.0142117916,
-0.0411255024,
0.0146204084,
0.0090486286,
0.086816214,
0.0333003253,
-0.0018870111,
-0.0185865108,
0.0144120427,
0.0118060503,
0.0129630314,
-0.0536555722,
0.0369585678,
-0.0305859521,
0.0001629545,
-0.0382819287,
0.0190476533,
-0.0264462121,
0.0164009091,
0.0036344891,
0.0318250395,
0.0304727796,
-0.0133509506,
-0.0363807157,
0.019736439,
-0.0446712486,
-0.0758485794,
0.0093497764,
0.048480846,
-0.0477533601,
-0.0030811969,
-0.059402056,
-0.0590198673,
0.0248546265,
-0.0400872007,
0.00646627,
0.0318333246,
-0.0045488193,
0.0382389687,
-0.0093581406,
0.0902106911,
0.0446041673,
0.0277991388,
-0.0972620249,
-0.0189851075,
-0.0448698327,
0.0086911721,
-0.0354775861,
0.0718399584,
-0.0093366085,
-0.0249636434,
-0.0689855441,
0.0051644794,
-0.0174419507,
0.0224667024,
-0.0200024005,
0.0315808728,
0.0022144718,
0.0372317918,
-0.0450873971,
0.0173043776,
-0.0583284236,
-0.0024775341,
0.0480318144,
0.0008807601,
-0.0030460979,
0.0143270548,
0.0208924767,
0.0187571254,
0.0161362309,
0.0457777679,
-0.0433610007,
-0.0136179617,
0.0163892042,
-0.0451091193,
-0.0409344472,
-0.0576050691,
-0.0140405837,
-0.0816645324,
0.0386132933,
0.0094765918,
-0.0376892276,
0.0040154723,
0.0077829552,
0.0357286148,
0.0065768161,
0.0442747101,
0.0085032927,
0.0361696817,
0.0440911949,
0.0091324039,
0.0087272255,
0.0073491931,
0.0428899527,
0.0030547539,
0.0605964549,
0.0106623694,
0.0080222422,
0.0098344162,
-0.0058695553,
-0.0102255465,
0.0012551851,
0.0379809216,
-0.0009777487,
0.0304792672,
0.0041176407,
0.0786358044,
-0.0225908924,
-0.0189172383,
0.0612519644,
0.0625208318,
0.0057814349,
-0.0497531071,
0.0318317935,
0.0273961034,
0.0390845127,
0.0717763454,
-0.0046438812,
0.0354380459,
-0.0177740399,
0.0531915128,
0.1026541069,
0.0362674482,
-0.0228657406,
-0.0483364463,
-0.0238293875,
0.0063535441,
0.0055675609,
0.0384999476,
-0.0169849321,
0.0017987397,
-0.0294062104,
0.0566273741,
-0.0051551512,
-0.0691926032,
0.018176645,
-0.0321369022,
0.0620485097,
0.0400576219,
0.0402469002,
0.0001451554,
-0.0409316048,
0.0014147918,
0.0023115419,
0.0270735025,
0.0528733507,
-0.0380872674,
0.01539216,
-0.0403244309,
-0.0068134251,
0.002805297,
-0.0067250514,
0.0135089718,
-0.0034600121,
0.0020434877,
0.0228437204,
-0.0381509215,
-0.0500602052,
0.028738685,
0.0326043963,
-0.0341418535,
0.0077413307,
-0.0219318662,
0.0223698542,
0.046627488,
-0.0417378582,
0.0235473122,
0.0082910256,
-0.0079847369,
-0.0118740136,
0.0002163732,
-0.0507788397,
-0.0468926728,
0.0474388227,
-0.0544245318,
0.0144866677,
0.0286006592,
-0.0195037741,
-0.0662003979,
0.0032915836,
-0.0820260942,
-0.0216159113,
-0.0638940036,
0.0262592454,
0.0246310402,
-0.0127300825,
-0.0520395152,
0.0660772398,
0.0209109541,
0.0386238918,
0.0448298007,
0.0019328245,
0.0357810967,
-0.0581367463,
-0.008366162,
0.0256133694,
-0.0101678325,
0.0432183407,
0.0581631102,
-0.002069222,
-0.0389008597,
-0.0186141822,
-0.1024402827,
0.0264034793,
-0.024059983,
0.0042757369,
0.0571341924,
0.0054839081,
-0.0132174771,
-0.0073323022,
-0.0725555047,
-0.0339876786,
0.0583562329,
0.0176439602,
0.006979146,
0.0183381215,
0.0470791608,
-0.0402002372,
-0.019504616,
-0.0060666781,
0.0415393859,
0.0220023505,
0.0107749505,
-0.0506053232,
-0.0270254333,
-0.0877873451,
-0.0198265538,
0.0309913363,
0.0122668222,
0.0272286125,
0.0261363126,
0.0491828285,
0.0086492747,
0.0622134171,
-0.0314239152,
0.0766550153,
-0.0173774399,
-0.0444722325,
-0.0039076027,
-0.0348486491,
0.0024260131,
0.0148380827,
-0.0349425897,
0.0051754946,
0.0154331923,
0.0754640773,
-0.0023172994,
-0.0238001179,
0.0178118199,
-0.0261896551,
-0.0066739442,
-0.0810960382,
-0.0302560646,
-0.0135781579,
0.0407941192,
-0.0196830314,
-0.0059339716,
0.0861353427,
-0.0702251345,
0.0373002291,
-0.0797589272,
-0.0219110474,
-0.0223290361,
0.0247661527,
0.0111833755,
0.0525500961,
0.0088485721,
0.0014431807,
-0.0816909373,
-0.0326412357,
0.0536315143,
-0.0699266344,
0.0667413473,
-0.0376132876,
-0.0056076641,
0.0000570453,
-0.0032910907,
-0.0447322913,
-0.0303126313,
0.0178819578,
0.0251203347,
0.0147780441,
-0.0070800311,
-0.030253524,
0.0254928004,
0.0655072927,
0.023313079,
-0.0395314656,
-0.0111848256,
-0.010748066,
0.1001132205,
0.0790215507,
0.0456675738,
0.0441353433,
-0.0444469154,
0.0169826616,
0.0375663601,
0.0424591266,
0.0253645796,
0.0358086191,
-0.0177961905,
-0.0121815884,
-0.0641843304,
0.031529706,
0.0212552007,
0.0937673375,
-0.0244209282,
0.0051579974,
0.0901530087,
0.0331398994,
-0.0078192651,
-0.0093912436,
0.0295788441,
0.01550077,
0.0093636503,
0.0265038274,
-0.0684260949,
-0.0139124133,
-0.0179842506,
0.0582754686,
0.0003767447,
-0.0269093458,
-0.0197535548,
-0.062617369,
-0.0012345604,
0.0035571782,
-0.1031931788,
-0.0349106528,
-0.0277073886,
0.0263720583,
0.0140145849,
0.0171389449,
0.0147255613,
0.0028921249,
0.0211274289,
0.0233884044,
-0.054868795,
0.0181163196,
0.0041751671,
-0.0457865223,
0.0125260968,
0.0686321184,
0.0327264741,
0.0073365364,
-0.0054798066,
-0.0046424335,
-0.0795881748,
-0.016415799,
0.0446886085,
0.0562714599,
-0.013366282,
0.0091366637,
-0.0303697251,
0.017985465,
0.0529206842,
-0.0122415628,
0.0320064202,
-0.0046214517,
-0.0031839095,
-0.012618646,
-0.0456363149,
0.0614131726,
-0.0011546329,
0.1013447717,
0.0460926034,
-0.0220398214,
-0.0000409413,
-0.022594681,
0.0290378872,
-0.0916910097,
-0.0040204572,
-0.0007585006,
0.0071865614,
0.0067065419,
-0.0940925702,
-0.0550559312,
0.0100259716,
-0.0175733306,
-0.0229628216,
-0.0018962733,
-0.0139268953,
0.0214763861,
-0.0473163016,
-0.0086261025,
0.0068532722,
0.0112582846,
-0.0006442079,
-0.0114804776,
0.019720545,
-0.0430438779,
-0.027113013,
0.0455329902,
-0.0945170224,
-0.0442400463,
-0.0315869972,
0.0276507549,
0.0154036144,
0.032577727,
-0.0072895531,
0.0247323792,
0.069385916,
0.0021037061,
0.0065540685,
0.0608737916,
-0.0358735546,
0.0207438078,
-0.0282120369,
-0.0163518693,
-0.0695530996,
0.0243162848,
-0.0315322019,
0.0657687411,
-0.0140143083,
-0.0760398284,
0.0417401642,
0.0467968881,
-0.0094700046,
-0.0220820569,
0.0036104356,
-0.0044769389,
-0.0285300836,
-0.0066172867,
-0.0219098181,
-0.0152951619,
0.0051307385,
0.0013236417,
-0.0163902231,
0.0058908481,
0.0259889103,
-0.0186093766,
0.0364478566,
-0.020134097,
-0.0373116657,
-0.0102156214,
-0.0440484509,
-0.0241042934,
-0.0098674092,
-0.0600200295,
-0.0249430109,
-0.0231349673,
0.0258564763,
0.0207398925,
0.0315341875,
0.0211365707,
-0.0214443412,
0.0355615541,
0.0311907195,
-0.083804816,
-0.0087554911,
-0.0538137071,
0.0290562958,
0.0253193509,
0.0098682838,
0.0122427652,
0.0088982545,
0.0069583971,
-0.029705666,
0.0017116936,
0.0165004432,
0.0010511292,
0.0053730053,
0.026578445,
0.0234483723,
0.0033229818,
0.0662939623,
-0.0278356448,
0.0094572222,
-0.0121982042,
-0.0422160402,
-0.0411149599,
-0.0528158359,
-0.0764314085,
0.0579402931,
-0.0131400097,
-0.0332814902,
-0.0481354631,
-0.0257813595,
0.0355978943,
0.0408605486,
0.0318506546,
-0.0028156971,
0.0327210538,
0.0428429022,
-0.0157730319,
-0.0045735682,
-0.026196029,
-0.0229181256,
-0.0573346764,
0.0112991529,
0.0018560677,
-5.605231671e-33,
-0.0549688488,
-0.0380477831,
0.0051178164,
-0.0279736072,
-0.0394981354,
0.000781501,
-0.0463004708,
0.0136072943,
-0.0038239502,
-0.0109622823,
0.0209009796,
0.0041305996,
0.0027156132,
0.0268813707,
-0.0090059722,
-0.0292036235,
0.0165329352,
-0.0160344876,
-0.0645652786,
0.0287500154,
0.0459051356,
-0.0204989277,
0.0372800119,
-0.0298422761,
0.0300292447,
-0.0400942266,
-0.0202667397,
-0.0066726548,
0.0108229332,
0.0552042276,
-0.0080639478,
0.0413022563,
0.0119023137,
-0.0540413745,
-0.0301886369,
0.0203348026,
-0.0307359844,
-0.0314624943,
0.0261541475,
-0.0408443362,
-0.0518003814,
-0.0247379132,
0.0220324621,
-0.0280413255,
0.0004396632,
-0.0391719155,
0.0516326986,
-0.0253505968,
0.0115660233,
-0.0663826391,
0.001118151,
0.0030547662,
-0.0249418654,
-0.0276452899,
-0.0357003808,
0.0768396109,
0.0112711396,
-0.0188716035,
-0.0181524474,
0.0404188782,
0.0076390058,
0.023782691,
0.0535101183,
0.0239050929,
-0.0210062824,
0.0820532665,
0.0180111211,
-0.0718047023,
-0.0409879014,
-0.0123836854,
-0.0214192234,
-0.008438779,
0.0724743158,
0.0428612828,
0.0370218642,
0.05562336,
-0.0421247482,
0.0767567679,
-0.0194909144,
0.0087271128,
0.0064103608,
-0.0370807499,
-0.0253035631,
0.0021174508,
-0.0554494821,
0.0180410743,
-0.0193063896,
-0.0431229249,
0.0283820592,
-0.0348931476,
-0.0184480082,
0.0111545827,
0.0311978087,
-0.0106340945,
0.0292117912,
0.0143686803,
-0.0380202234,
0.0257255752,
0.0000626591,
0.0100287162,
-0.0158574935,
0.0625491813,
0.0419873409,
0.0299368352,
0.0014984714,
0.0111873774,
0.0267343987,
0.0051281969,
-0.0225614235,
0.0270969272,
0.0049024108,
-0.005302601,
-0.0450708382,
-0.0357970856,
0.0000665283,
0.024805136,
-0.0156413764,
0.0013390296,
-0.0295230597,
-0.012712013,
0.0031494619,
-0.0470011123,
0.010104876,
0.0216330811,
-0.0117393509,
0.0277378075,
-0.0292665511,
0.0189035516,
-0.0003861742,
-0.002597129,
0.0041551194,
0.0473612137,
2.476e-7,
0.030225588,
0.0092538819,
0.021551786,
0.0005535862,
-0.0257592034,
0.0000020908,
0.0036319313,
0.0225109681,
0.0308819301,
-0.0367859118,
0.0303037763,
0.0542570204,
0.0402368233,
0.076087594,
-0.0777505711,
-0.0428619534,
-0.097508125,
-0.0064706588,
-0.0319438316,
0.0140106399,
0.0814962089,
0.0407804735,
-0.0033865587,
-0.0036784685,
-0.0154981827,
-0.0258581992,
0.0279554632,
0.0095941015,
-0.0210325476,
0.0191038549,
0.0473133177,
-0.027268488,
-0.0032387401,
0.0277706385,
-0.0073453714,
-0.031476602,
0.0994636118,
-0.0088043874,
0.0325476117,
-0.0617532358,
-0.0440190509,
0.0085407691,
0.0224690326,
-0.0014271525,
0.0527695045,
-0.0414896235,
0.0161741655,
-0.0256655142,
-0.0695177987,
0.0012971741,
0.013763506,
-0.0044104597,
-0.0171500593,
0.0275293272,
-0.0088974331,
0.02597804,
0.0105213812,
-0.0333082415,
-0.0472553931,
0.0433927886,
-0.0117259733,
-0.0564036034,
-0.0212305579,
-0.0402256139,
-0.0076718964,
-0.1194426119,
-0.0186787993,
1.942302147e-34,
0.0317562185,
0.0108083719,
-0.0217541717,
-0.0355241261,
0.0066244486,
-0.0294996854,
-0.0053818654,
-0.0371583998,
0.0065053045,
-0.0751825124,
-0.0104088513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12303v1 | Presence of informal language, such as emoticons, hashtags, and slang, impact the performance of sentiment analysis models on social media text? | 2023-01-28T22:21:51 | 2023-01-28T22:21:51 | Aadil Gani Ganie | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study aimed to investigate the influence of the presence of informal
language, such as emoticons and slang, on the performance of sentiment analysis
models applied to social media text. A convolutional neural network (CNN) model
was developed and trained on three datasets: a sarcasm dataset, a sentiment
dataset, and an emoticon dataset. The model architecture was held constant for
all experiments and the model was trained on 80% of the data and tested on 20%.
The results revealed that the model achieved an accuracy of 96.47% on the
sarcasm dataset, with the lowest accuracy for class 1. On the sentiment
dataset, the model achieved an accuracy of 95.28%. The amalgamation of sarcasm
and sentiment datasets improved the accuracy of the model to 95.1%, and the
addition of emoticon dataset has a slight positive impact on the accuracy of
the model to 95.37%. The study suggests that the presence of informal language
has a restricted impact on the performance of sentiment analysis models applied
to social media text. However, the inclusion of emoticon data to the model can
enhance the accuracy slightly. | [
0.0953276902,
0.0395756327,
-0.0321647376,
0.0393676423,
-0.0237797424,
0.0242709201,
0.0069449153,
0.0395896249,
0.0297833681,
-0.0545410439,
-0.0066152597,
-0.0120849879,
-0.0300877187,
0.0591709428,
-0.0079042362,
-0.0256561954,
0.006345077,
0.0470870696,
0.0529733002,
-0.0369300023,
0.039995037,
0.0060258708,
0.0046776757,
0.0290915035,
-0.0516225994,
0.0130710863,
0.006527693,
0.056206882,
-0.0288658589,
-0.0042535956,
0.0587464832,
0.0455575585,
-0.0081778513,
0.0362883843,
0.0000018037,
-0.0178096779,
0.0453069396,
-0.0269148853,
-0.0003267422,
-0.0006059082,
0.1196000129,
-0.0128120799,
-0.0304565299,
0.0359004922,
-0.0400864705,
0.0018157706,
0.0613074303,
0.0045791017,
0.0482098795,
0.0353462473,
-0.0326346047,
-0.0098243617,
-0.0301062558,
-0.0035307207,
-0.0254762415,
0.0002072454,
0.0306721088,
-0.0117878634,
-0.0644597113,
0.0141708981,
-0.0217115954,
0.0415491164,
0.0032425094,
-0.0018090932,
-0.0065797851,
0.0086210687,
-0.0167392716,
-0.0453412086,
0.0007927835,
0.0257731006,
-0.0076871207,
-0.0116866715,
-0.027092956,
0.0033789959,
0.0003803917,
-0.0108674383,
-0.0407494381,
-0.028974304,
0.0256895944,
0.0157944653,
-0.0291925445,
0.0208771415,
0.006601695,
0.0804270953,
0.0253508184,
-0.0041701267,
-0.00994376,
-0.0245709606,
-0.0271162502,
0.0342342965,
-0.0006450018,
-0.0165541247,
0.0499987863,
-0.0201286431,
0.031348303,
0.0530455224,
-0.0137124937,
-0.058715146,
0.0372989401,
-0.1037149876,
-0.0365700163,
-0.0027265721,
0.0080684014,
0.0192601532,
-0.0281515121,
-0.014996618,
0.0161799695,
0.0654896051,
0.0163475443,
-0.0384762734,
-0.0619090013,
-0.0055668266,
-0.0253115185,
0.042362459,
0.0009288685,
-0.002052936,
-0.080810301,
0.0282388497,
0.0053422144,
-0.0427627042,
-0.0011255817,
0.0280163623,
-0.0039072214,
0.0350358486,
-0.0340018049,
-0.0100897262,
-0.0566095673,
0.0533973165,
-0.0286793634,
-0.0659897253,
0.056029465,
-0.0112396916,
0.0612709187,
-0.0217591487,
0.039782878,
0.0113356235,
0.0354340822,
-0.0664298758,
-0.0621729568,
0.0123353377,
-0.0432619266,
-0.0317644402,
-0.0142971566,
-0.0668913499,
0.021742072,
-0.0048901048,
-0.0193457305,
0.0209495425,
0.0054061762,
0.0239520408,
-0.0855462626,
0.0376743078,
-0.0783092901,
0.0075063603,
0.045259539,
-0.0076807127,
0.0138429189,
0.032167986,
0.0283013266,
0.0349510349,
0.0454424173,
-0.0166678894,
-0.0270882081,
0.0286603197,
-0.0024252874,
-0.0050128866,
-0.099503167,
0.0088553755,
-0.0885882154,
-0.0059995474,
-0.0170882586,
0.0679950118,
-0.0022579129,
0.0055303918,
0.0346000493,
0.0422334373,
-0.0100055141,
0.0557996817,
-0.0006410205,
0.0331048444,
0.0420777611,
-0.0283520669,
-0.0066020233,
-0.0039977096,
-0.0399071947,
-0.0353546441,
-0.014124617,
-0.010182919,
-0.0219754614,
-0.0652727708,
-0.0111482684,
-0.0363491811,
0.0879714042,
-0.0174727123,
0.0204169918,
0.0036630079,
-0.0272508897,
-0.0364513099,
0.024910666,
-0.0739664584,
-0.0464667715,
-0.0020166235,
-0.0080096209,
0.0819093287,
0.0210624747,
0.0444618389,
-0.0294386614,
-0.0291520637,
-0.0166718978,
0.0517058931,
-0.0248670336,
0.0306691006,
-0.0020591111,
-0.0456800312,
0.0068270057,
0.0204854552,
0.0054148277,
-0.0213448424,
0.0210672934,
0.0612103194,
-0.0187636353,
0.0193607006,
-0.0299027096,
0.0027450686,
0.0042174058,
0.0084135355,
0.0104621239,
0.0011237266,
0.0607862845,
0.0369564444,
-0.0130143417,
-0.0174226779,
-0.0096436385,
-0.0139855128,
-0.0629183352,
0.0228274371,
-0.0093902713,
-0.0460967235,
0.0283010919,
-0.0241692457,
-0.0129506402,
0.0368023477,
-0.0206662342,
-0.0255734138,
0.0675373375,
-0.0366956331,
0.0655118823,
-0.0527647808,
-0.060979981,
-0.086585708,
0.0350497663,
0.0187957324,
0.0207912736,
-0.0150621282,
0.0074021849,
-0.0215495564,
0.0219476409,
0.0117806001,
0.0584714524,
-0.0379864313,
0.0116903465,
-0.0035096714,
0.0214065313,
0.0159288757,
0.0011570497,
-0.0301454719,
-0.0337039977,
-0.1200554222,
-0.0029506742,
-0.0052762353,
-0.0109230205,
0.0180052426,
-0.0042592296,
-0.0262736846,
-0.0165004153,
-0.0032246599,
0.037939705,
-0.0271732714,
0.037890628,
0.0339282975,
-0.0101350332,
-0.0050121923,
-0.0404636264,
-0.0306662749,
-0.0055706785,
-0.0014653656,
0.0361121893,
-0.0443324111,
0.0826542899,
0.0519477539,
-0.0285595637,
0.0063796607,
0.0199024957,
-0.1242636666,
0.0031817476,
0.025235787,
-0.0184348673,
0.00901521,
0.0662543848,
0.0508264415,
-0.0342050493,
-0.0088141179,
-0.042242948,
0.0030008743,
-0.0025193908,
-0.0235505663,
-0.0362811908,
-0.0555619039,
-0.0347600803,
0.0347931534,
0.0160299502,
0.0079829004,
-0.0515105315,
0.0164430924,
-0.0197384693,
-0.0108301751,
0.0116510997,
-0.0370295085,
-0.0293027498,
0.0064433734,
0.0014342678,
-0.027960632,
0.0259355623,
0.0140238591,
-0.0461006202,
-0.0201290697,
-0.0354808718,
-0.0061311503,
0.0301425345,
-0.0182588659,
0.0336078517,
0.0007657041,
-0.0301874951,
-0.0009895945,
-0.0254746974,
-0.0028743702,
-0.0439214073,
0.0014989006,
0.0541371033,
-0.0047950731,
0.0387831368,
-0.0154814338,
-0.0139517207,
-0.0570348315,
-0.0520170033,
-0.0147693381,
0.0246004481,
-0.0115771452,
0.0462171771,
-0.0067561017,
-0.0443545692,
-0.044269409,
-0.0294351652,
-0.0108135007,
0.00249325,
-0.0272556562,
0.029962644,
-0.0177422725,
0.0253150184,
0.0314609297,
-0.0082923193,
0.043076016,
-0.0509108901,
-0.0150294499,
-0.028991878,
-0.0018848832,
-0.0028815982,
0.0195945967,
-0.0255879462,
-0.0181400124,
0.0279616639,
-0.0028574353,
0.0236656684,
0.1141778082,
0.0234458018,
-0.0231801122,
0.0070114266,
0.0287385806,
-0.0179042704,
0.0388219692,
-0.0030176362,
-0.0415434949,
-0.0294927061,
-0.0078293784,
0.0230536032,
-0.0445896648,
-0.0104867462,
0.0067359284,
-0.1045354828,
0.0107721444,
-0.0123626692,
-0.0001840642,
0.0408295691,
0.0258983057,
-0.0055695744,
-0.0180350635,
0.0223490689,
-0.0511430763,
-0.0014948207,
0.000174586,
0.0358581394,
-0.0442081653,
-0.0545620769,
0.0190045387,
-0.0058497582,
0.049423106,
0.0068750563,
0.0774316043,
-0.0718218014,
-0.0143576991,
0.0189985633,
-0.0149955479,
0.0258903671,
-0.0261786245,
0.0804103613,
-0.0165818706,
-0.024836041,
-0.0649441481,
-0.0169088524,
-0.0513115861,
0.0440389439,
-0.0365952142,
-0.0130251786,
0.0159121919,
-0.0309852194,
-0.050422065,
0.0019767883,
0.0029701751,
0.0367783718,
0.0324368849,
-0.0768603757,
-0.024413364,
-0.0063136793,
0.0000419855,
-0.0421395823,
-0.0156633444,
-0.032552395,
-0.0038304746,
-0.062530607,
-0.060078159,
-0.0489771813,
-0.0046271184,
0.0189237818,
-0.0219316557,
0.0338178277,
-0.0069656521,
-0.0296011791,
0.0014479446,
-0.0127490852,
0.0370360948,
0.0229825433,
0.0090279598,
0.000908286,
0.0110822506,
-0.0156672895,
-0.0071689324,
-0.0271654837,
-0.0515366904,
-0.0418017283,
0.0587737374,
0.0441603512,
0.0060266964,
-0.0137167107,
-0.0343717858,
-0.0902333632,
0.0103044556,
0.0489807315,
-0.0079843737,
0.0156457964,
0.0534448959,
0.0336349346,
0.0167827383,
0.0440379456,
-0.0029844018,
0.0493100956,
0.0111436518,
-0.0156893004,
-0.0669730678,
-0.0256888866,
-0.0056812484,
0.0242540408,
0.0311923381,
-0.0010799663,
-0.1021095663,
0.0040878262,
-0.018756371,
0.0100296997,
-0.0117320241,
-0.0483372062,
-0.0207363963,
0.0041767466,
0.0067068054,
-0.0567348525,
-0.0467724241,
-0.0282196756,
0.0102748908,
0.0204133186,
0.0616290048,
0.0271336101,
0.0611880943,
0.0130724274,
0.0513290949,
-0.0367279835,
0.0042246962,
0.0361437723,
-0.0243927557,
0.0104629379,
-0.0189659111,
-0.004211429,
-0.0103694694,
0.0032789074,
0.0335711911,
0.0158006437,
0.0158541463,
-0.0010258452,
0.0490604863,
0.022257641,
-0.0276897643,
0.0409428142,
-0.0435531363,
0.038706027,
-0.0066088163,
-0.0039088456,
-0.0423163436,
-0.056579113,
0.047079742,
-0.0223504044,
-0.031042587,
-0.0214062855,
0.0300549734,
-0.0463903993,
0.0333936885,
0.0239503197,
-0.0158681422,
-0.0088583054,
0.0539624207,
0.0517416,
0.0338214412,
-0.0018038746,
0.0644411817,
-0.0249330923,
-0.0809703395,
0.0520404838,
-0.089707762,
0.0440377668,
0.0146476505,
0.0332070105,
0.0517441146,
0.0348980688,
0.0548354946,
-0.0393217728,
-0.0001741469,
-0.0214321204,
-0.0296177119,
-0.0071109319,
-6.0742451e-33,
0.0280198306,
-0.0630810857,
-0.0391620956,
0.0053485609,
0.0042884224,
0.016830489,
-0.0367650501,
0.0289244764,
-0.006926558,
0.0323642381,
-0.0020849381,
0.0206131674,
0.0108318217,
0.0119494675,
0.0689079016,
-0.0261778552,
0.0303095691,
-0.0202504452,
0.0275433492,
-0.0149854124,
0.0353307799,
0.0485474505,
0.0669653639,
-0.1135481894,
0.0456572399,
-0.0199240651,
-0.0369713865,
-0.0041884747,
0.0682681426,
0.0473889001,
0.0003334958,
0.0827244893,
0.0154859917,
0.041200757,
-0.0168036409,
0.02341922,
0.0020497106,
-0.0322208814,
0.0166859645,
0.0395624377,
-0.0159679167,
-0.0135704791,
0.0751460716,
-0.0022129999,
-0.0723281726,
0.028459562,
0.0360725485,
-0.0146713285,
0.0336868204,
-0.0194421448,
-0.0285105258,
0.0293982457,
-0.0013147556,
-0.0004787221,
0.0207980908,
0.028024679,
-0.0008307482,
0.0157185644,
-0.0430582203,
0.0176508203,
-0.0533919483,
-0.0489252619,
0.0011597993,
-0.0193386767,
0.0206980892,
0.0366982557,
-0.0007329342,
0.0483529642,
0.0088424161,
-0.017953584,
0.0624599196,
0.0225404948,
0.0518311001,
0.0837527961,
0.0619679019,
-0.0683928132,
-0.0225363821,
-0.0374203101,
0.0612179898,
0.0070263743,
0.0227693096,
-0.000637223,
-0.0817819014,
-0.0156588126,
0.0266571846,
0.0149354571,
-0.0165638775,
-0.0821965262,
-0.0219550412,
-0.0250227433,
-0.003546512,
0.0054454259,
0.0158220846,
-0.0773660913,
-0.0410362072,
-0.0169676673,
-0.0090848953,
0.0623080507,
0.0223056357,
0.0531768277,
-0.0202065893,
0.010289602,
-0.0046651964,
0.0184027907,
-0.0046056705,
0.0372926109,
0.0620469563,
0.0422376022,
-0.0436436497,
-0.0206579529,
0.0132496571,
-0.0140535757,
-0.0210993979,
0.0146573633,
-0.0299892686,
0.030914912,
-0.0207567923,
0.0042151567,
0.0233547464,
0.0422669239,
-0.0278511066,
-0.0295547731,
0.004397043,
-0.004277051,
-0.0338301919,
-0.0504302941,
0.0031179294,
-0.0551790372,
-0.0130420662,
-0.0515993685,
0.0004612878,
-0.0150825772,
2.563e-7,
0.0648677722,
0.0935487449,
-0.0165795926,
0.010988743,
0.0301786754,
0.0549602211,
0.0071857548,
-0.0042347144,
-0.0061658518,
0.0293663293,
0.0274633765,
-0.0048251525,
0.0086350366,
0.0461898036,
-0.0796903744,
0.0127121052,
-0.0805177391,
0.0271488726,
0.0049960008,
0.034852542,
0.0247810762,
0.0720599294,
0.0486768298,
-0.0392953493,
-0.0215543266,
-0.0464751683,
0.0271184128,
-0.0328057595,
0.0217323266,
0.0112887761,
-0.0029463356,
0.0319331028,
0.016308967,
0.0227207597,
-0.0147460708,
-0.0008439753,
0.0301804431,
0.0038743664,
-0.0413562804,
-0.0046379059,
0.0365441665,
-0.0265110843,
-0.0002003268,
-0.0428043306,
0.0404141098,
0.0160734337,
-0.0503175184,
-0.0295267664,
0.0109268567,
0.0240914132,
0.083878994,
-0.0202473439,
-0.0192238055,
-0.0078547662,
0.0174298976,
-0.0394728146,
-0.0104037579,
-0.0419945866,
0.0164833646,
-0.0121153072,
-0.0357710086,
-0.002343063,
-0.0072320453,
0.0259328429,
0.0444721468,
-0.0032678428,
0.0524359085,
1.75933714e-34,
0.0314080529,
-0.0086749224,
0.0341876671,
0.0295293871,
0.0034507548,
0.0446798354,
0.0247744247,
0.0130761601,
0.014338458,
-0.0048591373,
0.0071795983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.01292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.01292v1 | How learners produce data from text in classifying clickbait | 2023-01-28T20:23:39 | 2023-01-28T20:23:39 | Nicholas J. Horton, Jie Chao, Phebe Palmer, William Finzer | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Text provides a compelling example of unstructured data that can be used to
motivate and explore classification problems. Challenges arise regarding the
representation of features of text and student linkage between text
representations as character strings and identification of features that embed
connections with underlying phenomena. In order to observe how students reason
with text data in scenarios designed to elicit certain aspects of the domain,
we employed a task-based interview method using a structured protocol with six
pairs of undergraduate students. Our goal was to shed light on students'
understanding of text as data using a motivating task to classify headlines as
"clickbait" or "news". Three types of features (function, content, and form)
surfaced, the majority from the first scenario. Our analysis of the interviews
indicates that this sequence of activities engaged the participants in thinking
at both the human-perception level and the computer-extraction level and
conceptualizing connections between them. | [
0.072702691,
-0.0175997559,
-0.0487680398,
0.0015510143,
-0.0413342491,
0.035427656,
-0.0003810076,
0.0040113544,
0.0116839614,
-0.0653413609,
0.0243031159,
-0.0074609281,
0.0012142917,
0.0332070179,
-0.0108559337,
-0.0518955626,
-0.0026030636,
-0.0128081935,
0.0207547732,
0.0353801399,
0.051794555,
0.0378626361,
0.0075183972,
0.0169928893,
0.003057631,
-0.0358272605,
-0.0072686779,
-0.0117213959,
-0.021678837,
-0.0248209238,
0.0136107169,
0.0477674007,
0.0444620997,
0.0129566444,
0.0000019604,
-0.026347436,
-0.0191459954,
-0.0085226949,
-0.0451797061,
0.0226630419,
0.0611735173,
0.0413045399,
-0.0001947831,
-0.0048991875,
-0.0366649814,
0.0323277637,
0.0574316494,
0.0565359779,
0.0396591984,
0.0353898071,
-0.0102879656,
-0.0382627212,
-0.026898656,
0.0263048913,
0.0585103221,
0.0573011562,
0.0117842928,
-0.0040477845,
0.0441474244,
0.0529710874,
0.0263058953,
0.007060932,
-0.008112574,
-0.0185569301,
0.0010431298,
0.0236671064,
-0.0087205563,
-0.0374210402,
0.0462119691,
0.019521879,
-0.0010311822,
-0.025882123,
0.005376956,
0.0231114347,
0.0210329276,
0.0484787002,
-0.0612514392,
0.0314665399,
-0.0385930054,
0.0083024688,
-0.0267136209,
0.0060201515,
-0.0074535627,
0.0466906168,
0.0173750445,
-0.013437924,
-0.0435779952,
-0.0058952146,
0.0283467732,
0.0101342369,
0.0491031967,
-0.0326079205,
0.0147278905,
0.0254296381,
0.0326729827,
0.0209151916,
0.0043812017,
-0.0607518777,
0.0020869193,
-0.0604938008,
-0.0435544513,
-0.0123338439,
-0.0053849109,
0.0206206013,
-0.0002934475,
0.0007026775,
0.0077400245,
0.0242282823,
-0.0118976347,
0.0572339706,
-0.0742707253,
-0.0320527144,
-0.0118962526,
0.0675775856,
0.0158693213,
0.0017618188,
0.0368591473,
0.0105560757,
-0.0048560584,
0.0220144801,
-0.1046220809,
0.0327849463,
-0.0093521904,
0.0110889832,
-0.0287098251,
0.0064218859,
0.0075754328,
0.0259813927,
0.0023951838,
-0.0084439004,
-0.003692999,
0.0283005945,
0.0203276686,
-0.0325079076,
0.0157222375,
0.002776,
-0.0595353134,
-0.0042864755,
-0.0879968107,
-0.0815861598,
0.0035190717,
0.0026245001,
0.039226152,
-0.0352256447,
-0.0162816364,
0.0332583189,
-0.010783107,
-0.0129959183,
-0.0022458418,
0.0522338375,
-0.0329585187,
0.0728645697,
0.0042264685,
-0.0254156105,
0.0412720442,
0.0651291162,
0.055033315,
0.0405516997,
0.0031456451,
0.1278639883,
0.0330707766,
-0.0096177971,
0.0311561283,
-0.0152765792,
-0.0000039322,
-0.0121405348,
0.0004241015,
0.0090833372,
-0.0249009151,
0.0255163293,
-0.0018603076,
0.0069447937,
-0.0272795931,
0.0634687245,
0.07657554,
0.0727065876,
-0.0097122891,
0.0300237983,
0.0090004662,
0.016262209,
0.0049428213,
0.0409145877,
0.0168203972,
-0.003051053,
0.0145156393,
0.0150525812,
-0.0355000012,
0.0254236944,
-0.0001367832,
-0.0378905982,
-0.0324322954,
0.0103361048,
0.0257001072,
0.0331301019,
-0.0061995611,
0.0499822944,
-0.0320985392,
-0.028138455,
-0.0190581176,
-0.0517817289,
0.0395972393,
-0.0334909111,
0.0329666063,
0.0417778939,
0.0329224132,
0.0183438957,
0.0102983536,
-0.0429387316,
0.0387959741,
0.0370982476,
0.0054930011,
-0.0272157639,
-0.1008075327,
-0.0130590275,
-0.0168649498,
-0.0523378551,
-0.0023565029,
0.0032594497,
-0.0613732785,
0.0088641411,
0.033232417,
-0.0307985079,
-0.077361986,
0.0273723863,
0.027850464,
-0.0502944253,
-0.0544221774,
0.053720668,
-0.0140160564,
0.0324297771,
0.0099219745,
0.0121143032,
0.0064944951,
0.0171316415,
0.0098560005,
0.0223799795,
0.0446725041,
0.0249868892,
-0.0108859595,
-0.1032135263,
0.0004242985,
0.0341840014,
0.025463054,
0.0127033256,
0.0383914374,
-0.0654844418,
0.0011916929,
-0.0440843999,
-0.0413471125,
-0.0294840261,
0.0103649367,
-0.0274474565,
0.0596694127,
0.0588718653,
0.0206546541,
0.0251976792,
-0.0369813144,
0.0096417023,
-0.0006680439,
-0.0137919812,
0.0388945565,
-0.0005613103,
-0.007627625,
0.0149411913,
-0.0520619005,
-0.0547742881,
-0.0061952537,
-0.0472661704,
-0.0227705911,
-0.0282847006,
0.0482266434,
0.0430803783,
-0.0575621314,
-0.0108864428,
-0.0084088119,
-0.0319926627,
-0.0826035291,
-0.0250900295,
0.018123813,
0.0204494521,
0.0138120269,
0.0376949906,
0.0202317331,
0.0301767569,
-0.0383488126,
0.0724490955,
0.1070557833,
-0.0303389803,
-0.0145346122,
0.0225475896,
-0.0052035735,
-0.0483401604,
0.01176045,
-0.0051900116,
0.0018372444,
0.0121092461,
0.0182307605,
0.0560259372,
0.049994126,
0.081539847,
0.0126945125,
-0.0264537558,
-0.013268101,
-0.0233165585,
-0.0190325025,
0.0338880792,
-0.0065133157,
-0.0744162798,
0.042751994,
0.0033354741,
0.0184884723,
0.0149603579,
0.0191759281,
0.1024095416,
-0.01341944,
0.0560684465,
-0.0702612326,
-0.0748591423,
-0.0048054978,
0.0276913028,
-0.0295377336,
0.0041119806,
0.0624616034,
-0.0140586197,
0.0146251954,
-0.0829860345,
-0.0184239782,
0.013060593,
0.0711891353,
-0.045232188,
0.032815598,
0.0612277426,
-0.0584122986,
-0.0463871025,
0.0258744545,
0.0653609484,
-0.0322555341,
0.0092631495,
-0.0245381687,
-0.0295069404,
-0.0014943015,
0.0129592912,
-0.0349280201,
-0.058067847,
0.0099201342,
-0.0245950185,
0.0465362519,
0.0171471853,
-0.0381554924,
0.0132454867,
0.0607825406,
-0.0191097911,
-0.0224120114,
-0.015602638,
0.0195538364,
0.0863049626,
0.0365316905,
-0.0021865349,
-0.0133857122,
0.0040188725,
0.0415467545,
0.0394537821,
-0.0119190952,
0.0088760816,
0.0097689582,
-0.004805584,
0.0090632532,
-0.0493643768,
-0.0092953267,
-0.0295968633,
-0.0097418912,
-0.0617728457,
-0.0306757148,
0.0559646972,
0.047402259,
-0.0090072714,
-0.0179337412,
0.0106020356,
-0.0491787195,
-0.0109786186,
0.0249582417,
-0.046197243,
0.0176802464,
-0.0250618439,
-0.0028351594,
-0.0684785023,
-0.0162172914,
-0.0253856983,
-0.0610191412,
-0.0018227341,
-0.0102215614,
-0.0336146504,
-0.0165281743,
-0.0503536537,
-0.0316126421,
0.04299872,
0.0121945785,
-0.0097711226,
-0.0168228503,
0.0467022993,
0.0632636547,
-0.0065282974,
-0.042823188,
0.0210316423,
0.042952124,
-0.0118929129,
0.0443696156,
0.0411384664,
-0.041962564,
-0.03776123,
-0.0135445325,
-0.0414501168,
-0.0077009946,
0.0039258706,
0.0622173995,
-0.0162808467,
0.0265662856,
-0.0253854822,
0.0544683151,
0.0165182464,
-0.0263896678,
-0.0083146989,
0.0588402823,
-0.0229813736,
-0.0447967723,
-0.0458037853,
-0.0381362326,
0.0123815378,
0.0294228569,
0.0416403338,
-0.0199859217,
0.0051290598,
-0.0247311424,
0.0286090337,
-0.0548059307,
-0.0734301955,
0.0090320725,
-0.0215313863,
-0.0073040621,
-0.0342608653,
-0.0717938468,
0.0260178819,
0.0115604438,
0.0274305101,
-0.0126666799,
-0.0092570707,
0.0102291601,
-0.1083769575,
0.0475036949,
0.0349724032,
-0.0053114854,
0.0033954291,
-0.0347860195,
-0.0030403479,
-0.0660070404,
-0.0314276107,
-0.0080002723,
-0.0466986336,
-0.0020066132,
-0.0072419043,
-0.0338225476,
0.026708262,
-0.0329825729,
0.0249994826,
-0.039645832,
0.0331868157,
0.0693806261,
-0.0281694196,
-0.0142167313,
-0.0179242846,
-0.0083586341,
0.0035750808,
-0.0210957229,
0.0068169278,
0.0303751491,
0.0014813436,
-0.0810360685,
-0.0948042423,
0.0212713964,
0.0405470096,
0.0312550925,
0.0457060933,
-0.0072874776,
-0.0228262674,
-0.0320358165,
-0.0423535034,
0.0416323207,
-0.0579852089,
0.0000723405,
-0.0013025388,
0.0229498837,
0.0257497188,
-0.0194915421,
0.0236831922,
-0.0435524173,
0.0159984156,
-0.0521343052,
-0.0183130503,
0.0029894907,
0.0209695082,
-0.0068572611,
-0.0039683147,
-0.0167019814,
-0.0057542366,
0.0260676704,
0.0288303718,
0.0191232692,
0.0489882343,
0.0585763901,
0.0040983348,
0.0527109616,
0.0334348567,
-0.0651124343,
0.0227021296,
-0.0404182337,
-0.0390622616,
-0.0327080525,
-0.0279872678,
-0.0123530198,
-0.0187855642,
0.0097293267,
0.0422405377,
0.0292122345,
-0.0178120211,
-0.0537712499,
0.0174106229,
0.0190759171,
-0.0120994532,
-0.0386665352,
0.0424589105,
-0.0545771234,
-0.015818011,
0.0496684052,
-0.0705545619,
-0.0048917686,
-0.0113671161,
0.0555044003,
0.0329082683,
0.0295701176,
-0.0033126504,
-0.0650140643,
-0.0405443497,
0.0189651214,
0.0024377587,
0.052200567,
-0.0131072719,
0.0248771869,
0.0738023967,
-0.0016875846,
0.0092814369,
-0.0384545922,
0.0345860757,
-0.0336401723,
-0.0130386548,
0.0012975932,
-6.118792295e-33,
-0.0009172107,
-0.1073753536,
-0.0196281802,
0.0637961775,
-0.0545881391,
0.0219739582,
-0.0236697495,
0.0099707693,
-0.0026524698,
0.0008519708,
-0.0019134376,
0.0097045181,
-0.0201097075,
0.0013667356,
-0.0102815451,
-0.0288067404,
0.0269411802,
-0.0035461625,
-0.0339989215,
0.0060784039,
0.0255022142,
-0.003909816,
0.0216035135,
-0.0646928698,
0.0698774531,
-0.0414892025,
-0.050158564,
-0.0259198472,
0.0379638039,
0.0030805098,
0.0030952122,
0.0371045284,
0.0356299132,
-0.0566260666,
0.0063951397,
0.0985695496,
-0.0233034194,
-0.0718190074,
0.0488906838,
0.0235547218,
-0.0061733159,
-0.0194582902,
0.0624489784,
-0.0441340655,
0.0389293358,
0.0105542075,
0.0904106423,
-0.0023211795,
0.0306425616,
-0.0071542314,
-0.0338306949,
-0.0121084284,
-0.0378724523,
-0.0063309111,
0.0620132387,
0.0644983724,
0.0333146378,
0.0070869154,
-0.0809140727,
0.0638455451,
0.0167766307,
0.0290977992,
0.069225654,
0.0200252775,
-0.0130269071,
0.0536702611,
0.0065551791,
0.0296704359,
-0.0760503039,
0.032997895,
0.0094320588,
0.0076234587,
0.0560098737,
0.0725849047,
0.0384684652,
-0.0462631248,
-0.0088521652,
0.0267541017,
0.0443179868,
-0.0508881398,
-0.0329702087,
-0.0502279066,
-0.0227645691,
-0.0413937792,
-0.0209583398,
-0.0001906317,
-0.0262494981,
-0.0630506799,
-0.0124646593,
-0.042379003,
-0.036277473,
0.0449348204,
-0.051114928,
-0.0000410077,
-0.0086521534,
-0.0041541588,
-0.0137779666,
0.0112363975,
-0.0109686088,
-0.0363424495,
-0.029754201,
0.0355855227,
0.0051692324,
0.0156627949,
0.0342737138,
-0.0074822088,
0.0124967806,
0.0064336224,
-0.0219701082,
-0.0287422389,
-0.0164185967,
0.0021124445,
-0.0106547633,
-0.028430352,
-0.0005672068,
0.0397987664,
-0.0096854074,
-0.0324767008,
0.0461290181,
-0.0053507173,
-0.0298389979,
-0.0262406841,
-0.0560167767,
-0.0041565266,
0.0049092597,
-0.0482195318,
0.0050596972,
0.004129908,
0.0374850333,
-0.0860274583,
-0.0058192085,
0.014712397,
2.817e-7,
0.0135264536,
0.0253014769,
-0.0178233627,
-0.0065406947,
0.0094703017,
0.0380061716,
0.0286461357,
-0.0100255385,
0.0441065803,
-0.0664901063,
0.0069782156,
-0.0098746279,
-0.0001008413,
0.036095731,
-0.1275959611,
-0.0281715058,
-0.0184377544,
-0.017179925,
-0.028671775,
0.0151668703,
0.0958507583,
-0.0449341759,
-0.0113974661,
-0.0076253549,
-0.0181106627,
-0.0158582665,
-0.0157162249,
0.0028977722,
0.005532058,
0.0313959643,
0.0120813353,
-0.0275329966,
0.0004202616,
0.0522912256,
-0.0109392731,
-0.0474024825,
0.0515246615,
-0.0246948209,
0.0178431794,
-0.0186209008,
-0.030750813,
-0.0155221559,
0.0109747211,
-0.0607674457,
0.0512650646,
-0.0343493149,
-0.0137314415,
0.0142563786,
-0.010595114,
-0.0507021658,
-0.0139439981,
0.0045918575,
-0.0327031091,
0.019810535,
-0.01851728,
0.0067859692,
0.0361193977,
-0.0427325852,
0.0294181742,
0.029485032,
-0.0316768661,
-0.0088233547,
-0.0110376617,
-0.0303364322,
0.0330174491,
-0.0377564952,
0.0140369963,
2.29227184e-34,
-0.0114805764,
-0.0033026009,
0.0034158232,
-0.0042978055,
-0.0134231895,
0.0399598069,
0.0347086042,
-0.016140515,
0.0372570492,
0.008473835,
0.0042597107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12217v1 | Semantic Parsing for Conversational Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs | 2023-01-28T14:45:11 | 2023-01-28T14:45:11 | Laura Perez-Beltrachini, Parag Jain, Emilio Monti, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we are interested in developing semantic parsers which
understand natural language questions embedded in a conversation with a user
and ground them to formal queries over definitions in a general purpose
knowledge graph (KG) with very large vocabularies (covering thousands of
concept names and relations, and millions of entities). To this end, we develop
a dataset where user questions are annotated with Sparql parses and system
answers correspond to execution results thereof. We present two different
semantic parsing approaches and highlight the challenges of the task: dealing
with large vocabularies, modelling conversation context, predicting queries
with multiple entities, and generalising to new questions at test time. We hope
our dataset will serve as useful testbed for the development of conversational
semantic parsers. Our dataset and models are released at
https://github.com/EdinburghNLP/SPICE. | [
0.0570089929,
-0.005924975,
0.0013507027,
0.0532316752,
-0.0142154163,
0.0181973577,
-0.0432795845,
-0.0347784609,
0.0085634841,
-0.0468126908,
0.0320663117,
0.0489673428,
-0.0260251258,
0.0522413738,
-0.0109842373,
-0.0286316536,
0.0155633111,
-0.0195465516,
0.0126360161,
0.0284483656,
0.0240774117,
0.0594295412,
0.0012911463,
0.0260814987,
-0.0321712643,
-0.0270285159,
-0.0220992919,
0.0033207538,
-0.0669990107,
-0.0229540616,
0.0065392349,
0.0318122767,
0.0263817664,
0.0155563578,
0.0000016778,
-0.0471381694,
-0.0163502302,
0.0228607301,
-0.057252977,
-0.0526341982,
0.0024334476,
0.0040221,
0.0544504188,
0.0022823534,
-0.0613102019,
-0.0448266864,
0.0039657825,
0.0386945307,
0.0404858477,
0.0228255186,
-0.0202227924,
-0.0422462597,
-0.0248680357,
0.0223978106,
0.0241223555,
-0.0750216469,
0.0213879552,
0.0466997847,
0.0051773461,
-0.0026889623,
-0.006838988,
-0.0063247853,
0.0113108037,
-0.0072339955,
0.0433662497,
-0.0018518409,
-0.0301785972,
0.0041991021,
-0.0125519466,
0.0975534245,
0.0388068035,
-0.0094353659,
0.0304288231,
0.0370468311,
-0.0165497847,
0.0011606446,
-0.0374528468,
-0.012309839,
-0.0392665863,
-0.0145047745,
-0.0193850752,
-0.0297239386,
0.0083744833,
0.0046274466,
-0.0325668976,
0.1097840443,
-0.0046764528,
-0.0049551949,
0.0119924005,
-0.0076634712,
-0.0100288335,
-0.0538584739,
0.0039925571,
0.038145978,
-0.0625994131,
0.0507099517,
-0.0374930799,
0.0098635629,
0.0258934591,
-0.0394095778,
-0.0421558395,
0.0444560945,
0.0367719196,
0.0513224639,
0.0022850204,
0.002419889,
-0.0144478129,
0.0263150781,
-0.0503192842,
-0.0606405586,
-0.0736793503,
-0.0010513467,
-0.0651176348,
0.0295978114,
-0.0628200695,
-0.0239302907,
-0.0113566294,
0.0645251721,
0.0229428019,
0.0456130728,
0.0295974109,
0.0611302294,
-0.0248996075,
0.030148888,
-0.0506061427,
0.0317045003,
-0.0396024436,
0.0005514144,
0.0114689078,
-0.0519242436,
-0.0019274798,
-0.0034016091,
0.0426684059,
-0.0431357697,
-0.0330380611,
0.0331390537,
0.0407235809,
0.0081344945,
-0.0062894546,
-0.097122848,
0.0248735882,
0.0000822497,
-0.0117829563,
-0.0629169717,
0.0515642054,
0.0343093686,
-0.0065951515,
-0.0426793881,
0.0106562153,
0.0431660749,
-0.025735721,
0.0666600317,
-0.0347950757,
0.0071180374,
0.0349905565,
0.0132494597,
-0.0236665066,
0.0743387043,
0.0032920418,
-0.0040283813,
0.0636002123,
-0.0060823304,
-0.0563898981,
0.0068575186,
0.0307205729,
-0.0243478436,
0.0179413259,
0.077658169,
-0.0085347546,
0.0335378647,
0.001466218,
0.0210085716,
-0.0138984621,
-0.0480337441,
-0.0257976633,
0.0487615094,
-0.0463200398,
0.0048721498,
0.0493628457,
0.0309408326,
0.0011547649,
-0.0160252061,
-0.0431377366,
-0.0127919931,
-0.00921572,
-0.0036660777,
-0.0272725616,
-0.0229065437,
-0.0258827098,
-0.0014514319,
0.0096864076,
0.0191389248,
0.0120699368,
0.0506787412,
0.0432703122,
0.0181926917,
-0.0326852016,
0.0856280774,
0.0195605364,
-0.0160912145,
0.0078139901,
-0.0208751559,
0.0344564989,
0.0706749931,
0.0394206904,
-0.0244335588,
-0.0657768175,
0.0031727669,
0.0098667517,
0.0201233234,
0.0188828409,
-0.0438681245,
0.0134285241,
-0.0140293343,
-0.0303456187,
-0.0317381024,
-0.0159336012,
-0.0237758867,
0.018536102,
-0.0251539201,
0.0184020214,
-0.0546691306,
0.0135621885,
0.0161049515,
0.0024105636,
0.0220437963,
0.0079228561,
-0.0294917356,
0.0199358631,
0.048152335,
0.0254668444,
0.0277166031,
0.0205203667,
0.0078904023,
-0.0269755926,
0.0228877254,
0.0035674798,
-0.0646696389,
0.0416001342,
-0.0162442625,
-0.0349221192,
0.0023127566,
-0.0567295998,
-0.0605350919,
0.0199344177,
-0.0121151693,
0.0726810545,
-0.0107996427,
-0.0497479737,
0.0559004657,
-0.0329790823,
-0.0274976399,
0.0371609963,
0.0006894531,
0.0123892566,
-0.042852141,
0.0041143037,
0.0350973122,
-0.0575919524,
-0.0238539614,
-0.0246362854,
0.0066376375,
-0.0072539155,
0.010516014,
-0.0200677775,
-0.0948114097,
0.0467618816,
-0.1179586798,
0.0166669711,
-0.0085352091,
0.0371152721,
0.029213842,
0.0448058434,
0.050301753,
-0.0340233631,
-0.0434479937,
0.0339300781,
0.0313195139,
0.0029976426,
0.0389016084,
0.0457967781,
-0.0225755647,
-0.0061625941,
-0.0253539998,
-0.027028352,
0.0404540896,
0.0032847284,
0.0039988309,
-0.0037499778,
0.0068660839,
-0.0582703613,
0.0435876586,
0.0015258451,
0.0245016534,
-0.0108260876,
-0.0506237,
-0.0312138181,
0.0221119802,
-0.0280284472,
0.0359570906,
-0.0430411622,
-0.0272763614,
-0.0609251969,
0.0138241574,
-0.0070472187,
0.0236181002,
-0.0671257079,
0.0012962529,
0.0340230204,
0.0201541353,
0.0167041086,
0.0159368198,
-0.0357469432,
0.0085855499,
-0.0006349781,
0.0104612624,
-0.0491444506,
0.0039999178,
0.0329850614,
0.0526364557,
-0.0184515845,
0.0283697471,
0.0753904954,
-0.0012584061,
-0.0182736795,
-0.0150354719,
-0.0153626092,
-0.0470546596,
0.0661788061,
-0.0013988238,
0.0190763753,
-0.0510603674,
-0.0478659719,
-0.0072116242,
-0.0385369733,
0.0328832567,
-0.0191434883,
0.0334831513,
-0.0374768786,
0.0451466031,
0.0281259101,
-0.0053105899,
-0.0264216196,
-0.0215116534,
-0.0664381087,
0.0256785341,
-0.0023860077,
0.0256795753,
0.0232090242,
-0.0186921228,
-0.0580842048,
-0.0245867539,
0.0189355835,
-0.0137254866,
-0.0222284272,
0.0210835095,
0.0765801147,
0.0155152921,
-0.0208503101,
0.0348501354,
0.0381425768,
0.0609707385,
0.0318568684,
-0.0430294499,
-0.020963572,
0.0105857933,
0.0126101514,
-0.0471711569,
0.0179330744,
-0.0167786479,
0.0208596736,
-0.0498341024,
-0.0190635193,
0.1054771766,
0.0429656208,
0.0379708111,
0.0061939578,
-0.0149089843,
0.0337075144,
0.0223439429,
0.05288155,
-0.129395932,
-0.0482855551,
-0.0310315304,
0.0084566753,
0.0120328711,
-0.0746238679,
0.0120290127,
-0.101976648,
-0.0186567344,
-0.0398557335,
-0.0328395292,
-0.0015821425,
-0.0196023639,
-0.0282554273,
-0.0458553508,
-0.010234613,
0.0230388977,
-0.0122600663,
0.0188597236,
0.0025199861,
0.0297978073,
0.0013310441,
0.0634240732,
-0.0083689354,
0.0050730659,
0.0375535339,
0.0140156103,
0.0020265472,
0.0007028247,
0.0048592011,
0.0001762842,
-0.0163786188,
-0.0298487712,
0.0526512377,
-0.0086483276,
-0.0010504125,
-0.0277825352,
0.0204636753,
-0.0665818974,
-0.0027174971,
0.0182785448,
0.0505183637,
-0.0505375192,
0.0083645601,
0.0320983082,
-0.001210494,
0.0044214535,
0.0821558461,
0.0199594758,
0.0605844334,
-0.0720685571,
-0.0566127039,
-0.0177850109,
-0.0637433976,
0.0094877379,
0.0282751676,
0.0127516007,
0.0203486793,
-0.0414039455,
-0.0315392241,
0.0821517408,
-0.0072210059,
-0.0290788952,
0.0032830129,
0.0275849663,
0.0337762274,
-0.0343218371,
0.0364041254,
-0.0155163854,
0.0321138166,
-0.0016984259,
-0.0158638023,
0.0361007452,
-0.0060966029,
-0.0541723706,
0.0062492765,
-0.061752528,
-0.0333345719,
-0.0059548086,
0.0328936055,
0.0180826802,
0.0307674799,
-0.03690378,
-0.0182281248,
0.0108550563,
0.0019870906,
-0.1097217277,
-0.0562008321,
0.008602472,
0.0415072404,
0.0058267368,
0.0651800036,
-0.0631790608,
-0.0223061666,
-0.0641149804,
0.0679115802,
-0.0433685444,
-0.0654379129,
0.0514756441,
0.0263420511,
-0.0146726593,
0.0469030738,
0.0132136811,
0.0071831807,
0.0134019498,
-0.0314034559,
-0.0527795851,
-0.0476509109,
-0.0008652639,
-0.0230201613,
-0.048489891,
0.0180871729,
-0.0137591651,
-0.0398223586,
0.0250143986,
-0.019139573,
-0.0356586426,
0.0508979522,
-0.0397149287,
0.0478812344,
-0.0045965356,
-0.0175935626,
0.0175111368,
0.0159454364,
0.0144374622,
-0.0112161888,
0.034652587,
0.0285636,
-0.0035959645,
-0.0222095419,
-0.008076,
-0.0619768351,
-0.0712749958,
0.0406582393,
0.0297999661,
0.0101375515,
0.0013952832,
0.0479265116,
-0.0014894472,
-0.0072450712,
0.0068459082,
0.0323100984,
-0.0039250557,
-0.0346468166,
0.0684022456,
0.024949668,
-0.0228846669,
-0.0398008227,
0.07364811,
-0.0061964812,
0.0566618629,
0.0239867289,
-0.0672818571,
-0.0449424386,
-0.0423104018,
0.0178460088,
0.0564867184,
-0.0044201431,
-0.0104428502,
-0.0295827761,
-0.0606073625,
-0.0206089541,
-0.0193567295,
-0.0240282677,
0.0074354727,
0.0630092025,
0.0497235022,
0.0615826175,
-0.057244353,
-0.0231248047,
0.0195322055,
-0.0525541976,
-0.0383386202,
-0.0291691255,
-5.377761024e-33,
-0.0268298667,
-0.0239386857,
0.0503431559,
0.0511018708,
-0.0213582087,
-0.0486269109,
-0.030709736,
-0.0294742789,
-0.0263666306,
0.0148936845,
-0.0090633957,
0.0377057977,
0.0117323073,
0.0539715476,
-0.0014341065,
-0.065252088,
0.0251762364,
-0.0139709879,
0.0483428352,
0.031507954,
0.0840263367,
0.037841551,
0.0113180047,
-0.0099219549,
0.0259253848,
0.0034489592,
0.0274913684,
0.0542023182,
-0.0019237413,
0.0447373539,
-0.0070920801,
0.0408412106,
0.0144055001,
-0.0039908681,
-0.0059547038,
-0.0122795021,
-0.1048939005,
-0.0097042676,
0.0236064214,
0.0370926522,
-0.0694086701,
0.0185041074,
0.0568981916,
-0.0081266956,
0.0786031708,
0.0017196684,
0.0288443603,
0.02934625,
-0.0150210802,
-0.0401709303,
-0.0140090436,
0.0333113521,
-0.0330351926,
-0.0217334088,
-0.0042972551,
-0.0145528978,
0.015131223,
-0.0195260998,
-0.0170943346,
-0.004876981,
-0.0348224528,
0.003586736,
0.0023684225,
0.0128710838,
0.0193035528,
-0.0110755796,
-0.0282846391,
-0.010598816,
0.0013308041,
0.0331556462,
-0.0553460829,
0.0669263005,
-0.0403120369,
0.020729715,
0.0072688116,
0.0147661781,
-0.0586915985,
0.018520236,
-0.0101326257,
0.0747560486,
-0.0561973751,
-0.0025031189,
-0.0066271131,
-0.0315540992,
-0.0385741405,
0.0410099998,
-0.0350786708,
-0.0164655223,
0.0276508164,
-0.0446686372,
0.0088890009,
0.0109934267,
0.00680651,
-0.0729685277,
0.0184481218,
0.0416198187,
0.0130809015,
-0.0248853117,
0.0005931185,
0.0368905403,
0.0000283131,
-0.0050717844,
0.0180847179,
-0.0441537052,
-0.0122785196,
0.0197347254,
-0.0143753327,
-0.0320569128,
-0.0052423696,
0.019252535,
-0.0518076867,
0.0010598929,
-0.0668629184,
0.0323463604,
0.033085946,
0.0573305152,
-0.0347174741,
0.0222017616,
-0.00088543,
0.0285828914,
-0.0205164421,
-0.0306598525,
0.0486844629,
-0.0191153046,
-0.0245271306,
-0.025258366,
-0.0272641648,
-0.0190482177,
-0.0067441538,
-0.0042988746,
0.0142946858,
0.0029738024,
2.361e-7,
0.0437024757,
0.0017013431,
0.0258894246,
0.0687316507,
-0.0001823664,
0.0047590118,
0.036869999,
0.0525780655,
-0.0075697573,
-0.0517603718,
-0.0206562914,
0.0085362438,
-0.015075759,
0.0478343666,
-0.072864145,
-0.0262667537,
-0.0195032582,
-0.0526333414,
-0.035993576,
-0.0184180662,
0.0727370009,
0.0481253043,
0.0113524301,
0.0153085059,
-0.0178574398,
-0.0315355882,
0.0036141579,
0.0175040122,
0.0018762999,
0.0195795372,
0.0239347257,
-0.0061444803,
0.0140523566,
0.0368626863,
-0.0112823276,
0.0193441994,
0.0023211075,
0.0561427549,
-0.0287028309,
0.0099007944,
-0.0290306211,
-0.0696367398,
0.0384824872,
-0.0399031267,
0.0618905984,
-0.0517810695,
-0.0084558344,
0.0378941447,
-0.021317333,
-0.0340278931,
-0.0577721409,
-0.0026654697,
0.0183645226,
-0.0018503529,
0.0306492448,
-0.0103539759,
0.0267741252,
-0.0361561552,
0.0292369034,
0.0436958075,
-0.0425657406,
-0.0145395044,
0.0068643768,
0.006962304,
0.0073401574,
-0.0073907054,
0.0016702287,
1.686758629e-34,
0.0238485709,
0.0646471605,
-0.0012147301,
0.0265085194,
0.0577403829,
-0.0170148257,
-0.0159774683,
0.0039919172,
0.054439418,
-0.1131690368,
0.0101027954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12206v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12206v1 | Semantic Tagging with LSTM-CRF | 2023-01-28T14:06:17 | 2023-01-28T14:06:17 | Farshad Noravesh | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the present paper, two models are presented namely LSTM-CRF and
BERT-LSTM-CRF for semantic tagging of universal semantic tag dataset. The
experiments show that the first model is much easier to converge while the
second model that leverages BERT embedding, takes a long time to converge and
needs a big dataset for semtagging to be effective. | [
0.014960072,
-0.0202043243,
0.0301974248,
-0.0021054819,
-0.0231038518,
0.0363368951,
-0.0148165394,
0.0091989441,
0.0130555471,
-0.0495059527,
0.0002711142,
0.014884348,
-0.011104743,
-0.0113354605,
0.0012953458,
-0.0259324387,
0.057971634,
0.0320002697,
0.0306818318,
0.0104578482,
-0.001263957,
-0.0328365974,
0.0065938151,
0.0125489552,
-0.050044436,
-0.0119452467,
0.0015349665,
-0.0019246305,
0.0297598485,
-0.0430960506,
0.0056940154,
0.0448412113,
0.0303254426,
0.0232296679,
0.0000015291,
-0.0286742859,
-0.0587587766,
0.0122477561,
0.0172793157,
-0.0199170783,
0.0097646946,
0.0024487227,
-0.0281518567,
0.0427095294,
-0.0336597934,
-0.0058370871,
0.0189959891,
0.0653747544,
0.0578402802,
0.0801506341,
-0.0076801097,
-0.0850521922,
0.0617267191,
-0.0261215474,
0.0072091678,
-0.0401478335,
0.0404016152,
0.000321054,
0.0379020311,
-0.0181444883,
-0.0338294208,
0.0218957122,
0.0074550449,
-0.0113962675,
0.0281052478,
-0.0040605399,
-0.0597970709,
0.0227401741,
0.015425005,
0.0533403158,
-0.018613562,
0.0016237941,
0.0168937575,
0.0443225652,
-0.037261337,
-0.0509063601,
-0.0464273356,
0.0260333568,
-0.0207718294,
0.0511993468,
0.0254974533,
-0.0544096753,
0.0637748092,
0.0263741817,
-0.0353665091,
0.0722274631,
0.0407303162,
-0.041917026,
-0.0197391231,
-0.0108919162,
-0.0369361304,
-0.024373861,
0.0025824797,
0.04372916,
-0.0291740727,
0.0495295003,
-0.0669082478,
-0.0376560651,
-0.0061647152,
-0.0155149465,
-0.0155191682,
0.0318302996,
0.0329413787,
0.054535564,
-0.0746134669,
0.0180505309,
-0.0494155474,
0.0428221449,
-0.0343816951,
-0.0648743957,
-0.104948923,
-0.0242449921,
-0.0590482987,
0.0602744482,
0.0270884763,
-0.0307205841,
-0.1094186679,
0.0354788601,
0.0131437937,
0.0419389307,
0.0083791139,
-0.0161671136,
-0.0299701914,
0.0496821851,
-0.0617739633,
0.016657019,
-0.0281865839,
-0.039688129,
-0.0085904598,
-0.0288046245,
0.0246714279,
0.0196463298,
0.0162732955,
-0.0298582818,
0.0261949953,
0.0300768837,
0.0475651734,
-0.0258627534,
-0.0794719979,
-0.0294306446,
-0.0024710884,
0.0032814667,
0.0595560931,
-0.0380847715,
0.0070283907,
-0.0085984506,
0.0083824098,
0.0079983752,
0.0028187595,
0.026821766,
-0.0288779307,
0.1057769582,
-0.075045757,
-0.0192287378,
0.0167418085,
0.0017378153,
0.0443080664,
0.0348482542,
0.0600229986,
0.0011578071,
0.0649418235,
-0.0062086536,
-0.0144441454,
0.0086297607,
0.0181037951,
-0.0121608805,
-0.0667218119,
-0.0074488991,
0.0570992976,
0.024626052,
0.0200766586,
0.0383482426,
-0.0080700032,
-0.0137437768,
-0.0185607821,
0.021721255,
0.0589894652,
0.0150958635,
0.015245473,
0.0022657607,
0.0024152116,
-0.0166352354,
0.0091687534,
-0.0183659811,
-0.0072750738,
0.0215748809,
-0.0021230939,
-0.033883214,
-0.0359028503,
0.0162894558,
-0.0322884656,
-0.0259261969,
0.0055642365,
-0.0286883656,
0.0618680306,
0.0136105232,
-0.0213709101,
0.0455268882,
0.0319468789,
-0.0325896107,
0.0245836433,
-0.0508853495,
0.0307429377,
0.0341032855,
0.0666231662,
-0.0900115371,
-0.073184289,
0.0043747174,
0.0106288772,
0.0555824526,
0.0373406783,
0.0000942221,
-0.0521547794,
-0.0329331793,
-0.0154567501,
0.0119806202,
-0.0035232401,
0.0018937902,
-0.0073916148,
0.0193041433,
-0.0040949825,
-0.0320765376,
0.0008704118,
0.0605824478,
0.014580369,
0.0118801882,
-0.0084831957,
-0.021351628,
0.0149880787,
0.0359365195,
-0.0157074742,
0.0299605895,
0.0329953469,
-0.0256819446,
-0.0296813753,
-0.0094399648,
-0.0083537204,
-0.0626349822,
0.0544063151,
-0.0295799598,
-0.0536073186,
0.0038506594,
-0.0482638068,
-0.0560650304,
0.0133906305,
0.0113196792,
0.0851901844,
-0.034589529,
0.0186151732,
0.021183718,
-0.039632991,
-0.0222585071,
0.0517540574,
0.02744429,
0.0527892932,
0.0253151618,
0.0592163727,
0.0442801677,
-0.0358066149,
-0.0917893276,
0.0023899211,
0.0053509665,
-0.0407279842,
-0.0210919827,
-0.0077745351,
-0.0767649338,
-0.0150366472,
-0.0610808395,
0.0075330655,
0.0063645858,
0.0385189988,
-0.0084767593,
0.0049573048,
0.0124938525,
-0.0034281637,
-0.0378632694,
-0.0060276501,
-0.0024005121,
0.0007956927,
0.0413955301,
0.0319380499,
-0.0677812621,
-0.0457869135,
-0.0070475941,
-0.0202643406,
0.0255161095,
0.0338089429,
-0.0192310661,
-0.0200706646,
-0.0318394527,
-0.0138197709,
0.051828891,
-0.0119714094,
-0.0442915447,
0.0062729395,
-0.0230350234,
0.0341848694,
-0.0122497799,
-0.0060810791,
-0.0030264365,
-0.006964481,
0.0080085052,
-0.0076836343,
0.02681127,
-0.0487555377,
0.0236225929,
-0.0138759911,
-0.0024657366,
0.0266431551,
0.0759399608,
-0.0455825999,
0.0169296917,
-0.0172704998,
-0.0413556099,
-0.0185258426,
-0.0019837895,
-0.0285440851,
0.0193641596,
-0.0216904823,
0.0002104908,
-0.0084093483,
-0.0195089541,
0.0350730307,
-0.0260837059,
0.007388541,
-0.0302513465,
0.0064924452,
-0.0448093228,
0.0465337522,
-0.010107168,
0.0116952565,
0.0151142832,
-0.0382421166,
0.0081810793,
-0.0343748257,
0.0339477398,
-0.0171097517,
-0.0106165987,
-0.0098643443,
0.0321889259,
-0.0103587955,
0.0316946171,
-0.0337797478,
-0.0133601045,
-0.0277837291,
0.0652259514,
0.013715893,
-0.0210066885,
0.0208816938,
0.0226866081,
-0.0004837976,
0.01193708,
-0.0021260062,
-0.0030153443,
0.0110217985,
0.0541812554,
0.0297656693,
-0.0493161902,
-0.0321219787,
0.0544571877,
0.0145401694,
0.0118107125,
0.0448936634,
0.0027601304,
-0.0678359047,
0.0021328887,
-0.0106972437,
-0.0811196119,
-0.0348886549,
-0.0463394374,
-0.0617124736,
-0.0610827543,
0.0026841043,
0.1318757236,
0.0610068217,
0.0052797119,
-0.0218456425,
-0.010019456,
-0.0150939748,
0.007699817,
-0.0161079075,
-0.0503061637,
-0.0306166038,
0.0138886012,
0.0020681315,
0.050695736,
-0.0498654209,
0.0333592966,
-0.0579937808,
-0.003787864,
-0.0263698921,
-0.015090229,
-0.0081843175,
-0.0296150465,
-0.0249229167,
0.0227241311,
-0.0336221308,
0.0083074905,
-0.0133487647,
0.0270326473,
0.0332615413,
-0.059839271,
0.0077527049,
0.0018084492,
-0.0906313509,
0.0737896115,
0.0909634382,
0.0520516224,
-0.034197893,
-0.0426380299,
0.0517467372,
0.0093570799,
-0.0123332124,
-0.0501879789,
-0.016868975,
-0.0506391414,
-0.0530430526,
-0.0000564376,
-0.071328178,
-0.0355990641,
-0.0039132703,
-0.0397503376,
0.0794049054,
-0.0288822614,
0.0405288786,
-0.0032684158,
-0.0337157026,
-0.0328862555,
0.0832275748,
-0.0069933762,
-0.0118696326,
-0.0329161808,
0.0323966444,
-0.0424387679,
-0.0274822637,
0.0561724938,
0.0224889852,
-0.0933426842,
-0.0697819591,
-0.0803311169,
-0.0467530936,
0.078817673,
0.031065492,
-0.02040614,
0.0172571726,
0.029307887,
0.0062090997,
-0.0698400885,
0.0183125176,
-0.0481098928,
0.0161119774,
-0.0527868532,
0.0062636011,
0.0603653044,
0.0512480289,
-0.0184489191,
-0.0295626242,
0.0102798119,
-0.010928697,
-0.002790303,
-0.0069262031,
0.0158890765,
0.0070189247,
-0.0286524203,
-0.0147510609,
0.0069237906,
-0.0154986009,
-0.0240843035,
0.0031236156,
0.0520727262,
0.0582612045,
0.0134334434,
0.0222649295,
-0.0490665399,
0.0081661111,
-0.0111587103,
0.0940580219,
-0.0195033122,
-0.0051456117,
-0.0023300317,
0.0012415125,
0.0496711358,
-0.0126136094,
0.0072030528,
-0.0226144064,
0.0150563009,
0.0169517715,
-0.025282694,
-0.0334087349,
0.0329804979,
0.0319234133,
-0.0059243916,
-0.0145603968,
0.0138971154,
-0.0138040772,
0.013098429,
0.0315025076,
0.019864941,
0.0231692195,
0.0496210791,
-0.0394099876,
0.012893565,
0.0033702373,
-0.0436709449,
0.0090659903,
-0.0174417775,
-0.0323292166,
0.0320166945,
0.0313663036,
0.0310632885,
-0.0036889198,
0.0129386727,
0.0240136255,
0.0311786812,
0.0024591296,
0.0287923161,
0.0683858097,
0.0595711879,
0.0063403705,
-0.0097582843,
-0.0251349751,
0.005242845,
0.0239736419,
0.0149034346,
-0.031755738,
0.0920931548,
-0.0028572343,
-0.0538814627,
-0.0450016409,
0.0299928822,
0.0097049,
0.0439004079,
0.0208937172,
-0.0560750663,
-0.0298088398,
0.0115150558,
0.0582131743,
-0.0126736043,
-0.0291125663,
0.0165219866,
0.0104700914,
-0.0500121638,
0.0843409896,
0.0149818053,
-0.0210882574,
0.0462551266,
0.0464466512,
0.0075540515,
0.0393016227,
0.0062377504,
-0.026838921,
0.0142965941,
-0.0107135214,
-0.0457156636,
0.0011829874,
-5.317606203e-33,
-0.0394384749,
-0.0210925471,
0.018554138,
-0.0022633316,
-0.0260404013,
-0.0110562816,
-0.0157480799,
-0.0185920075,
-0.0239319466,
0.0218285676,
-0.0222694594,
0.0279591549,
0.0255652871,
0.0362019911,
-0.0106462445,
-0.0528006963,
0.0215643886,
0.0044461461,
0.0379942022,
-0.0091362521,
0.0127796661,
0.0839428678,
0.0778093189,
-0.0390589014,
0.0202338751,
-0.0067375908,
-0.0097156027,
0.0173203405,
0.0799635425,
0.0572257787,
-0.0541713797,
0.0136798956,
0.0179861113,
-0.0463153645,
0.0157946236,
0.0610646382,
-0.0957843438,
-0.036557477,
0.009922279,
0.0246948954,
-0.0397160538,
0.0245351046,
-0.0096155601,
-0.0009501374,
0.0496288389,
0.0746888742,
0.0271511711,
-0.0367040895,
-0.0078917565,
-0.0475119539,
-0.0402855948,
0.0459089577,
0.0393932089,
0.013980004,
0.0288664028,
-0.0497953258,
0.0067748968,
0.0260418132,
-0.0492284074,
-0.023678232,
-0.0209375452,
0.013255083,
0.0368553326,
0.0196101461,
0.0282944478,
0.0276441928,
-0.0232567824,
-0.0412735939,
0.0441556536,
0.0273921452,
-0.015635293,
0.0434527174,
0.0555231646,
0.0339594595,
0.0069033261,
0.0038252505,
-0.0578962937,
0.0192842856,
0.0573735721,
0.0408919491,
-0.037773177,
0.0243947916,
-0.0218211617,
0.0070644449,
0.003248353,
0.0568522997,
-0.0349367186,
-0.0237931442,
0.0386493057,
0.0108155608,
-0.0277045947,
0.0361711197,
-0.0104348827,
-0.0234943014,
0.0096431226,
-0.0288056619,
0.0282289311,
0.0132330172,
-0.0311364774,
0.0041427435,
-0.0348898917,
-0.0787238106,
0.0294380002,
-0.0545023158,
-0.03630016,
-0.0096833734,
0.0333816595,
0.0142435068,
-0.0420283228,
0.0119496481,
-0.0050457544,
-0.0200746059,
-0.0299180448,
0.0186256114,
0.0046040681,
-0.0031906308,
-0.0025078824,
0.0244788397,
0.026937766,
0.0523483977,
-0.0311210081,
-0.032090351,
0.0243503153,
0.0035807847,
0.0162041113,
-0.0057227858,
-0.0114125228,
0.0610243306,
-0.0129957125,
-0.0449268855,
0.007149993,
0.0020083997,
2.388e-7,
0.0653561801,
-0.0022879213,
0.0319027118,
0.0067529269,
-0.0080205705,
-0.0044304319,
0.0115247406,
0.0524703562,
-0.0384454131,
-0.0002367691,
0.0155463954,
-0.0501090772,
-0.0218797438,
0.0042051151,
-0.0861267373,
-0.0343497731,
-0.0395268016,
-0.0153611209,
-0.0084271869,
0.0251865406,
0.0415750258,
0.1147585735,
0.0361174308,
-0.0131400814,
-0.0140344454,
-0.0618130751,
0.0345455036,
-0.0017044669,
0.005264957,
0.0235828068,
0.0117993932,
0.0704156458,
-0.0079617379,
0.008620997,
-0.0197025016,
0.0149100348,
0.0118407942,
0.0337131582,
-0.0134217311,
-0.0265831929,
-0.0066102305,
-0.0488717109,
0.0218327735,
-0.0225007031,
0.0398236103,
-0.040680334,
-0.0247564465,
0.0321307033,
-0.0111871613,
0.0105857691,
0.0141910193,
-0.0062891669,
-0.0307161491,
-0.0330823772,
0.0299416725,
-0.0131635349,
-0.0461666323,
-0.1369628757,
0.0228373557,
0.0060106153,
-0.0509506725,
-0.0107516339,
-0.0233157594,
-0.0056372616,
0.0335502364,
-0.0603273958,
-0.0176813956,
1.964595214e-34,
0.0077705896,
-0.0179878473,
-0.0420597084,
0.026323989,
0.0041943761,
0.029467687,
-0.0172056314,
0.0043606954,
0.0251739416,
-0.080596514,
-0.0068143238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12140v1 | Multilingual Sentence Transformer as A Multilingual Word Aligner | 2023-01-28T09:28:55 | 2023-01-28T09:28:55 | Weikang Wang, Guanhua Chen, Hanqing Wang, Yue Han, Yun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual pretrained language models (mPLMs) have shown their
effectiveness in multilingual word alignment induction. However, these methods
usually start from mBERT or XLM-R. In this paper, we investigate whether
multilingual sentence Transformer LaBSE is a strong multilingual word aligner.
This idea is non-trivial as LaBSE is trained to learn language-agnostic
sentence-level embeddings, while the alignment extraction task requires the
more fine-grained word-level embeddings to be language-agnostic. We demonstrate
that the vanilla LaBSE outperforms other mPLMs currently used in the alignment
task, and then propose to finetune LaBSE on parallel corpus for further
improvement. Experiment results on seven language pairs show that our best
aligner outperforms previous state-of-the-art models of all varieties. In
addition, our aligner supports different language pairs in a single model, and
even achieves new state-of-the-art on zero-shot language pairs that does not
appear in the finetuning process. | [
-0.0166875906,
0.0624858886,
0.0316283256,
0.0499839224,
-0.0632340312,
0.0052047553,
0.0137323001,
-0.0606202409,
-0.0197576731,
0.0236753337,
-0.0537847951,
-0.0131671382,
0.0075378921,
-0.0463222899,
0.0291861296,
-0.0017613684,
0.0540391505,
0.0293818917,
-0.0205113981,
0.0018775779,
0.0535197929,
0.044334542,
0.0010836808,
0.0086114621,
-0.0283250418,
-0.0416200273,
0.017658364,
0.0124317119,
0.0657538995,
0.0004172726,
0.0110502448,
0.0060680215,
-0.0011224599,
0.0574669428,
0.0000015271,
-0.0338516869,
-0.0480746515,
0.0005547734,
0.0357688144,
-0.0147888074,
-0.0048007411,
-0.0805181861,
0.0000664076,
0.0324815698,
-0.0193893798,
0.0059847869,
0.0831813961,
0.0277790446,
0.0266584773,
0.0790274888,
-0.0326114744,
-0.0369175933,
0.0136085162,
-0.0399769358,
-0.0545294695,
-0.0342951007,
-0.003616285,
0.0071540582,
-0.0403488129,
-0.0369675197,
-0.0464029089,
0.0436258987,
0.001077356,
0.0129885394,
-0.0459928326,
-0.0154287042,
-0.0384286381,
-0.0351855494,
-0.0095983604,
0.0701227635,
-0.0814908296,
-0.0324256942,
-0.026517652,
0.0033065309,
-0.0261628814,
0.0001992195,
-0.0148029989,
0.0295350943,
0.0031339626,
0.0554506071,
0.0362400711,
0.0050252327,
0.0656750649,
-0.0190916229,
-0.0197343007,
0.0472324751,
0.0696969852,
-0.0750405416,
-0.0034442644,
0.0171549525,
-0.0005089151,
-0.0070898007,
-0.0049440218,
0.0011410778,
-0.0337279178,
0.0216664933,
-0.0657353699,
-0.0602749623,
0.0082241213,
-0.0397216603,
0.0352761783,
0.057475049,
-0.00547614,
0.0540870354,
-0.0473948941,
0.0569167286,
-0.021755537,
0.0157787129,
-0.0454415642,
-0.0605803728,
0.0205142554,
0.0117429579,
-0.0229471307,
-0.0261992346,
-0.0251074135,
-0.0228878092,
-0.0283265654,
0.0290592518,
0.016442582,
0.0414159484,
-0.0035339231,
-0.0586731769,
-0.0467313193,
-0.0419933535,
0.0315608382,
0.0847710148,
-0.0246302672,
0.000070692,
-0.0227828249,
-0.0171702318,
-0.0384780131,
0.0419383086,
0.0122630382,
-0.0529567003,
0.0091153169,
0.0296153985,
-0.0425023027,
-0.0397931337,
0.0114421276,
0.0354578197,
-0.0130088264,
-0.0679491907,
-0.0185764637,
-0.0529201142,
0.0988410115,
-0.0078193676,
0.0124483155,
-0.0205161069,
0.0110017676,
-0.0080698235,
-0.043096602,
0.0671580657,
0.0122851506,
0.0129708862,
-0.0286877193,
-0.0553662404,
0.0647885427,
0.0719500706,
0.0349717699,
-0.0089973751,
0.0647321641,
-0.0095579186,
-0.0044366955,
0.0966543853,
-0.0182581451,
0.0066387444,
-0.0025486043,
-0.0083294651,
0.0302299932,
0.0474150963,
0.0255488735,
0.0069138664,
-0.0024147741,
0.0304812603,
0.0163501147,
0.0064829597,
0.0325269438,
0.010250763,
0.0494875498,
-0.0187778752,
-0.0454787724,
0.023179438,
-0.0033422261,
0.033411473,
0.0029088052,
0.0589540638,
0.0321295522,
0.1099964231,
-0.0302055739,
0.0175646171,
-0.0171154365,
-0.0390462503,
-0.0073707337,
-0.013847122,
0.0501825623,
0.0112775536,
-0.0568057783,
0.0789825097,
0.044500798,
-0.0546955541,
0.0033337178,
0.0252925456,
-0.0161871705,
0.0119178277,
0.0202383399,
-0.0118673127,
-0.0550465249,
0.0018022637,
-0.0330327563,
0.0801522583,
0.0625383928,
0.0052084303,
0.0308144577,
-0.0858167335,
-0.0191400032,
-0.0245366488,
-0.0149125177,
0.0460756943,
0.0023217266,
0.0326920599,
0.01505969,
-0.0307595842,
-0.0105421087,
0.0332172588,
-0.0583985932,
0.0156557765,
-0.0062274383,
0.0449751168,
0.0027109466,
-0.0036686666,
-0.0054331976,
0.0037855781,
0.0022227881,
-0.0468632355,
0.0354198143,
0.0557524897,
-0.0053154286,
-0.0752100274,
0.038971439,
-0.0315557234,
-0.0320191048,
0.0390054919,
-0.0436040275,
-0.0452850983,
-0.0471473075,
0.0334706903,
0.0215204004,
-0.034399353,
0.03376095,
-0.0100392401,
0.0173056852,
-0.0246927608,
0.0135300588,
0.0104243234,
0.0377272554,
-0.0231262688,
-0.0453040972,
0.0322980732,
-0.0097049065,
-0.041552864,
0.0106853843,
-0.0001517649,
0.0141171478,
0.0316786394,
0.0003773819,
0.0046936213,
-0.0341033228,
-0.0721300319,
0.0512076318,
-0.0411285721,
0.0365462638,
0.0483946167,
0.0399001725,
0.0035880397,
-0.0331940427,
-0.0562869571,
0.0083494559,
0.0412738882,
0.0125237014,
0.0670777485,
-0.0353066698,
-0.0068414952,
-0.0457816161,
0.0056567369,
-0.0189633146,
0.0335517004,
-0.0171678942,
-0.0202898979,
-0.044913169,
-0.0080284746,
-0.0418323912,
-0.0063621397,
-0.0047780378,
-0.0579871573,
-0.0097135734,
0.0141175175,
0.0632010475,
0.0396818072,
0.012196511,
-0.0104160774,
0.0149647957,
0.0221428629,
-0.0203291643,
0.0300546736,
-0.0219175406,
0.0000587472,
-0.0508854426,
-0.0072758924,
0.0318468772,
0.0761073902,
-0.018718008,
-0.0019979845,
-0.05444986,
-0.0145324897,
0.0392038897,
-0.000654975,
0.0103120375,
0.0303839426,
-0.0111152176,
-0.0098206494,
-0.0516548827,
-0.0240429249,
0.0515996292,
-0.0487481914,
-0.0154288337,
-0.0585535392,
-0.0202656966,
-0.0401043892,
0.0039175074,
0.0119614778,
0.0412356518,
-0.0487470217,
-0.0062402966,
-0.0461047813,
-0.0256455932,
0.0145445466,
-0.0071005826,
0.011579901,
0.0040798513,
-0.0163601376,
-0.0497142114,
-0.0541712902,
-0.0216294155,
-0.0636102483,
-0.0177240763,
-0.0103632072,
-0.0176150966,
-0.0000984889,
-0.0733201355,
0.0125120953,
0.0270308331,
0.0225756224,
-0.0115370303,
0.0460888036,
-0.0249888003,
0.0688143596,
0.0696879104,
0.0164700486,
-0.002286925,
-0.0339193903,
0.0214110818,
-0.0026256116,
-0.0153712416,
-0.0112363845,
-0.0090671778,
-0.0389908627,
0.0366161652,
-0.0335480794,
0.0226763878,
-0.0494316295,
0.0730894133,
0.0013070034,
-0.0018265788,
0.0933906734,
0.0209518261,
0.0143582979,
-0.0271550156,
-0.0016152096,
0.0305703171,
0.0118062729,
0.0247372407,
-0.1031225473,
-0.0384701937,
0.0021486583,
-0.0373375416,
0.0530863516,
0.0097425608,
-0.0181078203,
-0.1045339555,
-0.0338447206,
0.0280820206,
-0.050279621,
-0.0308897197,
-0.01584295,
-0.0144743109,
-0.0342116579,
0.0462368093,
-0.0132926749,
0.0115779554,
0.0052387444,
-0.0147026842,
-0.0005140711,
-0.0545619875,
0.0085977446,
-0.0729854107,
0.0175917409,
0.0441385023,
0.0511864126,
-0.0353321321,
-0.0301903095,
0.0220563598,
-0.006996227,
-0.0332801081,
0.0595936477,
-0.0098941708,
-0.0600767918,
-0.0500084162,
0.0297209546,
0.0109301321,
-0.0063233902,
0.0156975202,
0.0103278765,
0.0556418784,
0.0396087281,
0.0266257469,
0.0340679474,
-0.0070114587,
-0.0101129124,
0.0640629455,
-0.0167949758,
-0.0477891192,
-0.0162366796,
0.0057154782,
0.0092812032,
-0.0397675596,
0.0032294316,
0.0289403815,
-0.053332109,
0.0271675698,
-0.0427301563,
-0.0790793151,
0.0228360761,
0.0406821594,
0.0229285043,
-0.0242019929,
-0.0326036885,
-0.0122257043,
-0.0168556664,
0.0522331744,
-0.0042776326,
0.0078601819,
-0.0413121022,
0.0265392847,
-0.003384003,
-0.0019317495,
0.0114045478,
-0.0172787625,
-0.0559691377,
-0.0686161891,
-0.038858436,
0.044590719,
0.0038052364,
0.0670923591,
-0.0348832496,
0.040747799,
0.0043587168,
0.0481876731,
-0.0220680926,
0.007161017,
0.0421702079,
-0.013933856,
-0.0133092059,
0.0395325311,
-0.0284747723,
0.0043278369,
0.0092190839,
0.0746238753,
-0.0089656077,
-0.0797456279,
-0.0067943097,
0.0156540424,
0.0445978828,
-0.0472781807,
0.0185440425,
-0.0288460348,
0.0163863357,
-0.029935386,
-0.0316605121,
-0.0113514392,
-0.0239018761,
0.0458917953,
-0.0052053966,
0.0095987646,
0.0174387991,
-0.0196999162,
-0.0105079766,
-0.0274678171,
-0.0042316313,
0.0029349846,
-0.014874368,
0.0104471622,
0.0296269972,
-0.0272203442,
0.0133938836,
0.0017560817,
0.0195111074,
-0.0368576907,
0.033556968,
-0.0003607297,
0.0226972532,
-0.0133936359,
0.0490415804,
0.0029428371,
0.0418124944,
-0.0088351676,
0.0134816403,
0.1076875031,
-0.0467361696,
0.08915966,
-0.0067146239,
-0.03501397,
0.0106577929,
0.0662601069,
-0.0246239975,
-0.0030796675,
0.0081315245,
-0.0108179208,
-0.0423107333,
-0.0036683711,
0.0496563017,
-0.035773769,
0.0117817568,
0.0060205073,
0.0080676647,
-0.0330195799,
-0.0039358358,
0.0355057418,
-0.0159886107,
-0.0374311581,
-0.0406445228,
-0.0249537732,
-0.0408331119,
0.0230131056,
0.0289819743,
-0.0514999069,
0.0382538252,
-0.0185295716,
0.0650902689,
-0.0413120389,
0.0136004183,
-0.0242449939,
-0.0188926719,
-0.0007996229,
-0.0246639214,
-0.0060889167,
-5.296473018e-33,
-0.0122533822,
0.033889804,
0.0074975775,
-0.0310418755,
-0.0279357806,
0.0003412295,
-0.003759372,
-0.0133181643,
-0.0380819403,
0.021313699,
0.0076237596,
-0.0480089411,
0.01577859,
0.0317287222,
0.0044244453,
0.0182706993,
0.0472590402,
0.017120041,
-0.0128698535,
-0.0352899022,
0.023567684,
0.0284896214,
0.0973086804,
-0.0110157598,
-0.0044321134,
-0.0182252694,
-0.0149881328,
0.0116446977,
0.0273030661,
0.044867333,
0.0008201837,
0.0039495071,
0.0208870769,
-0.0043183793,
-0.0131827574,
0.0416213684,
-0.085450463,
-0.0081112422,
0.0467169955,
0.0271388758,
-0.0164876822,
-0.0307364706,
0.0047433358,
-0.0542238615,
0.0307458676,
-0.0238866825,
0.0252856258,
-0.0193125624,
-0.0022153184,
-0.0154111311,
-0.0884847939,
0.0163694788,
-0.0049237465,
0.0014035541,
0.0545049086,
0.0469153225,
0.0218009632,
0.0441180542,
-0.0395347401,
-0.0076522767,
-0.0430171788,
0.0253091082,
0.0650938004,
0.0138990814,
-0.0066648135,
0.0334679484,
-0.0293452274,
-0.0250769854,
0.0368765593,
0.0299028438,
0.0051223524,
0.0272832662,
0.0248641241,
0.1009245291,
0.0086492579,
0.005088958,
-0.0764596015,
0.0298642516,
0.0095231254,
0.0019124008,
0.022176031,
0.0066246493,
0.0024614211,
0.0148430523,
-0.0051551233,
-0.0217545591,
-0.0158933084,
-0.0257600006,
0.0167508218,
0.0102730412,
-0.0032749132,
0.0185957085,
0.0496802367,
-0.0354198962,
-0.0058081443,
0.0139570367,
-0.0303506944,
-0.004275322,
-0.0350536034,
0.0466222987,
-0.0561846755,
-0.0457185023,
-0.0222860929,
0.0144566242,
0.01497526,
0.0223280042,
0.0741901472,
-0.0119997216,
-0.0772630423,
0.0268995166,
-0.0232385527,
-0.0126419729,
-0.0219039209,
0.0251499284,
0.0311854053,
0.0026459934,
-0.007271999,
0.0372894593,
0.0501965731,
-0.0239550844,
0.0016019905,
-0.0084844558,
-0.0017590919,
0.0242679864,
-0.0072866664,
0.014916339,
-0.0294674337,
0.0173986275,
0.0063130814,
-0.0549338683,
0.0112153022,
0.0062028668,
2.25e-7,
0.0536260493,
-0.0028400833,
0.0742483884,
-0.024758108,
-0.0149552962,
0.0150862783,
-0.0560711771,
0.0508943312,
-0.0295585729,
0.0232619978,
0.0293063167,
-0.0248500165,
0.0822004527,
0.01125417,
-0.0698465183,
0.0086164,
-0.0746816397,
-0.0020129869,
-0.0596170314,
0.0160169192,
0.0201594979,
0.1046673283,
0.0180359501,
0.0263121128,
-0.0376795009,
-0.0451656766,
0.0767097026,
-0.024934873,
-0.0647320449,
0.0260988008,
-0.0089594964,
-0.0103645427,
-0.0179342069,
-0.0045526717,
-0.0295424163,
0.0570516139,
0.0184827056,
0.0844007507,
-0.0021363758,
-0.01765709,
-0.0033294111,
0.0066673695,
-0.0344683565,
-0.0465584323,
0.0638412312,
-0.0330734961,
-0.0173872057,
-0.0306920111,
-0.0256898422,
0.0539660901,
0.0534988046,
-0.0179127231,
-0.0201128125,
0.0290149096,
0.0856768936,
0.0113525763,
-0.0598228388,
-0.0320718698,
-0.0524169728,
0.0256373752,
-0.0152486265,
-0.0211731438,
0.0116629917,
-0.0458794571,
0.0426644534,
-0.0428568013,
0.0019249087,
2.054206454e-34,
0.023626972,
-0.0120643433,
0.033484377,
0.0156595856,
0.0046343161,
-0.0597167984,
-0.0368947648,
0.0142995343,
-0.0121042849,
-0.0388121866,
-0.0065563433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12139v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12139v3 | Bipol: Multi-axes Evaluation of Bias with Explainability in Benchmark Datasets | 2023-01-28T09:28:19 | 2023-09-16T15:56:11 | Tosin Adewumi, Isabella Södergren, Lama Alkhaled, Sana Sabah Sabry, Foteini Liwicki, Marcus Liwicki | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate five English NLP benchmark datasets (on the superGLUE
leaderboard) and two Swedish datasets for bias, along multiple axes. The
datasets are the following: Boolean Question (Boolq), CommitmentBank (CB),
Winograd Schema Challenge (WSC), Wino-gender diagnostic (AXg), Recognising
Textual Entailment (RTE), Swedish CB, and SWEDN. Bias can be harmful and it is
known to be common in data, which ML models learn from. In order to mitigate
bias in data, it is crucial to be able to estimate it objectively. We use
bipol, a novel multi-axes bias metric with explainability, to estimate and
explain how much bias exists in these datasets. Multilingual, multi-axes bias
evaluation is not very common. Hence, we also contribute a new, large Swedish
bias-labelled dataset (of 2 million samples), translated from the English
version and train the SotA mT5 model on it. In addition, we contribute new
multi-axes lexica for bias detection in Swedish. We make the codes, model, and
new dataset publicly available. | [
0.0171648972,
0.0644404069,
-0.0344986729,
0.0612740368,
-0.0197517239,
0.0402418822,
0.0316227749,
-0.033849068,
0.0314947441,
-0.0311850403,
0.0071585225,
0.0185742844,
0.0126788225,
0.028030809,
0.0110848285,
-0.0445870869,
0.057795655,
0.0272109751,
0.0489601977,
-0.0216897149,
0.0245496742,
0.0306793749,
-0.0337591916,
0.0429327153,
-0.0283447392,
0.0006844475,
0.037094254,
0.0003116926,
0.0162335522,
-0.0186658204,
0.0099449093,
0.0546257421,
-0.0423975065,
0.0232351441,
0.0000019847,
-0.0759845152,
-0.0204049312,
-0.0055112494,
-0.0291730706,
-0.0221487712,
0.0347603187,
-0.0135362083,
0.0142204771,
0.0104052806,
-0.0142138842,
0.0013259184,
0.0753279328,
0.042558156,
0.0799948052,
0.0329595096,
-0.007472204,
-0.0382429175,
-0.0296195969,
0.0008089312,
-0.0008097793,
-0.0343961008,
0.0069105797,
0.0071869907,
-0.0679865032,
-0.0136774015,
-0.0469572656,
-0.0021317806,
0.0085730869,
0.0217793267,
-0.0021956302,
0.0046229614,
-0.023197826,
-0.056132935,
0.0283502545,
0.0781182349,
-0.0092756879,
-0.0399646014,
0.0085027777,
-0.0334423184,
0.0389142856,
0.0179059748,
-0.0224911794,
0.0117731169,
-0.0007224148,
0.0068354784,
0.0699736848,
-0.0026860817,
0.0223130863,
0.0232895147,
-0.0078049279,
0.0678758249,
-0.0100945709,
-0.0155235678,
0.0567335598,
0.0212458558,
0.0038242482,
-0.0254006367,
-0.0118003786,
-0.0161969382,
-0.0313277915,
0.0115192961,
0.0141526088,
-0.0323297717,
0.0329796039,
-0.0526975803,
0.0122880377,
-0.0077317543,
-0.0468381122,
0.0257032197,
-0.0160434712,
0.0374103524,
0.0050267545,
-0.0000049035,
-0.0621188171,
-0.0494401716,
-0.0195099544,
-0.0035639883,
-0.0123853721,
-0.0251214411,
-0.0131191975,
0.0418867096,
-0.0386883095,
-0.0347253978,
-0.0753979683,
0.0086814929,
0.0107503431,
-0.0232867058,
-0.008935323,
0.0139571279,
-0.0264589638,
0.0519218035,
-0.0613375455,
0.0237505101,
-0.0546026714,
-0.0714808106,
-0.0012485413,
0.0230138768,
0.0051189573,
-0.0496903546,
0.0268381741,
0.0307678245,
0.0420907661,
-0.0137093244,
-0.0016641798,
-0.0519037358,
-0.0257089864,
-0.0659729242,
-0.0008823874,
-0.0289720837,
0.0258204453,
0.010490288,
-0.0048761871,
-0.0257806592,
-0.0175660364,
0.0033246402,
-0.0480228476,
0.0523164533,
0.006484692,
-0.0072153825,
-0.0128875906,
-0.0222606305,
-0.0217870902,
0.0831465647,
-0.0105549665,
-0.008843489,
0.0790465623,
-0.0280287005,
0.0103454012,
0.0215854086,
0.0691754818,
0.0276967585,
-0.0066378596,
0.0244842302,
-0.0071891602,
0.0053009447,
0.0524532571,
-0.0128348209,
-0.0112110702,
0.0151694827,
0.0351405405,
0.0120248599,
0.0285498612,
-0.0218510013,
-0.0076528196,
-0.0232143924,
-0.0276477933,
-0.0077953204,
-0.0527750514,
0.0264252424,
0.0117399683,
0.0067597153,
-0.0109913917,
0.0255947653,
0.0144163445,
-0.0615633689,
-0.0193744153,
0.0297994092,
-0.0336598307,
0.0198048204,
0.0039357222,
0.0156209078,
0.0087332381,
0.0935227647,
0.0189106166,
-0.0367857032,
0.0272098258,
-0.026729526,
0.0238672514,
-0.026754437,
-0.0204869919,
-0.0392065756,
-0.0224322341,
-0.04323598,
-0.0124296201,
0.0280077998,
0.0551712401,
-0.0186815839,
0.0190312341,
-0.0259071756,
-0.0335793309,
0.0218232237,
0.0473838821,
-0.0050651757,
-0.0095640058,
0.0159621146,
-0.0196607113,
-0.0779378489,
-0.044449944,
0.0591934547,
0.0032201293,
-0.0182119664,
0.0062144119,
0.009118638,
0.0683114827,
0.0454606749,
-0.0185135398,
-0.0023410507,
0.0302557535,
-0.0186590273,
-0.0110763144,
0.0414325446,
-0.0146904085,
-0.0504215993,
0.025673056,
-0.0879043266,
-0.0530752577,
0.0441959389,
-0.0529503785,
-0.0254632067,
0.0123741515,
0.0049260007,
-0.006455217,
-0.0025058112,
-0.0317561813,
-0.0221645031,
0.0365262032,
-0.0491659567,
0.0302356817,
-0.0269260965,
0.0527433716,
-0.0209095068,
-0.0577150546,
0.0550180711,
-0.0060508498,
-0.0012126593,
0.0563503578,
-0.0189151708,
-0.0038304199,
0.0358577408,
-0.0137750544,
-0.0415156111,
-0.0149446642,
-0.0489358343,
0.0079567032,
-0.0216323212,
0.0035756191,
0.0437785089,
-0.0015646077,
-0.0131844534,
-0.0339748934,
-0.0553183481,
-0.0169968512,
0.0157994647,
0.0393264703,
0.0454330482,
-0.0234277006,
0.0061899219,
-0.0169478655,
-0.0274882782,
-0.0405343845,
0.0767877772,
0.0372768678,
0.0044030822,
-0.0320297964,
-0.0245324504,
-0.0308469739,
-0.0247082766,
0.0032480853,
-0.0173604954,
0.0055989795,
0.0228411313,
-0.01939255,
0.060086228,
-0.0169440713,
-0.0277290456,
0.0388361961,
0.0212636776,
-0.0387462154,
-0.0118061788,
-0.0369668268,
0.0050269272,
0.0020206207,
-0.0621244125,
0.0313090794,
0.0296326522,
0.0342177898,
-0.0380572453,
-0.0230781864,
0.0345349163,
-0.0311074294,
-0.0178395659,
-0.034954004,
-0.0190004688,
0.0009577363,
0.0828664154,
-0.0434063189,
-0.0498576798,
0.0195369087,
0.0003679377,
-0.004438913,
-0.0629360154,
0.014032186,
-0.0591273233,
0.0635870919,
-0.0109288907,
0.0280839689,
0.0154519761,
-0.0192758851,
-0.0300457161,
-0.0657177866,
0.0509650186,
-0.0200843513,
-0.0090485262,
-0.0346842334,
-0.0086328397,
-0.0127089825,
-0.0198080428,
-0.0097510321,
-0.0336543769,
-0.0291653797,
-0.0088261804,
0.0059643444,
0.0060980129,
-0.0130639076,
-0.0299126878,
0.0072613694,
0.0161675401,
-0.0124836713,
0.0144179231,
0.0010367634,
-0.0011310597,
0.0397240818,
0.044231642,
0.038455192,
-0.0079681044,
-0.0067708702,
-0.0000424775,
-0.02552885,
0.0484203845,
-0.0100074336,
0.0268896576,
0.0259507131,
-0.0518604629,
-0.0178174041,
-0.0248276461,
0.0302473996,
-0.0211872067,
0.0270468257,
0.0770739615,
0.000411514,
-0.0215745028,
0.0326846428,
-0.0060962541,
0.0363880768,
0.0508289821,
-0.0052988161,
-0.0882924125,
-0.0336327255,
0.0310206059,
0.0021725791,
-0.0093876459,
-0.0539807677,
-0.0297426153,
-0.1186511219,
0.0193724912,
-0.0163136926,
-0.0481208339,
-0.0352308005,
-0.0771872029,
-0.0200566389,
-0.1054736078,
0.0183533579,
-0.0119307097,
0.0294214748,
0.0611002073,
0.0032707718,
-0.0584607907,
-0.0359041616,
0.034351632,
-0.0430285484,
0.0365316495,
0.0043546902,
0.0705806166,
-0.041402813,
0.0093175443,
0.0665602759,
-0.0287116487,
-0.0506055877,
-0.0400065035,
0.1155001298,
-0.0309863649,
-0.0242131837,
-0.0511140265,
0.0770267844,
-0.0100355791,
0.013960571,
0.0034340895,
0.0798457712,
0.0604997873,
-0.0267972555,
-0.0179886594,
-0.0081146806,
0.0070682894,
0.0832055435,
0.0236103348,
-0.0136396093,
-0.0279369596,
-0.0272548068,
-0.0022766073,
0.0121395299,
-0.0448551439,
0.0245266687,
0.0119550154,
0.0042531411,
-0.0456202999,
-0.0441930033,
-0.0016864493,
0.0478671044,
-0.0004157119,
0.0200921185,
-0.0339523256,
-0.0282915123,
-0.021091979,
0.0266087521,
0.0047484227,
0.0171915125,
0.0191587452,
0.0201918539,
0.0050510396,
-0.0239798222,
-0.0429101065,
0.011828878,
0.0050836517,
-0.0297989119,
0.0354816392,
0.0121807586,
0.0281194169,
0.0517841205,
0.0056858705,
-0.0471149534,
0.0060750409,
0.0507613979,
-0.0306046139,
0.002032201,
0.038676437,
-0.0024069417,
0.0235201325,
0.0232614931,
-0.0307586491,
0.0387999117,
0.0160460807,
0.0072891545,
0.0013142141,
-0.0177441426,
0.0169068519,
0.0515565872,
0.0562447421,
-0.0386216529,
-0.0063671977,
-0.0787851065,
-0.0179957952,
0.0167947989,
-0.0586533733,
0.0028295484,
0.0188058373,
0.0260694921,
-0.0414956138,
-0.0220276453,
-0.0313704908,
-0.0569098182,
-0.0155801913,
-0.018259,
0.0476495475,
0.0427547023,
0.0286414232,
-0.0367690027,
0.0281275958,
-0.0144267539,
0.0081597315,
-0.0160301421,
0.060503535,
0.0189333223,
0.0200778805,
0.0341107622,
0.0082508959,
0.018569665,
-0.0108589884,
-0.0655271187,
0.012060307,
0.0229550432,
-0.0612688586,
0.0622514822,
-0.0549947321,
0.0890976787,
0.0116909984,
0.0000877771,
0.0179721955,
0.0597673431,
0.0194436237,
-0.0200722031,
0.0279845763,
-0.0090109399,
-0.044477053,
0.0147792315,
0.0329050981,
0.0159537867,
0.0568831414,
0.0027031042,
-0.0054869624,
-0.0538403131,
-0.0058135204,
0.0305431038,
-0.0068837185,
-0.0185858514,
-0.0058266292,
-0.0936910212,
-0.0531100482,
-0.0168898664,
0.001632725,
0.0150406985,
-0.0059146672,
-0.013999748,
0.0600489378,
0.0071839984,
-0.0602994971,
-0.04859972,
0.0117458403,
-0.042139817,
0.014699311,
-0.0106517645,
-6.106871681e-33,
-0.0029136941,
-0.0449084304,
-0.0306614824,
-0.0260786954,
0.0059589567,
0.0267509054,
0.0098578474,
-0.0169433746,
-0.0779922754,
0.0401464552,
0.0163048226,
0.0079561966,
0.0143016027,
-0.0247211847,
-0.0098676234,
-0.027791854,
0.0307196751,
0.0134073878,
-0.0238866322,
-0.0054919594,
0.0242170636,
0.0144996336,
0.0920525789,
-0.0621208176,
0.1051230505,
0.0203476362,
-0.0355991945,
0.032117866,
-0.0265661068,
0.0374531485,
-0.0050431723,
0.0662362128,
0.0505504422,
-0.0411393046,
0.0012568348,
-0.0077375774,
-0.0511152893,
-0.0624652207,
0.0414571017,
0.0674349591,
0.0317153111,
0.0053717522,
0.0383542404,
0.0010466013,
-0.0632736832,
-0.0372378156,
0.0611713789,
-0.0163470935,
0.0057251444,
0.0452730581,
-0.0111020869,
0.0316009261,
-0.0442142822,
0.0276307203,
0.0046710153,
0.0641226843,
0.0036793242,
0.0300682951,
-0.0303121414,
0.0210656691,
0.0058740401,
-0.0105644865,
0.0283938739,
-0.031980928,
0.0041104127,
0.0752745792,
0.0742998794,
0.016886998,
0.0052717929,
-0.0233607851,
0.0356179439,
0.0099826939,
0.1024285033,
0.0876658037,
0.0657940507,
0.0264509693,
-0.0839471593,
-0.0052640196,
0.0223616604,
0.0484802946,
0.0172196794,
-0.0380108878,
-0.0647604242,
-0.0362640321,
-0.0837085471,
-0.1033100709,
-0.0227357354,
0.0195397306,
0.0448870957,
-0.0291402526,
-0.0167339277,
0.0307312477,
0.0147858001,
-0.0404365957,
-0.0002567355,
0.045837041,
-0.0101390742,
-0.0107586142,
0.0169009063,
0.0057403212,
-0.0578266643,
-0.0076771444,
-0.0208154283,
0.0620296523,
0.0595984496,
-0.0106934318,
0.0445770696,
-0.012764792,
-0.0572553948,
0.0069602611,
-0.0258198231,
-0.0143666333,
-0.0229624268,
0.0231391266,
0.0506027229,
-0.0080632456,
-0.0250103325,
0.0242688432,
0.0553254709,
0.0219329149,
-0.0164784677,
-0.0169762075,
-0.0446521305,
0.0389183424,
-0.0188085679,
-0.0192345064,
0.0083986884,
-0.0264563132,
0.0330168791,
-0.0345009081,
-0.0096139777,
-0.0414195731,
2.612e-7,
0.033075083,
0.0411481708,
0.0002983849,
0.0052782632,
-0.0028483828,
0.0432107374,
-0.0134790558,
0.022883229,
-0.0094165681,
0.0058236662,
-0.0266020894,
-0.0093828999,
0.0082295295,
0.0273547992,
-0.0500343889,
-0.0030072539,
-0.0557781495,
0.0291237291,
-0.0474424511,
0.0398609452,
0.0690461919,
0.077078484,
0.0209410153,
0.0044960808,
-0.0108838519,
-0.0025237706,
0.0082783541,
-0.0455377102,
0.0297296941,
0.0144697214,
0.0243219435,
-0.0073075597,
0.0469990633,
0.0283598062,
-0.0036858595,
0.0150304381,
-0.0039629117,
0.0394400433,
-0.0020123729,
0.0115221301,
-0.0021837163,
-0.013491,
-0.0082854079,
-0.1078533307,
0.0767055824,
0.0104178144,
-0.0811886713,
-0.0778061524,
-0.0756576881,
0.0064163059,
0.0751701593,
-0.0127912303,
-0.0158631168,
0.0095159747,
0.0240088664,
-0.0124771176,
-0.0182264019,
-0.0261370782,
-0.0667989329,
0.0092930105,
0.0305737965,
-0.0287536252,
0.0161264408,
0.0523851514,
0.0283363611,
-0.0565023087,
0.011036762,
2.472433798e-34,
0.029997088,
-0.0134431729,
0.034751799,
-0.033195544,
0.0510504842,
-0.0163879916,
0.0225939564,
0.0131327622,
0.0353863798,
-0.0230711065,
0.0071473932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12134v1 | Underwater Robotics Semantic Parser Assistant | 2023-01-28T09:04:43 | 2023-01-28T09:04:43 | Parth Parekh, Cedric McGuire, Jake Imyak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; C.3 | Semantic parsing is a means of taking natural language and putting it in a
form that a computer can understand. There has been a multitude of approaches
that take natural language utterances and form them into lambda calculus
expressions -- mathematical functions to describe logic. Here, we experiment
with a sequence to sequence model to take natural language utterances, convert
those to lambda calculus expressions, when can then be parsed, and place them
in an XML format that can be used by a finite state machine. Experimental
results show that we can have a high accuracy model such that we can bridge the
gap between technical and nontechnical individuals in the robotics field. | [
-0.0002579065,
0.0124854259,
-0.0387146585,
-0.0380250774,
-0.0285319705,
0.0038550466,
0.0030810281,
-0.0255443249,
-0.0270951912,
-0.0867665559,
-0.0011494972,
0.0455054194,
0.0420051329,
0.0498608761,
-0.0135810785,
-0.0715073347,
0.0805155858,
-0.0194859393,
0.0014776631,
0.0134273376,
-0.0183425564,
0.0086277965,
-0.0203947388,
0.0300385635,
0.0368131474,
-0.0086514167,
-0.0449501686,
-0.0316419639,
-0.0316145122,
-0.0500833057,
-0.022472756,
-0.0260267407,
0.0550536439,
0.0146460598,
0.0000019932,
-0.0544861257,
-0.0265369806,
0.0175295267,
0.0075748172,
-0.0052973945,
-0.0137886582,
-0.0066573969,
0.0286873989,
0.0006849287,
-0.0430994555,
0.0170618538,
0.0397957526,
-0.0422068574,
0.0964218751,
0.0617873445,
-0.0176852718,
-0.0597123243,
-0.0353639275,
0.0480375849,
0.0028994284,
-0.0994134098,
0.0316577107,
0.051861167,
0.0811818168,
-0.0594418757,
-0.0108978394,
0.0314188823,
-0.0003139121,
0.0020483606,
-0.0499802344,
0.0310571473,
0.0327044502,
-0.0336282365,
-0.0336949863,
-0.005512266,
0.0489689671,
0.0152191566,
0.0303377267,
0.0111464458,
-0.0078295236,
0.0049997675,
-0.0305572953,
0.0425881855,
-0.0157335531,
0.00421798,
0.0000773349,
-0.0119886566,
-0.0101202764,
0.0023315761,
-0.0865374133,
0.1419503093,
0.0011029782,
-0.0069179204,
-0.0650485158,
-0.0148224318,
0.0075941724,
-0.0498818494,
0.0757280737,
0.0661126077,
0.0053956192,
0.0112572052,
-0.0616970807,
-0.0599702783,
-0.0275179353,
-0.0386734121,
0.0154382344,
0.0291359611,
0.0249144733,
0.0246976018,
0.0170477349,
0.0387560762,
0.0303846896,
0.0165167861,
-0.030061977,
0.0135882376,
-0.0682123676,
-0.0174652748,
-0.0488256812,
0.0504897274,
-0.0116626211,
0.009715342,
0.0168102086,
0.0183422547,
0.0378115959,
-0.0316277258,
-0.0509126522,
-0.0322265774,
-0.02974624,
0.0468132608,
-0.0384859107,
-0.0178947356,
0.0285396669,
0.0323288254,
0.0032557708,
-0.0232327674,
0.0352339633,
0.0001745822,
-0.0009376111,
-0.021124633,
-0.0335127525,
0.1038732827,
0.0077360291,
-0.017892506,
-0.0188979115,
-0.0239690114,
0.0448748395,
-0.0151544753,
-0.0139976321,
-0.0366971865,
0.059083011,
-0.028321119,
-0.0223137438,
-0.0443397276,
0.0108427154,
-0.009871345,
0.0478640832,
0.0528199635,
-0.048329059,
0.0080338484,
0.0185815431,
-0.0097091142,
0.0090391217,
0.0180024933,
0.0751131848,
-0.023983866,
0.002319786,
-0.0323072858,
-0.0415624343,
0.0074967537,
-0.0621277727,
-0.0470635593,
-0.0266012475,
0.0186972953,
-0.0010985904,
0.0355331227,
0.0039761071,
0.0048162877,
0.0017136609,
0.0298758913,
-0.0087774536,
0.0533363782,
-0.0253331494,
0.0598967336,
0.0711582452,
0.0440822244,
0.0254184492,
-0.0079660602,
-0.0162570737,
-0.0155062415,
0.0283135306,
0.0078385584,
-0.041259855,
0.0316179134,
-0.0097276866,
-0.0652258322,
-0.0057488615,
0.0085326377,
0.0147643862,
-0.0440060534,
0.0076760873,
0.0002707934,
-0.0141855692,
0.0457567871,
-0.0194716007,
-0.0271820296,
0.0079798326,
-0.0341678411,
0.040631216,
0.0461235233,
0.0101532266,
-0.0601167977,
-0.0466011167,
0.0015287072,
-0.0217275769,
0.0662724301,
-0.0132831428,
0.0123301446,
-0.006490611,
-0.0246626753,
-0.0248656888,
0.0631781965,
0.0131960521,
0.0361089595,
-0.0147977183,
0.0233148374,
0.022972757,
-0.018450411,
-0.0303803869,
0.0675534084,
0.0428895243,
0.0243748482,
-0.0071240524,
-0.022290919,
0.0372625254,
0.0072098947,
0.0193190277,
0.0272312816,
0.0092333825,
-0.0129209897,
-0.0690038577,
0.0323733687,
-0.0066812476,
0.020209983,
0.0342512503,
-0.0643081218,
-0.0180976931,
0.0551165007,
-0.0424865857,
-0.0420960523,
-0.0155738583,
-0.0311907232,
0.0466495939,
0.0336602628,
0.0128638269,
0.0453584604,
0.0021188904,
0.020000929,
0.0050474638,
0.018459361,
0.0126957567,
-0.0639914051,
-0.0313357376,
-0.007676343,
-0.0642735809,
-0.0040959814,
-0.0151043739,
-0.0409530774,
-0.008506042,
0.033707764,
0.0242004301,
-0.0009507384,
0.0510262474,
-0.0255241618,
-0.0032673334,
0.023971267,
0.0375227705,
0.0022920929,
-0.0215428807,
0.0228642263,
0.0198297035,
-0.0180301145,
-0.0067865355,
-0.0255933106,
-0.0112172198,
0.0269966796,
0.0012150266,
-0.060583923,
-0.0477731191,
-0.0186867286,
-0.0578604341,
0.0218665823,
0.0774290934,
-0.0607074536,
-0.0829427242,
0.0495861359,
-0.0636601076,
-0.0046324134,
0.0087696686,
-0.0064859116,
0.0320939124,
-0.0371138267,
-0.0524527766,
0.0256454479,
0.0172562115,
-0.0241143014,
0.0514744632,
-0.0072764605,
-0.0326733105,
0.0157334302,
-0.0332941934,
0.0037798518,
-0.0412611105,
0.0171761885,
0.0172333922,
0.0195758734,
-0.032376837,
0.0388023108,
-0.0178013891,
-0.0059068426,
-0.0250458661,
-0.0207352825,
0.0060519245,
-0.0034603244,
-0.0386939049,
0.0533758923,
0.0082866708,
-0.0047353217,
0.0149858855,
-0.0042779474,
0.0022308661,
-0.0592735372,
0.0054111895,
-0.0159772914,
0.0597379133,
-0.0109812664,
0.0053780689,
0.0321129635,
-0.0550801046,
0.0418306515,
-0.0446708873,
0.0199815407,
-0.0067105177,
0.0238360986,
-0.055828616,
0.0649263933,
-0.0049262242,
-0.0129949115,
-0.0444214456,
0.0416372493,
-0.032838542,
0.0452842228,
-0.0131393867,
-0.04127644,
-0.0304669291,
-0.0241698474,
0.0348000862,
-0.0067459927,
0.0073965224,
-0.0027670416,
-0.0531829149,
0.014159021,
0.0061414475,
0.0240926445,
-0.011965272,
0.0570587181,
0.013100381,
0.0085760793,
0.0256520174,
-0.0114144282,
-0.0441343598,
-0.0181709845,
-0.0034590985,
-0.0461633019,
-0.0085250186,
0.0463093296,
0.0024793092,
-0.0615499392,
-0.0186069682,
0.0313455984,
0.0318368077,
0.0262440071,
0.0233908035,
0.0107946936,
-0.0570318699,
0.036979951,
0.0222992115,
-0.0332326852,
-0.0245160926,
-0.0045074448,
0.0358228683,
0.0142110828,
-0.0201690961,
-0.0177106876,
-0.0590876043,
0.0324821435,
0.0121506536,
-0.059253823,
-0.0402452089,
-0.085105896,
0.0101754796,
-0.0142171513,
-0.0186693873,
0.0382074714,
0.0239566024,
0.0289512053,
0.008582579,
-0.0199769437,
-0.0077055441,
0.0385009535,
0.00126123,
-0.0234450586,
0.0937177762,
0.0649334788,
-0.0524518155,
-0.0184691865,
0.0180001035,
-0.0060167252,
0.0254901834,
-0.0188022982,
-0.1110280901,
-0.0083964495,
-0.0064486144,
-0.016676832,
0.0088133402,
-0.0302552059,
0.0224646479,
0.0200556647,
0.0754492953,
-0.032883428,
0.0374271683,
-0.0341754705,
-0.0367050581,
0.0070218933,
0.0213577729,
-0.0140975229,
0.0142816631,
-0.0518351495,
-0.0507905819,
-0.0587062947,
-0.0061506876,
-0.0495848246,
-0.0088790292,
-0.0399734005,
-0.0563149154,
-0.1091372594,
0.0066632777,
0.0321764462,
0.0225170143,
0.0428023711,
-0.0220290758,
0.06596829,
0.0277766865,
-0.030891303,
-0.0002466102,
-0.0456840359,
0.0528788306,
0.0084379874,
0.0057984428,
0.0269025024,
0.003077158,
-0.0442004651,
0.0597788543,
0.0313198902,
-0.0492997356,
0.0710379928,
0.0573916025,
0.019051889,
-0.0757539198,
-0.0152515769,
0.0480580553,
-0.0080471784,
0.0769758895,
-0.0467065051,
0.011607199,
0.0486534499,
0.087519303,
0.0005250321,
-0.0009237215,
-0.031405367,
-0.0140404319,
-0.0705547035,
0.0621307231,
-0.0522229522,
-0.0620727651,
0.04958928,
0.0643263906,
0.0443869084,
0.041821152,
-0.0218261518,
0.0506029725,
-0.0218237955,
-0.0178360902,
0.0031327819,
-0.0261391606,
0.0565790236,
-0.0400912128,
0.0195439607,
0.0361705422,
0.0197521094,
-0.0213522874,
-0.0192153789,
0.0348157957,
0.0663516521,
0.04314873,
-0.0141480416,
-0.023621168,
-0.0279995035,
-0.0216842797,
0.0154902991,
-0.0356492512,
0.0139956903,
-0.0147333974,
0.0225515347,
0.0251024682,
0.0226816069,
-0.0286587961,
-0.003404781,
-0.0403526351,
-0.0775400847,
0.0477389321,
-0.0076795858,
0.0469735973,
0.0534959435,
-0.0149546163,
-0.0490787663,
0.023867961,
-0.0011558409,
0.0459138975,
0.0041096448,
-0.0252851993,
0.047754921,
0.0380772948,
-0.0150609976,
-0.0419837832,
0.0078452202,
-0.0123683698,
0.0528577231,
0.0267569646,
-0.0105647873,
-0.0362455808,
-0.0538516082,
0.0033254609,
0.0749346539,
-0.0205395054,
-0.0508644618,
-0.025904296,
-0.0212080404,
0.0126196183,
0.0458146483,
0.036396727,
0.0000641554,
0.0694039091,
0.0235300716,
-0.0202472154,
-0.0352707133,
-0.0086946534,
0.001549544,
-0.0303155947,
-0.0130207539,
-0.0394451842,
-5.260080081e-33,
-0.0423575342,
-0.0258510727,
0.0096443258,
0.0521432348,
-0.0178023428,
-0.0682590753,
-0.0180300903,
0.0233325344,
0.0334680416,
-0.0126125012,
0.002635828,
0.0145527637,
0.0145807397,
-0.0214267671,
0.01761082,
0.0062580374,
0.0405920111,
-0.0298145954,
0.0046759192,
-0.061161235,
0.0614379682,
0.0156763531,
0.0352472924,
-0.0124597847,
-0.0192413013,
0.0073443917,
-0.0159052052,
0.0212335177,
-0.0156121384,
0.0026247306,
-0.000295597,
0.0073493472,
-0.0203021541,
0.0022554549,
-0.0579577349,
-0.0235383473,
-0.0479072072,
0.0027693345,
0.0257518608,
0.0181239843,
-0.0188629292,
-0.0230591483,
0.0406269282,
-0.0207225773,
-0.0006900785,
0.0049003316,
0.0388684459,
0.002762259,
0.0040237452,
0.0008440751,
-0.0684703588,
0.0353940018,
-0.0246182624,
-0.0360783823,
0.0500418991,
0.0105325831,
-0.0118034203,
-0.062042769,
0.022387797,
0.0190940425,
-0.0357861258,
0.0518429615,
0.0179398153,
-0.0220524985,
0.0370243005,
0.0117228189,
0.0156863052,
-0.0474633016,
-0.0131830592,
0.0656580627,
0.0028631974,
0.051286187,
0.0226305798,
0.0051672147,
0.0263284072,
0.016185388,
0.0016109697,
0.0186777525,
-0.0184116717,
0.0825016201,
0.0068571689,
0.0249999259,
-0.0339879952,
0.0407756455,
0.0060016261,
-0.0256063528,
0.0346570797,
0.0109228194,
0.0174152739,
-0.029854212,
-0.0481595509,
-0.0011513175,
0.0324129425,
-0.0004899249,
-0.0045509525,
-0.0237118732,
0.0273538902,
-0.0220409855,
-0.0138804317,
0.0009615003,
-0.0202316865,
-0.0357694775,
0.0131216059,
-0.0383702628,
0.071623452,
-0.0089779831,
-0.0640155226,
0.0460921675,
-0.0075019696,
-0.0029392403,
-0.0273091551,
-0.0307910684,
-0.0243625715,
0.0340816192,
0.055332005,
0.0238597989,
-0.0168913566,
0.0051601012,
-0.0338105336,
-0.0850403011,
-0.0296202339,
0.0058676139,
-0.0347561054,
0.0488591678,
-0.0486190617,
-0.0329447538,
-0.0488557927,
0.0599972159,
-0.0094152987,
-0.0039502084,
-0.0136611676,
0.0795396864,
2.736e-7,
-0.0167173445,
-0.0059794118,
0.0571490228,
0.0626557842,
0.0231368542,
0.0324616358,
0.0109471893,
-0.0020285011,
-0.0445605963,
-0.0307098627,
-0.0153662264,
0.0142830815,
-0.0116163585,
0.0158919469,
-0.0520751067,
-0.0200830996,
0.0419999436,
-0.0369460471,
-0.04189891,
0.0011508156,
0.1099869162,
0.0593362153,
0.0435997806,
-0.0050808336,
-0.0258684382,
-0.0422043055,
-0.0188370291,
0.0356009342,
0.0727567226,
-0.0095109697,
-0.0285709258,
0.0152306585,
-0.0148879718,
0.0033092487,
0.0009861186,
0.0059814863,
0.0300174113,
0.0752360672,
-0.011274565,
-0.0025181654,
-0.0042412058,
0.0422809124,
-0.032198742,
-0.0073858704,
-0.0010733826,
-0.0668837056,
0.011817106,
-0.0358878076,
-0.0610090047,
0.0132879317,
-0.0701940656,
0.0281152669,
0.0034151266,
-0.0065914234,
-0.0117245065,
0.0098184301,
-0.0035084118,
-0.0357592851,
0.009042155,
-0.0294222385,
-0.0533360168,
-0.0103171123,
-0.0286203586,
0.0577717237,
0.0317980349,
-0.039553687,
-0.0207925159,
2.116605e-34,
-0.0175655894,
-0.0273918509,
0.0088280989,
0.0917318687,
0.0175609868,
0.0270790067,
-0.0398738831,
0.0252323374,
0.0249460787,
-0.0500150286,
-0.0174834821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.12132v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.12132v3 | AutoPEFT: Automatic Configuration Search for Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning | 2023-01-28T08:51:23 | 2024-01-29T10:41:51 | Han Zhou, Xingchen Wan, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large pretrained language models are widely used in downstream NLP tasks via
task-specific fine-tuning, but such procedures can be costly. Recently,
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) methods have achieved strong task
performance while updating much fewer parameters than full model fine-tuning
(FFT). However, it is non-trivial to make informed design choices on the PEFT
configurations, such as their architecture, the number of tunable parameters,
and even the layers in which the PEFT modules are inserted. Consequently, it is
highly likely that the current, manually designed configurations are suboptimal
in terms of their performance-efficiency trade-off. Inspired by advances in
neural architecture search, we propose AutoPEFT for automatic PEFT
configuration selection: we first design an expressive configuration search
space with multiple representative PEFT modules as building blocks. Using
multi-objective Bayesian optimisation in a low-cost setup, we then discover a
Pareto-optimal set of configurations with strong performance-cost trade-offs
across different numbers of parameters that are also highly transferable across
different tasks. Empirically, on GLUE and SuperGLUE tasks, we show that
AutoPEFT-discovered configurations significantly outperform existing PEFT
methods and are on par or better than FFT without incurring substantial
training efficiency costs. | [
0.0298119914,
0.0599352382,
-0.0033992329,
0.0175652634,
-0.0316332877,
-0.0173585061,
0.0214282423,
-0.0193078462,
-0.0635317415,
-0.0343924798,
-0.0711696446,
-0.0118083237,
0.0310436692,
0.0006715584,
0.0441712514,
-0.0235913098,
0.0185067449,
-0.0071425424,
-0.0042586294,
0.0175842047,
-0.0025007839,
0.0166814458,
-0.0435607694,
0.0558773689,
-0.0179548692,
0.0286609009,
-0.0237419549,
0.0457585193,
0.0283314027,
0.0244119,
0.0473128967,
0.0910060331,
-0.0077391779,
-0.0008289394,
0.0000021017,
-0.012467253,
-0.0279775746,
-0.000919025,
-0.0214456785,
0.0373508893,
0.0442591831,
0.0252614599,
-0.0326763839,
0.0278406236,
-0.0194176398,
-0.0513640717,
0.0686866939,
0.0562489927,
0.0512714349,
0.0986211374,
-0.0111515634,
-0.0172861405,
-0.0063429205,
-0.0572179407,
-0.0508936979,
-0.0462037921,
-0.0066066789,
-0.0686231107,
-0.0060030431,
0.0138936508,
-0.0233827867,
0.0298206042,
0.005275772,
0.025635045,
0.0334411114,
-0.0060358602,
-0.0617444366,
-0.0561021455,
-0.0120088821,
0.0759721845,
-0.0954753086,
-0.0209777858,
0.0110675609,
-0.0499816053,
-0.0428443439,
-0.0002067547,
-0.0352464654,
-0.003135568,
0.0320629552,
0.0045017311,
0.0266046356,
-0.0343846343,
0.0486282483,
0.0074770376,
-0.0087180948,
0.0424459614,
0.0253117792,
0.0085255215,
0.0346235894,
-0.0298183784,
-0.0738636702,
-0.0274416842,
-0.0239135828,
-0.0117797814,
-0.0475319438,
-0.002115926,
-0.0522950925,
-0.0378109217,
-0.0019297739,
0.0097962338,
0.0795138925,
0.0459473245,
0.0006566559,
0.029009264,
-0.0480387174,
-0.0050682034,
-0.0298046395,
0.0145909162,
-0.0582147278,
-0.008972263,
-0.0282561202,
0.0029744406,
-0.0629351735,
0.0041074706,
-0.0614989288,
-0.0570796616,
-0.0205753632,
-0.0195630472,
-0.0016692771,
-0.0231535677,
0.0298192538,
0.0153947677,
-0.0363051295,
0.0010180618,
0.0152833248,
0.0399996117,
-0.0424083471,
0.0129161747,
-0.0082211336,
-0.0230976902,
-0.0237711668,
0.0348314345,
0.0155706825,
-0.0398251601,
0.0476612709,
0.0653474852,
0.0058987057,
-0.0518181436,
-0.0338512138,
-0.0055434201,
-0.0219554137,
-0.0665772855,
0.0218235031,
-0.0218932964,
0.0250255931,
-0.0295543615,
0.0119312657,
-0.0498615764,
-0.0041345796,
0.0035076148,
-0.0363151468,
0.073576957,
0.0020913209,
0.0144338766,
0.0127966423,
-0.0242364127,
-0.010486789,
0.0981166437,
0.0241784845,
0.0521753691,
0.0364930108,
-0.026818553,
-0.0251946691,
0.0490809642,
-0.0014156176,
-0.0061344365,
0.0025828469,
-0.0195751619,
0.0390224531,
0.038417127,
0.0184777584,
-0.0194807947,
-0.0247648451,
-0.0091167176,
0.0251476336,
0.0376992933,
0.0820686743,
0.0078326389,
0.0200745091,
-0.0084642982,
0.0208557397,
-0.0369131714,
-0.0593305491,
0.037834473,
-0.0336488485,
-0.0165566783,
0.0255350154,
0.0540032759,
-0.0416835845,
-0.0204362534,
-0.0160767995,
-0.0011590462,
-0.0261362698,
0.0191102438,
0.033040829,
0.0051667537,
-0.0416283906,
0.0276116878,
0.0244366881,
-0.0264618434,
-0.0187207535,
-0.0439085886,
-0.0568519011,
0.0604291633,
0.026263414,
-0.0491767749,
-0.0249920357,
0.0275738556,
0.0179635156,
0.0370722041,
0.05689466,
0.008839651,
0.031398166,
-0.0566025823,
-0.0415495932,
-0.0195062868,
0.0226639248,
-0.0039797998,
0.0504764169,
-0.0150520243,
0.0292487666,
-0.0170116369,
-0.0401102044,
0.0431214273,
-0.0246976893,
-0.0316728987,
0.0338256806,
0.0257801488,
0.0131455045,
0.0105666248,
-0.0081550889,
-0.0034530608,
0.0303549375,
-0.0006300394,
0.0157314036,
-0.0194006804,
-0.0356198363,
0.0158317778,
0.0024355471,
-0.0144750848,
0.0374080166,
0.0199633911,
-0.0528786182,
-0.0591447763,
0.020297844,
-0.0083982982,
0.0397925936,
-0.0203050803,
0.0202273279,
-0.0299962945,
0.0057560671,
-0.0469072722,
-0.0128860706,
0.0419000499,
-0.0222646091,
-0.005850343,
0.045250915,
0.0399168804,
-0.0230503418,
-0.0271131024,
0.0009566165,
-0.0000417176,
0.0185131319,
0.0290884357,
0.0208410025,
-0.0411945656,
-0.0490008332,
-0.0601683743,
0.0588089935,
-0.0430808254,
-0.0161249544,
0.0370196737,
0.0285745654,
0.0050052898,
0.002751847,
-0.0039647869,
0.0438176543,
-0.0353995822,
0.0180964209,
0.0064588473,
-0.0117753725,
-0.037236765,
-0.0371415094,
-0.0495136976,
0.0091291638,
0.0123901945,
-0.0016849244,
-0.0074453293,
-0.0403044447,
0.0045357854,
0.0093732877,
0.0153497793,
0.0038900697,
-0.0640992746,
-0.0133907506,
-0.0383690149,
-0.003106059,
0.0962494984,
-0.0369661413,
0.0350354761,
0.0223014839,
0.0291492175,
-0.0217382871,
0.0291683283,
-0.0599337146,
-0.0192053635,
-0.0150244385,
0.0492070168,
0.0130021982,
0.0589747764,
-0.0434343144,
-0.0071427268,
-0.0890084654,
0.0300650001,
-0.0207534656,
-0.0083673829,
0.0226609595,
0.0115958443,
0.0129907997,
0.0403357781,
-0.0007864449,
-0.0375608727,
0.0372409709,
-0.0229493361,
0.0060654343,
-0.0533374622,
-0.0153433327,
-0.0263912901,
0.0420000032,
0.0223634206,
0.0072159702,
0.0489065088,
-0.0139195248,
-0.0583075918,
0.0136280516,
0.0513684452,
0.0008740411,
0.0218124781,
-0.0278293863,
0.0075949086,
-0.0262160692,
-0.0600658506,
-0.0132004255,
-0.0338395722,
-0.0154322796,
0.0321661159,
0.0150294974,
-0.0569691435,
-0.0447382033,
0.0007626128,
-0.016063856,
0.0473931879,
-0.0306395143,
0.0217273049,
-0.0408089608,
0.0056729321,
0.0613939762,
0.055641856,
0.0506122001,
0.0046179569,
-0.0652253404,
-0.0133935548,
0.0256948639,
0.0181073882,
-0.0311095547,
0.0222638194,
0.0426507778,
-0.034875799,
-0.0506084599,
-0.0139354141,
0.0612350926,
-0.0640857443,
0.0171398614,
0.0947956666,
0.0230013542,
-0.0364995562,
0.0150509365,
0.0750022084,
0.0379312821,
0.0127820726,
0.024007272,
-0.0373939909,
-0.0672940612,
0.0139325149,
0.04705441,
0.0153555227,
0.0115681048,
-0.005606438,
-0.0948168933,
0.0244351309,
0.0206825268,
0.0101634916,
-0.0075470991,
-0.044007834,
0.0221535135,
-0.0743795261,
0.0140895164,
0.003173555,
-0.0017420821,
0.0181046445,
-0.0046806424,
-0.0085182572,
-0.0768550709,
0.0322093405,
-0.0163975675,
0.0450933203,
0.0279584937,
-0.0380023085,
-0.0097876173,
-0.0465024374,
0.0544222072,
-0.0278044976,
0.0105730603,
-0.0611721687,
0.0312749706,
-0.002222161,
-0.0228241161,
0.0194395054,
0.0413311124,
-0.0332436897,
0.0099880965,
-0.0313090123,
0.0473787934,
-0.0119305281,
0.0220401958,
0.0122307194,
-0.0200436227,
-0.0109470775,
0.0584872849,
0.009943272,
-0.0533576012,
-0.0244714003,
0.0021570276,
-0.0216393266,
-0.0806756318,
-0.0081562633,
-0.0053634071,
0.0041107214,
-0.0229591392,
-0.0250336751,
0.0271004587,
0.0489355437,
0.0580343045,
0.015623346,
-0.0177896805,
0.0068588774,
0.0271424092,
-0.0600074045,
0.0445322692,
-0.01107651,
0.0098830462,
-0.0604412965,
-0.0304823983,
0.0769449547,
-0.01220222,
-0.0048402934,
0.0175923575,
-0.0725442171,
-0.0809108019,
0.0110397832,
0.0436957031,
0.0154305315,
0.0474188328,
-0.0296985283,
-0.0773285925,
-0.0185740255,
0.0174006838,
-0.0438308045,
0.0319824331,
0.039416533,
-0.0388132446,
-0.0225266367,
0.0304367989,
-0.019260129,
0.0198433436,
0.0457640924,
0.0659987256,
0.0501604006,
-0.0626939684,
-0.0012212807,
0.0257216655,
0.0605418943,
-0.0443763025,
-0.0133494074,
-0.0421671905,
0.0184218157,
0.0261152498,
0.0041799662,
-0.0432354882,
0.0057092099,
0.0157561824,
0.0092878984,
-0.0163988154,
-0.0039112614,
0.0323124379,
0.0520844646,
0.0006862165,
0.0405822992,
-0.0083165038,
-0.0436867028,
0.0107732732,
0.0183266643,
0.004322384,
0.0571216978,
0.0216586459,
0.0394273512,
-0.0579893254,
0.0248928424,
0.0603563711,
0.0202796031,
-0.0928600207,
0.0512738153,
-0.0203828961,
-0.0762557611,
-0.0563596264,
-0.007847785,
0.0614597946,
-0.0432735234,
0.0537593067,
-0.0388002768,
-0.0495903455,
-0.0083830031,
0.0377377272,
0.0209407527,
0.0518727377,
0.0047791763,
0.0307442788,
-0.0238904059,
-0.0383046903,
0.0385938287,
0.0069068144,
0.0323764272,
0.0038291872,
0.0355525352,
-0.0344922617,
-0.0205483343,
-0.0248909667,
0.0235480014,
-0.0134182805,
0.0289312582,
-0.019475488,
-0.0394376293,
-0.0449677445,
-0.0234483518,
-0.0215771087,
-0.0005805227,
0.0403808989,
0.0562103353,
0.0088850418,
0.0061955112,
-0.0055185901,
-0.0735822245,
0.0192320962,
-0.0059291068,
0.0080026556,
-6.647075987e-33,
-0.005628326,
0.0184070878,
-0.0049350876,
0.0200741012,
-0.0237337705,
-0.0081741847,
0.0007929395,
0.008468044,
-0.0559760854,
-0.0246330872,
-0.0171511769,
-0.0236952137,
0.0206398237,
0.0250091702,
0.005039501,
0.0307950415,
0.0581080243,
-0.0297848731,
-0.014436692,
0.0080149984,
0.0041608796,
0.0041366336,
0.0397010446,
-0.0114250118,
-0.0723153353,
0.0338796712,
-0.0281419139,
0.0484889783,
0.0028190294,
0.0550440401,
0.0017807523,
0.0318091549,
-0.0155600989,
-0.03792217,
0.0003795019,
-0.0092948787,
-0.1040389165,
-0.0413063392,
0.0176527444,
-0.0015708915,
-0.0190918576,
-0.0047419034,
0.0441079177,
-0.0000624376,
-0.0180873219,
-0.0141840875,
0.0158168431,
-0.0233111549,
-0.00563933,
0.0091401171,
-0.0695122257,
0.0209675655,
0.0135946665,
-0.0207131691,
0.0722570047,
-0.0040852707,
-0.023061512,
-0.0127694821,
-0.0512189567,
-0.0119027607,
0.0303851161,
0.0785882249,
0.0141186044,
0.0478985533,
0.0090481443,
0.0057027224,
0.032041233,
0.0181165468,
0.0194888562,
0.011338166,
0.0814504251,
0.0527814738,
0.0350279808,
-0.0099270213,
0.057327088,
-0.0199029408,
-0.052501101,
-0.030095093,
0.0324829407,
0.0171657614,
0.01998174,
0.0340917856,
0.008517405,
-0.0036087455,
-0.0705334023,
0.0111083975,
-0.034309119,
-0.0187599603,
0.0270324908,
0.0475004204,
-0.0078268787,
0.0096645858,
0.0197242014,
-0.0224479139,
0.0642458498,
-0.008487897,
-0.0324591808,
0.0105413292,
0.0152453752,
0.0096669393,
-0.0520580299,
-0.0438340083,
-0.000938311,
0.0245334022,
0.0220053401,
-0.0388881005,
0.0190987457,
0.0616549514,
-0.0538979955,
-0.0071843546,
-0.0219384059,
0.018329272,
0.0168615133,
0.0562683679,
0.0251641348,
0.0136346882,
-0.0172520522,
0.000009749,
0.0208768025,
0.0024770787,
-0.0255339872,
0.0112085799,
0.0310076866,
0.0100904293,
-0.0058009685,
0.0193947162,
-0.0183041468,
-0.0355696231,
0.0290435143,
-0.0673806965,
-0.0315221027,
0.0318869129,
2.874e-7,
0.0422252789,
0.0555813424,
-0.001275872,
0.0033673246,
0.0080936719,
0.0336330906,
0.0017666543,
-0.0300958492,
-0.0401456431,
0.0034519278,
0.0030770937,
0.0442370325,
0.0742308199,
0.0013020558,
-0.0828977749,
0.0179421138,
-0.0097458921,
0.0586690865,
-0.0380249321,
-0.0141201587,
0.0099763209,
0.1100164875,
0.0213725623,
-0.0220652297,
-0.0000934845,
0.0238236524,
0.0321081504,
-0.015170156,
0.0301006231,
0.044061549,
-0.0447049178,
0.0375341028,
-0.0246661566,
0.032237187,
-0.0302345883,
0.0242019463,
0.0063866386,
0.0871905163,
0.0041321032,
-0.0527010523,
0.0236548893,
0.0030636438,
0.0088909334,
-0.0486099906,
0.0709508285,
-0.0882883295,
-0.0230539609,
-0.0328459367,
0.0056319986,
-0.004458454,
0.0362971015,
-0.0336013287,
-0.0113640036,
0.0408187546,
0.02930508,
0.0094156172,
-0.0426942483,
-0.1196804941,
-0.0046375794,
0.0830258057,
-0.0162235424,
-0.0212796591,
-0.0444642603,
-0.0556049235,
0.0594797768,
-0.0319567099,
-0.0284399074,
2.950745205e-34,
0.0570950583,
-0.045206219,
0.0432650261,
-0.0031063997,
0.0087210834,
0.0133312158,
-0.0192805398,
0.0054610688,
0.0007533783,
-0.0791567862,
-0.0394626595
] |
Subsets and Splits