id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04811v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04811v1 | A Large-Scale Multilingual Study of Visual Constraints on Linguistic Selection of Descriptions | 2023-02-09T17:57:58 | 2023-02-09T17:57:58 | Uri Berger, Lea Frermann, Gabriel Stanovsky, Omri Abend | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a large, multilingual study into how vision constrains linguistic
choice, covering four languages and five linguistic properties, such as verb
transitivity or use of numerals. We propose a novel method that leverages
existing corpora of images with captions written by native speakers, and apply
it to nine corpora, comprising 600k images and 3M captions. We study the
relation between visual input and linguistic choices by training classifiers to
predict the probability of expressing a property from raw images, and find
evidence supporting the claim that linguistic properties are constrained by
visual context across languages. We complement this investigation with a corpus
study, taking the test case of numerals. Specifically, we use existing
annotations (number or type of objects) to investigate the effect of different
visual conditions on the use of numeral expressions in captions, and show that
similar patterns emerge across languages. Our methods and findings both confirm
and extend existing research in the cognitive literature. We additionally
discuss possible applications for language generation. | [
0.0085104965,
0.0814797059,
-0.0420372039,
0.0425178036,
-0.0205104463,
-0.0077129556,
0.012067141,
0.0138501162,
-0.0080234092,
-0.0900965706,
0.0075823045,
-0.0380217843,
0.0568532012,
0.0282657798,
0.0510997362,
-0.0712884441,
0.0025688526,
-0.0300980173,
-0.0242662709,
0.0098644001,
0.00414943,
0.0225131623,
-0.0004147265,
0.0214215033,
-0.0628400743,
0.0403742008,
0.0218559895,
-0.03202549,
-0.0102953976,
-0.022468267,
-0.0446898155,
0.0641346052,
0.0533714704,
0.0108638369,
0.0000018606,
-0.0612299033,
0.0379230864,
-0.0237403177,
0.0194087718,
-0.0198422484,
0.0538197272,
-0.0804679841,
0.0153639587,
-0.042803891,
-0.0385657884,
-0.0062118345,
0.0981174931,
0.030831201,
0.019778315,
0.0034360804,
-0.0344885513,
-0.030306505,
-0.0206026845,
-0.0171871502,
0.0197854564,
0.0368784703,
0.0017662431,
0.0578620769,
-0.0008677589,
0.0165346358,
-0.0469684564,
0.025678413,
0.015003847,
0.0025921911,
-0.0102969818,
0.042475231,
-0.0404913127,
-0.0725797415,
0.0066102538,
0.0757745057,
0.0351120569,
-0.0297815744,
-0.0221613832,
-0.0004637147,
-0.0059062531,
-0.0000892717,
-0.0362624936,
0.0602379143,
0.0375959203,
0.0477552451,
-0.0361690745,
0.0246589165,
-0.0105248829,
0.0033024545,
0.0062335976,
-0.010188601,
0.0251084175,
0.0396018252,
-0.0090537947,
0.0241995845,
-0.0634619445,
-0.059787441,
-0.0075779022,
-0.0249656644,
0.0163074434,
0.0176793039,
-0.0230199005,
-0.0414902195,
0.0137899006,
-0.053264644,
0.0162486844,
0.0302891489,
-0.0568711422,
0.0173844527,
-0.0277267266,
0.0620535798,
0.0074355616,
0.0110701136,
-0.0668218806,
0.0199921019,
-0.0187221579,
-0.0301374532,
-0.0263593812,
-0.0068427604,
-0.0134684406,
-0.0271996763,
-0.0732617304,
0.0062111043,
0.0021633995,
0.0031402286,
-0.0431596339,
-0.0008507829,
-0.0158890802,
0.0294038355,
-0.0508984141,
0.0077068368,
-0.0285767708,
0.0195677895,
-0.069354482,
-0.0669341758,
0.0344408564,
0.0194783509,
-0.0000293081,
-0.019881295,
-0.0260935035,
0.0717697665,
-0.0466669984,
0.0003522295,
0.0189895723,
-0.0436557494,
-0.0267635249,
-0.0184281506,
0.0086993864,
-0.042543862,
-0.0076470659,
0.0210043676,
0.0294359587,
-0.0556004383,
0.0372965038,
0.020919621,
0.009509583,
0.07798329,
-0.0028498054,
-0.0045424895,
-0.0261177346,
-0.0064451308,
0.0309950579,
0.0636653528,
0.028374996,
0.0176519677,
0.0609363317,
-0.0446147807,
0.0242627095,
0.0571559966,
-0.0227086172,
0.0162139405,
-0.0543256514,
-0.0429591201,
0.0457848832,
0.0028081189,
0.0354425721,
0.037090905,
-0.0159790441,
-0.0266963411,
0.1033965945,
0.0495697707,
-0.0378314368,
0.0003347294,
0.0239245612,
-0.0163830593,
-0.0284788702,
0.0190379303,
-0.0245966185,
0.0463530123,
0.0387515761,
0.0151690068,
-0.0147454115,
0.0265961494,
-0.0239191595,
-0.0337826535,
-0.0154266749,
0.0042593246,
0.0352120437,
-0.0207654703,
0.0250549372,
0.0306257084,
-0.0040832264,
0.0205477625,
0.0026013402,
-0.0741033405,
0.0043618344,
-0.00339483,
0.0113693951,
0.0361026973,
0.0049774814,
0.0252235699,
0.0192260537,
0.0065077692,
0.0415580943,
0.0601000711,
0.0387230702,
0.0119387805,
0.0244724769,
-0.0449927598,
0.0044756811,
-0.0243835878,
-0.0021943795,
-0.0080382088,
-0.0582713261,
0.0226087924,
0.0050316537,
-0.0337136164,
-0.0412878692,
0.0444947891,
0.0331638418,
-0.0454313941,
-0.0325394385,
0.0209890138,
-0.0239344165,
-0.0315061659,
0.0105094239,
0.0430772118,
-0.0209710989,
-0.0245113783,
0.0149881318,
0.088318333,
-0.0403058343,
-0.0030240621,
0.0304182153,
-0.0786960274,
-0.0123469997,
-0.0310333427,
0.0012793948,
-0.0300299618,
0.0408552811,
-0.067085892,
0.0207259022,
-0.0369994044,
0.0081977714,
-0.003279957,
0.0406980328,
-0.0083060777,
0.0489113294,
0.0116673028,
-0.0038425066,
0.0024428556,
-0.0513816848,
0.0485382937,
-0.0081313802,
-0.0022706322,
0.0126767987,
0.0106172906,
0.0083683366,
0.0394128338,
0.0244419929,
-0.0521741174,
0.0242988337,
-0.0855692104,
-0.0545692444,
-0.0143222567,
-0.0176524948,
0.0018183588,
-0.0381044745,
0.0174074322,
-0.0278112274,
-0.0387470275,
0.0025126357,
-0.0087962216,
0.0373562612,
0.0400465764,
0.0013984017,
-0.0427025408,
-0.0250388663,
-0.0148513373,
0.0070776423,
0.0744797438,
0.0780809894,
-0.0321967266,
-0.0360845663,
0.0291327648,
-0.0305138789,
0.0165492054,
-0.0023500347,
-0.0036945352,
0.035063941,
0.0128110358,
0.0100843115,
0.0108374711,
-0.0343672186,
0.0244963486,
0.0679121614,
-0.0257646441,
-0.0096748462,
-0.0591608658,
-0.0147914188,
-0.0497644544,
0.0190175362,
-0.0622472093,
-0.016326664,
0.0318095572,
-0.0077796346,
-0.0065269754,
-0.050534118,
0.0480947942,
-0.0367631316,
-0.0459274463,
-0.0535298064,
0.0320245959,
0.0107760886,
0.1109301671,
-0.0001500831,
-0.0440717861,
0.0398412421,
-0.0052451356,
-0.0245601553,
-0.0136487801,
0.0457445942,
-0.0233286973,
0.0873240083,
0.0476108529,
0.0147379646,
0.0515875965,
0.0122913001,
-0.067558378,
0.0047138468,
0.0518554151,
0.0257481541,
0.0845380574,
-0.1040713117,
0.0073176813,
-0.0100518838,
-0.0714319348,
-0.0350247324,
-0.0314363688,
-0.0280024856,
0.012098995,
-0.0261767525,
-0.0071257316,
-0.0139653869,
0.0130834319,
0.0223971959,
0.0191927813,
0.0152850756,
-0.0023885891,
-0.0313355476,
0.0403875187,
0.0419622213,
0.0141527103,
-0.0238866564,
-0.0232220683,
-0.0128879622,
0.0102485437,
-0.020338783,
0.0529246107,
-0.0509255901,
0.0356294215,
0.052471716,
0.0064682201,
-0.0512868054,
0.035314966,
0.0382404849,
-0.0298220981,
0.0189626757,
0.0428061336,
0.0298488643,
-0.0380074009,
0.0337879136,
-0.0204227176,
0.0123664271,
0.0378405452,
0.007025959,
-0.0977056101,
-0.0138955116,
-0.0204339717,
-0.0721754506,
-0.0072021238,
-0.0016620983,
-0.0386076979,
-0.1201518551,
0.04079099,
0.0306467321,
-0.0757113546,
-0.0350691676,
-0.0114207687,
0.0120938467,
0.0031262299,
-0.0168737154,
-0.0143671697,
-0.0258698203,
0.0400817916,
-0.0031797029,
0.0395941101,
-0.0321216583,
-0.0143756568,
-0.0194980819,
-0.0220240876,
0.0036580015,
0.0240223762,
-0.0452977791,
-0.0421362892,
0.006917954,
0.0226522852,
0.0101418151,
0.0123472866,
0.0585067756,
0.0492759421,
-0.0475944653,
-0.0222054422,
0.0180972349,
-0.007625917,
-0.0381960347,
-0.0133677814,
0.0314475484,
-0.0028062626,
-0.0180933941,
0.0095113674,
0.0240754113,
-0.0063379118,
0.0000293884,
0.0529309548,
-0.0262151174,
-0.0051206457,
-0.0310272481,
0.0136643732,
-0.0304470733,
-0.0508116931,
-0.0238228217,
-0.0185268838,
-0.0685919151,
-0.1164571121,
-0.0126989083,
0.0280933157,
0.012968244,
0.0647212639,
-0.0349917747,
0.0374770574,
0.0021819423,
-0.0241840146,
0.0390057229,
-0.0183578972,
0.021612471,
-0.0219314955,
-0.0157640167,
0.0305662528,
-0.0295025706,
0.0170867071,
0.0322027504,
-0.0056253942,
-0.0489160642,
-0.0345162153,
0.0704424456,
0.0167537685,
-0.002018543,
0.0441806801,
-0.0683835149,
-0.0296284165,
0.0200352743,
0.0547820292,
0.0213060137,
-0.0180993825,
-0.0268019419,
-0.0052249366,
0.0232034791,
0.0032203486,
0.0234549828,
-0.0143008269,
0.0101079214,
-0.058418978,
0.0060025644,
0.042499844,
-0.0041848365,
-0.0051577091,
-0.0806487799,
0.0482994504,
-0.0303233005,
-0.0240567345,
-0.0567287393,
-0.0227017682,
-0.0280564446,
0.0179225765,
0.0123677542,
0.0684080794,
-0.0114039313,
-0.015145991,
-0.0232951622,
0.0100706993,
0.0313921496,
-0.0002385287,
0.0611158125,
0.0048291869,
-0.0045132469,
0.0187825318,
0.0098741725,
0.0312169064,
-0.0435453728,
0.062249504,
-0.0100205699,
0.0559604838,
0.0115485042,
-0.0123872133,
-0.0313340984,
0.0211299304,
0.0570355207,
-0.014544053,
0.0195950456,
0.0074526723,
0.0719816238,
-0.0446897522,
0.0428865366,
-0.0690267608,
-0.0078530824,
-0.0079734866,
0.0251082946,
-0.0035686153,
-0.0473389216,
0.0287952796,
0.0145869432,
-0.0242207572,
-0.02175951,
0.0543403104,
-0.005264705,
-0.0167178493,
0.0240695365,
-0.0351134688,
0.0006672897,
0.006457224,
0.0212065466,
-0.0341535136,
-0.0020703562,
0.0425054431,
-0.0622048192,
-0.093068026,
-0.0096727889,
-0.0212897882,
0.0171444844,
0.0306500178,
0.0576401465,
0.0264615659,
0.0093307057,
0.011770851,
-0.0340554267,
-0.0132094128,
-0.0390900671,
0.0302791316,
-0.067420952,
-5.343980255e-33,
-0.0110086445,
-0.0599277318,
0.007374553,
0.0104023861,
0.0294829383,
-0.0218368806,
-0.029234698,
0.044997178,
0.0153787546,
0.025246527,
0.0243990961,
-0.0583706014,
0.0178134311,
0.0222229511,
0.0603637174,
0.0022234432,
0.0310506243,
0.006970474,
-0.0385695659,
-0.0315383002,
0.0591859035,
-0.0357079245,
0.0774400011,
-0.0549590141,
0.0333009474,
0.0440957062,
-0.0123894885,
-0.005645318,
0.0247005243,
0.0381177962,
-0.0245464034,
0.0644493923,
0.0235589519,
-0.0238372311,
-0.0189787913,
0.0446415506,
0.0207498726,
-0.0624599196,
0.060243763,
0.0706948489,
-0.0194826946,
-0.0171197187,
-0.0007342712,
-0.0854070708,
-0.0369184427,
0.0308808237,
0.0645299479,
-0.0227298923,
0.0057930211,
0.0111452462,
-0.0603155196,
-0.0192190018,
-0.0149587914,
-0.0318532325,
0.0627656803,
0.0344092809,
0.0013326321,
-0.0133018875,
-0.020397244,
0.1003059521,
-0.0074847289,
0.0185737815,
0.0669597536,
0.0198981669,
0.0194818024,
0.0449717492,
0.0263996981,
-0.005890178,
-0.0181552414,
0.0094857225,
0.0446106419,
0.0468633957,
0.0702464953,
0.0508516729,
0.0518969148,
-0.0034189157,
-0.0302581433,
-0.0219066478,
-0.0265346803,
0.0199180525,
0.0040910183,
0.0058324514,
-0.0232990701,
-0.0218810793,
-0.0380984843,
-0.0155671602,
-0.0256051403,
-0.0044544009,
0.0144687984,
-0.020725444,
0.0382168852,
0.0410082079,
0.0520846359,
-0.0294623375,
-0.0553947315,
-0.0137366727,
-0.0399032757,
0.0637084693,
0.0019469155,
-0.0163326822,
-0.013123123,
-0.0293923356,
0.0211994965,
0.017046392,
0.0463561565,
0.0200869143,
0.0357488953,
-0.0021733383,
-0.0306548588,
0.0027209911,
-0.0240617972,
-0.0434785299,
0.0100397049,
-0.0000321304,
0.0254289899,
0.0204437803,
-0.0535133071,
-0.0338658839,
-0.0088434108,
-0.031238934,
-0.0314597599,
-0.0182788782,
-0.0468988121,
0.018124003,
-0.0336541981,
-0.0071336986,
-0.0555563308,
0.006539437,
0.0600820594,
-0.0341879092,
-0.0202534907,
0.0076262713,
2.62e-7,
0.0329212844,
0.0451977029,
-0.0246352423,
0.0211412739,
0.0296475403,
0.0330605693,
-0.0185723063,
-0.0051245266,
-0.0321671516,
-0.039535962,
0.0019587507,
-0.0071993046,
0.0254699104,
0.0013660492,
-0.013515343,
0.0406683162,
0.0134266354,
0.0136715984,
-0.0319381058,
-0.0200734232,
0.033738222,
0.0587907918,
-0.0264719017,
-0.0029444548,
-0.0027756614,
-0.0762778968,
0.0819382742,
-0.0650188774,
0.0110725164,
-0.0044959919,
0.0083928388,
0.021435244,
-0.0166740846,
0.0592904016,
-0.0191667508,
-0.0179909747,
0.0724326447,
0.0069778925,
-0.013470958,
0.016898999,
-0.0487820506,
0.0108680297,
-0.0431593843,
-0.028264543,
0.0556347072,
-0.0472751074,
-0.0377510861,
0.0037400378,
0.0314845666,
0.0226253439,
0.0590748303,
-0.032452479,
-0.0488129109,
0.0412284806,
0.0503100343,
-0.0136825815,
-0.0413920693,
-0.0130825359,
-0.0346148051,
-0.0082864957,
0.0036478871,
-0.0423114039,
-0.0472953394,
-0.0112537537,
0.0067602461,
0.0067814584,
-0.0269268863,
1.863946035e-34,
0.0341670029,
-0.0185333453,
0.042736806,
-0.0002007031,
0.0128523102,
-0.0332033299,
-0.0173602346,
0.0588862002,
0.0346425585,
-0.0233187806,
0.0006897093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04790v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04790v1 | Massively Multilingual Language Models for Cross Lingual Fact Extraction from Low Resource Indian Languages | 2023-02-09T17:29:56 | 2023-02-09T17:29:56 | Bhavyajeet Singh, Pavan Kandru, Anubhav Sharma, Vasudeva Varma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Massive knowledge graphs like Wikidata attempt to capture world knowledge
about multiple entities. Recent approaches concentrate on automatically
enriching these KGs from text. However a lot of information present in the form
of natural text in low resource languages is often missed out. Cross Lingual
Information Extraction aims at extracting factual information in the form of
English triples from low resource Indian Language text. Despite its massive
potential, progress made on this task is lagging when compared to Monolingual
Information Extraction. In this paper, we propose the task of Cross Lingual
Fact Extraction(CLFE) from text and devise an end-to-end generative approach
for the same which achieves an overall F1 score of 77.46. | [
0.0460751131,
-0.0044121239,
0.0089146225,
0.1012379453,
-0.0527021214,
0.0187568087,
-0.0307572018,
0.0067134197,
0.0394533351,
-0.0264150258,
0.0217223894,
-0.0168099999,
-0.0036185887,
0.0354232788,
0.0289711505,
-0.0239021517,
0.0325249098,
-0.0259030666,
0.0276425648,
-0.0349756554,
-0.0008909279,
0.0452785641,
-0.0346470587,
-0.0400833189,
-0.0812176615,
-0.0215940867,
0.0558762029,
-0.0411831848,
0.0151521051,
-0.0144530311,
-0.0100798486,
-0.0043177167,
0.0058069262,
-0.0109243607,
0.0000016993,
-0.071545437,
-0.0216674805,
0.0258354954,
-0.0256217364,
-0.0000600951,
-0.0050671026,
-0.0152696865,
0.0082237562,
-0.0267279968,
-0.0314026475,
-0.0191842075,
0.0264613368,
0.0624515116,
0.0080973078,
0.0995813683,
-0.0159902126,
-0.0650840029,
0.0469140075,
0.0131898653,
0.0427347086,
-0.012764615,
0.027189346,
0.0544448197,
-0.0148211038,
0.0055249059,
-0.0127254548,
0.0136389239,
0.0081889955,
-0.0201186463,
-0.0192705113,
0.0189224333,
0.0115498602,
-0.006663389,
0.0390597656,
0.0576961413,
-0.0030310706,
-0.0060447957,
0.0193727389,
0.0232744906,
-0.0336746015,
0.0150305647,
-0.0323825553,
0.0507635511,
-0.0686731115,
0.0318603255,
0.0654707327,
-0.0001761793,
0.0158545487,
-0.01368983,
0.027105758,
0.0359131135,
0.0253891163,
-0.0180081744,
-0.0305341538,
0.0224563386,
-0.0035919116,
-0.0466983542,
-0.0117418868,
0.0122449175,
0.0186383277,
0.0356444232,
0.0054988465,
-0.0271968357,
0.0137699805,
-0.0742051303,
-0.0721927509,
-0.010822366,
-0.0462747999,
0.0618948303,
-0.0264646076,
-0.0181804672,
-0.0317056961,
-0.0111034615,
0.0105413208,
-0.0371628888,
0.0050913165,
-0.0096199922,
0.0217086524,
0.0256353728,
-0.0239010267,
0.0205721706,
-0.0503958724,
-0.0186899379,
0.0242016707,
0.027583234,
0.0646395162,
-0.0419098288,
-0.03164123,
-0.0335416198,
0.0006756346,
0.042553857,
-0.0075202608,
0.003725765,
-0.0215267781,
-0.0491553135,
-0.003996558,
0.0058598616,
0.0263542905,
-0.0186930876,
-0.0179657396,
0.0534769557,
0.0054264814,
-0.0019384705,
-0.0818266943,
0.0045203222,
0.0113001242,
-0.0666001439,
-0.0389544889,
-0.0725152418,
0.0741596147,
0.0334086604,
-0.0065432354,
-0.0226232018,
0.0445434786,
-0.0065623578,
-0.0670935661,
0.0398098603,
-0.033756651,
-0.0020400465,
0.035344772,
0.0043772347,
0.0515041016,
0.0500669256,
0.0518002398,
0.006891924,
0.0979914591,
0.0232606661,
0.0123975733,
0.032361161,
0.0019881688,
-0.0094141671,
0.0516364872,
0.0172331929,
0.0354437865,
-0.0225399453,
0.0115327761,
0.0292614214,
-0.0057719667,
0.0438254066,
0.0420310721,
-0.0144090429,
0.025933994,
0.0648064539,
0.0722823218,
-0.0121161388,
0.0224145129,
0.0395564735,
-0.0010499178,
0.0121123465,
-0.0150536681,
0.0527614802,
0.0312531069,
0.0733702555,
0.008654871,
-0.0072059999,
0.0015406027,
-0.0478772409,
-0.0439502411,
0.0016172448,
0.1011149213,
-0.004615711,
-0.0216322206,
0.0131013105,
0.1065616384,
-0.0761318654,
0.0639720336,
0.002501931,
0.0520688333,
0.0271371566,
-0.0050096801,
-0.0268323459,
-0.0087775961,
0.0228228644,
-0.0058105551,
0.037866462,
0.0394982509,
-0.0384358913,
-0.0024470077,
-0.0275632143,
-0.0006794598,
0.0048494395,
-0.0093795536,
0.0052317893,
0.0083508175,
0.0451927222,
0.0182365254,
-0.0402360559,
-0.0080729397,
0.0126178032,
-0.0522746146,
0.0091520511,
-0.0010344711,
0.0147600174,
-0.0140497293,
0.028861016,
-0.0128924195,
-0.03312058,
0.0288460292,
-0.0487243421,
0.0084952032,
0.0293613747,
0.0164156165,
-0.0620319843,
0.0210935213,
-0.0306199007,
0.0138253858,
-0.0370736681,
-0.0103407782,
-0.0287709441,
-0.0174995251,
0.025425341,
0.061414402,
-0.0146856457,
0.0226625931,
0.0345803648,
0.0048672268,
0.0198553372,
0.102653712,
0.0065199011,
-0.0050561074,
-0.0246108864,
-0.0620671809,
0.0310662463,
-0.0313256569,
0.0072583752,
0.0235771891,
0.0515721291,
0.0086628916,
0.0286623444,
-0.0068903025,
-0.0320603363,
-0.0259812865,
-0.085930109,
0.0039904625,
0.0047753719,
0.0434469618,
-0.0114001911,
0.0451101921,
-0.0057089897,
0.0254200064,
-0.0345720313,
0.0012824922,
0.0130568724,
0.0076984656,
0.0479870178,
0.0103040626,
0.0222241729,
-0.0141390413,
-0.0102475947,
-0.0136722829,
0.061104089,
0.0084544141,
-0.0215367414,
-0.0224945918,
0.0295451581,
-0.0536550134,
0.0179572348,
-0.0343922861,
-0.007684065,
-0.0636506081,
-0.0333298929,
0.0608944446,
0.004273471,
-0.0076798708,
-0.0106124692,
-0.0252409801,
-0.0392599925,
0.0054223277,
0.0185363665,
-0.0217408706,
0.0367215127,
-0.008977429,
-0.0122888852,
-0.004031627,
-0.0278307721,
0.0178313684,
-0.0275958441,
-0.0140752774,
-0.0084532257,
-0.0327520669,
0.0152242752,
-0.0087864827,
0.0541211367,
-0.0009150602,
0.0558527596,
-0.0251587387,
-0.0150581188,
0.0636236519,
-0.0387002043,
0.0227892324,
-0.022165915,
0.0088489261,
-0.044935137,
0.046747569,
-0.0216137972,
0.0302829538,
-0.0307972822,
-0.0047097644,
-0.0013760822,
-0.010615428,
0.0523985736,
-0.019371856,
0.0176529512,
-0.0470079035,
0.0366839878,
-0.0292909108,
-0.0081039472,
-0.0203820933,
-0.0486926362,
0.0380814783,
-0.016772734,
0.0200664103,
-0.030811267,
0.0153031414,
0.0151205035,
0.0551788807,
-0.0254930835,
-0.0021221726,
0.0196079388,
0.0313697048,
0.0686881617,
0.0721364319,
0.0010155485,
-0.0083196322,
0.0230815243,
-0.0057675508,
0.0241953954,
-0.0192205999,
-0.0286088586,
0.0482583381,
-0.0039804284,
-0.0114258733,
-0.0490983017,
-0.0259724241,
-0.0348892808,
0.0329270251,
-0.0166596416,
0.0065332754,
0.0716184229,
0.0080672698,
-0.0070724571,
0.0014359514,
-0.0267393626,
-0.0574856214,
0.0016311101,
0.0097497832,
-0.1001109704,
0.0205608942,
-0.0168589111,
-0.0546472333,
-0.0016794092,
-0.0175721142,
-0.0281952396,
-0.1101243198,
-0.0182668101,
-0.0127100628,
0.0213726219,
-0.0596635342,
-0.0257858839,
-0.0521729104,
-0.020143766,
-0.0484981835,
0.0006719567,
-0.017920088,
0.0076345513,
0.0103264702,
0.0123956017,
-0.0284776203,
0.0156566296,
-0.0252518617,
-0.0265120622,
0.0119576221,
0.0147999786,
-0.0443643145,
-0.0354528017,
-0.0155642647,
-0.0296879783,
-0.0632051155,
0.0012338662,
0.0294664782,
-0.0165658183,
-0.0130590592,
-0.0188951138,
0.0263754893,
0.0045832554,
-0.0160534941,
0.0374335237,
0.0799767748,
0.0795010775,
-0.012315114,
0.028659014,
-0.0238460153,
0.0285740923,
0.0450226627,
-0.0075273463,
-0.000710676,
0.0162478257,
-0.0245050285,
-0.0328113586,
-0.0378141776,
-0.071659483,
0.0333114937,
-0.0728808045,
-0.0719558224,
-0.0503015667,
-0.051923234,
0.0238953363,
0.0412948839,
0.0311837774,
0.0365996473,
0.0193276405,
0.0108311484,
0.0013533932,
-0.0153674725,
-0.0433033928,
0.0060572568,
-0.0319022201,
-0.0077280286,
0.0693103373,
-0.0370460488,
-0.0093598077,
-0.0135261128,
-0.0158211589,
-0.0618310496,
-0.0115281725,
0.034125492,
0.0058117569,
0.0113437157,
-0.0352789238,
-0.0016751832,
0.078349553,
0.0550498925,
-0.0774718747,
0.0002835362,
0.0198057853,
0.0307462979,
0.0131893698,
0.051393263,
-0.058185406,
0.0156518389,
-0.0317963436,
0.0462565012,
-0.0582805872,
-0.0320847072,
0.0300937537,
0.0649163052,
-0.0070554614,
-0.0625810996,
0.0067741005,
-0.0548379421,
-0.0099475924,
-0.0486711748,
-0.0240808371,
-0.0154527174,
0.0114725642,
0.005564888,
0.0143934935,
-0.0047598747,
0.0006760219,
0.0390384421,
-0.0015557948,
-0.0102441655,
0.0113780266,
0.0281115249,
0.0507420674,
0.0192269217,
-0.0420420021,
-0.008834389,
-0.0089294845,
-0.0252945945,
-0.0115915751,
-0.0616049618,
0.0305945016,
-0.0166669693,
-0.0321713537,
0.0129018864,
-0.0077889655,
0.0352800414,
0.0398808569,
-0.0136673525,
0.0393118151,
0.0912039205,
-0.0095887678,
0.0694875568,
-0.0266027711,
-0.0190680046,
-0.0094648469,
0.0323485211,
-0.0063639698,
0.0035621189,
0.0250106156,
0.0042345636,
-0.0379257984,
0.0206557605,
0.0845681354,
-0.0217785947,
0.0332753994,
0.0423205383,
-0.0394296758,
-0.0410788916,
-0.0488058701,
-0.034929879,
-0.0298888143,
0.0212499928,
0.0197450947,
-0.0856499076,
-0.0511707552,
-0.0017406449,
-0.004223879,
0.0080023501,
-0.0124971112,
-0.0324071161,
0.0674266815,
0.0463190414,
-0.0152229453,
-0.063103646,
0.0513608418,
-0.0244003404,
-0.0064154342,
0.0464711189,
-5.763380476e-33,
-0.0394670963,
-0.0222509317,
0.0205154512,
0.0384359919,
-0.0202339683,
0.0138224559,
-0.0188235249,
-0.0138706053,
-0.046747826,
0.0448241569,
0.0026663905,
-0.0117548248,
0.0188341495,
0.0099159023,
0.0045674997,
0.0021488657,
0.0059026051,
0.0434731543,
0.0169766843,
0.0368393995,
0.0820507035,
-0.0161124449,
0.110272564,
-0.0704997405,
0.0632881448,
-0.0492598973,
0.0062345136,
0.0382254794,
0.0255003013,
0.0124315741,
-0.0401088856,
0.0400535762,
0.016266657,
-0.0333742909,
0.0373608209,
-0.0429176502,
-0.0932916924,
0.0100728907,
0.06514211,
-0.0008424781,
0.0298347175,
-0.0376944356,
-0.0124958484,
0.0028959226,
0.0314862765,
0.0246497951,
0.0420482345,
0.0034407377,
-0.0357814431,
-0.0541796796,
-0.078657344,
0.0544251539,
0.0147964377,
0.0227411259,
-0.0105587263,
-0.0142699117,
0.0344234817,
-0.0327952318,
-0.053579919,
0.0200581644,
-0.002040765,
0.0449256711,
0.0527662784,
-0.0358485281,
-0.0051803524,
0.00634332,
-0.0426082388,
-0.0370388515,
-0.0186065901,
0.0504053794,
-0.0474235788,
0.0376343951,
-0.0534990281,
0.1024857685,
-0.0132751437,
-0.086007528,
-0.0948326066,
0.0153825022,
0.0046409648,
0.0296082441,
-0.029205082,
-0.0407786183,
-0.0421708748,
-0.015092046,
0.0447074361,
-0.0034860719,
0.0019061615,
-0.0367195234,
-0.008098335,
-0.0323843397,
-0.0112437354,
0.0547722206,
0.0062588332,
-0.0105611319,
-0.000284288,
0.0472150855,
-0.0304547567,
0.0195077043,
-0.0337199122,
0.0037562591,
-0.0703303367,
-0.0521171205,
-0.0540097579,
0.0389433838,
0.0036222842,
0.0354539566,
0.0236972906,
-0.0226543248,
-0.0481362082,
-0.0051450697,
-0.0412777327,
0.0263332482,
-0.0052624722,
0.0314073823,
-0.0007259764,
0.0104676429,
-0.0339719094,
-0.0180632826,
0.0667732954,
0.0274481643,
0.0215039533,
-0.0091704177,
0.0409023203,
0.0137186414,
-0.0012845639,
0.0149464235,
-0.047947932,
-0.0217367783,
0.0077980105,
-0.0368727483,
0.0088414624,
0.0418080315,
2.427e-7,
-0.0142366542,
-0.0018951397,
0.026061831,
-0.0010498035,
-0.0333906487,
0.0167662948,
-0.0279587526,
-0.0031634544,
-0.0329550989,
-0.0296575427,
-0.0274314322,
0.0371211283,
-0.0037147265,
0.0770588443,
-0.0880149156,
0.0110263294,
-0.0306672007,
-0.0731912032,
-0.0584123135,
-0.0265893936,
-0.0169037227,
0.012208405,
0.068953976,
0.003738926,
-0.019723272,
-0.0480240807,
0.0409216434,
0.018453408,
-0.0967575908,
0.041284129,
0.0387876183,
-0.0168166179,
-0.0282001309,
0.0229317378,
-0.0171674453,
0.0256726947,
0.0384498462,
0.0572395846,
0.0232563857,
0.0319352522,
0.0005513483,
-0.0281864349,
0.0063058482,
-0.0053747329,
0.0588748567,
0.0552407354,
-0.0209419969,
-0.01821886,
0.0008951575,
0.0215772502,
-0.0054862704,
-0.035977833,
-0.0141543113,
0.0011130112,
0.0317473002,
-0.0587170199,
-0.0342132486,
0.0074724504,
-0.0139342239,
0.0396642052,
-0.0035941552,
-0.0844034255,
0.042392619,
-0.0245875716,
0.0247158501,
-0.0311635528,
0.0425101295,
1.889890826e-34,
0.047913406,
-0.004580766,
-0.0004524155,
-0.0216677357,
0.0559666976,
-0.0188530013,
-0.0338304453,
-0.0235576965,
-0.0122459177,
-0.0547578037,
-0.0119485278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04761v1 | Toolformer: Language Models Can Teach Themselves to Use Tools | 2023-02-09T16:49:57 | 2023-02-09T16:49:57 | Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Roberto Dessì, Roberta Raileanu, Maria Lomeli, Luke Zettlemoyer, Nicola Cancedda, Thomas Scialom | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) exhibit remarkable abilities to solve new tasks from
just a few examples or textual instructions, especially at scale. They also,
paradoxically, struggle with basic functionality, such as arithmetic or factual
lookup, where much simpler and smaller models excel. In this paper, we show
that LMs can teach themselves to use external tools via simple APIs and achieve
the best of both worlds. We introduce Toolformer, a model trained to decide
which APIs to call, when to call them, what arguments to pass, and how to best
incorporate the results into future token prediction. This is done in a
self-supervised way, requiring nothing more than a handful of demonstrations
for each API. We incorporate a range of tools, including a calculator, a Q\&A
system, two different search engines, a translation system, and a calendar.
Toolformer achieves substantially improved zero-shot performance across a
variety of downstream tasks, often competitive with much larger models, without
sacrificing its core language modeling abilities. | [
0.0209460948,
0.0686482936,
-0.0092401411,
0.036142271,
-0.0397099853,
0.0011088664,
0.0180286802,
0.0103821307,
0.0190432146,
-0.0723890066,
-0.0306719579,
-0.018934194,
-0.0353146233,
0.0657535121,
0.0223138686,
-0.0420426317,
0.0504279025,
-0.0408363342,
0.0035314835,
0.0108066602,
-0.0197959561,
0.0243411101,
-0.0092819948,
0.0719225258,
-0.0220078584,
-0.0127096297,
-0.0191703718,
-0.0178189669,
-0.0444200374,
-0.0032020903,
0.0150081953,
0.0468133949,
0.0189358834,
0.1022164747,
0.0000017665,
-0.0535232797,
-0.0113955438,
-0.0025551568,
-0.0470119528,
-0.016971102,
0.0311840698,
-0.0034145624,
0.0093943179,
0.0424923562,
-0.0760315657,
-0.0416453034,
0.0279457401,
-0.0031344914,
0.0505514443,
0.0772172064,
0.0001424853,
-0.0006010979,
-0.0184645448,
-0.0263942238,
-0.0038459387,
-0.0351905562,
-0.0113097942,
-0.0383801572,
-0.0046535549,
-0.003472073,
-0.0026220668,
0.0207629576,
0.03118168,
-0.020545803,
0.0015701842,
0.0484608598,
-0.0725178495,
-0.0307664927,
-0.0179531388,
0.0321325101,
-0.0586719364,
-0.0661747679,
0.0136639895,
-0.0036918439,
-0.0065110135,
-0.0132301254,
-0.0621293113,
-0.0064191408,
0.0308544319,
0.0080061415,
0.0185964592,
-0.0327826478,
0.0384535119,
0.0450669453,
-0.023148587,
0.0708552375,
0.006367872,
0.0120506799,
-0.015105485,
0.0159999821,
0.0224386752,
-0.0931832567,
-0.0131996516,
0.0717292726,
-0.0339554735,
0.024075143,
-0.0451184958,
-0.0340415575,
0.0235529561,
-0.057949122,
0.013932406,
0.0614944696,
-0.0337556265,
0.0436522514,
-0.0568925031,
0.0252228249,
0.018085964,
0.0512205213,
-0.0183588788,
-0.0060535059,
-0.0348011293,
-0.0218868982,
-0.0362015106,
0.0373169929,
-0.0206550527,
-0.0248191413,
-0.0151472446,
0.0276250262,
0.0170701481,
0.0291206837,
0.0165515598,
-0.0011882383,
-0.0388990752,
-0.0395767167,
-0.0226827469,
0.0487431958,
-0.0414747521,
0.0045358124,
0.031221427,
-0.0565986075,
-0.0319962278,
0.0016245825,
0.0108474335,
0.0071357046,
0.0024253691,
0.110654071,
-0.0194483828,
0.0015471757,
-0.0276476312,
-0.0275741033,
0.0237598922,
-0.0475926697,
-0.0003224175,
-0.0946486518,
0.0200562999,
0.0427018292,
-0.020410426,
-0.03915672,
0.0259801876,
0.0082234284,
-0.001791434,
0.0795037076,
0.0153038222,
-0.0053753494,
0.0391529799,
-0.0107784923,
-0.0113543198,
0.0978841037,
0.0204472076,
0.0436934158,
0.0368414856,
0.008763805,
0.0259726103,
0.0705013648,
0.0069493437,
-0.0153415138,
-0.0589480884,
0.0048224544,
0.0255749263,
0.0298540294,
0.0002935099,
0.0368727408,
-0.0009968099,
0.0130585041,
0.0269389711,
0.0409066863,
0.0296946093,
0.0022074052,
0.0807706341,
-0.02616979,
-0.0084005957,
-0.0291582122,
-0.0960157365,
0.0204554573,
-0.0146902949,
0.0105299158,
0.0172128063,
0.0174031295,
-0.0256474111,
-0.0523647256,
-0.017624082,
-0.0305448323,
-0.0327727608,
-0.0113026667,
0.0597371869,
0.024518678,
-0.0317070372,
0.0369691886,
0.0126052974,
-0.032443136,
0.0129807135,
-0.071567066,
0.0052767238,
0.035509713,
0.0570584647,
-0.0232798941,
-0.0386200994,
-0.0057915077,
0.0075615859,
0.0404593311,
0.0694736391,
-0.031732142,
0.0212631002,
-0.0351422951,
0.0002890124,
0.0001997461,
0.0250477139,
0.0003028364,
0.0340978466,
0.0061195525,
0.0196014233,
-0.0842114985,
-0.0157630835,
0.0467153043,
-0.0156702474,
-0.0518905409,
0.0203433167,
0.0153179038,
-0.0089973761,
-0.024972938,
0.0263720527,
0.0301721357,
0.0304571483,
-0.0245448574,
-0.0289010797,
0.0052963137,
-0.0209881626,
-0.0216084383,
0.0694350749,
0.0413482226,
-0.0098812794,
0.0206527896,
-0.0399026833,
-0.0492996909,
0.0576880313,
0.0003371068,
0.0857256204,
-0.0128834294,
0.0247892402,
-0.0010326382,
-0.0311951395,
0.0022248221,
0.0607621372,
0.0034400658,
0.0172298402,
-0.0308212023,
0.0119989663,
0.0014948489,
0.0057300776,
-0.0096000088,
0.0001434013,
-0.0221757498,
0.0232684091,
0.0021027275,
0.0157275014,
-0.0362446979,
-0.0277098827,
-0.083520703,
-0.0040150173,
-0.0402737036,
0.0227906518,
0.0121212713,
0.012898135,
-0.0019982962,
-0.056732703,
-0.0077931662,
-0.0195440371,
-0.0127346683,
0.0325018354,
0.0173024163,
0.0390510932,
0.0021637012,
-0.0432078689,
-0.0134909879,
-0.0445391722,
0.0412639901,
0.002830843,
0.0003304658,
-0.0229685567,
-0.0089599751,
-0.0344570987,
0.0439257957,
-0.0062306952,
-0.0178652983,
0.0120211709,
-0.0464214981,
-0.0100171575,
0.0534204319,
-0.0150270956,
0.0294328742,
0.0599365644,
0.0104004322,
-0.1021981686,
0.012249005,
0.0037718846,
-0.0256016813,
-0.0118033485,
-0.0062393271,
-0.02048821,
0.0687342063,
-0.0148815224,
0.0174744278,
-0.0279519521,
0.0529708825,
-0.0009298689,
-0.0436571427,
-0.0039986148,
0.0203807764,
-0.0339879431,
0.0293546151,
-0.0006565159,
-0.0721594468,
0.0750824139,
-0.0272226334,
-0.0298317783,
-0.0168412756,
-0.0120585812,
-0.0302338582,
0.0691167116,
0.0169214662,
-0.0065643885,
-0.0083618453,
-0.0429462269,
-0.0528633632,
0.018215267,
0.0011927468,
-0.038430348,
0.071696192,
-0.0513249896,
0.0247262083,
0.0150192836,
-0.0361480638,
-0.0594699904,
-0.0170969144,
-0.0649292246,
0.0433146134,
-0.0600349195,
-0.0291816797,
-0.020518925,
-0.0116172675,
0.005180005,
0.0876859128,
-0.0375794992,
-0.0084246071,
-0.0136041744,
-0.0029647874,
0.0583922938,
0.0093894787,
-0.0089946883,
-0.0147737367,
0.0305682942,
-0.0073783784,
0.0984135121,
-0.0386022367,
-0.0440433621,
-0.0163256712,
0.0178909376,
-0.0466706827,
-0.0080781057,
0.0343745574,
0.015986545,
-0.0673151985,
-0.0207896121,
0.1216315702,
0.0356114507,
-0.0456342138,
-0.0029269373,
-0.0352714956,
0.0115304934,
0.0604003519,
0.0589127801,
-0.0857177824,
-0.0396511406,
0.0095096594,
0.0273707695,
0.0121399919,
-0.022700144,
-0.0141912298,
-0.1363178194,
0.0060387268,
-0.0005753614,
-0.0493084043,
0.0132871903,
-0.0346121266,
-0.0046673003,
-0.0317666903,
-0.0022373432,
0.0135244848,
-0.023745222,
0.0034094984,
0.0045501082,
-0.0259878505,
-0.0377751812,
0.0145611083,
-0.0195513964,
0.0385129154,
0.0590114072,
-0.0163013767,
-0.0197458044,
0.0156502202,
0.0635857433,
0.0100553958,
0.0055128187,
-0.0483218879,
0.0356826819,
0.0003979788,
-0.0185560472,
0.0482388549,
0.0325606242,
-0.0194951389,
-0.0065005277,
-0.0086487578,
0.0791449174,
-0.0113776419,
-0.0176472552,
0.0082620699,
-0.0254390333,
0.0179239847,
0.0446002185,
0.0348141901,
-0.0220379792,
-0.0435606129,
-0.0621566288,
-0.021725338,
-0.053304974,
-0.0341514423,
-0.0307241417,
0.0035959098,
-0.0266813841,
-0.0574473292,
-0.0177402887,
0.0722505078,
0.0552563332,
0.0076195048,
-0.0000751719,
-0.0140354652,
0.0225524921,
-0.0407052785,
0.0116758021,
-0.0211048238,
0.0025601077,
-0.0555928722,
-0.0256337766,
0.0286399797,
-0.0043265428,
-0.0092466883,
0.0215155967,
-0.0577383749,
-0.083007358,
-0.0090367021,
0.0894091576,
0.032033816,
0.0452363864,
-0.0455146283,
-0.0351681598,
0.0225365032,
0.0883764923,
-0.0424931273,
-0.0197330769,
0.0338410623,
0.0003007752,
0.0102527179,
0.0529061928,
-0.0651103705,
0.0001372139,
-0.0047084852,
0.0345048346,
-0.0420825593,
0.0062671439,
0.0385063253,
0.0076357983,
0.0269775148,
-0.0340419114,
0.0372071639,
-0.0203182902,
0.0092147049,
-0.0111339781,
-0.0275171921,
-0.0234710258,
0.0104573909,
-0.0214414261,
0.0230039172,
0.0184510816,
0.0102759972,
-0.0316959172,
0.0445860103,
-0.0255342778,
0.0014387033,
0.000755508,
0.035856612,
0.0422143042,
0.0073994235,
-0.0096554039,
-0.0182894785,
0.0209175404,
0.0327814966,
-0.0595652759,
0.0121896723,
0.015399863,
0.0330992229,
-0.0177394841,
-0.0025615667,
-0.0622737855,
-0.0963295624,
-0.034896452,
0.0040420392,
0.0340914093,
-0.0528504476,
0.0153081287,
-0.0461510271,
-0.0082931938,
-0.0205540713,
0.0163699444,
0.0306804664,
-0.0362350941,
0.0045423964,
0.0160463694,
-0.0106833968,
-0.0280753467,
0.0761007592,
-0.0303097852,
0.0568382479,
0.0365095586,
0.0194059405,
-0.0362141319,
-0.0261723921,
0.0211450141,
0.0011779813,
-0.0276164878,
0.0054534487,
-0.0383932702,
-0.0774901137,
-0.00806705,
0.0141529413,
-0.023255121,
-0.0061608721,
0.0327610113,
0.0724432543,
-0.0000490332,
0.0213592481,
-0.0409422033,
0.0405289121,
0.0241363943,
-0.0360645093,
-0.0181245506,
-5.579433978e-33,
-0.0294087548,
-0.0218496826,
0.0264956877,
0.0111601558,
0.0482298285,
0.0188844074,
-0.0411235318,
0.0193457361,
-0.0364528485,
-0.003451193,
-0.0318529345,
0.0122959297,
0.0338296182,
0.0018001347,
0.072883293,
-0.0145760654,
0.0416188501,
-0.0410278104,
-0.0363862514,
-0.0085176164,
0.0295292493,
0.0274097435,
0.0826529041,
-0.0335250944,
-0.0062225335,
0.0134834619,
-0.0126718534,
0.0536383055,
0.0297364816,
0.0691484064,
0.0308545101,
0.0370377302,
0.0133607872,
-0.0211663153,
-0.0342015699,
-0.0011660134,
-0.066313751,
-0.0605279915,
0.0250303037,
0.0281601064,
-0.020428054,
-0.0093745599,
0.0548607707,
-0.0340854079,
-0.0185650457,
0.0133074773,
0.0267794318,
0.0025151926,
-0.0182191562,
0.0100669339,
-0.0533398017,
0.0078557739,
0.023408059,
-0.0445946902,
0.0320033692,
0.034406092,
0.0161377639,
-0.0194248855,
-0.0316853859,
0.0186876636,
-0.001511519,
0.0662789941,
0.0929115117,
0.0273452327,
-0.0236446857,
0.0584165417,
0.0000957065,
-0.0189778619,
-0.0200471599,
-0.0095316591,
0.0614265129,
0.0441688113,
0.026674442,
-0.0068141334,
0.0251022428,
0.0061582439,
-0.0016755917,
0.0295457188,
0.061371401,
0.0390293412,
-0.0127027184,
-0.0000554525,
-0.0003750151,
0.0056537348,
-0.0216004681,
-0.0199812856,
-0.0492412038,
-0.0271571223,
0.0072080726,
0.0316765681,
0.0141562959,
0.0002100443,
0.030999966,
-0.0403393358,
-0.0251275003,
0.0289144088,
0.0038190996,
0.0212899223,
0.0032895969,
0.0349730439,
-0.0456767865,
-0.0205775611,
-0.0172762182,
0.0073047252,
0.0264337137,
0.0182195939,
0.023726115,
0.0221798327,
-0.0881196782,
-0.0001163334,
-0.057588499,
0.0076923985,
0.0040791947,
-0.0261338856,
0.034701325,
0.0016628898,
-0.0202073958,
0.024107961,
-0.0039328923,
-0.0218097158,
-0.0306195691,
0.0089855539,
0.0055047069,
0.0189685319,
-0.0584124997,
-0.0355198346,
-0.0430363193,
0.0266346913,
0.0321574844,
-0.0215402916,
-0.0055537843,
0.0016725775,
2.458e-7,
0.0595967136,
0.0478564128,
0.0029088603,
0.0506049246,
-0.0008896018,
0.0384386778,
-0.0261204354,
0.0336673073,
-0.0145070804,
-0.0003294068,
-0.0300325006,
-0.0042623919,
0.0327987708,
0.0383658148,
-0.0993191972,
0.0178119112,
-0.0575869754,
0.0160247274,
-0.0579255186,
-0.0133430669,
-0.0077953744,
0.1108062714,
0.0371244177,
-0.0033179882,
-0.0364988483,
-0.050778348,
0.0255030729,
0.0123641519,
-0.0057618306,
0.0250913985,
-0.0208640229,
0.0542676449,
0.007948515,
0.0013925626,
-0.0533994175,
0.01659224,
0.0134469178,
0.0497516617,
-0.0103327008,
-0.0081583224,
-0.0023343756,
-0.0236991495,
0.00309633,
-0.0429576486,
0.0534949936,
-0.0334254503,
0.0096840458,
-0.0238902383,
0.0305194873,
0.0384745896,
-0.0287455246,
-0.0183179919,
-0.0239880141,
0.0478091501,
0.0235870313,
0.0001423058,
-0.0118047697,
-0.0641111284,
-0.0708519891,
0.0232409909,
-0.0182377156,
-0.0235913731,
-0.0545392297,
-0.0146536008,
-0.0090034623,
-0.042166058,
-0.0062786681,
2.321853431e-34,
0.0381209366,
0.0063527743,
0.0025174418,
0.0922517478,
0.0124095427,
-0.000214487,
0.0095208567,
0.0494666845,
0.0346863046,
-0.0316813774,
-0.0270153694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04725v1 | Lightweight Transformers for Clinical Natural Language Processing | 2023-02-09T16:07:31 | 2023-02-09T16:07:31 | Omid Rohanian, Mohammadmahdi Nouriborji, Hannah Jauncey, Samaneh Kouchaki, ISARIC Clinical Characterisation Group, Lei Clifton, Laura Merson, David A. Clifton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | Specialised pre-trained language models are becoming more frequent in NLP
since they can potentially outperform models trained on generic texts. BioBERT
and BioClinicalBERT are two examples of such models that have shown promise in
medical NLP tasks. Many of these models are overparametrised and
resource-intensive, but thanks to techniques like Knowledge Distillation (KD),
it is possible to create smaller versions that perform almost as well as their
larger counterparts. In this work, we specifically focus on development of
compact language models for processing clinical texts (i.e. progress notes,
discharge summaries etc). We developed a number of efficient lightweight
clinical transformers using knowledge distillation and continual learning, with
the number of parameters ranging from 15 million to 65 million. These models
performed comparably to larger models such as BioBERT and ClinicalBioBERT and
significantly outperformed other compact models trained on general or
biomedical data. Our extensive evaluation was done across several standard
datasets and covered a wide range of clinical text-mining tasks, including
Natural Language Inference, Relation Extraction, Named Entity Recognition, and
Sequence Classification. To our knowledge, this is the first comprehensive
study specifically focused on creating efficient and compact transformers for
clinical NLP tasks. The models and code used in this study can be found on our
Huggingface profile at https://huggingface.co/nlpie and Github page at
https://github.com/nlpie-research/Lightweight-Clinical-Transformers,
respectively, promoting reproducibility of our results. | [
0.0641716719,
0.0452969335,
0.016827615,
-0.0249035452,
-0.0121339178,
0.0217586104,
-0.0326318741,
0.0333387218,
-0.0148414075,
-0.0234762616,
-0.0080780257,
-0.0404352024,
0.0067443834,
0.0343808532,
-0.0086684469,
-0.0577258058,
0.0397952683,
0.0100215413,
0.0299105756,
0.0102088721,
-0.012260288,
0.0044639977,
-0.0225974489,
0.0608698651,
0.0227124505,
0.0022323919,
0.0201394986,
-0.0085202074,
0.0167278778,
-0.0769337416,
0.0148351323,
0.0335538797,
-0.0230695866,
-0.0175986271,
0.000002004,
-0.0282513108,
-0.0202261377,
0.0314184949,
-0.0437370054,
-0.035162136,
0.0447202586,
-0.0734037757,
0.0249204673,
0.0154647166,
-0.0456913635,
-0.0569515787,
0.0183206834,
0.0801937804,
0.0598033667,
0.0498409793,
-0.0143925091,
-0.0077892444,
0.0233923011,
-0.024483284,
-0.004928797,
-0.0202228371,
0.0402100421,
-0.0112168193,
0.0160635151,
0.0033309094,
0.0074947532,
0.0214222018,
-0.0240014177,
0.0446621738,
0.0219133906,
0.0383694768,
-0.0493548885,
-0.0378176756,
-0.0013824767,
0.0698840395,
-0.0348887853,
-0.0185093526,
0.0507287495,
0.0014175365,
-0.0329637825,
0.0074490854,
-0.0317244641,
0.0035877631,
-0.0357972272,
0.0038560692,
0.0056416327,
0.0189179704,
0.0272843409,
-0.0226292685,
-0.0329926796,
-0.0179376714,
0.0053449217,
-0.0065865261,
0.0197552592,
-0.0069593168,
-0.0304912105,
-0.0529677123,
0.0297525767,
0.038893383,
-0.003346558,
0.0072591286,
-0.0264166184,
-0.0225135013,
0.0680216923,
-0.0674983561,
0.0061763511,
0.0022127221,
0.0088941129,
0.0243228097,
-0.0246859733,
0.0014523638,
-0.0035360514,
0.0288135037,
-0.0102788825,
0.0125665097,
-0.0518592224,
0.0040512974,
-0.0199891813,
0.0375676639,
-0.0091076279,
-0.0136557873,
-0.063144125,
-0.0030182577,
0.0158520155,
0.0092382841,
0.0637279302,
0.0374843031,
-0.0179374758,
0.0150776831,
-0.0017269612,
0.0467182435,
-0.0021996058,
-0.013242566,
-0.0238196962,
-0.0508309565,
0.0043743681,
-0.0241019018,
0.0206190199,
-0.0328727923,
0.0491655134,
0.0687064528,
0.0262042563,
-0.0593727976,
-0.0040784813,
-0.0165965743,
-0.0264018606,
-0.0249093603,
-0.0065079466,
-0.0603799596,
0.0465013571,
0.0256410409,
0.0204415284,
-0.0737101808,
0.0350785553,
0.0039187814,
-0.0611366779,
0.0670376495,
-0.0692623109,
-0.000134043,
-0.0350148417,
0.0300261527,
-0.0115550645,
0.0329031721,
0.0347174369,
-0.0498348065,
-0.0026202782,
-0.0088274796,
0.0002738239,
-0.0030579241,
0.0055158874,
-0.0701876357,
0.0104652345,
0.0147911431,
-0.018556837,
0.0255360622,
-0.0264927223,
0.0632276088,
-0.0025195694,
-0.0039147777,
0.0301235262,
0.0495960936,
0.0348851532,
0.020372685,
0.0060008215,
-0.012636994,
0.0339835286,
-0.0357709527,
-0.0134343849,
-0.0083533144,
0.0307181999,
-0.0008154203,
-0.0494702496,
0.0212492868,
-0.0273281671,
-0.0455890335,
-0.0206786171,
-0.0240396485,
-0.0225328859,
-0.0083326222,
0.0484728888,
0.0110696582,
-0.028165374,
0.107446827,
0.0701349452,
-0.0483898707,
-0.0183440205,
-0.049119927,
-0.0552489161,
0.0308270287,
0.0466923378,
-0.0507344939,
-0.0645352975,
-0.0398601629,
-0.0184956621,
-0.0290160384,
0.0111219371,
-0.0129063129,
0.041678153,
-0.038543079,
0.0041877371,
0.0428817607,
0.0247116424,
-0.0571659021,
0.029348081,
0.0265062358,
-0.0072043235,
-0.0552012138,
-0.0201643091,
0.0550634675,
-0.0650312454,
-0.0289874449,
0.0114352694,
-0.0111825578,
0.0209626909,
0.0058410503,
-0.0196869615,
0.0188400634,
0.0557271056,
-0.0520662926,
-0.0269153249,
0.0153195085,
-0.0149616301,
-0.0703960359,
0.0061375112,
-0.0107051171,
0.0223448258,
0.0143494997,
-0.0255247205,
-0.0137192272,
-0.0618753359,
-0.0310133137,
0.059336707,
0.0120882262,
0.0308013782,
0.0427633561,
0.0056170793,
-0.044526957,
0.0195754748,
-0.0255688205,
0.0136233745,
0.0022220938,
-0.0722308457,
0.0027860177,
0.0089395838,
-0.0443849526,
0.0180020537,
-0.031767305,
-0.0102730915,
0.0056476123,
-0.0037911821,
0.0161381271,
-0.0343199186,
-0.1183325425,
0.0062252018,
0.0034501357,
0.0138796512,
0.0443204716,
0.0582583472,
0.0036687613,
-0.0275044926,
-0.017750483,
-0.0296520852,
0.0226029232,
0.0082791457,
0.0253299493,
0.0450901538,
0.0141497487,
-0.0178144425,
-0.0106026698,
-0.0174956899,
0.0518546365,
-0.015882358,
-0.0247522388,
0.0013726824,
0.0195996184,
-0.0264973734,
0.0105236135,
-0.0041688448,
-0.0104031498,
0.0069528832,
-0.0147602586,
0.0125639727,
0.0270931665,
0.0160487071,
0.0430299155,
0.021208616,
0.0045619993,
-0.0022021846,
0.0238499306,
-0.0544660911,
-0.0106286788,
-0.0076545812,
-0.0323708616,
0.0019157227,
0.0931563303,
-0.0055645686,
-0.0148210255,
-0.0385069475,
-0.0657574683,
-0.0139463767,
0.038047377,
-0.0215362776,
0.0316571444,
-0.0341573656,
0.0062051103,
0.0011545762,
-0.018694032,
0.0727531984,
-0.0270049553,
0.0331247039,
-0.071425043,
-0.0306053404,
-0.0316560529,
0.0371665619,
0.0112217199,
0.0167376902,
0.0093887486,
-0.0036577666,
0.0045377957,
0.0381259806,
-0.0045575644,
-0.0661616251,
0.0802403241,
-0.0101751089,
0.0354521461,
0.0012838145,
-0.0503980964,
-0.0554023795,
-0.0290515274,
-0.0451429859,
-0.008977904,
0.002643713,
0.0053318613,
-0.0722011551,
0.045104973,
-0.0203385781,
0.090163298,
0.0221331883,
-0.0190765224,
-0.0063665803,
0.0199598353,
0.0278494991,
-0.0034758928,
0.0115557713,
-0.0250622705,
0.0340388007,
0.0879656449,
0.0044479165,
0.0294158794,
0.008005078,
-0.0005551871,
0.0145728495,
-0.0503537618,
-0.0130967246,
0.0235932246,
0.0503687449,
-0.0681446567,
-0.008584071,
0.109055385,
0.0225445237,
-0.047033783,
0.0436796546,
0.0275459811,
-0.0022390559,
-0.0102187861,
0.0042141811,
-0.0431300625,
-0.0544932857,
0.0200197976,
0.0327384472,
-0.0045742299,
-0.0540189072,
0.0155560309,
-0.0104552489,
-0.0061044139,
-0.0090215877,
-0.0291987993,
-0.0088873031,
-0.0670509711,
-0.006716588,
-0.0373260491,
-0.0553626418,
-0.0050269486,
-0.04930076,
0.0108462516,
0.002136695,
-0.0717574209,
-0.0911577642,
0.0160821266,
-0.0115217539,
0.0434064493,
0.0325994305,
0.0242075548,
0.0085897455,
0.008558684,
0.0076774899,
-0.0275964588,
-0.0192246754,
-0.0018650269,
0.0761407316,
-0.0010622442,
-0.023893645,
-0.0395786054,
0.0164722651,
-0.0580135025,
-0.0448549502,
-0.0291717332,
0.0441760421,
-0.0212927535,
-0.0311656371,
-0.0404479578,
-0.0061756326,
0.0037708965,
0.058250457,
-0.0172048397,
0.0011547621,
-0.0414244942,
0.0366471037,
0.0316367224,
0.0149922715,
-0.0618207268,
0.0267181545,
-0.0314115137,
-0.0156490225,
-0.0408827104,
-0.0079289237,
0.0484615527,
0.0030385274,
0.0035956344,
0.0176709238,
0.0477535017,
0.0248436537,
-0.1029294729,
0.0614630096,
0.0532613322,
-0.0072935466,
-0.0630154684,
-0.0515126996,
0.0601902045,
0.0180775933,
-0.0323040038,
0.0029782462,
-0.0522410274,
-0.0040444559,
0.0090242689,
0.0579759739,
0.0207381845,
-0.0151262125,
0.0124333939,
-0.0015915181,
0.0499677733,
0.0506381206,
-0.0466058776,
-0.0272245966,
-0.0079381736,
-0.0231494159,
-0.0090108495,
0.0205944367,
0.0010056749,
0.0392596759,
-0.0094068237,
0.0576421916,
-0.0156969726,
-0.0241164416,
0.0098064644,
0.0380530395,
0.0460892543,
-0.0203843676,
-0.0381559543,
-0.0202660821,
0.0231212601,
0.0034257791,
0.0429743566,
-0.0530850627,
0.0312167332,
0.0184531976,
0.0356293358,
-0.0236079488,
0.0439830571,
-0.0226436015,
-0.0332869478,
-0.0349242613,
0.0360495374,
0.0267718863,
-0.0134998439,
0.0736315623,
-0.0137433726,
0.0040115528,
0.0089499587,
0.0137333563,
-0.0002558052,
-0.0365516879,
0.0290493723,
0.009549154,
0.0479483306,
-0.0075413333,
0.0700259209,
-0.082014665,
0.0065341471,
-0.0364870727,
0.0195645764,
0.0216768943,
-0.0059459028,
0.0373313986,
-0.0401486531,
0.0203706678,
-0.0226292554,
0.0445086919,
-0.033373788,
0.041696012,
0.018573096,
0.0145005276,
-0.0196856111,
-0.0201513264,
0.1060836092,
0.0102008153,
0.0554236919,
0.0134561555,
-0.0216216985,
-0.0532601438,
-0.0153308557,
0.0057737739,
0.0143626248,
-0.0478953496,
0.0045409598,
-0.0601412281,
-0.048670914,
0.0668643713,
-0.0584376641,
-0.019690061,
-0.0280942991,
0.0524590835,
0.0088159032,
0.0166202616,
-0.0128395827,
-0.0192122255,
0.0382381268,
0.001430894,
-0.0172380693,
0.0294117182,
-5.777580448e-33,
0.029051438,
-0.0069261221,
0.0051341858,
-0.0238477346,
-0.0183623433,
0.0508143008,
-0.0229415745,
-0.0105214939,
-0.0068480452,
0.0338259526,
-0.0389242955,
0.0018164946,
0.0080111269,
0.0483216308,
-0.0047013997,
-0.0147131514,
0.0351725221,
0.0162180327,
-0.0239011403,
0.0405061878,
-0.0203039479,
0.0911845565,
0.0403610989,
-0.0697345734,
-0.0232522786,
0.0016188988,
0.0357334875,
0.001656014,
0.0196397919,
0.051201988,
-0.0475233383,
0.0202646889,
0.0416346118,
-0.0097025177,
-0.0153191732,
-0.0111629013,
-0.1264975816,
-0.0050169146,
-0.0110228462,
-0.01858069,
-0.0317562558,
0.0110060824,
0.0613320693,
-0.0090703228,
-0.0037625395,
-0.0158630479,
0.0073764892,
-0.0340411402,
-0.0204723179,
-0.0600264966,
-0.0211234894,
0.0516620129,
0.0154205458,
-0.0105365673,
0.0157482661,
-0.0074765943,
-0.032452032,
0.0364452861,
-0.0255155116,
-0.0335028656,
0.0194231141,
0.0621723011,
-0.023756979,
-0.0383707359,
-0.0205024313,
0.0709910989,
-0.0125828981,
-0.0100135244,
-0.0399656743,
0.0119417096,
-0.0379110165,
0.0625740811,
0.0305203386,
-0.0038489103,
0.0352164172,
-0.0463443659,
-0.0910531357,
0.0307053421,
-0.0273340326,
0.0590145253,
0.0143193239,
-0.0523041077,
-0.0147611555,
0.0049545174,
-0.0303217117,
0.0010381022,
0.000275065,
-0.0009500107,
0.0322720222,
0.0263359528,
-0.012184645,
0.0342722759,
0.0111866836,
-0.0390755758,
0.0098947398,
-0.0026752697,
0.0390099064,
0.0219040997,
-0.0339375362,
-0.0041104415,
-0.0200897064,
-0.0187223572,
0.0192982461,
-0.0265487116,
0.0396424755,
-0.0037173824,
0.0252704248,
-0.0152868964,
-0.0601874068,
-0.0181892626,
0.0182200093,
0.0196777675,
0.0081224376,
0.0937055871,
0.0348532125,
0.0369264409,
0.0098142568,
0.0362472907,
-0.0052672452,
-0.0078632208,
-0.0338967294,
0.0055261608,
0.0525883958,
0.0172676668,
-0.0193162188,
-0.0255924426,
-0.0430392325,
0.0763768554,
0.0063299923,
-0.0543907098,
-0.0169543419,
-0.0217351057,
2.749e-7,
0.0898727253,
0.0437095389,
-0.0028537537,
-0.0381879956,
0.0149649289,
-0.008609008,
0.0140006263,
0.0200309437,
-0.025677871,
-0.0268361457,
0.0346561633,
0.0211534202,
0.0365688615,
0.0409232825,
-0.0870826319,
-0.0572601445,
-0.0878569633,
-0.0676904917,
-0.0077126999,
-0.0500354357,
0.0501956642,
0.0900809243,
-0.0294364393,
-0.020858245,
0.0201683957,
-0.0114039453,
0.0351597443,
-0.0015334038,
0.0427171625,
0.0584580898,
0.0232039075,
0.0013211011,
0.010008458,
0.0351307243,
-0.0223105233,
0.0123402113,
0.0033642503,
0.130920127,
-0.0626815706,
0.0058254381,
0.0284098834,
0.010791163,
0.022130426,
-0.0181945805,
0.0781640708,
-0.0495550074,
-0.0250357725,
-0.0287817307,
-0.0199748557,
-0.0133267883,
0.0413829163,
0.0135797635,
-0.0136262933,
0.0747934207,
0.0263695084,
0.0132659758,
-0.0560176559,
-0.1114851832,
-0.0241970252,
0.0386002064,
-0.0239276309,
-0.016652884,
0.0184682924,
-0.0465441309,
-0.0039846646,
-0.0543922707,
0.0085428292,
2.784105565e-34,
0.0316375233,
0.0064722467,
-0.0111473333,
0.040841043,
0.0020721625,
-0.0469941609,
0.0183104295,
-0.014558672,
-0.010843168,
-0.0719129592,
-0.0089380704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04716v1 | Improving the Generalizability of Collaborative Dialogue Analysis with Multi-Feature Embeddings | 2023-02-09T15:58:32 | 2023-02-09T15:58:32 | Ayesha Enayet, Gita Sukthankar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conflict prediction in communication is integral to the design of virtual
agents that support successful teamwork by providing timely assistance. The aim
of our research is to analyze discourse to predict collaboration success.
Unfortunately, resource scarcity is a problem that teamwork researchers
commonly face since it is hard to gather a large number of training examples.
To alleviate this problem, this paper introduces a multi-feature embedding
(MFeEmb) that improves the generalizability of conflict prediction models
trained on dialogue sequences. MFeEmb leverages textual, structural, and
semantic information from the dialogues by incorporating lexical, dialogue
acts, and sentiment features. The use of dialogue acts and sentiment features
reduces performance loss from natural distribution shifts caused mainly by
changes in vocabulary.
This paper demonstrates the performance of MFeEmb on domain adaptation
problems in which the model is trained on discourse from one task domain and
applied to predict team performance in a different domain. The generalizability
of MFeEmb is quantified using the similarity measure proposed by Bontonou et
al. (2021). Our results show that MFeEmb serves as an excellent domain-agnostic
representation for meta-pretraining a few-shot model on collaborative
multiparty dialogues. | [
0.0491656289,
0.0317333974,
-0.0218515582,
0.035020411,
-0.0208749026,
0.0072110728,
0.0224995892,
-0.0231528301,
-0.0248054322,
-0.0802448541,
-0.0193590485,
-0.0695261732,
-0.0361989886,
0.0370409638,
0.0034212444,
-0.0825813711,
0.0429926403,
0.0325858183,
0.0458342321,
-0.0011121941,
0.0217321552,
-0.0045015328,
-0.0298741646,
0.0578202531,
-0.0438711084,
-0.0047427984,
-0.0455403626,
-0.0125514418,
0.0602647625,
0.006928789,
-0.0106887743,
0.0466088876,
0.062732935,
-0.0091701839,
0.0000021451,
-0.049423933,
-0.0095611364,
-0.0328851119,
0.0000503376,
-0.0198801253,
0.0362417065,
-0.0031753124,
0.0148419039,
0.0328300111,
-0.0389215201,
-0.0010501944,
0.0236008465,
0.0553199351,
0.0462352931,
0.0841131657,
-0.0128813824,
-0.0113851596,
-0.0324344076,
-0.0036389886,
-0.0485139005,
-0.073325038,
-0.0148221403,
0.0122958329,
-0.0224694908,
-0.0043868008,
-0.0099964775,
-0.0218029637,
-0.0102152526,
-0.0074680718,
-0.0044261417,
0.0213845763,
-0.0472542085,
-0.0026660971,
-0.0001764822,
0.0778817609,
0.0235894006,
0.0278761499,
-0.0031599023,
-0.0184021499,
0.0151974978,
0.026185479,
-0.0071608298,
-0.0389755033,
0.0088187726,
-0.0071746851,
-0.0240743719,
0.0371848308,
0.0046188398,
-0.0203046463,
-0.0011944652,
-0.0149305342,
-0.0080342591,
-0.0113007538,
-0.0384522639,
-0.0070528528,
-0.0273882598,
-0.0294498391,
-0.0299066845,
0.0039182338,
-0.0466403738,
0.0067784828,
-0.0273109004,
-0.0365457647,
-0.010906605,
-0.0667967796,
0.058011733,
0.0205011293,
-0.0004045876,
0.0499724932,
0.014461292,
0.0438489765,
0.0196388364,
0.0041439719,
-0.0342949517,
-0.0177579951,
-0.1049733087,
0.0150666023,
-0.0421589389,
0.0318590999,
-0.0173589308,
-0.0323616564,
-0.0066737393,
0.0344914608,
-0.0238290187,
-0.0042726966,
0.0252525136,
0.0410367288,
-0.0062390431,
-0.0093963575,
-0.0342123024,
0.0335184895,
-0.0479507931,
0.0203285031,
-0.0236698426,
-0.0445588678,
0.004927502,
0.0077998568,
-0.0039800326,
-0.0012699394,
-0.0073359348,
0.0834470168,
-0.0210997686,
-0.0413882956,
0.0312933214,
-0.0035400125,
-0.0302389264,
-0.059456639,
0.0204976015,
-0.0253762528,
0.0477277189,
-0.0358406901,
-0.0132496664,
-0.0077773491,
0.0028954146,
-0.0341997221,
-0.0352143794,
0.0693625584,
-0.0089346347,
0.0210585408,
0.0467437059,
0.0348129123,
-0.0305146314,
0.054911714,
0.036770355,
-0.0011116952,
0.0495435856,
0.0035279626,
-0.0096509764,
-0.005067063,
-0.0203455165,
-0.0069118277,
0.0421436615,
0.011913537,
-0.0063610212,
0.0262884051,
-0.0164900366,
0.0308874547,
-0.0539138056,
-0.0758276582,
0.0457130484,
0.0481620952,
0.0179619957,
0.0232606921,
0.0223798119,
0.0594399385,
-0.0326762162,
-0.0102181528,
-0.0067828577,
0.0431917273,
0.0181786604,
-0.0273379479,
0.0542137176,
0.01967852,
-0.0613812208,
-0.0457201041,
-0.0078378506,
-0.0102955634,
0.0087967906,
-0.0308170877,
0.018283274,
-0.0272319727,
-0.0529269539,
0.0481135137,
0.0067173894,
-0.0446973443,
-0.0286895502,
0.0033036082,
0.0276379455,
0.0555097423,
0.0560597256,
-0.0404798277,
-0.0944381431,
-0.0415226929,
0.0280846339,
0.0085635101,
0.0605476946,
-0.0220877118,
0.0398823358,
-0.0635069013,
-0.0280379634,
-0.0059405528,
0.0037579357,
0.0543197468,
-0.0137112243,
-0.0082729133,
0.0052770511,
0.0452155136,
0.0115385847,
0.0094630169,
-0.0286358148,
0.0043014963,
0.0027251986,
0.0425987653,
0.0822694078,
0.04094081,
-0.0305930302,
-0.0346859992,
0.0352489948,
-0.0334014222,
-0.0418483466,
0.0783123448,
-0.0272705797,
-0.0420351997,
0.0377286859,
-0.0177607946,
0.0237890165,
0.0097474707,
-0.0396712944,
-0.0115943737,
0.0565837324,
-0.0189322568,
-0.02028553,
-0.0214570239,
-0.021811353,
-0.0145211322,
0.0065428177,
0.0125411376,
0.0118959406,
0.002521253,
-0.0272215474,
0.0055951369,
0.0043013687,
0.0507303849,
-0.0142434118,
-0.0038747161,
0.0569182225,
0.0344204642,
0.0171731319,
0.0252374914,
-0.0206625611,
-0.0287362542,
-0.0304417014,
-0.1379618794,
-0.0153718246,
-0.0140550034,
0.0002284842,
0.0119280191,
-0.0351670124,
-0.0085302172,
-0.0217561182,
-0.0315610208,
0.0191344805,
0.0285014957,
0.0219647475,
0.0248483196,
0.0205247011,
0.0134781413,
-0.0443979576,
0.0455741063,
-0.0022464518,
0.043871548,
-0.0127050001,
-0.0332293175,
-0.0325010605,
0.0573712066,
-0.0564415194,
0.0320270695,
-0.0357539058,
-0.0459524728,
0.0356341675,
0.0190824308,
0.0326567739,
0.0476947241,
0.0413175151,
0.0320508629,
0.0249384046,
-0.034628462,
-0.0492938571,
0.0501701385,
-0.0210837126,
-0.002332371,
-0.0555835627,
-0.0023393796,
-0.0228531435,
0.043358393,
-0.0046675396,
0.0104568498,
-0.0894593075,
0.017013045,
0.0089612873,
-0.0227988772,
0.0222801063,
-0.0300436728,
-0.0207213815,
-0.0138000231,
-0.0061797742,
-0.0065858881,
0.0748601407,
-0.0074191797,
0.0060282694,
-0.0747182891,
-0.02172851,
-0.0330285281,
0.0730603114,
-0.0229416788,
-0.0017290687,
0.01267015,
0.0065439087,
-0.0780492052,
-0.0183413904,
0.0476823524,
-0.022035148,
0.012486848,
-0.029370809,
-0.0250338055,
-0.0108907633,
-0.0176802389,
-0.0212872792,
-0.0654994324,
-0.0316364951,
0.0221751127,
0.0061946344,
-0.0099857645,
-0.0325292386,
0.0119737005,
-0.0121053653,
-0.0298484527,
0.0386402719,
-0.0097338101,
-0.0006537528,
0.0319660157,
0.0218168236,
0.0414619967,
-0.0292118117,
-0.0287736077,
0.0304327328,
0.0379308388,
0.032682579,
-0.0562527366,
-0.0259202626,
-0.0500404052,
-0.0334419049,
-0.0036902218,
-0.0163310636,
-0.0263207518,
0.0689705089,
-0.0097960681,
0.0200180933,
0.1052114069,
0.0202929657,
-0.0265654325,
-0.0042787581,
-0.0118021313,
0.0055302074,
0.0314319991,
0.0114556858,
-0.0541771278,
-0.0364470072,
-0.0243907776,
-0.004404075,
0.0041434215,
-0.0574126393,
-0.0003105437,
-0.0888642371,
0.0082775559,
-0.0026773897,
0.0175179541,
-0.0322421454,
-0.0073122596,
0.0218561031,
-0.0428126976,
-0.0118184434,
-0.0772462264,
0.046624545,
-0.0083638821,
0.0226021074,
-0.0370265879,
-0.0179136824,
0.0304383989,
-0.045983769,
0.0651703551,
0.0589081831,
0.078304328,
0.032745488,
0.0212365948,
-0.0254780985,
0.0297541525,
0.0175670758,
0.0015773837,
0.0999342352,
-0.0486132875,
0.008322346,
0.033971414,
-0.0079193488,
-0.0056786481,
-0.0095094666,
0.0260061435,
0.05745399,
-0.0275487527,
-0.0108985445,
-0.0209361501,
0.0547002964,
0.0226016976,
0.0415597893,
0.0126514044,
-0.0165723711,
-0.0066718948,
0.0068027801,
0.0255907923,
-0.0080798781,
-0.0241130181,
-0.0679000169,
-0.0006507869,
0.0346582904,
-0.0736647695,
-0.0812456161,
0.0272199363,
0.0346541293,
-0.0318930373,
-0.0116344625,
-0.02403423,
0.0269899815,
-0.0027724612,
0.0019729112,
0.0012968715,
0.0232142415,
-0.0102211712,
0.0063185324,
0.0620149262,
0.0258360989,
-0.0102255307,
-0.0020526957,
-0.0622435845,
-0.0557457618,
-0.0469755605,
0.0598613396,
0.0065824366,
0.0276519805,
0.0163298957,
-0.0217854083,
0.0315683447,
0.0216650814,
-0.0291168354,
0.0284835231,
0.0662726611,
0.0161374584,
-0.0126256412,
0.0464664176,
0.0000651314,
0.0126271071,
-0.0178852342,
0.017857952,
-0.0700332597,
-0.11931739,
-0.0247322693,
-0.0517055392,
0.0563947,
0.0367876217,
-0.0318826623,
-0.0373013951,
0.018114632,
-0.0166528244,
-0.0038633735,
-0.0511195101,
-0.0033968047,
-0.0333898365,
-0.0380676836,
-0.0036683192,
0.0248654503,
-0.0340579189,
0.0494052358,
0.0213734712,
0.0273916349,
0.0331800841,
0.0169644728,
-0.0168345161,
0.032238733,
0.0134306122,
-0.0161048286,
0.0071011805,
-0.0087083541,
0.0046108877,
0.0833313242,
-0.0085078068,
-0.0040418594,
0.0224161185,
0.0531311631,
-0.0621023141,
-0.0285805948,
-0.0031708733,
0.012530881,
0.023178393,
-0.0217693187,
0.0374833122,
-0.0414336585,
0.0234754905,
-0.029291518,
0.0658259839,
-0.0495406613,
-0.017330138,
0.048550304,
0.0426170714,
-0.0388833433,
0.0247150697,
0.0967911407,
-0.0135506531,
0.0372897424,
-0.0203829631,
-0.026050888,
-0.0552436337,
-0.0239575878,
0.060589321,
0.0596018992,
-0.0134654623,
0.0238527711,
-0.0865382031,
-0.0161407534,
0.0458093472,
-0.0278968699,
0.0063567245,
-0.0128794927,
0.0174972154,
0.0398743413,
0.0063971374,
0.0528962277,
-0.0462867096,
-0.0097368024,
-0.0109753599,
0.0094616599,
-0.0215405021,
-5.733387738e-33,
-0.0529307164,
-0.037419267,
0.027710529,
0.0071682245,
-0.0296725687,
0.0092006577,
-0.008358662,
0.0159830675,
-0.0303408075,
0.0119559336,
0.0104972096,
0.0135383895,
0.0015150848,
-0.0307736546,
0.0112854969,
-0.028032491,
0.0514295958,
-0.0375436246,
0.0024290045,
0.0212395582,
0.0594585016,
0.0143092833,
0.0235370547,
-0.0978086516,
-0.0353176109,
0.0125843324,
0.0081661521,
0.0114580384,
0.0375305898,
0.053812284,
0.0139538292,
0.0080268374,
0.0165834315,
-0.0490945242,
-0.0164128598,
0.0031395138,
0.0051378817,
-0.0435705371,
-0.0020547656,
-0.0285759233,
-0.0145240296,
-0.009678958,
-0.0462918393,
0.022268001,
0.0190953054,
-0.0468563661,
0.0351173691,
-0.0209864546,
-0.0235122778,
-0.0281572212,
-0.0675607324,
0.0335943773,
-0.0245224927,
-0.0484724529,
0.0453387983,
0.0636657253,
0.0488961004,
-0.0240099095,
-0.0532386862,
0.0295860823,
-0.0483340621,
-0.0211850591,
0.022412492,
-0.0100440606,
0.0097606163,
0.0794792175,
0.0373498946,
0.0563125163,
-0.0323710255,
-0.0200198051,
-0.0089204358,
0.0627876371,
0.0340667069,
0.1020122766,
-0.0273344256,
-0.0071625849,
-0.0473010391,
0.0183005277,
0.0149690732,
0.0284366254,
0.0248214528,
0.0594736747,
-0.0329109058,
-0.0208012238,
-0.0127328793,
0.0030394886,
0.0103916945,
-0.0716866404,
0.0235826019,
0.011167069,
-0.0043742307,
0.0029141353,
0.0583152883,
-0.0557862259,
0.0401006527,
0.0613305792,
-0.0331659392,
0.0045552542,
-0.007838591,
-0.0188531186,
-0.084459424,
-0.0168454964,
0.0355895311,
0.0116502726,
0.0318154767,
-0.0174274463,
0.0338649601,
0.0119202156,
-0.030027302,
-0.0291988421,
0.0003363272,
-0.0162715204,
-0.0269243978,
0.0594174452,
-0.0075697349,
0.023320334,
-0.0148254,
0.0642202869,
-0.0015333713,
-0.049302835,
-0.0083440142,
0.0118359756,
0.0109412558,
-0.0157543514,
-0.0259991772,
-0.0028350272,
-0.0331686735,
0.0014727887,
0.0182467587,
0.013821994,
-0.0303064715,
-0.0418399535,
2.895e-7,
-0.0044418415,
0.0389235131,
0.0330485292,
-0.0112922965,
0.0089457519,
0.0948440507,
-0.0069170906,
0.0611158162,
0.0048818309,
-0.0258665197,
0.0807984993,
0.0494484231,
0.0399196073,
0.056281276,
-0.0511377901,
-0.0544106737,
-0.0561635792,
-0.0470160693,
-0.0207374655,
-0.0268705692,
0.0792384446,
0.0463665128,
0.058228489,
0.024715241,
-0.0383164436,
-0.0058315857,
0.0493497364,
-0.0425642096,
-0.064639546,
0.0078513399,
-0.0012028359,
-0.0339415967,
-0.0446661226,
0.0178231299,
-0.0243292693,
0.050846193,
0.0058720536,
0.0466564298,
-0.0126400869,
-0.0472739302,
-0.0114996964,
0.011192563,
-0.021478869,
0.0243018474,
0.0212237574,
-0.0720313787,
-0.0307810865,
-0.017159773,
-0.0230907612,
0.0216044243,
0.0700702146,
0.014112195,
-0.0096488465,
0.0164559018,
-0.0026812984,
-0.0055465647,
0.0161124077,
-0.075599879,
0.0255944952,
0.0072815013,
-0.0777783841,
-0.0336655043,
-0.002509956,
-0.0082958126,
0.0369433314,
0.0074333441,
0.0370962843,
2.108263123e-34,
0.0183181781,
0.0161775593,
-0.0189284105,
0.0339067839,
0.0428812243,
-0.0294343289,
-0.0257259849,
-0.0289679803,
0.0698131248,
-0.0223571975,
0.0143797053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04700v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04700v1 | Augmenting NLP data to counter Annotation Artifacts for NLI Tasks | 2023-02-09T15:34:53 | 2023-02-09T15:34:53 | Armaan Singh Bhullar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | In this paper, we explore Annotation Artifacts - the phenomena wherein large
pre-trained NLP models achieve high performance on benchmark datasets but do
not actually "solve" the underlying task and instead rely on some dataset
artifacts (same across train, validation, and test sets) to figure out the
right answer. We explore this phenomenon on the well-known Natural Language
Inference task by first using contrast and adversarial examples to understand
limitations to the model's performance and show one of the biases arising from
annotation artifacts (the way training data was constructed by the annotators).
We then propose a data augmentation technique to fix this bias and measure its
effectiveness. | [
0.024434479,
0.099519223,
-0.0142258517,
0.0580966249,
-0.0133694336,
0.0351675972,
0.0010680493,
0.0053139357,
0.0153183853,
-0.0795823708,
-0.0056025665,
0.0434478857,
-0.0005054003,
-0.0065745488,
0.0271529201,
-0.0582829118,
0.0465930589,
0.0014855759,
-0.0145993913,
0.0075399256,
0.0018589947,
-0.0120771583,
-0.0016414208,
0.0266360827,
-0.0563024879,
-0.0025487912,
-0.0004595934,
0.003520445,
-0.011033956,
-0.033424817,
0.0084717823,
0.0567331165,
0.000429354,
0.074015595,
0.0000018476,
-0.0525090471,
0.0058386521,
0.0289933328,
-0.0876217633,
0.0196708255,
0.0200653467,
-0.024432417,
0.025904635,
-0.0048604934,
-0.0396852307,
-0.0519568697,
0.0519788079,
0.0838877112,
0.0547065474,
0.0772964582,
-0.0096910577,
0.0068921167,
0.0159341246,
-0.0345570482,
0.004970538,
-0.0609049052,
0.027102014,
0.0278001539,
-0.0213333946,
0.0015463111,
-0.016738886,
0.0288384613,
0.0352059193,
0.0589886196,
-0.0119037041,
0.0203650631,
-0.0541554615,
0.005759099,
-0.0121068135,
0.0649485812,
-0.0016313684,
-0.0249769017,
-0.0357400738,
-0.037236169,
0.0119545897,
0.0180054735,
-0.0137408059,
0.0169971939,
0.0056511024,
0.0069357255,
0.0287778769,
-0.0050500338,
0.0477018915,
0.0190321282,
-0.0106648747,
0.0345630795,
0.0019148979,
-0.0185249858,
0.0287789572,
0.0540789217,
-0.0494557209,
-0.0484652184,
0.0023886333,
-0.0004154305,
-0.0019945903,
0.0065520471,
-0.0615330264,
-0.0746660009,
0.0208549425,
-0.0296739861,
0.0458125323,
0.0048450306,
-0.0821689814,
0.0469904914,
-0.0500456803,
-0.0004343574,
-0.0351555385,
0.026521679,
-0.0444590598,
-0.0223153736,
-0.0014056752,
0.0116348732,
-0.0417975746,
0.0303508136,
-0.0461926833,
-0.0075712851,
-0.0215615463,
-0.0129587743,
-0.0394534208,
0.0204795673,
-0.0416570716,
0.0261414815,
-0.0471045561,
0.0066098985,
-0.045308236,
-0.0052548489,
-0.0426929258,
0.0496422797,
-0.0214309897,
-0.0878620222,
-0.0200801603,
0.0288099423,
0.0055192672,
-0.0522279516,
0.0111900494,
0.0900661051,
0.0254917368,
-0.0505117141,
-0.0431710035,
-0.0058532744,
-0.0077392855,
-0.0259180926,
0.004754602,
-0.0258368235,
0.0484440327,
-0.0079658208,
-0.0122872815,
-0.0400988869,
0.0016488034,
-0.0044665695,
-0.0500943847,
0.1059550345,
-0.0561054945,
-0.0429619849,
-0.0018047618,
-0.0071546934,
-0.0375324674,
0.0591773838,
0.0049730134,
0.0041540293,
0.018971255,
0.0191559978,
0.0292046331,
0.0277526099,
0.0479195379,
-0.0004862172,
0.0109144337,
0.0167002939,
-0.0086215865,
0.0142722977,
0.0216856841,
0.0216191765,
-0.0344037004,
-0.0339650065,
0.0379967988,
0.0192769412,
-0.0255773664,
0.0140364962,
0.0043055029,
-0.0337373018,
0.0198456012,
0.046796754,
-0.0584292412,
0.0012709767,
-0.0325551555,
-0.0289934427,
0.0336859822,
-0.0097630993,
-0.0177474357,
-0.0655567199,
-0.0109447548,
-0.024261741,
0.0124999015,
0.0305700153,
0.0409381688,
0.0615530461,
-0.0040083467,
-0.0030080911,
0.0327584967,
0.0018302675,
-0.002406985,
-0.039694123,
-0.002095219,
0.0155900624,
0.0536400415,
-0.0587815046,
-0.0302818716,
-0.0050996607,
0.006129758,
0.0240430124,
0.0724010617,
-0.0060870345,
0.0214479957,
-0.0131258294,
-0.0275745578,
-0.0266190488,
0.0499697961,
0.0289734248,
0.0341540463,
-0.0255133752,
0.0289708544,
-0.046501521,
-0.0674309283,
0.0518997572,
-0.0363356657,
-0.0454327092,
0.0127470037,
0.0257167555,
0.0232810136,
0.0134113375,
-0.0268475078,
0.0045143017,
0.017080538,
-0.0125873871,
-0.020991629,
0.014498461,
0.0088257995,
-0.0517055057,
0.0369461961,
-0.0719390884,
-0.0482589342,
0.0559427775,
-0.0650894716,
-0.0290133245,
-0.0073601734,
-0.0122121032,
0.0351821594,
-0.0213411152,
-0.0112516331,
0.0328120887,
0.0525560156,
-0.0245859083,
0.0583708771,
0.0139818676,
0.0139728924,
-0.0098806359,
0.0330657773,
0.0357288569,
-0.0027456221,
-0.0333461203,
-0.0063148574,
-0.005141139,
0.0027697536,
0.0255045146,
-0.0506314337,
-0.0491426773,
0.031958133,
-0.055157911,
0.0158080067,
-0.0148226619,
-0.0121892998,
0.0354869962,
-0.0138714369,
-0.0078150192,
-0.0492923297,
-0.0090641323,
-0.0355903059,
0.0047561843,
0.0387462303,
0.0565209612,
0.0177728012,
0.0410094336,
-0.0428851582,
-0.0135083552,
-0.0301116426,
0.0404289924,
0.019254351,
-0.0430761911,
-0.050122004,
0.0398179665,
-0.0116433343,
0.086588487,
-0.0167135671,
-0.0024986507,
0.0214620903,
-0.007319733,
-0.0135587705,
0.0788373426,
-0.0375367738,
0.0381158143,
0.0439279489,
0.0140778162,
-0.0436571948,
0.0134528689,
-0.0199036077,
0.0140721882,
0.0052083828,
-0.0175830368,
0.0056529976,
0.0344348326,
-0.0166525561,
-0.0267561935,
-0.0176469851,
0.0170512181,
-0.0289869867,
-0.0210083164,
0.0083336169,
-0.0058178068,
0.0053329389,
0.0617120974,
-0.0331215598,
-0.0271354038,
0.0563800037,
-0.0193862524,
0.0114359707,
-0.0405360274,
-0.0018285575,
-0.0291818921,
0.078245759,
0.033266969,
0.0000948836,
0.0223789401,
-0.0087797483,
-0.0256497115,
-0.0028127155,
0.0112378486,
-0.0149106085,
0.0169160943,
-0.0108367354,
0.0168748721,
-0.0232775472,
-0.0415914096,
-0.0476027802,
-0.0364111103,
-0.0195748694,
-0.0276980307,
0.0107908407,
-0.0032433863,
-0.0152518675,
-0.0380386673,
-0.0246406235,
0.0613197908,
-0.009066008,
-0.0014983838,
-0.0352944471,
0.0220453907,
0.052257292,
0.0283805598,
0.0596268438,
-0.0296196975,
0.0063338652,
0.0523835309,
0.0049360753,
0.0322272889,
-0.0795820355,
0.0067628771,
0.0295779109,
-0.0177926533,
-0.0201935414,
0.006281619,
0.0497630127,
-0.0524029769,
-0.0067936531,
0.0730765015,
0.0095350454,
0.0003875571,
0.0169313475,
0.0389335603,
0.0130622257,
0.0135828219,
0.0046547395,
-0.1412394345,
-0.0420979857,
0.001687536,
-0.0038961854,
-0.0097976923,
-0.0348674133,
-0.0164351091,
-0.1462944001,
0.0181167144,
-0.0181192625,
-0.0307974089,
0.0058852592,
-0.0347385928,
0.0242740624,
-0.0479505695,
0.0401508659,
-0.0480998345,
0.0310012437,
0.0256303027,
0.020675417,
-0.0120271519,
-0.0826964825,
0.002502244,
-0.046141386,
0.0672197416,
0.0434940197,
0.0232259929,
-0.0098289633,
0.0183279142,
0.0623738691,
0.0181179885,
0.0046265121,
0.0051720813,
0.1422646046,
-0.0073503726,
-0.0310815629,
0.0015343844,
0.0188074894,
-0.0195913594,
-0.0193039943,
-0.0083000194,
0.0446535535,
-0.0018772009,
-0.0009772435,
-0.0279069357,
-0.0143566402,
0.0069556022,
0.0785405263,
0.0174722727,
-0.0170995519,
-0.0362268761,
-0.0297214109,
0.0202684868,
-0.0486838855,
-0.0027505958,
0.0659496412,
-0.0027446907,
-0.0285636224,
-0.0559438206,
-0.1014716998,
0.0473865792,
0.0259213783,
0.0225671008,
0.0041892617,
-0.04529218,
-0.0241387971,
-0.0069665667,
0.0849846005,
-0.0528539605,
-0.0026825755,
0.019250527,
-0.0386110805,
-0.014375628,
-0.0146187562,
-0.0053416491,
0.0302149616,
-0.0945039541,
-0.054019127,
0.0148560973,
0.0656366348,
0.0232504047,
0.0793562606,
-0.0459869467,
-0.0571014136,
-0.0285765938,
0.0650521442,
-0.0216276702,
-0.0319189727,
0.0365949199,
-0.0317198895,
0.0099924542,
0.0191971529,
-0.0289933905,
0.0353081189,
0.0496255197,
0.0099879475,
-0.0299310442,
-0.0160113033,
0.0521027781,
0.0249653775,
0.0924608782,
-0.0171150491,
-0.001185754,
-0.0117653795,
-0.0139119346,
-0.0141317686,
-0.0484660827,
-0.0299731307,
0.025393445,
0.0106025273,
0.0190928802,
-0.0083360812,
0.0028936916,
-0.0003593173,
0.0245397929,
-0.0755111799,
-0.0232026931,
0.0756757483,
-0.0075498577,
-0.0024940798,
0.024658611,
-0.0072707706,
0.0354929343,
0.0228347871,
0.0623426847,
0.0028299515,
0.0186176654,
0.0561500676,
0.0280233286,
-0.0035965124,
-0.017165374,
-0.0847564191,
-0.0050648707,
-0.0321613997,
0.0250347592,
0.0710585266,
-0.0887477696,
0.0188878514,
-0.0145466048,
-0.0151424995,
0.0102391578,
0.0007571121,
0.0146944597,
-0.011622428,
0.0165425204,
0.0045326264,
-0.0009241588,
0.0185000319,
0.0394182988,
0.000723367,
0.0852485672,
0.0005587055,
-0.0098607559,
-0.0355144255,
-0.0342953876,
0.0003652368,
-0.002795195,
-0.0062100347,
0.0267914664,
-0.0355630405,
-0.0975671038,
-0.0291510224,
0.006614978,
0.0269875955,
0.0126319509,
0.0031325975,
0.0277924929,
0.0036423877,
-0.0312697887,
-0.0332818143,
0.0069421083,
0.0033290999,
0.0009216623,
-0.0144916205,
-6.284897361e-33,
-0.027439747,
-0.0238792133,
0.0117580779,
-0.0200150907,
0.0203398131,
0.0237836335,
-0.0319041498,
-0.0210084748,
-0.0644602031,
0.0134859877,
-0.0140098063,
0.0170928035,
0.0065117478,
0.0168616045,
-0.0371391401,
-0.0496765375,
0.0472706445,
0.0197079256,
-0.0374532081,
-0.0332029723,
0.0185903106,
0.0152410725,
0.0636675656,
-0.0893406346,
0.0295173246,
0.0045581898,
-0.0160331894,
0.0067648264,
-0.005957433,
0.0361432768,
-0.0092884749,
0.0365596674,
0.0232041795,
-0.0319803543,
-0.0142621724,
-0.0116322404,
-0.0879183635,
-0.0347756371,
-0.0013853613,
0.0699501559,
-0.0453074835,
0.0129414611,
0.041787114,
-0.0194544755,
-0.0002938977,
0.0146628153,
0.0235325061,
-0.0321696997,
0.005439932,
0.0134843197,
-0.0530469194,
0.0273445453,
-0.00727783,
-0.0066538486,
0.0506397523,
0.0336462893,
0.0297770407,
-0.0048139472,
-0.0678661019,
-0.0128431059,
0.0648639575,
0.0116211781,
0.0084165568,
0.0063403472,
-0.0190430284,
0.062622413,
0.0287439581,
0.0403271019,
-0.0326907746,
0.0126128038,
0.0084813954,
0.0305761788,
0.0606096946,
0.0535723753,
0.0943254977,
0.0111730732,
-0.0463438444,
0.0147775123,
-0.0066882707,
-0.0153821316,
-0.0103525324,
-0.0065248352,
-0.0500217378,
-0.0140296193,
-0.0639326796,
-0.0470816866,
-0.0305274781,
-0.0114423642,
0.0307221133,
0.0127324946,
-0.0109367007,
0.0585701093,
-0.0080106063,
-0.0505269282,
-0.0174202807,
-0.0126550337,
-0.0000516914,
-0.0153400982,
-0.0007339549,
0.0166707356,
-0.0284031611,
-0.027632216,
0.0157997124,
0.0021022798,
0.0450684167,
-0.007381367,
0.0965022892,
-0.0069078067,
-0.0562135726,
-0.0021031543,
-0.048883386,
0.0149810845,
0.0317054018,
-0.0145176789,
0.0716442615,
0.0277578123,
-0.0123064751,
0.04178771,
0.0514051169,
0.0220698416,
-0.0500594415,
0.0069948765,
-0.0063496036,
-0.0312902257,
-0.0097858999,
-0.0382458717,
-0.0035259961,
-0.0151305478,
0.0238085445,
-0.0913293809,
-0.0151367197,
-0.0061936453,
2.501e-7,
0.04817494,
0.034445066,
0.0284312554,
0.0088900635,
0.0169350207,
0.0196895599,
-0.0133974096,
0.002561152,
-0.0059656659,
-0.0388609208,
-0.0068369522,
0.0333086327,
0.0374883339,
0.0222439729,
-0.0305590462,
-0.0282013472,
-0.0373021066,
0.0170737375,
-0.0405511111,
-0.0018108132,
0.0488541126,
0.107341215,
0.0396652557,
-0.0140833994,
-0.0030991617,
-0.035877835,
0.0466332138,
-0.011610412,
0.0217817426,
0.0148307802,
0.0066838944,
0.0404758081,
0.0132537009,
0.0662339255,
-0.0231457669,
-0.0072273263,
0.0358541459,
0.032715369,
0.0100682667,
-0.0051488965,
-0.0559143163,
0.000815079,
0.0156025821,
-0.0111168437,
0.0859032199,
-0.0387605429,
-0.0590387285,
-0.0713516101,
-0.0508594103,
0.0033671586,
0.0285414904,
0.0177078191,
0.0051455111,
-0.0022639667,
0.0061376435,
0.0065299757,
-0.0423298329,
-0.0640329942,
-0.0346436575,
0.0190698523,
-0.0160325058,
-0.004543778,
0.0001879285,
-0.0116261039,
0.0296025481,
-0.0518120378,
-0.0137363411,
2.246354781e-34,
0.0230179969,
-0.0168228969,
0.029784508,
0.009591965,
0.0385229699,
-0.0069396598,
0.0289592426,
-0.013323254,
0.031692218,
-0.0213877577,
-0.0045584715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04643v1 | A Novel Approach for Auto-Formulation of Optimization Problems | 2023-02-09T13:57:06 | 2023-02-09T13:57:06 | Yuting Ning, Jiayu Liu, Longhu Qin, Tong Xiao, Shangzi Xue, Zhenya Huang, Qi Liu, Enhong Chen, Jinze Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Natural Language for Optimization (NL4Opt) NeurIPS 2022 competition,
competitors focus on improving the accessibility and usability of optimization
solvers, with the aim of subtask 1: recognizing the semantic entities that
correspond to the components of the optimization problem; subtask 2: generating
formulations for the optimization problem. In this paper, we present the
solution of our team. First, we treat subtask 1 as a named entity recognition
(NER) problem with the solution pipeline including pre-processing methods,
adversarial training, post-processing methods and ensemble learning. Besides,
we treat subtask 2 as a generation problem with the solution pipeline including
specially designed prompts, adversarial training, post-processing methods and
ensemble learning. Our proposed methods have achieved the F1-score of 0.931 in
subtask 1 and the accuracy of 0.867 in subtask 2, which won the fourth and
third places respectively in this competition. Our code is available at
https://github.com/bigdata-ustc/nl4opt. | [
0.032852754,
0.0675701201,
0.000335726,
0.0249569789,
0.0132709285,
0.0041411784,
0.0011840338,
-0.0127122374,
-0.0127785951,
-0.0436190143,
-0.0145535776,
0.0070074382,
-0.0135011189,
-0.0025444448,
0.0428192504,
-0.0562102832,
0.0427322164,
-0.0090000769,
-0.020373676,
0.0191518348,
-0.0160946529,
-0.0139097627,
-0.0220140051,
0.0226948727,
-0.0259384941,
0.0256420393,
-0.0278447587,
-0.0202127844,
0.0316136591,
-0.0632231608,
0.0283675324,
0.0616667047,
-0.0113816382,
0.0327026993,
0.0000026106,
-0.0703363493,
-0.0857547,
-0.000984065,
-0.0654615089,
-0.0353092477,
0.0237903707,
-0.0074759349,
-0.0154713048,
-0.0018180485,
-0.039955657,
-0.0043557789,
0.0238027815,
0.0488457829,
0.0796019956,
0.071080789,
-0.0094858827,
-0.0217230991,
0.0141845187,
0.0045968206,
-0.0260446742,
-0.0578045808,
-0.0096330671,
-0.0672502592,
-0.0164282005,
0.0061719799,
0.0193538442,
0.0268767849,
0.0229262691,
0.0291595347,
0.0464549102,
0.0384115465,
-0.0466586985,
-0.0007614002,
-0.0427642576,
0.0784492493,
-0.0160436109,
0.0047461754,
0.0411271751,
-0.0229292512,
0.0079434766,
-0.0567279942,
-0.0117298495,
-0.0115034385,
-0.00020962,
-0.0092316624,
-0.0154479984,
0.0353422947,
0.0189894717,
0.012059303,
0.0059105861,
0.0609704219,
0.0033441789,
-0.0276077371,
0.0383744575,
-0.0251421016,
-0.0146058379,
-0.0487211533,
0.0631347448,
0.0572041459,
-0.0420370549,
0.0200620741,
-0.0217391364,
-0.0520852394,
-0.0257554613,
-0.0209401958,
0.056760408,
0.0054185512,
0.070615381,
0.0341417454,
-0.058603406,
0.0847536325,
-0.0196389519,
-0.0465952381,
-0.0040350687,
0.0094759194,
-0.0695227161,
-0.0179597009,
-0.0626312271,
0.0728907511,
-0.0614829436,
0.0049848533,
-0.0192849133,
0.0029694929,
-0.0104352841,
0.0149932951,
0.0158996619,
0.0350202434,
-0.0225251447,
0.0040465156,
-0.0465216935,
-0.000848163,
-0.0418323763,
-0.0338852964,
-0.0498193353,
-0.0248529352,
-0.0009520922,
0.0177255254,
-0.0137648908,
-0.0130498083,
0.0086586121,
0.1073044538,
0.0018670957,
-0.0220257062,
-0.0359387584,
-0.0468542539,
0.0089110015,
-0.0666307732,
-0.0125344647,
-0.052911099,
0.0531190559,
-0.0364757068,
-0.012487784,
-0.0577256642,
0.027181752,
-0.0148774162,
0.0098762857,
0.0811259821,
-0.0354614817,
-0.0286574997,
0.0535491779,
-0.0157106686,
0.0425914787,
0.0765355974,
0.0391202644,
0.0549602546,
0.013531073,
0.0170227587,
-0.0219476074,
0.031348139,
0.0379992276,
-0.0230020471,
0.0386634544,
-0.0061172713,
-0.0192547832,
0.0505748577,
-0.0045606056,
0.0260713696,
0.0108719282,
-0.027321877,
0.0122460183,
0.0116703631,
0.0527404509,
0.0098157693,
0.0120854508,
0.0248133205,
-0.023482779,
-0.0318421237,
-0.0142266992,
0.0132039487,
-0.0659515411,
-0.0095095737,
0.0087893726,
0.0231677014,
-0.0070512081,
-0.0611753464,
0.0095753493,
-0.0104135778,
-0.0357914716,
-0.008431538,
0.0261161122,
-0.0004113895,
-0.0971531123,
0.0529654697,
0.0076377317,
-0.0091495663,
0.0195303187,
-0.0174588542,
0.0142112244,
0.009994098,
0.0358987972,
-0.0372339077,
-0.0184426568,
-0.02422948,
-0.0445241705,
0.0257346462,
0.0228559878,
-0.029925188,
0.0032967364,
-0.0559073575,
-0.0216564797,
-0.0224784389,
-0.006768859,
0.0476409011,
0.018526556,
0.0268396121,
0.0291872285,
0.0213038009,
-0.0449716151,
0.0560853928,
-0.0111747906,
-0.0627426878,
0.0376551636,
0.040057268,
0.036006514,
0.0573701635,
0.0221157055,
0.0219625644,
-0.0121547785,
-0.0273228493,
-0.053111162,
-0.0288425889,
-0.0161953531,
-0.0584426038,
0.0335578285,
-0.0382635184,
-0.0159196593,
0.0085089114,
-0.0382094495,
-0.059809342,
-0.0121901948,
-0.0308714788,
-0.0131318746,
-0.0269998852,
0.0057593058,
0.0278007723,
-0.0052199927,
-0.0668933988,
0.0931754336,
0.0145413373,
0.015729107,
0.0074576274,
-0.0066732871,
0.0362364314,
-0.0690248683,
-0.00150162,
0.0115659405,
-0.0108856773,
-0.0057183877,
0.0297484081,
0.0271918271,
-0.0465015098,
-0.0194035619,
-0.0636073127,
0.0484583788,
-0.0140587185,
0.0532278493,
0.0354478694,
0.0031493925,
-0.0338250063,
-0.0024019047,
-0.015449021,
0.0309840441,
-0.0198503658,
-0.0425827615,
0.0458884798,
0.0302266926,
0.0047988533,
-0.0036857547,
0.0102700656,
-0.0551747829,
0.0025820632,
0.0513852052,
-0.0476769209,
-0.0546197221,
0.067980431,
-0.0115130953,
0.003969213,
0.0138769671,
0.0189823229,
-0.0126329232,
0.0240787938,
0.0258433353,
0.0589988194,
-0.0115781063,
0.0519150607,
0.0079681715,
0.0161713529,
-0.0713820308,
0.0536685809,
-0.0560967326,
0.0406433456,
0.0014401241,
-0.0512649715,
0.09081655,
0.0851815864,
-0.0027477641,
-0.0229492057,
-0.0392853469,
0.0683086142,
-0.020608196,
-0.0275939796,
-0.0527088009,
0.0224141963,
-0.0103182588,
0.0311815329,
0.0219507031,
-0.0298286658,
0.0800060704,
-0.0308751911,
0.0034092332,
-0.090058051,
-0.0066855727,
-0.0599736869,
0.0397372879,
0.0237934254,
-0.0038234892,
0.045200374,
-0.046124164,
-0.029942289,
0.030877322,
0.0307058655,
0.0145167168,
-0.0031308187,
0.0147846388,
0.0125433644,
-0.0170172248,
-0.0467683487,
-0.0527449511,
-0.0272187255,
-0.0205841642,
0.0489134304,
0.0449071452,
0.0106798429,
-0.0555474423,
0.048064623,
0.0007284808,
0.0289141908,
-0.0379668996,
0.0032933513,
-0.044366803,
0.0123989498,
0.0491923317,
0.0120835733,
0.0245022066,
-0.0056961947,
0.0127417557,
0.023184076,
0.0203909315,
0.0033403349,
-0.0194933936,
0.037185397,
0.003173803,
-0.0737989247,
-0.0012502882,
-0.0009252401,
0.0219075289,
-0.0207044426,
0.0448923483,
0.1146360338,
0.0395331942,
-0.0060310378,
0.0115777003,
0.0006371735,
0.0097332932,
0.0377286375,
0.0327340439,
-0.0365601368,
-0.046410609,
0.011353354,
0.0476240851,
-0.0016801577,
-0.0816221982,
-0.0265908763,
-0.1032929644,
0.0066151302,
-0.0053411596,
-0.0727839023,
0.0301441085,
-0.047571715,
-0.0092275692,
-0.064127028,
-0.0176566746,
-0.0233715363,
0.0166426189,
0.0401897691,
-0.0006884327,
-0.0059492611,
-0.0315341726,
-0.0292089619,
-0.0407891646,
0.0310357697,
0.0627123713,
0.0316726528,
0.0049590562,
0.0279542562,
0.0239749197,
-0.0105237644,
-0.0098637398,
-0.042963095,
0.0253110174,
-0.0334906429,
-0.0000849691,
-0.0281057861,
0.0356042944,
-0.0480785742,
-0.0064418297,
0.0622569881,
0.0564164482,
0.0063466481,
0.0006663059,
-0.0088226749,
-0.0203344729,
0.0537147895,
0.0580441281,
0.0111448839,
-0.0033231878,
-0.018669406,
-0.0232100729,
0.0186358672,
-0.0718523562,
-0.0005197545,
-0.0037947216,
0.0059021334,
-0.0127924373,
-0.0634128526,
-0.0552867614,
0.07384523,
0.0585486032,
0.0091276551,
-0.029326871,
0.0064006457,
0.0030417491,
-0.0559004247,
0.0089765331,
-0.0050349999,
0.0110467523,
-0.0756449103,
-0.0355282575,
0.0436765924,
0.0076743714,
-0.047148522,
0.0603425875,
-0.0269370619,
-0.0710683092,
-0.0464633703,
0.0802110359,
0.0137007143,
0.0342747532,
-0.0097915214,
-0.0284292083,
0.0341046304,
0.0790704265,
-0.0349984802,
-0.0390165225,
0.005359455,
-0.002488351,
-0.0277626757,
0.0108523378,
-0.0042255782,
0.0319876596,
-0.006556463,
0.0694279075,
0.0059925341,
-0.0177266914,
0.0311239418,
0.0793619603,
-0.0079053892,
-0.0438060462,
-0.0462565646,
-0.039985545,
0.0087586148,
0.0041353297,
-0.017166419,
-0.0281535331,
0.0230030976,
-0.0103668245,
0.0145349344,
0.0533373319,
0.0519650578,
0.0122220954,
0.0100776581,
0.0060313633,
0.0218259227,
0.0319186449,
0.050528571,
0.0148277618,
-0.0016664847,
0.0329484418,
0.0478942022,
0.0531605482,
0.0433491431,
-0.0264865495,
0.0136437584,
0.0511077829,
0.0330835022,
-0.0385359228,
0.0296896826,
-0.0011084394,
-0.0086005526,
-0.0604133531,
0.0039397855,
0.0285558142,
0.0085569983,
0.0052967872,
-0.0396160856,
-0.0316208601,
0.0062628277,
0.0083460808,
0.000098037,
-0.020384673,
0.0477220453,
0.0391348787,
-0.0117356237,
-0.054594826,
0.0491401888,
0.00205835,
0.010661236,
0.0177698433,
0.0091143288,
-0.0951678529,
-0.0172184315,
0.0153033938,
0.0141677381,
-0.0357822739,
0.0334943943,
-0.0099017946,
-0.0351889618,
-0.0219311845,
-0.0125263128,
-0.0090415468,
0.0272396579,
0.0667836741,
-0.0012116323,
-0.0108766435,
-0.0210613403,
-0.0281575173,
0.0255081579,
-0.0473057218,
-0.0320958011,
-0.0024984968,
-6.772170627e-33,
-0.0533707626,
-0.0652863383,
0.0109384386,
-0.0162681062,
0.0038544016,
0.0049271937,
-0.0362395011,
0.0141004305,
0.0402250811,
-0.0519661196,
-0.0048088869,
-0.0511259548,
0.0238037594,
0.0145471524,
-0.044977162,
-0.0141996602,
0.0293809753,
-0.0235075019,
-0.0659029037,
-0.0015547463,
0.0279588625,
0.0549809746,
0.0744203925,
-0.0289196316,
0.0244811848,
0.0118424771,
-0.0115430141,
0.0279453974,
0.0453915261,
0.0536498353,
-0.0473455675,
0.0354590416,
0.0095371641,
-0.082540296,
-0.0203984194,
-0.0045811534,
-0.0760914311,
-0.0663849413,
-0.0097154491,
0.0300001837,
-0.076224871,
-0.0483479984,
0.0340541005,
-0.0204721726,
-0.032615751,
0.0197049417,
0.0451420508,
0.0033865592,
-0.0122101894,
-0.0252424348,
-0.0627728626,
0.0258097369,
-0.0140186762,
0.022049671,
0.0579129234,
-0.0007588274,
0.0281462967,
-0.0217223633,
-0.0487838425,
0.0178761296,
0.0191220753,
0.0295345094,
0.0744724795,
0.0159932487,
-0.0071566436,
-0.0015348897,
0.0385507159,
-0.0080949804,
-0.0632693693,
-0.0011170594,
0.0207684487,
0.0022058387,
0.0234021731,
0.0156349279,
0.0171042457,
-0.0293068737,
-0.0539363511,
0.0563958548,
-0.0094849654,
0.0352630466,
-0.0243564006,
0.0049767089,
-0.041144602,
-0.006976957,
-0.0462233461,
-0.051350303,
-0.0278557166,
-0.0283343773,
0.0256779734,
0.0034891535,
-0.076266937,
-0.006798191,
0.0019697668,
-0.0276162717,
-0.0090765161,
0.0181409419,
0.0475458764,
-0.0169944838,
0.0134057794,
0.0349297747,
-0.0485014617,
-0.0205897372,
0.0010876496,
0.0186686609,
0.0626243055,
-0.0209217668,
0.0025827074,
0.0288777109,
-0.0426544994,
0.0212091655,
-0.0246214867,
0.0434637293,
0.0058726682,
0.0501087829,
-0.0005287103,
-0.0258832723,
0.0003283714,
0.0190663207,
0.041941382,
-0.0227022599,
-0.0187917743,
0.0548546426,
0.0315386653,
0.0353810377,
0.0005731198,
0.0194614902,
-0.008404443,
-0.0059343134,
0.0299832411,
-0.0217329599,
-0.0186634846,
-0.0186523497,
3.151e-7,
0.0126069244,
0.0308408067,
0.0184781663,
-0.0024746961,
-0.0138599472,
0.0269990079,
-0.0036644693,
0.0139922714,
-0.0521233343,
-0.0100843003,
0.0175465494,
-0.0154355429,
0.0208079461,
0.0246621445,
-0.0887855589,
-0.0020674434,
0.0194676295,
0.0077042719,
-0.0775104687,
0.0326642059,
0.0257374495,
0.0845467448,
-0.0010844244,
0.0124606946,
-0.0528576821,
-0.0038568559,
0.0188983232,
-0.0117479935,
0.0399887525,
0.0591542795,
-0.0055510704,
0.0154504953,
-0.0430176519,
0.0283503942,
-0.0222556349,
0.0616961345,
0.0305737779,
0.0733010098,
0.0109197665,
-0.0327389501,
0.035317935,
-0.0208110716,
0.0114699928,
-0.0596368946,
0.0610316508,
-0.0454950817,
-0.063599214,
-0.0115635255,
0.0097257234,
-0.0213440154,
-0.0016899077,
-0.016651487,
0.0007744489,
0.0138667244,
-0.0020694395,
-0.0193404313,
0.0068092807,
-0.062691085,
0.0340615846,
-0.0107279383,
-0.0248144586,
0.0009570398,
-0.0289957281,
0.0265472066,
0.0376674943,
-0.0442521349,
-0.0105824387,
3.037267099e-34,
-0.0034815283,
0.01462314,
0.0092690745,
0.0136258686,
0.0212150849,
0.0104253944,
-0.0572920851,
0.0075779012,
0.0136352526,
-0.0654735267,
-0.0336721167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04618v1 | Robust Question Answering against Distribution Shifts with Test-Time Adaptation: An Empirical Study | 2023-02-09T13:10:53 | 2023-02-09T13:10:53 | Hai Ye, Yuyang Ding, Juntao Li, Hwee Tou Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL | A deployed question answering (QA) model can easily fail when the test data
has a distribution shift compared to the training data. Robustness tuning (RT)
methods have been widely studied to enhance model robustness against
distribution shifts before model deployment. However, can we improve a model
after deployment? To answer this question, we evaluate test-time adaptation
(TTA) to improve a model after deployment. We first introduce COLDQA, a unified
evaluation benchmark for robust QA against text corruption and changes in
language and domain. We then evaluate previous TTA methods on COLDQA and
compare them to RT methods. We also propose a novel TTA method called online
imitation learning (OIL). Through extensive experiments, we find that TTA is
comparable to RT methods, and applying TTA after RT can significantly boost the
performance on COLDQA. Our proposed OIL improves TTA to be more robust to
variation in hyper-parameters and test distributions over time. | [
0.0658124462,
0.072306104,
-0.0201206878,
-0.0009931201,
0.0130695319,
0.0010526525,
-0.0469852239,
0.0036190925,
-0.0538084023,
-0.0339854658,
-0.0119165862,
-0.051912535,
-0.0279968008,
0.0029643553,
0.0177831892,
-0.030110864,
0.0678105727,
0.0056639416,
-0.0351488702,
-0.0051819445,
-0.0028274124,
-0.0152945612,
-0.0070910598,
-0.0206849389,
0.045152165,
-0.0130540151,
-0.0136025259,
0.0055591059,
0.0235606767,
-0.0011834322,
0.029302571,
0.0531197824,
0.0112187853,
0.012772589,
0.0000020013,
-0.0288510118,
-0.0241586715,
-0.0024509169,
-0.0359712765,
0.0297753122,
0.0331383832,
0.0182584021,
0.0068346644,
0.0536228828,
-0.0619255044,
0.0366240479,
0.0300550554,
-0.000165988,
0.0526513308,
0.0685585439,
0.0185683854,
0.0266263224,
0.0025013532,
-0.0033878032,
-0.0365820192,
-0.0878515989,
0.0150558027,
0.0267990045,
0.0468316749,
0.0143771712,
-0.0477190167,
0.0091904262,
0.0217892192,
0.0168882534,
-0.0260379296,
0.0111817401,
-0.0527819581,
0.0445560217,
-0.0292050038,
0.0711548626,
-0.0045672785,
-0.0376767069,
-0.0094610332,
-0.0093041174,
0.0141678173,
0.0296814647,
-0.0191788375,
-0.0250523854,
0.0135790762,
-0.0103822472,
-0.0305825341,
-0.0285461098,
0.0060822242,
0.0305120219,
-0.0157727282,
0.0751518384,
0.0043087844,
-0.0579772331,
-0.0151084941,
0.0099018803,
-0.0736456886,
-0.0110348202,
-0.0092694042,
0.0625055283,
-0.0378740951,
0.0145224156,
-0.0406698547,
-0.0583657846,
0.0173328407,
-0.0195291415,
0.0323562175,
0.0222721323,
-0.0251823775,
0.0214574244,
-0.0299824737,
0.0949741155,
0.0050143017,
0.0145027507,
-0.0486720763,
-0.0027962015,
-0.0754951686,
-0.0218115784,
-0.0197755899,
0.0466283709,
-0.0384916365,
0.0075241709,
-0.0082235616,
0.0698611662,
0.0030149559,
-0.0319328904,
-0.0093748579,
0.0362678543,
-0.0556926578,
0.0272030663,
-0.0486176796,
0.0325056389,
-0.0463403016,
0.0324083529,
-0.023244746,
-0.0587230995,
-0.0277576707,
0.0071938359,
0.0031450051,
-0.0131045682,
0.0109163579,
0.0690275505,
-0.0276036356,
-0.0381314829,
0.0069635762,
0.0117404303,
-0.015561644,
0.009529545,
0.0011882172,
-0.0413022377,
0.0156157501,
-0.0406299494,
-0.0198147241,
-0.0094234459,
-0.0155421114,
0.0318522379,
-0.0322167613,
0.044281289,
0.0111847781,
0.0090109827,
0.0432685874,
-0.0162727162,
0.0032123735,
0.0648086816,
0.0165139046,
-0.0585586019,
0.0543944426,
0.0050407611,
0.0279947389,
0.0065101571,
0.0312388986,
0.0525691807,
0.0181494877,
0.056888435,
-0.0105974134,
0.0396959372,
0.0266814418,
-0.0175247882,
-0.0209254213,
-0.0515086204,
0.0380204134,
0.0048743756,
-0.0060322974,
-0.0125264553,
0.0056677344,
-0.0113924015,
-0.0025636996,
-0.006740219,
-0.0667414665,
0.0097868023,
-0.0553694852,
0.0405710526,
-0.063880302,
0.0073052854,
-0.0472302213,
-0.0183394477,
-0.0130032627,
0.0139084263,
-0.0046004658,
-0.01083537,
0.0130545059,
0.0326156057,
-0.0351339169,
0.021500254,
0.0021469933,
0.0356776305,
0.0232556164,
-0.0660587326,
0.0480868556,
0.0315612629,
0.0468556136,
-0.0640996024,
-0.0333129019,
-0.0405262932,
0.0566360466,
0.030615529,
0.0048993807,
-0.0272712242,
-0.0083474871,
-0.0090621142,
-0.0222052559,
0.0011474137,
0.0108322268,
0.0259022489,
0.033744093,
0.0563283712,
-0.0044261855,
-0.088746421,
0.0049998076,
0.0391205475,
-0.0178591441,
-0.0251131449,
0.021075381,
-0.0182390343,
0.0288291182,
-0.0143082319,
-0.0187238399,
-0.0113754375,
-0.0051258281,
0.0170134809,
-0.0252437871,
0.0172751769,
-0.0259041078,
-0.0220427923,
0.0383327678,
-0.011583264,
0.0145933144,
0.094325088,
-0.0655878633,
-0.0173807684,
0.0246995166,
-0.0032040712,
-0.0075433156,
-0.0369713455,
0.0029623918,
-0.0158290137,
0.0398025289,
-0.0620945804,
0.0475059524,
-0.0125156734,
0.012874905,
-0.0405663997,
0.0470190719,
-0.0014433975,
-0.0458959118,
0.0219715312,
0.0016025667,
-0.0218210462,
0.0312083419,
0.0037723689,
0.016798906,
-0.0324231125,
-0.0142902955,
-0.052138675,
0.014642003,
-0.043305207,
0.063393496,
0.0613379925,
-0.0049534561,
-0.0402035937,
-0.0387456752,
-0.0339493006,
0.0151472315,
0.0228229538,
0.0200072099,
0.0567397363,
0.015958298,
0.0265888572,
-0.0332703404,
-0.0003604336,
-0.011825298,
0.050191015,
-0.0519291125,
0.0105957771,
-0.0701386854,
-0.02778868,
-0.0329186432,
0.0355980061,
0.0040677642,
-0.0614430904,
-0.0353941843,
0.0338925198,
0.026916936,
0.0703879148,
0.0506065004,
-0.0171256736,
0.0259243809,
0.0550225563,
-0.0353548639,
0.0380272567,
-0.0143406475,
-0.0670872256,
-0.0196764879,
-0.0425673425,
0.0305724125,
0.0414216593,
0.0049792905,
-0.0101273777,
-0.0602160357,
0.0242352821,
-0.0422929749,
-0.0116244648,
-0.0160322413,
0.0333971232,
-0.0336862355,
-0.0133017823,
-0.0252180789,
-0.0075311409,
0.097155869,
0.0140997553,
0.01658866,
-0.0932394713,
-0.0078053372,
-0.008234472,
-0.0058790427,
-0.0196854956,
0.0072173262,
-0.0072198901,
-0.0242616702,
-0.0731923953,
-0.0720253512,
0.0389934815,
-0.0102625582,
0.0068580355,
-0.0525323674,
0.0112404302,
-0.0121052675,
-0.0263388064,
-0.0262014866,
-0.0964910462,
-0.0098582972,
0.0139704589,
-0.0544218346,
-0.0085351355,
-0.0292284247,
0.0042282944,
-0.0049348967,
0.0527359173,
-0.0249927379,
-0.0092348363,
-0.019452123,
0.0583715998,
0.0897802934,
0.074049063,
0.0241282508,
-0.011635418,
0.0167112835,
0.028107537,
0.0334316529,
-0.0107413605,
-0.0048252614,
-0.0008160278,
-0.0035791968,
-0.0333405323,
-0.0046872995,
0.051498197,
0.0511773191,
0.0063274275,
-0.0498800464,
0.0702572316,
0.0514457598,
0.0482599102,
0.0244128108,
-0.0248291213,
0.0660011843,
0.0212778617,
0.0553454235,
-0.0961908251,
-0.0193320271,
-0.0251880717,
0.0880360156,
-0.0012104828,
-0.0335755721,
0.0202612393,
-0.0947190449,
-0.0037784195,
-0.0260759648,
-0.091894187,
-0.033647228,
-0.0489036851,
0.0292398576,
-0.0111171138,
0.074749589,
0.0185239371,
-0.0046690754,
0.0121117895,
0.0585037917,
-0.0060678585,
-0.0652343333,
0.0361522846,
-0.0006087525,
0.035350278,
0.0801921785,
0.0090267453,
-0.0246766321,
-0.0062920148,
0.0132919606,
-0.0645995215,
0.0144327879,
0.0101799807,
0.0276973434,
-0.0046506687,
-0.0030250011,
0.0150109045,
0.0319335386,
-0.0330344103,
0.0226214565,
0.0261787269,
0.0678352416,
-0.0110525247,
-0.023617886,
-0.0040822877,
-0.0286942702,
0.0295261312,
0.0445731245,
0.0030099952,
-0.0596053042,
-0.035661418,
0.0075711096,
-0.0415450856,
-0.0373450182,
-0.020944722,
0.0209693182,
0.0212443396,
0.0355350897,
-0.1256099343,
-0.0406591594,
-0.0428409651,
0.0404104888,
-0.0282635763,
-0.008551144,
-0.0338681452,
0.0096948566,
-0.0414090008,
0.0220009424,
-0.0272863023,
0.006850705,
-0.0491593443,
0.0219312999,
0.0434467793,
-0.0273289513,
-0.03890213,
-0.0406159386,
-0.0622780845,
-0.0469962955,
0.0246569123,
0.0551710092,
0.0133302221,
0.0253261235,
-0.0201302096,
-0.0257528536,
0.0519623719,
0.0259336662,
0.0107860053,
0.055337742,
0.0506766327,
-0.050536409,
-0.0261598881,
0.0257955268,
-0.0645420924,
0.0038207942,
0.011146591,
0.0398352034,
0.0083437515,
-0.0265593491,
0.0180494525,
0.0000589671,
-0.016215818,
0.0460300297,
-0.0702863857,
0.0159198027,
0.045340091,
-0.0067428374,
0.0030914557,
0.0145855704,
0.0231980067,
0.0102123953,
-0.0220997203,
-0.005455649,
0.0069676703,
-0.0310817081,
0.0507414825,
-0.0234731045,
0.0070500681,
0.0591783896,
0.0374456607,
0.0083817793,
0.0036420494,
-0.0014412625,
-0.0239537358,
0.0011724307,
0.0930605233,
0.016557809,
0.0478476696,
0.033989761,
-0.0221409071,
-0.0257156342,
-0.0036903897,
-0.0879529491,
-0.0192322284,
-0.0656220019,
0.0412564836,
0.0235880502,
-0.0153857116,
0.0176814124,
0.0027379978,
-0.0153717697,
0.0010530272,
-0.0368585475,
-0.0050667436,
0.0058324602,
0.0650732294,
0.0223350562,
0.0115456814,
0.0540676601,
0.0588358082,
0.0358315818,
0.0690678284,
-0.0319039486,
0.02006598,
-0.0279964898,
0.0193413142,
-0.0184166245,
-0.0176681783,
-0.0113909347,
0.0207629483,
0.0016307791,
-0.0416685417,
0.0440749675,
0.0050214478,
0.0065287491,
-0.0186245218,
0.0332526155,
0.0533242337,
0.0364754423,
0.0102021731,
-0.0352850407,
0.0231980179,
0.0274515059,
0.0051107476,
-0.0116032409,
-6.785465468e-33,
-0.0062373765,
-0.0049413084,
-0.003123811,
-0.0758011118,
0.0001225069,
0.002503118,
-0.0194045547,
-0.0146630127,
-0.0540829971,
-0.023835266,
-0.0249364413,
0.028458178,
0.010870534,
0.0133066662,
-0.0163274743,
-0.0554816797,
-0.0070440299,
-0.0242883917,
-0.0810011998,
-0.0216684118,
0.0037547064,
0.034678679,
0.0526880845,
-0.0301185045,
-0.0061050956,
-0.0109951394,
0.0063499697,
0.0111651979,
-0.0231797528,
0.0754505321,
0.0050177611,
0.0283922032,
0.02155165,
-0.0170398671,
0.0001909016,
0.0058436678,
-0.0660809427,
-0.0489337668,
-0.0149520766,
0.0155814569,
-0.0143368626,
-0.0016901806,
0.0161286127,
-0.0099916803,
0.020517556,
0.0015995665,
0.0152849555,
-0.0472890213,
-0.0004952435,
-0.0123458756,
-0.0282869004,
0.0215873476,
-0.0120224655,
0.0044432404,
-0.0622217394,
0.06511949,
0.0031097056,
0.0177115016,
-0.0208182186,
-0.043399483,
0.0225013159,
0.0327954553,
0.0621759966,
0.0109862052,
-0.0240238328,
0.0050374605,
-0.0600507669,
0.0154377297,
0.0259189177,
-0.0402675569,
0.0306604281,
-0.079934366,
0.0714832991,
0.0832277611,
0.009448776,
-0.0223053452,
-0.0551411696,
0.0277643856,
0.0066388035,
0.0052761757,
0.0243161637,
0.019679239,
-0.0488471612,
0.021350665,
-0.0448144861,
0.0461573191,
-0.0252864324,
-0.0402824096,
0.0596236512,
0.0071118334,
-0.0494587533,
0.0123797962,
0.0131672798,
-0.0431649946,
0.0117364721,
0.0282792915,
-0.0478802845,
0.0227388777,
-0.0014255638,
0.0400976874,
-0.0118755046,
-0.0276110824,
0.0384649299,
0.0062615606,
-0.0067187306,
-0.0086969407,
0.0058708289,
0.0205191839,
-0.0738727674,
0.0113899875,
0.0205613766,
0.0364354551,
-0.0054074442,
0.0367866158,
0.0010695126,
0.0162746813,
0.0108752623,
0.0201734658,
0.0219553616,
-0.0342049748,
-0.0358403325,
0.0431286246,
-0.0056268363,
0.0222034231,
-0.0263328571,
0.0055929422,
0.0011048916,
0.0658057332,
-0.0796896517,
-0.0932078436,
-0.0098759299,
0.0360478908,
2.76e-7,
0.062680237,
0.0396946333,
0.0244006012,
-0.0176254157,
0.0098615475,
-0.0106664896,
-0.0074310657,
0.0322584137,
0.023220839,
-0.0116177071,
0.024890326,
-0.0072515178,
0.0085730627,
0.0249927063,
-0.0886225328,
-0.0479938686,
-0.0749987736,
0.0221631248,
-0.0334234349,
-0.0456178188,
0.027820738,
0.1120958105,
-0.0039029259,
0.0020260899,
-0.0283306558,
-0.0531437919,
0.0414887108,
0.0384542868,
0.0110737002,
0.0147226714,
0.0161406398,
-0.0165865161,
0.0154793449,
0.0267643873,
-0.0298376083,
0.0301720407,
-0.012741887,
0.0267047659,
-0.0288737305,
-0.0660160035,
-0.0256833211,
-0.0183268134,
0.0379637256,
-0.0472869538,
0.0645215586,
-0.0562487282,
0.0048345327,
-0.0064199441,
-0.065682143,
-0.0108938087,
0.0209439304,
-0.0235393923,
0.0053941985,
0.0267632492,
0.0197631437,
0.0436001085,
-0.0014810862,
-0.0640212446,
0.0140121421,
0.0413716324,
-0.0070473505,
-0.0202203672,
-0.0316745266,
-0.018889701,
0.0115279155,
-0.0764685348,
0.0337796882,
2.279906191e-34,
0.0327016413,
-0.009431608,
0.0227793362,
0.031737987,
0.0024151809,
0.0145221362,
0.0629569963,
-0.0317395702,
0.0585721247,
-0.0468171611,
-0.006830499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04580v1 | Generating a Structured Summary of Numerous Academic Papers: Dataset and Method | 2023-02-09T11:42:07 | 2023-02-09T11:42:07 | Shuaiqi Liu, Jiannong Cao, Ruosong Yang, Zhiyuan Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.7 | Writing a survey paper on one research topic usually needs to cover the
salient content from numerous related papers, which can be modeled as a
multi-document summarization (MDS) task. Existing MDS datasets usually focus on
producing the structureless summary covering a few input documents. Meanwhile,
previous structured summary generation works focus on summarizing a single
document into a multi-section summary. These existing datasets and methods
cannot meet the requirements of summarizing numerous academic papers into a
structured summary. To deal with the scarcity of available data, we propose
BigSurvey, the first large-scale dataset for generating comprehensive summaries
of numerous academic papers on each topic. We collect target summaries from
more than seven thousand survey papers and utilize their 430 thousand reference
papers' abstracts as input documents. To organize the diverse content from
dozens of input documents and ensure the efficiency of processing long text
sequences, we propose a summarization method named category-based alignment and
sparse transformer (CAST). The experimental results show that our CAST method
outperforms various advanced summarization methods. | [
-0.0003623547,
0.03576703,
0.0346177407,
-0.0378363058,
0.0198217575,
0.0079885246,
0.0123590333,
-0.0047224374,
-0.0354176611,
-0.038928818,
-0.0084216278,
0.0014709034,
0.0297076069,
-0.0101134507,
0.0065664314,
-0.0762492269,
0.0307236109,
0.0008330697,
-0.0035239721,
-0.0043727015,
0.0192014128,
0.0033070291,
0.0129196644,
0.0012207938,
0.0263726451,
0.001317473,
-0.0203184988,
-0.0146367392,
0.0464141518,
-0.0273421556,
0.016582448,
0.0240329001,
0.0303340964,
0.053120818,
0.0000017267,
-0.0366331898,
-0.0458510779,
0.0275533088,
0.0374332853,
0.0284055788,
0.065820694,
-0.0654876754,
0.0034179103,
-0.005919172,
0.0209788959,
-0.0292683356,
0.0407957435,
0.0654937699,
0.0323357433,
0.05865217,
-0.0284727011,
-0.0838009343,
0.0417297184,
-0.0025223924,
-0.0095706927,
0.0072848657,
0.0073987283,
0.0242959727,
0.0000618868,
0.0392270759,
0.0165188704,
-0.0113546299,
-0.0281467922,
-0.0505353883,
0.032773219,
0.0265437905,
-0.0646640509,
-0.0128037091,
0.0354385674,
0.0486875176,
0.0020126149,
-0.0010105813,
0.0830095485,
0.0095475521,
-0.022431083,
0.0565322638,
-0.1016465127,
0.0451670811,
-0.0047632102,
-0.0109725697,
0.0264471136,
0.034965165,
-0.0132373422,
0.011840825,
-0.0359062552,
0.0031351687,
0.0164803695,
-0.0533938631,
-0.0344817415,
-0.018749319,
0.001418216,
-0.0427230932,
-0.0167540554,
0.0246075206,
-0.0356905833,
-0.0254263096,
-0.0326811485,
-0.098645553,
0.0710897669,
0.0068481863,
0.0114184301,
-0.0188631546,
0.0440855213,
0.0308343712,
0.0022472392,
-0.010201158,
-0.0355983675,
-0.0224326067,
-0.0416505337,
-0.0306724086,
-0.025684895,
0.0156544819,
-0.0058020987,
0.0424197093,
-0.0089606959,
-0.0250557996,
-0.0414169915,
0.0230874345,
0.0134292394,
0.0245468821,
-0.0073630312,
0.0089128297,
-0.0426341109,
-0.0215553623,
0.017627269,
0.0708025396,
-0.0177612603,
-0.0132950125,
0.0140863163,
0.0679498762,
-0.0089267874,
0.0382087603,
0.0481797121,
-0.0044699349,
-0.0119508654,
-0.002113655,
-0.0241057426,
-0.0077502164,
0.0008670496,
-0.0436470285,
0.0028061224,
-0.0350237042,
0.033470273,
-0.0838042274,
0.0354122557,
-0.0044513908,
-0.0054291277,
0.0033846402,
0.009893748,
0.0300890021,
-0.046366673,
-0.0088406075,
-0.0475664288,
-0.0039969529,
0.0546226762,
0.0143634239,
0.0552587546,
0.0073243538,
0.0049287598,
0.0273654461,
0.0281799436,
-0.0446135402,
0.0153463883,
-0.000787036,
0.0283449814,
0.010167066,
0.0611311272,
-0.0063821273,
-0.0106518278,
0.0114384526,
0.0137715414,
0.0381082334,
-0.0202050079,
0.034736257,
0.0211024098,
0.0704375058,
0.0016598265,
0.0273822974,
-0.0224932805,
0.0479656123,
0.0237606168,
0.0184626225,
0.0204459894,
0.0359728225,
-0.0072936295,
0.0651891455,
0.0786978975,
0.0027557798,
-0.0121865943,
0.0155005315,
0.0042860461,
0.0207078345,
-0.0298719574,
-0.0009474508,
0.0525432192,
0.0258385967,
-0.0216581617,
0.0619168654,
0.024344312,
-0.0612481497,
0.0188116301,
0.0337241925,
0.0510704853,
-0.0510147288,
0.0367991477,
-0.0730820149,
-0.0398394205,
-0.0198189598,
0.0074502933,
0.045915775,
0.0269359741,
-0.0267719161,
-0.0426831879,
-0.0497360453,
-0.0151300645,
-0.0015939103,
-0.0105079925,
-0.024743801,
0.000134537,
-0.0094777727,
0.0332667865,
-0.013298816,
-0.0518424176,
0.0337559097,
-0.0099287322,
-0.0045061451,
-0.0084718205,
-0.0547739901,
0.0485983752,
0.028817201,
-0.0215364937,
0.0198892858,
0.082806766,
-0.0194131583,
-0.0104026916,
-0.0098105641,
-0.0054131541,
0.0223635808,
0.0243190452,
-0.0799651369,
0.0004584477,
0.0391482711,
-0.04033738,
-0.0593138747,
0.0098978765,
-0.017649902,
-0.0584804155,
0.0174750537,
0.0169519391,
0.0142061906,
0.0233148318,
-0.0344925486,
0.0568982586,
0.0268876124,
0.0563759394,
0.0532913171,
-0.0806617066,
0.0182163101,
-0.0364581347,
-0.0120652029,
0.0107617667,
-0.0025013869,
-0.0178514607,
0.0728299394,
-0.0087132277,
-0.0312501565,
-0.0200696588,
-0.104192093,
0.0265882611,
0.0147625031,
0.0174172893,
0.0755010322,
0.0234489962,
0.0233638305,
0.0113352258,
-0.0426747501,
-0.0395823494,
0.0289400928,
-0.0305251889,
0.0399557203,
-0.0021408314,
0.0281314012,
-0.0317124762,
-0.0237237439,
-0.0146700097,
0.0198243931,
0.0358662605,
0.0019241713,
-0.0279989224,
0.0495248213,
0.0137944566,
-0.0294084121,
-0.0000722636,
0.0300464928,
-0.0223986544,
-0.0094046788,
0.0168438926,
0.0445433147,
0.0643916205,
-0.002510339,
0.0479060709,
-0.0091041252,
-0.0290631354,
-0.0172803923,
-0.0524700209,
0.0338307731,
-0.0215593968,
-0.0525570065,
0.0495295972,
0.0333549753,
0.0067736572,
0.0133678252,
0.0222232156,
-0.0311510283,
0.0073042233,
0.0145160994,
-0.0275824498,
-0.0030960923,
0.0129689481,
0.0335962102,
0.0124924434,
0.0203873012,
-0.0022977863,
-0.0357607156,
-0.0099529522,
-0.0622953102,
0.005100775,
-0.077649802,
0.0017335856,
-0.0158348605,
0.0270897858,
-0.0307052825,
0.0028742545,
-0.0621944554,
-0.0155099509,
-0.0042192517,
-0.0245326757,
0.0126554184,
-0.0182742868,
0.0234810449,
-0.0786733776,
0.0110421833,
0.0044332086,
-0.0615231544,
0.0191548597,
0.0380759314,
0.0441084057,
-0.0495274253,
-0.0852214396,
-0.0094674313,
0.0569700114,
0.0311402455,
-0.0134624401,
-0.0343373269,
-0.0166310091,
0.0881598219,
0.0988126174,
-0.0088355336,
0.0102186399,
-0.0077377111,
-0.0038808326,
0.0802074745,
-0.0050535011,
0.0238800142,
0.0100709666,
-0.0393942706,
-0.01951061,
-0.0913465396,
0.0277038738,
-0.0448385365,
0.0220568068,
-0.0093793627,
0.0231045764,
0.1010201499,
0.0261936449,
-0.0420777127,
-0.0319623314,
-0.0172635727,
0.0457004346,
0.0113786003,
0.0060841856,
-0.0767250732,
0.0349981152,
-0.0084556807,
0.0273819342,
0.0038245998,
-0.0307833627,
0.0275095068,
-0.0476191677,
0.0115364436,
0.0317478515,
-0.0570584871,
-0.0131068463,
-0.0295077562,
0.0035294618,
0.0060019577,
-0.0193486437,
0.0311722513,
-0.0340726115,
-0.0174755678,
0.0186367184,
-0.0244990978,
0.0102885514,
-0.0303704813,
-0.0176252127,
0.0126579218,
0.0059827757,
0.0591142476,
-0.0304424483,
0.0250547249,
0.0349367037,
-0.0399246253,
-0.0470194556,
-0.0052836952,
0.0327158123,
0.0092155142,
0.008120209,
-0.0155043947,
0.0673724338,
-0.0264873616,
-0.0081806686,
0.0755961984,
0.0439572744,
0.0053176028,
-0.0157930236,
-0.0815677494,
0.0101820249,
-0.0370799042,
0.0373431183,
-0.0202581901,
0.006710636,
-0.0112900091,
-0.0029910263,
-0.020584207,
-0.0100305565,
-0.0432313308,
0.0056615337,
-0.0535058603,
-0.0342691727,
-0.0468231477,
-0.0023516614,
0.0182381123,
-0.0058058035,
0.0029244965,
-0.0139211891,
0.0349743366,
-0.0345288068,
-0.0714611411,
0.0074658892,
-0.0241509955,
-0.0259243511,
-0.0224353485,
-0.0373792835,
0.0549042411,
-0.0135897109,
-0.0174179263,
-0.0357800759,
-0.0434540994,
-0.034568876,
-0.0050657992,
-0.0056774653,
0.0097820899,
0.0524722524,
0.009191799,
0.0197226815,
0.0843528211,
0.048722133,
-0.0293687191,
0.0187619012,
-0.0174435973,
-0.0211674087,
-0.0415011905,
-0.0288789533,
-0.0514636599,
0.0418820493,
-0.0475591905,
0.0020211933,
-0.0423354469,
-0.0276292693,
0.0183189828,
0.041709125,
-0.0125840204,
-0.0343850106,
0.0479724407,
-0.0057038018,
-0.0195632335,
-0.0233313683,
-0.0281690434,
0.0122424681,
0.0265192874,
0.0088874064,
-0.01879742,
0.0238047987,
0.1103053913,
-0.0305532422,
0.0086841369,
-0.0365059488,
0.0267902128,
-0.0353452563,
0.0071412125,
-0.0040580481,
-0.0070118909,
-0.0367196985,
-0.0320943072,
-0.0566285104,
0.0311860703,
0.0095546991,
-0.0074504442,
0.0336146653,
0.0222673602,
0.0026045609,
0.0245350879,
-0.1065164059,
0.0085406173,
-0.0453645475,
-0.02199715,
0.0147174988,
-0.0384291448,
0.0564275086,
-0.0166718084,
-0.0208601356,
-0.0268420912,
0.0536922105,
0.0084491,
0.0369016118,
-0.0108607905,
0.0232228488,
-0.0031133047,
-0.0113139721,
0.0973784178,
-0.0145376269,
-0.036177095,
0.0444021933,
-0.0169197023,
-0.0352025889,
-0.0290961638,
-0.0008908064,
0.0446647666,
0.0080791572,
-0.0614927523,
-0.0022600791,
0.0214695614,
0.0444078334,
0.0022402592,
0.008852127,
-0.0234285388,
0.0153264171,
0.0033675211,
0.0056669689,
0.040548332,
-0.033444576,
0.041266419,
-0.0405032597,
-0.0496303625,
-0.0136734825,
-5.801382739e-33,
-0.0174082909,
-0.0479709618,
-0.0319614671,
0.0208410714,
-0.0374970175,
-0.0014009171,
-0.0528609864,
-0.0318152755,
0.0082641523,
0.0073373327,
-0.0381127447,
0.0050846655,
-0.0000205008,
0.0412326977,
0.0534157194,
0.0459778197,
0.03053643,
0.0023958303,
-0.0244902056,
0.0771915764,
0.0267867651,
-0.0349818878,
0.0397802778,
-0.1062975749,
0.0176778585,
-0.0155190108,
0.0123714935,
-0.0636080429,
0.0515924916,
0.0246083438,
-0.0056675961,
-0.0150836902,
0.0274186321,
-0.0270997658,
-0.0196328964,
0.0345062055,
-0.0691084936,
0.0199277177,
0.0148805408,
-0.0251002703,
-0.0121791316,
-0.0729752183,
0.0172898564,
-0.0431511179,
0.0267425478,
-0.0639501959,
0.0628122985,
-0.0465221703,
-0.0509488545,
-0.1345522702,
-0.0248958115,
-0.0008820682,
-0.0732500628,
0.034884911,
0.0071403068,
0.0250141136,
0.0047093364,
0.0716359541,
-0.0041280403,
0.0431160927,
-0.0171094947,
0.0754840523,
0.0181128625,
-0.0299862064,
0.0318889283,
0.0288932379,
-0.0250103809,
-0.00944228,
0.0075814649,
0.0129130231,
-0.0058107381,
-0.0110070668,
-0.0021582199,
0.0260820556,
0.0916126594,
0.0301658567,
-0.0287431031,
0.0846345425,
-0.0446520261,
0.0172244925,
0.0472549684,
0.0030523387,
0.0687528625,
-0.0026451852,
0.0231291931,
0.014310237,
-0.0020895372,
0.017356297,
-0.0455494821,
0.009763659,
-0.0554438457,
0.0250636563,
0.0245528072,
-0.0422136076,
-0.0000074248,
0.0297469273,
-0.0005033689,
0.0603179261,
-0.0147408079,
-0.0539290905,
-0.0586682074,
-0.0431004427,
0.0477806255,
0.0244879313,
-0.0102734286,
0.0206427332,
0.0587954782,
-0.0226907507,
-0.0370025299,
-0.0162212495,
0.0167983379,
-0.0074835983,
-0.0351075344,
0.0405710861,
-0.0350797474,
0.0264041964,
0.034651041,
0.0206831954,
-0.0045648413,
0.0253593288,
0.0042627654,
0.0366445594,
0.0251744576,
0.0261130147,
0.0192019753,
0.0222732294,
-0.0195798874,
-0.0169560928,
0.0506841615,
-0.0115883164,
-0.0062586362,
-0.0249018706,
2.458e-7,
0.033945851,
0.0337954573,
0.0321554057,
0.0026271744,
0.0143298591,
0.0119464304,
0.0142881013,
0.0433125272,
0.0071761059,
0.0277389679,
0.0509465002,
-0.0270141177,
0.0185816735,
0.0350798815,
-0.1180726886,
-0.0674996302,
-0.0710856616,
-0.0692388564,
-0.0611644201,
0.0123588964,
0.0313205719,
0.0653806925,
-0.0410199761,
0.0023488645,
-0.0018169149,
0.0015645748,
0.0243801847,
0.0060661221,
0.0071969777,
0.0413782336,
0.0002821862,
-0.008398544,
-0.0151075274,
-0.0273191798,
0.0044128913,
0.0087284753,
0.0154199749,
0.0308218747,
0.0013279583,
0.0143113686,
0.0270481035,
-0.0163843036,
0.0337184407,
0.0139625547,
0.0047759516,
-0.0617177561,
-0.020097943,
-0.0637279972,
-0.0596314594,
0.0329557993,
-0.0272104591,
0.0130812936,
0.0122910487,
0.0544227436,
-0.0017763894,
-0.0315511003,
0.0046349638,
-0.0177984312,
-0.0238150246,
0.067068629,
-0.0065735462,
-0.0293697845,
0.0242206398,
-0.0318407156,
-0.002425812,
-0.0731150061,
-0.003972772,
2.583008787e-34,
0.0833952874,
0.0084302323,
-0.0502040721,
0.0138044693,
0.0169440992,
-0.0590920672,
-0.0372404866,
0.0267731249,
-0.0213856809,
-0.0765758008,
-0.0001394399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04562v1 | NLP-based Decision Support System for Examination of Eligibility Criteria from Securities Prospectuses at the German Central Bank | 2023-02-09T11:00:58 | 2023-02-09T11:00:58 | Christian Hänig, Markus Schlösser, Serhii Hamotskyi, Gent Zambaku, Janek Blankenburg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As part of its digitization initiative, the German Central Bank (Deutsche
Bundesbank) wants to examine the extent to which natural Language Processing
(NLP) can be used to make independent decisions upon the eligibility criteria
of securities prospectuses. Every month, the Directorate General Markets at the
German Central Bank receives hundreds of scanned prospectuses in PDF format,
which must be manually processed to decide upon their eligibility. We found
that this tedious and time-consuming process can be (semi-)automated by
employing modern NLP model architectures, which learn the linguistic feature
representation in text to identify the present eligible and ineligible
criteria. The proposed Decision Support System provides decisions of
document-level eligibility criteria accompanied by human-understandable
explanations of the decisions. The aim of this project is to model the
described use case and to evaluate the extent to which current research results
from the field of NLP can be applied to this problem. After creating a
heterogeneous domain-specific dataset containing annotations of eligible and
non-eligible mentions of relevant criteria, we were able to successfully build,
train and deploy a semi-automatic decider model. This model is based on
transformer-based language models and decision trees, which integrate the
established rule-based parts of the decision processes. Results suggest that it
is possible to efficiently model the problem and automate decision making to
more than 90% for many of the considered eligibility criteria. | [
0.0679280311,
0.0092771584,
-0.015162182,
-0.0037887231,
-0.0411073752,
0.0026399279,
-0.0077925413,
0.0350783728,
-0.0037162937,
-0.0808127001,
0.0214337669,
0.0021152094,
0.013342727,
0.0353001952,
-0.0470820963,
-0.0366037861,
0.0203252696,
-0.0212304611,
0.054989215,
0.0355240367,
0.0331873745,
0.0253677536,
0.0085004671,
0.0191807318,
-0.0143003128,
0.001708301,
0.0075810244,
-0.0365385376,
-0.0229812879,
-0.0131678833,
-0.0210037921,
0.0195876155,
0.0076098791,
-0.0092816353,
0.0000017959,
-0.0861151963,
-0.0628000423,
0.0156706497,
-0.0050826482,
-0.0325008705,
0.0688031614,
-0.0442391522,
-0.0065501574,
0.0056123538,
-0.046365153,
0.0300150961,
0.0192426816,
0.0739311278,
0.0700104982,
0.0627031177,
-0.0298447516,
-0.0478544459,
-0.0189158916,
-0.0007171514,
-0.0399272107,
-0.0533157624,
0.0182877388,
-0.0081562446,
0.028251294,
0.0112701831,
0.0089802239,
0.0079687014,
-0.0190520268,
-0.0380889513,
-0.0129736913,
-0.0212139543,
-0.003841518,
-0.0298745949,
-0.038620837,
0.0062361392,
0.0314976536,
0.0204865001,
0.006503358,
-0.0416448489,
0.0030860433,
0.0511788838,
-0.0143268658,
0.0435193293,
-0.0484182052,
-0.0144217033,
0.0425244011,
0.0425416008,
-0.02754003,
-0.0036096466,
-0.0061205472,
0.0819290429,
-0.0207245704,
-0.0667163879,
0.062245734,
0.0264020991,
0.0257540196,
-0.0637912452,
0.0668851882,
0.037430767,
0.0233285669,
0.0293943416,
-0.0072916644,
-0.01254021,
0.0422477648,
-0.0570330918,
-0.0219182223,
-0.0130214598,
-0.0020898089,
0.0453180186,
-0.0192345846,
0.0126865814,
0.0280862805,
-0.0227993075,
-0.0177652836,
0.018412726,
-0.0635642111,
-0.0256577097,
-0.0438100994,
0.0650952682,
-0.0367264524,
-0.0202968009,
-0.0750959739,
-0.013804446,
-0.0092227738,
0.027058417,
0.0586571693,
-0.0122895315,
0.0217944141,
-0.0050536701,
-0.10224621,
-0.0314040519,
-0.026084153,
-0.0056618876,
-0.0477811806,
0.0362569988,
0.0693541542,
0.0200754814,
0.0191760901,
0.0009109722,
0.0122706341,
0.0566117465,
0.0511431955,
-0.0229379497,
-0.0459322296,
-0.0440769419,
0.0064527416,
-0.0197786521,
-0.0204627942,
0.0106708603,
-0.0260437801,
-0.0022704876,
0.0013804521,
-0.0252391323,
-0.0008776532,
0.0216000341,
0.0119846053,
0.0842472464,
-0.0107592857,
-0.0382479839,
-0.0063036857,
-0.0385956541,
0.0098341601,
0.0078866091,
0.0042357952,
0.0278961025,
0.0390276574,
-0.0235889163,
0.046846889,
0.0094818771,
-0.0555728078,
-0.0801517963,
0.0242768358,
0.0248566344,
-0.0596404821,
-0.0301536061,
0.00051405,
0.006703042,
0.0011101326,
-0.0128031932,
0.006773632,
0.0959019959,
0.0858274177,
-0.0184451826,
0.0042819371,
0.0511172637,
-0.0011221048,
0.0056955195,
0.0413395688,
0.0013673581,
-0.0151150068,
0.0157839544,
-0.0886857286,
0.0091991611,
0.0076645678,
-0.0792992488,
-0.0376708247,
-0.0010868785,
0.0309148971,
-0.0333961956,
0.0494364351,
0.0139044989,
-0.0483740866,
0.0342130326,
0.0111411819,
0.002722376,
-0.0488045998,
-0.033291284,
0.010218529,
0.0758041292,
0.0527540483,
-0.0636835471,
0.0620117299,
-0.0193431228,
-0.0604922101,
0.0590671115,
0.0404590331,
-0.0107772192,
-0.0479955375,
-0.0370393731,
-0.0130159818,
0.0404170491,
0.0005253306,
0.0044899783,
-0.0422144495,
0.0046532904,
-0.0092591625,
0.0186816119,
-0.0187060013,
0.0614288449,
0.0253622718,
-0.0271875318,
0.021135889,
0.0217863452,
0.0058760615,
0.0419401601,
0.0066376175,
0.0102302982,
-0.0042250301,
0.0198588017,
-0.0345906503,
-0.0004919791,
0.020392498,
0.0382278524,
-0.0010815702,
-0.0234419871,
-0.0353288241,
-0.0416921899,
-0.0172063224,
0.0028083031,
-0.0161712281,
-0.0275380388,
0.0072603701,
-0.0686241388,
0.0121547263,
-0.0107821533,
0.0022810514,
-0.0490922406,
0.0648627281,
0.0383528844,
0.0063448003,
-0.0098213507,
-0.0566309169,
0.0296215974,
-0.0425673686,
0.0334672071,
-0.004266331,
-0.0390297137,
0.0443485491,
0.0500402302,
0.0159092322,
0.0045835208,
0.0051545305,
-0.0305244606,
-0.0219766293,
0.0155812642,
0.0259766802,
-0.0052104006,
-0.0038789967,
-0.004858145,
-0.0189238563,
0.009239235,
0.0059246444,
0.0074187913,
-0.0224497505,
0.0770342276,
-0.0153329531,
-0.0191833209,
-0.0058376486,
-0.0147426389,
-0.0214803945,
0.0360927135,
0.0959135219,
-0.0386869796,
-0.0487492234,
0.062586613,
0.0187083334,
0.0167959705,
0.008683621,
0.0458485335,
0.0140061695,
0.0133903408,
-0.0616446063,
0.0396283381,
-0.0060510575,
0.0660622939,
0.0244452246,
0.0043833968,
-0.0298127513,
-0.0006720144,
-0.0105746686,
0.0681015626,
0.0030320757,
0.0257711094,
0.0664320886,
-0.000462918,
-0.0093917148,
-0.0014618626,
-0.044512447,
0.026836589,
-0.0429349206,
0.006221158,
-0.0618646294,
-0.0103585087,
-0.0111050727,
0.0973353535,
0.0273785684,
-0.0307585653,
0.0573090278,
-0.0197443683,
0.0033161482,
-0.0971134529,
-0.0360158309,
-0.0662127584,
0.0463613905,
-0.0178475045,
0.0177922435,
0.040076606,
-0.0160853565,
0.0044856411,
-0.0469417684,
0.0515331738,
-0.0111807976,
0.024384087,
-0.0174236391,
0.052993156,
-0.008744684,
-0.0212679245,
-0.0124552669,
-0.0260710735,
0.0012366497,
0.0103686228,
0.0399968587,
-0.0152800577,
-0.053601522,
0.0707724467,
-0.0261275377,
0.0432820581,
0.0316170901,
-0.0475485772,
0.0045491694,
0.0117434235,
0.0259726774,
-0.0247394592,
0.0454595126,
0.0146369608,
0.0266361721,
0.0082754996,
-0.0316106081,
0.0283212457,
-0.0178965628,
-0.0042012562,
-0.022502128,
-0.1082372963,
0.0230829306,
0.0032893005,
-0.0514906198,
-0.0641633421,
0.0450846031,
0.0874344036,
0.0329837389,
0.031259425,
0.0027628052,
0.0036994009,
-0.08566048,
-0.0302914567,
0.0600098819,
-0.0586155839,
0.0154247154,
-0.0020529134,
0.0159190707,
-0.0498291142,
-0.0083035175,
-0.0178134087,
-0.0738571361,
0.0906900764,
-0.0312560499,
0.0169159081,
-0.0145615274,
-0.0505068004,
-0.0282419547,
-0.0535851493,
-0.0209145471,
-0.020604929,
-0.0273197778,
-0.0240898617,
-0.0185358413,
-0.0945941359,
-0.0319603682,
0.0031190854,
0.0106983325,
-0.0624538846,
0.0456312411,
0.045373559,
-0.0081689637,
0.006823421,
-0.024957059,
-0.0280481298,
0.0108282929,
-0.0161654167,
0.0276360363,
0.0007349772,
0.0025474764,
-0.0367870629,
-0.0049542356,
-0.0191377904,
0.0239096191,
0.0232241638,
0.0447969809,
-0.0244333614,
-0.0489428565,
-0.0185928661,
0.0255444404,
-0.0125316475,
0.0534486473,
-0.0196127594,
-0.0345597938,
-0.0262547228,
-0.0555742644,
0.0169560406,
-0.0518110096,
-0.0167178847,
0.0288177282,
-0.0345082209,
-0.0404433794,
-0.07046552,
-0.0396996103,
0.0021876579,
0.0449554659,
0.019679714,
0.0232616011,
0.0929723382,
0.0036670894,
-0.024384765,
0.0177555531,
0.0220588241,
0.0328817964,
-0.044584915,
0.0230567697,
0.030864045,
0.0180704799,
-0.0682098866,
0.0004488872,
0.0459902436,
-0.0086221453,
-0.0204298701,
-0.011355713,
0.0371080898,
-0.0411375351,
-0.0329717323,
-0.0038508745,
0.0403575338,
0.01515825,
-0.0138061214,
-0.0644407943,
0.0232254229,
-0.0199749693,
-0.0193475075,
-0.0218654852,
0.0052329456,
0.0419194177,
-0.0341415927,
-0.0228375662,
-0.0294045862,
-0.00782625,
0.033086583,
0.0264420565,
-0.0004153034,
0.028032748,
-0.0282112211,
-0.0133669712,
-0.0167993885,
0.0215259865,
-0.0119684832,
-0.0263149887,
-0.0432854258,
0.0291249398,
-0.0107486621,
-0.0012374789,
-0.0154273268,
-0.0475306846,
-0.0317272544,
0.0000068769,
0.0708326623,
0.047992751,
0.048352275,
-0.0045726667,
-0.0423513427,
0.0371559411,
0.0022692138,
0.02229454,
0.0244120192,
0.0031152675,
0.0297907144,
0.0030988336,
0.0296447854,
-0.0185565688,
-0.0045740954,
-0.0090698376,
0.0215635877,
-0.026531158,
0.0338630192,
0.0208077896,
-0.0166004878,
-0.0190848615,
-0.0781468526,
0.0214230455,
0.0019941439,
0.0154690295,
0.0603932142,
-0.0217179712,
-0.0041684285,
0.0107438331,
-0.0350180119,
-0.0269573666,
0.0250636432,
0.0057401019,
-0.0206756126,
-0.0449693389,
-0.0718971267,
-0.0520919859,
-0.0358259305,
0.0007583212,
-0.0074180854,
-0.0186869502,
0.0174295157,
-0.0880934447,
-0.0095055541,
-0.00429792,
-0.0004139738,
0.0193074346,
-0.0113670724,
0.0027039647,
0.0561905093,
0.0264504571,
0.0174629427,
-0.0364401042,
-0.0256958958,
-0.0233308878,
0.0056390245,
-0.0761206374,
-5.261276513e-33,
-0.0260023512,
-0.0532994643,
0.0349698551,
0.0194213577,
0.0601855889,
-0.0077545983,
0.0116263274,
-0.0611838438,
0.0250070505,
0.0024465292,
0.0110332072,
-0.0125609236,
0.0244823918,
-0.0105122998,
0.0142238345,
0.0277632251,
0.0353772119,
-0.0098713012,
-0.030426763,
-0.0700518191,
0.0396903269,
0.0199855715,
0.0200773142,
-0.034227185,
0.0451852344,
0.0454714112,
-0.0426827595,
-0.0235946234,
0.0351256877,
0.066772595,
0.0097000832,
0.0203467775,
0.037538074,
-0.117109023,
0.0043801046,
0.0681529045,
-0.0490032919,
-0.0539513379,
0.0041602328,
0.0499844365,
0.0586208962,
0.0219699834,
0.0350649878,
-0.0117847845,
-0.0400483198,
0.0370173156,
0.0363378264,
0.0025385693,
0.001674655,
-0.0457367785,
-0.0943852812,
0.0443042144,
0.0265956484,
0.0463651903,
0.0682709292,
0.0345867388,
-0.0162430368,
0.0089426208,
-0.018156385,
0.0262546856,
0.026419105,
0.016846329,
0.0187186189,
-0.0478336886,
-0.0509715676,
0.0178845134,
-0.0169552546,
-0.0173357204,
0.027440846,
-0.0207381584,
0.0100255096,
0.0364103541,
0.0199045986,
-0.0072446349,
0.0630949885,
-0.0127422884,
-0.0120138107,
0.0592878647,
0.0155303106,
0.0767456442,
0.0273348931,
-0.0089909798,
-0.0360381939,
-0.0350592397,
0.0175944716,
0.0004340461,
-0.0120365238,
-0.0148519306,
0.0378941931,
0.015483818,
-0.0362376124,
0.0397202224,
-0.0170417,
-0.0351465344,
-0.0528814867,
-0.0324429534,
0.0282107908,
0.0219453778,
-0.0113319987,
-0.009347585,
0.0030437009,
-0.0406544544,
0.0134829404,
0.0093661686,
0.0122742169,
-0.0163361896,
-0.0149365002,
-0.008901123,
-0.0381352268,
0.0145952953,
0.0259416122,
-0.0016629781,
0.0024538068,
0.0534727722,
-0.0223712251,
0.0400581844,
-0.0100716287,
-0.0124861244,
-0.0115131047,
-0.0170449782,
-0.0099518253,
-0.0222974829,
0.0042941552,
0.0337199345,
0.0091286041,
-0.0167932585,
0.0103961024,
0.0070669027,
0.0223093331,
0.0160120372,
0.0047581503,
0.0573756993,
2.536e-7,
0.0561649874,
0.0793200508,
-0.0344775282,
0.0082805399,
0.003427244,
0.0196234453,
-0.0047915881,
-0.0135437623,
-0.0123453876,
-0.0029316745,
0.0386848524,
-0.0415961035,
0.0250052232,
0.0479483083,
-0.0874291211,
-0.0611940958,
0.0155574176,
-0.0126014678,
-0.0729331896,
0.0580027029,
0.0633661747,
0.0442096666,
-0.0107320873,
-0.0266674012,
-0.0292598847,
-0.0690992624,
-0.001928741,
-0.0209626183,
-0.0046974914,
-0.0121489987,
0.1112204641,
-0.0123754106,
0.007306878,
0.0720614716,
-0.0037408038,
0.036246106,
0.0059432806,
0.0489769243,
-0.0163113885,
0.0691901296,
0.010466327,
-0.0178650524,
0.002567705,
-0.0002489449,
0.0252792146,
-0.0617846474,
-0.0255538225,
-0.0432618298,
-0.0264067557,
-0.0107409246,
0.0208221283,
0.028947141,
-0.0331728645,
-0.0069756294,
0.0088140266,
-0.0138152232,
0.0179762095,
-0.0609989278,
0.0370596237,
0.0121302474,
0.0183625799,
0.021300178,
-0.0186403375,
0.0230585374,
0.0481037274,
-0.0549318381,
0.0108002564,
2.483841145e-34,
0.0660368055,
-0.0205609612,
-0.0362317413,
0.0283375084,
0.0606703572,
0.0356410258,
0.0214644223,
0.0296237059,
-0.0138585595,
-0.0627925918,
0.0304043721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04555v1 | Data Augmentation for Robust Character Detection in Fantasy Novels | 2023-02-09T10:47:03 | 2023-02-09T10:47:03 | Arthur Amalvy, Vincent Labatut, Richard Dufour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a low-level task often used as a foundation
for solving higher level NLP problems. In the context of character detection in
novels, NER false negatives can be an issue as they possibly imply missing
certain characters or relationships completely. In this article, we demonstrate
that applying a straightforward data augmentation technique allows training a
model achieving higher recall, at the cost of a certain amount of precision
regarding ambiguous entities. We show that this decrease in precision can be
mitigated by giving the model more local context, which resolves some of the
ambiguities. | [
0.0360436179,
0.0547245257,
-0.0136329466,
0.0686051771,
0.0232521463,
0.0430722944,
-0.0049970881,
-0.0099761188,
0.0178873371,
-0.0154657746,
0.0004605029,
-0.0475550964,
0.0448424257,
0.0151327439,
0.0475916974,
-0.0326806754,
0.0537060089,
-0.0304091927,
0.0178246293,
0.0249553919,
0.005354838,
0.0244079623,
-0.0133746611,
0.0087489709,
-0.0066338722,
-0.0151986126,
-0.0300274808,
0.0170280412,
0.0613961034,
-0.0504588,
0.0025259159,
-0.0041468414,
-0.0065644938,
0.0392618813,
0.000001971,
-0.037559621,
-0.015900271,
-0.0071236021,
-0.0497199371,
-0.0364704914,
0.0131224822,
-0.0236544665,
0.0104489569,
-0.0286981706,
0.0097145317,
-0.0326208584,
0.0572083779,
0.088426739,
0.0274274461,
0.0703331605,
-0.0078270556,
-0.0206625517,
0.0117739467,
0.0080215037,
0.0350770503,
-0.0134640541,
0.0052940245,
-0.0111079123,
0.0110686999,
0.0275649875,
-0.0217420254,
0.0421793833,
-0.0240627658,
0.0552886352,
0.0330599062,
0.0514926985,
-0.0131855393,
0.0441922285,
0.0060252277,
0.0554074273,
0.0162413176,
-0.0115608005,
-0.0234173872,
-0.0172849167,
-0.007712598,
0.0073496881,
0.0149748381,
-0.0300218798,
-0.0409234166,
-0.0075865225,
0.0092660189,
0.0052179229,
0.0464951359,
0.005937661,
-0.0319088064,
0.0148874475,
-0.0004541291,
-0.0419039428,
0.0023405512,
0.0071746721,
-0.0678028315,
-0.0217736382,
0.01750765,
0.0517634824,
0.0010529925,
0.0182069577,
-0.0406761803,
-0.0381223485,
0.0039830524,
-0.0638473108,
-0.0112286396,
0.0389838926,
-0.023255052,
0.027290877,
-0.0297307912,
0.0183371846,
0.0173338763,
0.0174164511,
0.0161894355,
-0.0156876985,
0.0026791727,
-0.0215618368,
-0.0568974465,
0.0305731595,
-0.0412447564,
-0.0083234152,
-0.0377298035,
-0.0383428819,
-0.006802436,
0.0382674858,
-0.0118075898,
0.0312936269,
-0.0329350978,
-0.014973334,
-0.0601013042,
-0.0076731578,
-0.0376412645,
0.0052656694,
-0.0382810235,
-0.0338359326,
-0.0051354421,
-0.0609365776,
0.0637249276,
-0.0499545373,
0.0582036711,
0.0810942724,
0.0127540575,
-0.0713386387,
-0.0737810507,
-0.0035363592,
0.0050671045,
-0.0335170664,
-0.0622427091,
-0.0080793668,
0.0220986977,
-0.0355990827,
0.0474943146,
-0.0360378847,
0.0221821014,
0.0112791015,
-0.0487714671,
0.1007470191,
-0.0577981509,
-0.0158547983,
0.0278950687,
-0.0002331363,
0.0184885338,
0.05270667,
0.0540858544,
0.0037140695,
0.0171028562,
0.0026562328,
0.0128274513,
0.0112054953,
-0.0019010215,
-0.0261255819,
-0.0071390742,
-0.001928884,
-0.0249392428,
0.0176526904,
0.0165947247,
0.0160607491,
-0.0268988106,
-0.0413324386,
0.0608473271,
0.0330325849,
0.0200580582,
0.0051428112,
0.025201397,
-0.0098029617,
0.010483006,
-0.0025633483,
-0.0438875332,
0.0008749025,
-0.0139614455,
0.0134900082,
-0.0532862954,
0.0231792331,
0.0276370104,
0.0066596079,
-0.0028450133,
-0.0103139635,
0.0268197525,
0.0229740907,
0.0445077606,
0.0060389279,
-0.0578637421,
-0.0103476411,
0.0162922703,
-0.0456925109,
0.0392324142,
0.0129396953,
0.004245712,
0.0789731517,
0.0569755696,
-0.0592360348,
-0.0605196245,
-0.0501103997,
-0.0473686382,
0.0314299762,
-0.0302122869,
-0.031686347,
0.0825999156,
-0.0532597974,
0.0200958587,
-0.0142828552,
0.011067464,
0.038858749,
-0.0076877684,
0.0256778449,
0.019504901,
-0.0113200527,
-0.043771442,
0.0576040894,
-0.0567030571,
-0.053808149,
-0.0364135765,
0.0713070109,
-0.0439497232,
0.0468371585,
-0.0251127873,
-0.0522358678,
0.0179785248,
-0.0400433838,
-0.0138438074,
0.0140563371,
-0.0018749185,
-0.0012102565,
0.049010653,
-0.0138007589,
-0.0373271815,
-0.0103338053,
0.0009036844,
-0.0416399986,
0.0028627466,
-0.0260342024,
0.0272048097,
-0.0094653266,
0.0450570397,
0.0067040734,
0.0104523869,
-0.0463404469,
0.0813909546,
0.0074150697,
0.0227407962,
-0.0077943131,
0.0187115185,
0.0091406545,
-0.0505907387,
-0.0340334401,
-0.0217766669,
0.0499591455,
-0.0430681668,
0.0071154968,
-0.0529977158,
-0.0188061688,
-0.0267821383,
-0.0673559234,
0.0066362531,
0.0256896559,
0.0206032172,
0.0025136168,
0.0338911377,
-0.0458019525,
-0.01735924,
-0.0326000415,
-0.0344477147,
-0.0214565117,
-0.008194901,
0.0385898314,
0.0462007932,
-0.0077526621,
0.0077620968,
0.0161066335,
-0.0233556945,
0.0257415511,
0.0326470546,
-0.046276059,
-0.0458672419,
0.000890474,
-0.0278557725,
0.0303233806,
-0.0159986857,
-0.0219641905,
-0.0175808035,
-0.0023504638,
-0.0198673513,
0.0386388414,
-0.0262030493,
-0.0066924137,
-0.0030404218,
-0.0485537313,
-0.0180622395,
0.0475647897,
0.0366369598,
0.0193681773,
0.0064961147,
-0.0480876453,
0.0065340744,
0.0536207855,
-0.0440846793,
-0.0106916605,
-0.0415151604,
0.0043705041,
0.0201008413,
-0.0238259956,
-0.0251692217,
-0.0175263472,
-0.0064155259,
0.0358408131,
-0.0382640325,
0.0069281082,
0.0524993241,
-0.0331016891,
-0.0330515988,
-0.0167528819,
0.013112559,
-0.038700778,
0.0388013609,
0.0302473567,
0.0220695473,
0.0254661832,
-0.0876294374,
-0.0082181552,
0.042478852,
0.0175151117,
-0.0254912134,
0.0706078261,
0.0016637279,
-0.0125636319,
-0.0244085826,
0.0086460412,
-0.0418086164,
-0.0030988285,
-0.0426386073,
-0.0621215664,
-0.0089198453,
-0.035625916,
-0.0079954173,
0.0178986918,
-0.0154480003,
0.0403838195,
-0.0169411674,
-0.0250366628,
-0.0230150297,
-0.0066886228,
0.0194400921,
0.0252406225,
0.0387526415,
-0.0418256,
-0.0040962677,
0.0028077101,
-0.073048234,
-0.0544114374,
-0.032909397,
0.0346723869,
0.0215831716,
-0.045253817,
-0.0074688694,
-0.0302306861,
0.0167861525,
-0.1049476787,
0.0015492226,
0.0843645483,
0.01263717,
0.0118349865,
-0.0127077959,
0.0060803387,
-0.0277660843,
0.0276130792,
0.0024196671,
-0.0809991732,
-0.0133062778,
0.0359317064,
0.0239769071,
-0.0285409261,
-0.078211762,
-0.0198962539,
-0.0921803266,
0.0091637373,
-0.0110718776,
-0.0814849362,
-0.0359972306,
-0.0100044627,
0.0240045749,
-0.0381697267,
0.0348174013,
-0.003850692,
-0.0279818028,
0.0027483841,
-0.0115723806,
0.0503984913,
-0.0021944542,
-0.0515736267,
-0.0513836369,
0.0561285466,
0.0376044996,
0.0595818013,
-0.0142695159,
0.019102281,
-0.0327799283,
0.0115609858,
-0.0034368117,
0.006019495,
0.10877911,
-0.0313817896,
-0.0332484357,
-0.0222671088,
0.0080536492,
0.0114577087,
-0.0444035903,
0.0206272993,
0.0048351483,
-0.002771693,
0.0391343236,
0.0038060739,
0.015053913,
0.0327799842,
0.0466010496,
-0.0040809582,
0.0032558143,
-0.0125526562,
0.0007349458,
0.0377840139,
-0.0294110011,
-0.0138245486,
0.0238813311,
-0.021560356,
-0.024769336,
-0.0503419377,
-0.0535373911,
0.0562101491,
0.0597391836,
0.0903608277,
0.0351911709,
-0.0050225216,
0.0199707989,
-0.0256224182,
0.0249615218,
-0.0280669425,
0.0043518934,
-0.020146681,
-0.0084550688,
0.0041012075,
-0.0510105491,
0.0155403772,
0.0041928096,
-0.0607968643,
-0.0300814565,
0.0057658623,
-0.0079517066,
0.0215207879,
0.0655883178,
-0.0390363596,
-0.0853938907,
0.0047268914,
0.0461497344,
-0.0580180027,
0.0206426233,
-0.0025338468,
0.025860494,
-0.0298567098,
0.002295522,
-0.0114090359,
0.0171335116,
0.0100502027,
0.0019970355,
-0.0288814306,
-0.0045454246,
0.0086428886,
0.0279229097,
0.0342714638,
-0.0509463735,
0.0100445962,
-0.0533244126,
0.031576775,
-0.0397083461,
-0.0072552632,
0.0211266074,
-0.0035307689,
0.0063301316,
0.0146336984,
-0.0300991554,
0.0090392511,
0.0025286749,
0.0432528667,
-0.0741714165,
-0.006504246,
0.0434728004,
0.015463002,
0.0159145631,
0.0273718331,
0.0080751767,
0.0095758252,
-0.0029474297,
0.082511574,
0.0130412448,
0.0261330418,
0.0079564499,
-0.0103958268,
-0.0576877072,
-0.0197999235,
-0.0502601862,
0.0095644258,
-0.0163562559,
0.0452599488,
0.0202686228,
-0.0141786272,
0.0345279239,
-0.017955875,
-0.0106061343,
0.0329264514,
0.0055730827,
0.0284668561,
0.0075374828,
-0.0300489049,
0.0478762127,
-0.0199175458,
0.0284240581,
0.0254061483,
-0.0259335283,
0.0628866553,
0.0106143355,
-0.0399349332,
-0.0300120469,
-0.01311462,
0.0440849289,
0.0404464081,
-0.0276067629,
0.0347062834,
-0.0675828308,
-0.0594046712,
0.0464509204,
-0.0135957254,
0.0155550586,
0.0094054118,
-0.008546263,
-0.0446043983,
0.0299154762,
-0.0203857906,
-0.0386482701,
0.0254391059,
0.0232448224,
-0.0003099843,
-0.0214107465,
-5.50072508e-33,
-0.0541118532,
0.0155897094,
-0.0041004079,
-0.0056828307,
-0.0390251502,
0.0267965402,
0.0165236369,
-0.0093318736,
0.014635291,
0.0211094618,
-0.0179523602,
0.0126320291,
0.0203348994,
-0.0152645875,
-0.0354981795,
-0.0284498483,
0.064874135,
0.0585940629,
-0.0130896065,
-0.0150321946,
0.0526637658,
0.0557510667,
0.0841549113,
-0.0966140851,
0.0452039242,
-0.0106761334,
-0.0425021537,
-0.0036063837,
0.0696476996,
0.0407642648,
-0.0285086278,
0.0032435833,
0.0095465649,
-0.0067716725,
0.0017486126,
-0.0002890465,
-0.1635785997,
-0.0063849199,
-0.0026619933,
0.0753128305,
0.0519503504,
-0.0310052652,
0.0358351879,
-0.0090725599,
0.0492364392,
-0.0048044422,
0.0497324541,
-0.0390798673,
0.0030812637,
-0.0169058554,
-0.0862646326,
0.0202595107,
-0.0266777854,
0.031762857,
0.0710749701,
0.0207564197,
0.0233971328,
0.0008688231,
-0.0720853955,
-0.0404606126,
0.0873615742,
-0.0346225202,
-0.0281950943,
0.0953254253,
-0.0294945333,
0.0855997205,
0.0554954447,
0.0040902994,
-0.0489255898,
0.0635742918,
0.0435738452,
-0.032093171,
0.0010148387,
0.0911824033,
0.0777285546,
0.0061174138,
-0.0643073022,
0.022218734,
0.0004440269,
0.0118433824,
0.0181178767,
-0.0133929914,
-0.0875353515,
-0.0194610916,
-0.0109392833,
-0.010365122,
-0.0345500894,
-0.0289354213,
-0.0067011886,
-0.0128162401,
-0.070986338,
0.0544723161,
-0.0087507982,
-0.0460603386,
-0.0413413309,
-0.0004837846,
0.0297851004,
0.0131711671,
-0.0161297489,
0.0079717245,
0.0294780973,
-0.0401451401,
0.0540080816,
0.0012864069,
0.0624072254,
-0.0091670956,
0.053264454,
0.0233864766,
-0.0869653448,
-0.009220575,
-0.0053920215,
0.0399045944,
-0.0068602026,
0.0649923682,
0.0431923568,
-0.0465512574,
0.0025385704,
0.0388605893,
0.02534247,
0.0091380505,
-0.018314762,
0.0083870729,
-0.0034991743,
-0.011038186,
-0.02686234,
-0.0113435686,
0.0284185354,
-0.0317807198,
0.0125114974,
-0.0963025168,
-0.0027183325,
-0.0187778939,
2.715e-7,
0.0013560737,
-0.0112135485,
0.0531756803,
-0.000905396,
-0.0314156078,
0.018003447,
-0.0142607419,
0.0246868674,
0.0208962411,
-0.0328425094,
0.0198032465,
-0.0082909586,
0.0130782677,
0.0226316266,
-0.0802658275,
-0.0164626054,
0.0179656371,
0.0017763023,
-0.029299207,
0.0139054265,
0.013169881,
0.0751374289,
0.056041535,
-0.0333052166,
0.0389108844,
-0.0194809306,
0.0349452496,
-0.0234168135,
0.0161433481,
0.0456672944,
0.0345911123,
0.0720243081,
-0.0029349469,
0.0383548923,
-0.0125279715,
0.0460624918,
0.0062700803,
0.030788755,
-0.0434679799,
0.0371167585,
-0.0144772185,
-0.0350250676,
-0.002159198,
-0.0180636626,
0.0851516277,
0.0092456164,
-0.0277724918,
-0.0046224175,
-0.0413884409,
0.0167558361,
-0.0074840416,
-0.012313365,
-0.034189228,
0.0303546134,
0.0314139612,
-0.0225544479,
-0.0107165286,
-0.1116418913,
0.0183330067,
0.0387916528,
0.013870311,
-0.0192500614,
0.0169144254,
-0.0136378724,
-0.0099274404,
-0.094507426,
0.0045495597,
2.375170595e-34,
-0.0248436909,
0.0023406686,
-0.0231397562,
0.0404652543,
0.0410217829,
-0.022389112,
0.01702719,
0.0010462014,
0.0217201747,
-0.0183326658,
-0.004062287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04542v1 | Efficient Attention via Control Variates | 2023-02-09T10:16:20 | 2023-02-09T10:16:20 | Lin Zheng, Jianbo Yuan, Chong Wang, Lingpeng Kong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Random-feature-based attention (RFA) is an efficient approximation of softmax
attention with linear runtime and space complexity. However, the approximation
gap between RFA and conventional softmax attention is not well studied. Built
upon previous progress of RFA, we characterize this gap through the lens of
control variates and show that RFA can be decomposed into a sum of multiple
control variate estimators for each element in the sequence. This new framework
reveals that exact softmax attention can be recovered from RFA by manipulating
each control variate. Besides, it allows us to develop a more flexible form of
control variates, resulting in a novel attention mechanism that significantly
reduces the approximation gap while maintaining linear complexity. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that our model outperforms state-of-the-art efficient
attention mechanisms on both vision and language tasks. | [
0.0022880801,
-0.005318074,
0.0025983984,
0.0324589871,
0.0059443102,
0.0250267461,
0.0269533936,
-0.0323394053,
-0.0232758932,
-0.0046872371,
-0.0057705706,
-0.0661993772,
0.0264884159,
0.0835492238,
0.0308209863,
-0.0421792939,
0.0116021074,
-0.0472568646,
0.0588621721,
-0.0184175484,
0.0216418095,
-0.0270556919,
0.0167797823,
0.0478847884,
-0.0160820987,
0.0065662516,
-0.0382334888,
0.0008650607,
0.0178673975,
0.0011622375,
0.0068107825,
0.0666935444,
0.0130152069,
-0.0074988422,
0.0000020555,
-0.0191698335,
0.0402001031,
-0.0005564057,
0.0356839299,
0.0235259589,
-0.0191982202,
-0.0093345419,
0.0104953013,
-0.0168793444,
0.0283035133,
-0.0046340171,
0.1067750603,
0.0352019854,
-0.0223815404,
0.0685639754,
-0.0003570396,
-0.0307636783,
-0.011523651,
-0.0624939278,
0.0454186536,
-0.0778471977,
-0.002715437,
-0.1052478403,
-0.0188766364,
-0.0153184226,
-0.047246851,
0.0365829058,
0.0129833361,
0.0227725301,
0.0668369979,
0.0364702493,
-0.0328114145,
-0.0169016887,
-0.0189750828,
0.0818924606,
-0.0666455477,
-0.0122504858,
0.0027463683,
-0.0165643655,
-0.0041277581,
-0.0121319294,
-0.0381201915,
0.0119188624,
0.0035088225,
0.0204158071,
0.0017712195,
0.0061212555,
0.0385961309,
-0.0150736757,
-0.012552591,
-0.0113688875,
-0.0166643709,
-0.009853866,
-0.0031077466,
0.0299070738,
-0.0504506342,
-0.0179276783,
-0.0191509053,
0.0201458987,
-0.0005080431,
-0.0293609146,
-0.0792351142,
-0.0701329932,
-0.0193773042,
-0.0454963893,
0.0282735601,
0.0099625671,
-0.0338316932,
0.0548278987,
0.0006761774,
0.0844834447,
-0.0372423232,
0.0171863269,
0.0068793949,
0.0415765122,
0.0212837178,
0.0613054521,
0.0112229409,
0.0408646055,
-0.0192174707,
-0.0167584829,
-0.0042077326,
-0.0129300226,
-0.0320527665,
-0.0065780594,
0.001074021,
0.0270553771,
-0.0313733704,
0.0123010445,
-0.0023109058,
0.0229443014,
-0.0253724605,
0.0019520496,
0.002974228,
-0.0297524966,
-0.0422476493,
0.0145105608,
0.0369486101,
-0.0045180512,
-0.0171948709,
0.0733100772,
-0.0212701671,
-0.064052023,
-0.0263606478,
-0.0179756396,
0.0045545744,
-0.0035825167,
0.0518664978,
-0.0501992069,
0.0272883102,
-0.022998631,
0.0005355594,
0.0092988741,
0.0303900186,
-0.0116857458,
-0.0293424278,
0.0038321228,
0.0473783612,
-0.004711262,
-0.0377121344,
-0.0297682136,
-0.0057128118,
0.049399849,
0.0307011548,
0.0140501997,
-0.0236804858,
0.0079263998,
0.0137268277,
-0.0026574056,
0.0140830539,
0.0130636375,
-0.0007507399,
-0.0229101814,
0.0117740557,
-0.0069768727,
0.0811739117,
0.000437325,
-0.0104572447,
-0.0110381488,
0.0616142638,
0.0196314175,
0.0015302626,
0.0588044152,
0.0350446254,
0.0025029646,
-0.0196592901,
-0.0021726266,
-0.0974107981,
0.1181855947,
0.0189386178,
0.0123941395,
0.0313927606,
0.0082764439,
-0.0556983128,
0.0089311916,
0.0038942681,
-0.0105813267,
-0.0034219075,
0.0239946153,
0.0262106489,
-0.0345466956,
-0.0302887652,
0.0149506442,
0.0226796772,
-0.0053180871,
-0.0242955517,
-0.0362364948,
0.0370422192,
0.0358814709,
-0.0040279184,
-0.0511780791,
-0.012963268,
-0.0180098284,
0.0181771964,
0.0004794184,
0.0585738085,
0.0560533628,
0.0305184983,
0.0000343956,
-0.0291631874,
-0.0451346412,
-0.0147533137,
0.0571774989,
-0.0398832597,
0.0270662848,
0.0013138331,
0.0345160924,
-0.0411887579,
0.0039642956,
0.0325052254,
-0.0134563269,
-0.0130398674,
0.0318644196,
0.0667696744,
0.0160330292,
-0.0220656097,
0.0304350089,
0.008211703,
-0.0268018991,
0.0583627783,
-0.030853888,
-0.0293930955,
-0.0269797612,
-0.0055347066,
-0.0518154427,
0.0142591661,
0.0581055135,
0.0041521764,
-0.03227688,
0.0653409511,
-0.0359903686,
-0.015887972,
-0.018224474,
0.021503469,
0.040724609,
0.0941128656,
0.0031899347,
0.0474518761,
-0.0185801629,
0.0413451046,
0.0416977443,
-0.0339234471,
-0.0099881329,
-0.0475977026,
-0.0040962785,
-0.0226434302,
-0.0214275271,
-0.0265758745,
-0.0272969585,
-0.0065459935,
-0.0153306993,
-0.0090611698,
-0.0024766193,
-0.0237186737,
-0.0545500219,
0.0068274257,
0.00375384,
0.0225588176,
0.0154200066,
-0.0025978799,
0.0001718739,
0.0205201898,
-0.0508861542,
0.0106641501,
-0.0467309095,
-0.025361713,
-0.0129171209,
-0.0572179407,
-0.0460251905,
0.023925906,
0.0309350975,
0.0090755243,
-0.0613014884,
0.0020648772,
-0.0215782579,
-0.0085583627,
0.0559920557,
0.0051292302,
-0.0379323848,
-0.0168957543,
-0.0636396334,
0.0120159704,
0.1617904156,
-0.0025189633,
-0.0255472846,
0.0688331351,
-0.0283633061,
-0.0009603081,
0.0603104793,
-0.0307999719,
-0.0017257944,
-0.0113601061,
0.0124913417,
0.0175431836,
0.0555114485,
-0.0289491881,
-0.0204352811,
-0.0851395577,
-0.0055528907,
0.0529210307,
-0.0532789081,
0.0075803744,
0.0304163508,
-0.0390757956,
0.0189102069,
-0.0559066124,
-0.0097231204,
0.0437636189,
0.0043625226,
0.0052394993,
0.0017499853,
0.0256857183,
0.0174882989,
0.0266774334,
0.0637280196,
0.0180901978,
-0.0198538993,
-0.0420357212,
-0.0326322652,
0.0184140429,
-0.0090110358,
-0.012378606,
0.0765740722,
-0.0196003336,
0.0198045764,
-0.0036657408,
0.0179414321,
0.0135463038,
-0.0400349125,
-0.0043997611,
0.039897088,
0.0258582663,
-0.0098580569,
-0.0434798859,
0.0022968259,
0.0718637705,
0.0570384935,
-0.0044937292,
0.0116349943,
-0.011053293,
0.0149802873,
0.0361206047,
0.0587407239,
0.0112855295,
-0.0301409885,
0.0041371277,
0.0329741687,
0.0357488245,
-0.0028479672,
-0.0129662044,
0.0027383375,
0.0305531621,
-0.0050133001,
-0.0250049271,
0.0512470677,
0.0752998888,
-0.0585382842,
-0.0334127806,
0.0613413416,
-0.0188096818,
-0.0689320043,
0.0143737029,
-0.0172423795,
0.0287498012,
0.0331438892,
0.0128191421,
0.0217954163,
-0.0523492321,
-0.0132874921,
0.0326728709,
0.0052590985,
-0.0215835627,
0.0119656073,
-0.0244028382,
0.0014946897,
0.0125822006,
-0.0586169064,
-0.0861032084,
0.0323219039,
0.0538793653,
0.005108715,
-0.0359340534,
0.0240030978,
0.0186385512,
-0.0034960241,
0.0275827665,
0.0493781753,
0.0046386612,
0.0490246303,
-0.0148506798,
0.0236398894,
0.1006393582,
-0.0533344336,
-0.0149808824,
-0.0429604128,
-0.0201329514,
0.0187297296,
0.0083927289,
0.00199492,
0.0058124857,
0.0088194152,
-0.0500111952,
-0.0119758388,
0.0279238205,
-0.0140005127,
0.0266883764,
-0.0123587539,
0.0782964826,
-0.0006470471,
-0.0441805944,
-0.0220349468,
-0.0297455862,
-0.0027637628,
0.0187588874,
0.0771599486,
-0.0237342808,
-0.0270342343,
-0.0129012363,
-0.0115342345,
-0.0685949475,
-0.0757598355,
0.0034700357,
0.0237208586,
-0.0803251565,
-0.0306773409,
-0.0434937105,
0.0118257971,
0.0366756395,
-0.0141561544,
-0.049227789,
0.0144274943,
-0.0005497813,
-0.0003061865,
0.0349114873,
-0.0126164136,
0.0005153947,
-0.0179077704,
-0.0243187454,
-0.0165787563,
-0.0221074689,
-0.0093631344,
0.0733494461,
-0.0931104571,
-0.0407791436,
0.0250653438,
0.026636295,
0.0005283753,
0.0252266321,
-0.0102152461,
-0.0637383163,
0.0540815853,
-0.0126635144,
-0.0184192602,
0.0998314321,
0.0409331881,
-0.0530367009,
0.0167147946,
0.0632188469,
-0.0474400222,
-0.0284035746,
0.041050747,
0.0200938825,
-0.0096018808,
-0.0237380899,
-0.0447788388,
-0.0335950404,
0.0342575423,
0.0357410274,
0.040519245,
-0.0075516817,
0.007066967,
0.0713729858,
0.0125908162,
-0.0758354962,
-0.0207134821,
-0.0103425011,
0.0117497584,
0.0156338234,
-0.0091963857,
0.0411172137,
-0.0621540919,
-0.0184933096,
-0.0033242747,
-0.0466643199,
-0.0070208265,
-0.0054448401,
0.0287177321,
-0.0186723694,
0.0079722898,
0.009782793,
0.005760977,
0.0092976019,
0.0207560118,
-0.0070455191,
0.0249476265,
-0.0211589802,
-0.0551953167,
-0.0510273799,
-0.0352343246,
0.012472352,
0.0001373768,
0.0230728276,
-0.0582232699,
0.0333246477,
0.0019908024,
-0.0155294416,
-0.0574088953,
0.0072698961,
-0.0067132129,
0.0046983319,
0.0255575385,
0.0257037003,
0.0395631865,
-0.0629530028,
0.0728746578,
0.007866255,
-0.0257226247,
-0.0082990471,
0.0268390272,
-0.007258581,
-0.0179166626,
0.0117668407,
0.0388507172,
-0.0198218431,
0.0236151498,
0.0200097896,
-0.0441309437,
0.0322420448,
-0.0600538626,
0.0030872438,
-0.0010754227,
0.0317966938,
0.0029815587,
-0.0122579597,
-0.018963851,
0.0028519067,
0.0007533578,
0.0375641622,
-0.0188639089,
0.0013877826,
-6.927426247e-33,
-0.0125590833,
-0.0196420234,
-0.0516574569,
-0.0091799246,
-0.0261579081,
0.0268675685,
-0.0203713998,
0.0375118479,
-0.0266768504,
0.013329953,
0.0041746763,
0.0320314243,
-0.0003990498,
0.0374633968,
0.0111325514,
-0.070403181,
-0.000039067,
-0.0212959368,
0.0076585901,
0.0323967412,
0.0180469975,
0.0124561051,
0.0792797804,
-0.0370694362,
-0.0121148368,
0.0427272208,
0.0055627711,
-0.0113190645,
0.0019231766,
0.0308709145,
0.0094800433,
0.031902656,
0.0120519446,
-0.0547308363,
-0.0452508032,
0.0057633482,
-0.0466188528,
-0.0422921628,
-0.0070857671,
-0.0118910167,
-0.042633649,
-0.0351315625,
0.1099849045,
0.0454961546,
0.0368240923,
-0.0798950121,
0.021377407,
-0.0049911062,
-0.0585982613,
-0.026072152,
-0.0154336626,
-0.0081043011,
-0.0395362228,
0.0078892233,
0.0280962512,
-0.0083027156,
-0.0330111496,
0.0427205414,
-0.0238528866,
0.0057454128,
0.0277213808,
0.0863413215,
0.0316522904,
0.0412794463,
0.0270065088,
-0.0077849375,
0.0181862041,
0.0033192448,
-0.0663366467,
-0.0306570884,
0.0031641938,
0.006949489,
0.0459966622,
0.0019327754,
0.0005425858,
0.0452221483,
-0.0867214501,
-0.0446585976,
-0.0323850214,
0.0759552494,
0.055206757,
-0.0416424312,
-0.01700335,
0.0139704058,
-0.0001346304,
0.0477034263,
-0.0745541081,
0.0205218866,
0.0106811197,
0.0184956398,
-0.0048566386,
0.0013247321,
0.0394928344,
-0.0038693631,
0.0470541678,
0.0233091414,
0.0251780935,
0.0454996154,
0.0107618663,
-0.0354921259,
-0.0772489905,
0.019004235,
-0.0077074529,
-0.0029159533,
-0.0142756645,
-0.0075899889,
-0.0056524533,
0.0461395234,
-0.0436852202,
-0.0462867618,
-0.0381563194,
0.0003090208,
0.0206430033,
0.0370404497,
0.0598882772,
-0.0628138259,
0.0075919302,
0.0759765729,
-0.0193932764,
-0.0263478961,
-0.0062890579,
-0.0181259178,
0.0179930069,
0.0303624813,
-0.0459272303,
-0.0001189429,
-0.0952051952,
-0.0183579866,
0.0251756106,
-0.0227987096,
-0.0313873291,
0.0287067294,
2.868e-7,
-0.0395452082,
-0.044905182,
-0.0556609184,
0.0159472115,
0.0270658191,
0.0508114137,
0.0471675172,
0.0629388392,
0.0126511464,
-0.0539787561,
0.0260910057,
0.0675321966,
0.0100648431,
-0.0648582801,
-0.0949767604,
-0.030683687,
-0.0097789373,
0.0446328297,
-0.003893303,
-0.0488443524,
-0.020413056,
0.0984432399,
0.0117043806,
0.0096418597,
0.0379564278,
-0.0000358385,
0.014808814,
0.0253706332,
-0.0143893203,
-0.050959412,
0.0502599962,
0.0071845939,
-0.0656084567,
-0.0077761305,
-0.0249313712,
0.0036539254,
0.0083285328,
0.0382834189,
-0.0158221498,
-0.0771967396,
-0.0016336883,
-0.000723814,
0.0130960979,
0.0115191108,
0.0449513569,
-0.0331692211,
-0.0190370735,
0.0206083544,
0.0056570615,
0.0175445434,
-0.0556906834,
-0.0143197067,
0.0305075366,
-0.0222358387,
-0.0073992731,
-0.0373369306,
-0.0127255078,
-0.0706459507,
-0.0064442046,
0.0099401046,
-0.0375678688,
-0.004170639,
-0.0876372904,
0.0044980166,
0.0320053473,
0.0281381086,
-0.0435515009,
2.13052795e-34,
0.0425083525,
-0.010550932,
0.0289587285,
-0.0004668031,
-0.0258812625,
-0.0309783723,
-0.0790277943,
-0.0189494211,
0.0475773774,
-0.0561930127,
-0.0476356708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04511v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04511v3 | A Large-Scale Analysis of Persian Tweets Regarding Covid-19 Vaccination | 2023-02-09T09:08:19 | 2024-01-13T04:44:21 | Taha ShabaniMirzaei, Houmaan Chamani, Amirhossein Abaskohi, Zhivar Sourati Hassan Zadeh, Behnam Bahrak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI, I.2.7 | The Covid-19 pandemic had an enormous effect on our lives, especially on
people's interactions. By introducing Covid-19 vaccines, both positive and
negative opinions were raised over the subject of taking vaccines or not. In
this paper, using data gathered from Twitter, including tweets and user
profiles, we offer a comprehensive analysis of public opinion in Iran about the
Coronavirus vaccines. For this purpose, we applied a search query technique
combined with a topic modeling approach to extract vaccine-related tweets. We
utilized transformer-based models to classify the content of the tweets and
extract themes revolving around vaccination. We also conducted an emotion
analysis to evaluate the public happiness and anger around this topic. Our
results demonstrate that Covid-19 vaccination has attracted considerable
attention from different angles, such as governmental issues, safety or
hesitancy, and side effects. Moreover, Coronavirus-relevant phenomena like
public vaccination and the rate of infection deeply impacted public emotional
status and users' interactions. | [
0.0548265688,
0.0582588166,
-0.0200584289,
-0.0403364711,
-0.0159482192,
0.0105703054,
0.0030276782,
-0.0220426228,
0.0109883389,
-0.0284083728,
0.0349035449,
0.0088061197,
-0.0349899717,
0.01961587,
-0.027285343,
-0.0598453097,
0.0017651782,
0.0445879661,
0.0623648129,
0.0255020279,
0.0347776189,
0.0245324038,
0.004012343,
0.0337537974,
0.018850727,
0.0278322343,
-0.0052039092,
-0.0110358531,
0.062924929,
-0.0609873161,
0.0434102938,
0.0025980384,
0.0157892946,
0.0023765569,
0.0000018728,
-0.0134817371,
-0.0556577668,
-0.0180544667,
0.067112565,
-0.0510802045,
0.1305042058,
-0.0565086082,
-0.0100344578,
0.0415287949,
-0.034601137,
-0.0223824196,
0.0446167812,
0.0761553869,
0.0694751963,
0.0710431635,
-0.0318777785,
-0.0393832438,
-0.0149915693,
0.0159473028,
0.0023312632,
0.0042966455,
0.038199544,
-0.0399882458,
-0.0080212848,
0.0179054905,
0.0493518449,
0.0413940027,
-0.0585625395,
-0.0133168343,
-0.0011651648,
0.0297268964,
-0.0283401832,
-0.0527851433,
0.0229393486,
0.0187756736,
0.0392245278,
-0.0301130265,
0.0549665019,
-0.0072060726,
-0.0005548458,
0.0590332039,
-0.0453096032,
-0.0006574548,
-0.0158972368,
0.0369806923,
0.0229680091,
0.0251268446,
0.0058375993,
0.0324295573,
-0.0296277069,
0.0572729185,
-0.0106138699,
-0.0657257587,
-0.0090210605,
-0.0219672658,
0.0165967122,
-0.0193208307,
0.0690925494,
0.0036827824,
0.0123676006,
0.0139403827,
0.0338407941,
-0.0734201893,
0.0182151943,
-0.1192479432,
-0.0893941596,
-0.0009928171,
0.0475855395,
-0.0005724571,
0.0761268809,
-0.043636661,
-0.0086959638,
0.0034986287,
0.0232033096,
0.0091627501,
-0.0695940554,
0.0314921103,
-0.0249455627,
0.0046944465,
0.016732078,
0.0357402079,
-0.0418810286,
-0.0056954408,
-0.023699509,
-0.0402097963,
-0.0472686589,
0.0047791498,
-0.001531226,
0.028718587,
0.0173097476,
0.0700019822,
-0.0273654237,
0.0183693096,
-0.0085086133,
0.0223635677,
0.0228965133,
-0.0134567143,
0.0656293929,
0.0054063457,
-0.0149460593,
0.0089026224,
0.0298481099,
-0.0365711078,
0.010444209,
0.0178702362,
-0.0097917905,
0.0136443302,
-0.0046949172,
-0.0530524291,
0.0256568361,
0.033080779,
-0.0144010698,
0.0182958059,
0.0132804532,
0.0156104816,
-0.0649989843,
0.0116193378,
0.0038235858,
0.0220268872,
0.0721493065,
0.021733487,
0.0548074506,
0.0174530633,
-0.0016296187,
0.0788912252,
0.0374780074,
-0.0006662505,
0.0459850691,
-0.0079275388,
0.0055355811,
0.0034177194,
0.0373602621,
-0.0238122679,
-0.0327969603,
0.0005046891,
-0.0648249313,
0.052973263,
-0.0095387138,
0.008308962,
0.0180150531,
0.0601170547,
-0.0385853127,
-0.0294405874,
-0.0485507995,
0.0738455653,
-0.0018083069,
-0.0159256421,
0.0265543275,
-0.0114706419,
0.012704324,
-0.0129858516,
0.0175435673,
0.0364013314,
-0.0307562221,
-0.0207778681,
-0.023119688,
-0.0173997134,
0.0389939882,
-0.0363627635,
0.0492701679,
-0.0496161692,
-0.0349965282,
0.0293890517,
0.0439188145,
-0.05837081,
0.0082106749,
-0.05708123,
0.0012994028,
0.0487334915,
0.0063769808,
-0.0075172759,
-0.0423147306,
-0.048872266,
-0.0001463612,
0.0012170905,
-0.0118075525,
0.0050543007,
-0.0729295313,
0.0011066786,
0.0034486288,
0.0344483368,
0.0578778163,
-0.0178638902,
-0.0186231192,
0.0369656794,
-0.0098550078,
0.020035075,
0.0330346115,
0.0023864773,
-0.009246652,
0.022642605,
-0.0233451296,
0.0187779032,
0.0269745421,
0.0396223702,
0.0162387583,
0.0139925499,
0.0748355091,
-0.0324424915,
-0.0596979968,
0.0138680814,
0.0460273698,
0.0478335135,
-0.0147090862,
-0.0883890539,
0.0069774278,
0.0286465064,
-0.018796999,
0.0203532632,
0.0725710914,
-0.0040432825,
0.0101229455,
-0.002702011,
0.0251983907,
-0.0563303307,
-0.0115932468,
-0.0010787898,
0.0105005531,
-0.0346393734,
-0.0155447125,
-0.0134336967,
-0.1132057235,
-0.037826363,
-0.0171691831,
0.0113526694,
0.0278178044,
0.0171328466,
0.0062014544,
0.0262378119,
-0.0536918528,
-0.0318945199,
-0.0460878164,
-0.0778728947,
-0.0065582185,
-0.0025589131,
0.0230893772,
0.0286853071,
0.0450168177,
-0.0116222687,
0.0352338515,
-0.007342875,
-0.0339403041,
0.0275436118,
-0.0017324146,
0.0161234457,
0.0017520828,
0.01477757,
-0.0685989186,
-0.0239539426,
-0.0743144602,
0.0139327087,
0.0320415497,
-0.0427501351,
0.0380862951,
-0.0181527045,
-0.0209891535,
-0.0000464849,
-0.0263338257,
-0.0390717387,
0.007546037,
-0.0346286297,
0.0273280013,
0.0063435477,
0.0432812348,
0.0615563951,
0.0339844152,
0.0074740425,
-0.0223349538,
0.0123374155,
-0.0652484521,
-0.0108355107,
0.0150819989,
-0.0635760427,
0.0535961762,
0.0461063124,
-0.0021232951,
0.0238420721,
-0.0368402153,
0.0194737259,
-0.05384757,
0.0128631731,
-0.0269094799,
0.0130455894,
0.0140263317,
0.0182112847,
0.0178652126,
-0.0008140157,
0.0029006223,
0.0521823689,
0.0663357973,
-0.074662976,
-0.0439754501,
-0.0399033502,
-0.0237221625,
-0.0074887984,
-0.0082433522,
0.0262300875,
0.0159929041,
0.0311480258,
-0.0797007605,
-0.0251310281,
-0.0404301025,
-0.0025289096,
0.0259841494,
-0.0070475014,
-0.0077005336,
-0.0000280986,
-0.0061566923,
-0.0801638737,
-0.051074639,
-0.0114193792,
0.0660809949,
-0.0222879015,
-0.0295147002,
0.0136392359,
0.0220031776,
-0.0258615203,
0.0116039366,
-0.0247477088,
0.0441708192,
0.0237317272,
0.0325073265,
-0.0802105516,
-0.0041938131,
-0.0085783917,
-0.0124459956,
0.0412171446,
0.0378911756,
-0.0250287633,
-0.0219827574,
-0.0401685126,
0.0116103701,
-0.0346250013,
-0.0082639782,
-0.0254111458,
-0.0008099853,
-0.0169787165,
0.0536948703,
0.0867642835,
0.0300292969,
0.0034266966,
-0.0034251832,
-0.0268830769,
-0.0434384085,
-0.0200385805,
0.0487660542,
-0.0431862101,
0.039340321,
-0.0033367877,
-0.0032342873,
-0.0293524582,
-0.0182551388,
0.0042687068,
-0.021662876,
0.0120814433,
-0.0004625958,
0.0249858536,
-0.0134857064,
-0.0740966871,
0.0356775932,
-0.0146043934,
-0.0599455386,
-0.0214106813,
-0.0112617258,
0.0068818526,
-0.0019767589,
-0.0456594639,
-0.0157798454,
-0.0020786393,
0.0008363512,
-0.0069239298,
-0.0021209547,
0.0868359581,
-0.0157354791,
-0.0679536164,
-0.0408478156,
0.0288660992,
-0.0289525799,
-0.0124368528,
0.0605852194,
-0.0166195296,
0.0281343013,
-0.0548629798,
-0.0071526286,
-0.0451524183,
-0.0190652069,
-0.0124553638,
0.0583474487,
-0.0251560584,
-0.0699931681,
-0.053002771,
0.0424677022,
0.0184270479,
0.027236199,
0.004716008,
-0.0017148334,
-0.0040177167,
-0.0084755477,
0.0542824976,
-0.0174151566,
-0.0453504026,
-0.0537609234,
-0.0156381819,
-0.1093800366,
-0.0300340969,
-0.0023833304,
-0.0258404408,
-0.0011999938,
-0.0341139175,
-0.0642719641,
0.082377702,
-0.0053083529,
-0.0122153377,
-0.0130719878,
0.0350179821,
0.0035337855,
-0.0169217512,
-0.0411531143,
0.0287224818,
0.0236388557,
-0.0016410273,
-0.00953741,
-0.0319725648,
-0.0460241064,
0.0301156174,
-0.0336310714,
0.0214373861,
-0.0178772751,
0.0181845929,
0.0191619284,
0.0497737005,
0.0816022381,
-0.0184500385,
-0.0467296205,
0.0132205049,
0.0245693363,
0.0161655378,
0.0073671588,
0.0192240309,
0.0127995992,
-0.0354340151,
-0.0353664085,
-0.0742245689,
0.0062710214,
0.0088497102,
-0.0330031514,
0.0758733451,
0.0290093329,
-0.059548866,
-0.055540774,
-0.0458204262,
-0.0248437691,
-0.0043163705,
0.0051351534,
-0.031470757,
-0.027754223,
0.0290070102,
-0.0756918266,
0.0046893838,
-0.0461807139,
0.0094877873,
-0.0422939174,
0.0471212938,
-0.002948635,
0.0133330226,
-0.0013088477,
-0.0199704003,
0.0114511857,
-0.0302543435,
-0.005533963,
-0.0001767257,
-0.0161761791,
-0.0185241215,
-0.029935509,
-0.0193671342,
0.0464337468,
0.0458219685,
-0.0366647877,
-0.039561078,
-0.0254727136,
-0.0071081589,
-0.0036283056,
-0.016932128,
0.0417723916,
0.008191308,
-0.018262852,
-0.0024976169,
0.0374286175,
-0.010961391,
-0.0000996188,
-0.000606223,
-0.0148791233,
-0.0349294953,
-0.0229165014,
0.0045677898,
-0.0315008648,
0.0509069636,
0.0395741351,
-0.0577517152,
0.0025030829,
0.0308677666,
0.0283189639,
-0.0242915004,
-0.0266990624,
0.0272004716,
-0.0570978373,
0.0016954408,
0.0668376237,
-0.0604445189,
-0.0073607392,
-0.0226472858,
0.0198914874,
0.0525918268,
0.0097239381,
0.0494580492,
-0.0651126802,
0.0410345532,
-0.0691055581,
-0.041833207,
-0.0110595832,
-6.351129121e-33,
0.023163233,
-0.0085250009,
-0.0394828655,
0.0131889535,
-0.0224251207,
0.010759362,
-0.0129837366,
0.0210045017,
0.0042105755,
0.0279928595,
-0.0151650254,
0.0486986451,
0.0042612287,
-0.0114930784,
0.0262285806,
-0.015183188,
0.0668764189,
-0.0046458263,
-0.0008618365,
0.0563056991,
0.0542487279,
0.0345643423,
0.0357413329,
-0.1044851691,
0.0362548381,
-0.0237385035,
0.0006529226,
-0.0022214057,
0.0696514472,
0.035329286,
0.0083942888,
0.036657393,
0.0280166585,
-0.0372398794,
0.0294247773,
0.0613919944,
-0.0060905726,
-0.0231176913,
-0.0325550511,
-0.0329899788,
-0.0046056579,
-0.0567967743,
0.0494777188,
0.0310167726,
-0.0341533124,
0.0201972891,
0.0348883159,
0.0218632109,
0.0391740203,
-0.0708320141,
-0.0324670263,
0.0268311948,
-0.0445460193,
0.0217382256,
-0.0045135268,
0.060995508,
-0.0106619056,
0.1186022684,
0.0108746355,
0.0508864932,
0.0208961982,
0.0219983868,
0.0118889781,
-0.0472590402,
0.0199141111,
0.0328503288,
-0.0191632733,
0.0011783225,
-0.0426171869,
0.0156719461,
-0.015529233,
0.0295666624,
-0.0003996477,
0.0374173373,
0.0036853668,
-0.0344307087,
-0.0555314943,
0.0470595174,
-0.0366224386,
0.0696333349,
0.0234018955,
0.0182597023,
-0.0232675616,
0.0079635391,
0.0289851725,
-0.0272868145,
-0.0006905324,
-0.0005602496,
-0.0492186844,
0.0095044831,
-0.0465939045,
-0.0000832309,
-0.0098394835,
-0.0049227942,
0.0037272216,
0.0379263908,
-0.0312741324,
0.0236372352,
-0.0140356086,
0.0121736815,
-0.0381841026,
-0.0020818617,
-0.0025000148,
0.0267798398,
0.0214394536,
0.0025557533,
-0.0442534909,
0.0086399084,
-0.0650072917,
-0.0320400782,
0.0096717766,
0.0184460804,
-0.0389551707,
0.0265113376,
-0.0076732752,
0.0339373425,
0.0167547464,
0.0005216353,
0.0453554504,
0.0381090604,
0.0276055653,
-0.024356544,
-0.0635718107,
0.0050540897,
0.0034492461,
0.0134616308,
-0.0210160017,
0.0456706136,
0.0172710642,
-0.0527212843,
-0.0210341718,
-0.0444473103,
2.795e-7,
0.0677493215,
0.0810706615,
-0.0396990739,
-0.0107229808,
0.0284048077,
0.0606185943,
-0.0158844125,
0.0215662383,
0.0236357823,
-0.0077901864,
0.0197169129,
0.0010312651,
-0.0089216679,
0.0355860963,
-0.0723042414,
-0.0107519291,
-0.0509055853,
0.0147621473,
-0.0218047574,
0.0090166777,
0.0662495345,
0.0512276553,
0.0087597147,
0.0242865514,
-0.0595931299,
0.0390074439,
0.0453550331,
-0.0568216071,
-0.0510725453,
0.0298969392,
0.0201448686,
-0.0098118503,
0.0037434334,
-0.0103557538,
-0.0363122933,
-0.0269237366,
0.0152633768,
0.0403098986,
0.0259965546,
0.002689006,
0.036133118,
-0.0309258923,
-0.0048318072,
-0.0082488665,
0.0127592692,
-0.0903439447,
-0.0598801151,
-0.0712465495,
-0.0489094108,
0.0341483913,
0.0452071093,
-0.0111492444,
-0.048559878,
0.0351823568,
-0.0206321385,
0.0153967664,
0.0023030941,
-0.0396476537,
0.0430682898,
-0.0314753242,
-0.02876742,
-0.0531891398,
-0.0023988911,
0.0136632705,
0.004044048,
0.0295889769,
0.0824454948,
1.657307445e-34,
0.0491276421,
0.0249342062,
-0.0597408004,
-0.0130714728,
0.019359488,
-0.0039032346,
-0.0369276516,
0.0109739657,
0.0040795845,
-0.0368144959,
0.0184512362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04465v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04465v1 | Detecting Contextomized Quotes in News Headlines by Contrastive Learning | 2023-02-09T07:04:11 | 2023-02-09T07:04:11 | Seonyeong Song, Hyeonho Song, Kunwoo Park, Jiyoung Han, Meeyoung Cha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Quotes are critical for establishing credibility in news articles. A direct
quote enclosed in quotation marks has a strong visual appeal and is a sign of a
reliable citation. Unfortunately, this journalistic practice is not strictly
followed, and a quote in the headline is often "contextomized." Such a quote
uses words out of context in a way that alters the speaker's intention so that
there is no semantically matching quote in the body text. We present QuoteCSE,
a contrastive learning framework that represents the embedding of news quotes
based on domain-driven positive and negative samples to identify such an
editorial strategy. The dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/ssu-humane/contextomized-quote-contrastive. | [
0.0567260198,
0.053072203,
0.0121592395,
0.0547034293,
-0.0333953574,
0.0221860185,
-0.0047447607,
-0.0275892951,
-0.0039916234,
-0.0470676757,
-0.0058475058,
0.0179660041,
-0.0174148716,
0.0064192074,
0.0071572266,
-0.0579918399,
0.0248182565,
0.0415546969,
0.0369110852,
-0.0046397401,
0.0368489437,
0.0400918238,
0.0196239986,
0.0422955677,
0.008451079,
-0.0605425462,
0.0104205925,
0.0337873176,
0.0742316842,
-0.0328272842,
0.0222372096,
0.0102025159,
0.0145169683,
0.0278164633,
0.0000015108,
-0.0445677005,
0.0047303727,
0.001463326,
-0.0124274958,
-0.0172640365,
0.1050661653,
-0.0717362463,
-0.0148585709,
0.0019537325,
-0.0357150137,
-0.017716093,
0.0275070276,
0.0644249693,
0.0714126527,
0.0690551102,
-0.0283451378,
-0.0373265892,
0.0056780623,
-0.0031924474,
-0.0415508039,
-0.0130947521,
0.0486058816,
-0.0191092584,
-0.0533162169,
0.0503316596,
0.000144831,
0.0188560244,
0.033180818,
0.0016378057,
-0.0694739893,
0.0019810658,
-0.0347617678,
0.035374213,
-0.0097184675,
0.0412552543,
0.0307054445,
-0.0172103886,
0.0062727216,
-0.0279661957,
-0.0119179962,
0.0384060591,
-0.0258922875,
0.0077926139,
-0.0146314753,
0.021593865,
0.0562600866,
0.0225621555,
-0.0073196124,
0.0393260121,
-0.0060879975,
-0.0105505213,
0.0106471935,
-0.0193903204,
0.0019411455,
0.0050401003,
-0.0267218035,
-0.0019079832,
0.0090077249,
-0.0309695043,
-0.0032891156,
0.0016720803,
-0.0466835573,
-0.0634516478,
0.0224769711,
-0.060336601,
-0.0342648625,
-0.0111618303,
-0.0256542359,
0.0326910242,
-0.0080251992,
-0.0224361047,
-0.0242638346,
0.0029268083,
0.0121237598,
-0.0093779098,
-0.0173132159,
0.0178537462,
0.0120198764,
0.0075676967,
-0.0424770862,
-0.0277966708,
-0.0341112092,
0.0154561931,
-0.0396674164,
0.0285663027,
-0.0249339566,
0.0195320584,
-0.0255608335,
-0.0079188095,
0.0066073425,
0.0132368952,
-0.002560395,
0.0164882466,
-0.0458433405,
-0.0046858988,
-0.0235255845,
0.0465285964,
0.0035743166,
-0.0246527717,
0.0010444606,
0.0469231158,
-0.0047280514,
-0.0294756833,
-0.0286111757,
-0.014064448,
-0.0279788394,
-0.0018256569,
-0.0210491754,
-0.0530425422,
-0.0182120875,
-0.0102123991,
-0.002060581,
-0.0447810665,
-0.0017041645,
0.0350911431,
-0.0436730832,
0.0479719266,
0.0244193915,
-0.0601196997,
-0.0057869498,
0.0140625685,
0.013476857,
0.0886944756,
0.0528347045,
0.0380552188,
0.0509945191,
0.0530221649,
-0.0283856317,
-0.0082441224,
0.0384724028,
0.0284868907,
-0.0221935399,
0.0100318072,
-0.0224769842,
0.0128205633,
0.0565688238,
0.0525291674,
-0.0187732782,
-0.0573262349,
0.0536162443,
0.029306408,
-0.0144250393,
-0.0004452267,
0.0571792237,
0.0461400077,
-0.0240317062,
0.0260659494,
-0.0155251808,
-0.0142151127,
-0.0073952009,
0.0170905888,
-0.0109517807,
0.048789449,
-0.0086912513,
0.0050783837,
0.0190705005,
0.0017794719,
0.0144645749,
-0.0390031636,
0.0239073616,
0.0272232909,
-0.0652440563,
-0.0029198148,
0.0209905263,
-0.0066820257,
-0.0366550162,
-0.0244829692,
0.0287286062,
0.0019025886,
0.0471021608,
0.0048467163,
0.0128971385,
-0.043323379,
0.0072660726,
0.0547802635,
-0.0101568578,
-0.020391712,
0.0183595493,
-0.0058031338,
-0.0128355725,
-0.0347861834,
0.0063239452,
0.000791417,
0.0227462966,
0.0378074944,
0.0128740752,
0.0237231143,
-0.0086902613,
0.0238492489,
-0.0144649576,
-0.0183963962,
0.0130588515,
0.0400781706,
0.0157939885,
0.0455580428,
-0.0068702614,
-0.0365335718,
0.0095225712,
-0.0328587107,
-0.0120674884,
0.0754676536,
-0.0397963971,
-0.060635481,
0.0184820313,
-0.0813227221,
-0.024725683,
0.0643553212,
-0.0582987145,
-0.0130833443,
0.0230575725,
-0.0028530594,
0.0170488954,
-0.0373043865,
-0.0252414774,
-0.0224121585,
0.0182964168,
-0.0197447613,
0.0869911984,
-0.0134362839,
0.0044877827,
0.019474363,
0.0330765508,
0.0021491093,
0.0115950434,
-0.0214430057,
-0.0174008906,
0.0048377025,
0.0071349647,
-0.0012928891,
-0.0294725578,
-0.0673624948,
0.0243972521,
-0.0573356077,
0.0299932212,
-0.0273038689,
0.0303486139,
0.0448785424,
-0.0097140698,
0.0109592769,
0.00829113,
0.0075918646,
-0.0709973052,
-0.0097804414,
0.0236269236,
0.0412541591,
0.0029703535,
0.0333641507,
-0.0289993919,
0.0138744777,
-0.0486058481,
0.0693275407,
-0.0116267493,
0.0252702702,
-0.0523736365,
0.0795882642,
0.0197423585,
-0.0118788974,
-0.0102787428,
-0.017333623,
-0.0064628017,
0.0254570413,
0.0122008855,
0.1049192026,
0.0462534651,
0.0471190177,
-0.0001687797,
0.034528207,
-0.032007996,
0.0014129482,
-0.0271245763,
0.0134573327,
-0.0119793285,
-0.0409208462,
0.026698377,
0.0333447382,
0.0186859816,
0.0107840262,
-0.0130146323,
0.0563521869,
-0.0102454349,
-0.0158360302,
0.036595732,
0.0047657611,
-0.0189134385,
0.0120228194,
-0.0113452952,
0.0223383959,
0.0528107435,
0.015190552,
0.0194888916,
-0.0422463603,
-0.0343890004,
-0.0213350505,
0.0134034725,
-0.0454042591,
0.0178298242,
0.0121540427,
-0.0479662418,
-0.0348631106,
-0.0691566169,
0.0326370224,
0.0026387761,
0.0515308119,
-0.0171847548,
-0.0112098623,
-0.008734311,
-0.051991459,
-0.0511009358,
-0.083739832,
-0.0275736935,
0.0133553194,
0.0438731909,
-0.0214583129,
-0.0130321151,
-0.0063996622,
0.029766364,
0.0379145108,
-0.028422324,
-0.023295464,
0.0055710976,
0.0704453886,
0.062932454,
0.0156196449,
0.0339881144,
0.0243752804,
0.0250537097,
0.0599729232,
-0.0089515625,
0.0089621497,
-0.0380751304,
-0.0339015834,
-0.0095542679,
-0.0192445181,
0.0155883981,
-0.023604298,
0.0236104559,
-0.0321941413,
-0.0250665229,
0.0730324835,
0.0238096341,
-0.0541670173,
-0.036403507,
-0.0120379515,
-0.0004879903,
0.0216187928,
-0.0227849372,
-0.1092397347,
-0.0287128612,
-0.0107831983,
0.0163132474,
-0.0149114598,
-0.0188315492,
-0.0193714332,
-0.0942447484,
0.0095521957,
-0.0075474009,
-0.0151825156,
-0.0270499624,
-0.0491979606,
0.0066608987,
-0.0456568003,
-0.0127210533,
-0.0004324558,
-0.0420959145,
0.0034398062,
-0.0191932954,
0.0166620053,
-0.0501303114,
-0.00826417,
-0.0063868277,
0.0019718055,
0.0194265731,
0.0454510711,
0.0018155555,
0.0173294973,
-0.048600167,
-0.1054528356,
-0.0289869513,
-0.020942986,
0.0781797841,
-0.0596040748,
-0.0092794625,
-0.040029455,
0.0329340249,
0.0295273401,
-0.031651862,
0.0044133975,
0.0149698872,
0.0074597606,
0.0214491859,
-0.0515171587,
0.066091001,
0.0534193888,
0.061130546,
0.0268458892,
-0.0199010056,
-0.0216472223,
-0.0108005274,
0.0306553766,
-0.0617827773,
-0.0388865992,
-0.006515367,
-0.0387174152,
0.0276158322,
-0.0692839473,
-0.0258389246,
-0.0379132628,
0.0441951528,
0.0033979288,
-0.0224627722,
-0.00178898,
-0.0179956742,
-0.0920647234,
-0.0223009735,
-0.0233442765,
0.0092942445,
0.0013074334,
0.0175788198,
0.0730291158,
-0.0057759667,
-0.0202833042,
0.0392592959,
-0.0325985253,
-0.0478275642,
0.0013669312,
-0.0099070985,
0.0135622583,
0.0587729327,
-0.0001492354,
0.0134070711,
0.0607317351,
0.0959533602,
0.012132898,
0.0089191701,
0.069814235,
0.0417830832,
0.0231520925,
0.0168486591,
-0.0056967819,
0.028304683,
-0.0023836789,
-0.0177706815,
-0.0749688819,
0.0368209779,
-0.0155437514,
-0.04235797,
0.0498767979,
0.0064098132,
0.0097184302,
-0.0352046005,
0.0150912739,
-0.0368437245,
-0.0218613036,
-0.0240708683,
0.0246624537,
-0.0221534502,
0.0135676591,
-0.0385038666,
0.024874337,
-0.0346653834,
0.0393850952,
-0.0376287363,
0.0142102325,
0.0666723326,
0.0290120021,
-0.0292438529,
0.0100860139,
-0.035304103,
-0.0070343572,
-0.0031840752,
0.0348670892,
0.0145849604,
0.0541309416,
0.0317434072,
-0.0101984711,
0.0025028717,
0.0025306714,
-0.1101332158,
0.0296734124,
-0.0364170596,
-0.0343785919,
0.0124467909,
-0.0637332648,
0.0398577005,
-0.0058065807,
-0.0224591251,
0.030512888,
0.0301753115,
-0.0458497107,
-0.0191864874,
0.0285332054,
0.0170455314,
-0.0209602844,
0.0462979488,
0.0146752074,
-0.0181300435,
0.0464953668,
0.0237461124,
-0.0375405885,
-0.0421739854,
-0.0316773206,
0.0395147093,
0.0258950572,
0.0330189019,
-0.0343722776,
-0.0493028015,
-0.0499127321,
0.0789328888,
0.0119456155,
0.0175046027,
0.019745769,
-0.0196101591,
0.0334618017,
0.0396276712,
-0.0190895293,
-0.0342052616,
0.0548548438,
-0.0274954736,
-0.0489692166,
-0.0243503675,
-5.320590122e-33,
-0.0163470469,
-0.0315938294,
-0.0362782329,
0.007949397,
0.0000907161,
0.0285282284,
-0.0251216479,
-0.0533723086,
-0.0402924679,
0.0570362583,
0.0065637822,
0.0372046642,
0.0007759889,
0.0382672623,
0.0082039712,
-0.0114629827,
0.0667523593,
0.0050670928,
-0.0060008424,
0.0076752659,
0.0627591982,
0.0085669765,
0.0467510372,
-0.1113001555,
0.0257824883,
-0.0261421669,
-0.0534893423,
0.0041070334,
0.076534465,
0.056997925,
0.006661254,
0.0241039786,
0.012495988,
-0.051795397,
0.0034696884,
0.0484933294,
-0.0838392228,
-0.0224982724,
0.059858609,
-0.0305646695,
-0.0451074578,
-0.0229525287,
0.0331786871,
-0.0256412793,
0.0011265398,
-0.0017594536,
0.052836474,
-0.0277611185,
0.0094732754,
-0.0480463132,
-0.0678611472,
0.0217174031,
-0.0161767267,
0.0441474207,
0.0071180211,
0.0213320926,
0.0400895253,
0.0850143507,
-0.0825826749,
-0.0065118158,
-0.0551721081,
-0.0176140126,
-0.0015241507,
-0.0066407067,
0.0019713994,
0.0705957189,
-0.0027403089,
-0.0241602119,
0.0548269376,
0.0010397475,
0.0079464279,
0.0036602139,
0.0077595199,
0.1557979435,
0.004164834,
-0.0253005829,
-0.0601057224,
0.0026311392,
0.0264359936,
-0.0059693516,
0.0160496607,
-0.0088771181,
-0.0258786846,
0.0065225009,
0.0245846305,
-0.0570665263,
-0.0309981182,
-0.0320709981,
-0.0033020929,
-0.0215983987,
-0.0491961315,
0.0690391734,
0.016695315,
-0.0722691491,
0.0139110805,
0.0705439448,
-0.055484619,
0.0007701571,
0.0173543524,
0.0126344291,
-0.0457913466,
-0.0126429228,
0.0101499539,
0.0359403044,
0.0153892506,
-0.0268528629,
0.0829357207,
-0.0107205156,
-0.083552964,
0.0008534248,
0.0237841774,
0.0281725582,
-0.0545965806,
-0.0180757847,
0.0195932761,
0.0219454952,
-0.0078431442,
0.0236371793,
0.0410513431,
-0.0006175404,
-0.0214158073,
-0.0394589864,
-0.0263361204,
0.0316010006,
-0.0209976081,
-0.0270463564,
0.0270354599,
0.0444262885,
-0.0039575738,
-0.0704044998,
-0.0041260482,
-0.0375165753,
2.264e-7,
0.0174269956,
0.0322837196,
-0.0046121893,
0.0054873163,
0.0157699697,
0.0598780848,
0.0370700583,
0.0359153636,
0.0078611663,
-0.0194286183,
0.0000025772,
0.0040065432,
-0.0003929065,
0.0018403643,
-0.094818145,
0.0438837484,
-0.0460750684,
-0.0437886976,
-0.0132829947,
0.0111299735,
0.0883728117,
0.0518379919,
0.0313244276,
-0.0129592,
-0.0153361876,
-0.033173386,
0.024796484,
-0.0151303494,
-0.0573101416,
-0.0309749041,
-0.0199852157,
0.0199402161,
-0.0031256122,
-0.0166277848,
-0.0082500018,
0.0345308445,
-0.0211448204,
0.0475297682,
0.0414016098,
-0.02399325,
-0.0386769101,
-0.0281533804,
0.0183883514,
-0.0148267495,
0.0431124568,
-0.0771588758,
-0.0334291682,
-0.1350309551,
-0.0782862008,
-0.0078264242,
0.0504630208,
-0.0172370411,
-0.031862177,
0.0173257887,
-0.0289844759,
0.0290771388,
0.0012981703,
-0.0848366171,
0.0026533548,
0.045486223,
-0.0041316603,
-0.0102249496,
0.0340535939,
-0.0018766075,
0.0361406878,
-0.0491712242,
0.0359454602,
1.769130592e-34,
0.063326329,
0.0089682546,
0.0056517208,
0.0218871739,
0.0015069292,
0.0118059516,
-0.0283460747,
-0.0202056468,
0.0413638316,
-0.0055514462,
0.0157254022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04460v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04460v2 | Bag of Tricks for Training Data Extraction from Language Models | 2023-02-09T06:46:42 | 2023-06-01T10:14:55 | Weichen Yu, Tianyu Pang, Qian Liu, Chao Du, Bingyi Kang, Yan Huang, Min Lin, Shuicheng Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | With the advance of language models, privacy protection is receiving more
attention. Training data extraction is therefore of great importance, as it can
serve as a potential tool to assess privacy leakage. However, due to the
difficulty of this task, most of the existing methods are proof-of-concept and
still not effective enough. In this paper, we investigate and benchmark tricks
for improving training data extraction using a publicly available dataset.
Because most existing extraction methods use a pipeline of
generating-then-ranking, i.e., generating text candidates as potential training
data and then ranking them based on specific criteria, our research focuses on
the tricks for both text generation (e.g., sampling strategy) and text ranking
(e.g., token-level criteria). The experimental results show that several
previously overlooked tricks can be crucial to the success of training data
extraction. Based on the GPT-Neo 1.3B evaluation results, our proposed tricks
outperform the baseline by a large margin in most cases, providing a much
stronger baseline for future research. The code is available at
https://github.com/weichen-yu/LM-Extraction. | [
0.0630428493,
0.1004199386,
-0.0284205358,
0.0789858177,
-0.0534699671,
-0.0004930248,
0.032567773,
0.0261521693,
0.0292364843,
-0.0484056883,
-0.0358971395,
-0.041554302,
-0.0103806145,
0.0313682631,
0.0250818152,
-0.0092458464,
0.012682952,
-0.0354406796,
0.0100602191,
-0.0225198902,
-0.0107854232,
0.0143199693,
0.019750433,
0.0194145292,
0.0177032538,
0.0063206754,
0.0040864642,
-0.0292408522,
0.0256757773,
-0.0312459022,
0.0091810059,
0.0543667227,
-0.0175828841,
0.0679139271,
0.0000018049,
-0.0374085307,
-0.0629915893,
0.0247464869,
0.0015352216,
-0.0014754338,
0.0488160625,
-0.0067736153,
-0.0164655466,
0.0318064205,
-0.0463962965,
0.0031287258,
0.0279609486,
0.0369242057,
0.045228228,
0.0815105662,
-0.0224927124,
-0.0087446598,
-0.0084289638,
-0.0375390537,
-0.0101238489,
-0.0375774875,
0.0476180352,
-0.0633662567,
-0.0347343422,
0.034890227,
0.0420653634,
0.0096592279,
-0.0084781116,
0.0086803427,
-0.034783341,
0.0479705557,
-0.0497363769,
-0.0196174458,
-0.0222626086,
0.0632857159,
-0.0073028523,
-0.003859584,
0.0560716093,
0.020137785,
0.0199734531,
0.0123370187,
-0.0240615718,
0.0567286313,
-0.0231726188,
0.042028442,
0.0260633081,
0.0004054415,
0.0252895486,
-0.0065898001,
0.0024200545,
0.0822792128,
0.0168294627,
-0.0277978275,
0.0003759076,
-0.0267775953,
0.0233646538,
-0.0462395661,
0.0604848489,
-0.0214237925,
0.0593782477,
0.0360598937,
-0.0529170148,
-0.0389457382,
0.0274675339,
-0.0506678075,
0.0016068454,
-0.0103462972,
0.0079739904,
0.0254410412,
-0.0320410654,
0.0363781862,
0.0092129298,
0.0401219651,
0.0006435402,
-0.0028129746,
-0.0291689038,
-0.0269250832,
0.0004058963,
0.062790744,
-0.0485401452,
0.0132167311,
-0.0396924652,
0.0075566131,
0.0034131981,
0.0202945601,
-0.0135549158,
-0.0121850623,
-0.0095975175,
0.0073818308,
0.0062513538,
-0.0820103288,
0.0060963877,
-0.0077650091,
-0.0120657096,
-0.0698571876,
-0.0047249794,
-0.0153588746,
0.016214598,
-0.0288975798,
-0.0091718286,
0.0760165229,
0.0189010873,
-0.0258902386,
-0.019356668,
-0.0535511449,
0.0233361181,
-0.0313619673,
-0.0048997235,
-0.0523051471,
0.0139697669,
-0.0185813755,
-0.0022156383,
-0.0494555309,
0.0166361276,
0.0417218134,
-0.0693543851,
0.0423903726,
-0.0395547561,
-0.0050633298,
0.0008813114,
0.0275049675,
0.0039282334,
0.0502625927,
0.0228320025,
0.0708955973,
0.0809391662,
-0.0134500265,
0.0291973967,
0.0555370227,
0.0420978628,
0.0047698896,
0.0058509326,
0.0074406653,
0.0064708181,
-0.0715933666,
-0.0072391955,
0.0652358904,
-0.0049961139,
-0.0249098167,
0.065577291,
0.0769157186,
0.0119682327,
0.0220243912,
-0.041385401,
0.0298144631,
0.0112904469,
0.0056570419,
-0.0533316657,
-0.0381138995,
-0.0668198466,
-0.0207645092,
-0.0094706332,
0.0410203375,
0.0132539794,
-0.0047526732,
0.0029176096,
-0.0372668281,
0.035588719,
0.0315094441,
0.018669216,
0.0262100212,
0.0047032055,
0.0584599003,
0.0257561505,
-0.0580666661,
-0.0041301185,
-0.0456585996,
-0.0112823192,
0.0483526997,
0.034508124,
-0.0262124445,
0.0056328559,
-0.0180912018,
-0.0373867303,
0.0189201459,
0.0001824378,
-0.0149572492,
0.0749811083,
-0.034571521,
-0.046183344,
0.0195179116,
0.0094594155,
0.03225483,
0.0338664912,
0.0059078489,
0.0548439212,
-0.0471561588,
-0.0293685403,
0.0544537455,
-0.026256416,
-0.0393336192,
0.0556159019,
-0.0001134987,
0.0242235791,
0.0393605307,
-0.0080866469,
-0.0074849729,
0.0376164839,
0.0014600471,
0.0313310586,
0.0072855903,
-0.0031066164,
-0.0327567868,
0.0010083088,
-0.0236790925,
0.0085879825,
0.0831489339,
-0.058940798,
-0.0168576129,
-0.0161962677,
0.0271616969,
0.0428992659,
-0.0566718504,
0.0132179307,
-0.0009688159,
0.0244703107,
-0.0305139292,
0.0465889685,
-0.0164792519,
0.0052098171,
-0.0320320427,
-0.0038208363,
0.0142455809,
-0.0411437228,
-0.0205119532,
0.0316799171,
-0.0401098318,
0.0264154579,
0.0466641635,
0.0343344137,
-0.0348562635,
-0.0285303518,
-0.0415516794,
0.0063895606,
-0.020410005,
0.0529835001,
0.0185381174,
0.0071682166,
-0.02486353,
-0.0309989695,
-0.0705565363,
-0.0567836203,
-0.0535173565,
0.0090862233,
0.0263385903,
0.010555502,
-0.0198729411,
-0.0176462922,
-0.0092945751,
-0.009171484,
0.039939139,
-0.0177978519,
-0.0257257335,
-0.0194576979,
0.0400330275,
-0.0113892471,
0.031835191,
-0.0136432154,
-0.0112282857,
-0.0168198068,
0.0078130877,
-0.0169275794,
-0.0038083231,
0.0417028479,
0.0204758979,
0.029693203,
0.0313608013,
-0.0363987722,
-0.030820271,
-0.0287728254,
0.0390694737,
-0.0263641458,
-0.0299153179,
0.0621261932,
0.0008906553,
0.0174134392,
-0.0327331088,
-0.0224472899,
0.0218670033,
-0.011670352,
-0.0382858776,
-0.0447402336,
0.0274519082,
-0.0222589094,
0.0187480878,
-0.0079885218,
-0.0491563715,
0.0519056581,
-0.0511830747,
0.0169359278,
-0.046261441,
-0.0371971764,
-0.0123383515,
0.0600449443,
0.0121079357,
0.0574349128,
0.0378945582,
-0.059112139,
0.0178545825,
-0.0000305602,
0.0299980771,
-0.0562708229,
0.0085692126,
0.0118732797,
-0.0032576199,
0.0055601066,
-0.0526367724,
-0.0725520179,
-0.0814600587,
0.024447564,
0.0051424508,
0.01876284,
-0.03263551,
0.00939433,
-0.0068123178,
-0.011536424,
0.0429399647,
-0.0285663903,
0.0128885098,
-0.0028594309,
0.0387531705,
0.034793783,
-0.0669376031,
0.0021328088,
-0.0250014961,
-0.009710541,
0.0873740539,
0.0801066756,
0.029652806,
0.025598187,
-0.0186645109,
0.0316491239,
-0.0479979068,
0.0023091224,
0.0262310002,
0.0199079886,
-0.0233477689,
-0.0045767315,
0.0897730738,
0.0313942432,
-0.0436831526,
-0.0012037237,
0.0452335328,
0.0335814506,
0.003192554,
0.0126948077,
-0.0793224946,
0.011047069,
0.0209654588,
0.074191153,
-0.048901964,
-0.0453223772,
-0.0305528007,
-0.1204068512,
0.0196897313,
0.0097324243,
-0.0544218011,
-0.010183692,
-0.0529165976,
0.0018592632,
0.0114040282,
0.0028594292,
-0.0054130452,
-0.0049594031,
-0.0104891881,
0.0091990102,
-0.0328642018,
-0.0676486865,
-0.017547654,
-0.0295315236,
0.0299019646,
0.0453461669,
0.0290207379,
-0.0374443159,
-0.0065479563,
0.0242126733,
0.0160898753,
-0.0459290184,
-0.0091826776,
0.0616400875,
-0.0242581815,
-0.0076075685,
0.0032422959,
0.0562533997,
-0.0134448614,
-0.0105194105,
0.0425307602,
0.0115451962,
-0.00651481,
-0.0183727536,
0.0155639565,
-0.0288908407,
0.0279508922,
0.0783372819,
0.0057940669,
-0.0334761515,
0.0103561264,
-0.0631858259,
0.0338892341,
-0.0318449698,
0.0131226331,
0.0065368474,
-0.0019268894,
-0.0321786776,
-0.0689806566,
-0.0147456853,
-0.0098145157,
0.0227873437,
0.0322698243,
0.0277887788,
0.0266246106,
-0.0086524757,
-0.0372473523,
0.0036436808,
-0.0393630303,
-0.0116471024,
-0.0399536565,
-0.0264385697,
0.019349372,
0.0071330303,
-0.0404812656,
0.0217952933,
-0.0494926311,
-0.0859200358,
0.012165172,
0.0142279444,
0.0162397251,
0.0396621525,
-0.0308434591,
-0.0506359339,
0.0759054497,
0.0723530874,
-0.0386683084,
-0.0415124856,
0.0538114123,
-0.050640557,
0.0123010734,
0.0288225934,
-0.0557732023,
0.0072373715,
0.0292462446,
-0.0120616397,
-0.0351315513,
-0.0053553237,
0.002894551,
0.0635790303,
0.0533311591,
-0.0123019656,
0.0344873667,
-0.0712604076,
0.0213907156,
-0.0463452861,
-0.0257582869,
-0.0304745268,
0.0238367748,
0.0280326419,
-0.0048740134,
0.0135455532,
-0.0258798357,
0.0048773955,
0.0462822877,
-0.0440937281,
0.0079746125,
0.0049121701,
0.0476435833,
0.03087206,
-0.0285460204,
-0.0172096584,
0.0337094069,
0.0374277756,
0.0502017364,
-0.051971443,
0.0124035617,
0.0044584642,
-0.0217512976,
0.0020095299,
0.068687208,
-0.050438948,
-0.0057871751,
-0.0577767715,
0.0342724584,
0.0118788946,
0.0052151838,
0.0400877967,
-0.0444511585,
0.0016936832,
-0.009872823,
0.007846076,
-0.0019026175,
-0.0362475403,
-0.0124791162,
-0.0069031548,
-0.0489390753,
0.0485994034,
0.0823915154,
0.0362429135,
-0.0038801071,
0.0038409857,
-0.035738565,
-0.051909171,
-0.000708248,
0.0172453411,
0.0395237245,
-0.027038129,
-0.0246468559,
-0.0323643759,
-0.0637974367,
-0.011663368,
-0.0187843218,
0.0180375651,
0.0068734414,
0.0129532525,
0.0572389327,
-0.0040709176,
-0.0156647768,
-0.1066412926,
-0.0309908316,
0.0371233262,
-0.0351097807,
0.0084126582,
-5.713894001e-33,
-0.0040759817,
-0.0272142608,
-0.0400079712,
0.0334749669,
0.0361455269,
0.0030278782,
-0.0102881296,
-0.0239649322,
-0.0090979077,
-0.0222760215,
-0.0322509333,
-0.0104845082,
0.027092455,
0.0481960326,
-0.0509718247,
0.008563295,
0.023413308,
-0.0084315855,
-0.0323031433,
0.0393441096,
0.0571611635,
0.0642620847,
0.0607342385,
-0.082898654,
0.0464729294,
-0.0159354806,
-0.0231815521,
0.003205894,
0.0037818204,
0.0666123927,
-0.0179430265,
0.0167242382,
0.0115640312,
-0.0486691482,
0.0185877997,
0.0255699344,
-0.0595177263,
-0.0246995464,
-0.0107696727,
-0.0224658232,
0.0238803457,
-0.0416307226,
0.0430535562,
-0.0398186445,
0.0004577886,
0.0160700474,
0.0092546744,
-0.0025562171,
-0.0349929817,
-0.0367917158,
-0.0028896045,
0.0374322794,
0.0055410028,
0.0355120637,
0.0800134316,
0.0380521491,
0.0027224647,
-0.0047676144,
-0.042900499,
0.032853961,
0.0415694341,
0.0283927005,
0.0335032418,
0.0431331471,
0.0220962297,
0.0660352781,
0.0383544527,
0.0131193409,
0.0174844079,
-0.0002718883,
0.0129368398,
0.0406071991,
-0.0180396475,
0.0223537888,
0.0161083788,
-0.0638305768,
-0.0712966323,
0.0352545194,
0.007259259,
-0.047523845,
0.0371631682,
-0.0325394049,
-0.0786320791,
-0.0256139729,
-0.0319336839,
-0.0460199416,
-0.020663498,
-0.0040772664,
0.0245992448,
0.0112057664,
-0.0842965692,
0.0004208135,
-0.0068712002,
-0.0483362004,
-0.0618877299,
0.041578725,
-0.0049424111,
-0.0231469199,
-0.014564747,
0.0319560021,
-0.0440200232,
-0.047250919,
-0.000672751,
-0.022548819,
0.0222982839,
0.0051459083,
0.0384940766,
0.0090344455,
-0.0727657899,
0.0022174083,
-0.0177520346,
0.0566379279,
0.0156574324,
0.0309575927,
-0.0009675534,
-0.0346078984,
0.0150255151,
0.0048835245,
0.0689524785,
0.0396410301,
-0.0555260219,
0.0336633474,
0.0017753069,
0.0038579688,
0.0044683362,
-0.024468882,
-0.0110948514,
0.0136444597,
0.1048788428,
0.0081521804,
0.0005495811,
-0.0012818633,
2.491e-7,
0.009309832,
0.0083419643,
-0.0120145744,
-0.0093178125,
0.0052869078,
0.0621287376,
-0.0044416054,
0.0615671463,
0.0275409762,
0.0256815422,
-0.0401161201,
-0.0167288985,
0.0368506648,
0.061735075,
-0.0846514851,
-0.0014667501,
-0.0318366289,
-0.0332656503,
-0.0525041148,
0.0135429045,
0.0088502765,
0.0925851613,
0.0375694968,
-0.0271737333,
-0.0446522571,
-0.0733473971,
0.0156141091,
-0.031908717,
-0.0308107063,
0.0159927625,
0.0483331457,
0.0684418753,
0.005287298,
-0.0236441176,
-0.0367296822,
0.0481975116,
-0.0303320792,
0.0775180832,
0.0212635268,
-0.0279606283,
0.0103166001,
-0.044950854,
-0.0051999176,
-0.0546313003,
0.059678182,
0.0012529974,
-0.0408274941,
-0.0480417386,
0.0164101869,
-0.0562224202,
-0.0069320449,
-0.0462455116,
-0.0288380664,
0.0354733281,
0.0073962472,
-0.0106362971,
-0.0083432822,
-0.0638061613,
-0.0194394402,
-0.0446354374,
-0.0172793064,
-0.0368675813,
0.0135441571,
0.0274004824,
-0.0225366931,
-0.022834992,
0.0731807947,
2.457592723e-34,
-0.0312910713,
-0.0106072929,
-0.0298993252,
0.0299150813,
0.0300609022,
-0.0019899735,
0.0592,
0.0229174141,
-0.0474684685,
-0.0479374416,
-0.0152293183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04459v1 | Global Constraints with Prompting for Zero-Shot Event Argument Classification | 2023-02-09T06:39:29 | 2023-02-09T06:39:29 | Zizheng Lin, Hongming Zhang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | Determining the role of event arguments is a crucial subtask of event
extraction. Most previous supervised models leverage costly annotations, which
is not practical for open-domain applications. In this work, we propose to use
global constraints with prompting to effectively tackles event argument
classification without any annotation and task-specific training. Specifically,
given an event and its associated passage, the model first creates several new
passages by prefix prompts and cloze prompts, where prefix prompts indicate
event type and trigger span, and cloze prompts connect each candidate role with
the target argument span. Then, a pre-trained language model scores the new
passages, making the initial prediction. Our novel prompt templates can easily
adapt to all events and argument types without manual effort. Next, the model
regularizes the prediction by global constraints exploiting cross-task,
cross-argument, and cross-event relations. Extensive experiments demonstrate
our model's effectiveness: it outperforms the best zero-shot baselines by 12.5%
and 10.9% F1 on ACE and ERE with given argument spans and by 4.3% and 3.3% F1,
respectively, without given argument spans. We have made our code publicly
available. | [
0.0442393273,
-0.0134789813,
0.0189856775,
0.0421685688,
-0.0015141496,
0.0204517208,
0.0156290382,
-0.0044865687,
0.0327118374,
-0.0870664641,
-0.0162819885,
-0.0093282424,
-0.054279644,
0.0287099816,
-0.0048200507,
-0.0584147908,
0.0580069982,
-0.0020007265,
0.0344860069,
0.0386003964,
0.0152955698,
0.018757103,
-0.0454269834,
0.0519714132,
-0.0157047175,
-0.0101637272,
-0.0205217693,
-0.0075994786,
0.0215898529,
-0.0147026395,
0.0105305761,
0.0334891602,
0.0227026287,
0.0148483412,
0.0000018233,
-0.0840064064,
-0.0282700099,
-0.0483047366,
-0.067451708,
0.0012805854,
-0.0238664933,
0.0087405303,
0.0074482677,
-0.0174949579,
-0.0121668214,
-0.0674197301,
0.0315068699,
0.0594015978,
0.0327866115,
0.0989346877,
-0.0191737078,
0.0166400578,
-0.02682909,
-0.0165621564,
0.0034027323,
-0.0104093663,
0.0132268295,
-0.0266837832,
0.0308825169,
0.0131446887,
0.0234965179,
-0.0052389521,
0.0072847451,
0.0081262421,
-0.009527416,
0.0381587483,
-0.0597193837,
0.012573557,
-0.0178038348,
0.0501193181,
-0.0123137115,
-0.0445629321,
0.0339870229,
-0.0282622855,
0.0104271546,
0.0034455629,
-0.0383829586,
0.0198494531,
-0.0214728266,
0.0066947225,
0.0636239797,
0.0573918372,
0.002447098,
-0.0150944591,
0.0292143952,
0.0465532839,
0.0092446441,
0.0084502269,
-0.0004075707,
-0.0034415333,
-0.0297803488,
-0.0640957952,
0.0075859535,
0.0366238393,
-0.0209001321,
0.0047372067,
-0.0491795577,
0.023785511,
0.0015266726,
-0.0346343331,
0.0112991137,
0.0240406673,
-0.0108380411,
0.0545040295,
-0.0069517284,
0.0309769996,
0.0316462629,
-0.0034624536,
-0.0218755286,
0.0041591949,
-0.0527062267,
0.0167018808,
-0.0424551591,
0.0197515246,
-0.0327275731,
-0.0048144218,
0.004725032,
0.010559652,
0.023603553,
0.0120751131,
0.0117217256,
-0.0111222481,
-0.0438129455,
-0.0051414534,
0.0108416118,
-0.0058033918,
-0.0366474725,
-0.0006110281,
-0.0120255593,
-0.0355487503,
-0.0453100055,
0.0278179683,
0.0151782623,
-0.0317890011,
-0.0165880714,
0.0333188549,
-0.0281429552,
-0.0283707678,
-0.0542314537,
-0.0475628451,
-0.0358430967,
-0.0137251122,
-0.0332444124,
-0.0403181911,
0.0090227025,
-0.020975491,
0.0020187183,
-0.0108716786,
0.0232083239,
-0.0258320402,
-0.0280035678,
0.0309830848,
0.0169369727,
-0.031050995,
0.0061384272,
0.0109424042,
-0.0196098592,
0.0815544575,
0.0201045442,
0.0238801576,
0.0665523112,
0.0328909047,
0.0048964014,
0.0313937776,
-0.0003873104,
-0.0074570482,
0.0649176463,
-0.0113073131,
0.0584318452,
-0.0245578904,
0.04662285,
-0.0242573489,
-0.0306777079,
-0.0340057909,
0.0233978927,
0.03803882,
-0.0257021915,
-0.0263061542,
0.0847471878,
-0.0154460492,
-0.0215875059,
0.0378930345,
-0.0213208664,
-0.0486458912,
-0.0016576553,
-0.0077680699,
0.0086863637,
-0.0407613814,
-0.0433415584,
-0.0070071481,
0.006941542,
-0.0362757258,
-0.0497680455,
-0.0163421147,
0.0297048576,
-0.0096580079,
-0.0477555394,
0.0458241366,
0.0239093471,
-0.0647387356,
0.0096544018,
0.0139141446,
0.028730955,
-0.0045104702,
0.0221443493,
-0.0645854473,
-0.0525736101,
-0.0194380917,
0.054208409,
0.0176454745,
0.0562760383,
-0.0541832857,
0.0801273957,
-0.0387486666,
0.0019948115,
-0.0216195006,
0.0222830418,
0.0124652609,
-0.0174843483,
-0.0152281048,
0.0158634726,
0.0274575092,
-0.0296277497,
0.0234390367,
-0.0105117038,
-0.0933287069,
0.0104105994,
0.0220516808,
0.0160717517,
0.0204089452,
0.0088727614,
-0.0140224062,
0.0250370447,
-0.0576014742,
0.0034360299,
0.0423884913,
-0.0563755929,
-0.032383211,
0.0233812016,
0.0183964893,
0.0069598784,
-0.020434605,
-0.0323518626,
-0.0639794469,
-0.030985482,
0.0307834856,
0.021881355,
0.0036747176,
0.0055836579,
0.0147877345,
-0.0344033539,
-0.0429407358,
0.0453503765,
0.0642676875,
0.0149809597,
-0.0083306031,
0.0135599272,
0.0556901209,
-0.0469213687,
-0.0353442095,
0.0037327611,
-0.0029850577,
-0.0374091007,
0.0474125594,
-0.0228387918,
-0.0388901047,
0.0236114319,
-0.1069657803,
0.0514165387,
-0.0200754404,
0.0429775305,
0.0315787606,
0.0143743968,
-0.0281276871,
-0.0164697114,
-0.0132066486,
-0.0817527249,
-0.012006307,
-0.0048544756,
0.0325397924,
0.0389905088,
0.013049785,
-0.0471818261,
0.0223733149,
-0.0636735559,
0.0609633103,
0.0097314836,
-0.0322426073,
-0.0374703854,
0.0423296541,
0.0312577859,
0.0555382036,
-0.0015824545,
-0.0070459615,
-0.0000337098,
0.0025627643,
0.0231205802,
0.0429183058,
-0.0427449383,
0.0205084197,
0.0078871567,
-0.0403006673,
-0.0562498644,
0.0258930828,
-0.0208285619,
-0.0060812943,
-0.0072301687,
0.0436776504,
0.032579843,
0.096740447,
0.017566273,
0.0107109165,
-0.0689333081,
-0.0274013691,
-0.010966761,
0.0054518832,
-0.0101602133,
-0.062691018,
-0.0276443828,
0.0243857019,
-0.0426652022,
-0.0051870407,
0.0699273199,
-0.0387528837,
-0.0230094325,
-0.049579937,
0.0048174788,
-0.0387366451,
0.0705382079,
-0.0230167806,
0.011453649,
0.0825571716,
-0.0484729707,
-0.0251796655,
-0.0014026307,
0.0265488531,
0.0065059578,
0.0257811211,
-0.0530040227,
-0.0064166849,
-0.0354874209,
-0.0329715125,
-0.0484655574,
-0.0479848869,
-0.0034451301,
0.0181386638,
-0.0380067639,
0.043290887,
-0.0157197658,
0.026207881,
-0.011808645,
0.0574142784,
-0.0311156157,
0.0203704443,
-0.0345923789,
0.0505595729,
0.0320502929,
-0.0061670081,
-0.0534886383,
0.0218057185,
0.0204710644,
0.028599672,
0.0276044756,
0.02051978,
-0.0198479816,
0.014653841,
0.0253883731,
-0.075328812,
-0.0349939279,
-0.016233759,
0.0643723011,
-0.0661223456,
0.0266643893,
0.1076638997,
0.0534050576,
-0.0551186763,
-0.0139615983,
0.0011128723,
0.0051790476,
0.0082660941,
0.014595421,
-0.0967174768,
-0.0592324585,
-0.0178556144,
-0.0042960448,
-0.0264764484,
-0.0397881046,
-0.0104506314,
-0.1020823419,
0.0007263885,
0.0120388847,
0.0113107897,
0.0090625081,
-0.0440980531,
0.0384644382,
-0.0421172865,
-0.0426245779,
-0.0063332906,
-0.0085350899,
0.0065820706,
0.018954657,
-0.0243269186,
-0.0370941162,
0.0207803883,
-0.0549569279,
0.0403240807,
0.0160411559,
0.0247269236,
0.0221639518,
0.04664547,
0.0158589073,
-0.0540599488,
-0.0074267187,
-0.0164695624,
0.035834495,
-0.0182554387,
0.0037018147,
0.0230812598,
0.0532726273,
-0.0095391348,
-0.0512485318,
0.023133019,
0.0810762197,
-0.003644004,
0.0334065072,
0.0193746015,
-0.0093858233,
0.0519082956,
0.0675456598,
0.0261979569,
0.0037940836,
-0.013517011,
-0.0323842913,
0.0096876379,
-0.0779341683,
-0.0090881651,
-0.0027691154,
-0.0417082384,
-0.0449256562,
-0.0805462748,
-0.059271317,
0.0413480699,
0.0435409844,
0.0115365554,
0.0044607338,
-0.0078379586,
0.0025499861,
-0.023831604,
0.0487454534,
-0.0349861979,
-0.0065413723,
-0.0245857779,
0.0127942506,
0.0296628233,
0.0146835111,
-0.0094913179,
0.075757958,
-0.0244309641,
-0.0550537072,
-0.0408076309,
0.0210094247,
0.0148217231,
0.0588657036,
-0.035546314,
-0.023360759,
-0.00376556,
-0.0043004793,
0.0005665012,
-0.0208230894,
0.0531958714,
0.0136911022,
-0.0200806167,
0.0201127399,
-0.0359642543,
0.0233967155,
-0.0129663469,
0.0252635665,
-0.0666465536,
-0.0361101143,
0.02082734,
-0.0158959217,
0.0854315534,
-0.0027640141,
-0.0367086492,
-0.0380860642,
0.0049038255,
-0.0179543495,
0.0003645041,
-0.0189263951,
0.0502173565,
-0.0192968808,
-0.0170839634,
0.0016713376,
-0.009124672,
-0.0607036501,
0.0529572405,
-0.0619502217,
0.0064403778,
0.0620066524,
0.0258304272,
-0.015715953,
0.0055600107,
-0.054161083,
0.0441029929,
0.0330256745,
0.0042051203,
-0.0478726216,
0.0360255353,
0.0273368172,
0.0099411784,
0.0084729921,
0.019471515,
-0.0568549857,
0.055788137,
0.0057737348,
-0.034815982,
0.0714081675,
-0.0758395717,
0.0710475817,
0.0122042643,
0.0091036037,
-0.0068707177,
0.0456540063,
0.0196719747,
0.0048776311,
0.0059532463,
0.043479152,
-0.0133175729,
0.0408723801,
0.0786908865,
-0.0161945987,
0.0630188435,
0.0309694558,
0.0133767035,
-0.0435579643,
-0.0183961876,
0.040518485,
0.0373889618,
-0.0192512348,
-0.0031465858,
-0.0448932089,
0.0253043994,
0.0140338605,
-0.0110991355,
-0.0168909002,
0.0011439024,
0.0366924405,
0.0216453616,
-0.0014879002,
-0.005354376,
-0.0342576429,
-0.0037659565,
0.0390286185,
-0.0255816225,
-0.0563473813,
-5.681837535e-33,
-0.0304598808,
0.0139954453,
0.0019213808,
0.088166751,
0.0029937818,
0.0345179215,
-0.017056752,
-0.0113888131,
0.007664544,
-0.0107855638,
0.0003973717,
-0.0438176133,
0.0232247841,
-0.0367951579,
0.0242432691,
-0.0266577583,
0.0287236311,
-0.0002487817,
-0.0513848402,
0.039486248,
0.0819819272,
0.010306133,
0.0500110462,
-0.0668527409,
0.0625004023,
-0.0115910778,
-0.0066012968,
0.0045689656,
0.0841571838,
0.0723518729,
0.0038026015,
0.0237683114,
0.0329988636,
-0.064533636,
0.0106578348,
0.0415212326,
-0.0704578087,
-0.0516899936,
0.0473141894,
-0.0209141783,
0.0023796761,
-0.0749471486,
-0.024262188,
-0.0012882501,
0.0290570352,
-0.0251308605,
0.0327964835,
0.0022372834,
-0.0099523468,
-0.0665070638,
-0.0681047589,
0.0302205794,
-0.0108268149,
-0.0403629094,
0.0230339598,
0.0629511476,
0.0343241282,
0.0123429447,
-0.0119345495,
0.0055969344,
-0.0401788764,
0.0377877466,
-0.0048031784,
0.0023645924,
-0.0499565452,
0.0467847921,
-0.058903221,
-0.0070519079,
-0.0097478097,
0.0459047854,
-0.0126112858,
0.0307650231,
-0.003662789,
0.0509894527,
0.0274570435,
0.0305526126,
-0.078271538,
0.0480549522,
0.0764809549,
0.0136236781,
-0.0284862313,
-0.0029787275,
-0.0310164988,
-0.0108407959,
-0.0074828202,
-0.0305676181,
-0.0074835848,
-0.0225853901,
0.0216062088,
0.0115703521,
0.018541269,
0.087189354,
0.0466617495,
0.0046333093,
0.0089022452,
0.023383528,
0.0045244885,
0.0038024294,
0.0025333255,
0.0082773389,
-0.0438514315,
-0.0261693783,
0.0462555699,
-0.0082478672,
0.0676905587,
0.0112855406,
0.0287524257,
0.0190317165,
-0.0261161439,
-0.0126183722,
-0.0147431176,
0.0028117325,
-0.0341348834,
0.0454963148,
-0.0012359684,
0.0177962575,
-0.000094928,
0.0690801963,
0.0098540625,
-0.014531184,
-0.0013120857,
-0.0393257998,
-0.0079557085,
0.027953187,
-0.0158026256,
-0.0239678901,
0.0223594755,
0.0284280665,
-0.0078722592,
-0.0186883435,
0.0103925876,
-0.0095240865,
2.439e-7,
0.0434055366,
0.00680546,
0.0148794325,
0.0246095899,
-0.0261905938,
0.0364067815,
-0.012470033,
0.0515207052,
0.0117363557,
-0.0089406734,
-0.0139742047,
-0.0204729065,
0.0257776808,
0.0390066989,
-0.1197595894,
-0.0555809364,
-0.0535526685,
-0.0056332839,
-0.0674817264,
0.013672146,
0.1018238813,
0.0724530891,
0.0465627201,
0.0203948263,
-0.013317571,
-0.0364103466,
0.0311840922,
-0.0047736899,
-0.0451198965,
0.0483330749,
0.0222444888,
-0.0128070489,
-0.0368714146,
0.0520448536,
-0.0218600873,
0.0428789407,
-0.0190095734,
0.0655789673,
-0.0229201578,
-0.0244524274,
0.0063549504,
-0.0194160696,
-0.0009699467,
-0.0352480449,
0.0793029591,
-0.0371022597,
0.0088913972,
0.0123488549,
-0.0368727632,
0.0535355993,
-0.0487396754,
0.0142368823,
-0.0281252451,
0.0371622257,
0.0048399549,
0.0024343857,
-0.0160832815,
-0.0863972008,
-0.0336176008,
0.0119915633,
0.0007643842,
-0.0198649429,
0.0281635579,
-0.0678341314,
-0.0130574619,
-0.0959379598,
0.0053536487,
2.565147012e-34,
-0.0109624211,
-0.0032353851,
0.0011731328,
0.035396032,
0.0248278268,
-0.0208353512,
-0.0556761511,
0.0102781821,
0.0358417146,
-0.027039919,
-0.0173754245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04456v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04456v2 | ERNIE-Music: Text-to-Waveform Music Generation with Diffusion Models | 2023-02-09T06:27:09 | 2023-09-21T09:30:00 | Pengfei Zhu, Chao Pang, Yekun Chai, Lei Li, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun, Hao Tian, Hua Wu | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS | In recent years, the burgeoning interest in diffusion models has led to
significant advances in image and speech generation. Nevertheless, the direct
synthesis of music waveforms from unrestricted textual prompts remains a
relatively underexplored domain. In response to this lacuna, this paper
introduces a pioneering contribution in the form of a text-to-waveform music
generation model, underpinned by the utilization of diffusion models. Our
methodology hinges on the innovative incorporation of free-form textual prompts
as conditional factors to guide the waveform generation process within the
diffusion model framework. Addressing the challenge of limited text-music
parallel data, we undertake the creation of a dataset by harnessing web
resources, a task facilitated by weak supervision techniques. Furthermore, a
rigorous empirical inquiry is undertaken to contrast the efficacy of two
distinct prompt formats for text conditioning, namely, music tags and
unconstrained textual descriptions. The outcomes of this comparative analysis
affirm the superior performance of our proposed model in terms of enhancing
text-music relevance. Finally, our work culminates in a demonstrative
exhibition of the excellent capabilities of our model in text-to-music
generation. We further demonstrate that our generated music in the waveform
domain outperforms previous works by a large margin in terms of diversity,
quality, and text-music relevance. | [
0.0041168551,
0.0152327204,
-0.0164146628,
-0.0205576699,
-0.0088801654,
-0.0219516661,
0.0343565233,
-0.0023991643,
-0.0011477896,
0.0261198655,
-0.0428831987,
-0.0318816714,
0.007196744,
0.0043888907,
0.0188706201,
-0.0719203502,
0.011353855,
-0.0722011998,
-0.02034056,
-0.0136366477,
-0.0052255308,
-0.0148760201,
-0.0164037235,
0.0089330338,
-0.0288518406,
-0.0114982082,
-0.0401378311,
0.0549369045,
0.0190609097,
-0.021185467,
-0.0641627461,
0.0473095365,
0.011619499,
0.0137606477,
0.0000019177,
-0.0270092096,
-0.0141265979,
0.0035898946,
0.0669236034,
-0.0182069801,
0.0071621942,
0.0317876786,
-0.0421310998,
0.0011387675,
-0.0076667047,
0.0473517366,
0.0541220494,
-0.01652872,
0.0828328282,
0.0661947131,
-0.0023167063,
-0.0462775193,
0.0009809366,
-0.0206388738,
0.0716601461,
0.051227279,
0.0152082378,
-0.0096774492,
0.0663318858,
0.0039914669,
-0.0061892094,
0.0560901165,
0.0105595849,
-0.0064088427,
0.0659776032,
0.0564128906,
-0.010626141,
-0.0469125211,
-0.0289622378,
0.0739244968,
0.0548069701,
-0.0085357726,
0.0362577587,
0.0083383797,
0.0188178234,
0.0666050464,
-0.0479950719,
0.014626517,
-0.0135508748,
0.008076326,
-0.0459678583,
-0.0040114722,
0.0353518687,
-0.0310769491,
0.0428350046,
0.009003995,
0.0385510363,
-0.0747696683,
0.0344123393,
-0.0062041115,
0.010085539,
-0.0662328154,
0.0550175719,
0.0195684861,
0.007625964,
-0.0030966972,
-0.0435093567,
-0.0576376282,
0.0010788689,
-0.0164965969,
0.0659984574,
-0.0068926592,
0.0262463111,
0.050660383,
-0.0076999674,
-0.0213904791,
-0.0482588895,
-0.061982248,
-0.0347562246,
0.025821168,
-0.0303540509,
-0.0106097041,
-0.0546539165,
0.0140456138,
0.0151924882,
-0.0298833065,
-0.0215588231,
-0.0098124472,
-0.0071478491,
-0.0041084704,
0.0488282405,
0.0120637594,
-0.0497143492,
0.0175974239,
-0.0019146501,
-0.016555395,
-0.0101528233,
0.0488669947,
0.0514446981,
0.0405544639,
-0.00918792,
-0.0021484441,
0.032058958,
-0.021771675,
0.0359308124,
0.0182675067,
0.0140219713,
0.0007289726,
0.0020264979,
-0.0488172956,
-0.0517845228,
-0.0058140079,
-0.009424855,
-0.0929026306,
0.0142449019,
-0.0170277674,
0.0007499226,
0.0116830757,
-0.0130991219,
0.0533872098,
-0.0121109635,
0.0223723054,
-0.0232154615,
0.0474892855,
0.0263452493,
-0.0055933339,
-0.0381351076,
0.0234771725,
0.0585638434,
0.0307195932,
0.0006548151,
-0.0289146155,
0.0287540797,
0.0379918329,
0.0242309067,
0.0093038855,
-0.0077577517,
-0.0286988486,
0.0100572892,
0.0354409814,
0.0359272547,
0.0516473167,
-0.0044028368,
0.0072405352,
0.0785149038,
0.0431485176,
0.0048434245,
0.0383742824,
0.0601492636,
0.0192991327,
0.0094697,
0.0396847241,
0.0553156659,
0.0177119225,
0.0374028832,
0.0345073119,
0.0760933533,
-0.003372554,
-0.0139287002,
-0.0096911034,
0.0099926395,
-0.0271273516,
0.0252508447,
-0.0258033555,
0.0079348404,
0.038704779,
-0.0456705056,
0.0326018669,
0.004355107,
-0.0883405954,
0.0393492542,
-0.0285708066,
0.0542590022,
0.1064869463,
0.0614091232,
-0.0354797505,
0.0838266686,
-0.0288284067,
0.0389155224,
0.0614211969,
-0.0134773338,
-0.0018502353,
-0.0202172138,
-0.0159363188,
-0.0123212589,
-0.0085329106,
-0.0175919048,
0.0112733543,
-0.0559389591,
0.0389887355,
0.0063103321,
-0.0165152829,
-0.0179195199,
0.0168910176,
0.0013720462,
-0.0805763081,
0.0232049525,
0.0165659226,
0.0204041824,
0.0448195972,
-0.0364410505,
0.0468519628,
-0.0084477309,
0.0303249229,
0.0024996605,
-0.0070726965,
-0.0557746366,
0.014571717,
0.02159857,
-0.0625717789,
0.039134983,
-0.0085422555,
0.0629954562,
-0.0580060743,
0.0309544131,
-0.0333740152,
0.025839895,
0.0167508516,
0.0199702997,
0.0048488141,
-0.0169902388,
0.0253692996,
0.0315007567,
0.0510786176,
0.0256385226,
0.0342420042,
0.0161766279,
0.0044100662,
-0.0415725596,
-0.0399496146,
-0.0026649421,
0.0051182616,
-0.0033553136,
-0.0194362607,
-0.0381624997,
-0.055435624,
-0.0482548065,
-0.0875344798,
0.0175363775,
-0.0012890407,
-0.0151566658,
0.0167823918,
-0.0124571733,
-0.0104444949,
0.0218263455,
-0.0362987779,
-0.0420424789,
0.0189217348,
0.0159036107,
-0.0241971314,
-0.0067871981,
-0.0424656309,
-0.0173028838,
-0.0289894324,
0.012184958,
-0.0214202628,
0.0080739213,
-0.0225939192,
-0.0249158442,
0.0016365981,
-0.0490554012,
-0.0292214807,
0.0278926473,
0.0162596237,
0.0310491826,
-0.0392316394,
0.1023012325,
0.0326162726,
0.0076823481,
0.0047054943,
0.038664069,
-0.0481028073,
-0.0105765741,
0.0042521451,
-0.0186740924,
0.0499297976,
0.0029694263,
-0.0345043652,
0.0010933268,
0.0308087356,
0.098084867,
-0.0082626604,
-0.0207976289,
0.0156820323,
-0.0291818958,
0.0121907759,
-0.0486756563,
-0.0406631976,
-0.0357941799,
0.0171761047,
-0.0213670582,
-0.0434485748,
0.0604786649,
-0.0292278342,
0.0052524549,
-0.0241419114,
-0.0497466139,
0.0075220768,
-0.0088178283,
-0.0376382358,
0.0078443233,
0.0452842638,
-0.0135235935,
-0.0384217054,
0.0333788209,
0.034114141,
-0.0685191453,
-0.0247364864,
-0.0029917436,
-0.0017107243,
0.0147800865,
0.0316717923,
-0.0120427581,
-0.0592642576,
0.0534694754,
0.0163789373,
0.0044778055,
-0.0097289877,
0.0131591549,
0.0088593811,
0.0317838639,
0.0123488745,
-0.0220671482,
-0.0184542611,
-0.0470585078,
0.0872789547,
-0.0035594767,
-0.0586414821,
-0.0238416251,
-0.0535360314,
0.014841957,
-0.0348057784,
0.0400299244,
-0.0055786171,
-0.0067418148,
-0.0040737647,
-0.0334759168,
-0.0004909419,
-0.009748823,
0.0646646917,
0.0376612842,
-0.0271829534,
0.0019539015,
0.0843513086,
0.0506718196,
0.0114694182,
-0.011294581,
0.0579940863,
0.0602256171,
-0.0041018636,
-0.0022190711,
0.0008061311,
0.0220523607,
0.034842696,
0.0618559271,
0.0341427736,
0.0065336335,
-0.00504001,
-0.0386836939,
0.0550163873,
0.0183460806,
0.0171963815,
0.0211048294,
-0.043126408,
-0.0078375023,
0.06224861,
-0.04919957,
0.0257664379,
-0.0318161137,
0.0269136187,
0.0343401395,
0.0301951673,
-0.0287172236,
-0.0495604165,
-0.059156388,
0.0211036503,
0.0843951777,
0.0497197621,
-0.0357602388,
-0.0877051279,
-0.0106664896,
0.0010541908,
-0.0009726463,
0.0233875439,
0.0083198855,
0.0491936579,
0.0005967365,
-0.0280881468,
0.0295041949,
0.0120837884,
-0.0101985084,
0.0355184004,
0.0622837134,
-0.0024079329,
-0.0283891167,
-0.028357178,
0.0242406502,
0.0685331374,
0.0773575902,
0.039134521,
-0.0445772074,
0.0078039388,
-0.0216455702,
0.0208574049,
-0.044526808,
-0.0341710113,
-0.0048811203,
-0.0324369445,
-0.028701989,
-0.086122036,
-0.0124303801,
-0.0182702336,
0.0547340102,
0.0412254594,
0.0315826759,
-0.0161056425,
-0.0471754335,
-0.0591821261,
0.0302061085,
-0.0005823479,
0.0344176553,
-0.0499996431,
-0.0853927508,
-0.0360577628,
-0.0705840886,
-0.0277871322,
-0.0056332592,
-0.0783209652,
-0.0289395582,
-0.0139464047,
0.0142258666,
0.027882589,
-0.0130166681,
-0.0052545364,
-0.0007855569,
0.0579404123,
0.0498339869,
0.0200409647,
0.0254565403,
0.0125983283,
-0.0260774642,
0.0323192999,
-0.0319170281,
-0.0506441556,
0.0276066083,
0.0172611922,
0.0249148868,
0.0488037951,
0.0152589185,
0.0357254446,
-0.0310046729,
-0.0166910458,
-0.0316842236,
0.0154085364,
-0.0574619621,
-0.0192945004,
-0.0340843648,
-0.0076724561,
-0.0423141271,
-0.0186135974,
0.0336778909,
0.0293365382,
-0.0106944218,
-0.0179860648,
-0.0184200499,
-0.0276953392,
-0.0562194474,
0.0181257296,
0.0336389206,
-0.0159895495,
0.0340424962,
-0.0297175478,
0.0373979658,
0.0128253549,
-0.0028150582,
-0.0082184793,
0.0408887453,
0.0048897257,
0.0182966497,
-0.0194297787,
-0.0075309402,
0.0079455813,
-0.0695585087,
-0.0295878053,
-0.0484742001,
-0.0013718285,
0.0305844657,
0.0191660337,
0.0178783834,
0.0035781346,
0.0088570239,
0.0028418214,
0.02055257,
0.0242342297,
-0.0229077861,
0.0078783948,
0.0109895794,
0.0119070215,
-0.0015745678,
0.0561522208,
-0.0646631643,
-0.0115801627,
-0.0391754694,
-0.0290165469,
-0.0013581103,
-0.0002020705,
-0.015659105,
-0.008324841,
-0.0072244531,
-0.017389629,
-0.0219305251,
-0.0654694885,
0.0265016947,
0.0117980996,
0.0044952277,
-0.0094450964,
0.0609152876,
0.0171420462,
-0.0379721373,
0.0391486734,
0.0015347301,
-0.0061758556,
-0.0345312059,
-0.057609573,
-0.0356785692,
-5.570249326e-33,
-0.0534368418,
-0.0156387109,
-0.0280570164,
-0.0087189963,
-0.01994415,
-0.0220619738,
-0.0687696412,
-0.0050972397,
0.0448056236,
-0.0162278078,
0.0000286328,
0.0232728198,
0.0106163779,
0.0127695277,
0.0137158809,
0.0059697782,
0.0515093766,
-0.0183875263,
-0.0325636491,
0.0360444486,
0.0166919138,
0.0193766449,
-0.0431073718,
-0.0164029989,
0.0380499735,
-0.0516895801,
-0.0304798614,
-0.0485905111,
0.0362269208,
0.0309303794,
-0.0360395201,
0.017956214,
0.0006268693,
-0.0044246772,
-0.0312756896,
0.0729233474,
-0.0211507492,
-0.0232198257,
0.0148944501,
-0.0159011222,
-0.0133620584,
-0.015778983,
0.0572444648,
-0.0104277702,
-0.0306776259,
0.0439706407,
0.0523057245,
-0.0049504568,
0.0118152257,
-0.0617966019,
-0.0562911443,
-0.0096230377,
-0.0351727158,
-0.0341515243,
0.0204010401,
0.0734446049,
-0.0207931269,
0.02520293,
-0.0433309413,
0.0556573533,
0.0521290079,
0.0297425613,
0.0347810052,
0.0219689757,
0.0043825894,
0.0585209206,
0.0189993158,
-0.0349124447,
-0.0017019287,
0.0214962102,
-0.0287049059,
0.0307814684,
0.0206059273,
-0.0136103556,
0.0359887183,
-0.0202476103,
-0.0060816631,
0.0298325755,
-0.0241554547,
-0.0715605095,
0.0099707032,
0.0260270908,
-0.0387537032,
-0.0010790969,
-0.0342739187,
-0.0349256136,
-0.0312750526,
-0.0417696908,
0.0421407633,
-0.0277060568,
-0.0016988424,
-0.0700100511,
-0.0097252363,
0.0015951226,
-0.0435410701,
-0.03565716,
-0.06716609,
0.0523630753,
-0.0059346901,
-0.0561409667,
-0.022393778,
-0.0229705889,
0.1190105081,
0.0278357938,
0.0103745516,
0.0272907019,
-0.0316882655,
0.0512313358,
-0.0599211641,
-0.0140067535,
0.0033105093,
0.02110455,
0.0291524399,
-0.0173583757,
0.0336637273,
-0.0082817711,
-0.0123411734,
0.0175132044,
0.0046676756,
0.0114747686,
0.005960891,
-0.0377945825,
-0.0428693481,
0.0196248088,
-0.002357793,
0.0230599064,
-0.0161235947,
0.0509169437,
0.0237775724,
-0.0454609357,
-0.0427024253,
0.0264442954,
2.797e-7,
0.0136805102,
-0.0028016083,
-0.0050126128,
0.0399892628,
0.0321439244,
-0.0103422282,
-0.0893809199,
0.0062328083,
0.0341549478,
-0.0251898523,
0.0403942168,
-0.0121483263,
0.0755814686,
0.0260660425,
-0.122975938,
-0.0217922218,
-0.1085384488,
0.0136056915,
-0.0802320912,
0.0106709516,
0.0818712115,
0.0320805609,
0.0109894518,
-0.0236823224,
-0.0005719006,
0.0232799202,
0.0524141267,
-0.0102165705,
0.0331712849,
-0.0731660426,
-0.0265189353,
-0.0626846328,
-0.0261068828,
0.0215056278,
-0.0681576207,
0.0084178839,
0.0581471846,
-0.0075534489,
0.0319275819,
0.0071243159,
0.0084086852,
0.0062696445,
0.0086894426,
-0.0423441567,
0.0587461852,
0.0273387972,
0.0086626215,
0.0152108334,
-0.0756631866,
-0.0102540404,
0.0044412669,
-0.0303582996,
-0.0571420342,
-0.041695755,
0.0137577886,
0.0232429542,
0.0334511288,
0.0169875938,
-0.0125461612,
-0.0277368594,
-0.0578408055,
-0.0673988909,
-0.0526437908,
-0.0015552219,
-0.0018446388,
-0.0577038042,
0.0032843645,
2.279572139e-34,
0.0556528345,
-0.065998517,
0.0207240097,
-0.0481789447,
0.0230111592,
0.0070438553,
0.0013994772,
-0.0073908791,
0.0170600228,
-0.0661200657,
-0.0603366718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06407v1 | Correcting Real-Word Spelling Errors: A New Hybrid Approach | 2023-02-09T06:03:11 | 2023-02-09T06:03:11 | Seyed MohammadSadegh Dashti, Amid Khatibi Bardsiri, Vahid Khatibi Bardsiri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spelling correction is one of the main tasks in the field of Natural Language
Processing. Contrary to common spelling errors, real-word errors cannot be
detected by conventional spelling correction methods. The real-word correction
model proposed by Mays, Damerau and Mercer showed a great performance in
different evaluations. In this research, however, a new hybrid approach is
proposed which relies on statistical and syntactic knowledge to detect and
correct real-word errors. In this model, Constraint Grammar (CG) is used to
discriminate among sets of correction candidates in the search space. Mays,
Damerau and Mercer's trigram approach is manipulated to estimate the
probability of syntactically well-formed correction candidates. The approach
proposed here is tested on the Wall Street Journal corpus. The model can prove
to be more practical than some other models, such as WordNet-based method of
Hirst and Budanitsky and fixed windows size method of Wilcox-O'Hearn and Hirst. | [
0.0982321054,
-0.0220842641,
0.0027698933,
0.0043410743,
-0.0557224415,
-0.0144976359,
0.0103485966,
0.0223887525,
0.0079401331,
-0.0741328299,
0.0209387932,
-0.037719205,
0.0405439064,
-0.0461529568,
0.029718969,
-0.0113575188,
0.0933941305,
0.0180338882,
-0.0031638972,
0.0145577583,
0.0539750494,
0.0183028821,
-0.0486994907,
0.0225270446,
-0.0131047294,
-0.0068095881,
0.0316229649,
0.0214720313,
0.0067353095,
-0.0002490866,
-0.0007809522,
0.0508799702,
-0.0314748436,
0.0281405617,
0.0000019538,
-0.0448778942,
-0.0479039252,
-0.0273108575,
0.0091666356,
0.0139445476,
0.0378630385,
-0.0164158307,
-0.0313093513,
0.0480225235,
0.0106690899,
0.0366346836,
0.0515900552,
0.0174719859,
0.0558541231,
0.0624374859,
-0.0146819884,
-0.0050025792,
0.0075779138,
0.0307523515,
-0.0001460871,
0.026946554,
0.0218921956,
0.0135406395,
0.0137033463,
-0.0325414017,
-0.0188864078,
-0.0036553959,
-0.0674136579,
-0.0434747823,
0.0152761685,
-0.0340728685,
-0.0469955839,
0.0032682738,
-0.0093954895,
0.0054000122,
0.0062362291,
-0.0156542491,
0.0340778083,
-0.0025291024,
0.0044034924,
0.0543603301,
0.030492574,
-0.0323907509,
-0.0711416826,
-0.0081696576,
0.068890959,
-0.0480989069,
-0.0098565966,
0.0341666527,
0.0308665652,
0.0596386753,
0.011609083,
-0.0481768399,
-0.047288347,
0.0207380895,
0.0196091775,
-0.0056420807,
0.0319653898,
-0.0246177986,
-0.0379064754,
-0.0030064103,
-0.0433219597,
-0.0710745975,
-0.0073247924,
-0.0380603001,
0.0033802383,
-0.0166847073,
0.01854291,
0.0038532277,
0.022878021,
0.0274596605,
0.0653814301,
0.0035260262,
-0.0070583038,
0.0628342032,
-0.022208916,
0.0039309012,
-0.0584115982,
0.0012945049,
-0.0025504115,
-0.002080892,
-0.078448616,
-0.0659768581,
-0.0234715771,
-0.0166455153,
0.0425801836,
-0.0182259139,
-0.0248815045,
-0.007703213,
-0.0219479818,
-0.0059091705,
0.0306172185,
0.0065606586,
-0.0183832254,
-0.01819635,
0.0001433895,
0.0319394283,
0.0474008508,
-0.0112438807,
-0.0038037824,
-0.0055436296,
0.0188542772,
-0.0332194343,
-0.0056190779,
-0.015201021,
-0.0637915134,
0.0117547372,
-0.0590396821,
-0.048259899,
-0.044511877,
-0.0593767613,
-0.0038902992,
0.0027538307,
0.021096291,
0.0103838798,
-0.0097388104,
0.0489077158,
-0.0504377484,
-0.0032504662,
0.0082334997,
-0.0324159153,
0.0459381454,
-0.0071404651,
0.0171189141,
-0.0384651832,
0.0443655662,
0.0015591647,
0.048158396,
0.0002794938,
-0.0837286487,
-0.0244484749,
-0.0056365328,
-0.0224448983,
-0.0075613656,
0.0614196658,
0.0340968519,
0.0622606874,
-0.0372849181,
0.0059039057,
0.0252274834,
0.0235560238,
0.0480524451,
0.0097265961,
-0.0029429854,
-0.0557189733,
0.0796758235,
0.0093544498,
-0.003484414,
-0.0361566879,
-0.0413433947,
-0.0001588706,
0.0058531323,
-0.0029772951,
0.0293488801,
-0.0400708728,
-0.0380942337,
0.0203320906,
-0.007514542,
-0.0780560002,
0.0479475483,
-0.0055111833,
-0.0574676618,
0.009771781,
-0.0122207403,
-0.007005326,
-0.0125090843,
-0.041234795,
0.0022698019,
0.0997676775,
0.1163923815,
-0.0121111991,
-0.0090503823,
-0.0100224325,
-0.0596576594,
0.0321556255,
0.0602681674,
-0.0079056574,
-0.0615169965,
-0.0573269054,
0.0201815069,
0.0706805885,
0.0239829458,
-0.0103201438,
-0.0047658207,
0.0273199789,
0.0162956696,
0.0285104346,
-0.0469464846,
0.0150071951,
0.0210343041,
0.0069699152,
-0.0458704047,
-0.0246264711,
-0.0063050259,
0.020434944,
-0.040202681,
0.031161014,
-0.0428941585,
-0.0122181186,
0.0033073032,
-0.0370429978,
0.001191788,
-0.0339633636,
0.0341018029,
-0.0693189129,
0.0092366999,
0.0401709303,
0.0225356966,
-0.0218219105,
0.0029232665,
-0.0569219477,
0.0187835079,
-0.0656247959,
0.0371183529,
-0.0114373099,
-0.0015560994,
-0.0610501096,
0.0391458049,
0.0314291939,
0.0430211574,
-0.042746935,
-0.036160104,
-0.0019306107,
-0.0421102196,
0.0139469402,
-0.0028552478,
0.0153014492,
0.0518895425,
0.0600558631,
0.0169182289,
-0.0124197556,
-0.0288240425,
0.0025986049,
-0.0031332104,
0.0078188013,
0.0493260995,
0.024116829,
-0.0104478942,
-0.0167106334,
-0.0042601181,
0.0428533256,
0.0423431695,
0.0287520997,
-0.0437480696,
0.0907982588,
-0.0288747959,
-0.0152257718,
-0.073081471,
-0.0054646372,
-0.010142779,
-0.0202012211,
0.0431234315,
-0.1000597253,
-0.0795183107,
0.112231575,
0.0096031064,
0.020666426,
0.0566166006,
-0.0614410974,
-0.0056049996,
-0.0356823727,
0.0039486228,
0.0203500465,
0.0035510245,
-0.0000091019,
0.0041929968,
-0.0147896996,
0.0203636549,
-0.0320656113,
0.0207098387,
-0.0035533069,
-0.0006105925,
-0.0379028805,
0.0263845194,
0.0108808791,
0.0250143688,
-0.0495763868,
-0.0021181894,
0.0015981521,
-0.0197835937,
0.0251720008,
-0.0222200863,
-0.0415770262,
-0.0005932337,
0.0445302241,
-0.0277626682,
-0.0341443382,
0.0441477634,
0.0088534458,
0.0262294989,
-0.0973915383,
0.0066186618,
-0.0055510155,
-0.050576739,
-0.0120805427,
0.0325801037,
0.0329067186,
-0.0684373379,
-0.0623565726,
-0.0309907366,
0.0919810608,
-0.0401134714,
0.0263560358,
-0.0515816957,
0.0456751846,
0.0112765236,
-0.0037249974,
-0.0237824172,
-0.052683033,
-0.0193286855,
-0.0422479622,
0.0610606149,
-0.038838353,
-0.0193634126,
0.01138278,
-0.0213239584,
0.0672719628,
-0.0001509774,
-0.0220383648,
0.0029754094,
-0.0005331445,
-0.0090951435,
0.0206963196,
0.0765192211,
0.0324497409,
-0.0137047051,
0.0209169053,
0.0091166627,
0.0564446747,
0.0016523955,
-0.0028570781,
0.0247538853,
-0.0555107892,
-0.0652471632,
-0.0046419147,
-0.0188202616,
-0.0510266013,
-0.0421178937,
0.094746381,
0.0596093349,
-0.0108321728,
-0.0173424184,
0.0216038134,
-0.0599499643,
0.0025717949,
0.0566990413,
-0.0333507247,
-0.0240918808,
0.0587094165,
0.017058365,
-0.0423936322,
-0.0212303717,
0.0144755663,
-0.1014573798,
0.0323260613,
0.0493205599,
0.0471787341,
-0.0585745946,
0.0144479889,
0.0151868919,
0.0137916747,
-0.0012719864,
0.0734926015,
-0.0302724633,
0.0071540889,
0.0290430095,
-0.0667705387,
-0.0789565071,
-0.052872926,
-0.0401687771,
0.0244412329,
0.0328497849,
0.013535711,
-0.027167134,
-0.0302099492,
0.0072045568,
0.0071150661,
-0.0085158059,
-0.0108281188,
-0.0025613359,
0.0253002699,
-0.0266836509,
-0.0632460862,
-0.0135120498,
-0.057944417,
0.0030298298,
-0.0330544971,
0.0426253155,
-0.0424980596,
0.0175317284,
0.0007411893,
0.0342682935,
0.0268366076,
0.0068468289,
-0.0038511292,
0.0027962225,
-0.0151233841,
-0.0429596938,
0.0225645192,
-0.049152866,
0.0104830554,
0.0304109622,
-0.0479449257,
-0.0199001078,
-0.1086795032,
-0.0151867811,
-0.0323134474,
0.0566492379,
0.0296124779,
0.0027199099,
0.0330322161,
0.0071361111,
0.0205387566,
-0.0635743886,
0.0280306023,
0.0390858017,
-0.033111874,
0.0636105165,
-0.0087589966,
0.0396316238,
-0.0158187766,
-0.0032810699,
-0.0104340157,
-0.0348059162,
0.0255362913,
-0.0152822277,
0.0196217261,
-0.0539712869,
-0.0444815531,
-0.0310482923,
-0.0554285422,
0.0477318503,
0.0596700907,
0.0181912053,
-0.0163684487,
-0.0823486298,
-0.0120972088,
-0.0285286531,
0.0029965078,
-0.0163271967,
-0.0328464136,
0.0451539531,
-0.0164869446,
0.0057381825,
0.0460602939,
0.0269881468,
0.0345421769,
-0.0204712711,
0.0434624515,
-0.0616013221,
-0.0289506409,
-0.0050811069,
-0.0257620923,
-0.0016104843,
-0.0158790108,
-0.0105629452,
-0.0316651948,
-0.0281807687,
-0.0121924719,
-0.0690526441,
-0.0063534705,
0.0335234143,
0.029381929,
0.0187515318,
0.011144856,
-0.0216318592,
-0.0302329883,
0.0271572676,
0.0140416268,
0.0128363166,
0.0111836065,
-0.0157838725,
-0.0274867378,
0.0195605941,
-0.0137636345,
-0.0260756109,
-0.0197906401,
-0.0098071871,
0.0734210983,
-0.0279656872,
0.0388373882,
0.0817926601,
-0.02262187,
0.0311134886,
-0.0500081815,
-0.0035982828,
-0.0092262207,
0.0383657627,
0.0301795471,
0.0528361797,
0.0024634337,
0.0054546827,
0.0026544847,
-0.0583690852,
0.0384181961,
0.0114504751,
0.0103362435,
-0.0337773077,
-0.1036826596,
0.0138818733,
-0.0113156512,
-0.048146043,
-0.0274722781,
-0.0075817155,
-0.0069209398,
-0.0442674421,
-0.0335163251,
-0.0117158415,
0.0770072117,
0.0413754806,
0.007953872,
-0.0201096851,
0.0430729799,
0.0185706988,
0.0043158513,
-0.0468001142,
-0.0098345829,
-0.0067259474,
-0.0124721481,
0.0035489069,
-5.699017018e-33,
-0.0334856063,
-0.0263356101,
-0.0239795595,
-0.0483273044,
-0.0277041886,
-0.0206130613,
0.0048031998,
-0.0017813495,
0.0360193811,
0.0332622044,
-0.0163897332,
0.0441481471,
0.0112325307,
-0.0322134905,
0.03702645,
0.0459048152,
-0.0013636983,
-0.0116818435,
0.0211530514,
-0.0777825043,
0.0359055251,
0.043623291,
0.0841210634,
0.0148921255,
0.0367519669,
0.0026833564,
-0.0374331735,
0.0271508805,
0.0049532549,
0.0316817574,
0.0476470627,
0.0513381213,
-0.0102725672,
-0.0074481317,
-0.0112191103,
-0.0082354993,
-0.0587395579,
-0.0469955616,
0.0514936298,
0.0525932498,
0.0117197745,
-0.0279294867,
0.0260074399,
-0.023865886,
-0.049354028,
0.043975208,
0.0144136213,
-0.0417969637,
0.0019337592,
-0.0219449587,
-0.0221281126,
0.0137257306,
0.0223414078,
0.0299918782,
0.0174840298,
0.0271601733,
-0.0399376564,
-0.0525158867,
-0.0464255176,
0.0115144756,
0.0311862379,
0.071251899,
-0.0134276832,
-0.0088323159,
-0.0343970209,
0.0329739749,
-0.0191648044,
-0.0019231462,
0.0502454527,
-0.0067370674,
0.0181298852,
-0.0273180846,
0.0450361744,
0.0508371182,
0.0886859372,
-0.0592356846,
-0.0511702336,
0.0001680821,
-0.0222745724,
0.0276504699,
-0.0057834345,
-0.0016681167,
-0.0780416429,
-0.060361404,
0.0054556993,
0.0341493599,
-0.006157937,
0.0024345301,
0.0198744275,
0.0332729295,
0.0188242234,
0.0343555957,
-0.0142645901,
-0.016864771,
-0.0062736128,
-0.0444216914,
0.019884482,
0.013912065,
-0.0334782265,
0.0163986478,
0.0121136289,
-0.0452486314,
-0.0063148313,
0.0735241324,
0.0287620779,
0.0052446686,
-0.0020382006,
0.0093767634,
-0.0829731822,
0.0226560291,
0.0306772273,
0.0207608715,
0.0077809244,
-0.0532355271,
-0.0140717542,
-0.0169108212,
0.0194001701,
-0.0114471186,
0.0332148746,
-0.027354341,
0.0340456329,
0.0059712282,
-0.0183856618,
0.0144300368,
0.014364481,
0.0217779744,
0.0065698936,
0.0133763999,
0.0232137199,
-0.0099719409,
0.00695473,
-0.0108905304,
2.79e-7,
0.0313357748,
0.091196999,
-0.0011960627,
0.0071772286,
0.0205658916,
-0.002291589,
-0.0045769904,
0.0420361795,
-0.0225756317,
0.00598962,
0.0307967644,
-0.0522032045,
0.0610416792,
-0.0280231666,
-0.0343867131,
0.00050202,
-0.006694505,
0.0186782796,
-0.0121337473,
-0.020052705,
0.0577518679,
-0.0035237623,
0.0166448783,
-0.0227310937,
-0.0458522178,
-0.0541910641,
-0.0017724556,
0.0059159086,
-0.0385447964,
0.0329596326,
0.1175545305,
0.0010153304,
0.0490414053,
0.0546547249,
-0.0399530791,
-0.0338606648,
0.0849579722,
-0.0216316152,
0.0007483081,
0.1096279919,
0.0133185629,
0.0119374003,
0.0022130504,
0.0029218791,
0.0218131486,
0.0265253298,
0.0313800536,
-0.0416950919,
-0.0235992894,
-0.0097471494,
0.011103821,
-0.0228881277,
-0.0134745967,
0.0127691459,
0.0238701291,
0.0585576743,
-0.0011441141,
0.0000230523,
0.028653603,
0.0385767668,
0.0206266902,
-0.0190798622,
0.0214909539,
0.008936272,
0.0001924209,
-0.0208611879,
-0.0081717046,
2.437952554e-34,
0.0411362723,
-0.0058254991,
0.0295696408,
-0.0043714182,
0.0273983926,
0.0245407671,
-0.0029691928,
0.0035842725,
0.0084653217,
-0.051680997,
-0.0016292094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04449v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04449v3 | Read and Reap the Rewards: Learning to Play Atari with the Help of Instruction Manuals | 2023-02-09T05:47:03 | 2023-10-26T08:23:48 | Yue Wu, Yewen Fan, Paul Pu Liang, Amos Azaria, Yuanzhi Li, Tom M. Mitchell | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | High sample complexity has long been a challenge for RL. On the other hand,
humans learn to perform tasks not only from interaction or demonstrations, but
also by reading unstructured text documents, e.g., instruction manuals.
Instruction manuals and wiki pages are among the most abundant data that could
inform agents of valuable features and policies or task-specific environmental
dynamics and reward structures. Therefore, we hypothesize that the ability to
utilize human-written instruction manuals to assist learning policies for
specific tasks should lead to a more efficient and better-performing agent. We
propose the Read and Reward framework. Read and Reward speeds up RL algorithms
on Atari games by reading manuals released by the Atari game developers. Our
framework consists of a QA Extraction module that extracts and summarizes
relevant information from the manual and a Reasoning module that evaluates
object-agent interactions based on information from the manual. An auxiliary
reward is then provided to a standard A2C RL agent, when interaction is
detected. Experimentally, various RL algorithms obtain significant improvement
in performance and training speed when assisted by our design. | [
0.0499509536,
0.0186048858,
-0.0172121059,
0.0190187488,
-0.011204035,
0.0331873149,
-0.0415896066,
-0.0160811581,
0.0072877053,
-0.0173893459,
-0.0251348577,
0.0258243028,
-0.0123200044,
-0.0087421928,
-0.0369297601,
-0.0635841936,
0.0265396982,
-0.0342629068,
0.0378945917,
0.0136703523,
-0.008618881,
-0.0467436984,
-0.0275407862,
0.0253140014,
0.0061550797,
-0.0131371561,
-0.0501656346,
0.0006706274,
0.0314590074,
-0.0319921784,
0.0028610243,
-0.0325169489,
0.0484167598,
-0.0073749218,
0.0000019288,
-0.0388998352,
-0.030909624,
-0.02031455,
-0.0032294046,
-0.0109230392,
0.0255201105,
0.0089711659,
-0.0067477464,
0.007398867,
-0.0378294885,
-0.0110589741,
0.0442509986,
0.027784355,
0.0436743833,
0.0495991446,
0.0160255451,
-0.0044929897,
0.0214431044,
0.0207226481,
0.076742433,
-0.0467256345,
-0.0034094383,
0.069213137,
0.0886330232,
-0.031947948,
-0.031802427,
-0.0015222643,
0.0522904955,
-0.0079040872,
-0.0034799313,
0.0522353388,
0.0421481691,
-0.0139303161,
-0.0343936346,
0.0268282704,
-0.0123869032,
0.0271395333,
0.0523483828,
0.0130205695,
0.0470422395,
0.0024815379,
-0.0157916266,
0.0405057259,
-0.0575758666,
-0.0089185284,
-0.0130645791,
-0.0086352173,
0.0018820431,
-0.0356723368,
0.0082862629,
0.0744906738,
-0.0495289154,
-0.0513937436,
0.0100794118,
0.0159651935,
0.0238831807,
-0.033678636,
-0.0336592942,
0.0427048542,
-0.0386572555,
0.0282103885,
-0.0187628567,
0.0281784609,
-0.0240977071,
-0.022278158,
0.0472937934,
0.0043950342,
0.0059434893,
0.037245322,
-0.0065592583,
0.0363757126,
-0.0011352788,
0.0239492599,
-0.0232547931,
0.0527710915,
-0.0922720283,
-0.0003357589,
-0.0496973358,
0.0971031785,
0.0141975693,
-0.0113906041,
-0.0223903395,
0.0322517306,
-0.0132950433,
0.0224032458,
-0.0280211568,
0.0275409576,
-0.0171553753,
0.0268282406,
-0.0703271553,
-0.0409882888,
-0.0688757673,
0.007166713,
0.0244521033,
0.0078281648,
0.0022280226,
-0.0186330024,
-0.0017717781,
0.0037160451,
0.0027252312,
0.1285912097,
0.0038558294,
-0.0252072047,
-0.0206046794,
-0.0378425829,
0.0503713824,
-0.0124148596,
0.0585234165,
-0.0147451097,
0.0131477052,
-0.0407727845,
0.0169523302,
0.0094939256,
0.0074342419,
0.0150746433,
0.015948087,
0.0734453723,
0.002882544,
0.011964893,
0.0179725755,
0.0153925139,
-0.0509730503,
0.060209576,
0.0501498282,
0.0265878476,
0.0066741705,
0.0161851551,
0.0238252524,
0.0146059534,
-0.0139742959,
-0.0616448633,
0.0540197417,
0.0018542411,
0.0018857875,
0.057763882,
0.0265458375,
-0.0069343564,
-0.0555933192,
0.0131484745,
0.0252108518,
0.0430669971,
0.0196866244,
0.0004098212,
0.0319881104,
0.0399295203,
0.0209227372,
0.005840329,
-0.0252144877,
0.0620838255,
0.0009999481,
0.0149941798,
-0.067941241,
0.0169617906,
-0.0021626335,
-0.0601800382,
0.0340414084,
-0.0089937486,
0.0456388704,
-0.00493734,
0.0136566004,
-0.0029262274,
-0.0598830581,
-0.0518190674,
0.0310202036,
-0.0125077879,
-0.0081452262,
-0.0892649293,
0.0601612516,
0.058764454,
0.0428527109,
-0.0799869597,
-0.0155888507,
-0.0182652827,
0.0217032172,
0.0175266266,
0.0064414758,
-0.0455480963,
0.0439099818,
0.003042507,
-0.0493063219,
-0.0473565832,
0.0089340471,
0.0884379223,
0.0322621539,
-0.0093889916,
-0.0373451374,
0.0254393574,
-0.0423417538,
0.0474747866,
-0.0287058689,
-0.0751902461,
0.0116073377,
0.0177102871,
0.0086197946,
0.0121593485,
-0.0270660296,
-0.0119908461,
0.0105497194,
-0.0030235457,
0.0083810557,
0.0043649152,
-0.0320874862,
0.0092120869,
0.0289823245,
-0.0380907841,
-0.008111231,
0.0529116057,
0.0259693563,
0.0048827915,
-0.015017096,
-0.0194204375,
0.0671936795,
0.0176619403,
0.0008301869,
-0.0030388674,
-0.0253004637,
0.0088836979,
0.0419211388,
0.0160801392,
-0.0546781309,
0.0005182344,
-0.0629911497,
-0.0204837248,
-0.0731759369,
0.0390483998,
-0.0101074576,
-0.0105566708,
-0.0017758203,
0.0492971614,
0.0385423005,
-0.0511240996,
0.0168674886,
-0.0022265227,
-0.033804521,
-0.0123268776,
0.0020812892,
0.00566711,
-0.0312366281,
-0.0007062448,
-0.0129389903,
0.019815024,
-0.0061398419,
-0.0349469557,
0.0015889461,
0.0220530778,
0.0513755642,
-0.0349655598,
-0.0384841338,
-0.0090499958,
-0.0160318017,
-0.0276725758,
0.0631499514,
0.0314777605,
-0.0544990264,
-0.0089179482,
0.0045946306,
0.0070225722,
-0.0269057043,
-0.0194884744,
0.0460452065,
-0.0347033963,
-0.0311036445,
0.146946311,
-0.0158481393,
0.0628891066,
0.0626828149,
-0.0275739767,
-0.0433215722,
0.0500680357,
-0.0179004222,
-0.0176046994,
-0.0307337325,
-0.0132281464,
0.0433606841,
0.0700521469,
-0.0577630103,
0.0134204114,
-0.0696922615,
-0.0071061072,
0.0066290186,
-0.1047940627,
-0.0453410149,
-0.0179578923,
-0.0333354883,
-0.0169051774,
-0.0622586273,
0.0016223345,
0.0891829208,
0.0151375812,
-0.0008020666,
-0.0243118349,
0.0095550958,
0.0096563464,
0.0379877016,
0.0096443538,
0.0036921056,
0.0106422966,
-0.0165441036,
-0.0165722165,
-0.0106560672,
0.0380712859,
0.0186636038,
-0.0160412453,
-0.0780439377,
-0.0164271034,
0.0279662851,
-0.0378926098,
-0.0249693599,
0.0197823457,
0.0189338047,
-0.0204375163,
-0.0132568665,
-0.0461193174,
-0.0580915324,
-0.0217005555,
0.0699515864,
-0.0024979005,
-0.0102918362,
-0.0263776425,
-0.0158513896,
-0.028832471,
0.079734385,
0.0005300082,
-0.0151627567,
-0.0751575381,
0.0637516975,
0.0082814554,
0.0133493729,
-0.0731971413,
-0.0217507929,
0.0182414185,
-0.0191604625,
-0.0470417924,
0.017572904,
0.0774273351,
0.003188977,
-0.0542712621,
-0.0500178486,
0.0398332551,
0.0214444771,
-0.018906733,
-0.0105346963,
-0.0255865343,
0.017795898,
-0.0216466021,
0.0626237988,
-0.0322632641,
-0.0101680644,
-0.0229071602,
0.0552290678,
-0.0115661649,
-0.0412101895,
0.0411571078,
-0.0830786899,
0.0223781876,
-0.0153455297,
-0.0773551315,
-0.0449529663,
-0.0168842487,
-0.037616659,
-0.0248512328,
-0.0291431304,
0.0303575676,
-0.0488353781,
-0.003739319,
0.0378135517,
-0.0000479955,
0.0180367995,
0.0043343948,
-0.026248876,
0.0177736245,
0.0998967066,
0.0235998891,
-0.0141961398,
-0.0143006044,
-0.0428503342,
0.0459030755,
0.0282709356,
-0.0081575261,
0.0268555209,
-0.0371246748,
0.0073284316,
0.0155074159,
0.0529161394,
0.0185855255,
0.0060496964,
0.024293568,
0.0562150553,
0.0168183725,
-0.0242831055,
-0.0417833962,
-0.0203012805,
0.0524772331,
0.0383337364,
-0.0306538176,
-0.0288155135,
-0.0426820479,
-0.011093677,
-0.0346680433,
-0.0658655614,
-0.0099879503,
-0.0486396179,
-0.0479379706,
-0.0301476382,
-0.0934262872,
-0.0745185092,
0.0058077495,
0.0389012657,
0.0102323145,
-0.0369750187,
0.0279336497,
0.0694142282,
-0.0444720387,
-0.0299675576,
-0.0246974677,
-0.0314778201,
-0.0350111127,
-0.044272542,
0.0168506838,
-0.0574731417,
0.0025242809,
-0.0081772106,
0.0208471436,
-0.0256650709,
0.0533204675,
0.1044336557,
0.0239954572,
0.0563662238,
0.0225913618,
0.0114264637,
0.0309121832,
0.0523280129,
-0.0377233289,
0.02515723,
0.028069837,
0.0363658667,
0.0288779531,
0.0155112753,
-0.0847720653,
-0.0077208048,
-0.0309868623,
0.0157406274,
-0.0408966839,
0.0446482785,
0.0121328617,
-0.0416099206,
0.0216964968,
-0.0052311965,
-0.0353323072,
-0.0032367613,
0.0329380184,
-0.0266123433,
0.025097603,
-0.0571319573,
0.0203011744,
-0.0011166484,
0.031667646,
0.0324312076,
0.0309396517,
0.0335121043,
0.0270788912,
-0.0073213922,
0.0019622121,
0.0488854013,
0.0477403216,
-0.0255617537,
0.014280743,
0.0386851467,
0.0066351262,
0.0213912576,
0.0625336915,
0.0430278331,
0.0428946801,
0.043420881,
0.005084163,
-0.0193382334,
0.0165591575,
-0.0280492529,
-0.0458905175,
0.0203408394,
-0.0057506463,
0.0560979694,
-0.0145033216,
-0.0134183988,
-0.0571234263,
0.016396042,
0.0187538862,
-0.0212719478,
-0.0017247241,
-0.0368263088,
0.0353084914,
0.0422203243,
0.0207140055,
-0.0224134885,
0.0371447802,
0.004885002,
0.0608481169,
-0.0426625721,
0.0011230273,
-0.0470034517,
-0.0341563113,
0.0688428357,
0.01189519,
-0.0369590931,
-0.022493219,
-0.0442880392,
-0.0114518944,
-0.0537733883,
0.074045673,
-0.0104651507,
0.0141251329,
0.0557965189,
0.0004519626,
0.0164428055,
-0.0653618723,
-0.0299695227,
-0.033906389,
-0.0674632043,
-0.0120941233,
0.0038078281,
-5.44487918e-33,
-0.0377246998,
-0.0278907046,
0.0406422764,
0.0328446068,
0.0068399995,
-0.0034995407,
-0.021389138,
-0.0119178994,
0.0030586731,
0.0288770013,
0.0018366671,
-0.0039782687,
0.0048189354,
-0.0303261299,
0.0350292102,
-0.0444373861,
0.0089061866,
-0.0334104635,
-0.0359274596,
-0.0014810686,
0.0093580876,
0.0240913127,
0.0200369805,
-0.0688267723,
0.021137828,
0.0141721852,
-0.0036734664,
-0.0017871179,
-0.0216113329,
0.0318022333,
0.0037921995,
-0.0359886885,
0.0057188002,
-0.0235799942,
0.0071583572,
0.0335185118,
-0.1082807481,
-0.0368561782,
0.0022789347,
-0.0122865038,
-0.0558866933,
-0.0372612253,
0.0259230733,
0.0169094764,
-0.0109363925,
-0.0091423467,
0.0622003525,
0.0014382263,
0.0224645492,
-0.0034933852,
-0.0617401898,
-0.0244215932,
-0.0058039608,
-0.0432381704,
0.0586484037,
0.0549805723,
0.01398033,
0.0076535805,
-0.0001825527,
0.0234758221,
0.0030960876,
-0.0083777728,
0.0233477615,
0.0330276787,
0.062724553,
0.0462869927,
0.0153207835,
-0.0032886879,
-0.0092073251,
0.0346511938,
0.0232057944,
0.019184256,
-0.0349503569,
0.010373082,
0.0513007902,
0.034230303,
-0.0438565649,
0.0661316812,
0.003495578,
0.0942556337,
-0.0242847372,
0.0024781728,
-0.0663838461,
0.0308278371,
0.0096888533,
0.0454048887,
0.0191394389,
-0.0640314445,
0.0357271433,
0.0256310888,
-0.0182898603,
-0.0562191457,
-0.0156171471,
-0.0228630677,
-0.0051842486,
-0.0171620753,
-0.0101427585,
0.0150043126,
-0.0249408539,
-0.0323706567,
-0.0771833584,
-0.0471686311,
0.0054587252,
-0.0213529989,
0.0358074866,
0.0275603794,
-0.028856881,
0.0642187446,
-0.0000743787,
-0.0043447251,
-0.0213657301,
0.0344300717,
0.0311416294,
-0.0444031321,
0.0149442153,
-0.000892145,
-0.006719742,
0.0516395867,
-0.0355055444,
-0.0520671979,
-0.0190165956,
-0.0097233048,
-0.0209925678,
0.0052325842,
-0.0258460157,
-0.034763813,
-0.035884317,
0.0595840774,
-0.031187728,
-0.0338474922,
-0.0071234684,
0.0039325277,
2.763e-7,
-0.0512454323,
0.0409289189,
0.0391143113,
0.0206077937,
-0.0047465307,
0.0538432598,
-0.0272894688,
0.0163453985,
-0.0078468425,
-0.0130620711,
0.0385457613,
0.04926496,
0.0010775393,
-0.0153288059,
-0.1110074967,
-0.0529676974,
0.0131902266,
-0.0098339254,
-0.0408588126,
-0.0174126104,
0.0367148444,
0.0110484641,
0.0069422736,
-0.0054916348,
0.0526660793,
0.0139599778,
0.008650736,
-0.0436031595,
0.0415337868,
-0.0023903134,
0.0159112699,
0.0106923543,
-0.0412590578,
-0.0217254274,
-0.0073123658,
0.0146765877,
-0.034418378,
0.0616929159,
0.0013423207,
-0.0478890501,
-0.0064039472,
0.0215147808,
0.0218712017,
0.0179941319,
0.0254917834,
-0.0151587045,
0.0093794279,
0.0391032808,
-0.0135396151,
-0.0073135784,
-0.086819388,
-0.0088487687,
-0.0013589654,
-0.0288978778,
-0.0488204323,
-0.0116258664,
-0.0026758339,
-0.0626943111,
0.002877929,
0.0176229775,
0.0041930596,
-0.0279261209,
-0.0426593684,
0.0257973596,
-0.0300542619,
-0.068644844,
-0.0138306227,
1.942829972e-34,
-0.0292050932,
-0.0464120023,
-0.0080435453,
0.0477454774,
0.0226470549,
0.0355384834,
0.0014264981,
0.0357363261,
0.0525029264,
-0.0052608927,
-0.0164473299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04443v1 | Enhancing E-Commerce Recommendation using Pre-Trained Language Model and Fine-Tuning | 2023-02-09T05:20:52 | 2023-02-09T05:20:52 | Nuofan Xu, Chenhui Hu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | Pretrained Language Models (PLM) have been greatly successful on a board
range of natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, it has just started
being applied to the domain of recommendation systems. Traditional
recommendation algorithms failed to incorporate the rich textual information in
e-commerce datasets, which hinderss the performance of those models. We present
a thorough investigation on the effect of various strategy of incorporating
PLMs into traditional recommender algorithms on one of the e-commerce datasets,
and we compare the results with vanilla recommender baseline models. We show
that the application of PLMs and domain specific fine-tuning lead to an
increase on the predictive capability of combined models. These results
accentuate the importance of utilizing textual information in the context of
e-commerce, and provides insight on how to better apply PLMs alongside
traditional recommender system algorithms. The code used in this paper is
available on Github: https://github.com/NuofanXu/bert_retail_recommender. | [
0.0739722028,
-0.0015278867,
-0.0253678579,
0.0167622026,
-0.0012678684,
-0.0151648214,
0.0330819748,
0.004820128,
0.0182310641,
-0.0882785693,
-0.0923382714,
0.0071689347,
0.0029097076,
0.0651058406,
-0.0218285415,
-0.021883769,
-0.0028940588,
-0.0140899895,
0.0226722527,
0.0107302414,
0.032840021,
0.038735386,
0.0379688628,
0.0049536405,
0.0693403035,
0.01602244,
0.0164014362,
-0.018506024,
-0.0060357465,
0.0002748893,
0.0646700785,
0.0055954852,
0.0265737493,
-0.0417057797,
0.0000019281,
-0.0507816561,
-0.0234500859,
-0.0473515131,
0.0018386135,
0.0172320735,
0.0175969526,
0.0649290532,
0.0520464256,
0.0310327858,
-0.0550874285,
0.0301579405,
0.0185962226,
0.0929976776,
0.0171618015,
0.0746009126,
-0.022188874,
-0.0380921513,
0.0088625839,
-0.0187976714,
0.0106716156,
-0.0263364986,
0.037921153,
-0.0284835994,
0.0118154092,
0.0221011154,
0.0012205718,
-0.037324857,
-0.0363056026,
0.0191289447,
0.0334059857,
0.0217620172,
-0.013759207,
-0.003521296,
-0.0286313668,
0.100498572,
-0.0200938042,
-0.0276714228,
-0.0221653059,
-0.0017977603,
-0.0322818533,
-0.0268050209,
0.0166889671,
-0.019513417,
0.0134810805,
0.038349025,
-0.005792845,
0.0307277478,
0.0398147888,
0.0389806256,
-0.0068102418,
0.0739192069,
0.0043463269,
-0.0480447151,
0.0055263592,
0.0119133005,
-0.0105272746,
-0.0209130105,
0.0286582541,
-0.004893098,
-0.0295412727,
-0.0044972575,
-0.0209526196,
0.0599906109,
-0.0087961731,
-0.0513701029,
0.0407639407,
0.0156203676,
-0.0143737411,
0.0515194908,
-0.0136283785,
-0.0031969594,
0.0440203622,
-0.0009303005,
-0.0506094918,
0.0246057697,
-0.0146137848,
-0.0126273911,
-0.0232726932,
0.032473769,
-0.0222295299,
-0.0401960537,
-0.0451152958,
0.0196671765,
0.0314482227,
-0.0242098868,
0.0208545867,
0.0084281489,
0.0154413497,
-0.0027100444,
-0.0759025887,
-0.0056673074,
-0.0524469912,
0.0532764122,
-0.0350802578,
-0.015648229,
0.0442054309,
0.0213779155,
0.0171976183,
-0.0500119366,
0.0360934772,
-0.001205707,
0.0498317219,
-0.0666453317,
-0.0867715776,
-0.0009162194,
-0.0083207628,
-0.0552140735,
-0.0335923694,
-0.0380153582,
0.043157611,
0.0443969928,
0.0023004792,
-0.016687898,
0.0158456601,
-0.0214427579,
-0.0284296572,
0.0857251436,
-0.029867921,
-0.0268311091,
0.0034588496,
-0.0283164587,
0.0500888415,
0.0067815878,
-0.0067904894,
0.0592515096,
0.0760218501,
0.0001393288,
0.0204205234,
0.0229461584,
-0.0444355942,
-0.0370476954,
-0.0141000049,
0.0480622798,
-0.0436445214,
-0.016855998,
0.035091877,
0.0141136423,
-0.0358859301,
0.0227131564,
0.0641786233,
0.0155780027,
0.0411598869,
0.0570602529,
0.0356590301,
0.0421508849,
0.0050665806,
-0.0362583883,
0.0230081528,
-0.0298952386,
-0.0698973313,
-0.0130010853,
0.0427237041,
0.0338656902,
-0.0398768,
-0.047999993,
0.0270893872,
-0.0656692907,
0.037044581,
0.0378546752,
0.0364028141,
-0.010167934,
-0.0538266189,
0.0101460591,
0.0527053215,
-0.0286778416,
-0.0103857433,
-0.0110934107,
0.0308415983,
0.1366562545,
0.0333994068,
-0.0320753418,
0.0211942885,
-0.0357732661,
-0.0008561551,
-0.0224168729,
0.0598294772,
-0.0026727729,
0.0231981725,
-0.0635798797,
-0.0570909046,
0.0012927424,
-0.00866793,
0.0243106801,
0.0242576953,
-0.0046052337,
0.024611637,
0.0073827282,
-0.0017982015,
0.0070077507,
0.0033565327,
-0.013557137,
0.0351918563,
0.0042155166,
0.0009841246,
-0.0053890361,
-0.0004206557,
-0.0108940545,
0.0012244948,
-0.0002535068,
-0.0152636617,
-0.0111581935,
0.0049262387,
-0.0073177842,
0.0468723439,
-0.0084325066,
0.0387081578,
0.0196067039,
0.0113331741,
-0.0023585504,
-0.0301652886,
0.0015723172,
0.0620588884,
-0.0226858538,
0.0266439766,
-0.0370184071,
0.0348716564,
-0.0290608872,
0.043123275,
0.0450389832,
0.0360191092,
-0.0104929684,
0.0018153146,
-0.0149138207,
0.0021015392,
-0.0472839214,
-0.011806231,
0.0231051184,
0.0411149673,
0.0508424155,
0.0065342369,
-0.0207284708,
-0.0132693285,
-0.0577098578,
-0.0072820168,
0.0215945989,
0.0018419564,
-0.0239071827,
0.0231126212,
-0.0325190425,
-0.0118156597,
-0.0007452391,
0.0209142081,
-0.0337203816,
0.0115432572,
0.0349706374,
0.0148432106,
0.0023614408,
-0.0437173955,
-0.0138482163,
0.0175529234,
0.0210318323,
0.0044612763,
-0.0264067296,
-0.0372476727,
0.0169901177,
-0.0184221175,
-0.0147222904,
-0.0162210055,
-0.0006231487,
-0.063794896,
-0.0245865453,
0.040923588,
-0.0186465718,
-0.0021356437,
-0.0096544055,
0.0404363982,
-0.0224238951,
-0.0452876799,
0.0027716064,
-0.0400308371,
-0.0006953586,
-0.0327556841,
0.0288283937,
0.0186221153,
0.0347643532,
-0.0489318706,
-0.0175740849,
-0.0320107117,
-0.0178582519,
0.0280593,
0.0115076667,
-0.0383368097,
-0.005832071,
-0.0077179032,
0.0498916954,
0.0065523149,
-0.065900363,
0.0468789414,
-0.0156838875,
0.007846511,
-0.0518485643,
-0.0322150439,
-0.0605815835,
-0.0252013858,
0.009657531,
0.0107401302,
-0.0206307974,
-0.0363307633,
0.008533326,
0.0272366349,
0.0176236797,
-0.0328741781,
0.0171704646,
0.0246866681,
0.0056688017,
0.0129438918,
-0.0402126051,
-0.0428736508,
-0.0889768675,
-0.0313947313,
-0.0151442531,
0.0388876349,
0.0082210451,
-0.0791832805,
0.0211657118,
-0.0335484855,
0.0222803652,
0.0017633939,
-0.0496973358,
0.0241916254,
-0.0244389605,
0.046574939,
-0.0525088832,
-0.0067107477,
-0.0065010255,
-0.0055731684,
-0.0221976303,
-0.0595700741,
-0.0461515523,
-0.0339998528,
0.0107909692,
0.06388399,
-0.0549800359,
-0.0173097551,
0.0786781386,
-0.0307851676,
0.0124678789,
0.0175805818,
0.1212161258,
0.0231954474,
-0.0645847246,
-0.0220030043,
0.0169334337,
-0.0092294486,
0.0437598117,
0.0337383971,
-0.0335162841,
-0.0254896414,
-0.0157630555,
0.0146899009,
0.0373382568,
-0.0032346046,
-0.0143070929,
-0.0900261998,
-0.0293475278,
-0.0017613331,
0.0174205396,
-0.013449572,
-0.044002872,
-0.0334643275,
-0.0183688086,
0.0424649231,
-0.0286043566,
-0.0301290788,
0.0166071616,
-0.0000379054,
-0.0580316745,
-0.0612207726,
0.047886461,
-0.0330364965,
0.008547157,
0.0669425651,
0.0117609752,
-0.0265517645,
0.0216378346,
0.0277794562,
-0.0209415536,
-0.0041370667,
0.0019774539,
0.0364376679,
-0.047222238,
0.0245239921,
0.0060660662,
-0.0298434347,
-0.0245197769,
-0.0015747705,
0.0132909706,
0.0011416896,
-0.0006854147,
-0.0009183788,
0.00295664,
0.0190120284,
-0.0320081972,
0.0636793151,
-0.0077121006,
-0.0584111325,
-0.0033645327,
-0.0500807427,
-0.0382836238,
0.0156889185,
-0.0366135761,
0.0045200353,
0.0110193901,
0.0071948534,
-0.0618303604,
-0.0298115034,
0.0452644974,
0.000943867,
0.0368024893,
0.0468901172,
-0.0275464188,
0.007461464,
0.0041009132,
0.0435319655,
-0.0316717178,
0.0402393788,
-0.0783756077,
0.0235893782,
0.0382780321,
-0.083428368,
0.0004125005,
-0.02129554,
-0.0175187159,
-0.0467615649,
-0.0302489791,
0.0683683902,
0.0146183958,
0.0398281701,
-0.0521597378,
-0.0954243243,
0.0176814497,
0.0539268553,
-0.0499367565,
-0.0488713868,
0.0201893654,
0.0206721239,
0.0164354891,
0.0156856775,
-0.0463151261,
0.0053123613,
0.0110809626,
0.0130849052,
0.0359525494,
-0.061809089,
0.0344784819,
-0.001362437,
0.0757734329,
-0.0204602573,
0.038290143,
-0.026789248,
0.0350014456,
-0.0117077604,
-0.0483469516,
-0.0462014601,
-0.0354479589,
0.0612268001,
0.0032390943,
-0.0279810764,
0.0123414798,
-0.0435307994,
0.0052513471,
-0.0223930441,
0.0262129698,
0.0142256794,
-0.0104721868,
0.008606418,
-0.0022452751,
0.0208714698,
-0.0013031523,
0.040792115,
-0.0025565783,
-0.0211740509,
0.0233998597,
-0.0046118088,
-0.0177009944,
-0.0452229567,
0.0430404842,
0.0082530975,
-0.0340024121,
-0.0408139974,
0.009260132,
0.0296122897,
-0.0677557737,
-0.00266991,
-0.0185727775,
-0.0135208135,
-0.0438200608,
0.0331084654,
-0.008800528,
0.0053111454,
0.0352317169,
0.021908978,
-0.0568865798,
0.04038072,
0.0684542432,
-0.0042738877,
-0.0020744728,
0.0350850374,
-0.05446079,
-0.0314409882,
0.002930322,
0.0146581838,
0.0588529482,
-0.0580479689,
0.0019305426,
0.0051031974,
-0.0191218629,
-0.0002128799,
-0.0491634719,
0.0234280583,
0.0068492354,
0.0527408496,
0.0747351572,
0.004700941,
0.0464085303,
-0.0607450977,
-0.0092997793,
0.0370038263,
0.0021718887,
-0.030648293,
-5.869759042e-33,
0.0338940471,
-0.0089056334,
-0.0050326912,
0.0317006484,
0.0135104265,
-0.004251603,
0.0108404215,
0.0064513325,
0.0264123548,
-0.0112285428,
-0.0087808874,
-0.0017126838,
0.0193127673,
0.0167668816,
-0.0100028515,
-0.0382523835,
0.0341130346,
0.0470633321,
-0.0463664532,
0.0081284018,
-0.0155699151,
0.0681175292,
0.055041682,
-0.0289041568,
0.0132318707,
-0.0429568999,
-0.0266841035,
-0.0004165504,
0.0535172336,
0.0996802971,
-0.0165376533,
0.0425750129,
0.006001906,
-0.0051966915,
-0.0070833876,
0.0195235703,
-0.0634454265,
0.0117101595,
0.046579551,
0.0230715405,
0.0047138692,
0.0243936069,
0.0130767291,
-0.0295706186,
0.0162461102,
0.0384999849,
0.0443172231,
-0.054156214,
-0.0472635254,
-0.0662947893,
-0.0338280872,
0.02432728,
-0.0203233119,
-0.0118489256,
0.0596769266,
0.0780316591,
-0.0232955925,
0.0785203353,
-0.005280639,
0.0619813912,
0.0092030838,
0.0059007318,
-0.0026311148,
-0.0319990665,
-0.0444664396,
0.0393035598,
-0.0010306784,
-0.0153056066,
0.0194577612,
0.0208861548,
-0.0008864405,
0.0539835095,
-0.0123258624,
0.0270673241,
0.0072123925,
0.0020963682,
-0.0394403413,
0.0524058752,
0.0149271172,
-0.0372675359,
0.0283942185,
0.0028215519,
-0.0539723933,
-0.0586475208,
-0.0012288211,
-0.0036500762,
-0.0605829954,
-0.0255236477,
0.0150851738,
0.0290927235,
-0.0087381555,
0.0217841342,
0.010755837,
-0.0914077461,
-0.0771512091,
0.0085823853,
-0.0303546526,
-0.0302434545,
0.0225770492,
0.0095043676,
-0.0497598462,
-0.0459938832,
0.0061922292,
-0.0607685111,
-0.0352347903,
-0.0307804998,
0.0546310693,
0.0152637651,
-0.0521291606,
0.0080602672,
0.0500586107,
-0.0540879481,
0.0070144082,
0.0633827671,
0.038463451,
0.0302103255,
-0.0420953631,
0.074822031,
0.0301306453,
0.0007046316,
-0.031304054,
-0.0706740394,
0.0400430672,
0.0278579593,
-0.0144006424,
-0.03837502,
-0.023885496,
0.0149163762,
0.0297584999,
-0.0587255172,
-0.0424662754,
-0.0183822233,
2.589e-7,
0.0566287972,
0.0714263096,
-0.0492193624,
-0.0265811291,
-0.0079963328,
0.0311888345,
0.0207609199,
0.0331589989,
0.0233446397,
0.046918679,
0.0508176684,
-0.0181572884,
0.0315789096,
-0.0304490793,
-0.0318359993,
0.00690623,
-0.0433041118,
0.005005613,
-0.0703864619,
-0.0148111433,
0.0131667815,
0.1120870635,
0.0473217741,
-0.0219402499,
-0.0305370092,
-0.0399345346,
0.0491325893,
-0.0877552256,
-0.0173771139,
0.0295339972,
0.0288177263,
0.0631992221,
-0.064003557,
-0.0081432024,
-0.0331956036,
0.0711209327,
0.0185556076,
0.0519623421,
0.0124609061,
0.0002197012,
0.0080547715,
-0.0001289346,
-0.0062265992,
-0.0406166874,
0.090919666,
-0.0230953861,
-0.0240086298,
0.0012275376,
-0.0224270727,
-0.0347532667,
0.0494616292,
-0.0533142425,
-0.0339284129,
0.013849074,
0.027757084,
-0.0191448163,
-0.0425723121,
-0.0619202144,
-0.0009564038,
-0.0020578762,
0.0034641777,
-0.0068074074,
-0.0015594498,
0.0405426919,
0.0400012583,
-0.0464390181,
0.0806457251,
2.211155613e-34,
0.0569372773,
0.0029477058,
-0.0028820066,
0.0159436334,
0.0357957892,
0.0020089052,
0.0088482117,
0.0065943981,
0.0221199133,
-0.0834891424,
-0.0037279464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04434v1 | Real-Time Visual Feedback to Guide Benchmark Creation: A Human-and-Metric-in-the-Loop Workflow | 2023-02-09T04:43:10 | 2023-02-09T04:43:10 | Anjana Arunkumar, Swaroop Mishra, Bhavdeep Sachdeva, Chitta Baral, Chris Bryan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Recent research has shown that language models exploit `artifacts' in
benchmarks to solve tasks, rather than truly learning them, leading to inflated
model performance. In pursuit of creating better benchmarks, we propose VAIDA,
a novel benchmark creation paradigm for NLP, that focuses on guiding
crowdworkers, an under-explored facet of addressing benchmark idiosyncrasies.
VAIDA facilitates sample correction by providing realtime visual feedback and
recommendations to improve sample quality. Our approach is domain, model, task,
and metric agnostic, and constitutes a paradigm shift for robust, validated,
and dynamic benchmark creation via human-and-metric-in-the-loop workflows. We
evaluate via expert review and a user study with NASA TLX. We find that VAIDA
decreases effort, frustration, mental, and temporal demands of crowdworkers and
analysts, simultaneously increasing the performance of both user groups with a
45.8% decrease in the level of artifacts in created samples. As a by product of
our user study, we observe that created samples are adversarial across models,
leading to decreases of 31.3% (BERT), 22.5% (RoBERTa), 14.98% (GPT-3 fewshot)
in performance. | [
0.0385427922,
0.0932591781,
-0.0294245947,
0.0170940161,
-0.0501506217,
-0.0117952684,
-0.0151777091,
0.0416857749,
-0.0346130766,
-0.0491758585,
-0.0129953576,
-0.0166690443,
0.0081364736,
0.0187682323,
0.0588031895,
-0.0783110261,
0.0235177539,
-0.0059868204,
0.0122719957,
0.0145206135,
0.0251147263,
-0.0243617482,
-0.0184733626,
0.039514076,
-0.0430988558,
0.0098949652,
0.0126747238,
0.0030563534,
0.0001773184,
-0.051980488,
0.0035786661,
0.0876685157,
-0.0200379379,
0.0554822832,
0.0000020805,
-0.0355236568,
0.0167339016,
0.0238407459,
-0.0292372089,
0.041961316,
0.0504153483,
-0.0086503113,
0.0034998585,
0.0179125294,
-0.0363711976,
-0.0091153271,
0.0325846933,
0.0022951472,
0.0405253842,
0.0483031385,
-0.0197974779,
0.0644195452,
-0.0174278803,
-0.0316657014,
-0.0321061388,
-0.0288000535,
-0.0082500288,
0.010359793,
0.0349136516,
-0.0255397055,
0.0016100002,
0.0395309515,
0.0303390007,
0.0069891941,
0.0289002322,
0.0237847883,
-0.0583494157,
-0.0205942132,
-0.0316848382,
0.0817381218,
-0.0298749376,
-0.0199635979,
-0.0124613093,
-0.025980955,
0.0003856349,
0.0133706518,
-0.0391516313,
-0.0029971646,
-0.0035045084,
-0.0005330416,
-0.0704449713,
-0.0143870395,
0.0280243121,
0.0144100012,
0.0434922241,
0.0157818291,
0.0183435362,
-0.0133875627,
0.0150938267,
0.0558991618,
-0.0070283739,
-0.0565369539,
0.0258943029,
-0.0006106049,
-0.0596932285,
-0.0116657075,
-0.0319143347,
-0.0975338966,
0.0313848257,
-0.0453869589,
0.0909437463,
0.0280530415,
-0.0232583135,
0.0383435674,
-0.016086936,
0.0469284989,
0.0178211145,
0.0364018567,
-0.0075174486,
0.0155905997,
-0.0574237406,
0.0026009877,
-0.0432806686,
-0.0090190191,
-0.0395260118,
0.0036351765,
-0.0310370233,
-0.0078828102,
-0.0621571019,
0.0351115987,
-0.0137846703,
0.0175579116,
-0.024099445,
0.0165465642,
-0.038176477,
0.0174608864,
-0.0765400007,
-0.002063107,
-0.0000413054,
-0.0831870064,
-0.0114809461,
0.0216610599,
-0.0378937647,
-0.0077168932,
0.0023365647,
0.0776321217,
-0.004859854,
-0.0276732128,
-0.0102347517,
-0.0422383621,
0.0010992356,
-0.0376030467,
0.0140503319,
-0.048451636,
0.022671463,
-0.0066601788,
-0.0005920317,
-0.0163428094,
-0.0111326622,
0.0179349259,
0.0127421226,
0.0896100029,
-0.0091219991,
-0.0031306955,
-0.0169056784,
0.0094422018,
-0.0231168084,
0.0862895399,
0.0355321355,
0.0025050826,
0.045387622,
-0.0014062701,
0.0251047965,
0.065936923,
0.0229668468,
0.0108682932,
-0.0609723888,
0.0104873972,
-0.0091302516,
0.0676953718,
0.0245516226,
0.0634531155,
-0.0307447314,
0.0066083032,
0.0623637512,
0.0259903688,
-0.0303975902,
-0.0183023717,
-0.0011756485,
-0.020825278,
0.0173098482,
-0.0035723536,
-0.0184383933,
0.0222630594,
-0.0117539195,
-0.0095204627,
0.0056552519,
0.028680075,
-0.0118299611,
-0.0194417648,
-0.0601761043,
0.0320248865,
-0.0033218793,
-0.0045008552,
0.0353388824,
0.0284236651,
-0.0239199102,
0.0073469547,
0.009026452,
-0.0461553931,
0.0019505848,
-0.0202322379,
-0.0056281951,
0.0398491621,
0.080296278,
-0.0148080718,
0.0160959587,
-0.010843561,
-0.0068176053,
0.0393625312,
0.0943827182,
-0.0301522128,
-0.0324546359,
-0.010549047,
-0.0400568619,
0.0093062045,
0.007965982,
0.0117469886,
0.0730942264,
0.0093827145,
0.0068836068,
-0.0914273113,
-0.0661345795,
0.0487839729,
-0.0119629391,
-0.0189635754,
0.0189954638,
0.0034205252,
0.0122402813,
0.0187176,
-0.0146696847,
0.0198405106,
0.0221104138,
-0.0119127352,
-0.003196286,
0.0194817018,
0.0096321069,
-0.0034104234,
0.0399427786,
-0.0732722282,
-0.0560084879,
0.0944119841,
-0.0289674215,
-0.0063998494,
-0.0104176132,
-0.0197288264,
-0.0080878567,
-0.0213928502,
0.005975307,
-0.0095745604,
0.0049735117,
-0.0409732088,
0.0382790491,
0.0009413444,
0.0098876432,
-0.0161375906,
0.0227173995,
0.0173596907,
-0.0219927747,
-0.0179942995,
0.0368258469,
0.0162633825,
0.027324127,
0.0177434981,
-0.0145523064,
-0.0893970877,
0.0019361472,
-0.0708272904,
-0.0012575925,
-0.0198046174,
0.0089420164,
0.020011263,
-0.0280780345,
-0.0083134687,
-0.0210984852,
-0.0169655252,
-0.0211988706,
0.0044281427,
0.0479411408,
0.0497120135,
0.0065570609,
0.0266346354,
-0.0469121784,
-0.0206920411,
-0.0270612836,
0.039055448,
0.0469164997,
-0.0143835787,
-0.0372308604,
-0.0017568619,
0.0143817049,
0.0210358109,
0.0055699055,
-0.007820826,
0.0485685766,
0.0187618285,
0.0541412048,
0.0467063263,
-0.0034410239,
0.0495366864,
0.0405191593,
0.0063055675,
-0.0443718396,
-0.0039044439,
0.013049786,
-0.0081452578,
0.0216329508,
-0.0049256012,
0.0350376479,
0.0132041844,
-0.0344614163,
0.0011485197,
-0.0612788536,
0.0469297431,
-0.0712276399,
-0.0301429126,
-0.0566381887,
-0.029939888,
-0.0406611189,
0.0243409164,
-0.0306687765,
-0.0433717184,
0.0595056154,
-0.0168148335,
0.0014172716,
-0.0286147986,
0.0107038179,
-0.0159926843,
0.0397406742,
-0.0008054692,
-0.0142530352,
-0.0089176828,
0.0058383164,
-0.0343115702,
0.0121383052,
0.0325844586,
-0.0389075167,
-0.0068428298,
-0.0688521713,
0.0118783778,
-0.0164527018,
-0.0551460944,
-0.0488745533,
-0.0151481917,
-0.0524233654,
0.02492816,
0.0349879079,
-0.0357761197,
-0.0114146732,
0.0009904037,
-0.0032943801,
0.0219053701,
-0.0123555595,
-0.0277671795,
-0.0003729639,
0.0214735959,
0.0322566144,
0.0204958692,
0.0221979227,
-0.0582325421,
-0.0150398025,
0.0598828159,
0.1033519432,
0.0074201562,
-0.0658914074,
0.007435035,
0.0080438042,
-0.0101431962,
0.010661995,
0.0121835703,
0.0375275873,
-0.0402687266,
0.0209061075,
0.0708122998,
0.0207852162,
-0.0350083001,
0.0229874309,
0.0043254672,
0.0571172237,
0.0341852605,
0.0377082936,
-0.097712934,
-0.0289980005,
0.0179572478,
0.0565294065,
-0.013216353,
-0.0275078658,
-0.0125112468,
-0.1395007372,
0.0368783697,
-0.0200310163,
-0.0244625211,
0.0462712869,
-0.0402974673,
0.0081484597,
-0.0333058611,
0.0323978998,
0.0075677824,
0.0151862372,
0.0274282005,
0.0412358642,
-0.0093709556,
-0.0806116611,
0.0318109542,
-0.0817714706,
0.042023547,
0.047213804,
0.0237304959,
-0.0026871525,
-0.0390078276,
0.0303023383,
0.0462558605,
0.0302006751,
-0.0079254005,
0.1085527167,
0.0095548285,
-0.0329707041,
-0.000589614,
0.0097775161,
-0.0389992744,
0.0043202164,
-0.0271930583,
0.0427480303,
0.0442316122,
-0.0304259043,
-0.0426274315,
-0.0272754431,
0.0058704326,
0.0721221194,
0.0256133173,
-0.039891459,
-0.0476217195,
-0.0006752991,
0.0181254745,
-0.0897558331,
-0.0507537462,
0.0062271925,
0.000087337,
-0.0232439972,
-0.0812457055,
-0.0778397173,
0.0712346211,
0.0786387995,
0.0292576849,
-0.0190194454,
-0.0228247624,
-0.0024298739,
-0.040774703,
0.075046964,
-0.0164360758,
0.0589926615,
-0.0719434246,
-0.0177877937,
-0.0014083211,
0.0500961505,
-0.0096597364,
0.0602308623,
-0.1203359887,
-0.0601639263,
0.0073707108,
0.0424825624,
0.0240192208,
0.0129412906,
-0.0128667783,
-0.0888299346,
0.0079640131,
0.0546558499,
-0.0099167116,
0.0119549967,
-0.0092171179,
-0.0407848656,
-0.0139103178,
0.0022333709,
-0.0243040994,
-0.0307529382,
0.0144072408,
0.040558137,
-0.0086517734,
-0.0225650258,
0.0418187939,
0.0489934795,
0.0670266896,
-0.0401733257,
-0.0247676242,
0.0026008079,
-0.029956568,
-0.0108108195,
-0.0185707659,
-0.0367147215,
-0.0081162537,
-0.0193890203,
-0.0045687337,
-0.0092328023,
0.0663594753,
-0.0081156176,
0.0161174312,
-0.0575708933,
-0.0072076088,
0.0169876702,
0.0271130968,
0.0145669179,
0.021408692,
0.0110668447,
-0.0269771051,
-0.0115266535,
0.0612441301,
-0.0112117203,
-0.0027249705,
0.053858187,
0.0063857222,
0.0171710253,
0.025172675,
-0.0523874871,
-0.0399740674,
-0.0285327975,
0.0156218782,
0.0286062304,
-0.015864905,
0.0287260078,
-0.0444131158,
-0.0212830976,
-0.0006111395,
-0.0330482796,
-0.0353130363,
0.0046544243,
0.0313447751,
0.0188254453,
-0.0023197718,
-0.0031125154,
0.0657705963,
0.0134174554,
0.0539884977,
-0.0290896259,
0.0032890995,
-0.0579001233,
0.0032704156,
0.013102171,
-0.0320827961,
-0.0049266196,
-0.0242932104,
-0.0732221454,
-0.071147576,
0.0053488426,
0.0388656594,
0.0170717314,
0.0059351437,
0.0429835953,
0.0463877767,
-0.021470977,
-0.0220821016,
-0.008774369,
-0.0022142711,
0.0050387764,
-0.0295014232,
-0.0314955637,
-6.802835601e-33,
-0.0064122551,
-0.0572713502,
0.03097458,
-0.0600480698,
0.0091550769,
0.003730857,
-0.0194432717,
0.0304314885,
0.0026970869,
0.034486495,
-0.0265938155,
0.0073797079,
0.0121252369,
-0.0276643205,
0.0115554146,
-0.0046613556,
0.0929287001,
-0.0306300316,
-0.0567089617,
-0.0287915599,
-0.0174668394,
0.0134961726,
0.027009137,
-0.0698251948,
0.0165310223,
0.0432443246,
-0.0480082445,
0.0109295072,
0.0167359728,
0.038169384,
0.0033729423,
0.0431942195,
0.0011200587,
0.0020316411,
-0.0373018645,
-0.0313026085,
-0.0595210157,
-0.0234940089,
-0.0035252995,
0.0454440713,
-0.0657821596,
0.0231105238,
0.0549425147,
-0.010823383,
-0.03497345,
0.0233320054,
0.0290819574,
-0.0054067937,
-0.0454407707,
0.0101625947,
-0.0459881015,
0.0213369243,
-0.0187231917,
-0.005642056,
0.0327359885,
0.0403698646,
-0.0057919668,
-0.0076142438,
-0.0692265183,
0.0138842901,
0.0343279764,
0.0131133469,
0.0669404045,
0.0207726415,
0.0044891257,
0.0663288757,
0.0166785438,
0.0190671515,
0.02883837,
-0.0330092236,
0.0563696735,
0.0312920734,
0.0878873244,
0.0823236927,
0.0660548508,
-0.0217278656,
0.0024307643,
0.0586051084,
-0.0144570423,
0.0066936021,
-0.0087921927,
0.0290430114,
-0.0779175609,
-0.0125195934,
-0.0341762379,
-0.0333049037,
-0.0487745255,
-0.0021962323,
0.0561905168,
0.031878341,
-0.0248577725,
0.0098401792,
-0.0163000766,
-0.0222908966,
-0.0011242026,
-0.0230270866,
-0.0249804296,
0.0511865504,
0.0168926734,
-0.0234888885,
-0.0258231517,
0.0239327904,
0.0026004286,
0.0816730633,
0.0553322844,
-0.0147296721,
0.0391348302,
0.013678995,
-0.0702967793,
0.0299880803,
-0.0402822532,
0.0324484594,
0.0301564485,
-0.0514895767,
0.0303296074,
0.0019813238,
-0.0177186076,
0.0444734916,
0.0301053934,
-0.0274682604,
-0.054451149,
0.0418496989,
-0.0002882053,
-0.0131760715,
-0.001473592,
-0.0321019515,
-0.0020216887,
0.0110406419,
0.0779402182,
-0.0527276061,
-0.0225190651,
-0.0248846468,
2.714e-7,
0.0195492767,
0.0924725309,
0.0532993637,
0.0010828604,
-0.0159369111,
0.0365798064,
-0.0329852812,
0.0120206531,
-0.0207728259,
0.0088575715,
-0.0143445833,
-0.0074893087,
0.0668356121,
0.0600149594,
-0.0298494399,
-0.0229731984,
-0.0581258237,
0.0220235456,
-0.0529227853,
-0.0179230776,
0.0386303924,
0.0163315386,
0.019175604,
-0.0309790596,
-0.003112677,
-0.0658889487,
0.0667182654,
-0.0311487,
0.0004017625,
0.0037035174,
0.0390816368,
0.014022219,
0.0142678879,
0.0274216477,
-0.0513226949,
-0.0369096994,
0.0265835095,
0.0197312441,
-0.0021687883,
-0.0269451924,
-0.0229129083,
-0.0061844764,
0.0033312484,
-0.0286085512,
0.0341270901,
-0.0120031405,
-0.0140118096,
-0.0465767309,
-0.0058752336,
-0.0167491063,
0.0327920467,
-0.0119174933,
-0.0273460466,
0.0129407654,
0.0025501549,
0.0201144535,
-0.0519882441,
-0.0379259326,
-0.0211684145,
-0.0240024701,
-0.0266303383,
-0.0151677746,
-0.0348156095,
0.0116624879,
-0.0241067614,
-0.0261084549,
-0.0168029778,
2.524199861e-34,
0.0427029021,
0.0061849579,
0.0465236679,
0.0102815637,
0.0435798541,
0.0210595895,
-0.0315455049,
-0.0027814857,
0.0188972354,
-0.0227530003,
-0.0072975499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04424v1 | A Transformer-based Response Evaluator for Open-Domain Spoken Conversation | 2023-02-09T03:38:07 | 2023-02-09T03:38:07 | Vrindavan Harrison, Rishi Rajasekaran, Marilyn Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many open-domain dialogue systems rely on multiple response generators, any
of which can contribute a response to the dialogue in a particular context.
Thus the ability to compare potential responses and then select the best plays
an important role in ensuring a dialogue system is coherent and engaging.
Dialogue coherence goes beyond simply remaining on topic -- some trivia may be
on topic and engaging when mentioned out of the blue, but may not be coherent
and grounded in the context of the conversation. We carry out experiments on
response selection in the Athena system, an Alexa Prize SocialBot that has
dedicated content and multiple topic-specific response generators for a large
number of topics. First, we collect a corpus of Athena conversations with live
human traffic, where potential responses from all enabled response generators
are logged and subsequently annotated for response quality. We compare several
off-the-shelf response ranking methods for open-domain dialogue to
Athena-Heuristic, a heuristic response ranker that was field-tested in Athena
during the third Alexa Prize competition. We also compare these to a
transformer-based response ranker we call Athena-RR, that we train on our
Athena conversations. Athena-RR uses both the conversational context and the
dialogue state to rank the potential responses. We find that Athena-RR with a
Recall@1 of 70.79\% outperforms Athena-Heuristic and all of the off-the-shelf
rankers by a large margin. We then conduct a live A/B study comparing
Athena-Heuristic to Athena-RR in a 6,358 conversations with Alexa users. We
show that Athena-RR leads to significantly longer conversations that receive
significantly higher user ratings than the heuristic rule-based ranker. | [
0.0766718239,
0.0430303439,
-0.0064315107,
-0.019019654,
-0.013206535,
-0.0090818601,
0.011495878,
-0.0113977306,
-0.0021791433,
-0.0653547198,
-0.0204365905,
-0.040606603,
0.0011715945,
0.0508053191,
-0.0441460349,
-0.058044482,
0.0085472595,
-0.0160225369,
0.0394835882,
0.0103318999,
-0.0212243553,
0.0026249117,
-0.0283131748,
0.0677143037,
0.0093920957,
0.0018787223,
-0.0319929197,
0.0021197612,
0.0324672386,
-0.0098061608,
0.0011747512,
0.03331054,
-0.001049164,
0.0335984193,
0.0000018117,
-0.0595216453,
-0.0203300118,
-0.0146701355,
-0.0322101302,
-0.0605574585,
-0.0046442118,
0.0535477325,
-0.0074200635,
0.0744260028,
-0.0656555444,
0.0073108827,
0.039118927,
0.0444869697,
0.0660980344,
0.0649421662,
-0.0238011479,
-0.0191561505,
0.0262882747,
-0.0052718329,
-0.0272353441,
-0.0399123356,
-0.0133575555,
-0.0062875715,
0.0293452255,
0.0361295454,
-0.0110363821,
0.0044379481,
0.0200335979,
-0.0445826128,
0.0344787128,
0.0196145047,
-0.0665652603,
-0.0211673602,
-0.0292791836,
0.0952397063,
0.0570031814,
0.0262459256,
0.0235718712,
0.0207331795,
0.0198458228,
-0.017930001,
-0.0456646942,
-0.0012877973,
-0.0022658322,
-0.0061265063,
-0.038080994,
0.0466590486,
-0.0569120236,
0.0117218746,
-0.0340440087,
0.049148865,
0.0075301738,
-0.0117016789,
-0.020955842,
0.0066657527,
-0.0004826729,
-0.0707119629,
0.0253274776,
0.0367631763,
-0.0686151534,
0.0004222877,
-0.0116978623,
-0.024607921,
-0.011683614,
-0.0019354651,
0.0041422709,
0.0439863242,
0.0110739283,
0.030072337,
0.0178063959,
0.0834299996,
0.0217035711,
0.0001914436,
-0.0424838178,
-0.0171168558,
-0.0463097021,
0.0130412513,
-0.0125722867,
0.0423282161,
-0.0570283644,
-0.0304681081,
-0.0409562252,
0.0280163139,
-0.0074760779,
-0.0034227497,
-0.0236891862,
0.0648879632,
-0.0224421434,
0.0358384103,
-0.0337673612,
0.0290215611,
-0.0310435258,
0.0253517348,
0.0379735455,
-0.0815414414,
0.0016705615,
0.0327571556,
0.0291264486,
-0.0070978552,
-0.0096182711,
0.0440622978,
-0.029276507,
-0.0518526174,
0.0623916946,
-0.0115945041,
-0.0425550044,
-0.0801102147,
0.0018972908,
-0.0405931175,
0.0248486344,
0.0517868511,
-0.0232360903,
0.0241168365,
0.0226669591,
0.0134041142,
-0.0149915032,
0.0156801976,
0.0108483899,
0.0248577073,
0.0170830619,
0.0347251557,
-0.004424639,
0.0205158088,
0.0300359428,
0.0216205493,
0.047289107,
-0.0156093994,
0.017606426,
-0.0121025983,
-0.0102855405,
-0.0096601583,
0.0627848357,
0.0339148641,
-0.0221602283,
0.0173963979,
0.0183944013,
0.0412001051,
-0.0401877649,
-0.0292493571,
0.0684982538,
0.0516950376,
0.0084950943,
0.0555995926,
0.0128034437,
0.0384041183,
0.0232691057,
0.0255786367,
-0.0174872205,
0.0168716386,
-0.0263530239,
-0.0148751922,
0.0460073128,
0.0017118203,
-0.0237606987,
-0.0658935532,
0.03318353,
-0.0118628806,
0.0269986484,
0.006425119,
0.0267303865,
0.022057835,
-0.053638503,
0.0009332815,
-0.0236423947,
-0.0663244501,
-0.0302330684,
-0.0387208536,
0.0378233418,
0.0623409078,
0.0636802465,
-0.0180441272,
-0.03330414,
-0.0271161608,
-0.0080323648,
0.0451741964,
0.0413899235,
-0.0083054807,
0.0413724817,
-0.0327727757,
-0.0211170167,
-0.0089199739,
-0.0288843084,
0.0399288684,
-0.0171592683,
0.0118407449,
-0.0047765048,
0.0364175141,
0.0232333466,
-0.0298606195,
0.0157333687,
0.0111251958,
0.0538352095,
-0.0172659419,
0.0413648747,
0.0572722442,
-0.0147201261,
0.01050804,
0.0345449373,
-0.0256566051,
-0.034449704,
0.0217092372,
-0.0622661076,
-0.0042465846,
0.0281533618,
-0.0160513297,
-0.0128961243,
0.0842570812,
0.0019419127,
-0.0583225898,
0.0284555927,
-0.049291227,
0.0258255862,
-0.0129764844,
0.0105484864,
0.0142590301,
0.0330904685,
-0.0123449108,
0.0493100323,
0.0155432345,
0.0104307905,
0.0493076742,
0.0002751643,
-0.0158670172,
-0.0576874241,
0.0014308894,
0.0329419672,
-0.0214389041,
0.0133096538,
0.0180111043,
-0.0104328459,
-0.0566351637,
-0.0278127622,
-0.1243252903,
0.0075053638,
-0.0382603817,
-0.0103975693,
-0.0090457452,
0.027013991,
0.0081449356,
-0.0214327741,
-0.0492623523,
0.0093398839,
0.0614398047,
0.0326048136,
0.0166932195,
0.0056899176,
-0.0319195129,
-0.0332713202,
0.0088815456,
0.0125797214,
0.0375348739,
0.013919075,
0.0405647084,
-0.0444072336,
0.0073515647,
-0.0578704588,
0.0273813326,
-0.0105645973,
-0.0438209511,
0.0415874384,
-0.000537226,
0.0288988352,
0.0292770546,
0.0883757919,
0.015492877,
-0.0022291676,
-0.0098701306,
-0.0726493746,
0.0057972618,
-0.0237621963,
0.0149217155,
-0.0385635607,
0.0212841444,
0.004052097,
0.0296835117,
0.0032408442,
0.0254396312,
-0.0473705381,
-0.0050743422,
0.0283359569,
-0.0457102545,
-0.0225841012,
-0.0108971708,
-0.021696806,
0.0588556081,
0.0223250277,
-0.0210745092,
0.0533467941,
-0.0208784007,
-0.0189090893,
-0.0718484521,
-0.0312536471,
-0.0211954862,
0.0253815427,
-0.0231408011,
0.0219470803,
-0.0036502951,
-0.0307054408,
-0.0255158208,
-0.0137788728,
0.0129045937,
-0.0708231404,
0.0491079092,
-0.0110758217,
-0.0216152426,
-0.0206380468,
-0.0756850317,
-0.065637514,
-0.0298707206,
-0.0100965323,
0.0220739599,
0.0100860037,
-0.019361319,
-0.04108271,
0.0104189627,
0.0084718466,
0.0264264848,
-0.0176809672,
-0.0115041696,
0.0148912333,
0.0664841756,
0.0520420931,
0.1146693453,
0.0199970007,
0.0292984117,
0.0525892973,
0.0526426435,
0.0945755541,
-0.0262808483,
-0.0306544974,
-0.0296488982,
0.042263072,
-0.0220271647,
-0.0089739915,
0.0027140335,
0.0458862409,
-0.0024753411,
-0.029706426,
0.0984351784,
0.0222825874,
-0.0149582895,
-0.0184217114,
-0.0540341288,
0.0369173773,
0.0158754867,
0.0432830118,
-0.0741637349,
-0.0072895032,
-0.0021065548,
0.0332862027,
-0.0213697851,
-0.0432408452,
-0.0026069698,
-0.1283617467,
0.0326592959,
-0.0357243158,
-0.0422005467,
-0.0308338646,
-0.0252165589,
0.0122941323,
-0.0202942751,
-0.0126215657,
0.0060519855,
-0.0037332638,
-0.0069533354,
-0.0002875674,
-0.0161945485,
-0.0091642002,
0.0159481093,
-0.0210838299,
0.063658841,
0.0481674299,
0.0487387963,
0.022294255,
-0.0014725783,
-0.0405427031,
-0.0115226014,
0.0173175465,
0.0009782185,
0.03598544,
0.0089858361,
0.0097167194,
-0.0420095585,
-0.0006473733,
0.0137096485,
-0.0273573324,
0.0047734184,
0.0128629291,
-0.0512909479,
0.0117909582,
-0.0274263825,
0.0658376738,
0.0280016214,
0.0567578152,
0.0312014837,
-0.0389355533,
-0.0667662099,
-0.0174695645,
0.0200569797,
-0.0290862396,
-0.0308239497,
-0.0076709976,
0.0324514844,
-0.0326725207,
-0.0989197418,
-0.0281279199,
-0.006854719,
0.0320675559,
-0.0335791856,
-0.0271926187,
-0.0071949861,
0.0255306922,
-0.0102042379,
0.0031933971,
0.0059057982,
-0.0084206006,
-0.0306712873,
-0.0038904843,
0.04666223,
-0.0571989939,
-0.0192875061,
0.0410709269,
-0.0121821621,
-0.0264320001,
0.0160374362,
0.04411982,
0.0273784623,
0.0307999644,
-0.0334147364,
-0.0012430592,
0.0174170248,
0.0204215739,
-0.0749534145,
0.0036887445,
0.0588437878,
0.0465015024,
-0.02951096,
0.0185441282,
-0.0611416399,
0.0216711294,
0.001953556,
0.0316333324,
-0.0427999273,
-0.0792224854,
-0.0102588758,
-0.0034977291,
0.0623033829,
0.0229771528,
-0.0093703708,
0.0143879158,
0.0280060899,
-0.017668277,
0.0152774118,
-0.0578772426,
-0.0035675603,
-0.0136682997,
-0.0192994867,
0.0032478198,
0.0307195131,
-0.0469706468,
0.0364127494,
-0.0479379632,
-0.0011191028,
0.0205455311,
-0.0326962061,
-0.0040634251,
-0.0146060875,
-0.0072200419,
-0.0035384798,
0.0669164509,
0.0350785442,
0.0071298829,
0.0659121871,
-0.013626013,
-0.0407201499,
0.0490582138,
0.0596392602,
-0.1104414612,
-0.0493009463,
0.0078937914,
0.0307355579,
0.0175604708,
0.0370046534,
0.0592320934,
0.0100463172,
0.0242497921,
-0.0217986796,
0.0357587449,
-0.0071495026,
-0.0130537031,
0.0082541369,
0.0072446298,
-0.0243721567,
0.0531550311,
0.0476611182,
-0.0304632317,
-0.0205726251,
0.0108819921,
-0.0174967162,
-0.0509567671,
-0.0508467518,
-0.0380282141,
0.0189522784,
0.0035066083,
-0.0224174019,
-0.0532918796,
-0.0260735862,
0.0135993306,
-0.0281418078,
-0.0032825149,
-0.0222012009,
0.0449637808,
0.0330681242,
-0.0089668855,
-0.0286982059,
-0.0636647269,
-0.027814744,
-0.0545649305,
-0.0216698833,
-0.0067814412,
-5.880169514e-33,
-0.0280535258,
-0.0404837318,
-0.0030420292,
0.0107358405,
-0.0449804179,
-0.0152068241,
-0.0417210013,
0.0276400726,
-0.0152226062,
-0.0209729131,
-0.0369923003,
0.0451633818,
0.0128061948,
0.0175562389,
-0.0288936626,
-0.0708503947,
0.0666464865,
-0.0019751596,
-0.036525704,
0.0434300937,
0.052071888,
0.0079373717,
0.0013612345,
-0.0917363316,
-0.015794063,
0.010786782,
0.0102798985,
-0.0043116491,
0.0148322796,
0.0660320222,
0.0046401825,
0.0722613782,
0.0168119892,
-0.0645709559,
0.0176451262,
0.0732726678,
-0.0678634942,
-0.0341644958,
-0.0063105561,
-0.0080335345,
-0.0560019538,
-0.0073413718,
0.0307756346,
0.0099650379,
-0.0149825113,
-0.0082343211,
0.0264907032,
-0.0067615062,
0.0061255349,
-0.0340154655,
-0.0507923067,
0.0076774014,
-0.04023638,
-0.0677554905,
-0.0251181964,
0.1204818636,
0.0421884619,
0.0066469912,
-0.0589532368,
0.0536824726,
-0.0447416231,
-0.0129462387,
0.023350466,
-0.0115804262,
-0.0078892326,
0.0633496046,
-0.0049649663,
0.004789345,
-0.0115841245,
-0.0315646157,
-0.0552382395,
0.0656315461,
0.0550718606,
0.0353713855,
-0.0269583464,
-0.01206306,
-0.052435454,
0.0555863306,
0.0206247475,
0.0143303927,
0.0141046848,
0.0078010871,
-0.0332604237,
0.031575419,
-0.0067498451,
0.0081316317,
-0.0522639453,
-0.0479400381,
0.0265677534,
0.025995411,
-0.0594601259,
-0.0043845251,
0.0510191061,
-0.0611175001,
0.0178035498,
0.0424381569,
-0.0443625487,
0.0190361347,
0.0039227917,
-0.0203301311,
-0.0004096633,
0.0093491822,
0.0754769668,
0.0026123526,
0.0102519048,
-0.0035128566,
-0.048446402,
0.0150187425,
-0.0442967564,
0.0007738475,
0.0058389325,
0.055698134,
-0.0473967567,
0.0106871072,
0.0067274668,
0.0201394856,
-0.023247879,
0.0791032761,
-0.0065504611,
0.0486084856,
-0.0489548445,
-0.0331275836,
0.0284000225,
-0.0197151061,
-0.0285951067,
-0.000603774,
0.0050408463,
0.0188549627,
-0.0058133202,
-0.0118757077,
-0.0426106602,
-0.0063046827,
2.605e-7,
-0.0043929503,
0.0332334414,
0.001733367,
0.0022894819,
0.0219579022,
0.0578286834,
0.037271753,
0.0438872725,
0.0325070918,
0.0053454554,
-0.0230092835,
0.0006755221,
0.0645756945,
0.0359438658,
-0.0867369696,
-0.0347213112,
-0.0831684768,
-0.0321224853,
-0.0301774815,
-0.0032168718,
0.0752565041,
0.0723232478,
-0.0170636326,
0.004822026,
-0.0103323134,
0.00405405,
0.0260354895,
-0.0163517892,
-0.043961037,
-0.0095150499,
0.0513198748,
-0.0143973874,
0.0080794021,
0.0119205564,
-0.0100977253,
0.0348131098,
0.0225118101,
0.0505854078,
0.0187945422,
-0.0926849321,
0.0057154582,
0.0161894411,
0.0293936487,
-0.0305247605,
0.049452655,
-0.0359196439,
-0.0522860736,
-0.0042485278,
-0.0312372334,
-0.0247197095,
0.027611468,
-0.0024452514,
-0.0142428111,
0.0042849528,
-0.004164842,
0.0031744945,
0.0155599387,
-0.0479672514,
0.0193135198,
-0.0033684347,
-0.0615323931,
-0.0729679763,
-0.0242465325,
-0.035144493,
0.036258962,
-0.0190774556,
0.0034588641,
1.968681205e-34,
0.0205229968,
0.0221036673,
-0.0138161294,
0.0591886938,
0.0163564682,
-0.0099924169,
0.0050773164,
-0.0060321176,
0.0568831302,
-0.0662829503,
-0.003098564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04415v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04415v3 | Few-Shot Table-to-Text Generation with Prompt Planning and Knowledge Memorization | 2023-02-09T03:04:11 | 2023-08-17T01:51:48 | Zhixin Guo, Minyxuan Yan, Jiexing Qi, Jianping Zhou, Ziwei He, Zhouhan Lin, Guanjie Zheng, Xinbing Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models (PLM) have achieved remarkable advancement in
table-to-text generation tasks. However, the lack of labeled domain-specific
knowledge and the topology gap between tabular data and text make it difficult
for PLMs to yield faithful text. Low-resource generation likewise faces unique
challenges in this domain. Inspired by how humans descript tabular data with
prior knowledge, we suggest a new framework: PromptMize, which targets
table-to-text generation under few-shot settings. The design of our framework
consists of two aspects: a prompt planner and a knowledge adapter. The prompt
planner aims to generate a prompt signal that provides instance guidance for
PLMs to bridge the topology gap between tabular data and text. Moreover, the
knowledge adapter memorizes domain-specific knowledge from the unlabelled
corpus to supply essential information during generation. Extensive experiments
and analyses are investigated on three open domain few-shot NLG datasets:
human, song, and book. Compared with previous state-of-the-art approaches, our
model achieves remarkable performance in generating quality as judged by human
and automatic evaluations. | [
0.0114875929,
0.0375665985,
0.0208037831,
-0.030207159,
-0.0374056473,
-0.007070967,
0.0418406166,
0.009328248,
-0.0221466776,
-0.022532681,
-0.0607722886,
-0.0139923412,
0.0100390669,
0.0158644468,
0.0442589372,
-0.0047808648,
0.0358948745,
-0.0135309827,
-0.024072703,
0.0157370418,
0.0042139962,
-0.0002511202,
-0.0129664475,
0.0272080544,
-0.0077748136,
-0.0047585443,
-0.0270713326,
0.0234288666,
-0.0322883986,
-0.0271921959,
-0.0182451364,
0.085144639,
-0.0073105632,
-0.0067318408,
0.0000017628,
0.0069354097,
-0.0674814954,
-0.0241395645,
0.0082645603,
-0.0270809922,
0.0371340886,
-0.0368883945,
0.0005975863,
0.0089558959,
-0.0222736225,
-0.0251454115,
0.002405402,
0.0358720757,
0.0804311186,
0.092067346,
0.0071150246,
-0.0074628028,
-0.0215710048,
-0.0400972255,
0.031823013,
-0.0130071761,
-0.0174438432,
-0.0332208872,
0.0186701864,
-0.0121464664,
-0.0009694829,
0.0609354228,
0.0057431371,
-0.0009456574,
0.0302481335,
0.0463436283,
-0.0141325993,
-0.0144633306,
-0.0060064821,
0.077986747,
0.0009951732,
-0.0428805426,
0.0358011425,
-0.0030772528,
0.0143879689,
-0.0221178159,
-0.0175095852,
0.0340061635,
0.0094479462,
-0.0046186261,
-0.0180610046,
0.0260417853,
0.0026276798,
-0.015683718,
-0.0109409355,
0.0071446369,
0.0096216081,
-0.0427372456,
-0.0053517218,
0.0099291373,
0.0158607643,
-0.0620286837,
0.0158358775,
0.0518592298,
-0.0653081238,
0.0206404924,
-0.0738579556,
-0.0433659218,
-0.0129296435,
0.0149611682,
0.1076297387,
0.0609667301,
0.0034048127,
-0.0138445124,
-0.0502428077,
0.0226612985,
0.0155469943,
0.0298519656,
-0.0387460627,
0.0225507244,
-0.0299482215,
0.0187249631,
-0.0591626391,
0.0287122298,
-0.0373932272,
-0.0146079129,
-0.0097273579,
-0.0034947104,
0.009115899,
0.0210048612,
0.0206447132,
0.0116532436,
-0.0273366906,
-0.0068664695,
0.0006416228,
-0.0095364358,
-0.0242375936,
0.0014169258,
0.0392241627,
-0.0406533703,
-0.026993813,
-0.0048600216,
0.0383552536,
0.0090633463,
0.024054287,
0.05350741,
-0.053148523,
-0.0358667113,
-0.0535056442,
-0.0571648888,
-0.0530175306,
-0.0687125623,
-0.0311292373,
-0.0491595306,
0.0553081296,
0.0061900574,
-0.0130351065,
-0.0645134374,
0.0045907451,
0.0362625606,
-0.0208237208,
0.032643687,
-0.0095729074,
0.0502502248,
0.0046174433,
-0.0080035552,
-0.0147946812,
0.0352742709,
0.0430244207,
0.0413489193,
-0.0281290486,
0.0138427084,
-0.0058296579,
0.0366695635,
0.0561093763,
-0.0359113365,
0.003646086,
-0.0013730007,
0.0014395785,
0.042349916,
0.0371038355,
0.0253993534,
-0.0035801018,
0.0578284189,
0.0672618449,
0.0066708159,
0.0366652831,
0.054114379,
0.0845341533,
0.0154452678,
0.0171608645,
0.0269706063,
-0.0081926128,
0.0270419996,
-0.0039080335,
0.0436528586,
0.0894244835,
0.0293781944,
-0.0370966792,
-0.0314077437,
0.0331374854,
-0.0124266539,
-0.0367339812,
-0.0181011427,
0.017527312,
0.0747600794,
-0.1013484374,
0.0159364436,
-0.0047136801,
-0.0565964729,
0.0350420736,
0.0077393916,
0.0405859463,
0.0531842522,
0.0389143862,
-0.0101642516,
-0.0045700227,
0.0089131054,
0.0345571265,
0.0720269606,
0.0180362016,
-0.0124405632,
0.0028370977,
-0.0074064042,
-0.0052577714,
0.015237811,
0.0114618177,
0.0155630549,
-0.0048730127,
0.0071431296,
0.0370153487,
-0.021044258,
-0.0215819664,
0.0382649004,
-0.0071556326,
-0.0227182396,
0.0247991867,
0.0044721924,
0.0029256537,
0.0262595993,
-0.0299258232,
0.0591185354,
0.012952297,
-0.01697734,
0.0429851897,
-0.0194131583,
-0.0699361786,
-0.0496740639,
-0.0048172269,
0.0251413342,
-0.0079557821,
-0.0375929214,
-0.0113906777,
-0.0713688955,
0.0155663639,
0.0085190721,
-0.018061934,
-0.038661506,
0.0272671673,
0.054097794,
0.0004459982,
0.0002239104,
0.0575942025,
0.0140869487,
0.0129083488,
0.061923191,
-0.023738075,
0.0048533059,
-0.0360210799,
0.0225866623,
-0.0349741615,
-0.0007580823,
0.0032842332,
0.0203412063,
0.0353274532,
-0.0455385409,
-0.0117849158,
-0.0740767047,
0.0569538958,
-0.0144773042,
-0.0080780368,
0.0354069285,
0.0072635366,
-0.0177066308,
-0.0084424149,
-0.0446236357,
0.0050865491,
0.0448677391,
-0.0124228997,
0.0404135324,
0.0139063951,
0.0081386575,
-0.0399037898,
0.0082978262,
-0.0014523274,
-0.0043705404,
-0.016046023,
-0.0167779606,
-0.0233400539,
0.0454241633,
-0.0233474802,
-0.0053111073,
0.0506583899,
0.0025291888,
0.0032875952,
0.0017515126,
0.0823520645,
0.0097480165,
-0.0146525409,
0.0066544381,
0.0137486225,
-0.0158880129,
-0.0366958193,
-0.0068749492,
-0.0354577042,
-0.0128661199,
0.0219332818,
-0.02623084,
0.0622207858,
0.0534672923,
0.0332277417,
0.0164518803,
-0.0627886578,
0.0162063818,
0.0038276599,
-0.0204839762,
-0.0567707457,
0.0542877316,
-0.0070332838,
0.0062129749,
-0.0321661793,
-0.0113119623,
0.0315063223,
-0.0738276392,
0.0112814149,
0.0040204832,
0.0172363333,
-0.018431494,
0.021437075,
0.0000049601,
0.0297304094,
0.027827289,
-0.0073771076,
-0.0896476209,
0.0361707322,
-0.0063988823,
-0.0224683266,
0.0501461253,
-0.0717506558,
0.0032537126,
-0.0146783618,
-0.0270779394,
-0.0369791314,
-0.0557803772,
0.0156099573,
0.020909803,
0.0142880958,
0.0171902254,
0.0007952106,
-0.0061044386,
0.0238921419,
0.0535634533,
-0.0268554427,
-0.0275679994,
-0.0464240052,
0.0749843121,
0.0290046949,
-0.0184639543,
-0.0376876816,
-0.0239792187,
0.0291542728,
0.0190055463,
-0.0174194667,
0.0031494212,
-0.0044992161,
0.0177022219,
0.0000988783,
-0.0142674735,
-0.0021255584,
0.0605464876,
0.0190201011,
-0.0315602832,
-0.02648771,
0.1162836105,
0.0183528811,
0.0127624096,
-0.0058306088,
0.0468584858,
0.0589268543,
-0.0143499132,
0.0404281057,
-0.0724156424,
-0.0208066404,
-0.0024656975,
0.0408964492,
0.0186150819,
-0.0557120666,
-0.0570797883,
-0.118223995,
0.0106160333,
0.0181593671,
-0.0472833328,
-0.0390343815,
0.0051817717,
-0.0401286185,
0.0183512326,
0.0193095207,
0.05660652,
-0.024710184,
0.0617094785,
0.0158462543,
-0.0231723189,
-0.0576897226,
-0.0304594785,
-0.0636256114,
0.0855178833,
0.0671565607,
0.0130290762,
0.0217342507,
0.0247866102,
-0.0428418443,
0.0053111319,
0.0275314376,
-0.0084303701,
0.0167475995,
-0.0179137774,
0.0038128428,
0.0215290133,
0.023448471,
-0.0347920954,
0.0065854024,
0.0201572403,
0.0196575113,
-0.018319862,
-0.0076710451,
0.0182932038,
0.0337351672,
0.0151581522,
0.0936188549,
0.0453442223,
-0.0169283357,
-0.0344317891,
0.0115730194,
-0.0236761793,
-0.1268357038,
-0.0060611186,
0.028859714,
-0.0303130653,
-0.0352347381,
-0.0895967856,
-0.0197897647,
0.0621945448,
0.0517221503,
0.0116685228,
0.0160141904,
-0.0503254384,
-0.0046913889,
-0.0296789203,
-0.0225921478,
-0.0539147593,
-0.0087228687,
-0.0848568827,
-0.075130254,
0.0148346359,
-0.0724111795,
0.0186442342,
0.0212972201,
-0.0675881356,
-0.0188900847,
-0.0100903884,
0.0507653095,
0.0201052781,
0.03747008,
0.0160458144,
-0.0022265271,
0.0520511232,
0.0567051955,
-0.0795559287,
0.026381379,
0.0037044829,
-0.0085005816,
-0.0101754908,
0.0369436741,
-0.0453609116,
0.0355476178,
0.0214307792,
0.0489412397,
0.0371106043,
-0.0058514592,
0.056652952,
0.0054710871,
0.0243191216,
-0.0500840023,
-0.0401089638,
-0.0194713306,
-0.0331317969,
-0.0600454658,
-0.0202376489,
-0.0505638644,
-0.0041349554,
0.0297094155,
0.0081408145,
-0.0183532201,
-0.0124608874,
-0.0146135539,
0.0605723374,
-0.0187704805,
-0.0433418229,
0.0231121797,
-0.0333376937,
0.0311565157,
-0.0136563107,
-0.0216632113,
0.004253278,
-0.0144790448,
0.0007161002,
-0.0259608366,
0.0363827981,
0.0154626779,
-0.0117456978,
-0.0112386905,
0.0500186756,
-0.0202154256,
-0.0252079517,
-0.0475673713,
0.0090799714,
0.0229617581,
0.0195741449,
0.0192652699,
-0.0172074754,
0.0116132023,
-0.0046652728,
0.0482244752,
0.0338649526,
-0.0192800108,
0.0001858381,
-0.0199330803,
-0.0078882221,
-0.0242143497,
0.1146375537,
0.0317822248,
-0.0074274819,
0.0035027866,
0.0050692582,
-0.0493184961,
0.011575127,
-0.0047417902,
-0.0157391764,
-0.0247631557,
-0.0443724766,
-0.0564326383,
-0.0353526138,
0.0390416905,
0.0358332619,
-0.0264599919,
0.009632213,
0.0422201604,
0.0174072944,
-0.0137198279,
0.036207933,
-0.0482479483,
-0.0026176115,
-0.0087643554,
-0.0433017947,
-0.0093510048,
-5.884627209e-33,
-0.0962503552,
-0.0150142582,
0.0079060877,
-0.0702007338,
0.0096641053,
-0.0214222353,
-0.0857453644,
0.0030751061,
0.0353729874,
-0.0287104864,
-0.0350694619,
-0.0102164391,
0.0198792554,
0.0139622772,
0.0082344851,
-0.0232573804,
0.0693464801,
-0.0443126261,
-0.0388363898,
0.0428592302,
0.0054475651,
0.055953905,
-0.0226641353,
0.0120000746,
0.0172409937,
-0.0317296609,
-0.0325144939,
-0.033066459,
0.0463501774,
-0.0006899466,
-0.0206382331,
0.0201815646,
0.0123850806,
-0.0227190666,
-0.0700662136,
0.0514547378,
-0.1209785566,
-0.0207483321,
0.0057855882,
-0.0088654673,
-0.0279807597,
-0.0377661847,
-0.0122195128,
-0.0338034518,
-0.0201799255,
0.0098062446,
0.0173561927,
-0.0351699665,
-0.0043373308,
-0.0338810049,
-0.0266666524,
-0.0187865589,
-0.0118484404,
-0.0603225566,
0.049352251,
0.0734050423,
-0.0124816103,
0.0009547439,
-0.0417591482,
0.0425209105,
-0.0066350223,
0.0349998884,
0.057226155,
0.0001304903,
-0.0244914908,
0.0275269542,
0.0401788577,
-0.0028170808,
-0.0194546301,
0.056703452,
-0.027510453,
0.0545501858,
0.0149477143,
0.044003468,
0.0271291193,
-0.0188613757,
-0.0199534353,
0.0679324716,
-0.0157205351,
-0.0472538657,
0.0043931254,
-0.0251656566,
0.0105749965,
-0.0291683748,
-0.0124533018,
-0.0404656604,
-0.0164351389,
-0.0368420333,
0.0464414693,
0.0329998061,
0.0003334601,
-0.0301640015,
0.05426443,
0.0049840533,
0.0105605684,
0.01097121,
-0.043727126,
0.0105487043,
-0.0080863386,
-0.0063530817,
-0.0764381438,
-0.0453305244,
0.076443851,
0.0045183427,
0.0222915467,
0.0460912473,
0.0313547812,
0.064170748,
-0.0523671359,
0.0045059328,
-0.0293966532,
0.0617001653,
0.0149793876,
-0.0266920403,
0.007192241,
-0.0151529675,
-0.0134483203,
0.0545845479,
0.002811146,
-0.0404299125,
0.0204957407,
0.0211061165,
0.01535377,
-0.0052162027,
-0.0006677831,
0.0247665513,
-0.0120409457,
0.0150562134,
0.0270442069,
-0.0249084905,
0.0069015301,
-0.0056420597,
2.464e-7,
0.0372562781,
-0.008423212,
0.0451038033,
0.0155352401,
-0.0060313684,
-0.0063572936,
-0.019266326,
0.0409646295,
-0.0343224704,
-0.0194427762,
0.0576168485,
-0.0429986604,
0.0844251141,
-0.0067149615,
-0.0841712281,
-0.0046857418,
-0.0537669323,
0.0406316221,
-0.0712133497,
-0.0359098427,
0.0580798239,
0.0464665331,
-0.0579208061,
0.0002995773,
0.0031736603,
-0.0147080515,
0.059649229,
-0.0373555645,
0.0067658266,
-0.0080599915,
0.0604695939,
-0.0494134948,
-0.0345538296,
0.0327825844,
-0.0544139333,
-0.0095611783,
0.0170060452,
0.0476407148,
0.0489781499,
-0.016786566,
-0.0009523171,
-0.0428467542,
0.0027162207,
-0.0284308959,
0.0756199136,
-0.0653919429,
0.0000046355,
0.0825205371,
-0.0185820758,
0.0261566918,
-0.0388659611,
-0.0094911801,
-0.0421398208,
0.0072066681,
0.0635704771,
0.0362267978,
0.0146044185,
-0.0248782076,
-0.0312546976,
0.0113852601,
-0.0310490951,
-0.0085726548,
-0.0388981439,
-0.0362345278,
0.0041258046,
-0.0936648697,
-0.0274010394,
2.302497493e-34,
0.0343681835,
-0.0362792797,
0.026127737,
-0.0154432729,
0.0276823919,
-0.0176388267,
0.0248284992,
0.0063034496,
0.0200665332,
-0.0640435442,
-0.0465530828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04391v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04391v7 | The Re-Label Method For Data-Centric Machine Learning | 2023-02-09T01:09:57 | 2024-01-14T13:50:20 | Tong Guo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In industry deep learning application, our manually labeled data has a
certain number of noisy data. To solve this problem and achieve more than 90
score in dev dataset, we present a simple method to find the noisy data and
re-label the noisy data by human, given the model predictions as references in
human labeling. In this paper, we illustrate our idea for a broad set of deep
learning tasks, includes classification, sequence tagging, object detection,
sequence generation, click-through rate prediction. The dev dataset evaluation
results and human evaluation results verify our idea. | [
0.023486428,
0.0554463118,
0.0092111016,
0.0055726324,
-0.0034947658,
0.000160323,
0.0240130424,
-0.0317955464,
0.0065882141,
-0.0283999722,
-0.0578207262,
0.0029271832,
-0.0515101925,
0.0663040355,
0.0322566107,
-0.0312128849,
0.0077624377,
0.031161081,
0.0387835652,
0.0183024462,
-0.0304373428,
-0.0362838879,
0.0030233245,
0.0048368545,
-0.03949783,
-0.0018215871,
-0.0068245763,
0.0161192808,
0.0248790029,
-0.066390872,
0.0497337878,
0.0349694379,
0.0093318438,
0.0685361549,
0.0000019431,
-0.0152267097,
-0.0074682538,
-0.0202702023,
-0.0586711019,
-0.0049847732,
0.0292997342,
0.0244384911,
-0.0112849195,
0.005610947,
-0.0310119018,
-0.017143745,
0.056419421,
0.0680976957,
0.0586267821,
0.0495388843,
-0.0217804089,
-0.0622804761,
0.0286228471,
-0.0280298758,
0.0375030302,
-0.0440376289,
0.0284014083,
0.0428268872,
0.0000805017,
0.0001859542,
0.0175601132,
0.0458970666,
0.0612801649,
-0.0052703824,
0.0479355119,
0.0184732955,
-0.0580061115,
-0.0299789254,
0.0075220168,
0.1192017496,
-0.052969601,
-0.0123292785,
-0.0031900227,
-0.0038446526,
-0.0011622889,
-0.0801577717,
-0.0246591307,
-0.0083663967,
0.0165792275,
-0.0035801809,
-0.0457630977,
0.0491283089,
0.0511809178,
0.0010024057,
-0.0049529122,
0.0307574663,
-0.0075806761,
-0.0026723598,
-0.0050438307,
0.0229755994,
0.0236325115,
-0.0501775891,
0.0319374017,
0.0176366251,
-0.0349007733,
0.0065950365,
-0.0702652484,
-0.0362793915,
-0.0209906548,
-0.0533092991,
-0.0243812334,
-0.0279489681,
-0.0570522659,
0.05232298,
-0.0636457875,
-0.002014627,
0.0006623953,
0.0414815582,
0.0048279148,
-0.0103302393,
-0.0410279743,
0.0034522763,
-0.0263120029,
0.0267927404,
-0.0037664983,
-0.0184867289,
-0.0552068315,
0.0121456608,
-0.0566094257,
0.0025520292,
-0.0111434534,
0.0282356627,
-0.0664012507,
0.0028724689,
-0.015746817,
0.0078924457,
-0.0155137535,
0.0209199153,
0.0382763445,
-0.0733475536,
0.0167079326,
0.0139187081,
0.0310978852,
-0.0098603396,
0.0312945545,
0.0788362324,
-0.0158368051,
-0.0090570133,
-0.051601246,
-0.0362714343,
-0.0083650285,
-0.0083871186,
-0.0093654459,
-0.0488261357,
0.0125416564,
-0.0405867845,
-0.0153784053,
-0.0662136227,
-0.0004203801,
0.0013569836,
0.026876362,
0.0929712504,
-0.032443475,
-0.0229504667,
0.0329878479,
0.0203831997,
0.0125979455,
0.0045861988,
0.0393064991,
0.0832848623,
0.0596801601,
0.0170159377,
0.0926132053,
0.0221191086,
0.0342083648,
-0.0207677223,
-0.019799944,
-0.0115295462,
-0.0073130531,
0.0222715642,
0.0183609948,
0.0240319725,
-0.0104957409,
-0.0354067087,
0.0434091613,
-0.0302626695,
0.0060633123,
-0.0029725563,
0.0082263406,
0.0319769159,
-0.0064554671,
-0.0330041945,
-0.0049672164,
0.033296071,
0.0236418135,
0.0102536716,
0.0053674472,
-0.0108325882,
-0.053582605,
-0.0302823242,
0.0124085452,
-0.0236818362,
-0.0160758775,
0.0286625419,
0.0602819063,
0.0113087986,
-0.0493321382,
0.0223846287,
0.0013964307,
-0.0200116299,
0.0006053246,
-0.0421155877,
-0.0224967916,
0.0166414399,
0.0406195857,
-0.0578474775,
-0.0510575026,
-0.0325403549,
0.0446077846,
-0.0174121503,
0.0294383466,
-0.0307167526,
-0.004885071,
-0.0443514958,
-0.0647857115,
0.0035976206,
-0.0227358788,
0.0561815239,
0.005453113,
-0.0433281474,
0.0424714871,
-0.0413349308,
-0.0580351949,
0.0376074463,
0.0073132422,
-0.0576433577,
0.0365980826,
0.0353969708,
0.047900591,
0.0207518358,
-0.0042252531,
-0.0118808439,
0.0596828498,
0.0124843139,
-0.0160982814,
-0.0104939034,
-0.0224366225,
-0.0068554319,
0.0405456387,
-0.0600068942,
-0.0164821986,
0.0255500264,
-0.0595859289,
-0.0659130439,
-0.0080129867,
-0.0177203696,
-0.0567482039,
0.0057059764,
0.0038861164,
0.0391433351,
0.0268851109,
-0.0319081843,
0.0500079542,
0.0465320125,
0.0045100162,
0.0116674835,
0.040329732,
0.0208059605,
-0.0593329817,
-0.0360666327,
-0.0083310809,
-0.0411849953,
0.0012746138,
0.0535063706,
-0.0131815774,
-0.028074678,
0.0428271107,
-0.0330403708,
-0.0330865867,
-0.0017656041,
-0.0143921217,
0.0150259882,
0.0003777438,
0.008784472,
-0.0671370924,
-0.0558556207,
-0.0066579878,
-0.0028932213,
-0.0089742765,
0.0217040908,
0.0348489285,
-0.0215413701,
-0.0022757889,
-0.0141558992,
0.0095889326,
0.0065674437,
0.0241748113,
-0.0404503196,
-0.0409934185,
0.0022342007,
-0.0056056865,
0.0510282218,
-0.0040167957,
-0.0083822906,
-0.0132347299,
0.0296191592,
-0.008305518,
0.0355756581,
-0.0529113933,
0.014565777,
0.0131809069,
-0.0059859455,
-0.0198182929,
0.0074982722,
-0.0210258979,
0.0103369197,
0.0075633274,
-0.0314623043,
-0.0013429276,
0.0431046747,
-0.0276036393,
0.016137436,
0.0056539155,
-0.0093759401,
0.0160435233,
-0.0301645808,
-0.0800098255,
0.020075513,
-0.0289730504,
0.0191369262,
-0.0192111824,
-0.0467237309,
0.0608865544,
-0.0045122094,
-0.0284485202,
-0.0245818645,
-0.0367173702,
0.015169383,
0.0477575175,
0.0027233274,
0.0030294913,
-0.0066197701,
-0.0653809309,
-0.0578007251,
0.0306438655,
0.0034290715,
-0.0335978121,
0.0030947176,
-0.0487700738,
0.0137538407,
-0.01768874,
-0.007617129,
-0.0724559873,
-0.0073682098,
-0.0241753031,
0.0243012775,
-0.0024316148,
-0.0237326398,
-0.0792182982,
0.0167583432,
0.0224140566,
0.0822650343,
0.0109345447,
0.0082538519,
-0.0145879164,
0.0294275619,
0.0455395021,
-0.0010932134,
-0.0163418576,
0.0180811733,
0.0035573714,
0.0307015702,
0.0595368445,
-0.0208993554,
-0.0499571674,
-0.0019371457,
0.0182415806,
0.0057637407,
0.0162448119,
0.0119760679,
0.0074828733,
-0.0409030207,
0.0019453265,
0.0773823634,
-0.0118356803,
-0.0529469028,
-0.0085509429,
0.0570756197,
-0.003148054,
0.0391109139,
0.0281366315,
-0.0561531074,
-0.0608563833,
0.018031422,
0.0481869653,
0.0058780764,
-0.0167546272,
0.0042369706,
-0.0831067637,
0.0350540616,
-0.0177263021,
-0.050815016,
-0.0692680553,
-0.0358703174,
-0.0008144074,
-0.0157034304,
0.0106609138,
-0.0056428104,
0.0420144461,
-0.0163888354,
0.0487081148,
-0.0062159705,
-0.0797687471,
-0.0080634011,
-0.0364441723,
0.0514143929,
0.0699575245,
0.0141432723,
-0.0014051516,
-0.0196777135,
0.0285736509,
0.0134786274,
-0.0108333267,
0.0296316892,
0.0715823099,
-0.0296443105,
-0.0295877513,
0.0368028097,
0.0309122354,
-0.0639765635,
0.0064406884,
-0.0242265817,
0.0401205271,
-0.0048862956,
0.0241809841,
-0.0293422695,
-0.0261151027,
0.0263915975,
0.0597093925,
0.0166833978,
-0.0265249945,
-0.0041361083,
-0.0015303598,
0.0344017632,
-0.0217620283,
0.0109495064,
-0.0010303508,
-0.087723054,
-0.0910353437,
-0.0780500844,
-0.0445093848,
0.0359268039,
0.0578537881,
0.0198399778,
-0.0340284742,
0.0007785296,
0.0285583176,
-0.0779894441,
0.0003368748,
-0.0200014971,
0.0249960069,
-0.0768725872,
-0.0065027419,
0.0443771668,
0.0043752319,
-0.0202494282,
0.0727362335,
-0.0409119129,
-0.0366394781,
0.0185480919,
0.044085443,
0.021890536,
0.0218248852,
-0.016406158,
-0.0584487393,
0.0130942687,
0.090378277,
-0.062295489,
-0.0456615537,
0.0141349463,
-0.0356165208,
-0.023724312,
-0.0088334512,
-0.0646651685,
0.0645204261,
0.0515096262,
0.002915831,
-0.0370699428,
-0.0303240567,
0.0158853009,
0.0191033594,
0.0826630071,
-0.0001533682,
0.0138733322,
-0.0358271599,
0.0054433867,
0.0560560152,
-0.0209315531,
-0.0421144068,
0.0429856777,
0.0359590203,
-0.000400347,
-0.0062228953,
0.0323212855,
0.0107800784,
-0.0386681445,
-0.0389145948,
-0.0331708081,
0.00806861,
0.0385883935,
-0.0164614916,
0.0113804191,
0.0245062876,
0.0097180493,
0.0468814857,
0.0574009642,
0.0320495367,
-0.0254539214,
0.0461110473,
0.0011642908,
-0.0206532869,
0.0322725624,
-0.0488378145,
-0.0052411403,
-0.0921802223,
0.0033505682,
0.022779284,
0.0206346437,
-0.0115161901,
-0.0317874327,
-0.0186045934,
-0.0298289657,
0.0316925161,
-0.0107583543,
-0.0299784467,
0.0130231483,
0.0019927404,
-0.0162128676,
0.0089048743,
0.0632397458,
0.035895586,
0.0251269937,
-0.0352791622,
-0.0357001051,
-0.0597323403,
0.0366729014,
0.0393639579,
0.019294478,
-0.0093331002,
0.0188814849,
0.0338190533,
-0.0748477876,
0.0101999985,
-0.014595435,
0.0496368408,
-0.0086792279,
0.0537539721,
0.0545649827,
0.0100976424,
0.0058114403,
-0.0233771987,
0.0191274118,
0.0344145708,
-0.0389772393,
-0.0183724929,
-5.897665645e-33,
0.005791523,
-0.0180907473,
-0.0143721178,
-0.0185906943,
0.0121732326,
0.0146917868,
-0.0136456564,
0.0056927679,
0.0280519072,
0.0130258789,
-0.0068926569,
0.0350133553,
0.0343739465,
0.0313898623,
-0.0094564334,
-0.0434717573,
0.0773519278,
-0.0252898801,
-0.0041995877,
0.0389496312,
-0.0009601183,
0.0543731973,
0.0720160082,
-0.119990401,
0.01774613,
0.0064498694,
-0.0094157476,
0.0039930465,
0.0494790003,
0.0278427228,
-0.0142376758,
0.0212164372,
0.0058277878,
-0.0846683308,
-0.0158918817,
0.0062326118,
-0.0901684165,
0.0211921483,
-0.0712332726,
0.0789155811,
-0.0262997169,
-0.0175936073,
0.1035208106,
-0.0278744511,
-0.0061384295,
0.0468095355,
0.0574103817,
-0.0283017009,
-0.0350931138,
-0.0312103443,
-0.0332646742,
0.0282618366,
-0.013341126,
-0.035681732,
0.067676276,
0.0581070781,
-0.0064894482,
0.0020244329,
-0.1259503812,
-0.0097747836,
0.0136705544,
0.0331501774,
0.0747977272,
0.0665525869,
0.0119590098,
0.0380362272,
0.0806748122,
0.0083163381,
-0.0011171746,
0.0040734462,
-0.0032398484,
0.0683750063,
0.0309694856,
0.031390164,
0.0649922788,
-0.0122303851,
-0.0417476669,
0.0544156581,
-0.0130688474,
0.0073542716,
-0.0058244229,
0.045451764,
-0.0407892279,
-0.0024743804,
0.0089644026,
-0.0158234984,
-0.0223596767,
0.0086335875,
0.0267602578,
0.0168051962,
-0.0621753447,
0.0459551476,
0.0158376228,
-0.0549109913,
-0.0091884267,
-0.0109304395,
0.0194887519,
0.0370257795,
0.0201443247,
-0.046260424,
-0.0575450771,
-0.020631494,
0.0245925635,
0.0404305942,
0.0160108842,
-0.0317408256,
0.0285292361,
0.0338485055,
-0.0298286583,
0.0051180683,
-0.0204675253,
0.0069274646,
0.0254254639,
0.0415077694,
0.0151851196,
-0.0298904814,
-0.0184846483,
0.0393878371,
0.0108381975,
0.0186268725,
0.0135602346,
-0.0118624549,
0.0248294659,
-0.004200601,
-0.0311751962,
-0.0200608,
-0.0402332954,
-0.0090009738,
0.0070965607,
-0.0506621785,
0.0024982237,
-0.0112494063,
2.712e-7,
-0.0261819288,
0.0025777477,
0.0277480762,
-0.0032908437,
0.0154923582,
0.0446356423,
0.0318577215,
0.0098367911,
0.0118183531,
-0.0558231585,
0.0395388491,
-0.0417799354,
0.0547319427,
-0.0173692536,
-0.076598905,
-0.0451966003,
-0.0486190394,
0.0519106239,
0.0102492152,
-0.0002808253,
0.0022709514,
0.1270500869,
0.0244398266,
-0.0407583565,
0.0500342622,
-0.0107918326,
-0.0088208951,
-0.0096261948,
0.0480105691,
0.0203356948,
0.080537796,
0.0661653057,
-0.0520697907,
0.0248574074,
-0.0387715362,
-0.0315814875,
0.0539383478,
0.0166244935,
-0.0104425084,
-0.0035038961,
-0.0227973592,
-0.0031282846,
0.0233129505,
0.0033255597,
0.0252742115,
-0.0377174392,
-0.0302260462,
0.0008092937,
-0.0405083559,
-0.0284643993,
-0.0057462351,
-0.0165423509,
0.015746817,
-0.0163716506,
0.0291889813,
-0.0363570899,
-0.0486982912,
-0.0670655891,
0.0066354121,
-0.0074383989,
-0.0400826186,
0.0266043991,
-0.0444140621,
-0.0292362459,
0.0129469596,
-0.0063425303,
0.0182379764,
1.983529168e-34,
0.0215871856,
0.0042984276,
-0.0286429226,
-0.0031123429,
0.003656562,
-0.0022931811,
-0.004765294,
0.0150011871,
-0.0084165623,
-0.0055093556,
-0.0339726731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06451v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06451v1 | Ordered Memory Baselines | 2023-02-08T22:36:25 | 2023-02-08T22:36:25 | Daniel Borisov, Matthew D'Iorio, Jeffrey Hyacinthe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Natural language semantics can be modeled using the phrase-structured model,
which can be represented using a tree-type architecture. As a result, recent
advances in natural language processing have been made utilising recursive
neural networks using memory models that allow them to infer tree-type
representations of the input sentence sequence. These new tree models have
allowed for improvements in sentiment analysis and semantic recognition. Here
we review the Ordered Memory model proposed by Shen et al. (2019) at the
NeurIPS 2019 conference, and try to either create baselines that can perform
better or create simpler models that can perform equally as well. We found that
the Ordered Memory model performs on par with the state-of-the-art models used
in tree-type modelling, and performs better than simplified baselines that
require fewer parameters. | [
0.0281191804,
0.0836477578,
0.0143558998,
0.047147695,
-0.0291993394,
0.0096875168,
-0.0575641841,
-0.0371321142,
-0.013817993,
-0.0848348141,
0.0165577233,
-0.0560089238,
-0.0051713972,
0.0140316719,
-0.0340588726,
-0.0618889704,
0.0300561059,
0.0042809076,
0.0510150604,
0.009823855,
0.0003990123,
0.0105512515,
0.0107252263,
-0.0089712534,
-0.0320796706,
-0.0528751723,
-0.0269177053,
0.0087649869,
-0.0129854968,
-0.0484582633,
0.0277710613,
0.013747992,
0.0118041318,
0.0342208631,
0.0000021112,
0.0143975616,
-0.0029615508,
-0.0137964441,
-0.0033208353,
0.0113618793,
0.0088834977,
-0.0285425894,
-0.0115151694,
-0.0168608278,
-0.0324780121,
-0.0461722463,
0.0217219498,
0.0650545433,
0.0602508597,
0.105557546,
-0.0148796262,
-0.0765149072,
0.0365344286,
-0.0351742133,
-0.000969771,
-0.032298319,
0.004173405,
-0.0306607075,
-0.0241240729,
0.0605135076,
-0.0069432347,
-0.021698216,
0.0069846287,
0.0271721482,
0.0138578154,
0.0144220022,
-0.0132223889,
0.0206559934,
-0.0460485965,
0.0470478237,
0.0002528596,
0.0009561977,
-0.0071317437,
-0.0312577747,
0.0018852653,
-0.0377046987,
-0.0367804021,
0.0584304817,
-0.0053353366,
0.0348302126,
0.0306898039,
0.0275447126,
0.0319633931,
0.0192023069,
-0.0315428302,
0.0763880759,
-0.0263743177,
-0.057743568,
0.0164795611,
0.0011276125,
0.0253429506,
-0.0151280276,
-0.0109394733,
0.0303789955,
0.0195359979,
0.0243002493,
-0.0031247861,
-0.0037811163,
-0.005168193,
-0.083503671,
0.0074163564,
0.0246808007,
0.0130479038,
0.0461882949,
-0.0274409484,
0.0494638085,
-0.0033909988,
0.0121648656,
-0.0165525917,
0.0237008017,
-0.0422431789,
-0.0245809741,
0.0058249081,
0.0918850601,
-0.032514777,
-0.0063898936,
-0.0208252594,
0.0072579691,
-0.0182794519,
-0.0138069084,
0.0062445235,
0.027911555,
0.0097992178,
0.0425204933,
-0.0291109029,
0.0193497371,
-0.0183609892,
-0.0012635922,
0.0058878893,
-0.0118745295,
-0.0175887309,
0.0250729378,
-0.0053270841,
-0.0033129659,
0.0102750966,
0.067998834,
0.0585971028,
-0.0448573977,
-0.0188927073,
-0.0100078247,
-0.012112557,
-0.033205457,
0.0585657097,
-0.0709338039,
0.0243795533,
-0.0135317519,
0.0102569722,
0.0023229942,
0.0214192066,
0.0584716238,
-0.065181978,
0.0201247185,
0.0289294999,
-0.0226678345,
-0.0442074947,
0.0035784333,
0.0401610136,
0.0235705189,
0.0271961652,
0.0445790775,
0.0318563133,
-0.0003674056,
-0.0374575108,
-0.0151398471,
0.0022991209,
-0.0507684089,
-0.0245412681,
0.0013244082,
-0.085448958,
0.000774756,
0.0014257373,
0.0099853855,
-0.0097377673,
-0.0558861345,
0.0116265817,
0.0328232534,
-0.0427667573,
0.0117531857,
0.00967752,
-0.0394582115,
0.0185868666,
-0.0030376746,
-0.036076922,
0.0127907991,
-0.0161425341,
0.0184779353,
-0.034116637,
-0.0051010647,
-0.0356924422,
-0.0393919796,
-0.0232927296,
-0.0373592153,
0.0442550294,
-0.039521303,
0.0384758897,
0.0335066207,
-0.0494057089,
0.0182704069,
0.0112571027,
-0.0479282886,
-0.0346911475,
-0.0279056579,
0.0007273316,
0.0639227927,
0.0135396011,
-0.031462241,
-0.010981028,
0.0043422817,
-0.0167586487,
0.0397990234,
0.0248874128,
0.0100910412,
-0.0097245928,
-0.0160639025,
-0.0034042043,
-0.0391376093,
0.0431775302,
0.0237151626,
-0.0019472901,
-0.0186182652,
0.0228317361,
0.031409096,
-0.0282344818,
0.0157378539,
0.0260728188,
0.0030337221,
0.0274135135,
-0.0086787939,
0.0465712883,
0.0275976695,
-0.0004644088,
0.0397862606,
0.0539201424,
-0.0342282169,
-0.0760994926,
-0.0033158064,
-0.0892200842,
-0.0692354888,
0.0139522776,
0.0042133383,
-0.0205417164,
0.0522383638,
-0.1065222025,
-0.0264079347,
0.034970779,
-0.039615389,
0.0334740989,
-0.0316323079,
0.0209094882,
0.026259087,
-0.0139883878,
-0.0223516859,
0.0992038175,
-0.077642113,
0.0054010451,
-0.0095974589,
-0.0324354805,
0.0005365641,
0.0003803667,
-0.0528977327,
0.0186729189,
-0.0071319654,
0.0109038986,
0.0298458599,
0.0221872255,
-0.0358307995,
-0.003667247,
-0.0899670273,
0.0283950847,
-0.0126786092,
0.0240848437,
0.0193941649,
0.009233769,
0.0337189697,
0.0009704769,
-0.0429648347,
-0.0033093477,
-0.0048371293,
0.0287876073,
0.0512303002,
-0.0427202545,
0.0160676111,
-0.0365319028,
-0.0459326468,
-0.0663083196,
0.0290281177,
-0.0272045564,
-0.089773789,
0.0022785575,
0.0346350372,
-0.0538277291,
0.0227968469,
-0.0196226146,
-0.0119234426,
0.003201765,
-0.0312568992,
0.0411704481,
0.0973224938,
0.0117270239,
0.04922444,
0.0146306595,
0.0109791812,
-0.0108904904,
0.0069332547,
-0.0561219342,
0.0517857261,
0.0400233343,
-0.0122002447,
-0.0103184767,
0.1239730045,
0.0171539765,
0.0036840169,
-0.0324776471,
0.0191572066,
0.0000844985,
0.0170056559,
-0.0217511021,
-0.016019946,
-0.0034181904,
-0.0122998143,
-0.0507720113,
-0.016376771,
0.0562091544,
-0.0062901909,
0.0117268125,
-0.0382476635,
0.0053488277,
-0.061074134,
0.0629411042,
0.0640379936,
0.0001600492,
-0.0142666232,
0.0081757158,
-0.0043776562,
-0.0012311953,
-0.020841565,
-0.0344065428,
0.0071204924,
-0.0230056997,
0.014952763,
-0.0157584902,
-0.0283728819,
0.0026301998,
-0.0400166102,
-0.0267254226,
0.0396055952,
-0.0019677747,
-0.0020611489,
-0.0253068469,
0.0052996385,
0.0153801059,
0.028772207,
-0.0031203395,
0.0013739015,
-0.018958671,
0.0606644414,
0.0109619349,
-0.029800998,
0.0488333106,
0.0014181247,
0.0355588123,
0.0782405734,
0.0266138054,
0.0343480855,
-0.0529456437,
0.0125998985,
-0.0015624148,
0.0012832903,
-0.0521451868,
-0.0004300858,
-0.0389421806,
-0.0677171871,
-0.0054905582,
0.1164877042,
0.0340390988,
-0.0120646553,
-0.0078693554,
-0.018552376,
0.0273444541,
0.0264677722,
-0.0245515872,
-0.0497433618,
-0.0346647874,
-0.0088532791,
-0.029164549,
-0.0038747941,
-0.0446027629,
0.0016167294,
-0.1093344316,
-0.0085504334,
-0.0098777348,
-0.0493302047,
-0.0107808728,
-0.037563581,
-0.0184344575,
0.0411184467,
-0.0511894524,
-0.0008790665,
0.0063067037,
-0.0075499024,
-0.0136126056,
-0.0648362711,
0.0054282546,
0.0542525128,
-0.0129950726,
-0.0006506036,
0.0938453227,
0.0421212129,
0.0023765606,
0.0076165348,
0.0280632526,
-0.0269074589,
0.0153715303,
-0.0189458709,
0.025960898,
-0.0469602197,
-0.013332733,
-0.0220695715,
-0.0057222401,
-0.0755105913,
0.0314734131,
-0.0240450669,
0.0784263909,
-0.0020439664,
-0.0620587617,
-0.0343158953,
0.0154255368,
-0.0312462971,
0.0658162311,
0.0199797302,
-0.0209304057,
-0.07083226,
-0.0284027476,
0.0190357119,
-0.030717317,
-0.0295336638,
0.0388018563,
0.0470335372,
-0.0083439033,
-0.0766025633,
-0.0692321956,
-0.0282441657,
-0.0117401304,
-0.0316069089,
-0.0144643402,
0.0355591886,
-0.0361731611,
-0.0539045818,
0.0116824294,
0.0144655714,
-0.001145673,
-0.0282095782,
0.0066482541,
0.0802075192,
0.0557228588,
-0.0389126018,
0.0076838904,
-0.0567100495,
-0.0272814166,
-0.0130614908,
0.100054957,
0.0091143651,
0.016154794,
0.0225689281,
0.0079686362,
-0.0243600793,
0.0275770091,
-0.0539780185,
0.0291685499,
0.0476564355,
0.0249438193,
0.0091283256,
0.0391638502,
-0.0203523859,
0.0581494831,
-0.0071730278,
0.0528479517,
-0.0163930189,
-0.0039890106,
0.0097889993,
-0.026713714,
0.0578294396,
0.0766244754,
-0.0080923261,
-0.0039133201,
0.0462038517,
-0.0588202737,
-0.0335715897,
-0.0419798903,
0.0065278448,
-0.0177470259,
0.024241874,
-0.0742255896,
-0.0500639267,
0.0322236754,
0.0214333627,
0.0040628267,
-0.0207518376,
0.0670530945,
-0.0077108582,
-0.025534533,
0.0089133773,
-0.039107684,
0.0142166819,
-0.0295184199,
0.0097012501,
0.0071868086,
0.0516636334,
0.0027036967,
0.0177085996,
0.0025735984,
0.0089327507,
-0.0665870383,
-0.035857629,
-0.0145655386,
-0.0251983553,
0.0269872192,
-0.0281814244,
0.0141058089,
-0.0020916613,
0.0078327125,
-0.00717645,
0.020949129,
0.018130552,
-0.0369026028,
0.0191643611,
0.0444000959,
-0.0173586495,
-0.0060304618,
0.0566197485,
0.0191879198,
0.0171344355,
0.0417907201,
0.0158748589,
-0.0141086914,
-0.027917942,
0.0237791855,
0.0310817026,
0.0301778186,
0.0225199256,
-0.0719812065,
-0.0262217019,
0.0633110777,
-0.0015135962,
0.0538349263,
-0.0002234322,
0.0444083251,
0.0472583883,
-0.0013759471,
0.0139935501,
-0.0399117358,
0.0047427472,
-0.0665616915,
-0.0388867594,
-0.0579685196,
-6.169137616e-33,
-0.0278779529,
-0.0103384638,
-0.0044461004,
0.0311835632,
-0.0142197069,
0.0348042175,
-0.0277644973,
-0.0020228394,
-0.0120532783,
0.0239946712,
0.009292095,
0.0291999672,
-0.0136441384,
0.0505536273,
0.0240498707,
-0.0131052649,
0.0291241258,
-0.0328160226,
0.0016810443,
0.0234810971,
0.0627761707,
0.029204078,
0.0639203116,
-0.0352004543,
0.0072460934,
-0.0155872954,
0.0162251275,
0.0180066619,
-0.0073211538,
0.0253624804,
-0.0045081233,
0.029129833,
0.0680240169,
-0.0254268367,
0.0107405223,
0.0349281244,
-0.0911905244,
-0.0391216353,
0.0064664502,
0.0082129613,
-0.0464611612,
-0.0043457909,
0.0285397153,
-0.0035747692,
0.0426746085,
-0.0213762317,
0.0166329462,
-0.0120502664,
-0.041582942,
-0.049426958,
-0.0391851589,
0.0201293863,
0.0137814851,
0.0184866749,
0.0079210969,
0.0669139922,
0.0058869096,
0.0850645676,
-0.0594488978,
0.0134462165,
-0.0609516054,
0.0448305197,
-0.0221843049,
-0.0219296105,
0.0062249787,
0.085971728,
0.009730055,
0.0078309868,
-0.0335381739,
0.0509404279,
-0.0320754051,
0.0422430113,
0.0476457812,
-0.0159613639,
0.0466456972,
0.0286770631,
-0.082987085,
-0.009932437,
0.0410720892,
0.0493868217,
0.0323377363,
-0.0071233534,
-0.0433994196,
-0.0100226654,
-0.0028891168,
-0.0370263569,
-0.0439376533,
-0.0198029112,
0.0302537121,
0.0038848785,
-0.0064101447,
-0.0258107167,
-0.0040220278,
-0.0305267181,
0.0019624964,
0.0812881365,
-0.0214812234,
-0.002595247,
0.0025387388,
0.0460682362,
-0.0738305822,
-0.0189375468,
-0.0228079632,
0.001108846,
0.0172146522,
0.0181137156,
0.0558848679,
-0.0026647053,
-0.0639579594,
-0.0269933026,
-0.000439244,
0.0285922196,
-0.0355488956,
0.0858444199,
0.0184895378,
0.0337032788,
-0.0033494441,
0.1024339795,
0.0172405392,
0.004665378,
-0.017649442,
-0.0188542437,
-0.0070233736,
0.0073401574,
0.0193936769,
-0.0366904624,
-0.00494604,
0.0178854261,
-0.0169327501,
-0.0660245121,
-0.0006640591,
0.0140857249,
2.744e-7,
0.0138658118,
0.0389319696,
0.0162768941,
0.0291842278,
0.0506670699,
0.0239422545,
0.0102752596,
0.0235189069,
-0.0120765334,
-0.0539556853,
-0.0203139577,
0.0153483404,
0.0052268496,
-0.0097435229,
-0.1206067055,
0.0404780507,
-0.1012440175,
-0.0248904712,
-0.0066758269,
-0.0313683264,
0.0403030962,
0.1048807502,
0.0092552397,
-0.0084689278,
-0.0252406225,
0.000389146,
0.0878908038,
0.0012445245,
0.0046739806,
-0.0233055688,
-0.0100273788,
0.0128314886,
-0.0400125571,
0.0093849031,
0.017202558,
0.0436905399,
0.0142419655,
0.0760086477,
-0.0058865533,
-0.0433685444,
0.0353476256,
-0.0173943881,
-0.0182294082,
-0.0065117949,
0.0474411324,
-0.0715775639,
-0.0338762105,
-0.0344906151,
-0.0192360524,
0.0209797621,
0.0354043767,
0.0178371146,
-0.0150567936,
-0.012043545,
-0.0152315833,
-0.030033214,
0.0152046923,
-0.0862063095,
-0.0104452204,
-0.0079697566,
0.0007748418,
-0.0016411619,
-0.0231481753,
0.0338742696,
-0.0038040983,
-0.0441537797,
-0.0352384225,
2.473672889e-34,
0.065845795,
-0.0438425429,
-0.0066722655,
0.0452959388,
0.0208245665,
-0.0160048101,
-0.0197407901,
-0.0107009057,
0.0214886814,
-0.0400784947,
-0.0167329051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04359v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04359v1 | Sentiment analysis and opinion mining on educational data: A survey | 2023-02-08T22:14:08 | 2023-02-08T22:14:08 | Thanveer Shaik, Xiaohui Tao, Christopher Dann, Haoran Xie, Yan Li, Linda Galligan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis AKA opinion mining is one of the most widely used NLP
applications to identify human intentions from their reviews. In the education
sector, opinion mining is used to listen to student opinions and enhance their
learning-teaching practices pedagogically. With advancements in sentiment
annotation techniques and AI methodologies, student comments can be labelled
with their sentiment orientation without much human intervention. In this
review article, (1) we consider the role of emotional analysis in education
from four levels: document level, sentence level, entity level, and aspect
level, (2) sentiment annotation techniques including lexicon-based and
corpus-based approaches for unsupervised annotations are explored, (3) the role
of AI in sentiment analysis with methodologies like machine learning, deep
learning, and transformers are discussed, (4) the impact of sentiment analysis
on educational procedures to enhance pedagogy, decision-making, and evaluation
are presented. Educational institutions have been widely invested to build
sentiment analysis tools and process their student feedback to draw their
opinions and insights. Applications built on sentiment analysis of student
feedback are reviewed in this study. Challenges in sentiment analysis like
multi-polarity, polysemous, negation words, and opinion spam detection are
explored and their trends in the research space are discussed. The future
directions of sentiment analysis in education are discussed. | [
0.0552449003,
0.0075584697,
-0.0216311403,
0.0440277904,
-0.0282997899,
0.0319350734,
-0.023102032,
-0.0382472649,
0.0070915157,
-0.0809794068,
-0.0230236333,
-0.0114754308,
-0.0418757349,
0.0053994283,
-0.0361669436,
-0.0341650583,
0.0167735405,
0.0532345548,
0.0412742309,
0.0202496387,
0.0129864784,
0.0337419026,
-0.0397931002,
0.0137977265,
-0.012919982,
-0.0125321252,
0.0051576588,
-0.0052697985,
0.0039559617,
-0.0246600844,
0.0271702576,
0.0263166036,
-0.0530000441,
-0.0050054733,
0.0000020169,
-0.0192771796,
-0.0427706912,
-0.0291745141,
0.0266358126,
-0.0103743877,
0.0750517249,
0.0257748216,
-0.0133490618,
0.0041956916,
-0.0692725629,
-0.0007438739,
0.0271168202,
0.0437517129,
0.0877843276,
0.0535109416,
-0.0068561696,
-0.0377327241,
-0.0142084192,
0.0520131923,
-0.0089599285,
0.0564599708,
0.015296218,
-0.0369186774,
-0.0229501929,
0.0132801468,
-0.0186052043,
-0.0133213811,
-0.04584096,
-0.0462088622,
0.0079892436,
-0.0325997025,
-0.0002945677,
-0.0219879393,
-0.0029833785,
0.0148460837,
0.0101923458,
0.0120224524,
0.0121573862,
-0.0080593061,
-0.0007300228,
0.0016412822,
-0.0056038778,
0.018341789,
-0.0151641648,
0.0314388759,
0.0052540042,
0.0114377784,
-0.0235844776,
0.0497490577,
0.0251119435,
0.0372661613,
-0.0385519676,
-0.0292729568,
0.0291112307,
0.0641377866,
0.0159349833,
0.0164781027,
0.0347680598,
0.0222458243,
0.0359952301,
0.0300315972,
-0.0038989177,
-0.0498311073,
0.016181184,
-0.0910432413,
-0.0223678574,
0.0216097459,
-0.0029861589,
-0.0088646831,
0.0183319338,
-0.0343859866,
0.0296443775,
0.0206772108,
-0.0093649402,
0.0306763873,
-0.0587831996,
0.0205277726,
0.0329358988,
0.0689850524,
0.012318206,
0.0303096958,
-0.0708768591,
-0.0273660477,
-0.0564474389,
0.0218821857,
-0.0176395159,
0.0096174311,
0.0420465469,
0.0342921577,
-0.0394428261,
0.0614699796,
-0.0157935806,
0.0290729757,
-0.0605264753,
0.0264065191,
0.0492585972,
0.0465708338,
0.006624388,
0.0262508951,
0.0056769885,
0.0327283628,
0.0386422835,
-0.0234827679,
-0.0711333379,
-0.0557405464,
0.0085100103,
-0.0230138153,
0.0122854747,
-0.0446346998,
-0.0216458775,
-0.0172622055,
-0.0080031585,
0.0125890877,
0.0243721996,
0.0166753251,
0.0173834339,
0.0269410182,
-0.0457325615,
-0.0431314223,
0.0142330006,
0.009670319,
0.0645106956,
0.0088731088,
0.0122503405,
0.0284527857,
0.0515522435,
-0.0108823832,
0.0186343715,
-0.0336063914,
0.0019581313,
-0.0507542267,
0.0055385139,
-0.0331028514,
-0.0583417974,
-0.0183174256,
-0.0574347675,
0.0402953848,
0.0104057575,
-0.002067171,
-0.0193297826,
0.0026328699,
-0.0570144765,
0.0340786241,
-0.0443265997,
0.0263442192,
0.0320175849,
0.0140425032,
0.0134250904,
0.0117983231,
0.0161232166,
-0.0324790068,
0.0299999081,
-0.0273986515,
0.0154553214,
-0.1054328009,
-0.027363481,
-0.0209042951,
0.0174402185,
-0.0172497313,
0.0317798033,
-0.0239266288,
-0.0326676108,
-0.017354602,
0.0539392158,
-0.095176436,
0.020766763,
-0.0439450331,
0.046025984,
0.0913284421,
0.0159448627,
-0.0283202957,
-0.0450143218,
-0.0439137258,
-0.0454273932,
0.0303740352,
0.0307529811,
-0.0145195536,
-0.029731676,
-0.0481530353,
0.0122901611,
0.0170377735,
-0.0071790684,
-0.0122889504,
-0.0324018598,
0.0426594131,
-0.014011289,
0.005890585,
-0.0456766635,
0.0268918313,
0.0254229009,
-0.0322816707,
0.0074374643,
0.0383688323,
0.0239468589,
0.0675116405,
-0.0054879328,
-0.0156410299,
0.0312088635,
0.0132513251,
-0.065597631,
-0.0265087262,
0.003234552,
-0.0104148891,
0.0422666706,
-0.0772304386,
-0.0137430355,
0.0106552122,
-0.0082584182,
-0.0162785109,
0.0367277376,
-0.0092655923,
0.0200115144,
-0.010074473,
0.0107326265,
-0.0448583327,
0.011085608,
-0.0241783597,
-0.0051287445,
0.0022495841,
0.0141288023,
-0.0406701453,
-0.0469814688,
0.0445009246,
0.0408539511,
-0.0735488385,
-0.0164306201,
0.0180436354,
-0.0031999231,
0.0188044421,
-0.0002630502,
-0.0429514572,
-0.0144437598,
-0.0745000318,
-0.0029645758,
0.0276272297,
0.0303556118,
-0.0160558298,
-0.0398639962,
0.0079826228,
0.0261025168,
-0.0031026658,
-0.0040696589,
-0.0355987884,
-0.0150990291,
0.0481478907,
0.009853242,
0.039565511,
-0.0524485707,
-0.0047634984,
-0.0547801107,
-0.0172538012,
0.0895498171,
-0.0416693129,
0.0039232844,
0.0640598238,
-0.0195701383,
0.0270772278,
0.0204876624,
-0.0516309105,
0.0089216391,
-0.0044555822,
-0.0189665537,
0.0382720493,
0.0157778282,
0.0622278713,
0.0447468162,
0.0086888215,
-0.0186112542,
0.0312534124,
-0.0525428355,
0.0566908121,
-0.0195376817,
0.0062884283,
-0.0047231927,
0.007713106,
0.0124751413,
-0.0603659153,
-0.0092952242,
-0.000383791,
-0.0413542986,
0.0367229469,
0.0030696273,
-0.0291822925,
0.0172382202,
-0.0230225883,
0.0592896603,
0.0149962455,
0.0637240559,
0.0317267776,
0.0267626643,
-0.1149677336,
0.0125411311,
-0.0267618317,
0.0145660043,
-0.0370553657,
-0.0136066303,
-0.0153078996,
0.0370765924,
0.034650322,
-0.0331520699,
-0.0139324171,
-0.0262842476,
0.0036725618,
-0.0194588955,
-0.0327037983,
0.0094483895,
0.0168220773,
0.0001132443,
0.0025421709,
-0.0275358222,
-0.0340723619,
0.0341076702,
-0.017723022,
-0.0029057201,
-0.0490920544,
-0.0284537133,
-0.0407737568,
-0.0135809826,
-0.0415160097,
0.0484796204,
0.016090095,
0.0274760835,
-0.0452897027,
0.0275234189,
-0.0035919852,
0.0114834048,
0.0616484582,
-0.0217542313,
-0.0000758179,
0.0055213897,
-0.0407270193,
0.027136296,
-0.0175675303,
0.0031206,
-0.0430202223,
-0.0137338843,
-0.069500111,
0.022861734,
0.0879852325,
0.0452341773,
-0.0474342853,
-0.0016062481,
-0.0001369911,
-0.0432779379,
-0.0035405117,
0.0190822165,
-0.0397218429,
-0.0124412831,
-0.0766246244,
0.0409688391,
-0.0364488475,
-0.024748167,
0.0137561522,
-0.0720036924,
0.0126646459,
-0.0328589082,
0.0192053206,
-0.0275342893,
-0.0426346213,
-0.0171343926,
0.0032662272,
-0.0261331201,
-0.0709639117,
0.0415913425,
0.0334100835,
0.0533017628,
-0.0410078838,
0.0051578656,
-0.0040242686,
0.022416601,
0.0186262261,
0.0178650841,
0.1047007516,
-0.0644347817,
-0.0596389025,
0.0080343811,
0.008088774,
-0.0273900758,
-0.0084671145,
0.0800048783,
-0.0350477248,
-0.0287129451,
-0.0181220043,
-0.00250721,
-0.0561435409,
0.0327434205,
0.0425870717,
0.0711259022,
-0.031949237,
-0.0108096963,
-0.0814568028,
0.0362078547,
0.0341417752,
0.035890691,
-0.0241593998,
-0.0855619535,
0.018407736,
-0.0227323659,
0.0356126577,
-0.046666313,
-0.0228081699,
-0.0134034622,
-0.0012259418,
-0.013064744,
-0.040216431,
-0.0474231429,
0.0229034889,
0.012170813,
0.002138108,
0.0001675903,
0.0504151583,
0.0281610582,
-0.0530688316,
-0.0022220712,
0.051534988,
0.021597527,
-0.03680465,
-0.0641116947,
0.05437975,
0.0115359398,
-0.0162985157,
-0.0488611385,
0.0009517514,
-0.0360722803,
0.0199031215,
0.0165930763,
0.0023201434,
-0.006393611,
0.0112088816,
-0.0077976161,
0.0186299887,
0.0651146844,
-0.0067632594,
-0.0165728666,
0.0388678201,
0.05766863,
0.011209839,
-0.0018643512,
0.0219774824,
0.0398271792,
0.010222299,
-0.0440423861,
-0.030994121,
-0.0405689888,
-0.0014649094,
0.0160380788,
0.0668462366,
0.0171889085,
-0.015345294,
-0.0168939661,
-0.0091371154,
-0.0105912993,
-0.0341108218,
0.0028453732,
-0.029836569,
-0.008822131,
0.0179685615,
-0.0712042302,
-0.0005351708,
-0.0169064645,
0.0013863205,
0.0328564495,
0.118644692,
0.0297230277,
0.0284366049,
-0.0187657271,
-0.0020968958,
-0.011020585,
-0.0138651468,
0.0254031923,
0.0132851824,
0.0103311157,
0.0295917764,
0.0254740585,
-0.0124758687,
0.0429636016,
0.0205720253,
-0.0003403412,
0.0459574535,
-0.035682179,
0.0149998087,
-0.0540566556,
-0.010581376,
0.0222958084,
-0.0317170806,
0.0274795871,
-0.0019230137,
0.0130188754,
-0.0378957801,
-0.0141471615,
0.0067574992,
-0.0201528575,
-0.0047542183,
-0.0254813209,
0.0010091693,
-0.0873797089,
0.0349702388,
0.0151549717,
-0.0308196135,
-0.0345607735,
0.0200106446,
0.0453527421,
0.0086567132,
0.0398855433,
0.0682811588,
-0.0476860926,
0.0002332408,
0.0585376509,
0.0037117796,
0.0396640934,
-0.0381137915,
0.0309955068,
0.0302421506,
-0.0069453106,
0.0593171529,
-0.0638839379,
0.0240877084,
-0.0431704596,
-0.025302995,
-0.006813156,
-5.750110615e-33,
-0.0286679119,
-0.0467842892,
-0.0487257056,
0.0882836133,
-0.0047248537,
-0.0200445745,
-0.0090531465,
0.0654519498,
-0.0202790629,
0.0576928183,
0.0162070021,
0.0343609974,
-0.0196351241,
0.0373261645,
0.056763038,
0.0035789579,
0.0312010106,
-0.0211989358,
0.046631027,
0.0101307118,
0.0641284063,
0.00215313,
0.0771968737,
-0.1327532381,
0.0608934015,
0.0033672324,
-0.0403520726,
-0.0180218238,
-0.0171688031,
0.0316188224,
-0.0119398134,
0.0752211139,
0.0053265323,
-0.0039702859,
0.0282863658,
-0.0097271949,
0.0065557393,
-0.0557430983,
-0.0314071625,
0.0203919206,
-0.0162810087,
-0.031909354,
0.0348756388,
0.0437348597,
-0.0556963682,
0.0184158795,
0.0631303564,
-0.0025521917,
0.0525043309,
-0.0685113221,
-0.0563555397,
0.0282266568,
-0.0408805907,
-0.0122931041,
0.0123253716,
0.0360127017,
0.0115065202,
0.006620768,
-0.0716631562,
0.0534176603,
-0.0062731863,
-0.0048297984,
-0.019892687,
-0.0551662855,
-0.0260766484,
0.0892070234,
0.0195561536,
0.0155408559,
-0.0126125179,
0.0451262332,
0.0439363718,
0.0010551339,
0.0562278964,
0.0435266197,
0.0014082276,
-0.0470014028,
-0.0147819519,
0.0453943536,
0.0536615215,
-0.0291472748,
0.0296602659,
-0.0330824442,
-0.0480001979,
-0.0014307195,
0.0533988252,
-0.0476667546,
0.0074631111,
0.0048549715,
-0.0204468723,
-0.0681669638,
-0.046501454,
-0.0009149788,
-0.0420700721,
-0.0461650975,
-0.0267354157,
0.0247398429,
-0.033228185,
0.0342083834,
-0.0219042804,
-0.0185907036,
-0.0301616509,
0.0141071565,
-0.0388197415,
-0.0134148961,
0.014084612,
-0.0082402211,
0.037026383,
0.0263116192,
-0.052683413,
-0.0314125866,
0.0184096005,
0.0133673102,
0.0163121987,
0.0100132488,
-0.0426608473,
0.0108400146,
-0.0089980001,
0.0458547063,
0.011157861,
0.0670213401,
-0.0163759552,
-0.0036053655,
0.0133307241,
-0.023968827,
-0.0208233874,
-0.0618198551,
-0.0007541592,
-0.0316728018,
-0.0470408686,
-0.0922178552,
0.0204468928,
-0.0375441909,
2.727e-7,
0.0494826101,
0.0819585919,
-0.0129835038,
-0.0702856556,
0.0063846968,
0.0696985945,
0.0256912317,
-0.0172146987,
0.0178381447,
0.0080218595,
0.0176880397,
-0.0109706419,
-0.0080975583,
0.0305153113,
-0.1051191986,
-0.003114677,
0.0465479083,
-0.029145645,
-0.0138632096,
0.0522046424,
0.1260967851,
0.0462389067,
0.0644981712,
0.0018109239,
-0.0276981331,
0.0546996631,
-0.0229078345,
-0.0055312165,
0.0163666643,
0.0117422296,
-0.006093482,
-0.0424804911,
0.0016077507,
-0.0021202536,
-0.012127148,
0.0081883147,
0.0242073238,
0.0212722495,
0.0140774446,
-0.048359219,
0.0515390635,
0.0322617367,
0.0188988093,
0.0226226822,
0.0156656578,
-0.0156954005,
-0.0137486719,
-0.0593437366,
-0.0083925631,
0.0180478729,
0.0382790715,
-0.0047544134,
-0.0341547877,
0.006679303,
-0.0109669175,
-0.067579776,
-0.0058642426,
-0.0479452498,
0.020539239,
-0.0243524015,
0.008080719,
-0.0026057453,
0.0571976416,
0.0220708717,
0.0418603681,
0.0110045895,
0.0163042992,
1.732725394e-34,
0.0545021631,
-0.0424510241,
0.0156104965,
-0.0127026439,
0.0104224272,
0.0456419587,
-0.0463529639,
-0.0204063989,
0.0242146626,
-0.003764838,
0.0097292764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04343v1 | CRL+: A Novel Semi-Supervised Deep Active Contrastive Representation Learning-Based Text Classification Model for Insurance Data | 2023-02-08T21:23:52 | 2023-02-08T21:23:52 | Amir Namavar Jahromi, Ebrahim Pourjafari, Hadis Karimipour, Amit Satpathy, Lovell Hodge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Financial sector and especially the insurance industry collect vast volumes
of text on a daily basis and through multiple channels (their agents, customer
care centers, emails, social networks, and web in general). The information
collected includes policies, expert and health reports, claims and complaints,
results of surveys, and relevant social media posts. It is difficult to
effectively extract label, classify, and interpret the essential information
from such varied and unstructured material. Therefore, the Insurance Industry
is among the ones that can benefit from applying technologies for the
intelligent analysis of free text through Natural Language Processing (NLP).
In this paper, CRL+, a novel text classification model combining Contrastive
Representation Learning (CRL) and Active Learning is proposed to handle the
challenge of using semi-supervised learning for text classification. In this
method, supervised (CRL) is used to train a RoBERTa transformer model to encode
the textual data into a contrastive representation space and then classify
using a classification layer. This (CRL)-based transformer model is used as the
base model in the proposed Active Learning mechanism to classify all the data
in an iterative manner. The proposed model is evaluated using unstructured
obituary data with objective to determine the cause of the death from the data.
This model is compared with the CRL model and an Active Learning model with the
RoBERTa base model. The experiment shows that the proposed method can
outperform both methods for this specific task. | [
0.0336172618,
0.0651160777,
0.0011326669,
-0.0001963035,
-0.0386992656,
0.0551772974,
0.0018968342,
0.039334543,
0.0272477455,
-0.0690024048,
0.007080737,
-0.0367504209,
-0.0229236726,
0.0247119125,
-0.04159927,
-0.0709800199,
-0.0119537432,
0.0217111241,
0.0455732048,
0.0193133429,
-0.0026400359,
0.0417021215,
0.0027554417,
0.0153045859,
-0.0023475767,
0.0104436427,
0.0107674673,
-0.0204666834,
0.0237628929,
-0.0162382573,
0.0277822055,
0.0192539766,
0.0296025444,
-0.0082124136,
0.0000021293,
-0.0331540257,
-0.0656553358,
0.011012949,
-0.0067403801,
-0.0154364621,
0.0669371709,
-0.0218334701,
-0.0026672387,
0.0079801464,
-0.0483025424,
-0.033126615,
0.0307880286,
0.0876979083,
0.0353012159,
0.0898967013,
-0.0379283316,
-0.089507319,
0.0534355901,
-0.0100172618,
-0.0100793513,
-0.0409432985,
0.0405758098,
0.018983556,
-0.0093881506,
-0.0021605766,
-0.0166393314,
0.0530875511,
0.0288756583,
0.008523942,
0.0093873665,
0.0194291193,
-0.0069254478,
-0.0016177794,
0.0175159872,
0.0121621871,
-0.0157472547,
-0.0058984444,
0.0270179585,
-0.0600510687,
0.0126803359,
0.0088151293,
0.0150573449,
0.0381539762,
-0.0224947613,
0.018919073,
0.039871309,
0.0570549443,
-0.0161230415,
-0.0146599114,
-0.0121836318,
-0.0449812524,
-0.0266657453,
-0.0303533413,
0.0253483485,
0.0062792418,
0.0094398679,
0.001414706,
0.0581364632,
-0.0074303383,
0.0040318533,
-0.0035824559,
-0.00774854,
-0.0899910182,
0.0658254325,
-0.1108250469,
0.0067872512,
-0.0475666113,
-0.0428516418,
0.0417926684,
0.0007826628,
-0.0224358216,
0.0229173917,
-0.005023527,
-0.0068268739,
0.0117719397,
-0.055091694,
-0.0072351466,
-0.0078876261,
0.0909011886,
0.0034111552,
0.0052663083,
-0.0614616834,
0.01166372,
-0.0106090838,
-0.0162593909,
0.0204687342,
0.0400442816,
-0.0211437643,
0.0183761399,
-0.0275173653,
-0.0231757518,
0.0163442455,
0.0092293024,
-0.0668379962,
-0.0062477188,
0.0705139488,
0.0430264845,
0.048578959,
-0.0319865458,
0.0318750776,
0.0419847481,
-0.0042559491,
-0.0931469873,
-0.0600847267,
0.0178395174,
0.0058682719,
0.0048363362,
-0.0493897721,
-0.0182494372,
-0.0235676914,
-0.0150908651,
-0.0314865187,
-0.0357249975,
0.0054399054,
-0.0154266171,
-0.0313154906,
0.0569981076,
0.0026114122,
-0.0265918989,
0.0521451384,
-0.0299858358,
0.0279219057,
0.0245208479,
0.0135620739,
-0.0003889487,
0.0216397792,
0.007537432,
0.0150268869,
-0.01434833,
0.0230451263,
-0.0449188016,
-0.0180739965,
0.0403158776,
-0.0582160614,
-0.0266790111,
-0.0180328079,
0.0284881201,
0.0076805679,
-0.0044883871,
0.0240225643,
0.0032013648,
0.0186609533,
0.0837202072,
0.028315613,
0.0595531985,
-0.0224701706,
-0.0146490345,
0.0084669916,
-0.0049818046,
-0.0290660448,
0.0065624979,
-0.0181141365,
-0.0105002318,
-0.0414760932,
-0.0381511152,
0.011295368,
-0.0390546322,
0.0382350199,
-0.0213423744,
0.0660229623,
0.0068225353,
-0.080040656,
0.0165807996,
0.0204450469,
0.0045095445,
-0.0367409103,
-0.0490739271,
-0.0041446104,
0.0486351661,
-0.0005469768,
-0.0657384098,
-0.0237653404,
-0.0417101346,
0.0226771086,
0.026481241,
0.0333929956,
0.0273430087,
-0.0124236606,
-0.0484489016,
-0.038753584,
0.0327378809,
0.0136676179,
0.0049713561,
-0.0444288962,
0.0316124372,
0.0188391302,
0.0319155641,
-0.0660820454,
0.0252134483,
0.0011293982,
-0.0592324957,
0.0204949901,
0.0201397873,
-0.0000573825,
0.0087544303,
-0.0348197706,
-0.0274679661,
0.0155497156,
-0.0284373574,
-0.0758816898,
0.0046135224,
-0.0295031331,
0.0044220281,
-0.0520525239,
-0.0492081307,
-0.0144704105,
0.0560027212,
-0.0263371225,
-0.0173806567,
-0.0496128276,
-0.0372547433,
-0.0142539535,
-0.0560648516,
0.0201719198,
-0.0023679258,
0.0139698228,
-0.032417465,
0.0931605473,
-0.0176760405,
0.0122555504,
-0.0068955529,
-0.0581573397,
0.0016798325,
-0.0439222082,
-0.0253923424,
-0.0410250351,
-0.0210317969,
0.037967138,
0.0362319537,
0.0133007951,
0.0025589545,
0.0128828771,
-0.0319603719,
0.0262794439,
-0.0408117957,
0.002956487,
0.0071321921,
0.0285742469,
0.0025728124,
-0.0223383754,
-0.0445230454,
-0.0175650027,
0.003637515,
-0.0236575138,
0.042059686,
-0.012224975,
0.0231648292,
-0.0083197765,
-0.0137844747,
-0.004879138,
0.0385271199,
0.0462684929,
-0.0606314577,
-0.0396440737,
0.0369924195,
0.0435672551,
0.0176412147,
0.0257812534,
-0.0197309926,
-0.0433494784,
-0.0112186084,
-0.0529309213,
0.0444485918,
0.0429060273,
0.0356635898,
-0.0504469387,
0.030154435,
-0.0204960126,
0.0380914994,
-0.0822422728,
0.0228528809,
-0.011191058,
-0.0547867343,
-0.0097392714,
0.0410088301,
0.0124921026,
-0.0104341218,
-0.0361288376,
-0.0648444146,
0.0026094289,
0.0328242294,
-0.0001704306,
0.0173357651,
0.0054856371,
0.0048650424,
0.0192711093,
-0.0363708064,
0.0186189581,
0.0595594607,
0.0300625563,
-0.0830660239,
-0.0590215996,
-0.0429342315,
0.0516777337,
0.0059796269,
0.0185328834,
0.0042532082,
-0.0452150404,
-0.0099176075,
-0.0582789257,
0.0044398922,
-0.0049126684,
0.0039606662,
0.0260856915,
0.0121243773,
-0.0212496463,
-0.0396258794,
-0.0479301438,
-0.085400708,
-0.002823073,
0.030307401,
0.0345454141,
0.0086401589,
-0.0436320528,
0.0453390814,
-0.0400348753,
0.0587159768,
0.0213028509,
-0.0344819725,
-0.0203741454,
0.0350967199,
0.0534192808,
-0.0291007403,
0.0177753922,
-0.0178353768,
0.0294805188,
0.0416324213,
-0.0304324757,
0.0404838547,
-0.0326513685,
-0.0152111743,
-0.0183431432,
-0.0829407051,
-0.0077102454,
-0.0085608056,
-0.0611128546,
-0.0180139467,
0.0065422081,
0.0758942515,
0.0341682322,
-0.065757513,
-0.0148507431,
-0.0098686758,
-0.0567333251,
-0.0220788959,
0.0469067246,
-0.0171875916,
-0.0096268374,
-0.0277835242,
-0.005432101,
0.0186317228,
-0.0231040157,
0.0433950089,
-0.0196404401,
0.0459373966,
-0.0115287909,
-0.0036471158,
-0.0087098368,
-0.0149656162,
-0.0247340016,
-0.0437148511,
-0.0044340463,
-0.0170745943,
-0.0348450243,
-0.0206108652,
0.0222615805,
-0.0660530254,
-0.012915195,
-0.0031310141,
-0.0120961424,
-0.0175682679,
0.0298672188,
0.0348378718,
-0.0481109135,
-0.037080165,
0.0221660044,
-0.0428036526,
0.0033725849,
-0.0154653359,
0.1188047826,
0.0045017125,
-0.0033742564,
-0.0371371023,
-0.0033996799,
-0.0402911901,
0.0040953825,
-0.0187808499,
0.0329902396,
-0.0528078079,
-0.0219716895,
-0.0469482318,
0.0200112239,
0.0211364869,
0.0246055014,
-0.0213661324,
-0.0773973018,
-0.0424630716,
0.0280621257,
0.0324738398,
-0.0065379175,
-0.0153825628,
0.0096302927,
-0.0500687174,
-0.057225652,
-0.0606134757,
0.0043779956,
-0.0014395349,
0.0380061194,
-0.0108854156,
-0.0075984765,
0.0380300768,
-0.0555638634,
-0.0703897625,
-0.0054026563,
-0.0038232061,
0.0203881394,
0.007510582,
-0.0461397655,
0.0516870581,
-0.0395731591,
-0.0546859577,
-0.0651310608,
-0.0138606308,
0.000844114,
0.0148960054,
0.000177487,
0.0112573197,
0.0175395943,
-0.0063703647,
-0.0324409977,
0.095928587,
0.0501940288,
-0.0532854237,
-0.0508938432,
0.0403975993,
-0.0420697033,
0.0075324648,
0.006709266,
-0.0321092606,
0.0219663121,
0.0139578665,
-0.0082450714,
-0.015169749,
0.0181618128,
-0.023975499,
-0.0216888394,
0.03991732,
0.030885037,
-0.0243100692,
-0.0362489261,
0.0202843491,
0.0283253454,
0.0008896867,
-0.0296150241,
0.0399743989,
0.044013083,
0.0515514165,
-0.0368989408,
0.0159733184,
-0.0090464158,
-0.0125389537,
-0.0057135485,
0.0462941788,
0.053931728,
0.023558965,
0.0029632463,
0.0155929849,
0.0070617292,
0.0131763984,
0.0461542234,
0.03936157,
0.0312457941,
0.0191209428,
-0.0000262634,
0.0530829467,
-0.0318883024,
0.0162610319,
-0.0275408495,
-0.0165446978,
-0.0450072922,
0.0120026888,
0.0544584952,
-0.0415305495,
0.0025013424,
-0.0354801863,
0.0251820758,
0.0370671451,
0.0340364501,
0.0329295136,
-0.0046021221,
0.0002327114,
-0.0023552289,
-0.0188999698,
0.0198260564,
0.0385414436,
0.0364981256,
0.0008482683,
-0.0067509837,
-0.0242825374,
-0.0486258417,
0.0020798456,
0.0882614851,
0.0320011079,
-0.0156835653,
-0.013216448,
-0.0057970271,
-0.0609981008,
0.0783747435,
-0.0391035043,
-0.0235010628,
-0.0129569592,
0.0498755053,
0.0196472649,
0.0461413711,
0.0069586327,
-0.0370134115,
0.0088629499,
0.0036081395,
0.0109434985,
-0.0053231204,
-6.30255696e-33,
0.0124036856,
-0.020025352,
-0.0149924047,
0.0263791773,
0.0116354916,
0.0562477633,
0.0359104909,
-0.032791853,
0.0417619608,
0.0077786362,
0.005564753,
0.035630729,
0.0156102972,
0.043371696,
0.0206271783,
-0.0366808958,
0.0069567924,
0.0120598422,
0.0183315743,
0.0293878093,
0.0015356629,
0.0714928806,
0.0425326526,
-0.1101521477,
0.0286820102,
0.0234856587,
-0.015021407,
-0.0016138972,
0.0385083631,
0.0462275222,
-0.0237354171,
0.0268114917,
0.0437923037,
-0.0451721847,
0.0076976684,
0.0314887017,
-0.0696925297,
-0.0359795839,
0.0101857595,
0.0310971215,
-0.0069120773,
-0.004462746,
0.0364971012,
0.0185766295,
0.0123796677,
-0.0106528206,
0.0760432929,
0.0025567252,
0.0176368281,
-0.0618154518,
-0.0361208916,
0.0616955832,
-0.0394936651,
0.0480077714,
0.0358823724,
-0.0075008413,
-0.0123752877,
0.0406559892,
-0.0660898983,
-0.0820308998,
-0.0071807979,
-0.0108879758,
-0.0344964266,
-0.0250719152,
-0.038979914,
0.0442153402,
0.0033294694,
0.0120571591,
-0.0228965115,
-0.0043216636,
-0.0226103552,
0.0523438044,
0.00575634,
0.0655967668,
0.0362651795,
-0.0433452949,
-0.0633536279,
0.0609517246,
0.0432942174,
-0.0298456848,
0.0615332834,
-0.0054765698,
-0.0577733405,
0.0031932301,
0.0166177936,
-0.0136613939,
-0.0195005145,
-0.0112622827,
0.0044286815,
0.0292254854,
-0.0114258947,
0.0430720262,
-0.0105685061,
-0.0448054001,
-0.0293041933,
-0.005906512,
0.006394574,
0.0237227324,
-0.0178826898,
-0.0251243114,
-0.0261162482,
-0.0616865084,
-0.030445924,
0.0190061852,
0.0074483259,
0.0225064177,
0.0636652261,
0.0336969085,
-0.0563499257,
0.0067654001,
0.0525848716,
-0.0202735681,
0.0147258015,
0.0581051111,
-0.0166000091,
0.0273182727,
0.0050033513,
0.0327396169,
0.0363697261,
0.013089939,
0.0017720313,
-0.0545494147,
-0.0102576502,
0.0161716174,
-0.0165277831,
-0.0314857662,
0.0053932271,
0.0367113799,
0.0318118818,
-0.0772721693,
-0.0005910377,
-0.009993745,
2.869e-7,
0.0991331562,
0.0361248963,
-0.022720376,
-0.0228563584,
0.0104376478,
0.0447593965,
0.0678927973,
0.0425998233,
0.0244793594,
0.0659994483,
0.0532284193,
-0.025593685,
0.0185680073,
0.0186748002,
-0.1312859952,
0.0037875201,
-0.0644302517,
0.0079445774,
-0.0452301465,
0.0596123338,
0.1009712592,
0.0748518333,
0.0097189806,
-0.0615082011,
0.006751237,
-0.0115240756,
0.0260888543,
-0.0470538847,
0.0218547918,
-0.0098981056,
0.0017199753,
0.0266540106,
0.0057775737,
0.0473587215,
-0.0054825074,
0.0377471335,
0.0083226701,
0.0537594892,
-0.0243802164,
-0.0186529234,
0.0581848137,
-0.0169968829,
0.0125340894,
0.0092943925,
0.070291765,
-0.0434289612,
-0.0654200241,
-0.0247035492,
-0.081637457,
-0.0086965123,
0.0339735448,
0.019943472,
-0.0249676518,
0.0388265997,
0.009346704,
-0.0102047157,
-0.0439541303,
-0.0724588558,
0.0320738629,
0.0259680487,
0.0103049604,
0.0141614536,
-0.0171383861,
0.0352663621,
0.0413777269,
-0.0302292593,
0.0528017096,
2.571581926e-34,
0.042379681,
0.0355086252,
-0.0249641445,
0.0116367461,
-0.0130085684,
0.0028382689,
0.0482695214,
0.0187580343,
-0.0066339229,
-0.0762962475,
0.0084823016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04269v1 | Diagnosing and Rectifying Vision Models using Language | 2023-02-08T18:59:42 | 2023-02-08T18:59:42 | Yuhui Zhang, Jeff Z. HaoChen, Shih-Cheng Huang, Kuan-Chieh Wang, James Zou, Serena Yeung | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Recent multi-modal contrastive learning models have demonstrated the ability
to learn an embedding space suitable for building strong vision classifiers, by
leveraging the rich information in large-scale image-caption datasets. Our work
highlights a distinct advantage of this multi-modal embedding space: the
ability to diagnose vision classifiers through natural language. The
traditional process of diagnosing model behaviors in deployment settings
involves labor-intensive data acquisition and annotation. Our proposed method
can discover high-error data slices, identify influential attributes and
further rectify undesirable model behaviors, without requiring any visual data.
Through a combination of theoretical explanation and empirical verification, we
present conditions under which classifiers trained on embeddings from one
modality can be equivalently applied to embeddings from another modality. On a
range of image datasets with known error slices, we demonstrate that our method
can effectively identify the error slices and influential attributes, and can
further use language to rectify failure modes of the classifier. | [
-0.0014731457,
0.0939416289,
0.0135423923,
0.0568493828,
-0.012879367,
0.0406577811,
-0.0049681216,
0.0011896933,
-0.0015514459,
-0.103085652,
0.008504401,
-0.0158748943,
0.0118937921,
0.0459769443,
0.0291263424,
-0.0668253675,
0.0313302279,
-0.0148528619,
-0.0242608637,
0.0016635287,
0.0123731382,
-0.0133283241,
0.0153040355,
0.0525353439,
-0.0200688634,
-0.0244789422,
-0.0093336767,
0.0009485539,
0.0264719427,
-0.0212800317,
-0.0040448043,
0.0415778384,
0.0280469265,
-0.0022024428,
0.0000019802,
0.0007376418,
0.0205885973,
0.0166084468,
-0.0004495726,
0.0019828673,
0.0570841171,
-0.0578594245,
0.0256260578,
0.0071136607,
-0.0259942729,
-0.0427028909,
0.0677214488,
0.0645071641,
0.0639550984,
0.024974443,
-0.0133320745,
-0.036155045,
0.0218638964,
0.0113304518,
-0.0207591988,
-0.0070987586,
0.0240652785,
0.0161399394,
-0.0267597791,
0.0017855611,
-0.0298950002,
0.0149224671,
0.0028198794,
0.0172615089,
-0.0134285586,
0.0322321765,
-0.0055507235,
-0.0386447757,
-0.0323065594,
0.0664582625,
0.0104848919,
0.0223214645,
-0.0069342991,
-0.018583158,
0.0137714194,
0.0273813996,
0.0153001789,
-0.0018570208,
-0.000704817,
0.0179447904,
-0.0241204351,
0.0044121663,
0.0257129073,
-0.0040117581,
-0.0353433862,
-0.0466184467,
-0.0109978197,
0.025351204,
-0.049797982,
0.0126554156,
-0.043722529,
-0.0145831397,
-0.0322397053,
-0.0075506438,
-0.0131361634,
-0.0084548518,
-0.0706996247,
-0.0314163826,
0.0226445794,
-0.0183912236,
0.061873585,
-0.014989377,
-0.0817904025,
0.0822592527,
-0.0087749399,
0.0432243608,
-0.0298716333,
0.0249566734,
-0.0120321922,
-0.0255809911,
-0.0456260666,
0.0086719124,
0.0124359708,
0.0021838031,
0.0067413305,
-0.0520933457,
-0.0265110079,
-0.0011313685,
-0.0454708934,
0.0319245867,
-0.0212942325,
0.019938292,
-0.017848039,
0.0027761173,
-0.0330995843,
0.0084103849,
0.0311191063,
0.009338079,
-0.0169755053,
-0.0713915825,
0.0121221533,
0.0518177189,
-0.0000199548,
0.0126033742,
0.0032719551,
0.0874805972,
-0.0009027886,
-0.0415182859,
-0.0626199841,
-0.0324018449,
-0.0721976534,
-0.0025094843,
-0.000947681,
-0.0559955612,
-0.0248658862,
0.0086242901,
0.0161533188,
-0.0084366063,
0.0238748938,
-0.0324488133,
-0.0371354744,
0.1479165554,
-0.0572586022,
-0.0385657623,
-0.0121328272,
0.0009085485,
-0.0129646137,
0.0659381077,
0.0156117957,
-0.0226374939,
0.0187009089,
-0.0159333218,
0.0625399426,
-0.0048176944,
-0.0031210724,
0.0034067605,
-0.0556979589,
-0.0065610902,
0.0066758352,
-0.0067723077,
0.0259179212,
0.0342268832,
-0.0021010069,
-0.0345211439,
0.0374377519,
0.0321841016,
0.0112801827,
0.0129697165,
0.0517121963,
0.0125751933,
-0.0303490926,
-0.0057255575,
-0.0463741086,
0.0124244774,
-0.0152306762,
-0.0145831434,
0.0066352827,
0.0290121287,
-0.0403623171,
-0.0583020709,
-0.0418092795,
-0.0379829705,
0.0003163128,
-0.0145564983,
0.0844311714,
-0.0293624587,
-0.0125010842,
0.0135224722,
0.0353400894,
-0.0068839821,
-0.0305069946,
-0.0696923211,
0.0128594553,
0.0513079539,
-0.0075575709,
-0.0462804176,
-0.011821893,
0.0069202934,
0.025470892,
-0.0129387835,
0.01747844,
-0.0048136152,
0.031051822,
-0.0323589146,
-0.0470962971,
-0.0050782035,
0.0279822778,
-0.008783157,
-0.048360765,
-0.0144174369,
0.0205033235,
-0.0260249823,
-0.0339002647,
0.0418985784,
0.049137257,
-0.0134106381,
-0.0122413188,
0.0376989022,
0.0337044708,
-0.0088717062,
-0.0194760356,
-0.0180011056,
0.0169989895,
-0.0167039856,
-0.020473877,
0.0453185774,
-0.0073447973,
-0.0108458381,
0.0456534028,
-0.0688163936,
-0.0104492465,
0.031433057,
-0.0719225407,
-0.0185426734,
0.0383525044,
-0.0608622245,
-0.0148823662,
-0.0215437952,
0.0072564539,
0.0011546316,
0.0255524497,
-0.0039112787,
0.069927521,
-0.0276421607,
-0.0125633497,
0.0324239433,
-0.0261271857,
0.0225736815,
0.0074032201,
-0.0340941697,
-0.0092322733,
-0.0156997088,
0.0348681286,
-0.0135019729,
-0.0094601819,
-0.0294258203,
0.0195056424,
-0.0676170662,
-0.0680164322,
-0.0118363546,
-0.0298850853,
-0.0164321177,
-0.0447827354,
0.021128891,
-0.0331794508,
0.0003308452,
0.0065921755,
-0.0017204093,
0.0062967101,
0.0466848426,
0.0170274042,
-0.0307285618,
-0.0218579434,
0.0038934054,
-0.0011676771,
0.0812559873,
0.0108245024,
0.0082100611,
-0.0788425654,
0.0251362249,
0.0079593826,
0.0582562946,
-0.0154952593,
-0.0413793102,
0.0129595511,
-0.0023984713,
-0.0356453434,
0.0780118331,
-0.0083356733,
0.0781061277,
0.0249281842,
0.0135325622,
-0.0112529946,
-0.0236575194,
-0.004072343,
-0.0171997547,
-0.004038081,
-0.0316077061,
-0.0504618771,
0.0706244782,
-0.0049124938,
-0.0113509344,
-0.0527789667,
0.0526319481,
-0.005333751,
-0.0056824856,
-0.0124405082,
0.0168869644,
0.0181663167,
0.0354082733,
-0.0136827091,
-0.0584045984,
0.063060753,
-0.0308552943,
0.0105144847,
0.0260663461,
-0.0480308719,
0.0102528222,
0.0393591002,
-0.0012982177,
0.0197988041,
0.0488477424,
-0.007316452,
-0.0156696998,
-0.0394674428,
0.0198295098,
0.002780694,
0.0784076229,
-0.0650923401,
0.0141103938,
-0.0197283141,
-0.0546603799,
-0.0276604127,
-0.0409900025,
-0.0464704931,
0.0010274928,
-0.0130605511,
-0.0344507433,
-0.0418314822,
0.0160716511,
0.0121733593,
0.0281518698,
0.0132972812,
-0.0531635173,
-0.0256852116,
0.0310897809,
0.0118324785,
0.0332201645,
0.0069300989,
-0.0470488071,
0.0015058776,
0.0530247316,
0.0025706873,
0.0391041189,
-0.1163795888,
0.0031321999,
0.0114008905,
0.0518474504,
-0.0203272421,
0.0172499511,
0.0391640626,
-0.0505373627,
-0.009056665,
0.046945475,
-0.0065236348,
-0.0315579399,
-0.0017559377,
0.0265370645,
-0.0013718775,
0.0367043018,
-0.0257376228,
-0.062889941,
-0.0693577006,
-0.020251533,
0.0232527889,
0.0145812519,
0.0351148397,
0.0174788944,
-0.0703463256,
0.0654306784,
-0.0020427676,
-0.0230142567,
-0.0739157274,
-0.0008632008,
-0.0242928229,
-0.0582165532,
-0.0190935377,
-0.0454682447,
-0.0201523285,
0.0067013176,
0.0138643337,
-0.0008903777,
-0.0622995831,
0.019389594,
-0.0506757945,
0.0104649635,
0.02803123,
0.0044017825,
0.0033304726,
-0.064482443,
0.0032925177,
-0.0330255404,
0.0179236159,
0.0116808563,
0.0751655102,
-0.0268452503,
-0.0454633906,
0.006477192,
0.0215692334,
-0.0427743569,
-0.0147545552,
-0.0562984869,
0.0717715546,
-0.0109398859,
0.0229229145,
-0.0448271409,
0.0151739186,
0.0240462124,
0.037405327,
0.011574355,
-0.0308366083,
-0.0357983075,
0.0160146598,
0.0239215326,
-0.0190730505,
-0.0277523994,
0.022473529,
0.0332560092,
0.0160222854,
-0.0418622196,
-0.0108534992,
-0.0038558112,
0.0225908756,
-0.0084323781,
-0.057724677,
-0.0433046073,
0.0159675032,
-0.0580390617,
0.0789917856,
0.0058591384,
0.0136797028,
-0.0304752141,
0.0041415552,
0.0738427565,
-0.0118011199,
-0.0466759056,
0.0130203264,
-0.0486845411,
-0.0438371226,
-0.0317638107,
0.0776090026,
0.0097416053,
0.0185002238,
0.0088198194,
-0.0365076847,
0.0237079561,
0.0664833412,
0.0297281761,
-0.0040821489,
0.0697838441,
-0.0341948234,
-0.0082116928,
0.0236795917,
-0.0251185317,
-0.011360365,
-0.0074674743,
-0.0517639518,
-0.0569115393,
-0.0188796334,
0.0101452926,
-0.0314635932,
0.0958805159,
-0.0347219221,
-0.0288621448,
-0.0084227175,
-0.0078752246,
0.0107042314,
-0.0171991326,
-0.0733965486,
0.0496919937,
-0.00114949,
-0.011460783,
0.0171980225,
0.0206485968,
0.0025175428,
-0.0016767208,
-0.0250756647,
0.0490284786,
0.0852595642,
-0.0219218526,
-0.0100286519,
0.0109747509,
0.0070438543,
-0.0137261488,
-0.0042860322,
0.0211236719,
0.0086711356,
0.0620790422,
0.0240082201,
0.0253183618,
-0.0293967761,
0.0289352443,
-0.0165093951,
-0.0314887352,
-0.0508871861,
0.0281049944,
0.0547918864,
-0.0132985422,
-0.0022511536,
-0.0131563302,
-0.0184306968,
-0.0193259399,
0.0524351075,
0.0105234776,
0.0006100321,
0.0826578662,
0.0505434051,
-0.0274260882,
0.006798482,
0.0517717749,
0.0092544928,
0.0264197122,
-0.0049961139,
-0.017035868,
-0.0321739577,
0.0086315153,
0.0664916933,
0.0006123139,
-0.0361550413,
0.0246549416,
-0.0479085445,
-0.0767783597,
0.0169744864,
0.0418614745,
0.0124771213,
0.0231209211,
0.0046078162,
0.0728164688,
0.0525282882,
-0.0167154558,
-0.0287859179,
-0.0308548789,
-0.0093157357,
0.0346735716,
0.0140032172,
-6.104555222e-33,
-0.0110740056,
-0.0612861551,
0.0118968552,
-0.0310037211,
0.0270903558,
0.033690054,
-0.0106918635,
0.0246639438,
-0.0222555771,
0.0287621133,
0.0366423503,
0.0124165528,
0.0022284379,
0.0319694057,
0.0232205577,
-0.0170099139,
0.0321816243,
-0.0032594893,
-0.0123253921,
-0.0161195062,
0.0492074266,
-0.0292633437,
0.0240331832,
-0.1124608368,
-0.006783525,
0.0438171253,
-0.0338445716,
0.0159950331,
0.0031061324,
0.0721252263,
-0.0202307608,
0.0172680654,
0.0086422814,
-0.0177789442,
-0.0178637858,
-0.0050627813,
-0.0270936061,
0.0077710836,
-0.007559909,
0.0375497006,
-0.0794960856,
0.0058748005,
0.0379204452,
-0.0235016365,
0.0058786236,
-0.0337166823,
0.0700412616,
-0.0369105116,
0.019482784,
0.0464380458,
-0.0540816002,
0.037584655,
-0.0183862932,
-0.0402783751,
0.049554199,
0.0396650955,
0.0545021929,
0.0521453433,
-0.0461951718,
0.0117537715,
0.0355188958,
-0.0074177752,
0.0814306438,
0.0520756021,
-0.0197562333,
0.0713621676,
0.0273629595,
-0.0485716946,
0.0206972808,
-0.0450753644,
0.0097037181,
0.0827209577,
0.0858065933,
0.075219661,
0.0238461569,
0.0158992242,
-0.0111992555,
-0.0037227734,
-0.0661548078,
0.0220011938,
0.0039434615,
0.0220865048,
-0.0465090983,
-0.0065532774,
-0.0253731813,
-0.0612546988,
-0.0483008586,
0.0122361137,
0.0255564414,
0.0327059962,
-0.0336449333,
0.0671437755,
0.0511330254,
-0.0349354446,
-0.0059561972,
0.0045439904,
-0.0076253978,
0.0388576873,
-0.0162914935,
-0.0198359769,
-0.0068762302,
-0.0330288373,
0.0263703428,
0.0152171049,
0.0473868772,
0.0080500543,
0.0383383259,
0.0221514609,
-0.0402589925,
0.005669056,
-0.0003621685,
-0.0180005822,
-0.0316863023,
0.035540171,
0.0617709011,
0.0017043182,
-0.0334558673,
0.047438167,
-0.0020585365,
0.0258299392,
-0.0284310598,
-0.0296666846,
-0.027515715,
0.0169164501,
-0.0192052927,
-0.0420843065,
-0.0472194143,
-0.0300258659,
0.0156848691,
-0.0471785516,
-0.0202075727,
0.022529386,
2.688e-7,
0.0218201522,
0.0225058924,
-0.0111205028,
-0.005719902,
0.0070106019,
0.1092064381,
-0.0229094587,
-0.0131753786,
-0.0242636055,
-0.0477018803,
0.0402712114,
0.0139647098,
0.0599615835,
0.032467138,
0.0124159725,
0.0487741455,
-0.0145051936,
-0.0049473979,
-0.028939588,
-0.0085291173,
0.0774151981,
0.1280532479,
0.0043290588,
-0.0182565283,
0.059343446,
-0.0715180859,
0.0679331645,
-0.0242403001,
0.0260420199,
-0.0435983054,
-0.0068515539,
0.048814483,
-0.0138552282,
0.0445725322,
-0.0156721715,
-0.0278346203,
0.0158252418,
0.0176086109,
-0.0179684442,
-0.0038464232,
-0.0456711315,
0.0463387668,
-0.0179478433,
-0.0313611962,
0.0610781685,
-0.0708174556,
-0.0232689362,
-0.0804842338,
0.0059562451,
-0.0311011374,
0.0422626585,
-0.0047800252,
-0.0141060995,
0.0117273778,
-0.0240478851,
-0.0262752436,
-0.0428484492,
-0.0939219818,
0.0190058034,
0.0179901905,
-0.0408530459,
-0.0078816563,
0.0034126067,
-0.0226245783,
0.10032437,
-0.0146708703,
-0.0465645902,
2.369109911e-34,
0.0331357159,
-0.0117996242,
0.0161573105,
0.0189187285,
0.0116433678,
0.0107424362,
-0.0402551927,
-0.0349239446,
0.0298784766,
-0.0311582331,
0.0052565057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04197v1 | Hierarchical Event Grounding | 2023-02-08T17:09:41 | 2023-02-08T17:09:41 | Jiefu Ou, Adithya Pratapa, Rishubh Gupta, Teruko Mitamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event grounding aims at linking mention references in text corpora to events
from a knowledge base (KB). Previous work on this task focused primarily on
linking to a single KB event, thereby overlooking the hierarchical aspects of
events. Events in documents are typically described at various levels of
spatio-temporal granularity (Glavas et al. 2014). These hierarchical relations
are utilized in downstream tasks of narrative understanding and schema
construction. In this work, we present an extension to the event grounding task
that requires tackling hierarchical event structures from the KB. Our proposed
task involves linking a mention reference to a set of event labels from a
subevent hierarchy in the KB. We propose a retrieval methodology that leverages
event hierarchy through an auxiliary hierarchical loss (Murty et al. 2018). On
an automatically created multilingual dataset from Wikipedia and Wikidata, our
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the hierarchical loss against
retrieve and re-rank baselines (Wu et al. 2020; Pratapa, Gupta, and Mitamura
2022). Furthermore, we demonstrate the systems' ability to aid hierarchical
discovery among unseen events. | [
0.0186819155,
0.0532502979,
-0.0113826049,
0.0530165769,
-0.0104618231,
0.0053040492,
-0.0325900652,
0.0176561289,
0.04854545,
-0.0326687917,
0.0218192507,
0.00780711,
-0.008493593,
0.0433190688,
0.0052767107,
-0.0783170909,
0.0380020402,
0.0351616964,
-0.000670071,
0.0216327142,
-0.0011181856,
0.0268859696,
-0.0232179835,
0.0184721835,
-0.0413070098,
0.0168565512,
-0.0235639811,
0.014835231,
0.0397606976,
-0.0509026386,
0.0321252011,
0.0260771383,
0.0771123841,
0.0265453421,
0.0000019419,
-0.0294748023,
-0.0005094184,
-0.0269229189,
-0.0063280668,
0.0261885636,
-0.0585768335,
-0.0387959331,
0.0208536163,
-0.0489031635,
-0.0118300943,
-0.0429043695,
0.0056656031,
0.0610780567,
0.0019723105,
0.0479741618,
-0.0224938411,
-0.0426448397,
0.0357550383,
-0.0217942335,
-0.0042802701,
-0.049097091,
0.0012687813,
-0.0102911992,
-0.0386129245,
0.0152619397,
0.0197670665,
0.0097412979,
-0.0025198008,
-0.0051590847,
0.0383915752,
0.0378156267,
-0.0293064807,
0.0279389899,
0.0250575487,
0.0631051958,
0.0185657162,
-0.0339045972,
0.0449274741,
0.0362132303,
0.0074865995,
-0.0039404342,
-0.0389927067,
0.0293556638,
-0.0300720874,
0.006829638,
0.037668705,
0.0191396885,
0.0153634762,
0.0194493886,
0.0289109442,
0.0697364956,
0.0208225213,
-0.0100053502,
-0.0137201417,
0.0045943926,
0.0161429923,
-0.0448722318,
0.0621959679,
0.0278712437,
-0.0468382426,
0.0178692434,
-0.0017611078,
0.0516711622,
0.0178808402,
-0.0965456739,
-0.0403064713,
0.0323342271,
0.0006502403,
0.0396019034,
0.0070558139,
0.0128917415,
-0.021279769,
-0.0201773047,
-0.0193690211,
-0.0045424895,
-0.0382674821,
0.0212776009,
-0.0338099152,
0.0304124728,
-0.0507435091,
0.01707072,
0.016327301,
-0.0071946979,
0.0091814287,
0.0054135527,
-0.0709937587,
0.0200636182,
-0.0509064049,
-0.014006692,
-0.0384571962,
0.0352794379,
-0.0679942146,
-0.0013424347,
-0.0176825728,
0.0213285889,
-0.0164383128,
0.0237872433,
0.0242344998,
0.0066441363,
-0.0166921839,
0.0242668707,
-0.0203045532,
0.0006123133,
-0.0825850815,
-0.0473363139,
0.0165002234,
-0.0313884094,
-0.0045396811,
-0.0472724438,
0.0245066453,
-0.0234988071,
-0.0349397361,
-0.0368447118,
0.0242251754,
0.0065066172,
-0.0588518344,
0.0436769426,
-0.026392268,
-0.0256241746,
0.0339739621,
0.0369747169,
-0.0011869818,
0.0489034615,
0.0495083369,
0.0534483828,
0.0640401095,
0.0425972193,
-0.0636591166,
-0.010569199,
0.0393382125,
0.0245149061,
0.002809261,
0.0051593324,
-0.0687982067,
0.0521723218,
0.0609293841,
-0.0237848088,
-0.0425287336,
-0.0021796792,
0.0243977066,
0.0598272681,
-0.0848916024,
-0.0046323366,
0.0282003861,
-0.0209828578,
-0.0390895978,
0.0593236499,
-0.0305883437,
-0.0064655934,
0.0076610809,
-0.0146714365,
0.0085943593,
-0.0230048671,
-0.0235376637,
-0.0137604,
0.0227739271,
0.0140533699,
-0.0102274911,
-0.0099130664,
0.0364913456,
0.0148192253,
-0.0024772251,
0.1034312248,
0.0515893213,
-0.0532968529,
0.0558783114,
0.0230297651,
0.0000980497,
0.0489648692,
0.0254639219,
-0.0386709236,
-0.0375282243,
0.0132845193,
0.0582469068,
0.0436834022,
-0.0251931641,
-0.0669291764,
0.0310872532,
-0.0136623727,
-0.0199046433,
0.0211793836,
0.0191001967,
0.0066673122,
0.0023885716,
-0.0047782748,
0.0193069186,
-0.0517035834,
-0.0007369197,
0.0206936579,
-0.0155261448,
0.0043622078,
-0.0239155795,
0.0258775037,
-0.0282989088,
0.0070176874,
0.0121473009,
-0.0031906185,
0.0732177496,
-0.0415849239,
-0.0322636738,
0.0066873608,
-0.0010105618,
-0.0717007592,
0.0360087827,
-0.056757886,
-0.0257135835,
0.0051467712,
-0.0278382655,
-0.0512373373,
0.0319893137,
-0.0077129873,
0.0534181781,
0.0006689135,
-0.0088407081,
0.0057528536,
-0.0349123478,
-0.0515857562,
0.0955829918,
-0.014746327,
0.0161654837,
-0.0201558936,
-0.0058846199,
0.0285152253,
-0.0217079613,
-0.0153585998,
0.0403484888,
0.0002979455,
0.0129919937,
0.0543069988,
-0.0471747704,
-0.074701041,
0.0169559997,
-0.0843485221,
0.0472995639,
-0.0263374671,
0.0512239449,
0.0126424087,
-0.0079105282,
-0.002566824,
-0.0415491574,
-0.0290678777,
-0.0218958966,
-0.0432753786,
0.0157741569,
0.030687023,
0.049675107,
0.0235049222,
-0.0438727401,
-0.0295002852,
-0.0445743985,
0.0746780261,
-0.014616454,
-0.038673345,
-0.0301994048,
0.0119894827,
-0.0410548486,
0.0126060946,
-0.0246048942,
0.0211935192,
0.0072259307,
0.0039947,
0.0518236011,
0.0358079597,
-0.0115226479,
0.0530689694,
0.0066733044,
-0.0621292256,
-0.0461970605,
0.0284490827,
-0.0178557169,
0.0148247201,
-0.0101646297,
-0.0036441118,
-0.0144063896,
0.0419599228,
0.0064272354,
0.0050210687,
-0.0336720459,
-0.04762014,
-0.0030499261,
0.0247919597,
-0.063176699,
-0.0212831944,
-0.004415324,
0.0415309183,
-0.0384542383,
-0.0297161341,
0.0377105288,
0.005245863,
0.0274506565,
-0.0013730378,
0.0142214634,
-0.0329256505,
0.093132332,
0.0025140562,
0.0101795485,
0.0216465574,
-0.066771917,
0.0092726639,
0.048778031,
0.0185477585,
0.0072049303,
0.050130222,
-0.0336576626,
0.0219226293,
-0.0088479007,
-0.0278018862,
-0.0267942585,
-0.0100071095,
0.0257827956,
0.0051823687,
-0.0398200192,
0.0193709675,
-0.0648094565,
-0.0009820717,
0.0193692595,
0.0422873572,
0.0055837706,
-0.0226697307,
0.0015785006,
0.0866021588,
0.0477998033,
-0.0185089521,
-0.0002465092,
0.0105117047,
-0.0252702422,
0.0520401821,
0.0539876707,
-0.0072303074,
0.0180596821,
0.0041771648,
0.0030915395,
-0.057521604,
-0.0371345207,
-0.0230170656,
-0.005098192,
-0.0979220346,
-0.003275384,
0.0795342624,
0.040801011,
-0.0466547273,
0.0140307946,
0.0254776031,
0.0369920507,
0.0129453726,
-0.0198834408,
-0.0514218546,
0.0123975137,
-0.0053470242,
-0.0030377207,
0.0212454814,
-0.0730049461,
0.0328540206,
-0.0586329438,
0.0069195987,
-0.0064144661,
-0.0310941171,
-0.0597806573,
-0.060504403,
0.0354218669,
-0.0029638985,
-0.0238647722,
0.0224614982,
0.0070752264,
-0.0240722317,
-0.0212200768,
-0.056375552,
-0.0643579587,
0.037270803,
-0.0640675202,
0.0137107875,
-0.0122467605,
0.0638095364,
0.0137297846,
0.0261614155,
-0.0549885258,
-0.0328722037,
-0.03055471,
0.0079851588,
0.0473354124,
-0.0099025471,
0.0189095009,
-0.0340868458,
0.0334220715,
-0.024428837,
-0.0318420529,
-0.0191383958,
0.0780198202,
0.0058300351,
0.008507302,
0.0088938391,
-0.0039853877,
0.0340007581,
0.0412313677,
-0.0109744426,
0.0267576873,
0.0197061524,
-0.0073976861,
0.0576738454,
-0.0384357125,
0.0004168439,
0.0288689584,
-0.0444355607,
-0.0018990994,
-0.0853778347,
-0.0678479448,
-0.0199835487,
0.0196147189,
-0.0401878878,
0.0308956373,
0.0066406461,
-0.0402687378,
-0.0560495071,
0.0727718994,
-0.0403482914,
-0.0235266536,
0.0267485548,
0.0072599449,
0.0137451952,
0.0290549044,
-0.0038143778,
0.0268969983,
-0.006281307,
-0.0372541547,
-0.0439480655,
-0.0200051144,
0.005208591,
0.0427068695,
-0.0073265,
-0.024609156,
-0.0039741662,
0.0048964289,
-0.0215424169,
0.0051808455,
-0.0114197945,
0.0071987933,
-0.0398905613,
0.0687980875,
-0.041357372,
0.0093314964,
-0.0386178903,
0.0858520716,
-0.0142623624,
-0.0312900394,
0.0000696804,
-0.031351734,
0.05776494,
-0.0326948948,
-0.0266836043,
-0.046980314,
0.0056087552,
-0.0162191745,
-0.022665482,
0.0191216394,
0.0266705267,
-0.0166672729,
0.0048023406,
-0.0168483648,
0.0097804666,
-0.0040230514,
0.0350132175,
-0.0468827002,
-0.0165270455,
0.0413587689,
0.0105214249,
-0.0065410528,
0.0232401118,
-0.0383320227,
0.009915893,
-0.0081125936,
0.0481979921,
-0.0674741045,
-0.0138969198,
0.0353682339,
-0.0106109316,
-0.0242851414,
-0.0163791329,
-0.0315848812,
0.0594633445,
-0.0077976109,
-0.0537587367,
0.1104780212,
-0.0265058987,
0.0468232855,
-0.0072609317,
-0.0123674953,
0.0156632513,
-0.0041660592,
0.0092655886,
-0.019223867,
-0.008670209,
0.027448887,
-0.0247696079,
0.0826167166,
0.0529832914,
0.0621166378,
0.0697746202,
0.0307771824,
-0.0287915822,
-0.0195411369,
-0.0310804248,
0.0003508674,
0.0674752742,
-0.0326435044,
-0.0071881032,
-0.0689600483,
-0.0080429455,
0.0524055697,
-0.010380866,
-0.0219612308,
-0.014522288,
0.0335659422,
0.0283710249,
0.037503548,
-0.0245772824,
-0.0250076838,
0.0175651293,
-0.0091875764,
-0.0266687721,
-0.0670528635,
-6.038097914e-33,
-0.0583103709,
-0.0551455505,
0.0117538841,
0.0648293346,
-0.0496677831,
0.0438631848,
-0.0531062558,
-0.0250080209,
-0.0237759631,
0.0421064086,
-0.0026887802,
-0.002610876,
0.0037551413,
-0.0144928712,
0.0201840084,
-0.0114698429,
0.022115387,
0.0172645804,
-0.0205732305,
0.0524642505,
0.0869447365,
0.0349928401,
0.0791251883,
-0.067167744,
0.0255184136,
-0.0110471826,
0.0057427711,
0.0329836272,
0.0484837629,
0.027278753,
-0.0094415927,
0.048833508,
0.0359838642,
-0.0078933137,
0.0104278065,
0.0180103481,
-0.118398115,
-0.0099002346,
0.0046688667,
-0.0094366809,
0.0119504761,
-0.0333673395,
0.0066622444,
-0.0017829869,
0.0446025319,
-0.0490903147,
0.0402832292,
-0.0061959522,
-0.0657024682,
-0.0592900589,
-0.0724401921,
0.0470677875,
0.0083935484,
-0.0019745517,
-0.0227391105,
-0.0176645909,
0.0485410765,
0.0035888711,
-0.0462450981,
0.0197245851,
-0.0634232834,
0.0379143059,
-0.0316869281,
-0.0451240093,
-0.0379346088,
0.0590787306,
0.007908266,
0.0502051525,
-0.0539481975,
0.0162671153,
0.0195373353,
0.0257516112,
0.0143730529,
0.0490596034,
0.0200694855,
0.0090467678,
-0.1060970873,
0.0459563024,
-0.0001775769,
0.0316293016,
-0.0554007366,
0.0497522801,
-0.0344478935,
-0.0201726276,
-0.0334980749,
-0.0109134289,
-0.0187549274,
-0.0117072565,
-0.0065270416,
0.0097492663,
0.0441216752,
0.0499464311,
0.0010601907,
0.017485125,
-0.0116917994,
0.0679541305,
0.0352880992,
0.0174113419,
-0.0074629928,
0.0216423497,
-0.0457376428,
-0.0062613403,
0.02281693,
-0.0246252902,
0.0231060293,
0.0123837674,
0.0355532505,
0.0193639006,
-0.0058063427,
0.0057015163,
0.0013899654,
-0.0642563254,
-0.0287617408,
-0.0169476718,
0.0235590767,
-0.0019535907,
0.0189022645,
0.0584064834,
0.0413107201,
0.036671754,
-0.0071719666,
-0.02193336,
-0.0248777736,
0.0358536057,
0.0287945364,
0.0108154891,
-0.041920159,
0.0267669689,
0.0013661905,
-0.0577803701,
-0.0097550917,
-0.0048892312,
2.7e-7,
0.0001469038,
0.0413076505,
0.0429152995,
0.0153404707,
0.0003145169,
-0.0013394093,
0.001729951,
0.0398452431,
-0.0123492321,
-0.0425847135,
-0.0181361325,
0.0003060522,
0.0293104481,
0.0685750544,
-0.0928598046,
-0.051024925,
-0.0629549921,
-0.0443792939,
-0.0643397346,
-0.0360411108,
0.0411900394,
0.0304252803,
0.0266848374,
0.0020461604,
0.0070231915,
-0.0265697669,
0.062784858,
0.0159494132,
-0.0559895448,
0.0149823567,
-0.0078670392,
0.0215969868,
-0.052256763,
0.0583947711,
-0.0328321829,
0.0366036929,
0.018526895,
0.0384548865,
-0.0176071059,
-0.0042639403,
-0.0026257271,
-0.059484452,
-0.0085887844,
-0.0194283426,
0.0327742286,
-0.0190120433,
0.0163546167,
0.0807029679,
-0.0270144939,
0.043352969,
-0.0159394387,
-0.005571356,
-0.0712720528,
0.01717522,
-0.0222418159,
0.0297335535,
-0.0017759261,
-0.0931673422,
-0.0134480326,
0.0770552307,
-0.0170832817,
-0.0243074838,
0.0188318007,
-0.0636901185,
-0.0199131146,
-0.020374544,
0.0066300235,
2.435149505e-34,
-0.0004548113,
0.0024164338,
-0.0527610891,
0.0047387718,
0.0597915426,
-0.03513797,
-0.0500057042,
-0.0098060751,
0.0305264816,
-0.0401662812,
0.0151500041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04185v1 | Efficient Joint Learning for Clinical Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction Using Fourier Networks: A Use Case in Adverse Drug Events | 2023-02-08T16:44:27 | 2023-02-08T16:44:27 | Anthony Yazdani, Dimitrios Proios, Hossein Rouhizadeh, Douglas Teodoro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Current approaches for clinical information extraction are inefficient in
terms of computational costs and memory consumption, hindering their
application to process large-scale electronic health records (EHRs). We propose
an efficient end-to-end model, the Joint-NER-RE-Fourier (JNRF), to jointly
learn the tasks of named entity recognition and relation extraction for
documents of variable length. The architecture uses positional encoding and
unitary batch sizes to process variable length documents and uses a
weight-shared Fourier network layer for low-complexity token mixing. Finally,
we reach the theoretical computational complexity lower bound for relation
extraction using a selective pooling strategy and distance-aware attention
weights with trainable polynomial distance functions. We evaluated the JNRF
architecture using the 2018 N2C2 ADE benchmark to jointly extract
medication-related entities and relations in variable-length EHR summaries.
JNRF outperforms rolling window BERT with selective pooling by 0.42%, while
being twice as fast to train. Compared to state-of-the-art BiLSTM-CRF
architectures on the N2C2 ADE benchmark, results show that the proposed
approach trains 22 times faster and reduces GPU memory consumption by 1.75
folds, with a reasonable performance tradeoff of 90%, without the use of
external tools, hand-crafted rules or post-processing. Given the significant
carbon footprint of deep learning models and the current energy crises, these
methods could support efficient and cleaner information extraction in EHRs and
other types of large-scale document databases. | [
0.0241471604,
0.0826443285,
0.0193129126,
0.0314273871,
0.0062185181,
0.0375947393,
-0.0233033765,
-0.0106343878,
0.028007362,
-0.0006603362,
-0.0051416112,
-0.0611656979,
-0.0087638432,
0.0092603993,
0.0102888215,
-0.0188671593,
0.0186109636,
0.0292202663,
-0.0083643869,
0.0115053412,
-0.039820198,
-0.0045205685,
-0.0178868137,
0.0068092337,
-0.0131916786,
0.0063132262,
-0.0168634746,
0.0204569679,
0.0524228662,
-0.0556119941,
0.0029026594,
0.0155386794,
-0.0057376516,
0.0284948982,
0.0000022652,
-0.0294697694,
-0.0326266289,
0.020019291,
-0.0349328518,
-0.0388749614,
0.003864612,
-0.0355402902,
-0.0023853614,
-0.017088268,
0.0242980849,
-0.0766900033,
0.0333059654,
0.0846682265,
0.0062274351,
0.0420778394,
-0.0120667936,
-0.0035180121,
0.0667480081,
-0.0459228754,
0.0213325564,
-0.0510071218,
0.0354469121,
-0.0620726421,
-0.00246449,
-0.0442472957,
-0.0156167354,
0.0612208769,
0.023737045,
0.0274304524,
0.0397512242,
0.0472557507,
-0.0674887896,
-0.0001629132,
-0.0020882252,
0.0988335982,
-0.0623757392,
0.0243990235,
0.032799419,
-0.0019217163,
-0.0361115001,
-0.0237244964,
-0.0007901298,
-0.0037733784,
-0.0425063409,
0.0061495914,
-0.0092028268,
-0.0113148792,
0.0391358659,
-0.0041627316,
-0.0256878026,
-0.0225579385,
0.003245651,
-0.039011579,
0.0650299415,
-0.0084208008,
-0.0272220597,
-0.0258471593,
0.043008469,
0.0249138232,
0.0065377126,
0.02141097,
-0.0318905264,
-0.0448211953,
0.0393789299,
-0.0926759392,
-0.0224086326,
0.0074900738,
-0.005456273,
0.0527062528,
-0.0368815735,
-0.0048061023,
-0.0450800546,
-0.0232913382,
-0.0066242088,
0.0133551173,
-0.025457697,
-0.0023711787,
-0.0306113474,
0.0526821762,
-0.0339759663,
-0.02840643,
-0.025667971,
-0.0231908802,
-0.0225046594,
0.0314169824,
0.0537831187,
0.070834443,
-0.0040192609,
0.0180457383,
0.0221194066,
0.041262012,
-0.004351458,
-0.0207414925,
0.0045189098,
-0.0491053574,
0.0121346172,
-0.0136115914,
0.0395236202,
-0.0374497473,
0.0563109554,
0.0925768912,
0.0250552334,
-0.0494021662,
-0.0061840625,
-0.0185419098,
0.0024580061,
-0.0305512659,
0.0132614225,
-0.051317025,
0.0718684196,
-0.0060298429,
-0.0049740672,
-0.0294873323,
0.0427070111,
0.0040975055,
-0.0733910277,
0.0466787331,
-0.0508032888,
-0.0411173999,
0.0539416969,
0.0208279192,
0.0262259878,
0.0417867899,
0.0581358671,
-0.0180463158,
0.0065415245,
-0.0222094003,
-0.0286936536,
-0.0108716907,
0.0436974764,
-0.0731486976,
0.0038105664,
0.0124375913,
-0.0106259482,
0.0607273653,
-0.0048777619,
0.0642100424,
-0.004816548,
-0.0525970832,
-0.005364242,
0.0403896421,
0.0305993538,
0.0427645631,
-0.0007058718,
-0.0317567661,
0.0054182778,
-0.0587422289,
-0.0216751937,
0.0462504923,
0.0294266846,
0.0027430025,
0.0180478208,
0.0100936852,
-0.0321999341,
-0.0047100619,
0.0188699737,
-0.0415406749,
-0.0158295278,
-0.0323699191,
0.0240138099,
-0.0306576453,
-0.0598054864,
0.0904970914,
0.0491807684,
-0.0205055401,
-0.0272792634,
-0.0009970271,
-0.0447284319,
0.0719958693,
0.0049965736,
-0.0412096642,
-0.0316178165,
-0.0258696042,
-0.0351772495,
-0.019109441,
0.0123591162,
0.0079111522,
0.0697696805,
-0.035105858,
-0.0010213665,
0.0142120868,
-0.0103763631,
-0.0006421986,
-0.0071461257,
0.0326724723,
-0.0095719015,
-0.0269916654,
-0.0288737323,
0.0149947731,
-0.0106165474,
-0.0579934306,
0.0070608314,
0.0530787483,
0.0348528512,
0.0300062858,
-0.020765638,
0.0164261702,
0.0352567509,
-0.061062526,
-0.0302703511,
-0.032699883,
-0.0101154046,
-0.0145294527,
0.0000702811,
0.0003562684,
-0.0031696602,
-0.0245013237,
-0.0323849618,
-0.0234509148,
-0.0041405312,
-0.0129583189,
0.0258631222,
0.0153774451,
0.0177261084,
0.0636167377,
0.0087160524,
-0.0307034291,
0.0185493901,
-0.0154795814,
0.0147256786,
-0.0011749415,
-0.0522566997,
0.0046949997,
-0.0223963652,
-0.0087636029,
0.0109544359,
0.0141862361,
-0.0035648027,
-0.0207199231,
-0.0312609076,
-0.0101893786,
-0.0430583321,
-0.0955342576,
0.0158046018,
0.0223020371,
0.034257032,
-0.0215250254,
0.0383475572,
0.0009343469,
-0.0131504834,
-0.0353302136,
-0.0332571901,
-0.0552363768,
-0.0290331077,
0.0279888157,
0.0374747552,
-0.0335349627,
-0.0168019813,
-0.0449600555,
-0.0242412928,
0.0610437468,
0.0022747903,
-0.0698822215,
0.0268197898,
-0.0421392396,
-0.017684767,
0.0152844349,
0.0094400682,
0.0206572525,
-0.0437465869,
0.016975658,
-0.0001354348,
0.0669706836,
0.022786336,
0.0256526843,
-0.0313935466,
-0.0101007586,
-0.0012594742,
0.0754289925,
-0.0288385283,
0.0388885774,
0.0297166165,
-0.0028059985,
0.0053774286,
0.0777422488,
-0.0175563879,
0.0164097212,
-0.0044207373,
-0.0498594642,
0.0126135759,
-0.0047750347,
-0.0442663282,
0.0183119103,
-0.0367476419,
-0.0649587065,
-0.0273384564,
-0.026364686,
0.0597191676,
-0.0151473517,
0.0205984898,
-0.0715024471,
-0.0077780001,
-0.0364678092,
-0.0095103597,
0.0372320041,
0.0285565499,
-0.0171559099,
-0.0263265893,
0.0230850317,
0.0157222748,
-0.0093243457,
-0.0469432808,
0.0577097051,
0.0105329668,
0.0506559983,
-0.0485034436,
-0.0311972387,
-0.0364004597,
0.0095969923,
-0.024247393,
0.0104129426,
0.0021374549,
-0.0041669267,
-0.0287148636,
0.0358919613,
0.007707925,
0.0782161802,
0.0363783166,
-0.0130499536,
0.0142051391,
0.0390856192,
0.0175925922,
-0.0269471593,
-0.0036332465,
-0.0080115553,
0.0129359998,
0.0510224514,
0.0458082445,
0.0186778214,
0.0009321233,
0.0166024528,
-0.0195171107,
-0.0357184298,
-0.0109502012,
0.0181106348,
0.0199856441,
-0.0543575324,
0.0236064047,
0.0816101506,
0.0141613819,
-0.0536636673,
0.0310531296,
0.0604502447,
-0.0516495183,
-0.0247684717,
0.015714474,
-0.0594434887,
-0.0321042687,
0.0017558844,
0.0041529508,
0.0171091333,
-0.0596194752,
0.0033884945,
-0.023313228,
-0.0065356172,
-0.0162448827,
-0.0288144425,
-0.0434028059,
-0.0510211885,
-0.0098176403,
-0.0078582354,
-0.0130809136,
-0.027435666,
-0.0141518079,
-0.0437506214,
0.0457837656,
-0.0352223702,
-0.0042582061,
-0.0156318471,
-0.0467864126,
0.0016973171,
0.0121187391,
0.011696212,
-0.03036993,
-0.0436193347,
0.0043975534,
-0.0368212163,
-0.0078011695,
0.0013933296,
0.0816840082,
-0.0419155695,
-0.0370345004,
-0.0278755464,
0.0268112309,
-0.064880006,
-0.0386054106,
-0.0044268733,
0.0714949518,
-0.0062859221,
-0.0029110252,
-0.0205855463,
-0.0155116534,
0.0127017954,
0.0423667915,
0.0100979507,
-0.0206124689,
-0.0195618179,
0.0346342549,
0.0251759402,
-0.0591443591,
0.0074628824,
-0.0047217188,
-0.0178118404,
-0.030709615,
-0.0139304288,
-0.0186505206,
0.0326083787,
0.0103308,
-0.0207466614,
-0.0010664149,
0.0636365265,
0.0149717415,
-0.0802721754,
0.0273047239,
0.0281242747,
0.0171871707,
-0.0521643162,
-0.0312013011,
0.0079496279,
0.0342189893,
-0.0296943542,
-0.0135774575,
-0.0951084346,
-0.0089338766,
0.00856457,
0.0028158529,
0.0058691632,
0.0103409449,
0.0383582786,
0.0185123775,
0.0096671665,
0.0931345373,
-0.042841211,
-0.0240710396,
0.0009867878,
-0.031706024,
-0.0305114631,
0.0231869612,
-0.0085428767,
0.0263842642,
0.0154758152,
0.0422037654,
0.022717353,
-0.0161782391,
-0.0165484902,
-0.0020276092,
0.0188476853,
0.0046217521,
-0.0068650087,
-0.0505073816,
0.0764697492,
0.0283911452,
0.0511494055,
-0.0215223134,
-0.0127579197,
-0.0134514747,
0.0322086215,
-0.0186670516,
0.0343139507,
0.0629144683,
-0.0891160518,
-0.0146968337,
0.0343812294,
-0.0496342257,
0.0162427276,
0.0191058926,
-0.0254085064,
-0.0268564168,
0.0042444132,
0.0441491045,
0.0280232877,
-0.0226807091,
0.0181995686,
0.0113755986,
0.0467566215,
-0.0349326506,
0.0257062782,
-0.0106038647,
-0.0240690336,
-0.0234579965,
0.0060282378,
0.048312746,
-0.032691922,
-0.003212593,
-0.0301556773,
-0.0166770183,
-0.0106063355,
-0.0170235243,
-0.0277377293,
0.0601802096,
0.037763644,
0.047490079,
-0.023937678,
-0.0346034728,
0.0864887014,
0.0183862802,
0.0545722432,
0.0211800653,
-0.0156753808,
-0.0331192836,
-0.0175626855,
0.0295456555,
-0.0274995938,
-0.0411495119,
0.0119523583,
-0.0181242116,
-0.0371748395,
0.0576682724,
-0.0290398244,
-0.0295932032,
-0.0128030963,
0.0605417266,
0.0077973711,
0.056368053,
-0.008286858,
0.0377139077,
0.0516025499,
0.0105673056,
-0.0091438228,
0.0124921659,
-6.607786558e-33,
0.0287483353,
0.009540176,
-0.0153255127,
0.0037426534,
-0.0169926826,
0.0740958229,
-0.0321749784,
-0.0395268984,
-0.0035059301,
0.0125447344,
0.0028230436,
0.0128722871,
0.0127857169,
0.0377151482,
0.0041116797,
-0.0414800532,
0.0240099952,
0.0416945778,
0.0072622029,
0.0419486277,
0.0150100309,
0.0917495564,
0.0342189781,
-0.0624046698,
-0.0414785333,
0.0217631757,
0.0710998774,
-0.0069148783,
0.0255915318,
0.0662579462,
-0.0437195078,
0.0215055738,
0.0124061899,
-0.0612993017,
0.0141696557,
0.0066834823,
-0.1535381824,
-0.0337146409,
-0.0325411782,
-0.0084356712,
-0.01914897,
-0.0327478983,
0.0613862872,
0.0270150192,
0.012184836,
-0.0403963253,
0.008071295,
-0.0100880545,
-0.0377015993,
-0.0977830738,
-0.0210077669,
0.0665712878,
-0.0014287176,
0.0460598059,
0.0187306721,
-0.0566754341,
-0.0239680577,
0.0141313635,
-0.0906825811,
-0.0688023195,
-0.0096452935,
0.0361911021,
-0.0060516754,
0.0075479085,
-0.003671058,
0.0629060045,
0.0669919923,
0.0012875897,
-0.0338324532,
0.0349889882,
-0.0278937034,
0.0317999162,
0.0086957105,
-0.0208080206,
0.1034010276,
-0.0141778821,
-0.1206454858,
0.0203333907,
-0.0262988098,
0.0362326093,
0.0020208645,
0.00143724,
-0.0321682841,
0.0059701134,
0.0016126427,
0.0425450467,
-0.0261221528,
0.0079401648,
-0.002238919,
0.0253798049,
0.0117062265,
0.0281711183,
-0.0139340758,
-0.0194170643,
-0.0166306961,
-0.011929011,
0.0930199251,
0.0040106536,
-0.0037032762,
-0.0221020319,
-0.0546960346,
-0.0260328092,
0.0064013889,
-0.0011791193,
0.0334771536,
-0.0007732731,
0.0723062605,
-0.0018070776,
-0.0597267188,
-0.0381095707,
-0.0103436373,
0.0161729306,
0.0003510813,
0.0826855898,
0.0377448499,
0.0115164043,
0.0204298608,
0.0536335036,
-0.0186449438,
0.0128812557,
-0.0232514031,
-0.0027318308,
0.0324377976,
0.0322238617,
-0.005541754,
0.0035716223,
-0.038919244,
0.0325976871,
0.0145436311,
-0.1211058423,
-0.0164381079,
0.0171690658,
3.254e-7,
0.0678455979,
-0.0112363715,
0.0922622308,
-0.0546568334,
0.0303314906,
-0.0136253014,
0.0204348881,
0.029456595,
-0.0352069288,
0.0188257825,
0.0430121534,
0.007352212,
0.0270545501,
0.0232801866,
-0.0632048398,
-0.0544111505,
-0.0838037804,
-0.0128934244,
-0.0344641022,
-0.0176108014,
0.0251337606,
0.0873201266,
-0.0055318531,
-0.0158306677,
0.0306516606,
0.0281914398,
0.0255112406,
-0.0296791904,
0.0565845519,
0.0210278425,
-0.0094975755,
0.0164598525,
-0.0059141801,
0.0415772535,
-0.0201941114,
0.0112494472,
0.0115263779,
0.0625899434,
-0.0401863605,
-0.0082763322,
0.0294414312,
-0.0385196581,
0.0148098264,
0.0176240765,
0.0620425642,
-0.0512214825,
-0.0501142554,
0.0229756031,
-0.0234855209,
0.025501743,
0.033788342,
0.0254341513,
-0.01064118,
0.0252045821,
0.0244197156,
-0.0124623794,
-0.0091248527,
-0.0984698161,
0.0253896881,
0.0703866333,
-0.0105012329,
-0.015526941,
-0.0126096401,
-0.0633588433,
0.0457041152,
-0.0115377465,
-0.0078138597,
3.085553514e-34,
0.027735278,
-0.0011938669,
-0.0088574812,
-0.0136711681,
0.0059308168,
-0.0425926447,
-0.0047725518,
-0.0387525782,
-0.0226590075,
-0.0664440319,
-0.0238412786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04166v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04166v2 | GPTScore: Evaluate as You Desire | 2023-02-08T16:17:29 | 2023-02-13T16:19:05 | Jinlan Fu, See-Kiong Ng, Zhengbao Jiang, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) has enabled the development of
sophisticated models that are capable of producing high-caliber text, images,
and other outputs through the utilization of large pre-trained models.
Nevertheless, assessing the quality of the generation is an even more arduous
task than the generation itself, and this issue has not been given adequate
consideration recently. This paper proposes a novel evaluation framework,
GPTScore, which utilizes the emergent abilities (e.g., zero-shot instruction)
of generative pre-trained models to score generated texts. There are 19
pre-trained models explored in this paper, ranging in size from 80M (e.g.,
FLAN-T5-small) to 175B (e.g., GPT3). Experimental results on four text
generation tasks, 22 evaluation aspects, and corresponding 37 datasets
demonstrate that this approach can effectively allow us to achieve what one
desires to evaluate for texts simply by natural language instructions. This
nature helps us overcome several long-standing challenges in text
evaluation--how to achieve customized, multi-faceted evaluation without the
need for annotated samples. We make our code publicly available at
https://github.com/jinlanfu/GPTScore. | [
-0.0065916874,
0.0494761206,
0.0130660888,
-0.0083136186,
-0.0278434288,
0.0191663988,
0.0287406147,
0.0117035145,
-0.0088744462,
-0.0252858549,
-0.0392215066,
-0.0348701328,
-0.011743281,
0.0811262801,
0.0052723135,
-0.0515881069,
-0.012850753,
0.0210811142,
0.0068994253,
0.0149338981,
0.0111057879,
0.025596384,
0.0009586873,
0.0274789594,
-0.0226526726,
-0.0190573465,
-0.0065835044,
-0.0021705197,
0.0534765311,
-0.0249920804,
-0.0101476209,
0.0731552467,
-0.0129492478,
0.0738906935,
0.0000020592,
-0.0226567108,
-0.0075189578,
0.0032187477,
0.0130465757,
0.0342613831,
0.0651003867,
0.0099770725,
-0.0245418157,
-0.0121996775,
-0.0595940016,
-0.0217776485,
0.0310083143,
0.0299287811,
0.0746401921,
0.0681674406,
-0.0156747047,
-0.0239893571,
-0.0003246713,
-0.020717049,
0.0221871119,
-0.0223597288,
-0.0280406494,
0.0056112558,
-0.0133864442,
0.0083376812,
0.0142641636,
0.0112335952,
0.0679531917,
-0.0378852002,
0.0303119738,
0.0632390082,
-0.0001843706,
-0.006334011,
-0.016205268,
0.0608379431,
-0.0368006416,
-0.0254681576,
-0.0052332268,
-0.0552660637,
-0.0321707278,
-0.0515365154,
-0.0470861048,
0.0202935468,
0.0186276492,
0.0278476216,
0.0022441368,
0.0446078964,
-0.0001316125,
0.0125684962,
0.0038887286,
0.0006857521,
0.0323402211,
-0.0282620285,
-0.0128668165,
0.0330521464,
-0.0178464819,
-0.0703311637,
0.0061287382,
0.0364421755,
-0.0167691782,
-0.0157577973,
-0.0550230891,
-0.0476959348,
0.0198432598,
-0.0178737305,
0.0721807778,
0.0118293241,
0.0071545239,
0.023455739,
-0.0322003402,
0.0687017217,
0.0229903217,
-0.0002784598,
-0.0342594571,
0.0287178233,
-0.066881597,
-0.0067410939,
-0.0340232924,
0.021058552,
-0.0169187468,
-0.036675781,
-0.066357553,
0.0000734784,
0.0147126298,
-0.0029118261,
0.028599536,
0.0395185463,
-0.042901203,
-0.0112395696,
-0.0169445612,
-0.0094715301,
-0.0487337187,
-0.0082497103,
0.0210811235,
-0.0345293172,
-0.032849215,
0.0390059948,
0.0238647144,
0.0031255563,
0.0058153621,
0.0374500677,
-0.0183287431,
-0.0296773203,
-0.0056049079,
-0.0224546734,
-0.0206467044,
-0.0893475041,
-0.0134691214,
-0.0517186411,
-0.0034209527,
-0.0093058199,
-0.0113081094,
-0.0215405449,
-0.006245642,
0.0342719704,
0.025109414,
0.0008212956,
-0.0042495183,
-0.0089506563,
-0.0021508893,
0.0108778058,
0.0299505424,
0.0338741206,
0.052166298,
0.0949151069,
-0.0131291328,
0.0186872315,
0.0427500382,
0.032825999,
0.0384464301,
0.0103669884,
0.0083141979,
-0.004676302,
-0.0419572182,
0.027041493,
0.017804388,
0.036381118,
-0.0241114106,
0.0304886829,
0.0703716055,
0.0158681497,
0.0174969286,
0.0479880869,
0.1149166748,
0.0109941307,
0.0006654783,
0.0069874218,
0.0009686806,
0.0366292298,
-0.0252104308,
0.0223579146,
0.037489254,
0.0270159524,
-0.0231042728,
-0.0503260233,
0.0277986322,
-0.020837307,
-0.0185292028,
-0.0253751837,
0.0376520306,
0.0446282029,
-0.0697760135,
-0.0398065932,
-0.0090957144,
-0.1041375324,
0.025523195,
-0.0577617176,
0.0489880815,
0.0902869105,
0.0790684596,
0.0092192665,
-0.0088933501,
0.0172970947,
-0.0359505266,
0.0719730258,
0.0134654175,
-0.000224606,
0.0170765799,
-0.0557766259,
-0.027451165,
-0.0341197103,
0.0031878785,
0.047797516,
0.0029548418,
0.0325474627,
0.0458756983,
-0.03017167,
-0.0586118698,
0.0329692848,
-0.0043152282,
-0.0656313822,
0.0241491944,
-0.0248656049,
0.0118205212,
0.0310728531,
-0.0447835699,
0.0165037643,
0.0096234428,
-0.0078859739,
-0.0268928073,
-0.0168365706,
-0.039696224,
-0.0183561444,
-0.0138360113,
-0.0464102514,
-0.015569373,
0.019332407,
-0.0496527702,
-0.0493354276,
0.0059928233,
-0.0253394358,
-0.0206099395,
-0.0679318756,
-0.0061545172,
0.0259746183,
-0.0017461028,
-0.0299326405,
0.0779077485,
0.010457715,
0.0055179014,
-0.0022957395,
0.036400266,
0.0276752412,
-0.0332709588,
-0.0068568089,
-0.0196855552,
0.0223417617,
0.0036916777,
0.0370741673,
0.0897046402,
-0.0467384905,
-0.0189648196,
-0.0931291431,
0.0272529852,
-0.0300504602,
0.0285030566,
0.0477341935,
-0.0125880986,
-0.010694433,
0.0292219482,
-0.0510468706,
0.0053867032,
0.0735611171,
-0.0282644089,
0.0391968526,
-0.0074719675,
0.0307942443,
-0.0226979163,
0.0099739907,
0.0130270468,
0.0291008595,
0.0770633295,
0.0434967428,
-0.0122819636,
0.0443200469,
-0.0312285926,
-0.0263948347,
0.0385613367,
-0.0574438944,
0.0316981599,
-0.0117674712,
0.0729693919,
0.0386822447,
0.0229518469,
0.0477520786,
-0.0036456205,
0.0020872166,
-0.0200957395,
-0.0163929351,
-0.0403610244,
-0.0085219955,
0.0168190524,
-0.0269487333,
0.0117466934,
0.048398219,
0.0227907412,
-0.0004666102,
-0.0886584148,
0.0602867901,
-0.0278674178,
-0.0420987308,
-0.0012906688,
0.0219593104,
-0.0061891112,
0.0202182606,
-0.0177418068,
-0.0737208575,
0.038009841,
-0.046902854,
-0.0232542865,
-0.0297532491,
0.0265465509,
-0.016536789,
0.0646927208,
0.0308571719,
0.0221237671,
0.0120034525,
0.0253711771,
-0.0335651226,
0.0430704579,
0.0148126045,
-0.032467287,
-0.0149180377,
-0.0339483134,
-0.0008996033,
-0.0211658087,
-0.0142541751,
-0.0327344351,
-0.0005868822,
0.0118785417,
0.0002506662,
0.0439456329,
-0.0264855456,
0.0023179497,
-0.0031757834,
0.0184543226,
0.045068562,
-0.0347347185,
-0.0223255381,
-0.0179268233,
0.0522486567,
0.0317465961,
-0.0341389216,
-0.0062394696,
-0.0299497135,
0.0050238171,
0.0435069799,
0.0204143673,
0.0393497609,
-0.0328556523,
0.0098983785,
-0.0099374168,
-0.0124749858,
0.016387403,
0.0236158334,
0.0393455811,
-0.0392195806,
-0.0362512395,
0.1174665317,
0.0428689793,
-0.0121512981,
-0.0197678898,
0.0427341238,
0.0268485155,
-0.0113743413,
0.0153567102,
-0.0793801993,
0.0049379026,
-0.032538753,
0.027364349,
-0.0351863466,
-0.0013762318,
-0.0171488803,
-0.1088366285,
0.0679926276,
0.0246456824,
-0.0195851382,
-0.0064984118,
0.004583301,
-0.0383431874,
-0.0183673035,
-0.0295514669,
-0.0078079794,
0.0074152481,
0.0493317619,
0.0120494496,
0.0107817817,
-0.0672668442,
0.020996334,
-0.0107324114,
0.0253939554,
0.1081222594,
0.041845303,
0.0055646556,
-0.0293100215,
-0.0197425913,
-0.0258772951,
-0.0190901775,
-0.0121036116,
0.0493197031,
0.0044985404,
0.0024303102,
-0.0212896187,
0.0243198127,
0.0016915451,
-0.0061036255,
0.0114562884,
0.0249600578,
-0.0138769168,
-0.0287891515,
-0.0161608979,
0.0132349283,
0.0178257562,
0.057259582,
0.0585884191,
-0.042418357,
-0.0579775088,
-0.0361695811,
0.0091188531,
-0.1521822363,
-0.0623038225,
-0.0008594152,
0.0221153423,
-0.0327907093,
-0.0941157266,
-0.0760398209,
0.0241243485,
0.0383855775,
-0.0061484394,
-0.0489806384,
-0.0542595796,
-0.0071279546,
-0.031890966,
-0.0089012086,
-0.0184146184,
-0.0157849919,
-0.0602335446,
-0.0513867512,
0.0246124119,
-0.0427895412,
-0.039055936,
0.0567006245,
-0.0549023263,
-0.0266522486,
-0.0134695088,
0.0792920291,
0.0188639387,
-0.0274393614,
-0.018141374,
-0.0401737615,
0.1002302542,
0.0474958606,
-0.013175101,
-0.002756282,
0.0153472591,
-0.0015558817,
-0.0172059294,
0.0053572254,
0.0034761706,
0.0720160156,
0.0208546147,
0.0189605951,
0.022677118,
-0.0174114238,
0.0247259624,
0.0143237198,
0.0171671901,
-0.0678280294,
-0.0078865597,
-0.0275462214,
-0.0294605717,
-0.0516237095,
-0.0156026445,
-0.0585923642,
0.0108259004,
0.0394733697,
0.0107798688,
-0.0338327587,
0.0606096648,
-0.0310825296,
0.0360044725,
-0.0715429783,
-0.0262569897,
0.0067832815,
0.0206998307,
-0.0039228904,
-0.0158050749,
-0.0175125692,
-0.0156261772,
-0.0358332768,
0.0133007336,
-0.0172477141,
0.04724399,
0.0248914436,
0.0156449378,
0.0426150523,
0.0700176805,
-0.0550288334,
-0.013822224,
-0.0933128297,
0.0354103893,
0.0468652286,
0.0208189432,
0.0770737678,
-0.042327527,
0.0066825757,
-0.0308278184,
0.0354441814,
0.0241158884,
-0.0436281674,
-0.0472775698,
0.0082687885,
0.0001412438,
-0.0309466105,
0.0837437958,
0.014274654,
0.0110584656,
0.0212459229,
0.0015129047,
-0.0483807549,
-0.0302337147,
-0.0191735718,
-0.0217924248,
0.0327837616,
0.0156399962,
-0.0393037722,
-0.0362178795,
0.033313103,
0.0665192083,
0.0300148968,
0.0120079014,
0.0613004975,
0.0348868892,
-0.0579363257,
0.0162783153,
-0.0238595586,
-0.0010777533,
-0.0243917685,
-0.0351152122,
-0.0040971972,
-6.03978732e-33,
-0.0428198203,
-0.055714462,
0.0197276883,
-0.0223074649,
-0.0395145901,
-0.0094163436,
-0.050718423,
-0.011358087,
0.0678565651,
0.0054948749,
0.0012224464,
-0.0229226798,
0.0142727224,
0.0472023264,
-0.0108618708,
0.0001276768,
0.0458235033,
-0.0235341843,
-0.058523573,
0.0864897743,
0.0036912593,
0.0096385861,
0.0485856421,
-0.0354452059,
-0.0004094057,
-0.0262265541,
-0.061031498,
-0.0492466465,
0.000848212,
0.0493312404,
-0.0312853009,
0.0126868393,
0.014118623,
-0.0459044836,
-0.0232590474,
0.0052899471,
-0.0118315425,
-0.0312218927,
-0.0341367386,
-0.0170449913,
-0.0687697083,
-0.0226791482,
0.0100703249,
-0.0196264088,
-0.0331960842,
-0.0015907085,
0.042725116,
-0.0132431667,
0.0324061736,
-0.0613863654,
-0.0743038952,
0.0236423984,
-0.0281101279,
-0.0378469937,
0.0076202657,
0.0183278061,
-0.0003034728,
0.0298893657,
-0.0280761868,
0.0219844598,
0.0511451438,
0.0327315517,
0.0451238379,
0.0075219385,
0.0072685033,
0.0368512571,
-0.0054963334,
-0.0117642032,
-0.0496496074,
0.0045536621,
0.0127656264,
0.0099213254,
0.0637805685,
0.0657464787,
0.0240368936,
0.0060718199,
-0.0581871793,
0.0950018764,
-0.0257901829,
-0.0229462851,
0.0279207192,
-0.0261085909,
-0.0015167355,
0.0249319188,
-0.0286746733,
-0.0568002053,
-0.0284302272,
-0.0367164128,
0.047809843,
0.0266058408,
-0.0322117172,
-0.0160887614,
0.0160282496,
-0.0028113038,
0.0084868306,
-0.0093938699,
-0.060216926,
0.036391627,
-0.0074239401,
-0.0007670282,
-0.0170996059,
-0.0166206844,
0.0724782646,
0.042794887,
0.0120971734,
-0.0137094455,
0.0174297579,
0.045989681,
-0.0602119863,
0.0318452194,
-0.036494568,
0.0380260125,
0.0118380878,
-0.0129542574,
-0.0089692809,
-0.0306570269,
-0.0319737382,
0.0360611752,
-0.0024619931,
0.0217362642,
-0.0366429985,
-0.0222679283,
0.0167336259,
0.0135967107,
-0.0481876954,
0.0335977562,
-0.0201515649,
-0.0216768645,
0.013565002,
-0.0377927274,
-0.0221622158,
0.0178606454,
2.554e-7,
0.0205051452,
0.027272623,
0.0415202901,
0.0191293769,
0.0037794693,
0.0255652964,
0.0015972005,
0.0382251032,
-0.0010756071,
0.0056215017,
0.0319105648,
0.0267037116,
0.0444723256,
0.0205927044,
-0.0324500576,
0.0419078134,
-0.0548231006,
-0.0029700063,
-0.043387983,
0.0004626781,
0.0819940716,
0.0425202586,
-0.0039182506,
-0.0032711693,
0.0568941571,
-0.0180816855,
0.0724266395,
0.0210644975,
-0.0096113095,
0.0085747549,
0.0187815558,
0.0132123642,
-0.0339921005,
-0.0185447447,
-0.0146070868,
-0.0127736228,
0.0303542912,
0.0663236901,
0.0066671846,
-0.0216821618,
0.0163020678,
0.0047318609,
0.0276591182,
-0.0527364388,
0.0603599623,
-0.0407989509,
-0.021122735,
-0.0041677775,
-0.0274428967,
-0.0040003182,
0.041978661,
-0.0499930605,
-0.0349041075,
0.0415457599,
0.0146399811,
0.0143152019,
-0.0046375389,
-0.0398221724,
-0.0238895677,
-0.0058484999,
-0.0367358364,
-0.0230286792,
-0.0715445578,
-0.0031102733,
0.0187299717,
-0.0453303829,
-0.0200757924,
2.349321199e-34,
0.0322932117,
-0.0394891724,
0.0193741117,
-0.0500030071,
0.0272221994,
0.0249149129,
-0.0000656901,
-0.0219777003,
0.0113273505,
-0.0607101619,
-0.0230274741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04156v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04156v1 | Prompting for Multimodal Hateful Meme Classification | 2023-02-08T16:04:08 | 2023-02-08T16:04:08 | Rui Cao, Roy Ka-Wei Lee, Wen-Haw Chong, Jing Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.MM | Hateful meme classification is a challenging multimodal task that requires
complex reasoning and contextual background knowledge. Ideally, we could
leverage an explicit external knowledge base to supplement contextual and
cultural information in hateful memes. However, there is no known explicit
external knowledge base that could provide such hate speech contextual
information. To address this gap, we propose PromptHate, a simple yet effective
prompt-based model that prompts pre-trained language models (PLMs) for hateful
meme classification. Specifically, we construct simple prompts and provide a
few in-context examples to exploit the implicit knowledge in the pre-trained
RoBERTa language model for hateful meme classification. We conduct extensive
experiments on two publicly available hateful and offensive meme datasets. Our
experimental results show that PromptHate is able to achieve a high AUC of
90.96, outperforming state-of-the-art baselines on the hateful meme
classification task. We also perform fine-grained analyses and case studies on
various prompt settings and demonstrate the effectiveness of the prompts on
hateful meme classification. | [
0.0621413887,
0.0538074337,
-0.0194815211,
0.0481943823,
0.0115394499,
0.0574991144,
0.0471234396,
0.0203667898,
0.0210091136,
-0.0956911296,
-0.0565618239,
-0.0157444868,
-0.0284548607,
0.0313390307,
0.0181561951,
-0.0632800683,
0.0221752748,
0.0192326307,
0.0298752543,
-0.0235365164,
0.0484881848,
0.0162111111,
-0.0166601427,
0.0380368643,
-0.0931233242,
-0.0122268284,
0.0305155311,
0.0307032913,
0.0038802272,
-0.0229240078,
0.0683158562,
0.040638756,
0.0248399973,
0.028689269,
0.0000018421,
-0.0459931828,
0.0332646854,
-0.0425101593,
-0.0184667781,
-0.039296817,
0.0413665883,
-0.0111258319,
0.0017172963,
0.0131573668,
-0.0171009321,
-0.0112059237,
0.0614646189,
0.0703648254,
0.0676465854,
0.0617752559,
-0.0148711745,
-0.0241980795,
-0.0172524061,
-0.0157267563,
0.0272681415,
0.0071783345,
0.0123091061,
-0.0416344665,
-0.0428727455,
0.0405933857,
-0.0242469516,
0.0265019182,
0.024041798,
0.0164710004,
-0.0020257076,
-0.0017806498,
0.0156782698,
-0.0477728099,
-0.0114640715,
0.0818615034,
-0.0179412737,
-0.0002978251,
-0.0160821732,
-0.0008530241,
0.0107259611,
-0.0386502072,
-0.0435331985,
0.0385434665,
-0.0090789869,
-0.0013972051,
-0.0293701869,
0.0305838175,
0.0405008383,
0.0588396713,
0.0271793939,
0.0021235603,
-0.0041112676,
-0.0186375491,
0.0335114002,
-0.0109558776,
-0.0270695146,
-0.024235988,
-0.0092825489,
0.0193121638,
-0.0250491425,
0.0232648551,
-0.0664164573,
-0.0267172474,
0.0243458673,
-0.0422725491,
0.0390343405,
0.0193720125,
-0.0762556121,
0.0342879593,
-0.0114441123,
0.0537069067,
-0.006934627,
0.0329200812,
0.0166721269,
0.0067493026,
-0.010735264,
-0.0121843806,
-0.0068777823,
-0.0118419733,
0.0042687831,
-0.0016748572,
-0.0416475125,
0.0111198658,
-0.0457608476,
0.0086004157,
-0.0215202812,
0.0061195623,
0.0028561936,
0.0056113377,
-0.0545545705,
0.0057696709,
-0.0449560285,
0.0176485665,
-0.0268439166,
-0.079171218,
0.0165695474,
0.0208100937,
-0.0157183148,
-0.0168046169,
0.0356917195,
0.0628914833,
0.0243017673,
-0.0324007794,
-0.0352957398,
-0.0369552448,
-0.0403902419,
-0.0473294854,
0.0120891174,
-0.0430250578,
0.045252312,
-0.0275753923,
-0.0084469495,
-0.0577191338,
0.0040285038,
0.0150373625,
-0.0189311262,
0.1061370149,
0.0144717675,
-0.0287080146,
0.045080252,
0.0370606109,
-0.0291364454,
0.0452505685,
-0.027369285,
0.0531605519,
0.0753482655,
-0.0208595097,
-0.0006779464,
0.0387883969,
0.0460324734,
-0.0213367976,
-0.0320970416,
0.0473271348,
-0.0160533264,
-0.0021357529,
0.0315200686,
0.047457844,
0.0017413733,
-0.0573333353,
0.0562895797,
0.0440051258,
-0.0502261557,
0.0039526327,
0.0759662986,
-0.0094885873,
-0.0070149917,
-0.0457896031,
-0.0799619332,
0.0062736999,
-0.0538433008,
-0.0255718604,
0.0517312251,
0.0521452315,
-0.0512213819,
-0.0436980985,
-0.0120615186,
-0.0648179576,
0.0243780836,
-0.0097995494,
0.0274931844,
0.0422825515,
-0.0511112548,
0.0006578699,
0.0387822501,
-0.0335160159,
-0.0086755753,
-0.0314026549,
0.0477369502,
0.0595734157,
0.0246433578,
-0.0206116419,
-0.0034283146,
-0.0478842407,
0.0158561729,
0.0321152136,
0.0149850016,
-0.0019797464,
0.0072966069,
-0.037116237,
-0.0287144259,
0.0115826661,
0.0069918945,
0.0167822074,
0.0463396013,
0.0333272927,
0.0214293525,
0.0599581003,
0.0041939775,
0.019978283,
0.0096178688,
-0.0439821519,
-0.0124586588,
0.0408434309,
0.050345283,
0.0207916275,
-0.0157037135,
-0.0574067123,
0.0024405066,
-0.0297852159,
-0.0319426693,
-0.011828566,
-0.0887636021,
-0.05836346,
0.016629152,
-0.0336269885,
-0.0100474879,
0.0714803189,
0.0000041218,
0.020921398,
0.0562277846,
-0.0050030602,
0.0129454806,
-0.057521712,
-0.02624215,
-0.0257765446,
0.0305349026,
-0.0037268724,
0.0731080249,
-0.0173436776,
-0.0093919663,
0.0411131084,
-0.0097315339,
0.0172204766,
0.0249439925,
-0.0694870651,
-0.0296597369,
-0.0042740246,
-0.0039632865,
-0.0085061584,
0.0262911152,
-0.0217417013,
0.020691501,
-0.0940829441,
-0.0072584236,
-0.0138425799,
-0.0480388142,
0.0067932089,
0.0026549057,
-0.0153354965,
-0.0438218862,
-0.0423135422,
0.0096834842,
0.0215476193,
0.0402004644,
0.0037436662,
-0.0192735903,
0.0090068076,
-0.0316281468,
-0.0047824732,
0.0132677983,
0.0547465235,
0.0187845621,
0.0061741434,
0.0335411429,
-0.0187532399,
-0.0433404259,
0.0315911211,
-0.0067291446,
-0.0406035669,
0.0248272065,
0.0074572302,
0.0297811013,
0.0183148496,
0.0468935743,
0.0892952308,
-0.0003263279,
0.0184090734,
-0.044146888,
0.007209918,
-0.0101549858,
0.0087670488,
0.0034188079,
-0.0449646264,
0.00877087,
0.0774067417,
0.0387267396,
0.0155013576,
-0.0754754171,
0.0611014143,
-0.0251381118,
-0.0298628751,
-0.0571394786,
-0.0707712919,
0.0091751423,
-0.0043536089,
-0.0510545224,
-0.0839609504,
0.07087107,
-0.0313908197,
-0.0299659781,
0.0158592239,
-0.0066188211,
0.0016411338,
0.0868504271,
0.0264330152,
0.0404740945,
-0.002778156,
0.0012886286,
0.0141822686,
-0.0485644452,
-0.0024142847,
-0.0066386163,
-0.0220918134,
-0.0087080272,
0.0081867725,
0.0130515555,
-0.0440192409,
-0.0755545944,
-0.075513199,
-0.0346143022,
-0.0547940917,
-0.0233587585,
0.0032004232,
0.0335477777,
0.0094511593,
0.0218445808,
-0.0136846546,
0.0005317198,
-0.0133583825,
0.0313364342,
-0.005531312,
0.0390045978,
-0.0089831641,
-0.0102764796,
-0.0143078687,
-0.0000846554,
0.0288473219,
-0.011224241,
-0.004883361,
-0.0399956703,
0.021965906,
0.0158899203,
0.0414807238,
0.008996198,
-0.0180555359,
0.0204423182,
0.0012294592,
0.0169583671,
0.1055625677,
0.0119035896,
-0.0499665253,
-0.0044441009,
0.0417827293,
-0.0174084902,
0.0259208828,
-0.0201572683,
-0.0600821637,
-0.0509859771,
-0.0458563827,
0.0132347057,
-0.0539264642,
-0.0035260483,
-0.0014764121,
-0.0815927684,
-0.0019217725,
-0.0183308516,
-0.0284902211,
-0.0149703156,
0.0334763192,
0.0209827404,
0.012456974,
0.0162766278,
-0.033767432,
0.0205900185,
0.0059175412,
-0.0211807266,
-0.0338931717,
-0.0281260312,
0.0248193312,
-0.0241652373,
0.0552005768,
0.0497611724,
0.0163679328,
-0.0008567967,
-0.0497193746,
0.0507573076,
-0.0222234726,
0.0016755443,
-0.0804766938,
0.0474763587,
-0.0118803065,
-0.0451795347,
-0.0193548556,
0.0028054097,
-0.0169158261,
0.0010501557,
-0.0007587607,
0.0589166358,
0.0009324467,
0.0044492683,
-0.0499497354,
0.0266956873,
0.0234419387,
0.0919797942,
0.035980396,
-0.0606640056,
0.016492486,
-0.0349777602,
-0.0009731013,
-0.028623376,
-0.0507554598,
-0.0021314076,
-0.0261519551,
-0.0199576784,
-0.0336763933,
-0.0425476469,
0.033462476,
0.0096465386,
0.0291784741,
-0.0416457392,
-0.0446507894,
0.005302914,
-0.0484379753,
0.0441929847,
-0.0008588111,
0.0224988554,
-0.0338686034,
-0.0366982818,
0.004334447,
-0.0431520715,
-0.0171082336,
0.0100368056,
-0.0260049924,
-0.0258143954,
0.0215888992,
0.1002148613,
0.0148526104,
0.0324313454,
0.0020830508,
-0.0465948619,
0.090577215,
0.033493042,
-0.0341604501,
-0.0137871346,
0.0345356017,
0.0186719671,
0.0148039591,
0.0247686449,
-0.0251983739,
0.0569335334,
0.0261409897,
-0.0469249785,
-0.0501975752,
-0.0254078414,
-0.0099366643,
-0.0257597156,
0.0513818413,
-0.0095038805,
-0.0582807437,
-0.0195676517,
-0.0162001345,
-0.0027531737,
-0.0368536636,
-0.0227482188,
0.0052689072,
0.0131599931,
-0.0013407528,
-0.0282053202,
-0.0365919732,
-0.0306050573,
0.0402901843,
-0.0180204231,
0.0069664661,
0.0889293775,
0.0442738049,
0.0111148963,
0.0214663781,
-0.0227104984,
0.0393065661,
-0.0002615126,
-0.0303332862,
-0.0124488622,
0.0814048648,
-0.0034988907,
-0.0215803552,
0.0094318502,
0.0223127678,
0.0368282311,
-0.0118168909,
-0.0037080671,
-0.0067348932,
0.0012051315,
-0.0266995225,
-0.0052034254,
0.0029980349,
-0.0073729921,
-0.0027487963,
0.0056304922,
0.004676173,
-0.0657200292,
0.0429195575,
0.0354809389,
-0.015901709,
0.0088905236,
0.0476047993,
-0.0553129762,
0.0361548737,
0.0379884988,
-0.0360781811,
-0.0424230434,
0.0381480157,
0.0532578342,
0.0289327279,
-0.0011294638,
0.0592576861,
-0.0244717114,
-0.0495529212,
-0.0050489437,
-0.0250372477,
-0.0090372572,
0.0391544476,
0.0251200981,
0.0739421248,
0.027259076,
0.0300463755,
0.0094274553,
0.0235459283,
-0.0240417942,
-0.0483082868,
-0.0061778608,
-5.960540634e-33,
-0.0326200947,
-0.0242141187,
-0.0066141947,
-0.0253170691,
0.0063990569,
0.0109014362,
0.0078032129,
-0.0007912365,
0.0105028367,
0.0012588075,
0.0100150993,
-0.0041200998,
-0.0115367277,
0.0082153007,
-0.0125484439,
-0.0148378955,
0.0216689594,
-0.0193943661,
-0.0261028484,
0.0047512655,
0.0448534153,
0.0319147147,
0.0122354236,
-0.0523908734,
0.0534106791,
-0.0300830826,
-0.0338824764,
0.0337871686,
0.0422237366,
0.0776713416,
-0.0442336351,
0.0860452056,
0.0433433168,
0.0016790318,
-0.0053635668,
0.0919428989,
-0.0747118518,
-0.0253668725,
0.0149482079,
0.0265220739,
-0.0182778817,
-0.0162201561,
0.0287213046,
-0.0191056281,
-0.0133698303,
0.0017911778,
0.0399027579,
-0.0259355512,
0.0475474261,
-0.0151507324,
-0.0468024909,
-0.0068851472,
-0.0212926939,
-0.0369248204,
0.0002092903,
0.0412231125,
0.0312220957,
0.0128600337,
-0.054478284,
0.0542967543,
-0.04316644,
-0.0518609621,
0.0189328399,
0.0038918697,
0.0047633741,
0.0913832262,
0.0010239647,
0.0128701329,
-0.023102697,
0.0292928796,
0.0108432788,
0.0292424057,
0.0293777306,
0.0718071833,
0.0355406627,
-0.0468941405,
-0.0323666148,
0.0217610672,
0.0335354358,
-0.0242418293,
0.0189752467,
-0.0359906293,
-0.0611089505,
-0.0002418386,
0.0064440952,
-0.0439357385,
-0.0303763542,
-0.0605881736,
0.0360738933,
-0.0036911352,
-0.0004629488,
-0.0167805329,
0.0173350554,
-0.0241716988,
-0.0088782487,
0.0189472865,
0.0218439866,
-0.0125235766,
0.0381714366,
0.0229991637,
-0.0103537692,
0.025937967,
0.0578044616,
-0.0581420846,
0.016403174,
0.024179358,
0.0670201853,
0.0522540286,
-0.0815588608,
-0.013382636,
-0.0153630041,
0.0542590208,
-0.0275440961,
0.0307871345,
0.0035266851,
0.0640387461,
-0.0471554995,
-0.0029812048,
0.0179923177,
-0.0341114812,
-0.0223325826,
-0.0381148048,
-0.0221167039,
0.0303036943,
-0.0257222243,
-0.0496356003,
-0.0093076518,
-0.0070980098,
0.0012340349,
-0.0925369561,
0.0101531446,
-0.0232135057,
2.431e-7,
-0.0036009701,
0.0004368066,
0.005447383,
0.042200774,
0.0273050703,
0.0443121679,
-0.0097581092,
0.0139967715,
-0.0182553846,
-0.0260857195,
-0.0044928538,
0.0642539114,
0.0107520306,
0.0334666781,
-0.0090769865,
-0.0393061601,
-0.0236895792,
0.0120086335,
-0.0836051777,
0.0169989206,
0.0509683713,
0.078913182,
0.0672791302,
-0.0605717525,
-0.0227395445,
-0.0382387564,
0.0295661204,
-0.0641389489,
-0.0006440673,
-0.064031899,
0.0695936903,
0.0026391947,
0.0171993524,
0.008599841,
0.0114510264,
-0.0480926707,
0.0204092711,
0.023752464,
0.0298015978,
-0.0480372645,
-0.0032114096,
0.0383434519,
-0.0198802538,
-0.0492614657,
0.0571709052,
0.0123036057,
0.002535444,
-0.0668689236,
-0.020344995,
-0.0215608571,
0.0590672307,
-0.0180088822,
-0.0431642085,
-0.029043382,
0.059471976,
-0.0154733211,
0.000335937,
-0.1144394279,
0.0007181938,
0.0039548161,
-0.0350861177,
-0.0040032933,
-0.0421039984,
-0.0390692689,
0.0514987148,
0.0087110884,
0.0416710153,
1.841880147e-34,
0.0176189691,
-0.0355181322,
0.0202512555,
-0.0305753481,
0.0155354897,
0.0108464072,
0.0180784781,
-0.0132056205,
0.040193066,
-0.0428491719,
-0.0175572243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04116v1 | Training-free Lexical Backdoor Attacks on Language Models | 2023-02-08T15:18:51 | 2023-02-08T15:18:51 | Yujin Huang, Terry Yue Zhuo, Qiongkai Xu, Han Hu, Xingliang Yuan, Chunyang Chen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large-scale language models have achieved tremendous success across various
natural language processing (NLP) applications. Nevertheless, language models
are vulnerable to backdoor attacks, which inject stealthy triggers into models
for steering them to undesirable behaviors. Most existing backdoor attacks,
such as data poisoning, require further (re)training or fine-tuning language
models to learn the intended backdoor patterns. The additional training process
however diminishes the stealthiness of the attacks, as training a language
model usually requires long optimization time, a massive amount of data, and
considerable modifications to the model parameters. In this work, we propose
Training-Free Lexical Backdoor Attack (TFLexAttack) as the first training-free
backdoor attack on language models. Our attack is achieved by injecting lexical
triggers into the tokenizer of a language model via manipulating its embedding
dictionary using carefully designed rules. These rules are explainable to human
developers which inspires attacks from a wider range of hackers. The sparse
manipulation of the dictionary also habilitates the stealthiness of our attack.
We conduct extensive experiments on three dominant NLP tasks based on nine
language models to demonstrate the effectiveness and universality of our
attack. The code of this work is available at
https://github.com/Jinxhy/TFLexAttack. | [
0.0582630336,
0.0840644315,
-0.0189121384,
0.0787028521,
-0.0504043736,
-0.0160600133,
-0.0023634119,
0.008358974,
-0.0006254846,
-0.0682117715,
0.0071394276,
0.0297116581,
0.0118259378,
0.0689747557,
0.0726611838,
0.0247064829,
0.0614915267,
-0.031905584,
-0.0298614763,
-0.0014388802,
-0.0229978673,
-0.0034917358,
0.0078699877,
0.0390781686,
-0.0118810087,
0.0123723131,
-0.0022852854,
0.0037701277,
-0.008603191,
-0.0209826436,
0.0031198012,
0.0350611806,
-0.0178698692,
0.068825908,
0.0000019443,
-0.0241956078,
-0.0399210863,
0.0216876194,
-0.0108298697,
0.0262593478,
0.0187700875,
-0.0316427313,
-0.0374592431,
0.0078995274,
-0.0588603839,
-0.0235214643,
0.0374203324,
0.0479941294,
0.0911215246,
0.0865619034,
-0.0026279157,
-0.0050912406,
0.0459317043,
-0.0168992169,
-0.0035176466,
-0.0275718588,
0.0166282281,
-0.0384909734,
-0.031380102,
0.0182717368,
-0.023067642,
-0.0051699895,
-0.0123407329,
-0.0159604903,
-0.0142899845,
0.0258581433,
-0.0334432162,
-0.0445802733,
-0.0167260077,
0.0448399447,
-0.0709234402,
-0.0216001477,
-0.0108116213,
0.0121569308,
-0.0026993051,
0.0256379712,
0.0216351841,
0.0181613714,
0.0259347241,
-0.0032280891,
0.0469640419,
-0.0360279679,
0.0548589118,
0.0001274352,
0.0118312165,
0.0473688692,
0.0268636979,
-0.015417764,
-0.0206204094,
-0.067025654,
0.0076778368,
-0.0745738149,
-0.0275197979,
-0.0009122759,
0.0161035098,
0.0276009124,
-0.0527688451,
-0.0321658216,
0.0321146585,
-0.0565804504,
0.0075043794,
0.0444672331,
-0.0344619378,
0.0251565725,
-0.0400449745,
0.0319955684,
-0.0138081927,
0.0207799021,
-0.002022628,
0.009104155,
-0.0243103299,
-0.0351320989,
-0.0302229002,
0.0183687732,
-0.0571709424,
-0.0256939419,
-0.0204918291,
0.017196767,
-0.014219665,
0.0214183461,
-0.0178371631,
0.0167124439,
-0.02087285,
0.0344586484,
0.0280371122,
-0.0399080478,
0.0125839477,
-0.0244620889,
-0.024834618,
-0.0899001658,
-0.0248613525,
-0.0232430045,
-0.0346457623,
-0.013192839,
-0.0020051764,
0.0778160915,
0.0405258723,
-0.0371569283,
-0.0658147335,
-0.0475595482,
-0.0074380175,
0.0128315752,
-0.0267307833,
-0.0776298866,
-0.046082817,
-0.0303709768,
0.0035182531,
-0.0588846542,
0.0259002224,
0.0231836513,
-0.0569017902,
0.1097096726,
-0.0353363231,
-0.0316865034,
0.0274584834,
0.0085043041,
-0.0134591628,
0.0720818415,
-0.0036104131,
0.0378261879,
0.0570573658,
-0.0136147095,
0.0244219564,
0.0277769975,
0.0110130711,
0.0247022454,
-0.0595753044,
-0.0042186878,
0.0409897231,
-0.0484358594,
-0.0201105699,
0.042800229,
-0.0176340733,
-0.0318194479,
0.0606976412,
0.0733538494,
-0.017901266,
0.0459090099,
0.0275769252,
-0.0357307643,
-0.0464282408,
-0.0268060248,
-0.0867283493,
-0.0523920767,
-0.0739074647,
-0.0190765988,
0.0025221049,
0.0239193458,
0.0229297802,
-0.0249761492,
-0.0136131719,
-0.0152415028,
0.044453796,
-0.0294653866,
0.0358841531,
0.0632719919,
-0.0020394833,
0.0469975173,
0.0181073118,
-0.0298724957,
-0.0254055951,
-0.065533787,
-0.0500778407,
0.0433869064,
0.0887141451,
-0.0051780422,
0.0182291996,
-0.0436864235,
-0.0337852985,
0.0224386062,
-0.0010790812,
0.0074918834,
0.0161543489,
0.002562396,
-0.0075786589,
-0.022880327,
0.0443865508,
0.0128643513,
0.0292815529,
-0.0091558192,
0.0064049256,
-0.0124259647,
-0.0292991344,
0.040256165,
-0.008115259,
-0.0828280672,
0.0099450517,
0.0155536616,
0.02277348,
0.0017730119,
-0.0271657053,
0.02854985,
0.041254051,
-0.0141485622,
-0.001721701,
-0.0145894727,
0.0208254289,
-0.0136346547,
0.0415710881,
-0.0129344119,
0.0156601947,
0.0848580226,
-0.0238377824,
-0.0231973622,
0.0521849915,
-0.0435678959,
0.0896680579,
-0.003985553,
0.0123281563,
-0.0060658758,
0.0275656004,
-0.0322360396,
0.0343642086,
-0.0258762892,
0.0266602114,
-0.0438079201,
0.0111849094,
0.0096971309,
-0.0042423243,
-0.0409439914,
0.0257489011,
-0.0356909595,
0.0098116454,
0.0104663987,
-0.0025919692,
-0.0024164368,
-0.0198238902,
-0.0382799916,
0.0015423171,
-0.0243396685,
0.0306706652,
0.0302119367,
0.0302637275,
-0.0225827098,
-0.0261672307,
-0.0000066712,
-0.0377342068,
-0.0151227973,
0.0370119363,
0.0001570491,
-0.020561317,
-0.0428068154,
-0.0123944748,
-0.0297672767,
-0.0263744686,
0.0914579481,
-0.0305264276,
0.008868455,
-0.0420260727,
-0.0061826417,
0.0073028798,
0.0668272525,
-0.0179225355,
-0.0537223592,
0.018937774,
0.0109916544,
-0.0366632231,
0.0826171786,
0.0140080797,
0.0443219543,
0.0567569993,
0.0001967922,
-0.0369286723,
-0.0088304477,
0.0336951539,
-0.0219664499,
-0.0588087216,
-0.0116600525,
0.0086728139,
0.0767612606,
0.0320339985,
-0.0304456614,
-0.0170138236,
0.0182549134,
-0.0152299432,
-0.0149847949,
-0.0097849984,
-0.0548124872,
-0.0395777635,
-0.0011553111,
-0.0133688543,
-0.0877006203,
0.0697039142,
-0.0675834492,
0.0231868308,
-0.0457225442,
-0.0365058407,
-0.0126957176,
0.05009868,
0.0046388446,
0.0331767052,
0.0435097516,
-0.032265462,
-0.0013310174,
-0.0228140913,
0.0303249955,
-0.0274194237,
0.0288628917,
-0.0205109101,
-0.0072890865,
-0.0166101586,
-0.0211710427,
-0.0765444189,
-0.0558004566,
-0.0317521468,
0.0150896497,
0.0533954315,
-0.0407343507,
0.0053926301,
-0.0157406051,
0.0101643596,
0.0275331587,
0.0069932598,
-0.0146619948,
-0.0323083512,
0.015201238,
0.0445684232,
-0.0772805586,
0.0041414886,
0.0167594682,
-0.003781256,
0.0707981735,
0.0575242005,
0.0177863371,
-0.0529784448,
0.0296954606,
0.013219174,
-0.037284527,
-0.0048451577,
-0.0018088751,
-0.0022739072,
-0.0315086097,
-0.0321101025,
0.065273203,
0.0321775004,
-0.0239427295,
0.0335728526,
0.0245315563,
0.001780668,
0.0428579561,
0.0013951433,
-0.0683209673,
-0.0408941731,
0.0355688632,
0.0141709866,
-0.0151937585,
-0.0167240817,
-0.0272866394,
-0.1382509023,
-0.0304476023,
0.0167106502,
-0.0279239118,
0.0010260737,
-0.079131715,
-0.0217709132,
-0.0127946381,
-0.0081045311,
-0.0238620993,
0.0154202217,
0.0078509059,
-0.024897974,
0.0162315257,
-0.0115019931,
0.0191294234,
-0.0274871308,
0.0742285028,
0.0787138939,
0.0067068338,
-0.0192210805,
0.0243344009,
0.0606862567,
-0.0000848832,
0.0086767785,
-0.0087479157,
0.0441822521,
-0.0165434051,
-0.0175588429,
0.0595564805,
0.0542827807,
-0.0436230525,
-0.0036638933,
-0.0069175242,
0.0373245068,
0.0178713202,
0.0175692085,
-0.0199720506,
-0.0425830595,
0.0455758199,
0.04003172,
0.0132082663,
-0.0306774098,
-0.0214022398,
-0.0883759409,
-0.0202959143,
-0.0061292872,
-0.0881072432,
0.0054583796,
0.0363150388,
-0.0819610506,
-0.045570679,
0.011778499,
-0.0027407757,
0.0248716921,
0.0360909849,
0.0168986712,
-0.0094712982,
0.0184377097,
-0.0491234139,
0.0229306854,
-0.0022525913,
0.048034057,
-0.0406988636,
-0.0062398738,
0.0317243151,
0.0036682261,
-0.0157047324,
0.008833928,
-0.0563890114,
-0.0892921686,
0.0022917117,
0.05865198,
0.0190997012,
0.0448987186,
-0.0427049361,
-0.0395425856,
0.0851333067,
0.0450641699,
-0.0462778099,
0.0055146744,
0.0621310398,
-0.0296533778,
0.0326518863,
0.0352485925,
-0.0334209315,
-0.0079172151,
0.0588531196,
0.0116321314,
-0.0341489539,
0.0139975436,
0.0202174801,
0.040400289,
0.0790422782,
-0.0136301341,
0.0184456855,
0.0191679243,
0.0178493131,
-0.0156251155,
-0.0290379636,
-0.0151293129,
0.0421434455,
0.0162958894,
-0.0023130511,
0.0261579361,
-0.0350915454,
-0.0125964452,
0.0319052078,
-0.0093769142,
0.0406110734,
0.0395718589,
0.03338347,
0.0483012833,
0.0175786838,
-0.0094944555,
0.0233265832,
-0.0183835272,
0.0198210552,
-0.0220053941,
0.0040519675,
0.0032901838,
-0.0056292661,
-0.0486199595,
0.0330197997,
-0.0733604953,
0.0067105466,
0.0084668836,
0.0045682457,
0.0178287681,
-0.0292542856,
0.0182724074,
-0.0087000923,
0.0026627816,
0.0002732723,
-0.0266546719,
0.0070416364,
-0.0393855311,
0.011753737,
0.0036755172,
-0.0222868156,
0.0284042917,
0.0848637968,
0.0302660186,
0.0702959225,
0.0213517733,
-0.0014880826,
-0.0443337932,
0.0021497968,
0.0438207723,
0.039760448,
-0.0307845045,
0.0201322548,
-0.0272686183,
-0.0973318517,
-0.0161481779,
0.0058445558,
0.0345569849,
0.0263317563,
-0.0257098768,
0.0689352676,
0.0403243266,
0.0104892934,
-0.0839494541,
0.0243086163,
0.0428890511,
-0.0596039221,
-0.0080445157,
-5.653361185e-33,
0.0507349446,
-0.0351561345,
-0.0416873805,
0.0231214296,
0.0467496887,
0.0285750162,
-0.0095828976,
0.0071618771,
-0.0294081736,
-0.0141310645,
-0.011779407,
0.0159358531,
-0.0053069638,
0.0207569301,
-0.0239196513,
0.0309628155,
0.0092204455,
0.0059426748,
-0.0339846425,
0.0059221243,
0.0523606129,
0.0136505086,
0.0422299132,
-0.034424495,
0.0258841831,
0.0097928466,
-0.0230861809,
0.0409707427,
-0.0330598578,
0.0695290118,
-0.0084833521,
0.0197038706,
-0.0052975658,
-0.0490761288,
-0.01103763,
0.0318727791,
-0.0167738814,
-0.0111061977,
-0.0083621386,
-0.0137774264,
0.0338531137,
-0.0439114943,
0.0688972846,
-0.0249933787,
-0.0096096704,
0.0109177399,
0.0053430754,
-0.0337827206,
-0.0303022787,
0.0054560634,
-0.0314714722,
0.0238002166,
-0.0295343027,
-0.0237100683,
0.0168554783,
-0.0136263482,
0.0219748784,
-0.0223321375,
-0.0515838191,
0.0253046453,
0.0377719477,
0.0322284624,
0.048116412,
-0.0066251582,
0.007066966,
0.0579627194,
0.0400104336,
-0.0146054504,
-0.0038601845,
0.0077208481,
0.0177109428,
0.0515372939,
0.0411615744,
0.0459377319,
0.0878355727,
-0.0530385971,
-0.0362403132,
-0.012614293,
0.0090562431,
0.0246276446,
0.0503347032,
0.0243320409,
-0.0715630054,
0.0081713954,
-0.038839858,
-0.0258356631,
-0.0357805714,
-0.0089908596,
0.0064672991,
0.0273909234,
-0.0465989299,
-0.0077490415,
-0.0063828519,
-0.0737087503,
0.0071450206,
0.0457849614,
0.0151121914,
-0.0227203108,
-0.0093567409,
-0.0039641438,
0.0132711418,
-0.0058511025,
-0.0258827507,
-0.0348298512,
0.039224375,
0.0077533787,
0.0150136771,
0.0093852254,
-0.0786796883,
-0.0142380521,
-0.0264832173,
0.0120985061,
0.0160442349,
0.0450624079,
0.0462436639,
-0.0298420303,
0.004913717,
-0.0096443119,
0.0359107852,
0.018974049,
-0.0516051166,
0.0404643826,
-0.0231161211,
0.0204721428,
-0.0144396396,
-0.0321282744,
-0.0086292755,
0.0509743616,
0.0614400506,
-0.0348224305,
0.0036907878,
-0.0152385831,
2.796e-7,
0.0019298916,
0.0333986059,
0.0033216092,
0.0194290429,
0.0137869054,
0.0792334825,
-0.0067443047,
0.0589440428,
-0.0140301008,
-0.0372249037,
-0.0746234655,
0.0046460619,
0.0261660293,
0.0258422941,
-0.063029401,
0.0264873374,
-0.0499107391,
0.0144756977,
-0.0409269482,
-0.002345555,
0.0113954879,
0.1153515577,
0.0199800171,
-0.0223247726,
-0.0219898988,
-0.0721306801,
-0.0121252807,
0.003832398,
-0.0096504614,
0.000627413,
0.0296777673,
0.0563298836,
0.0171014518,
-0.0008057896,
-0.0598672591,
0.0120392172,
-0.0640827343,
0.0237108767,
-0.0492404848,
-0.0233608112,
-0.0331144892,
-0.0567210801,
-0.0128964502,
-0.0230200123,
0.0611773543,
0.0288042482,
-0.0140616447,
-0.0560915619,
0.0027820356,
-0.0011689991,
0.0285653975,
-0.0490782186,
-0.0171037428,
0.0228644181,
0.0185201149,
0.0134054357,
-0.0023814521,
-0.088712275,
-0.0394109376,
-0.0283886325,
-0.012662285,
-0.0274164602,
-0.0020110896,
0.0093798582,
-0.0026209147,
0.0068782624,
0.0075195287,
2.790324205e-34,
0.0083975242,
-0.0309394635,
0.0070343702,
0.0404426195,
0.0602705218,
-0.0107349642,
0.0306206942,
0.0061701336,
0.0040805996,
-0.0408186801,
-0.0306392983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04084v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04084v2 | Reception Reader: Exploring Text Reuse in Early Modern British Publications | 2023-02-08T14:37:35 | 2023-04-18T13:41:20 | David Rosson, Eetu Mäkelä, Ville Vaara, Ananth Mahadevan, Yann Ryan, Mikko Tolonen | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.HC, J.5 | The Reception Reader is a web tool for studying text reuse in the Early
English Books Online (EEBO-TCP) and Eighteenth Century Collections Online
(ECCO) data. Users can: 1) explore a visual overview of the reception of a
work, or its incoming connections, across time based on shared text segments,
2) interactively survey the details of connected documents, and 3) examine the
context of reused text for "close reading". We show examples of how the tool
streamlines research and exploration tasks, and discuss the utility and
limitations of the user interface along with its current data sources. | [
0.0502838604,
-0.021155294,
-0.0147086922,
0.0252481662,
-0.0431948453,
0.014666968,
0.0302088857,
0.0330882706,
0.0202644337,
-0.0323269665,
-0.0184569564,
0.0677747875,
0.06161879,
-0.0013565207,
-0.0253160335,
0.0011562372,
0.0074447514,
0.0556072257,
-0.0698521584,
0.0254717898,
0.0602714531,
0.0380964205,
0.0286419895,
0.0069241296,
0.0152256368,
-0.0172932371,
-0.0389540493,
0.0058231605,
0.0106858797,
-0.0260128602,
0.0114632649,
0.0495100692,
0.0229389314,
0.025959149,
0.0000017969,
0.0010519195,
-0.0023824137,
-0.0151846176,
-0.0193743147,
0.0679724142,
0.0965508297,
0.0819222257,
0.0038688525,
-0.0705550388,
0.0067343777,
0.0321911089,
0.0085996594,
0.0175816361,
-0.0238636453,
-0.0162100233,
0.0086208964,
0.0000589794,
0.0076677264,
0.0177427307,
0.0810129941,
0.0048197256,
-0.0206360947,
0.0273471791,
0.0981101394,
0.0838850811,
0.0110622551,
0.0602078103,
-0.0194608569,
-0.0260880999,
-0.0280966423,
-0.0056327251,
0.0182464365,
0.0075702467,
-0.0100767212,
-0.0198876318,
0.1256810427,
-0.0102260476,
0.0476319827,
0.0009265175,
-0.0473725311,
0.0685190111,
-0.0414973237,
-0.0701151565,
-0.0308175012,
0.0061485758,
-0.0314949565,
-0.0306571331,
0.0119804954,
0.0152803231,
-0.0253053419,
-0.0126122963,
-0.0074442364,
0.0236310568,
0.0365696326,
0.0056071472,
0.0386038087,
-0.0427923016,
-0.0085520605,
0.0187944211,
0.1079109684,
-0.0039453334,
-0.0042820582,
-0.0521212369,
0.0104686338,
0.0210697781,
0.0643413067,
0.0024275985,
-0.0620238297,
0.0230276063,
0.0855727792,
-0.0274652541,
-0.0049917581,
-0.0536892042,
0.0146521861,
0.0297266468,
-0.0440065563,
-0.0150193339,
0.0003221819,
0.0144839948,
0.0173693541,
-0.0655401424,
0.023232935,
-0.0336452425,
0.0392094776,
0.0014909575,
0.0172030572,
-0.0127946557,
-0.0138150845,
-0.0119710816,
-0.01141492,
-0.0363570787,
-0.0214753617,
-0.020518329,
-0.0456166938,
-0.0475057624,
-0.0069018309,
-0.0346900001,
0.0298672877,
-0.0626990646,
-0.0400794074,
-0.0317579024,
0.0146160098,
-0.0239660982,
-0.0277988724,
-0.0426568277,
-0.0090997247,
0.0391309969,
0.017127838,
-0.0203807987,
0.0348942876,
-0.0002687126,
0.0346023142,
0.0235828292,
0.0110606346,
0.0236226581,
-0.0568817332,
-0.015249704,
-0.0583329462,
-0.0109680993,
-0.0077326461,
0.0013682706,
0.0228558369,
-0.0290448591,
0.0212854333,
-0.025357211,
0.0392233804,
0.0336524136,
0.0299556702,
0.0304724518,
-0.0297353063,
-0.0307562836,
-0.0120688332,
-0.0388189964,
-0.0614852123,
0.0180421825,
-0.0083669135,
-0.0059740776,
-0.0917031094,
0.0152259897,
0.0259871371,
0.0497705229,
0.074070476,
0.0278196763,
-0.0160392988,
0.0514639616,
0.0299148913,
0.0129077686,
0.0173185058,
0.0095919715,
0.0345744863,
-0.0050077969,
-0.0522287488,
-0.0154321035,
0.0207591057,
-0.0145756556,
-0.0007429266,
0.0266183,
0.0163283702,
-0.0211829171,
0.0045666881,
0.0170914885,
0.038370233,
-0.0160983633,
-0.0263404325,
-0.0497541577,
0.0188039877,
0.0379340984,
0.0595659167,
0.1310892105,
0.0890718997,
0.0170896761,
0.080804117,
0.0375015326,
-0.0146838343,
0.0478181876,
0.0158901624,
-0.0127132405,
0.0167320911,
-0.0030304536,
-0.0270213932,
-0.0346849151,
-0.0381370373,
0.0141492188,
-0.0554911941,
0.0607553758,
-0.0137125291,
-0.0427903943,
-0.010073035,
0.0338399746,
0.0343546048,
-0.0308038406,
-0.0140719647,
0.00874284,
-0.0244341884,
0.0261278078,
-0.0295122731,
0.0066271932,
0.0088160103,
0.0114566665,
0.0269170031,
0.0477507077,
0.0101151895,
0.0428016298,
0.0172247346,
-0.0799413249,
0.0702744648,
0.0017687641,
0.0122175319,
-0.0239802878,
0.0080798371,
-0.0405958146,
0.0868066102,
0.010276149,
-0.0152196325,
-0.0283967704,
-0.0050827465,
-0.0094934637,
0.041648753,
0.0160501394,
0.0179119054,
0.0070060082,
-0.071791023,
0.0255963802,
0.0340566523,
-0.0277243238,
-0.0311135296,
0.0381391719,
0.017630849,
0.0536880605,
-0.0672406703,
-0.0299117677,
-0.0312628485,
-0.0794714466,
-0.005443383,
-0.0064591207,
0.0184621587,
0.029074572,
-0.0040387148,
-0.0064564371,
0.0184089001,
0.0571753234,
-0.010362206,
-0.0726416856,
0.0122961132,
0.0255137142,
-0.0142959142,
0.0202910416,
-0.0273862071,
-0.0095277987,
0.0086377813,
0.0478266142,
0.0259124674,
-0.0215424821,
-0.0532771386,
-0.0443924479,
0.0446661673,
-0.0400476865,
-0.0065466482,
0.049119018,
0.0137633411,
0.0033914847,
0.004803184,
-0.0152530279,
-0.0104514994,
0.0117615489,
-0.0127512962,
-0.0712087899,
-0.0732203871,
-0.0184707958,
0.0250103008,
-0.0040139765,
0.0004746171,
-0.0443308316,
0.0570534058,
-0.0505646989,
-0.0274540465,
0.0408526957,
0.0167173874,
0.0015926972,
0.0176896024,
-0.0279146153,
-0.0750445575,
-0.0623815432,
-0.0403138846,
0.0455158167,
0.0288772378,
0.0141910231,
-0.077098757,
-0.0094419774,
0.0120032104,
-0.0806976706,
0.0165305585,
0.0001106588,
0.0862608552,
-0.0301206838,
-0.0154842073,
0.0134445336,
-0.0302875713,
0.0000247707,
0.0268540587,
0.0791162625,
-0.0214296468,
0.0090229949,
0.0012409481,
-0.0128419409,
0.0357901044,
0.0271806195,
0.0136473775,
-0.0227336641,
-0.0330218971,
-0.0695552975,
0.0342496373,
-0.0375709794,
-0.0590857677,
-0.0080967322,
0.0561564229,
0.0229128469,
0.0183027536,
-0.019036755,
0.0130472556,
0.0484130718,
0.0141286654,
0.0115481932,
-0.0052809552,
-0.024139937,
-0.0803065896,
0.0250317585,
-0.0636242926,
0.024797868,
0.0043806131,
0.0025445998,
-0.0015053907,
-0.0249670539,
-0.0521014929,
0.0168444198,
-0.0353083871,
-0.0564311855,
0.0219308324,
0.0346526019,
0.0320657194,
-0.0804130509,
-0.0338571668,
-0.0403672867,
-0.0327891335,
-0.0045859977,
-0.0142217623,
-0.0655718446,
0.0618000738,
0.000390815,
0.0283001009,
0.0093120495,
-0.0243600067,
-0.0002813489,
-0.0477158651,
0.0298151597,
-0.0173132904,
-0.0035283072,
0.0466823429,
0.0171982124,
0.0142528303,
0.0181358084,
-0.0925642997,
0.0190234743,
-0.0133634787,
0.0223061349,
-0.0329456851,
-0.0226939693,
0.0367028415,
-0.0505027175,
-0.0077747791,
-0.0394936725,
0.0044830525,
0.0612154268,
-0.0052223993,
-0.0411960445,
0.0049801632,
-0.0746328756,
-0.008503193,
-0.0109969331,
0.0774306059,
0.032205373,
0.039539203,
-0.0506573506,
0.0053119776,
0.0321521759,
-0.0370711982,
0.030255435,
-0.0363583937,
0.0173071194,
-0.0132342167,
-0.0447410904,
0.0031585512,
0.0489577912,
-0.0204883777,
0.0326355211,
-0.0052368324,
-0.015047065,
-0.0075867409,
0.0766637027,
-0.0104036387,
-0.076862216,
0.0172299072,
-0.0287677962,
-0.0161272101,
-0.0618655682,
-0.0165315513,
-0.0642400756,
0.0418057367,
0.0852951109,
0.015231262,
0.0101477085,
-0.0551312268,
-0.0180879664,
-0.0224128049,
-0.0219804309,
-0.0178600382,
-0.0109855877,
0.0087264478,
0.0056746947,
-0.0046727532,
-0.0021749707,
-0.0022278051,
-0.0138819423,
0.0040171384,
0.013415169,
-0.033237543,
0.029894527,
-0.0176768843,
-0.0040809908,
-0.0197099037,
-0.0358057134,
0.0149062257,
0.0173976626,
-0.01026065,
-0.0484845936,
0.0465577617,
-0.0376329497,
-0.0085913399,
-0.0294313841,
-0.0127037419,
-0.0194097944,
-0.0414640382,
0.0126586109,
-0.01127561,
-0.0027461431,
-0.0449936166,
-0.0083189029,
-0.0252856575,
0.0326457843,
0.0162051562,
-0.000563401,
0.0057293358,
0.0098576313,
0.0238464884,
0.0165859964,
-0.025392374,
-0.0604000054,
-0.008409569,
0.0736638904,
0.0185276549,
0.0845383555,
-0.0476644859,
0.0062945457,
0.0411194228,
-0.0024105641,
-0.0288889408,
-0.0066795358,
0.0052208458,
0.0389255583,
-0.0047189496,
0.1036506891,
0.036886692,
0.003959232,
0.0317630395,
-0.0117209703,
0.0079251723,
-0.0009077865,
-0.0741437301,
-0.0376588106,
0.0588720739,
-0.0186848529,
0.003786589,
-0.0431601815,
0.093766965,
0.0168438759,
-0.0361228436,
-0.025738569,
0.0089609027,
-0.0094508426,
0.0278409831,
-0.05880934,
0.0084779989,
0.0018367011,
0.0022686112,
0.0241916459,
-0.0641676411,
-0.0231243409,
0.0198277254,
-0.0140020065,
-0.0401379392,
-0.0177438222,
0.0234026462,
-0.0203293897,
0.0257222187,
-0.0274183471,
-0.0381481573,
-0.002263068,
0.0727793202,
0.0277200378,
-0.0176685322,
-0.0178264156,
0.0396566465,
0.0251483079,
-0.0200034417,
0.0255323593,
-0.0013470753,
0.074616693,
-0.0203053113,
-0.0690665841,
-0.0295227729,
-5.823742479e-33,
0.042548161,
-0.0158513077,
0.0014265907,
0.029615365,
-0.0264080483,
0.001652573,
-0.0041325116,
-0.0324953049,
0.0158088692,
-0.0103821857,
-0.0711471066,
-0.0030205462,
0.0050404794,
-0.0301243737,
0.0415005013,
0.0233843271,
0.0309658609,
0.0639372244,
-0.0374883376,
-0.0021349285,
0.0743051469,
0.006741635,
-0.0144898938,
-0.0677057952,
0.0359484591,
-0.0541729666,
-0.0099715628,
-0.0307726618,
0.0781425461,
0.0147284698,
-0.0107698981,
-0.0801219046,
0.0098469052,
0.0565495193,
-0.0171563663,
0.0883130655,
-0.0391784757,
-0.0509735756,
0.0227179751,
0.0129691949,
0.0445593558,
-0.0094956569,
0.0004573126,
0.0092313718,
-0.0402196944,
-0.0054206327,
0.0444089733,
0.022194434,
-0.0869506747,
-0.0080900108,
-0.0095056184,
0.0017087947,
-0.0306703318,
0.0286460239,
0.0367121585,
0.0030211543,
0.0171377081,
0.0094748409,
-0.0680321902,
0.0062860898,
-0.017319398,
-0.0014046557,
-0.0443052277,
-0.0303712543,
0.027593337,
0.0459774695,
-0.0030181434,
-0.0101222908,
0.0241354406,
0.0298360549,
0.0107179871,
-0.031503737,
-0.00311165,
0.0539218411,
0.0094671175,
-0.0031809581,
0.0351711065,
0.0093047107,
0.0173413772,
0.0270180348,
0.027776666,
-0.0089047402,
-0.0038216312,
-0.016289629,
0.0011383862,
0.0143040335,
0.0083213476,
-0.0258613154,
-0.0128940456,
-0.019280931,
0.0129219014,
-0.0134001523,
-0.0232221019,
-0.0015358607,
-0.097806409,
-0.022380786,
-0.001137704,
0.0547998697,
-0.0146114063,
-0.0274042245,
-0.0060124677,
0.0204928387,
0.0027000806,
0.0101434505,
-0.0095480466,
-0.0147184245,
0.0275543779,
0.0161066223,
-0.0309424754,
-0.0196754579,
0.0265275035,
-0.0427923426,
-0.0124465879,
-0.0243955087,
0.0436317883,
0.0032110494,
0.0218981151,
-0.0262597948,
0.0171310678,
0.0045880605,
0.0136731211,
-0.0359547064,
0.0266541466,
-0.0062158736,
0.0350771025,
0.0169722829,
-0.0035053855,
0.0385557562,
0.0776766464,
-0.0294410158,
0.0065913335,
-0.004006783,
2.694e-7,
0.0574730858,
-0.0236308724,
0.0447124466,
0.00415206,
0.0057090814,
-0.0350837931,
-0.014213752,
0.0281715579,
-0.0696547031,
0.0030759214,
0.0389472768,
-0.0389746316,
0.0714617297,
0.0390483402,
-0.0639229417,
-0.0460781455,
-0.0761983246,
-0.0738550723,
-0.0496029966,
-0.0051086107,
0.0091929846,
-0.0129319998,
0.0110206306,
-0.0187345855,
0.0011320286,
-0.0079157799,
-0.0114739807,
-0.0716824681,
0.0170277301,
-0.0195431821,
0.0220391955,
0.0077850637,
-0.0253928863,
0.0117101166,
0.0091070933,
-0.0089775128,
-0.002418977,
-0.0647662133,
0.0540655218,
0.0290737767,
0.0034193508,
-0.0462356023,
0.0088782646,
0.0056183706,
0.0181638878,
0.0675456822,
0.0533155873,
0.0290733874,
-0.0350211076,
-0.0255366229,
0.0170392618,
-0.0206047744,
-0.0406461842,
0.0222979113,
-0.0005531479,
0.0043374519,
0.0297124255,
-0.0548720323,
0.047055833,
0.0216923915,
-0.0147076175,
-0.0208375566,
-0.0151874181,
-0.052145496,
-0.0086540673,
-0.0427266769,
0.0097201709,
1.967777773e-34,
0.0352954119,
-0.0745799169,
-0.0294675697,
0.0502807871,
0.019419862,
-0.0220902674,
0.0453478694,
0.0328889936,
-0.0144534614,
-0.0415343419,
-0.0241078231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04054v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04054v7 | Towards Inferential Reproducibility of Machine Learning Research | 2023-02-08T13:47:00 | 2023-10-09T15:05:36 | Michael Hagmann, Philipp Meier, Stefan Riezler | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.AP, stat.ML | Reliability of machine learning evaluation -- the consistency of observed
evaluation scores across replicated model training runs -- is affected by
several sources of nondeterminism which can be regarded as measurement noise.
Current tendencies to remove noise in order to enforce reproducibility of
research results neglect inherent nondeterminism at the implementation level
and disregard crucial interaction effects between algorithmic noise factors and
data properties. This limits the scope of conclusions that can be drawn from
such experiments. Instead of removing noise, we propose to incorporate several
sources of variance, including their interaction with data properties, into an
analysis of significance and reliability of machine learning evaluation, with
the aim to draw inferences beyond particular instances of trained models. We
show how to use linear mixed effects models (LMEMs) to analyze performance
evaluation scores, and to conduct statistical inference with a generalized
likelihood ratio test (GLRT). This allows us to incorporate arbitrary sources
of noise like meta-parameter variations into statistical significance testing,
and to assess performance differences conditional on data properties.
Furthermore, a variance component analysis (VCA) enables the analysis of the
contribution of noise sources to overall variance and the computation of a
reliability coefficient by the ratio of substantial to total variance. | [
-0.005815743,
0.045249857,
-0.0332751945,
-0.0033692014,
-0.0263823122,
-0.0061831442,
0.0287808683,
-0.0279893875,
-0.031579297,
-0.0223522261,
-0.0248243734,
0.0042300043,
0.0439969413,
0.0186965689,
0.0381075107,
-0.0305239279,
0.0180041697,
-0.0065182545,
-0.008579609,
-0.0215796269,
-0.0448905379,
-0.0531199314,
0.0128479917,
0.0336310342,
-0.0318643078,
0.0045575364,
0.0080162762,
0.0174649619,
0.0271996111,
-0.007167568,
0.0052565294,
0.0441133603,
-0.0092124771,
0.0368510075,
0.0000021752,
-0.0474034883,
-0.0114886258,
0.0547100827,
-0.0271206461,
0.0099322554,
0.0120095899,
0.0221616197,
0.0219586976,
-0.0128369713,
0.0290120654,
-0.0451433957,
0.0454573072,
-0.0005695609,
-0.0087215472,
0.0094528347,
-0.0109810708,
0.0127766309,
0.041519925,
-0.0250134002,
0.0188272074,
0.0061096209,
-0.0106395204,
0.0136171076,
-0.0388638712,
-0.0270375125,
-0.0023857474,
0.0313409641,
0.0426463149,
0.0460850634,
0.0196758229,
0.0386113785,
-0.0572457872,
0.0112229036,
-0.0176708456,
0.0209359545,
0.0170749016,
0.019519316,
-0.0418825969,
-0.003945068,
-0.0059333947,
0.0600627027,
-0.0447828583,
0.0226140674,
0.0306071769,
-0.0070177917,
-0.0656264946,
0.006373887,
0.0719521865,
-0.033578407,
0.0088315671,
0.066378206,
0.0209511369,
-0.0465099737,
0.0194015075,
0.0494396202,
-0.012360326,
0.0183403753,
-0.0538324527,
-0.0271478072,
-0.0123098418,
-0.0147697786,
0.0080559934,
-0.0202674568,
0.0368532762,
-0.0296850987,
0.0716134235,
-0.0179525167,
-0.0394572951,
0.0047829021,
-0.0395666845,
0.0517658442,
0.0307514798,
0.036297556,
0.0099162906,
-0.0074816919,
-0.0638315976,
0.0298207756,
0.0858757645,
0.0388421267,
0.0270481892,
0.0054003,
-0.0879949331,
0.0314557888,
-0.0180401094,
0.0419489592,
-0.0510779284,
0.0028558727,
-0.0063593718,
0.0646544844,
-0.0201489106,
-0.0584293418,
0.003407527,
0.0229896568,
0.0048528574,
-0.0428183377,
0.0002293739,
0.00838832,
-0.0088104494,
0.0036251843,
0.0429727621,
0.0683230683,
0.0300142597,
-0.0042551798,
-0.0356929637,
-0.0067877909,
-0.0288451612,
-0.0799120665,
0.0046643871,
-0.0397988074,
-0.009806674,
0.0328125432,
0.0185182728,
0.0104196388,
-0.0171244368,
-0.0410314463,
-0.0020956863,
0.0641777366,
0.0016047283,
0.0253451243,
0.0172784161,
0.004786477,
-0.0476902314,
0.0401739329,
0.0538241118,
0.0111647686,
0.0498249345,
-0.0302069671,
-0.0011864397,
-0.0082088038,
-0.0053054532,
-0.036445573,
-0.0277285762,
-0.0088794921,
0.0130710388,
-0.0451045893,
-0.0299652256,
0.0361774825,
-0.0447694585,
0.0207996871,
0.0465735383,
0.0348448865,
0.0094446009,
0.0031854897,
0.0203774627,
-0.0660694018,
0.0336749852,
0.0178929958,
-0.068511188,
-0.0036756513,
-0.0433409996,
0.0140152685,
0.0379099511,
-0.0091872411,
-0.0283407904,
-0.0685445592,
-0.0408923477,
-0.0455515794,
-0.018941693,
-0.011793267,
0.0949635357,
-0.0741587058,
0.0053917696,
-0.0179741029,
0.0174764991,
0.0130753079,
-0.0406153426,
-0.0890061259,
0.0396920852,
0.0105153723,
0.0206097923,
-0.0030978459,
0.022682149,
-0.010859645,
-0.0371257849,
-0.0622628257,
-0.0084780445,
-0.0002681788,
0.0711401999,
0.032417018,
-0.0602235943,
-0.0325977989,
0.022844255,
0.024324147,
0.0214063823,
0.0122373812,
0.0093298368,
-0.0629939064,
-0.0792960599,
0.0248828828,
-0.0044473549,
0.0080275983,
0.0419766419,
-0.0231027231,
0.0635085329,
-0.0339301825,
-0.0478241332,
-0.0152455689,
0.0243761037,
0.0166138615,
0.0024417341,
0.006590629,
0.0457228869,
0.0210533794,
0.0035373932,
-0.0603016354,
-0.0425577722,
0.0465761609,
-0.0369917564,
-0.0235050246,
0.0017956059,
-0.0177264903,
-0.0003528949,
-0.0383760668,
0.0172808152,
-0.0575428009,
0.0105399024,
-0.0311930161,
0.0250033345,
-0.0034271332,
0.008435186,
0.0048199752,
-0.0261191931,
0.0786884278,
0.0068130572,
-0.0243769996,
-0.0130501464,
-0.0374707021,
0.0056831073,
0.0084238639,
-0.0061466526,
-0.0432774872,
0.0122283697,
-0.073123768,
-0.0145443697,
-0.0297757015,
0.0200189315,
-0.0082356203,
-0.0257185679,
-0.0128015066,
0.0018775006,
0.0488429815,
-0.0147628365,
0.0345666073,
0.0290320609,
0.0498739555,
-0.0205066521,
0.0043434543,
-0.0760493949,
-0.0292944908,
-0.0090020364,
0.0806246251,
0.047515627,
0.0338886678,
-0.0238370933,
0.0187757686,
-0.0203775838,
-0.0337488279,
0.0097775264,
-0.0040579042,
0.0540951714,
0.0597892031,
0.0339821763,
0.0737248287,
-0.0278302394,
-0.0142716924,
0.0519324318,
0.0264071561,
-0.0363119245,
-0.004152,
-0.0215455536,
-0.0257255677,
0.0053471569,
-0.0643895566,
0.0171501003,
-0.006299281,
-0.0038309344,
0.010292232,
-0.0071506049,
0.0578588545,
0.0182552096,
-0.0521469675,
-0.0590277724,
0.0139112892,
0.0050326707,
0.0821200237,
-0.0411109291,
-0.1184350029,
0.0634020939,
-0.0136318617,
0.0106015289,
-0.0015489422,
-0.0045028743,
0.0260052532,
0.0213238522,
0.0021139167,
0.0182157271,
-0.0353741348,
0.0308387633,
0.0106325913,
-0.0164822191,
0.0429018922,
-0.0443720631,
-0.0127449948,
-0.0342787653,
-0.014551972,
0.0268445052,
0.0050634528,
-0.0805023536,
0.0265266467,
0.0178184174,
0.0058305436,
0.0183765534,
-0.0212226529,
0.0012185787,
0.0158030242,
0.0345196202,
-0.0202300306,
-0.027919719,
-0.0305394661,
0.0315862074,
0.0073424168,
0.0060556708,
-0.0275142714,
0.0387951508,
-0.0321294963,
0.0242696591,
-0.0182467233,
0.0126274843,
0.0266358219,
-0.0590112284,
0.0225488804,
-0.0340521261,
0.01759848,
-0.0213384721,
0.0174655672,
0.0371731408,
-0.0213782452,
-0.010867483,
0.0813528299,
0.0029189312,
0.0147688603,
-0.0077878456,
-0.0390420966,
0.0252680462,
-0.0199855883,
0.0175663438,
0.0070078708,
0.0167701729,
-0.0013870861,
0.0649761111,
-0.014494922,
0.0315836444,
0.0479635596,
-0.0688086078,
0.0772527307,
-0.0321175195,
-0.0810997561,
-0.0670289621,
-0.1202454045,
0.0089785084,
-0.0502494946,
0.051618468,
-0.034070462,
0.0072825537,
0.0038001214,
0.0270138793,
-0.0540909953,
-0.1136311516,
0.0144912209,
-0.0655161366,
0.0577518232,
0.0944877416,
-0.0273581576,
-0.0267073475,
-0.0507717282,
-0.0075589395,
0.0446820669,
0.015042847,
0.0067666508,
0.0922206715,
0.0046280697,
-0.0092893513,
-0.0476325192,
0.0051866448,
0.0111123081,
0.014216464,
-0.0028607498,
0.0627369583,
-0.0185587481,
-0.0505868718,
-0.040642228,
-0.0500315353,
0.0079448381,
0.0503638461,
0.0173094161,
-0.0259674024,
-0.0470434539,
-0.0238334611,
0.0081760781,
-0.0175733957,
-0.0125211952,
0.0221004188,
-0.0251614023,
-0.0564750582,
-0.0191942919,
-0.0625661463,
-0.0049281749,
-0.0140617611,
-0.0165190287,
0.0134113543,
-0.0236626193,
0.0009482747,
-0.0636620224,
0.0347692929,
0.0553765297,
-0.0109780533,
-0.0225617364,
-0.0116453385,
0.0257413145,
-0.0344198346,
-0.0337463096,
-0.0118162213,
-0.0675157681,
-0.0343413353,
-0.0018953921,
0.1274902672,
0.0173136201,
0.0481129475,
-0.0093336944,
-0.0134271439,
0.0507563986,
0.0052906894,
0.0029026603,
-0.0064922892,
0.0577822812,
-0.0436076559,
-0.0189204346,
-0.0391503647,
-0.0225330275,
0.0557051301,
0.0520925485,
-0.0489879698,
0.0087811379,
-0.0484795943,
0.0016088523,
0.0284178182,
0.0987949669,
0.0008038593,
-0.0528614037,
0.0162831116,
-0.0214571785,
0.0316135585,
0.0190981552,
-0.0208751839,
-0.0218273085,
0.0226974413,
0.0254363492,
-0.0453698002,
0.0087768584,
-0.0349529684,
0.0245151669,
-0.0165016335,
0.0290443078,
-0.027285615,
0.0507545546,
-0.0158509035,
0.0361077003,
-0.0272487383,
-0.0054671867,
0.0324951261,
0.0158619396,
0.0409661345,
-0.0196420103,
-0.0218291637,
0.0342502147,
0.0032789989,
0.023037577,
-0.0758358911,
-0.0122331623,
-0.0180992968,
-0.031100288,
0.0214550868,
0.0009915014,
0.0401188545,
-0.0346442163,
0.0252903104,
-0.0779346228,
-0.0058637899,
0.0264820904,
0.0918009207,
-0.0131864958,
-0.009275103,
-0.0311333425,
0.018640833,
0.0567305833,
-0.0009965283,
0.0349868797,
-0.0932515189,
-0.0227202754,
-0.0203687288,
-0.0257922821,
0.0098972032,
0.013060255,
-0.0442311242,
-0.0300994832,
0.0026239252,
-0.0591242164,
0.0309842844,
0.0276903287,
0.1050916389,
-0.0113640977,
-0.062704429,
0.0781506225,
-0.0107759824,
0.0233063623,
0.0084205335,
-0.0423961021,
0.0366340466,
0.0067188311,
-0.0174658634,
-6.693665971e-33,
0.0233183764,
-0.0173705351,
-0.02021957,
-0.0266672317,
0.0125961499,
0.0335220173,
-0.0492741242,
0.0225058235,
-0.002982598,
0.0041200346,
-0.0116741136,
0.0124703189,
0.0253995713,
0.0091972379,
0.0827503428,
-0.0226888452,
0.0249704272,
0.0005409085,
-0.0136599587,
-0.0206568129,
-0.0218863338,
0.0342972428,
0.0364026837,
-0.0631565005,
0.0288426131,
0.0234245267,
-0.0306842383,
-0.0573889837,
-0.0498067699,
0.0411939807,
-0.0149582056,
0.0420455262,
0.012060375,
-0.0186177865,
-0.0126251094,
-0.0436306484,
-0.0134029444,
0.0014710262,
-0.0237336196,
-0.0045453417,
-0.0527031869,
0.0218312945,
0.0609656163,
0.0080976533,
-0.0969046131,
-0.0106648663,
0.0467604101,
-0.0291757695,
-0.0061152405,
-0.0192143191,
-0.0114394985,
0.0168470442,
-0.0135118766,
-0.0100633223,
0.0012710897,
0.0499981828,
-0.0197334234,
0.041532848,
-0.0382526852,
0.017535584,
0.0047151046,
-0.0502686985,
0.0698397383,
0.0491947606,
0.022978561,
0.0659402385,
0.0817582756,
0.0090024527,
-0.0216510408,
-0.022452075,
0.0485273004,
0.0624536723,
0.0443664417,
0.0601770803,
0.0644565448,
0.0075976364,
-0.1049622819,
0.0720351413,
-0.0298915133,
-0.002036402,
0.0017617032,
-0.0065529328,
-0.0250272825,
-0.0108513506,
-0.023392424,
-0.0281926822,
-0.0089995041,
-0.0397097543,
0.0283993557,
-0.0158891995,
-0.0587510131,
-0.0397930406,
0.0485305935,
-0.0315746218,
0.0080098705,
-0.0158561114,
0.0094394656,
0.0249482151,
0.0343375802,
0.0049993019,
-0.0161992386,
-0.0050764447,
0.0263490658,
0.0526868887,
0.0602623336,
-0.0203718804,
0.0270229056,
0.0362341963,
-0.0215905327,
0.0077578411,
-0.0024583356,
-0.002280894,
-0.0106747923,
-0.017545335,
0.0262824874,
-0.007104089,
-0.0048199859,
0.0265161525,
-0.0244944803,
0.0407014564,
-0.0335948132,
-0.0010863214,
-0.0162784383,
-0.0237131249,
0.0095982309,
-0.0083422484,
-0.0258953515,
-0.0225134995,
-0.0117017208,
0.0021576926,
0.0059585455,
-0.0232820287,
2.905e-7,
0.0452527553,
0.0296578538,
-0.0155264791,
0.01584333,
0.0263402425,
-0.0086204363,
-0.0689553469,
-0.0279277917,
0.024780076,
0.0069122897,
0.0471597239,
0.0055072149,
0.059300486,
0.0130724413,
0.0534607731,
-0.0554701611,
-0.0358273499,
0.0219610371,
-0.0212568007,
0.0324680321,
0.0335491598,
0.043734137,
0.0202530473,
-0.0289498214,
0.0212905072,
0.0320560671,
0.0292724613,
-0.0700199828,
0.0204396751,
0.0071921893,
0.018582955,
0.0261266083,
0.0472228937,
0.0244344361,
-0.0208677091,
-0.0291286893,
0.0024158815,
0.0148292994,
-0.0271189399,
0.0127675338,
0.0137136364,
0.0288259145,
0.0550959185,
-0.0236019138,
0.0569173731,
-0.0205445066,
-0.0202348735,
-0.014407252,
-0.0150320241,
0.0006088651,
0.1368981898,
-0.0241168942,
0.0014441502,
-0.0069324821,
-0.0122769708,
0.0113381706,
-0.0348930359,
-0.0200000294,
0.0013084819,
-0.0080315676,
-0.0341596343,
-0.0661550686,
0.0175140575,
-0.0419557653,
0.0373326465,
-0.0237928052,
-0.0164745394,
2.611353583e-34,
0.026561629,
0.0131513551,
0.0155908111,
0.0224213395,
0.0045070103,
-0.0039288015,
-0.0103251627,
-0.0554184914,
-0.0082507702,
-0.0035375725,
0.0090668686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04045v1 | Revisiting Offline Compression: Going Beyond Factorization-based Methods for Transformer Language Models | 2023-02-08T13:36:06 | 2023-02-08T13:36:06 | Mohammadreza Banaei, Klaudia Bałazy, Artur Kasymov, Rémi Lebret, Jacek Tabor, Karl Aberer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent transformer language models achieve outstanding results in many
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, their enormous size often
makes them impractical on memory-constrained devices, requiring practitioners
to compress them to smaller networks. In this paper, we explore offline
compression methods, meaning computationally-cheap approaches that do not
require further fine-tuning of the compressed model. We challenge the classical
matrix factorization methods by proposing a novel, better-performing
autoencoder-based framework. We perform a comprehensive ablation study of our
approach, examining its different aspects over a diverse set of evaluation
settings. Moreover, we show that enabling collaboration between modules across
layers by compressing certain modules together positively impacts the final
model performance. Experiments on various NLP tasks demonstrate that our
approach significantly outperforms commonly used factorization-based offline
compression methods. | [
-0.0084833819,
0.1008964032,
-0.0172473155,
0.0283515602,
-0.0269993003,
0.0151361628,
0.0505537726,
0.0212561861,
-0.0563194975,
-0.011007986,
-0.0000673167,
-0.0137533071,
0.0366583019,
0.0637335479,
-0.0068596662,
0.0009597296,
0.0088160234,
-0.0034296303,
-0.0636431798,
0.0033980906,
0.0058946302,
0.0321040675,
0.0227279104,
0.0773920566,
-0.0240014568,
0.0203441158,
-0.0262701567,
-0.0192286801,
-0.0288242456,
0.0272590127,
-0.0396244563,
0.0457971469,
0.0305865016,
0.0203560889,
0.0000020148,
0.0087464713,
-0.0327009596,
-0.0191258397,
-0.0360528566,
0.022170011,
0.062071342,
-0.0434034616,
-0.0021432452,
0.0157692973,
-0.0438799746,
-0.0893580914,
0.055243928,
0.0163555127,
0.0427598432,
0.0236850344,
-0.0097926576,
-0.0002739231,
0.0555150658,
-0.0314688124,
-0.0369407237,
-0.0315374061,
0.0022220362,
-0.0235214308,
-0.0397136398,
-0.0000182907,
-0.0544278994,
0.0255279988,
0.0405181944,
0.0192001574,
0.0322567746,
0.0068427436,
-0.0376513265,
-0.0481613539,
-0.0020090565,
0.0709384158,
-0.0500880964,
-0.0299620666,
-0.0035158838,
-0.0070594694,
-0.0410109237,
0.0067314832,
-0.031967409,
0.0496292226,
0.034921024,
0.0253315214,
-0.0235364661,
0.0497126244,
0.0267811399,
-0.0052211704,
-0.0259218272,
0.0517495759,
0.019796215,
-0.003872934,
-0.0374605469,
0.0055033653,
-0.0069235121,
-0.0159548484,
0.0254770331,
0.0002748221,
0.0145598594,
-0.02285395,
-0.0469836891,
-0.0347293913,
-0.0240957644,
-0.0019138284,
0.0221647341,
0.0300614964,
0.0382639952,
0.0028642991,
-0.0380225293,
0.0349962898,
0.0061802901,
-0.0166214257,
-0.0235352777,
-0.0401381738,
-0.0329112336,
0.0092979223,
-0.0497773066,
0.0376165845,
-0.0447664633,
-0.0662951395,
-0.0076801577,
-0.0021471707,
0.0110907946,
-0.0087501183,
0.0312519521,
0.042999316,
-0.0405773148,
-0.0094438028,
0.0386071093,
0.0526530705,
-0.0054969098,
0.0037810942,
-0.0032075476,
-0.0542771555,
-0.0107565792,
0.0192754734,
0.0628209636,
0.0034868747,
0.0090532703,
0.010537249,
0.0144375814,
-0.0449154973,
0.0141432453,
0.020151414,
0.0064996225,
-0.0023628424,
-0.0209293347,
-0.0649495646,
0.0547153726,
-0.0221184287,
0.0375457034,
-0.0450373068,
0.0199209247,
0.0138348471,
-0.0343400463,
0.0571849085,
0.0284362119,
0.0147376694,
0.018087836,
0.0044971542,
0.0467501357,
0.028302541,
0.0511211269,
0.0273737144,
0.0226335283,
-0.0492522158,
0.00780696,
0.0515461266,
0.0248997677,
-0.0024547498,
-0.0299572572,
-0.049152974,
-0.0417985916,
-0.0062483847,
0.0406717286,
0.0687295198,
-0.0444069132,
0.0158860981,
0.0311346464,
0.0310467277,
0.0340823717,
0.0986246318,
0.0203563981,
0.0416888818,
-0.039099846,
-0.0192353688,
0.0191844311,
0.0419719368,
-0.0016247889,
0.0059079076,
0.0612006076,
0.0661068261,
-0.0293362308,
-0.0292345881,
-0.0039014376,
-0.0579490028,
0.0605452806,
-0.016829662,
0.0259650256,
0.0423785895,
-0.0403479822,
0.078932561,
0.014704884,
-0.079699941,
0.0240929518,
-0.0347555391,
-0.0286739729,
0.0183364898,
0.1036183834,
0.0612241998,
0.0256428774,
-0.0560645722,
-0.0295819342,
0.036615748,
-0.0176393893,
-0.0215592682,
0.0242766272,
-0.1033767238,
-0.0366216786,
0.0146698877,
0.0135615012,
-0.0040513449,
0.0145247439,
0.013155519,
0.0340732858,
-0.0067025241,
0.0036188525,
0.01689611,
-0.0265567359,
-0.0131212324,
0.04652353,
0.0088998787,
-0.0009943662,
-0.0192348044,
-0.0268432219,
0.0034355409,
0.0396597274,
-0.0835423768,
-0.0411320031,
-0.0358219221,
-0.0477480516,
-0.0410606004,
-0.0013693855,
-0.0530783869,
0.0472947732,
0.0874628127,
-0.0211415011,
-0.033450406,
0.0270550847,
-0.0521499701,
0.0185603388,
-0.01385919,
0.007819864,
-0.0195280891,
0.0492603257,
0.0106794164,
0.020356765,
-0.0337492675,
0.0254908856,
0.0183067434,
-0.0321337171,
0.010207043,
0.0008695889,
-0.0354293808,
0.0142540894,
-0.0139587484,
0.0089206481,
0.0352499671,
-0.0044862512,
0.0327084698,
-0.0256632399,
-0.0405560136,
0.0066159246,
-0.0260928497,
-0.0081972498,
0.0339180008,
0.0672979578,
0.0317767598,
0.0134956306,
-0.0048564579,
0.0057925843,
0.001171952,
0.0248375423,
-0.007286218,
-0.0395349972,
0.0139640588,
-0.0075794104,
-0.071802184,
0.0249478649,
0.091000177,
-0.0660706311,
-0.0143861333,
-0.029632207,
-0.0055521242,
-0.0260336325,
0.0118928533,
0.0192741174,
-0.0512356386,
-0.0081278132,
-0.0154656433,
0.0418571159,
0.0457725935,
0.0074079866,
0.0221546553,
0.0874868631,
-0.0032144282,
-0.0478822999,
-0.0072917584,
-0.0465219319,
0.0097640818,
-0.0021149032,
-0.0381784514,
-0.0318520479,
0.0850307867,
0.0066656517,
0.0178618059,
-0.0582287163,
-0.0246363692,
-0.0190530811,
-0.0144666769,
0.0061852704,
-0.0495832637,
-0.0111387474,
0.0262713637,
-0.0209496655,
-0.0169652216,
0.0781434104,
-0.0410805307,
-0.0364126563,
-0.0266325567,
-0.006809094,
-0.0502447933,
0.0459453799,
0.0117664561,
0.0184033513,
-0.019608086,
-0.0059402948,
-0.0103174951,
0.0365018882,
0.0192681309,
-0.0378219411,
0.023175884,
0.0031960483,
-0.0102648996,
-0.0119493082,
-0.0303052422,
-0.0041132323,
-0.0142872967,
-0.0075670783,
0.0259936042,
0.0605498739,
0.0064050164,
-0.0622849092,
0.0552653521,
-0.0117084067,
0.0565839112,
0.0265890639,
0.0111474991,
-0.0275788326,
0.0771103278,
0.0561188012,
0.0207996387,
0.0483798347,
0.0139036262,
0.023869155,
0.0379135683,
0.0153921396,
-0.0037473529,
-0.0318647325,
-0.0024783693,
0.0438522063,
0.0161765255,
-0.0049416712,
0.0222384185,
0.0017395661,
-0.0448631197,
-0.033104375,
0.1004646048,
0.0304994062,
-0.055007115,
0.0162210558,
0.0093490398,
0.0439051837,
-0.012844923,
0.0044070883,
-0.0421205461,
-0.0269088205,
0.0185185615,
-0.0035429266,
0.0288704094,
-0.0166466422,
0.0043860269,
-0.1026208624,
0.0113335103,
0.0317052118,
0.0540039204,
-0.0287517719,
-0.0617434606,
-0.0163074266,
-0.052963838,
0.0064299088,
-0.0156392585,
0.0204066224,
-0.0114485268,
-0.0011513453,
-0.0426323935,
-0.0559987538,
-0.010968199,
0.0007343075,
0.0674902797,
0.0370590724,
0.0018735572,
0.0317308381,
-0.0587021708,
0.0019623751,
-0.0471034795,
0.0120716784,
-0.0388811231,
0.0126883937,
0.0035906781,
0.0025713423,
0.0113321152,
0.0077221445,
-0.0593062118,
-0.0161717236,
-0.045538336,
0.0697649345,
0.0016506454,
-0.0425773971,
-0.015884554,
-0.0289823208,
-0.0150772016,
0.0486148857,
0.0415017419,
-0.0120995343,
-0.0310101435,
0.0042038634,
0.0033912568,
-0.0123919202,
-0.0871899724,
-0.019505376,
0.0489963219,
-0.0149938008,
-0.0335941799,
-0.0118574649,
0.0041266438,
0.0028566518,
-0.0216298643,
-0.0435303375,
0.0251116082,
0.0118760886,
-0.0575607494,
-0.0021558341,
-0.0114074117,
-0.0122845024,
-0.009585754,
0.0316614211,
0.0282268599,
0.0091652218,
0.0097199567,
0.0230548363,
-0.1019068137,
0.0000960693,
-0.0055463025,
0.022026008,
0.0259516258,
0.0343385972,
-0.0013044333,
-0.0614971109,
0.0285903569,
0.0234683268,
-0.0842951685,
0.0358818211,
0.0185444821,
-0.0383355655,
0.0033950377,
0.0487759598,
-0.0135036334,
0.0317223221,
-0.0419318713,
0.0632626265,
-0.0209783446,
-0.0584268942,
0.0075545362,
-0.0455636904,
0.0410315841,
-0.005053659,
-0.0044772225,
-0.0171156321,
0.0294434913,
0.009601132,
0.011683614,
-0.0658592507,
0.016250629,
0.0496216081,
0.0195234921,
0.0067142597,
0.0478390157,
0.0332496278,
0.0045653475,
0.0077497456,
0.0034038015,
0.0032585422,
-0.0327354781,
0.0093374532,
0.0232251249,
-0.0347480997,
-0.0033104348,
0.0262530521,
0.0139258932,
-0.0599909611,
-0.0017201628,
-0.0213559289,
0.0236267745,
-0.0382151678,
0.0447823629,
-0.0452370532,
-0.0125468923,
-0.0503406115,
0.0011492767,
-0.0118513973,
-0.0088746296,
0.0745059252,
0.0074620727,
-0.0068025747,
-0.0279317293,
0.0042695235,
-0.0126314862,
-0.0367853604,
-0.0066775829,
0.0004937131,
-0.0212441832,
0.0171520896,
0.0911980644,
0.0141049484,
0.0052029719,
-0.0190102085,
0.020576356,
-0.0419220254,
-0.0127056362,
-0.0266298465,
0.0455999784,
-0.0298613515,
-0.0030040699,
-0.0256956946,
-0.0428073183,
-0.0021086538,
-0.028683845,
-0.0019766418,
-0.0256002136,
0.0279233772,
0.0172756687,
0.006300014,
0.0248079896,
-0.0085506821,
0.0115419896,
0.0010084149,
-0.0340132043,
-0.0297369212,
-6.311087376e-33,
0.0053791488,
-0.0101232575,
-0.0245952066,
-0.0124300411,
-0.0082467515,
0.0605185889,
-0.0323971249,
0.0007187333,
0.0002667778,
-0.0335404761,
-0.0191234648,
0.0136840772,
0.0018384511,
0.0557694957,
0.0021847992,
-0.0052243308,
0.090921849,
-0.0227808934,
-0.0333415344,
0.0459063686,
-0.0010541305,
0.0280350391,
0.0030741382,
-0.0118300635,
-0.0447704494,
-0.0037342568,
-0.0016042159,
-0.0372842997,
0.0446121916,
0.062254671,
-0.0543976463,
0.0413940512,
0.0090887919,
-0.0645181611,
-0.0349739119,
0.0169032924,
-0.0837903917,
-0.0100178374,
-0.0352630913,
-0.0115399063,
-0.0552886054,
-0.0301084965,
0.0647264048,
0.0114188837,
-0.0078076897,
-0.0290060509,
0.012942099,
-0.0130867539,
-0.0724793896,
-0.069911845,
-0.0337403417,
0.0055640414,
-0.020758979,
-0.0348131582,
0.0769716799,
0.0314694867,
-0.0311340485,
0.0298361853,
-0.0918962732,
0.0367358364,
-0.0253104344,
0.0696178004,
0.0803896934,
-0.0480574109,
0.0067065977,
0.0453062318,
-0.024388494,
-0.0204674341,
-0.0453771688,
0.0178939514,
0.049436029,
0.0420484804,
0.054476276,
0.0568158776,
0.0436557643,
-0.0142061096,
-0.0356320068,
0.0177841913,
0.0285748225,
0.0434561409,
0.0140318172,
0.0391472392,
-0.0055293101,
-0.0300489943,
-0.0363537259,
-0.0272793733,
-0.0324868113,
-0.0357090905,
-0.0053346064,
0.0563461073,
-0.0708348155,
-0.02128895,
0.0460482575,
-0.074860394,
0.0087710982,
0.0435786843,
0.00622408,
0.0265664551,
0.02926323,
0.0085906228,
-0.0506372564,
0.0094784666,
0.0339051746,
-0.0343554057,
-0.0024135998,
-0.0202581584,
0.0003420859,
0.0717914104,
-0.0762298331,
-0.0271444079,
-0.0158584472,
-0.0189984031,
0.0072886287,
0.0316829011,
0.0411903746,
0.0248443782,
-0.0184440836,
0.0208120383,
-0.0218407959,
0.0357921049,
-0.000436915,
-0.0086689284,
0.0571831428,
0.0345710292,
-0.0456164554,
-0.0131965335,
-0.0953546315,
-0.0091310013,
0.0758389458,
-0.0486514643,
-0.0304305386,
0.0177914537,
2.573e-7,
0.019505918,
0.0453928076,
0.0360018201,
-0.0590153523,
0.0466741361,
0.0195155032,
0.0361326151,
0.0224736203,
-0.0027029912,
-0.0104106674,
0.0150718233,
0.0378888175,
0.0511177555,
0.0085015846,
-0.0377723947,
0.0266531054,
-0.0654572472,
0.00549589,
-0.0520189255,
-0.053832911,
-0.0013824175,
0.1407858729,
-0.000578443,
-0.0160546191,
-0.0086557548,
0.0095119933,
0.0487574078,
0.0022468027,
-0.012656807,
-0.0027545774,
0.0046108998,
0.0140814772,
-0.0318088084,
-0.0066879005,
-0.0014951079,
0.0111755077,
0.0143368114,
0.0706567541,
0.0177244563,
-0.0443008728,
0.0104984622,
-0.040893849,
-0.0435539708,
-0.0364796333,
0.0760686249,
-0.0406322554,
-0.0142737664,
-0.0294820536,
-0.0087664593,
0.0339885317,
0.0289453175,
-0.0055567883,
-0.0020008453,
0.0152180446,
0.0323013738,
0.0216427073,
-0.0277246721,
-0.0597384311,
0.0042536212,
-0.0247284025,
-0.0252090562,
-0.0263253152,
-0.0531480685,
-0.0388618708,
0.0654658452,
-0.0057306876,
-0.0012912119,
2.420541003e-34,
0.0119872419,
0.0249401499,
0.017297063,
0.0191716608,
-0.003845735,
-0.0618209168,
-0.002959033,
-0.0081646666,
-0.027775947,
-0.1122727469,
-0.0357593969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06466v1 | ChatGPT versus Traditional Question Answering for Knowledge Graphs: Current Status and Future Directions Towards Knowledge Graph Chatbots | 2023-02-08T13:03:27 | 2023-02-08T13:03:27 | Reham Omar, Omij Mangukiya, Panos Kalnis, Essam Mansour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Conversational AI and Question-Answering systems (QASs) for knowledge graphs
(KGs) are both emerging research areas: they empower users with natural
language interfaces for extracting information easily and effectively.
Conversational AI simulates conversations with humans; however, it is limited
by the data captured in the training datasets. In contrast, QASs retrieve the
most recent information from a KG by understanding and translating the natural
language question into a formal query supported by the database engine.
In this paper, we present a comprehensive study of the characteristics of the
existing alternatives towards combining both worlds into novel KG chatbots. Our
framework compares two representative conversational models, ChatGPT and
Galactica, against KGQAN, the current state-of-the-art QAS. We conduct a
thorough evaluation using four real KGs across various application domains to
identify the current limitations of each category of systems. Based on our
findings, we propose open research opportunities to empower QASs with chatbot
capabilities for KGs. All benchmarks and all raw results are available1 for
further analysis. | [
0.075305298,
-0.0023707503,
-0.0193544477,
0.0291042496,
-0.0395764597,
0.0025125272,
-0.0404070541,
0.0209437609,
0.0902482569,
-0.0045244913,
-0.0092498232,
0.0202162918,
-0.0300389621,
0.0555570498,
-0.0164385457,
-0.0268851221,
0.0240165237,
-0.0176130272,
0.0398589037,
-0.0149404267,
0.0182911269,
0.0226141606,
-0.0413321927,
0.0273690466,
-0.029551072,
-0.0279756915,
-0.0250389595,
-0.0367873199,
-0.00035642,
-0.004807692,
0.0148527874,
0.0083464766,
-0.0081192479,
0.0101606632,
0.0000019648,
-0.012428958,
0.002008291,
0.0202287063,
-0.0672106743,
-0.0467928536,
-0.0144323129,
0.0264043007,
0.0265890248,
0.0412873589,
-0.0834006816,
-0.0012284992,
0.0202993862,
0.0232101474,
0.049190823,
0.0351058505,
-0.0145309437,
-0.0099331355,
-0.0033978552,
0.0081298286,
0.0028504101,
-0.098151885,
0.0293465499,
0.0735800937,
0.0525539182,
-0.0042199199,
-0.0079781823,
0.0298435558,
0.0112549039,
-0.0151849622,
0.0179199129,
0.0291536544,
-0.0544331819,
0.0099927131,
-0.0233730208,
0.1128442064,
0.0327635184,
-0.0096781738,
0.0159171633,
0.0367415473,
0.0119251031,
0.0121979266,
-0.0425798744,
-0.0146494852,
-0.0215904694,
-0.0361712314,
-0.0524468273,
-0.0268088281,
-0.0120168682,
-0.0180963092,
-0.0156961698,
0.0351026356,
0.0082430895,
-0.0341373868,
0.018285064,
-0.0081470925,
-0.0061345375,
-0.0699630156,
0.0027102956,
0.0920241773,
-0.0313018709,
0.040692687,
-0.0024670206,
0.0235271286,
0.0015603363,
-0.0449122228,
-0.0557041503,
0.0415614098,
0.0286960807,
0.0787691996,
0.0122916447,
0.0725324079,
0.0396495983,
0.0256245304,
-0.0387338623,
-0.0722821876,
-0.0620581545,
-0.0382913537,
-0.0700085685,
0.0308190491,
-0.0296432227,
-0.0245052446,
-0.0137017928,
0.0580760315,
0.0369129851,
0.0060434272,
0.0320724137,
0.0700241029,
-0.0106344065,
0.0078650117,
-0.0752655268,
0.0049758661,
-0.0883268341,
0.004034346,
0.0086966297,
-0.0791220814,
-0.0194560587,
0.0079845414,
0.0285451468,
-0.0051347446,
0.0005651168,
0.0819029957,
0.0055260607,
-0.0382895693,
0.0230122823,
-0.0213269908,
0.0164822415,
-0.0335059799,
0.0063575921,
-0.0209865645,
0.086897172,
0.0142686274,
-0.0390892476,
0.0025485202,
0.0198292416,
0.0166175384,
-0.0345651656,
0.0412099957,
-0.050472375,
0.0308909826,
0.0275691394,
0.0153216636,
-0.0785781667,
0.0393239148,
0.0334576406,
-0.0072950381,
0.0490421616,
0.0256268885,
0.0203964971,
0.0013570449,
0.0341428295,
-0.0184196476,
0.0379827581,
0.0772413462,
-0.0253421739,
0.0371663086,
-0.0222636648,
0.0328474976,
-0.0295122825,
-0.0204768982,
0.0160507634,
0.0825603902,
-0.0209106077,
0.0276491158,
0.0002272648,
0.0267054196,
0.0609747693,
-0.0295531601,
-0.0122908503,
0.0418174118,
-0.0293894913,
-0.017820403,
-0.003976773,
-0.0366863869,
-0.0263906643,
-0.0219315328,
0.0238111392,
-0.003936185,
0.0422692001,
0.0287364032,
0.0198808108,
0.0169479344,
-0.029154921,
-0.0169537216,
0.0025501002,
-0.016557334,
-0.0611468218,
-0.059060093,
0.0416024961,
0.0774546936,
0.0764496624,
-0.0077071115,
-0.0617183223,
0.0356151871,
-0.025842594,
0.020255072,
0.0329632275,
-0.0261154231,
0.011433878,
-0.0137718106,
-0.0282889437,
-0.0257922541,
-0.0183876753,
0.0255169161,
0.05812148,
0.0464817099,
-0.0260692388,
-0.0591044948,
0.0173479822,
0.0005147094,
0.0035191928,
0.0079925172,
-0.0151596535,
-0.0150124859,
-0.0038540382,
0.0256826971,
0.0062353457,
0.0082841748,
0.036403805,
0.0086318757,
-0.0625695363,
0.0210270677,
0.008943445,
-0.0669904575,
0.039897874,
-0.0143566104,
-0.0090652918,
0.0168046318,
-0.0224552378,
-0.0487937443,
0.0187317207,
-0.0349768661,
0.0600969307,
-0.0251217559,
-0.0361258872,
-0.0050225458,
-0.0142981578,
-0.0083792498,
0.0565840378,
0.0387985222,
-0.035689421,
-0.0033760783,
-0.0181457084,
-0.0076423879,
-0.0403507985,
0.0128419837,
0.0116122784,
0.0351255462,
0.0026405191,
0.0090722889,
-0.0073281494,
-0.0636879578,
0.023175953,
-0.1324973553,
0.0189805329,
0.0068804966,
0.0064598205,
0.0116639268,
0.0287680831,
0.0014299528,
-0.0430204906,
-0.0786338821,
0.0449871793,
0.0407049656,
0.0153435441,
0.0617073439,
0.0352774784,
0.0028323727,
-0.069831267,
0.0165863503,
0.0250618532,
0.0220842194,
0.0223793779,
-0.0005979693,
0.0099085281,
-0.0018233686,
-0.0843413845,
0.0438154638,
-0.0184771921,
-0.0270123128,
0.0242612101,
-0.035964299,
0.0096792299,
0.0443041772,
0.0270191468,
0.0260359142,
-0.0097672138,
0.0077374675,
-0.0697741508,
0.0356960706,
-0.0226636305,
0.0001131558,
-0.0195169169,
-0.0102387043,
0.0046683727,
-0.0051135551,
0.0132777737,
0.0217648204,
-0.0695997924,
0.0519838445,
0.0527924486,
-0.0043822271,
-0.0247307438,
0.0179766174,
0.0091158645,
0.0062028966,
-0.0295697637,
0.0171803925,
0.0594844893,
0.0254241806,
-0.0181069039,
-0.0095721213,
-0.0209985264,
-0.0403776504,
0.0451467596,
-0.0214961413,
0.0172511395,
-0.0312612541,
0.0062457421,
-0.0245044343,
-0.0184925441,
0.0032692039,
-0.0499955826,
-0.0215441789,
0.0165877696,
0.0244520418,
0.0264181942,
-0.0164722428,
-0.0378850214,
0.0048264521,
-0.0480051078,
-0.0024177325,
0.0387181006,
-0.0296024941,
0.006425669,
0.0120376805,
0.0027000264,
-0.0028332702,
-0.0185454302,
-0.0217761844,
-0.0117829498,
0.0289414804,
0.0583353639,
0.0368342884,
0.0016896507,
0.0347869992,
0.0541428402,
0.0715934783,
0.0305295978,
-0.0177999176,
-0.0143804485,
-0.046866551,
-0.016757451,
-0.0165747739,
-0.0052260929,
-0.0313725471,
0.0344813131,
-0.0234686807,
-0.0026381083,
0.1021777689,
0.0268317424,
0.0047964738,
-0.0037241061,
-0.0075952779,
0.0084445523,
0.0043437034,
0.0708233267,
-0.108241342,
-0.0393848307,
-0.0203219578,
0.0504443012,
-0.0061498927,
-0.0754365474,
-0.0115820039,
-0.0864099041,
0.0073053935,
-0.0487207174,
-0.0345636457,
-0.059499681,
-0.0400179438,
0.0149218757,
-0.0112099191,
-0.0374996662,
0.0095080193,
-0.0067968336,
0.014613633,
-0.0028324211,
-0.0208879169,
0.0207635928,
0.06928958,
-0.0150941359,
0.0308270548,
0.0347437374,
0.0661077946,
0.0429319963,
0.0144485869,
-0.0292675439,
0.0292340405,
0.0125365714,
0.0190421976,
0.0559735931,
-0.0181273967,
-0.008023506,
-0.0584208965,
-0.0219730064,
-0.0235294122,
0.0304476675,
0.0468195975,
0.0421844311,
-0.0333807729,
-0.0060975389,
-0.0229347162,
0.0054686349,
-0.0039415001,
0.0718149394,
0.0128315119,
0.0150552876,
-0.0930910483,
-0.0349110402,
0.0127148973,
-0.0311416388,
-0.0076932493,
-0.00789278,
0.0105166724,
0.0338590331,
-0.1061893255,
-0.0689108223,
0.0362384655,
-0.0017502588,
-0.0099990712,
0.0112851951,
0.0359688327,
0.0354962349,
0.0082125878,
-0.0143617755,
-0.0714631826,
-0.0239742976,
-0.0137291523,
-0.0312413927,
0.0075874119,
-0.0283457432,
-0.0228688587,
-0.0145045184,
-0.0406415202,
-0.0204319246,
-0.034310516,
0.0228191819,
0.0210229494,
0.0120252585,
-0.0392457061,
0.0152127864,
0.0247830264,
0.0291403029,
-0.0509699136,
-0.0045848023,
0.0300533362,
0.021788897,
-0.0014656866,
0.04030196,
-0.0973709524,
-0.0268521979,
-0.0525095612,
0.0362770036,
-0.0593719333,
-0.0215112735,
0.0179272182,
0.0450736359,
-0.0453396291,
0.0618809201,
-0.0207261499,
-0.0077943909,
0.0092477268,
-0.0532767065,
-0.0023473792,
-0.0481996275,
0.002252924,
-0.023800347,
-0.0076450715,
0.0216410048,
-0.0190455578,
-0.0321866721,
0.0278759953,
-0.0181194656,
-0.0424160324,
0.056391336,
-0.0104666697,
0.0112978788,
-0.0109158391,
-0.013769866,
0.0326353982,
0.0175915156,
0.0390839875,
-0.0168536436,
0.0426728427,
0.0183369461,
-0.0601957031,
0.0146037471,
0.0347527638,
-0.1278561801,
-0.1233711615,
0.0286271274,
0.0559298024,
0.0253356248,
0.0422375724,
-0.0038435664,
-0.0326479003,
0.0112270024,
-0.002399781,
-0.0099922894,
0.0100957211,
-0.0200265925,
0.0321612209,
0.0163111035,
-0.011678136,
0.0337820239,
0.0484942533,
-0.0193182789,
0.0275945663,
-0.0116298432,
-0.0480884388,
-0.0231132004,
-0.04309747,
0.0159441531,
0.0086599439,
0.0306461733,
-0.0024303545,
-0.0231652874,
-0.0322840586,
-0.0138647985,
-0.0130145941,
-0.0509795249,
-0.0185467526,
0.0612615496,
0.0499700978,
0.0316130407,
-0.0466373488,
-0.054058075,
0.0366875641,
-0.0672429278,
0.001181409,
0.0210453235,
-5.990394517e-33,
-0.0188956466,
-0.0366800316,
0.0290931072,
0.0213452075,
-0.0301459171,
-0.023253886,
-0.0570661053,
-0.0272153579,
-0.058061026,
0.0137609672,
-0.0452392921,
0.0418744981,
0.0008294983,
-0.0090699289,
-0.0223294348,
-0.0496909581,
-0.0095977392,
-0.032359194,
0.0080707688,
0.0531747267,
0.0362728536,
0.0302227717,
0.0017689321,
-0.0164764002,
0.0161078237,
-0.0308932364,
0.0306630787,
0.0156759731,
-0.0029319075,
0.0331565477,
-0.0221263673,
0.0526513048,
0.0259062871,
0.0109227216,
0.0300818812,
0.0099241203,
-0.0821255967,
-0.0449605472,
0.0088851377,
0.0068373792,
-0.0611801744,
0.0145624923,
0.0074701277,
-0.0153431548,
0.0430841707,
0.0072367182,
0.0250444356,
-0.0112098791,
-0.0053196903,
-0.0165981594,
-0.0148492362,
0.0002157639,
-0.0250494443,
-0.0434705503,
-0.044123888,
0.053109847,
0.0136778038,
-0.0099101774,
-0.0308826622,
0.0224939566,
0.0085996864,
-0.0249878932,
0.0141314063,
0.0071029244,
0.0223612748,
0.0088954736,
0.0329056196,
-0.0120267319,
-0.0160185676,
0.0126418052,
-0.0211299676,
0.0440109968,
0.0378360301,
0.0052817157,
-0.0178134944,
-0.0183726866,
-0.0541475527,
0.0258702356,
0.0427640565,
0.0208059624,
-0.0144881913,
-0.0005989992,
-0.0514284559,
-0.0008309308,
-0.0204439238,
0.0270652771,
-0.0322848819,
-0.0306433886,
0.02585922,
-0.0062943925,
-0.0081272339,
-0.0459770486,
-0.0089076664,
-0.0554928854,
0.0450233482,
0.0694656447,
-0.0166546423,
-0.0051275785,
0.0122762034,
0.0312319323,
-0.0367596634,
0.0373406783,
0.0543045402,
-0.0082416106,
0.0117617734,
0.0379105546,
-0.0553248599,
-0.0089741629,
-0.0144844037,
-0.0176111273,
-0.0291745123,
0.0485423766,
-0.0554853678,
-0.0385030583,
-0.0090530589,
0.0518210642,
0.008210442,
0.0434627905,
0.0063554016,
0.0699687675,
-0.0265648011,
0.0074014589,
0.0163735934,
-0.0477582142,
-0.0231127813,
-0.0048223129,
-0.033037331,
0.0256355274,
-0.0599580482,
-0.0584624037,
-0.0037972271,
0.0149408393,
2.59e-7,
0.011876571,
0.019165596,
0.0280184392,
0.062692374,
0.0152339498,
0.0171325151,
0.0464941226,
0.0434117876,
0.0141874971,
-0.0100619346,
0.0203651004,
0.0675591156,
-0.0013483667,
0.0482489802,
-0.0569272302,
-0.0317796804,
-0.0628841072,
-0.0972774699,
-0.0413896739,
-0.0179338269,
0.0806528628,
0.0227785055,
0.006165857,
0.0068311878,
-0.0317008123,
-0.0841628686,
0.035997387,
0.0210398138,
0.0012949328,
0.0248963442,
0.0311297216,
0.0476643518,
-0.0008356915,
0.03620046,
0.0292452313,
0.0316424482,
0.0147258583,
0.0273447931,
-0.0005248954,
-0.0661889613,
0.0090143029,
-0.0127113201,
0.0360181332,
-0.0469499417,
0.1194484383,
-0.0411964208,
-0.0193817876,
0.0097403787,
-0.0122051798,
-0.0186112747,
-0.0115735093,
-0.0293343514,
-0.0054807276,
-0.0081408126,
-0.0058262688,
0.0035941713,
0.0161449686,
-0.0477392823,
0.0537890345,
-0.0073286705,
-0.0292574726,
-0.0349950567,
-0.0224458966,
-0.0053064488,
0.0016174654,
-0.0091906525,
0.01939868,
1.77950169e-34,
0.0195178762,
0.0070208712,
0.0083499085,
0.0356434472,
0.0382862017,
0.0157394186,
0.0290002637,
-0.0210051201,
0.0360377543,
-0.0779726207,
0.0011229254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04023v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04023v4 | A Multitask, Multilingual, Multimodal Evaluation of ChatGPT on Reasoning, Hallucination, and Interactivity | 2023-02-08T12:35:34 | 2023-11-28T09:01:12 | Yejin Bang, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Nayeon Lee, Wenliang Dai, Dan Su, Bryan Wilie, Holy Lovenia, Ziwei Ji, Tiezheng Yu, Willy Chung, Quyet V. Do, Yan Xu, Pascale Fung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper proposes a framework for quantitatively evaluating interactive
LLMs such as ChatGPT using publicly available data sets. We carry out an
extensive technical evaluation of ChatGPT using 23 data sets covering 8
different common NLP application tasks. We evaluate the multitask, multilingual
and multi-modal aspects of ChatGPT based on these data sets and a newly
designed multimodal dataset. We find that ChatGPT outperforms LLMs with
zero-shot learning on most tasks and even outperforms fine-tuned models on some
tasks. We find that it is better at understanding non-Latin script languages
than generating them. It is able to generate multimodal content from textual
prompts, via an intermediate code generation step. Moreover, we find that
ChatGPT is 63.41% accurate on average in 10 different reasoning categories
under logical reasoning, non-textual reasoning, and commonsense reasoning,
hence making it an unreliable reasoner. It is, for example, better at deductive
than inductive reasoning. ChatGPT suffers from hallucination problems like
other LLMs and it generates more extrinsic hallucinations from its parametric
memory as it does not have access to an external knowledge base. Finally, the
interactive feature of ChatGPT enables human collaboration with the underlying
LLM to improve its performance, i.e, 8% ROUGE-1 on summarization and 2% ChrF++
on machine translation, in a multi-turn "prompt engineering" fashion. We also
release codebase for evaluation set extraction. | [
-0.0073341159,
0.0042131175,
0.0030091142,
0.0554199181,
-0.0629520416,
0.0418130793,
0.0256790631,
0.0009897695,
0.0456461124,
-0.0467393883,
-0.0315151401,
-0.0237017963,
0.0001293417,
-0.0100988913,
0.0448749922,
-0.0444742627,
0.045226004,
-0.0336677767,
-0.0241332557,
-0.0011964191,
0.0053892005,
0.0264773965,
-0.0561518297,
0.0477198586,
-0.0136731463,
-0.0234273989,
-0.0441318043,
0.0029534285,
0.0189107079,
-0.008454347,
-0.0397689082,
0.0269756615,
0.0255676564,
0.0330981277,
0.0000021434,
-0.05988089,
-0.0142363254,
-0.0161846057,
-0.0136728575,
-0.0649812147,
0.0199294221,
0.0271575879,
-0.0101158498,
-0.0004968761,
-0.0440711677,
0.0344051495,
0.0355245359,
0.0550036021,
0.0739906952,
0.0717539266,
-0.0110116629,
-0.0264054388,
0.0209297109,
0.0330861881,
0.0861970112,
-0.0147870863,
-0.0234831385,
0.052421093,
0.0350724906,
-0.021787094,
0.0020860338,
0.0450063795,
0.0420209616,
-0.0158321764,
-0.0263032392,
0.0290402398,
-0.0580064133,
-0.0458642431,
-0.0106566558,
0.0759697631,
-0.0120153893,
-0.0107290866,
0.0133179193,
0.0338932015,
0.0077917469,
-0.0049666958,
-0.0506424122,
0.0613812208,
-0.0351354703,
0.0031370444,
0.0139859607,
-0.0096555995,
0.0156709347,
0.0002704108,
-0.0098165246,
0.0476540402,
0.0044495403,
-0.0061718579,
0.0410481989,
0.0218667462,
-0.0236419048,
-0.0466350764,
-0.0144779803,
0.0595033169,
-0.0656591281,
0.0133460211,
-0.009323528,
0.0291117169,
0.0295151342,
-0.0552279688,
0.0122966738,
0.0581545867,
-0.0526123345,
0.0663881749,
-0.0342794135,
0.0075228447,
0.0170514453,
0.085388504,
-0.0011922342,
-0.0090653449,
-0.091134958,
-0.0175754279,
-0.0236978959,
0.0450491942,
0.0063151745,
-0.0045987982,
-0.0231162757,
0.053579554,
-0.0050627226,
0.0622249544,
0.0244225506,
-0.0097320778,
0.0058378386,
-0.0193073433,
-0.0297117904,
0.017253438,
-0.0344918333,
-0.0100592105,
0.0346818268,
-0.0689226091,
-0.0077234861,
0.0245556049,
-0.0279121865,
-0.01379677,
-0.0006158981,
0.1179792583,
-0.0337051935,
-0.0151467407,
-0.0468028933,
-0.0535882898,
-0.0046744249,
-0.0870997831,
0.0106832962,
-0.063083604,
0.0530415066,
-0.0030515911,
-0.0197510142,
-0.0125628822,
0.0102973459,
0.0391499847,
0.0153311295,
0.100457646,
-0.0119855627,
-0.0269823112,
0.0329094976,
0.0370954871,
-0.0705478266,
0.0900527164,
0.0258988664,
0.0247621406,
0.0430699699,
-0.0077707889,
0.0093521234,
0.0142126791,
-0.0233715866,
-0.0159697179,
0.0220664907,
-0.0092612943,
0.012165172,
0.0138033228,
-0.0220278949,
0.0324205644,
-0.0500001907,
-0.0086165052,
0.0302726682,
0.0333148651,
0.0298289973,
-0.0049121343,
0.0375263207,
0.0076209418,
-0.0020725192,
0.0240819026,
-0.0691371188,
0.0615021512,
-0.041096665,
0.0064754891,
0.03332996,
0.0065811947,
-0.0268919114,
-0.0503679588,
-0.0008539563,
-0.0126684019,
0.0239059217,
-0.0040461263,
0.0282192621,
0.0165583212,
-0.0555493347,
0.0521305613,
0.0355757922,
-0.0596751943,
-0.0260425471,
-0.0500058047,
0.0268877223,
0.0821040943,
0.0493597537,
-0.0505419858,
-0.0296025332,
-0.0367491692,
0.0433121361,
0.0556615815,
0.0012616542,
-0.0005707769,
0.0274918694,
-0.0684743151,
-0.0103897564,
-0.0152018918,
-0.0076311878,
0.0496860929,
-0.0227878354,
-0.0037804542,
-0.0012059471,
-0.0153870732,
0.0212465972,
0.0275708362,
-0.0231951214,
-0.0053458805,
-0.0325008482,
0.0021500301,
0.0113789774,
0.0102333138,
0.0073968335,
-0.0007608979,
-0.0008790331,
-0.0481450893,
-0.0320958234,
0.0481841825,
-0.05421298,
-0.0711779669,
0.042031765,
-0.0524703488,
-0.0213678107,
-0.0308737103,
-0.0372785367,
-0.0385539606,
0.0184200127,
-0.0282657351,
0.0085313302,
-0.0579881333,
0.0001749629,
0.0373681374,
-0.0056545292,
-0.015642507,
0.0854880139,
0.0050470633,
0.0040007853,
0.0277641453,
0.0290260818,
0.0216879006,
-0.0432199426,
-0.0166706294,
0.0347195268,
-0.0049295491,
0.0040423921,
-0.0106876381,
0.0242165811,
-0.067564711,
-0.0344408713,
-0.1009928584,
0.0304921437,
-0.014645759,
0.0132520087,
0.0189363845,
-0.0049616029,
0.0087148147,
-0.0050278576,
-0.0529478416,
0.020728685,
0.019858731,
0.0173702966,
0.0442815796,
-0.0119691845,
0.0113668153,
-0.0003205772,
0.0052683139,
-0.0134951603,
0.0303069744,
0.001846073,
-0.0141569497,
-0.0656812191,
0.0314332582,
-0.0557189919,
-0.001489885,
-0.0193402618,
-0.0132002961,
0.0647610724,
-0.0140157305,
0.030790396,
0.0569349565,
0.0000536301,
0.0054369289,
0.0333303064,
-0.0357849896,
-0.0429099798,
0.0188314263,
0.0143396482,
-0.0040003886,
0.0112856887,
-0.0208838321,
-0.0433757827,
0.0474609062,
0.0030897877,
0.0305121429,
-0.0753436387,
0.010598111,
0.0071050287,
-0.020599477,
-0.0476848036,
0.0293406826,
-0.0142040793,
0.0428952351,
-0.0335289314,
-0.0206133891,
0.0639467165,
-0.0265873335,
-0.0388371721,
-0.0094523085,
0.0071807839,
-0.0308338944,
0.0593807027,
-0.0229427926,
0.0017911994,
-0.0268765856,
-0.0350722075,
-0.0544132404,
-0.0111180097,
0.0384387411,
-0.0297956076,
0.0266575515,
-0.0364684053,
-0.0083494997,
-0.0296056587,
-0.0170481429,
-0.0411051027,
-0.0006090692,
-0.0181496628,
-0.0218662713,
-0.0275713336,
0.0215057246,
-0.0131967254,
0.0005819477,
0.0322613195,
-0.0084007978,
0.0037542779,
-0.0372150093,
-0.0239538327,
-0.0037817112,
0.0059434571,
0.0395392291,
-0.0172840934,
-0.0181008782,
0.0465614088,
0.0806903914,
-0.0033960252,
-0.0357569642,
-0.0172512084,
0.0282941889,
-0.0114978515,
-0.0198084861,
-0.0258518513,
-0.012355647,
0.0707244873,
-0.0622559078,
0.0120540727,
0.0998100713,
0.0179888941,
-0.0444942415,
-0.0115760621,
-0.0283977073,
0.0402682796,
0.0152882123,
0.009946499,
-0.1186076328,
-0.0554599017,
0.0082191294,
0.0018752074,
0.0004343569,
-0.0348097049,
-0.0270151608,
-0.1063099653,
0.0332464539,
0.0001676225,
-0.0055319588,
0.0242195167,
-0.0272838417,
-0.0142364223,
-0.0140306922,
0.0103432219,
0.0092247101,
0.0134629318,
-0.014309478,
0.0073998026,
-0.0268057417,
0.0024182415,
0.0428206921,
0.007902395,
0.0286361724,
0.0287152082,
0.0480464883,
0.0072111678,
-0.0706071854,
0.0438848846,
0.0189051926,
0.0252106749,
-0.0150108263,
0.0562610477,
-0.0049323021,
-0.0073197098,
-0.0267124642,
0.0328552313,
-0.0237134565,
-0.0424702317,
0.0150482133,
0.0809982046,
-0.064917244,
0.0080703488,
0.0114864092,
0.0536998771,
-0.0193399917,
0.0761175454,
0.0034977617,
-0.007679713,
-0.0705827475,
-0.0296506118,
-0.019619558,
-0.0697517097,
-0.038301751,
0.0118596712,
0.0299318153,
-0.0167185441,
-0.071862042,
-0.0392447524,
0.0262455959,
0.0596336201,
-0.0168877617,
0.0167987607,
-0.0387065336,
0.0196371116,
-0.0115177315,
-0.0010731024,
-0.0232942998,
0.0076076635,
-0.013110145,
0.006744775,
0.0126850186,
-0.0549736097,
0.0069258958,
0.0084169414,
-0.0821557194,
-0.0694353953,
-0.018605344,
0.0514759831,
0.027828075,
0.0613881461,
-0.021586014,
-0.007026047,
0.0196595415,
0.0490028784,
-0.0087649478,
-0.0116088083,
0.0410361737,
0.0681813434,
0.0190838184,
0.0195993427,
-0.0297907144,
-0.0134214107,
-0.0057807174,
0.0283322986,
-0.0389324725,
-0.0061028269,
0.0086237499,
0.0306687038,
-0.0000571596,
-0.0282345787,
-0.0032884888,
-0.0166764278,
0.0079660155,
-0.0375450887,
0.0025134331,
-0.0402547307,
0.0274413843,
-0.0100581739,
-0.0679439455,
0.0360799618,
-0.0170654617,
-0.0389597081,
0.0027805779,
-0.0199725684,
0.0357888341,
0.0228305347,
-0.0119983871,
-0.013982147,
0.0068882699,
-0.031923525,
0.0041042119,
-0.0055632601,
0.0471379459,
-0.0223650783,
0.1113965288,
0.028935818,
-0.0241107848,
0.0114745926,
0.0560777038,
-0.0499516577,
-0.0529410727,
0.025938943,
0.0782569721,
0.0698768795,
0.0333554298,
0.0286016688,
-0.0352759771,
0.0183191858,
0.0245481133,
0.0760024861,
0.0583307259,
-0.0338401347,
-0.0041745119,
0.0188370887,
-0.0210887864,
-0.0293054692,
0.0726436675,
-0.0889292657,
0.0005364924,
0.0157139674,
0.0109405518,
-0.0710423514,
-0.0394487754,
-0.0126000093,
0.0163881052,
0.0096668219,
-0.0110495891,
-0.0403427146,
-0.0599350259,
-0.0224814154,
0.0180461034,
-0.0144064194,
0.0116374493,
0.0350344963,
0.0505972691,
0.0181394126,
0.0039886907,
-0.0158108789,
-0.0018361891,
0.0184306949,
-0.000341894,
0.0122132944,
-6.113512489e-33,
-0.0308382679,
-0.0193395484,
0.0512364805,
0.0201117452,
-0.0125519615,
-0.0366441943,
-0.0398236476,
0.0297861472,
0.0006111242,
-0.0047391178,
-0.0025288942,
-0.009645951,
0.0136623587,
0.0089466739,
0.0074902186,
-0.0505266376,
-0.0086881556,
0.0264185295,
-0.0271682627,
0.0313018933,
0.0616583936,
0.0125924516,
0.0600627698,
-0.0581383891,
0.0527806804,
-0.0126513764,
-0.0273112413,
0.0138811171,
-0.0123377144,
0.0402887538,
-0.0270636696,
0.0361489579,
0.0300285742,
-0.0472675748,
-0.0111305378,
0.0100599527,
-0.040395949,
-0.0599415079,
0.0201805029,
0.0290613603,
-0.0715912506,
-0.0250841808,
0.0113787008,
-0.0277366452,
0.0133865383,
-0.0362937041,
0.0258130245,
-0.0199810918,
-0.0227407999,
0.0144659467,
-0.0391715765,
0.0088261431,
-0.0332898349,
-0.0544301867,
0.0041678292,
0.0426668338,
-0.0149698788,
-0.0059914016,
-0.0636610091,
0.0019747433,
-0.0499087423,
-0.0331654735,
0.0767293721,
-0.0286709629,
0.0016064598,
0.0608205087,
0.0293737818,
0.0241260324,
-0.0593590215,
0.0189625472,
0.0022874884,
0.0776602179,
0.0392094627,
0.0421857871,
0.0163813736,
0.027961757,
-0.0446519665,
0.0361949615,
0.0016661098,
0.048511412,
0.0437958948,
0.0116390726,
-0.0181561634,
-0.0080357548,
-0.0047074654,
0.0268863291,
-0.0183471646,
-0.0604445264,
0.0177410282,
-0.0210261606,
0.00897412,
-0.0430401675,
0.0399844237,
-0.0308260489,
0.0183542389,
0.0151279476,
-0.0320278108,
0.0029464918,
-0.0051221387,
-0.0015927877,
0.0059553781,
-0.0139281694,
0.0383000225,
0.0153298136,
0.0425566025,
0.0158923231,
0.0443484895,
0.0032354516,
-0.0405477993,
-0.0037719798,
-0.0669072196,
0.0467715636,
0.0101774912,
0.036547821,
0.0253147818,
-0.0183364842,
-0.0465354361,
0.0265531931,
-0.0012239872,
0.0038364381,
0.001772939,
0.0004454785,
-0.0275933966,
-0.011481164,
-0.0382631272,
0.0096488213,
-0.0244055744,
-0.0017066111,
0.0124561209,
-0.0453004055,
0.0011130383,
0.02538055,
2.897e-7,
0.0197276771,
0.0296468399,
0.0040897895,
0.0478715859,
0.0063581215,
0.0227044541,
-0.0230769906,
0.0078771943,
0.0133875525,
-0.0659836531,
-0.0098007591,
0.0540581793,
0.072945945,
0.0659216642,
-0.0810808316,
-0.0449487567,
-0.0176157039,
-0.0172650944,
-0.0582592599,
0.0358548015,
0.1274837852,
0.0444997251,
-0.0032818683,
-0.0286723338,
0.0314402021,
-0.0389445871,
0.049840413,
-0.0305276364,
-0.0335100591,
-0.0201294627,
0.0564115755,
0.0127771776,
0.0171188507,
0.0426579453,
0.005453214,
-0.0692366287,
0.0079042679,
0.0191716682,
-0.0055177868,
-0.0650982261,
-0.0072246082,
-0.0423499458,
0.0106778303,
-0.0459759384,
0.0938248858,
-0.0136521989,
-0.0494469851,
0.0135068689,
-0.0096488455,
-0.0453772545,
0.0244088452,
-0.0057888329,
-0.0372246429,
0.0192020498,
0.0123275239,
-0.0219461806,
-0.0238715131,
-0.0759485289,
-0.0206036512,
0.0037911965,
-0.017488962,
-0.0315318815,
0.0108098639,
-0.0183145124,
0.0333859175,
-0.0769696832,
-0.038233228,
2.613129222e-34,
0.0235611834,
-0.0043995441,
0.0487742275,
0.0331788138,
0.0411191396,
0.0241573416,
0.041297894,
-0.00665366,
0.0119920745,
-0.0332741849,
-0.0186116975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04012v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04012v2 | CodeLMSec Benchmark: Systematically Evaluating and Finding Security Vulnerabilities in Black-Box Code Language Models | 2023-02-08T11:54:07 | 2023-10-23T14:08:09 | Hossein Hajipour, Keno Hassler, Thorsten Holz, Lea Schönherr, Mario Fritz | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | Large language models (LLMs) for automatic code generation have achieved
breakthroughs in several programming tasks. Their advances in competition-level
programming problems have made them an essential pillar of AI-assisted pair
programming, and tools such as GitHub Copilot have emerged as part of the daily
programming workflow used by millions of developers. The training data for
these models is usually collected from the Internet (e.g., from open-source
repositories) and is likely to contain faults and security vulnerabilities.
This unsanitized training data can cause the language models to learn these
vulnerabilities and propagate them during the code generation procedure. While
these models have been extensively assessed for their ability to produce
functionally correct programs, there remains a lack of comprehensive
investigations and benchmarks addressing the security aspects of these models.
In this work, we propose a method to systematically study the security issues
of code language models to assess their susceptibility to generating vulnerable
code. To this end, we introduce the first approach to automatically find
generated code that contains vulnerabilities in black-box code generation
models. To achieve this, we present an approach to approximate inversion of the
black-box code generation models based on few-shot prompting. We evaluate the
effectiveness of our approach by examining code language models in generating
high-risk security weaknesses. Furthermore, we establish a collection of
diverse non-secure prompts for various vulnerability scenarios using our
method. This dataset forms a benchmark for evaluating and comparing the
security weaknesses in code language models. | [
-0.006593762,
0.0747928023,
-0.0231017731,
0.0189790037,
-0.0537707619,
-0.0139817894,
0.0128913373,
-0.0054638544,
0.0225696098,
0.0033166576,
0.0227297358,
0.0197200906,
0.0046009128,
0.0623498745,
0.0539925247,
0.0469189882,
0.0366817713,
-0.070669122,
-0.0358426906,
0.0022406809,
-0.0330186933,
0.0109507004,
-0.0015835873,
0.0336311124,
0.0322890058,
-0.0259800088,
-0.0393478423,
0.047746364,
0.0047534225,
-0.0275081936,
-0.0020120707,
0.0369905122,
-0.0368331559,
-0.006012605,
0.0000024179,
-0.0356062688,
-0.0289157946,
0.0264682826,
-0.0199209992,
0.0299802311,
-0.0300827511,
-0.020200111,
-0.0136654386,
0.0321595632,
-0.0155367153,
0.011665551,
0.0450090989,
-0.0295024421,
0.0795767084,
0.0499923378,
0.0260972567,
0.0326882042,
0.0294636078,
0.0180512667,
0.0383934863,
-0.0306381583,
-0.0052096965,
0.0121402508,
-0.003062861,
0.0318674296,
0.0138035445,
-0.0177187622,
0.0481364727,
-0.0176024996,
0.0019022564,
0.0340572633,
-0.0488368198,
-0.0266111121,
-0.0191764254,
0.0297065377,
-0.0743949115,
-0.0349662788,
-0.0005209586,
-0.0108241066,
-0.0003292583,
-0.0196381602,
0.0271377582,
0.0436805636,
0.0121278688,
-0.0228403378,
0.0251610819,
-0.0076295324,
0.0097307218,
-0.0122989882,
0.0323570073,
0.0415072516,
0.0137893381,
-0.016626209,
-0.0149398288,
-0.0540966094,
0.017285658,
-0.0735456347,
-0.0173647143,
0.0475769229,
0.0204543695,
0.0137583632,
-0.0446882881,
-0.024417771,
0.0590132587,
-0.0201580543,
-0.0039047445,
0.0222821757,
-0.0394170135,
0.0007137909,
-0.0494602919,
0.0545407571,
0.0098951245,
0.0128376679,
0.0300803855,
0.0422506705,
-0.0116298618,
0.0038817895,
-0.0420378149,
0.0195264686,
0.0026712951,
0.0608599149,
-0.0148502896,
0.0266080368,
-0.0102493055,
0.1100591868,
-0.0388276987,
-0.021867007,
-0.0096345469,
0.0000993463,
0.0572458357,
-0.0870826915,
-0.0401352905,
-0.0424567685,
-0.0201885756,
-0.0887926891,
-0.0065225344,
0.0098349126,
-0.0579308458,
-0.0213465579,
-0.0045038881,
0.0828303695,
0.0385930426,
0.0350052267,
-0.0582023412,
-0.0881410986,
-0.0275177956,
0.0286599789,
-0.0129829114,
-0.102978684,
-0.0573737435,
-0.0094479779,
-0.0092084398,
-0.0848033503,
0.0093950946,
-0.0262076166,
-0.0041293008,
0.0471806861,
-0.0525336973,
-0.0051208604,
0.0100664366,
0.0392067805,
-0.008503437,
0.0030590801,
-0.0040960368,
0.0244160611,
0.0182296354,
-0.0565492176,
0.0706482157,
0.0176940169,
-0.0034095205,
0.0442321561,
0.0028976793,
0.0411029793,
0.0667004585,
-0.0333217531,
-0.0261439271,
0.0526276529,
-0.0146312062,
-0.0405732952,
0.0325721651,
0.0175288562,
-0.0390947908,
0.022604106,
0.0424990915,
0.0080680801,
-0.0108374711,
-0.0165944062,
-0.0479363613,
0.0457233973,
-0.0520785414,
-0.035574574,
-0.0450139716,
0.0377535522,
-0.0006185172,
-0.0130326599,
0.0275675151,
-0.0383475274,
-0.015909588,
-0.0263077877,
0.0188103318,
0.0269451104,
0.0004260867,
0.0162146743,
0.0195170101,
-0.0635048971,
-0.0606915578,
-0.0753026009,
0.003198131,
0.034621913,
0.0451940037,
-0.0245116949,
-0.0317034647,
-0.0247331541,
-0.0155916037,
-0.0356255807,
0.0151272966,
0.015230271,
0.0222191177,
-0.0292019416,
-0.0048957928,
-0.043536853,
0.0070981318,
0.0334361605,
0.0087212976,
-0.0426495224,
0.0353706516,
0.0222695116,
-0.0365797281,
0.0341340899,
-0.0404977761,
-0.0339770652,
0.0266258046,
0.0010793796,
0.0014917827,
-0.0093333516,
-0.024449233,
0.0483948663,
0.0344203487,
-0.0025095961,
-0.0159130841,
-0.0242805388,
-0.0041662632,
0.0069326591,
0.0205243081,
-0.0499494374,
0.00217098,
0.0222860966,
-0.0407238156,
0.0063655283,
0.0488472842,
-0.0277586672,
-0.0159865227,
0.0206092354,
0.0254600886,
-0.0204423647,
-0.0123062013,
-0.0242909975,
0.0147022698,
0.0040811338,
0.026990518,
0.0059619891,
0.0795106143,
0.0170838181,
-0.0336863175,
-0.0403108969,
-0.0178064164,
-0.0596285649,
0.0179037359,
0.0061580883,
0.061092373,
0.0003048433,
-0.0229848456,
-0.0462133065,
-0.0060764551,
-0.0233597998,
0.0085228039,
0.0410173945,
0.0167829711,
-0.019304717,
-0.0226630047,
-0.0294740852,
-0.0291920416,
-0.0416605324,
0.0047934586,
0.0071627139,
-0.0105332686,
-0.0460502915,
-0.0149662951,
-0.0016956341,
-0.0165933352,
0.0597944371,
-0.0040034824,
0.0374585353,
-0.0475427844,
0.0972453132,
0.0099594183,
-0.0037099989,
-0.0059475419,
-0.0650327727,
-0.007645186,
-0.01869772,
0.0144962342,
0.0467387401,
0.019541502,
-0.0026632897,
0.070541583,
0.0126660466,
-0.0424772948,
-0.0110103618,
0.0654155761,
-0.0599740222,
0.0087360628,
-0.0726777613,
0.049705714,
0.0491694994,
0.0150748147,
-0.0117530748,
-0.0411210321,
0.0335776433,
0.0169948284,
-0.0075828824,
0.0163777862,
-0.0582620911,
0.0059859562,
0.0481231958,
-0.0354659855,
-0.1082942113,
0.0352310315,
-0.055317834,
0.0079657454,
0.0038665549,
-0.0394936837,
-0.0191040579,
0.0537201948,
-0.0049384083,
0.0303665306,
0.0302659832,
-0.0127381478,
-0.0614473075,
-0.017266253,
0.002024211,
-0.0159011856,
0.004272257,
-0.0190907512,
-0.026630776,
-0.0103059737,
-0.0425391346,
-0.0325276405,
-0.0193116218,
-0.0197859611,
-0.0127975577,
-0.0087019233,
0.0006194189,
0.0762597397,
-0.0043365397,
0.0089837983,
0.0214550663,
0.0307636503,
-0.037150681,
-0.0225865655,
-0.0347909927,
-0.0084103635,
-0.1235574931,
-0.0345065035,
0.0048134113,
0.029457124,
0.0361919552,
0.0731005073,
0.0883719251,
-0.069322139,
-0.0091335531,
0.0036435088,
-0.0181446243,
-0.0208860915,
0.0688109025,
0.0224477723,
-0.0146722952,
-0.0324701443,
0.0514827557,
0.0158474986,
-0.0341096148,
0.0399839915,
-0.0286976714,
0.0136767514,
0.044685863,
0.0307928752,
-0.0830116495,
-0.004797772,
0.0090503693,
0.0418844335,
-0.0446559303,
-0.0295907985,
-0.0054005822,
-0.1387670189,
0.0167123899,
0.0170502886,
-0.0021596015,
-0.0292100571,
-0.0163051151,
-0.0209614672,
-0.0045898436,
-0.0431705043,
0.048473455,
0.0223021768,
0.0117136519,
0.0008574716,
-0.0497094281,
0.0052969148,
0.0534293503,
-0.0312381033,
0.026611425,
0.084691979,
-0.0121359937,
-0.0059340415,
0.0319585577,
0.0523616932,
-0.0138036311,
0.0012100179,
0.0172481555,
0.044007238,
0.0184410177,
-0.0208716337,
0.0823106989,
0.0388788581,
-0.0542881526,
-0.0178311151,
0.0703678653,
0.0159280151,
-0.0194351356,
-0.0148164425,
-0.0239724405,
-0.0072304574,
0.0364430882,
0.0371145867,
0.0423814431,
-0.0337319002,
-0.0177238584,
-0.0559784286,
0.0381675772,
-0.0619982406,
-0.0082933884,
-0.0030173275,
0.033357285,
-0.0259245913,
-0.0391579457,
0.0044952491,
-0.0264039766,
0.0260993876,
0.0487345196,
-0.0698507056,
0.0022540144,
0.0034096783,
-0.017630063,
-0.0281526893,
-0.0162119791,
0.0367138498,
-0.0324262865,
0.0085701542,
0.0045155459,
-0.0189035963,
-0.0336157903,
-0.004009278,
-0.0945432857,
-0.0555203632,
-0.0225887448,
0.1022132486,
0.0161940269,
-0.0275492836,
-0.0406848155,
-0.0473273769,
0.0003260253,
0.018392358,
-0.0338527039,
-0.0006215972,
0.0188004654,
-0.032174129,
0.0263401847,
-0.0223790947,
-0.0518044345,
-0.0160926636,
0.0742623806,
-0.0247743335,
-0.0572391748,
0.002198427,
0.0290619861,
0.0426865518,
0.0128703592,
0.013798668,
0.0038499734,
0.0209576711,
0.0271635726,
0.0099410703,
-0.0192991402,
-0.0284409523,
0.034238793,
0.0004834287,
-0.0216484927,
0.0681372285,
-0.0249424372,
-0.0160218142,
0.0441683456,
0.0061713099,
0.0701306462,
0.0616920292,
0.0769102871,
0.0810481906,
-0.0229837187,
-0.0124283796,
0.0400565602,
-0.0211607125,
0.0232777297,
0.0197801366,
0.0402267799,
-0.0102281887,
0.042139437,
0.0338956527,
0.0405214503,
-0.0563285872,
-0.0567650981,
0.0371364914,
0.0211238433,
0.0104564736,
0.0568233691,
-0.0081349267,
-0.0009462038,
0.0100793093,
-0.0594873652,
0.0225077923,
-0.0095673623,
-0.0726481602,
0.0108240396,
0.0053197802,
-0.0100728832,
-0.0054289079,
0.1040521562,
-0.0029741377,
0.04543823,
-0.0101561891,
0.010193645,
-0.0406176597,
0.0230525043,
0.0594049506,
-0.0055513727,
-0.0281521585,
-0.0471813045,
-0.0339477174,
-0.0764278173,
0.0014063829,
0.0098029049,
0.0662663653,
0.0487974435,
0.0168837588,
0.0746004432,
-0.0089712292,
0.0310954973,
-0.0475489944,
-0.0072295596,
0.0016448322,
-0.0498151183,
-0.0444129333,
-5.572701334e-33,
0.0043843668,
-0.0521532148,
-0.0533865839,
0.0252370294,
0.060981553,
0.0105221365,
-0.0435790829,
0.0126099475,
-0.0189756397,
-0.0346511044,
0.0378924832,
0.0123573346,
0.0038659335,
-0.0260857288,
0.0386203341,
0.0199731011,
0.0125890821,
0.0065465174,
-0.0516665243,
0.0402803011,
0.0040017059,
0.0160121918,
-0.027981149,
-0.0384321474,
0.0157932676,
-0.0258482192,
0.0036145367,
-0.0288635455,
0.0081193428,
0.0453229882,
0.0381448567,
-0.0045525329,
-0.0052577504,
-0.0116395438,
-0.017935032,
-0.0003721636,
0.0317216143,
-0.0348802097,
-0.0201024488,
-0.0448338166,
0.0258405749,
-0.0888974294,
0.0581302308,
-0.0063141244,
0.0159743447,
0.0023557462,
-0.0082272915,
-0.0089532416,
0.0148624899,
-0.0424528867,
-0.0006532887,
0.0320579782,
-0.0860212222,
0.000658648,
-0.0240425766,
0.0284537096,
0.0116139762,
-0.0035458547,
0.0652476922,
0.0345059186,
0.0557265058,
0.0023989717,
0.0460958295,
-0.009677304,
-0.035395585,
0.0024729127,
0.0360349678,
-0.0140371574,
0.0056878733,
0.0374434777,
0.003924225,
0.0411318354,
0.0544811524,
0.0607129149,
0.0134826079,
-0.009075922,
-0.0242970455,
0.0185099766,
-0.0080989711,
0.0203595217,
0.035685651,
-0.0170751251,
-0.0585765243,
0.0012943568,
-0.0378924087,
-0.0476660393,
-0.0111847278,
-0.0244312976,
0.0254096743,
-0.0136315888,
-0.040906813,
-0.0118134981,
-0.0026095747,
-0.0283721499,
0.04093666,
0.046621494,
-0.0150430417,
-0.0172512382,
-0.0258571152,
0.0286137424,
0.0024735958,
-0.0138039934,
0.0101110535,
-0.0345705412,
0.0747613236,
0.0318062492,
0.0149562461,
0.0001467269,
-0.0716513395,
-0.0058426159,
-0.0433715321,
0.006088356,
-0.0041519185,
0.0580262654,
-0.0021978579,
-0.025946755,
0.0086597474,
0.0035234683,
0.0146457562,
-0.039648585,
-0.0557136983,
0.0248653572,
-0.0042782528,
0.0363793597,
-0.0150232753,
-0.0203343499,
0.0028422589,
0.0227288026,
0.0432533212,
0.0094856517,
-0.0360227935,
0.0123419156,
3.091e-7,
0.0054752878,
0.0043533617,
0.0241107494,
0.034936551,
0.0163532812,
0.0646838397,
-0.0341393016,
0.0455370918,
-0.0086657843,
-0.0272955988,
-0.0436281189,
-0.0011415832,
0.0549118556,
0.0397296622,
0.0032974628,
0.0102686677,
-0.0675811693,
0.0156458188,
-0.0692771152,
0.0233879481,
0.0693148449,
0.050699573,
-0.0147394305,
-0.0198067203,
0.0177846327,
-0.0622053333,
-0.0142169232,
-0.0154885594,
0.0214744806,
0.0381877981,
-0.0711659789,
0.0422497727,
0.0062216069,
0.0275014937,
-0.0449445993,
-0.0624254309,
-0.0238410085,
0.0453144014,
0.0260386877,
0.0390775464,
0.0157601573,
-0.0146471933,
-0.0090819104,
-0.0669831932,
0.0631637499,
0.0108342897,
0.0004141798,
-0.0119218016,
-0.015246368,
-0.0122361304,
0.0314627327,
-0.0415447801,
0.017889915,
-0.0218039434,
-0.0291024223,
0.0028642465,
0.0004166925,
-0.0132231368,
-0.0420311019,
-0.037838731,
0.0027984367,
-0.0474780761,
-0.0204801615,
0.0560771376,
0.00958296,
0.007157742,
0.0500625297,
2.921427871e-34,
0.0062873675,
-0.0552258529,
0.0103851752,
-0.0117119504,
0.0273506362,
-0.0119739054,
-0.0262888763,
0.0242796056,
-0.0242761355,
0.043920517,
-0.0271254405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04001v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04001v1 | Leveraging Summary Guidance on Medical Report Summarization | 2023-02-08T11:21:58 | 2023-02-08T11:21:58 | Yunqi Zhu, Xuebing Yang, Yuanyuan Wu, Wensheng Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study presents three deidentified large medical text datasets, named
DISCHARGE, ECHO and RADIOLOGY, which contain 50K, 16K and 378K pairs of report
and summary that are derived from MIMIC-III, respectively. We implement
convincing baselines of automated abstractive summarization on the proposed
datasets with pre-trained encoder-decoder language models, including BERT2BERT,
T5-large and BART. Further, based on the BART model, we leverage the sampled
summaries from the train set as prior knowledge guidance, for encoding
additional contextual representations of the guidance with the encoder and
enhancing the decoding representations in the decoder. The experimental results
confirm the improvement of ROUGE scores and BERTScore made by the proposed
method, outperforming the larger model T5-large. | [
0.0361112468,
0.0372925065,
0.031779673,
-0.0409726277,
0.0049419431,
0.0360869728,
-0.0398828015,
0.0103264647,
-0.0464737713,
-0.0136718918,
-0.0224921908,
-0.0498556942,
0.037283849,
0.041509185,
0.0291777123,
-0.1041802913,
0.0142763425,
0.0195948761,
0.0113314921,
-0.0050530056,
0.0150512923,
0.0096518351,
0.0097967191,
0.0342897624,
0.0405722931,
0.0248101614,
0.0257387944,
0.0130356792,
0.0550655685,
-0.0628613159,
0.0159747545,
0.0131882094,
0.0370369554,
-0.0056172162,
0.000002037,
-0.0390724503,
-0.0443514287,
0.032605201,
0.001315754,
-0.0217093322,
0.0278041176,
-0.1030037403,
0.0173054058,
0.0313398577,
0.0172748882,
-0.0460278876,
0.0013882646,
0.0532234088,
0.0867254958,
0.0687939674,
-0.0176096372,
-0.0412704647,
0.0380652286,
-0.0202919208,
-0.0362068973,
-0.0061454079,
0.0071926303,
0.0545449294,
-0.0081809275,
-0.03847472,
-0.0168427285,
0.0338526517,
0.0200899374,
0.0320987739,
0.0089937765,
0.0601310208,
-0.021207111,
0.0282821432,
0.0272877123,
0.0494913273,
-0.0028984658,
-0.0318406485,
0.0079894904,
0.011323751,
-0.0179878939,
-0.0215339959,
-0.0571653098,
0.0226545054,
-0.0345455147,
0.0065508797,
0.014462241,
0.0288736057,
-0.0232942663,
-0.0091836778,
-0.0531168953,
-0.0414031148,
0.0020693184,
-0.0303505789,
-0.0016777104,
0.0122842621,
-0.0121372044,
-0.0318482891,
0.054993201,
0.0363065861,
-0.0256456789,
-0.0079004914,
-0.0586958528,
-0.0782366022,
0.0427048989,
-0.0247164704,
0.0006003494,
0.0269380137,
0.018442275,
0.0270736963,
-0.0049512493,
0.0149545614,
-0.0044687688,
0.0498074256,
-0.0676024705,
-0.0258606058,
-0.009190117,
-0.0002292262,
-0.0484099016,
0.0313435681,
-0.0345475599,
-0.0016273088,
-0.0569698475,
-0.0218502805,
0.0513499081,
-0.0127997585,
0.0220793188,
0.0157290269,
-0.0419221409,
-0.0040051173,
0.0305591878,
0.0127906902,
-0.0113429092,
-0.0195081625,
-0.0018594082,
0.0045286161,
-0.0070825857,
0.0079685031,
0.0175869428,
0.0281247012,
0.0075222757,
0.0073141432,
-0.0388985761,
-0.0105603132,
0.0367127396,
-0.0231059138,
0.0012067342,
0.0040364927,
-0.0232721586,
-0.063478671,
0.010297915,
0.0153375883,
0.0027979361,
0.021699477,
-0.0073650293,
0.0035202829,
-0.0397226959,
0.0172331203,
-0.0578404665,
-0.0007251718,
0.0457905754,
0.0262918435,
0.0076169632,
0.0370272584,
0.0392564125,
-0.0111739552,
-0.0171999224,
0.0298287757,
0.0039367438,
0.0190240499,
0.0207686778,
-0.042018123,
0.0184239596,
0.0074489582,
-0.0180125665,
0.0039602728,
0.0365626328,
0.0695363507,
-0.0576912276,
-0.0000158812,
0.0169700552,
0.0503007285,
0.0155126518,
0.0072511337,
0.0271347575,
-0.0123109017,
0.0428654365,
0.0215288233,
0.0171488356,
0.0198531244,
-0.0038475534,
0.0659481734,
0.0458306298,
0.0083567211,
-0.0450693332,
-0.0409877673,
0.0049242103,
0.0008578616,
-0.0137504376,
-0.0079034399,
0.0404806286,
0.0192853808,
-0.0730377212,
0.0506141558,
0.0306151863,
-0.0429162197,
0.0247481447,
-0.0017331957,
-0.0270310994,
0.0560531951,
0.1054567918,
-0.0397430435,
-0.0486434102,
-0.0088992752,
-0.0193918366,
0.0015928049,
0.0332143195,
-0.0262897313,
0.0142262029,
-0.0746326298,
-0.0488885604,
0.0173805431,
0.0035896818,
-0.0125502087,
-0.0159362368,
-0.0046615484,
0.0030160793,
-0.0279341675,
-0.0584014691,
0.0350904167,
-0.0387731232,
-0.0079243807,
-0.0331901535,
-0.0263970569,
0.0179991219,
0.0172676761,
-0.0169632975,
0.0323301442,
0.0221141428,
-0.0298281517,
-0.0077245836,
0.0315988585,
-0.0703766271,
-0.0820324942,
-0.004846938,
-0.066730544,
0.0153130013,
0.0178451948,
-0.0166570842,
-0.0392299816,
-0.0357175618,
-0.0802635774,
0.0316643268,
-0.0152706327,
0.0379233249,
0.0446005538,
-0.0392856114,
0.0020347356,
0.0482666306,
-0.0350489467,
0.0005937367,
0.0444290601,
0.0135138705,
0.0083536375,
0.0036190844,
-0.0090148076,
-0.0076573128,
0.0141041232,
-0.0091600725,
0.0325240083,
0.026843464,
-0.0146944132,
-0.0134631163,
-0.1258686632,
-0.0098785618,
-0.0319974869,
0.0143426089,
0.0731928572,
0.0481372215,
0.0046885251,
-0.0156780072,
-0.0219191685,
-0.0501694232,
0.0141722914,
0.0107018501,
0.0341768637,
0.0373793989,
0.023818193,
-0.0375371464,
-0.0174229387,
-0.0118122408,
0.0138989855,
0.0116468845,
-0.0254366174,
-0.0033381898,
0.0142565975,
-0.0110133952,
-0.0132968351,
0.0054565733,
-0.0305791944,
0.0044931453,
-0.032533329,
0.052987732,
-0.0000813942,
0.017687954,
0.0322756432,
0.0265142322,
0.0077381195,
-0.025828572,
-0.0036637704,
-0.0397571996,
-0.0055157654,
-0.0039061864,
-0.0599249378,
0.0269780643,
0.0609332174,
0.0406007841,
0.0178853795,
-0.0430552699,
-0.0717737153,
-0.0074328585,
-0.0120051634,
-0.0582873113,
-0.0264289863,
-0.0125542441,
0.0258793943,
-0.0197540168,
-0.0093831131,
0.1013038456,
-0.0048304056,
0.0110583398,
-0.1109949052,
0.0097191771,
-0.061270453,
0.0185854584,
-0.0083799241,
0.0312639512,
0.0134866498,
-0.0568485707,
0.0167677756,
0.0111764362,
0.0180002376,
-0.0479126982,
0.0515353046,
-0.0216165707,
0.0240497496,
-0.0048884614,
-0.0127123557,
-0.0173434205,
-0.0415419638,
0.0119394148,
0.0254242755,
0.0243437514,
0.0079319635,
-0.0878445879,
0.0612681955,
0.0079729967,
0.1086183861,
0.0063815457,
-0.0188429058,
-0.0082756002,
0.0699859932,
0.0181635059,
-0.026075229,
-0.0018580862,
-0.0728441253,
0.0273537599,
0.0590996742,
0.0402422324,
-0.0023760279,
0.0100895949,
-0.0033777086,
-0.0065060928,
-0.0430883318,
0.0168336295,
0.0133437216,
0.0616489165,
-0.041232653,
-0.0263104551,
0.1152834594,
0.0455562323,
-0.0423576757,
-0.008220071,
0.0139611736,
0.0097951619,
-0.0216428209,
-0.0082345009,
-0.0210370366,
-0.0043882336,
0.0008664932,
0.0208583586,
0.0196651723,
-0.0184067003,
0.032378912,
-0.0584616512,
0.0034246927,
0.0075340164,
-0.0773819759,
-0.083918944,
-0.025639493,
-0.0050862748,
-0.0047503388,
-0.0109749362,
0.0210443698,
-0.0287575368,
-0.0092126969,
0.0206630882,
-0.0945676416,
-0.0423283465,
-0.0354402624,
-0.0429645851,
0.0001371295,
0.0792980492,
0.020222744,
-0.0199866164,
0.0489732735,
0.0067739654,
-0.0473232344,
-0.0150760664,
-0.0014109648,
0.0980958492,
-0.007789582,
0.0093825189,
-0.0260972735,
0.0338402428,
0.01905692,
-0.0004809586,
-0.0258266628,
0.0030260775,
-0.025109401,
-0.0123924678,
-0.0658408329,
0.0419128425,
-0.0116949668,
0.0577800684,
0.0151783442,
0.0371500812,
0.002865768,
-0.0034161957,
0.0545824356,
-0.0346289538,
0.0083983559,
0.0013166312,
-0.0752661824,
-0.0556806438,
-0.074899517,
-0.0414369851,
0.0812715739,
-0.0165666882,
-0.0033733742,
-0.0066795242,
0.0073909727,
-0.0127907479,
-0.0704710484,
0.033859767,
0.0128896385,
-0.0180110186,
-0.0299681947,
-0.0743891746,
0.0577103496,
-0.0052236696,
-0.0177049097,
0.0120447353,
0.0151712466,
0.0055263233,
-0.0258125756,
0.0363799669,
0.0169407241,
0.0308633093,
-0.0093586175,
0.0165497027,
0.0880772024,
0.0130742053,
0.006669953,
-0.0245896429,
-0.0041292948,
0.0040463228,
-0.0072138808,
0.0009399487,
-0.046904657,
0.0343792588,
-0.0106790457,
0.0455741547,
-0.018706087,
-0.0103896167,
0.0339191295,
0.036036931,
-0.0065047522,
-0.022583995,
0.0118716219,
-0.0341965854,
-0.0022916861,
-0.0440642014,
0.027109433,
-0.0361882038,
0.0624183305,
0.0145571269,
0.0043518925,
-0.0196835771,
0.0813680515,
-0.0058652256,
-0.0429371707,
-0.0559085086,
0.0419269949,
-0.0301169194,
0.0047152098,
-0.0005501597,
-0.022145465,
-0.0581027903,
-0.0402803496,
-0.003916014,
-0.0095179379,
0.0011373617,
0.0161675978,
0.0276456773,
0.0497804247,
-0.0026687218,
0.0646014735,
-0.0670645833,
-0.0053343549,
-0.075708434,
0.016673021,
0.0248709694,
-0.0182707794,
0.0449170172,
-0.0190830082,
0.0143196518,
-0.0195422508,
0.0152120925,
-0.0011362409,
0.0237484369,
-0.001525862,
0.0141394762,
0.0425536931,
-0.0253680274,
0.0946624503,
-0.0318996124,
0.0372815654,
0.0006431083,
-0.0459015407,
-0.0496441536,
-0.0143986894,
0.0441524573,
0.0140134022,
-0.0511126332,
-0.0065162154,
-0.0202684253,
-0.005274218,
0.0342881344,
0.0052049253,
-0.0161548704,
-0.0175463781,
0.0798519626,
0.0227293316,
-0.0011949966,
0.0023735024,
0.0015280981,
0.0328165442,
-0.0166499149,
0.012655179,
0.0073442366,
-5.77665695e-33,
-0.0185806341,
0.0232565068,
0.008602852,
-0.0530690141,
-0.0307069067,
0.0287748408,
-0.0672634616,
-0.0688925385,
0.0161661524,
0.0079366295,
-0.019816583,
0.005657543,
0.0043511037,
0.0361854173,
-0.0010771496,
-0.0073752846,
0.0406384058,
0.0219642986,
-0.0475606471,
0.0364271663,
-0.0120787965,
0.0419189818,
0.0429138318,
-0.0532086864,
-0.0000787309,
-0.0160219073,
-0.000778971,
-0.0188237131,
0.0234273802,
0.0361668915,
-0.0244606659,
-0.0147980852,
0.0314624347,
-0.010987686,
-0.0592615902,
0.0119586568,
-0.1115622371,
-0.0086155282,
0.0260913707,
-0.0218094774,
-0.0593985766,
-0.0245412234,
0.0400791802,
-0.0220666379,
0.0131681338,
-0.020974163,
0.0263747349,
-0.0496474504,
0.0014813083,
-0.1077496335,
-0.0007883197,
0.0466749929,
-0.0296419486,
-0.0194098037,
0.0181312654,
0.0117614726,
-0.0273132697,
0.0181843434,
-0.0052989349,
0.0059831133,
0.0602964237,
0.0299091302,
-0.0082000308,
-0.0178823434,
0.0164277237,
0.0341014266,
-0.0034261448,
-0.0329803899,
-0.0131803025,
0.0330772735,
-0.0535366647,
0.0159055721,
0.0102571575,
-0.0237922035,
0.0459206849,
0.0062771426,
-0.0517237075,
0.1079446524,
-0.0394319333,
0.0313452631,
0.0248323698,
-0.0015926401,
-0.0542437285,
-0.002164246,
-0.0082951086,
-0.0027333098,
0.0009109634,
-0.0070713093,
0.0024229814,
0.0267581604,
-0.0046718721,
0.00433406,
0.0209172051,
0.0087729162,
0.0606565773,
-0.0245472882,
0.0559241846,
0.0361356847,
-0.0412220247,
-0.0080434363,
-0.0382930189,
0.0281176195,
0.0551700555,
-0.0085276524,
-0.0119386027,
0.0166709274,
0.040670082,
-0.002205082,
-0.03621573,
-0.0102903368,
0.0357869267,
-0.0252278838,
-0.0495426133,
0.0415877551,
0.0034281467,
0.0191277713,
0.0097237797,
0.0321528502,
-0.0387047119,
0.0003383633,
-0.0357295759,
-0.0091375597,
0.039151568,
0.012256911,
-0.0154884793,
0.0053621633,
-0.0448168367,
0.0194124822,
0.0583672188,
-0.0283719935,
-0.0275253579,
0.0211197753,
2.668e-7,
0.1035521701,
0.0278229006,
0.0776357427,
0.0050609075,
0.0016726275,
-0.0041322075,
-0.0063459827,
0.0383652188,
0.0211097822,
0.0120842662,
0.0564574003,
0.012984423,
0.0288946759,
0.0132520255,
-0.0664274469,
-0.0298223831,
-0.0798826069,
-0.0622705519,
0.0061162664,
-0.0369690768,
0.0592492335,
0.0622304715,
-0.0618412532,
-0.0149687128,
-0.009231505,
0.0233625341,
0.0258352365,
-0.0111494465,
-0.0331540033,
0.0475224555,
0.0334564075,
0.0156095549,
0.0029368724,
0.0272728465,
-0.0140243331,
-0.0088272439,
0.0356835797,
0.0473124236,
-0.0129795577,
-0.0049742856,
0.0222532786,
-0.0045097661,
0.0156639926,
0.0099342996,
0.03745839,
-0.0486295745,
-0.0178221725,
0.0289662536,
-0.0628345683,
0.0349314362,
0.0019822861,
-0.0106708081,
-0.0703374669,
0.0660244152,
0.0076391222,
0.0070994808,
-0.0203129016,
-0.0979052112,
-0.0343340337,
0.0234064832,
0.0119712362,
-0.0360648632,
0.0566313528,
-0.0106240083,
-0.0038801706,
-0.1161122024,
0.004149179,
2.665588413e-34,
0.0964122042,
0.0020593174,
-0.0341739878,
0.0252044052,
0.0351016968,
-0.0714931041,
0.0163418725,
0.001213112,
0.0219784249,
-0.0760361627,
-0.0229494832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06476v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06476v3 | Is ChatGPT a General-Purpose Natural Language Processing Task Solver? | 2023-02-08T09:44:51 | 2023-11-19T15:43:58 | Chengwei Qin, Aston Zhang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Jiaao Chen, Michihiro Yasunaga, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spurred by advancements in scale, large language models (LLMs) have
demonstrated the ability to perform a variety of natural language processing
(NLP) tasks zero-shot -- i.e., without adaptation on downstream data. Recently,
the debut of ChatGPT has drawn a great deal of attention from the natural
language processing (NLP) community due to the fact that it can generate
high-quality responses to human input and self-correct previous mistakes based
on subsequent conversations. However, it is not yet known whether ChatGPT can
serve as a generalist model that can perform many NLP tasks zero-shot. In this
work, we empirically analyze the zero-shot learning ability of ChatGPT by
evaluating it on 20 popular NLP datasets covering 7 representative task
categories. With extensive empirical studies, we demonstrate both the
effectiveness and limitations of the current version of ChatGPT. We find that
ChatGPT performs well on many tasks favoring reasoning capabilities (e.g.,
arithmetic reasoning) while it still faces challenges when solving specific
tasks such as sequence tagging. We additionally provide in-depth analysis
through qualitative case studies. | [
0.0342031755,
0.0449235402,
0.0122306244,
0.0229812339,
-0.0852768123,
0.0349256508,
0.0115292864,
-0.0010365233,
0.0271090306,
-0.0981951356,
-0.0169367529,
-0.0320760682,
0.0080541577,
0.0357811935,
0.0116355792,
-0.0101456204,
0.0547545515,
-0.003245041,
0.0526515804,
0.0177446175,
0.003162767,
0.0034820405,
-0.0278069451,
0.0578532554,
-0.0053138682,
-0.0221424643,
-0.0123822903,
-0.0340706594,
-0.0036315594,
-0.0135014271,
0.0310642272,
0.0419940278,
0.0142707471,
0.0491129644,
0.0000017105,
-0.0370203927,
-0.0112711815,
-0.0039444338,
-0.0484789796,
-0.0227273274,
0.0226813201,
0.0053462661,
-0.0186409242,
0.0501986109,
-0.0631543472,
-0.0207140613,
0.0234616138,
0.0785436779,
0.0707787275,
0.105331324,
-0.0074728853,
-0.0457834005,
0.021472156,
-0.024019124,
0.0605579093,
-0.0758741498,
0.0202143453,
0.0301954318,
0.0223008301,
0.0041262158,
-0.0258512739,
0.0323775858,
0.0137481876,
0.0086093033,
-0.0110598123,
0.0358162485,
-0.0909643322,
-0.0190303735,
-0.0309081972,
0.0853007063,
-0.0337089077,
0.0029689069,
0.0116594797,
-0.0036503777,
-0.011095685,
-0.0402295515,
-0.0543050133,
0.0337592475,
0.0081673432,
0.0314795636,
-0.0003587279,
0.0025525943,
0.0090515949,
0.0000178349,
-0.0097327046,
0.0792636722,
-0.0138415368,
-0.0191391148,
0.0106079672,
0.0141210938,
-0.0590731725,
-0.0756009519,
-0.0058566337,
0.0607811771,
-0.016265234,
0.0341285281,
-0.0219584815,
0.0055247764,
0.0058717569,
-0.0442354679,
-0.0001471152,
0.084790282,
0.0227312967,
0.0680334121,
-0.0299183447,
0.0476756059,
0.0125931147,
0.0114272786,
-0.0036258837,
-0.0165075622,
-0.1064637229,
-0.0288732965,
-0.0331836194,
0.0428126417,
-0.0328852832,
-0.0310865622,
-0.0414654836,
0.018287681,
0.0055091041,
0.0039140703,
0.0260710828,
0.0201600417,
-0.0159086697,
-0.0150599526,
-0.0323927663,
0.0472593382,
-0.0110481428,
0.0112142917,
0.0065526068,
-0.0692984983,
-0.0168947466,
-0.0210806858,
0.0256283581,
-0.0332082473,
0.0082382485,
0.0729213357,
0.004900652,
-0.0527727678,
-0.0410669707,
-0.0126370396,
-0.0201950483,
-0.1034715325,
0.0075910464,
-0.0332231112,
0.0240344964,
0.0110888984,
-0.0041561741,
-0.0029137267,
0.0129907895,
0.0341453925,
-0.054673776,
0.1016049162,
0.0442715436,
-0.0039815772,
0.002585588,
0.0092468914,
-0.0188237354,
0.0845841914,
0.0348842479,
-0.0245213974,
0.027483413,
-0.0055603553,
0.0176669154,
0.030142203,
0.0063984357,
-0.0215583015,
0.0122988438,
-0.0098487763,
-0.0124761211,
0.0122721437,
-0.016332753,
0.0415625758,
-0.0342867188,
-0.0180914365,
0.033699356,
0.0715389624,
0.0256580804,
0.0283886567,
0.0238459371,
0.036339853,
-0.0161760468,
0.0030787373,
-0.0549824163,
0.0159002952,
-0.0479112267,
0.009656542,
0.0050690086,
-0.0117641836,
-0.0296410974,
-0.0342595913,
-0.0398352183,
0.0118001476,
0.0297074988,
-0.0075633596,
0.0439226329,
-0.0021798331,
-0.0546686985,
0.0114512639,
0.0089125121,
-0.0389489383,
-0.0257289,
-0.0709385797,
0.0122217108,
0.0419406481,
0.0722902566,
-0.0281962659,
-0.0615602247,
-0.0318668224,
-0.0022885848,
0.030187048,
0.0277288686,
0.0031090814,
-0.0023099673,
-0.0456641912,
-0.0241102502,
-0.0030902787,
0.0212006513,
-0.0000272079,
0.0304560922,
0.0031078018,
0.0119609833,
0.0017888988,
0.011399827,
0.0248597302,
-0.055205483,
-0.0370396636,
0.0217403658,
-0.0181100722,
0.0167964809,
0.0088755758,
-0.0151149556,
0.0226447992,
-0.0022194958,
-0.014863397,
-0.0640908629,
0.0232278109,
-0.0384054743,
-0.0780556202,
0.0626359731,
-0.0212850627,
-0.0206277817,
0.006290318,
-0.0694297552,
-0.0500637256,
0.0362556279,
-0.0240989272,
0.0224734452,
-0.0306701455,
0.01034554,
0.0272253361,
0.0057847644,
-0.0162078533,
0.0567342192,
0.0167485494,
0.0150048072,
-0.0320489965,
0.0013858509,
0.0134891681,
-0.0152839534,
-0.045150768,
-0.0097091924,
-0.0132683367,
0.0081427591,
0.0280491263,
0.0094134007,
-0.0569684505,
-0.0041230442,
-0.1087783799,
0.0498414561,
-0.0100269169,
0.0328726061,
0.0323835574,
-0.0040794276,
-0.0065492797,
-0.0088907704,
-0.0526299253,
0.0192599259,
0.0508885309,
0.0094031766,
0.0593443513,
0.0046237651,
0.0004033516,
-0.0385389253,
-0.0010175942,
-0.0360712893,
0.0305938236,
0.0109167136,
-0.0265182909,
-0.0121027306,
0.0274326541,
-0.0366968103,
0.0420806371,
-0.0085695293,
-0.0187305938,
-0.0002613365,
-0.0004172808,
0.0196532439,
0.0355908051,
-0.0094247069,
0.0184197985,
-0.0085799275,
-0.0204145759,
-0.0579597279,
0.0397630632,
-0.0332036093,
-0.030512061,
-0.0039635622,
-0.0072971466,
-0.0273069609,
0.1171376854,
-0.0272707809,
-0.0256093089,
-0.0666860417,
0.0267821979,
0.0051349816,
0.0158914942,
-0.0559175424,
0.0323391855,
-0.0075023207,
0.0210387073,
-0.0369802974,
-0.0203845054,
0.0476222001,
0.0005467399,
-0.0238690041,
-0.0689479411,
0.0037035402,
-0.0642904714,
0.0729609653,
0.0105355401,
-0.0176028255,
0.0375627913,
-0.0288866032,
-0.0215956289,
-0.0116283558,
0.0181988515,
-0.0188814271,
0.0337149203,
-0.0373189673,
0.0419761576,
-0.0311726201,
-0.0278935991,
-0.0439097136,
-0.0330248736,
-0.0392425433,
0.03534998,
-0.0040072296,
-0.0157176834,
-0.0439137109,
-0.0039738342,
0.0034274347,
0.043972712,
-0.0177714545,
-0.0152690439,
-0.030655507,
0.0336877331,
0.0444664098,
0.0071313316,
0.0095194597,
0.0313277356,
0.024455009,
0.064592503,
0.0480878167,
0.0125405993,
-0.0192983523,
0.0082045766,
-0.0012402702,
-0.0572911389,
-0.0199663118,
0.007617794,
0.0348817334,
-0.0712779015,
-0.0036128454,
0.1282370538,
0.0490775369,
-0.0045048641,
-0.0160837416,
-0.0156746935,
-0.0029297054,
0.0224514958,
0.007442737,
-0.1080195755,
-0.0738178045,
0.0127603328,
-0.0298714377,
-0.0138926357,
-0.0633097067,
-0.0331098773,
-0.1233945563,
0.0275155995,
-0.0059613534,
-0.0291676987,
0.0221257787,
-0.0415138789,
-0.0034583074,
-0.0469055288,
0.0071394611,
-0.0133263776,
-0.0272001419,
0.0149709731,
0.0165541153,
-0.0461607501,
-0.0552963503,
0.0586860813,
-0.033635281,
0.0611121133,
0.0615716875,
0.0316600017,
0.0186157189,
0.0126086259,
0.0649983585,
0.0314101391,
-0.0003657866,
0.0017736065,
0.0487067811,
-0.0246542674,
-0.0024336064,
-0.0016876991,
0.0273421146,
-0.0476209112,
-0.0065796128,
-0.0032158033,
0.0807361007,
-0.0173633993,
0.0042593982,
-0.0156117454,
0.0243202448,
0.00554098,
0.1019536108,
0.0139404023,
-0.0071461834,
-0.1006945744,
-0.0408332087,
-0.0294463262,
-0.0442014709,
-0.0444919914,
0.0052193832,
0.0118564013,
-0.0356720239,
-0.0671255514,
-0.0312387254,
0.0638272241,
0.01066068,
-0.0204310305,
-0.0218560919,
0.0169926975,
0.0182680804,
-0.0316153057,
0.0091976812,
-0.0406471863,
0.0125081502,
-0.0378986895,
0.0158659592,
0.0377154276,
0.0115143666,
-0.0273903329,
0.0109002432,
-0.090006806,
-0.0700575411,
-0.0369397998,
0.0229509212,
0.0258983038,
0.0311464071,
-0.0284426399,
-0.0157262217,
0.0086241979,
0.0736050084,
-0.0678043887,
0.003872788,
0.0221493337,
0.0395966545,
0.0109800482,
0.0359657891,
0.0108337766,
0.0286690425,
0.0078035872,
0.0677361339,
-0.0189233962,
0.0126538696,
0.0143236266,
0.0147938002,
0.0509144962,
0.0129086925,
0.0125938524,
0.0047641355,
-0.0130435219,
-0.0208074246,
-0.0127724558,
-0.0529350042,
-0.0241086781,
0.020629406,
-0.0224551056,
-0.0159584619,
-0.0079286937,
-0.0777813345,
0.0543914028,
-0.0095963618,
-0.0038945172,
0.0243346747,
-0.0331291445,
0.0170052927,
-0.0265091155,
0.0047407616,
0.0090388954,
0.0239920374,
0.0154977133,
-0.0101103708,
0.0698381588,
0.0049931537,
0.0322799012,
-0.0181627646,
0.0033729929,
-0.0681449994,
-0.0446111262,
0.0059973649,
0.0659999698,
0.0716889352,
-0.0059157447,
0.0225634873,
-0.0309895426,
-0.0164905749,
-0.0175384432,
0.0218461696,
-0.0105146067,
-0.0206070039,
0.020188842,
0.0210457016,
-0.0308610667,
-0.0129334666,
0.0904407352,
0.0149920844,
0.0494109802,
0.0303532258,
-0.0161143988,
-0.0387191363,
-0.038293574,
0.0090568438,
-0.0130118048,
0.0161512364,
0.0479460731,
-0.0618129447,
-0.0698696375,
-0.0201711841,
-0.0115477908,
0.0212478023,
-0.0051848022,
0.0273576044,
0.0313564315,
-0.0163337421,
-0.0027547728,
-0.0567345172,
0.0081413062,
-0.0131873935,
-0.0235300623,
-0.0268932134,
-5.888080223e-33,
-0.0187420733,
-0.0276002809,
0.0633873567,
0.025098918,
0.013007205,
0.0032199353,
-0.031981647,
0.0402887166,
-0.0063788756,
-0.0044282698,
-0.0404915176,
0.0134887435,
0.012029374,
0.0268230885,
0.0079959789,
-0.0340268984,
0.0315335579,
-0.034700226,
-0.0063079908,
-0.0108229127,
0.0328242406,
0.0313402936,
0.0688112676,
-0.0279032327,
0.0179546941,
0.0100343609,
-0.0006827317,
0.0260549095,
0.0210887622,
0.0388602726,
-0.0333583914,
0.0128618982,
0.0501820594,
-0.0541738346,
-0.012955999,
0.049401667,
-0.0853439644,
-0.0321939513,
0.0237397868,
0.0027954334,
-0.0289358124,
0.0021623825,
0.021774929,
-0.0064985272,
0.00224773,
-0.0320024714,
0.0080602495,
-0.0166124832,
-0.0007573466,
0.0171654187,
-0.0418515466,
0.0404723734,
-0.0288690627,
-0.0336964168,
0.0269802772,
0.0455642603,
-0.0140308142,
0.0056568822,
-0.0403264165,
0.0156077286,
0.0083037987,
0.0243728627,
0.0390901864,
-0.0293183066,
0.0010433291,
0.0548550263,
0.0141543206,
-0.0108133797,
-0.0587478839,
-0.0156479012,
0.0111632142,
0.0372660346,
0.0368735306,
0.020340357,
0.0692415312,
0.0145883933,
-0.061234504,
0.0122054331,
0.0354813375,
0.035747204,
0.0049972958,
0.0205343757,
-0.038200587,
-0.0147167165,
-0.0125054698,
0.0200643968,
-0.0538086854,
-0.036440704,
0.0327680781,
0.0179037228,
0.0104388203,
0.0190437604,
0.0538777225,
-0.0599240214,
-0.0054430822,
0.0204990562,
-0.0087117814,
0.0083965342,
0.003203748,
0.0331331007,
-0.0800293535,
-0.0191298835,
0.0098149627,
0.0310978405,
0.0051434063,
-0.0113571836,
0.0445208699,
0.0170264971,
-0.0640813932,
-0.0128641855,
-0.0455645882,
0.0578120537,
-0.019829005,
0.0549210832,
0.0300941896,
0.018635476,
-0.0184215307,
0.0587142073,
-0.0014788589,
0.0006760822,
-0.0052222232,
0.0143732792,
-0.0271010324,
-0.008741064,
-0.0095091034,
-0.0073869359,
-0.0171774775,
0.011664358,
0.0126609793,
-0.0366987921,
-0.0047495691,
0.0068512815,
2.553e-7,
0.0436384939,
0.0478794686,
0.0171614233,
0.0094538014,
0.0346418358,
0.0532081798,
-0.0210761707,
0.0280439071,
0.004686702,
-0.0065329229,
0.0033027593,
0.0318873189,
0.0284008011,
0.0249712281,
-0.0738082603,
-0.0208989903,
-0.0475753322,
-0.0271460526,
-0.0389045961,
-0.0014416517,
0.0627949238,
0.089924477,
0.0177218821,
-0.0009184539,
-0.0018955683,
-0.0618776716,
0.0690027773,
0.0002673681,
-0.0342078954,
0.030505836,
0.0202459004,
0.039740406,
0.003088973,
0.024864655,
-0.0095866034,
0.0180769917,
-0.0021392906,
0.0902078897,
-0.0009209116,
-0.0158772264,
-0.0159700513,
-0.0095232213,
-0.0073747775,
-0.0257715564,
0.1127751991,
-0.108667478,
-0.0582212508,
-0.038354516,
-0.0043181861,
-0.0052648713,
0.0284648761,
0.0072792936,
-0.0152557977,
0.0118559645,
0.0293108281,
-0.0181855466,
-0.0291583538,
-0.0987383276,
-0.0049684653,
0.0033100003,
-0.0432340689,
-0.0032691676,
-0.0238708425,
0.0055966135,
0.0447884575,
-0.059659604,
-0.010180464,
2.389688868e-34,
0.0440932028,
-0.0126891993,
0.0131285936,
0.0342183448,
0.0409901477,
0.0159314349,
-0.0137531869,
0.0162997022,
0.0224235095,
-0.040319439,
-0.011503892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03950v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03950v1 | Improving (Dis)agreement Detection with Inductive Social Relation Information From Comment-Reply Interactions | 2023-02-08T09:09:47 | 2023-02-08T09:09:47 | Yun Luo, Zihan Liu, Stan Z. Li, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | (Dis)agreement detection aims to identify the authors' attitudes or positions
(\textit{{agree, disagree, neutral}}) towards a specific text. It is limited
for existing methods merely using textual information for identifying
(dis)agreements, especially for cross-domain settings. Social relation
information can play an assistant role in the (dis)agreement task besides
textual information. We propose a novel method to extract such relation
information from (dis)agreement data into an inductive social relation graph,
merely using the comment-reply pairs without any additional platform-specific
information. The inductive social relation globally considers the historical
discussion and the relation between authors. Textual information based on a
pre-trained language model and social relation information encoded by
pre-trained RGCN are jointly considered for (dis)agreement detection.
Experimental results show that our model achieves state-of-the-art performance
for both the in-domain and cross-domain tasks on the benchmark -- DEBAGREEMENT.
We find social relations can boost the performance of the (dis)agreement
detection model, especially for the long-token comment-reply pairs,
demonstrating the effectiveness of the social relation graph. We also explore
the effect of the knowledge graph embedding methods, the information fusing
method, and the time interval in constructing the social relation graph, which
shows the effectiveness of our model. | [
0.0487818271,
0.0419250131,
0.0230573341,
0.0677947924,
-0.0553412996,
0.0131534087,
-0.0223302655,
-0.0253000483,
0.0321730226,
-0.0691335648,
-0.0156266037,
-0.0020338648,
0.0303667765,
-0.0019007995,
0.0002025822,
0.0152307199,
0.0268449169,
0.0440810099,
0.0311010145,
-0.0084268712,
0.0562480465,
0.0251373518,
-0.0215626024,
0.0249273218,
-0.0104058878,
-0.0305352267,
0.0351201817,
-0.0164961647,
0.0423242562,
-0.0423108339,
0.0257801842,
0.0534679964,
-0.000310413,
0.0537310578,
0.0000016105,
-0.0228706207,
-0.0046792817,
-0.0075685568,
0.0187340081,
0.0055953036,
0.009795906,
-0.025636714,
0.0066099591,
0.0284482557,
-0.0790426284,
-0.0530010648,
0.0146446209,
0.0666471794,
0.0356752463,
0.0850487798,
-0.0370557047,
-0.0468359403,
0.0090292376,
-0.0217841007,
-0.0356723852,
-0.0214235634,
0.0485526249,
0.015893586,
-0.0159823615,
0.0262573902,
0.0006859105,
0.0117928656,
-0.0091819745,
-0.046710737,
0.0446556509,
0.0108923409,
-0.025848195,
0.0029390431,
-0.0019095527,
0.0678425655,
0.045157142,
-0.0219090432,
0.0159657132,
-0.0106054945,
-0.0176773239,
0.0629424304,
0.0048545217,
-0.0076390398,
-0.0274935123,
0.0220495407,
-0.0349663757,
0.0102229444,
0.0494722947,
0.0140163479,
0.0029073618,
0.0781339034,
-0.0169853587,
-0.0369192064,
-0.0026292794,
0.0356765538,
-0.0410911143,
-0.049749922,
0.0151796397,
0.0152177932,
0.0270251296,
0.0223840848,
-0.0156804137,
0.0020724691,
0.026330078,
-0.0665530413,
-0.022832619,
-0.0472736433,
0.0129460664,
0.0650577322,
-0.0060574058,
-0.0165003929,
-0.0447873585,
-0.0378557853,
-0.0077171773,
-0.0275938381,
-0.0546650402,
0.0116279488,
-0.0088019231,
0.0207563397,
-0.0185275301,
-0.0097047957,
-0.045232147,
0.0164793544,
-0.0167054273,
0.0268678702,
0.0149004627,
-0.0087324753,
0.0353806429,
0.0077228267,
-0.0258873645,
0.0213409718,
-0.0323035233,
0.0406411998,
-0.0107953977,
-0.0050145313,
0.0134379901,
0.0177379344,
0.0521395281,
-0.01882964,
0.0039682286,
0.0164774247,
0.0329982378,
0.0000935877,
0.0178939831,
-0.024827579,
-0.0330428034,
-0.0484851152,
0.0269341581,
-0.0507888831,
0.0616378076,
0.028340051,
-0.0556328893,
0.0011071751,
0.0130457487,
0.0184317827,
-0.0566928424,
0.0235149898,
-0.044968497,
-0.0072741625,
0.0412720479,
0.0004028903,
0.0062225945,
0.0307759456,
0.0243989099,
0.0167867299,
0.052193407,
0.028961461,
-0.0148343807,
0.0166494735,
0.0558683462,
-0.0154859945,
0.0544337407,
0.0043308018,
-0.0180227738,
-0.0155068394,
-0.012548699,
0.0464782082,
-0.0314742327,
-0.0687948465,
0.0288354233,
0.0478856303,
-0.0529080629,
0.0503598899,
-0.0232575126,
0.019924093,
0.0333665796,
0.0163405109,
-0.0032087739,
0.0159966331,
-0.0129087735,
0.008724466,
0.0083787814,
0.0322488695,
-0.0102609983,
-0.0149580082,
-0.0069294237,
-0.0143861743,
0.0664446577,
0.0076424154,
0.0562231056,
0.0151194641,
-0.0712532997,
0.0008466982,
0.0574355125,
-0.0424117483,
-0.0344519019,
-0.0018177197,
0.0433306023,
-0.0082344087,
0.0238143597,
-0.0285577681,
-0.045181755,
-0.0360825248,
0.0059198178,
0.0398488156,
0.049913723,
-0.0130606471,
-0.0215006713,
-0.0304998774,
-0.0286485609,
0.0237808377,
-0.0225780588,
0.0421220101,
0.0380345881,
0.0116423769,
0.0124249505,
0.0286477134,
-0.0016367976,
-0.0091105364,
0.0172451921,
0.0583541505,
-0.0023231267,
0.0080221891,
0.0531619415,
0.0789595991,
-0.0199881177,
0.0101564182,
0.0466206633,
-0.0208774172,
-0.0188839585,
0.0173902139,
-0.0329099856,
-0.0447014123,
0.0512537062,
-0.0124118142,
-0.0710790232,
0.0182006024,
-0.0247284453,
-0.0377903357,
0.0487385094,
-0.0086177159,
0.0745489523,
-0.0026859276,
-0.0415552519,
0.0004680936,
0.0006426073,
-0.0277663395,
0.045927804,
-0.003895967,
-0.0264228974,
-0.0218874998,
-0.0567972288,
0.0400849245,
0.0375481546,
-0.0523297004,
-0.0246347636,
0.0232730117,
-0.003075578,
0.072639823,
-0.0488971882,
-0.0313758068,
-0.0146665936,
-0.140075624,
-0.010641329,
-0.0128069902,
0.0365478545,
0.0072475132,
-0.0148991933,
0.0465877838,
0.0050868848,
-0.0570539832,
0.0040408387,
-0.0225831028,
0.0120286988,
0.0626020804,
-0.0155838868,
-0.0000207515,
-0.0730108023,
-0.0027836089,
-0.0183253791,
0.0642646477,
0.0620233603,
-0.0497054197,
-0.0094106998,
0.0312584192,
-0.085074991,
0.0437547751,
-0.0391537361,
-0.0533303469,
0.0269718487,
0.023228813,
0.0083970707,
0.0327707343,
0.0216747075,
0.0111293057,
-0.0061826003,
-0.0018448395,
-0.049789343,
-0.0056140842,
-0.0424160734,
0.067358911,
0.0063182437,
-0.0012601698,
0.0100747729,
0.0547119714,
0.012300808,
-0.0350195616,
-0.0108894175,
-0.0135042183,
0.0582711548,
0.005848364,
0.0151243778,
-0.0463168249,
0.0329569839,
-0.0186478533,
-0.0491574667,
-0.0073516062,
0.0588282794,
-0.0346928239,
-0.0115006277,
-0.0366655774,
-0.0303310491,
-0.0389456414,
0.0287524406,
0.0189025123,
0.009427743,
-0.0103358719,
0.0139971683,
-0.0206693765,
-0.0388635322,
0.0659048408,
-0.0172179826,
0.0202269815,
0.0128288921,
0.0350713991,
0.0133158267,
-0.0144542139,
-0.0117845079,
-0.0508266501,
-0.0436224937,
-0.0165939201,
0.0268660598,
-0.0571100637,
0.0468010157,
-0.0028297375,
0.0167759638,
0.0049249162,
-0.0008555187,
-0.0081971306,
-0.0075272699,
0.0380102284,
0.0321832821,
-0.0111891404,
0.0148595553,
-0.0084380247,
-0.0311480481,
0.0922049657,
-0.0024999713,
-0.0113157174,
-0.0603274368,
-0.0683537573,
-0.0370464772,
0.0049320981,
-0.0198682882,
-0.0809090883,
0.0376469158,
-0.0233134013,
0.0429062285,
0.0847404972,
0.0074870666,
-0.0439602882,
-0.0435967781,
0.0400003716,
-0.0009187621,
0.0032179214,
0.0036466632,
-0.089675799,
-0.0049913567,
-0.0532663688,
-0.0450648703,
0.0158043113,
-0.0434406027,
-0.0148393568,
-0.0599645004,
-0.010721908,
-0.0043470333,
-0.0273381472,
-0.0363703407,
-0.0291998703,
0.0054489537,
0.0153279463,
-0.0204375237,
-0.0308615826,
0.0041469801,
0.0000479004,
-0.0109491367,
-0.0470215455,
-0.0008738162,
0.0066635818,
-0.055688858,
0.0723340139,
0.0529517047,
0.0735520795,
0.0091445623,
0.0081313886,
0.0576391667,
0.0248372033,
-0.0118782707,
-0.0078662541,
0.0547169484,
-0.037890967,
0.0173259508,
-0.0385061279,
-0.0287265833,
-0.0383285657,
-0.0101039959,
0.0178451575,
0.0702093542,
0.0177191906,
-0.0240864549,
-0.0102973748,
0.0511234477,
0.0065878346,
0.061415717,
0.0022273951,
0.0234469902,
-0.038288217,
0.0066234963,
0.0241193604,
-0.0346495137,
0.0018790622,
-0.0368876681,
-0.0159322694,
0.0016022233,
-0.1035565957,
-0.04775998,
-0.0091190599,
-0.0140587995,
-0.025234513,
0.0084973304,
0.10922122,
-0.0012479429,
-0.0646225065,
-0.0014271499,
0.0043022349,
0.0081424629,
0.0159524865,
-0.0232964177,
0.0461734906,
0.0150503637,
-0.0253187194,
-0.0263794307,
-0.0396115445,
-0.0850003436,
-0.0347562842,
0.0205561724,
0.0146677047,
0.0278068762,
-0.0263495892,
-0.0037491245,
0.0247116573,
0.0237203613,
-0.0162842702,
-0.0052754036,
0.0457418002,
0.0310813375,
-0.0142193707,
0.0058321287,
-0.0160453487,
0.0160173178,
0.0075626089,
-0.023761861,
-0.0821983218,
-0.0421034954,
-0.0146671087,
-0.0198888984,
0.0261777379,
0.039843332,
0.0211391058,
-0.050383497,
-0.0034113538,
-0.0484882332,
0.0003670575,
-0.04188722,
0.0034096057,
-0.0374709964,
-0.0469206646,
-0.0333857536,
0.0222901572,
0.0020059973,
0.062889494,
-0.0074998685,
0.0356280208,
0.0175402053,
0.0222132187,
0.0164242368,
-0.0125872483,
-0.0243954733,
-0.0313378088,
0.011712959,
-0.023235403,
0.0082178116,
0.0515009277,
0.0265127216,
-0.0502189733,
0.011380896,
0.0120492,
-0.0849065781,
0.0257115886,
-0.0183488894,
0.0202140864,
0.0333105288,
-0.0158818681,
0.073382251,
-0.0107129943,
0.0070371851,
-0.0176906623,
0.0585744157,
-0.0352101587,
-0.0117834052,
0.0194085538,
0.0063457484,
-0.0503669865,
0.0538626164,
0.0577909723,
-0.0307286866,
-0.0080577116,
0.0134142367,
-0.0730017871,
-0.0216615442,
-0.0224426109,
0.016987728,
-0.0070114266,
-0.010170755,
0.0389683433,
-0.040192008,
-0.0380724184,
0.0130160823,
-0.0248998869,
-0.006835904,
0.0304400679,
-0.025542954,
0.0440501198,
0.0224991869,
-0.0017661175,
-0.0379272774,
0.0373552144,
-0.0529234186,
-0.0278758723,
-0.0467546619,
-5.584843088e-33,
0.0033729158,
-0.0639921948,
-0.0400997102,
0.0648028851,
-0.0253069401,
0.0092794364,
-0.041158177,
-0.0108802747,
-0.0087424982,
0.0710750148,
-0.0023584729,
0.0564176291,
-0.0131263863,
0.0126930224,
-0.0195477698,
-0.0362861417,
0.0323701911,
-0.020268824,
0.0247724988,
0.0205434561,
0.0328988396,
-0.0127145071,
0.0531335622,
-0.1404719651,
0.0443183109,
-0.0392192192,
0.005102146,
0.0054229475,
0.012463307,
0.0433841236,
-0.0127950599,
0.0053790552,
0.0336559713,
0.0103606917,
-0.0003829499,
0.0662651286,
-0.0770173222,
-0.022299882,
-0.0003214368,
-0.0177631881,
-0.0292587765,
0.0259160195,
0.0488033071,
-0.001883202,
0.0319557674,
-0.0027269078,
0.0647145659,
0.0070390897,
-0.0004909262,
-0.0588852242,
-0.0609027818,
0.0558532141,
0.0173639748,
0.0096751358,
0.0015017968,
0.0009883868,
0.0447846428,
-0.0077858591,
-0.0653281137,
0.0100007327,
-0.0650323704,
-0.0179513916,
-0.0277948584,
-0.0319797248,
0.0079193944,
0.0811129287,
0.0030223988,
0.0473950319,
-0.0014113062,
-0.0038499092,
-0.027152136,
0.0145645998,
0.0146755632,
0.0740004927,
-0.014155183,
-0.0335135013,
-0.0946635231,
0.001996435,
0.0869796947,
0.0037743666,
0.010297332,
0.005865952,
-0.0320862494,
-0.0101472763,
0.0557874255,
-0.0090121906,
-0.0297069848,
-0.0364875831,
-0.0212663114,
0.0108032385,
-0.0263380148,
0.027370872,
-0.0127266394,
-0.0696007684,
-0.0446410999,
0.0807181746,
-0.0023155829,
0.0433516949,
0.0223715268,
-0.0259769056,
-0.0609516054,
0.0162438806,
-0.0272158794,
0.0078802425,
0.0240907501,
0.0275499597,
0.0478218794,
-0.0209712554,
-0.0581354573,
-0.0237117,
-0.0355035178,
-0.0056176241,
-0.0342121311,
-0.0146038728,
0.0183811691,
0.0405598059,
-0.0037195049,
0.0604900606,
-0.0068774982,
0.0653754249,
-0.0330512151,
0.0118813654,
0.01217811,
0.0184512511,
-0.0124660982,
-0.0578067489,
0.0239657927,
0.0074122599,
-0.0074825371,
-0.0226950999,
0.0000632259,
-0.0411608927,
2.403e-7,
0.0177440699,
0.0437558182,
0.0664872304,
-0.0166705456,
0.0301732272,
0.0464904979,
0.0195875242,
0.0517385863,
0.0010807454,
-0.0051680245,
0.0225788988,
0.010979726,
0.0266298112,
0.0491746627,
-0.0795299113,
-0.0422424339,
-0.0815255418,
-0.0619493909,
0.0188991278,
-0.0197792053,
0.0363272578,
0.0443533249,
0.0385596789,
0.0337574184,
-0.0636397526,
-0.0166270453,
0.0757911503,
-0.0127843404,
-0.029352963,
0.0129518881,
0.0351079144,
-0.0550215505,
-0.0413471088,
0.0307001155,
-0.017102493,
0.0422250144,
0.0185456164,
0.0323926434,
0.002588931,
-0.012519625,
-0.0066721365,
-0.0124434773,
0.0234566946,
-0.0071241627,
0.0302785728,
-0.060511969,
-0.0088990629,
-0.0714540705,
-0.0231229216,
-0.0119680548,
0.0187442005,
0.0480390862,
-0.0080701392,
0.0400824845,
0.0007714104,
-0.0530544594,
-0.0023016816,
-0.0827969611,
0.0319951847,
0.0329729952,
-0.0216071457,
-0.0366739668,
0.0239766929,
-0.0230117068,
0.0405766666,
-0.0438531525,
0.0299410149,
1.738390726e-34,
0.0520386249,
-0.0277135689,
-0.0109721599,
0.0163149033,
0.0606862009,
-0.0365967155,
-0.041891668,
0.0257018134,
0.0672647879,
-0.0311015174,
0.0176924299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03905v1 | COMBO: A Complete Benchmark for Open KG Canonicalization | 2023-02-08T06:46:01 | 2023-02-08T06:46:01 | Chengyue Jiang, Yong Jiang, Weiqi Wu, Yuting Zheng, Pengjun Xie, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Open knowledge graph (KG) consists of (subject, relation, object) triples
extracted from millions of raw text. The subject and object noun phrases and
the relation in open KG have severe redundancy and ambiguity and need to be
canonicalized. Existing datasets for open KG canonicalization only provide gold
entity-level canonicalization for noun phrases. In this paper, we present
COMBO, a Complete Benchmark for Open KG canonicalization. Compared with
existing datasets, we additionally provide gold canonicalization for relation
phrases, gold ontology-level canonicalization for noun phrases, as well as
source sentences from which triples are extracted. We also propose metrics for
evaluating each type of canonicalization. On the COMBO dataset, we empirically
compare previously proposed canonicalization methods as well as a few simple
baseline methods based on pretrained language models. We find that properly
encoding the phrases in a triple using pretrained language models results in
better relation canonicalization and ontology-level canonicalization of the
noun phrase. We release our dataset, baselines, and evaluation scripts at
https://github.com/jeffchy/COMBO/tree/main. | [
0.0324727409,
0.0583534837,
0.0276857484,
0.0388562344,
-0.0006932289,
0.0354107544,
-0.034844093,
0.0257435739,
-0.0003932012,
-0.0866614059,
-0.0110704266,
0.0702469796,
-0.0420118012,
-0.0157551896,
-0.0122691039,
-0.0110388501,
0.0560041703,
0.0216271412,
-0.0368225574,
-0.0020247751,
0.0126851304,
0.025466999,
0.0222512111,
-0.012298963,
-0.0391345248,
-0.0276230313,
0.0138036963,
-0.0006731569,
-0.0022583108,
-0.0224419627,
-0.0111281648,
0.0650801286,
-0.0094575649,
0.0168928504,
0.0000016896,
-0.080242373,
-0.0301952213,
-0.0153182922,
-0.0217890125,
0.0057362015,
-0.0084222564,
-0.0451686941,
0.0606796481,
-0.0151830129,
-0.0535735823,
-0.0567666478,
0.0195282716,
0.0595716462,
0.0192338023,
0.0501153357,
-0.0068935496,
-0.0642401278,
0.0226203855,
0.0008242464,
-0.039434921,
-0.0342108719,
0.0216333214,
0.0287146233,
-0.0311958101,
0.0101952963,
-0.0400608815,
0.0480630957,
-0.0053421203,
-0.001709259,
0.0314006582,
0.0137687158,
-0.0815484598,
-0.0015163682,
0.0215366818,
0.1320112199,
0.0278160162,
-0.023868531,
0.0201758668,
0.0185724236,
0.0166608132,
-0.0088181766,
-0.003227995,
0.0019518106,
-0.023300359,
0.0321419612,
-0.0197943933,
-0.0211452544,
0.0522522777,
0.0203689616,
-0.031992767,
0.0399745703,
0.0008675611,
-0.0143593196,
0.0561566912,
0.0154571533,
-0.0554332621,
-0.0568263344,
0.0146407569,
-0.0047446056,
-0.0245915782,
0.0335983261,
-0.0621112622,
-0.0634009838,
-0.0083572092,
-0.0592414849,
-0.0010254959,
0.0116935428,
0.0101990914,
0.0304920468,
-0.0578842275,
0.0212302711,
-0.0292691514,
0.0306758303,
-0.0312258303,
0.0061993203,
-0.0902457088,
0.0270780027,
-0.0682569444,
0.0560297593,
0.0209021512,
-0.0096764602,
-0.0242644604,
-0.0038531977,
-0.0123947635,
0.0354370102,
0.0442212746,
0.0269383565,
-0.0027344837,
-0.0095464597,
0.0004445116,
0.0300549231,
-0.0641351491,
-0.0188918039,
-0.0257142782,
-0.0094366232,
0.0063765245,
-0.0022824351,
0.027432248,
-0.0013912538,
-0.0167940091,
0.0290756449,
0.0181417856,
-0.0020266611,
0.0074077756,
-0.0698083341,
0.0020517684,
-0.0147791691,
-0.051872883,
-0.079130128,
0.0299459752,
0.0284949224,
0.0204816666,
-0.0600005575,
0.0335368253,
-0.0295612868,
-0.0757555217,
0.0658251792,
-0.0495086499,
-0.0085839098,
-0.0205728896,
0.0135054514,
0.0285588093,
0.0567492619,
0.0454917029,
0.0006455544,
0.0562582538,
0.0107850488,
-0.0459417477,
0.0091777695,
0.0464730561,
-0.0202121623,
-0.0026617497,
0.0250234753,
-0.0030458907,
0.0940962136,
0.0282096546,
0.0525030009,
-0.0266424492,
-0.0118487412,
0.0010904566,
-0.0244460292,
0.0186303034,
0.0046935994,
0.0470121428,
0.0131524643,
0.0213681236,
-0.0109425066,
-0.0288179312,
-0.0445426777,
-0.0259294603,
0.0162489843,
-0.0153684076,
0.0204778947,
-0.0044269497,
-0.0259883627,
0.0075211674,
-0.0167613514,
-0.0501502752,
-0.0051279892,
0.0762949362,
0.0505874082,
-0.0298173986,
0.079292722,
0.0238185339,
-0.0367176756,
0.0310062543,
0.0138096521,
0.0059934217,
0.0118850404,
0.0630608723,
-0.0142813623,
-0.0210770722,
-0.0042008748,
0.0213670488,
-0.0077913287,
0.0237311367,
-0.0512865409,
0.0024212729,
-0.0459581502,
-0.0398434736,
0.0025323788,
0.0029039755,
0.005478105,
0.0483208783,
-0.0048451843,
0.0296706874,
-0.0448932312,
-0.002244611,
0.0447441489,
0.0349743888,
-0.0182846263,
0.0013089878,
0.0165602844,
0.0128060887,
0.0203488339,
-0.0059126527,
-0.0098323869,
0.0147253079,
-0.0045608291,
-0.0001464195,
0.0039162654,
-0.0184680317,
-0.0342064202,
0.0509335995,
-0.0089394208,
-0.0470168367,
0.0426277071,
-0.0707460493,
-0.0271884426,
-0.0123821981,
0.0473372526,
0.0414054096,
-0.0043962244,
0.0113859475,
0.0106923059,
-0.0200377516,
-0.0318307765,
0.0749752969,
0.013460339,
0.003551092,
0.0077588256,
-0.0610952415,
0.0502751693,
0.0097321961,
-0.0288857147,
0.0104416981,
-0.0292513985,
0.020950878,
0.0173755214,
0.0072280131,
-0.0818372369,
-0.0075440062,
-0.1119288877,
0.0318151377,
0.001048682,
0.0572156385,
0.0318255499,
0.0405890346,
0.0036368303,
-0.0022503349,
-0.0017576357,
0.0533840545,
-0.0158178248,
-0.0209915787,
0.0262706317,
0.0072247661,
0.0117329434,
0.0161210336,
0.0050013768,
-0.023147298,
0.0655644834,
-0.0148405042,
-0.034686368,
-0.0026580403,
0.1097394824,
-0.0467677489,
0.0221727304,
0.0309620332,
0.0260367487,
-0.008311375,
-0.0137268007,
0.073156707,
0.0357905701,
-0.0299027655,
-0.0047240681,
0.0522372723,
-0.008712627,
-0.0640052333,
-0.0096872654,
-0.0019735382,
-0.053834457,
-0.0387513936,
0.0253037233,
0.0236368086,
0.0263275914,
-0.0000846756,
-0.0306374747,
-0.018328499,
0.0071663456,
-0.0286589339,
-0.0259365011,
-0.0750431642,
0.0306338966,
-0.0056320196,
0.0235415399,
-0.0333374813,
0.015788544,
0.0375506058,
0.007850551,
0.0490967892,
0.019705005,
0.0649348646,
-0.0232380275,
0.0737981126,
-0.0260786451,
0.0155345071,
0.0062440629,
-0.0408002809,
-0.0431416854,
0.0019333082,
0.0253391862,
-0.0240858402,
0.0208270065,
-0.0549575202,
0.040579401,
-0.0031107555,
-0.0026245634,
-0.0188283455,
-0.0028413688,
-0.0369894318,
-0.0036896581,
-0.0469640866,
0.0303546861,
0.0115681328,
-0.0022734706,
-0.0313776806,
0.028017845,
-0.0055441181,
-0.0206018314,
-0.038728144,
0.0764158294,
0.0227678586,
0.0095734894,
0.0004354878,
0.0230513383,
0.0127110248,
0.0596558638,
0.005964675,
0.0001925625,
-0.0308375526,
0.0135743292,
0.0048580393,
-0.066179879,
-0.0306192078,
-0.016979482,
-0.005720153,
-0.0201108176,
-0.0117394356,
0.1090028733,
0.0520033576,
-0.0412419885,
-0.0171873793,
0.0126417251,
-0.011000785,
-0.0043681124,
-0.0085597998,
-0.1224083826,
-0.0397561938,
0.0053661712,
-0.0029870169,
0.0493206903,
-0.0758788213,
0.0157722812,
-0.0553556085,
-0.0123899374,
-0.007806614,
-0.0377893783,
-0.021169316,
0.011122602,
0.0078314207,
-0.0441510789,
-0.00786003,
0.016605638,
-0.0100899329,
0.0453732312,
-0.0280076005,
0.0539473593,
-0.0496015549,
0.0137857236,
-0.0744789466,
0.0266224332,
-0.006911892,
0.0282662828,
0.0217327233,
0.0491758101,
0.0051129987,
-0.0080247661,
-0.0378872976,
-0.0260933843,
0.0282375887,
-0.0038865369,
0.0021623683,
-0.0247457176,
-0.0059097908,
-0.0764145628,
0.0146543086,
0.0267309304,
0.0584498234,
0.0092725484,
-0.0379469469,
0.026301669,
-0.0352679938,
-0.0130323023,
0.0514818244,
0.0154916532,
0.0229136944,
-0.0301051345,
-0.0192158259,
0.0042309556,
-0.0797011778,
-0.0129172811,
0.027142182,
-0.0607109889,
-0.0482588075,
-0.0709675699,
-0.0322573222,
0.0658194721,
-0.008691323,
0.0267112143,
-0.00257278,
0.0131045841,
0.015382058,
-0.0713445842,
0.0357746482,
-0.064153038,
-0.026643604,
-0.059062589,
0.0216262098,
0.0307333823,
0.0071300757,
-0.0256354529,
0.0349042341,
-0.0424336381,
-0.015223993,
0.0049567875,
0.0176264606,
0.0097308289,
0.038900204,
-0.0478220023,
-0.0358834751,
-0.0070785112,
0.0788362548,
-0.0504225604,
0.0331758037,
0.0159189105,
0.0051362226,
-0.0117136706,
0.0613208599,
-0.0615473092,
0.0022855357,
-0.0157890171,
0.0630086884,
-0.0374230519,
-0.0224796478,
0.0410529263,
0.0491318926,
0.008147195,
-0.015243059,
0.0491171069,
-0.036937464,
-0.0088563496,
-0.021469688,
-0.0224743597,
-0.0428665467,
0.052242849,
0.0560966246,
-0.0060180789,
0.0017981438,
0.0061104735,
0.0018999265,
0.0254423339,
-0.0064670653,
-0.0654715896,
0.0473756529,
0.0464035608,
0.0419363193,
-0.0183290411,
-0.0474174395,
0.0322282948,
-0.0003043122,
-0.00785363,
-0.0760249123,
-0.014451866,
0.0072977049,
-0.0061288304,
-0.0405133404,
0.0272791311,
-0.017199412,
0.0335668661,
0.0066301748,
0.0221484695,
0.0719588026,
0.0145133361,
0.073094964,
-0.0363510214,
-0.0299614388,
-0.0041742185,
0.048148606,
-0.0076005463,
0.0004789732,
0.0093252482,
-0.0057332171,
-0.0065222564,
-0.001576948,
0.0761290789,
-0.023777565,
0.0631083846,
0.0184799396,
-0.0511955097,
-0.0488869846,
-0.0138301095,
-0.0258086734,
0.0341273099,
-0.0035758545,
0.0014412872,
-0.0291281752,
-0.0260930657,
-0.0088904789,
0.0068434235,
-0.0387122221,
0.0091756191,
0.0246080402,
0.0257442594,
0.0357961282,
-0.0256283004,
-0.0158170089,
0.027651757,
-0.047341641,
-0.0644016564,
-0.0248902328,
-5.358522222e-33,
-0.0320427157,
0.001041858,
-0.0220316127,
0.0246269107,
-0.0390471965,
0.0122239981,
-0.0077631325,
-0.0017905597,
-0.0215919744,
0.024951905,
-0.0265634712,
0.0193180088,
0.0076730088,
-0.0074706492,
0.0106363688,
-0.0191532131,
0.0091399392,
-0.0209196396,
-0.0141677633,
0.0173664428,
0.0528236032,
0.0403239466,
0.0911247954,
-0.0753590912,
0.0314939506,
-0.0139530003,
-0.0128293121,
-0.0064179432,
0.0284171943,
0.0524876304,
-0.0061295698,
0.0540999845,
0.0280887559,
0.0206222776,
-0.0008398324,
-0.0412854217,
-0.1627648771,
-0.0304807182,
0.0237206817,
0.0309181828,
-0.0680794939,
-0.0540006794,
0.0374587514,
0.0014781858,
0.0369046256,
-0.0187837668,
0.0232571438,
-0.015227763,
-0.0543899834,
-0.0637131929,
-0.0183025859,
0.0211436637,
0.0180044826,
0.0211491939,
0.026460465,
-0.0077313422,
-0.0221010391,
0.0166861024,
-0.0118596945,
0.0002358808,
0.0005188114,
0.0259777028,
0.0433411524,
-0.019677978,
0.0028503907,
0.0116582438,
-0.0678788498,
-0.0480347201,
-0.029316837,
0.0467033312,
0.0019077467,
0.0487993397,
-0.0079336902,
0.0845275372,
0.0203650538,
-0.0134913996,
-0.0558129027,
0.0065042349,
0.0048830947,
0.0101961857,
-0.0485437624,
-0.0192961376,
-0.0004961424,
-0.0023327232,
-0.0522517227,
0.0128621189,
-0.0242076274,
-0.0459978878,
0.0403060839,
-0.0307240188,
-0.023048507,
-0.0065185055,
0.0062186178,
-0.0408983454,
-0.0198049732,
0.0560767613,
0.0368085541,
0.0482485145,
-0.0032916449,
0.0245876964,
-0.0268598739,
-0.0329564102,
0.0334013291,
-0.037625175,
0.0209929533,
0.0076487903,
0.0296254326,
-0.0307920817,
0.0004868675,
0.0228610802,
-0.0019133386,
-0.0593630932,
-0.0322315581,
-0.0130791608,
0.0183740389,
0.0588463843,
0.027366614,
0.0191945825,
0.0732024089,
-0.0152104609,
-0.0224653222,
-0.0133623965,
0.0525143221,
0.0309781656,
0.0258654319,
-0.0031303277,
-0.0361814834,
-0.0124953678,
0.0185777266,
-0.0106993262,
-0.0063784374,
0.0348402783,
2.497e-7,
0.0747876018,
0.0066714613,
0.028973924,
0.0390899703,
-0.0432524458,
-0.0035430531,
0.0407243222,
0.0623024143,
-0.0307442453,
-0.0452611893,
0.0145051153,
-0.0135895722,
-0.0257172212,
0.0079806307,
-0.084605284,
-0.0450454764,
0.0043438408,
-0.0291077439,
-0.037621893,
-0.007579376,
0.1154908538,
0.0610813908,
0.0280943811,
0.0311079249,
-0.0386879779,
-0.037596114,
0.0454440899,
-0.0196914077,
0.0053476603,
0.0519094355,
0.0435517505,
0.0073962715,
-0.0134083927,
0.0379609801,
0.0255195964,
-0.004685665,
0.0346341319,
0.0342621505,
0.0085651753,
0.0439140759,
-0.0316005312,
-0.0751857311,
0.0254468955,
-0.0447204262,
0.0510988608,
-0.0531228222,
0.0063944981,
0.0276470296,
-0.014076177,
-0.0097847851,
-0.0048129791,
0.0094550252,
0.0061461525,
0.0145878131,
0.0303094629,
0.0184656642,
-0.0422427319,
-0.0908462778,
-0.0093175108,
-0.0083618695,
0.0137682389,
-0.0300403666,
0.0232936684,
-0.0227288678,
0.0280148853,
-0.0658767894,
-0.0040235445,
1.84727112e-34,
0.0086070374,
0.0052754236,
0.0104641765,
-0.0056348816,
0.0189984888,
-0.0557425171,
-0.0214166641,
-0.0085565895,
-0.015695516,
-0.0802068338,
0.0306266937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03896v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03896v3 | EvoText: Enhancing Natural Language Generation Models via Self-Escalation Learning for Up-to-Date Knowledge and Improved Performance | 2023-02-08T06:09:55 | 2023-04-13T07:29:20 | Zhengqing Yuan, Huiwen Xue, Chao Zhang, Yongming Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, pretrained models have been widely used in various fields,
including natural language understanding, computer vision, and natural language
generation. However, the performance of these language generation models is
highly dependent on the model size and the dataset size. While larger models
excel in some aspects, they cannot learn up-to-date knowledge and are
relatively difficult to relearn. In this paper, we introduce EvoText, a novel
training method that enhances the performance of any natural language
generation model without requiring additional datasets during the entire
training process (although a prior dataset is necessary for pretraining).
EvoText employs two models: $G$, a text generation model, and $D$, a model that
can determine whether the data generated by $G$ is legitimate. Initially, the
fine-tuned $D$ model serves as the knowledge base. The text generated by $G$ is
then input to $D$ to determine whether it is legitimate. Finally, $G$ is
fine-tuned based on $D$'s output. EvoText enables the model to learn up-to-date
knowledge through a self-escalation process that builds on a priori knowledge.
When EvoText needs to learn something new, it simply fine-tunes the $D$ model.
Our approach applies to autoregressive language modeling for all Transformer
classes. With EvoText, eight models achieved stable improvements in seven
natural language processing tasks without any changes to the model structure. | [
0.0345630646,
0.0532213077,
0.0086540869,
0.0125679262,
-0.0057146112,
0.0172207821,
0.0050715758,
-0.0161631927,
0.0173020717,
-0.0685786381,
-0.0020414463,
-0.0101167448,
-0.0238551572,
0.0591497608,
0.0375716202,
-0.0214938186,
0.0361211896,
0.0004534503,
-0.0020001619,
0.0003615943,
-0.0099184206,
0.0268501639,
-0.0129490132,
0.0239523891,
-0.0306721386,
0.0079589589,
-0.0145133529,
-0.0110307951,
0.0196214542,
-0.0410265028,
0.0455448143,
0.0638057515,
0.0345205739,
0.0270515531,
0.0000021787,
-0.0427020639,
-0.0188481342,
-0.0197634008,
-0.0119130258,
-0.0139000053,
0.0197310373,
-0.0404278412,
-0.00619409,
0.0384387113,
-0.0610716455,
-0.0360295065,
0.0275093094,
0.0412251689,
0.083679311,
0.094056569,
-0.0046823514,
-0.0465453714,
0.0207246896,
-0.0341100693,
-0.0112841725,
-0.0024601936,
0.0062311348,
0.0286895093,
-0.0311799403,
0.0220994726,
-0.0168084446,
0.0367699489,
0.0283344463,
-0.0217948165,
0.0315479673,
0.0585716367,
-0.0033316412,
-0.0245246124,
-0.0181138646,
0.0467655621,
-0.0267067216,
-0.0349342041,
0.0253688674,
-0.0279457737,
-0.027542647,
-0.0180421192,
0.0035455609,
0.028941201,
-0.0025788157,
0.0222453959,
0.0255447607,
0.0226983521,
-0.0074689277,
0.0225591939,
-0.029656738,
0.0201298986,
0.0076801707,
-0.0066111535,
-0.0257209092,
-0.0068127336,
0.0166153051,
-0.0601043366,
-0.0015295156,
0.0517555065,
-0.0119989645,
0.0162060559,
-0.0698292181,
-0.0394638814,
0.0258961748,
-0.0425916761,
0.0272737127,
0.0161186587,
0.0019001217,
0.0011223287,
-0.0505437702,
0.0435225777,
0.0155642787,
-0.0312743634,
-0.0300412755,
0.0307039209,
-0.0457509793,
-0.0248137061,
-0.0927174538,
0.0221173204,
-0.0342964344,
-0.0264031868,
-0.0591740683,
0.0221652202,
0.015756255,
-0.0018367864,
0.0174132492,
0.0404663272,
-0.0824631378,
-0.0179200266,
-0.005119781,
0.0096840272,
-0.0161575656,
-0.0133608468,
0.042210795,
-0.046496395,
-0.0020299326,
0.0076012546,
0.0276566762,
0.0071458467,
-0.0055920519,
0.0488958806,
-0.0334268585,
-0.0261525773,
-0.0725649074,
-0.0605842061,
-0.0256410949,
-0.0644650683,
0.0013109479,
-0.0535718687,
0.0109146517,
-0.0007150665,
-0.0119413296,
-0.0108839376,
0.0242398437,
0.0017994599,
-0.0178228244,
0.0550209619,
-0.0578022674,
-0.0038617786,
0.0438837782,
-0.0162976608,
0.034112338,
0.0731203035,
0.0546634868,
0.0345252678,
0.0168275591,
0.004152636,
0.0372454338,
0.0131255519,
0.0074232752,
-0.026873365,
0.0121154124,
-0.0155094247,
-0.0634691939,
0.024392454,
0.0102923904,
0.0253892094,
-0.0134485783,
0.0301695317,
0.0455919504,
-0.0235607661,
0.0389297456,
0.0543753207,
0.0768088847,
0.0136736669,
-0.0181486048,
0.0128506301,
-0.0161786191,
0.0255844705,
-0.011190542,
0.0455617122,
-0.0137698231,
0.0287614074,
-0.0332300253,
-0.0715513751,
0.0141252428,
-0.016376514,
0.0097502582,
-0.0634059757,
0.04644458,
0.0706739202,
-0.0747106522,
0.0482879132,
0.0088215955,
-0.0767112076,
0.0044026803,
-0.045080319,
0.0242551193,
0.0541466773,
0.0500947312,
0.0269651301,
-0.0266515575,
-0.0204107687,
0.0151179964,
0.0650091246,
0.0287070051,
0.0018443351,
-0.0067026298,
-0.0540571064,
-0.0364378057,
-0.0149812559,
0.0246881712,
0.0274120905,
0.0126960054,
0.0089909565,
0.069689393,
-0.0083497334,
-0.0659939945,
0.0438662432,
-0.0507586896,
-0.0548121445,
0.0378736369,
0.0044664978,
-0.0049207113,
-0.0049839383,
-0.038098257,
0.0116719976,
0.0081126532,
-0.0323533975,
-0.0434286073,
0.044607874,
-0.0632243827,
-0.0255039539,
0.0122235892,
-0.0319367424,
0.0260459576,
-0.0123640103,
-0.0588699877,
-0.0518671907,
0.0217280425,
-0.0598356128,
0.0323641077,
-0.0640464798,
0.0197763741,
0.0246338397,
0.0011823284,
-0.008601293,
0.0656477287,
0.0072185709,
-0.022316236,
0.0077217724,
0.0233189575,
0.0355850048,
-0.0017158191,
-0.0076659718,
-0.006581808,
-0.0150312856,
0.0159840845,
0.0538683459,
0.0349294916,
-0.0434561931,
-0.0360756256,
-0.0380518585,
0.0048277173,
-0.031916365,
-0.0014513131,
0.0260211881,
-0.0045689372,
-0.0137698567,
-0.0239985883,
-0.0389420874,
0.0235136189,
0.053164091,
-0.0190113336,
0.047039438,
-0.0034530195,
0.0150609491,
-0.0209829621,
0.0273899548,
-0.0012283843,
0.040900711,
0.0523137264,
0.0054395571,
-0.0668991208,
0.0644367561,
-0.0357207917,
0.0234060809,
0.0014381452,
-0.0645033419,
-0.0090449005,
0.0181134455,
0.0562163368,
0.0034679286,
0.0721533224,
0.0103551857,
0.0072121867,
0.0003946452,
-0.0273387413,
0.0107542574,
-0.0727116466,
-0.0344232246,
-0.0041271737,
-0.0202297643,
0.0359581597,
0.0739558861,
0.0175113399,
-0.0189347062,
-0.0666439533,
0.020670142,
-0.0079987682,
-0.0337618925,
0.0195513833,
-0.0137929888,
-0.0003887875,
0.0002277356,
-0.0284035895,
-0.0649028048,
0.0509722196,
-0.0322714485,
0.0132816788,
-0.0379208326,
0.0054918402,
-0.0090021966,
0.0359896906,
0.0495530851,
0.0435835384,
0.0491372906,
0.0001476532,
-0.0172446929,
0.011920481,
0.0362294987,
-0.0310329795,
0.0362184867,
-0.0377348289,
0.0263042282,
0.0095872972,
-0.0312451478,
-0.0923150629,
-0.0201080162,
0.0101713091,
-0.0193769932,
0.0037669956,
-0.0348622948,
-0.0182573777,
0.002919093,
-0.0165338572,
0.0822606683,
-0.0177608989,
-0.0479644835,
-0.0178787913,
0.0286483038,
0.0422135964,
0.0106498394,
0.0075309472,
-0.0254426524,
0.0381996967,
0.032302171,
0.0054433313,
0.0005319572,
-0.0760762617,
-0.0007876013,
-0.0200092569,
-0.0397864096,
0.0084637962,
0.0184226334,
0.0197457001,
-0.0629435703,
-0.0414313972,
0.1274732649,
0.014681641,
0.0286710151,
0.009737947,
0.0326302499,
0.0424348488,
0.0321503393,
0.036284972,
-0.0767709464,
-0.0039575063,
-0.0126185194,
0.0361962356,
-0.0193819962,
-0.0224688631,
-0.0553210266,
-0.1253988445,
0.0562408157,
0.0140909692,
-0.02314955,
-0.0129528865,
-0.0130302366,
-0.0537717976,
-0.0120646367,
-0.0265844427,
0.0192062948,
-0.0308911428,
0.0254202262,
0.0382590033,
-0.0475748368,
-0.0570604503,
-0.0470796078,
-0.0331717096,
0.0387719981,
0.0505364239,
0.0392666124,
0.020507656,
-0.0124233151,
0.0074977148,
-0.0146289049,
0.0353588648,
-0.0167902112,
0.0612737127,
-0.0156067014,
-0.0318791308,
0.0062596416,
0.0450949259,
-0.0137054306,
0.0021115958,
-0.0042948201,
0.0154830571,
-0.0247673225,
-0.0516106486,
-0.0120244939,
0.0135882841,
0.0231241565,
0.0383675732,
0.0078651514,
-0.0080989823,
-0.0189437829,
-0.0258090887,
0.0562553667,
-0.0607321784,
-0.0099654719,
0.0090905745,
-0.0092967562,
-0.0330157988,
-0.0982458591,
-0.0344888829,
0.0084387613,
0.0579483733,
0.01268721,
-0.0238488428,
0.0090727769,
-0.0200694501,
-0.0717768744,
-0.0099214111,
-0.0068620881,
-0.03437078,
-0.0311671253,
-0.0399728343,
0.0421683788,
-0.0271978285,
-0.023508694,
0.0329438746,
-0.0651017576,
-0.0726999566,
-0.0052223732,
0.0845831558,
0.0213458892,
0.0454041436,
0.008234106,
-0.027777981,
0.0786113515,
0.0751996115,
-0.0294663683,
-0.0001169818,
0.0214128606,
-0.026076071,
-0.0284714568,
0.0257609189,
-0.0124806883,
0.0513924286,
-0.0111356806,
0.0296825953,
-0.0235538948,
-0.021381449,
0.0429905094,
0.0118997889,
0.0082831988,
-0.0691588446,
0.0133010624,
-0.047766041,
-0.015339314,
-0.0146337794,
-0.0066508376,
-0.0653083846,
0.0522419289,
0.0046761576,
-0.0021948982,
0.0017398681,
0.0128406892,
-0.0282766949,
0.0232273359,
-0.0229065828,
-0.0304295719,
-0.0222985391,
0.0140055558,
0.0164033584,
-0.0086865788,
-0.0169698112,
0.0306675266,
0.0234448668,
0.0215770695,
-0.0240190737,
0.0680468529,
0.020262368,
0.0225643888,
-0.0125612393,
0.0240315404,
-0.0487212278,
-0.0066382298,
-0.0871566162,
0.0258052424,
0.055311501,
-0.0072454489,
0.0805555433,
-0.0625435933,
0.0227595083,
-0.0127699822,
0.0744957253,
0.013160157,
-0.0515010245,
-0.0127320169,
-0.0158669632,
-0.0320703015,
-0.0151390443,
0.0875984132,
0.0180438031,
0.0511574931,
-0.0017185701,
0.0004786602,
-0.0708859563,
-0.0247432031,
-0.002639978,
-0.0431788564,
0.0049051018,
0.0206417441,
-0.0084845768,
-0.0646075532,
0.0062434552,
0.023015121,
0.0216551423,
0.0021510634,
0.079375945,
0.0409665219,
-0.0266583879,
-0.0000418305,
-0.0407563858,
0.0013720655,
-0.0057328846,
0.0134609155,
0.003279716,
-6.472780297e-33,
-0.0231271647,
-0.0392189734,
0.0394480117,
0.0007341942,
-0.0175392572,
0.0107696112,
-0.0319647714,
0.0047919462,
0.0408807844,
0.0220123287,
0.0099127907,
-0.0008186258,
0.0070847897,
0.0432679839,
0.0031178237,
0.0179509372,
0.0893165842,
-0.0220855549,
-0.0387957059,
0.0433424525,
0.0355343036,
0.0587851927,
0.0527819917,
-0.0604390092,
-0.0314643979,
0.0127486233,
-0.0330469646,
0.0090189418,
0.0315025114,
0.0387990251,
-0.0234596003,
0.0385543257,
0.0244250949,
-0.0630767643,
-0.029216826,
0.0062134932,
-0.076349929,
-0.0284134746,
-0.0165690947,
-0.0141098304,
-0.0310812313,
-0.005127911,
0.0531375222,
-0.0358653739,
-0.0200964995,
0.0129295597,
0.0441482067,
-0.0396222435,
0.0090121068,
-0.0613464974,
-0.0630349964,
0.0211685058,
0.0022976731,
-0.042509146,
0.0005676638,
0.0703569204,
0.0036176231,
-0.037334539,
-0.04486233,
0.0279372707,
0.0490765199,
0.0351091102,
0.0724434182,
0.015016946,
-0.007611597,
0.0713838637,
-0.0012427781,
0.0100297872,
-0.0343183912,
0.0168347135,
0.0231397264,
0.0579458438,
0.0153148277,
0.0366545059,
0.0239217337,
-0.039511878,
-0.0436893404,
0.0539181158,
-0.0120507311,
0.0255676564,
0.0213945955,
-0.0591259561,
-0.0104860347,
-0.0087372763,
-0.0445688106,
-0.0094764736,
-0.003079891,
-0.0342767723,
0.0322790928,
0.080949761,
-0.0272271205,
-0.018909812,
0.009304639,
-0.0367549807,
-0.032828711,
0.0186949912,
-0.0411715768,
-0.025729971,
-0.0154234357,
0.0175201986,
-0.0314294472,
-0.0442600325,
0.0419033319,
0.0397859663,
0.0001259454,
0.0024769588,
0.0220709294,
0.0362827294,
-0.0813860372,
0.0439916141,
-0.0276525244,
0.065072462,
0.0051681385,
0.0088914065,
0.0058060996,
-0.0080058938,
-0.0339925587,
0.0479316898,
0.0064806473,
-0.0128348181,
-0.0195714701,
0.0108405473,
0.0422898307,
0.0684318766,
-0.0305172112,
0.0144218858,
-0.029804619,
0.0172310844,
0.0385880135,
-0.0651061088,
-0.0251151472,
0.0239571277,
2.846e-7,
0.0196625162,
0.0555246174,
0.0593879446,
-0.0000856938,
0.0053871842,
0.0393315665,
-0.0055700527,
0.0468734801,
0.0021136671,
-0.0076082828,
-0.0073279482,
0.0098269228,
0.0468511879,
0.0098311678,
-0.0428998843,
-0.0165947974,
-0.0876579434,
0.0029567869,
-0.0578863285,
-0.0286035482,
0.0661557466,
0.0504176393,
-0.0248632766,
-0.0202575326,
0.0305788033,
-0.0419815332,
0.0815052167,
0.0165779162,
-0.0129141202,
0.0360090733,
0.0407758728,
0.0776419118,
-0.0265176799,
0.0067549394,
-0.0569537133,
-0.0032670097,
-0.0364195518,
0.0334472805,
-0.0003655458,
0.0087939352,
0.0522218905,
0.0201451611,
-0.0078948596,
-0.0298789814,
0.0459894501,
-0.09939982,
0.0046932753,
-0.0251735989,
-0.0211327821,
0.0239283852,
0.0003407893,
-0.0549418442,
-0.0458946452,
0.0229982827,
0.0367782675,
0.0068734526,
0.0007925849,
-0.0661207959,
-0.0145044159,
-0.0187253449,
-0.0456648059,
0.0020210936,
-0.0464769751,
-0.001942326,
0.0313088335,
-0.0050741299,
0.006226596,
2.525070461e-34,
0.0228034817,
-0.0265583936,
-0.0128967352,
-0.0189781096,
0.0152470926,
0.001692291,
0.0324472822,
0.0059775962,
-0.0011368779,
-0.033626698,
-0.0379653014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03848v1 | Controlling Personality Style in Dialogue with Zero-Shot Prompt-Based Learning | 2023-02-08T02:45:21 | 2023-02-08T02:45:21 | Angela Ramirez, Mamon Alsalihy, Kartik Aggarwal, Cecilia Li, Liren Wu, Marilyn Walker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt-based or in-context learning has achieved high zero-shot performance
on many natural language generation (NLG) tasks. Here we explore the
performance of prompt-based learning for simultaneously controlling the
personality and the semantic accuracy of an NLG for task-oriented dialogue. We
experiment with prompt-based learning on the PERSONAGE restaurant
recommendation corpus to generate semantically and stylistically-controlled
text for 5 different Big-5 personality types: agreeable, disagreeable,
conscientious, unconscientious, and extravert. We test two different classes of
discrete prompts to generate utterances for a particular personality style: (1)
prompts that demonstrate generating directly from a meaning representation that
includes a personality specification; and (2) prompts that rely on first
converting the meaning representation to a textual pseudo-reference, and then
using the pseudo-reference in a textual style transfer (TST) prompt. In each
case, we show that we can vastly improve performance by over-generating outputs
and ranking them, testing several ranking functions based on automatic metrics
for semantic accuracy, personality-match, and fluency. We also test whether NLG
personality demonstrations from the restaurant domain can be used with meaning
representations for the video game domain to generate personality stylized
utterances about video games. Our findings show that the TST prompts produces
the highest semantic accuracy (78.46% for restaurants and 87.6% for video
games) and personality accuracy (100% for restaurants and 97% for video games).
Our results on transferring personality style to video game utterances are
surprisingly good. To our knowledge, there is no previous work testing the
application of prompt-based learning to simultaneously controlling both style
and semantic accuracy in NLG. | [
0.0434998646,
0.0238127317,
-0.0224958118,
-0.000299423,
-0.0135149704,
-0.0206093732,
0.0400920361,
-0.0187303443,
-0.0179392826,
-0.0389919318,
-0.0651746839,
-0.0048451121,
0.0053750682,
0.0172099452,
0.0280059688,
-0.059698604,
0.0380874686,
0.0129369088,
0.0456262715,
-0.0001735194,
0.0091013964,
0.0571104102,
-0.0201695338,
0.0442561544,
-0.0145514654,
-0.0153487902,
-0.0002592868,
0.0255004633,
0.026886791,
-0.0186431147,
0.0272299368,
0.0263101589,
0.0004946547,
-0.0195100885,
0.0000018396,
-0.0348413177,
-0.0077296146,
-0.0361313596,
0.03261647,
-0.0311359279,
0.0686275065,
0.0460095108,
-0.0123680066,
0.018970022,
-0.0356787778,
-0.0292672049,
0.0377740189,
0.059840221,
0.072561726,
0.0728934854,
0.0017410895,
-0.0366911553,
-0.0438372046,
-0.0159314256,
0.0342091918,
0.0056772907,
-0.0315638781,
-0.0684905201,
0.0136591699,
0.0295506716,
0.0073080319,
-0.0151754962,
-0.0327467285,
-0.0011959625,
0.0011878161,
0.0140477885,
-0.0318806395,
0.0105266878,
0.0135898227,
0.0759486184,
0.0223592911,
-0.0075375596,
0.0077405428,
-0.0044998294,
0.0296543632,
-0.0157825146,
0.0058666556,
0.0331273749,
-0.0111888293,
-0.013231067,
0.0000307207,
0.0270424988,
-0.0376540571,
-0.0176371783,
-0.0098903375,
0.0278166328,
0.0178234838,
-0.0114967981,
-0.0165238325,
-0.0021773528,
0.0026616473,
-0.0654802173,
-0.0194206238,
-0.0087684551,
-0.0609802417,
0.0331834443,
-0.0759053975,
0.0269732308,
0.0169379842,
0.0130061302,
0.0543302186,
0.0171601158,
-0.0064281356,
-0.0198880155,
0.0226364005,
0.0399503782,
0.0174429975,
0.0193446688,
-0.0441084355,
0.0205342863,
-0.0739954114,
-0.0124939252,
-0.0329745114,
0.018308891,
-0.0013710057,
-0.0163042359,
-0.0672916397,
0.0155907301,
-0.0128297023,
0.002427825,
-0.0093391091,
0.0354418494,
-0.0317846909,
0.0256537795,
-0.053029377,
0.0365096256,
-0.044536788,
-0.0107340002,
0.0212077387,
-0.0019349551,
0.0269129872,
0.0079678698,
0.0581844375,
-0.0300913043,
0.0207059607,
0.0273683704,
-0.0213491954,
-0.0413099378,
-0.0322543122,
-0.0581824183,
-0.0679606199,
-0.0612621382,
-0.0281397048,
-0.0450324751,
0.0115957698,
-0.0336831063,
-0.0139367236,
-0.0325652063,
0.0120511148,
0.0601541847,
0.0064298785,
0.0492167696,
-0.0045349994,
-0.0122343032,
0.0138398688,
0.0045583327,
-0.0196407493,
0.0119016841,
0.0222987868,
0.0151457358,
0.0078850538,
-0.0178776439,
-0.00386946,
0.0048207282,
0.0102430824,
-0.0190886147,
-0.0064904699,
-0.0312850364,
0.0351332463,
0.0439603366,
0.0416688249,
0.0623203851,
-0.0298210718,
-0.0016159582,
0.0929920822,
0.00806366,
0.0306121241,
0.0077478187,
0.0718865767,
0.0879403502,
-0.0093880966,
0.0311104972,
-0.014149691,
0.0083100684,
-0.0431144573,
0.0162286963,
-0.0121355429,
0.0033683188,
-0.0162362438,
-0.040071588,
0.0242214371,
-0.0077875727,
0.0222636014,
-0.0232243072,
-0.0339867137,
0.0464654826,
-0.0528627671,
-0.0027572869,
0.0172743239,
-0.0615548044,
-0.0018774234,
-0.0149204936,
0.0346960388,
0.1341449916,
0.0318334885,
0.0209923945,
-0.0263743699,
-0.0244726986,
-0.0321978927,
0.0424754024,
0.0279720332,
-0.0391885415,
0.0131279696,
-0.0459124707,
0.0281309728,
-0.0299156159,
-0.0117372414,
0.0381181985,
-0.0171941593,
0.0381151587,
0.0156033663,
0.0622154027,
0.015311989,
-0.0071670152,
-0.0217266176,
-0.0572735295,
0.0560621358,
0.0374804586,
-0.0165222548,
0.021044597,
-0.0249230787,
-0.0013616596,
-0.0229875371,
-0.0105505576,
-0.0162005629,
0.0687172413,
-0.053558372,
-0.0610761568,
-0.0106435437,
-0.021296097,
0.0013957255,
-0.0059377193,
-0.0059809592,
-0.0371804796,
-0.0214362647,
-0.0293126069,
0.002463239,
-0.0349710323,
0.0158697627,
0.0296910647,
0.0577842928,
-0.0276382659,
0.0537863225,
0.039106261,
-0.0107506989,
0.0619156919,
0.0388917811,
-0.0109882765,
-0.0659177452,
-0.0076052039,
-0.0122578135,
0.012891219,
0.0175930839,
0.0154636158,
0.0177254882,
-0.053811986,
-0.0427697115,
-0.0808708295,
0.0198025461,
0.0196189899,
-0.0168955568,
0.0284921899,
0.0077022682,
-0.0156372916,
0.0038714309,
-0.0628965795,
-0.0167195797,
0.0265515,
0.0075804335,
0.06646128,
0.0105963117,
-0.0181495864,
-0.0187415313,
0.0120726554,
-0.0317121074,
0.0339339599,
-0.0370463766,
0.0484483987,
-0.024724232,
0.006417118,
-0.0469653383,
-0.014206321,
0.0247138459,
-0.0341461524,
0.0505210087,
0.0046311831,
0.0353350192,
0.0511823893,
0.0748643428,
0.0034406858,
0.0181347635,
-0.0199354906,
-0.0219571292,
0.0038583882,
-0.0031946034,
-0.0052014547,
0.0089777121,
-0.0338386372,
0.0255669784,
0.0046138316,
0.0578111187,
0.0270032883,
-0.0852871835,
0.0621080473,
0.0515961796,
-0.048457969,
0.0339255966,
0.0325582325,
-0.0298901759,
0.0328039303,
0.0042539705,
0.0205274485,
0.0533205234,
-0.0193129834,
-0.0039536119,
-0.0103796702,
-0.0098082665,
-0.0139069613,
0.0434309393,
-0.0159850903,
0.0428840779,
0.0683848113,
-0.0341456681,
-0.0515137538,
-0.0374667384,
0.0289654359,
-0.0179112479,
0.0368979312,
-0.0277952235,
-0.0413758792,
0.0440890789,
-0.0266063623,
-0.0484684445,
-0.0773184523,
-0.0082485937,
-0.0073770341,
0.0371657759,
-0.0156175839,
-0.0053131264,
-0.0478870608,
-0.0064738044,
0.0130721116,
-0.0387688354,
-0.027933972,
-0.0118813701,
0.0267580915,
0.0635752976,
0.040430557,
-0.0312848911,
-0.0142156482,
0.0016191634,
0.0099451598,
-0.0658121482,
0.0258417912,
-0.0326809734,
0.0187366251,
-0.0045834575,
-0.0450114049,
-0.0276075825,
0.0350841582,
0.0273813773,
-0.0075196475,
-0.0146203237,
0.1175287887,
0.0390758887,
0.0082457997,
0.013835948,
0.0413096286,
0.0274267271,
0.0156034864,
0.05562355,
-0.0710970163,
-0.0383904204,
-0.0358804427,
0.04898417,
-0.0622200146,
-0.0206709914,
-0.0727785453,
-0.1321045011,
0.0278807413,
0.0115637816,
-0.049614951,
0.0123352194,
0.005966417,
-0.0102750231,
-0.0048591672,
-0.0081487801,
-0.0351503007,
-0.0053302436,
0.0171699189,
-0.0079169897,
-0.0166393984,
-0.0372280143,
0.0569272377,
-0.031095257,
0.0624069385,
0.0455583446,
0.0604899935,
0.0488783829,
-0.0247999299,
-0.0878528878,
-0.0024732142,
0.0445710272,
-0.00865479,
0.0720764771,
-0.0371284075,
0.0060337293,
-0.0509036221,
0.0257207528,
0.0113789337,
0.018006891,
0.0092817182,
0.0067208381,
-0.0191181619,
-0.0111682247,
-0.0250822194,
0.061006885,
0.0633560866,
0.0599840656,
0.0101998756,
-0.0812345445,
-0.0075843967,
-0.0062928409,
-0.0146034677,
-0.0499866679,
-0.0339462385,
-0.0100226365,
-0.0074491622,
-0.0114690252,
-0.0993973017,
-0.0436330773,
-0.0238754638,
0.0761511549,
-0.0017365632,
-0.0432635024,
-0.0348400623,
0.023124082,
-0.0030182835,
-0.04572374,
-0.0264755525,
0.0195291843,
-0.0479697771,
-0.0360729881,
0.0813654959,
-0.0719596073,
0.0066251149,
0.0244631711,
-0.0199194495,
-0.0663230717,
-0.0064561716,
0.0528423563,
0.0119773783,
0.0547609925,
0.0143608348,
-0.0395393446,
0.0501693711,
0.0687071979,
-0.0125592165,
0.028055653,
0.029237587,
0.0544328988,
-0.019872563,
0.0151878195,
-0.0139750559,
0.0427323729,
-0.0344080292,
0.001536531,
-0.0090426747,
-0.0910023302,
0.0299625434,
0.0306988321,
-0.0166597646,
-0.041976545,
-0.0099094976,
0.0022874491,
-0.0130352424,
-0.0547244288,
-0.0329006463,
-0.0164558794,
-0.0761836469,
0.0185571685,
0.0019531709,
-0.0143038668,
-0.0284134969,
-0.0592875853,
0.047800716,
-0.0540989935,
-0.0301489178,
0.0315857977,
0.0078956448,
-0.0287153665,
0.0185341332,
-0.0220134575,
0.0152022652,
0.0099820038,
0.0577750802,
-0.0282411668,
0.0568716824,
0.0135672707,
-0.0031458957,
-0.0304784663,
0.0464228541,
-0.0349469557,
0.0282138847,
0.0260277931,
0.0031974684,
0.0202587917,
-0.0178235881,
0.0365775861,
-0.0179309566,
0.031419456,
0.0003674436,
0.0591213889,
0.0189477559,
-0.0649044663,
0.0137672117,
-0.0022795987,
0.0003750687,
-0.0218854025,
0.0384704508,
-0.0224964116,
-0.015791541,
-0.0049234503,
-0.0129036428,
-0.0631906539,
0.0184657797,
-0.017283354,
0.0279489476,
0.0106345071,
-0.0274831336,
-0.079013966,
-0.0456027798,
0.0784158111,
0.0051927506,
0.03130202,
-0.0220622085,
0.051614169,
0.0166976377,
-0.0080507779,
-0.0162573978,
-0.0383009091,
0.0015189113,
-0.0064791557,
0.010748378,
-0.0338270888,
-5.259241071e-33,
-0.0581435785,
-0.0375974178,
0.0286813769,
0.0134598287,
-0.0212478209,
-0.0356219448,
-0.0330510102,
0.0104211289,
0.0216693338,
0.0015970262,
-0.0347721651,
-0.0477583185,
-0.0010645003,
0.0039685075,
-0.0026896847,
-0.0251049194,
0.0579412095,
-0.0003139653,
-0.0589506552,
0.0431509502,
0.0739858001,
0.0170373712,
0.0366462395,
-0.0598836616,
-0.0276857894,
-0.0097611314,
-0.0228436217,
-0.0290533639,
0.0624308176,
0.0340658538,
0.0395016335,
0.0672691688,
-0.0003601847,
-0.0440074727,
-0.0053279642,
0.0431560501,
-0.0389359742,
-0.0602600574,
0.0216179788,
-0.0011579365,
0.0191444978,
-0.0529039763,
-0.0135061005,
-0.0307662785,
-0.0146736773,
-0.0067416313,
0.0487251952,
0.0040583936,
0.0118736569,
-0.0165153816,
-0.0773459896,
-0.0149196489,
-0.0192872472,
-0.0602383874,
-0.0024084335,
0.0536432937,
-0.0011300227,
-0.0031146791,
-0.0385686494,
0.0573999323,
-0.0442294478,
-0.0124984728,
0.0175421201,
0.0428288355,
-0.0164027009,
0.054935813,
0.0478566103,
0.0645159185,
-0.0289527588,
-0.0019711568,
0.0278821066,
0.0457326509,
-0.0249444768,
0.0825828984,
0.0146884508,
-0.0288034901,
0.0061836741,
0.044067055,
0.0833481103,
-0.0739061832,
0.0055525419,
-0.0185521413,
-0.0416450799,
-0.0294856261,
-0.0156479292,
-0.0099518243,
-0.0203983486,
-0.0484357812,
0.0196677633,
-0.003261206,
-0.0330134444,
-0.0091199297,
0.0244769864,
-0.0121962493,
-0.0046378141,
0.0338945426,
-0.0869155154,
0.0081887916,
-0.0436907187,
-0.0343458131,
-0.0462470576,
-0.0143755097,
0.0670473427,
0.0379204005,
0.029973967,
0.0372281745,
0.0190765876,
0.0462005809,
-0.0536889471,
-0.0124175912,
0.0200403873,
0.0582614541,
-0.037726596,
-0.0139470985,
0.0043209391,
0.0090662977,
-0.0402835123,
0.0301936455,
-0.0019694353,
-0.0005391484,
-0.0131675266,
-0.005988765,
0.0322952271,
-0.0025785451,
-0.0369279906,
0.0207738299,
-0.0162739288,
-0.0204132274,
-0.0035621682,
-0.0476921238,
-0.0135968747,
-0.0029071337,
2.684e-7,
-0.0558829084,
0.0307063572,
-0.0078419186,
0.0575320423,
0.0045579989,
0.0540954694,
0.0391244367,
0.0417821072,
0.0294773802,
-0.029810803,
0.0300736725,
0.0028064449,
0.0279671606,
0.0155116068,
-0.0969491228,
0.0194436181,
-0.0052603744,
0.0657930151,
-0.0310425162,
0.0095241414,
0.1183705777,
0.0179371703,
0.0259791762,
-0.0115550961,
0.0407693572,
0.0427796952,
0.0454083644,
0.024575159,
-0.0163033325,
0.0015638109,
0.0100041293,
-0.0442608446,
-0.0227306932,
0.0341171138,
-0.0143900653,
-0.0178391468,
0.0034195471,
0.0469141416,
-0.0031848797,
-0.0386549868,
0.0080469288,
0.018579511,
-0.0283226669,
0.0012986477,
0.044670321,
-0.0264612529,
-0.033126466,
-0.0330371931,
-0.0450337231,
-0.0086739706,
-0.0097519662,
-0.0216009691,
-0.041671209,
0.0094849579,
0.0254402999,
0.0120723182,
0.0048334803,
-0.0543755665,
0.007474469,
0.0008891196,
-0.0206637084,
-0.0224359389,
-0.0019701079,
0.0103814304,
0.008981362,
-0.0572163425,
0.0277628098,
2.179283186e-34,
-0.015401897,
0.0287534837,
0.0288039409,
-0.0622650348,
0.0164370872,
0.0389308371,
0.0307350829,
-0.0047514238,
0.0720339939,
-0.0559006035,
-0.0272973143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03822v2 | Clinical BioBERT Hyperparameter Optimization using Genetic Algorithm | 2023-02-08T01:11:59 | 2023-02-13T03:55:10 | Navya Martin Kollapally, James Geller | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Clinical factors account only for a small portion, about 10-30%, of the
controllable factors that affect an individual's health outcomes. The remaining
factors include where a person was born and raised, where he/she pursued their
education, what their work and family environment is like, etc. These factors
are collectively referred to as Social Determinants of Health (SDoH). The
majority of SDoH data is recorded in unstructured clinical notes by physicians
and practitioners. Recording SDoH data in a structured manner (in an EHR) could
greatly benefit from a dedicated ontology of SDoH terms. Our research focuses
on extracting sentences from clinical notes, making use of such an SDoH
ontology (called SOHO) to provide appropriate concepts. We utilize recent
advancements in Deep Learning to optimize the hyperparameters of a Clinical
BioBERT model for SDoH text. A genetic algorithm-based hyperparameter tuning
regimen was implemented to identify optimal parameter settings. To implement a
complete classifier, we pipelined Clinical BioBERT with two subsequent linear
layers and two dropout layers. The output predicts whether a text fragment
describes an SDoH issue of the patient. We compared the AdamW, Adafactor, and
LAMB optimizers. In our experiments, AdamW outperformed the others in terms of
accuracy. | [
0.0237715803,
0.0966315717,
0.0064908373,
-0.0441447683,
-0.021620661,
0.0264434069,
0.0193106532,
0.0273566619,
0.0290567819,
-0.0241703894,
0.040599443,
-0.0233419575,
-0.023110047,
0.0601491518,
-0.0449108854,
-0.0193142071,
0.0202085823,
0.0386987329,
0.0504532233,
-0.0180782303,
-0.0549689867,
0.0111578349,
-0.0109363338,
0.0465431251,
-0.008360168,
0.022433171,
0.0577430353,
-0.0049389577,
0.0473675244,
-0.0351431593,
0.0088431798,
0.0306651331,
-0.0456349701,
-0.0029290789,
0.0000023337,
-0.0508255512,
-0.0484218486,
0.0084641241,
-0.0349234268,
-0.0637401193,
0.0439032726,
-0.0295877811,
0.0016919295,
0.011737681,
-0.0234512985,
-0.0147463903,
-0.0059253615,
0.0770613924,
0.0002600107,
0.0514804386,
-0.0252620727,
-0.0282526333,
0.049333185,
-0.0109670972,
0.0339341052,
-0.0046124272,
0.0481053665,
-0.0073410207,
-0.0065111453,
-0.0123374313,
0.0237092339,
0.0308580995,
-0.0155059341,
0.0392981321,
0.0412721001,
-0.0117663294,
-0.0310258083,
-0.0052523157,
0.0201875288,
0.0693200678,
0.0221635588,
0.0080052642,
0.0489016064,
-0.0289306063,
0.0349679627,
0.0182890389,
0.0144946165,
-0.0313586853,
-0.0373934545,
0.0112234289,
0.0319551043,
0.0090716025,
0.0041081696,
-0.0305273514,
0.0132550765,
0.0630959421,
-0.0190998185,
-0.0055752336,
0.010452616,
-0.0305813439,
-0.0183288362,
-0.0254071727,
0.0710971355,
0.0220221877,
-0.0181532688,
0.0099210227,
-0.0175778288,
-0.0606421046,
0.0599511154,
-0.0639581531,
0.0137206968,
0.0129526993,
-0.0109166456,
-0.0054296614,
0.0129587138,
0.004824549,
-0.0302110519,
0.0006316387,
-0.0212614331,
0.0019168137,
-0.0971357822,
0.000536664,
-0.0170602798,
0.0671488494,
0.0197513457,
-0.01822857,
-0.0743869469,
-0.0173721015,
-0.003238627,
-0.032258004,
0.0375262685,
0.0635999516,
0.0123010036,
0.0381273627,
-0.0090049524,
-0.0261682048,
-0.0089674005,
-0.0104981158,
-0.0341456607,
0.0075263204,
0.0774402991,
0.0025501414,
0.0704880729,
0.0019238105,
0.0212702826,
0.080263041,
0.0554640368,
-0.0097708981,
-0.0190550331,
-0.0456219316,
-0.0362684205,
0.0197949782,
-0.0037866496,
-0.0287300032,
0.0065087099,
-0.0081642186,
-0.0258164518,
-0.1003580764,
0.0130292019,
-0.0349211246,
-0.0577888452,
-0.0075224494,
-0.0305323582,
-0.0272002351,
0.0657977089,
0.0110701285,
-0.0098490082,
0.0218679663,
0.0386562273,
-0.0289781597,
0.0261626057,
-0.038071461,
0.0119467843,
-0.011820334,
0.0088522276,
-0.0697791055,
0.0085211983,
-0.0200723968,
-0.019278964,
0.0777248144,
-0.0245711412,
0.021909032,
-0.0098606199,
0.0132689141,
0.0316767283,
0.0576051027,
0.0656205714,
0.0604119077,
0.0144720506,
0.0212187357,
-0.0230920799,
-0.0372931547,
-0.0037817352,
-0.0125545412,
0.0164106265,
-0.0206031259,
-0.0339819454,
-0.0084316041,
-0.0134326927,
-0.0691928491,
-0.0213689394,
0.0096697388,
-0.0423824713,
-0.0232547354,
0.0274929963,
-0.0356067047,
-0.0278424677,
0.0865356177,
0.0382853858,
-0.010723236,
-0.0294008404,
-0.0344966538,
-0.0148009509,
0.0724472553,
0.0307520404,
-0.0670023859,
-0.0363120362,
-0.0234719068,
-0.0221379679,
-0.0048853112,
0.0038967754,
-0.0035329091,
0.0180923492,
-0.0268280581,
-0.0202574059,
0.0257759448,
0.0365580693,
-0.0156612378,
-0.0239734221,
0.0556281134,
0.0143652558,
0.0222481824,
-0.0507737584,
0.0340660736,
-0.0364343934,
-0.0172052123,
0.016916329,
-0.004983318,
0.0471536852,
0.0372237973,
0.007974701,
0.0187797658,
-0.004964747,
-0.0443600193,
-0.0632801503,
-0.0243362449,
-0.0422771759,
-0.0239135399,
-0.012642106,
-0.0450618602,
0.0529959835,
0.0088433549,
-0.0085964408,
-0.0237546172,
-0.0002843894,
-0.0357809439,
0.0446750075,
-0.0020615293,
0.006194395,
0.0148701761,
0.0292856786,
-0.0402892977,
0.0415923558,
-0.0015725777,
-0.0398543961,
-0.0379596725,
-0.0790678039,
0.0137281055,
-0.0347437374,
0.0656126961,
-0.0255601425,
-0.0342881344,
-0.0186115466,
0.0100093931,
0.0317398161,
-0.0027576492,
-0.0167876668,
-0.0980653018,
0.0046978304,
0.0001011349,
0.0158540681,
-0.0032824434,
-0.0183274057,
-0.0006546968,
-0.0053599295,
-0.0553140715,
0.047744479,
0.013191971,
-0.0371241793,
0.0606282912,
0.0006445145,
-0.0002211235,
-0.0266231876,
-0.0071642608,
-0.058122959,
0.0333745517,
0.012878512,
0.0146576753,
0.0136109116,
-0.0305168815,
-0.062280748,
-0.0145962033,
0.0214874409,
-0.0131976567,
-0.0321999192,
0.0040375874,
-0.0080084167,
0.0693576485,
-0.016016636,
0.0155486725,
-0.0035085655,
0.0670215935,
0.0028283116,
0.0106322467,
-0.0606523119,
0.075584121,
-0.0020778934,
-0.045587521,
0.0103792166,
0.0676883012,
0.0079712272,
-0.0315088071,
-0.0447568409,
0.0342329852,
-0.0260475427,
0.0449963063,
-0.0410076827,
0.0009968241,
-0.019727312,
0.0233220663,
-0.0001804731,
-0.0200159252,
0.072085999,
0.0305355173,
0.0662458539,
-0.0660417676,
-0.0231791195,
-0.0639151782,
-0.003525299,
0.0032525582,
0.0182266068,
0.0178125259,
-0.00556099,
0.0315346681,
0.0228654947,
0.0239006318,
-0.0363829844,
0.0205043685,
-0.035970632,
0.0202112217,
0.0236788578,
-0.0491300188,
-0.0173532218,
0.0015409734,
-0.0124800755,
0.0343028978,
0.0317710452,
-0.0001017608,
-0.0371076688,
-0.0037579166,
-0.0310829934,
0.1135367081,
-0.0089793457,
0.0014792953,
-0.0236349814,
0.0130025512,
0.056554921,
-0.0400077775,
0.0038641507,
0.0221743006,
0.0259732939,
-0.012025076,
-0.0396949127,
0.0031098025,
0.0106069027,
0.0337499455,
-0.0172195267,
-0.0394336693,
-0.0268206429,
0.0173389371,
-0.0014214683,
-0.0420663841,
0.0181901548,
0.0944697559,
0.0323007666,
-0.0211205818,
0.0356603265,
-0.0174695961,
-0.0334200375,
-0.0230123475,
0.0075689745,
-0.0474998988,
-0.0289910547,
-0.0146435304,
0.0247784853,
-0.0267249066,
-0.048239693,
0.0457941182,
0.015836129,
0.0192590132,
-0.0151412049,
-0.0604530275,
0.0192718413,
-0.0300408583,
-0.0226058029,
-0.067444481,
-0.0420782976,
-0.0568163395,
0.0018047108,
-0.0131328637,
0.0108868824,
-0.0863801837,
-0.0647005215,
0.0172640197,
0.0101403622,
0.0284185279,
0.0202833991,
0.0490005203,
0.0017222227,
-0.0248914324,
0.0185363144,
0.0209822357,
-0.002538336,
-0.0280241407,
0.0886433125,
-0.0148605919,
0.0060563344,
-0.0719694793,
0.072986193,
-0.0537613481,
0.0027563761,
-0.0191874262,
0.0571476258,
-0.0303821005,
-0.0656995997,
-0.0419018753,
0.0202361438,
0.0223358721,
0.0528894812,
-0.0344517455,
-0.0350078978,
-0.0205133613,
0.0212372616,
0.0169325564,
-0.0536839776,
0.0150308041,
0.024124369,
-0.0596579462,
-0.0360909775,
-0.0450064391,
-0.0145878326,
0.0091146706,
0.0165766459,
0.0199913234,
-0.0019174204,
0.0390315428,
-0.0054162298,
-0.0843045861,
0.0472267866,
0.0220420156,
-0.024775384,
-0.0065096868,
-0.0477688015,
0.1021080911,
-0.0245409552,
-0.0289212782,
0.002386864,
0.0141279865,
-0.0073385513,
0.0064681801,
0.0389495455,
0.0212234035,
0.0067144372,
0.0087930588,
-0.0469010435,
0.0550534204,
0.0002596919,
-0.0294990875,
-0.0583524182,
0.0022779179,
0.0173795,
-0.0483106375,
0.0266754422,
0.0103346286,
0.0446523689,
0.0165876299,
0.0018290842,
-0.0186481811,
-0.0216596927,
-0.0190988556,
0.026088316,
0.0120906597,
-0.0236435235,
-0.0681948066,
-0.0454709157,
0.0232585724,
-0.0038315067,
0.0434933305,
-0.0235384312,
0.0283306353,
0.024708949,
0.0023625959,
-0.0253186356,
-0.0152927823,
-0.02309989,
-0.0441864729,
-0.0699046105,
0.0912014842,
-0.0095450059,
0.0440551303,
0.0173465665,
-0.0143497707,
-0.0005265175,
0.0371527784,
0.0198568068,
0.0225163959,
-0.0331324078,
0.0690882578,
-0.0007968363,
0.0576988608,
-0.0273218174,
0.0153462188,
-0.0453305542,
0.0059776492,
-0.0471889712,
0.0139465462,
0.0393569432,
-0.0038029882,
0.0228961054,
-0.0216628183,
-0.0250998084,
0.0013830154,
0.0165761523,
-0.0424912609,
0.0350227766,
-0.0073975236,
-0.014124535,
-0.0304165091,
-0.0019560696,
0.0607943535,
0.076215826,
0.0228608493,
-0.010629572,
-0.032728985,
-0.0609166436,
0.0159419291,
0.1019626036,
0.0195717793,
-0.0877970532,
-0.0210473891,
-0.0413460918,
-0.0317565948,
0.0722468942,
-0.019968003,
-0.0155906854,
0.0044720494,
0.0560177863,
-0.0110676158,
-0.0285422187,
-0.072263658,
-0.0180965289,
0.0182494726,
-0.0670971423,
0.0018019088,
0.027756365,
-6.701450682e-33,
-0.0008185495,
-0.0333982781,
0.0046685762,
0.0299114231,
-0.0296981446,
0.0236321408,
-0.0191004183,
-0.0071119354,
0.0075095473,
0.0247996859,
0.0080057578,
-0.0046899952,
0.0050834431,
0.0479042307,
0.0227889549,
-0.0517498665,
0.0103811389,
-0.0097866682,
-0.0042295782,
0.0179743152,
-0.0095550399,
0.083965309,
0.0075084688,
-0.0574225001,
0.004290327,
0.0198335294,
0.045712065,
0.0163077768,
-0.0001801973,
0.0432759374,
-0.037135791,
0.0437175855,
0.0342495702,
-0.0342981927,
0.0300490968,
0.0114673153,
-0.0742302909,
-0.0684698373,
-0.0129151773,
-0.0316167548,
-0.037330091,
-0.0699670017,
0.0643818006,
0.036535386,
-0.0492505096,
-0.0013370867,
0.0464016125,
-0.0243489109,
-0.0242789071,
-0.0905241743,
-0.0339008868,
0.033228077,
-0.0029512034,
0.0373050347,
-0.0006207906,
-0.0169709716,
-0.0205777306,
0.0087160505,
0.0049997079,
-0.0287111457,
0.0205310229,
-0.0081091383,
-0.0114185009,
-0.0134876855,
0.0040182252,
0.0308770668,
0.0175832547,
0.0045197131,
-0.0227296259,
-0.0114379637,
0.0001387836,
0.0208643526,
0.0327812284,
0.0095812771,
0.015892487,
-0.0561352894,
-0.1044301391,
0.0261689723,
-0.0320048109,
-0.0361471251,
0.0001265229,
-0.0171847474,
-0.0002651859,
0.0004035326,
-0.0359474383,
-0.0078670718,
-0.0179476961,
-0.0080170175,
0.0040353877,
0.0094759744,
-0.0089109764,
0.0394979566,
-0.0073787938,
-0.0298557878,
0.0298857708,
-0.0125992764,
0.0366254039,
-0.0039117066,
-0.0108239576,
-0.0075184181,
-0.0368214175,
-0.0316488072,
-0.0040179854,
-0.0048828106,
0.0749993101,
0.0132990237,
0.0331124999,
-0.0400368646,
-0.0209483765,
0.0056291432,
0.0501257516,
-0.0023618385,
0.0154573871,
0.0887027383,
-0.0017195102,
0.0049681589,
0.0266256705,
0.0463429466,
0.0556171387,
0.0359779634,
-0.0448086709,
0.0141791468,
0.0381244943,
-0.0053517856,
-0.0377363861,
-0.012573895,
-0.0083438233,
0.0141171375,
-0.0084940363,
-0.0629192293,
-0.0026702911,
-0.0166250318,
3.139e-7,
0.0603392906,
0.0914165378,
-0.0031223905,
-0.088818118,
0.0506415293,
-0.0111125922,
0.0422783569,
-0.0024758354,
-0.028074,
-0.0018399179,
0.0858288258,
0.0055986461,
0.0322074294,
0.019204028,
-0.0643729046,
-0.0508693494,
-0.0063085598,
-0.038218461,
-0.021400461,
0.0283271428,
0.0545619316,
0.0702375546,
-0.0352335088,
-0.0255694371,
0.0253735743,
0.0526652634,
-0.0084358826,
-0.0059725018,
0.0261030197,
0.0720361024,
-0.0153206857,
-0.0106426673,
-0.0312602893,
0.075766407,
-0.0037784416,
0.0050725467,
-0.000565727,
0.0926866308,
-0.0640624464,
-0.0242336057,
0.0283782165,
0.0163656306,
0.0340439118,
-0.0329395756,
0.0505249798,
-0.0112350909,
-0.0774925724,
0.000526572,
-0.004686167,
-0.0266992431,
0.046982225,
-0.0130522102,
0.033117976,
0.0103800166,
0.0245291386,
0.0057638451,
0.0006407434,
-0.0437769815,
0.0057788529,
0.0649390519,
-0.0316278338,
-0.0310940389,
0.0177322328,
0.0119061312,
0.0639220104,
-0.0658010021,
0.0267643072,
3.018751456e-34,
0.0341265835,
0.0336199477,
0.0007619996,
-0.0519142076,
0.0223792959,
0.008360005,
-0.0214155745,
0.0195529032,
0.0094226645,
-0.0604865067,
0.0017881674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03815v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03815v1 | Long Text and Multi-Table Summarization: Dataset and Method | 2023-02-08T00:46:55 | 2023-02-08T00:46:55 | Shuaiqi Liu, Jiannong Cao, Ruosong Yang, Zhiyuan Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.7 | Automatic document summarization aims to produce a concise summary covering
the input document's salient information. Within a report document, the salient
information can be scattered in the textual and non-textual content. However,
existing document summarization datasets and methods usually focus on the text
and filter out the non-textual content. Missing tabular data can limit produced
summaries' informativeness, especially when summaries require covering
quantitative descriptions of critical metrics in tables. Existing datasets and
methods cannot meet the requirements of summarizing long text and multiple
tables in each report. To deal with the scarcity of available data, we propose
FINDSum, the first large-scale dataset for long text and multi-table
summarization. Built on 21,125 annual reports from 3,794 companies, it has two
subsets for summarizing each company's results of operations and liquidity. To
summarize the long text and dozens of tables in each report, we present three
types of summarization methods. Besides, we propose a set of evaluation metrics
to assess the usage of numerical information in produced summaries. Dataset
analyses and experimental results indicate the importance of jointly
considering input textual and tabular data when summarizing report documents. | [
-0.0119385822,
0.0158420373,
0.016123075,
-0.0224926341,
-0.0138611523,
0.030329803,
-0.037289381,
0.0299525559,
-0.0269186124,
-0.0380343944,
-0.012596651,
0.0219356325,
0.0405080058,
-0.0087696016,
0.0085110934,
-0.0342201144,
0.021438444,
0.0352236032,
-0.0373355448,
0.0393839441,
0.0509723648,
-0.0034634352,
0.0179410018,
-0.003658453,
0.012721898,
0.0359910168,
0.0178798232,
-0.0264534671,
0.0165419821,
0.0094831083,
-0.0160957128,
0.0074389046,
0.019013321,
0.0079666134,
0.0000019106,
-0.0191218033,
-0.0655627623,
0.0110640656,
0.0186326988,
0.0615751818,
0.0622952171,
-0.0849611014,
0.0352691822,
0.0089441184,
-0.0189780071,
0.0178820007,
-0.020759996,
0.0431241468,
0.0509498715,
0.025424052,
-0.0138140582,
-0.0424711145,
-0.0319386348,
-0.0084935306,
-0.003577343,
-0.0360047892,
-0.0247074682,
0.0559749641,
0.0001771356,
-0.0605407059,
0.005656546,
0.0461051464,
0.0010764132,
-0.0326953977,
-0.0063993991,
0.0261006691,
-0.0694426298,
0.0060543776,
0.0218655597,
0.0624376498,
0.0101897139,
0.0144719165,
0.0348757803,
-0.0045920555,
0.0203683209,
-0.0267425813,
-0.063431792,
0.0406052731,
-0.0315901265,
0.0009191026,
-0.0170179401,
0.0352220461,
-0.0548697598,
0.0238780342,
-0.0213815011,
-0.0096317744,
-0.0306487493,
-0.0254155062,
0.0082973829,
-0.0019922608,
-0.0009885416,
-0.025714526,
0.0114446497,
0.025687702,
0.0182109065,
-0.0171898175,
-0.0283417311,
-0.0841185823,
0.0588080175,
-0.0646487996,
0.0039016912,
-0.0015758002,
0.0158121716,
0.063022472,
-0.044491224,
-0.0036615185,
0.0289989728,
-0.0167663749,
-0.0221332945,
-0.0043894146,
-0.0131337475,
0.0240656715,
-0.0082418974,
0.0638587847,
-0.0552908145,
-0.0151978359,
-0.017103564,
-0.0007290533,
-0.0099895084,
0.0395394377,
0.0174718108,
-0.001897393,
0.0298251472,
-0.0109686423,
-0.0204072446,
0.000009303,
-0.0344239324,
-0.0130887683,
-0.0036866537,
0.0009733757,
0.0027071245,
0.0001138579,
0.0507188924,
0.0326109715,
0.035632018,
0.022597529,
-0.0354220569,
-0.0187277365,
-0.0527328216,
-0.037489377,
0.0024813795,
-0.0416862369,
-0.035817299,
-0.027357839,
0.0219225492,
-0.0002987849,
-0.0314856879,
-0.0076497127,
0.0138309682,
0.0128899142,
-0.0173586551,
0.0021876767,
-0.0117273321,
0.0124939559,
0.0262926538,
-0.0369761251,
0.0253893305,
0.046478577,
0.0439173169,
0.0391189158,
0.0187533516,
0.0173358005,
-0.0009077606,
0.0253033619,
0.0197201781,
-0.0000086192,
0.0369152389,
0.0367270373,
-0.0302024931,
-0.028527664,
-0.0017206195,
-0.0079745911,
-0.0135651976,
0.0610382557,
0.0590410605,
0.0357800201,
0.007149606,
0.0537696667,
-0.0070994422,
0.0253181867,
0.0607667118,
0.0168139748,
0.0441105403,
0.0380950794,
-0.0120927598,
0.0894330814,
0.1059810743,
0.0134859607,
-0.020356182,
-0.0626622438,
0.020383684,
0.0348501168,
0.0013522401,
0.0243188385,
0.0359347984,
0.0193402804,
-0.0606571324,
-0.0096610235,
-0.0108102681,
-0.077407822,
0.0045672096,
0.0167927742,
0.0420605801,
0.0326169096,
0.0387399383,
-0.0895258337,
0.0460113175,
-0.0196160469,
0.0359839238,
-0.0031278916,
0.0455602892,
-0.0122612007,
-0.0155395633,
-0.0282435101,
-0.0168523751,
0.0311954487,
0.0229569599,
-0.027604565,
-0.0262506232,
-0.0140110385,
0.0402292684,
-0.0247980114,
-0.0879978016,
0.0327650458,
0.0369853973,
0.0197295658,
-0.0084089711,
-0.0158837531,
0.0039308676,
0.0552488491,
-0.0083307493,
0.0264338534,
0.0150682842,
0.0177899767,
0.0233921278,
-0.0106993113,
0.0345832184,
0.0263434108,
-0.0062791696,
-0.0408591218,
-0.0255563725,
-0.0050179372,
-0.0180442538,
-0.0428477228,
0.0091069173,
-0.0723874196,
-0.0399407297,
-0.0173250251,
0.0250136387,
-0.0086227749,
0.0307879038,
0.0207549501,
0.0778135657,
0.0177939795,
0.0108351549,
0.0136331702,
-0.0867011994,
0.0101679042,
-0.0356175303,
0.0353958569,
-0.0380564816,
-0.0312927663,
0.0184570346,
0.0622708909,
-0.0014171951,
-0.0503191762,
-0.0219848827,
-0.1028475463,
0.016817648,
-0.0238282792,
0.0072406447,
0.0642435551,
0.0206421446,
-0.0294641238,
-0.0028639378,
-0.0041126432,
-0.0682988092,
-0.0048719011,
-0.0274679959,
0.070229508,
0.0111454111,
0.0280092619,
-0.0601137131,
-0.0244455822,
-0.0056299092,
0.0225358326,
0.040326912,
-0.0575191379,
-0.0081883483,
0.0339016877,
0.0027055806,
-0.0379830673,
0.0355440117,
0.0118877441,
-0.0349453315,
-0.002076311,
0.0382968448,
0.0645373538,
0.0444557182,
0.0201106369,
0.0143970223,
-0.0080335727,
-0.0163790509,
-0.0227819253,
-0.033381585,
0.0455898754,
0.0569777749,
-0.0681709573,
0.0681809261,
-0.0186213627,
0.0139137013,
-0.005089296,
-0.0267597213,
-0.0018939838,
-0.0253234208,
0.0026815373,
-0.060295593,
0.0458389595,
0.0069493507,
0.0416116193,
0.0081893923,
0.0154121323,
-0.0113551598,
-0.0177868474,
0.0228439253,
-0.0372323245,
0.012523395,
-0.0615806989,
0.0429803431,
-0.0101418877,
0.0073024603,
-0.0351746008,
-0.0190104563,
0.0074620461,
-0.0263338834,
0.0697223544,
-0.0160904787,
0.0934624523,
-0.0508663952,
0.0278687757,
-0.0382152051,
0.0152534414,
0.0346436091,
-0.044602517,
0.0160407275,
0.0114882989,
0.0633110255,
-0.0004463234,
-0.0972338095,
-0.0057991366,
0.0786693245,
0.0769100785,
-0.0176362041,
-0.0442449413,
-0.0187455192,
0.0295055564,
0.0359633565,
-0.0345305428,
0.0121921608,
-0.0375848934,
0.026775917,
0.032961946,
0.0089591611,
-0.0108602643,
0.0357208624,
-0.0176152941,
-0.0670920163,
-0.0623336323,
0.0458017811,
0.0023220934,
-0.0263305698,
-0.0234160814,
0.0157625005,
0.0490803942,
0.0201356951,
0.0052440655,
-0.049979426,
0.0049249125,
0.0021104142,
-0.0043906365,
0.0115291467,
-0.0353812613,
0.0141842207,
-0.0183093268,
0.0129442224,
0.0104114972,
-0.0452373549,
-0.0273789335,
-0.0591084026,
0.0286239758,
0.0010015958,
-0.0765979439,
-0.1043837294,
-0.0462741256,
0.0040588435,
-0.0432119109,
0.0033268675,
0.0501134619,
-0.0425958075,
-0.0047078989,
0.0182134435,
-0.1241529733,
0.0143667497,
-0.0483985506,
-0.0231167693,
-0.0628281608,
0.0385711081,
0.0485530272,
-0.0246366113,
0.0524784215,
-0.0003741187,
0.0021706996,
-0.0230179876,
0.0005274664,
0.1151846945,
-0.0070486972,
0.0028147036,
-0.0131715843,
0.0593874566,
0.0168015826,
0.0567544103,
0.0636354163,
-0.0177154932,
0.0039368542,
-0.0167839061,
-0.0026121368,
0.0619668178,
-0.0480353273,
0.0167190768,
0.0522733927,
0.0228601117,
-0.0206175596,
-0.0119289644,
-0.053002201,
-0.08192911,
0.0174954515,
0.0049048271,
-0.073114872,
-0.020867344,
-0.0687252581,
-0.0508109629,
0.066693455,
-0.002989176,
0.0160398949,
0.0232753418,
-0.0412287712,
0.0295713749,
-0.0313325115,
-0.0191401206,
-0.0357434377,
0.0131300762,
-0.0106547391,
-0.0178018399,
0.019407602,
-0.0095822802,
-0.0241640117,
0.0221402701,
-0.0431571826,
-0.0077847624,
-0.0375599116,
-0.0117975296,
0.0220859759,
0.0221819468,
0.0074028387,
0.0391630419,
0.0461264625,
0.0026433002,
-0.0656096265,
-0.0219387487,
-0.016635932,
0.0071100155,
-0.0064823343,
-0.0111967819,
-0.045525115,
-0.000775217,
-0.0433572121,
0.0312343948,
-0.0023859774,
0.0229128245,
0.0241298713,
0.0495189242,
-0.0331373923,
0.0135009177,
-0.0361566208,
-0.0221603941,
-0.0021743753,
-0.0542807057,
-0.0270887334,
0.0017208363,
0.0731856227,
-0.0027150228,
0.0301622432,
-0.0278021246,
0.0946703553,
0.0081939921,
-0.0015488414,
-0.022222707,
0.0156942252,
-0.0106327329,
-0.0334764756,
-0.0433486179,
-0.0361384414,
-0.0422527269,
-0.0799952745,
-0.0348653831,
-0.0041938033,
0.0256094504,
-0.0112931589,
0.0375911854,
0.0019964874,
-0.016603075,
0.0572795421,
-0.0494248942,
0.0328641757,
-0.0529128611,
0.0111886738,
0.0101183159,
-0.0248132534,
0.0453259386,
-0.0318734497,
-0.0057412446,
0.0161930155,
0.0667759702,
0.0481705442,
0.0244722161,
-0.0591319278,
0.0061157639,
-0.0007593999,
-0.005618115,
0.081792675,
0.0005962675,
-0.0337587968,
-0.0165475998,
-0.0279569905,
-0.0672008842,
-0.0216564611,
0.009929793,
-0.0082606226,
-0.0055133863,
-0.067630522,
-0.0690845326,
0.0072842808,
0.0289810076,
0.0577681847,
-0.0071140891,
0.002693732,
-0.0044829384,
0.0309886541,
0.0421117619,
0.0182431769,
-0.0638542846,
-0.0002722087,
-0.020870382,
0.0024241796,
-0.0306742154,
-5.332029886e-33,
-0.0258454327,
0.0054522012,
-0.0425377116,
0.0007933702,
-0.02210439,
0.002946028,
-0.0312759839,
-0.0401691608,
0.0263739582,
0.0085922182,
-0.0404860079,
0.0362998694,
0.028228702,
-0.0113349594,
0.0163315404,
-0.0218934547,
0.0011601292,
-0.0211386643,
-0.046372015,
0.0214330684,
0.0071355212,
-0.0084785288,
0.0184732359,
-0.0136424266,
0.0536663122,
0.0201381836,
-0.0215623807,
-0.061147023,
0.0648303404,
-0.0187149607,
0.0041573495,
-0.0305028018,
0.0268818252,
-0.0547799207,
-0.06635914,
0.0244028997,
-0.0852591246,
-0.0092681563,
0.0286002923,
-0.0144628575,
-0.0034169834,
-0.0004014008,
0.0234513134,
-0.0297951009,
0.0114292931,
-0.0499808192,
0.0628013611,
-0.0437111482,
-0.0243242979,
-0.0981329083,
0.0015918943,
0.0479130745,
-0.0309644341,
0.0289423764,
0.064133808,
0.064533852,
-0.0129588498,
-0.0277748574,
0.020208247,
0.020899538,
0.0306227133,
0.0182987712,
0.0319255814,
-0.0145892892,
0.0562931895,
0.0091470955,
-0.0138033777,
0.0280451942,
-0.0187659208,
0.0181149412,
-0.0216649082,
0.0000942163,
0.0435811989,
0.0024422719,
0.0281896275,
0.0095137637,
-0.0344916582,
0.1138388366,
-0.019137511,
-0.0160042457,
0.0173691511,
-0.0404767357,
0.0008323124,
0.0018180028,
0.005280823,
0.0340490527,
-0.0104633905,
0.0238084644,
-0.0185407139,
0.0133924959,
-0.0253569447,
-0.0200131293,
-0.006409796,
0.0054729641,
0.0021231675,
0.0093334047,
0.0088691637,
0.0444057062,
-0.000443102,
-0.0931933075,
0.0026459335,
0.0040038247,
0.0137617961,
0.0313419588,
-0.0019253287,
-0.0134152025,
0.050049521,
-0.0017116332,
-0.0097757298,
0.0083213802,
0.017305756,
0.0269169491,
-0.0009085236,
-0.0195501596,
-0.0364350043,
0.0145662557,
0.0016554972,
-0.0044393986,
0.0137545466,
0.0129701067,
0.0104228891,
0.0026075458,
0.0101931468,
0.0278535839,
0.0192301907,
0.0096715475,
-0.024724517,
-0.0095974822,
0.0656344891,
0.0136618642,
-0.0088418974,
-0.0023808514,
2.335e-7,
0.057989113,
0.0080917291,
0.081902422,
0.0002648916,
-0.0259373225,
-0.0182587262,
0.0007652057,
0.0311434232,
-0.0201857947,
-0.0063044769,
0.0916003212,
-0.0301807765,
0.0635632798,
0.0290932395,
-0.0498781465,
-0.0890825018,
-0.0555538274,
-0.0772899017,
-0.0550428145,
-0.0200241543,
0.0086821839,
0.0430879928,
-0.0275073536,
0.0096614156,
-0.002305896,
-0.0377399586,
0.0091065885,
-0.0624757633,
0.0103133935,
0.0231422503,
0.1090361997,
-0.0319624357,
-0.0457034148,
0.0079478947,
-0.0389649905,
-0.0010243071,
0.0617266335,
0.0260328501,
0.0325742327,
0.0366967544,
-0.0123804612,
-0.064741239,
0.0167434402,
0.0134378411,
0.0442378633,
-0.0462656803,
-0.0113308094,
0.0312618092,
-0.0219155736,
0.0575046241,
-0.0206234735,
0.0187030695,
-0.0183015559,
0.0863899216,
-0.0161285382,
-0.0118138567,
0.0387278646,
-0.041926641,
-0.0282792225,
0.0450799726,
0.0077569182,
-0.0063938675,
0.0233217608,
-0.0011726159,
-0.0032489481,
-0.0462895632,
-0.0291327275,
2.137202554e-34,
0.0706371441,
-0.0268142223,
-0.0256876368,
-0.024230374,
0.0766514465,
-0.0635225028,
-0.0200774372,
0.0137394797,
-0.0064061554,
-0.0826972276,
0.010594869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03780v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03780v3 | Reliable Natural Language Understanding with Large Language Models and Answer Set Programming | 2023-02-07T22:37:21 | 2023-08-30T08:56:37 | Abhiramon Rajasekharan, Yankai Zeng, Parth Padalkar, Gopal Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Humans understand language by extracting information (meaning) from
sentences, combining it with existing commonsense knowledge, and then
performing reasoning to draw conclusions. While large language models (LLMs)
such as GPT-3 and ChatGPT are able to leverage patterns in the text to solve a
variety of NLP tasks, they fall short in problems that require reasoning. They
also cannot reliably explain the answers generated for a given question. In
order to emulate humans better, we propose STAR, a framework that combines LLMs
with Answer Set Programming (ASP). We show how LLMs can be used to effectively
extract knowledge -- represented as predicates -- from language. Goal-directed
ASP is then employed to reliably reason over this knowledge. We apply the STAR
framework to three different NLU tasks requiring reasoning: qualitative
reasoning, mathematical reasoning, and goal-directed conversation. Our
experiments reveal that STAR is able to bridge the gap of reasoning in NLU
tasks, leading to significant performance improvements, especially for smaller
LLMs, i.e., LLMs with a smaller number of parameters. NLU applications
developed using the STAR framework are also explainable: along with the
predicates generated, a justification in the form of a proof tree can be
produced for a given output. | [
0.0329163894,
0.0704097748,
0.0089266812,
0.0427573249,
-0.0330539569,
0.0193881206,
-0.0181521885,
-0.0145334089,
0.0104733463,
-0.0308080278,
0.0411196873,
0.0187685937,
-0.0126209464,
0.0256163161,
-0.0171099808,
-0.0312547348,
0.03966875,
-0.0466416441,
0.0501565784,
0.0030845192,
0.029333869,
0.0682367757,
0.0001264386,
0.023297593,
-0.0201529674,
-0.0257156584,
-0.0137557769,
-0.0254222285,
-0.0176123325,
-0.011810313,
-0.0192690343,
0.0102915457,
0.0454622172,
-0.0218264852,
0.0000021729,
-0.0491717756,
-0.0226652231,
0.012935441,
-0.0531893149,
-0.0104316222,
-0.0265815463,
0.0191480815,
0.0292470455,
0.036913801,
-0.0494075045,
0.0082709137,
0.0220355298,
0.0738353059,
0.0874992982,
0.0573379993,
-0.0042079734,
-0.0684913099,
-0.0015745409,
0.0219694767,
0.0593166724,
-0.072203882,
0.026644811,
0.0385797843,
0.0523593128,
-0.0234283805,
0.0093300026,
0.0218952373,
0.0385559276,
-0.0335431919,
-0.0144005688,
0.0208117589,
-0.0284539815,
-0.0353633873,
-0.014857633,
0.0584533587,
0.0007437533,
-0.0474269204,
-0.0140786907,
0.0000351663,
-0.0053553344,
0.0574040338,
-0.0409392789,
0.06692186,
-0.0413590483,
0.0215201285,
0.027367577,
-0.0305916611,
0.0315980092,
0.0048096627,
-0.0339191146,
0.0964640453,
-0.0120950351,
-0.018986918,
-0.0093850764,
-0.0033656738,
-0.0490399264,
-0.0647765324,
0.0141498717,
0.0788653269,
-0.0602530427,
0.0697179064,
-0.0068193972,
0.0378755517,
-0.0017230107,
-0.0312389936,
0.0098848697,
0.0590509176,
0.0184243452,
0.0765615925,
-0.0053403904,
0.033245001,
-0.0043013091,
0.0089067323,
-0.0522376187,
-0.0347144082,
-0.0796779171,
-0.0164208841,
-0.0129082352,
0.0660916269,
-0.0316314586,
0.0262173004,
0.0096962946,
0.0214457102,
0.0007721714,
0.031266015,
0.018125942,
0.0221209433,
-0.007507035,
-0.0396458879,
-0.0647969916,
0.0420290008,
-0.0656018779,
0.023471579,
0.0179040898,
-0.0512096547,
-0.0117963515,
-0.0049830996,
0.0084914034,
-0.0334849209,
0.0097281644,
0.064935267,
0.0240504723,
-0.0036419407,
-0.0168472212,
-0.0532137454,
0.0282174237,
-0.0774570778,
-0.0229906198,
-0.0615012273,
0.048845768,
0.0383367576,
-0.0277210362,
-0.0388847552,
0.0336712785,
0.0359122418,
-0.0190580115,
0.05988672,
-0.007289446,
0.0368213579,
0.0275165606,
0.0313592218,
0.0082445107,
0.037718609,
0.0109181833,
0.0048740092,
0.033998128,
-0.0234806091,
0.0122498488,
-0.0080737295,
0.0331206284,
-0.0071977056,
0.0249327086,
0.0728492588,
-0.0004933985,
0.0184465647,
-0.0484382547,
0.0172049254,
-0.0259469617,
-0.0195336938,
0.026833972,
0.0583622679,
-0.0088474834,
0.0163955223,
-0.0037225261,
0.0079027489,
0.0152242631,
-0.0359142721,
-0.0425477251,
0.0189632289,
-0.0631195307,
-0.0025325634,
-0.0220775809,
0.0040222709,
-0.008733076,
-0.0510702021,
-0.0155112511,
0.0105410106,
-0.0258601103,
0.0447999015,
0.044650808,
-0.0124819167,
-0.023849627,
0.0498991832,
0.0001427493,
-0.0684434697,
-0.0045335833,
-0.0451055653,
0.0758989006,
0.0308535676,
0.0569329113,
-0.0332494229,
0.0029489005,
-0.0051605962,
-0.0025317364,
0.0144497994,
0.023201894,
-0.0221675709,
0.0237999763,
-0.0131099978,
-0.0130771901,
-0.0003036431,
-0.0259246994,
0.0426075682,
0.0368227325,
-0.0309801195,
-0.0170230009,
-0.0120737627,
-0.0100634247,
0.0223734155,
-0.014277745,
-0.0173751526,
0.001799669,
-0.0205288697,
0.0456927978,
0.0387905426,
0.0044481843,
0.0375019275,
0.0281786565,
0.0118710967,
-0.0552136302,
0.0307951551,
-0.0185826868,
-0.0055775554,
0.0664618909,
-0.0259521697,
-0.0563152768,
-0.0011294582,
-0.0470719002,
-0.0656730309,
0.0096965805,
-0.0254428368,
0.0279134717,
-0.0271886308,
-0.0081697637,
0.0343813635,
-0.0263837036,
-0.0266386773,
0.0817528814,
0.033918187,
-0.0179835502,
-0.0105610155,
-0.0283361766,
0.025787035,
-0.0252225511,
0.0548895523,
0.0269161966,
-0.0057072705,
-0.0128546562,
0.0385120586,
0.0190758929,
-0.0478207208,
0.0169654284,
-0.0418298095,
0.0118853394,
0.0124027906,
0.0346987322,
0.0165046416,
0.0035003966,
-0.0077638733,
-0.0063897939,
-0.0410929099,
-0.0210407991,
0.0437446646,
-0.0174929295,
0.0285144057,
0.0078479145,
-0.0149834966,
-0.0043636775,
-0.0023267374,
-0.0384172015,
0.0276232213,
0.0292486791,
0.0188536551,
-0.0484272428,
0.0203628466,
-0.0627647042,
0.0271148607,
0.0210915077,
-0.022770917,
0.035988275,
-0.042077139,
-0.0244225804,
0.0728832334,
0.0003488718,
0.0261303987,
0.0256607533,
-0.0276873428,
-0.0271373596,
0.0147896623,
-0.0610412285,
-0.0208412781,
-0.0139986901,
-0.0409679636,
-0.0282821711,
0.0420296192,
0.0237829685,
0.0126871597,
-0.0451707765,
0.0375695564,
0.0422096886,
0.0102232052,
-0.0682638735,
-0.0116513716,
0.011537875,
0.075631462,
-0.0173575487,
-0.023808429,
0.0920848921,
-0.0166011732,
-0.0011184022,
-0.0608734377,
-0.0189824961,
-0.035296604,
0.0563069731,
-0.0283904653,
-0.0010437912,
-0.0073441328,
0.001296881,
0.0052549033,
-0.0386205316,
0.0411263183,
-0.0244756024,
0.0411980376,
-0.0889601335,
0.0112557234,
-0.0010552531,
-0.0388630554,
-0.028546501,
-0.0521290749,
-0.0565868877,
-0.0080877049,
-0.0399809554,
-0.0343248099,
-0.0289945416,
-0.009509109,
0.0406378917,
-0.0238933656,
-0.0275282916,
-0.0110044964,
-0.0066924659,
0.0085677803,
0.0245456789,
0.0491619296,
0.0160719659,
0.0088831596,
0.0603817217,
0.0738247931,
0.0260685496,
-0.0046724905,
0.0068470016,
0.0304834247,
-0.0038359866,
-0.0432034098,
-0.000515094,
0.025303334,
0.063090913,
-0.0869570225,
-0.0095965732,
0.1204549447,
0.0472046472,
0.0325590409,
-0.0182359312,
-0.0466486923,
0.0204005223,
0.0168435164,
0.0491010658,
-0.0828743577,
-0.0432722047,
-0.0036962163,
0.0102887945,
0.0045380048,
-0.0249487348,
-0.0199773721,
-0.1157086268,
0.0287884176,
0.0097377887,
-0.0720259845,
-0.0189246815,
-0.0745017156,
-0.0047756177,
0.0033318617,
-0.0447730832,
0.036722701,
0.0087471697,
0.0130217932,
0.0028786461,
0.0163295828,
0.002709836,
0.0724011436,
0.0147575773,
0.0323483087,
0.0529141575,
0.0418288,
0.0184977893,
-0.0304746907,
-0.011262605,
-0.0276976228,
-0.0007089219,
-0.0419108532,
-0.0030871599,
-0.0096305832,
0.0033577273,
-0.0389932655,
0.0586682148,
-0.0728566423,
-0.0384472422,
0.0464595668,
0.0932155997,
-0.030962266,
0.0032644921,
-0.0140908537,
-0.0044428105,
-0.012036127,
0.0983401015,
0.010297603,
0.0295010358,
-0.0554166622,
-0.0797448456,
-0.0501278043,
-0.0338940956,
-0.0347608328,
0.0206678752,
0.0043249582,
0.011807316,
-0.0173897706,
-0.019497307,
0.0323282033,
0.003065903,
-0.011315221,
-0.0120689925,
0.0293708108,
0.025977781,
-0.0204667617,
0.0288442895,
-0.033997491,
0.0109293489,
0.0017167643,
0.0007765429,
-0.0177234113,
-0.0637942627,
-0.0216846354,
-0.0174046215,
0.0041761049,
-0.057218723,
-0.0133819627,
0.0181367919,
0.0331340209,
0.0360401906,
-0.0151181715,
-0.0226466991,
-0.0302141197,
0.015932193,
-0.0420759693,
-0.0404796973,
0.0148804896,
0.0095907692,
0.0251712874,
0.0218304507,
-0.0266044382,
0.0219212882,
-0.0169328731,
0.032545872,
-0.0364525504,
-0.0315982662,
0.0524506606,
0.053311795,
-0.0116481902,
0.0348461233,
-0.0049568652,
-0.012867149,
-0.0006246265,
-0.0769815445,
-0.0082675451,
-0.0184143148,
0.0307918768,
0.006955374,
-0.0439308472,
0.0141234193,
-0.0224309266,
-0.0419514738,
-0.004547176,
-0.0015145876,
0.017542107,
0.0405801758,
0.002854283,
-0.0125683742,
-0.0289634112,
-0.0113919629,
0.0011931696,
-0.0154327443,
0.0413778499,
-0.0194847435,
0.0702017769,
0.0356314592,
-0.0194329079,
0.0156714786,
-0.0207000617,
-0.0685411096,
-0.0971578583,
0.0146430833,
0.057110399,
0.0154032502,
0.0153512321,
0.0261947308,
-0.0591579117,
0.0012898968,
0.0207185429,
0.034326084,
0.0375667624,
-0.000246468,
0.0665068254,
0.0248857159,
-0.0215566177,
-0.0408513844,
0.026284527,
-0.0026658759,
0.0177637879,
0.0206490085,
-0.0429541096,
-0.0421102196,
-0.0291322656,
-0.0252535604,
-0.0014465967,
0.0012564105,
0.0199270118,
-0.0332789868,
-0.052390147,
-0.0559040718,
0.0446863472,
-0.0075677191,
-0.0039836001,
0.0252311677,
0.048310332,
0.0002069179,
-0.067974031,
-0.0288442988,
0.0373893566,
-0.107165806,
0.0066929711,
0.0033672396,
-6.504637663e-33,
-0.0256467666,
-0.0471720248,
0.032057073,
0.0007726005,
0.0200992543,
-0.0388958715,
-0.0463736653,
-0.016785834,
-0.0447787717,
0.011897143,
-0.0030165173,
0.0611228719,
0.0103970896,
0.0075325589,
-0.0162005294,
-0.0278214365,
-0.0113930702,
-0.0026285299,
-0.0173633732,
0.019526029,
0.0483071692,
-0.0279088896,
0.0525032319,
-0.0717619732,
0.0199192166,
-0.0003269097,
-0.0028927459,
0.0628259182,
-0.0631556138,
0.029302638,
-0.0117414463,
0.0359905064,
0.0124395555,
-0.0422888435,
0.0173393656,
0.0433202051,
-0.0814553127,
-0.0504385643,
0.0860220864,
-0.0280287769,
-0.0595400929,
0.0000271702,
0.0304233599,
0.0216994118,
0.0113193421,
-0.0143927075,
0.0272120107,
-0.0150188897,
0.0237380285,
0.0148785738,
-0.0199610367,
0.0247112866,
-0.031117728,
-0.0425215252,
0.0167755932,
0.0221306849,
-0.0175219439,
0.0103494013,
0.00968327,
0.0091415141,
0.0212539546,
0.0077530681,
0.0523552299,
-0.0214571096,
-0.0092931911,
0.0222416185,
-0.0035216839,
-0.0442074127,
-0.029089028,
-0.0012981434,
-0.0328333341,
0.0628718808,
0.0451780632,
0.0191451386,
0.0180067345,
0.0219150838,
-0.1035531387,
0.0299784597,
-0.0007026097,
0.0700737759,
0.0367385037,
0.0174793415,
-0.0325645879,
-0.0077992179,
-0.0325217471,
0.0228914134,
-0.0304113794,
-0.0191449728,
0.0139128836,
-0.0345653296,
-0.0375249833,
-0.0026158821,
-0.0005524114,
-0.0249793287,
-0.0059805615,
0.0462596305,
-0.0132066021,
-0.0263548549,
-0.0175946541,
0.0232702047,
-0.0593137331,
0.0156475566,
0.0009728962,
-0.0045993309,
0.0141682392,
0.0146181192,
-0.0237217676,
0.0029873522,
-0.0143783176,
-0.0081746392,
-0.0725831091,
0.0229712911,
-0.0305057485,
-0.0228840336,
0.0319883563,
0.0442519151,
0.0051798378,
0.0426996835,
-0.0168893952,
-0.0151398294,
-0.0348437838,
-0.0116675617,
0.0291596763,
-0.0136450622,
-0.0071772467,
0.0072549945,
-0.0365583636,
-0.0146597093,
0.0095112836,
-0.0496411324,
-0.0134206051,
0.0436577573,
2.835e-7,
0.0246452354,
0.0356524624,
0.0390529782,
0.0662559718,
0.0350800566,
0.039748691,
0.0196182597,
-0.0186132509,
0.0428094827,
-0.0570166185,
0.0024490093,
0.0521547198,
0.0170646422,
0.058853779,
-0.0303133652,
-0.0147934556,
-0.0513502099,
-0.0448256545,
-0.0570238084,
0.0188644584,
0.1339516938,
0.0593175218,
0.0238455217,
-0.0005035418,
-0.0046628141,
-0.0210779645,
0.0201394092,
-0.0195675101,
-0.0116079422,
-0.0274560712,
0.0001655647,
0.016351318,
0.029593166,
0.0298686028,
0.0136813484,
0.0034469182,
-0.015543405,
0.0730147883,
-0.0218283683,
-0.0335302204,
-0.0409510136,
-0.0268117916,
0.0189731531,
-0.0588585958,
0.0918160751,
-0.0523367673,
-0.0571330898,
-0.0176437255,
0.0018987549,
-0.0666134059,
-0.05811885,
0.0082404353,
-0.0039553265,
-0.0069584399,
-0.0071070376,
-0.0175327547,
-0.0003004091,
-0.0637153089,
-0.0227009673,
0.04245352,
-0.0158476569,
-0.0060060462,
-0.019705873,
-0.0092494041,
0.0101216426,
-0.0639114529,
-0.045255933,
2.509410672e-34,
0.0171566475,
0.0124253538,
0.00776183,
0.022980867,
0.0897982195,
0.0059318929,
-0.0318226069,
0.0157481991,
0.0491152667,
-0.0727921203,
-0.0297841486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03773v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03773v1 | What Matters In The Structured Pruning of Generative Language Models? | 2023-02-07T22:05:55 | 2023-02-07T22:05:55 | Michael Santacroce, Zixin Wen, Yelong Shen, Yuanzhi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Auto-regressive large language models such as GPT-3 require enormous
computational resources to use. Traditionally, structured pruning methods are
employed to reduce resource usage. However, their application to and efficacy
for generative language models is heavily under-explored. In this paper we
conduct an comprehensive evaluation of common structured pruning methods,
including magnitude, random, and movement pruning on the feed-forward layers in
GPT-type models. Unexpectedly, random pruning results in performance that is
comparable to the best established methods, across multiple natural language
generation tasks. To understand these results, we provide a framework for
measuring neuron-level redundancy of models pruned by different methods, and
discover that established structured pruning methods do not take into account
the distinctiveness of neurons, leaving behind excess redundancies. In view of
this, we introduce Globally Unique Movement (GUM) to improve the uniqueness of
neurons in pruned models. We then discuss the effects of our techniques on
different redundancy metrics to explain the improved performance. | [
0.0094342474,
0.0771029666,
-0.0122995339,
0.0153491804,
-0.0435097925,
0.0021961806,
0.0513623692,
0.0086833574,
-0.0529551879,
0.0332921892,
-0.0106312335,
-0.0675221905,
0.0210847128,
0.0304484591,
0.037384212,
-0.0256016422,
0.0471936613,
-0.0256991219,
0.0236139316,
0.0051126955,
-0.0054438524,
0.0035519802,
0.0173179433,
0.0550342165,
-0.0085670399,
-0.0253475439,
-0.001112437,
0.0045780567,
0.0014009618,
0.008509608,
-0.0097819669,
0.0730724707,
-0.0165004171,
0.0450291634,
0.0000020065,
-0.0003667842,
0.0132058216,
0.0000803798,
-0.0068510668,
0.081274271,
0.0372791886,
0.0126139177,
-0.0324860476,
0.0100001767,
-0.0039993157,
-0.0581812263,
0.0469291061,
0.0239740349,
0.0415127613,
0.0881891251,
-0.0001555464,
-0.0292821284,
0.0069546388,
-0.0762515962,
0.0023425901,
0.0136210872,
0.0146118738,
-0.0063761026,
-0.0239412654,
-0.0151591673,
-0.0162011757,
0.0325375646,
0.0468502603,
0.0247182976,
-0.0160819739,
0.0482466333,
-0.0395251103,
-0.0223644245,
0.0128456336,
0.0337107107,
-0.0681504235,
-0.025578117,
0.018667914,
-0.0339049213,
-0.0056034266,
-0.0391458832,
-0.0544389114,
0.0352496691,
0.017740177,
0.0318840556,
0.0065381392,
-0.0027719324,
0.0506969355,
-0.0308809523,
-0.0064902129,
0.0261810105,
0.0509704649,
0.0114799831,
-0.0547578186,
0.0156984404,
-0.02853157,
-0.0384477414,
-0.0022503885,
-0.0057644844,
0.011670894,
-0.0005595385,
-0.0668922961,
0.0019568698,
-0.0145314503,
-0.0147727132,
0.0649763644,
0.0460426323,
0.048885297,
-0.0077897175,
-0.0173962377,
0.0565618537,
0.0039992211,
-0.0192918889,
-0.0232288931,
0.014718106,
-0.0100170933,
-0.0292953309,
-0.0433079898,
0.0316042677,
-0.0390984751,
-0.0474554189,
-0.0417138152,
0.0142356576,
0.0054696463,
-0.0698564574,
0.0146335214,
0.0213669818,
-0.0371337458,
-0.0041084397,
0.0254628379,
0.0131190959,
-0.0408881865,
-0.0088856416,
0.0237285905,
-0.0720362887,
-0.0295374636,
0.0361308344,
-0.0034643174,
-0.0278940275,
-0.0286191162,
0.0396821983,
-0.0004345658,
-0.0246333349,
-0.0661375225,
0.0003437341,
-0.0241120644,
-0.0638292953,
0.0182931256,
-0.0568678901,
0.0311034396,
-0.0378857814,
-0.0119829988,
-0.0658139661,
-0.0150790857,
0.0043747374,
-0.0282398108,
-0.0067787631,
-0.0076568932,
0.0356327221,
0.0239184089,
0.0104677426,
0.0476298854,
0.0350222811,
0.0446309187,
0.0262918547,
-0.0021359702,
-0.0201511644,
0.0003164861,
0.0422780178,
0.0314845033,
-0.0355716608,
-0.0367609225,
-0.0904830992,
-0.0499361753,
0.0163931288,
0.0792858079,
0.0863266587,
-0.0715391636,
-0.0064176847,
0.0701809302,
0.0240246356,
0.0403980054,
0.0666022822,
0.0890640542,
-0.0078830086,
-0.0051977015,
0.0500932373,
-0.0329689421,
0.0255516041,
-0.0090236105,
0.0237677228,
0.0122231795,
0.0563298389,
-0.052001249,
-0.0243409444,
-0.000795719,
0.0124306502,
-0.0038677838,
-0.0493128374,
0.0282282494,
0.0416934155,
-0.0293096602,
0.0383950062,
-0.0013079396,
-0.0767207667,
0.0004531707,
-0.050668776,
-0.0133450851,
0.0257182419,
0.0562557317,
0.0301214717,
-0.0241616536,
0.0520863011,
-0.0060604564,
0.041910328,
0.0172962528,
0.0188710056,
0.0503503606,
-0.0457309298,
-0.0068812026,
-0.0086928634,
0.0250547156,
0.0140351681,
0.0376950055,
-0.0123914797,
0.0470733419,
-0.0288581476,
-0.014947203,
0.0285442229,
-0.0491240881,
-0.0246683937,
0.0248668622,
-0.0156907011,
0.0239035226,
-0.0198069382,
-0.0380361304,
0.0367605165,
0.0327700377,
-0.0297386684,
0.0313712806,
0.0033147915,
-0.0683023557,
-0.0546361282,
0.030275004,
0.0078754332,
0.0302495454,
0.0497885756,
-0.0144667812,
-0.0475307964,
0.0515424386,
-0.0577283651,
0.0359344631,
-0.0643776432,
0.0289146509,
0.0207160953,
0.0448212102,
-0.0076620928,
0.0466843285,
-0.008277067,
0.0038347319,
0.0434641987,
-0.0014679185,
0.0073732575,
-0.0741532892,
-0.0273184311,
0.001376544,
-0.012289146,
0.0038864291,
0.022753587,
0.0234720316,
-0.0007295784,
-0.0198227074,
-0.0284734424,
0.015073943,
-0.0158988144,
0.0320635252,
0.033253517,
0.0512152277,
-0.0104008988,
0.0298374705,
-0.0061395098,
0.0165431295,
0.0404133163,
0.0160634238,
0.0261339191,
-0.0352242775,
-0.0532175824,
-0.03357476,
-0.0357499905,
0.0323292464,
0.0662808493,
-0.0212818477,
-0.0188543554,
-0.0262243785,
0.0461933166,
-0.0450184979,
0.0141653512,
0.0132990377,
-0.058332663,
0.0098659787,
0.0084499717,
0.0695781857,
0.0097615104,
-0.018868342,
0.0416798294,
0.031159088,
-0.0194417704,
-0.0048916568,
-0.0022370934,
-0.0483087786,
0.0278358888,
0.0029945807,
-0.0462906323,
0.0176816937,
0.0810359642,
0.0504737087,
-0.0270669386,
-0.0666960105,
0.0139731541,
-0.0244488623,
-0.0399453156,
0.0086725494,
-0.0009672967,
-0.0336823799,
0.0137258396,
-0.022166105,
-0.053607624,
0.0128456727,
-0.0550915077,
-0.0023817653,
0.0015305375,
-0.0033000396,
-0.0075707743,
0.0466548651,
0.0524469092,
0.0253083184,
0.0058493954,
-0.0072001494,
-0.0431281589,
0.0303026661,
0.0040013972,
0.0006424024,
-0.015250559,
-0.0571662113,
0.0099162534,
0.0165117029,
-0.0202161316,
-0.0138700809,
-0.0012162433,
0.0334504284,
0.0336889997,
0.0658921972,
-0.0307418033,
-0.0084923441,
0.0216079112,
0.0074818255,
0.066079244,
-0.0162550937,
0.0017692954,
-0.0007463754,
0.0515963323,
0.0500139035,
-0.0222281963,
0.028221624,
-0.035849236,
0.0128692845,
0.0260167196,
0.0111493021,
0.0414191969,
-0.0696378052,
0.0210482422,
-0.0163735691,
-0.0135705173,
-0.0312467404,
0.0216570552,
0.0377706885,
-0.0471716821,
-0.0470738932,
0.0976926312,
0.0027914548,
-0.0079477569,
0.0377098843,
0.0363043696,
0.1000608131,
-0.0174417812,
0.0213769544,
-0.0241114181,
0.0062776003,
-0.0027292289,
-0.0000719542,
0.0014387282,
-0.0005786858,
-0.0285763312,
-0.1330804825,
0.0493327342,
0.0264741257,
-0.0384709127,
0.000650858,
0.0225617923,
-0.0244301558,
-0.023684727,
-0.0139795626,
0.0279070456,
-0.0251789056,
0.0217967145,
0.0133249601,
-0.0598848425,
-0.0546141602,
-0.0403431356,
-0.007251346,
0.0563348457,
0.0692468509,
0.0060944711,
0.013953764,
-0.0350023285,
0.0770686641,
-0.0040022261,
0.0047896691,
-0.0201456491,
0.0349530131,
0.0532712676,
-0.0050894725,
-0.0343207307,
0.0158721227,
-0.0197867583,
-0.0192563888,
-0.0456545539,
0.0679091141,
-0.0110524446,
-0.0630756319,
-0.0248384364,
0.0166227687,
-0.0142319379,
0.0688132048,
0.0695666149,
-0.023074057,
-0.0838904604,
-0.0066044326,
0.0265336987,
-0.0855865702,
-0.0237543676,
0.0143485125,
0.0261860751,
-0.0781003088,
-0.0530239269,
-0.0237812418,
0.0059546153,
0.0403545275,
-0.0399458818,
0.0198946558,
-0.0349427499,
-0.0179001596,
-0.0153084863,
-0.0001323501,
-0.009518858,
-0.0348869301,
-0.060184259,
-0.0067287479,
-0.0172191188,
-0.0054012998,
-0.0318989456,
0.0009666286,
-0.1123981848,
-0.071350649,
-0.0216189921,
0.0571565069,
0.0273096375,
0.0103647094,
0.0150821013,
-0.0301261693,
0.0172425508,
0.0344547406,
-0.0056762467,
0.0703900158,
-0.0101716816,
-0.0562882796,
-0.0213554222,
0.0415907279,
0.0229428019,
0.0525164269,
0.0136950826,
0.0784085393,
0.0394470878,
0.0022764117,
0.0019284775,
0.0271639489,
0.0219067261,
-0.0183893777,
0.0309982318,
-0.048104044,
-0.0315897688,
0.0088447323,
0.0180119239,
-0.0749068409,
0.0303254277,
0.0444049053,
0.0329954736,
-0.041507829,
0.0024413841,
0.0170897525,
0.023143176,
-0.0176859535,
-0.0570757277,
0.0056107552,
-0.012395151,
-0.000608425,
-0.0219138078,
-0.0048482167,
0.0342430025,
-0.0410956144,
-0.0160325877,
-0.03393602,
-0.0003413955,
0.0066190343,
0.0380265489,
-0.0264940597,
0.0306358803,
-0.036513079,
-0.0672775134,
-0.0517662503,
0.0099790553,
0.0287352055,
0.0242286604,
0.0901706219,
-0.0141663868,
0.0047943653,
-0.0523379147,
0.0396177731,
0.0254244227,
-0.0026673235,
-0.0253466275,
0.0105206817,
-0.032041505,
-0.0692777559,
0.0939520374,
0.0678254142,
0.0282932185,
-0.0318317115,
-0.0029647918,
-0.0198683795,
-0.0536213405,
-0.0374735147,
-0.0254049525,
-0.0162681434,
-0.0075558485,
-0.0527867414,
-0.0693300292,
-0.0234427657,
0.0324284211,
0.0502613597,
-0.011902702,
0.0526268817,
0.0419513918,
-0.0270387307,
0.0029672249,
0.0044854656,
-0.0281599835,
-0.0258043166,
-0.0338069424,
-0.0152806174,
-6.755230284e-33,
-0.0408541001,
-0.0159408487,
0.0490914062,
-0.0344269387,
-0.062153101,
0.0147079816,
-0.0637084693,
0.0049516568,
0.0108521339,
0.018025795,
-0.0062985928,
0.0180080868,
0.0052754441,
0.0323938392,
-0.0052266694,
0.037975736,
0.0572832972,
-0.0297164135,
-0.0415027365,
0.0597534217,
0.0125889033,
0.0277334619,
0.0455971546,
0.004819402,
-0.0516568981,
0.0137181804,
-0.024768034,
-0.0221190546,
-0.0170589071,
0.0230762623,
-0.0427827202,
-0.0030740311,
0.0309114587,
-0.0328969061,
-0.0285424516,
-0.0042897011,
-0.0501199663,
-0.0412422791,
0.0329592824,
-0.0301986039,
-0.0397378355,
-0.0132851657,
0.0505599827,
-0.0151191354,
-0.0377468094,
-0.0137501424,
-0.0022944198,
-0.0140306707,
-0.0544527285,
-0.0283128731,
-0.0740435123,
0.0292212926,
0.0296195652,
-0.021043336,
-0.0067921099,
0.0363046862,
-0.0510442741,
-0.0013154076,
-0.0132573098,
0.0027979929,
0.0336905457,
0.0704662427,
0.0453284681,
0.0147741474,
0.0313620567,
0.0536889471,
0.0167488679,
-0.0205237754,
-0.0508583635,
0.026422061,
0.045717705,
0.0592957325,
0.0339590237,
0.0202794727,
0.0474766232,
-0.0174876899,
-0.0830990374,
0.0149555467,
-0.0086127697,
0.0121458117,
0.0336785764,
0.0134701347,
0.0148195028,
-0.0278151091,
0.0024554175,
-0.064030692,
-0.0115246447,
-0.0409931205,
0.0504157282,
0.0149253067,
-0.0503416657,
-0.028578965,
0.0372169092,
-0.0088213524,
-0.005963468,
0.0733272135,
-0.043327067,
0.0164331179,
0.010900978,
0.0142846601,
-0.0271414313,
-0.0242129602,
-0.0059414785,
0.0227366295,
0.0210388396,
-0.0170002058,
-0.0125955595,
0.0523968637,
-0.0439487211,
-0.0050931666,
-0.0575544946,
0.0273758229,
-0.0013477766,
0.0781993195,
0.0345363915,
-0.0229630601,
-0.0063600373,
0.0262466669,
0.0015244239,
-0.010294362,
-0.0195230749,
0.0511643626,
0.0315610357,
0.0396819636,
-0.0368095115,
0.0111849168,
-0.0256345812,
0.0337659307,
0.0534271449,
-0.0385770202,
-0.0528850928,
0.0284168404,
2.669e-7,
0.0231718589,
-0.0208130814,
0.0372065678,
0.0171840396,
0.0310824662,
-0.0112250671,
-0.0044597182,
-0.0043013184,
-0.029320186,
0.0202926602,
0.02987835,
0.0144890854,
0.07519418,
-0.0085478127,
-0.0561314337,
0.038791392,
-0.0923386961,
0.0088959765,
-0.0267871451,
-0.0574596897,
-0.0398159213,
0.0581018701,
0.0032142813,
-0.032143984,
0.0187567752,
-0.0326419622,
0.0394815765,
-0.0040521007,
0.0125815505,
0.0155647993,
0.0145078935,
0.0018302784,
-0.0238102823,
-0.0625107586,
-0.0005585936,
-0.0050692186,
0.017082328,
0.0827087834,
-0.0017004191,
-0.0051005539,
0.0493642986,
0.0086230701,
-0.0107234577,
-0.0315794311,
0.0420794003,
-0.0214679409,
0.0132212462,
-0.0133942384,
0.0245797522,
0.0070817736,
0.0294022094,
-0.0430420563,
-0.0157093182,
0.0038688097,
0.019875709,
-0.0114700422,
-0.0226433929,
-0.017497234,
0.0003480712,
-0.0069313222,
-0.0781231076,
-0.0260915216,
-0.0655231476,
0.0033133158,
0.0276115909,
-0.0183976684,
-0.0364514627,
2.612139695e-34,
0.026918916,
-0.0270761829,
0.0107230479,
-0.0047543305,
0.0382554792,
-0.0002233098,
0.0288597587,
0.0093287714,
-0.0504573025,
-0.0536411591,
-0.0614066496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03765v1 | Transformer-based Models for Long-Form Document Matching: Challenges and Empirical Analysis | 2023-02-07T21:51:05 | 2023-02-07T21:51:05 | Akshita Jha, Adithya Samavedhi, Vineeth Rakesh, Jaideep Chandrashekar, Chandan K. Reddy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in the area of long document matching have primarily focused
on using transformer-based models for long document encoding and matching.
There are two primary challenges associated with these models. Firstly, the
performance gain provided by transformer-based models comes at a steep cost -
both in terms of the required training time and the resource (memory and
energy) consumption. The second major limitation is their inability to handle
more than a pre-defined input token length at a time. In this work, we
empirically demonstrate the effectiveness of simple neural models (such as
feed-forward networks, and CNNs) and simple embeddings (like GloVe, and
Paragraph Vector) over transformer-based models on the task of document
matching. We show that simple models outperform the more complex BERT-based
models while taking significantly less training time, energy, and memory. The
simple models are also more robust to variations in document length and text
perturbations. | [
0.0294461511,
0.0565309264,
0.0206223316,
0.0314150341,
-0.0481336191,
0.0125807906,
0.00556657,
0.0180982668,
-0.0348501466,
-0.02713768,
0.0005533714,
-0.0335696302,
0.0061641755,
0.0137208654,
-0.019015139,
-0.01399229,
0.024729602,
0.0053950469,
-0.0453314409,
0.014080436,
0.0269981399,
-0.0042629535,
0.0170386881,
0.0121519109,
-0.0246000662,
0.0130687179,
-0.0407761857,
0.0368574038,
0.003699424,
0.011506076,
-0.0023479508,
0.0158400983,
0.0056690699,
0.0651501864,
0.0000015266,
-0.0359046981,
-0.0361713544,
0.0138565721,
-0.0034830587,
-0.0182961877,
0.041173242,
-0.0539918505,
-0.0043517374,
0.0031647305,
0.0256442782,
-0.037411347,
0.0492842458,
0.1049903706,
0.0147620467,
0.0785273686,
-0.0294153243,
-0.0451434329,
0.0904779658,
-0.0353871584,
0.0053980988,
-0.0023460626,
0.0172645673,
-0.0746112093,
0.0223745927,
0.0089356238,
-0.030978201,
0.0265192855,
-0.0021696931,
-0.0143573442,
-0.0111064501,
0.0294184554,
-0.0543183088,
0.0526897423,
0.010005069,
0.0537645221,
-0.0637241453,
-0.0360791087,
0.010341811,
0.0150350099,
-0.0129360892,
0.0306752082,
-0.0107326321,
0.0121508287,
-0.0448853336,
-0.0034576617,
-0.0179242697,
0.0062077125,
0.0084571578,
0.0126918051,
-0.0479755476,
-0.0073007066,
0.0132164685,
-0.0446673557,
-0.02555326,
-0.017847877,
-0.0050235605,
-0.0523404963,
0.0654990301,
0.0173063129,
0.0642945319,
-0.039368961,
-0.0617227964,
-0.0870803446,
-0.0069537624,
-0.0033549061,
0.0112707,
0.0572986379,
-0.0148311174,
0.0469852686,
-0.0792923719,
0.0643861368,
-0.0414411351,
0.0217196066,
-0.0363785513,
-0.0298844669,
-0.0276275221,
-0.0016221862,
-0.0698004216,
0.0333553292,
0.0032674246,
-0.0515600629,
0.0255412105,
0.0001722202,
0.009329102,
0.0428124517,
0.0012653966,
-0.0061039473,
-0.0071689789,
-0.0185550563,
-0.0059666787,
0.0511310361,
-0.0274124518,
0.0003266105,
-0.012667723,
-0.0067181168,
-0.0031614071,
0.0307232291,
0.0440270789,
-0.0372459069,
0.0362521447,
0.0133243557,
-0.0248591229,
-0.0601757243,
0.0201495867,
0.0180631764,
0.0074293795,
-0.0154741658,
0.0347970687,
-0.0481470339,
0.0624626353,
-0.0085724993,
0.0164430775,
0.0117731402,
0.0000176521,
0.0392130427,
-0.0364993289,
0.0885966718,
0.0482327789,
0.0067068799,
0.0553637296,
-0.0217747819,
0.0031016197,
-0.0084524555,
0.014981702,
0.032567773,
0.0194458161,
-0.0191524662,
0.0194869991,
0.0533397049,
0.0080473879,
-0.0203898679,
0.0123976385,
0.0049579856,
0.0265395343,
0.0436796024,
0.0197882764,
0.0557260737,
-0.0249722041,
-0.0535236672,
0.0626759604,
0.093894057,
0.043414101,
0.0231277477,
-0.0009018162,
0.0161811877,
-0.0117870364,
0.0148973279,
-0.0158313662,
0.0200601332,
0.0113426568,
-0.0024210759,
-0.0220700372,
0.0202496964,
-0.0580824502,
0.0299036577,
0.0043260162,
-0.0507307537,
0.0181365218,
-0.0162112601,
0.0486401208,
0.0037446124,
-0.0278294813,
0.0899588764,
-0.0391322672,
-0.0402980782,
-0.0206395369,
-0.0098146768,
-0.0243963543,
0.0347912535,
0.0656601116,
0.0098486254,
-0.0160027575,
-0.0220621824,
0.0319719017,
0.0359901786,
0.0672283843,
0.0071389149,
-0.0088553606,
-0.0723771676,
-0.0027593884,
0.0295296926,
-0.0351705141,
0.0106959734,
0.0199477002,
0.0305334423,
0.0156704038,
-0.0348974802,
-0.0173211396,
0.0272529665,
-0.0277178604,
-0.0410817079,
-0.0013544667,
0.0405165739,
0.0115257334,
-0.0065953648,
0.0049354201,
0.0367951542,
0.0463286452,
-0.0369570926,
-0.0178523809,
-0.0143227046,
-0.0405651443,
0.0038846873,
0.0236256216,
-0.024822237,
0.024273634,
0.0603805333,
-0.0105057638,
-0.0360469632,
-0.0439710766,
-0.0446358174,
0.03098947,
-0.0084295468,
0.0272217896,
-0.0130907446,
0.0034737645,
-0.0155352466,
0.0080000702,
0.0244144704,
0.0124832569,
-0.032285478,
-0.0155638084,
0.0446180254,
-0.0554661937,
-0.0628319234,
-0.0060263444,
-0.0206929501,
-0.0013417773,
0.0223199278,
-0.0500280298,
0.0202757753,
-0.0643622726,
-0.093664594,
-0.0025018358,
0.0105274767,
0.0090239029,
-0.0329130217,
0.0226057004,
0.001379975,
-0.0177570172,
-0.0610840507,
-0.0253607165,
0.0002029699,
0.0093373554,
0.0330285765,
-0.0106657604,
-0.0382578,
-0.0157612395,
-0.0311632957,
-0.0225166194,
0.041851908,
-0.0037244428,
-0.0547460951,
-0.0291822907,
-0.0292866509,
0.0271857213,
0.0460813157,
-0.0262661427,
-0.0246496201,
-0.0176243223,
-0.0092596756,
0.0317927599,
0.0816762671,
0.0580782779,
-0.0439364016,
-0.0072482782,
0.027513504,
-0.0635068864,
0.0150917917,
-0.043294128,
0.040310964,
-0.0080901114,
-0.0116494913,
0.0189005826,
0.0161312204,
-0.0493629016,
0.0299377199,
-0.0027224899,
-0.0379342064,
0.0321858451,
0.033863537,
-0.003925465,
-0.0418972075,
0.0022717118,
-0.0150605068,
-0.0127489567,
-0.0198419951,
0.057249181,
-0.0743367225,
-0.0016196873,
-0.021582203,
0.009564437,
-0.0499623604,
0.0414085984,
0.018911723,
0.0352130421,
-0.0183606055,
-0.0032150298,
0.0119323842,
0.0129929511,
0.0347867683,
-0.0200923737,
0.0413107462,
0.0522601716,
0.051207412,
-0.0499450266,
-0.0669146925,
-0.0270677377,
-0.0631216317,
0.0003514654,
0.0041604815,
-0.0066628302,
-0.0413469002,
-0.1081394851,
0.0891289487,
0.0103649348,
0.0798464417,
-0.0394326858,
-0.0093873376,
-0.0343657695,
0.068936035,
0.0245010853,
-0.0370061621,
0.0107814278,
-0.0127761252,
0.0047583864,
0.0435696989,
0.043581605,
0.0347993113,
-0.0417059734,
-0.027615793,
0.020560557,
-0.0532331951,
0.0029783288,
-0.025934346,
0.0090487543,
-0.0348720476,
0.0026607867,
0.0929016024,
0.0076021575,
-0.0509345643,
-0.0586389937,
-0.0192536823,
-0.013607257,
-0.0279856808,
0.0397245288,
-0.0444594026,
-0.0137618519,
0.0472051315,
0.0259993821,
0.0274483077,
-0.0118094413,
-0.0065065143,
-0.1014671177,
0.0047311825,
0.0097233551,
0.0262720995,
-0.0477584004,
-0.0436373986,
-0.0150402151,
0.0300410986,
-0.0011621376,
-0.004469722,
-0.0275572725,
-0.0693201646,
0.0144807333,
-0.007486375,
0.0019633987,
-0.0027058041,
-0.0803373829,
-0.0125649404,
0.0223413184,
0.0140463123,
-0.0039761332,
-0.0552535169,
0.0361441374,
0.0255049802,
-0.0200757086,
0.0277239326,
0.0425510071,
-0.0651890934,
0.0201930888,
0.0057923901,
0.0189580321,
-0.0026357525,
-0.0097810449,
-0.0106787086,
0.0289473571,
-0.0219957866,
0.0014529423,
-0.0478404462,
-0.0290490966,
-0.0466956124,
0.085056372,
-0.0010703274,
-0.027792247,
-0.0399430059,
0.0102945743,
0.014430589,
-0.018963499,
0.0149952406,
0.0132463025,
-0.0140180076,
-0.0414000303,
-0.0441812575,
-0.0178225487,
-0.007836733,
0.0382047445,
0.0171415228,
-0.0200191382,
0.0197481476,
-0.0021499186,
-0.0677206665,
0.0410812199,
-0.0264008287,
0.0396360904,
-0.108437866,
0.0648485795,
0.0271443743,
-0.0235761572,
-0.0233701188,
-0.0423320048,
-0.0815853179,
-0.0020779243,
-0.0002364273,
-0.0270226635,
0.0165814795,
0.0476722978,
-0.0303750243,
-0.0375634208,
0.0019259007,
0.0620545708,
-0.0129262311,
-0.0148880426,
-0.0146505442,
-0.0718199685,
-0.0149894431,
-0.0041388902,
-0.0344254263,
0.0377344377,
0.0126073174,
-0.0105587374,
0.0139153004,
-0.0492744185,
-0.0034998711,
-0.0032057271,
0.0350160152,
0.0246323533,
0.0577647835,
-0.0180788822,
0.0376827531,
0.0136779044,
0.0146559803,
0.0010709717,
-0.0297536571,
0.0475758091,
0.0263889935,
0.0114320051,
0.0307095964,
0.0188915301,
0.0142356679,
-0.0490014404,
-0.0101999734,
-0.0316945612,
0.0092718573,
0.0087865777,
-0.0111014359,
-0.0171672516,
-0.0129855322,
0.0099258767,
0.0396867916,
-0.0465703309,
0.0211291611,
0.0553636514,
0.0367836803,
-0.0492468998,
0.0389833115,
-0.0540318564,
-0.0408959761,
-0.0500159487,
-0.0124536548,
0.0456796214,
-0.0664017126,
-0.0407797992,
-0.0254898369,
-0.0039793449,
-0.031334687,
-0.0464796238,
0.0334393866,
0.0011600025,
0.0265533961,
0.038658727,
0.0198596194,
-0.0105124367,
0.0517757423,
0.0168790668,
0.0460978858,
-0.0040660324,
-0.0591233671,
-0.0099884281,
0.0077114757,
0.0201361608,
-0.0122418609,
-0.0250176135,
-0.046110753,
-0.0014541026,
0.0047903694,
0.0634316131,
-0.0230570957,
-0.0050728996,
0.0057389294,
0.04402107,
0.0575346053,
0.0205617007,
-0.001403064,
0.0012522499,
0.0330853797,
-0.0028087678,
-0.0247114617,
-0.003938653,
-4.92565855e-33,
0.0287431087,
0.0045106551,
0.0091003552,
0.0203570146,
-0.0217434932,
0.022420099,
-0.0012174407,
-0.0734886378,
-0.0072040348,
-0.0075629409,
-0.0368346348,
-0.0056228293,
0.0227892995,
0.0382148325,
-0.0035827556,
0.0032164673,
0.053925354,
0.004538971,
-0.0452914573,
-0.0207083188,
0.0338355303,
0.023519244,
-0.0056356471,
-0.0280169528,
-0.035270799,
-0.021397084,
0.0246753953,
0.0098559298,
0.0422021374,
0.0708494782,
-0.0116472375,
-0.0371926837,
0.0342336595,
-0.0177623201,
0.0095715728,
0.096806854,
-0.1153599694,
0.027174769,
-0.0530786291,
0.0134168845,
0.0306462273,
-0.0255154762,
0.0334649906,
-0.0176769756,
-0.0021342579,
0.0030616056,
0.0249748509,
-0.0180000644,
-0.0141560696,
-0.0508788042,
-0.0493301749,
0.0286204703,
0.0376355648,
-0.0248097647,
0.0621333793,
0.0126297316,
0.0332378186,
0.0294816084,
-0.0730863437,
0.0000704297,
-0.0277265199,
0.0578517951,
0.0211312901,
-0.0159951076,
-0.0266260486,
0.027260948,
0.0178538524,
-0.0166762415,
0.0028379061,
-0.0201906543,
0.0320421755,
-0.0228659026,
0.0815731585,
0.0030167396,
0.0740992799,
-0.0170398038,
-0.0334775485,
0.0472723693,
0.0539187714,
0.0612838827,
0.0149270445,
0.007992602,
-0.0487790406,
0.0065804413,
-0.0287538376,
0.0098853568,
-0.0268476512,
0.0035954406,
0.0386759751,
0.0522802211,
0.0215772185,
0.0043532182,
0.0691181496,
-0.0182941612,
-0.014235273,
0.0169079006,
0.0029538521,
0.0218503997,
-0.009603275,
-0.0007916242,
-0.0323695019,
-0.043313168,
0.0339096561,
-0.0099800145,
-0.0166106783,
0.0095958607,
0.0686319098,
0.0243359022,
-0.0762274265,
-0.0109452829,
-0.0215310417,
-0.0321275853,
-0.0127621926,
0.0386792868,
0.0505302027,
0.0233681891,
0.0439926349,
0.0398878343,
-0.0074694157,
-0.0102811689,
-0.0210309122,
0.0077116941,
0.0307239015,
0.0217053909,
0.0022052601,
0.0050761793,
-0.0629470497,
0.0409646295,
0.0095568569,
-0.0664536804,
0.0239707548,
0.0528290011,
2.269e-7,
0.0263049696,
0.0218615476,
0.0895527378,
-0.0222504586,
0.0260673463,
0.0128802573,
0.0190046281,
0.0558987819,
-0.0285725165,
0.061116185,
-0.0034245718,
-0.0338649601,
0.0575129129,
-0.0025225612,
-0.0928143039,
-0.0118436506,
-0.108206436,
-0.0046677249,
-0.0624347292,
-0.0119850701,
0.010899269,
0.0749223381,
0.0014313451,
-0.0031441918,
0.0057517407,
-0.0750359297,
0.0728287175,
-0.0101766502,
0.0425591059,
0.0146122668,
0.0411049537,
-0.0162268374,
-0.0118233254,
0.0140445139,
-0.0014325283,
0.047728058,
0.0386570096,
0.0411262065,
-0.011355673,
-0.0081711141,
-0.0172136966,
-0.0216663834,
-0.0343084484,
-0.0625522956,
0.0551778898,
-0.0513271615,
0.026052963,
-0.0003250275,
-0.0455758758,
0.0139490673,
-0.0210482944,
0.0275603216,
-0.0238474645,
0.0464856327,
0.0628214031,
-0.0147787817,
0.0268228389,
-0.0881839395,
0.0128719481,
-0.0210604686,
-0.0231120735,
0.0233257692,
-0.0922326446,
-0.018597696,
0.0739985779,
-0.0302278865,
-0.0403037816,
2.099653316e-34,
0.0049635214,
-0.0148687474,
-0.0221241787,
-0.0167080294,
-0.0046264245,
-0.0190807357,
0.0264960453,
0.0422893204,
-0.0343822166,
-0.0861100629,
-0.0325285792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03754v1 | Augmenting Zero-Shot Dense Retrievers with Plug-in Mixture-of-Memories | 2023-02-07T20:59:31 | 2023-02-07T20:59:31 | Suyu Ge, Chenyan Xiong, Corby Rosset, Arnold Overwijk, Jiawei Han, Paul Bennett | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we improve the zero-shot generalization ability of language
models via Mixture-Of-Memory Augmentation (MoMA), a mechanism that retrieves
augmentation documents from multiple information corpora ("external memories"),
with the option to "plug in" new memory at inference time. We develop a joint
learning mechanism that trains the augmentation component with latent labels
derived from the end retrieval task, paired with hard negatives from the memory
mixture. We instantiate the model in a zero-shot dense retrieval setting by
augmenting a strong T5-based retriever with MoMA. Our model, MoMA, obtains
strong zero-shot retrieval accuracy on the eighteen tasks included in the
standard BEIR benchmark. It outperforms systems that seek generalization from
increased model parameters and computation steps. Our analysis further
illustrates the necessity of augmenting with mixture-of-memory for robust
generalization, the benefits of augmentation learning, and how MoMA utilizes
the plug-in memory at inference time without changing its parameters. We plan
to open source our code. | [
0.0327523425,
0.0289192386,
0.0046133231,
0.0343546234,
0.0071002962,
0.0224833935,
-0.0183391161,
-0.0130762383,
-0.0190301333,
-0.0541819111,
-0.0484623574,
-0.0566952489,
-0.0360304751,
0.0305180717,
0.0185357872,
-0.0215087328,
0.0663606375,
0.0189118907,
0.0111386655,
0.0079143541,
0.0017428315,
-0.0007004175,
-0.013692447,
0.0072794324,
-0.0061878767,
0.0346424729,
-0.0333049484,
-0.0001157341,
0.0154995928,
-0.0253629349,
0.008013106,
0.0197749641,
0.0454163179,
0.0454804078,
0.0000019453,
-0.0289941095,
-0.0414299667,
0.0022261548,
-0.0432139188,
-0.021245297,
0.0157537051,
-0.0179166459,
0.0209747683,
-0.014048961,
-0.006307913,
-0.0710939914,
0.054184895,
0.036313314,
0.0375922658,
0.093869634,
-0.0117542241,
-0.0200064257,
0.0438469797,
-0.021950379,
0.0755966231,
-0.0330954343,
0.0198668856,
-0.017729925,
0.0187040754,
0.0479856841,
0.0054671308,
0.0366732143,
0.0220886935,
0.0535204001,
0.0546601973,
0.0434391499,
-0.0162875354,
-0.0145587455,
-0.0029364645,
0.0349487849,
0.0298367739,
-0.025946226,
-0.023025861,
0.0135913333,
-0.0285444669,
-0.0285631865,
-0.0529087484,
0.0218542367,
-0.0011883893,
0.0091602113,
-0.0384979136,
-0.0204058401,
0.0373942442,
0.027833784,
-0.0685568377,
0.0355028659,
0.0297691785,
-0.0361002423,
0.002905179,
0.0161928162,
-0.0124460971,
0.0126455044,
-0.0102766417,
0.0381259918,
0.0081215212,
0.0267138407,
-0.0172004029,
-0.0758800954,
0.0327256471,
-0.0026093735,
0.0250951871,
0.0534005277,
-0.0566313714,
0.0554422922,
-0.0346043669,
0.0261940714,
-0.0365316719,
0.017512057,
-0.0513740852,
-0.0443969965,
-0.0537731163,
0.0077713369,
-0.0395389684,
0.0738236755,
0.0265165251,
-0.0161923207,
-0.0483038202,
0.017292222,
-0.0078026778,
0.0053521125,
-0.0107400781,
0.0052097766,
-0.0765672177,
-0.0203280468,
-0.0025015734,
0.0433989391,
-0.0314000174,
0.0049761492,
0.0175499953,
-0.0584234484,
-0.051700227,
0.0088255405,
0.03918216,
-0.0494576097,
0.0026475135,
0.0133559695,
-0.0686615407,
-0.1075154617,
-0.057821352,
0.005439382,
0.0041563152,
-0.0620928295,
0.0137773445,
-0.0529006384,
0.0222576298,
0.0022414066,
-0.0119915623,
-0.0060313027,
-0.0044430615,
0.0199259743,
-0.0238869619,
0.0503134578,
-0.0420723222,
-0.058226075,
0.0429652072,
0.0128245903,
-0.0326077826,
0.0774965733,
-0.0114610186,
0.0304764882,
0.0111226235,
0.0415788256,
0.0231090151,
0.0012672757,
0.0484156646,
0.0079740928,
-0.0394641273,
-0.0146368006,
-0.0136271166,
-0.0223508067,
0.0304806847,
0.0301739015,
-0.0676163584,
-0.00281261,
0.0142911971,
0.0215421021,
0.0314763226,
-0.0340208635,
0.0311301909,
-0.0261578895,
-0.0103515796,
0.001818253,
-0.0339068957,
0.0410603769,
-0.0830033422,
0.028485842,
0.0410481654,
0.0062333555,
-0.0507606231,
0.0000984311,
-0.0061938902,
-0.0218542982,
0.0175061766,
0.0074198586,
0.1034698933,
-0.0039350786,
-0.017133534,
0.0524712168,
0.0166513659,
-0.0377786271,
-0.0061352006,
-0.0357614942,
0.036362987,
0.0279909931,
0.0277126487,
-0.054147359,
-0.0461246669,
-0.0034352285,
-0.0199124999,
0.0149026187,
-0.0111908326,
0.010563937,
0.0361554623,
-0.0898766816,
-0.0086757662,
-0.031969253,
0.0361230113,
0.0480741486,
0.0488017164,
0.0319966041,
0.0581387356,
-0.0007390996,
0.0480610467,
0.0147631038,
-0.0451829471,
-0.0396706685,
0.0039335517,
-0.0085961185,
0.0101138772,
-0.0042501241,
-0.0072048511,
0.0163579881,
0.0608176179,
-0.026428096,
-0.0261658728,
-0.004855257,
-0.0517108515,
-0.0157679319,
0.0335735083,
0.0479522794,
0.0380757339,
-0.0360573009,
-0.0334804803,
-0.0587595329,
0.0631409287,
0.0076928469,
0.0456802212,
-0.0586742163,
0.0110873319,
0.0260502454,
-0.0123221604,
-0.0075685238,
0.0626499206,
-0.0205177758,
0.0136495782,
-0.0031474894,
0.0096964668,
0.007067115,
-0.0604447946,
-0.0639870688,
0.0065255472,
-0.0122848982,
0.0233441163,
0.0169726554,
-0.0407724902,
-0.0476915874,
-0.0062038177,
-0.0975872576,
0.0207854621,
-0.0375814214,
-0.0376540124,
-0.0024538485,
0.0307113379,
0.0208372381,
-0.035282068,
0.0226661582,
0.0144130187,
-0.0121319108,
0.0584004223,
-0.0135138882,
0.0512280576,
0.0333555676,
-0.033692807,
-0.0302410629,
0.0150556238,
0.0184103474,
-0.0499354899,
-0.0435035601,
0.0007474029,
-0.0068035875,
-0.0448570363,
0.0344613269,
-0.0423065424,
-0.0019341867,
0.0191452745,
-0.0795306861,
0.0125169987,
0.063211225,
0.0058237682,
0.0024740642,
0.0379583649,
-0.0063361581,
-0.06512063,
0.0239784513,
-0.0064775436,
-0.0329128653,
0.0193368029,
-0.0004707423,
-0.043984212,
0.0475635678,
-0.0221978705,
0.0003336771,
-0.0467843302,
-0.0105214287,
-0.0082279351,
-0.0183025058,
-0.0409839638,
-0.0083183302,
-0.0186924301,
0.032460507,
-0.0297830831,
-0.0393234007,
0.0650201216,
-0.0172571726,
-0.0423058793,
-0.0224660821,
-0.0221509915,
-0.0338441581,
0.0425250642,
0.0014027298,
-0.0002180965,
-0.0126261478,
-0.0132682463,
0.0027398882,
-0.0147619909,
0.0097003784,
-0.0284816213,
0.0552088507,
0.0016585466,
0.0394448638,
-0.0118077276,
-0.0189006664,
-0.0425979011,
0.0073046628,
0.0079214014,
0.0161553584,
-0.0140547538,
-0.0161842071,
-0.0686592683,
-0.0226537455,
0.0687740445,
0.0816080347,
-0.0184997972,
-0.0062671024,
-0.0201092102,
0.0160864815,
0.044160556,
0.0053655105,
-0.0389149077,
-0.0331789516,
-0.0480262861,
0.0313302465,
0.0274421368,
-0.0448362604,
-0.0372308269,
0.0019107276,
0.0202797465,
0.0146861216,
-0.0140055567,
0.0054931282,
0.0156370103,
-0.0355229229,
-0.0326818153,
0.0695524216,
0.0225109309,
-0.064530015,
-0.0556818545,
-0.0268723294,
0.0175658017,
0.0390017256,
0.0168600567,
-0.0962995663,
-0.0209926423,
0.0022858812,
0.0093254503,
0.0201207958,
-0.0004703077,
-0.0203281101,
-0.1334919482,
0.007925462,
0.0241186023,
-0.0307570249,
-0.0091635538,
-0.0375311859,
-0.0265136398,
-0.0196673367,
0.0236918069,
0.0253197514,
0.0003403574,
-0.0178589839,
0.0031281749,
0.0747611299,
-0.0642337427,
-0.0075430945,
-0.0119394744,
0.0370126665,
0.0211993493,
-0.0203977283,
0.0097634662,
-0.0106673604,
0.0135200908,
-0.0330309197,
0.0033245084,
-0.008186779,
0.0806672499,
-0.031110784,
0.0027534247,
0.0166472159,
-0.0042154407,
0.0299175195,
-0.0275221821,
-0.0411306322,
0.0485059023,
-0.0120682558,
0.0215820577,
-0.0270567909,
-0.0294388551,
-0.0196386073,
0.0539929606,
-0.0036237452,
0.0146108605,
0.0158276316,
0.0011483845,
0.0037490427,
-0.0227502231,
0.0472957231,
0.013237454,
-0.0191782322,
-0.0620678253,
-0.0539594144,
-0.0459215939,
0.0376554541,
0.0681798607,
-0.018620735,
0.0007903883,
-0.0387389883,
-0.0154527919,
-0.0469400026,
0.0435386486,
-0.0266191456,
-0.0323891789,
-0.0631503835,
-0.0194818154,
0.0221550912,
-0.0270232931,
-0.0023002673,
0.0104976008,
-0.0451855548,
-0.0627538785,
0.0060018296,
0.0828824639,
0.0247002598,
0.0752114803,
-0.0024136994,
-0.0486817248,
0.0518576913,
0.0413928591,
-0.0393796973,
0.0115675684,
0.0341061652,
-0.0115061523,
-0.0014739893,
0.0175036285,
-0.0825960264,
0.0306130778,
0.0106135653,
0.0237804204,
-0.0233983416,
0.0248403195,
0.0142018087,
0.0069806287,
0.0516884029,
0.0217803251,
0.0362147056,
-0.0314816311,
0.0137648014,
-0.0543369576,
-0.004349811,
-0.0297553036,
-0.0034834361,
0.0460029244,
-0.0418576971,
-0.0009514862,
0.0000746144,
-0.0015773823,
0.0668619573,
-0.0184690859,
-0.0425189957,
0.0444719754,
-0.0130605409,
0.0182924177,
0.0220961403,
-0.0512445085,
0.0213402659,
-0.0081205294,
0.0417210832,
-0.0490267128,
0.0482126437,
0.0083008949,
-0.006711877,
-0.0763025731,
0.0122507084,
-0.0784840733,
0.0071817269,
-0.0050313328,
0.0519920401,
0.0471469089,
-0.0487104654,
0.0624102093,
0.0003584957,
-0.0194090772,
-0.0216281656,
-0.0275712162,
0.004248586,
-0.035101749,
-0.0132378498,
0.0452721044,
0.0046042912,
0.0421080142,
0.0594301708,
-0.0154418275,
0.030558316,
-0.0244428702,
0.0193818901,
-0.0108615458,
0.0198941287,
0.0467789732,
0.0754164308,
-0.0086001977,
-0.0086289542,
-0.015348997,
-0.0492629036,
0.0353070162,
-0.0244482048,
-0.0306479074,
0.0300520826,
0.0268449914,
0.0513042025,
-0.0020602213,
-0.0217467993,
-0.017634552,
0.0022443498,
0.0284672361,
0.0041462695,
-0.0245608184,
-6.776628689e-33,
-0.0399641991,
0.0196305327,
0.0347317494,
-0.077706486,
0.0060927137,
0.009293234,
-0.0216504149,
0.0203329027,
-0.0469798185,
-0.0168979317,
-0.0175993405,
0.0051039751,
0.0190984197,
0.0391439945,
0.0058255754,
0.0189397093,
0.0517732203,
0.0120135499,
-0.0066204485,
0.0160894655,
0.0796170011,
0.0698922202,
0.0709983185,
-0.0097285211,
0.0136153642,
0.0034315069,
0.0097405547,
0.0250574742,
0.0337088704,
0.0419766232,
-0.0144433957,
0.0366547443,
0.0281548426,
-0.002972919,
-0.0141548179,
-0.0337348841,
-0.0984470397,
-0.0236718245,
0.0204708893,
-0.0285998993,
-0.011616759,
-0.0101760477,
0.029248748,
-0.0507435463,
0.0300596114,
-0.024628181,
0.0096640363,
-0.0112331612,
-0.0527907014,
-0.0061154873,
-0.0603605919,
0.0097984076,
0.030430859,
0.0212177187,
0.0437668897,
0.0228882879,
0.0126358438,
0.0557243787,
-0.0762907043,
-0.0082497336,
-0.0234699026,
0.0534271672,
0.0226657484,
0.0532804579,
-0.0033139028,
0.0687276497,
0.0229565315,
0.0051238653,
-0.0415459312,
-0.0336552374,
0.0784730613,
0.0179870091,
0.0104640182,
0.0259786807,
0.0775902569,
0.0002780957,
-0.0202911235,
0.008213819,
0.0293186624,
0.0729527995,
0.0265264641,
0.0556597561,
-0.0452057831,
0.002684861,
0.0019685985,
0.0075107859,
-0.0700061843,
-0.0444248728,
0.0384745337,
0.0581199341,
-0.0189422593,
-0.0079804352,
0.0655930042,
-0.0029860043,
0.0188968033,
0.036510177,
-0.0104452567,
0.0013871401,
-0.0197620038,
0.0392076038,
-0.0616833903,
-0.0431563929,
0.0527441166,
0.0234701913,
-0.0449089259,
0.0150143709,
0.0509262048,
0.0223641545,
-0.0543501563,
-0.0066644461,
-0.0335673243,
0.0057164654,
0.0027915405,
0.0421923436,
0.0247831848,
0.0540847033,
-0.0082315672,
0.0583876148,
0.0093194498,
0.0156445634,
-0.0084120808,
-0.0529503562,
0.0232241936,
-0.0106470305,
-0.016240336,
0.0318157226,
-0.0150070479,
0.0116853034,
0.026190348,
-0.0352943465,
0.020959124,
0.0422004536,
2.666e-7,
0.0253183786,
0.0181103311,
0.025309708,
-0.0260547437,
-0.02318356,
0.0080248481,
-0.0507395156,
0.0083389776,
0.0463643149,
-0.0290036239,
0.0029728345,
0.0436434634,
0.0055942982,
0.0224477667,
-0.0687170327,
0.006633841,
-0.0567756668,
-0.0143084563,
-0.0258052796,
-0.0296360217,
0.0290384404,
0.1202348843,
0.0302575286,
0.0068103843,
0.0240128897,
-0.0576809123,
0.0840742663,
0.0196550321,
-0.0247838274,
-0.0041315383,
0.0629780293,
0.0683253631,
-0.0110305827,
-0.0147575941,
-0.0062546269,
0.0226304587,
0.0003458845,
0.0400526598,
-0.0418125279,
-0.0608581565,
0.0170703419,
0.0124819158,
-0.0221136566,
-0.0223640334,
0.0840956941,
-0.0402086936,
-0.0059512672,
-0.0147113195,
-0.0666091219,
0.0373879038,
0.0109719178,
-0.0188844167,
-0.0206260551,
0.0201925542,
0.0069161067,
0.0318582579,
-0.0268143956,
-0.1135739982,
-0.0140170278,
0.0241955016,
-0.024226971,
-0.005909496,
-0.0238799658,
-0.0067513399,
0.0101020271,
-0.0702116713,
0.0009307931,
2.208811971e-34,
0.0520921052,
-0.002328336,
0.0245011747,
0.0276748743,
0.0061332122,
-0.0147216339,
-0.0690798089,
0.0263907798,
-0.0138275027,
-0.0729782358,
-0.0167145412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03693v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03693v6 | Concept Algebra for (Score-Based) Text-Controlled Generative Models | 2023-02-07T20:43:48 | 2024-02-08T02:43:08 | Zihao Wang, Lin Gui, Jeffrey Negrea, Victor Veitch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | This paper concerns the structure of learned representations in text-guided
generative models, focusing on score-based models. A key property of such
models is that they can compose disparate concepts in a `disentangled' manner.
This suggests these models have internal representations that encode concepts
in a `disentangled' manner. Here, we focus on the idea that concepts are
encoded as subspaces of some representation space. We formalize what this
means, show there's a natural choice for the representation, and develop a
simple method for identifying the part of the representation corresponding to a
given concept. In particular, this allows us to manipulate the concepts
expressed by the model through algebraic manipulation of the representation. We
demonstrate the idea with examples using Stable Diffusion. Code in
https://github.com/zihao12/concept-algebra-code | [
-0.0088998489,
0.0703305379,
-0.0382010639,
0.0417547859,
-0.0358278379,
0.0161724128,
-0.0013930729,
-0.0041964585,
-0.0657108575,
0.0141351009,
-0.0211146157,
-0.0148127386,
0.0097980518,
0.0811178312,
0.0360595137,
-0.098820284,
0.0114940275,
-0.0444022305,
-0.0408421084,
-0.028104594,
-0.0012518426,
-0.0598706156,
-0.0216157064,
-0.0082413005,
0.023922639,
-0.0529115796,
-0.0108272545,
-0.0751549155,
0.0021103364,
0.0240517892,
-0.0226979349,
0.0430158377,
0.0297186822,
0.0006430623,
0.0000020419,
-0.0096321255,
-0.0311868265,
0.0083259512,
0.0123162381,
-0.004017252,
0.0081240162,
0.0183299165,
-0.019004425,
-0.044232361,
-0.0272823609,
0.0052672625,
0.0660372525,
0.0457935221,
0.0543000512,
0.0392982624,
-0.0122470083,
-0.0882054493,
0.0546605773,
-0.0331963971,
0.0963544548,
-0.0152302412,
0.0407556444,
0.0369596742,
-0.0204001833,
0.0100416718,
-0.0715605915,
-0.0067442632,
0.0170073081,
-0.0185987111,
0.1039566249,
0.0462046862,
0.0411429703,
-0.0310616456,
0.0251630526,
0.0234078802,
0.0179583915,
-0.0175711066,
0.0000999482,
-0.006314653,
-0.01020303,
0.0273116864,
-0.0137576424,
0.0139499847,
-0.0036536837,
0.022389831,
-0.0078428183,
-0.0049946965,
-0.0011975649,
-0.0231048409,
-0.0258838665,
-0.0026803955,
0.0599105135,
0.0121847205,
-0.0426420718,
0.0391417146,
-0.0455755629,
-0.0305831861,
0.0077500846,
-0.006281612,
0.0574029721,
0.012178584,
-0.0064624506,
-0.0175113548,
-0.0279275738,
-0.0527536832,
0.0169131495,
0.0235708095,
0.0475591794,
0.0228180382,
-0.0126076192,
0.0829590634,
-0.0091034221,
0.0004390574,
-0.0622663796,
0.0264983848,
-0.049627915,
-0.0189510249,
-0.0555831753,
0.0301831421,
0.035135366,
0.002416997,
-0.0811334029,
0.0250778124,
-0.0567461997,
0.0136519913,
-0.0137178497,
-0.003542569,
-0.0541209169,
0.0206829421,
-0.0404652543,
0.0038586191,
-0.0354864039,
-0.002642222,
0.0202886015,
0.0309895016,
-0.0279196948,
-0.0270690415,
0.0177390631,
0.0239416473,
-0.0410419181,
-0.0165818594,
-0.0133860819,
-0.0032605291,
-0.0045706583,
0.0005988441,
-0.014873757,
-0.0410340987,
0.021334732,
-0.0373177603,
0.0223040413,
-0.0028203791,
0.0131376842,
-0.0911765993,
0.001455341,
-0.0274931882,
0.0061445986,
0.0276117511,
0.0416129306,
-0.0173430257,
0.0307487063,
0.0592571311,
-0.0101718465,
0.0423600711,
0.0118349614,
0.0510731936,
-0.038548898,
0.0136212418,
0.0435651988,
0.0066514444,
0.0665287822,
-0.0046272357,
-0.0471506491,
-0.0099866176,
0.0573513061,
0.0155622633,
0.0261376183,
0.0646003559,
-0.0699875504,
-0.0160163138,
0.0358690433,
0.047654368,
0.038878765,
0.0548520647,
0.0179785714,
-0.0239192992,
0.0028964956,
0.0610536486,
0.010168286,
0.0397361964,
-0.0545524433,
0.0215496104,
0.0040430245,
0.0242062695,
-0.0477997884,
-0.0641969591,
0.0212110523,
0.0141646983,
-0.0074544265,
-0.0526568219,
0.0608397461,
0.0319272019,
0.0034526531,
-0.0316328444,
0.028550515,
-0.0415880792,
0.0304888003,
-0.0513821505,
0.0574101694,
0.0813655481,
0.0496241152,
-0.0311068725,
0.0199920088,
0.008986922,
-0.0935183913,
0.0635901615,
-0.0328113064,
-0.0495826192,
-0.0326337703,
0.0146322539,
-0.0132296477,
-0.0204101633,
0.0164221805,
0.0136093507,
-0.0246201251,
-0.0181877855,
-0.0360392779,
0.0007541372,
-0.0044778404,
0.0335544422,
-0.0004565,
-0.0440803133,
-0.0098047769,
0.0044995318,
0.0362849347,
-0.0080992579,
-0.0156531706,
0.0088588754,
0.0112683363,
-0.0063425158,
-0.0512410328,
-0.0254869852,
-0.0174830835,
-0.0404148065,
0.0123191364,
-0.0286233909,
0.0227243472,
-0.0581958778,
-0.0142018842,
-0.0273230951,
0.0831071436,
-0.01929898,
0.0059679118,
-0.0237471852,
0.0214733575,
0.0047594211,
0.006369838,
0.0004095521,
0.0948743597,
-0.0092938663,
0.0279134642,
-0.0359141827,
0.0294436831,
0.0027492375,
0.0139804147,
0.0185601544,
0.0021327077,
0.0320298821,
0.0277747884,
0.0372452624,
-0.0205724463,
0.003943691,
-0.0232127234,
-0.0002566664,
-0.0317959152,
-0.0211218707,
0.0059514656,
0.0473542809,
-0.0006700711,
0.0056365067,
0.0390848964,
-0.0385349914,
0.0208764784,
-0.0028084889,
-0.0059749899,
-0.0213848818,
0.0151546737,
-0.0230702646,
-0.0218436923,
-0.0025776566,
-0.0004851992,
0.0552393869,
-0.003266297,
-0.0483579673,
-0.0447436795,
0.0633588359,
-0.0428703465,
0.0461078286,
-0.0234159641,
-0.021159526,
0.0116522899,
-0.0644297376,
0.0739297569,
0.0493886992,
0.0110989399,
0.0909740329,
0.0621431917,
-0.0174333844,
-0.0056812214,
-0.0068122968,
-0.0721328184,
0.0142262438,
0.0133841829,
-0.0020334236,
-0.0085193394,
0.088508442,
0.0109808119,
-0.0396801345,
-0.0645751879,
0.0510808975,
-0.0200369395,
-0.0226417258,
-0.0650747865,
0.0105260806,
0.0130936028,
0.0047733099,
-0.0372753702,
-0.0514957383,
0.0568040311,
0.0140742455,
0.0044160313,
-0.0287753679,
-0.0111506088,
0.0008192066,
0.0858132541,
0.045527257,
0.0063229618,
0.0784038752,
0.0356909595,
-0.044648692,
0.0143090477,
0.0520790145,
-0.0000860346,
-0.0076355389,
-0.0364997983,
0.0181521941,
0.0327854529,
-0.0043141576,
-0.0498574488,
0.033657372,
0.0484822094,
-0.0014205254,
0.0361548774,
-0.0079376474,
-0.0026498269,
-0.0001231178,
0.0454660729,
-0.0097378399,
-0.0006863542,
-0.0322411396,
-0.0032614754,
0.0365086608,
0.0633644015,
-0.0400500856,
-0.0380198285,
-0.0432168283,
0.0043336302,
0.0583738014,
-0.0528408512,
-0.032634858,
0.0176915769,
0.0400383845,
0.0168075636,
-0.0165916663,
0.0045958161,
0.02958172,
-0.0079208883,
-0.0239848755,
-0.0773353055,
0.0389682874,
0.0449055135,
0.0157629699,
0.0147305885,
-0.0084805489,
0.0385778025,
0.0265548676,
0.0274801645,
-0.0578224063,
0.0276691411,
-0.0228641946,
-0.0243515484,
0.0107266149,
-0.0102776885,
-0.0000521143,
-0.0147419646,
0.0074082036,
0.0339649357,
-0.0486902781,
-0.0573361479,
-0.026375968,
0.0261284187,
-0.0021187752,
-0.0757411942,
-0.0125598656,
0.033207655,
0.054674454,
0.0109830732,
0.0359621793,
-0.0272213239,
-0.0100928983,
-0.0160266981,
0.0085069602,
0.0930272043,
0.0053040786,
0.021672314,
-0.0780946314,
-0.0647054538,
-0.0341602564,
-0.0260044374,
0.0012797272,
0.0334552526,
0.0217919033,
-0.0094073368,
-0.0057969373,
0.0631280541,
0.017115565,
-0.0561802015,
-0.0300495625,
0.0871053934,
-0.0067490865,
-0.0446037203,
-0.001178026,
-0.0224812534,
0.0478402935,
0.0585996732,
0.0285233054,
-0.0390880555,
-0.0154796196,
-0.0662008449,
0.0114847096,
0.0279257726,
-0.0971657932,
-0.0255170763,
0.0056757266,
-0.0460123271,
-0.1064727455,
0.0167868417,
0.0068036732,
0.02723605,
-0.0008083858,
-0.0094450144,
0.0084893527,
-0.0550362952,
-0.0261282828,
-0.017129045,
-0.0152745498,
-0.0176162347,
-0.0049293102,
-0.1082788706,
0.0291256551,
-0.0447977185,
-0.0631288663,
0.0238333568,
-0.0390733927,
-0.0611481369,
0.0450615175,
0.0587441027,
0.0215618126,
-0.0251038671,
-0.0114578241,
-0.0138753522,
0.0939167589,
0.0176597238,
-0.0268655289,
0.06120288,
-0.0036193135,
0.0286707152,
0.0074356333,
0.0244164225,
-0.0354984365,
0.0709077269,
0.0181897562,
0.0016995278,
-0.0143792015,
0.0369675308,
0.0240392294,
-0.0401153564,
0.0321474709,
0.0364414528,
-0.0210999083,
-0.0489801876,
-0.0316811651,
-0.0393679738,
-0.0443426818,
-0.0556111485,
-0.032672938,
0.0384233333,
-0.0065151541,
-0.0134171452,
0.0073294146,
0.0436029993,
0.0445197709,
-0.0161828585,
-0.0615018718,
0.0327103734,
0.0099186758,
-0.002197908,
0.0521494523,
0.05521008,
-0.0065330416,
-0.0142366569,
0.0084380666,
-0.0120392041,
0.0402046889,
0.0288190376,
0.0053198724,
-0.0243205074,
-0.033537332,
-0.0756303519,
-0.019079553,
-0.0368992202,
0.0346917808,
0.0515875295,
0.0576410256,
-0.0016357488,
-0.0346649773,
-0.0160252061,
-0.028613748,
0.0090970453,
0.0199964512,
-0.0271799248,
0.0092175435,
0.0211550072,
0.0329606049,
-0.062379241,
0.0762356147,
-0.0485029556,
0.049275849,
-0.0521945171,
0.0049610743,
-0.0258013494,
-0.0279373396,
-0.0063098674,
0.0139303701,
0.0130520742,
-0.0004760055,
-0.0763036907,
-0.0173774175,
-0.0069020623,
0.0411626548,
0.0350949019,
-0.004223513,
0.0587644503,
0.0264494941,
-0.0466083884,
-0.0124425879,
-0.0184986815,
0.0406708196,
-0.0151149807,
-0.0141130229,
-0.0070190346,
-6.057172882e-33,
-0.0968117863,
-0.0094564846,
0.0226979237,
0.0441951193,
-0.027618235,
0.0059352973,
-0.0226952564,
0.0104741743,
0.0436855704,
0.0175396558,
0.0262398068,
0.0394797139,
-0.0253495704,
-0.0005488382,
-0.0263387021,
0.0026595076,
0.0390835553,
-0.0326573253,
-0.0397002585,
0.0524304137,
0.0461862125,
-0.0027151087,
0.0088332919,
-0.0383999944,
0.037780717,
-0.0063693481,
-0.0225675087,
-0.0364954062,
0.0184435435,
0.0483173653,
-0.0797673166,
-0.0127193769,
-0.0080326935,
-0.0408520624,
-0.0563547537,
-0.0072933682,
-0.0315211788,
-0.0451240428,
-0.0151466122,
-0.0229872912,
-0.0455861613,
-0.0286633968,
0.0646483079,
0.018262608,
-0.0321719311,
-0.0066180229,
0.0371756367,
-0.014567907,
0.0233050566,
-0.0253518336,
-0.0719111115,
-0.0091922265,
-0.0335079469,
-0.003244349,
0.027256079,
-0.0600949265,
0.0027000369,
0.0067237439,
-0.0078297835,
0.0333840139,
0.04607917,
0.0594125316,
0.0189299509,
0.0193099137,
0.0447271727,
0.0710869431,
0.0302673914,
-0.0436411127,
-0.0229700357,
-0.0335999355,
-0.0060784207,
0.0233547185,
0.0410278738,
0.0146928327,
0.0406038724,
-0.0049390756,
-0.0598879606,
0.0562845394,
-0.04189533,
0.0266397484,
0.0084820101,
0.0397302359,
-0.0077593531,
-0.0285742972,
-0.0413719825,
-0.0540185161,
-0.0301880594,
-0.0021930505,
0.0009195781,
0.0125073707,
-0.0366365276,
-0.0282805581,
0.0135876276,
-0.0250716116,
-0.0397657342,
0.0241602194,
-0.0429964326,
0.0662170351,
0.0341887847,
-0.003313689,
-0.034957435,
-0.0206748173,
0.0422612764,
0.0439928658,
0.0052126744,
0.0175399333,
-0.0084585613,
0.0363795124,
-0.0285027735,
-0.0034797867,
-0.0416106395,
-0.0452463664,
-0.0004108442,
-0.0106942728,
0.0043059732,
0.0035687117,
-0.0001290015,
0.014353497,
0.0148060536,
0.0111417314,
-0.008840153,
-0.0420171991,
-0.0183755439,
0.0621779785,
-0.0118234726,
0.004991286,
-0.006188822,
0.0156848934,
0.1024871767,
-0.0370595269,
-0.0181501396,
-0.0061518559,
2.715e-7,
0.0359163545,
0.030865144,
0.0007451119,
0.0171955694,
0.0472221784,
0.0153968437,
-0.0159796439,
0.0166787151,
0.0336731002,
-0.0354663841,
0.0124644442,
0.045260299,
-0.0363571458,
0.0029843855,
-0.0137195969,
0.0361912847,
0.0248434413,
0.0049124276,
0.0009193847,
-0.0119888037,
0.0758380964,
0.0341211297,
0.0194901582,
0.0347139351,
0.005424371,
0.046543017,
0.1006935313,
0.0082140397,
0.0178015884,
0.0149209527,
-0.0116625335,
-0.02302761,
-0.0059309565,
-0.021756297,
-0.0048752395,
0.0271595269,
0.0509290919,
0.0327848643,
-0.0068678837,
0.0322408006,
-0.0207053609,
0.0023497925,
-0.0108997393,
-0.0253462251,
0.0394994318,
-0.044104021,
-0.0110780913,
0.0142266005,
-0.0257962458,
0.0424971543,
-0.0018416697,
0.0223450568,
-0.0452937819,
-0.0103682857,
-0.0247094128,
0.0509035178,
0.010781494,
-0.0316754505,
-0.0015873308,
-0.0221287627,
-0.0213599484,
-0.0606699139,
-0.0269665997,
-0.0263565835,
-0.0255589597,
-0.0394500867,
-0.0359321013,
2.842332254e-34,
0.0060216775,
-0.0081137959,
-0.0101415263,
0.0064127622,
-0.0002198733,
-0.0572829284,
-0.0166817158,
0.0133896014,
0.0378033221,
-0.0576743782,
-0.0368334912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03716v1 | Mining Effective Features Using Quantum Entropy for Humor Recognition | 2023-02-07T19:09:09 | 2023-02-07T19:09:09 | Yang Liu, Yuexian Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humor recognition has been extensively studied with different methods in the
past years. However, existing studies on humor recognition do not understand
the mechanisms that generate humor. In this paper, inspired by the incongruity
theory, any joke can be divided into two components (the setup and the
punchline). Both components have multiple possible semantics, and there is an
incongruous relationship between them. We use density matrices to represent the
semantic uncertainty of the setup and the punchline, respectively, and design
QE-Uncertainty and QE-Incongruity with the help of quantum entropy as features
for humor recognition. The experimental results on the SemEval2021 Task 7
dataset show that the proposed features are more effective than the baselines
for recognizing humorous and non-humorous texts. | [
0.0528708473,
0.0545673929,
-0.0318626687,
0.0578667633,
-0.0169307254,
0.0305415802,
-0.0122462036,
0.0697286054,
0.0452445,
-0.0655122176,
0.0012568277,
-0.0285385624,
0.0146820685,
0.0235500056,
-0.0218638256,
-0.0673212931,
-0.0122609911,
0.0288008079,
-0.0306341257,
-0.0658438355,
-0.041358795,
-0.0553645194,
-0.0353133604,
-0.0064151594,
0.04895005,
0.0573250428,
0.0209608935,
0.0853224695,
0.040214207,
0.0096374098,
-0.0568072274,
0.0425191373,
-0.0333152339,
-0.0324041806,
0.000001342,
-0.0748727247,
-0.0116011705,
-0.0278890897,
0.0231211577,
-0.0033354114,
0.0180486962,
-0.0330727622,
-0.0700835958,
-0.0193384178,
-0.0056913611,
0.0441371724,
0.0884727612,
0.0409352556,
-0.0101402821,
0.0632883236,
-0.0063014035,
-0.0146968449,
0.0007463129,
0.0040389588,
0.0461316817,
-0.0569336526,
0.0497412272,
0.015862057,
-0.0404777713,
-0.0250974353,
-0.0513594858,
-0.0097375531,
-0.022261247,
0.0460839011,
-0.0198172368,
0.0447963327,
0.0178304762,
0.0476518497,
-0.0311156698,
0.0588514023,
-0.0280400403,
0.0172988065,
0.0164262466,
0.0146092372,
-0.0227526277,
-0.0262667071,
-0.004877097,
0.0067833099,
0.0011683189,
0.0063288277,
0.0048427628,
0.0599184483,
-0.010481514,
0.0217452124,
0.0448680967,
0.0307793245,
0.0398876108,
-0.0414020829,
-0.0179659128,
-0.0339595824,
-0.0816496089,
0.0148875611,
0.0260151215,
0.029606767,
0.0598393232,
0.0354904719,
0.0003658642,
-0.0340322815,
0.0545305833,
-0.0812009349,
-0.0285722129,
0.0244259927,
-0.013768604,
0.0755980462,
-0.0073299026,
0.0370595008,
0.0116450069,
-0.0025515573,
-0.0227484014,
0.0016594555,
-0.0167980343,
0.0511462465,
-0.001095136,
0.0367523842,
0.0197904557,
-0.0434427634,
-0.0871139243,
0.0348341465,
0.0268206745,
-0.000616463,
0.0093211401,
0.0605734438,
-0.0101920934,
-0.012451224,
0.0098783216,
0.0209869053,
-0.0348043852,
-0.0125163235,
-0.0972152948,
-0.0214626621,
-0.0085220635,
0.0507403128,
0.0294187907,
-0.0404484868,
0.0080478704,
0.0665593967,
0.051453501,
-0.1023948938,
-0.0049168286,
0.0338083059,
-0.1008907333,
-0.0126199359,
0.0332939327,
-0.0221889392,
-0.0125203645,
-0.008249172,
0.0174827054,
-0.0215122886,
0.0018889051,
-0.0139853712,
-0.0402239226,
0.0224204026,
-0.0177978538,
-0.0463313907,
0.0356117673,
0.0012632214,
-0.001325677,
0.0207133684,
0.0139135728,
-0.0047075823,
0.0287774596,
-0.0331279375,
-0.0087838918,
-0.0515127666,
-0.0097851213,
-0.0035212061,
-0.0424314998,
-0.0148876579,
-0.0392518677,
0.0116753932,
0.003690003,
0.0111174751,
-0.0152151911,
-0.0150230769,
-0.022372717,
0.0377296768,
0.0058901994,
0.0434146263,
-0.0312439632,
-0.0294621307,
-0.0066203754,
0.0380264632,
-0.0138623985,
0.0509018227,
-0.0934782773,
-0.0004432224,
0.0512089096,
0.0169906691,
-0.0022596805,
-0.0572221503,
-0.0314488113,
-0.0124154771,
0.0398450345,
-0.0433364473,
0.0786744803,
0.0046079447,
-0.0286047086,
-0.0285242014,
0.0229128227,
-0.0288173985,
-0.0264467075,
0.0056015071,
0.0022092885,
0.0904944092,
0.0323298052,
-0.0230426397,
0.0375838093,
0.024243677,
-0.0484741665,
-0.0065988167,
-0.0033371376,
0.0444612317,
0.0254245494,
-0.0238621924,
0.0002448312,
-0.0360511057,
0.0289150309,
0.0070109507,
0.004257062,
0.0595170371,
-0.0055279969,
0.0408212058,
0.0773877278,
0.0186549574,
-0.0207695439,
-0.0118736085,
0.0088988505,
-0.0001161777,
0.064615421,
-0.0012564327,
-0.0182230771,
-0.008656295,
0.0336262323,
-0.0566093437,
-0.0560418777,
0.0170708839,
-0.0068358439,
-0.0362890139,
0.0233062413,
-0.0469949879,
0.0325785764,
-0.0181162059,
0.0017170288,
-0.0284178536,
0.0970256478,
-0.045202028,
0.0019156728,
-0.0606096126,
-0.0318853781,
-0.0333128199,
0.0422541164,
-0.0263672881,
0.1095995307,
-0.0115134194,
0.0784131512,
-0.019402476,
-0.0363384262,
0.0087296749,
-0.0207344033,
-0.0089610079,
0.0247231666,
-0.0014914266,
0.0240706746,
-0.0135741932,
-0.0233889632,
0.0398404747,
-0.008641799,
-0.0603600256,
0.0081668524,
-0.0019224874,
-0.0200034231,
0.0312576145,
-0.0205346234,
-0.021542279,
-0.0160666108,
0.0113690877,
-0.0064077983,
-0.0194169655,
-0.0240030643,
-0.0019041841,
0.0081332587,
-0.0290076621,
-0.0069313976,
-0.0008928868,
-0.025038179,
0.0266788509,
-0.0221613757,
0.0457326807,
-0.0250240192,
0.0490799472,
-0.0462827235,
-0.0240767859,
-0.0091503887,
-0.0758948997,
-0.0216959938,
-0.0078985225,
-0.0004500076,
0.0293419659,
0.054850854,
0.0418555737,
0.0684390292,
-0.0066452213,
0.019281622,
-0.0095607778,
-0.0390209854,
0.1182194948,
-0.0090515735,
-0.0467875078,
0.0004550126,
-0.0216505639,
0.0392205156,
0.0512416735,
-0.0725726336,
0.0167789347,
0.0171372257,
0.024600992,
-0.0189038068,
-0.0188487191,
-0.0281056874,
-0.0032082626,
0.0121235214,
0.0293929912,
0.0742253065,
-0.0016650934,
0.0008879688,
-0.0607716516,
-0.0347149521,
-0.0046172934,
0.0622484647,
-0.0373719484,
0.0637355223,
-0.0153462533,
0.0026743191,
0.0039891559,
-0.0366367102,
0.0132655902,
-0.0156922918,
0.0026263432,
0.0242077932,
-0.0239029359,
-0.0073844455,
-0.0016301572,
0.0168498959,
-0.0424772091,
-0.0427996665,
-0.0075304261,
-0.0591547601,
-0.0507762618,
0.0142598012,
0.0357257649,
-0.0031799693,
-0.065161258,
-0.0354344994,
-0.0071811727,
0.0118121644,
0.021506099,
0.055906523,
0.013504846,
0.0473287962,
0.046285443,
-0.0175669156,
0.0144989444,
-0.0413746759,
0.0302258357,
0.0088667031,
-0.0135514094,
0.0253260061,
0.0166616216,
0.0070309499,
0.006252185,
0.026041789,
0.0420328751,
-0.0112899523,
0.0495879687,
0.0229577459,
0.0318485238,
0.0189247802,
0.0110329501,
-0.0502937809,
-0.0020140188,
-0.015438715,
-0.0399474949,
-0.0385197252,
-0.0141791971,
0.0044785836,
-0.0242562834,
0.0086210016,
-0.0152435163,
-0.0242428463,
0.0077039925,
0.0368966274,
0.0044587483,
-0.0563992746,
-0.0070836199,
0.0247124247,
-0.0296152737,
-0.0500313081,
-0.0231728014,
-0.0008514231,
-0.0039816508,
0.0217221715,
0.0288620908,
-0.0498706959,
0.0092271743,
0.0328106545,
0.0247705188,
0.0481390841,
0.0374685265,
-0.0335042365,
-0.0617985018,
-0.086677745,
-0.1229978949,
-0.0251586754,
-0.0009343662,
0.0363601483,
0.0142463678,
0.0085392054,
-0.0273108222,
0.0026973032,
-0.0070510344,
-0.0076936753,
0.0009619014,
0.0037539911,
-0.0503972024,
-0.0561382808,
-0.0190824624,
0.0209645741,
-0.042640388,
0.1017277166,
-0.009801425,
-0.0172274467,
-0.033016976,
-0.0145316301,
0.0237513985,
-0.015388988,
0.0106376018,
-0.0343534984,
0.0061376342,
-0.0607007593,
-0.0757052377,
0.0239164103,
-0.0399319343,
0.0382631458,
-0.0282702986,
-0.0344486088,
-0.0546400324,
0.032071311,
-0.0126276743,
-0.0712767392,
0.0219453461,
-0.0354282707,
-0.0183459576,
0.0286148582,
0.0160297211,
-0.0744860396,
-0.0306019802,
-0.0007105918,
-0.0076094912,
-0.0507331043,
0.0539775416,
0.0211622026,
0.0234001838,
-0.0596665889,
-0.0250898134,
-0.03230533,
0.031926021,
0.0939495638,
0.009621012,
0.0231233612,
0.0256510191,
0.0213200822,
0.009891931,
0.0147635657,
-0.0127411392,
0.0094592758,
0.0219448842,
0.0077425563,
-0.068513684,
-0.1145280898,
-0.0306602903,
-0.0280726217,
0.0405238271,
0.0038342029,
-0.0684784278,
0.0628343076,
0.0001301527,
0.0121138198,
0.0277355444,
-0.01600595,
-0.0196685009,
0.0408868864,
0.0294514783,
-0.0405103602,
0.0042052837,
-0.0141178565,
-0.004664138,
0.0121067399,
-0.0163343865,
0.0369589776,
0.0086135874,
-0.025876455,
0.0139275379,
-0.038104929,
-0.001099508,
0.0115057323,
-0.0022005402,
0.0434204079,
-0.00430683,
0.0192736201,
-0.0381710418,
-0.0126027009,
0.0326782875,
-0.071962826,
-0.0117723728,
0.0028008751,
0.0222544931,
0.0737224221,
0.050981421,
0.0380238146,
-0.0609543435,
0.0220559835,
0.0192363225,
0.0276672412,
0.0273237173,
-0.0269656461,
0.0525077097,
0.0171787776,
-0.0224013235,
-0.042365741,
0.0413518175,
-0.0440075584,
0.0454545431,
0.0272757132,
-0.0143387765,
-0.0306739751,
-0.0165702049,
0.0032856127,
0.0567195304,
-0.0124990279,
0.0492470153,
-0.028870143,
0.0022400657,
0.0514892526,
-0.0306400936,
0.0264519174,
-0.0276944004,
0.0412990339,
0.0557802394,
0.0009775073,
-0.0096848961,
-0.0219625868,
0.0001526071,
-0.035007704,
0.0186389182,
-0.0315579735,
-5.082424313e-33,
-0.0104485778,
-0.0298384428,
-0.0700747594,
0.0375772975,
0.0622187406,
-0.023929419,
-0.0435201973,
0.0124247419,
-0.0202004556,
-0.0238568299,
0.0542366467,
0.0000159172,
0.0005850044,
-0.0514687859,
0.0080940481,
-0.023694938,
0.0169257503,
0.022565918,
0.000911572,
-0.0065891603,
0.0385784544,
0.0026169426,
0.0506719239,
-0.0445290208,
-0.0025353872,
0.0054898653,
-0.0168005284,
0.0250640195,
0.0507688783,
0.0104533108,
-0.0444791205,
0.0522746071,
-0.0080225971,
0.046292197,
0.0320959985,
-0.0229608752,
-0.0003120478,
-0.0379356742,
0.012630716,
0.0000799732,
-0.0022263655,
-0.018662123,
0.0360377394,
-0.0095574493,
-0.0468123332,
0.0070070173,
0.042887304,
-0.0109011568,
0.0275134463,
-0.0523853973,
-0.0022318056,
0.0113063063,
-0.0245740414,
-0.0103088031,
0.006939197,
0.0040022689,
0.0377529524,
-0.0085901553,
-0.0232789796,
0.0535184518,
-0.0363009162,
-0.0303874239,
-0.0694178492,
-0.0560150482,
0.0227804147,
0.0546653084,
0.0103624687,
-0.009457265,
0.0179854203,
-0.0298022944,
0.0125217298,
-0.0033649844,
0.0687705278,
0.0593380779,
0.096409373,
-0.0400051512,
-0.0358426273,
0.0049823951,
0.0707658753,
-0.0226466469,
0.0397930518,
0.0080927173,
-0.0661385134,
0.0026977938,
0.0873693451,
0.0390749983,
0.0001940991,
-0.0957633778,
-0.0271119699,
0.0210144576,
-0.0145665267,
0.0108646536,
0.0087667741,
-0.0276667774,
0.0067816013,
0.0279031117,
0.0203594323,
0.0431732647,
0.0377210081,
-0.0392733365,
0.0002571989,
-0.0479347371,
0.0563319288,
0.0300771948,
-0.0011543807,
-0.0111290812,
0.0433978029,
-0.006789892,
-0.0157816056,
0.0173475966,
0.006509426,
-0.0104494896,
0.005147974,
-0.0225884859,
-0.0438152663,
0.0535957031,
-0.0182132348,
-0.042301394,
0.0090600289,
0.0524550714,
-0.0195486434,
0.0471574292,
-0.0054647978,
0.0503240265,
-0.0252431892,
-0.0422583148,
-0.0124413865,
-0.1025615707,
-0.0405698195,
-0.0454438664,
0.0146328881,
-0.0272910856,
2.484e-7,
0.0221674722,
0.0149094602,
0.0056183524,
-0.0228453856,
0.0532012507,
0.028321499,
-0.0256781802,
0.0119293882,
0.0067971945,
0.0282233115,
0.0320382193,
0.005697974,
-0.0338539146,
0.0079874042,
-0.0501157902,
0.007598415,
-0.0252608079,
0.0009542144,
0.005748942,
0.0380735844,
0.0684232637,
0.0214800518,
0.0322441347,
0.0346153602,
0.0326946452,
-0.0316710807,
0.0230238214,
-0.0149660157,
0.0581644773,
-0.0249764845,
-0.0272555221,
0.0045212172,
0.0148025155,
-0.0046291701,
0.0208369698,
-0.0375249498,
-0.0192300919,
0.0162215624,
-0.0035213118,
-0.0403025039,
-0.0174951274,
0.0127132619,
0.004849175,
-0.0209838208,
0.036343623,
0.0425999314,
-0.0482976511,
-0.0069809793,
-0.0355036892,
0.011511093,
0.0837419704,
0.0464082249,
-0.0208995547,
-0.0147768306,
0.0256895479,
-0.0135807442,
0.0114414021,
-0.041056063,
-0.0233995225,
0.0315646082,
-0.0216752682,
-0.0079748407,
-0.0108546978,
-0.0520666838,
0.0439076275,
-0.1100981757,
-0.0029058128,
1.937500299e-34,
0.0271251369,
0.0303314477,
0.0115831513,
-0.0185339786,
-0.0246348865,
0.0174162537,
-0.0105868019,
-0.0201607496,
0.0322247446,
0.0247349851,
0.0055856812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04089v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04089v2 | ZipLM: Inference-Aware Structured Pruning of Language Models | 2023-02-07T18:55:28 | 2023-10-26T06:42:40 | Eldar Kurtic, Elias Frantar, Dan Alistarh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The breakthrough performance of large language models (LLMs) comes with major
computational footprints and high deployment costs. In this paper, we progress
towards resolving this problem by proposing a novel structured compression
approach for LLMs, called ZipLM. ZipLM achieves state-of-the-art
accuracy-vs-speedup, while matching a set of desired target runtime speedups in
any given inference environment. Specifically, given a model, a dataset, an
inference environment, as well as a set of speedup targets, ZipLM iteratively
identifies and removes components with the worst loss-runtime trade-off. Unlike
prior methods that specialize in either the post-training/one-shot or the
gradual compression setting, and only for specific families of models such as
BERT (encoder) or GPT (decoder), ZipLM produces state-of-the-art compressed
models across all these settings. Furthermore, ZipLM achieves superior results
for a fraction of the computational cost relative to prior distillation and
pruning techniques, making it a cost-effective approach for generating an
entire family of smaller, faster, and highly accurate models, guaranteed to
meet the desired inference specifications. In particular, ZipLM outperforms all
prior BERT-base distillation and pruning techniques, such as CoFi, MiniLM, and
TinyBERT. Moreover, it matches the performance of the heavily optimized
MobileBERT model, obtained via extensive architecture search, by simply pruning
the baseline BERT-large model. When compressing GPT2, ZipLM outperforms
DistilGPT2 while being 60% smaller and 30% faster. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/IST-DASLab/ZipLM. | [
-0.0227375887,
0.1001502723,
-0.0006367874,
0.0299578551,
-0.0462653749,
0.0167321637,
-0.0048864596,
0.0400778949,
-0.0451843999,
0.0070672398,
-0.0120022316,
0.0087058144,
0.0263780002,
-0.0173092578,
0.0176804941,
-0.0350291096,
0.01493893,
-0.0191724785,
0.0037279453,
-0.0106159328,
0.0065238313,
0.0284612197,
0.0302556939,
0.0393034816,
0.0225298628,
-0.0208532698,
-0.0218883324,
0.0259791147,
-0.0248671286,
0.0130476123,
-0.0075794952,
0.0638367459,
0.0340668634,
0.0185490698,
0.00000222,
-0.0124277873,
-0.0187497735,
0.0109307468,
-0.0440054648,
0.0632373318,
0.0344161764,
-0.0155894449,
-0.0094314134,
0.030176267,
0.0175948646,
-0.054765895,
0.0401625894,
0.0080259591,
0.0477782339,
0.0762326866,
0.0019944347,
-0.0468530282,
-0.0025691122,
-0.0350151062,
-0.0528120622,
-0.0314446166,
0.0108506875,
-0.0090019451,
-0.0118335625,
-0.0145832831,
-0.0254239086,
0.0098394323,
0.0420407206,
0.0572987162,
-0.0537579283,
0.0317606628,
-0.0591746382,
-0.0413858145,
0.023949828,
0.0401776657,
-0.0306920931,
-0.0586645454,
0.0072055482,
0.0097056888,
-0.0089192139,
-0.0443117842,
-0.0330390334,
0.0468422659,
-0.0064117154,
0.037967559,
0.0207352918,
-0.0235936921,
0.0414943025,
-0.007428125,
-0.0520795509,
0.03653704,
0.0477954485,
0.0015224393,
-0.0357215926,
-0.0273894276,
-0.0171208736,
-0.0506744199,
-0.0026894142,
-0.0123520885,
0.017874321,
-0.0157449488,
-0.0750586018,
-0.0205730684,
0.0006014972,
-0.0094591659,
0.0349914618,
0.0389255509,
0.021397464,
0.0183270443,
-0.0142183006,
0.0562015735,
0.0120990258,
-0.020534195,
-0.0371039286,
-0.0222755857,
0.0029836481,
0.0098471297,
-0.05290097,
0.0375925936,
-0.0515822992,
0.0101965917,
-0.0191593692,
0.0002915248,
-0.0039571361,
-0.0124597447,
0.0516563468,
-0.0158561375,
-0.0209092852,
-0.0069383034,
0.023102235,
0.0455534458,
-0.0496998504,
-0.0021175789,
-0.0277553648,
-0.0809298903,
-0.0171958096,
0.0333182141,
0.0058663855,
-0.0336375982,
0.0381547101,
0.0467273742,
0.0089922482,
-0.0565913655,
-0.0402747467,
0.006100812,
0.0143075772,
-0.0642183647,
0.0023244838,
-0.0867493749,
0.0285923313,
-0.0256520882,
0.0062081288,
-0.0523849241,
-0.0106768785,
0.0203148294,
-0.0420408919,
0.0423174202,
-0.0091554755,
0.0232659783,
-0.0047666649,
-0.0005383327,
0.0391389355,
0.08363913,
0.030708272,
0.0219809245,
-0.0009721209,
-0.0271862615,
-0.0544825867,
0.0629638731,
0.0455494523,
0.0250058342,
-0.0520523153,
-0.0059560938,
-0.0414569192,
0.0023740428,
0.0629392862,
0.0871984139,
-0.0528750643,
-0.0439652316,
0.0482929647,
0.0400412939,
0.0398984402,
0.0621759593,
0.0103757884,
0.039608594,
0.0166600365,
-0.0002969948,
-0.0167878941,
0.0002370417,
-0.0305893887,
-0.0045818756,
0.0252841655,
0.0502987057,
-0.0435754173,
-0.0074464045,
-0.0524170473,
-0.0273351204,
0.0207035728,
0.0100922622,
0.0446166024,
0.0146762216,
-0.0411877967,
0.0958316624,
0.0317871049,
-0.0517319739,
-0.0336508192,
-0.07299795,
-0.0161232781,
0.0186514836,
0.0521920957,
0.0232181586,
-0.0323673226,
0.0283400081,
-0.0159434304,
-0.0061405497,
0.0093009165,
0.0025912249,
0.0375370681,
-0.0633999035,
-0.0074119829,
0.0172102712,
0.0265003517,
0.0095315529,
0.06168212,
0.0027635966,
0.0040625986,
-0.0532568805,
0.0185295288,
0.0237905439,
-0.0434125625,
-0.0133633427,
0.0201441776,
-0.0036049841,
0.0378432423,
-0.0182583686,
-0.0408677012,
0.0016771411,
0.0522899516,
-0.0386074185,
0.0133395111,
-0.0335668027,
-0.0138912704,
-0.0848579928,
0.0334007889,
-0.0197597817,
0.0203345213,
0.0892559439,
-0.0459972844,
-0.0140014105,
0.0051878653,
-0.0667551905,
0.0525891744,
-0.0482809693,
0.0129473796,
-0.0031282557,
0.0131270308,
0.0071043377,
0.0336762741,
-0.0488342345,
0.0135200229,
0.0581152439,
-0.0064104339,
-0.0071884175,
-0.0275120176,
-0.0318744108,
0.0217125807,
-0.0255205967,
0.0052080946,
0.0208602622,
0.0238118861,
0.0198639557,
-0.0075014094,
-0.0814999118,
0.0097235255,
-0.0375728011,
0.023664685,
0.0146444654,
0.04149694,
-0.0083411895,
0.0030731161,
0.0010999134,
-0.0057472871,
-0.0039390204,
0.0347113796,
-0.0087915156,
-0.0422693603,
-0.0399566293,
-0.0081876721,
-0.0453086458,
0.0236028302,
0.0710137114,
-0.0718180016,
-0.0452898256,
-0.0216102824,
0.023842318,
-0.0223041214,
0.0202444326,
-0.0041830479,
-0.0626126453,
-0.0218796451,
-0.0356560424,
0.0499645174,
0.0405212976,
-0.0035440847,
0.0386016257,
0.042452246,
-0.0103940181,
-0.0479147136,
0.0234379433,
-0.0205725562,
-0.0244406257,
-0.0160635319,
-0.0844123811,
-0.0108717978,
0.0953566208,
-0.0040792543,
-0.0011619695,
-0.07542409,
-0.0350663774,
0.0036607215,
-0.030289406,
-0.0100207739,
0.00425496,
-0.001352859,
0.0170582552,
-0.0145870987,
-0.0669429377,
0.0471108481,
-0.0563899092,
-0.0044311592,
-0.0197923668,
-0.0118936226,
-0.0414174423,
0.0786766782,
0.0375762768,
0.0343673974,
-0.0063962978,
-0.0055046068,
-0.0474261083,
0.025117375,
0.000766329,
-0.0375780798,
-0.0107344147,
-0.030304864,
0.0184286665,
-0.0226617809,
-0.0304793976,
-0.0000938695,
-0.0044474835,
-0.015901031,
0.0258859787,
0.0324984714,
-0.0396905728,
-0.0165886953,
0.0236177072,
-0.0172558837,
0.0592182763,
0.0182994884,
0.0511672683,
0.0043711322,
0.0194444042,
0.030646082,
-0.0056376723,
0.0313573927,
-0.0404930413,
0.0110224066,
0.0560800247,
0.0378614217,
0.0347623192,
-0.0517016053,
0.0018319498,
0.0435042903,
0.0070753796,
-0.0319101252,
0.0298310239,
0.0497672781,
-0.0493163615,
-0.017706912,
0.1056280062,
0.0108137904,
-0.0193272587,
0.0123464381,
0.0215623286,
0.0959519893,
-0.0132077299,
0.0206811447,
-0.072640039,
-0.0610328168,
0.0494168624,
0.0086903004,
0.0191813409,
-0.0040347129,
-0.0060364162,
-0.117417939,
0.0379735529,
0.0081292205,
0.0149581721,
-0.0130158225,
-0.0608128272,
-0.0183777139,
-0.0257871002,
0.0044146813,
0.0301366746,
-0.0091988696,
0.0016020307,
0.0176658351,
-0.062582314,
-0.047958184,
0.0167781152,
0.0026342904,
0.0434139632,
0.0429072604,
0.0248686336,
0.016311001,
-0.044693172,
0.0376493447,
0.0079712132,
-0.0465414971,
-0.0325136185,
0.025816882,
-0.0027391396,
0.0174766872,
0.01260651,
0.0295447148,
-0.0243828036,
-0.0060907206,
-0.0230371766,
0.0742740929,
-0.0020144468,
-0.0298218541,
-0.0251817275,
-0.0177497398,
-0.050568223,
0.0982490703,
0.0438377298,
-0.0053845053,
-0.0417719707,
0.0086930422,
-0.0181102566,
-0.0134868464,
-0.006937163,
0.012984463,
-0.023592392,
-0.0681132823,
-0.0176837947,
0.0124888457,
0.0281632766,
0.0199611969,
-0.0422134735,
-0.0241500698,
-0.0274709091,
0.037813656,
-0.0888566673,
0.0095506255,
-0.0132442191,
0.0090350006,
-0.0605604425,
0.0052504758,
0.0237341467,
0.0250580385,
-0.0217868239,
0.029754959,
-0.142342031,
-0.0423709117,
-0.0287015047,
0.0412020721,
0.0228897799,
0.0657981858,
0.001105665,
-0.0382871181,
0.029312348,
0.0399503335,
-0.0234381761,
0.0644266233,
0.0266937967,
-0.0838590264,
0.0098181181,
0.0711722374,
-0.0179736577,
0.0226503443,
-0.0206206366,
0.0581320189,
-0.0006012198,
-0.0236893483,
-0.0015423329,
0.0336874574,
0.0172251593,
-0.0110431388,
-0.0317408442,
0.011595482,
0.0361598432,
0.0028130922,
-0.0066232579,
-0.0658852234,
0.034927845,
0.0143765491,
0.0414093249,
-0.0067335148,
0.0152440714,
0.0379036963,
0.009761598,
-0.0094015822,
0.0153061477,
0.0193307158,
-0.0011906255,
0.0509486645,
-0.0180486832,
-0.0101539753,
-0.0205536205,
-0.0040374636,
0.0065678027,
-0.0653579086,
0.010633247,
0.0142127257,
0.0372759588,
-0.03757203,
0.0179099347,
-0.004985536,
-0.0536114015,
-0.0527518168,
0.0576119721,
0.0299348868,
0.0122947646,
0.0614939518,
-0.0179779474,
-0.0108555472,
-0.057398349,
0.0139652686,
0.0067553073,
-0.0044768024,
0.0059305937,
0.0116285514,
-0.0266433638,
-0.0131095322,
0.0836258605,
0.0510766581,
0.057632491,
-0.0265783276,
-0.0058922921,
-0.0324327126,
-0.0577540025,
-0.0360523984,
0.0115626883,
-0.0109637827,
-0.0060787019,
-0.0392704234,
-0.0728427023,
-0.0277773514,
0.0124310544,
0.0240725316,
-0.0049939803,
0.0513646677,
0.0425876565,
0.003715117,
-0.0136227924,
-0.0133603625,
-0.0125900228,
-0.0106278537,
-0.0425785854,
0.017088281,
-6.53650605e-33,
-0.0080681033,
0.0399001203,
0.0188215654,
-0.0498315394,
-0.037337549,
0.0316334218,
-0.0342468806,
-0.0339778587,
-0.0055272328,
0.0037452716,
-0.0048416816,
0.014625675,
-0.0022952189,
0.0319081321,
-0.0438298993,
0.0148457214,
0.0606813766,
0.0035263954,
-0.0407687873,
0.0200795755,
0.0099924626,
0.0274728741,
0.0360826701,
0.0271483287,
-0.0753392503,
-0.0002803958,
-0.0046002381,
0.0072729695,
0.0153106591,
0.0385333113,
-0.0171556454,
-0.0057120775,
0.0018983792,
-0.0290602613,
-0.0163352471,
0.003039483,
-0.0964468345,
-0.0068826848,
0.0315326639,
-0.0020722912,
-0.0420202576,
-0.0156686772,
0.0365486853,
0.030920757,
-0.0123654557,
-0.0180002097,
-0.0113307526,
-0.0216253828,
-0.0226058494,
-0.0331255049,
-0.0082449196,
0.0391545966,
0.0067956587,
-0.0299798232,
0.0515021011,
0.0324173793,
-0.0328621343,
0.0376878157,
-0.0112422993,
-0.0049487962,
0.042183131,
0.0904717445,
0.0722307265,
0.0088949725,
0.0150869843,
0.0355793908,
0.0075881882,
-0.02970035,
-0.0261427332,
0.0269869659,
0.0608536862,
0.0505208746,
0.032968808,
0.0111862458,
0.0437950976,
0.0065084635,
-0.090795055,
0.0070202434,
0.051819738,
0.0433751382,
0.0128606679,
0.0263804309,
-0.0071776542,
-0.0276043043,
-0.0428838059,
-0.0297249146,
-0.0223614108,
-0.0134210186,
0.0209655855,
0.0183077026,
-0.047947593,
-0.0142185586,
0.0541319959,
-0.0308146402,
0.0026839904,
0.035064701,
-0.032343749,
0.0007436326,
0.0144701274,
0.0710536763,
-0.039290987,
-0.0107016675,
0.0074062976,
-0.0319318213,
0.0175076518,
-0.0090789394,
0.0162517391,
0.0489529856,
-0.0604978688,
-0.0211391449,
-0.0596375242,
-0.0050402526,
-0.0277407467,
0.0548012815,
0.0592205934,
0.0240219645,
0.0222538263,
0.027172979,
0.0207108427,
0.0233910289,
-0.0430996828,
0.0124611836,
0.0364277102,
0.0199867804,
-0.0135166626,
-0.0095899068,
-0.05806005,
0.0121093644,
0.0350016169,
-0.0670406371,
-0.0418525636,
0.0366930999,
2.801e-7,
0.0101597356,
0.0096452078,
0.0348544195,
-0.0067684446,
0.0084120519,
0.0098008867,
0.0011096526,
0.0168760717,
-0.0071007507,
-0.0011185297,
0.0110772261,
0.0260669421,
0.0727820098,
0.0163624119,
-0.0893931165,
0.0291872025,
-0.0676617995,
-0.0133485738,
-0.042392578,
-0.0291089993,
0.0050285533,
0.1296554655,
0.019424526,
-0.0286199339,
0.0051559638,
0.0219942853,
0.025722554,
-0.0330624171,
-0.006836589,
-0.001974775,
-0.0181867406,
0.0178448446,
-0.0017398354,
-0.0372001864,
-0.0164957251,
-0.0031852217,
-0.0114355115,
0.1089982465,
0.0053485511,
-0.0062394496,
0.0468937308,
-0.0213115867,
-0.0495687984,
-0.0079671061,
0.0820158944,
-0.00556977,
-0.0153143154,
-0.0278074946,
-0.0258329529,
-0.0017864265,
-0.0203743055,
-0.0010763106,
-0.0172129031,
0.0445643812,
0.0220252629,
-0.0268233009,
-0.0224973802,
-0.0650343746,
-0.0137838032,
-0.0201527625,
-0.068461135,
-0.0470666066,
-0.0492061041,
0.0119099533,
0.0327243768,
-0.04815064,
-0.0036018996,
3.182945288e-34,
0.025422724,
-0.0187922847,
-0.0244369227,
0.0448266715,
0.0133763598,
-0.0468198769,
0.0082277842,
0.0147085357,
-0.0455614291,
-0.0675374344,
-0.0351559445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03675v2 | Auditing Gender Presentation Differences in Text-to-Image Models | 2023-02-07T18:52:22 | 2023-02-08T01:55:54 | Yanzhe Zhang, Lu Jiang, Greg Turk, Diyi Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Text-to-image models, which can generate high-quality images based on textual
input, have recently enabled various content-creation tools. Despite
significantly affecting a wide range of downstream applications, the
distributions of these generated images are still not fully understood,
especially when it comes to the potential stereotypical attributes of different
genders. In this work, we propose a paradigm (Gender Presentation Differences)
that utilizes fine-grained self-presentation attributes to study how gender is
presented differently in text-to-image models. By probing gender indicators in
the input text (e.g., "a woman" or "a man"), we quantify the frequency
differences of presentation-centric attributes (e.g., "a shirt" and "a dress")
through human annotation and introduce a novel metric: GEP. Furthermore, we
propose an automatic method to estimate such differences. The automatic GEP
metric based on our approach yields a higher correlation with human annotations
than that based on existing CLIP scores, consistently across three
state-of-the-art text-to-image models. Finally, we demonstrate the
generalization ability of our metrics in the context of gender stereotypes
related to occupations. | [
0.0135209691,
0.0767059103,
-0.0183863677,
0.0084903529,
0.0024537495,
0.0272150803,
0.0510561876,
0.0079755355,
-0.0168800186,
-0.0583305284,
0.0109248767,
-0.0286534671,
0.0661737025,
0.0437374748,
0.0374109633,
-0.0729923919,
-0.057347022,
0.0222473703,
0.0078756306,
-0.0050422624,
0.0299155377,
0.0389525294,
0.0117148235,
0.0504910797,
-0.0250521302,
-0.0709363818,
0.0364677608,
0.0395010449,
0.0033742439,
0.008126881,
0.0081470832,
0.0586319603,
-0.0021730263,
-0.0187715665,
0.0000019181,
-0.0692870766,
0.0146595929,
0.048593834,
0.0154539831,
0.0285218004,
0.0651278272,
0.0066321585,
-0.029039856,
-0.0184376072,
-0.017169049,
0.0198741518,
0.0642478094,
0.0709734783,
0.0617849976,
0.0008688417,
-0.0231419634,
0.009731384,
-0.0704931766,
-0.0190114155,
0.0089390567,
0.0358701311,
0.0036768264,
-0.0004984401,
-0.0524989218,
0.0062099304,
0.0038611551,
0.0182805043,
-0.033408504,
0.0132993115,
0.0057991892,
0.0671692193,
-0.0083642192,
-0.0586576536,
0.0180723872,
0.0398162119,
0.0038617563,
0.0079790475,
0.0120016914,
-0.0192197319,
0.0346572623,
0.0491221286,
-0.0155072631,
0.0061285114,
-0.0258350577,
-0.020197574,
-0.0951399207,
0.0018720756,
-0.0060180444,
0.0000455512,
0.0135122929,
0.0032176767,
0.0185280014,
0.0051297504,
-0.0325608216,
0.0053177839,
-0.0106416298,
-0.068705447,
0.0314120762,
-0.0052807732,
0.0876701325,
-0.0278799981,
-0.0160622913,
-0.0573857427,
0.0055572269,
-0.0493773259,
0.0389701314,
0.0094764475,
-0.0190991201,
0.0189670064,
-0.0332181975,
0.0769241527,
0.022058785,
0.0022514029,
-0.0092447335,
-0.011290946,
-0.0225747731,
-0.0307261404,
0.025098009,
-0.0394679345,
-0.0103478422,
0.0068650879,
-0.0376007594,
-0.0319179147,
-0.0742945001,
0.0102493363,
0.0179484151,
0.0438593216,
-0.0437676646,
0.0134842005,
-0.0372235104,
-0.0245415363,
-0.0288194269,
0.0040750415,
-0.0243395641,
-0.0346596539,
0.0250466708,
-0.0135511952,
0.0372132212,
0.0045399945,
0.0104605937,
0.0210152157,
-0.0323943533,
0.0115561411,
-0.0048258309,
-0.022366235,
-0.0243183989,
-0.031774506,
0.0392712466,
-0.0858149678,
0.0116721243,
0.0113037657,
0.0119287968,
-0.0722088069,
-0.0097015817,
0.0166335423,
-0.0097532216,
0.0612456538,
0.0568908602,
0.0308996849,
0.0792242736,
0.009100914,
-0.0587561131,
0.0675549284,
0.0441017784,
0.0405541323,
0.0381863527,
-0.0096454276,
0.0089874361,
0.0426530875,
0.031585753,
0.0052724546,
-0.0413133092,
0.0044277376,
0.0218694434,
0.0254007448,
0.0781878904,
0.0030198889,
0.0095330551,
-0.0176396035,
0.0854578465,
0.0847530663,
0.0466976687,
0.0294074398,
0.0439822078,
0.0140748741,
0.016071884,
0.0306984894,
-0.0378657617,
0.0228230301,
0.0189283881,
-0.0204772372,
-0.0181216225,
0.0485470146,
-0.0279678982,
-0.0199804958,
0.0058673914,
0.0011701727,
0.0305418018,
-0.0177028645,
-0.0084918831,
0.0604218952,
0.0099706398,
0.01854055,
-0.0131800128,
-0.0597422123,
-0.0148608489,
-0.0646590814,
0.0180685259,
0.0563699603,
-0.0291869566,
0.0051079434,
0.0446194299,
-0.0197539777,
-0.0188069437,
0.0461140648,
-0.0111941099,
0.014282533,
0.0298456755,
-0.0157554764,
0.0085306885,
-0.0109344954,
0.0263899788,
0.0302768815,
0.0275329482,
0.0314619988,
0.047453206,
-0.0409175344,
-0.0630661994,
0.0325344503,
0.0122250738,
-0.0238084067,
0.0231062528,
0.0465149172,
-0.0167364664,
0.0190173164,
-0.0259310976,
0.0147236735,
-0.0176790096,
-0.0076651755,
-0.006242292,
0.0596119538,
0.0135720987,
0.0188210271,
0.0143699842,
-0.0775351599,
-0.0879401043,
-0.0086717401,
0.0030990555,
-0.0065821982,
0.0162292384,
-0.0235114284,
0.0124778254,
-0.0381539129,
-0.0189739261,
0.005596566,
0.0235114079,
0.0195927788,
0.0287806783,
-0.0007843755,
-0.0208725724,
-0.0001764025,
-0.0352919884,
-0.0321933739,
-0.042671971,
-0.0052272007,
-0.0442636125,
0.004340393,
0.0339777321,
0.0130487233,
-0.0015487623,
-0.0331190787,
-0.0333814882,
-0.0421817265,
-0.0372485369,
0.0201952122,
-0.0213177092,
-0.0233606864,
-0.0283995178,
-0.0181942154,
-0.0105243763,
-0.052323021,
-0.034964174,
-0.0431430936,
0.0238451976,
0.042299211,
-0.0114407092,
0.0598492958,
-0.0361674801,
-0.0256623384,
-0.0111652231,
0.0805390179,
0.0478175618,
0.0175364427,
-0.0332867168,
-0.0052993479,
-0.0222909972,
0.0023443506,
0.0190995522,
-0.0329217203,
0.0439782292,
0.0349594615,
0.0563293733,
0.1092754602,
0.0519114584,
-0.0065788273,
0.0036892609,
-0.0028092493,
-0.0318185501,
-0.0307529438,
0.0144396778,
0.0611311011,
0.0768891275,
-0.1024520248,
-0.0006941792,
-0.0149298673,
-0.0252185576,
0.0129970908,
-0.0637896508,
0.0734736845,
-0.0077683823,
-0.0536301024,
-0.0376876034,
0.0208699387,
0.0154804345,
0.0242562294,
-0.0323788039,
-0.0266136825,
0.0244866926,
-0.0566153489,
0.0006191291,
0.0744745061,
0.0093889926,
-0.0053754756,
0.0460634679,
-0.0008097435,
0.0384533554,
0.0453630164,
0.0107466923,
-0.0617154688,
0.004772488,
0.0854286626,
-0.0413779169,
0.009414278,
-0.0136541193,
-0.0139479293,
0.0007518608,
-0.0255496074,
-0.0026154534,
-0.0213182699,
0.0084972978,
-0.0124622928,
-0.0234862138,
-0.0389202982,
-0.0027702579,
0.0480582565,
-0.0321799293,
0.0012342451,
-0.0280380845,
-0.0117711369,
0.0135007277,
0.0290316939,
0.0184294153,
0.0011537725,
-0.0439313613,
-0.0335151851,
-0.0380397923,
0.0388716459,
-0.0609597825,
0.0173733085,
-0.0253524184,
0.0044702264,
-0.0168933291,
0.0211075675,
-0.0090503376,
-0.0167657454,
0.04615096,
-0.037590459,
0.0200790595,
0.0816422999,
-0.0044034696,
-0.0454792194,
-0.0201748479,
0.0317748189,
0.0221036393,
0.0213395227,
0.0117875077,
-0.0368308611,
0.010022969,
0.0086918576,
0.0096488697,
-0.0460168719,
-0.0345865935,
-0.0003640964,
-0.1007186994,
0.0122213252,
0.0047168308,
-0.0388428718,
-0.0201739799,
-0.0102008758,
0.0403737575,
-0.0061229975,
-0.0361651704,
-0.0270262361,
-0.0162874442,
0.0143670812,
-0.0026528386,
-0.0661877543,
-0.0472900122,
0.0239820164,
-0.0479715988,
0.0506225079,
0.0264241584,
0.077917926,
0.0079435771,
-0.0574920252,
-0.0398869328,
0.0139412228,
0.0252407044,
-0.0107829189,
0.074026078,
-0.051309187,
-0.0108895022,
-0.0423893742,
0.0496914908,
0.0893969014,
0.0095223812,
-0.0184252206,
-0.0313409418,
0.0342834964,
-0.0159492157,
-0.066931583,
-0.0365350246,
0.0118056014,
0.0510622859,
0.0354313403,
-0.0565885678,
-0.0507210344,
-0.05326204,
0.049827911,
-0.0028235542,
-0.0575474538,
0.0063206712,
0.0155671919,
-0.0581680238,
-0.0481930524,
-0.010644176,
0.0116944714,
-0.0011822223,
-0.0092260288,
-0.0833642185,
-0.0177257806,
0.0355248637,
-0.1151281521,
0.0163077936,
0.0042706914,
0.0266241338,
0.0157096032,
-0.0104209138,
-0.0110486709,
-0.0414761789,
-0.0397611111,
0.0323850662,
-0.0477126576,
-0.017988855,
-0.007775085,
0.0530523658,
0.0152407391,
0.0319066644,
0.0085958308,
-0.0634782612,
0.0391872264,
0.0598811433,
0.0127336299,
0.0184079148,
0.0154255219,
0.0187796354,
-0.0117679574,
0.01532654,
-0.0322646499,
0.0452238917,
-0.0034310138,
-0.0384730548,
0.0148127219,
-0.0586199611,
-0.0153029189,
0.0028542988,
-0.0208562128,
-0.0486930683,
0.0316142812,
-0.0220428146,
-0.051134415,
-0.0239994898,
-0.01570349,
-0.0344237126,
-0.0365415998,
-0.0160957519,
0.0270919092,
-0.0069140471,
0.0141693028,
-0.0039290516,
0.0545884259,
-0.057938043,
-0.0425445698,
0.0344011039,
0.0301165711,
-0.0284682531,
0.0128651643,
0.0171240009,
-0.0144336903,
-0.0383278318,
0.0252926499,
0.0189925749,
0.0243901666,
0.0233608037,
0.0297867209,
-0.0159032624,
0.0402141996,
-0.0022302079,
0.0232773572,
-0.0610575564,
0.0295830313,
0.0020891153,
-0.0078401146,
0.0568806008,
-0.0068725972,
-0.0280533955,
0.0116149327,
0.0207300074,
0.0029081029,
0.0063962466,
0.0117912274,
-0.0097091934,
0.0165448915,
-0.0394205153,
0.0369577035,
0.0349011011,
0.0067545502,
-0.0414346047,
-0.0764020905,
-0.0266416091,
0.0043051727,
0.0155166099,
-0.061258316,
0.0102082463,
0.0150377695,
-0.0828290731,
-0.0706299096,
0.0231804326,
0.0113152079,
0.0178438462,
0.0382771119,
0.0013789199,
0.0300862547,
-0.020827705,
-0.0201727226,
-0.0059712701,
-0.0094703231,
-0.0124074826,
0.0176167972,
-0.0023244596,
-5.818064841e-33,
-0.0508420877,
-0.0639308915,
-0.0444471687,
0.018067779,
-0.0187163725,
0.0050184573,
-0.0148871532,
-0.014698023,
0.0386441313,
0.0352069028,
-0.0019988869,
0.0225631073,
0.0070804195,
0.0003286146,
0.0194134358,
0.0648881793,
0.0817161649,
0.014416107,
-0.0535689965,
-0.0219919886,
-0.0033676797,
-0.0151659148,
0.0330125019,
-0.0889167935,
0.0423870534,
-0.0173947178,
-0.0368685126,
-0.0454157926,
0.0391967036,
0.0363749973,
-0.000278706,
0.0038155494,
0.0188470259,
-0.0245056003,
0.0164408144,
0.0703100488,
-0.0829502344,
-0.0238431897,
-0.0269249361,
0.0207025316,
-0.0196567327,
-0.0253906045,
0.0107485307,
-0.0004382704,
-0.0238616653,
-0.0749214813,
0.0971957743,
-0.016296586,
0.0704659596,
0.0101039158,
-0.0185340121,
0.0000926183,
-0.0481677614,
-0.026626166,
0.045332849,
0.0494900569,
-0.0084730508,
-0.010034726,
-0.1009662151,
0.0427221805,
0.008145161,
-0.0370732099,
0.0488513671,
0.0376952216,
0.0627828389,
0.0190321207,
0.0338709019,
0.0407405347,
-0.0396520868,
-0.0436185747,
0.046650216,
0.0125006363,
0.0213175118,
0.0628844947,
0.0428550802,
-0.0124386633,
-0.0069496292,
0.0303668547,
-0.0309594609,
-0.0001343173,
0.0136466091,
-0.0046378388,
-0.0407185331,
0.0008706888,
-0.0375219882,
-0.0825663656,
-0.0261415411,
-0.0371577777,
0.0063770497,
-0.0174448248,
-0.0650566146,
0.0561871082,
-0.0021683057,
-0.0241088439,
-0.0343717486,
-0.0522293895,
-0.0460877977,
0.0133388536,
0.0109364949,
-0.0259892624,
-0.0283330437,
0.0032815447,
0.0572592691,
0.0804779083,
0.0597084425,
0.0177307632,
0.0211082902,
0.0110998098,
-0.0614540912,
-0.040443588,
-0.0021751062,
-0.0070970347,
-0.0327147394,
0.0065168724,
0.0209339913,
0.0073393276,
-0.0636799559,
-0.0165233575,
0.0088359276,
0.0440760218,
-0.0320392214,
-0.0275512673,
0.0348670185,
-0.0049569514,
-0.026603438,
0.0043092412,
-0.0140997991,
-0.0193670169,
0.0541539937,
-0.0188882183,
-0.0041242228,
-0.0150597254,
2.478e-7,
-0.0124658188,
0.0308520999,
0.014463474,
0.0251614191,
0.0487017408,
0.061454013,
0.0086090853,
0.0298141353,
0.0584851876,
-0.0436600409,
-0.0275403056,
0.0370176136,
0.0209651999,
0.0188713837,
0.0138022415,
0.0157728456,
-0.0527916998,
0.0282849167,
0.0090849409,
0.0153345289,
0.01868283,
0.0178034473,
0.0291920323,
-0.0284282584,
0.0232675914,
0.0008980817,
0.0793910176,
-0.0169938728,
0.03156716,
-0.0241472907,
-0.0087392246,
0.0071083494,
0.0145996902,
0.0431981087,
-0.0068036593,
-0.0171220973,
0.0753744543,
0.0169763044,
-0.0595036894,
0.0532211922,
-0.0135100354,
0.0142821306,
-0.0189511273,
-0.0524525456,
0.0558742024,
-0.0227505285,
-0.0469522625,
-0.0722995177,
-0.0331805162,
0.0175433308,
0.0713902563,
-0.0192979034,
-0.0400289372,
0.0266386177,
0.0310502853,
-0.0015240905,
-0.0211985111,
-0.0596723817,
-0.0623851269,
-0.0259804744,
0.0042570583,
-0.0294915773,
-0.0457759462,
0.0273841824,
0.0223321542,
-0.0437695645,
0.0084595839,
1.732821133e-34,
-0.0261600129,
0.0476795807,
0.0017567534,
-0.0160610545,
0.0047138673,
-0.0016625741,
0.0161978919,
-0.0296163131,
0.0394725539,
-0.0152931577,
0.0060130069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03668v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03668v2 | Hard Prompts Made Easy: Gradient-Based Discrete Optimization for Prompt Tuning and Discovery | 2023-02-07T18:40:18 | 2023-06-01T12:26:45 | Yuxin Wen, Neel Jain, John Kirchenbauer, Micah Goldblum, Jonas Geiping, Tom Goldstein | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The strength of modern generative models lies in their ability to be
controlled through text-based prompts. Typical "hard" prompts are made from
interpretable words and tokens, and must be hand-crafted by humans. There are
also "soft" prompts, which consist of continuous feature vectors. These can be
discovered using powerful optimization methods, but they cannot be easily
interpreted, re-used across models, or plugged into a text-based interface.
We describe an approach to robustly optimize hard text prompts through
efficient gradient-based optimization. Our approach automatically generates
hard text-based prompts for both text-to-image and text-to-text applications.
In the text-to-image setting, the method creates hard prompts for diffusion
models, allowing API users to easily generate, discover, and mix and match
image concepts without prior knowledge on how to prompt the model. In the
text-to-text setting, we show that hard prompts can be automatically discovered
that are effective in tuning LMs for classification. | [
0.0222772378,
0.0577430911,
-0.0026990087,
0.0398338437,
-0.0137807494,
-0.0055649765,
0.0629141107,
0.0195229873,
0.008652064,
-0.0159817524,
0.0005445963,
-0.0322628878,
0.0083278622,
0.0400833748,
0.0166968703,
-0.0766662359,
0.0030070192,
-0.0257602483,
-0.0173306819,
-0.0189473405,
0.0063464548,
0.0108151138,
0.0016305539,
0.0038390998,
-0.0331670344,
-0.0251200069,
-0.0195449907,
0.04701069,
0.0278341547,
-0.0265907086,
0.0037012531,
0.0653664991,
0.0299458709,
0.0150012299,
0.0000022373,
-0.0414864384,
-0.0269163921,
0.0069843363,
-0.0415928885,
-0.0449104793,
0.063821055,
-0.023435276,
0.0102605131,
-0.0226948727,
-0.0056434707,
0.027247401,
0.0796024501,
0.0336233862,
0.0665029436,
0.0550871007,
-0.0216911472,
-0.0270467009,
0.0026242195,
-0.0409222245,
0.0679102018,
-0.0436034799,
0.0167010929,
-0.0575857721,
-0.0115206549,
0.0360298119,
-0.0393472798,
0.0467947535,
0.0145155648,
-0.0087424461,
0.0676623285,
0.067745246,
0.0344396234,
-0.0695518032,
-0.0330847017,
0.0870636553,
-0.0354068242,
0.0035093834,
0.0359479748,
-0.0663026348,
-0.0044723074,
0.0274457335,
-0.009504877,
-0.0103802569,
-0.0190914031,
0.0129797263,
-0.0530843586,
-0.0152995773,
0.0185177308,
0.0030260638,
-0.0121525778,
0.0097836014,
0.0138832945,
0.0111619905,
-0.0014176832,
0.0107337385,
-0.0342435054,
-0.0746532455,
0.0301708821,
0.0329995155,
-0.0451740362,
-0.0161638707,
-0.0290713497,
-0.0507917106,
0.0120771779,
0.0190333389,
0.0753442794,
0.0020366528,
-0.023750877,
0.0575254709,
-0.0123673473,
0.0111899981,
-0.0359690972,
-0.0085820034,
-0.0259970948,
0.0252277516,
-0.0014774272,
-0.0252986662,
-0.0376790687,
-0.0001180216,
-0.0375225805,
-0.0157084819,
-0.0262455624,
0.0127995787,
-0.0219332222,
-0.0064566359,
0.0115887001,
0.0299178157,
-0.0633447245,
-0.0267166868,
-0.034563873,
-0.0133818332,
-0.040599063,
0.0023990953,
0.0455674715,
0.0075670844,
-0.0101125073,
0.0164644569,
0.0409465954,
-0.0066810516,
-0.001218198,
0.0452175327,
-0.0353189707,
0.0009865145,
-0.012918612,
-0.0455643125,
-0.0034034741,
-0.0291616488,
0.0354386568,
-0.0472954661,
0.0232450236,
-0.0046374942,
0.0205896925,
-0.0471715741,
-0.0033034373,
0.0070594009,
-0.0074882754,
0.093205303,
-0.0057162498,
-0.0068039689,
0.0642453283,
0.0085033886,
-0.0474882796,
0.061917007,
-0.0014586166,
0.089929767,
0.0212708246,
-0.0044393451,
0.0285876989,
0.0426859222,
0.0467637517,
0.0164697357,
-0.0000266115,
-0.020957591,
0.0067659901,
0.0593069978,
0.0201562084,
0.0429641977,
-0.0260729603,
-0.0054780068,
0.0642189905,
0.0687186718,
0.0328231603,
0.0102523975,
0.0591031015,
0.0089473324,
-0.0394180194,
-0.0004584957,
-0.0074853734,
0.0324283838,
-0.0267225523,
-0.0051868339,
0.021049099,
0.0197677054,
-0.0365950391,
-0.0471314825,
0.0202184245,
-0.0090306252,
0.023794787,
0.0210572165,
0.0272410363,
0.014644728,
-0.046114333,
0.0144593287,
-0.0060996586,
-0.0236909632,
-0.0278824605,
-0.1013682187,
0.0713762864,
0.0854872689,
0.0253004972,
0.0039482689,
0.0263747014,
-0.0006178225,
0.0610902756,
0.0585278124,
0.0085040275,
-0.0054330486,
0.0311489757,
-0.0424929671,
-0.0432639122,
0.02575217,
0.0174379088,
0.0218816511,
-0.0155593567,
0.0252144765,
0.0162361078,
0.0141928466,
-0.0183416139,
0.0357817523,
-0.0041672993,
-0.0462386236,
0.0696369857,
0.0335805714,
-0.0047400719,
-0.0126332706,
0.0204925872,
-0.0134098465,
-0.0021660775,
-0.0281864014,
-0.0273619778,
-0.0285766963,
0.0010657166,
-0.0026979297,
-0.0107478937,
-0.0225324985,
-0.0445792675,
-0.0144625651,
-0.0643798262,
0.0019188488,
-0.0155439349,
-0.0186997671,
0.0121178478,
-0.0343688913,
-0.0149601409,
0.00094925,
0.0214742348,
-0.0198178962,
0.0722248331,
0.0115824891,
-0.0065528541,
0.0199394077,
0.017511135,
-0.0013238105,
-0.0486588255,
0.0135372151,
-0.0206282176,
0.0156633835,
0.0212639403,
0.0336018316,
0.0396316424,
-0.0359085985,
-0.0238484405,
-0.0788094252,
-0.0044183335,
-0.0111049842,
-0.0227013398,
-0.0035732423,
0.020566579,
-0.0108006904,
-0.0003340925,
-0.0189719796,
0.0248385873,
-0.0173550341,
0.0098308865,
0.0495143384,
0.0115873264,
-0.0087117683,
-0.0315537006,
-0.0092472211,
0.0064502899,
0.054900948,
0.0289800707,
-0.0108475816,
-0.0446107872,
0.0182265341,
-0.0029313795,
-0.0087660942,
0.0035417082,
0.0060475697,
0.0142622404,
-0.0053421715,
0.0643091798,
0.1016040817,
0.0356798097,
0.0616740882,
-0.0087728612,
0.0124531472,
-0.0630703866,
0.0156740155,
-0.0508515127,
-0.0127038043,
0.0389961638,
-0.0475336686,
0.0189127661,
0.0730482414,
-0.0068884697,
-0.0164123122,
-0.0597445183,
0.0537321046,
0.0045992872,
-0.0129168462,
-0.0879445896,
0.0335228927,
-0.0070290905,
0.0255172644,
-0.042931132,
-0.0861484483,
0.0714771301,
-0.0141048962,
-0.0002971916,
-0.0091187628,
-0.0299049336,
-0.0062285331,
0.0242479183,
-0.0148386611,
0.0258436427,
0.0412211046,
0.0150028532,
-0.0329482369,
0.0122434618,
0.0423744023,
-0.0182940215,
0.0153894434,
-0.0217955373,
0.0155038349,
-0.0068580713,
-0.0318856761,
-0.0312216319,
-0.0725298971,
0.0253035147,
-0.0144943418,
-0.0069681127,
-0.0242930539,
-0.0009294519,
0.0046079224,
-0.0041215271,
0.0363469534,
-0.0320615694,
-0.038341973,
-0.0172662716,
0.0279468,
0.0518170185,
0.0015791047,
-0.0429493152,
-0.0688392371,
0.0053613619,
0.0081761004,
-0.0100954091,
0.0068740044,
-0.0258203931,
0.0234467685,
0.0101588573,
0.0246617403,
-0.0031409562,
0.0358356573,
0.0669835284,
-0.0317519978,
-0.0181537699,
0.0682309568,
0.0235954821,
-0.0750647187,
-0.0223457534,
0.0112133631,
0.077239491,
0.0030470924,
0.0237569883,
-0.0618130751,
-0.0490670353,
-0.0069195717,
0.0497723743,
-0.0098808417,
-0.0019495205,
-0.0309801996,
-0.056628678,
0.0732880756,
0.014436841,
0.0055968366,
-0.0034467045,
-0.0435282961,
-0.0028335797,
0.0045274268,
-0.0263074674,
-0.0263215825,
0.0066045262,
0.0097633339,
-0.0015738737,
0.008819011,
-0.0701349154,
-0.0164867714,
-0.0098155718,
-0.0244833939,
0.1070223227,
0.0103899594,
0.0288531519,
-0.0735721588,
0.0479282141,
0.011419232,
0.000336348,
-0.0318791904,
0.0221189372,
0.0055016656,
0.0072774831,
-0.0223993007,
0.0775094032,
0.011662785,
-0.0266023576,
-0.0091222981,
0.086889118,
0.010911257,
-0.0427995063,
-0.0652686581,
-0.0250199325,
0.0966032222,
0.0565873832,
0.0379385352,
-0.0899256542,
-0.0250807162,
-0.0707935989,
0.0451815352,
-0.0215343945,
-0.0614907816,
-0.0249229819,
-0.033163853,
-0.0521149151,
-0.0743214041,
0.0185807161,
0.0041082073,
0.0702354312,
0.0038621391,
-0.0117070517,
-0.0428953134,
0.0009022833,
-0.0582440235,
0.0496168956,
-0.0031117331,
0.0200619698,
-0.0680309907,
-0.0559793264,
0.0487644784,
-0.0642540082,
-0.0366359986,
0.0598879009,
-0.1008606777,
-0.0676559135,
-0.0294101238,
0.0532363243,
0.0251097213,
0.0137989987,
-0.0207977351,
-0.0607827939,
0.1252250075,
0.0905797258,
0.0226998702,
0.0106153646,
0.017510388,
0.0232531466,
-0.0262645129,
0.0036155407,
-0.0587615222,
0.0191563182,
0.0135122128,
0.0140328165,
-0.0211533438,
-0.0025631383,
0.0014621299,
-0.0219593029,
0.0350703485,
-0.043196626,
-0.0454395972,
-0.0525501184,
0.0023987456,
0.0413138643,
-0.0094199432,
-0.0692598298,
-0.0107717589,
0.0287785213,
-0.018860247,
-0.0038931463,
-0.0047979467,
0.0355134271,
0.0433370955,
-0.0544691719,
-0.0030968818,
0.0002271935,
0.0495908111,
0.0506456681,
0.0021875245,
0.0110599259,
0.0398051143,
-0.0463062227,
0.0350896977,
-0.0001146007,
0.0473356582,
0.0361207239,
0.022178432,
-0.0391732007,
0.0354573838,
-0.0324172601,
-0.0631838813,
-0.0575338639,
0.0452013202,
0.0382825918,
0.0261573698,
-0.0039540245,
-0.0243109148,
-0.0355706774,
-0.0183032732,
0.0216689464,
0.0142118353,
-0.0473379791,
0.0359287634,
0.0092500858,
0.0146708963,
-0.0451765805,
0.0499322228,
-0.0284964349,
0.022976242,
-0.0330205187,
-0.014531035,
-0.0277984273,
0.0172772463,
0.0115339439,
-0.0219182093,
0.0146886185,
0.0296592303,
-0.0341241993,
-0.0511256382,
0.0036669425,
0.0093888547,
-0.0173037536,
0.0293147918,
0.0577780306,
0.0547845438,
-0.0103205265,
-0.0073625557,
-0.0351497829,
0.0300986115,
-0.047585275,
-0.0291615017,
-0.0226052869,
-6.815437635e-33,
-0.0379758067,
-0.0538947657,
-0.0056940145,
-0.0187306367,
0.0034327877,
-0.0044417367,
-0.0364839025,
-0.0067354208,
0.0329455473,
0.0176263284,
-0.0271592271,
-0.026832303,
0.0112465015,
0.0303125605,
-0.0176791456,
0.0174530111,
0.0332207046,
-0.0225591846,
-0.0505459085,
0.0380918346,
0.0187424999,
0.0383134559,
-0.0167521052,
-0.0451771133,
0.0022934962,
0.004924559,
-0.0346459113,
0.0249966644,
0.0008052734,
0.0413593985,
-0.0340348445,
-0.0037844926,
-0.0011881875,
-0.0285243466,
-0.0336761251,
0.0426099487,
-0.0739037693,
-0.0338014439,
-0.0197399464,
-0.0122531699,
-0.0988340974,
-0.060269773,
0.0303961858,
-0.0165025406,
-0.0029574579,
-0.0147061637,
0.0546599813,
-0.0117813842,
-0.0031220827,
-0.0427988134,
-0.0379384644,
0.0064686206,
-0.0021665436,
-0.0222093333,
0.0361392722,
-0.0174403843,
0.0270816442,
0.0327355005,
-0.058265157,
0.0176441614,
0.0317715667,
0.0059869718,
0.0458560996,
0.0479006097,
0.0218526535,
0.0406442769,
0.0320885591,
-0.0143097322,
-0.0104242489,
0.0050952407,
0.0099481363,
0.0203603916,
0.0118623069,
0.0384869128,
0.0643095225,
-0.0203549732,
-0.0399183854,
0.042611938,
-0.0583122894,
-0.043522805,
0.0119184293,
0.0257043317,
0.0316696577,
-0.0070457584,
-0.0415339768,
-0.0544659197,
-0.0306740794,
-0.023546176,
0.0163465403,
0.0471856333,
-0.0309002548,
-0.0360347815,
0.0324148424,
0.0169634558,
-0.0136498315,
-0.0213318896,
0.0076781316,
0.0322352536,
0.0278627854,
-0.0112780845,
-0.0286263004,
-0.0496181399,
0.0410229377,
0.0129464315,
0.0302343424,
0.0491208211,
-0.0059879152,
0.0164169315,
-0.039012596,
0.0087894415,
-0.0335401893,
0.0294466224,
-0.0230034683,
0.0329886116,
0.0104449494,
-0.022213947,
-0.0304953735,
0.0630903915,
-0.012713003,
0.0167032089,
-0.041984994,
0.0124946153,
-0.0264556222,
0.0373787545,
-0.0285874028,
0.0041758581,
0.0073335888,
0.0462179817,
0.0756930634,
-0.0499058515,
-0.0160862934,
0.0265867319,
2.857e-7,
0.0084899757,
0.0214247257,
-0.0138486689,
0.0359341949,
0.0059011881,
0.0568995737,
-0.0177975781,
0.0017930625,
-0.0200125352,
-0.0634490699,
0.0245186612,
0.046793513,
0.044086922,
0.0101023391,
-0.0773433074,
0.0183155742,
-0.0022268302,
0.0474253967,
-0.0579712018,
-0.0176092237,
0.0439992957,
0.0653829947,
0.020296745,
-0.010043527,
0.0589554422,
0.0059513459,
0.0549667254,
-0.0492837653,
0.0652266219,
0.0069650444,
0.0258462466,
-0.0458601564,
-0.0192120411,
0.0117297936,
-0.0346872173,
0.001010758,
0.0111469245,
0.054166764,
-0.0140799973,
-0.0453096107,
-0.010535243,
0.0279534515,
0.0160632301,
-0.0426025316,
0.044195164,
-0.014217535,
-0.0000856965,
-0.0450144745,
0.0039024807,
-0.0303278975,
0.0411125943,
-0.0402956158,
-0.0420840122,
0.0011715192,
0.0029408301,
0.0101697836,
-0.0083474061,
-0.0861978903,
-0.0003495777,
-0.0220223702,
-0.0576298796,
-0.0509832874,
-0.0837125331,
0.0481988229,
0.0264018513,
-0.0525534675,
-0.012941326,
2.559584996e-34,
0.037557058,
-0.0247437283,
-0.0040407837,
0.0260577779,
0.0366539843,
0.0100828288,
0.0086386539,
-0.0021710244,
0.0326808728,
-0.0694218278,
-0.0260614417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03645v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03645v2 | Exploitation and exploration in text evolution. Quantifying planning and translation flows during writing | 2023-02-07T17:52:33 | 2023-02-08T11:25:23 | Donald Ruggiero Lo Sardo, Pietro Gravino, Christine Cuskley, Vittorio Loreto | cs.CL | cs.CL | Writing is a complex process at the center of much of modern human activity.
Despite it appears to be a linear process, writing conceals many highly
non-linear processes. Previous research has focused on three phases of writing:
planning, translation and transcription, and revision. While research has shown
these are non-linear, they are often treated linearly when measured. Here, we
introduce measures to detect and quantify subcycles of planning (exploration)
and translation (exploitation) during the writing process. We apply these to a
novel dataset that recorded the creation of a text in all its phases, from
early attempts to the finishing touches on a final version. This dataset comes
from a series of writing workshops in which, through innovative versioning
software, we were able to record all the steps in the construction of a text.
More than 60 junior researchers in science wrote a scientific essay intended
for a general readership. We recorded each essay as a writing cloud, defined as
a complex topological structure capturing the history of the essay itself.
Through this unique dataset of writing clouds, we expose a representation of
the writing process that quantifies its complexity and the writer's efforts
throughout the draft and through time. Interestingly, this representation
highlights the phases of "translation flow", where authors improve existing
ideas, and exploration, where creative deviations appear as the writer returns
to the planning phase. These turning points between translation and exploration
become rarer as the writing process progresses and the author approaches the
final version. Our results and the new measures introduced have the potential
to foster the discussion about the non-linear nature of writing and support the
development of tools that can support more creative and impactful writing
processes. | [
0.0305173732,
0.0236736387,
-0.0475028642,
-0.0380950049,
-0.0616655275,
-0.0147840781,
0.0076601002,
0.006754206,
-0.0151114725,
-0.0024591053,
0.0225186422,
-0.0431654714,
0.0281636342,
0.0405546576,
-0.0053300061,
-0.0255783461,
-0.0106339771,
-0.0071669249,
0.0051004509,
0.034735065,
0.0009625666,
0.0277729556,
0.0039400309,
0.0524765886,
0.0549495332,
-0.0387484357,
-0.0559359603,
-0.0010504356,
0.0336654484,
-0.0178316347,
-0.0455427691,
0.0722450241,
0.0350069553,
0.0948883519,
0.0000019424,
-0.0252157561,
-0.0246703867,
-0.0239540134,
0.0298999585,
-0.0026265485,
0.0541457012,
0.0060826703,
-0.0326830447,
-0.0262653138,
-0.0371108204,
0.0172238592,
0.0329407118,
-0.0030175776,
0.0105829854,
0.0478534661,
0.0009812174,
-0.0369042866,
0.0278903171,
0.0092427405,
0.018730469,
0.0365158245,
-0.0049400409,
-0.0146072218,
0.0242684688,
0.0159455426,
-0.0057035354,
0.0367033929,
0.006337767,
-0.061088223,
0.0096649993,
0.0352206193,
0.0326017179,
-0.0396625549,
0.0306330547,
0.0078778062,
0.0270300582,
-0.0036823568,
0.0243728906,
-0.0231792275,
-0.0235898998,
0.0148845268,
-0.0490535088,
0.0049968446,
-0.0216606874,
-0.0281912889,
-0.0104957391,
-0.0011182365,
-0.0165540278,
0.0083306497,
0.0324684829,
0.009522195,
0.0067540701,
-0.019838484,
-0.0379973389,
0.0020591235,
0.0456818081,
-0.0818563104,
0.036334835,
0.0182728022,
0.0232995823,
0.006664231,
-0.0164604187,
-0.0574664809,
0.0044942042,
-0.0179722439,
0.0976164192,
0.0068209404,
0.0663393736,
0.024918288,
0.0239506066,
0.0215315092,
-0.0046319505,
-0.0140889408,
-0.0494779497,
0.0507863648,
-0.0683404207,
-0.0054490198,
-0.0187845249,
-0.0195681527,
0.0079876669,
-0.0310047641,
-0.0301371776,
0.0321808867,
0.0468937941,
-0.0115101319,
-0.0522924662,
0.0204804391,
-0.0251288787,
0.0106359143,
0.0047642468,
-0.0161902942,
-0.0103520285,
0.02329625,
-0.0076614614,
0.0734983981,
0.0071397424,
0.0090322811,
0.0330232456,
-0.0198034421,
-0.030812053,
0.0140052708,
-0.0081521524,
-0.0075123208,
-0.0169656742,
-0.0618782304,
0.0184805393,
-0.006455218,
0.010772733,
-0.0552442074,
0.0390458293,
0.0182550792,
-0.0319990665,
-0.0321619771,
-0.0347533263,
0.0031484247,
-0.0019584803,
-0.0110022761,
-0.0088527808,
0.0248185731,
0.0491312481,
0.0129896645,
0.0011882397,
-0.0166132711,
0.0806701556,
0.0354966298,
0.0229503158,
0.0095569175,
0.0320547223,
0.0241161417,
-0.0319131874,
0.0421673805,
0.0321165733,
-0.0190189239,
-0.0362595171,
0.0797772035,
-0.0212384705,
0.0041201632,
-0.0295656417,
0.0413074419,
0.0677875206,
0.0636437759,
0.0470939539,
0.041961927,
0.0339997932,
0.0177873913,
-0.0047991248,
0.0300412197,
0.0716837049,
0.024419168,
0.0360994488,
-0.0081279343,
0.0101671023,
-0.0275996309,
0.0089988802,
-0.0227116775,
-0.0050011948,
0.0554645881,
0.0094905132,
-0.0583885349,
-0.0142824436,
0.0219038837,
-0.0297061857,
-0.0195169188,
-0.041879043,
-0.0861510411,
0.0263306666,
0.0408345498,
0.029438924,
0.0952939391,
0.0560118295,
-0.0345485061,
-0.0008840185,
-0.0341518335,
0.0285681933,
0.0322024785,
-0.0099766934,
-0.0073350277,
-0.0079711117,
-0.0028819882,
-0.0284695476,
-0.023538461,
-0.0129177179,
-0.0047978484,
-0.0186918601,
0.02022136,
-0.0156405289,
-0.0192268733,
-0.0722588748,
0.0491455719,
-0.0450260527,
0.0185911618,
-0.00183627,
-0.0094020776,
-0.0000632449,
0.027944481,
-0.0461942106,
0.0178782865,
0.0343442149,
-0.0307012834,
-0.0480317175,
0.089974843,
0.0303912833,
0.019469073,
0.004079394,
-0.0769310892,
0.007067028,
-0.0452116095,
0.0188643187,
-0.0408549905,
0.0445559807,
-0.0268937387,
0.0157118235,
0.0073049623,
0.0028445995,
-0.046651382,
-0.0390225202,
-0.043642465,
0.0240868777,
-0.0126100229,
0.0614405759,
-0.0129376044,
-0.0121249724,
0.0313149877,
0.0298667755,
0.0110389506,
0.0040165228,
0.0283458326,
0.0077733244,
0.0297768284,
-0.0056368844,
-0.0450506918,
-0.0866592005,
-0.0653346181,
0.011878822,
-0.0249062944,
0.0327267572,
0.0528417751,
-0.019211527,
-0.0070299832,
0.0385824107,
0.0055536786,
-0.017245546,
-0.0133016603,
-0.0286490172,
0.0556571372,
-0.0082582943,
0.0031669291,
-0.0098044705,
0.0087679774,
-0.0272915177,
0.0333834514,
0.0776594803,
-0.0193450805,
-0.050084617,
0.0324528031,
-0.0106996624,
-0.0615211502,
-0.0043135956,
-0.0157177225,
0.0357285887,
0.0057423683,
0.0599739812,
0.0292420778,
0.019654071,
0.0137107726,
0.0661719888,
-0.0220391788,
0.0113602644,
-0.0231922492,
-0.0003671668,
0.0506366231,
0.0002038594,
-0.064905107,
0.0462749451,
0.003505528,
0.0327830762,
-0.0122740781,
-0.026221646,
0.03223316,
-0.044572331,
0.0134411417,
0.0129143232,
-0.0331311412,
-0.0402564146,
0.0762325004,
-0.0256173369,
-0.0342239179,
0.0321654081,
-0.0023546203,
0.0129601313,
-0.0328146815,
0.0030971065,
-0.029502891,
0.1024586931,
-0.0072443029,
0.0117801456,
0.0076624528,
0.0096414005,
-0.0604389086,
0.038180273,
0.0406764969,
-0.0000789313,
0.016603658,
-0.0516626649,
-0.020028919,
-0.0083755655,
-0.0025797093,
0.0158743486,
-0.0133476937,
0.0252502821,
0.0089586722,
0.0614099354,
-0.0735706091,
-0.0251138546,
-0.0214419179,
0.0508742481,
0.0955646336,
0.0040105437,
-0.0223171506,
-0.0176539011,
0.0160466619,
0.0198747423,
-0.02161319,
-0.0205961745,
-0.0654384792,
0.0069568544,
0.0421729125,
-0.0402104855,
0.0351859331,
0.001960956,
-0.0248359255,
-0.016081918,
-0.0335501432,
-0.0479632467,
-0.0065544867,
0.0432277173,
-0.0371409208,
-0.0262282398,
0.0626772344,
0.0328152589,
-0.0320964195,
0.0010997952,
-0.0366858169,
0.026013976,
0.0270817112,
0.0425708145,
-0.0498970784,
0.033892937,
-0.016499171,
0.0169883855,
-0.0335371122,
-0.0622394793,
-0.0181837995,
-0.0230190177,
0.0335364081,
0.0076564103,
-0.0561315492,
0.0576754063,
-0.0292811245,
-0.0049372264,
0.0445704088,
-0.0943482071,
-0.0055506094,
0.0292646568,
0.0139389765,
-0.0126882736,
-0.0499429889,
-0.0039055368,
-0.0260226261,
-0.0355841182,
-0.0210478958,
0.0303679295,
0.0776226595,
0.0061057727,
-0.0132478001,
-0.0153817004,
0.0229289662,
0.022088388,
-0.0146198831,
0.0216128994,
0.0599351451,
0.0519748591,
-0.0298645776,
0.0263260901,
-0.0271817967,
-0.0547767058,
0.0272891428,
0.0718831494,
-0.030120356,
-0.0205995105,
-0.0265104473,
0.0115164146,
0.017144531,
0.008184406,
0.0485101603,
-0.059253186,
-0.0431548283,
-0.0547996163,
0.0460772887,
-0.1159772798,
-0.054575488,
-0.0403175168,
-0.018239338,
0.0450975075,
-0.0733601153,
-0.0385786109,
0.0064352821,
0.0616606995,
0.0531991944,
0.0299622044,
-0.0352635272,
-0.0651879609,
-0.0928596556,
-0.0293558966,
0.049618125,
0.0272741839,
0.0218366198,
-0.035431657,
-0.0531885996,
-0.007285058,
-0.0049404935,
0.0239361692,
-0.0946239606,
-0.0398880132,
0.0158417914,
-0.0053039151,
0.0200959798,
-0.0540896542,
0.0215700809,
-0.0819812641,
0.0173254535,
-0.0273273494,
0.0277020074,
0.0319355018,
-0.0095127216,
0.0424957536,
-0.028478343,
0.0216204096,
0.0212906972,
-0.0291215461,
0.0236083828,
0.0168814454,
-0.0418201536,
-0.0295641273,
-0.028117612,
-0.024642637,
0.0021173654,
-0.053534776,
-0.0454991907,
-0.0661601648,
-0.0186002254,
0.011184318,
-0.0291376021,
-0.0260482524,
-0.0128915738,
0.0168954693,
-0.0190799125,
-0.0247307476,
0.0905687138,
-0.047333546,
-0.0201691091,
-0.0582878329,
0.0363303609,
0.0525843836,
0.0480963066,
0.0229719318,
0.0265918355,
-0.0075120749,
0.0363813378,
-0.0620454699,
0.0394184105,
0.0300348867,
0.0052597555,
0.0220383294,
0.0151517615,
0.0124290511,
0.0288269501,
-0.0949443877,
-0.0209349189,
0.0227389093,
-0.016891636,
0.0398055837,
0.0158784166,
0.1021897718,
-0.0116358232,
0.0012870011,
-0.0183545705,
0.0530933402,
-0.0091830594,
-0.0403801091,
-0.0605686866,
-0.0014245954,
0.0101395175,
-0.002524419,
0.0555010438,
-0.036597345,
0.0383648127,
-0.014795457,
-0.0171561539,
-0.0161210876,
-0.0033722389,
-0.0034511988,
0.0177598316,
0.0384604968,
-0.0077562109,
-0.0841215849,
0.0229849629,
0.0741696805,
-0.0062792646,
0.019592708,
-0.0358691961,
0.0074569923,
0.045661658,
-0.0537264757,
-0.0102913305,
-0.0647036657,
0.0113932034,
-0.0282866396,
-0.0407117866,
-0.0248546526,
-5.421344681e-33,
0.0043307184,
-0.0928649381,
0.0093889283,
0.0314110518,
-0.0665768906,
0.000006324,
-0.0484360568,
0.0149584599,
0.0361070409,
0.0011397188,
-0.0335453972,
0.0089235781,
-0.0126481364,
-0.0313628241,
0.0530795865,
0.0466522798,
0.041401457,
0.0008187389,
-0.0645499527,
0.0083030174,
0.0558556765,
0.0235045347,
0.0381112546,
-0.0515211597,
0.0376969017,
-0.0384247079,
-0.0082940944,
-0.0204058997,
-0.0008694184,
-0.0054532336,
0.0132661825,
-0.0071401079,
0.0211394466,
-0.0384127572,
-0.0257349126,
-0.0252869446,
0.0204421747,
-0.0321459249,
0.0052252011,
0.0039510289,
-0.0099971434,
-0.0539895631,
0.038335748,
-0.0109643415,
-0.037358027,
-0.0309987329,
0.0447201058,
0.022953257,
-0.0339177437,
-0.0379683748,
-0.0705003813,
0.0297125801,
-0.0294380151,
-0.0105664842,
0.0064859116,
0.0013511686,
0.0319655128,
-0.0486351177,
-0.1027179286,
0.0384273045,
-0.0211815722,
0.0440371409,
-0.0060001276,
0.0080068819,
0.0167405177,
0.0723949596,
0.019475678,
0.0716059208,
-0.0325209387,
0.0342235714,
0.0265504122,
0.0274925455,
0.0279229823,
0.0378741249,
0.0041797971,
0.004999151,
-0.0046263775,
0.0276453961,
-0.0247663949,
-0.0350715518,
0.011779543,
0.028444415,
0.0375181586,
-0.0490174964,
-0.0402888618,
-0.0698950887,
0.014134313,
0.0045195352,
-0.0197883062,
-0.0003266634,
-0.0097978106,
-0.0364808291,
0.0141285611,
0.0045649586,
-0.005085391,
0.0048594396,
-0.1033732221,
0.1001680866,
0.0022991593,
0.0095632551,
-0.0356435068,
-0.0290559717,
-0.0132801719,
0.0621325113,
0.0576944835,
-0.0115916934,
0.0063917595,
0.0259903353,
-0.0420496166,
-0.0195626095,
-0.0191351008,
0.0148659134,
-0.0075358204,
-0.023850752,
0.0116990162,
-0.0150639936,
0.0248029344,
0.0107538085,
0.0564703941,
0.0320669226,
-0.0338986255,
-0.0059402771,
-0.0089059053,
-0.0013997403,
-0.007761077,
0.0213499125,
-0.0028607093,
0.0346616618,
0.0429712757,
-0.0453303307,
-0.0100242132,
-0.0049519115,
2.646e-7,
0.0590878427,
0.0630742759,
0.0089409985,
0.003315984,
0.0257353429,
0.0167970136,
-0.0384559743,
0.0006967848,
-0.0238485225,
0.0319392905,
0.0283080656,
-0.0151893245,
0.0510223396,
0.0635806769,
-0.0886907876,
-0.0350940749,
-0.0767707825,
0.0184634272,
-0.0796497986,
-0.0053087319,
0.0570708141,
-0.0328439139,
0.0096729398,
-0.0093610091,
-0.0212845337,
-0.0238446575,
0.0467672013,
0.0151770776,
0.0506412201,
0.0154817719,
-0.0119692506,
-0.0375659764,
-0.011778445,
-0.0182927996,
-0.0375259481,
-0.0092616584,
-0.0119373919,
0.0296821091,
0.0081477296,
0.0317494236,
0.056620568,
-0.0073053367,
-0.014120752,
-0.0237055253,
0.012077284,
0.0220938213,
-0.0016678602,
-0.0005010339,
0.0593653768,
0.006420943,
0.0446945131,
0.0020623198,
0.0171800181,
0.0356433578,
-0.0033231052,
0.0034039118,
0.0361179523,
-0.0392173976,
-0.0270553268,
0.0078208353,
-0.0374839194,
0.0074989791,
-0.0578254871,
0.0210621897,
-0.020077616,
-0.0612261556,
0.0187993851,
2.39183759e-34,
0.0129895573,
-0.0289150458,
-0.0022146404,
-0.0176671762,
0.0333644561,
-0.0034495953,
0.0879353136,
-0.0054010754,
0.0146754282,
-0.0312618092,
-0.0467124023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03589v1 | CALaMo: a Constructionist Assessment of Language Models | 2023-02-07T16:56:48 | 2023-02-07T16:56:48 | Ludovica Pannitto, Aurélie Herbelot | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents a novel framework for evaluating Neural Language Models'
linguistic abilities using a constructionist approach. Not only is the
usage-based model in line with the underlying stochastic philosophy of neural
architectures, but it also allows the linguist to keep meaning as a determinant
factor in the analysis. We outline the framework and present two possible
scenarios for its application. | [
0.0062844241,
0.0808957443,
-0.0449071079,
0.0426948443,
-0.0265751742,
0.0091005117,
0.0014379601,
-0.0151000423,
-0.0372423232,
-0.0107117593,
-0.0541977175,
-0.1031824127,
0.0229482185,
0.0289327409,
0.0500730649,
-0.0146494247,
0.0321889296,
-0.0300368853,
0.0131385578,
0.0174601357,
-0.0222411435,
-0.0469404086,
0.0093358746,
0.030718239,
-0.0151058817,
-0.0178728998,
-0.0053028595,
-0.0514152274,
-0.0452854,
-0.0317216404,
-0.0124443108,
0.0486980714,
-0.0368343815,
0.0491859317,
0.0000017159,
-0.0255867895,
0.0499836355,
-0.0019934233,
-0.0243248809,
0.0195869599,
0.0768188238,
0.0286148693,
-0.0345656127,
-0.0109983822,
-0.0560246333,
0.0286215357,
0.048341874,
-0.0119036585,
0.0146208387,
0.0462118015,
-0.0122637311,
-0.0592037663,
0.0510550663,
-0.0472386517,
-0.0174727272,
-0.0009421683,
0.0263184048,
0.0089150956,
0.0363600664,
-0.0080628358,
-0.0389607362,
0.0463118516,
0.0533056036,
0.0029298412,
0.0048054159,
0.0155926663,
0.0147446254,
-0.0407732688,
-0.0009232169,
0.0305123236,
0.0091845123,
-0.0035352432,
-0.0157285035,
0.0069177863,
0.0010667165,
-0.0045542521,
-0.0328509212,
-0.00871142,
0.0509295687,
0.0352136344,
0.0541618988,
-0.0148330601,
0.0453948192,
0.0011682372,
-0.0008988188,
0.0761976242,
0.0352463536,
-0.031038858,
-0.015785832,
0.0003088671,
0.027743144,
-0.0526849888,
-0.0157105848,
0.0303811952,
0.0164967999,
0.0446751975,
-0.0073674014,
-0.0167521872,
0.0124682803,
-0.094012998,
0.0562894456,
0.0055510951,
-0.0045468225,
0.0247945413,
-0.026561942,
0.0456750467,
-0.0072955023,
0.0078736236,
-0.0481674783,
0.0288885664,
-0.0397859402,
-0.0170861855,
-0.0275820624,
0.0043869405,
-0.0076142568,
-0.0389245264,
-0.0581811145,
0.0177281648,
0.0116404798,
-0.0461872071,
0.0239079669,
-0.0047008581,
-0.0362260304,
0.0300866757,
-0.0764203891,
-0.0261021927,
-0.0088095786,
0.027064357,
-0.0006683607,
-0.0648936927,
0.0083698472,
0.0351660512,
-0.0538567342,
-0.0321287103,
-0.0003114207,
0.0511719026,
0.0220976472,
-0.022815831,
-0.0265646819,
0.0133880302,
-0.0624556504,
-0.039683111,
0.0229229461,
-0.0547774918,
0.0039297547,
-0.0153828263,
0.0004636742,
-0.0583666563,
-0.0064941468,
0.0018424572,
-0.0392369628,
0.0384667479,
-0.03858364,
0.0094563169,
-0.0139835551,
-0.0016914661,
0.0628642812,
0.0630890355,
0.0837872401,
-0.0148569169,
0.0068888296,
0.0074016792,
-0.0117620165,
0.039538905,
-0.0076609044,
-0.0048416932,
-0.0598799251,
-0.0273326878,
-0.0150474077,
0.016283771,
0.0097850496,
0.0831153914,
-0.0237070676,
-0.0115763256,
0.0342916921,
0.0179440584,
0.0460990965,
0.0184980147,
0.0947072282,
-0.072914876,
0.021147659,
0.0073010423,
-0.0246405341,
0.0051992149,
-0.0203594118,
0.012727391,
-0.0363243483,
0.0041287597,
-0.0204881262,
-0.0744215772,
-0.0164929796,
-0.0213437621,
0.0386033617,
-0.021590827,
0.0671951398,
0.0113252029,
0.0140089896,
0.0173565987,
-0.0014312636,
-0.0065179272,
0.0183184762,
-0.0879370272,
0.0051381853,
0.0020323133,
0.0019547537,
-0.0059146658,
-0.0088445405,
0.0440579355,
-0.0365713798,
0.0841964856,
0.0518856123,
0.0072803702,
0.0104274917,
-0.0310642105,
0.0115143852,
-0.0066733831,
0.0359074697,
0.0183967426,
-0.0517460816,
0.0149321035,
0.0081016617,
-0.0360628217,
-0.067334339,
0.0490036421,
0.0073486376,
-0.0151731092,
-0.0203542858,
-0.0002327898,
0.0389794633,
0.0164503343,
-0.0125674689,
0.0693075284,
0.0351133309,
-0.0450719595,
-0.0130843427,
0.0265877768,
-0.0389536805,
-0.0058397558,
0.0405156091,
0.0074196802,
0.0400910191,
-0.0136625487,
0.0312149897,
-0.0452726074,
0.0695954636,
-0.0376442187,
0.0603700615,
-0.0537419617,
0.0487034731,
-0.031551905,
0.0534014627,
-0.0246457625,
0.079463087,
-0.0129771186,
0.048203703,
0.0084014386,
0.0446358323,
0.0497712158,
-0.0554899685,
-0.0878308862,
0.0060434835,
-0.0073052859,
0.0080989366,
-0.0046417085,
0.0206926335,
-0.0359349065,
-0.0473927259,
-0.0470443927,
-0.0207846537,
-0.0143898642,
0.0381581821,
0.0167142116,
-0.028653482,
-0.0092041902,
0.0062986198,
-0.0022030086,
0.0092455121,
-0.0132511118,
0.0223096255,
0.0629729331,
0.0066070319,
-0.0653093383,
-0.0483578183,
-0.0548971333,
-0.0210791342,
0.0424688496,
0.034218315,
0.0046860385,
-0.0385117531,
0.0254114438,
-0.0384945422,
0.0079139378,
0.0126286447,
-0.0694989339,
0.0563369654,
-0.0038808854,
0.0087849852,
0.073444128,
-0.0236309711,
0.0516558103,
0.0536015928,
-0.0212709662,
0.0249285772,
0.0143889133,
-0.0099396128,
-0.0182628166,
-0.0476024523,
-0.035414882,
-0.0090001421,
0.0954414979,
0.0105315913,
-0.0374630131,
-0.0329488888,
0.0284279957,
-0.0616409555,
-0.0365566909,
0.0072909882,
-0.0120376656,
-0.0284878965,
0.0546288379,
-0.0266834125,
-0.0319638252,
0.0418039151,
-0.0533151701,
-0.0055831592,
-0.0127940495,
-0.0000202154,
-0.0220814925,
0.0537599549,
0.0446055382,
-0.006407185,
0.041865699,
-0.0132364901,
-0.0436482467,
-0.0158921126,
-0.0123722022,
-0.0238489304,
-0.0003987742,
-0.0528819747,
-0.006042459,
0.0201839115,
-0.0076783826,
-0.016448481,
0.0108950557,
-0.0277684759,
0.0506136529,
0.0137472423,
0.0307306033,
-0.0125054102,
0.0231664404,
-0.0140757989,
-0.0024343187,
-0.0113953976,
0.0188896693,
-0.0092452839,
0.0181057025,
0.0083573507,
0.0277367234,
0.041491583,
-0.0092726778,
0.0258872434,
-0.0151527151,
0.0146357743,
0.0836071819,
-0.0739850402,
0.0440161116,
0.0050380789,
0.0110227698,
-0.0547164939,
0.0086213211,
0.0286650024,
-0.0449983776,
-0.0456474498,
0.1072130203,
0.0200135987,
-0.0170076843,
0.0182057396,
0.0048339483,
0.0050811283,
0.0311981421,
0.0117699159,
-0.0433804058,
-0.002265556,
-0.012838277,
-0.0131953526,
-0.0266134497,
-0.0119467499,
-0.0126604084,
-0.0914649293,
0.0022890912,
-0.00999106,
-0.0524229668,
0.0008694163,
-0.0163227189,
-0.0066142804,
-0.0043669133,
0.029825002,
0.0339250453,
0.0219459869,
0.0043639475,
0.0071396665,
-0.0260922704,
-0.0704156533,
0.014176433,
-0.0421618968,
0.0696859434,
0.0595919825,
0.0341632441,
-0.0581699498,
-0.0457814634,
0.0366495401,
-0.0329620875,
0.001737486,
0.021346448,
0.0116082868,
0.0278285034,
-0.0465445742,
-0.001547359,
-0.0298811495,
-0.0211389866,
-0.0128056845,
-0.0572984628,
0.0545338541,
-0.0008042748,
-0.0371699594,
-0.0120639261,
0.009428869,
-0.0023733217,
0.0362445116,
0.0726392642,
-0.0568365082,
-0.0187403616,
-0.0117154568,
-0.0241925325,
-0.018917283,
-0.0287526101,
0.0423127897,
0.028771041,
-0.0350373387,
-0.0683299825,
-0.0478399731,
-0.0179029219,
0.0349826626,
0.0284916535,
0.0098610157,
0.0157578439,
-0.0556108654,
0.0167234037,
0.0364714898,
0.0058486392,
0.0094924541,
-0.0815048888,
-0.0041988613,
0.0499207005,
0.0063798199,
-0.0339157954,
0.0009003504,
-0.0759320557,
-0.0510506332,
0.0193209704,
0.0607396252,
0.0318657085,
-0.0540150367,
-0.0524475612,
-0.0682046041,
-0.0027231737,
0.0098203039,
0.002249117,
0.039876502,
0.015058089,
-0.0536474437,
-0.0023198356,
0.0345179215,
0.0061219353,
0.0380574353,
0.0124571137,
0.0539890267,
-0.000966123,
-0.0064796582,
0.011936333,
0.0078580789,
0.044694107,
-0.0136012649,
-0.0055291727,
-0.0183086041,
-0.0124159642,
-0.0305768643,
0.0009445942,
-0.018215403,
-0.0061849975,
0.0430454575,
0.0292556155,
-0.0165421348,
-0.0365038514,
-0.0176888332,
0.0213701017,
0.054959666,
-0.0008367099,
0.0599289089,
-0.0016479169,
-0.0339139067,
0.0295874272,
0.0084575759,
0.0146430321,
-0.0698595643,
0.0240632202,
-0.0334829539,
0.0048389812,
-0.0182498842,
0.0132201249,
-0.0227956362,
0.0188608859,
-0.0522256941,
-0.0296630207,
0.0027167534,
0.0015596125,
0.0514476113,
-0.010977963,
0.0457098,
-0.0267291032,
0.004206067,
-0.0351553597,
0.015733134,
0.0074713845,
-0.0089063505,
0.0315914042,
0.007703274,
0.0028522899,
-0.0343803428,
0.026418902,
0.0314629972,
0.01158222,
-0.0235285927,
0.0298884884,
-0.0078861173,
-0.0192933716,
-0.0162907895,
-0.0061709625,
-0.0506571829,
0.0046322653,
-0.0547728091,
-0.1110721976,
0.0139514208,
0.0852411464,
0.0498155504,
0.0192133039,
0.0213163123,
0.0485016182,
-0.0172919426,
0.0379267894,
-0.038651783,
-0.014901612,
0.0377353095,
-0.0010769465,
-0.0220867544,
-5.831656862e-33,
-0.0637278631,
-0.0095661161,
0.0428742282,
-0.009764404,
-0.0135440649,
-0.0213726051,
-0.0423814729,
0.0346094929,
-0.0605933368,
-0.0132794194,
-0.0066060759,
0.0164513923,
0.0120234312,
0.034459807,
0.0293855239,
0.0140246386,
-0.0052549751,
-0.0270019658,
0.0240837745,
-0.0414021499,
-0.0158490259,
0.0134826759,
0.0651236698,
-0.0428139307,
0.0680701137,
0.0308112092,
0.0025670158,
0.0079253782,
-0.0015003923,
0.0846714973,
-0.0394262373,
0.017596744,
0.0411688127,
0.0054719439,
0.0109045487,
-0.0216883998,
-0.0143528692,
-0.0471203029,
0.0427214243,
0.0010513357,
-0.0219232459,
-0.0246999189,
0.082337603,
-0.0156965423,
-0.054096505,
0.0256411619,
0.0190746803,
-0.0507537909,
-0.0242288224,
0.0248616729,
-0.068449378,
0.0039168266,
0.0299007464,
0.0112949451,
-0.0020488133,
-0.0483915135,
-0.0561192185,
0.0012548227,
-0.0380438901,
0.0067953337,
-0.013831432,
0.0701808035,
0.0460330658,
0.067750439,
0.0373342484,
0.0384574309,
0.0439748578,
-0.0261050854,
0.0020237563,
-0.0121759512,
0.1207903251,
0.0202301312,
0.0657666102,
0.0342299491,
0.0421384014,
-0.0152670983,
-0.0869986787,
-0.0422317274,
0.0723622665,
0.0286618583,
0.0183983929,
-0.0129308589,
-0.0201972388,
-0.0167096406,
-0.0631055385,
-0.0883862823,
-0.0294691473,
-0.0142378164,
0.0255610179,
-0.0118632633,
0.0175141618,
-0.0381174982,
0.0035387296,
-0.0477878153,
-0.005185829,
0.0136099681,
-0.0033005993,
0.0378133953,
0.0111493245,
0.0551927723,
-0.0202755146,
-0.0412885174,
-0.0417997874,
0.0678465143,
0.0138696637,
-0.0171614513,
0.000605641,
0.02967228,
-0.0005347197,
-0.0099593354,
-0.035940744,
-0.0357524231,
0.024487244,
0.0266683027,
0.0256029684,
0.0042534168,
-0.02446522,
0.0228411946,
-0.0079219928,
0.034324415,
-0.0237183087,
0.004195333,
0.0331525952,
0.040524058,
-0.031817697,
-0.0142285395,
-0.011663042,
0.058722727,
0.0491781496,
-0.0524052903,
0.0018674424,
0.0139994845,
2.53e-7,
0.0834179819,
0.0042524571,
-0.0096143894,
0.0354148783,
0.0331374332,
-0.0056862561,
-0.0819369107,
0.0033874514,
-0.0125094457,
-0.0071544163,
-0.0111212246,
0.0290444773,
0.0379760042,
-0.0007834299,
-0.052573815,
-0.0051403972,
-0.0549650453,
0.0042821625,
-0.0247646458,
0.0022196372,
0.0120025119,
0.1052735597,
0.0037465731,
-0.0181228127,
-0.0630413741,
-0.0805296823,
0.0566925928,
0.000949871,
0.0115244752,
0.0323056653,
0.025904566,
0.0612730496,
0.0129949683,
0.013835826,
0.0165331997,
0.054077059,
0.0312070865,
0.0422543325,
-0.0030974667,
-0.0121964552,
0.018340731,
-0.0174370445,
-0.0263368636,
-0.0458018705,
0.050830543,
-0.0645789728,
-0.0392869227,
-0.013928527,
0.0143611021,
0.0513409972,
0.0379551351,
-0.0489153713,
-0.0409063473,
-0.0001239357,
0.0337316543,
-0.042422466,
-0.0155056287,
-0.0272183958,
-0.0056660944,
0.026974149,
-0.0383941196,
-0.0530580841,
-0.0405327082,
-0.012564173,
0.0456917249,
-0.0124040339,
0.0089362655,
1.852966872e-34,
0.0373859592,
-0.0133108487,
0.0324153863,
0.0142285582,
0.0167454835,
-0.0002253934,
0.0054935687,
-0.0089090113,
-0.0215537734,
-0.0913316607,
-0.0299516656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03694v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03694v1 | Characterizing Financial Market Coverage using Artificial Intelligence | 2023-02-07T16:03:33 | 2023-02-07T16:03:33 | Jean Marie Tshimula, D'Jeff K. Nkashama, Patrick Owusu, Marc Frappier, Pierre-Martin Tardif, Froduald Kabanza, Armelle Brun, Jean-Marc Patenaude, Shengrui Wang, Belkacem Chikhaoui | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | This paper scrutinizes a database of over 4900 YouTube videos to characterize
financial market coverage. Financial market coverage generates a large number
of videos. Therefore, watching these videos to derive actionable insights could
be challenging and complex. In this paper, we leverage Whisper, a
speech-to-text model from OpenAI, to generate a text corpus of market coverage
videos from Bloomberg and Yahoo Finance. We employ natural language processing
to extract insights regarding language use from the market coverage. Moreover,
we examine the prominent presence of trending topics and their evolution over
time, and the impacts that some individuals and organizations have on the
financial market. Our characterization highlights the dynamics of the financial
market coverage and provides valuable insights reflecting broad discussions
regarding recent financial events and the world economy. | [
0.0011360315,
0.0587049276,
-0.0428604968,
-0.0277110487,
0.0162813161,
-0.0074949861,
0.0117676929,
0.0504224859,
0.0107198982,
-0.0764757469,
0.024411045,
0.0050342116,
-0.0272388104,
0.0936027095,
0.0147881368,
-0.055074431,
0.026104195,
-0.0225618016,
0.0582591891,
0.0203723628,
0.0413677655,
-0.0155800711,
0.0068391077,
0.0150952823,
-0.0058292621,
0.0014087206,
-0.0058381488,
-0.0402896889,
0.0114867883,
-0.0063708154,
-0.0071548475,
-0.0067539937,
0.0403876342,
0.0226785,
0.0000016538,
-0.0295372307,
0.0309512708,
-0.0236948077,
0.0142283952,
0.0003050168,
0.0439143851,
-0.0511052571,
0.0351026766,
0.0239082351,
-0.0843567401,
0.0707275048,
0.060639482,
0.0310228672,
0.0574364811,
0.0745856911,
-0.0364008732,
-0.0419784002,
0.0198688507,
-0.0266601238,
0.0229464155,
-0.0790971443,
0.0321701169,
-0.0178413764,
-0.0140942866,
-0.0294531528,
-0.0187800676,
0.0652499571,
-0.0065107392,
-0.0152847143,
0.0090535972,
0.0056489371,
-0.0476064272,
-0.0189067144,
-0.0564126708,
0.0310477521,
0.0434340946,
0.0395967849,
0.0347805507,
-0.016241191,
-0.0013313252,
0.0293321237,
-0.0249112342,
0.0517237261,
0.0081678918,
-0.0044938866,
-0.0036185512,
0.028356608,
0.021957824,
-0.0083490014,
-0.0092941467,
0.0145123526,
-0.0134266438,
-0.025842404,
0.0361847952,
-0.0019585458,
0.0463532619,
-0.0522601344,
0.03253977,
0.0103963111,
0.0252117068,
0.0078098434,
0.0027901437,
-0.0536509231,
-0.0287736561,
-0.118071869,
-0.0046079522,
0.0165078584,
-0.0142330853,
0.0335137025,
-0.0113793751,
-0.0085764397,
0.0362370312,
-0.0732493624,
0.0104927868,
0.0086158346,
-0.058373671,
0.0285664387,
-0.0119473385,
0.0588994175,
-0.0439975187,
-0.0500407778,
-0.0389951617,
0.0071716951,
-0.035469193,
0.0246638916,
-0.0430441126,
-0.0140634952,
-0.0010318051,
-0.0042317323,
-0.023431126,
-0.0160315353,
-0.0707778931,
0.0443406142,
-0.001006141,
-0.0093805809,
0.0336913429,
0.0241778754,
-0.0166495014,
-0.0034191618,
0.0034095356,
0.051749479,
0.0408219993,
-0.0283267014,
-0.0599506572,
-0.0429759994,
-0.0112688318,
0.0312680677,
-0.0376918241,
-0.006450939,
0.0113743134,
-0.0406737104,
-0.0092187449,
0.0202878807,
0.0090048946,
-0.0113322753,
-0.050609991,
0.0693554506,
0.0049266638,
-0.0187026691,
0.053154476,
-0.0350841768,
0.0468753353,
0.0556817055,
0.0156510882,
0.0194638576,
0.0692901686,
0.0103388345,
0.0113013266,
0.0446151085,
0.0079991454,
-0.0337580293,
-0.0023912492,
0.0178549606,
-0.0160363894,
-0.0082630953,
0.0270048492,
0.0242085718,
0.0049226689,
-0.0212136451,
0.0651452616,
0.0551993735,
0.002255104,
0.0063796737,
0.0195138603,
0.0429091863,
0.0197867602,
-0.0061649736,
0.0441434495,
-0.0030119263,
-0.0367027968,
0.0197051987,
0.0033080757,
-0.0102057215,
-0.0701210871,
-0.0348491259,
-0.00575333,
-0.045968134,
0.009043891,
-0.0076100151,
0.0215497389,
-0.0322250947,
-0.0257472452,
0.0714232028,
0.0405431092,
-0.0079800375,
0.0231393613,
-0.0227346942,
0.0348519385,
0.060917899,
-0.0113869924,
-0.0052622645,
0.0495657884,
-0.0203857459,
-0.005795571,
0.0658283532,
0.0162124299,
0.0034051868,
-0.0552912913,
-0.0574754216,
0.0228540655,
0.0224709548,
0.0419046171,
0.0266968403,
-0.031745173,
0.0359643698,
-0.0249648225,
-0.0114646936,
-0.0179733112,
0.0290288236,
0.0244783424,
-0.0159844588,
0.0075685754,
-0.0143977348,
0.026567474,
0.0281266142,
-0.0007079245,
-0.0270936303,
-0.0115592415,
-0.0177258514,
-0.0361803733,
0.0182245243,
-0.0096750427,
0.0534512363,
-0.0159292389,
-0.0636563525,
-0.0056004478,
0.0248567238,
-0.027811056,
-0.0229055155,
0.0423545875,
-0.0223365594,
0.0294837002,
-0.0674654394,
-0.0785057843,
0.006440897,
0.0266024582,
0.0094957948,
0.0632507429,
-0.0045905197,
-0.0178263877,
-0.0198696367,
-0.0049532084,
0.0175771303,
-0.0383049101,
0.0372256041,
0.0047877892,
-0.0533287562,
0.0438906811,
0.0468920767,
-0.0523950607,
0.0023075482,
-0.0046863453,
-0.0748617873,
-0.0487221479,
-0.0120558506,
0.0185057819,
0.0076014763,
0.0222611688,
-0.0075512282,
-0.0081588365,
-0.0047287135,
-0.0263824575,
-0.0303529669,
-0.0171237011,
0.0574433915,
0.0123043722,
-0.0077607464,
-0.0515317358,
-0.0151620349,
-0.0424104296,
0.0148636103,
0.06761159,
-0.0458361432,
-0.0080150208,
-0.0357928053,
-0.0206846707,
0.0108072972,
-0.0106599731,
0.0071243281,
-0.0095794667,
0.0271701422,
-0.0130829941,
0.0666005015,
0.0558692999,
0.1103154942,
-0.0559512004,
0.0280692745,
0.0052807298,
0.0305669084,
-0.0082556801,
-0.010300287,
-0.0382489078,
-0.0036727656,
0.0539253615,
0.0260365307,
0.0088414317,
0.0209373962,
-0.0758774504,
0.014917234,
-0.0203347784,
-0.0030818977,
-0.0293671247,
-0.0091022179,
-0.0298813209,
0.0667281225,
0.0283410922,
-0.03271145,
0.0274479855,
0.0253237206,
0.0038100134,
-0.0101183085,
-0.0630795211,
-0.0591774099,
0.0232610293,
-0.0333573073,
0.0202466976,
-0.0079694875,
-0.0821855962,
-0.0200785305,
-0.0533343293,
0.0258825663,
-0.0153892683,
0.0107055111,
-0.0484856442,
0.0248473026,
0.0166413952,
0.0053566205,
-0.011337393,
-0.0761131644,
-0.0333369635,
0.0039192401,
0.0681620464,
-0.0702044219,
-0.0610827431,
0.0271279253,
-0.0312390495,
-0.0265677683,
0.006255832,
-0.0242226794,
0.0355723836,
0.0373065621,
0.0677134693,
-0.0032001485,
-0.0062799663,
-0.0103788953,
0.0714463964,
0.0193542931,
0.0696653575,
0.0218052529,
-0.0396240242,
-0.0090767276,
-0.0334287509,
-0.0517133847,
0.0292135123,
0.0494092964,
-0.0326083973,
-0.0171049237,
0.026050631,
0.090701215,
0.0105102193,
0.0134585621,
0.0101768998,
0.0396349728,
-0.0201679897,
-0.0327668972,
0.0475206114,
-0.1209001243,
0.0084803002,
-0.0287746266,
0.0369725972,
0.0161899328,
-0.0373015814,
-0.0028778152,
-0.1148478314,
0.0651395321,
-0.0093743876,
-0.009239844,
0.0063023176,
-0.0422586501,
-0.0329184085,
-0.0349344015,
0.035024561,
-0.0230315756,
-0.0229542386,
0.0074410136,
0.0267071091,
-0.1172332242,
-0.0576616041,
0.0241392888,
-0.0213217977,
-0.0095076291,
0.0194320846,
0.030535249,
-0.04758754,
0.0051759211,
-0.0657326207,
-0.0181155242,
0.0147799766,
0.0103229657,
0.0857612044,
-0.035167478,
-0.0332797021,
0.0183817223,
0.0462272242,
0.0035157651,
0.068122074,
0.0136070037,
-0.0122463387,
-0.041085586,
-0.0637024716,
-0.024823131,
0.0445575938,
0.012586331,
0.0442363918,
0.0034385079,
-0.0430614129,
0.0125334859,
-0.0339138359,
0.0116859153,
-0.0609611236,
-0.0302131455,
-0.0282473639,
0.0408752598,
-0.0382228047,
-0.0637395754,
-0.0328052677,
0.0014158227,
0.0138037279,
0.0290852413,
0.0067750826,
0.0823063776,
0.0225983374,
-0.0203407016,
0.0062522809,
0.014596913,
-0.0056672953,
-0.0242589973,
-0.0071498617,
0.0237447284,
-0.0033320775,
-0.0390881822,
0.0581205934,
-0.0397449136,
-0.0450334065,
0.0137343258,
-0.0040566954,
0.0320957638,
-0.0216609351,
-0.0145890117,
0.044466015,
0.044894293,
0.0603136271,
-0.0632618219,
-0.0345996097,
0.0496456474,
-0.0049012895,
-0.0042176112,
0.0305810701,
-0.0314553231,
-0.0134794656,
-0.070363678,
-0.0287580788,
-0.0725626871,
0.0421980284,
-0.0335563347,
-0.0435602516,
0.0225505531,
0.022559505,
-0.0380288474,
-0.0389326997,
-0.0574734099,
0.0180838127,
0.0326452143,
-0.001749124,
-0.0071222922,
0.0188582484,
0.0059891031,
-0.0365241133,
0.0778306648,
-0.043752756,
-0.0686526522,
-0.0332424715,
0.0025031315,
0.0084724873,
0.0370811746,
-0.0265079085,
-0.0099946754,
0.0295012668,
0.0187411755,
0.0441466607,
0.0065216469,
0.0205986481,
-0.0205020513,
0.0167295653,
0.0324829482,
0.0372823738,
-0.0123119829,
-0.0439392105,
-0.0270085558,
0.0276453998,
0.0430632979,
0.0087388083,
-0.0306518245,
-0.0152093368,
-0.0281529389,
0.0269413535,
0.0275345035,
0.0341717042,
-0.0149302818,
-0.046272222,
-0.0113784615,
-0.02295422,
-0.0704046711,
-0.009414494,
0.0798762515,
0.0296650343,
0.0247908942,
-0.0040439717,
0.0180380438,
-0.0101833083,
-0.0257200096,
0.0495128557,
0.054572437,
-0.0079765134,
0.0003054295,
-0.045513168,
-0.0529957935,
0.0366044603,
-0.0431403294,
0.0201075897,
0.0079095587,
0.046909634,
0.0343485065,
0.0182387885,
0.0556508228,
0.0113001633,
-0.0194674917,
-0.0791312382,
-0.0054845419,
-0.049397666,
-5.74124004e-33,
-0.0270459782,
-0.0250781775,
0.0154951205,
0.0591173321,
0.0177516546,
0.0136208348,
-0.0249523614,
0.0094125597,
-0.0320056081,
0.0080211908,
0.0281661488,
0.0648735538,
0.0181069523,
0.0081494916,
0.0637527108,
-0.0028452144,
0.0239037517,
-0.047869727,
0.0054973694,
-0.0057419664,
0.0242084432,
0.0711060688,
0.0365676843,
-0.0667112395,
0.0269641746,
0.01379715,
-0.0470435061,
-0.0607386455,
0.1001540646,
0.037346404,
-0.0045321072,
0.0486537628,
0.0152490502,
-0.0497307107,
-0.0129788965,
0.0226023141,
-0.015267564,
-0.0491260476,
0.0304877404,
0.0206914097,
-0.0066687423,
0.0158063564,
0.0294749979,
-0.0034301432,
-0.0111793652,
0.0262882896,
0.0626927316,
-0.0037536584,
0.0317165218,
-0.0027567921,
-0.0569050945,
0.012142974,
-0.0279068109,
0.0270844717,
0.0287829265,
0.0543766394,
0.023369547,
0.0298688598,
-0.0277394075,
0.0241293628,
-0.0205954518,
0.0114394976,
0.0169263873,
-0.0069331466,
-0.0327498689,
0.0662256703,
-0.0022380741,
-0.0127961524,
-0.0145069929,
0.0005113198,
0.0152233401,
0.053778708,
0.0148689179,
0.009811582,
0.0081117498,
-0.0780408382,
-0.0391729884,
0.0214571767,
0.0516465157,
0.0204302799,
-0.00805791,
-0.0076155174,
-0.0234885402,
-0.0197735894,
0.0164992735,
-0.0154115194,
-0.0069846236,
-0.0014304832,
0.0111682722,
-0.0027100928,
0.0214914624,
0.0472503901,
0.0219559073,
-0.052555874,
-0.0564857572,
-0.0133402459,
0.0199091118,
0.0035635587,
0.0117273508,
-0.0183188561,
-0.053505864,
-0.0271723717,
-0.0081120413,
0.0392450765,
-0.0104278494,
-0.0449843369,
-0.0114605492,
0.0271353833,
-0.0191835798,
-0.0222534835,
0.0347998813,
-0.0163805187,
0.0220265072,
0.0409371667,
0.0047174762,
0.0517857783,
-0.0085973125,
0.0078114187,
-0.0196044166,
0.0388459265,
-0.0030816398,
-0.0528216958,
-0.0330089927,
0.0300325528,
-0.0118737286,
-0.0180212166,
-0.0121083176,
0.0668531433,
0.0289263353,
-0.0367730111,
-0.0204506032,
0.0223256815,
2.481e-7,
0.0398922004,
0.068846494,
0.0032869841,
0.0173283536,
0.019916378,
0.0436244495,
-0.0088467235,
0.019469317,
-0.0120380111,
-0.0275841989,
0.0237931721,
-0.004100787,
0.0471987091,
0.010872487,
-0.0883393362,
-0.0439431779,
-0.0784061328,
0.0299188904,
-0.1100050062,
0.0487405621,
-0.0005797824,
0.0614161417,
0.017728189,
-0.0158237815,
-0.0014172194,
-0.079638347,
0.0311255027,
-0.0178712253,
-0.0416046977,
0.0183614232,
-0.0133059146,
0.0520372875,
-0.0360986777,
0.0133187547,
-0.0460872315,
0.0270395465,
0.0192903131,
-0.0110737691,
0.0073327115,
0.0037422781,
-0.0193896387,
0.002984992,
-0.0367419496,
-0.0070750839,
0.0010591857,
-0.0513227396,
-0.042741321,
-0.0830804557,
-0.0258757994,
0.0278155245,
0.0228946228,
0.0120380642,
0.0172627382,
0.0105382046,
-0.0012238669,
-0.0223881677,
0.0299543608,
-0.0421046689,
0.0225030258,
-0.0154552385,
-0.0515331961,
0.0439720936,
-0.0351639315,
0.0145056508,
0.0242694896,
0.0044280053,
0.032936234,
1.628544567e-34,
0.062698327,
-0.0281357802,
-0.0444711,
0.0368917957,
0.0503636897,
0.0327174477,
-0.0232566539,
0.0291438214,
-0.0107279485,
-0.0541305579,
-0.0214718673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03528v1 | Efficiently Upgrading Multilingual Machine Translation Models to Support More Languages | 2023-02-07T15:20:13 | 2023-02-07T15:20:13 | Simeng Sun, Maha Elbayad, Anna Sun, James Cross | cs.CL | cs.CL | With multilingual machine translation (MMT) models continuing to grow in size
and number of supported languages, it is natural to reuse and upgrade existing
models to save computation as data becomes available in more languages.
However, adding new languages requires updating the vocabulary, which
complicates the reuse of embeddings. The question of how to reuse existing
models while also making architectural changes to provide capacity for both old
and new languages has also not been closely studied. In this work, we introduce
three techniques that help speed up effective learning of the new languages and
alleviate catastrophic forgetting despite vocabulary and architecture
mismatches. Our results show that by (1) carefully initializing the network,
(2) applying learning rate scaling, and (3) performing data up-sampling, it is
possible to exceed the performance of a same-sized baseline model with 30%
computation and recover the performance of a larger model trained from scratch
with over 50% reduction in computation. Furthermore, our analysis reveals that
the introduced techniques help learn the new directions more effectively and
alleviate catastrophic forgetting at the same time. We hope our work will guide
research into more efficient approaches to growing languages for these MMT
models and ultimately maximize the reuse of existing models. | [
0.0044890405,
0.0828731209,
-0.012787981,
0.0488546714,
-0.0233849753,
0.0186908152,
-0.0002898313,
0.0040430562,
-0.021947505,
0.0064101582,
-0.0497532077,
-0.0538747609,
-0.0044864006,
0.0055726357,
0.0169806611,
-0.0353863984,
0.0336690284,
-0.0245086215,
-0.0519488491,
-0.0297215246,
-0.0195064414,
0.0320990793,
0.0529356673,
-0.0017168426,
0.0017103484,
-0.0003741495,
-0.0145261073,
0.0257561728,
0.0083528217,
-0.0166369304,
-0.0194424,
0.0087721897,
0.0486754365,
0.1032806933,
0.0000020663,
-0.0301225409,
-0.0549285524,
-0.0043885559,
0.0054529179,
0.0253944471,
0.0790689662,
-0.0641248822,
-0.0080283191,
0.0228364952,
-0.0176620688,
-0.0344488658,
0.0588399284,
-0.0255451854,
0.033328414,
0.0652677044,
-0.0048878887,
-0.0390712097,
0.0204564296,
-0.0651627108,
-0.0372130796,
-0.0529610701,
-0.0237701423,
0.0305440165,
-0.0496211313,
0.0207475442,
-0.0266254824,
0.0612564906,
0.0283976477,
0.0253035668,
-0.0232539885,
0.0344804488,
0.0288148765,
-0.0210443698,
-0.0139941685,
0.0356877521,
-0.0868684053,
-0.0154483048,
-0.0272316523,
-0.0108637726,
-0.0134688094,
-0.0351883061,
-0.0405724421,
0.0023231823,
0.008162234,
0.001996693,
0.0175882336,
-0.0073743002,
0.0657038093,
0.0015744586,
-0.0416512527,
-0.0224880278,
0.0483750366,
-0.0001796296,
0.0026481978,
0.0046834187,
-0.0175477359,
0.0233614147,
0.024199158,
-0.0019518685,
-0.0144285988,
0.0333305635,
-0.033063665,
-0.0540781207,
0.0133441761,
-0.0556865744,
0.0486787558,
0.0703440756,
0.006228989,
0.0573195629,
-0.0366601609,
0.0254679881,
-0.0613418929,
-0.0311965365,
-0.0942141339,
0.007166272,
-0.0135366414,
-0.0107769128,
-0.0664554015,
0.0021034121,
-0.0148346741,
0.0045572105,
-0.0043385839,
0.0378970504,
0.0184293818,
-0.014159007,
0.0061757723,
-0.0449854396,
-0.0752443597,
-0.0089788698,
0.0399912894,
0.0618128702,
-0.0281532723,
-0.043354772,
0.0019093283,
-0.0641723275,
-0.0368602462,
-0.0162384044,
-0.0053661936,
-0.0227891654,
0.0307852738,
0.0802937895,
-0.0238404199,
-0.029684931,
-0.0614911988,
-0.0087952791,
-0.0067523844,
-0.0577942505,
0.0175174978,
-0.0595487468,
0.0739697367,
-0.0039713453,
0.020128116,
-0.0364236981,
-0.0166764166,
0.0001125299,
-0.0449113846,
0.0506492816,
0.0056904643,
-0.0145648085,
0.0411650315,
-0.0090125008,
-0.0120250694,
0.1052559614,
0.0223018676,
-0.0105330693,
0.0383275822,
-0.0000908524,
-0.0289166868,
0.0669835731,
0.0128056295,
0.0643195063,
-0.0132400524,
-0.0299198888,
0.0364347063,
0.0395735614,
0.026200993,
0.028537089,
-0.0413171053,
0.00192271,
0.0304591358,
0.0204933602,
-0.0162389707,
0.0645860061,
0.051396288,
-0.0350994132,
-0.0289569814,
0.0221112613,
-0.0087155607,
0.0336627476,
0.0235521365,
-0.021524895,
0.0080447961,
0.048547823,
-0.0396361575,
-0.0321894959,
0.0033638971,
-0.0308306664,
0.0106129451,
-0.0335543938,
0.0585680716,
0.026931271,
-0.0209948085,
0.0566317737,
0.0174447075,
-0.0567068756,
0.0392939299,
0.0037615867,
-0.0437043346,
0.0522870682,
0.0489060245,
-0.0195043292,
-0.0357613228,
-0.0085880067,
-0.0027417943,
0.0116311116,
0.0882419199,
-0.0020527034,
0.0444829911,
-0.0704826638,
0.0044039208,
0.014402559,
0.0123233022,
0.0592037141,
0.0209808331,
0.0198886953,
0.0293474365,
-0.0325718373,
-0.0516824871,
0.0075102602,
-0.0911412835,
-0.0080083711,
0.0098376973,
0.016088713,
0.0295816753,
0.0066701095,
-0.0070244479,
-0.0068239868,
0.0293213557,
-0.0364774019,
-0.0329731368,
0.0345966145,
-0.0760009959,
-0.0314333588,
0.0318278857,
0.0153174857,
0.0274541788,
-0.0052095414,
-0.0604779758,
-0.0326351672,
0.0558468364,
-0.0366406143,
0.0157971829,
-0.0415117852,
0.0517044179,
-0.0243486799,
-0.012647274,
-0.0300138034,
0.0411305428,
-0.0291870777,
0.0067902319,
-0.0013822181,
-0.0429295972,
0.0252284352,
-0.0248455405,
-0.0492993072,
0.0517351478,
0.0264697913,
0.0420665294,
0.0314839408,
-0.0032968267,
-0.0088245897,
-0.0282021593,
-0.0644733906,
0.0110249752,
-0.0271271542,
0.0340019464,
0.024568392,
0.0520261191,
0.0295332093,
-0.0276736114,
-0.0172648542,
0.0116356174,
0.0008014285,
0.070681937,
-0.0091361841,
-0.0142687233,
0.0065100123,
-0.0178228356,
-0.0360295177,
0.0296030324,
0.064745158,
-0.028865492,
-0.0302447211,
-0.0753134713,
-0.0007358923,
-0.0466059372,
0.0211853795,
-0.020613635,
-0.0234514177,
-0.0215571616,
-0.0296505187,
0.0399401635,
0.0498942435,
-0.0256441627,
0.0239766836,
0.0561827384,
0.0120274331,
-0.0698515996,
0.0171235707,
-0.0217292402,
-0.0647311881,
-0.0196500272,
-0.0216404106,
-0.0146656986,
0.0241355859,
-0.0212960485,
-0.019742867,
-0.0508862287,
-0.0069834506,
-0.0154481186,
-0.0128021035,
-0.0163934175,
0.0234266855,
0.0190895908,
0.0015420839,
-0.0211854354,
-0.0583225973,
0.0428710468,
-0.0067922315,
-0.0064664846,
-0.0695636421,
0.020292731,
-0.0186020788,
0.0498446636,
0.0190593861,
0.0693652928,
-0.0143717369,
-0.0283728279,
-0.0636102706,
0.0169776883,
0.0135466112,
-0.0309092179,
0.0445703939,
-0.0694520175,
-0.0102572041,
-0.0213895477,
-0.0360711478,
-0.0087204129,
0.0245280899,
-0.002530443,
-0.0002525407,
-0.0146716209,
-0.0129554383,
-0.0471269451,
-0.0155303087,
0.0179493222,
0.0818657801,
0.0220817067,
0.0131770717,
-0.0048981663,
0.0439311191,
-0.0228275936,
-0.015941551,
0.0039200485,
-0.0503530614,
0.0387051553,
0.0391023643,
0.0084332051,
-0.0306184758,
-0.0386064164,
-0.0049778861,
0.0414997786,
-0.0016296756,
-0.0288497601,
-0.0148193743,
0.0119931241,
-0.0379661396,
0.0030221669,
0.0541135408,
0.0151112108,
-0.0427245982,
-0.0069497349,
0.0038180649,
0.0500441007,
0.0367801636,
0.0199332219,
-0.0896286294,
-0.0149475178,
0.0172524601,
0.0193663333,
0.0480032638,
0.0137755489,
-0.040325474,
-0.1009205356,
-0.0034822333,
0.0605098493,
-0.0691747889,
-0.0220115148,
-0.0395701528,
-0.0449998789,
-0.0178322271,
0.0240547191,
0.0126549592,
0.0336054936,
-0.0106067499,
0.0011452666,
0.0176730286,
-0.0636135787,
-0.0116198799,
-0.0555757396,
0.0145901153,
0.037844032,
0.0402000844,
-0.0056528645,
-0.0196071696,
0.0282488186,
-0.0014225941,
0.0044892733,
-0.0170506164,
0.0260003563,
0.0308524184,
-0.0093728378,
0.0601666309,
0.0172923189,
-0.0163329113,
0.0264270902,
0.0090969149,
0.0624781474,
0.0160091221,
0.0057398914,
0.0254801158,
-0.0510826372,
-0.0125221135,
0.0284663588,
0.0095603419,
-0.0435734689,
0.0247314237,
-0.0134158134,
0.0051138434,
-0.047800187,
0.0223122761,
0.0131374868,
-0.0653191283,
-0.0349733606,
-0.0707806572,
-0.0214960873,
0.013538707,
0.0266051646,
0.0437518731,
0.0131601775,
0.0183277223,
-0.0027232529,
-0.0428903103,
0.0193592217,
-0.058420334,
0.0018511802,
-0.0287484117,
0.0389104299,
0.0072204396,
-0.0198231526,
0.0186012387,
0.000153457,
-0.0904412791,
-0.0624043457,
-0.0216654632,
0.0633850321,
0.0152864819,
0.0524972789,
0.0089290282,
-0.0268790647,
0.0175126698,
-0.0079820035,
0.0071007661,
0.0207598265,
0.0304692686,
-0.0118102469,
-0.0217332914,
0.0534803867,
-0.0093956459,
-0.0138199124,
0.007677576,
0.056295272,
-0.005369911,
0.0029390801,
0.000498367,
0.0256411787,
-0.0059848279,
-0.0443554223,
-0.0088920547,
-0.035273362,
0.022693513,
0.0170748699,
-0.0310620498,
-0.0471473448,
0.0058554285,
0.0382033065,
0.0140949693,
-0.0148776649,
-0.0186345223,
0.0427131057,
-0.0060723214,
0.0144957807,
-0.0440033786,
-0.0122271637,
0.0206780508,
0.0531499013,
0.0259009302,
-0.0393663496,
0.0118857268,
-0.0495190136,
0.0087894574,
-0.0626628697,
0.0441339724,
-0.0147279901,
-0.0146906804,
-0.0454399809,
0.0381706096,
-0.0213767216,
-0.0590347685,
-0.0273563452,
0.0268224627,
0.1006210744,
0.005633201,
0.0811230689,
-0.0188981779,
-0.0247978717,
-0.0319018625,
0.0037900498,
0.0220970828,
-0.0540146455,
0.0136255315,
-0.0156823546,
-0.0005482101,
0.020378964,
0.0760272592,
-0.0210545845,
0.0410817303,
-0.025470661,
0.0092150029,
0.0100212665,
-0.0198576674,
0.0143114431,
0.004342204,
-0.0219755955,
0.0066646133,
-0.0209670905,
-0.0526747108,
-0.0006087115,
0.007217587,
-0.0070829438,
0.0093914717,
0.0076021138,
0.0887108445,
-0.034118481,
0.0363435782,
-0.0462290794,
0.0223792698,
-0.0004028259,
-0.0286824293,
0.0178285707,
-5.938116242e-33,
0.0215904564,
0.0316867791,
0.0105393957,
-0.0479525365,
-0.0216348264,
0.0173372831,
-0.0070943236,
-0.0053973901,
-0.0160077102,
-0.0208974257,
-0.0134100905,
-0.0114696817,
0.0058663026,
0.0190673973,
0.0286007877,
0.0220553596,
0.0693866983,
-0.0122284908,
-0.0117531214,
0.0282945819,
0.0633164346,
0.0337259583,
0.1056540459,
-0.0125529701,
0.0046174899,
0.008240818,
-0.0070985053,
0.0532119684,
0.0094979592,
0.0264617987,
0.0042786496,
0.034702003,
0.025405189,
-0.0429352447,
-0.0327379368,
-0.0454861484,
-0.0903622657,
-0.0016021786,
0.0177856907,
0.0636119992,
-0.0216690544,
-0.0449728779,
0.026935989,
-0.0383981168,
0.0104895206,
-0.0198390968,
-0.014942145,
-0.0437583104,
-0.0681389645,
0.0352325961,
-0.057367105,
0.0102534993,
0.0393264815,
0.0029409807,
0.0283384658,
0.0314176045,
0.0059315334,
0.0057391878,
-0.0833257139,
-0.0110938875,
-0.02572155,
0.0636053607,
0.0671431348,
0.0321917534,
-0.0194551703,
0.0244700909,
0.0038034008,
-0.0059898095,
0.0464815348,
-0.0111189811,
0.0417252183,
-0.0072180117,
0.0593041591,
0.0268830936,
0.0597662032,
-0.0289969444,
-0.0421917774,
-0.007963419,
0.017988503,
0.0184732415,
0.0424557216,
0.0287756156,
-0.0065185865,
-0.0270835776,
-0.0825104266,
-0.0094957687,
-0.0483016409,
-0.0298932642,
-0.0063439612,
0.0402237326,
-0.017584946,
-0.0312982984,
0.0791197419,
-0.0159912221,
-0.021547256,
0.0185408629,
-0.0104461126,
0.0060798679,
-0.0140694296,
0.078701131,
0.0093881236,
-0.0406262279,
-0.0319573805,
-0.0213209148,
-0.0209614225,
-0.0183514003,
0.0725240409,
0.0435806587,
-0.0570350066,
0.0108247669,
-0.058677569,
-0.0302227102,
0.0029684303,
0.0540952832,
0.0238006413,
0.0113833286,
-0.0000222281,
0.030749131,
0.0673560351,
-0.0017845792,
-0.0433300436,
-0.0091062309,
0.0274689142,
0.0382842906,
-0.0294852965,
0.0205113087,
-0.0344516635,
-0.0158613715,
0.0445940904,
-0.0686629638,
-0.0194255188,
0.0190585963,
2.761e-7,
0.0407173969,
0.0264890604,
-0.0005353334,
-0.028477855,
0.0241212994,
0.0369773619,
-0.0391196497,
0.0329421796,
-0.0092383558,
0.0684597492,
0.0174334869,
0.0363538153,
0.0772617236,
0.0424345955,
-0.070672445,
-0.020699095,
-0.0537564196,
0.0369870737,
-0.0338147618,
-0.0493848845,
-0.0010869099,
0.1049842909,
0.0051904484,
-0.0102280295,
-0.0136276819,
-0.0414952077,
0.0926007107,
-0.0133642089,
-0.0264941566,
0.0001605218,
0.0265728254,
0.0870120004,
-0.0311242118,
-0.039994441,
-0.0477918275,
-0.0062171323,
0.026580127,
0.0604299866,
0.0130553087,
0.0154122803,
0.0479141921,
-0.0178250447,
-0.0486489162,
-0.0102177449,
0.025135614,
-0.0267012324,
0.0083367592,
-0.0102869812,
0.004164421,
0.0246686544,
0.058023721,
-0.0329160243,
-0.0462275371,
0.0496365428,
0.0405609347,
0.0186416712,
-0.0277708247,
-0.0545926765,
-0.014278465,
0.0104237078,
-0.0127548268,
-0.0588202365,
-0.0304387882,
-0.0227490682,
0.0180104859,
-0.0368698426,
0.0054169311,
2.291508917e-34,
0.041847121,
-0.0267721452,
0.0275726169,
0.0079154111,
0.0151736708,
-0.0506282374,
0.0093306657,
-0.0010104512,
-0.0232101809,
-0.0325104706,
-0.0311254263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03512v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03512v3 | A Survey on Arabic Named Entity Recognition: Past, Recent Advances, and Future Trends | 2023-02-07T14:56:52 | 2023-08-08T13:27:29 | Xiaoye Qu, Yingjie Gu, Qingrong Xia, Zechang Li, Zhefeng Wang, Baoxing Huai | cs.CL | cs.CL | As more and more Arabic texts emerged on the Internet, extracting important
information from these Arabic texts is especially useful. As a fundamental
technology, Named entity recognition (NER) serves as the core component in
information extraction technology, while also playing a critical role in many
other Natural Language Processing (NLP) systems, such as question answering and
knowledge graph building. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive review of
the development of Arabic NER, especially the recent advances in deep learning
and pre-trained language model. Specifically, we first introduce the background
of Arabic NER, including the characteristics of Arabic and existing resources
for Arabic NER. Then, we systematically review the development of Arabic NER
methods. Traditional Arabic NER systems focus on feature engineering and
designing domain-specific rules. In recent years, deep learning methods achieve
significant progress by representing texts via continuous vector
representations. With the growth of pre-trained language model, Arabic NER
yields better performance. Finally, we conclude the method gap between Arabic
NER and NER methods from other languages, which helps outline future directions
for Arabic NER. | [
0.0382615924,
0.0176083688,
0.0219395496,
0.0280578583,
-0.0143711315,
0.0544102751,
0.0379244983,
-0.0085072219,
-0.0233211257,
-0.0270027313,
-0.0111466739,
-0.0962490588,
0.0286443569,
0.0172346029,
0.0105290441,
-0.0243634917,
0.00938538,
-0.0550710894,
0.0346304923,
0.0242208987,
0.0252632704,
0.0060510593,
-0.0164896827,
0.0107940501,
0.0026810318,
-0.0074997623,
-0.0372742489,
-0.0372373909,
0.0163482055,
-0.0279290285,
0.0191430561,
0.0454861894,
-0.0274781622,
0.0148446606,
0.0000018798,
-0.074848637,
-0.0649712086,
-0.0325245447,
-0.0363806412,
-0.0401318446,
0.0107818451,
-0.0589684434,
-0.0621536151,
-0.0184377804,
-0.0280488431,
-0.0337451734,
0.039162118,
0.077722609,
0.0204969309,
0.0606226213,
0.0096818097,
-0.0541046262,
0.0603535771,
0.0124809537,
-0.0158272535,
-0.0170857124,
-0.0024329659,
-0.0326034836,
-0.0218066126,
0.0081130126,
0.004213023,
0.0184285194,
0.0063528111,
-0.0133475019,
-0.0190711208,
-0.0021123572,
-0.0242082085,
-0.0224243328,
0.0146298092,
0.0737441704,
-0.0570976287,
0.020242162,
0.0113038057,
-0.0165228304,
-0.0331413038,
-0.0341252945,
-0.0089764697,
0.050307963,
-0.0533486754,
-0.0001747487,
0.0539743677,
0.0239426419,
0.0023363146,
-0.0003361875,
-0.0432663299,
0.0329431705,
-0.0041361628,
-0.0415847823,
0.0406280309,
-0.0091723967,
0.0052750395,
-0.0177873615,
0.0645166934,
0.0212521087,
0.0686177462,
0.0084255692,
-0.0096390927,
-0.0238390323,
-0.0006220983,
-0.0736025721,
0.0025145924,
0.0356383063,
-0.0049084839,
0.0272962544,
-0.0857844651,
0.0296769887,
0.0178957228,
0.0190969147,
0.0086310962,
-0.0109919254,
-0.042537313,
-0.0138115957,
-0.0222031511,
0.0663781762,
-0.0386566184,
0.0071553728,
-0.0597812794,
0.0206570923,
-0.0059130555,
0.0226285011,
0.000091622,
-0.0047317417,
0.0061934618,
-0.0148276957,
-0.0295588113,
-0.001361155,
0.0034723573,
-0.0162553731,
-0.0665517375,
-0.0758614987,
0.0222286973,
-0.0151627492,
0.0646439195,
-0.0077211144,
0.0088380454,
0.0780881569,
0.0172439441,
-0.1195713207,
-0.0624436028,
0.0291314609,
0.0138178105,
-0.0092511149,
0.0195271038,
-0.0473099053,
0.053673476,
-0.0051258528,
-0.0267966408,
-0.032023564,
0.0205060616,
0.0083610965,
0.0130598322,
0.0830127001,
-0.0096869301,
-0.0261902306,
0.0540053807,
0.0001809146,
0.0924508646,
0.0082357302,
0.0441673473,
0.0037710897,
0.0177537892,
0.0058265221,
0.001201342,
0.0334973596,
0.0087029506,
-0.0449093729,
0.0056836521,
-0.0311377384,
-0.0298699252,
0.01080852,
-0.0165200587,
0.0159004312,
-0.0135774771,
-0.0092537785,
0.02330992,
0.0198898576,
0.0011523558,
0.0366946198,
0.0111502623,
0.0233757254,
0.0508939996,
-0.0152635239,
-0.0180720799,
0.000830661,
0.0047139488,
0.0292234868,
-0.0100168465,
0.069518052,
-0.0226623937,
-0.0513747185,
0.0100495275,
-0.038556058,
0.0138185844,
-0.0108748181,
0.0953613073,
-0.0045341635,
-0.0703352243,
0.0210766457,
0.0374750309,
0.0072042593,
0.0166323651,
-0.0285929963,
-0.0113975899,
0.0471279621,
0.0035271295,
-0.0315368138,
-0.0579910539,
-0.0205089133,
-0.0254701208,
0.0428451039,
-0.0012374212,
-0.0093523897,
0.0377596915,
-0.0236746557,
-0.0246803313,
0.0322854444,
-0.0031953852,
-0.0050615962,
0.0071435692,
0.0676502287,
0.0143015543,
-0.0149856126,
-0.0344871953,
0.0429184996,
-0.0233742576,
-0.0203087591,
0.0022274805,
0.0598678365,
0.0030907441,
0.0707407743,
0.0020652774,
-0.0297648404,
0.0136984959,
-0.0449779741,
-0.0438051298,
-0.0225652047,
-0.0271573327,
-0.0177797489,
0.0120509202,
-0.0128579792,
0.0036509598,
0.0101799788,
-0.0056614871,
-0.0290238373,
0.009982232,
0.0340328477,
0.0352917574,
-0.0251769647,
0.0564789437,
0.0329213142,
0.048492752,
-0.0310589708,
0.0588626117,
-0.0446613953,
-0.0196444951,
0.0003022613,
-0.0279449727,
0.0225966722,
0.0109594604,
-0.0247043353,
0.045120284,
-0.0161214843,
-0.0193012934,
0.0377747826,
0.0224896912,
-0.0129998373,
-0.0086232312,
-0.0399090908,
0.0130094346,
-0.0294503067,
0.0699601769,
-0.03058221,
0.0323378555,
-0.0278708693,
-0.0141009325,
-0.0126322508,
-0.0389957204,
-0.0133133009,
-0.0055212271,
0.0507148653,
-0.0068200193,
-0.0139094256,
-0.0267923418,
-0.0107338922,
-0.0127315614,
0.048251532,
0.0423625372,
-0.0750859454,
0.0127943242,
0.0040814327,
-0.0182187371,
0.0402374342,
0.0120272171,
0.0282546896,
0.0049149734,
0.0081370957,
0.002276778,
0.0311469864,
-0.0082567204,
0.0473759733,
-0.0307725649,
0.0005047334,
-0.0349773504,
0.0307495575,
-0.0389770456,
0.0309233572,
-0.0300920848,
-0.0408540741,
0.0107222581,
0.0390163511,
-0.052369643,
0.0266581643,
-0.0125433719,
0.0035625496,
-0.0215164069,
0.0018354323,
0.0079394048,
0.0378715023,
-0.0090517467,
0.0373010635,
-0.0061943973,
-0.0376853272,
0.0110723963,
-0.0316889845,
0.0154736582,
-0.0094298758,
0.0035097429,
-0.0568555631,
0.0194448214,
-0.0012841058,
0.0198371299,
0.0171101429,
-0.0840803981,
0.0225296449,
0.0496583618,
-0.0030300634,
-0.0161905736,
0.0028857833,
0.0007153968,
0.0111370645,
-0.0374259651,
0.0121837342,
-0.0204336625,
0.0235340185,
-0.050677076,
0.0197556037,
0.0147616332,
-0.0000281195,
0.0122770611,
0.0662392378,
0.0110646235,
0.0346183218,
0.0049086106,
0.0148786511,
-0.0355877504,
0.0289612934,
0.0439857841,
0.0085374201,
0.0361342095,
0.0100613013,
-0.0136202723,
0.0225684326,
-0.0701520741,
-0.0191301107,
-0.0292608868,
-0.0073649725,
0.0296418648,
-0.0702894256,
-0.0022617157,
-0.0587548874,
-0.0104513718,
-0.0590716861,
0.0347898379,
0.1036627516,
0.0098673878,
-0.0280019529,
-0.0163039546,
0.0185762849,
-0.0383717082,
-0.0309340563,
-0.0310718101,
-0.1058241203,
-0.0191423092,
0.0284049436,
-0.0265478883,
0.0197852347,
-0.0491888821,
0.0384406112,
-0.080133535,
-0.0333679207,
-0.0410940871,
-0.0540897325,
-0.0293621197,
-0.0548950844,
-0.0079016294,
-0.0075790351,
-0.016245449,
-0.0709465221,
-0.0213721339,
0.0059511703,
0.042688027,
-0.0062881596,
-0.0760963336,
0.0142681478,
-0.0558286458,
0.0031847702,
0.0411513373,
0.0360140912,
-0.0208561551,
0.0019049736,
-0.0167171787,
-0.0473890863,
-0.0257964395,
-0.0193384252,
0.0230979361,
-0.0461078584,
-0.0204400457,
-0.0294081885,
-0.0314805284,
-0.0566451512,
0.0136262318,
-0.0122815445,
0.0151089132,
-0.0087842885,
0.0138834501,
0.0073255259,
-0.03585127,
0.0073094815,
0.0414480679,
-0.0454488173,
-0.0437800474,
-0.0576745272,
0.014275237,
-0.0079441536,
-0.0339486785,
-0.061448101,
-0.0137243373,
0.0060757529,
-0.0033321297,
-0.0422801375,
-0.0680883303,
0.0296178199,
0.0179611314,
0.0204612091,
0.0088608824,
0.0532110296,
0.0301507358,
-0.0445787832,
-0.0053916043,
0.0009062051,
0.0063219722,
-0.0677601174,
-0.0058108717,
-0.0001467844,
-0.0428821966,
0.0014134002,
-0.0133243948,
-0.0553490408,
-0.0237035528,
0.0034571176,
-0.0173390023,
0.0053344574,
0.0029583706,
-0.0058039241,
-0.0390413031,
0.0425772853,
-0.0080132559,
-0.0108817369,
-0.0198595654,
0.0363800973,
0.0112108691,
-0.0383121967,
0.0280760154,
0.0139836874,
0.0269903932,
0.0134830419,
-0.0064038993,
0.0019621931,
-0.0526469909,
-0.0069592856,
-0.0312079042,
0.0342675708,
0.0010447662,
-0.0632154942,
-0.0671117753,
0.0372974351,
0.01507279,
0.0404950529,
0.0049176295,
-0.0004666402,
-0.0038879607,
0.039796941,
-0.0095519172,
0.0525471643,
0.0281124637,
-0.0059029958,
-0.0176939592,
0.0442121476,
0.0004694827,
0.0627385974,
-0.0165007059,
-0.0074873236,
0.0422268584,
0.0187847521,
0.006116712,
0.0410550646,
-0.038399525,
-0.0340835936,
-0.0319088846,
0.0126273781,
-0.003398322,
0.069326058,
0.0054702261,
0.0018820969,
-0.0499857031,
0.0795635805,
0.0527761951,
-0.030819213,
0.0401500128,
0.0225106142,
0.0139339762,
0.0040755579,
-0.0026318918,
-0.017197324,
-0.004130227,
-0.0188513063,
0.0019066497,
-0.015466013,
0.007222306,
0.0327737667,
0.0448730253,
-0.0061420221,
0.0384441465,
-0.0136773698,
-0.021573633,
0.0062019695,
0.0349300206,
0.0001103661,
-0.0472774692,
0.0189340673,
-0.036113441,
-0.0601326302,
0.0547774546,
-0.0305923205,
-0.0064446125,
0.0208523907,
0.0171585195,
0.0489665829,
0.0245837867,
-0.0335195735,
-0.0464595072,
0.0110190716,
-0.0016067162,
-0.0327867381,
-0.0008484687,
-5.784350928e-33,
0.0086266911,
-0.0253743529,
0.0148011846,
0.014628537,
0.0169780497,
0.0240875557,
-0.022656329,
0.0067778062,
-0.0173598342,
-0.0304995216,
-0.0351267494,
-0.009455421,
0.0608518347,
0.0103369458,
-0.0261450429,
-0.0514143631,
0.0411012843,
0.0147559252,
-0.007358673,
0.0318084061,
0.0353156365,
0.0968997627,
0.1177175343,
-0.0828945562,
0.0510363057,
-0.0026760984,
0.0087098517,
-0.0013094239,
0.0681790486,
0.0855564475,
-0.0705456436,
0.0024047119,
0.0223483089,
-0.0726944283,
0.030574955,
0.0127618434,
-0.1401547045,
0.0037076131,
-0.0515004843,
0.0674327016,
-0.0293367095,
-0.0244988464,
-0.0123587009,
0.0201234184,
-0.0189335421,
0.0736353695,
0.0408507362,
0.006724929,
0.0063196425,
-0.0369941592,
-0.1124976948,
0.0611262247,
0.0163467377,
0.0438384153,
0.0689560696,
0.018904265,
0.0225555487,
-0.0048902887,
-0.1042717472,
-0.0188987348,
0.0358636118,
-0.006344886,
0.0372280404,
0.0312650427,
-0.0553951226,
0.0210440382,
0.0300287381,
-0.0157916136,
0.0133652929,
0.0326971151,
0.0249095522,
-0.0184956137,
-0.0286624227,
0.0408330895,
0.0388071761,
-0.0280605089,
-0.1006617844,
0.0341149792,
-0.0285576694,
0.0337806679,
-0.0078911614,
-0.049366273,
-0.0913669616,
0.0241086185,
0.0232815705,
-0.0289335065,
-0.0124101331,
-0.0013376848,
0.0311729945,
0.0255677551,
-0.077430658,
0.0791864544,
-0.0020183651,
0.0056826132,
-0.0141472314,
0.029379325,
0.0324380919,
0.0224613138,
-0.005539069,
0.0093922578,
-0.06803298,
-0.0728507265,
-0.0214492381,
-0.0173561294,
0.0192685109,
-0.0208331514,
0.0358811244,
0.0243386775,
-0.0653545409,
0.0135102542,
0.000437333,
0.0427093729,
0.0183149129,
0.1053256616,
-0.0043686274,
-0.0324001275,
0.0012206014,
0.0237937067,
0.0685964376,
-0.0138810743,
-0.0374642871,
0.0054426836,
0.0146179777,
-0.0050595035,
-0.0051221759,
0.017267108,
-0.0275635682,
0.0113894548,
-0.0112866154,
-0.0895005018,
0.009825971,
-0.02296119,
2.559e-7,
0.0103458799,
-0.0134402877,
0.0461960658,
-0.0205152929,
-0.0142497411,
0.0101448996,
0.0728354007,
0.0572407953,
-0.0229470842,
0.0323076993,
0.0076434808,
0.0074616927,
-0.0153184151,
-0.0093025221,
-0.1075556651,
-0.0290209725,
0.0249418635,
0.0193107333,
-0.0520146824,
0.0256414544,
0.0111735966,
0.1155989468,
-0.0433659963,
-0.0235354137,
-0.0529474914,
-0.0378205031,
0.0326569602,
0.0343324319,
0.0232714023,
0.0442408286,
0.0460426323,
0.0193362478,
-0.0287194457,
-0.0083185155,
-0.0056917467,
0.0499975793,
0.0393298008,
0.0782799944,
0.0015516464,
0.0127485218,
-0.0046166275,
-0.0379011035,
0.024059616,
-0.0055976682,
0.110508047,
0.0031701664,
-0.0063762972,
0.0311128292,
0.005047312,
0.0094148777,
0.0272236895,
-0.004921311,
-0.0000822568,
0.042030409,
0.0645391941,
-0.0331982188,
0.0004275575,
-0.0354039595,
0.0412150547,
-0.0186887607,
0.0436039865,
0.0296338703,
-0.0042875581,
-0.0444090217,
0.0213061571,
0.0136286505,
0.0178214461,
2.190246048e-34,
-0.0170362256,
0.0339712761,
-0.0286349226,
0.0326613002,
-0.0023798291,
-0.0067172027,
-0.0190129224,
-0.0009468652,
-0.0099302437,
-0.0124735087,
-0.0010128547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03508v1 | Cluster-Level Contrastive Learning for Emotion Recognition in Conversations | 2023-02-07T14:49:20 | 2023-02-07T14:49:20 | Kailai Yang, Tianlin Zhang, Hassan Alhuzali, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A key challenge for Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC) is to
distinguish semantically similar emotions. Some works utilise Supervised
Contrastive Learning (SCL) which uses categorical emotion labels as supervision
signals and contrasts in high-dimensional semantic space. However, categorical
labels fail to provide quantitative information between emotions. ERC is also
not equally dependent on all embedded features in the semantic space, which
makes the high-dimensional SCL inefficient. To address these issues, we propose
a novel low-dimensional Supervised Cluster-level Contrastive Learning (SCCL)
method, which first reduces the high-dimensional SCL space to a
three-dimensional affect representation space Valence-Arousal-Dominance (VAD),
then performs cluster-level contrastive learning to incorporate measurable
emotion prototypes. To help modelling the dialogue and enriching the context,
we leverage the pre-trained knowledge adapters to infuse linguistic and factual
knowledge. Experiments show that our method achieves new state-of-the-art
results with 69.81% on IEMOCAP, 65.7% on MELD, and 62.51% on DailyDialog
datasets. The analysis also proves that the VAD space is not only suitable for
ERC but also interpretable, with VAD prototypes enhancing its performance and
stabilising the training of SCCL. In addition, the pre-trained knowledge
adapters benefit the performance of the utterance encoder and SCCL. Our code is
available at: https://github.com/SteveKGYang/SCCL | [
0.0097986916,
0.061510589,
-0.0109444093,
0.0341019928,
0.0151712289,
0.0394077823,
0.0303710122,
-0.0346411169,
0.0459170304,
-0.0185239464,
-0.0472716428,
-0.0332981646,
-0.0285621863,
0.045845896,
-0.0206216015,
-0.1125228852,
0.0062883492,
0.042150978,
0.0414496735,
-0.0150251137,
0.0345595218,
0.0105158528,
-0.0352325104,
-0.0119623076,
-0.0543470457,
-0.0015702279,
-0.021652909,
-0.0090891225,
0.0389401764,
-0.0374793075,
0.0382352546,
0.0601004809,
0.0331282578,
-0.0236796048,
0.0000022512,
-0.0380112194,
0.000126432,
-0.0300671309,
-0.0010054384,
-0.0263996702,
0.1002766788,
-0.0414868854,
-0.0128935724,
-0.0116575742,
-0.0084371576,
-0.0463687629,
0.074699156,
0.1079276577,
0.0587452948,
0.0606923625,
-0.0502792336,
-0.0393255465,
0.0066792974,
0.0156416874,
-0.0025669087,
0.0021264956,
0.0212449078,
0.0351242721,
-0.0226381849,
-0.0124823321,
-0.039696157,
0.0056409226,
0.0100274188,
0.0101027992,
0.0265876651,
0.019525921,
0.0036459458,
-0.0054584602,
-0.0189431254,
0.0762815252,
0.0217115544,
0.0353224277,
-0.0155122848,
-0.0069942852,
0.0040454632,
-0.0538151003,
0.0032639483,
-0.0183847137,
-0.00104937,
0.0259347595,
0.0016902013,
0.0860407725,
-0.0384391993,
-0.002257677,
-0.0148970122,
-0.0327990353,
-0.0183468331,
-0.016636651,
0.0246686973,
0.0166028216,
0.0099881431,
0.0401790179,
-0.0137915472,
-0.0463011898,
0.0102395667,
-0.0016844309,
-0.0274406709,
-0.0409128554,
-0.0402324162,
-0.0468358174,
-0.022585988,
0.0429821014,
-0.0544616915,
0.0354587846,
0.0152241159,
0.0371149145,
0.0022862814,
-0.0468288437,
-0.0395609513,
-0.033309903,
-0.0297576059,
0.0340632573,
-0.0117543256,
0.0308556464,
-0.0700603649,
-0.0420119911,
-0.0589293279,
0.0278092287,
-0.0352647789,
0.0044286707,
-0.0306147411,
0.0202364065,
0.0241628233,
0.0091053136,
0.009496972,
0.0407610126,
-0.0180206709,
0.0378150903,
-0.0313657522,
-0.0715770647,
0.0014961535,
0.0401327647,
0.0387828052,
-0.0239274055,
0.0112294992,
0.0426939055,
-0.0260355435,
-0.0310223643,
-0.0319796205,
0.0007482883,
-0.0443633422,
-0.0125590758,
-0.0005247009,
-0.037483573,
0.0571900159,
-0.0147699891,
0.0086958623,
-0.0501943305,
0.0020913663,
-0.0643533543,
-0.0283453185,
0.0948781893,
-0.0009067851,
-0.0440366641,
-0.0044827992,
0.0063368548,
-0.035342589,
0.032288406,
0.0117894439,
0.0238701794,
0.0129225431,
-0.0336168334,
0.0235456824,
-0.0124346856,
0.007283906,
-0.0253190435,
-0.0084656654,
-0.0151057858,
-0.0121238297,
0.024084866,
0.0489141829,
0.0361020416,
-0.0493298359,
-0.0339172967,
0.0394158624,
0.0361076482,
-0.027476877,
0.0677176416,
-0.0535323359,
0.0464869328,
-0.0016935559,
-0.0132061979,
-0.0193764623,
0.0393495969,
-0.0548807792,
-0.0298496913,
0.0450469367,
0.0081416834,
-0.0639020726,
-0.0321591981,
0.0083239339,
0.000659777,
0.0172186047,
-0.0203787368,
0.0524750911,
-0.01076316,
-0.0276479963,
0.011858047,
0.033708144,
-0.0603250042,
-0.0290455427,
-0.0217156447,
0.0062926863,
0.055141665,
-0.0310603064,
-0.0380157977,
-0.0243238043,
-0.015198471,
-0.021651784,
0.0403360054,
-0.0032463404,
-0.0108331954,
0.0590944812,
-0.061497502,
0.0091478247,
-0.0217046794,
-0.0104148174,
0.0152476439,
-0.011223047,
0.0277763288,
-0.021131251,
-0.0043030353,
0.0336930715,
-0.0186447781,
0.0220670532,
-0.0264626388,
0.0278957468,
0.0200395808,
0.0552649982,
0.0048967153,
-0.019199064,
-0.0590806045,
0.0054022335,
-0.0176296718,
-0.0075479285,
0.047183644,
-0.0581994392,
-0.1120138988,
0.0203057006,
-0.0174463615,
-0.0014998879,
0.0078595355,
-0.0564393848,
-0.0407642759,
0.0590370707,
-0.0169627927,
0.0707437322,
-0.0260237288,
-0.0032071152,
-0.0072230548,
0.0723635405,
0.0317218117,
0.0518315472,
-0.0205041431,
-0.0425885469,
-0.0006808126,
0.0231072512,
-0.0081260009,
-0.0117985001,
-0.0385962911,
-0.00941943,
0.0201650485,
0.02666419,
-0.0122198928,
-0.0036135218,
-0.0711632222,
-0.0491146296,
-0.0957763195,
-0.0244090129,
-0.0075660348,
-0.0092470469,
0.0038953305,
0.0089519536,
-0.0234013014,
-0.0041649565,
-0.0383749828,
0.0024554846,
0.0242177527,
-0.0046786638,
0.0065127471,
-0.0111940103,
0.0286913682,
-0.0292276964,
0.035501074,
0.0195354726,
0.0306566022,
-0.039472241,
-0.0101076895,
0.0161931776,
0.020088695,
0.0100549925,
0.0319498293,
-0.0153617617,
-0.0369816385,
-0.0213652793,
0.005945229,
0.0104758609,
0.0378480889,
0.0192023516,
0.1180766821,
-0.0295163561,
-0.0455500595,
-0.0469438769,
0.0510535873,
-0.0189549606,
0.0610578582,
-0.0332442373,
-0.0005139539,
-0.0466624498,
0.0540504716,
0.0262733158,
0.037499696,
-0.0465894416,
0.0011346296,
0.0522031412,
-0.0519850589,
0.0009364809,
-0.0056843464,
-0.0045794509,
-0.0229041986,
-0.0121209128,
-0.0266798828,
0.0501087159,
0.0118029173,
-0.0608395562,
-0.0770258158,
-0.0225489177,
-0.0008860755,
0.0466494858,
-0.0682105049,
-0.0005025071,
-0.0127778621,
-0.0124451276,
-0.0022340433,
-0.0588853694,
-0.0521060862,
-0.0224798117,
0.0230480414,
-0.0074078464,
-0.0233877171,
0.0512836352,
-0.0566551872,
-0.04824939,
-0.0130838668,
-0.0490004122,
0.0297782682,
0.0068649976,
-0.0305315871,
-0.0301331729,
-0.0064315968,
0.0301699024,
-0.0274588279,
0.0269269962,
-0.0243797358,
0.0121880043,
0.0797671676,
0.0253601205,
0.0165321715,
0.0235063173,
-0.0115830265,
0.0572954863,
0.0873242691,
0.0154874576,
-0.036067497,
-0.0239910018,
0.0566039756,
0.0129850889,
0.0274971705,
0.0132259764,
-0.0448716506,
0.0087608295,
-0.0174371079,
0.0269181486,
0.1239937171,
0.0105040325,
-0.0483612753,
0.0017773664,
-0.0205317996,
-0.002833138,
-0.0143437423,
0.010118735,
-0.0072553814,
-0.0456640236,
-0.0294773374,
0.0248603784,
0.0064555984,
-0.0310011134,
0.0142538045,
-0.0623294711,
0.0240852255,
0.0083870636,
-0.075379096,
-0.059887331,
-0.03081364,
0.0351061374,
-0.0404526666,
-0.019866284,
-0.0425474569,
0.0298713408,
-0.0312299188,
0.0188435856,
-0.0098218853,
-0.0406191833,
0.0492609702,
-0.0005240404,
0.0520039313,
0.0031265712,
0.0662382469,
-0.0006077457,
-0.0155527415,
-0.0192334335,
-0.0562378652,
-0.0326991975,
-0.0411085673,
0.0384286232,
-0.028776506,
-0.0177177954,
-0.0171000045,
0.0448496565,
-0.0349150896,
-0.0162096974,
-0.0188544691,
0.0505172051,
-0.0383060947,
-0.023541905,
-0.021568764,
0.0337396301,
0.048787497,
0.0557071082,
0.0125213582,
-0.0171020888,
0.0065945196,
-0.0072542015,
0.0289008711,
0.0133162048,
0.0095099406,
-0.0370691717,
0.0399940349,
0.0232129637,
-0.0345276631,
-0.0699349865,
0.000414074,
0.0378438011,
-0.061087925,
-0.059397053,
-0.0112926448,
-0.021692019,
-0.0615373626,
0.0376673751,
-0.0015866151,
-0.0167633183,
0.001963129,
-0.0317168981,
0.039878048,
-0.0416034237,
-0.0215572864,
-0.0179709252,
0.0136344712,
-0.0432238765,
-0.0088353492,
0.0375717394,
-0.0012448985,
0.0526666492,
0.0409246273,
-0.0154702934,
0.0719989464,
0.0056380252,
-0.0116599826,
0.0138254967,
0.065261513,
0.0179715976,
0.0009290458,
0.005742657,
-0.0050754067,
0.066959247,
0.0238189902,
-0.0088996412,
-0.0420447364,
-0.0830871686,
-0.0518228114,
-0.0274332874,
0.0646016449,
0.0519727841,
-0.0163011383,
-0.0340523906,
-0.0078617297,
-0.0041243457,
-0.0002113957,
-0.0580572486,
-0.0333575457,
-0.0207694322,
0.0385892205,
-0.0564127453,
0.0016669583,
0.0033097765,
-0.0282661952,
0.0420087762,
0.0323647037,
0.0629179627,
-0.0052166907,
-0.0119757978,
0.0322119705,
-0.0108332094,
0.0114606507,
0.0113818394,
0.0144430827,
-0.0011424867,
0.0455507822,
0.028661089,
-0.0461392626,
0.0006966803,
0.0487884432,
-0.0046458584,
0.015281369,
-0.0539528988,
-0.0212300662,
-0.0031805446,
-0.0494645089,
0.0188540723,
-0.0570224561,
0.0262339301,
-0.0179109946,
0.016845895,
-0.0394502431,
-0.0419790111,
0.0309256986,
0.0097222626,
-0.0134581234,
0.0161236171,
0.0084077576,
-0.0944038555,
0.0615142323,
-0.0038966101,
0.0162944943,
-0.0442905091,
0.0095087308,
0.0874897093,
0.0001030985,
0.028069159,
0.0471338034,
-0.0456727035,
-0.0272433981,
0.0769476295,
-0.0499244109,
-0.0157687962,
0.0078192679,
0.0563977323,
0.03499512,
-0.0098326867,
0.0306763854,
-0.0206267741,
-0.0180578418,
-0.0434642844,
-0.0260751657,
-0.0048974701,
-6.215380095e-33,
0.0035670775,
-0.012080837,
-0.018230496,
-0.0249864794,
-0.0194206294,
0.053218741,
-0.0246928558,
-0.0104784882,
-0.0103007713,
0.0477417856,
0.0084386533,
0.0354174413,
0.0022655656,
0.0391704738,
-0.0134158861,
-0.0001123153,
0.035977345,
0.0111738872,
0.0236921385,
0.0479441695,
0.0332076922,
0.0358019471,
0.0515256301,
-0.1032186672,
-0.0190799888,
0.0376057513,
0.010189442,
0.0230579171,
0.0798562244,
0.0274837743,
-0.0396784805,
0.0699498355,
0.0015946629,
-0.0250818375,
-0.0144338124,
0.0098401476,
-0.0495156087,
-0.0155148022,
-0.0163863581,
0.0023410679,
-0.0251851883,
-0.0194783453,
0.0058038831,
0.032827422,
-0.0028150843,
-0.0460422598,
0.0100678317,
-0.0127484482,
0.0265255775,
-0.0332221687,
-0.0227961894,
0.0330548622,
-0.0315189734,
-0.0051152962,
0.0472917221,
0.042422425,
0.0322390795,
0.0129031222,
-0.0698205456,
0.019457655,
-0.0459575281,
-0.0350508839,
0.0044664629,
0.01739504,
0.0244755838,
0.0799953043,
0.03924435,
-0.0214964319,
0.0050075208,
0.0464271046,
0.0060669254,
0.0407833643,
0.0022255995,
0.0508849584,
-0.0327089727,
-0.002583896,
-0.0097254952,
0.0319522209,
0.0047666533,
0.0108062401,
0.0206935331,
0.0133764958,
-0.0526705533,
-0.0149908056,
0.0000693229,
-0.0221074782,
-0.0151817789,
-0.0272925645,
0.0223070662,
-0.0335731246,
0.0083034001,
-0.0035202545,
0.0171448812,
-0.022522347,
0.0273325834,
0.0511139594,
-0.0066812695,
0.0510649458,
0.0149406269,
0.0082280412,
-0.0244248472,
-0.0531240888,
0.066558823,
0.0205011331,
0.0221366119,
0.0147583941,
-0.0174086522,
0.0171609074,
-0.0303040911,
-0.0006674613,
0.0018348352,
0.0291714948,
-0.0281773377,
0.0280414261,
-0.0469099991,
0.0338088945,
0.0022271969,
0.0449675396,
-0.0147963632,
0.0559628196,
-0.0015347577,
-0.0549313091,
0.000302619,
0.0621388145,
-0.0388898812,
-0.0003578596,
-0.0138150286,
-0.0558193661,
-0.0159959327,
0.0020915472,
0.0146882609,
-0.0096604461,
3.007e-7,
-0.010769817,
0.0193403214,
0.032486286,
-0.0720909834,
0.0396294966,
0.0834218264,
0.0199859794,
0.0384782813,
0.0329131559,
-0.0115924003,
0.071495004,
0.041845765,
0.0637513548,
0.0158679131,
-0.0770164728,
0.0011706097,
-0.0228562672,
-0.0237865504,
-0.0027483995,
0.0456197709,
0.1235552281,
0.0873115137,
0.0468807369,
-0.0054650251,
0.0207155365,
0.0315614343,
0.0267288741,
-0.0100660715,
0.0169461127,
0.0073096347,
-0.0173328314,
-0.0171925388,
0.0010473906,
0.0121629406,
0.0201514121,
0.0290970299,
-0.0241431966,
0.0453792699,
0.0250688456,
-0.0816031396,
0.0207444187,
0.0580961406,
-0.0424239971,
-0.0159364939,
0.0380053334,
-0.0711354464,
-0.03142507,
-0.0256996043,
-0.0414850526,
-0.0098827919,
0.0271089654,
-0.0047047646,
-0.034963131,
0.0228523202,
-0.0012517066,
-0.0174679682,
-0.0431406461,
-0.0793601722,
0.0400921293,
0.0334344991,
-0.0406884067,
-0.0331685804,
-0.0017331403,
0.0310957059,
0.0502167344,
0.0114686871,
0.0144688105,
2.019270395e-34,
0.0042505516,
0.0090224305,
-0.0112957684,
0.0324508622,
0.0064111291,
-0.0174899437,
-0.0352978185,
-0.04945134,
0.0654742792,
-0.0729045868,
0.0113738645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03491v1 | Learning Translation Quality Evaluation on Low Resource Languages from Large Language Models | 2023-02-07T14:35:35 | 2023-02-07T14:35:35 | Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Mauro Verzetti, Paul K. Rubenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Learned metrics such as BLEURT have in recent years become widely employed to
evaluate the quality of machine translation systems. Training such metrics
requires data which can be expensive and difficult to acquire, particularly for
lower-resource languages. We show how knowledge can be distilled from Large
Language Models (LLMs) to improve upon such learned metrics without requiring
human annotators, by creating synthetic datasets which can be mixed into
existing datasets, requiring only a corpus of text in the target language. We
show that the performance of a BLEURT-like model on lower resource languages
can be improved in this way. | [
0.0176387895,
0.0724700615,
0.0020522377,
0.0568809062,
-0.0347405784,
0.0152799767,
0.0235721953,
0.013072663,
-0.0282695852,
-0.019917991,
-0.0348964036,
-0.0628292635,
0.0315586515,
-0.0330166258,
0.0289953407,
-0.0313966908,
0.0117437299,
0.0116541004,
-0.0226478521,
0.0106336446,
-0.0007953843,
0.0127144773,
0.0288828537,
0.0331934132,
-0.0118576707,
0.0054755691,
0.0386762097,
0.0436782725,
0.0359135754,
-0.0228965655,
-0.0358544514,
0.0234637838,
-0.0209041797,
0.0637589768,
0.0000017529,
-0.045187261,
-0.0333863758,
0.0325272903,
-0.0022190283,
0.0349025838,
0.0794303492,
-0.0577049665,
-0.0239272993,
0.0395270325,
-0.021026304,
-0.0150096584,
0.0519990809,
-0.023473477,
0.06358435,
0.0619690791,
-0.0094249845,
-0.02084939,
-0.0161715765,
-0.0196173657,
-0.017229788,
-0.0347591415,
-0.0264270101,
0.0440145768,
-0.0306200814,
0.0104613267,
-0.00327004,
0.0364392549,
0.0108012976,
-0.0265246537,
0.0205285996,
-0.0194015186,
-0.031511981,
-0.0343718715,
0.0162891243,
0.0439593308,
-0.0516456105,
-0.0310381204,
-0.0334838741,
-0.0000450055,
-0.0124802198,
-0.0256436486,
-0.0152562829,
0.0006160437,
-0.01437042,
-0.0042320248,
0.0188557319,
0.0346966647,
0.0397107042,
-0.0181727447,
-0.0375651866,
-0.0076750186,
0.0245860666,
-0.0231804792,
-0.0348561555,
0.0276389308,
-0.0301764477,
0.0068188589,
-0.0021101395,
-0.0101327943,
-0.0025876048,
0.0141645456,
-0.0098538324,
-0.0388528965,
0.0218315329,
-0.0235960651,
0.0373581499,
0.0292777047,
-0.0300839115,
0.0423807763,
-0.0168288369,
0.050970614,
0.000270783,
0.0145349018,
-0.0744961277,
-0.021560546,
-0.0097698718,
0.0693025291,
-0.000249244,
-0.0238690078,
-0.0288670026,
0.0112433936,
-0.0348734558,
0.005278335,
0.0072530173,
0.0251093078,
0.0420370325,
-0.051231727,
-0.0461254343,
-0.0211953521,
-0.020422589,
0.0206282921,
0.0310040247,
-0.0147020277,
0.0012070925,
-0.053931389,
0.0013321753,
-0.0016562517,
-0.0050572711,
-0.0307295378,
0.011482981,
0.0867021754,
0.0112471022,
-0.0311985109,
-0.0410330631,
0.0046924357,
-0.0218486134,
-0.070061326,
-0.0362573452,
-0.0825672373,
0.0418529101,
0.0043460014,
0.0242107678,
-0.042359259,
0.0081154071,
-0.0071713012,
-0.0035363368,
0.0695235506,
-0.0043058898,
0.0267142411,
-0.002395456,
-0.0275472812,
-0.0124668786,
0.0612496249,
0.0454063714,
0.0084666898,
0.0458127335,
0.0075271786,
0.0018071145,
0.0732418448,
0.0080044186,
0.0698939711,
-0.0077273622,
-0.0038726877,
0.0205536503,
0.0208121892,
0.0375810452,
0.0620257407,
-0.0222103707,
0.0221669488,
0.0854789689,
0.0088494504,
0.0358853303,
0.0337560736,
0.0461422056,
-0.001054681,
-0.0044859601,
-0.0016035857,
0.0157475322,
0.0122577976,
0.0194829479,
-0.0006595834,
0.0884050503,
0.0601651855,
0.0066461214,
-0.0815072209,
-0.033134792,
-0.0350191258,
-0.0189989209,
-0.0104328934,
0.0606240742,
0.016303964,
-0.030627856,
0.0166894272,
0.023082396,
-0.0742619112,
0.0307687279,
-0.0054927794,
0.0065320157,
0.05317837,
0.0873465538,
-0.012291762,
0.0204795618,
-0.0260862689,
-0.016818421,
0.0601267628,
0.0334470682,
-0.0212279465,
0.0235249586,
-0.0332366824,
-0.0116013112,
0.0422965847,
0.0319748893,
0.0164839011,
-0.0025388519,
0.0092089847,
0.0476505794,
-0.0693067461,
-0.1227834672,
0.0239707399,
-0.0173797403,
-0.0201094598,
0.0246231724,
0.0193758011,
0.0505329259,
0.0293257628,
-0.0318971723,
0.005976954,
0.021698961,
-0.0641794875,
0.0046789083,
0.0004453354,
0.0120088682,
-0.0316461138,
0.0418423787,
-0.0390622839,
0.0132195521,
0.0175155886,
-0.0391868502,
-0.0453096889,
-0.0246515311,
-0.056150414,
0.0249896739,
-0.0322298594,
0.0477082618,
-0.0221192986,
-0.0271310844,
-0.0473146103,
0.0161697157,
-0.0226809289,
0.0333788209,
0.0010154911,
-0.0311976969,
0.0421460047,
-0.0168123767,
-0.0275569521,
0.0273240265,
0.0150131788,
0.0768376887,
0.0672235265,
0.0369829796,
-0.0108700152,
-0.0259399805,
-0.0570684448,
0.0229867417,
-0.0187330674,
0.0215977486,
0.0397138111,
0.0233906005,
0.0352336429,
0.0237158947,
-0.0363327265,
-0.0384314023,
0.0186414607,
0.0083435131,
0.0162823964,
0.0040380089,
-0.022849964,
-0.0329300165,
-0.0081307357,
0.0385597497,
0.0378587916,
0.0180832967,
0.0185543112,
-0.0594473667,
0.0415315889,
-0.0367604308,
-0.0072817598,
0.0284889154,
-0.082859844,
0.0057930578,
-0.0131196827,
0.0142030288,
0.0345196426,
-0.0165701825,
-0.0030521483,
0.0439559892,
0.0340301171,
-0.0502699539,
-0.0219126008,
-0.0491275601,
-0.0425269492,
-0.017666908,
-0.0686095357,
-0.0018464301,
0.0064538997,
-0.0138676781,
-0.0244468302,
-0.0539597049,
0.0250461176,
-0.0460733399,
0.0012791504,
-0.011951372,
0.0311536454,
0.0166188646,
0.0778900012,
-0.0350428037,
-0.0587189682,
0.0349034555,
-0.0527923442,
0.0132460287,
-0.0460894629,
0.0141455391,
-0.052812364,
0.0248076189,
-0.0082370108,
0.0344841816,
-0.0573680326,
0.0282393657,
-0.0279198512,
0.0437699743,
0.035715837,
-0.0466479734,
0.0331898592,
-0.0707141161,
0.0173334647,
-0.007594802,
-0.0167717766,
-0.0290095415,
0.0225247145,
-0.0108973281,
-0.0379352383,
0.0196589138,
-0.0211605411,
-0.0175250079,
0.0195468515,
0.0124562774,
0.0440376662,
0.0098780291,
-0.0112576382,
0.016091682,
0.0269091837,
-0.0402739719,
-0.0101778628,
0.0407277234,
-0.0447516628,
0.0102178417,
0.0035393676,
0.0066975104,
-0.0142173423,
-0.0366108306,
-0.0464585871,
0.043320857,
0.0367418453,
-0.0023731829,
-0.0067761638,
0.0353922248,
-0.0415413007,
-0.0495688431,
0.1000479683,
0.0224163849,
-0.0157706868,
-0.0004264943,
-0.0230127182,
0.0447877236,
0.0257510766,
-0.0030020156,
-0.061534334,
-0.0124923456,
-0.0069822986,
0.0496924929,
0.0061413161,
0.0219436176,
-0.020348005,
-0.1471498907,
0.0145545043,
0.0500605479,
-0.0283168089,
-0.046811264,
-0.0382816456,
-0.0293725561,
-0.0798115805,
0.0261190627,
-0.0058641993,
0.0338675603,
0.0031831467,
0.0118711619,
-0.0259484816,
-0.0913408846,
-0.0063417205,
-0.0378926545,
0.0398631841,
0.0523337685,
0.0476508886,
-0.0161793083,
-0.02987184,
0.0205627847,
-0.0225098319,
-0.0443797745,
0.0135929286,
0.0414527953,
0.0116412798,
-0.0335897729,
0.0446538851,
0.0027542757,
-0.0144693274,
0.031027304,
0.0200633351,
0.0268044546,
-0.0001963032,
0.028551165,
0.0141677177,
-0.0372628719,
0.0020068148,
0.0482722819,
0.0316137001,
-0.0556922108,
0.0149699077,
-0.0085952934,
-0.0414680652,
-0.0548050888,
-0.0273131169,
0.0192874819,
-0.0676610097,
-0.0464839302,
-0.1235173717,
-0.056449417,
-0.005928318,
0.0474017672,
0.0257181339,
0.0165642034,
0.0145255672,
-0.0117797013,
0.0018971136,
0.0403719321,
-0.0410875678,
0.0173170008,
-0.058693286,
0.0086327726,
0.0101694427,
-0.0184522774,
-0.0070358813,
0.0271215085,
-0.0611838289,
-0.0604665913,
-0.0295627527,
0.064735055,
0.0300259273,
0.0499932729,
-0.0486878604,
-0.017420873,
0.0084107481,
0.0192854423,
-0.0395561717,
-0.0151103167,
0.0405722335,
-0.0204883739,
-0.0078167981,
0.0512020923,
-0.0296943802,
0.0052464325,
0.0016398401,
0.0298378225,
-0.0331054442,
-0.0376240686,
0.0499274619,
0.0468326658,
0.0293535423,
-0.0539381206,
-0.0323242173,
-0.0245948974,
-0.0073484094,
-0.0201417264,
-0.0256118681,
-0.0593899973,
-0.001618339,
0.0542623885,
0.0010318841,
-0.0258375853,
0.0004328886,
-0.0326212682,
0.0014441856,
0.0214600042,
0.0017297154,
-0.0032285824,
0.0144566866,
0.0134107405,
0.004154434,
-0.0265233256,
0.0107911574,
-0.0149894971,
0.0172268581,
-0.0040276153,
0.0071437317,
0.0157435779,
0.0257985704,
0.0371898077,
0.0615490563,
-0.0029889338,
-0.0204910859,
-0.040693786,
0.0127338236,
0.0930706933,
-0.0124546345,
0.1311096996,
-0.0088202301,
-0.0235105772,
-0.055098068,
0.0647787228,
0.0085486891,
-0.0115973419,
-0.0279777311,
-0.0029627518,
-0.0092043597,
0.0313909501,
0.0661055744,
-0.0075957146,
0.0089891227,
-0.0308337267,
-0.0066795978,
-0.0282867905,
-0.0053029256,
-0.0103321122,
-0.0332316048,
-0.0180562064,
-0.0175048038,
-0.0669011474,
-0.0684072375,
0.0083868755,
0.0531411618,
0.0050358674,
-0.0086744102,
-0.0079476647,
0.079204686,
-0.0438043475,
0.0530383326,
-0.0636603683,
-0.0356486477,
-0.0266904794,
-0.0174237881,
-0.0012138295,
-5.499200978e-33,
0.0043375408,
-0.0197538994,
-0.0056064767,
-0.0511215553,
-0.0049924334,
-0.0031945466,
0.000577137,
-0.0240142923,
0.0008270904,
0.0043047117,
0.005023289,
-0.0192959886,
0.0148704657,
-0.0028558336,
0.0058332384,
0.0289068744,
0.0532360449,
0.0416014269,
-0.0530291647,
-0.0023508479,
0.0256399009,
-0.015268309,
0.0479323007,
-0.0579171143,
0.0423112884,
-0.0153052956,
-0.0353744179,
0.0253060795,
0.0424285345,
0.0424390361,
-0.0076813358,
0.0341031551,
0.0185588598,
-0.0378141068,
-0.0155056482,
-0.0378188603,
-0.0532177128,
0.0304453243,
0.0141130993,
0.0325667672,
-0.0250138566,
-0.0361256413,
0.0351330526,
-0.0256414525,
-0.033031188,
0.0047535249,
0.0195503905,
-0.0743634328,
-0.057715904,
-0.0026425854,
-0.051375322,
0.0473445989,
-0.0038432721,
-0.0403169245,
0.0300558265,
0.02732566,
-0.0269107372,
-0.0052119116,
-0.0419296324,
0.0048433766,
-0.0159980357,
0.0602327287,
0.0702745691,
-0.0104185091,
-0.0276003331,
0.0241043847,
0.0030331933,
-0.0020895679,
0.0549119972,
-0.0074613774,
0.023333909,
0.0056270347,
0.0677738413,
0.0804925337,
0.0241225548,
-0.0353774242,
-0.0721201673,
0.0700590983,
-0.0250781104,
0.010059583,
0.0099529196,
-0.0016467067,
-0.0125916088,
0.0158544518,
-0.0646776929,
-0.0376865789,
-0.0237076171,
-0.0007609185,
0.0059907651,
0.0078879427,
-0.0403247327,
-0.0515152775,
0.0682960674,
-0.0171166789,
-0.0099420501,
-0.0149585614,
-0.0193634965,
0.0123298131,
-0.0256963205,
0.0289004892,
-0.0190433897,
0.0024703345,
-0.0135081075,
0.0359573737,
0.0161337294,
-0.021053534,
0.0867749602,
0.0162551478,
-0.0481072925,
0.0289120339,
-0.0652039647,
0.0103668422,
-0.0331911705,
0.0251533072,
0.0216367859,
-0.0274753347,
-0.0161291994,
0.0532905869,
0.0247737039,
0.0121741826,
-0.0114942081,
0.0138110975,
0.0219510496,
0.0202115998,
-0.0630326197,
0.0014445119,
-0.0094446214,
0.0134554766,
0.0402731113,
-0.0125800222,
-0.0282664336,
-0.0132814748,
2.418e-7,
0.0554063842,
0.0402925462,
-0.0072775744,
0.0228254925,
-0.0228024106,
0.0216411576,
-0.0554484278,
0.0268006176,
-0.0201387312,
-0.0137810595,
0.02953621,
-0.0029336629,
0.1018931717,
0.0195328295,
-0.0740166232,
-0.0297801439,
-0.0366408564,
0.0124681443,
-0.038330432,
-0.0304901227,
0.0402170382,
0.1086325124,
0.0065296465,
-0.0171695501,
-0.006409599,
-0.0386798196,
0.0802651867,
-0.0164750777,
-0.0542320237,
0.0056272051,
0.095414117,
0.0484342948,
-0.0212307014,
-0.0149398828,
-0.0480178669,
0.0011986976,
0.030786857,
0.0535320789,
-0.00053201,
0.0004486391,
0.0298467241,
-0.0301788859,
-0.0169432499,
-0.0164682996,
0.0436797328,
0.0170368962,
-0.0018649759,
0.0038111785,
-0.0232018568,
0.0141357249,
0.0678984076,
-0.0427020676,
-0.051641535,
0.0214613862,
0.0411202312,
-0.0249639172,
0.0031951226,
-0.0240196083,
-0.0421126522,
0.0054319445,
0.0191716645,
-0.0836860761,
0.0404111855,
0.0222383644,
0.0027838992,
-0.0429367684,
0.0082105994,
2.053270191e-34,
0.0921669751,
-0.0387263373,
0.0339556746,
-0.0081763733,
0.0413057022,
-0.0295312349,
-0.0060342578,
-0.0255971551,
-0.0234137233,
-0.0068361377,
0.0189923309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03490v1 | Natural Language Processing for Policymaking | 2023-02-07T14:34:39 | 2023-02-07T14:34:39 | Zhijing Jin, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Language is the medium for many political activities, from campaigns to news
reports. Natural language processing (NLP) uses computational tools to parse
text into key information that is needed for policymaking. In this chapter, we
introduce common methods of NLP, including text classification, topic modeling,
event extraction, and text scaling. We then overview how these methods can be
used for policymaking through four major applications including data collection
for evidence-based policymaking, interpretation of political decisions, policy
communication, and investigation of policy effects. Finally, we highlight some
potential limitations and ethical concerns when using NLP for policymaking.
This text is from Chapter 7 (pages 141-162) of the Handbook of Computational
Social Science for Policy (2023). Open Access on Springer:
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-16624-2 | [
0.0132480487,
0.0851110667,
-0.0076865121,
0.0314290114,
-0.055667609,
0.0160219185,
0.0055437903,
0.0168848094,
0.0239862166,
-0.0613711625,
0.1046326682,
0.0094662411,
0.0116766561,
0.0962352529,
-0.0089511685,
-0.0803418532,
0.0140799806,
0.0356738344,
0.0694218278,
0.0324599594,
0.0167634655,
0.0211110432,
0.0213451535,
0.0825242996,
-0.0237923078,
0.0434671603,
-0.0143808639,
-0.0469178967,
0.0172268394,
-0.0332289711,
-0.0025237824,
0.0183862336,
0.0028641999,
-0.0304289181,
0.0000018897,
-0.0471619479,
-0.0256115012,
-0.021619821,
0.0572747774,
-0.029904604,
0.0871848986,
-0.0561039262,
-0.0227449015,
0.0098160822,
-0.0403079018,
0.0237695947,
0.0362954065,
0.0279835835,
0.0523861907,
0.0404754169,
-0.0015251026,
-0.0595062114,
-0.0126671828,
-0.0042194515,
-0.0294490885,
-0.0022352927,
0.0531705394,
-0.0370129682,
-0.0351894088,
0.0276694801,
0.0049830526,
0.0214855149,
-0.0191136282,
0.0034424877,
-0.0075899507,
0.0173143167,
0.0028805409,
-0.0240402445,
-0.0108092623,
0.0252653603,
0.0477622524,
-0.0146242203,
0.073419556,
-0.0255420804,
0.001988031,
0.0380093902,
-0.0420777537,
0.0371243618,
-0.0323035903,
0.0397907495,
0.0444984287,
0.0285517611,
-0.0047889594,
0.0363368839,
0.0067828419,
0.0849057585,
-0.0324012078,
-0.0391340069,
-0.0073699933,
-0.0077869399,
0.0340340063,
-0.0543777458,
0.0438455231,
-0.0108918091,
0.0082156826,
0.0561688542,
0.0181442108,
0.0112464353,
0.0545490831,
-0.0842941701,
-0.0080698272,
-0.0125202546,
0.0026928771,
0.0399912596,
0.066300191,
-0.0196544975,
0.0122027732,
0.0019115863,
-0.0043103918,
0.0193721727,
-0.051720541,
-0.0058344393,
-0.0225492436,
0.0152231175,
-0.0526589118,
0.0292328428,
-0.0229716562,
-0.0186317861,
-0.0329564288,
0.0113671934,
-0.0244391542,
0.0413260236,
-0.0314202011,
0.0039972807,
-0.0879986882,
0.0417688526,
-0.0443709008,
0.0392241031,
-0.0484785438,
0.0410091355,
0.0352581032,
0.0088805258,
0.0321498029,
0.0369870774,
0.0029979672,
0.0396846794,
0.024822196,
0.0065970039,
-0.0108295782,
-0.0322737023,
-0.0439057946,
-0.0051269443,
-0.0183856804,
-0.0723890364,
0.0214196779,
-0.0413756818,
-0.001022693,
-0.056618847,
-0.0003678953,
0.0285590906,
-0.0549398512,
0.0334415585,
-0.0240875259,
-0.0112862904,
0.0182569399,
0.0203871205,
0.0477632843,
0.0403146781,
0.0506131575,
0.0367185064,
0.0330667831,
0.003389125,
0.0086505534,
-0.0045290291,
0.0009695282,
0.0170793571,
-0.0176890157,
0.0214597993,
-0.0403752439,
-0.0252477564,
-0.0057370854,
0.017867744,
0.0060918531,
-0.0107207503,
0.0195159391,
0.1221677661,
-0.0374892987,
-0.0040623122,
-0.0046223383,
0.0525386967,
-0.0338267498,
-0.0122528318,
0.0064787357,
-0.0314518176,
-0.0004996593,
-0.0352918878,
0.0236601233,
0.0265137851,
0.0076172613,
-0.0514681637,
-0.0068337279,
0.0151226586,
0.0605747961,
-0.0005770481,
0.0256042797,
-0.0063080098,
-0.0194395781,
0.0007578306,
0.0291451048,
-0.0036843431,
0.0163772665,
-0.0459041893,
-0.0204742458,
0.0220479518,
0.0115198223,
-0.0325405896,
0.0160339419,
-0.0453534238,
0.0205883011,
0.0282095354,
0.0390587226,
-0.0380255617,
-0.0333760753,
-0.001722486,
-0.0286287405,
0.0264483131,
0.0314469934,
0.0291424841,
0.0047058477,
0.0123845302,
-0.0062039574,
0.0322794653,
-0.0108069787,
0.058610525,
0.0406303927,
-0.041204378,
-0.0042136051,
-0.0063679852,
0.0267162584,
0.0177632049,
0.0102854762,
-0.0036027576,
-0.0002312166,
0.0034062928,
-0.0100968014,
-0.0116044628,
0.0234264135,
0.0095596779,
-0.002021455,
-0.0504143089,
-0.0067848349,
-0.0069469353,
-0.0402332805,
-0.0053052097,
0.0419250913,
0.0029799759,
-0.0067520076,
-0.0171636473,
-0.0022684839,
-0.0432438217,
-0.0330615193,
-0.0593081005,
0.0569383986,
-0.0105515849,
0.0086928532,
-0.0540120862,
-0.0386058353,
0.0410605483,
-0.023120638,
-0.0038488922,
0.0239010416,
0.0014272701,
0.0252541136,
0.0793095306,
-0.0190673769,
-0.020991968,
-0.0384176448,
-0.0077929501,
0.0391819775,
-0.0234424248,
0.0328925401,
0.0040664473,
-0.0275524985,
-0.0152532114,
0.000932913,
-0.0050055031,
-0.047402177,
-0.0261317641,
-0.0076280911,
0.0376393721,
-0.0001382515,
-0.0036780194,
-0.0230440218,
-0.0014798106,
-0.0610219389,
0.0214527566,
0.0531401783,
-0.0505564697,
-0.0205171537,
0.0207539704,
-0.0157869942,
-0.0020563644,
-0.0229777638,
0.0155848339,
0.0132211503,
0.021696927,
0.0081832698,
0.0120535344,
0.0232519209,
0.0749472305,
0.0485196263,
0.0032651424,
-0.059664391,
-0.0150668155,
-0.0585199893,
0.0716472939,
-0.0352936834,
-0.0340916589,
0.080173552,
0.0386389755,
0.0301540457,
0.0098736975,
-0.0344709232,
0.03148406,
-0.047916133,
-0.0001099148,
-0.0625120029,
-0.0154028619,
-0.0252374802,
0.0373765863,
0.0190293547,
-0.0398968272,
0.035628777,
0.0182362534,
0.0463357344,
-0.1036217064,
-0.0045651766,
-0.0305094272,
0.0586126894,
0.007087125,
0.0005487057,
-0.001884662,
-0.0241581425,
0.0646686181,
-0.047931686,
0.0286993999,
-0.0378546119,
0.0255603194,
-0.0741683096,
0.0290065221,
-0.020073304,
-0.037152674,
-0.0404064916,
-0.079665646,
-0.0018202261,
-0.0026193105,
0.0261682887,
-0.0080441553,
-0.0321641266,
0.024133198,
0.0379630364,
0.0240229759,
0.0230229646,
-0.0069395974,
-0.0158160366,
-0.0139236627,
0.0025978351,
-0.0288284011,
-0.0019057168,
0.0585725382,
-0.0157125071,
0.0329483822,
0.0163864028,
0.0269202627,
-0.0224794373,
0.0121278176,
0.0035188873,
-0.0561056621,
0.0143866586,
0.0492302775,
0.0216821115,
-0.0600739382,
0.0268890765,
0.0441311933,
0.0503848754,
-0.0005166477,
0.0097871413,
0.0131853698,
-0.0263815131,
0.0107970359,
-0.0036566381,
-0.077620551,
0.0385803767,
0.0143807046,
-0.0195813216,
-0.0688151047,
-0.0428629443,
-0.0131056048,
-0.0436373241,
0.0330451131,
-0.0063963416,
0.0134818498,
-0.0287422687,
-0.0893975124,
0.0039191237,
-0.0494519584,
-0.0577402189,
-0.0405036733,
-0.008025351,
0.0040383697,
0.0213703252,
-0.0645448416,
-0.0617366768,
-0.0157481581,
-0.0064521385,
0.0635222122,
0.0192387141,
0.1134608835,
-0.0085755978,
0.0368715674,
0.0185851678,
0.0102775544,
-0.0186570976,
-0.0070975018,
0.0198180042,
0.0073070396,
0.001159505,
-0.0558528155,
0.0203807149,
0.023338791,
-0.0335727111,
0.0223095063,
0.0418988578,
-0.0659874752,
-0.0433775932,
0.0060186721,
0.0553724207,
0.0164884683,
0.0546918362,
0.0110751009,
0.0255812351,
-0.0230985209,
-0.0535342731,
0.0211996827,
-0.0416601598,
-0.0580787919,
-0.0094312299,
-0.0145323938,
-0.0107551394,
-0.0174303818,
-0.0557415821,
0.0101432335,
-0.0129451826,
0.0060347128,
-0.0131228091,
0.0982321799,
0.0045377021,
0.0339083336,
0.034902595,
-0.0219156574,
-0.0107435528,
0.0196077302,
-0.0580319874,
-0.002369331,
0.0844213516,
-0.0406776145,
-0.0023559856,
-0.0143699721,
-0.0453553535,
0.0186647214,
-0.0401407592,
0.0134187341,
-0.0161378309,
-0.010645288,
-0.0240411591,
0.0505068861,
0.0826996267,
-0.0299466308,
-0.0411354974,
0.0111979134,
0.0459734313,
0.0043033888,
-0.0011520083,
0.034674909,
0.0335100852,
-0.0231055617,
-0.024553312,
-0.0815482065,
0.0123967985,
0.000240281,
-0.003208136,
0.0309125613,
-0.0282095782,
-0.0633819848,
-0.0636199787,
-0.0670314431,
-0.0062393043,
-0.0265289415,
-0.0040102857,
-0.0002664976,
-0.0142208328,
0.0168236867,
-0.064837493,
0.0363075137,
-0.0728155375,
0.0088372631,
0.006482081,
0.0897168145,
0.0178985223,
0.0471105836,
0.0137155559,
-0.0127477748,
0.0089057721,
0.0268382225,
-0.0086892536,
0.0445161909,
0.0221079178,
-0.0003231826,
0.0049056252,
-0.0089987749,
-0.0116912406,
-0.0019547767,
-0.0281227194,
-0.0053754416,
-0.0230005793,
0.0363356918,
0.0026448066,
0.0060593118,
-0.0179902725,
-0.0240816679,
0.0006636147,
0.0080032134,
-0.0007475067,
-0.0047254921,
-0.047812257,
0.0361047834,
-0.0178956054,
-0.0802835077,
-0.0224862304,
0.0171911009,
0.0095567275,
0.0124459546,
0.0499235503,
0.0061988845,
-0.0045530149,
-0.0637347326,
0.0070745531,
0.0223408788,
-0.015172638,
-0.0345672369,
-0.0672545955,
0.0276758745,
0.0100203864,
-0.0102500012,
0.0091798538,
0.0130527401,
-0.0219009742,
0.0028329126,
-0.0117936684,
0.0237786248,
-0.0569361337,
0.01490991,
-0.0211871583,
-0.0238894112,
-0.0233678091,
-5.855128178e-33,
-0.0191768482,
-0.0494242571,
0.0433287285,
-0.0039906232,
0.0434657782,
-0.0009924292,
-0.0045293197,
-0.0023227432,
0.0168169513,
0.0067211804,
0.0154494448,
0.0083346292,
0.027822135,
-0.0165972617,
0.0145978713,
-0.0196215399,
0.0294447429,
-0.0242859889,
-0.0029963651,
0.004737257,
0.0210701954,
-0.0134526528,
0.04489775,
-0.1040487215,
0.1005489677,
0.0718078315,
-0.0166634936,
-0.042878136,
0.0553356335,
-0.0186799541,
-0.0353646614,
0.0362231359,
0.0301870164,
-0.1012985483,
-0.0237192027,
0.0976558179,
-0.0389082208,
-0.0548596792,
-0.0026832924,
-0.0211047344,
0.0225713886,
-0.0405241698,
0.0543067269,
0.0439851284,
-0.0565968156,
0.0200676005,
0.0516249686,
-0.0203349479,
0.0216634609,
0.0123559833,
-0.0588999242,
0.0663146079,
-0.041727785,
0.0569385625,
-0.0021237079,
0.0140550192,
-0.0026290044,
0.0470330417,
-0.0432227999,
0.0147464368,
-0.0178342536,
-0.0252933633,
0.0111310296,
-0.0458404236,
0.0025040226,
0.0654554218,
-0.002884614,
0.0102790175,
-0.0409177877,
0.0028818608,
0.0474181958,
0.0167093743,
0.0139090875,
0.0568988994,
0.0544841327,
-0.0255971961,
-0.0808393806,
0.0494621135,
0.0348107554,
-0.0100689707,
-0.0048070862,
-0.0279371664,
-0.0506674126,
-0.031664785,
-0.0515903607,
-0.0362898968,
0.0192856845,
-0.0053722528,
-0.0035463236,
0.0053629098,
-0.0117460936,
0.118992731,
0.0030897192,
-0.0532331355,
-0.0007765095,
0.004202873,
-0.0120795723,
-0.0221528225,
-0.0013210342,
0.0113805449,
-0.0763874128,
-0.0307157561,
0.0019016938,
0.0162675716,
0.0528723672,
-0.0173310116,
-0.0115642166,
-0.0330098979,
-0.0678088292,
-0.0029937965,
0.0206559747,
-0.0248830039,
0.0461839549,
0.0260027796,
0.021257164,
0.0041675321,
0.0369295105,
-0.0000356934,
0.0079710726,
0.0099701844,
0.0171107259,
-0.034686286,
-0.0611743294,
0.027040489,
-0.0455012918,
-0.0016645241,
-0.0384793431,
0.0210758653,
0.0211794917,
0.0031827409,
-0.0139413299,
-0.0424257815,
2.418e-7,
0.051306244,
0.0825778693,
-0.001038034,
-0.0328235775,
-0.016130859,
0.0240383949,
0.0366379842,
0.0646513626,
-0.0293763503,
-0.0270810425,
0.0103711504,
-0.0186250079,
0.0007605258,
0.0490676053,
-0.0853300244,
-0.0046473076,
-0.0573869199,
-0.0014104043,
-0.0931651816,
0.03990658,
0.0070104785,
0.0502763465,
0.0670139566,
-0.0009392764,
-0.0283655971,
0.0094374595,
0.0170247406,
-0.045750238,
-0.0384978168,
0.0316026099,
0.0305568613,
0.0031182617,
-0.0004496131,
0.0309788454,
-0.0132219428,
0.0214714818,
-0.0422956124,
0.0877598524,
0.0089913709,
0.0127753615,
-0.0390633047,
-0.0462328568,
-0.0213731546,
-0.0018594865,
0.0719838589,
-0.0318861306,
-0.0484524667,
-0.0540081225,
-0.0043466594,
-0.0100833839,
0.029415369,
0.0127363456,
-0.0205961429,
0.0204577744,
0.0053509944,
-0.0204095114,
0.0131346649,
-0.0546305664,
0.0275834519,
-0.0010746651,
-0.0147758471,
-0.0392066985,
0.0102344146,
0.0415209979,
0.0378814265,
-0.0534052774,
0.0471395366,
2.329397029e-34,
0.001437313,
-0.0086821429,
-0.0146844704,
-0.0470769443,
0.0415173657,
0.0352869481,
-0.0333861113,
0.0138636576,
-0.0027259514,
-0.0639543161,
0.0316674486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03475v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03475v1 | Entity-Aware Dual Co-Attention Network for Fake News Detection | 2023-02-07T14:00:40 | 2023-02-07T14:00:40 | Sin-Han Yang, Chung-Chi Chen, Hen-Hsen Huang, Hsin-Hsi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fake news and misinformation spread rapidly on the Internet. How to identify
it and how to interpret the identification results have become important
issues. In this paper, we propose a Dual Co-Attention Network (Dual-CAN) for
fake news detection, which takes news content, social media replies, and
external knowledge into consideration. Our experimental results support that
the proposed Dual-CAN outperforms current representative models in two
benchmark datasets. We further make in-depth discussions by comparing how
models work in both datasets with empirical analysis of attention weights. | [
0.0488440469,
-0.009632092,
-0.0074408548,
0.0704547167,
-0.0172663331,
0.0012540916,
-0.0168053564,
0.0059247408,
0.0347791575,
-0.0278173238,
-0.040695142,
-0.0354633182,
-0.0201821625,
0.0499159992,
0.029237397,
-0.0165882092,
0.0783866942,
0.0343635008,
0.0580083914,
-0.0053131781,
0.0410223417,
0.0319874994,
0.0026075691,
-0.0013925107,
-0.0046456619,
-0.0137219764,
0.0203068517,
0.0197181664,
0.0427158996,
-0.0244509093,
0.0372516364,
0.0579710342,
0.0297881681,
0.091584079,
0.0000014733,
-0.0197741259,
0.0094878403,
-0.018281281,
-0.0381874591,
-0.0023098555,
0.0035334525,
-0.0601811521,
0.004161634,
0.0031993671,
0.0014623435,
-0.001147872,
0.0183544196,
0.0795046985,
0.0757562667,
0.1041662768,
-0.0173726697,
-0.0040001962,
0.0177632123,
-0.0369855911,
0.0007757937,
-0.0403075442,
0.0452982411,
0.0003356959,
-0.0149600897,
0.068234317,
0.0156138567,
0.010699044,
0.0239694398,
-0.0258120168,
-0.011978412,
0.0385633335,
-0.0126654105,
0.0058691269,
-0.0054292064,
0.0471534804,
-0.0554931052,
-0.0529872701,
0.037731275,
0.00786338,
0.0256098788,
0.0077671618,
0.0134285735,
0.0058672875,
-0.0188905206,
0.0260586441,
0.0364819989,
-0.0138239088,
0.0239212532,
0.0360924639,
-0.0068199555,
-0.0144194122,
-0.0229022335,
-0.0202906802,
0.0090538645,
0.0070774965,
-0.0019950802,
-0.068264991,
0.046860572,
0.0065568346,
0.012036006,
-0.0256069973,
-0.0768492073,
-0.0606403872,
0.0147088217,
-0.1071840972,
-0.0391244851,
-0.0173361041,
-0.0185079668,
0.0951924101,
-0.034164995,
-0.0168662611,
-0.0446803905,
0.0350525491,
0.0057507902,
-0.03439302,
0.0018789067,
-0.0054347459,
0.0109165525,
0.0478908084,
0.0012842955,
-0.0156037658,
-0.0459224321,
-0.0199280139,
-0.0340501368,
0.0002362414,
0.0081616864,
-0.0010507012,
-0.0078641772,
-0.0371796079,
0.0199834816,
0.0251044221,
-0.0121302744,
0.043450743,
0.0047931601,
-0.0431820638,
-0.0341185182,
0.0477421023,
-0.018728517,
0.0038559022,
-0.0041590603,
0.0008487691,
-0.0053974544,
0.0012256036,
-0.043936085,
-0.0314874277,
-0.0217109472,
-0.05249447,
-0.0035171446,
-0.0500043221,
-0.0070018871,
-0.0444800071,
-0.0285023581,
-0.0091907959,
-0.009739737,
0.0234259907,
-0.0510923602,
0.0121981269,
0.012102115,
0.0014969511,
0.0288392566,
0.0333551206,
0.0032995208,
0.0755639598,
-0.0139940018,
0.0653055161,
0.0427795127,
0.0453136303,
-0.0245941412,
-0.0012439822,
0.0772860721,
0.0149333933,
0.033976987,
-0.0025549103,
-0.0371726193,
0.0034154342,
0.0192875843,
0.0029118676,
-0.0052575083,
-0.0783685595,
0.0914753973,
-0.0474864542,
0.0028852955,
0.0135789113,
0.0477299802,
0.032860335,
-0.0249857754,
0.0183560122,
-0.0478176475,
0.0459138304,
-0.0718020871,
-0.0290285312,
0.0165493172,
0.0229378939,
-0.049890954,
-0.0001763378,
0.0141204176,
-0.020819962,
-0.0073779481,
-0.0153901484,
0.0189481564,
-0.0064107524,
-0.0343511552,
-0.0039468999,
0.0018190942,
0.0208669454,
0.0111424923,
-0.0339087099,
0.0266189929,
0.0134616783,
-0.0037599157,
-0.0101718185,
-0.0060874508,
-0.0272168703,
0.0027543611,
0.029829165,
0.0442991704,
0.0048173862,
-0.0442789942,
0.0183860473,
0.0139875738,
-0.0374519192,
0.0179212727,
-0.0009259745,
0.0048044282,
0.0574096814,
0.0162940044,
0.0082793608,
-0.0362084508,
0.0108824074,
0.0004706969,
0.0263542011,
-0.0230361558,
0.0379072651,
0.0182393678,
0.0395316929,
0.0250703152,
-0.0105217444,
0.0470696129,
0.0091158058,
-0.0357472673,
-0.0629083812,
-0.0191651266,
-0.0468818136,
-0.0080777165,
-0.0504534505,
-0.0628045276,
0.0754066333,
0.0083974618,
0.0031308013,
0.0450409763,
-0.0175023843,
0.0002549934,
-0.0465129986,
-0.0614360906,
-0.0025212171,
0.0680480376,
0.0562647879,
0.0873800814,
-0.056664262,
0.0072374293,
0.0167628918,
-0.0153538035,
-0.0198718868,
-0.022675937,
0.0014358792,
-0.0411319025,
0.025435783,
-0.0213425513,
0.0082463538,
-0.0405818,
0.0123966206,
-0.0103444457,
-0.0233078748,
-0.0115341889,
-0.0568655208,
-0.0007853164,
0.046870932,
-0.0218260176,
0.0075664045,
0.0312075168,
-0.0380090252,
0.0244208574,
0.0082049649,
-0.0012713177,
-0.0127498507,
-0.0484325923,
0.0494045094,
0.0056965989,
0.0184334628,
-0.0155630866,
0.0282595977,
-0.0003487958,
-0.1050987393,
-0.0239436012,
-0.0066629346,
-0.0364228003,
0.0132185929,
-0.0328956619,
0.0063588792,
0.0021292109,
0.0096850153,
0.0089647695,
0.0565774105,
0.0467792638,
0.0329487957,
0.0086835604,
0.0709242895,
-0.0486123636,
-0.0188219175,
-0.0297093447,
0.0565907769,
-0.0177724902,
-0.0430632047,
0.0426217318,
0.0666064397,
0.0059291241,
-0.0100464569,
-0.0019886834,
0.0269912649,
0.0416345187,
-0.032904271,
0.0109055173,
-0.0418212302,
0.0075671896,
-0.040648967,
-0.0487691946,
-0.0117588118,
0.1220193505,
0.0165393092,
0.0291377958,
0.0209683478,
-0.0386418775,
-0.0222584419,
-0.0254482124,
-0.0040834392,
0.0220585652,
-0.000356847,
0.0016634582,
0.0097205816,
0.0282951389,
0.0441285335,
-0.0112441601,
0.0216677282,
0.0263043083,
0.0527172871,
0.0183541216,
0.0059049437,
-0.0531717502,
-0.0796778798,
0.0025042025,
0.0159519315,
-0.0291150995,
-0.0249506831,
-0.0744966492,
-0.0001469062,
0.0382087268,
0.0477815159,
-0.0080510592,
0.0236231536,
0.0004453503,
0.0482010432,
-0.0053707156,
0.0102095688,
0.0611494631,
-0.0364099964,
-0.0153277852,
0.0772839263,
-0.0183643475,
-0.0158770047,
0.0050236257,
-0.0522854514,
0.0199653842,
-0.0238881167,
0.0100313211,
-0.0437869243,
0.014554508,
-0.0292172357,
0.0173818711,
0.0649736524,
-0.0136669828,
-0.0459495448,
0.0170295071,
0.0298343375,
-0.0318367407,
0.028414676,
-0.0166517515,
-0.0552238896,
-0.020121038,
-0.0128954854,
-0.0236871336,
-0.0053270198,
-0.0434146598,
-0.0135838967,
-0.0673248693,
-0.0089349579,
-0.0445287302,
-0.005893616,
-0.0582671501,
-0.0550767593,
0.0184535328,
0.0286823865,
-0.0198633987,
-0.0269136634,
0.0470985435,
-0.0218505766,
-0.0264567919,
0.0342377909,
-0.0545285568,
0.007925991,
-0.017323425,
0.0636645705,
-0.0040245275,
0.0128965508,
-0.001364882,
-0.0688319802,
-0.0096833156,
-0.0345154926,
-0.0473392084,
-0.0296706986,
0.0656061172,
-0.0553148575,
-0.0063132001,
-0.0287582111,
0.049852211,
0.0048644235,
-0.0023118935,
-0.0242296699,
0.0580045171,
0.0279808827,
-0.1069712266,
-0.0263851527,
-0.0009464666,
0.0774715543,
0.0678405315,
0.0348397642,
0.0073547317,
-0.0015754596,
0.0061321403,
-0.0268889405,
-0.0128586991,
-0.0530116037,
0.0470909141,
0.0085110944,
-0.0537199974,
-0.0267814044,
-0.0074718273,
-0.0171041042,
-0.0137561681,
-0.0422940366,
-0.0162185058,
0.0240030978,
-0.0541906282,
0.0015352218,
0.0081756655,
-0.0154647389,
0.0617932677,
-0.0257700346,
0.0019339602,
0.0309835728,
0.0022213638,
-0.0247472618,
0.0282900259,
-0.0714164898,
-0.0306373127,
-0.0001871287,
0.0120204799,
0.0004961578,
0.0424054675,
-0.0480976589,
-0.0459804125,
0.0183505658,
0.0022857727,
-0.0740416721,
0.0132801002,
0.0018225334,
-0.0203297585,
0.0406919532,
0.0469495319,
-0.0014654795,
0.0496096872,
0.0410337932,
-0.020875439,
-0.0732780024,
-0.0054802913,
0.0085982177,
0.0199506618,
0.0238806326,
0.0198153798,
0.0479263477,
-0.0630722567,
-0.023346575,
0.0033178788,
-0.035820704,
0.0193535518,
0.0109743681,
0.0196178053,
-0.0270355009,
0.0121301068,
0.0259565171,
-0.0087171448,
-0.0171958935,
-0.0593147017,
-0.0282800235,
-0.0016944221,
0.0496277921,
-0.0092735691,
-0.0008965407,
-0.049019888,
0.0375877842,
0.0209192429,
0.0555575155,
-0.0271326806,
-0.0166133381,
-0.0004949471,
-0.0445131212,
0.0146147683,
-0.0327343643,
-0.0209953282,
0.0457093567,
-0.0129873743,
0.0647342354,
0.0317684151,
-0.016307231,
0.0242891982,
0.0115774702,
-0.0086537208,
-0.0157894064,
-0.0223418549,
-0.0187281203,
-0.0332965292,
-0.0051209577,
0.0126728537,
-0.0164362658,
0.0687064603,
0.0667838305,
-0.0136531275,
-0.0080962712,
0.0073739244,
-0.0685121119,
-0.0288654696,
0.0135294991,
-0.0117561007,
0.0389475785,
-0.0345946588,
0.0516079515,
-0.0435789265,
-0.0611379109,
0.0103375707,
0.004145788,
0.0168988667,
0.0364485756,
-0.0159428846,
0.059537068,
0.0278265141,
0.0218510907,
-0.0318806879,
0.0143693332,
-0.0035399632,
-0.0247208476,
0.005588246,
-5.867574826e-33,
0.0334147029,
-0.0251525976,
-0.0627289414,
-0.0320822001,
0.0081353104,
0.0538923629,
-0.0183224212,
-0.0205134656,
-0.046927426,
0.012979026,
0.037441887,
0.0476884581,
-0.0272017606,
-0.01839629,
-0.0744058639,
-0.0265928321,
0.0152466409,
0.0218884554,
-0.022521399,
0.0361713618,
0.0660974011,
-0.002875169,
0.0601022169,
-0.0640487969,
0.049338948,
-0.0379684269,
-0.0066343052,
0.0257270001,
-0.0251129903,
0.0518906862,
-0.0127370553,
0.0408886597,
0.0537645668,
-0.0328594185,
0.005818048,
0.0362991355,
-0.0495699421,
-0.0305170547,
0.0155776227,
-0.0293719471,
-0.0559056699,
-0.0200813767,
0.0555125438,
0.0160070006,
0.0219958182,
0.0035264045,
0.025841279,
0.0270948187,
0.0075663077,
0.0016441446,
-0.0328892507,
0.0113089532,
-0.0246773604,
0.0407556333,
-0.0354272649,
0.065793708,
0.014649584,
0.0393762775,
-0.1299760193,
0.0165728722,
-0.0572580583,
0.000555089,
0.0188717116,
-0.0493988134,
-0.0405685529,
0.0550097562,
-0.0263973717,
0.0558133908,
-0.0888402164,
0.0129591385,
0.0023792305,
0.0227864161,
0.0818285942,
0.0762916133,
-0.0055626072,
-0.0613151379,
-0.1165493354,
0.0237307623,
0.0161348991,
-0.0061424789,
0.0308313742,
-0.0420619585,
0.003237521,
0.0313310996,
-0.001090713,
-0.0260557607,
-0.0498099104,
-0.0092325415,
-0.0124994479,
0.0461700857,
-0.0264381059,
0.0650795102,
0.011651922,
-0.0211405754,
-0.003718856,
0.0158777479,
0.0277313273,
-0.012975513,
0.0575671569,
0.0695933253,
-0.0909235105,
0.0156579055,
0.022831602,
-0.0021324037,
-0.0080691613,
-0.0090715103,
0.0839727744,
-0.0197791569,
-0.0146672726,
0.0066305329,
-0.0240000635,
0.0374667756,
-0.0526071079,
-0.0073384936,
0.0266273618,
-0.029033592,
-0.0129873939,
-0.0007476112,
0.0087354463,
0.0296566412,
0.0087787975,
0.0207624137,
-0.0142306518,
0.0513746627,
-0.0102232369,
0.0099977814,
-0.0435775667,
0.001410949,
-0.0013765517,
-0.0907746702,
0.0157712568,
0.0210179053,
2.418e-7,
-0.0173671488,
0.0174808837,
-0.0152523937,
0.0054159788,
0.0260089897,
0.0352753736,
0.0283538681,
0.0534936376,
-0.0180182084,
-0.09592513,
-0.0400813408,
0.0682633445,
-0.0251870081,
0.012391923,
-0.0559309013,
0.0132207405,
-0.0463861078,
0.0236312598,
-0.0316082761,
-0.0219359938,
-0.0208522361,
0.0523915999,
0.0355412029,
0.0121697914,
0.0202096719,
-0.0105735166,
0.039440304,
0.0579401962,
-0.0286729541,
0.0091438377,
0.0945364833,
0.0044285324,
-0.0040805005,
0.0209558103,
-0.014884091,
0.0255576856,
0.042933289,
0.0113807889,
0.0066270847,
0.0021592439,
-0.009263698,
-0.0455721468,
0.0161449742,
-0.0510790832,
0.0664104298,
-0.0564950034,
-0.0340932049,
-0.045726791,
-0.0344232023,
0.0155072594,
0.0278984159,
0.0021826536,
-0.0137904519,
0.0311214514,
-0.0093990574,
-0.0021994817,
0.0348488986,
-0.0543700792,
0.0102466401,
0.0012574021,
-0.0599244162,
0.0218148399,
-0.0349149704,
-0.0415849946,
0.0695128217,
0.0022016696,
0.0285983849,
1.498265929e-34,
0.0288862865,
-0.0050823591,
-0.0178894736,
-0.0250867773,
-0.0198782086,
0.0066944896,
-0.0718651339,
-0.043404121,
0.0435059071,
-0.0152025195,
-0.0153032662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.04096v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.04096v1 | Real-Word Error Correction with Trigrams: Correcting Multiple Errors in a Sentence | 2023-02-07T13:52:14 | 2023-02-07T13:52:14 | Seyed MohammadSadegh Dashti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Spelling correction is a fundamental task in Text Mining. In this study, we
assess the real-word error correction model proposed by Mays, Damerau and
Mercer and describe several drawbacks of the model. We propose a new variation
which focuses on detecting and correcting multiple real-word errors in a
sentence, by manipulating a Probabilistic Context-Free Grammar (PCFG) to
discriminate between items in the search space. We test our approach on the
Wall Street Journal corpus and show that it outperforms Hirst and Budanitsky's
WordNet-based method and Wilcox-O'Hearn, Hirst, and Budanitsky's fixed windows
size method.-O'Hearn, Hirst, and Budanitsky's fixed windows size method. | [
0.0617143176,
-0.0025896924,
0.0095501998,
0.0056854393,
-0.0330519825,
0.0007111405,
0.0371754207,
0.0114858327,
-0.0042023184,
-0.0554975793,
0.0324553624,
-0.0231455807,
0.0212397017,
-0.0427125171,
0.0105077522,
-0.0155106252,
0.1034441665,
0.0092308288,
0.0125656864,
0.0159501694,
0.0341145098,
0.0269290935,
-0.0569844209,
0.0168153942,
-0.0075260531,
-0.009618626,
0.000470096,
0.0429636165,
0.0184705462,
-0.0222175438,
0.0154312467,
0.0440151356,
-0.0357214101,
0.0173107237,
0.0000019352,
-0.0162546542,
-0.0554607324,
-0.0308793094,
0.0146228429,
0.0136037916,
0.0242717527,
0.0124060018,
-0.0175435282,
0.0589542948,
0.0008017615,
-0.0048440993,
0.0365800261,
0.0248163752,
0.0356745943,
0.0648636967,
0.0026928335,
0.0077022538,
-0.0033032978,
-0.0021243715,
0.0254593305,
0.013251462,
0.0145398322,
0.0157644767,
-0.0158359241,
0.0002518076,
-0.0129799694,
0.0099893734,
-0.0659692958,
-0.0369104296,
0.0113247503,
-0.0317079537,
-0.039981775,
-0.007604009,
0.0093027046,
-0.0020634979,
-0.0257770605,
0.0081666745,
0.0262702629,
-0.005947487,
0.0003424371,
0.0275968481,
0.0201068036,
-0.0190526266,
-0.088512443,
-0.0083629973,
0.0326263979,
-0.0613243319,
0.0023320124,
0.03713594,
-0.0084455675,
0.0636163875,
0.015458947,
-0.0278382227,
-0.0237982795,
0.031125972,
0.0003376738,
0.0004473513,
0.0620303713,
-0.0256506577,
-0.0203244593,
0.0136319166,
-0.0508786179,
-0.0616990551,
-0.0049364609,
-0.0214966964,
0.0078885071,
-0.0169294067,
0.0022379174,
0.0116729056,
0.0218683537,
-0.0027110917,
0.0763010085,
0.031723462,
-0.0187339131,
0.0424546376,
-0.0187542997,
0.0137791866,
-0.0446119644,
0.0158481207,
-0.0295350961,
0.0156443454,
-0.0826121494,
-0.0436212271,
-0.0312537923,
-0.003404222,
0.0472907759,
-0.0187931955,
-0.0282154996,
-0.0001925056,
0.0052974587,
0.0061623515,
0.0258937031,
0.0143574039,
-0.0101573598,
-0.0271417107,
-0.0049663736,
0.0328046642,
0.0494994186,
-0.0039769714,
0.0009886514,
-0.0088922288,
0.0079107899,
-0.0606929772,
-0.0031224329,
-0.0287284926,
-0.0573711097,
0.0382366404,
-0.0273955353,
-0.0587547906,
-0.0124154408,
-0.0628991425,
-0.0001015791,
0.0168035384,
0.0253181476,
0.0358925648,
-0.0330686457,
0.0563782714,
-0.0535755642,
0.0041678138,
0.0125740664,
-0.0127255823,
0.0430192202,
-0.0161370281,
0.0302381888,
-0.037580315,
0.0743496493,
0.01017481,
0.006787607,
0.0068881689,
-0.078817144,
-0.0275353789,
-0.0021576318,
-0.0310396012,
-0.0130956257,
0.0517286286,
0.0394179523,
0.0375121534,
-0.0457752943,
0.0138101904,
0.0035968786,
0.0440058783,
0.0449042246,
-0.0052163,
0.007901853,
-0.0615513436,
0.0772761703,
-0.0138989063,
-0.0071750027,
-0.0580958053,
-0.0445349328,
-0.0040708664,
0.0277989581,
-0.0104291467,
0.013514353,
-0.0550739281,
-0.0393980592,
0.0153938308,
-0.0057823318,
-0.086623475,
0.0542499982,
-0.0168881863,
-0.0690351352,
-0.0097269844,
-0.0035878075,
-0.0360896587,
0.0035174023,
-0.0380125232,
0.0238929093,
0.1110249311,
0.1097884253,
-0.0255049635,
0.0258656051,
0.0023302054,
-0.0453886166,
0.0471727327,
0.029601045,
-0.0268937144,
-0.0520112701,
-0.0626655072,
0.0203072876,
0.0689048469,
0.0280990377,
-0.0087015899,
0.0005600945,
0.0429287665,
0.0029415525,
0.0300578289,
-0.0193727892,
0.0091657778,
0.0268525295,
0.021421494,
-0.026688002,
-0.025183389,
-0.0088802865,
0.0268416721,
-0.0381477401,
0.0318737812,
-0.0095258094,
-0.0211659893,
-0.004212819,
-0.0323526151,
0.0275673456,
-0.0627611727,
0.0315772295,
-0.051503364,
0.019751152,
0.0380557105,
0.0047417521,
-0.0188455768,
-0.0075777699,
-0.0283659529,
0.0512256697,
-0.0464581773,
0.0297524054,
0.0102384249,
0.0029397123,
-0.0755475461,
0.0410105474,
0.0021919252,
0.047400672,
-0.0733829066,
-0.0209501814,
-0.0108034657,
-0.0147378724,
0.0049654786,
0.0009391052,
0.0254628602,
0.054541871,
0.0378946066,
0.0142992986,
-0.0184427034,
-0.0314989835,
-0.0332511328,
0.0170295555,
0.0111534111,
0.0480679795,
0.0312744603,
-0.0153840771,
-0.0132380137,
-0.0241200365,
0.0285913926,
0.0433449969,
0.0428671278,
-0.0524182878,
0.092914097,
-0.0539293885,
-0.0319851488,
-0.0666665286,
-0.0182149448,
-0.003838365,
-0.0009414686,
0.028116351,
-0.0739441365,
-0.0735899583,
0.093006216,
-0.0001331359,
0.0096743796,
0.0419532433,
-0.024766732,
-0.0118811168,
-0.0567648411,
-0.0402095765,
0.0258690268,
0.0259075314,
0.0322384462,
-0.0120060919,
-0.0303451307,
0.011504312,
-0.0276029129,
0.021113446,
-0.0104199322,
0.0233320333,
-0.0561415665,
0.0266288798,
0.0057241474,
0.0346347578,
-0.034863539,
0.0006482952,
-0.0216413997,
0.0005204245,
0.0225144904,
-0.0275590103,
-0.0396534614,
0.0220340267,
0.0430574752,
-0.0320264809,
-0.0380258299,
0.0259490516,
0.0104637025,
0.0259383991,
-0.089957051,
0.0025048179,
-0.0117267165,
-0.0362227038,
-0.0064478782,
0.0307165049,
0.0303720124,
-0.0465920046,
-0.037978828,
-0.0515852906,
0.0670374036,
-0.0523056462,
0.0502991304,
-0.070983164,
0.0308928285,
0.0150873056,
0.0042090192,
-0.018815564,
-0.0523597598,
-0.001056346,
-0.0452936813,
0.0513753258,
-0.0518835708,
-0.0576210134,
-0.0053231246,
-0.0053290329,
0.0628640354,
0.0029130352,
-0.0555371232,
0.0197517313,
0.0232516285,
-0.0253828168,
0.0203601271,
0.0510026328,
0.0019324658,
-0.0192992706,
0.0621871687,
0.0201687049,
0.071754396,
0.007430857,
0.0075934525,
0.0253482927,
-0.0519811325,
-0.0559471026,
-0.0131533658,
-0.0181452483,
-0.0412510633,
-0.0566987582,
0.0918747038,
0.0744922906,
-0.0541050732,
-0.0175275337,
0.010914091,
-0.0446126722,
-0.0069237854,
0.038332887,
-0.0521609262,
-0.0361971371,
0.0396366715,
0.040414203,
-0.0200809054,
-0.0214252137,
0.0067828405,
-0.1305983365,
0.0412366763,
0.0443462543,
0.0381896272,
-0.0589104109,
-0.010493964,
0.023165904,
0.0223365184,
-0.0328660682,
0.0703776479,
-0.0219090264,
0.0060070381,
0.039224904,
-0.0627449676,
-0.0817678422,
-0.0438467078,
-0.0349140167,
0.0138944946,
0.0313184708,
0.0013960877,
-0.0283365306,
-0.0116529549,
-0.0117613031,
0.008476343,
-0.0304419659,
-0.0078870011,
0.0252148174,
0.0133589339,
-0.0164491907,
-0.0496517532,
-0.021394046,
-0.0893043131,
-0.0293394867,
-0.00035318,
0.0225585122,
-0.0468079001,
0.023742171,
-0.0096773282,
0.0252930094,
0.030414952,
0.0053874436,
-0.0266817454,
-0.0183801893,
-0.0032817782,
-0.0529921129,
0.0200009979,
-0.0499880984,
0.002433012,
0.0230896492,
-0.0380689539,
-0.0206833091,
-0.0922339335,
-0.01403182,
-0.0168230664,
0.0452622399,
0.0142729059,
-0.0287459996,
0.0283171497,
0.0201122276,
-0.0107743284,
-0.0366616733,
0.039820306,
0.0337175578,
-0.0370449349,
0.0680909604,
-0.0050645275,
0.0327346474,
-0.0204285849,
0.0022642727,
-0.0459451973,
-0.00923537,
0.0439967215,
-0.0300183259,
0.0165774338,
-0.046059873,
-0.0341638848,
-0.0091356132,
-0.0240287259,
0.0537958294,
0.0556411557,
0.0416942723,
0.0005116294,
-0.0489574708,
-0.0218125023,
-0.0244455598,
-0.0106193125,
-0.0128619988,
-0.0378922634,
0.0400663354,
-0.0197348557,
-0.0105416542,
0.0146642169,
0.0301506147,
0.0440195538,
-0.0115351537,
0.0562661216,
-0.069625929,
-0.018480774,
0.0129467584,
-0.0304666758,
-0.0071008848,
-0.0015576095,
-0.0148317879,
-0.0725359917,
-0.0419760719,
0.008689817,
-0.0267896466,
-0.0121355075,
0.0394389741,
0.02767515,
-0.0106830047,
0.0232187398,
-0.0413513109,
-0.0404138453,
0.0155357672,
0.0002858024,
-0.0036775062,
0.0211789105,
-0.034908887,
-0.0100481426,
0.0104183275,
-0.0324279368,
-0.0260801595,
-0.0069680964,
-0.0321132727,
0.0518781096,
-0.013221086,
0.0424725153,
0.0716525167,
-0.0178726874,
0.0381904952,
-0.0480277836,
-0.0125418035,
-0.0222879462,
0.0311214924,
0.032946866,
0.0604571253,
0.0032691029,
0.0097806314,
-0.0050501637,
-0.0708710104,
0.0560695343,
-0.0162354335,
0.0167442542,
-0.0398871563,
-0.1128131151,
0.0102909394,
-0.0175706372,
-0.0356544219,
-0.0049453583,
-0.0082582021,
-0.0217274167,
-0.0497898869,
-0.0202217344,
0.0046255169,
0.1048870534,
0.0317292213,
0.0135789672,
-0.0076333294,
0.0561731271,
0.0321161859,
0.0267539155,
-0.0270379167,
0.0055639395,
-0.0147480052,
-0.0097134477,
0.0193925854,
-5.578075547e-33,
-0.0450411402,
-0.0735405982,
-0.041053772,
-0.0651060864,
-0.029868247,
-0.019432785,
0.006786935,
0.0243621841,
0.032477431,
0.0319247991,
-0.0162595939,
0.0555104613,
0.0121389255,
-0.0319347046,
0.0635126755,
0.0522430278,
0.007225228,
-0.0193119645,
0.012524602,
-0.0516733006,
0.0560407341,
0.0389973074,
0.0632401109,
-0.007769648,
0.0562778302,
0.0083063031,
-0.0449170582,
0.037198998,
-0.0002394652,
0.0363615267,
0.0525273196,
0.0523042865,
-0.0247206688,
0.0359173454,
-0.011030592,
-0.00031729,
-0.079331249,
-0.0532095283,
0.0301645678,
0.0372632593,
0.000651988,
-0.0151582798,
0.0347501375,
-0.0102283619,
-0.0184273589,
0.0213158187,
0.0318712629,
-0.0535238311,
-0.0251616947,
-0.0150947301,
0.0152847879,
0.026758112,
0.0075154747,
0.0414891019,
-0.0031622301,
0.0178065766,
-0.0168059338,
-0.0147397034,
-0.0722473562,
0.0084720086,
-0.0106557077,
0.0513970368,
-0.0240148026,
0.0077971676,
-0.0283525623,
0.0607224517,
0.0144496877,
0.0100570219,
0.0523045883,
-0.0319526307,
0.0088472962,
-0.0382782482,
0.0507758707,
0.0450194813,
0.0924585387,
-0.0377302989,
-0.0810389221,
-0.0041984408,
-0.0239866897,
0.0098352674,
0.0150873195,
-0.0083636269,
-0.0723401234,
-0.0425068438,
0.0117599415,
0.0069400468,
-0.0013916554,
-0.0100413449,
0.0043916311,
0.0482992679,
0.0203896631,
0.0180520359,
-0.0226751901,
-0.0012344787,
-0.0151366713,
-0.0479438156,
0.0003686101,
0.021580644,
-0.0570360795,
-0.0070714885,
0.0221346132,
-0.0329223201,
-0.039422933,
0.0414129905,
0.0236393735,
0.0119832559,
-0.0001610531,
0.0102034006,
-0.1026536971,
0.0080560073,
0.0364966057,
0.0156370159,
-0.0025040335,
-0.0352967307,
0.0067569125,
-0.0181438942,
0.01347226,
0.0094873197,
0.0307103824,
-0.0045189722,
0.0418308489,
-0.0056130737,
-0.017475795,
0.0170837454,
0.0334620103,
0.0155202774,
0.0094024818,
0.0155523568,
0.0610638745,
-0.0317692198,
0.0133770751,
-0.0155554609,
2.729e-7,
0.0593250394,
0.065694429,
0.0099869873,
0.0146501698,
0.0227753613,
0.0065870928,
-0.0155134276,
0.0377070159,
-0.0478327088,
0.0367114507,
0.0191787593,
-0.015044786,
0.0775605589,
-0.001130291,
-0.031820748,
-0.0157173015,
0.0150841586,
0.0131769925,
-0.013590347,
-0.0065968493,
0.0644854084,
0.0171457585,
0.036992833,
-0.017171165,
-0.0508845486,
-0.0272459351,
0.0156645887,
-0.0011353996,
-0.0411846526,
0.0245113615,
0.1053200737,
-0.0008225558,
0.0351788439,
0.038769152,
-0.0357117429,
-0.0385376513,
0.0844482109,
0.001295623,
0.0020163483,
0.0789195672,
0.0222724769,
0.0009129443,
0.0014490165,
0.0176057834,
0.0194004774,
0.0284850337,
0.04556695,
-0.0339471959,
-0.0016684921,
0.0055661104,
0.041622445,
-0.012058693,
-0.0280081779,
0.0134627596,
0.0207758565,
0.0579549409,
0.0127326194,
-0.0369226187,
0.0135208825,
0.0405400768,
0.0006193698,
-0.0466079675,
0.0313571058,
0.0234500002,
0.0016453506,
-0.024840476,
-0.0085365018,
2.608143014e-34,
0.0552889816,
0.0058366484,
-0.0022166185,
-0.0118688261,
0.0224367343,
0.0000841214,
0.0195074044,
-0.0032352791,
0.0130522763,
-0.0601026341,
-0.0061560147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03353v1 | What do Language Models know about word senses? Zero-Shot WSD with Language Models and Domain Inventories | 2023-02-07T09:55:07 | 2023-02-07T09:55:07 | Oscar Sainz, Oier Lopez de Lacalle, Eneko Agirre, German Rigau | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language Models are the core for almost any Natural Language Processing
system nowadays. One of their particularities is their contextualized
representations, a game changer feature when a disambiguation between word
senses is necessary. In this paper we aim to explore to what extent language
models are capable of discerning among senses at inference time. We performed
this analysis by prompting commonly used Languages Models such as BERT or
RoBERTa to perform the task of Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD). We leverage the
relation between word senses and domains, and cast WSD as a textual entailment
problem, where the different hypothesis refer to the domains of the word
senses. Our results show that this approach is indeed effective, close to
supervised systems. | [
-0.0043462957,
-0.0120703643,
-0.0158710536,
0.0855164677,
-0.0412191786,
0.0307733938,
-0.018820513,
0.0033793531,
0.0175796952,
-0.0719430074,
-0.0244647097,
0.0018639968,
0.0077402666,
-0.0089249788,
-0.0068196314,
0.0143858176,
0.0697317272,
-0.0228389464,
-0.0536655784,
0.0111848665,
-0.0234238207,
0.0178835671,
-0.0278841145,
0.0095909275,
-0.0048766932,
-0.0287025552,
0.0326339193,
0.0031219956,
0.0015811925,
-0.0133854458,
-0.0214724187,
0.0279352982,
0.0523895957,
0.0447985642,
0.0000018785,
-0.077523753,
-0.0435237326,
-0.0146368938,
0.0026025348,
-0.0450156145,
0.0255911946,
-0.0569245033,
0.0400242545,
-0.0164008997,
-0.0295960363,
-0.0078190789,
0.0268048327,
-0.0279730801,
0.0314812995,
0.0231796969,
-0.0116772773,
-0.0526961572,
-0.041562438,
0.0152804237,
0.0158974677,
-0.0304427855,
0.0335724801,
0.0016817965,
-0.0081557455,
-0.0559820533,
-0.0645352677,
0.0484370217,
0.0048681069,
0.0384897515,
-0.0214057211,
0.0034235208,
-0.0112920357,
-0.000414263,
0.0204955526,
0.0175628159,
0.0284097623,
-0.0337183475,
0.0132404538,
0.0067383349,
-0.0277245417,
0.0547882617,
0.027691165,
0.017225001,
-0.045988854,
0.0201732498,
0.0278284587,
0.033517722,
0.0421123803,
0.0507207923,
-0.0171746854,
0.1364886165,
0.0154076349,
-0.0107278964,
-0.0121128755,
0.0191716105,
-0.0304497425,
-0.0276862998,
0.0018810811,
-0.0079991538,
0.0020732067,
0.0691246912,
-0.0378140509,
-0.0310905837,
0.0128223095,
-0.0655034631,
-0.0289025642,
0.0149264047,
-0.0179125108,
0.0567945614,
-0.0154343257,
0.0005259322,
-0.0086962124,
-0.0029814916,
-0.0422432087,
-0.0327376053,
-0.0652829707,
0.0031086823,
-0.0515624732,
0.0276105683,
-0.0476405025,
-0.0108093349,
-0.0493020415,
0.0277981944,
-0.004418401,
-0.0139467502,
-0.0157178789,
-0.0230947658,
-0.063865453,
0.0026328922,
-0.0419702865,
0.0260561649,
-0.0262568984,
0.0232681707,
-0.064636685,
-0.0092233233,
0.0074095093,
0.0272413827,
-0.0022058112,
-0.0380151384,
-0.0083662821,
0.0851684883,
0.0517441817,
-0.0289681908,
-0.0738324374,
-0.0507609472,
-0.0593512431,
-0.0196154397,
-0.0200209115,
-0.0653584749,
-0.0155475745,
0.0419578031,
0.0172902197,
-0.0636454895,
-0.0220595542,
-0.0167986862,
-0.0158775374,
0.1140515655,
-0.019408932,
-0.0058251163,
0.0246877279,
0.0106082112,
0.0043298551,
0.0945937112,
0.0328832157,
0.0024640036,
0.0540347807,
0.0342142135,
-0.030139707,
0.0083848191,
-0.0240592267,
0.0256629977,
-0.0257931482,
-0.0209870879,
-0.0047575012,
0.013080027,
-0.0056879926,
0.0502045862,
-0.0430202894,
-0.0201790147,
-0.0054361089,
0.0632637441,
0.0208123364,
-0.0540131405,
0.0840436667,
-0.0220774673,
-0.0059517575,
0.0304309111,
-0.0380001366,
-0.043734774,
-0.0385887474,
0.0110399043,
-0.0103297606,
-0.0167877078,
-0.0028027955,
-0.0454208329,
-0.0528587401,
-0.0361236036,
0.0078485766,
0.0062036631,
0.0769306198,
0.0201242156,
0.0039227102,
0.0207016729,
0.036270678,
-0.0345171019,
0.0516424477,
-0.0585293323,
0.016268542,
0.0729097575,
0.0330237187,
-0.0606402755,
-0.0207377411,
0.0117619997,
0.0120197674,
0.050821878,
0.013282991,
-0.0246894676,
0.0342339538,
-0.0079606511,
-0.0175846145,
0.01248259,
0.0340194888,
0.0017064693,
-0.0205642562,
0.0109093478,
0.0118407076,
-0.1302786618,
0.0087044183,
0.0450061671,
-0.0356417112,
-0.033436697,
-0.0295091029,
0.0316778831,
0.0031412456,
0.0098007768,
-0.0247104932,
0.016232565,
-0.0098957587,
-0.0611255355,
-0.0115919122,
0.0125627555,
0.0040196958,
-0.0480579026,
0.0293786172,
-0.0290807132,
-0.0100912452,
-0.0028840522,
-0.0218568761,
-0.0139480103,
0.0223165192,
-0.0031574513,
0.0491998158,
-0.0604697466,
0.0174874011,
-0.0196055342,
-0.0291724931,
-0.0359631516,
0.0687984079,
0.0072370786,
0.0406789221,
-0.0356101282,
0.0472096987,
0.0286293551,
0.0348836668,
-0.0606362596,
-0.0129910391,
0.0232305955,
0.0082331179,
0.0363946743,
-0.0303080734,
-0.0516046397,
-0.0025527887,
-0.0730922371,
0.0251466576,
0.0006793822,
0.0214012861,
0.0163638275,
0.0271566994,
-0.0003549572,
-0.0061176452,
0.0300134849,
-0.0052694301,
-0.0068526343,
0.0307390187,
0.0357041322,
-0.0300310794,
-0.0120068043,
-0.0308055226,
-0.0131688658,
-0.0567199588,
0.0639457554,
0.0195074826,
-0.0556986593,
-0.0361690409,
0.0027588943,
-0.0797127336,
0.0447229594,
0.0246134289,
-0.0156672541,
-0.0148683041,
-0.007481724,
0.0004332973,
0.032598678,
0.0001212748,
0.0648568124,
0.0836698189,
-0.0012489399,
-0.0114152376,
-0.0069285291,
-0.0098715164,
0.0096722897,
-0.0209377632,
0.0043605547,
0.0248694811,
0.0813169703,
0.0178125799,
-0.0241302531,
-0.0037117014,
0.0387749374,
-0.0521449186,
-0.0156988744,
0.0049814223,
0.0036437537,
-0.016467711,
0.0630559027,
-0.0118253678,
-0.0423040912,
0.0716601014,
-0.0255705789,
0.0314787105,
-0.0838030726,
-0.0007252276,
-0.0224809218,
0.0589274131,
-0.0284944419,
0.041526597,
0.0307722222,
-0.0084934346,
-0.0411850624,
-0.0278268978,
0.0735345855,
-0.0196212772,
0.0557281487,
-0.0732835308,
0.0548113249,
0.0005962037,
0.0162426401,
-0.0647649392,
-0.011575873,
-0.0637203157,
0.0340918414,
0.0136740692,
0.0054123257,
-0.0084495703,
0.0132727623,
0.0030918298,
0.0177202225,
0.0443790741,
-0.0282266364,
-0.0249084309,
0.0295128673,
0.0504709296,
-0.0416851863,
-0.014757378,
-0.0213468373,
0.0059220381,
-0.0111015635,
-0.0171106849,
-0.0169592574,
-0.031080205,
0.0052192947,
0.0269047171,
-0.0487235822,
-0.0255332403,
-0.0079033487,
-0.0040604826,
-0.0225968938,
-0.0155249611,
0.1339133829,
0.0592176877,
-0.0519506633,
0.0076464424,
0.0045194542,
-0.0237322077,
0.0198135655,
-0.016271973,
-0.1009660438,
-0.0709181055,
-0.0209111534,
-0.021794498,
0.0373609066,
-0.0260571036,
-0.0114916172,
-0.080992341,
-0.0000997024,
-0.0282720122,
-0.0418574139,
-0.0165021196,
-0.0026729081,
0.0343269743,
0.0057852645,
-0.0316889025,
-0.0341763645,
-0.0069495514,
-0.0038690807,
0.0075582671,
0.048176527,
-0.0121292109,
0.0212930236,
-0.0591755323,
0.0168307927,
0.0837017447,
0.0413724333,
0.020356426,
-0.05608299,
-0.0345452242,
-0.0649806559,
-0.0304295029,
-0.0067112488,
0.0068990616,
-0.0360083394,
0.0171355736,
0.0269085765,
0.0121821463,
-0.0421179347,
-0.0172833763,
0.0150808543,
0.040486902,
-0.0336420238,
-0.043067269,
-0.033932697,
-0.0157245863,
0.0002107778,
0.1007017493,
-0.0011391676,
-0.0109433262,
-0.0191112272,
-0.0006090682,
-0.0212717913,
0.0098443227,
-0.0159543082,
-0.0349910259,
-0.0514778942,
-0.0215108916,
-0.0853345841,
0.0007479913,
0.0238197688,
0.0407348722,
-0.0078200223,
0.0356987268,
0.0262173694,
0.0116064716,
-0.0675678551,
0.0140317082,
-0.027507877,
0.0401297733,
-0.0250151139,
0.0132143041,
0.0777922422,
-0.0121912127,
-0.0358931385,
0.0446126796,
-0.0330660865,
-0.0332107544,
0.0056671537,
-0.019899074,
0.0285306349,
0.0304163061,
-0.0608731546,
0.0108052921,
0.0012229531,
0.0350953341,
-0.0116686327,
0.048178684,
0.0168439317,
0.0526302308,
0.0038791888,
0.0698094964,
-0.0439195074,
0.0591368675,
0.0208959058,
0.0036891138,
-0.0093341032,
-0.0127520571,
0.0184522681,
-0.012225504,
0.0699513853,
-0.0157404896,
-0.0264419969,
-0.0200110059,
-0.0348844379,
-0.0183061715,
-0.0456412733,
-0.0051143686,
0.0228762645,
-0.0038063023,
-0.0207517017,
-0.0269824956,
0.0455283523,
-0.0327778123,
0.0189191382,
0.0093135806,
0.0033086163,
0.0867466331,
-0.0086313523,
-0.0260620136,
-0.0240073875,
0.0038757357,
-0.018443767,
-0.035201937,
0.0058078752,
-0.014396877,
0.0177619383,
0.0167647619,
0.0041502696,
-0.066039741,
0.0096315881,
-0.0410086326,
0.0029782259,
0.0276284274,
0.0621133074,
0.0515245348,
-0.0292861797,
0.0361368805,
0.0021237934,
0.0123654027,
-0.0074370019,
0.0472583622,
0.0517911911,
0.031350676,
0.0276834387,
0.0385911576,
-0.0188898146,
-0.008236899,
0.0656693056,
0.0002280335,
0.0589964911,
0.0144160865,
-0.0422943644,
-0.0142498603,
-0.0234003589,
-0.0149067994,
0.0463564619,
-0.0069286576,
0.0658667833,
-0.098150529,
-0.0793638304,
0.0471957549,
0.0064223399,
0.0054803374,
0.0115848808,
0.0348777026,
0.0472391695,
0.039722126,
-0.0137847932,
-0.0252449922,
-0.0062118103,
-0.0454317406,
-0.0392633229,
-0.0402847454,
-5.645867041e-33,
-0.0360896066,
-0.0323697478,
0.0080278693,
-0.0253744777,
0.0170546863,
0.0123624969,
-0.0091239819,
-0.0221314039,
-0.0428968892,
0.0157930795,
0.0380616821,
0.0541993119,
0.0139465751,
0.0088178031,
-0.0151772965,
-0.0115332399,
0.0486935936,
0.0229687784,
-0.0356062949,
-0.0367499627,
0.0859216228,
-0.0192967374,
0.0641270727,
-0.0251856502,
0.0362662822,
-0.0376433469,
0.0024065915,
0.0423747189,
0.0265725963,
0.0536839887,
-0.0167334322,
0.0519357733,
0.0164403562,
-0.0055206167,
0.0114626558,
0.0200937502,
-0.0689788088,
-0.0550135635,
0.0777228028,
-0.0305559393,
-0.0449751206,
-0.0154004954,
0.0383208953,
0.0030725568,
0.0093433447,
0.0345689841,
0.0564872697,
-0.0286820959,
-0.0251875017,
-0.055080235,
-0.0804956704,
0.0352011584,
-0.0006940623,
-0.0351525769,
0.0371012948,
0.0034694674,
0.0001919644,
-0.0042660581,
-0.033113312,
0.0207158569,
-0.0181861427,
0.0210278854,
0.0564511307,
0.0169198234,
-0.0110665495,
0.0592833161,
-0.0178305507,
-0.055524826,
0.0236902535,
-0.0211519729,
0.0434146374,
0.0291515496,
-0.0083066029,
0.0653413236,
0.0444410741,
0.0104972711,
-0.02800918,
0.0065956833,
0.0181667171,
0.0083153071,
0.0207728408,
-0.0271448679,
-0.0440564044,
-0.0286312979,
-0.0646735579,
-0.0069784266,
-0.0375297032,
0.0037565615,
0.0312056858,
-0.0318205282,
-0.0333235413,
0.0115595935,
0.0179097708,
-0.0505700111,
0.0330605395,
0.0396177769,
0.0262493342,
-0.0049513616,
0.0223658625,
0.0176325738,
0.0458457172,
-0.038357947,
-0.0026871345,
0.0563874133,
0.0060001668,
0.0017257564,
0.0137705849,
-0.0321730226,
-0.0002436246,
0.0055937953,
-0.0190991648,
-0.0393710099,
-0.0433849916,
0.0074191154,
0.0379598886,
0.0258661415,
0.0000253266,
0.0079404591,
0.0128243249,
-0.0439878255,
-0.016553903,
0.0128289005,
-0.0241069049,
0.0542139448,
-0.0470600687,
-0.0144328829,
0.0290010814,
0.0385085791,
0.0271317791,
-0.0371896662,
0.0033150499,
-0.0011468075,
2.642e-7,
0.0717023164,
0.016736554,
-0.024400264,
0.0257091951,
0.000288856,
0.0039762622,
0.0357566029,
0.0100624627,
-0.0226055775,
-0.0405530259,
-0.04144435,
0.0212176759,
0.0044949432,
0.0451676138,
-0.0356565081,
0.013511287,
0.0381901711,
0.0557864606,
-0.0191001128,
0.0003734687,
0.069968529,
0.0737906545,
0.0277054068,
-0.012523951,
-0.0401473083,
-0.0676968843,
0.0300278272,
-0.0051715127,
0.0436993763,
-0.0055638822,
-0.0106793372,
0.0067948652,
0.0683943927,
0.0450206324,
-0.0198925976,
0.0259524286,
0.0178839713,
0.0450951606,
-0.0327032954,
-0.0017396401,
-0.0425190255,
-0.0221684221,
0.0176444072,
0.0014526215,
0.0795723945,
-0.0411671139,
0.0138647482,
-0.0034712488,
0.0014741775,
0.0140211927,
-0.0111489845,
0.0132889403,
-0.052275788,
0.0196647681,
0.0120255174,
-0.0285490137,
-0.0198617373,
-0.0618469045,
-0.0038958318,
0.0179559477,
-0.0087796701,
-0.0389682874,
0.0304755531,
-0.0394811332,
0.0521767661,
-0.1032312736,
-0.0034085698,
2.169463905e-34,
0.0508702882,
0.0219225809,
-0.005610907,
0.0260800701,
0.0200171713,
-0.0131816054,
-0.0166941714,
0.0027909882,
0.0394360013,
-0.0400758609,
0.0105733033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03341v1 | The Effect of Metadata on Scientific Literature Tagging: A Cross-Field Cross-Model Study | 2023-02-07T09:34:41 | 2023-02-07T09:34:41 | Yu Zhang, Bowen Jin, Qi Zhu, Yu Meng, Jiawei Han | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.LG | Due to the exponential growth of scientific publications on the Web, there is
a pressing need to tag each paper with fine-grained topics so that researchers
can track their interested fields of study rather than drowning in the whole
literature. Scientific literature tagging is beyond a pure multi-label text
classification task because papers on the Web are prevalently accompanied by
metadata information such as venues, authors, and references, which may serve
as additional signals to infer relevant tags. Although there have been studies
making use of metadata in academic paper classification, their focus is often
restricted to one or two scientific fields (e.g., computer science and
biomedicine) and to one specific model. In this work, we systematically study
the effect of metadata on scientific literature tagging across 19 fields. We
select three representative multi-label classifiers (i.e., a bag-of-words
model, a sequence-based model, and a pre-trained language model) and explore
their performance change in scientific literature tagging when metadata are fed
to the classifiers as additional features. We observe some ubiquitous patterns
of metadata's effects across all fields (e.g., venues are consistently
beneficial to paper tagging in almost all cases), as well as some unique
patterns in fields other than computer science and biomedicine, which are not
explored in previous studies. | [
0.041987244,
-0.0239167735,
-0.0149566019,
-0.0716188475,
-0.0216403063,
0.0361204594,
0.0635646507,
0.0083641522,
0.0006525687,
-0.1033397391,
-0.0015811083,
0.046545472,
0.0028827959,
-0.0024246695,
0.010133517,
-0.0203918442,
0.0379913487,
-0.0032849223,
0.0499487221,
0.01217415,
-0.0116325328,
-0.0139106233,
0.0203834809,
0.019194793,
0.0249961969,
-0.0205719024,
0.0104650185,
-0.0337886736,
-0.0144440187,
-0.0431075655,
0.0342542045,
0.0485389754,
-0.0044188914,
0.0575192571,
0.0000014571,
-0.0447153226,
-0.0666862056,
0.0279229898,
0.0096297255,
0.0300886538,
0.0575919673,
0.0037391158,
0.026951855,
-0.0136636738,
0.0028884071,
-0.0554453842,
0.0158756189,
0.0514867269,
-0.0342412442,
0.0127928788,
-0.0033246139,
-0.0265389718,
0.0478388667,
0.0191644449,
0.0719586015,
-0.0106577212,
0.0519523732,
0.0496293344,
0.0514367521,
0.0849441141,
0.0038774277,
0.0491658561,
-0.0407064892,
0.0031972316,
0.0500879921,
0.0641245693,
-0.0314290635,
0.0070518106,
0.0298732687,
0.0016902388,
0.054914467,
-0.0600147247,
0.0593288578,
-0.0075391131,
0.0022944831,
0.07085298,
-0.0403990149,
0.0065663233,
0.0027110716,
-0.0555946939,
0.041084446,
0.015864918,
0.0310677141,
0.0588301718,
0.0422077589,
0.1000955179,
0.0058317664,
-0.0252987556,
-0.0125493454,
0.0017910508,
-0.0049738372,
-0.0611278899,
0.0099683693,
0.0297446381,
0.0449088328,
0.0091810077,
-0.0192975383,
-0.0635077283,
0.064873457,
-0.0202307124,
-0.0420311391,
-0.0344780311,
-0.0077944971,
0.0440225266,
-0.0054798699,
-0.0685585737,
0.0006316875,
0.0232306812,
0.0101617333,
-0.0061482294,
-0.0854149908,
-0.0552223511,
0.0102391746,
0.0548738949,
0.0352192074,
-0.0119254431,
-0.0222449861,
-0.0064091654,
0.0024407867,
-0.0301628038,
-0.043784935,
-0.0198011324,
-0.0231219996,
0.0188978519,
-0.0061653238,
0.000468661,
-0.023824105,
0.0504167601,
0.0043942183,
0.0219232198,
0.012879245,
0.0328962803,
0.018317258,
-0.0250997432,
0.0344142094,
-0.0204165131,
0.0659766942,
-0.0439361893,
-0.0579263903,
-0.0558155179,
-0.0042557423,
-0.0163078867,
0.0500364862,
-0.030405581,
-0.0262630787,
0.0334940478,
0.014576111,
0.0061136717,
-0.033028014,
-0.0113609098,
-0.0393044353,
0.0454231501,
-0.0589445978,
-0.029838765,
0.1128430739,
0.0251431242,
-0.0144807268,
0.0085645895,
-0.0058261808,
-0.0066957911,
0.0637276843,
-0.0285043493,
0.0289341155,
-0.0319545493,
0.0022451701,
-0.0193616003,
0.0209210124,
-0.0150998849,
0.0775960609,
0.0024878376,
-0.0320298932,
-0.0377644859,
-0.0537922829,
0.0177217145,
0.0264839977,
0.0600527748,
0.0068677524,
-0.0126905972,
0.0016865568,
-0.005739776,
-0.0165383592,
-0.0025203372,
0.0388889834,
0.0047376803,
-0.0228720959,
0.0130245304,
0.0173429139,
0.0147632128,
-0.0347911939,
-0.0223551411,
-0.0128164794,
0.0115932962,
0.016548153,
-0.0181914028,
0.0657953918,
-0.0025033813,
0.0311414283,
0.0275443178,
0.0423443317,
0.0258514155,
0.0199942347,
-0.0161609296,
-0.0023386448,
0.0092856353,
0.0517243631,
-0.0761104971,
-0.0106937215,
-0.0373954922,
0.0488403253,
-0.0027324618,
0.0320587941,
-0.0076297368,
-0.0562069006,
-0.0182103124,
-0.0144159561,
-0.0239765476,
0.0184468012,
0.0090458589,
0.0122740502,
0.005286823,
-0.0104080038,
-0.0330467522,
-0.0322398916,
0.0610248893,
-0.0431581661,
-0.0191687364,
-0.0045641013,
-0.0459301472,
0.0049232673,
-0.0038959617,
-0.0023686909,
0.004458698,
0.0418796726,
0.0092606619,
-0.0215845443,
-0.0512670502,
0.0784499198,
0.0668493435,
0.0555104725,
0.0252242368,
-0.0014100869,
-0.0088701211,
0.007305325,
-0.0221625958,
0.0050732349,
0.0089294314,
0.0004936832,
-0.0084898481,
0.0119811222,
-0.0356353819,
0.0287942495,
-0.0615673698,
0.0315373316,
0.0284731295,
0.0785495862,
-0.0085838446,
-0.0502093434,
0.0017257209,
0.0494486429,
-0.0209809672,
0.0338767692,
-0.0136193335,
-0.0038089149,
0.0695921183,
-0.0601242781,
-0.0119180223,
-0.0177813601,
-0.0739885941,
-0.000594515,
0.0157654881,
-0.0001203638,
-0.0267437119,
-0.0306197144,
0.0084375832,
0.0175897069,
-0.0004460978,
-0.0193877574,
-0.0266300365,
0.0002901279,
0.0399296619,
0.0198562723,
-0.0121653127,
-0.0017417304,
-0.0284054764,
-0.0387663729,
0.0706046149,
0.0291937254,
-0.0538583584,
-0.0287447218,
-0.0427274108,
-0.0184896085,
-0.024063604,
-0.021068247,
0.0373051837,
-0.0178105384,
0.0130376294,
-0.0208745021,
0.0362056382,
0.0178569816,
0.0135756312,
0.0525154099,
0.0244587343,
-0.0574017055,
-0.0222792644,
-0.0410048068,
0.037210539,
0.0048369695,
-0.0191401914,
0.0546354912,
0.0314711258,
-0.0578786731,
-0.0009398866,
0.0084838094,
-0.0234130025,
-0.0091453623,
-0.0197225269,
-0.0146148074,
0.007028338,
0.0174149908,
0.057590235,
0.0365612507,
-0.0185214076,
0.0284991283,
-0.0194917098,
0.0058614737,
-0.0604748614,
-0.0124845011,
-0.0210275054,
0.0210846383,
-0.0011653875,
0.0044943891,
0.0647270605,
-0.0062063658,
0.0124784857,
-0.0005094361,
0.025128277,
-0.0198988337,
-0.0507930219,
-0.0213878099,
0.0146585871,
0.0047580847,
0.0497445725,
0.028062759,
-0.022953365,
0.0096314372,
0.0546174645,
-0.0172361694,
-0.0005205531,
-0.0454845801,
0.0385654755,
0.0667995512,
0.0377138779,
-0.0622068755,
-0.0347966887,
-0.0063485401,
0.0505073071,
0.0654975921,
-0.0689310282,
-0.0105337622,
0.000569239,
-0.0297685303,
0.0224452019,
-0.0293363556,
0.0067501776,
-0.0172608253,
-0.0205203816,
0.0224466827,
-0.1319508404,
-0.0518816933,
0.0195999686,
-0.0257571097,
-0.0437855236,
0.0186156984,
0.0702726617,
0.0483945981,
-0.0300266575,
-0.0321964286,
-0.0121995276,
0.0027224855,
0.0263936408,
0.0034458984,
-0.0134376874,
0.0075564799,
0.0064041526,
-0.0086673517,
-0.029434301,
-0.0315559022,
0.0181649122,
-0.0058111735,
0.0004962905,
-0.0206074119,
-0.0084841261,
0.0237140656,
-0.066851601,
-0.0296078101,
0.02080415,
-0.0472955368,
-0.0352476314,
-0.0060590114,
0.0110490965,
0.0514619164,
-0.0329621918,
-0.0408974253,
0.0050181029,
-0.010749056,
0.059258204,
-0.0081357863,
0.0117772501,
-0.0718040094,
-0.0124604516,
0.061933469,
0.0464744978,
-0.0213588588,
-0.0254206657,
0.0651987568,
-0.0184075776,
0.0561483614,
0.0111983735,
-0.0149801839,
-0.0189144481,
-0.0268147402,
0.0159510281,
0.0692849383,
-0.016411297,
0.0013705259,
-0.0574760064,
-0.0089788903,
-0.0316696987,
0.0326004326,
-0.0116301589,
-0.0408565477,
-0.0257186089,
-0.0101428125,
0.0195480771,
0.0569781214,
-0.014547985,
-0.0072346916,
-0.0499307141,
-0.1036391854,
-0.0507728606,
-0.0363139287,
0.0104715526,
-0.0002489754,
0.0194435287,
0.0555316545,
0.0195343569,
-0.0127568701,
-0.0860186517,
0.0258874279,
-0.0168401878,
-0.0086055221,
0.0201426484,
-0.0329382047,
0.1114050448,
0.0091959182,
-0.0364764147,
-0.0054644574,
0.0133959418,
-0.0432909019,
-0.0053845854,
-0.0043477491,
0.0188500248,
0.0093498621,
-0.0189815406,
-0.0590281524,
-0.0118561611,
0.030378744,
-0.0399074405,
-0.0127487676,
0.0076896558,
-0.0665332898,
-0.0378202833,
-0.0386255942,
-0.0421427377,
0.0583658032,
0.0043649944,
-0.0326946899,
-0.0435996838,
0.0031537858,
0.0016287164,
0.015451489,
0.0685627386,
-0.0548962317,
-0.0352472328,
0.0160262045,
-0.0261955615,
0.0218319613,
-0.020691717,
0.0396632552,
-0.0297094584,
0.0133247403,
0.0020372767,
-0.0248035062,
0.0718515739,
-0.0135202799,
0.0560623147,
0.0055800658,
-0.0029024335,
-0.0706842244,
0.0700740889,
-0.0291980747,
-0.0018378817,
-0.0339017324,
-0.0641922951,
0.0083968695,
0.0111131091,
-0.0185012612,
0.0223928411,
0.0329260454,
0.0412170701,
0.0009459514,
0.0029484287,
-0.1169610992,
0.026907742,
-0.0116634285,
0.0072467728,
-0.0079933517,
0.0044222088,
0.0118341455,
-0.0368490256,
-0.0642089471,
-0.0421780013,
0.0381907336,
0.0389035009,
0.0148399612,
0.0206921119,
0.0158492792,
-0.0668493137,
-0.0109180743,
0.0593193956,
0.0464339741,
-0.0071001281,
0.0186728556,
-0.0514297001,
-0.0048256926,
-0.0165082868,
0.0051099812,
0.036356587,
-0.0133961122,
-0.0044414443,
-0.0299097337,
0.0249109697,
0.0365149863,
-0.0175759159,
0.0052779554,
-0.0220263787,
0.0233364832,
0.0470214076,
0.0050766314,
-0.0094679464,
-0.0449447222,
0.0327965282,
-0.0142504256,
-0.0181221347,
0.0047545135,
-5.349730259e-33,
-0.008091419,
-0.0513194278,
-0.0087792128,
0.0707352459,
0.0004088898,
0.0143700242,
-0.0137447072,
-0.0155133763,
0.0002453682,
0.0123121161,
-0.0216529779,
0.0258622766,
-0.0054910518,
-0.0093573369,
0.081168212,
-0.0188060589,
0.0159229711,
0.0251955241,
-0.024162503,
0.0396719575,
0.0089781377,
0.001015375,
0.0221079085,
-0.0545651801,
0.0672366992,
-0.0015394833,
-0.0054740342,
-0.0754295886,
0.0426001176,
0.059892267,
-0.0458388552,
0.0144330487,
0.0276531242,
-0.0747714937,
0.0279783905,
0.0132023515,
-0.0816128328,
-0.0002231259,
-0.0051043937,
0.0130272238,
0.0653720275,
-0.0587077364,
0.0056198332,
0.0073390161,
-0.0212882701,
0.0007670383,
0.11415378,
0.0055903085,
-0.0798451826,
-0.1024370864,
-0.0243651494,
0.0241739433,
-0.0229153465,
0.0618919507,
0.0616166964,
0.0219161306,
0.0115895942,
0.1299358606,
-0.032013882,
0.0342308916,
-0.0010380726,
0.0264548603,
0.0099106617,
-0.0046325736,
0.0317388102,
0.030258609,
-0.0157174468,
0.0374098569,
0.0656066239,
-0.024660781,
0.0113919917,
-0.0350968167,
0.0219191611,
0.0048503266,
0.0644487441,
-0.0247445405,
-0.0472247787,
0.0469129533,
-0.0180160757,
-0.0287758037,
-0.0036768469,
-0.008117063,
-0.004227954,
-0.0115761226,
0.0099751642,
-0.0086625181,
-0.0079826098,
-0.0020009254,
-0.0137479044,
-0.0249104537,
-0.0245426539,
0.0462790169,
-0.0104730241,
-0.0332976207,
-0.0678189248,
0.0000289262,
-0.0123128351,
0.0725187659,
-0.0120786969,
-0.0005816607,
-0.0530786403,
-0.0594784692,
0.0130479168,
-0.0110850511,
0.0283927973,
-0.0301986188,
0.0685598478,
-0.0190433078,
-0.0574876368,
-0.0122440811,
0.0343431234,
-0.0217986312,
-0.007799814,
0.0092958221,
-0.0008034335,
0.0309579335,
0.0336820781,
0.0149654727,
0.063376449,
0.0370909646,
0.0014495678,
-0.0364790857,
-0.0173842162,
0.0092294076,
0.0115935681,
-0.0068029226,
-0.0115734516,
0.0135589652,
0.0141860871,
-0.0137557592,
0.0074854949,
-0.0299398191,
2.327e-7,
0.0652709156,
0.0690611899,
-0.0145228747,
-0.0515951589,
0.0200594831,
0.0469688848,
0.0004746453,
0.0126622096,
-0.0206790045,
-0.0184652545,
0.0027639931,
-0.0509518795,
0.0301029012,
0.0149869286,
-0.0418771915,
-0.0586710349,
-0.0178896599,
-0.0050157472,
-0.0476742536,
0.0108577004,
-0.0119821802,
0.0144188516,
-0.0100312801,
0.0192846376,
-0.0460837223,
-0.0020945417,
0.0466833264,
-0.0627144948,
0.0262198877,
0.0711369589,
0.0217300523,
0.0269250702,
0.0031453362,
0.0100252777,
-0.0504081734,
0.0019521575,
-0.007248959,
0.0207216628,
-0.0315592177,
0.0097080525,
0.0036074361,
-0.0214080065,
0.0400279574,
-0.0321335867,
0.0202495027,
-0.0041739079,
-0.0375592001,
-0.0159669966,
-0.0418901071,
-0.007283079,
0.0536928847,
-0.0239329226,
-0.0089261718,
0.02989625,
-0.0276502054,
-0.0236339793,
-0.0140844993,
-0.0864307731,
0.0044522532,
0.0670232698,
-0.0272658188,
-0.0258042477,
-0.0068041845,
-0.023595497,
0.0641173273,
-0.0628030673,
0.0164770242,
1.947944979e-34,
0.0603280813,
-0.0092664473,
-0.0377953127,
0.0389736108,
-0.0165733416,
-0.0047149169,
-0.0310657211,
0.014756049,
-0.0020192454,
-0.0535567589,
0.036993444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03338v1 | Learning Manner of Execution from Partial Corrections | 2023-02-07T09:25:58 | 2023-02-07T09:25:58 | Mattias Appelgren, Alex Lascarides | cs.CL | cs.CL | Some actions must be executed in different ways depending on the context. For
example, wiping away marker requires vigorous force while wiping away almonds
requires more gentle force. In this paper we provide a model where an agent
learns which manner of action execution to use in which context, drawing on
evidence from trial and error and verbal corrections when it makes a mistake
(e.g., ``no, gently''). The learner starts out with a domain model that lacks
the concepts denoted by the words in the teacher's feedback; both the words
describing the context (e.g., marker) and the adverbs like ``gently''. We show
that through the the semantics of coherence, our agent can perform the symbol
grounding that's necessary for exploiting the teacher's feedback so as to solve
its domain-level planning problem: to perform its actions in the current
context in the right way. | [
0.0428103097,
-0.0247536153,
-0.0290687215,
-0.0051704599,
-0.0570191666,
-0.0161434021,
-0.0385617539,
-0.031534858,
0.0075232415,
-0.0294799004,
-0.0102164047,
-0.0073651001,
-0.0205044094,
-0.0061362088,
0.0007293455,
-0.0516737327,
0.0840683728,
-0.015184395,
0.0009135824,
-0.0120674707,
-0.028967645,
-0.0808885992,
-0.0192984324,
0.0324801728,
-0.0287462454,
-0.0350821353,
-0.096852392,
-0.0074989987,
-0.0146330697,
-0.0442494638,
-0.0120818336,
0.0100311385,
0.0315285176,
0.0048843282,
0.0000019745,
-0.0394407548,
-0.0006617705,
-0.0466128029,
0.0005337841,
-0.0261099972,
-0.0202775449,
-0.0254387241,
-0.0099032698,
-0.0150242224,
-0.074326463,
0.0444200151,
0.0509039164,
0.0386197791,
0.0386019982,
0.0581799299,
0.0228722692,
-0.0020648781,
0.0014124869,
0.0137639428,
0.0249152519,
-0.0595186949,
0.003972997,
0.0281026196,
0.023880003,
-0.0020489572,
-0.0822946355,
-0.0252244696,
0.0215622913,
-0.0181108415,
-0.0708841607,
0.0391296037,
0.0445688069,
-0.0374672823,
-0.0138084218,
-0.0212572608,
0.0429436527,
0.0058708098,
0.0329532139,
-0.0082111163,
0.0149964225,
0.0087230019,
0.0052677798,
-0.0098493453,
0.0030176719,
0.0287676156,
0.0176316742,
-0.0248255376,
-0.0052632806,
0.0329910889,
0.0341187418,
0.0949957296,
-0.0673436001,
-0.038654089,
-0.0023646825,
0.0047435486,
-0.0135491444,
-0.0550015084,
-0.0143511677,
0.0643634126,
-0.0559795052,
0.0135574397,
-0.0573665611,
0.0229186639,
0.0086160861,
-0.0355730318,
0.0067948392,
0.0368962623,
0.012320729,
0.0380030088,
-0.0093025919,
0.0456318632,
-0.011776669,
0.062337365,
-0.0258504432,
0.0318128839,
-0.0515784994,
-0.0020939563,
-0.0478639901,
0.0726545602,
0.0075528231,
-0.002991735,
-0.0538937449,
0.0106086526,
-0.0685419217,
0.0196813885,
-0.0632277876,
0.0072776098,
-0.0488172993,
-0.0107082967,
-0.0835148916,
-0.038760338,
-0.0444944687,
0.060997583,
0.0246156715,
0.0377574861,
-0.0181257054,
-0.0311755724,
-0.0107319141,
0.0237707347,
-0.0128146317,
0.0906090513,
0.0064432202,
0.0061435504,
-0.0606055148,
-0.0588872433,
0.0102847917,
-0.0278657842,
0.0049526431,
-0.0306548793,
-0.0420606993,
-0.0124347564,
-0.0267350227,
-0.074168168,
0.0030598161,
-0.0189270489,
0.0080994545,
0.046102725,
0.0449579433,
0.0006734567,
-0.0147557054,
0.0028894839,
-0.0710896552,
0.0498464368,
0.0179393888,
0.0398196466,
0.0062904814,
0.0243457071,
0.029865969,
-0.0055385521,
0.0087579703,
-0.0103987623,
0.0139565058,
-0.0418245085,
0.0077956039,
0.0364718251,
0.0307954326,
0.0357481539,
-0.0389887318,
0.0322121643,
0.0067492248,
0.0509879589,
0.0028090887,
-0.0366440974,
0.0585417859,
-0.0034845069,
-0.0182095803,
0.0715979859,
-0.0532570891,
-0.0024988772,
-0.034482751,
0.0348159261,
-0.0697474107,
-0.02093683,
-0.0320239253,
-0.064614132,
0.0138669349,
-0.0034118716,
0.0480657965,
-0.029496571,
0.0362921804,
0.0408475921,
-0.0369574167,
-0.0284680258,
0.0136540942,
0.0039829602,
-0.00404398,
-0.05549144,
0.0330738164,
0.0256984495,
-0.0143471714,
-0.0633786991,
-0.0342544019,
0.008963462,
0.0462779328,
0.0232893806,
0.0052593448,
-0.0289860945,
-0.0112207597,
-0.0156250745,
-0.0285527185,
-0.0091504827,
0.037087068,
0.0254156888,
-0.0373200886,
-0.0079251993,
-0.0212408695,
0.0570450947,
0.0275078099,
0.0519680344,
0.0272733457,
-0.0490438677,
-0.0243666321,
0.0168065205,
0.0225334261,
0.0172311608,
0.0065040924,
0.0228952374,
0.0336893015,
0.0408762284,
-0.0172218047,
0.020350812,
-0.0507637858,
0.0181236155,
0.0439522304,
-0.0165875126,
-0.0157212317,
-0.0113181965,
-0.0024398421,
-0.0488301069,
0.0441232882,
0.0066408212,
0.0691649243,
0.0003493821,
0.0515619703,
-0.0098553682,
-0.0641766265,
-0.0099942079,
0.0556929298,
0.0067657358,
-0.0043194699,
0.0119404979,
0.0531795137,
-0.0120608527,
-0.0207251664,
0.0063354187,
0.014368305,
-0.0161472224,
0.0449363664,
0.0181139279,
0.0373275429,
-0.0308112502,
-0.0208412167,
-0.0203401409,
-0.0290463641,
0.0056243455,
-0.0104113277,
0.0009909178,
-0.0333376005,
0.0198081862,
-0.024689896,
0.0468166806,
0.0786787719,
0.0200186167,
0.0121299159,
0.0155795729,
0.0089602675,
-0.0405143574,
-0.0428019948,
-0.0023191173,
-0.0337522998,
-0.0267782155,
-0.0131123299,
-0.0138608227,
-0.0386186913,
0.0715810359,
-0.0000256364,
0.0524602421,
-0.0179968532,
-0.036060296,
0.0545971096,
-0.0001267786,
-0.0269917604,
0.0609079339,
-0.0273354705,
0.0688890219,
0.0808074251,
0.0046521942,
-0.0451266393,
0.0120847467,
-0.0214627422,
-0.0059437579,
-0.0264095645,
0.0228055604,
-0.0131677371,
0.0779351816,
0.0236207079,
0.0221744366,
-0.0391809903,
-0.0111558149,
-0.0445055589,
-0.0387363583,
-0.0181121454,
-0.0696825385,
-0.0329461657,
0.0413867682,
-0.0262091327,
-0.0330909118,
0.0806610435,
0.0436783582,
0.0160009358,
0.0119198784,
0.0000945386,
0.014380632,
0.0683553368,
-0.0131609933,
0.0033139319,
0.0278562382,
-0.0306596495,
-0.0554317906,
-0.0448822379,
0.0691099167,
0.01967193,
0.0495328307,
-0.0855067819,
-0.0180315822,
0.0017373179,
-0.0455395244,
-0.0600247979,
0.0030767233,
-0.0221789889,
0.0457447432,
-0.0091300337,
0.0003203792,
-0.0168213453,
-0.0151374741,
0.011915735,
0.0087154396,
0.0035496128,
-0.032041721,
-0.043637488,
-0.0693344995,
0.0230330508,
0.0519876406,
-0.0255701151,
0.0093660876,
0.0272356644,
0.046976082,
0.0369557738,
-0.0244043339,
-0.0288199075,
0.0335758403,
-0.0004818609,
-0.0198624413,
-0.0261038728,
0.0509700365,
0.0329421759,
-0.0082832277,
-0.0531271659,
0.0496650226,
0.0230939332,
0.0259123072,
0.0407649763,
-0.0608336926,
-0.0225788653,
0.0261790007,
0.0257570967,
-0.0452625006,
-0.029555779,
-0.0019774223,
0.0068868832,
-0.0042712614,
-0.0258648377,
0.04969877,
-0.0649165437,
0.0283561442,
0.0091052782,
-0.0190397035,
-0.0313221775,
-0.0038892999,
-0.0057490054,
0.0126179485,
-0.0080566835,
0.0164632462,
0.0174705256,
-0.0005841108,
0.0645309538,
0.07787285,
-0.0346705578,
-0.0511042848,
-0.0397718213,
0.0236008875,
0.0778390318,
0.0066479808,
-0.0217533596,
-0.004234348,
0.0243682973,
0.0313864239,
0.0393454805,
-0.0279117692,
-0.0404204056,
0.0210682731,
0.0138474824,
-0.001577442,
0.0334998965,
-0.0094269803,
-0.0879160613,
0.0429855175,
0.075124234,
-0.04384562,
0.0025861084,
-0.0270899814,
-0.006363974,
0.0109995324,
0.0202066917,
-0.0061621736,
-0.0067587281,
-0.0321101211,
-0.0446259268,
-0.0240231697,
0.0313327275,
-0.0479684137,
-0.038207829,
-0.0349382944,
0.0084214797,
-0.0647296757,
-0.0630440414,
0.0531143062,
0.0663945675,
0.0523739234,
-0.0319330879,
0.0276383013,
-0.0007717298,
0.0045641325,
-0.0555323958,
0.0279971864,
0.0134399198,
-0.0551332422,
-0.0219130497,
0.0206651818,
-0.0241794121,
-0.0094141066,
-0.0309332814,
0.0409792848,
-0.0817524716,
0.0645198897,
0.073398307,
0.0311671961,
0.0065918854,
-0.026903253,
0.0174902808,
0.005660193,
0.0188092366,
-0.0170079377,
0.051940009,
0.0584515482,
-0.033232484,
0.007925991,
0.0401964858,
-0.0322496295,
0.0108507387,
0.0215076786,
0.0527824461,
-0.0389473401,
-0.004730782,
0.0583786629,
-0.03465949,
0.0614312738,
-0.0087282164,
-0.0123198554,
-0.0280319117,
0.0055383965,
0.0327059627,
-0.0471290462,
-0.0224085059,
0.0134914843,
-0.0266651399,
0.0134267183,
0.0247673448,
-0.0370982029,
-0.0083327079,
0.0087059839,
0.0242072027,
0.0039043101,
0.0535767376,
0.022651799,
-0.0241838787,
0.0478413664,
-0.0017607671,
0.0237331707,
0.0015159647,
0.0353489332,
0.0170702077,
0.0533910803,
0.0380644388,
0.0294535011,
-0.0606171452,
-0.0279468447,
-0.0785690993,
-0.0375036299,
0.0210380089,
0.0177065786,
0.0469423831,
-0.0568132028,
-0.0143468538,
-0.0973857343,
0.0227699634,
0.0202119518,
0.042592153,
0.0168444011,
-0.0344843008,
0.0302632134,
0.0557135269,
0.0331496522,
-0.0231721457,
0.0530036688,
-0.0836764723,
0.0953426138,
-0.0160108581,
-0.011038634,
-0.0188810471,
-0.0298475605,
0.0758922547,
0.0153607987,
-0.0003983253,
-0.0112233786,
-0.0677607507,
-0.018770922,
-0.0358639546,
0.0554756373,
0.0347773172,
-0.0474854633,
0.0264995843,
0.0135851381,
0.0138901528,
-0.0391353406,
-0.0337425321,
-0.0075475858,
0.0207496732,
0.0178303178,
-0.0591784902,
-5.409504882e-33,
-0.0689121634,
-0.0070662238,
0.0370499752,
0.0112723494,
0.0145132989,
-0.005285589,
-0.001269359,
0.0327261165,
-0.0153991161,
0.0536957495,
-0.0244987365,
0.0176323727,
0.0197014324,
-0.0506378114,
0.0794267356,
-0.0204101298,
0.0132387821,
-0.0044805221,
-0.0268012509,
-0.0602934472,
0.0124820238,
-0.0040815831,
0.0218020752,
-0.0498764589,
0.0161075816,
-0.0061180145,
-0.0419657268,
0.0213509072,
-0.0227784216,
0.0445433632,
0.0234506205,
-0.0185773224,
-0.0100617511,
-0.0207756292,
-0.0370860249,
-0.0088889403,
-0.038386818,
-0.0869650021,
0.0165749248,
0.004488539,
-0.0286806319,
-0.0211893599,
0.0037751494,
0.0065810564,
-0.0294019915,
0.0576397404,
0.010595304,
0.0197076742,
-0.0018084575,
0.0253345184,
-0.1042810678,
-0.0250642262,
-0.0090821357,
-0.076019004,
0.0086665237,
-0.0339832306,
-0.0222474467,
-0.0840659663,
-0.0423863381,
0.0434677675,
0.0341005214,
0.001079404,
0.0178929549,
0.0300650261,
0.0036300577,
0.0667667985,
0.02811791,
0.0336333662,
0.0374763533,
-0.0045429319,
-0.0119720064,
0.0637420639,
-0.0323313922,
0.0126847699,
0.0524366498,
-0.0081720995,
-0.0106824581,
0.0239994563,
-0.0135641946,
0.0942651108,
-0.0176354945,
0.0397275016,
-0.0351640917,
-0.0157434642,
-0.0055142832,
0.0245244578,
0.0050917123,
-0.0325407907,
-0.0017428141,
-0.0025548784,
-0.010492987,
-0.027216075,
-0.022251755,
0.0060575171,
-0.0043288576,
-0.0448101126,
-0.0168917775,
0.0320740677,
-0.0146868778,
-0.0073059788,
-0.0305905789,
-0.0755833834,
-0.0329920128,
-0.002773403,
0.0092216479,
0.0603811294,
-0.0062470729,
0.0620194487,
-0.0047712899,
-0.0072901142,
-0.0148779284,
-0.034421593,
0.033866588,
-0.0959057063,
0.026110217,
0.0114582274,
-0.0343672149,
0.0128635233,
-0.0124858199,
-0.0837293938,
-0.0267733485,
0.0355509147,
-0.0011108912,
0.0524469726,
0.0074246158,
-0.0259582121,
-0.0243137889,
0.0427417383,
-0.0044164313,
-0.0316597745,
0.0018136294,
0.0493571535,
2.891e-7,
-0.0214926936,
-0.0122948764,
0.0149023412,
0.0356261246,
-0.0198492333,
0.0604355447,
-0.0610274449,
0.0055178865,
-0.0036467286,
-0.0270097796,
0.0479862243,
0.0195687432,
-0.0484542623,
-0.0092509678,
-0.0333912037,
0.0221319553,
0.0474485755,
-0.0479971953,
0.0063410336,
0.0008361331,
0.0011729635,
0.0253129974,
0.0201728661,
0.0060318108,
-0.0038352767,
-0.0029213051,
0.024714062,
-0.0081803296,
0.0649237037,
-0.0117173679,
-0.0102842981,
-0.0452932678,
0.0187509526,
0.0194330942,
0.0155937616,
-0.0237624813,
-0.0276628677,
0.0367578939,
-0.0383605026,
0.0555301197,
-0.0164626949,
-0.0153818913,
0.0167385824,
0.0541420989,
0.0206506662,
-0.0356231108,
-0.0084380396,
0.0362030007,
0.0366204679,
0.0024072633,
-0.0332230441,
0.0184319131,
0.0023156153,
-0.0302199777,
-0.0174204763,
0.0318167657,
0.0024741578,
0.0054694638,
0.0114734285,
0.0187905915,
-0.0004323771,
-0.0437752679,
0.0456623137,
0.043189425,
-0.0038275295,
-0.0688049644,
-0.0306364819,
2.084720405e-34,
-0.0000252583,
-0.0058293585,
0.0630848631,
0.0462410152,
0.005949514,
0.0114819221,
0.0116195977,
0.0543113239,
0.0724428371,
0.0366073921,
-0.0506852232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03297v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03297v1 | AutoWS: Automated Weak Supervision Framework for Text Classification | 2023-02-07T07:12:05 | 2023-02-07T07:12:05 | Abhinav Bohra, Huy Nguyen, Devashish Khatwani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating large, good quality labeled data has become one of the major
bottlenecks for developing machine learning applications. Multiple techniques
have been developed to either decrease the dependence of labeled data
(zero/few-shot learning, weak supervision) or to improve the efficiency of
labeling process (active learning). Among those, Weak Supervision has been
shown to reduce labeling costs by employing hand crafted labeling functions
designed by domain experts. We propose AutoWS -- a novel framework for
increasing the efficiency of weak supervision process while decreasing the
dependency on domain experts. Our method requires a small set of labeled
examples per label class and automatically creates a set of labeling functions
to assign noisy labels to numerous unlabeled data. Noisy labels can then be
aggregated into probabilistic labels used by a downstream discriminative
classifier. Our framework is fully automatic and requires no hyper-parameter
specification by users. We compare our approach with different state-of-the-art
work on weak supervision and noisy training. Experimental results show that our
method outperforms competitive baselines. | [
0.0302965119,
0.0195392165,
0.0358926132,
-0.0161051843,
0.0078384904,
0.0438016169,
0.0606002025,
-0.0095083285,
0.0533571988,
-0.0558426566,
-0.0495647714,
-0.0169597249,
-0.0237223785,
0.0029684978,
0.0138839493,
-0.0313919447,
0.0005493786,
-0.0245977566,
0.0602635518,
0.0094391014,
-0.0011219274,
-0.0023958359,
-0.0197090246,
-0.0125623802,
-0.062931031,
-0.0033008475,
0.0231382083,
-0.024133198,
-0.0028847933,
-0.013391627,
0.0554114394,
0.050466001,
-0.0265908707,
0.0255976394,
0.0000019908,
-0.0507368371,
-0.0189203527,
0.006743825,
-0.000545633,
0.0194485635,
0.0265278444,
-0.0321400203,
0.0216993392,
-0.017098438,
-0.0099925827,
-0.0581937283,
0.0426902734,
0.0877176151,
0.0471860617,
0.0300201196,
-0.029885374,
-0.0166175049,
-0.0180305671,
-0.0304657351,
0.0438437872,
-0.0894053057,
0.0476656221,
-0.0317294002,
-0.0515586399,
0.0280374605,
0.0193882324,
0.0319415964,
-0.0029153309,
-0.0322592147,
0.034319751,
0.0251835398,
-0.0285048448,
-0.0336662047,
0.0067574163,
0.079248704,
0.0213388521,
-0.0409179106,
0.0155161191,
-0.0497852601,
0.0131308436,
-0.0050911233,
0.0017969894,
0.0207383092,
-0.0109736798,
0.0028522757,
-0.032691624,
0.0656367317,
0.0018170567,
0.0418939702,
0.0478760898,
0.019715881,
-0.0357652642,
-0.0214716885,
0.0529696085,
0.0394749977,
-0.0497370288,
-0.0049311793,
-0.0083092004,
0.0156339407,
-0.0136344032,
0.0110749425,
-0.0615820624,
-0.0500554442,
0.0206064209,
-0.0499925949,
-0.023195006,
-0.0464510657,
-0.0282647237,
0.08238253,
0.0030196148,
-0.0516594648,
0.0353307463,
0.0123664765,
-0.0129388263,
-0.0056611574,
-0.0596124977,
-0.0046486645,
-0.0309385192,
0.0658195764,
0.0067725847,
-0.0001449499,
-0.0576574765,
-0.0019762411,
-0.033214435,
-0.0015703129,
0.0028954216,
0.0474304743,
-0.0305935033,
0.0290582888,
0.0104771666,
-0.0111743128,
-0.0216659047,
0.0343958549,
-0.0335781537,
0.012767273,
-0.0013953465,
0.0479632504,
0.0305404663,
0.0004709734,
0.0132744545,
0.0799954534,
-0.0227162931,
-0.0500153303,
-0.0771692395,
-0.0329721682,
-0.0540171526,
-0.0064191036,
-0.0214835089,
-0.0352253057,
-0.015295947,
-0.0030470856,
-0.0123478146,
-0.0516932122,
0.0067742639,
0.00030473,
-0.0498421341,
0.0839225128,
-0.058010269,
-0.0207428597,
0.0526113659,
0.0128897093,
-0.0042613973,
0.0492830724,
-0.0164998677,
0.0398303382,
0.0504843891,
0.0296558253,
0.0498440526,
-0.0088072205,
0.0296607912,
0.0427691638,
0.001529639,
-0.0237854645,
-0.0010108099,
-0.0109681459,
-0.0133883683,
0.0242428463,
0.0044131903,
0.0207195282,
0.0271979067,
-0.0177638587,
-0.0257399082,
0.0009996311,
0.0205452833,
0.023669675,
0.0252919942,
-0.0412275158,
-0.0212087426,
-0.0044746855,
-0.032884825,
-0.0198731888,
-0.024118619,
-0.0537300184,
-0.046807833,
-0.0598315559,
-0.0118139265,
-0.0452281758,
-0.0276215933,
0.0164330769,
0.0696232021,
0.0384618789,
0.0097981421,
0.0160289556,
0.0452071503,
-0.0193157382,
-0.0267360061,
-0.0325836837,
0.0223698523,
0.0283839833,
-0.0049440423,
-0.0696529523,
-0.0100692706,
-0.0328947417,
0.1170913056,
0.0135214832,
0.0392547809,
-0.0122974124,
0.0336088277,
-0.0504557751,
-0.0776806027,
0.0253122691,
0.0350978188,
0.0251432303,
-0.0005355767,
0.0024327303,
0.0462514535,
-0.0278463028,
-0.0577243119,
0.0467465967,
0.0283285864,
-0.081617631,
0.0668129548,
0.0170928314,
-0.0029483731,
0.0077070529,
-0.0151589187,
-0.0063326368,
0.0167181864,
-0.0098406589,
-0.0170330014,
-0.055203639,
-0.009305397,
0.0155244255,
0.0153456964,
-0.0292438827,
-0.0428128392,
-0.0297555644,
-0.0269168559,
-0.0545310676,
-0.042876184,
-0.0202444028,
-0.0531094968,
-0.0392597429,
-0.0173246861,
0.0001847941,
-0.0062570269,
-0.0585468262,
0.0842482671,
0.0506549552,
0.0287371669,
0.0161120668,
-0.0204635784,
0.0229580086,
0.0271930415,
-0.0227310751,
-0.0618559644,
-0.0294024218,
0.0362465866,
0.0397204719,
0.0485327877,
-0.0383283123,
-0.0016288406,
-0.0199546572,
-0.0240553524,
-0.0160677619,
-0.0227177907,
-0.0130810682,
-0.0047734976,
0.0073803677,
-0.0207232926,
-0.0317767859,
0.0039337887,
-0.042327784,
0.0148997521,
0.0193145256,
0.010405845,
0.0228967853,
-0.0006295256,
0.023628952,
-0.0137985889,
0.0146070514,
0.0401998647,
-0.0657439008,
-0.0408528559,
0.0495359823,
0.0001746162,
0.0226701349,
0.0265109893,
-0.009985039,
-0.0065604988,
-0.0097532803,
-0.0086613614,
0.0061928155,
-0.0387223549,
0.0353826359,
0.0155323269,
0.0210578982,
-0.0441283733,
0.0110301757,
-0.0234549977,
0.0002340454,
0.0149952713,
0.0066144997,
0.0044007138,
0.0539904945,
0.0017254279,
-0.0162557792,
-0.0461251661,
0.0065207379,
-0.0158333573,
-0.0100928675,
-0.0572136417,
0.0219455324,
-0.0041330857,
0.0125835268,
-0.0127936052,
-0.0564455837,
0.0486351885,
0.0035726835,
-0.0025324768,
-0.0128726158,
-0.0365175121,
-0.0068963985,
0.026051525,
-0.0082204957,
0.0240191612,
0.0485614948,
-0.0150043359,
-0.0165901054,
-0.0280561466,
0.0306384545,
0.0159215108,
-0.0065182764,
-0.0248898305,
0.0428300165,
-0.0107608642,
-0.0142421136,
-0.0481838137,
-0.0390190855,
-0.0230021309,
0.0051662247,
0.0113402987,
-0.0098049138,
-0.0384839363,
0.011815194,
0.0228654258,
0.0423112512,
-0.0094971359,
-0.0402392522,
-0.0013486587,
0.0173317809,
0.0362547636,
-0.0746237189,
-0.0543500148,
-0.0429090336,
0.0059651444,
0.0537534431,
0.0273798108,
0.0247760266,
0.0180062186,
-0.0009745805,
0.0106447171,
0.0119346138,
-0.0015311907,
0.0037437172,
0.0291811116,
-0.0021152592,
-0.0070547247,
0.104449302,
0.0459361039,
-0.063096717,
-0.0248592626,
0.0187976658,
0.0198037252,
0.0422576666,
0.0175345168,
-0.0155521901,
-0.0553856306,
-0.0300624259,
0.0777754337,
-0.0005627104,
-0.0329082273,
0.0054693371,
-0.0785481334,
0.0203724429,
0.0138069242,
-0.0272020977,
0.0246388111,
-0.055026304,
0.0146989059,
-0.0130735692,
-0.0503497534,
-0.0458706133,
0.0208898801,
-0.0136487074,
0.0592320077,
-0.0387454852,
-0.0530943871,
-0.0208870862,
-0.0178853888,
0.0319577418,
0.0043092291,
-0.0013629547,
-0.0156367589,
-0.0311868414,
0.0670837909,
-0.0269392449,
-0.0384140536,
-0.0359118879,
0.0793247819,
-0.0174705219,
-0.027356457,
-0.0005376573,
0.0334424414,
-0.0345274657,
-0.0061383098,
0.0160157494,
0.0543393828,
-0.0226448979,
-0.007759281,
-0.0179779399,
-0.0321945064,
0.0376098529,
0.0588841587,
-0.0022921921,
-0.0808414593,
0.0127080325,
0.007169982,
-0.0089902682,
-0.0060441517,
-0.0394046456,
0.0405387431,
-0.0729628354,
-0.1015974507,
-0.048691161,
-0.0527856052,
0.0726790577,
0.0813723728,
0.0244442318,
-0.0104284333,
-0.0097107524,
0.0019427182,
-0.0363768451,
0.0000683021,
-0.0435439125,
0.0187037382,
-0.0351780988,
-0.0563522056,
0.0682312101,
-0.0042591924,
-0.0068815672,
0.0364528038,
-0.0103809312,
-0.0531703569,
0.0161914472,
0.0451050624,
0.0118651846,
-0.0013262029,
-0.0307133757,
-0.0769215673,
0.051509589,
0.0985746607,
-0.030806791,
-0.0334012248,
0.03719965,
-0.0053972895,
-0.0060436106,
0.0134973451,
-0.0453082137,
0.0525445007,
0.0654521957,
-0.0255751964,
-0.0430767499,
-0.0107163666,
0.0073773912,
-0.0040092384,
0.0837710798,
-0.0363628864,
-0.0022595862,
-0.0083942274,
-0.004338982,
0.0186122227,
-0.0566720814,
-0.0227677375,
0.0437482707,
0.0326510556,
-0.0075711817,
-0.0446651801,
0.037269298,
0.0099236509,
0.0565276109,
0.0050200564,
-0.0097011961,
0.0036951916,
0.0081369299,
-0.0039866073,
-0.0095336623,
-0.0033920333,
0.0192642473,
0.0374479443,
0.0262782965,
0.016003944,
-0.0009672852,
0.0290329251,
0.0338277556,
-0.0444632061,
-0.027071679,
-0.0584957339,
-0.0006917618,
-0.0494340435,
0.0668957382,
0.0153301433,
-0.0427628681,
0.011638768,
-0.028882768,
-0.0273371767,
-0.0115690418,
0.0019408849,
0.0248279031,
0.0183678195,
0.0017615289,
0.0254375916,
-0.0210058633,
0.0306959115,
0.0659692436,
0.0738549307,
0.0177449062,
-0.014630028,
-0.0271802079,
-0.0547878034,
0.0354106985,
0.0666944832,
0.0225414895,
-0.0051032938,
0.0042939563,
0.0024681033,
-0.0460096784,
0.0130522707,
-0.0539138056,
-0.000039511,
0.0323230401,
0.0520781279,
0.0270052087,
-0.0126342596,
0.0092097884,
-0.0221353211,
-0.0290135685,
0.0704947338,
-0.0233284272,
0.0114635946,
-6.428447997e-33,
0.0255045444,
-0.0557846203,
-0.0309731513,
0.008272687,
0.0521017089,
0.0165831205,
0.0257504955,
0.0239250679,
0.0623491704,
0.0607857928,
-0.0007211401,
0.0044538914,
0.0297073945,
0.0331558362,
0.0180944018,
-0.0242120586,
0.0415108651,
-0.0133285671,
0.0071034883,
0.0287137572,
0.0117190927,
0.0285677388,
0.0120873656,
-0.1524328291,
0.0527055785,
-0.0005197821,
-0.0473703183,
0.0209187362,
0.0703108087,
0.0203506742,
0.0130617898,
0.0597628169,
0.0130398488,
-0.0132254614,
0.0208036602,
0.0175886974,
-0.0890515447,
-0.0167541914,
-0.0393555835,
0.0158666074,
-0.0093169231,
-0.0016207581,
0.0231799427,
0.0143598365,
0.0322126746,
0.0186449885,
0.063505128,
-0.0288095232,
-0.0511912704,
-0.078379713,
-0.0077385302,
0.0461442433,
-0.0109336171,
-0.0037423654,
0.0396595076,
-0.0048563951,
-0.0157129858,
-0.0221198965,
-0.0601560362,
-0.0133336922,
0.0012277954,
0.0124541335,
-0.0154243689,
0.041111961,
-0.0309499409,
0.0185765848,
0.0419927351,
0.0233246125,
0.0039853747,
-0.0179944113,
-0.0095448764,
0.0415355526,
0.0254970789,
0.0373247676,
0.0280845314,
-0.0223236158,
-0.0401115865,
0.039362397,
-0.0005454705,
-0.0205265023,
-0.0119018527,
-0.0013788563,
-0.0774340183,
-0.0306446366,
-0.0001615497,
0.0252675079,
-0.04105426,
0.0108597083,
0.0133783789,
0.0401288867,
-0.0901528746,
-0.0004134918,
-0.0209660474,
-0.0283988286,
-0.0426504165,
-0.0313866101,
0.0276244506,
0.0414383151,
-0.0402136855,
-0.0764513537,
-0.0393792242,
-0.0603633411,
0.0301282164,
0.0340615101,
0.0242136735,
-0.0067378073,
0.1002065986,
0.014906303,
-0.0873075351,
-0.0089338822,
0.0167427901,
0.0160106402,
0.0351889953,
0.0293450821,
0.0057310034,
-0.0274842493,
-0.0032138524,
0.0477709025,
0.0392484106,
-0.0050907345,
0.0080155656,
0.0006878201,
-0.0252444409,
-0.0038437783,
-0.0274989977,
-0.0146750491,
0.0087268893,
-0.0068144207,
0.0474029891,
-0.066663973,
0.0139298616,
-0.0100766905,
2.711e-7,
0.0018793655,
0.0561780594,
-0.0248231571,
-0.0320881233,
-0.011680847,
0.076843746,
0.022849828,
-0.0037543303,
-0.0390525013,
-0.0409822129,
0.0307639204,
-0.0152502432,
0.0527195632,
0.0328129455,
-0.1020099744,
-0.0487187058,
-0.0025707283,
0.0211299118,
-0.0181681085,
0.0236895084,
0.0776030049,
0.0925526991,
0.0425992869,
-0.0381893031,
0.0085460767,
-0.0737144724,
0.0289945416,
0.0174105875,
0.0289571937,
0.0285975039,
0.0597628169,
0.0073839566,
-0.0024243221,
0.0279867332,
-0.0499880426,
-0.013086115,
0.0216788128,
0.0499272309,
-0.0234302096,
0.0134423738,
0.0078080869,
0.0173878819,
0.0480802543,
0.0767948329,
0.073404178,
-0.0818568021,
-0.0088639641,
0.0278144144,
0.0316020995,
-0.0371227711,
0.0063351183,
-0.0073890691,
0.0034047016,
-0.0082011158,
0.0036988347,
-0.0072749578,
-0.042216029,
-0.0778560787,
0.0017287441,
-0.0182256494,
0.0077720578,
-0.0025642188,
0.0034158535,
0.0451110005,
0.0361493826,
-0.0426298566,
0.0191376228,
2.166852333e-34,
0.0498697162,
-0.0173323285,
0.0256918836,
-0.0061352514,
-0.0179168675,
0.0123422528,
-0.0302218962,
-0.0067750379,
0.018883504,
-0.0117274979,
0.0161890164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03269v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03269v3 | PLACES: Prompting Language Models for Social Conversation Synthesis | 2023-02-07T05:48:16 | 2023-02-17T04:11:53 | Maximillian Chen, Alexandros Papangelis, Chenyang Tao, Seokhwan Kim, Andy Rosenbaum, Yang Liu, Zhou Yu, Dilek Hakkani-Tur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Collecting high quality conversational data can be very expensive for most
applications and infeasible for others due to privacy, ethical, or similar
concerns. A promising direction to tackle this problem is to generate synthetic
dialogues by prompting large language models. In this work, we use a small set
of expert-written conversations as in-context examples to synthesize a social
conversation dataset using prompting. We perform several thorough evaluations
of our synthetic conversations compared to human-collected conversations. This
includes various dimensions of conversation quality with human evaluation
directly on the synthesized conversations, and interactive human evaluation of
chatbots fine-tuned on the synthetically generated dataset. We additionally
demonstrate that this prompting approach is generalizable to multi-party
conversations, providing potential to create new synthetic data for multi-party
tasks. Our synthetic multi-party conversations were rated more favorably across
all measured dimensions compared to conversation excerpts sampled from a
human-collected multi-party dataset. | [
0.0878055394,
0.047830686,
-0.0146477772,
0.0064762351,
-0.0418215171,
-0.0079814699,
0.019297082,
0.0053064283,
0.0461852737,
-0.0337840877,
-0.0399782993,
-0.0316542946,
0.0250137858,
0.0645941645,
0.0184661467,
-0.0576375723,
0.0164253581,
-0.0156756341,
0.0263888706,
-0.0033908857,
0.0229774751,
0.0270067845,
-0.0143826706,
0.0475702249,
-0.0275158733,
0.0002849369,
-0.0198812019,
0.0131688602,
-0.0028609023,
0.0079015121,
0.0283082668,
0.0875626802,
0.0043672156,
0.0139635578,
0.0000018617,
-0.027369285,
0.0233464781,
-0.0370051637,
0.0008724513,
-0.0130045079,
0.068752259,
0.0075358874,
-0.0155823063,
0.0367874466,
-0.0746106952,
0.0152253415,
0.021791663,
0.0472593531,
0.0843631998,
0.0986891612,
-0.024638582,
0.0094552375,
-0.0226243511,
-0.0268883798,
-0.005964288,
-0.0264331289,
-0.0161673222,
0.0199665762,
0.0442707092,
0.0477648601,
0.0413351618,
-0.0021252311,
0.0243225936,
-0.0515564755,
0.0402470566,
0.0190439019,
-0.0678859428,
-0.0500717051,
-0.0264499728,
0.1029651314,
0.0307601653,
-0.0155518688,
0.0114083663,
0.0072334986,
0.0389514044,
0.0052942862,
-0.0502654985,
0.0090676099,
-0.0033984901,
-0.001545254,
-0.0199583769,
0.0340740718,
-0.0114497608,
-0.0099601755,
0.0331683271,
0.0120753525,
0.0038182633,
-0.0099797416,
-0.0529703237,
0.0087704565,
0.0143298609,
-0.0693727732,
0.0093766879,
-0.0117007466,
-0.0642562658,
0.0161091033,
-0.0796110258,
0.0317852423,
0.0236019585,
-0.0269301198,
-0.0042122738,
0.0170559678,
-0.0072828447,
0.050311055,
0.0041806023,
0.0128867384,
0.0158786103,
0.0072519961,
-0.0139647322,
-0.036540553,
-0.0286792964,
-0.0024237507,
-0.0462909639,
-0.0055855969,
-0.0807446092,
-0.0403886735,
-0.0285750795,
0.0500594378,
0.0005373862,
0.0326206721,
0.0305232685,
0.0369713865,
-0.0306005273,
-0.0220475122,
-0.0186541211,
-0.0381231457,
-0.0561216623,
0.0168254524,
0.0537143089,
-0.0967178494,
0.0023747124,
0.0352876596,
0.0200192221,
0.0130200405,
-0.0333189517,
0.0450013876,
-0.0029708364,
-0.0145304706,
0.0216018744,
-0.0443168506,
-0.0018689001,
-0.0411044247,
-0.0375381075,
-0.0481552593,
0.0783267841,
-0.0093588,
-0.0280762743,
-0.0273253601,
0.0198621396,
0.0339174122,
-0.0222750306,
0.0352596231,
-0.0344590284,
0.0449520797,
0.0255163088,
0.0241656043,
-0.0150750149,
0.0664801449,
0.0335351489,
0.0366479494,
0.0519760512,
0.0045672371,
0.0531241931,
0.0366958603,
0.0137237143,
0.0234081242,
0.0082992092,
0.0223324671,
0.0011088363,
0.0373147167,
-0.0144798271,
0.0549716875,
-0.0247206371,
-0.0035036274,
0.0758066475,
0.0453814715,
-0.018413173,
0.0575885065,
0.0354248099,
0.0508736707,
0.0053253225,
0.005150835,
-0.0316733867,
0.0263686478,
-0.0353391208,
-0.0410359688,
0.0626459792,
-0.0061967708,
-0.0295754708,
-0.029656779,
0.0379076637,
0.000995197,
0.0379932635,
0.0042602071,
0.0037526982,
0.0330215655,
-0.0639408156,
0.0225940607,
0.0166174117,
-0.0668456852,
-0.0434831269,
-0.0116259474,
0.0409394577,
0.1073740274,
0.0695418417,
0.005997418,
0.0109065762,
-0.0125316782,
0.0091845691,
0.0240142141,
0.0893123373,
-0.0191841125,
0.018330127,
-0.0497518778,
0.0051404852,
0.0005265914,
-0.0003166139,
-0.0132337287,
0.0547643453,
-0.0015270587,
0.0110448617,
-0.0100537557,
-0.0200864431,
-0.0065678144,
-0.0382559821,
0.0359234288,
0.0070328391,
-0.0061981822,
0.0048850337,
0.0428482778,
-0.0078474702,
-0.0000933805,
0.010756705,
-0.0185844507,
-0.0164750498,
0.0215814319,
-0.0478158444,
-0.0289041661,
0.0028483942,
-0.0199456271,
-0.0223791897,
0.0187265445,
-0.0238266252,
-0.0350692347,
0.0207454581,
-0.0220827814,
0.0335748047,
-0.017307207,
0.013122513,
0.0192479193,
0.0469462238,
0.0062467791,
0.0296854004,
-0.0005525725,
0.0098245125,
0.0372748375,
0.0235767365,
-0.0158584323,
-0.0574339144,
0.0210640114,
0.0199171677,
-0.0078449333,
0.0116333934,
0.0318892859,
0.0128489193,
-0.0697936341,
-0.0578977056,
-0.1417484581,
-0.0077179275,
-0.0249391701,
-0.0242960583,
0.0245536324,
0.0371941924,
-0.0297363438,
-0.009526127,
-0.0718996748,
-0.0277021807,
0.0258461796,
0.004971534,
0.0464983322,
-0.0219609011,
-0.0104695382,
-0.0475290008,
0.0117146634,
0.0206300858,
0.0518160239,
0.0135727841,
-0.0197743624,
-0.04814649,
0.0182539485,
-0.0395378843,
0.0164348297,
-0.0116809616,
-0.0608307235,
0.0298508182,
-0.0243842434,
0.068131268,
0.047514569,
0.0646129176,
0.0407468975,
-0.0340722427,
0.0062806676,
-0.0554686747,
-0.0114510544,
-0.0291742608,
0.0387085266,
0.0004502246,
-0.0542769134,
0.0214628037,
-0.0011828743,
0.0119099803,
0.0225894451,
-0.0656584427,
0.0440829359,
0.0332818702,
-0.0356922299,
-0.011920996,
-0.0085785585,
-0.0166637637,
0.0414026976,
-0.0283013992,
-0.029832134,
0.0610313639,
-0.0282100551,
-0.0172152948,
-0.0092838965,
-0.0372776613,
-0.0241324157,
0.0552304462,
-0.0280688256,
0.0106232781,
-0.0322412886,
0.0012511208,
-0.0312272068,
-0.0063260943,
0.0314577371,
-0.0558331497,
-0.0107930964,
-0.0443892367,
-0.0020591849,
0.0363614075,
-0.0232157782,
-0.0480984673,
-0.0729921609,
-0.0493239015,
0.0002099675,
0.0260280725,
-0.0378055125,
-0.0102356737,
0.0029571285,
-0.0176038332,
0.04389406,
-0.0010941656,
0.0118216658,
-0.0138313491,
0.0128478622,
0.0232710354,
0.0094986176,
-0.0363617241,
-0.0324322321,
0.0752463415,
0.0423756875,
0.034287367,
0.0083880732,
-0.0203251708,
-0.0310726538,
0.0024703734,
0.0298018996,
-0.0186664462,
-0.0034915258,
0.0684954897,
-0.0234261379,
-0.0124628218,
0.1052507386,
0.0106669916,
-0.0403221846,
0.0070892712,
-0.017505832,
0.0331833735,
-0.0014881709,
0.0168713648,
-0.098000288,
-0.0306539144,
0.0080411267,
0.0127097359,
-0.018762894,
-0.050092537,
-0.0095873363,
-0.1162005588,
0.037435133,
-0.0098635778,
-0.0230900031,
-0.0380948447,
-0.0035510703,
-0.0134892119,
0.017512409,
-0.0147064114,
-0.0139689585,
0.0293992646,
-0.0018351156,
-0.0085019544,
-0.0436286628,
-0.0578426495,
0.0355645195,
-0.023878919,
0.1169148088,
0.0402821787,
0.0584817007,
0.0428638197,
0.0047724759,
0.0347948372,
0.0299095158,
-0.0102399345,
0.0200142302,
0.0637351274,
0.0029157738,
-0.0135513665,
-0.0178977195,
0.0466284044,
-0.0201336369,
-0.0192400198,
0.0114303082,
-0.0081580859,
-0.0541253798,
-0.006150614,
-0.0109681245,
0.069142051,
0.0620134957,
0.0782833546,
0.0569376275,
-0.0443548448,
-0.0079278983,
-0.024995815,
-0.0046310532,
-0.0396268032,
-0.0165547766,
0.0101916939,
0.0017495543,
-0.0055878484,
-0.0910734981,
-0.0481800623,
0.0535275862,
0.0024113178,
-0.0139129786,
-0.0314854383,
0.0120027177,
0.0026262521,
0.0126166297,
0.0361171477,
-0.0323463455,
0.0163247958,
-0.0403559171,
-0.0510387123,
0.0273500979,
-0.0543370172,
0.0101150367,
0.0266763102,
-0.0547446422,
-0.0452958159,
-0.0077684042,
0.0422334038,
0.0211557169,
0.0534317791,
-0.0322231688,
-0.030604152,
-0.0060999375,
0.0223788489,
-0.0402927622,
-0.0153484922,
0.0132695762,
0.0664325953,
0.0066554192,
0.0445990898,
-0.0443541631,
0.0170769598,
-0.0302362554,
0.0197281968,
-0.0418094806,
-0.0659962222,
0.0164401382,
0.0112411994,
0.0178632848,
0.0015424221,
0.0254629813,
-0.0288781486,
-0.0062325555,
-0.072832115,
-0.025649799,
-0.0679567531,
0.0258437097,
-0.0071900282,
-0.0208325908,
0.0066212206,
-0.0030345621,
-0.0807763115,
0.0398080498,
-0.0234565288,
-0.0161559414,
0.0127137098,
-0.0159706958,
0.0384841077,
-0.0127726076,
-0.0178115685,
0.0334006026,
-0.0413740575,
0.0198418591,
-0.0028277372,
0.0473111086,
0.0171774402,
-0.0343773924,
0.0244614016,
0.0508326553,
-0.0709624067,
-0.0517213605,
-0.008598539,
0.0895107239,
0.0147909084,
0.0238972828,
0.0420397222,
-0.0284112226,
0.0134095969,
-0.0078665596,
0.069423452,
-0.0001589629,
-0.0475354306,
-0.0195204038,
0.0000102762,
-0.0365856364,
0.0251573119,
0.0690808743,
-0.0267695952,
0.0128686531,
-0.0079764016,
-0.0023502489,
-0.048544541,
-0.0187419131,
0.0270849094,
0.0048468621,
0.0087377066,
-0.0127051147,
-0.0496914312,
-0.0288759172,
-0.0383187868,
0.022852296,
-0.0029238262,
-0.0040798374,
0.0437116325,
0.0462751687,
-0.035075862,
0.0433924682,
-0.0624451041,
0.0131212156,
-0.0140552018,
-0.033712361,
-0.025045475,
-6.032520194e-33,
-0.0032546478,
-0.0394422449,
0.0057801912,
-0.0126434471,
-0.0381700434,
-0.0220891666,
-0.0541427955,
0.003546248,
-0.0010106855,
0.0134533122,
-0.0400780961,
0.0367098153,
0.0147185614,
0.036508251,
-0.0141747221,
-0.0227536596,
0.0482197553,
-0.0305351019,
-0.0218829904,
0.0651745498,
0.0265544765,
0.0045591225,
-0.0032746736,
-0.0778310969,
0.0293566231,
-0.0347276554,
-0.0290035624,
0.0103716571,
0.0496236272,
0.0201768875,
-0.01097822,
0.0237404704,
0.0005893767,
-0.0252558272,
-0.0211797711,
0.0701695234,
-0.0224823691,
-0.0142574431,
0.0094172889,
-0.0205555297,
-0.0490059257,
-0.0225416366,
0.0097223483,
-0.0317003801,
0.0079954835,
0.0370828658,
0.0231650397,
-0.0378933474,
-0.0142899202,
-0.0260648932,
-0.0383191928,
0.0156354085,
-0.0284516029,
-0.0718044639,
-0.0230271406,
0.0825530961,
0.0276894383,
-0.0017297911,
-0.0092348903,
0.0847735703,
-0.031269934,
-0.0230836663,
0.0219696127,
-0.0043116543,
0.0201967265,
0.0623485073,
0.0314021036,
0.0658924356,
-0.0272221789,
-0.0252784733,
-0.0192865618,
0.063248381,
0.0330644064,
0.0808935612,
-0.0254017748,
-0.0313655771,
0.0102883922,
0.0368740186,
0.0367670953,
-0.0598830953,
0.0179123897,
-0.0192707554,
-0.0404633768,
-0.0093937358,
-0.0162176657,
-0.000057634,
-0.0135781597,
-0.0178223085,
0.0279774684,
0.017388897,
-0.0405450575,
-0.0454075783,
0.0151242279,
-0.0634260476,
0.0181744844,
0.0204546656,
-0.0532993041,
0.0071188458,
-0.0088526057,
-0.0140083618,
-0.0145074399,
-0.0292725079,
0.0505949147,
0.029821042,
0.0187010523,
0.023637481,
-0.0069327741,
-0.0030940974,
-0.0334663205,
0.0129162557,
-0.0281524733,
0.0822524503,
-0.0423471332,
-0.0062738033,
0.0016443039,
0.009552991,
-0.0366770029,
0.0471212678,
-0.0194194242,
0.0526011027,
-0.0174755324,
-0.0172529854,
0.0017384471,
0.0016942326,
-0.0367159694,
-0.0020861989,
-0.0526776463,
-0.0406907089,
0.0357186906,
0.0022238921,
-0.0157931857,
-0.0353939533,
2.472e-7,
-0.0328739509,
0.0334906317,
0.0227651503,
0.018431874,
0.0126554323,
0.0463314019,
0.0332346335,
0.0601104312,
0.00013672,
-0.0116895959,
0.0280863158,
0.0251938011,
0.0736680254,
0.0098579023,
-0.1152185723,
-0.0381229818,
-0.1041365191,
-0.0386317968,
-0.0333667211,
-0.0169178303,
0.065730989,
0.0604646988,
0.0141546549,
-0.0060378183,
-0.0208444931,
-0.0186250135,
0.0414464474,
-0.0635374933,
-0.0620718449,
0.0330192409,
0.0496749431,
0.0150676174,
0.0151698748,
-0.0132431127,
-0.0161215086,
0.0000037645,
0.0224892646,
0.0491448902,
0.0207123384,
-0.0468207747,
0.0110397004,
-0.0185164139,
-0.0020170275,
-0.0302219931,
0.0352621377,
-0.0572932176,
-0.014869174,
-0.016199138,
-0.0207853261,
-0.0306410827,
0.0170235727,
-0.0300739594,
-0.0226164944,
0.0275035147,
0.0151689975,
-0.01019648,
0.0186993685,
-0.0392201655,
-0.010120119,
-0.0299909469,
-0.0585797504,
-0.0654881522,
0.0043352013,
-0.0048611802,
0.0057350863,
0.0026371507,
0.0269145668,
1.725695617e-34,
0.0526800193,
0.0252409782,
-0.0066480823,
0.0268580019,
0.0385960229,
-0.0153633663,
-0.0075868159,
0.0033993281,
0.0418123938,
-0.0428221487,
-0.0047319187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03241v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03241v4 | Continual Pre-training of Language Models | 2023-02-07T03:57:55 | 2023-04-12T10:36:44 | Zixuan Ke, Yijia Shao, Haowei Lin, Tatsuya Konishi, Gyuhak Kim, Bing Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Language models (LMs) have been instrumental for the rapid advance of natural
language processing. This paper studies continual pre-training of LMs, in
particular, continual domain-adaptive pre-training (or continual DAP-training).
Existing research has shown that further pre-training an LM using a domain
corpus to adapt the LM to the domain can improve the end-task performance in
the domain. This paper proposes a novel method to continually DAP-train an LM
with a sequence of unlabeled domain corpora to adapt the LM to these domains to
improve their end-task performances. The key novelty of our method is a
soft-masking mechanism that directly controls the update to the LM. A novel
proxy is also proposed to preserve the general knowledge in the original LM.
Additionally, it contrasts the representations of the previously learned domain
knowledge (including the general knowledge in the pre-trained LM) and the
knowledge from the current full network to achieve knowledge integration. The
method not only overcomes catastrophic forgetting, but also achieves knowledge
transfer to improve end-task performances. Empirical evaluation demonstrates
the effectiveness of the proposed method. | [
0.017882904,
0.008140903,
-0.0300531611,
-0.0049123443,
-0.0183473509,
0.0313081369,
0.0064648362,
-0.0562973842,
0.021749109,
-0.0747271478,
-0.0451440215,
-0.0241803173,
-0.0245127305,
0.0554807484,
0.0334853679,
-0.0468651094,
0.0680250451,
-0.0180515386,
-0.0449910425,
-0.0150314495,
-0.0083220173,
-0.0292946622,
-0.0033968904,
-0.012274811,
0.0264073908,
-0.0267797932,
-0.0069752401,
-0.0437497236,
-0.0133557878,
-0.0273785666,
0.0384739228,
0.0445846319,
0.0511320829,
-0.0290115271,
0.0000023686,
-0.0744716972,
-0.0387141481,
-0.0235842708,
-0.0439291745,
-0.0248550754,
0.0565926656,
0.0153705114,
0.0075009661,
0.0238305759,
-0.0732194111,
-0.0546625517,
0.0260404069,
0.0297414642,
0.0759855509,
0.0573471561,
-0.0159064475,
-0.0470933244,
0.0409622639,
-0.0300313514,
-0.0411266051,
-0.0563606285,
0.0486660935,
0.0001652715,
-0.0177023355,
-0.0085726073,
-0.0159321167,
0.0571904778,
-0.0058109104,
0.0179719776,
0.0396496505,
0.034605179,
0.0207506977,
-0.0094295656,
-0.0231736805,
0.0396789983,
-0.045087494,
-0.0496670865,
0.0018566726,
0.0157893579,
0.0026932003,
0.0126823541,
-0.0357960425,
-0.0265822578,
0.0487708673,
0.0226603523,
0.0136799226,
0.0000862632,
0.0173123442,
0.0210844185,
-0.0615361929,
0.0201056097,
0.0238781292,
-0.0316143185,
0.0211160183,
0.008019302,
-0.0415014438,
-0.0398225524,
0.034592472,
0.0619811229,
0.0279281978,
0.0405585952,
-0.073516652,
-0.0405693054,
-0.0147726955,
-0.0836587548,
0.0525885411,
0.0336859189,
-0.0458152182,
0.054239694,
-0.0995741561,
0.0481769592,
0.0164011419,
-0.0076397755,
-0.0505401567,
0.0040885694,
-0.0845328718,
-0.0275026616,
-0.0570829362,
0.0712679997,
-0.0040631318,
-0.011387025,
-0.0130548468,
0.0220721997,
-0.022041928,
-0.0307530649,
0.0079936702,
-0.0135600101,
-0.0543802418,
-0.0188618209,
-0.0410375334,
0.0374262668,
-0.011103929,
0.0348510407,
-0.0243717469,
-0.0243520252,
-0.0089932084,
-0.0196375176,
0.0079847956,
-0.0258486923,
0.0353233367,
0.0778678507,
0.0077011194,
-0.0334577598,
-0.090930067,
0.0189129114,
0.0295101833,
-0.0581474751,
0.0198896453,
-0.0200687908,
0.0043857386,
-0.0133576794,
0.0172307231,
-0.0650616363,
0.0030559839,
0.0002968689,
-0.0262851305,
0.101568602,
-0.0249962602,
0.0158999208,
0.0390664302,
0.0059272875,
0.0065505398,
0.0730833486,
-0.0013033682,
-0.0277236942,
-0.0027386015,
-0.0052412939,
-0.0073148077,
0.0254635457,
0.0234196354,
0.0178030822,
-0.0372740626,
-0.010912085,
0.0291274115,
-0.0159025788,
0.03753113,
-0.0011191074,
-0.0087804263,
0.0051888749,
0.0506044999,
-0.0122184204,
0.0385011919,
0.0339967236,
0.056944333,
-0.0486872122,
0.0134607097,
0.042160511,
-0.0465700477,
-0.0153600788,
-0.0286207087,
0.0125081716,
-0.0376698859,
0.0254907273,
-0.0459373817,
-0.0143984696,
0.025271479,
-0.0277127307,
0.0482769012,
-0.001936226,
0.0840214193,
0.0568229705,
-0.0504191704,
0.0277780835,
0.0469940677,
0.0129039539,
0.0421179682,
-0.0269188974,
-0.0271475296,
0.0240941979,
0.0047799386,
-0.0627103671,
-0.0630071014,
-0.0191421229,
0.0217587519,
-0.0094410535,
0.0312770493,
-0.0083307549,
0.0041180076,
-0.0487843789,
-0.0117216073,
0.0109971268,
0.0148719978,
0.0621982403,
0.0138914529,
0.0377743542,
0.026190022,
-0.005505119,
-0.0249490552,
0.0350945592,
-0.0794660002,
-0.0676937699,
-0.020260999,
-0.0114251431,
0.0222357493,
0.0129465666,
-0.0282857846,
-0.0017707919,
0.035519138,
-0.0487629361,
-0.030446792,
0.0282220114,
-0.0800151452,
-0.0123139238,
0.0497362949,
0.0095145181,
0.0038650921,
0.0248996224,
-0.0124849426,
-0.0498176627,
-0.0046520373,
0.0391665921,
0.0693523884,
-0.0411342457,
0.0440707691,
-0.0022600663,
0.0061099101,
-0.0563451014,
0.0591144674,
0.0330137461,
-0.0015243186,
-0.0027060595,
0.0277581234,
-0.0090733264,
-0.016296193,
-0.0200977679,
-0.0016330589,
-0.0104112094,
0.0051179123,
-0.0090142163,
-0.013792309,
-0.0432247594,
0.0105533693,
-0.0530630387,
0.0085354913,
-0.0110501163,
-0.0074596354,
0.0133995013,
0.0161396936,
-0.0166582763,
-0.0148498751,
-0.0105220275,
0.0206069332,
0.0071727494,
0.0264456309,
0.0010568171,
0.0155745856,
0.0165984351,
-0.021892339,
0.0022711512,
0.0118752662,
0.0322837457,
-0.0272354893,
-0.047250893,
-0.0483072177,
0.0903758109,
0.0091320248,
0.0582132339,
-0.0103802774,
-0.0218677055,
-0.0519475155,
-0.0099319397,
0.0632271692,
0.0566608272,
0.0082999514,
-0.0115345009,
0.0617143363,
-0.01727999,
-0.0273303632,
0.0080214599,
-0.0591958687,
-0.0225380324,
-0.0130114146,
0.0419076234,
0.0309165083,
0.0718054771,
-0.0096694659,
-0.0413328186,
-0.0287949201,
-0.0083897468,
-0.0735381767,
-0.0272316094,
-0.0237400718,
-0.0236810446,
-0.0322794653,
0.0019899595,
-0.0077416347,
-0.0244571455,
0.0466710068,
-0.0222094506,
0.0132341934,
-0.069804132,
-0.0397545733,
0.0039749639,
0.0225337241,
0.0166850388,
0.0114092836,
0.054558672,
-0.0423878245,
-0.0590128526,
0.0133988801,
0.0127222873,
-0.0278154071,
0.0273982082,
-0.0181611888,
0.0365352891,
0.0049419273,
0.0102759674,
-0.0737125278,
-0.0249923039,
-0.00084658,
0.0104211746,
-0.012329991,
0.0423497483,
-0.0417399779,
0.0491517149,
0.0145024629,
0.0708120391,
0.0041019227,
-0.0057727131,
-0.0119600771,
0.014950892,
0.0272144694,
0.0180601384,
-0.0118522393,
-0.0018635027,
0.00623998,
0.0108700329,
0.0536669604,
-0.0213206261,
-0.0277821571,
0.0174883846,
0.0121044004,
-0.0389812253,
-0.0275436789,
0.0022488213,
-0.009844251,
-0.0396207012,
-0.0277097821,
0.1107140109,
0.0295701791,
-0.0332027562,
-0.00049355,
0.0131843444,
-0.0209487528,
0.0433556847,
0.0291201044,
-0.060974922,
-0.0177062899,
0.0204828158,
-0.0129769202,
0.0108828451,
-0.0360146239,
-0.0210252944,
-0.1127833724,
-0.0263011623,
0.0245032925,
-0.0153360255,
0.009769585,
-0.0317674242,
-0.0042751338,
0.0171762574,
-0.0055282637,
-0.0134487208,
-0.0222642235,
-0.0119292988,
0.044445429,
-0.0177491903,
-0.0503203943,
0.0100483485,
-0.0309312958,
0.0697174519,
0.0890239999,
0.0141967162,
-0.0082423771,
0.0199964568,
0.0918846428,
-0.0210094359,
0.0253043603,
-0.0181319062,
0.0277440492,
-0.0205008816,
-0.015501013,
0.0271223076,
-0.0019591781,
-0.033557266,
-0.0308938045,
0.0019387433,
0.0595804229,
0.0112468693,
0.0064491564,
0.0071779531,
-0.0152775999,
-0.0107806548,
0.0464007668,
-0.0053220773,
-0.0372047797,
0.0225940868,
0.0061235288,
-0.0113808773,
-0.010098502,
-0.0307181515,
0.0300100818,
-0.0756869987,
0.0072102514,
-0.0639423802,
-0.0147082238,
0.0420550667,
0.0599840507,
0.0676129982,
0.0092963977,
0.0349143222,
-0.0049874946,
-0.0429311246,
0.0059941923,
-0.0470239148,
-0.0046164673,
-0.0540919751,
-0.032228332,
0.067055136,
-0.0339703336,
-0.0210409593,
-0.0019693107,
-0.0199180394,
-0.05177439,
0.0577084981,
0.0434710532,
0.0252471808,
0.0381768718,
-0.0275012199,
-0.068757154,
0.0653977841,
-0.0007265351,
-0.0410902835,
0.0359026678,
0.0262393262,
-0.029075671,
0.0145468451,
-0.0119397799,
-0.0358065218,
0.0308815613,
0.0376990736,
0.0166177973,
0.0081931474,
-0.0080628227,
0.0290439352,
-0.0103276232,
0.0492226966,
0.0155189987,
0.0185510721,
-0.0552097559,
0.0005386146,
0.0107991453,
-0.0087144775,
-0.0338859484,
0.0066500367,
0.0327569656,
0.0321384296,
0.0053073531,
-0.002410887,
-0.0144864898,
0.0229709763,
-0.0154228471,
-0.03193032,
0.0210754275,
0.016417684,
0.0287302211,
0.0461185351,
-0.0174558181,
-0.014852887,
0.0103337178,
0.015474787,
-0.0477665365,
0.0222503189,
0.0124773998,
0.0196121708,
-0.0370697677,
0.0158516336,
-0.0350764133,
-0.0352794938,
-0.0411246344,
0.0162980966,
0.085266389,
-0.0400031991,
0.0259497985,
-0.0264840666,
0.0046800757,
-0.0367965549,
-0.0084457267,
0.0191496201,
-0.0020581835,
0.027369285,
0.0122869089,
-0.0117692165,
0.0240184981,
0.0878978893,
0.0123789208,
0.0514549054,
-0.0012568109,
0.0167407673,
-0.01848487,
0.0097700888,
0.0006488848,
0.0335295834,
-0.0392199829,
0.0323139578,
-0.0095351525,
-0.0907299072,
0.0096649239,
-0.0574502796,
0.0127134938,
-0.0054751905,
0.0197507348,
0.0242793374,
-0.0113653569,
0.01428439,
-0.0325207859,
0.0204453301,
0.0488998443,
0.012462724,
0.0285847839,
-7.136164656e-33,
-0.0650442019,
0.0134686958,
0.0170279015,
-0.0236966647,
-0.0277950782,
-0.0070219305,
-0.0194933675,
-0.0052752323,
0.0030034794,
-0.0195237249,
-0.0031719811,
-0.0017759393,
0.0167163014,
0.0031455089,
-0.0181799009,
-0.012000761,
0.0598013327,
0.0194145758,
0.0321315378,
-0.0146680251,
0.0220260676,
0.088050738,
0.0403769724,
-0.0691602156,
-0.004805062,
0.0224097837,
0.0116496235,
0.0165630113,
0.0558388457,
0.0319537669,
-0.0206562318,
0.0070219585,
0.0339438505,
-0.0671197325,
-0.0510331951,
0.0090991324,
-0.1108692139,
-0.0283460189,
0.0302736927,
0.0211547017,
0.0260080937,
-0.0099218013,
0.0280605797,
-0.0030808041,
0.0233319253,
-0.0001163727,
0.0341739208,
-0.0546537265,
-0.0301497541,
-0.0183716659,
-0.0718876198,
0.0124152564,
0.0306583233,
-0.0186779667,
0.0258905999,
-0.0164408982,
-0.0121440981,
-0.0129636107,
-0.0896912813,
0.0004260772,
0.0172243416,
0.0496865995,
0.0271253027,
0.0257951487,
0.0305072125,
0.0344024226,
0.0173987746,
0.0109514315,
0.0294798296,
0.0099086091,
0.075451307,
-0.0026438381,
-0.0060018599,
-0.0230026636,
0.0528713949,
-0.0628084466,
-0.042301584,
0.0196780786,
-0.0416261069,
0.0354991481,
0.0139672952,
0.0389785767,
0.0175232925,
-0.0145100718,
-0.04053922,
0.0471101962,
-0.0230627488,
-0.0232541282,
0.0428112447,
0.0156170828,
-0.0097617013,
0.0097405529,
0.0419034511,
-0.0432711728,
-0.0102057634,
-0.0283415075,
-0.0070652487,
0.0238957722,
-0.0179574788,
0.0433135852,
-0.0562126562,
-0.0476381592,
-0.0104261478,
-0.0025332051,
-0.0108868908,
-0.011527257,
0.0203623623,
0.0521542914,
-0.0679252818,
-0.0146319121,
-0.0208776109,
-0.0052883402,
0.0779179782,
0.0517137572,
0.0208833218,
0.0414723195,
-0.0127279079,
0.0738127902,
0.0500256009,
-0.0842531696,
-0.0301000196,
0.0317845382,
0.0369074196,
0.0568834506,
-0.0426792428,
-0.0367267504,
-0.0203831494,
0.0331755579,
0.0465510227,
-0.0705965087,
-0.0115153845,
-0.018853534,
3.125e-7,
0.0205451604,
0.0161891337,
-0.0148674939,
-0.0199613702,
-0.0004654162,
0.0245406013,
-0.0320930891,
0.0466370471,
0.0394308642,
0.0327579454,
-0.0071613444,
0.0229803082,
0.0023774412,
0.0046008579,
-0.0810158923,
-0.0338570438,
0.0307782404,
-0.0066605271,
-0.044240579,
0.0212397631,
0.009194186,
0.0693758428,
0.0200908873,
0.0067029279,
-0.0034609134,
-0.0889422297,
0.0827564672,
0.0088134846,
0.0055376296,
-0.0069172527,
-0.0156562515,
0.0691384897,
-0.0535503477,
0.0419807248,
-0.0398390181,
0.0390181802,
0.0207754038,
0.0387631655,
-0.013169569,
0.0023033635,
0.0268721506,
0.0017683911,
-0.0159925651,
-0.0014338405,
0.0696805641,
-0.1190688536,
-0.0289488398,
-0.0032967455,
-0.0339381918,
-0.0045441855,
-0.0166612137,
0.0325682573,
-0.0240809768,
0.0195658058,
0.017928822,
0.0479122289,
-0.0569182634,
-0.1031148806,
0.0065411357,
0.0443414822,
-0.0335350223,
-0.0176932216,
-0.0271731988,
-0.0198889971,
0.0503495522,
-0.0613789558,
0.0480566286,
2.927766816e-34,
-0.0083328197,
0.0065966365,
0.0200091321,
0.0634499639,
0.0010656845,
-0.0318731703,
-0.0126044089,
0.0294813812,
0.010404502,
-0.0765726492,
-0.0164350998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03222v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03222v1 | Bringing the State-of-the-Art to Customers: A Neural Agent Assistant Framework for Customer Service Support | 2023-02-07T03:11:06 | 2023-02-07T03:11:06 | Stephen Obadinma, Faiza Khan Khattak, Shirley Wang, Tania Sidhom, Elaine Lau, Sean Robertson, Jingcheng Niu, Winnie Au, Alif Munim, Karthik Raja K. Bhaskar, Bencheng Wei, Iris Ren, Waqar Muhammad, Erin Li, Bukola Ishola, Michael Wang, Griffin Tanner, Yu-Jia Shiah, Sean X. Zhang, Kwesi P. Apponsah, Kanishk Patel, Jaswinder Narain, Deval Pandya, Xiaodan Zhu, Frank Rudzicz, Elham Dolatabadi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Building Agent Assistants that can help improve customer service support
requires inputs from industry users and their customers, as well as knowledge
about state-of-the-art Natural Language Processing (NLP) technology. We combine
expertise from academia and industry to bridge the gap and build
task/domain-specific Neural Agent Assistants (NAA) with three high-level
components for: (1) Intent Identification, (2) Context Retrieval, and (3)
Response Generation. In this paper, we outline the pipeline of the NAA's core
system and also present three case studies in which three industry partners
successfully adapt the framework to find solutions to their unique challenges.
Our findings suggest that a collaborative process is instrumental in spurring
the development of emerging NLP models for Conversational AI tasks in industry.
The full reference implementation code and results are available at
\url{https://github.com/VectorInstitute/NAA} | [
0.0927996337,
0.0067541986,
-0.0376909785,
0.0376958959,
-0.0504788905,
-0.0323975682,
0.0250241533,
-0.0327333584,
0.0185559895,
-0.0672565922,
0.0082439668,
-0.0171717871,
-0.0253074896,
0.0788801834,
-0.0190495085,
-0.0321233161,
0.0023256487,
0.0182124097,
0.0619503967,
0.0373635441,
-0.0018553289,
0.0197541248,
-0.0352373905,
0.0763220638,
-0.0359053165,
-0.0180239957,
-0.0018411576,
-0.005850425,
0.0008501757,
-0.026203325,
0.0896689072,
-0.0113446396,
0.0370782912,
0.0146376276,
0.0000018965,
-0.069803305,
-0.0123895006,
0.0021161027,
-0.0518998504,
-0.0461716577,
0.0242293067,
0.004855975,
0.0137780039,
0.0429445803,
-0.0498041324,
0.0380285531,
0.0015447836,
0.0643427223,
0.0598341003,
0.055146236,
-0.0192311872,
-0.0273523685,
-0.0101866573,
-0.0123717645,
-0.014522234,
-0.0628563315,
0.0012860904,
-0.011992896,
0.0429171361,
-0.0058092489,
0.0340312198,
0.0395751372,
0.012563332,
-0.0132246949,
0.0050730295,
0.0356924944,
0.0019820703,
-0.0183305163,
-0.0838453323,
0.0915721208,
0.0129021741,
0.0407721698,
0.0024331866,
0.0043788939,
-0.013242227,
-0.0540966578,
-0.025846649,
0.0245600473,
-0.0171012711,
-0.0342679657,
-0.0203411896,
0.0361385234,
-0.0212529916,
-0.0154459653,
0.0066738864,
0.0528298095,
-0.0090850927,
-0.0213413592,
-0.0016722525,
0.0056559127,
0.0166255794,
-0.0299694762,
0.0438854136,
0.0549864508,
-0.0692457333,
0.0199915655,
0.0046487637,
0.0037050615,
0.0169909783,
-0.0583286546,
0.009615344,
0.0190474465,
-0.0345133208,
0.0217764657,
-0.0270266999,
0.0237632953,
0.0118966056,
0.0027517385,
-0.0422937088,
-0.0094359526,
-0.0615378805,
-0.0076364363,
-0.0617937855,
0.0422362462,
-0.0928996578,
-0.0477890037,
-0.0039846883,
0.0435874537,
0.0074297381,
0.0008576639,
0.0021248322,
0.0901116729,
-0.0414162129,
-0.0059971004,
-0.044328697,
0.0247616544,
-0.0481545143,
0.0364182368,
0.0017883067,
-0.0489806309,
0.0120960036,
0.030763343,
-0.006746518,
0.0168920271,
0.0007064005,
0.04551946,
-0.0116041917,
-0.0777939111,
-0.0459907465,
-0.0161638986,
-0.0054997676,
-0.0671603605,
-0.002975947,
-0.0000805124,
0.044753395,
0.0126960315,
-0.0251809396,
-0.021477133,
0.0248607118,
0.0306207053,
-0.0045577832,
0.0352772512,
-0.030008655,
0.0070256949,
0.0430932008,
0.0086422591,
0.004059332,
-0.0024330933,
0.0201774202,
0.0435671769,
0.0514030755,
0.0122239022,
0.0067560663,
-0.0343268551,
-0.0175244659,
-0.0421944149,
0.0372958221,
0.0452143289,
-0.0570871793,
0.0368442722,
0.0227057319,
0.0499899946,
0.007913786,
-0.0105883535,
0.0415403284,
0.0437596776,
0.0091846064,
0.0179616492,
0.0584851652,
0.0760934725,
-0.0445560068,
-0.0338969603,
-0.0203467086,
0.0297713839,
-0.0100309085,
0.0228330418,
-0.0094498089,
0.0131090935,
-0.0584925786,
-0.0409011617,
0.0225724857,
-0.0423862897,
0.0295365863,
0.0339841582,
0.010736309,
-0.0048183817,
-0.0738858357,
-0.0149581106,
-0.0249618739,
-0.0410264805,
-0.0144301616,
-0.0279117133,
0.0402006879,
0.0947466642,
0.0530010797,
-0.0279159583,
-0.0576632619,
-0.0154815679,
-0.03416631,
0.0874438882,
0.0182747431,
-0.0089203846,
0.0393639132,
-0.040825922,
0.0102732824,
-0.0322753862,
-0.0113412812,
0.0337070152,
-0.0287820902,
0.0031207085,
0.0332533903,
0.0424293615,
-0.0076831384,
0.0205887277,
-0.0056556747,
-0.0243423171,
0.0302308053,
0.0222154222,
0.0307046734,
0.0677721575,
-0.0064695966,
0.0119335176,
0.0306298546,
-0.0402461961,
-0.0449063443,
0.0445059985,
-0.0046983976,
-0.0248694327,
0.0102339219,
0.0016610544,
0.0038437103,
0.0471080802,
-0.0033925229,
-0.0423828699,
0.0241664834,
-0.0398845375,
0.0061645717,
-0.0596529543,
-0.0292517524,
0.0366436578,
0.029573001,
-0.000438221,
0.0444126725,
0.05144706,
-0.0267263539,
0.0183162484,
0.0272632372,
0.0191968698,
-0.0318988636,
-0.0077259918,
-0.010551692,
-0.0019824551,
0.0297551453,
0.0578416884,
0.0177240614,
-0.0196353737,
0.0176380612,
-0.058523491,
0.0136572197,
-0.0207590796,
-0.017796278,
-0.0099788802,
0.0316588283,
-0.0056365584,
-0.0408203192,
-0.0374504626,
0.0331580974,
0.0492839292,
-0.013110267,
0.0455626883,
0.0422504991,
-0.0568938255,
-0.0429050252,
0.0467746481,
0.0024379126,
-0.01101356,
0.031809479,
-0.0438799299,
-0.1051802859,
0.0371553563,
-0.0413314104,
0.0477339253,
-0.0146352667,
-0.0257569719,
0.0283651929,
-0.0023861858,
-0.0172858145,
0.0564735197,
0.0064290999,
0.0201087035,
-0.0194608644,
-0.0212701131,
-0.0561596043,
0.0503025167,
-0.0751101449,
-0.0098215789,
-0.0283610485,
-0.0019076404,
0.0631406456,
0.0398152322,
0.0146597605,
0.0069021503,
-0.0481297411,
-0.0222476963,
0.0260619465,
-0.0107729277,
-0.0083822887,
0.003333664,
-0.0262122341,
0.0450608693,
0.0268244073,
-0.0212956239,
0.0561175942,
0.0036746007,
-0.021316072,
-0.1053539664,
-0.0475412607,
-0.0735903084,
0.0511068068,
-0.056577716,
0.0397349447,
0.0237442907,
-0.0496322438,
0.0198764354,
0.0206267219,
-0.0517180748,
-0.0077821985,
0.0197916217,
-0.0325451344,
0.0330512039,
-0.0188575815,
-0.0153869484,
-0.0504803732,
-0.0446261466,
-0.0321100503,
0.0333406329,
0.0402523726,
0.0013042239,
-0.0316565707,
0.002110516,
0.0073700296,
0.0422957614,
0.0002550443,
-0.0208296664,
-0.0415484309,
0.0169010013,
0.0454167314,
0.0710715726,
0.0367788039,
0.0443795472,
0.0188321453,
0.0312561058,
0.0334178917,
-0.0035565072,
-0.0545613319,
-0.0323333479,
0.0079873195,
-0.0356157795,
0.0380556062,
0.0400675423,
0.013272563,
-0.0030696678,
-0.0017151471,
0.0837469548,
0.0303839166,
-0.0433493964,
0.0136386007,
0.0096416911,
-0.0215369985,
0.0380952545,
0.0656186864,
-0.0533571579,
-0.0367295146,
-0.0246897209,
0.0282791536,
0.0014451611,
-0.0205028299,
-0.0334889293,
-0.0820054412,
0.0739631057,
-0.0505876504,
0.0174692106,
-0.0544338897,
0.0046565365,
0.0061520021,
0.0340387486,
0.063099362,
-0.0321037099,
-0.0018083872,
-0.0459601991,
0.0132078305,
0.0069245431,
-0.0631870478,
0.0187893435,
-0.0305402242,
0.0629862174,
0.0756880865,
0.0092595993,
0.0337658189,
0.0180164278,
-0.0092293229,
0.0096007846,
0.0629823655,
0.0014771889,
0.0357774831,
-0.0219153985,
0.0092926333,
0.0063960366,
0.0201139934,
-0.0901430547,
0.0240875594,
0.0202560499,
0.0115027614,
-0.053871166,
0.0069674859,
-0.0309181809,
0.0389142781,
0.0521606766,
0.0809549168,
-0.0020001817,
-0.0353387035,
-0.0340266675,
-0.0119477455,
0.0270061381,
-0.0021901235,
0.0065147788,
-0.0062805745,
-0.007909026,
0.0201417841,
-0.0743241981,
-0.082873337,
0.0417924933,
-0.0156253912,
0.0268880054,
-0.0048282542,
0.0305724572,
0.0107414974,
-0.0059506814,
-0.0147643862,
-0.0088291802,
0.0472389832,
-0.0512313917,
0.0070979791,
0.0259570573,
-0.0516200811,
-0.009643225,
0.0122244954,
-0.0441464968,
-0.0496546291,
-0.0106176632,
0.0612612367,
0.0184468031,
0.0275358483,
-0.0018549813,
-0.0463501401,
-0.0493754633,
0.0646603405,
-0.0766523629,
-0.0093559399,
-0.009356047,
0.0434601679,
-0.0280318204,
0.0354254991,
-0.0567939617,
0.0173015818,
-0.0365002379,
0.0602102801,
0.0159809124,
-0.0519224331,
0.0338082165,
-0.0006155972,
-0.0144620277,
0.0234626755,
0.0157076549,
-0.0332218818,
0.0320479311,
-0.0148425475,
0.0031177092,
-0.0700218081,
-0.0238702651,
-0.0670626312,
-0.0120307272,
0.0395864919,
-0.0146597875,
-0.0618372858,
0.0248410776,
-0.0198705476,
0.0093218712,
-0.0034148658,
0.015086134,
-0.0114004705,
-0.0088641727,
-0.0062184837,
0.001734185,
0.0102845281,
0.0558920354,
-0.0021453162,
0.0727975518,
0.0201186985,
-0.0374156982,
-0.0462927818,
0.0391614623,
-0.0411951318,
-0.0964548066,
0.0217950288,
0.0144768059,
0.0235923771,
0.0077873692,
0.0036036656,
-0.0583112948,
0.0431217365,
-0.0097660283,
0.0340841189,
0.0063306331,
0.0052451878,
0.0168325175,
-0.0009660025,
-0.0081716962,
-0.0195546988,
0.059514761,
-0.0456740782,
0.0059022172,
-0.0217889305,
-0.0054077073,
-0.0733027905,
-0.0327914134,
0.0271553993,
0.027391132,
-0.0361840315,
-0.0158157051,
-0.0469544567,
0.0039749285,
0.0045653218,
-0.0343365483,
-0.0078851348,
-0.0312377512,
0.0305278637,
0.0439306423,
0.0214873999,
-0.0531153046,
-0.0186657235,
-0.0137365339,
-0.0847956911,
-0.0098890737,
-0.0479293428,
-5.917137342e-33,
-0.0121692792,
0.0078348098,
0.0399528481,
0.0281093419,
0.0150122782,
0.0174390133,
-0.044329498,
-0.0284235533,
-0.0018847036,
-0.0293246973,
-0.0215810202,
0.0181968603,
0.0133117866,
0.0009854552,
-0.0090016508,
-0.0276235845,
0.0542068407,
-0.0299146306,
0.0233966578,
0.0647664592,
0.0174660385,
0.0511461571,
0.0283505954,
-0.1024871171,
0.0328686498,
0.0019052532,
0.0290586166,
0.0471454486,
0.0097766882,
0.0317682773,
-0.0357191637,
0.0717038512,
0.0317469612,
-0.0529478751,
0.0338640511,
0.0412855931,
-0.0249115527,
-0.0286305863,
-0.0004290506,
-0.0051697604,
-0.0595506765,
-0.0057418072,
0.0041982718,
-0.0235366952,
-0.0027817271,
0.0633544996,
0.0283509232,
0.0012056549,
0.006008219,
0.0002053782,
-0.0881166011,
-0.0222416725,
-0.013867165,
-0.0423664488,
0.0111510716,
0.0514073782,
0.0127477292,
-0.0030298799,
-0.063391231,
0.0033673267,
-0.0462839454,
-0.0377239808,
0.0116277356,
-0.0075072213,
-0.0449843667,
0.0384115875,
0.0501845814,
-0.0079165464,
-0.018595282,
-0.0114022596,
-0.0266238786,
0.0774172917,
-0.0137036843,
0.0179813579,
-0.0312348865,
-0.0392609015,
-0.0109780058,
0.0535387509,
0.0783946961,
0.0344154015,
0.0461642705,
-0.0166600719,
-0.0654508024,
-0.001274984,
0.0174885709,
0.00364716,
-0.0362402834,
-0.0270730034,
0.0580794662,
0.0441394225,
-0.0125467665,
-0.0031863623,
0.0307106618,
-0.0477574654,
0.0371120572,
-0.0003864398,
-0.0108198496,
-0.007114687,
0.0055242321,
-0.0066607678,
-0.0782101527,
-0.0015298896,
0.0003449136,
-0.0102220103,
-0.0084148366,
-0.0124884238,
-0.0147568295,
0.0198587291,
0.0159990899,
0.0290703885,
-0.0281302221,
0.0520597249,
-0.0303408206,
0.0318385176,
-0.0264779944,
0.0422204956,
-0.0342062488,
0.0605151206,
0.0046432395,
0.020235084,
-0.0341362171,
-0.006478678,
0.0397681892,
-0.0026986948,
-0.0405407138,
0.0026312857,
-0.0048314249,
0.0372191295,
0.0086077629,
-0.0256372448,
-0.0105755981,
0.0030002499,
2.582e-7,
-0.0144312782,
0.0302588176,
0.0120784286,
0.0453047715,
0.0177755188,
0.0474796742,
0.0172940008,
0.0257575158,
-0.0077239876,
0.0211349037,
0.0050584143,
-0.016823221,
0.0072625675,
-0.0020114372,
-0.0790915415,
-0.0257836357,
0.0068237078,
-0.0173829161,
-0.0762068853,
0.0045653544,
0.0663962141,
0.0319656283,
-0.0424219221,
-0.0359148979,
-0.0156743918,
-0.0190840848,
0.0327014476,
-0.0477167256,
0.0118581979,
0.0338919312,
0.031751506,
0.0220986176,
-0.0118799303,
-0.022284342,
0.0003657149,
0.0637177229,
-0.0274904091,
0.038461335,
-0.0169614237,
-0.0817752853,
0.0278903432,
0.0231547635,
0.0354114734,
-0.0375982374,
0.0197305214,
-0.0662643313,
-0.0336251855,
0.0002604057,
-0.0164230093,
0.0012563105,
-0.0606918335,
-0.004097783,
-0.0010191198,
-0.0080352128,
-0.0021999457,
-0.0512338281,
0.0070332363,
-0.0763848498,
0.0512954034,
-0.0025998079,
-0.033677496,
0.0213840157,
-0.0361251943,
-0.0023040609,
0.0095704682,
-0.0175809022,
0.0267760009,
1.832919298e-34,
0.007278393,
-0.005355563,
-0.0004313337,
0.0822028145,
0.0101387864,
0.0032741202,
-0.0232655518,
0.0156005183,
0.020511942,
-0.0661092922,
-0.0301009621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03205v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03205v1 | An entity-guided text summarization framework with relational heterogeneous graph neural network | 2023-02-07T02:27:21 | 2023-02-07T02:27:21 | Jingqiang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Two crucial issues for text summarization to generate faithful summaries are
to make use of knowledge beyond text and to make use of cross-sentence
relations in text. Intuitive ways for the two issues are Knowledge Graph (KG)
and Graph Neural Network (GNN) respectively. Entities are semantic units in
text and in KG. This paper focuses on both issues by leveraging entities
mentioned in text to connect GNN and KG for summarization. Firstly, entities
are leveraged to construct a sentence-entity graph with weighted multi-type
edges to model sentence relations, and a relational heterogeneous GNN for
summarization is proposed to calculate node encodings. Secondly, entities are
leveraged to link the graph to KG to collect knowledge. Thirdly, entities guide
a two-step summarization framework defining a multi-task selector to select
salient sentences and entities, and using an entity-focused abstractor to
compress the sentences. GNN is connected with KG by constructing
sentence-entity graphs where entity-entity edges are built based on KG,
initializing entity embeddings on KG, and training entity embeddings using
entity-entity edges. The relational heterogeneous GNN utilizes both edge
weights and edge types in GNN to calculate graphs with weighted multi-type
edges. Experiments show the proposed method outperforms extractive baselines
including the HGNN-based HGNNSum and abstractive baselines including the
entity-driven SENECA on CNN/DM, and outperforms most baselines on NYT50.
Experiments on sub-datasets show the density of sentence-entity edges greatly
influences the performance of the proposed method. The greater the density, the
better the performance. Ablations show effectiveness of the method. | [
0.0431676432,
0.0037780558,
0.0228247568,
0.0317220129,
-0.0097354148,
0.0085727358,
-0.0413329527,
-0.0325371325,
0.0546932556,
-0.0409015603,
0.0112898368,
0.0050599505,
0.008422303,
0.0177300628,
0.0370994136,
-0.077242583,
-0.0057764575,
0.0451179557,
0.0182110611,
-0.0067205732,
0.0255779549,
0.0486367419,
0.0325837284,
0.0132209938,
-0.0232095327,
0.0207901504,
-0.0082441382,
0.0307598989,
0.0449316204,
-0.0093230251,
0.0218967833,
-0.0322061889,
0.0355119966,
-0.0133319218,
0.0000021016,
-0.0308031999,
-0.0300280526,
0.0020968944,
-0.0114643108,
-0.0038190838,
0.0268055368,
-0.0494394302,
0.0211919509,
-0.0219018478,
-0.0042303693,
-0.0278612413,
-0.0033508553,
0.061937511,
0.0462120473,
0.0761179179,
-0.0381357558,
-0.037458647,
0.0415310487,
-0.0088469172,
-0.039564468,
-0.0231375583,
0.0147311753,
0.0396551862,
-0.0134507474,
-0.0105490526,
-0.0115117244,
0.0249891821,
0.0334758721,
0.0037429046,
0.0744328201,
0.03719965,
-0.0338679068,
0.0330748893,
0.0156093808,
0.1122870594,
-0.0131912557,
0.0081595564,
0.027675515,
-0.0040861764,
0.0006051024,
-0.0181002337,
-0.0328750834,
0.0250784867,
-0.0040633371,
0.0455368645,
-0.0346520394,
0.0056345379,
0.0004837739,
0.0289602261,
-0.0297731347,
0.004986186,
-0.005963868,
0.00486319,
0.0076809186,
0.0253652465,
-0.0527569838,
-0.0369452685,
0.0482329167,
0.0466893427,
-0.0016746377,
-0.0213050712,
-0.0312330555,
-0.0488692522,
0.0120497961,
-0.0508422367,
-0.0239898171,
0.0138116721,
0.0392178372,
0.0242918637,
-0.0325597674,
0.0243056379,
0.0128213847,
0.015078404,
-0.0529901274,
-0.034075629,
-0.043939814,
0.0128661161,
-0.0747870803,
0.0765013918,
-0.0172024369,
-0.0419532992,
-0.0430252738,
0.0130312908,
0.0046927375,
0.0173472594,
0.0445657,
0.0671845526,
0.0089061698,
-0.0057640583,
0.017998863,
0.0210471656,
-0.0537525639,
-0.0101153143,
0.0054578558,
0.0309226941,
0.0008927357,
0.0108955717,
0.0601652935,
-0.0093708318,
-0.0011989078,
0.0252942294,
-0.0192514677,
-0.0219505839,
-0.0406738669,
-0.0414003953,
-0.0005929735,
-0.0363660641,
-0.0151298167,
-0.0603064299,
0.0169519987,
-0.0026154066,
-0.0230555348,
-0.0169073623,
0.0014224716,
-0.0022327276,
-0.0875462964,
0.0005676731,
-0.0371707417,
-0.0205939598,
0.0269126985,
-0.0050124424,
0.017143691,
0.0446997248,
0.0867310986,
0.0422275923,
0.0426462442,
0.0473683216,
-0.0572039783,
0.0193278771,
0.0334622599,
0.0069397814,
0.0313992426,
-0.0162322391,
-0.0842017978,
0.0002304093,
0.0448658019,
0.0822794735,
-0.0424630567,
0.0046590432,
0.0439850129,
0.0426144414,
-0.031276498,
0.0461471304,
0.0458593443,
0.0461265445,
-0.0016460791,
0.0726401582,
-0.0030128539,
0.0323995873,
-0.0096301204,
0.0496745221,
0.0627703965,
0.0133901639,
-0.0372862667,
-0.0074004238,
0.0338142067,
-0.0149145508,
0.0518358052,
-0.0054698354,
0.0383737274,
0.0123221129,
-0.0763350949,
0.0413143113,
0.0033534456,
-0.0414980948,
0.0132291857,
0.0237385854,
-0.0145948296,
0.0491863415,
0.0167514738,
-0.0064990665,
-0.0185417328,
-0.0162134822,
-0.0308434889,
0.0031764884,
0.0285034943,
-0.0363506004,
-0.0042939312,
-0.0730004385,
-0.0412675552,
-0.0341793038,
-0.0117050586,
0.0007356711,
-0.0261082053,
0.0082742078,
0.047281228,
-0.0472657494,
-0.0281463526,
0.0126230186,
0.0337864831,
0.0291053466,
-0.0084465193,
0.0050613331,
-0.0252417345,
0.0470727272,
-0.0106589897,
0.0058085532,
0.0054314355,
-0.0292394441,
-0.0368560627,
-0.0270053707,
-0.0457886718,
-0.0559750609,
0.0120568294,
-0.0514419936,
0.0046153828,
0.0060988851,
-0.0385313593,
-0.0620195344,
0.0410123058,
-0.0505490117,
0.02290361,
-0.0261943843,
-0.0325365774,
0.0213793758,
0.0040136175,
-0.00752196,
0.0835121274,
0.0047001075,
-0.0128245624,
0.020536622,
-0.0526078902,
-0.0138474274,
-0.0421591625,
-0.0051145954,
-0.0194869339,
0.0278054066,
0.0122183217,
0.0458126813,
-0.00409743,
-0.0216020532,
0.0014085014,
-0.1212908104,
0.0210551396,
-0.0032461931,
0.0214047022,
0.0404588878,
0.0315895453,
0.0051728408,
-0.0098018181,
-0.0287977047,
0.0000328438,
-0.0025138943,
-0.017504219,
0.0238361601,
-0.0001731235,
0.0520568527,
-0.0249125119,
-0.054273203,
-0.0243274942,
0.0939597338,
-0.0003591388,
-0.0690730587,
0.0058161537,
0.0425783135,
-0.0419644825,
-0.0053836103,
0.0107547622,
0.0119289365,
-0.0359422229,
0.0321037844,
0.0664121658,
0.0264203921,
0.0112353899,
-0.001240136,
0.0196245536,
-0.010941484,
-0.0325033478,
0.0123974271,
-0.0223102253,
0.0944560319,
0.0067405896,
-0.0248183012,
0.0002986584,
0.0099230455,
0.0422342718,
-0.0429839902,
-0.0265023932,
0.0119512007,
-0.0111052124,
0.0235326719,
-0.0405875035,
-0.0199021064,
0.032250952,
-0.065319851,
-0.063627772,
0.037960276,
0.0608314425,
0.0163366701,
0.0325056352,
-0.0167270266,
-0.0207602121,
-0.0521544367,
0.0232031699,
0.0106397383,
0.0284894258,
0.0175413433,
-0.0178656932,
-0.0420351364,
-0.0229151547,
0.0217172354,
-0.0011962014,
0.0666633546,
0.012910123,
0.0285635348,
-0.0260642637,
0.0063628196,
0.0121324984,
0.0330297463,
-0.0203760974,
0.065094389,
0.0516392998,
0.0238948353,
0.0281090438,
-0.0109498398,
0.0176467374,
0.0250337478,
-0.042145703,
-0.0118716434,
-0.0175857339,
0.116831921,
0.05623037,
0.0198275372,
0.0126053439,
-0.0111260451,
0.0352470651,
0.0395063683,
0.0051774383,
-0.0457686186,
-0.0202097688,
0.0054840818,
-0.0320488103,
-0.0567605309,
0.0061519137,
-0.0254506432,
0.0813057646,
-0.0268106218,
0.0335696638,
0.0661732107,
-0.0006420856,
-0.0462301448,
-0.0136966147,
0.0342101641,
0.03878152,
0.0017644584,
-0.0004755198,
-0.0877331421,
0.0022507214,
-0.0106360149,
0.0019812873,
0.0271188244,
-0.0639081001,
0.0051395688,
-0.0444310606,
-0.0227155127,
0.0028799733,
-0.0467361175,
-0.035399884,
-0.0176523607,
0.0162413083,
-0.0004942559,
0.016100714,
-0.0160665531,
-0.0078351982,
-0.0052666212,
0.0036660342,
-0.0426068939,
0.0189443603,
-0.0211011749,
-0.0278304145,
-0.022122046,
-0.0031982618,
0.0536292382,
0.0040321592,
0.0482736342,
0.0195943657,
-0.0437874235,
-0.0286016203,
0.0061971331,
0.0929479823,
-0.0152990678,
0.0227111354,
-0.0565889031,
0.0242024474,
0.0031155145,
-0.0020341729,
-0.0055130455,
0.0474737547,
0.0234516021,
-0.0557616726,
-0.036599163,
-0.0078730388,
-0.0168968122,
0.0383961089,
0.0315462872,
0.0088166595,
-0.0677128732,
-0.0245806482,
0.0085235573,
-0.1209420785,
-0.0013019401,
0.0330899172,
-0.0404419042,
0.0214828923,
-0.0508992001,
-0.0632544458,
0.0201075319,
-0.0478213951,
-0.0008754637,
-0.0236816574,
0.050883498,
-0.0095036514,
-0.0540972538,
-0.0078270622,
-0.0131394612,
0.010856363,
0.0414595939,
-0.0275314599,
0.0326069966,
-0.0088049173,
-0.0084286071,
0.0066893501,
-0.0255539455,
-0.0576564707,
-0.0588663481,
0.0247414187,
-0.0012615146,
0.0729011297,
0.0059299753,
-0.0098516494,
0.083273977,
0.0040392624,
-0.0390592925,
0.0147335837,
0.0101152696,
0.0237419512,
-0.0335975513,
0.0313659012,
-0.0826038793,
0.0345411859,
-0.011696768,
0.0778968409,
-0.048724059,
-0.0656004995,
-0.0102782361,
0.0119437613,
-0.0382886678,
-0.0054788888,
0.0445600003,
-0.0761820525,
-0.0280709788,
-0.008036566,
0.0042330422,
-0.0371617973,
0.0329219475,
-0.0439888313,
0.0244018808,
-0.0098743876,
0.038227845,
0.0409038439,
0.0042169578,
-0.0509246364,
-0.0190799553,
-0.0405398048,
-0.0372530259,
-0.0328703113,
0.0171784908,
-0.0552389584,
-0.0219957922,
-0.0333664715,
-0.0192407109,
-0.0187353231,
-0.0025611639,
0.0382180177,
-0.0363987274,
-0.0298147444,
0.0136526637,
-0.05995344,
0.0707014427,
-0.0636003464,
-0.0056663631,
0.0783151016,
-0.0167929083,
0.0432051532,
0.0058981376,
-0.0145116188,
-0.0112192854,
0.0537206419,
0.0245468784,
-0.0091098994,
-0.034307979,
0.0176736023,
0.0179258622,
0.0193678737,
0.0589644238,
-0.0124318916,
0.0289278794,
0.0252290964,
-0.0390594974,
-0.0538703464,
-0.0499470718,
0.0088067567,
0.0390622467,
-0.0131303901,
-0.0303429049,
-0.0196400769,
-0.0493016727,
0.0477790721,
0.0073187943,
-0.0047354773,
-0.0011676626,
0.0534541085,
-0.0331402831,
0.0304245036,
-0.0198821854,
-0.0299742203,
0.0101691391,
-0.0340324044,
0.0094676316,
0.0056079109,
-6.20281553e-33,
-0.0174485799,
-0.0166018866,
-0.0211523306,
-0.0048437882,
-0.0794165209,
0.0508617237,
-0.0928179771,
-0.0293549113,
-0.01823253,
0.0306448992,
0.0095037688,
0.013310357,
-0.0084316032,
0.0478200056,
-0.0212202612,
0.017358575,
0.0213759113,
-0.0071640438,
-0.0027488694,
0.057086803,
0.0212464705,
0.0524335131,
0.0610451587,
-0.0254959408,
0.0351289138,
-0.0287447665,
0.0191110857,
-0.0280080102,
0.0679517686,
0.0148260975,
-0.0200745706,
0.0521449633,
0.0449892916,
-0.0109938234,
-0.0221450701,
0.0039233654,
-0.1120460778,
-0.044487033,
0.0021499842,
-0.0397114865,
-0.0622809194,
-0.0419421159,
0.0364534222,
0.0013719512,
0.0513399877,
-0.0540755577,
0.0871711224,
-0.0097923046,
-0.033491265,
-0.0856507495,
-0.0133207096,
0.0259622112,
-0.0389174893,
-0.0045729913,
0.0118839517,
0.0258946251,
0.0162970573,
-0.0262575615,
-0.0628095046,
0.0037976929,
-0.0284022372,
-0.0199237969,
-0.0385352485,
0.0215251446,
0.012344365,
0.0584473535,
-0.0295340475,
-0.0219572857,
-0.090856269,
0.0437646322,
0.0071346313,
0.0047012619,
-0.0090145394,
-0.0153347813,
-0.0110021532,
0.0043338956,
-0.0866383538,
0.0608593971,
0.0126952715,
0.0117738796,
0.0055486546,
-0.0052533499,
0.0203398652,
-0.0236280151,
0.0227039866,
-0.0280571096,
-0.0086954851,
-0.0246549901,
-0.0513852797,
0.0076013608,
-0.0397888124,
0.0163800921,
-0.0015524239,
-0.0621235855,
-0.0099268714,
0.0727781728,
-0.0080486555,
0.0260332935,
0.0458656847,
0.0021183407,
-0.0364167206,
0.0085363239,
0.0229198541,
0.0079345759,
-0.0074343993,
0.0091895144,
0.0619595535,
0.0061065848,
0.0033524593,
0.0064447895,
0.0047633299,
-0.0130927665,
-0.0590286776,
0.0320377201,
-0.0351192914,
0.0369049832,
-0.0082177315,
0.0293578506,
0.0112209423,
0.0306417886,
0.0129668312,
0.0731325373,
0.05519839,
0.0653688908,
-0.0239123572,
-0.0006414388,
-0.0137512349,
0.0378009155,
0.0084029818,
-0.0422063544,
-0.0230607316,
0.0087782461,
2.689e-7,
0.045185972,
-0.0053771273,
0.0959270895,
0.0006985135,
-0.0216100477,
0.0082440171,
-0.0043038917,
0.0715061352,
0.0246501882,
-0.0288034007,
0.0478004999,
0.0704030097,
-0.0053655845,
0.0215207171,
-0.0916080847,
-0.0036907184,
-0.0418951735,
-0.0607298873,
-0.0393669643,
0.0144158835,
0.0635853708,
0.0215002652,
0.0147710675,
0.0174023788,
-0.0436082445,
0.015624973,
0.0287196022,
0.0087990519,
-0.0065937531,
0.019522978,
0.0045458465,
-0.0020705627,
-0.0543745272,
0.0243910234,
-0.0053786612,
0.011830979,
0.0678699538,
0.0266236197,
-0.006659728,
-0.0173798651,
-0.0018975975,
-0.0284243859,
0.0301785711,
0.0144239161,
0.0498788506,
-0.0678712279,
-0.0212090779,
-0.0010973557,
-0.0165699739,
0.0334974229,
-0.0291182566,
-0.0032157595,
-0.039408356,
0.0379437283,
0.0191209968,
-0.0119471792,
0.004638182,
-0.0609755218,
-0.0170837492,
0.0522305258,
0.0099165114,
-0.0172110815,
0.0006613688,
-0.0073554879,
0.0201608092,
-0.0489410982,
0.0225724038,
2.344054203e-34,
0.0526142009,
0.0001542284,
-0.0427273475,
-0.0145896198,
0.0099078855,
-0.0740817934,
-0.0394979902,
-0.0343458354,
0.0110996133,
-0.0632298738,
-0.0184757765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03202v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03202v2 | Exploring the Benefits of Training Expert Language Models over Instruction Tuning | 2023-02-07T02:24:30 | 2023-02-09T04:55:39 | Joel Jang, Seungone Kim, Seonghyeon Ye, Doyoung Kim, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Kyungjae Lee, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Language Models (LMs) instruction-tuned on multiple tasks, also
known as multitask-prompted fine-tuning (MT), have shown the capability to
generalize to unseen tasks. Previous work has shown that scaling the number of
training tasks is the key component in making stronger MT LMs. In this work, we
report an unexpected finding that an expert LM fine-tuned on just a single task
can outperform an MT LM trained with 300+ different tasks on 11 different
unseen datasets and on 13 datasets of the BIG-bench benchmark by a mean
accuracy of 3.20% and 1.29%, respectively. This finding casts doubt on the
previously held belief that simply scaling the number of tasks makes stronger
MT LMs. Leveraging this finding, we further show that this distributed approach
of training a separate expert LM per training task instead of a single MT LM
for zero-shot inference possesses many benefits including (1) avoiding negative
task transfer that often occurs during instruction tuning, (2) being able to
continually learn new tasks without having to re-train on previous tasks to
avoid catastrophic forgetting, and (3) showing compositional capabilities when
merging individual experts together. The code is available at
https://github.com/joeljang/ELM. | [
0.0414341949,
0.0416942351,
-0.0196640491,
0.0148460185,
-0.0103645511,
0.0291855447,
0.045326449,
-0.0410665385,
-0.0283237249,
-0.0489662327,
-0.0940974951,
0.0074952715,
-0.0050646439,
-0.0068035759,
0.0528444536,
-0.0402913913,
0.0244372208,
-0.0372639969,
0.0182310976,
-0.0109400861,
0.0031225369,
0.0354627557,
-0.0172068607,
0.04210186,
0.0165360291,
0.0047201011,
-0.0051708966,
0.0254727453,
0.0241538547,
0.0244998392,
0.0315553024,
0.0584979951,
0.0426764786,
0.0089125838,
0.0000020346,
-0.034037549,
0.0181910302,
-0.0343827941,
-0.0199562609,
-0.0110358233,
0.0227585863,
-0.0134836463,
0.0307085831,
0.0149433687,
-0.0170565639,
-0.0378362089,
0.0556338876,
0.0211862829,
0.0419990644,
0.1116272956,
0.005094836,
-0.0201836415,
0.0258353483,
-0.0412471034,
0.0067239939,
-0.0198513586,
0.0297930315,
-0.000590489,
-0.0217954982,
0.0351537652,
-0.0268412381,
0.0194961876,
0.0248521287,
0.029502362,
-0.0060139135,
0.0585589036,
-0.041939307,
-0.0309977364,
-0.0227790866,
0.0492928214,
-0.0575515255,
-0.0245556347,
-0.0010893482,
-0.0038177546,
-0.005473386,
0.0161093716,
-0.0382174253,
0.0251042955,
-0.006624565,
0.0194760673,
0.0336798579,
-0.0261600055,
0.0468846709,
0.0285956971,
-0.014364237,
0.0448715277,
0.0102924658,
-0.014846704,
-0.0022265492,
0.0140278572,
-0.0551595539,
-0.0398595259,
-0.0223278236,
0.003742812,
-0.0260881484,
0.0107690785,
-0.0644374788,
-0.0426001772,
-0.0012437097,
0.0015315105,
0.0650463328,
0.0331269279,
-0.0213730522,
0.0667288452,
-0.0370797738,
0.0196173321,
0.023635786,
0.0411093198,
-0.0557322614,
-0.0200946573,
-0.0980946496,
0.0007555528,
-0.0111840153,
-0.0035663522,
-0.0148252081,
0.00356229,
-0.0108790267,
0.008382082,
-0.0136019317,
-0.017298935,
0.0083789099,
-0.0040475596,
-0.0857704803,
-0.0295788124,
0.0159710944,
0.036535047,
-0.0383647196,
0.068964377,
-0.0004465005,
-0.0362163074,
-0.0218901392,
0.0426203832,
-0.0088198557,
-0.0277258642,
0.0441530794,
0.0380171053,
0.0044835927,
-0.0225711223,
-0.006984686,
0.0059877397,
-0.0181996748,
-0.0821944177,
-0.0003253813,
-0.0568278544,
0.0515333451,
0.0048231087,
0.0025045429,
-0.0144423638,
-0.0124957925,
-0.004221146,
-0.0476166382,
0.0519115515,
0.0023735508,
0.032612551,
0.0321544409,
-0.0084932027,
-0.0344361067,
0.088360548,
0.0118847257,
-0.0103970692,
0.0202297829,
-0.0042654509,
0.0176915191,
0.0326281078,
-0.0180397723,
0.0251752418,
0.0219235998,
0.0008360767,
-0.0016028547,
0.0049826382,
0.0442044884,
0.0250204392,
-0.0361440703,
0.000633475,
0.0655312538,
0.0189448036,
-0.0017318209,
0.0014892749,
0.0567871556,
0.0270397644,
0.0034790707,
0.0324548073,
-0.0747432634,
0.0262654964,
-0.0129399579,
0.0031194489,
0.0074416716,
0.0230346825,
-0.050469134,
-0.0064388327,
-0.0067745582,
-0.0186711475,
-0.0273657609,
0.0228901152,
0.0634043515,
-0.0074567432,
-0.0349201001,
0.0199870691,
0.0585217886,
-0.0163102243,
0.0093683433,
-0.0733961016,
-0.0031035149,
0.0559903383,
0.0038197013,
-0.0092545319,
-0.048673328,
-0.0133770658,
0.0604671612,
0.0177497864,
0.040770635,
-0.018184755,
0.0524543747,
-0.0667687431,
-0.0250006914,
-0.046054244,
0.0369115062,
0.0043638293,
0.0205493364,
-0.005703635,
0.0169214662,
-0.0463979021,
-0.0350482389,
0.0298145972,
-0.0469009355,
-0.0109074339,
-0.0173332654,
0.0188087132,
-0.0192622617,
-0.040342208,
-0.0297776908,
0.0006584974,
0.0090719312,
-0.0431385897,
0.0210048873,
0.0062564062,
-0.0606569089,
-0.0204306915,
0.0054677515,
-0.0352725014,
-0.0127913551,
0.0260881539,
-0.0493859798,
-0.0444386266,
0.0072948951,
-0.0006118463,
0.022953948,
-0.0126132835,
0.0157469232,
-0.0251136497,
0.0164718926,
-0.0237526465,
0.035583511,
0.0083661722,
0.0014645185,
0.0068693697,
0.0074400492,
-0.0203498565,
-0.0297509599,
-0.015298117,
-0.0293339975,
0.0224386379,
0.015483398,
-0.0009574269,
0.0177522525,
-0.0559130944,
-0.0394798405,
-0.1160754114,
0.016471399,
-0.0458472706,
0.0317639336,
0.0400900841,
-0.0071892696,
-0.0175199155,
0.0016048398,
-0.0176830962,
0.007843338,
-0.0365155078,
0.0285135042,
0.0099699292,
-0.0085352706,
-0.0265175253,
-0.0383034535,
-0.022150442,
-0.0155568942,
0.025382407,
-0.0001891331,
-0.0063020135,
-0.052269239,
0.0139222927,
-0.0108408872,
0.0152338566,
-0.0165925175,
-0.0252492446,
-0.0125210872,
-0.0304285344,
0.0643870905,
0.0906407684,
-0.0229361709,
-0.0031287437,
0.0480669066,
-0.0217135586,
-0.0430407077,
0.0232337248,
-0.006899931,
-0.0161869731,
-0.0455128103,
0.0047347732,
-0.0268453881,
0.0759521797,
-0.0096381698,
-0.0316767953,
-0.0573538654,
-0.0031848999,
0.0009910001,
-0.0341727622,
0.0254848208,
0.0044417609,
-0.0046067056,
0.0017221522,
-0.0442639329,
-0.0761219487,
0.0782668442,
-0.0097945817,
-0.013826943,
-0.0621943213,
-0.0108319065,
-0.024895709,
0.0623084269,
0.0135061862,
0.011155,
0.0060963789,
0.0028522594,
-0.0839618742,
-0.0031465364,
0.0213801861,
0.0095397029,
0.0248611476,
-0.0640442371,
-0.0100888181,
-0.021930309,
-0.0413594432,
-0.0020452414,
-0.0331472531,
-0.038213592,
0.027264256,
0.0169544797,
-0.0190192647,
-0.0744425356,
-0.0158131439,
0.0327186026,
0.0426591635,
-0.014812096,
-0.0012981929,
-0.0074314,
-0.0083423713,
0.0388886072,
-0.0044981008,
-0.0317324027,
-0.0871121436,
0.0142989345,
0.022924114,
0.0540613309,
0.000101761,
-0.017405808,
0.0138292322,
0.0210730731,
-0.023799032,
-0.043865066,
0.0233587902,
0.0780702233,
-0.0676164478,
-0.0086767524,
0.1021567583,
-0.0026349821,
-0.0548166558,
-0.0006128764,
0.0231786687,
0.0072915354,
0.0341527797,
0.0258140303,
-0.0746971071,
-0.0634428188,
0.0074451249,
0.0164738763,
0.0283034742,
-0.0131107159,
-0.0123289023,
-0.097656697,
-0.0034727925,
0.0109956171,
-0.0556044914,
-0.0141793014,
-0.0329058953,
0.025944069,
-0.0263025127,
0.0040826062,
-0.0075920708,
-0.0030689584,
0.0230500121,
0.0453920066,
0.008669978,
-0.086667411,
0.0592326,
-0.0547973104,
0.0707566962,
0.052522026,
-0.0047052009,
-0.0062189614,
-0.0300077014,
0.0314597487,
0.0160452612,
0.0132984258,
-0.0022406294,
0.047231406,
-0.0553083345,
-0.0073914202,
0.0180776659,
0.0489185788,
-0.0087145604,
0.0139464661,
0.0235865656,
0.0510681868,
0.0029127318,
-0.0365759172,
0.0110198641,
-0.0356321186,
0.0068597342,
0.083033748,
0.0251035467,
-0.0602946244,
-0.0131869959,
-0.0093468251,
-0.0361823887,
-0.0525259003,
-0.0082678786,
0.0419614427,
-0.0038138994,
-0.0217580963,
-0.027535554,
-0.028687153,
0.0722913742,
0.0435509719,
0.0316545106,
-0.0112005714,
-0.0140349595,
0.003247146,
-0.0210110135,
0.0499067567,
-0.0266794264,
0.0123382872,
-0.0525252633,
-0.044160746,
0.0595588163,
-0.0166189298,
0.0074297595,
0.0170846805,
-0.1245618984,
-0.0665539876,
-0.0219321158,
0.0691024214,
0.0166920424,
0.0594136007,
0.0070140935,
-0.0613781624,
0.0167922843,
0.0296949726,
-0.0635783747,
0.0339727588,
0.0575043075,
-0.0181270242,
0.0196460858,
0.0608108602,
-0.038260866,
0.0329790674,
0.0565776601,
0.0214300361,
-0.0098718936,
-0.0142934611,
-0.0302464794,
-0.0087003065,
0.0514153838,
-0.0118828379,
0.0091756405,
-0.0368334875,
0.0165944546,
0.0236273408,
-0.0160649661,
-0.0385485366,
-0.0134182852,
0.0104595143,
0.0089774849,
0.0127938529,
0.04046892,
0.0317258239,
0.0111404881,
-0.0500290021,
0.0269364566,
0.0088225463,
0.0057688886,
0.0323102698,
0.0178935118,
-0.0504691005,
0.0095750708,
0.0087266155,
0.0323450975,
-0.0307105184,
0.0331972428,
0.0146290176,
0.0125139309,
-0.0315292999,
0.00881398,
-0.0738869533,
-0.0413281545,
-0.0093233557,
0.0269695129,
0.0709952712,
-0.0270146616,
0.0640550479,
0.0112370206,
-0.0088473028,
-0.046143923,
0.026241798,
0.0055758441,
-0.0014179446,
0.0087300595,
0.0292655323,
-0.0191366859,
0.0342180915,
0.09213911,
-0.0057578646,
0.0600371435,
0.0104913842,
0.0297789332,
-0.0209318437,
-0.000423769,
0.0075844191,
0.0034257295,
-0.011203602,
0.0187873654,
-0.0004728865,
-0.0634813905,
-0.0141445044,
-0.0142701454,
0.0112061547,
-0.000631471,
0.0282662157,
0.0557784662,
-0.0397565402,
-0.0244161468,
-0.0172762927,
-0.0269137006,
0.0468142815,
0.0193372145,
-0.0255736243,
-6.432185334e-33,
0.0024462033,
0.030162774,
0.0079464326,
-0.0163134765,
0.0273731481,
0.0152027588,
-0.0387647897,
0.0025370263,
-0.0428140648,
0.0020796729,
0.0066177691,
0.0067941118,
0.0093394006,
0.0228740722,
0.0389451012,
0.0043816217,
0.056785807,
-0.0178656299,
-0.0109739164,
0.0298047923,
0.018836908,
0.0303622652,
0.093694225,
-0.029633699,
0.0018824665,
0.0025144082,
-0.0083964281,
0.0141150458,
-0.0266995728,
0.0510224812,
0.0091348514,
0.0547864325,
0.0202428382,
-0.050989598,
-0.0505950861,
-0.0229464509,
-0.0712469444,
-0.0404807106,
0.0245156419,
-0.0177461207,
-0.042646721,
-0.0167643502,
0.0683419555,
0.0131502552,
0.0080928123,
-0.0191771891,
0.0460216142,
-0.0279174596,
-0.0247276295,
-0.0058089979,
-0.0274858717,
0.0124619184,
-0.0167274922,
-0.0411561206,
0.0308180489,
0.02609195,
0.0077026901,
-0.0282758176,
-0.0399239548,
0.0065778145,
0.001822923,
0.0417983085,
0.0617255569,
0.0492436104,
0.0011129846,
0.0445558093,
0.0291385129,
0.0333464257,
-0.0069146371,
0.0042478922,
0.0631879568,
0.0686973855,
0.0162426736,
-0.0050004944,
0.002017929,
0.0292148273,
-0.083898671,
-0.0016339334,
0.0416757278,
0.0615350828,
0.034965653,
0.0137013495,
-0.045720432,
-0.0410508476,
-0.0456094742,
0.0013477781,
-0.0334226228,
-0.0121644652,
0.0272492841,
0.0299130324,
-0.0186968315,
0.0195208769,
0.0392836519,
-0.0339956321,
-0.0092394678,
0.0095732948,
-0.0481918268,
-0.002244561,
-0.0097597269,
0.0285402164,
-0.0868245587,
-0.0503636114,
0.0288309474,
0.0146711813,
0.0216731504,
0.0125284083,
0.0680031851,
0.0262439661,
-0.0580553375,
-0.0331086069,
-0.0354489125,
-0.0112864207,
0.0351754278,
0.0695623457,
0.0443938114,
0.0329522565,
-0.0078106471,
0.0483178273,
0.0122837014,
-0.0427975655,
-0.0204668809,
-0.020406805,
-0.0074378205,
0.0245111044,
-0.0243275575,
0.0014735733,
-0.0363576859,
-0.0952649787,
-0.0129641583,
-0.0331348926,
-0.0277374592,
0.014361375,
2.682e-7,
0.0089923292,
0.037387643,
-0.0159583185,
-0.0058679925,
-0.0054229568,
0.0386900604,
-0.036685247,
0.0294946264,
0.0209495127,
-0.020655388,
-0.0127992965,
0.0802794024,
0.0701302513,
0.0077159703,
-0.0936798379,
-0.0038520992,
-0.0432489216,
0.077038087,
-0.0504995584,
0.0054615713,
0.0239907615,
0.1109881178,
0.0616463087,
-0.0122407507,
0.0146366758,
-0.0444539487,
0.0613896027,
-0.0216154549,
-0.0107814223,
0.0361174531,
-0.0020948935,
0.0839130729,
-0.0189184621,
0.0696582645,
-0.0238637608,
0.0132881831,
-0.0256681107,
0.0902173892,
-0.0083085829,
-0.0080972966,
0.0104995528,
-0.0080032256,
-0.0147630805,
-0.0096412608,
0.0901064724,
-0.0856467709,
-0.0303997211,
-0.0034355749,
0.0024899708,
-0.0103962561,
0.0158841331,
-0.0172385573,
-0.0356033631,
0.0231971033,
0.0194203649,
-0.0106387241,
-0.0498672687,
-0.0859438032,
-0.0157761369,
0.0316973589,
-0.0609642193,
-0.051083032,
-0.0137495818,
-0.0021182315,
0.035250552,
-0.0713294074,
0.0193885975,
2.49920132e-34,
0.0250003971,
-0.0149847539,
0.0167009644,
0.0352579094,
0.0163828526,
-0.0220631324,
-0.0851000175,
-0.0147991842,
0.0225779582,
-0.0787541419,
-0.0461598337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03194v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03194v2 | UDApter -- Efficient Domain Adaptation Using Adapters | 2023-02-07T02:04:17 | 2023-02-16T08:17:56 | Bhavitvya Malik, Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Min-Yen Kan, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose two methods to make unsupervised domain adaptation (UDA) more
parameter efficient using adapters, small bottleneck layers interspersed with
every layer of the large-scale pre-trained language model (PLM). The first
method deconstructs UDA into a two-step process: first by adding a domain
adapter to learn domain-invariant information and then by adding a task adapter
that uses domain-invariant information to learn task representations in the
source domain. The second method jointly learns a supervised classifier while
reducing the divergence measure. Compared to strong baselines, our simple
methods perform well in natural language inference (MNLI) and the cross-domain
sentiment classification task. We even outperform unsupervised domain
adaptation methods such as DANN and DSN in sentiment classification, and we are
within 0.85% F1 for natural language inference task, by fine-tuning only a
fraction of the full model parameters. We release our code at
https://github.com/declare-lab/domadapter | [
-0.0003780571,
0.0512284823,
-0.0076815812,
0.0399839431,
0.0004844356,
0.0130977072,
0.0307323076,
-0.0222901776,
0.0112865251,
-0.0589034893,
-0.0711230859,
-0.0034099955,
-0.0380784534,
0.0292923171,
-0.0323248133,
-0.0468807109,
0.0253325626,
0.0032883107,
-0.0081221266,
-0.016014928,
-0.0062485682,
0.0055455598,
-0.0300017036,
0.0038122714,
0.037777137,
-0.0102122789,
0.0189596228,
0.0059398687,
0.0059738765,
-0.003319446,
0.035144221,
0.0343493856,
0.0565160364,
0.0083744014,
0.0000022185,
-0.0528210215,
-0.0388689674,
-0.030661149,
-0.0043965238,
-0.0007849773,
0.0253748968,
-0.0259253439,
-0.0038409973,
0.001731057,
-0.0620413981,
-0.0642459169,
0.0448029265,
0.0841996521,
0.0333258063,
0.1190404892,
-0.0222785138,
-0.0089206873,
-0.007797671,
-0.0432825647,
-0.0473627299,
-0.0784244314,
0.0342931375,
0.0046755113,
-0.0282086078,
0.0073313951,
-0.0451704413,
0.0002109189,
-0.0054422836,
0.0085460255,
-0.0207135063,
0.0056854361,
0.0213342775,
0.0074515743,
-0.0140391234,
0.0796757042,
0.0002280175,
-0.0489974394,
-0.0291223433,
-0.0357914455,
0.0072334516,
0.0143386088,
-0.0061818752,
-0.054449033,
0.0229026135,
0.0266150888,
0.0070454762,
0.0298476461,
0.0304440912,
0.0034839301,
-0.0252450556,
0.0402066745,
-0.0041030268,
0.004469628,
0.0194918253,
0.0616304502,
-0.0068187839,
-0.0126706595,
-0.0013986696,
0.0037698769,
-0.0046124323,
-0.0173307452,
-0.0696084648,
-0.0767482072,
-0.0518454611,
-0.0454506427,
0.0842166767,
0.0244198386,
-0.0247492865,
0.0611413494,
-0.0261320714,
0.0148612624,
-0.0347947255,
-0.0117033031,
-0.0466879196,
0.0033740751,
-0.0479420945,
0.0241037477,
-0.0366663598,
0.0289751906,
-0.0502570011,
0.0099797649,
-0.016777033,
0.0446864218,
-0.0089686671,
-0.072373271,
0.0072536217,
-0.0056418455,
-0.033316128,
-0.0258843638,
-0.0269209314,
0.0761924759,
-0.0513017923,
0.0691252649,
-0.030428309,
-0.0241045728,
-0.0210864507,
0.0453741029,
0.0441114269,
-0.0442319512,
0.029511258,
0.0715271458,
0.0188678689,
-0.0385535769,
-0.0444107242,
0.047790654,
0.0051835938,
-0.0651523694,
0.036951676,
-0.0360585526,
0.0443088301,
0.0017853567,
0.0016070559,
-0.0846690312,
-0.0420568772,
-0.0337655433,
-0.0313461535,
0.078972891,
-0.0001686703,
-0.0273729209,
0.015715329,
0.0026948387,
-0.0389738567,
0.0958056375,
-0.0019584897,
0.020823095,
0.0222493317,
-0.0177669395,
-0.0052232444,
0.0068090218,
0.0208086912,
0.0214766879,
0.0092569524,
0.0275966767,
-0.0156937502,
-0.0155370915,
0.0722618774,
-0.0298024602,
0.0100194523,
-0.0122573562,
0.0295630023,
-0.0284053944,
0.0299296919,
0.0281889308,
0.0217733625,
0.0081724906,
-0.0060504642,
0.0050956397,
-0.0493881293,
0.0281260498,
-0.0189931858,
-0.0379182771,
0.0136947613,
0.035251122,
-0.0624659173,
-0.0529977456,
0.0434259512,
-0.0207406841,
0.0072769616,
0.0268008336,
0.0575460009,
0.0503302403,
-0.0413685627,
0.0362593085,
0.0569154769,
-0.0188443065,
-0.0012065676,
-0.037280038,
0.042355787,
0.0026139894,
-0.0109918565,
-0.0587746277,
-0.0228494834,
-0.0045919186,
0.0721989349,
0.0257301293,
0.0584948175,
0.0145770172,
0.0378110893,
-0.0273085665,
-0.03377451,
0.0029747838,
0.0225867964,
0.0458785892,
0.0198623035,
0.0364473611,
0.0395609103,
-0.0746854618,
-0.0032842085,
0.0205448736,
-0.0436005145,
-0.0411662944,
0.0599019751,
0.0026968773,
0.0264914557,
0.0007525642,
-0.0279821716,
-0.0288562141,
-0.0047546672,
-0.0516445115,
-0.0294042397,
-0.00640614,
-0.0412103496,
-0.0461293198,
0.0216787905,
-0.0253178868,
0.0093964133,
0.0653810576,
-0.031332463,
-0.0276474748,
0.0569453128,
0.0245583169,
0.0312993824,
-0.0143671893,
-0.0150664104,
-0.0182418302,
0.0784084499,
0.0155059993,
0.0340683386,
0.0556346476,
-0.0425704345,
-0.0385983773,
0.0165702179,
-0.0112442281,
0.0344572738,
-0.0060120407,
-0.0300950352,
-0.0118052736,
0.0354894176,
0.0131339738,
0.0144104054,
-0.0018745238,
-0.004352564,
-0.0713750124,
0.008395656,
-0.0378399938,
0.0341719389,
0.0234370437,
0.0613991469,
-0.0166751817,
-0.0136727784,
-0.0193359219,
0.0384991132,
-0.021308573,
0.0303617474,
0.018968083,
-0.0019102721,
0.0342557691,
-0.0499926843,
0.0145943379,
0.0008799094,
0.0228645802,
-0.017522892,
-0.0416608527,
-0.0471290834,
0.0354589298,
-0.0007473427,
0.0455003157,
-0.0115612876,
-0.0229123738,
-0.0385074206,
-0.0178464316,
0.0489093401,
0.054494977,
-0.0190615468,
0.0180142745,
0.0484673418,
0.0141524402,
-0.0484414846,
0.0162220355,
-0.0443245173,
0.0171009675,
-0.0492873751,
0.0501905084,
0.0364363715,
0.0685949251,
-0.0423630141,
-0.0483853407,
-0.050637655,
0.030498093,
-0.0153909596,
-0.005525209,
0.0312023945,
0.0279431269,
-0.0076600481,
0.0233807322,
0.0128547316,
-0.031493403,
0.0559530072,
-0.0047035059,
0.0158066396,
-0.0998390839,
-0.0235517081,
-0.0377047658,
0.0327802338,
0.0214060191,
0.0163709205,
0.0412225351,
0.0093770837,
-0.0474801809,
0.0276768636,
0.0091959499,
0.0180848595,
0.06039498,
-0.0264963992,
0.0335217044,
-0.0230909344,
-0.0536237285,
-0.0177908242,
-0.0548789799,
-0.0445799902,
-0.0117757265,
-0.0468831286,
-0.0290546548,
-0.0657341182,
-0.0111092404,
-0.0098155132,
0.0287898723,
-0.0154295797,
-0.0050667194,
-0.0023103843,
0.0297040995,
0.0431983732,
0.0591144003,
0.0109201232,
0.0060890648,
0.0161945093,
0.0300161242,
-0.0166217964,
0.0047154184,
-0.0498295166,
0.0040451162,
0.0304035004,
-0.0069781328,
0.0083678616,
-0.0117771002,
0.0783812776,
0.0009107926,
0.0071782139,
0.1045975015,
-0.0175662208,
-0.0526262708,
-0.0154992742,
-0.0051545119,
-0.0007587926,
0.0137468679,
0.0287684053,
-0.0480884239,
-0.0750517398,
-0.0204859879,
0.0126237813,
0.0278800596,
-0.0232022777,
-0.0030835909,
-0.0877806544,
-0.0135508236,
-0.0064526321,
-0.0385429971,
-0.0121760452,
-0.0416889526,
0.023467185,
-0.0188038219,
-0.0081452578,
-0.0425305255,
0.0180895682,
-0.0067026182,
0.0096548963,
-0.0193759818,
-0.0650886074,
0.0093337093,
-0.0486133322,
0.0326981917,
0.0575430878,
0.0062881294,
-0.0224564523,
0.004509381,
0.0481462367,
-0.0339221992,
-0.0097332029,
-0.033126343,
0.0534055233,
-0.0139567154,
-0.0095821247,
0.030435646,
0.0071178386,
-0.0916265622,
0.0216487013,
0.0308069997,
0.0698628053,
-0.0053509101,
-0.0313785747,
-0.0227722917,
-0.0065917796,
-0.0045852493,
0.0567375086,
0.0050391238,
-0.064562805,
-0.00267826,
0.0093715368,
-0.0484551229,
-0.0554757155,
-0.0247042496,
-0.0274988506,
-0.0368725732,
-0.0240205098,
-0.0531629212,
-0.0077062328,
0.0124846594,
0.0585712455,
0.0002603957,
-0.0284572951,
-0.0032831766,
0.0042708381,
-0.0604627356,
0.019713277,
-0.0416601487,
-0.0020734831,
-0.0354731008,
-0.0301284939,
0.0713058189,
-0.0181913003,
-0.0150113795,
-0.0009958501,
-0.0582939908,
-0.0498597361,
-0.0117367366,
0.0558644831,
0.0090872431,
0.0494370908,
-0.0283537097,
-0.0148273595,
0.0295128599,
0.0611381307,
-0.0180105437,
0.0429706834,
0.0542310923,
-0.0512137935,
-0.002603722,
0.0406719968,
-0.0475156903,
0.0576384515,
0.0687709749,
0.0051464722,
0.0006120049,
-0.0478763133,
-0.0273053516,
-0.0249621309,
0.087311089,
0.0358873457,
-0.0231195521,
-0.0295425057,
-0.0029123763,
0.0084838057,
-0.0170487054,
-0.0520089269,
-0.0205165874,
0.0244493186,
0.0069652656,
-0.0204796046,
0.0702128485,
0.0032263473,
0.0258321445,
-0.0253002029,
0.0399491005,
0.0450218096,
0.0375953317,
0.0103093833,
0.0095914928,
0.0048292652,
-0.045150321,
0.0695573613,
0.0292069968,
-0.0350656919,
0.0204701964,
0.0124635864,
0.0168010965,
-0.0197374821,
0.0140705146,
-0.0584217645,
-0.0172718875,
-0.0419703983,
0.0096379193,
0.038783852,
-0.0531291664,
0.0400126651,
-0.0012249534,
0.0060284026,
-0.0422932059,
0.0148874419,
0.006425288,
0.0359402709,
0.0472327173,
-0.0066271629,
-0.0196017232,
0.011134387,
0.0779086351,
0.0068155448,
0.049863115,
0.0473993309,
0.031288404,
-0.0339243002,
-0.0277648903,
0.009316734,
0.0154450815,
-0.0046066903,
0.016007904,
0.0038562703,
-0.0448798873,
0.0123521276,
-0.0663404837,
0.003236965,
0.015418333,
0.0061857426,
0.0283488501,
0.0014483414,
0.0200188048,
-0.0286385193,
0.0076510794,
-0.0186106805,
-0.0065866802,
-0.0021797679,
-6.676498611e-33,
-0.0221654046,
0.0262415428,
-0.0092860153,
-0.0039612674,
-0.0257331468,
-0.0134592345,
-0.0325674601,
0.0158589985,
-0.0255008433,
-0.0050439709,
0.0025340102,
0.0240692925,
0.0155661087,
0.0389040038,
-0.0290977005,
-0.029589029,
0.0665771589,
0.0091546755,
-0.0137626035,
0.0197689906,
-0.0065775067,
0.0386511423,
0.0570595972,
-0.1080560833,
-0.006729506,
0.0054666977,
0.0135259656,
0.0001874719,
0.0794968531,
0.0279964861,
-0.0093876561,
0.0655081868,
0.0375580043,
-0.0416780226,
-0.0054430729,
0.029680673,
-0.0984013677,
-0.0420871936,
-0.0005426785,
0.0444661565,
-0.0039202916,
-0.0145471292,
0.0067854538,
0.0410866588,
0.005828701,
-0.0347805321,
0.0283727534,
-0.0392595604,
0.0214188881,
-0.022370562,
-0.0761220753,
0.0114493649,
0.0259349681,
-0.009013488,
0.0212774966,
0.0376607142,
0.0277166609,
0.0191682111,
-0.0759088472,
0.0177257527,
-0.0235935412,
0.0349313989,
0.0142535744,
0.0130523043,
-0.0195604227,
0.0420158803,
0.0031717175,
0.0058850949,
-0.008595014,
0.0150138764,
0.0196990427,
0.0114226425,
-0.0001560236,
0.0691178516,
0.0266552381,
-0.0531724915,
-0.0684206635,
0.0415207408,
-0.0011795938,
-0.0340661891,
0.0106873373,
0.0106848795,
-0.0331939757,
-0.0122669414,
0.0133481994,
0.0302584767,
-0.0293975435,
-0.0438003726,
0.011687276,
-0.0010089551,
-0.0255493633,
-0.0006906072,
0.0126331868,
-0.0954137444,
-0.0109473178,
-0.004429657,
-0.0069726156,
-0.0341626108,
0.0211973805,
0.0090365466,
-0.0077292137,
-0.0469644256,
0.0198652316,
0.0105180629,
0.0100062629,
0.0056069293,
0.0424233004,
0.0081798285,
-0.0842262208,
-0.0318536833,
-0.0095766233,
-0.0007386625,
0.0308120009,
0.1180263013,
-0.0141271567,
0.025634354,
-0.0205085222,
0.0595675148,
0.0242249295,
-0.0320810042,
0.000335329,
0.0263022389,
0.0035914953,
0.0174055006,
-0.0526874512,
-0.0530744903,
-0.0125878267,
0.0076925578,
-0.0157757755,
-0.1058963165,
-0.0316143595,
-0.0251842327,
2.916e-7,
0.015170658,
0.0483289137,
-0.0261130668,
-0.0369895585,
0.0161039177,
0.0695423037,
-0.00348914,
0.0485049449,
0.0007924737,
0.0184822883,
0.0166771244,
0.0211580638,
0.0231264811,
0.0188507196,
-0.0845930874,
0.0067972867,
0.0377957448,
0.0377659872,
0.0021252988,
0.0002927935,
0.0617309101,
0.1105677485,
0.0181554761,
-0.0186052807,
0.0081792045,
-0.0587737262,
0.0648497939,
-0.0294772871,
0.015375454,
0.0169670768,
-0.0152359735,
0.0252818353,
-0.0287545752,
-0.0013212891,
-0.0420565233,
0.052546531,
0.0007763559,
0.0608538985,
0.0371187031,
-0.0167768002,
0.0105415247,
0.0168412756,
0.0373898372,
0.0044195205,
0.0839714929,
-0.0796664059,
-0.048400104,
-0.0471284911,
-0.0259647723,
0.0027482787,
-0.0046701753,
0.0116944555,
-0.0014919873,
-0.0000803681,
0.0351028293,
-0.010986248,
-0.0549821146,
-0.0720138475,
0.0062389323,
-0.0010492326,
-0.0321563929,
-0.0133992778,
-0.0138196861,
0.0080153057,
0.0640310422,
-0.044505503,
0.059691187,
2.400971089e-34,
0.0188946687,
-0.005015647,
-0.0047934917,
0.0000827444,
-0.0087881703,
-0.005882591,
-0.0245640483,
-0.0460559539,
0.0464403741,
-0.0500873066,
0.0157429148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03183v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03183v1 | Capturing Topic Framing via Masked Language Modeling | 2023-02-07T01:23:14 | 2023-02-07T01:23:14 | Xiaobo Guo, Weicheng Ma, Soroush Vosoughi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Differential framing of issues can lead to divergent world views on important
issues. This is especially true in domains where the information presented can
reach a large audience, such as traditional and social media. Scalable and
reliable measurement of such differential framing is an important first step in
addressing them. In this work, based on the intuition that framing affects the
tone and word choices in written language, we propose a framework for modeling
the differential framing of issues through masked token prediction via
large-scale fine-tuned language models (LMs). Specifically, we explore three
key factors for our framework: 1) prompt generation methods for the masked
token prediction; 2) methods for normalizing the output of fine-tuned LMs; 3)
robustness to the choice of pre-trained LMs used for fine-tuning. Through
experiments on a dataset of articles from traditional media outlets covering
five diverse and politically polarized topics, we show that our framework can
capture differential framing of these topics with high reliability. | [
0.029979689,
0.0449941568,
-0.0091048684,
0.0160231721,
-0.0309636444,
-0.0094586546,
0.0369412862,
0.0111329174,
-0.0231095981,
-0.0696780384,
0.0153511018,
-0.0435997918,
-0.0279764123,
0.094663091,
-0.0083302474,
-0.0693281218,
0.0438000485,
0.0015396292,
0.035112977,
-0.0176587235,
0.0399686769,
0.0303033348,
0.0073783807,
0.0432488099,
-0.0167379268,
-0.0253807083,
0.0020920981,
0.0162832439,
0.0303304475,
-0.0181557443,
0.0397461876,
0.0712964162,
0.0292244703,
0.0578287505,
0.0000017991,
-0.0283560082,
-0.0180855244,
-0.0379994325,
0.0195777565,
-0.0026906878,
0.0679976121,
-0.0218079388,
0.0134427659,
0.028208822,
-0.0467775352,
-0.0067870412,
0.026346663,
0.0510381833,
0.0679423362,
0.0540426895,
-0.0016515437,
-0.0040114443,
-0.0230983719,
-0.0247106142,
-0.0493832342,
-0.0163679477,
0.0527735874,
-0.0531921275,
-0.0980403796,
0.0484612472,
-0.0113436496,
-0.0090271775,
0.0020962579,
0.0031772684,
-0.0387031324,
0.0084630949,
-0.0282749403,
-0.0062915739,
-0.0172915347,
0.0554571487,
0.0115203848,
-0.0280524939,
0.0295654852,
-0.0536759794,
-0.0055982606,
0.0065435637,
-0.0225512162,
0.0194735955,
-0.0083731953,
0.0303112809,
0.0223075021,
-0.0129452515,
0.0122034354,
0.0329420529,
-0.0079536345,
0.0278771874,
0.0047953972,
-0.0068362998,
-0.0492514595,
-0.0184186138,
0.0027453494,
-0.0802555233,
0.0272820331,
-0.0018120145,
-0.0336264409,
0.0182457026,
-0.0328469574,
-0.0707375333,
0.0126867499,
-0.0299060345,
-0.0328485742,
0.0002123439,
-0.0041607474,
0.0412405171,
0.0034280408,
0.0157044306,
-0.0248224009,
0.0045794891,
-0.0054883002,
0.0042169606,
-0.0246293861,
-0.0042729387,
-0.018341653,
0.0307001472,
-0.0661244392,
-0.0146620376,
-0.0006985603,
-0.0183632262,
-0.0298423097,
0.0090108272,
-0.0319188312,
0.0042684665,
-0.0355686657,
-0.0266865436,
-0.0164113063,
0.0622343644,
-0.0680688024,
0.0292206071,
0.0158024505,
-0.0106431805,
-0.0038384777,
0.0240281448,
-0.0040687141,
0.0026023523,
-0.0000594964,
0.0411184952,
-0.022900749,
0.023756301,
0.0111133363,
-0.0454531759,
-0.0281703752,
0.0009916334,
0.021747997,
-0.0816836506,
0.0325622633,
0.0255368091,
0.0099902665,
-0.0217509605,
0.0102593629,
0.0211106725,
-0.0118365688,
0.0667127594,
0.0326305106,
-0.01005881,
0.0652015582,
0.0344739072,
-0.0103572281,
0.0941747352,
-0.0156790633,
0.0385742821,
0.0550213866,
-0.0159257837,
0.0052492213,
0.0263459794,
0.0263312142,
0.0408605076,
0.0103554428,
0.0034675715,
0.0333929546,
0.0064424551,
0.0281148609,
0.0566249527,
0.0107552027,
-0.0473224148,
0.0570711307,
0.0509224683,
-0.0527561083,
-0.0019588936,
0.0355956741,
0.0318447389,
-0.0239066165,
0.0485970825,
0.0064319465,
-0.0099005373,
-0.004723927,
-0.0402177125,
0.0154762901,
0.030399289,
-0.0366547145,
-0.026810579,
-0.0078712152,
0.0146025391,
-0.0021331536,
-0.0224892218,
0.0067646205,
0.009828886,
-0.0525794029,
0.0670173913,
0.0277108736,
-0.0270612296,
0.0170374848,
-0.042751614,
0.0134055056,
-0.0156566817,
0.0034381268,
-0.021694446,
-0.010288626,
-0.0623328723,
0.0580181554,
0.063740015,
0.0295522399,
-0.0090316441,
-0.0459574386,
-0.0285644606,
-0.0123575283,
-0.0175477471,
0.0224094354,
0.0495663434,
0.0056051537,
0.0190005377,
0.0036066638,
0.0109744277,
-0.0133350678,
0.0418832228,
0.0079406314,
-0.0358799249,
0.0098213153,
0.0107844314,
0.0480595827,
0.0226311162,
-0.0114196893,
-0.0033178939,
0.0172317438,
-0.0349109322,
-0.0570433848,
-0.024432037,
-0.0615045689,
0.0045039593,
0.0031711659,
-0.081106998,
-0.0165097285,
0.0072561102,
-0.0548446365,
-0.0343565829,
0.0336883366,
0.0084535647,
-0.037450403,
-0.0175845865,
-0.0238737836,
-0.035337422,
-0.0011616071,
-0.0502316505,
0.0572040305,
0.0031918632,
0.0296403673,
0.0179523528,
-0.0196300186,
-0.0017766417,
-0.0019937516,
-0.0159960296,
0.0184797756,
0.0067727221,
0.0193271097,
0.0416670218,
-0.0163412392,
-0.0367600359,
-0.0563269891,
-0.0902236328,
0.0007653526,
-0.0349707231,
-0.006769741,
0.061494831,
-0.0330025479,
-0.0208954383,
-0.000624173,
-0.0485600643,
-0.0794461221,
-0.0133160651,
0.009937318,
0.0241675824,
0.0246738419,
0.0134432223,
-0.0209781025,
-0.0007813567,
-0.0505705066,
0.0550484359,
0.002827374,
-0.0273438003,
-0.0253533665,
0.0326447375,
-0.0119647654,
-0.0100554973,
-0.0398535654,
-0.0173072368,
-0.0054602688,
0.0223826319,
0.0404745266,
0.0618659258,
0.0651971102,
0.0231187996,
0.0484035946,
0.0291168299,
-0.0533638783,
-0.0238215867,
-0.0493456163,
-0.0188632254,
-0.0080148801,
-0.0543508939,
0.0557395555,
0.0733184665,
0.0578584597,
0.0081479922,
-0.0621357635,
0.0668807402,
-0.0480288267,
-0.0120198615,
-0.0345787592,
-0.0278042387,
-0.0289230198,
0.0528580509,
-0.0174621809,
-0.0305733532,
0.0773751661,
-0.0004765973,
0.0463852547,
-0.0477302037,
-0.0082439231,
-0.04174399,
0.0242837202,
-0.0115184123,
0.0257856045,
0.0013421,
-0.0241279081,
-0.0704490766,
-0.0549892932,
0.0339851864,
-0.0304917507,
0.023135189,
-0.040822573,
-0.0104098171,
0.0092771808,
-0.0482763499,
-0.0433513634,
-0.1090968847,
-0.042934332,
0.0169088412,
0.0432134271,
0.0022305206,
-0.0052773794,
0.0156651139,
0.0254884213,
-0.0082174288,
-0.0092642829,
0.0135632455,
-0.0120422486,
0.0415400341,
0.0440378524,
-0.037762735,
0.0130645111,
-0.0226110723,
0.0461744592,
0.0202092193,
0.0263006613,
0.0367701501,
-0.0069951494,
-0.017721232,
0.0087548252,
-0.0060971398,
-0.0020018057,
-0.0075038923,
0.055480767,
-0.0244182833,
0.0307164714,
0.1266141683,
0.0378630683,
-0.0420918837,
-0.0257080663,
-0.0348840505,
0.0200653542,
0.0319362693,
0.0217439365,
-0.0903835967,
0.0083906697,
0.01645891,
0.0207969137,
-0.0412718281,
-0.0355964787,
-0.0202550478,
-0.1046139374,
-0.0056704455,
0.0147834336,
-0.0085840141,
0.0123844417,
-0.0601642244,
0.003066326,
0.0218095072,
-0.0013576169,
-0.0227574091,
0.0212997627,
-0.0070832907,
0.0234405249,
-0.0419780314,
-0.0302439965,
0.0134303933,
-0.0364605188,
0.0303169303,
0.0166103914,
0.0314126797,
-0.0152870407,
-0.0354524739,
0.0079425154,
0.0075486894,
-0.0113665583,
-0.0288174171,
0.0466444977,
-0.0508773774,
-0.0135629503,
-0.0308292806,
0.0751486644,
0.015274154,
-0.0269563608,
0.019892877,
0.0186970942,
0.0115630971,
-0.0463153832,
-0.0031418854,
0.0280941203,
0.0537714586,
0.0758350417,
0.048906941,
-0.0640325025,
0.00324342,
-0.0499821082,
0.0472304076,
0.0057261195,
-0.0068065147,
-0.0247308183,
-0.0221544839,
0.0437568538,
-0.0547464676,
0.0069599175,
0.0221003443,
0.0426356904,
0.0305713769,
0.0093969796,
0.0213592052,
-0.0141467797,
-0.0370614529,
0.0579721704,
-0.0120791495,
0.0155540127,
-0.0474811532,
-0.0218858346,
0.0381035618,
-0.0075377128,
-0.0431860872,
0.0534228124,
-0.041862011,
-0.0748645589,
0.0362719148,
0.0017431091,
0.0167454593,
0.0353228897,
0.0157557875,
-0.0385429636,
0.0400870182,
0.0523727983,
-0.0076322975,
0.0183463097,
0.0292461198,
0.0393883288,
-0.0061226911,
0.0315311812,
-0.0250548664,
0.0246699378,
0.0490781479,
-0.0077751442,
-0.0403811336,
0.0079048509,
-0.0068059997,
-0.0006657126,
0.0727511048,
-0.0178472698,
-0.0384053402,
-0.055901628,
-0.0162493736,
-0.0266030673,
-0.0532239377,
0.0100678885,
0.0034698115,
0.0045002247,
-0.0351843461,
-0.0300152339,
0.0695422292,
-0.0521923751,
0.052540753,
-0.0283040293,
0.0191709492,
-0.033356972,
0.0385112576,
0.0340364352,
-0.0035696956,
-0.0122683048,
0.0102589484,
0.0071369484,
0.0203460436,
0.010137612,
0.0505088978,
0.0445043631,
0.0184683707,
0.000682452,
0.005080387,
-0.0329675488,
-0.0549501628,
0.0000307727,
0.0348990262,
-0.0048458157,
-0.0320411995,
-0.0230857283,
0.0115348333,
-0.0370566733,
-0.0024185183,
0.0233332478,
0.026000157,
-0.0247891527,
0.0676627681,
0.0131289698,
-0.0521464869,
0.013479121,
0.0454442911,
-0.0523703396,
0.0269943457,
0.0546039827,
-0.0126111945,
-0.0186333302,
0.0478836298,
0.0441841297,
0.0612266213,
0.0183425322,
-0.0090343906,
-0.0836828575,
-0.0387209244,
0.0444395952,
-0.0191186573,
-0.010871388,
0.006293097,
0.0166946761,
0.0572920553,
-0.0054908972,
0.0302571245,
-0.0493050031,
0.0394809656,
-0.0088234385,
-0.0295583196,
-0.01814414,
-6.495138199e-33,
-0.0294184722,
-0.0447755046,
-0.0411771871,
0.0294378642,
0.0163330641,
0.0424604081,
-0.0118370708,
0.0157362148,
-0.001514,
0.0223631728,
0.0023442227,
0.0245791432,
0.011973192,
0.0155100115,
-0.0407020003,
-0.0177317094,
0.059124995,
-0.0327678546,
-0.0580872335,
0.0077222898,
0.0365100801,
0.0115085421,
0.0146965059,
-0.0627598241,
0.0284481179,
-0.0168257281,
-0.019381674,
-0.0070550246,
0.0302550886,
0.0192056429,
-0.0150293158,
0.0400109887,
0.0391980037,
-0.0542606562,
-0.0197638571,
0.1059161052,
-0.027367577,
-0.0344682299,
0.0484347828,
-0.0266257655,
0.0044420697,
-0.0297218766,
0.0032701155,
0.0007483443,
-0.0499974154,
0.0234402474,
0.0412028395,
0.0091722663,
0.0209182836,
-0.0186559632,
-0.0146140121,
0.0089212554,
-0.0112712225,
0.0025776848,
-0.0299014542,
-0.007225255,
0.0441547595,
0.0867015794,
-0.06215344,
0.0170325581,
-0.0036884593,
0.0308671575,
0.0504634045,
0.0282878876,
0.0123987775,
0.1029395908,
0.0336791389,
0.0545558818,
-0.041370865,
-0.0153964031,
0.0220103785,
-0.0100610815,
0.0650329739,
0.0744101033,
0.0119802514,
-0.0319975615,
-0.0597207285,
0.007010452,
-0.016217256,
0.0004514419,
0.0562812239,
-0.0075266352,
0.0050314781,
-0.0314979963,
-0.1060482264,
-0.0360934623,
-0.0399048403,
0.0121648079,
0.0022493415,
0.0284890141,
-0.0638732538,
-0.0281379521,
0.0299755819,
-0.0307667833,
0.0071781171,
0.0191896819,
-0.0121711986,
-0.0163311418,
0.0192805622,
0.0488364957,
-0.0320507586,
-0.010127848,
0.0196972247,
0.0080655394,
0.0292810835,
-0.0405042134,
0.008349753,
-0.0305697024,
-0.0912413448,
0.014471055,
-0.0209891796,
0.0361120701,
-0.0178764965,
0.0350467041,
0.0163256079,
0.0277971383,
-0.0117222583,
0.0153324679,
0.0184387378,
-0.0352703705,
0.0161932092,
-0.0051347208,
-0.0633031949,
0.0583535247,
-0.0594420545,
-0.0037257264,
0.0120721254,
0.0236875769,
0.0915231034,
-0.0306628626,
-0.0309595149,
-0.0204186812,
2.496e-7,
0.0332591608,
0.0813273564,
-0.0146659771,
0.0107203731,
0.0276786741,
0.0640368834,
0.0321212597,
0.0402954891,
0.0019959861,
-0.0716555566,
-0.0387193486,
0.0040612957,
0.0262778457,
0.0226723291,
-0.0871724859,
0.0176884998,
-0.0629565492,
0.0439878255,
-0.0529260263,
0.0064572999,
0.0114257811,
0.0717871785,
0.016117258,
0.0143464478,
-0.0182981454,
-0.0294361021,
0.0563085563,
-0.0400232449,
-0.0400218517,
0.0178041365,
-0.0175910145,
-0.0146913147,
0.0203171559,
0.0287193153,
-0.0162278339,
0.0091307973,
0.0169876851,
0.0701649636,
0.0403047092,
-0.0270158183,
-0.0298079047,
0.0166086946,
-0.0317397267,
-0.0777806342,
0.0574214384,
-0.0676328316,
-0.0150570357,
-0.1105641574,
-0.0253946781,
-0.0396622755,
0.0482631102,
-0.0375315323,
-0.0208010729,
0.0279442742,
-0.0112141874,
0.027998589,
0.0132800192,
-0.057399869,
-0.0176814124,
-0.0239618886,
-0.0534592308,
-0.0340471677,
-0.0200961698,
-0.0097162221,
0.0091620879,
-0.0488196425,
0.0448696613,
2.321249154e-34,
0.0448503494,
-0.0011326531,
-0.0362358056,
-0.020043185,
0.0355031677,
0.0000442755,
-0.0484781899,
0.0027949626,
0.0336411037,
-0.0601962917,
0.0026629551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06474v1 | Applying BERT and ChatGPT for Sentiment Analysis of Lyme Disease in Scientific Literature | 2023-02-07T01:15:05 | 2023-02-07T01:15:05 | Teo Susnjak | cs.CL | cs.CL | This chapter presents a practical guide for conducting Sentiment Analysis
using Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques in the domain of tick-borne
disease text. The aim is to demonstrate the process of how the presence of bias
in the discourse surrounding chronic manifestations of the disease can be
evaluated. The goal is to use a dataset of 5643 abstracts collected from
scientific journals on the topic of chronic Lyme disease to demonstrate using
Python, the steps for conducting sentiment analysis using pre-trained language
models and the process of validating the preliminary results using both
interpretable machine learning tools, as well as a novel methodology of using
emerging state-of-the-art large language models like ChatGPT. This serves as a
useful resource for researchers and practitioners interested in using NLP
techniques for sentiment analysis in the medical domain. | [
0.0363443866,
0.0518469475,
0.0154574811,
-0.0115122665,
-0.0410039276,
0.0169461947,
-0.0185340084,
0.0262865461,
0.0808736384,
-0.0828935802,
-0.0145733757,
0.0521288104,
-0.0165773667,
0.0121068405,
-0.0157157872,
0.0057546659,
0.008785855,
0.0837824866,
0.0972871631,
0.0308071673,
0.0129800877,
0.0050192899,
-0.0048702452,
0.0491025969,
0.0352655314,
-0.0351273566,
0.0680417791,
0.0058018966,
0.0374025069,
-0.1028644219,
0.0250434503,
-0.0180668384,
0.0094328113,
-0.0078788344,
0.0000018257,
-0.0210201535,
-0.0096151289,
0.0185420364,
0.0672343746,
0.0043581538,
0.0545058995,
-0.0550460443,
0.0111150583,
0.047889363,
-0.0405163057,
-0.0563640445,
0.0443069525,
0.0684793368,
0.0369668789,
0.0622510202,
-0.0225507729,
-0.0209588278,
-0.0140914563,
0.0256711598,
0.0009617813,
0.0440434217,
0.0659265667,
-0.0215458684,
0.0217461344,
-0.00881219,
0.0001399511,
0.0157796722,
-0.0577606112,
0.0058026421,
-0.0093200058,
0.0248524472,
-0.0386407673,
-0.0018576443,
0.0081455633,
-0.005312697,
0.0202535223,
-0.0473419353,
0.002622989,
0.0014099855,
-0.0112486752,
0.0147840986,
-0.0328555703,
0.0076186834,
-0.0138740726,
0.0205210317,
0.0283595193,
0.0266391113,
0.0079033906,
0.0268332846,
0.0062027457,
0.055791676,
0.0044227792,
-0.0357438326,
-0.0376702696,
0.0072208885,
0.0039175614,
-0.0124192769,
0.0385624655,
0.0347546078,
-0.0040750573,
0.0127742309,
0.0452418327,
-0.0382512808,
0.0712689906,
-0.0785593167,
-0.0285689402,
-0.0124355126,
-0.0084384298,
-0.0015853435,
0.030336367,
-0.040690545,
-0.0011267213,
0.0131767606,
0.0327012651,
0.0489170142,
-0.0603277124,
-0.0151157007,
0.0001276625,
-0.0004171909,
0.0284577776,
0.0127567407,
-0.0598685443,
-0.0373875387,
-0.004613338,
-0.0125272563,
-0.0189308058,
0.0164648574,
0.0123951081,
0.0457963832,
0.003361413,
0.0620284714,
0.0019259917,
0.0179157127,
-0.0492601432,
-0.0339908898,
0.0009408022,
-0.0166325495,
-0.0010267572,
-0.0311954562,
0.0304171499,
0.0770798028,
0.0551633835,
-0.0141083058,
0.0187712796,
0.038966082,
-0.0444147401,
-0.0193435047,
-0.030910816,
-0.0363921523,
-0.0074993619,
0.0480518155,
0.0288906377,
-0.0122486027,
-0.0120289205,
-0.0012287135,
-0.0660178289,
0.023082668,
-0.0807188377,
-0.0118470574,
0.0248890817,
0.0047299066,
0.0530280322,
-0.0087054707,
-0.0025564677,
0.0002734009,
0.0273389034,
-0.0252399668,
0.0132189523,
-0.0352746584,
-0.0000892196,
-0.0163168311,
0.031443689,
0.0293173771,
-0.0023544971,
0.0001703404,
-0.0624937862,
0.063948825,
-0.0035268848,
0.0027100865,
0.0091985622,
0.0528822839,
-0.0081007648,
-0.012206668,
-0.01431535,
0.0444753021,
0.0229705442,
-0.0089767501,
0.0154616097,
-0.0225869045,
0.0072093047,
-0.0207282528,
-0.0029256151,
0.0174870249,
0.0134172132,
-0.040021766,
-0.0703495964,
0.0064641917,
0.0400638133,
-0.0203955751,
0.0152771547,
-0.0110806804,
-0.0242164955,
-0.0187841766,
0.0736226961,
-0.0557348691,
0.020586336,
-0.0395998843,
-0.0043698195,
0.0338102616,
0.0364886299,
-0.0203728061,
-0.0462794639,
-0.031656608,
-0.0449465029,
0.0252184998,
0.0078345062,
-0.0029832828,
-0.024257103,
-0.0217671953,
0.0084833298,
-0.0021369588,
0.0286460593,
-0.0117670828,
-0.0139267435,
0.0266937818,
-0.0314318798,
-0.0159210376,
-0.0413706824,
0.0459976271,
0.0035938642,
-0.0337795243,
-0.0217576064,
-0.0257954579,
0.046650447,
0.0179593861,
-0.0220566783,
0.0462414809,
0.0338359177,
-0.0332101956,
-0.0501254983,
0.0322562605,
0.0413427129,
-0.0086968122,
0.0099057676,
-0.0534922704,
-0.0005666339,
0.0134587968,
-0.0135455914,
0.0188035294,
0.0179615431,
-0.0487427339,
0.0586109124,
0.0013377755,
-0.0113684628,
-0.0258596186,
-0.0218504202,
-0.040874213,
0.0097320005,
0.0227406286,
0.0077392589,
-0.0165609512,
-0.0637523383,
0.0119638732,
-0.0479069054,
-0.0326640345,
-0.0100412304,
0.0300954189,
0.012843783,
0.02862918,
-0.0103778495,
-0.0091243889,
-0.0267420132,
-0.1048580483,
0.0021269526,
0.0170126148,
0.0435284562,
0.0103312051,
-0.0309582874,
-0.0094654188,
0.0166400298,
-0.0194138419,
-0.0740042627,
0.0085831545,
0.0409574248,
0.04925723,
-0.0010533448,
0.0219909642,
-0.0365772173,
0.0288377535,
-0.0720344633,
0.0324686393,
0.0554057099,
-0.0154568013,
-0.0322700925,
-0.0485124141,
-0.0654703826,
-0.0045922701,
0.0091988677,
-0.0577655174,
0.0223191008,
0.0011126286,
-0.0061075715,
-0.0044524893,
0.0214448776,
0.0524240583,
0.054162275,
0.0097835856,
-0.0374455675,
-0.0026402967,
-0.0704444647,
0.0495840237,
0.0003464167,
-0.0007875122,
0.0496438295,
0.0910470039,
0.0345750898,
-0.039212659,
-0.0382041186,
0.0152407829,
-0.0103154983,
0.027478775,
-0.0017896207,
-0.0157944877,
0.0334821269,
-0.0036720978,
0.020840181,
-0.0332043208,
0.0690596923,
0.0133014536,
0.0206371266,
-0.1407639086,
0.0055788336,
-0.0622509457,
-0.0128539419,
0.018981602,
0.0033366759,
0.0079586925,
0.0006709513,
0.0553816967,
-0.0325260274,
0.007367854,
-0.007726544,
-0.0078192754,
-0.0164576732,
0.0013084918,
0.0156694166,
-0.0044332161,
0.0038210065,
0.0022693288,
-0.0713923723,
-0.018563332,
0.0629303381,
-0.0173560511,
-0.0414646901,
0.0291437544,
-0.0105504738,
-0.0059381342,
0.0129267452,
-0.009864362,
0.0325364955,
-0.0247206353,
0.0002382779,
-0.0522623323,
0.0227066912,
0.0171570051,
-0.0318105035,
0.0664696321,
-0.017128149,
0.0410015024,
-0.0434327312,
-0.0016081864,
-0.005707867,
-0.0575796142,
-0.0109084463,
-0.027758183,
0.0098495213,
-0.0231470373,
-0.0099253785,
0.1204615384,
0.0402061045,
-0.0153985834,
0.014405014,
-0.045546703,
-0.0105677079,
-0.0372907743,
0.0215763003,
-0.0345318988,
-0.0247706976,
-0.0480968654,
-0.0120686516,
-0.0245169271,
-0.039321702,
0.0075395419,
-0.0276699625,
0.017550176,
-0.0143650407,
0.0001382808,
-0.0486023948,
-0.0728042051,
-0.0080133053,
-0.0122832982,
-0.0041706273,
-0.0196780749,
-0.0219252016,
0.0271971207,
0.0039281137,
-0.0979581699,
-0.0430515446,
0.0369485393,
0.0223517809,
0.0271390174,
0.0429647341,
0.0995671377,
-0.0322388299,
-0.0147073613,
0.0169451423,
-0.0103765056,
-0.0163539387,
-0.0368892699,
0.0796263814,
-0.0318099037,
-0.0094658546,
-0.0404935069,
-0.0175513066,
-0.0289154928,
-0.0067202998,
0.0181342978,
0.0349819548,
-0.0416754074,
-0.0356067531,
-0.0685474575,
0.0641291589,
0.0257282406,
0.0496326983,
0.0046510315,
-0.0214650631,
-0.0423714221,
0.0201659519,
0.0131848063,
0.0370954946,
-0.0559670031,
-0.0045540659,
-0.0790022835,
-0.0555625856,
-0.1028267294,
-0.0009008962,
0.0421539918,
-0.0243325233,
0.0236336291,
0.0122863706,
0.0592473224,
-0.0045012212,
-0.0943125039,
0.0347790457,
0.0573578328,
0.0060350066,
-0.0040252805,
-0.0380606167,
0.0914334059,
0.0178418923,
-0.0198434126,
0.0100391246,
-0.016343968,
-0.032567516,
0.0020409687,
0.0134703368,
0.021116849,
-0.0049778484,
0.024300376,
0.0045620217,
-0.0000205502,
0.0686507449,
0.01993661,
-0.0483973511,
0.0151950223,
0.0535973534,
0.0235450715,
-0.0202361438,
0.0100911278,
0.0615924634,
0.0243414994,
-0.0032306074,
-0.0259861555,
0.0109306229,
-0.0010993459,
0.0191254579,
0.0751146451,
-0.0021310314,
-0.0326527096,
-0.0184043515,
-0.0425967425,
-0.0069105718,
-0.0018797109,
-0.0456503965,
-0.0462894626,
-0.014460464,
0.0197753906,
-0.0881144851,
0.015028636,
-0.0825839192,
0.0263212882,
-0.0430755913,
0.1276091337,
0.0030922587,
0.0105411969,
0.0381070785,
-0.0556773804,
-0.0340274982,
-0.0158897843,
-0.0239898097,
-0.0006227042,
0.0384397916,
0.0096028848,
0.0369060785,
0.0278282352,
0.0211157892,
0.0280598942,
-0.0432384871,
0.0156912189,
-0.0244762655,
0.0000811806,
-0.0615068972,
-0.0171748791,
0.0650350526,
-0.0241305493,
-0.0092582284,
-0.0132412128,
0.0720189959,
-0.0062732929,
0.0159444492,
0.0515219755,
-0.0099927755,
-0.0578343049,
-0.0576196313,
0.0308368187,
-0.002451364,
0.0471221544,
0.0488411561,
-0.0430092402,
-0.038374424,
-0.0512365289,
0.0534702092,
-0.0230578389,
0.0009012299,
0.0336976349,
-0.0487241931,
-0.0146142608,
0.0410171226,
-0.0252196509,
0.0324710459,
-0.0239488259,
-0.0267651454,
0.0061814804,
0.0367542319,
0.0170852412,
-0.032234557,
0.0455210581,
-0.0280774683,
-0.0316734686,
-0.0279047843,
-5.171339441e-33,
0.0057835975,
-0.0671214759,
-0.0152249038,
0.0251618307,
-0.0010989843,
0.0486769229,
-0.016807219,
-0.0014899091,
-0.0240648631,
0.0423200093,
-0.0022004859,
0.0205897912,
-0.0012625632,
0.0421837755,
0.0220646672,
-0.0009717856,
0.0125771891,
0.0155734634,
-0.0049074483,
-0.0027554911,
-0.016401194,
0.0344061777,
0.0666597188,
-0.0815181285,
0.0389396958,
-0.0026729745,
-0.0207008515,
-0.0259386115,
-0.0339769162,
0.0161052756,
-0.0342108607,
0.017248949,
0.0374801531,
0.0060134283,
0.0182061419,
0.0306800883,
0.0006119715,
-0.0312458146,
0.0226348396,
-0.0079423562,
0.0119206058,
0.0306088887,
0.0524671562,
0.0020544084,
-0.0349779949,
0.0436867364,
0.0453057103,
-0.0474645011,
0.0144489389,
-0.0556421839,
-0.0511266701,
0.0264378581,
0.0089829005,
0.0150957359,
-0.0106100161,
0.0047779749,
-0.0262058191,
0.0807242095,
-0.0490052626,
-0.0055348142,
0.0192208551,
-0.0185008254,
-0.0264608469,
-0.0550459549,
0.0189856887,
0.0762018263,
0.0063944752,
0.0004695185,
-0.0424941927,
0.0566716008,
-0.0079758344,
0.0050993385,
0.0097808549,
0.0155927278,
0.0251581464,
0.0113008879,
-0.0654468089,
0.0361059122,
0.0192694236,
0.0145824766,
0.0268771574,
-0.0038892746,
0.0048822295,
-0.0289802775,
0.0076976879,
0.0022671265,
0.0124759488,
-0.0005259721,
-0.0271669608,
-0.0498289764,
-0.0459514558,
-0.0294617359,
-0.0339237265,
-0.0096651614,
-0.0467775837,
-0.0042400141,
-0.0120584527,
0.0040230891,
-0.0214945842,
-0.0110237254,
-0.0324198119,
0.0024306024,
-0.0027766437,
0.0134507455,
0.0334883146,
-0.0144416569,
0.0261265431,
-0.0159446355,
-0.0714848861,
-0.0255573373,
0.0127669284,
0.0188857447,
0.0010665187,
0.101166077,
0.0087959198,
-0.0143085998,
0.0228138212,
0.033642631,
0.0102791833,
0.0153482771,
0.0098648053,
0.0682497174,
-0.0211109202,
-0.0192757268,
-0.0380052812,
-0.0243115854,
0.0037094865,
0.0368451476,
-0.0324749835,
-0.070566915,
0.0176001508,
-0.0764504448,
2.522e-7,
0.1338201761,
0.1021897793,
-0.0226832721,
0.0044730809,
0.0385153964,
0.0430311039,
-0.0171775576,
0.0180531535,
0.0111906957,
0.0135889174,
0.008993132,
-0.0066204094,
-0.0196226351,
0.0374113321,
-0.0507902764,
-0.006052136,
-0.0691474229,
-0.0451268218,
0.0126740998,
0.0232957155,
0.0366499685,
0.0297324117,
0.0107443715,
-0.0139835738,
0.0065821917,
0.0105306497,
0.023698926,
-0.0503274724,
0.0016461143,
0.0604558215,
-0.0009781929,
0.0044831699,
0.0212503038,
0.0339043252,
-0.0242979825,
-0.0455446765,
-0.0164165553,
0.0427982472,
-0.0162950438,
0.0269888416,
0.0277767759,
0.0026195827,
0.0109180147,
-0.0133447731,
0.0150076495,
-0.0862668976,
-0.0665865242,
-0.0653843805,
-0.0165576041,
-0.0028752743,
0.0617367402,
0.0014377215,
-0.0302936137,
0.0172485616,
-0.0019392685,
-0.0145294257,
-0.028800115,
-0.0756352171,
-0.021937646,
-0.0081469603,
-0.0300305653,
-0.0509282239,
0.0305981003,
-0.0201460849,
0.0181080941,
-0.0963941589,
0.0304412264,
2.072101289e-34,
0.0840655342,
-0.0195081253,
-0.0196614694,
0.0227066483,
0.0098684067,
0.0250921212,
0.0251619332,
-0.0006570851,
0.0172844119,
-0.0097321616,
0.0145202037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03169v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03169v3 | Data Selection for Language Models via Importance Resampling | 2023-02-06T23:57:56 | 2023-11-18T21:33:01 | Sang Michael Xie, Shibani Santurkar, Tengyu Ma, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Selecting a suitable pretraining dataset is crucial for both general-domain
(e.g., GPT-3) and domain-specific (e.g., Codex) language models (LMs). We
formalize this problem as selecting a subset of a large raw unlabeled dataset
to match a desired target distribution given unlabeled target samples. Due to
the scale and dimensionality of the raw text data, existing methods use simple
heuristics or require human experts to manually curate data. Instead, we extend
the classic importance resampling approach used in low-dimensions for LM data
selection. We propose Data Selection with Importance Resampling (DSIR), an
efficient and scalable framework that estimates importance weights in a reduced
feature space for tractability and selects data with importance resampling
according to these weights. We instantiate the DSIR framework with hashed
n-gram features for efficiency, enabling the selection of 100M documents from
the full Pile dataset in 4.5 hours. To measure whether hashed n-gram features
preserve the aspects of the data that are relevant to the target, we define KL
reduction, a data metric that measures the proximity between the selected
pretraining data and the target on some feature space. Across 8 data selection
methods (including expert selection), KL reduction on hashed n-gram features
highly correlates with average downstream accuracy (r=0.82). When selecting
data for continued pretraining on a specific domain, DSIR performs comparably
to expert curation across 8 target distributions. When pretraining
general-domain models (target is Wikipedia and books), DSIR improves over
random selection and heuristic filtering baselines by 2-2.5% on the GLUE
benchmark. Code is available at https://github.com/p-lambda/dsir. | [
0.0146467341,
0.066023238,
-0.0022837291,
-0.0145849232,
-0.0298451986,
0.0209490545,
0.020758437,
0.0329849347,
0.0082551893,
-0.082678698,
-0.0228413325,
-0.0133768162,
0.0034746255,
0.0070691444,
0.0148423258,
-0.0494157709,
0.0056949742,
-0.0203984622,
0.0001596288,
-0.0270675048,
0.0065833875,
0.0507877879,
0.0140758725,
0.0290024132,
0.0221455377,
0.0292161684,
0.0295289345,
0.0068731806,
-0.0204798859,
-0.0071161459,
0.0240997281,
0.0900161937,
0.0370822847,
-0.0381499492,
0.0000023701,
-0.0472643487,
-0.0460321717,
-0.0283280276,
-0.0147196911,
0.005182086,
0.0376162454,
-0.0472575203,
0.000590558,
-0.008262122,
-0.0343908109,
-0.0370140001,
0.0375908427,
0.0478679352,
0.0106893852,
0.0563779175,
-0.0216566641,
-0.0325489193,
0.0019130094,
-0.0335142463,
0.0121633336,
-0.0583923385,
0.0455436334,
0.0483138263,
-0.0215251669,
0.0275011081,
-0.0140729798,
0.0109827789,
-0.0307914633,
-0.0054424452,
0.0515906252,
0.0177094713,
-0.0208087377,
0.0195774324,
0.0397363007,
0.080812715,
-0.0427386463,
-0.057221625,
0.0299272686,
-0.0182466544,
-0.0175331719,
0.0355842523,
-0.0393428355,
-0.0353597365,
0.0089346208,
0.0494696647,
-0.0035679541,
0.0094847707,
0.040277347,
0.0387580954,
-0.0068282047,
0.0133467661,
0.0136073111,
-0.0094957361,
0.041913297,
0.0205246042,
-0.0674736947,
-0.0404548906,
-0.0000579941,
-0.0386483148,
-0.0059900559,
0.0087593365,
-0.0621261783,
-0.0488536768,
-0.0023474859,
-0.0162323527,
-0.0106299873,
0.0056902994,
0.0218900256,
0.0494858809,
0.0325577296,
0.0182130188,
0.0484792739,
0.0120390737,
-0.027807951,
0.0026936536,
-0.0616658814,
0.0241820589,
-0.0220407806,
0.0439449735,
0.0112187685,
-0.0005193645,
-0.0247797258,
-0.0202770289,
0.0021013352,
-0.0620880015,
0.0326437131,
-0.0173740648,
-0.0375244431,
-0.0222801268,
0.0001935114,
0.0251543075,
-0.0080156801,
0.0370924696,
-0.0603120737,
-0.0423815139,
0.0229384247,
0.0083254073,
0.0082089184,
-0.0453117415,
0.0342836566,
0.0275728181,
0.0009660099,
-0.0679399818,
-0.0587142706,
0.0175785739,
0.0033926424,
-0.0596898459,
-0.0163473263,
-0.0791141838,
-0.0009024182,
-0.0045928354,
0.0253412202,
-0.0893148705,
-0.0340629481,
0.015996471,
-0.0431613997,
0.057295423,
0.0073441183,
0.0211601909,
0.0268898569,
-0.0272512101,
0.0149702402,
0.0536406972,
0.01866965,
0.0018911188,
0.0631673709,
-0.0173834842,
0.0156698599,
0.0031879407,
0.0040126294,
0.0287338216,
-0.0155471954,
-0.0162366442,
-0.0274023414,
-0.0106313489,
0.0474586077,
-0.0071272533,
-0.0204311255,
-0.0274900291,
0.0584486052,
0.0786523819,
0.012445177,
0.0104792919,
-0.0066527808,
0.0680568442,
0.0091567403,
0.0066943015,
-0.0215936322,
0.0167259462,
-0.0190186985,
-0.0085849557,
0.0210080799,
0.0314014554,
-0.0407472029,
-0.0199986529,
-0.0004097232,
-0.0023145266,
0.0058176205,
0.0390770994,
0.1012919545,
0.0195772815,
-0.0065505826,
0.0506249703,
0.0470048338,
-0.0475879498,
0.0018353206,
-0.0333628431,
0.0207357481,
0.0351179354,
0.0421151482,
-0.0496549308,
0.0211204365,
-0.0037679104,
0.0730093718,
-0.0171345454,
0.0403148793,
0.0011216666,
0.0026615865,
-0.0728766248,
-0.0572155491,
0.0199877992,
0.0287603773,
0.0044473801,
0.0065046847,
0.0236541331,
0.0135393031,
-0.0816869289,
-0.0582436174,
0.0508349054,
-0.0236613248,
-0.024476815,
0.0198550168,
-0.0008332415,
0.0297370628,
-0.0080255158,
-0.0320376493,
-0.0232919995,
0.0216583367,
-0.0111482665,
0.0072948267,
-0.0431203619,
-0.0124006299,
0.0008396048,
0.0172032062,
-0.0466398336,
0.0186901558,
0.0591062121,
-0.0502365343,
-0.0351522006,
0.0286448095,
-0.0311510619,
-0.0023612566,
-0.0581207722,
0.0071348189,
-0.0404574424,
0.0242190529,
-0.0673633516,
0.0556878746,
0.0032410047,
-0.0055528185,
0.0007826513,
-0.0321362242,
-0.0005721237,
-0.0210612547,
-0.0182669703,
0.0253326315,
0.0058426117,
0.0331965573,
0.0636823922,
0.0215401743,
-0.0061739562,
-0.0159714818,
-0.0789249763,
-0.014583624,
-0.0476047955,
0.0286774747,
0.0047545726,
0.0284049343,
-0.0246920399,
-0.0156033738,
-0.0020365883,
-0.0395987406,
-0.0226988122,
-0.0104618939,
-0.011932252,
-0.028611755,
0.0532772765,
-0.0332557671,
-0.0356474183,
0.0394060127,
0.0589758754,
0.0120792156,
-0.0372332036,
-0.0015912675,
0.0382705331,
-0.038658414,
0.0111238202,
-0.0042234501,
-0.0177972037,
-0.0336698852,
-0.0282170419,
-0.024651764,
0.0063491263,
0.0124610066,
0.0048555853,
0.0727089047,
0.0117912116,
-0.0572294965,
-0.0140479729,
-0.0217243228,
0.0357996114,
-0.0352519676,
-0.0134750921,
0.021394195,
0.0410881266,
0.0074716406,
-0.0410376936,
-0.0475071408,
0.0370629542,
-0.0120304096,
0.0270262584,
-0.0510046445,
0.0299918707,
-0.0073814937,
0.0246952865,
-0.0063227876,
-0.0615895018,
0.0776729137,
-0.0353212506,
0.0083931796,
-0.0907743648,
-0.0038503956,
-0.0247539859,
0.0344098657,
-0.0026892284,
-0.0159785207,
0.0246794093,
0.0188479125,
-0.0121185379,
0.0230968837,
0.0284191538,
-0.0251801591,
0.0425345153,
-0.080807358,
0.0739198551,
0.0290962812,
-0.0089008054,
0.0042397678,
-0.0554461218,
-0.0298976153,
-0.0168765243,
0.0078525878,
0.0055101505,
-0.0135337682,
0.0395470932,
0.0188538153,
0.0663821325,
-0.0074197855,
-0.0118059814,
0.0036059748,
-0.0024025128,
0.060759861,
0.0137548875,
-0.0054086884,
0.0061948495,
-0.0097694239,
0.0200022552,
0.0498878621,
-0.017394403,
-0.0154105527,
0.0342993513,
0.0368565954,
-0.0395758376,
-0.030108504,
-0.0052787485,
0.009327054,
-0.0249142591,
0.028815493,
0.1065130085,
0.0096301567,
-0.1019500941,
-0.0007532362,
0.0441732965,
0.0201082826,
0.0026971644,
0.039584633,
-0.0346573554,
-0.0516983531,
0.0217839312,
0.0381550491,
-0.005395411,
-0.0549883991,
-0.0211931393,
-0.082740292,
0.0492087193,
0.0103856493,
-0.0288838949,
-0.0148719866,
-0.0692343637,
0.0229192264,
-0.0488198809,
0.010876854,
-0.0158621464,
-0.0402472802,
0.0128873345,
0.0175692867,
-0.0210828595,
-0.1107265502,
0.0387040377,
-0.0111121098,
0.0109335799,
0.0558048449,
0.0252948459,
0.0038021074,
-0.0030755566,
0.0389885195,
-0.0023391596,
-0.020840643,
-0.0320009999,
0.0789059997,
0.0058591585,
-0.0046495483,
0.0116675487,
0.0565827228,
-0.0379048288,
0.0192493666,
-0.0042935489,
0.0423011072,
-0.0299112592,
-0.0222372431,
0.0142619507,
-0.029983826,
0.0200396869,
0.0563399494,
0.0253930464,
-0.0435961075,
-0.008802495,
0.0038341081,
0.0009566509,
-0.0124640632,
-0.0649458617,
0.0181978513,
-0.0447988324,
-0.0317298025,
-0.0683357865,
-0.0130540002,
0.0343635902,
0.0335444175,
-0.0064144814,
0.0419282652,
0.0128659075,
-0.0059942277,
-0.0294412076,
0.0545832291,
-0.0441064946,
0.0134391086,
-0.0584963784,
-0.0402734168,
0.03615826,
-0.0418098047,
-0.0429400206,
-0.0105440542,
-0.0314414501,
-0.0426911116,
0.0003000646,
0.0329635739,
0.0252873469,
0.0277271215,
-0.0114632184,
-0.0863615796,
0.0424893498,
0.0026169731,
-0.0586979203,
0.0347334072,
0.0168701969,
-0.0991005823,
-0.0215737224,
0.0507783331,
-0.0542855151,
0.0597472712,
0.0347420312,
-0.0099243037,
-0.0019673763,
-0.0129970526,
-0.0258766059,
0.0324508548,
0.0592691116,
-0.0130241243,
-0.0073029515,
-0.0577126183,
0.0081912093,
0.0300805848,
-0.0114414198,
-0.0643154532,
0.0219541807,
0.0005446169,
0.0015135608,
-0.0345110781,
0.0256493818,
-0.0195730422,
-0.0143985106,
-0.0271818377,
0.0020246785,
-0.0301889833,
0.0572541095,
0.0431039296,
0.0012716645,
-0.0118324887,
-0.0034658406,
0.0124573074,
0.0142139187,
-0.0276246481,
-0.0190657526,
0.0058324025,
0.0250171963,
-0.0426654778,
0.017916128,
-0.0512114652,
-0.0180287287,
-0.0373649448,
-0.0045759338,
0.0640120432,
-0.0683214068,
0.100089103,
0.0006503896,
-0.0020320783,
-0.0729054362,
0.0276738107,
0.0570901893,
0.0168550368,
-0.0203387123,
0.0089860829,
-0.0371857435,
0.0619900413,
0.1312472671,
0.0315077342,
0.0090121236,
0.031994693,
-0.030299997,
-0.0109086586,
-0.012172346,
-0.01478473,
0.0378794782,
-0.0179779343,
0.0000568479,
-0.0449140668,
-0.0497841053,
-0.0014355002,
-0.0727463737,
-0.053100355,
0.0041444646,
0.0767212287,
0.0578427128,
-0.0211581755,
0.053337276,
-0.0479909778,
-0.0402316488,
-0.051490508,
-0.0228979886,
-0.0078226468,
-6.887296339e-33,
0.0143984295,
-0.0147206243,
-0.0339903347,
0.0092697879,
0.0149784395,
0.0172394942,
-0.0357820652,
-0.0231056884,
0.0039719827,
0.0184464473,
-0.015911825,
-0.0055808425,
0.0119904475,
0.0359210745,
-0.0222965088,
0.0232707635,
0.0390163735,
-0.0090344241,
-0.0152067756,
0.0425674841,
0.0193416625,
0.0473133735,
0.0834273174,
-0.0668590292,
-0.0115050534,
0.0004731345,
0.0199219752,
-0.0264781881,
0.0292042419,
0.0464120656,
0.0001805532,
0.0593369156,
0.024129767,
-0.0848144963,
-0.0408145264,
-0.0354152806,
-0.043066591,
-0.0535929538,
0.0000453147,
0.0070671048,
0.0205068011,
-0.0084067658,
0.0297450572,
0.0119214375,
-0.0035215928,
-0.0202646311,
0.0611536056,
-0.0208850056,
-0.0615802854,
0.0016173237,
-0.0142660392,
0.0573984273,
-0.0116630113,
0.0036894807,
0.0597798079,
0.0228810515,
-0.0082587944,
0.009193155,
-0.0114515563,
0.0182757825,
0.031945318,
0.0387254544,
0.0379744433,
-0.0212172158,
0.0225086771,
0.0890433267,
-0.0150711564,
-0.0313557163,
0.0216581337,
-0.0066281841,
0.0511111654,
0.0142797288,
0.0120966025,
0.0433879793,
0.0513879433,
-0.0287807342,
-0.0795013607,
0.052547276,
0.022933485,
0.0030062119,
0.0247285292,
0.0188300721,
-0.0206451621,
-0.0493760183,
-0.0378413685,
-0.0061841868,
-0.0207187627,
-0.0380265824,
-0.001587112,
0.0226353426,
-0.0535956882,
0.0022388797,
0.0114444243,
-0.0343453921,
-0.0560419708,
0.056966994,
-0.0402243771,
0.0078787077,
0.0224357974,
-0.021744309,
-0.0273102652,
0.000138684,
0.0424549505,
-0.0370352082,
0.0134119447,
-0.0244402084,
0.0070701065,
0.0208067559,
-0.019276984,
0.0019756863,
0.0110266684,
-0.0202056244,
0.0076767486,
0.0835826769,
0.0046032863,
0.0450506546,
0.0099925166,
0.056594599,
0.011408383,
-0.0201994721,
0.00398074,
-0.0236588735,
0.0236201566,
0.0333660692,
-0.0217772648,
-0.0251849033,
-0.0335621275,
-0.0334039591,
0.0636173338,
-0.0080536241,
-0.0197567064,
0.011918393,
3.032e-7,
0.0489296094,
0.0449062623,
-0.014430291,
-0.0504963771,
0.0055206344,
0.0342919827,
-0.0069318167,
0.0491107777,
0.0033464432,
0.0116882073,
0.0249338727,
0.0174643844,
0.0928883925,
0.0052727195,
-0.1288517714,
-0.0121007292,
-0.0312064644,
0.0057023438,
-0.0356650762,
-0.0240432266,
-0.0173761323,
0.0887604728,
0.0309912413,
-0.0264637098,
0.0054361764,
-0.0179018341,
0.0343002528,
-0.0650928766,
0.022710368,
0.0388519131,
0.0649621114,
0.0301567987,
-0.0353516005,
0.0434163697,
-0.0362305976,
-0.0018376723,
0.024358118,
0.0637861341,
-0.0170952752,
0.0106845871,
-0.0131185967,
0.0250607934,
0.0129851475,
-0.0104191126,
0.0954147279,
-0.0309838038,
-0.011128258,
0.001814009,
0.0028928604,
-0.0407376774,
0.0180286355,
-0.0091229817,
-0.0226932187,
0.0523855649,
0.0406344011,
-0.0130632631,
-0.041705858,
-0.0718278438,
0.0098152589,
0.0259351488,
-0.0480444729,
0.0099634323,
-0.0329590701,
-0.0345990732,
0.0436336584,
-0.0476203598,
0.0502920449,
2.951948939e-34,
0.0299678277,
0.0054515316,
-0.0155376932,
-0.0109176459,
-0.0022541822,
-0.0170870107,
0.0125158336,
0.0132394312,
-0.0233717728,
-0.0893417671,
0.0062070587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03162v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03162v3 | Protecting Language Generation Models via Invisible Watermarking | 2023-02-06T23:42:03 | 2023-08-27T00:13:09 | Xuandong Zhao, Yu-Xiang Wang, Lei Li | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language generation models have been an increasingly powerful enabler for
many applications. Many such models offer free or affordable API access, which
makes them potentially vulnerable to model extraction attacks through
distillation. To protect intellectual property (IP) and ensure fair use of
these models, various techniques such as lexical watermarking and synonym
replacement have been proposed. However, these methods can be nullified by
obvious countermeasures such as "synonym randomization". To address this issue,
we propose GINSEW, a novel method to protect text generation models from being
stolen through distillation. The key idea of our method is to inject secret
signals into the probability vector of the decoding steps for each target
token. We can then detect the secret message by probing a suspect model to tell
if it is distilled from the protected one. Experimental results show that
GINSEW can effectively identify instances of IP infringement with minimal
impact on the generation quality of protected APIs. Our method demonstrates an
absolute improvement of 19 to 29 points on mean average precision (mAP) in
detecting suspects compared to previous methods against watermark removal
attacks. | [
0.0363097265,
0.0866250247,
-0.0115052313,
0.0643220693,
-0.0586482547,
-0.0111397319,
0.030976288,
0.0211868584,
-0.0119710164,
-0.0252870489,
0.0246285275,
0.0034243774,
0.0189628135,
0.0463804677,
0.0532415882,
0.0334270597,
0.0289382022,
-0.0064332644,
0.0080609713,
-0.019544946,
-0.0227719024,
0.0083744582,
0.0538165718,
0.0412902758,
-0.0014997785,
-0.0025717635,
-0.0049567795,
0.0186327044,
-0.00016631,
-0.0111178216,
-0.0334130116,
0.0735631287,
-0.0250572562,
0.0964689925,
0.0000021077,
-0.0351207815,
-0.0335377306,
0.0337414928,
-0.0308681056,
0.0761407912,
0.0017976676,
0.0106652062,
-0.006174135,
0.0265734494,
-0.0343327262,
0.0382735655,
0.0226132143,
0.0060770991,
0.0862779468,
0.0216358118,
-0.0080525335,
0.0046351403,
0.0133386822,
-0.0009614162,
0.0007898395,
-0.0441809595,
0.0079011451,
0.0081449589,
-0.042273704,
0.0248478279,
0.0129328705,
0.0419392958,
0.0012196578,
-0.0003024655,
-0.0364243761,
0.0044226544,
-0.0389712676,
-0.0286621526,
-0.001270615,
0.0245587155,
-0.0828979164,
-0.045211751,
0.0186906476,
-0.0030276622,
0.0202342886,
0.0153978486,
-0.0007154568,
0.0285582244,
0.0209062193,
0.0199907906,
0.0399673805,
-0.0107194623,
0.0395249575,
-0.0240125842,
0.009656406,
0.0522125214,
0.0594877116,
0.0060950778,
-0.0613218807,
-0.0426620841,
-0.0306995343,
-0.0812873617,
0.0034479755,
-0.016272461,
0.0373915136,
0.0175842196,
-0.1086079478,
-0.0634674132,
0.0076932418,
-0.0475955121,
0.0040476019,
0.0479173586,
0.0132004796,
-0.0011588096,
-0.0466562584,
0.039479766,
-0.0059418296,
0.0443372503,
0.0212851651,
-0.0142371617,
-0.0028049964,
-0.0304051731,
-0.0277227163,
0.0574668497,
-0.0612075664,
-0.03271823,
-0.0247140974,
0.0345576555,
-0.0061050877,
0.0333559588,
-0.0386857428,
0.0148912678,
-0.010244241,
-0.0044842018,
0.0615141615,
-0.0601643026,
0.039119903,
-0.0119935498,
-0.0094092302,
-0.0610347278,
-0.024281349,
0.0044367318,
-0.0126192775,
0.0353529118,
-0.0227905624,
0.0860386193,
0.0187789984,
-0.012611011,
-0.0312583856,
-0.1138671711,
0.0289433673,
0.0192854032,
-0.0270700343,
-0.0834895298,
-0.0324151926,
-0.0217504986,
-0.0141295698,
-0.0916863233,
0.0223431122,
0.0022651765,
-0.0441489257,
0.0360903367,
-0.0432700031,
-0.0064085131,
-0.0187357049,
0.0183163583,
-0.0153358765,
0.056159731,
0.0168862659,
0.0495791212,
0.0596816987,
0.0002256628,
0.0417754352,
0.0389685743,
0.0109843472,
0.0246670414,
-0.0300738681,
-0.0471155941,
0.0668392852,
-0.063046746,
-0.0114163207,
0.0537853204,
-0.0091264667,
-0.027436262,
0.0632984713,
0.0564933792,
-0.0470804572,
0.0328286588,
0.0125065017,
0.0161630251,
-0.025701521,
-0.0322268605,
-0.0007369847,
-0.0475981198,
-0.0598290302,
-0.02550059,
0.0260883346,
0.012598481,
0.0229758751,
0.0204402357,
-0.0069416952,
-0.0370739587,
0.00919363,
-0.0393352844,
0.002353882,
0.0545674041,
-0.0186977275,
0.058397688,
0.0012458861,
-0.0312162936,
0.0079248147,
-0.0885268301,
0.0015562652,
0.0363717899,
0.0871621817,
0.057985913,
0.0737988576,
0.0049789939,
-0.0607771315,
0.0312722586,
-0.0221348554,
-0.0042467457,
0.0498940945,
-0.0129536167,
-0.0231685136,
-0.0216897484,
0.0234154984,
0.0364541076,
0.0346773453,
0.0483928621,
0.0565781184,
-0.0785791501,
-0.0250286199,
0.0010630498,
-0.0245738775,
-0.0636366755,
0.032507129,
-0.0254563447,
0.0118184388,
0.0255565029,
-0.0319556259,
0.054920923,
0.0092075923,
-0.0253853593,
0.0050180024,
-0.0009833756,
0.0178578775,
0.0184834674,
0.0210676044,
-0.0186375342,
0.0424041599,
0.0417915806,
-0.0157130919,
-0.0121312737,
0.057992164,
-0.0444577709,
0.0440237634,
-0.0265058763,
0.0373352952,
-0.0220478866,
0.0450610742,
-0.0236358959,
-0.0159682743,
-0.0221859887,
0.0165571831,
0.0270688422,
0.027775405,
0.0335441828,
0.0212418009,
-0.0406807698,
0.0010706196,
-0.0414951779,
0.0025230772,
0.0091915308,
0.0247764364,
0.019046288,
-0.0168169662,
-0.013223676,
0.0028610886,
-0.0229039025,
0.0222688541,
0.0467622615,
0.0433345847,
-0.0189740974,
-0.0105000585,
-0.0172715262,
-0.0572498925,
0.0093801897,
-0.0071990993,
-0.0014504935,
-0.0430690907,
-0.0602261461,
0.0148914224,
0.0073937173,
0.0275456067,
0.0834589154,
-0.0268926602,
-0.013428783,
-0.0623443127,
-0.0136490557,
-0.0278380271,
0.0166880563,
0.0288476441,
-0.0216748528,
0.0002114107,
-0.0111275548,
-0.0272055864,
0.0066809836,
0.0145250782,
-0.0095706014,
0.0128031056,
-0.003442884,
-0.0489045605,
-0.0497093089,
-0.0132290162,
-0.0104559213,
-0.0015053973,
-0.0552276634,
0.0553707331,
0.0482725576,
0.0447669774,
-0.0240439214,
-0.0194802433,
0.0594780631,
-0.0034684166,
-0.013570996,
0.0064498656,
-0.0228325315,
-0.0310805012,
-0.0015187468,
-0.0210406724,
-0.0626930445,
0.0244532339,
-0.0816318467,
0.0367730223,
-0.0353911519,
-0.012278487,
0.0306913145,
0.0338621177,
-0.0255922284,
0.0373291783,
0.0195960291,
-0.0297175311,
-0.0042620976,
0.0147675825,
0.058665216,
-0.0501294397,
-0.0359490998,
-0.0404201001,
-0.0199609008,
0.0116979787,
0.0324553251,
-0.0616742037,
-0.019662071,
0.0043525524,
0.0126254968,
0.0672577098,
-0.0180648807,
0.0332024992,
-0.0021174671,
0.0094718151,
0.0365311019,
-0.0044950726,
0.0077289795,
-0.0555150546,
0.0405374765,
0.0034352844,
-0.0854907855,
-0.0149415927,
-0.0004715698,
0.0057369228,
0.0485864244,
0.016030468,
0.0192003883,
-0.0071617812,
0.003609352,
0.0350097269,
0.0011081037,
0.0138347484,
0.0510570034,
0.0090476489,
0.0117282048,
-0.0157101341,
0.0525993668,
0.0292409025,
0.0226663109,
0.0402048044,
0.0104275746,
0.0361109339,
0.0136865824,
-0.0138673233,
-0.0924865529,
-0.0051993937,
0.0351715498,
0.0638677031,
-0.0294763651,
-0.0084603727,
-0.0405877978,
-0.0843684301,
0.0131265279,
0.0387413017,
-0.0184211936,
-0.0342249461,
-0.0249658469,
-0.0326933637,
0.0581823587,
-0.0090624103,
-0.0374995656,
0.0657382309,
0.0237375051,
0.0075943423,
-0.0317845494,
-0.0504235327,
-0.0223274734,
-0.0192264691,
0.0276305098,
0.0731809139,
0.0037537245,
0.0175583977,
-0.0376295708,
0.03237639,
-0.0011948338,
-0.0255178288,
-0.002973763,
0.0131848296,
0.0222117864,
-0.0268565658,
0.0103538996,
0.025025133,
-0.0104717622,
-0.0592187271,
-0.0242976248,
0.0024818834,
0.0057460163,
-0.0168438889,
0.0002297984,
-0.0307382382,
0.0543269441,
0.0295841638,
0.036016766,
-0.0215966459,
-0.0230473951,
-0.0605558828,
0.0320012346,
-0.0410162508,
-0.0150462678,
-0.0061015198,
-0.0069447379,
-0.0980234444,
-0.0642214417,
0.052651003,
-0.0613221191,
0.0306742527,
0.0571511164,
0.0295034293,
0.0274802037,
-0.0175892469,
-0.0477954112,
-0.0410885736,
-0.0622734092,
0.0339917131,
-0.0298669916,
-0.0080825584,
-0.0223110095,
-0.0037708741,
-0.0415550731,
0.0647095293,
-0.0920911208,
-0.090174742,
0.0156404786,
0.057350602,
0.0276898742,
-0.0040175286,
-0.0366258211,
-0.0436471105,
0.0729773045,
0.0534163825,
0.0109651303,
0.0046319459,
0.0461519957,
-0.0360198468,
0.0251627378,
0.0116898045,
-0.0421683677,
-0.0223052707,
0.0771678239,
-0.0046302327,
-0.0088016251,
0.0133843347,
0.0151410457,
0.0898840427,
0.0039486405,
-0.0456847437,
0.0415045843,
0.0087422458,
0.0101119503,
-0.0303010866,
-0.0141862733,
-0.0355433337,
0.0177864805,
0.0185996145,
-0.0207717735,
0.0268906988,
0.0028122168,
0.0047285222,
0.0145048965,
0.0272405352,
-0.0209847409,
-0.0455563702,
0.0378545932,
0.0444067307,
-0.0109931333,
-0.020429682,
0.0184075236,
-0.0092378277,
0.0053086076,
-0.0229150355,
0.0170036238,
0.0161196459,
-0.0027022318,
-0.0007239188,
0.041621495,
-0.0284174513,
-0.0714196712,
-0.0314059481,
0.0436122492,
0.0178026669,
0.0322224498,
0.0081700776,
-0.046739839,
0.0176701583,
-0.0169265326,
0.0132757844,
-0.0340025425,
-0.0546725206,
-0.0391822569,
-0.0442191921,
-0.0354344845,
0.0278024897,
0.0727983415,
-0.0038997137,
0.0465997308,
-0.0228992011,
-0.0240153521,
-0.0464733988,
-0.0065768976,
0.0530077145,
0.0383706987,
-0.0529413372,
-0.002851363,
-0.0457481556,
-0.0731217191,
-0.0180274807,
0.0022180404,
0.0427129976,
0.0467698574,
-0.0349561386,
0.0562394187,
-0.0049298052,
-0.0076282583,
-0.0892497376,
0.0148742627,
0.0262717251,
-0.0543823056,
0.0129144052,
-5.622070627e-33,
0.0132594584,
-0.0182800386,
-0.0727613345,
-0.0028556548,
0.0410955437,
0.0286441818,
-0.043058712,
0.0169563331,
0.0311464779,
-0.0194810666,
0.0242394321,
-0.0189273302,
0.0173686799,
0.0210441574,
-0.0374905914,
0.0207863953,
0.0341622308,
0.0373375155,
-0.0265132878,
0.0381106436,
0.0548742898,
-0.0144657139,
0.0017258852,
-0.0505969375,
0.0036402964,
-0.0449265689,
-0.022685485,
-0.0310628358,
-0.0193578284,
0.0193642844,
0.0083564967,
0.0063838516,
-0.0130870705,
-0.0175831486,
-0.0494736061,
0.0027181879,
0.013883288,
-0.0240517594,
0.0196631495,
0.0032537251,
0.0349669084,
-0.0616641976,
0.0401865952,
-0.0051336898,
-0.0279366821,
0.0408583619,
-0.0285455752,
0.0013453604,
-0.0431034118,
-0.049821388,
-0.026584696,
-0.0037093027,
-0.0202682316,
0.0042475918,
0.0527697168,
-0.0180627294,
0.0138793634,
-0.0244787056,
-0.0615987778,
0.0410235152,
0.0350335613,
0.0116484184,
0.0689009726,
0.0158351082,
0.0044701337,
0.0385136381,
-0.0028188485,
-0.0240993164,
0.0444585234,
0.0181391276,
0.0173335094,
0.0514881313,
0.023466384,
0.0109405909,
0.078061685,
-0.0536410548,
0.0205413103,
0.0317355767,
-0.042867519,
-0.0329267979,
0.0582729876,
-0.0219393056,
-0.0247418992,
-0.0087151499,
-0.0420012996,
-0.0711120516,
-0.0273101255,
-0.0168864522,
0.0226076059,
0.0256516729,
-0.0494394191,
-0.0033292281,
0.0113969622,
-0.0752921328,
-0.0305782091,
0.0222834554,
-0.0241246577,
-0.0082621779,
-0.0284972917,
0.0041250228,
0.0344797075,
-0.0194533579,
0.0308982078,
-0.0517396629,
0.0351942889,
-0.0094137229,
-0.0108574824,
0.0074161915,
-0.0740908161,
0.0103013227,
-0.0193047263,
0.0493736938,
0.0282300115,
0.0018714068,
0.0178170316,
-0.022832673,
-0.0056068129,
-0.0736114904,
0.0156356841,
-0.0038273048,
-0.0158590861,
0.0363991372,
-0.000521005,
0.0359711163,
-0.0044085262,
0.0229315963,
-0.0187241584,
0.0528040491,
0.0565346405,
0.0113344677,
-0.0306050107,
-0.0144735519,
2.946e-7,
-0.0112030162,
0.0107756453,
0.0372095257,
0.0031831702,
0.0167068522,
0.0643441081,
0.0198835768,
0.0555960461,
-0.0446794443,
-0.0169537608,
-0.072374694,
-0.0391201377,
0.0498550534,
0.0012219441,
-0.0604920387,
0.058453761,
-0.0557811297,
0.0048280112,
-0.0616644137,
-0.0122391423,
0.0451389477,
0.0540837906,
0.0238417871,
-0.0401642695,
0.0016320848,
-0.0407677516,
-0.0122033972,
0.0050139539,
0.0031579176,
0.0008994619,
0.0141211562,
0.0264520776,
0.0571555272,
0.013041487,
-0.0743148625,
-0.0107448921,
-0.0269799102,
0.0177038442,
0.0039197695,
0.0116590392,
-0.0470862091,
-0.0542131364,
0.0038231853,
-0.0332626887,
0.0273372829,
0.0694852471,
-0.0176173449,
-0.0610550568,
-0.0327790231,
-0.0068953754,
-0.0031207085,
-0.0095410319,
0.003181316,
0.0263915695,
0.0055874661,
0.0432402492,
0.0072566075,
-0.0362951085,
-0.0342514403,
-0.0730474815,
-0.036305733,
-0.0315364748,
-0.0227961466,
0.0179903843,
0.0364885777,
0.0067374818,
0.0512944311,
2.915112114e-34,
-0.0007739219,
-0.0565377809,
0.0174388029,
0.0699469224,
0.0264415219,
0.0086653857,
0.0184402484,
0.0360655971,
-0.0183812957,
-0.0011789495,
-0.0193956029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03147v1 | It's about Time: Rethinking Evaluation on Rumor Detection Benchmarks using Chronological Splits | 2023-02-06T22:53:13 | 2023-02-06T22:53:13 | Yida Mu, Kalina Bontcheva, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL | New events emerge over time influencing the topics of rumors in social media.
Current rumor detection benchmarks use random splits as training, development
and test sets which typically results in topical overlaps. Consequently, models
trained on random splits may not perform well on rumor classification on
previously unseen topics due to the temporal concept drift. In this paper, we
provide a re-evaluation of classification models on four popular rumor
detection benchmarks considering chronological instead of random splits. Our
experimental results show that the use of random splits can significantly
overestimate predictive performance across all datasets and models. Therefore,
we suggest that rumor detection models should always be evaluated using
chronological splits for minimizing topical overlaps. | [
0.0398404002,
0.0494063608,
0.0090936041,
0.0474619642,
-0.0652887151,
-0.0279652141,
0.0313581601,
0.0234688111,
-0.0118725402,
-0.0457733795,
0.0236988887,
-0.0567884855,
-0.0085523231,
0.0655112714,
-0.0539932214,
-0.0215462931,
0.0529548414,
0.0062099681,
0.0375270694,
-0.0223051328,
-0.0062608812,
-0.0045989975,
-0.0097718835,
0.0107799191,
-0.0443909019,
-0.004772366,
0.0099454606,
0.0025660566,
-0.0024314863,
-0.0462597795,
-0.0012289715,
0.0302445497,
0.0392602347,
0.0520267487,
0.0000016803,
-0.0295435861,
-0.029045755,
0.0253388174,
-0.0308845155,
0.0077355951,
0.0271084402,
-0.0238189436,
0.0067056012,
0.0377815515,
-0.0238162354,
-0.0163305383,
-0.0160509329,
0.0439943783,
0.0286534838,
0.0679027736,
-0.0305477288,
0.0106167486,
0.021647634,
-0.0317305848,
0.0429618768,
-0.0902731866,
0.0501903109,
-0.0279003195,
-0.0778879896,
0.0003749013,
0.0164178107,
-0.0162897874,
0.0190161932,
0.0340618268,
0.0252643749,
0.0429904014,
-0.02331171,
-0.0265472382,
-0.0425656959,
-0.0342094749,
-0.0141197005,
-0.0434113443,
-0.0151798548,
0.0127512133,
0.0179736931,
0.0085580284,
-0.0367392339,
-0.0148545047,
-0.0266067255,
0.0128344605,
0.0229023453,
0.0235819891,
0.0361421593,
0.0344874784,
0.0411856771,
0.0571753718,
0.0021200748,
-0.0475121066,
0.0104385382,
0.0141696008,
0.0331311785,
-0.0703349859,
-0.0110977888,
0.0141741568,
0.0041897967,
0.0131923957,
-0.0611925945,
0.0303622,
0.0120012751,
-0.1182181314,
-0.0738648251,
-0.0096223373,
0.0137392329,
0.0503426306,
0.0258847158,
-0.0580034032,
0.0068393275,
-0.0118341316,
0.0481734052,
0.0217695851,
-0.0270180851,
0.045178622,
0.0120544797,
-0.0059544491,
-0.0166305974,
0.0235959869,
-0.0299346931,
-0.0028994901,
-0.0007523109,
-0.0288227871,
-0.0275908541,
0.0018543439,
-0.0146130361,
0.0170209985,
-0.0247365292,
0.0092046224,
-0.0013416173,
0.0395982116,
-0.0146292374,
-0.0100863772,
-0.0346011892,
0.0062778252,
-0.0098752091,
0.0315313786,
0.0029331429,
-0.0233264416,
0.0022129477,
-0.0271317791,
-0.0539668612,
-0.0279894266,
-0.016120851,
-0.0198172331,
-0.0013548598,
-0.0398694538,
-0.0143557247,
-0.0369470082,
-0.0014591122,
0.0253632814,
-0.021668477,
0.0039940956,
-0.0560350865,
0.0450948626,
-0.0082961386,
0.0147358077,
0.0763890669,
0.046737425,
-0.0127363075,
0.0938688591,
0.0156813674,
0.0929887369,
0.0626625195,
0.0289193634,
-0.0418787152,
0.0052470583,
0.0625833273,
-0.0082287956,
0.0390736125,
-0.0170320906,
-0.0162606873,
-0.0463381521,
-0.0379438363,
-0.0403985195,
-0.0227111559,
-0.0333851278,
0.0342648476,
-0.0410436317,
-0.0639232397,
0.0092742648,
0.0334068909,
0.0179373696,
-0.0257605221,
-0.0342495851,
-0.0402661301,
-0.0347957425,
-0.0518777892,
-0.0064200331,
-0.0055254856,
0.0347531438,
-0.0332006961,
-0.0324262865,
-0.0129331527,
-0.0051133945,
-0.001147561,
-0.0251720622,
0.0266810562,
-0.0031600739,
-0.0354556553,
0.0648620203,
0.045097556,
0.0461921208,
-0.028349882,
-0.0542017631,
-0.0005946812,
0.0299922377,
0.0184022691,
0.021658618,
-0.0261047725,
-0.0114082349,
0.0522952415,
-0.0136908628,
0.0467603356,
-0.0135823935,
-0.000957339,
0.0049949042,
0.0012825666,
-0.0103419889,
0.0423666015,
-0.0156113105,
0.0873504281,
0.063337028,
-0.0246589426,
-0.0407195687,
-0.0428431816,
0.0276965424,
-0.0224106628,
0.0054796403,
-0.0065773646,
-0.0009083151,
0.0354383476,
-0.02606773,
0.0067803436,
-0.0518550761,
0.0500672646,
0.0355666056,
-0.0255787298,
0.0162026994,
0.0044862903,
-0.0415705703,
0.0172766075,
0.0309505258,
-0.0442919321,
-0.0091787465,
-0.0250736065,
0.0223839805,
0.0470428728,
0.0164238662,
-0.0026903104,
-0.0390654355,
-0.0285418276,
-0.0477800295,
0.0095305433,
0.0290843379,
0.0645925254,
-0.0458174683,
-0.0351183377,
-0.0237187129,
-0.0126957642,
0.0433534831,
0.0223077368,
0.0062593063,
-0.0019461595,
-0.0200774819,
0.0042372411,
-0.0016091273,
-0.0300674755,
0.0099127144,
-0.0165963452,
-0.0684469789,
0.0064487965,
-0.0327275768,
-0.0075114802,
0.0337447971,
0.0128372852,
0.0051793531,
0.0039424486,
0.0054476508,
0.0164753161,
0.0070913029,
0.0322453007,
-0.0374930091,
-0.0066399351,
-0.0079766959,
-0.0187881868,
0.0241253488,
-0.0128026512,
0.0620237887,
0.0227218829,
-0.0392248444,
-0.0257460568,
-0.0327555239,
-0.0575713515,
0.0088608982,
-0.0348148458,
0.0271050148,
-0.0019780232,
0.0214997865,
0.0027198156,
0.0218696073,
0.032931447,
0.0884432718,
0.0130323749,
0.0231488738,
0.0108073186,
-0.0008818393,
-0.0161481313,
0.064995043,
-0.0653775707,
-0.0491600297,
0.0064312895,
0.069733128,
0.0062069977,
0.023269074,
-0.0316990167,
0.0437057279,
-0.0010886462,
-0.0413187295,
0.0229422729,
-0.0339556858,
0.00091663,
0.0211533718,
-0.0675129443,
-0.0724060312,
0.0650773942,
0.0034461792,
0.0549069718,
-0.0239511207,
-0.0433198884,
-0.0222201347,
0.0358883701,
-0.033674784,
-0.0069565913,
0.0367390178,
0.0240045488,
0.0094573898,
-0.0156109799,
0.0397126265,
-0.0121344551,
-0.0345947295,
-0.0237467121,
0.0539647862,
0.0434216037,
0.0052028382,
-0.0477979593,
-0.1296492368,
-0.00588192,
-0.0308197942,
-0.0223695002,
-0.0065574204,
-0.07933411,
0.0283976085,
-0.0434684902,
0.0170497373,
-0.0136116957,
-0.009709646,
0.0767205581,
0.0297971908,
-0.0034537376,
-0.0719167516,
0.0068588145,
-0.0184826832,
0.0280378703,
0.0630806684,
0.0113738738,
-0.030326575,
-0.021429114,
-0.0325147919,
-0.0206666384,
-0.0134705612,
0.0067069931,
-0.0175026469,
0.0193133354,
-0.051284533,
-0.0369165018,
0.0953224078,
0.026694579,
0.0015331585,
0.001201537,
0.0388764255,
0.0492190421,
0.0227066167,
-0.0287209414,
-0.0418663956,
0.0121084396,
-0.0249870867,
-0.0093689179,
0.0194571801,
-0.0144719454,
-0.0332532935,
-0.0377239361,
0.0465232581,
-0.0382148884,
-0.0386222191,
0.0039087301,
-0.0653723627,
0.0100074634,
0.0210107248,
-0.0148060415,
-0.0131475227,
0.0191938672,
-0.0166422129,
0.0000977412,
-0.0786585957,
-0.0264514834,
0.0342335775,
0.0105321007,
-0.0058952258,
-0.0097928327,
0.0245749541,
0.0033326012,
-0.015728198,
0.0161341056,
0.0385062434,
-0.0206968542,
-0.0331322774,
0.0961433873,
-0.0518636741,
0.0192087125,
0.0159549657,
-0.0031521968,
0.0151293352,
0.0063120886,
0.0110266646,
0.0386267826,
0.0124115851,
-0.0847879574,
-0.0173565242,
0.0366688855,
0.0356188491,
0.05327674,
0.0248288065,
0.0007908484,
0.0072293342,
-0.0089217285,
-0.016520761,
0.01014206,
-0.013479053,
0.0340358652,
-0.0311083607,
-0.0991737172,
-0.0278976541,
-0.0393622704,
-0.0163029097,
0.0439627916,
-0.0493017323,
0.0311779194,
0.003870822,
-0.0093448544,
-0.0685416833,
-0.0152581157,
0.0233465061,
0.0030178234,
0.0187168382,
0.0042513213,
0.0161628574,
0.0166125447,
-0.0056493809,
0.050728064,
-0.1275524497,
-0.0750247017,
0.0103351437,
-0.0039504622,
0.0233348086,
0.0936269239,
-0.0231869724,
-0.0231719371,
0.0619231053,
0.0023685661,
0.0220545214,
0.0257112924,
0.0061890627,
-0.0530778728,
0.0449196324,
0.0024492939,
0.0031092861,
0.0686261952,
0.0149511248,
-0.055433318,
-0.086506784,
0.0221117008,
-0.0262984838,
-0.0059060361,
0.0334851965,
-0.0362816453,
-0.0225818045,
0.0048525101,
-0.0078262277,
-0.0144462055,
-0.0016934235,
0.0170062669,
-0.0032360039,
0.0457351431,
0.0146587994,
-0.0297933333,
0.016940508,
0.0089610191,
0.0069510159,
-0.0382267423,
-0.058586996,
0.0174611583,
0.0364374928,
0.0180139262,
0.0193966795,
-0.0066964109,
-0.0403627828,
0.0015239129,
-0.0051645329,
0.0213199239,
-0.0448119491,
0.0122141866,
-0.0203045402,
0.011972215,
-0.065259248,
-0.0709507391,
-0.0443960056,
-0.0249538627,
0.0061822161,
0.0103771379,
0.0220283475,
0.0293868557,
-0.0062305373,
-0.0191057865,
0.0355493985,
-0.0271141417,
-0.0269155558,
-0.0184643194,
0.0185259283,
0.0034741913,
-0.0506613217,
0.0846650824,
0.0424895771,
0.0625215173,
0.0284814741,
0.0328641571,
-0.0765649974,
-0.0438030511,
0.0199024379,
-0.0121403998,
0.0526595078,
0.0186103527,
-0.0250579827,
-0.0447315313,
-0.0212374106,
0.0850447565,
-0.0137818344,
0.0611896515,
0.0359247737,
-0.0238316692,
0.1103323698,
0.0578599274,
0.0181695558,
0.0074165892,
-0.0170649979,
0.0321777314,
-0.0503021367,
-0.0028265971,
-6.141869821e-33,
0.0405107103,
-0.0097290436,
-0.0089532621,
0.0124100456,
-0.0248804763,
0.0611041151,
0.0045637405,
-0.0272286497,
-0.0106734838,
0.0507249273,
0.0225875638,
0.0588901937,
0.0027436814,
-0.023922408,
-0.0247224942,
-0.0237598307,
0.0504685976,
-0.024473289,
0.0001625713,
0.0348402709,
0.0445135161,
0.0426573157,
0.0368128978,
-0.035135597,
0.0436647758,
-0.0238520093,
-0.0100715691,
0.0214931164,
0.0146702155,
0.0217092726,
-0.0025006828,
0.0394519493,
0.0415677316,
-0.0199232176,
-0.0075127501,
-0.013441857,
-0.0317029841,
-0.0355624594,
-0.0060578897,
-0.0263835434,
0.0332359523,
0.0669136643,
0.0036604707,
0.0487769544,
0.003780649,
-0.0367478058,
0.0271088872,
-0.0139277112,
-0.0102055995,
-0.0063883034,
-0.0080195256,
0.014411943,
0.0117532434,
-0.0216213744,
-0.010416029,
0.0295807347,
0.0396218672,
0.0203136783,
-0.0881564319,
0.0310834013,
-0.0399519838,
-0.0045887516,
-0.0368883573,
-0.0417248309,
-0.0430365242,
0.0339407101,
0.026666211,
0.0914891586,
0.007399905,
0.0315717459,
0.0281645115,
0.0659687445,
-0.0061762505,
0.0445372947,
0.095498845,
-0.0527027994,
-0.1238740012,
0.0333226509,
0.0791028515,
-0.0632913932,
0.0227780528,
0.0180513859,
-0.0682995021,
-0.0150324097,
0.0379806384,
0.0033415307,
-0.0018911603,
-0.011845394,
-0.0135706328,
0.0670830756,
0.0122014368,
0.0991683453,
0.0231171343,
-0.0301011931,
-0.0035623489,
0.010542443,
-0.0178153105,
0.0127580659,
-0.0018635417,
0.0587732308,
-0.0700611025,
0.0153995622,
0.0245296564,
0.0664981753,
-0.0192815308,
-0.0521498397,
0.0585202277,
-0.0244291164,
-0.0427633598,
0.0222678091,
-0.0297684278,
0.0439380556,
-0.0039338586,
0.0306668822,
0.0213196278,
-0.0001803239,
0.0022354557,
0.0089937355,
0.0094396016,
0.0403402597,
0.0044234432,
0.0148396874,
-0.0403124094,
0.02212625,
0.0458143614,
-0.0186504982,
-0.0153987538,
-0.0230421238,
-0.0459152907,
-0.0847779587,
-0.0068334895,
-0.0222735647,
2.54e-7,
-0.0263223872,
0.0278988574,
-0.0184330568,
-0.0107552717,
0.0419304073,
0.0122963395,
-0.0019747212,
-0.0065556397,
-0.0033789331,
-0.0566730462,
-0.0237517226,
0.0547075905,
-0.0115466388,
0.044310201,
-0.0472057536,
-0.0371800885,
-0.0555016585,
0.0040789996,
-0.0641920045,
-0.0271972828,
0.0114959069,
0.0152132772,
0.0454363786,
-0.0219417233,
-0.0104074022,
0.0092326133,
0.0551557764,
0.0102262991,
-0.0762975812,
0.0412561521,
0.0601844825,
0.0077822572,
-0.0375853777,
0.0167121869,
-0.0382390432,
-0.0000334633,
-0.0516089946,
-0.0535518155,
-0.0139088668,
0.0129482932,
0.0056143678,
-0.0094083473,
-0.0063275117,
-0.0053425259,
0.0301292427,
-0.0060003172,
-0.0462837219,
-0.0532354005,
-0.0503389314,
0.052069407,
0.0381289087,
0.0103372559,
0.0233599637,
0.0199817196,
-0.0382257588,
-0.0314180106,
-0.0150378551,
-0.0333161391,
-0.0016441918,
0.0290110372,
-0.0535382181,
-0.0334641598,
0.0372891352,
-0.0388745368,
0.0216110386,
-0.0145689091,
0.0314164869,
1.926028897e-34,
0.0418578386,
0.0182487331,
-0.0194720309,
0.0302063748,
0.0085332785,
0.0137436893,
0.0006097312,
-0.056930948,
0.0071757161,
0.025510544,
0.0262112375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03145v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03145v1 | Techniques to Improve Neural Math Word Problem Solvers | 2023-02-06T22:41:51 | 2023-02-06T22:41:51 | Youyuan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SC | Developing automatic Math Word Problem (MWP) solvers is a challenging task
that demands the ability of understanding and mathematical reasoning over the
natural language. Recent neural-based approaches mainly encode the problem text
using a language model and decode a mathematical expression over quantities and
operators iteratively. Note the problem text of a MWP consists of a context
part and a question part, a recent work finds these neural solvers may only
perform shallow pattern matching between the context text and the golden
expression, where question text is not well used. Meanwhile, existing decoding
processes fail to enforce the mathematical laws into the design, where the
representations for mathematical equivalent expressions are different. To
address these two issues, we propose a new encoder-decoder architecture that
fully leverages the question text and preserves step-wise commutative law.
Besides generating quantity embeddings, our encoder further encodes the
question text and uses it to guide the decoding process. At each step, our
decoder uses Deep Sets to compute expression representations so that these
embeddings are invariant under any permutation of quantities. Experiments on
four established benchmarks demonstrate that our framework outperforms
state-of-the-art neural MWP solvers, showing the effectiveness of our
techniques. We also conduct a detailed analysis of the results to show the
limitations of our approach and further discuss the potential future work. Code
is available at https://github.com/sophistz/Question-Aware-Deductive-MWP. | [
-0.0248927977,
0.1159087941,
-0.0011480374,
0.0657545999,
-0.0365517922,
0.0168898944,
0.0224260036,
-0.0095903417,
-0.0759831741,
0.01436109,
0.0256568249,
0.0042572287,
0.0017989912,
0.0495318249,
0.0202428456,
-0.0020252694,
0.0094138449,
-0.0245026499,
-0.0041958401,
-0.0104192682,
-0.0065492978,
-0.0145907896,
-0.0591548532,
0.0051267617,
-0.0602462627,
-0.0577372015,
0.0021553596,
-0.0562395602,
0.0099046938,
-0.024337288,
0.0010707402,
0.0160643812,
0.0335666128,
0.0513558984,
0.0000020758,
-0.0221133083,
-0.0263613053,
0.0147060491,
-0.0564031303,
-0.0248760134,
0.0039839977,
-0.0363508835,
0.0180257913,
0.0158912055,
-0.058067888,
-0.0007465217,
0.0235528685,
0.0252741482,
0.0710020587,
0.0458076,
-0.0251609515,
-0.0552170277,
0.0441141129,
-0.0111550232,
0.0373018645,
-0.0818172991,
0.0041274326,
0.0298645962,
-0.0115629127,
-0.0141488612,
-0.0461846776,
0.0450220034,
0.0998297632,
-0.0101798242,
-0.0165430773,
-0.0146543505,
-0.0058002817,
0.005621369,
-0.0381849296,
0.0954731926,
-0.0358125903,
0.0025675138,
-0.0142830433,
-0.019093357,
0.0007990602,
-0.000428514,
-0.0242892727,
0.0252453107,
-0.0045570661,
0.0019170651,
-0.0501894467,
0.0347563028,
0.022051366,
0.015112713,
-0.0441467464,
0.0647396147,
0.0202008989,
-0.0272453781,
-0.026936125,
-0.0118508823,
-0.0701580793,
-0.0086772516,
0.1209453717,
0.0471941009,
0.0222933404,
0.030072391,
-0.0382183716,
-0.068764247,
-0.0429258421,
-0.0628281832,
-0.0097263707,
0.0929301456,
0.032655336,
0.0318778716,
-0.0375288166,
0.0732206702,
-0.0356036499,
-0.0068230205,
-0.0325343274,
0.0193373282,
-0.027055677,
-0.0372148268,
-0.0373327136,
0.0346655026,
-0.0090997471,
-0.0230329614,
-0.004487637,
0.0213197861,
-0.0151218306,
0.0096742827,
0.0132305976,
0.0184969064,
0.013096503,
-0.0355272405,
-0.0357708484,
0.0219523348,
-0.0685346946,
0.0232701022,
0.0008847491,
-0.0221121889,
-0.0263549779,
-0.0191176143,
0.0124423364,
-0.0360909328,
0.0291564222,
0.071420677,
-0.0017055967,
0.0004686817,
0.0205199011,
-0.0355117582,
0.0231968816,
-0.039061673,
0.0172473621,
-0.0553797446,
0.0994669795,
-0.0014471463,
-0.0497074947,
-0.050539203,
0.0051660747,
0.0373642594,
0.0328002609,
0.087156035,
0.0288790464,
-0.0271343347,
0.0435602665,
-0.0174444392,
-0.0048922468,
0.0461169109,
0.0690524876,
-0.0073729847,
-0.0149645433,
-0.0069836024,
0.0016634897,
0.0247139279,
0.0223667808,
-0.0247706901,
-0.051441364,
-0.0046754968,
0.019434901,
0.0686742067,
0.0256325193,
0.0268708356,
-0.070958592,
-0.0374516994,
0.015067297,
0.0560936257,
-0.0039019445,
0.0346386693,
0.0177675448,
-0.0151480464,
0.0042435862,
-0.0045600911,
-0.053407561,
0.0162053164,
-0.0233998969,
-0.0252832863,
-0.0098427972,
0.0049656369,
-0.0167267006,
-0.0522376522,
0.009913492,
-0.001751482,
0.0216292851,
0.0228517111,
0.0286071189,
-0.0116143841,
-0.0190091915,
0.0520337857,
0.0059537743,
-0.0297541413,
0.0056483168,
-0.0042551262,
0.0065273545,
-0.0045163264,
0.0785299838,
-0.0235683806,
-0.0209297892,
-0.0026167184,
-0.0314550437,
0.0165141039,
0.0242202021,
0.0041014524,
0.0127040483,
-0.0698493794,
-0.0280870125,
-0.037055105,
-0.009601797,
0.0074694767,
0.003999725,
0.015820194,
0.0359531082,
-0.0194472373,
0.0291426592,
0.050609611,
-0.0083382018,
-0.0600060932,
0.0321215205,
0.0124247344,
0.0097232554,
-0.0031065776,
0.0412911139,
0.0538710803,
-0.0194104537,
-0.0485086925,
-0.0428358242,
-0.0198705066,
-0.0997985899,
-0.0813693255,
0.0733667985,
-0.0637042075,
-0.0135060567,
0.0021699267,
-0.0631683096,
-0.0132069709,
0.0474609211,
-0.055702284,
0.006943678,
0.0016824668,
-0.0012583464,
0.0205373093,
0.0115273092,
-0.0109438896,
0.0709007233,
0.0010385317,
-0.0067062201,
-0.0409396552,
0.00751389,
-0.0030923225,
0.0096553769,
0.0216860045,
-0.0236596577,
-0.0269372538,
0.0036918889,
-0.0128284385,
0.014148213,
0.0052782088,
-0.0158468224,
0.0195335057,
0.0043771574,
0.0218668357,
0.0537737422,
0.0285192113,
0.0037663886,
0.0268314611,
-0.0097295698,
-0.0548487715,
0.0177207254,
-0.0220593922,
-0.0274048019,
0.046221517,
-0.0150377546,
0.0025678426,
-0.0156949125,
-0.0466782488,
-0.0559816137,
0.0505741611,
0.0185829699,
0.0137593606,
-0.0213882104,
0.0271647666,
-0.0409194119,
0.0219703428,
0.0045685312,
0.0100589441,
0.0149563812,
-0.0179410093,
0.0293673798,
0.0609844886,
-0.0204267111,
0.0552519858,
0.0246411655,
-0.0112113599,
-0.0892637447,
0.0163035188,
-0.0325424857,
0.0140631348,
0.0055484874,
0.003299834,
-0.0201812051,
0.0837308764,
0.0009583577,
0.0068669664,
-0.0387709662,
0.0585465655,
0.0137878098,
0.0062936055,
-0.0727908239,
0.0080855573,
0.0016984522,
0.0291805379,
-0.0199222453,
0.0007763482,
0.0803530216,
0.0140567785,
-0.0134644434,
-0.077233322,
0.0259781592,
-0.0763923526,
0.0236715376,
-0.0178656094,
-0.016866684,
-0.041738607,
-0.0450152345,
-0.0263806544,
0.0273052119,
0.0312330183,
-0.0246732999,
0.0269687772,
-0.0245102495,
0.0240968764,
-0.0189488903,
-0.043578051,
-0.0426083393,
-0.0081610624,
0.0007803708,
0.025868101,
-0.0131227644,
0.001854111,
-0.0373640098,
0.0242400821,
0.0150868483,
0.0396134295,
-0.0312297922,
-0.0082829976,
-0.0592906699,
0.0249548145,
0.032307893,
0.041841425,
0.0495217144,
-0.0274735484,
0.004907954,
0.0036239161,
0.0276316963,
-0.0000943958,
-0.0128800478,
0.0552568808,
0.0057714349,
-0.0212326124,
0.0378245935,
0.0358549096,
-0.0038308888,
-0.0875669867,
-0.0142340921,
0.0675721392,
0.054560177,
-0.0380188003,
-0.005839312,
-0.0643146932,
-0.0082756709,
0.0077558071,
0.0331967957,
-0.096229583,
-0.039933037,
0.0359849595,
-0.0180123597,
0.0514314435,
-0.047506988,
-0.006458492,
-0.0968490466,
-0.0224491805,
0.0238665845,
-0.0063681272,
-0.0236307792,
-0.0139051974,
-0.0229563992,
-0.0008035965,
0.0199396778,
-0.0003331987,
0.0270290226,
0.0141051374,
-0.0089085596,
0.0091585061,
-0.0277254041,
0.0056628617,
-0.038868051,
-0.0515873097,
0.0665742457,
-0.0131679866,
-0.014513188,
-0.0789759308,
0.0094308108,
0.0477719903,
-0.0500981137,
0.0136512145,
0.0035167127,
-0.0157026257,
-0.0088894907,
-0.0145495525,
0.0580081083,
-0.0937710553,
-0.01135932,
0.0372616649,
0.0863910243,
-0.0075773206,
0.0021076738,
-0.0294644851,
-0.026056638,
-0.0136650689,
0.0512931123,
0.0482110195,
-0.0088786567,
-0.052025456,
-0.0389830731,
-0.014595787,
-0.045415733,
-0.0086022066,
-0.0060977591,
0.1024930179,
0.0112162475,
-0.0382637642,
-0.0313906334,
0.0539655089,
0.0309550576,
0.008469345,
-0.0740682185,
0.0688187554,
-0.0344302617,
-0.0493136905,
0.0234110616,
-0.0230306014,
0.0292204618,
-0.0315473601,
0.0805115625,
-0.0092321616,
0.0090276478,
-0.0246877167,
0.0282666888,
-0.0921762735,
-0.0343154334,
-0.0173505973,
0.0208338909,
0.0057800533,
-0.0350745432,
-0.0356466286,
-0.01399408,
0.0073323995,
0.0149028609,
-0.0649901778,
-0.0108277379,
0.0124412803,
0.0066953297,
0.0204490628,
0.0020653547,
-0.0079816049,
0.0146581503,
-0.0065620369,
0.0819495022,
-0.0271701012,
0.0005770923,
0.04007167,
0.0124171255,
-0.0269687567,
0.0447626896,
0.037337251,
0.0012793374,
0.0257957708,
-0.0360582434,
0.0196527895,
-0.0728317872,
0.0256586988,
0.0129075823,
-0.0150258746,
0.0182327088,
-0.0233984031,
0.0518512689,
0.0184883736,
0.034314312,
0.0443767719,
0.0059105777,
0.0201262757,
0.0214237068,
-0.0272848345,
0.0294566564,
0.0032567251,
-0.0115939332,
0.0290125255,
-0.0166667141,
0.0376341045,
0.0243417975,
0.0162945297,
-0.0770040751,
-0.008254881,
-0.0122847902,
-0.0808234662,
0.0065573053,
-0.0080924695,
0.0028244692,
0.0402166247,
-0.0627008006,
-0.0082469499,
-0.0019942143,
0.0206169952,
0.0074960086,
0.0045600459,
0.0006005635,
0.0541449524,
0.0511075333,
0.0219426583,
-0.0796756968,
0.0366329886,
-0.0466941297,
0.027763579,
-0.0014042363,
0.0373521596,
-0.0283823479,
-0.0306404941,
-0.0014950008,
0.0243204087,
-0.0235942565,
0.0163274836,
-0.0287652109,
-0.0552606955,
-0.0410984084,
-0.0189917888,
-0.0090404944,
0.0305988993,
0.0387583226,
0.0458812825,
-0.0382104479,
-0.022407813,
0.0494955033,
0.0591849945,
-0.0442862734,
-0.0577082857,
-0.0446852706,
-5.725234215e-33,
-0.0220948029,
-0.0152520388,
0.0483499691,
-0.010732607,
0.0030689556,
-0.0063095419,
-0.0396611243,
0.0020916162,
-0.0174017176,
-0.0091914758,
-0.0239295103,
0.0228643026,
0.0093819872,
0.0294488315,
0.0018074785,
-0.0220409818,
0.0101095987,
-0.0360028856,
-0.0241556987,
-0.0660340488,
-0.0109509286,
0.0355343036,
0.0536960252,
-0.0310749039,
-0.0025187004,
0.0103269378,
0.0131205376,
0.0564204864,
0.0023728865,
0.0392608903,
-0.0455612428,
0.0084650498,
0.0122415954,
-0.0236743931,
-0.0390869305,
0.0318602212,
-0.0495354645,
-0.0558594838,
-0.0260607973,
0.0203054156,
-0.0676086247,
-0.0363861099,
0.059905082,
0.0098186461,
-0.006774527,
-0.0270898845,
0.0154731041,
0.0068602455,
-0.0044382671,
-0.0021743432,
-0.0123810647,
0.0297111012,
-0.0226562582,
-0.0174308196,
0.0529634394,
0.012532983,
-0.0291380733,
-0.0144780781,
-0.0516378321,
-0.0042518089,
0.0023660867,
0.0085931309,
0.0105298935,
-0.0092212316,
0.0099143814,
0.0133655062,
0.0119955866,
-0.0410156287,
-0.0260886885,
-0.0005261833,
0.0537352636,
0.0174663123,
0.0900817513,
-0.0046056607,
0.1098765954,
0.0229643267,
-0.0307999849,
-0.0178281236,
-0.0093152309,
0.0383790545,
-0.0114042759,
0.0189842917,
-0.0272287056,
-0.016066039,
-0.041240681,
0.0216129422,
-0.0789974853,
-0.0234939698,
0.0208627786,
-0.0220271032,
0.000583951,
-0.0029200423,
0.0374615155,
-0.0431094095,
0.0138133122,
0.0398917384,
0.0460559092,
0.0226193033,
0.0266623888,
0.0470773093,
-0.0330725946,
-0.0042855577,
-0.0311698131,
0.0154684996,
0.0497700945,
0.0113431094,
-0.0179049727,
0.0117992805,
-0.0028161628,
-0.0181284361,
-0.0492415614,
-0.0235546213,
0.0456485078,
0.0486071818,
0.016790593,
0.0440944359,
-0.0105214911,
0.00863171,
-0.0189947747,
-0.0185355991,
-0.0007794324,
0.0423168689,
0.0143624544,
0.0646766499,
-0.0054213349,
-0.050301861,
-0.0441484414,
0.0192327052,
0.0596639775,
-0.0732066706,
0.0066089281,
0.0171878561,
2.836e-7,
0.0452424288,
0.0385664664,
0.0481827483,
0.0188123193,
0.017306013,
0.0200616717,
0.012059845,
0.0010761805,
-0.0227786247,
-0.0414413475,
0.0241997056,
0.0591393486,
0.0243580118,
0.0104511138,
-0.0126515189,
0.0046216506,
-0.0509053916,
-0.003896378,
-0.0332395509,
0.0194725841,
0.0519518889,
0.0634102598,
0.0175476111,
0.0046485863,
-0.0025952009,
-0.0246855468,
0.0206564292,
0.0361684859,
0.0218202733,
0.0012435059,
-0.0418587439,
-0.024736831,
0.0060731247,
0.0170682948,
-0.0006000241,
0.0748084411,
0.0306505281,
0.0614235736,
0.0125634102,
-0.0119426101,
-0.0256350022,
-0.01819662,
-0.0231956765,
-0.030851366,
0.0540515557,
-0.0825439766,
-0.0518689416,
-0.0180258006,
0.0063023306,
-0.0414150432,
0.0395032912,
0.0081430255,
0.034220539,
-0.0092058461,
0.0553617887,
-0.017366169,
-0.0132657858,
-0.0658186227,
-0.0114892358,
0.0035578387,
-0.0544898659,
0.0354559608,
-0.0518324114,
-0.0164253563,
0.0661806166,
0.0146607263,
-0.0098373201,
2.561365227e-34,
0.0248267017,
0.0068462417,
0.0518277884,
0.0410912111,
0.0484858416,
-0.0030164428,
-0.0392541401,
0.049519442,
0.0284357313,
-0.0818684772,
-0.0271889903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03126v1 | Context-Gloss Augmentation for Improving Arabic Target Sense Verification | 2023-02-06T21:24:02 | 2023-02-06T21:24:02 | Sanad Malaysha, Mustafa Jarrar, Mohammed Khalilia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Arabic language lacks semantic datasets and sense inventories. The most
common semantically-labeled dataset for Arabic is the ArabGlossBERT, a
relatively small dataset that consists of 167K context-gloss pairs (about 60K
positive and 107K negative pairs), collected from Arabic dictionaries. This
paper presents an enrichment to the ArabGlossBERT dataset, by augmenting it
using (Arabic-English-Arabic) machine back-translation. Augmentation increased
the dataset size to 352K pairs (149K positive and 203K negative pairs). We
measure the impact of augmentation using different data configurations to
fine-tune BERT on target sense verification (TSV) task. Overall, the accuracy
ranges between 78% to 84% for different data configurations. Although our
approach performed at par with the baseline, we did observe some improvements
for some POS tags in some experiments. Furthermore, our fine-tuned models are
trained on a larger dataset covering larger vocabulary and contexts. We provide
an in-depth analysis of the accuracy for each part-of-speech (POS). | [
0.0200833473,
-0.0052627604,
0.0040776245,
0.0502405502,
-0.0246039517,
0.0276184306,
-0.0126446765,
-0.0064438256,
-0.0459861457,
-0.0279062018,
-0.034150023,
-0.0670606121,
0.040552713,
0.0099938633,
0.0409373716,
0.0066094599,
0.0290748253,
-0.0286909845,
-0.0481993929,
-0.0033654196,
0.0326062478,
0.0593374558,
-0.0333509445,
0.0242909621,
-0.024802601,
0.0192737002,
0.0106362533,
0.0273460895,
0.0705579221,
-0.0054468727,
-0.02188031,
0.0214511305,
-0.0047716564,
0.0202186275,
0.0000019793,
-0.0626826659,
-0.0299922917,
-0.0357859731,
-0.0359421819,
-0.0179274213,
0.0587731749,
-0.0592611209,
-0.0349483043,
-0.0168427341,
-0.0117626404,
0.0140118049,
0.0408367068,
-0.0163149741,
0.0332584456,
0.0358822607,
-0.0027073214,
-0.0495854355,
0.0471003801,
-0.0101443818,
0.0418250412,
-0.0616859384,
-0.0061978605,
0.0125746708,
0.0344642662,
-0.0117838774,
-0.0265566856,
0.0378337428,
-0.0065524983,
0.0161763094,
-0.0081484616,
-0.0039776075,
-0.0461037941,
-0.0023034827,
0.0291934907,
0.0332749486,
0.0357119292,
-0.0091214003,
-0.04991455,
-0.0131258816,
-0.02605143,
-0.0254688151,
0.0227426402,
0.0043840329,
-0.0336786024,
0.015091016,
0.0542570539,
0.0016099086,
0.0401135087,
0.0320644379,
-0.0855977684,
0.0506617427,
0.0281792171,
-0.036911469,
0.0098137138,
-0.0048968997,
-0.0250241067,
-0.0012236683,
0.0008816854,
-0.0271763187,
0.0077258772,
0.010500662,
-0.0354106426,
-0.0448332019,
0.0249542706,
-0.0466775149,
0.0091324793,
0.0899460092,
-0.0500633344,
0.0244979281,
-0.0508847311,
0.0220167357,
0.0225741733,
0.035823781,
-0.0758148506,
-0.0452588536,
-0.0585002974,
0.0248296894,
-0.0734011978,
0.0207464881,
-0.0674762875,
0.019339174,
-0.1135176122,
0.0296726152,
-0.0204867199,
0.0035000902,
-0.0347966067,
-0.0365308449,
-0.0622172318,
-0.0075244512,
-0.0203838274,
-0.0222149789,
-0.0118959025,
0.0013970842,
-0.0368838832,
-0.0851983428,
0.0245429464,
-0.0015405566,
0.0211087223,
-0.0097294366,
0.0086819576,
0.0497422628,
0.0015274099,
-0.0856934264,
-0.0745353624,
0.0300911162,
-0.0360345803,
0.0135059087,
-0.0546819754,
-0.0516945869,
0.0069613974,
-0.015818933,
-0.0078014228,
0.0038400195,
-0.0261322055,
0.0083665997,
0.0309340321,
0.0945159271,
-0.0093617579,
-0.0353409126,
0.0356053151,
0.0028630469,
0.0299261045,
0.0841052756,
0.0620331317,
-0.018222766,
0.0217952617,
0.0189161804,
-0.0436453037,
0.0403161533,
0.0144712878,
0.0309016164,
-0.065383099,
-0.0271778889,
-0.0010983596,
0.0821908712,
-0.0232910439,
0.0233748034,
-0.0480779372,
-0.0278862063,
0.0078224316,
-0.005111834,
-0.0107464734,
-0.0301066488,
0.0275220536,
0.0095335459,
-0.0038193278,
-0.0146199698,
0.0211067572,
-0.032102026,
-0.0281229056,
0.0145761706,
0.0053204391,
0.0308700167,
-0.0311716143,
-0.0274766441,
-0.0239944644,
-0.0068085412,
0.0557326972,
-0.0082767513,
0.1039228365,
0.0211162809,
-0.0310973115,
0.0096757868,
0.0093711447,
-0.0071876273,
0.0489780642,
-0.0814922526,
-0.0390729047,
0.0566871241,
0.0551344492,
0.0104471063,
-0.0928523615,
-0.006676557,
-0.009089632,
0.0326056704,
0.0126552815,
0.0020199206,
0.0049788188,
-0.0479603633,
-0.0214693677,
0.0338424705,
-0.0157829579,
-0.0009143726,
0.0064046518,
0.0164289083,
0.0165282637,
-0.0863991305,
-0.0057286336,
0.0350321531,
-0.0139528904,
0.0147215379,
0.0169820152,
0.0172898006,
0.0259897001,
0.0300437231,
-0.0149485199,
-0.0112312371,
0.0060080858,
-0.0412426665,
-0.0173534807,
0.0095449751,
-0.0067775501,
0.0181976594,
0.0492215045,
0.0035533428,
-0.0025607604,
0.0293525308,
-0.0087652812,
-0.0273874197,
0.0358707905,
-0.024964612,
0.0713282898,
-0.0818844289,
0.0358723812,
0.0057292692,
0.0185209028,
-0.0312985182,
0.0233104471,
-0.0231092684,
-0.0174140837,
-0.0264652427,
0.059277188,
0.0278582163,
0.0135465367,
-0.0257468689,
0.0058221691,
0.0103860795,
0.0073661925,
0.0397314355,
-0.0058775158,
-0.0531341918,
-0.0066123772,
-0.0987552926,
0.0020544911,
-0.0100983204,
0.0520301275,
-0.0015454888,
0.0478979871,
-0.02529593,
0.0029384145,
0.0310412385,
0.0031911957,
-0.0042828149,
0.035678193,
0.0182506721,
0.020412609,
-0.0321266353,
-0.0182100721,
0.006447257,
0.0156522654,
0.0244507585,
0.0462144054,
-0.0446653329,
0.0210665539,
-0.0627970248,
-0.0219607186,
0.0166806281,
0.0251062363,
-0.0348573141,
0.0284942593,
-0.0031137166,
-0.0075496035,
-0.0339920223,
0.01317559,
0.0192916486,
-0.0056456239,
-0.0115585942,
-0.0414213575,
-0.0012110656,
0.0038659435,
-0.0754976943,
-0.0325968415,
-0.0241502561,
-0.0243811179,
0.0072311531,
-0.0109563908,
-0.0037759081,
-0.0498857982,
-0.029858293,
-0.0339614749,
-0.0111044999,
-0.0131786577,
-0.0001245455,
-0.010424627,
0.0523986407,
-0.0280334465,
-0.0451278389,
0.0497316681,
-0.041851718,
0.0039896243,
-0.0284926966,
0.0188418776,
-0.0089087207,
0.0328549519,
-0.0418943763,
0.030941261,
-0.0429162495,
-0.0433169939,
-0.0139864003,
-0.0345095806,
0.0227659307,
-0.0118581979,
0.0145439114,
-0.0850738958,
0.0299903974,
-0.0021252141,
0.0056404783,
-0.040421918,
-0.0093828281,
-0.0503705032,
0.0281803962,
0.0162618831,
-0.0219508857,
-0.0263370629,
0.0234120209,
0.0016369477,
0.0619845465,
0.0252093505,
-0.0171861649,
0.0035655573,
-0.0343991555,
-0.0068535223,
-0.0210639797,
-0.0211295467,
-0.0007718928,
-0.0372810438,
0.0040802709,
-0.0240005571,
-0.0328288451,
-0.1056206226,
-0.0208857134,
0.0673137158,
-0.0293209311,
-0.0282974262,
-0.0358858258,
-0.0200563017,
-0.02790506,
-0.0030252561,
0.0878033414,
0.0249350015,
-0.0159248039,
0.0032882846,
0.0117486622,
-0.0202502161,
-0.0074017532,
-0.0295488629,
-0.1279388666,
-0.0476175919,
0.0202844255,
0.0273091402,
0.0298002791,
0.0151920468,
0.0290627684,
-0.1106378213,
-0.0002483818,
-0.0020288441,
-0.079849124,
-0.0700059533,
-0.0184426904,
0.0134953987,
-0.0054437579,
0.0045017875,
-0.024033241,
0.0094669443,
0.0020205928,
0.0719783604,
0.0337439813,
-0.0640628561,
0.036411047,
-0.0428136773,
0.0465413556,
0.1049218774,
0.0296907891,
-0.0033893858,
-0.0597509667,
0.0227408409,
-0.0727881715,
-0.0384088866,
0.0090776421,
-0.0078127151,
-0.0498269647,
-0.003793152,
0.0418304391,
-0.0316520296,
-0.0270704404,
-0.0053910133,
-0.0425393879,
0.0352192409,
-0.0310695358,
0.0867943838,
-0.0147419199,
0.0118163861,
-0.034836527,
0.0505720265,
-0.024056321,
-0.0186227448,
0.0491914786,
0.0291098896,
-0.0253366642,
-0.0664903075,
0.0341970511,
0.0157303046,
-0.0426422395,
-0.0086868675,
-0.0614161715,
-0.0378070138,
0.0431305766,
0.0411058627,
0.0092271166,
0.016586706,
-0.0388448872,
0.0101359747,
-0.0431625508,
0.0262379348,
-0.0116534904,
0.038621027,
-0.0570929311,
-0.0230045617,
0.03001846,
-0.0744921863,
0.0123093249,
0.0505151488,
-0.0269937832,
-0.0157474857,
0.0195974726,
0.0022320184,
0.0182219036,
0.0340189487,
-0.0529475026,
-0.0155446734,
0.0038685161,
-0.0032723565,
-0.0010472554,
0.0385041386,
0.0287234019,
-0.0034350073,
-0.0309142433,
0.0329766758,
-0.0114417886,
0.0143412659,
0.0196732897,
-0.0100532165,
-0.0028343794,
-0.035702318,
0.030499436,
-0.0060890848,
0.0770389363,
-0.0916308835,
-0.0640856102,
-0.0495799519,
0.0287000835,
-0.005020739,
0.0166707523,
0.0104602315,
-0.0054283645,
0.0351831988,
-0.0275187008,
0.0077206567,
-0.0109387022,
-0.052702345,
0.0011451355,
-0.0145653114,
0.0182177648,
-0.0258234628,
0.0380932502,
-0.0047225826,
0.0399097167,
0.000539411,
-0.0571107119,
-0.0474418141,
0.0176708549,
-0.0258526728,
0.0008091539,
0.0152200358,
0.0288006756,
0.0175703317,
0.0626465231,
0.0074359532,
0.0359669141,
-0.026848102,
0.0495507084,
0.0449639149,
-0.0229869671,
0.0329421833,
0.0125200972,
0.007926764,
-0.0201246012,
0.0243451223,
-0.0359200798,
-0.0333251283,
0.0029330852,
0.0009559952,
0.0099018086,
-0.0067118974,
0.0255623516,
-0.0364964083,
0.0508965887,
0.0032751216,
-0.0034300454,
0.0032516487,
-0.0176278688,
-0.0019379704,
0.0322028026,
-0.028856108,
0.0237454213,
-0.0617285483,
-0.0835312605,
0.047034584,
0.038594272,
0.0163484197,
0.050795339,
0.0634730458,
0.0524215773,
0.0103392024,
-0.003283893,
-0.0445653014,
-0.0067863651,
-0.0203409679,
-0.0034574904,
-0.0018539327,
-5.759841136e-33,
-0.0091561936,
-0.0072073368,
0.0260685515,
-0.0238161199,
-0.024693232,
0.0082201622,
-0.0035127597,
-0.0243881475,
0.0136688221,
0.0132059064,
0.0067057903,
0.0295462385,
0.0455511324,
0.0086143911,
0.0182735119,
-0.0066228905,
0.0332878232,
0.0201871768,
-0.001379182,
0.0222255252,
0.0537225865,
0.0403250903,
0.1220990047,
-0.0252209529,
0.0315573364,
0.0033134476,
-0.0206807945,
0.0046043089,
0.0306143817,
0.1084900573,
-0.0094764233,
0.0620277934,
0.0004884089,
-0.0191308316,
0.0179616474,
-0.0307744592,
-0.0567003712,
0.0099945478,
0.035789039,
0.0352671817,
-0.0110068507,
0.0050763329,
-0.0281288158,
-0.0050008493,
-0.0696154609,
0.0857484117,
-0.0045381417,
-0.0817407221,
-0.0137885101,
-0.0013107935,
-0.0890458748,
0.0672848448,
0.0207048487,
-0.0223947242,
0.0650453046,
0.0291540977,
-0.0047325874,
-0.0314167738,
-0.0226091668,
0.0210726056,
0.0014783101,
0.0056757918,
0.0779189914,
0.0499927551,
-0.0580376685,
0.052747272,
0.0031781616,
-0.0370684192,
0.048696585,
0.0128549272,
0.051256191,
-0.0230896939,
0.0222760215,
0.0901434124,
0.0426904783,
-0.0154002924,
-0.0405208766,
0.0584607571,
-0.0245479234,
0.0493805259,
0.0117321378,
-0.0093944436,
-0.0686658695,
0.0044418247,
-0.0206986871,
0.0213879775,
-0.0391957015,
0.0157514028,
0.0089380629,
-0.0026142525,
-0.0287455395,
0.0883661881,
0.0148252966,
0.0238636378,
0.0625155792,
-0.0243119616,
0.0042940374,
-0.0398956835,
-0.0138148023,
0.0693121031,
0.0080426233,
-0.0738743022,
0.0290763266,
0.0123418598,
-0.0044938093,
0.0079707559,
0.0403389819,
0.0266203005,
-0.0306119975,
0.0269824658,
-0.0528710447,
0.0140863992,
-0.0451962724,
0.0176346693,
0.0206695888,
0.0014318185,
0.0002448894,
0.0534662306,
0.0212899242,
-0.0130092446,
-0.0046358178,
-0.0243788194,
-0.0147418212,
0.0011585333,
-0.0081654591,
0.0350171179,
0.0036986771,
-0.0123298364,
0.0077780695,
-0.0452159271,
-0.0162901822,
-0.007897824,
2.86e-7,
0.0503203347,
0.0143530304,
0.0447820947,
0.0167856682,
-0.0479226671,
0.002231508,
-0.0013002201,
0.0201186705,
0.0081687802,
0.0107694417,
0.0098591615,
0.009736523,
0.0216149408,
0.0236380789,
-0.0369823128,
0.015642928,
0.0299911126,
0.0685523525,
-0.0163361989,
0.0248912461,
0.0526114032,
0.0903161243,
-0.0230485108,
-0.0260943267,
-0.0206790697,
-0.0264836811,
0.0554976314,
-0.0235508513,
-0.0230693836,
0.0121586574,
0.0676909164,
0.0300161093,
0.0387491398,
0.055635944,
-0.0456125326,
0.0153982732,
0.0096820947,
0.0202981848,
-0.0298139006,
-0.0231513996,
-0.0010143541,
-0.0074114841,
-0.0239589438,
-0.0041020554,
0.0411135554,
-0.020646628,
-0.0024887866,
0.0165982004,
-0.0362636,
0.0590536669,
0.0224384405,
-0.0591910779,
-0.0484631397,
-0.0074638254,
0.0782714561,
-0.0156672634,
-0.0463599935,
-0.0380347446,
0.0585149005,
0.0313630961,
0.014660405,
-0.019741185,
0.0187699571,
-0.0069228252,
0.0215699747,
-0.0251435097,
-0.0285992939,
2.191170143e-34,
0.0508859828,
0.0194659345,
-0.0260110293,
-0.0242176,
0.0256537516,
0.001958994,
-0.0030207871,
0.0255958214,
0.0117292339,
-0.0122382035,
-0.0045705275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03106v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03106v3 | Efficient and Flexible Topic Modeling using Pretrained Embeddings and Bag of Sentences | 2023-02-06T20:13:11 | 2024-02-10T17:45:03 | Johannes Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models have led to a new state-of-the-art in many NLP
tasks. However, for topic modeling, statistical generative models such as LDA
are still prevalent, which do not easily allow incorporating contextual word
vectors. They might yield topics that do not align well with human judgment. In
this work, we propose a novel topic modeling and inference algorithm. We
suggest a bag of sentences (BoS) approach using sentences as the unit of
analysis. We leverage pre-trained sentence embeddings by combining generative
process models and clustering. We derive a fast inference algorithm based on
expectation maximization, hard assignments, and an annealing process. The
evaluation shows that our method yields state-of-the art results with
relatively little computational demands. Our method is also more flexible
compared to prior works leveraging word embeddings, since it provides the
possibility to customize topic-document distributions using priors. Code and
data is at \url{https://github.com/JohnTailor/BertSenClu}. | [
0.0286121666,
0.0462664366,
-0.0024727576,
0.0248540919,
-0.002971807,
0.0150402738,
0.0077975714,
-0.0455744378,
-0.010423054,
-0.069057487,
-0.002014762,
0.0317578092,
-0.053218849,
0.0495426394,
0.021665141,
-0.0497024395,
0.0299159046,
-0.0097195404,
0.0530293919,
0.0032505805,
0.0468739681,
0.017063858,
-0.0066079008,
0.0363062732,
-0.0351387709,
-0.0159576964,
-0.0094455071,
-0.0291511752,
0.0212470274,
-0.0198193453,
0.0440838598,
0.05892241,
0.0359828882,
-0.0376394764,
0.0000019098,
-0.0139056724,
-0.0134583162,
-0.0517109074,
0.0174263101,
0.0308612902,
0.0809351578,
-0.0154767046,
0.044428125,
0.009530386,
-0.0221828111,
-0.0225880314,
0.0394751728,
0.0922691301,
0.0425760262,
0.0601611473,
-0.0267617349,
-0.0200848933,
0.0092171803,
-0.0450402349,
0.0187714808,
-0.0496448651,
0.0292810109,
0.0188237876,
0.0054112771,
0.0520678498,
-0.0168170799,
0.0066368086,
0.0063199941,
-0.0141545115,
0.0368838124,
0.0356663503,
-0.0018945074,
0.0136148334,
-0.0273468345,
0.0684054494,
-0.0136234658,
-0.042821154,
0.0278496556,
-0.0154494131,
-0.0637662709,
-0.0179105755,
-0.045971252,
0.0344932899,
0.0472551435,
0.034801919,
0.0430387482,
0.0292952489,
0.0289795753,
-0.0089332927,
0.0115101775,
0.0330789797,
0.0373358503,
-0.0166597012,
-0.0199007336,
0.0279452037,
-0.0359517075,
-0.0513590425,
-0.0137446243,
0.0056422073,
-0.0009827538,
0.0070090252,
-0.0250558853,
-0.0158321746,
0.0092031891,
-0.0355432704,
-0.0228287559,
-0.0110875322,
0.0086210435,
0.0427805558,
0.0244414285,
-0.0470285751,
-0.014607707,
-0.0478426032,
-0.0836621821,
-0.0064952085,
-0.0052772202,
0.0192080289,
-0.0219588354,
0.0037855522,
-0.0393001959,
-0.0419611223,
-0.0226335935,
0.0364076346,
0.0023882433,
-0.015580127,
0.0213722084,
0.0091452887,
-0.0497357175,
-0.0110603645,
-0.0057436177,
0.0034697221,
-0.0739681125,
0.0699651688,
-0.020908704,
0.0280837081,
-0.0245037191,
0.0350966528,
0.0210175496,
-0.0025010509,
-0.0163096413,
0.0330150612,
-0.0195096154,
-0.0502276421,
-0.0514503755,
0.0398673937,
-0.0042294208,
-0.0223362502,
0.0275366809,
-0.0708155781,
0.0408147834,
0.0206315443,
-0.0113773523,
0.0129173025,
0.0070910519,
0.0151092121,
-0.0411579125,
0.0394299813,
-0.0026332296,
0.0007617954,
0.0578889623,
0.0269948989,
0.0212686099,
0.0954279006,
-0.0124877477,
0.0545497872,
0.0599420108,
0.0201645065,
0.0205395892,
0.0144691169,
-0.0283523481,
0.020579258,
0.0304836016,
0.0066465158,
-0.0010267106,
-0.0054069622,
0.0408408381,
-0.0061035482,
-0.0434970409,
0.0216960181,
0.0244438704,
0.0575021096,
-0.0404032879,
0.0209560078,
0.0312533937,
0.0405518971,
-0.0084055522,
-0.0285866726,
0.0212174188,
-0.0005960893,
0.0016592413,
-0.0452625714,
0.0463755168,
0.015998112,
-0.0578581877,
-0.0427666567,
0.0055595827,
-0.0296250209,
0.0197101552,
-0.0297515728,
0.0269571021,
0.018045431,
0.0050288425,
0.038882006,
0.0546978936,
-0.0045675337,
-0.0088072838,
0.0172430594,
0.0436072312,
0.0179446563,
0.0624995902,
-0.0503033996,
-0.0177527014,
-0.0100964839,
0.0152749391,
0.0222805403,
0.0158275049,
-0.0342310928,
0.0045103515,
-0.0416816399,
-0.0165310577,
-0.0479013398,
0.0522527173,
0.0088418974,
0.0246141963,
-0.0065197512,
0.0160393715,
-0.0569503643,
0.0243537407,
0.0538740978,
-0.0286036786,
-0.0208486132,
0.0546341464,
-0.0302093122,
0.0287345052,
-0.0219623391,
-0.0067201001,
0.0198126137,
0.0429347157,
-0.0543978922,
-0.0181477852,
0.0082149655,
-0.0136369998,
-0.0561739914,
0.0057349727,
-0.0486700088,
-0.0357659012,
-0.0121654905,
-0.0766231939,
-0.0169233344,
0.0269826483,
-0.0141851902,
0.0161282253,
-0.0533496551,
-0.0168362428,
0.0119108548,
0.0101640038,
-0.0460810997,
0.0715834722,
-0.0155609986,
0.0306669548,
-0.039809864,
-0.0028020572,
0.0380132608,
-0.0324199386,
-0.0249014664,
-0.0003483507,
0.0216760598,
0.0033956154,
0.0523485541,
0.0098577114,
-0.0139441174,
-0.0097021833,
-0.1563284397,
0.0138779953,
-0.0195772145,
-0.0119246533,
0.0529028736,
-0.0103454096,
-0.0229335167,
-0.0153367519,
-0.0414422639,
-0.0138350129,
-0.0120601375,
0.0049893591,
0.0339173749,
-0.0257440042,
0.0199759472,
-0.0548718087,
-0.0179616511,
-0.0250907373,
0.0679917112,
-0.0295029245,
0.0244075991,
-0.0374003276,
0.0131856604,
-0.0164910648,
0.0194308925,
-0.0183796436,
0.0378553607,
0.0026277341,
-0.0296720453,
0.128967613,
0.0274222828,
0.0389497504,
0.0455718003,
0.0238622222,
-0.0074841101,
-0.0024159343,
-0.0139697287,
-0.0320261307,
0.0557449721,
-0.0281312708,
-0.0414407961,
0.0227124263,
0.0619767867,
0.0161370616,
-0.009204031,
-0.0220779143,
-0.0065573636,
-0.0081969816,
-0.0130246729,
-0.0737433657,
-0.0172534026,
0.0372114033,
0.0143297249,
-0.0462849103,
-0.0230058488,
0.0623724088,
-0.0212638937,
-0.0049367012,
-0.0795014054,
-0.0172940213,
-0.0349460132,
0.0496690981,
0.0331114195,
-0.002516177,
-0.0418174379,
0.054627981,
-0.0183988567,
0.0304817483,
0.0165601913,
0.0116540678,
0.0116396863,
-0.0355056524,
0.0070913876,
-0.0025958312,
-0.0248534009,
-0.040251337,
-0.0819024518,
0.0075764768,
-0.0011185291,
0.0133045446,
0.0116543686,
-0.0332536921,
-0.0022968564,
0.0156636238,
-0.0120913507,
0.000341739,
-0.0127294352,
-0.0271216743,
0.058996208,
0.0855167508,
-0.076963149,
-0.0220350083,
-0.0128383338,
-0.0169225894,
0.0480926335,
0.0449817069,
0.0013740275,
-0.0565187111,
0.010356796,
0.0297377426,
-0.0451648384,
0.0008713236,
0.0159509443,
0.0568921305,
0.0152673852,
-0.0310545936,
0.1123227775,
0.028134726,
-0.0547320321,
0.0038814817,
0.0181738678,
-0.0082100928,
0.0042692032,
0.0389964618,
-0.0191579293,
-0.0102318069,
-0.0166862402,
-0.0116852503,
0.030376235,
-0.0207262672,
-0.016597284,
-0.0818015486,
0.0300331637,
-0.0094704833,
0.0386547446,
-0.0150823351,
-0.0576396994,
-0.0039422666,
-0.0115249036,
-0.0460120477,
-0.0398979932,
0.0098982854,
0.0200639851,
0.0140254349,
-0.0086493641,
-0.0279252473,
0.0282219462,
-0.0240860134,
0.0262615159,
0.0180244278,
0.0162479691,
0.0177295692,
0.0113108847,
0.0100252097,
-0.0450689793,
-0.0665142685,
0.0449246503,
-0.0114249848,
-0.0526143275,
0.0108120162,
-0.0034075922,
0.0474097021,
-0.0365091972,
-0.0667338595,
0.0233637728,
0.0864464417,
-0.0258047339,
-0.0234123152,
-0.048840005,
-0.0169291105,
0.0331462659,
0.0710370392,
0.0119301723,
-0.0540245548,
0.0053445231,
-0.0469345674,
0.0322737582,
0.0651660562,
-0.0047796476,
-0.0338224694,
0.0005371051,
-0.0543813594,
-0.0566883869,
-0.0459577367,
0.0356600992,
0.0274995696,
0.0022115151,
0.0081072748,
0.0111558791,
-0.0283812881,
-0.0329635963,
0.0461048,
-0.0264513157,
-0.023285795,
-0.003250638,
-0.0359823816,
0.0427501984,
0.0013826839,
-0.0332953967,
0.0044022263,
-0.0839076638,
-0.0396001935,
-0.0095535209,
0.0211965479,
0.0030919418,
0.0149512533,
-0.0618344545,
-0.0747145712,
0.0234306213,
0.0282736886,
-0.0487948507,
0.0109363403,
-0.0016330805,
0.0419183783,
0.0243279506,
0.0220696088,
-0.0379343107,
0.1069090217,
0.0047658151,
0.0571218319,
-0.0750820711,
-0.0742081851,
-0.0284624174,
-0.0321230888,
0.0858509317,
-0.0199608803,
-0.0369878449,
-0.0790099576,
-0.0320995748,
-0.0339966938,
-0.0281987283,
-0.0145037398,
-0.0095286667,
0.0150181875,
0.0161346141,
-0.0605974048,
0.052734632,
-0.017461339,
0.0445896573,
0.0226340871,
-0.0050426638,
0.0534217097,
0.01583956,
-0.0360967442,
0.0278509576,
-0.0189710855,
-0.0323358029,
-0.0203048736,
0.0055488325,
-0.0361953601,
0.0469532423,
-0.0019041511,
-0.0104625309,
-0.0376927704,
0.0210595205,
-0.0795385465,
0.0500411578,
-0.0293203313,
0.0569392741,
0.0345222987,
-0.0651077032,
0.0143167041,
-0.0381007008,
-0.0103497226,
-0.0402333178,
0.0594863556,
0.0171840936,
-0.0262706727,
0.0068598883,
0.0365899131,
-0.0453889221,
0.0079989824,
0.0801759213,
0.0067323125,
0.0063632713,
0.0031059666,
-0.0273747612,
-0.0430018492,
-0.0259262454,
0.0155209098,
0.0401540212,
-0.0013176921,
0.0421185829,
-0.0196723696,
-0.0369885713,
0.0056136595,
-0.0234989729,
-0.0145525504,
0.0144282738,
0.0694970489,
0.1036011651,
-0.0113314614,
0.0368364379,
-0.0467191339,
0.0421308689,
0.0014066298,
-0.0677048489,
-0.0694015026,
-6.232094155e-33,
0.0155236479,
-0.0185074862,
-0.0131544853,
-0.0095153209,
0.0217652414,
-0.0035192859,
-0.0384657905,
-0.0004720543,
0.0479128435,
0.0202219021,
-0.0222842116,
0.0130546307,
-0.0076118615,
0.0368079431,
-0.0178411081,
0.0219105948,
0.0477442108,
-0.0092465319,
-0.0119944261,
0.0257567074,
0.026342608,
0.0364767611,
0.025157081,
-0.0313473307,
0.004095315,
-0.0560408905,
-0.0042905691,
0.0254089162,
0.0722767115,
0.0119523518,
-0.0683380589,
0.0353541337,
0.0470112525,
-0.0208258908,
-0.0008988498,
0.016254006,
-0.0584591404,
-0.051254496,
-0.0326402634,
-0.0449246168,
-0.0189387966,
-0.0009538651,
-0.0184645504,
0.0046951235,
0.0240396075,
0.0363490321,
0.0655045584,
-0.0034923609,
-0.0008830433,
-0.0418825075,
-0.0556162484,
0.0162552986,
-0.0192647986,
0.0234938506,
0.007118538,
-0.0186151341,
0.0151122399,
0.0267907418,
-0.0011531351,
0.0332666188,
-0.0308837947,
0.0372432284,
-0.0050587934,
-0.0208178256,
0.0072501097,
0.0508400723,
-0.0233895537,
-0.0023829325,
-0.0495713502,
0.0048031616,
0.0272812955,
0.0313682854,
0.0060201865,
0.0237145498,
0.0031267921,
0.0162757933,
-0.0886550695,
0.0918355212,
0.0295964275,
0.0239922833,
0.0158792697,
0.0225437097,
-0.0131042805,
-0.0410826355,
-0.0410443358,
-0.001963407,
0.0088893557,
-0.0057826005,
0.0067943875,
0.0429100096,
-0.0386580303,
0.0051804157,
0.0189625584,
-0.0287844818,
0.0149581898,
0.0322025977,
-0.0226623882,
0.0084170252,
0.037075635,
0.0338273123,
-0.1028104052,
-0.040359389,
0.0399474129,
-0.0149480319,
-0.0233288836,
-0.0294449776,
0.0171952229,
-0.0162101928,
-0.0436280295,
0.0243520662,
-0.0148240421,
-0.0246873591,
-0.0202059597,
0.0412547253,
0.0070878132,
0.0302000903,
-0.0013964556,
0.0198428854,
0.0463094078,
0.0597920232,
0.0102852061,
-0.0496109501,
-0.0069490816,
0.0376881771,
-0.0102650821,
-0.0067462721,
-0.0343810916,
0.0240091067,
0.0144175673,
-0.0821720511,
0.0001153909,
-0.0154986614,
2.617e-7,
0.0674434751,
0.0153142456,
0.0155250803,
0.00720412,
0.051989235,
0.0323978551,
0.0046772105,
0.0500056781,
-0.0065997331,
-0.0105165634,
0.0285429601,
0.0588440634,
0.0063131158,
0.0347162597,
-0.06187094,
0.0008608425,
-0.0458432995,
0.021670768,
-0.0537136905,
-0.036668174,
0.0147423502,
0.1120031253,
0.0500557721,
0.0249895565,
-0.0272772908,
-0.0296045262,
0.0853684619,
-0.0238272119,
-0.0454445444,
0.0495541058,
0.0545732379,
0.0207776763,
0.001061619,
-0.0413289033,
-0.015262844,
0.0244319309,
0.0261583831,
0.0541938506,
0.0002179677,
-0.0420474559,
0.0060977205,
0.004125162,
-0.0077849422,
-0.0001493554,
0.0721606985,
-0.0432540327,
-0.0196354184,
-0.0311612487,
-0.020728847,
0.0360240713,
0.0170064215,
-0.0205973312,
-0.0388344042,
0.0085105747,
0.0047280919,
-0.0059420611,
0.005181626,
-0.075953573,
-0.0096465927,
0.0029487112,
-0.064128764,
-0.0094859153,
-0.0098527176,
-0.0146371312,
0.0612291731,
-0.0449469201,
0.0344225578,
2.637926414e-34,
0.0403479263,
0.0055463528,
-0.0422556065,
-0.040768601,
0.0206688587,
-0.0165466499,
-0.0253735036,
0.0089674983,
0.0079054506,
-0.0783508345,
0.0024942532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03488v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03488v2 | APAM: Adaptive Pre-training and Adaptive Meta Learning in Language Model for Noisy Labels and Long-tailed Learning | 2023-02-06T18:40:04 | 2023-05-02T22:29:38 | Sunyi Chi, Bo Dong, Yiming Xu, Zhenyu Shi, Zheng Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Practical natural language processing (NLP) tasks are commonly long-tailed
with noisy labels. Those problems challenge the generalization and robustness
of complex models such as Deep Neural Networks (DNNs). Some commonly used
resampling techniques, such as oversampling or undersampling, could easily lead
to overfitting. It is growing popular to learn the data weights leveraging a
small amount of metadata. Besides, recent studies have shown the advantages of
self-supervised pre-training, particularly to the under-represented data. In
this work, we propose a general framework to handle the problem of both
long-tail and noisy labels. The model is adapted to the domain of problems in a
contrastive learning manner. The re-weighting module is a feed-forward network
that learns explicit weighting functions and adapts weights according to
metadata. The framework further adapts weights of terms in the loss function
through a combination of the polynomial expansion of cross-entropy loss and
focal loss. Our extensive experiments show that the proposed framework
consistently outperforms baseline methods. Lastly, our sensitive analysis
emphasizes the capability of the proposed framework to handle the long-tailed
problem and mitigate the negative impact of noisy labels. | [
0.0245573446,
0.0123836249,
0.0031988444,
0.0083324043,
0.0057305787,
0.000709628,
-0.0390829891,
-0.0290215332,
-0.0579572469,
-0.0184319913,
-0.0461989008,
0.0082500512,
-0.0139962686,
-0.0004738705,
-0.0032231894,
-0.064718172,
0.0031561449,
0.0028305373,
0.0417393669,
-0.0135677187,
0.0151194381,
-0.0155560663,
-0.0007633803,
-0.0047473446,
-0.0301336888,
0.0023906778,
0.0312548503,
0.0260738451,
0.0241966303,
-0.0429319665,
0.0610147044,
0.0394924991,
-0.0009488647,
0.0375894159,
0.0000021472,
-0.0469175242,
-0.0035518915,
-0.0024719695,
-0.0244358312,
-0.0147136645,
0.0831313878,
0.0246824697,
-0.024369603,
0.0238053035,
-0.0197894145,
-0.0797037408,
0.0620236322,
0.0592645183,
0.0482403748,
0.0556506179,
-0.0047818199,
-0.0670780465,
0.0122616403,
-0.0570504516,
0.0475738086,
-0.0428806655,
0.0181399863,
-0.0269188005,
-0.0307799261,
-0.005379891,
-0.0091005871,
0.0290397983,
0.0034228102,
0.0119866952,
-0.0070663276,
0.0334057622,
-0.0160053354,
0.0282456484,
-0.0123812594,
0.1030713543,
-0.0525226295,
-0.0001185162,
-0.0074420902,
-0.0345929302,
0.0277267136,
-0.0133031495,
-0.0268224999,
0.0115963789,
0.0493301041,
0.0251901951,
-0.0087643415,
0.0398327149,
0.0283459388,
0.0164305177,
-0.0434331,
0.0400461741,
-0.0124675026,
-0.0289318264,
0.0401710011,
-0.0355776474,
-0.0714941099,
0.0258553941,
0.0288365483,
0.0148312505,
0.0253495295,
0.0292336512,
-0.0441461205,
-0.0838784277,
0.0148037178,
-0.0930036977,
0.0183716919,
0.0127054928,
-0.0780075043,
0.0360626988,
-0.0132457446,
-0.0345254205,
0.0219881386,
0.0250658505,
-0.0288030505,
-0.0207179897,
-0.043158371,
0.0015738355,
-0.0607864298,
0.0747935325,
0.0013080947,
0.026295349,
-0.0593848117,
-0.0137771182,
-0.0015034016,
-0.0237754229,
0.0435961597,
-0.000199317,
-0.0422572233,
-0.0379962772,
0.0031510117,
0.0642903075,
-0.0301843509,
0.0171313267,
0.0081597501,
0.0064493036,
0.0128168855,
0.0206513107,
-0.006424224,
-0.0423328727,
0.0594539568,
0.0714339912,
0.0625198781,
-0.0449975692,
-0.078439422,
0.0148689253,
-0.0445469618,
-0.0375603959,
-0.0059368559,
-0.0558541231,
0.0055873459,
-0.04410889,
0.0202034004,
-0.0278286096,
0.0154523589,
0.0177419558,
-0.0233610645,
0.0545475446,
-0.0443348438,
-0.0137476567,
0.0266385376,
0.0013863567,
0.0354857035,
0.0631147176,
0.0495068282,
0.0191412549,
0.012554707,
0.008624889,
0.0136570446,
0.0132821836,
0.0397306867,
-0.0197948981,
-0.0551282614,
-0.0367131419,
-0.0106333727,
0.0094862115,
0.016447356,
0.0506247878,
-0.0163248908,
-0.0439571887,
0.0620644242,
0.0124593414,
0.0032644176,
-0.0152527336,
0.0183051955,
-0.0284531396,
-0.0042088181,
0.0063772318,
-0.0344898477,
0.0072198645,
-0.0568362623,
-0.0031398307,
-0.0040297001,
-0.0019003738,
-0.0660798699,
-0.0701178834,
0.0276891161,
-0.0247613937,
-0.0418961123,
0.0008448823,
0.0731489211,
0.0294191241,
-0.0051916037,
0.0101350145,
0.0608939528,
-0.0041337064,
0.0256091654,
-0.0276575685,
-0.0478060357,
0.0426206551,
-0.0084064016,
-0.09359961,
0.0051337052,
-0.0222993195,
0.0359582305,
0.0387539528,
0.0220055897,
0.0205313507,
0.0229071621,
-0.0605039261,
0.0061301906,
0.0232799202,
0.0233114995,
0.0186918955,
-0.0333285257,
0.0037756499,
0.0297678914,
-0.0705591887,
-0.0876141191,
0.0476381257,
-0.0230441112,
-0.0741062015,
0.0461209156,
0.0053302282,
0.0068584243,
0.0129932649,
-0.0177736934,
0.0211740453,
0.0401311405,
-0.028832322,
-0.0014495183,
-0.0287143011,
-0.0474921539,
-0.0452417284,
0.0675589964,
-0.0647198558,
0.0132473307,
0.0155381234,
-0.0516093336,
-0.0564141832,
0.0268840306,
-0.0080800187,
0.0379524939,
-0.0456224792,
0.03046914,
0.0019909262,
0.0420945063,
-0.0597058646,
0.0430354886,
-0.0139422733,
0.0012741949,
-0.0291113872,
-0.0628127903,
-0.0238459669,
0.0139861451,
-0.0703552142,
-0.0038027021,
-0.0295238383,
0.0325252041,
0.0205529127,
-0.0201125089,
-0.025663659,
-0.0171869565,
-0.0166754108,
-0.0068438277,
-0.0356583819,
0.0166016202,
0.0146160666,
0.0257834811,
-0.008617837,
-0.025142692,
-0.0421011709,
0.0183093362,
-0.0261570066,
0.0112130987,
0.0466078781,
0.0453147255,
0.0189434476,
-0.018136315,
-0.037605416,
0.0062628943,
0.0472715385,
-0.0201731902,
-0.0373513438,
-0.0104294159,
0.0126273241,
-0.0036009592,
0.0514854565,
-0.0015423067,
-0.0202043019,
-0.0483147204,
-0.0325435698,
0.0444525108,
0.0223187022,
0.029947482,
-0.022461161,
0.0455264226,
0.0170207191,
-0.0347825885,
-0.001232186,
-0.0571107976,
-0.00014723,
-0.0180763584,
-0.027299501,
-0.0113095781,
0.0728506893,
-0.0380459018,
0.0129868072,
-0.0093895774,
-0.029259691,
0.0091700414,
-0.0230357125,
-0.0069456366,
0.0448095202,
-0.0054350682,
0.0115654627,
-0.0156769957,
-0.0053493986,
0.0649256632,
-0.0055347919,
-0.0151710035,
-0.0135934418,
-0.0358121879,
-0.01636477,
0.0207404625,
0.0062259189,
0.0043357569,
0.065838635,
-0.0271320455,
-0.0527833439,
-0.0803766996,
0.0350330919,
-0.0283685308,
-0.0294407755,
-0.0085226651,
0.0097718546,
-0.0146829253,
0.0142627973,
-0.0117815621,
-0.0335035212,
0.0030375179,
0.0004706588,
-0.0606606863,
0.02876384,
-0.0401391909,
0.0225740764,
-0.0049664993,
0.0757858381,
-0.0012831718,
0.004318343,
-0.0021986219,
0.0216811541,
0.0303267352,
-0.0364781395,
0.0429776795,
-0.0180083439,
0.0190379657,
0.0218953434,
0.0345362537,
-0.0201144293,
-0.0391848758,
-0.0252665412,
0.0316155478,
-0.0355924405,
0.0011333326,
0.033060912,
-0.0265910551,
-0.0815238357,
0.0166890565,
0.0977582186,
0.0132813165,
-0.053278476,
-0.0077827899,
0.0197663605,
0.035062544,
0.0179012921,
0.0296400152,
-0.0190031137,
-0.038099099,
-0.0005540497,
0.0280658975,
-0.0086238561,
-0.0369100235,
0.0058870907,
-0.102708362,
0.0117007112,
-0.0128882751,
-0.0095158359,
0.0071206582,
-0.0275086835,
0.0107993316,
-0.0511490814,
0.0466030613,
-0.0176840778,
-0.027540436,
-0.0061943303,
0.0515640788,
-0.0247426983,
-0.0508848689,
0.0078838198,
-0.0536912717,
0.0545681529,
0.0542719848,
0.0019468602,
-0.039431233,
-0.0036387243,
0.1014821082,
-0.0302291121,
-0.0296952557,
-0.0169113576,
0.0909252912,
-0.038903527,
-0.0140432296,
0.0242262501,
0.0167645402,
-0.078293547,
0.0109704649,
-0.0110337604,
0.0465782247,
0.0111188535,
0.0039547808,
-0.0211036522,
-0.0011163799,
0.0120152012,
0.0479248539,
0.0135063948,
-0.0686146468,
-0.0252948832,
0.0194952656,
0.0018986302,
-0.0205180682,
-0.0390579253,
0.0395063646,
0.0136889759,
-0.0674708039,
-0.0424746312,
-0.0407841578,
-0.0006720625,
0.0474695489,
-0.0016468101,
0.0101156915,
0.0027154915,
0.0050179176,
-0.068593882,
0.0107799247,
-0.045818083,
-0.0191351101,
-0.0649167374,
0.0119393207,
0.0715919882,
-0.0282791983,
-0.0082846256,
-0.0075353975,
-0.0573112816,
-0.051619038,
0.0300932098,
0.0623554923,
0.0098293945,
0.0161299575,
-0.0163188167,
-0.0622022673,
0.0487303361,
0.0771715343,
-0.0161994994,
-0.0171082616,
0.0637523904,
-0.0382973738,
-0.0035998325,
0.0319993049,
-0.0203036796,
0.0773817748,
0.0505353026,
-0.0007346628,
-0.028806014,
-0.0370428823,
0.0542436689,
0.0229968019,
0.0858217552,
0.0049238536,
-0.0575406179,
-0.0307574999,
0.0005084641,
0.0125318943,
-0.0298419539,
-0.0208786912,
0.0272415187,
0.0212830994,
-0.0184248164,
-0.0079442374,
0.020119695,
-0.0177101903,
-0.0265265796,
0.0163089801,
0.0347785838,
-0.060694471,
0.0358066522,
-0.0238252506,
0.0326923728,
0.0105994744,
0.0090984385,
0.041515708,
0.0447307006,
-0.0013237775,
-0.0319852643,
0.0288303066,
0.0299032424,
-0.0337247141,
0.0206083003,
-0.0667290166,
0.0010712643,
-0.0776658803,
0.0143043986,
0.0308313444,
-0.0018144002,
-0.0183449518,
-0.0123969037,
0.0129883597,
-0.0518509038,
0.0095197922,
0.0036603715,
0.018546693,
0.0068170293,
0.0042397971,
-0.0163106825,
0.011892559,
0.0767370462,
0.0191830155,
0.0426930003,
0.0512779765,
0.0268831868,
-0.0367168114,
-0.0138831409,
-0.0313903354,
0.0247739647,
-0.0282696504,
0.0429566242,
-0.0214745048,
-0.0611603484,
0.0061224625,
-0.0245018229,
0.0322759785,
0.0171819441,
0.0495975167,
0.0163817313,
0.0034241672,
0.0368398055,
-0.013684094,
-0.0197368972,
0.0242108051,
-0.0126971686,
0.0184701849,
-6.624571148e-33,
-0.0393097848,
-0.0043286169,
-0.0066660163,
-0.0055876654,
0.0012190238,
-0.0040282584,
-0.0156585798,
0.0260528307,
-0.0566417314,
0.0188107304,
-0.0113445958,
0.0103248656,
0.0251780599,
0.0408814475,
-0.0287465416,
0.0045798542,
0.0445708968,
-0.0132738724,
0.0274518989,
-0.0100869462,
-0.0002889283,
0.0611351058,
0.0824193731,
-0.0705523342,
-0.0207152981,
0.0207823161,
-0.0226825196,
0.0395096093,
0.0346384346,
0.0302134119,
-0.0054926835,
0.0820207447,
0.0207066685,
-0.0236193761,
-0.0253397804,
-0.0151364962,
-0.1000956818,
-0.0303951763,
-0.0128987329,
0.0088203726,
-0.0069923359,
-0.0110660745,
0.0783641487,
0.0002561976,
0.0202776007,
-0.0117684575,
0.0672634393,
-0.0556218661,
-0.0384834521,
0.0111440904,
-0.0189957265,
0.0524409562,
-0.0001784171,
-0.0193882249,
0.0515672751,
0.038574744,
0.0057180035,
0.0319907926,
-0.0363898426,
0.0180277303,
0.0161955785,
0.0551069155,
-0.0262131765,
0.0560197495,
-0.0016921462,
0.0319226459,
0.0574242547,
0.0458672494,
0.0566552915,
-0.0240161475,
0.0638423264,
-0.0023126544,
0.0327574722,
0.0363774411,
0.0856047571,
-0.028076658,
-0.0568885058,
0.0264994241,
-0.0023265821,
0.0192505457,
0.0157023445,
0.0176321901,
-0.0151445819,
-0.0241490249,
-0.0385705009,
-0.0614328422,
-0.0444204397,
0.0181638934,
-0.0118522076,
0.0383330397,
-0.0260071922,
0.0340709314,
-0.004605426,
-0.0264046025,
-0.009482515,
-0.0295188911,
0.0084514739,
0.014262151,
-0.0008996833,
0.0189834293,
-0.0422353484,
-0.0215753056,
0.0097733447,
0.0328050517,
-0.0003208445,
0.000712104,
0.0833238512,
0.0071227909,
-0.0525679663,
-0.0056987703,
0.004314594,
0.0032737667,
0.0272725001,
0.0380522721,
0.0158365425,
0.0146104461,
-0.0085624065,
0.0689511672,
0.0271793008,
-0.0586464964,
0.0045870142,
0.0007614823,
0.0343557633,
0.0384391584,
-0.0334062316,
-0.009862097,
0.0240734275,
0.0036358924,
0.0828447789,
-0.0408886261,
-0.014411415,
-0.0190791376,
2.99e-7,
0.0476179346,
0.0115053356,
0.031210294,
-0.028244162,
-0.0072867675,
0.0322834142,
-0.0177547392,
0.012557379,
-0.0150178978,
-0.0323660523,
0.0365962163,
0.009846081,
0.023393821,
0.0118206581,
-0.0620248131,
-0.0260204915,
-0.0384567082,
0.0282852259,
0.0117566362,
0.0016741606,
0.0403512157,
0.1081966087,
0.0134151727,
-0.0245423801,
0.0057151723,
-0.0154756326,
0.0572255701,
-0.0349481739,
0.0549511462,
0.0177856144,
-0.0495156124,
0.0538170524,
-0.0303223841,
0.0156023083,
-0.0107985139,
0.0043849056,
0.0026428846,
0.0557544082,
-0.0150718493,
-0.0195821356,
0.0564252324,
0.0485348031,
0.0104322722,
0.0463254601,
0.0171496086,
-0.0990130678,
-0.0577101149,
-0.0369505584,
-0.041864574,
-0.0131977051,
0.0415462181,
-0.0287134666,
-0.0056810621,
-0.0105539793,
0.0068943347,
0.0090303561,
-0.0733486861,
-0.1042622402,
-0.0135424007,
0.0394591875,
-0.003977309,
-0.0162564311,
-0.0230862945,
-0.0401959158,
0.0289083365,
-0.063816689,
0.0372855552,
2.346481645e-34,
0.0615833253,
-0.0275898334,
-0.022344226,
0.0061421609,
-0.0294091199,
0.0033764236,
-0.047656104,
-0.0051965886,
0.0271161031,
-0.0358652584,
-0.0338622108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02997v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02997v2 | Erasure of Unaligned Attributes from Neural Representations | 2023-02-06T18:32:17 | 2023-04-18T10:34:01 | Shun Shao, Yftah Ziser, Shay Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Assignment-Maximization Spectral Attribute removaL (AMSAL)
algorithm, which erases information from neural representations when the
information to be erased is implicit rather than directly being aligned to each
input example. Our algorithm works by alternating between two steps. In one, it
finds an assignment of the input representations to the information to be
erased, and in the other, it creates projections of both the input
representations and the information to be erased into a joint latent space. We
test our algorithm on an extensive array of datasets, including a Twitter
dataset with multiple guarded attributes, the BiasBios dataset and the
BiasBench benchmark. The last benchmark includes four datasets with various
types of protected attributes. Our results demonstrate that bias can often be
removed in our setup. We also discuss the limitations of our approach when
there is a strong entanglement between the main task and the information to be
erased. | [
-0.013449681,
0.0849848017,
-0.0046396344,
0.0179400574,
-0.0298192929,
0.0162610207,
0.0246903859,
-0.0062519931,
0.0043994905,
0.0309136268,
-0.0474315174,
-0.0140358973,
0.0373631008,
0.0043822061,
0.0128073376,
-0.0162672698,
0.0424056277,
0.0195762869,
0.0228558984,
-0.0379534774,
-0.0035713026,
-0.039809037,
0.0180373881,
-0.0108072693,
-0.0380784534,
-0.0285086352,
0.0003139898,
-0.0429581963,
0.0387862921,
0.0148551399,
0.0249619,
0.031836614,
-0.0226658769,
0.0103493342,
0.0000022239,
-0.0081532337,
-0.0049642823,
-0.005515438,
-0.0084535806,
0.0294590332,
0.0189708807,
0.02598425,
0.0287191719,
-0.01300749,
-0.0324176922,
-0.0313325413,
0.0560707673,
0.0425358005,
0.0524280146,
0.0782835558,
-0.0230495781,
-0.0227281451,
0.0117409779,
-0.0287149176,
0.0239150543,
-0.0148608061,
0.051011011,
-0.0954571888,
-0.0982822552,
0.0072633973,
-0.0127727948,
0.052438315,
0.0253743827,
0.0401442423,
0.0720053837,
0.025304772,
-0.0068479772,
-0.0062005739,
0.0246433411,
0.0606495775,
0.000349953,
-0.0083636669,
0.0540909506,
0.0035032176,
0.028578002,
-0.0323878676,
-0.015229634,
-0.0058995429,
0.0132578835,
0.0278016664,
-0.0536313169,
-0.0224355049,
0.0448497459,
-0.0150884707,
0.0396191962,
0.0243755803,
0.0182340536,
-0.0180776119,
-0.0105063152,
-0.0147485305,
-0.0094541209,
-0.0169407967,
0.0239111166,
-0.0085670752,
-0.0135846781,
-0.0172556359,
-0.0542655885,
-0.0377582759,
-0.0531580448,
0.0081862919,
0.0578805618,
0.0185295176,
0.0271726362,
0.0467861146,
-0.0307354629,
0.0277216174,
-0.038435787,
0.0314857624,
0.0033272395,
0.0009871058,
-0.0313177146,
-0.038345281,
0.0467080139,
0.0555615462,
0.0442867912,
0.0242571607,
-0.0143298125,
-0.0167541765,
-0.1031644121,
0.0369306244,
-0.0529642254,
0.0642204285,
-0.0310873929,
0.0135048749,
-0.0298133902,
0.0092803016,
0.0110556455,
0.0421766639,
-0.0116952164,
-0.0044395295,
-0.040921513,
0.0382342711,
0.0352298096,
-0.050656531,
0.0000744107,
0.080192104,
0.0098704537,
-0.0238732249,
-0.0202674158,
-0.0478002653,
0.0275905225,
-0.0472160131,
0.0525040776,
-0.0055028773,
0.0424241796,
-0.0295432284,
-0.0355094336,
-0.1067254096,
-0.0251006782,
0.0315805636,
-0.0653698742,
0.0653234199,
-0.0069620255,
-0.0223879851,
0.0272988398,
0.0107858265,
-0.0241447035,
0.0002009173,
0.007943619,
0.08370547,
-0.0100595457,
-0.0380577222,
0.0216409508,
0.0108260708,
0.065903008,
-0.005957745,
-0.0377912819,
-0.0031891626,
0.0077436371,
-0.0100045931,
0.0224521607,
0.0205013063,
-0.029979473,
-0.0539723635,
0.0689992234,
0.0048713768,
-0.0068922308,
0.0327547267,
-0.0458072163,
-0.0059610819,
0.0042119925,
-0.0165720731,
-0.0865927488,
0.0754907429,
-0.0240303539,
-0.0421605036,
-0.024218021,
0.0145399794,
-0.0600561611,
-0.0249062572,
0.0503163189,
-0.040448539,
0.0226889048,
-0.0108911106,
0.0168698654,
0.0184878502,
0.0044582048,
0.0599123314,
0.0005391719,
-0.0046640481,
0.0535425916,
-0.0292790346,
-0.0368627124,
0.0071036457,
0.0094974153,
-0.0506176539,
0.0231439788,
-0.0341112502,
-0.0198345426,
-0.0135619584,
-0.0236275662,
-0.0014600471,
0.0801960379,
-0.0412784889,
-0.059075743,
-0.0243501179,
0.0088999532,
0.0012024826,
0.0203628987,
-0.0224281661,
-0.0001604976,
0.0016751039,
-0.0049458328,
0.0145830736,
0.0018977236,
-0.070449084,
0.0125581743,
0.025944164,
-0.0131670712,
0.0505804308,
0.0070043039,
-0.022971319,
0.0292789731,
-0.0036843894,
-0.026667336,
-0.0329107605,
-0.0590070263,
-0.0013593673,
0.0373000018,
-0.0827789307,
-0.0439245291,
0.0729730576,
-0.0338802002,
-0.0277595036,
0.0581950769,
-0.0174401756,
-0.0393400788,
-0.0137529504,
-0.0193728302,
-0.0331453644,
0.0127600422,
0.0269950666,
0.0469265096,
-0.019848479,
-0.0355391018,
-0.0274388473,
-0.05093484,
0.0037605134,
-0.0335096084,
0.0017161887,
-0.036000289,
0.0057680928,
0.0276625492,
0.0096748499,
-0.0531835444,
-0.0288991667,
0.001255689,
-0.0315042511,
0.0100879222,
0.0165563971,
0.014262544,
0.0169391539,
0.0200092457,
0.0476033986,
-0.0338636823,
-0.027314987,
0.0233255979,
-0.0458857603,
0.0297539849,
0.0504213013,
-0.0127098374,
-0.0311240405,
0.0424612425,
-0.0158476792,
-0.01241636,
0.0457615368,
-0.0319439247,
-0.0096400166,
-0.0089133568,
-0.0196860451,
-0.031233497,
0.0187161248,
0.0199757311,
-0.015644554,
-0.0355258398,
0.0116309589,
-0.0482866392,
0.0537327267,
-0.0093352962,
0.049433507,
0.0548398681,
0.0424893424,
-0.0016709827,
-0.0177050047,
-0.0299564898,
0.0457653292,
0.0202247929,
-0.0085386951,
-0.0043483647,
0.0204330105,
0.0488332622,
-0.0031589954,
-0.041387964,
0.0761517435,
-0.0001982576,
-0.0676184148,
-0.0263531879,
-0.0030645707,
-0.0331006534,
0.0143166622,
-0.0717697442,
-0.0068621971,
0.0829965696,
0.0345833749,
0.0336573198,
0.0318951793,
0.0192414336,
-0.0050464566,
-0.0124600567,
0.0283692684,
0.0307990424,
0.0272032097,
-0.030878583,
-0.0352106839,
-0.0080866609,
0.0393226221,
-0.0267088152,
-0.0394196473,
-0.0091637196,
-0.0179133732,
-0.0104124648,
-0.0186354201,
-0.0142733073,
-0.0463247821,
0.0666575059,
0.0231105983,
-0.0591635182,
0.0096909041,
-0.0412977003,
-0.0856170878,
0.0313885994,
-0.0163314268,
-0.0110095097,
0.0225665942,
-0.0100725554,
0.0305830371,
-0.0040867114,
-0.0192039609,
-0.0281653088,
-0.0284607355,
-0.0218761936,
0.0779292434,
-0.0196541306,
0.0319759436,
-0.0410381965,
0.027240606,
-0.0116444081,
0.0031865321,
-0.0168731343,
-0.0438300222,
0.0544923991,
0.0082635945,
0.0259489007,
0.0523955449,
-0.0033528062,
-0.0632893145,
0.0112789935,
0.0731841177,
-0.0238631666,
0.0186145902,
-0.0200612973,
-0.119034566,
-0.0009820311,
-0.0025788217,
0.0187531058,
0.0422121733,
-0.0539936759,
0.0019672676,
-0.0588368289,
-0.0054972623,
0.0080877142,
-0.034789715,
-0.0647475272,
-0.0104957856,
0.0502486564,
-0.0552904718,
0.0460378565,
-0.0254284572,
0.0212357026,
0.0009917971,
-0.0061082863,
0.0418762267,
-0.0158063378,
-0.0023592198,
-0.0180394482,
0.0543506704,
0.030389566,
0.0366273932,
-0.0269864518,
-0.0359055474,
-0.0335604809,
0.0014958237,
0.0000857629,
0.0078816162,
0.1188910455,
0.0317999795,
-0.0276834946,
-0.0271172952,
0.0694172904,
0.0005458393,
-0.0117413914,
-0.0144165112,
0.0352193303,
0.001774922,
-0.0078799706,
0.0276798606,
-0.0853388235,
0.0132977571,
0.0629138649,
0.0183913931,
-0.0616835654,
-0.027317645,
-0.0214321092,
0.0100493534,
-0.0111360066,
-0.0029179875,
0.01832431,
-0.0036319718,
-0.0587533228,
-0.0331191458,
-0.0119794784,
0.0030851595,
-0.0070417495,
0.019462131,
-0.0144941499,
0.0344841219,
-0.0568166263,
-0.0667890534,
0.023752369,
-0.035139136,
-0.0044481046,
0.0486096404,
-0.0025603645,
-0.0181462429,
-0.0311543886,
-0.0118311048,
-0.050685633,
-0.035812214,
-0.0605153516,
0.0636247471,
-0.0003990403,
0.0188827831,
0.0426096804,
-0.0172230508,
-0.0681113452,
0.0407690853,
0.0564399399,
-0.0507232733,
0.047502961,
0.0383017957,
-0.0095170988,
-0.011615606,
0.0512897484,
-0.0132303182,
0.0017746981,
0.0692477748,
-0.0403847732,
0.0040548611,
0.040295817,
0.0012580761,
0.0215470325,
0.080108352,
0.0357911661,
0.0074346415,
0.000141765,
-0.0154674836,
0.0037121687,
-0.0285715219,
0.0351178199,
-0.0040093735,
0.0393881388,
0.068732731,
-0.0013088658,
0.0114429025,
0.0535727218,
0.0181441177,
-0.0363187827,
-0.033073362,
-0.0219234265,
-0.0082972515,
-0.0171989016,
0.0712064207,
-0.0071490249,
0.1067106202,
0.0384677835,
0.0147534553,
-0.0273974258,
-0.01011521,
0.0312599875,
0.0411735326,
-0.0850483552,
0.0046516717,
-0.0200576186,
-0.0298722386,
-0.0113826571,
0.0092684943,
-0.0143743837,
0.0080943415,
-0.0188841242,
0.0002856462,
-0.0112223299,
-0.0031264641,
0.0201016683,
0.0027587819,
0.0240353681,
0.04830385,
-0.0074757105,
0.0021652635,
0.0075824051,
0.0778930932,
0.0053650388,
0.0602324381,
-0.066667214,
-0.0074118618,
-0.0706446692,
-0.0139567629,
-0.0212678332,
0.0187368467,
-0.0208337121,
-0.0090701943,
-0.0100527229,
-0.078204006,
-0.0068498505,
-0.0454189293,
0.022597257,
-0.0005696041,
0.0187907312,
-0.017417334,
0.0121103767,
-0.0240041874,
0.0039717518,
-0.0161655564,
0.0359479599,
-0.0659402758,
0.0090166414,
-6.85205208e-33,
0.0146521078,
-0.0128959408,
-0.0116978809,
0.0269574393,
0.0142715583,
-0.0041260109,
-0.0039936216,
-0.0309306346,
-0.0071186586,
0.0154393818,
-0.0254414193,
0.0220094305,
-0.0072161248,
0.0094261141,
-0.0027789816,
-0.0265005268,
0.0479681157,
-0.0421021357,
-0.008620386,
0.0372091793,
0.0570708364,
0.0137919802,
0.0575040728,
-0.0885407627,
0.0080175381,
0.0022594973,
-0.0632772744,
0.0231070407,
-0.0323214196,
0.020162195,
-0.0508556627,
0.0270894598,
0.0292557478,
-0.0296604447,
-0.0032349129,
-0.0001968955,
-0.1079559997,
-0.0313013792,
-0.03663899,
0.0171517693,
-0.0401486903,
-0.0759465471,
0.0420164429,
-0.0030840584,
-0.061068058,
-0.021814229,
0.0415696017,
0.0048320843,
0.0310105998,
0.0057072723,
0.0152474232,
-0.0062278528,
-0.027710136,
0.0127888182,
0.0769391581,
-0.0181467868,
-0.0278816372,
0.0117630763,
-0.0985301882,
-0.0043574097,
-0.0365010053,
0.0089052208,
0.0226765443,
0.0288347136,
0.0146162063,
0.0663208142,
0.0988461971,
0.0190966409,
0.0107173221,
-0.0188295823,
-0.0158830862,
0.0149916057,
0.0323133208,
0.0404374823,
0.0638045892,
-0.0476121902,
-0.0492321998,
0.013291982,
-0.0045109503,
0.0221791398,
-0.0256232601,
0.0551317781,
0.0147545291,
-0.0289188363,
-0.0418979563,
-0.0306086596,
-0.0785656497,
-0.0150976451,
-0.0230170954,
0.0008337167,
-0.0408078022,
0.0773764402,
0.0120337838,
-0.020205671,
-0.0122278566,
0.0423301682,
0.0315798521,
0.0345053971,
0.0372980647,
-0.045672223,
-0.0400743894,
-0.007117393,
0.0326183587,
0.0084902588,
0.0498939194,
0.0206450541,
0.0546083264,
0.0508628711,
-0.0116965845,
-0.0327351019,
-0.0309385192,
0.029834222,
0.0482102782,
-0.0196567085,
0.0067671458,
0.0095587252,
-0.0153860934,
0.0360161811,
0.076940164,
0.0617004856,
-0.0408281237,
0.0014524193,
0.0408576988,
0.0094952444,
0.00128618,
-0.0062327217,
0.0140526146,
-0.0581706874,
0.0137213729,
-0.057687778,
-0.0131530948,
-0.039776437,
2.969e-7,
-0.0113189481,
0.0178391431,
0.0419725291,
-0.0215423759,
0.0524555407,
0.0746353194,
-0.0031902718,
0.057525333,
-0.0535195842,
-0.0131113548,
-0.0252251532,
0.0276306309,
0.0230710506,
0.0097478069,
-0.0451860875,
0.0225527212,
-0.0141120274,
-0.0041961623,
-0.0312547795,
0.0381400213,
-0.0141064012,
0.0277967546,
0.0424660221,
-0.018645294,
0.0143485414,
0.0261299536,
0.0424808972,
-0.0114728548,
-0.0123402849,
-0.0299146846,
0.0169903245,
-0.0121412631,
-0.0011339311,
0.0159225725,
-0.0245058984,
-0.028295448,
0.008135573,
0.06024931,
-0.0035811749,
-0.0461960062,
-0.0290664099,
0.0055120359,
0.0215656366,
0.0055933283,
0.0528749824,
-0.0025425712,
-0.1021543071,
-0.033516515,
-0.0697947592,
0.0339063182,
0.0069672265,
0.0322367325,
-0.0062582404,
-0.0271421112,
-0.0355604291,
0.0240397621,
-0.0449991412,
-0.0488527194,
-0.033497829,
-0.0035534878,
-0.0254018996,
-0.0463123918,
0.0275557507,
0.0537232831,
0.0505533293,
-0.0543389954,
0.0164690949,
2.52862174e-34,
-0.0156693961,
-0.0249925889,
0.0484231748,
0.0010247432,
-0.0022989376,
-0.0334023125,
-0.0053080278,
-0.0103623671,
0.0349323973,
-0.037833225,
-0.0152042592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02962v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02962v1 | LoFT: Enhancing Faithfulness and Diversity for Table-to-Text Generation via Logic Form Control | 2023-02-06T17:49:27 | 2023-02-06T17:49:27 | Yilun Zhao, Zhenting Qi, Linyong Nan, Lorenzo Jaime Yu Flores, Dragomir Radev | cs.CL | cs.CL | Logical Table-to-Text (LT2T) generation is tasked with generating logically
faithful sentences from tables. There currently exists two challenges in the
field: 1) Faithfulness: how to generate sentences that are factually correct
given the table content; 2) Diversity: how to generate multiple sentences that
offer different perspectives on the table. This work proposes LoFT, which
utilizes logic forms as fact verifiers and content planners to control LT2T
generation. Experimental results on the LogicNLG dataset demonstrate that LoFT
is the first model that addresses unfaithfulness and lack of diversity issues
simultaneously. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/Yale-LILY/LoFT. | [
0.0140919518,
0.0780468807,
0.0000020243,
0.0044850446,
-0.0695490167,
-0.0031896103,
-0.0191871412,
0.0011313622,
0.002817801,
-0.0163305346,
0.0207330957,
-0.002559186,
0.0034098097,
0.0698294416,
0.0333957076,
0.0043543866,
0.0826157033,
0.0259073228,
-0.0573916659,
0.0132015506,
0.0186714493,
0.0270371456,
-0.0061276671,
0.0187745541,
-0.0349468887,
-0.0036569494,
-0.0323499739,
0.0104573965,
0.0273981187,
0.004882101,
-0.0149834314,
0.0729787871,
-0.017867947,
0.0173982233,
0.0000018121,
0.013786382,
-0.0780535415,
0.0083717806,
0.0056937416,
-0.0416459963,
0.038045276,
-0.0134947523,
0.0011160943,
0.0095923562,
-0.0484725647,
0.038798999,
0.0267729685,
0.0665343851,
0.114849478,
0.0753188059,
0.0082470868,
-0.0231243651,
-0.0088054715,
-0.0012914162,
0.0523176715,
0.0179104339,
-0.0283807646,
0.0282688625,
-0.0035998698,
-0.0125059057,
0.0181861538,
0.0220024418,
0.0469652191,
-0.0183841959,
0.0043289633,
0.0160057507,
-0.0379412286,
-0.0125654833,
0.018095443,
0.0750833973,
0.0234818514,
-0.052953776,
0.0380367935,
0.0103619024,
0.0171625391,
-0.0297335535,
-0.0168047808,
0.0491223596,
-0.0391566902,
-0.004114931,
0.0417838171,
0.0011443011,
-0.0115975607,
-0.016236132,
-0.022186162,
0.0451922826,
-0.0001533897,
-0.0322769694,
-0.0208289102,
0.0193301626,
0.0184458084,
-0.0829388499,
-0.0028080579,
0.0161498133,
-0.0760462135,
0.0053704795,
-0.0651112497,
-0.0560045242,
0.0190825798,
-0.0627962053,
0.0250204802,
0.0389370397,
0.009655498,
-0.0298854709,
-0.0361062177,
0.0061690309,
0.0013938244,
0.0457824208,
-0.045607958,
-0.0027332846,
-0.0308153052,
0.0246731564,
-0.0436303988,
0.0274513811,
-0.0730439797,
-0.0083054826,
-0.0064771581,
-0.0037170041,
-0.0421496928,
0.0748099461,
0.0044603967,
0.0144187398,
-0.0396313481,
-0.0007787379,
-0.0200173743,
-0.0008916941,
-0.0280557536,
-0.0331975967,
0.0435208902,
-0.0665166676,
-0.0208998527,
-0.0077425973,
0.0061564837,
0.0024827069,
0.0043225931,
0.0289434195,
-0.0511465855,
0.0387664139,
-0.0530587845,
-0.0680250004,
-0.0140134599,
-0.0689755008,
0.0016245523,
-0.0621816479,
0.0332439058,
0.0005199253,
-0.0091515658,
-0.0494797528,
0.015048245,
0.0506815761,
-0.0089169331,
0.0161285978,
-0.0268840268,
-0.0069720051,
-0.0146959256,
-0.020095,
-0.021405654,
0.0726274252,
0.0277984999,
0.0303244162,
-0.0173387788,
0.0181273129,
-0.0186898783,
-0.0010302186,
0.0509663746,
-0.0052067558,
0.0002223653,
0.0456000641,
-0.000403036,
0.0299128853,
-0.0062145772,
0.0358521938,
-0.0130120618,
0.0715765059,
0.0464358628,
-0.0481740534,
0.0552408099,
0.0627160966,
0.0396732986,
-0.001809803,
-0.0025161647,
0.0488777757,
-0.0501004457,
0.0445441715,
0.0279196836,
0.0362466425,
0.0337553881,
0.0492267609,
0.0112906825,
-0.0463966094,
0.0135646826,
0.0182609204,
0.0015472386,
-0.0183416456,
-0.0124652544,
0.0555277616,
-0.0475985482,
0.0421694517,
-0.005291861,
-0.0807746723,
-0.0079112565,
-0.0050095581,
0.0511786304,
0.0552831367,
0.0309639871,
-0.0174312219,
-0.0250369273,
-0.0045925253,
-0.0045999526,
0.0500501208,
0.0581817552,
-0.016320724,
-0.0198686905,
-0.0204901006,
-0.0346585289,
0.0112451473,
0.0179271549,
-0.000118093,
0.0288658943,
0.0018910554,
0.0284630693,
-0.0352850594,
-0.0317429975,
0.0368607603,
0.0409821123,
0.0589627326,
0.0062221382,
-0.002409539,
0.0170837864,
0.0327602997,
-0.0272343606,
0.0499484576,
0.0007299708,
-0.0056800167,
-0.0187409688,
0.004259964,
-0.0494351499,
-0.0368506797,
0.0342635773,
-0.0497837998,
-0.0569057055,
-0.0135045741,
-0.061112117,
-0.0523240082,
0.0087044546,
-0.0554782599,
-0.0615731515,
-0.0409032367,
-0.0111897988,
0.0380244851,
-0.0099309525,
0.0182442255,
0.0964225754,
-0.0007569602,
-0.0174377784,
-0.018268995,
-0.0346679166,
0.0271067806,
-0.04775846,
0.0747235939,
-0.0163311437,
-0.0110795023,
0.0087775337,
0.0221217424,
0.0449041761,
-0.063219808,
-0.0282520745,
-0.0679433644,
0.0286119431,
-0.0411714464,
0.0095675541,
0.0337004997,
-0.0055535645,
0.0080500394,
0.0079738712,
-0.0903941914,
-0.0054620425,
0.0490345247,
-0.0210079495,
0.0547011383,
-0.0164960697,
-0.0063145924,
-0.0093062539,
-0.0236729458,
-0.0203885157,
0.0106497193,
0.0155240018,
-0.0026332242,
-0.0297079813,
-0.0210314635,
-0.0385976247,
0.0153208207,
0.0514241084,
0.0220714491,
0.0038041214,
0.0119285258,
0.0437977202,
0.0178656653,
0.035252437,
-0.0156629849,
0.0117991855,
0.0045892354,
-0.0148204658,
0.0427176505,
-0.0240371544,
0.0613688417,
0.0186257549,
-0.07476978,
0.0570852682,
-0.0103129558,
0.0070640184,
-0.0107777948,
-0.0565045141,
0.027081402,
0.0092867641,
-0.0198337566,
-0.0050339275,
0.0203718878,
0.0051889247,
0.0066035884,
-0.0360847153,
0.0236214753,
0.0315659679,
-0.0473759994,
0.0375421271,
-0.0456047691,
0.0206204951,
-0.0564610362,
0.0321482308,
0.0100560412,
0.0229633003,
-0.0010689015,
0.0084671667,
-0.0768207312,
-0.0056745969,
0.05436638,
-0.0192463528,
0.1120761782,
-0.0594217293,
0.0099723656,
-0.0276381839,
-0.0351073779,
-0.0375019833,
-0.0260511804,
0.002709423,
0.0135441059,
0.0140829543,
-0.0109832138,
-0.0278319903,
-0.056176018,
0.0242333822,
0.0248268433,
-0.0131851174,
-0.0215022825,
-0.035455469,
0.0160683226,
0.0661260113,
0.0281517934,
0.0181251373,
-0.0161531139,
-0.0139652053,
0.0577219017,
-0.0562864207,
-0.0147662396,
0.0026160919,
0.0118675474,
-0.0215161256,
-0.0295336954,
0.011848188,
0.0276984349,
0.0090450849,
-0.0294988435,
-0.033065401,
0.0482171029,
0.0011816162,
0.0541244075,
-0.0040038223,
0.0056330436,
0.0813245624,
0.0012616566,
0.0285546631,
-0.1129811183,
-0.0094260704,
0.0019969342,
0.0105100255,
-0.0180333816,
-0.0402167924,
-0.0262042861,
-0.0965177789,
0.0504795313,
0.0150638036,
-0.0630353242,
-0.0775304437,
0.0174421668,
-0.0166407879,
-0.0141477874,
0.014380591,
0.0557843857,
-0.0036395015,
0.040844731,
0.0065702614,
-0.0207365975,
0.0033722755,
-0.0540589727,
-0.0455060974,
0.0164253637,
0.0607178733,
0.0122397207,
-0.0045795236,
-0.0085432455,
-0.0318277106,
0.0213827696,
-0.0164829288,
-0.0087893838,
0.0434842072,
0.010833323,
0.0120725911,
0.0008069956,
0.0179357808,
-0.0008366483,
-0.012466602,
0.0289743003,
0.031215284,
-0.0197572615,
-0.023005208,
-0.0276361071,
0.0387490615,
0.0164142214,
0.0712957382,
0.0321078151,
0.0153538836,
-0.0485444665,
-0.0447650217,
-0.028854873,
-0.1108545735,
0.0204707067,
0.0579991154,
-0.0336282216,
-0.0187922213,
-0.0732034743,
-0.0041207867,
0.0093208253,
0.0693186596,
-0.0167103298,
0.0061227465,
-0.0143346656,
-0.0189585723,
-0.0234505218,
-0.0244702678,
-0.0468664989,
0.029190911,
0.0086285463,
-0.0261806455,
-0.0409397893,
-0.0447987095,
-0.0108387843,
0.0407492965,
-0.0439585671,
-0.0205588769,
0.0053874468,
0.0193604492,
0.0287683439,
0.0405982584,
0.0072426442,
0.0529803894,
0.0096696829,
0.0535215922,
-0.0208888259,
-0.0023677985,
-0.0046630069,
-0.0209766179,
0.009525218,
0.0410197489,
-0.0302954931,
-0.0064647207,
0.0038462877,
0.0593865067,
0.0413151719,
0.0060703298,
0.0477810651,
0.024790233,
-0.0560945533,
-0.0071729831,
-0.0060934294,
-0.0184397362,
0.0089915851,
-0.0705890581,
-0.0542699397,
-0.0330886692,
0.0308715999,
-0.0081105288,
-0.0044950666,
0.019411847,
-0.0073519512,
0.0140344221,
0.0533211157,
-0.0117853889,
-0.0279871225,
0.0047960337,
0.0031070423,
0.0332975723,
-0.0449696183,
-0.0461064912,
-0.0204035416,
-0.0226503722,
0.0310340337,
-0.0154979993,
0.0345859006,
0.0647557303,
-0.0391209088,
-0.0480955057,
0.0271066558,
-0.0595965944,
-0.0009381935,
-0.0417804867,
-0.0086605232,
0.0299868211,
0.0416069329,
0.0363504067,
-0.0540637784,
-0.0075923624,
0.0158423781,
0.0519497767,
0.0602007806,
-0.014234202,
-0.0224629417,
-0.0294948742,
-0.0033537485,
-0.0836463943,
0.0604317337,
-0.0060075573,
-0.00551472,
-0.0158935338,
-0.0251382086,
-0.0658882409,
-0.0410359316,
-0.046301093,
-0.0265101697,
0.0021568451,
-0.0579881296,
-0.0604035966,
-0.045640301,
0.0962485597,
0.0968345404,
0.0292971358,
0.0151641294,
0.0226285402,
0.0505940653,
0.0604737923,
-0.0421595052,
-0.022814095,
0.0389497317,
0.0168352854,
-0.047588259,
-0.0297663305,
-5.916352332e-33,
-0.0592196025,
-0.0132099567,
-0.0014739141,
-0.0514697395,
-0.0294515882,
-0.0364253186,
-0.0536205806,
-0.0195283648,
-0.0016517629,
0.0331649818,
-0.0205173995,
0.0405122302,
0.0340421274,
0.0081804078,
0.0103158103,
-0.0448992029,
0.0525334626,
-0.0075033363,
-0.0280715264,
0.0175638441,
0.0115842754,
-0.0125789745,
0.0102687068,
-0.0343184546,
0.0283438787,
0.0027065533,
-0.0162597485,
-0.0144070191,
-0.0539944433,
0.0017873039,
0.0146167483,
0.0227749813,
0.0174413025,
-0.0333063677,
-0.0598095171,
-0.0040140348,
-0.0914508551,
-0.0342740715,
0.0082479836,
-0.0268571004,
-0.0418784693,
-0.0361929946,
0.0232932977,
-0.0290279966,
-0.0157616623,
-0.040184211,
0.0016689254,
-0.0324414782,
0.0244038049,
-0.0314445272,
-0.0354537666,
0.0179146919,
0.0099088335,
0.0142359566,
-0.0303487182,
0.0293165147,
0.0313818753,
-0.0608363152,
-0.0205037575,
0.0250973552,
0.0178926587,
0.0101893833,
0.0541069321,
-0.023612693,
-0.0168496668,
0.0387282073,
0.0180250127,
0.0324375108,
-0.0738847032,
0.0557800531,
-0.0501198024,
0.07527107,
0.0728819072,
0.0657461211,
0.0025829379,
-0.0084135868,
-0.0748003796,
0.0513209626,
-0.0373571292,
-0.0073747355,
-0.015138329,
-0.0523371659,
-0.0092188027,
-0.0004390293,
-0.0022924044,
0.0123577425,
-0.0044419351,
-0.0152517725,
0.0156532153,
0.024819389,
-0.0023265469,
-0.0148258191,
0.0004031418,
0.0053488188,
-0.0083460705,
0.0239181295,
-0.0325691812,
-0.0118240071,
-0.0033487508,
0.0113088097,
-0.0010469974,
-0.0331026465,
0.0370714068,
0.0229231399,
0.0144199114,
0.0378921144,
0.0521022677,
0.0283370502,
-0.046914842,
0.0312001407,
-0.0323983282,
0.0708164498,
0.0037785335,
-0.016099304,
0.011366264,
-0.0085106464,
0.0057351761,
0.02535953,
0.009154819,
0.0101071838,
-0.0232358128,
0.037018545,
0.0226081535,
0.0312467404,
0.0154785914,
0.022341691,
-0.0567399263,
-0.0136119574,
0.0164493788,
-0.0127966637,
0.0091990111,
0.0100271618,
2.396e-7,
0.0283572134,
-0.0227633845,
0.0619694963,
0.0705504641,
-0.0020509262,
0.0171068385,
0.0110361092,
0.0260602403,
-0.0516969785,
-0.0239518713,
0.0003044645,
-0.0072955745,
0.0668732077,
0.0617005639,
-0.0133385891,
-0.0268664975,
-0.0589796714,
-0.0210616216,
-0.0586735271,
0.0084244777,
0.0966503173,
0.0786450803,
-0.0505717881,
-0.0029504886,
0.0155940428,
-0.0056697684,
0.017646553,
0.0185877811,
0.004352388,
0.0368603356,
0.0717558339,
-0.0856692567,
0.0134666506,
0.0332285911,
-0.0343433358,
-0.0191144273,
-0.0181185324,
0.0403011404,
0.024968233,
0.0131744072,
-0.012236611,
-0.0693673864,
0.0289124269,
-0.0343901291,
0.0622047149,
-0.0224257503,
0.0190589838,
0.0396023951,
-0.048008021,
0.0299831145,
-0.0083091464,
0.0241325218,
-0.0303830486,
0.0228320677,
0.0383094475,
0.0224389583,
0.0245749149,
-0.0123488782,
-0.0481428169,
-0.0126434155,
-0.0428371318,
-0.0295366123,
-0.0039987788,
0.0404459685,
0.0047396431,
-0.0263284314,
-0.0471711457,
2.360824972e-34,
0.0485157892,
-0.0040145325,
0.0206413437,
-0.017175246,
0.0822993666,
-0.0331977718,
0.0017649801,
0.0078442879,
-0.0082960892,
-0.0395915583,
-0.0524873659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02900v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02900v1 | Controllable Lexical Simplification for English | 2023-02-06T16:09:27 | 2023-02-06T16:09:27 | Kim Cheng Sheang, Daniel Ferrés, Horacio Saggion | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning Transformer-based approaches have recently shown exciting results
on sentence simplification task. However, so far, no research has applied
similar approaches to the Lexical Simplification (LS) task. In this paper, we
present ConLS, a Controllable Lexical Simplification system fine-tuned with T5
(a Transformer-based model pre-trained with a BERT-style approach and several
other tasks). The evaluation results on three datasets (LexMTurk, BenchLS, and
NNSeval) have shown that our model performs comparable to LSBert (the current
state-of-the-art) and even outperforms it in some cases. We also conducted a
detailed comparison on the effectiveness of control tokens to give a clear view
of how each token contributes to the model. | [
0.0042304355,
0.0074213659,
-0.0093734823,
0.0365687609,
-0.0634100065,
0.0053524999,
0.0161254965,
-0.0021507924,
-0.0254163947,
-0.0131760463,
-0.024714876,
0.0660367012,
0.0275695827,
-0.039010182,
0.0446140245,
-0.0584533215,
0.0358868986,
0.0134889269,
-0.0186916497,
0.0094298748,
-0.0102728866,
-0.0028555021,
0.0015009876,
0.0395974591,
-0.0080422349,
-0.0110120848,
0.0354122557,
0.0175245758,
0.0015662084,
0.0609225929,
0.0605658703,
0.0687486976,
-0.0190588199,
-0.0161446743,
0.0000019944,
-0.0104152011,
-0.0435478017,
-0.0117428405,
0.0285158306,
0.0569819249,
0.0645040944,
-0.0298240408,
-0.004744078,
0.0281859189,
-0.0122133698,
-0.003061726,
0.0456087478,
0.0755648911,
0.0648774281,
0.0602736585,
-0.0325856917,
-0.0670315623,
-0.0314567871,
-0.0138355345,
-0.0262640603,
-0.018425107,
0.025545476,
-0.0090935538,
-0.0158875901,
-0.0466283597,
-0.0609356835,
0.0458291695,
0.0210119821,
-0.0317093842,
0.0085596601,
-0.0196644943,
-0.0535568222,
-0.0160182733,
0.0094104735,
0.0528876036,
-0.0556678548,
-0.0706731454,
0.0181489568,
0.0017274455,
0.01862197,
0.0114435237,
-0.0469690338,
-0.0172390491,
0.0263491683,
0.0172538441,
-0.0151580013,
-0.0617412366,
0.0173160434,
0.0252312813,
-0.0145265805,
0.03890891,
0.0584273152,
-0.0321702734,
-0.0564283654,
-0.0053517097,
0.0140111009,
-0.0578118078,
0.0661397278,
0.0191779081,
-0.026828615,
-0.0125800027,
-0.0351057276,
-0.0911499411,
-0.0166900307,
0.0120666856,
0.0104355067,
0.0307310037,
-0.0091643874,
-0.0096696317,
-0.0512760654,
0.0531674512,
-0.0048145545,
0.0572815724,
-0.0462251641,
-0.0115545141,
-0.0094949976,
0.0255606044,
-0.0866354257,
0.0230889712,
-0.0412249975,
0.0033265103,
-0.05437617,
-0.0134316934,
0.0256005041,
-0.0469664186,
0.0095226886,
-0.0103003951,
-0.0071020788,
-0.0305804797,
0.0397486612,
0.0882594064,
-0.0149406586,
0.026685562,
-0.012786231,
-0.0415126644,
-0.0170955192,
0.0038390507,
0.0576081537,
-0.0077836411,
0.0058242744,
-0.0272579081,
-0.0304452088,
-0.0453402214,
-0.02596182,
0.0117589748,
0.0212030169,
0.0090333633,
-0.0157118365,
-0.0635861456,
0.0015287533,
-0.0108197005,
0.0128726596,
-0.013950604,
-0.0175208468,
0.0058397776,
-0.0249788798,
0.0774791539,
-0.0358398408,
0.0140910363,
-0.006314965,
0.0002227177,
0.0154886283,
0.0264385436,
0.0304397196,
0.0227821376,
0.0348743424,
-0.0417194553,
0.0605474822,
0.0495923646,
-0.0021489323,
-0.0116747161,
-0.0012773063,
-0.057967294,
-0.0916120186,
0.0152853467,
0.0552475862,
0.0660829768,
-0.0613684617,
0.0177929569,
0.0671186,
0.0131689925,
0.038838286,
0.048236575,
0.0376955047,
0.0078907441,
0.0261375848,
0.0263513438,
-0.0352586843,
-0.0250728708,
0.003027546,
0.0488484278,
0.0004900557,
0.0011775909,
-0.0262193009,
-0.0266941264,
0.0144819971,
-0.0247311592,
0.0268441085,
-0.0038367191,
0.0217173826,
0.0541246533,
-0.0642552227,
0.089664273,
0.00368786,
-0.056545265,
0.0060771024,
-0.0441999584,
-0.0345235653,
0.0395241939,
0.0535300337,
0.0098855905,
-0.088921383,
-0.0084222518,
-0.0260947272,
0.0346116163,
0.0465856828,
-0.0217953064,
0.0222423244,
-0.0735802054,
0.0038190028,
0.0179260056,
0.0133063458,
-0.0174550004,
0.0353050977,
-0.0492528453,
0.0179768763,
-0.0587875582,
-0.0011161779,
0.0458345562,
-0.0025755446,
-0.0027603256,
0.0214823522,
0.0195204392,
-0.0007543916,
-0.0146317231,
-0.0034574594,
0.0183681361,
-0.0005470866,
-0.0221409947,
-0.0305634439,
-0.0007325756,
-0.02302761,
-0.0599121526,
0.0546197817,
-0.0647614375,
-0.0341628343,
0.0928647444,
-0.0443138517,
-0.0224157032,
-0.0061962414,
-0.0448247828,
0.0349219479,
-0.0382704586,
0.0674557537,
0.0025555473,
0.0128544616,
-0.0390502848,
0.0188979823,
0.0191159081,
0.0385041349,
0.0598133206,
-0.0139290486,
-0.0111923665,
0.0087666977,
0.0034283539,
-0.07647416,
-0.0463224053,
-0.0178621411,
0.0314550139,
0.0296396911,
-0.0214555636,
-0.0311574973,
-0.0930261761,
-0.0186870154,
-0.0238831714,
0.0216743369,
0.0476392359,
0.0707547143,
-0.012543085,
-0.0102938879,
0.009332899,
-0.0086798547,
0.027099913,
0.0190927107,
0.0551056564,
-0.0239051748,
-0.0747629181,
-0.050045196,
-0.0112963906,
0.0018160328,
0.0085443873,
-0.0054442589,
-0.0170255285,
0.0047272826,
0.007152074,
0.006792014,
0.0095222378,
0.0351766199,
-0.063838616,
-0.0470615327,
-0.0024557721,
0.062608026,
0.0596156828,
0.023353897,
-0.0020611244,
-0.0017104336,
-0.0091275517,
-0.01096942,
0.0250013415,
-0.0218573119,
-0.0123906704,
-0.0485743806,
-0.0388790742,
0.0356039032,
0.0667229444,
0.0104773343,
0.0179398488,
-0.036480654,
-0.0240692701,
0.0192490406,
-0.0088535147,
-0.0061157383,
-0.0027905945,
-0.041079063,
0.0016880966,
-0.030312743,
-0.0083135944,
0.0422713012,
-0.0020502934,
-0.0035623428,
-0.0644442961,
0.0244126972,
-0.0284151062,
-0.0053374562,
0.0037153419,
0.028330721,
0.0168453138,
-0.0258172862,
-0.0266885441,
-0.0409964286,
0.0133357337,
-0.0101294219,
0.046806071,
-0.0441822857,
0.0156202503,
-0.0179687981,
-0.0599434599,
-0.0141351772,
-0.0452695861,
-0.0107840514,
0.0079058697,
0.081872873,
-0.0312172938,
-0.0230547357,
-0.0431786142,
0.0103081418,
0.0848765001,
-0.0031974446,
-0.0078272326,
-0.0052266186,
0.0550295599,
0.0514591597,
0.0161438715,
0.0397371911,
0.0080541335,
-0.0148857944,
-0.0037681879,
0.011712783,
-0.0239343084,
-0.0216696542,
0.0019687426,
0.0185553413,
-0.0761809349,
0.0002617924,
0.023636004,
0.0336403027,
-0.0381435454,
-0.0165146999,
0.1180390716,
0.0087624667,
0.0031684733,
0.0110238129,
0.0193572585,
0.0057706446,
-0.0250745453,
0.0054231994,
-0.0740057006,
-0.0377160385,
0.0329242311,
-0.0150641836,
0.0410585627,
-0.0042648404,
0.0028639098,
-0.0541143566,
0.0578704327,
-0.0140867867,
-0.0456910282,
-0.0478985533,
-0.0288542416,
0.0074774125,
-0.0186981987,
0.0234379638,
0.0266550481,
-0.0320617296,
-0.015323001,
-0.0407077894,
-0.0397233367,
-0.0493034944,
-0.0069025522,
-0.0368369892,
0.0325297788,
0.0164160859,
0.0368939489,
-0.0008696989,
-0.0440005101,
0.0421055108,
-0.0050438349,
-0.020353023,
-0.01791876,
0.0150189912,
0.0339935534,
-0.0282818172,
-0.0175066777,
0.0193496291,
-0.0129900193,
0.0158659127,
-0.0183326881,
0.0396917686,
0.0361899175,
-0.0323732868,
0.0346321873,
-0.0002097679,
-0.0234579407,
0.0596698001,
0.0533754379,
0.0191716403,
-0.0563561879,
0.0104882522,
-0.0236934647,
-0.072915785,
-0.0414836258,
-0.0088040894,
-0.0323998444,
-0.0539006926,
-0.0757757276,
-0.0196163114,
0.0374843739,
-0.0030575066,
0.0060317037,
-0.0113835726,
0.0177810844,
-0.0026706522,
-0.0357751064,
0.0099071879,
-0.0294349622,
0.0300705079,
-0.0547275841,
0.012743324,
0.0032583755,
0.0252108909,
0.0015563351,
0.0380529091,
-0.0603147447,
-0.0417566411,
0.0290557481,
0.0577503107,
0.0214860979,
0.0337052308,
-0.0173268709,
-0.0440279879,
0.0199852679,
0.0422662012,
-0.0328368396,
0.0532387532,
0.0347664803,
-0.0240564421,
0.0143406466,
0.0552923232,
-0.0369955972,
0.0396303311,
0.0078764642,
0.0388311073,
0.0074414015,
-0.0388227366,
0.0032953767,
0.0385444611,
0.0350183658,
-0.0241990704,
0.0422999822,
0.0078935195,
-0.0008479476,
-0.0542249791,
0.0212448034,
-0.0200408641,
0.0340215862,
0.0140023949,
0.0429845899,
-0.0350689515,
0.0380173288,
-0.0279497653,
-0.0337640569,
-0.0152121698,
0.0128384642,
-0.0411474966,
-0.0551130399,
0.0138872731,
-0.0182474982,
-0.0194266941,
-0.0287242886,
0.0109491665,
0.0026756967,
-0.0072215004,
-0.0040616109,
0.0132155642,
0.0431354716,
-0.0948323905,
0.0406023487,
-0.0250216275,
-0.0150240846,
-0.0124202613,
0.0337849446,
0.05402679,
-0.0108862873,
0.0986262038,
-0.0399839208,
-0.0351796523,
-0.0147801777,
0.0063118446,
0.004426253,
0.0099386154,
-0.0089906519,
-0.0121018253,
0.0090371044,
-0.0011558397,
0.0705799013,
-0.0399935581,
0.0558092482,
0.0178874303,
0.0025150736,
-0.0505234599,
-0.0392993502,
-0.0219831206,
-0.0054467479,
-0.0004294674,
-0.042466253,
-0.0216915216,
-0.0657265857,
0.0406949744,
0.0062256726,
0.0123592885,
-0.0232045911,
0.0367393196,
0.0208453089,
0.0054049348,
-0.0463439152,
0.0071800076,
0.0055082869,
0.0409519151,
-0.0617633611,
-0.0616657808,
-6.337829137e-33,
0.0077902447,
0.03388175,
0.0149571225,
-0.0091526024,
-0.0594177134,
0.0112094572,
-0.0774773061,
-0.0267804265,
-0.0228381008,
0.0525731295,
-0.0363807492,
0.0204935111,
0.0208479613,
0.029353248,
-0.0047003962,
0.0191314109,
0.090814732,
0.0028835589,
-0.0145962099,
-0.0073879948,
-0.0422810093,
0.0365518667,
0.0408101305,
-0.0384038985,
-0.0545937456,
0.014073384,
-0.0421950668,
0.0102808326,
0.03418139,
0.0076949443,
-0.0013041203,
0.0125867799,
0.0227958243,
-0.0564683564,
-0.0435099863,
0.0249217376,
-0.0973521918,
-0.0070699323,
0.062783286,
0.012400615,
-0.0337172039,
-0.05510341,
0.0897719637,
-0.0137675395,
-0.0058332016,
0.0021905492,
0.0016586193,
-0.042311348,
0.0064461119,
-0.0771253109,
-0.0502724349,
0.0139035303,
-0.0332126431,
-0.0666710809,
-0.006014612,
0.010088277,
-0.0460111164,
0.0017406342,
0.0157999862,
0.0093873804,
0.0625578538,
0.0657052398,
0.0543999486,
-0.0312544703,
-0.004008546,
0.0011359551,
0.0160139203,
0.0024583507,
-0.0194802955,
-0.0295138191,
0.0431959145,
0.0501824692,
0.0800805017,
0.0162187386,
0.001908005,
-0.0182529334,
-0.008661516,
0.0359681547,
0.0268361624,
0.0532860979,
-0.0262407288,
0.0151857492,
0.0023987021,
-0.0301394388,
-0.0017187792,
0.0287406631,
-0.0176606271,
0.0086515527,
0.020223964,
0.0267372616,
-0.0332867019,
-0.000172138,
0.0156332236,
-0.0248585884,
0.0189931132,
0.05547278,
0.0136044687,
0.042590946,
-0.008546087,
-0.0391991399,
-0.0069762315,
0.0175059773,
0.022062486,
0.0509090945,
-0.0099514611,
0.0085057067,
0.0117046032,
0.0378268138,
-0.0627910346,
0.0260524545,
0.019165853,
-0.0105583528,
-0.000719782,
-0.0151060754,
0.0146352137,
0.0290390477,
0.0142964674,
0.008967692,
0.0123225516,
-0.0368304513,
0.0052611376,
0.0419230983,
0.0646723732,
0.0338036604,
-0.0005771987,
0.011769033,
-0.0534015335,
0.0544173531,
0.0296241939,
-0.0421833992,
-0.0229218919,
-0.0226539429,
2.629e-7,
0.0695225522,
0.0620805733,
0.0771347061,
0.00118615,
-0.0030203783,
0.0115489466,
0.0645221621,
-0.0183526576,
-0.000044622,
0.0487868153,
0.0503278747,
-0.0296235736,
0.0248985924,
-0.0406323895,
-0.0810231715,
0.0169073418,
-0.0567854941,
-0.0236771181,
-0.0201908574,
-0.0235083178,
0.0261031222,
0.071624659,
-0.0022431982,
-0.0204504207,
-0.0238318127,
-0.0139629142,
0.0016089107,
-0.0543831028,
-0.0101302126,
0.0374359637,
0.0321133323,
-0.016747091,
0.0363595299,
-0.0092405342,
-0.0388021581,
-0.0070449295,
-0.0137674492,
0.0996645838,
-0.0165008996,
0.0582134761,
-0.0022640387,
-0.0657557696,
-0.0218403693,
-0.0349506028,
0.0661026761,
-0.069230698,
0.0564972758,
0.0040702117,
-0.0516195223,
0.0344170481,
0.0004576385,
-0.0278604645,
-0.061761044,
0.0508943982,
0.042842295,
0.017068712,
-0.0357351489,
-0.0912874788,
-0.0376473665,
0.0248309337,
-0.0094019305,
0.032516893,
-0.0238206703,
-0.0147226034,
0.0367174558,
-0.0283604283,
0.0055095037,
2.488836077e-34,
0.03549226,
-0.0105199041,
0.0182920396,
0.0169926882,
0.0276117157,
-0.0386457145,
-0.0072226827,
0.0282973219,
-0.0090127783,
-0.0688015074,
-0.0138045512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02888v1 | Findings of the TSAR-2022 Shared Task on Multilingual Lexical Simplification | 2023-02-06T15:53:51 | 2023-02-06T15:53:51 | Horacio Saggion, Sanja Štajner, Daniel Ferrés, Kim Cheng Sheang, Matthew Shardlow, Kai North, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We report findings of the TSAR-2022 shared task on multilingual lexical
simplification, organized as part of the Workshop on Text Simplification,
Accessibility, and Readability TSAR-2022 held in conjunction with EMNLP 2022.
The task called the Natural Language Processing research community to
contribute with methods to advance the state of the art in multilingual lexical
simplification for English, Portuguese, and Spanish. A total of 14 teams
submitted the results of their lexical simplification systems for the provided
test data. Results of the shared task indicate new benchmarks in Lexical
Simplification with English lexical simplification quantitative results
noticeably higher than those obtained for Spanish and (Brazilian) Portuguese. | [
-0.0293161236,
0.0100436332,
-0.0455255173,
0.0428063758,
-0.0523185506,
-0.0057968441,
0.0019866431,
0.0227298308,
-0.0134115024,
-0.0041703121,
-0.0102187553,
0.0270121247,
0.0563233979,
-0.0400223248,
0.0480282307,
-0.0914022177,
0.0594324246,
-0.0156366564,
-0.0693687722,
0.0051037259,
0.0101200147,
0.0257443469,
-0.0046041333,
0.0064898361,
0.0456330404,
0.0011383309,
0.0677569807,
-0.0172216333,
-0.009119194,
0.0052479622,
-0.0048152646,
0.052933909,
-0.0757169127,
0.011176656,
0.0000021699,
-0.0529144555,
-0.0446034484,
-0.0064948378,
0.0488654301,
0.0411063284,
0.0906167179,
-0.0312945992,
-0.0109609887,
0.0158835202,
-0.0139487935,
-0.0347337797,
0.0239684414,
0.0124253863,
-0.0001361688,
0.0174066033,
-0.0296668876,
-0.0471587107,
-0.0446991846,
-0.0029199328,
-0.0126359044,
-0.0124050202,
-0.0024590457,
0.0123212878,
-0.0114311846,
-0.0270879045,
-0.0182245094,
0.0685171112,
-0.015096698,
-0.0213002097,
-0.0051232716,
0.005512815,
-0.0283427723,
-0.0269286744,
0.0260253996,
0.0363155007,
-0.0048215217,
-0.0527183898,
0.0006005671,
0.010341675,
-0.0064328667,
0.0049642678,
-0.0443652421,
-0.0275480133,
0.0164002012,
0.0042846934,
-0.0069446252,
-0.013894855,
0.0271243416,
0.0438978374,
0.0342731699,
0.0571344644,
0.0647381917,
-0.0193475485,
0.0071380008,
-0.0115344329,
0.0426430553,
-0.0649263039,
0.0796755701,
-0.0026776255,
-0.0059654601,
0.0211418457,
-0.034602534,
-0.0713695288,
0.0403843708,
-0.0602447391,
-0.0003765021,
0.0156576484,
-0.0019992045,
0.0133329351,
-0.0634458959,
0.0389973894,
0.0028380151,
-0.0257821344,
-0.0488804877,
0.0059351418,
0.0141869085,
0.0265860371,
-0.0456552804,
0.0124265086,
-0.0431669094,
0.0248807613,
-0.0625325888,
-0.0269860085,
0.0363257267,
-0.0568323918,
-0.0280779302,
-0.016048966,
0.006459868,
-0.0476141982,
0.0086386101,
0.0565971509,
-0.0698171183,
0.0170204341,
-0.0474502258,
-0.0528317392,
0.0138499048,
0.0254438557,
0.027584726,
-0.0016430308,
-0.0026728541,
-0.0263646469,
-0.0569339246,
-0.0084311422,
-0.0073734326,
-0.0408211574,
0.0246749148,
-0.015184748,
-0.0444212109,
-0.0767163336,
0.0116594965,
-0.0224028863,
0.0423571542,
-0.040912047,
-0.0162979979,
-0.0010918659,
-0.0295748115,
0.0559705086,
-0.0456666686,
0.0107507473,
0.0241792351,
0.0116901677,
0.0076470459,
0.0427225046,
-0.0048308047,
-0.0373884365,
0.0928946659,
-0.0334528312,
0.0144782038,
0.0422841311,
-0.0145798409,
0.0017811042,
0.0349674784,
-0.0434428565,
-0.0440577902,
0.0234113801,
0.0552371368,
0.0752098262,
-0.0513338745,
0.0062036365,
0.0334566273,
0.0464371555,
0.0240252595,
0.030749809,
0.0254379082,
-0.0163250752,
0.0358796827,
0.0285165515,
0.0268403143,
-0.0666544139,
-0.0280757584,
0.0434821807,
0.018773919,
0.0482006073,
-0.0063523981,
-0.0223898813,
0.0185380559,
-0.0078714425,
0.0652295873,
-0.0422570147,
0.0165480543,
0.0202912465,
-0.067878522,
0.0023891244,
-0.0025113754,
-0.0718940347,
0.0499448329,
-0.038040556,
-0.038123887,
0.0449698046,
0.0506967977,
0.0048743421,
-0.0453848243,
0.0254665352,
0.0096794367,
0.0139711648,
0.01098652,
-0.0146906115,
0.0284257848,
-0.0842518508,
0.0229916982,
0.0424118116,
-0.0015317333,
0.008933288,
0.0076450352,
0.0062180348,
0.0326594412,
-0.057978645,
-0.0283510741,
0.0433778428,
-0.0291927755,
0.0054598148,
0.0072630001,
0.013363542,
-0.0196351092,
0.0276509151,
0.0129000712,
0.0046230364,
-0.0100620165,
-0.0296816286,
0.0339691378,
0.0138083212,
-0.000741759,
-0.0221177507,
0.0447673462,
-0.0597596802,
-0.0048177224,
0.0391624123,
0.0214769058,
-0.0054872236,
-0.000919076,
-0.0318927392,
-0.0012120787,
-0.0179531034,
0.0625385195,
-0.0279425643,
0.0398927592,
-0.0263237134,
-0.0003039094,
0.0192943346,
0.0428085178,
0.0206787623,
-0.0647901222,
0.0209038518,
-0.0121795516,
0.0273410417,
-0.0173461419,
-0.0371722504,
-0.0360135995,
0.0337522067,
0.025969347,
-0.0349728912,
0.027082596,
-0.0636582896,
-0.0186146982,
-0.0022499196,
0.0540600754,
0.0455068611,
0.0494199991,
-0.0083558718,
0.0025767679,
0.0286577959,
-0.0134984311,
0.0238914136,
0.0329877324,
0.0556974337,
-0.0335679315,
-0.0441383086,
-0.0580452196,
-0.0082188491,
0.0459988862,
0.0254605543,
0.0018755858,
-0.059975531,
-0.0355278552,
0.0133295925,
-0.0091853738,
-0.0233034454,
0.0513166077,
-0.0312954225,
-0.0479265004,
0.0357917473,
0.0763983652,
0.0436022542,
-0.0151821328,
-0.009316816,
0.0368966497,
-0.0015459921,
-0.0025601287,
-0.034822464,
0.0367224701,
0.0139594944,
-0.0532027669,
-0.0749426857,
0.0590982214,
0.0207589939,
-0.023325976,
-0.0027699836,
-0.0070598805,
-0.0469654575,
-0.0538813174,
-0.07366357,
-0.0184927508,
-0.0128062256,
-0.0261432007,
0.0321319178,
-0.0054130098,
-0.0052025318,
0.0466093756,
0.0114372578,
-0.0059544938,
-0.0978441238,
-0.009538753,
-0.0204452164,
-0.0003953254,
-0.0191294961,
0.0353479125,
-0.009520812,
-0.0366994329,
-0.0152803045,
-0.0532394983,
0.0261297394,
-0.0048861806,
0.0367836133,
-0.073895447,
-0.0065983557,
-0.0125567354,
-0.0459586345,
0.0336914808,
-0.0274477471,
0.0041720276,
-0.0139798736,
0.0616711043,
0.0029226723,
-0.0258018002,
-0.0056360969,
0.0130412588,
0.0716817901,
0.0259761419,
-0.006838568,
0.0155760348,
0.0469022207,
-0.0018976828,
-0.0194408223,
0.0221507717,
0.0056553455,
0.0074208598,
0.0265258923,
0.0403919071,
-0.0553269461,
0.0418945104,
-0.0162877031,
0.0484717153,
-0.0723550469,
-0.0470297337,
-0.0115531394,
0.016311964,
-0.0285243317,
0.03643848,
0.0655265599,
0.0206496734,
-0.0100443512,
0.0094768964,
-0.0050488198,
0.0080043357,
-0.0348406993,
0.0087156342,
-0.0791405141,
0.0059344098,
0.0387040749,
-0.0241251737,
-0.0049734516,
-0.0081834188,
-0.0097523676,
-0.0620287247,
0.0168668963,
-0.0113715036,
-0.0524867922,
-0.0559922941,
-0.0500091501,
-0.0033913988,
-0.0065637422,
0.0001524217,
0.0446915478,
-0.0346468464,
0.0139504271,
-0.0373625793,
-0.0667695329,
-0.0559173636,
-0.0513007492,
-0.0218316875,
0.0071949498,
0.0019986741,
0.049996525,
0.0109078921,
0.0023073112,
0.0411385857,
-0.0147275599,
0.007403635,
-0.0352022871,
0.0049416642,
0.0751800761,
-0.001489523,
-0.0392897539,
0.0255375132,
0.0265894551,
-0.0090035833,
0.0406907275,
0.022016624,
0.056219887,
-0.0313913077,
0.0170088187,
0.0063414499,
-0.023182394,
0.0268942676,
0.0210396294,
0.0468637347,
-0.0056061703,
-0.0030418648,
-0.0074278456,
-0.0631067306,
-0.0598909818,
0.0071076937,
-0.0882578343,
-0.0973711461,
-0.0693543777,
-0.0783812255,
0.0277045853,
-0.0112513779,
0.0105203567,
0.0160887558,
-0.0064064953,
0.0227402952,
0.0020249912,
-0.024048645,
0.0028948644,
0.0426129475,
-0.0254989155,
0.0321775414,
-0.0299545079,
0.0361757651,
0.0021410105,
0.0462896228,
-0.0314760245,
-0.0329744667,
0.0034550445,
0.0256551486,
0.0244296305,
0.0093461378,
-0.0135410205,
-0.0720514283,
0.0045707896,
0.0114861149,
-0.0260370821,
0.083301045,
0.0087625682,
-0.0163907968,
0.0101580732,
0.0365494266,
0.0112659801,
0.0167709552,
-0.0331897289,
0.035658665,
-0.0089529883,
-0.0149994651,
-0.0043826015,
0.0463206954,
0.0183596034,
-0.0334501155,
0.0114139114,
-0.0202042889,
0.0060364311,
-0.0777636617,
0.0333037712,
0.0062906304,
0.0527479127,
0.030904118,
0.0286825132,
-0.0444424674,
0.0389208645,
-0.0158418827,
-0.0669189617,
0.0028572527,
0.0314876214,
0.0115280589,
-0.004483162,
0.0066018472,
0.0041668173,
-0.0025639113,
0.0007714148,
-0.0567282513,
0.0046642958,
-0.0351546593,
-0.0408088267,
-0.0167186577,
0.0132218208,
-0.0784049705,
0.0287940931,
0.0273026153,
-0.0094596809,
0.0196975898,
0.0390644409,
0.0530008636,
0.0142274424,
0.1275422573,
-0.0174566265,
-0.0371397473,
-0.0076348949,
-0.0039057045,
0.0020338185,
0.0132547291,
-0.0323769413,
-0.0159029216,
-0.0060666292,
0.0089376681,
0.0920423344,
-0.0592110828,
0.0416986458,
0.0065694256,
-0.0135249756,
-0.0086037712,
-0.0360123925,
-0.0260755122,
0.0234180093,
-0.0313248597,
-0.0544859096,
-0.0461801104,
-0.0372231118,
0.0012280992,
0.0014276728,
0.0008056499,
-0.0137244761,
0.0112967053,
0.0659195334,
0.0161678158,
-0.0374113917,
-0.0093909176,
-0.0205671228,
-0.0366624631,
-0.0388992541,
-0.015043661,
-6.22867714e-33,
0.0287473779,
0.0233319327,
0.006444646,
-0.0465461463,
-0.0570024587,
0.0335792601,
-0.0610569715,
-0.0161947664,
-0.0148957232,
0.0416247621,
-0.0244275294,
0.0089176651,
0.0433877297,
-0.0177152939,
0.0150728766,
0.0620437451,
0.0613175668,
0.006423044,
-0.0037075065,
-0.0127248662,
-0.0260349922,
0.0097218389,
0.0723597482,
-0.0769497827,
0.0184823107,
0.0343920738,
-0.0543323644,
0.0087499619,
0.0593071654,
0.029339809,
-0.018319007,
0.0129974335,
0.0278390143,
-0.0305655152,
-0.0306849331,
-0.0005648664,
-0.0665412769,
-0.0363088734,
0.1135504991,
0.0193694308,
-0.0544166751,
-0.0648524761,
0.069998242,
-0.0067154639,
-0.0135075999,
0.0265250858,
0.0067613339,
-0.0478733368,
-0.0105515486,
-0.0245370492,
-0.0877282768,
0.0550587475,
-0.0217528511,
0.0135578802,
0.0383095741,
0.0497856848,
-0.059783753,
-0.0380499847,
-0.0026740818,
0.0547683537,
0.0167868529,
0.0533563495,
0.0611998104,
-0.0205010045,
0.0010377329,
0.0112301437,
0.0355682634,
-0.0057274587,
0.0046377978,
0.0161733944,
0.050333146,
0.0109652439,
0.0504268967,
0.0667357966,
0.0188318305,
-0.0130147031,
-0.0139687303,
0.0485786237,
0.0221059676,
0.0140518639,
-0.0391861722,
0.012053051,
-0.0106084859,
-0.0270422809,
-0.0223130975,
0.0188442897,
-0.0019307684,
-0.0323518515,
0.0032826071,
-0.0212722532,
-0.0264680665,
0.0334348381,
0.0001467895,
0.01241636,
-0.0489086471,
0.0040306915,
0.019727923,
0.0542142317,
-0.0061960141,
-0.0066030389,
-0.0061375322,
0.0205669589,
-0.0181831066,
0.0410831906,
0.0033475058,
-0.0248908196,
-0.0129002752,
-0.013552364,
-0.0737661421,
0.0190583318,
0.0569293015,
-0.0228173528,
0.0315016359,
-0.0216467772,
0.0159872957,
0.019303415,
0.0111961188,
0.0275540762,
0.0594452992,
-0.0257866178,
-0.0045767003,
-0.0059274477,
0.0549946167,
0.0413423032,
-0.0013701831,
0.0185776688,
-0.0459896512,
-0.0002799785,
0.0543944649,
-0.0067254128,
-0.0288321972,
-0.0549981669,
2.737e-7,
0.0788787827,
0.0557364039,
0.0444286801,
-0.0021463188,
-0.0209643301,
-0.0178254452,
0.0430331901,
-0.0243821964,
-0.048658669,
0.0738177299,
0.0457394533,
-0.0208436139,
0.0185952894,
0.0025929713,
-0.0375059545,
0.00451324,
-0.0101815294,
-0.044308804,
-0.0537115857,
-0.034887597,
0.0155853983,
0.0376174487,
0.0002277347,
0.001169593,
-0.0334254429,
-0.0397544876,
-0.0188456159,
-0.0588457435,
-0.0000497833,
0.0308633819,
0.051507052,
-0.0328549892,
0.0278991554,
-0.0088791857,
-0.0225419831,
-0.0279161613,
0.0208756104,
0.0500565171,
-0.0217181891,
0.0978123397,
0.0156145934,
-0.0792032182,
-0.0414099097,
-0.0422692187,
0.0635065809,
0.0092816884,
0.0147044817,
-0.0029252737,
-0.0225920025,
0.0386292748,
0.0563316979,
-0.0240949821,
-0.0764172524,
0.0568016991,
0.0342569537,
0.0169514176,
-0.0461839698,
-0.0545105487,
-0.0435002446,
0.0373672917,
0.0208704043,
0.0221650675,
-0.0094449958,
0.0202874877,
0.0280912276,
-0.023595361,
0.0143405171,
2.292155898e-34,
0.0287407748,
-0.0015250297,
0.0296718143,
0.0081480881,
0.037861675,
-0.0501774438,
-0.0282728355,
0.0505447574,
-0.0194566436,
-0.0535017326,
0.0111781517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02852v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02852v1 | Guide the Learner: Controlling Product of Experts Debiasing Method Based on Token Attribution Similarities | 2023-02-06T15:21:41 | 2023-02-06T15:21:41 | Ali Modarressi, Hossein Amirkhani, Mohammad Taher Pilehvar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Several proposals have been put forward in recent years for improving
out-of-distribution (OOD) performance through mitigating dataset biases. A
popular workaround is to train a robust model by re-weighting training examples
based on a secondary biased model. Here, the underlying assumption is that the
biased model resorts to shortcut features. Hence, those training examples that
are correctly predicted by the biased model are flagged as being biased and are
down-weighted during the training of the main model. However, assessing the
importance of an instance merely based on the predictions of the biased model
may be too naive. It is possible that the prediction of the main model can be
derived from another decision-making process that is distinct from the behavior
of the biased model. To circumvent this, we introduce a fine-tuning strategy
that incorporates the similarity between the main and biased model attribution
scores in a Product of Experts (PoE) loss function to further improve OOD
performance. With experiments conducted on natural language inference and fact
verification benchmarks, we show that our method improves OOD results while
maintaining in-distribution (ID) performance. | [
0.0223223828,
0.0490639433,
0.0194550287,
0.0173484571,
-0.0411912911,
0.0192707181,
0.0423420444,
-0.0318597108,
-0.0217127148,
-0.0513617992,
-0.014170466,
0.0255387034,
0.0219419934,
0.0242430344,
0.0300922785,
-0.0468574353,
0.0149508817,
0.0193724241,
0.0569906309,
-0.0265628677,
-0.0033478546,
0.0072312835,
-0.0162924398,
0.031266883,
-0.0075400248,
-0.0075418139,
0.0567131117,
0.0435133316,
0.0700976327,
0.0023525578,
0.0237828232,
0.0265614633,
-0.0024773818,
0.0074722753,
0.000002082,
-0.038846191,
-0.0247489046,
0.0308307093,
-0.0610897057,
-0.0163839869,
0.0274068136,
0.0361697078,
0.0292615891,
0.0231627114,
0.0052093132,
-0.0386727527,
0.0698895529,
0.0775886253,
0.0020094065,
0.0725860894,
-0.0153974686,
0.0144064566,
-0.0016426867,
-0.0255638454,
-0.0148174968,
-0.0034068555,
0.0208034776,
-0.0051542288,
-0.0767623261,
-0.0197966192,
0.0021736003,
0.0134218819,
0.0327864774,
0.063031204,
0.0410323478,
0.0419695713,
-0.0131945796,
0.0085085211,
-0.0033008612,
0.076297313,
-0.0871178582,
-0.0437514968,
-0.0155744348,
-0.0399486944,
0.0598995164,
0.0349958725,
-0.0453945287,
-0.0047065327,
-0.0079874666,
0.0284751076,
-0.0013392288,
0.0332616083,
0.0391801819,
0.0247427411,
-0.0291462559,
0.0148817059,
-0.0088524297,
0.0028632034,
0.0146382554,
0.0149877872,
-0.075231865,
-0.0437141396,
-0.0051140464,
-0.0344386511,
0.0297545269,
-0.0082854852,
-0.0262408759,
0.0009209235,
-0.0223537963,
-0.0357720107,
-0.0014765933,
0.0034984474,
-0.0519260317,
0.0376548953,
-0.0297606066,
-0.0006900452,
0.01412722,
0.0327947177,
-0.0026482255,
0.0075847195,
-0.0620601662,
-0.004192702,
0.0076863617,
0.0627646074,
0.0201780684,
-0.0004810845,
-0.0331088454,
-0.0332591236,
-0.057418026,
-0.0342125967,
0.0141192526,
0.0739081502,
-0.0165204257,
-0.0094152149,
-0.032080397,
0.0713215992,
-0.0332217589,
0.0530417077,
-0.0188996773,
-0.0658175349,
-0.0221959595,
0.0515709743,
-0.0148743521,
-0.0027882715,
0.0295306854,
0.0389486514,
0.0204675887,
-0.0378403254,
-0.0334531777,
-0.0400064439,
-0.0223821271,
-0.0873668492,
-0.0078644017,
-0.0751563534,
0.001443478,
0.0091171013,
-0.0003435877,
-0.0639988109,
-0.0279898457,
0.0019012431,
-0.0425103083,
0.0348567776,
0.019256698,
-0.0104115875,
0.0220489986,
-0.0078893369,
-0.0330683589,
0.0644294322,
-0.0118251359,
0.0279177893,
0.0093537718,
0.0600408763,
0.0339168832,
0.0004574368,
0.0417529754,
0.0067749242,
-0.0293444674,
0.0083759865,
0.0032312935,
-0.0149896462,
0.0731182024,
-0.0051747649,
-0.0583656989,
-0.0059435694,
0.0601669997,
-0.0476791188,
0.0023940953,
-0.0015143427,
-0.0000542299,
0.0123948725,
-0.0120674558,
0.0106912591,
-0.0794570968,
0.0403015055,
-0.0093051009,
-0.0179089699,
-0.0052330857,
0.0376491062,
-0.0276029035,
-0.0278070103,
0.0329941213,
-0.0018811149,
-0.0455198847,
0.0755816475,
0.0499472283,
-0.0002725834,
0.0019903118,
0.084697932,
0.0415099487,
-0.001784311,
-0.0099769039,
-0.0686934143,
-0.0170344226,
0.0076899035,
0.0257156063,
-0.0177729074,
0.0063298214,
-0.0232681576,
-0.0003852644,
-0.0152799953,
0.0158035457,
-0.0107691931,
0.0228720866,
-0.0373531915,
-0.0651860908,
-0.0382646807,
0.0319735706,
0.0355660282,
0.0033678908,
0.0249965601,
0.0321483836,
-0.1011948287,
-0.013811551,
0.0177263394,
0.0464123003,
-0.0390936397,
0.0206702221,
0.0230493192,
0.0173075497,
0.0085662454,
-0.0248023067,
-0.014848832,
-0.0033937157,
0.0061647035,
-0.0138598122,
0.0087733185,
-0.0412827991,
-0.0632159337,
0.0163349696,
-0.0953146145,
-0.0359532461,
0.0104165673,
-0.0581354722,
-0.0117426235,
0.0198475383,
-0.0288844611,
0.0092341462,
-0.0346359722,
-0.017933419,
-0.0308876466,
0.0045526437,
-0.0235382356,
0.1120433137,
-0.0149790524,
-0.016286144,
-0.0027276503,
-0.0276433378,
0.0579461642,
-0.010802228,
0.016060479,
-0.0272814985,
-0.0102476934,
-0.0182164218,
0.0217419099,
-0.0258083567,
-0.0172298681,
-0.0221466366,
-0.0645329654,
-0.00969138,
-0.0261401255,
0.0136842085,
0.004160862,
0.0175389387,
-0.0132419653,
-0.0274615791,
-0.0385204554,
-0.0928917155,
-0.0231875423,
0.0120147839,
-0.0089104753,
-0.0191235449,
-0.0073042773,
0.0275585111,
0.0001104485,
-0.0198993105,
0.0740188956,
0.0085479422,
-0.0051874053,
-0.0580277704,
-0.0063327816,
-0.0479090288,
-0.00373141,
-0.0162226614,
0.022150524,
-0.0413696133,
0.0372257344,
0.0355202369,
0.0924207941,
-0.0554967858,
-0.0111643681,
0.0681920499,
0.020209698,
-0.061719276,
-0.0055364543,
-0.0118675167,
0.0295652207,
-0.0030734518,
-0.0202980991,
-0.0345712043,
-0.0261962712,
0.0310349334,
-0.0318223499,
-0.0214321986,
0.0226539597,
-0.0002575682,
-0.0440355316,
0.00479268,
-0.0348439291,
0.0210820716,
0.0058009038,
-0.0276540164,
-0.0533347353,
0.0826198608,
0.0138852345,
0.0379555561,
-0.0610837303,
0.0087076947,
-0.0287213456,
0.0106739867,
0.0017699739,
0.0079203928,
-0.000917964,
-0.0111249192,
-0.0573790558,
-0.0215381291,
0.0510368198,
-0.0004915114,
0.0147615559,
-0.0256736204,
0.003997176,
0.0092284502,
-0.0229302365,
0.0006831724,
-0.0435193628,
-0.0061836108,
0.0159515608,
-0.0221145786,
-0.0032806459,
-0.079925932,
-0.0198229756,
0.018686967,
0.0175406095,
-0.0419352613,
0.0041453075,
0.036581859,
0.01962859,
0.0108923912,
-0.0263020303,
0.0119564291,
-0.0282669365,
-0.039217405,
0.0235246848,
0.0355579108,
0.0021334083,
-0.0197492223,
0.0041842749,
-0.0072586522,
-0.0085894568,
-0.0054251067,
0.0365580879,
0.0284586232,
-0.0180819165,
0.0158321559,
0.0714835376,
-0.0055385488,
-0.0629266575,
0.0085252011,
0.0006848113,
0.0481404848,
0.039333567,
-0.0220876802,
-0.0706583932,
-0.0586328544,
-0.001468799,
0.0256364923,
-0.0168743208,
-0.0253788549,
0.0214396678,
-0.1016515419,
0.0296822861,
-0.0110176941,
-0.0063142166,
-0.072346963,
-0.0704196393,
0.0314062722,
-0.0672112554,
-0.0098305773,
-0.0346586555,
0.0284142289,
0.0170023181,
0.0460151508,
0.0140382983,
-0.0772372186,
0.0194846783,
-0.0525254384,
0.0158210546,
0.0495799966,
-0.0058385413,
-0.0005631613,
0.0026535382,
-0.0065519377,
-0.0025649089,
0.0173216518,
0.0114102326,
0.1041406915,
-0.0427628271,
0.0186910573,
-0.0255117286,
0.0616998076,
0.0115562761,
0.018459918,
-0.0175061487,
0.0549816601,
0.0096228793,
-0.0355820581,
-0.0317287184,
-0.0450997837,
0.0368696675,
0.0779109299,
0.0074609378,
0.0083853742,
-0.0371975265,
-0.0103580682,
-0.0350941345,
0.0528291613,
0.0145690078,
0.0618720204,
0.0313605443,
-0.110507071,
-0.0376792625,
0.0075081252,
0.0019474587,
0.071850583,
-0.0141016468,
-0.0070629101,
-0.037006665,
0.023290934,
-0.0192296654,
0.031756755,
-0.0242433026,
0.0234574433,
-0.0002254036,
0.0233071987,
0.0258930158,
-0.0329509042,
-0.044531893,
0.0284928493,
-0.0525241792,
-0.0647745132,
0.0172276422,
0.0534934513,
0.0269068927,
0.0812931955,
-0.012581978,
-0.0299804378,
0.1150861308,
0.0917213857,
-0.0307343118,
-0.0147690056,
0.0349599794,
-0.060350053,
0.0203612205,
0.0154422075,
-0.0286180601,
0.0226613116,
0.0628013834,
-0.0234401505,
0.0036207945,
-0.0263247993,
-0.0002652096,
-0.0134440539,
0.0542112365,
-0.0224949121,
-0.0471811406,
-0.0272129606,
0.0362133831,
0.0054718959,
-0.0324197486,
-0.0080688894,
0.0369519591,
0.0494851395,
0.051510524,
-0.0149822272,
0.011449324,
0.0126304645,
0.0145066576,
0.0142728779,
0.0258564595,
-0.0003672289,
0.0338591374,
-0.0292311031,
-0.0196181759,
-0.0223970599,
-0.0198529419,
0.0142140472,
0.0039799474,
-0.0035602516,
-0.0010778544,
0.0484835282,
0.0104360003,
-0.0249172822,
-0.0393468551,
-0.0734234676,
0.0050006993,
-0.0457392894,
0.0286988989,
0.0103133069,
-0.0406218395,
0.0057562124,
-0.0033439496,
-0.0205220859,
-0.0072245738,
-0.0028380994,
-0.005171156,
0.0132591901,
0.003909884,
0.0030120572,
-0.0097967964,
0.010607142,
0.0752074271,
0.0354540385,
0.0592914,
-0.0422464125,
-0.0273802131,
-0.0317954905,
-0.018819306,
0.0168083049,
0.0199619029,
-0.0099012824,
0.0242067371,
-0.0490331575,
-0.0664037168,
-0.0204172656,
-0.010313266,
0.0556586944,
-0.0020656516,
0.0610059686,
0.0715186894,
-0.0248233639,
-0.0570200272,
0.0178467389,
-0.0390591845,
0.0248515103,
-0.0101038879,
-0.0178913493,
-6.409283031e-33,
0.0257239677,
-0.0210416839,
-0.0383994654,
-0.0236477125,
0.0068127075,
-0.0038172277,
-0.0004979579,
-0.0289919414,
-0.0443045162,
0.0403440818,
0.0192912612,
0.0309032071,
0.020793926,
0.0001950866,
-0.0066623855,
-0.0189794376,
0.0655180067,
0.0158263836,
-0.0278407615,
0.0414719209,
0.0077257673,
0.0045125359,
0.0746514574,
-0.0682926401,
0.0240543485,
0.0059016477,
-0.0361055098,
0.0136927487,
-0.0081406012,
0.0411515459,
0.0194109846,
0.0547679625,
0.0292193368,
-0.0447641946,
-0.0048775556,
-0.0179883689,
-0.0604746677,
-0.064439036,
-0.0020801318,
-0.0147495465,
0.0324140787,
-0.0026396178,
0.0421652608,
0.0418099016,
-0.0038786659,
-0.0598668121,
0.0689352676,
-0.0179561209,
-0.0171439555,
-0.0309390854,
-0.0283016618,
0.050869517,
-0.0178128481,
0.0001410029,
-0.0066518569,
0.0212700143,
0.0311267115,
-0.0065244664,
-0.0237701647,
-0.0140935164,
0.0165137276,
0.0040779146,
0.0324477851,
0.0143985944,
-0.0119842859,
0.0541377328,
0.0128310695,
0.0147623904,
-0.0349590927,
-0.0659161061,
0.0397159494,
0.0348897912,
0.0445495769,
0.0589609966,
0.0746855512,
0.0254399441,
-0.123491548,
0.0375675969,
0.0181334056,
0.0277077984,
0.0224659089,
-0.0034629635,
-0.0663480461,
-0.0335453525,
-0.0258839484,
-0.0370917693,
-0.0219354108,
-0.0329496376,
0.0049348339,
0.0321348161,
-0.026353227,
0.0325610079,
0.0092593385,
-0.0396175161,
-0.0227898471,
0.030563876,
0.0041547748,
0.0211485904,
0.0150191868,
0.008157243,
-0.0733690038,
-0.0057258699,
0.0295294151,
0.0453850403,
0.0289142597,
-0.0217576586,
0.0796440244,
0.0101576271,
-0.0624132901,
-0.0061821975,
-0.0044884994,
-0.0013812529,
0.0112859784,
0.054170344,
0.0226186067,
0.0321386941,
-0.0149700707,
-0.0191151556,
0.0120472973,
0.0181962624,
-0.0271225255,
0.0268386267,
-0.0034717093,
0.0069087236,
-0.0484454706,
-0.0028889012,
0.0050524706,
-0.0796340704,
-0.0117072575,
-0.0472756885,
-0.0394768044,
0.0074727815,
2.845e-7,
0.0148950014,
0.0252200272,
0.0100722192,
-0.0131812841,
-0.0189508647,
0.0473622642,
0.0205502342,
0.0330048203,
0.0205101725,
-0.0712184459,
0.0451779217,
0.0518974438,
0.0030267183,
0.0202098843,
-0.0964672863,
0.0473294705,
-0.0198143385,
-0.0000955132,
-0.0330679901,
-0.028697256,
0.0114668161,
0.0989833996,
0.0452798307,
-0.0223378558,
0.0211243741,
0.0006503243,
0.027034387,
0.0210479517,
0.0465536155,
-0.0016997213,
0.0866599977,
0.0183963999,
0.0274016261,
0.0818740055,
-0.0057569677,
0.0217010509,
0.0162019338,
0.0083755869,
-0.023195209,
-0.0156675875,
-0.0249019656,
0.0199968256,
0.0459995866,
-0.0638385639,
0.0496375673,
-0.0445044748,
-0.0510325395,
-0.0428650007,
-0.0585765727,
-0.0133952592,
0.039917022,
0.0185478013,
-0.0056498237,
0.0397428088,
0.0007053101,
0.0016493374,
-0.0169390254,
-0.0688003302,
-0.0423225649,
0.0045128451,
-0.0404482037,
-0.062559709,
0.0297875367,
0.010570325,
0.0518270321,
-0.0440765508,
0.030857563,
2.593951216e-34,
0.0403677672,
0.0216306392,
-0.0071006855,
-0.0298114829,
0.043821957,
0.0017803588,
-0.0261979997,
-0.0266562533,
0.0151945278,
-0.0136120152,
-0.0178250819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02813v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02813v2 | Migration Reframed? A multilingual analysis on the stance shift in Europe during the Ukrainian crisis | 2023-02-06T14:36:33 | 2023-05-19T16:44:59 | Sergej Wildemann, Claudia Niederée, Erick Elejalde | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The war in Ukraine seems to have positively changed the attitude toward the
critical societal topic of migration in Europe -- at least towards refugees
from Ukraine. We investigate whether this impression is substantiated by how
the topic is reflected in online news and social media, thus linking the
representation of the issue on the Web to its perception in society. For this
purpose, we combine and adapt leading-edge automatic text processing for a
novel multilingual stance detection approach. Starting from 5.5M Twitter posts
published by 565 European news outlets in one year, beginning September 2021,
plus replies, we perform a multilingual analysis of migration-related media
coverage and associated social media interaction for Europe and selected
European countries.
The results of our analysis show that there is actually a reframing of the
discussion illustrated by the terminology change, e.g., from "migrant" to
"refugee", often even accentuated with phrases such as "real refugees".
However, concerning a stance shift in public perception, the picture is more
diverse than expected. All analyzed cases show a noticeable temporal stance
shift around the start of the war in Ukraine. Still, there are apparent
national differences in the size and stability of this shift. | [
0.0096020689,
0.0238100775,
-0.0059768623,
0.0130524458,
-0.053315822,
0.019232139,
0.0182018708,
-0.036856398,
0.0046927207,
-0.0458607599,
0.0583076403,
-0.0288521238,
-0.0405261554,
-0.025918588,
-0.0101154102,
-0.0011954224,
0.0454141274,
0.0269304309,
0.0349211656,
-0.022369286,
0.0386248082,
0.0509483814,
-0.0057539595,
0.023787478,
-0.0040066768,
0.0270761959,
0.0059665185,
-0.0434533842,
0.0820927247,
-0.026089184,
-0.0025882006,
0.0359703489,
0.0085915281,
0.05368701,
0.0000014929,
-0.018265985,
-0.0438058972,
-0.0233726501,
0.0674294457,
-0.0689460933,
0.0296256728,
-0.0842891112,
-0.0040840255,
-0.0216339342,
-0.0464268252,
0.0099613657,
0.0310852099,
0.0250963848,
0.0907418802,
0.0783547908,
-0.0046852147,
-0.0602641813,
-0.0173927899,
0.0238096118,
-0.0397158414,
0.0229080804,
0.024343675,
-0.0775894597,
-0.0679571703,
0.0223835278,
0.0032784571,
0.0462911502,
0.0043805647,
-0.0102118421,
-0.039580401,
0.0032296968,
-0.0365347825,
-0.0521060862,
-0.0035723003,
0.028431816,
0.0000866647,
-0.0196992643,
0.0266304538,
-0.0314024687,
-0.0131764589,
0.0335534886,
0.0018814461,
0.0066189435,
-0.0391598009,
0.0415734462,
0.0249672625,
-0.0037016936,
0.0015473033,
0.0368052907,
-0.0314759463,
0.0814041495,
-0.0451701321,
-0.0052112178,
0.0296423901,
0.0254507456,
0.0194581728,
-0.0178600326,
0.0613321364,
0.0335705951,
-0.0404335037,
0.028810231,
0.0184997097,
-0.0419104435,
0.0071129724,
-0.0872168243,
-0.0331874155,
0.0148249501,
-0.0239764825,
0.067632474,
0.0000602973,
-0.0225456432,
-0.0205372665,
-0.0592615232,
0.0083529092,
-0.0053222883,
-0.0609557256,
0.0422002487,
-0.0113475071,
-0.0130696287,
0.0030724208,
0.0401840806,
-0.0055650938,
-0.005267289,
0.0001312019,
-0.008323878,
-0.0377522409,
-0.0395909213,
-0.0002512988,
0.0376889445,
-0.0442632511,
0.1101489663,
-0.0351326056,
-0.0207117666,
-0.0459248461,
-0.0104139037,
0.047983814,
-0.0131952632,
0.0192122366,
-0.0052756541,
0.0111407461,
0.013447064,
-0.0228801239,
0.0275585838,
-0.0003351564,
-0.0289522205,
-0.0096211731,
-0.0614248402,
0.0126370424,
-0.079399839,
0.0322978832,
0.0323887095,
0.0142793572,
-0.0415688716,
0.0141536612,
0.0357492343,
-0.0431905948,
0.0347308405,
0.0203744024,
0.0351691097,
0.011419653,
-0.0099150473,
0.0231741052,
0.0838336498,
-0.0505371392,
0.0131029021,
0.0578111075,
-0.0067458004,
0.0100185638,
0.0463810936,
-0.010505558,
0.0045351484,
0.0108290622,
0.031069383,
-0.0482012965,
-0.0339688845,
0.0134535059,
0.0064482982,
0.0209538043,
-0.0083859647,
0.0411999784,
0.0637798086,
-0.0371526405,
0.037882451,
-0.0046088756,
0.0446810722,
-0.0139206303,
0.026882112,
0.0324316882,
0.0096914973,
0.0303146057,
-0.0136203123,
0.0036659136,
0.0933017805,
0.000186347,
-0.0158917289,
0.0310981777,
0.0223643221,
0.0510808937,
-0.0398839191,
0.0022602123,
-0.036762841,
-0.0125481542,
0.0165534485,
0.0116226934,
-0.0621800795,
0.0070631485,
-0.0081387348,
-0.0034190328,
0.0014863104,
-0.0234517734,
-0.0361482576,
-0.0205992665,
-0.0683206171,
0.0590136386,
0.0467485152,
0.0259043984,
0.0150472,
-0.0227146428,
0.0032728368,
-0.0193039346,
0.049253311,
0.0071523022,
0.023917146,
-0.0066526029,
0.0185573138,
-0.0049078097,
0.0027734477,
-0.0030651488,
0.0112311002,
0.0442885086,
0.0299371853,
-0.0018557969,
0.0178081784,
-0.0310542602,
0.0591308996,
0.008198617,
-0.0285417717,
0.0413947105,
-0.004686262,
0.0169752873,
0.0201737043,
0.0169826318,
0.0369631723,
0.0205312837,
-0.0406013317,
-0.0798139796,
-0.0127637349,
-0.0436534397,
0.0322471932,
0.0599503629,
0.0110096959,
-0.0361295156,
-0.0115684615,
-0.0050291168,
-0.062914148,
-0.0077887676,
-0.0262415782,
0.0525838584,
-0.0090450682,
0.053450115,
-0.0236295629,
-0.0623742715,
0.0599385723,
0.0012442522,
-0.0171766989,
0.0218638182,
0.0064223893,
0.029017536,
0.0367723927,
-0.0291037522,
-0.0158822425,
0.0276222844,
-0.0614874475,
-0.0019913015,
-0.0352946855,
0.0317245536,
0.0650697649,
-0.0069686826,
-0.0117808832,
0.0099202935,
-0.0462673903,
-0.0509141162,
-0.0160311218,
0.0108346222,
0.0328378752,
-0.0466644168,
0.0467017405,
-0.0213639196,
0.0129595436,
-0.0456991158,
0.0060085841,
0.0060092225,
-0.0311762933,
-0.021027673,
-0.0240047742,
-0.0703152865,
-0.017243132,
-0.0187767595,
-0.0630610138,
0.0385864973,
0.0247607213,
0.0620942526,
0.0056188735,
0.0297457501,
0.0516560413,
0.0450610556,
0.0512147173,
-0.0212197956,
-0.0310256854,
-0.0502172001,
0.0198624507,
-0.0347899683,
-0.0400349014,
0.0245952196,
0.0213079583,
-0.0045508803,
-0.018349994,
-0.0170185957,
-0.0169805754,
-0.0734900609,
-0.0234588627,
-0.0287476517,
0.0392066576,
0.018776359,
0.0352590494,
-0.0025901555,
0.0168869831,
0.0033331478,
0.0379090533,
0.058160603,
-0.0536161475,
-0.0458682105,
-0.0236880109,
0.057479199,
0.0229919069,
0.017239647,
0.0114676831,
0.0070556803,
-0.0000795164,
-0.0875844359,
0.0386630483,
-0.0096750064,
0.0311795641,
-0.0456716269,
0.0085604712,
0.0198570881,
0.0029157053,
0.014388469,
-0.0791165605,
-0.0129067255,
-0.0054256232,
-0.01713554,
-0.0142683936,
0.0243186168,
0.0073826341,
0.0616995767,
-0.0021932896,
0.0211626794,
-0.0088479947,
-0.0143466499,
0.0472076535,
-0.0221906025,
-0.0110929171,
0.0287161153,
-0.0120721543,
-0.0313365795,
0.0522559658,
-0.0012775786,
0.008002134,
-0.0019824749,
-0.0357365981,
-0.0121479193,
-0.0355382226,
0.0037717053,
-0.0367734581,
0.0389124528,
-0.0429999754,
0.0229460392,
0.0206267349,
0.0420250297,
0.0020372355,
-0.0109085478,
0.0027250622,
-0.023863012,
0.0365262739,
0.0201462302,
-0.051676318,
0.0568008907,
-0.0146217449,
-0.0314149596,
-0.0812420771,
-0.0171673074,
-0.0206052177,
-0.0421124995,
0.0085902009,
-0.0149949174,
-0.045546107,
-0.0157189332,
-0.0675796866,
0.0329034999,
-0.0316021666,
-0.0574336685,
-0.0247616824,
0.0101838419,
0.0302159265,
-0.0064498903,
-0.0705819875,
-0.0186230633,
-0.0435618348,
-0.040266674,
0.0105712805,
-0.048284959,
0.0753371492,
-0.0124186389,
-0.0261227451,
0.0470380448,
-0.0141788954,
-0.0295347665,
-0.0321296006,
0.0293804314,
0.0079356534,
-0.0295487233,
-0.0099554881,
-0.0024904839,
-0.0215061028,
-0.0155158183,
-0.0111187445,
0.0567047335,
0.0042741299,
-0.0137097696,
0.0032656477,
0.0269864574,
0.0593444258,
0.0172040202,
-0.0015253519,
-0.0046777348,
0.0042853365,
-0.05637265,
0.038488131,
-0.0380389839,
-0.0308881868,
0.005089581,
-0.066967614,
-0.0687659383,
0.0005037287,
-0.013546668,
0.0061556129,
0.0336871073,
0.0030599288,
0.0037877699,
0.0666022971,
0.0031892988,
-0.0681561232,
0.0453625806,
0.0305264816,
0.0438872762,
0.0179341901,
-0.0225283578,
0.0170042887,
0.05293395,
-0.0389428735,
-0.0131604476,
-0.0555668063,
-0.0497157723,
0.0009132901,
-0.0529106259,
0.0164973792,
-0.0044348785,
0.013923211,
0.0050648134,
0.0051345499,
0.0339745618,
-0.0267996415,
-0.0057268282,
0.017464038,
0.0281233881,
-0.0206115376,
0.0336129367,
0.075186938,
0.0138928434,
0.0528146625,
-0.0448675156,
-0.0674744695,
0.0477745384,
-0.0099033294,
-0.0355137736,
0.037422426,
0.0023542023,
-0.0740466788,
-0.067102015,
-0.054137934,
0.0044084978,
-0.0300921891,
0.0255136024,
-0.0396256149,
0.0140048666,
0.0033564477,
-0.0489518791,
0.0798933059,
-0.0215960052,
0.0208967552,
-0.0406431369,
0.0247530509,
0.0245692693,
0.0221250374,
0.0087372549,
-0.0388510786,
0.0339157023,
0.0160984676,
0.0030179303,
-0.0108187133,
-0.0153702134,
-0.0033869345,
0.0054292306,
-0.0207841489,
0.0221882127,
0.0135980742,
-0.0285508521,
-0.0327981338,
-0.0187989362,
0.0385980904,
0.036770869,
-0.0232009534,
0.036775656,
0.04951974,
-0.0344274193,
-0.0079041477,
0.0105423843,
-0.0096625453,
-0.0358421616,
-0.0006121038,
-0.0207302477,
-0.0225214288,
0.0473018996,
-0.0164235421,
-0.0800110474,
0.0166713372,
0.0381314717,
-0.0672576874,
-0.0010968887,
-0.0078870105,
-0.0186964758,
-0.0325463563,
-0.0074580121,
-0.0025520409,
-0.0564300679,
-0.0273001771,
0.0074673635,
-0.0252260603,
-0.0207807198,
-0.0101037463,
-0.0147872753,
0.0863763615,
0.0137806879,
0.0524961464,
-0.0863180906,
0.0482520647,
-0.0393727012,
-0.0178667102,
-0.017911911,
-5.62495316e-33,
0.0343670323,
-0.0314093977,
-0.0357901193,
-0.058142744,
0.0014831657,
-0.0027746228,
-0.0139146792,
0.0081259273,
-0.0213618763,
0.0226993449,
0.0045979554,
0.0265047774,
0.021473458,
-0.0155371046,
-0.0163030941,
-0.0038999317,
0.0088793589,
-0.0191176124,
-0.0485652648,
-0.0064093363,
0.0511263758,
-0.0179791059,
0.0768421814,
-0.0567888319,
0.0568449907,
0.0182194076,
-0.0201327,
0.0009837565,
0.0701089203,
0.0124144247,
-0.0248163305,
0.0561470874,
0.0745263919,
-0.0588116124,
0.0299905427,
0.0809610412,
-0.0237246118,
-0.0253870189,
0.0184978545,
0.0183376446,
-0.0184461251,
-0.0289477166,
0.0103535205,
-0.0082345037,
-0.0276609845,
0.0568668284,
0.0315303095,
0.0196272526,
0.0567830466,
0.0089728208,
-0.0853800476,
0.0233273003,
-0.0572850294,
0.0439524502,
-0.013628142,
0.056951385,
0.0399000086,
0.0576491691,
-0.0785875022,
0.0231332686,
-0.0646757632,
-0.0025971546,
0.0184211023,
-0.0331944041,
0.0101722451,
0.0549199656,
-0.0063679349,
0.0300892014,
0.0051193647,
0.0134995645,
-0.0230061505,
-0.0264392272,
0.023166256,
0.0834788233,
-0.0103459498,
-0.0433122925,
-0.083016701,
-0.0051428704,
0.0428632498,
0.0142009156,
0.0108693643,
0.0075931731,
0.0255868807,
-0.0100740334,
-0.0317757241,
-0.0980124325,
-0.0157053713,
-0.0175943915,
-0.0315996036,
-0.0353653431,
-0.0220884606,
0.0199157111,
0.05719845,
-0.0003939655,
-0.0452341847,
-0.0291948467,
-0.0323321745,
0.0409056358,
0.0374532454,
0.0970089957,
-0.0447254181,
-0.0213228185,
-0.0302900001,
0.0457657203,
0.057627093,
-0.0020418612,
0.0382044129,
0.0084798401,
-0.0667922422,
0.003712533,
-0.0348382182,
0.0379793793,
-0.0309900455,
0.1070604175,
0.0247952193,
0.0173616055,
-0.0035720218,
0.0165020041,
0.05387583,
0.0030403456,
0.0141764805,
-0.0053674714,
-0.0600106195,
0.027362816,
-0.0071070837,
-0.0130789671,
-0.0221994258,
0.086662665,
0.0216424521,
-0.0215561762,
-0.0236248374,
-0.0106126061,
2.334e-7,
0.0673792362,
0.0416427404,
-0.0215980876,
-0.0219657216,
0.0485457964,
0.0169392917,
0.0078122634,
0.0273041073,
-0.01496928,
-0.0287188012,
-0.0308778733,
0.0128643131,
0.0233383179,
0.0323989615,
-0.0503587872,
-0.0048225834,
0.002315443,
0.0307274554,
-0.0646955296,
0.0678631216,
0.0315351859,
0.0684219226,
0.0174821354,
0.0294440649,
-0.0758880973,
0.0217703301,
0.0321281329,
-0.0265661255,
-0.060127221,
0.0246270448,
0.0146077154,
-0.0266353022,
-0.0037218365,
0.0067870547,
0.0125754504,
0.0169761777,
0.0333368443,
0.0162828248,
0.0248772353,
0.011579602,
-0.0005803232,
-0.0361089967,
0.0094718682,
-0.0820002928,
0.064420253,
-0.0541870706,
-0.0280626751,
-0.0934635848,
-0.0326619633,
-0.0056405864,
0.0696206987,
0.006736591,
-0.0857774243,
0.0484823547,
0.0024137064,
-0.0016414297,
0.0095941201,
-0.039927125,
-0.0322464742,
-0.0142041994,
-0.0236266516,
-0.0221097227,
0.0178334136,
-0.0186034534,
0.0264012665,
-0.0212036632,
0.0316284746,
1.263899447e-34,
0.0389128402,
0.011358805,
-0.025868874,
-0.0119719207,
0.0399995074,
0.0092358533,
-0.0253772996,
0.0105878823,
-0.0193191506,
0.0221124366,
0.0328838564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02780v1 | Coherence and Diversity through Noise: Self-Supervised Paraphrase Generation via Structure-Aware Denoising | 2023-02-06T13:50:57 | 2023-02-06T13:50:57 | Rishabh Gupta, Venktesh V., Mukesh Mohania, Vikram Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose SCANING, an unsupervised framework for paraphrasing
via controlled noise injection. We focus on the novel task of paraphrasing
algebraic word problems having practical applications in online pedagogy as a
means to reduce plagiarism as well as ensure understanding on the part of the
student instead of rote memorization. This task is more complex than
paraphrasing general-domain corpora due to the difficulty in preserving
critical information for solution consistency of the paraphrased word problem,
managing the increased length of the text and ensuring diversity in the
generated paraphrase. Existing approaches fail to demonstrate adequate
performance on at least one, if not all, of these facets, necessitating the
need for a more comprehensive solution. To this end, we model the noising
search space as a composition of contextual and syntactic aspects and sample
noising functions consisting of either one or both aspects. This allows for
learning a denoising function that operates over both aspects and produces
semantically equivalent and syntactically diverse outputs through grounded
noise injection. The denoising function serves as a foundation for learning a
paraphrasing function which operates solely in the input-paraphrase space
without carrying any direct dependency on noise. We demonstrate SCANING
considerably improves performance in terms of both semantic preservation and
producing diverse paraphrases through extensive automated and manual evaluation
across 4 datasets. | [
0.0189645831,
0.0332400985,
0.0193052106,
0.0450791717,
-0.0620554686,
-0.0400071479,
0.0066442392,
-0.0238862671,
-0.0258592274,
-0.0618767068,
0.0067097461,
0.0375417545,
-0.0115511073,
-0.0218647216,
0.023584269,
-0.0611100644,
0.021055581,
-0.0405400433,
-0.0207262654,
-0.0177916437,
-0.0239330344,
0.0086486563,
-0.0017796793,
-0.0035424531,
-0.0005047678,
-0.0519938767,
-0.0105506135,
0.0105513111,
-0.0003725164,
0.0298671499,
0.0125122853,
0.0116666509,
0.01307981,
0.0169277769,
0.0000019451,
-0.0672800615,
-0.0622365586,
0.0185377076,
-0.0108114323,
0.0314407796,
0.0390788913,
0.0241595153,
0.0407841057,
-0.0137120672,
-0.0285776891,
0.0129282624,
0.0174569339,
0.0022600917,
0.1078421921,
0.0323754922,
-0.0117830904,
-0.0597583614,
0.014305843,
0.0301292185,
0.0395037979,
-0.0206733104,
0.0182933249,
0.0274577085,
0.0203082971,
0.0233021658,
-0.0490279347,
0.0659273565,
0.0078266487,
-0.007837398,
0.0622858293,
0.0061519104,
-0.0025666063,
-0.0131776417,
0.0089346068,
0.0926517546,
-0.0288232099,
-0.0190032981,
0.0235348567,
-0.0082538351,
-0.0125318598,
0.0644993037,
-0.0332276598,
0.0479304083,
-0.0182783268,
0.0228709318,
-0.0173876546,
0.0280792322,
0.0003590919,
0.0444467291,
-0.0145968767,
-0.008306725,
0.0251351167,
-0.0378260911,
-0.0404687151,
0.0045054387,
-0.0141579788,
0.0114156008,
0.0249114484,
0.0543242134,
0.0074105137,
0.0224295873,
-0.0611310415,
-0.1055101156,
0.0028127297,
-0.0363293216,
0.0043499526,
0.0221103039,
0.0157142114,
0.0297473148,
-0.0492277294,
0.0346447937,
-0.027935937,
0.0378675647,
-0.0753869191,
-0.0180227086,
-0.0760370716,
0.0114721665,
-0.0594169982,
0.123405233,
-0.0025720645,
-0.0065842802,
-0.0566053391,
0.002776515,
0.015533451,
0.004817958,
-0.0216552783,
0.0402799621,
-0.0632075369,
-0.0075962064,
0.0353332199,
0.0194842964,
-0.0305821281,
-0.0133879688,
-0.0339644887,
-0.0307970438,
-0.0315703303,
0.0314473026,
0.0523927473,
-0.028509913,
0.008122867,
0.0656764209,
-0.0146734687,
0.0089746574,
-0.0165185239,
-0.0654108226,
-0.0301269814,
-0.0572101176,
-0.0126156267,
-0.0615094788,
-0.0036990116,
0.020083474,
0.0031439317,
-0.0655238703,
0.0236806516,
0.0429231562,
-0.0367228463,
0.0588413551,
0.0028851193,
-0.0381603464,
0.0304322913,
0.0203393437,
-0.0091492487,
0.044540409,
0.0605971366,
-0.0166521892,
0.046387352,
0.0108456369,
0.0021984628,
-0.0422759764,
0.0292206444,
0.0095220599,
-0.0017604136,
0.0080378335,
0.0306568351,
0.0233214144,
0.0137526868,
0.0873677284,
-0.0421550833,
-0.0183465574,
0.058163695,
0.0683629364,
-0.007393071,
0.0280035678,
0.0603400841,
0.0348164923,
0.0247142501,
0.0791289359,
-0.0024837307,
-0.0345667899,
-0.0266994238,
0.078426294,
0.0058415788,
0.0238476656,
0.0000834887,
-0.0777413249,
-0.0094291549,
-0.0097377859,
-0.006255683,
-0.006133189,
0.0386110954,
0.0393270738,
-0.0430838019,
0.0441254452,
-0.0329301544,
-0.0616094507,
0.0275868494,
-0.0034074378,
0.0514315926,
0.0257480387,
0.0775419846,
-0.0357642211,
-0.0140801249,
-0.0122225797,
0.0048505105,
0.0373366773,
-0.013360139,
-0.0217781048,
0.0357859246,
-0.0847062245,
-0.0305823628,
-0.0507659838,
-0.0096857138,
-0.0454074778,
0.029205827,
-0.0067075752,
0.0476965681,
-0.0367114805,
-0.0621624514,
0.0309706964,
-0.0201470926,
-0.0634290725,
0.0013075039,
0.0070049972,
-0.0039694454,
0.045185335,
-0.0026392736,
0.0525314175,
0.0008739139,
-0.0440767407,
-0.0076684025,
-0.0000327426,
-0.0909734741,
-0.0162017215,
0.0357126221,
-0.0924840644,
-0.0157959368,
-0.0179898608,
-0.0093642054,
-0.0566462837,
0.0594709553,
-0.0532344058,
-0.0067494456,
-0.0425035581,
0.0153701026,
-0.0084631555,
0.0016600949,
-0.0265124869,
0.0857824162,
0.0573192276,
0.0270976927,
0.0462505147,
0.0062472709,
0.0539336316,
0.0178001802,
-0.0111071141,
-0.0578836203,
0.0195004232,
0.0044522979,
0.0059597306,
-0.0107414303,
-0.0619115494,
-0.0066729803,
0.0157698877,
0.0048026722,
0.010245353,
-0.0185610689,
0.0695088357,
0.02770341,
0.0392901823,
-0.039118927,
0.0261673778,
0.0013191309,
-0.0135708945,
-0.0149584236,
0.0619015209,
0.0156437177,
-0.0091689099,
-0.0464754626,
0.0029425663,
-0.0240263883,
0.0358231403,
0.0384774581,
-0.032930728,
-0.0363984108,
0.0484957919,
-0.022876706,
0.0026143489,
0.0296588391,
-0.0069081406,
-0.008119748,
-0.0316308439,
0.0409326702,
0.0719416589,
0.0060766544,
-0.0203389265,
0.0522329025,
0.0040496844,
-0.0533837751,
-0.008223189,
-0.0019617751,
0.0122107258,
-0.0150396451,
-0.0059969532,
0.016176803,
0.0363196321,
0.0453035906,
-0.0411397964,
-0.0368033312,
0.0148347607,
-0.0272346456,
-0.0211968794,
-0.0545541979,
-0.0436414666,
-0.0223908201,
-0.0220762733,
-0.0213992111,
-0.0111011229,
0.1120149717,
-0.0195151474,
0.0041498453,
-0.0733965412,
0.0095808217,
-0.0344578251,
-0.0026095787,
-0.0379509404,
0.0245986916,
0.0560630336,
-0.0100838169,
-0.0676448345,
-0.0585205778,
0.097111769,
-0.0320075117,
0.0550385304,
-0.0760067254,
0.0058627566,
-0.0088831969,
-0.0266275443,
-0.0474669151,
-0.0540787056,
0.0191878695,
0.0078335516,
-0.015359845,
-0.0051954915,
-0.0007624414,
-0.0269448552,
0.0127875116,
0.029499907,
-0.033667855,
-0.0325251259,
-0.0453872681,
0.0705245808,
0.041877348,
0.054936558,
-0.0021960321,
-0.0382309742,
0.0172890015,
0.0081477147,
0.0331973583,
-0.0230327453,
0.0025716205,
-0.0090195648,
-0.0258834269,
-0.0513804406,
-0.0044260523,
0.0168128777,
0.0270605795,
-0.0146959592,
-0.051542066,
0.0814331174,
0.0017946158,
0.0027226943,
-0.0236428082,
-0.051480446,
0.0269817673,
0.0029211219,
-0.0028238299,
-0.0165163577,
-0.0099294567,
-0.0402405038,
0.0307687428,
0.0273166019,
-0.0295443125,
-0.00771731,
-0.0825939029,
0.0066915909,
0.0329065211,
-0.0210698731,
-0.0475040749,
0.0050951848,
-0.0305319242,
-0.0200615805,
0.0039370009,
-0.0217950381,
-0.0514582321,
0.0449565016,
0.0205961354,
0.0093212957,
-0.0200480055,
-0.0789174512,
-0.034427885,
0.0007724242,
0.0103454748,
0.0111660091,
0.0210550129,
-0.0014233293,
0.0096502863,
-0.0033181317,
-0.0242098738,
0.0108009502,
0.0819306672,
0.0041571986,
0.0207042359,
-0.0058786352,
0.0311023984,
-0.049343165,
-0.0142683825,
0.0478143133,
0.0571917295,
0.0149918124,
0.0117944423,
-0.0221765749,
0.0382418856,
0.0041602664,
0.0906198099,
0.0635201633,
0.0115847439,
-0.0370664038,
-0.0105800405,
0.0382630751,
-0.0927824527,
-0.0461777411,
0.0072247433,
-0.0176041946,
0.0397499502,
-0.0853871629,
-0.0492280647,
-0.0085615115,
0.0484297164,
0.0317334719,
0.0701728389,
0.0413737781,
-0.0065861172,
-0.0026092213,
-0.0232090745,
-0.0715506822,
-0.0368420891,
0.0376419351,
0.0001223805,
0.0240019578,
-0.0146074258,
-0.0023540617,
0.0296349674,
-0.0792207345,
-0.0465633683,
0.0273209028,
0.0255767852,
0.0167890824,
0.0513299629,
-0.0169321056,
0.0316517092,
0.0873385593,
-0.0141291199,
-0.0472059473,
0.0340985022,
0.0522225127,
-0.0187226105,
0.0092874048,
0.0476078019,
-0.0261204764,
-0.0345713049,
0.0121786511,
0.0326735787,
-0.0190874189,
-0.0489285029,
0.0604917258,
0.0070321294,
-0.0148890875,
-0.0102146855,
0.0411372483,
0.0090068253,
0.0384445563,
-0.0157154594,
-0.0344133787,
-0.0156457052,
0.021883944,
0.0306955539,
-0.0400444046,
0.0133347474,
0.0196267553,
-0.0385248885,
0.0726819038,
0.0052402108,
0.0093171401,
0.0007018045,
-0.0460881777,
-0.0250334572,
-0.026213564,
0.0122606661,
0.0116468789,
-0.0247767232,
0.0200173333,
0.0092667919,
0.0212393627,
0.0105339531,
-0.0244484842,
-0.0245460179,
0.004589329,
-0.0885206461,
-0.0240626335,
-0.0224516913,
-0.0088520003,
0.0321562849,
-0.0055697188,
0.0784855485,
-0.0318962298,
-0.0152871544,
0.00655152,
0.0595358014,
0.0055692322,
0.0447553396,
-0.0081299059,
0.027926296,
0.0550315902,
0.0237768311,
0.1026715934,
-0.0005660511,
0.0272471029,
0.0148253934,
0.0167499576,
-0.0680236071,
-0.0519992448,
-0.0096254284,
0.0525238104,
-0.0006687739,
-0.0229998976,
-0.0276674461,
-0.0494674519,
0.035475269,
0.0105013195,
0.0077716308,
-0.0243634935,
0.079084605,
0.0148139056,
-0.0190216675,
-0.0059068413,
-0.0309102051,
0.0826807171,
0.0508376993,
-0.0281263459,
-0.0539952517,
-5.964873433e-33,
-0.0171893649,
-0.0393548608,
-0.0223904978,
-0.0357304364,
0.0040030032,
0.0099785309,
-0.0201218575,
-0.0107876286,
-0.0086540505,
0.0072023049,
0.0011200951,
0.027603779,
0.017597165,
0.0529066958,
0.0283447634,
-0.0074612582,
0.0437302813,
-0.0184422992,
-0.0123056332,
-0.010895825,
0.0164741445,
0.0232519358,
0.023469802,
-0.0819719955,
0.0185805317,
-0.043272458,
0.0016172355,
-0.0384577699,
0.0369531885,
0.0534037463,
-0.0075116856,
0.0867867991,
-0.0140551617,
-0.0102725988,
-0.0413729101,
-0.0248971842,
-0.0951347798,
-0.0459242538,
0.0155551387,
-0.0339025706,
-0.0729175583,
-0.0566563644,
0.0359239168,
-0.0275324117,
0.0121425679,
0.0040073013,
0.0625154823,
-0.013318277,
-0.0194884166,
0.0212292075,
-0.0556205958,
-0.0000774832,
-0.0427244678,
-0.0011964149,
0.0126904603,
0.012505848,
-0.0007429323,
0.0307281706,
-0.010018385,
0.0501016229,
-0.0222772527,
0.0500471443,
0.0020199462,
0.0092669781,
-0.0162277147,
0.0168582387,
-0.0196121186,
-0.0449277461,
0.0046427646,
-0.0329327732,
-0.0201184098,
-0.0069787838,
0.0491482094,
0.0758838952,
0.0138627607,
0.0614910349,
-0.0240069963,
0.0224091485,
0.0027801157,
0.0036460939,
0.0314381197,
-0.0180008076,
-0.0311889425,
-0.0079472493,
-0.0235588904,
-0.0140517214,
-0.0057998509,
-0.0302051175,
-0.0107882936,
-0.0013392736,
-0.0751012117,
-0.0028690724,
0.0050803763,
-0.0231251772,
-0.023270091,
0.0028418731,
-0.0072567989,
0.0149095347,
0.0064355256,
0.0117974654,
-0.0138621302,
-0.0157942344,
0.014786548,
0.056877885,
0.02631546,
0.0005245446,
0.010970965,
0.0212241393,
-0.0244896431,
-0.0026914743,
-0.0328864828,
-0.0494240075,
-0.0090851653,
-0.0359811299,
-0.0040938836,
0.0414297096,
-0.0039679818,
0.0199163798,
0.0240310468,
0.005480811,
0.0356632285,
-0.0083701974,
0.0150423143,
-0.0027695976,
-0.0051574521,
-0.0219023805,
-0.0037777624,
0.0158443283,
0.0260306131,
-0.0432401411,
0.012209041,
-0.0016085774,
2.677e-7,
0.0444451645,
0.0158599988,
0.0600927845,
-0.0309591722,
-0.024411954,
0.0116394777,
0.0104434267,
-0.005543618,
-0.0400051884,
-0.0686084107,
0.0189297218,
0.0481691398,
-0.0035871645,
-0.0059465119,
-0.1088058129,
0.0041264058,
-0.0280811246,
0.0330513567,
-0.0490011834,
0.0196890123,
0.0659086406,
0.0606836528,
0.0060136612,
0.0090381606,
-0.0589528196,
-0.0186279174,
0.0338656902,
-0.0044467119,
-0.0280345939,
0.0176971722,
0.0083961273,
-0.0327499136,
-0.0110454587,
0.0020082972,
-0.005260468,
0.0058836984,
0.062737979,
0.0249637682,
0.0427534021,
-0.0294155888,
-0.0199673548,
-0.0578850433,
0.025999533,
-0.0302529186,
0.0340618752,
-0.0419815816,
-0.024484925,
0.0118391989,
-0.0231813267,
0.0448534191,
0.0179251339,
0.0031187409,
-0.0362986736,
-0.0190152824,
0.0039496729,
0.0163220204,
-0.0109318933,
-0.0199161246,
-0.0196176451,
-0.0273516253,
-0.0385635979,
-0.0055974983,
-0.0120541267,
-0.0312321912,
0.0717021599,
-0.0384394974,
0.0215504467,
2.431522233e-34,
0.0395487659,
0.001559631,
0.0301796496,
0.028075818,
-0.007274664,
-0.008621281,
-0.0419703238,
0.0018070206,
0.0286320075,
-0.0175318178,
-0.0203097872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02676v8 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02676v8 | Chain of Hindsight Aligns Language Models with Feedback | 2023-02-06T10:28:16 | 2023-10-18T07:11:12 | Hao Liu, Carmelo Sferrazza, Pieter Abbeel | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Learning from human preferences is important for language models to match
human needs and to align with human and social values. Prior works have
achieved remarkable successes by learning from human feedback to understand and
follow instructions. Nonetheless, these methods are either founded on
hand-picked model generations that are favored by human annotators, rendering
them inefficient in terms of data utilization and challenging to apply in
general, or they depend on reinforcement learning, which often suffers from
imperfect reward functions and relies on extremely challenging optimizations.
In this work, we propose a novel technique, Chain of Hindsight, that is easy to
optimize and can learn from any form of feedback, regardless of its polarity.
Our idea is inspired by how humans learn from extensive feedback presented in
the form of languages. We convert all types of feedback into sequences of
sentences, which are then used to fine-tune the model, allowing us to take
advantage of the language comprehension capabilities of language models. We
condition the model on a sequence of model generations paired with feedback. By
doing so, the model is trained to generate outputs based on feedback, while
learning to identify and correct negative attributes or errors. Applying our
method to large language models, we observed that Chain of Hindsight
significantly surpasses previous methods in aligning language models with human
preferences. We report significant improvements on summarization and dialogue
benchmarks, with our approach markedly preferred in human evaluations. | [
0.0645104498,
0.0866912007,
0.0015468872,
0.0212498326,
-0.0298600607,
0.0150737809,
-0.0587511882,
-0.0250136461,
0.0137484856,
-0.0345588028,
-0.0406372361,
-0.0418117158,
0.0188500881,
0.019692922,
0.0059209419,
-0.1045618802,
0.0394635238,
-0.0326780342,
-0.0167780034,
-0.0087846061,
0.0168007221,
0.0158750229,
0.011738847,
0.0501674488,
0.0081260307,
0.0115153408,
-0.0139685245,
-0.02049537,
0.0350607112,
0.0019002401,
0.0348820798,
0.0465606488,
0.0053900983,
0.0161930956,
0.0000019908,
-0.0166924801,
0.0152406488,
-0.0491868854,
0.013922275,
-0.0122007094,
0.0607039332,
0.0005199733,
0.0109230932,
0.0060758227,
-0.0360880755,
0.0071096453,
0.0175920818,
0.0229305476,
0.0763058066,
0.0557785854,
0.0201303717,
-0.0043043541,
-0.0083284862,
-0.0398053862,
-0.0110991439,
-0.0437087789,
0.0018993499,
-0.0045944517,
0.0176826082,
0.006164724,
-0.0019235673,
0.0360774361,
0.015343138,
-0.0136858914,
0.0235655364,
0.0283819456,
0.0230698884,
-0.0265895706,
-0.0320554599,
0.0797415376,
0.0188366175,
-0.0448540151,
-0.0057623959,
-0.0098551931,
0.0111800721,
-0.030114172,
-0.0375422612,
0.003970331,
0.0000431294,
0.0414232947,
0.0084790802,
-0.0000149433,
0.0244700164,
0.0438543782,
0.0096916351,
0.067664057,
-0.0119994348,
-0.0192239694,
-0.0109181991,
0.0332403071,
-0.020040527,
-0.0388261788,
0.0202710256,
0.0149319246,
-0.0450651646,
0.017915383,
-0.0521684326,
-0.0009708733,
0.0091689043,
-0.0317667499,
0.0261962116,
0.0273750406,
0.0076587889,
0.0494489484,
-0.0052524628,
0.05334232,
0.0079290411,
-0.0021542944,
-0.056460429,
0.0013165486,
-0.0286549069,
-0.0013679706,
-0.0243087634,
0.0231907908,
-0.0118960468,
-0.0019004941,
-0.0370720737,
0.0199103113,
-0.0132567203,
0.0159273092,
0.0102868984,
0.0390113145,
-0.0339946151,
-0.0301613305,
-0.0421250276,
0.0396952182,
-0.0517902263,
-0.0155761251,
0.0318078287,
0.0021908223,
-0.0091547063,
0.0087688956,
-0.0057873162,
-0.0003764403,
-0.0120028546,
0.0602907203,
-0.0223029871,
0.0116420798,
-0.0196604524,
-0.0168318525,
-0.0331695192,
-0.0528632589,
-0.0039689969,
-0.050094489,
0.0020775034,
-0.0121354442,
-0.0210497826,
-0.0568990558,
0.0192563422,
0.0329464972,
-0.0420089811,
0.0553821884,
-0.0100895539,
0.004240959,
0.0237964392,
-0.0116296252,
-0.0056293551,
0.0492155068,
0.0478510968,
0.0648657903,
0.0045037819,
0.0248688459,
0.0169159696,
0.0460905768,
0.0212812759,
0.0273245089,
-0.0395371169,
-0.0060875639,
-0.0288942773,
0.0537592173,
0.0311592408,
0.068425782,
-0.0136401085,
0.0064326474,
0.0783510581,
0.0257343203,
-0.0242415648,
0.0077884849,
0.0436179861,
0.0429051742,
-0.0184722971,
0.0180682428,
-0.0415420048,
0.0404846705,
-0.0341919735,
0.0183040202,
0.0321757682,
-0.0169546716,
-0.0164167695,
-0.0874003991,
0.0014202788,
-0.0103604225,
0.0468136407,
0.0149951121,
0.0300041772,
0.0320031941,
-0.0605809018,
0.0170909055,
0.0433450639,
-0.0563054197,
0.0136909923,
-0.033617124,
0.0502067842,
0.0855537727,
0.0383282527,
-0.0104434388,
-0.0310340598,
-0.014124264,
-0.0234032515,
0.0419813879,
0.0638859943,
-0.0347645804,
-0.0103746224,
-0.0495766252,
-0.0194007456,
0.0489393994,
0.0109126354,
0.0166930091,
0.0215241108,
-0.0449692644,
0.0121642575,
-0.0067088278,
-0.0703516081,
0.040610183,
-0.0213240925,
-0.0086597018,
0.0080598202,
0.021140689,
0.0290029719,
0.005931369,
0.0343271941,
0.0126533145,
0.0170774721,
-0.0076955049,
-0.0466794446,
0.0347910263,
-0.0962744132,
-0.0561709031,
0.0254781917,
-0.0138910981,
-0.0091283591,
0.0600255765,
-0.0266551878,
-0.0428370349,
0.0480464734,
-0.0357491523,
0.0153364697,
-0.0337319486,
0.0284572374,
-0.0067772823,
-0.0268251859,
-0.0365394279,
0.049757313,
-0.0221646037,
-0.0049675731,
4.955e-7,
-0.0318877697,
-0.0153307104,
-0.0378259942,
-0.0184230488,
-0.0076630064,
0.0133565785,
0.0323755108,
0.0765243694,
0.0511390716,
-0.0568189919,
-0.0197368879,
-0.1076316312,
-0.0158587992,
-0.0306257755,
0.0004255839,
0.0221108645,
-0.0107771205,
0.0086371331,
-0.048599951,
-0.0494784415,
-0.0011636236,
0.0061496808,
-0.0085579203,
0.0483093001,
0.0183767285,
0.007084331,
-0.0741679445,
-0.0127933826,
-0.0098423613,
0.0113643575,
-0.0091035822,
-0.0033627106,
-0.0357245691,
0.009474243,
-0.0347690806,
0.0291677807,
-0.0016470165,
-0.0418170989,
0.002112533,
-0.0212335046,
0.0316330045,
0.0579113178,
0.0471761152,
0.0343532711,
0.0454502143,
0.0360297859,
-0.0512546822,
0.0118115293,
-0.0477584898,
-0.0104798516,
-0.0225170702,
-0.0042716665,
-0.0031910308,
0.0785020515,
0.009054062,
0.0085916016,
-0.0968614146,
0.0275450982,
-0.034945678,
-0.0418202877,
-0.0390669331,
-0.0275322665,
-0.0390863344,
0.0481903851,
-0.0430360734,
-0.0346891098,
0.1213230193,
0.0016845175,
0.0060158172,
-0.0364680551,
-0.0025121295,
-0.023902541,
0.0545866713,
0.0174435619,
0.0251412634,
0.0093246242,
-0.0110657467,
-0.0781598166,
-0.0107236234,
0.0438755229,
-0.0256868154,
0.0592332222,
-0.0674943924,
-0.0026488798,
0.0235484727,
-0.070650816,
-0.0609348081,
-0.0589246713,
-0.0373721197,
0.0054197269,
-0.0176999904,
-0.0148739517,
-0.0202752966,
-0.0093933111,
0.0052164863,
0.0376610905,
-0.0318140723,
-0.0015440303,
-0.0092383148,
0.0049886885,
0.084282957,
-0.012746227,
0.0031258827,
-0.0376371592,
0.0097419079,
0.0232907385,
0.0702984631,
0.0033020217,
-0.0037514535,
0.0008019091,
0.0367533751,
-0.0152862221,
-0.0279675703,
0.0312774517,
0.0422078893,
-0.057706967,
-0.0270042419,
0.1125993207,
0.029017061,
-0.0630419254,
0.0152382413,
-0.0074944491,
0.0518995412,
0.0250969436,
0.0322659761,
-0.0579464771,
-0.0470197462,
0.0114596263,
0.0552800708,
0.017806435,
-0.0322175063,
0.0087897945,
-0.1298926473,
-0.0114989346,
0.0167706646,
-0.0489184447,
-0.0027299151,
-0.0032456722,
-0.0078087295,
-0.0301603843,
0.0130350627,
0.034748055,
-0.0028619647,
-0.0094586071,
0.0071297707,
-0.0301549304,
0.0010728051,
0.0366149433,
-0.0118524171,
0.0550846383,
0.0906812996,
0.0473008379,
0.0217444021,
-0.0146361394,
0.0286147073,
-0.0006598512,
-0.0080513703,
-0.0056794593,
0.0411858894,
-0.011262984,
-0.0073063741,
0.0007543924,
0.0581260361,
-0.0028835374,
0.0004353722,
0.003784288,
0.0315052904,
-0.0060039456,
-0.0189170539,
0.0072557367,
0.0409149081,
0.0116714509,
0.0689399615,
0.0339812674,
-0.0798925161,
-0.0348352268,
-0.0387436859,
-0.0245977249,
-0.0705975741,
-0.0519880392,
-0.006606611,
0.015371467,
0.0114619313,
-0.1141729802,
-0.0730908066,
-0.0071274624,
0.0070196223,
0.0351384245,
-0.025813438,
0.0124155125,
0.0010433196,
-0.0213202834,
0.0104792835,
-0.0269981343,
-0.004825403,
-0.0580988526,
-0.0158730373,
0.0343172774,
-0.057118278,
-0.010978221,
0.0308106635,
-0.0859651268,
-0.0713821799,
-0.0081330026,
0.0884638131,
0.019366961,
0.1029202566,
-0.0263878629,
-0.0538142212,
0.0051427358,
0.0121245328,
-0.0132461945,
-0.0075741624,
0.0391358212,
0.0465429872,
-0.0203475617,
0.0624374785,
-0.0402714647,
0.0124413632,
-0.0074046147,
0.0368937291,
-0.0239143204,
-0.0561650023,
0.0437299982,
0.0019382667,
0.0261052046,
-0.0672973618,
-0.0325902663,
-0.038494654,
-0.0248084795,
-0.019985009,
-0.0538590029,
-0.0405530557,
0.0001815025,
0.0075773662,
-0.0035881174,
-0.001649257,
-0.0382769667,
-0.012160141,
0.0297868885,
-0.0578977801,
-0.0179467499,
0.0175533313,
0.0068257418,
0.0196124483,
0.0193362441,
-0.0389947221,
0.0042068148,
-0.0001854161,
0.0482471026,
-0.0098360535,
0.0673956126,
0.0319861174,
-0.0180714037,
0.0004785239,
0.0166818295,
-0.0722651184,
-0.0351609662,
-0.0435797088,
0.0276100822,
0.0490061715,
-0.0037765007,
0.0715722218,
-0.0351792052,
0.0013644595,
-0.010190187,
0.058114022,
-0.0114301126,
-0.0605328567,
-0.0016211648,
0.0220096577,
-0.0016631935,
0.0048223943,
0.0659073591,
-0.0004837617,
0.0251911953,
-0.0088947164,
0.0124824112,
-0.0481714867,
-0.0327652097,
-0.0018334583,
0.0040019457,
-0.0189522412,
0.0192201547,
-0.0429474264,
-0.0562993325,
-0.0230895523,
0.0444683805,
0.0057517258,
-0.0278221164,
0.0665122271,
0.0216383059,
-0.0427626893,
0.0036586337,
-0.0883938968,
0.0056472183,
-0.015589376,
-0.0067890952,
-0.0512257814,
-6.322161267e-33,
-0.0414857939,
-0.0084856795,
0.0135263363,
0.0042082537,
-0.0318528563,
-0.0428725369,
-0.0542952456,
0.0212872997,
-0.0063437964,
0.0162217915,
-0.0259008575,
-0.0093633188,
0.0004008147,
0.0422372967,
0.0515707061,
-0.0044542886,
0.0600026473,
-0.0111056557,
-0.0421099961,
0.0128373373,
0.0352056958,
0.0202370603,
0.0481960699,
-0.0269137342,
0.0356199406,
-0.0105581274,
-0.0470535383,
0.0769889876,
0.014047374,
0.0463173762,
-0.0076245116,
0.0197451543,
0.0106077697,
-0.0583629124,
-0.0336507373,
0.0027673035,
-0.0668509752,
-0.0051375586,
0.0250831395,
0.0034946697,
-0.0648742691,
-0.0134928739,
0.0222977586,
-0.0304607879,
-0.0253491867,
0.0159968957,
0.0311755333,
-0.0283739474,
-0.0159802865,
0.0192141235,
-0.0739416704,
-0.0039054195,
-0.0164320786,
-0.0522723421,
0.0277041029,
0.0693162754,
-0.013668485,
-0.0133942114,
-0.0238861702,
0.0450173318,
0.0236671865,
0.0242080819,
0.0806529745,
0.0404235125,
0.0112892054,
0.0831959546,
-0.0045902543,
0.0125573752,
-0.021754479,
-0.0036522958,
0.0379598588,
0.0138100889,
0.0225157291,
0.0317005403,
-0.0113974074,
-0.0013927999,
0.0134127801,
0.0233012326,
-0.002075562,
0.0433814749,
0.0129239596,
0.0189214628,
-0.0375318602,
-0.0366623811,
-0.0604052693,
-0.0207988862,
-0.0118118394,
-0.0059196013,
0.0084903426,
0.0320518427,
-0.039003469,
-0.0394159071,
0.0167751722,
-0.0353858434,
-0.0031784039,
0.0344550051,
-0.0541439839,
-0.0055638519,
0.0075684623,
0.0365714356,
-0.0530803651,
0.0181038957,
-0.0018913513,
0.0138492323,
0.0073313643,
0.0194998756,
0.061789941,
0.0126811424,
-0.0362663716,
0.0152388373,
-0.0325853862,
0.0437275209,
-0.0196419116,
-0.0201371461,
0.0467561074,
0.0152629167,
-0.0308772773,
0.0764255822,
0.0069135842,
-0.0126720024,
-0.0326855704,
-0.0095583145,
0.0163928475,
0.0055572083,
-0.0484261215,
-0.0027022157,
-0.0116874436,
0.0206770115,
0.025582647,
-0.0243718568,
-0.0140855396,
0.0222404301,
2.504e-7,
0.0064344993,
0.0457021892,
0.0591557175,
0.0152099794,
0.0021830616,
0.0838226825,
-0.0010932956,
-0.005651522,
0.015748905,
0.0293982271,
0.0512244366,
0.0291238464,
0.0905792043,
-0.0050713727,
-0.1038492396,
-0.0253475942,
-0.0865171701,
-0.0074044843,
-0.0170324948,
-0.0540134385,
0.0450475514,
0.0771000758,
0.0232884455,
-0.0018822857,
-0.0012089449,
0.0134088704,
0.0637948886,
-0.0498847701,
-0.0266274437,
-0.0010363001,
-0.0086279372,
0.0127780605,
-0.0130444076,
-0.0216151085,
-0.0060953861,
-0.0148885455,
0.0017019868,
0.0608282909,
-0.0105226599,
-0.0471843444,
-0.0182574205,
0.0430102535,
0.0301851984,
-0.0461468622,
0.0357305892,
-0.04739758,
0.0010380382,
-0.0336844064,
0.0236992985,
0.0009795987,
-0.0120002814,
-0.0264035594,
-0.032158833,
0.0156744756,
0.0210751928,
0.0170996189,
0.0063942824,
-0.0691790879,
-0.054965999,
0.0231726356,
-0.0163320675,
-0.0073668892,
-0.0242597088,
0.0361291543,
-0.0146210724,
-0.0731606185,
0.0098502403,
2.058730271e-34,
0.0575802885,
-0.0118807424,
-0.0079719694,
0.0136174187,
0.0365626924,
0.0089339288,
0.0037731393,
0.0051542888,
0.0760418102,
-0.0286911447,
-0.0442159325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02655v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02655v1 | Evolution of grammatical forms: some quantitative approaches | 2023-02-06T09:50:48 | 2023-02-06T09:50:48 | Jean-Marc Luck, Anita Mehta | cond-mat.stat-mech | cond-mat.stat-mech, cs.CL | Grammatical forms are said to evolve via two main mechanisms. These are,
respectively, the `descent' mechanism, where current forms can be seen to have
descended (albeit with occasional modifications) from their roots in ancient
languages, and the `contact' mechanism, where evolution in a given language
occurs via borrowing from other languages with which it is in contact. We use
ideas and concepts from statistical physics to formulate a series of static and
dynamical models which illustrate these issues in general terms. The static
models emphasise the relative numbers of rules and exceptions, while the
dynamical models focus on the emergence of exceptional forms. These unlikely
survivors among various competing grammatical forms are winners against the
odds. Our analysis suggests that they emerge when the influence of neighbouring
languages exceeds the generic tendency towards regularisation within individual
languages. | [
0.0146521516,
0.0017125692,
-0.0532630906,
-0.0097387023,
-0.0189585052,
-0.0374163426,
-0.0629329979,
0.000005209,
-0.0546724051,
-0.0486400761,
-0.0007613134,
-0.0743306205,
0.0189312529,
-0.0237787366,
0.0658484623,
-0.0526816659,
0.0555561967,
-0.0471371673,
-0.0568251908,
0.0226628501,
0.0180405024,
-0.0613498837,
0.0264211334,
-0.0011309943,
0.0134514878,
0.0539832152,
-0.0296477564,
-0.0510132499,
-0.003578977,
0.0244537462,
-0.0304725654,
0.0042357226,
-0.0081225447,
0.0483893678,
0.0000016199,
-0.063051641,
0.0492021218,
-0.0143076498,
-0.0161414556,
0.0192432012,
-0.002039178,
0.0250046514,
-0.0543661304,
-0.0748983845,
-0.0005980114,
0.0194313712,
0.0346510075,
-0.063760668,
-0.0225608628,
0.0256696399,
0.005146055,
-0.0211930033,
0.0570802204,
-0.0567864552,
0.0108688604,
0.0128872842,
0.0442819707,
-0.0391870551,
0.0150299966,
-0.0394598283,
-0.0355128422,
-0.0132181263,
0.0053219111,
-0.0053996816,
-0.0800853521,
0.0020998274,
0.017974874,
-0.014174697,
0.0042188866,
0.0313743465,
0.0118343141,
-0.0519085862,
-0.0128713595,
0.0076463851,
0.0208090879,
0.0326164737,
-0.0119566591,
-0.0040539652,
0.0212593228,
0.0424757041,
0.1117095873,
-0.0511733182,
-0.000162445,
0.0133988028,
-0.016799625,
0.073689431,
0.0458791628,
-0.0622947551,
-0.016208386,
0.0129519645,
0.0231231228,
-0.0691955313,
-0.0248733386,
0.0154539272,
0.0297839623,
0.0193243567,
0.0135348141,
0.0135966232,
-0.0116149588,
-0.0070367889,
0.0175962243,
-0.0270170085,
-0.0066630756,
0.0148583958,
-0.0067273667,
-0.0014505143,
-0.0133444071,
-0.053060241,
-0.035848517,
0.0443059132,
-0.034974996,
-0.0114323637,
-0.0066870395,
0.0140995421,
-0.0048308847,
0.0261041969,
0.0047996412,
0.0051704245,
0.0241480507,
-0.0459706187,
-0.0402574465,
-0.0543493778,
-0.0536850654,
0.0200238992,
-0.0012054458,
-0.0238479581,
-0.0336158425,
0.046679914,
-0.0060597076,
-0.0484483279,
0.0026040403,
-0.0156884491,
0.0274228659,
-0.0029064845,
-0.0537140779,
-0.0000160819,
0.0122723188,
0.0165194366,
-0.0033476979,
0.0112189678,
-0.0571215153,
0.0091296108,
-0.0296390485,
-0.0025386501,
-0.0306050871,
-0.0090011498,
-0.0320534483,
-0.0505329706,
-0.0205090847,
-0.0624779686,
-0.069166787,
-0.0432190709,
-0.0423916988,
0.0279003121,
-0.0038432612,
-0.0272430796,
0.0335996412,
0.0061415001,
0.0190283041,
-0.0572302938,
0.033519078,
-0.0187477898,
0.0303472579,
0.0322774798,
-0.0058482885,
0.0317730047,
0.0034856771,
-0.0171696655,
0.0129821422,
0.0068384525,
-0.0023895865,
0.049421858,
-0.0212238804,
-0.0266800821,
0.0028316053,
0.045917064,
-0.0036168471,
0.0310277063,
0.0613998249,
-0.0326736309,
0.0000810295,
0.0670506209,
0.0087097632,
-0.084621653,
-0.0398609899,
-0.0466854908,
-0.0419712737,
0.0348243192,
0.007773865,
-0.0111129573,
0.0033248554,
0.0059447992,
0.007962781,
-0.041784469,
0.0411447324,
0.0279708318,
0.0195329376,
0.0197465178,
0.0111518363,
-0.0394346677,
0.0052765235,
-0.0254254825,
0.0794304237,
-0.0484381616,
-0.0369366556,
0.0097081298,
-0.0154485526,
0.0547091588,
-0.0089795105,
0.0045587095,
0.0199197158,
-0.0016774128,
0.0168870464,
0.0251567829,
0.0120219486,
0.0088661741,
0.0053965915,
-0.0013102586,
-0.1073122323,
0.0331978016,
-0.0093525583,
0.0042303838,
0.0051194876,
0.0302407909,
-0.0110298581,
0.0091337273,
-0.0527455918,
-0.0217124838,
0.0202131644,
-0.0167524982,
-0.0148237469,
0.0489762798,
0.0032015939,
-0.0118626859,
0.0096725486,
0.0800000727,
0.0234526619,
0.0309571642,
0.0542725846,
-0.0027128311,
0.0622200929,
-0.0825617015,
0.0328775495,
-0.0225410573,
0.0826645941,
-0.0995093659,
0.1088149399,
0.017116325,
0.0250016078,
-0.0233299974,
0.0379012823,
-0.0256101917,
0.0282342918,
0.0098263677,
0.0313189998,
-0.0176578388,
-0.0342351608,
0.0401420593,
-0.0392526574,
-0.0051908549,
-0.0004080046,
0.0075936918,
-0.0413486287,
0.0464956351,
-0.0217935741,
0.0028909016,
0.006532941,
0.0227531604,
-0.042194739,
0.0125973383,
0.0649529323,
-0.0014397384,
0.0084243938,
-0.0193222631,
0.0547609329,
0.0394033678,
0.0261413716,
0.0218945239,
0.0236500744,
0.024821464,
-0.0129278582,
-0.0566850379,
-0.0739374757,
-0.0085401274,
-0.013808541,
-0.0025104452,
-0.0182562228,
0.0242635291,
-0.0459425971,
-0.0021140126,
-0.0528638922,
0.0298429709,
-0.0166517235,
-0.0548233762,
0.0267506018,
-0.0173174515,
0.0770662203,
0.0081832111,
-0.023169158,
0.0260941666,
0.0025974372,
-0.0247610491,
-0.0188518241,
-0.051711753,
-0.0325702056,
0.0047495426,
-0.0855507106,
-0.0150111672,
0.0217728261,
0.1150950491,
-0.0007178005,
-0.0439156815,
-0.0024402507,
0.068504028,
-0.0615221374,
-0.0238202363,
0.0561437532,
-0.0411942191,
-0.0433851443,
0.0508742109,
-0.0266577974,
-0.0304877572,
0.0305272359,
0.0104525611,
-0.0117874388,
-0.0153453872,
-0.0278745499,
0.0050833113,
0.0630362108,
0.0413025394,
-0.0212551914,
0.0567646064,
0.0101357307,
-0.063775152,
-0.0232953206,
0.0518307053,
0.0498590544,
0.0172635838,
-0.050616499,
0.0022280989,
-0.0079383096,
-0.0412784815,
0.0551962927,
-0.0427244566,
0.0077344724,
0.006894032,
-0.0059244991,
-0.0018910035,
0.0396981202,
0.0277225152,
-0.0137469508,
0.0129869366,
0.0256104283,
0.0285035521,
-0.0320476256,
0.0307205301,
0.0287571978,
0.0353015363,
-0.0067826221,
0.0092018666,
0.010812182,
0.0390171446,
-0.0081246831,
0.0490981154,
-0.0149559546,
0.0176600013,
0.0518340096,
-0.00608401,
-0.0621033981,
0.0143964356,
0.0229247697,
-0.0115498556,
0.0343001597,
-0.0018053133,
0.0052031381,
0.0540513694,
0.097341761,
-0.0448543616,
0.0185081456,
0.0285698604,
0.0016333045,
-0.0404943861,
0.0496716015,
-0.0047688782,
-0.0404244214,
-0.0106156291,
-0.0340167619,
0.0367245078,
-0.0773651972,
-0.0055382214,
-0.0053410456,
0.0065867733,
0.0299365949,
0.0121467495,
0.0051865806,
0.0327447467,
-0.0203861948,
0.0525265113,
-0.0051352209,
0.0162952878,
0.0241314583,
-0.006097578,
-0.0310674738,
-0.0518251173,
-0.053918913,
-0.0093668792,
0.0272344574,
0.0291299913,
-0.0644993931,
-0.0491833612,
0.0570134558,
-0.0108229797,
0.0056531718,
0.0140670342,
-0.0601809323,
0.1113373265,
0.0239764098,
-0.0615027882,
0.0109986719,
0.0225587711,
-0.0048577879,
0.0181989521,
0.0949619263,
-0.011647081,
-0.0854544938,
-0.0242961608,
-0.0457616709,
-0.0545783006,
0.0346736722,
0.0243822876,
-0.0285811611,
-0.0164612643,
-0.0332417302,
-0.0063772234,
0.0264680814,
-0.0638990179,
-0.0148894936,
-0.0024341037,
-0.0916257352,
-0.0875372365,
0.0247138534,
-0.0394100808,
0.0384759642,
0.0417105146,
-0.0335569791,
-0.0115218069,
-0.0148768267,
0.0534003042,
-0.0023745953,
0.0205198452,
-0.0209832434,
-0.0226076134,
0.0040642614,
0.0324602835,
-0.0176190101,
-0.0445208065,
-0.0631146953,
0.0043364228,
-0.0789911523,
0.015825972,
0.0412447229,
0.018355269,
0.0013613533,
0.0277737472,
-0.0619241297,
-0.0562067293,
-0.0183709059,
0.0506424047,
0.0425476246,
-0.0001198607,
-0.064818345,
0.0474441499,
0.0130787138,
0.0184232928,
-0.019389974,
0.0183560848,
0.0299614351,
-0.0441336781,
-0.018518636,
0.0418564118,
-0.0044271359,
0.0087741157,
-0.0590612181,
-0.0441008657,
0.0019191208,
-0.0181911252,
-0.0041277134,
-0.0006125491,
-0.0129638221,
0.0084652565,
0.0365494117,
0.0556981415,
-0.0121194152,
-0.019179048,
-0.0122224651,
0.0712301657,
-0.0431302786,
0.0425885208,
0.0713824034,
0.0586751886,
0.0407006927,
0.0435211807,
0.0288048182,
0.066129759,
-0.0892507136,
0.0390109904,
-0.0346420631,
-0.0580216534,
-0.0010428684,
-0.0068898723,
-0.0017614344,
-0.0164915938,
-0.0334721655,
-0.0052573998,
0.024055928,
-0.0329276808,
0.0553345233,
0.0052166609,
0.0320500284,
-0.0253304671,
-0.0044126906,
-0.0189483762,
-0.007004959,
0.0018270391,
0.0119876778,
0.0023906822,
0.0056688776,
-0.0086565707,
0.0368054472,
0.0368337184,
-0.0609971285,
0.0278829113,
-0.0080500972,
0.0132911978,
0.0288330261,
0.0171672087,
-0.0240914319,
-0.0269814096,
0.0407778136,
0.02951557,
-0.0433296673,
-0.0437703021,
-0.0612474829,
0.0046211598,
0.0186421499,
-0.0055856043,
0.0192162916,
0.0637329891,
-0.0134002073,
-0.0029476772,
-0.0502786785,
0.0144742802,
0.0233449936,
0.0164439883,
0.0124626886,
-5.1407472e-33,
0.0259336866,
0.0719686821,
-0.0435755067,
0.0375286676,
-0.021238545,
-0.0376698263,
-0.0316552036,
0.0366384834,
-0.0213927813,
0.0145222144,
0.0068551064,
-0.0209471881,
-0.0185316503,
-0.0124322223,
0.0527659208,
0.0062759225,
-0.0268472452,
-0.0124246879,
0.0317003131,
-0.0594215617,
-0.0294045899,
-0.0186285432,
0.0751466006,
-0.0056900568,
0.0784495473,
0.0047011808,
-0.005951799,
0.0278938543,
-0.0431793407,
-0.0051677595,
0.0140259219,
0.0049660439,
0.017850792,
-0.0129886353,
0.0037838726,
-0.0473605916,
0.0533100963,
-0.0543369353,
0.0456059203,
-0.0231690835,
0.0081217242,
-0.0406661145,
0.0031599328,
0.0027979657,
-0.1012402177,
0.0480722599,
0.0049110642,
0.0159095302,
-0.0175171718,
0.0056646094,
-0.0115724262,
-0.0082937665,
-0.0195924155,
0.0172281843,
-0.0232008342,
-0.0509319156,
-0.0039077834,
-0.079837881,
0.0324762911,
0.0383871533,
0.0060823951,
0.0431271754,
0.0054342723,
-0.0398958959,
-0.0034659575,
-0.0260060839,
0.0801917389,
0.0153735606,
0.0100398092,
0.039298851,
0.0197933819,
0.0704128146,
-0.0352471434,
0.0193873048,
0.0181183312,
0.0202436578,
-0.0153714698,
-0.0252123587,
0.1023533791,
0.0147857089,
-0.0706429929,
0.0259974543,
-0.0106623992,
-0.0164895728,
0.0042761881,
-0.030975448,
0.0295220017,
0.008922522,
-0.0302315149,
-0.023837585,
0.0697810575,
-0.0229944028,
0.0139700193,
-0.0312237348,
-0.0552641749,
-0.017559668,
-0.0096476916,
0.0295348819,
0.022413576,
0.0041269325,
0.0082718031,
-0.0218484048,
-0.0379008502,
0.003504497,
-0.0006062158,
0.0560949221,
-0.0280367341,
0.0277031902,
0.0311069265,
-0.0018907835,
0.021337647,
-0.0803459585,
0.0185210668,
0.0022129433,
0.0312419478,
0.0376525372,
-0.0073321387,
-0.0047072135,
0.0728747249,
0.0348903053,
-0.0222717654,
0.0344358906,
0.017874578,
0.0243530069,
-0.0051444578,
-0.0301955175,
0.0011891406,
0.0369455442,
0.0683027729,
-0.0256398097,
-0.0087827723,
-0.007353025,
2.496e-7,
0.0210809149,
0.0276769828,
0.0400957428,
-0.0265729483,
0.0424042232,
-0.0195064619,
-0.0416225344,
-0.032279335,
0.0141398655,
0.0262329839,
0.0053916206,
-0.0444199629,
-0.0020847896,
0.0239392519,
-0.0140737407,
-0.0082370862,
-0.051164072,
-0.0110014649,
0.0127825849,
0.0005746369,
-0.0513288602,
0.0592228398,
0.0266339313,
-0.0201115627,
-0.0261826888,
-0.0297901053,
0.015151063,
-0.0165598076,
0.0410615206,
0.0595686063,
0.002851475,
-0.0433199704,
0.0142501984,
-0.0376742631,
-0.0176236834,
0.0463157967,
-0.01919288,
-0.0526829474,
-0.017035991,
0.0769561753,
0.0429006591,
-0.0342422053,
-0.0026265944,
-0.0033296077,
0.0241366532,
0.0275248084,
0.0017960272,
0.0255994424,
-0.0333881974,
0.0510697775,
-0.0336027257,
0.0130226752,
0.0244645067,
0.0056742667,
0.0410547145,
0.0137056122,
-0.0218602661,
-0.0201655403,
-0.0543837547,
0.0728878379,
-0.0312261898,
-0.045794189,
0.0211666822,
-0.0118328435,
0.016936725,
0.0059971064,
-0.0297517404,
1.853771236e-34,
0.0165384095,
-0.0031285624,
0.0708898157,
0.0116510214,
0.0195604768,
0.000423132,
-0.0039598057,
0.0579266325,
0.0435195044,
-0.0263542011,
-0.043781586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02568v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02568v4 | Less is More: Understanding Word-level Textual Adversarial Attack via n-gram Frequency Descend | 2023-02-06T05:11:27 | 2024-04-15T08:11:18 | Ning Lu, Shengcai Liu, Zhirui Zhang, Qi Wang, Haifeng Liu, Ke Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Word-level textual adversarial attacks have demonstrated notable efficacy in
misleading Natural Language Processing (NLP) models. Despite their success, the
underlying reasons for their effectiveness and the fundamental characteristics
of adversarial examples (AEs) remain obscure. This work aims to interpret
word-level attacks by examining their $n$-gram frequency patterns. Our
comprehensive experiments reveal that in approximately 90\% of cases,
word-level attacks lead to the generation of examples where the frequency of
$n$-grams decreases, a tendency we term as the $n$-gram Frequency Descend
($n$-FD). This finding suggests a straightforward strategy to enhance model
robustness: training models using examples with $n$-FD. To examine the
feasibility of this strategy, we employed the $n$-gram frequency information,
as an alternative to conventional loss gradients, to generate perturbed
examples in adversarial training. The experiment results indicate that the
frequency-based approach performs comparably with the gradient-based approach
in improving model robustness. Our research offers a novel and more intuitive
perspective for understanding word-level textual adversarial attacks and
proposes a new direction to improve model robustness. | [
0.0446033962,
0.0602128841,
-0.0352055281,
0.0597432405,
-0.0350285769,
-0.0092227357,
-0.0041214023,
0.01734161,
-0.035698846,
-0.0543241054,
0.0043726265,
-0.0444176272,
0.0605154112,
0.0123006627,
0.0831331164,
-0.0294905864,
0.0500539429,
-0.0022925902,
-0.0355777331,
-0.0197663195,
0.0168479607,
-0.0080780247,
-0.0042526927,
0.0448310599,
-0.0176793206,
-0.0194534399,
0.0092360051,
0.0190377813,
0.009056285,
-0.0067096022,
0.0244670399,
0.029882038,
0.0220078193,
0.0809790194,
0.0000017132,
-0.0002474105,
-0.0185048245,
0.0282928795,
-0.0336622745,
0.0419413596,
0.0599081479,
-0.0467808396,
-0.0161387995,
0.0025280754,
0.0089935102,
-0.0108893858,
0.0021749015,
0.0731475577,
0.0471515357,
0.1298306882,
0.0057919398,
-0.0490928181,
0.0320389569,
-0.0459037684,
-0.0150756454,
-0.0474254973,
0.0205597244,
-0.0087847384,
-0.0506789908,
0.0177646894,
-0.0091937818,
0.0021435916,
0.0055567245,
0.0270331074,
0.0051810616,
0.0194153097,
-0.0164273474,
-0.0106687825,
0.0289846808,
0.0309585556,
-0.0228368007,
-0.0227318201,
-0.0213517677,
0.0047764159,
0.0299042165,
0.006670482,
-0.0171801336,
-0.0139831407,
0.0202437937,
0.0043985397,
-0.0057029552,
-0.0051873033,
0.0536506549,
0.0311122555,
0.0150805991,
0.0084685851,
0.0001662156,
-0.0366821252,
-0.0033744699,
-0.0480179973,
-0.0468132831,
-0.0168257169,
0.014767522,
-0.0027178605,
0.0444893613,
0.0060331603,
-0.102581203,
-0.0681461692,
0.0506324805,
-0.0835658312,
0.083502762,
0.0007504963,
-0.0034429049,
0.0009483985,
-0.0010162165,
0.0237415675,
-0.0013229831,
-0.0167973489,
-0.0047498695,
0.0223813746,
0.0048031383,
-0.0154770017,
0.0004156887,
0.0055234395,
-0.0367757455,
0.0054465081,
-0.0369245373,
-0.0098862341,
-0.0138005149,
0.0410968661,
-0.0757147297,
0.0123246899,
-0.0610674359,
-0.0092609199,
0.0149766654,
-0.0412779003,
0.0049827704,
0.0310588889,
-0.0160323288,
-0.0545728616,
-0.0375778712,
0.0169230606,
-0.0325144939,
-0.0189125277,
-0.0209490974,
0.101206392,
0.0537888668,
-0.0395408869,
-0.0422243439,
-0.0542845987,
-0.0160020962,
-0.0193083882,
-0.0135584865,
-0.0372989401,
-0.0413156115,
-0.0076299533,
-0.020316584,
-0.0701426491,
0.0146771483,
0.0296284501,
-0.0348666497,
0.0821012706,
0.0380953103,
-0.0380975194,
0.0388415456,
0.0332924724,
0.0059535448,
0.0702046603,
0.0250513721,
0.0427447818,
0.0455112085,
0.0286436174,
-0.0073549859,
0.0016036223,
0.0590897202,
0.0216489788,
-0.0090673771,
-0.031727571,
-0.0192383975,
0.0090417778,
0.0188393779,
0.0412213691,
-0.0177827608,
-0.0782213062,
0.1200154722,
0.0356274955,
-0.0411148742,
0.0515089184,
0.0149554685,
0.0096434541,
0.0074110138,
0.0421311148,
-0.0594788305,
-0.0320691913,
-0.0883740708,
-0.0321070626,
0.003687503,
0.0208994448,
0.0002442431,
-0.0452182926,
-0.0302792098,
0.0099048372,
0.0376982316,
-0.0318061113,
0.009119221,
0.0423362069,
-0.0107533215,
0.0005896362,
0.0401335135,
-0.0068440158,
-0.0160176493,
-0.0393609665,
-0.0232639257,
-0.0156232547,
0.0580621772,
-0.0197610222,
0.051563479,
-0.0133565906,
-0.0227056127,
0.0262913499,
0.0448811837,
0.003789529,
0.0200420115,
0.0052019008,
0.00767953,
-0.0723593235,
0.013195036,
0.0397211686,
0.0058618551,
0.0063884612,
0.0060880254,
-0.0366155952,
-0.0514089726,
0.051123783,
0.0111687342,
-0.0485405996,
0.0131423734,
0.0167471934,
0.00995115,
0.0070555941,
-0.049105823,
0.0158504006,
0.0277854092,
-0.0059686466,
-0.033650592,
-0.0577834062,
0.0093495082,
-0.0345020406,
-0.0098218843,
-0.0180214383,
-0.0041133752,
0.0479008965,
-0.0392440818,
0.0325512365,
0.0413786061,
-0.0695383772,
0.0321033783,
0.0087599335,
-0.0149506535,
-0.006589998,
0.0720762089,
-0.0248673093,
0.0775320977,
-0.0193287637,
0.0093808547,
-0.0458539724,
0.0001221003,
0.018796593,
-0.0198640637,
-0.0143681383,
0.0061924206,
-0.0284833666,
0.0022862335,
0.0118424958,
-0.0255745575,
0.0068425881,
0.019705439,
-0.0181708299,
-0.0210084096,
-0.0304700956,
-0.0033242372,
0.007828638,
-0.016878413,
-0.0201399717,
-0.0114476159,
0.0120650064,
0.0228906497,
-0.0365782529,
0.0232519396,
0.0312207937,
-0.0152842496,
-0.0172952097,
-0.0253152102,
-0.0066249031,
-0.0101469904,
0.1013092622,
-0.019157948,
-0.0277273227,
-0.0455442667,
0.0348688215,
0.0043822662,
0.065093495,
-0.018029917,
-0.0496223234,
0.0076671983,
0.0612470545,
-0.0033426019,
0.0772609562,
0.041899886,
0.1107077897,
0.0310098883,
0.061028529,
-0.0024417278,
-0.007412889,
-0.0020014294,
0.0253075473,
-0.045720838,
-0.0239672437,
0.0366577506,
0.0638364851,
0.0670590848,
-0.0051629078,
-0.0065717935,
0.080402419,
-0.0257979855,
-0.0443937816,
-0.0117757265,
-0.0177960079,
-0.0211254135,
-0.0271820799,
-0.0212700479,
-0.0426520444,
0.0642677695,
-0.0373744369,
0.0247353259,
-0.0398845933,
-0.0537295714,
0.028730724,
0.0476619527,
0.0207963064,
0.0195556618,
0.0542070307,
-0.0062792324,
-0.0216440242,
-0.0322928876,
0.0622393042,
-0.0111728767,
0.0604353696,
-0.0192305483,
-0.0184339732,
-0.0055881725,
-0.0342153534,
-0.0812243521,
-0.0643017367,
0.0116541255,
0.0029722112,
-0.0090587307,
-0.0383400619,
-0.0579690896,
-0.0482079573,
0.0232712906,
0.0033366815,
-0.0335270911,
-0.0115925707,
-0.012280575,
0.0734155476,
0.0471009575,
-0.0464064181,
0.054607898,
-0.0100353016,
0.0237441733,
0.0905250758,
-0.0279028509,
0.026993122,
-0.0349314772,
-0.0212096833,
0.0056483229,
-0.0180371646,
-0.0019235138,
0.0163441151,
0.0466491953,
-0.0624305755,
-0.0193858165,
0.0396624357,
-0.0061586029,
0.0317285657,
0.0665563047,
0.0322712697,
0.0507828407,
0.0004637489,
-0.006747236,
-0.0142839076,
-0.0277959108,
0.0121811628,
0.0384902544,
-0.0205712356,
0.0114312284,
-0.0296614654,
-0.0669242144,
-0.0044696578,
-0.0022342012,
-0.0038572946,
-0.0371631086,
-0.0387487561,
-0.0056657577,
0.0092128115,
0.0381268449,
-0.0328813083,
0.0237040427,
-0.0037851627,
0.0217916127,
-0.0250251479,
-0.0814604163,
-0.0068276874,
-0.0216268003,
0.0248613395,
0.0592160523,
0.0416405015,
-0.048237104,
-0.0148307905,
-0.0056305439,
0.0009261675,
-0.0001553704,
0.0311778914,
0.0706858858,
-0.0165050514,
-0.0039429348,
0.0151258018,
0.0465782657,
-0.0113539826,
-0.0390918367,
-0.0249454696,
0.003702403,
0.0053301798,
-0.0256966874,
-0.0417252481,
0.0108158458,
0.0370791964,
0.0771399513,
0.0254781917,
-0.0516983271,
-0.0125692757,
-0.0852463022,
0.0154151767,
-0.0411252156,
-0.0819298029,
0.0453465916,
0.0344509557,
-0.0089197969,
-0.0629312918,
-0.0342974626,
-0.0620761216,
-0.001307785,
-0.0002926588,
0.0063102446,
-0.0175370034,
-0.0126922354,
-0.0076778238,
-0.0006443096,
0.0299166441,
0.0496366248,
-0.0014540652,
-0.0383277647,
-0.0033382594,
-0.0060658809,
-0.0406525172,
0.0183601379,
-0.0962389857,
-0.0875677392,
0.0258776844,
0.0058005755,
0.0102484347,
0.0358007178,
-0.032289315,
-0.0954371467,
0.0585232452,
0.0517440513,
0.0106356703,
0.0205096137,
0.0794493854,
-0.0323554054,
0.0293191746,
0.0698369965,
-0.0132623222,
0.0143647334,
0.0505914614,
-0.0111468183,
0.0019003759,
0.0319860131,
0.0138717517,
-0.0161923543,
0.0501041599,
-0.0166355502,
-0.0066059162,
0.0331147425,
0.0294252913,
-0.0169242024,
-0.0323976055,
0.0027633049,
-0.007930194,
0.0003518072,
-0.0016705036,
-0.007904239,
-0.0140753174,
-0.0128967529,
0.0215588044,
-0.029538516,
0.0227522627,
-0.0042460877,
0.0244266447,
0.0074818763,
0.0224342514,
-0.0240892135,
0.013583825,
-0.0211433936,
0.0242278054,
-0.0094849272,
0.022402266,
0.0005956866,
-0.0145197278,
-0.0296016615,
-0.0126678394,
-0.0717219189,
-0.0009259341,
-0.0418597683,
-0.0208767317,
0.0389567018,
-0.0208159741,
-0.0165838338,
-0.0418154374,
-0.010575504,
-0.0116276396,
0.0068878448,
-0.0023589048,
-0.0183244143,
0.0105374204,
0.0121479835,
-0.0083937924,
0.0430026948,
0.0819684938,
0.0329089202,
0.032161355,
0.0337668508,
-0.0369074531,
-0.0168305356,
-0.0281324256,
0.0614170283,
0.0082545877,
-0.0114574349,
0.0170956608,
-0.0685588047,
-0.0691918358,
0.0022979386,
-0.0070315469,
0.0665360838,
0.0042070728,
-0.0097023603,
0.0500696041,
-0.0041266764,
0.0409094505,
-0.0513115898,
0.0461785905,
-0.0160814282,
-0.0412660278,
-0.0088191638,
-5.641422203e-33,
0.0150051676,
-0.008378624,
-0.0624999031,
-0.0046098274,
0.0238304436,
0.0175486021,
0.0003855522,
-0.0195812434,
-0.0176905766,
0.0394923016,
0.0078700911,
0.0269423351,
-0.0208305977,
0.0402011946,
-0.0697144419,
-0.0181339812,
0.0482219122,
-0.012878025,
-0.0324137509,
-0.0014484045,
0.0379235707,
0.0269022845,
0.0546526052,
-0.0557242893,
0.0379927084,
-0.0087956041,
-0.0218596812,
-0.0406013429,
-0.002965261,
0.058060769,
-0.0278296545,
0.0463106185,
0.0040450911,
-0.0209663473,
-0.0051980349,
0.0078480048,
-0.0173623804,
-0.0169300642,
-0.0057010297,
0.0309789535,
-0.0247102734,
0.0090590902,
0.0151964854,
-0.0286850426,
-0.0181415472,
-0.0155693563,
0.0001695668,
-0.0134440186,
-0.0311606731,
-0.0296222605,
-0.038359277,
0.0324278809,
-0.0146855926,
0.0043858769,
-0.0162020326,
0.0047632274,
0.038748689,
-0.020921167,
-0.053756427,
-0.0306481831,
0.0189793929,
0.0387862213,
0.0091248145,
-0.0221048966,
-0.0382645391,
0.0808725357,
0.0120064868,
0.0179992765,
-0.0172761027,
-0.000425893,
0.0013851078,
-0.0060157743,
0.0628066584,
0.0743289664,
0.0953594893,
-0.0321936458,
-0.0938687548,
-0.0073604896,
-0.0124136768,
0.0368349217,
0.0524843298,
-0.0037637225,
-0.0950997248,
0.0098313456,
-0.0385416932,
-0.090131931,
-0.0283030756,
-0.0245632119,
0.0129293175,
0.0024176263,
-0.0208740812,
0.0026449033,
-0.0308708251,
-0.0513182916,
-0.0253772959,
0.039519798,
-0.0241329242,
-0.0433556288,
0.0163782388,
0.0148970746,
0.0108072916,
-0.0092456583,
0.0065240785,
-0.019966552,
0.0519640632,
-0.0087601924,
0.1030666679,
0.0131627126,
-0.0363750421,
-0.0148840332,
-0.0107021835,
0.0128479172,
0.024681475,
0.0211337414,
0.0468234159,
-0.0117528262,
-0.0342752524,
0.0092158969,
0.0108676162,
-0.0028858236,
-0.0353605188,
0.0067210258,
-0.0500625074,
0.01409618,
-0.010016934,
-0.0658914149,
-0.0109538939,
0.0193409547,
0.0525420308,
-0.1009950414,
-0.0041606263,
-0.0202638656,
2.604e-7,
-0.0089778965,
0.038502682,
-0.0062886183,
0.0214275997,
0.0478646234,
0.0721781105,
-0.0152473683,
0.0806247219,
-0.0503530912,
-0.0242025591,
-0.063986592,
-0.0163938534,
0.0402636975,
0.0343634635,
-0.0219657756,
0.0008559976,
-0.0393152125,
0.0142456777,
-0.0346815884,
-0.0215208326,
0.0240887199,
0.1232064739,
0.0190949738,
-0.0023634271,
-0.0003093104,
-0.0352111049,
0.0308615938,
0.0089394134,
0.0081995092,
-0.0199249554,
0.0281677507,
0.0024306898,
0.040487621,
-0.003671312,
-0.0682189465,
0.0070437151,
0.0000669317,
0.0386645161,
-0.020873256,
0.0018043889,
-0.046867732,
-0.0093588447,
-0.0008620546,
-0.0250629783,
0.0559107214,
-0.0063223452,
-0.0291055851,
-0.0190593638,
-0.0006026924,
0.0091431411,
0.0405673124,
-0.0256662816,
-0.0489474125,
-0.0032372763,
0.0050191847,
0.0200476851,
-0.0046223635,
-0.0737577155,
0.0049558696,
0.0139717646,
0.0009966785,
0.0036456245,
-0.0177506227,
-0.0080306064,
0.0521552823,
0.0003968886,
-0.0302298982,
2.382700187e-34,
0.0190675966,
-0.0302737374,
-0.019012915,
-0.001157976,
0.0386737809,
0.00760986,
0.0648936406,
-0.0024931019,
0.025074156,
-0.017738875,
-0.0327123739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.03494v8 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.03494v8 | A Categorical Archive of ChatGPT Failures | 2023-02-06T04:21:59 | 2023-04-03T20:02:26 | Ali Borji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have been demonstrated to be valuable in different
fields. ChatGPT, developed by OpenAI, has been trained using massive amounts of
data and simulates human conversation by comprehending context and generating
appropriate responses. It has garnered significant attention due to its ability
to effectively answer a broad range of human inquiries, with fluent and
comprehensive answers surpassing prior public chatbots in both security and
usefulness. However, a comprehensive analysis of ChatGPT's failures is lacking,
which is the focus of this study. Eleven categories of failures, including
reasoning, factual errors, math, coding, and bias, are presented and discussed.
The risks, limitations, and societal implications of ChatGPT are also
highlighted. The goal of this study is to assist researchers and developers in
enhancing future language models and chatbots. | [
0.065221332,
0.0561264418,
-0.0136062028,
0.0307457969,
-0.0655950084,
-0.0082128849,
0.0263889078,
0.0032362521,
0.0571924113,
-0.0459654406,
0.0043585016,
-0.0276795849,
0.0155961709,
0.0410493091,
-0.0019016579,
-0.0347375758,
0.0585038476,
-0.041651357,
0.0297920182,
-0.0048056291,
0.0062165437,
0.0115216859,
-0.0328989066,
0.0881245136,
-0.0298041143,
-0.027137652,
-0.0463004783,
-0.0123589542,
-0.0000453119,
0.000438389,
0.0149448505,
0.0183395222,
-0.0069000521,
0.0957415625,
0.0000020998,
-0.0334998965,
-0.0078413049,
0.0287123732,
-0.0355347395,
0.0243631229,
0.0428560413,
0.0044053509,
-0.0272046328,
0.0712452456,
-0.0472565889,
0.0001475158,
0.058859989,
0.0750160739,
0.0662058741,
0.0941359997,
-0.0052060424,
-0.0065422175,
0.0421895161,
-0.0091780312,
0.0197815746,
-0.0739751607,
0.0213366635,
0.0278559513,
0.0238978732,
0.0167558342,
-0.0019167984,
-0.0002319557,
0.0414511748,
-0.0104730604,
-0.0321459286,
0.0433100201,
-0.0641714334,
-0.0352811664,
-0.0332714282,
0.0469346903,
-0.0023451673,
-0.0122417994,
-0.0104013104,
0.0026345092,
-0.0099088112,
-0.0236328971,
-0.0250972304,
0.0269389488,
-0.0177233461,
-0.0009180671,
-0.029639896,
0.0018963527,
0.011474018,
0.0139582679,
-0.0086525446,
0.0485345274,
0.0067543979,
-0.0072361664,
-0.0441998094,
-0.0027706355,
-0.0064078877,
-0.0651696548,
-0.0057066865,
0.0404631868,
-0.01764475,
0.0274922866,
-0.0478040501,
-0.0074454173,
0.0380927324,
-0.0797577128,
-0.0459412634,
0.0652210861,
-0.0206769295,
0.0229341816,
0.0080828629,
0.0641068891,
-0.0155784776,
0.0385830849,
0.0008704485,
-0.022709962,
-0.0631086826,
-0.035315156,
-0.0324088149,
0.0310451575,
-0.0018539424,
-0.0338737033,
-0.0433210954,
0.0398235619,
-0.0032775523,
0.0211926997,
-0.0151053425,
-0.0024872401,
-0.0347943939,
-0.0145130362,
-0.0210783295,
0.0052740462,
-0.0367473327,
0.0186173562,
0.0167054106,
-0.1161917895,
-0.006291647,
0.0255338196,
-0.0450360328,
-0.0284213647,
-0.026358299,
0.1014657021,
0.0010295693,
-0.0203568079,
-0.0309011638,
-0.022908695,
-0.0442280173,
-0.045289617,
-0.0112003898,
-0.0525403433,
0.0175307989,
-0.0012024834,
-0.0086889425,
-0.0170439444,
0.021660693,
0.0223560743,
-0.0583087541,
0.0563996844,
-0.032324221,
0.0007524328,
0.0381154306,
0.0453582741,
-0.0068616769,
0.061067082,
0.0373235941,
0.0383937322,
0.0308592618,
-0.0079719862,
0.0495835058,
0.0054707183,
-0.0035655426,
-0.0116627384,
0.0213469062,
0.010356063,
0.0137766302,
0.0181192048,
-0.0075514191,
0.0696597323,
-0.0302258991,
-0.0289772395,
0.0703349635,
0.0574404895,
-0.038961485,
0.0489147678,
-0.015738029,
0.0216554627,
0.0291491244,
-0.0138747282,
-0.0499702655,
0.0161010083,
-0.0442777276,
-0.0056007695,
-0.0050585177,
0.0125794252,
-0.0372179188,
-0.0243615434,
-0.0046561775,
-0.0313344486,
0.0496838838,
0.0066299629,
0.048312664,
-0.0027979028,
-0.0296288319,
0.0172665566,
0.0185364243,
-0.0663402453,
-0.0598280281,
-0.0990281776,
0.0076045142,
0.0528060272,
0.0582295507,
0.0053884047,
-0.0337438621,
0.0068049342,
0.0011721603,
0.048603259,
0.0613286123,
0.033674784,
-0.0010355777,
-0.0462746173,
0.0106074009,
-0.0137290452,
0.009703991,
0.0181548446,
0.0289682876,
0.0347954221,
0.005546235,
0.011162186,
-0.0091787037,
0.0296738502,
0.0003118038,
0.0061871554,
-0.0136801936,
-0.0210348777,
0.0554437302,
0.0082068965,
-0.0282472763,
0.0251591336,
0.0081778662,
0.0295223277,
-0.0324618071,
0.0128539577,
-0.0265691392,
-0.003341927,
0.0363499559,
-0.0389980525,
-0.0177038144,
0.0469147116,
-0.0428258404,
-0.0212537646,
0.0383815207,
-0.0567181036,
0.0564710088,
-0.0386626497,
-0.0072918748,
-0.0226864796,
0.0263053086,
-0.0259718448,
0.0328189023,
0.0253565963,
-0.0445062555,
-0.0212120023,
0.0344915614,
0.0303085726,
-0.0456113257,
-0.0373338535,
0.0168809071,
-0.0204918459,
0.0480684526,
0.0422816835,
0.0242892224,
-0.050553564,
-0.0205842424,
-0.1250310689,
-0.0184901822,
-0.0091376146,
0.0112387007,
0.0154098608,
0.0167484712,
-0.0210296623,
-0.03215326,
-0.0312041771,
0.0219170339,
-0.019275479,
0.0055943476,
0.0313582085,
-0.0213705171,
-0.0442851186,
-0.0369185135,
0.0093775131,
-0.0272551086,
0.024418667,
0.0043105357,
-0.0113895675,
-0.0180993881,
0.0384872817,
-0.0328316018,
0.0212585889,
-0.0197611917,
-0.0706472993,
0.0595715493,
0.0011761875,
0.0159146171,
0.0425536856,
0.0469862148,
0.0555836074,
0.0274641961,
-0.0046997005,
-0.0506068021,
0.0073475381,
0.0013212607,
-0.0544844382,
0.0117364638,
-0.020786101,
-0.0138072269,
0.0334756747,
0.021058334,
0.0101615321,
-0.0849211887,
0.0121921226,
-0.0093977051,
-0.0313473642,
-0.0376576819,
-0.01895383,
-0.0283857137,
0.0249062683,
-0.0206546746,
-0.0448493175,
0.0587199889,
-0.0258198231,
0.0104016298,
-0.0452146046,
-0.0228847507,
-0.0277309995,
0.0821041316,
-0.0275245551,
0.0225110352,
0.0332658477,
-0.036976032,
-0.0395198874,
-0.0430922806,
0.0030137785,
-0.040437378,
-0.0164131094,
-0.0499712117,
0.0204603206,
0.0043384712,
-0.0230640974,
-0.0560003407,
-0.0405507199,
-0.0373527035,
-0.0228941962,
0.0046999152,
-0.0278020315,
-0.0356969945,
0.0032687492,
0.0123257386,
0.0126658054,
-0.0181312636,
-0.0274357535,
-0.010939884,
-0.0220307969,
0.0463701338,
0.0162329189,
0.0113690132,
0.0130554605,
0.04129548,
0.105782181,
0.0431736186,
0.0177761242,
-0.0536712147,
-0.0300365742,
-0.0068498105,
-0.0097168982,
-0.0034419354,
0.0487588346,
0.0575960614,
-0.0514989719,
-0.0330878757,
0.0997766107,
0.0373778827,
-0.0418031998,
0.0027503131,
-0.022536898,
0.0191360656,
-0.0276654381,
0.0066473959,
-0.112326242,
-0.0162022524,
0.0179704353,
0.0271849111,
-0.0347174071,
-0.0016685141,
-0.0069113406,
-0.1113013253,
0.0219757333,
0.0125741158,
-0.0634826794,
-0.0473498739,
-0.0340251327,
-0.0188526046,
-0.0071948022,
0.0633447915,
0.0228349231,
0.0276265126,
-0.0067982897,
0.0088572828,
-0.0836213604,
-0.0255095772,
0.0598825626,
-0.0253108628,
0.0820326433,
0.0725480542,
0.0383965708,
-0.0009319232,
0.0233140178,
0.056084998,
0.0261136293,
0.0024760454,
0.0345037915,
0.049456872,
0.002556103,
-0.0089523997,
-0.0435811691,
0.021792829,
-0.0261824764,
-0.0410693958,
0.0295435078,
0.0455956794,
-0.0580956675,
-0.0080057243,
-0.0396032929,
0.0147082126,
0.0199694913,
0.0722902194,
0.0141872149,
-0.0140649611,
-0.0675200447,
-0.0411275327,
-0.0121310642,
-0.0144082019,
-0.0421823822,
0.0193229746,
0.0502805933,
-0.0562032647,
-0.0447993539,
-0.052769728,
-0.0052147419,
-0.000928951,
0.0082754558,
-0.0311018564,
0.0153576341,
0.0368179046,
0.0123109762,
-0.0008442033,
-0.0478671864,
0.0198475365,
-0.0383433551,
0.0317747965,
0.0008315197,
-0.0472975373,
0.0107912095,
0.027925726,
-0.0728248432,
-0.0499852039,
0.0106459539,
0.0557840653,
0.0344144739,
-0.0058587533,
-0.0646058545,
-0.0181918088,
-0.0053030718,
0.0430131555,
-0.0476548113,
-0.0074055251,
0.044353988,
0.0264399964,
0.0270322897,
0.0112200044,
-0.0414151847,
-0.0056224456,
-0.0146018434,
0.0101990467,
-0.0428056791,
-0.0305373855,
0.0388758443,
0.0364251547,
0.0346853808,
0.0217387229,
0.0226327106,
0.0156924073,
0.0122419586,
-0.0577816218,
0.0022472821,
-0.0236298498,
0.0101008099,
0.0102442764,
0.0087564392,
0.0200524386,
-0.0292229112,
-0.0505201295,
0.0208679065,
0.0168719403,
0.0179129019,
0.0244922657,
0.0567402244,
0.0131443506,
-0.0178907085,
-0.0364216231,
0.0078666443,
-0.0154419001,
0.0283292737,
0.0081108538,
0.0683617219,
0.0050569177,
-0.022307178,
0.0136098992,
0.0284042489,
-0.0994095355,
-0.0893386528,
0.0283759292,
0.0770895183,
0.0447559059,
0.0484451093,
0.0154701564,
-0.065245308,
0.0107371975,
-0.0317600407,
0.0544189773,
0.0007140422,
-0.0329217762,
0.0026200411,
-0.0012813357,
-0.0360103436,
-0.0114221741,
0.0738406405,
-0.023688104,
0.0296560563,
0.0102404673,
-0.0122540453,
-0.0228875224,
-0.0275339317,
-0.0013851854,
0.0207953993,
-0.0359201431,
-0.0302008335,
-0.042512998,
-0.0509414524,
-0.0407296717,
0.0177969337,
0.0481393822,
0.0123000657,
0.0373785533,
0.0697714165,
-0.0075619421,
-0.0042107296,
-0.0510037988,
-0.0054908507,
-0.0299893077,
-0.0041992706,
-0.0070028384,
-6.277935496e-33,
0.0037932375,
-0.0296919253,
0.0235374589,
0.0261664633,
-0.0277937707,
-0.0138026141,
-0.0448163673,
0.0271392707,
-0.0606731698,
-0.0084775928,
-0.0261224005,
0.0450310819,
0.0179775469,
0.0209261011,
0.0128674386,
-0.0126986476,
0.0172133502,
0.0003820319,
-0.0082012732,
0.0267428719,
0.0345803909,
-0.0044571082,
0.0214838311,
-0.0944957733,
0.0429809913,
0.0042525642,
-0.0380425602,
-0.0191232339,
-0.0384679213,
0.0486064479,
-0.0191781782,
0.0464351214,
0.0027852806,
-0.0158479307,
-0.00886722,
0.0270750187,
-0.00607744,
-0.0278047509,
-0.0016505806,
0.0256087165,
-0.0069882954,
-0.0384168066,
0.0181923993,
-0.0359516442,
-0.0270350408,
-0.0031134414,
0.0162692908,
-0.0177462865,
-0.0163956471,
0.0341854393,
-0.0425726809,
0.0114155468,
-0.0240356885,
-0.0247264616,
-0.0224232823,
0.0433983058,
-0.0182129312,
-0.0264704283,
-0.0227876529,
0.0331422202,
0.0040741069,
-0.029690424,
0.0459356122,
-0.0144804753,
-0.0008280474,
0.0529574938,
0.0651445091,
0.0037629257,
-0.0563459471,
-0.0331979133,
0.0086247073,
0.0182613004,
0.0668633059,
0.0631766021,
0.0062610651,
-0.0514706299,
-0.068420589,
0.0073626614,
0.0599026009,
0.0412086099,
0.0483447835,
0.0192704424,
-0.0864035636,
-0.0177684221,
0.0248436332,
0.0330603607,
-0.0308859777,
-0.0535579026,
0.0221576318,
-0.023218656,
0.0139581878,
-0.0269928556,
0.0336770266,
-0.0670741126,
0.0279909503,
0.0049496409,
-0.0189594999,
0.008604832,
-0.0122193135,
0.0386968143,
-0.0396876074,
-0.0101663554,
0.023511041,
-0.0037949644,
0.0278711356,
0.0133413384,
-0.0062879636,
0.0262556449,
-0.0313314125,
-0.0109720854,
-0.0216790624,
0.0256753992,
0.0312630422,
0.0140250614,
0.0137220286,
-0.0104136327,
-0.009030018,
0.0266588721,
-0.0030755978,
0.0102102263,
-0.0534281768,
0.0081975237,
-0.0262770932,
-0.0206526946,
-0.0178340152,
0.0114944419,
-0.0475751087,
0.0160731245,
0.0075464263,
-0.0533037297,
-0.0246012677,
-0.0083985906,
2.778e-7,
0.0177702885,
0.039027825,
0.038564831,
0.0250780396,
0.017873019,
0.0528514944,
-0.0119644133,
0.0592997149,
0.0050791148,
0.0261955392,
0.0181026552,
0.0341630392,
0.0820995718,
0.0369467288,
-0.0608435012,
-0.033923164,
-0.0889249966,
-0.0473087765,
-0.051265642,
0.0440917462,
0.0881130174,
0.0965191424,
0.0126444763,
0.0063376632,
0.0132240867,
-0.032029707,
0.0375447199,
-0.0152575057,
-0.0187792946,
0.0203950685,
0.0232987646,
0.0443833619,
0.0161863435,
0.0260575321,
0.018392399,
-0.0380818136,
0.0001547276,
0.0395593494,
-0.0102385497,
-0.0453631356,
-0.0097395899,
-0.013514475,
0.0003194769,
-0.0774521306,
0.0703057796,
-0.043583218,
-0.0569755621,
-0.0243334863,
0.0109442854,
0.0145112174,
0.0444370992,
-0.0017839456,
-0.0161155052,
-0.00499867,
0.0086109685,
0.0008831664,
0.0025894307,
-0.0531187542,
0.0178993475,
-0.0126705412,
-0.0580161922,
-0.0577875376,
-0.0215659086,
0.0187217295,
0.0473713465,
-0.0118267918,
0.0025390543,
2.215527901e-34,
0.026417546,
-0.0306165349,
-0.0123413159,
0.0332677923,
0.0492228754,
0.0333285332,
0.0676271543,
0.0211765245,
0.0220447946,
-0.0041615423,
-0.0403686091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02500v1 | TempEL: Linking Dynamically Evolving and Newly Emerging Entities | 2023-02-05T22:34:36 | 2023-02-05T22:34:36 | Klim Zaporojets, Lucie-Aimee Kaffee, Johannes Deleu, Thomas Demeester, Chris Develder, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | In our continuously evolving world, entities change over time and new,
previously non-existing or unknown, entities appear. We study how this
evolutionary scenario impacts the performance on a well established entity
linking (EL) task. For that study, we introduce TempEL, an entity linking
dataset that consists of time-stratified English Wikipedia snapshots from 2013
to 2022, from which we collect both anchor mentions of entities, and these
target entities' descriptions. By capturing such temporal aspects, our newly
introduced TempEL resource contrasts with currently existing entity linking
datasets, which are composed of fixed mentions linked to a single static
version of a target Knowledge Base (e.g., Wikipedia 2010 for CoNLL-AIDA).
Indeed, for each of our collected temporal snapshots, TempEL contains links to
entities that are continual, i.e., occur in all of the years, as well as
completely new entities that appear for the first time at some point. Thus, we
enable to quantify the performance of current state-of-the-art EL models for:
(i) entities that are subject to changes over time in their Knowledge Base
descriptions as well as their mentions' contexts, and (ii) newly created
entities that were previously non-existing (e.g., at the time the EL model was
trained). Our experimental results show that in terms of temporal performance
degradation, (i) continual entities suffer a decrease of up to 3.1% EL
accuracy, while (ii) for new entities this accuracy drop is up to 17.9%. This
highlights the challenge of the introduced TempEL dataset and opens new
research prospects in the area of time-evolving entity disambiguation. | [
0.0418315381,
0.0091969436,
-0.013582183,
-0.0217116289,
0.0056074089,
0.0407695472,
-0.0249574501,
-0.0092666121,
0.017370183,
-0.0457592644,
0.048449792,
0.0064248606,
0.0072429562,
-0.0212585274,
0.0314093456,
-0.0401174948,
0.0572948568,
0.0039269691,
-0.0453418233,
-0.0182907116,
-0.0238033887,
0.0058061704,
-0.0375263803,
-0.011584606,
-0.0152137019,
-0.0126615111,
-0.0317596756,
-0.0069581862,
0.0602681711,
-0.013456923,
-0.0124014951,
0.0562133975,
-0.0024562848,
0.0633729473,
0.0000018472,
-0.0825803578,
-0.0097802971,
-0.0167661645,
-0.0738027841,
0.0123123238,
-0.0067963097,
-0.0220354944,
-0.0028145481,
-0.0505398251,
-0.013920092,
-0.0406016149,
0.007198907,
-0.0181283355,
0.047028672,
0.0419496894,
0.0133076543,
-0.0372615904,
0.0229685064,
-0.0265420433,
-0.0047974023,
-0.0400787406,
0.0369759947,
-0.0251615904,
-0.0247248765,
0.0006203479,
-0.0188382789,
0.0524347536,
0.0115788113,
0.0018852663,
0.0323496647,
0.0401303917,
-0.034212172,
0.0045501408,
0.0201325305,
0.0709145591,
0.0369538851,
-0.0233873185,
0.0304401219,
0.0448205397,
-0.0018543007,
0.0147311985,
0.0071937311,
-0.0301138535,
-0.0193957482,
-0.0123357754,
0.0191982165,
-0.0222102851,
0.0487234443,
0.0394771695,
-0.0199404713,
0.0076137609,
0.0157990027,
-0.0234507564,
0.0027520135,
0.0132602537,
0.0063860016,
-0.0457363129,
0.0097178388,
0.0115281446,
-0.0268516801,
0.0364602134,
-0.0628229827,
-0.0096866414,
0.0212521981,
-0.0269254334,
-0.0862459987,
-0.0111505035,
0.0198558662,
0.0842103437,
-0.0382560194,
-0.0145364925,
-0.0310222153,
-0.0555357412,
0.0248246696,
-0.0374148339,
-0.0815852731,
0.0163708143,
0.001134537,
0.038867373,
-0.0168410018,
0.0069178282,
-0.0388281494,
-0.0128443222,
0.0022408941,
0.0578142591,
-0.0244100001,
-0.026224751,
-0.0234434567,
0.0163332839,
-0.0624584369,
0.0148662832,
-0.0366512239,
-0.0236123689,
-0.0378735177,
-0.0170396734,
-0.0015143445,
-0.0143837007,
0.0024989671,
-0.0464966632,
0.0119131915,
0.038815856,
0.0380771719,
-0.010978139,
-0.0632842183,
-0.0334911011,
0.025919985,
-0.0220299251,
-0.0284478776,
-0.0389654525,
0.0405529365,
0.0055602156,
-0.0124039613,
-0.068314977,
-0.0047647222,
-0.0145269446,
-0.0673375875,
0.0800369009,
-0.0752123147,
-0.0070769619,
0.0152489124,
0.0024662544,
0.0406219624,
0.0642291605,
0.0447409749,
-0.0546151586,
0.0508244336,
0.0574960001,
-0.0690006614,
0.0133959996,
0.0492501482,
0.0209962185,
0.0422988571,
0.0042741708,
-0.0382070467,
0.05277941,
0.028380651,
0.0378019772,
-0.0083983978,
-0.0567501746,
0.009935285,
-0.021572791,
0.0118905129,
0.03663975,
0.0532823019,
-0.0162117705,
0.0064764326,
-0.0173677877,
-0.0336003862,
-0.0050419122,
-0.0230156239,
0.0027394709,
-0.0195129514,
0.0451297462,
-0.0190433692,
0.0198496021,
0.0250289682,
-0.0081293536,
-0.008206212,
-0.0051733912,
0.0540957339,
0.0180345271,
-0.0117424782,
0.1242641434,
0.0504378863,
0.0102063483,
0.0100382157,
0.006275102,
0.0002816149,
0.0779641122,
0.0332013033,
0.0075901598,
-0.0595015474,
-0.0393124186,
0.0236542486,
0.0490807071,
0.037096478,
-0.0642701089,
0.0147458063,
0.0005747454,
-0.0186480507,
0.0230242927,
0.0015399015,
0.0022856211,
0.0950116143,
0.0811719224,
0.0347487964,
-0.0626981705,
0.0221307855,
0.0467233285,
-0.0367073081,
0.0194030628,
-0.0499390177,
0.0271504223,
-0.0500989109,
0.0477837138,
0.00170774,
-0.0460763201,
0.0346859246,
0.0009436639,
0.0160844401,
0.0222940147,
0.0342557132,
-0.0309273917,
0.0756714121,
-0.0016635975,
-0.0381754711,
-0.025826294,
-0.030839283,
-0.0382081792,
0.0317651667,
-0.0046948614,
0.0548833609,
0.0107809128,
0.019148346,
-0.0207908712,
0.0144818788,
-0.0350492671,
0.100561887,
-0.0150117101,
-0.0002210505,
0.0418291129,
0.0192444958,
-0.0050690728,
-0.0236790236,
-0.055361852,
0.0075076595,
0.0458311588,
-0.0455662385,
0.0097770225,
-0.0153104486,
-0.0932529345,
0.0081169903,
-0.0423225611,
0.0155975744,
-0.0131633114,
0.021235982,
0.0113396384,
0.0067092464,
-0.0165061913,
0.012962305,
0.0522913411,
-0.0044763465,
-0.0414939262,
-0.0030578326,
0.0209593549,
0.0315121859,
-0.0061232583,
-0.0496764891,
-0.0113104479,
-0.0219330825,
0.0383246019,
0.0250199828,
-0.0957444385,
-0.0334181115,
0.0133429281,
-0.0694964081,
-0.0065019317,
-0.0133718615,
0.0483352281,
-0.0227744058,
0.0181860998,
0.0588455275,
0.0098199416,
-0.0215227827,
0.0289057419,
0.0057205488,
-0.02197586,
-0.0546722002,
0.0358100235,
0.0031652306,
0.0375884064,
-0.0339127406,
-0.0103585441,
-0.0031906606,
0.0146450317,
-0.0419525802,
-0.014168134,
-0.0257697068,
0.0458786786,
-0.0098042237,
0.0051587042,
0.0130501017,
0.0220851004,
-0.0182444416,
-0.0110104904,
-0.0292272288,
0.0001462528,
0.0358818099,
0.0370372385,
0.036901515,
-0.0095675169,
0.0158505011,
0.0069159609,
0.0558431409,
-0.004093755,
0.0063337968,
0.0433934964,
-0.0169291049,
-0.0302639268,
0.0601200052,
0.0166411307,
-0.001149137,
0.0646210164,
-0.0425414257,
0.0639586896,
0.0207941104,
0.0222217161,
-0.0139020644,
-0.0299977902,
-0.0195904933,
-0.008114228,
-0.0258621499,
-0.0264660418,
-0.0111548547,
-0.0036970975,
0.0058288053,
-0.0006326228,
0.0402625911,
-0.0500107855,
-0.0044911462,
-0.0035988907,
0.0570943356,
0.0154070202,
0.0517466143,
0.014411659,
0.0177106615,
0.0048077684,
0.0661324188,
-0.0398311764,
-0.0161692556,
-0.0179277919,
-0.0220274348,
-0.1027415246,
-0.0607156679,
-0.0203952603,
0.0014864247,
-0.0302103758,
-0.0044053919,
0.0920032412,
0.0430741385,
-0.0319254063,
0.0046594739,
0.0395955518,
0.0055785067,
0.0070026643,
-0.0016880744,
-0.0853065029,
-0.0131003791,
-0.0101928832,
-0.0093685221,
0.0122150825,
-0.1217291728,
-0.0063204425,
-0.0994976386,
-0.0400970578,
-0.03510461,
-0.0119988443,
0.0136858812,
-0.041224055,
0.0244187247,
-0.0368231386,
-0.008959421,
0.0110033918,
0.0017158135,
0.0376024507,
0.0077466811,
-0.0073945732,
-0.0592427664,
0.0229759291,
-0.0733551681,
0.0952208266,
0.0118363509,
0.0397532843,
0.0022355304,
0.0037395782,
0.0048880479,
-0.0414151028,
-0.0367373899,
-0.0150501793,
0.0626065657,
-0.0078039421,
0.0048240237,
-0.0059601078,
-0.0274424069,
-0.0146910558,
0.0038101908,
-0.0072023198,
0.0425445549,
0.0318739228,
0.021776123,
-0.0136671225,
-0.034402959,
0.0031460533,
0.0447103456,
-0.0200265273,
0.0040986901,
-0.000050489,
0.0050382419,
0.0104786139,
-0.0235775858,
-0.0007958813,
0.0077829654,
-0.0797326788,
-0.0097208358,
-0.0778844804,
-0.0515055284,
0.0100186719,
0.0336561389,
0.0255028047,
0.0383275077,
0.0037621178,
-0.0003245144,
-0.072201483,
0.0191555005,
-0.0221756492,
0.0146362754,
0.0028968772,
-0.0414898098,
0.0494374149,
0.0470821001,
-0.013450833,
0.033197619,
-0.0933456123,
-0.0463234335,
0.0381073654,
-0.016456062,
0.0223072059,
0.0663829446,
-0.0397066511,
-0.0201600101,
0.0418534167,
0.0170427524,
-0.0000252156,
0.0318761356,
-0.0260205697,
0.0531561151,
-0.0073990538,
0.067135483,
-0.061876405,
-0.041121874,
-0.0268011242,
0.0379923023,
-0.0693004355,
-0.0103781009,
-0.024360735,
0.0055084229,
-0.0017741326,
-0.0255632307,
-0.002193951,
0.0118667865,
-0.0029403691,
0.0304533709,
-0.0061375936,
0.0385278724,
-0.0106914164,
0.0009261169,
0.020690335,
-0.0305803902,
0.0665478259,
0.0349193662,
0.0249466021,
-0.0574057549,
-0.0233973246,
0.024304891,
-0.0009666647,
0.0054686684,
-0.0068844412,
0.0074200085,
0.0130759329,
0.0358729772,
0.0396962427,
-0.0378497839,
-0.0182730947,
0.0097154872,
-0.012347389,
-0.0233832169,
0.0004262473,
-0.0307421703,
0.0178728141,
0.0066749267,
0.0235931575,
0.0682078078,
0.0146285277,
0.113224268,
0.0159338471,
-0.0258433614,
0.0292319413,
-0.0179649349,
0.0057395822,
-0.0009321095,
0.0179709382,
-0.0005809449,
-0.0099160718,
0.0773808807,
0.0612699986,
-0.0070329159,
0.099398084,
-0.0042250799,
-0.0128831835,
-0.0229981486,
-0.0084288716,
-0.0846437141,
-0.0405701585,
0.0002185608,
0.0052216575,
-0.0516981184,
-0.0515284613,
0.06143016,
-0.0197745282,
0.0017721005,
0.0341983363,
0.0326214209,
0.012401388,
0.0509596057,
-0.0363992788,
-0.0131336534,
-0.0061476314,
0.0233750176,
-0.0305274948,
-0.0288626254,
-5.630282557e-33,
-0.0451906137,
0.0220621545,
0.014507371,
-0.0232743807,
-0.0714517757,
0.016567748,
-0.0136382682,
-0.0046917638,
-0.0641606003,
-0.0214817915,
0.0069201556,
0.0617172904,
0.0066166529,
-0.0220405348,
-0.0044380273,
-0.0726236925,
0.0322339125,
0.0176174957,
-0.0096650776,
0.0119548589,
0.0385802649,
0.0251446925,
0.0619403422,
-0.0624178015,
0.0648601577,
0.0162775628,
0.0056964215,
0.0279453285,
0.0421316177,
0.0578001328,
0.0129339462,
0.0452657081,
-0.0001007271,
-0.0364324115,
-0.005793408,
-0.0710907802,
-0.152060166,
-0.0078768432,
-0.0106737027,
0.0315536,
0.0270166453,
-0.038776204,
0.0498149469,
0.0325846113,
0.0124625973,
-0.0051874346,
0.0492501184,
0.0047245286,
-0.032732103,
-0.0590683147,
-0.0093553029,
0.0444411598,
-0.0112037519,
0.0403166078,
-0.0120270438,
-0.0224764906,
0.0288447961,
-0.0369994491,
-0.0915236846,
0.0077811377,
0.0269982889,
-0.0213852692,
0.0174204037,
-0.0429919623,
0.0271675866,
0.0379431099,
0.0090234932,
0.0019176921,
-0.0271818116,
0.0242003519,
0.0253582448,
-0.0301840305,
-0.0371784084,
0.0457968414,
-0.0078237075,
-0.0182118639,
-0.0535683781,
0.0289269593,
0.0555551052,
0.0418154523,
-0.0364394188,
-0.0163368415,
-0.0271225907,
-0.0026473892,
-0.0385076553,
0.0120461928,
-0.01145152,
-0.0338976458,
-0.0047731497,
0.0001094486,
-0.0493415631,
0.0352935828,
-0.0347418748,
-0.0182505548,
-0.0573077127,
0.0171351824,
-0.000835827,
0.0124573158,
0.0211252645,
0.0046534692,
-0.0391589515,
-0.0044220411,
0.0132763786,
0.0196261797,
0.0283886585,
-0.0148951299,
0.0105631268,
0.018213274,
-0.0422870032,
0.0098804366,
0.0229008906,
0.0046917466,
-0.0374581665,
-0.0501653403,
0.0139415096,
-0.0051622353,
0.0073282081,
-0.037697345,
0.1173750982,
0.0076141404,
-0.0163908545,
0.0473311134,
0.051880464,
0.0139666088,
-0.0124414414,
-0.0173655376,
0.014047863,
0.0448006131,
-0.02162873,
-0.0852858871,
-0.0172957573,
-0.0108389538,
2.555e-7,
0.0389818437,
0.0417599231,
0.017400071,
0.016358478,
0.0111732539,
-0.0345697217,
0.0277126078,
0.0209807977,
-0.0405803956,
-0.0194026548,
-0.0241772067,
-0.0080735721,
-0.0137688573,
0.0387371816,
-0.0535272993,
-0.0504186153,
-0.0100264866,
0.0199603401,
-0.0698423088,
-0.0088805147,
0.0093795732,
0.0411168188,
0.059165094,
-0.0106491968,
-0.026652975,
-0.0306211114,
0.0458577424,
-0.0051541459,
-0.0001681971,
0.0118269064,
0.016421238,
0.0545104332,
-0.0024587074,
0.0451367833,
-0.0325533263,
0.0383146219,
-0.0104532177,
-0.0045078099,
0.018956054,
0.0012353321,
-0.0080575319,
-0.0710147172,
0.0105553307,
-0.0077249398,
0.0754717365,
-0.0017287176,
0.0246601161,
0.0657209978,
-0.0361651145,
0.0276891179,
-0.0046252054,
0.001000519,
-0.0485923775,
0.0231175553,
-0.0178185422,
0.0201794673,
-0.0240053292,
-0.1047484949,
-0.0099347029,
0.0275066178,
-0.0171769466,
-0.0328395553,
0.0319977105,
-0.0463525578,
-0.013671401,
-0.0381974541,
0.0237803664,
2.009472466e-34,
-0.0202832241,
0.024572866,
-0.0210668929,
0.0309481267,
0.0150685143,
-0.0372934043,
-0.0131795239,
-0.0388485678,
0.0158533175,
-0.0268518087,
-0.0014373042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02479v1 | Hatemongers ride on echo chambers to escalate hate speech diffusion | 2023-02-05T20:30:48 | 2023-02-05T20:30:48 | Vasu Goel, Dhruv Sahnan, Subhabrata Dutta, Anil Bandhakavi, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Recent years have witnessed a swelling rise of hateful and abusive content
over online social networks. While detection and moderation of hate speech have
been the early go-to countermeasures, the solution requires a deeper
exploration of the dynamics of hate generation and propagation. We analyze more
than 32 million posts from over 6.8 million users across three popular online
social networks to investigate the interrelations between hateful behavior,
information dissemination, and polarised organization mediated by echo
chambers. We find that hatemongers play a more crucial role in governing the
spread of information compared to singled-out hateful content. This observation
holds for both the growth of information cascades as well as the conglomeration
of hateful actors. Dissection of the core-wise distribution of these networks
points towards the fact that hateful users acquire a more well-connected
position in the social network and often flock together to build up information
cascades. We observe that this cohesion is far from mere organized behavior;
instead, in these networks, hatemongers dominate the echo chambers -- groups of
users actively align themselves to specific ideological positions. The observed
dominance of hateful users to inflate information cascades is primarily via
user interactions amplified within these echo chambers. We conclude our study
with a cautionary note that popularity-based recommendation of content is
susceptible to be exploited by hatemongers given their potential to escalate
content popularity via echo-chambered interactions. | [
0.0551633611,
0.0357874036,
-0.0269445349,
0.0062639317,
-0.0182547513,
-0.0139569668,
0.0144985756,
-0.0322066583,
0.0210916791,
0.0134736244,
-0.0041324669,
-0.0023679892,
0.0456323549,
0.0080437716,
0.0283549689,
-0.0224156175,
0.0008757123,
0.044130668,
-0.0029589629,
-0.0090084765,
0.0625506565,
0.0121496283,
0.0293140206,
0.0075498722,
-0.0120681468,
0.013909081,
0.0593591556,
0.017448483,
0.0413566343,
-0.0151085341,
0.0216492526,
0.0146252718,
-0.0023908301,
0.0270979535,
0.0000020266,
-0.0116675086,
0.0111534158,
-0.0317819938,
0.0160333961,
-0.0530538931,
0.0596108139,
-0.022409467,
0.0086624594,
0.0429571271,
-0.017801661,
0.0316268392,
-0.0059385309,
0.0005642029,
0.0542992279,
0.0018044757,
-0.0268753935,
-0.0517165288,
0.03382596,
0.0167387743,
0.024421256,
0.06478744,
0.0081414804,
-0.0654376596,
-0.0379054025,
-0.0067790649,
0.0015948785,
-0.0084761744,
0.0248754099,
-0.0076276497,
0.0669574216,
-0.0348249115,
0.0226987116,
-0.030174775,
0.0122790132,
0.0395845771,
-0.0128631704,
0.0029388978,
0.0333228782,
0.0143544609,
-0.0009623222,
-0.0033381262,
-0.0080490699,
0.0193906277,
-0.0299719293,
-0.0240100697,
0.0153640676,
0.0548580624,
0.0627029985,
0.0427600145,
0.0366111733,
0.018803779,
-0.0135859651,
-0.0259706918,
0.0010369672,
-0.034533482,
0.0153112747,
-0.0017217743,
0.0463909879,
0.0014332794,
-0.0092141312,
0.0232948065,
-0.0231767502,
-0.0189806707,
0.0013870095,
-0.0792390853,
0.0039258525,
0.0091743618,
0.0241165198,
0.0238333326,
0.0407564007,
-0.0233603809,
-0.0384588502,
0.0014398417,
0.0085942792,
0.0399887711,
0.0170809701,
0.0267186761,
0.0286656525,
-0.0220119637,
0.0385369435,
0.0144304363,
-0.0176161602,
-0.0253996495,
-0.0631909743,
0.0100476323,
-0.0607085712,
0.0231752954,
0.0517773256,
0.0076886034,
-0.0212067664,
0.0083945757,
-0.0402043946,
0.0050971555,
0.0027669854,
0.0061919573,
-0.0005021201,
0.024027653,
0.0093323756,
-0.0047757067,
0.0317412429,
0.0331277214,
0.0317072198,
-0.0126069421,
-0.0023586659,
-0.0484614708,
0.0136035811,
-0.0067844545,
0.0043622442,
-0.0817705765,
0.0147087798,
0.0328507386,
-0.0305383876,
-0.0128723998,
-0.0132532418,
0.0109891966,
-0.044196751,
0.0588213727,
-0.0037734883,
-0.0227685217,
0.0627074912,
0.0590938441,
0.0123208677,
-0.0099825831,
-0.0405372009,
0.0493483655,
0.0409236103,
0.0032178985,
0.0014872578,
0.0398847163,
0.0533046015,
0.0389661863,
-0.0011957015,
0.0131153762,
-0.0555038564,
-0.0717258453,
-0.0075627645,
0.0137212304,
-0.0150106279,
-0.0340423211,
0.0404323451,
0.0444350056,
-0.0810537711,
-0.0140864924,
0.025880428,
-0.0037182951,
-0.0473495349,
-0.0475322232,
-0.0335225798,
-0.0251734313,
-0.0033787275,
-0.0476438664,
0.053620562,
0.077662684,
-0.03208277,
0.0100633213,
-0.02937451,
-0.0060243802,
0.0929325446,
-0.035521958,
-0.0268833283,
0.0179040879,
-0.0041023046,
0.0286533795,
0.0553442985,
0.0309835095,
0.0320087075,
-0.006414542,
-0.0095750196,
0.0694306791,
0.0213535707,
0.0136054279,
-0.0170770288,
-0.0479541123,
0.005831237,
0.0168450139,
0.0040444983,
-0.0053956751,
-0.0485032089,
-0.0184437092,
0.0173121877,
0.0932712629,
0.0083443327,
-0.0008123577,
0.0531030893,
0.0196919441,
-0.0253595524,
0.0432082899,
-0.0156048965,
-0.0247449074,
0.0290581472,
0.0390094519,
-0.0199158937,
0.0085602598,
0.0599779114,
0.0184277967,
-0.0178170651,
-0.0327930078,
-0.0081743915,
0.0033967013,
-0.081939362,
-0.0044765226,
-0.0506512411,
0.0771596432,
0.0172304865,
-0.0380774587,
-0.0495220758,
0.0315047018,
0.0644311979,
0.0370368585,
0.0891276151,
0.0269316081,
-0.0272025391,
0.0248592738,
-0.0501858145,
-0.0344026573,
-0.0012060555,
-0.0103889871,
0.0639866814,
-0.0443277918,
-0.0003372535,
0.044859536,
-0.0666308627,
0.0461131297,
0.0916262195,
-0.0059027644,
-0.0980414972,
-0.015180707,
0.0023021381,
0.0057420391,
-0.0507863909,
-0.0177623481,
0.0292595271,
-0.0187120251,
-0.023750199,
-0.0118696569,
-0.0120477062,
0.037464004,
0.0229684543,
0.0124562448,
0.0714716017,
-0.0140683306,
0.0128430724,
0.0166137349,
0.0015362704,
-0.0041889134,
-0.0370833725,
-0.0375794098,
-0.0645054728,
-0.0091025038,
-0.0036793242,
0.013854173,
0.0320537724,
-0.0259053428,
0.0671012178,
-0.0220571756,
-0.0912638381,
-0.0173659828,
-0.0302263983,
-0.0146523779,
0.0119659994,
-0.015595681,
-0.0161546469,
-0.0087282723,
0.0439963192,
0.0995890647,
0.0261976328,
0.061708875,
-0.0144282421,
-0.0362584479,
-0.0399750397,
0.0651084334,
-0.0601009838,
-0.0237460304,
0.0090286545,
0.0294893701,
0.0816222355,
0.0008058476,
-0.0146893952,
0.0098004183,
-0.0720380917,
-0.0102208536,
-0.0453758091,
-0.071167253,
0.0192633122,
-0.0281619038,
-0.04950637,
-0.0419047363,
-0.0029061793,
0.0128134657,
0.0592367202,
0.0358572416,
-0.04863346,
0.015356862,
0.0296590216,
0.0254136194,
0.0424104594,
-0.0567929633,
-0.0123246927,
0.0026193839,
-0.0424498245,
0.0891924948,
-0.0146055203,
-0.0672395453,
0.0028598041,
0.026023997,
0.0341363586,
-0.010971576,
-0.0069386959,
-0.0784961879,
-0.0439203233,
-0.0475932099,
0.0746152848,
-0.0308398716,
0.0041719801,
-0.0067540556,
0.0819489732,
-0.0448465124,
0.03705718,
-0.0344620198,
0.0222771931,
-0.0030989812,
-0.0125459945,
-0.0479236916,
0.0786673501,
-0.0225501675,
-0.0371211879,
0.0445244871,
0.0086356169,
0.0331550874,
-0.0253693908,
-0.0093822433,
0.0111969756,
0.0343388841,
0.0109007787,
-0.0141461156,
0.0238300171,
0.029820798,
0.0288094506,
0.0418249518,
0.0088155186,
-0.0161451995,
-0.0200552475,
0.0008040497,
0.0481730141,
0.0107389474,
-0.004445733,
-0.0958862454,
0.0345233344,
-0.0141705405,
0.0127365356,
-0.0381449386,
-0.0450514071,
0.0023791227,
-0.0453099906,
-0.0048427875,
-0.0075282953,
0.0072993315,
-0.0451326147,
-0.0174870249,
-0.0072163632,
0.0072175958,
-0.005219175,
-0.0382184088,
0.030981373,
0.0094893211,
-0.0306356642,
-0.0649086162,
0.0672234893,
0.0210509021,
-0.0694852024,
0.0227476228,
0.0079970229,
0.0222158097,
-0.0136288265,
0.025608385,
0.0690312982,
0.0112599162,
-0.0260379761,
-0.044013679,
0.0622912236,
0.0198902935,
-0.0031132875,
-0.0543027818,
0.0346546061,
0.007359799,
0.027362911,
0.0109138163,
0.0358418114,
0.0629118532,
-0.050820712,
-0.0310958046,
0.0338099264,
0.0029256633,
0.0241654962,
0.0101525728,
-0.0370973572,
0.0682346374,
-0.0564925112,
0.0288365725,
-0.0210334696,
-0.1028471664,
-0.0272115041,
0.0184727255,
0.0267322939,
-0.0263062567,
0.0088385521,
-0.0194392018,
0.0036632535,
0.0292812847,
-0.0005954041,
0.023803845,
-0.0644592345,
0.0229492784,
-0.0526746437,
0.0258950684,
0.0333625749,
0.0215390958,
0.0050736731,
-0.032550294,
0.0083960798,
-0.0556755289,
0.0323508494,
-0.0005889713,
-0.0240007099,
0.0610839054,
0.038277816,
0.0095134014,
0.0438815318,
-0.0198712349,
-0.0111675281,
0.0829605013,
0.0163974073,
-0.0204931945,
0.0048819287,
0.0037140108,
-0.0239223056,
0.0427971557,
-0.0010436999,
0.0036129639,
0.0181552637,
0.0671855658,
-0.100648731,
-0.0493021086,
0.0150540201,
-0.0434641093,
-0.0342672355,
-0.004447992,
0.0069158925,
-0.0032417176,
-0.0270762313,
-0.0248878412,
-0.0039601936,
-0.0579969846,
0.0348658785,
-0.0136134606,
0.0046830624,
-0.0164924134,
-0.03768491,
-0.0396986753,
-0.0044986699,
0.0258088354,
-0.0616340898,
-0.0001080682,
-0.012070491,
-0.0115260351,
0.0462124795,
-0.0040152702,
0.0288596414,
0.0480681807,
-0.0228301864,
0.0007042938,
-0.0055457614,
-0.0402431488,
-0.0159290228,
-0.0193828642,
0.0459744968,
-0.0192878991,
0.0043843812,
-0.0691432059,
0.0152072394,
-0.0270695314,
-0.0444878414,
0.007400373,
0.0405062288,
0.04144511,
-0.0182299856,
-0.0079583339,
-0.0109733008,
-0.0339134932,
-0.021551447,
-0.0273445975,
0.0529506244,
-0.019641459,
0.0411987118,
0.002139759,
-0.0114422953,
0.0209044684,
0.062101908,
-0.0550313629,
0.0069450913,
0.0023925041,
-0.0062339995,
0.0698433369,
0.0090362374,
0.0235476885,
-0.0299527124,
-0.0263113268,
-0.0104864705,
-0.0383899547,
0.0159139801,
-0.013189055,
-0.0253876075,
0.0282079596,
-0.0093353027,
0.0603801422,
0.0242390931,
0.0364850052,
-0.0418013781,
-0.0582223721,
0.0496789031,
-6.038135383e-33,
0.0213533677,
-0.0423996709,
-0.0306211375,
-0.030457275,
-0.016020976,
-0.0115812849,
0.0265025813,
0.0188957043,
-0.0214357581,
0.0135354986,
-0.0056227846,
0.0176230799,
-0.0039347527,
0.0068472698,
-0.0069749835,
-0.0288061555,
0.0064749573,
-0.0152099188,
-0.0016052687,
0.0008297232,
0.0395044126,
-0.0154582271,
-0.0609805472,
-0.0596327484,
0.0191297513,
-0.0334094837,
-0.0094166081,
0.01098675,
0.0294798929,
-0.0004133398,
0.0096028028,
0.0242575537,
0.0247322768,
-0.0527800284,
0.0012932507,
0.0450945571,
-0.0271251909,
-0.0083581554,
0.0329529271,
-0.0425346009,
0.0000365969,
0.0117799789,
0.0311073158,
0.0061808652,
-0.0099041983,
-0.0179439392,
0.0186405536,
0.0456114635,
0.0055030836,
-0.0036439821,
-0.0453158505,
0.0234480854,
-0.0456651971,
0.0171259642,
-0.0595771186,
0.0080369413,
0.0430274382,
0.0099094594,
-0.095235087,
0.0373815969,
-0.0565498322,
-0.0082970783,
-0.0160070397,
-0.0219987761,
0.0024198121,
0.058853291,
0.0152761992,
0.064873606,
-0.0271750856,
0.0372671299,
-0.0309600923,
0.0520366915,
0.0282071549,
0.0069783721,
0.0061401883,
-0.1040074453,
-0.0448674522,
-0.0010309438,
0.0249790344,
-0.0695064962,
0.0031869572,
-0.0426657721,
-0.0598791279,
-0.0311231967,
-0.0080912625,
-0.0716226622,
-0.0451351926,
-0.0207390748,
-0.0181718972,
0.0263402872,
-0.0452276953,
-0.0420687385,
0.0204667039,
-0.0162280612,
-0.0274995994,
0.0533530749,
0.0006459287,
0.0118426904,
0.0493378267,
0.0159018114,
-0.0551974848,
0.0193843208,
-0.0538548231,
-0.0238109659,
0.0117549989,
-0.0067413291,
0.0246063937,
0.0325097963,
-0.0559608564,
0.0160893034,
0.0172232389,
0.0200883541,
-0.051410906,
-0.0009226708,
0.0106880646,
0.0955441371,
-0.0313423388,
-0.0870363489,
0.0533910803,
0.0347287916,
0.0248761754,
0.0239588507,
-0.0674184933,
-0.0152874226,
-0.0134596778,
-0.0206663497,
-0.04205795,
0.0356650688,
0.0275960527,
-0.0881271437,
0.0177523494,
-0.1102179289,
2.614e-7,
0.005244683,
0.0357987881,
-0.0063643749,
0.0302269645,
0.0527109876,
0.0331225619,
0.0888336971,
0.004914748,
-0.0394341089,
-0.077981554,
-0.0311786849,
0.0561580472,
-0.0275073126,
0.0383883044,
0.0225327853,
-0.0133306449,
-0.0173401963,
0.0084013008,
-0.0352887623,
-0.005879296,
-0.053656213,
0.0325734057,
0.0478223003,
-0.0093022771,
-0.0180894732,
0.026009053,
0.0272276942,
-0.0183191486,
-0.020139182,
-0.0250425916,
0.0082429955,
0.0210896693,
-0.035265822,
-0.0422168262,
-0.0150995236,
0.0237966888,
-0.0318979546,
-0.0141199473,
0.0474775583,
-0.0120318364,
0.0237697419,
0.0051196753,
-0.0007691776,
-0.034814775,
0.0335088633,
0.0025695683,
-0.0169434454,
-0.0772553086,
-0.0484121181,
-0.0140513526,
0.0278007928,
0.0455888286,
0.0007385236,
-0.0004255735,
-0.0074157794,
0.0049739066,
0.001838823,
-0.0674354956,
0.0131241428,
-0.0183071457,
-0.027195327,
-0.0448005125,
-0.0252611078,
0.0145569937,
0.0252883304,
0.1012967899,
0.0384026244,
2.063769973e-34,
0.0166795384,
-0.0273657627,
0.0007831273,
-0.0746287182,
0.0122083919,
-0.0043131337,
-0.0599946082,
-0.0226627588,
0.0507726036,
-0.0322868787,
-0.0066922656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02463v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02463v3 | Nationality Bias in Text Generation | 2023-02-05T19:15:33 | 2023-02-14T21:34:34 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Sanjana Gautam, Ruchi Panchanadikar, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Little attention is placed on analyzing nationality bias in language models,
especially when nationality is highly used as a factor in increasing the
performance of social NLP models. This paper examines how a text generation
model, GPT-2, accentuates pre-existing societal biases about country-based
demonyms. We generate stories using GPT-2 for various nationalities and use
sensitivity analysis to explore how the number of internet users and the
country's economic status impacts the sentiment of the stories. To reduce the
propagation of biases through large language models (LLM), we explore the
debiasing method of adversarial triggering. Our results show that GPT-2
demonstrates significant bias against countries with lower internet users, and
adversarial triggering effectively reduces the same. | [
0.0571130477,
0.0845455676,
-0.0300319418,
0.0088648116,
-0.0215833336,
-0.0024857598,
0.066952914,
-0.0199913122,
0.0455055721,
-0.0615278743,
0.0224901866,
-0.0423512571,
0.0152262216,
0.022067409,
0.0422870778,
-0.0351403989,
0.0234438293,
0.0427535661,
0.0200922675,
-0.0534936637,
0.0291689672,
0.0502004847,
0.036103446,
0.0581985377,
-0.0147393178,
0.024166286,
0.0632876381,
0.0038247816,
0.0169708263,
-0.0137594268,
0.0158293284,
0.0388914943,
-0.0235430989,
0.0386841409,
0.0000018329,
-0.0536617674,
0.0030312194,
-0.0064889686,
0.0600858331,
0.0058355504,
0.0892306715,
-0.0490480103,
-0.0043185279,
0.044757504,
-0.0437100418,
-0.0288648251,
0.0405030735,
0.0149056436,
0.0420401208,
0.0637416467,
-0.0270392112,
0.0031802221,
-0.0398694985,
-0.0054728142,
-0.0167130586,
0.0121460473,
0.021374546,
-0.0165840238,
-0.0665674359,
-0.0108417366,
0.0168326888,
0.0041145012,
-0.0067537804,
0.0119043738,
0.0031617614,
0.0251463577,
-0.0266295094,
-0.0317253061,
0.0223393086,
0.024462143,
0.0162374116,
-0.0410167016,
0.0081209484,
-0.0059954021,
0.0011200741,
0.0325006656,
-0.025938943,
0.032530766,
0.0032804424,
0.0270370487,
0.0287723839,
0.0101722749,
0.023819739,
0.0607986376,
0.0173351932,
0.030042965,
0.0206412915,
-0.0046501635,
-0.0513645113,
0.0423489995,
0.0033302205,
-0.048392266,
0.0505249761,
-0.0043066745,
-0.0148275206,
0.0155099202,
-0.0437305011,
-0.0296358541,
0.036359217,
-0.0840295777,
-0.0178087596,
0.004091192,
0.0384581797,
-0.0024329985,
-0.0133330459,
-0.0058928491,
-0.0177804362,
-0.0123772258,
0.0243176073,
-0.0051582367,
-0.0071553299,
0.0001751479,
0.0125685344,
-0.0132376952,
0.0043992517,
0.047169175,
-0.0746031031,
0.0115244212,
-0.0293217655,
0.009569875,
-0.0009601169,
0.0112763075,
-0.0463188738,
-0.0043240041,
-0.0335597917,
0.0112570664,
-0.0647811964,
0.0066553056,
-0.023430001,
-0.0605519712,
0.026155185,
-0.0231683161,
-0.0126016289,
-0.0387983695,
0.0060371594,
0.0452515818,
0.0349424928,
0.0089030964,
-0.05662857,
-0.0409329534,
0.0104718236,
-0.0385788009,
-0.0197078455,
-0.0856089443,
0.012830982,
0.0342390649,
0.0040861955,
-0.078682594,
0.017731851,
0.0445276648,
-0.0580983385,
0.0271584038,
0.0072699967,
0.0114032375,
0.0546667464,
0.003435405,
0.0013537734,
0.077323176,
-0.0105615221,
0.0336466916,
0.0533750951,
0.0006565275,
-0.0042781923,
0.0379791856,
0.0139688915,
0.008610473,
-0.0248425268,
-0.0322857574,
-0.0204108339,
-0.0226735231,
0.0503861941,
0.0524688698,
0.0052254428,
0.0092890756,
0.0748883933,
0.0082008019,
-0.0376780704,
0.0612006523,
0.0342467241,
0.0122171259,
-0.082069017,
0.0280334819,
-0.0372092277,
-0.0151209692,
-0.0456743762,
-0.0170854963,
0.0302088745,
0.0899812579,
-0.0249010306,
-0.0154939871,
-0.0114898141,
0.0175904632,
0.0572647229,
-0.008843339,
0.0198625438,
0.0254190415,
0.0032174094,
0.0224411357,
0.0308246613,
-0.0664134324,
0.025846757,
-0.0209612846,
-0.0091134226,
0.0262090508,
0.0340734534,
0.0138276285,
0.029969668,
-0.0270873867,
-0.0053024814,
0.0584007837,
0.0484615564,
0.0010582395,
-0.0382473767,
-0.0069538816,
0.0049843127,
0.0117910868,
0.0189274829,
0.0309524406,
0.0733082667,
0.0469847843,
0.0229115989,
-0.0103634233,
-0.0328464769,
0.0085246433,
-0.0254774746,
-0.0072249812,
-0.0126215769,
0.0059098438,
0.0066702198,
0.0295591187,
-0.0379568301,
-0.0004129995,
-0.0128672803,
-0.0410889871,
-0.0368445255,
0.0171279293,
-0.0022500854,
-0.0295127276,
-0.0002787205,
-0.0498469993,
-0.0016942995,
0.023566464,
-0.0105037121,
0.0030472984,
0.0734127983,
0.0056341034,
0.0074493708,
-0.0116154309,
-0.0149725499,
-0.0234127454,
0.0183062721,
-0.0248961765,
0.0690223426,
-0.0203657635,
0.0223610364,
0.0092546502,
-0.0174841732,
0.0061350418,
-0.0153112533,
-0.0246229731,
0.0620338582,
-0.0216613151,
-0.0082838666,
0.0705967024,
-0.020259276,
-0.0089343861,
-0.0025614167,
-0.0613488853,
0.0052401787,
-0.0240491517,
0.0027692223,
0.0455875136,
0.0214234255,
-0.0177920572,
0.0306529608,
-0.0647487342,
-0.0305239055,
0.021049669,
0.0608491823,
0.0138906902,
-0.0215585288,
0.0109405313,
-0.0342563428,
-0.0029351965,
-0.0046289703,
0.0364688821,
0.0626953691,
-0.0406890586,
-0.0138662299,
0.042638652,
-0.038030263,
-0.0020070125,
-0.0291349739,
-0.0573834293,
-0.0021479367,
0.0347330905,
0.0247687176,
0.0202687513,
0.0035190745,
-0.0002771913,
0.0298158284,
0.0002729025,
-0.033831913,
-0.0396920666,
-0.0240884442,
0.0342739783,
0.0082324734,
-0.1071357206,
0.0172201749,
0.0647264197,
0.0432017297,
-0.0200489946,
-0.0396474898,
0.0776994899,
-0.0660258979,
-0.027558092,
-0.0073466715,
-0.0213875901,
0.0096517149,
0.0306335799,
-0.0164830573,
-0.0622728504,
0.0478560701,
-0.000313535,
0.0492183529,
-0.0207659397,
-0.0163316205,
-0.0198168885,
0.0230423491,
0.0140207699,
0.0671836287,
0.0080402829,
0.0014457483,
-0.0394702367,
-0.0209209882,
0.047256954,
-0.0136079602,
-0.0157648753,
0.0100391731,
-0.0054634223,
0.0020463376,
-0.0283658132,
-0.0391237661,
-0.0724973008,
-0.0089760674,
0.0100375786,
0.0668364242,
-0.0265692789,
0.0169611517,
0.02462814,
0.0394091606,
-0.0302999597,
-0.0264644437,
-0.0065845093,
0.0115020955,
0.0346738063,
0.0362916104,
-0.0604753084,
0.0367095955,
-0.0121908607,
-0.0007409971,
0.0031024753,
0.0391066559,
0.0220677089,
0.0326600075,
-0.0254853442,
0.0067540077,
-0.0488408431,
-0.0506751947,
-0.0297084451,
0.0471739806,
-0.0195538681,
0.0152816074,
0.0656291246,
0.0016749098,
-0.0246145055,
0.0074912501,
0.0174119379,
0.0331060439,
0.0330775753,
0.0388647988,
-0.0551158376,
0.0272945277,
-0.0026776639,
-0.0176938586,
-0.0771706998,
-0.0251754187,
-0.0571609996,
-0.1519037932,
-0.018496193,
0.0052191541,
-0.0265316181,
-0.011982467,
-0.0181493592,
-0.0224689934,
0.0022081721,
0.0156894289,
-0.0368077829,
-0.0006444462,
0.0296733659,
-0.0038500414,
-0.054138083,
-0.0562323146,
-0.0139687657,
-0.0500438884,
0.0549497977,
0.026029719,
0.0660812408,
-0.0252950769,
0.0096641025,
0.0257908776,
-0.0013367462,
-0.0064858473,
-0.0551362857,
0.0600765757,
-0.0112153636,
-0.0118022161,
-0.0437916219,
-0.0080595305,
0.0333234221,
0.0101654138,
-0.0169832818,
-0.0061978293,
0.0443127193,
-0.0498467982,
-0.0128843281,
0.031787131,
0.011680671,
0.0534243286,
0.0334717073,
-0.0581258722,
-0.0298464783,
-0.0583979972,
0.0075926608,
-0.0594470464,
-0.0629797801,
-0.0026972014,
-0.015250572,
-0.0906933099,
-0.0860805884,
-0.049274724,
0.001496507,
-0.0003721664,
0.0311397444,
0.0038598541,
-0.0037256705,
-0.0155369909,
0.0132864313,
0.0063808011,
-0.018939944,
0.0338881575,
0.0100220619,
-0.0089381272,
0.026029475,
-0.0361248814,
-0.0083275307,
0.0205438491,
-0.0372549482,
-0.0744413882,
0.0383739658,
0.0201494619,
0.0184120368,
0.0201249924,
-0.0187294688,
-0.0755860284,
0.0556222498,
0.046811372,
-0.0073891715,
0.009978395,
0.0091843605,
0.0264498126,
0.0253494941,
0.0297453199,
-0.0038768053,
0.0221744701,
0.0308452714,
0.0064103734,
-0.0527992994,
0.0164990928,
0.0150868287,
0.0166603383,
0.038345091,
-0.0416280404,
-0.0078690546,
-0.0663282275,
-0.0593118444,
-0.0454813875,
-0.0054569221,
-0.0168391354,
-0.0298430547,
0.0226063356,
0.0302322563,
-0.0238736998,
-0.0110548353,
-0.0620198734,
-0.0054008835,
-0.0222119167,
0.0305443779,
-0.0013522648,
0.0643311292,
0.0223378353,
0.0135469818,
-0.0225859825,
0.0114475759,
0.0065214396,
0.0129057541,
-0.0253858287,
-7.021e-7,
-0.0074035213,
-0.0047164625,
0.0123487907,
-0.0175671056,
-0.0130798528,
0.014189221,
-0.0121960081,
-0.0077026989,
0.0659437776,
-0.0271310788,
0.0756189227,
0.0201562885,
0.0029150839,
0.0203425679,
-0.0006349499,
0.0253314879,
-0.0498350486,
-0.0067314734,
-0.0371016748,
-0.0609902143,
0.031343177,
0.0785093233,
0.0056462493,
0.019548187,
0.0381158926,
-0.0639221594,
0.0035934865,
-0.0216611009,
0.0369965397,
-0.0313184299,
-0.0054402021,
0.0147944018,
-0.0901410207,
-0.0652962178,
-0.0341041759,
-0.0128674563,
0.0221225005,
-0.0182027519,
0.0213550273,
0.0587507561,
-0.032071203,
0.0354683511,
-0.0714627281,
0.0178168304,
-0.0746357217,
-0.0397328846,
0.0037459184,
-6.49720707e-33,
-0.0050453781,
-0.0746552721,
-0.0184757542,
-0.0171984751,
-0.0098423474,
-0.0005303137,
-0.0290802009,
0.0227445923,
-0.0139137432,
0.0208398234,
0.0053882101,
-0.0104951551,
0.0107989507,
0.0049522985,
-0.0204867553,
-0.0086559914,
0.0610126704,
0.019871708,
-0.0119836153,
0.0399894118,
0.0422711633,
0.0183001664,
0.0300240107,
-0.0661609247,
0.0646501929,
-0.0151748983,
-0.0504398197,
-0.0200052708,
0.0586679578,
0.0118881632,
-0.019146679,
0.0668807179,
0.0310168229,
-0.0323270112,
-0.0066708764,
0.0053609912,
-0.0013512319,
-0.0256338865,
0.0406829342,
0.0083519639,
0.0381936915,
-0.0407521948,
0.048882097,
-0.0171152875,
-0.0610247552,
0.0262142494,
0.04105369,
0.0141645633,
0.0034475895,
-0.037339922,
-0.0758918598,
0.0394944027,
0.0261587258,
0.0484389737,
-0.0321725607,
0.0546158925,
0.0192749407,
0.0382475145,
-0.0167932697,
0.0086110933,
0.0170217194,
0.0358842984,
0.0427857637,
-0.0072613526,
0.0169297792,
0.0831424221,
0.0233402941,
0.0610406511,
-0.0242893137,
-0.0083284434,
0.0096720746,
-0.0303744916,
0.0335687809,
0.120739378,
0.0197755266,
-0.0495783724,
-0.0451353937,
0.0044636345,
0.0640694052,
-0.0324959271,
0.0678670779,
-0.0587133504,
-0.0404072031,
-0.0411011092,
-0.0334948488,
-0.0758220553,
-0.0333189778,
-0.0759026632,
0.0247078072,
0.0005507752,
-0.017049605,
-0.0250121132,
0.0149224168,
-0.0307333898,
-0.0483064316,
0.044569917,
0.0018875664,
-0.0372876339,
0.0043977345,
0.0149711696,
-0.0248586778,
0.0171103459,
-0.0599224679,
0.023928171,
0.0059683174,
0.0010706985,
0.0154845351,
-0.0015837891,
-0.0717098638,
0.0009695034,
-0.0329423435,
0.0392631888,
-0.0075202733,
0.0143308612,
0.0138811991,
-0.0022477766,
-0.0237953793,
-0.0265375078,
0.0603550598,
0.0102781048,
-0.0001606247,
-0.0123944553,
-0.0474045798,
0.0566786863,
-0.0601476207,
-0.0306157079,
-0.014712655,
0.0520119332,
0.0430372022,
-0.0434120223,
-0.0413477197,
-0.0831466988,
2.668e-7,
0.0112047521,
0.083194539,
-0.0504983962,
0.0311050937,
0.017023921,
0.0331998542,
0.0350894481,
0.0444475412,
0.0147841191,
0.0203091372,
-0.0393173583,
-0.0084995739,
0.0163877439,
0.0719046891,
-0.0972069204,
0.068123281,
-0.0625569522,
0.0583416373,
-0.0318391547,
0.0061801057,
-0.0209830999,
0.0339695141,
0.0267018005,
-0.0096763922,
-0.0316077136,
-0.0558884889,
0.056962721,
-0.0642129108,
-0.0520872958,
0.0120018553,
0.0228567012,
-0.0040471931,
0.0364362672,
-0.0191416051,
-0.0156517662,
0.0142419441,
0.027276665,
-0.0089353221,
0.0293889623,
0.007775316,
0.0145685095,
-0.0292649083,
-0.0055015273,
-0.0826047659,
0.0577992909,
-0.0008276199,
-0.0377355851,
-0.0431003682,
0.013115298,
-0.0252772532,
0.069770202,
-0.0410083048,
-0.0478750728,
0.0047489125,
0.0119141294,
0.0261263996,
-0.0220780019,
-0.0289399046,
-0.0314737372,
-0.0220846869,
-0.0059329271,
-0.0436357781,
0.0194038432,
0.0410307385,
-0.0219875872,
0.0251657255,
0.0389540978,
2.493393873e-34,
0.0288334135,
0.0032125984,
0.0087351706,
-0.0351016782,
0.0668142661,
0.0335070975,
-0.0253053308,
-0.0051888907,
0.0241993722,
0.0004731934,
0.0052126753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.02453v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.02453v1 | FineDeb: A Debiasing Framework for Language Models | 2023-02-05T18:35:21 | 2023-02-05T18:35:21 | Akash Saravanan, Dhruv Mullick, Habibur Rahman, Nidhi Hegde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | As language models are increasingly included in human-facing machine learning
tools, bias against demographic subgroups has gained attention. We propose
FineDeb, a two-phase debiasing framework for language models that starts with
contextual debiasing of embeddings learned by pretrained language models. The
model is then fine-tuned on a language modeling objective. Our results show
that FineDeb offers stronger debiasing in comparison to other methods which
often result in models as biased as the original language model. Our framework
is generalizable for demographics with multiple classes, and we demonstrate its
effectiveness through extensive experiments and comparisons with state of the
art techniques. We release our code and data on GitHub. | [
0.0146514419,
0.1116432399,
-0.0184896309,
0.028956363,
0.0157088023,
0.0364546813,
0.0697147474,
-0.0121413991,
-0.0017005595,
-0.0496657938,
-0.0227289367,
-0.0260824319,
0.0162362047,
-0.0102322642,
0.0355334803,
-0.0676699281,
0.0231214147,
0.0206494424,
0.0434990786,
-0.0531964675,
0.0267348159,
0.0444545783,
0.017669972,
0.0571089238,
-0.0016162102,
-0.0117802061,
0.0579231158,
0.0040017669,
0.0086890692,
0.0420199782,
0.0657913089,
0.069504723,
0.0196380559,
0.0577255413,
0.0000017391,
-0.0240255259,
-0.0018022393,
-0.0106051741,
-0.0350345373,
-0.0266995057,
0.0946869552,
-0.0308854263,
-0.0013719726,
0.0310056154,
-0.0150203379,
-0.0164994281,
0.0692497715,
-0.0070573986,
0.0222929195,
0.035537947,
-0.0080340011,
-0.0160921998,
-0.0499280952,
-0.0388169363,
0.0037096001,
-0.0007422321,
0.0300164465,
-0.0134973424,
-0.0666143447,
-0.0148860719,
-0.0190892611,
0.0131463781,
0.0309411995,
0.0039335852,
0.0385883413,
0.0080578774,
-0.0351228341,
-0.0124218892,
0.0119863404,
0.0500612818,
-0.0502404831,
-0.0385469645,
-0.0181714315,
0.0127249695,
0.0161808226,
-0.0016642236,
-0.0145282699,
0.0065370942,
0.0285744611,
0.0244921036,
-0.0017450092,
0.0278636888,
0.060106162,
0.0266224407,
0.0029440743,
0.0285548791,
0.0364201739,
0.0102937082,
-0.0039387252,
0.0465457179,
0.0188322328,
-0.0307448376,
0.0240101088,
-0.0450151823,
-0.0126383528,
0.0200686734,
-0.0454241224,
-0.0089074634,
0.0109973727,
-0.0073794588,
-0.0124642244,
0.0015202464,
-0.0110788802,
0.0206886735,
0.0199303478,
-0.020529313,
0.0451530628,
0.0304117836,
-0.0106324991,
-0.0264827777,
0.009393801,
0.0069491244,
-0.0075713,
-0.0286825784,
0.003069415,
0.0669647902,
-0.0721653625,
-0.0251278728,
-0.0367850885,
0.0033210907,
-0.0110019976,
0.0186598767,
-0.0620333329,
-0.030758176,
0.0016030126,
0.0146868769,
-0.0406237356,
0.0130690839,
-0.0160604548,
-0.0804198533,
0.0018177931,
0.007272759,
-0.0168603919,
-0.0417500399,
-0.0305426549,
0.0150763299,
0.0281670969,
-0.0252907779,
-0.0394154154,
-0.0168665256,
-0.0140648978,
-0.0544242226,
-0.0302586053,
-0.0826180279,
0.0546046346,
-0.0144901071,
0.0309265405,
-0.0944685712,
-0.0358716808,
0.0147018414,
-0.0324108899,
0.0759222135,
0.0275295395,
-0.0163026247,
0.0404381752,
0.0403576568,
0.0413669497,
0.1085886881,
-0.014920231,
0.0001957039,
0.0424588248,
-0.0178288668,
0.0108180624,
0.0564975813,
0.0277206246,
0.0156220673,
-0.0444086194,
-0.000071013,
0.0019098801,
-0.0039547891,
0.064607814,
0.0179278869,
0.0015965739,
-0.063616626,
0.043821875,
0.0728421658,
0.0092340382,
0.0407033265,
0.0311188847,
0.0123446165,
-0.036659006,
-0.0078238798,
-0.0623901933,
-0.0220266208,
-0.0072818012,
-0.0532797463,
0.0227283835,
0.0603627227,
-0.0172815043,
-0.0250684116,
0.0056922371,
-0.0199723989,
0.0438745618,
0.0281817,
0.0408247858,
0.0143692931,
0.0408066474,
0.0425952487,
0.0778031647,
-0.0418006666,
0.0243436377,
-0.0319680683,
0.0128196441,
0.0471548364,
0.0207759645,
-0.0183960218,
-0.0060068103,
-0.0340987667,
0.0012587605,
0.0463589989,
0.0595530272,
-0.0245966036,
0.0661004558,
-0.0675505996,
-0.0292461235,
0.0297912359,
0.0573762208,
0.0374314673,
0.0738354623,
0.0113277752,
0.0411356427,
-0.0679193139,
-0.0132467812,
0.0302063581,
-0.0376204401,
-0.0510971285,
-0.0023564873,
0.0337827615,
-0.0098405182,
0.0042220368,
-0.0104960492,
-0.0245483872,
-0.0451427922,
0.0107850498,
0.0355482139,
-0.0170697961,
-0.0679504573,
-0.0747607276,
0.0054059005,
-0.0526661389,
-0.0562122799,
0.0168022774,
-0.0495645702,
0.0128966952,
0.0521228239,
-0.010074066,
0.0247406103,
-0.0197609309,
-0.012228433,
-0.0534837618,
0.031279292,
-0.0416044742,
0.0451862663,
-0.0146329664,
-0.0013205981,
0.0035203537,
-0.0383488946,
-0.0112699531,
-0.0593177117,
-0.0328239165,
0.0042100661,
0.0077310521,
0.0109220482,
0.0360044651,
-0.0040621446,
-0.0170062091,
0.0233062301,
-0.0484514832,
-0.0264461637,
-0.0357475206,
-0.000917073,
-0.0094166128,
0.0169250965,
-0.0222070273,
-0.0526098609,
-0.0316266827,
-0.0405504219,
-0.0270435717,
0.0392921716,
-0.0092646256,
-0.0428461544,
-0.0016825844,
-0.0290904548,
-0.0568997115,
-0.0208692905,
0.0770198926,
0.0233293213,
0.0120093701,
-0.0073482427,
-0.0351532586,
-0.04665225,
0.0220873319,
-0.0074063828,
-0.0076472964,
-0.0076063853,
0.021514751,
0.0327423438,
0.0519331172,
-0.0054892041,
0.0392695256,
0.0342479125,
-0.0116005959,
-0.0395946801,
-0.0274685435,
-0.0399597175,
0.0218387358,
-0.0202564206,
-0.0715121403,
-0.0118059488,
0.0629702359,
0.023336757,
-0.0433634594,
-0.0592960045,
0.0359448381,
-0.0393747799,
-0.0237723012,
-0.0638186932,
0.0016520708,
-0.0169233251,
0.0054381909,
-0.0619894639,
-0.0811144561,
0.0747530684,
0.0047294004,
0.007310777,
0.0090342378,
-0.017031949,
-0.0202660952,
0.007399993,
0.0115501303,
0.0384584516,
0.0513151996,
-0.0156584829,
-0.0574855395,
-0.013732098,
0.0139899347,
-0.0524774007,
0.0697037727,
-0.0048268167,
-0.034792237,
0.0017160651,
-0.0444073603,
-0.0404243618,
-0.0627288297,
-0.0210109223,
0.0104943682,
0.0235946532,
-0.0360148214,
-0.0569445007,
-0.0314007513,
0.0005569084,
0.0133493086,
-0.0045414418,
0.0075136768,
0.0211212169,
0.0250355024,
0.0251605026,
-0.0104523851,
0.0237737559,
-0.0459120795,
0.0030369391,
0.0219836049,
0.0300822556,
0.0154835656,
-0.0107154101,
-0.007056633,
0.0402268618,
-0.026862679,
-0.0027190144,
-0.0020876836,
0.0340995863,
-0.0323076658,
0.0101138111,
0.1181073785,
0.0036836714,
-0.0738000795,
0.0114828162,
0.0163478293,
0.0567999184,
0.0221443158,
0.0203664564,
-0.0712395385,
-0.0214394517,
0.0192998145,
0.0306688268,
-0.0059481245,
-0.0268961564,
-0.0118924705,
-0.0881271586,
0.0184602924,
0.022256434,
0.000388309,
-0.0082391752,
-0.0159082431,
0.0199908782,
-0.0442658439,
0.0443384275,
-0.0420385748,
0.0192579143,
0.0097047966,
0.0017792799,
-0.0445665792,
-0.0747343376,
0.0283888653,
-0.0509635136,
0.0663818344,
0.0347956866,
0.0358057804,
-0.0205806661,
0.0081917252,
0.027492946,
-0.0470047705,
-0.0456817932,
-0.0117726624,
0.0735300034,
-0.0458606444,
-0.003543556,
-0.0150753511,
0.0322035179,
0.0126990154,
0.0045719715,
-0.0130623681,
-0.0028068533,
0.0242482461,
-0.0233931784,
-0.0199555103,
-0.009455652,
0.0108881881,
0.0818375647,
0.0570048094,
-0.0363372378,
0.0102671301,
-0.1108939275,
-0.0119545162,
-0.0103607439,
-0.0440368913,
0.0083509162,
-0.0024366989,
-0.0349062346,
0.0032746505,
-0.0387413278,
0.0429429114,
0.0095771924,
0.0020974174,
-0.0201600455,
0.0139568979,
-0.0409066752,
-0.0243636034,
0.0636945441,
-0.0846593529,
0.045791503,
-0.0027111084,
-0.0327183828,
-0.0325969309,
-0.0291808434,
-0.0123042371,
-0.0201738812,
-0.04803342,
-0.0668418407,
0.0580484755,
0.0168148726,
0.0119932313,
0.0682589561,
-0.0449375063,
-0.0855837986,
0.1003159955,
0.0336008221,
-0.0023666781,
-0.0218980741,
-0.0032121975,
-0.0114854546,
0.0115322107,
0.0476029515,
-0.0241576545,
0.0259991437,
0.0542697757,
-0.0414690375,
-0.0468043536,
-0.0074005048,
-0.0343806185,
-0.0170275141,
0.0341428816,
-0.0280386433,
-0.002521713,
-0.0628253743,
-0.0406286493,
-0.005363002,
-0.0457416065,
0.0042983047,
-0.0337257273,
0.0446802303,
0.0165422969,
-0.0222343206,
-0.0201307908,
-0.0312674753,
0.0035791264,
-0.0328124799,
0.0634315163,
0.0191000421,
0.0243521817,
0.0325425826,
0.0288389549,
0.0105921095,
0.0666265637,
-0.0476426184,
0.0499539338,
0.0098957624,
-0.0017610013,
0.0042482042,
-0.0017082768,
-0.0345569812,
-0.0053580101,
-0.0122445123,
0.0443684347,
-0.0238161534,
0.0192402788,
0.0237422362,
-0.0506770946,
0.0219750572,
0.018406624,
-0.0182045642,
-0.0024768219,
-0.0164903793,
0.0281620882,
-0.0321259759,
0.0340363383,
-0.0148561783,
-0.0147321569,
0.031524919,
0.0810337663,
0.0475323722,
0.0314991176,
0.0070417929,
-0.0468362346,
-0.0291078892,
-0.0081368927,
0.0384683758,
0.0165154319,
-0.0383276716,
0.0000485,
-0.0355778895,
-0.0834911838,
-0.0409507155,
0.0119086411,
0.0078078108,
0.0522801504,
0.0300780423,
0.0356989168,
-0.0495437793,
-0.0262965597,
-0.0314494073,
0.0171620399,
-0.0612889789,
-0.0350978673,
0.0019061506,
-6.097529439e-33,
-0.0277478732,
-0.0200448446,
-0.0537444651,
-0.0611150376,
-0.0004086498,
0.0107858609,
-0.005397473,
0.0079373326,
-0.0181854945,
0.0378035568,
0.0003173745,
0.0243863054,
0.0178857725,
0.024090454,
-0.0176678747,
-0.0217448324,
0.058823511,
0.0207482483,
-0.0217977744,
0.0184556134,
-0.0246217139,
0.0315111317,
0.0503276996,
-0.0269637723,
0.0444481522,
-0.0054539093,
-0.0181841142,
0.0294655785,
0.0033758979,
0.0526783466,
-0.0424858034,
0.0747701973,
0.0212639477,
-0.0103961695,
-0.0159771983,
0.0648147687,
-0.0644289777,
-0.0236344263,
-0.0077151377,
0.0377056561,
-0.0066058803,
-0.0319075659,
0.0349775627,
-0.0061854413,
0.0044684969,
-0.0340487361,
0.0433204509,
-0.0072350479,
0.006300543,
0.029167993,
-0.0509332791,
0.0562632233,
-0.0202384815,
0.0216980968,
0.041519817,
-0.0065195737,
0.0188241415,
0.0311636291,
-0.0243581422,
0.0011995598,
0.0202672221,
-0.0007140961,
0.034448076,
0.0403980911,
0.0075280145,
0.0531993657,
0.0310901571,
0.0076209293,
-0.0299889483,
-0.0376194939,
0.0549936965,
-0.0325189568,
0.014758761,
0.0736972392,
0.043457184,
-0.015633557,
-0.023480894,
0.0249685533,
0.0122857653,
-0.0111299213,
0.0387514979,
-0.0164452419,
-0.0527314954,
-0.0410005152,
-0.0499080718,
-0.0773802623,
-0.0055948622,
-0.0337897688,
0.0142698279,
0.0205184724,
-0.0326997638,
0.0078151608,
0.0078504952,
-0.0528906621,
-0.0182127338,
0.0339588784,
0.0084016453,
-0.0457043462,
0.0229684934,
0.0314060375,
-0.062212117,
0.0177681707,
0.0124675622,
-0.0033175335,
0.0032217912,
-0.0055162814,
0.0742959455,
0.0092915678,
-0.0727798343,
0.0085785827,
-0.0143984584,
0.0005277579,
0.0110814702,
0.0591602884,
0.0480800644,
0.0237314962,
0.0028173025,
-0.0103880465,
0.0551012419,
0.0055228998,
0.0008386315,
0.0005652101,
-0.018670192,
0.0409073792,
-0.0339590386,
-0.0333287455,
0.0189774595,
-0.0186131541,
0.0692368746,
-0.0193215571,
-0.0058823349,
-0.0537473373,
2.169e-7,
0.0482654497,
0.0411141776,
0.0056208996,
-0.0162264295,
0.0137631549,
0.031918861,
0.0500486232,
0.011991269,
0.0202858467,
0.0182894655,
-0.0223622825,
0.0527698807,
0.068375513,
0.0352255926,
-0.0685500056,
0.0419384129,
-0.0312733203,
0.0422195494,
-0.0243675001,
0.0021112273,
-0.0254737362,
0.0977791622,
0.0452200361,
-0.0223528352,
-0.0028156082,
-0.0068692951,
0.0217054728,
-0.0554623604,
-0.0126612335,
0.0146839255,
0.0337138325,
0.0467300117,
0.0371180139,
0.0132111339,
-0.016576346,
0.0198421311,
0.0041368208,
0.0471305698,
-0.0045974911,
0.0175483394,
-0.0406023785,
0.0179373641,
-0.0177975222,
-0.0686656162,
0.0487090163,
-0.0089109661,
-0.029172644,
-0.0697519779,
-0.0151143223,
-0.0035770221,
0.0590265431,
-0.0199591815,
-0.0403846912,
0.0024455762,
0.0447145142,
-0.0210195724,
-0.0332282148,
-0.0868974552,
-0.0379130244,
0.0010581914,
-0.0520236865,
-0.0337663032,
0.0442464277,
0.002985199,
-0.0031581731,
-0.0220242441,
0.0434253998,
1.854333614e-34,
0.0307663362,
0.0397152863,
0.015323895,
-0.035012722,
0.0284662228,
-0.0001257559,
-0.0009314904,
-0.0355145149,
0.0348196924,
-0.0293147489,
0.0070908042
] |
Subsets and Splits