id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08659v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08659v1 | Uncertainty-aware Self-training for Low-resource Neural Sequence Labeling | 2023-02-17T02:40:04 | 2023-02-17T02:40:04 | Jianing Wang, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Ming Gao, Aoying Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural sequence labeling (NSL) aims at assigning labels for input language
tokens, which covers a broad range of applications, such as named entity
recognition (NER) and slot filling, etc. However, the satisfying results
achieved by traditional supervised-based approaches heavily depend on the large
amounts of human annotation data, which may not be feasible in real-world
scenarios due to data privacy and computation efficiency issues. This paper
presents SeqUST, a novel uncertain-aware self-training framework for NSL to
address the labeled data scarcity issue and to effectively utilize unlabeled
data. Specifically, we incorporate Monte Carlo (MC) dropout in Bayesian neural
network (BNN) to perform uncertainty estimation at the token level and then
select reliable language tokens from unlabeled data based on the model
confidence and certainty. A well-designed masked sequence labeling task with a
noise-robust loss supports robust training, which aims to suppress the problem
of noisy pseudo labels. In addition, we develop a Gaussian-based consistency
regularization technique to further improve the model robustness on
Gaussian-distributed perturbed representations. This effectively alleviates the
over-fitting dilemma originating from pseudo-labeled augmented data. Extensive
experiments over six benchmarks demonstrate that our SeqUST framework
effectively improves the performance of self-training, and consistently
outperforms strong baselines by a large margin in low-resource scenarios | [
0.0351359621,
0.1136891842,
0.0306471977,
-0.0118381307,
0.0066043907,
0.0122115491,
0.0222991277,
-0.0319901705,
0.0330714993,
-0.0083126286,
-0.036038395,
-0.0272019748,
0.000898738,
0.0118604843,
0.0399562418,
-0.0135021703,
0.0357874073,
-0.0072204317,
0.0708351359,
0.0039939573,
-0.0159594938,
-0.0252800472,
-0.0194464475,
-0.005933932,
-0.0643582121,
0.0203042515,
-0.0033435926,
0.0057360176,
0.031146042,
-0.0689582154,
0.0262573808,
0.0831682608,
-0.0259181689,
0.0595687293,
0.0000020407,
-0.0477328897,
-0.0338314846,
0.0047907312,
-0.0669894218,
0.0039729406,
0.0096950177,
0.0309558492,
-0.0210110787,
0.0039061275,
0.0008434845,
-0.043476183,
0.0604491942,
0.0633815154,
0.0333742611,
0.0737682208,
0.005470912,
0.0022120331,
-0.0135011924,
-0.0637126938,
0.0293414406,
-0.0600163452,
0.0261489097,
-0.0269572902,
0.0015417209,
0.0215710178,
0.0194245502,
0.0293219164,
0.0193971321,
-0.0149448449,
-0.0009848692,
0.0480130166,
-0.0275622159,
-0.0142366951,
-0.0161162671,
0.0426222906,
-0.0117456084,
-0.0054373071,
0.0203138869,
-0.0358215794,
0.0236491989,
-0.040630646,
-0.0012985403,
0.0399773866,
-0.0092451209,
0.0108324634,
0.0048300535,
0.0353326946,
0.0726600811,
0.0209176242,
-0.0056184367,
0.0641158968,
-0.0122887781,
-0.0246542953,
-0.017296778,
-0.0053906189,
-0.037078768,
-0.0613841414,
0.034462519,
0.0172483064,
-0.0051473016,
0.0413806401,
-0.0770279914,
-0.0490183681,
0.0060256943,
-0.0364374369,
-0.0393333025,
0.0284797233,
-0.0165356975,
0.034349978,
0.0009153952,
-0.0163838789,
0.0150339603,
0.0173211005,
0.0107361572,
0.0035346816,
-0.0365264863,
-0.0002030437,
-0.0464501306,
0.0648476854,
-0.0240942575,
0.0143375807,
-0.0489807501,
-0.0014598134,
-0.0180460773,
0.0516320467,
0.0022503622,
0.0071250745,
-0.0354473777,
0.0024793029,
-0.0274706911,
-0.0123464167,
-0.0185464751,
-0.0314039588,
0.0507034846,
-0.0731671527,
-0.0155148227,
-0.0024260953,
-0.0079369145,
-0.0668680146,
0.0072377082,
0.0771147981,
0.0227496866,
-0.0736991763,
-0.0675446913,
0.0161239412,
-0.0341878124,
-0.0546916164,
-0.0232143216,
-0.0282382537,
-0.009351938,
-0.0266538896,
0.0005965361,
-0.0861582085,
0.0383293964,
0.0071117319,
-0.0199251957,
0.1046032235,
-0.0553995408,
-0.076558806,
0.0564821586,
0.0134957395,
0.015912747,
0.0437945612,
0.034737505,
0.0152587378,
0.0424525701,
0.0069640395,
0.0322040953,
-0.0014740073,
0.0519054867,
-0.039242018,
-0.0156387221,
-0.0009614779,
0.012598508,
0.030176023,
0.018562343,
0.0410167724,
-0.0042402819,
-0.0189201813,
0.0550102443,
-0.0040350086,
-0.0453924425,
-0.0176870488,
-0.0192605574,
0.0112719415,
0.0112284962,
-0.018783927,
-0.0661737546,
0.0331758782,
0.002701086,
0.033234559,
0.0397516526,
-0.0057847141,
-0.0140567319,
-0.0628288686,
-0.0565148368,
-0.0110707013,
-0.0188679956,
0.0290093087,
0.0701064095,
-0.0039566061,
-0.0209584758,
0.0390217081,
0.0062604137,
-0.0265743285,
0.0089687677,
-0.0197453033,
0.0012129592,
0.0190131776,
0.0249223933,
-0.0726438016,
-0.0511413664,
-0.0597341545,
-0.0199072063,
0.0433565155,
0.0103674503,
0.0273812581,
0.0392350629,
-0.0412861779,
-0.0322581753,
0.0125176013,
0.0177410152,
0.0421403423,
0.0010830568,
0.0179015547,
0.0342925116,
-0.0500728562,
-0.0355929546,
0.0262520853,
-0.0163345672,
-0.0870192125,
0.0796218291,
0.0021142357,
0.0718951672,
0.038849894,
-0.0235682745,
0.0241259933,
0.0354634635,
0.0128108915,
-0.0196003634,
-0.0497510657,
-0.0692761764,
-0.0155557925,
0.0589748099,
0.0107598575,
-0.0401667021,
-0.011063044,
-0.0509616658,
-0.0723603889,
-0.0032929173,
-0.0311225019,
-0.0456855372,
-0.0531763881,
0.0098453602,
0.0487282686,
0.0292670038,
-0.0214084182,
0.0419573933,
-0.0245844722,
0.0153075727,
0.0015326686,
0.0295872651,
0.0136406031,
-0.0554576628,
-0.0681249723,
-0.0111905066,
-0.0283700135,
-0.016920859,
0.0372579135,
-0.0092518497,
-0.029070612,
0.034306597,
-0.059968859,
0.0033580859,
-0.014179958,
0.0284602493,
-0.0007654544,
0.0291072503,
-0.0125251338,
-0.050927259,
-0.0235543735,
-0.0430242568,
-0.0357112214,
-0.0190123394,
0.0441954173,
0.0373308249,
0.0100239245,
-0.0113869999,
-0.0030489748,
0.0001165121,
-0.0169677921,
0.0037354399,
-0.044891838,
-0.0594514236,
-0.0221276991,
-0.0289294291,
0.0392280929,
0.0050685951,
-0.0085612461,
-0.013321545,
0.0100709042,
-0.0150089078,
-0.0081408685,
-0.0044286302,
-0.0196561012,
0.0348302126,
0.0106364936,
-0.0074297283,
0.0363301523,
-0.0189419128,
0.0401373953,
0.023913024,
-0.0346492492,
-0.0023440935,
0.0651918501,
-0.0283970907,
0.0166166779,
-0.0313719846,
0.0163224004,
-0.0046166261,
-0.0431121215,
-0.0262796506,
0.0304758418,
-0.0247092377,
0.0219671614,
-0.0169531573,
-0.0410026759,
0.0796992853,
-0.0327486917,
-0.016386874,
-0.0374787115,
-0.0135630956,
0.0050411471,
0.0115659367,
0.0152121447,
-0.0090897325,
0.053431686,
-0.0532354414,
-0.0068554617,
-0.0159884989,
0.0280942041,
-0.0237107817,
-0.0532676317,
-0.029850116,
0.0296048727,
-0.0020522275,
-0.0062514935,
-0.050512258,
-0.0065808515,
-0.0275160223,
0.0137643991,
0.0294477157,
-0.0098787695,
-0.010415853,
0.0133698499,
-0.0051311608,
0.0961720869,
0.0047864029,
0.0052090911,
0.0007157319,
0.0294764824,
0.0107897157,
0.0061167222,
0.0691300631,
0.0149450563,
-0.027592089,
0.0140576009,
0.0441771373,
-0.0251227301,
0.0080196066,
-0.0115816146,
0.0358009003,
-0.0430899709,
0.0245537087,
0.056966763,
0.047108911,
-0.0228590332,
-0.042974811,
0.1122793928,
0.0070009101,
-0.0159835536,
-0.0290729981,
-0.0064591039,
0.014094132,
0.0230926853,
0.0154969534,
-0.0428036191,
-0.0259173978,
0.0182022136,
0.0633372739,
-0.0065823155,
-0.0612114146,
-0.0033676759,
-0.0856860802,
0.0307019986,
-0.0080995504,
-0.0759402886,
-0.0097235162,
-0.0779420659,
0.0016442086,
-0.0509465747,
0.030498445,
-0.0370957106,
0.0180342253,
-0.0077517219,
0.048618637,
-0.0067712432,
-0.0790750533,
-0.0630951747,
-0.0431496687,
0.0641582161,
0.0193304867,
-0.033160612,
-0.0355580188,
-0.002534372,
0.0378721021,
-0.0034566969,
-0.0478783175,
-0.0220944677,
0.0564159043,
-0.0357697904,
-0.0347994827,
0.0047777556,
0.0275839139,
-0.0095275445,
-0.0315249749,
-0.0112689044,
0.0398170725,
-0.0094514051,
0.0265950002,
0.0063166637,
-0.0333332643,
0.0338583104,
0.0595275462,
0.0013874524,
-0.0243910141,
0.0116727632,
-0.0015754702,
0.0488323271,
-0.0115255602,
0.0718455762,
0.048724927,
-0.0386271514,
-0.0743532479,
-0.0493230857,
-0.0506938621,
0.0109816473,
0.0345536247,
0.0133932754,
0.0138221066,
0.0614448413,
-0.0204849765,
-0.0727989823,
0.0125263873,
-0.0209835079,
-0.0192449372,
-0.0574025027,
-0.0075108223,
-0.0043338011,
0.0054525072,
-0.0004118611,
0.0248696804,
-0.087991789,
-0.0684236214,
0.0131960055,
0.0812886581,
0.0052031665,
0.0356889963,
-0.0143320607,
-0.0463326909,
0.0393416807,
0.1022332087,
-0.0274270959,
-0.0321460143,
0.0471557342,
0.0050076139,
-0.0190475378,
0.0030386564,
-0.0282159485,
0.0314160958,
0.04528163,
0.0385969169,
0.0025162431,
-0.0307719372,
0.0142380223,
0.0210279077,
0.0856306627,
-0.0520236418,
0.031316001,
-0.04109817,
0.0212226678,
0.0035938197,
-0.0006692244,
-0.0064568822,
-0.0062680757,
0.0263801236,
-0.0085562402,
-0.0042721825,
0.0275024343,
-0.0205935314,
0.026558971,
-0.0128041161,
-0.0332958549,
-0.0188198257,
-0.0032436012,
-0.0165097732,
-0.0206128526,
0.0079004876,
0.0413324311,
0.0609329566,
0.0420602039,
-0.0108326701,
0.0215307157,
0.0327698365,
-0.0020359601,
0.026508918,
0.0080039343,
-0.0243480057,
-0.0134108551,
-0.0692731589,
0.0340396948,
0.0502859615,
-0.020989174,
-0.0102936644,
-0.0390951708,
-0.0120435115,
-0.0190891214,
0.0154750319,
0.0087726153,
0.0072816792,
0.0289115403,
0.0145686297,
-0.0321318395,
0.0225983579,
0.0572030134,
0.0456006825,
0.0188584737,
0.007434831,
-0.0106577789,
-0.0484367236,
-0.0034072024,
-0.0011300255,
0.0697352588,
-0.0346148349,
-0.0142526347,
0.0106425341,
-0.0825551897,
0.0217357539,
0.0187735781,
0.0079103429,
0.0281005036,
0.0445194505,
-0.0052726641,
-0.0256150886,
-0.0075148335,
-0.0207183361,
0.0224553403,
0.0463062786,
-0.0212758947,
0.0131488843,
-6.643484117e-33,
-0.0050315894,
-0.0445306078,
-0.0107014999,
-0.044312939,
0.0469158068,
0.0046896264,
-0.0274704378,
0.0036782417,
0.0346248485,
-0.011750441,
-0.0160286929,
-0.0048116068,
0.0393987708,
0.0696797147,
0.0268148687,
-0.0026316755,
0.0670308396,
0.0039843428,
-0.0238304064,
-0.0199910551,
0.0254183561,
0.0450721197,
0.1092049628,
-0.099839665,
0.0465699621,
-0.0013524416,
-0.003392067,
0.0123297451,
0.045915015,
0.0250977501,
-0.0274126306,
0.0167993642,
0.0001288258,
-0.0508237891,
-0.0011342335,
-0.0273835566,
-0.1345536411,
-0.0575097129,
-0.0334042385,
0.0199045837,
-0.0018743954,
-0.0223637745,
0.0135520892,
-0.0148422467,
-0.0092495596,
0.04997034,
0.0231300592,
0.01576709,
-0.0298088081,
-0.0183783229,
0.0115417726,
0.0627476498,
0.0032410908,
0.0333919823,
0.0312175006,
0.0093903039,
-0.0036217307,
-0.0229687281,
-0.0757747516,
-0.043693047,
-0.0173481014,
0.0249941722,
0.0547102503,
0.0650405064,
0.0013937327,
0.0247864556,
0.0623262785,
0.0137380883,
0.0012925423,
-0.0021072561,
-0.01544079,
-0.0204952396,
0.0362583026,
0.020295579,
0.0742830038,
-0.0166860931,
-0.0542763099,
0.0177626554,
-0.0141449915,
-0.0049717398,
0.0028883063,
0.0199434496,
-0.0430439822,
-0.0079891793,
-0.0101811299,
-0.0557083525,
-0.0395931341,
0.0062010963,
0.0183591843,
0.0197862014,
-0.0456276499,
0.0574622899,
0.0019643195,
0.0103286663,
-0.0499418378,
-0.0263787787,
0.0735012665,
-0.0061394018,
0.023573339,
0.0117467595,
-0.0502290241,
-0.0201615151,
0.0072253421,
-0.0056028944,
0.0093802521,
-0.0008453182,
0.0623208173,
-0.0174479391,
-0.0468728468,
0.0243519917,
-0.0230229273,
0.0712609068,
0.0171007998,
0.022454042,
0.035077814,
-0.0206343997,
0.0043351767,
0.0452169105,
0.0540254861,
0.0061303028,
0.0073762732,
0.0302763768,
0.003939461,
0.0010272851,
0.0108840754,
-0.0270804856,
0.0122251865,
-0.0004265184,
-0.0083084628,
-0.0519294664,
0.0250413343,
0.0207753703,
2.899e-7,
0.0089313965,
0.0152637176,
0.0436412916,
-0.0255569611,
0.0021766471,
0.0447810143,
-0.0198181048,
0.0238536485,
-0.0252052899,
-0.0293607786,
0.0179131739,
-0.0262408424,
0.0271131936,
0.0448981449,
-0.1012592167,
-0.0933196768,
-0.0343010984,
0.0412607826,
-0.0168743692,
0.0423547849,
0.0359664932,
0.1270514727,
0.0355072878,
-0.0081327343,
-0.0212983396,
-0.0441164374,
0.0086160759,
-0.0063986992,
0.0166364089,
0.0053560343,
0.0237847324,
0.0755865946,
-0.0326299891,
0.0159073193,
-0.0452413708,
0.0062914346,
0.0028991206,
0.0617056228,
0.0185405612,
-0.0042140065,
-0.0060255625,
0.0195590146,
0.0230095442,
-0.0149103701,
0.0538997725,
-0.0781073496,
-0.0345547572,
-0.0161556825,
-0.0314185321,
-0.0316038057,
0.0658429191,
-0.0007064521,
-0.0228977595,
0.009090744,
0.0173339024,
0.007979325,
-0.0364124104,
-0.0635901913,
0.0098507991,
-0.0140632903,
-0.0273874551,
0.0162964743,
-0.0339353271,
-0.0220150799,
0.0167239271,
-0.0303286575,
-0.0030871322,
2.407459037e-34,
0.0286561754,
-0.0417839848,
-0.0534965694,
0.0143047934,
-0.0067378134,
-0.015646426,
-0.0395804346,
0.0231255442,
0.0060084797,
-0.0084472718,
-0.0117548704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10915v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10915v2 | Conformers are All You Need for Visual Speech Recognition | 2023-02-17T01:31:55 | 2023-12-13T04:31:44 | Oscar Chang, Hank Liao, Dmitriy Serdyuk, Ankit Shah, Olivier Siohan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS | Visual speech recognition models extract visual features in a hierarchical
manner. At the lower level, there is a visual front-end with a limited temporal
receptive field that processes the raw pixels depicting the lips or faces. At
the higher level, there is an encoder that attends to the embeddings produced
by the front-end over a large temporal receptive field. Previous work has
focused on improving the visual front-end of the model to extract more useful
features for speech recognition. Surprisingly, our work shows that complex
visual front-ends are not necessary. Instead of allocating resources to a
sophisticated visual front-end, we find that a linear visual front-end paired
with a larger Conformer encoder results in lower latency, more efficient memory
usage, and improved WER performance. We achieve a new state-of-the-art of 12.8%
WER for visual speech recognition on the TED LRS3 dataset, which rivals the
performance of audio-only models from just four years ago. | [
0.0082336375,
0.0306615382,
-0.0082283607,
0.0400218703,
0.0062713255,
-0.0067847278,
0.0069820061,
-0.0186464842,
0.0092515498,
-0.0121111963,
-0.0396704301,
-0.0290683657,
0.0375010185,
0.0713945553,
0.0258208029,
-0.1044230908,
-0.0325889774,
-0.0483862869,
0.0160409249,
0.0020277186,
0.0144710261,
-0.0161343329,
-0.0217950344,
0.0414606147,
-0.0034115978,
-0.0113525046,
-0.0361148678,
0.0176670868,
0.0321489722,
0.0140889781,
-0.0685490966,
-0.0030152418,
0.0684468672,
-0.0496348776,
0.0000020248,
0.0469626002,
0.0009176587,
0.004523234,
-0.0142705357,
0.014519982,
0.003486505,
-0.0604965203,
-0.0281838179,
0.0245159492,
-0.0342223458,
-0.0507335626,
0.0665268376,
0.0310811065,
0.0269799661,
0.021989191,
-0.0199128799,
-0.0095929215,
0.0932569504,
-0.004661812,
0.0012980523,
-0.030940393,
-0.0396818668,
-0.0203369875,
-0.0147111462,
-0.0723536015,
-0.0908821598,
0.0451917276,
0.019673273,
-0.0036101595,
0.0369040221,
0.0191882849,
-0.0175194424,
-0.0330039561,
-0.0432656035,
0.0662969723,
-0.0183512028,
0.0082922075,
-0.0003567982,
0.027794715,
-0.0235828254,
0.0102896746,
-0.0106110545,
0.0315643623,
-0.0212822575,
-0.0026417617,
-0.0626745597,
0.0005880191,
-0.0131925521,
-0.0636052638,
0.0051470469,
-0.0810122564,
0.0130034722,
0.0106386952,
-0.0081526004,
-0.0081680082,
-0.026657043,
-0.0168676917,
-0.0050325384,
-0.002252925,
0.0328382924,
-0.0557967946,
-0.0572492294,
-0.0135508217,
-0.0588199459,
-0.022304954,
0.0346093923,
0.0463524908,
-0.0523513071,
0.0323918797,
-0.0111623658,
0.0970232487,
-0.0341874175,
0.0374591127,
0.0053609656,
-0.0350659229,
0.0108055165,
-0.0186624564,
-0.0374066755,
-0.0038275316,
-0.0376075618,
-0.0517368242,
-0.0163755678,
0.0245476291,
-0.03649031,
0.0016824456,
0.0159221012,
0.0322237089,
0.0117685925,
-0.0107755074,
-0.0248546116,
0.0658417791,
0.0426615253,
0.0202427339,
-0.0222586039,
-0.0777933151,
-0.0064415545,
0.0294399615,
0.0534342155,
0.007044638,
0.0020770195,
0.0886252522,
-0.0215475727,
-0.0405506454,
-0.0055125793,
0.0289775301,
0.0041834116,
-0.0048839068,
0.0692936406,
-0.0251281019,
0.0245874505,
-0.0098471697,
0.0096065663,
-0.0269080475,
0.0126061067,
-0.0088279936,
0.0084724603,
0.052207835,
0.0119050052,
-0.0128730172,
0.0089835804,
-0.0105017265,
0.0208594557,
0.0016375858,
0.0572290905,
0.0190963149,
-0.0154515579,
-0.0469084531,
0.0147947473,
0.0454981476,
-0.0093526449,
0.0060625183,
-0.0623962283,
-0.0198749825,
0.0373353288,
-0.0087177679,
0.0636376664,
0.0553285368,
-0.0377861261,
-0.0509690791,
0.0909661725,
0.0254738331,
0.049012322,
-0.0487303212,
0.0167351048,
-0.003070872,
0.0220019855,
-0.0148907984,
-0.0127983876,
0.0505040959,
0.005981104,
0.0136756916,
0.0081503913,
0.0348874815,
-0.0468682945,
-0.0259818733,
-0.0006558226,
-0.0273826029,
0.0089409752,
0.0607320517,
0.0242869277,
-0.0009481571,
-0.0562187731,
0.0095545594,
-0.026161233,
-0.0321764238,
0.0120859211,
-0.0349101536,
0.0159039777,
0.082452178,
0.0294733848,
0.0066904048,
-0.0072843758,
0.001057526,
0.0170730222,
0.0190796871,
0.0059754588,
-0.0035754903,
0.0670578405,
-0.0684971213,
-0.0455216877,
0.0238215346,
-0.0004573193,
0.0344741233,
-0.0276033916,
0.0085467119,
-0.0296847485,
0.0026849215,
0.0396478064,
-0.0018983027,
0.0044912812,
0.0078031244,
-0.0391722396,
0.0699916855,
0.0098414999,
-0.007427989,
-0.0300930701,
-0.0201114547,
0.0266765375,
-0.0549680367,
0.0660367906,
0.0277607068,
-0.0297481399,
0.0096336398,
0.0242517944,
-0.0619276762,
0.0216118991,
0.0640272051,
0.0080243303,
-0.0317068174,
0.0495378971,
-0.0279681962,
0.0705364868,
-0.0239414331,
0.028689649,
0.0359936543,
0.0145856142,
0.0210742205,
-0.026668353,
-0.0298604723,
-0.0489280485,
0.0028987241,
-0.0187910423,
-0.022690542,
-0.0448456667,
-0.0284837242,
0.0302539077,
0.0072359322,
-0.0155497948,
-0.0134143066,
0.0049944483,
0.0075043375,
-0.0422488861,
-0.0757290125,
-0.0336716548,
-0.0294930208,
-0.0484750494,
-0.0181895569,
0.0117119411,
0.0344236717,
-0.041307997,
-0.0097200004,
0.0212997608,
-0.034075778,
0.0104114348,
-0.0397822708,
0.0310567822,
-0.0489643477,
-0.0241191201,
-0.0076698307,
0.0435881652,
0.0222410467,
-0.0282195881,
-0.0222272146,
0.0042105941,
-0.0338865593,
0.009392783,
0.0560926013,
-0.0182392262,
-0.0061139041,
-0.0267856494,
0.0146437492,
0.0407408141,
0.0618449971,
0.0206090566,
0.0416012034,
-0.0154598504,
0.0050523607,
-0.0025370063,
0.001820129,
0.03042873,
0.0311377402,
-0.0111697903,
0.0133636696,
-0.0680261478,
-0.0049648387,
0.006930477,
0.0748095289,
-0.0763879865,
0.0074979323,
0.0436463095,
-0.0132142231,
-0.0499750338,
-0.019964641,
-0.0117492443,
0.0213708878,
-0.0558958389,
-0.0728051141,
0.005812468,
-0.0641424134,
-0.0484029427,
0.0951912329,
-0.0069593373,
-0.0380114093,
0.0576946624,
0.0502021909,
-0.0267990455,
-0.0626129583,
-0.0548768565,
-0.0386663824,
0.0178567432,
0.0401662104,
-0.0194126181,
0.0794551149,
-0.0377793424,
-0.0284277648,
-0.0759226233,
-0.0154063478,
-0.0085917786,
-0.0145052448,
-0.0371944383,
0.0078195967,
-0.0325437188,
-0.0175916199,
-0.0475937128,
0.06214552,
0.0131602017,
0.0230482016,
0.0210318416,
0.0158674419,
-0.0229550153,
0.0420272015,
0.0383261554,
0.0478000902,
-0.0536452048,
-0.0486569069,
0.0227297302,
0.0388764106,
0.0347725712,
-0.0380598456,
-0.0554765873,
0.0225101858,
0.0585504323,
0.0868340954,
-0.042157717,
0.0393606201,
0.004120206,
-0.0684837326,
0.0291204453,
0.0424762964,
-0.0261897463,
-0.026556123,
-0.0440970212,
0.0350369476,
0.0563623719,
0.0262220409,
-0.0032831475,
-0.0416563228,
-0.0452130251,
0.0398594737,
-0.0198918264,
0.049880337,
0.0120813819,
-0.0338430256,
-0.0383603647,
0.0836583972,
0.0090334779,
0.0151234083,
-0.0473745503,
0.0262001585,
-0.019639926,
-0.0249742698,
0.0343253687,
0.0124943359,
-0.0337898619,
-0.0167503636,
0.0390491672,
-0.0304589011,
0.0081891101,
0.0208426937,
-0.0310521852,
-0.016425902,
0.0247427784,
0.0035136899,
0.0093429564,
-0.0786844715,
0.0364949964,
0.029081678,
0.0089296196,
-0.0018432584,
0.0509678423,
-0.0189003367,
-0.0593144074,
0.0535205416,
0.0112635233,
0.0028003664,
0.0115331057,
-0.0090337535,
0.039591305,
-0.0144949844,
0.0100657688,
0.0237147715,
0.0199925359,
-0.0421666913,
0.0107301334,
0.0215836894,
-0.0329806134,
-0.0211648326,
0.0279264227,
0.0071298652,
-0.0068037901,
-0.0637309328,
-0.0424893871,
0.0696014911,
-0.0415982492,
-0.0028320891,
0.0158008039,
0.0077208262,
0.0303633884,
0.0026082837,
-0.0392237008,
0.0201307777,
0.0363226607,
-0.0667897239,
0.0368561409,
-0.0237127095,
0.0241234638,
-0.0869485512,
-0.0067042983,
0.0027716132,
-0.0520459972,
-0.0190538,
0.0138702542,
-0.0202078819,
-0.0285889469,
-0.0393057466,
0.0277892407,
0.0080556013,
0.0873414949,
0.0165470615,
-0.0078182733,
0.0255656689,
-0.0144515941,
0.0176140834,
0.0535277389,
0.0421204679,
-0.0598338209,
-0.0030287749,
0.0011966501,
-0.0167875532,
-0.002939909,
-0.012106196,
-0.0052626859,
0.0398383625,
-0.0297534931,
-0.0082125254,
-0.0079371883,
0.0829275921,
0.0047631292,
0.0531924367,
-0.0442974158,
0.0445471704,
-0.0121868653,
0.0673939213,
-0.0735273063,
-0.0147488825,
0.0002679126,
0.0451635122,
-0.0100117,
0.0389145985,
0.0607083775,
-0.0143879279,
-0.0231077895,
0.0660137609,
-0.0212706383,
-0.0025975723,
-0.0199997798,
0.0171089321,
0.0253630485,
0.0052447612,
0.0167682748,
0.030380534,
0.0116734197,
-0.0051909843,
-0.0037893024,
-0.0190309118,
-0.0325927213,
0.0448525771,
-0.0289073922,
-0.0229350571,
-0.0422546417,
0.0311226901,
0.0234976485,
0.0033356156,
-0.0077293087,
0.0341021642,
-0.0059041255,
-0.0228961967,
0.049235452,
-0.0252076797,
-0.0389073789,
0.0579265431,
0.0023399454,
-0.0273424573,
-0.0127803776,
-0.0038002944,
0.0103635434,
0.0064481264,
-0.0374305211,
0.0315922201,
-0.0392446332,
-0.044272691,
0.0374096371,
-0.0394854024,
-0.0065048919,
0.0188747011,
-0.0024687543,
-0.0505329743,
0.0709799752,
0.0025416312,
0.0150010185,
0.0042225178,
0.0286691282,
-0.0337851755,
0.0262246151,
-0.0007273075,
0.0140744001,
-0.0658038333,
0.0062176371,
0.0000863135,
0.0265844688,
-5.710330049e-33,
-0.0375740528,
-0.0020781553,
0.0657231361,
0.0193531476,
-0.0186934043,
0.007246166,
-0.0037663893,
0.0341470838,
0.0049181692,
-0.0158336088,
0.009365404,
0.0133245848,
0.0126702869,
0.0392886959,
-0.020560829,
-0.0127557237,
0.0533729121,
-0.0224726833,
0.0046946933,
-0.0129314605,
0.019799348,
0.0210636202,
0.0085112611,
-0.0538597368,
-0.1019433588,
0.0257172696,
0.005816306,
-0.0304197352,
0.0316398889,
0.044566337,
0.0013549327,
-0.0029910516,
-0.0147262402,
-0.006119417,
0.0072097601,
0.0044495962,
-0.0842386484,
0.0419697501,
-0.0212238505,
0.0658337176,
-0.074403055,
-0.0060211825,
0.0314813033,
0.0088573182,
-0.003753551,
-0.0691091195,
0.0522251762,
-0.0248206295,
-0.0480979457,
0.000814317,
-0.0303885713,
0.0223552752,
-0.0259615071,
-0.010454555,
0.065115422,
0.0451439917,
0.0032426354,
0.0084472466,
-0.0406316519,
0.0231553186,
-0.0331163108,
0.00847911,
0.0481451936,
0.0299917608,
0.0308062918,
0.0387583971,
0.0253492575,
-0.0823721737,
-0.0013150267,
0.0000585358,
0.0345860459,
0.0471133851,
0.0059049353,
-0.0072166459,
0.01131362,
-0.0567075536,
-0.0299448129,
-0.026003873,
-0.044140771,
0.0296831205,
0.0070836912,
0.0133875748,
-0.0269187335,
0.0221987739,
-0.0349350646,
0.0035723504,
-0.0498399884,
0.0263749249,
0.0866584629,
0.0526646301,
0.0142230205,
-0.0325443894,
0.0591251813,
-0.053884916,
0.08040791,
0.0273158867,
-0.0280823056,
0.0483481288,
0.0030973558,
-0.0119425915,
-0.0303397011,
-0.011259987,
0.0476289168,
-0.0208971165,
0.001597504,
-0.0282536708,
0.0267107859,
0.0687166527,
-0.0691798106,
-0.0331516452,
0.0041779261,
0.0702133924,
0.0202739481,
0.0472256951,
0.0507690758,
-0.0267479271,
-0.0207295939,
0.0457388572,
-0.0661210641,
0.015211652,
-0.0232663639,
0.0048207743,
0.0104717184,
0.0115753552,
-0.0089619244,
0.0411234125,
-0.0151110059,
0.0031288592,
0.0062321918,
-0.0325511694,
-0.0074227513,
0.0176764242,
2.829e-7,
-0.0593410283,
-0.0128186187,
0.0351532511,
-0.0019466284,
0.0220991429,
0.011027067,
0.0136241037,
-0.0027448314,
0.0024286048,
-0.0032454468,
0.0310653243,
0.0403342769,
0.0510867834,
-0.0536168106,
-0.0262123197,
0.0199696738,
-0.0515674762,
-0.0190031696,
0.0462497696,
-0.0206501633,
-0.0179689582,
0.0920174122,
-0.0155904135,
-0.0148920827,
0.0392475165,
-0.0088277413,
0.078418985,
-0.003517892,
0.0170805529,
-0.0720251128,
-0.0054992167,
-0.0011307505,
-0.0434288941,
0.0112380451,
-0.0134086171,
0.0137429973,
-0.0028629298,
0.0330530368,
-0.0530416369,
-0.0840906203,
-0.0213275403,
0.0535059012,
-0.0605865531,
0.0712736547,
0.0515659042,
0.0162061397,
-0.0521663465,
-0.0090369126,
-0.0540114306,
0.0056851152,
0.0148151182,
-0.005993491,
-0.0100554405,
0.0249779616,
0.0350536108,
-0.0716673061,
0.0029322312,
-0.0448649973,
0.0303647779,
-0.0139866332,
-0.0521025397,
-0.0058935019,
-0.0460745767,
0.0118328938,
0.044890333,
0.0282949228,
-0.0743876398,
1.597008602e-34,
0.0446891636,
-0.0316946544,
0.02829892,
-0.0247824062,
-0.0056126644,
-0.0262107812,
0.0206705946,
-0.019873241,
0.0242990851,
-0.0648247823,
-0.0465614162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08624v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08624v6 | InstructABSA: Instruction Learning for Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-02-16T23:29:22 | 2023-11-13T17:56:19 | Kevin Scaria, Himanshu Gupta, Siddharth Goyal, Saurabh Arjun Sawant, Swaroop Mishra, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce InstructABSA, an instruction learning paradigm for Aspect-Based
Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) subtasks. Our method introduces positive, negative,
and neutral examples to each training sample, and instruction tune the model
(Tk-Instruct) for ABSA subtasks, yielding significant performance improvements.
Experimental results on the Sem Eval 2014, 15, and 16 datasets demonstrate that
InstructABSA outperforms the previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) approaches on
Term Extraction (ATE), Sentiment Classification(ATSC) and Sentiment Pair
Extraction (ASPE) subtasks. In particular, InstructABSA outperforms the
previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) on the Rest14 ATE subtask by 5.69% points, the
Rest15 ATSC subtask by 9.59% points, and the Lapt14 AOPE subtask by 3.37%
points, surpassing 7x larger models. We also get competitive results on AOOE,
AOPE, and AOSTE subtasks indicating strong generalization ability to all
subtasks. Exploring sample efficiency reveals that just 50% train data is
required to get competitive results with other instruction tuning approaches.
Lastly, we assess the quality of instructions and observe that InstructABSA's
performance experiences a decline of ~10% when adding misleading examples. | [
0.0371478572,
0.0398401581,
0.0221191011,
0.0281599052,
-0.0063085491,
0.042556826,
0.0051334882,
0.003821017,
-0.0245548673,
-0.0424120575,
-0.0635604039,
-0.0426710881,
-0.0524062552,
0.0409828797,
-0.0364149697,
-0.0325156078,
0.0328204073,
0.021261517,
0.0124021471,
-0.00657734,
0.0273048095,
0.0376956314,
-0.0249146949,
-0.0283621084,
-0.0053521823,
-0.0079240445,
-0.0066599096,
-0.0076521267,
0.0207168255,
-0.0184231829,
0.0780209899,
0.0200415645,
-0.0013142853,
-0.0245141946,
0.0000022838,
-0.0027668069,
-0.0528826527,
-0.0299824495,
0.0238145478,
0.0001124908,
0.0669239461,
-0.0241959766,
0.0327694565,
0.0219087135,
-0.0542348661,
-0.0298155975,
0.0076011075,
0.090780817,
0.070800364,
0.1017044559,
-0.0159760341,
-0.0303913523,
-0.012160317,
-0.017516071,
-0.0160603225,
-0.0381998047,
-0.0023655596,
-0.0425199158,
-0.0176582951,
0.0847641975,
-0.0058063525,
0.006424428,
0.0182307083,
0.0291088,
0.0054959082,
0.0080597075,
0.0352396145,
0.0174538568,
-0.0150556229,
0.0472483486,
0.0526515245,
0.0104345279,
0.0118250791,
-0.0021976312,
-0.0126951821,
0.0077603413,
-0.0027136663,
-0.0179968681,
-0.0127960183,
0.0377338417,
0.0557113849,
0.0218210481,
-0.0283679981,
0.0136552984,
0.0417848341,
0.007783717,
-0.0316657573,
-0.062787734,
0.0387571566,
0.0627991036,
0.0022232933,
0.0123338448,
0.0104749864,
-0.0012283107,
-0.0143785048,
0.0386649147,
-0.0148951421,
0.0386810303,
0.0060877749,
-0.0502556413,
0.0330065265,
-0.0053112349,
-0.0177681874,
0.0240073949,
0.0028827675,
-0.0374380574,
0.0561717488,
0.0136592062,
-0.0382969677,
0.0369503796,
-0.0960679501,
0.0419596434,
-0.007199856,
0.0665638447,
-0.0453584306,
0.0210885368,
-0.0539417043,
-0.0199103057,
0.0000432621,
-0.0126456833,
0.0214856099,
-0.0132488925,
0.0152776577,
0.0219969563,
-0.0331698433,
0.0163784605,
-0.0487317666,
0.0426597819,
-0.0527754799,
0.0187614691,
-0.0144449184,
-0.0024893868,
0.0040314989,
0.0011732429,
0.042528946,
-0.0112142675,
0.0163425431,
-0.0755096152,
-0.0317232646,
-0.0126650473,
0.0144694522,
-0.0503090434,
-0.0125953043,
-0.046795994,
0.049716685,
-0.0160287041,
-0.0281333681,
0.0067102457,
0.0174159985,
0.0123745389,
-0.0325820707,
0.0442710184,
-0.0282351207,
-0.0171995312,
-0.0427797474,
0.0427752249,
0.053080298,
0.0480267629,
-0.0381763428,
0.0423819236,
0.0276549216,
0.0093046185,
0.0019500148,
-0.0107364934,
0.0213274602,
0.0041661896,
0.0456574596,
0.00303776,
-0.0268041268,
-0.0437633954,
0.017946016,
0.0309263766,
0.0066297487,
-0.0445157178,
-0.0043509086,
-0.0368274264,
-0.0223652553,
0.0662430003,
0.0298456382,
0.0559536815,
0.014423077,
-0.010513789,
-0.0248832013,
0.0084131947,
-0.0231848005,
-0.0236581769,
0.0172040202,
-0.040002808,
-0.0441113599,
-0.074672617,
0.0008677727,
-0.0356947631,
-0.0116039105,
0.0133841299,
0.0437545106,
0.0167785827,
-0.0645466968,
0.0105915526,
0.084659934,
-0.0439783819,
-0.0361883752,
-0.0186629388,
0.0476251356,
0.070450522,
-0.0082281437,
-0.0296868086,
-0.0348842181,
-0.0308087915,
0.0086349221,
0.0336852856,
0.0292622019,
-0.0300786514,
0.0106557012,
-0.0551887974,
0.0087005422,
-0.0249137748,
0.0168304127,
-0.0080926185,
0.0213554259,
0.0297381952,
-0.0059666415,
0.0113111595,
-0.0119406311,
0.0148844589,
-0.0137586584,
-0.0585202612,
0.0034467359,
0.0113528436,
0.0135883605,
0.0424405336,
-0.0036896847,
-0.0317521021,
0.0242645238,
-0.029911343,
-0.0445461832,
-0.0187621079,
-0.0539217144,
-0.0636836588,
-0.0006608389,
0.0222373605,
-0.0232437439,
0.0091693876,
-0.050367292,
0.0127428947,
-0.0095598493,
-0.0163703244,
0.0064890902,
-0.0152434278,
-0.0070646387,
0.0102540404,
-0.0000517686,
-0.0101258354,
0.0418947041,
-0.0426018536,
0.0140926745,
-0.0392807424,
-0.0164770838,
0.002191321,
0.0329180509,
0.0033041034,
-0.0365680754,
0.0033365954,
0.0050071012,
0.007797013,
0.0600723475,
-0.0406708121,
-0.0450573005,
-0.1067179665,
0.0156384204,
-0.0004358009,
0.0608324595,
0.0242358595,
-0.0344743058,
-0.0026532344,
0.0228200927,
-0.0230460092,
-0.029508967,
-0.0637398437,
0.0201957803,
0.0335100293,
0.0289988965,
0.0121208606,
-0.0486107171,
0.0109762913,
-0.023484638,
-0.0295867026,
0.0125248218,
0.0201935675,
-0.0353206024,
0.047002539,
0.0018778818,
0.001541555,
-0.0049716053,
-0.0296887215,
-0.0270483177,
-0.0214494858,
-0.0318275131,
0.0156298205,
0.0148512414,
0.0493963771,
-0.0090583889,
0.0115783121,
-0.0340184607,
0.0465246625,
-0.0508235432,
0.0015667274,
-0.0049124132,
-0.0526499115,
-0.0043118587,
0.0722154751,
-0.0145988502,
0.0169029981,
-0.041643668,
0.0169917662,
-0.01609331,
0.018116923,
0.0225698613,
0.0399131663,
0.0228788704,
-0.0508178249,
-0.0251101758,
0.00143146,
0.0692622885,
0.0378638394,
-0.0234347526,
-0.1229737252,
-0.0210783817,
-0.0255403891,
0.0494279973,
-0.0429893397,
-0.0012361138,
0.0409111381,
0.0272674225,
0.0077718836,
-0.0231893566,
-0.0172123313,
-0.0165119581,
0.040504761,
-0.0031694756,
-0.0162424911,
0.0091855219,
-0.0277223829,
-0.0103264423,
-0.0469023921,
0.0121259661,
0.0012514389,
0.0107588014,
0.0068846764,
-0.0045097698,
-0.0539469346,
-0.0295946579,
-0.0299410447,
-0.0207359213,
-0.032555569,
0.0304732062,
0.0163221285,
0.0626182407,
-0.0580862239,
-0.012936336,
-0.0393447168,
0.0223127641,
0.0645265579,
-0.0401161648,
-0.0262376554,
0.0025298374,
-0.0102837486,
0.0341781303,
-0.014011465,
0.0071225828,
-0.0294076223,
0.0893085673,
-0.0566013418,
-0.0173590295,
0.1213146299,
0.0438581444,
-0.0395485125,
-0.0095150163,
0.0359860957,
-0.0297936201,
0.0336437263,
0.0106689371,
-0.0438278541,
-0.0464601703,
-0.0620293804,
0.0594018586,
-0.0102614025,
-0.0082284147,
0.0097018955,
-0.0959105492,
0.0197511017,
-0.0265249629,
-0.04767536,
-0.0578348413,
-0.0594365485,
0.0003739649,
-0.0247296337,
-0.0051565957,
-0.028431667,
-0.0352037065,
0.0121367769,
0.0169637185,
-0.0198627524,
-0.0150743295,
0.0526311733,
-0.0129273348,
0.0272526387,
0.0070667323,
0.0274953451,
-0.0058914977,
-0.0433860272,
0.0177652724,
-0.0553801432,
0.0036684738,
-0.0594914593,
0.0962442681,
-0.0455498025,
-0.0227673538,
-0.0006864825,
0.015945727,
-0.0511651412,
0.035720028,
0.0208792221,
0.0341039635,
-0.0001874345,
-0.0077601071,
-0.0157102905,
0.011866102,
0.0290555935,
0.0618162751,
-0.0108990353,
-0.0710304379,
0.0091072386,
-0.0016606026,
0.004120585,
-0.0686301664,
-0.0097003821,
-0.055731561,
-0.044807028,
0.003453759,
-0.0552380495,
-0.0848052129,
0.0197358243,
0.013153566,
-0.0325317234,
-0.0200397521,
-0.0122029949,
0.0045759948,
-0.0436657146,
0.0125982165,
-0.0006396819,
-0.0012746104,
-0.0192442257,
-0.0792675093,
0.0547978245,
-0.0137527892,
-0.0084076999,
-0.0217907857,
-0.0249830373,
-0.036466375,
-0.007075639,
0.0510996655,
-0.0093663158,
0.0322232097,
0.0293451287,
0.0208472311,
0.0205558762,
0.0405437984,
-0.0209376439,
-0.0041589881,
0.0867471397,
0.0529020168,
0.0193418674,
0.0401034988,
0.0105235316,
0.0629825443,
0.0198794063,
0.0119487233,
-0.066451557,
0.0312205553,
0.0080182217,
-0.0115698408,
0.0713875741,
0.0412581861,
-0.040302515,
-0.0252946522,
0.0081394743,
-0.0002298297,
0.0000241114,
-0.032829266,
0.0105771525,
-0.0088217491,
-0.0098063881,
-0.0569749177,
0.0658767894,
-0.0153948711,
0.0262828823,
-0.0322680473,
0.0801507756,
-0.0045130504,
0.0248139035,
-0.0373780131,
0.0108314324,
-0.0289655421,
-0.0331423581,
0.0495673008,
0.0003093064,
-0.001074566,
0.073439002,
-0.000652935,
0.0310159419,
-0.0157302395,
0.0123923942,
0.014898533,
0.0470583402,
-0.0270377435,
0.0161251239,
-0.0020825169,
-0.048918914,
0.0442591943,
-0.02443018,
0.0090336315,
0.0151961148,
0.0236079302,
-0.0476875119,
0.0135365389,
0.0395588465,
0.0183171406,
0.0018239489,
-0.0126045663,
0.0368485264,
-0.10225977,
0.0525761507,
0.0346628577,
-0.0012861317,
-0.0358219817,
-0.0073641869,
0.0369471833,
0.0163936969,
0.0048791785,
0.0655525401,
-0.0157070104,
-0.0163204689,
0.0087837717,
-0.0508943796,
0.0150425537,
0.0101049021,
0.0522096753,
0.0337787829,
0.0120177055,
0.0320074894,
-0.0628183782,
-0.0289844573,
0.0022178357,
-0.0306357555,
0.0149683356,
-7.036906648e-33,
-0.018186206,
0.0289289653,
-0.0056456332,
0.0398906171,
-0.0065268087,
0.0236073826,
-0.0058930949,
0.0407178439,
-0.0049982844,
0.0471859984,
0.0339375138,
0.0043639508,
-0.0128568299,
0.0223399401,
0.0171324015,
-0.0090807183,
0.0458918922,
-0.0045711915,
0.0088635813,
0.0302251521,
0.0467930026,
0.0321453586,
0.0776674971,
-0.1289363503,
0.0354879759,
-0.0032613182,
-0.0322134644,
0.0133000687,
0.0217783563,
0.0301367026,
-0.004256485,
0.04008542,
0.0313686356,
-0.034961082,
0.0266119409,
-0.0014974253,
-0.0472004749,
-0.0451629162,
0.0098913889,
-0.0269444007,
-0.0579659715,
-0.046639137,
-0.0084670549,
0.0202603396,
-0.0060888045,
-0.0320596807,
0.0117753102,
-0.018607283,
0.0486031398,
-0.0599377118,
-0.0671917424,
0.0083331056,
0.0231595729,
-0.0505621471,
0.0120831849,
0.0313340463,
0.0254622363,
-0.0096900156,
-0.0169787183,
-0.0052028354,
-0.0153056961,
0.0498990901,
-0.041452568,
-0.0359300226,
-0.0337406658,
0.0452134795,
-0.0169304367,
-0.012491337,
0.007542294,
0.0327005796,
-0.0002956788,
0.0322539955,
0.0040086112,
-0.0095518269,
0.0280122254,
-0.0183599219,
-0.0499575846,
0.028000718,
0.0664700046,
0.0046642539,
0.034629792,
-0.0248921886,
-0.0970489681,
-0.0012977594,
0.0328815989,
-0.0192644782,
-0.0132105397,
-0.0337455124,
-0.0033981793,
0.0617561676,
-0.0357987508,
0.0203608572,
-0.0365107358,
-0.0334242098,
0.0002512494,
0.0229314305,
-0.0458515547,
0.0036733795,
0.0034569439,
-0.0366139226,
-0.1088747829,
-0.0425654054,
-0.0171882138,
-0.0139380181,
0.0059949742,
0.0001182716,
0.1013948247,
0.0105074886,
-0.090370886,
-0.0174878314,
-0.0004140845,
0.0656238794,
-0.0210464709,
0.0121412296,
-0.0337557644,
0.0302552693,
-0.0345795713,
0.1294145882,
0.0031054835,
0.0461021923,
-0.0466190726,
-0.0130418967,
0.0168127883,
0.0072252983,
-0.0150991259,
-0.0082473429,
0.0211236402,
-0.0330689959,
-0.0534936264,
-0.0691781119,
-0.0296010934,
-0.0012366213,
2.966e-7,
0.0161946639,
0.0745182112,
-0.0134726213,
0.0230063759,
0.003377663,
0.0647015572,
0.0045601157,
0.0177530013,
-0.0060652625,
0.0044579292,
0.0226814356,
0.0531951822,
0.0091405138,
0.0332580246,
-0.0485813506,
0.0271497034,
0.013066737,
-0.0279084705,
-0.0255664047,
0.0155250672,
0.0867792219,
0.0809245035,
0.0420801491,
0.0004215247,
-0.0151428226,
0.057453014,
0.0520172715,
0.0016477993,
-0.0473284759,
0.0244770832,
-0.0524963737,
0.0222743843,
-0.0184929091,
-0.0182256177,
-0.0280488916,
0.0263615213,
-0.0214865915,
0.0665035769,
0.0232688878,
-0.0583620258,
0.0489355884,
0.0220979359,
0.0220891908,
0.0181083772,
0.0543609411,
-0.0402533412,
-0.0175490845,
-0.0677554607,
-0.0240320116,
0.0668792054,
-0.0105885267,
0.0186769757,
-0.0157819856,
0.0362277031,
-0.0267530195,
-0.054214526,
-0.038970381,
-0.0588831902,
0.0017058626,
0.0584371723,
0.0367143042,
-0.0186530463,
0.0233325642,
0.0480993167,
-0.0188652966,
-0.0363705717,
0.019295644,
2.693027711e-34,
0.0464367196,
-0.0176119469,
0.0185599197,
0.0465014689,
-0.0233630706,
-0.0026639551,
-0.0664338768,
-0.0263364054,
0.032271307,
0.0058649029,
0.0226191562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10186v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10186v7 | E2E Spoken Entity Extraction for Virtual Agents | 2023-02-16T21:45:35 | 2023-11-09T20:51:27 | Karan Singla, Yeon-Jun Kim, Srinivas Bangalore | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | In human-computer conversations, extracting entities such as names, street
addresses and email addresses from speech is a challenging task. In this paper,
we study the impact of fine-tuning pre-trained speech encoders on extracting
spoken entities in human-readable form directly from speech without the need
for text transcription. We illustrate that such a direct approach optimizes the
encoder to transcribe only the entity relevant portions of speech ignoring the
superfluous portions such as carrier phrases, or spell name entities. In the
context of dialog from an enterprise virtual agent, we demonstrate that the
1-step approach outperforms the typical 2-step approach which first generates
lexical transcriptions followed by text-based entity extraction for identifying
spoken entities. | [
0.0291035958,
0.0304591153,
0.0028461863,
0.0391526707,
0.0433726534,
0.0381225757,
0.0122868437,
0.0208792817,
0.0053234445,
-0.02132608,
-0.0158612989,
-0.007329748,
0.0177631788,
0.0310098939,
0.0283151399,
-0.058887057,
0.0247567035,
-0.040833015,
-0.0014262812,
0.0164322518,
0.0106414268,
-0.0007633413,
-0.0443886258,
0.0211122204,
0.0069563314,
0.0389347114,
-0.0122748706,
0.0113524748,
0.026737025,
0.0102665024,
-0.0208875388,
-0.0248343814,
0.0341083556,
-0.0016999315,
0.0000016849,
-0.0139678018,
-0.0539561249,
0.000503782,
-0.1160709709,
-0.0123909684,
0.0079583209,
0.003344344,
-0.0327631384,
0.0121453647,
0.0148746213,
-0.0335196666,
0.0757819265,
0.0434331745,
0.0267457478,
0.0602310076,
-0.0414974652,
-0.0097661559,
0.0289602038,
0.0138381803,
-0.0042626238,
-0.055486694,
0.0125959832,
-0.0335751884,
-0.0140798539,
-0.0005838045,
0.0424214751,
0.0195797961,
-0.0203345306,
0.0332886428,
0.015864959,
0.0540457107,
-0.0330110341,
-0.023155015,
-0.0413993038,
0.1074149981,
0.0229351763,
0.0471276976,
0.0354937501,
0.0049971514,
-0.0095020933,
-0.0192780569,
0.0361609533,
-0.0234998856,
-0.0166844893,
-0.03121222,
-0.0007836863,
0.0382896401,
-0.0149322469,
-0.0331350379,
-0.0532528311,
0.0267312881,
0.0228977054,
-0.0347735547,
0.0407206044,
0.0267674215,
0.0280714724,
0.0003969358,
0.0684433654,
-0.0004320387,
-0.0294748638,
0.0151862856,
-0.0232685246,
-0.0079287328,
-0.0832149237,
-0.0141555844,
0.0220569689,
0.0407248251,
0.0142542562,
-0.0072781076,
-0.0130104562,
0.0527587421,
-0.0014066597,
0.0352362208,
0.0328873768,
-0.0349102207,
-0.0025430908,
0.0128380377,
-0.0820795596,
0.0409590267,
-0.0389968418,
-0.0178696029,
0.0003512065,
0.002330933,
0.0007532192,
0.0315098614,
-0.0010081633,
-0.0116760423,
-0.0234907772,
-0.0157284606,
-0.0125769405,
0.0043762121,
-0.0492507666,
0.0292530935,
0.008024347,
-0.0753770918,
-0.007236151,
-0.0258296616,
0.0707251728,
-0.0373461954,
0.0137814553,
0.071048446,
0.017590208,
-0.0443604887,
-0.0148033155,
-0.0223568752,
0.013081043,
-0.0274382345,
-0.027883634,
-0.0161504261,
0.0539774932,
-0.0316825509,
-0.0013700679,
-0.0349864289,
0.0091913594,
-0.0510881096,
-0.0429899618,
0.0821409076,
-0.0332964659,
0.0186970346,
0.0692921951,
-0.0118725123,
0.0271277893,
0.0148107717,
0.0593953319,
-0.0099084349,
0.038700413,
-0.0212341454,
0.0352516361,
0.0789680332,
-0.0043713418,
-0.0358518623,
0.0406770445,
0.0167314969,
-0.0135734687,
0.0048220344,
0.026597118,
0.0495760031,
-0.0661410615,
0.0110510373,
0.028604757,
0.0517802984,
-0.0076069389,
-0.0020115867,
0.0349893421,
0.0310357306,
-0.0044455011,
-0.0013127726,
-0.0102523929,
-0.0223395135,
0.0153855439,
-0.0097057112,
0.0199322458,
-0.0055505019,
-0.0363236256,
0.0038625682,
0.0789979026,
-0.0280522965,
0.0058333697,
0.0082988692,
0.0221136827,
-0.0056670909,
-0.0844721869,
0.0623249523,
0.0059993211,
-0.0604977906,
0.0092322063,
0.00230037,
-0.0247658957,
0.0829698741,
0.0452293716,
0.0090389913,
-0.0377328321,
-0.0341279171,
-0.0597444773,
0.0185886975,
0.0044168914,
-0.0281993654,
0.0812030509,
-0.028366318,
-0.026533071,
0.0416726992,
-0.0118902624,
0.0530148372,
0.0031792596,
0.0142494459,
0.032220155,
0.0195720047,
0.0147464396,
-0.0009252677,
-0.0165214334,
-0.0229609758,
0.0232654903,
0.0530858673,
0.0160027146,
0.0429550596,
-0.0378664657,
-0.0377680175,
0.0074083507,
-0.0320503786,
0.0217091013,
0.015543743,
-0.0145294135,
-0.0010905021,
-0.0188641082,
-0.0358060524,
-0.0024302274,
0.0237216596,
-0.0001382896,
-0.0541334637,
-0.0517116264,
-0.0458352752,
0.0429052189,
0.0174067561,
0.0215055719,
0.0121866008,
0.0303048361,
0.0126186963,
-0.0082721096,
0.0269794874,
-0.0234092996,
0.053300038,
0.0214433745,
-0.045875445,
-0.0558428355,
0.0065997308,
0.0243935399,
0.0406674482,
-0.0203668773,
0.0087049427,
-0.0268954132,
-0.0250044726,
-0.014524525,
-0.0815073624,
-0.0136955073,
-0.0067884726,
0.0349796824,
0.0059269923,
0.031248413,
-0.0359226763,
-0.0312232245,
-0.0301125906,
-0.0107890749,
-0.011907733,
-0.0238186866,
0.0150733683,
0.0017053303,
-0.0348733291,
-0.0309160594,
0.0087886238,
0.0028164121,
-0.0082633439,
0.0069043776,
-0.0462470129,
-0.0551032759,
0.0467619859,
-0.0093542002,
0.0295463651,
0.0104821622,
-0.0206376277,
-0.009257976,
0.0321111977,
0.0204292703,
0.0550344847,
0.0014866517,
0.0410557315,
-0.0579850972,
-0.0382389948,
-0.064048104,
0.0269283298,
-0.0174775589,
0.0351108499,
-0.04684202,
-0.0070162914,
0.0270719603,
0.0316436552,
-0.0062316647,
0.0691165999,
-0.0417610072,
0.0141164064,
0.0358619541,
-0.0536873527,
0.0146606294,
-0.0154935662,
-0.0385895111,
0.0209166575,
-0.0108243003,
0.0259223673,
0.0446859412,
-0.0657245889,
-0.0517683439,
0.002921025,
0.0112131946,
0.0092559475,
-0.006801758,
-0.0018388319,
0.0096118152,
0.0195651632,
-0.1171982437,
-0.0008222795,
0.0506222509,
0.0057826326,
-0.0391898602,
-0.0042015733,
-0.0045428681,
-0.0142355263,
-0.0065491996,
-0.0400024392,
-0.0411834791,
0.0053985082,
-0.0569875278,
0.0209104959,
0.0205667373,
-0.0368253067,
-0.0249005873,
0.0409360975,
0.0173021052,
0.0451614112,
0.0013573687,
0.0007113285,
-0.0448852368,
0.0316051953,
0.0478700511,
0.0835731849,
-0.0166118387,
-0.0360615924,
0.0567298122,
-0.0058753327,
0.0116011379,
-0.0284157302,
0.0270152204,
0.009809576,
0.0125472788,
-0.0408682376,
-0.0000064488,
0.0287390202,
0.049651891,
-0.0394910574,
-0.0021790941,
0.1205123141,
-0.0165432021,
-0.0075911782,
-0.0270830374,
0.0399032496,
0.0037550847,
-0.0157234054,
0.0403863266,
-0.0512691587,
-0.034516912,
0.0265964177,
0.0285265446,
-0.0063007772,
-0.0464639179,
0.0203168727,
-0.1168741807,
0.0201331247,
0.0109691471,
-0.0181774795,
-0.03470378,
-0.0165261086,
0.0141873043,
-0.0241586547,
0.0270137116,
-0.0068788449,
-0.0088109346,
-0.0178260095,
0.0155978613,
-0.0224873237,
-0.0051835729,
0.0314487331,
-0.0331026912,
0.0717043355,
0.0717864931,
0.0306164864,
-0.0144140692,
-0.0057208454,
-0.0649636164,
-0.0503116474,
-0.0116373599,
0.0046023983,
0.0735707283,
-0.0630913898,
-0.0273591243,
0.0093332035,
0.0203156471,
0.0225136783,
0.0429835208,
0.0328482389,
0.0142920846,
-0.0168417525,
0.0011333517,
0.0569365993,
0.0082137426,
0.0216405205,
0.063797392,
0.0171637721,
-0.028818462,
-0.031769678,
-0.0151757039,
0.0601389557,
-0.0334303565,
-0.0605471618,
0.011235062,
0.0064328262,
-0.039090775,
-0.0692177713,
-0.075435929,
0.0515218228,
0.053258989,
0.0059094382,
-0.0215732325,
0.0847643241,
0.0495877005,
-0.0117588453,
-0.023615526,
-0.0366221294,
0.0192632619,
-0.0380024463,
-0.019728072,
0.0112306876,
-0.0227215774,
-0.0275702812,
-0.031754218,
-0.0194083508,
-0.0446002781,
-0.0057875896,
0.0136819426,
0.0110344272,
0.0768400058,
-0.0404210016,
-0.0400158875,
0.0461090058,
-0.0249550603,
-0.1120823845,
-0.0190904327,
0.0589709021,
0.0118913548,
-0.0182287637,
0.0194938853,
-0.0283589456,
0.0270156842,
-0.002700072,
0.0196446888,
-0.0767971054,
-0.1002567858,
-0.0142117068,
0.0284845121,
0.0538027845,
0.0080296407,
0.0230919532,
-0.056244351,
0.050066594,
-0.0238112733,
0.0704597458,
-0.0422858745,
-0.0101308785,
-0.0270417612,
0.0195402876,
0.0163420588,
0.02176526,
-0.02905472,
-0.013522815,
0.0031773492,
0.0098906206,
-0.0177657679,
0.0361420512,
0.016380759,
-0.0237338822,
-0.0007441106,
0.0686350018,
0.0561434887,
0.0638292581,
-0.0246736817,
0.0408320166,
-0.0227014497,
-0.0170698073,
0.003442561,
0.0256806947,
-0.0221794788,
-0.0169912539,
-0.0357349887,
0.0499345288,
0.0049287183,
0.0071240249,
0.066974014,
-0.004799387,
0.0312746167,
-0.0135019757,
0.0115402332,
-0.0307239778,
-0.0062136189,
0.0066258828,
-0.0008376821,
-0.0226944461,
0.0014502931,
0.0275352485,
-0.0299328677,
0.0540629663,
-0.0400147438,
0.0386842377,
-0.0694678947,
-0.047080975,
-0.0192397293,
-0.0189366452,
-0.0305342283,
-0.0141943255,
-0.0118086068,
-0.023417756,
0.0256478786,
-0.0088771125,
-0.0302716792,
-0.0302380398,
0.0325859971,
-0.0288614482,
-0.0238839649,
0.020507073,
-0.024383612,
-0.0492283367,
0.0004378204,
-0.0015571804,
-0.0045161275,
-5.598014503e-33,
-0.0744418949,
0.0153581211,
0.0502808914,
0.0306098033,
-0.0481944755,
0.01049772,
-0.0452045538,
0.0105755189,
-0.0141006056,
-0.0518959537,
-0.0161970053,
-0.0054433313,
0.040901199,
0.0004716057,
-0.0478669256,
-0.0183582623,
0.0609161034,
-0.0059241052,
0.0113409664,
0.0294239279,
0.0157549698,
0.0765744746,
0.0618554614,
-0.0841067955,
0.0000962938,
-0.0108762821,
0.0096045388,
-0.0127854869,
0.0762891099,
0.0293647181,
-0.028025791,
-0.0114620337,
-0.0262513254,
-0.0651247427,
0.0004708359,
0.0461520813,
-0.1093954295,
0.0091387369,
-0.0429182202,
0.0693087056,
0.0044733495,
-0.0466193743,
0.0161365252,
0.0031189709,
0.0014061512,
0.0253757387,
0.0311202016,
-0.0031565707,
0.0161455069,
-0.0462329052,
-0.0575546958,
0.0391667001,
-0.0225409418,
0.0194774996,
0.1009917632,
0.039359089,
0.031179063,
-0.0662430674,
-0.0718986765,
0.0120524075,
0.0229852423,
-0.0508025251,
0.0092099002,
0.0185572468,
0.01067641,
0.0389413163,
0.0563996024,
-0.0201613419,
-0.0413846485,
0.010167758,
0.0180375502,
0.0423633456,
-0.0411274843,
0.0491122901,
0.0119359111,
-0.0373199619,
-0.0389943421,
0.0292812511,
-0.0021758832,
-0.0201191958,
-0.0227364078,
-0.0155325169,
-0.0744632855,
0.024909215,
-0.0174086392,
0.020939419,
-0.0208847616,
-0.0454886332,
0.0370798707,
-0.0102154734,
-0.041490078,
0.0008235169,
0.0624719039,
-0.0359858982,
-0.0078515559,
-0.0144482162,
-0.0019137724,
-0.0135312127,
-0.0398862734,
-0.0000954307,
-0.0407550782,
-0.0614354797,
0.0665749684,
0.0184876453,
0.0284424201,
0.0041927686,
-0.0233275238,
-0.0020206224,
-0.043106731,
-0.0218569227,
0.0011482922,
0.0425059982,
-0.0269434359,
0.0292875618,
0.0366379023,
-0.01193933,
-0.0160722435,
0.0180849079,
-0.0127689699,
-0.0083239349,
-0.0231343769,
0.0176022165,
0.0641534999,
0.0363179371,
-0.0408714227,
0.005206577,
-0.0128848264,
-0.0295039769,
0.0053045689,
-0.0115906959,
-0.0034108297,
-0.0236666352,
2.442e-7,
-0.0255551077,
0.0233598668,
0.0622206219,
-0.0203341413,
0.0130383559,
0.0441295803,
0.0699540153,
0.0206316896,
-0.003744035,
-0.0226859562,
0.0528082103,
0.0059194621,
0.0778340846,
0.0052378639,
-0.0863392279,
-0.0720252991,
-0.0165971499,
0.0069601792,
-0.0570260547,
0.0404562838,
0.0548148975,
0.0646542236,
-0.0122231282,
-0.0171976406,
-0.024049608,
0.0324793905,
0.0261613932,
-0.0319749303,
0.0398278944,
0.0305860378,
-0.017774174,
0.0470590256,
-0.0401866622,
0.0453765728,
-0.0142524578,
0.0499522202,
0.0174276289,
0.0674022436,
-0.0194300879,
-0.0314635485,
-0.0059699896,
-0.0406426042,
-0.0184572376,
0.0422706045,
0.065440312,
-0.0380904488,
-0.0282476489,
0.0270180404,
-0.0595013835,
-0.0033232861,
-0.055485066,
-0.0032959473,
-0.0188433509,
0.0260394327,
0.0199703928,
-0.0317725129,
-0.0076053175,
-0.0644626766,
0.0600632951,
0.0032041431,
-0.0384605415,
-0.0311295614,
-0.0016549701,
-0.0555186309,
0.0220670421,
-0.0027704008,
0.0206820518,
1.484122574e-34,
-0.0485269837,
0.0286359247,
-0.0011251263,
0.0577516891,
0.0176999196,
-0.0194227397,
0.0350014083,
-0.0236902703,
-0.0038367915,
-0.0573089831,
-0.0335506573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08590v1 | What A Situated Language-Using Agent Must be Able to Do: A Top-Down Analysis | 2023-02-16T21:30:26 | 2023-02-16T21:30:26 | David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even in our increasingly text-intensive times, the primary site of language
use is situated, co-present interaction. It is primary ontogenetically and
phylogenetically, and it is arguably also still primary in negotiating everyday
social situations. Situated interaction is also the final frontier of Natural
Language Processing, where, compared to the area of text processing, very
little progress has been made in the past decade, and where a myriad of
practical applications is waiting to be unlocked. While the usual approach in
the field is to reach, bottom-up, for the ever next "adjacent possible", in
this paper I attempt a top-down analysis of what the demands are that
unrestricted situated interaction makes on the participating agent, and suggest
ways in which this analysis can structure computational models and research on
them. Specifically, I discuss representational demands (the building up and
application of world model, language model, situation model, discourse model,
and agent model) and what I call anchoring processes (incremental processing,
incremental learning, conversational grounding, multimodal grounding) that bind
the agent to the here, now, and us. | [
0.0414334089,
-0.0372858606,
-0.0445112623,
0.000707884,
-0.0223616567,
-0.0145202624,
0.0082866447,
-0.0176336076,
0.0456776172,
-0.0898452625,
-0.0263585411,
-0.0010913463,
0.0387518667,
0.0078235911,
0.0171400812,
-0.0477843061,
0.0081273718,
0.0100212526,
0.014423959,
0.0075811008,
0.0000894063,
0.0018426342,
-0.0206965879,
0.0417664945,
-0.0355374403,
-0.0058351303,
-0.044144243,
-0.0359530635,
0.0174066536,
0.0119385757,
0.0016231051,
0.0372403413,
0.0698083639,
0.0063732634,
0.0000021485,
-0.0234165657,
0.0510488302,
-0.0410181396,
0.005378393,
-0.0814538971,
0.0205388609,
0.0020009459,
-0.0156706367,
-0.0328104533,
-0.0846549943,
-0.0370867141,
0.017582085,
0.0156359263,
-0.0193130672,
0.0209980719,
-0.02104255,
-0.0092108017,
0.0136479782,
0.0490374006,
0.0181664452,
0.004223363,
0.0047920067,
0.0359192379,
0.0809104964,
0.0177887939,
-0.0409457497,
0.0517341234,
0.0198595338,
-0.0410491154,
0.0246594138,
0.0615469515,
-0.0108462172,
-0.019316975,
-0.0040942421,
0.0565458946,
0.0607318692,
-0.014771563,
-0.0236778203,
0.0191082917,
0.0134209329,
0.019184377,
-0.008474675,
0.035830114,
0.012579238,
0.0271034334,
0.0065411176,
-0.0053761122,
-0.0196092483,
0.0449328683,
0.0094099818,
0.1001913026,
-0.0392252728,
0.005104789,
-0.0019464561,
0.0343036875,
0.0380861536,
-0.0644038618,
0.009552123,
0.0404210649,
-0.0352676921,
0.0378762223,
-0.012057608,
0.0504768975,
-0.0100631118,
-0.0510821007,
0.0125570623,
0.0317606628,
-0.0222312175,
0.0328022279,
0.0363309644,
0.016197674,
0.0117060291,
-0.0211276039,
0.0001487879,
0.0415419154,
-0.0330581181,
-0.0081324382,
-0.0213965513,
0.0078604082,
-0.095593214,
-0.0224868339,
0.0552900769,
0.0750576481,
0.010099276,
0.0151044233,
-0.0439555757,
0.0325961523,
-0.0397586823,
0.0218911208,
-0.015717905,
0.0092020715,
-0.0520715453,
0.0337575451,
-0.0200825147,
-0.0914176255,
0.0356170647,
0.0101451641,
0.0249124728,
-0.0266277939,
-0.0671112239,
0.041734729,
0.0229272377,
-0.0463371873,
-0.0261438321,
-0.0313719884,
-0.0221590679,
-0.0677127019,
-0.0377311856,
-0.0246157479,
-0.0019962806,
0.0062371343,
-0.0255119521,
-0.0800298974,
0.0119833127,
0.0125899175,
-0.0051694531,
0.0820872933,
0.0133039514,
0.0005313416,
0.0560451746,
0.0028251624,
0.0266072955,
0.0245544333,
0.0455149785,
0.0057617812,
0.0398712493,
0.0055423873,
0.0021534127,
-0.0138621805,
-0.0209817849,
0.0069441199,
0.0295423996,
0.0132646048,
-0.0321650058,
0.0212939996,
-0.0132681709,
0.009702771,
-0.014513474,
0.0328559354,
0.0567972474,
0.0929807052,
-0.0180709679,
0.009852048,
0.0087294579,
0.0338949598,
-0.0540260263,
0.0285714697,
-0.0221290141,
0.0413369909,
-0.0190920364,
-0.0111888144,
-0.042012237,
0.0164480116,
-0.0289409328,
-0.0423580967,
0.0213672537,
0.0205677748,
0.0620791502,
-0.0187084544,
-0.002975703,
0.0026799678,
-0.00284058,
-0.0106091071,
0.0342321917,
-0.0542689748,
0.0047367206,
-0.0275018793,
0.0068067857,
0.0495929569,
0.0045734057,
-0.0066272491,
0.0013555571,
-0.0122224633,
0.0379712321,
0.0667872652,
-0.0234643985,
-0.0093710711,
-0.0359956548,
-0.0043365746,
-0.0345896482,
-0.0283466801,
0.0015291276,
0.0156808849,
-0.0458746962,
0.0508204289,
0.0054200171,
0.0466958322,
-0.013209613,
0.0068809772,
-0.0140969297,
-0.0192055088,
-0.0516979955,
0.0231056567,
-0.0018664482,
0.0343047529,
-0.0132125523,
0.000147073,
0.0372305848,
-0.0012737415,
0.0265622549,
0.1076075286,
-0.027086461,
-0.0283346847,
0.0308891833,
-0.0666768104,
0.009045844,
-0.0448551737,
0.0452364683,
-0.0273075253,
0.0421198644,
-0.0500002317,
0.0549908318,
-0.0303045046,
0.0042506605,
-0.0406219848,
-0.0013290296,
-0.0206767637,
0.0591785908,
0.0004230001,
-0.026264118,
0.0114912605,
0.0305508561,
0.0019891381,
-0.0218273923,
-0.0005249075,
-0.0159376767,
0.0381240137,
0.0241146237,
0.0503770337,
0.0134806111,
-0.0538911447,
-0.0133319125,
-0.1132384166,
-0.0705935135,
-0.0307301022,
-0.0108123664,
0.0298141278,
-0.0045363884,
-0.015508472,
-0.0331539437,
-0.0192038361,
0.0194136184,
-0.0075030145,
0.0294098165,
0.0417607315,
0.0091986042,
-0.0091637541,
-0.0376734659,
0.0309349857,
0.0058597494,
0.0288529973,
0.0178675633,
-0.0882904828,
-0.0474870987,
0.0234812424,
-0.0428359099,
0.0012500617,
0.0032446492,
-0.0121948496,
0.0614041798,
0.01501582,
0.0108288806,
0.0065251645,
0.0018325328,
0.0990152061,
0.0351270065,
-0.0457020067,
-0.051447276,
0.0139629273,
0.0032370384,
0.0221758727,
-0.0456621051,
0.0055085616,
-0.0272516888,
0.0507575534,
0.0113595575,
0.0084685376,
-0.0280302279,
0.0402508304,
-0.0306086875,
-0.0758909807,
-0.0053303093,
-0.0158845726,
-0.0257141776,
0.0432314053,
-0.0234239511,
-0.0280135721,
0.0374232419,
0.0145521555,
-0.0217493232,
-0.0221392475,
-0.015982626,
0.0186427999,
0.0835317224,
0.0031854154,
0.0279510692,
-0.0103862276,
-0.0338734202,
-0.0522759482,
-0.0689950958,
0.0046788598,
-0.001609499,
-0.0110853203,
-0.0644295365,
0.0117784301,
0.0313114263,
-0.0482948534,
-0.0265034027,
0.0116190463,
-0.0375088342,
0.0208859891,
-0.0488787107,
0.0114199724,
0.0036799,
0.0250385515,
0.0342738405,
0.0329847261,
0.0321994536,
-0.0172236525,
-0.0422112867,
0.0182001851,
0.0384730287,
0.081369102,
-0.0121293925,
0.0620880872,
0.019098876,
0.0424979031,
-0.0014062972,
-0.0208560415,
-0.0004341365,
0.0203115623,
0.0263747126,
-0.0195901785,
-0.0488741994,
-0.0031982358,
0.0327665284,
-0.0336280838,
-0.0256150365,
0.0798012763,
0.0301478151,
-0.0234297793,
0.0338502005,
-0.0547818728,
-0.0220330078,
0.0140592763,
0.0234666914,
-0.0281494353,
0.0238402374,
-0.0194192864,
-0.0548886657,
-0.0228998065,
-0.0364137962,
-0.0005101272,
-0.066017963,
0.0428284295,
0.0133207375,
-0.0127318269,
0.0089313956,
0.0206087008,
0.0105309365,
0.0596355237,
0.054559689,
-0.0121434806,
-0.0010912716,
0.0079443883,
-0.0044400045,
0.0242108665,
-0.008264021,
-0.0102847842,
-0.037828669,
0.042518802,
-0.0043368344,
0.0741027519,
0.022989314,
-0.0481631346,
0.018764006,
0.0168920793,
0.054818172,
-0.022551829,
-0.0375885777,
-0.0331991725,
0.0122314384,
-0.0538617633,
0.0362721942,
-0.0408207923,
-0.0257337522,
0.01348422,
0.0600329787,
-0.0680791438,
0.0294890869,
0.0129390825,
0.0208874363,
0.0420267284,
-0.0112101641,
0.0334911495,
-0.0511514358,
-0.0158584788,
-0.0168823097,
0.0263776667,
0.0680329129,
-0.0516117252,
0.0084101092,
-0.0108510572,
0.0046442971,
-0.0592229404,
-0.0943635702,
0.0424290337,
0.0523775332,
0.0386721492,
-0.0099633327,
0.0432004407,
-0.0085820155,
0.0001744161,
0.0138762817,
-0.0151469084,
0.031054141,
0.0500101149,
-0.014923024,
0.0517072417,
-0.0679492354,
0.0180506296,
-0.0842425898,
0.0336073153,
-0.0629715398,
-0.013763289,
-0.0123466607,
0.0258647129,
0.0683534443,
-0.0105576944,
-0.0309958104,
0.0300289337,
-0.0443667434,
-0.082814239,
0.0637671128,
0.0023703363,
-0.0388721004,
0.0257169101,
0.0219287407,
0.012077569,
-0.0014924171,
-0.0295046791,
0.0181054212,
-0.0834150389,
-0.0409851223,
0.0163527746,
-0.0484957062,
0.0262814499,
-0.0139235109,
-0.0201304834,
-0.0409662537,
-0.0062919823,
-0.0000299854,
-0.0300221872,
-0.0214731265,
0.0079106186,
-0.0134480968,
0.0687114671,
0.0106915357,
0.0053618983,
-0.0546275228,
0.0263267271,
0.0334995314,
0.0049243057,
0.030343974,
-0.0107391318,
-0.0349798314,
0.04785778,
-0.009725784,
0.0584775805,
-0.0412867144,
0.0428578444,
0.0036795747,
0.0459370278,
0.0180869009,
-0.0753794685,
-0.0145837693,
0.0363141634,
-0.0287511144,
0.0123220999,
0.0100501738,
0.0776548535,
0.0518098362,
-0.001935998,
0.0327829719,
-0.0189997703,
0.0184993744,
0.0129793594,
0.0119967898,
0.0458094105,
-0.1173471734,
-0.0246667583,
-0.0009506667,
-0.0414375179,
0.0164256617,
0.0037347993,
-0.0450579636,
0.0350705795,
0.0031346201,
-0.0110362023,
-0.0021424848,
-0.0325609371,
-0.0116132461,
0.0065777344,
-0.0089107845,
0.0539517775,
-0.0566485561,
-0.0610241033,
-0.0064903945,
0.0157172102,
-0.0563917197,
-0.0405411646,
0.0194007009,
0.0116388388,
0.0172413811,
-0.0202903375,
-0.0697500035,
0.0141683975,
-0.0391921438,
0.0047994545,
0.0035788589,
-5.956698237e-33,
-0.0698121488,
-0.0738001913,
0.0545703769,
0.024769878,
-0.0542687327,
-0.009525096,
-0.0421551168,
0.0322928354,
0.0030255099,
0.0402883552,
-0.0198311117,
0.0061612753,
0.0042596888,
-0.0036899578,
0.0072578532,
-0.0068470151,
-0.0223449189,
0.001411945,
0.0088127283,
-0.0172580685,
0.039451994,
0.0009893137,
0.0128732752,
-0.0845547393,
0.0425489098,
-0.0080911592,
-0.0167017318,
0.0325789675,
0.0055949292,
0.0136049688,
-0.0441547483,
0.0494784862,
0.0371048115,
0.0107548544,
0.0196857229,
0.0685734451,
-0.0696246997,
-0.0617494285,
0.0488548838,
0.0653031617,
-0.028892884,
-0.034146823,
-0.0217180941,
-0.0294330157,
-0.0537559018,
0.059626203,
0.0275638457,
-0.0163205005,
-0.0222589318,
0.055873625,
-0.0963856429,
0.0021590935,
-0.0235862285,
-0.0024561121,
0.0225211065,
-0.0109599913,
0.0120010925,
-0.0933477879,
-0.0779469162,
0.0431309678,
-0.0330822989,
-0.0297979694,
0.063448295,
0.004747923,
0.0330487564,
0.0741509721,
0.0129014701,
0.0301668681,
-0.041266866,
-0.0096569825,
0.0232281443,
0.0142116062,
-0.0531805754,
0.0567414053,
-0.1010311842,
-0.0086627593,
0.0033553564,
-0.0088040568,
0.0657953247,
0.0331057049,
0.0129798083,
0.0135200648,
-0.0280639492,
-0.0317196138,
-0.0392497741,
-0.0067460011,
0.0102453465,
-0.0597078577,
-0.0109163122,
-0.0234369878,
-0.009347368,
0.0085873986,
-0.0207890701,
-0.0540236048,
-0.0540626943,
-0.0312212836,
-0.0057221693,
-0.0011225815,
0.022421632,
0.0370772518,
-0.0037855732,
-0.0231287349,
-0.011069024,
0.025585616,
0.0110733276,
0.039956633,
-0.0332633518,
0.0575077347,
0.0024240015,
-0.019289704,
-0.0223153979,
-0.0038227744,
0.017311614,
0.0094002811,
0.0234654304,
0.0048513426,
-0.0422900468,
0.0296720415,
0.0494494401,
0.016814312,
0.0016601683,
0.0221951921,
-0.0364686772,
0.0211085845,
-0.0300697945,
-0.0063764304,
-0.0332712792,
0.0953818932,
0.0774420574,
-0.0246374253,
-0.0038573428,
-0.0234177653,
2.899e-7,
0.0058532897,
0.035287749,
0.0076253805,
-0.0784422383,
0.037461739,
0.0294681881,
0.0047070137,
0.0449683033,
-0.0083333245,
-0.0361903086,
0.0321831703,
0.01218135,
0.0139362849,
0.0250761397,
-0.0749896765,
-0.0060006515,
-0.0257332232,
-0.0156699792,
-0.0436545201,
0.0258866623,
0.0212961491,
0.0234114397,
-0.006652981,
-0.0102711134,
-0.0353287384,
-0.0858497396,
0.0120974714,
-0.0585895553,
0.0321535282,
-0.0152316475,
-0.039199546,
0.0038709817,
-0.0132607799,
-0.0149689512,
0.0284451954,
0.0369929671,
-0.0112404497,
0.0245263167,
-0.0237055831,
-0.010893262,
0.0205816478,
-0.0078983996,
-0.0135493651,
-0.0179207623,
0.038096372,
-0.046577476,
-0.0192591716,
0.0171552561,
0.0430503637,
-0.017298555,
-0.0180415288,
-0.0107800299,
-0.0177076682,
-0.0198882893,
0.0090353778,
-0.0294183809,
-0.0092085088,
-0.0763871893,
0.0137481196,
-0.0183968693,
0.0015177323,
-0.0322358124,
-0.0097424034,
-0.0146606015,
0.0400597565,
-0.0443917736,
0.0057464368,
1.820183092e-34,
-0.0168118589,
0.0387609862,
0.0228951052,
0.0461898819,
0.0302227587,
0.0181459766,
0.0684909225,
0.0039088982,
0.0769292414,
-0.0249175765,
-0.0251452401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08589v1 | Syntactic Structure Processing in the Brain while Listening | 2023-02-16T21:28:11 | 2023-02-16T21:28:11 | Subba Reddy Oota, Mounika Marreddy, Manish Gupta, Bapi Raju Surampud | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Syntactic parsing is the task of assigning a syntactic structure to a
sentence. There are two popular syntactic parsing methods: constituency and
dependency parsing. Recent works have used syntactic embeddings based on
constituency trees, incremental top-down parsing, and other word syntactic
features for brain activity prediction given the text stimuli to study how the
syntax structure is represented in the brain's language network. However, the
effectiveness of dependency parse trees or the relative predictive power of the
various syntax parsers across brain areas, especially for the listening task,
is yet unexplored. In this study, we investigate the predictive power of the
brain encoding models in three settings: (i) individual performance of the
constituency and dependency syntactic parsing based embedding methods, (ii)
efficacy of these syntactic parsing based embedding methods when controlling
for basic syntactic signals, (iii) relative effectiveness of each of the
syntactic embedding methods when controlling for the other. Further, we explore
the relative importance of syntactic information (from these syntactic
embedding methods) versus semantic information using BERT embeddings. We find
that constituency parsers help explain activations in the temporal lobe and
middle-frontal gyrus, while dependency parsers better encode syntactic
structure in the angular gyrus and posterior cingulate cortex. Although
semantic signals from BERT are more effective compared to any of the syntactic
features or embedding methods, syntactic embedding methods explain additional
variance for a few brain regions. | [
0.0085739437,
0.0221453309,
-0.0350177288,
-0.0010677774,
-0.0341608152,
0.0441264771,
-0.0113633117,
0.0276686661,
0.0050027096,
-0.0436436757,
-0.018677935,
-0.0199351236,
0.0517650507,
0.021717377,
0.0810029432,
-0.0553790182,
0.0304602906,
-0.0100129023,
0.0376753993,
0.0284598432,
0.0072611142,
-0.0152310506,
-0.0268757604,
0.0498071089,
-0.0193454102,
-0.0083874045,
-0.0165594704,
-0.0312571302,
-0.0234176256,
-0.0129101938,
-0.0411993787,
0.0333236754,
0.0198419262,
-0.0141307805,
0.0000017545,
-0.0114888093,
0.0260691009,
-0.0009813039,
-0.0043307659,
-0.0097214971,
0.0023874764,
-0.0110799018,
-0.0006084205,
-0.008912771,
0.0002541244,
-0.0169633124,
0.0485905074,
0.0396386236,
0.0058683963,
0.0525639988,
-0.0282850433,
-0.0447822101,
0.0565227866,
-0.0062605697,
0.0264289249,
0.0411434695,
0.0453819409,
-0.0275529344,
-0.0233442076,
0.0129122343,
-0.0367288962,
-0.0400382318,
0.0248294491,
0.0296816155,
0.0276995245,
0.0757339075,
-0.0309407078,
0.0035889314,
0.0058522634,
0.0145487012,
0.0099415099,
-0.0490152314,
0.0153747257,
0.018052768,
-0.0173995886,
-0.0093997363,
-0.0427477993,
0.0365950502,
-0.021908829,
0.0509688109,
0.0761437714,
-0.0425683782,
0.0050103627,
-0.0437484123,
0.0016128679,
0.0936565623,
0.0024642723,
-0.0698049739,
0.0380283929,
0.0311227515,
-0.0450904779,
-0.0476018898,
0.0210558511,
-0.0698750615,
0.0044913003,
0.0189963281,
-0.024801828,
-0.0695160404,
-0.0168868396,
-0.0768906176,
-0.0096863033,
0.0422412492,
-0.0112895034,
0.0223598853,
-0.0298725348,
0.0362601429,
-0.0462656766,
0.0416575633,
-0.0263918824,
0.0403174534,
-0.0653424114,
-0.0535595566,
-0.0351237729,
0.0275844503,
-0.0045182332,
-0.0639336631,
-0.0161799993,
-0.0070317658,
0.0196686871,
-0.0290817562,
-0.0220829677,
0.0095911985,
-0.0300064012,
0.0807312131,
0.0017939033,
-0.0106382584,
-0.0469612256,
0.0262667481,
-0.007248994,
-0.0087869987,
-0.0294715129,
0.0862806886,
-0.0260407571,
-0.0376246199,
-0.0372601449,
0.0062737805,
0.0049014185,
-0.0185054485,
-0.0045762006,
-0.0169399232,
-0.0290325806,
0.0341649391,
0.0556292199,
-0.0540755726,
-0.0000486459,
0.0341086648,
-0.0231505223,
-0.009358664,
-0.0021594691,
0.021769017,
-0.0201690067,
0.0149119003,
0.0184886791,
-0.0199980568,
0.0126986885,
-0.0055676373,
-0.0245009437,
0.0235370677,
0.054713998,
-0.0146970581,
-0.0323402472,
-0.0252395906,
-0.0507787503,
0.0199162792,
-0.0208555162,
-0.029825259,
-0.078971535,
-0.0416011699,
0.0025001559,
0.028339535,
0.036339391,
0.0207842123,
-0.043369703,
-0.0196645539,
0.0260791816,
0.0682151914,
-0.0055522765,
-0.0008650199,
0.0106495898,
-0.0179521088,
0.0194601677,
0.0346254073,
-0.045158416,
0.0134664737,
0.0088380855,
0.0069846599,
-0.0271621086,
-0.0450491309,
0.0228599347,
0.0039157844,
-0.0234149918,
-0.0292705968,
0.0062598665,
-0.0229731146,
0.0258051958,
0.0035853875,
-0.0360750929,
0.0772407949,
0.0340346955,
-0.0120906606,
0.0022689148,
-0.0006196966,
-0.0210664626,
0.023671953,
0.0079875831,
-0.0163132697,
-0.0086053675,
-0.0094487108,
-0.0041564656,
0.0562057346,
-0.0234422684,
0.0373338461,
0.0646844506,
-0.0040115281,
-0.0034838524,
0.0018749364,
0.006101266,
0.002269025,
-0.0640390515,
-0.0357924774,
-0.0398591012,
-0.0359247178,
0.0277143437,
0.0531324744,
-0.0088248374,
0.0016197312,
-0.0149332592,
-0.0004869944,
0.0352963954,
-0.0103411488,
-0.0364470594,
0.0447885357,
0.0160555653,
-0.0521695018,
0.0299060829,
0.0180316102,
-0.0677224025,
-0.0320359245,
-0.0087449877,
0.0072348928,
-0.016978981,
0.0480514057,
0.0538609661,
-0.0232187863,
0.0031792913,
-0.0918239355,
0.0825825781,
-0.0022266146,
-0.015083326,
-0.0344487987,
0.0160193611,
-0.0346338488,
0.0629636273,
-0.0106528066,
0.0184773281,
-0.0257469062,
-0.0288514066,
0.0374714099,
-0.0204776675,
-0.0394015722,
-0.0024006201,
-0.0026016396,
-0.0667781755,
-0.010589188,
-0.0254648793,
-0.0587919839,
-0.0249892659,
-0.1017651334,
-0.0278704725,
0.0129584521,
0.046938777,
0.0329606719,
-0.0268324334,
0.0099623501,
0.0209546275,
-0.0052468595,
0.0229249299,
-0.0363578424,
0.044585675,
-0.0011343007,
0.0055745714,
-0.0503416024,
-0.0418766774,
-0.0229217038,
-0.0950593129,
0.0842901394,
-0.0027539369,
-0.0696823746,
-0.0577569231,
0.0413358249,
0.0197247304,
0.0117663043,
0.0222790763,
-0.0489383638,
0.0723609701,
0.0030477976,
0.0460536145,
0.0922467932,
-0.0522320867,
0.0084701683,
0.0589089617,
-0.0335980803,
-0.0247673392,
-0.0215505864,
0.0010756404,
0.0880382434,
-0.0679366291,
-0.0208078362,
0.0202992521,
0.1044685394,
0.0770659223,
0.0260247812,
-0.0243141316,
-0.0042533455,
-0.0390389785,
-0.0201740228,
-0.0053201276,
-0.0691700131,
-0.0676496997,
0.0392957218,
-0.0202591214,
-0.0286004674,
0.0761861876,
-0.0159711316,
-0.0357230268,
-0.0460700504,
0.0184192639,
-0.0016066054,
0.0416118316,
0.0585137568,
0.002053953,
0.0055586789,
-0.1007680595,
-0.0297656953,
0.0051037725,
-0.0176020805,
0.0291121751,
-0.0285338052,
-0.0096492032,
-0.0171016026,
0.0362956524,
0.0041953344,
-0.0176884849,
-0.0236070734,
-0.0021020696,
0.0192002449,
0.0326155089,
-0.007846185,
-0.0070069637,
0.0013353032,
0.0274835713,
0.0190785583,
-0.0276084952,
-0.0252783597,
-0.0327519812,
0.0355166011,
-0.0089446101,
-0.0056577753,
0.0143303545,
-0.0134902075,
-0.0212631654,
0.03264907,
0.0337221883,
0.071859695,
-0.0567788109,
0.0205780212,
0.006749847,
-0.0201555267,
-0.0731987506,
0.0157454219,
-0.0250322502,
-0.0181427207,
-0.0087372307,
0.1104259193,
0.0451839715,
-0.0517864004,
0.0119957961,
-0.0331905633,
0.0529776216,
0.0170547403,
0.0202087592,
-0.0446933396,
0.010328657,
0.0116550764,
-0.0186690129,
0.0014052559,
-0.0335274674,
0.0323376358,
-0.0492937267,
0.0191609245,
0.0023992783,
-0.009575285,
-0.0164804067,
-0.036554534,
0.0325612351,
0.0125837857,
-0.0107844071,
0.0084441314,
0.0091544958,
0.0204846542,
0.0315796286,
-0.0556812882,
-0.0138207152,
-0.0104817217,
-0.0310022905,
0.0445320569,
0.0640591234,
0.0210668482,
-0.0492231138,
-0.0030006194,
0.0346275978,
-0.019727489,
0.0122511238,
-0.0036021075,
0.0288611557,
0.0487152226,
0.0076120333,
-0.0439493135,
-0.0065035825,
-0.0016620214,
-0.0505267568,
-0.0402407087,
0.1097250804,
-0.0435156599,
0.0129763791,
0.0421652645,
0.0352752134,
0.001862876,
0.0402220525,
0.0865096003,
-0.0528363995,
-0.0214312114,
-0.0129651995,
0.0490777455,
-0.0200074669,
-0.0043430221,
0.0115233548,
0.0293212496,
-0.0285296235,
-0.0699811354,
-0.03201456,
0.0508233532,
-0.0010041312,
0.0206495766,
0.0341944732,
0.0745878816,
-0.0714825764,
0.0191310029,
0.0123895444,
0.0516226217,
-0.0089455731,
-0.0113640083,
-0.028719157,
-0.0198996644,
0.0074923038,
-0.0277665574,
-0.0267463699,
-0.0261077788,
-0.0486416556,
0.0687063038,
0.0236248542,
0.0095775686,
-0.0272531342,
0.0030204407,
-0.0536219068,
-0.0145722404,
0.0289429016,
-0.0448301993,
0.0681004152,
-0.0294907466,
-0.0030592619,
0.0436733514,
0.0019344133,
0.0060982937,
-0.0204291753,
-0.009972224,
0.0059578936,
-0.0251563713,
0.0431315377,
0.0241246428,
0.0089290394,
0.0797283724,
0.0250593908,
0.0260421298,
-0.0251017902,
0.001407944,
-0.0270133205,
0.0303956475,
-0.0179226473,
-0.0402818359,
0.0338337533,
0.0430172831,
-0.0285029374,
-0.0134420795,
-0.0133598326,
0.0011965012,
0.0032735867,
0.0249226354,
-0.0196491815,
-0.016404625,
-0.0052827988,
0.0523260422,
0.0206009373,
-0.025548391,
-0.0550419204,
-0.0028542469,
0.0025201973,
0.0195026193,
0.0038395836,
-0.0390342437,
-0.0308271013,
-0.0189179201,
-0.0282007046,
-0.0203899629,
0.0564303547,
-0.0165470336,
0.018365033,
-0.0231118016,
0.0683672205,
-0.0333653875,
0.0319709741,
0.0033153838,
-0.0055167512,
-0.0190051496,
-0.0220483467,
0.0662827417,
0.0125450389,
0.0029257562,
-0.0707776695,
0.0586327165,
0.0317161568,
-0.0033757158,
0.0173761528,
-0.0062947059,
-0.0244945455,
-0.0275391508,
0.0057031051,
0.0216618124,
-0.0638755336,
0.0282212887,
-0.0132075455,
-0.0221748296,
0.0117886905,
-0.0252789482,
0.0375069119,
-0.0384769402,
0.0272846296,
0.0241215192,
-0.0016274879,
-0.0619849376,
0.03472206,
0.0128608439,
0.005470877,
-0.0588693395,
-0.0620671734,
-5.414725546e-33,
-0.0509102009,
-0.0260495339,
-0.0039477176,
0.0316985101,
-0.0323585346,
-0.0059792637,
-0.0513607636,
0.0452172533,
0.0537138954,
0.0194497611,
-0.0005286254,
0.0264261924,
0.0111278091,
0.0134825148,
0.0654839426,
-0.0100154998,
-0.0237402134,
-0.0478982627,
-0.0041689374,
-0.0315761864,
0.0486143939,
0.0310277194,
0.0895571187,
-0.0505756252,
-0.0170779377,
0.0361090861,
0.0263201911,
0.0017990798,
-0.0423011295,
0.0499976091,
-0.0050120656,
0.04366678,
0.0422906466,
0.0237539858,
-0.0230763536,
0.0573080257,
-0.0092969751,
-0.0488532297,
0.0761585683,
0.0389697812,
-0.0415256433,
-0.0104963621,
0.0827811211,
-0.0402228944,
0.0320474654,
0.0095636901,
0.0287661925,
-0.017170174,
-0.0102620963,
0.0513476431,
-0.0680829659,
-0.0218565874,
-0.0080922339,
0.0315138027,
0.016492622,
0.0521010533,
-0.0502879657,
0.0153664686,
-0.0619029328,
-0.0199690908,
-0.0515799113,
0.0726463124,
-0.0298657641,
-0.0201216601,
0.0409608819,
0.06623099,
0.0525062419,
0.0021031678,
-0.0424281172,
-0.0130636152,
0.0667918995,
0.0393691361,
0.0152217047,
-0.0454749987,
0.0212478433,
0.0050905822,
-0.0500573963,
-0.0362355597,
0.0683123097,
0.0411927961,
0.013421488,
-0.0050400556,
-0.0203333646,
-0.037116915,
-0.0030624166,
0.0101994043,
-0.0193283651,
-0.031106228,
0.019621579,
-0.0604560338,
0.0488600396,
0.0093751382,
0.0317502245,
-0.0131151052,
0.0517439172,
-0.0070951683,
-0.0268460792,
0.0550047904,
0.0292401761,
0.0054273661,
-0.0477672368,
-0.0396302119,
0.0114619602,
-0.0251736045,
0.0730437785,
-0.0010788589,
0.013319415,
-0.0036206713,
-0.0153220808,
-0.0068224319,
-0.0199623816,
-0.0466394164,
0.0303367078,
0.0115575623,
0.0423068926,
0.0180897899,
-0.0024200934,
-0.0225119498,
0.009092926,
0.0008008222,
-0.0341230631,
-0.0071126567,
-0.0320505723,
0.0383311212,
-0.0055421744,
-0.0302915741,
-0.0154266329,
0.0169943683,
0.0217747204,
-0.0363357775,
-0.0354194753,
0.0130105475,
2.659e-7,
0.0727757215,
0.0725058243,
0.0133882519,
0.0511098877,
0.0519813783,
0.0058143185,
0.0059407814,
0.0359135792,
0.0034318822,
-0.0380207077,
-0.0420192964,
-0.0197185464,
0.0058434028,
-0.0042191208,
-0.0874412656,
0.0022371393,
-0.0750016123,
0.0208891314,
-0.0463403277,
-0.0028433758,
0.0525060743,
0.0274602808,
-0.0118413437,
0.0055891233,
0.0035255565,
-0.0016010026,
0.0691289231,
-0.0238531213,
-0.0138082886,
-0.0224836096,
-0.0475517511,
-0.0260929111,
0.0015848525,
0.0615520179,
0.0124018956,
0.0182118248,
-0.0142473634,
0.0248404685,
0.0098715443,
0.0169473682,
0.0439660251,
0.007976139,
-0.0346270017,
-0.0422092974,
-0.0013316215,
-0.0695384815,
-0.0668366477,
0.0323512703,
-0.0058820159,
0.0155446203,
0.0358711965,
0.022384448,
-0.0172696225,
-0.0305645373,
0.0085218735,
-0.0377288982,
0.0132360589,
0.0115202842,
-0.0389259607,
0.062009722,
-0.0630539656,
0.0164087489,
-0.0251404028,
-0.0117790801,
0.0423471965,
-0.0455608331,
-0.0261196773,
2.473172385e-34,
-0.0365008004,
-0.0074817906,
0.0781567469,
0.0515270643,
0.0059226286,
-0.0037673409,
0.0299608745,
0.0117174378,
0.0114153856,
-0.0714855418,
-0.011702531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08583v1 | JEIT: Joint End-to-End Model and Internal Language Model Training for Speech Recognition | 2023-02-16T21:07:38 | 2023-02-16T21:07:38 | Zhong Meng, Weiran Wang, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Tara N. Sainath, Tongzhou Chen, Ehsan Variani, Yu Zhang, Bo Li, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | We propose JEIT, a joint end-to-end (E2E) model and internal language model
(ILM) training method to inject large-scale unpaired text into ILM during E2E
training which improves rare-word speech recognition. With JEIT, the E2E model
computes an E2E loss on audio-transcript pairs while its ILM estimates a
cross-entropy loss on unpaired text. The E2E model is trained to minimize a
weighted sum of E2E and ILM losses. During JEIT, ILM absorbs knowledge from
unpaired text while the E2E training serves as regularization. Unlike ILM
adaptation methods, JEIT does not require a separate adaptation step and avoids
the need for Kullback-Leibler divergence regularization of ILM. We also show
that modular hybrid autoregressive transducer (MHAT) performs better than HAT
in the JEIT framework, and is much more robust than HAT during ILM adaptation.
To push the limit of unpaired text injection, we further propose a combined
JEIT and JOIST training (CJJT) that benefits from modality matching, encoder
text injection and ILM training. Both JEIT and CJJT can foster a more effective
LM fusion. With 100B unpaired sentences, JEIT/CJJT improves rare-word
recognition accuracy by up to 16.4% over a model trained without unpaired text. | [
-0.0102168433,
0.0618857034,
0.0277918894,
0.0432208814,
-0.0087530762,
0.0068163206,
-0.0170543008,
0.0029300286,
-0.0153979771,
-0.0318577848,
-0.0579508506,
-0.0064487588,
0.02797365,
0.0109907445,
0.0414420925,
-0.0012501593,
0.05768428,
-0.0429394431,
-0.0217187684,
-0.030806683,
0.0049687861,
0.0098630963,
-0.03732609,
0.0116884075,
0.0122771813,
0.0596640185,
0.0066348882,
0.0428787805,
0.0538888574,
-0.0413348302,
-0.0326485112,
0.0265109446,
0.0361235775,
0.0275056157,
0.0000022755,
-0.0165431611,
0.0045078867,
-0.0168533772,
-0.0267927255,
-0.000721976,
0.0098977527,
-0.0116334939,
-0.0067132465,
0.0414584056,
-0.0008348307,
-0.030180186,
0.0635540932,
0.0424716696,
0.002857469,
0.0798674598,
-0.0097945658,
-0.0205033198,
0.0647612363,
-0.0221790243,
0.0228430722,
-0.0127723301,
0.0195432715,
-0.0433432609,
-0.0111466572,
-0.0367483608,
-0.0028547863,
0.025904458,
-0.0093561681,
-0.0013423202,
0.0636323243,
0.0352008827,
-0.0271239839,
-0.0041147601,
-0.0329666212,
0.0520212986,
0.0337776877,
-0.0390252061,
0.005361516,
0.0131059187,
-0.0574226864,
-0.0086554689,
0.0082005411,
-0.0148815485,
0.022842804,
0.0158033986,
0.0071705799,
-0.0038027796,
0.0164534729,
-0.00448405,
-0.0505315289,
-0.034819182,
0.0416650586,
-0.0242881216,
0.0107525345,
-0.014232954,
-0.0226484314,
-0.0061632851,
0.0070085698,
0.0325891338,
0.0494041927,
-0.0021494003,
-0.0568015985,
-0.0665984377,
-0.0074293287,
-0.0187865347,
0.0094825244,
0.0579042509,
-0.0310240369,
0.0129220225,
-0.0276053287,
0.0227164421,
-0.0018832358,
0.0638670251,
-0.0289660562,
-0.0082734991,
-0.0438400917,
-0.0083805183,
-0.0166306403,
0.013460407,
-0.0156618189,
-0.0391811728,
-0.0268119238,
-0.0000155566,
0.0063991225,
-0.0282794125,
0.027114423,
-0.0061581107,
-0.0790468007,
-0.0405022353,
0.0205031373,
0.036264196,
0.0599295311,
0.0489370301,
-0.001778378,
-0.0547454692,
-0.0201317929,
0.0298615433,
0.0468253493,
-0.0097070038,
0.0155007457,
0.0745896548,
-0.0224109851,
-0.0592315122,
-0.0427510776,
0.0287208967,
-0.0406788141,
-0.0475613512,
0.0078478754,
-0.0354847908,
0.0113366386,
-0.0164213814,
0.0216741692,
-0.0297579207,
0.0136626083,
-0.0210315343,
0.0092358179,
0.0914758742,
0.0139970835,
-0.0018597805,
0.0613473281,
-0.0107564079,
0.0729003325,
0.0541209243,
0.0328989476,
-0.0382594541,
-0.038580887,
-0.0109062744,
0.0043780394,
0.0828982294,
0.0144391917,
0.0561567731,
-0.0934004784,
-0.0194195919,
0.0181614533,
-0.0168938432,
0.0750524104,
0.049508255,
-0.0154752312,
0.022100646,
0.0787194148,
0.0169438869,
0.0699627027,
-0.0027329624,
-0.0139912926,
0.0033455491,
-0.0052139228,
-0.0528671071,
-0.0098014576,
0.0173460357,
-0.0386692062,
-0.0014201603,
0.065539673,
0.0344341062,
-0.0275927335,
0.0180688277,
-0.0116782198,
-0.0051472406,
0.010988432,
0.0247408673,
0.0760516524,
-0.0107884808,
-0.0488396659,
0.0557793453,
0.0319331549,
-0.0058030761,
0.0343704782,
-0.0282193627,
-0.0249925796,
0.0267728884,
0.0264146533,
-0.0185810197,
0.0126670906,
-0.0209753308,
-0.069687672,
0.0685358867,
0.0247130357,
0.0278912093,
0.0415517353,
-0.0762369782,
-0.0241521653,
0.0577849448,
0.0104072541,
0.0648684874,
-0.0624246113,
0.0516904928,
0.0118659884,
-0.0541604869,
0.0229815878,
0.0003586775,
-0.0612116382,
-0.035108719,
0.0142415259,
0.0096240789,
0.02428893,
0.0085869161,
-0.0261301864,
0.0050681308,
0.0267690383,
-0.0351660699,
-0.0295631774,
0.020700004,
-0.0711673647,
-0.0544778556,
0.0484253503,
-0.0268555656,
0.0489197448,
0.0451638922,
0.0371497683,
-0.0963585228,
0.0130875614,
-0.0422325805,
0.0664775595,
-0.0630193576,
0.0248843152,
0.0225967038,
0.0105617903,
0.0048644263,
0.0062362347,
-0.0117815835,
-0.0283398572,
0.0093244966,
-0.0803086311,
0.0102008134,
-0.0351130553,
-0.0428094268,
0.0566923656,
0.0166215766,
0.0338705219,
-0.0129170865,
0.0028096836,
-0.0139612686,
-0.0423563421,
-0.1023342013,
-0.0103223333,
-0.0059509594,
0.0375058688,
0.0130046913,
0.0277992822,
-0.013338984,
-0.0079576997,
-0.0122016538,
-0.0215508137,
-0.0021188131,
0.0032740459,
-0.0211656187,
0.0264034923,
-0.0121803666,
0.0012093703,
0.0031223295,
0.0008283347,
0.0279682614,
-0.03540482,
-0.0187366214,
-0.0412834026,
0.0272300709,
0.0082080364,
0.015861053,
-0.0200716667,
-0.0442284942,
-0.0298794042,
0.000354186,
0.0412395447,
0.0093626734,
0.0288713239,
-0.0587170757,
0.0116540184,
-0.0143205859,
-0.0562971495,
0.0141409263,
0.0423604324,
-0.0007634451,
-0.0370822884,
-0.0062317909,
-0.0446232669,
0.021721378,
0.015797874,
0.0364112556,
-0.04900885,
-0.0152750425,
0.0045172614,
-0.0367829278,
-0.0039819013,
-0.0315567106,
-0.0573628433,
0.0115446122,
-0.0282895677,
-0.0273492429,
0.0155610526,
-0.0971574336,
-0.0106819291,
-0.0458471812,
-0.0419937,
-0.0361797176,
-0.0044045644,
-0.0089872796,
-0.0176490396,
-0.0135055995,
-0.0361675844,
-0.0225102492,
0.010779365,
0.0449641757,
-0.0308663212,
0.0600061491,
0.0077271466,
0.0221315995,
-0.0332170203,
-0.0259828772,
-0.0154171335,
-0.021910686,
-0.0332549922,
0.0010740095,
-0.004833865,
-0.0248080902,
-0.0179898497,
0.0131519129,
0.0356238037,
0.0779759437,
0.0074155941,
0.0128419986,
-0.0200606864,
0.0557400957,
0.0375151522,
0.0150012635,
-0.0258992873,
-0.031785965,
0.0567162707,
-0.0301427431,
0.0380808301,
-0.0130367847,
-0.0412074551,
-0.0115237292,
0.0330206789,
0.0444815792,
-0.019819621,
0.0251086876,
0.0712592006,
-0.0313568227,
0.0006023122,
0.0591244958,
-0.0252188593,
-0.0923614725,
-0.0355644077,
-0.0139831947,
0.0544544086,
0.0126670795,
-0.0106041981,
-0.043658372,
-0.0538123436,
0.0477581881,
0.0358094834,
0.0029613988,
0.0184158608,
-0.0253804289,
-0.0866925493,
0.000868611,
0.069360584,
-0.0331024863,
-0.0463470593,
-0.0306764562,
-0.0161076374,
-0.0271445047,
0.0435941704,
-0.0165069457,
-0.0459479652,
-0.0257732514,
0.0382198952,
-0.0384071842,
-0.0591311865,
-0.0266007669,
-0.0029427526,
0.0688944981,
0.0305935722,
-0.0087331813,
-0.0217287745,
0.0016019325,
0.0896411315,
-0.0115167219,
0.023709951,
-0.0323129371,
0.0561034195,
-0.0093381461,
-0.0091509102,
0.0085540172,
0.0371708013,
-0.0129603604,
-0.0102179889,
0.0061246236,
0.0710233897,
-0.0334109589,
0.022906106,
-0.0105741257,
-0.0114818104,
-0.0027778244,
0.0472282171,
0.0089232046,
-0.0110186394,
-0.0060728304,
0.0273617562,
0.022546405,
-0.0219059791,
-0.0058344691,
-0.0070366343,
0.0163342636,
-0.0522465259,
-0.0394909866,
-0.0325956717,
-0.0148028638,
0.0313916877,
0.0231425427,
0.0115162311,
-0.0677997172,
0.0253154486,
-0.0302779302,
0.0212923419,
-0.0466805883,
-0.0040604044,
-0.027176233,
0.016354952,
0.0155088268,
-0.0579881594,
-0.0088798683,
0.0044595869,
-0.055758331,
-0.0817252919,
-0.0303419754,
-0.0312843919,
0.0204604454,
0.1129393578,
0.0029551152,
-0.0234250613,
0.1028663144,
0.0119477119,
-0.0816441104,
0.0473774262,
0.0554318689,
-0.0252451673,
-0.0177640952,
0.0147454469,
-0.037770994,
0.0078693256,
0.0286164749,
0.01346297,
0.0169983283,
-0.0879305229,
-0.0011568592,
0.0114495214,
0.0455982201,
-0.013630229,
-0.0000791326,
-0.0515228175,
0.0356365889,
0.0088801319,
0.0514860451,
-0.0275945924,
-0.0006897215,
0.0463147014,
0.0270165522,
-0.0153851202,
0.0485570952,
0.014875452,
0.0326394513,
0.0070073591,
0.0642598942,
0.0188304298,
0.0369801372,
0.0018473098,
0.0097072097,
-0.0218991619,
0.030542627,
0.0268168319,
0.0188291036,
-0.0305366814,
0.0383942984,
-0.0074994662,
-0.0129082249,
-0.0051207286,
0.0032282211,
-0.033872325,
-0.0021328579,
-0.0411535949,
0.0367305242,
0.0502864607,
0.0149132274,
0.0601893589,
-0.0030447189,
0.007754148,
-0.0325302146,
0.00019828,
-0.0567596965,
0.0318522006,
0.0211446658,
-0.0130561283,
0.0033395151,
0.0349644013,
0.0446444303,
0.0432834253,
0.0572569147,
-0.0423375592,
0.0624147542,
-0.0407470167,
0.0225788727,
0.0866548941,
0.0034682036,
-0.031693086,
0.0070962319,
0.0228065662,
-0.0649814904,
0.0403205827,
-0.0439240895,
-0.0064419555,
-0.0141495988,
0.0017223104,
-0.00399487,
-0.0212405194,
-0.0054668905,
0.0270407815,
-0.0178709738,
0.0310755614,
0.0103117991,
0.0218000561,
-7.559492498e-33,
-0.0250390694,
0.0280125365,
0.0140102599,
-0.010010682,
-0.0394706242,
0.0171193704,
0.0006947359,
0.0127189932,
0.0147770196,
-0.0214128178,
-0.0151340719,
-0.0005142285,
0.026307337,
0.0244460031,
0.007523125,
0.0306522846,
0.0816455036,
-0.0134202363,
0.006019556,
-0.0180129167,
0.0142803565,
0.0525562279,
0.0642268434,
-0.019127911,
-0.0372078717,
0.0186036788,
-0.0080312612,
-0.0181299374,
0.0215809401,
0.02356348,
-0.0431495272,
0.0275844857,
0.0059959064,
-0.0422148854,
-0.0259166025,
0.0332323425,
-0.0963803455,
0.0155106569,
-0.0158054568,
0.0054954849,
0.0138588063,
-0.0553848036,
0.042666167,
-0.0163830649,
0.0068050064,
-0.0388288945,
0.023084281,
-0.0233061835,
-0.0152743431,
-0.032249473,
-0.0086360937,
0.061691355,
-0.0122803766,
-0.0127726328,
0.037386585,
0.0145010678,
-0.011352906,
-0.0223296378,
-0.0703393444,
0.0196760334,
-0.0279254206,
0.0359625034,
0.0302462131,
0.0370702259,
-0.0258248337,
0.0349813327,
0.022489341,
-0.0471741371,
0.0034053358,
-0.0356806479,
0.0570355169,
0.0042995093,
0.0215281881,
0.0552597418,
0.0532770976,
-0.0356010459,
-0.0448171124,
0.0227110833,
0.0094583109,
0.0198119413,
0.0088161686,
0.0501539893,
-0.0361745059,
0.033026401,
-0.0637098849,
-0.0339440592,
-0.0477170832,
-0.0117549542,
0.0418270417,
0.0573099591,
-0.0064118714,
-0.0430754572,
0.0543042235,
-0.0198648442,
-0.004026026,
0.0279600434,
0.0151760774,
-0.0002087397,
-0.0429233238,
0.0322040357,
-0.0613566004,
-0.0642071962,
0.0760431513,
0.0391540341,
-0.0122426879,
-0.0345200673,
0.0205323044,
0.0317986496,
-0.09560287,
-0.0209031273,
-0.014417001,
0.0100869536,
0.0157646276,
0.0206961911,
0.0269820057,
-0.0073174438,
0.0120145539,
0.0193509236,
-0.0276421458,
0.0250005312,
-0.0129050426,
-0.026503697,
0.018447686,
0.0292959325,
0.0023051903,
0.0285942648,
0.0127574345,
-0.0728783756,
0.0046797553,
0.0022781612,
0.0006906632,
0.0250831842,
3.176e-7,
-0.0131646767,
-0.008539848,
0.0250132866,
-0.0871940255,
0.0072768792,
0.0228245147,
-0.0333531238,
0.0323069207,
0.0107734445,
-0.0081435312,
0.0135768792,
0.0276179127,
0.0683747232,
-0.0139386952,
-0.0524319112,
-0.0234754067,
-0.041113589,
0.0309821088,
-0.0243335795,
-0.0156694874,
0.0048152027,
0.0937771499,
-0.0223867279,
-0.0287222937,
0.0014348292,
-0.0698386282,
0.0709936544,
-0.0132897506,
-0.0132425483,
-0.0210616235,
0.0199377201,
0.002592454,
-0.0137851844,
0.0175741185,
-0.0352080017,
0.0497266352,
-0.0093657291,
0.02528085,
-0.0579975545,
-0.086196959,
0.0183515865,
0.0890712366,
-0.0444828458,
-0.0104758292,
0.0535095483,
-0.0376909152,
-0.0319137275,
-0.066080533,
-0.06264662,
-0.0061732023,
0.0458312109,
-0.0017556355,
-0.0018353199,
0.0064345519,
0.0322736688,
-0.0031409203,
-0.047303576,
-0.0841875449,
0.0104001947,
0.0161800534,
-0.0925538614,
0.0047677597,
-0.0748730227,
0.0125061814,
0.0387068987,
-0.0019692436,
0.0099354656,
2.801694358e-34,
0.0176362693,
-0.039831385,
-0.0078173243,
0.0087474659,
0.0096990997,
-0.0398470573,
-0.045121409,
0.0246229563,
0.012253928,
-0.0890234038,
-0.0205237474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08582v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08582v2 | Pretraining Language Models with Human Preferences | 2023-02-16T21:03:33 | 2023-06-14T13:27:58 | Tomasz Korbak, Kejian Shi, Angelica Chen, Rasika Bhalerao, Christopher L. Buckley, Jason Phang, Samuel R. Bowman, Ethan Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) are pretrained to imitate internet text, including
content that would violate human preferences if generated by an LM: falsehoods,
offensive comments, personally identifiable information, low-quality or buggy
code, and more. Here, we explore alternative objectives for pretraining LMs in
a way that also guides them to generate text aligned with human preferences. We
benchmark five objectives for pretraining with human feedback across three
tasks and study how they affect the trade-off between alignment and
capabilities of pretrained LMs. We find a Pareto-optimal and simple approach
among those we explored: conditional training, or learning distribution over
tokens conditional on their human preference scores given by a reward model.
Conditional training reduces the rate of undesirable content by up to an order
of magnitude, both when generating without a prompt and with an
adversarially-chosen prompt. Moreover, conditional training maintains the
downstream task performance of standard LM pretraining, both before and after
task-specific finetuning. Pretraining with human feedback results in much
better preference satisfaction than standard LM pretraining followed by
finetuning with feedback, i.e., learning and then unlearning undesirable
behavior. Our results suggest that we should move beyond imitation learning
when pretraining LMs and incorporate human preferences from the start of
training. | [
0.0746775568,
0.0689533874,
-0.0271546878,
0.0182857495,
-0.0232936144,
0.0224904679,
-0.0083251568,
0.0130287288,
0.0071034948,
-0.0536783002,
-0.0280783903,
-0.0131877111,
-0.0318341255,
0.0157035254,
0.0354071446,
-0.0679133609,
0.0327010825,
0.0064303917,
0.03027834,
-0.0233088639,
0.047249686,
0.0222120937,
0.0154564921,
0.0214325096,
-0.0104275839,
0.0123127485,
0.0138049228,
0.0201784559,
0.0058890535,
-0.0215952024,
0.0614984781,
0.0454081148,
0.0105675189,
0.005709514,
0.000002106,
-0.0365713611,
-0.0001100267,
-0.0349215232,
-0.0058449488,
0.0148353754,
0.0802769959,
0.0012979711,
-0.0229697861,
0.028018957,
-0.0567886159,
0.020669518,
0.0500806794,
0.0432782918,
0.0602202564,
0.0824465975,
0.0011105114,
0.028468946,
-0.0191182978,
-0.0168798566,
0.0103602083,
-0.0192856044,
0.0071023582,
-0.0303546693,
-0.000108614,
0.0168842319,
0.0169238225,
-0.0126808221,
0.0275412761,
0.0152824195,
0.0126091428,
0.0312316995,
-0.0077880658,
-0.0236606505,
-0.0120376302,
0.0597272627,
-0.0475444496,
-0.0617462061,
0.0066199428,
-0.0219613891,
0.0125999758,
-0.0095165474,
-0.0089006182,
0.0022686212,
-0.0080835652,
0.0317719057,
-0.000428112,
-0.0199334472,
0.0250887126,
0.0657221153,
0.0025087304,
0.0409801081,
-0.010919001,
-0.0547124483,
0.0089678038,
0.0002331185,
-0.0227362476,
-0.0669364557,
0.0184828695,
0.0036968179,
-0.0381657369,
0.0208828133,
-0.0976427123,
-0.0263134651,
0.0480359159,
-0.0316942893,
0.0510050356,
0.0289722644,
-0.0207056608,
0.0229471009,
-0.0295691751,
0.0487997457,
-0.0161591675,
0.0633938834,
-0.0441238917,
0.0301489532,
0.0120870825,
-0.0153541183,
-0.0345116034,
0.0285543893,
0.0008453038,
0.016436182,
-0.0164098181,
0.0401084684,
-0.0182109009,
0.0268799327,
-0.0125059066,
0.0262020826,
-0.0516910665,
-0.0227208249,
-0.0551292673,
-0.0255481135,
-0.0433951169,
0.0457427278,
0.0206340384,
-0.0455541871,
0.0008418083,
0.012725709,
-0.0304544456,
-0.0370994061,
0.0286913328,
0.0763955936,
0.0008208673,
0.0007313679,
-0.0230434947,
-0.0096694026,
-0.0078666247,
-0.026943488,
-0.0107955281,
-0.0601756908,
0.0004977679,
-0.003684314,
-0.0333579779,
-0.0504108705,
-0.0000074519,
0.0327534825,
-0.0317432396,
0.0682448149,
-0.0097449673,
-0.0157270059,
0.0070260568,
0.005604994,
-0.0093629565,
0.0513708144,
0.0238941386,
0.0860414952,
0.0172287729,
-0.0004004665,
0.0021894067,
0.0302479994,
0.0394923016,
0.0306419674,
-0.0272032674,
0.0055156723,
0.0215450563,
0.0276378524,
0.0612935759,
0.0743900165,
-0.0241116937,
-0.0388212837,
0.0932470411,
0.0252907779,
-0.0182185695,
0.0023371514,
0.044567138,
0.0406435505,
-0.0199098438,
0.0469814427,
-0.0703631639,
0.0234158523,
-0.0338100791,
-0.0005724617,
0.0119313328,
0.0230092108,
-0.0175148528,
-0.0456478111,
0.0012685246,
-0.0410025716,
0.0465263948,
-0.0148388585,
0.0381892473,
0.0423403345,
-0.0549839959,
-0.0207334571,
0.0499528833,
-0.0278615952,
0.0273510851,
-0.0623974204,
0.0525299944,
0.1082236022,
0.0497102961,
-0.0244603939,
0.0109980078,
-0.0276154839,
-0.0003021093,
0.0417775884,
0.0661017448,
-0.0217760745,
-0.0372405872,
-0.0359502137,
-0.0176878422,
-0.0220794249,
0.0067653474,
0.0320513025,
0.0243803114,
-0.0074116779,
0.0168836359,
-0.000753406,
-0.070697397,
0.0663253292,
-0.0028924937,
-0.0105735054,
-0.0079825725,
0.0118138995,
0.0493515059,
-0.0196473245,
-0.0054791849,
0.0036339918,
0.0125193344,
-0.010311815,
-0.0340354405,
0.0046184119,
-0.0576007962,
0.0031562992,
0.0317277238,
-0.0300647449,
0.0022957043,
0.0715694353,
-0.0307263043,
0.0075617102,
0.0072532156,
-0.0161922369,
0.0549090579,
-0.0495495871,
0.0121389134,
-0.0231435671,
-0.0248163566,
-0.0463413708,
0.0278100092,
-0.0095747514,
0.0114529971,
-0.0163352843,
-0.0111978557,
-0.0095155854,
-0.015782835,
-0.0295266733,
-0.0090985717,
-0.0132332426,
0.0607543439,
0.0425110683,
0.0426626727,
-0.0282809567,
-0.0352724306,
-0.0777805746,
-0.027164707,
-0.0240621958,
-0.004888129,
0.038779635,
-0.0127875572,
-0.0144196982,
-0.0261718705,
-0.0525229387,
-0.0377652831,
-0.0068887756,
0.0268652141,
0.0344840847,
-0.0209115222,
0.0150510045,
-0.0585114211,
0.0145918829,
-0.0047364426,
0.007165567,
-0.0015837493,
0.0200842898,
-0.0342941694,
0.0349841751,
-0.0321389176,
0.0309698358,
-0.0195287075,
-0.0712924451,
0.0282403287,
-0.0018173381,
0.0092006195,
0.0966787636,
0.0762898698,
0.0244660843,
0.0420983396,
0.0734068826,
-0.0947267562,
-0.0045570848,
-0.0288360976,
-0.0237453002,
-0.0376740173,
-0.0312334727,
0.0483399928,
0.074869208,
0.0172134265,
0.0190138854,
-0.0715157688,
0.0798362866,
-0.0163546894,
-0.0440412126,
0.0141516794,
-0.0440993905,
-0.0260525346,
0.0279796943,
-0.0389287993,
-0.0853345841,
0.113148056,
-0.0265805237,
0.0220503006,
-0.0480713323,
0.0073813302,
0.0170761272,
0.0079615675,
0.0088212956,
0.0367703401,
0.040319711,
0.0118641378,
-0.0709244534,
0.0053342986,
0.0562082604,
-0.027895147,
-0.0022171701,
-0.02760626,
0.0157403126,
0.0104013486,
-0.0683883876,
-0.0766131505,
-0.0955070704,
-0.0073875804,
-0.0321667902,
0.0296420977,
0.0024893936,
0.0066727558,
-0.0114814732,
0.0069221961,
0.0180949178,
-0.0051531121,
0.0032578327,
-0.0080543272,
-0.0274218041,
0.0718326345,
0.0016729976,
-0.022986155,
-0.0123830223,
-0.0269223899,
0.0336009972,
0.0454809703,
-0.0018005983,
-0.0039093504,
0.00966198,
0.0089332415,
-0.0247690231,
0.0051189894,
0.026136741,
0.0189254228,
-0.0118926279,
-0.0007064654,
0.0901257917,
0.0220439322,
-0.0296167973,
0.015486801,
0.0251024328,
0.0497510433,
0.0240026433,
0.0191482119,
-0.0961017311,
-0.0021485584,
-0.0133127235,
0.0432900935,
-0.0320233144,
-0.0013423159,
-0.0108930478,
-0.1084041521,
-0.0329207405,
0.011498034,
-0.0233623181,
-0.0004349652,
-0.0278629195,
-0.0103243869,
-0.0128668146,
0.0096049234,
-0.0121828746,
0.0138320494,
0.0035632998,
0.0234351903,
0.0134695154,
-0.0394616872,
0.0094776005,
-0.0387954935,
0.0693905205,
0.1093862429,
0.0214355215,
-0.0114460932,
-0.0379291028,
0.0288091283,
0.0066027632,
-0.0114876619,
-0.0214902386,
0.0367494337,
-0.0295970645,
-0.0046370281,
-0.0101638045,
0.0401434153,
0.0190196335,
0.0058852658,
-0.0123871779,
0.0364316665,
0.011468146,
-0.0303234309,
-0.0088492259,
-0.0022470006,
0.0331673734,
0.0522212982,
0.0344137214,
-0.0994609073,
-0.0238757171,
-0.0500630364,
-0.014004509,
-0.0684911087,
-0.03707055,
0.0004022896,
-0.0056371973,
-0.0005848574,
-0.1089248881,
-0.049891118,
-0.0278927349,
0.0206572264,
0.0380878597,
-0.0420765616,
0.0166186448,
-0.0347086005,
-0.018373264,
0.0083424915,
-0.0283895675,
0.0124993874,
-0.0502152629,
-0.0425793231,
0.0088731581,
-0.070396103,
-0.012683372,
-0.0432703905,
-0.027293155,
-0.0737645254,
0.0119734518,
0.0964518785,
0.0202670265,
0.0736621842,
-0.0401408561,
-0.0525334068,
0.0552922152,
0.0666343197,
-0.0656618178,
-0.0043503218,
0.0583467856,
-0.0044375355,
0.0101936636,
0.0266783312,
-0.03765909,
0.0317966677,
0.0394195989,
-0.0129952747,
-0.0009754192,
-0.0338417888,
0.0607936867,
0.0182959605,
0.0198095925,
-0.0266066436,
-0.0193249527,
-0.033162076,
-0.0056231958,
0.0086735124,
-0.0360030681,
-0.0079474598,
-0.0314121209,
0.0246612206,
0.0079866089,
-0.0031027524,
-0.0289463457,
-0.0434892029,
0.052552741,
-0.0324011333,
-0.0127930595,
0.0012969526,
0.0753303096,
0.0420873314,
0.0041241967,
-0.0277669914,
0.0222156197,
-0.005701771,
0.039935153,
-0.0220382642,
0.0393994041,
0.030632047,
-0.007915563,
-0.0112791909,
0.0444367491,
-0.0201692544,
-0.016800398,
-0.0571208373,
-0.0223898403,
0.0139368018,
-0.0295864046,
0.0511260889,
-0.0276164263,
0.0052424422,
-0.0042931223,
0.0236082822,
-0.0227016546,
-0.0430570431,
0.0118238647,
0.0064124321,
-0.0475538857,
0.0086036446,
0.0652958676,
-0.004283125,
0.0377173051,
-0.0128438184,
0.0046250266,
-0.0434796326,
-0.0068251337,
0.0097155245,
0.0236790851,
-0.0259177908,
-0.0112455012,
-0.0374502391,
-0.0604510009,
-0.024710061,
0.0396855734,
0.0161883086,
-0.0129860286,
0.0376917832,
0.0651258379,
-0.0364177004,
0.0487344041,
-0.0433348119,
-0.0071879867,
0.0300587881,
-0.0393141061,
-0.0550331213,
-6.285635719e-33,
-0.0049268263,
-0.0251839887,
-0.0030563131,
0.0229281448,
-0.0089326827,
-0.0290032085,
-0.0149066886,
-0.0028766841,
-0.0302859563,
-0.023732651,
-0.0042224363,
-0.0378517732,
-0.0009581738,
0.0012483817,
-0.0055574225,
-0.0188183673,
0.0375608467,
-0.0365561731,
-0.068978101,
0.0140368463,
0.0120945117,
0.0061841425,
0.0129694175,
-0.0650681779,
0.0358305052,
-0.0064382059,
-0.0346862003,
-0.0027372658,
-0.019924948,
0.0614545681,
-0.0052083251,
0.0245668497,
0.0127030462,
0.0028406961,
-0.0244558603,
0.0325532816,
-0.0482347868,
-0.012037742,
0.0400809422,
0.0046744957,
0.001206444,
-0.0305735152,
0.0577267744,
-0.0345972069,
-0.0418861583,
0.0451339521,
0.0346284136,
-0.0115599129,
-0.0165282842,
0.002755536,
-0.075810343,
-0.0090031121,
-0.0017688243,
-0.0448600464,
0.0004168804,
0.0809616297,
-0.0048313374,
0.0320487618,
-0.0436524265,
0.0551494509,
-0.0059182877,
-0.0045778966,
0.0625630468,
-0.0110076647,
0.0196874291,
0.0877122432,
0.0013841707,
0.0352215357,
-0.022586802,
0.0145304594,
0.0742830262,
-0.001763524,
0.0397828892,
0.0394322202,
0.0326229744,
-0.0673594028,
-0.0105696078,
0.039413821,
0.010020515,
-0.0096966252,
0.0456386618,
0.0331273749,
-0.0365898535,
-0.029574953,
-0.0339702554,
-0.042071376,
-0.0215121098,
-0.0607209727,
0.0234342366,
0.0165156201,
-0.0367463157,
-0.0467540845,
-0.0097751394,
-0.0340078399,
-0.0207434259,
0.0007453666,
-0.0468803272,
-0.0048426446,
-0.0089306524,
-0.0048541962,
-0.081154339,
-0.0099189878,
0.0238353331,
-0.0116784368,
0.0179641265,
0.0300525464,
0.0877927914,
0.0118898768,
-0.0549088493,
0.026381772,
-0.0387842804,
0.0363841541,
0.035059303,
0.0019348743,
0.041338075,
0.0318192206,
-0.0166964978,
0.0124844927,
-0.0054546515,
-0.0744792223,
-0.0930768475,
-0.0026764977,
-0.0080316011,
0.0206340309,
-0.0456538238,
-0.0192618482,
-0.0418770835,
0.040425431,
-0.0046143127,
-0.0699721724,
-0.0198705308,
-0.0025571031,
2.775e-7,
-0.0086081848,
0.0410819426,
0.0309390593,
-0.0049405107,
0.0030625253,
0.0634542927,
0.0101891262,
0.0443135351,
0.022386197,
-0.0115031358,
0.0148840174,
0.0121563738,
0.0343738794,
0.0343195125,
-0.0761627331,
0.0005231912,
-0.0814923793,
0.0190123934,
-0.0406859852,
-0.0224969815,
0.0490452908,
0.0755549073,
0.0455613583,
-0.0044791889,
0.0195039939,
-0.0081709735,
0.0441312082,
-0.0472593419,
-0.0106044766,
-0.0149391936,
-0.0045609707,
0.0168067589,
-0.0034594552,
0.0066171801,
-0.0109436996,
-0.015070417,
-0.0151094263,
0.0486959703,
0.0078903744,
-0.0411353298,
-0.0084272539,
-0.0061670062,
0.0076689064,
-0.0570199527,
0.0539178774,
-0.0238353405,
0.0231627077,
-0.0361451693,
-0.0000834773,
-0.0198055152,
0.0013050056,
-0.0522311702,
-0.0283630248,
0.0112643801,
0.012907641,
0.0421197675,
-0.0021651932,
-0.0404840186,
-0.023759082,
0.01877,
-0.032047268,
-0.0488422886,
-0.035431806,
0.0500113405,
0.0270919073,
-0.0248323958,
0.0476465225,
2.447078248e-34,
0.0207365099,
-0.0294286292,
0.0310951229,
-0.0036884656,
0.0293485522,
0.0434254594,
0.0317037553,
0.022893155,
0.0420782454,
-0.0241277181,
-0.0245590806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08577v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08577v3 | For Generated Text, Is NLI-Neutral Text the Best Text? | 2023-02-16T20:46:36 | 2024-01-20T02:36:12 | Michail Mersinias, Kyle Mahowald | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore incorporating natural language inference (NLI) into the text
generative pipeline by using a pre-trained NLI model to assess whether a
generated sentence entails, contradicts, or is neutral to the prompt and
preceding text. First, we show that the NLI task is predictive of generation
errors made by GPT-3. We use these results to develop an NLI-informed
generation procedure for GPT-J. Then, we evaluate these generations by
obtaining human annotations on error types and overall quality. We find that an
NLI strategy of maximizing entailment improves text generation when the nucleus
sampling randomness parameter value is high, while one which maximizes
contradiction is in fact productive when the parameter value is low. Overall,
though, we demonstrate that an NLI strategy of maximizing the neutral class
provides the highest quality of generated text (significantly better than the
vanilla generations), regardless of parameter value. | [
0.0348677039,
0.0638145506,
-0.0002969021,
-0.0022194018,
-0.0440428443,
0.0244534574,
0.0070837229,
0.0069412482,
0.030106809,
-0.0240323339,
0.0265287738,
-0.0070810635,
-0.0050692628,
0.0244108345,
0.0445928685,
-0.0289778952,
0.0414153822,
0.0193988755,
0.0277881417,
0.0212467667,
0.0103260102,
0.0538008697,
-0.0107442345,
0.0139681688,
-0.0459533073,
0.0209560767,
0.0033967872,
0.0175418574,
0.0240239017,
-0.0351535454,
0.0081324931,
0.0701600313,
0.000201998,
0.0379354134,
0.0000019357,
-0.029090438,
0.0068299803,
-0.0047620917,
-0.0011885531,
-0.0185534805,
0.0614045411,
-0.0030427126,
-0.0207529496,
0.0279277451,
-0.0391119458,
0.0335159861,
0.0479983017,
0.0860551,
0.0471454673,
0.0683000386,
-0.0211856347,
-0.0013160213,
0.012349301,
-0.0298681464,
0.0275766719,
0.013690873,
-0.0022459954,
-0.0066784723,
-0.0256357212,
0.0057500815,
0.0336164199,
0.0151517987,
0.0540517978,
-0.0066630812,
-0.0169428624,
0.0576903932,
-0.0201035123,
-0.0285222679,
0.0117081981,
0.0335244685,
-0.0143644409,
-0.0346110836,
-0.0009387015,
-0.0377845727,
0.0036502818,
-0.0263162106,
0.0089279152,
0.0614813566,
-0.0527884476,
0.0381551199,
0.0636258796,
0.0111715598,
0.0100388126,
-0.0129407607,
0.0151020745,
0.0368568785,
0.0405687615,
-0.0329956114,
0.0289370585,
0.043923974,
-0.0386162959,
-0.0632820427,
0.002381339,
-0.009892595,
-0.0012382451,
0.0072342041,
-0.0745978653,
-0.0298634693,
0.0434653126,
-0.0350178555,
-0.0104181916,
0.0083514452,
0.008759602,
0.0154027278,
-0.0276365895,
-0.0201724637,
-0.000067963,
-0.0126653761,
-0.0212742854,
-0.0006907634,
-0.0012811315,
-0.0200566407,
-0.0349677205,
0.0258623995,
-0.0504042991,
-0.016971413,
-0.0228737835,
0.0101349549,
0.0057741068,
-0.0101148635,
0.0056994772,
0.0129499296,
-0.0570292287,
-0.0089804223,
-0.0469551533,
0.0058449833,
-0.0544411428,
0.0254439674,
0.0060646292,
-0.0661058277,
-0.0139718344,
0.0349258818,
0.0161691774,
-0.0165391974,
0.0016243584,
0.0762076005,
-0.0375915989,
-0.0063210735,
-0.0815554634,
-0.0293704513,
-0.0079282532,
-0.0670788363,
-0.0042028273,
-0.0555583909,
0.0167445764,
-0.0048527336,
-0.0295800567,
-0.0245050397,
0.0167151447,
0.0338608101,
-0.0022659709,
0.0055688238,
-0.0360230394,
-0.0291320682,
0.0313037075,
0.0060698027,
0.0405164883,
0.0503057092,
0.0240920112,
0.0237805024,
0.0047096373,
0.0329124369,
0.001973598,
-0.0034522717,
0.0339211263,
0.001260084,
0.0176411103,
-0.0205614679,
-0.0209407862,
0.0076313997,
0.025873594,
0.0538006201,
-0.0310748946,
-0.0204269476,
0.042025663,
-0.0033673849,
-0.0206672736,
0.0135553097,
0.0816608444,
0.036040388,
-0.0315728523,
0.0510598868,
-0.0281953868,
0.0674473792,
-0.0696703419,
0.0106822448,
0.0328465886,
0.0383398198,
-0.0260713734,
-0.0618130155,
-0.0065883673,
-0.0244461,
-0.0052481578,
-0.0683592707,
0.0249336865,
0.0412193127,
-0.0832507089,
-0.0126561895,
0.0258052573,
-0.1075330228,
0.010765465,
-0.0178291649,
0.0655541569,
0.0489193872,
0.0357979573,
0.012189379,
-0.0407182314,
-0.0123048685,
-0.0301946104,
0.1026909724,
0.0291043576,
0.0071388441,
0.0049069221,
-0.0288045909,
-0.010295013,
-0.0166854039,
0.0208628885,
0.0421045013,
0.0337485597,
0.0357693844,
0.052761279,
-0.0127283167,
-0.0397731252,
0.0491039939,
-0.0373493098,
-0.0431164876,
0.0203111134,
0.0218980219,
0.0168088507,
-0.0050566355,
-0.038061928,
0.0084599024,
-0.0055141537,
-0.0205904953,
-0.0660771653,
0.0074913069,
-0.0486065075,
-0.0763332844,
-0.03056941,
-0.0748065114,
-0.0248066708,
0.0033019637,
-0.0485676676,
-0.0350003392,
0.0109610008,
-0.0564523302,
-0.0040477044,
-0.083091408,
-0.0365986228,
0.0324879363,
-0.0080488734,
-0.0217813011,
0.0762835741,
0.011280112,
-0.0145656383,
0.0204330459,
0.0138345463,
0.057013832,
-0.0318160467,
0.0073973201,
-0.0073487367,
-0.0066103889,
-0.0135719161,
0.0735278949,
0.0524173193,
-0.0265520625,
-0.0391060561,
-0.0631241649,
0.0198949538,
-0.0216083582,
0.0101452814,
0.0467539467,
-0.0082486095,
-0.0135167595,
-0.0031195215,
-0.0409015268,
-0.009206499,
0.0556296147,
-0.0087284362,
0.0650546923,
-0.0225787833,
0.0309114121,
-0.0275032055,
0.0246611778,
-0.028091386,
0.0196735356,
0.0554716326,
0.0119980201,
-0.0319953673,
0.0597608127,
-0.0624596886,
0.0006231053,
0.0251215957,
-0.0325535722,
0.0403004363,
-0.0166738648,
0.0854970664,
0.0330983289,
0.0348335952,
0.0176883023,
0.0122073991,
0.0019199275,
-0.0036276239,
0.0185408853,
-0.0389832407,
0.0202210732,
0.0181486178,
-0.0705296695,
0.0370996259,
0.0644433722,
0.0406684577,
-0.0098774387,
-0.091345489,
0.0593991019,
-0.0200111102,
-0.0010320464,
0.0257250983,
0.0052801254,
0.0037877355,
0.0310357437,
-0.0245972071,
-0.0499621108,
0.0869982019,
-0.0184081383,
0.007623815,
-0.0772584677,
0.0057472531,
-0.0179150384,
0.0447907485,
0.0248496532,
0.0098625757,
0.0446423739,
0.0204218552,
-0.0393217988,
0.0180643536,
0.0449872389,
0.0143674249,
-0.0009532308,
-0.0611201487,
-0.0167108644,
-0.0329831615,
-0.0380319282,
-0.0483494774,
-0.0313543305,
0.0203835685,
-0.0198870599,
0.0304345526,
-0.0160260387,
0.0278983079,
-0.0288598947,
-0.0086504817,
0.0432831645,
-0.0388316438,
-0.0183040667,
-0.0314098224,
0.0394969545,
0.0550185964,
-0.0198300481,
0.0212000515,
-0.0103656054,
-0.0236122422,
0.0382629633,
-0.0395438559,
0.0473936312,
-0.0206531212,
-0.0112029528,
-0.0082538258,
-0.0101267919,
-0.0297752116,
0.0255411305,
0.0358146131,
-0.024526244,
-0.0358060189,
0.0921083838,
0.0285904035,
0.0167940278,
-0.0184008498,
0.0028705825,
0.0753185153,
-0.0083153276,
0.0135314027,
-0.078566052,
-0.0227150079,
-0.0216426849,
0.0161182769,
-0.041967582,
-0.0068210028,
-0.0325921178,
-0.1365079135,
0.0580419712,
0.0121530378,
-0.0591154099,
-0.0292125456,
-0.0313782357,
-0.0254863165,
0.021359412,
-0.0119369859,
0.0099684596,
0.0161810424,
0.050612729,
0.0129458457,
-0.0064925989,
-0.0489009209,
-0.0380016491,
-0.0192507692,
0.0297296681,
0.0549460389,
0.0376077965,
0.0018781407,
-0.0293633174,
0.0087992623,
-0.0289289039,
-0.0084081283,
-0.0211568736,
0.0669706687,
0.00531762,
0.0142295742,
-0.0788094848,
0.0381061621,
-0.0179926511,
-0.0155648757,
0.0075145783,
0.0545577705,
-0.0228561219,
-0.0544943325,
-0.0225434098,
0.0438400581,
0.0411853567,
0.0762701705,
0.0374354757,
-0.0209198464,
-0.0476675332,
-0.0298640877,
0.043833442,
-0.0904935971,
0.0128301494,
-0.0107598491,
0.0216689371,
-0.0237077083,
-0.1006547436,
-0.0637421459,
0.0034421377,
0.0551137179,
0.0064195902,
-0.0404558964,
-0.0305739101,
-0.0429590866,
0.0005600824,
-0.0205013566,
-0.0045564617,
-0.0176149439,
0.003688348,
-0.0295125525,
0.0299206562,
-0.0150916455,
-0.0064258608,
0.0440133847,
-0.0734528229,
-0.0571484342,
-0.0375970937,
0.0672961697,
0.0208938457,
0.0247489586,
-0.009059052,
0.0062261242,
0.0009362861,
0.089842014,
0.0025671935,
0.0132752471,
0.0166306961,
0.0204607248,
0.0105725024,
0.0185322501,
-0.0242214743,
0.0208671503,
0.0137021076,
0.0246899147,
0.0043475498,
-0.0583028533,
0.0244806241,
0.0125962235,
0.0107245417,
-0.0327568799,
0.0257283021,
-0.0597322918,
-0.010441727,
-0.0432871804,
-0.0048405742,
-0.0281747151,
0.0166501421,
0.0149713336,
0.0327632986,
-0.0301176943,
0.0524438992,
-0.0474618189,
0.0688834563,
-0.0171272606,
-0.0460308455,
0.0328732543,
0.0571368821,
-0.0195301436,
-0.0418285504,
-0.0525608435,
0.0047868057,
-0.0271905549,
0.0383997299,
-0.0214061756,
0.0536597408,
0.0422621816,
-0.0168727078,
0.0298279263,
-0.0006205612,
-0.0413446464,
0.0162109248,
-0.0478129722,
0.0205859374,
0.0459201112,
-0.0020893654,
0.0728289336,
-0.0651589036,
0.0144807734,
0.0209796671,
0.0674506575,
0.021978179,
-0.054751642,
-0.0029569436,
-0.0157147571,
-0.0236498676,
-0.0350431614,
0.0523350239,
0.0162281357,
0.0247071572,
0.0037026191,
0.0186582487,
-0.0386275277,
-0.0414466262,
-0.0069491714,
0.0051435167,
0.0115027251,
0.0351628587,
-0.0403246097,
-0.0374570899,
0.0000081759,
0.0576839894,
0.0353054293,
-0.0015543543,
0.0467609055,
0.0407623723,
-0.0311869085,
-0.0473938584,
-0.0037584659,
0.0480654538,
-0.0447445251,
0.0070196008,
-0.0582141727,
-6.290926178e-33,
-0.0617359094,
-0.0637352094,
0.0012351347,
0.0011023848,
-0.0064555896,
-0.0484383442,
-0.0553274825,
-0.009865622,
0.0242224578,
0.0229579881,
0.0254487004,
0.0097593656,
0.0014269396,
0.038238667,
-0.017849708,
-0.0043659452,
0.0459242389,
0.0114160078,
-0.0526066348,
0.0345206335,
0.045949813,
-0.0033943104,
0.0524186827,
-0.053344816,
0.0076069324,
-0.037485607,
-0.0232568718,
-0.0218064133,
-0.0343225077,
-0.0000405068,
-0.0179294478,
0.0275321677,
0.0168408696,
-0.0380166769,
0.0100456523,
0.0023156141,
-0.0201034527,
-0.0846194699,
0.0032814469,
-0.0226528272,
-0.0668724179,
-0.0287905782,
0.0113731995,
-0.024248099,
-0.0234276615,
0.0236715116,
0.0499371327,
0.0169685297,
0.0380746685,
-0.0569909215,
-0.1053922847,
0.0154340193,
0.0088897776,
-0.0042134151,
-0.068756856,
0.0300811119,
0.006486393,
-0.0244906805,
-0.0076690977,
0.0058760825,
0.0333949998,
0.0052087102,
0.0050026802,
-0.0255782772,
-0.0175386351,
0.047941003,
0.0061074891,
0.0168645252,
-0.0817945302,
-0.0016727338,
-0.0113797514,
0.0087428037,
0.0568804033,
0.0757979527,
0.0281316098,
-0.0098264376,
-0.0765156671,
0.062590234,
-0.0058900937,
-0.0120043345,
0.0175503865,
-0.0505723208,
0.0043011429,
-0.01326406,
-0.0233951248,
-0.0810885653,
-0.0047570183,
-0.0268739462,
0.0339215957,
0.0256741773,
-0.016981693,
-0.0225023776,
-0.0000128998,
0.0294799414,
0.0121313557,
0.0437362194,
-0.0667124242,
-0.0231272485,
-0.008949264,
0.0289421994,
-0.0525814518,
-0.0137702143,
0.0520911738,
0.0322526284,
0.0132821342,
0.0043416051,
0.0389692821,
0.0102654155,
-0.0662645698,
0.0230670925,
-0.0475203134,
0.0644885823,
-0.0010473863,
-0.0313359573,
0.0214331262,
-0.00957077,
-0.0041984841,
0.0292086322,
0.0183084831,
0.0167100821,
-0.0688799173,
0.0373791382,
0.0012669893,
0.0099264635,
-0.0229970794,
0.0214092918,
-0.0135738663,
0.0215410069,
-0.0175543074,
-0.0649836436,
-0.0173404869,
0.0151306111,
2.557e-7,
0.0135909244,
0.0158961024,
0.0682653859,
0.0246197861,
0.0068558725,
0.0287051518,
0.0086449794,
0.0227442235,
-0.0036718168,
0.0307531822,
-0.0003102115,
0.0008460624,
0.0315919071,
0.0474307835,
-0.0671342835,
0.0568420067,
-0.0505954884,
-0.0017526549,
-0.0599984862,
0.0009663579,
0.1120149791,
0.0534036718,
0.011390049,
-0.0123109967,
0.0169086643,
-0.0253916848,
0.0872032046,
0.0197937973,
-0.0047555682,
0.0049735135,
0.0572954863,
-0.0009182765,
-0.0040072524,
0.0217022561,
-0.0144525226,
-0.0304601323,
-0.0269331373,
0.0586345121,
0.0035145308,
-0.019430805,
0.0264775585,
-0.0037292752,
0.0022173177,
-0.0375049673,
0.0672941282,
-0.0307647996,
-0.0089629181,
-0.0130924722,
-0.0134237381,
-0.0061098048,
0.0023248079,
-0.0357308052,
-0.0483179204,
-0.0150018148,
0.0045487839,
0.0165984817,
-0.009486068,
-0.0208099782,
-0.0092317564,
0.0014956146,
-0.0432904512,
-0.0370090157,
-0.0540536456,
0.0412099399,
0.0528299026,
-0.0029413919,
0.0064461157,
2.357061783e-34,
0.0287073795,
-0.0217765663,
0.0161497388,
-0.0417199358,
0.0411629751,
0.0351423174,
-0.0062445197,
0.0126750255,
0.0136069311,
-0.0074766553,
-0.0171271786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08575v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08575v1 | Foundation Models for Natural Language Processing -- Pre-trained Language Models Integrating Media | 2023-02-16T20:42:04 | 2023-02-16T20:42:04 | Gerhard Paaß, Sven Giesselbach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM, 68W20, 68W25, I.2.6; I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.10; I.4.8; I.4.10; I.5.2; I.5.4; I.7.0;
J.1; J.3; K.4.1; K.4.2; K.5.0 | This open access book provides a comprehensive overview of the state of the
art in research and applications of Foundation Models and is intended for
readers familiar with basic Natural Language Processing (NLP) concepts. Over
the recent years, a revolutionary new paradigm has been developed for training
models for NLP. These models are first pre-trained on large collections of text
documents to acquire general syntactic knowledge and semantic information.
Then, they are fine-tuned for specific tasks, which they can often solve with
superhuman accuracy. When the models are large enough, they can be instructed
by prompts to solve new tasks without any fine-tuning. Moreover, they can be
applied to a wide range of different media and problem domains, ranging from
image and video processing to robot control learning. Because they provide a
blueprint for solving many tasks in artificial intelligence, they have been
called Foundation Models. After a brief introduction to basic NLP models the
main pre-trained language models BERT, GPT and sequence-to-sequence transformer
are described, as well as the concepts of self-attention and context-sensitive
embedding. Then, different approaches to improving these models are discussed,
such as expanding the pre-training criteria, increasing the length of input
texts, or including extra knowledge. An overview of the best-performing models
for about twenty application areas is then presented, e.g., question answering,
translation, story generation, dialog systems, generating images from text,
etc. For each application area, the strengths and weaknesses of current models
are discussed, and an outlook on further developments is given. In addition,
links are provided to freely available program code. A concluding chapter
summarizes the economic opportunities, mitigation of risks, and potential
developments of AI. | [
0.0744833872,
0.0144886607,
-0.002915116,
0.0186115168,
-0.0466356725,
0.0093368692,
-0.0006516401,
-0.0079383655,
0.0201867074,
-0.1060108766,
0.0118236775,
-0.0177946351,
-0.0445019081,
0.0525686927,
0.0133651569,
-0.0866777599,
0.0548417196,
0.0115342243,
0.0186749268,
0.020734068,
0.0236858055,
0.0201293062,
0.0042461953,
0.0296865478,
-0.0477404334,
-0.0114357602,
-0.0245339759,
-0.0033601443,
-0.0125014912,
-0.0179447941,
-0.0048917327,
0.0743092969,
0.0756501704,
-0.0031209968,
0.00000218,
-0.055600509,
-0.0244563073,
-0.0239224229,
-0.0020638758,
-0.0183559526,
0.0281404834,
-0.007808527,
0.0042776186,
0.0301446933,
-0.0620549172,
-0.0057772594,
0.0568118878,
0.0721405372,
0.0767265111,
0.0855183676,
-0.0234051477,
-0.056967061,
0.0428878479,
0.0051030982,
0.0022966955,
-0.042395927,
0.0266580954,
0.0137216393,
0.0251471829,
0.0104464162,
-0.0232285578,
0.0308636036,
0.0170424599,
0.0207938608,
0.0138972923,
0.0380783975,
-0.0475477837,
-0.0577669032,
-0.0633079037,
0.0688197017,
-0.0366824567,
-0.0541614182,
-0.0039001496,
0.0121499468,
-0.0072444719,
0.0108285742,
-0.0444831364,
0.0335001871,
0.0060459431,
0.011617627,
0.0103326449,
0.0010349372,
-0.02779603,
0.0339291207,
-0.0254333373,
0.045510266,
0.0213979743,
-0.0503354371,
-0.0111137023,
0.0075117396,
-0.0203723665,
-0.0825396329,
0.0420529321,
0.0553514473,
0.0427141041,
0.0228455681,
-0.0637323037,
-0.0229346883,
0.0059338119,
-0.0613054559,
-0.0063440311,
0.0333838984,
-0.0237879325,
0.0807665735,
-0.026627982,
0.0678875744,
-0.0196152031,
0.0202231724,
-0.0288534593,
0.0270444658,
-0.0530360341,
-0.0161919203,
-0.0886651576,
0.065417856,
-0.0314255618,
-0.0804436281,
-0.0064619537,
0.0311189089,
0.0265612379,
-0.0100103766,
0.0035658986,
0.0247648042,
-0.0317637101,
-0.0190805048,
-0.0378567986,
-0.0021110626,
-0.0281002987,
0.017209582,
-0.0113190813,
-0.0443315692,
0.0004293036,
0.0124336639,
0.0357246622,
0.0059038401,
0.0363768898,
0.0550706722,
0.0009722901,
-0.0651448518,
-0.0424461737,
0.0013808565,
0.0103294486,
-0.059016183,
-0.01031473,
-0.042148672,
0.0160302129,
0.0034629628,
0.0024579822,
-0.0118827103,
0.0131285191,
0.0353879407,
-0.0176978279,
0.0980426818,
0.0113275982,
0.0263185464,
0.0684408695,
0.0077581042,
0.0265752338,
0.0489826165,
0.022623919,
0.0390413776,
0.0497420728,
-0.0119643128,
0.0229166839,
0.0336396582,
0.0001553114,
-0.0120848548,
0.0107855145,
0.0239857081,
-0.0283618234,
-0.0040625818,
-0.0227106027,
0.0444131531,
-0.0271181073,
0.0046421899,
0.0736058727,
0.0838182122,
0.0011521515,
0.039213419,
0.0693627596,
0.017979525,
0.0159613695,
0.0054213703,
-0.0354611501,
0.0123046404,
-0.0267481077,
0.0157092325,
-0.0109078148,
0.0336968675,
-0.0541103259,
-0.034673892,
-0.0042890757,
-0.0201823208,
0.0303359088,
0.0027293642,
0.0464442857,
0.0239383411,
-0.0929530263,
0.0070656803,
-0.0102931047,
-0.0421835519,
0.0090655647,
-0.0197014306,
0.0124598052,
0.0453576781,
0.0402334109,
-0.0525506735,
-0.0221421141,
-0.0206747558,
0.0138501329,
0.0183710307,
0.0288702156,
0.0134452162,
-0.0224374048,
-0.0311924908,
-0.0001244886,
0.0007246268,
-0.0062012188,
0.0497789085,
-0.0043813093,
0.0232137814,
0.0191555135,
0.0097876983,
-0.0090664309,
0.0569133759,
-0.0057969783,
-0.0484301895,
-0.0520898588,
0.0233669803,
0.0546926819,
0.035627488,
-0.018400345,
0.0062290742,
0.0551602691,
-0.0031238603,
-0.021901112,
0.0120285256,
-0.0528278165,
-0.0442918651,
0.0175176635,
-0.0401080623,
0.0205284785,
0.0368948914,
-0.0282949153,
-0.0507349931,
-0.0018305593,
-0.0355231911,
0.0432139039,
-0.075172089,
0.0504106954,
0.0197876226,
-0.0214617774,
-0.0329789445,
0.0674358383,
0.0088234227,
-0.0139586534,
-0.0025180662,
0.0253037065,
0.0238705352,
-0.0758724809,
-0.0274114069,
-0.0052111843,
-0.0109221442,
0.0167994406,
0.054681927,
0.0095637431,
-0.0540294647,
-0.0135024562,
-0.0972186252,
0.0198627058,
-0.0074878642,
0.005793218,
0.019307198,
-0.0031258664,
-0.0168891326,
-0.0270500071,
-0.026463015,
-0.0014014759,
0.0387052484,
-0.0031442188,
0.0160070769,
0.0226996671,
-0.0164572001,
-0.0545010902,
-0.014762206,
-0.0125108808,
0.0279427785,
0.0252498686,
-0.0403178893,
-0.0257980749,
0.0323172361,
-0.0115590626,
0.0684123561,
0.0042899773,
-0.0626554638,
-0.0089948969,
-0.0400846303,
0.0179931819,
0.0878797174,
0.0326363109,
0.0389524139,
-0.0092770196,
-0.0066933436,
-0.0238902252,
0.0287891775,
-0.0552843139,
0.0096793501,
0.0059409328,
-0.0080352398,
0.0439842567,
0.0649399385,
0.0048881997,
0.0045054294,
-0.0701022297,
0.011018347,
0.0027792549,
-0.0155962622,
-0.0020824508,
-0.0407967009,
-0.0193853565,
0.0413279757,
-0.0369085222,
-0.0496723726,
0.0607838556,
-0.045466356,
-0.0051565133,
-0.0532851368,
-0.0032873503,
-0.0284135267,
0.0425362065,
0.0457316525,
0.0519808978,
0.0226650555,
-0.0275136326,
-0.0384565704,
-0.0082155894,
0.0255771969,
-0.0252328701,
-0.0012866515,
-0.0086473553,
0.0259357933,
0.0066627907,
-0.0236983877,
-0.0477921404,
-0.0466293134,
-0.0149619523,
-0.0110031972,
-0.0138464496,
0.0202512909,
-0.0418174192,
0.0621734522,
0.0054170252,
0.0506674796,
0.006868259,
0.0055014631,
-0.0352118127,
0.0562980548,
0.0321407802,
-0.0353266709,
-0.0300941933,
0.000225527,
0.0307272188,
0.027718721,
0.0356126018,
-0.0197865684,
-0.0441891663,
0.0297555104,
0.001102715,
-0.0627139956,
-0.0284299012,
0.0331595205,
0.0178383682,
-0.0643820316,
-0.0120781483,
0.1286183894,
0.0487514958,
0.003317876,
-0.0293111671,
0.0417046808,
-0.0510458536,
0.0294076968,
0.0282709207,
-0.0539888181,
-0.0250515323,
-0.0198817831,
-0.0209309421,
0.0106788818,
-0.0038926974,
-0.0031853474,
-0.0972180367,
0.0378266983,
0.0078716977,
-0.0205009542,
-0.0434570275,
-0.0290394872,
-0.0349419191,
0.0116069559,
-0.04431656,
-0.0109119946,
-0.0187463053,
0.0058217989,
0.0043935045,
-0.0086873807,
-0.0452119559,
0.0116762901,
-0.0470761433,
0.0287961662,
0.0897070915,
0.035090141,
-0.0194912143,
-0.0008839068,
0.0076469947,
-0.0176093839,
0.0164135788,
-0.0056298175,
0.0467917658,
-0.0612348989,
0.0028219349,
-0.0145446584,
0.0149636064,
-0.0023372695,
-0.0247325357,
-0.0169493761,
0.0635719374,
-0.0055114091,
-0.0010167239,
-0.0471571311,
0.02885863,
0.0037839063,
0.0734026209,
0.0198207777,
-0.0408198535,
-0.0518770888,
0.0011535808,
0.0278144479,
-0.0398485325,
-0.0254313368,
0.003969945,
-0.0191417281,
-0.0236526374,
-0.0834595039,
-0.0378826931,
0.0419577733,
0.0387050435,
0.0299125463,
-0.009622491,
0.0537968352,
0.021368891,
-0.0361433439,
0.0318185054,
0.0108619621,
-0.023344025,
-0.0887211263,
-0.0116236582,
0.0389923342,
-0.0507181399,
-0.0230711512,
0.0010595348,
-0.0269299913,
-0.0405407548,
-0.0122939581,
0.0921145901,
0.0237690639,
0.013176593,
-0.0193009619,
-0.0316124856,
0.0152664054,
-0.0084003098,
-0.0570251532,
0.0006541361,
0.0056738486,
-0.0180476978,
-0.0145933647,
-0.0027234729,
-0.0108166998,
0.0645624325,
-0.0047465656,
0.0161167774,
-0.0446175747,
-0.0521574505,
0.0524461791,
-0.0057402481,
0.0502183475,
-0.0008789873,
0.0040187743,
-0.0364345834,
0.0035533619,
-0.0127218571,
-0.0144069185,
-0.0506275557,
0.0072620953,
0.0141338939,
0.0218351781,
-0.0004986129,
-0.0033282938,
-0.0678387582,
0.0056252554,
-0.0181461126,
0.0156149501,
0.0318115652,
0.017862292,
-0.0178306345,
-0.0174222905,
-0.0120935021,
-0.0046047606,
-0.0376122333,
0.0319258571,
-0.003752511,
0.0790154785,
-0.0003970522,
0.0062093483,
-0.000508084,
0.0518595688,
-0.0558973514,
-0.0270447936,
-0.0488575101,
0.0434825309,
0.0697573051,
-0.0356842317,
-0.0052304966,
-0.0241026301,
-0.0208035465,
-0.0122102946,
0.0119853755,
0.0198906381,
-0.0459274501,
0.025332652,
0.0229413193,
0.0056174323,
0.0169905499,
0.0546288379,
0.0224404298,
0.0428514965,
0.0300575774,
-0.0352759734,
-0.0518862903,
0.0049451492,
0.0326004997,
0.0157854073,
-0.0177660231,
0.0628299564,
-0.0441855788,
-0.054364685,
0.0090359673,
0.0016081455,
0.0014518426,
0.0036582984,
0.0723172948,
0.0520028621,
-0.0018960229,
-0.0101134432,
-0.0244873948,
0.0260323584,
-0.0596608222,
-0.0271102693,
-0.0030610976,
-6.39609178e-33,
-0.0434942134,
-0.0376163684,
0.017893739,
0.0064287954,
-0.0065106121,
0.0042985533,
-0.0046696286,
-0.0141806928,
-0.0019242896,
-0.0071310024,
-0.0302584209,
-0.0040380722,
-0.0017463234,
0.0256464705,
-0.051603388,
-0.0003402591,
0.0351343714,
-0.0289664157,
-0.0169060081,
-0.0201940816,
0.0042448854,
0.0485562086,
0.0467265435,
-0.0653333887,
-0.0605253428,
-0.0307269134,
-0.0237699803,
0.0025269084,
0.0362112261,
0.0687113032,
-0.0053945556,
-0.0189576503,
0.0275271349,
-0.0536515787,
-0.0039273328,
0.0799355805,
-0.0795991868,
-0.0206912793,
0.0215448644,
0.0220539905,
-0.0219728798,
-0.0139558697,
0.0157861449,
-0.0589883588,
0.003989289,
0.0163939204,
0.042742867,
-0.0133823864,
0.0190472472,
-0.0082812626,
-0.0806896016,
-0.005071044,
-0.0282648057,
-0.0519360118,
0.0404616706,
0.0270761214,
-0.0116761383,
0.0267455187,
-0.0306863822,
0.0177164916,
0.0381741747,
0.0282055605,
0.0564214997,
-0.0064205481,
0.0086008031,
0.0164259579,
-0.023900792,
-0.0362526476,
-0.0176790711,
-0.0270802453,
-0.0024616346,
0.075567916,
0.0489253812,
0.0179020464,
0.014825887,
0.0187428128,
-0.0507709496,
0.0320755802,
-0.0081959357,
0.0616939031,
0.0174629744,
-0.0069651892,
-0.0334399045,
0.0246037003,
-0.0473303683,
-0.0126706427,
-0.0172491539,
-0.0473243184,
0.0594364069,
0.0340853147,
-0.0024525465,
0.0147712426,
0.0593635701,
-0.045703277,
0.0205656309,
0.0107095186,
-0.0144351749,
0.0313287377,
-0.0250282679,
0.0630418286,
-0.077384904,
-0.0259743296,
0.0522543564,
0.0055186059,
-0.0156320054,
0.0070338761,
-0.0047924374,
0.0272611827,
-0.0344095044,
0.0011523918,
0.0062299147,
0.0118861711,
0.0081183966,
0.0424861759,
0.0225957613,
0.0310867038,
-0.0262198783,
0.0584858209,
0.0011881171,
-0.0383776464,
-0.0409313142,
-0.0618229918,
0.0060639689,
0.0449076034,
-0.0388865843,
0.0112484274,
-0.0526878424,
0.0343230553,
-0.0005274141,
-0.0492112227,
-0.0244051591,
0.0416970029,
2.891e-7,
0.0400234647,
0.047888238,
0.0394216739,
0.0162328295,
-0.0003724815,
0.0295176804,
0.0014218687,
0.0437215902,
0.0130413277,
-0.0234524254,
0.0228178035,
0.0495648943,
-0.0041099656,
-0.0307355523,
-0.0630839318,
-0.0241122637,
-0.0344405547,
0.0022677241,
-0.0771452039,
-0.0068125566,
0.0678146183,
0.102292195,
0.0052075777,
0.0020496948,
-0.0185806919,
-0.0494111031,
0.0663617328,
-0.0048445994,
-0.0057599838,
0.0037004312,
0.0105347335,
0.044099696,
-0.0444790088,
0.0259593669,
-0.024186505,
0.0303743854,
0.0434495993,
0.0541069545,
-0.0410669111,
-0.0186777227,
-0.0014259886,
0.0054183328,
-0.0198661257,
-0.0780048966,
0.0848378316,
-0.0528852828,
-0.0175132174,
0.0086739296,
-0.0586262755,
-0.0222061872,
-0.0058829361,
-0.0119368853,
-0.0219655409,
0.0104327993,
0.0367275961,
-0.0073496057,
-0.0019412661,
-0.1145384163,
0.0273985434,
0.0064140237,
-0.0110868448,
0.0068647615,
-0.044800356,
-0.0166015793,
0.0579549707,
-0.0419583283,
-0.0129439784,
2.894036097e-34,
0.0082233734,
-0.0038769182,
0.0214116573,
0.015622071,
0.0148337046,
0.0160091817,
-0.0315161571,
0.0019901199,
0.0149615509,
-0.0872863531,
-0.0192363672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08531v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08531v1 | Learning with Rejection for Abstractive Text Summarization | 2023-02-16T19:07:08 | 2023-02-16T19:07:08 | Meng Cao, Yue Dong, Jingyi He, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art abstractive summarization systems frequently hallucinate
content that is not supported by the source document, mainly due to noise in
the training dataset. Existing methods opt to drop the noisy samples or tokens
from the training set entirely, reducing the effective training set size and
creating an artificial propensity to copy words from the source. In this work,
we propose a training objective for abstractive summarization based on
rejection learning, in which the model learns whether or not to reject
potentially noisy tokens. We further propose a regularized decoding objective
that penalizes non-factual candidate summaries during inference by using the
rejection probability learned during training. We show that our method
considerably improves the factuality of generated summaries in automatic and
human evaluations when compared to five baseline models and that it does so
while increasing the abstractiveness of the generated summaries. | [
0.0374825411,
0.0383211263,
0.0310492907,
0.0035635238,
-0.0067786081,
0.0298061613,
-0.0813786834,
-0.0114011159,
-0.0578876249,
-0.0176979005,
0.0349768959,
-0.0249326881,
0.0284272358,
0.0257571563,
0.0200133231,
-0.0930513442,
0.0196979493,
0.008060283,
0.0404592007,
-0.004906883,
0.0340733565,
0.0013055924,
0.0363223888,
0.0376929604,
0.0025499172,
0.0118993036,
0.0131507171,
-0.0111736525,
0.0152020957,
-0.0215708744,
-0.0211190209,
0.0115487808,
0.0218163598,
0.0201213118,
0.0000019532,
-0.046177201,
-0.0450903364,
-0.0041261371,
0.008498081,
-0.0083573125,
0.0753974691,
-0.0575191565,
0.0292008817,
0.0193020795,
0.0174580589,
-0.0246193465,
0.0255507715,
0.1127310619,
0.0695501342,
0.0676000491,
-0.0095990961,
0.0075366511,
0.004307563,
-0.008169231,
-0.0356864966,
0.0083818184,
-0.0084602823,
0.0351731479,
-0.037824519,
-0.0150759695,
0.0003139841,
0.0250687134,
0.0148639623,
0.0307684001,
0.031791877,
0.020339027,
-0.0789245963,
-0.006922029,
0.0372403339,
0.051435858,
0.0179497544,
-0.0478987172,
-0.0034224729,
-0.0018705726,
0.0033775435,
-0.0154560003,
-0.0453387313,
0.0398707651,
-0.0254771337,
0.0415383056,
-0.0022293122,
0.0525772423,
-0.0078424979,
0.0424537957,
-0.0227258876,
0.0029126334,
-0.0028452319,
-0.0249384232,
-0.0095228218,
0.0272915512,
-0.0256921258,
-0.0239519905,
0.0227704477,
0.0185404252,
0.0060828566,
-0.0321333297,
-0.065926522,
-0.067045182,
0.0120305913,
-0.0171690919,
-0.0272889286,
-0.0123864086,
0.0121818343,
0.031195296,
-0.0070612789,
-0.0226520393,
0.0317329243,
0.0466712825,
-0.0526202843,
-0.0264971871,
0.0058249063,
0.0178082213,
-0.0513920076,
0.0872155726,
-0.0594686009,
-0.0090234559,
-0.0398050435,
-0.0097893374,
-0.0179001968,
-0.0025635946,
-0.0631881431,
0.0288325883,
-0.022805877,
-0.0125754327,
-0.0100783221,
0.0075185332,
-0.0105461553,
-0.0127033032,
0.0255047977,
-0.0039695408,
-0.0245157983,
0.0079220077,
0.0446096957,
0.0329439975,
0.0078618638,
0.0355619937,
-0.0352239534,
-0.0205774233,
0.0072766701,
-0.022174513,
0.0208300371,
-0.0312356986,
-0.0340130813,
-0.0405972265,
-0.010960713,
-0.0145895779,
-0.0160673521,
-0.0286765508,
-0.0151036307,
0.0208009016,
-0.0161236078,
0.0375446677,
-0.0340739526,
-0.0319448002,
0.0429729931,
0.0147286514,
-0.0374335647,
0.0399310887,
0.0249286368,
0.0543397181,
0.0496047772,
0.0505857095,
0.0287025012,
0.0183211584,
0.0450850017,
0.0116763068,
0.0205068216,
-0.0317390375,
-0.0578441918,
-0.0230699722,
0.0464472659,
0.0723497123,
-0.0527106635,
0.0135458056,
0.0646827593,
0.031524729,
-0.0295132753,
0.0351326726,
0.0083489716,
0.0652625486,
0.0164945684,
0.0742114484,
-0.0305784978,
0.0282012746,
-0.0599638745,
0.0690157786,
0.0723044202,
-0.0003646375,
-0.0146259796,
-0.0711373016,
0.035117276,
-0.0300044511,
0.0183666553,
-0.0012074321,
0.0515138134,
0.0334842093,
-0.0702443495,
0.0004175412,
0.0180499796,
-0.0449354202,
0.0323059037,
-0.0175869279,
0.0442772061,
0.0046866932,
0.0613551699,
-0.0554456189,
0.0405868068,
-0.0232233014,
-0.0078060422,
0.0619276464,
0.0527762398,
-0.0228156894,
-0.0004856101,
-0.0475324467,
-0.0372609831,
0.0141271437,
0.0155807417,
-0.0070623611,
-0.0045303861,
-0.0113087352,
0.049062036,
-0.0297048464,
-0.0940426663,
0.0335231796,
0.0171826649,
-0.0588389263,
0.0068441848,
0.0083129536,
0.012777444,
0.0448458679,
-0.0145368492,
0.0247926656,
-0.0050420924,
-0.043807108,
-0.0400040783,
0.0215577818,
-0.0474188961,
-0.0451494083,
0.007096529,
-0.0745187551,
-0.0104253814,
0.0689146891,
-0.0225551203,
-0.0383316875,
0.0427841321,
-0.0692072585,
0.0576682836,
-0.0520356707,
-0.0009236923,
0.0159175973,
0.0066745859,
-0.0063373097,
0.0626034513,
-0.0165165439,
0.0081571331,
0.0519364811,
-0.0201492906,
0.0148475925,
-0.0257823393,
-0.0407158919,
-0.0134672979,
-0.0165587459,
0.0245932639,
0.0608496591,
-0.0181318913,
-0.0153322313,
0.023067411,
-0.0311169084,
-0.0253543947,
-0.0281890202,
-0.0127765257,
0.0477420799,
0.0100005148,
0.0234744959,
-0.0122159412,
-0.0164514184,
-0.0258688293,
0.0106196655,
-0.0168077275,
0.0331600383,
0.0024951117,
0.0238631591,
-0.0539023802,
-0.0065358998,
0.0033003164,
0.0311138704,
-0.0180036295,
-0.0055466406,
-0.0353729054,
0.042547863,
-0.0073839067,
0.0143288318,
0.0060092704,
0.0099285739,
-0.025107583,
-0.0107683223,
-0.0275487974,
0.0188069474,
0.0302551277,
0.0114097521,
0.0289472546,
0.0388775319,
-0.034358602,
-0.0220938846,
-0.0272271857,
0.0558588989,
0.0226125866,
-0.0428772755,
0.0427192077,
0.0328740887,
0.0418117791,
0.0175423119,
-0.05182679,
0.0215716232,
-0.0328609534,
-0.0448421612,
-0.0312792249,
-0.0386220366,
-0.0098333862,
0.0153278392,
-0.0553264879,
-0.0300384257,
0.0884107649,
-0.0237898305,
0.0275448989,
-0.0802026019,
-0.0155572072,
-0.0197899174,
0.0220470708,
0.0076337452,
0.0322316848,
0.0157851987,
-0.0193320587,
-0.0317077003,
-0.0591858402,
0.0304927099,
-0.0160810258,
0.080293715,
-0.0402314551,
-0.0107534658,
-0.0244251322,
-0.0011898031,
-0.0062078433,
-0.0495352782,
0.0042539211,
0.0192988906,
0.0127111552,
0.0068658581,
-0.0528048426,
-0.0001189695,
0.0310335606,
0.0687459409,
-0.0248946473,
-0.0184247866,
-0.0179017,
0.0320827253,
0.0926829055,
0.0341725536,
0.048970595,
-0.0492629632,
0.0463289246,
0.0609433129,
0.0171056073,
-0.0172168612,
-0.0020615961,
-0.0252656192,
-0.0083617009,
-0.0284619331,
0.0195681322,
-0.0150549635,
0.0541710556,
-0.0232857987,
-0.0098981773,
0.1064868346,
0.006087414,
-0.040338736,
-0.0156038366,
-0.0117205996,
0.0605180971,
0.0014240418,
-0.0168399755,
-0.0560869873,
-0.0016141422,
-0.0049312501,
0.0511306152,
-0.0011004027,
-0.0251990482,
0.0085197147,
-0.0959921852,
0.0022963677,
0.0314786211,
-0.115951702,
-0.0773296207,
-0.0357065201,
-0.0032143241,
-0.0369328335,
-0.0014929887,
0.0011719515,
-0.0132497502,
0.0110368216,
0.0111944256,
-0.0724725276,
0.0010077623,
-0.035931848,
-0.0359092876,
-0.0169046819,
0.0462052934,
0.0439811647,
-0.006336208,
0.0373379104,
0.0319828764,
-0.0681358799,
-0.0271624811,
0.0048503531,
0.0854433253,
0.0066967946,
0.0248880219,
-0.0304217096,
0.061828997,
0.0102498084,
-0.026745731,
-0.0072237672,
0.0109834438,
0.0002276727,
-0.0108428476,
-0.0542440452,
0.0452405401,
0.0105046062,
0.0871118829,
0.0434451215,
-0.020933006,
-0.0331872515,
-0.0435166024,
0.0270725675,
-0.0853999779,
0.0066573187,
-0.00817052,
-0.0282249451,
-0.032615263,
-0.1191507205,
-0.0500848107,
0.0055636857,
0.0064153303,
-0.0097593637,
0.014037909,
0.0097553413,
-0.0039958134,
-0.0062546069,
-0.0111965658,
-0.0111223664,
-0.0251196828,
0.024859203,
-0.0221640337,
0.013618038,
-0.0481801517,
-0.0189209878,
0.050577078,
-0.0016816251,
-0.056649901,
-0.0171961114,
0.0219257064,
0.0255264025,
0.0864258334,
0.024561679,
-0.0051663732,
0.0781553239,
-0.0005578168,
0.0255128983,
0.029545106,
0.0360072032,
0.0399360321,
-0.0179242864,
0.0209689066,
-0.0524141192,
0.0292560961,
-0.017151624,
0.0052828975,
-0.0268620979,
0.0124203255,
0.0462079979,
0.0391957872,
-0.0321663097,
-0.027930852,
-0.0245254617,
-0.0286184419,
-0.0185187645,
-0.0168077927,
-0.0167693887,
-0.030535372,
0.0340555906,
0.0051498325,
-0.0046174708,
-0.0356516466,
0.0173620302,
-0.0041205487,
0.0558045581,
-0.0306080133,
-0.0164242573,
-0.0170215424,
0.0046964036,
-0.0415358953,
-0.027303515,
-0.0669296533,
-0.0419146456,
-0.0414774157,
0.0123457778,
-0.0185669921,
-0.0200623199,
0.0352976955,
-0.0058466285,
-0.0035437969,
0.001510852,
-0.0867240354,
0.0503806472,
-0.095648855,
-0.0230360087,
0.006619534,
-0.0672814548,
0.0644384548,
-0.0099788141,
-0.0070424457,
-0.0088221366,
0.0189774409,
0.0067902179,
-0.0188895594,
-0.0302502979,
0.0199635737,
0.0280709341,
0.0038029344,
0.0655328557,
-0.0199024528,
0.026632119,
-0.0084260236,
-0.0000764956,
-0.0564141907,
-0.0016514997,
-0.0281676371,
0.0464331098,
-0.0048649805,
-0.0057575237,
-0.0445253365,
-0.0538861789,
0.0203695949,
0.0421243645,
0.0405254737,
-0.0231207944,
0.0406328738,
0.0150841428,
-0.0076944954,
-0.0309103876,
-0.0353995711,
0.0025703367,
0.0560065582,
0.0241651051,
-0.0484603904,
-5.739607205e-33,
-0.0251206923,
0.0030582179,
-0.0458540097,
0.0151024666,
-0.0381223783,
0.0113085415,
-0.0545956455,
-0.025692638,
0.0095751751,
0.0095823612,
-0.0142743373,
0.0316768214,
0.0080291145,
0.0514163785,
-0.013202603,
0.0443344042,
0.0610386766,
-0.0084235836,
-0.0496144779,
0.0372627154,
0.0483362004,
0.0019117479,
0.032288406,
-0.0778397024,
0.0256249923,
-0.0057794042,
-0.0371233374,
-0.019548066,
0.0495605953,
0.001841107,
-0.0126950378,
0.0281665996,
0.0349574536,
-0.0210540574,
-0.0465748645,
-0.004166251,
-0.0895138979,
-0.024567591,
0.0255385228,
-0.0333359167,
-0.0136810215,
-0.0266331881,
0.052668158,
-0.0234793164,
-0.0172835756,
-0.0303564966,
0.0460550971,
-0.067655243,
-0.0331392698,
-0.0612031482,
-0.0565577857,
0.0381508172,
-0.0271120258,
0.0090214377,
0.0278944019,
0.0238301568,
-0.0124828797,
0.0036439595,
-0.0442283601,
0.0226117484,
0.0202833209,
0.0330849364,
0.0106696039,
-0.0069726519,
-0.0232322291,
0.0768441111,
-0.0025940416,
-0.011054513,
-0.0309914146,
-0.0167826023,
0.0218574684,
0.0114003662,
0.033794187,
0.0542076826,
0.061101988,
0.0055715917,
-0.0508345328,
0.1055812761,
-0.0452959575,
0.0334584191,
0.0377907865,
-0.012942221,
-0.0043682358,
0.0013252386,
-0.0284072291,
-0.0294394605,
-0.0068304148,
-0.0009539808,
-0.0098245516,
0.0445959754,
-0.0582996421,
-0.0078243082,
0.0072091264,
-0.0399777032,
0.0219416507,
-0.0064058299,
-0.0200134628,
-0.0009766119,
0.0080453409,
-0.0563332103,
-0.0245380364,
0.0043534259,
0.0134141184,
0.0209260713,
-0.0017715219,
-0.0082947994,
0.073976025,
0.006024329,
-0.0462218858,
0.0178809576,
-0.0095627448,
0.022719048,
0.0046002832,
0.0296646226,
0.0042709815,
0.0028740328,
0.0086741103,
-0.0104167517,
-0.0558362901,
0.0206712577,
-0.0202281754,
0.0498167165,
0.0324992575,
0.033610113,
-0.0237348657,
0.0055211061,
0.0142710935,
-0.0171144251,
0.068210803,
-0.0511998646,
-0.0138252713,
0.0046444684,
2.438e-7,
0.0214449521,
0.0131126465,
0.0886261538,
-0.0044541368,
-0.034046568,
0.0373264626,
0.0152609618,
0.0383204184,
0.0106249209,
-0.0147023555,
0.0483567417,
0.0094227614,
0.0458356999,
0.0295567587,
-0.1248627231,
0.01284834,
-0.0483530462,
-0.0403483137,
-0.0008602418,
-0.0045582708,
0.0622660965,
0.0874742121,
-0.0221391246,
-0.0145729156,
0.0155705614,
-0.01341125,
0.0371822007,
-0.009398574,
-0.0234845746,
0.0173325744,
0.0571968816,
-0.0266905185,
0.0028433264,
-0.0081543829,
-0.0404651128,
-0.0087170554,
0.0546599887,
0.0235556029,
0.0115631213,
-0.0380189195,
-0.0042457059,
-0.0056472109,
0.025158653,
0.0099597499,
0.0334924571,
-0.0449261032,
-0.0113195432,
-0.0189404935,
-0.0691985339,
0.0285561886,
-0.0072132302,
0.0040421477,
-0.0363133997,
0.0470435508,
0.0051748734,
0.0142733213,
0.0165467337,
-0.0691592321,
-0.0264101326,
0.0116398307,
-0.0040595517,
-0.0323476195,
-0.0023168996,
-0.0059629744,
0.0057128104,
-0.0854371339,
0.0125081604,
2.450069559e-34,
0.1173294932,
-0.0215064343,
-0.01911062,
0.0058155996,
0.0243978202,
-0.0165455323,
0.0513425134,
-0.0049924771,
0.0051750434,
-0.0397866704,
0.0082329633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08500v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08500v2 | Auditing large language models: a three-layered approach | 2023-02-16T18:55:21 | 2023-06-27T07:40:15 | Jakob Mökander, Jonas Schuett, Hannah Rose Kirk, Luciano Floridi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, K.4; K.6 | Large language models (LLMs) represent a major advance in artificial
intelligence (AI) research. However, the widespread use of LLMs is also coupled
with significant ethical and social challenges. Previous research has pointed
towards auditing as a promising governance mechanism to help ensure that AI
systems are designed and deployed in ways that are ethical, legal, and
technically robust. However, existing auditing procedures fail to address the
governance challenges posed by LLMs, which display emergent capabilities and
are adaptable to a wide range of downstream tasks. In this article, we address
that gap by outlining a novel blueprint for how to audit LLMs. Specifically, we
propose a three-layered approach, whereby governance audits (of technology
providers that design and disseminate LLMs), model audits (of LLMs after
pre-training but prior to their release), and application audits (of
applications based on LLMs) complement and inform each other. We show how
audits, when conducted in a structured and coordinated manner on all three
levels, can be a feasible and effective mechanism for identifying and managing
some of the ethical and social risks posed by LLMs. However, it is important to
remain realistic about what auditing can reasonably be expected to achieve.
Therefore, we discuss the limitations not only of our three-layered approach
but also of the prospect of auditing LLMs at all. Ultimately, this article
seeks to expand the methodological toolkit available to technology providers
and policymakers who wish to analyse and evaluate LLMs from technical, ethical,
and legal perspectives. | [
0.0519860983,
0.1070262343,
-0.0370467082,
0.0418552868,
-0.0638035908,
-0.003657944,
0.0374513976,
-0.0154644977,
0.0365155078,
-0.0384763442,
-0.0132306237,
0.0093813855,
0.0134115834,
0.0578252152,
0.0352242291,
0.034882389,
0.0282507241,
-0.0365620367,
-0.0134660965,
0.0163099058,
0.00249828,
0.0265327524,
0.0543245822,
0.0503203198,
-0.0014225319,
-0.0035797837,
0.0029043343,
-0.0466194935,
-0.0313868523,
-0.0075205141,
0.0093634976,
0.0136992633,
0.0163975116,
0.0764722899,
0.0000020448,
-0.0589833371,
-0.0222693793,
0.0541437417,
-0.0090746284,
0.0662826672,
0.05861504,
-0.0056780018,
-0.022031866,
-0.0096621951,
-0.0329201929,
0.0497667268,
0.0291143991,
-0.0058317375,
0.0256760474,
0.0404453501,
-0.003559316,
-0.0082227075,
0.0404488631,
0.0189140197,
-0.0714697391,
-0.0303025208,
0.0048846072,
0.0023267234,
0.030483041,
0.0239524283,
0.0143766291,
0.0573005751,
0.053679686,
-0.0242503379,
-0.017606603,
-0.0096197193,
0.0047274027,
-0.027531961,
-0.0361712687,
0.0197766628,
0.0246783793,
-0.022127511,
0.0403232686,
0.0138435569,
0.0173783526,
-0.0093452986,
0.0177006908,
0.0740082562,
-0.0170438383,
0.0028546797,
0.0344896019,
-0.0343212746,
0.0372654162,
0.0372208357,
0.0114795063,
0.0463056527,
-0.0181325302,
-0.035249915,
-0.0230790209,
0.0176681392,
0.0657614917,
-0.0449939743,
0.007677583,
0.0443218946,
-0.0188621394,
0.0344116427,
-0.0207146984,
0.014127424,
0.027331274,
-0.0459211618,
0.0448494777,
-0.0152764786,
-0.0190609656,
0.0184636619,
-0.0039558313,
0.0533489846,
-0.0474974625,
0.0741556734,
-0.0274253096,
0.0173534416,
0.0105256913,
-0.0069593322,
-0.0003480318,
0.0351889282,
-0.0240473747,
0.0094587961,
-0.0043914518,
0.0452861488,
-0.0480987355,
0.0857777596,
-0.0294550303,
0.0064150211,
0.0386777148,
-0.0349049419,
-0.0161759239,
-0.0549682267,
0.0099405795,
0.0392457806,
0.0026590934,
-0.0482886918,
0.0271976516,
0.0194594823,
-0.0654551685,
0.0084380414,
0.0195545144,
0.1116410345,
0.0288946386,
-0.0051705367,
-0.0333058015,
-0.0642307177,
-0.0191760138,
-0.0667618364,
0.0219293144,
-0.0610839128,
-0.0345687903,
-0.0218811482,
-0.021745529,
-0.0614367649,
-0.019588396,
-0.0071731163,
-0.024749767,
0.0276209433,
-0.0465527363,
0.0299310014,
0.0092492811,
0.0467125438,
0.0146479355,
0.0304287467,
0.0393860452,
0.0049185283,
0.0452773571,
0.0070989449,
0.0425642766,
0.0371257775,
-0.0208461378,
0.0190419666,
-0.0458713435,
0.0025563266,
-0.0105062919,
0.0022503342,
-0.0113717932,
0.0609278455,
0.0101302834,
-0.0065309783,
0.050299041,
0.0907698274,
-0.0333024226,
0.0121661555,
0.0255922098,
-0.042879533,
-0.0044937562,
-0.0014532831,
-0.0260126721,
-0.0107688252,
-0.0357502736,
-0.0287160184,
-0.0620122477,
0.0562398024,
-0.0214959439,
-0.0655661598,
-0.0007549161,
-0.0591472834,
0.026441725,
0.0591803752,
0.0208331179,
-0.0230225325,
0.0113965617,
-0.0216706619,
-0.0025745092,
-0.0387190692,
-0.0150739178,
-0.1038852781,
0.0518027805,
0.081080623,
0.0385409966,
-0.0330362655,
0.0053426614,
-0.0281296149,
-0.0381991602,
0.0234914683,
0.0246497616,
-0.0218732841,
-0.0037244081,
0.0011681564,
-0.0320604406,
-0.0282106642,
-0.0062388033,
0.0173515752,
-0.0195335932,
0.0267038159,
-0.0196949914,
-0.0185409524,
-0.0881754756,
0.036014609,
-0.0417002179,
0.0003205358,
-0.0342509188,
0.0067962813,
0.0024835493,
0.0361269303,
-0.0152207194,
0.032405328,
0.0376944467,
-0.0042322571,
0.0035992325,
-0.0132472003,
0.0448964164,
0.0839869455,
0.0201026369,
-0.050353907,
-0.0204999615,
0.023915451,
-0.0235040542,
0.0031260762,
0.033516109,
-0.025420621,
0.0276426468,
-0.0080026267,
0.02206802,
-0.086491473,
-0.0220413916,
-0.0429299287,
0.0070294277,
-0.0292249713,
-0.0191787779,
-0.0242547411,
-0.0043895254,
0.0324783958,
0.0060851634,
-0.0519732051,
0.0657457709,
-0.0049237013,
0.0358497165,
0.0609775297,
0.028421184,
-0.0058963974,
-0.0147051876,
-0.0626474172,
-0.0238733273,
0.0036333723,
0.0224243738,
-0.0291749574,
-0.0175097045,
0.0005169684,
-0.0068450053,
-0.0178041514,
-0.0523912944,
0.0128685283,
0.0131789232,
0.0214654747,
-0.0238423273,
-0.0598887838,
-0.0184209645,
-0.0120757483,
-0.0128473211,
0.0397959612,
0.0269917585,
0.0007667843,
-0.0713178813,
0.0169390608,
-0.0472029373,
0.0146040441,
0.0191351585,
-0.0112314606,
0.041205965,
0.0098032756,
-0.0463466011,
0.0643330589,
-0.0033956813,
0.0595664009,
0.0452676378,
0.0267857239,
-0.0348841287,
-0.0313418694,
0.0574945137,
-0.0160987377,
-0.0056507308,
0.0013543717,
0.0278492849,
0.0132158883,
-0.0249119774,
-0.0034887346,
0.0142349107,
0.0453671291,
-0.0498466268,
-0.0423083343,
0.0102866814,
-0.0812045336,
-0.0293070767,
0.0483006686,
0.0018790334,
-0.0769437626,
0.0629689246,
-0.040090058,
0.0219819341,
-0.019220246,
-0.054884553,
-0.0377473943,
0.0746937022,
-0.0271375515,
0.0391476154,
0.0158133861,
-0.0031599917,
-0.0137960259,
-0.0115022585,
0.0371119492,
-0.0608796254,
0.0494197085,
-0.0607695729,
0.029306354,
0.0176158939,
-0.0311165377,
-0.0255790576,
0.0027004173,
-0.0594555251,
0.0287871268,
-0.0032307892,
0.0056984755,
-0.0138077699,
-0.0274165217,
0.0620826222,
0.0319511443,
0.0491639525,
-0.0083958087,
-0.0158420131,
-0.047724396,
-0.0159345921,
-0.0310055874,
0.0619094595,
-0.0179618411,
0.0135935955,
0.0255394094,
0.0091791023,
0.026558781,
-0.0220402218,
0.0052181617,
0.0161452629,
0.0151082473,
0.0322845131,
0.0401293151,
0.0163083188,
-0.0611085333,
-0.012593301,
0.0440467782,
0.0076591903,
-0.0344211981,
0.0402384475,
0.0216483623,
-0.054860916,
0.0265597329,
0.0257067177,
-0.1166251898,
0.0300379265,
0.0071551153,
0.0143352961,
-0.0782625675,
-0.0162258875,
-0.0038329798,
-0.0878141448,
0.0677214116,
0.0123495115,
-0.0089878114,
-0.0061260951,
-0.0075929882,
-0.0381652266,
-0.0061706007,
0.0588904656,
-0.0264023654,
0.0159437191,
-0.043529585,
0.0243552346,
-0.0671248138,
-0.017736394,
0.0363119766,
-0.0537415482,
0.0865403563,
0.0897093788,
-0.0060027461,
-0.0382187888,
-0.0033687674,
0.030650977,
0.0156856794,
-0.0026186868,
0.032436002,
-0.0285152849,
0.0308880955,
-0.0278731175,
-0.0348163806,
-0.0040070303,
-0.0341727734,
-0.0216418281,
0.0387193561,
0.0732831135,
-0.0548241213,
-0.0290768798,
-0.020771198,
-0.0560422726,
-0.0013605335,
0.0397606157,
-0.0162186436,
-0.0167796519,
-0.045397535,
-0.0172103792,
-0.0250219796,
-0.0101178354,
-0.0293001886,
0.023497954,
0.0141152479,
-0.0040255194,
-0.0601375699,
-0.0370488577,
-0.0394626521,
-0.015688993,
0.0445222855,
-0.0384181663,
0.0631694868,
-0.0168811046,
-0.0044199415,
0.0266339462,
-0.0181950741,
0.0471889041,
-0.0412198156,
-0.0116089201,
-0.0239985231,
0.0123976134,
0.0351676717,
0.0252724048,
0.0313261263,
-0.0327816345,
0.0060414602,
0.0451578088,
0.0254370254,
-0.0039740736,
-0.0365745723,
-0.0132802334,
0.0332659483,
0.0165831912,
-0.0435680002,
0.0111709684,
0.0404869653,
-0.0193185676,
-0.01002526,
-0.0026167333,
-0.0321501791,
-0.0153182466,
0.0336028747,
-0.0477779247,
-0.0225761048,
-0.0195010677,
0.0354522131,
0.0272810459,
-0.0195038449,
-0.0503975637,
0.0261421483,
-0.010021586,
-0.0561881177,
-0.0098826708,
-0.0253780112,
-0.0278951339,
-0.0057246787,
0.0073681823,
0.004132635,
0.0173633862,
0.0397522673,
-0.025177883,
0.0054409909,
-0.0366326347,
0.0619438216,
7.133e-7,
0.0466349944,
0.0198825561,
0.0135751367,
-0.0123561593,
0.0515269116,
-0.0599888079,
0.0281932913,
0.0105702868,
0.0438479371,
0.0002031265,
0.0290413611,
0.0156879947,
0.0694529787,
-0.0334906839,
-0.0744052231,
0.0212943107,
0.0566870756,
0.0078670932,
0.0571638048,
-0.0096210437,
-0.0035930877,
0.0218154248,
-0.0234430376,
-0.0111247851,
-0.020093875,
-0.0485730059,
-0.0362882167,
0.0221609361,
-0.0490669198,
-0.0162997115,
0.0549513027,
0.0148067018,
0.0386546031,
-0.0500268191,
0.0010857016,
0.0177157223,
-0.0769906268,
0.0301200636,
-0.056438379,
-0.0465606637,
-0.0550648794,
-0.0710481331,
-0.0809015706,
-0.0416727886,
0.029511204,
0.0108568147,
-0.020236114,
-0.0048144977,
0.0553195029,
0.0310662016,
-0.0215152595,
-0.0404882543,
-0.0191333219,
-0.023730468,
-0.0231536683,
0.0141713843,
-5.495559517e-33,
0.0268261246,
-0.0374701954,
0.0279328022,
-0.0148675386,
-0.0174642708,
0.0353593007,
-0.0306652691,
0.0021988507,
-0.0522865504,
0.0052984185,
-0.0023882396,
0.0045773489,
-0.0064992229,
-0.024722619,
0.0563155301,
-0.0155540789,
0.0174954925,
-0.0099407611,
0.0108684273,
0.0289661065,
-0.0272666179,
-0.0421197116,
0.0319228023,
-0.0648619086,
0.0767115057,
0.0357769094,
-0.0202932879,
0.007714971,
-0.0651073903,
0.0688664243,
-0.0002253411,
0.0426252261,
0.0191747062,
-0.0385453179,
0.0002455369,
0.024005292,
0.0051024868,
0.0287224799,
0.0123478314,
0.0074915946,
-0.0066225771,
-0.0567125119,
0.0749594346,
-0.0149924289,
-0.0374377295,
0.0175815877,
0.0072168098,
-0.0393424295,
-0.026878221,
-0.0364455618,
-0.0697720721,
0.0031775052,
-0.0401836112,
0.01485918,
0.0174154676,
0.0216570944,
-0.0234808382,
-0.0142427478,
-0.0171878096,
0.0170160942,
0.0083230594,
-0.0702036247,
0.0757716969,
0.0090765338,
0.0033140327,
0.0520957708,
0.0151598966,
0.0284958463,
-0.0283326339,
-0.0307649001,
0.0250793137,
0.0761803985,
0.0404964983,
-0.008841712,
-0.0729875565,
-0.0333330333,
-0.0288831238,
0.0047292174,
0.0115987975,
0.044902768,
0.0087140985,
-0.0219672807,
-0.0696082562,
-0.029003866,
0.008738881,
-0.0470055863,
-0.0271169078,
0.0115257427,
0.0303378031,
0.0116486521,
-0.0255181175,
0.0051586353,
0.0088558737,
-0.1050274149,
0.0102497395,
-0.0370118581,
-0.0000882702,
0.0045237932,
0.0072534885,
0.0345207527,
-0.0452991202,
-0.0306900945,
-0.0168728251,
0.0139285456,
0.0494989268,
0.0158178583,
-0.0025081681,
0.0369604565,
-0.0110600898,
0.034004271,
-0.0335994065,
0.0151043581,
0.0410258621,
-0.0163451154,
0.0194979906,
0.0122912657,
0.011466153,
0.018170679,
-0.0063179936,
0.0143780131,
-0.0567554347,
0.0307636149,
-0.026102731,
0.007002152,
-0.0514230169,
-0.02523176,
-0.0537135825,
0.0745993927,
0.0731331035,
-0.0073069236,
-0.016458232,
0.0080784122,
2.826e-7,
0.0057662106,
-0.011198272,
0.0179315992,
-0.0341029614,
-0.0076498184,
0.0410783254,
0.0125749055,
0.0573298708,
-0.0367447957,
-0.0442938581,
0.0020217823,
-0.0097683948,
0.040463157,
0.0104601709,
-0.0161224194,
0.0015050354,
-0.0698476285,
-0.0076037347,
-0.1092684194,
0.0347932316,
0.0210404098,
0.0331322663,
0.0217170343,
-0.0438887775,
-0.0163063537,
-0.0320408233,
0.0017515889,
-0.0207009856,
-0.0053169755,
-0.0160999354,
0.0259271003,
0.0611271895,
0.0063949605,
0.0124921016,
0.0174797587,
0.0195898078,
-0.029667329,
0.0634793043,
-0.0081097465,
0.0279698242,
-0.0311898235,
-0.075782463,
0.0075046406,
-0.0441479236,
0.0569736138,
0.0203890596,
-0.0140304817,
-0.0780594945,
0.0455685444,
-0.0658883899,
0.0230102595,
0.0122679286,
0.0274436865,
0.0215678923,
-0.0014010246,
-0.0294922963,
0.0323945954,
-0.048349306,
0.0228540134,
0.0164672583,
0.0009655695,
-0.039452415,
-0.004567842,
0.0369731858,
0.0077696517,
-0.0338342674,
0.0787350535,
2.312975464e-34,
-0.0114712473,
-0.0498480275,
0.0231026392,
0.0268644243,
0.0319203213,
0.0682721734,
-0.025524551,
-0.013589099,
0.00149903,
-0.0186671093,
0.0035553731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08468v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08468v3 | LEVER: Learning to Verify Language-to-Code Generation with Execution | 2023-02-16T18:23:22 | 2023-09-01T17:37:42 | Ansong Ni, Srini Iyer, Dragomir Radev, Ves Stoyanov, Wen-tau Yih, Sida I. Wang, Xi Victoria Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE | The advent of large language models trained on code (code LLMs) has led to
significant progress in language-to-code generation. State-of-the-art
approaches in this area combine LLM decoding with sample pruning and reranking
using test cases or heuristics based on the execution results. However, it is
challenging to obtain test cases for many real-world language-to-code
applications, and heuristics cannot well capture the semantic features of the
execution results, such as data type and value range, which often indicates the
correctness of the program. In this work, we propose LEVER, a simple approach
to improve language-to-code generation by learning to verify the generated
programs with their execution results. Specifically, we train verifiers to
determine whether a program sampled from the LLMs is correct or not based on
the natural language input, the program itself and its execution results. The
sampled programs are reranked by combining the verification score with the LLM
generation probability, and marginalizing over programs with the same execution
results. On four datasets across the domains of table QA, math QA and basic
Python programming, LEVER consistently improves over the base code LLMs(4.6% to
10.9% with code-davinci-002) and achieves new state-of-the-art results on all
of them. | [
-0.0204169843,
0.0845504254,
-0.0045994902,
0.0393821672,
0.0115676094,
0.0007500208,
-0.0526655726,
0.0184977073,
0.0117849968,
-0.0159813445,
0.0017287667,
0.0163545571,
0.0173056833,
0.0411552452,
0.0745041743,
0.0215361547,
0.0212326758,
-0.0266469084,
-0.0432993025,
0.0084442412,
-0.0172017086,
0.0405567698,
0.0029513519,
0.0539663099,
0.0216488875,
-0.0147010991,
-0.0026628552,
0.0108691175,
0.0098079201,
-0.0428450033,
-0.003128625,
0.0453771986,
0.0030903982,
0.0030747419,
0.0000021807,
-0.0316607207,
-0.0288111772,
0.0060542864,
-0.007658259,
0.0084997127,
0.0076057417,
-0.0281447601,
0.0053738807,
0.054373987,
-0.0474084839,
-0.02329625,
0.0267413277,
-0.0696080029,
0.0859648287,
0.08444269,
0.0221402664,
-0.0041900282,
0.0060133948,
0.0092828572,
0.0070277965,
-0.0318462066,
-0.0162352286,
0.0635481328,
-0.0161774624,
-0.0190824084,
0.0093271742,
0.0059863343,
0.0422013365,
0.0007729798,
-0.0230668411,
0.0324390233,
-0.0326680653,
0.0140962796,
-0.0036773088,
0.0591141693,
-0.0751451254,
-0.0961961076,
0.0151055185,
-0.0181433503,
-0.0078547411,
-0.0513110906,
0.00600769,
0.0461605303,
0.0152456425,
0.0224706493,
0.0351160802,
-0.0032759365,
0.036138285,
-0.0118434988,
-0.0510532632,
0.0471119694,
0.0025643753,
-0.0171510875,
-0.0046258392,
0.005608412,
0.0292127728,
-0.0512734428,
-0.0205153953,
0.0596625507,
-0.041238118,
-0.0048568104,
-0.0567065291,
-0.0314728394,
0.0078394702,
-0.0201264918,
0.035108462,
0.0465430059,
0.0103128431,
-0.0117815547,
-0.0699761212,
0.0556658842,
0.0206258036,
0.0272577498,
-0.0344642326,
0.0166703891,
-0.028404681,
0.0258228909,
-0.0235214084,
0.0371426716,
-0.0264904648,
0.0282190833,
-0.0415202267,
0.0170329958,
-0.0069560758,
0.0960668325,
-0.0098364465,
0.0041439505,
-0.0241123531,
0.0028019743,
0.0073560476,
-0.0337538682,
-0.0028558972,
-0.0409808345,
-0.0106988242,
-0.06062622,
-0.0034487904,
0.046648711,
-0.0431314223,
-0.010265314,
0.034046717,
0.0697457492,
-0.0132167665,
0.0149696395,
-0.0523531698,
-0.049998533,
0.0193878524,
-0.062644273,
-0.0024179178,
-0.1127902716,
-0.0163044948,
-0.0056793597,
-0.0040594074,
-0.0687891543,
0.0159283392,
-0.0007774424,
0.0283304844,
0.0627885684,
-0.0203173291,
0.0008988414,
-0.0245919731,
0.0087016942,
-0.00296617,
0.0390767455,
0.0803270638,
0.0220276248,
-0.02113414,
-0.0163402893,
0.0313788019,
0.0485168695,
0.0351816192,
0.0076236501,
-0.0161898099,
0.026213672,
0.018142296,
0.0037226982,
0.0201520249,
0.0321698524,
-0.0192230623,
0.0329460725,
-0.0128305787,
0.0071729664,
0.0220180117,
0.0431207493,
0.0883410871,
0.0178433377,
-0.008467528,
-0.0102681909,
-0.0550985374,
0.0341047682,
0.0111284368,
0.02686432,
0.0060663396,
0.0399251878,
-0.0101049133,
-0.0751960576,
-0.0107470891,
-0.0370557718,
0.0056527629,
0.0025757179,
0.0110376207,
0.0206960607,
-0.0712762699,
0.0284353066,
-0.0272247382,
-0.0823631957,
0.0071975724,
-0.0732515752,
0.0402048193,
0.0415957123,
0.0398744233,
-0.0285727419,
0.0175601505,
-0.0039751809,
-0.0346317329,
-0.0103785926,
0.0178092476,
-0.0263354983,
0.028339237,
-0.0279118493,
-0.0163052566,
-0.0144965965,
0.0104540857,
0.0143392636,
0.033411514,
-0.000357096,
0.0471469946,
-0.0344682969,
-0.0518377386,
0.0491226576,
-0.0197805837,
-0.0401293784,
0.0485200733,
0.0086832503,
0.0366192162,
-0.0312915482,
-0.0299006794,
0.0343814418,
0.0119682206,
-0.0084575647,
0.0029439155,
-0.0377284624,
-0.0195110086,
-0.0546374768,
0.0228871368,
-0.0533015989,
-0.0224045534,
0.0361952335,
-0.0691175163,
-0.0178104062,
0.0271951016,
-0.0227515679,
-0.0244492553,
-0.0246341433,
0.0266046952,
0.0034311768,
-0.0162688363,
-0.0076855775,
0.0551390573,
-0.0170284621,
0.0077789156,
-0.0090175224,
0.0192967672,
0.0159627646,
-0.0190121327,
0.0235702787,
0.0069022649,
-0.0339013152,
0.051475089,
-0.004305454,
0.0785054788,
-0.0339338705,
-0.0132438801,
-0.0707612038,
0.0354412422,
-0.0161992237,
0.0461967401,
0.023216391,
-0.0183283221,
0.0200536307,
-0.0122643486,
-0.0659431964,
-0.0288437996,
0.0313730575,
-0.0350566506,
0.0467707664,
-0.0265599079,
-0.0438612141,
-0.0453257002,
0.0043436051,
-0.0264619924,
0.0564521998,
-0.0200017914,
0.0228249617,
-0.0745682865,
0.0909812227,
-0.021260947,
0.0046540927,
0.0130816055,
-0.0378376134,
0.0160381719,
-0.0200960338,
-0.010460618,
0.0391085818,
-0.0147639308,
-0.0344029441,
0.0635694563,
0.0308528692,
-0.0920592919,
-0.0023152926,
0.01942439,
-0.0321842693,
0.0190654714,
-0.073947303,
0.0516856164,
0.0544089302,
0.0179140791,
-0.0109305717,
-0.0549775623,
0.0134836184,
0.0413386226,
-0.0187732186,
-0.0141408648,
0.0085304761,
0.0112569313,
0.0593906417,
-0.0165854301,
-0.0804162323,
0.0594455227,
-0.0512576438,
0.0209049154,
-0.034667667,
-0.0147378175,
-0.0310763977,
0.0249383897,
-0.0042457245,
0.0215081945,
-0.0386032686,
-0.0242718253,
-0.0542913079,
-0.0083549218,
-0.0215521846,
-0.0737739876,
0.0860672072,
-0.0592345707,
0.018120056,
-0.0111309718,
-0.0294134803,
-0.0554163828,
0.020273868,
-0.0077201077,
0.016756136,
0.0099381143,
-0.0099658147,
0.0443366989,
-0.0224090535,
-0.0203309618,
0.0369862169,
0.0232942849,
-0.0360207632,
-0.0070671998,
-0.0030378525,
-0.0370554216,
-0.0227845423,
0.0137376143,
-0.0165450778,
-0.013463893,
0.0158681478,
0.0410739593,
0.0653477684,
-0.085154295,
-0.0097951461,
0.0173595324,
-0.0155822057,
0.0022807328,
0.0786952898,
0.0112053072,
-0.0482362248,
-0.0146835204,
0.0865387842,
0.0271210466,
0.0084881885,
0.0306781698,
0.007885769,
0.047297705,
0.0514937118,
0.0745742694,
-0.1250096112,
-0.0253538936,
-0.0146908779,
0.0566171408,
-0.0087663429,
-0.0131831756,
-0.0425581299,
-0.1613873839,
0.0521024391,
0.0443920903,
-0.0286045577,
-0.0432130136,
-0.0124513162,
-0.0518345758,
-0.0068135872,
-0.0146230655,
0.0530635454,
0.0094740614,
0.0321419761,
0.0082958592,
-0.0289720371,
-0.0273123197,
0.0157300513,
-0.0287788454,
0.0297181811,
0.0832372382,
0.018578425,
0.026178427,
-0.0022065372,
-0.0010335398,
0.0080443788,
0.0022122434,
-0.0169039778,
0.0254757572,
0.0018181618,
-0.0028094787,
0.0606683344,
0.0339049548,
-0.0657122135,
0.0069514397,
0.0283928309,
0.0464888327,
-0.015513801,
-0.0396516249,
-0.006162269,
0.0049881339,
0.0129110692,
0.0178726576,
0.0481599607,
0.0257801879,
-0.0417702086,
-0.081781581,
0.0064406493,
-0.0864397362,
-0.0266234577,
0.0021305694,
0.0029713856,
0.0033719714,
-0.0715366378,
0.0227896515,
0.0246259756,
0.0348051302,
-0.0080165593,
-0.0283155516,
-0.0051337876,
-0.0173796173,
-0.0712873861,
-0.0000575334,
-0.0530179255,
0.0296986699,
-0.0300489962,
-0.0054971282,
0.005188561,
-0.0439411178,
-0.0079059973,
0.030676268,
-0.115528509,
-0.0444216393,
-0.0709742978,
0.0932574868,
0.0183603987,
0.0522480123,
-0.0330795459,
0.0005600787,
-0.0029727826,
0.0437131561,
-0.037259113,
0.0012092447,
0.0144925453,
-0.0165091418,
0.0220258404,
-0.0060539846,
-0.0752808973,
0.004871564,
0.0254095346,
0.0139143681,
-0.006917892,
-0.007108266,
0.0453837886,
0.0489640385,
-0.022177143,
-0.0239336044,
-0.0388924517,
0.0115031041,
0.0265278313,
0.0174458418,
-0.0229234677,
-0.0409897938,
0.0557982586,
0.0217667408,
-0.005124663,
0.0325528271,
-0.0471413769,
-0.0214838181,
0.0553493798,
0.0003900908,
0.0442858674,
0.0101529276,
0.0395498574,
0.0664117634,
-0.022627946,
-0.0234485343,
0.0292658955,
0.0089065656,
0.0555381812,
-0.0027728803,
0.0124010229,
0.0166407637,
0.0400944725,
-0.0088531412,
0.0309572425,
-0.0082450602,
-0.0584559739,
-0.0514204539,
-0.0115503883,
0.0562195443,
0.0631924719,
0.0323526673,
-0.0263358783,
0.0380898491,
0.0060838377,
0.0494621769,
-0.0169335138,
-0.027776219,
0.0125315711,
0.006876789,
0.0014978347,
-0.0336097889,
0.0801580027,
0.0100935288,
-0.0081584109,
-0.0121073434,
0.0017950257,
-0.0603401251,
-0.0303098876,
0.0105500072,
-0.0199755356,
-0.0224200096,
-0.0316136107,
-0.0130793117,
-0.1018246114,
-0.0072262529,
0.0767232999,
0.0338970311,
-0.0141765699,
0.0103472155,
0.0745789632,
0.0070917876,
0.0152199585,
-0.040326789,
0.0018422677,
0.0172399674,
-0.067178376,
-0.0397130214,
-5.795135354e-33,
-0.0282023828,
-0.0346945561,
0.0131652663,
-0.0023156106,
0.017314896,
-0.0056314897,
-0.0615112223,
-0.0227480661,
0.0172951613,
-0.0226330217,
0.0216531977,
0.0331418887,
0.0076055527,
-0.0185530353,
0.0051749134,
-0.0042771786,
0.0331734605,
-0.0188511536,
-0.0718043596,
0.0284287725,
-0.0314224362,
0.0034145098,
0.0176274087,
-0.0453538075,
-0.0049662958,
-0.0006916728,
-0.0026497494,
-0.0017175516,
-0.0278259125,
0.0378686637,
0.0194251947,
0.029757401,
0.0076671215,
-0.0338172019,
-0.0292801503,
-0.0203477312,
-0.028843848,
-0.0181879979,
0.0010750117,
-0.0119018862,
-0.0177287702,
-0.0519391149,
0.0661333054,
-0.0087630646,
-0.0641719848,
-0.000685823,
0.0118753016,
-0.0194198452,
0.005498861,
-0.0559317432,
-0.059758842,
0.0181707237,
-0.0365392603,
-0.0296992343,
-0.0019525444,
0.0281706564,
-0.0244245958,
0.0269210022,
-0.0100251725,
0.0197980143,
0.0183247849,
0.0513020828,
0.0925506577,
-0.0125023806,
-0.0238854811,
0.0140930433,
0.0353063121,
0.0001836059,
-0.0168544687,
0.0424869768,
0.0338793211,
0.040244069,
0.0388327539,
0.0515642874,
0.0281656031,
-0.0122284433,
-0.0716139227,
0.0584820025,
-0.0116477497,
-0.0037042249,
0.0093774116,
-0.0264021158,
-0.0187078975,
0.0038132744,
-0.0559947565,
-0.0020190708,
-0.0276376177,
-0.0401105024,
0.0496508218,
0.0125953173,
-0.0240164846,
-0.031219298,
0.0251891054,
-0.0508492813,
-0.0158873685,
0.0241497476,
-0.0482177846,
-0.0056136507,
-0.0228561219,
0.0420012176,
0.0019271274,
-0.0171717014,
0.0259782691,
-0.0278941579,
0.0786588117,
0.0233543087,
0.0103955176,
0.017507039,
-0.0520883054,
0.0310287513,
-0.0560428686,
0.0217470452,
-0.0032057699,
0.0627955496,
-0.0013586744,
-0.022304032,
0.0110145062,
0.0135689983,
-0.0195601881,
-0.0351274237,
-0.0165108517,
0.0074174185,
0.0286402851,
0.0438865125,
-0.0425897948,
-0.0205770209,
-0.0432653129,
0.0366113,
0.019056201,
-0.0155323418,
-0.0389720127,
0.026451664,
2.819e-7,
0.0311637595,
0.0227808785,
-0.006920313,
0.0633649528,
-0.0249273144,
0.034046974,
-0.0256749708,
0.0128791463,
0.0141025484,
-0.0292438082,
-0.0045232605,
0.0068688956,
0.0649660006,
0.0352299847,
-0.0307417791,
0.0479636081,
0.0027232324,
0.0107902009,
-0.0435619131,
-0.0241071116,
0.0428913534,
0.0862678885,
-0.0354929045,
-0.0319086052,
0.0353379697,
-0.0336376131,
0.010395959,
0.0018292582,
-0.0028641685,
0.0310607366,
-0.038410753,
0.0057486184,
-0.0027143052,
0.0193848368,
-0.0212689377,
-0.0052617369,
-0.0206263959,
0.0675153658,
-0.0023844824,
0.0390837267,
0.0358751304,
-0.0266254321,
0.0253518168,
-0.0718714297,
0.0315286741,
-0.0276907273,
0.0181168448,
0.0063260528,
-0.0164520387,
-0.0201389045,
-0.0184594411,
-0.0336274654,
0.0228391215,
0.016796438,
0.0060844989,
-0.0052554831,
-0.0007018985,
-0.0165380165,
-0.0474069454,
-0.0149824852,
-0.0089396508,
-0.0424940772,
-0.0059037292,
0.0262029171,
0.0046519716,
-0.0461099036,
0.0203724056,
2.810012128e-34,
0.0264102612,
-0.0226056129,
0.0288057644,
0.0324409157,
0.0659068972,
0.0019198452,
-0.0103971567,
0.0185106527,
0.0147081548,
0.0219566431,
-0.0392206013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08464v1 | Evaluating and Improving the Coreference Capabilities of Machine Translation Models | 2023-02-16T18:16:09 | 2023-02-16T18:16:09 | Asaf Yehudai, Arie Cattan, Omri Abend, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Machine translation (MT) requires a wide range of linguistic capabilities,
which current end-to-end models are expected to learn implicitly by observing
aligned sentences in bilingual corpora. In this work, we ask: \emph{How well do
MT models learn coreference resolution from implicit signal?} To answer this
question, we develop an evaluation methodology that derives coreference
clusters from MT output and evaluates them without requiring annotations in the
target language. We further evaluate several prominent open-source and
commercial MT systems, translating from English to six target languages, and
compare them to state-of-the-art coreference resolvers on three challenging
benchmarks. Our results show that the monolingual resolvers greatly outperform
MT models. Motivated by this result, we experiment with different methods for
incorporating the output of coreference resolution models in MT, showing
improvement over strong baselines. | [
0.0099358158,
-0.0009483622,
-0.0101950336,
0.0279161613,
-0.0237612966,
0.002111967,
0.0057934052,
-0.0217513405,
0.0425833501,
-0.020398166,
-0.0611821041,
0.0347363316,
0.0111663211,
-0.0503254235,
0.0206575785,
-0.038372416,
0.0212011877,
-0.0223384202,
-0.0100896442,
0.0040145754,
0.0238207523,
0.0266848039,
-0.012171709,
0.0133148069,
-0.0260151736,
-0.0116284629,
0.0079513909,
0.0133680701,
0.0693702772,
0.0211572517,
0.0005234052,
0.0452154614,
-0.0151745016,
0.0929129422,
0.0000018612,
-0.019525785,
-0.0382505804,
0.03607421,
0.0213430896,
0.014363871,
0.0063354555,
-0.0377173834,
-0.0054568499,
-0.0084745735,
-0.0237778015,
0.0239329133,
0.0471694879,
-0.0036012491,
0.0619558841,
0.0230626073,
-0.0190960001,
0.0120070186,
-0.0188986175,
-0.0597688034,
-0.1033123881,
-0.0808935389,
-0.0172640923,
0.0198711846,
-0.036471311,
0.0078783659,
0.0045634094,
0.0614700653,
0.0276029203,
0.0157721341,
-0.012121737,
0.0236242991,
-0.083082214,
-0.0296998341,
-0.0066377814,
0.0582939424,
0.0065061101,
0.0166698657,
-0.0035720943,
-0.0007161294,
-0.0299383868,
-0.0445568748,
-0.0388830863,
-0.0156613979,
-0.0088221645,
0.0004579634,
0.016516218,
0.0437422246,
-0.0073719271,
0.0068919379,
-0.0449605547,
0.0784198642,
0.0181572735,
0.0235445686,
0.0503917821,
0.0313742645,
-0.0290511604,
-0.0162017047,
0.0795917436,
-0.0271638837,
-0.0076402989,
0.0178527273,
-0.034772031,
0.0264494829,
-0.0109835137,
-0.0794447511,
0.0400962718,
0.0463555679,
-0.0380331948,
0.0252586342,
-0.0248220544,
0.0855870917,
-0.0551725961,
0.0536249094,
-0.0528451651,
-0.041140452,
-0.0296076015,
0.0442635305,
-0.0472345762,
0.0277076419,
-0.0465791486,
-0.0095771682,
-0.0439019278,
0.0007329476,
0.023401795,
-0.011521508,
-0.0009413085,
-0.0389128402,
-0.0821737275,
-0.0103333658,
0.0072376137,
0.0701277107,
-0.0129098371,
-0.0180733129,
-0.0245005004,
-0.0771606714,
-0.0066097388,
0.0212065987,
-0.0281535257,
-0.0671233311,
-0.0268807784,
0.0523042791,
-0.0368693992,
-0.0203618929,
0.0338964537,
-0.0370213427,
-0.0642153025,
-0.054982096,
-0.043526154,
-0.0757935792,
0.0373257287,
0.0324071534,
0.0245678127,
-0.0942930281,
0.0268262215,
-0.0075917756,
-0.0173684247,
0.0362492539,
0.0259051099,
-0.0124417068,
0.006555255,
-0.0202175565,
0.0109805604,
0.0571704805,
0.0160192586,
0.0444273017,
0.0328003764,
0.0409369543,
-0.0495858565,
0.0570896454,
0.0432364643,
0.0454831831,
-0.0043762475,
0.0023355556,
-0.0328039564,
-0.0089419819,
0.0172453485,
0.0623237081,
0.0267941877,
0.0086648231,
0.0387709066,
0.0500433147,
-0.0238557719,
-0.0061776484,
0.0100300554,
-0.0229500476,
0.006892174,
0.0536059774,
-0.04290241,
0.0186093468,
0.0028183581,
-0.0143379578,
0.0778384432,
0.0291249715,
-0.0187801775,
-0.0346881002,
-0.0290499069,
0.0172045194,
-0.0056788884,
-0.0239720996,
0.0606976673,
0.0062921084,
-0.0270202905,
0.0404974073,
-0.0239309687,
-0.0478158817,
0.0197781716,
0.0012145891,
-0.0663899854,
0.004908863,
0.0153121604,
0.020277366,
-0.0514334962,
0.0139901666,
0.0269223079,
0.0623081028,
0.0509143919,
-0.0092677781,
0.0610406697,
-0.035891097,
-0.0147811444,
0.0513756014,
0.0021198683,
0.0322453044,
0.0213869158,
0.0175290722,
0.0480979197,
-0.0532475226,
-0.0560159646,
0.003627178,
-0.0230282173,
0.0047384501,
0.0146830706,
0.030280387,
0.0319864154,
0.0551586114,
0.0055929385,
-0.0086882915,
0.0447785184,
-0.0289825965,
-0.0234226361,
0.055560898,
-0.0285670254,
-0.0033049774,
0.0277588554,
-0.0476358272,
-0.0091518089,
-0.044579491,
-0.0276909042,
-0.0290266685,
-0.0211587101,
-0.0395781659,
0.0069320137,
-0.0164769832,
0.019786356,
0.0325775407,
-0.0018329876,
-0.0275359582,
0.0139948744,
-0.0326598696,
0.0021577675,
0.0384588838,
-0.0257544667,
0.023060957,
-0.0753974393,
0.0088826427,
-0.0030984653,
-0.0074213725,
0.0070124133,
0.054335691,
0.0207912493,
-0.0237868074,
-0.0187690835,
-0.045944564,
0.0297998954,
-0.0233487729,
0.0277805161,
0.0400317684,
0.0205860455,
0.0304240249,
-0.0191550665,
0.008206103,
-0.0203599576,
0.035229519,
0.0133352233,
0.0092180287,
0.037500266,
-0.0084872236,
-0.0507838875,
-0.0025372847,
-0.007850429,
0.0120046241,
0.0000812431,
-0.0294970553,
-0.0128617063,
0.0099200699,
-0.0178803727,
0.0284393206,
0.012205448,
-0.0348732211,
0.0069333762,
-0.0122117475,
0.0116113694,
0.0609899871,
-0.0300223399,
0.0208425466,
-0.0124090929,
-0.0714553371,
-0.0664854124,
0.0174743477,
0.0018807985,
-0.0898676738,
-0.0297240112,
-0.0406854041,
0.0086686732,
0.0659223795,
0.0223782156,
-0.0013416955,
-0.0767889395,
0.0076675736,
-0.0297406279,
-0.0300383251,
0.0006217562,
0.0333755948,
-0.0094492333,
0.0638098195,
-0.0372932442,
-0.0528826416,
0.0594074391,
-0.0583073571,
-0.0087805251,
-0.0210471991,
0.0124900173,
-0.0446629487,
0.0410341807,
-0.0193441771,
0.0050280057,
0.0414810516,
-0.041531235,
-0.0304791257,
0.007748073,
0.0233468004,
-0.0052997405,
0.0523320474,
-0.0583732389,
0.0248434469,
-0.0071824556,
-0.0014488826,
-0.0407995023,
0.0766158998,
-0.034365721,
-0.0123289898,
-0.009534399,
0.0136606582,
-0.0238726418,
0.016535474,
0.017155407,
0.0334163643,
-0.0084706014,
0.0074366769,
-0.0283092745,
0.039319437,
-0.0190753452,
-0.0083975773,
-0.028041305,
-0.0578108206,
-0.0046107653,
0.0283535589,
0.005110696,
-0.0288278908,
-0.0232948624,
-0.027906511,
0.0372994542,
-0.0233747438,
-0.0345827527,
-0.005543638,
0.0558952428,
-0.0138698611,
-0.0381246582,
0.1042794958,
0.0439005196,
-0.0145521834,
-0.0059938701,
0.0039061359,
0.0119791804,
0.039456293,
-0.0108239092,
-0.0149380844,
-0.0199707802,
0.0176527034,
0.0253589395,
0.0456596017,
0.0077913683,
-0.0005546826,
-0.0982135385,
-0.0000425341,
0.0430356711,
-0.086238794,
-0.0583740324,
-0.0017394652,
0.0154532297,
-0.0648393631,
0.0061018784,
-0.0099887028,
0.0293704532,
0.0182000473,
-0.0146975787,
0.0279958118,
-0.0085276589,
0.0128951035,
-0.0685188174,
-0.0158173461,
0.0624803752,
0.0529794134,
0.0402475856,
0.0376438275,
0.0171438884,
-0.0544607937,
-0.0061898483,
-0.0332994424,
-0.0009546335,
-0.0003276001,
-0.0029715244,
0.0196323488,
0.0458022095,
0.002983964,
0.0275986027,
0.0248742979,
0.0266313981,
0.0162983965,
0.0517688394,
0.0079189604,
-0.001960428,
-0.0126944706,
0.0426541567,
0.0029661339,
0.0001659097,
0.0085950019,
-0.0161493532,
0.0099904686,
-0.0503271334,
-0.0623684824,
0.0139772063,
-0.043598216,
-0.0043585952,
-0.0692844689,
-0.061414957,
-0.0080313468,
0.0367954709,
0.0285445936,
-0.018617617,
-0.0008742971,
-0.0003659089,
-0.0265371334,
0.0305878837,
-0.0421651304,
0.0037792043,
-0.0931068882,
0.0397600271,
0.0317561179,
0.0348850377,
-0.0154328858,
0.1193172857,
-0.0749625936,
-0.0699177608,
-0.0305090174,
0.0358678512,
0.0167984758,
0.0438664593,
-0.0497449003,
-0.0067247818,
-0.0250727907,
0.0171678867,
-0.0444515944,
0.003796641,
0.0304365661,
-0.0156987626,
-0.019697722,
0.0633024275,
-0.0267148279,
0.0339305326,
-0.0096499398,
0.0512763634,
-0.0117918001,
-0.1135167181,
0.0251752343,
0.0250152908,
0.048274409,
-0.0228442959,
-0.0185102802,
0.0002296742,
0.0201664884,
-0.022687953,
-0.0262966622,
-0.0100561874,
0.0001482543,
0.0105885286,
-0.0041250791,
0.0125642437,
0.0335532874,
-0.0198017266,
0.0423654765,
0.0043222327,
-0.0287855919,
0.0024849204,
-0.0054375525,
-0.0132173374,
0.0160681903,
-0.000191761,
0.0331355482,
0.018676471,
0.0485097952,
-0.0531964116,
0.0273698643,
-0.0127692651,
0.0216889698,
0.0287674889,
0.0029323744,
-0.0173406675,
0.008329575,
-0.0661937147,
0.0017585473,
0.0727264509,
-0.0052369996,
0.1335380822,
-0.0023393463,
-0.0188684016,
-0.0253320765,
0.0447957739,
0.008683145,
0.0063316864,
-0.0200687088,
-0.019712599,
0.023586737,
0.0468104966,
0.0354941674,
-0.0182573162,
-0.0308447517,
0.0172264744,
-0.0215717983,
-0.031235056,
-0.0463119671,
-0.0347775742,
-0.0671321154,
0.0001695817,
0.0196809005,
-0.0367105864,
-0.035171099,
0.0523364469,
-0.0077894912,
0.0091644479,
-0.0008732976,
-0.010242926,
0.0582917519,
-0.0187452063,
-0.0079442123,
-0.0324518345,
0.0165328123,
0.0089995917,
-0.0421636179,
-0.0466613248,
-5.931289192e-33,
-0.097534135,
-0.0200059488,
-0.0385317057,
-0.0425309092,
0.0031934241,
0.0182566717,
-0.0443876348,
0.0127782701,
0.005503329,
-0.0011709753,
0.0062739584,
-0.0177421458,
0.0359027386,
-0.0098418556,
-0.0070704324,
0.0271993689,
0.0660733879,
0.0197964162,
-0.0416245908,
0.0047552562,
0.041649133,
0.0005872425,
0.0821941346,
-0.0716352388,
0.0430918597,
0.0123680346,
-0.0290613361,
0.023641713,
0.0246110093,
0.0472066216,
0.0128531484,
0.0121798599,
-0.0125075839,
-0.0361370891,
-0.0258108433,
-0.0450258292,
-0.133292228,
0.0211557765,
0.0459534414,
0.0720950067,
0.0079118405,
-0.0526310802,
0.0306471419,
-0.0509354435,
-0.0145379305,
-0.0194648523,
0.02740632,
-0.0314727984,
-0.0018317892,
0.0140351141,
-0.040023271,
0.0221531875,
-0.0288535859,
-0.0126295201,
0.0380347222,
0.0961387306,
0.0104040308,
-0.0069565144,
-0.0707249716,
0.0215578321,
-0.0019498807,
0.068856962,
0.0866073444,
-0.0093567921,
-0.0174366813,
-0.0174147394,
-0.0099962587,
-0.0366247781,
0.02352654,
0.011954884,
0.0485945754,
0.0142373974,
0.0340413935,
0.0888533741,
-0.0110551491,
0.0298563037,
-0.0195501428,
0.0405997932,
0.0034511639,
0.0066247522,
0.0295226462,
0.0218201373,
-0.0406453088,
-0.0060660811,
-0.0537493452,
-0.0899575055,
-0.0204859599,
-0.0604029372,
0.019690223,
0.0013432781,
-0.0413745418,
0.0184347592,
0.0886720419,
-0.0196314193,
-0.0070716948,
-0.0006120096,
-0.009288704,
0.0311129857,
-0.012895911,
0.0652909353,
-0.0354137868,
-0.0109946886,
0.0015651145,
0.0407639854,
0.0218972433,
-0.0307736248,
0.0259008668,
-0.0019525333,
-0.0373220406,
0.0034510875,
-0.042106621,
0.0073575852,
-0.0453597344,
0.0098653277,
0.0234518088,
-0.0072685503,
-0.0136419088,
0.0690919161,
0.0096680298,
0.0091815144,
-0.0393744372,
-0.0012449659,
0.0658538938,
0.0368065462,
-0.0205415022,
0.0255285092,
-0.0039130929,
-0.0157161262,
0.0086133117,
-0.0071096886,
-0.0439343154,
0.008274355,
2.398e-7,
0.0333871879,
0.0264758766,
0.0571135134,
0.0091087855,
-0.0057807467,
0.00890496,
-0.026116984,
0.0193159003,
0.0176908728,
-0.0228704046,
-0.0014858119,
0.0354514681,
0.051752612,
0.0436739698,
-0.0523490645,
-0.0133847399,
-0.0266989302,
0.0222520381,
-0.0363866203,
0.0129105914,
-0.012344162,
0.0783664212,
-0.0003924253,
0.0343225896,
-0.0347001888,
-0.0020996183,
0.0472759902,
0.0142994318,
-0.0090836743,
0.0364100784,
-0.0134852212,
0.0533770993,
-0.044734288,
0.0006350297,
-0.0020229595,
0.0113393795,
0.0657080114,
0.0828551203,
0.0043474687,
-0.046822574,
0.0002227309,
-0.0212377291,
0.0118896402,
-0.0238049943,
0.0427868813,
-0.0720865726,
-0.0146012744,
-0.0063916235,
-0.0184263792,
0.0400516838,
-0.0143589266,
-0.0045238049,
-0.0170928072,
0.0491323695,
0.0305029415,
0.0244503655,
-0.0316178724,
-0.0118520642,
-0.067358762,
-0.0061487802,
0.001166083,
-0.0233209264,
-0.0126856351,
-0.0292983335,
-0.0911275372,
-0.0064485511,
-0.0152943386,
1.946676042e-34,
0.0227138922,
0.0132993646,
0.0013728482,
0.0046745837,
0.0198416691,
-0.0413046144,
-0.0449400246,
-0.0125521729,
0.0109485015,
0.0067830472,
-0.007352103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10914v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10914v1 | GLUECons: A Generic Benchmark for Learning Under Constraints | 2023-02-16T16:45:36 | 2023-02-16T16:45:36 | Hossein Rajaby Faghihi, Aliakbar Nafar, Chen Zheng, Roshanak Mirzaee, Yue Zhang, Andrzej Uszok, Alexander Wan, Tanawan Premsri, Dan Roth, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent research has shown that integrating domain knowledge into deep
learning architectures is effective -- it helps reduce the amount of required
data, improves the accuracy of the models' decisions, and improves the
interpretability of models. However, the research community is missing a
convened benchmark for systematically evaluating knowledge integration methods.
In this work, we create a benchmark that is a collection of nine tasks in the
domains of natural language processing and computer vision. In all cases, we
model external knowledge as constraints, specify the sources of the constraints
for each task, and implement various models that use these constraints. We
report the results of these models using a new set of extended evaluation
criteria in addition to the task performances for a more in-depth analysis.
This effort provides a framework for a more comprehensive and systematic
comparison of constraint integration techniques and for identifying related
research challenges. It will facilitate further research for alleviating some
problems of state-of-the-art neural models. | [
0.0460412875,
0.0879945084,
0.0143793691,
0.0269297604,
-0.0424679816,
-0.0140520334,
-0.0070039253,
-0.0292497966,
0.0220457315,
-0.047751084,
-0.0098476158,
-0.0186174605,
0.0054334067,
0.0639046878,
-0.0089038415,
-0.0390921533,
0.0279194731,
-0.018128559,
-0.015075705,
0.0288239773,
-0.01643667,
-0.0091772769,
0.0014240715,
0.0344487913,
-0.0674567148,
-0.0113597717,
0.0136761945,
0.0234149322,
0.0475751646,
0.0246630367,
0.0248205233,
0.0308563001,
0.0371610783,
0.0350815207,
0.000001949,
-0.0679407194,
-0.0250516683,
-0.0048046419,
-0.0324714445,
0.0062410845,
-0.0041974355,
-0.0766785443,
0.0066654985,
-0.0251506995,
-0.0359562933,
0.0052011823,
0.0603065081,
0.0731946155,
0.0693585947,
0.0550230555,
-0.0140858293,
0.0092478925,
0.0427473783,
-0.0304170568,
-0.0110957865,
-0.039756123,
0.0507417545,
0.0014932451,
-0.0065780613,
-0.0526846871,
-0.0157746207,
0.0511881225,
0.0532365143,
-0.0032574281,
0.0195601359,
0.0159127768,
-0.0650367662,
-0.0246577617,
-0.0457334667,
0.0693366006,
-0.0047293077,
0.0031271884,
-0.0142685948,
-0.0360570177,
0.0071838791,
0.0400413908,
-0.039730832,
-0.0243629403,
0.0303440373,
0.014994218,
-0.044121746,
0.0831920058,
0.0279579796,
0.0309082065,
-0.008468695,
0.0353375897,
-0.0094420612,
-0.0230983291,
0.0468328781,
0.0083095171,
-0.0394826792,
-0.0177099016,
-0.0091445921,
0.0143483989,
0.0134911425,
0.0114076827,
-0.0449874215,
0.0059481426,
0.0021078323,
-0.0227158871,
0.000020519,
0.0087763444,
-0.0268650874,
0.0954286903,
-0.0455310568,
0.1015658304,
-0.0551507846,
0.0045123682,
-0.0168714654,
-0.0124664195,
-0.0701785088,
-0.0286195613,
0.001259199,
0.0294340625,
-0.0303702578,
-0.0567364246,
-0.0136132501,
-0.0054245852,
-0.0390265025,
0.0409457199,
-0.0027458784,
0.0349706225,
-0.0276900455,
-0.0232418682,
-0.0563375875,
0.0150615918,
-0.0206411369,
0.0059473072,
-0.0171320792,
-0.0201844126,
-0.0103973122,
0.0055805575,
-0.0099275066,
-0.0400638357,
-0.007760413,
0.0606975667,
0.0220224969,
-0.0196271241,
-0.005894172,
-0.0501273684,
-0.0423934944,
-0.0840916783,
0.0241563469,
-0.0439626314,
0.0237192418,
-0.0487337597,
-0.008359829,
-0.0870881081,
0.0256674457,
-0.0169884283,
-0.0255584903,
0.1046003774,
0.027963968,
-0.0492544994,
-0.0116010951,
0.0582350791,
0.0137347383,
0.0999989212,
-0.0101614268,
0.0112424595,
-0.0111823007,
0.0439183898,
-0.0035978451,
0.0210250001,
0.0225954875,
-0.0223621428,
-0.0320968851,
0.0063706506,
0.0222942177,
0.0142394342,
-0.0025068605,
0.0430372953,
-0.0110198073,
-0.0285052098,
0.0535792895,
0.0265966915,
0.0070910724,
-0.0219388343,
0.0100630224,
-0.018785201,
0.018225193,
0.0193861276,
-0.0800914243,
0.0168165043,
0.0305445679,
0.0066480609,
-0.0150688784,
0.0333676524,
-0.0143188024,
-0.0637537464,
0.005668561,
-0.0377309099,
-0.0049826265,
-0.0023698641,
0.0718530044,
0.0030633954,
-0.0134518333,
0.0246034302,
0.000778739,
0.0147781642,
0.0059624151,
0.0083881291,
-0.0539103411,
0.0391557664,
0.0296836384,
-0.0716017187,
-0.0530891232,
-0.0014874587,
0.0232515074,
0.0804975182,
0.0489415936,
0.0082402797,
0.0331451148,
-0.0422261953,
-0.0534288436,
-0.0155211519,
0.0143979406,
0.0204454754,
0.0408915132,
0.0009518574,
0.0440924428,
-0.0012531306,
-0.0021068177,
0.0512153879,
-0.0111567499,
-0.0517562106,
-0.0250305627,
0.0143703157,
0.0037400329,
0.0339126065,
-0.0016638072,
-0.0034247101,
0.0292595811,
-0.0449534133,
-0.0382058956,
0.0174932946,
-0.0796433464,
-0.005064446,
0.036045976,
-0.0690128952,
-0.0147971669,
0.0296679493,
-0.0371959396,
-0.0480330177,
0.008906818,
0.0080746226,
0.0436801054,
-0.0321205072,
-0.0375604033,
0.0255860947,
-0.0094415369,
-0.0182901956,
0.0974185318,
-0.0075286855,
-0.0195532646,
0.0306477416,
-0.0552502982,
0.0133911846,
-0.0162400845,
-0.0216767862,
-0.0273277555,
-0.0099219615,
0.0276345666,
0.0127903624,
-0.0100234002,
-0.0463863723,
0.0238295831,
-0.0104231844,
0.0019833667,
0.0110847251,
-0.0130885644,
-0.0163910519,
0.0000346428,
0.0144867571,
-0.019655589,
-0.0303131938,
-0.044443965,
-0.0250997338,
0.0099490201,
0.0307625216,
0.0686619356,
-0.0039351797,
-0.0183590595,
0.0032751192,
-0.0153391417,
0.0568670742,
-0.0002685463,
-0.0232935511,
-0.0071014478,
0.0218780227,
-0.0288694575,
0.0599190556,
-0.0329320803,
-0.0009271855,
-0.0053252196,
-0.0059074736,
0.0162970889,
0.0377386026,
-0.0579756424,
0.0059517063,
0.0440142378,
-0.0280813444,
-0.0449683405,
0.0226911698,
-0.0065307105,
0.0270518269,
-0.0047864672,
0.035151016,
-0.0132006388,
0.050878115,
-0.0288765151,
-0.0306063388,
-0.0543334,
0.0619148836,
-0.0261647403,
-0.0527341329,
-0.0361043178,
-0.0377271809,
0.0064904327,
0.0353670903,
-0.0484143868,
-0.0431977361,
0.0717294067,
-0.0305577647,
0.0020025666,
0.0225163065,
-0.0235052854,
-0.0433570184,
0.0631070808,
0.0245050825,
0.0166917406,
0.0471117012,
-0.0012163313,
-0.0750615448,
0.0014387595,
0.0224828441,
0.0064311232,
0.0690292716,
-0.0413277186,
0.0345296524,
-0.015090676,
-0.0168555323,
-0.0758721977,
-0.0107913921,
-0.0127602937,
0.0269794725,
-0.0015301785,
-0.0291563999,
-0.0323338769,
0.0202601384,
-0.0187194888,
0.0359896533,
0.0053901388,
-0.0156832784,
-0.0326930285,
0.016914716,
0.0652387738,
0.0375289284,
-0.0028564993,
0.0211591423,
0.0019172744,
0.028748516,
0.0172340255,
-0.000779164,
-0.0570995733,
0.0105127301,
-0.0232753642,
-0.0320043936,
0.0178539865,
-0.0005695581,
0.0155980876,
-0.0820347518,
0.0025803316,
0.0826400816,
0.0281657409,
-0.0144533645,
-0.029745711,
0.0102360668,
0.0087995334,
0.0428266041,
0.0052705379,
-0.0497307777,
-0.0545338094,
0.0069250055,
-0.0074935304,
0.0154547459,
-0.0350649171,
-0.0117960647,
-0.0881706402,
-0.007178816,
0.0102319801,
-0.0324066952,
-0.054003261,
-0.0143702002,
-0.0032518185,
-0.02812187,
-0.0213978142,
-0.0634441972,
0.005169089,
-0.0476641133,
-0.0225390531,
-0.0256945398,
-0.0549010113,
0.0072006439,
-0.0537215099,
0.0463681705,
0.0500803404,
0.000058154,
0.0153123103,
-0.0157281626,
0.0265628062,
0.0021857433,
-0.0100057069,
0.0032989995,
0.0336339809,
-0.0058836672,
-0.0045775175,
0.0263488796,
0.0305456147,
-0.0510471649,
-0.0182410572,
-0.034050297,
0.0922169834,
0.0332709365,
0.0208477043,
-0.0468020365,
-0.0193772539,
0.0000784895,
0.091940172,
0.0157727692,
-0.0224934369,
-0.0194807053,
-0.0299920067,
-0.0119162295,
-0.0504841357,
-0.0302929766,
0.0474508107,
-0.0006771424,
0.0052628904,
-0.0618792847,
-0.044460021,
0.0116340453,
0.0396734141,
0.0106094852,
-0.0079250438,
0.0295562558,
0.0035927917,
-0.0650474131,
0.0342016816,
-0.0338326171,
0.0035615165,
0.0010212655,
0.0338462032,
0.0014432035,
-0.0182282403,
-0.0345158018,
0.0680178553,
-0.0329439119,
-0.0463854708,
-0.0401393399,
0.0294285677,
0.0235821605,
0.0447174646,
-0.0374178551,
-0.0048006321,
-0.0155143412,
0.0562235862,
-0.0098949093,
-0.0410080031,
0.0346180312,
-0.04986348,
-0.0083959131,
0.0219052155,
-0.0687434599,
0.0147659024,
0.0030103547,
0.0161414966,
-0.0374982506,
-0.0304604005,
0.0404527411,
-0.0377430618,
0.0153049808,
-0.0222032387,
-0.0487097427,
-0.0028054449,
0.0161168575,
-0.0075297127,
-0.0233473089,
-0.0550858341,
-0.0185620971,
0.0557818338,
0.0269160941,
0.0228988472,
0.0037813406,
0.0447939858,
0.0159917399,
-0.0113546448,
-0.0390958525,
0.0764112398,
-0.0169116277,
0.0250748433,
0.0041254302,
-0.00710832,
0.0643263683,
-0.013934277,
0.0236810055,
-0.017325446,
-0.0032307249,
0.0420218781,
0.037243221,
0.0059006535,
-0.0078691784,
-0.0608018152,
-0.0063550333,
-0.0243739542,
-0.0154843479,
0.0369774736,
-0.0371050425,
0.0232759211,
-0.0136821298,
-0.009064951,
-0.0057120277,
0.0010958434,
0.0144994771,
0.0093994532,
0.0359760746,
0.0501653366,
0.0219970252,
0.0255301148,
0.0698318034,
0.0575119257,
0.0673610196,
-0.0167354587,
-0.0075051724,
-0.0592012405,
-0.0270372983,
0.0279611032,
0.0068890923,
-0.0250557624,
0.0170344692,
-0.0606410839,
-0.0750554129,
0.0255892631,
0.0087953843,
0.0116821593,
0.0557059646,
0.0227294769,
-0.0009199874,
0.0048804656,
-0.0309824403,
0.0329108611,
-0.0401823632,
-0.0326294415,
-0.0102392118,
0.0276227854,
-6.116951177e-33,
-0.0342416912,
-0.0341287181,
0.0113329152,
0.0037471913,
-0.0031693801,
0.0368846059,
0.011047665,
-0.0510274731,
-0.000525299,
-0.0179071072,
0.0231338162,
-0.0093516158,
0.0053456537,
0.0230689254,
-0.0105431685,
-0.022276666,
0.030199429,
0.0153404558,
-0.0034569481,
-0.0262163486,
0.0208001062,
0.0358836651,
0.0230196398,
-0.0231584329,
0.023581095,
0.0306868665,
-0.0116871987,
0.0522113629,
0.0226224232,
0.0748614594,
-0.038115114,
0.0142107587,
0.0404955,
-0.0583900139,
-0.0126834828,
0.041904442,
-0.1047355533,
-0.0289542712,
0.0141496621,
-0.0001139127,
-0.0387454405,
-0.0123407757,
0.0358664468,
0.0049787974,
0.0624803342,
-0.0529651605,
0.0390071273,
-0.0356907547,
-0.0104247658,
-0.0414666086,
-0.0834064335,
0.0137269329,
-0.0197559819,
-0.0250577051,
0.0856945515,
0.018898068,
0.0316720791,
-0.0051663746,
-0.0507704765,
-0.0047725728,
0.0093958518,
0.0574491806,
0.0635390282,
0.0238745101,
-0.0352121629,
0.0651621893,
-0.0685684755,
-0.0773276836,
-0.0360400341,
-0.0028387962,
0.0442715473,
0.0829752386,
0.0457022898,
0.060156282,
0.0298299603,
0.0263513308,
-0.0816794932,
0.0214259103,
-0.0214006286,
0.0384837836,
-0.0225078501,
0.0248855427,
-0.0442472696,
0.010334718,
-0.0264780503,
0.0147887953,
-0.0434740782,
0.0140292989,
0.0572662428,
0.0551343597,
-0.0385938361,
0.0742861032,
0.0252083465,
-0.0614310056,
0.0318965353,
0.0387819521,
0.0431311093,
0.0175646674,
0.0030077293,
0.0221782699,
-0.0967308357,
-0.0137842307,
0.0342659689,
0.0218102168,
0.0418044999,
-0.0345040895,
0.0661681518,
0.0105892066,
-0.0332058929,
-0.0055408329,
-0.030603407,
0.0463001765,
0.001753278,
0.0185582619,
0.0441485532,
-0.0026163456,
-0.0282534231,
0.0030795338,
0.0149580184,
-0.0048848563,
0.0054942877,
0.0454604737,
0.0367176495,
0.0111929383,
-0.0078214575,
-0.0212142076,
0.0038880352,
-0.018845195,
0.0230787862,
-0.0468933843,
-0.0109254699,
0.0100628566,
2.597e-7,
0.0275800545,
0.0318496972,
0.0234897397,
0.0244973693,
0.0225473158,
0.0355306752,
-0.0161774699,
0.0133635988,
-0.0660359785,
-0.0660607219,
0.0206921026,
0.0558041111,
0.0396163575,
0.0187711865,
-0.0635182783,
0.0002813693,
0.0154456189,
-0.0326279141,
-0.0394347757,
-0.0185043402,
0.0668043718,
0.0536493249,
0.0071251988,
-0.0178178176,
-0.0116842045,
-0.091335915,
0.0426528938,
-0.0172642171,
0.0144285504,
0.0003445997,
0.0244509485,
0.0475754514,
-0.0525893979,
0.0841945335,
0.0045848065,
0.0365571119,
0.0540357083,
0.0451552793,
0.0146920178,
-0.0293969568,
-0.0313783288,
0.0190656353,
0.0051521948,
-0.017884586,
0.0645770058,
-0.0518162362,
0.0123756817,
-0.0094282823,
-0.0121095972,
-0.0216012206,
0.0201889426,
0.0460281819,
0.0109050795,
-0.0179946963,
0.0205106512,
-0.0147461938,
-0.0298885722,
-0.086266309,
0.0026374413,
0.0215105861,
-0.0197772197,
0.0053806244,
-0.0466031097,
-0.0190066658,
0.0442727432,
-0.0559697635,
-0.0377769917,
2.367056929e-34,
0.0150413699,
-0.0013271755,
0.0197426751,
0.0074974392,
-0.0112151001,
-0.0064135031,
-0.112911284,
0.000276573,
-0.0024475511,
-0.064053908,
0.0069603752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09301v1 | Exploring the Representation Manifolds of Stable Diffusion Through the Lens of Intrinsic Dimension | 2023-02-16T16:22:30 | 2023-02-16T16:22:30 | Henry Kvinge, Davis Brown, Charles Godfrey | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Prompting has become an important mechanism by which users can more
effectively interact with many flavors of foundation model. Indeed, the last
several years have shown that well-honed prompts can sometimes unlock emergent
capabilities within such models. While there has been a substantial amount of
empirical exploration of prompting within the community, relatively few works
have studied prompting at a mathematical level. In this work we aim to take a
first step towards understanding basic geometric properties induced by prompts
in Stable Diffusion, focusing on the intrinsic dimension of internal
representations within the model. We find that choice of prompt has a
substantial impact on the intrinsic dimension of representations at both layers
of the model which we explored, but that the nature of this impact depends on
the layer being considered. For example, in certain bottleneck layers of the
model, intrinsic dimension of representations is correlated with prompt
perplexity (measured using a surrogate model), while this correlation is not
apparent in the latent layers. Our evidence suggests that intrinsic dimension
could be a useful tool for future studies of the impact of different prompts on
text-to-image models. | [
-0.0350591615,
-0.0048797484,
-0.0276611298,
0.0180359855,
-0.0216058213,
0.0027874669,
0.0212269332,
0.015846014,
-0.0084443437,
0.0504369698,
-0.0163531862,
-0.0831575692,
0.0152376341,
0.0712637231,
0.0101402616,
-0.0874107182,
-0.0079282308,
-0.0362541601,
-0.0369057134,
-0.0328994282,
-0.0081231846,
-0.0448883139,
-0.0090104584,
0.0143339382,
0.0049010976,
-0.0347470008,
-0.0285460427,
-0.0063919909,
-0.0163008124,
-0.0615330637,
-0.080821,
0.0634668916,
0.0419599526,
-0.0074648564,
0.0000023807,
-0.0513055138,
0.0247414,
0.0034128777,
-0.031709563,
0.0316713303,
0.0442521535,
-0.004731257,
0.0058067022,
-0.0459081642,
-0.0174653344,
0.041229073,
0.0405300371,
0.033620134,
0.0074409535,
0.0036173016,
-0.0092378063,
-0.0187715311,
0.0305738747,
-0.0074235252,
0.0417428054,
0.0021134599,
0.0026033125,
0.0057498333,
0.0065120938,
0.0463392213,
-0.0546404831,
-0.0084164096,
0.0291028712,
0.0136956675,
0.0648601577,
0.0311834682,
0.0825496241,
-0.0632251948,
-0.0164640564,
0.0742704496,
0.0743238181,
0.0256128963,
0.0041797822,
-0.017792711,
0.0027659296,
0.1399340332,
-0.0876788348,
-0.0381612815,
-0.0007906575,
-0.0265991185,
-0.0415711738,
0.0195187349,
0.0194702074,
-0.0074706851,
0.0045331004,
0.0082193688,
0.0227417443,
-0.0056496123,
-0.0430176109,
0.0059712017,
0.0180177297,
-0.0533151478,
-0.0066230423,
0.0039202152,
0.0432182997,
-0.0140967099,
0.0414523073,
-0.0006318175,
0.0033273699,
-0.0425983593,
0.0928337574,
0.0104458844,
0.0009468325,
0.0463325195,
0.0113703404,
0.0141214216,
-0.0733845532,
0.0340979882,
0.0007117693,
0.1253508329,
-0.0090807686,
0.0053722872,
-0.0127262669,
0.0098532615,
-0.0170853175,
-0.0647884011,
0.0115163643,
0.0488724597,
0.0185458735,
-0.0095947953,
-0.0321694799,
0.0006060783,
-0.0100525301,
0.0004200971,
-0.0612034537,
0.0063339481,
-0.0699442625,
-0.0180111881,
0.0107341828,
-0.0049229176,
-0.0044602519,
-0.0399231799,
0.0215998739,
-0.0170302596,
-0.0134069044,
0.041388087,
0.0363467485,
0.0134273032,
-0.0107889948,
-0.0313818865,
0.0037252263,
-0.0067099095,
0.0215294752,
-0.0289626047,
-0.0049551423,
0.0360423885,
0.0033340678,
-0.0351524949,
-0.0381095707,
-0.0021215444,
-0.0159283374,
0.0448835641,
0.0050204047,
0.0069295126,
0.0486961864,
0.0147755537,
-0.0631243736,
0.0289144404,
-0.0195675045,
0.0394043289,
0.0344187953,
-0.0452084169,
0.0269767568,
0.0070388997,
0.0169693138,
0.0481615812,
0.0113870827,
0.0031154121,
0.0071097519,
0.0130831832,
0.021740865,
0.0277751591,
-0.0675621778,
0.0027727159,
0.0782003179,
0.099192895,
0.0157808699,
0.0147778522,
0.0149118137,
0.0030536489,
-0.0113663618,
0.0565973446,
-0.0432316661,
0.0529011711,
0.0423038416,
0.0274717491,
0.0307006352,
0.0031171138,
-0.049291186,
-0.0408445075,
0.0032960705,
0.0227043778,
0.0098097632,
-0.0265144333,
0.0334000774,
0.0182636194,
0.0061589261,
0.0017476476,
-0.0302982107,
-0.03554786,
-0.029470861,
-0.0222370774,
0.0627956763,
0.0288862791,
0.006647672,
0.0194576271,
0.0445572957,
-0.0178915896,
0.0286175013,
0.0143909091,
0.0417927578,
0.0065737786,
-0.0396851934,
0.0038741925,
-0.0122379828,
-0.024915386,
0.020219598,
0.0205715988,
-0.0452704057,
0.0011587066,
-0.0223411135,
-0.0158042274,
0.0122969123,
-0.0049024187,
-0.0367035307,
-0.0191301201,
-0.0697146356,
0.0233502369,
0.0026030461,
0.0199447367,
0.005102817,
0.0315919258,
0.0054408209,
0.0286124423,
-0.01255529,
0.0054803244,
-0.0315818489,
0.0717600584,
0.0139569901,
-0.0141629782,
0.0498400591,
-0.0602516159,
0.0385780632,
0.0014703143,
0.0920278803,
0.0051279278,
0.0496323705,
0.0074966769,
0.0088905105,
-0.0244914982,
-0.0005695075,
-0.0017415013,
0.056250371,
-0.0097324261,
0.0131401271,
0.0465996675,
0.0443513133,
0.0266863424,
-0.0168459807,
0.0364817046,
-0.0293119736,
0.0013676767,
0.0225819871,
0.0229294915,
-0.0425669812,
-0.0497374013,
0.0198741369,
-0.0226855148,
-0.0608126484,
0.003549167,
0.0309322737,
0.0345588885,
-0.0105409501,
-0.0214243513,
0.0202853903,
-0.0078594824,
-0.0127227493,
0.0079526585,
0.0316851474,
0.0243816022,
0.0018311855,
-0.0378787555,
-0.021025259,
-0.0243250802,
0.0069015734,
0.0373487659,
0.0430665873,
-0.0071845818,
-0.0053489357,
0.0155049469,
-0.0062948652,
-0.0226719752,
-0.025134474,
0.0274643507,
0.0364769921,
-0.0289117843,
0.0340291746,
0.027396759,
-0.0103163412,
0.0854113251,
-0.0271803122,
-0.0279078428,
-0.0224818029,
-0.0182756931,
-0.0598925985,
0.0312743708,
-0.0007849408,
-0.0457232445,
0.0269150585,
0.0767236575,
-0.013084203,
-0.0092584575,
-0.0415994264,
0.0584486313,
-0.0274120513,
0.0035510906,
-0.0247029234,
-0.0040061432,
-0.0207020864,
0.0875080973,
-0.0376675539,
-0.0617060736,
0.0443646125,
-0.0285843275,
0.0221540704,
0.0130604245,
0.0238597598,
-0.0291084144,
0.0498376153,
-0.0282392371,
0.0102447672,
0.0414325185,
-0.0113426102,
-0.028241735,
-0.0147208599,
0.0412442945,
-0.0133247497,
0.0145385414,
-0.0210579131,
-0.0211247317,
0.0112351431,
-0.0201524757,
0.0062100203,
-0.0573838837,
0.0262792073,
-0.0187457111,
-0.0079132672,
-0.0338297486,
0.0483896323,
-0.0086362334,
0.0288742799,
-0.0086203571,
-0.0279493481,
-0.0381307639,
-0.0004809148,
0.0104327947,
0.006756708,
0.052531153,
0.033158876,
-0.1080697402,
0.0538951792,
0.0216366183,
0.0135855787,
-0.0000523732,
-0.0186089966,
0.020110419,
-0.0002569623,
0.046468012,
-0.0719309449,
0.0734237283,
0.0691605806,
-0.0040726052,
-0.0060598957,
0.0305472687,
0.0007996467,
-0.0285670664,
0.0091045713,
-0.0710493922,
0.0587768145,
0.0338497683,
-0.0125269406,
-0.0277450569,
0.0319973566,
0.0029419451,
-0.0158305876,
0.0041035581,
-0.0271516014,
0.0251621846,
-0.0664669946,
0.0566340722,
0.0038733012,
-0.015076641,
0.0528239273,
-0.0236998405,
0.012752967,
0.078739807,
-0.0379028693,
-0.0187977999,
-0.0421184115,
0.0271234978,
0.0106572546,
0.0178965461,
-0.0349760875,
-0.0330030918,
-0.0229538251,
-0.0318450592,
0.0074179587,
-0.0148484493,
-0.0168918185,
-0.0996740162,
0.0157575868,
0.047436446,
0.0456776284,
0.0048457952,
0.053034462,
0.0564438105,
0.025156986,
-0.0399559401,
0.0160717741,
-0.0107477866,
-0.0257316865,
-0.0390626341,
0.0787722617,
0.0063596531,
-0.0244564153,
-0.04845367,
-0.0393805839,
-0.0151719525,
0.0165459253,
0.0658694357,
-0.0423675776,
-0.0198104568,
-0.0553538762,
0.0624248944,
0.0475324355,
-0.0712507442,
-0.0024107902,
0.0425937846,
-0.0275009796,
-0.0477553867,
0.0068499725,
-0.0574065447,
0.0743862018,
0.0174604338,
-0.0215310249,
-0.0355752334,
-0.0232897829,
0.0043689697,
0.0610562377,
0.0040531149,
0.0340874419,
-0.0565271825,
0.0367282853,
-0.0336108804,
-0.0727717951,
-0.0282022487,
-0.0204317588,
-0.0395613275,
-0.0313398056,
-0.0163672175,
0.0251954999,
0.044887349,
-0.0320368074,
0.0061422945,
-0.0365283079,
0.0217398144,
-0.0375816412,
-0.024753971,
0.0174953118,
0.0167230517,
-0.0043218657,
-0.0136962049,
-0.0081646526,
0.0020701608,
-0.0158416294,
0.0073052053,
0.0139615331,
0.0120342532,
0.0108995773,
0.0008798314,
0.0038408558,
0.0586620644,
0.0351584069,
0.0061010169,
-0.0055183065,
-0.0124323359,
-0.0103494013,
-0.0028784284,
-0.0256354995,
-0.0266342796,
0.0255405307,
0.0038454849,
0.0027420854,
-0.0229931716,
0.0071143312,
0.0401070826,
-0.0426734537,
0.0058908104,
0.0111642983,
0.0224048905,
0.033828564,
0.0220674258,
-0.0231053345,
0.017731823,
-0.0603246838,
0.0450625382,
0.0361448973,
0.0623600744,
-0.0038062164,
0.000911561,
-0.0172342062,
0.0148325171,
-0.080637604,
-0.1059524715,
0.0032895,
0.0289313924,
0.0165510681,
-0.0082415491,
-0.0100001032,
-0.0095172832,
0.0086266538,
-0.0198974703,
-0.0142388744,
0.0315046534,
-0.0616372377,
0.0318602622,
0.024393186,
0.0308277179,
-0.0323160179,
0.0222764798,
-0.0575240664,
0.0017458213,
-0.073539637,
-0.0153174223,
-0.004438078,
0.024074167,
0.0206470434,
0.0556996986,
0.0090484265,
-0.0044388254,
-0.1323746443,
-0.0556220748,
-0.0025109835,
0.0116066523,
-0.0310018808,
-0.0299899448,
0.0431909785,
0.0677963495,
-0.0208668169,
-0.010772326,
0.0138837062,
0.0391869955,
-0.080278635,
0.0082924459,
-0.0104433848,
-6.478047981e-33,
0.0076177889,
-0.0100393174,
-0.0058547915,
0.0053496184,
-0.015299256,
-0.0087103071,
-0.024292957,
0.0478058122,
-0.002192684,
0.0133353528,
-0.044357013,
-0.0311559513,
-0.0006311325,
-0.0032753171,
0.0141646434,
0.0009444695,
0.0131729692,
-0.0104270447,
-0.0650254115,
0.0183156691,
-0.0120951906,
-0.0147477202,
-0.0185553785,
-0.0646722764,
0.0484382249,
-0.0039158119,
0.0292375479,
-0.023056386,
0.0219280683,
0.0615969487,
-0.0427619219,
-0.003018311,
0.0208134502,
-0.072006017,
-0.0592625439,
0.045572456,
-0.0265936013,
-0.0290174261,
0.0225499421,
-0.0230604634,
-0.0757980272,
-0.0311533827,
0.0004301073,
-0.024215471,
-0.0534231476,
-0.0296248924,
0.0478174388,
-0.0243643876,
-0.0162301883,
0.0456122644,
-0.0425208397,
0.0043978486,
-0.0122843515,
0.0253976602,
0.0239479002,
0.0169240795,
-0.0034486365,
0.0008391271,
-0.0177879464,
0.0416773632,
0.0013018596,
-0.0065294695,
0.0372260325,
0.0419119783,
0.0359382555,
0.0531255491,
0.0269007012,
0.0378438085,
-0.0281981938,
-0.0377215333,
0.0089083333,
0.0715781525,
0.033078827,
0.0341052897,
0.0411935747,
0.0206427779,
-0.0076360926,
0.0253025778,
-0.0132543324,
-0.0030150455,
0.0249952637,
-0.0103809303,
-0.0569506027,
-0.0229805727,
-0.0269464813,
-0.0230101664,
-0.0260006338,
-0.0579254664,
0.0247164462,
-0.0200436339,
0.0242729299,
-0.0206407271,
0.0192589648,
-0.0186408032,
-0.0878813639,
-0.0267534591,
0.0007460099,
0.0755647421,
0.0129529759,
-0.0181899294,
-0.0257584471,
-0.0293018594,
-0.0673598424,
0.064072378,
0.0258158818,
0.0219451617,
-0.0345675349,
0.0127008921,
-0.0184734091,
-0.0276682191,
-0.0063866796,
-0.0401851498,
0.050947316,
0.0091254367,
0.0551275387,
-0.0404636413,
-0.018238375,
0.0285433475,
-0.0058287489,
0.0265936311,
-0.017517833,
-0.0103578381,
-0.0566474535,
0.0319477841,
-0.0068291896,
-0.0427093953,
-0.0551579818,
0.033346463,
0.0866722241,
-0.1015879363,
-0.0400558189,
-0.0146610532,
3.065e-7,
0.0165801644,
0.0356018059,
0.0370313711,
0.01868104,
0.0513802618,
0.0271462575,
-0.0485704392,
0.0092660915,
0.0099436929,
-0.0882325098,
-0.0044784821,
0.032123819,
0.0136202229,
0.0060619647,
-0.0502417833,
-0.0217949487,
-0.0175244268,
0.0567544326,
-0.0255992655,
0.0141025586,
0.0147628197,
-0.0131104896,
-0.016588401,
0.0023933188,
0.0002758186,
-0.0193701852,
0.0602702424,
-0.0410605893,
0.0850904286,
-0.0053925798,
-0.0471626632,
-0.0434364639,
-0.0159568321,
-0.0055224709,
-0.0074018072,
0.015016811,
0.0178833008,
-0.007602083,
0.0107408734,
0.0329865143,
0.0017474289,
-0.0422231033,
0.0162801314,
-0.0796613172,
0.0463442244,
-0.0524022542,
-0.0394284353,
-0.0013583809,
-0.021245243,
-0.0337772481,
0.0582850352,
0.020097807,
-0.0345338099,
-0.0303974058,
0.0162038077,
-0.0295187682,
0.007374431,
-0.0420682952,
-0.0091494964,
-0.0107204719,
-0.0149027351,
-0.0679200515,
-0.0845590979,
0.0126352878,
0.0132651916,
-0.0071569844,
-0.0348811224,
3.064153777e-34,
0.0590247586,
-0.0116152791,
0.0779437944,
-0.0028969888,
0.0169322789,
-0.0438603312,
0.0459109135,
0.0030626478,
0.0704105273,
-0.0980346501,
-0.0301038008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10144v1 | Stabilising and accelerating light gated recurrent units for automatic speech recognition | 2023-02-16T16:18:58 | 2023-02-16T16:18:58 | Adel Moumen, Titouan Parcollet | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | The light gated recurrent units (Li-GRU) is well-known for achieving
impressive results in automatic speech recognition (ASR) tasks while being
lighter and faster to train than a standard gated recurrent units (GRU).
However, the unbounded nature of its rectified linear unit on the candidate
recurrent gate induces an important gradient exploding phenomenon disrupting
the training process and preventing it from being applied to famous datasets.
In this paper, we theoretically and empirically derive the necessary conditions
for its stability as well as engineering mechanisms to speed up by a factor of
five its training time, hence introducing a novel version of this architecture
named SLi-GRU. Then, we evaluate its performance both on a toy task
illustrating its newly acquired capabilities and a set of three different ASR
datasets demonstrating lower word error rates compared to more complex
recurrent neural networks. | [
-0.0168662556,
0.0357959047,
0.0007816209,
0.0713634714,
-0.0441392139,
-0.0028389692,
0.070587799,
-0.0260585062,
-0.0122420797,
0.0172513574,
-0.0117091695,
-0.0679413676,
0.012523287,
0.0607251748,
0.0195316058,
0.0126007413,
0.0447044857,
-0.0274454299,
-0.0170094613,
-0.0362612009,
0.0105200037,
-0.0418928862,
-0.0254084803,
0.0075789536,
0.017574219,
0.0165085401,
0.0091747502,
-0.0144972512,
-0.0173425525,
-0.0403235294,
-0.0285419039,
-0.0347935371,
0.0207200348,
0.0255636219,
0.000001979,
-0.0229986366,
0.0010667881,
-0.0307905078,
-0.0437035337,
0.0088092014,
0.0111301597,
-0.0370733589,
-0.0473511741,
0.0382457376,
0.000821037,
-0.0778572634,
0.0199149325,
0.0669923946,
-0.040950872,
0.0673259795,
0.0118379183,
-0.079704687,
0.0317151919,
-0.0361451991,
-0.0513475463,
-0.0317893662,
0.0169583149,
-0.0315500647,
-0.0045201811,
-0.0558996983,
-0.0373673029,
0.0511451811,
0.0219916385,
-0.0253349207,
0.0324789695,
0.0148839559,
0.011624556,
0.0129252188,
-0.0232220329,
0.0454426296,
-0.0515552685,
-0.0090958802,
-0.008324055,
-0.0217768215,
-0.0551885627,
-0.0213198811,
-0.0305698067,
0.0124193514,
0.0470836163,
-0.0005261151,
-0.0271021836,
-0.0506220274,
0.0905741379,
-0.01098652,
0.0302913748,
0.058950711,
0.0412529483,
-0.028706206,
0.0427387469,
-0.0179855693,
-0.0049010119,
-0.0552711375,
-0.0004903724,
0.0916444734,
-0.0166693386,
0.0366973244,
-0.0127852298,
0.0043268632,
-0.0369406976,
0.0076290304,
0.0838662386,
0.0269478131,
0.0016549357,
0.0291390251,
-0.027501557,
0.0566383414,
-0.0121792089,
0.0162580572,
-0.0096908044,
0.0153520936,
0.024266053,
0.0195750743,
-0.0179569144,
0.0246088505,
-0.0104649374,
-0.0180388335,
-0.059493959,
0.018265957,
0.032156352,
0.0112933721,
-0.0225147251,
-0.0015963494,
-0.0220365133,
0.0033228665,
-0.0097631281,
0.0499053858,
0.0165275019,
-0.0373238176,
-0.0031358805,
-0.0595134534,
-0.015964143,
0.0445195325,
0.011197242,
-0.0021014563,
0.0138894934,
0.0597054772,
0.0051985625,
-0.03886443,
-0.0649544522,
0.056473963,
-0.0307794511,
-0.0515643358,
0.0355280712,
-0.0345971584,
0.0275730062,
0.0010140591,
-0.0204223879,
-0.0415584631,
0.0358026177,
-0.0010370878,
0.048051849,
0.0696320832,
-0.0589765795,
-0.0444757231,
0.0484600849,
0.0115628056,
-0.008712437,
0.0173035283,
-0.0005552794,
0.0269179605,
-0.0008549031,
-0.0235035531,
0.050948713,
0.0417207293,
0.0320733637,
-0.0193905886,
-0.0448434241,
-0.0558251888,
-0.0314265266,
0.0185066499,
0.0271065291,
0.0560625494,
-0.0084204106,
-0.0073929126,
0.0076717054,
0.051922854,
0.0054020635,
0.0952725336,
-0.0027346709,
-0.0522001982,
0.0089790616,
-0.0023977656,
-0.0043714172,
0.0296848286,
-0.0023007633,
0.0135289021,
-0.01860944,
0.0264663864,
-0.0484489873,
-0.0101063745,
-0.0158481412,
-0.0184432454,
0.0254851971,
0.0172915515,
0.0224501435,
0.0186341144,
-0.0268569924,
0.0573491044,
0.0327272266,
-0.0376821719,
0.0303017553,
-0.0212572366,
0.0074191568,
0.0415800363,
0.0557596274,
-0.0406325795,
-0.0539214313,
-0.016696509,
-0.0134493355,
0.0638691187,
0.0190356076,
0.0046130749,
0.0298259519,
-0.0849394426,
0.0025442508,
0.0128240231,
-0.0647179559,
0.0479046479,
-0.02565974,
0.0170664992,
-0.0081604719,
0.0235875025,
-0.0486221053,
0.0091113988,
-0.0386560336,
-0.0573921353,
0.03357381,
-0.0133525431,
0.0734566376,
0.0066528139,
-0.0109560788,
-0.0302246995,
0.0423462242,
-0.052731093,
-0.0210689586,
0.0401025973,
-0.067247346,
0.0106253596,
0.0811231583,
0.0032797428,
0.0041622277,
0.0385056101,
0.0007565293,
-0.060554713,
0.1018102095,
-0.0227462146,
0.0218698103,
-0.0416404009,
0.0087057473,
0.0516725108,
0.0054001184,
-0.000459869,
0.0337069333,
-0.0092915231,
0.0200856291,
0.003529151,
-0.0057141618,
0.0250252355,
-0.0264132358,
-0.0678304136,
0.0270683989,
0.0062147942,
0.0157300569,
0.0100298142,
-0.0143132005,
0.0248747952,
0.0116214138,
-0.0742032006,
-0.04789849,
-0.0452303924,
-0.0045192544,
-0.027266724,
0.0120025771,
-0.0098862527,
-0.0183867142,
-0.0186336469,
0.0157007966,
-0.0190853402,
-0.01313667,
0.020976698,
0.0225151386,
-0.0488157868,
-0.0290044732,
-0.02951313,
0.0424271263,
0.0034719319,
0.0109519279,
-0.0509499088,
0.0053505586,
-0.0279280711,
-0.0101485616,
0.0520050116,
-0.0141624706,
-0.0355900526,
-0.0004612499,
-0.0008213746,
0.0548278615,
0.043642927,
0.0184126478,
-0.0223727077,
0.0289349779,
0.0084766252,
-0.0027032723,
0.0194514245,
-0.0245763883,
0.0108239846,
0.0042834827,
0.0492963567,
0.0059243585,
0.0194577686,
-0.0109182326,
0.0268233921,
0.0006871158,
-0.0474284813,
0.0126014361,
-0.0609648153,
-0.0148361772,
0.0053260522,
-0.0139515316,
-0.0143176699,
0.0013753982,
-0.0108115906,
-0.0047455193,
-0.0304372311,
0.0213762112,
-0.0133568188,
-0.0351222083,
-0.0737383217,
-0.0244312491,
0.0102090919,
0.0313829035,
-0.0456173159,
-0.0000150082,
0.0481416769,
0.0284028351,
-0.0270244591,
0.0371842422,
0.0931469053,
-0.0356762148,
0.0208788738,
-0.0334873982,
-0.075221464,
-0.0213380028,
0.046390973,
-0.0431605764,
-0.0201347023,
-0.0002029637,
-0.0389338695,
0.0056892503,
-0.0177582428,
0.0207989197,
0.058248084,
-0.0355963893,
0.0106410682,
-0.0506538786,
0.0360074826,
0.0205691438,
0.0110895932,
0.0285767969,
-0.0085996836,
-0.0087021114,
0.0150031736,
0.0312131029,
0.0115230707,
-0.1205528602,
0.0317000411,
0.0242640581,
-0.0119935898,
-0.0101201357,
0.0048342245,
0.0279608332,
-0.0609109998,
-0.009485676,
0.0364021137,
-0.0284835082,
-0.0448330343,
-0.0285204183,
0.0362255126,
0.0119888112,
-0.0034121876,
-0.0076336381,
-0.0512303449,
-0.0309229698,
0.0001232229,
0.0097676208,
0.0686031953,
-0.0207918026,
-0.0267183967,
-0.0531384423,
0.0225906931,
0.0291269384,
0.0145683028,
-0.0473362617,
-0.0040243105,
-0.0187425613,
-0.0003332843,
0.0723569468,
0.0258865152,
-0.0046933801,
-0.0322390608,
0.0315959454,
-0.0313229933,
-0.0611012876,
0.0199033078,
-0.057853967,
0.0234735627,
0.0688756257,
-0.0030253122,
0.0064883069,
0.0045675631,
0.0741786286,
0.0463461503,
0.0185088161,
0.001523395,
-0.0179747064,
-0.0124632102,
-0.0564752929,
0.039874129,
0.0419634357,
-0.0469501279,
0.013048213,
0.0136333061,
0.0513480566,
-0.00299338,
-0.0087587005,
0.0184402075,
-0.0253151022,
-0.0049541211,
0.0358282663,
0.0080965217,
-0.0331533179,
-0.0428022631,
-0.0150579186,
0.0108337468,
-0.0410600714,
-0.0321517661,
-0.0232777651,
0.0352759138,
0.0040810923,
-0.0216231514,
-0.0403772555,
-0.0441857092,
0.0145077286,
0.0556839146,
-0.0254618619,
0.0359991528,
-0.0050513772,
-0.0388814621,
-0.0140497331,
-0.0331358463,
-0.0190412924,
-0.0711386651,
0.04283268,
0.0120463707,
-0.0355331972,
0.0159861539,
-0.0051022302,
-0.0948366821,
-0.0465548038,
0.0185778476,
-0.0057973205,
0.0136381779,
0.0057354714,
0.0248597134,
-0.0347077698,
0.0306946337,
-0.0322390869,
0.0204374418,
0.0293406043,
0.0149149122,
0.001810601,
0.0104092807,
0.0313005932,
-0.0242540743,
0.0400089957,
0.0413844772,
0.0044013914,
-0.0220989361,
-0.02146836,
-0.0179276783,
0.0109200282,
0.0260914173,
0.0165450722,
0.0174008477,
-0.0208786149,
0.0518455468,
0.0098762251,
0.0618033633,
-0.0199222006,
0.0161005277,
0.0296566933,
-0.0089092199,
-0.0101432493,
0.0248996578,
0.0817926675,
-0.0512544662,
-0.0517680682,
0.0252309963,
0.0078048194,
0.0016617824,
-0.0246323403,
-0.0165441446,
-0.0153526543,
0.0307956636,
0.0151057513,
0.0128874173,
-0.0023068413,
0.0501436852,
0.0547049269,
0.030679414,
-0.0244402513,
-0.0038044068,
-0.0319086686,
-0.062984392,
-0.0120405387,
0.0396190584,
0.0556859225,
0.0363868326,
0.00439846,
-0.0311798453,
-0.0189499296,
-0.025110364,
0.0167526323,
0.0046102675,
-0.0006678223,
0.0264517758,
0.0193663519,
-0.0195864197,
0.074264355,
0.0104774665,
0.0054118722,
-0.000306833,
0.0574713685,
0.1043653339,
-0.0423568264,
-0.0288732406,
-0.0272798017,
-0.0288732722,
0.0250221938,
-0.0175342802,
-0.0097088767,
-0.0323289633,
0.0409276634,
-0.008511683,
0.0602492653,
-0.0505132861,
0.0442767031,
0.0088494988,
0.0184809025,
-0.0136898933,
0.0402891301,
-0.0054366104,
0.0110251019,
-0.0055694971,
0.0032766408,
-6.14603401e-33,
-0.004307867,
0.0203521922,
0.031500712,
0.0393227041,
0.0382866934,
-0.0001292794,
-0.0306902304,
-0.0350366384,
-0.0142204687,
-0.0479078628,
-0.0356194116,
0.0113836639,
0.0168059841,
0.0309186149,
-0.0002932495,
-0.0587973446,
0.0629980862,
-0.0178570002,
-0.0176976025,
0.0070489077,
0.0415445343,
0.0263739005,
0.0146089774,
-0.0595145784,
-0.0497979522,
0.0287278928,
-0.0139604285,
-0.0308712851,
0.0042712791,
0.0074315919,
-0.0708626285,
0.0301053058,
-0.0132411746,
-0.0500784516,
-0.0260934792,
-0.0096880822,
-0.0907255337,
-0.0108829662,
-0.0424968973,
0.0194178652,
-0.0728256181,
0.0164313391,
0.0383906513,
0.0373527668,
-0.0521331504,
-0.0341446213,
-0.0188963488,
0.008101495,
-0.0304704215,
-0.0863989294,
0.0000733072,
0.0159365833,
-0.0040282332,
0.0294522662,
0.0523277223,
-0.0467502475,
-0.0368182994,
0.0161412768,
-0.0682906434,
-0.0202382635,
0.0432544835,
0.0670433566,
0.0377925858,
0.0110955909,
-0.0089912694,
0.0491835475,
0.0824477822,
-0.0206715725,
-0.02815881,
-0.0136957383,
-0.004934804,
-0.0066253874,
0.0500365123,
-0.0101829516,
0.0997453183,
-0.039271608,
-0.0351927802,
-0.0689962134,
0.0763872266,
0.0551530644,
0.0395308882,
0.0442808345,
-0.0542034954,
0.0031044781,
0.0224859994,
-0.023498347,
-0.0398173481,
-0.0565879606,
0.0386538059,
0.0144276246,
0.025542656,
-0.0106672421,
-0.0126400869,
0.0050304416,
0.0031670358,
0.0060105883,
0.0520776734,
0.0052480046,
0.0057751117,
0.0008162268,
-0.0891889706,
0.0060371114,
0.0081224693,
0.0129362037,
-0.0105963722,
0.0138924327,
0.0191698521,
0.107166484,
-0.0487764105,
-0.0362588055,
-0.0403953865,
0.037185885,
0.0617443137,
0.0672429949,
0.0781911165,
-0.0290491451,
0.024784483,
0.1003032997,
-0.0218572132,
0.0100837965,
-0.0002102644,
-0.013993823,
0.0505680069,
0.0395981371,
-0.0198078584,
-0.0130398022,
-0.0246528778,
0.0161734261,
-0.0065288842,
-0.0431640968,
0.0137108723,
0.0220680702,
2.789e-7,
-0.0494784378,
0.0054421476,
0.0576627962,
0.049383603,
0.023406174,
-0.0121684484,
0.0151126245,
0.0308047738,
-0.0032189584,
-0.020803079,
0.0123574063,
0.0148577979,
0.0129266921,
-0.0010077091,
-0.0565220043,
-0.0288616158,
-0.0569663681,
0.0134200417,
0.0062904786,
-0.0470348299,
-0.0335754566,
0.0836130604,
0.0005076693,
-0.0176353604,
0.0281523354,
-0.0243454706,
-0.004480496,
0.0040154043,
0.0087913517,
-0.0033210993,
0.0566291101,
0.0437048897,
-0.0308768917,
-0.0283629168,
-0.0159400348,
0.0327134766,
-0.0228200983,
-0.0017038702,
-0.0250936728,
-0.1051208302,
0.0080781067,
0.0379804894,
-0.0162702426,
0.0264438987,
0.026607316,
0.061410524,
0.0147418045,
-0.0061373101,
0.010672641,
-0.0360975936,
-0.0164187066,
-0.0308628399,
-0.0006886236,
0.0057494394,
0.0027372441,
-0.0478239693,
-0.0300262403,
-0.1011471599,
0.047552105,
0.0113586904,
-0.0282801688,
0.0533143468,
-0.0394183621,
0.0011916374,
0.0074247625,
0.0040487954,
-0.0445809625,
1.888045162e-34,
0.0467145666,
-0.0530357361,
0.0051379055,
0.0318996087,
0.0105411839,
-0.0476683341,
-0.1405721605,
-0.0254707634,
0.0261412356,
-0.0161613598,
-0.0563694723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08399v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08399v5 | Large Language Models Fail on Trivial Alterations to Theory-of-Mind Tasks | 2023-02-16T16:18:03 | 2023-03-14T13:47:26 | Tomer Ullman | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Intuitive psychology is a pillar of common-sense reasoning. The replication
of this reasoning in machine intelligence is an important stepping-stone on the
way to human-like artificial intelligence. Several recent tasks and benchmarks
for examining this reasoning in Large-Large Models have focused in particular
on belief attribution in Theory-of-Mind tasks. These tasks have shown both
successes and failures. We consider in particular a recent purported success
case, and show that small variations that maintain the principles of ToM turn
the results on their head. We argue that in general, the zero-hypothesis for
model evaluation in intuitive psychology should be skeptical, and that outlying
failure cases should outweigh average success rates. We also consider what
possible future successes on Theory-of-Mind tasks by more powerful LLMs would
mean for ToM tasks with people. | [
0.0194647945,
0.0470859259,
-0.0303515773,
0.0276689157,
-0.0459418967,
0.0378257334,
-0.0336860865,
-0.0135991117,
0.0191623475,
-0.0104867276,
-0.0584808588,
-0.0469644628,
0.0193889737,
0.0344057903,
0.0498078652,
-0.0094712246,
0.0197756831,
-0.0201028921,
-0.0110384598,
-0.014264198,
-0.0595837124,
-0.0013962041,
-0.0090836035,
0.0061439816,
0.0418224819,
-0.0002032736,
-0.0160705596,
-0.0205985736,
0.0164034087,
-0.0484357029,
-0.0786124691,
-0.0012095707,
-0.0041281539,
0.0194917098,
0.0000019308,
-0.0740342364,
0.0264157224,
-0.0004447584,
-0.037383832,
0.0030412483,
0.0037800132,
-0.0065019913,
0.013977793,
-0.0031152349,
-0.039233584,
0.0489687845,
0.014334945,
0.0659931973,
-0.0096545527,
0.0365306959,
-0.0063774735,
-0.0135311326,
0.0182477906,
-0.001158257,
0.0754618868,
-0.0519589558,
0.0238885935,
-0.0261036828,
0.0030372939,
-0.0225214642,
-0.0022734408,
-0.0122804279,
0.0147186145,
0.0257084407,
-0.0202377196,
0.0302443597,
-0.0296445023,
-0.0356947407,
-0.0271240249,
0.0649478957,
0.0928669199,
-0.0078776497,
-0.0101471562,
0.0237473175,
0.0119365714,
0.0298847985,
-0.0396947972,
0.0355011486,
-0.0049545122,
0.0113684162,
0.0427979566,
0.0080384668,
0.0173081551,
0.0350248031,
-0.0505640507,
0.0985665917,
-0.0300373565,
-0.0315494537,
0.0199110974,
0.0221844763,
-0.0692525655,
-0.0486899652,
-0.043740809,
0.0117003825,
0.0234200172,
0.0088478914,
-0.0229620561,
0.0490800776,
-0.0308904573,
-0.0263815466,
0.0873657539,
0.0547198653,
-0.0055652382,
0.0453327075,
-0.0104343025,
0.0662975535,
-0.0293348376,
0.0458505638,
0.0064668739,
0.0080034966,
-0.0654173642,
0.0181408115,
-0.0050381576,
0.0627303869,
0.0538663529,
-0.0206094198,
-0.0395208187,
0.0109690391,
-0.016118804,
-0.010794458,
-0.0323615596,
-0.0081169549,
-0.0364226289,
-0.0256748646,
-0.0559557304,
0.0221686158,
-0.0222011451,
0.0317501985,
0.0199114475,
-0.0629346892,
-0.0274536256,
0.0127815874,
0.0051744999,
-0.0042522741,
0.0125026628,
0.0181737188,
0.0185122695,
-0.0272152387,
-0.034968406,
-0.0236051809,
-0.0194140896,
-0.0757840574,
-0.0059953928,
-0.0400150269,
-0.0046042805,
0.0150257088,
-0.0019413442,
-0.0385541581,
0.0065735267,
-0.0110113015,
-0.0818631127,
0.0738640428,
0.0325927474,
0.0115020229,
-0.0260350928,
0.0008291815,
-0.0625474229,
0.0092409076,
0.0350118354,
0.0148077365,
0.0053306017,
0.0395921692,
0.0220495444,
0.0119195711,
-0.0067321616,
-0.0151213594,
-0.0107471813,
-0.0033513103,
-0.0125361001,
0.0469844639,
0.0365147814,
0.0611467548,
-0.0319368728,
0.0129979793,
0.071267955,
0.0676725879,
-0.0334103033,
0.0048157708,
0.0613598004,
0.0099464469,
0.0261401907,
0.0188828036,
-0.1059382111,
0.0273515079,
-0.0649480373,
-0.0264307521,
0.0068795914,
0.0061918846,
-0.0405574366,
-0.0109606087,
-0.0186133739,
0.0119351828,
-0.0001955762,
-0.0005034748,
0.0524271727,
-0.0297293887,
-0.0046804086,
-0.0090930248,
0.0178300384,
-0.0158811137,
-0.0160095375,
-0.0808184147,
0.0265134443,
-0.0156302638,
0.0220273975,
0.0033569734,
0.0196960978,
0.0092819091,
0.008271738,
0.0344224721,
0.080849275,
0.0150384046,
-0.0165071096,
-0.0205162428,
0.0173166096,
-0.011601232,
0.0187311079,
0.0093552666,
-0.0388961881,
0.0086275851,
-0.0185899958,
-0.0588999242,
0.0364695378,
0.0142439045,
0.0057847654,
0.0011764893,
-0.0617729165,
0.0174255949,
0.048721727,
0.0117145674,
-0.0013374038,
0.017410269,
0.0151718957,
-0.0003307239,
0.0200168043,
0.0656730831,
-0.0139441537,
-0.0447365791,
0.0318212695,
-0.0122652296,
-0.058701098,
0.0481480286,
0.0084517952,
-0.0255509485,
0.0435868166,
-0.052841682,
0.0153657142,
-0.0211772583,
0.0525704995,
-0.0295766331,
0.0012240066,
0.0109089343,
0.073605895,
-0.029386403,
-0.0083154496,
0.0166970305,
-0.0191750955,
0.0257075634,
-0.0610849932,
-0.0167367514,
-0.0142272878,
0.0106430547,
-0.02852479,
-0.0150158703,
-0.0257936884,
-0.0316354968,
-0.0312121231,
-0.0537648723,
-0.0278234724,
0.0133206155,
0.0149061941,
-0.0032561154,
-0.006379338,
-0.0001571709,
0.0191034768,
-0.0396046825,
0.0359221399,
0.0265489276,
0.0469997339,
0.0368186124,
-0.0180755146,
-0.02840323,
-0.0093843639,
0.026200274,
-0.0388449952,
0.0235000569,
0.012211482,
-0.0040024477,
-0.027239535,
0.0429775789,
-0.0630784482,
0.0078099952,
-0.0206259396,
-0.0340993293,
0.0267047379,
0.0082200039,
-0.0055540805,
0.1012048572,
-0.0383057296,
0.0039601782,
0.0601885282,
0.0240255017,
-0.0556932762,
0.0036873061,
0.0051286281,
-0.0165584814,
-0.0282204803,
-0.0713331401,
-0.0199895632,
0.0712895393,
0.0338865444,
0.0002613868,
-0.0664531887,
0.0642940775,
0.0121972617,
-0.0554612577,
0.0023946473,
-0.0070640827,
-0.0342575572,
0.0778496638,
-0.0311132632,
-0.0438990407,
0.0819467306,
-0.0174365267,
0.0035002052,
-0.0363113545,
0.0172859095,
-0.0161565803,
0.058059115,
0.0061378749,
0.0221212506,
0.0337796845,
0.0090429429,
-0.0761937574,
-0.0253304318,
-0.0204012375,
-0.0031440624,
-0.0039736051,
-0.0531465039,
-0.0040510045,
0.02252803,
-0.0120540289,
-0.0276211146,
0.0078950236,
-0.0608471818,
0.0046552974,
-0.0081848307,
-0.0075331004,
-0.0413061976,
-0.0295328703,
0.0740924925,
-0.0271526091,
0.0160726737,
-0.0389360152,
-0.0257212762,
-0.0223229267,
0.0352188088,
0.0218751673,
0.0636476874,
-0.0310499892,
0.0210191142,
0.0431666896,
0.0813677683,
0.0423892289,
-0.0047190692,
0.0304926056,
0.0136860432,
0.0388649851,
-0.0345730893,
0.052449517,
0.0800873414,
0.0219265968,
-0.0027829029,
0.1055252701,
0.0396561138,
-0.0322523564,
0.0167342424,
-0.0021263137,
-0.0042771162,
0.0192198958,
-0.0045389882,
-0.0532722585,
-0.0185168236,
0.0292597041,
0.0031715564,
-0.0394336693,
-0.07669992,
-0.0012736495,
-0.1051317677,
0.0367314965,
-0.0078163873,
0.0275353342,
-0.0327782184,
-0.0455808975,
0.054144334,
-0.0140897017,
-0.0199512541,
0.023371093,
0.0104532279,
0.0268185586,
-0.0057287905,
0.0111182509,
-0.0352329798,
0.0541258901,
-0.0463605411,
0.053135518,
0.0444699824,
0.0396175236,
-0.0061593712,
-0.0746241361,
0.0029416033,
0.0685612932,
0.0150707578,
-0.010785074,
-0.0010614985,
-0.0007179723,
0.0109262262,
-0.0202399679,
0.0460695811,
-0.0373906791,
-0.0174751561,
-0.0115418043,
0.0834904462,
-0.0287954826,
-0.042210076,
0.0136330323,
0.0345586501,
-0.0564092547,
0.0960802063,
0.0377444103,
-0.0422193371,
0.0047748494,
-0.0137663214,
-0.040700689,
0.036910262,
-0.0596296713,
0.0357290544,
0.020362692,
-0.0316763893,
-0.0742760673,
-0.0381168686,
0.0006974547,
0.0584171526,
0.0077162688,
-0.0358829573,
0.0073405271,
-0.0021827146,
-0.0033925904,
0.0293140635,
-0.0624636821,
0.00501065,
-0.0355398133,
0.0368385315,
0.0438463129,
-0.0659789518,
-0.0000946487,
0.0187246837,
-0.0072336532,
-0.0684943572,
0.0000388275,
0.0266672615,
0.0391250476,
0.0314448401,
0.0163932834,
-0.0269820355,
-0.0029819321,
-0.0497691296,
0.0050029485,
0.0898872986,
0.0079285307,
0.0793459341,
0.0192441531,
0.0717406049,
-0.0099603701,
0.0086726211,
0.0293604024,
0.0293772127,
-0.0165354367,
-0.0091734286,
0.0339299105,
0.0280043185,
0.0282479338,
0.0351375826,
0.0187097564,
-0.011248772,
-0.0103443163,
-0.0094007012,
0.0000029178,
-0.0569422431,
-0.0232722182,
0.0552598573,
0.0471023731,
-0.0351790786,
-0.0844445825,
-0.011403867,
0.0297988132,
-0.0015915614,
0.0043368577,
-0.0157601833,
0.0365873948,
0.0254531354,
0.0144415749,
-0.0078014657,
-0.0231188126,
-0.050656192,
0.0241682362,
0.0287516937,
0.0911393538,
0.0465107188,
-0.0431399643,
-0.0404436663,
-0.0145790298,
-0.0848017186,
-0.0806268081,
0.049280297,
-0.0087963911,
-0.0178984795,
0.000892424,
-0.013026949,
-0.0626374781,
0.0163934641,
0.0125919422,
0.0239800662,
0.0137343127,
-0.0199355986,
0.0222729314,
-0.0112920925,
-0.0017470677,
0.0084165363,
0.0237714518,
-0.047740709,
0.046027422,
-0.0239443686,
-0.0246061627,
-0.0261936169,
0.0153920362,
-0.0048344531,
0.0562201664,
0.0014754845,
0.0370013453,
-0.0832776576,
-0.0518335998,
0.0287028961,
-0.0009517217,
-0.0019112829,
-0.0399059877,
0.0209874287,
0.0752574578,
-0.0119913183,
-0.0125069236,
0.015004239,
-0.0381763577,
-0.0271637421,
-0.0144025609,
-0.0313806124,
-6.087449208e-33,
-0.0167110227,
0.0072274222,
-0.007151891,
0.0064838482,
-0.0100717787,
-0.0347538069,
-0.0503809601,
0.0150496121,
-0.0438340157,
0.0054100822,
-0.0222248361,
-0.0021541284,
0.0084068608,
0.0027040003,
0.0029541601,
0.0227349382,
0.0040021813,
-0.0182724986,
-0.0324560925,
-0.052315332,
-0.0064978506,
-0.0253872443,
0.0387900099,
-0.0750790089,
0.0506830998,
0.0161459967,
0.01002381,
0.0270406101,
-0.0244807471,
0.0161906146,
-0.0308441855,
0.014629649,
0.0289355777,
-0.0166498423,
0.0031675904,
-0.0087621687,
0.0019454894,
-0.0434585139,
0.0485903025,
-0.0241819862,
-0.0043642377,
-0.0355951004,
0.0074780812,
-0.0120239984,
-0.0723460093,
0.0127971917,
0.0153411599,
-0.0138453469,
0.0281745847,
0.0386079289,
-0.0482943952,
-0.0176710207,
0.0248479154,
-0.0235180873,
-0.0217977967,
-0.0248052683,
-0.0299693346,
-0.0020729126,
-0.0438413769,
0.0243543796,
0.0280181952,
-0.0397498906,
0.0662043542,
-0.0362054147,
0.0227350779,
0.0748017132,
0.0857913345,
0.044419691,
-0.0380448438,
-0.0266937595,
0.0210851748,
0.0477611162,
0.0351605304,
0.0673845932,
0.0192302205,
0.0505259559,
-0.0406210236,
0.0058066021,
0.0502448939,
0.0318405963,
0.0747876093,
0.0187707916,
-0.0655660704,
0.0148261273,
-0.0495981574,
-0.024397485,
-0.0525909178,
-0.0177940559,
0.0028955329,
-0.0072888909,
-0.0029787901,
-0.0367615297,
0.0358300805,
-0.0446414724,
0.0046494831,
-0.0385643318,
-0.0155799566,
0.0385704413,
-0.0081117172,
0.000658068,
-0.0496337228,
-0.007471445,
-0.0334682204,
0.0339307673,
0.0230094623,
0.0217251051,
-0.0094472673,
0.0045922203,
-0.0157146193,
-0.0272637587,
-0.042089846,
-0.0413488932,
0.0104417661,
-0.0368509404,
0.0452049598,
0.011523976,
-0.0128137283,
-0.026411308,
-0.0246076602,
-0.0358337276,
-0.034817569,
0.040474847,
-0.0131784556,
0.011458301,
-0.0443765484,
-0.001133678,
-0.0134426188,
0.0026990962,
0.0273954533,
0.0013169498,
-0.0212703086,
0.0059342086,
2.793e-7,
-0.0050876243,
0.035173256,
-0.0183183067,
-0.0086160386,
0.019669285,
0.0540484153,
-0.0219484698,
-0.0015763142,
0.0164242927,
-0.0556922071,
-0.0150667559,
0.0617933869,
0.0366736986,
0.0010511923,
-0.0614718609,
0.0118744355,
0.0427991599,
-0.0139383525,
-0.0120874029,
0.0238457751,
0.028963441,
0.059574306,
0.0361063443,
-0.0070429635,
0.0062668952,
-0.0146027701,
0.0488208346,
-0.0575100854,
0.016478641,
-0.0071225106,
0.0054961606,
0.0053195618,
0.0074912803,
0.0413560979,
0.051374875,
0.0384432971,
-0.0008418972,
0.0023618699,
-0.0101747522,
-0.0168070756,
-0.0263278894,
-0.0196731463,
-0.0164364856,
-0.0495033264,
0.0437601246,
-0.0987124741,
-0.096664004,
0.0449756347,
0.0228436328,
-0.0179744959,
0.0004037658,
0.0434369743,
0.01430507,
0.0043423735,
-0.0012269666,
-0.0142424768,
-0.0162066054,
-0.0605113395,
0.0170178488,
-0.019510081,
-0.030460557,
-0.0896930173,
-0.0311972685,
-0.0124027263,
0.0275893137,
-0.0831425712,
-0.0293227546,
2.334173163e-34,
0.0208561867,
-0.0022815363,
0.0273845084,
0.0039535519,
0.0693536401,
-0.0122224735,
0.0158057809,
0.0266772602,
0.0628517345,
-0.1115313992,
-0.0041118129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08387v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08387v2 | LEALLA: Learning Lightweight Language-agnostic Sentence Embeddings with Knowledge Distillation | 2023-02-16T16:05:34 | 2023-12-26T08:11:37 | Zhuoyuan Mao, Tetsuji Nakagawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale language-agnostic sentence embedding models such as LaBSE (Feng
et al., 2022) obtain state-of-the-art performance for parallel sentence
alignment. However, these large-scale models can suffer from inference speed
and computation overhead. This study systematically explores learning
language-agnostic sentence embeddings with lightweight models. We demonstrate
that a thin-deep encoder can construct robust low-dimensional sentence
embeddings for 109 languages. With our proposed distillation methods, we
achieve further improvements by incorporating knowledge from a teacher model.
Empirical results on Tatoeba, United Nations, and BUCC show the effectiveness
of our lightweight models. We release our lightweight language-agnostic
sentence embedding models LEALLA on TensorFlow Hub. | [
0.0179285593,
0.0716090202,
0.0145557942,
0.0629117191,
-0.0210130252,
0.0106638456,
0.0113029797,
-0.0525681376,
-0.0141629884,
-0.0155493328,
0.0024979957,
-0.009835884,
-0.0062119719,
-0.0247945487,
0.0348446369,
-0.0656171963,
0.0134481229,
0.0017026914,
0.026428936,
-0.0085498849,
0.0415434949,
0.0162898712,
0.0066021355,
0.0107098604,
-0.007971759,
-0.0306117516,
-0.044174578,
0.0195343755,
0.043471314,
0.0064345296,
0.0482818373,
0.0264818463,
0.0370680206,
0.0430574976,
0.0000018691,
0.0237490777,
-0.0060894308,
-0.0450987406,
0.0068523469,
0.0369122475,
-0.0205217134,
-0.0579162464,
0.0037135743,
0.0003711738,
-0.0029223496,
-0.0121796299,
0.0521280877,
0.0199592095,
0.0550271086,
0.0906436592,
-0.015491914,
-0.0269397572,
0.0131031331,
-0.0683669224,
-0.0411216915,
-0.0374568328,
-0.006087584,
-0.034925133,
-0.0637812242,
0.0046242769,
-0.0370847173,
0.0333809443,
0.0363986827,
0.0006380173,
-0.0134377815,
-0.0044569322,
-0.0308277868,
-0.0230581556,
0.0113752848,
0.0947464556,
-0.0274127033,
0.00726528,
-0.0110379364,
0.0085667586,
0.0017781036,
-0.0109151695,
-0.0517587662,
0.024062559,
0.0453936085,
0.0396703705,
0.009772039,
0.0434840657,
0.0316407047,
-0.0154337762,
-0.0117060421,
-0.0042970725,
0.0541635863,
-0.0649688318,
-0.0147476662,
0.0305248927,
-0.0293814391,
-0.0152731938,
-0.0214972552,
-0.0117408792,
-0.0134364897,
-0.0036708564,
-0.0454175398,
-0.0397417471,
0.0133917602,
-0.0246435348,
0.0159946512,
0.0547971129,
-0.0342930183,
0.0402929708,
-0.036478214,
0.0728308409,
-0.0202878248,
0.048441954,
-0.0301617756,
-0.0228596684,
-0.00923853,
-0.0056638732,
-0.0191424321,
0.0147399595,
-0.0580405071,
-0.055495806,
-0.0112820286,
0.0238762852,
-0.0128665697,
0.0521565005,
0.0201395787,
0.0161925498,
-0.0452847853,
-0.0057421732,
0.0194294602,
0.0944050103,
-0.0366016105,
-0.0079827234,
-0.0069645299,
-0.0257985238,
-0.0611147471,
0.0223697443,
0.032391455,
-0.0377058536,
0.0168578308,
0.0170732178,
-0.0416500792,
-0.0317633785,
-0.0006983167,
0.0017577736,
-0.0367298089,
-0.0814495906,
0.006035618,
-0.0746964216,
0.0708509833,
-0.0014548097,
0.0327313244,
-0.0847189948,
0.0230291393,
0.0171859916,
-0.0429174565,
0.0211012717,
0.0333493054,
-0.0177645367,
-0.0463844538,
0.0042304043,
0.076719448,
0.0795776099,
0.0282056369,
0.0440563411,
0.0281507131,
0.013314018,
-0.0439254083,
0.0344655812,
0.0275775045,
0.0383248962,
-0.0285812244,
0.0169357527,
0.0029906835,
0.0612340607,
0.0267984364,
0.0538490228,
0.0094432905,
0.0167948045,
0.0583016612,
-0.0023672304,
-0.0107155368,
-0.0084273219,
0.0537541062,
0.012550653,
-0.0402133502,
0.0056756409,
-0.0448969454,
0.0411718078,
0.0529311784,
0.0207099095,
0.0621647909,
0.0814308524,
-0.0510867946,
-0.0035237146,
-0.0057762857,
-0.027859509,
-0.0112780388,
0.0039926865,
0.0235843714,
0.0083801746,
-0.0515380092,
0.0814551413,
0.0482272618,
-0.0752182677,
-0.0297944825,
0.0464647971,
-0.0216717552,
0.0472519659,
0.0073963027,
0.0119105149,
-0.0379521251,
-0.0176406279,
0.032924857,
0.0830093101,
0.0494052358,
-0.010084792,
0.0454383641,
-0.0800011232,
-0.0199727304,
-0.0442562923,
0.0204970371,
0.001245206,
0.0225505009,
0.0274655167,
0.0551310033,
-0.0506477021,
-0.0137094809,
0.0300790947,
-0.0073685325,
-0.0409652367,
-0.0139134172,
0.072413601,
0.0270508379,
0.0173857529,
0.0089768181,
-0.0217988472,
0.0270663071,
-0.0637637973,
0.0006975266,
-0.0124661718,
-0.0538096204,
-0.1185978279,
0.0326478444,
-0.046923019,
-0.0324927717,
0.0785983726,
-0.0644179881,
-0.0633517355,
-0.0118423961,
-0.0090878364,
0.0032729513,
-0.01672915,
-0.0023678301,
0.0084682899,
0.0159923583,
-0.0163982976,
0.0303561483,
-0.0079617882,
0.0048973435,
0.0220159069,
-0.0214151926,
0.0424101613,
-0.029583754,
-0.0780578032,
-0.0133659402,
0.0176191181,
0.0226167478,
0.0316864736,
0.0086190477,
0.0252219327,
-0.0245323088,
-0.068149291,
0.0279930755,
-0.0338207893,
-0.0086676404,
0.0289281812,
0.0599792711,
0.0273784939,
-0.0191276167,
-0.067090109,
-0.0070729577,
-0.018554043,
0.0111176884,
0.0394988582,
-0.0279026255,
-0.0272323452,
-0.0426859856,
-0.0025560865,
-0.0033930317,
0.0378978141,
-0.0413366668,
0.0184780452,
-0.0044347569,
0.0033653849,
-0.0244954694,
0.0139934532,
0.0076116924,
-0.0639868826,
-0.0129452068,
0.0031606304,
0.0173434578,
0.0641425177,
-0.0241127126,
0.0307019372,
0.0155550353,
0.0370638892,
-0.0204611346,
0.0430291556,
-0.0185327101,
0.0171544384,
-0.0458003879,
-0.0144783035,
-0.0249817818,
0.0792272687,
0.0012873573,
-0.0055788807,
-0.0840099305,
-0.0160656869,
0.0358554348,
0.0076707588,
-0.0245699584,
0.0281429328,
-0.0020190331,
-0.0099782553,
-0.0478640459,
-0.0276544821,
0.0623403788,
-0.0220397953,
-0.0223697033,
-0.0189538654,
-0.0029198746,
-0.0403496884,
0.0393876992,
0.0138275102,
0.0343523361,
-0.0507583581,
0.0038491278,
-0.0608184785,
0.0151069593,
-0.00279607,
0.0108238515,
0.0230198689,
-0.0012672202,
-0.0264054462,
-0.0462631807,
-0.0629129484,
-0.0158503763,
-0.0541450158,
-0.0350047573,
0.033955086,
-0.0055322461,
-0.0080586625,
-0.0559398718,
-0.0139966747,
0.0117787002,
0.0166026559,
-0.0204884764,
0.058843188,
-0.0651794001,
0.0463604406,
0.0704089254,
-0.011481436,
-0.0371203609,
-0.0414453782,
0.0221029725,
0.0272542443,
-0.008050805,
0.001065276,
-0.0183509272,
-0.020159794,
0.0413822159,
0.0053038471,
0.0101913903,
-0.0197598804,
0.0584307835,
-0.0219857879,
-0.005417753,
0.1041264459,
-0.0094646271,
-0.0100498144,
0.0041073966,
0.0541340224,
0.0748234168,
0.0122699402,
-0.0051364996,
-0.0960200354,
-0.0575172864,
-0.0011414816,
-0.0109802308,
0.0427594669,
-0.0066570491,
0.0028556078,
-0.0848442242,
-0.0363652259,
0.0305701755,
-0.0027523593,
-0.0405842364,
0.0000043218,
0.0041822814,
-0.020277217,
0.0438763127,
0.0066884537,
0.006783254,
0.0034083603,
-0.0014626659,
-0.0164137036,
-0.0528294034,
-0.0001319277,
-0.0421965495,
0.016562989,
-0.0034011591,
0.0337145217,
-0.0178909265,
-0.0368902758,
-0.0144816199,
-0.0281193256,
-0.0365803055,
0.049298428,
0.048812937,
-0.021501027,
-0.0444969349,
0.0320156366,
0.0362116769,
-0.0734295249,
0.0164943766,
0.008659835,
0.0843073502,
0.0248982161,
0.0025212027,
-0.0045613758,
-0.0331224203,
0.0185330175,
0.0940719694,
0.0205862392,
-0.0539333858,
-0.0395499393,
-0.0033697186,
-0.0087717334,
-0.074337475,
-0.0087012192,
-0.0109957727,
-0.0001995435,
-0.0041230423,
-0.0424599312,
-0.0768528879,
0.0410337634,
0.00711306,
0.0255838688,
-0.0025010824,
-0.0121839419,
-0.0011088247,
-0.0354078002,
0.0343880728,
-0.0216057841,
0.0174043719,
-0.021585973,
0.0045535415,
-0.0297830291,
0.0322579555,
-0.0075524733,
0.0288832039,
-0.1238988638,
-0.0813831016,
-0.0166581403,
0.0221331976,
0.0014993873,
0.0531941839,
-0.0089830263,
0.0268636737,
0.0731368661,
-0.0009727032,
-0.0271747615,
0.0399235785,
0.0397804081,
-0.0247833207,
0.0045222151,
0.0632815734,
-0.0352219269,
-0.0016769808,
0.0319940522,
0.0561053418,
-0.0121371923,
-0.0602743551,
0.0068086078,
-0.0184678268,
0.0278934371,
-0.03071809,
-0.0039425837,
-0.0303849112,
0.0222081337,
-0.0151648661,
-0.0207257196,
-0.0515646189,
-0.0123436907,
0.0249010567,
0.0265347995,
0.0070419651,
0.0112372525,
0.0328229666,
0.0177672021,
-0.0452334955,
-0.010009855,
-0.0081669865,
-0.0140557438,
0.030087579,
0.0107121132,
-0.0262493156,
0.0078221885,
-0.03386648,
0.000616769,
-0.0239848476,
-0.0083301589,
0.0421548896,
0.0121812588,
-0.0158973001,
0.0205371995,
-0.0358399414,
-0.0019639449,
-0.0174241103,
-0.0013263013,
0.0833495036,
-0.039616555,
0.0602132753,
-0.0033297101,
-0.0140093137,
0.004472604,
0.0253517367,
-0.0332981572,
-0.0060932091,
0.0165420957,
0.011163353,
-0.0257764552,
0.0206171162,
0.0746147707,
0.0213295445,
0.0441778935,
-0.0032697383,
0.026403496,
-0.0454062819,
-0.0025034619,
0.0391379036,
0.0441410877,
-0.0042455234,
-0.0087314025,
-0.0100410953,
-0.0448346734,
0.0131075867,
-0.0050568958,
-0.0391291901,
-0.0027429336,
0.0307380389,
0.0295065176,
-0.0322883539,
-0.0116744041,
-0.0127371186,
0.0117675597,
-0.0081680836,
-0.0557386056,
-0.0291307047,
-6.34561091e-33,
-0.0036384258,
0.06273029,
-0.0119998176,
-0.0134737818,
-0.0351665318,
0.0075141625,
-0.027045019,
-0.0267090704,
-0.029098969,
0.0630365536,
0.0130826971,
-0.0001813859,
0.0082886675,
0.0739786029,
0.0334398784,
0.0263987817,
0.0716700926,
0.0182907451,
0.0006733784,
0.0256803315,
0.0464820713,
0.0193743985,
0.0671782941,
-0.0401319489,
0.0055303364,
-0.0377426744,
-0.0005879605,
0.0225789566,
0.0395688601,
0.022923857,
-0.0059094275,
0.0284478776,
-0.0066660121,
-0.0033727479,
-0.019071091,
0.042804908,
-0.0714607015,
-0.0135170305,
0.0264760889,
0.0252590235,
-0.0242084935,
-0.0647268221,
-0.0081215659,
-0.0296652857,
0.0441084914,
-0.0367113762,
0.0281164143,
-0.0032452801,
-0.0030671484,
-0.0046557528,
-0.0764690042,
-0.0076890681,
-0.0371244475,
-0.029642377,
0.0085769668,
0.0320892744,
0.0266921893,
0.0146450363,
-0.0578001365,
0.0082799299,
-0.0303888228,
0.0636279136,
0.0219723787,
0.0025111116,
-0.0338336602,
0.0480027534,
-0.0363955013,
-0.0244402662,
0.0025879475,
0.0107437326,
-0.0022392333,
0.0454813913,
0.0342152491,
0.075112775,
0.0291149113,
0.0055364161,
-0.1009032503,
0.0010977557,
0.0243989993,
0.0040251338,
0.010409696,
0.0050154082,
-0.0212583002,
-0.0285867248,
0.0040107146,
-0.0403999463,
0.0007184356,
-0.004135631,
0.0459560417,
0.0251399204,
-0.0009761248,
0.0056766849,
0.0422784388,
-0.0487548709,
0.0302222446,
0.0432057604,
-0.0330056287,
0.0033199433,
0.0010411876,
0.024042761,
-0.0556448027,
-0.0205202568,
-0.0016930574,
0.0144264475,
0.0091948695,
0.0198691227,
0.1093995497,
0.0000810989,
-0.0605431832,
-0.0073588802,
-0.050234627,
-0.0196363516,
-0.0311497264,
0.0220630057,
0.0235449802,
0.0018450612,
-0.0183372162,
0.0102963783,
0.017709082,
-0.014156593,
-0.0138059435,
-0.0015205727,
0.0314157829,
0.0061399415,
-0.020869758,
-0.0272814855,
-0.0251016878,
0.0105809728,
0.0181923583,
-0.0638015792,
0.00647741,
-0.00342424,
2.545e-7,
0.0147042517,
-0.0124179451,
0.0395654999,
-0.0179753155,
0.0095288195,
0.020879399,
-0.0111632729,
0.0539076589,
-0.0399587154,
-0.0081713237,
0.0299190413,
0.0286746118,
0.0626144782,
-0.0031162014,
-0.1408113688,
0.0366444737,
-0.0741734654,
-0.0250433702,
-0.047891479,
0.0025073676,
0.007991394,
0.1047761217,
0.0446267277,
-0.0041601039,
-0.0104850922,
-0.0154803926,
0.052542612,
0.0090311104,
-0.0142536331,
0.0190515332,
0.00679636,
0.001750585,
-0.024403289,
-0.00910223,
-0.0089962864,
0.0655328855,
0.0088836467,
0.0969815999,
-0.0095132822,
0.0162146464,
-0.028642457,
-0.0086785788,
-0.0271590631,
-0.055021733,
0.0686136484,
-0.0337725319,
-0.0066399965,
-0.0107274642,
-0.0282550938,
0.0411059335,
0.0343670398,
0.03544892,
-0.0030338767,
0.0199242812,
0.0563903004,
-0.0348271616,
-0.0253224634,
-0.048651766,
-0.0453898013,
-0.0063566077,
-0.0529884398,
-0.0377527773,
-0.0188283566,
-0.0214180164,
0.035261564,
-0.0424931832,
0.0031631915,
2.436389973e-34,
0.0073234322,
0.0110203652,
0.0195918791,
0.0181979463,
0.0077890893,
-0.0696731284,
-0.0403770953,
-0.0249575861,
0.0122979954,
-0.0560718961,
-0.0191349704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10314v1 | Dynamic Named Entity Recognition | 2023-02-16T15:50:02 | 2023-02-16T15:50:02 | Tristan Luiggi, Laure Soulier, Vincent Guigue, Siwar Jendoubi, Aurélien Baelde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a challenging and widely studied task that
involves detecting and typing entities in text. So far,NER still approaches
entity typing as a task of classification into universal classes (e.g. date,
person, or location). Recent advances innatural language processing focus on
architectures of increasing complexity that may lead to overfitting and
memorization, and thus, underuse of context. Our work targets situations where
the type of entities depends on the context and cannot be solved solely by
memorization. We hence introduce a new task: Dynamic Named Entity Recognition
(DNER), providing a framework to better evaluate the ability of algorithms to
extract entities by exploiting the context. The DNER benchmark is based on two
datasets, DNER-RotoWire and DNER-IMDb. We evaluate baseline models and present
experiments reflecting issues and research axes related to this novel task. | [
0.0353823416,
0.0070251259,
0.0053820885,
0.0126885669,
-0.0042406977,
0.0576696023,
-0.0175923426,
0.0176282078,
0.0119513106,
-0.0575852282,
-0.0183424409,
-0.0524647832,
0.0138201071,
0.0172954928,
0.0176390838,
-0.0581690446,
0.0269744005,
-0.0268045552,
0.0084206145,
0.0401115306,
-0.0274488423,
-0.0079831695,
-0.03354555,
-0.0129540265,
0.0011168005,
0.0263810139,
-0.0272128899,
0.0081655532,
0.0627824664,
-0.0762189105,
0.011492732,
0.0137595842,
0.0182100032,
0.0306873135,
0.0000016899,
-0.0336734429,
-0.0292581934,
0.0034448702,
-0.0529598743,
-0.0318507291,
0.0126453014,
-0.0100223543,
-0.0238603223,
-0.0085954089,
-0.0068971114,
-0.0783224925,
0.0201369468,
0.0319543742,
-0.0129826711,
0.071697697,
-0.0165183451,
-0.0111561595,
0.0545211695,
-0.016623158,
-0.0039286213,
-0.0339466073,
0.035247419,
-0.0274526477,
0.0076987729,
0.0036396361,
0.0052185277,
0.014196693,
-0.0119674224,
0.0477492176,
0.0263455492,
0.0697328746,
-0.0475101992,
0.0293403827,
-0.0283000935,
0.0949365124,
-0.0062318482,
0.0291023944,
0.0531745888,
-0.0058551612,
-0.0349448211,
-0.0461481847,
-0.0270787645,
-0.0218451228,
-0.0511013158,
-0.0207611863,
0.0139479814,
0.0475271977,
0.0288991444,
-0.0030422227,
0.0058704712,
0.0153656416,
0.0167903434,
-0.0449375808,
-0.0023381077,
0.0059432108,
0.0146616865,
-0.05947515,
0.0259516537,
0.0328139551,
0.0443387367,
0.0371346772,
-0.0206386521,
0.0047066323,
-0.0092977034,
-0.0551052578,
-0.0183183458,
0.0126655614,
0.0012519651,
0.0497808494,
-0.0601467453,
0.030029634,
-0.0328583084,
0.0085435444,
0.0666928962,
-0.0120621826,
-0.0658462942,
0.0130943051,
-0.0233772267,
0.0534971878,
-0.0026638138,
-0.0188579131,
-0.0351171456,
0.0181620792,
0.0014476028,
0.0155596556,
-0.0246249828,
-0.0102973133,
-0.0261938088,
0.0094785877,
-0.0105666379,
-0.0137781883,
-0.0248920117,
-0.017687479,
-0.0131228361,
-0.0387011245,
-0.0055438438,
-0.0464164168,
0.0633731931,
-0.062819235,
0.0257585756,
0.0857810676,
0.0256042015,
-0.0977887735,
-0.0760666281,
-0.0083411131,
-0.0076833069,
-0.0302304011,
-0.0156390704,
-0.0251355041,
0.052700717,
0.0043186741,
-0.0149662877,
-0.0129340477,
0.0168458037,
-0.0023383894,
-0.0441425741,
0.079869464,
-0.0118927844,
-0.0116157196,
0.029887436,
0.0056521413,
0.0162371621,
0.0284992699,
0.042074699,
0.019801667,
0.0480227545,
0.0261271819,
0.0236775074,
0.0559205972,
0.0138748158,
0.0007484336,
-0.0136159034,
0.0367978103,
-0.0178260747,
0.0062739216,
0.0192961078,
0.0138899963,
-0.0322066508,
-0.0032956363,
0.0331833884,
0.0288506914,
0.0307502337,
-0.0027076367,
0.0376193114,
-0.0086973887,
0.0118611995,
-0.0115726832,
-0.0337190107,
0.0164856631,
-0.0287424847,
0.0322602391,
-0.0191037394,
0.056549225,
-0.0166774951,
0.0211037565,
0.0046807122,
-0.017181661,
0.0106099509,
0.0131264385,
0.0654069707,
0.0139518427,
-0.0744638741,
0.0478161983,
0.0244567171,
-0.0169803724,
-0.0141970655,
0.0005211218,
0.0153141245,
0.053514272,
0.0514542498,
-0.0600488223,
-0.0577980541,
-0.0403835662,
-0.009866517,
0.0372486562,
0.0104600899,
-0.0466247909,
0.0589047223,
-0.0212502237,
-0.0219339877,
0.039358221,
0.0075273532,
0.0490397811,
0.0668916404,
0.0660054684,
0.0150578599,
-0.0042555896,
-0.0305436458,
0.0460102782,
-0.0333155543,
-0.0515214093,
-0.0202057939,
0.040281795,
0.0087574134,
0.0332073756,
-0.0202391483,
-0.0496457443,
0.0139649184,
-0.0484652296,
-0.0135674467,
0.004616749,
-0.0241962671,
-0.034685649,
-0.0082427077,
-0.0041608345,
-0.0279921796,
-0.0392244048,
-0.013661894,
-0.049564518,
-0.0124984747,
0.0266085491,
0.035040129,
-0.008129742,
0.011324266,
0.0208782461,
0.041545637,
-0.0360391252,
0.0944266021,
-0.0116743166,
0.0195218883,
0.0316803679,
0.0039541922,
-0.0121704563,
-0.0547770523,
-0.0292144325,
0.0290389191,
-0.0124969175,
-0.0316788703,
0.009889299,
-0.0252067354,
-0.0467585847,
-0.0228248499,
-0.0475598909,
0.0017892082,
-0.0026379118,
0.050584767,
0.0091448613,
0.0421075784,
-0.038982261,
-0.0183809977,
-0.0069759251,
-0.0250557065,
-0.0542084575,
0.0105083827,
0.0393237025,
0.0340022705,
-0.0361152366,
-0.0093899202,
0.0016050385,
-0.0598311685,
0.0308595784,
0.0114956452,
-0.0668006539,
-0.0215863213,
0.0297324285,
0.0089393733,
0.0056394604,
0.0149986865,
0.0101207606,
-0.0195877403,
0.0256918352,
0.0120871579,
0.075528264,
-0.020899063,
0.0173574537,
-0.05463719,
-0.0386021808,
-0.0503444299,
0.0478330776,
-0.0150287813,
0.0699526742,
0.0002488597,
-0.0481455103,
0.020683866,
0.0888681114,
-0.0317999497,
0.033382237,
-0.0372386761,
-0.0098002702,
-0.0086056357,
0.0114109684,
-0.0172512699,
0.0096744234,
-0.0329336934,
0.0198523942,
-0.0342705473,
0.0022751032,
0.0535664856,
-0.0411114618,
-0.0170552265,
0.0081757251,
0.0037897404,
-0.0364734977,
0.0471314155,
0.0079335961,
0.0028203062,
0.0241717771,
-0.0801901743,
-0.0014041917,
0.0474239141,
0.0043249624,
-0.0237815436,
0.0600128099,
0.0120192077,
0.0133096892,
-0.0209504906,
-0.0273925643,
-0.0423951522,
-0.0039781067,
-0.0381836556,
0.0081651043,
-0.0622914322,
-0.0411041677,
0.0017824183,
0.0480115898,
0.0001371252,
0.0724153742,
0.0229012705,
-0.0170054007,
-0.0426689796,
0.0604665801,
0.0104939034,
0.0181498993,
0.0016698203,
0.0085712699,
0.0236638989,
0.0060368883,
0.0457214378,
-0.0239260811,
0.005778118,
0.0099072661,
0.0155969094,
-0.056353882,
0.0092896735,
0.0013963841,
0.0093821716,
-0.0581115447,
-0.0222040284,
0.0744528472,
0.0126234889,
-0.0439970791,
-0.0183251891,
0.0511961095,
0.0207402911,
0.0312463157,
0.0240649972,
-0.0766528249,
-0.0482515059,
0.0186383445,
-0.0030481552,
-0.0117743937,
-0.0889306664,
-0.0030289954,
-0.1032529473,
-0.008494853,
-0.0400375389,
-0.0221557412,
0.0314262137,
-0.0325942822,
0.0169769078,
-0.0172255673,
-0.0059402976,
-0.0249121822,
-0.0107739232,
-0.0064323889,
-0.0038940716,
-0.0042366078,
-0.0694696084,
0.0522194728,
-0.0285933074,
0.0353685506,
0.0426785499,
0.0341464877,
-0.0229701046,
-0.0002407904,
0.0214037281,
-0.0521275364,
-0.0138971899,
0.0124403229,
0.0614237003,
-0.0567928627,
-0.0103529952,
-0.0310897864,
-0.0033792804,
-0.0328982994,
-0.0303747393,
0.0130637838,
0.0609074384,
0.0098481858,
0.033232905,
-0.0062095374,
-0.0498069301,
0.0332176723,
0.0821666345,
0.0117692854,
-0.0312706158,
-0.0214611143,
0.0025019255,
0.0068301554,
-0.0652221069,
0.0123911584,
-0.0032302437,
-0.0461093634,
-0.038477838,
-0.0624238402,
-0.0320485495,
0.0174586624,
0.064645566,
0.0164201222,
-0.0200869367,
0.0310778245,
0.0243354142,
-0.0871938318,
0.0206394773,
0.0003662149,
0.0206632651,
-0.0498188995,
-0.0220720824,
0.0078849057,
-0.006262219,
-0.0410793945,
0.0412170663,
-0.0798939168,
-0.0642921478,
0.0304196719,
-0.0091191856,
0.0204757694,
0.0643423572,
-0.0214480758,
-0.0132710719,
0.0516493693,
0.0128821637,
-0.0288903285,
-0.0083589172,
0.0017758467,
0.056690786,
-0.0091757495,
0.0240689609,
-0.0442170277,
0.0047847722,
0.0399126634,
0.0303902384,
-0.0658438951,
0.0102720978,
-0.017500734,
0.0134175308,
0.0198219921,
-0.0050860345,
-0.0570998676,
-0.0531908758,
0.0280107297,
0.0256058853,
0.0235579107,
-0.0077058841,
-0.0180348754,
0.0128226597,
-0.0050892704,
-0.0315603428,
0.0762185752,
0.0034575586,
0.01788049,
-0.0343712829,
-0.0044886209,
0.0415132344,
0.0469404534,
0.0097630601,
-0.0303729456,
0.0087429071,
0.0653254092,
0.0225121267,
0.0528692305,
-0.036718972,
0.0338734053,
0.011221637,
-0.0164292268,
-0.0322471671,
0.0022051239,
-0.0643046498,
0.0617162883,
-0.0241615977,
0.0852477103,
0.0138596436,
-0.0117828548,
0.0317773409,
-0.0030308748,
-0.011293292,
0.0477121957,
-0.0068758745,
-0.0231607389,
-0.0228703003,
0.024708759,
0.0445221551,
-0.0303882435,
0.0249699447,
0.0704783276,
-0.0040869238,
0.0271709301,
0.0265315399,
-0.0004869782,
-0.0450219736,
0.0191829652,
0.0315972976,
0.0052792714,
-0.0066980044,
0.0270778034,
-0.0529635102,
-0.0475802086,
0.0641373396,
-0.0493258908,
0.0080601219,
-0.0236732047,
0.0001839328,
0.0014049133,
0.0363706015,
-0.0337615721,
-0.0241737664,
0.0112618124,
0.020495031,
-0.0346969515,
-0.0120764161,
-5.926050528e-33,
-0.0373549126,
0.0076290183,
0.0057269768,
-0.0105120568,
-0.0273340717,
0.0667321905,
-0.012582588,
-0.0148016755,
0.0195401739,
-0.0425168723,
-0.0164092258,
0.0205574036,
0.0355905369,
0.0184248388,
-0.0122416345,
-0.0474381782,
0.0336602069,
0.0211498961,
-0.0199935157,
0.0174322911,
0.054705523,
0.083249703,
0.0678109005,
-0.0627383515,
0.024465574,
0.0163744967,
-0.0032477241,
-0.0017539341,
0.078455314,
0.0585388467,
-0.0633586124,
-0.0204733908,
0.0225577857,
-0.0355639495,
0.0114919478,
0.0480472632,
-0.1815665662,
0.018012248,
-0.0728667229,
0.0557327792,
-0.0017207161,
-0.0383669883,
0.0341806859,
-0.0183335245,
0.0231272727,
0.0006014234,
0.0245741662,
-0.0164708402,
-0.0261445623,
-0.033196032,
-0.0526262261,
0.0673187152,
0.0154857291,
0.0432321653,
0.0451138504,
-0.0185768101,
0.030372683,
0.0171653051,
-0.1096626371,
-0.0172749143,
0.0017408503,
-0.0268400442,
0.0037709347,
0.0388840996,
-0.0095181717,
0.0472972132,
0.0583332181,
-0.0140522122,
-0.0281574037,
-0.0254908595,
0.0103062345,
0.0159975104,
-0.0462699346,
0.054683391,
0.082449533,
-0.0139879854,
-0.0570262671,
-0.0002895955,
0.0413466468,
-0.0066599688,
-0.0033314389,
-0.0201674607,
-0.0791141093,
0.0171766207,
0.0101562887,
-0.003499792,
-0.044562187,
-0.0061704167,
0.0357720666,
0.042019438,
-0.0467320792,
0.0402060673,
0.0307705961,
-0.0150798792,
-0.0348632596,
-0.0099158641,
0.0317928903,
0.0292097069,
0.0074711107,
-0.0017760261,
-0.0434811041,
-0.0505093671,
-0.0056864731,
0.026141597,
0.0292502921,
-0.016995348,
0.0585169941,
0.0172578916,
-0.0818037167,
-0.0156052886,
-0.0131300082,
0.0552669615,
-0.0091255112,
0.0636895299,
0.0238058493,
-0.0142272459,
-0.0071062008,
0.0121486206,
0.0737544075,
0.0115321483,
0.0031004555,
0.0340483189,
0.0221451633,
0.0521567762,
-0.0066061281,
-0.022388611,
0.0109640267,
-0.0365199521,
0.0051325322,
-0.072555691,
0.0122855734,
0.022941174,
2.511e-7,
-0.0071504838,
-0.0065655387,
0.0536448844,
-0.0246603899,
0.0068365489,
0.0074969684,
0.0197476,
0.0423559695,
-0.0445002653,
0.0056648687,
-0.0099658612,
-0.0205373522,
0.0093496982,
0.0260175876,
-0.091056563,
-0.0445753448,
-0.0184544846,
0.0141450595,
-0.0533776321,
0.0044146511,
-0.0120645016,
0.057014402,
0.0003999588,
-0.0071870317,
-0.0339971296,
-0.0725362226,
0.0514074154,
0.0294156373,
0.0420864932,
0.027110111,
0.0080278656,
0.0713547394,
-0.0362116583,
0.0213027336,
-0.0147109777,
0.0441507511,
0.017344987,
0.0492452011,
-0.0155286286,
-0.0172308944,
-0.0021706705,
-0.0632450357,
-0.0027266315,
-0.0138650695,
0.0762598813,
-0.058350943,
-0.0075626345,
0.0059811845,
-0.0170676019,
-0.0146140829,
0.0055379989,
0.0001722827,
-0.0044968929,
0.0564974472,
0.0268085506,
-0.0345667265,
-0.0047415937,
-0.108703427,
0.0182719883,
0.0140925031,
-0.0102106296,
0.0223084167,
-0.029532576,
-0.0026638731,
0.0210119374,
-0.0567345805,
0.0023673661,
2.405568833e-34,
-0.0166059714,
0.044701878,
-0.0523928516,
0.0496526435,
0.0051865117,
-0.0356517248,
-0.0513083823,
-0.0151200751,
-0.006799846,
-0.0445553884,
-0.0063356026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08374v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08374v3 | Efficiency 360: Efficient Vision Transformers | 2023-02-16T15:43:32 | 2023-02-23T19:36:20 | Badri N. Patro, Vijay Srinivas Agneeswaran | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformers are widely used for solving tasks in natural language
processing, computer vision, speech, and music domains. In this paper, we talk
about the efficiency of transformers in terms of memory (the number of
parameters), computation cost (number of floating points operations), and
performance of models, including accuracy, the robustness of the model, and
fair \& bias-free features. We mainly discuss the vision transformer for the
image classification task. Our contribution is to introduce an efficient 360
framework, which includes various aspects of the vision transformer, to make it
more efficient for industrial applications. By considering those applications,
we categorize them into multiple dimensions such as privacy, robustness,
transparency, fairness, inclusiveness, continual learning, probabilistic
models, approximation, computational complexity, and spectral complexity. We
compare various vision transformer models based on their performance, the
number of parameters, and the number of floating point operations (FLOPs) on
multiple datasets. | [
0.008779401,
0.0414675102,
-0.0147816595,
0.0653186738,
-0.0472439416,
-0.0293838568,
0.0535432771,
-0.0296106599,
0.0079189176,
-0.0517452657,
-0.0338123813,
0.0204004571,
0.0089745009,
0.025307674,
-0.0280555952,
-0.0874105394,
-0.0172042884,
-0.031754002,
-0.0479624383,
-0.0164945032,
-0.0391744189,
-0.0324664749,
0.0053692372,
0.0386366919,
-0.051496394,
0.0100793783,
-0.0002197075,
-0.0111210104,
0.013485631,
0.0296410564,
-0.0113217793,
0.0491217114,
0.0358137861,
0.0198987201,
0.0000022137,
-0.0028271927,
-0.0351296216,
0.0357070677,
-0.0022338778,
-0.0113386111,
0.0476718247,
-0.0147974193,
0.0077264155,
0.0588553511,
-0.0323338956,
-0.0009908126,
0.0854985118,
0.051217746,
0.0415028669,
0.0413880236,
-0.0287719108,
-0.0235103965,
-0.0024196291,
-0.0186008904,
-0.0317823589,
-0.0170065984,
0.0148741184,
-0.0689930543,
-0.0648982674,
-0.0155352056,
-0.0640738755,
0.0527264811,
0.0025394468,
0.0146293631,
0.0484528951,
0.0186959319,
-0.0280319322,
-0.0735135227,
-0.0248491261,
0.0065325024,
-0.0353891961,
0.0280811433,
0.0305331685,
0.0086242436,
0.0251156166,
0.0109243151,
-0.0177308749,
0.0311119594,
-0.0049161077,
0.0244034361,
-0.0765631199,
0.0386981741,
-0.0163124595,
-0.0074142581,
0.0198475067,
0.0169709027,
0.0123288371,
0.0476595983,
-0.017008068,
0.0074474812,
-0.0042887158,
-0.0270216744,
0.0266050845,
0.020552218,
-0.0041814395,
-0.0329736099,
-0.0645887181,
-0.0151974922,
-0.0202619899,
-0.032864958,
0.0273819026,
-0.0203676317,
-0.0059541957,
0.0479129292,
-0.0043946207,
0.0700580627,
-0.0419486426,
0.0513358563,
0.0039990027,
-0.0288594086,
-0.0090082856,
0.0063937739,
-0.0395486131,
0.0289681945,
-0.0232738052,
-0.0303689875,
-0.0467921644,
0.0408383533,
-0.0583589673,
-0.0045785811,
0.0251395293,
0.0194582939,
-0.0151684219,
0.0001371749,
-0.0283148959,
0.0041575888,
0.0507161133,
0.010014602,
-0.0359368473,
-0.0592790358,
0.0209582169,
-0.0051954864,
0.0308130682,
0.0047669057,
0.0213077851,
0.0779386908,
0.0236497838,
-0.0602873564,
0.0133955777,
-0.0217263754,
0.0224863719,
-0.0257102437,
-0.0042518312,
-0.0390932597,
0.018404033,
-0.0400527343,
0.009042359,
-0.0047952733,
-0.0217460822,
0.0198931061,
-0.0167355649,
0.0603276789,
0.0013279595,
0.0094851423,
0.0313363783,
0.0208074097,
-0.0289132614,
0.0179413222,
0.0339018181,
0.0078477059,
0.0468711406,
-0.0426672697,
0.0598658696,
0.0162555948,
-0.0214780178,
-0.0476980172,
0.0346972458,
0.0162872039,
-0.0422526263,
-0.0361842737,
0.0034223117,
0.0588374808,
-0.0028885524,
-0.0603581406,
0.0362136289,
0.0221015196,
-0.0057139788,
0.009118096,
-0.0525364019,
0.022775108,
-0.0078911213,
-0.0309084449,
-0.0379852168,
0.0663749948,
-0.0045849285,
-0.0615592077,
-0.0301454309,
0.0268437453,
-0.0306933131,
-0.0044453107,
0.0186270345,
-0.0605690405,
0.0073921806,
0.0391607955,
0.0147102792,
-0.0029722734,
-0.0290726945,
0.0606525168,
-0.0394044556,
-0.0464617126,
-0.0324173719,
-0.0980925411,
-0.008433939,
0.0382351242,
0.0463799238,
0.0006383486,
0.0614509657,
-0.0493363589,
-0.0069113206,
-0.027972145,
-0.0082788477,
0.0171431955,
0.0701979771,
-0.022337649,
-0.0755002722,
0.027249096,
-0.0049664532,
0.0051328968,
0.0035544105,
-0.0053239325,
-0.0005647584,
-0.0049396926,
0.038331937,
0.0190453921,
0.067263633,
-0.0332566276,
0.0579789281,
0.0370932631,
0.0262918808,
0.0110981464,
-0.0032483409,
-0.0148664778,
0.0276532397,
-0.0084896013,
0.0051256632,
0.0184225421,
-0.0060451892,
0.0720214322,
-0.0067060888,
-0.0832603574,
0.02846683,
0.0987338945,
-0.0433486588,
-0.0159958433,
-0.0064327582,
-0.0404461548,
-0.0090552624,
-0.0054034954,
0.0317185447,
-0.036587555,
0.0672381446,
-0.0257799439,
-0.0171782728,
-0.0145648671,
-0.0197262969,
-0.0403469503,
-0.0665487573,
0.0589462034,
-0.0137599697,
-0.0142616099,
-0.0001010153,
-0.0251052659,
0.0068131369,
0.0187895168,
-0.0109468149,
0.0274414252,
-0.022880448,
-0.0350456424,
0.0112240333,
-0.0426162705,
-0.0178765003,
-0.019248236,
-0.0120772198,
0.0400905982,
-0.0428799875,
-0.0358103067,
0.0594680198,
-0.0483699553,
0.0053690048,
-0.0112287924,
0.0059903837,
-0.0889005139,
0.0518667884,
-0.0536668003,
0.0564495064,
0.030375056,
0.0174090154,
-0.0006071479,
-0.0387582332,
-0.0013224268,
0.0281416718,
0.0497882888,
0.0113934195,
-0.0037065428,
-0.0488262735,
0.028548602,
-0.0043728342,
0.0603981055,
0.0242325552,
0.0300518181,
0.0446492434,
0.0492692925,
0.039327763,
-0.0121183498,
-0.0336563662,
-0.0273273196,
-0.0246794391,
-0.0159114618,
-0.0077752387,
-0.0109046483,
0.0032095953,
-0.0312870555,
-0.020515129,
-0.0136691509,
0.0055311183,
-0.0392494872,
0.000127276,
-0.0052050264,
0.0098080123,
-0.0052939747,
-0.0003858038,
-0.0471676998,
0.0240592752,
-0.0142034348,
0.0113129355,
0.0295393728,
-0.0175049454,
0.0015752969,
0.0458636805,
0.0407289006,
0.0422075428,
-0.0166410971,
-0.0374014527,
-0.0241249129,
0.0086628217,
0.0835828707,
-0.073308304,
0.0365622826,
-0.0118289553,
-0.0335460268,
-0.0598138236,
-0.0493358448,
-0.050509464,
-0.0404383428,
0.0093444409,
0.0249318425,
-0.0075688423,
-0.0409938209,
-0.0523494631,
0.0154732615,
0.023079589,
0.0471414216,
0.0303201359,
-0.027740512,
0.0067713913,
0.0201058313,
0.0073361527,
0.042215459,
-0.0029227363,
-0.0042275158,
-0.0153506184,
0.0807346925,
0.0476249121,
0.0321653448,
-0.0139335776,
-0.0391060263,
0.0387587622,
0.0101962071,
-0.0229795985,
0.0246584769,
0.0201782174,
-0.0248057432,
0.0500869229,
0.0263832174,
-0.0160260312,
-0.063286446,
-0.0140082836,
0.0517508835,
-0.0160283484,
0.051475931,
-0.0090320762,
-0.056678798,
-0.0084269634,
0.0351873785,
0.0503831021,
-0.0371888466,
-0.046802558,
-0.0144266207,
-0.0367214829,
0.033476606,
-0.0366160646,
0.0174731743,
-0.0865448415,
-0.0290004425,
0.0239304099,
-0.060345158,
0.0011720004,
-0.043645069,
-0.0241251383,
-0.0357404239,
0.0131555414,
-0.0083567593,
0.0008382128,
-0.0084758978,
-0.0522348508,
-0.0315298699,
0.0328781046,
-0.0050274222,
0.0017671274,
-0.0809806958,
-0.0340780281,
-0.0040385984,
-0.0114267012,
0.009682091,
0.0697844177,
-0.003825919,
-0.011466397,
0.0007904462,
0.0279171504,
0.029619256,
0.0142966146,
-0.0316622183,
0.0563179366,
-0.0116122905,
-0.0056878808,
-0.0046499618,
-0.0381592289,
-0.0014105411,
0.0460130684,
-0.0372921526,
-0.0283533242,
-0.0131354518,
-0.0003654986,
0.0513509475,
-0.0205445699,
-0.0367457941,
0.0437072217,
0.0213395953,
-0.1197071075,
-0.0047752196,
0.0772113726,
-0.0041858498,
0.0112183625,
0.0123595288,
-0.0640160367,
0.028640341,
0.04289262,
-0.1171603277,
-0.0039796736,
-0.0136826355,
0.0529410802,
-0.0544749536,
0.0104725175,
0.0477011278,
0.0055784653,
-0.0337105468,
0.0147838406,
-0.0848183632,
-0.0249896497,
0.0556904934,
0.061268162,
0.0094233034,
-0.0134920999,
0.0218440872,
-0.0419751368,
0.032526426,
0.0901519433,
-0.0109861614,
0.0381549336,
0.0771000162,
-0.0649760365,
-0.0277350135,
0.013384576,
-0.0432871841,
-0.0107538756,
0.0314232036,
-0.0494899675,
-0.0122359702,
-0.0381806158,
-0.0282590222,
0.0074835569,
0.0635266155,
-0.0307208076,
0.0653922185,
0.0012899749,
0.0519363545,
0.022038633,
0.0312264431,
-0.0430198424,
-0.0200446658,
0.008509486,
0.0067535611,
0.0170329995,
0.0772011876,
0.0333690718,
-0.0577317402,
0.0012709558,
0.0336808152,
0.0001864875,
-0.0645260885,
-0.0224421415,
0.0247714017,
-0.0212057065,
0.0183232259,
0.0769858286,
0.0082000457,
0.0123827308,
0.0286830068,
0.0107255569,
0.0167540889,
-0.0123858172,
0.0423126854,
-0.0225406867,
-0.0467778631,
-0.0170310568,
0.0240554176,
0.0178673137,
0.0350161679,
-0.0427818,
-0.0687954351,
-0.0052215471,
-0.0278309248,
0.0427669398,
-0.0067175291,
-0.0080071418,
0.0537642986,
-0.0028828385,
0.0158325378,
0.0059514875,
0.057714168,
-0.0073526325,
-0.0319414362,
-0.0488946028,
-0.0245032739,
-0.0648813993,
-0.0059374594,
-0.0129963551,
-0.0402723141,
0.03358097,
0.0241094436,
-0.0193190519,
-0.0412788838,
0.0094027938,
-0.0641817302,
0.050350707,
-0.0247197952,
0.0329182968,
0.0197675955,
0.0324901529,
-0.0262336619,
-0.0179834422,
-0.0385609418,
0.0024621554,
0.0264499653,
0.0187448431,
-6.149149437e-33,
0.0128020495,
-0.0276339389,
-0.0170681365,
0.0451537594,
0.0026923337,
0.0025982172,
0.0298043936,
-0.0074028592,
-0.0350631289,
-0.025651535,
-0.0143820969,
0.0194443986,
0.0164984949,
0.0467265286,
-0.0085255234,
-0.0408810824,
0.0829817504,
-0.0289269593,
-0.0250249542,
0.0095049357,
0.0394382104,
0.0184669569,
0.0353266075,
-0.0780492947,
-0.0475743301,
0.0538440011,
-0.0533138365,
-0.0013049652,
-0.0069262618,
0.026737377,
-0.0125455586,
0.0228368286,
0.0197104681,
-0.0252712406,
-0.0128944777,
0.0283686016,
-0.0727508664,
0.0231170859,
-0.0530380011,
0.0984081328,
-0.0135698169,
-0.0278939903,
0.0438225381,
-0.0247833878,
-0.0264559202,
-0.0749055818,
0.0021634407,
-0.022210855,
-0.0130441897,
-0.020981323,
0.0286265779,
0.000523906,
-0.0143979201,
-0.0302588269,
0.0921457782,
0.0322364233,
0.0183460694,
-0.0030829473,
-0.0513987206,
-0.0001479285,
0.0225392953,
0.000484921,
0.0214060545,
0.0282156263,
0.0401680768,
0.031332694,
0.0509117171,
-0.0541177914,
-0.0210245382,
-0.0441098958,
-0.0007447267,
0.0683982819,
0.0485602506,
0.0362827256,
0.0643826649,
-0.0344087519,
-0.0369988121,
0.0111815892,
-0.0767093822,
0.0110393604,
0.0338565409,
-0.0138362171,
-0.0310094673,
0.0144263124,
-0.0136112552,
-0.0151573075,
-0.0264730919,
0.033199545,
-0.0112758698,
0.0423792154,
-0.0341099203,
0.0441449322,
0.0460077114,
-0.0757671446,
-0.0071990117,
0.0254165363,
0.0464866199,
0.0322667956,
0.0232452918,
-0.0350220352,
0.0142466547,
-0.0095177628,
0.0496478714,
0.0022262086,
0.0299831126,
-0.0195641555,
0.0250205398,
0.1006553248,
-0.0695500672,
-0.0200862028,
-0.0109584564,
0.0673879981,
0.0292793289,
0.0196979344,
0.0187747143,
-0.0002030552,
-0.0168066788,
0.0301829968,
-0.03013313,
0.0307484977,
-0.0237898007,
0.0263951048,
-0.0001956095,
0.0233985223,
0.0152421957,
0.0016769771,
-0.010383931,
-0.0229937807,
0.0326142535,
-0.0377766192,
-0.0403042547,
-0.0153160933,
2.955e-7,
-0.0479346961,
0.0041903565,
-0.0202892348,
-0.0140723819,
0.0248943307,
0.0563560463,
0.0279795621,
0.0551346876,
-0.0198405385,
0.0100060562,
-0.0179086979,
-0.0085536465,
0.0507866442,
-0.0066436627,
-0.0320137478,
-0.0441914387,
0.015544774,
0.0201801527,
-0.0110776601,
0.0120366653,
0.0400338098,
0.1012036353,
0.0049495231,
-0.0261887237,
0.0394374803,
-0.0102386242,
0.0354611017,
-0.0453863107,
0.0561506897,
-0.0823818222,
0.0328598097,
0.0535522252,
0.0209602583,
0.0171702467,
-0.0379843079,
0.0250765942,
-0.020504443,
0.0869037211,
0.0067794621,
-0.0283307526,
0.0077360831,
-0.0223844368,
-0.0417151861,
-0.0030282489,
0.0370257907,
-0.0162390713,
-0.0557885244,
-0.01819654,
-0.0051178285,
-0.0317597017,
0.0286726505,
0.0038378218,
0.0219235905,
-0.0009994996,
0.0217045173,
-0.0361250751,
0.005216267,
-0.040669471,
0.0318848789,
-0.0744635686,
-0.0177404098,
-0.0101594301,
0.0171305332,
-0.0189913101,
0.0446774811,
0.062940076,
0.0016311797,
2.572972545e-34,
0.0035057908,
-0.0100065283,
0.0061105732,
0.0234843232,
-0.0210144017,
-0.0246470738,
0.0653321594,
-0.0385383517,
-0.0135953641,
-0.0366177708,
-0.0212327261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08362v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08362v2 | Conversation Style Transfer using Few-Shot Learning | 2023-02-16T15:27:00 | 2023-09-21T23:14:02 | Shamik Roy, Raphael Shu, Nikolaos Pappas, Elman Mansimov, Yi Zhang, Saab Mansour, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conventional text style transfer approaches focus on sentence-level style
transfer without considering contextual information, and the style is described
with attributes (e.g., formality). When applying style transfer in
conversations such as task-oriented dialogues, existing approaches suffer from
these limitations as context can play an important role and the style
attributes are often difficult to define in conversations. In this paper, we
introduce conversation style transfer as a few-shot learning problem, where the
model learns to perform style transfer by observing only a few example
dialogues in the target style. We propose a novel in-context learning approach
to solve the task with style-free dialogues as a pivot. Human evaluation shows
that by incorporating multi-turn context, the model is able to match the target
style while having better appropriateness and semantic correctness compared to
utterance/sentence-level style transfer. Additionally, we show that
conversation style transfer can also benefit downstream tasks. For example, in
multi-domain intent classification tasks, the F1 scores improve after
transferring the style of training data to match the style of the test data. | [
0.0164269898,
0.0357502662,
-0.0024373645,
0.0262676291,
-0.0421972945,
0.0057221074,
0.0209527463,
0.0030606773,
-0.0270728301,
-0.056684684,
-0.0792238861,
-0.0480462126,
0.0205719657,
-0.0001479259,
0.0280937254,
-0.055890277,
0.0078165606,
0.0230881795,
0.0492009595,
0.0361104123,
0.0504706837,
0.0206449088,
-0.0171161611,
0.0066633499,
0.0113777816,
-0.0377411656,
-0.0131590711,
0.0520215668,
0.0342557915,
0.0393742397,
0.0382805131,
0.0475556925,
0.007441666,
-0.0364831686,
0.0000016163,
-0.0214825347,
-0.0166053642,
-0.0440535769,
0.0222130977,
-0.0304838568,
0.0753599629,
-0.0121692251,
-0.0026370944,
-0.004302992,
-0.0202431455,
-0.0267884843,
0.0453785881,
0.1040057316,
0.0568631887,
0.0969259739,
-0.0487848669,
-0.0642825812,
-0.0074457522,
-0.0254089031,
0.0232161116,
-0.0836908966,
0.0116776647,
-0.0044752997,
-0.0286211297,
0.0467142239,
0.006532839,
0.0097945686,
-0.0274919812,
-0.0243670437,
0.0203700326,
-0.0129496083,
-0.0641859248,
0.0366098508,
0.0113941357,
0.1026890576,
-0.0007863995,
0.0000894942,
-0.0025920551,
-0.00987266,
0.0304244552,
-0.0408626199,
-0.0812742189,
-0.0335809179,
-0.0018616574,
0.0092042498,
-0.0369212627,
0.0171849057,
-0.0123669486,
-0.0159778185,
-0.0046988209,
-0.0179390721,
-0.0018959552,
-0.0093382606,
-0.0226514209,
-0.0025201107,
0.0117539484,
-0.0376351066,
-0.0024656006,
-0.0067446493,
-0.0222856104,
0.0020441506,
-0.0713923797,
0.0029830625,
-0.0132094426,
-0.0211162269,
0.0601688474,
0.003746205,
0.0262151342,
0.0283488892,
-0.002147876,
0.0190292709,
-0.0118405875,
0.0051237582,
-0.0542571545,
-0.0229413398,
-0.1082390845,
0.0019540992,
-0.0542497523,
0.0104122059,
0.0044524283,
-0.0197973419,
-0.0109327119,
0.0122550679,
-0.0145005379,
-0.0266945027,
-0.0099246753,
-0.0173435751,
-0.0321502127,
-0.0078730984,
0.0442897454,
0.0692728236,
0.014104737,
0.0553748533,
0.0238353331,
-0.0061955573,
-0.0379089378,
0.0462393761,
0.0468324795,
-0.0261012651,
-0.0201179795,
0.0086807916,
-0.0469790325,
-0.0163087808,
-0.0361652151,
-0.0161120072,
-0.0283826832,
-0.041867353,
-0.023394946,
-0.0249805953,
0.0012339802,
-0.0297482405,
-0.0072474736,
-0.0224001594,
-0.0208821893,
0.0257095713,
-0.0337406248,
0.060832303,
0.0490091406,
-0.0049225832,
0.0315505974,
-0.0088079311,
-0.0131359054,
0.0609534867,
0.005015966,
0.0288617015,
-0.0003143447,
-0.0171654597,
0.0113855321,
0.0292324889,
0.0415727124,
0.0182208698,
0.0002406234,
-0.0133792721,
0.0233731009,
0.0415779687,
0.0444766581,
0.0233824216,
-0.0209230818,
0.0063514761,
0.0705016702,
-0.0224929545,
0.0528126918,
0.0031016641,
0.0245721079,
0.0684769005,
-0.0174472779,
0.0123633062,
-0.021809347,
0.0139087113,
-0.0283256229,
0.0016748856,
0.0226640701,
-0.0276342463,
-0.0627366081,
0.0096163386,
0.0308781285,
0.0019098235,
-0.002218503,
-0.0382238664,
0.0210457034,
0.06623362,
-0.0599351153,
0.02085503,
-0.0136431465,
-0.0098261256,
-0.0445523448,
-0.0129872272,
-0.0124691213,
0.0646636859,
-0.001210981,
0.0060378765,
-0.0444771312,
-0.0394179784,
0.0399975367,
-0.00096249,
0.0267193336,
-0.0334229246,
0.0766304657,
-0.0438574739,
0.0008921297,
-0.0387386866,
-0.0173276067,
-0.0178871099,
-0.0574212,
0.0251232646,
0.0085936869,
-0.0054060495,
0.0237327088,
0.0117396414,
-0.0051062955,
-0.0286963042,
0.0599782765,
0.0226820409,
0.0054355171,
0.019231217,
-0.0162629876,
-0.0138686281,
-0.0433536619,
-0.0223937239,
0.0058897841,
0.0433001705,
-0.0637077838,
-0.1106690243,
-0.020915376,
-0.000875583,
-0.0180694666,
-0.0032760589,
-0.061452426,
-0.0621267073,
-0.0053688609,
-0.007954414,
-0.0001265545,
-0.0114080412,
-0.0009685866,
0.0237283316,
0.0421347022,
-0.030818725,
0.0181677453,
0.0503662899,
-0.0325816609,
0.012764669,
0.002517778,
0.0083267912,
-0.0103211161,
0.0426812172,
-0.0364888161,
-0.0109257549,
-0.0027072809,
-0.008114486,
0.0382818431,
-0.0442010611,
-0.0121181868,
-0.096431151,
0.0019029544,
-0.0091806985,
0.0128081115,
0.0221988298,
0.0032665199,
-0.003549306,
-0.01852208,
-0.0773469582,
0.0175362602,
-0.0272537656,
0.0013115567,
0.0647412464,
-0.0053909821,
-0.0087589873,
-0.0329294503,
0.017483769,
0.0059169186,
0.0614962205,
-0.0180100482,
0.0007202592,
-0.0401241258,
0.0140486406,
0.0152471391,
-0.0055312142,
0.0104289865,
-0.0151760029,
-0.0083977794,
-0.018950142,
0.0243020616,
0.0728895366,
0.0490457863,
-0.0142311333,
-0.0297989734,
-0.0070500667,
-0.0419373848,
0.0129829301,
0.012766744,
0.0311729256,
-0.0245157108,
-0.0205854084,
0.050882671,
0.032325048,
0.0183876008,
0.03742145,
-0.0617336482,
0.0124510657,
0.061153587,
-0.0372184329,
0.0147924442,
0.0257596225,
-0.0091274548,
-0.0146101993,
-0.007842551,
0.0132504646,
0.0464594886,
-0.0197720565,
-0.0327491611,
-0.0054683732,
-0.0050004902,
-0.024942236,
0.0313918442,
-0.0382535085,
0.0156766195,
0.0441719629,
-0.0328541994,
-0.0519804023,
-0.0246366672,
0.0651487932,
0.0074341027,
0.0478806905,
-0.030667156,
0.0058756629,
-0.0278003961,
-0.0438651741,
-0.020319473,
-0.0700570717,
-0.0098806247,
0.0197507124,
-0.0033978438,
-0.0065944279,
-0.0292605516,
0.0021818511,
-0.0183234476,
0.0460637286,
-0.0188837554,
-0.0116467569,
0.0073171165,
0.0754495114,
0.0291905459,
0.0033946023,
-0.0697304979,
-0.0052441056,
0.0469721742,
0.028920956,
0.0195799768,
0.0352255553,
-0.0182324219,
-0.0176531859,
0.0118445791,
0.0157808643,
-0.0438305289,
-0.0058358135,
0.1091414988,
-0.014083025,
-0.0410636552,
0.1063953042,
0.0183229819,
-0.0479525365,
-0.041572772,
-0.0065392489,
0.0176049955,
-0.0072323936,
0.0274595823,
-0.0840890855,
-0.0843207389,
-0.0153763462,
-0.0016609235,
0.0249804836,
-0.0053205513,
-0.0241702665,
-0.0761828274,
0.0155673008,
0.011806868,
-0.0901902914,
-0.0160779003,
-0.0121451048,
0.0312762409,
-0.0338393189,
0.0052546333,
-0.037731722,
0.0037755519,
-0.0335530676,
0.0027471618,
-0.001287518,
-0.0445514768,
0.0396946184,
-0.0009283716,
0.0647498593,
0.0420191772,
0.0575900339,
-0.0014930314,
0.0036804632,
0.0094437161,
-0.0104655679,
0.0073265438,
0.0121901063,
0.0806148797,
-0.0276045911,
-0.0080931177,
-0.0025230986,
0.0147415334,
-0.0117679788,
-0.0191076975,
0.0177348815,
-0.0018816339,
-0.0334918462,
-0.0248503685,
-0.010672437,
0.0079958839,
0.044044137,
0.0663264394,
0.0467802398,
-0.0467799418,
-0.0273065362,
-0.0331750587,
-0.0101589421,
-0.0757541731,
-0.0081193242,
-0.0156248305,
-0.0055748648,
0.0206922721,
-0.0983534828,
-0.0234521572,
0.0004112762,
0.0387119427,
-0.0273874756,
-0.0252680872,
0.0001254534,
0.0029360675,
-0.0186937451,
-0.0449840948,
-0.019130988,
0.0620199814,
-0.0020901645,
-0.0224158578,
0.07028009,
-0.0247675553,
0.0107107954,
0.0059885965,
-0.0882997289,
-0.0351679586,
-0.0349083804,
0.0474362597,
-0.0001146784,
0.0565243475,
-0.0214306582,
-0.0303425901,
0.0152194547,
0.0632870644,
0.015863331,
-0.0168715548,
0.0897388533,
0.0018214786,
0.0037973111,
0.0461566932,
-0.0078748483,
0.0573527701,
0.0130360108,
0.0227238834,
-0.0422696918,
-0.0466302112,
0.0074448413,
-0.017714601,
0.0249439068,
0.0387598276,
-0.0200694669,
0.0266816001,
0.0249013733,
-0.0213645883,
-0.025045136,
-0.0621003322,
-0.0455380566,
-0.0015609277,
-0.0068842215,
-0.0015285,
0.0157505982,
-0.0153061505,
0.0434322394,
-0.0539850332,
-0.0208401568,
0.044929482,
0.0150991706,
-0.0261943173,
0.0133532835,
-0.0370955318,
0.0162595175,
0.0401554666,
0.0292253718,
-0.0186699498,
0.0709778145,
0.0437097326,
-0.0007501805,
-0.0023115303,
0.0219747685,
-0.0642644018,
0.0282418635,
-0.0445057191,
-0.0176043473,
0.0201001186,
-0.0231852625,
0.0581537485,
0.0178640597,
0.0288972985,
-0.016447356,
0.0848641694,
-0.0347802043,
-0.0254378561,
0.0085707661,
0.0060780118,
0.0093871402,
0.0059775584,
0.0824230984,
-0.0156761371,
0.0129033588,
-0.0029974116,
0.01299218,
-0.0451553985,
-0.0067176335,
0.0415102728,
0.0049615148,
0.0417399071,
0.0023350595,
-0.0152569618,
-0.0363095589,
0.0332643613,
-0.077684544,
0.0226827785,
0.0144968256,
0.0280713122,
0.0492884405,
0.0018707626,
-0.028708186,
-0.0318390578,
0.0108865397,
0.0259321984,
0.018391462,
-0.0255730469,
-5.211488817e-33,
-0.0207498483,
0.0093082637,
0.004635402,
0.0290967356,
-0.0230804347,
-0.0434268042,
-0.0554807931,
-0.0311468225,
-0.0391576961,
0.0320548229,
-0.0217375457,
0.0195071418,
0.0097368499,
0.0629110783,
0.0195384342,
0.0141622471,
0.0489105433,
0.0000488849,
-0.0346729495,
0.0518354401,
0.0481360741,
0.0145295197,
0.0872183219,
-0.0639792383,
-0.0331559889,
-0.0019823853,
-0.0536419377,
0.0121225454,
0.0692263916,
0.0129336724,
0.0318383984,
0.0038158007,
0.0192384087,
-0.0765082166,
-0.0307452735,
0.0357914045,
-0.0451819412,
-0.032396961,
-0.0006016517,
0.0054484131,
0.0043699029,
-0.0139432037,
0.0109536061,
-0.0316284858,
0.0699940845,
-0.0392917059,
0.0348378383,
-0.03645752,
-0.005250731,
-0.0604945496,
-0.0613810159,
0.0150838057,
-0.022852201,
-0.0672023445,
0.0127536012,
0.0471547619,
-0.0022335565,
-0.0195049196,
-0.023886729,
0.0110140797,
-0.0569559783,
-0.0105375731,
-0.0009783062,
0.0487556197,
-0.0199746992,
0.0396600701,
-0.000986436,
0.0738552287,
-0.024757551,
-0.0178178642,
0.0111688254,
0.0630450249,
-0.0117103681,
0.0915837809,
0.0011719492,
-0.0035357263,
-0.0246321633,
0.0371434167,
0.0260083862,
0.0193013586,
-0.0137182605,
0.0378024355,
-0.0252794027,
-0.0157678649,
-0.0046722349,
-0.0143440627,
-0.0119652515,
0.0008151851,
-0.0041208002,
-0.0097682886,
0.0206030458,
0.0242339969,
0.0683029145,
-0.0474337675,
-0.0243828632,
0.0103806425,
-0.0535936952,
0.0423036106,
-0.0359690189,
-0.0438061319,
-0.0513604879,
-0.0472257361,
0.0698949024,
0.0766506419,
0.0324992947,
0.0193408113,
0.1063729972,
0.0158193335,
-0.0521735623,
-0.046089083,
0.0013756832,
0.0167573895,
-0.035420116,
0.0252068415,
-0.0202785395,
0.0241783783,
-0.0540116318,
0.0801597834,
-0.0073974328,
-0.0219166186,
0.0147991702,
-0.0213039201,
0.0137527548,
0.0060822647,
-0.0444806367,
-0.0183770917,
-0.0117775351,
-0.0592599101,
-0.0102481442,
-0.0236596093,
-0.0144705717,
-0.0026713051,
2.332e-7,
-0.0173702668,
0.0293567292,
0.0158331636,
0.0092568975,
0.0180166084,
0.0782051161,
0.0078648664,
0.0574425533,
-0.0085230749,
0.018880384,
0.0584282205,
-0.0018154206,
0.0794812888,
0.0069246367,
-0.1095662639,
-0.0065597505,
-0.038350638,
-0.0109693836,
-0.0039422307,
-0.0233037174,
0.0793015584,
0.0662534684,
0.025498854,
-0.0195378494,
0.0368480198,
-0.0149925929,
0.0771732032,
-0.0009287243,
0.0101727983,
0.029425079,
-0.0098182168,
-0.0415192544,
-0.0319568329,
0.04708983,
-0.0237264149,
-0.0177197736,
0.0164516345,
0.0828222558,
-0.0030858074,
-0.013377184,
-0.0329038352,
0.0139575014,
0.0360287763,
-0.0139201526,
0.0525410026,
-0.0718044564,
-0.0524014086,
-0.0593065508,
-0.0486034155,
0.0141640315,
0.0169568229,
0.039806053,
-0.0140783302,
0.0416723713,
0.0229491293,
0.0087755034,
-0.0249167345,
-0.0941418782,
-0.0095664524,
-0.0008217187,
-0.0142530417,
0.0142473774,
0.0065475809,
-0.0175038222,
0.0281876493,
-0.0166704413,
0.0343263261,
1.53009152e-34,
0.0231952891,
-0.0296452232,
0.0165897161,
0.0583339334,
-0.0125766629,
0.0126330582,
-0.0090534389,
-0.0104820421,
0.0519739501,
-0.0753213465,
0.0140012214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09302v1 | Bridge the Gap between Language models and Tabular Understanding | 2023-02-16T15:16:55 | 2023-02-16T15:16:55 | Nuo Chen, Linjun Shou, Ming Gong, Jian Pei, Chenyu You, Jianhui Chang, Daxin Jiang, Jia Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table pretrain-then-finetune paradigm has been proposed and employed at a
rapid pace after the success of pre-training in the natural language domain.
Despite the promising findings in tabular pre-trained language models (TPLMs),
there is an input gap between pre-training and fine-tuning phases. For
instance, TPLMs jointly pre-trained with table and text input could be
effective for tasks also with table-text joint input like table question
answering, but it may fail for tasks with only tables or text as input such as
table retrieval. To this end, we propose UTP, an approach that dynamically
supports three types of multi-modal inputs: table-text, table, and text.
Specifically, UTP is pre-trained with two strategies: (1) We first utilize a
universal mask language modeling objective on each kind of input, enforcing the
model to adapt various inputs. (2) We then present Cross-Modal Contrastive
Regularization (CMCR), which utilizes contrastive learning to encourage the
consistency between table-text cross-modality representations via unsupervised
instance-wise training signals during pre-training. By these means, the
resulting model not only bridges the input gap between pre-training and
fine-tuning but also advances in the alignment of table and text. Extensive
results show UTP achieves superior results on uni-modal input tasks (e.g.,
table retrieval) and cross-modal input tasks (e.g., table question answering). | [
0.0004899369,
0.0829111636,
-0.0059725256,
0.0001302286,
-0.0197350718,
0.0127597274,
0.0055876737,
0.0165657885,
-0.0369600616,
-0.0322380997,
-0.068371594,
-0.0313891321,
-0.011985668,
0.0237514433,
0.043804884,
-0.0258768275,
0.0533073097,
0.0076675811,
-0.0615340956,
0.0223899167,
0.0361899957,
-0.0285932738,
-0.0172173623,
0.0027536361,
-0.0038052693,
-0.0263248943,
-0.044637803,
0.001614202,
-0.0306520592,
0.0023536771,
0.0281453449,
0.0862538964,
0.0413792431,
0.0031745604,
0.0000019539,
0.0376305953,
-0.0530001223,
-0.0184046943,
0.0216614921,
-0.0457003154,
0.0544491708,
-0.0592613928,
0.014503167,
-0.0011510871,
-0.0342652053,
-0.0542295836,
0.0133567853,
0.0745241344,
0.0382741652,
0.0596470647,
-0.0142817972,
-0.0356450342,
0.0053139632,
-0.0057634907,
0.0372897945,
-0.0318649486,
-0.0041097607,
-0.0016823135,
-0.0052370038,
-0.0044353711,
-0.0070780441,
0.0622680523,
0.0182161238,
0.010787487,
-0.013945248,
0.0438458771,
-0.004776428,
0.0302770417,
-0.0181227792,
0.1125786155,
-0.0018320979,
-0.0415342338,
0.0022045947,
0.0154566318,
0.0190496873,
-0.0066776662,
-0.0359973498,
-0.0365602747,
0.0120761329,
-0.0011550189,
0.0074602822,
-0.0211350713,
-0.0039258385,
0.0057512717,
-0.0127951642,
0.0157561488,
-0.0041759987,
-0.0519996509,
0.001350219,
-0.0301119704,
0.0045605558,
-0.0292241685,
0.0322276428,
0.0530622937,
-0.0363074355,
0.0057197195,
-0.0229170993,
-0.0804814771,
0.0103204912,
-0.0086086076,
0.0448986031,
0.0430142395,
-0.0396274589,
0.0260108057,
-0.049590189,
0.0144762974,
-0.0429133624,
0.0636210889,
-0.0389295556,
-0.0122895641,
-0.0260341018,
-0.0026236512,
-0.0388821214,
0.0119077209,
-0.0711223409,
-0.0120620588,
0.0379801653,
0.0073894607,
0.0038257127,
0.0084833205,
0.023553947,
0.029966794,
-0.0417165831,
-0.0253637992,
-0.0142698176,
0.0490995124,
-0.027613692,
0.0445032939,
-0.0203462169,
-0.0645248592,
-0.0103557687,
-0.0264478941,
0.0272632912,
-0.0270647854,
0.059798833,
0.0912884846,
-0.084020488,
-0.0199454017,
-0.0508226305,
-0.0028918346,
-0.0381402932,
-0.0502307229,
0.0059576752,
-0.0127595775,
0.0373192504,
0.0061016497,
0.0114899138,
-0.0447016396,
-0.0116741518,
0.0469118021,
0.0026966347,
0.0797656029,
0.0130899232,
0.0160984192,
-0.0007711552,
-0.0239613801,
-0.0146219898,
0.049896013,
0.0391407311,
-0.0180539228,
-0.0421373732,
-0.0137225157,
-0.0352958106,
0.0418428294,
0.0390117764,
-0.0239113122,
-0.0384424403,
0.0273278672,
0.0257891733,
0.0252615716,
0.0258008055,
0.0303507391,
-0.0123657668,
0.0223137755,
0.0683525726,
0.0065133604,
0.0334703363,
0.0813770518,
0.018166855,
-0.0051753512,
0.0006232982,
0.0645995587,
-0.0257522222,
0.0223292094,
-0.0231892038,
0.0039945287,
0.0569322668,
0.0024906788,
-0.0436038673,
-0.05531995,
0.0495187491,
0.002203431,
0.0299484283,
-0.0058823265,
0.0763461813,
0.0272092596,
-0.0858439952,
-0.026156934,
0.0089853471,
-0.0389626175,
-0.0004148492,
0.0043318737,
0.0293348748,
0.0364994258,
0.0163778439,
-0.082231991,
-0.0168609079,
0.0030086827,
0.0123669533,
0.014557342,
0.0445942692,
-0.0161158238,
0.0297000613,
-0.0036734252,
-0.0123020178,
0.0276793987,
0.0016921591,
0.0082072672,
-0.0217211321,
-0.0045819194,
-0.013674384,
-0.0489622913,
-0.0135353105,
0.0454602204,
0.042518869,
-0.0189864617,
-0.0285753403,
0.0107440371,
-0.0097175818,
-0.0022495168,
-0.0079738796,
0.0114647113,
0.0309266187,
-0.0396420211,
0.044663582,
-0.0264655426,
-0.0639868975,
-0.0198096614,
0.0245716684,
0.0092740906,
-0.0394950435,
0.042177517,
-0.0076064258,
-0.0502538383,
0.0256900471,
-0.0019402478,
-0.010365556,
-0.0288185403,
0.0012030726,
0.0118103558,
0.0281936191,
-0.0170468036,
0.0639567301,
0.0195074268,
0.03643943,
0.0203110203,
-0.0756671652,
0.0369964801,
-0.0156345814,
0.0095914667,
-0.0302136466,
-0.0351205058,
0.03576665,
0.0244254749,
0.0207789093,
-0.0573447868,
-0.0235716105,
-0.0962356031,
0.0397652127,
-0.0369017124,
0.0167977717,
0.0392813832,
0.0030943062,
-0.0067373738,
-0.0509282164,
-0.0607998893,
0.0013434213,
0.0149597405,
-0.0042761238,
0.0626019612,
0.0236889645,
0.0228532162,
-0.0542739332,
-0.0274146087,
-0.0171002559,
0.0153499739,
-0.0448011346,
-0.0315902643,
0.001717622,
0.0389577448,
0.0341443233,
0.0544411018,
0.0073942007,
-0.0359460302,
-0.0019767398,
-0.0100622224,
0.0549759492,
0.0703663081,
-0.0272974838,
0.0122360466,
-0.002581452,
-0.0153710488,
-0.0459698252,
0.039787665,
0.0059223063,
0.0029384692,
-0.0312074795,
-0.021861501,
0.0249690861,
0.0893907845,
-0.0319666751,
0.0070358138,
-0.0464633889,
-0.0249099378,
0.0142684719,
-0.0213160571,
-0.0543487258,
0.0821106881,
-0.0124779819,
0.0033334792,
-0.0474976487,
0.0080127586,
0.023702763,
-0.0560466908,
-0.0029742077,
-0.0193571337,
-0.0156342853,
-0.0287573673,
0.055812683,
0.0066077192,
-0.0004308407,
0.0200890172,
-0.0318803638,
-0.0915719867,
0.0057912017,
-0.0014867756,
-0.0267845467,
0.0863497257,
-0.0246083122,
0.0137244985,
-0.0273225121,
-0.0377077647,
-0.0084479107,
-0.0846882761,
-0.0089577679,
0.0349028967,
0.0244771112,
0.024794884,
-0.0410297215,
0.007125291,
0.0457205735,
0.0685009584,
-0.0208719205,
-0.0105983727,
-0.0723066851,
0.0791876242,
0.0217600483,
0.0284736603,
-0.0532914847,
-0.0195720457,
0.0222804546,
0.027418226,
0.0180704705,
-0.0315386653,
-0.0369535238,
0.028319953,
0.0378119722,
-0.0154022537,
-0.0347247534,
0.0409233458,
0.0073504671,
-0.0692207739,
-0.0210444611,
0.0703144297,
0.0013821435,
-0.0212277565,
-0.0339837633,
0.044780679,
0.0344024375,
0.019391058,
0.0376165435,
-0.0621713735,
-0.0577900223,
-0.010786402,
-0.0356248058,
0.0344156101,
-0.0177992806,
-0.0210359134,
-0.0741770193,
-0.027811937,
-0.0101841623,
-0.0583552308,
-0.0813021138,
0.0045718043,
0.0263750665,
-0.012774528,
0.0611301064,
0.0248294752,
-0.0314194709,
0.0075037396,
0.0422977656,
0.0000121694,
-0.0445828065,
-0.0295237415,
-0.0672182664,
0.0127916234,
0.0496140644,
0.03140359,
-0.0567443334,
-0.0480494834,
0.0323356763,
-0.0168005917,
0.0337057114,
0.0170531832,
0.0545658357,
-0.0194964968,
-0.0004169185,
0.0066187712,
-0.0107711777,
-0.0144898538,
-0.005433938,
-0.0224043783,
0.0410711318,
-0.0220116358,
0.0342850946,
0.0352929011,
-0.0050365906,
0.0087794624,
0.0545819029,
0.0286068209,
-0.024629388,
-0.0504310839,
-0.0051733684,
-0.0339650884,
-0.0740105584,
0.0200232174,
0.0459177606,
-0.0093158493,
0.0053950748,
-0.0270568095,
-0.0191812515,
0.0639615282,
0.0294511262,
0.007656734,
0.0499307066,
-0.0483562499,
-0.0219341405,
-0.0377268158,
0.0318388268,
-0.0499613844,
0.0173208732,
-0.0297676791,
-0.0622531809,
0.0063273371,
-0.0511822402,
-0.0200061221,
0.0195146687,
-0.0475847274,
-0.027285926,
-0.0077692312,
0.0157518983,
0.013599515,
0.0284525882,
0.0219924133,
-0.036173448,
0.0015921877,
-0.022700727,
-0.0828852132,
-0.0248627588,
0.0326602869,
-0.0688765272,
0.013778042,
0.0217092,
-0.0358047746,
-0.0064399051,
0.0195070244,
0.0249187574,
0.0035602765,
0.0006976835,
0.0523679964,
-0.0444510877,
0.0445887372,
0.0459297299,
-0.0132954568,
-0.0340606458,
0.0037481519,
-0.0146602495,
-0.0322064161,
-0.0047276239,
-0.0157395788,
0.0257019419,
0.0141640306,
-0.0383735932,
0.0110948468,
0.017439194,
0.053526558,
-0.0420853831,
0.003905538,
0.0443039611,
-0.0293181092,
0.0054187239,
-0.0065574488,
0.0079742791,
0.0066100168,
0.0080000991,
0.0179879908,
-0.0332472622,
0.036737904,
0.0297216773,
-0.039284274,
-0.0602175929,
0.0678863376,
-0.065272063,
-0.0215006266,
-0.0219507255,
-0.0212343894,
0.0242253244,
-0.0015577758,
-0.0104160523,
0.0227706749,
-0.0093188006,
0.0155034121,
0.0340261459,
0.0298315249,
0.0093237236,
0.0431707017,
-0.0003266404,
0.0003735698,
-0.0182265397,
0.0955939889,
0.0138705783,
0.0142024979,
0.0046938704,
-0.0062518003,
-0.0572606735,
0.0552112162,
0.0377409942,
0.0314457566,
-0.0498106927,
-0.0144748697,
0.0091172401,
-0.0197402593,
0.0575497672,
0.0495676547,
-0.0368064158,
0.0066684247,
0.0341103487,
0.0505045094,
0.0168658402,
-0.0107306018,
-0.0465264693,
0.0222118683,
0.0288570635,
-0.0014671346,
-0.0394665748,
-6.432851693e-33,
-0.0498066284,
0.026001472,
0.0106050428,
-0.0451301634,
-0.0033028712,
0.0024018248,
-0.0527828299,
-0.0268226489,
-0.0097904811,
-0.0029791321,
-0.0379752293,
0.0308650993,
0.0225744843,
-0.003563768,
0.0110668764,
-0.0768451616,
0.0459334366,
-0.0218677558,
0.0225779209,
0.0038487462,
-0.021359764,
0.0518912412,
0.0448341109,
-0.0500500239,
0.0398723334,
0.0080103967,
-0.015915703,
-0.0098767281,
0.0213682,
0.0372500941,
-0.0473299697,
0.0282272026,
0.0385969058,
-0.05281201,
-0.050370533,
0.0653759167,
-0.1442631632,
0.0128542483,
0.0107677449,
0.0362613872,
-0.0573037937,
-0.0310794171,
0.0134299127,
-0.030264305,
0.0047089318,
-0.0002542358,
0.0527022257,
-0.0319255218,
0.019821927,
0.0145358667,
-0.0165479798,
-0.0024024583,
-0.0170831792,
-0.0186308883,
0.0638518333,
0.0523491241,
0.0347672291,
-0.0184322614,
-0.0302499142,
-0.006804219,
-0.0073475339,
0.0356121473,
0.0309650451,
0.0001089613,
0.0023817059,
0.026199894,
0.0216076132,
-0.008463433,
0.0115952352,
-0.0430103503,
0.0043042209,
0.0373177715,
0.0334765837,
0.0436897017,
0.0514135584,
0.0140844267,
-0.0366813615,
0.0731830373,
-0.0191578548,
0.0173383262,
-0.0297510214,
0.0120377038,
-0.0040032542,
0.0034929302,
-0.0262331851,
-0.034986645,
-0.0183134805,
-0.0155628389,
0.0121392822,
0.0066299611,
0.0441278256,
0.0162071548,
0.0589445867,
0.0070412694,
-0.0062087406,
0.0513131469,
-0.0028625105,
0.0132317198,
0.010266521,
0.0099179074,
-0.0295164231,
-0.0551203266,
0.0553619042,
-0.0385959409,
0.0465154089,
0.0313427113,
0.0375856683,
0.0295608398,
-0.071187973,
-0.0335090198,
-0.0359237716,
0.0048092208,
0.0221952852,
0.0351327844,
0.0315653533,
0.0143835936,
-0.0284815971,
0.0513606183,
0.0253753103,
-0.0104921721,
-0.0440921076,
-0.019661298,
0.0219813008,
0.020759102,
0.0099365748,
0.0062384629,
-0.0520910509,
-0.0045904918,
0.0317027904,
-0.0298378728,
0.0065666605,
0.0228957478,
2.556e-7,
0.0798226222,
0.0007358483,
0.0615147837,
0.0064891581,
-0.0105415313,
0.0206418894,
-0.0178559422,
0.013928581,
-0.0319085121,
-0.0380155221,
0.0453793928,
0.0091796909,
0.065558061,
0.0118450383,
-0.0241448693,
-0.0442100577,
-0.0436936803,
0.0108065968,
-0.022461215,
0.0195070356,
0.0576484837,
0.0868109614,
-0.0749287531,
0.0015652903,
-0.0026289204,
-0.0421985127,
0.0508813523,
-0.0635438114,
0.0416579992,
0.0002796336,
0.0139502129,
-0.0202314481,
-0.0118704755,
0.0613997206,
-0.0231178906,
0.0378502756,
0.030755287,
0.0269956589,
-0.0092544183,
0.0136682102,
-0.0091724927,
-0.0395509079,
-0.0229059774,
-0.0519785248,
0.0905001238,
-0.0620761029,
0.0251544937,
0.0338755175,
-0.0058130166,
0.0283452068,
-0.0021982139,
0.022700347,
-0.0308797192,
0.0351101756,
0.0395799652,
0.0083903195,
-0.0368524529,
-0.07376609,
-0.0207742136,
0.0569871254,
-0.0363394395,
0.0175751615,
-0.0392128229,
-0.0673022717,
0.0223150365,
-0.085694015,
-0.0254666675,
2.196728945e-34,
0.0130677046,
-0.0298082903,
0.0307889879,
0.0344440863,
0.0409703329,
-0.04436066,
-0.0032223533,
-0.0233198013,
0.015830785,
-0.1124193519,
-0.0194413438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08351v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08351v2 | A Survey on Event-based News Narrative Extraction | 2023-02-16T15:11:53 | 2023-03-10T20:39:14 | Brian Keith Norambuena, Tanushree Mitra, Chris North | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Narratives are fundamental to our understanding of the world, providing us
with a natural structure for knowledge representation over time. Computational
narrative extraction is a subfield of artificial intelligence that makes heavy
use of information retrieval and natural language processing techniques.
Despite the importance of computational narrative extraction, relatively little
scholarly work exists on synthesizing previous research and strategizing future
research in the area. In particular, this article focuses on extracting news
narratives from an event-centric perspective. Extracting narratives from news
data has multiple applications in understanding the evolving information
landscape. This survey presents an extensive study of research in the area of
event-based news narrative extraction. In particular, we screened over 900
articles that yielded 54 relevant articles. These articles are synthesized and
organized by representation model, extraction criteria, and evaluation
approaches. Based on the reviewed studies, we identify recent trends, open
challenges, and potential research lines. | [
0.0469006076,
0.0458266772,
-0.0285555366,
0.0330550484,
-0.0673252866,
0.0103014307,
-0.0399135798,
-0.0061516175,
0.0178600177,
-0.0344287939,
0.0696713924,
0.0185722113,
-0.0402945243,
0.0820071176,
-0.0800515711,
-0.0639807954,
0.0024821146,
0.0265119914,
0.0623911768,
0.0437562503,
-0.0092088291,
0.0596936867,
-0.0190130677,
-0.0045276517,
-0.0014391197,
0.0301232133,
-0.008469006,
-0.0314475708,
0.0225304291,
-0.0493703298,
-0.0354788825,
-0.034645658,
0.0616058558,
-0.0042802831,
0.0000019734,
-0.0510024801,
-0.0357896984,
-0.0389864892,
-0.0085224072,
-0.0330286175,
-0.001680453,
-0.0575113818,
0.0042843297,
-0.0486541539,
-0.0350492783,
-0.0437866524,
-0.0355592892,
0.0483401231,
-0.0030006536,
0.0747250915,
-0.0376330428,
-0.037478812,
0.0191753861,
0.0525290668,
-0.0390808769,
-0.0187079925,
0.0127662821,
0.010408096,
0.0201281514,
-0.049818147,
0.0158010758,
0.0197556205,
0.013880915,
0.0171671975,
-0.050549522,
0.0583807603,
-0.0123543525,
0.0005973902,
-0.0391052924,
0.0244392268,
0.056328129,
0.0041840849,
0.0540060624,
0.0001553329,
-0.0084047774,
0.0257664733,
-0.0470642895,
0.0587298758,
-0.0342114791,
0.0139672812,
0.0475624651,
0.0136714615,
-0.0367726758,
-0.0024594979,
0.0051277275,
0.0330417864,
0.0178081021,
-0.000518574,
-0.0519222394,
-0.0042254012,
0.0336018689,
-0.0170163792,
0.0278663673,
0.0449821427,
0.0216583852,
0.042174235,
-0.0223398227,
0.0343898088,
-0.050344009,
-0.1360140145,
-0.0243742261,
-0.0008486136,
0.0077458872,
0.0401125997,
0.0232992992,
-0.0305251088,
0.0237633605,
-0.0322973579,
-0.0067668036,
0.020285327,
-0.0578304343,
0.0478973724,
-0.0115442844,
0.046455659,
-0.0192280356,
-0.0021110508,
0.0408906862,
-0.0030141328,
0.0589986742,
-0.0006905618,
-0.0626280233,
0.0069962055,
-0.0495722629,
-0.0107043935,
-0.0289408881,
0.0071462248,
-0.050359495,
0.0000885967,
0.0000041824,
0.0007304576,
-0.0244654175,
-0.0066640256,
0.049478516,
0.005334198,
-0.0179986376,
-0.0040793885,
-0.0377450623,
0.0001567777,
-0.0790376067,
-0.0455464199,
0.0069701974,
-0.0087338584,
-0.0265765842,
-0.0275246017,
0.0452660844,
-0.0038853604,
0.0011329983,
-0.01889956,
-0.0171784963,
-0.014003328,
-0.0591207296,
-0.0309225768,
-0.0153801125,
-0.004978545,
0.0395365767,
-0.0106514134,
0.0228104945,
0.0434412695,
0.0941383839,
0.0642872974,
0.0791672468,
0.0346349217,
-0.0049067936,
-0.030053474,
-0.0195540208,
-0.0096606705,
0.0268181805,
-0.0074558607,
-0.0066074794,
0.0002995583,
-0.0043234387,
-0.0256166607,
-0.0414871275,
0.0023819061,
0.0308846012,
0.0346549563,
-0.0359589718,
0.0203595236,
0.0624622777,
-0.0305739809,
0.0488700196,
0.0567731671,
0.0214552637,
-0.0202855822,
-0.0029653017,
0.0068869758,
-0.0380727053,
0.0498323478,
-0.0105668996,
-0.0224765651,
0.0353744924,
-0.0134236291,
0.0322327577,
0.0080302991,
0.0077285948,
-0.0139429104,
-0.0333001092,
0.0127086546,
0.0423617251,
-0.0276609454,
0.0581221357,
-0.0066459142,
0.0129576279,
0.0109427953,
0.0511999652,
-0.0178001635,
-0.0332998298,
-0.009028649,
0.0206683613,
-0.0216029547,
0.0106916148,
-0.0211531054,
0.0023730912,
0.0211992525,
0.0013065437,
-0.0120833116,
0.0184502676,
-0.0207734238,
0.0037540239,
0.0253232867,
-0.0268172864,
0.0258810092,
-0.0482994504,
0.0464326032,
-0.021438079,
-0.0375202224,
-0.0361867063,
0.0108870249,
-0.0296984334,
0.0123818088,
0.0213747919,
-0.0330975689,
0.0331804194,
-0.0089108758,
-0.006363262,
0.0549605228,
-0.0011722592,
-0.049574323,
-0.0042280317,
-0.0340486802,
-0.038387008,
-0.0290869176,
-0.0218563285,
-0.0225903187,
0.0302052088,
-0.0017438557,
0.008300418,
-0.0055260584,
-0.002916846,
-0.0033267129,
-0.0445221104,
-0.0155576179,
0.101482816,
0.0333864614,
-0.0360203348,
-0.0250731241,
-0.0623969994,
-0.0127055952,
-0.0222324021,
0.0184092857,
0.0304124709,
0.0028278457,
-0.0156282932,
0.0645476282,
-0.0500594899,
-0.0283576194,
-0.0148812365,
-0.0393562503,
0.069281131,
-0.0255529713,
0.0388655774,
0.0344574638,
0.0098626511,
-0.0335698314,
0.0181214102,
-0.0280637573,
-0.0638821125,
-0.0328758657,
-0.0070513431,
0.021127766,
0.0648678467,
-0.0104940012,
-0.0365628451,
0.0150736934,
-0.0496165715,
0.0715659186,
0.0533738807,
-0.0545095317,
-0.0410282053,
0.0003555405,
-0.0236282013,
0.0126498723,
-0.0351990573,
0.0212259125,
0.0082681132,
0.0029061984,
0.0287496634,
0.0895027891,
0.0388942547,
0.073655352,
-0.0254383646,
-0.0436943956,
-0.0025079763,
0.0120019848,
-0.0955185369,
0.0486256182,
-0.0332734473,
-0.0337236896,
0.0548741817,
0.0058918702,
0.02575849,
0.0327363499,
-0.0379184596,
-0.0085196281,
-0.0031023354,
0.0136793451,
0.0379652455,
-0.0124597307,
-0.002764127,
0.0430491827,
-0.0058218092,
0.0271506608,
0.0623125769,
0.0321907252,
0.0899474323,
-0.0351110585,
-0.0224957876,
-0.069040224,
0.0581880957,
-0.0546071939,
0.032044109,
0.0213839971,
-0.0403167754,
0.0075961286,
-0.0359660052,
0.0351113528,
-0.0101323146,
0.0210195314,
-0.0453634746,
0.0045613647,
0.0213534124,
-0.0015197294,
-0.0305375569,
-0.0480646156,
0.0138413068,
-0.0020149467,
0.0147086577,
0.0095416103,
-0.0529883765,
0.0170310475,
0.0225899164,
0.00507002,
0.0020044271,
-0.0138955917,
0.0003582827,
0.0569166578,
0.0534141399,
-0.0063767834,
0.0183697753,
0.0264594331,
0.0060762791,
0.0482630804,
0.052634988,
-0.0026182448,
0.018545121,
-0.0028377702,
0.0137592778,
-0.0801526979,
-0.0082721924,
-0.0065997755,
0.0212122034,
-0.0440824851,
0.0089575695,
0.0827251822,
0.0409653522,
0.0213564392,
0.0127099166,
0.0665373504,
-0.0560531467,
-0.0070306445,
-0.0038162186,
-0.0412179157,
0.0409591645,
-0.0256836861,
-0.0244193748,
-0.0335161872,
-0.0661331713,
-0.0204198696,
-0.0200397614,
0.0048636994,
-0.0052653486,
0.0294650905,
-0.0632313043,
-0.0510607362,
-0.0045651998,
-0.0145129105,
-0.0445288271,
0.0150500238,
-0.0166125968,
-0.0147011951,
-0.0032228471,
-0.0672883168,
-0.022557253,
0.030781785,
-0.0057218028,
-0.0288405921,
-0.0058803339,
0.0442407541,
-0.0031289775,
0.0621861108,
-0.0631400272,
-0.0122916168,
-0.0331650674,
0.0044709891,
0.0434494242,
-0.0632745475,
0.0170985423,
-0.0221089441,
0.0598704107,
0.0566337965,
-0.0392282158,
0.0427534953,
0.0414474383,
-0.0026258829,
-0.0552480444,
-0.002708744,
-0.0083495714,
0.0053754952,
0.0702190623,
0.0296049695,
0.0183038842,
0.0045184153,
0.0069523309,
0.0031487667,
-0.0459146351,
-0.0172524303,
0.0123301633,
-0.0363084376,
-0.0263912026,
-0.02824983,
-0.0718542635,
-0.0170105156,
0.0246583391,
0.0082946233,
-0.0299171805,
0.0760600045,
-0.005254352,
-0.0379646719,
0.0100061866,
-0.0221988112,
-0.03674943,
0.0437858999,
0.0003154387,
0.0130114518,
0.0241547413,
-0.0040181363,
0.054274831,
-0.0126661584,
-0.0031799194,
0.012079211,
-0.0471757688,
0.0018486192,
0.0366088264,
0.0089226272,
0.0144526139,
0.0271570534,
0.0133259026,
-0.0297707003,
-0.0255536046,
-0.0153037729,
0.0272239186,
0.0121500865,
-0.0190305114,
0.0079127681,
0.0270406753,
-0.0375845879,
0.0101192007,
-0.0539429076,
0.0154618006,
0.0413780846,
-0.0084037334,
0.0167872272,
-0.0214387253,
-0.055925075,
-0.080780603,
-0.045418229,
-0.066265218,
0.0130052501,
-0.0212578755,
0.0176403094,
-0.0313321948,
0.0177354291,
-0.0485080853,
0.0196645558,
-0.0486933775,
0.0122628072,
-0.0559312254,
0.0271424688,
0.0475582108,
-0.0271658078,
-0.0324892588,
-0.0234816968,
-0.0031374951,
0.018719878,
-0.0209559891,
0.0229836609,
-0.0239586197,
-0.0135297533,
0.0163885541,
-0.0261057112,
-0.0186478663,
-0.0256296545,
-0.0942542627,
0.0442871414,
-0.01399503,
0.0485509858,
0.0255195368,
-0.0277638901,
-0.0011116371,
-0.0211573578,
-0.0034133149,
0.05380762,
-0.0022778695,
0.0230760574,
0.011221936,
-0.0175044686,
0.0214911178,
-0.0453960784,
0.0370786041,
0.0150893787,
-0.0363110565,
0.0764525905,
0.0205625538,
-0.0416253805,
-0.0267222282,
-0.0496232882,
0.0294478983,
0.0350739285,
-0.0038164014,
-0.0426826403,
-0.0705156177,
0.0626898706,
0.0573653765,
-0.0127946064,
0.0237935428,
-0.0288128536,
-0.048761718,
0.0636883825,
0.0607502535,
-0.0352424048,
-0.0480919518,
0.0457300134,
-0.0304384995,
-0.0037213131,
0.0242338069,
-6.377219953e-33,
-0.0164807774,
0.0241105482,
0.0024697231,
0.0610286668,
-0.0497495122,
0.0405125432,
-0.034306705,
-0.0407954641,
-0.036693234,
0.0299655758,
0.0091995392,
-0.0153268501,
0.0131388968,
-0.0565635897,
0.003302939,
0.0103523983,
0.0053178077,
-0.0088401828,
-0.035901662,
0.0206609927,
0.0540883429,
0.0201674961,
0.0575728379,
-0.0559941679,
0.0633696467,
-0.0003904724,
0.0239394903,
-0.0142004089,
0.1329412609,
0.0244116746,
0.0028298663,
0.0032376228,
0.030067442,
-0.0631993338,
0.0027988409,
0.0079809083,
-0.1036169901,
-0.0005078227,
0.0411070473,
0.0030236414,
0.0236958303,
-0.0148500763,
-0.0025170355,
0.0101648141,
-0.0051323916,
-0.0108210091,
0.0429826342,
-0.042576462,
0.0044687674,
-0.0151666105,
-0.069812268,
0.0321480557,
-0.0119685372,
0.0140810804,
0.0054396563,
0.0153436866,
0.0328798369,
0.0163094588,
-0.0254704822,
0.0242248457,
-0.0400050394,
0.0316008814,
-0.0209398195,
-0.0337594524,
-0.0283719711,
0.0468667895,
0.0000513122,
0.007406564,
-0.0666359589,
0.0811276361,
0.0107257888,
0.0337360278,
-0.0240810998,
0.0450090878,
-0.0068393121,
-0.0419576317,
-0.0773511827,
0.0653822944,
0.0699815452,
-0.0206933413,
-0.0092279315,
-0.0035807791,
-0.0390706994,
0.0020363089,
0.0244529117,
-0.0164611265,
0.0290018786,
-0.0103577394,
-0.0171874929,
-0.002537674,
-0.0318912975,
0.0919725448,
0.0116211046,
-0.0196515787,
0.0020101955,
-0.0030449883,
-0.0445497632,
0.0376554094,
-0.0118390005,
0.0366791189,
-0.0395977348,
-0.0113860024,
0.0181406401,
0.0404458866,
0.0279773418,
-0.0362311527,
0.0109073697,
0.0065329038,
0.0169742834,
-0.0125211505,
0.0176117849,
-0.0173661653,
-0.0299555603,
-0.0391788483,
0.0024133129,
0.0544939525,
0.0039049673,
-0.0518278331,
0.0363571309,
0.0233562551,
0.0379212238,
-0.0479402132,
-0.0057088914,
0.0262170546,
0.0312349983,
0.0144845638,
0.0065332865,
0.038440641,
-0.0314271152,
-0.0025016104,
-0.0119505487,
-0.0047232634,
2.606e-7,
0.0092371162,
0.0232571959,
0.0611250177,
0.0247084107,
-0.0253110174,
0.0032707967,
0.0234162509,
0.0161871202,
0.0211654603,
-0.080614239,
0.0096691456,
0.0691596344,
-0.0000664053,
0.0539909676,
-0.0404782034,
-0.0225476921,
-0.0337221585,
-0.0349305905,
-0.1066994891,
-0.0048904242,
0.1151496023,
-0.012202505,
0.0245088376,
0.0158406589,
-0.0307906866,
-0.0095608924,
0.0074378345,
0.0080031306,
-0.1031522304,
0.0473349355,
-0.0076237815,
0.0104016364,
-0.0577666201,
-0.0268119611,
-0.0116641177,
0.0318607017,
0.0047268895,
0.0235043168,
0.0092513524,
0.0123989321,
0.0159360282,
-0.028015526,
-0.0018038809,
-0.0018409991,
0.0724698082,
-0.052010145,
-0.0251017846,
-0.0528746471,
-0.0442035235,
0.0579554699,
-0.0255316999,
0.0208371449,
-0.037176203,
0.0619395487,
-0.0150046311,
0.0031653722,
-0.0051629627,
-0.0488409624,
0.0303526912,
0.0545616299,
0.0012215143,
0.0076317731,
0.0377603807,
-0.0158814881,
-0.028830979,
-0.0598027669,
0.0570059717,
1.94340601e-34,
0.0090190899,
0.048106622,
-0.0222548041,
0.0181100648,
0.0508474335,
0.0218028761,
-0.0518460646,
-0.0381537601,
0.0231472682,
-0.0134684257,
0.0093906913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08343v1 | Cluster-based Deep Ensemble Learning for Emotion Classification in Internet Memes | 2023-02-16T15:01:07 | 2023-02-16T15:01:07 | Xiaoyu Guo, Jing Ma, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Memes have gained popularity as a means to share visual ideas through the
Internet and social media by mixing text, images and videos, often for humorous
purposes. Research enabling automated analysis of memes has gained attention in
recent years, including among others the task of classifying the emotion
expressed in memes. In this paper, we propose a novel model, cluster-based deep
ensemble learning (CDEL), for emotion classification in memes. CDEL is a hybrid
model that leverages the benefits of a deep learning model in combination with
a clustering algorithm, which enhances the model with additional information
after clustering memes with similar facial features. We evaluate the
performance of CDEL on a benchmark dataset for emotion classification, proving
its effectiveness by outperforming a wide range of baseline models and
achieving state-of-the-art performance. Further evaluation through ablated
models demonstrates the effectiveness of the different components of CDEL. | [
0.0016634166,
0.0435809754,
-0.0136909671,
-0.0057795825,
0.0143292649,
0.0598493442,
-0.0047968845,
-0.0015978049,
0.0696280971,
-0.0305846352,
0.0170930903,
-0.0433167219,
-0.0321474299,
0.020049613,
-0.0013626504,
-0.1052539647,
-0.000687842,
0.0880384669,
0.0037214747,
-0.0488038845,
0.0533725023,
0.0218623299,
-0.0129241217,
0.0450603813,
-0.0625607222,
-0.0204107575,
0.0011051504,
0.015681088,
0.0329842567,
-0.0105028749,
0.0063825985,
0.0492392853,
0.0455810167,
0.0146070989,
0.0000020565,
-0.0258954242,
-0.0162527822,
-0.040413063,
-0.026139468,
-0.0084419698,
0.0405698568,
0.019820096,
-0.0221610852,
-0.0076313838,
0.0122661106,
-0.006671295,
0.114532128,
0.0346363485,
0.0659662262,
0.0474687107,
-0.0354153626,
-0.0054240571,
0.0032350826,
0.0092345998,
0.0016489489,
-0.0093139317,
0.007495543,
-0.0113537684,
-0.0220467504,
-0.039303232,
-0.015028785,
0.0310905352,
0.0091915233,
0.030232653,
0.0349032022,
0.0195372067,
-0.0391035415,
-0.0239270478,
0.0049906662,
0.0500593744,
-0.0105337277,
0.0000859377,
0.0011422737,
0.0190831479,
0.0229915455,
-0.0322868265,
-0.0430754945,
0.0012250481,
0.0034314112,
0.0311709624,
-0.029773375,
0.0871387869,
0.0266673863,
0.0362599492,
-0.0331440978,
0.0012465359,
-0.0272810198,
0.0125327911,
-0.0041667465,
0.046363622,
-0.0749068931,
0.0273094717,
0.0252241697,
-0.0290426835,
0.029120706,
0.0035470407,
-0.0159003623,
-0.0669097528,
-0.0083312895,
-0.0102542667,
-0.005384997,
-0.0269375686,
-0.0156735703,
0.0633838251,
0.0122821154,
0.0062516383,
-0.0062752976,
-0.0445922986,
0.0193973687,
0.0012156831,
-0.0782634169,
0.0087417634,
0.0264053419,
0.0421828963,
0.0213798434,
-0.0530189984,
-0.1140901372,
0.0154590327,
-0.045308806,
0.0019955109,
0.0080747036,
0.05854607,
0.039826002,
-0.0031140607,
0.0247273892,
-0.0078948271,
-0.0182608236,
0.0339724198,
0.0055426722,
-0.0814054012,
0.027392881,
-0.0047025341,
0.0426576994,
0.0044330326,
0.0215921644,
0.0157615803,
-0.0106673762,
-0.0023447024,
0.0177731216,
-0.0130668823,
-0.0518816225,
0.0084413448,
0.0120111564,
-0.0934577882,
0.0713528022,
-0.0092714513,
0.0277041774,
-0.0175975133,
-0.0042443937,
-0.0232899915,
-0.0077464753,
0.0563245639,
0.0000869614,
-0.0010913059,
0.0101943864,
0.0166853927,
-0.0289153811,
0.0157645736,
-0.0250738915,
0.0825181156,
0.0674225911,
-0.0263421386,
0.0509113818,
0.0327420197,
0.0019548489,
-0.0171296056,
-0.0141380755,
-0.0126652159,
-0.0266465079,
0.0187224522,
-0.0298065711,
0.0207518172,
-0.0396496467,
-0.008521161,
0.0121983411,
0.0273522958,
0.0087725343,
0.0462822467,
-0.0584774502,
0.041110754,
0.0150746722,
-0.0783983395,
0.0017448777,
0.0460986607,
-0.0479117781,
-0.029822398,
0.0530518033,
0.0648446977,
-0.0624395646,
-0.0220998693,
0.0040554302,
-0.0322116166,
0.01109902,
-0.0056998362,
0.0421205573,
-0.042082388,
-0.0297346096,
-0.0008573604,
0.0264719762,
-0.0769896135,
-0.0126483161,
-0.0183513518,
0.0063096136,
0.0274466854,
-0.0112693086,
-0.0316872559,
-0.0014280758,
-0.0343564413,
0.0113781691,
0.003810311,
-0.0634274632,
0.0185872726,
0.048241742,
-0.0694769397,
0.0120330928,
0.0135440752,
0.0246549938,
0.0159547143,
0.0245235749,
0.0480744466,
-0.0211898405,
0.0439423099,
-0.0052888412,
0.008941289,
0.0215134677,
0.0274920221,
0.0150981545,
0.0672974139,
0.0500843748,
-0.0006425136,
-0.0133700129,
-0.0639323965,
0.028111862,
-0.0312793814,
-0.0731572136,
0.0179504622,
-0.0567613542,
-0.0815749019,
0.0316333026,
-0.0505905785,
0.0263704527,
-0.0016240581,
-0.0367921628,
-0.0133746359,
0.093580313,
-0.0308031868,
0.0078878216,
-0.0339682698,
0.0122953365,
-0.035172563,
0.0583346449,
0.0104887336,
0.0525920913,
-0.0294487774,
-0.039383091,
-0.0669540837,
-0.0080920458,
0.008173638,
0.0205147211,
-0.0476028845,
0.0071112867,
-0.0281923916,
0.0289247334,
0.0024744177,
-0.0428064689,
-0.0720714852,
-0.0611209795,
-0.0656898022,
-0.0206340533,
-0.0135958754,
-0.0329212956,
-0.0071116658,
0.0125429127,
-0.021272907,
-0.0262104236,
-0.0515615307,
0.0610663109,
0.0199731234,
-0.014643481,
-0.0060414332,
-0.0175313279,
0.031586051,
-0.0443470143,
-0.014715109,
0.0106007149,
0.0442627221,
0.00298186,
-0.0452312417,
0.028001599,
-0.0144050131,
-0.0370608978,
-0.0090509234,
0.0013502976,
-0.0300490838,
-0.0042691277,
-0.0335083902,
-0.0001185374,
0.0592565089,
0.0271265935,
0.0811125487,
-0.0530497134,
0.0094564557,
-0.0409382693,
0.0024319631,
0.0052276771,
0.0650258586,
-0.0138860699,
-0.0192525722,
-0.0241367407,
-0.0014517172,
0.0029805577,
0.0189167131,
-0.054387439,
0.0609389357,
0.0282180123,
-0.0408492126,
-0.0401874967,
-0.0360084139,
0.0473149419,
-0.0609259419,
-0.0408692993,
-0.0710024312,
0.0330058374,
0.0327222198,
-0.0520739406,
-0.0137757193,
-0.0210228153,
-0.0251548477,
0.0687600598,
-0.0157539528,
0.0214466359,
0.0203572661,
0.0045412621,
0.0386477187,
-0.0196658075,
-0.044639945,
-0.0291874055,
-0.0001848628,
0.0418830588,
-0.0116081657,
0.0139499381,
-0.013098387,
-0.0453002453,
-0.0156757217,
-0.0201132074,
-0.0158802606,
0.0218166672,
-0.0044260579,
-0.0451775342,
-0.0124895275,
0.0284246765,
-0.093436636,
0.0141888512,
-0.0167295299,
0.0265453383,
0.0341066159,
0.0067557758,
-0.0297208428,
-0.0067390762,
-0.0531638414,
0.0355545841,
0.0501868017,
0.03693543,
-0.0481811203,
-0.0789664388,
0.0050377557,
0.0027344655,
0.026043633,
-0.0133461477,
-0.0662952587,
0.0308411308,
-0.0192078091,
0.0481708534,
0.0914660618,
0.0072006937,
-0.0611360818,
0.002553677,
0.0147493426,
0.0052058073,
0.0034837867,
0.0116494317,
0.0225100815,
-0.0401650406,
-0.0479589775,
0.0084780771,
0.0074449,
-0.0251293685,
0.0518057682,
-0.0298038907,
0.020702498,
0.0225527193,
-0.0674733371,
0.0025401206,
-0.0031120547,
0.0162970144,
-0.0496433713,
-0.0421793014,
-0.0546577238,
0.0448873974,
0.0021383553,
0.0360691063,
-0.0323611945,
-0.0692945346,
0.0044086496,
-0.0477003679,
0.0452988632,
0.0393791609,
0.0391592868,
-0.0249422919,
-0.0215774849,
-0.0308398288,
-0.0345353223,
-0.0033136662,
-0.0364572629,
0.0585277826,
0.0026850407,
-0.0250311363,
-0.0197942238,
-0.0000311586,
-0.0418532752,
0.0520006455,
-0.0027669847,
0.0359935202,
-0.0467251278,
-0.0470175594,
-0.0601808764,
-0.0158136431,
0.0199159719,
0.0245025102,
0.0277468152,
-0.0110073602,
0.0124963792,
-0.0330740735,
-0.002796622,
-0.0403181948,
0.0155213382,
-0.0535774268,
0.0226835255,
0.0043340567,
-0.0561596379,
-0.0166510735,
0.0270453002,
0.052744098,
-0.0448425375,
-0.0137655428,
-0.0350772105,
0.0078745121,
-0.0494695492,
0.0397122912,
0.0258517507,
0.0139043862,
-0.0181698035,
-0.0181800388,
0.0283292048,
-0.0181027278,
0.0004855962,
-0.0171282981,
0.0033039032,
-0.0477738976,
0.0088530229,
0.046960745,
0.0043199104,
0.0102356756,
-0.0004724367,
-0.0538242273,
0.090664342,
0.0984657928,
0.0378673673,
-0.0054022055,
0.0108295679,
-0.0347424857,
-0.0035148191,
0.001985308,
0.006249798,
0.0863054544,
-0.0396472216,
-0.0477023683,
-0.0814577118,
-0.0149199385,
-0.0455522202,
0.0001770735,
0.0137400264,
0.0085502025,
-0.0622387938,
-0.0021414754,
-0.0499397889,
0.0293633826,
0.0003158332,
-0.0153065072,
-0.0154121239,
0.0241445061,
0.0191365015,
-0.0376868322,
0.0271742567,
0.0530628003,
-0.0018825447,
0.0210959017,
0.040925961,
0.0489860252,
0.0224598125,
-0.0300389417,
0.0460811704,
0.0036192215,
0.005006657,
0.0396361686,
-0.0201726481,
-0.0133836921,
0.0048214565,
-0.0197274182,
-0.0258300025,
-0.0204134397,
0.0961613059,
0.0394474305,
0.0200005043,
-0.0112086376,
-0.0272705145,
0.0371545106,
-0.0464311056,
0.0514766648,
-0.0136217894,
0.0062609669,
-0.0445922315,
-0.0110302474,
-0.0332920253,
-0.0518723466,
-0.0102295149,
0.0092708431,
-0.0070555038,
0.0108336164,
0.0228188075,
-0.1094966605,
0.0258615855,
0.0103583224,
-0.012244639,
-0.0489106961,
0.0458986573,
0.0667830929,
-0.0002499196,
0.0087090833,
0.0440887846,
0.0214123335,
-0.0188300069,
0.0283775125,
-0.0621507354,
0.0304113999,
0.0250326674,
0.0378349945,
0.0401492491,
0.0073258672,
0.0830595419,
-0.0351992324,
-0.0061796731,
-0.0661177933,
0.0043353159,
0.0022026263,
-6.136395323e-33,
0.0179906003,
0.0157658383,
-0.057050921,
-0.048140116,
-0.0497655384,
-0.0028751018,
-0.0048466222,
0.038232211,
0.0199450552,
0.0108777648,
-0.0044398932,
0.0002327071,
-0.0244967043,
0.0239664055,
0.0109561561,
0.0047479803,
-0.0043944367,
0.0180535279,
0.0017867904,
0.0416448377,
0.0531635806,
0.0353657119,
0.0160741992,
-0.0665848777,
-0.0468591936,
0.024350794,
-0.0215290301,
-0.0107612805,
0.0661795884,
0.0488892756,
-0.0030645921,
0.0530240126,
0.0323672146,
0.008450048,
-0.0054330481,
0.0319395028,
0.0067363712,
0.0146877486,
-0.0818411782,
-0.0126331653,
-0.011404709,
-0.0350801907,
0.0560155064,
0.0112298522,
0.0088973586,
-0.009571298,
0.0538764633,
-0.0246530343,
0.0287110321,
-0.0299081057,
0.0228274111,
0.0414083637,
-0.0305601545,
-0.0014377565,
0.0131838331,
0.0505495481,
0.0280930735,
0.0659190789,
-0.0335325971,
0.067094557,
-0.0460692681,
-0.0294026975,
0.0306468774,
0.042111706,
0.0250470843,
0.0668308213,
0.0287976526,
0.0278236642,
-0.0618501827,
0.0353706107,
0.0599995591,
0.0634035096,
0.0601210445,
0.0439695194,
0.0081681684,
-0.0150452517,
-0.0292188041,
0.0667646602,
0.0195995569,
-0.0023350189,
0.0180218089,
0.0341983624,
-0.0520686805,
0.0175886229,
0.0193913877,
-0.0231410898,
-0.0102458177,
-0.0418685935,
-0.0259783696,
-0.029319454,
-0.054400865,
0.002078414,
0.0161927417,
0.0026914817,
0.0062882379,
-0.0131968604,
0.0124800196,
0.0620313063,
0.0387371555,
0.0054272399,
-0.0206751544,
0.0032480792,
0.0572698303,
0.0241842158,
0.0026184469,
0.029912604,
0.0211751368,
0.0316507481,
-0.017142076,
-0.0038294056,
-0.0124572348,
0.0038408816,
-0.0197427012,
0.0242027417,
-0.0240970161,
0.0187999904,
-0.0009546202,
-0.02981578,
0.0004090513,
0.0409134887,
0.0172895826,
-0.0514592156,
-0.0249044504,
0.0187369287,
-0.0157369133,
-0.0185509156,
-0.049241282,
-0.0555196069,
-0.0160074756,
-0.0431440696,
0.011192454,
-0.0263032485,
2.702e-7,
-0.0020718703,
0.0395581499,
0.0240951292,
-0.0505019985,
0.0400220193,
0.0654060245,
-0.0378792807,
0.0051734038,
-0.0029200506,
-0.0050663101,
0.0783428103,
0.0606815889,
0.0241358988,
-0.0174115729,
-0.0263398755,
0.008827135,
-0.0223207884,
0.0573032424,
-0.0144572034,
0.0095119458,
0.0160531811,
0.0932905748,
0.0546988286,
-0.0370903872,
0.0033372373,
0.0114375725,
0.0507208966,
-0.0368315913,
0.0340647846,
-0.000623863,
0.0042814366,
0.0126369856,
-0.022800602,
0.0068782181,
0.0262653157,
-0.0242344793,
0.0333108455,
-0.0239796825,
-0.0167860761,
-0.0216978081,
0.0524760075,
0.0324203484,
0.0046736114,
-0.0336394943,
-0.0010669844,
-0.0508740805,
-0.0184519943,
-0.0436693765,
-0.0637012795,
-0.0076575545,
0.0850830376,
0.0167228952,
-0.0057522301,
0.0145144267,
0.001585478,
-0.0502659641,
-0.0228699818,
-0.104984358,
0.0049179015,
-0.0191914272,
-0.0608996451,
-0.0001372189,
-0.0156342145,
0.0474056453,
0.0308213662,
0.0458762497,
-0.000704748,
1.827091532e-34,
-0.0043941522,
-0.0162185598,
-0.0158910155,
-0.0212539565,
-0.0232905038,
-0.0192136243,
-0.0224214215,
-0.0305490792,
0.0374365039,
-0.0580987483,
0.0035791255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08326v1 | NUAA-QMUL-AIIT at Memotion 3: Multi-modal Fusion with Squeeze-and-Excitation for Internet Meme Emotion Analysis | 2023-02-16T14:29:58 | 2023-02-16T14:29:58 | Xiaoyu Guo, Jing Ma, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes the participation of our NUAA-QMUL-AIIT team in the
Memotion 3 shared task on meme emotion analysis. We propose a novel multi-modal
fusion method, Squeeze-and-Excitation Fusion (SEFusion), and embed it into our
system for emotion classification in memes. SEFusion is a simple fusion method
that employs fully connected layers, reshaping, and matrix multiplication.
SEFusion learns a weight for each modality and then applies it to its own
modality feature. We evaluate the performance of our system on the three
Memotion 3 sub-tasks. Among all participating systems in this Memotion 3 shared
task, our system ranked first on task A, fifth on task B, and second on task C.
Our proposed SEFusion provides the flexibility to fuse any features from
different modalities. The source code for our method is published on
https://github.com/xxxxxxxxy/memotion3-SEFusion. | [
0.020634545,
0.0608307123,
-0.0068375147,
0.0204991885,
0.0099270782,
0.0423796326,
-0.0006273852,
-0.0231926646,
0.016449634,
-0.0585865676,
-0.0215748586,
-0.0507597364,
-0.0073253186,
0.0752888396,
-0.0145010054,
-0.0569077246,
-0.0153370649,
0.0553056858,
-0.0107407691,
-0.0212359689,
0.0320849493,
0.0203146283,
-0.0247538686,
0.043118827,
-0.0731872916,
0.0195428468,
-0.0051850923,
0.0247245338,
0.057218872,
-0.0081305085,
0.007612112,
0.0224487092,
0.0266434327,
-0.000752594,
0.0000022868,
-0.0234382171,
-0.0086750947,
-0.0268221498,
0.0111812809,
-0.0342015475,
0.0475053452,
0.0043144501,
-0.0318895467,
0.0186207406,
-0.0130495895,
0.0454439335,
0.0821723491,
0.0580270402,
0.08957991,
0.0597927272,
-0.04513257,
-0.02117314,
0.0151853291,
0.0004120552,
0.0126056904,
0.0083344085,
0.0165617522,
-0.0554953329,
0.0162753277,
-0.0646354407,
-0.0176060293,
0.0212660264,
0.0191696808,
0.0190376658,
0.0221125577,
0.0394379608,
-0.0086221397,
-0.0091767292,
-0.04899868,
0.071065329,
0.0038378052,
0.0335250944,
0.0320173874,
0.022104634,
0.000349828,
-0.0326076858,
-0.024851935,
-0.0296612494,
-0.006269719,
0.0270855818,
-0.0399327539,
0.0515005067,
-0.0052721519,
0.029627163,
-0.0134244477,
-0.0242810659,
-0.0056388909,
0.0075413096,
0.0091841277,
0.0209862161,
-0.0005447222,
0.0237490591,
0.0285456702,
-0.0024857982,
0.0209943578,
-0.0195160564,
-0.0235039219,
-0.0520018935,
-0.0014976553,
-0.0566090383,
0.000872688,
0.0182144903,
-0.0148963993,
0.0487812087,
-0.0044940491,
-0.0177290849,
-0.0113703925,
0.0089443875,
-0.0302661862,
-0.0020102095,
-0.0708597973,
0.0306240581,
0.0288606714,
0.0562648177,
-0.00106494,
-0.0586620346,
-0.1398229152,
-0.0032015622,
-0.0576620214,
-0.0263704006,
-0.0356839783,
0.0399120227,
0.0246568304,
0.0063724085,
0.0025959997,
0.0122420732,
0.0034330657,
0.0426722951,
-0.0254641138,
-0.0477813967,
-0.0041426332,
0.0025766334,
-0.0008443444,
0.0039831684,
0.0462938324,
0.0312609747,
-0.0417030752,
-0.0350565985,
-0.0131503129,
-0.0037592831,
-0.0477116667,
-0.0146768698,
0.0345301181,
-0.0396366157,
0.0429508425,
-0.0158099178,
0.0409814529,
0.0057120225,
-0.0042338655,
-0.0455946177,
-0.0069327787,
0.0813689008,
0.0153338863,
-0.0240641311,
0.0066433558,
0.0352700949,
-0.0144152269,
0.0188285913,
-0.0102291489,
0.0803083032,
0.0393332057,
-0.0151979206,
0.0340026692,
-0.0093862424,
0.0024880841,
-0.0021276418,
-0.0409439802,
-0.024477832,
-0.0631302074,
-0.0002076635,
0.0093951616,
0.0315747894,
-0.0365438908,
-0.0076544369,
0.0105901845,
0.0277891662,
0.0216824953,
0.0441264063,
-0.0600854121,
-0.0140206208,
0.036833521,
-0.059164498,
-0.0302405264,
0.0603623539,
-0.0225380789,
-0.017264979,
0.0249171089,
0.1239156947,
-0.0512257032,
-0.0436828807,
-0.0019748965,
-0.070738785,
0.0186158679,
0.0087326225,
0.0435602106,
-0.0277896617,
-0.0310602784,
0.0338810124,
-0.0043785507,
-0.0880017951,
-0.0229005888,
-0.052488409,
-0.0123683801,
0.0308759138,
-0.0142108034,
-0.0505603887,
-0.0263279919,
-0.0011395287,
-0.0172421914,
0.002899277,
-0.0404103212,
0.023054596,
0.0160766318,
-0.0515570752,
-0.0250694919,
-0.0178476106,
0.0132183665,
0.0093176682,
-0.05509983,
0.0438390002,
0.0040483894,
0.0550704896,
0.0512381196,
-0.0093869008,
0.0232619978,
0.0111948047,
-0.0078984955,
0.0150687909,
0.0489069521,
0.0113086067,
-0.0096308878,
-0.002515849,
0.0358667672,
-0.0515102297,
-0.0385333076,
0.0368296355,
-0.072012201,
-0.0039055448,
0.0743490979,
-0.0238267351,
0.0372450687,
-0.0016759412,
-0.0480089076,
-0.0443826504,
0.1081743166,
-0.0115089323,
0.032096561,
-0.0240331423,
0.0028769094,
0.0100392327,
0.0301832091,
0.0307601094,
0.0503203832,
-0.0426730663,
-0.0422420725,
0.0014385395,
-0.0174076632,
-0.0063468488,
0.0774838328,
-0.0404712744,
0.0245469976,
-0.0156639814,
0.0141749512,
-0.0095739039,
-0.0341502354,
-0.0803808793,
-0.0653704852,
-0.1156438217,
-0.0097575225,
0.0095038339,
0.0083687557,
-0.0078331409,
0.0242953561,
-0.0310238972,
-0.0480482429,
-0.0335767046,
0.0695830435,
-0.0286449026,
0.0053038537,
-0.0114138871,
0.0126223238,
0.0291831754,
-0.055186972,
-0.0118400073,
-0.0061392556,
0.0330110602,
-0.0179623328,
0.000511096,
0.0375456885,
-0.0542764887,
-0.0511312895,
0.0191638283,
0.0006635569,
-0.0485945158,
0.0243807938,
-0.0326661579,
0.0629221275,
0.041066207,
0.0349416882,
0.099251844,
0.011361382,
-0.0296893213,
-0.0199760254,
0.0504055917,
-0.0114638023,
0.0476002581,
-0.0174568053,
0.0053674867,
-0.0345395878,
0.0418484733,
-0.0192984827,
0.0218659993,
-0.0252466276,
0.0243831128,
0.0143238055,
-0.024904808,
0.0150345815,
-0.017344065,
-0.0200688876,
-0.0447870381,
-0.0114474734,
-0.0411349759,
0.0448701158,
0.001438039,
-0.0590870082,
-0.0259636194,
-0.0315158181,
-0.0484735817,
0.061758168,
-0.0479275212,
0.0225241408,
-0.0022154918,
0.0191957075,
0.017736055,
-0.036099378,
-0.0043186354,
-0.0558601841,
0.0157334376,
0.0364561975,
-0.0049458016,
-0.0236947294,
-0.0325904191,
-0.0162005741,
-0.0421437882,
-0.0366280936,
-0.0259746462,
-0.0306298137,
-0.0333447158,
-0.0235291887,
-0.0020853612,
0.0392621458,
-0.0319693126,
0.0031345915,
-0.0134566287,
0.0166429747,
0.062405616,
0.0404655598,
0.0253756624,
0.0054852245,
-0.0093666594,
0.0210901182,
0.0539801568,
0.0360797718,
-0.0175310299,
-0.0512111224,
0.0254326724,
0.0359410718,
0.0357106291,
-0.0037687519,
-0.0485139154,
0.0596049465,
-0.0332785025,
0.0580048412,
0.0759754404,
0.0292639099,
-0.0475498438,
0.0007865099,
0.0332287513,
0.0038923377,
0.0084305257,
-0.0023321582,
-0.0031812659,
-0.0550266467,
-0.0302102491,
0.0108169047,
0.0116577158,
-0.0036524364,
0.0308396965,
-0.0537226126,
0.0256670061,
0.0104294866,
0.0158816446,
0.013014623,
-0.0215423554,
0.0411018953,
-0.0226729978,
-0.0474769734,
-0.0621797442,
0.0116644157,
0.0025380871,
0.0351917073,
0.10077326,
-0.0616420396,
-0.0315990411,
-0.0112759797,
0.0265304092,
-0.0330992229,
0.0558815375,
-0.0419489369,
-0.1213255823,
0.0359739773,
-0.0431041904,
-0.0110842902,
-0.0354442038,
0.0371113159,
0.0201852527,
-0.0164210927,
-0.0388358198,
-0.0074668033,
-0.0389883853,
-0.0259732101,
-0.0617982224,
0.0417749435,
-0.042704165,
-0.0002853805,
-0.0660879239,
0.0167642012,
-0.014294249,
0.0184950884,
-0.0001460316,
-0.0418300554,
-0.0098320041,
-0.0238453764,
0.0338824056,
-0.0137414038,
-0.0294169374,
-0.0373022556,
-0.0004153306,
-0.0316859558,
-0.0496717505,
-0.0136559345,
-0.0184853896,
0.0656167194,
-0.0301005039,
-0.0436520576,
-0.0477137752,
0.0132996812,
-0.0314930305,
0.0458712317,
0.0316881984,
0.0235314276,
-0.0037557415,
0.0274112225,
0.027683299,
0.0219470412,
-0.0009498653,
0.0114775859,
-0.0356852487,
-0.0527232997,
-0.0207451247,
0.0234176479,
0.0151865324,
-0.0218192544,
-0.0020514193,
0.0189917665,
0.0649839416,
0.0760920048,
-0.0128450086,
-0.007479555,
0.0723951682,
-0.0496716015,
-0.0107234214,
-0.0094356425,
-0.0131827872,
0.0383527391,
-0.0094454093,
-0.0207220055,
-0.0469141155,
-0.0415915139,
-0.0045427401,
-0.0450791344,
0.0394148342,
-0.0142756822,
-0.0308205578,
-0.0157741904,
-0.0230426267,
0.0353794172,
0.0262484215,
-0.0482476316,
-0.0085567189,
0.0157027394,
0.0259204749,
-0.0134183178,
-0.0139337759,
0.063418813,
-0.0174993705,
0.023373168,
0.021223275,
0.0857517719,
0.013520713,
-0.050081905,
0.02124051,
0.0165635329,
0.0253534317,
0.0243077148,
-0.0186360385,
-0.0255095176,
0.0289472714,
-0.0063659414,
-0.0621817373,
-0.0191025957,
0.0952899605,
0.0135430954,
0.020412609,
-0.0083329901,
-0.0040163584,
0.0621465184,
-0.0186795499,
0.0598303191,
0.0069846651,
0.0141290873,
-0.0030230891,
0.003693877,
-0.0469033681,
0.0094250431,
0.0063496297,
-0.0046521868,
-0.0131246215,
0.0107375924,
0.0327046961,
-0.0969201997,
0.0360130854,
0.014740577,
-0.0209382921,
-0.0211987253,
0.0260759592,
0.0432748422,
0.0220038034,
-0.0119437091,
0.0333389305,
-0.0426381193,
-0.0469851755,
0.0664516091,
-0.0435271785,
-0.0151164206,
0.0351401307,
0.0283631999,
0.0387013666,
0.007333423,
0.0240644868,
-0.0459363125,
-0.0281739831,
-0.0409507528,
-0.0212889854,
0.0465317518,
-6.687925885e-33,
0.026671337,
0.0166186318,
-0.0539093241,
0.0032263054,
-0.0413780361,
0.0437959991,
-0.0015076182,
0.0245948993,
0.0278706159,
-0.0196198002,
-0.0051830788,
0.002422994,
0.0082256822,
0.0089750923,
-0.0077756546,
0.0059351604,
0.023929907,
0.0321920104,
0.0034572014,
0.0323390625,
0.0455372483,
0.0394596048,
0.0430703163,
-0.1074553579,
-0.0084524378,
0.0248438474,
-0.0632529184,
0.0119587742,
0.0376837067,
0.0551286489,
-0.0256007053,
0.0508963875,
0.0051051588,
-0.0011868363,
0.0006892333,
0.0109445686,
-0.0311828442,
0.007062187,
-0.0202951152,
-0.0197041612,
-0.0581460334,
-0.0316012353,
0.0598139837,
0.020781083,
0.0039414186,
-0.0321853571,
0.0384980552,
-0.0215527005,
0.0533462502,
-0.0434580296,
-0.0090477243,
0.0249229092,
-0.0196703728,
-0.0334644988,
0.0147887953,
0.0251372959,
0.0456429087,
0.009196288,
-0.0730149746,
0.0387589112,
-0.0431999527,
-0.0241298396,
0.0196107738,
0.0300656017,
-0.0111687286,
0.0721988603,
-0.0159573182,
-0.0091239475,
0.001053764,
-0.0112700816,
0.0289617646,
0.0649627969,
0.0394500159,
0.0615439638,
0.0427588336,
0.003865517,
-0.0060688555,
0.041872032,
0.0308116358,
0.018562464,
-0.0099204984,
0.0589534417,
-0.0104966061,
0.0356978439,
0.0276960246,
0.0278590731,
-0.0288667772,
-0.046589423,
-0.018735053,
0.0278736111,
-0.0091732601,
0.0246006362,
-0.0037510749,
0.0040501612,
0.0242720861,
-0.0007421537,
0.009066795,
0.0487942398,
0.0210131109,
-0.0350975171,
-0.0125782089,
-0.0130526479,
0.0541865118,
-0.0207685139,
0.023513129,
-0.0018812863,
-0.0027428209,
0.0646385178,
-0.0385325104,
-0.0079600858,
-0.0120110996,
0.0164502487,
0.0026728704,
0.0224498976,
-0.0026362531,
0.0261459872,
-0.0460274071,
-0.0242402479,
-0.0081217745,
0.0995224118,
-0.0323609374,
-0.0526938289,
-0.003344246,
0.0501604415,
-0.0201472864,
-0.0264761578,
-0.0472290851,
-0.0180304591,
-0.0223810393,
-0.0718843937,
-0.0147506967,
-0.0055774995,
3.106e-7,
-0.0116645182,
0.0019645172,
-0.003095634,
-0.0792325959,
0.0185747799,
0.0779961646,
-0.0439939946,
0.0147407027,
0.0052129803,
-0.0176010244,
0.0390442535,
0.0418790393,
0.0378569402,
0.0168040246,
-0.078795813,
-0.0293521788,
-0.0233157407,
0.0094055478,
-0.0145969605,
0.0349878892,
0.0819483101,
0.0924928337,
0.0770936608,
-0.0321919583,
-0.0070158546,
-0.0383277833,
0.0731505528,
-0.0181480609,
0.0003945548,
-0.0334084444,
0.0529009029,
-0.0115009854,
-0.0137963463,
-0.0232828278,
0.0022808332,
-0.0299900062,
0.0337367132,
0.0002749377,
0.0079113832,
-0.0632275194,
0.0158290062,
0.0557034202,
-0.0016802676,
-0.0252276938,
0.0167084914,
0.0077171703,
-0.0349476114,
-0.076113157,
-0.026014097,
0.018494511,
0.0706663206,
-0.0012093922,
-0.0225790143,
0.0015330553,
-0.0022673269,
-0.0135225467,
-0.0283394884,
-0.083490856,
0.0073680915,
0.028428806,
-0.0301114656,
0.0019852184,
-0.0395432189,
-0.0041214963,
0.0452651419,
-0.0157800335,
-0.0173171684,
2.53025159e-34,
-0.002981164,
-0.0344625823,
0.0272342749,
0.0353094973,
-0.0022718539,
0.0122938436,
-0.0369568169,
-0.0314684212,
0.0076162,
-0.0397987626,
0.0105270883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08268v1 | Retrieval-augmented Image Captioning | 2023-02-16T12:54:13 | 2023-02-16T12:54:13 | Rita Ramos, Desmond Elliott, Bruno Martins | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Inspired by retrieval-augmented language generation and pretrained Vision and
Language (V&L) encoders, we present a new approach to image captioning that
generates sentences given the input image and a set of captions retrieved from
a datastore, as opposed to the image alone. The encoder in our model jointly
processes the image and retrieved captions using a pretrained V&L BERT, while
the decoder attends to the multimodal encoder representations, benefiting from
the extra textual evidence from the retrieved captions. Experimental results on
the COCO dataset show that image captioning can be effectively formulated from
this new perspective. Our model, named EXTRA, benefits from using captions
retrieved from the training dataset, and it can also benefit from using an
external dataset without the need for retraining. Ablation studies show that
retrieving a sufficient number of captions (e.g., k=5) can improve captioning
quality. Our work contributes towards using pretrained V&L encoders for
generative tasks, instead of standard classification tasks. | [
0.0393868238,
0.0685528368,
0.0079084113,
0.0184968878,
0.0129873464,
0.0006460932,
0.0016251679,
0.0072396626,
-0.0035322614,
-0.070995681,
-0.009486815,
0.0030603565,
-0.0211013984,
0.0490449779,
0.0079929372,
-0.0772437453,
0.0100373663,
-0.0136967432,
0.0012453146,
-0.005765643,
0.0396692753,
0.0033984508,
0.005075573,
0.0439835936,
-0.0407969169,
0.0219899658,
-0.0070874989,
0.0105112307,
-0.0105162952,
-0.0198468938,
0.0064037531,
0.0593653098,
0.087397635,
-0.0191595592,
0.0000018229,
0.0021226807,
0.0038323523,
0.0041262642,
0.0273745507,
-0.0185956284,
0.0167434867,
-0.0397925228,
0.0436250158,
-0.0011207124,
-0.0186195765,
-0.0247139689,
0.0710946023,
0.0288799237,
0.0978883207,
0.0401467867,
-0.0315561183,
-0.0437768325,
-0.0067024222,
-0.0311689768,
0.0070201666,
0.0086842282,
-0.0301311016,
0.0416606925,
0.0023127997,
0.0023812889,
-0.0218281168,
0.0717510805,
0.0082775699,
-0.0167375077,
0.0266606342,
0.0483268574,
-0.0345940478,
-0.0393438451,
-0.0222040694,
0.0682698414,
0.0551900268,
0.0078543844,
-0.04902431,
0.020515414,
0.0037736443,
-0.0175474435,
-0.0436973386,
0.0348707996,
0.0285897311,
-0.0132639436,
-0.0457421243,
0.027016744,
-0.0121845519,
-0.0142165599,
-0.0013653641,
-0.0504473299,
0.0389365293,
0.0172472168,
-0.0530781113,
0.0269236919,
-0.0324314795,
-0.0427122414,
0.0145143075,
0.0126497541,
0.0131246895,
-0.007253055,
-0.0484507717,
-0.0570895262,
-0.0084588556,
-0.0180963688,
0.0234047044,
0.0107745128,
-0.0814439058,
0.0473814383,
-0.0135348085,
0.0476540662,
-0.008270991,
0.042613063,
-0.047673773,
0.0070056724,
-0.0338104591,
-0.0273105707,
-0.0612100065,
0.0410273746,
-0.0398072861,
-0.0621344633,
-0.0378601886,
0.0038167294,
-0.0050736028,
-0.0175514054,
-0.0219350569,
0.0518041886,
-0.0230065379,
0.0176170394,
-0.0449404046,
0.0293324515,
0.0081737377,
0.0041281437,
0.0023604345,
-0.0298543964,
-0.0176553614,
0.0334269293,
0.0521715507,
-0.0171300694,
-0.0057325936,
0.0497125946,
-0.0555564053,
-0.048408132,
0.007236816,
-0.0277674012,
-0.0593868531,
-0.0144539271,
0.0270521622,
-0.0242710225,
0.032352332,
-0.0032749837,
-0.0150683708,
-0.0257942285,
0.0146798184,
0.0152260819,
0.0199583266,
0.1000004411,
-0.0436262228,
-0.0049741287,
0.0363081135,
0.0111724399,
0.0083221355,
0.0475820936,
0.027986465,
0.0410382822,
0.0330421142,
0.0005047727,
0.0653214678,
0.026233146,
0.0121554211,
-0.0171717294,
-0.0359579809,
-0.0066867792,
-0.0197286047,
0.0007867664,
0.0336903594,
0.0384635627,
-0.0390420593,
0.0585693642,
0.0653334707,
0.0205065962,
-0.0119293723,
0.0318831876,
0.0441416875,
-0.0006333187,
-0.0029085507,
0.0170793515,
-0.0300458837,
0.0702589303,
0.0269845277,
0.0165464636,
0.0247877743,
0.0134395724,
-0.0373227336,
-0.0339707099,
0.0120030493,
-0.0312467031,
0.0299425256,
-0.0120461313,
0.0308185276,
0.0241915584,
-0.0638023317,
0.0595269091,
-0.021628052,
-0.0685859323,
0.0101611894,
-0.0394758508,
-0.0051106811,
0.0603786632,
0.0592689514,
0.0066306307,
-0.035960678,
0.0085969577,
0.0222794916,
0.0623741932,
0.0199243557,
0.0085485075,
0.009749555,
-0.0492881462,
-0.0458627865,
-0.0560314097,
0.000676839,
0.0269124825,
-0.0080801304,
0.0127646467,
0.055762548,
0.0216643121,
-0.0670623481,
0.0282678325,
0.0615081713,
-0.0231272206,
-0.0152272712,
0.0324685164,
-0.010548261,
0.0144111738,
-0.0552122779,
0.0174194705,
0.0132018588,
-0.017898554,
-0.029670177,
0.0854820311,
-0.0534625389,
-0.0867431387,
-0.0023655696,
-0.0525245927,
-0.014702037,
-0.0098514706,
-0.016191775,
-0.050049413,
0.0163768344,
-0.0615552813,
0.0295200758,
-0.0870547369,
-0.0095814625,
0.0155896181,
0.011917145,
0.0311794691,
0.036503654,
0.0007175495,
-0.0405225717,
0.0308919679,
-0.0121950051,
0.0085738981,
-0.0370477363,
-0.0536446981,
-0.0260151662,
0.007002647,
0.0428297333,
0.0702026486,
0.0487973057,
-0.0268920977,
0.0057744156,
-0.0964087099,
-0.0320114046,
-0.0275145303,
-0.0379631743,
-0.0190214328,
0.0097873192,
0.0252614897,
-0.0358167402,
-0.0249107033,
-0.00924832,
0.0402532294,
0.0310920943,
0.0545269623,
0.0322039798,
-0.022152137,
-0.0250736959,
0.0089815268,
0.0457753539,
0.0580491647,
0.0236232243,
-0.0323466398,
-0.0164193716,
-0.0307301972,
-0.0342657194,
0.0047756778,
0.0035605752,
-0.0525618158,
0.0059738066,
-0.0329223722,
-0.0016731939,
0.0122663509,
0.0137511101,
0.0392478853,
0.0076283119,
-0.0059954613,
-0.0310294218,
0.0279808026,
-0.0224355105,
-0.0960698724,
0.0598245412,
0.0022945905,
-0.0033335944,
0.009648555,
-0.0369866826,
0.023790054,
-0.067716822,
0.0008829952,
0.0282051694,
-0.0586647652,
-0.0543460175,
-0.0115354909,
-0.0072675534,
0.0303986799,
-0.0412863679,
-0.0681586042,
0.0398291498,
-0.0364521258,
-0.0504385792,
-0.0163270161,
0.0151218595,
0.0035068486,
0.0807742104,
0.0253853798,
0.0398692414,
-0.0138107454,
-0.0059644291,
0.0256604254,
-0.0127820522,
-0.0010256555,
-0.0146106388,
0.0406812616,
-0.0458407663,
0.0229149386,
0.0002702753,
-0.0422649682,
-0.0330902264,
-0.0133088734,
-0.0033406313,
-0.0266794246,
-0.0523860939,
0.0121643394,
-0.018478753,
0.019240696,
0.0358578414,
0.0424674116,
0.0061925687,
0.0042327051,
-0.0220124945,
0.0525039732,
0.0374326706,
0.0237001851,
-0.093211554,
-0.0480845794,
0.0032177221,
0.0095921466,
-0.0157590061,
-0.0056555644,
-0.0484003834,
0.0219763871,
0.0094572268,
0.0415124558,
0.0188839585,
0.022530593,
0.0560575426,
-0.0499246307,
-0.0277009197,
0.0675553903,
0.0131582925,
-0.0114230402,
-0.0357822329,
0.0322604403,
0.0111520858,
0.0283872616,
0.0026501443,
-0.0594644696,
-0.052316498,
-0.0334974863,
-0.0002027787,
0.0352226868,
0.0447531603,
-0.0534748174,
-0.0866218358,
0.0326585062,
0.0071103112,
-0.0241786819,
-0.0650590286,
0.009571353,
-0.0518230535,
0.0174435824,
-0.0264977664,
-0.0096257953,
0.027043581,
0.0293727629,
0.0056262738,
0.0222315453,
-0.0314241052,
-0.0138590662,
-0.0432313532,
-0.0167682599,
0.0917320177,
0.0193667728,
-0.0268907566,
-0.0310046114,
-0.0263407193,
0.0039893608,
0.0191706456,
0.011542798,
0.0734210759,
-0.0293694325,
-0.0387836024,
0.0148908952,
-0.0129410271,
0.0115027744,
-0.0190506224,
0.0014336763,
-0.0002010414,
-0.010286917,
0.0069719902,
-0.0380477607,
0.0342917219,
0.0069317361,
0.0313811861,
0.0382038392,
-0.0225283951,
0.0041903993,
-0.0047808224,
0.0006343408,
-0.1088760123,
0.0278914869,
0.0046063503,
-0.0255261399,
-0.0005712005,
-0.0924861059,
-0.0075646113,
0.0363961942,
0.0315912701,
0.0205234196,
-0.0236134063,
-0.0093396036,
0.0323533751,
-0.0591712259,
0.0488560684,
-0.0266396273,
-0.0192839094,
-0.0129877497,
-0.0239444003,
0.0611532517,
-0.0237789657,
-0.0163098071,
0.0382123739,
-0.002938746,
-0.0119520491,
-0.0485448875,
0.1052780375,
0.0094544105,
0.0300636552,
0.0247451384,
-0.012940269,
0.0203099214,
0.0628629923,
0.0083750729,
-0.0035140703,
0.0061871232,
-0.0232939608,
-0.0293171965,
-0.0033887101,
-0.0426776335,
0.0359566472,
-0.0417578928,
0.0284041204,
0.0140023362,
-0.0518657528,
0.0155234244,
0.0255323127,
0.0281741805,
-0.0614201948,
0.0368074253,
-0.028074665,
-0.0087250043,
-0.0150537454,
-0.0114237908,
-0.0670573711,
0.0453519896,
-0.0138753597,
0.0401837602,
0.0042026453,
0.0037004363,
-0.0149015905,
0.0283386149,
-0.012845885,
0.0004465848,
0.0356025472,
-0.0377990119,
-0.0030453592,
0.0154269878,
-0.0201145373,
0.0047922409,
-0.0112304119,
0.0177252349,
-0.0449793935,
0.0367496684,
0.0212460756,
-0.0021641678,
-0.0104857637,
0.0477624871,
-0.0104524996,
0.0094734766,
-0.0730929449,
0.0653948784,
0.0551490262,
0.0005859186,
0.0330345109,
-0.0126864873,
-0.019200949,
-0.0044694128,
0.0583381914,
-0.0030988704,
-0.0720043778,
0.0412168615,
-0.006992653,
-0.0065437509,
-0.0042083072,
0.0316652656,
-0.0210002102,
0.0339989848,
-0.0075666751,
-0.035655465,
-0.0403215513,
-0.0091087474,
0.0084355045,
-0.0014889817,
-0.0060045593,
0.0550901406,
0.0270725023,
-0.0472075753,
0.0127495881,
0.0151529275,
-0.0086277109,
0.0373901501,
0.0748341754,
0.0274400227,
0.0219759941,
-0.0162889771,
-0.0004948095,
-0.0013093241,
-0.032181628,
0.0307201501,
0.00854252,
-5.377673964e-33,
-0.0597193502,
-0.0295597203,
0.0295092836,
-0.0491718985,
-0.0267218519,
0.0175921153,
-0.0593178123,
0.0267785136,
0.0200429112,
-0.0002121987,
0.0316972844,
-0.0496450365,
0.008249593,
0.0510745272,
-0.0007851812,
0.0066179242,
0.0534007438,
0.0070276204,
-0.0055812784,
0.0221289303,
0.0252322871,
0.00709819,
0.0364911817,
-0.0322154276,
-0.0029261769,
-0.0260104146,
-0.0438396595,
0.0047813109,
0.0673522353,
0.0415667705,
-0.0240350142,
0.0387437232,
-0.009667702,
-0.0098352134,
-0.0274428278,
0.013729698,
-0.0601182282,
0.0071620797,
0.0271892697,
0.0273284353,
-0.060120903,
-0.0125873992,
0.0044619902,
-0.0548262,
-0.0028656796,
0.0120897461,
0.0607084595,
-0.0172024872,
0.0281204823,
-0.0282816626,
-0.0395193473,
-0.0187829286,
-0.0280986689,
-0.0400426984,
0.0387565121,
0.043459937,
0.0399960913,
0.0185748618,
-0.0376121178,
0.0396779217,
0.0227345824,
0.0072005554,
0.0618328936,
0.0480425842,
-0.0067791878,
0.046835918,
-0.0161979627,
-0.0372935534,
-0.0398595072,
0.0259069838,
-0.0064926897,
0.0812066048,
0.0364442877,
0.0612844825,
0.0414413884,
-0.0008312272,
-0.0188478418,
0.0410053916,
-0.0976727009,
0.0095769763,
0.02492732,
0.0120440647,
0.0120448032,
0.0128293764,
-0.0494882613,
0.0050171334,
-0.0328063071,
-0.0378475673,
0.0500100292,
0.0498330332,
-0.0257757939,
0.0413263924,
0.0801469088,
-0.0281567406,
0.0150264939,
-0.0035786203,
-0.0411918536,
0.03574517,
-0.0260726269,
0.0003752011,
0.0238467436,
-0.0339343585,
0.0850217789,
0.0083193788,
-0.0010555082,
0.0184369888,
0.0673437193,
0.031978067,
-0.0261107478,
0.0164913815,
-0.0237873755,
0.0087198419,
-0.0408714786,
-0.0093492009,
0.0092497086,
0.0371750593,
-0.0895388126,
0.0067495466,
-0.0197789669,
0.0324365422,
-0.0433357023,
-0.0651647076,
0.0213836916,
0.0364443213,
-0.0263384897,
0.0527662113,
-0.0313146263,
-0.0315895975,
0.0034610608,
-0.0592611656,
-0.0308442339,
0.0212325472,
2.467e-7,
0.0121522294,
0.0177666582,
0.0731131285,
0.0018591104,
0.0070058121,
0.0375097767,
-0.0150467493,
0.0291859489,
0.0118937446,
-0.0328579433,
0.0362015404,
0.0287865642,
0.0355402827,
-0.037053097,
-0.0257515945,
-0.0048586982,
-0.0525770895,
-0.0130142756,
-0.0359848551,
-0.0278742667,
0.0788413137,
0.0579226315,
-0.0355701335,
-0.0215366967,
0.007449355,
-0.0997623503,
0.1044345051,
-0.0114276344,
-0.0126724159,
-0.0087932032,
0.023980597,
0.074843742,
-0.0374997668,
-0.0074532903,
-0.0289241057,
-0.0107501084,
0.0693845525,
0.0265295506,
-0.0275909156,
-0.0295540411,
-0.0233416837,
0.0800995827,
-0.0226157233,
0.0065012253,
0.0583365597,
-0.0702544674,
-0.0017830047,
-0.0077024959,
-0.0180350672,
0.0062377518,
0.0182266328,
-0.0562372468,
-0.0592011251,
0.0234309621,
0.0585898198,
0.0108602587,
-0.0324811637,
-0.0963043869,
-0.0219017696,
0.0069076847,
-0.0378173478,
-0.0092234686,
-0.0665242746,
-0.0207823217,
0.0312113371,
-0.0474104322,
-0.0108263977,
1.705870973e-34,
0.0528961308,
-0.0198759791,
0.0053817849,
0.0101339445,
0.0259688161,
-0.0067799576,
-0.0144812074,
-0.0270488672,
-0.0028155979,
-0.0646731704,
-0.0308284089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08258v1 | Tragic and Comical Networks. Clustering Dramatic Genres According to Structural Properties | 2023-02-16T12:36:16 | 2023-02-16T12:36:16 | Szemes Botond, Vida Bence | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is a growing tradition in the joint field of network studies and drama
history that produces interpretations from the character networks of the
plays.The potential of such an interpretation is that the diagrams provide a
different representation of the relationships between characters as compared to
reading the text or watching the performance. Our aim is to create a method
that is able to cluster texts with similar structures on the basis of the
play's well-interpretable and simple properties, independent from the number of
characters in the drama, or in other words, the size of the network. Finding
these features is the most important part of our research, as well as
establishing the appropriate statistical procedure to calculate the
similarities between the texts. Our data was downloaded from the DraCor
database and analyzed in R (we use the GerDracor and the ShakeDraCor
sub-collection). We want to propose a robust method based on the distribution
of words among characters; distribution of characters in scenes, average length
of speech acts, or character-specific and macro-level network properties such
as clusterization coefficient and network density. Based on these metrics a
supervised classification procedure is applied to the sub-collections to
classify comedies and tragedies using the Support Vector Machine (SVM) method.
Our research shows that this approach can also produce reliable results on a
small sample size. | [
-0.0078339679,
-0.0089286799,
-0.0375470333,
0.0402461328,
-0.0042242375,
-0.0047251275,
0.0076052835,
0.0301455725,
0.0467563048,
-0.0078787701,
0.0348511115,
-0.0270963795,
0.0148194544,
0.0418788791,
0.0138986139,
-0.0616397932,
-0.0177181233,
0.00434695,
0.056331493,
0.0079809399,
0.0032257151,
0.0390613154,
-0.0018536719,
0.0129597383,
0.0314618051,
-0.0009608745,
0.0332106575,
-0.003325419,
0.0809167847,
-0.0183444526,
-0.0048814891,
-0.0027956229,
-0.0039411187,
0.0482098162,
0.0000016743,
-0.0436205491,
0.0013395614,
-0.0548858196,
0.0743099973,
-0.0136006745,
0.04153217,
0.0303407125,
-0.0009405299,
-0.00242934,
0.0210403763,
0.023507569,
0.0288684312,
0.0173364505,
0.0211674888,
0.0632013902,
-0.0253026672,
-0.0480608903,
0.0144157363,
-0.0250504911,
-0.0204221997,
0.0095047001,
0.0177444313,
0.0320823565,
0.0231146049,
-0.0117220329,
-0.0689872876,
0.0112164225,
-0.0624242872,
-0.0020349808,
0.0091918698,
0.0385250337,
-0.0505071059,
0.0023885407,
0.0337033458,
0.0433987007,
0.0327191241,
0.0014953583,
0.0647786185,
0.0293471459,
-0.0034360089,
0.0925288647,
-0.0390146039,
0.0036461949,
-0.008308067,
-0.0159441419,
-0.0243939422,
0.068430081,
0.0265571438,
-0.0229182038,
0.0412788726,
-0.0510173738,
-0.010269613,
0.0205644928,
-0.0038820915,
-0.058190383,
-0.0618093051,
-0.0161618851,
0.0063351719,
0.0101773608,
0.0361283794,
0.0083981594,
0.0381067097,
-0.0210717209,
0.0247089807,
-0.0656607226,
0.0004701867,
-0.0123687228,
0.0361354649,
0.0407078192,
0.00178981,
-0.0365418978,
0.0000949747,
-0.0016335086,
0.002388326,
0.0426616892,
-0.0699180886,
0.015776949,
-0.0125497468,
0.0194539409,
-0.0029619308,
-0.0181351285,
-0.0457526185,
0.0050039259,
-0.0152416211,
-0.0033975795,
-0.0064662765,
0.0093954159,
0.0632252842,
-0.0004106933,
-0.035129901,
0.0417797156,
-0.0724865124,
0.0066600302,
-0.0906723887,
0.0817385912,
0.0380306281,
0.0400927998,
0.0411779359,
0.0188760273,
0.0226813126,
0.0460343324,
0.0146551076,
-0.0491014421,
-0.0565123856,
-0.0076976675,
-0.0199531689,
-0.0318116508,
-0.0449541658,
-0.0463417657,
0.0297964029,
0.002636329,
-0.0108443741,
0.0161818583,
-0.007492736,
-0.0173936915,
-0.0494976863,
-0.0016962367,
-0.0109177222,
0.0174561553,
0.0556730628,
0.0040751239,
0.0334353782,
-0.0365487784,
0.0591712482,
-0.0098454412,
0.0427276567,
-0.0054357708,
0.0177864395,
0.0113743413,
-0.0266991407,
-0.0098010441,
-0.0181046501,
-0.0258727148,
0.0098270876,
0.0155319711,
-0.0051507815,
0.0186078381,
-0.0436048843,
-0.0530789606,
0.0202140156,
0.0763163865,
0.0570078418,
0.0481350683,
0.000713499,
0.0075187981,
0.0245287176,
-0.004472685,
-0.0050417883,
0.0080974987,
0.0103848567,
-0.0031071305,
-0.0397889465,
0.0042666574,
0.0065010684,
-0.0150849363,
-0.0055146865,
0.0210427381,
0.036556609,
-0.0479209945,
0.0411536209,
-0.0036347916,
-0.0265339445,
-0.0277317334,
0.0471227877,
-0.0295592826,
0.0282283947,
0.0245739836,
0.0251364671,
0.0754067749,
0.0334179997,
-0.0794699416,
0.0455175489,
0.0103744864,
0.0030199818,
-0.0359246694,
-0.0370100252,
-0.0199592188,
-0.0145026725,
-0.0435033962,
0.0575897954,
0.021292368,
0.0133803403,
0.0154004218,
-0.0939264297,
0.0143839056,
-0.0457362086,
-0.0224961136,
-0.0256763604,
0.0274237487,
-0.0508998632,
0.024233913,
-0.03083531,
-0.0161349233,
0.0369380191,
0.030950116,
-0.0074606892,
-0.0453912467,
0.0374760851,
-0.0199681483,
-0.024967717,
0.0418940336,
0.0061045955,
0.0172909386,
-0.0061854329,
-0.0961572006,
0.0049443538,
0.0024453178,
0.0030713263,
-0.0317193568,
0.094040595,
-0.0463613197,
0.0179776791,
0.0005015257,
0.0294578709,
-0.0146732908,
-0.0029147856,
-0.014563323,
0.0607637875,
0.0194336697,
0.0473136716,
-0.0834636092,
-0.0097385384,
0.0259281993,
-0.0314955898,
-0.0167916734,
-0.0228964221,
0.0039851819,
0.0102880923,
0.0421586297,
-0.0513843745,
0.0214524884,
-0.0418578535,
-0.0402973369,
-0.0186140984,
-0.029647829,
-0.0045222319,
0.013991368,
-0.0028307517,
-0.0380903371,
-0.0217595343,
-0.0158408675,
0.0695697218,
0.0241081398,
-0.0683400258,
0.0314594917,
0.0047763586,
-0.0902757347,
-0.0147894807,
-0.0204646662,
-0.0292388108,
0.0827162638,
0.0338078775,
-0.0066062151,
-0.012786977,
0.0065358682,
-0.0255402513,
-0.0137050198,
-0.0349309184,
-0.0246022176,
-0.0583387278,
0.0239444803,
-0.0291837044,
0.0050399238,
0.0249018725,
0.0211745799,
0.0548406281,
-0.0251977667,
0.0356895141,
-0.021575192,
-0.0319623388,
0.0295463726,
-0.0802206323,
-0.0539893508,
0.0155973556,
0.0238584802,
0.0116348974,
-0.0299165621,
-0.0034531555,
-0.0330629013,
0.0135301482,
0.0689539611,
-0.0014366306,
-0.0883306116,
-0.0018061455,
0.0370449461,
0.0329405703,
0.0214432627,
0.0239064209,
-0.0244523827,
0.0355576649,
-0.042466484,
-0.0742010102,
-0.0254296549,
0.0856341571,
0.0338529684,
0.046764385,
-0.0222640578,
-0.018088663,
-0.049955979,
0.0116109978,
0.0902221277,
-0.0222116672,
0.0092613809,
0.0343440436,
-0.0218201112,
0.0150664048,
0.0408131666,
-0.0280538388,
0.0107100755,
-0.0204325598,
-0.0537682921,
0.0485733002,
-0.0486916229,
-0.0232548509,
0.0607600883,
-0.0690302551,
-0.0089061642,
0.0103587145,
-0.0179225579,
0.0064943084,
0.0871338472,
-0.0215409659,
-0.0348102003,
-0.0480578318,
0.0261709839,
0.0443811119,
0.0156731494,
-0.0844174623,
-0.0149184521,
-0.0155228944,
0.0019192288,
-0.0018864948,
-0.0439777933,
0.0090178037,
-0.0487348847,
0.0123127345,
-0.0210348759,
0.0011899662,
0.0483872853,
0.0501195937,
-0.0458273813,
0.0194651708,
0.0170420222,
0.0008524365,
0.0354045704,
0.0218081232,
0.0157058407,
0.0654903725,
-0.0298211072,
0.041277986,
0.0526393987,
-0.058009401,
0.0106201395,
-0.0516745672,
0.037110921,
0.0227274112,
-0.0661275834,
-0.0089359572,
-0.0397840813,
-0.0036248299,
-0.0642641932,
-0.0202368982,
-0.012066016,
-0.0162469167,
-0.0218972433,
0.0077623255,
-0.0505114831,
0.0133444024,
0.0176718794,
-0.0498123914,
0.0671307966,
-0.0782477036,
0.0423667431,
-0.0414984748,
-0.0053520831,
-0.0205480065,
-0.0208973438,
-0.0182340574,
0.0127008772,
0.1095772907,
0.0255335364,
0.0184443332,
-0.0500190035,
0.0152333854,
0.040635705,
-0.0397170261,
0.0405511484,
0.023148369,
0.0236692913,
-0.0717680529,
-0.0372424237,
0.0541063435,
-0.0426518433,
0.016903108,
-0.0114763184,
0.0010178882,
0.0125395535,
-0.0208010301,
0.0284308493,
-0.0069449618,
-0.0690983012,
-0.0154966163,
-0.0102283396,
-0.0458528325,
-0.0381439961,
0.0327780098,
-0.0538659878,
0.059906356,
0.0196243227,
0.0014409418,
0.0214538909,
-0.0121399285,
-0.0788624734,
-0.0073721227,
0.0203471836,
-0.0270096473,
0.0080353962,
-0.0136114238,
0.0226707011,
-0.0369174704,
-0.0218711216,
-0.0515329838,
-0.0427158214,
-0.0450571068,
0.0013485537,
-0.030129049,
0.0218452979,
0.0474611335,
-0.0251125805,
-0.0598085709,
0.0425577909,
0.0028850392,
-0.0560723469,
0.0083959196,
-0.0626484528,
-0.0348811857,
-0.050769262,
0.0053738323,
-0.0310176667,
0.0545276292,
-0.0208143536,
0.0097502042,
-0.0746145993,
-0.0168482065,
-0.0284521431,
-0.0105070462,
0.0352966115,
-0.0381167419,
-0.0353166908,
-0.0186474398,
-0.0582404844,
0.0032110503,
0.0075338758,
0.0402433984,
-0.0170762669,
0.004013441,
-0.0194542501,
-0.0402994938,
-0.0192937665,
-0.0234709345,
-0.0081343241,
0.003130727,
0.0053719217,
0.0837496743,
-0.0161207356,
-0.0036542402,
0.0441391282,
-0.0061294427,
-0.0267460588,
0.0169986449,
0.0305429343,
0.0185522772,
-0.0305238925,
0.0477276742,
0.0134745948,
-0.0310549885,
0.0369852595,
-0.0164120384,
0.0211884491,
-0.0028055499,
-0.0406452306,
0.0172018707,
-0.0362338722,
0.0139208511,
-0.0289845355,
0.0087782564,
-0.0017697098,
0.0249729156,
-0.0165491942,
-0.0012514112,
-0.033118397,
0.038604822,
-0.0057920166,
0.0759497285,
0.0452984348,
-0.0116582848,
-0.0513262562,
0.0550823659,
-0.0920776278,
-0.0061253621,
0.0186003316,
0.0186317768,
0.0372435749,
-0.0059441584,
-0.0018007027,
-0.0631964728,
-0.0640870705,
0.0250866953,
-0.0520204231,
0.0583488978,
0.0173722766,
0.0093553346,
0.0164235197,
0.0468134172,
0.1036237478,
-0.0056367484,
0.0110071581,
-0.0515710488,
-0.0039686533,
0.0269516353,
-5.529984971e-33,
-0.0121784806,
-0.0570530742,
-0.0371725298,
0.0406963117,
-0.0514175482,
-0.0159854572,
-0.0332689285,
0.0074865213,
0.0131072011,
0.0257909,
0.0305150915,
0.0426079929,
-0.0141150802,
-0.0288137905,
0.0202791039,
0.0164771453,
0.0204260517,
0.030727027,
-0.0418897197,
0.0013971659,
0.0725900605,
0.0390376858,
0.0185903814,
-0.1157337651,
-0.0230126251,
-0.0496190563,
-0.0033660447,
-0.0069187316,
0.0920537263,
0.0256818347,
-0.0059211971,
0.0557298325,
0.0210845731,
0.025132576,
0.0240443312,
0.0059579653,
-0.0283393711,
-0.0198172703,
0.0186896585,
-0.0042097587,
0.0228139162,
-0.0095356582,
0.0295529719,
-0.0248146206,
0.0090626031,
-0.0300017707,
0.1083404347,
-0.0040679961,
-0.0029790655,
0.0114391809,
-0.0079545258,
0.0069716475,
-0.0543665886,
0.012726008,
0.0053422749,
-0.0265250858,
0.0247779377,
0.0224360451,
-0.0378123298,
0.0576845929,
-0.0832516998,
0.0104593616,
-0.0204326063,
0.025241809,
-0.0206647869,
0.0669204593,
0.0100216838,
-0.0111269886,
-0.0319756828,
0.0503852032,
0.0025456417,
0.0196502171,
0.0398807079,
0.0214375742,
-0.0287944768,
-0.0229122527,
-0.0616133772,
-0.0023590869,
0.0126424171,
-0.0241601765,
0.0162430778,
0.0044802995,
0.012794774,
-0.0476589277,
0.0291205067,
-0.0314729661,
0.0242369846,
-0.0074829855,
-0.0459915511,
-0.01165077,
-0.0285996161,
-0.0043559484,
-0.0106925331,
-0.0353629589,
0.0035931985,
0.0385106914,
0.0019540437,
0.0582224578,
0.0072253812,
-0.003591768,
0.0499803498,
0.0012144392,
-0.0122399582,
-0.0079662018,
0.0144944256,
-0.0330637135,
0.020878844,
-0.0011175849,
-0.0161091723,
-0.0034331554,
0.0532519408,
-0.0588210747,
-0.0332318097,
-0.0220086072,
-0.018412536,
0.0113827502,
-0.0022053383,
0.0002078472,
0.0484340526,
0.0535937734,
0.0233839024,
0.0056721708,
-0.029214127,
-0.0273134075,
-0.0131819472,
-0.0256314445,
-0.0286026541,
0.0036856097,
0.048462674,
-0.0416481905,
-0.0193256233,
-0.0728739947,
2.726e-7,
0.0615792349,
0.0212426148,
0.0214509051,
0.013043398,
0.0157437995,
0.0104421377,
-0.0148524074,
0.0287193134,
-0.0005132824,
-0.0177374091,
0.0511811264,
0.0184088983,
-0.0159095917,
0.0733437389,
-0.073661916,
0.0029394925,
-0.073521167,
-0.0226493981,
-0.0169386212,
-0.0021929436,
0.0263074078,
0.0371474996,
0.0572875291,
0.0239714868,
-0.0047833319,
-0.0479578711,
-0.0248139612,
-0.0346726067,
-0.0047373772,
0.019485781,
-0.0183675662,
-0.0306155793,
-0.0318156742,
0.0603723377,
0.0062775258,
0.017155556,
-0.005890267,
-0.0467574857,
-0.0059123603,
0.0477516353,
0.0220192075,
0.0030258859,
0.0204830561,
0.0127699953,
0.0071954201,
0.0083986027,
-0.0537736379,
0.0630814135,
-0.029930491,
-0.014521447,
0.0638917461,
0.0337959193,
-0.0152447438,
0.0602072254,
-0.0042442004,
0.0107836248,
0.0538334697,
-0.0619359128,
0.0301486608,
0.091595754,
-0.0108968439,
-0.0524482802,
0.0486220382,
0.0325149521,
0.0701666623,
-0.0074803843,
0.0316091254,
2.310276878e-34,
0.0549853593,
0.0009045054,
-0.0383697301,
-0.0210020877,
0.0029662838,
-0.0519631356,
0.0015448247,
0.0162055977,
0.0225238316,
-0.0362595208,
-0.0258412622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08229v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08229v1 | Improving Spoken Language Identification with Map-Mix | 2023-02-16T11:27:46 | 2023-02-16T11:27:46 | Shangeth Rajaa, Kriti Anandan, Swaraj Dalmia, Tarun Gupta, Eng Siong Chng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The pre-trained multi-lingual XLSR model generalizes well for language
identification after fine-tuning on unseen languages. However, the performance
significantly degrades when the languages are not very distinct from each
other, for example, in the case of dialects. Low resource dialect
classification remains a challenging problem to solve. We present a new data
augmentation method that leverages model training dynamics of individual data
points to improve sampling for latent mixup. The method works well in
low-resource settings where generalization is paramount. Our datamaps-based
mixup technique, which we call Map-Mix improves weighted F1 scores by 2%
compared to the random mixup baseline and results in a significantly
well-calibrated model. The code for our method is open sourced on
https://github.com/skit-ai/Map-Mix. | [
-0.0359642394,
0.0598976761,
0.0092399204,
0.0170336347,
0.0051011383,
0.0296773892,
0.0068667987,
-0.0225296244,
0.0116348788,
-0.0352700241,
-0.0707179308,
-0.0351662375,
0.0271298811,
0.0308890883,
0.0168939102,
-0.0196420979,
0.0578685738,
-0.0295188893,
0.0006997088,
-0.0054580807,
-0.0130535187,
0.0217669159,
-0.0324378237,
0.0022274361,
-0.0062709386,
0.0127976425,
-0.0114373043,
0.0143864024,
0.0499166809,
0.014358025,
0.0180199333,
0.0660756901,
0.0124465609,
0.0835490301,
0.0000019807,
-0.043254178,
-0.0198899154,
0.0003012648,
-0.0414929315,
0.0071981777,
-0.0033807082,
0.0464699641,
-0.0001111205,
0.0298331454,
0.0159850679,
-0.0891291127,
0.0606125891,
0.0121328495,
0.0342317708,
0.0534845293,
-0.0029933536,
-0.0296416376,
-0.0038625731,
0.0091097541,
0.0046599577,
0.0004718797,
-0.0144684697,
0.0100284535,
-0.0273877606,
-0.0394551195,
0.0074207755,
0.0302167237,
-0.0020196456,
0.0650478005,
-0.035435304,
0.0092635695,
-0.059807349,
0.0194764435,
-0.009596684,
0.0778736323,
-0.058891654,
-0.0290707741,
-0.0121492324,
-0.0086674588,
-0.0393513553,
-0.0185072608,
0.0040069195,
-0.0371977501,
-0.0107798073,
0.0142545933,
0.010670769,
0.0222218838,
0.052361723,
0.0109482408,
-0.0294645466,
0.0324190408,
0.0261177365,
0.0014057566,
0.0088727511,
-0.0039335336,
0.0188570879,
-0.0263504181,
-0.0048447098,
0.0432999246,
-0.0450191945,
-0.0205144361,
-0.0308091026,
-0.0639196038,
0.0016459476,
-0.0717271119,
0.0252669454,
0.0479343347,
-0.0748448148,
0.0497967117,
-0.0071583744,
-0.0157255158,
0.0090732919,
0.0087562678,
-0.0255767312,
-0.0508574359,
-0.0402118079,
0.0289707854,
-0.0022553466,
-0.0005528998,
0.0007620216,
0.0281844381,
-0.0223777443,
-0.004900774,
-0.0198162887,
0.022631567,
0.0066908761,
-0.051543314,
-0.034467537,
-0.0131029496,
0.0383761227,
0.0406692959,
0.0057292357,
0.0368768349,
-0.0182115976,
-0.0573823303,
-0.0218829624,
0.0245731007,
0.0236306302,
0.0036628461,
0.027504012,
0.0396527871,
-0.0164042413,
-0.0539474785,
-0.0886262357,
0.0349573866,
-0.0058345632,
-0.0638517365,
0.013738689,
-0.0696862489,
0.0194195118,
0.0112221707,
0.0247767735,
0.0311701782,
-0.0466294438,
-0.069942072,
0.0064293849,
0.0540219136,
-0.0159157403,
0.0252401531,
0.0339958258,
-0.0316570103,
0.0168734267,
0.0954779908,
-0.0000526361,
-0.0058615268,
0.009990396,
-0.021498641,
0.0089617651,
0.0852650851,
-0.0130063584,
0.0419988371,
-0.0470396951,
-0.0037834216,
-0.0110678319,
-0.0357334539,
0.0289094932,
0.0023161524,
-0.0266249534,
0.0390143879,
0.0065817162,
0.0245021749,
0.0348875932,
0.0286266673,
0.0410761945,
0.0454838201,
-0.012909607,
0.0023731864,
0.0086924434,
-0.0346981063,
-0.0173574649,
0.0044781305,
0.0388711095,
0.1023281515,
-0.0726338625,
0.0139280139,
-0.0325545147,
-0.0506645702,
0.019041691,
0.0429192856,
0.0465511754,
-0.0042016613,
0.0329128094,
0.0691099241,
0.0679382607,
-0.0195136108,
0.0511759222,
-0.0327050313,
-0.006228304,
0.0220333152,
-0.0337052569,
-0.046967648,
-0.0085552298,
-0.0298644658,
0.0075866678,
-0.0057277516,
0.0538446903,
-0.0217660461,
0.0889428407,
-0.0535437278,
-0.0303194653,
0.032563366,
0.0276546497,
0.0480534919,
-0.001559768,
0.0082895663,
0.0124230795,
-0.0606811345,
0.0000948319,
-0.0117418692,
-0.0365291536,
-0.0375871621,
0.0413906574,
0.0341471024,
0.0355752036,
0.0470939539,
-0.0139244068,
-0.0307570975,
-0.0025826029,
-0.0036818136,
0.0389046669,
0.0411789827,
0.0244461633,
-0.0775843412,
0.0566656925,
0.0329934955,
-0.0474651307,
0.0095743407,
-0.0492180325,
-0.0880112275,
0.0472967215,
-0.0273103472,
0.0939604193,
-0.0439316817,
0.0074593667,
-0.0129916901,
-0.0129632084,
-0.0036455153,
0.0565293357,
0.0009866161,
-0.0036379728,
-0.003058057,
-0.0239309426,
0.0789377689,
-0.050766889,
-0.0304901376,
-0.0083284192,
-0.0230633821,
0.010464496,
-0.0104880258,
0.0072531281,
-0.0225024931,
-0.0190282743,
-0.0766833052,
-0.0119567709,
-0.0535599478,
0.03277006,
0.0075994227,
0.0305235814,
-0.0227702521,
-0.0635974929,
-0.0477827825,
-0.0198901072,
0.0117756473,
0.0026108124,
-0.0443766676,
0.0068413871,
0.0039555207,
-0.0163749326,
0.0027372474,
-0.0033292018,
0.0174368359,
-0.0340533443,
-0.0188898351,
-0.033239156,
-0.0217062235,
0.0024500748,
0.0335473903,
-0.0007820732,
-0.0141728446,
-0.038671378,
0.0032736992,
0.0431386828,
-0.0061800885,
-0.0359215625,
-0.0375284329,
0.0484721474,
-0.0330551676,
-0.0252508204,
0.0135548627,
-0.014098431,
0.002174539,
-0.0384681597,
-0.0147229545,
-0.0385039672,
0.0440603755,
-0.0200037789,
-0.0029255447,
-0.0288720187,
-0.0620470643,
-0.0129759982,
0.0078367889,
0.0040898714,
0.0180508662,
-0.0174366795,
-0.0081307385,
-0.0147636961,
-0.0387441106,
0.0614906177,
-0.0858805999,
-0.0266808141,
-0.0575595945,
-0.0328031108,
-0.0186300371,
0.0027921372,
-0.0380099639,
0.0094850808,
-0.0349659696,
-0.031482324,
-0.0287007485,
-0.0010449114,
-0.0158022325,
-0.0548098385,
0.0425338633,
-0.0071601723,
0.0056848307,
-0.0100581339,
-0.0236223191,
-0.02426962,
-0.0350789018,
-0.0221745148,
0.0244152602,
-0.0045585008,
-0.0321700349,
-0.0040704901,
0.0139211845,
0.0307125486,
0.0560880676,
-0.0171162467,
0.050274957,
-0.0048704804,
0.0350207724,
0.0324958637,
0.076522626,
0.0077027832,
-0.019217087,
-0.0205350854,
-0.0649187788,
0.0585635491,
-0.0054126456,
-0.0295323823,
-0.0029858616,
0.0315870233,
0.0103925476,
-0.0174527466,
0.0127927735,
0.0625311881,
-0.0012326697,
0.0150069268,
0.0910755694,
-0.0145202838,
-0.0410812199,
-0.0345170721,
-0.0029407707,
0.0456249714,
0.0221787803,
0.0282464195,
-0.0541549288,
-0.0240920167,
0.0193452872,
-0.0047112438,
0.0157603063,
0.018096393,
-0.000136901,
-0.0967165977,
0.0135004241,
0.0315924808,
-0.0708702207,
-0.0034194032,
-0.0274111293,
-0.0115612177,
-0.0432387441,
0.0420295112,
-0.0658311993,
-0.001346194,
-0.015485446,
0.0572830066,
0.0093840854,
-0.0965639949,
0.0027098237,
-0.0263158735,
0.0716864765,
0.0019784796,
-0.012158867,
-0.0516574718,
-0.0143928006,
0.0424460135,
0.0270742718,
-0.04502213,
-0.0213380232,
0.0249951407,
0.0097118476,
-0.0197979622,
0.0424625129,
0.0038268934,
0.0041681966,
-0.0120469527,
-0.024433475,
0.0487261228,
-0.0172027219,
0.0503994524,
0.0167841054,
-0.0277444012,
0.0627820939,
0.0507737212,
0.0379530676,
-0.0195777267,
0.0479371436,
-0.0089184865,
0.0600637048,
-0.0213358644,
0.0122783286,
0.0556141548,
-0.0494520627,
-0.0623682924,
-0.0001648496,
-0.023143271,
0.0182841942,
0.038782686,
0.0197225623,
0.035781268,
-0.039301794,
-0.0046224417,
-0.0457015745,
0.0690374896,
-0.0153903607,
0.0176934097,
-0.0477076508,
-0.0711578652,
-0.0005412981,
-0.043851994,
-0.0159244221,
0.0094911596,
-0.1210173592,
-0.0704007372,
0.0322356559,
0.0347396955,
0.0125356009,
0.0480599329,
-0.0430880859,
-0.0660621896,
0.0424741283,
-0.0216519088,
0.0255885255,
0.0016993148,
0.0558193438,
-0.0123627586,
-0.0301709827,
0.0026326992,
-0.0634157062,
0.0340198576,
0.0666375682,
-0.0366009995,
-0.066407755,
0.001168743,
-0.0161594246,
0.0076655587,
0.097024858,
-0.044474721,
0.0235417746,
-0.0439153016,
0.0007553661,
0.0246901903,
0.0141781587,
-0.0226331092,
-0.0268591829,
0.0275212526,
-0.0112537751,
0.0031233479,
0.0264506079,
-0.0014974077,
0.0291424468,
0.0150489751,
0.0328589119,
0.0435724631,
-0.0065774424,
0.0225906521,
0.0175163671,
-0.0347559527,
0.0756403059,
0.0379051641,
0.0135022951,
0.0013876396,
0.0033744271,
-0.0064139608,
-0.0194890667,
-0.0132935215,
0.0029773479,
-0.0271670818,
-0.0433117971,
-0.0313611142,
-0.0225637201,
0.0378370285,
-0.0508228168,
0.0444075055,
0.0060821497,
0.0168102533,
-0.0492818095,
0.0070658792,
-0.0094668679,
-0.0195797682,
-0.0127930418,
-0.0108258454,
-0.0378548913,
0.0314532667,
0.068243064,
0.0391257294,
0.0319477655,
-0.0216603018,
0.0439016372,
-0.0124934958,
-0.0098547926,
0.0117531167,
0.0231944751,
-0.0561991893,
0.0417266972,
-0.0326303355,
-0.0680444092,
0.0270714816,
-0.0009027233,
0.0154400896,
0.0381442755,
-0.0051351925,
0.0314892381,
-0.052018065,
0.0165563226,
-0.0180103909,
-0.0301429071,
0.044289697,
-0.007812052,
0.020700112,
-6.470374207e-33,
-0.0164953135,
0.0479350798,
-0.0151986908,
-0.0426177196,
0.0182215553,
0.0116874687,
-0.0215805788,
0.0372167192,
-0.0511435755,
-0.0306957942,
-0.0172390081,
0.0024802198,
0.0415421575,
0.0550626814,
-0.0244400743,
-0.0158791021,
0.0721358433,
0.0172930509,
0.006163138,
0.001016815,
0.0405099802,
0.022678826,
0.1087087989,
-0.0562481508,
-0.0559588596,
-0.0068744342,
-0.0094648432,
0.0267709065,
0.0002747194,
0.0347617678,
-0.0153731806,
0.0543189757,
0.0068388362,
0.0230239239,
-0.0242813062,
-0.0134821618,
-0.0547410287,
-0.0289156232,
-0.0115116434,
0.0690718666,
0.0320944116,
-0.0073546828,
0.0189167429,
-0.028516287,
-0.0234901123,
-0.0265853833,
0.0339614414,
-0.0349764936,
-0.0166733097,
0.0080069313,
-0.0120937014,
0.0406505056,
0.0250870362,
0.0064323931,
0.0613296703,
0.0329524763,
0.0066523771,
-0.0245853029,
-0.0708595291,
0.0184889436,
0.0590978228,
0.0228849873,
0.0519154817,
0.0895446464,
-0.0000541966,
0.0388682224,
0.0241646767,
0.000668769,
0.0150931943,
-0.0124090919,
0.0430751145,
-0.0233612396,
-0.018293146,
0.0668974295,
0.0372299962,
-0.0430220775,
-0.058401864,
0.0238717347,
0.0415885225,
-0.0435510464,
-0.0018873231,
-0.0063844868,
-0.0439005196,
-0.0084729325,
-0.0428108573,
-0.0543354265,
-0.0228226893,
-0.0311701167,
0.0197203979,
0.0093453964,
0.0244047325,
0.0124279549,
0.0851771384,
-0.0227551404,
-0.0314457566,
-0.0265507065,
0.007875178,
-0.0113874376,
-0.0146274706,
0.0450253375,
-0.0641418993,
-0.060732346,
0.0136334635,
0.0058426224,
0.0198722053,
-0.0014382075,
0.0503909402,
0.057414446,
-0.0425472297,
0.0347585157,
0.0128248548,
-0.0035574371,
-0.0025787696,
0.068895489,
0.0471787006,
0.00351358,
0.018063629,
0.0612307228,
0.0167989358,
0.0403894223,
0.0277704969,
-0.0638692975,
-0.0028024511,
0.0462027453,
-0.007399308,
-0.0190966632,
-0.0084807882,
-0.0413507223,
0.0259438772,
-0.027998371,
0.0460274331,
0.0029274407,
2.709e-7,
-0.0024722803,
0.0027838058,
-0.0116598085,
-0.0671749189,
-0.0126047647,
0.0115908254,
-0.0601268299,
-0.0288577788,
-0.0226382148,
-0.0152532002,
-0.0144866491,
0.0024335799,
0.0855057538,
0.0527508147,
-0.0713800117,
-0.0150429178,
-0.0824493319,
0.038730517,
-0.0388751104,
0.0189451072,
-0.0122687891,
0.1417127997,
0.0302174501,
-0.0206182487,
0.0220532194,
-0.0069251158,
0.0412797667,
-0.0227469653,
-0.020640621,
0.0275474936,
0.0076340693,
0.013043683,
0.0048426078,
-0.0177839026,
-0.0620914437,
0.0460112505,
0.008250339,
0.0501811728,
-0.0080649685,
-0.0427937247,
-0.000880285,
0.0168027263,
-0.0206344314,
-0.0302237794,
0.0575217903,
-0.0136258211,
-0.013827011,
-0.0180328209,
-0.0287744645,
0.0330488682,
0.0221645292,
-0.0087116873,
-0.0142107941,
0.0139615452,
0.0197490901,
-0.0507699214,
-0.0225130823,
-0.0711130723,
-0.0176973138,
0.0398885794,
-0.0418546125,
-0.0084203742,
0.0263891462,
-0.0412894599,
0.0293934606,
-0.023845844,
0.0304581877,
2.319350225e-34,
0.0250895079,
-0.0014129346,
0.0077990126,
-0.0033296298,
-0.0134640792,
-0.0337089002,
-0.0259065926,
0.0156457033,
0.0031704013,
-0.0104698911,
0.0114884628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08220v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08220v2 | Dialogue State Distillation Network with Inter-slot Contrastive Learning for Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-02-16T11:05:24 | 2023-03-07T07:00:35 | Jing Xu, Dandan Song, Chong Liu, Siu Cheung Hui, Fei Li, Qiang Ju, Xiaonan He, Jian Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | In task-oriented dialogue systems, Dialogue State Tracking (DST) aims to
extract users' intentions from the dialogue history. Currently, most existing
approaches suffer from error propagation and are unable to dynamically select
relevant information when utilizing previous dialogue states. Moreover, the
relations between the updates of different slots provide vital clues for DST.
However, the existing approaches rely only on predefined graphs to indirectly
capture the relations. In this paper, we propose a Dialogue State Distillation
Network (DSDN) to utilize relevant information of previous dialogue states and
migrate the gap of utilization between training and testing. Thus, it can
dynamically exploit previous dialogue states and avoid introducing error
propagation simultaneously. Further, we propose an inter-slot contrastive
learning loss to effectively capture the slot co-update relations from dialogue
context. Experiments are conducted on the widely used MultiWOZ 2.0 and MultiWOZ
2.1 datasets. The experimental results show that our proposed model achieves
the state-of-the-art performance for DST. | [
0.010561402,
0.0915439278,
0.0023928436,
0.0256695617,
-0.019460205,
0.0094596948,
-0.0047408463,
-0.0000199174,
-0.0083413692,
-0.0071984176,
-0.0250860937,
-0.0751787052,
0.008316786,
0.0591280088,
0.0013461382,
-0.0671021566,
0.0493052714,
-0.0000853276,
-0.011072916,
0.0234137904,
0.0277631432,
-0.0102638127,
-0.0493610427,
0.016693702,
-0.0023813315,
-0.025379505,
-0.0787871033,
0.0266842488,
0.013083267,
-0.0417671874,
0.0269136317,
0.0383681916,
0.0465635322,
0.0080164028,
0.0000022066,
-0.023211075,
-0.0201148242,
-0.0485200621,
-0.0684170276,
-0.033642754,
-0.0301244669,
0.0294524953,
0.0009726891,
0.0336783454,
-0.0520574637,
-0.0230659321,
0.0208910834,
0.0478341356,
0.0940817818,
0.0687835962,
0.003125,
-0.0138108358,
0.0299164057,
-0.0173621178,
-0.0132699031,
-0.0690487772,
0.0333802663,
0.0179088414,
-0.0334550738,
-0.0106045566,
-0.0255997423,
0.0021940765,
0.0323596708,
-0.0380507521,
-0.056903895,
-0.0021273007,
0.0060833558,
-0.0138265537,
-0.0254317783,
0.1064382195,
0.0308644269,
0.0442400463,
0.0153851472,
-0.0126256058,
-0.0103354752,
-0.0308966134,
-0.0351527408,
-0.0618665665,
-0.0220660008,
0.0029076608,
-0.0200919416,
0.0405733883,
-0.0156641882,
-0.0025350172,
-0.0374566726,
-0.0020429275,
-0.024467444,
-0.0249801613,
-0.0201188922,
-0.0244909357,
0.0221246108,
-0.058271125,
0.0281612482,
0.0130798519,
-0.0624443851,
0.0120588411,
-0.0210683607,
-0.0154111907,
-0.0075509674,
-0.0003836676,
0.0214055292,
0.0276279282,
-0.0441632867,
0.0320192054,
0.0400257297,
0.0727686733,
-0.0092351241,
-0.0227203928,
-0.0385940261,
0.0146515965,
-0.0613734499,
0.0097828107,
-0.0550683737,
0.0402006768,
-0.0339026265,
-0.039044451,
-0.0178961437,
0.0178438537,
-0.0354061536,
0.0207889136,
0.0153556233,
0.0399636887,
-0.0470937826,
0.0096024517,
-0.0356850736,
0.0897142068,
-0.0010178002,
0.0173056778,
0.0352144577,
-0.0374455675,
-0.0418637134,
0.0205852054,
0.02408191,
-0.0075027081,
-0.0155943902,
0.0726049244,
-0.0030490998,
-0.0468358956,
-0.039014291,
-0.0021367471,
-0.044755999,
-0.0500671081,
0.001375746,
-0.01179145,
0.0547994785,
-0.0329634212,
0.0011242074,
-0.0380848236,
0.01070501,
0.0021564458,
0.0174895786,
0.0406930931,
-0.029654827,
-0.0238501932,
-0.0135709951,
0.0008232642,
-0.0033386112,
0.0503093749,
0.0439656563,
0.0115509192,
0.0065773861,
0.0081407037,
0.0104508698,
-0.0089103933,
0.0432154983,
0.0267234016,
-0.0114174802,
0.0039044593,
-0.0161169805,
0.0036915236,
0.0385422967,
0.0652177259,
-0.0653835982,
-0.0318965167,
0.0735405833,
0.0268917065,
0.0412133969,
-0.0102693541,
0.0111000622,
0.0520540886,
-0.0089583034,
0.0415613875,
-0.0192963909,
0.0242286306,
0.0536012575,
-0.0186524801,
0.0682727993,
-0.0101055866,
-0.0452709012,
-0.042668134,
0.0423692875,
-0.0037792388,
0.0597047955,
-0.0074824211,
0.0464600995,
0.0260425061,
-0.070949398,
0.0476499088,
0.0093577914,
-0.0115563227,
-0.0229880679,
-0.0552903153,
-0.0308842584,
0.0745447129,
0.0179426819,
-0.0216910709,
-0.0546089895,
-0.0764736086,
-0.0048763659,
-0.0064457711,
0.015693523,
-0.0271223281,
0.0806475282,
-0.0516571961,
-0.0312976278,
-0.0130461734,
0.0016778169,
0.0228195507,
-0.0117856292,
-0.0261718109,
0.0072954679,
0.025532933,
0.0328875892,
-0.0133756902,
0.0026822111,
-0.0155304698,
0.0178107414,
0.0042119874,
0.0507270955,
0.0248928517,
-0.008030613,
-0.0308914874,
0.008974052,
-0.0014216043,
-0.003006198,
0.0096161617,
-0.0967541263,
-0.1058096513,
0.029757319,
0.0253352672,
0.0110602593,
0.019746121,
-0.0581999123,
-0.0853098333,
0.0163930357,
-0.034563072,
0.0139869712,
-0.0325711817,
0.0063719857,
0.0597252659,
0.0162598286,
-0.0092015602,
0.0185448658,
-0.0443241969,
-0.0168432016,
0.0177406836,
0.0172836483,
0.03171397,
-0.0400321707,
0.0012484307,
0.0272350125,
-0.0417077728,
0.0244150516,
0.0065439399,
0.0099606737,
-0.0665676147,
0.0121955071,
-0.047982391,
0.0243235696,
-0.0357989036,
0.0084042167,
0.0347087905,
0.029007379,
0.0082993014,
-0.0337011255,
-0.0385535322,
-0.0292503685,
0.0426675007,
-0.0359398015,
0.0371941663,
0.05853495,
-0.012474129,
-0.0560929179,
0.0194965191,
-0.0006826973,
0.0157388616,
-0.0738156736,
-0.0320079103,
-0.0387093425,
0.0290617514,
-0.0024134219,
0.038666904,
-0.0290915351,
-0.0350527912,
0.0135503775,
0.0022740685,
-0.0293976199,
0.0355993994,
0.0133600757,
0.044614058,
-0.0300297644,
-0.0630283877,
-0.0575714484,
0.0679707527,
-0.0256493017,
0.0459205508,
-0.0301631037,
0.0056552696,
-0.0073023736,
0.0520656705,
0.0230981801,
0.0461754054,
-0.0301574823,
-0.0505961291,
0.0164376628,
-0.0015041814,
0.0036677062,
-0.0064882669,
-0.0574507229,
0.000572486,
-0.0390739441,
-0.0326481722,
0.0619683526,
-0.0072694481,
-0.0221652612,
-0.0377708636,
-0.0382429659,
-0.0211371444,
0.0512165092,
-0.0199153982,
0.0067215441,
0.0494242683,
-0.0518395714,
-0.0421461016,
-0.0501346141,
0.0146396272,
-0.0460289121,
0.0602721684,
-0.0358631276,
0.0116370786,
-0.0111908652,
-0.0551868305,
-0.0472992696,
-0.0042430675,
0.0024189283,
0.0100837117,
0.0153205823,
-0.0210923869,
0.0102738244,
0.0081639402,
0.0091091013,
0.0607745759,
0.0100783445,
-0.0066944347,
-0.0304598026,
0.0593729243,
0.0374809615,
0.0077335406,
-0.0204335693,
-0.0241428781,
0.0590678677,
0.0591345541,
0.0655905381,
-0.0043550762,
-0.0273743644,
0.0100830365,
0.0164571032,
0.0168810934,
-0.008095311,
-0.0112225451,
0.0761962458,
-0.0407727249,
0.004529594,
0.0675300136,
0.0156353787,
-0.0377871506,
-0.0303047933,
0.0296230074,
-0.0094365533,
0.0020150852,
0.0038938504,
-0.1080040857,
-0.043160215,
-0.0012263764,
0.034343902,
0.0129098129,
-0.0364189968,
-0.0343362242,
-0.0619488768,
-0.0026793892,
0.0020477925,
-0.0302777197,
-0.0256401077,
-0.0185461845,
0.0273697339,
0.0152955707,
0.0349980593,
0.0066131833,
0.0352255516,
-0.0414581969,
0.0408885479,
-0.004460759,
-0.0187641811,
0.0054314863,
0.0095653143,
0.0561068729,
0.0535760783,
0.0661402941,
0.015876431,
0.0058381739,
0.0005156904,
-0.0578202158,
-0.0074078543,
0.0056491783,
0.0809315071,
-0.0045473063,
-0.0131108332,
-0.0078319451,
0.0248089507,
-0.015355722,
-0.0317591652,
-0.020931704,
-0.0094706016,
-0.045813527,
0.020840181,
0.0120305317,
0.0157266408,
0.0621545166,
0.0293458793,
0.0309900772,
-0.0409284681,
-0.0202705171,
-0.0256133154,
-0.0036420086,
-0.0404741652,
0.0524029694,
-0.0472422354,
0.0203934014,
0.0534162521,
-0.0569870658,
-0.029583957,
-0.0057934015,
0.0393221714,
-0.0361483805,
0.0047750762,
0.0172208659,
-0.0005691099,
0.0005791269,
0.0026105063,
-0.0086096795,
0.0361600481,
-0.0380540863,
-0.0363400802,
0.0497164503,
0.0028686305,
-0.0096228886,
0.0420063175,
-0.093039237,
-0.0567695051,
-0.0112171723,
0.0588035397,
0.0179112554,
0.0663166642,
0.0120019699,
0.0205634441,
-0.0169762559,
-0.003427376,
-0.0069260583,
-0.0251104906,
0.0655545443,
0.0654404238,
-0.0379379094,
0.0211385265,
-0.0182427168,
0.0037136932,
-0.0276424978,
0.048700314,
-0.0707267076,
-0.0840078369,
0.0060609085,
-0.0384873487,
0.0651869848,
0.0505207814,
0.0017874525,
-0.0340729393,
0.0632365867,
0.0158749931,
-0.0043603578,
-0.0685162023,
0.0334718414,
-0.0121223703,
-0.0277966317,
-0.0025139726,
-0.0168313142,
0.0162642021,
-0.018148711,
-0.0103642289,
-0.0283618532,
0.04312592,
-0.0155171528,
0.0098299244,
0.0020503954,
-0.0026211671,
0.0211399794,
0.0601581372,
0.0431151763,
0.0115567287,
0.115883477,
0.0101352222,
-0.0262097791,
0.0224562455,
0.0404862501,
-0.0704496652,
-0.0343238525,
-0.0317703672,
-0.0059256749,
0.0365727134,
0.0288786404,
0.0301569458,
0.0180048291,
0.0420643352,
-0.0116756409,
0.0650101453,
-0.0171934403,
-0.0014432063,
0.0135024879,
0.0288364328,
0.0012764466,
0.050198026,
0.0544206463,
-0.0075741266,
0.0412185118,
-0.0253541172,
0.0427465476,
-0.0499385707,
-0.0030226307,
-0.000984848,
0.094181709,
0.0105445059,
-0.0056179427,
-0.0218917951,
-0.0623985156,
0.0153032131,
0.001292116,
0.0317619219,
-0.0221798047,
0.0576396659,
-0.0191754662,
-0.0043497272,
-0.01430046,
-0.0253381226,
-0.0529571436,
0.0228422265,
0.000624142,
-0.0185768716,
-6.420450227e-33,
-0.0175384991,
-0.0302343983,
0.0195682067,
-0.002690776,
-0.045121327,
-0.0126867285,
-0.0408380367,
-0.0178054906,
-0.0339055434,
-0.0024270103,
-0.0120245116,
0.0556001477,
0.024214685,
0.0402208343,
-0.0396995656,
-0.0349506661,
0.073470585,
-0.003615448,
-0.0031263544,
0.0577747039,
0.0590605624,
0.0334671214,
0.0492544509,
-0.0849953741,
-0.0115545001,
0.0074064499,
-0.0028682575,
0.0413012654,
0.0006454022,
0.0146334097,
-0.0078001423,
0.0235520266,
-0.0125005469,
-0.0512981936,
-0.0251068864,
0.0141920019,
-0.0441354066,
-0.0457164198,
-0.0050243125,
-0.0063633174,
-0.034246929,
0.0323882252,
-0.0065241004,
0.003148406,
0.0477550738,
0.0054286933,
-0.0165158864,
0.0306176804,
-0.0222936738,
0.009773232,
-0.0017410835,
0.020880701,
-0.0263167899,
-0.0950166807,
-0.0073867962,
0.0612758137,
0.0240833741,
-0.0864237174,
-0.0655492693,
-0.0031687387,
-0.0258243531,
-0.0053352639,
0.0169307943,
0.0427768789,
0.0055906917,
0.0840606838,
0.0401197225,
0.0291838162,
0.0471429713,
-0.0530179292,
-0.0307651255,
0.0390261561,
-0.0082470551,
-0.0005144929,
0.0059266104,
-0.0207324643,
-0.0246776361,
-0.0040706797,
0.0177234169,
0.0596986338,
-0.0275887847,
0.0368579887,
-0.0068403222,
-0.0370227061,
-0.008138557,
-0.0063716657,
0.0086520584,
-0.0292028729,
0.0235975403,
0.052331727,
0.007804093,
0.002288261,
0.0477658212,
-0.0437096208,
-0.0057583405,
0.0542772524,
-0.0385794975,
0.0063559902,
-0.0163501818,
-0.0300345644,
-0.0567084402,
-0.0532167554,
0.0310756899,
0.0338173844,
0.0176174697,
0.0053190892,
-0.002642957,
0.0220103152,
-0.0448769741,
0.0018864453,
-0.0361599512,
0.0501447432,
-0.0277637392,
0.0391755775,
0.0427665748,
-0.0089872386,
-0.0317910314,
0.0863892585,
0.0242711473,
-0.0135872019,
-0.0496978201,
-0.018216731,
0.0057676905,
0.0350588076,
-0.0148690613,
-0.0079747532,
-0.0192319173,
0.0002874799,
-0.0166881662,
-0.0340243839,
0.0028895722,
-0.0000607353,
2.966e-7,
-0.0112372441,
0.012404589,
0.0613902584,
-0.0039473465,
0.0285800379,
0.047868453,
-0.0156901926,
0.0073151141,
0.0382990614,
-0.0307845511,
0.0247687455,
0.0146374507,
0.0399837084,
0.0410424024,
-0.0933644176,
-0.0198619012,
-0.0471371375,
-0.0426531062,
-0.0242025554,
0.0048599583,
0.0744259208,
0.0519189462,
0.0340930745,
0.009641177,
0.030528836,
-0.0206138473,
0.0274121035,
0.0170680881,
0.0157690253,
0.0062988508,
0.0094000418,
-0.012441677,
-0.032317616,
0.0215245001,
-0.0086377449,
0.0571958646,
-0.0283238199,
0.0741750151,
0.0062452331,
-0.1037532687,
-0.0371092819,
0.0277293231,
0.0123396674,
-0.0002727011,
0.0316460952,
-0.0611525737,
-0.0079800524,
-0.0373349898,
-0.0107669523,
-0.0100923879,
0.0414602645,
0.0295180138,
-0.0002255253,
0.009886045,
-0.0221320391,
0.0132870497,
-0.0173410065,
-0.1030760109,
0.0120142465,
0.0029357555,
-0.024739854,
-0.0652873144,
-0.0295274165,
-0.0532005392,
-0.0154860048,
0.0132260788,
-0.0071699941,
2.433491645e-34,
0.023047559,
-0.0226615537,
0.0108364532,
0.0440169498,
0.0178463142,
-0.0154500697,
-0.0549700074,
0.006918476,
0.0582712106,
-0.0489295721,
-0.01324795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08215v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08215v2 | Aligning Language Models with Preferences through f-divergence Minimization | 2023-02-16T10:59:39 | 2023-06-06T13:09:21 | Dongyoung Go, Tomasz Korbak, Germán Kruszewski, Jos Rozen, Nahyeon Ryu, Marc Dymetman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Aligning language models with preferences can be posed as approximating a
target distribution representing some desired behavior. Existing approaches
differ both in the functional form of the target distribution and the algorithm
used to approximate it. For instance, Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) corresponds to minimizing a reverse KL from an implicit target
distribution arising from a KL penalty in the objective. On the other hand,
Generative Distributional Control (GDC) has an explicit target distribution and
minimizes a forward KL from it using the Distributional Policy Gradient (DPG)
algorithm. In this paper, we propose a new approach, f-DPG, which allows the
use of any f-divergence to approximate any target distribution that can be
evaluated. f-DPG unifies both frameworks (RLHF, GDC) and the approximation
methods (DPG, RL with KL penalties). We show the practical benefits of various
choices of divergence objectives and demonstrate that there is no universally
optimal objective but that different divergences present different alignment
and diversity trade-offs. We show that Jensen-Shannon divergence strikes a good
balance between these objectives, and frequently outperforms forward KL
divergence by a wide margin, leading to significant improvements over prior
work. These distinguishing characteristics between divergences persist as the
model size increases, highlighting the importance of selecting appropriate
divergence objectives. | [
0.0453641377,
0.0885997266,
-0.005456089,
-0.0048851613,
-0.0333899632,
-0.0053859949,
-0.048070237,
-0.0043401723,
-0.0642901883,
0.0220134109,
-0.0154313669,
-0.0668210834,
0.0111212842,
0.0306691397,
0.0360356979,
-0.0587485358,
0.0407795198,
-0.0222775545,
0.0000444431,
-0.0425349213,
0.0449893326,
-0.0260843728,
0.0185817555,
0.0280820336,
0.0212707128,
0.0060467054,
-0.0080823563,
-0.0004813164,
0.040190082,
0.0217184182,
0.0213120282,
0.026736822,
0.0251259319,
-0.0106163612,
0.0000022514,
-0.0120692747,
0.0092135146,
-0.0110297902,
0.0087430207,
-0.0196372643,
0.0660148859,
-0.0274131149,
-0.0374403037,
-0.0083788391,
-0.0321697965,
-0.0148862172,
0.0891627073,
0.0346073098,
0.0211021323,
0.063018851,
0.0013279576,
-0.0553804077,
-0.0009408694,
-0.0496102422,
-0.0201472323,
-0.0159460194,
0.0267853159,
-0.0080635399,
-0.0053220447,
0.0056428309,
-0.0407556333,
0.0332646333,
-0.0144635504,
0.0056986255,
0.0006646265,
0.044013571,
0.0093301041,
-0.0245575253,
-0.0033452897,
0.0631268844,
-0.0339591168,
-0.051619757,
0.0268297996,
-0.0522852801,
-0.020752633,
0.032246016,
0.0212720446,
-0.0101535823,
0.0198972672,
0.0523388721,
0.0321619585,
-0.034368407,
0.0539282039,
0.0092546223,
-0.0276306439,
0.0560285971,
0.0123857846,
-0.0306545459,
0.0068652793,
-0.0153196696,
-0.0383732729,
-0.040806789,
-0.0173064824,
-0.0134671796,
-0.0339618661,
0.0014858174,
-0.0394766405,
-0.05397477,
-0.0123791983,
-0.0221608765,
0.0453937463,
0.0484282821,
0.0268794782,
0.0172866303,
0.0517155565,
0.0728917569,
-0.0461863726,
0.0028625613,
-0.037345361,
0.0309252534,
-0.0098516,
-0.0091462545,
-0.0037654324,
-0.0020582862,
-0.0379354768,
-0.020159496,
-0.0502411276,
0.0271368306,
-0.0554115847,
0.0045211129,
0.019094862,
0.019894544,
-0.0500425845,
-0.0086436914,
-0.0261940751,
0.0436085239,
-0.0265258532,
-0.0021793381,
0.0324079208,
0.0353190042,
0.0156917162,
0.0281214211,
-0.0046460759,
-0.0168849155,
-0.0252143238,
0.0733591989,
-0.0050541647,
0.0279532596,
-0.0080011748,
0.0223786831,
-0.0433536656,
-0.0542330854,
-0.0192692336,
-0.0780921727,
0.0128969522,
-0.0302890614,
-0.0439507104,
-0.0759866014,
-0.0153642269,
-0.0242413785,
-0.0112960534,
0.0725676864,
0.0631230399,
0.0131823234,
0.0465698913,
-0.0529532023,
-0.0018866115,
0.0804743618,
0.0182438251,
-0.0074700746,
-0.0016939765,
0.0273591857,
-0.0000419862,
0.0469362102,
0.0317907147,
0.0344859622,
-0.0515373684,
-0.0258520246,
-0.0199655946,
0.0531633422,
0.0886719301,
0.0414286889,
-0.0174155068,
-0.0460059419,
0.0803253204,
0.0392572284,
0.0423098169,
-0.0268245004,
0.033718314,
0.0339755304,
-0.0719188973,
0.0025819878,
-0.0253582876,
0.0108758742,
-0.0086284764,
0.0297442544,
0.00650548,
0.0117473193,
-0.0279837772,
-0.0455062389,
0.0276494101,
-0.0283646286,
0.0245416146,
0.0268909056,
0.0590498783,
-0.0160782821,
-0.0457855016,
-0.0113451034,
0.0423749797,
-0.0232464168,
0.0134386709,
-0.0154808816,
0.0547663942,
0.0601843111,
0.0126765789,
0.0003705658,
-0.0257862359,
-0.0100294966,
-0.0540776663,
0.051413957,
0.0430501178,
-0.0117695089,
-0.0030964904,
-0.0315478593,
-0.0370652564,
0.0343559422,
0.0274886396,
0.0339281484,
-0.0069037494,
-0.0006003803,
-0.0103804264,
-0.0387058444,
0.0017411632,
0.0323244482,
-0.0037795817,
-0.0024252448,
0.0101272585,
0.0299495105,
0.053480871,
-0.0163628105,
-0.0012983127,
0.0168366842,
-0.0192853548,
-0.0192191284,
-0.01559297,
0.0002696389,
-0.0191122647,
-0.0148091624,
0.0427089669,
-0.0213349294,
0.0363560729,
0.0543377362,
-0.0343055725,
-0.0343495198,
0.0410564281,
0.0050174841,
0.0525813103,
-0.0349080637,
0.0197832473,
-0.014744306,
-0.022744175,
-0.0655590892,
0.0513260886,
-0.02100683,
0.0227031764,
-0.0337665975,
0.0296908375,
-0.0250295866,
-0.0625391006,
-0.0430420563,
0.0170430876,
0.0052430332,
0.058532238,
0.0809203833,
0.015433209,
0.0057718577,
-0.0080181109,
-0.0134503236,
0.0101784738,
-0.0429351665,
0.0183995143,
0.008123585,
0.0230746549,
-0.0181200411,
0.0340629853,
-0.0426512584,
0.0140823331,
0.0111020952,
0.011133071,
0.0273428448,
0.0294529032,
-0.0042841285,
-0.0665607005,
-0.0112838177,
0.0032797516,
0.0063378019,
-0.0537508093,
0.0310292374,
-0.0365568399,
0.058430519,
-0.0505553558,
0.0551524088,
-0.0489185527,
-0.0289815087,
-0.0173228569,
-0.0308509003,
0.0810905248,
0.0647726282,
0.0221497267,
0.0134553416,
0.0392385423,
0.0239741467,
-0.0872489139,
0.0157184526,
-0.0893435925,
-0.0333661027,
-0.0524940826,
0.0073869461,
0.0465982184,
0.0888715684,
0.0131470701,
-0.0145306131,
-0.0747603178,
0.0178438649,
-0.0163609963,
-0.0451806858,
-0.0294527467,
0.0329802595,
-0.0375978313,
0.0285482854,
-0.0415625796,
-0.0579100661,
0.0866253003,
-0.0027993971,
0.0365102217,
-0.0382105783,
-0.022521982,
0.002123693,
0.003970908,
0.0081826923,
0.0164317861,
0.0165248457,
-0.0035435688,
-0.0886652321,
-0.0001437926,
0.0589351803,
-0.0043947212,
0.0782150328,
-0.0119023006,
0.0303557403,
0.0016365666,
-0.0378219858,
-0.0338752121,
-0.0786018223,
0.0307672713,
0.0102795716,
0.0161265861,
-0.0379104502,
-0.0296209715,
0.0361963399,
0.0077320752,
0.0168410577,
-0.0095860539,
0.0048011458,
-0.0146728465,
-0.0059390208,
0.0909599885,
0.0066834604,
-0.029300034,
-0.0131877651,
-0.0445458554,
-0.0023193429,
0.0326852836,
0.0296435542,
0.0000958754,
0.0071786786,
0.0233524553,
-0.0332696177,
-0.0238622203,
0.0321525037,
0.0407584645,
-0.0077377278,
-0.0305893049,
0.0826676637,
0.0037729351,
-0.0597441755,
0.0167454518,
-0.0041105784,
0.1038889512,
-0.0124982242,
0.0363181978,
-0.0572340898,
0.0033954249,
-0.0116501404,
0.0472925827,
0.0011147019,
0.0060564899,
-0.00423746,
-0.1095476747,
-0.008013471,
0.0182827283,
-0.0732444823,
-0.0591707826,
-0.0269393828,
0.0185532663,
-0.0283298139,
0.0019833185,
0.0066330172,
0.0340645872,
0.0034724399,
0.0187006351,
0.0340630338,
-0.0732305124,
-0.0229099449,
-0.0443198048,
0.0390560962,
0.142726779,
0.0139582986,
0.0151673015,
-0.0148242572,
-0.0315464363,
-0.0301390383,
-0.0661686808,
0.0045900773,
-0.0470018908,
-0.0141727757,
0.0000835363,
0.0119994245,
0.0561135821,
-0.0137726022,
0.0225639269,
-0.0234161336,
0.0371061563,
-0.027103126,
-0.0288753025,
-0.0054404852,
-0.0008497189,
0.0837141648,
0.053372886,
0.0141989514,
-0.0766849369,
-0.0397351496,
-0.0439280085,
-0.0261182617,
-0.0094480999,
-0.0374611691,
-0.0134877246,
0.0274866764,
-0.0764387548,
-0.0797250792,
-0.0126501909,
-0.0519972555,
0.0194386542,
0.0063444348,
0.0043604951,
0.0291904379,
-0.0264789984,
-0.0214025788,
-0.0110890316,
-0.0225021597,
0.0218074415,
-0.050340753,
-0.0399111994,
0.0088951867,
-0.0341368988,
-0.0555087514,
0.0195419304,
-0.0728223026,
-0.1108270735,
-0.0050175893,
0.0574192666,
0.0098978421,
0.0431482494,
-0.0262751281,
-0.0289731286,
0.0413023196,
0.0884975269,
0.0093274591,
0.0370374769,
0.0243346691,
-0.0032862562,
0.0099622058,
0.0463137813,
-0.0420830138,
0.0139589431,
0.0187967494,
0.0768036097,
-0.0119240368,
-0.0388760716,
0.0104626492,
-0.029487865,
0.0141778737,
-0.0536311567,
-0.0549809299,
-0.035940133,
-0.039180167,
-0.0051533976,
-0.0401924625,
-0.0049170055,
-0.0531872176,
0.0435871184,
0.0029721942,
0.0060029095,
-0.0143722752,
0.0143483281,
0.0337514989,
-0.0531030819,
0.0169995483,
0.0525027029,
0.0397068821,
0.0656790659,
0.048095189,
0.0247706119,
-0.0067501375,
-0.0069664158,
0.02513876,
0.0091729984,
0.0272071604,
0.0394323058,
-0.0066747558,
-0.0324819274,
-0.0247450452,
-0.0471872576,
-0.0381957293,
-0.0097984131,
0.0308226459,
0.0587014146,
-0.0100337742,
0.0339443646,
-0.0364864841,
0.0126892524,
-0.047219675,
0.0348363966,
-0.00850794,
-0.0355890617,
0.0758826509,
0.0105137974,
-0.0029896491,
-0.015678551,
0.0591810532,
0.0230347328,
0.0204471927,
-0.0450098217,
0.0263689943,
-0.0391213894,
-0.0188183859,
-0.0036749195,
0.0420257598,
-0.0357739739,
0.0037290382,
-0.0495728217,
-0.0546309277,
-0.0306161996,
0.0488281138,
-0.014373282,
0.0013300114,
0.058385592,
0.0590594076,
-0.0606290214,
-0.0083161714,
-0.0800668448,
0.0046986556,
-0.0294759925,
-0.0294584762,
-0.0684318393,
-6.4005447e-33,
-0.0334231257,
0.0004687665,
0.0151272248,
-0.0132300435,
-0.0516332127,
-0.0406843238,
-0.0149643691,
0.0020532543,
-0.0155148515,
0.0088571357,
0.0068685976,
0.0057304171,
0.0023046001,
0.0165603347,
0.0035912003,
-0.0121989893,
0.0269777589,
-0.013659603,
-0.0321922675,
0.0015853971,
0.0170504097,
0.0233235527,
0.02650344,
-0.0270697251,
0.050293453,
-0.0232256595,
-0.0216165241,
0.0093493164,
0.0420483686,
0.0833298191,
-0.0161240324,
0.0396574624,
-0.0153785134,
-0.035350956,
-0.0231613535,
0.0055301976,
-0.0237774756,
-0.0175946448,
0.0403709672,
0.0075016511,
-0.0054407557,
-0.0173403081,
0.0485369749,
-0.0089550437,
-0.0339476019,
0.0223507378,
0.0336685665,
0.0155725731,
-0.0435367338,
-0.0155031411,
-0.0567084067,
0.017850941,
0.017396342,
-0.0003553544,
0.0210531224,
-0.0074371919,
-0.0049594287,
0.0077195689,
-0.0127763003,
0.0447993651,
-0.0048792721,
0.0434188172,
0.0897114426,
0.0625069886,
0.0439819582,
0.0127010224,
0.0023081745,
-0.0489166528,
-0.0193458665,
-0.0413818806,
0.0352327451,
0.0056132078,
-0.0283509903,
0.0412888899,
0.0139210876,
-0.014949494,
-0.0236471724,
0.0195084251,
-0.0065280059,
0.0022850495,
0.0198508501,
0.0715619028,
-0.0617452785,
-0.0277360845,
-0.0506428853,
-0.0117497845,
-0.0019268303,
-0.0369284675,
0.0352998525,
0.0034218403,
-0.0002228071,
-0.0397656709,
0.0217431523,
-0.0475743786,
-0.0133002093,
0.050338354,
-0.0187902488,
0.0253871903,
0.0002105631,
0.0106125316,
-0.0847529024,
-0.0178632773,
-0.0308120586,
-0.0081701474,
-0.0421335772,
0.0386106819,
-0.0219560768,
0.0046900609,
-0.0385128707,
-0.0014309539,
-0.0264445655,
-0.0227777734,
-0.0168904141,
0.0581620894,
0.0640455484,
-0.0104359724,
0.008666697,
0.0031273898,
0.0299132988,
-0.0300500169,
0.0042058914,
0.0164892301,
-0.0329284705,
0.029579984,
-0.0247729011,
0.0201125294,
-0.0189624485,
0.0432213545,
-0.0083169518,
-0.0406161994,
-0.0170413218,
-0.0021283892,
2.797e-7,
0.0264520012,
0.0066484148,
0.010015063,
0.0570687689,
-0.0289413668,
0.0382646732,
0.0181734115,
0.0028397969,
-0.0267894715,
-0.0109404661,
0.0389121622,
0.0291279182,
0.0027172929,
-0.0240387321,
-0.0894083902,
0.0586515367,
-0.0341192968,
0.0146103986,
-0.0022043998,
-0.0367402658,
0.0070269937,
0.0729823112,
0.0384054147,
0.0116408886,
0.0131166987,
0.0206686817,
0.0721048489,
-0.0442142114,
0.0013962918,
0.0205304269,
0.0149736274,
-0.0256230626,
-0.0090322495,
-0.0116195185,
-0.003275011,
0.0225648601,
-0.0224889014,
0.0617662929,
-0.0137196733,
-0.0396235138,
-0.0369918533,
0.0335830525,
-0.0064233942,
-0.0549288243,
0.0212191846,
-0.016709771,
0.0105533553,
-0.0310018603,
-0.007961018,
0.0069853202,
0.0043458142,
-0.022707805,
-0.0418998972,
-0.0113004548,
0.0424583405,
0.0211163349,
0.0093299868,
-0.0452252738,
-0.0129191559,
0.0631589517,
-0.0360716246,
-0.0220685359,
-0.0205554068,
0.0682969615,
0.0253226142,
-0.0214049332,
-0.0125022642,
2.495628231e-34,
0.0271506943,
0.0039201179,
-0.0138476398,
-0.0232450087,
-0.0302471649,
0.043830201,
-0.020768078,
0.0250814371,
0.0557542741,
-0.0467249751,
-0.0258306097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08198v1 | Un mod{è}le de base de connaissances terminologiques | 2023-02-16T10:28:23 | 2023-02-16T10:28:23 | Patrick Séguéla, Nathalie Aussenac-Gilles | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In the present paper, we argue that Terminological Knowledge Bases (TKB) are
all the more useful for addressing various needs as they do not fulfill formal
criteria. Moreover, they intend to clarify the terminology of a given domain by
illustrating term uses in various contexts. Thus we designed a TKB structure
including 3 linked features: terms, concepts and texts, that present the
peculiar use of each term in the domain. Note that concepts are represented
into frames whose non-formal description is standardized. Associated with this
structure, we defined modeling criteria at the conceptual level. Finaly, we
discuss the situation of TKB with regard to ontologies, and the use of TKB for
the development of AI systems. | [
0.0347932503,
-0.039409779,
-0.0258573312,
0.0453775637,
-0.0467591882,
-0.0236241445,
0.041380316,
0.0345715247,
-0.0261475537,
-0.0574961901,
-0.0232586116,
-0.0154693024,
-0.0049937554,
0.0715160221,
-0.042664174,
-0.0870792866,
-0.007867177,
-0.0030668685,
0.0135884238,
0.0182005726,
0.0036896814,
0.0336426347,
-0.0444996916,
0.0051445998,
-0.0519632548,
-0.0170180723,
-0.0196782108,
-0.0683667213,
-0.0023477618,
-0.0166976769,
-0.0009972723,
0.0112261968,
0.0152101303,
0.0025726231,
0.0000025271,
-0.0487837456,
-0.0120807299,
-0.0093451235,
-0.0206179116,
-0.0296763796,
0.0326356478,
0.0227623675,
0.0172973443,
-0.0691565052,
-0.0275827926,
0.0090098521,
0.0104892496,
0.0372598357,
0.0087194489,
-0.0096713966,
-0.0176609792,
-0.0404729843,
0.0213813242,
0.0572131425,
0.0152395163,
-0.0098708123,
0.0103824008,
0.0489596874,
0.0795842856,
0.0237377789,
0.021315001,
0.0029402573,
-0.0016456802,
-0.000965277,
0.0146625116,
-0.0018038822,
0.0277283583,
-0.0378648192,
0.0342295878,
0.0379488654,
0.133670643,
-0.011402756,
0.0189207233,
0.0249059573,
0.0011699834,
0.0607564412,
-0.017346533,
0.0625318959,
-0.048169028,
-0.035704188,
0.0120208142,
0.0093583856,
0.0000105387,
0.0202895962,
-0.0355085582,
0.0859590024,
-0.01905022,
-0.0226096734,
0.0135221435,
-0.0587489419,
-0.0169715341,
-0.034585055,
0.0236896668,
0.0274643265,
0.0139059722,
0.0407616571,
-0.0255095977,
0.0259088855,
-0.012002727,
-0.084636651,
-0.041611284,
-0.0051321238,
0.0012318287,
0.0257479232,
0.0120450649,
0.0416061021,
-0.0040983772,
-0.0011529071,
-0.0306272767,
-0.0229880232,
-0.1160367504,
-0.0159927011,
-0.0659640208,
0.0911099985,
0.0181350894,
0.00396802,
-0.0219930504,
0.0643236786,
-0.0452748276,
0.0028228043,
-0.0103276307,
-0.013295074,
0.0146117732,
-0.008780228,
-0.071152471,
-0.108835727,
-0.0109022083,
0.0026212938,
-0.0124848532,
-0.0417643487,
0.0702356696,
-0.0025311867,
0.0115424497,
-0.0068739252,
-0.0501630716,
0.0226900633,
0.0663973168,
0.0216689147,
-0.004847487,
-0.0416513421,
0.0155401407,
0.0118872719,
-0.0381473452,
-0.045479212,
-0.0107409339,
-0.0048191948,
0.0014380873,
-0.0160659049,
-0.0230001211,
-0.0114981728,
-0.0418338925,
0.0652034655,
-0.1033383459,
-0.0156182218,
0.0254683662,
0.0540833399,
-0.0343533494,
-0.0075929076,
0.005446027,
0.0244881641,
0.0378352515,
-0.0050467351,
-0.030471459,
-0.0570584536,
-0.0183384027,
-0.0547674522,
-0.0843978748,
0.0282733273,
-0.031324029,
0.0138611048,
-0.0154930092,
-0.0039510527,
-0.0161292162,
0.0240205284,
0.0255365446,
0.0635845661,
0.0392691419,
0.0615423471,
0.0769485086,
-0.0206406917,
0.0235149991,
0.023333773,
0.0203980375,
-0.0070289746,
-0.0443977416,
-0.0226429477,
-0.0698452517,
-0.0285057854,
0.0048538079,
-0.0685993209,
-0.0364892185,
0.0154027268,
-0.0172032844,
-0.0364114679,
0.0569288507,
-0.0075813653,
0.0284201186,
0.0550233126,
0.0002034753,
-0.0244838241,
-0.013829289,
-0.0646433681,
0.007676776,
0.0884185731,
0.050423488,
-0.0463793129,
-0.0693537071,
0.0424619429,
-0.0411174633,
0.0555940121,
0.0035662514,
-0.0494830646,
-0.0643482283,
-0.017887041,
-0.0122870021,
0.0049910131,
0.0155113647,
0.0317645334,
-0.0785454139,
0.0563319176,
0.024902422,
0.0000449005,
0.0014739087,
0.0063006114,
0.0331933685,
-0.001068588,
-0.0392038077,
0.0042699054,
0.0227698311,
0.0477543771,
-0.0022402797,
0.0019294281,
0.0375575423,
-0.0188984405,
-0.0345475078,
0.0210809484,
-0.0233727805,
0.0679290667,
0.0031061957,
-0.0052810512,
0.0743384361,
-0.0294217113,
0.0133192772,
-0.0354620554,
0.0098387739,
0.003477375,
0.0438953824,
-0.0184974037,
0.0224670172,
-0.0201595537,
-0.0031772854,
-0.0040709535,
0.035837125,
-0.006566131,
-0.0005701085,
0.007187794,
-0.0037550486,
0.0334723368,
0.0090053258,
0.0113028083,
0.046314422,
0.0146015193,
0.0202332214,
0.0264098346,
-0.033813376,
0.0047315052,
0.0464127287,
-0.0851623863,
0.0057009379,
0.0259690695,
0.0090595456,
0.0163779184,
-0.0281289276,
0.0083369948,
-0.0062884619,
0.0377646908,
0.0576241761,
-0.0526139326,
-0.0230024084,
0.0178389102,
0.0561254099,
-0.0493385792,
0.0361948833,
0.0062761731,
-0.0158646125,
0.0038688506,
0.0291828811,
-0.0303438623,
-0.0306532942,
0.0344945602,
-0.042714674,
0.0103101097,
0.0012794576,
0.0087455576,
0.0009482349,
-0.0264082886,
-0.0729925334,
-0.0104814954,
0.0078772409,
0.0375141837,
0.0611015446,
-0.0485771857,
-0.0047162431,
0.0069349022,
0.0131458119,
0.0389090367,
-0.0347431265,
-0.0452613607,
0.0284014363,
0.0331614241,
-0.0022394306,
0.0165414531,
-0.0524562448,
0.0441389009,
-0.0407283492,
-0.0104542542,
-0.0817459002,
-0.0166063644,
-0.0047840271,
0.0684969947,
0.0250422079,
0.0025750813,
0.0264945924,
0.0132328607,
0.0332319364,
0.0026869306,
-0.0326284803,
-0.012316064,
0.0452314019,
-0.0276336744,
0.0255111698,
0.0579306781,
0.0111491354,
-0.0141222356,
-0.0043346663,
0.027654266,
0.0106592551,
0.015156839,
-0.0491300486,
0.0334382206,
0.0362765379,
0.0340375863,
-0.0611985065,
0.0901003331,
-0.0041394923,
0.0552556701,
-0.0013273474,
-0.0059756781,
-0.0009357595,
0.0275449213,
0.011700334,
0.01423431,
0.031420026,
-0.0344167054,
-0.0163068436,
0.0198035389,
0.0271229781,
-0.0417178646,
-0.0080067776,
0.0684387162,
0.0259995926,
0.0162310395,
-0.0496936142,
-0.0315151513,
-0.0025985825,
-0.0272029229,
0.029480312,
-0.1000122204,
-0.0561131537,
-0.0155887194,
-0.0926789865,
-0.0397962965,
0.0041164029,
0.0979565457,
0.0618451945,
-0.004003692,
0.0167575143,
-0.0112168705,
-0.0847956464,
-0.0278202035,
0.0123177627,
-0.0448321179,
0.0445325971,
-0.0262835212,
-0.0356035046,
-0.0444669463,
-0.0021486983,
-0.0093920166,
-0.0016123514,
0.0072167953,
-0.0258288663,
-0.0419420749,
-0.0036177137,
0.016836606,
-0.0180533845,
-0.0164089091,
-0.0473506227,
0.0195342693,
0.0032727069,
-0.0271373838,
0.0322683081,
-0.0411334001,
-0.0361443646,
0.0306800362,
-0.0154967746,
0.0383667201,
-0.0029776257,
0.0640027523,
-0.0382512435,
-0.0458752736,
-0.015008932,
0.0041361134,
0.0459413603,
-0.02347623,
-0.0352092907,
0.0072540548,
0.009335137,
-0.0478489734,
-0.0502612069,
-0.0195592977,
-0.0178180952,
0.0076559829,
0.06705001,
-0.0661460459,
-0.0025489172,
-0.0366473235,
-0.0242289677,
-0.0454412699,
0.0172575545,
-0.0368062407,
0.0107379388,
0.0222176723,
-0.0002987174,
-0.0271496288,
-0.0026203261,
-0.0415563509,
-0.0056149703,
-0.0632782206,
-0.0610018931,
-0.0786778554,
-0.0141469911,
-0.0099178646,
0.0173173007,
-0.0041312445,
0.0003767263,
-0.0104311965,
0.0277469475,
-0.0410899296,
0.0138764586,
0.02542869,
-0.0563987494,
-0.0256060939,
-0.0402758345,
0.0425389595,
-0.0072642528,
-0.0389797539,
-0.0094146123,
0.1134114489,
-0.0098898886,
0.0366635248,
0.0320983231,
0.0109832454,
0.0083680404,
0.0022443356,
-0.024017483,
0.0918258205,
0.0202796906,
0.0048507131,
-0.0216819514,
0.0241784547,
0.0141044008,
-0.0025592693,
0.0205116123,
-0.0356272496,
0.0444690436,
-0.0558300316,
-0.026542386,
-0.0388882458,
-0.0086528501,
0.0329670683,
0.0108631728,
0.0191153008,
0.0056560342,
-0.0453600772,
-0.0051104287,
0.0296368115,
-0.0209735427,
-0.0192805715,
-0.0092919311,
0.0612606332,
-0.0027698067,
-0.0073926835,
0.0276892353,
0.0046915864,
-0.0421508066,
-0.0451425351,
0.0605818182,
0.0143258618,
0.0098814946,
0.0744915456,
0.0076772175,
0.0212615486,
-0.0050224122,
-0.0124423988,
-0.0389904417,
0.0101242037,
-0.0390055664,
0.073689945,
-0.0008546792,
-0.0448586047,
-0.0289233625,
0.0563412607,
0.0162411593,
-0.0138124153,
0.0041498663,
0.0686307773,
0.0444463417,
0.038318444,
-0.0343815945,
-0.0821754187,
0.0055999169,
0.0142025817,
-0.0029803955,
0.0537409969,
-0.0041029686,
-0.013834578,
0.041317042,
0.03008564,
-0.0263807084,
0.0215409901,
-0.0006012607,
0.0314184576,
0.005461961,
-0.0362670198,
-0.0114743123,
-0.009858083,
0.0218413416,
-0.0011681876,
-0.0726475045,
0.0415616632,
-0.0722091496,
-0.0375425182,
0.0540491939,
0.0301061794,
0.001512865,
0.007654076,
0.0882417485,
0.0413236208,
0.0390516408,
-0.0257772505,
-0.0337453373,
0.0345051028,
-0.0616014414,
0.0048186467,
0.0020508193,
-6.44127264e-33,
-0.0420073979,
-0.0360163525,
0.0391091108,
0.0355116092,
0.0033156935,
-0.0062346384,
0.036797002,
-0.0172276236,
0.0065317843,
0.0488986932,
0.012303181,
-0.0025156478,
0.0014529887,
-0.05912311,
0.003326271,
0.0260776505,
-0.0026452334,
0.0229184907,
0.0110669015,
0.0056013707,
0.0965021551,
0.0119891008,
0.0565196276,
-0.0870445296,
0.0910724476,
-0.0280359779,
0.0031503157,
0.0159371309,
0.0221392941,
0.0412127599,
-0.0241450593,
0.0261972863,
0.0324122012,
0.0054471479,
0.0134174228,
-0.0094720088,
-0.0094082588,
-0.0583670996,
0.0281927437,
0.0342318229,
0.0121989716,
-0.0517623797,
-0.0111257117,
-0.0062771994,
-0.0272727162,
0.0562449917,
0.0504086092,
-0.0294508394,
-0.0188227315,
0.0319474116,
-0.0326842517,
0.0223303605,
0.0139397457,
-0.0075353472,
0.0211771578,
-0.0016945614,
-0.0025005313,
-0.0434357412,
-0.031087378,
0.0321950614,
0.0117651708,
-0.0149115175,
0.0562706217,
0.025282098,
0.0470235236,
-0.0040047551,
-0.0204613842,
0.0114291403,
0.009421099,
-0.0288321041,
-0.0198655706,
0.073726669,
-0.0111663863,
0.0000300747,
0.0402002223,
0.0218251143,
-0.0124582471,
0.0099421786,
-0.0194078349,
0.0684957579,
-0.0075773424,
-0.0419223309,
-0.0718593001,
0.0042960695,
0.0066016372,
0.033013884,
-0.0350400582,
-0.051744435,
0.0206416585,
-0.0348556191,
0.0328782387,
0.0050626155,
-0.0607675985,
-0.0172297955,
0.0340107493,
-0.0007246686,
0.0540110506,
0.0014777323,
-0.0180018805,
0.0036524783,
0.0101675903,
-0.0439705849,
-0.0290819425,
-0.0109893065,
0.0288605671,
0.0375633091,
-0.0312921703,
0.0251667015,
0.0440170243,
-0.0164638571,
-0.0169623885,
-0.0770845115,
0.002372368,
-0.0371255912,
-0.0037800213,
0.0261252467,
-0.0035234345,
0.0432937182,
0.0174027607,
-0.0195732377,
-0.0175704863,
0.0173920877,
-0.0184486937,
-0.0150414491,
-0.0013031095,
-0.0294980146,
0.0164636783,
-0.0161723346,
0.0295884628,
0.0187118407,
0.0024624248,
-0.0046019377,
3.261e-7,
-0.0317683034,
0.0398493186,
-0.0327769443,
0.0029229999,
0.0023334238,
0.0224897154,
0.0041664043,
0.0009053742,
-0.0881744698,
-0.0202216431,
0.0476270877,
-0.002794177,
-0.0375884697,
0.0533831157,
-0.0943782479,
-0.050923422,
0.0594313368,
-0.066797033,
-0.043629963,
0.0271243658,
0.0317875035,
-0.0289100576,
0.0336666331,
-0.0053764363,
-0.0114918528,
-0.0187243707,
-0.0152935302,
-0.0162215848,
0.0163204428,
0.0644544512,
0.0322589725,
0.0423539057,
-0.0149709629,
0.0322525017,
0.0151924444,
0.0052430816,
-0.013951635,
0.0157086831,
-0.0109540671,
0.0342369713,
-0.0071253544,
-0.0885221288,
0.0065981522,
-0.009301573,
0.0114378119,
-0.0021592532,
0.0013341275,
0.0013640334,
-0.0031244888,
0.030278869,
-0.0505436994,
-0.0324247517,
0.0064382493,
-0.0263606571,
-0.0157589279,
-0.0171598289,
-0.0061197919,
-0.058646705,
0.0632078946,
0.0665958077,
-0.005482371,
-0.0439107716,
0.0018604776,
-0.0294211693,
0.0403679945,
-0.0050827474,
0.0419268943,
2.357953506e-34,
-0.0344205759,
0.02987279,
-0.0258790292,
0.0201798733,
-0.0055571245,
0.0144388694,
-0.0145813301,
0.0140519785,
0.0518239699,
-0.0463729165,
0.0093302298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08150v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08150v2 | Reanalyzing L2 Preposition Learning with Bayesian Mixed Effects and a Pretrained Language Model | 2023-02-16T08:54:05 | 2023-05-23T08:00:08 | Jakob Prange, Man Ho Ivy Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | We use both Bayesian and neural models to dissect a data set of Chinese
learners' pre- and post-interventional responses to two tests measuring their
understanding of English prepositions. The results mostly replicate previous
findings from frequentist analyses and newly reveal crucial interactions
between student ability, task type, and stimulus sentence. Given the sparsity
of the data as well as high diversity among learners, the Bayesian method
proves most useful; but we also see potential in using language model
probabilities as predictors of grammaticality and learnability. | [
0.0226113163,
0.0357056744,
-0.0456400216,
-0.0053367438,
-0.0183138549,
0.0204240978,
-0.0024052293,
-0.0087050525,
-0.0314240679,
-0.0361808687,
-0.026901586,
-0.0506744459,
0.0111468444,
-0.0306629073,
0.0509168878,
-0.0461220518,
0.0575084202,
0.0156546552,
0.01629683,
0.0041553453,
-0.022311464,
-0.0267837327,
-0.0525542386,
0.0519173853,
-0.0000842543,
-0.0396455936,
0.0096402457,
-0.0088848844,
-0.0166566242,
-0.0146648027,
0.0503460728,
0.0681127906,
-0.0135654137,
0.0075786496,
0.0000020341,
-0.0323826373,
-0.0002451757,
-0.040758986,
-0.0222724751,
0.018415451,
0.0563994907,
0.0453667901,
-0.0011350709,
0.0038430158,
-0.0420351289,
-0.06303069,
0.0509375669,
0.018279748,
-0.0298575256,
0.0592275523,
0.0022535278,
-0.0228260029,
0.0487043969,
-0.0068447837,
0.064149797,
0.0026850819,
0.0214785226,
-0.027946014,
-0.0047244276,
0.0050422749,
-0.0313745476,
-0.0055473517,
0.0131300623,
0.0324909054,
0.0180674847,
0.0219215006,
0.0177264251,
0.0334644504,
-0.0363484696,
-0.0149671352,
-0.0469749868,
-0.0226734802,
-0.0136162983,
-0.0444780029,
0.0437063202,
0.0686590448,
-0.0508863293,
0.047304742,
-0.0021548991,
0.0307066981,
0.0811636597,
-0.0996200368,
0.0226932317,
-0.0142817767,
0.0184605122,
0.1083300188,
0.0093527408,
-0.0476070531,
-0.0321800634,
0.0419289432,
-0.0104533006,
-0.0435551554,
-0.0242238455,
-0.0307075195,
0.0110906558,
0.0380393006,
0.0055023734,
-0.0376600213,
-0.0135701979,
-0.0812406316,
0.0829336718,
0.0250439215,
-0.0229172856,
-0.0169101954,
0.0086697666,
-0.0094520757,
0.0294982493,
0.0577274635,
-0.0271677803,
0.0617217124,
-0.0645109415,
-0.0454463065,
-0.0206827261,
0.0262749437,
0.0235308893,
0.003006876,
-0.0245388635,
-0.0242663343,
-0.0078163156,
-0.0649408773,
-0.0060807709,
-0.0389223434,
-0.0640206933,
0.0122251371,
-0.0677463412,
0.0445137806,
-0.0184372589,
0.0862374604,
0.0113857388,
-0.0247226823,
-0.0043408982,
-0.0245228857,
-0.0116247442,
-0.032217484,
0.0061603659,
0.0060393186,
-0.0191671699,
-0.0257087741,
-0.0454285517,
-0.0094566522,
-0.0401885882,
0.0099947732,
0.049254071,
-0.0523402058,
-0.0350108258,
0.0098510431,
0.0060013719,
-0.060832981,
0.003034811,
0.0283263642,
-0.0514279343,
0.0306042172,
0.0543288291,
0.0004238481,
-0.022315219,
-0.0316721909,
-0.0071343072,
0.0482463427,
0.0425775051,
-0.0455085337,
0.0124591729,
-0.0315587223,
-0.0368143097,
0.0096312305,
-0.0210810527,
-0.0158618912,
-0.0448160097,
-0.0288524404,
0.085825257,
-0.0125264209,
0.0030343351,
-0.0173879266,
-0.0116663249,
0.0572936311,
0.041103702,
-0.0106209423,
-0.0174066126,
-0.0260661021,
0.041616112,
-0.0292697009,
0.0168739706,
0.0198724344,
-0.0557878204,
-0.0120720789,
-0.0968347192,
-0.0007503443,
-0.0142118232,
0.0050239423,
0.0141003868,
-0.0619111098,
-0.0187286418,
-0.0017082003,
-0.0067751813,
0.0041747699,
0.0464186184,
0.0008718196,
0.0132804597,
0.0362497792,
0.0669399127,
-0.0491995029,
0.0185978319,
-0.0049084891,
0.0064878576,
0.0207849536,
-0.0034699785,
-0.0378632061,
-0.0197620802,
0.0030149494,
-0.0041698311,
0.0470635928,
0.0242999904,
0.0279634781,
-0.0057315966,
-0.0151766706,
-0.009092059,
-0.072188668,
0.022622982,
-0.0358778723,
-0.0541497134,
0.0011160235,
-0.0279726703,
-0.0578935258,
-0.0458113998,
0.0510217734,
-0.0305718519,
0.0072777183,
-0.010435665,
-0.0145559581,
0.0214480329,
-0.0139328791,
0.0065836199,
0.045665212,
0.0141649125,
-0.0107897865,
0.0196144748,
-0.0141220083,
-0.0203618277,
-0.0572900884,
0.0441728942,
-0.0399468504,
-0.0299501587,
-0.0093588904,
-0.0109536387,
-0.0435811169,
-0.0052648811,
0.0046508238,
0.0444054864,
0.0029168371,
0.0545306578,
-0.0277403295,
0.0217264127,
-0.0508891009,
0.0577855445,
-0.0066210241,
0.0284000803,
-0.0176638551,
-0.017505819,
0.0057980926,
0.0012776419,
-0.0425081402,
-0.0295541231,
0.0001262839,
-0.0161220916,
0.0381809436,
0.0217796918,
-0.0451327898,
0.0022023667,
-0.05349309,
0.0117599303,
0.0084635541,
0.0114994971,
0.0286786519,
-0.0411314182,
-0.0234642085,
0.0260064825,
-0.0101124309,
0.0014566067,
-0.0318183824,
0.0260942746,
0.0473986194,
-0.0206257422,
-0.0092910612,
-0.0343785509,
-0.0449861921,
-0.0653291717,
-0.0079225488,
0.0277431682,
-0.0109217064,
-0.0017474034,
0.0430751219,
0.0141111761,
-0.0267194416,
0.0459927246,
-0.0420487262,
0.0204599127,
0.0086144358,
0.0884815976,
0.0871479735,
-0.0062352829,
0.0208136067,
0.0723970607,
0.0030567732,
-0.0181793533,
-0.013533433,
-0.0497473776,
-0.0259857513,
-0.0474899001,
-0.0540595129,
-0.0188006684,
0.0729517266,
0.031272158,
-0.0328346789,
-0.0349874981,
0.0368705429,
-0.067382127,
0.0158247892,
-0.0150403455,
0.0175377894,
-0.0324189551,
0.04259599,
-0.0234501585,
-0.0207938459,
0.0418893062,
0.021990981,
0.0073966514,
-0.0858857483,
0.0243971962,
0.0180161167,
0.0071445294,
0.0230882019,
-0.0011797115,
0.0295663681,
-0.0098238606,
-0.0718814507,
0.0345607661,
0.0275970325,
0.0206118617,
-0.0099882707,
-0.0608331002,
-0.0219314899,
0.0223972164,
-0.024014933,
-0.0183378849,
-0.0533264279,
-0.0136262067,
0.0192203,
0.0200763922,
0.0106137553,
0.0155321602,
-0.0022579606,
0.0084990207,
-0.0083045084,
-0.0313156322,
0.0032928153,
-0.0229137465,
-0.0373557173,
0.0297506601,
0.0088306963,
-0.0342192203,
-0.0336336829,
-0.0290628895,
0.0197371393,
0.0451359488,
0.0294313319,
0.0081570363,
0.0525488444,
0.0390228443,
-0.0177096967,
-0.0859747306,
0.0510203987,
0.0308757611,
-0.0458711162,
-0.035748519,
0.0846907049,
0.0361503623,
-0.0568415709,
0.0235774834,
-0.0116845174,
-0.0052927374,
-0.0090781823,
-0.0062455777,
-0.0416509844,
-0.0270214267,
0.0147165954,
-0.0443785377,
-0.0069674496,
-0.0089243175,
0.0274710413,
-0.133525461,
0.012002619,
0.004065684,
-0.0383791588,
0.0257749036,
-0.0407851152,
0.0125734983,
0.0404355563,
0.0418362543,
-0.0127647715,
-0.0116243465,
0.0386423543,
0.0329591446,
-0.0002396827,
-0.0684390813,
-0.0084528942,
0.0024166936,
0.0372768976,
0.0196683854,
-0.0236876886,
-0.0571386851,
-0.0658033341,
0.0440041572,
0.0534969196,
-0.0202452317,
0.0031119031,
0.0114305336,
-0.0148870982,
0.0048399954,
0.002595356,
0.0328449793,
-0.0358833708,
-0.020745689,
0.008454226,
0.0995466933,
0.0020217262,
0.0176884308,
0.0112626161,
0.0299694855,
0.0282472949,
0.0696519464,
0.0369639471,
-0.0523738973,
0.0266705174,
-0.044924207,
-0.0246533789,
0.022736337,
-0.0189303085,
0.0897090808,
-0.0491443798,
0.0168940481,
-0.0665079281,
-0.0471344888,
0.0237576235,
-0.0124680456,
0.0286295358,
0.0485605635,
0.0443418361,
-0.013990107,
-0.027526008,
0.0529958718,
0.0269157868,
0.0017165249,
-0.0929113925,
-0.0558595434,
-0.0065135416,
0.0159506984,
-0.0323994644,
-0.045075018,
-0.0341076627,
-0.0473372452,
0.0503585339,
0.0671370849,
0.00657277,
-0.0555512458,
0.0293707084,
-0.0097929901,
-0.0177636072,
-0.0198019408,
0.0299758501,
0.0069513973,
0.0293729678,
-0.0404124483,
0.0189363733,
-0.003983127,
-0.005171767,
0.0061823209,
0.0630215108,
0.041019056,
0.0241687428,
-0.0439256914,
0.064881593,
0.0221363511,
0.1050096825,
-0.0266611502,
-0.0461094752,
-0.0484949201,
-0.0150785921,
-0.0700188726,
-0.0058635413,
-0.0056110793,
-0.0242657661,
0.0524817519,
0.0406229608,
0.0151901795,
0.0011321976,
-0.0327711813,
0.0080971401,
0.0153195029,
-0.0003777456,
0.014207053,
0.0117171593,
-0.0030949221,
0.0413367935,
-0.0003868818,
-0.0216073524,
0.0185042135,
0.0286372341,
0.0337201171,
0.0451279208,
0.0451426022,
-0.0038064455,
-0.0338325053,
-0.0234708469,
-0.0592760853,
-0.0275280625,
0.0126208123,
-0.0206335876,
0.0319751166,
-0.055368755,
0.034737207,
-0.0527476706,
0.0111401258,
-0.0338529386,
0.003582326,
0.0495254472,
-0.0163426492,
0.0399881415,
-0.0246990137,
-0.014350187,
-0.0674950108,
0.0894433334,
0.0078898631,
0.0149412882,
0.0033885138,
-0.0039751399,
-0.0081644943,
0.0037629213,
0.0560020804,
0.0442092456,
-0.0108194435,
0.0294186473,
-0.0390859358,
-0.0308783427,
-0.0551812053,
0.0057036681,
0.0061782529,
-0.0229483619,
0.0093162777,
0.0513685085,
-0.0326747,
-0.0174840689,
-0.0533931553,
0.0402924232,
0.0021771479,
0.0019366882,
-0.0241174418,
-6.848035563e-33,
-0.0396311879,
0.0109826634,
-0.0086191576,
-0.0212616306,
0.0379634351,
-0.0441723801,
0.0020125466,
0.0619765632,
-0.016232362,
0.0327634141,
-0.0013942587,
0.0167324189,
0.0200864449,
0.0497337244,
0.0933527723,
0.0156016704,
-0.0087292856,
-0.0126625327,
-0.0143518066,
-0.0540776327,
0.0464629605,
0.0097242687,
0.1009188667,
0.0487479419,
0.0771125779,
0.0133501664,
0.0315312482,
0.0011231675,
-0.0535936989,
0.0302893892,
0.0170365199,
0.0440250523,
0.0330063924,
-0.0174109824,
-0.0149673922,
-0.0252694115,
-0.0376928076,
-0.0732411295,
0.0366692878,
0.0101075051,
-0.0039266679,
-0.04332719,
0.0139621422,
0.0162906423,
0.014290737,
-0.0055783992,
0.0458440334,
-0.0146430433,
0.0050737886,
0.049322255,
-0.0347795673,
-0.0266931821,
0.0047493153,
0.0016357815,
-0.0165371038,
0.0065509691,
-0.0391794853,
-0.0295034256,
-0.0322105587,
0.0126487911,
0.017245885,
0.0695784092,
0.0374878012,
0.0293491483,
0.0480321981,
0.0218955819,
0.0615137145,
0.0228618365,
0.0303155072,
0.0359646082,
0.0773993134,
0.0097605027,
0.0148824221,
0.0024735844,
0.0791227594,
0.0152275385,
-0.0775509477,
-0.0004375344,
0.0801059231,
0.0028114435,
-0.0027185266,
0.0117825344,
-0.0208341964,
-0.0590453856,
-0.0066409712,
-0.0305347685,
-0.0028780696,
-0.0416025147,
0.0226456262,
-0.0436367691,
-0.0051835962,
-0.0311619416,
0.0281535853,
-0.0093029793,
-0.037276201,
-0.028458422,
-0.0297429152,
0.0185733046,
0.0059117349,
0.0553975441,
-0.0611258298,
-0.0380775928,
-0.0150141027,
-0.0032022838,
0.0104747722,
0.0709302127,
0.0517356321,
-0.0179337934,
-0.0263930764,
-0.0142833013,
-0.0252387319,
-0.0416980498,
0.0337532908,
0.0229165033,
0.0349040665,
0.0085266717,
0.0082887737,
0.0255796835,
0.0373567492,
0.0136915203,
-0.0390793942,
-0.0313461609,
-0.0578374006,
0.0277353283,
0.0259075873,
-0.0044969702,
-0.0398589112,
0.037926428,
0.03648654,
-0.0410508998,
-0.0291614756,
-0.0249533132,
2.72e-7,
0.0897515267,
0.0362437628,
-0.0255279485,
0.043896798,
-0.0108200433,
-0.0101815742,
-0.0341822766,
-0.0071012764,
0.0291873533,
0.0709673911,
0.0168300476,
0.0028769467,
0.0515566319,
-0.0026144835,
-0.0375373289,
-0.0552607514,
-0.027799394,
0.0309682917,
-0.0389071852,
0.0272060744,
0.0194452181,
0.0302919708,
-0.0195111949,
0.0110810008,
-0.0333582647,
-0.0117294025,
0.019693017,
-0.0498025268,
-0.0259840898,
0.0263916925,
0.0298889279,
0.0079561537,
0.0253013093,
0.0854740143,
-0.0281083789,
0.0126034934,
0.0165924132,
0.0143550579,
-0.011795843,
0.0128372358,
-0.0084855314,
-0.0011758889,
-0.0014330893,
-0.0443559363,
0.031669382,
-0.0575309359,
-0.0378167666,
0.0315104239,
-0.0268534459,
0.0097076269,
0.0373094082,
-0.0099948701,
-0.0401247777,
-0.022485584,
0.0308128688,
0.0079922928,
0.0029028058,
-0.0118403919,
-0.0458557419,
0.0918690935,
0.0014184786,
-0.0397210382,
0.0119258203,
-0.0560409874,
-0.0080205109,
-0.0193394516,
-0.0141216815,
2.285853228e-34,
0.0229848251,
0.0005301465,
0.0617034473,
-0.0148209548,
0.0268692411,
-0.0352912098,
0.0315287933,
0.0367400199,
0.0183213335,
-0.0771116242,
-0.0164475776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08148v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08148v1 | Empirical Investigation of Neural Symbolic Reasoning Strategies | 2023-02-16T08:49:47 | 2023-02-16T08:49:47 | Yoichi Aoki, Keito Kudo, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Ana Brassard, Masashi Yoshikawa, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Neural reasoning accuracy improves when generating intermediate reasoning
steps. However, the source of this improvement is yet unclear. Here, we
investigate and factorize the benefit of generating intermediate steps for
symbolic reasoning. Specifically, we decompose the reasoning strategy w.r.t.
step granularity and chaining strategy. With a purely symbolic numerical
reasoning dataset (e.g., A=1, B=3, C=A+3, C?), we found that the choice of
reasoning strategies significantly affects the performance, with the gap
becoming even larger as the extrapolation length becomes longer. Surprisingly,
we also found that certain configurations lead to nearly perfect performance,
even in the case of length extrapolation. Our results indicate the importance
of further exploring effective strategies for neural reasoning models. | [
0.0166062247,
0.0478985682,
-0.0167600028,
-0.003765658,
-0.0560718328,
0.017912969,
0.0240333322,
0.0101747615,
-0.0296560898,
0.0284728743,
0.0594586767,
-0.0090986146,
0.021296123,
0.0124567878,
0.0203923862,
-0.0217194334,
0.0181009918,
-0.0598124117,
0.0323418267,
-0.0163288992,
-0.0502248369,
-0.0151218446,
-0.0297361445,
-0.0029779735,
-0.0321836546,
-0.0154427281,
-0.012401171,
-0.0371568203,
0.0407770239,
-0.0268196221,
-0.0251297466,
0.0234917738,
0.0384216495,
0.0464225411,
0.0000021094,
-0.0314876288,
0.0348062329,
0.0009005727,
-0.0541241094,
-0.0039699543,
-0.047194615,
-0.0113103511,
0.049286671,
0.029384369,
-0.0308301747,
-0.0022074517,
0.0357387178,
0.0227749273,
0.0330214947,
0.0440872163,
0.0036064519,
-0.0422040932,
0.0116773155,
-0.0065133716,
0.0211975891,
0.0052623097,
-0.009023251,
0.022882998,
0.0289324336,
0.0104031693,
0.0224605836,
0.0025381704,
0.1039207354,
0.0414412692,
-0.0611167103,
0.0500622541,
0.0274327118,
0.0125055471,
0.000631888,
0.0401571877,
-0.0289576612,
-0.0305146966,
-0.0286007095,
-0.0171390753,
0.030223757,
-0.0170430578,
-0.0408002436,
0.0137414485,
-0.0408632495,
-0.0064654909,
0.0082768332,
0.0057866648,
0.0338708907,
-0.0234236848,
-0.032188911,
0.0798013359,
-0.0366423987,
-0.0257935058,
0.0325510167,
-0.0338475779,
-0.0394594073,
-0.0333177894,
0.0323986746,
0.0724312887,
0.0205996297,
0.0111025246,
0.0233650096,
0.0198850259,
-0.0146808494,
-0.0335263982,
0.0475923456,
0.1014625505,
0.0417168364,
0.0030724872,
-0.0956341624,
0.0383470841,
-0.0292874556,
0.0809548646,
-0.0133258309,
0.0288714413,
-0.0094309142,
-0.0272155609,
-0.0323238783,
0.0586811863,
-0.0104944129,
-0.0126883695,
-0.0422591679,
-0.0023158598,
-0.0150766335,
0.0165453441,
0.0185938329,
0.0075685587,
0.0651561394,
-0.0045051016,
-0.0463291407,
-0.034613587,
-0.1122779027,
0.0209474526,
0.0386038572,
0.0133368168,
-0.0163134616,
-0.0716233775,
-0.0029240311,
-0.0124289487,
0.0472311378,
0.0873105749,
0.0050135627,
0.00103889,
-0.0416279361,
-0.0284469686,
0.0579342321,
-0.0951338112,
0.0641063005,
-0.0769129694,
0.0655036047,
-0.0070715984,
-0.0384684913,
-0.0184660926,
0.0169383474,
0.0232168399,
-0.0105329566,
0.0583583638,
0.0106981844,
-0.0051350784,
0.0077358559,
0.0239005182,
-0.0242456999,
0.033037331,
0.0539249331,
0.0262522995,
-0.0216780473,
0.0020652215,
0.0020320397,
0.0029740455,
0.0267195571,
-0.0600483455,
-0.0300737657,
-0.0213425271,
-0.016088102,
0.0628994852,
-0.0288471896,
0.018636765,
-0.0660101473,
-0.0592697375,
-0.015957851,
0.0558468141,
0.0194343347,
0.0024092656,
0.1012816727,
-0.0694468245,
0.0413015373,
0.0030251041,
-0.0918802172,
0.0636791661,
-0.0050965794,
0.0072456682,
-0.0324108005,
0.0201883949,
-0.0232242439,
-0.0756935552,
-0.0042248643,
0.0272148531,
0.0435537435,
-0.0117853079,
0.0112444237,
-0.0152844684,
-0.0341935158,
0.0303017665,
0.0421402492,
-0.0106091909,
-0.0267656464,
-0.0239701718,
0.0048436937,
0.0357865207,
0.0152482083,
-0.0152605334,
-0.0265598036,
-0.0080252467,
-0.0004968785,
-0.0234744512,
-0.0099406159,
0.018512534,
0.0063768388,
-0.0380837992,
-0.0142477239,
-0.0266944561,
0.0062944381,
0.0302895252,
0.032416001,
0.0063989153,
0.0093650855,
-0.0093643405,
0.0302253906,
0.0261416472,
-0.0216979459,
-0.018808715,
-0.0010805245,
0.0259050764,
0.0032750848,
-0.0141075477,
0.03491164,
0.0188398659,
0.0117201833,
-0.0339999162,
-0.0425047427,
-0.0152998278,
-0.091594696,
-0.0529443882,
0.0442562476,
-0.0138339903,
0.0011353717,
0.0104427477,
-0.0556093641,
-0.0046759308,
0.0529161282,
-0.0351728424,
-0.0181527343,
0.0033487666,
0.0100335469,
0.0235505737,
-0.0219041947,
0.0037581972,
0.0651573092,
-0.04153651,
0.0237455908,
-0.0070928866,
0.0301583689,
0.0049782405,
-0.0031795572,
0.0499391295,
0.0334194638,
-0.0154708596,
-0.01415262,
-0.0435820781,
-0.0179724917,
-0.0307104196,
0.0133205326,
-0.0195814166,
-0.0035214322,
0.0117591554,
0.0124154808,
0.0029519801,
-0.0252981484,
0.0126264738,
0.0020833635,
-0.033407189,
0.0451536737,
-0.0150083788,
0.0114870332,
0.019991152,
-0.0000654495,
-0.0551447757,
-0.0077155372,
-0.0472757258,
-0.0585859008,
0.0769585818,
0.0478529334,
0.014438713,
-0.020692179,
-0.0175850168,
-0.0370715335,
-0.0115753878,
-0.0280021355,
-0.0210869312,
0.0309567321,
-0.032422103,
-0.0620648488,
0.0471731499,
-0.0141759124,
-0.01026983,
0.0171266403,
0.0054288981,
-0.0415323749,
0.0218707696,
-0.0482218601,
0.0272422582,
-0.0003649127,
-0.0142199183,
-0.0678016618,
0.0495992079,
-0.0159415118,
-0.0046728398,
-0.0450207777,
0.0346691385,
0.0313136615,
-0.0012745347,
-0.0276283156,
-0.0066330768,
0.0018833316,
0.0506368615,
-0.0318438672,
-0.0162756313,
0.0784427747,
0.0217444953,
0.0343423709,
-0.0278500114,
0.0120201055,
-0.0199491009,
0.0880912319,
0.0232946854,
0.0137892794,
-0.0110317934,
-0.0279767178,
-0.0370447114,
-0.0173845142,
-0.0029977236,
0.0077361898,
0.0405433811,
-0.0394838564,
-0.0052428539,
0.0061890902,
-0.0263574403,
-0.031474255,
0.0043874634,
-0.01911336,
0.0422431901,
-0.0460834876,
-0.0102986023,
0.028262293,
-0.0173839107,
0.0085234633,
0.070903115,
-0.0184335429,
-0.0345942713,
-0.0259873644,
-0.0298495684,
-0.0370998606,
0.0270976182,
0.082878679,
-0.0257640108,
0.0231375303,
0.0158864856,
0.0559502952,
-0.008503424,
-0.0492553748,
0.0309593063,
-0.0285288412,
-0.0457934439,
0.0066263415,
0.0395889543,
-0.0217189826,
-0.0815521926,
-0.0168703515,
0.0583578497,
0.0276086256,
0.0137132015,
0.0295545328,
-0.0383046456,
0.0075629032,
0.0259072855,
0.0376107991,
-0.0778981075,
-0.0136954961,
0.0352109484,
-0.0288922396,
-0.0220194217,
-0.0383366048,
0.0094670346,
-0.0815371946,
0.0069965278,
0.0081539908,
-0.054900907,
-0.0191390757,
-0.0265960675,
-0.004325361,
0.0426684953,
-0.0189043842,
0.0366009809,
-0.0046489956,
0.0101087512,
0.0027927617,
-0.0026191282,
-0.0017886821,
0.034707021,
-0.0273015145,
-0.0201422293,
-0.0184435509,
0.0091240695,
0.0175265931,
-0.0560120717,
0.0645909905,
0.0194053352,
0.0350868404,
-0.0336211398,
0.0455136746,
0.0523739904,
-0.0072566131,
-0.0111004049,
0.0375746675,
-0.024690045,
-0.0238644388,
-0.0099355765,
0.0673354864,
-0.0191418566,
-0.0152154844,
0.0088988785,
0.0305114221,
-0.0702074617,
0.0106449639,
0.0306956246,
-0.0219584797,
-0.0668422654,
-0.0235805586,
-0.0311123412,
-0.0278951824,
-0.0196384937,
0.0111664468,
0.0457304232,
0.0000399254,
-0.0258724298,
-0.0628749803,
0.02698173,
0.0662295669,
-0.0068897521,
-0.0158456825,
-0.016055394,
-0.021692941,
-0.0475924686,
0.006668542,
0.0009888067,
0.0425882749,
0.021909181,
0.0550523885,
-0.0322959088,
-0.0246532802,
-0.0318232812,
-0.0071071135,
-0.0822163597,
-0.0294278581,
-0.0210021939,
0.039989166,
0.0243623592,
0.0373128243,
0.0069210185,
-0.0159663707,
0.0139695695,
0.0160584897,
0.0292846579,
0.0021593412,
0.0485692136,
0.0273629893,
0.007448657,
0.0105180414,
0.011545036,
-0.0030397696,
0.0313012265,
0.0469757803,
-0.0340103656,
0.0847710148,
0.0193908177,
-0.0023239884,
0.0081549818,
0.0398397371,
0.0059336373,
-0.0220184512,
0.0744113103,
-0.0280874204,
-0.0173761658,
-0.0098753907,
0.0142051699,
0.0093652569,
0.0364980288,
-0.0136697954,
-0.0895888954,
0.0660167634,
0.018480055,
0.0315154828,
-0.0087726163,
-0.0019064208,
0.0422337353,
0.0424228497,
-0.018770013,
-0.0297459457,
0.0085056592,
-0.0090292785,
0.0314215459,
-0.0311252549,
0.0561419204,
0.0348757394,
0.026635712,
-0.0830077752,
-0.0226541776,
-0.0452689677,
-0.0790272728,
0.0267067179,
-0.0427630506,
0.0225731749,
0.0316726193,
-0.0543274917,
-0.0294455066,
0.0077837594,
0.0313930735,
-0.0280865505,
-0.0081309406,
-0.0239615832,
0.0260448772,
0.0477782525,
0.0282658506,
-0.081979081,
0.0115584088,
-0.0610538907,
0.0572237335,
-0.0281410702,
0.0259750839,
0.0085453698,
-0.0455641262,
-0.0590176471,
0.0108433599,
0.0216185451,
-0.009411131,
-0.0532880425,
-0.0804352686,
-0.0331391692,
0.0555698015,
0.0059917974,
0.0271644853,
0.0224919524,
0.0074256468,
-0.0052825278,
-0.0387808159,
0.0117644509,
-0.0215605963,
0.0138272243,
-0.0224124324,
-0.0341436863,
-5.703272308e-33,
-0.0081124501,
0.0020473886,
0.0598692037,
-0.0097698439,
0.0017484684,
-0.0268433504,
-0.042627912,
-0.000850602,
-0.0146859884,
0.0244654827,
-0.0153909205,
0.0175131932,
0.004471404,
-0.0150996875,
0.0324791744,
-0.0341508389,
-0.0246953387,
0.0019827092,
-0.0228745956,
-0.025127409,
0.0558651872,
0.006445704,
0.035936024,
-0.0645777509,
-0.0081738504,
0.0404775664,
-0.0063153622,
0.0118089244,
-0.0853974521,
0.0494905859,
0.0324528292,
-0.0393061377,
0.0290059615,
-0.0038559649,
0.0150180254,
-0.0193615742,
-0.0724067315,
-0.062506482,
0.0264955927,
0.0014387209,
-0.0555122644,
-0.053617321,
0.028006345,
-0.0184350703,
-0.011234873,
-0.034661971,
-0.0064061205,
-0.0186054111,
0.0182104874,
-0.0251708273,
-0.032109566,
-0.010084766,
-0.0038439527,
0.0242988225,
-0.0418007672,
0.0248719752,
-0.0360554308,
-0.0271577686,
-0.0373477973,
-0.0190330353,
0.0318907611,
-0.0303102806,
0.0055385195,
0.0183924176,
0.0367366634,
0.0391861498,
0.0724550709,
-0.0452543236,
-0.0532398112,
0.0301540606,
0.0051210131,
0.028980514,
0.1065497249,
-0.0320331715,
0.1182552725,
0.0106215533,
-0.0758502483,
-0.0330500603,
0.0096513079,
0.0558860935,
0.0243668575,
-0.0270485766,
-0.0198545102,
-0.0079416027,
-0.053395208,
-0.0072497935,
-0.0673860312,
-0.0701248273,
0.042423673,
0.005242845,
0.0317628048,
0.0013671293,
-0.0018278294,
-0.0211821757,
0.0113904728,
0.052222237,
0.0161384456,
0.0249294136,
0.0268552098,
0.0156264119,
-0.0274930298,
0.0043421597,
-0.0262254626,
-0.0251216833,
0.0301631819,
-0.0007188237,
0.0338652171,
0.022611523,
-0.0222607087,
-0.0180694442,
-0.0568110794,
-0.0058458424,
0.0529835187,
-0.0340150744,
0.0758008063,
0.0125753097,
-0.0187690761,
0.0129309483,
-0.0098834774,
-0.0056064408,
-0.0211350992,
0.090047732,
-0.0270648282,
0.0782062188,
0.0179666877,
-0.0236792658,
-0.0287583042,
-0.0254056901,
0.0120073631,
-0.0947466418,
-0.0072871246,
0.0614102632,
2.826e-7,
-0.0121784005,
0.0240128767,
0.0213140305,
0.0439106226,
0.0325025581,
-0.0049128719,
-0.0065024523,
-0.0683045462,
0.0204612408,
-0.0648907498,
-0.019606987,
0.0650084838,
0.0019115501,
0.0503120534,
-0.010050958,
-0.004045553,
-0.0096468581,
-0.0387156457,
0.0013633836,
0.0331352539,
0.0377478674,
0.0457392372,
0.0392380469,
-0.0144022051,
0.0128564844,
-0.0389623232,
0.0272025894,
0.0167901646,
0.0456025898,
0.002592748,
-0.0135739911,
-0.0415969044,
0.0247720852,
0.0343858264,
0.0214083567,
0.0312230196,
-0.0014414361,
0.0319215059,
0.022328591,
-0.0040307129,
-0.0222272612,
-0.0544695705,
-0.0058139232,
-0.0228529479,
0.0713117346,
-0.1054972559,
-0.0247567408,
0.0430483073,
0.0170564819,
-0.0212627091,
0.0257740375,
0.013289989,
0.0383834243,
0.0196722858,
0.0027152908,
-0.0212599933,
0.025725171,
-0.1091692001,
-0.0293860286,
0.0494089313,
-0.0270141456,
0.0138163166,
-0.0315990672,
0.0150142042,
0.0588351525,
-0.0133732827,
-0.0434252098,
2.311899841e-34,
0.009951314,
-0.0512073375,
0.0431457683,
0.0177484322,
0.0262156613,
-0.010772272,
-0.0344862081,
0.0119593274,
0.0420618095,
-0.0429055244,
-0.035305474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08146v1 | CluCDD:Contrastive Dialogue Disentanglement via Clustering | 2023-02-16T08:47:51 | 2023-02-16T08:47:51 | Jingsheng Gao, Zeyu Li, Suncheng Xiang, Ting Liu, Yuzhuo Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL | A huge number of multi-participant dialogues happen online every day, which
leads to difficulty in understanding the nature of dialogue dynamics for both
humans and machines. Dialogue disentanglement aims at separating an entangled
dialogue into detached sessions, thus increasing the readability of long
disordered dialogue. Previous studies mainly focus on message-pair
classification and clustering in two-step methods, which cannot guarantee the
whole clustering performance in a dialogue. To address this challenge, we
propose a simple yet effective model named CluCDD, which aggregates utterances
by contrastive learning. More specifically, our model pulls utterances in the
same session together and pushes away utterances in different ones. Then a
clustering method is adopted to generate predicted clustering labels.
Comprehensive experiments conducted on the Movie Dialogue dataset and IRC
dataset demonstrate that our model achieves a new state-of-the-art result. | [
0.0109792333,
0.0460971035,
-0.0215874612,
0.0712130666,
-0.0248751249,
0.0251951981,
0.0138934739,
0.0085652582,
0.0653425679,
-0.0157766994,
-0.0089071896,
-0.0504218861,
0.012043843,
0.0630937666,
0.0042043705,
-0.0908976793,
0.0336460024,
-0.0131986365,
0.0132921143,
0.0012674327,
0.0217638984,
0.0029801573,
-0.0386723354,
0.0028920169,
0.0106923003,
-0.0329051875,
-0.0204488505,
0.0082484679,
0.0386390574,
0.0131720509,
0.007265382,
0.0477489792,
0.0319895595,
0.0222482961,
0.0000017721,
-0.0333016627,
-0.0164877381,
-0.0444128178,
-0.0046254885,
0.0167792514,
0.0107382564,
-0.0086467741,
0.0074155317,
0.01544399,
-0.0352467597,
-0.0049761292,
0.042645596,
0.0706332475,
0.0687351376,
0.0668318421,
-0.0401027687,
-0.0526650548,
0.0440680645,
-0.0070567289,
-0.0381827988,
0.0002251019,
-0.0028441336,
0.0263107382,
-0.039257478,
0.006249371,
-0.0301294923,
0.0128002679,
0.0290085431,
-0.0210688226,
-0.0058282865,
0.0331547372,
-0.0209607463,
-0.0224420279,
-0.0094452696,
0.1122274324,
0.0495196059,
0.0356240422,
0.01629024,
0.0181287006,
-0.0179131031,
-0.0134258131,
-0.043377813,
-0.0385770537,
0.0100318566,
0.0211448073,
-0.0035590036,
0.0702817515,
0.0021274274,
0.0146145346,
-0.0124570439,
-0.0294695403,
-0.0132836467,
-0.0176196806,
-0.0501560755,
-0.0059527839,
-0.0072961864,
-0.0121210702,
0.0115687493,
-0.0103296656,
-0.0111916056,
-0.0071062804,
-0.0174032841,
-0.0093824686,
-0.0245349146,
-0.0016856205,
-0.0291728321,
0.0113922879,
-0.0138491597,
0.0780657977,
0.0147464555,
0.0144636687,
-0.0126216756,
0.00658452,
-0.0136884348,
-0.0026556267,
-0.0673074871,
0.0124943359,
-0.008663333,
0.046358645,
-0.0787521228,
-0.0515313372,
-0.0003592608,
0.0169073287,
-0.009550753,
-0.0058733579,
-0.0149723832,
0.0143076731,
0.0005788782,
-0.0104312496,
-0.0041493746,
0.0468440764,
-0.0489952862,
0.018322384,
0.0099890446,
-0.0531577021,
-0.014992726,
0.0458002575,
0.0038155187,
-0.0196916293,
-0.0556336418,
0.0649957135,
-0.0631565601,
-0.0419524908,
-0.0008763904,
-0.0053990362,
-0.065365918,
-0.0065872977,
-0.0249125566,
-0.0344217755,
0.0776598677,
-0.0129318424,
0.0066699674,
-0.0098599438,
-0.0047352067,
-0.0608561411,
-0.0281719007,
0.0798976272,
-0.0426828116,
-0.0073461113,
0.0410970002,
0.0288165789,
-0.0163610261,
0.0413305536,
0.0336707421,
0.01073456,
0.0473141074,
-0.01134835,
0.0303659532,
0.0060363691,
0.0009571499,
0.0177522432,
-0.0326207988,
0.0172454193,
0.0071792533,
-0.0261236373,
0.002361753,
0.0567489117,
-0.0826747194,
-0.027789427,
0.0641979277,
0.0548380837,
0.0007928819,
0.0173972864,
-0.067365773,
0.0728157461,
-0.0356246158,
0.0467184037,
0.0067650196,
0.0317138098,
0.0051247692,
0.0010909366,
0.1483407915,
-0.0197331961,
-0.0573893487,
-0.0560652502,
0.041034773,
-0.0030341379,
0.0735963732,
-0.0216601603,
0.0415855981,
0.0184279047,
-0.0501655564,
0.0254179724,
0.0449010208,
-0.0594298206,
-0.0021467141,
-0.0375456773,
-0.0028735322,
0.0734188855,
0.0317979008,
-0.0177322514,
-0.0383822881,
-0.0433045514,
0.018352259,
0.0522805713,
-0.0035709029,
-0.0228671823,
0.0912322775,
-0.0759675428,
-0.0072553516,
0.0088768788,
-0.0233487897,
0.0044148248,
-0.019008819,
-0.0424695276,
-0.0084347129,
0.0235844217,
0.0170452967,
-0.0065212375,
0.0155288111,
0.0044559077,
0.0285745487,
0.0181109682,
0.0642935634,
0.0291580092,
-0.0290863793,
-0.0457870364,
0.0285697691,
-0.0319424048,
-0.0124732973,
0.0021541065,
-0.045522891,
-0.1093300954,
0.018428199,
-0.0325326584,
-0.0171678569,
0.0151555277,
-0.0407405905,
-0.0697474629,
0.0404787026,
-0.0440860242,
0.0800006911,
-0.0243548453,
-0.0055720997,
0.0096310526,
0.0241758823,
0.0031734454,
0.0333236754,
-0.0366167501,
-0.0069360337,
-0.0244781356,
0.0402783304,
-0.0232153405,
-0.0373449586,
0.0075647342,
0.0007138143,
-0.0049725026,
0.0341040753,
0.0146246012,
-0.0312946029,
-0.0486536361,
-0.0500466861,
-0.068703115,
-0.0125114452,
-0.0062135989,
-0.0262796748,
0.0322645195,
-0.008147819,
-0.0043231281,
-0.0524556935,
-0.0234320611,
-0.0403906107,
0.0119590731,
0.011170187,
0.0244606137,
0.0200354643,
-0.0280887857,
-0.0324064307,
0.0068460745,
0.0190328211,
0.0371583179,
-0.0266686603,
-0.0344668292,
-0.0276662428,
0.0492495149,
-0.0147522343,
-0.0090570096,
-0.0438606665,
-0.0309649389,
-0.0001933658,
-0.0036979993,
0.0346165784,
0.0460646413,
0.0421110801,
0.0501740761,
0.0040954989,
-0.0436234884,
-0.0187548585,
0.0244427584,
-0.0276970193,
0.0271847676,
-0.0327566564,
-0.0157828536,
0.0033045327,
0.042983409,
0.0351175033,
0.0423089042,
-0.0507943854,
-0.0200498682,
0.0228348561,
-0.0148480879,
-0.0316779576,
-0.0151661895,
-0.0223398153,
0.0493690968,
-0.0513648577,
-0.0560024939,
0.0806011483,
-0.0024711948,
-0.0358630493,
-0.0437504575,
-0.0432767086,
-0.0049309884,
0.0578393452,
-0.0258994885,
0.0132613471,
-0.0223921742,
-0.0762924403,
-0.0307300761,
-0.0282862112,
-0.0006000745,
-0.010452183,
0.0654324889,
-0.0161622278,
-0.0085600484,
0.0266355593,
-0.0411099903,
-0.0272768866,
-0.0068359515,
-0.0055243974,
-0.0202434119,
0.0087634809,
-0.0231765471,
-0.0496203341,
0.0332881585,
0.0095608803,
0.0056326906,
-0.0101528242,
0.0011976614,
-0.0262995828,
0.0828363374,
0.0463065542,
-0.0026236423,
-0.0309738815,
-0.0706868693,
0.0755183846,
0.0657578707,
0.0058981953,
-0.0401392244,
-0.0152114881,
-0.0140146622,
-0.0033029886,
0.0193833821,
0.0051880558,
-0.0159031935,
0.0430804044,
-0.0014739874,
-0.0140373968,
0.1191142648,
0.015325183,
-0.0784253329,
-0.0373534299,
0.0205818694,
0.0296940152,
-0.0105111971,
-0.0159106124,
-0.0270701889,
-0.0332784764,
-0.0095237819,
0.0240426287,
0.0389351733,
-0.0115270996,
0.0032520099,
-0.0542605557,
0.0198178478,
0.048630368,
-0.0511074774,
-0.072025083,
-0.0510575399,
0.0133836921,
-0.0424687043,
0.0404994637,
0.0055747563,
0.0479708463,
-0.0323175415,
-0.00397874,
-0.029494537,
0.005501396,
0.0007457594,
0.0089164916,
0.0585193001,
0.0375190638,
0.0448898412,
0.0383707583,
-0.0173508935,
-0.0019850666,
-0.0679055527,
-0.039750725,
-0.0119982725,
0.0913850218,
-0.0009995232,
-0.0155723216,
-0.0405829772,
0.0390296206,
-0.029325882,
-0.0412597992,
-0.0001397788,
-0.0034889441,
-0.0123888934,
0.0100783464,
-0.002737107,
0.0494819768,
0.0144914454,
0.0574059524,
0.0101201609,
-0.0359549299,
-0.006421993,
-0.0262646694,
0.0430513546,
0.0119507844,
0.0305482093,
-0.073998332,
0.0103318132,
0.0437974595,
-0.0789510161,
-0.026685793,
-0.0021652856,
0.0233132336,
-0.0425899811,
0.0085339211,
0.0164877959,
-0.0095299818,
-0.0337226614,
0.0193624627,
-0.0003212888,
-0.0140052112,
-0.0548562296,
-0.0346603394,
0.0305602495,
-0.0166144632,
-0.0245502591,
0.0326745361,
-0.0350398757,
-0.0907815546,
-0.0272288211,
0.0083025591,
0.0177987311,
0.0831283629,
-0.0007576243,
-0.0027949861,
0.0237187464,
0.0152349425,
-0.0376266651,
-0.029071223,
0.0079752719,
0.0674493015,
-0.0040789763,
0.0145257236,
0.0035449613,
0.03011957,
-0.0125464574,
0.0092289085,
-0.1439710855,
-0.0857667178,
-0.0453724638,
-0.0356531255,
0.098259747,
0.0335829146,
0.002625715,
-0.0268600527,
0.0105286371,
-0.002940977,
0.0031822785,
-0.0157767162,
0.0111780232,
0.0083849318,
-0.0253580343,
0.0036396754,
0.0436295904,
-0.0123488409,
-0.0038102434,
0.0090336492,
-0.0285238437,
0.0416115858,
0.011708457,
0.0062027988,
0.0068114153,
0.0015050828,
0.0449627824,
0.0136878798,
0.0176882893,
0.0346004851,
0.0753431022,
0.0208366811,
-0.00039693,
-0.0001102911,
0.0474996492,
-0.0651669055,
-0.0111198509,
-0.0190872382,
0.0018868673,
-0.0071937311,
-0.0011503559,
0.0482694656,
0.0095047662,
0.0119376313,
-0.0272843502,
0.0840854272,
-0.0052395496,
-0.0091865771,
-0.0124864709,
0.042750217,
-0.0215727948,
0.0500227958,
0.0758476034,
-0.0602651611,
-0.022946028,
0.0434109643,
0.0133011024,
-0.0559985675,
-0.0038391396,
0.0150912004,
0.0577890724,
0.0073164441,
0.0522538647,
-0.0006253987,
-0.0365931913,
0.0224856623,
-0.0115944874,
0.0498740822,
0.0104887895,
0.0471580625,
0.016596999,
0.013130472,
-0.0132323047,
-0.0339519009,
-0.0186840836,
0.019397622,
-0.0146084521,
-0.0116547188,
-5.943488252e-33,
-0.0175792947,
-0.0381446183,
-0.0161218196,
0.024288198,
-0.0052043428,
0.0105913831,
-0.0294487048,
0.0012087966,
0.0042937533,
0.0162829868,
0.0310322139,
0.0663194135,
0.0101940511,
0.0558413044,
-0.0239195619,
-0.0250195023,
0.0464197658,
0.0152138034,
0.0149406269,
0.0556042381,
0.0584781095,
0.0120998621,
0.0033419933,
-0.0867228806,
-0.0039340481,
-0.0144048007,
-0.003736455,
0.0507292524,
0.0586149208,
0.0324513018,
-0.0493804552,
0.0159145389,
0.0095514907,
-0.0087896371,
-0.0315015614,
0.0367262326,
-0.0447955169,
-0.0096484646,
-0.0135389268,
-0.0141178071,
-0.0294989664,
-0.0055848658,
0.0240117628,
0.0165355615,
0.0328287445,
-0.0554236695,
0.018775478,
-0.0223260615,
-0.0207738541,
0.0311696585,
-0.0091985036,
0.0280982498,
-0.0684115887,
-0.0715782866,
0.0211691111,
0.0276746172,
0.0409108251,
-0.0182312243,
-0.0954679176,
0.0461444445,
0.0047006817,
-0.0068111219,
0.0115916198,
0.0349397473,
0.0156313926,
0.0852085724,
0.0256682578,
-0.0079292152,
-0.0260367412,
-0.0047154389,
-0.0323267132,
0.0461970232,
0.0119457701,
0.0413245223,
-0.0009048717,
-0.0204681009,
-0.0455563478,
0.0056674522,
0.001664444,
-0.0134799182,
0.0138985869,
0.047680147,
-0.047618527,
-0.0376023427,
0.0003952238,
-0.0272350498,
-0.0120790349,
-0.0233002082,
-0.0047559221,
-0.0042916676,
-0.0366971418,
-0.0629616454,
0.0344549902,
-0.0458481945,
0.0415582247,
0.0222502276,
-0.0270645451,
0.0115697933,
0.0117035024,
-0.0173246451,
-0.0311850514,
-0.0251122825,
0.065078415,
-0.0003221909,
-0.0134380069,
0.0060773301,
-0.0022696666,
-0.0440069363,
-0.0528027453,
0.0039930353,
0.0274095535,
0.0099868011,
-0.0291754324,
0.0177272242,
0.020153746,
0.0262835734,
-0.024603568,
0.08223553,
-0.0141293062,
0.0357140191,
-0.0267915763,
0.0016434815,
-0.0353172347,
0.0327446051,
-0.0068559735,
-0.0077197365,
-0.0171365831,
-0.0260249972,
0.0462485701,
-0.020570986,
-0.0228867978,
-0.0129182898,
2.507e-7,
-0.008607775,
0.0505046882,
0.035278704,
-0.0164530668,
0.0396366045,
0.0706932098,
0.0014100466,
0.0040600421,
0.0143306023,
-0.0498599224,
0.0201536361,
0.0576515757,
0.0694303662,
0.0205925573,
-0.0513021238,
0.0011109905,
-0.0858734846,
-0.0372956134,
-0.0230342839,
0.005520172,
0.0759061798,
0.0672885403,
0.0461633168,
0.0011232157,
0.0001534283,
-0.0340141244,
0.0284253564,
-0.0137456525,
-0.0356247611,
0.0123635111,
-0.0081293583,
-0.0107143847,
-0.0053299661,
0.030340137,
0.0195850581,
0.0099412147,
0.0104196863,
0.0493279509,
0.008931539,
-0.055262316,
-0.0170087628,
0.0666962788,
-0.0047193705,
-0.0023427359,
0.0456118546,
-0.0413244031,
-0.030814115,
-0.0006104892,
-0.0574762113,
0.0055525885,
0.0333316773,
0.0109775243,
-0.0454762764,
0.0452266149,
0.0002085633,
-0.0029862407,
0.0286261123,
-0.0894940868,
0.0157707334,
0.0165402088,
-0.0408584066,
-0.037370842,
0.0205456968,
-0.0193985049,
0.0192414485,
0.0103622442,
0.0238040611,
1.860055884e-34,
0.0273871738,
0.001009902,
-0.01040438,
0.0242061522,
0.0268872567,
-0.0596328303,
-0.0559125245,
-0.0409700647,
0.0380835086,
-0.067995809,
0.0169818625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08143v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08143v3 | Learning to Initialize: Can Meta Learning Improve Cross-task Generalization in Prompt Tuning? | 2023-02-16T08:37:22 | 2023-11-19T14:31:53 | Chengwei Qin, Qian Li, Ruochen Zhao, Shafiq Joty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt tuning (PT) which only tunes the embeddings of an additional sequence
of tokens per task, keeping the pre-trained language model (PLM) frozen, has
shown remarkable performance in few-shot learning. Despite this, PT has been
shown to rely heavily on good initialization of the prompt embeddings. In this
work, we study meta prompt tuning (MPT) to systematically explore how
meta-learning can help improve (if it can) cross-task generalization in PT
through learning to initialize the prompt embeddings from other relevant tasks.
We empirically analyze a representative set of meta learning algorithms in a
wide range of adaptation settings with different source/target task
configurations on a large set of few-shot tasks. With extensive experiments and
analysis, we demonstrate the effectiveness of MPT. We find the improvement to
be significant particularly on classification tasks. For other kinds of tasks
such as question answering, we observe that while MPT can outperform PT in most
cases, it does not always outperform multi-task learning. We further provide an
in-depth analysis from the perspective of task similarity. | [
0.0325791687,
-0.0310688633,
-0.0038559861,
-0.0177249033,
0.0106643429,
0.0187990274,
0.0268607065,
-0.0219006352,
-0.0776820481,
-0.0283034407,
-0.0673254803,
0.0276271123,
-0.0085982382,
0.0092422655,
0.0024300411,
-0.0534418076,
0.0837071463,
0.0033171254,
0.0151121542,
0.0084260525,
-0.0102019329,
-0.0208966043,
-0.0161147043,
0.0413131453,
0.0269929655,
-0.018521307,
-0.0066188136,
0.0097999731,
0.0242232084,
0.0048563364,
0.0070304936,
0.0738730356,
0.0143875191,
0.0360842608,
0.000001731,
-0.0556702912,
0.0226801913,
-0.0401420742,
-0.0455440544,
-0.0346922167,
0.018644318,
0.0171194375,
0.0199645516,
0.0413025282,
-0.0243531726,
-0.0805025175,
0.0380113088,
-0.0125159966,
0.0455256999,
0.0547384918,
0.0091645122,
0.0148843946,
-0.0295961015,
-0.0373433754,
0.0441964529,
-0.0236864015,
-0.0239929501,
-0.0630751774,
0.0091796154,
0.0176522303,
-0.0354041569,
0.0156687777,
0.0078485133,
0.024214616,
0.0031728128,
0.0478009321,
-0.032118611,
0.0101908008,
-0.0546896458,
0.0807998106,
-0.0245147888,
-0.0387294628,
-0.0284973569,
-0.0080477297,
0.0674001724,
0.0172461122,
-0.0364357308,
-0.0095931133,
-0.0063495818,
-0.0172735024,
-0.0393560603,
0.0007772451,
0.0101454007,
-0.015952602,
-0.0081754699,
0.0547576658,
0.0046142535,
-0.0458349809,
0.0216411278,
-0.020048283,
-0.039343968,
-0.0296632797,
-0.0183092318,
0.0327848941,
-0.0489141159,
0.0070539569,
-0.0563924164,
-0.0376893245,
0.0087480815,
0.0296764988,
0.069410786,
0.0517093837,
-0.0271176528,
0.0648162737,
-0.0270994138,
0.0291335117,
0.0121495379,
0.0380362719,
-0.0460721925,
0.0060656434,
-0.0827169344,
-0.0121730464,
-0.0657851845,
0.0333070643,
0.000124783,
0.0159371085,
-0.0378485471,
0.0650678575,
0.0447680242,
-0.0024679042,
0.0208821669,
-0.0165493451,
-0.0311555639,
-0.0276270024,
0.0025253096,
0.0389194116,
-0.0718182549,
0.0423831232,
0.0332013965,
-0.024356639,
-0.0286568571,
-0.0207539387,
0.0245534647,
-0.0403218009,
0.0062517826,
0.0297702756,
-0.001393864,
-0.0634920597,
0.0114543904,
0.0125759505,
-0.0057623205,
-0.0381810181,
0.0081322119,
0.0005911196,
0.0361656398,
-0.0296776537,
0.0076399688,
0.0256860517,
-0.0438993759,
0.0186068546,
-0.0043873992,
0.0829079524,
-0.0318543576,
0.005559633,
0.0127674397,
0.0084724724,
-0.0437692292,
0.0521173105,
0.0001849213,
0.0107675139,
0.0209672172,
-0.0168053769,
0.0156272184,
-0.0004210592,
0.0391252637,
-0.0164511651,
0.0363439098,
-0.001646092,
0.0671264678,
0.0209399574,
0.0211889371,
-0.0173846446,
-0.0414876305,
-0.0089838374,
0.0384753309,
0.0586511604,
-0.0120895598,
-0.038143035,
0.0722030029,
0.0079741068,
-0.0149802184,
0.0135035096,
-0.0680662096,
0.038181562,
-0.0266158022,
-0.0032289792,
0.0150198964,
0.0110114915,
-0.0750250444,
-0.0161429252,
0.0364707559,
-0.013530558,
-0.0836405009,
0.0012481106,
-0.0127169797,
0.0202738475,
-0.0243214741,
0.0013486255,
-0.0026317199,
-0.0360505916,
0.0172049701,
-0.036450211,
0.0094672302,
0.0381203257,
0.0068435143,
-0.0675717518,
-0.0476466678,
-0.0503869131,
0.0725510269,
0.0406800471,
0.0395014882,
-0.0338136815,
0.0471341647,
-0.0435254872,
-0.0197222568,
0.0015802913,
0.0018211465,
0.0295127369,
-0.0225222204,
0.0015087691,
0.0045118965,
-0.0611014105,
0.046151679,
0.0404549874,
-0.0398738459,
-0.0374064669,
0.0294087715,
0.0508098081,
0.0032793577,
-0.0086476123,
0.0002651145,
0.0012289658,
0.0114256311,
-0.0324810632,
0.0225016605,
0.0401858017,
-0.0546358563,
-0.0513569601,
0.0097164651,
-0.0290417038,
-0.0087596029,
0.0275577009,
-0.0542954132,
-0.0669336841,
-0.0292880964,
0.0187681206,
0.0343947373,
-0.0439263508,
0.0254991632,
-0.0324940048,
0.0207568873,
-0.0544379242,
0.021362979,
-0.0115478737,
0.0126780719,
0.0271886084,
-0.0240806658,
0.0144009907,
-0.0149418544,
-0.0290532857,
0.0070267213,
-0.012367866,
0.0115555786,
0.0297229718,
0.0083130887,
-0.0582106933,
-0.0280396212,
-0.1018568426,
0.0080336584,
-0.0266486369,
0.0167172197,
0.0570181273,
0.0305958092,
-0.0348441787,
-0.0491465293,
-0.0153891621,
0.0195926055,
-0.008729131,
0.0426979959,
0.0448535942,
0.0329861939,
0.0165332016,
-0.0304694418,
-0.022114262,
0.0001071862,
0.0383171365,
-0.0309530366,
0.0165149458,
-0.0295914095,
-0.0096328063,
0.0030739978,
-0.0047511435,
-0.0136126159,
-0.0077025513,
-0.0018929165,
-0.0215411782,
0.0423352867,
0.0684208348,
0.0174066462,
-0.0401171036,
0.0388341844,
0.0401762091,
-0.0696182847,
0.0180344284,
-0.0138368243,
-0.0213043839,
-0.0289008562,
0.0076838168,
0.0361320414,
0.0824686289,
-0.025275439,
0.00094348,
-0.0810466558,
0.0323101841,
-0.004482511,
-0.0546076037,
-0.059575662,
0.0283563398,
-0.0358019061,
0.0047596879,
-0.0462729223,
-0.0463596694,
0.0736650452,
0.0139002064,
-0.0041913781,
-0.0397853814,
0.0176131483,
-0.0130522484,
0.0152608948,
-0.0069089462,
0.0052337255,
0.0346478224,
-0.0384262949,
-0.0836465135,
-0.0400523953,
0.0292488486,
0.0047372226,
0.0083039999,
0.0135153672,
-0.0171430577,
-0.0322443582,
-0.0559643172,
-0.0402180701,
-0.0753835738,
-0.012086628,
0.000035668,
-0.061832536,
0.0282111261,
-0.0346537121,
-0.0295046624,
0.0119722625,
0.0422450341,
-0.0148829632,
-0.0161560364,
-0.034687601,
0.0199915878,
0.0375350602,
0.0283997487,
-0.030998677,
-0.0030320757,
0.0748516098,
-0.0103953518,
0.0603278726,
-0.0069571272,
-0.0153237591,
-0.008457968,
0.0338805206,
-0.0587581769,
-0.0214366131,
0.0479249023,
0.0326382481,
-0.0148915276,
-0.0039360886,
0.1149305776,
0.0406954288,
-0.0622160137,
-0.0346630886,
-0.0035749194,
0.0300615504,
0.0544394776,
0.0273489021,
-0.0362951346,
-0.0576570034,
0.0057593673,
0.0149418274,
0.0236353204,
-0.0184727386,
-0.0302427951,
-0.0963753834,
-0.0088917911,
-0.0276848972,
-0.0616066568,
-0.0167683158,
-0.0195250604,
0.0057446044,
-0.0044553461,
0.0382860713,
0.0118063791,
-0.0485817529,
0.012625129,
0.048799593,
0.0207987595,
-0.0548629835,
0.0116467476,
-0.0293909423,
0.0504074953,
0.0668208227,
-0.0066303997,
-0.019154273,
-0.0002877478,
0.0913553834,
0.0313155763,
0.0089555727,
-0.0108655524,
0.0652162358,
-0.0434813686,
0.0101750391,
0.0124033736,
0.0147735812,
-0.0308557227,
-0.0226296559,
0.0309805963,
0.0631350055,
0.0082683284,
-0.001571339,
-0.0067450744,
-0.0258281883,
0.0112790801,
0.054616116,
0.0637250692,
-0.0764632449,
-0.0325709879,
0.0084869368,
-0.0277524572,
-0.0606411994,
0.014261202,
0.0375253409,
0.0422999002,
0.0030155196,
-0.032909546,
-0.0522472113,
0.0394631177,
0.062810719,
0.0120557323,
0.0248041265,
-0.0483811758,
0.0281435195,
-0.0584778525,
0.0169279184,
-0.0656177327,
-0.0004692977,
-0.0902090073,
0.0177719705,
0.0475375354,
-0.031380143,
-0.0179084614,
-0.0535346903,
-0.0544068068,
-0.0309449192,
-0.0009364497,
0.0708529875,
0.0113769192,
0.0306967683,
-0.0292377081,
-0.0591565147,
0.080673486,
0.0211444665,
-0.006141718,
0.0191709604,
0.0641245991,
-0.0115511408,
-0.0247452036,
0.0238111988,
-0.0428442061,
0.0185266081,
0.0440090857,
-0.0027631056,
0.0126981605,
0.0114948321,
0.0319071338,
0.0191873703,
0.0665990263,
-0.0037461591,
-0.0065035583,
-0.041635029,
0.0157608148,
0.0317747518,
-0.0044727665,
-0.0039519919,
0.0103451898,
0.0247389413,
-0.0400568359,
0.0246224049,
0.0081237275,
-0.0431893058,
0.0419376232,
-0.0168223418,
0.0152729703,
-0.0044320212,
0.0668008626,
-0.006150818,
0.0226738695,
-0.0239832047,
0.0157382786,
0.0446097143,
0.02199132,
-0.0267256368,
0.0342847295,
0.0319789797,
-0.0041473582,
-0.0383891948,
0.0900164545,
-0.0877750963,
-0.0053525912,
0.0049843425,
0.0146108158,
0.0425325669,
0.0350675695,
-0.0306076612,
0.0264240541,
0.0010490791,
-0.0399841145,
0.0183908902,
0.0185242463,
0.0002105652,
0.0269615091,
0.0088069206,
-0.01262757,
-0.0004475498,
0.0836059824,
-0.0255038869,
0.0482253544,
0.013620154,
0.032829646,
-0.0584101044,
0.0097212,
-0.0319277346,
0.0304231439,
-0.0321276076,
0.0405534096,
-0.0598922186,
-0.0306547619,
0.0237659793,
0.0102640698,
-0.0054046414,
0.0330345593,
0.0378843807,
0.0286185481,
-0.0077946652,
-0.0108901644,
-0.0177247562,
0.0062435842,
0.0252730176,
-0.0099839773,
0.0133125018,
-5.42763578e-33,
-0.0482662357,
0.0304954778,
0.0300752893,
-0.0230243206,
-0.0021720477,
-0.0134914825,
-0.0271002576,
0.0121329306,
-0.0515320301,
-0.0246540848,
-0.0602636635,
0.0065562595,
0.0318490826,
0.0085463757,
-0.0078011248,
-0.0397522524,
0.0421904251,
-0.0193677526,
-0.0567859672,
-0.0069461348,
0.0178984143,
0.0580777749,
0.035622336,
0.0468108356,
-0.0053854915,
0.0291295294,
0.0008528677,
-0.0031010828,
0.0017184622,
0.0341487974,
0.0011983291,
0.0386891253,
0.0478357077,
-0.013313205,
-0.038236782,
0.08750429,
-0.0921386704,
-0.067716293,
0.0155007588,
-0.012125425,
-0.0402290002,
-0.0540045239,
-0.0421777591,
-0.0332837626,
0.0089844298,
-0.0033497177,
0.0380982049,
-0.0085273841,
-0.0500734746,
0.0128104752,
-0.0351196155,
-0.0187774766,
0.0062532937,
-0.0240583178,
0.026619412,
0.0787251815,
-0.0010747204,
0.01760206,
0.0162181109,
0.0324508175,
-0.0362488255,
0.0548217669,
0.0097769145,
0.060847491,
0.0088475626,
0.0374425128,
0.0397959873,
0.0213980805,
0.0652790666,
0.0015473899,
0.0307002626,
-0.0311858673,
-0.0124084167,
0.0769777447,
0.0340568349,
-0.0207402781,
-0.0257116295,
0.022650186,
0.0217878465,
0.018122172,
0.0134969885,
-0.0289481841,
0.0109951468,
-0.003156489,
-0.0976619348,
-0.0115022855,
-0.0331836417,
0.0002351279,
0.068107821,
0.0227869377,
-0.019194534,
-0.0144990915,
0.0701947287,
-0.0315621234,
0.0294502527,
0.0423656665,
-0.0057759881,
0.0082898308,
0.0130326012,
0.019607434,
-0.0524708182,
-0.0333019495,
0.0385353081,
0.0216561984,
0.0135343326,
0.0153535362,
0.0575576983,
0.0053178305,
-0.0648377985,
-0.014227842,
-0.0118884444,
0.011733694,
0.0110790823,
-0.0099166902,
0.0134827597,
0.0349088758,
-0.0180876702,
0.020930646,
-0.0005896087,
-0.0820496604,
-0.0092916582,
-0.014986448,
-0.0186136961,
0.0241539329,
-0.0090473639,
0.0159268323,
-0.012536007,
0.02538299,
0.0177953225,
-0.037939515,
-0.0133959297,
0.0088571664,
2.443e-7,
0.0147747751,
0.0143659469,
0.0288415831,
-0.0073272116,
0.0166883674,
0.0202404428,
-0.0181028917,
0.0483888797,
0.0244293679,
-0.0146814827,
0.0442769863,
0.0203454308,
0.0267546531,
-0.0080159307,
-0.0909373984,
0.0136958035,
-0.0414555632,
0.0486838557,
-0.0131359361,
-0.0137609234,
-0.0047020577,
0.0813961253,
0.0021984491,
0.0039312723,
-0.0052103987,
-0.0286627095,
0.0503824092,
-0.041988831,
0.0029354279,
0.0119638098,
-0.0415239371,
-0.0118098557,
-0.0058812569,
0.0317988135,
-0.0211728867,
0.0292253792,
0.0170952659,
0.0475136265,
-0.0137041975,
-0.0273273028,
-0.0305390079,
0.0085131638,
0.0215174481,
0.0205767993,
0.0832207799,
-0.0757881775,
0.0082952939,
-0.0421562344,
-0.0183836985,
0.0089659132,
0.0559441857,
-0.0298067499,
-0.0085952869,
0.0155929774,
0.0344638564,
0.0315919518,
-0.0167504735,
-0.0939799994,
-0.0137665682,
0.0192858502,
-0.0280424878,
-0.0577085018,
-0.0207201373,
-0.0362168737,
0.0615642406,
-0.0763894394,
0.0046279724,
1.522601761e-34,
0.01706017,
-0.028088823,
0.0697878376,
-0.0024283978,
-0.0485554226,
-0.0247500036,
-0.0348242968,
-0.0261506848,
0.0913285762,
-0.065256469,
-0.0176786352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08102v1 | Prompt Tuning of Deep Neural Networks for Speaker-adaptive Visual Speech Recognition | 2023-02-16T06:01:31 | 2023-02-16T06:01:31 | Minsu Kim, Hyung-Il Kim, Yong Man Ro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS, eess.IV | Visual Speech Recognition (VSR) aims to infer speech into text depending on
lip movements alone. As it focuses on visual information to model the speech,
its performance is inherently sensitive to personal lip appearances and
movements, and this makes the VSR models show degraded performance when they
are applied to unseen speakers. In this paper, to remedy the performance
degradation of the VSR model on unseen speakers, we propose prompt tuning
methods of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) for speaker-adaptive VSR. Specifically,
motivated by recent advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP), we finetune
prompts on adaptation data of target speakers instead of modifying the
pre-trained model parameters. Different from the previous prompt tuning methods
mainly limited to Transformer variant architecture, we explore different types
of prompts, the addition, the padding, and the concatenation form prompts that
can be applied to the VSR model which is composed of CNN and Transformer in
general. With the proposed prompt tuning, we show that the performance of the
pre-trained VSR model on unseen speakers can be largely improved by using a
small amount of adaptation data (e.g., less than 5 minutes), even if the
pre-trained model is already developed with large speaker variations. Moreover,
by analyzing the performance and parameters of different types of prompts, we
investigate when the prompt tuning is preferred over the finetuning methods.
The effectiveness of the proposed method is evaluated on both word- and
sentence-level VSR databases, LRW-ID and GRID. | [
0.0208514724,
0.0457697771,
-0.00351898,
0.015312138,
-0.0116596809,
-0.0118281553,
0.0552597977,
-0.0000657685,
-0.0057924842,
0.0049118455,
-0.0483434983,
-0.0131782778,
0.0205983054,
0.0397036783,
0.029616205,
-0.0929935873,
0.0009472559,
-0.0280856248,
0.0204286426,
-0.0154755712,
0.039909225,
-0.0014830638,
-0.0493976176,
0.0243281592,
-0.0347729214,
-0.0115208672,
-0.0122860558,
0.0477224588,
0.0307854936,
0.0185138881,
-0.0274794865,
0.0302510168,
0.0217847824,
-0.0063299094,
0.0000020623,
0.0152638704,
-0.0046675587,
-0.0076632975,
-0.0550953075,
0.0000500968,
0.0221545808,
-0.0469456613,
-0.0068702055,
0.0327886902,
-0.0235028006,
-0.0492219292,
0.0428683721,
0.0058876565,
0.0466601178,
0.051012218,
-0.0113082947,
0.0050143097,
0.0237668827,
-0.0234258305,
0.001898362,
-0.0599925816,
-0.0115370015,
-0.0617196448,
-0.0143744154,
-0.0606338829,
-0.0797618553,
0.0413674712,
-0.0035258909,
-0.0020962062,
0.0372963436,
-0.0156311579,
-0.0466255993,
-0.0585427545,
-0.040567819,
0.078315489,
-0.0067610354,
0.0302955844,
-0.0094550336,
-0.0369801857,
-0.0012398009,
0.0373464674,
0.0189463031,
0.0225633625,
0.0108930133,
-0.0251750574,
-0.1007423028,
0.0247702356,
0.00869451,
-0.0152528612,
-0.0399412364,
-0.0070859711,
-0.001035518,
-0.0064987815,
0.0136678759,
-0.0395450071,
-0.0148414159,
-0.0226452053,
0.0177897364,
0.003310794,
0.0023726649,
-0.0191925354,
-0.0481247902,
-0.0246867891,
-0.0448920578,
0.027122017,
0.0390023589,
0.0455695391,
-0.1152935252,
-0.0007156557,
-0.0210666955,
0.1070935354,
-0.019227121,
0.0434860736,
0.0216518547,
-0.009306279,
0.0014927052,
0.0101060374,
-0.0460968651,
-0.0288977437,
-0.0445833467,
-0.0315330736,
-0.0258220565,
0.0395004638,
-0.0135767125,
-0.0031781083,
0.001832195,
0.0332928374,
-0.0498457886,
-0.0005541454,
-0.0270363037,
0.0742733404,
0.0109021822,
0.0109552462,
0.0142293768,
-0.0907696337,
-0.0003272285,
0.0334635526,
0.0660998821,
0.010191042,
0.0654944405,
0.0552710518,
0.020339543,
-0.0227253847,
-0.0096581923,
0.0511585325,
-0.0466098525,
-0.014599408,
0.056862779,
-0.0716619343,
0.0257138424,
-0.0203434732,
0.0358354077,
-0.0221308395,
-0.0222215094,
-0.0104236798,
-0.0128351562,
0.0589987524,
0.0025638677,
-0.0026526127,
0.0419165976,
-0.0194502752,
0.0344902873,
0.0190861076,
0.0479507558,
-0.0088525768,
0.0085813189,
-0.0390083641,
0.0361772627,
0.0587913506,
-0.00416815,
0.0128998896,
-0.0446282998,
-0.0224503484,
0.0299567133,
0.0207500309,
0.0472147167,
0.0391574204,
-0.0142503539,
-0.0306200571,
0.062639676,
0.0247359872,
0.0267726611,
0.0088545401,
0.0342488661,
0.0017755128,
0.0116309393,
0.0194168407,
-0.0415531173,
0.0207069144,
-0.0000215066,
-0.0041964594,
-0.0003720108,
0.0186365284,
-0.058279328,
-0.0186111219,
0.0121618947,
-0.0374040976,
0.0168691706,
0.060169559,
-0.035685841,
0.0057865214,
-0.0422787555,
0.0295913368,
-0.0073021576,
-0.0081269564,
-0.0105386926,
-0.0301430728,
-0.0015785206,
0.0553273484,
-0.0239876304,
-0.0060688369,
-0.0240286589,
-0.0229054857,
0.0176207926,
0.0237600375,
0.0032321985,
0.0153691368,
0.0660643205,
-0.0812335834,
-0.0244124569,
0.0130414208,
-0.0042618522,
0.0430553705,
-0.0278497376,
0.0191943254,
0.0035661017,
0.0194735434,
0.0344226025,
0.0175569765,
-0.0290468261,
-0.0007257654,
0.0171466656,
0.0709464028,
0.007196303,
0.0283455569,
-0.0177138578,
-0.0310998484,
0.0145180738,
-0.0178653114,
0.0492542647,
0.0116635095,
-0.0606386028,
-0.0129806781,
0.0328971334,
-0.0522190332,
0.0445602387,
0.0587559491,
0.0029849606,
-0.0639919639,
0.0134375859,
-0.020658955,
-0.0194932055,
-0.0417716131,
0.02399466,
0.006090953,
0.0392864347,
-0.0047246674,
-0.0197265074,
0.0205586944,
-0.0265258737,
0.048468221,
0.066033788,
0.0061983103,
-0.0830366984,
-0.0417399108,
0.0079284385,
-0.007089213,
0.0165638383,
0.000499043,
0.0445062146,
-0.0347214788,
-0.0473622233,
-0.0652561188,
-0.007855935,
-0.0459561348,
-0.0465743467,
-0.0320331007,
0.0385809205,
-0.0172036961,
-0.0593141429,
-0.0584786385,
-0.0053005288,
-0.0198086519,
-0.0162877236,
-0.0067053176,
0.0188511778,
-0.0257716496,
-0.0313300602,
-0.0025382906,
0.0256392118,
0.0049320613,
-0.0115562398,
-0.04710529,
-0.0048408974,
-0.0385490023,
-0.0059700264,
0.067802377,
-0.0016732019,
-0.022028625,
-0.0263875797,
0.0295762271,
0.0601726472,
0.0694944635,
0.0323439203,
-0.0031965957,
-0.0335412733,
0.0306788366,
-0.0290930457,
0.0266964715,
0.0081709009,
-0.0290073622,
-0.0319755338,
-0.0056241108,
-0.0423653312,
-0.0431758091,
0.0034519371,
0.0445473939,
-0.0891961977,
0.01473922,
0.025531454,
-0.0186001956,
0.0082814721,
0.0183534622,
-0.0277265124,
0.0145599199,
0.0026955565,
-0.0568273962,
0.0260185245,
-0.0535337217,
-0.0667252392,
0.0108327139,
-0.047841426,
-0.0395263284,
0.0154333012,
0.0246655084,
0.0133558512,
-0.0231857561,
-0.0282524209,
-0.0685160905,
-0.0401181616,
0.0175787527,
-0.0072447518,
0.0329301506,
0.0090255197,
-0.0262384433,
-0.0384531245,
-0.0183478147,
-0.0447596759,
-0.0524400882,
-0.0453828461,
-0.0151824756,
0.0136490604,
-0.0309291277,
0.001490201,
0.0119195916,
0.0504083559,
0.0364779755,
0.0004420453,
0.0399591513,
-0.0527667664,
0.0158980526,
0.0597255789,
0.0812695399,
-0.0365327187,
-0.0353486538,
0.0415943675,
-0.0202349704,
0.024131529,
-0.0018568934,
-0.0707061738,
0.0356378295,
0.0504275262,
0.0477972105,
-0.0182436518,
0.0519707799,
0.0187036674,
-0.0175738763,
0.0635190159,
0.0643088743,
-0.0024753951,
-0.0598774552,
-0.0372069627,
0.0361141525,
0.0244352296,
0.0142086707,
0.0124607496,
-0.1031898707,
-0.0318234637,
0.0280843917,
0.0373076126,
0.0011362118,
0.0234334376,
-0.0571531467,
-0.0451237857,
0.0565099567,
-0.0072809565,
-0.028697636,
-0.009503644,
-0.0047509526,
-0.0046395864,
-0.0402561016,
0.0709956214,
0.0046112505,
-0.0108874161,
-0.0235450044,
0.0452493392,
-0.0451660305,
-0.0152543373,
-0.0060048769,
-0.0601617061,
0.0319593884,
0.0372785628,
0.0025329159,
-0.0177026372,
-0.0622376315,
-0.0007795208,
-0.0172708035,
0.0303641129,
-0.0143201686,
0.0571224168,
-0.0110599101,
-0.0477291979,
0.0477143154,
0.0368916094,
0.003848383,
0.0317196362,
0.0033349067,
0.0170658026,
-0.0130375009,
-0.0079654818,
-0.0154041499,
0.0304004662,
-0.0034529713,
0.028842207,
0.0327361487,
-0.0646708459,
-0.0010893499,
0.0408482589,
0.0314620957,
-0.0325260013,
-0.0330504104,
0.0152535615,
0.038575042,
-0.0534799099,
0.0141176172,
0.0178264547,
-0.0230077561,
0.0496036336,
0.0110139884,
-0.0430349447,
0.0212614462,
0.0663305148,
-0.0154191749,
0.0617838576,
-0.0161343887,
0.0463433899,
-0.0901058838,
-0.0091149686,
0.0180168431,
-0.0547293089,
0.0068674567,
0.0010093563,
-0.0569060892,
-0.0291233212,
-0.0105541907,
0.0035203754,
0.013797571,
0.1002566665,
-0.0124961315,
-0.0858648345,
0.0338121504,
0.0152580198,
-0.0046950886,
0.0463973805,
0.063480109,
-0.0199200027,
-0.0462105907,
0.0112370159,
-0.0210002195,
0.010696955,
0.0033768907,
-0.0360805988,
0.0008683729,
-0.1177547872,
-0.0139938379,
0.0258359611,
0.0398945883,
0.0122451214,
-0.0234275386,
-0.0446069911,
0.0164167285,
0.0542540662,
0.0400667451,
-0.0761070102,
-0.0252753031,
0.0038487834,
0.0443715192,
0.0010592595,
-0.0252464321,
0.0130899018,
-0.0111281304,
-0.0408536606,
0.07659778,
-0.00862223,
0.027383551,
-0.0011757507,
0.0338926874,
-0.0009170312,
0.0136929937,
0.009153029,
0.0145360688,
0.0167019274,
0.0091013312,
0.0526096076,
-0.0133832712,
-0.0161650665,
0.0447826274,
-0.0315397419,
-0.046661932,
-0.0118170856,
0.0504189096,
0.0123034501,
-0.0064996392,
-0.0369477607,
0.0427074023,
-0.0013980246,
-0.0186482351,
0.0231728069,
0.006738801,
-0.0367963053,
0.0370595045,
0.0085360855,
-0.0181991924,
0.0060779224,
0.0147575671,
0.011167096,
0.0065245903,
-0.0379230157,
0.0318416171,
-0.056852486,
0.0025918707,
0.0174871571,
-0.0219174549,
-0.0037691854,
0.0209674016,
0.0066928603,
-0.0500566773,
0.0702286661,
0.0060417978,
0.0245585572,
0.020744551,
0.068582572,
-0.0207236763,
-0.021929061,
0.0136068454,
0.0116038788,
-0.0300818011,
0.0235680733,
-0.0052860011,
0.0341055617,
-6.208638635e-33,
-0.0230761189,
0.0153657654,
0.0378988683,
0.0276048798,
-0.0443007834,
-0.0241167583,
0.004278989,
0.0151836332,
-0.0219016168,
-0.011466898,
-0.0244833101,
0.0035320839,
0.0408810079,
0.0316396281,
-0.0758873522,
-0.0517164208,
0.078801468,
-0.0123836743,
-0.0060953782,
0.0007319944,
0.0056327437,
0.0428777747,
0.0258247294,
-0.0553231202,
-0.0530448593,
0.007347085,
0.0031904283,
-0.0406207666,
0.0161422994,
0.0475547947,
0.00593381,
0.0234074276,
-0.0278704036,
-0.0148991458,
0.0170605239,
0.0468243696,
-0.0818677992,
0.0078599257,
-0.0346871912,
0.0837925971,
-0.0693153962,
-0.0120690912,
0.0404170752,
0.0064885351,
-0.0070834961,
-0.030031018,
0.0720792785,
-0.0401790291,
-0.0100476304,
0.0133759174,
0.0109241605,
0.0399565063,
-0.0078215459,
-0.0338688642,
0.0414803028,
0.0930120125,
-0.0226449408,
0.0026983165,
-0.0272695161,
0.0226221513,
0.028945066,
0.0110845482,
0.0250803474,
0.0690745413,
-0.0133399554,
-0.002201023,
0.0525667816,
-0.067624718,
0.0443305671,
-0.0341081917,
0.0700342208,
0.0268675201,
0.0342736579,
0.033480566,
-0.0327765606,
-0.0420101099,
-0.025669368,
-0.040064767,
0.0088635962,
-0.0220708884,
0.0029253822,
0.0028258699,
-0.0258189514,
0.0020407632,
-0.0581293553,
-0.0236167889,
-0.0443289652,
0.0116058635,
0.0264366586,
0.0305268113,
-0.0133149754,
0.0477427468,
0.0762053281,
-0.0469077677,
0.0465310887,
0.0091115953,
-0.0205534846,
0.0113291778,
0.0111972978,
0.0309572313,
-0.0326950066,
-0.0211878419,
0.0696014464,
0.0247525238,
0.0221477598,
0.0000893487,
0.0126119005,
0.083170183,
-0.0529720001,
-0.0328044742,
0.0375177711,
0.0502034687,
-0.0031798601,
0.0701474547,
0.0017257909,
-0.0063707372,
-0.0305401292,
0.0229939986,
-0.0254785307,
-0.0166470464,
-0.023077121,
-0.0160865802,
0.0212259386,
0.0232634842,
-0.05935077,
0.0177266356,
0.0204631276,
-0.0083980784,
-0.0077881701,
-0.0353044756,
0.0096021472,
0.0239330102,
2.933e-7,
-0.0450493954,
-0.012001941,
0.0577812605,
-0.0180332605,
0.0177488104,
0.0110693648,
0.0157337431,
-0.0066473982,
0.0184954982,
-0.026171349,
0.0154369054,
0.0080369823,
0.0298523568,
-0.0518085398,
-0.056956999,
0.0316641815,
-0.0524429791,
0.0301199369,
0.0053624115,
0.0131664779,
-0.0223287754,
0.0720035508,
-0.0237411298,
-0.0401918292,
0.0501859784,
-0.0027698334,
0.0128377713,
-0.0281159803,
0.0125106201,
-0.0284861717,
0.0386938602,
-0.00242391,
-0.0226076171,
0.05408426,
0.0002271494,
0.0663992092,
0.0126360711,
0.0282955058,
-0.0132567389,
-0.0612391904,
-0.0101192761,
0.0704743937,
-0.0542753637,
0.0067506018,
0.0665049031,
-0.0024843968,
-0.0254759379,
-0.0127469562,
-0.0406493321,
-0.014052758,
0.061173398,
-0.0230755527,
-0.0119964117,
0.0442968309,
0.0655468404,
-0.0566585772,
-0.0349497311,
-0.0691403151,
0.0158849172,
-0.0417187326,
-0.0558178537,
-0.0200915243,
-0.071380578,
-0.0212354772,
0.0420324802,
-0.0044581196,
-0.0143588018,
1.8997054e-34,
0.037298359,
0.0048475717,
0.020579638,
-0.0655048713,
-0.0314852446,
-0.0254858285,
0.0057298592,
0.0341338255,
0.049348224,
-0.0773243308,
-0.0584391691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08095v1 | PAAPLoss: A Phonetic-Aligned Acoustic Parameter Loss for Speech Enhancement | 2023-02-16T05:17:06 | 2023-02-16T05:17:06 | Muqiao Yang, Joseph Konan, David Bick, Yunyang Zeng, Shuo Han, Anurag Kumar, Shinji Watanabe, Bhiksha Raj | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Despite rapid advancement in recent years, current speech enhancement models
often produce speech that differs in perceptual quality from real clean speech.
We propose a learning objective that formalizes differences in perceptual
quality, by using domain knowledge of acoustic-phonetics. We identify temporal
acoustic parameters -- such as spectral tilt, spectral flux, shimmer, etc. --
that are non-differentiable, and we develop a neural network estimator that can
accurately predict their time-series values across an utterance. We also model
phoneme-specific weights for each feature, as the acoustic parameters are known
to show different behavior in different phonemes. We can add this criterion as
an auxiliary loss to any model that produces speech, to optimize speech outputs
to match the values of clean speech in these features. Experimentally we show
that it improves speech enhancement workflows in both time-domain and
time-frequency domain, as measured by standard evaluation metrics. We also
provide an analysis of phoneme-dependent improvement on acoustic parameters,
demonstrating the additional interpretability that our method provides. This
analysis can suggest which features are currently the bottleneck for
improvement. | [
-0.0206818525,
0.1019664407,
0.026707422,
-0.0189058352,
0.0010184135,
-0.043565657,
0.0256713256,
0.0046220324,
-0.0614967495,
0.0505299829,
-0.050138548,
-0.029608475,
0.0583724938,
0.0301770139,
0.0483514108,
-0.1057698727,
0.0207929201,
-0.0282977615,
0.0398296975,
-0.0213953201,
0.0287529938,
-0.0152388411,
-0.0533083081,
0.0297311116,
-0.0276618712,
-0.0087899892,
-0.024100842,
0.0072215116,
0.008615762,
0.0105128363,
0.0055598444,
-0.0083624804,
-0.0230729934,
-0.0302894488,
0.0000019702,
-0.0358660519,
-0.0260157045,
0.034847863,
-0.0399567597,
0.0412440561,
0.0540538989,
0.0593447126,
-0.0458047129,
0.0346508734,
0.0063867914,
-0.0284806564,
0.0697214901,
0.0045833066,
0.0287209395,
0.0596968159,
-0.0027943796,
-0.0082656136,
-0.0292734317,
-0.0217370149,
-0.048904635,
0.0246247761,
-0.0150173446,
-0.0797403976,
-0.0324891843,
-0.0520076118,
0.0174755733,
0.0550154783,
0.0085003534,
-0.0113748396,
0.058831431,
-0.0027875372,
-0.0098284027,
-0.0384087116,
0.0056376555,
0.0442458577,
-0.0178127456,
-0.0121608563,
0.0067399871,
0.0062078796,
-0.0090417769,
-0.0772094801,
0.03590196,
-0.0351758972,
0.0658399388,
0.0058984673,
-0.0609533451,
0.0270337518,
0.04333492,
-0.0074022543,
0.0207622536,
0.0167985633,
0.010370831,
-0.0354106054,
-0.0023262461,
-0.0158500113,
0.0071921898,
0.0186719149,
0.0758433342,
0.031638138,
0.0096442169,
-0.0175614655,
0.0353152119,
-0.0787044093,
-0.0291996878,
0.0108661065,
0.0299899131,
0.0312026329,
-0.0526737161,
-0.0437081456,
-0.0033932573,
0.0070768539,
0.021918403,
-0.0351440497,
-0.028640043,
-0.011023568,
0.0375032686,
0.0045143184,
-0.0309732221,
0.0247283466,
-0.0002863862,
0.0473851636,
-0.0344454087,
-0.0472269431,
-0.0824612752,
0.0237504113,
0.0413524024,
0.0460827984,
-0.0571728088,
-0.0365254506,
0.0041671265,
0.0564571433,
0.0086905332,
0.0435036011,
-0.0124422843,
-0.0505582467,
-0.0211537667,
0.0286422893,
0.0507514141,
0.0457981043,
0.0419896059,
0.0872504786,
0.0185148846,
0.0401762687,
-0.0569111332,
-0.0336168408,
-0.0112752486,
-0.0236943532,
-0.0380377248,
-0.0341691785,
0.0180117209,
-0.0409182049,
-0.0238746777,
-0.0267294906,
-0.0208294615,
-0.0414454937,
0.0391800068,
0.0094204536,
-0.0281000398,
0.032754261,
0.0767338201,
-0.015861012,
-0.0485601425,
0.0294620413,
0.0550772958,
-0.0517142229,
0.0047575817,
-0.0545511432,
-0.0452486575,
0.071948491,
0.0491495505,
0.0027531667,
-0.0454370566,
-0.0600507632,
-0.0196051095,
0.0056670709,
0.0692404807,
0.0049124146,
-0.0169364978,
-0.0333118811,
0.0806401744,
0.0021257291,
0.0768725276,
0.0193573553,
0.0098901382,
0.0047172559,
0.0113732424,
-0.0174388383,
-0.0228954181,
-0.0340878591,
0.0062589669,
0.0124759087,
0.0239450671,
0.0408299267,
-0.0584210865,
-0.0810289979,
0.0459700339,
-0.0586570352,
0.0029110217,
0.010986493,
0.0227100123,
0.0187658984,
0.0020056008,
0.0415923148,
0.0203820467,
-0.0435533673,
0.0602110587,
-0.0201172978,
0.0218258072,
0.0319028571,
-0.028366968,
-0.0460036509,
0.0003748937,
-0.0496593527,
-0.0550116301,
0.0408270694,
-0.0291086398,
-0.0118198832,
0.1212176457,
-0.0647217184,
-0.0027997007,
0.0410010219,
0.0222703107,
0.0461466536,
-0.0186993182,
-0.0071357642,
0.0347442962,
-0.0123694632,
0.0130378036,
-0.0310899857,
-0.0176003054,
-0.0110640442,
0.0369274989,
-0.002994071,
0.0533102527,
0.0436319225,
-0.0187320374,
0.015074701,
-0.0009126809,
-0.0478268042,
0.0337246843,
0.0236734208,
-0.0401346013,
0.02915808,
0.0564612448,
-0.0101615554,
0.0338075943,
0.0493990593,
0.0225523785,
-0.0765641183,
0.0926069096,
-0.0372228846,
0.0874321908,
-0.0430620685,
0.0306009594,
0.0169473477,
-0.0031494815,
0.0288245138,
-0.0266056415,
0.0284126364,
-0.0197857451,
0.0326251797,
0.027895933,
-0.0160078574,
-0.0499424711,
-0.0061051515,
0.0189840626,
-0.030424485,
0.0290343203,
-0.0066786259,
-0.0218806863,
-0.0439961627,
0.0240636598,
-0.0344154648,
0.0093215266,
-0.0175957065,
-0.004369962,
-0.0005953326,
0.0199573003,
0.0256661475,
-0.0356168039,
-0.0355338491,
-0.020050453,
-0.0265344661,
-0.0169750135,
-0.0164755601,
-0.0075946376,
-0.003140776,
-0.0375518166,
0.0028246841,
0.0255469717,
0.0100624524,
-0.0468839332,
-0.0173311401,
-0.0189594515,
0.0084968535,
-0.0047750729,
0.0256633572,
0.0325038433,
-0.0317433514,
-0.0403937101,
0.0200195014,
0.0322578251,
0.0362615027,
0.0032283578,
-0.0763856992,
0.036857266,
-0.014470771,
-0.0612866431,
0.0000016982,
-0.0371246524,
0.0708876252,
0.0150664328,
0.017182963,
-0.0011791878,
-0.004831905,
0.0336604491,
0.0321815386,
-0.0512880832,
-0.0108473692,
-0.0184509661,
-0.0567549951,
0.0142527707,
-0.038631402,
-0.0310603473,
-0.0152622499,
-0.0298441201,
-0.0502108783,
-0.0032450967,
-0.0411795862,
-0.0413591601,
-0.0278170537,
-0.0615117624,
-0.0004938043,
-0.0583327375,
-0.0172550436,
0.0271100197,
-0.0023137631,
-0.0418551639,
-0.0189049486,
-0.0039854627,
0.0395242497,
-0.0640934035,
0.0063164118,
-0.0428817049,
-0.0571844764,
0.0009611003,
0.0106656021,
-0.0328961425,
0.0477501228,
0.0054100985,
0.0106202317,
-0.0246615168,
-0.0182710383,
0.05262639,
0.0087362835,
-0.0003739497,
0.0494659096,
-0.0049520545,
0.0273282453,
0.0006866386,
0.0197361484,
0.0033021539,
0.0519072711,
0.005294174,
-0.0052100937,
0.0069951285,
-0.0209408924,
0.0652011111,
-0.0271902401,
-0.0619902238,
0.0132382205,
0.0104390299,
0.0073593985,
-0.0356333144,
0.0059270156,
0.0225190129,
-0.0755439773,
0.0406348109,
0.0476309285,
-0.0086915074,
-0.0359881967,
0.0261271819,
0.0158798117,
0.0363565348,
-0.0299331471,
-0.028964594,
0.0239789747,
-0.0014154324,
0.0380094647,
0.0457943492,
-0.0394467078,
0.0468044803,
-0.0410069153,
-0.0705068111,
0.0280356836,
0.0506711379,
0.0256964378,
0.0023910732,
-0.0464872457,
-0.0012116351,
-0.0569527633,
0.0740602985,
0.0136482427,
0.0395848155,
-0.0256461222,
0.0810881406,
-0.0904413387,
-0.0597159639,
-0.0741851181,
-0.0475916937,
0.0496864803,
0.0232399199,
-0.018822819,
-0.0088834213,
-0.0822731927,
-0.0139180338,
0.0062560057,
-0.0237181149,
-0.0011429113,
0.0499788336,
0.0506054796,
-0.0158512276,
0.0250748508,
0.0606241487,
-0.0038893002,
0.027876135,
0.033417467,
0.0069533843,
0.021531282,
0.0339918695,
0.0035094002,
0.0223290715,
-0.0137995044,
0.0286765527,
0.0080729909,
-0.0720968843,
0.0329180956,
-0.0065188329,
0.0297533106,
-0.0195921995,
0.0033532586,
-0.0064847628,
0.0249271374,
-0.0928997472,
-0.0318194777,
-0.0019098707,
-0.0523472764,
0.0131850215,
0.010931029,
-0.0220552795,
-0.00570289,
0.0099470876,
-0.0155573934,
0.022999499,
0.0094124814,
0.0358155333,
-0.0225852039,
-0.0053877942,
0.0220459457,
-0.0316702574,
-0.0144324964,
0.0063657304,
-0.0375429206,
-0.0723358393,
0.025797762,
-0.0067660715,
0.0160348974,
0.07596495,
-0.0426278673,
-0.0580884889,
0.0629025027,
-0.0062660752,
-0.0378796048,
0.013388047,
0.134258464,
-0.020700451,
0.0030238922,
0.0416969955,
-0.030362213,
0.057808131,
-0.0258607306,
-0.016244689,
-0.0144571932,
-0.0350352488,
-0.0054042665,
0.0088782879,
0.037647564,
0.0178150833,
0.0079994667,
-0.0295267012,
0.0338591933,
0.0040329536,
0.0381550603,
-0.0378653966,
-0.0175277609,
0.0232757684,
0.0510388277,
-0.0148492567,
0.0060397326,
-0.0148959113,
-0.0282303467,
0.0172129646,
0.0431209095,
-0.0395131186,
-0.008403643,
-0.0237904303,
0.0303295478,
0.0211473741,
0.0376911983,
0.0140245734,
-0.0111195641,
0.0013960749,
-0.030041771,
-0.0040345788,
-0.0315196887,
0.0006778584,
0.021519104,
-0.017978942,
0.0087091951,
-0.0104238447,
-0.008613199,
0.0005262275,
-0.0316028893,
0.0536451899,
-0.0067325989,
0.0227642152,
-0.0001980891,
-0.0056025349,
0.0115803787,
0.0274033584,
0.0078916783,
-0.0133828707,
-0.016930664,
0.006381507,
0.0311972015,
-0.0284089837,
0.0369177945,
-0.0509093367,
0.0574437976,
-0.012922897,
-0.0391089171,
-0.0317561105,
0.0344737358,
-0.0253421795,
-0.0097227329,
-0.0047747511,
-0.0457066521,
-0.006986748,
-0.0356487446,
0.0438717008,
-0.0230130609,
0.026883699,
-0.0421300754,
-0.0572182126,
0.0250752643,
0.0258866958,
-0.080342941,
0.0252283104,
0.0180256609,
0.0211749338,
-5.775665494e-33,
0.009333753,
0.0383844189,
-0.0125073642,
0.0195479989,
-0.0175962616,
0.0127090681,
-0.0234192051,
0.0277554262,
-0.0295589771,
0.0054742955,
0.0036107155,
0.0122609995,
0.0276764184,
0.0276166517,
-0.0193328429,
0.0203455426,
0.0893044695,
0.0012241454,
0.0254794583,
-0.0009143559,
0.0195068978,
0.0207849108,
0.0249598306,
-0.0427420177,
-0.0545805097,
0.0372133255,
-0.0574942604,
-0.0167668425,
0.0516248122,
0.0226985496,
0.0024216082,
0.0876064599,
-0.0377271026,
-0.0525487103,
-0.0027634159,
-0.0200770069,
-0.0354265943,
-0.0165433064,
-0.0199385229,
0.03180876,
-0.0431620739,
-0.0555556305,
0.0424173735,
0.0355149284,
-0.0423062257,
-0.0189716201,
0.0244663879,
-0.0607151091,
0.0089988383,
-0.0259113312,
0.034033522,
0.0534202643,
-0.0164466947,
-0.0210194346,
0.0632872805,
0.0544858575,
-0.050789237,
-0.0229339767,
-0.0602628812,
0.0445531197,
0.054990571,
0.0303232167,
0.0051835608,
0.0253027752,
-0.0067781638,
-0.0210080203,
0.0799740404,
-0.0447466373,
0.063532047,
-0.0188953746,
0.0461980589,
0.0206963494,
0.0719995722,
-0.0160339288,
0.041757632,
-0.0262260381,
0.0002569921,
0.0169808082,
-0.0168801956,
0.0295553673,
-0.0162501112,
0.0256064925,
0.0019093987,
0.0045051672,
-0.0689922795,
-0.0466864891,
-0.0207144003,
-0.005690814,
0.0073016151,
-0.0035791425,
-0.0106351888,
0.0197214484,
0.0218109265,
-0.0039574276,
0.0460122004,
-0.0161756519,
-0.0323406197,
-0.0268141143,
0.0336624235,
-0.0236001816,
-0.0390876308,
0.0058763907,
0.0777577907,
0.0398488343,
-0.0060616797,
-0.0492416359,
-0.0174454376,
0.0565284789,
-0.0416297093,
0.0038815879,
-0.0138187027,
0.0472377315,
0.030654341,
0.035486646,
0.0329708345,
-0.0105824927,
-0.0190715827,
0.0346913822,
0.0079957983,
0.0451463535,
0.007533649,
0.0125058349,
0.0270874295,
0.0284887627,
-0.0430763997,
0.0010770074,
0.0470453538,
-0.0442218371,
0.0438550152,
-0.0156113515,
-0.0246920921,
-0.0457214192,
2.841e-7,
-0.0608481616,
-0.0096661896,
0.0198033489,
-0.0001939818,
0.0352297425,
0.0232894104,
-0.0122878542,
-0.0202795621,
-0.0424248539,
0.0002410347,
0.0108953975,
-0.0223001707,
0.0699431226,
0.0318021253,
-0.032423377,
-0.0647583306,
-0.0526775122,
0.0056456081,
0.0185878407,
0.0135129252,
-0.0074424986,
0.047219824,
-0.0004300601,
-0.076354973,
0.0192351341,
0.0124286497,
0.0145036681,
-0.0220915563,
0.0128000146,
-0.0188498069,
0.0651995838,
0.0088752825,
0.0193171855,
0.0144640813,
-0.0723460764,
0.0253028665,
-0.0019576582,
0.0504512489,
-0.0239180513,
-0.0675627217,
0.0047719455,
0.0747737437,
-0.0097372048,
0.0262782387,
0.0475298613,
0.0596832782,
-0.0173524842,
-0.0287634246,
-0.072648339,
0.0174679589,
0.0135197751,
-0.0168701541,
-0.0300811473,
-0.0357134193,
-0.0316933729,
0.0083220806,
-0.0435937904,
-0.0318166204,
-0.0435402766,
0.0324219204,
-0.0196726583,
-0.0266106203,
-0.0423944667,
-0.0301117711,
-0.0088682044,
-0.0103631169,
0.009848495,
1.992720982e-34,
0.021047784,
-0.0663456768,
0.0260889791,
0.0011237644,
-0.0400975011,
-0.0057386211,
0.0251723155,
-0.0000955721,
0.0395661555,
0.0182161666,
-0.0239753947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08092v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08092v2 | Product Question Answering in E-Commerce: A Survey | 2023-02-16T05:09:41 | 2023-05-03T07:29:41 | Yang Deng, Wenxuan Zhang, Qian Yu, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Product question answering (PQA), aiming to automatically provide instant
responses to customer's questions in E-Commerce platforms, has drawn increasing
attention in recent years. Compared with typical QA problems, PQA exhibits
unique challenges such as the subjectivity and reliability of user-generated
contents in E-commerce platforms. Therefore, various problem settings and novel
methods have been proposed to capture these special characteristics. In this
paper, we aim to systematically review existing research efforts on PQA.
Specifically, we categorize PQA studies into four problem settings in terms of
the form of provided answers. We analyze the pros and cons, as well as present
existing datasets and evaluation protocols for each setting. We further
summarize the most significant challenges that characterize PQA from general QA
applications and discuss their corresponding solutions. Finally, we conclude
this paper by providing the prospect on several future directions. | [
0.0812899321,
-0.0153890923,
-0.0317187086,
0.0265861116,
-0.0419741124,
-0.0254469272,
0.0339182615,
-0.0384988151,
-0.0142168021,
-0.0649377629,
-0.0034734397,
-0.0166450795,
-0.0121165337,
0.0594437942,
-0.0136657227,
-0.0058297659,
-0.0224535652,
0.0176659245,
-0.020401882,
0.0145255383,
0.0404538624,
0.0301068183,
-0.0400940962,
-0.0024931321,
0.0107510705,
-0.0380487405,
-0.0235924181,
-0.0102671785,
0.0189579614,
-0.0293164067,
0.0496493615,
0.0344484933,
-0.0300552379,
-0.0613624267,
0.0000017788,
-0.0916295573,
-0.0091861943,
-0.0079202726,
-0.06022349,
-0.0056276927,
0.0048229885,
0.0695830137,
0.0450141579,
0.0461113825,
-0.0542477146,
0.0104196286,
0.0457467921,
0.0600473732,
0.0439407341,
0.0187112521,
-0.0380458683,
-0.0046960274,
-0.0079816766,
0.0209354907,
0.0299180485,
-0.0529902242,
0.0357863754,
-0.0298024993,
0.0344953537,
0.0084576057,
0.0116128176,
0.0059850295,
-0.0048066573,
0.0142681384,
0.0179803465,
-0.0016443647,
-0.0308477599,
0.0010550484,
-0.0402168185,
0.1189513206,
0.0329840668,
-0.000989662,
-0.015698636,
0.0086590759,
0.011844893,
0.0110869585,
-0.0188083928,
-0.0036018626,
-0.0181992725,
-0.0498329401,
-0.0529558659,
0.0571971796,
-0.0268291682,
-0.0245780367,
0.0095744133,
0.0549372993,
0.0177453086,
-0.0449427329,
-0.0145654585,
-0.0246453863,
-0.0323434994,
-0.054162275,
0.0175534151,
0.0489062294,
-0.0250335447,
0.011899245,
0.0189361647,
0.0245885123,
0.0315189473,
-0.0897779241,
0.0174740274,
-0.0131497653,
0.0158636738,
0.0344258733,
-0.0317618512,
0.0458692312,
0.0181367211,
-0.0438039899,
-0.0799377486,
0.0007163883,
-0.0322033763,
-0.0347102284,
-0.0394104645,
0.0456083342,
-0.0042356318,
-0.0081926882,
-0.0396882854,
-0.0102072442,
0.0022609849,
-0.0159257483,
-0.0054248399,
0.0626122132,
-0.005241645,
0.0068488494,
-0.0603331253,
0.0083493385,
-0.0810564607,
0.0386715941,
-0.0774089247,
-0.0417265445,
0.026011033,
0.0381902903,
0.0414166674,
-0.0172614399,
0.0046557351,
0.0207045209,
0.0088644717,
-0.0377489105,
-0.0770130977,
-0.0394152701,
-0.0106787281,
-0.024520969,
-0.045618657,
-0.0464429557,
0.0299501456,
0.0241843276,
-0.0416972563,
0.0200794674,
0.0022685833,
0.0363072082,
0.023288792,
0.0852047503,
-0.0176446829,
0.0172441024,
0.039246019,
-0.0209789053,
0.0413989276,
0.0081344582,
0.0036163027,
0.0262744855,
0.0730601698,
0.0232023783,
0.0659677982,
0.0039431797,
-0.0033083539,
-0.0362819135,
0.0071284017,
0.1150753647,
-0.0348319635,
-0.0181179419,
0.0118794013,
0.0367923751,
0.0171675459,
-0.0261737518,
0.0493406802,
0.0686032996,
-0.043592751,
0.016550025,
0.0004362199,
0.0336587615,
0.0236095004,
-0.0029865454,
0.0436834469,
0.0343585461,
-0.0138732754,
-0.0209916066,
0.01281502,
-0.0216525849,
-0.0382421874,
-0.0612959936,
0.0048974981,
-0.0294817798,
0.0092540747,
0.0678468421,
0.0077676997,
0.0100487834,
-0.0175189022,
-0.0047731479,
-0.0282122828,
-0.0202722736,
-0.0237522218,
-0.0161234085,
0.0901427716,
0.0694106668,
0.0365508273,
-0.0103431204,
-0.003102408,
0.0010585616,
-0.0218246952,
0.0162926223,
0.0167682767,
-0.0388730504,
-0.005972323,
-0.0055616368,
-0.0030062618,
-0.0166267026,
-0.0249518026,
0.0116825774,
0.0316050015,
-0.0036822781,
0.0129378084,
0.0074543096,
0.0368128382,
0.0048526912,
0.02098337,
-0.0482077524,
0.0455968715,
0.0095065003,
0.0208796896,
0.0335772187,
0.0120232683,
0.023316903,
0.0243607461,
-0.0368557237,
-0.0711654648,
0.011292682,
0.0328181684,
-0.0145071177,
0.0392511263,
-0.0404913574,
-0.0054114801,
0.0264724027,
0.0039763544,
-0.0372428149,
-0.0353124961,
-0.0368119664,
-0.0017692918,
-0.0668709502,
-0.0431954376,
0.0062963418,
0.0173598509,
-0.0545287803,
0.0454666838,
0.048050072,
0.0316688083,
-0.0097479988,
-0.0351898484,
0.02666899,
-0.0128676929,
0.0080124736,
0.0016988288,
-0.0069741332,
0.0328333192,
0.0139494352,
-0.0264121015,
-0.0388337262,
0.0460480265,
-0.0830237046,
-0.0020615249,
0.007774746,
0.0328454599,
0.022462368,
0.0298794508,
-0.012160616,
-0.0378614515,
-0.0780167133,
0.0038378818,
0.0119081922,
0.0221504495,
0.0725996941,
0.0294381119,
0.0104309907,
-0.0341092348,
0.0054255691,
0.0206303429,
0.0410619006,
0.0408464111,
0.0047260639,
-0.0566591918,
-0.0193306133,
-0.0588064529,
-0.0070300209,
0.0323393382,
-0.0271904599,
-0.0581916943,
0.0040253107,
0.0306429304,
0.0439117625,
0.0355017819,
-0.0664190874,
0.0157874711,
0.0040815524,
-0.0305737816,
-0.0136964479,
-0.0477639996,
-0.0369955823,
0.0366265289,
-0.0298716538,
0.0602120906,
0.0251216721,
-0.0125878574,
-0.0182628892,
-0.0193228275,
0.0488597825,
-0.0055994713,
-0.0084847538,
-0.0492115766,
-0.0102488874,
-0.0049472223,
0.0932241827,
0.0133000258,
-0.0188988354,
0.0785702989,
0.001478047,
-0.0018585149,
-0.0612680204,
0.0042987848,
-0.0818313062,
0.0181052405,
-0.0246243626,
0.0385500379,
-0.0415406637,
-0.028355686,
-0.0178953018,
-0.0021929808,
0.0361656509,
-0.0303735193,
-0.0002969703,
-0.0051649543,
0.0418032035,
-0.0417464264,
-0.0449761637,
-0.0277266521,
-0.0730247274,
0.0173147842,
-0.0235392079,
0.0128723914,
-0.0138415731,
-0.0141168311,
0.0600778572,
-0.0013978721,
-0.0032270127,
-0.0269726329,
-0.0270699337,
0.0053330376,
0.0546837971,
0.0705155358,
0.0302151274,
0.0441156775,
0.0355726779,
0.0004128865,
0.0519927181,
0.003979872,
0.0139794638,
-0.0019774032,
-0.0284017771,
0.0058553247,
-0.0562017113,
0.0439624712,
0.0417484678,
-0.0142945396,
0.0000549399,
0.0263236407,
0.0686090514,
0.0523080193,
-0.0102823824,
-0.0168282893,
0.0121148899,
-0.0340816267,
0.0244395118,
0.0475275479,
-0.0508234501,
-0.0112053799,
-0.0352886841,
0.0721444115,
-0.0095690731,
0.0002426482,
-0.0250793565,
-0.1239096895,
0.0040562893,
-0.0399017073,
0.0260335431,
-0.059220925,
-0.0209695268,
-0.0009317672,
-0.0115636606,
0.0559893548,
0.0062701595,
-0.0402593277,
0.0245158616,
0.0141008943,
-0.0232634377,
0.0193275847,
0.0453486256,
-0.0248033665,
-0.00371772,
0.0684365332,
-0.0227760822,
0.0039989748,
0.0003494289,
-0.0360819772,
-0.0493940413,
-0.0431038663,
0.0452589132,
0.0228616111,
0.0324125923,
0.0046641114,
-0.0027796691,
0.0253216308,
-0.0375555381,
0.0372462384,
0.0592458509,
0.0069977785,
0.0288744848,
-0.0140964063,
-0.0208134204,
0.0086490735,
-0.0321702622,
0.0711329356,
0.000676078,
-0.0688969493,
-0.0592546239,
-0.0041690394,
-0.0070264451,
-0.0482686423,
-0.0499677695,
-0.0081693735,
0.0366669334,
-0.0032037734,
-0.1166925505,
-0.0371936746,
0.0460459329,
0.0106890108,
0.0055304109,
-0.0363027751,
0.0211656243,
0.0633866563,
-0.007417059,
-0.0099669639,
-0.0042698896,
0.0179319084,
-0.0410928801,
0.0689556003,
0.0483535454,
-0.064235419,
-0.0134950038,
-0.0087375427,
-0.0456082039,
-0.0141560463,
-0.0209358092,
0.0362676121,
0.016828483,
-0.0177874546,
-0.0271073114,
-0.0397472717,
-0.0183751676,
0.0676318258,
-0.0343805142,
-0.0125473868,
-0.0042127636,
0.0682846084,
-0.0140653169,
0.0134562766,
-0.0665391758,
0.0136511233,
-0.0311943274,
0.0481205992,
0.0303435754,
-0.0551195964,
0.063432157,
0.0098033566,
-0.0068329838,
0.0491912216,
0.0174631756,
0.0016120286,
0.0613612719,
0.0191155951,
-0.0464955717,
-0.0318193249,
-0.0056746146,
-0.0371198282,
-0.0024579482,
-0.0029600146,
-0.0111132693,
-0.0450595655,
0.0380677506,
-0.0030348024,
-0.0058167293,
0.0315468349,
-0.018140845,
-0.0140411947,
-0.0017359868,
-0.0219435897,
-0.0054047853,
0.02165634,
0.0448209941,
0.0012554735,
0.0293840673,
0.0067768283,
-0.0119087184,
-0.0405559726,
0.0157016199,
-0.021525735,
-0.0627023131,
-0.0221956428,
0.0239311103,
0.0083566876,
0.0026468176,
-0.0045251818,
-0.0069220779,
-0.0132594798,
-0.0154743856,
-0.0066266186,
-0.018998608,
0.0084250607,
0.0405993685,
0.0279008523,
-0.0226791427,
0.0301492568,
0.0479131341,
-0.0199387204,
-0.0028036612,
-0.0206548255,
-0.0378136262,
-0.0496361181,
-0.0316519476,
-0.0160748307,
0.0199099556,
-0.0026932713,
-0.0040588076,
-0.0492771827,
-0.0379801169,
0.0035118922,
0.0085389717,
0.0048345467,
0.0220862385,
0.05935058,
0.0755122602,
0.0513272174,
-0.0127512021,
-0.017955916,
0.0166425072,
-0.0573325381,
0.0170984585,
-0.0454360843,
-5.795856079e-33,
0.025098471,
-0.0729889721,
-0.0306502916,
0.0052130469,
0.0365875587,
-0.0072757145,
0.0019244818,
0.0042331968,
0.0199432783,
-0.0043208906,
-0.0090906024,
-0.0093350317,
0.0032200804,
0.0325318202,
0.0065370877,
-0.0815490633,
-0.0062415181,
-0.0165523626,
-0.0195165593,
0.0549012274,
0.0200373996,
-0.0018534645,
-0.0030662692,
0.0271058995,
0.045824606,
-0.0514140129,
-0.0037814495,
0.0639362261,
0.0131271966,
0.0964912176,
-0.021449808,
0.0620467141,
0.0524215437,
-0.0091939541,
0.045310352,
0.0599109493,
-0.0753348395,
-0.0161513109,
-0.0261851847,
-0.016965583,
-0.0641356558,
0.0546546318,
0.0137084005,
-0.0169064272,
0.0361543857,
0.058986064,
0.0540882573,
-0.0251347795,
0.0117574921,
-0.0873024836,
-0.0321057998,
-0.0115753766,
-0.0224203356,
-0.0244146511,
-0.0004262872,
0.0941394791,
-0.0125166979,
-0.0165456012,
-0.0003690512,
0.0133762574,
-0.0255920291,
-0.0009035736,
0.0202378053,
0.0097538214,
-0.0207088832,
-0.0108825564,
0.0068103401,
-0.0175144654,
0.0124170771,
0.0090532955,
-0.0766930506,
-0.0059368596,
0.0840530321,
0.0417363346,
0.0262848344,
0.0782721043,
-0.0153824175,
0.0624719933,
0.060322877,
-0.011087805,
0.0055616875,
-0.0578820929,
-0.0360289514,
-0.0215903018,
-0.0156317838,
0.0729584098,
-0.0712466612,
-0.0091488557,
0.0198273547,
0.0013591823,
-0.0548265241,
-0.0112622678,
0.0089273602,
-0.0413224213,
-0.0589775443,
-0.0292267166,
0.0073002013,
0.0253764596,
0.0461667515,
0.0111605758,
-0.0120965661,
0.085463725,
-0.0155923478,
-0.0372409858,
-0.0403315201,
-0.006831272,
-0.016597081,
-0.0094728069,
-0.0540467538,
0.0190063622,
0.0179533772,
0.0228039119,
-0.0559826605,
0.0211659148,
-0.0017232866,
0.0534134991,
-0.0130932368,
0.0438670181,
-0.0034956911,
0.0133278463,
-0.0431219898,
-0.0332370736,
-0.0035170354,
-0.0025871294,
-0.0217680726,
0.0080972128,
-0.0261315182,
0.0531413779,
-0.0509278327,
-0.0441041067,
-0.0097431717,
0.0273204204,
2.451e-7,
0.0377567187,
0.0013836958,
0.0079200901,
0.0608343147,
0.0233020205,
0.0123000359,
0.0412133522,
0.0450158939,
0.0066343704,
-0.0220408347,
0.0352291837,
-0.0048658792,
0.0064606094,
0.0308919698,
-0.0841051936,
-0.0330385007,
-0.0581940189,
0.0015729649,
-0.0511118062,
-0.0074268323,
0.0875555202,
0.0251935478,
-0.0086869439,
0.0162973776,
-0.0258284993,
-0.0134202754,
0.0299533326,
0.0070828316,
0.0384029225,
0.0321966223,
0.0408338718,
0.0053636143,
-0.0093633197,
-0.0180773921,
0.0098744333,
0.0230795499,
0.0082886945,
0.0065618162,
0.0578469783,
-0.0864595324,
-0.0329961516,
-0.0313710794,
0.0340934508,
-0.0566680618,
0.0854341984,
-0.0738342553,
-0.0176978335,
-0.0308859497,
-0.0104626874,
-0.0128003899,
-0.0116168596,
-0.0086303987,
-0.015462121,
0.0345448963,
0.0213483945,
-0.0209507365,
0.007744743,
-0.0329816975,
0.0164682195,
-0.0020241758,
-0.0197778717,
-0.0224106126,
0.0057309167,
0.0314501114,
-0.0078341989,
-0.027253028,
0.0296198912,
1.811155663e-34,
0.0342705101,
0.0048816605,
-0.0150226392,
0.0297273789,
0.0001127387,
-0.0242276657,
0.0169314314,
-0.0433137231,
0.0413663313,
-0.0736359507,
0.0001345025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08091v1 | Do We Still Need Clinical Language Models? | 2023-02-16T05:08:34 | 2023-02-16T05:08:34 | Eric Lehman, Evan Hernandez, Diwakar Mahajan, Jonas Wulff, Micah J. Smith, Zachary Ziegler, Daniel Nadler, Peter Szolovits, Alistair Johnson, Emily Alsentzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although recent advances in scaling large language models (LLMs) have
resulted in improvements on many NLP tasks, it remains unclear whether these
models trained primarily with general web text are the right tool in highly
specialized, safety critical domains such as clinical text. Recent results have
suggested that LLMs encode a surprising amount of medical knowledge. This
raises an important question regarding the utility of smaller domain-specific
language models. With the success of general-domain LLMs, is there still a need
for specialized clinical models? To investigate this question, we conduct an
extensive empirical analysis of 12 language models, ranging from 220M to 175B
parameters, measuring their performance on 3 different clinical tasks that test
their ability to parse and reason over electronic health records. As part of
our experiments, we train T5-Base and T5-Large models from scratch on clinical
notes from MIMIC III and IV to directly investigate the efficiency of clinical
tokens. We show that relatively small specialized clinical models substantially
outperform all in-context learning approaches, even when finetuned on limited
annotated data. Further, we find that pretraining on clinical tokens allows for
smaller, more parameter-efficient models that either match or outperform much
larger language models trained on general text. We release the code and the
models used under the PhysioNet Credentialed Health Data license and data use
agreement. | [
0.0566564128,
0.0470778793,
0.0175107028,
-0.0166521333,
-0.0141194966,
0.0393957458,
0.0260021333,
0.0352896266,
-0.0080436394,
-0.0429344438,
-0.0299150888,
-0.0871826857,
-0.0015120151,
0.0340972953,
0.0194008388,
-0.0505580939,
0.0329867527,
-0.0078594862,
0.0273531899,
0.0158074163,
-0.0194096304,
0.0190548208,
-0.0096216537,
0.068061769,
0.0213069059,
-0.0045793522,
0.0313504525,
0.0164838284,
-0.0015113584,
-0.0686004907,
0.0063674711,
0.0434367806,
0.0150625166,
0.003349242,
0.0000019315,
-0.0261414275,
-0.0010184158,
0.0377025492,
-0.0615041889,
-0.0097092297,
0.0651239306,
-0.0689607635,
-0.0049015246,
0.0269916039,
-0.0258221738,
-0.0701766312,
0.0234104451,
0.0591185801,
0.0399916172,
0.085937418,
-0.0232101232,
-0.00965585,
0.0513814762,
-0.0393153168,
-0.0090341447,
-0.049360387,
0.0527828373,
0.0218561627,
0.0379474498,
0.012701462,
0.0128340395,
0.031494759,
-0.0026578249,
0.0358728021,
-0.0026681423,
0.0473923348,
-0.0188370291,
-0.0237733442,
0.0007628918,
0.0667325258,
-0.030914953,
-0.0073820706,
0.0311713293,
0.0042608604,
-0.0270681046,
-0.0077184909,
-0.0390238725,
0.0362853855,
-0.017148694,
0.0015814843,
0.0336920246,
-0.0103191799,
0.0554636456,
0.0138213374,
-0.0261799116,
-0.0179700591,
0.0049173823,
-0.0234945323,
0.0173663944,
0.0001261057,
-0.0450445116,
-0.0360564142,
0.0420487076,
0.0237386525,
-0.0318364874,
0.0227458831,
-0.034333501,
-0.0130062476,
0.0803358331,
-0.0583991855,
0.0319765732,
-0.0019672052,
-0.0064327633,
0.0427386686,
-0.0168325566,
-0.0039003671,
-0.0477157943,
0.0602766201,
-0.0353828594,
0.0029979981,
-0.025339257,
-0.0109244213,
-0.0228286069,
0.0124536976,
-0.0231349114,
-0.0219724793,
-0.0500349253,
0.0006025419,
0.0241042282,
0.024501428,
0.0296370909,
0.0215647798,
-0.0271885991,
-0.0240720268,
0.0195363518,
0.0168254264,
0.0171861369,
0.0151858376,
-0.0065937154,
-0.0804414451,
-0.0011072126,
-0.0137436949,
0.0080850311,
-0.0343759134,
0.0237020068,
0.066733703,
0.0229818448,
-0.0340843126,
-0.006707056,
-0.03000498,
-0.0513931103,
-0.0274429303,
-0.0039854716,
-0.0509036221,
0.0178236701,
0.0306132827,
0.0187562499,
-0.0558192022,
0.0189539809,
0.0228703748,
-0.0662531853,
0.069209598,
-0.043516323,
0.0065264022,
-0.0127208624,
0.0361572206,
-0.0123286955,
0.029616015,
0.0293180067,
-0.0382906459,
-0.0128758363,
-0.0263550095,
-0.0065811356,
0.0093378741,
0.0220171772,
-0.0434376784,
-0.0195093527,
0.0190030131,
0.0196254775,
0.0675047413,
-0.0223131925,
0.0786340311,
-0.0133530851,
-0.0271486696,
0.0464226827,
0.0739879608,
0.0236431323,
0.0107771885,
0.0172389224,
-0.0231357682,
0.0203637462,
-0.0487497747,
-0.0393032879,
-0.0290917903,
0.0263713039,
0.0025335168,
-0.0425479971,
-0.0201423168,
-0.0279084872,
-0.0290258713,
-0.0737170279,
-0.0275016315,
-0.0148421284,
0.0065457304,
0.0593336597,
-0.0236421321,
-0.0327707231,
0.0578115508,
0.0395714566,
-0.0396965779,
-0.0008790751,
-0.0573151112,
-0.0293174926,
0.0632750392,
0.052461829,
-0.0294661,
-0.0388409384,
-0.0374249369,
0.0366130248,
0.0180523209,
0.0471610203,
-0.0137552749,
0.024511693,
-0.054833822,
-0.0008568313,
0.0093409577,
0.0181016643,
-0.0613462999,
0.0122278994,
0.0141078476,
-0.0125004128,
-0.0551521108,
-0.0484873988,
0.0585745983,
-0.0771095902,
-0.010373842,
-0.0134577956,
-0.0117433239,
0.0223727785,
0.00608001,
-0.0164121129,
0.0424831994,
0.0308636986,
-0.039410349,
-0.0085882917,
-0.0191907361,
-0.0703958496,
-0.0286491811,
0.0166679453,
0.0017324528,
0.0099082896,
-0.0057268017,
-0.0295276158,
-0.0041685426,
-0.0470348559,
-0.0564646572,
0.0580831207,
0.0068634902,
0.0176549125,
0.0190574825,
-0.0052668387,
-0.056337785,
0.0233696569,
-0.0137583204,
-0.0048609101,
-0.0016380387,
-0.0230966061,
-0.0087463027,
-0.0093621165,
-0.0299442448,
0.0029170311,
-0.0126997186,
0.0074097849,
-0.0454342254,
-0.0038310168,
-0.0201678835,
-0.0376302004,
-0.1124834865,
-0.00129996,
-0.0082195811,
0.010391755,
0.0326864757,
0.0369599946,
0.0010906144,
-0.0184473116,
-0.0164999068,
-0.0477397442,
0.000802348,
0.0413978435,
0.028224783,
0.0399306193,
-0.0000552146,
-0.028883554,
-0.0307565797,
-0.0426636562,
0.0438358746,
-0.0029440438,
-0.0181566197,
-0.001710017,
0.026116671,
-0.0027714064,
-0.0046838471,
-0.008670737,
-0.0078260899,
0.008711216,
-0.0235375892,
0.0074859378,
0.064497292,
-0.0025318663,
0.0490028672,
0.025457358,
0.0164021514,
-0.034123145,
0.0137151834,
-0.0206032116,
-0.0276198946,
-0.0211226586,
-0.0227646306,
-0.0043350072,
0.0914715305,
0.0130537869,
0.0129531557,
-0.0433904715,
-0.0222111642,
-0.0252793673,
0.0260558445,
-0.0282666963,
0.000764939,
-0.0412989818,
0.0433450937,
-0.0088863987,
-0.0285775326,
0.0747855902,
-0.0056133969,
0.0268689618,
-0.054552678,
-0.0264021661,
-0.0437420122,
0.0234738141,
-0.0029257103,
0.0156866908,
0.0190117955,
-0.0384535119,
0.0152803753,
0.0197299346,
-0.013905976,
-0.0672167689,
0.0768718496,
-0.0293109994,
0.0358082317,
-0.0091419537,
-0.0718914643,
-0.0454735309,
-0.0267511886,
-0.0460526571,
0.0009757815,
-0.0149164842,
0.0145826358,
-0.0594843589,
0.0344663411,
-0.0128447749,
0.0957262889,
0.026199203,
-0.0105725313,
0.0082389861,
0.0108941719,
0.0302862227,
-0.0038733364,
0.00527272,
-0.0529718399,
0.0444519706,
0.0649754629,
0.0324005149,
0.0179163236,
-0.0186616033,
-0.0007116186,
0.0162281282,
-0.0345566832,
-0.025455229,
0.0373470932,
0.0385000743,
-0.0832162052,
-0.0142412633,
0.1185748875,
0.0161827076,
-0.0523426048,
0.0279139429,
-0.0094872359,
-0.0225292332,
-0.0256908108,
-0.0088602938,
-0.042784743,
-0.0505833998,
0.0145802405,
0.0232553016,
0.0121545391,
-0.034123674,
0.0339965746,
-0.0350805894,
0.0158859603,
0.0167143848,
-0.0210425388,
-0.0111546088,
-0.0387486331,
0.0030245809,
-0.0444321707,
0.0240191594,
0.0042955531,
-0.0442108214,
-0.0141798938,
0.013354348,
-0.0483919531,
-0.1108022705,
0.03667631,
-0.0252826158,
0.0536946878,
0.0468108431,
0.0104461284,
-0.007449552,
-0.0378495939,
0.0552529842,
0.0035016944,
0.0183708668,
-0.0080426717,
0.0863683522,
-0.0069756522,
-0.0067611476,
-0.0346454941,
0.0276250355,
-0.0532974377,
-0.0428531729,
-0.0453928597,
0.0734278709,
-0.0353431888,
-0.0350814201,
-0.0326697789,
0.0030001721,
-0.0105845993,
0.0691010803,
0.0057290639,
-0.020514749,
-0.0444187149,
0.0284445044,
0.0333908983,
-0.010465147,
-0.0412116833,
0.0292899348,
0.01106943,
-0.0172291864,
-0.0467832685,
-0.0099089677,
0.0403420068,
-0.0056972504,
-0.0024802098,
0.0306151211,
0.0217344761,
0.0107444962,
-0.0669426769,
0.0870386288,
0.0126591614,
0.0054715201,
-0.0770186186,
-0.014030979,
0.0560061932,
0.0027763466,
-0.0239927322,
-0.0070182499,
-0.0526271611,
-0.009743209,
0.0149523662,
0.022269452,
0.0203026142,
0.0025961895,
-0.0057281852,
-0.0269830506,
0.0316364504,
0.0307503548,
-0.0590031072,
-0.0564312041,
0.0009321807,
-0.0267460812,
0.0030325798,
0.0281892121,
-0.0241278037,
0.0196023639,
0.0318311304,
0.0438093953,
0.0048036724,
-0.0011232571,
0.0173910782,
0.0233030394,
0.0328847691,
-0.0097519467,
-0.0166711286,
0.0012920776,
0.0061056954,
-0.0069277287,
0.0385486782,
-0.0231728572,
0.0177849308,
0.0319896564,
0.0042874315,
-0.033691857,
0.0048484625,
-0.0329869464,
-0.0092508253,
-0.0393335409,
0.043958094,
0.0006630063,
-0.0040418478,
0.0748968795,
-0.0309290048,
-0.0276397057,
0.024413297,
-0.0095487889,
0.0068417923,
-0.0220679715,
0.0459219478,
-0.0065389057,
0.037727084,
-0.0084144399,
0.0739183724,
-0.059389051,
-0.0386713482,
-0.0355909131,
0.0013442248,
0.0375399441,
-0.012022973,
0.0367220268,
-0.0324568562,
0.0118956799,
-0.0345712565,
0.0346641131,
-0.007284672,
0.0090018949,
0.0542817675,
0.0257815961,
-0.0191077683,
-0.012677718,
0.1114965007,
0.0271358788,
0.0765919015,
0.0065328572,
-0.0186440889,
-0.0374822244,
-0.0184142161,
0.0205900967,
0.0097027607,
-0.0725091845,
0.0145396665,
-0.0617013946,
-0.0614427477,
0.0349625275,
-0.031863343,
-0.0303973295,
-0.0077847689,
0.0310629867,
0.0473569036,
0.0234361049,
-0.0230678897,
-0.0027788274,
0.0476791002,
0.0135927973,
-0.0152774649,
0.009946744,
-5.842129047e-33,
0.0349550955,
0.0061816452,
0.005916554,
-0.0150462827,
-0.006435337,
0.0384757183,
-0.0409819856,
-0.0145733822,
-0.0243077166,
0.0178004727,
-0.0319100842,
0.0119052809,
0.0130311558,
0.046202831,
0.0133148273,
-0.0348411761,
0.028147066,
0.0002899752,
-0.0060411668,
0.0292822476,
-0.0145765124,
0.0549750626,
0.0453271121,
-0.060249988,
0.00882365,
0.0126700075,
0.0307480562,
0.0095593696,
-0.0259404313,
0.07462053,
-0.0377288498,
0.0225895476,
0.0607101284,
-0.0192888416,
-0.0246146973,
0.0097063687,
-0.0882097185,
0.0246686712,
0.0056325826,
-0.0187463649,
-0.0385440253,
-0.0373339579,
0.0840200186,
-0.0061699073,
-0.0224189684,
-0.0146324383,
0.0006584938,
-0.0304028168,
-0.0238211136,
-0.0361657552,
-0.0260848776,
0.0525516421,
0.0137742888,
0.0088297985,
0.0082427468,
-0.0002989199,
-0.0451533645,
0.0523520224,
-0.0246753097,
-0.0237306133,
0.003896056,
0.0236805566,
0.0093103275,
-0.0312924236,
-0.0276856869,
0.0638824329,
-0.0020192552,
0.0067157694,
-0.0423697792,
0.0076436345,
-0.0059804977,
0.0507387035,
0.0473021306,
0.019822523,
0.0312370509,
-0.0268139672,
-0.10908176,
0.0172122587,
-0.0617294349,
0.0680242702,
0.0444630831,
-0.0199673735,
-0.0509151258,
-0.0028630609,
-0.0229096692,
0.0141073866,
-0.0224526934,
-0.0202049166,
0.036373809,
0.0128144585,
0.0077886214,
0.0274293758,
0.0077816527,
-0.0309251137,
-0.0060248813,
-0.0000195993,
0.0569344275,
0.0095464606,
-0.0490812622,
0.0063077305,
-0.0625643209,
-0.0219428986,
0.0171108842,
0.0029023418,
0.0435046107,
-0.0064741592,
0.0395797938,
-0.0223103501,
-0.0716006905,
-0.0278008208,
0.0039425585,
-0.0059693949,
0.0073136501,
0.0606749803,
0.0786459893,
0.0264704134,
0.0043214974,
0.0553677827,
-0.0271399431,
-0.0230678078,
-0.0318597965,
-0.0231899321,
0.0035104048,
0.003500629,
-0.0260235239,
-0.0118156038,
-0.0376110971,
0.0470284671,
0.0372557454,
-0.0321547464,
-0.0139524974,
-0.000409074,
2.64e-7,
0.1088653728,
0.0717362761,
0.0190896336,
-0.0298245903,
0.0387260467,
0.0201924387,
0.0007881679,
0.0058548492,
-0.0033469098,
-0.0074775326,
0.0190659426,
0.0054973271,
0.0848862007,
0.0342626609,
-0.059103027,
-0.0164400581,
-0.1101722047,
-0.0195203554,
-0.0271024425,
-0.0158470962,
0.0499586649,
0.096842587,
-0.0436606184,
-0.0459871218,
0.0088531822,
-0.027418619,
0.0504237711,
-0.0463471785,
0.0066521172,
0.033569552,
-0.0043310565,
0.0171083976,
0.0231898166,
0.053983096,
-0.0246992838,
0.0027585875,
0.0025058871,
0.1356083602,
-0.0581719093,
0.0374400318,
0.0179924648,
-0.0236197803,
0.0283064693,
-0.0539858676,
0.067840524,
-0.0689207464,
-0.0332408436,
-0.0056787953,
-0.0199887548,
-0.0233563241,
0.0337237082,
-0.0186869837,
-0.016199084,
0.0465297401,
0.0193714816,
-0.0001504107,
-0.0395145118,
-0.0880508572,
-0.0343480036,
0.0424058326,
-0.0274834912,
-0.0177495033,
0.0161523577,
-0.0077630598,
0.0262348857,
-0.0818028748,
-0.0010147154,
2.613073662e-34,
0.0271949079,
-0.0187517162,
0.0138141839,
0.0451914743,
0.0128456885,
0.005190033,
0.0278475881,
0.0138488198,
-0.0038841518,
-0.0889052674,
0.0053792936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08088v1 | TAPLoss: A Temporal Acoustic Parameter Loss for Speech Enhancement | 2023-02-16T04:57:11 | 2023-02-16T04:57:11 | Yunyang Zeng, Joseph Konan, Shuo Han, David Bick, Muqiao Yang, Anurag Kumar, Shinji Watanabe, Bhiksha Raj | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech enhancement models have greatly progressed in recent years, but still
show limits in perceptual quality of their speech outputs. We propose an
objective for perceptual quality based on temporal acoustic parameters. These
are fundamental speech features that play an essential role in various
applications, including speaker recognition and paralinguistic analysis. We
provide a differentiable estimator for four categories of low-level acoustic
descriptors involving: frequency-related parameters, energy or
amplitude-related parameters, spectral balance parameters, and temporal
features. Unlike prior work that looks at aggregated acoustic parameters or a
few categories of acoustic parameters, our temporal acoustic parameter (TAP)
loss enables auxiliary optimization and improvement of many fine-grain speech
characteristics in enhancement workflows. We show that adding TAPLoss as an
auxiliary objective in speech enhancement produces speech with improved
perceptual quality and intelligibility. We use data from the Deep Noise
Suppression 2020 Challenge to demonstrate that both time-domain models and
time-frequency domain models can benefit from our method. | [
-0.0328226425,
0.0912347361,
0.0392170399,
0.0076417262,
0.0235598646,
-0.032428313,
0.0358704068,
-0.0147980768,
-0.05711836,
0.0423852876,
-0.0491600037,
-0.0198535435,
0.0381963961,
0.0251937546,
0.014255085,
-0.0967400894,
0.0181202181,
-0.0279538073,
0.0339305364,
-0.0174786374,
0.0210719332,
-0.0212854166,
-0.0400810018,
0.0244093481,
-0.0329448059,
0.0023938993,
-0.0200859383,
0.025853144,
0.0205730572,
-0.0061084973,
0.0078643989,
0.0008266938,
-0.0082652643,
-0.0236059129,
0.0000021112,
-0.0139124719,
-0.0390018634,
0.0267347824,
-0.066310741,
0.0485027842,
0.0188647322,
0.0560265705,
-0.0441835523,
-0.0001802762,
0.0127305156,
-0.0207088273,
0.0553466231,
0.0255896784,
0.0157839898,
0.044420857,
-0.0020953908,
-0.0051557203,
0.0103854779,
-0.003643516,
-0.0083374688,
-0.0218850058,
-0.0286797117,
-0.0570399426,
-0.0138444602,
-0.0206994843,
0.0157830361,
0.0451829582,
0.0148935942,
-0.0013741823,
0.0896058381,
-0.0026188225,
-0.0098103378,
-0.0060337353,
0.0009104013,
0.0647056326,
0.0242399629,
-0.0105907321,
0.0074849552,
0.0090596834,
-0.0158580001,
-0.0642779022,
0.011635079,
-0.0766618773,
0.0938064083,
-0.0237317253,
-0.0674562603,
0.0684374347,
0.0389142334,
0.0194753036,
0.0366986059,
0.0069736969,
-0.0023066069,
-0.0397271886,
0.0076416,
-0.0471911989,
-0.0176097583,
0.0153890802,
0.044509951,
0.0215783846,
0.001054214,
-0.0536825769,
-0.0062108724,
-0.0583639555,
-0.0526604243,
-0.0109307393,
0.0207817424,
0.0317026116,
-0.0457311273,
0.001301421,
0.0087656835,
0.0100010289,
0.0185862444,
-0.0220755506,
-0.0183600839,
-0.0053767497,
0.0260363072,
0.0306750908,
-0.0232640151,
0.0513659716,
-0.0160757322,
0.0167995654,
-0.0271863546,
-0.0248095132,
-0.0737462863,
-0.0077133873,
-0.0040417886,
0.0559612326,
-0.0518642142,
-0.0423365161,
0.0145926671,
0.0154180666,
0.0243466794,
0.0466432981,
-0.0108524906,
-0.052557081,
-0.0310589299,
0.0227806382,
0.0798382759,
0.0034721354,
0.0337635204,
0.04365547,
-0.0015180175,
0.0197043605,
-0.0490871742,
-0.0337806083,
0.00407749,
0.0021280099,
-0.0427604839,
-0.044280909,
0.018936716,
-0.0436382033,
-0.0108554875,
-0.0344015099,
-0.0024441141,
-0.0585138462,
0.0332954638,
0.0101087727,
-0.0131294969,
0.0082876869,
0.0813395828,
-0.0070110648,
-0.0255537629,
-0.0113698151,
0.0449098758,
-0.0488189124,
-0.0052973717,
-0.043215055,
-0.0430679992,
0.0391414836,
0.0369867533,
0.0264494792,
-0.050857462,
-0.0566948391,
-0.0219846535,
0.0029020309,
0.0611166209,
-0.0122388583,
-0.0273316223,
-0.0189431272,
0.0714575723,
0.0055660289,
0.0402999967,
0.0040997672,
0.0005183853,
0.0069579766,
0.0118940007,
-0.0533167869,
-0.0402914993,
-0.018266039,
-0.0007939489,
-0.0052646031,
0.044857163,
0.0059734904,
-0.0492812954,
-0.0502323657,
0.0456392094,
-0.0430940539,
0.022303341,
0.0349391848,
0.0170887392,
-0.0300391987,
-0.0192726161,
0.0579108261,
0.0062528974,
-0.0459674597,
0.0353243537,
-0.0092461808,
-0.017527042,
0.008703745,
-0.0212901626,
-0.0265826918,
0.0244231299,
-0.0371734388,
0.01528598,
0.0261777658,
0.0071324972,
-0.007136018,
0.1323884428,
-0.0250448007,
-0.0487046279,
0.0140260151,
0.0003027814,
0.0261492729,
-0.0027943512,
0.0024284604,
0.0587149151,
-0.0536681712,
-0.0237088874,
-0.0354081132,
0.0043058777,
-0.0348262005,
0.0215080529,
0.0221654214,
0.0489026345,
0.0432646126,
-0.0219415464,
0.0227600913,
-0.0016854192,
-0.0483039133,
0.0328019112,
0.0522562265,
-0.0460453592,
0.0148457708,
0.0667498186,
0.004714828,
0.0175820254,
0.083652243,
0.0286138635,
-0.0534286313,
0.0899530426,
-0.0429193825,
0.0929773077,
-0.0390759669,
0.0310029984,
0.0082775848,
0.0015899697,
0.0223381221,
-0.0081118522,
0.0054592974,
-0.024716476,
-0.0037044117,
0.0274597425,
-0.0094274385,
-0.0687350854,
-0.0018241557,
-0.0123731084,
-0.027674906,
0.0285973437,
0.0182418674,
-0.0091683408,
-0.0502853021,
0.0296868384,
-0.0512586311,
-0.0068995198,
-0.010566867,
-0.007024134,
-0.0089741405,
0.0156057607,
0.023149725,
-0.0195357371,
0.0017331883,
-0.0361216515,
-0.0449746028,
-0.0097913155,
-0.0436051339,
0.0099334698,
-0.0075871944,
-0.022573011,
0.0037073365,
0.017406797,
0.007209599,
-0.0413743779,
-0.0431449041,
0.0454191975,
0.0074962168,
0.0097874263,
0.0471310429,
0.0363251194,
-0.0225172713,
-0.0482645966,
0.0108011058,
0.0335010849,
0.0553193018,
0.0071807685,
-0.0123531353,
0.0129607869,
0.0065078023,
-0.0569743812,
0.0242637955,
-0.0211429596,
0.057261683,
0.0144393221,
0.015505679,
0.0078425156,
-0.0097226929,
0.0264739729,
0.0315211117,
-0.0302440803,
0.0048058368,
-0.0156429335,
-0.0440699048,
-0.0019677044,
0.015956508,
-0.0353470519,
-0.0039756484,
-0.0339401327,
-0.0121750915,
-0.0039167707,
-0.0428993143,
-0.0183700789,
0.0004398935,
-0.0654679239,
0.0163228959,
-0.048332829,
-0.0165732298,
0.0255316328,
-0.0131782359,
-0.032128375,
-0.0053415205,
-0.0060687205,
0.0588192977,
-0.0536922216,
-0.0090494389,
-0.0154375266,
-0.0093259644,
-0.0054066069,
-0.0025586782,
-0.0199352559,
0.0099646337,
0.0143822031,
-0.0010600293,
-0.0228123479,
-0.0063474094,
-0.0263886936,
-0.0012845084,
0.0221430436,
0.0413873121,
0.0114800604,
0.0210340656,
-0.0171650182,
0.0499356128,
0.0067736576,
0.0472224206,
0.0323263817,
-0.0187209323,
0.0235155169,
-0.0167901479,
0.0913301334,
-0.0242088605,
-0.0695694834,
0.003243817,
0.0166204628,
0.0231944937,
-0.0330092944,
0.0279754847,
0.0798059776,
-0.0700627118,
0.0446450189,
0.0676595643,
-0.0218925923,
-0.02783232,
0.0191295333,
0.0338655785,
0.0261328574,
-0.0220308881,
-0.060942702,
0.0193885956,
-0.0258075316,
0.0513663851,
0.0260009039,
-0.0253627449,
0.0443100743,
-0.0458276235,
-0.0516831651,
0.0349173322,
0.0463673398,
0.0297578499,
-0.0221185368,
-0.0398551337,
0.0145952441,
-0.0303406827,
0.0624875315,
0.0146852424,
0.0391071886,
-0.0372458361,
0.0765109807,
-0.0653647333,
-0.046705734,
-0.0379775167,
-0.0245332364,
0.05356583,
0.0151227983,
-0.0096460069,
-0.0088983644,
-0.0614097156,
0.01872495,
0.0093527576,
-0.0431981236,
-0.0010630677,
0.0308619402,
0.0213636979,
-0.0081400685,
0.0549255051,
0.0744645372,
-0.0021378477,
0.0070052706,
0.0226757843,
0.0363471359,
0.0009375832,
0.0382917747,
-0.0034264703,
0.0315801427,
0.0030965465,
0.0458681956,
0.0111623481,
-0.0279426128,
0.0107150134,
0.0156133259,
0.0219764356,
-0.0543971919,
-0.0133593623,
-0.0234682206,
-0.0015804257,
-0.0907402709,
-0.0154502643,
-0.0285724662,
-0.0723626986,
-0.0049774484,
-0.0129005536,
-0.0081071863,
-0.0296303406,
0.0205465369,
-0.0416186787,
0.0493292138,
-0.0104091242,
0.0363583602,
-0.055984892,
-0.0005671991,
-0.0000962531,
-0.0203125272,
-0.0197863095,
0.0809267312,
-0.0600146018,
-0.0574657694,
-0.0177688617,
-0.0353118256,
0.0038009828,
0.080314748,
-0.01403144,
-0.0625806749,
0.0680163652,
-0.0162392221,
-0.0266471375,
0.0333409086,
0.1261932254,
0.0126314368,
-0.007355161,
0.0529148653,
-0.0613064617,
0.042719122,
-0.013858215,
-0.0233089142,
-0.0103071202,
-0.0271579623,
-0.0128750727,
0.0019971617,
0.0426104292,
0.0238262173,
0.0037656652,
0.0054820175,
0.027138507,
0.0027538941,
0.0191369299,
-0.0360781476,
-0.0111233583,
-0.0014368227,
0.0261563212,
-0.0085107721,
0.0113533642,
0.0210993011,
0.0156524461,
0.0019096429,
0.0590041354,
-0.0347175449,
-0.0406086557,
-0.0119721368,
0.009003425,
0.011394836,
0.0390250944,
0.0264692362,
-0.0074128485,
0.0150489286,
-0.0402426608,
-0.0119155534,
-0.0260562506,
0.0035665079,
0.0127194412,
-0.0357147604,
-0.0086030653,
-0.0081257848,
-0.0184949022,
-0.0142347282,
-0.0241895579,
0.0532267056,
0.0068094567,
-0.0018660733,
-0.0343387537,
-0.0087146796,
0.0119491443,
0.028870156,
-0.0000841968,
-0.0051152762,
0.006684497,
0.0292328596,
0.04787663,
0.0293052178,
0.0305155702,
-0.0244192742,
0.0621263981,
-0.0094899563,
-0.0322293043,
-0.0561029054,
0.0534139685,
-0.0327678882,
-0.000413332,
0.0127548771,
-0.0291484836,
0.0180668961,
-0.0667980388,
0.0250928849,
-0.0070318826,
0.0170947276,
-0.0343726985,
-0.057366997,
-0.007583654,
0.039560657,
-0.0711111501,
0.0279393345,
-0.0141040832,
0.0107906377,
-6.451645643e-33,
0.0073145018,
0.0427794233,
-0.0273335688,
0.0360293277,
-0.0164312515,
0.0418357179,
-0.0383644104,
0.039432209,
-0.0307315048,
0.0013654369,
0.001940476,
0.0060239346,
0.0411157161,
0.0318417363,
-0.0282557458,
0.0149894888,
0.0846354365,
-0.0205050223,
0.0307197813,
0.0116371606,
0.0189487524,
0.0173034798,
0.0261866134,
-0.0502835214,
-0.0584937148,
0.0417902358,
-0.0508134589,
-0.0036032142,
0.0700214356,
0.0061008786,
-0.0007371168,
0.0572485514,
-0.0548050106,
-0.0592722259,
-0.0096778292,
-0.0186322853,
-0.0444264747,
-0.014547606,
-0.0273818579,
0.0139589114,
-0.0552402362,
-0.0839776471,
0.0391599275,
0.0356126502,
-0.0637745559,
-0.061830733,
0.0199452266,
-0.0311946888,
-0.0127089219,
-0.0708938092,
0.036097791,
0.0590471178,
-0.0370051898,
-0.0412007645,
0.0637302175,
0.0428102575,
-0.0372351781,
-0.0152422041,
-0.0839020014,
0.0411910489,
0.0376815982,
0.0254051909,
0.0047883918,
0.0077144485,
-0.0072413287,
-0.0082532475,
0.0414938033,
-0.0189562365,
0.0545177571,
-0.0070460141,
0.0505767912,
0.0368912369,
0.0485534631,
-0.0120847095,
0.0351901352,
-0.0375047103,
-0.0093737636,
0.0383623466,
0.0189622864,
0.045767922,
-0.0194095653,
0.0484813489,
-0.016166389,
0.0089559965,
-0.0727407038,
-0.0432933681,
-0.0399231128,
0.0207544733,
0.010516976,
-0.0093924897,
-0.0169616528,
-0.0362096578,
0.0486977398,
-0.005673144,
0.0500561893,
-0.0004532839,
-0.0380681083,
-0.010291527,
0.0159733333,
-0.0312678739,
-0.014319744,
-0.0102817817,
0.0794333965,
0.0266086459,
0.0156244747,
-0.0845122784,
-0.0372883193,
0.0604121126,
-0.0221428126,
-0.007209382,
-0.0146102374,
0.0244025849,
0.0525038503,
0.0161716826,
0.0361880958,
-0.0345545411,
-0.0078100571,
0.0458467267,
-0.0225293804,
0.0619959012,
0.0185269415,
0.0233627111,
0.0169920977,
0.0292643551,
-0.0353891514,
-0.0023036397,
-0.0028787397,
-0.0839330256,
0.0556039177,
-0.0183479618,
-0.0236516744,
-0.0645138249,
2.991e-7,
-0.0901491567,
-0.0034755124,
0.0168039016,
-0.003452783,
0.03031292,
0.0489263721,
0.0207221601,
-0.0222414024,
-0.0477056764,
-0.0267288275,
0.0206572656,
0.0035395673,
0.0912835449,
0.0283407867,
-0.0143500352,
-0.0823607221,
-0.0528274514,
0.0096839126,
0.0339021534,
-0.0048201811,
-0.0311293118,
0.0433356315,
0.0147793097,
-0.0538708642,
0.0206748955,
-0.0137565928,
0.0386960953,
-0.0249566156,
0.0025212448,
0.0009630111,
0.0642913058,
0.0067880494,
0.0132336663,
0.0035426542,
-0.0700449273,
0.0224731043,
-0.0007773904,
0.0657478422,
-0.0226224605,
-0.1145938709,
-0.007288082,
0.0798352212,
-0.0020408472,
0.0401753709,
0.0793913752,
0.0253594108,
-0.0198660865,
-0.0098502263,
-0.0696763843,
0.017805025,
0.0173402838,
-0.0166694243,
-0.022222003,
-0.0549210235,
-0.0327633731,
-0.0144703072,
-0.0372852311,
-0.033597447,
-0.0275629535,
0.0391194373,
-0.0198722109,
-0.0236767083,
-0.0244433414,
-0.0300269127,
0.0201655962,
-0.0023670325,
0.0034425177,
2.063667117e-34,
0.0170236044,
-0.039073769,
0.0356814563,
-0.0123301689,
-0.0437497087,
-0.0211474113,
0.0088446327,
-0.0262329951,
0.0451737158,
0.004005753,
-0.0066412007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08084v1 | Learning Multi-Object Positional Relationships via Emergent Communication | 2023-02-16T04:44:53 | 2023-02-16T04:44:53 | Yicheng Feng, Boshi An, Zongqing Lu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The study of emergent communication has been dedicated to interactive
artificial intelligence. While existing work focuses on communication about
single objects or complex image scenes, we argue that communicating
relationships between multiple objects is important in more realistic tasks,
but understudied. In this paper, we try to fill this gap and focus on emergent
communication about positional relationships between two objects. We train
agents in the referential game where observations contain two objects, and find
that generalization is the major problem when the positional relationship is
involved. The key factor affecting the generalization ability of the emergent
language is the input variation between Speaker and Listener, which is realized
by a random image generator in our work. Further, we find that the learned
language can generalize well in a new multi-step MDP task where the positional
relationship describes the goal, and performs better than raw-pixel images as
well as pre-trained image features, verifying the strong generalization ability
of discrete sequences. We also show that language transfer from the referential
game performs better in the new task than learning language directly in this
task, implying the potential benefits of pre-training in referential games. All
in all, our experiments demonstrate the viability and merit of having agents
learn to communicate positional relationships between multiple objects through
emergent communication. | [
0.0296290666,
0.0598648749,
-0.0101903286,
0.0140713062,
-0.0107535198,
-0.0091713881,
-0.0036220732,
-0.0085511161,
-0.0416623652,
-0.0278030504,
-0.0077463933,
-0.0050688512,
0.0183262061,
0.0332153477,
0.0235705692,
-0.1014909297,
0.0049802409,
-0.0103413286,
-0.0008091503,
-0.0133483363,
-0.011504814,
-0.0259874538,
-0.0380455814,
0.0386394262,
-0.0600538626,
0.0373464078,
-0.0786925405,
-0.0156089235,
0.0316645764,
-0.0498469844,
-0.0673606917,
0.015833836,
0.0648153275,
-0.0141575094,
0.0000016178,
-0.0338625722,
0.0062724901,
-0.0276563969,
0.004240361,
-0.090027906,
-0.0058464268,
-0.0217858646,
0.0156763047,
-0.0196181983,
-0.0523793846,
-0.0402038544,
0.1047103703,
0.0450041927,
0.064885512,
0.0454535186,
-0.0186419971,
-0.0346540883,
0.0139037436,
0.002624217,
0.049804274,
-0.0466891229,
0.0214712117,
0.0255045705,
0.0446936414,
0.0050547123,
-0.0356066264,
-0.0042433394,
0.0098132584,
0.0060316022,
0.0492427461,
0.0595392548,
0.0071279714,
-0.0486875735,
-0.0321482457,
0.0961168706,
-0.0393562354,
0.0127570396,
0.0171526782,
-0.0004757988,
0.0253970716,
0.0246286038,
-0.0329540335,
0.0135622798,
-0.0072120279,
0.0017807761,
-0.0523174331,
-0.0031069114,
0.0036803582,
-0.0275516231,
0.0002767745,
0.054560665,
-0.0171126984,
-0.0040920386,
-0.0042659747,
0.0151925208,
-0.020161001,
-0.0896304101,
0.0011615821,
0.0173035935,
-0.0599886179,
0.0334826484,
-0.0298845079,
0.0063753836,
-0.0485456251,
-0.048459053,
0.0611489229,
-0.0090390835,
-0.0459947586,
0.0468838848,
-0.0011671663,
0.0644669682,
-0.0139138568,
0.0016674614,
-0.037657328,
0.0124014039,
-0.0513107851,
-0.0087421248,
-0.027605148,
0.0636287704,
-0.0260196496,
-0.037430454,
0.0078514377,
0.0115730148,
-0.0495063625,
0.0413475558,
-0.0261459593,
0.0224832259,
-0.0666085929,
-0.0000703632,
-0.0536578968,
0.0119095687,
-0.0696262047,
0.0329678282,
0.007480043,
-0.0256631337,
-0.0177925378,
0.0031376318,
0.0742663145,
0.0167993587,
-0.0366437435,
0.0903036594,
-0.0472216643,
-0.0302773677,
0.0054172757,
-0.0023510272,
0.0264459234,
-0.0437483005,
0.0733686164,
-0.0385167524,
0.012797988,
-0.0223435126,
-0.0053113573,
-0.0318460092,
0.0339484662,
-0.0129488558,
-0.016543705,
0.1189470813,
-0.0029077311,
0.0077000707,
-0.0022037968,
0.0249252524,
0.0066977586,
0.0593961366,
0.0718595833,
0.0222571976,
0.0051671099,
0.0101812761,
0.0161448121,
0.0300191864,
0.0003224526,
0.0073426119,
0.030297894,
-0.0277736522,
-0.0175317358,
0.0675521865,
0.0002424681,
0.0044923197,
-0.0574792922,
-0.007934574,
0.0444302037,
0.0447146073,
-0.0140890628,
-0.0106905801,
0.0532818474,
0.0322407931,
-0.0474921875,
0.0332553498,
-0.0352873988,
0.0681791604,
0.001858675,
-0.0162021089,
-0.0237701274,
-0.0031788135,
-0.0230085924,
-0.0431303419,
0.0323523283,
-0.0141669381,
0.0466877744,
-0.0184532255,
0.0410751775,
0.0550959371,
-0.0369622037,
0.022903353,
0.02451743,
-0.019271208,
-0.0274925344,
-0.0164469443,
0.0366617627,
0.0295747947,
-0.0180848707,
-0.0342965238,
-0.0156192994,
0.0028332106,
0.0156842116,
0.0548687838,
-0.0178415049,
-0.0296448115,
0.0606132746,
-0.0082596932,
-0.0360489637,
0.0011051411,
-0.003076907,
0.0770250484,
0.0085033821,
-0.0221470427,
-0.0083974507,
0.0206571445,
0.0512391776,
0.0185482726,
0.042905014,
-0.0095020132,
-0.0027316569,
0.0135342227,
0.0302017778,
-0.006879379,
-0.008814496,
0.0037808593,
0.0263380222,
0.003213523,
0.0084072417,
0.0610660836,
-0.0267536175,
-0.0233314112,
0.0135022262,
-0.0556128025,
-0.0023163396,
-0.0133861471,
-0.0204184242,
-0.037073914,
0.0752412677,
-0.0336079821,
0.0126294168,
0.040023908,
-0.0032914265,
0.0283358917,
0.0062539913,
0.0117271692,
0.040863242,
0.0066895024,
-0.0416714065,
-0.0097987438,
0.0273397919,
0.0098318905,
-0.0569856018,
0.0491979383,
0.023941204,
0.0119763575,
0.0025274213,
0.0427104272,
-0.0099932579,
-0.0531861819,
-0.0240574796,
-0.0396616124,
-0.0449187644,
0.009476115,
-0.0291896183,
-0.005677586,
-0.0277867578,
0.0212531872,
-0.0346632972,
-0.0494329482,
0.0681789145,
0.0193713419,
0.0107138725,
0.057284493,
0.0447027609,
-0.0336012281,
-0.0420790091,
0.0143091017,
0.0133850826,
0.0334346667,
0.0541371666,
-0.0253150649,
-0.0648135617,
0.0004718734,
-0.0208863635,
0.0609893352,
-0.0304980278,
0.0058347913,
0.0640009865,
-0.0451863445,
0.0163756832,
0.0722495019,
-0.0334032066,
0.0764513239,
0.0316367745,
-0.0612597913,
-0.0555175133,
0.0186193082,
-0.0198284779,
-0.0071681188,
-0.0598315746,
0.0018559159,
-0.0076593328,
0.0406942368,
-0.0369994789,
-0.0056706551,
-0.0647308826,
0.0180348549,
0.0397104546,
-0.092815198,
-0.0383103862,
-0.0138098784,
-0.0068287784,
0.0319351777,
-0.0477313586,
-0.0061761742,
0.0344927199,
-0.0180860274,
-0.012159883,
0.0138208857,
0.0006945672,
0.0277512427,
0.0934650972,
0.0593768209,
0.016650036,
0.0249952059,
-0.017463576,
-0.0879727826,
-0.0232423376,
0.025299225,
0.022510618,
-0.0020990218,
-0.0985323042,
0.0070672673,
0.0052528596,
-0.0487677045,
-0.0297168586,
0.0435811132,
0.0005571278,
0.0175982639,
-0.0488969311,
-0.0294976234,
-0.0521374531,
-0.0062523093,
0.0285611674,
-0.0084308181,
0.0362956002,
-0.0334915593,
-0.0516603105,
0.0247937907,
0.06802091,
0.0642240271,
-0.0661370382,
-0.0463769101,
-0.0185378827,
0.042432718,
0.0115836123,
-0.0110579459,
-0.0664460883,
0.0394581482,
0.0122214444,
0.0008866621,
-0.0214105267,
0.0548427925,
0.0287056193,
-0.0037955812,
-0.0426114425,
0.0189725906,
0.0072621461,
0.0111435456,
0.0017734119,
0.016829567,
0.0125130294,
0.0131815579,
0.0317721032,
-0.0699960068,
-0.0161515288,
-0.0001818928,
-0.0446419567,
0.0037149328,
-0.0461218394,
-0.0420935787,
-0.1104254276,
0.0057167104,
0.0044832826,
-0.0621472485,
-0.0438256748,
0.0032614027,
0.0007746484,
0.0004080125,
-0.0283379555,
-0.0202486478,
0.0193327852,
0.0144626675,
0.0070262728,
0.0206147619,
-0.0184820555,
-0.0288755875,
-0.0454794057,
0.0381176807,
0.0895748958,
0.0385116711,
-0.0143832983,
-0.0137445079,
-0.016659027,
0.0701740459,
0.0056557367,
0.0031609095,
0.0403383709,
-0.0150550837,
-0.0085090855,
0.046604149,
-0.0019990951,
0.0180771388,
-0.0199985746,
0.0101452162,
0.0396933742,
0.0024984097,
-0.0452154689,
0.0050242874,
0.0383177213,
0.0593293719,
0.0077641984,
0.0002491725,
-0.0287491549,
-0.0202604011,
-0.0381620489,
0.0245953053,
-0.00720585,
-0.0135509474,
-0.015792625,
-0.0094238129,
-0.0332531333,
-0.1233595684,
-0.0369553752,
0.0344385281,
0.0474652499,
0.0192884933,
-0.0331074186,
0.044295352,
0.0333520174,
-0.0098954635,
-0.0159319695,
0.006056923,
-0.0155445058,
0.0161181074,
-0.0544058494,
0.0033059132,
-0.0766297802,
-0.0161281228,
-0.0025910435,
-0.0652927607,
-0.0533976331,
-0.0387438834,
0.0920299515,
0.0236579534,
0.0381708667,
0.004560587,
-0.0498850495,
0.0003383262,
0.0171503611,
0.0227233134,
0.0083030146,
0.0318984687,
-0.007430119,
0.0070174783,
0.0044131917,
-0.0564891919,
0.0279891975,
-0.0060224799,
0.0272174496,
-0.0668335333,
-0.0255368985,
0.014538724,
-0.0214702357,
0.0315076597,
0.0085003525,
0.0155601082,
-0.0223371293,
0.0003790048,
-0.0062014903,
0.0063012363,
-0.0946926773,
0.0196995325,
-0.0000229822,
0.0581043884,
0.0556754433,
-0.0314494856,
0.0101887546,
0.0089592515,
0.0229289494,
-0.022504786,
0.0624143556,
-0.0060179224,
0.0082957391,
0.0271723215,
0.0391976163,
0.0389238223,
-0.0066443724,
0.0657040402,
0.0389814675,
0.0262769163,
0.0473924354,
-0.0395879857,
0.0116669014,
0.0132940747,
-0.0333482027,
-0.0286420956,
0.0192697681,
0.0738577917,
0.0764874071,
0.02682852,
0.0080782985,
-0.0528418124,
0.0302433614,
0.0237985402,
0.0516937077,
0.0172034334,
-0.0809461325,
0.0293647069,
0.0405835174,
0.0109016178,
0.0065261074,
0.068132475,
0.0092465365,
0.023146024,
-0.0575550534,
0.0155296354,
-0.0422615223,
-0.0192200188,
-0.005260725,
0.02684048,
-0.0002590449,
0.0674844757,
0.0308924634,
-0.0237974431,
-0.0238365941,
0.0318863727,
0.0108907055,
-0.0103101628,
0.086691834,
0.0366677381,
-0.0065835561,
-0.0392047837,
-0.0179578923,
-0.0569136553,
0.0040213005,
0.0029803684,
-0.0086316355,
-5.000328522e-33,
-0.0583080761,
-0.076841563,
0.0424614623,
-0.0150130466,
0.0005777332,
-0.0487120003,
-0.0520248003,
-0.0032540108,
-0.001959298,
0.0373987705,
-0.0023985333,
0.0090081003,
0.0109796403,
0.0219072476,
0.0019079224,
-0.0317436308,
0.0329933614,
0.0077259219,
0.0019264044,
-0.0028792447,
0.0376306251,
0.0243565701,
0.0453909077,
-0.0430274345,
0.0033166299,
0.0343847685,
-0.0246660039,
0.0227961708,
-0.0033485645,
0.0159403645,
0.0096604126,
-0.0136063406,
-0.0028126766,
-0.0090601882,
-0.0350886732,
0.0260988679,
-0.0785164312,
-0.0467838757,
-0.0101593249,
0.0343116373,
-0.076438114,
0.0096264631,
0.0243420489,
-0.0230714045,
0.0328840837,
-0.0228663255,
0.0478090681,
-0.0412030965,
-0.031298358,
0.0170561783,
-0.0373303667,
-0.0027582524,
-0.0320576578,
-0.0172234587,
0.0528336428,
0.0047040046,
0.0170672722,
-0.0293247942,
-0.0287593752,
0.0756772906,
0.0241073016,
0.0101607377,
0.0245967638,
0.0468059666,
0.0442289077,
0.0494132712,
0.0618592799,
-0.045929946,
-0.0169481877,
-0.0306574851,
-0.0248251334,
0.0799857974,
0.0307681449,
0.0248467438,
0.0143413236,
0.0521039329,
-0.0464318208,
0.0042133876,
-0.0117084589,
0.0488688573,
-0.0467789322,
0.0406521782,
-0.0171856284,
0.0047022412,
-0.0144441668,
-0.0016725257,
0.0087954914,
-0.0611765012,
0.0112476656,
0.0213359129,
0.0311044846,
0.0396803208,
0.0425060801,
-0.0344556905,
-0.0386957973,
-0.0333760157,
-0.0190150235,
0.0317972079,
-0.0153299533,
-0.0301773529,
-0.0496061072,
-0.0519012511,
0.0422031097,
0.009832684,
0.0234165769,
0.0485809669,
-0.0007769112,
0.0319354907,
-0.0224678516,
-0.0182039458,
-0.0162624642,
-0.0008042022,
0.0349821784,
-0.018207185,
0.0358397588,
-0.0155179519,
-0.0461246632,
0.0053126495,
-0.0084488625,
-0.0157327261,
0.0057015149,
0.005822775,
-0.0566271581,
0.0247154683,
-0.0338651985,
-0.017696362,
-0.0737996995,
0.02242193,
0.0316428281,
-0.0434703045,
-0.0343487859,
0.0192795638,
2.633e-7,
-0.0441099033,
0.0018918666,
0.0110281268,
0.0339488052,
-0.0060206819,
0.0323191658,
-0.0511899069,
0.0415863469,
-0.0221445374,
-0.0348580964,
0.020236738,
0.0509111732,
0.0073513757,
0.0068638269,
-0.0783650652,
-0.0239600781,
-0.0311900526,
-0.0172883067,
-0.0371060818,
-0.0192864891,
0.0091816718,
0.0551578589,
0.0136725176,
0.034629114,
0.0427627303,
-0.0176453441,
0.0433336236,
-0.0329128429,
0.0435260497,
-0.0117110927,
0.0131825237,
-0.0297279377,
-0.0531658754,
0.0294037852,
-0.0146742761,
0.0042059356,
0.0313108973,
-0.0071561718,
-0.0213514492,
-0.0145113645,
-0.023245329,
0.0242981333,
-0.0003022238,
0.0035924879,
0.0313192271,
-0.0825865939,
-0.0452067852,
0.0279191379,
-0.0089216093,
-0.0334167145,
-0.0414128229,
0.0126076993,
-0.0363079868,
-0.0395457298,
-0.0046771979,
0.0173589401,
0.0091704372,
-0.0540152453,
-0.0057161967,
0.0359986834,
-0.0122251976,
-0.0387596413,
-0.0186513178,
-0.0485434271,
-0.0063765342,
0.0095334863,
-0.0469900221,
1.369764422e-34,
-0.0067249225,
0.0139001664,
-0.0036753672,
0.0213990472,
0.0275560915,
-0.0210245308,
-0.0418049693,
0.0343465805,
0.0623901151,
-0.0118612414,
-0.0224219915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08081v1 | Exploring the Limits of ChatGPT for Query or Aspect-based Text Summarization | 2023-02-16T04:41:30 | 2023-02-16T04:41:30 | Xianjun Yang, Yan Li, Xinlu Zhang, Haifeng Chen, Wei Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text summarization has been a crucial problem in natural language processing
(NLP) for several decades. It aims to condense lengthy documents into shorter
versions while retaining the most critical information. Various methods have
been proposed for text summarization, including extractive and abstractive
summarization. The emergence of large language models (LLMs) like GPT3 and
ChatGPT has recently created significant interest in using these models for
text summarization tasks. Recent studies \cite{goyal2022news,
zhang2023benchmarking} have shown that LLMs-generated news summaries are
already on par with humans. However, the performance of LLMs for more practical
applications like aspect or query-based summaries is underexplored. To fill
this gap, we conducted an evaluation of ChatGPT's performance on four widely
used benchmark datasets, encompassing diverse summaries from Reddit posts, news
articles, dialogue meetings, and stories. Our experiments reveal that ChatGPT's
performance is comparable to traditional fine-tuning methods in terms of Rouge
scores. Moreover, we highlight some unique differences between
ChatGPT-generated summaries and human references, providing valuable insights
into the superpower of ChatGPT for diverse text summarization tasks. Our
findings call for new directions in this area, and we plan to conduct further
research to systematically examine the characteristics of ChatGPT-generated
summaries through extensive human evaluation. | [
0.0608634278,
0.0116302501,
0.0266035516,
-0.0021086482,
-0.0440766774,
0.0086285723,
-0.0270793475,
-0.0034751969,
-0.0229956266,
-0.0320184268,
-0.0160459634,
-0.0234013498,
0.0129724285,
0.0203779917,
-0.0014335641,
-0.0705779791,
0.040438354,
-0.0031472524,
0.0009606663,
0.0206551198,
0.0434119552,
0.0282310117,
0.0425633155,
0.0296867825,
0.0153134214,
0.013490973,
0.0084371194,
0.0052616661,
0.0320073329,
0.0216526091,
-0.0047113644,
0.0229865722,
0.0069660195,
0.0073727579,
0.0000018298,
-0.0343443118,
-0.0214998201,
-0.0086590676,
0.0333365798,
0.0393280126,
0.0730975643,
-0.0254747812,
0.0096888784,
0.0273188371,
-0.0190968253,
0.0001269716,
-0.0110951513,
0.0823129192,
0.0925436243,
0.0965853781,
-0.0149257677,
-0.0209981967,
0.0500725396,
-0.042835556,
-0.005781089,
-0.0476252921,
-0.0080545824,
0.0345960297,
0.0124152834,
0.0377713479,
0.0239185486,
0.0317219272,
0.0257407613,
-0.0119872121,
-0.0167673808,
0.0383946598,
-0.0690783858,
0.0097736213,
0.0229558218,
0.0389180481,
0.0023825977,
-0.0140578942,
0.0439798087,
0.0292427875,
0.0153061617,
0.0078170095,
-0.0855578557,
0.0283999555,
-0.0185687263,
0.0243331734,
0.0003439086,
0.0382786058,
-0.0279439837,
0.0204308629,
0.0145804025,
-0.0126964748,
-0.0067947982,
-0.0214707814,
-0.0269234814,
0.0142744323,
-0.0245824326,
-0.0647490472,
0.0118874852,
0.0093189375,
-0.0152380606,
-0.0233131386,
-0.053751532,
0.007939266,
0.0203927085,
-0.0461976826,
-0.0281801615,
0.0140218353,
0.0367708988,
0.0649707913,
0.0033039562,
0.027997477,
0.0246700756,
0.0025137458,
-0.0733424798,
-0.0114856195,
-0.0610891953,
0.0028796056,
-0.0476436652,
0.0265027247,
-0.0455354154,
-0.0283214692,
-0.0331601799,
0.0206055883,
0.0582840443,
-0.0475328863,
0.0288547166,
0.0108710984,
-0.0070549911,
-0.0033458571,
-0.000896886,
0.0036219521,
-0.0357481726,
-0.0388339162,
0.0445845313,
-0.012357315,
-0.0085701365,
0.009244049,
0.010305739,
-0.010107439,
-0.0127741806,
0.0175521467,
-0.0379908942,
-0.0379041955,
0.012137766,
-0.0232153684,
-0.0143391108,
-0.0577152558,
-0.0022017467,
-0.078454785,
0.0151076429,
0.0048226635,
-0.0336238183,
0.0010391535,
-0.0077584311,
0.0496913195,
-0.0610322729,
-0.0056764348,
0.0030764393,
0.0197687913,
0.0313549154,
0.026032418,
0.0308646988,
0.0555195287,
0.0451109149,
0.0593879409,
0.0501334369,
0.0167015456,
0.0092066405,
0.0155526921,
-0.0023036113,
0.0222487878,
0.0437977016,
-0.0095203221,
-0.0312025305,
-0.0152136032,
0.0242915042,
0.0855237097,
-0.0469852127,
-0.0051760632,
0.0767490417,
0.0390175693,
0.0019166403,
0.0343705826,
0.0107982988,
0.0650080144,
0.0366696864,
0.0622985922,
-0.0198796988,
0.0155139929,
-0.0455764718,
0.0557430871,
0.1166561246,
0.0398882255,
-0.0260852184,
-0.0481026694,
-0.0041030361,
0.0216351096,
0.0120276995,
-0.0126922652,
0.007579735,
0.0072669536,
-0.0448157266,
0.0176374689,
0.0203170571,
-0.0636876225,
0.0137006212,
-0.038929645,
-0.010351928,
0.0234781969,
0.0496714041,
-0.0196947288,
-0.0114237349,
-0.0026199655,
-0.0091712177,
0.0371001326,
0.0699359626,
-0.0004695104,
-0.0304277502,
-0.0366031863,
-0.016562717,
0.0003590357,
0.0035841018,
-0.0307569522,
0.0315814652,
-0.0125659695,
0.0322894715,
-0.0450168699,
-0.0349612348,
0.0132328924,
-0.0231580846,
-0.0111847967,
-0.0222164579,
-0.0501655266,
-0.0036413905,
0.0365861729,
-0.018953342,
0.0182107016,
0.0045419256,
-0.0204606932,
-0.0312894955,
0.0139976507,
-0.0657820776,
-0.0511678346,
0.0179285351,
-0.0568397269,
0.0078975707,
0.0120771565,
-0.031863723,
-0.0435323119,
0.0158677641,
-0.0478654131,
0.0006743358,
-0.0470967665,
-0.0070768604,
0.0363688655,
-0.0013095906,
-0.0309236925,
0.067076914,
0.0006544882,
-0.021601554,
0.021874126,
-0.0244274475,
-0.007029172,
-0.0349587388,
-0.0052855872,
0.0007803378,
0.0173669104,
0.0146342916,
0.0643453524,
0.0199165028,
-0.0347721092,
-0.0359191373,
-0.1407387704,
0.0398959853,
-0.0178850796,
0.0203484166,
0.0515223444,
0.022465203,
-0.0195523798,
0.0225249566,
-0.056515269,
-0.0340886712,
0.0337748192,
0.0264247097,
0.0197486561,
0.0197936948,
0.0463143177,
-0.0670481771,
-0.0187514685,
0.0052667316,
0.0435562283,
0.0106727509,
-0.0447130315,
-0.0097291227,
0.0485317186,
-0.0140801147,
-0.0346984901,
-0.0090127662,
-0.0193637758,
-0.0234791115,
-0.012342534,
0.0595177412,
0.0267990474,
0.051142402,
0.0102282912,
-0.0118817445,
0.000809274,
-0.0185947269,
-0.0065475921,
-0.0631623119,
-0.0018318186,
0.009545397,
-0.0465912297,
0.0456457213,
0.0602259412,
0.024221532,
0.0269038919,
-0.0422636271,
0.0513502546,
-0.0264894236,
0.011543219,
-0.0403343588,
0.0088409716,
-0.0075232857,
0.0137034766,
-0.0529042445,
0.0092840325,
0.0550910458,
-0.0231560804,
0.0180718619,
-0.0574487709,
-0.0145758232,
-0.0767096654,
0.0635363385,
0.006530419,
0.0195638668,
0.0059923171,
-0.0029046095,
-0.0332422219,
-0.0218309537,
0.0312480927,
-0.0255221799,
0.0613645725,
-0.0118615581,
0.0134926587,
-0.0307225827,
-0.004815754,
0.0071753333,
-0.0609201491,
-0.0232877061,
0.0339258164,
0.0240196567,
-0.005954789,
-0.0272139348,
0.0376604423,
0.0313117504,
0.0341632292,
-0.0570651703,
-0.0200000536,
0.0028003412,
0.0715599209,
0.0717052594,
-0.0119406125,
0.0289000422,
-0.0336309932,
0.0332529582,
0.0783777982,
0.020235844,
-0.0064027151,
0.0382706672,
-0.0347224995,
-0.0122040687,
-0.0561935455,
-0.0097464472,
-0.0361635871,
0.0802618936,
-0.0353562869,
-0.0175823532,
0.1091975272,
0.0239203665,
-0.0265169032,
-0.0247364175,
0.0341678597,
0.0511430912,
-0.0101330923,
0.00381247,
-0.0729078725,
-0.0248621237,
-0.0030451568,
0.0196270123,
0.0128293391,
-0.0227706581,
-0.0177772287,
-0.0880109221,
0.0273734313,
0.003402072,
-0.0851335451,
-0.0285040438,
-0.0354533195,
0.028643975,
-0.0430503786,
0.0105336057,
0.0297837816,
-0.048439417,
0.0198397338,
0.0105857197,
-0.0624915287,
0.0194954555,
-0.0081885597,
-0.022091642,
-0.0130348252,
0.0509422384,
0.0400261953,
0.0175926499,
0.0398418494,
0.0791991577,
-0.0461703539,
0.0006750987,
-0.0035634015,
0.0903058723,
-0.0204493739,
0.0222941674,
-0.0279356055,
0.0440569669,
-0.0065005338,
-0.0055361642,
0.0127325486,
0.0087290788,
0.018059874,
-0.0224810038,
-0.0437438637,
0.0442476496,
-0.0431245342,
0.0877167135,
0.047036875,
-0.0103157386,
-0.0481281169,
-0.0266383979,
-0.0008286655,
-0.0579840951,
-0.0923286527,
-0.0273995213,
-0.0279219355,
-0.0239910278,
-0.0858724117,
-0.0827566683,
0.0026657674,
-0.0392342396,
-0.0397226103,
-0.0148492083,
-0.0006494488,
0.025100302,
-0.0099540455,
0.0090731755,
-0.029059574,
-0.02558708,
-0.0313466415,
-0.0128407236,
0.0530659072,
-0.0424586199,
-0.0265706722,
0.0220573638,
-0.0788777545,
-0.032533817,
-0.0151170604,
0.0148459282,
0.0218667295,
0.0314740501,
0.0015812966,
0.0013609881,
0.0090160631,
0.0568505675,
0.0002529733,
0.0256318469,
-0.0094600637,
0.0385460109,
-0.0080171013,
0.016899446,
-0.0416285768,
0.0533379316,
-0.0420596413,
0.0415955931,
-0.033692874,
-0.0615013838,
0.0076359669,
0.0415204726,
0.0249354504,
0.0050850469,
0.0100030759,
-0.0275227483,
-0.0409532003,
-0.0250502191,
-0.0066549554,
-0.0479791313,
0.0095493998,
-0.0257387143,
0.0083154077,
-0.0110104671,
0.0580911785,
-0.0160825606,
0.0292311572,
-0.0795356557,
-0.0282439869,
-0.029084336,
-0.0274604633,
-0.0567724779,
-0.0181760136,
-0.0394316688,
-0.0224494897,
-0.0338973515,
0.0121946847,
-0.033900708,
0.0198118407,
0.0106218252,
-0.0125965383,
0.0259384178,
0.0393755697,
-0.1168423668,
-0.0047827116,
-0.0630630329,
0.0410862304,
0.0312863737,
-0.0511750132,
0.0786576197,
-0.0099222483,
-0.0198914856,
-0.0320623554,
0.0220658891,
0.0409792252,
0.0324109569,
-0.0507480688,
0.0197877772,
-0.0036966458,
0.0104537811,
0.0728265196,
-0.0465059653,
0.0108980108,
0.0508866683,
-0.0351592414,
-0.0150860893,
-0.0347519927,
-0.046397727,
0.0040019439,
0.0318355709,
-0.0205587745,
-0.0706136003,
0.0022744001,
0.005662878,
0.0284928326,
0.0302067026,
-0.0172965061,
0.030729698,
0.0434593931,
0.0071606762,
0.0185175389,
-0.057797078,
-0.0168509539,
-0.0293182526,
0.005619558,
0.0220115893,
-6.209274136e-33,
-0.0413852818,
0.0131845782,
-0.0104389209,
0.026642723,
-0.0665800348,
0.0114329839,
-0.0489447676,
-0.0069340486,
0.015908137,
-0.0080619706,
-0.0356966071,
0.0029923134,
0.0087546967,
0.0320393927,
-0.0176169965,
0.0135671338,
0.0295381341,
-0.0115379849,
-0.0413373783,
0.0655443221,
0.0286481753,
0.002889547,
0.0290952381,
-0.0502399765,
-0.0021049611,
-0.0311879367,
-0.0118002556,
-0.0044610351,
0.0501339138,
0.0430015624,
-0.0120140361,
0.0062026083,
0.0507907905,
-0.0503646061,
-0.0314606354,
0.0085379351,
-0.0770862028,
-0.0286407936,
0.040670339,
-0.0560245104,
-0.0328377485,
-0.0250930581,
0.0364943184,
-0.0282082856,
0.0134409657,
-0.0621721596,
0.0338084996,
-0.0275658984,
-0.0288777091,
-0.069238618,
-0.0130575998,
0.0493139476,
-0.0052042934,
-0.0415474735,
0.0082045291,
0.0412870422,
0.0120880129,
0.0143268378,
0.0064253388,
0.0311590768,
0.0064508431,
0.0548114441,
0.0227845777,
0.0004508962,
0.0075073815,
0.074469693,
-0.0020475811,
0.0123092327,
-0.0360015333,
-0.0018431438,
-0.0175020043,
0.0157609694,
0.0116165923,
0.0236737523,
0.0230955891,
0.0138649652,
-0.0217629801,
0.0865753815,
0.0080806892,
-0.006079854,
0.0381766371,
0.0115574794,
-0.0136582796,
-0.0093501462,
-0.0173321385,
0.0136227794,
-0.0170170832,
-0.0123211984,
-0.0130126011,
0.0309779551,
-0.0414543152,
-0.0074810609,
0.0316100754,
-0.0250155739,
0.0387299582,
0.01916641,
-0.0593734086,
0.035038501,
-0.0153894601,
-0.0105716391,
-0.0506424531,
0.0301663466,
0.0267685466,
0.0263990704,
-0.0164228231,
-0.0085659977,
0.0426204242,
-0.018420862,
-0.0428489484,
0.005781651,
-0.0085859615,
0.0560514815,
-0.0671786442,
0.0050062966,
-0.0031894278,
0.0096089086,
-0.0000913854,
0.0469164252,
0.0215720795,
0.0022022596,
-0.0405316204,
0.0112191942,
0.0198449083,
0.0044845804,
-0.003973329,
0.0529969148,
-0.0049276594,
0.0183531251,
0.0055867666,
-0.0232995227,
-0.0198530164,
0.0156862121,
2.438e-7,
0.0482932553,
0.0462180227,
0.0693462491,
0.0213595573,
-0.0184669085,
0.0314157791,
0.0062237247,
0.0226971898,
0.0500422381,
-0.001239782,
0.0254305154,
0.0699399188,
0.0499482118,
0.0368451811,
-0.0884876177,
0.0046399715,
-0.076933153,
-0.0517355129,
-0.0203722045,
-0.0146979382,
0.0599744767,
0.0729471147,
-0.0154502662,
0.0107402075,
-0.0331522226,
-0.0285400599,
0.0470303968,
-0.0295576081,
-0.0941716507,
0.0426192097,
0.028569106,
0.0200180672,
-0.0039468203,
-0.0432913825,
0.0102730282,
-0.0293220617,
0.0761483386,
0.0685827881,
0.0491124988,
-0.024594361,
0.0276826899,
-0.0105923824,
0.0242916699,
-0.0074896631,
0.0725554302,
-0.0489484034,
0.0030396844,
-0.0534639098,
-0.039406687,
0.0073822122,
-0.0132631585,
0.0063066003,
-0.053179726,
0.0654979795,
-0.0175572205,
-0.0043128761,
0.0012256792,
-0.0634082854,
-0.0477627665,
0.0253480598,
-0.0173883103,
-0.0426060818,
-0.0104126949,
0.0065712575,
-0.0264203679,
-0.0433671065,
-0.0218451824,
2.380857967e-34,
0.0857739225,
0.0070980419,
-0.0225981697,
-0.0185155589,
0.02656506,
-0.0038188596,
0.0297144316,
-0.0111307176,
-0.003679909,
-0.0577597469,
0.000012132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08079v1 | Document Flattening: Beyond Concatenating Context for Document-Level Neural Machine Translation | 2023-02-16T04:38:34 | 2023-02-16T04:38:34 | Minghao Wu, George Foster, Lizhen Qu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing work in document-level neural machine translation commonly
concatenates several consecutive sentences as a pseudo-document, and then
learns inter-sentential dependencies. This strategy limits the model's ability
to leverage information from distant context. We overcome this limitation with
a novel Document Flattening (DocFlat) technique that integrates Flat-Batch
Attention (FBA) and Neural Context Gate (NCG) into Transformer model to utilize
information beyond the pseudo-document boundaries. FBA allows the model to
attend to all the positions in the batch and learns the relationships between
positions explicitly and NCG identifies the useful information from the distant
context. We conduct comprehensive experiments and analyses on three benchmark
datasets for English-German translation, and validate the effectiveness of two
variants of DocFlat. Empirical results show that our approach outperforms
strong baselines with statistical significance on BLEU, COMET and accuracy on
the contrastive test set. The analyses highlight that DocFlat is highly
effective in capturing the long-range information. | [
0.0047625108,
0.0251191147,
0.0285324734,
0.047564704,
-0.0219321474,
-0.0033621469,
0.0295136254,
-0.0012318901,
-0.033985585,
-0.0224939659,
-0.0403594747,
-0.0406756289,
0.0492582917,
0.0008096017,
0.0388173126,
-0.0560544915,
0.0297346041,
0.0001722074,
-0.0191192646,
0.0208722018,
0.0057371538,
0.0034467524,
0.0293810908,
0.0273361839,
-0.0464777462,
-0.0265381914,
-0.0175429191,
0.0580397137,
0.0358542874,
-0.006409436,
0.0206325352,
0.0012761931,
0.0135325976,
0.0409803875,
0.0000019976,
-0.0233866349,
-0.0422226004,
0.0226510223,
0.0141873984,
0.0118447887,
0.0294459108,
-0.0829510689,
-0.0237735379,
0.0229208283,
-0.0030733224,
0.014076096,
0.0454124957,
0.0505649224,
0.0554802455,
0.1003318354,
-0.0258171353,
-0.0438128486,
0.0432375632,
-0.0886161551,
0.0393676646,
-0.0759544373,
-0.0276670363,
-0.0347572826,
-0.0190325677,
0.0217202716,
-0.0236781444,
0.0493679754,
0.0559973232,
-0.0262289923,
0.0165236313,
0.0436019897,
-0.0112783369,
-0.0090717617,
-0.0121999048,
0.0948047265,
-0.0561679192,
-0.002283185,
-0.0174736641,
-0.0247927047,
0.0158764422,
-0.0646960586,
-0.0589230992,
0.0305147916,
-0.0151071791,
0.0138559062,
0.0410321988,
0.0510087721,
0.0329169668,
-0.001754924,
-0.0621982366,
0.0001713781,
0.0026833701,
-0.0449583419,
0.0018965399,
-0.0050680838,
-0.012760466,
-0.0194377545,
0.063644357,
0.0285966173,
0.0044776504,
0.0137986802,
-0.0556149371,
-0.0542522147,
0.0226458982,
-0.0561576895,
0.0203433577,
0.0645198673,
-0.0318660364,
0.0521105267,
-0.0149038518,
0.0774116665,
-0.023016654,
-0.0199736841,
-0.0717179254,
-0.0038451839,
0.0039338553,
0.0361492299,
-0.0591320731,
0.0001148938,
-0.0533393621,
-0.0368546322,
0.0041714753,
-0.0071255602,
0.0179179143,
0.0014469718,
0.0571220517,
-0.024025606,
-0.0846746191,
-0.0252387263,
0.0262498409,
0.0631543025,
-0.015691895,
-0.0390026979,
0.0255902261,
-0.0040483316,
-0.0568758212,
0.0097909942,
0.0040482772,
-0.0373579077,
0.0038708067,
0.0417613164,
-0.041188933,
-0.0361392237,
-0.0250330865,
0.0114351716,
-0.0282222256,
-0.0536701381,
0.0266838204,
-0.0288480911,
0.0692614242,
-0.0181423239,
0.0047994074,
-0.0124801323,
0.0092593012,
0.021467736,
-0.0283389539,
0.05542114,
0.0110281147,
-0.0449192971,
0.0098655019,
0.0075012939,
-0.0045002718,
0.0431438833,
0.0211046655,
0.0544196516,
-0.0093034049,
0.0190710463,
-0.0276202969,
0.0131793525,
0.0431248993,
-0.0117895994,
-0.0072660712,
0.0063400134,
0.0030521406,
0.0197323281,
0.0615414269,
0.0408426896,
-0.0257996377,
0.0087060379,
0.0516896807,
0.0056125568,
0.0059262863,
0.0296338014,
0.0444065519,
0.0202501286,
-0.0399556682,
0.0250535067,
-0.0402229317,
0.0408329703,
0.0250385422,
0.0358271673,
0.0651773885,
0.0419722386,
-0.0146582909,
-0.0254826006,
0.0076985504,
-0.0309245326,
0.0421221703,
-0.0466826111,
0.0115655325,
0.0414484777,
-0.0767013952,
0.0554991215,
-0.0081125908,
-0.0413301922,
0.0194021948,
0.0248769969,
-0.0358203501,
0.0486944541,
0.0419840142,
-0.0282738358,
-0.0968702883,
-0.0115517499,
-0.0015066473,
0.0456615984,
0.0682703257,
0.0365860127,
0.0582300797,
-0.0520604886,
-0.009365865,
-0.0394174643,
-0.01744348,
0.0217745062,
-0.0007104533,
0.0139281312,
0.0359947197,
-0.0271197297,
-0.0145669533,
0.0361353084,
0.0022423898,
-0.0352949053,
0.0231666081,
0.0031500426,
0.030272387,
0.0030068792,
0.0104178721,
0.0282743406,
0.0139135215,
-0.0450620353,
-0.007846714,
-0.0213098135,
-0.0737865791,
-0.0549126677,
0.0098401941,
-0.0176558793,
-0.0213729683,
0.0023953363,
-0.0383804552,
-0.049826771,
-0.0238707159,
-0.0354775265,
0.0275896955,
-0.0115741612,
0.0319336802,
0.0631163269,
0.043743562,
-0.0309036747,
0.0442516394,
-0.0219973419,
-0.0122114951,
-0.0044979034,
0.0108461212,
0.0190203674,
-0.0020116458,
0.0224217754,
0.0096915616,
-0.0059481701,
0.0030779024,
0.0159337018,
0.0362983085,
-0.0308222994,
-0.04080173,
-0.0659912601,
0.0210411698,
-0.0184617508,
0.0395828336,
0.0533453003,
0.0553807989,
0.0190221816,
-0.0291930251,
-0.0391838029,
0.0077784341,
-0.00715638,
-0.0030317511,
0.0229907222,
0.0053460156,
0.0032531393,
-0.0417631902,
-0.0230556689,
0.0033125784,
0.0296972785,
0.019579174,
-0.0343608782,
-0.0489897691,
0.0154790729,
0.0019597365,
0.0207916778,
-0.0200034864,
-0.0320617855,
-0.0047506439,
-0.0425633155,
0.0211043078,
0.102773115,
0.0133630484,
0.0027809837,
0.0121859331,
-0.0108217811,
-0.059132684,
0.0403753668,
-0.0095227249,
0.0250713695,
-0.0194149856,
-0.0088542206,
0.0263326447,
0.0419533364,
0.0046139741,
0.0166474395,
-0.0461151674,
-0.0244229008,
0.0257084817,
-0.0166597404,
-0.0173223447,
-0.0077472609,
0.001915015,
-0.0066088294,
-0.0425546914,
-0.0326220207,
0.0435549803,
-0.0616138317,
-0.0149133848,
-0.0584161468,
0.0358746275,
-0.0507932603,
0.0261413958,
-0.0055990946,
0.0178055577,
-0.0379443839,
-0.0376766697,
-0.0095421085,
0.0130506549,
-0.0444947705,
0.013871328,
0.0267175678,
-0.0393325984,
-0.0046614041,
-0.0459130742,
-0.0451500155,
-0.0205962788,
-0.0250945445,
0.016625965,
0.015119981,
0.0505194664,
-0.0314590633,
-0.0436102785,
-0.0061435727,
0.0182731729,
0.111362353,
-0.0332409777,
-0.0186605807,
-0.0243823864,
0.0598468035,
-0.0115134707,
0.0029944743,
0.0530697554,
-0.0468639769,
-0.0007896795,
0.0553940535,
-0.0073243128,
-0.0046348185,
-0.0303238612,
-0.0244829524,
0.0181552414,
-0.0183771253,
-0.0228767265,
-0.0303093269,
0.0215536486,
-0.0957456231,
-0.0273835547,
0.0876537561,
0.0200866647,
-0.0675982982,
-0.0072948555,
0.0030003146,
0.0437654182,
0.0018967311,
0.042388998,
-0.0697480068,
-0.0236104541,
-0.0122296568,
0.0123271057,
0.0820540413,
0.0251384396,
-0.0349504165,
-0.0605866909,
0.0321348906,
0.0345532522,
-0.0558253974,
-0.0167080332,
-0.0049358755,
0.0077117635,
0.0307302196,
0.0340007283,
0.0190249141,
0.0033044985,
-0.042727489,
-0.0331820063,
0.0315934531,
-0.0353997014,
-0.0051655257,
-0.0228768792,
-0.0081183398,
0.0454075299,
0.0308048539,
0.0094434135,
0.00087296,
0.0741355643,
-0.0176858753,
0.0282291565,
-0.0047025154,
0.0342664756,
-0.0172427036,
0.0090262918,
0.0441071019,
0.0196191259,
-0.0545297563,
0.0162435956,
0.0010685447,
0.0439747907,
-0.0098198373,
-0.0015151362,
-0.014713495,
-0.0203957018,
0.0109553449,
0.048556909,
0.0269029643,
-0.0487192571,
-0.0261360873,
-0.0086400416,
-0.0004924572,
-0.0491962545,
0.0343997329,
-0.00377231,
-0.045633357,
-0.0432860292,
-0.0970148221,
-0.0794980004,
-0.0074796458,
0.0459380038,
-0.0059692175,
-0.0147197144,
0.0241485853,
-0.0309255701,
-0.0069643352,
0.0472927541,
0.0014795851,
0.0034741166,
-0.0442924425,
0.0303604379,
0.0287746303,
-0.0442846008,
-0.0014804451,
0.0213955585,
-0.0852303803,
-0.0414589494,
0.0107948631,
0.0301611181,
0.0098485816,
0.0815595388,
-0.0407532901,
-0.0273158997,
0.0355612896,
-0.0147168627,
-0.0430059247,
0.0322746336,
0.0364964344,
-0.0035735995,
-0.0004156846,
0.0341183394,
-0.0162226465,
0.0283707026,
0.014030966,
0.0289423596,
-0.0015839563,
-0.0245942734,
-0.0001725378,
-0.0406627245,
0.0181146041,
-0.0040245526,
0.0425612368,
-0.0179195199,
0.0598913096,
-0.0082884738,
0.0007727495,
-0.0541110821,
-0.0206055976,
0.0303350296,
-0.004832793,
0.0114772292,
0.0086368704,
0.0113336332,
-0.0284336675,
0.0090949852,
-0.0321697444,
-0.0127505604,
0.0189186931,
-0.0054151015,
0.0142726349,
-0.0043002316,
0.008625282,
-0.0136952437,
0.0258651618,
-0.0484122969,
0.0716921836,
0.0206217729,
0.004278827,
-0.0237227567,
0.0403589495,
-0.0519292057,
0.0356950164,
-0.0406929664,
-0.0315491781,
0.0594128519,
-0.0004879967,
0.109366782,
-0.0032310917,
-0.0082841283,
0.0089830533,
0.0208663866,
-0.0015885166,
-0.0240201317,
-0.0231708493,
0.0009234714,
0.0413310826,
0.0426681042,
0.0599495769,
-0.027553631,
-0.0381929167,
0.0070122192,
0.0050859847,
-0.0421518944,
-0.0141380206,
0.0069931615,
0.0101582473,
0.0059429468,
-0.0136091886,
-0.0031657447,
-0.0298274998,
0.0453419127,
0.0196669828,
-0.0296910889,
0.0015740079,
0.03549622,
0.0702796876,
-0.0305540115,
-0.0045715813,
-0.021531526,
0.0331786051,
-0.0055135782,
-0.0554499291,
-0.0737292767,
-6.596874297e-33,
-0.0427135117,
0.0075947978,
-0.0010715821,
-0.009824682,
-0.0632147565,
0.0222139824,
-0.0660214201,
-0.0384622291,
-0.0008825551,
0.0220447108,
-0.0539320745,
0.023312388,
0.0197847467,
0.03559874,
-0.0156788547,
-0.0047081942,
0.0526048504,
0.0072101564,
-0.02081085,
0.0520174094,
0.0405214876,
0.0250957552,
0.0825873539,
-0.0876744315,
0.0125094978,
0.0090560783,
-0.0112309335,
0.0038240999,
0.0034961607,
0.0148327202,
0.0158883426,
-0.0324019976,
0.030203307,
-0.0198685862,
-0.038693361,
0.0286987741,
-0.1151445955,
-0.0024158349,
-0.0179247223,
0.0116785644,
-0.0374640338,
-0.0612430833,
0.0621016808,
-0.0369348004,
0.0593711883,
-0.0470695831,
0.0066672331,
-0.0253488738,
-0.0433854312,
-0.0457577407,
-0.0475557931,
0.0037404054,
-0.0182230361,
0.0158580858,
-0.0217378978,
0.0247649178,
-0.0201221667,
0.034377154,
-0.0755795687,
-0.0207284782,
-0.0179983415,
0.0684720874,
0.0403441899,
-0.0228267945,
-0.0302406251,
0.0017151582,
0.029884411,
0.0188796781,
0.0017925492,
-0.0352822579,
0.0290696137,
-0.0032206224,
0.0568963699,
0.0189662762,
0.0750000477,
0.0279857572,
-0.0531500131,
0.0391774327,
-0.0187658649,
0.0259389803,
0.0036215303,
0.015361432,
-0.0223615728,
-0.0152503513,
0.0078189056,
-0.0162808169,
-0.0292902477,
0.0034802447,
0.0069689704,
0.0486572459,
-0.0096355313,
-0.0172900502,
0.0746164396,
-0.0012284362,
0.0528413802,
0.0423037708,
0.0108772581,
0.0422022976,
-0.0109837623,
-0.0060868026,
-0.0428129062,
-0.016001014,
0.018946765,
0.0419991463,
0.007354104,
0.0003601041,
0.078863427,
0.0386151001,
-0.0359882899,
-0.0156091256,
-0.0456833318,
0.0055906149,
-0.0238222256,
0.0198555216,
0.0248973351,
-0.0194650833,
0.00464027,
0.0854205713,
0.0324352495,
0.0125712128,
-0.02437534,
0.0132719176,
0.0234252401,
0.0522583202,
-0.0349205844,
-0.0001843525,
-0.0295870621,
0.0214637723,
0.0780561343,
-0.0686709955,
-0.0119502852,
0.042477943,
2.736e-7,
0.0724954009,
0.0073696356,
0.0306699313,
0.0084219677,
0.0194697399,
0.0061283037,
-0.0007997756,
0.0437458865,
0.0013982321,
0.0561237372,
0.0508659668,
-0.0170478132,
0.0428401232,
0.0147871207,
-0.1076686606,
-0.0287334677,
-0.0798444897,
0.0034512822,
-0.0649637431,
-0.0390098207,
0.021301752,
0.1135445088,
-0.026402818,
-0.0092877122,
0.010643255,
-0.0082863681,
0.054031305,
0.0066678729,
0.0011969708,
0.0082985479,
0.0135704735,
-0.02123609,
-0.0668140873,
-0.0162092894,
-0.0300039649,
0.0408702344,
0.0147560332,
0.088230826,
0.0062075732,
-0.0455199704,
0.039390754,
-0.0135919806,
-0.0134412488,
-0.0434355251,
0.0473940745,
-0.0628225505,
0.0162810441,
0.0197534934,
-0.0329089388,
0.0174635295,
0.0000284719,
-0.0096961064,
-0.0155396471,
0.0213770512,
0.0365340039,
-0.0289526675,
-0.0172576327,
-0.0775940716,
-0.074584201,
-0.0276160073,
-0.0242576115,
0.0120082051,
-0.0354855843,
-0.0040465491,
-0.0045322333,
-0.0022802176,
-0.0273340214,
2.882530258e-34,
0.0447342619,
-0.054432489,
0.0148728555,
-0.0262156092,
0.0463822521,
-0.0222996194,
-0.0153069301,
0.0026749684,
-0.0041123549,
-0.0697386414,
-0.0290966053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08068v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08068v2 | LabelPrompt: Effective Prompt-based Learning for Relation Classification | 2023-02-16T04:06:25 | 2023-08-13T03:04:08 | Wenjie Zhang, Xiaoning Song, Zhenhua Feng, Tianyang Xu, Xiaojun Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Recently, prompt-based learning has gained popularity across many natural
language processing (NLP) tasks by reformulating them into a cloze-style format
to better align pre-trained language models (PLMs) with downstream tasks.
However, applying this approach to relation classification poses unique
challenges. Specifically, associating natural language words that fill the
masked token with semantic relation labels (\textit{e.g.}
\textit{``org:founded\_by}'') is difficult. To address this challenge, this
paper presents a novel prompt-based learning method, namely LabelPrompt, for
the relation classification task. Motivated by the intuition to ``GIVE MODEL
CHOICES!'', we first define additional tokens to represent relation labels,
which regard these tokens as the verbaliser with semantic initialisation and
explicitly construct them with a prompt template method. Then, to mitigate
inconsistency between predicted relations and given entities, we implement an
entity-aware module with contrastive learning. Last, we conduct an attention
query strategy within the self-attention layer to differentiates prompt tokens
and sequence tokens. Together, these strategies enhance the adaptability of
prompt-based learning, especially when only small labelled datasets is
available. Comprehensive experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate the
superiority of our method, particularly in the few-shot scenario. | [
0.0519252755,
0.0459721088,
0.0003490796,
0.0424105003,
-0.0101531167,
-0.0033014796,
0.0148218414,
0.0019586759,
0.0560091436,
-0.0705520064,
-0.0497381426,
-0.0265890993,
-0.0304904599,
0.0227498617,
0.0079275947,
-0.0546259806,
0.0698302239,
0.0277787931,
0.0344185084,
0.0215861443,
-0.0149475681,
0.0019590983,
0.0063901623,
0.0096475231,
-0.0192645155,
-0.0346475355,
0.0041789026,
0.011174418,
-0.0101140887,
-0.0690494776,
0.0259238817,
0.097673364,
-0.0098216562,
0.0184542164,
0.0000019946,
-0.0937990919,
-0.0191672854,
-0.0343721323,
-0.0355163328,
-0.0329100005,
-0.0014433134,
0.0063347653,
0.0425523892,
0.0209599137,
-0.0464550219,
-0.0707498267,
0.0352064706,
0.0542296544,
0.0430137776,
0.064340584,
-0.0041823308,
-0.0147575876,
0.0108820545,
-0.0490004644,
0.0177490823,
-0.0101652537,
0.0136300307,
-0.0692130923,
0.017933676,
0.051498238,
-0.0217253547,
0.0221859775,
0.023906922,
-0.0099017201,
0.088497974,
0.057570748,
-0.0040873862,
-0.0328045711,
-0.0414214022,
0.0996691287,
0.0098979063,
-0.011252935,
-0.0137449326,
-0.0244379882,
0.0210754666,
-0.0033707244,
0.0126200831,
0.001561761,
-0.0274733976,
0.0012845378,
0.0214620698,
0.0470015407,
0.0294226594,
0.0206363108,
-0.0289225709,
0.0407260284,
-0.0003735887,
-0.0372800864,
0.0260881074,
0.0173103027,
-0.0173345301,
-0.065591827,
-0.0001300848,
0.0414277427,
-0.0499369912,
0.0247532818,
-0.0682066828,
-0.0085483277,
0.0195602663,
-0.0050712237,
-0.0181049835,
0.0160789154,
-0.0289789438,
0.0893953219,
-0.0171987377,
0.0202167444,
0.001311988,
0.029356949,
-0.0215078946,
0.0139936954,
-0.0264938883,
-0.0006398503,
-0.0681981295,
0.0481475629,
-0.0270445663,
-0.0087811612,
-0.0082638338,
0.0295607746,
-0.003297189,
0.0131050171,
0.0063227941,
0.0000240656,
0.0079333875,
0.0153173991,
-0.0548918694,
-0.023974482,
-0.0443313904,
-0.0040394012,
-0.0110849803,
-0.0228390396,
-0.0293382909,
-0.0113433003,
0.0044234414,
-0.0449262932,
-0.0093195988,
0.0710881278,
0.0292527769,
-0.0910320804,
0.0034530393,
-0.0122236162,
-0.0067446195,
-0.0317780748,
-0.0100367339,
-0.0214252807,
0.059018977,
0.0203116108,
-0.0185127705,
-0.0431691483,
0.0485886522,
0.0051408452,
-0.0479955114,
0.0746102333,
-0.031086551,
-0.0270388369,
0.0012767332,
0.022435924,
0.0099931797,
0.0554064736,
0.0061582639,
0.0017981089,
0.0380400792,
0.0099159265,
0.0015186771,
0.0018548592,
0.0557373576,
-0.0367309898,
-0.0064807539,
0.0505940206,
0.0566027798,
0.023785539,
0.0148721486,
0.0392734781,
0.0100736171,
-0.0535548069,
0.019686915,
0.0141236605,
0.013109169,
-0.0123277614,
0.0360798053,
0.0042527402,
0.0014310026,
-0.0005282802,
-0.0709804371,
0.0227200147,
-0.0204357412,
0.0091666067,
0.0183665603,
0.0192460567,
-0.0303510092,
-0.0173247959,
0.0021394785,
-0.0046689473,
-0.0464969799,
0.0142025203,
0.0500708334,
0.0548205636,
-0.0645981953,
0.0513602085,
0.049375914,
0.0016273845,
0.0019889772,
-0.0209932737,
0.0370089114,
0.0328602567,
0.0315874331,
-0.0767475441,
-0.0290235505,
-0.0528901443,
0.009055336,
0.0303098578,
0.0392678827,
-0.0071550035,
0.0149729392,
0.0076797521,
-0.0478202626,
0.0031488233,
-0.014989689,
0.0024109324,
0.0306754243,
0.0177741218,
0.0256107338,
0.0190300271,
-0.0099100629,
0.0529789589,
0.0043446012,
-0.0584100746,
0.0414940864,
0.0513516776,
0.0263848584,
0.0344707482,
0.034089271,
0.005548053,
0.054070361,
-0.0272859335,
0.0090650395,
-0.0347080044,
-0.0698960572,
-0.0914688036,
0.008941289,
0.0424273536,
-0.0318839401,
-0.0249530878,
-0.0393143818,
-0.0266581923,
-0.022821188,
-0.0089847324,
0.0794116035,
-0.0234946907,
0.0034273311,
0.0368551426,
0.0317837261,
-0.0572288632,
0.0953068584,
-0.0103137316,
0.0372053981,
0.0252085123,
0.0320360325,
-0.0250119343,
0.0012902067,
-0.0257671829,
-0.0002538089,
-0.0067468672,
-0.036148347,
0.0286257863,
0.0156519283,
-0.0768187195,
-0.0009331286,
-0.0341398902,
0.0092837429,
0.002240116,
0.0278119631,
-0.0110005429,
0.0231394731,
-0.0056597856,
-0.0408488475,
-0.0043857456,
-0.0143415295,
-0.0194190741,
0.0015527258,
0.0722722858,
0.0090778656,
-0.0144623928,
-0.0300434697,
-0.0057049501,
-0.0255860239,
0.0660084635,
0.0252108965,
-0.0216886513,
-0.0265237745,
0.0289006364,
-0.0104959588,
0.0180328954,
0.0038765157,
0.005494969,
-0.0072791683,
-0.0073909634,
0.0214639641,
0.0334324241,
0.0294502079,
0.0459770337,
0.0191646572,
0.0212172121,
-0.0451731421,
0.0404481441,
-0.0486602485,
0.0322612114,
0.0380246863,
0.01475868,
0.0068810428,
0.0879192054,
-0.0275772344,
-0.0003425455,
-0.0360100307,
0.0420574918,
0.028802447,
0.0194859188,
-0.0473249741,
0.0183778405,
0.0059934543,
0.0016257511,
-0.045542933,
-0.0353617184,
0.0855278224,
-0.0071243737,
-0.0152272675,
-0.0259920489,
0.0022105975,
-0.0515240468,
0.071317859,
0.024234103,
0.0135687748,
0.0582446717,
-0.055437915,
-0.0429369211,
-0.0251915883,
-0.0077474192,
-0.0009774911,
-0.007416768,
0.0102436021,
0.0082035288,
-0.0004042473,
-0.0255617574,
-0.0779743046,
-0.0754179582,
-0.0134457564,
0.0058625364,
-0.0044297809,
0.0196414944,
0.0043392791,
0.0191188883,
0.0011158253,
0.020923866,
-0.013801368,
-0.0111377249,
-0.0214600079,
0.0701585785,
0.027382914,
0.0055320505,
0.0109476401,
0.0024237104,
0.0356580317,
0.0196133498,
0.0175256357,
-0.0221690293,
-0.0004127877,
-0.0082330247,
0.0286262333,
-0.0617189929,
-0.0137966471,
-0.0003776479,
-0.000977556,
-0.0634890869,
-0.0164727271,
0.1275795251,
0.0401471853,
-0.0393625312,
0.0016389679,
0.0562659353,
0.0161555409,
0.0522953123,
0.0270477328,
-0.0541843437,
-0.0323159397,
-0.0252459273,
-0.0077706124,
0.0035129394,
-0.0473966263,
-0.0227608401,
-0.0957580507,
-0.0068672253,
-0.0259928051,
-0.0960916653,
0.0046514319,
-0.0761264935,
0.016301034,
0.017639095,
-0.0290901065,
-0.0058904365,
-0.0526946448,
0.0182883497,
-0.0112634366,
0.0154762967,
-0.0164809357,
0.0219622906,
-0.0544114672,
0.0608829036,
0.0530606769,
0.0272172205,
-0.0117417136,
-0.0113507034,
0.021993462,
-0.0262689963,
-0.0184328426,
-0.0410897732,
0.0626895428,
-0.0534795746,
-0.0038519094,
-0.003710777,
-0.0056372033,
-0.0571200177,
-0.0236789323,
-0.0071886596,
0.0756260678,
0.0064601749,
0.0058966698,
-0.0332334936,
-0.0080872318,
0.0408932939,
0.0816776827,
0.0333806388,
-0.0321290605,
-0.0404656492,
-0.0020273048,
0.0410831198,
-0.0082130758,
0.0164364204,
-0.0121066477,
-0.0323826857,
-0.0284941122,
-0.0464966111,
-0.0735838413,
0.0571340062,
0.0308759287,
0.0005029294,
-0.0027407762,
-0.0094820252,
-0.004128899,
-0.044938501,
0.0458296016,
-0.0135177327,
0.0083016939,
-0.0830751956,
-0.014092044,
0.0244045965,
-0.0561378077,
-0.0208236054,
-0.0215588678,
-0.0430291072,
-0.0187470224,
-0.0202178005,
0.0450047888,
0.008631208,
0.0580585897,
-0.0333929248,
0.0099929441,
0.0437691249,
0.0890663043,
-0.0799452513,
-0.0335515253,
0.0179639813,
-0.0038432162,
-0.0075735301,
0.0351546332,
-0.0407625362,
0.0087306118,
0.0384335257,
0.0345748737,
-0.0166588202,
-0.0807428434,
0.0277982708,
-0.0156534202,
0.1199361309,
-0.0043615899,
0.0043239477,
-0.0433177352,
0.0353127085,
0.0202567764,
-0.0321057513,
-0.0408155099,
0.0169515312,
-0.0268154088,
-0.0066048759,
-0.0099353381,
-0.032814078,
-0.0488391668,
0.037040554,
-0.0112894531,
-0.0139629934,
0.0381367989,
0.0205395985,
0.0268434156,
-0.0173439216,
-0.0234456491,
0.0256695002,
0.0309714861,
0.0156118972,
-0.0203585848,
0.0332378447,
0.0183980241,
-0.0058094584,
-0.011705419,
0.0137243038,
-0.0618561246,
0.0088395514,
-0.0428934209,
0.0167050865,
0.0268639382,
-0.0348914415,
-0.0409511738,
-0.0092447251,
0.0084247412,
-0.0008733496,
0.0409990065,
-0.0208338089,
-0.0407056883,
0.0383583792,
0.0153696751,
-0.0403185785,
0.0202175155,
0.0574329123,
-0.0083551286,
0.02264449,
0.0499619618,
-0.0290868469,
-0.0419413075,
0.0066606593,
0.0076919626,
0.0147140119,
-0.0310194846,
0.0512948483,
-0.0678851828,
-0.0431860276,
0.0231848713,
-0.0182659272,
-0.0538272001,
0.0361673385,
0.0424550883,
0.0306866374,
0.0223192796,
-0.0419400968,
-0.0482079312,
0.0510011949,
0.0048674815,
-0.0401069038,
0.0043247356,
-6.463077326e-33,
-0.0570982508,
-0.0619268417,
0.0080005527,
-0.0065966253,
-0.0172224343,
0.0319085047,
-0.0258826539,
-0.0387437195,
-0.0217153095,
0.0029352906,
-0.0404038653,
0.0069657643,
-0.007540076,
0.0218642596,
-0.0170794837,
-0.0495509729,
0.0310519598,
0.0154454503,
0.0020499101,
0.0184625573,
0.0146696065,
0.0617240965,
0.0371795073,
-0.0599656589,
0.0356880948,
-0.0185546111,
0.0228678957,
0.0229520425,
0.0007915152,
0.0607432202,
-0.0222261846,
0.0179734249,
0.000200861,
-0.0356992073,
0.0176132079,
0.0469531752,
-0.1392975748,
-0.076680094,
-0.0245837774,
-0.0139743974,
-0.0524424687,
-0.0259408075,
0.0112282764,
0.0063177468,
0.0691151991,
-0.0219486132,
0.0481861755,
-0.0041022664,
-0.040708378,
-0.0392444469,
-0.0372593813,
-0.0015023371,
0.0210607629,
-0.0130278561,
-0.0001066677,
0.0336537845,
0.0258997697,
0.0256742667,
-0.0482837148,
-0.0178283285,
0.0188511331,
0.0006031826,
0.0279783569,
0.0455330424,
-0.0170951486,
0.0385419726,
-0.0062368466,
-0.0112885227,
-0.0060173608,
0.012362102,
-0.0118288025,
0.0274592973,
-0.0152424267,
0.0168880168,
0.0285122655,
0.0083676465,
-0.0610367693,
-0.0040348209,
0.0197143834,
0.0214220155,
-0.0226481985,
-0.0264501907,
-0.0002386832,
-0.0251726545,
-0.0136166215,
-0.0391676798,
-0.0483172275,
-0.0156446323,
0.0061418596,
-0.0014204332,
-0.0198415685,
0.0227436628,
-0.0031096574,
-0.0201723967,
-0.0528945252,
0.0187501311,
0.0316167325,
-0.01574485,
0.0227057114,
0.0294812564,
-0.0818899348,
-0.0183288865,
0.0277943518,
-0.0314794071,
-0.0003791711,
0.0432079025,
0.0286554135,
-0.0158208385,
-0.0587303825,
-0.0173514001,
-0.0076073878,
0.0182250217,
-0.0430047587,
-0.0281208232,
0.0311406124,
0.0428318046,
-0.0019172594,
0.0899879783,
0.05167206,
-0.0345260948,
-0.0490599014,
0.0362218805,
0.0009282135,
0.0468304716,
0.0093328841,
-0.0227003805,
0.0084183561,
0.0572579689,
0.033997193,
-0.0414894335,
-0.0108805522,
-0.0062514353,
2.733e-7,
0.0484566018,
0.0330104232,
0.0086849257,
0.0297378562,
-0.0189868584,
0.031108629,
0.019228993,
0.0736014023,
-0.0258598793,
-0.0147787808,
0.0222782362,
-0.00730723,
0.0053951968,
0.0164207965,
-0.104662776,
-0.0130471205,
-0.0722165555,
-0.0000659022,
-0.0538562387,
-0.0254395511,
0.1049028933,
0.0993412212,
0.0575280115,
0.0068028835,
-0.0490364805,
-0.016027892,
0.0342005119,
-0.0234610904,
0.0233959779,
0.0200395733,
0.0129977698,
0.0021261135,
-0.0144068683,
0.0505178422,
-0.0308753364,
0.0366824158,
0.0077392962,
0.0297231339,
-0.0089954501,
-0.031618651,
-0.005272002,
-0.0027100779,
0.0257880241,
-0.0470563658,
0.067165345,
-0.0681800097,
0.0223493576,
-0.0076434142,
-0.0174639914,
-0.0053458572,
0.0404137857,
0.0108059226,
-0.0016912501,
0.0126461545,
0.0179441348,
-0.0173367895,
-0.0138554089,
-0.1044509485,
-0.01055439,
-0.0006835138,
0.0204864908,
-0.0056347069,
-0.0349226147,
-0.0071646972,
0.0312215388,
-0.037565209,
0.0035351582,
2.664100219e-34,
-0.012475023,
-0.0228637941,
-0.0230433028,
0.0491034575,
0.0038940848,
-0.0533938147,
-0.0111213783,
-0.0003958505,
0.0617025569,
-0.0522008836,
0.0277994405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10315v1 | Generalization algorithm of multimodal pre-training model based on graph-text self-supervised training | 2023-02-16T03:34:08 | 2023-02-16T03:34:08 | Zhangxiaobing, Tangzhenhao, Longzi, Fuxianghua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, a large number of studies have shown that the introduction of
visual information can effectively improve the effect of neural machine
translation (NMT). Its effectiveness largely depends on the availability of a
large number of bilingual parallel sentence pairs and manual image annotation.
The lack of images and the effectiveness of images have been difficult to
solve. In this paper, a multimodal pre-training generalization algorithm for
self-supervised training is proposed, which overcomes the lack of visual
information and inaccuracy, and thus extends the applicability of images on
NMT. Specifically, we will search for many pictures from the existing sentences
through the search engine, and then through the relationship between visual
information and text, do the self-supervised training task of graphics and text
to obtain more effective visual information for text. We show that when the
filtered information is used as multimodal machine translation for fine-tuning,
the effect of translation in the global voice dataset is 0.5 BLEU higher than
the baseline. | [
0.0343931429,
0.0026758129,
-0.0005236791,
0.030241346,
-0.0164347272,
-0.0110193845,
0.0210203882,
0.003984313,
0.0082211625,
-0.0432528332,
-0.064923346,
-0.0213965215,
-0.0060761734,
-0.0249235295,
0.0747228563,
-0.0728071406,
0.0131265,
0.0056370506,
-0.0074433205,
-0.0233160127,
0.0201676432,
0.0249932986,
-0.0254173595,
-0.0124364709,
-0.0732505023,
-0.0074724513,
-0.0134907579,
0.0727386847,
0.0063983304,
-0.0373822115,
-0.0634717494,
0.0313633978,
0.040550895,
-0.0044478374,
0.0000020517,
-0.0178814624,
-0.0137248849,
-0.0059614587,
0.0467864349,
-0.0182672348,
0.0511394665,
-0.028489776,
0.0045412211,
0.0140902428,
-0.0193740986,
-0.0375546366,
0.0738854855,
0.0341691598,
0.0893008336,
0.0886346921,
-0.0464373641,
-0.0509248786,
-0.0305886846,
-0.0148546752,
0.0106312688,
-0.036032293,
-0.0465826243,
0.0343497917,
-0.0245450642,
-0.0107497396,
-0.0482436046,
0.0784632266,
-0.0271427445,
-0.0075519346,
0.0134385088,
0.000597116,
-0.0183795132,
-0.0464376658,
-0.0206043124,
0.1160778478,
-0.0367739834,
-0.0031696453,
-0.0268356837,
-0.0027434113,
-0.0088155996,
0.0055193766,
-0.0308875646,
0.0241689086,
0.0084712664,
0.0112889679,
-0.0547244996,
0.014024172,
0.0455706976,
-0.0504623763,
-0.0315405913,
0.006265969,
0.0131942555,
-0.0105482601,
0.036579933,
0.0041863881,
-0.0083612716,
0.0117266467,
0.0423546098,
0.0089650173,
0.0090640048,
0.0208632927,
-0.0341668651,
-0.0686381608,
-0.02547062,
-0.0538616106,
0.0467719622,
0.0382050574,
-0.0416652523,
0.0573242232,
-0.0043380568,
0.0379043408,
-0.0324767493,
0.0510384813,
-0.0874723718,
-0.018865779,
-0.038951233,
0.0207218081,
-0.0804904103,
0.0005712128,
0.0017138458,
-0.0336104259,
-0.0399010405,
0.0096933283,
0.0055435258,
-0.0268155672,
0.0427595526,
-0.0088655259,
-0.0610859729,
-0.0094463117,
0.0032069366,
0.0390660651,
0.0127215041,
0.003214706,
-0.0499209985,
-0.026840739,
0.0156819262,
0.0223357249,
0.056790337,
-0.0279045682,
0.0056707817,
0.1016925797,
-0.0287305787,
-0.0555401295,
-0.0423925705,
0.0136057977,
-0.0263350569,
-0.0321628898,
0.0441697575,
-0.0349448919,
0.0661901385,
-0.020921411,
0.0400820524,
0.0169774592,
-0.0241863579,
-0.0280944277,
-0.0003271867,
0.0571467876,
-0.0192888416,
0.0358064137,
0.0560426563,
-0.0312937088,
0.0276360512,
0.0596409552,
0.0548211075,
0.0176960211,
0.0376648009,
-0.0413490534,
-0.0346534327,
0.0735237151,
0.0340005122,
0.0083647706,
-0.0261322074,
-0.0222946443,
0.0022046294,
0.026109254,
0.0294458661,
0.048942849,
-0.0372084789,
0.0049248631,
0.0838549882,
0.0355940945,
0.0534523427,
0.0062407772,
0.0494226702,
0.0259000659,
0.0198932961,
0.0273598731,
-0.0180815179,
0.0215431526,
-0.0043831887,
0.0062913154,
0.042097263,
0.0287661888,
-0.0430762507,
-0.0111439191,
0.023540182,
-0.0343992189,
0.0282815769,
-0.0190132651,
0.0277930852,
0.042885635,
-0.0445400327,
-0.0073423604,
-0.0043284474,
-0.0503119268,
0.0341058411,
0.0265546795,
-0.0528083369,
0.0465076454,
0.0294043571,
0.0142886667,
-0.0041038026,
0.0000042945,
-4.92e-7,
0.0167369917,
0.0299353302,
0.0258063339,
0.0309504494,
-0.0622299351,
-0.049339857,
-0.0131353689,
-0.0346821547,
0.0286692046,
-0.0413624905,
0.012948107,
0.0263361726,
-0.0322718211,
-0.0316038504,
0.0158604123,
0.0622529723,
-0.0155180488,
0.0161199383,
0.0504209846,
0.0220437739,
0.035596583,
-0.0248877276,
-0.0132837603,
-0.0057724272,
-0.0079129823,
-0.0037185429,
0.0470448546,
-0.0721480921,
-0.0618639067,
0.0266824253,
-0.0821007788,
0.0086990139,
-0.0040890835,
-0.0445778705,
-0.0815063491,
0.0043693553,
-0.0406271629,
-0.0076216245,
-0.0146650225,
0.0206998438,
0.0306823347,
-0.0047338605,
0.0116685322,
0.0059386147,
0.02935699,
-0.0411482416,
-0.0187418852,
0.0122787515,
0.0480693616,
-0.0718789473,
-0.0461636409,
0.0350947082,
0.0195668358,
0.0456033126,
0.0300071631,
0.0221617911,
-0.0408666469,
0.021077225,
-0.1214775369,
0.0035342474,
0.0013098178,
-0.0123038478,
0.0337774605,
0.0403220728,
0.0071872529,
-0.0716699958,
-0.0275752619,
0.0482174009,
0.0158610065,
-0.0003194555,
0.0068661855,
0.0086805234,
0.0526270308,
-0.024845846,
-0.0300418139,
0.0154530592,
0.0502815098,
0.018919982,
-0.039208401,
-0.0237819441,
0.0453060977,
-0.0532902405,
0.0533172339,
0.0089364173,
-0.0630321056,
0.0227033086,
-0.0100477543,
0.0616923645,
0.0278140567,
0.0108206877,
-0.0430887491,
0.0345499292,
0.0041694376,
-0.024883097,
0.009737174,
-0.0252297949,
-0.0008325791,
-0.0158456173,
-0.0147206411,
-0.0107181258,
0.0103294207,
0.0511044338,
0.0130362054,
-0.067227833,
-0.0407200456,
-0.0010324841,
-0.005032572,
-0.0462416299,
0.0235455558,
0.0163130518,
-0.0143730314,
-0.0101789627,
-0.067638576,
0.0555922054,
-0.0591878444,
-0.0110730873,
-0.0315795094,
-0.0378509946,
-0.022264434,
0.0668508783,
0.0217287727,
0.0393771827,
-0.0268986151,
-0.0064635468,
-0.0599042252,
0.0018647941,
0.0443450212,
-0.0069478392,
-0.0068668677,
-0.0028149353,
0.0031574047,
-0.0093022259,
-0.0009192924,
-0.0018578247,
-0.0038077573,
-0.0032919371,
-0.0396172665,
0.0267354846,
0.0113762794,
0.0125420755,
0.0225489717,
0.0259479489,
0.0437574387,
-0.0072796601,
0.0173806865,
-0.0268426389,
0.0340264626,
0.0010363501,
-0.0100974301,
-0.0880390778,
-0.0412485376,
0.0004588251,
-0.0339820459,
0.0019508218,
-0.0533777438,
-0.0763978511,
0.0040008412,
-0.0113938367,
0.028797647,
-0.0344366208,
0.004264351,
0.0423124991,
-0.0120391818,
0.0384392701,
0.0690327212,
-0.0169922523,
-0.0513278395,
-0.0407853238,
0.0479153544,
-0.0326725617,
0.0288205948,
0.0186358746,
-0.0852531195,
-0.0156160546,
-0.0375256613,
-0.0070334529,
0.0512216873,
0.0375209488,
-0.057116095,
-0.0597657375,
-0.0036068624,
0.0647850707,
-0.0517795235,
-0.0161068533,
0.0102059338,
-0.0385950543,
-0.0429778323,
0.0074010072,
-0.0324248374,
0.010367766,
0.0062661245,
0.0305782165,
0.0216115844,
-0.0508705452,
-0.034074679,
-0.0450670309,
-0.0311161038,
0.0346889086,
0.0550213978,
-0.0089654755,
-0.0180417839,
0.0614198595,
0.0334879719,
0.0449487753,
-0.0248678029,
0.0700656697,
-0.0040377406,
-0.0421808511,
0.0057568043,
-0.0219714195,
0.041685544,
0.0424381532,
0.0046882275,
0.04919957,
-0.0148133645,
0.0068141948,
0.0011495441,
0.0276177302,
-0.0017244518,
-0.0139532797,
0.0082461722,
-0.0453633256,
0.0075481497,
-0.0023956208,
0.0479091927,
-0.0815378577,
-0.0247374494,
0.0207966808,
-0.0457628556,
0.0107981246,
-0.0778043643,
-0.0237288252,
0.0072648851,
0.0709291697,
0.0336223729,
0.008634435,
0.0437164642,
-0.0006620398,
-0.0079794731,
0.0467416272,
-0.0314609073,
-0.0032559743,
-0.028195411,
-0.0391850844,
0.0082733417,
-0.0299902335,
0.0377820842,
0.0244468544,
-0.0567260571,
-0.0492204502,
-0.0547307841,
0.0727828443,
0.0094654933,
0.0592182092,
-0.0138884727,
-0.0464019813,
0.0386286527,
0.0182173997,
-0.0089025646,
-0.0231868438,
0.022763215,
-0.0015279767,
-0.0117518315,
-0.0061495765,
-0.0113872141,
0.0390596502,
-0.0235465262,
0.034103848,
0.015668435,
-0.0546705648,
0.0166640859,
0.0331970602,
0.0332946256,
-0.0217530653,
0.0408948623,
-0.0686987638,
0.0000845682,
-0.0091587603,
-0.0032177924,
-0.0508769229,
0.0048582209,
0.0369732417,
0.0046163998,
0.008185436,
-0.0165353101,
-0.0173335318,
-0.0092968326,
-0.0107959751,
-0.009137853,
-0.0291782878,
0.0056479461,
-0.0072003887,
0.0388168022,
0.0165018775,
0.05631724,
0.0307335705,
-0.0217468794,
-0.0123740779,
0.0448761955,
-0.0040958324,
0.0028822215,
-0.0138545772,
0.0366219468,
0.0022933299,
-0.0063025616,
-0.0288791917,
-0.0123970043,
0.0994724706,
-0.0022254656,
0.0801933184,
0.0214480739,
0.0039612874,
-0.0069051948,
0.0733909607,
-0.0032971159,
-0.0119566098,
0.0365888141,
-0.0470678248,
0.0093564996,
0.0321777277,
0.0410948992,
0.0029606014,
-0.0263743978,
0.0058851745,
-0.0046505579,
-0.0362187661,
-0.0136514604,
0.0110278632,
0.0057027545,
-0.0235075392,
-0.0169659294,
0.050263498,
-0.0817035139,
-0.0124214217,
0.0033125151,
-0.0168111101,
0.0194543041,
0.0666887537,
0.0433661379,
-0.0060107391,
0.0141810495,
-0.0158954542,
0.0061459253,
0.017485328,
0.0146720344,
0.0080813738,
-6.064331642e-33,
-0.0413664505,
-0.0299521443,
0.0317416787,
-0.0279857237,
-0.0321614966,
-0.0240855906,
-0.0200307965,
0.0034884913,
-0.0040105311,
0.0072832042,
0.0276718792,
0.0080655068,
0.0184672475,
0.012061175,
-0.048860617,
0.0562455393,
0.0717871338,
-0.0244779903,
0.0017365796,
0.0260764807,
0.0370822996,
0.062810868,
0.0924403891,
-0.0938797146,
-0.0168255679,
0.0017282509,
-0.0220351964,
0.0192132909,
0.025615992,
0.0173340756,
-0.0003072255,
0.0276791789,
-0.0023837895,
0.0113030886,
-0.0330406651,
-0.0172809828,
-0.0751369074,
-0.0339884795,
0.028915653,
0.0646001697,
-0.0634404495,
0.0000462987,
0.0658680052,
-0.0644753501,
0.0139529128,
-0.0055283601,
0.0509763695,
-0.0092407009,
-0.0226931106,
-0.0156786274,
-0.018768236,
0.0187291317,
-0.0164894387,
0.0063456963,
0.0459798276,
0.0731029287,
-0.0111832032,
-0.0049404488,
-0.0653135628,
0.0442051217,
-0.0412217006,
-0.0016359076,
0.0622228682,
0.0332521424,
0.008562698,
-0.0112198303,
0.0387806594,
-0.0191204231,
0.0144961867,
0.0000593361,
0.0262238774,
0.011489029,
0.0294241328,
0.0222765543,
0.0075842906,
-0.0231651831,
-0.0696820617,
0.0337422639,
-0.065418452,
0.0046031079,
0.0021224839,
0.0459442921,
0.0140497219,
0.0000719609,
-0.0439099893,
-0.0509958714,
-0.0252946634,
-0.0584479645,
0.0037720997,
0.0065266276,
-0.0050326115,
0.003677323,
0.0691984072,
-0.0203774478,
-0.0115690883,
0.000196104,
-0.0614434257,
0.0183137432,
-0.0293220803,
0.0204903986,
-0.0220874157,
-0.0736702979,
0.0449005589,
0.0152115338,
0.0307231341,
-0.0039768182,
0.0496494547,
0.0443224907,
-0.0173217766,
-0.0119705228,
-0.0281784683,
-0.0566160455,
-0.0317366235,
-0.0025078787,
0.0202784035,
-0.0010529548,
-0.0498775542,
0.0640913323,
0.0266525578,
-0.0095021194,
-0.0170700923,
-0.0519088469,
0.0422735065,
0.0408828668,
-0.0479721278,
0.0163045619,
-0.0177530106,
-0.0044721467,
0.0460586064,
-0.0667518899,
-0.0412481502,
0.0111139202,
2.76e-7,
0.0539505929,
0.0177498143,
0.0024024933,
0.0349986218,
0.0083225071,
0.0094796298,
-0.0646962225,
0.0167009383,
0.0100183496,
0.0142470459,
0.0521855615,
0.0264624692,
0.0396299399,
0.019475922,
-0.0502289683,
-0.0240656529,
-0.0499953441,
0.005985376,
-0.0382757038,
0.0365983211,
0.0316495486,
0.0780982375,
-0.0006219677,
-0.0214841273,
-0.0153485676,
-0.0396951213,
0.0913072675,
-0.0111643812,
-0.0376864038,
-0.0333778821,
0.0317267329,
0.0365920551,
-0.0779125839,
0.0066886032,
-0.0361781418,
0.0242789481,
0.0609727986,
0.01619385,
-0.0190078709,
0.0163390264,
0.0198825374,
0.0214595832,
-0.0455330685,
-0.0052484768,
0.0418503061,
-0.0425201729,
-0.0242846366,
0.0173163656,
-0.002225671,
0.0167263877,
0.0521224067,
-0.0409186818,
-0.0532379709,
0.0183025692,
0.0686404705,
-0.0106707215,
-0.0367399901,
-0.0374690369,
-0.0334972888,
0.0352077149,
0.0020139904,
-0.0108658317,
-0.029269835,
-0.0116019407,
0.0102598201,
0.0319202021,
0.0148758227,
1.676173325e-34,
0.0178073812,
-0.0337689407,
0.0336361155,
-0.0797692761,
0.0178755727,
-0.0288597513,
-0.0454712734,
-0.0083163697,
-0.0004110439,
-0.040343605,
-0.0486863554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08043v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08043v3 | GraphPrompt: Unifying Pre-Training and Downstream Tasks for Graph Neural Networks | 2023-02-16T02:51:38 | 2023-02-25T03:00:10 | Zemin Liu, Xingtong Yu, Yuan Fang, Xinming Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Graphs can model complex relationships between objects, enabling a myriad of
Web applications such as online page/article classification and social
recommendation. While graph neural networks(GNNs) have emerged as a powerful
tool for graph representation learning, in an end-to-end supervised setting,
their performance heavily rely on a large amount of task-specific supervision.
To reduce labeling requirement, the "pre-train, fine-tune" and "pre-train,
prompt" paradigms have become increasingly common. In particular, prompting is
a popular alternative to fine-tuning in natural language processing, which is
designed to narrow the gap between pre-training and downstream objectives in a
task-specific manner. However, existing study of prompting on graphs is still
limited, lacking a universal treatment to appeal to different downstream tasks.
In this paper, we propose GraphPrompt, a novel pre-training and prompting
framework on graphs. GraphPrompt not only unifies pre-training and downstream
tasks into a common task template, but also employs a learnable prompt to
assist a downstream task in locating the most relevant knowledge from the
pre-train model in a task-specific manner. Finally, we conduct extensive
experiments on five public datasets to evaluate and analyze GraphPrompt. | [
0.067587018,
0.0109033175,
0.0142178219,
0.0232757293,
-0.0206401478,
0.006014389,
-0.0038492703,
0.0134514784,
0.0790100992,
-0.0499580652,
-0.0335727297,
-0.0171548855,
-0.0162105449,
0.048201602,
0.0262372009,
-0.0295057315,
0.0251161028,
0.0161561035,
0.0390899554,
0.0065373508,
0.001867004,
0.0405385047,
0.0149484957,
0.0199561976,
-0.0183231588,
-0.0271617975,
-0.0003952326,
0.0411538258,
-0.0367613211,
-0.0603256486,
0.0209898688,
0.0507101342,
0.0086643659,
0.0021052479,
0.0000019465,
-0.0257706605,
0.0254769903,
-0.0121515179,
-0.0463948548,
-0.0151944505,
0.0324499123,
-0.0320684835,
0.0534892641,
-0.0182033945,
-0.0671425089,
-0.0293748789,
0.0370908007,
0.0548150614,
0.0340403765,
0.0746720731,
-0.0216480065,
0.0083886813,
-0.0032772066,
-0.0356151834,
0.0007890148,
-0.0439830534,
0.0096768774,
-0.0408537164,
0.0239055604,
0.0228396207,
-0.051416941,
0.009989324,
0.0133299222,
-0.0110543575,
0.0664672479,
0.0263583381,
0.0178499687,
-0.0062692133,
-0.0472219847,
0.1606738567,
-0.0210281201,
-0.0043725683,
0.0188208092,
-0.0456102192,
0.0200574677,
0.0193406027,
-0.0361414701,
-0.0392233506,
0.011431288,
-0.0025132904,
-0.0372904055,
-0.0177434999,
0.0436677821,
-0.0111483699,
0.0294129159,
0.0696313977,
-0.0347941592,
-0.0150290765,
0.0534680374,
0.0289445259,
-0.0221151356,
-0.0571024492,
0.0268359911,
0.0267289411,
-0.0711373463,
-0.0070653474,
-0.0388756953,
0.0103418855,
0.0077252188,
0.0191837065,
0.0611178502,
-0.0332690366,
-0.032808084,
0.043728698,
0.027404489,
0.0145273311,
-0.007272108,
0.0634676293,
-0.0213525202,
0.0364106968,
-0.0490066893,
0.0201173816,
-0.0584609695,
0.0150695713,
-0.003673512,
-0.0816926882,
-0.0362637639,
0.0339280553,
-0.0341446139,
0.0108706532,
0.0219799764,
0.0631022006,
-0.0040622945,
0.0109591046,
-0.0018785856,
0.0201557558,
-0.0344342329,
0.0153885502,
-0.0061251619,
-0.0143310474,
-0.0146083729,
0.0087340288,
0.0665332153,
-0.0179799628,
0.0305672307,
0.0539541021,
0.0520646349,
-0.0483654588,
-0.0078216884,
-0.0430417433,
-0.003225002,
-0.0408796184,
0.040667519,
-0.0387841277,
0.0553763993,
0.0190405678,
-0.0150960516,
-0.0104497205,
0.0048301681,
0.0046098004,
-0.0426363908,
0.0833637267,
-0.0256518945,
-0.0087898765,
-0.0291768722,
-0.0142763015,
-0.020060651,
0.0263778549,
-0.0064583234,
0.0590198115,
0.0426448397,
0.0127340406,
-0.0126666129,
0.0020212054,
0.0517669842,
-0.014286682,
0.0395688675,
0.009108807,
-0.0366928615,
0.0090811765,
0.0044811098,
0.0470691621,
-0.0269434452,
-0.0220836885,
0.0316681638,
0.0467471406,
-0.0017044606,
-0.02227032,
0.0659562647,
0.0546268187,
-0.0205933824,
0.0223700721,
-0.104391925,
0.0238789637,
-0.0009135979,
0.0016905076,
-0.0148423789,
-0.0310249068,
-0.0106113413,
-0.0147957485,
0.0417360179,
-0.0403200798,
0.0823673159,
0.0190393254,
0.040824499,
0.046851892,
-0.0479061939,
-0.0144071775,
0.032042481,
0.0099348826,
-0.0096464818,
-0.0059438162,
0.0046610888,
0.0635810271,
0.0238321424,
-0.0271778274,
-0.0479805171,
-0.0153120477,
0.0397135168,
-0.0342373252,
0.0782901943,
-0.0253713094,
0.0103854509,
-0.0320416912,
-0.0674512461,
-0.0469379835,
-0.0110015944,
-0.0035251169,
0.0149492174,
-0.0169171188,
0.0116584906,
-0.0533021539,
-0.052303791,
0.0129384734,
0.0633064657,
0.0052347113,
0.0040610922,
0.0212763529,
-0.0169668775,
0.0474312752,
0.0256620944,
0.0094261644,
0.0220611077,
0.0171479974,
-0.0113622108,
-0.0497400537,
-0.0492647849,
-0.0447507463,
0.0457246229,
-0.0192049854,
-0.0602517053,
-0.0021891871,
-0.0619846396,
-0.0298997182,
0.0521883629,
-0.0511228181,
0.0297134519,
0.0146831842,
-0.0391224846,
0.0018267232,
0.0149845844,
0.0114405919,
0.0515627749,
0.0191469155,
0.0217363928,
0.0145678008,
0.0118567469,
-0.0106545351,
-0.0447313003,
-0.0210930388,
-0.00607066,
-0.0013913021,
0.0074853217,
0.0267682672,
0.0373634733,
-0.0831141472,
0.0458080731,
-0.0940428525,
-0.0080324775,
-0.0166490711,
0.0221948996,
-0.0268616006,
0.0202667266,
-0.0002062615,
-0.0893622339,
-0.0689196885,
0.0376124531,
-0.0116511611,
0.0321804062,
0.0460949875,
-0.0161551535,
0.0128420368,
-0.0127191627,
-0.0430724919,
-0.0124938274,
0.0682816207,
0.0550041273,
-0.0271743573,
-0.0094582858,
0.0247018281,
-0.0357138775,
0.0040251948,
0.0130780442,
0.0302157495,
0.0080051376,
-0.0062136464,
0.0438461378,
0.0464666858,
-0.0263182689,
0.0317629986,
0.0162694789,
0.010437848,
-0.0431722403,
-0.0186164677,
-0.0709798485,
-0.0072067282,
-0.0211078376,
0.0069686049,
-0.0022534158,
0.0155762043,
-0.0039350279,
-0.0219084788,
-0.0460720249,
-0.0025439607,
-0.0198273826,
0.0203986857,
-0.0390089676,
-0.0335530862,
0.034246821,
-0.0094275344,
-0.0458008833,
-0.0318846218,
0.0919283777,
0.0132337278,
-0.0234893896,
0.043865025,
-0.0371170901,
-0.0482714884,
0.0682345033,
0.0572730415,
0.0193739533,
0.0245823767,
-0.0501885861,
-0.045839671,
0.0264057107,
0.0198914167,
-0.0287695546,
-0.0108498028,
0.047747571,
0.021232646,
0.0110914819,
-0.0136938635,
0.0057022134,
-0.0303560216,
-0.0176269058,
0.0258637071,
-0.0016288796,
-0.0241092965,
0.0408403538,
-0.0265388563,
-0.044635348,
0.0218728874,
-0.0313856937,
-0.0070389924,
-0.0300926268,
0.0253152661,
0.0196868945,
0.0177271031,
-0.0080569889,
-0.0437757149,
-0.0140499445,
0.029606035,
0.0214868132,
-0.0329080001,
-0.0405997112,
0.0362383351,
0.0050432882,
-0.0012770492,
-0.0177076664,
-0.0023039877,
0.0514822863,
-0.0394290164,
0.0081122834,
0.054649882,
0.0209173448,
-0.0835101977,
0.0122983679,
0.0485841893,
0.0012592413,
0.0278745312,
0.0021205337,
-0.1062311232,
-0.033561904,
-0.0153073873,
0.0398405455,
0.0451318622,
-0.0457609668,
-0.026323352,
-0.0706406459,
0.025750652,
-0.0035072039,
0.0136632379,
-0.0158421732,
-0.0642037764,
0.0168251116,
-0.0040934384,
-0.0003225615,
-0.0448215939,
-0.0313972831,
-0.0073025264,
0.0127497232,
0.0039830375,
-0.0624438487,
0.0150162941,
-0.046271313,
0.0185615737,
-0.0100121982,
0.0303546134,
0.0381908379,
0.0118195303,
0.0477504916,
0.0316118561,
-0.0165929645,
-0.0377463289,
0.0859937519,
-0.0038178188,
0.0064714556,
-0.0387504995,
0.0036355392,
-0.0454505719,
-0.0346611589,
-0.0511023663,
0.0803359151,
-0.0132774292,
-0.0502207577,
0.0020199961,
0.0091543319,
0.0392682664,
0.0197061542,
0.0740324929,
-0.0067396113,
-0.0445556231,
-0.0410053842,
0.0319926329,
-0.051255282,
-0.0257013887,
0.0053473995,
-0.0666682646,
0.0269427951,
-0.0427509472,
-0.0540080406,
0.0401375666,
-0.0063681384,
0.0106615676,
-0.0172197409,
0.0570459254,
-0.0362168588,
-0.0921041965,
0.0491584204,
-0.0181275588,
0.0213930607,
-0.0245075729,
-0.049787242,
0.0231627505,
-0.0095244525,
0.0066946913,
0.0185009409,
-0.0639847517,
-0.0693885088,
-0.0491442196,
0.0083946986,
0.0136605855,
0.0507934242,
-0.0370319039,
-0.0367691591,
0.0255863518,
0.0582771003,
-0.0338916183,
-0.0291678496,
0.0221519433,
-0.0299122799,
-0.0239701793,
0.025865173,
-0.0481799804,
0.0349117368,
0.0248283166,
0.0083139706,
0.0024379897,
-0.0442652516,
0.0042181546,
0.0714005604,
0.0482875556,
0.0191042088,
0.0186830945,
-0.0886066929,
-0.0537371784,
0.0280814264,
-0.0381059237,
-0.0221008249,
-0.0064417012,
0.0051977988,
-0.0011579235,
-0.0265743602,
-0.0440026745,
0.0164634231,
0.0338248014,
-0.0770061836,
-0.0201749206,
0.0118119866,
-0.0439188741,
0.0519462116,
0.0216785911,
0.0146277035,
0.0548589937,
0.0305757411,
0.0144320577,
-0.0180717334,
0.0155505547,
0.0398665331,
0.0014080275,
-0.0506763272,
0.0372427516,
-0.0525035299,
-0.0358072743,
-0.0097303856,
0.0140193673,
0.0226010233,
-0.0208304301,
0.0229854472,
0.0048098881,
0.0081750015,
-0.0013864824,
0.0640811101,
-0.0186181311,
-0.0517793223,
0.0297166463,
0.0171594825,
-0.0062952172,
0.0396956429,
0.0354345627,
0.0050896825,
0.0083344979,
0.006162744,
-0.0452532358,
-0.0449427813,
-0.0231514424,
-0.0023426085,
0.042860426,
-0.0204826836,
0.0225084927,
-0.0165774673,
-0.0850354955,
0.0074612517,
-0.0186857618,
-0.0048879492,
0.0416258574,
0.042205926,
0.0255259108,
0.0347945429,
-0.0105663259,
-0.0393803529,
0.0212838408,
0.0256451163,
-0.033384338,
0.0084159561,
-6.512715513e-33,
0.0054041138,
-0.0671676472,
0.0003770771,
0.0369837508,
-0.0539725795,
0.0348584577,
-0.0485417321,
-0.0281882025,
-0.0109642772,
0.0361065082,
-0.0233229958,
0.0199050792,
0.0068140333,
0.0096207717,
-0.0188895967,
-0.0613595881,
0.0361453518,
-0.0182066858,
0.0053643738,
0.0589933209,
0.0311917812,
0.044249922,
0.0297869612,
-0.0712995231,
0.06770394,
-0.019729536,
0.0194747988,
0.0045616785,
0.0200261958,
0.0334308967,
-0.0136261731,
0.0845077336,
0.0296660699,
0.0342849679,
-0.0052781766,
0.0687100589,
-0.0982085839,
-0.0608186312,
-0.0197587982,
0.0173404589,
-0.0732189342,
-0.00366719,
0.0289422385,
-0.0062681581,
0.0328777209,
-0.0150381029,
0.0509850457,
0.0469766557,
-0.0316896029,
0.004802255,
-0.0366328396,
0.0064534093,
0.0040902337,
-0.0258257259,
0.0225515626,
0.0276904181,
0.0199328698,
-0.009946296,
-0.0514333919,
0.0294711031,
-0.0352741182,
-0.0247906819,
-0.00968959,
0.0130663784,
-0.0184850488,
0.0438152403,
0.0029720247,
0.0204280075,
-0.0054447339,
0.0314983428,
0.0293546505,
0.0667743906,
-0.008171007,
-0.0363018364,
0.0141105531,
-0.0214726031,
-0.0646933466,
-0.013412361,
0.0305999294,
-0.0086112795,
-0.019536037,
0.0006897058,
0.0032018598,
-0.0581373721,
0.0044931276,
-0.0488237552,
-0.0449427813,
-0.0206452794,
0.0006647917,
0.0204424411,
-0.0289501194,
0.0487796068,
-0.0283068065,
-0.0692828745,
-0.0231167786,
0.0627763793,
0.0174993984,
0.0227883421,
-0.0017889031,
-0.0023514389,
-0.0479167551,
-0.0283955596,
0.0290748663,
-0.0492132343,
0.0233876668,
0.0090210754,
0.0881104693,
0.0146748545,
-0.0346810929,
-0.0052493247,
-0.0376160741,
0.027541507,
-0.0194940921,
-0.0032884537,
0.046474006,
0.0664863512,
-0.0351350456,
0.0682075173,
0.0571897402,
0.0228123087,
-0.0407419913,
0.0259733256,
0.01420293,
0.0322903171,
-0.0217591766,
-0.0403139479,
-0.0224225912,
0.0547756553,
0.0271093138,
-0.0636358857,
-0.0305124298,
-0.0157353319,
2.721e-7,
0.0373124257,
0.0460260957,
0.0474883206,
0.0405473523,
-0.004633937,
0.0125058098,
0.0043510543,
0.055687245,
-0.0043005394,
-0.0110899331,
0.0576456115,
0.0560468882,
-0.0346313119,
0.0072570047,
-0.0561636798,
0.0230662525,
-0.0800227895,
-0.0317376964,
-0.0461760536,
0.0201846659,
0.0345021635,
0.0195833482,
0.0286703855,
-0.0212917086,
-0.0142794941,
-0.0394653901,
0.0445792414,
-0.0277351532,
0.006666516,
0.0063185063,
0.020617079,
0.006511013,
-0.0293065812,
0.0477566607,
-0.026993176,
0.0270742662,
0.0369233787,
0.014321899,
-0.0043558073,
0.0053185783,
0.0016554302,
-0.001218684,
0.0228903666,
0.0093919532,
0.0589203686,
-0.0771898553,
-0.0220771842,
-0.039781373,
-0.0226162337,
-0.0398945473,
0.0481316559,
-0.0168356374,
0.0114162844,
0.0132293208,
0.019168213,
-0.0164451059,
-0.0207927935,
-0.0755054131,
0.0159482211,
0.0347775668,
0.0244250428,
-0.0373790301,
0.0009493873,
0.0279370453,
0.0124593135,
-0.0287273414,
0.0059491456,
2.14601968e-34,
0.0196898635,
-0.0071376511,
0.0126430243,
-0.022765765,
0.0064596226,
-0.0171231907,
-0.023071114,
0.0020092665,
0.0316322073,
-0.0840052366,
-0.0212105475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09300v1 | Search-Engine-augmented Dialogue Response Generation with Cheaply Supervised Query Production | 2023-02-16T01:58:10 | 2023-02-16T01:58:10 | Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Qi Liu, Haitao Mi, Longyue Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge-aided dialogue response generation aims at augmenting chatbots with
relevant external knowledge in the hope of generating more informative
responses. The majority of previous work assumes that the relevant knowledge is
given as input or retrieved from a static pool of knowledge. However, this
assumption violates the real-world situation, where knowledge is continually
updated and a chatbot has to dynamically retrieve useful knowledge. We propose
a dialogue model that can access the vast and dynamic information from any
search engine for response generation. As the core module, a query producer is
used to generate queries from a dialogue context to interact with a search
engine. We design a training algorithm using cheap noisy supervision for the
query producer, where the signals are obtained by comparing retrieved articles
with the next dialogue response. As the result, the query producer is adjusted
without any human annotation of gold queries, making it easily transferable to
other domains and search engines. Experiments show that our query producer can
achieve R@1 and R@5 rates of 62.4% and 74.8% for retrieving gold knowledge, and
the overall model generates better responses over strong knowledge-aided
baselines using BART and other typical systems. | [
0.0900625363,
0.0302633643,
-0.0044736257,
-0.0046859537,
-0.0058864444,
0.0010721865,
-0.0146260438,
0.0076158023,
0.0533186086,
-0.0750169158,
-0.0171341915,
0.0140264789,
-0.0673596784,
0.0459988937,
0.0046987874,
-0.0412038378,
0.0515637696,
-0.0221625417,
0.0144331427,
0.0061718817,
0.0280400459,
0.0200798959,
-0.0347388126,
0.0559071414,
-0.0494322218,
-0.0043001636,
-0.0674443096,
-0.0002718588,
-0.0104604037,
-0.0055488218,
0.0282966029,
0.0494162738,
0.0213228688,
0.0570200905,
0.0000015799,
-0.0396108218,
-0.003666372,
-0.0060671931,
-0.0350188464,
-0.0593903847,
0.0117999921,
0.0195731651,
0.0402093716,
0.0508577116,
-0.0641335249,
0.0287911072,
0.0487506129,
0.05468072,
0.060644947,
0.0888017118,
-0.0035232916,
0.0062117334,
0.0053367829,
-0.010900721,
0.0598207824,
-0.0553390719,
-0.0034532978,
0.0100964848,
0.0448631421,
0.029550638,
0.0053271423,
0.0264879391,
0.0065546706,
-0.0854080766,
0.0481936932,
0.0117610469,
-0.0619577877,
-0.0113001326,
-0.0152868889,
0.0878688321,
0.0423054397,
-0.0114183323,
0.0065021026,
0.021981949,
0.0344791375,
0.0090558752,
-0.0416723862,
0.0092939977,
-0.0044062263,
-0.0170080233,
-0.0307706874,
-0.0069424892,
-0.028141629,
0.0041902228,
-0.0036286756,
0.0236650202,
0.0093317581,
-0.0321274847,
-0.0126091903,
0.0113584278,
0.0265750717,
-0.0619595237,
-0.0179723538,
0.0635606572,
-0.056928575,
0.0286815949,
-0.0363409743,
-0.0105052926,
0.0127661033,
-0.0461842231,
-0.0486989953,
0.0357187502,
-0.0029213566,
0.0389351994,
-0.016568264,
0.0344648175,
0.0015112923,
0.0209081229,
-0.0290915072,
-0.0223885253,
-0.0645460039,
-0.0316832811,
-0.0404695682,
0.0358406454,
-0.0312173367,
-0.0364155881,
-0.0250221957,
0.0542497784,
0.0344073288,
0.0027994628,
-0.007061956,
0.0518801771,
-0.0576056018,
0.022937648,
-0.040406581,
-0.011561254,
-0.0141108148,
0.0151191428,
0.0563162826,
-0.0663838238,
-0.0231180005,
0.0307926219,
0.0114156995,
0.006630261,
-0.0293573737,
0.0735965222,
-0.033498548,
-0.0201003868,
-0.0176702682,
-0.0566111803,
-0.0019139551,
-0.0214377623,
-0.0026327327,
0.0074213427,
0.0536802933,
-0.0149689969,
-0.0509926006,
0.0017151126,
0.027281234,
0.0316040553,
-0.015208941,
0.0156589393,
-0.0387740806,
-0.0044038249,
0.0273171868,
0.004274738,
-0.0033272828,
0.0918023437,
0.0160531215,
0.0237183422,
0.0326416418,
0.0167487152,
0.0057726922,
-0.0365559906,
0.0336871743,
-0.0227572601,
0.0162938014,
0.0292895492,
-0.0243172664,
0.0429552197,
0.0056382744,
0.0302447546,
-0.0333290398,
-0.0061969524,
0.0385621004,
0.0077800998,
-0.0064766714,
0.010672099,
0.0381054841,
0.0246353205,
0.0132142985,
0.0024412831,
-0.021193577,
0.0356543958,
-0.0434656478,
-0.016399296,
0.0361685343,
-0.0171444062,
-0.0319012068,
-0.0252525415,
0.0381445698,
0.0137270922,
-0.012284725,
0.0277330019,
0.0457107425,
0.0263787173,
-0.0248690266,
-0.0063037183,
0.0014431785,
-0.0355693959,
-0.0092671197,
-0.0452880263,
0.0392475799,
0.0690532327,
0.0691438913,
-0.0221656431,
-0.0359238051,
-0.0092327222,
-0.0217847191,
0.0853826925,
0.0404839925,
-0.0321484096,
0.0277844071,
-0.0345556363,
-0.0460464098,
-0.0063348133,
0.0043996628,
0.0308507718,
0.0317043811,
0.0128058903,
0.0420387723,
-0.0126975775,
-0.0077724745,
0.0290324967,
0.0213050637,
-0.0243802667,
0.0090585221,
-0.0199080501,
0.023138959,
0.0269444212,
-0.0008757824,
0.0191026628,
0.0262144431,
0.0082575111,
-0.0680817068,
0.0208827052,
-0.019363327,
-0.0566092283,
0.0156014813,
-0.0210629199,
0.0174215101,
0.0002765665,
-0.0219150949,
-0.0573783554,
0.002592271,
-0.0533683673,
0.0543703027,
-0.0540725514,
-0.014678211,
0.0287958737,
0.0037307807,
-0.0387098566,
0.0398037992,
0.0256822463,
-0.0168490559,
0.0266712848,
0.0065288711,
-0.0063212016,
-0.0718239695,
0.0004663034,
-0.0196117945,
-0.0175405927,
0.0193080809,
0.046465382,
0.0220441967,
-0.0582139082,
-0.0005523951,
-0.119087331,
-0.0047022849,
0.0074763256,
-0.0236640051,
0.016946448,
0.0245232116,
0.0123330932,
-0.0353866071,
-0.0664124042,
0.0204739906,
0.0408727899,
0.0308926161,
0.0424885452,
0.0436643511,
0.0054900735,
-0.0532029197,
0.0263259988,
0.0253471229,
0.0161049906,
0.0508932211,
0.0096240574,
-0.0349807702,
0.0259497724,
-0.0610674471,
0.0366460271,
-0.0038860284,
-0.038808275,
0.0320612006,
-0.0360940881,
-0.0162995253,
0.0546067469,
0.0866280124,
0.0178969745,
-0.0009982334,
0.0002005443,
-0.1031324565,
0.0260710921,
-0.0351847075,
-0.0160802938,
-0.0158686098,
0.0030399156,
0.0370858572,
0.0107901935,
0.0113825323,
0.0159529001,
-0.0535954386,
0.0206761695,
0.0462511629,
-0.0758933425,
-0.0401438586,
0.0207197256,
-0.0109688295,
0.0322832279,
0.0005623145,
-0.0208634101,
0.0901550651,
0.0063656336,
-0.0048714271,
-0.0355795622,
-0.0100756614,
-0.005589426,
0.0248592868,
-0.03411448,
0.0474379249,
-0.0065954486,
-0.0104867006,
-0.0409874767,
0.0093611544,
0.0447639748,
-0.0445041433,
0.0003758124,
-0.0162771642,
0.0325413421,
0.0160051379,
-0.0366688594,
-0.0850094482,
-0.0367446803,
0.0083606681,
-0.0157047827,
0.0478532389,
-0.048103217,
-0.0251180436,
0.0269844308,
0.0442846715,
0.0358706266,
-0.0265022386,
-0.0419724546,
-0.0046986393,
0.0366019569,
0.0511437841,
0.0318826921,
-0.0181030612,
-0.00415044,
0.041315604,
0.0450685769,
0.0408611298,
-0.0151894744,
-0.0022243194,
-0.0349051617,
0.0042237947,
-0.006661267,
0.0155776525,
-0.0179297347,
0.0132042477,
-0.0236626044,
-0.0426012576,
0.0979517326,
0.0298679937,
-0.0345039442,
-0.0191752613,
-0.0268882774,
0.0127832694,
0.0117315659,
0.0655151904,
-0.0610803179,
-0.0147380689,
-0.0098475423,
0.055890657,
-0.0259083454,
-0.0314441323,
-0.0130073847,
-0.113173306,
0.0095829861,
-0.0294114258,
-0.0295418408,
-0.0296114646,
-0.0223072451,
0.0043702656,
0.0016096052,
-0.0266208369,
0.0284962263,
-0.003474432,
0.008107434,
0.0376181193,
0.0189004838,
-0.0391219966,
-0.0322812796,
0.0119581399,
0.0414638221,
0.0778268501,
0.0383576937,
0.0417573601,
0.041472014,
0.0088898074,
0.0032362298,
0.026373893,
-0.0240176879,
0.0721321553,
-0.0219281446,
-0.0118750511,
-0.0403353162,
0.0067620361,
-0.010152542,
0.0307240095,
0.0263169464,
0.0060901688,
-0.0506328531,
0.0339697562,
-0.0362864695,
0.0288681984,
0.0201296937,
0.0737418309,
0.0310150348,
-0.0122382892,
-0.0298453104,
-0.0258048177,
-0.0031131227,
-0.0575297438,
-0.0048737749,
-0.0067324899,
-0.0205754973,
0.0122718681,
-0.1187173799,
-0.0566127002,
0.0154590681,
0.0475566462,
0.0041596955,
-0.0149370721,
-0.0071466118,
0.0252454337,
-0.0097686015,
-0.0195207596,
-0.0376672149,
-0.0437853523,
-0.0404038057,
-0.0398544893,
0.0415421985,
-0.0634471774,
-0.0269058067,
0.0081843371,
-0.012577001,
-0.0627805442,
-0.0397436135,
0.0623869561,
0.0258495808,
0.0434739515,
-0.0233196821,
-0.0131567139,
0.0159832668,
0.0900748819,
-0.0487063676,
-0.0299690086,
0.02408888,
0.0397574529,
-0.0065087792,
0.0307371691,
-0.0900472328,
-0.0134491287,
-0.0353320651,
0.0505083986,
-0.032582134,
-0.0677905083,
0.0536908731,
0.0280822515,
0.0040267827,
-0.0007534896,
0.0346904397,
-0.0102953557,
0.0270963926,
-0.0370758325,
-0.0158961713,
-0.0634031445,
0.0332447439,
-0.031288337,
-0.013842796,
0.0311606303,
0.0082833581,
-0.0348452888,
0.0585950762,
-0.038774889,
-0.0575583465,
-0.0041026226,
0.0052265804,
0.0048114648,
0.0059845196,
-0.0239574667,
0.0272288006,
0.0343032368,
0.0192246009,
-0.009997136,
0.0711179823,
0.0371790752,
-0.0355939157,
0.0319371149,
0.0079000518,
-0.1227564067,
-0.0760402083,
-0.027291825,
0.0227576997,
0.0276543573,
0.0112192389,
0.0221842341,
-0.0466710404,
0.0189997312,
-0.0102434251,
0.0512468405,
0.0074124141,
-0.0123935696,
0.0057969075,
0.0115997847,
-0.0119748209,
0.0176967811,
0.0787361711,
-0.0173218939,
0.0276407786,
-0.0245370902,
-0.0324359387,
-0.0520440638,
-0.0425472334,
0.0386044867,
0.0411303379,
0.0029371097,
0.0108928932,
-0.0070665143,
-0.0307999235,
-0.045551233,
-0.0089495024,
0.006124727,
-0.0008987417,
0.0739485025,
0.0706399754,
0.0038086935,
-0.0062908698,
-0.0559418723,
0.0240034703,
-0.0596741438,
-0.0154333441,
-0.00692291,
-5.633591206e-33,
-0.0432201177,
-0.0332732946,
0.013069992,
-0.007671535,
-0.0344201289,
-0.0202864241,
-0.0549250431,
-0.0190401915,
-0.0309605766,
-0.0054685157,
-0.0048011667,
0.0211486351,
0.0011145399,
0.0171443522,
0.0034525176,
-0.0331377238,
0.0462258458,
-0.0142162479,
-0.0031762256,
0.0793706998,
0.0827115476,
0.0386021063,
-0.0108545534,
-0.0452164225,
-0.0001452065,
-0.0266222563,
-0.0174323432,
0.0392594747,
0.0162519831,
0.0484304205,
-0.0245185271,
0.0454797335,
0.018233899,
0.006802314,
-0.0008722128,
-0.0012190111,
-0.0660334304,
-0.0267883334,
-0.0125604626,
-0.0079253959,
-0.0158382189,
0.0108117945,
0.0220579989,
-0.0385323651,
0.0364422239,
0.0293716975,
0.0284504872,
-0.0133384345,
-0.0304143038,
-0.0585905798,
-0.0541816726,
-0.0058957548,
-0.0269018169,
-0.0592126027,
-0.0274664871,
0.1066609174,
0.0453530028,
-0.019374935,
0.0247641653,
0.0399403088,
-0.0094816973,
0.0158514027,
0.0330283195,
0.0330736041,
0.0158030558,
0.0517596267,
0.0076038647,
-0.0018142647,
-0.0041774497,
-0.0078707552,
-0.0093239555,
0.0257720184,
0.007712963,
0.0588775128,
-0.0133328633,
0.0052003283,
-0.0400897525,
0.0469058789,
0.0542851798,
0.0244168863,
0.008512211,
-0.0001814369,
-0.0465779044,
0.0182333849,
-0.0102554038,
0.0216066185,
-0.0338954739,
-0.0365975499,
0.0463445038,
0.0505340472,
-0.009494775,
-0.0554873534,
0.0231859945,
-0.0342361927,
0.0201670565,
0.0507616363,
-0.0228288136,
-0.0254736766,
-0.0144140627,
-0.0203836001,
-0.0182793215,
-0.023675628,
0.0787366256,
-0.0064801336,
-0.0285178162,
0.0326152854,
-0.0205614492,
0.0132632749,
-0.029817611,
-0.0107946368,
-0.0366643295,
0.0688800514,
-0.0445895493,
-0.0179499872,
-0.016798798,
0.0026631402,
-0.0292470437,
0.04806979,
-0.0102133704,
0.040827997,
-0.0233865418,
-0.0478809662,
0.0246028528,
-0.0027945535,
-0.0349927805,
0.0129977949,
-0.0010338639,
0.0082127471,
-0.0256458633,
-0.0578083619,
-0.0193210281,
0.012483486,
2.425e-7,
-0.0104030604,
0.0141181136,
0.0223239753,
0.0554924607,
0.0081659742,
0.0351834521,
0.0217676498,
0.0271673035,
0.0125248423,
-0.0100618051,
0.0023175133,
0.0275408085,
0.0279825274,
0.0185884945,
-0.1001730859,
-0.0756008103,
-0.0701137111,
-0.0685332865,
-0.0337435789,
-0.0199036561,
0.0890467912,
0.0241268557,
0.0036555189,
-0.0114841321,
-0.002078976,
-0.0565140918,
0.0523973927,
0.0276047699,
-0.0144494427,
0.0267751701,
0.0685701445,
0.0517793372,
0.011927532,
0.0241674185,
-0.0048163501,
0.0175467655,
-0.0067155869,
0.006196728,
0.001019939,
-0.0425313897,
0.0204926711,
-0.0018678646,
0.0383427553,
-0.0461079478,
0.0434342176,
-0.0330201909,
0.017896343,
-0.0293843187,
-0.029576784,
-0.0348639153,
-0.0142368563,
-0.0519847125,
-0.0369797051,
0.0052891118,
-0.015547649,
0.0310060401,
0.0175575931,
-0.0615667365,
0.01369844,
-0.0263017956,
-0.0743582472,
-0.0561122298,
-0.0546941012,
0.0151488278,
-0.0154820634,
0.001025451,
0.0008648554,
1.8590698e-34,
0.0395647697,
0.0093457876,
-0.0277546532,
0.0635479316,
0.0223481692,
0.0271172673,
0.0099512013,
-0.017900588,
0.0516096726,
-0.0684962422,
-0.022694014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07994v1 | À-la-carte Prompt Tuning (APT): Combining Distinct Data Via Composable Prompting | 2023-02-15T23:51:09 | 2023-02-15T23:51:09 | Benjamin Bowman, Alessandro Achille, Luca Zancato, Matthew Trager, Pramuditha Perera, Giovanni Paolini, Stefano Soatto | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We introduce \`A-la-carte Prompt Tuning (APT), a transformer-based scheme to
tune prompts on distinct data so that they can be arbitrarily composed at
inference time. The individual prompts can be trained in isolation, possibly on
different devices, at different times, and on different distributions or
domains. Furthermore each prompt only contains information about the subset of
data it was exposed to during training. During inference, models can be
assembled based on arbitrary selections of data sources, which we call
"\`a-la-carte learning". \`A-la-carte learning enables constructing bespoke
models specific to each user's individual access rights and preferences. We can
add or remove information from the model by simply adding or removing the
corresponding prompts without retraining from scratch. We demonstrate that
\`a-la-carte built models achieve accuracy within $5\%$ of models trained on
the union of the respective sources, with comparable cost in terms of training
and inference time. For the continual learning benchmarks Split CIFAR-100 and
CORe50, we achieve state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.0097503299,
0.0591520518,
0.020293545,
-0.0025846006,
-0.0488475524,
0.0071997046,
0.0941335037,
-0.0552969687,
-0.0080546532,
-0.0326035805,
-0.0339528583,
0.000454159,
-0.0091974055,
0.0099475095,
-0.0122100702,
-0.039617911,
0.0364463143,
-0.0019471251,
-0.0479967818,
0.011186514,
-0.0258928072,
-0.0089649763,
0.0016298629,
0.0065632202,
-0.0123456419,
-0.0216002688,
-0.026110176,
0.0169255175,
0.0337766409,
-0.0040144692,
0.019439131,
0.0782852918,
0.0013881178,
0.0374174267,
0.000002304,
-0.0498220809,
-0.0519958772,
0.0007305088,
-0.0627377629,
-0.009370341,
0.0157238618,
0.0350106731,
0.0189505201,
0.0312256943,
-0.0514716096,
0.0080801863,
0.0311966874,
0.0357247889,
0.0647687316,
0.0529145077,
-0.0131434966,
0.0015172258,
-0.0247486588,
-0.0473800525,
0.033911787,
-0.0465112478,
0.0178935193,
-0.0719588771,
0.0017795392,
-0.0100206351,
0.019251246,
0.0158817954,
0.0519371144,
0.0485953316,
0.0407575145,
0.0244415738,
-0.0066526993,
-0.0297825541,
-0.0537676439,
0.0492179804,
-0.0075974143,
-0.0182730816,
0.0389562882,
-0.0159630384,
0.0195762236,
0.0096630799,
-0.0298243016,
-0.01025532,
-0.0458802395,
0.0008002029,
-0.0651625246,
0.0408594012,
0.0084058903,
0.0088276379,
-0.0609303042,
0.0179390814,
-0.0066681197,
-0.0251081996,
-0.0237830635,
-0.0100989752,
0.0105670756,
-0.0489216745,
0.0367052034,
0.0219671987,
-0.0557808466,
-0.0234852619,
-0.0780690685,
0.004954055,
0.0037715887,
0.0230123475,
0.0592650101,
0.0154719464,
-0.0350461416,
0.0758856833,
0.0112672132,
0.0284946449,
-0.0274161473,
0.0183953941,
-0.013678153,
0.0433632992,
-0.048807539,
0.0136621231,
-0.0158617683,
0.0181773566,
-0.0847559646,
-0.0249559432,
-0.0293776486,
0.0279146601,
0.0145794228,
0.0037666485,
0.0078747645,
0.0279118437,
-0.0615514517,
-0.0088968892,
-0.000780611,
-0.0312181264,
-0.0211090073,
0.0322946459,
0.0598655865,
-0.0433498174,
-0.0046783979,
-0.0305398684,
0.0027834817,
-0.0159580521,
-0.0090648718,
0.0528917313,
-0.0209961515,
-0.016499022,
-0.0201955214,
-0.0636865348,
0.0149522312,
-0.0259866938,
0.0068515721,
-0.0462673977,
0.0635728836,
-0.0099102436,
-0.0024372027,
-0.0336968899,
-0.0180216599,
0.0129167661,
-0.0095279813,
0.0819833055,
0.0253033042,
-0.0293864906,
0.0216995161,
0.0277190823,
-0.053400673,
0.0415372327,
-0.0221577883,
0.0565766357,
0.0191595312,
0.0062026591,
0.0153704733,
0.0108634783,
0.0244235359,
-0.0031232983,
0.0365867168,
-0.0029203082,
0.0394468606,
-0.051043801,
-0.0339242592,
0.02551369,
-0.0259208269,
-0.019862093,
0.0511944033,
0.0321978107,
0.0371200852,
-0.0111974822,
-0.0061748582,
0.0294132736,
-0.0033356147,
-0.0061753578,
-0.0727098435,
0.0379485264,
-0.0250552371,
-0.0120602613,
0.0299598463,
0.0374129005,
-0.026634967,
-0.0650641248,
0.007513301,
-0.0605989881,
-0.0074810898,
0.0546360165,
-0.0003781002,
0.0251077581,
-0.0155197689,
0.0099511873,
0.0271404088,
-0.0670356974,
-0.043837782,
-0.0868393183,
0.0314355791,
0.0577428006,
0.0123752598,
-0.008338647,
0.0064364062,
-0.0249132775,
0.026816899,
-0.0131386006,
0.0219489131,
-0.0043758722,
0.0639282092,
-0.0473569483,
-0.0824076682,
0.0192959793,
0.0196228493,
0.069316633,
-0.0151672661,
-0.0470789373,
0.0212345906,
0.0363472477,
0.0391675904,
0.0229742825,
0.0038329279,
-0.0420239829,
0.0414711647,
0.045857463,
0.0396243222,
0.011603036,
0.0072438517,
0.0086926147,
0.0155758001,
-0.0247589219,
0.0059013506,
-0.0159788281,
-0.0527526513,
0.0128182452,
0.006307337,
0.0051989742,
0.0259476863,
0.0023347118,
-0.0271194037,
-0.0283775758,
-0.0583625771,
0.0071442816,
0.0338556655,
-0.0191669092,
0.0266649462,
0.0186367072,
0.0110325748,
-0.0214740988,
0.0607766211,
-0.0094494736,
-0.0303094983,
0.0306870174,
0.0125869773,
0.0107636908,
-0.0690496713,
0.008204828,
-0.0421729796,
-0.0316488817,
-0.0100656077,
0.0119768344,
-0.0036515202,
-0.0170994811,
-0.0181440022,
-0.0553881861,
0.0224828646,
-0.041153457,
0.008907143,
0.0182178896,
0.0583358966,
-0.0117717376,
-0.0611791536,
-0.0065808659,
-0.0210016239,
-0.0201980621,
0.0551573187,
-0.0076943906,
0.0214622896,
-0.0273073129,
-0.0126971966,
-0.0126159685,
-0.0095395306,
0.0137518076,
-0.0100212507,
-0.0096876547,
-0.0174494088,
-0.0333225541,
-0.0050491719,
0.0041907867,
-0.0277050585,
0.0221719276,
0.0240572821,
-0.0097898589,
0.0177366678,
0.102743797,
0.0190562289,
-0.0010732161,
0.0274639707,
0.0107500805,
-0.0531733967,
0.0100312149,
-0.0142083159,
-0.0344147533,
-0.0190395527,
-0.0021918393,
0.0625381842,
0.0563959219,
-0.0053075822,
0.0085555008,
-0.0425577946,
0.0422444418,
-0.0126279481,
-0.061221309,
-0.0526497066,
0.0328222178,
-0.0216840822,
0.0467858911,
-0.0150298607,
-0.0612875521,
0.0694414601,
-0.0023719019,
0.0167249739,
-0.0134077687,
-0.040398594,
0.0063573704,
0.0264236107,
0.0197130367,
0.0330879278,
0.0626665354,
-0.0221764334,
-0.043650873,
-0.0178956054,
0.0500991978,
-0.0443038493,
0.0394962505,
-0.0208656043,
-0.0054256897,
-0.0134248035,
-0.083534807,
-0.0435460694,
-0.0758504495,
0.0186306164,
-0.0373861454,
-0.0319382772,
-0.0173338652,
-0.0554590821,
-0.022283053,
0.0099726403,
0.0652917847,
-0.0184377041,
-0.0251522232,
-0.0074839047,
-0.0139870178,
-0.0001889563,
0.0084512932,
-0.0517540984,
-0.0262507275,
-0.0053662574,
0.04432033,
0.075616084,
-0.0086607533,
-0.0118046654,
0.0311017167,
0.0248895846,
-0.0133232987,
-0.0064009312,
0.044259835,
0.0571261905,
-0.0236318652,
0.0037343621,
0.0783080384,
0.0416763686,
-0.0694480985,
-0.0418078117,
0.0305948146,
0.0096435519,
0.0063146329,
0.0258803144,
-0.1032067761,
-0.0315999798,
0.0151660191,
0.0851008222,
0.0098644514,
-0.008705386,
-0.0201219376,
-0.0596990436,
-0.0071779289,
0.0166638829,
-0.00717782,
-0.0071230503,
-0.0556078739,
-0.0020865819,
-0.0525312237,
-0.0117819412,
-0.0135802785,
-0.0339378826,
-0.0050949906,
0.020490421,
0.0040887073,
-0.0355356745,
-0.0037695335,
-0.0018229403,
0.0147355748,
0.0707223043,
-0.0338831469,
0.0475033931,
-0.0624450855,
-0.0127163297,
-0.005456483,
-0.003186543,
-0.0175442193,
0.0460786931,
0.0040943907,
0.0357966796,
-0.0052208416,
0.0889010727,
0.0342043266,
-0.0591126978,
0.0219114143,
0.0201752298,
-0.0181919429,
0.0506642722,
-0.031259384,
-0.028055815,
0.0536867715,
0.0435397848,
0.0030859883,
-0.0639517382,
-0.0015482808,
-0.0261956099,
-0.0298525505,
-0.028759243,
0.0165795721,
0.0221485086,
-0.0311180372,
-0.0545939915,
-0.0459248833,
0.0089510698,
-0.0460267738,
0.0687488541,
0.0186519846,
-0.0356224366,
0.0057487548,
0.0514712781,
-0.058365304,
0.0125383912,
-0.0078614969,
0.0140893431,
-0.0554381609,
-0.0206988677,
0.0341831036,
-0.0408967994,
-0.0152386874,
-0.0035401015,
-0.04147413,
-0.0920935497,
0.0208134521,
0.0542859882,
0.0390650257,
0.0567818694,
-0.0051523275,
-0.0135193449,
0.0628393516,
0.0940017775,
-0.0265619513,
0.0151234297,
0.0831030011,
-0.0086251218,
-0.0339773931,
0.0193541199,
-0.0756912082,
0.021165235,
0.0162925459,
-0.0292242747,
-0.0768844187,
0.0010734,
0.0343349092,
-0.0221207086,
0.0489998497,
-0.0159359071,
-0.0132451644,
-0.0115414131,
0.0418583266,
0.0426631235,
-0.0089655444,
-0.0184207465,
-0.0035147618,
-0.0087585459,
-0.0309868455,
0.0369918682,
-0.0016983221,
0.0571294427,
-0.0026352028,
-0.0965162888,
0.0072747832,
0.0165431257,
-0.0100119459,
0.0175094008,
-0.0072196042,
-0.0328318179,
0.0365323909,
0.0490147807,
0.0091962582,
-0.0327827185,
0.0661875084,
0.0043636556,
0.0435019284,
-0.0624578036,
0.0557818748,
-0.0726273432,
-0.0261361469,
0.0092427367,
0.0322917141,
-0.0008513688,
-0.0025783023,
0.0012163756,
-0.021427013,
-0.0090240659,
-0.0361806117,
0.0261093639,
0.0127974292,
0.0115239844,
-0.0120469173,
0.0122865308,
0.0173752848,
-0.0021574001,
0.0569271855,
-0.0360550545,
0.0275688097,
-0.0348357856,
0.0037441514,
-0.0862266496,
-0.0274311882,
0.0123625202,
0.0009833381,
-0.0278937872,
-0.0321425013,
-0.0100291865,
-0.025902655,
0.011903896,
0.0186386369,
0.0330300666,
0.0267647058,
0.0491051078,
0.0353274532,
-0.0179107543,
-0.0314831734,
-0.0045748064,
-0.0079037342,
-0.0090071782,
0.0023985603,
0.0133074578,
-6.699121e-33,
-0.0062369038,
0.0332925059,
-0.0182467308,
0.0225373916,
0.0143380882,
0.0170303974,
0.0064720702,
-0.0091366582,
-0.0176700521,
-0.043216262,
-0.0462451056,
-0.0143905459,
0.0482456051,
0.0291351248,
-0.0046285526,
-0.0297356769,
0.0924569815,
-0.006265285,
-0.0395879596,
0.0401889123,
0.0645286068,
0.0438124016,
-0.0429149233,
-0.0662189648,
0.0129867932,
0.0047768657,
-0.0293361358,
-0.0120015536,
-0.0396798775,
0.0595298968,
0.0047441395,
-0.023436198,
-0.0027477283,
-0.0185866691,
-0.0272958074,
0.0947500914,
-0.1036321819,
-0.0295644458,
-0.0231931787,
0.005762361,
-0.0188602284,
-0.045883663,
0.0206291098,
0.0013139083,
-0.0265790969,
-0.0327389278,
0.0206063222,
0.0165921748,
-0.0335263982,
-0.0251962636,
0.0151296081,
-0.0168756098,
0.0174218491,
-0.0416586399,
0.0214442275,
0.0643209517,
0.0077499822,
-0.0281987675,
-0.0600392334,
0.054055769,
0.0054020244,
0.0092016691,
0.0398568027,
0.0391737558,
-0.0025649264,
0.05530544,
0.0208600815,
-0.0555201359,
-0.0118394904,
-0.0095051005,
-0.030864222,
0.0472616665,
-0.008329438,
0.0379527174,
0.0516380891,
-0.0545346998,
-0.0491984226,
0.0574100837,
0.0512474813,
0.0029309615,
0.0294302721,
0.0249452107,
-0.0194194242,
-0.0002662394,
-0.0369031541,
-0.0107931914,
-0.0278627593,
-0.0056705493,
0.0545729212,
0.0767146498,
-0.0754431412,
-0.0077617331,
0.0569081791,
-0.0191527624,
-0.0109366989,
0.0295497198,
0.0807323381,
0.0165087041,
-0.0110041881,
-0.0088409251,
-0.0259460565,
-0.0284849536,
0.0408905447,
0.0083060488,
0.0320995934,
-0.0036765656,
0.0555859879,
0.0698710755,
-0.0674634427,
-0.0145667875,
-0.0174641646,
0.051758565,
0.017576484,
0.02055078,
0.0566845834,
0.0002730105,
-0.015534536,
0.0524126925,
-0.0701243207,
-0.0384712219,
-0.0506439395,
-0.0009700747,
0.0255823135,
0.0148035884,
0.0017812893,
0.0011810582,
-0.0437040515,
0.0365568958,
0.0578596257,
-0.0300436579,
-0.0007478023,
0.0170761608,
3.078e-7,
-0.037181776,
-0.0160388146,
-0.0042291898,
-0.0186683442,
-0.0156501681,
0.0418992154,
-0.015762886,
0.0418131053,
0.0150673836,
-0.003936334,
-0.0226513445,
0.0239913296,
0.0502155237,
0.044693511,
-0.0660569072,
-0.0375975631,
-0.0296024755,
0.0460481457,
-0.0756494924,
0.0112163229,
0.0460973606,
0.0759552717,
0.0209969021,
0.0018539318,
0.0817422569,
-0.0126869828,
0.0312821865,
-0.0164151937,
0.011572862,
-0.0500929914,
0.0255542155,
0.014349971,
0.0080213193,
0.0321993716,
-0.0535551235,
0.0167099852,
-0.0403981619,
0.0777174085,
0.0216597784,
-0.0556176081,
0.0048967525,
-0.011484528,
-0.0024009855,
-0.0029729658,
0.0773980319,
-0.0695390776,
-0.0204032268,
-0.0028009939,
0.016404314,
-0.0226428583,
0.0308989175,
0.0060893106,
0.0196031798,
-0.0000956622,
0.007962238,
0.0317174457,
-0.0203110334,
-0.0970474929,
-0.0065798936,
-0.0236036237,
-0.0204587467,
-0.0374193378,
-0.0399526879,
-0.0010411056,
0.0185785647,
-0.037292704,
-0.0078737363,
3.000079922e-34,
-0.0020527085,
-0.0049935542,
0.0382563248,
0.0129004084,
-0.0171032716,
-0.003501818,
0.0516374558,
0.0372528732,
0.0459181555,
-0.069029443,
-0.0248637907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07974v1 | Tree-Based Representation and Generation of Natural and Mathematical Language | 2023-02-15T22:38:34 | 2023-02-15T22:38:34 | Alexander Scarlatos, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical language in scientific communications and educational scenarios
is important yet relatively understudied compared to natural languages. Recent
works on mathematical language focus either on representing stand-alone
mathematical expressions, especially in their natural tree format, or
mathematical reasoning in pre-trained natural language models. Existing works
on jointly modeling and generating natural and mathematical languages simply
treat mathematical expressions as text, without accounting for the rigid
structural properties of mathematical expressions. In this paper, we propose a
series of modifications to existing language models to jointly represent and
generate text and math: representing mathematical expressions as sequences of
node tokens in their operator tree format, using math symbol and tree position
embeddings to preserve the semantic and structural properties of mathematical
expressions, and using a constrained decoding method to generate mathematically
valid expressions. We ground our modifications in GPT-2, resulting in a model
MathGPT, and demonstrate that it outperforms baselines on mathematical
expression generation tasks. | [
-0.0568559468,
0.1145112067,
-0.0056847045,
0.0410751812,
-0.0026105307,
-0.005042532,
-0.0335178338,
0.0026337029,
-0.0927998573,
-0.0399367213,
-0.0326281749,
0.0063543264,
-0.0194578953,
0.061466258,
0.0281164348,
-0.0735094696,
0.0113571733,
-0.0162026938,
0.0356911682,
-0.016658159,
-0.0054013371,
0.0220974255,
0.011852704,
0.0111158593,
-0.055830162,
-0.0916274339,
0.0044830302,
-0.0439183787,
-0.0078176279,
-0.0526451468,
-0.0392485224,
0.0372635014,
0.0276905429,
0.0278182104,
0.0000018265,
-0.0041234312,
-0.0044782497,
0.0349841714,
-0.0363552943,
0.0078524277,
0.0069146212,
-0.0351340249,
0.0242164973,
-0.0021528576,
-0.0897702053,
-0.0135342451,
0.0469771028,
-0.0077973995,
0.0856063962,
0.0653259978,
-0.0179917794,
-0.0726195574,
0.0255147945,
-0.0041201226,
0.0331751406,
-0.0273634978,
-0.0048937188,
0.0284813624,
-0.014671539,
0.03924473,
-0.0308014695,
-0.006767462,
0.0656476244,
-0.0132411867,
0.0306943282,
0.0430976562,
-0.0273551662,
0.0275859237,
-0.0245567728,
0.0434237272,
-0.0013941629,
-0.0480763055,
0.0139269484,
-0.007508948,
-0.0199692007,
-0.0268527772,
-0.0574793853,
0.0492247753,
0.0007230274,
0.0241666976,
0.0010997736,
0.0000959855,
0.0447845683,
0.0161396377,
-0.0447772257,
0.0936732814,
0.0356385708,
-0.046660535,
-0.0528204069,
0.0076787588,
-0.0646391213,
-0.0223747008,
0.0346794389,
0.0106532145,
0.0355610102,
0.019168755,
-0.0843150467,
-0.0666435808,
-0.0405959785,
-0.0135427713,
0.0166607164,
0.0660890043,
0.0420322046,
-0.013539969,
-0.0235219635,
0.0564474612,
-0.0067772227,
0.0123809492,
-0.0051096617,
0.0524969734,
-0.031729959,
-0.0422998965,
-0.0402778983,
0.0474169217,
-0.0148147717,
-0.0092581557,
-0.0318946727,
0.0447195508,
-0.027088698,
-0.0197484624,
0.0100937234,
-0.0250848606,
-0.0228414796,
-0.020105822,
0.0160762072,
-0.0331633724,
-0.0177705176,
-0.0008232219,
0.0229240134,
-0.0257260278,
-0.0422671065,
0.0758731812,
-0.0121106673,
-0.0197945274,
-0.0260835961,
0.0601739623,
0.040175125,
0.0033301418,
0.0473023951,
-0.0434099808,
0.0111547876,
-0.0435528755,
0.0229803696,
-0.0495452881,
0.0557635538,
0.0129941013,
-0.0341746062,
-0.0267600883,
0.0062823147,
0.02762709,
0.0426411517,
0.0106763244,
-0.0334039703,
-0.019563498,
0.0065014693,
-0.0196450055,
-0.0027671924,
-0.0055380939,
0.0772782862,
-0.0286577474,
-0.0061153858,
-0.0204333551,
-0.0077170176,
0.0053232466,
0.0497620329,
-0.0264203921,
0.0097652832,
0.0308063962,
-0.0135039976,
0.0564125404,
-0.0069069606,
0.0422812402,
-0.0826128796,
-0.0155365895,
-0.0175062418,
0.0453743599,
-0.0188475456,
0.0291948188,
0.0881006345,
-0.00826554,
0.0272380002,
-0.0155317942,
-0.0478079282,
-0.0017049083,
-0.0359438844,
0.0143123139,
-0.032914564,
-0.0023835308,
0.0071880249,
-0.0261775386,
0.0090570543,
-0.0240784902,
-0.0066972957,
-0.0496545583,
0.0416163765,
0.0194789767,
-0.0084213326,
0.0732536167,
-0.0272003766,
-0.0528997406,
0.0168570802,
-0.0355263874,
-0.0078024236,
-0.0270538088,
0.0229944997,
-0.0199762769,
0.0063546766,
-0.0161824487,
-0.0273354892,
0.0609723702,
0.0123349708,
0.0107495068,
-0.0147931147,
-0.0281475708,
-0.0004034506,
-0.025869837,
0.0278804936,
0.0197763443,
0.0125099504,
0.0121419784,
0.0794940963,
-0.0229193941,
0.0107701849,
0.0455467813,
-0.0101665081,
-0.0383434705,
0.0273777265,
-0.0329408832,
0.0350965932,
-0.0041687503,
0.0079702009,
0.0905482993,
0.015098244,
0.0006762904,
-0.0256757382,
-0.0018097188,
-0.0971942097,
-0.0573426187,
0.0452635027,
-0.0410036445,
0.0077292803,
-0.0018098063,
-0.0387719199,
-0.0377335548,
0.0473695286,
-0.0565808639,
0.0231464412,
-0.039249599,
-0.0141455922,
0.043313995,
-0.0263587032,
-0.0036011087,
0.0821974948,
0.0241844729,
-0.0047375946,
0.015165545,
-0.0110591101,
0.0035843744,
-0.0195982549,
0.0200810358,
-0.0213132463,
-0.0143605322,
0.024845643,
-0.0038136474,
0.0475709997,
0.0173946377,
0.0082153743,
-0.0134357372,
-0.0003085863,
-0.0218007434,
0.0811825097,
0.0292041413,
-0.0280551128,
0.0164896511,
0.0380691551,
-0.0482179075,
0.0077050887,
0.0155126071,
-0.0248858575,
0.0365520082,
-0.0273676272,
-0.0008362497,
-0.0168498997,
-0.0200334657,
-0.0614089184,
0.0475176536,
0.020537056,
0.0098997373,
-0.0113540087,
0.0240170751,
-0.0318687409,
-0.0241338555,
-0.0025906933,
0.0441290066,
0.0514078066,
-0.0443131179,
0.0557746626,
0.0147824874,
-0.012097802,
0.0483951159,
-0.0118793231,
-0.0123468554,
-0.0411341712,
-0.0010915152,
-0.0274781007,
0.0462136231,
-0.0002094866,
0.0188922584,
0.0450566225,
0.0607798025,
0.0153283477,
-0.0083321398,
-0.0687815696,
0.0522818863,
-0.0103316912,
-0.0018116906,
-0.0220945794,
-0.0232880078,
-0.0306136068,
0.0183071122,
0.0112910355,
-0.0588693805,
0.0317585953,
-0.0023114316,
-0.0287511647,
-0.0326731987,
0.0108234771,
-0.0601923391,
0.0302499551,
0.0132733909,
-0.0090839481,
-0.0003267679,
-0.024879111,
-0.0161446445,
0.0254254527,
0.0378806107,
-0.0159153137,
-0.0236967895,
0.0040747696,
0.0270363167,
-0.0075560417,
-0.0131752072,
-0.0130181927,
0.0083040548,
0.0142403664,
0.0274614692,
0.0035015719,
-0.0358869955,
-0.0005321719,
0.0096572526,
0.0125877634,
0.0074833697,
-0.0389637686,
-0.0125679811,
-0.0399730243,
-0.003260212,
0.0226923674,
0.0170802847,
0.0217608493,
-0.0402045399,
-0.017368529,
0.0062528639,
0.0123554897,
0.0328802913,
-0.0281102695,
0.0118636824,
-0.0181455668,
-0.0171271358,
-0.0589111522,
0.0431478098,
-0.0209185462,
-0.0476543047,
0.000183814,
0.062935628,
0.0263717864,
0.013778354,
0.0144527564,
-0.0612128191,
0.0634480491,
-0.0040105456,
0.0069542374,
-0.1020018458,
0.0159769431,
0.0139463944,
0.0107540181,
0.0478614233,
-0.0280351657,
0.0031932397,
-0.0750085786,
0.0197218396,
0.0491475277,
-0.034601707,
-0.0154683227,
-0.0202337597,
-0.0445334464,
0.0246598106,
-0.0409026891,
0.0309058763,
-0.0158081017,
0.0561122932,
0.0159726162,
-0.0448607318,
-0.049361974,
-0.0191115532,
0.0101886913,
-0.0678452626,
0.0478779487,
0.0342293233,
0.0017003539,
-0.0384247787,
-0.0177315492,
0.0459473766,
-0.017846711,
0.0022624147,
-0.0544411428,
-0.0185114965,
0.0033051521,
-0.0149153126,
0.0665940791,
-0.0930897743,
-0.007049921,
0.0215515941,
0.1323415488,
-0.0238415338,
-0.0153789083,
-0.0263534673,
-0.0110294679,
-0.0168079622,
0.0348476432,
0.0216421485,
0.017996829,
-0.0599829629,
-0.0376083553,
0.0467320308,
-0.0179938991,
-0.0493726395,
-0.0178394802,
0.062732406,
-0.0024021326,
-0.0451686345,
-0.0362164825,
0.0328293517,
0.0231055804,
-0.0204469413,
-0.0435123555,
0.0068237879,
-0.0601219982,
-0.007257204,
0.0133598447,
-0.0518983528,
0.0119046764,
-0.0124482121,
0.0495938621,
-0.0027890578,
0.0245448072,
-0.0253978968,
0.0171561092,
-0.0493767262,
-0.0471194535,
-0.0471076146,
0.080173187,
0.0142353065,
-0.0268164519,
0.0038016974,
0.0406902395,
-0.0209373832,
0.0625774786,
-0.0680669695,
0.024439482,
0.0491042025,
-0.0336938389,
0.0125250397,
0.0040039457,
-0.0214494262,
0.0046130824,
-0.0409845188,
0.0633684546,
-0.0306360442,
-0.0135020148,
0.0580087714,
0.0523910969,
-0.0029542891,
0.0054231598,
0.0198965687,
0.0177108832,
-0.0277152117,
-0.0758074224,
0.003847328,
-0.0668834895,
0.0531222709,
-0.0123742288,
0.019039195,
-0.0018824768,
-0.035973914,
0.0126467329,
0.0384780578,
0.0316987187,
0.0445896871,
-0.0116157271,
0.0204865094,
0.0059898393,
-0.0205267221,
0.0120910667,
-0.0325245261,
-0.0364518166,
0.0120989755,
-0.0096067935,
0.0205321517,
0.0307593998,
0.0351730846,
0.0231675301,
-0.0345454477,
-0.0291224048,
-0.0819886476,
-0.0229931157,
-0.0148192197,
0.0142766209,
0.0716353133,
0.018323265,
-0.0820679963,
0.021749828,
-0.0285559557,
0.0780178085,
0.0404838473,
-0.0275092702,
0.03858025,
0.0150167588,
-0.0152210798,
-0.1086161211,
0.0579689741,
0.029201448,
0.0084385388,
0.003565677,
0.037218567,
-0.0283308104,
-0.0276433118,
-0.012905933,
0.0051732669,
0.0079599759,
0.0096481815,
-0.0596454814,
-0.0450797752,
0.022226518,
0.0101593556,
-0.0118988687,
-0.0293095596,
0.0712316334,
0.0525267497,
-0.0697194785,
-0.0052734744,
0.0280106291,
0.0441393182,
-0.0245252475,
-0.0381055325,
-0.0829167739,
-4.939346447e-33,
-0.0228507705,
-0.0281058922,
0.0190158226,
0.0402639881,
-0.0295522399,
-0.0125272172,
-0.0245382339,
0.0293084253,
0.043211557,
0.0078460006,
0.0273249801,
0.0376862958,
-0.0216310378,
0.0281431489,
-0.0122675654,
0.0071356706,
0.0095401565,
-0.0502012037,
-0.0230898689,
-0.0043940172,
0.0032718799,
0.0171181411,
0.0933140665,
-0.0523188785,
-0.0047367844,
-0.0149973407,
0.0013320075,
-0.0291249547,
-0.0258124974,
0.0446178913,
-0.0250053238,
0.0173710324,
-0.0203036461,
-0.0088572474,
-0.0606644526,
0.0041565089,
-0.0115958992,
-0.0438622013,
0.0033973907,
-0.0215352587,
-0.0780156851,
-0.0278704669,
0.053204637,
-0.0031897691,
-0.0390751623,
-0.0281274598,
0.0161626711,
0.0146318106,
-0.0397655256,
-0.0449454784,
-0.0481131673,
0.0496311486,
0.0079274857,
0.0182856452,
0.0177841932,
0.0415030196,
-0.0378129259,
0.0176828112,
0.0204176251,
0.0137086343,
0.0007449412,
0.0155178588,
0.012630011,
-0.0334154628,
0.0517051406,
0.0311982837,
0.0071251877,
-0.0580194406,
-0.0352776721,
0.00468993,
0.0240688622,
0.0452807061,
0.057493411,
-0.00764817,
0.0509160683,
0.0325268209,
-0.0295664743,
-0.0210951399,
-0.0275616851,
0.03422511,
-0.0090382379,
0.0183583945,
0.0142597202,
-0.0108977528,
-0.0133392243,
0.0020298844,
-0.0164949819,
-0.0434139185,
0.0176379196,
-0.027464617,
-0.0172378086,
0.0389809944,
0.0272156876,
-0.0155819431,
-0.0403400138,
0.014179931,
-0.0155216642,
-0.0012008701,
-0.0042377845,
0.0601454042,
-0.0390128195,
-0.0425550863,
0.0208782274,
-0.0155749349,
0.0445482209,
0.0214553997,
-0.0165539254,
0.0380955599,
-0.0026717982,
-0.009035523,
-0.0075768991,
-0.0287801232,
0.0206770338,
0.0434632339,
0.0462533981,
0.0374022797,
0.0337080918,
0.0291852206,
-0.0082251979,
-0.0106316693,
-0.0332789384,
0.0219879039,
0.0168814734,
0.055079449,
0.0118325772,
-0.0334463306,
-0.0164558347,
0.005459521,
0.0337584428,
-0.0679315701,
-0.0126648732,
0.0118686277,
2.519e-7,
0.0520925559,
0.0332574323,
0.0517579764,
0.0369668417,
0.0202501994,
-0.0058526173,
0.0086010117,
0.0167691894,
-0.0148849348,
-0.0514481142,
0.0143758487,
0.0125955753,
0.0239105653,
0.0153465513,
-0.0630314946,
0.0858469233,
-0.1141136587,
-0.0008771204,
-0.0264866147,
-0.0058575054,
0.1053313389,
0.0707378164,
0.009142709,
0.0399616547,
0.0000647024,
-0.0302137546,
0.0997940078,
0.0090400912,
0.0143973613,
-0.0069094468,
-0.0265279636,
-0.0249427445,
0.0153340483,
-0.0321347453,
-0.0105758235,
0.0422442928,
0.0495202243,
0.0782767013,
0.003203792,
0.0642070398,
0.0089321397,
-0.0221260656,
-0.0238042418,
-0.003339899,
0.0114450743,
-0.0738529786,
-0.0138788624,
-0.00636002,
-0.0521578938,
0.0050249752,
0.0115156872,
-0.0017393058,
0.0156129533,
0.0044796225,
0.028912954,
-0.0052607502,
0.018856097,
-0.0161352642,
-0.0236531459,
-0.0019308167,
-0.0681535825,
0.0062605361,
-0.0823117346,
0.0286451168,
0.0433243923,
0.0365159027,
-0.0468203239,
2.543696307e-34,
0.0401667841,
-0.0341979489,
0.0328042805,
0.0636344254,
0.0133833373,
0.0035015887,
-0.0266772863,
0.0439883918,
0.028223332,
-0.0383029655,
-0.0337360539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07926v1 | Commonsense Reasoning for Conversational AI: A Survey of the State of the Art | 2023-02-15T19:55:57 | 2023-02-15T19:55:57 | Christopher Richardson, Larry Heck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large, transformer-based pretrained language models like BERT, GPT, and T5
have demonstrated a deep understanding of contextual semantics and language
syntax. Their success has enabled significant advances in conversational AI,
including the development of open-dialogue systems capable of coherent, salient
conversations which can answer questions, chat casually, and complete tasks.
However, state-of-the-art models still struggle with tasks that involve higher
levels of reasoning - including commonsense reasoning that humans find trivial.
This paper presents a survey of recent conversational AI research focused on
commonsense reasoning. The paper lists relevant training datasets and describes
the primary approaches to include commonsense in conversational AI. The paper
also discusses benchmarks used for evaluating commonsense in conversational AI
problems. Finally, the paper presents preliminary observations of the limited
commonsense capabilities of two state-of-the-art open dialogue models,
BlenderBot3 and LaMDA, and its negative effect on natural interactions. These
observations further motivate research on commonsense reasoning in
conversational AI. | [
0.0590661317,
0.0430207588,
-0.0152467499,
0.0285415389,
-0.0239606965,
0.0014857057,
-0.0121816536,
0.0037091023,
0.0197118688,
-0.0478005745,
0.0017603126,
0.0579116233,
0.0135544538,
0.0267172754,
-0.0157171655,
-0.0526784919,
0.013421881,
-0.0209307708,
-0.0154645098,
0.0139013547,
0.0032613913,
0.0394558907,
-0.0417801887,
0.0649682805,
-0.0138845537,
-0.0286228806,
-0.0086399764,
-0.0274276379,
0.026239261,
0.0102279456,
-0.0164590161,
0.0143238129,
0.0322018526,
-0.0004878407,
0.0000018544,
-0.0312109385,
0.0434326977,
-0.0134450402,
-0.0018425221,
-0.0345750153,
-0.0024235118,
0.0053230724,
-0.0063635237,
0.022020746,
-0.0685512573,
0.0677576736,
0.0353312157,
0.0537334159,
0.0346717723,
0.0163103472,
-0.0260896292,
-0.0570855103,
-0.0123473527,
0.0247800704,
0.022957515,
-0.0887015909,
-0.0012059908,
0.0453701094,
0.0200175773,
-0.0197394527,
-0.000314798,
0.034246549,
0.0401463918,
-0.0589387044,
-0.0205092896,
0.0610979721,
-0.0566224046,
-0.0285089109,
-0.0334300064,
0.1111353859,
0.0345571712,
-0.0325257331,
-0.0203614123,
0.0084418226,
0.0213571731,
0.0067982557,
-0.0306847151,
0.0347345285,
0.0132800033,
0.0277074482,
0.0005488935,
-0.0094276201,
-0.0144444713,
0.0455558263,
-0.0230832286,
0.047816027,
-0.023041768,
0.0040513808,
0.028770389,
-0.0137831774,
-0.0077210059,
-0.0468488298,
0.003517186,
0.0796686634,
-0.016691003,
0.0366642661,
-0.01481687,
0.0260162167,
0.0171272513,
-0.0592397787,
-0.0280647594,
0.0409988165,
-0.0191692468,
0.0435637496,
0.0012257984,
0.0332030766,
0.0107419677,
0.037408676,
-0.0062416578,
-0.0257012602,
-0.0782567114,
-0.0104605462,
-0.0421663597,
0.0409067869,
-0.0638987273,
-0.0217892509,
0.0049464288,
0.029360123,
0.005569906,
0.032221958,
0.0177716594,
0.0374127217,
-0.0455723256,
-0.0239348114,
-0.0453935638,
0.0384767801,
-0.0317423642,
0.0408107862,
0.0336005092,
-0.0609006658,
-0.0248491429,
-0.0009452442,
0.026942201,
-0.0205843281,
0.00145803,
0.0230614822,
-0.0122260898,
-0.015989935,
-0.0379003286,
-0.0083971741,
-0.0072215013,
-0.0499267131,
-0.0232589897,
-0.0216543674,
0.0061057862,
0.0135664642,
-0.0057315095,
0.0199454259,
0.0203932356,
0.0127099454,
-0.0028358721,
0.0837461352,
-0.024417378,
0.0085854549,
0.0227509812,
0.0369274914,
0.0172072239,
0.0381350294,
0.0267957617,
-0.0040139873,
0.0169612374,
-0.0011747008,
0.0111840414,
-0.0331321657,
0.0077340468,
-0.0437284186,
0.0182181913,
0.0291686654,
-0.0567383207,
0.038700223,
0.0265133474,
0.0326340199,
-0.031102566,
-0.0168718509,
0.0547909886,
0.0848549977,
-0.0583915859,
0.0400106981,
0.0277036484,
0.0262683835,
0.0172525831,
0.0010534761,
-0.0441009998,
0.0434893668,
-0.027797604,
-0.0208846815,
-0.0397845693,
0.0075084055,
-0.0239044745,
-0.0211043432,
0.0054904628,
-0.0191105735,
0.0463608131,
-0.0295524281,
0.0219645295,
0.0044277511,
-0.0382022709,
0.0347096622,
0.0134992609,
-0.0804499462,
-0.0556631647,
-0.0524023436,
0.0087995725,
0.0354549661,
0.0318094268,
0.0050663301,
-0.091387853,
-0.0075862748,
0.0094691226,
0.0707839578,
0.034662243,
-0.0281620771,
0.0512006879,
-0.0428033322,
0.0126959579,
-0.0103835789,
-0.01656707,
0.0239869375,
-0.0218556635,
0.0185334161,
-0.0147447279,
-0.0237721726,
0.0157813709,
0.0126128662,
-0.0027548599,
0.0187499877,
-0.0299830809,
-0.0093182689,
0.0441386215,
0.0000108509,
-0.0012466243,
-0.0169500206,
0.028139364,
0.0012957565,
-0.0026059672,
0.090624705,
-0.0292292815,
-0.0698445886,
0.0240106564,
-0.0436273292,
-0.0784356743,
0.0561270677,
-0.0128187463,
-0.0217576157,
0.0286497734,
-0.0313265473,
0.0553867035,
-0.0620187595,
-0.0161434095,
-0.0209674649,
-0.0088357553,
0.0301589426,
0.0789798722,
-0.0175102148,
-0.0389613137,
0.0257347487,
-0.0120546529,
0.0195274744,
-0.044609677,
0.0127004152,
-0.0006840345,
-0.0073579648,
0.0039485861,
-0.0079724696,
0.0327974036,
-0.0351260677,
0.0001132856,
-0.1067333072,
-0.0332207792,
0.0010960011,
-0.0278400462,
-0.0236210506,
0.0010630725,
0.026754532,
-0.0210938212,
-0.0118281841,
0.0246634968,
0.0141837681,
-0.0019633351,
0.053834457,
0.0276327077,
-0.0176790971,
-0.0082041658,
0.0335175842,
-0.0024561703,
-0.0020681939,
0.0380711854,
0.0481484681,
0.0061188005,
0.0228858497,
-0.0589292981,
0.0525849834,
-0.0287691765,
-0.0828928798,
0.0409450158,
0.0094459997,
-0.0064441003,
0.0971048474,
0.0232411474,
0.0446818247,
0.0252781697,
-0.0352920443,
-0.0508978963,
0.0443581864,
-0.0037875222,
-0.0088408459,
-0.0491386093,
0.0054378402,
-0.0054742079,
0.0302378815,
-0.0023668744,
0.0375289954,
-0.084370546,
0.0022587494,
0.0497348979,
-0.0275026839,
-0.0078424253,
-0.0009736317,
-0.0111580966,
0.0444317646,
-0.0176685881,
-0.0150095765,
0.0836920366,
-0.0222454332,
-0.0205391515,
-0.046998892,
0.0011787278,
-0.0187791325,
0.045707535,
-0.0491393618,
0.0176418889,
-0.023870457,
-0.0224797074,
-0.0052905427,
-0.0299559776,
0.0259479713,
-0.0193065424,
0.0120572075,
-0.0526202582,
0.0275569595,
0.0058647073,
-0.0754213259,
-0.0290898699,
-0.0249173809,
-0.0378239192,
0.0276091248,
0.0156703591,
-0.0463453978,
-0.0405161977,
0.0083620651,
-0.0012949504,
0.0445856228,
0.0338487737,
-0.0251222607,
-0.0170049965,
0.0013152026,
0.0258046612,
0.0947224498,
0.0029982962,
0.0419028439,
0.0380244032,
0.0292877052,
0.0511206202,
-0.0369912349,
-0.0373594612,
0.0315734297,
-0.0179256387,
0.0089614019,
-0.0026970615,
0.0368894003,
0.0569729842,
-0.0265318565,
-0.0327857994,
0.0937323347,
0.0404251143,
0.0205169916,
0.0075882236,
-0.039749708,
-0.0041274657,
-0.0154028982,
0.0223063137,
-0.066619724,
-0.0629970506,
0.0060143298,
-0.0003164731,
-0.0243844707,
-0.0523135141,
0.0109995548,
-0.0994432643,
0.0347550996,
-0.0310747232,
-0.0733947009,
-0.080989413,
-0.0187874995,
0.0139814056,
-0.0023562778,
-0.0068301195,
-0.0051852493,
0.0192097407,
-0.0143302651,
0.0154958768,
0.0095890993,
-0.078416869,
0.0539834127,
-0.0049296208,
0.0616339892,
0.058723215,
0.0970062837,
0.0142734153,
-0.0703086257,
-0.0046779546,
-0.0166715384,
0.0245588087,
-0.0250562001,
-0.0077153542,
-0.0151918866,
0.0019888587,
-0.0308500715,
0.038827192,
-0.0410864614,
-0.0433041975,
-0.0024288262,
0.065751031,
-0.0641812608,
-0.0232206602,
-0.0131278252,
0.0491364077,
0.0274405386,
0.0783737451,
0.050765276,
0.0313788541,
-0.0432957672,
-0.0409341715,
-0.0265989508,
-0.0257936344,
0.003838785,
-0.0204272307,
0.0587115884,
-0.0157321896,
-0.0750980899,
-0.0146206617,
0.0323720239,
0.0266564246,
-0.0072864839,
-0.0245443564,
0.0149749257,
0.049742274,
-0.0204785354,
0.0320320055,
-0.0070838993,
-0.024117643,
-0.035073474,
0.0034102886,
0.0359180234,
-0.048980318,
-0.0445207208,
0.0302594975,
-0.00510483,
-0.0485430285,
-0.0256597865,
0.0666513592,
0.0279172007,
0.0322326273,
-0.0372403897,
-0.0288355798,
0.0079121245,
0.0637610853,
-0.0334959775,
0.0095055168,
0.0620908253,
0.0206859671,
0.0344172567,
0.0700396374,
-0.0195644032,
-0.018164726,
-0.0284248814,
0.0287837181,
-0.0531690679,
-0.043502178,
0.0130377524,
-0.010396936,
0.0104652494,
0.0466889665,
0.0155821312,
-0.0237543341,
0.0310386997,
-0.0076228958,
-0.0161515605,
-0.0638119429,
0.0249820519,
-0.0089619029,
0.0042272224,
-0.0102029527,
0.0102553377,
-0.0646177828,
0.0262910463,
0.0132315336,
-0.0047320928,
0.0408242755,
0.0333323032,
-0.0024492962,
-0.014411048,
-0.0057276967,
-0.0259806663,
-0.0176469889,
0.0471692458,
0.0103934919,
0.1023961902,
0.0563200153,
-0.0596590862,
0.02931959,
0.017360501,
-0.0816534981,
-0.0243554562,
0.0346405022,
0.0634333044,
0.0170825738,
0.0045769382,
0.0146277118,
-0.059636794,
0.0272843279,
0.0382200368,
0.0785321444,
0.0164123718,
-0.0442216173,
0.0444021001,
0.0066118883,
-0.0045563797,
0.0103858514,
0.0461583212,
-0.0573000982,
0.0220280085,
0.0041311248,
-0.0226552933,
-0.0306278411,
-0.0321178846,
0.0208986644,
0.0506594516,
0.0276133791,
0.0422373675,
-0.0551032424,
-0.038120728,
-0.0037178963,
0.015581755,
-0.0005553188,
-0.0139881037,
0.0115152523,
0.077920258,
0.0018617653,
-0.0680600181,
-0.0123176016,
0.0039721555,
-0.0886252224,
0.0207957197,
-0.0569056384,
-5.835444892e-33,
-0.0438334756,
-0.0411062948,
0.011638362,
0.0149077922,
-0.0124985604,
-0.0301057398,
-0.0917925015,
-0.0273451842,
-0.0400940925,
0.0376272537,
-0.0318773873,
0.0677317008,
-0.0003612352,
0.0051451349,
-0.0218713544,
-0.0319642536,
0.0162190162,
0.0260283332,
-0.0384653695,
0.0320156291,
0.0382609889,
-0.0317868888,
0.0478563346,
-0.0477183312,
-0.0041138157,
0.0185473152,
-0.0081476597,
0.021275254,
-0.0265128594,
0.043523699,
0.0038528459,
0.0399200171,
0.0105718523,
0.0066145654,
0.032158792,
0.033801429,
-0.0545112006,
-0.0595946126,
0.0394907035,
0.0052589825,
-0.0181163792,
-0.012660997,
0.0097111836,
0.0043687182,
-0.0228293259,
0.0261443816,
0.0300808456,
-0.0205511376,
0.0378891043,
0.0246124715,
-0.0512986667,
-0.004654529,
-0.0716198832,
-0.0777889192,
-0.0294573922,
0.0115269581,
-0.0291144773,
-0.0172958411,
-0.0253443867,
0.0450001322,
0.0036499542,
-0.0614962541,
0.0578763857,
-0.0379366465,
0.0264106058,
0.0530857779,
-0.0273612365,
-0.0136946244,
-0.0650445521,
-0.0019349911,
0.0258129332,
0.0738128424,
0.0428951271,
0.0412074663,
-0.0244548786,
0.0142271677,
-0.0395241566,
0.046480041,
-0.017029766,
0.0839440525,
0.0228815135,
-0.0010164737,
-0.0457155295,
0.0147420531,
-0.0149882622,
-0.0137730101,
-0.0055288388,
0.0015188582,
0.0034717277,
-0.0260907486,
-0.0249123704,
0.0203946177,
0.0370678753,
-0.032828331,
0.0155704804,
0.0481147058,
-0.0027368376,
-0.0066089947,
-0.0016527638,
0.0227270052,
-0.0426160619,
0.0106529156,
0.083619982,
0.0071017146,
0.0201899614,
0.0325635336,
-0.0010647821,
0.0211053751,
0.020221645,
-0.0272815283,
-0.0467766561,
0.0086259898,
-0.0430984497,
0.0259034038,
0.0185970981,
0.0318498015,
-0.0260832068,
0.0285667907,
-0.0386104845,
0.0113326432,
-0.0399558097,
0.0094721252,
0.000724395,
-0.0186178889,
-0.0467676707,
-0.0033994208,
-0.0444093607,
-0.0308139194,
-0.0151645085,
-0.0449490957,
-0.0086363349,
0.0425156727,
2.542e-7,
-0.0161720775,
0.0379136689,
0.0108842663,
-0.0116840955,
-0.0087398542,
0.0607981458,
-0.0049687829,
0.0163949486,
-0.0038221173,
-0.0171908122,
0.0258125253,
0.0603471436,
0.0393380038,
-0.0002213171,
-0.041538544,
-0.0134701533,
-0.0693341121,
-0.0661453977,
-0.0458399579,
-0.004278474,
0.0532325953,
0.0474204905,
0.0083895782,
-0.0188657194,
0.0503659584,
-0.0498648249,
0.0119390404,
-0.046402391,
0.0257400591,
-0.0153804664,
0.0112883579,
0.0067686294,
-0.0021418838,
0.0364294909,
0.0096930536,
0.0208305102,
-0.0141463121,
0.0332349427,
-0.0422558486,
-0.053663265,
-0.0192487091,
-0.0237466991,
-0.0028270558,
-0.059821412,
0.0711739287,
-0.0663591474,
-0.0468065999,
-0.0062109195,
-0.0000149219,
-0.0133806299,
-0.0214533191,
-0.0046217046,
-0.0164773371,
-0.0128080072,
0.0053230962,
-0.0338755772,
0.0098141683,
-0.071812056,
0.0361710228,
-0.0232247375,
-0.0257696826,
-0.0472303554,
-0.0274793394,
-0.0477569774,
0.0517109931,
-0.0543684922,
-0.0136760343,
2.013716414e-34,
0.0004164964,
-0.0029025942,
0.0006414206,
0.0408958308,
0.0524909608,
0.0360436402,
0.013593425,
0.0112495301,
0.0356238112,
-0.0592873171,
0.0005789396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07912v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07912v1 | Meeting the Needs of Low-Resource Languages: The Value of Automatic Alignments via Pretrained Models | 2023-02-15T19:06:17 | 2023-02-15T19:06:17 | Abteen Ebrahimi, Arya D. McCarthy, Arturo Oncevay, Luis Chiruzzo, John E. Ortega, Gustavo A. Giménez-Lugo, Rolando Coto-Solano, Katharina Kann | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large multilingual models have inspired a new class of word alignment
methods, which work well for the model's pretraining languages. However, the
languages most in need of automatic alignment are low-resource and, thus, not
typically included in the pretraining data. In this work, we ask: How do modern
aligners perform on unseen languages, and are they better than traditional
methods? We contribute gold-standard alignments for Bribri--Spanish,
Guarani--Spanish, Quechua--Spanish, and Shipibo-Konibo--Spanish. With these, we
evaluate state-of-the-art aligners with and without model adaptation to the
target language. Finally, we also evaluate the resulting alignments
extrinsically through two downstream tasks: named entity recognition and
part-of-speech tagging. We find that although transformer-based methods
generally outperform traditional models, the two classes of approach remain
competitive with each other. | [
-0.0150721092,
0.0842406675,
0.0125636617,
0.0269818213,
-0.0061244802,
0.03183816,
-0.0064295707,
-0.0459828749,
-0.0117305452,
0.0140055241,
-0.0694165304,
-0.0369804464,
0.047469344,
-0.0486273132,
0.0167692341,
-0.0187242199,
0.0590694882,
0.0104595199,
-0.0091304109,
0.0158196948,
0.0219776984,
0.0113827735,
-0.0185943451,
-0.0026461212,
-0.025891481,
0.0071149883,
-0.0084173391,
-0.0151269808,
0.0474776812,
-0.0209461302,
0.0139219277,
0.0516691245,
-0.0515786745,
0.0850289539,
0.000001634,
-0.0619094707,
-0.0847005919,
-0.0018852974,
-0.0203798953,
0.0055819973,
-0.0017647448,
-0.0561795011,
-0.0415077507,
0.0142804524,
-0.0349594504,
-0.045142889,
0.1132591069,
0.0064170905,
-0.0030868852,
0.0570635684,
-0.0253496952,
-0.0465133116,
0.0404052399,
-0.0308760293,
-0.0264314134,
-0.0465982333,
0.0108550815,
-0.0110534783,
-0.0279320534,
-0.0373098478,
-0.018236788,
0.0668357238,
-0.0124340309,
-0.0028683492,
-0.0249993913,
-0.0128884371,
-0.0685234666,
-0.0429890417,
0.0047338456,
0.0435621738,
-0.0465604067,
-0.0572758801,
-0.005913889,
0.0154259009,
-0.0283156484,
-0.0111020068,
-0.0043222504,
0.007159038,
0.0068998504,
0.0365577899,
0.0663516223,
0.026835911,
0.0567392223,
-0.0238976646,
-0.037350826,
0.0404951721,
0.0631622374,
-0.0375760384,
0.008209263,
0.0243764576,
0.0069249682,
-0.0483587235,
-0.0075859479,
0.0221785828,
0.0003499092,
0.0161377694,
-0.0713411346,
-0.0286979936,
-0.0168361533,
-0.0184750017,
0.0004311198,
0.0613940731,
-0.0200594589,
0.0338078253,
-0.024688825,
0.0413349941,
-0.0316316076,
0.0170075558,
-0.026146654,
-0.0509331338,
0.0026816817,
0.007371848,
-0.0502412915,
-0.0309293475,
-0.0236288495,
0.0111757675,
-0.0447956286,
0.0358338654,
0.0337072462,
0.0220660251,
0.0136651304,
-0.0327777117,
-0.0173210483,
-0.0143019259,
0.0102356831,
0.0708803535,
-0.000268721,
-0.0162810292,
-0.0055931285,
-0.0819531083,
-0.0104662031,
0.0210049264,
0.0016481989,
-0.0654197931,
0.0195394792,
0.0437087826,
-0.029231241,
-0.0751317516,
-0.012342249,
0.0103793973,
-0.0500135683,
-0.0642965883,
0.0057624276,
-0.0617990792,
0.0969216004,
0.0003779444,
0.0353582688,
-0.0491165891,
0.0107857129,
-0.0416080616,
-6.579e-7,
0.0865704268,
-0.0224831533,
0.028809201,
0.0080110542,
-0.0285676401,
0.0455117561,
0.0453600436,
0.0485018902,
-0.0260871686,
0.0592316985,
-0.0154783633,
-0.0226611383,
0.0843298659,
-0.0033707365,
0.0066407565,
0.025647847,
-0.0199509952,
0.0563797355,
0.0217034034,
0.0503572933,
0.0161838662,
0.0443042703,
0.0317451619,
0.0369145013,
0.0190179348,
0.0242312327,
0.0266452506,
0.0329574682,
-0.0131627452,
0.0084497454,
0.0089673512,
-0.0128380368,
-0.0046704691,
-0.0124784168,
0.0441398658,
0.0254334528,
0.0870136097,
-0.0332793631,
0.0075446041,
-0.0027305095,
-0.008064094,
-0.0277819484,
-0.0062332372,
0.0522432327,
0.0229844134,
-0.0448058844,
0.0680403188,
0.0408745185,
-0.0422921404,
0.0133007569,
0.0075898487,
-0.0028134568,
0.008358256,
0.0367719419,
-0.0098648965,
-0.042019207,
0.040348921,
-0.0007175541,
0.0466757603,
0.023529619,
0.0123424251,
0.0032635438,
-0.0537458211,
-0.0096931458,
0.0398160517,
0.0156418104,
0.0299763829,
0.0147371134,
0.0191318803,
0.0223092716,
-0.035291519,
-0.030710116,
0.0380619466,
-0.0534979254,
-0.0224781726,
-0.0286307596,
0.0319232494,
0.004804743,
0.0376215391,
-0.0264573749,
-0.009388959,
0.0266729984,
-0.0230601188,
0.0516865812,
0.0614195317,
0.0062333392,
-0.0317995735,
0.0546697862,
-0.0191978123,
-0.0354723297,
0.010630439,
0.0092139337,
-0.0572875887,
-0.051378049,
0.0081396624,
0.0461197495,
-0.0394945927,
0.1052468419,
-0.0152332466,
0.0216249619,
-0.021801427,
0.0224154424,
0.0161524806,
0.0508845113,
-0.0234325733,
-0.0675422326,
0.0302409492,
-0.0361104347,
-0.0571255386,
0.0320033841,
-0.0052860724,
-0.0364792161,
-0.0172594935,
-0.0075685484,
0.0061284425,
-0.0055344747,
-0.0774274543,
0.0408266895,
-0.0328408703,
0.0581738316,
0.0503000543,
0.0556373596,
-0.0192868747,
0.0005620035,
-0.013313395,
-0.0285296738,
0.0279658269,
-0.0181999374,
0.033767648,
-0.0111864125,
-0.0188372098,
-0.0676800683,
0.0286459159,
-0.0316535048,
0.0300422926,
0.021499509,
-0.0661524907,
-0.0458219796,
-0.0106221577,
-0.033452563,
0.0242292993,
0.0150443614,
-0.058967609,
-0.0260699391,
0.0464460328,
0.0587373972,
0.0190103482,
-0.0154824518,
-0.0047580735,
-0.0001662727,
-0.0006519742,
-0.0190682858,
-0.0089079235,
-0.017444646,
-0.0419103689,
-0.0389328115,
-0.0414081514,
0.0273345895,
0.1417915523,
-0.0303468537,
0.0124182049,
-0.0559870787,
-0.0369623899,
0.0018459837,
0.0025223589,
0.0419010334,
0.0448308364,
-0.0078153806,
0.009397476,
-0.0452672876,
-0.0357636288,
0.0554911122,
-0.085535787,
-0.027843684,
-0.0339176506,
-0.009937522,
-0.0315938294,
0.0190381613,
0.0200621504,
0.0100762723,
0.0167786237,
-0.0233685002,
-0.0190889798,
0.060604088,
0.0126858493,
-0.0114186192,
0.0343931839,
-0.0401722044,
0.0165650193,
-0.0263745524,
-0.031764254,
-0.0185879935,
0.0001463064,
-0.044991672,
-0.0089833504,
0.0178567767,
-0.0216111895,
-0.0307446811,
0.0407149903,
0.0105914045,
0.027632514,
0.003645319,
0.0288043115,
-0.0200660042,
0.0580511726,
0.0327406153,
-0.0230585095,
0.0248216167,
-0.0296834279,
0.0157038812,
-0.0119819203,
0.0207055528,
-0.0175038539,
-0.0024873065,
-0.048701331,
0.0387123115,
-0.0425508618,
0.0053644511,
-0.05090186,
0.0447276384,
0.0066850251,
0.000504081,
0.1196490154,
0.0196162816,
0.0163556524,
-0.0148733053,
-0.0084423004,
0.0097919162,
-0.0014294703,
-0.0016534469,
-0.0800258294,
-0.0279413629,
0.0113401655,
0.0007449397,
0.0357157513,
-0.0099410452,
-0.0038307123,
-0.1223611385,
-0.0307652447,
0.0207459554,
-0.0257815477,
-0.0164137539,
-0.0053413077,
0.000441929,
-0.0674766302,
-0.0049746549,
0.0222864579,
0.0115372138,
-0.0045955358,
0.020887645,
0.0065964945,
-0.0328902639,
-0.0176318958,
-0.0855694637,
0.0262799002,
0.0697958171,
0.0225347728,
-0.0118169272,
-0.0201827474,
0.0298565309,
-0.0166664477,
-0.0462076478,
0.0445207059,
-0.0124499043,
-0.0247141216,
-0.0446938127,
0.0168803856,
0.0061952621,
-0.0120801609,
0.0073831314,
0.0102293482,
0.0544945225,
-0.0001162277,
0.040408805,
0.0438803062,
-0.0268747043,
-0.0093458518,
0.0626299903,
0.0018942502,
-0.0256179422,
0.0117766811,
0.0261881053,
0.0225039665,
-0.0101101613,
-0.0102554001,
0.0374054164,
-0.0831380785,
-0.0614098683,
-0.0475757793,
-0.0631775036,
0.0412524268,
0.0360904261,
0.0432303846,
-0.025187267,
0.0316727608,
-0.0263231173,
-0.0371989496,
0.0612407289,
-0.0261810608,
0.0131685352,
-0.0733525231,
-0.0273449868,
-0.016373612,
0.0163904633,
0.0071999254,
0.0053260582,
-0.0881939754,
-0.0622204505,
0.0114171272,
0.019855313,
0.0253217686,
0.0335885324,
-0.0320950039,
0.0115560712,
-0.0348307118,
0.0243414156,
-0.0243845768,
0.0394601598,
-0.000728294,
-0.0111153936,
-0.0132391555,
0.0360303931,
-0.0220309664,
-0.0122238025,
0.0019617905,
0.055659093,
-0.0397001877,
-0.0385784879,
-0.0050581503,
-0.0032448722,
0.0853128657,
-0.0658764541,
-0.0309218708,
-0.0323008075,
0.0139443418,
-0.011313918,
0.0049044881,
0.002087814,
-0.0345819034,
0.0477482453,
0.0345247649,
-0.004292476,
0.0408495255,
-0.0211877748,
0.0225800127,
-0.0305890292,
-0.0092193307,
0.0049528806,
0.0008794599,
0.0027598995,
0.0097937845,
0.0254125409,
0.0521321297,
0.0287381858,
0.0454007797,
-0.034149006,
0.0142003195,
-0.018322764,
0.0348782241,
-0.0027019221,
0.0407506712,
0.0237985402,
0.0082599958,
-0.0257975049,
0.0194786489,
0.0850349888,
-0.0617184415,
0.0803177357,
0.0232108068,
-0.0283613373,
-0.0087125488,
0.0499334633,
-0.0455223173,
-0.0127470372,
0.0191277917,
-0.0100958273,
-0.0268832315,
-0.0197210107,
0.0400747918,
-0.0012874199,
0.0418201014,
0.004080866,
0.0028488778,
-0.0035360598,
-0.024176063,
0.0058904304,
-0.0712189749,
-0.0508396626,
-0.0555673987,
-0.0553782545,
-0.0422401503,
0.0331640691,
0.0058641764,
-0.0296356976,
0.0254445653,
0.00372719,
0.0331812873,
-0.0529205501,
0.0056455084,
-0.0174748898,
-0.0314697437,
-0.0148615269,
-0.0116416719,
-0.00321714,
-5.466946515e-33,
-0.0501704365,
-0.018077936,
0.0108823245,
-0.0330801383,
-0.0275142901,
0.0094220303,
-0.0394306034,
-0.0106181791,
-0.0101714013,
-0.0160100628,
-0.0042072251,
-0.0249092411,
0.035731867,
0.0150466682,
0.0201593582,
-0.0054987604,
0.0326251872,
0.0273243096,
-0.0253920332,
-0.0544340685,
0.0050682272,
0.037936531,
0.1124728099,
-0.0339051001,
0.0280590188,
-0.004727162,
-0.0204711221,
0.0050612446,
0.0668202341,
0.047233317,
-0.0134498021,
-0.0360495113,
-0.0008635944,
-0.0115233548,
0.0015589028,
0.0199568905,
-0.1134161875,
0.0094048334,
0.0408378765,
0.0663343295,
0.0253328737,
-0.0301726237,
0.0023375631,
-0.0288146455,
-0.0069740284,
0.0044654189,
0.0209254306,
-0.0343134366,
0.0244611055,
-0.0200582482,
-0.0907021314,
0.0353608578,
0.0071365465,
-0.0033352398,
0.0397130549,
0.0545627996,
0.019722404,
-0.0074281334,
-0.045853924,
0.0073361257,
0.0181702003,
0.0356423929,
0.1010638028,
0.0115505001,
0.0009602942,
0.0213062037,
0.0134740761,
-0.0639048666,
0.033917997,
0.0550678447,
0.0220222007,
-0.0081344321,
-0.0021627855,
0.0586336143,
0.0182338003,
0.0055451836,
-0.0480195396,
0.0513551161,
-0.0333721451,
-0.0242126007,
-0.031561926,
0.0063909646,
-0.0496580265,
0.0278871004,
-0.0048544426,
-0.0425520465,
0.0005271028,
-0.0149047356,
0.0085749822,
0.0014024897,
-0.0276918113,
0.040167436,
0.0496883914,
-0.0217311103,
-0.0150989518,
-0.0016910215,
-0.0076281093,
0.0184197091,
-0.0516570024,
0.0351441279,
-0.0511774197,
-0.0441651456,
0.01619073,
0.0196276773,
0.0353720933,
-0.0019735263,
0.0630202964,
-0.0034080963,
-0.0788437128,
0.0371609889,
-0.039949365,
0.0176961925,
-0.0148768155,
0.0342500657,
0.0477921367,
0.0062154201,
-0.00055441,
0.0338986628,
0.0714193881,
-0.0039453991,
-0.0281532612,
0.0078367293,
-0.0022029902,
0.0033142383,
-0.0172304455,
0.0196934063,
-0.0016232253,
0.002124531,
-0.0174878817,
-0.0458756275,
-0.0038745664,
-0.0018931666,
2.331e-7,
0.082417801,
-0.0022507838,
0.0803115815,
-0.0034064315,
-0.0257538408,
-0.0020023696,
-0.0113279708,
0.0404390432,
-0.0352030098,
0.0069929319,
0.0215132758,
-0.0240700897,
0.071117647,
0.0148537112,
-0.0596878156,
-0.041170489,
-0.026233701,
-0.0252493005,
-0.0604364797,
-0.0007010049,
-0.0105597088,
0.1069070622,
-0.0017501422,
0.014192597,
-0.0269554574,
-0.0192218199,
0.0564753003,
0.0006757376,
-0.03736775,
0.0479523875,
0.0336255915,
0.0246659163,
-0.0441233106,
-0.0236997753,
-0.0342155583,
0.0528574511,
-0.0066670179,
0.0494447164,
-0.0144871427,
0.0103845075,
-0.0026358715,
-0.0381736644,
-0.0217976756,
-0.0548045337,
0.0498248152,
-0.0156704504,
-0.002603377,
0.0016650803,
-0.02325112,
0.0331849605,
-0.0047987443,
-0.0002963078,
-0.0050443783,
0.0411762856,
0.0586371645,
-0.0320784152,
-0.0569876768,
-0.0152653418,
-0.0363647044,
0.0274779145,
-0.0070171347,
-0.0299418233,
0.0033751731,
-0.0213791914,
0.0334053151,
-0.0498569757,
-0.0108529162,
2.02598885e-34,
-0.0319850557,
0.0036226022,
0.0058870199,
0.0307325292,
0.0180507917,
-0.0474129766,
-0.0031711962,
0.0176270828,
-0.0407853052,
-0.0201831833,
0.0081018498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07866v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07866v1 | Do Deep Neural Networks Capture Compositionality in Arithmetic Reasoning? | 2023-02-15T18:59:04 | 2023-02-15T18:59:04 | Keito Kudo, Yoichi Aoki, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Ana Brassard, Masashi Yoshikawa, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Compositionality is a pivotal property of symbolic reasoning. However, how
well recent neural models capture compositionality remains underexplored in the
symbolic reasoning tasks. This study empirically addresses this question by
systematically examining recently published pre-trained seq2seq models with a
carefully controlled dataset of multi-hop arithmetic symbolic reasoning. We
introduce a skill tree on compositionality in arithmetic symbolic reasoning
that defines the hierarchical levels of complexity along with three
compositionality dimensions: systematicity, productivity, and substitutivity.
Our experiments revealed that among the three types of composition, the models
struggled most with systematicity, performing poorly even with relatively
simple compositions. That difficulty was not resolved even after training the
models with intermediate reasoning steps. | [
-0.0263441112,
0.1146190315,
-0.0185468867,
0.0003637799,
-0.0328381546,
0.0384879634,
0.0152324084,
-0.0224712212,
-0.0816109553,
-0.0011539957,
-0.0151634151,
-0.031911049,
0.0131599773,
0.0110909436,
0.0262653828,
-0.0074130413,
0.0241225045,
-0.0240050554,
-0.0099743493,
0.0019427694,
-0.0603885837,
-0.0003436233,
-0.0388165265,
-0.0066717854,
-0.0426168628,
-0.0418456793,
-0.0056758183,
-0.0517221354,
0.0197130125,
0.008204692,
-0.0372820161,
0.0471975952,
0.0324071869,
0.0878810361,
0.0000019688,
-0.0322198533,
0.00533771,
0.0056992937,
-0.0532319471,
0.0071323849,
-0.0205826908,
-0.0084570814,
0.0049549774,
0.0137034627,
-0.0260269083,
0.026254287,
0.0512084141,
0.0229599923,
0.048777774,
0.0447123162,
0.0142966257,
-0.0588124916,
0.013681856,
-0.0177424736,
0.0367456116,
-0.0005269321,
0.0027461175,
0.0140779447,
-0.0139944442,
-0.0069578798,
-0.0231404379,
-0.0029444804,
0.0975414068,
0.0108136758,
-0.0528754257,
0.0310333651,
-0.0037149845,
0.0237209629,
0.0386438183,
0.0503864251,
0.0013171923,
-0.0046860166,
-0.0095795859,
-0.0233284552,
0.0179163329,
-0.0430816188,
-0.0367545336,
0.0538540334,
-0.010331424,
-0.0037834586,
-0.0062801805,
0.0206158906,
0.0285846628,
-0.0140046561,
-0.0415552408,
0.0493482724,
0.0014181081,
-0.0328977741,
0.0211493336,
-0.0313850157,
-0.0354691558,
-0.0272388067,
0.0019605502,
0.05376691,
0.001013866,
-0.0037324282,
0.0140040461,
-0.0243049506,
-0.0327596478,
0.0058932547,
0.0558831841,
0.0890763029,
0.0316933654,
0.0205188412,
-0.0536071919,
0.0510162488,
-0.0118711675,
0.0530031249,
-0.0267734956,
0.0149453506,
-0.0354271829,
-0.0531108007,
-0.0402154997,
0.0640955269,
-0.0007752073,
-0.0295927227,
-0.0517041013,
-0.0048776804,
-0.0542648584,
0.0170289893,
-0.0093803825,
-0.0029961278,
0.0081419637,
-0.0142266545,
-0.0106950514,
-0.0045919623,
-0.0480866097,
0.0426961444,
0.0240061097,
0.0210798439,
0.0037946373,
-0.0264375526,
-0.0330854654,
-0.0041663982,
0.0279964395,
0.0635813698,
0.0032111078,
0.0221440755,
-0.0134160826,
-0.02883224,
0.0315411463,
-0.0655712187,
0.0544006713,
-0.0776561573,
0.0592972673,
-0.0227755681,
-0.0075720358,
-0.0281347949,
0.0022171389,
0.0091024311,
0.0266474579,
0.0510164648,
0.0423311405,
-0.0080894521,
-0.0033259185,
-0.0128976554,
-0.024880344,
0.0569569841,
0.0554433204,
-0.0035989212,
-0.0301410072,
-0.0177003201,
-0.020583624,
-0.0077674259,
0.0067895898,
-0.0526974574,
-0.0294180829,
-0.0415820368,
-0.0388455875,
0.0522508696,
-0.0143349404,
0.0622986183,
-0.0561224073,
-0.064166449,
-0.0071319286,
0.0413991623,
0.0565069877,
0.0200973954,
0.0912715197,
-0.0283110924,
0.0546636917,
0.0195155423,
-0.1063589975,
0.0481331274,
-0.0192367397,
0.0084299473,
-0.0113924015,
-0.0025832686,
-0.0295338519,
-0.0722386315,
-0.0002310431,
0.0140886242,
0.0179066956,
-0.0114960475,
0.0462677144,
-0.0090134013,
-0.0020295333,
0.0447085239,
-0.0026784353,
-0.0247886293,
0.0033066843,
-0.011033006,
0.0277002435,
0.0119057875,
0.0045677014,
-0.0426370688,
0.0075810878,
-0.024929177,
0.0104652913,
-0.0095976163,
0.0093330014,
-0.0093761785,
0.0163788572,
-0.0245692041,
-0.0300348233,
-0.0699246004,
0.0459136702,
0.00840683,
0.0061702034,
-0.0278880354,
0.0223382264,
-0.0412221067,
0.0457876474,
0.0113049401,
-0.038610667,
-0.0213334989,
-0.0138332946,
0.0319067836,
-0.018250078,
0.0074974145,
0.0191402007,
0.0686977282,
-0.0140154706,
-0.0144118136,
-0.0548383445,
0.0010096,
-0.0804724172,
-0.0438867323,
0.0281306077,
-0.0738947093,
-0.0164671317,
0.0131884189,
-0.0483001769,
-0.0362099893,
0.0655943379,
-0.0578505807,
-0.0181139279,
-0.0010653235,
-0.0015035609,
0.0231971778,
-0.0348762274,
0.0047159698,
0.0563270189,
-0.0035759963,
0.0240311846,
-0.0012629807,
0.0167211611,
0.0126645258,
0.0169703774,
0.0426682271,
-0.0274775159,
-0.0304824486,
-0.0122294351,
-0.0520376228,
-0.0117840292,
-0.0294992384,
-0.0109172072,
-0.0287322514,
-0.0034976902,
-0.0307055358,
0.0430542976,
0.0133889625,
-0.0156836752,
0.0215707086,
0.0201024916,
-0.042721156,
0.0336123221,
-0.0252004992,
0.0348728187,
0.0288695842,
-0.0155542884,
-0.0427976362,
0.0116334045,
-0.062720567,
-0.0787017867,
0.0662514865,
-0.0096010845,
0.0578987859,
0.0216563791,
-0.041622851,
-0.0019101986,
-0.0213111732,
-0.0167920552,
-0.0103405472,
0.0265204851,
0.0032885147,
-0.0156684276,
0.04068112,
-0.0225983355,
0.0120022083,
0.0029927276,
-0.0071107014,
-0.0006245688,
0.0303021725,
-0.0207451507,
0.0350823179,
0.0102755958,
-0.0138163706,
-0.0313204192,
0.1008965373,
-0.0534230694,
0.0083139269,
-0.0415879115,
0.0375551023,
-0.0177695565,
0.0224047247,
-0.0260791406,
-0.0169858057,
-0.0003118847,
0.0227023195,
-0.0281596575,
0.0050982945,
0.0669159219,
0.0241753403,
-0.0015611933,
-0.0222213864,
0.0297301337,
-0.0629892722,
0.0786727071,
-0.002518655,
-0.0078530163,
-0.0119009512,
-0.0478444546,
-0.076296851,
0.0019893709,
0.0476942733,
-0.0012914366,
0.0354283974,
-0.0096168388,
-0.0016980156,
-0.0343530849,
-0.0405132882,
-0.0258466564,
0.0633667037,
-0.0262368657,
0.0901477933,
0.0095753474,
-0.0344838127,
0.0088528208,
-0.0182139445,
-0.0040435069,
0.0247335266,
-0.0096711628,
-0.0230378862,
-0.019483896,
-0.016766943,
0.0044048475,
0.0445353761,
0.0903280303,
-0.0592140295,
0.0362704471,
0.004803902,
0.0474262424,
0.0113214422,
-0.0102060847,
0.0379497968,
-0.0110261496,
-0.0281090196,
-0.0111818947,
0.0388775952,
-0.0047277324,
-0.0662197471,
0.0112474458,
0.0516358465,
0.0273484644,
-0.0094884634,
0.0342248715,
-0.0479867235,
-0.0472638533,
0.0291472692,
0.0106062656,
-0.1273667961,
-0.0319387652,
0.0308180992,
-0.0582684912,
0.0195625927,
-0.0490072668,
0.0094251791,
-0.0708383098,
0.0075653959,
0.0332987532,
-0.0977539495,
-0.032041762,
0.0210016798,
-0.0034993722,
0.0032388475,
-0.0210104156,
0.0227581412,
-0.0342837945,
-0.0024646185,
0.0083719017,
-0.0378487296,
-0.0080182906,
0.0094765332,
-0.0141739054,
-0.0297112241,
0.0278923735,
-0.0009347924,
-0.0150707569,
-0.0673367903,
0.083445102,
-0.0100172367,
-0.0123221278,
0.0237230584,
0.0015884938,
0.0030147717,
-0.0075853798,
0.0010430833,
0.066130586,
-0.0407588556,
-0.0189362038,
-0.0231888164,
0.0815197676,
-0.0024178028,
-0.0365720354,
-0.0148498332,
0.0247979853,
-0.0294840988,
0.0419238769,
0.0514805056,
-0.0019863909,
-0.0592469722,
-0.0507378243,
-0.0202651583,
-0.07419312,
0.0154746789,
0.0465352833,
0.0951430127,
-0.0109259589,
-0.0205593668,
-0.0457961671,
0.0302952193,
0.027661005,
-0.0222904775,
-0.0279377047,
0.0030467273,
-0.0176970381,
-0.0636696294,
0.0230061077,
-0.0024010988,
0.0823266655,
-0.0109122721,
0.0527310409,
-0.0493633896,
-0.0118770162,
-0.0411985442,
-0.0601877309,
-0.1203610823,
-0.0165130459,
-0.0212321971,
0.0348083936,
0.0150101054,
-0.0228663087,
-0.0038492843,
-0.0181736238,
0.0185190476,
0.0165206734,
-0.0261381101,
0.0040125716,
0.0739434734,
-0.0092606246,
0.0119720725,
0.0280074291,
-0.0229823049,
0.0189026389,
0.0318861194,
0.0419057906,
0.0068857423,
0.0755829141,
0.0234979168,
-0.049228169,
-0.0154296765,
0.0578838028,
0.0361656658,
-0.009637027,
0.0411408879,
-0.0176313818,
-0.0154128913,
-0.0486882515,
-0.0114890365,
0.0111339213,
0.0240463745,
0.018703308,
-0.0242499989,
0.0559875704,
0.0310200118,
0.0256013125,
0.0270493552,
0.028315926,
0.0050232783,
0.0356750116,
-0.0090553602,
-0.0165365525,
0.0255627595,
-0.0318780802,
0.0311377477,
-0.007634066,
0.0339546688,
0.0324785076,
0.0338171981,
-0.0657524318,
-0.0266025849,
-0.0407496467,
-0.0702174678,
0.021783663,
-0.0356534235,
0.0615609176,
-0.0017119219,
-0.0713047683,
-0.0430055521,
0.0112020122,
-0.0076808697,
-0.0056630354,
-0.0092358841,
-0.0008682673,
0.0276444014,
0.0513301119,
0.0439968146,
-0.0676357523,
0.0354944319,
-0.0433159731,
0.0531457439,
-0.0090037789,
0.0439727791,
0.0165250059,
-0.0372318439,
-0.0106515363,
0.0478944518,
-0.0188969243,
0.0096112452,
-0.0733531788,
-0.051695656,
-0.0235653482,
0.0235083196,
0.0072825393,
0.0222016145,
0.0486936755,
0.060173355,
-0.0263294987,
-0.0305603053,
0.0322517566,
-0.0130571499,
0.0059019811,
-0.0013523332,
0.0028113164,
-5.725849146e-33,
0.0008414113,
-0.0256085768,
0.0467779525,
-0.0227864999,
-0.0075368867,
0.0072048483,
-0.0255680364,
0.0065686842,
-0.0201591235,
0.0502512567,
0.0028488394,
0.0258499589,
-0.0055374531,
0.0186080858,
0.0203800965,
-0.0079409778,
0.0138670681,
-0.0027564191,
-0.0377407782,
-0.0025374868,
0.0218475088,
-0.0146606686,
0.0493938588,
-0.0123187965,
-0.002318535,
0.0543011241,
0.0125930356,
0.0002205553,
-0.0804488957,
0.0757283866,
0.0176404268,
0.0039050197,
0.0183647648,
-0.0008351612,
-0.0349954702,
-0.0123705324,
-0.0525054894,
-0.0588199832,
-0.0038846217,
-0.0070844553,
-0.083919473,
-0.0384850055,
0.0588863231,
0.0044023772,
-0.0008635664,
-0.090303354,
-0.0020660667,
0.0043240925,
0.0133012142,
-0.0702820942,
-0.0597147495,
0.0110886879,
-0.0261421259,
-0.0005584332,
-0.0106519563,
0.0234859958,
-0.0129141482,
-0.01667195,
-0.0393997319,
0.0243662857,
0.0098605053,
-0.0030812188,
0.0166277401,
0.0115194479,
0.0137022128,
0.0078966869,
0.037828926,
-0.0055645891,
-0.0301560555,
0.0504098497,
0.0067613907,
0.0665479004,
0.0957291797,
-0.0176092703,
0.0946869403,
0.0398239121,
-0.0490517356,
-0.0455619954,
0.0022927932,
0.0393621251,
0.0002272149,
-0.0207523163,
-0.0099799559,
-0.0116527416,
-0.0564406365,
0.0119791599,
-0.0488057695,
-0.0289059654,
0.013677191,
0.0064651761,
0.0355343521,
0.012064538,
-0.0023119382,
-0.0471572243,
-0.0147438543,
0.0485386215,
0.0279020518,
0.0301738903,
0.0104012974,
0.0332085602,
-0.0437224843,
-0.0395282507,
0.0042299689,
0.0049496754,
0.0326393656,
0.0157573912,
0.0584186763,
0.03804015,
-0.021024568,
-0.0353473015,
-0.0322455205,
-0.0289644189,
0.0379314497,
0.0014200842,
0.0674755126,
0.0285104867,
-0.0046345065,
0.0230678208,
-0.0617663972,
-0.0050139171,
-0.0237084795,
0.0471754372,
-0.0204733275,
0.0784272999,
0.0333203375,
-0.0376719572,
-0.0351406187,
-0.0231543593,
0.0262034014,
-0.0558463894,
-0.0099180499,
0.0142235644,
2.632e-7,
0.0325172208,
-0.0156575441,
0.0392838866,
0.0305237826,
0.0365441032,
0.0072654388,
-0.0306210518,
-0.0195893794,
-0.0308294464,
-0.0174349509,
0.0144060981,
0.0470892638,
0.027958421,
0.0171366818,
-0.0244224202,
0.0134378811,
-0.0446974225,
0.0090387231,
-0.0314737298,
0.0234758202,
0.0395046324,
0.0742003694,
0.0026619888,
-0.00141551,
0.010806527,
-0.0073944381,
0.0422297455,
0.0195445772,
0.0454746895,
0.0055952864,
-0.0154564558,
-0.0439209677,
0.0359419584,
0.0195417143,
0.0009898894,
0.0556287691,
0.0074480339,
0.043856971,
0.0102963056,
0.0148237795,
-0.0268332027,
-0.040426027,
-0.0054836315,
-0.0022639642,
0.0574151389,
-0.1131935939,
-0.0247069336,
0.0090648737,
-0.0085764648,
-0.0023163271,
0.0585145466,
0.0311309043,
0.0345478058,
-0.0045965943,
0.0222102907,
-0.026430089,
0.023547953,
-0.0870558247,
-0.0141732004,
0.0308221877,
-0.0292324647,
0.0036658426,
-0.0322786346,
-0.0042642681,
0.04186178,
-0.0023221564,
-0.0584626906,
2.396824946e-34,
0.0564157069,
-0.0431770682,
0.0537910312,
0.0237610303,
0.0330152325,
-0.0430553108,
-0.0359989554,
0.0155246854,
0.0431596749,
-0.0387952812,
-0.0260353256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07863v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07863v4 | Speculative Decoding with Big Little Decoder | 2023-02-15T18:55:29 | 2023-10-12T17:23:56 | Sehoon Kim, Karttikeya Mangalam, Suhong Moon, Jitendra Malik, Michael W. Mahoney, Amir Gholami, Kurt Keutzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent emergence of Large Language Models based on the Transformer
architecture has enabled dramatic advancements in the field of Natural Language
Processing. However, these models have long inference latency, which limits
their deployment and makes them prohibitively expensive for various real-time
applications. The inference latency is further exacerbated by autoregressive
generative tasks, as models need to run iteratively to generate tokens
sequentially without leveraging token-level parallelization. To address this,
we propose Big Little Decoder (BiLD), a framework that can improve inference
efficiency and latency for a wide range of text generation applications. The
BiLD framework contains two models with different sizes that collaboratively
generate text. The small model runs autoregressively to generate text with a
low inference cost, and the large model is only invoked occasionally to refine
the small model's inaccurate predictions in a non-autoregressive manner. To
coordinate the small and large models, BiLD introduces two simple yet effective
policies: (1) the fallback policy that determines when to hand control over to
the large model; and (2) the rollback policy that determines when the large
model needs to correct the small model's inaccurate predictions. To evaluate
our framework across different tasks and models, we apply BiLD to various text
generation scenarios encompassing machine translation on IWSLT 2017 De-En and
WMT 2014 De-En, and summarization on XSUM and CNN/DailyMail. On an NVIDIA T4
GPU, our framework achieves a speedup of up to 2.12x speedup with minimal
generation quality degradation. Furthermore, our framework is fully
plug-and-play and can be applied without any modifications in the training
process or model architecture. Our code is open-sourced | [
0.0423833728,
0.0947545469,
0.0230296105,
0.0027839148,
-0.0455254838,
0.0169691145,
0.0165968984,
-0.010060803,
-0.0397876948,
-0.0208933037,
0.0240356978,
-0.0718088821,
0.0305619277,
0.0401490293,
0.0068430714,
-0.0472414792,
-0.0055396361,
-0.0187261887,
0.0145248491,
-0.0240816101,
-0.0015843746,
0.0359053649,
0.0009679778,
0.0442466177,
-0.0151214926,
-0.0118817212,
-0.0213545952,
0.0221291445,
0.0218234435,
-0.0052532535,
0.0116313519,
0.0342072174,
0.0075871213,
0.0633600578,
0.000002136,
-0.0003362524,
-0.0304050501,
0.0104680071,
0.0409202129,
0.0028788154,
0.0375405252,
-0.0546716601,
-0.042692855,
0.0369578451,
-0.0249877535,
-0.0495582893,
0.0458308384,
0.0312522277,
0.0153594185,
0.0629445985,
-0.0033272344,
-0.0197906904,
0.0295620412,
-0.0354980603,
-0.0259700604,
-0.0245494731,
-0.0118597513,
-0.0176619589,
-0.0455616564,
-0.0077441465,
0.0008648658,
0.0151945092,
0.0467781276,
-0.0112893796,
-0.0125109144,
0.0669261217,
0.0027698374,
-0.0393432863,
-0.0159107503,
0.0154229561,
-0.038282685,
-0.0471832938,
0.0090312809,
0.0040605483,
-0.0296244174,
-0.0492430218,
-0.0267680008,
0.0763099864,
-0.0178723428,
0.023530921,
0.0559868887,
0.0319106244,
0.022685755,
0.0232515037,
-0.0477844477,
0.0113945901,
0.0227721035,
0.0050407345,
-0.0619955063,
0.0411232673,
-0.0072926572,
-0.0590017326,
0.0218270086,
0.0151916724,
-0.0465696603,
-0.0170060266,
-0.0929403082,
-0.0616508015,
0.0021762021,
-0.0066299923,
0.0300247408,
0.0448284186,
0.0284675304,
-0.0136700096,
-0.0381460339,
0.0179925151,
-0.0056739571,
-0.0220293347,
-0.0328138396,
-0.0104508689,
0.0106526529,
-0.0090675121,
-0.0521419868,
0.0158719178,
-0.0821862668,
-0.035673134,
-0.0259314701,
0.0083045242,
0.0028273752,
0.0085675269,
0.0390877798,
0.0413098596,
-0.0615846254,
-0.0184238683,
0.0300688762,
0.0415244624,
-0.0253705159,
-0.0139650544,
0.0489298254,
-0.0735309869,
-0.020627765,
0.0263134036,
0.0287704542,
-0.0151754096,
-0.0217957459,
0.0481693223,
-0.0436128601,
-0.0167696141,
-0.0083591603,
-0.0463920273,
-0.0100175524,
-0.0692574456,
-0.0134224445,
-0.0849880129,
0.0204698853,
0.0200995095,
0.0044635446,
-0.0201596934,
0.0137067521,
0.0320224352,
0.0149236284,
0.0435287729,
-0.0349015854,
-0.0194183663,
0.039700482,
-0.0015415478,
0.0349555649,
0.0759600326,
0.053669937,
0.0806940421,
0.0034535092,
0.0118575981,
-0.0188068561,
0.0242221151,
0.0333283208,
0.0113120591,
-0.0134991603,
-0.0340445824,
-0.0208874457,
0.0353566483,
0.0709237829,
0.0817507207,
-0.0442848466,
0.0395833775,
0.0779752061,
0.0118090939,
-0.0103021963,
0.0441710465,
0.0591292419,
0.0394180492,
-0.0288055688,
0.0019819362,
-0.0122781238,
0.047340408,
0.0010302416,
0.0228385702,
0.0625030622,
0.080256924,
-0.01619111,
-0.0130307926,
0.0260433238,
-0.0291404743,
0.0202083495,
-0.0220773462,
0.0509257615,
0.0371125676,
-0.0692833439,
0.0606082864,
0.0150002213,
-0.0583976246,
-0.0034886564,
-0.0328533761,
0.0232806262,
0.071088329,
0.0647313669,
0.0550134741,
-0.001664429,
-0.0125600621,
-0.0245484691,
0.0651799217,
0.0230668131,
0.0103296628,
0.0045412532,
-0.0573474765,
-0.0008856584,
0.0213280655,
0.0053119953,
0.0372603796,
0.0458651446,
0.0120858317,
0.0393225886,
0.0118532628,
-0.0528262891,
0.0154820569,
-0.0322816074,
-0.025849849,
0.0265927296,
-0.0043149572,
0.0054028942,
-0.0078745764,
-0.0144789722,
0.0157038365,
0.0223856363,
-0.0471535809,
-0.024058843,
0.0260733683,
-0.063954629,
-0.0364545286,
0.0117523158,
-0.0206379872,
0.0407497883,
0.0527679771,
-0.0382688493,
-0.0574351214,
0.0408603027,
-0.05617515,
0.0220822394,
-0.0476607829,
0.0074360636,
0.027485365,
0.0268967431,
0.0036161954,
0.0293115638,
-0.0280110873,
-0.0018223308,
0.023456661,
0.0051406096,
-0.0187269542,
-0.0172116589,
0.0043882891,
-0.0085571837,
-0.0255768448,
0.0017087763,
0.0379284211,
0.011161088,
0.0116569232,
-0.0302885417,
-0.0750773549,
0.0133242011,
-0.0278811045,
-0.0030270463,
0.0339184515,
0.0546179712,
0.0042124842,
0.0073493849,
-0.0085881185,
0.0027104625,
0.0228814892,
0.0031544804,
0.0043620104,
-0.0092795053,
0.0118772974,
-0.0008494196,
0.0024420093,
0.0378915779,
0.0451038033,
0.0081203217,
-0.0284600146,
-0.0751019046,
-0.0020002034,
0.0029870293,
0.0065378393,
0.0039135325,
-0.0505346656,
0.0070777792,
-0.0039967708,
0.0885552242,
0.0203889739,
0.0317761451,
0.0249221381,
-0.0119523313,
-0.0007214866,
-0.0470121354,
0.0177705809,
-0.0309055634,
-0.0097207595,
-0.0202901177,
-0.071498923,
-0.011171178,
0.0822001696,
0.0166756883,
0.0017027741,
-0.0681884736,
0.0123148467,
-0.0178551059,
-0.0496853068,
0.0196659043,
-0.0163048916,
-0.0198860355,
0.011730439,
-0.019847881,
-0.0495792292,
0.0305581633,
-0.0546040125,
0.0052419323,
-0.0357255004,
0.0081415605,
-0.0275674127,
0.0530586094,
0.0314805992,
0.0285901465,
-0.0118422424,
-0.0183289256,
0.0015140733,
0.0568996146,
0.0032553326,
-0.0237478297,
0.0197671987,
-0.0303683057,
0.0037232072,
-0.0560866222,
-0.0349582843,
-0.0258262344,
-0.0299805067,
-0.036818821,
0.0040160576,
0.0698297024,
-0.063546218,
-0.0261297282,
0.006043822,
-0.019905718,
0.0571672432,
-0.0408564061,
-0.0198090523,
-0.0150838559,
0.037136931,
0.0621290356,
-0.0250948928,
0.0138844317,
-0.044074893,
0.0057441266,
0.0847733095,
0.0312161762,
0.0024016679,
-0.0788603723,
-0.0410114266,
0.0383623578,
0.008775779,
0.0037668024,
0.0223839488,
0.0796953887,
-0.0540725626,
-0.0462806188,
0.1131170392,
0.0082392944,
-0.0514370948,
0.0017436726,
0.0316187888,
0.0859650746,
-0.0197650529,
0.0101731261,
-0.0770855248,
-0.0299849026,
0.0386064276,
0.0386676751,
-0.0242817439,
-0.0218717717,
-0.0405240841,
-0.1026711687,
0.0473084748,
0.0256254002,
-0.0137036396,
-0.0260896869,
-0.0154036591,
-0.0547017306,
0.0139675299,
0.0059022838,
0.0337841548,
0.0051533515,
0.0289128181,
0.0353002809,
-0.0043703625,
-0.016750114,
-0.0343094841,
-0.0125794951,
0.0336174183,
0.0453829169,
0.0017367369,
0.0319876932,
-0.0129795419,
0.0047850925,
-0.0129779354,
0.004558512,
-0.0370339155,
0.0311476849,
-0.0227253772,
0.0082279667,
-0.0279835258,
0.0443023257,
-0.0313485339,
-0.0064115203,
-0.0232600253,
0.0320963524,
-0.0049823797,
-0.0446496606,
-0.0084099518,
0.009719437,
0.0268890932,
0.0491312668,
0.0374459177,
-0.0408894941,
-0.0564020947,
-0.0250744279,
0.0027064569,
-0.120130226,
0.0037476367,
-0.0537974834,
0.0467824936,
-0.0578808039,
-0.0587494522,
-0.0118990475,
0.002328377,
0.0362525024,
-0.0298579074,
-0.0101530263,
-0.0067611788,
-0.0184163526,
-0.0840026513,
-0.0120177232,
-0.0122267241,
0.0156482179,
-0.0584302247,
-0.0037180523,
0.0161901712,
-0.0339050442,
-0.0111095458,
0.0537269041,
-0.1362671107,
-0.0605915375,
-0.0098775914,
0.0356849395,
0.0160143618,
0.0616661012,
-0.0043668044,
-0.0544190295,
0.0460616685,
0.086795032,
-0.0567544922,
0.0149414232,
-0.0080240164,
-0.0119960215,
-0.003317758,
0.042002812,
-0.0015563916,
0.0176452827,
-0.0175140593,
0.0367965773,
0.0182208717,
-0.0163085125,
0.0081388196,
-0.0038638585,
0.0107787754,
-0.0771351233,
0.0126833469,
-0.0033568041,
0.0129056592,
-0.0154806683,
-0.0058236164,
-0.0513561852,
0.0296420511,
0.0328124017,
-0.013290423,
-0.0154863242,
0.0318364389,
0.0565095283,
0.0157870669,
-0.0224754307,
-0.0088123893,
-0.0517963655,
0.0214848109,
0.039512042,
-0.0158630833,
-0.0266282968,
-0.0394786075,
-0.0096423198,
0.0272694025,
-0.0362989083,
0.0118719731,
0.0351399966,
0.0162531976,
0.0012961132,
0.0225432701,
-0.0432249047,
-0.0252380967,
-0.05423823,
0.0077725071,
0.0377635956,
0.0152850337,
0.095650509,
-0.0268568881,
0.0147542758,
-0.0202874709,
0.0361636393,
-0.0125636589,
-0.0368021913,
0.0165557396,
-0.0103387265,
-0.0148634398,
-0.010771051,
0.1000684872,
0.0143437311,
0.015027822,
0.0147024523,
-0.0016532416,
-0.0384412147,
-0.0455427952,
-0.036092151,
-0.0038043822,
-0.0170658249,
-0.0066055688,
0.0052281674,
-0.0237899832,
0.0016119784,
0.0105449446,
0.0149089256,
-0.0182345696,
0.0142680611,
0.0336086303,
-0.0174460001,
-0.0214354824,
-0.0502963364,
0.0458134823,
0.0203540754,
-0.0144722052,
-0.0201109704,
-6.839313395e-33,
-0.014135845,
-0.0330943018,
0.0283635817,
-0.0510432385,
-0.0312118009,
0.0221212283,
-0.0363288149,
-0.0358135104,
0.0449832901,
0.0194841661,
-0.0031046434,
0.0032826983,
0.0251121949,
0.07122197,
-0.0007984893,
0.0435385481,
0.0841889903,
-0.0151163684,
-0.0366164744,
0.0550700873,
0.0471227914,
0.050467968,
0.0065645264,
-0.0033762045,
-0.0244739093,
-0.0260846261,
-0.0096028047,
-0.018897105,
0.0185136348,
0.0153354686,
-0.0244256109,
0.0134878764,
0.0121817952,
-0.0268255416,
-0.0451506972,
0.0322223604,
-0.1040221602,
0.0061837118,
-0.0027971684,
0.0282616951,
-0.050503321,
-0.0454042591,
0.0048938235,
0.0073461286,
-0.0175562445,
-0.0332528986,
-0.0169241764,
-0.0085517932,
-0.0326827466,
-0.0703348741,
-0.0539639816,
0.0288949069,
0.0051184371,
-0.0021116307,
0.0375660434,
0.0531503297,
-0.00247758,
0.0124203758,
-0.0740582123,
0.0039374526,
-0.01491863,
0.0537931658,
0.0598320067,
0.0093465224,
-0.0140584596,
0.0481436141,
0.0168186463,
-0.0175381526,
-0.061481405,
0.0328702591,
-0.0053212778,
0.0280298069,
0.0122867282,
0.0344194509,
0.0534743145,
-0.037605051,
-0.0418234728,
0.0393068977,
-0.0109903738,
0.0265107732,
0.0772015229,
0.0042769234,
-0.0037895902,
-0.0185174067,
-0.0186409634,
-0.0105680395,
-0.0077501982,
-0.0013259292,
0.0234637111,
0.0840265453,
-0.0398813151,
-0.021375766,
0.0344027542,
-0.0385765471,
0.0164954495,
0.0181717314,
-0.0104700653,
0.0032801344,
-0.02188625,
0.0119066145,
-0.0400528386,
-0.0202434249,
0.0435007289,
0.0244399048,
-0.0203749053,
0.0195697546,
0.0270353239,
0.0439828001,
-0.0758846328,
0.01298685,
-0.0590021349,
0.0797264427,
0.0094885491,
0.0225496441,
0.0344216339,
-0.0135528492,
-0.0215223618,
0.0219342727,
-0.0222960841,
0.0314088464,
-0.00785877,
0.0006012684,
0.0165072791,
0.0278291237,
-0.0325472578,
0.0285031926,
-0.0440655425,
0.0189772695,
0.0278394893,
-0.0564778112,
-0.0480640344,
0.0234937333,
2.836e-7,
0.0046840585,
0.0488081835,
0.0703269243,
0.0086720781,
0.0253414996,
0.0177398007,
0.0236159991,
0.0538232066,
0.0077421237,
0.0528268814,
-0.0013344595,
0.0157093536,
0.0730353594,
0.0020804445,
-0.0721666962,
0.0024916432,
-0.0770099759,
0.0260319058,
-0.022632502,
-0.0524145178,
0.0210285503,
0.0565844737,
-0.0328087769,
-0.0351432078,
0.0709767416,
0.0035351897,
0.0635491014,
0.0033245285,
-0.0129658571,
0.0035832063,
0.0242457539,
0.0173008163,
-0.0041487054,
-0.0237816237,
-0.0210811608,
-0.0322816521,
-0.0462514609,
0.0375590287,
0.0054899841,
-0.0040127924,
0.0341032222,
-0.0343690626,
0.0090087559,
-0.0569347627,
0.0403568819,
-0.0408612639,
-0.0044451477,
-0.0146210035,
-0.0359501466,
0.0175119322,
-0.016132256,
-0.0172702912,
-0.0185312517,
0.0402471088,
0.0310327131,
0.0080404291,
-0.0274704248,
-0.0470782034,
-0.0268517174,
-0.0408026688,
-0.0637494251,
-0.0291042943,
-0.0723146498,
0.0100294659,
0.0075776819,
-0.0352278091,
-0.0041689104,
2.87187734e-34,
0.054556407,
-0.0147897592,
-0.0252878573,
0.0191616956,
0.0170322079,
-0.027037872,
0.0254508238,
0.0261804685,
-0.0051874346,
-0.0570912585,
-0.0502547882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07856v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07856v1 | Dictionary-based Phrase-level Prompting of Large Language Models for Machine Translation | 2023-02-15T18:46:42 | 2023-02-15T18:46:42 | Marjan Ghazvininejad, Hila Gonen, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable machine translation (MT)
abilities via prompting, even though they were not explicitly trained for this
task. However, even given the incredible quantities of data they are trained
on, LLMs can struggle to translate inputs with rare words, which are common in
low resource or domain transfer scenarios. We show that LLM prompting can
provide an effective solution for rare words as well, by using prior knowledge
from bilingual dictionaries to provide control hints in the prompts. We propose
a novel method, DiPMT, that provides a set of possible translations for a
subset of the input words, thereby enabling fine-grained phrase-level prompted
control of the LLM. Extensive experiments show that DiPMT outperforms the
baseline both in low-resource MT, as well as for out-of-domain MT. We further
provide a qualitative analysis of the benefits and limitations of this
approach, including the overall level of controllability that is achieved. | [
0.0466558747,
0.0190350786,
-0.0003507843,
0.0467475243,
-0.0515562147,
0.018045079,
0.027066892,
-0.0031784347,
0.020240033,
-0.0155647798,
-0.0327094197,
-0.0495846309,
0.0000036426,
-0.0182374939,
0.014885678,
-0.0372681729,
0.0386829041,
-0.0697466135,
-0.0394218154,
-0.0221189409,
-0.0289273374,
0.0164548848,
0.023628002,
0.0027290273,
0.0211165436,
0.0022889315,
0.0099405982,
0.0373064876,
0.0006598602,
-0.018447021,
-0.0157656036,
0.0535304993,
0.0307184421,
0.0553166047,
0.0000021097,
-0.0492214821,
-0.0472616926,
0.0036960552,
-0.0155060235,
0.0202327389,
0.0550944023,
-0.0518620685,
-0.0079967706,
0.0135383699,
-0.0286538787,
0.0007481744,
0.0595442578,
0.0103295585,
0.0606302842,
0.0623572133,
-0.004334827,
0.004129441,
-0.0337087214,
-0.0711633861,
0.0085572312,
-0.0609939285,
0.0131305279,
-0.0188660379,
-0.0111612799,
0.045473218,
-0.0062514553,
0.0652060211,
-0.0051238039,
-0.0230742227,
-0.0150754601,
-0.0184201915,
-0.0188064091,
-0.0598899946,
-0.0441038646,
0.0751934126,
-0.0071930308,
0.0033934899,
0.0046699415,
-0.0040628863,
-0.0106530311,
0.03366201,
-0.0227498822,
0.0111358846,
0.0131509323,
0.0106566586,
0.0371458046,
0.0301440172,
0.0373329632,
0.0072334488,
-0.0801650509,
-0.0116737541,
0.0525405891,
-0.0322109014,
-0.0125852991,
0.0249240007,
0.0015308578,
-0.0607375428,
0.0107434755,
-0.0135527803,
-0.0517451614,
0.0168066248,
-0.0431123078,
-0.0486920327,
0.0061991471,
-0.0126639623,
0.0485424437,
0.0513260402,
-0.0457520001,
0.0702305287,
-0.0205168836,
0.0541461632,
-0.0494561307,
0.0001561258,
-0.0597103834,
-0.0154269086,
-0.0158380177,
0.0436084978,
-0.0346495472,
-0.0277144928,
-0.0686910972,
-0.0192337222,
-0.0036285012,
0.0280327275,
0.0157003012,
0.0277723894,
0.0183955207,
-0.0334106311,
-0.0547013991,
-0.032982517,
-0.0206519607,
0.0433841571,
0.0097146416,
-0.0267801415,
0.0188586712,
-0.0357658975,
-0.0145660657,
0.006382836,
0.006268878,
-0.037788175,
-0.0008075623,
0.080172427,
-0.0243718475,
-0.0343850218,
-0.0069890372,
-0.0121268984,
-0.0205320828,
-0.0450497419,
-0.0120550673,
-0.0595769547,
0.0520823151,
0.0313939564,
0.0230625086,
-0.0355147012,
0.0482033901,
-0.0039907554,
-0.0475148894,
0.0885109827,
0.0251503214,
0.0342460461,
0.026815895,
-0.0178546589,
-0.0296602268,
0.0615623109,
-0.0013933007,
0.0374305099,
0.0421567522,
0.0115972236,
-0.0099614756,
0.0605591461,
-0.000142255,
0.0870591626,
-0.0673127398,
-0.0056468844,
0.0488050506,
0.0377901606,
0.0176592655,
0.0807806104,
0.0140628414,
0.0491979383,
0.0925618634,
0.0319430567,
-0.0212547705,
0.0358817317,
0.0473672524,
0.00873404,
-0.0170754343,
0.009096493,
-0.0569965877,
0.0172167253,
0.0107321441,
-0.0050172135,
0.0730183348,
0.040018674,
-0.0059594363,
-0.0133721661,
0.0112915076,
-0.003352711,
0.0108685903,
0.0327430479,
0.0432837345,
0.0296248477,
-0.0461493731,
0.0360798165,
0.0118658403,
-0.0251865927,
0.0297325272,
-0.0283661056,
-0.0184810031,
0.0765779316,
0.0520788841,
0.0114127891,
-0.0152095323,
-0.0289646592,
0.0512585826,
0.0739321262,
0.0693589821,
0.0100201825,
0.005816652,
-0.0300916787,
-0.0286818724,
0.0355686918,
0.0040210313,
0.0283890385,
0.0210342575,
0.0344015919,
0.0287621822,
-0.035936445,
-0.0740914568,
0.0208496526,
-0.0429861844,
-0.0443674959,
0.0336647369,
0.0202335492,
-0.0042869151,
0.0140361553,
-0.0259261429,
-0.0084866369,
0.0035580788,
-0.0568142794,
-0.0186570771,
-0.0289901067,
-0.0301713552,
-0.0241100006,
0.0260638036,
0.0051440033,
-0.0056128791,
-0.0418571085,
-0.0420340635,
-0.0436503068,
-0.0272105038,
-0.008443079,
0.0384132415,
-0.0223842282,
0.0399523526,
0.0198272299,
0.004972259,
-0.0464384146,
0.027259171,
-0.007455321,
0.0037098662,
0.0619902126,
0.0005255292,
-0.0030193147,
-0.022286173,
-0.0292100813,
0.0361388139,
0.0260300394,
0.0240741465,
0.0398859009,
0.0390721597,
0.0118577667,
-0.0363674499,
-0.0393739343,
0.0114179971,
-0.0197758079,
0.0090490179,
0.024393443,
0.0534100197,
-0.012680443,
0.0004837542,
-0.0196648743,
-0.0074782004,
0.0176393203,
0.0285395477,
0.0063463128,
-0.0137004377,
-0.0058124042,
-0.0144679984,
0.0179606508,
0.0389134772,
0.0185662434,
0.0134661701,
-0.0476605669,
-0.0421228893,
0.0601761863,
-0.0224098861,
0.0121520432,
-0.0026829401,
-0.0642757863,
-0.0054907505,
-0.0487815365,
0.0723443478,
0.0475051068,
-0.0018633223,
-0.0319155268,
0.0512101613,
-0.0093185166,
-0.0665016323,
-0.0014184804,
-0.027504677,
-0.081945546,
-0.0178449135,
-0.0257014986,
0.0257049482,
0.0184009187,
0.0227658562,
-0.0029612186,
-0.0617622584,
-0.025433667,
-0.0223176125,
-0.0104317013,
-0.0337811783,
0.0502242744,
-0.0084387772,
0.0838628039,
-0.0285766087,
-0.0609566681,
0.0692743659,
-0.0448265821,
-0.0078508081,
-0.014167876,
-0.0105679426,
-0.0241477322,
0.0518324524,
-0.0467645749,
0.0273825452,
-0.0178841427,
-0.0001683967,
-0.0525757149,
-0.0046149967,
0.012155503,
-0.0341480561,
0.0528183207,
-0.0732546598,
0.0141161531,
-0.0147284186,
-0.0344647914,
-0.0562958345,
-0.0183817726,
-0.0337252729,
-0.0231815986,
0.0167277716,
-0.0487447716,
0.0063401251,
-0.0031862413,
0.0446113497,
0.0672330558,
-0.0065378183,
0.0050406447,
-0.0199704748,
-0.0098217195,
0.0119177476,
0.0138795106,
-0.0090329628,
-0.0532422662,
0.0404673293,
-0.0142197767,
0.0026595213,
-0.0229554381,
-0.002975441,
-0.0071461904,
0.0532584675,
0.0132960379,
-0.0202050433,
-0.0203683209,
0.0448424444,
-0.0420326032,
-0.0126538165,
0.0964212567,
0.0185003448,
-0.0820849463,
-0.0281773321,
-0.0239496678,
0.0018284268,
0.031822864,
0.0544618852,
-0.1200877354,
-0.0398483686,
0.0051334016,
0.0406452119,
0.0352794155,
0.0014979735,
-0.0370405614,
-0.1201545224,
0.0220113788,
0.0385261811,
0.0066449018,
-0.0569518805,
-0.0177842807,
-0.0021105818,
-0.0146297514,
-0.0048564943,
-0.0280167591,
0.0195272658,
-0.0314485766,
-0.0034533376,
0.0767393708,
-0.0610345379,
0.0090413904,
-0.0527467281,
0.0385442376,
0.0970935524,
0.0297401845,
0.0015571535,
-0.0181148127,
0.0086657843,
-0.0132548362,
-0.0028977913,
-0.0082913516,
-0.0078201685,
0.0202342067,
-0.0472287424,
0.0243531913,
0.0252586193,
-0.0271254834,
0.0169941951,
0.0292019341,
0.0898787081,
-0.0133667346,
0.0111964904,
0.0220908727,
-0.0313558877,
0.0590591058,
0.0772750005,
0.026666401,
-0.0483513176,
0.0137694078,
-0.0137060815,
-0.0457374565,
-0.0334501378,
0.0069093909,
-0.0074791042,
-0.0681789666,
-0.0162952784,
-0.1034054011,
0.0085478844,
0.0389866717,
0.0263657644,
0.0510637686,
0.0386453606,
-0.0107989796,
0.0109571852,
0.0227653664,
0.0283386633,
-0.0447418354,
0.0121235074,
-0.0949846506,
-0.0292475559,
0.0242450442,
-0.0627274588,
0.0110951737,
0.0302915145,
-0.0594877563,
-0.0824893788,
-0.0026330261,
0.0413829871,
0.0193394907,
0.0302972849,
-0.0298556853,
-0.0516291037,
0.0406508856,
0.0392917693,
-0.0011965876,
-0.011052073,
0.0188442525,
0.0388681851,
-0.0150803793,
0.0690948889,
-0.020766044,
0.0068583633,
0.0210925415,
0.0510674529,
-0.0157036502,
-0.0978680924,
0.018194193,
0.016555354,
0.0350486562,
-0.0496013016,
-0.0134284487,
-0.0395652652,
0.0088652279,
0.0137154739,
-0.0415331498,
-0.0497867838,
0.0061180936,
0.0587514155,
-0.0316871107,
0.0055219629,
0.0030843334,
-0.014687214,
-0.0109867072,
-0.0091380458,
0.0105782906,
-0.0318458602,
0.0033068182,
0.0716730952,
0.0306125395,
-0.0086639216,
0.0481598005,
0.0037874999,
0.0161409415,
-0.042741511,
0.0575254485,
0.0135449953,
-0.0023013561,
-0.0196270049,
0.0110002942,
-0.0338369943,
-0.0707921311,
0.0411228985,
0.0562397018,
0.0897411928,
-0.0016509077,
0.0785947442,
-0.0232864544,
-0.0270505976,
-0.0228397809,
0.0379520431,
0.0335830003,
0.0066982084,
-0.0027619232,
-0.010631999,
0.0014131214,
0.0531962477,
0.0339260586,
-0.0212971941,
0.0145968636,
0.0104504628,
0.0037613271,
-0.008453547,
-0.006491418,
0.0115980003,
-0.0469357595,
-0.0267230254,
0.0182093084,
-0.0394761413,
-0.0551348552,
-0.0068425052,
-0.0114463391,
-0.0238717105,
-0.0358913206,
-0.0061746361,
0.0662809908,
-0.0198485926,
0.0228382442,
-0.0557692759,
0.0145036997,
0.0085390043,
-0.0528005846,
-0.0365316831,
-6.539845188e-33,
-0.0020776726,
-0.0282585435,
0.018107133,
-0.0625855327,
-0.0138738928,
-0.0064733415,
-0.0466906093,
-0.0185307022,
-0.0094516259,
0.0185448825,
-0.053004887,
-0.0029273829,
0.0266345069,
-0.0016721799,
0.0266825296,
0.0025676922,
0.0643155128,
0.003125173,
-0.025227109,
0.0385612138,
0.0582730584,
0.0238234643,
0.0336525552,
-0.0315952189,
0.0530061275,
-0.019229237,
0.0042380774,
0.0243813228,
0.0170293506,
0.0059743212,
-0.0145310434,
-0.0087112291,
-0.0065737236,
-0.0319378003,
-0.0354777761,
0.0214214008,
-0.0644401088,
-0.0041463673,
0.0344960466,
-0.004797468,
0.0363973342,
-0.0519444644,
0.0006092729,
-0.0441972837,
0.0050798063,
0.0176875852,
-0.0141269034,
-0.0432635061,
-0.0488968156,
-0.010900029,
-0.046892073,
0.027659988,
0.0304328091,
-0.0564912967,
0.0327066071,
0.0440646298,
-0.0166241415,
-0.0126964487,
-0.0163470283,
0.0293040667,
0.0060789711,
0.0426645949,
0.0780235007,
0.0250036009,
-0.0123476479,
0.0046483111,
0.0010658018,
0.0008787462,
0.0279314853,
-0.0137187643,
-0.0076433443,
0.0122935493,
0.0146034528,
0.0693738535,
0.0312254783,
-0.0333954617,
-0.0173019711,
0.0197234228,
-0.0042319936,
-0.0212475415,
0.0398317799,
-0.0061664246,
-0.0231636818,
-0.0176473614,
-0.0511088744,
-0.0196137317,
-0.0370102711,
-0.0153230354,
0.0335051455,
0.0261697955,
-0.0505723283,
-0.0382146016,
0.0905725583,
-0.0145507697,
-0.0026091961,
0.0088621685,
-0.0000846398,
-0.0048432816,
-0.0259581469,
0.0280554444,
-0.0299526267,
-0.0489708483,
-0.0081034889,
-0.0103369225,
-0.0175284371,
-0.0039673662,
0.0050435639,
0.0175295491,
-0.0526493676,
0.0062300782,
-0.054527849,
0.0119186677,
-0.0334530175,
0.0561719313,
0.034195818,
-0.0135464426,
-0.0026681826,
0.0291625783,
0.027726246,
-0.0319323912,
-0.0037021674,
-0.0012122308,
-0.0054579391,
0.0454281643,
-0.0648729652,
0.0290432628,
-0.0590983778,
0.017665403,
0.0346289463,
-0.0249874834,
-0.022199532,
-0.0065685161,
2.903e-7,
0.015834799,
0.0520288013,
-0.032000076,
0.0557889268,
-0.0197796151,
0.0117061231,
-0.0368628241,
0.0092415074,
0.0127317356,
0.0148642436,
0.0323661901,
0.0309590176,
0.0892091468,
0.0104608396,
-0.1052404568,
-0.037854176,
-0.0000115823,
0.0349356122,
-0.0628949255,
-0.0344708189,
0.0417509861,
0.0816220194,
0.007220278,
-0.0007002357,
-0.0065851104,
-0.0528534502,
0.0626287013,
-0.0247775447,
-0.0107299248,
-0.0035419948,
0.023637861,
0.0263030455,
-0.0546176098,
-0.0129683232,
-0.0289552063,
0.0218154732,
0.0108505571,
0.1064278036,
0.0464759693,
0.0115760081,
-0.0071356646,
-0.0302971732,
-0.0095469104,
-0.03318692,
0.0432919674,
-0.0445461534,
0.0350479223,
-0.0220072176,
0.0299846753,
-0.0026765333,
0.0161385182,
-0.0585683994,
-0.0482972227,
0.0230558459,
0.0435992852,
0.0091310991,
-0.0244016759,
-0.0381878279,
-0.0059981276,
-0.0235063322,
-0.0078108916,
-0.0503112189,
-0.0295831412,
0.0110760247,
-0.0334647559,
-0.0013755866,
0.0137850866,
2.715450955e-34,
0.0206419043,
-0.0264713652,
-0.000146729,
-0.0008174127,
0.0430936292,
-0.0134578394,
-0.0089314543,
0.0116004767,
0.005667618,
-0.0595306121,
-0.0224452931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07845v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07845v3 | NL2CMD: An Updated Workflow for Natural Language to Bash Commands Translation | 2023-02-15T18:31:36 | 2023-06-18T16:27:16 | Quchen Fu, Zhongwei Teng, Marco Georgaklis, Jules White, Douglas C. Schmidt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PF | Translating natural language into Bash Commands is an emerging research field
that has gained attention in recent years. Most efforts have focused on
producing more accurate translation models. To the best of our knowledge, only
two datasets are available, with one based on the other. Both datasets involve
scraping through known data sources (through platforms like stack overflow,
crowdsourcing, etc.) and hiring experts to validate and correct either the
English text or Bash Commands. This paper provides two contributions to
research on synthesizing Bash Commands from scratch. First, we describe a
state-of-the-art translation model used to generate Bash Commands from the
corresponding English text. Second, we introduce a new NL2CMD dataset that is
automatically generated, involves minimal human intervention, and is over six
times larger than prior datasets. Since the generation pipeline does not rely
on existing Bash Commands, the distribution and types of commands can be custom
adjusted. We evaluate the performance of ChatGPT on this task and discuss the
potential of using it as a data generator. Our empirical results show how the
scale and diversity of our dataset can offer unique opportunities for semantic
parsing researchers. | [
0.0373018458,
0.0507971384,
-0.0232140254,
0.0248371623,
-0.0437880568,
-0.0001798032,
-0.0139116812,
-0.0121907247,
0.0005944149,
-0.0008425038,
-0.0151091861,
0.0275786147,
0.0067972066,
0.0185798183,
0.0374362096,
-0.0310946144,
0.0440354943,
-0.0102866264,
-0.0521493815,
0.0230717584,
0.0121727642,
0.0707318634,
-0.0108327912,
0.0661450624,
-0.0278144218,
0.0167863984,
-0.0050444063,
0.0399277695,
0.0228969213,
-0.013216489,
0.033758726,
0.0192786548,
-0.0033340368,
0.032331828,
0.0000018293,
-0.0552261434,
0.0131644774,
-0.0246777032,
-0.0237767808,
-0.0267966781,
0.0647627562,
-0.029071793,
-0.0192829482,
0.0036257349,
-0.0489445217,
-0.0193610489,
0.0357016027,
0.0060957386,
0.0943689048,
0.0841097236,
-0.0124440072,
-0.0399591513,
-0.0332018435,
-0.0034251362,
0.0317051262,
0.0147647439,
-0.0153439408,
0.0091754533,
-0.0037975267,
0.0235426854,
0.0236351993,
0.0293131303,
0.0109996581,
-0.0377368666,
0.0109162172,
0.0215770844,
-0.0314345695,
-0.0382190049,
-0.0162917096,
0.0541431308,
-0.0161113311,
-0.0306926891,
0.0166948214,
0.0015422937,
0.0099627776,
-0.0378784761,
-0.0380551703,
0.0391187705,
-0.0275222193,
-0.0022158688,
-0.0055516507,
0.0167950001,
0.0041605402,
-0.021268541,
0.0064101173,
0.0838566348,
0.0069425041,
0.0117403073,
0.021266887,
-0.013627206,
-0.0350604504,
-0.0507490523,
0.0405130982,
-0.0057387315,
-0.0349499695,
0.0172269139,
-0.079549253,
-0.0237978362,
0.0386560112,
-0.0193264727,
0.0073041739,
0.0403631292,
0.0012434206,
0.0561774522,
-0.0258467793,
0.0119349407,
0.0184855908,
0.0463261493,
-0.0406934507,
-0.0142532624,
-0.0908081383,
-0.0049936804,
-0.0627981573,
0.0168340709,
-0.0222832579,
0.0113883456,
-0.030960165,
0.0040723719,
0.008476261,
0.0474901274,
0.0523515753,
0.0040693409,
-0.0412336141,
0.014137106,
0.0137860905,
0.0009253782,
-0.0335065015,
-0.004104686,
0.0075816992,
-0.0430752896,
-0.0061826613,
0.022562068,
-0.0239422005,
-0.0332557894,
0.0009585358,
0.1111851558,
-0.0032969618,
0.0295442939,
-0.0300373975,
-0.0466258526,
-0.0118856048,
0.0197894406,
-0.0068074372,
-0.0934335217,
0.0844182447,
-0.0057541048,
0.0035264546,
-0.0408941433,
-0.0032771851,
0.0145409815,
-0.0207254626,
0.0708838478,
-0.0262981523,
-0.0040403795,
0.031452734,
-0.0029901285,
-0.0374376476,
0.0269594993,
0.0267908797,
0.033608567,
0.0310662296,
-0.0141472677,
-0.0145119494,
0.0517958291,
-0.0006056335,
-0.0159341469,
-0.0054179872,
0.0419404395,
0.0094874203,
0.0409593396,
0.060279157,
0.0588652007,
-0.0035636399,
0.0199978109,
0.0020115331,
0.0396931246,
-0.0201530587,
0.0103731118,
0.1031985879,
0.0306639485,
-0.0099266414,
-0.0513105951,
-0.0511813983,
-0.0129720829,
-0.0186517481,
-0.0172657985,
-0.0594943538,
0.0212338846,
0.0142875481,
-0.0143240523,
0.0253576916,
0.0008950611,
0.0140163777,
-0.0611753054,
-0.0283992942,
0.030080406,
-0.0008895522,
0.039812129,
-0.0060903495,
-0.0686540455,
0.0264856182,
-0.0390230715,
-0.0096829478,
0.0634908378,
0.0773796961,
-0.0073609431,
-0.0178561322,
-0.0355701894,
0.0563442819,
0.0233685877,
0.0266107526,
-0.019115651,
-0.0073695774,
-0.0309924297,
0.0045122416,
-0.0167626385,
0.003356999,
-0.0008167867,
0.0513101071,
-0.0158019345,
0.0362739563,
-0.0415275581,
-0.0504119396,
0.0504587851,
0.0315373503,
-0.0134294387,
0.0156937819,
0.0056843725,
-0.000674496,
0.0007827154,
-0.0183045585,
0.0146701029,
-0.006818776,
-0.0059733628,
-0.0347922109,
0.0287188664,
-0.0276948791,
-0.0333925597,
0.0296573397,
-0.0676876977,
-0.0232553016,
0.0067504337,
-0.0589277968,
-0.0258187857,
-0.0164599735,
-0.0631844699,
0.0088676,
0.0155971944,
-0.0020816529,
0.0212978907,
0.011386307,
-0.0249214135,
0.030772116,
0.0041614915,
-0.008151087,
-0.0096380571,
-0.0070257108,
-0.0126881879,
-0.0103646545,
-0.0019178524,
-0.0082291244,
-0.0522123352,
0.0016413485,
0.0334214978,
0.094024621,
-0.0582423881,
-0.0296843555,
-0.0415758826,
0.0125058535,
-0.0230688136,
0.0108817639,
0.0831207931,
0.0183926187,
-0.018249372,
-0.0173511319,
-0.0141429389,
-0.0461889468,
0.0168898646,
-0.0073325615,
0.0427099988,
-0.0073903347,
-0.046703577,
-0.033483956,
0.0055178003,
-0.0383767337,
-0.0094044674,
0.0023735608,
-0.0387431718,
-0.0255614724,
0.0460110717,
-0.003204318,
-0.0102456901,
0.0117969681,
-0.0452503264,
0.0223129168,
-0.0452903993,
0.0202571098,
0.0581161864,
-0.0120420204,
0.0184935965,
0.0163199436,
-0.0271682814,
-0.0472544059,
-0.0122534065,
0.0231570397,
-0.0482908003,
-0.0148204025,
-0.0613393039,
0.0396241732,
0.0471412763,
0.0521862097,
0.0513230413,
-0.0461444519,
0.0069831191,
-0.0034319349,
-0.0478978306,
-0.0450619534,
-0.0114920791,
-0.0134033067,
0.0397506393,
-0.0309391897,
-0.0134544931,
0.0555059873,
-0.0358662382,
-0.0326281413,
-0.0556830242,
-0.0240759589,
-0.0201284979,
0.0593490079,
0.0341398716,
0.025571784,
-0.0074919267,
-0.0570675097,
0.0224971268,
0.011429457,
0.016276136,
0.0074517271,
0.0117582548,
-0.0753179863,
-0.0154174762,
-0.0056668799,
-0.0033036801,
-0.0274098814,
-0.0637561753,
-0.0397127755,
-0.0268237796,
0.0343603864,
-0.0398119949,
0.0316535942,
-0.0459293984,
0.0120130545,
0.037648797,
0.0208192114,
-0.0309701245,
-0.036728438,
-0.0196071751,
0.0208245795,
-0.0085649285,
-0.0595048778,
0.0505692177,
0.0050234217,
0.0402286537,
0.0279787146,
-0.0019282383,
-0.0453564413,
-0.0026171578,
0.0025222253,
-0.0090362001,
-0.0002004593,
0.0272487029,
0.051891651,
-0.0132811852,
-0.0146526247,
0.0930277333,
0.0323752463,
0.0059998832,
0.0212559812,
-0.0104371039,
0.0353040621,
0.0252809748,
0.0240299776,
-0.0714718848,
-0.0568854697,
0.0106361313,
0.0477998406,
0.0104914065,
-0.024225371,
-0.029293377,
-0.1159073114,
0.0387878641,
0.0076584956,
-0.0500621721,
-0.0277577508,
-0.0305559672,
-0.0039469693,
-0.0442429036,
-0.0236616377,
-0.003037394,
0.0017394739,
0.0038859979,
0.0119143967,
-0.0167671423,
-0.0299247727,
0.0620493889,
-0.0277986713,
0.0274715386,
0.0966718793,
0.000849896,
0.0110671334,
0.0154226804,
0.0464264452,
0.0248866286,
-0.0004951773,
0.0010742833,
0.0447856747,
0.0093270503,
-0.0180327315,
-0.0273114294,
0.0902817398,
-0.0463450365,
-0.001493605,
0.0325959325,
0.0619826615,
-0.0407682993,
0.0117056742,
-0.0044078832,
0.020707462,
0.0218539014,
0.0615658686,
0.0494014136,
-0.014117226,
-0.0040665157,
-0.0586146936,
-0.0308978409,
-0.090601407,
-0.0456844307,
0.0234780461,
0.0053539341,
-0.0271156766,
-0.0691940337,
-0.0532811247,
0.0887219608,
0.0227309819,
0.0162245668,
-0.0612086467,
0.024858119,
-0.000096011,
-0.0065911217,
0.0237771384,
-0.0441394188,
0.0543057472,
-0.0284032244,
-0.023687873,
0.0163838044,
0.0086119622,
-0.012851282,
0.0223147329,
-0.0866345391,
-0.0605466031,
0.0378736071,
0.076130487,
0.0231512915,
0.0236146767,
-0.0696105063,
-0.0170272179,
0.0002900861,
0.0972449854,
-0.0811515152,
-0.027605379,
0.0365705155,
0.083632201,
-0.0010578088,
0.0316832289,
-0.0206678677,
-0.002432755,
-0.0341958404,
0.0265535731,
-0.0353116691,
-0.0167492684,
0.0741620213,
0.0397102609,
0.0292639714,
-0.0287043341,
0.0339293182,
0.0145883579,
-0.0124049447,
-0.0402810313,
-0.0448473729,
-0.0108603351,
0.017981546,
0.0222640429,
-0.0237201918,
0.0354661606,
-0.0236916635,
-0.062297564,
0.0050848089,
-0.0201421753,
0.000274379,
0.048285801,
0.0302644391,
0.0364646427,
0.018432308,
-0.0301704779,
0.0071299979,
-0.0311648995,
0.0286381394,
-0.0355978683,
0.0157014262,
0.0238314625,
-0.0255938452,
-0.045681946,
0.0595116541,
-0.0473015383,
-0.0441033505,
0.0175741259,
0.0406316854,
0.0642921329,
-0.0251488835,
0.0773375183,
-0.0612411164,
-0.0021061527,
0.0030181631,
0.0473283269,
0.0086202091,
-0.0288980436,
0.0255709607,
0.0141423848,
-0.019373348,
-0.0874483809,
0.0343394466,
-0.0583762191,
0.0258938223,
0.0282083191,
-0.0214371234,
-0.0454067215,
-0.0209791437,
-0.0062837005,
-0.0193439722,
-0.0167998169,
-0.0340904705,
-0.008019275,
-0.0399155542,
-0.0584019795,
0.0570482165,
0.026985161,
-0.001980654,
0.0726016834,
0.0558516718,
-0.0100339334,
0.0131764272,
-0.0202517062,
0.0469387248,
-0.0258540157,
-0.0787644535,
-0.0688535199,
-5.71684192e-33,
-0.0325451121,
-0.0054377303,
0.002832969,
0.0220982395,
0.0171867739,
-0.0529256761,
-0.064478986,
0.0112765096,
0.0059646475,
0.012337028,
-0.0321320333,
-0.0130589493,
0.0338355042,
0.0119758844,
0.0349200368,
-0.0282785539,
0.0301189553,
0.0005959611,
-0.0624490306,
0.0224527884,
0.0563517176,
0.0036180466,
0.0552091487,
-0.0553569831,
0.0203968752,
0.0247762259,
-0.0440227278,
0.0276709963,
0.0135047408,
0.0309593175,
0.0219367556,
0.0437960625,
0.0076856026,
-0.0342507288,
-0.0157973263,
0.026369663,
-0.0671280995,
0.0085186874,
0.0303400159,
0.0160693415,
-0.0328575373,
-0.0309799388,
0.0073399353,
-0.047555808,
0.0128778266,
0.0439737253,
0.0189772416,
-0.0078141382,
0.0219932608,
0.0030058359,
-0.0194907524,
-0.0032141341,
-0.047475569,
-0.014564787,
-0.0262204576,
0.0323010795,
0.0277549159,
0.039488554,
-0.0550387762,
0.0219220817,
-0.0145236356,
0.0454403497,
0.069898814,
-0.0414735749,
0.0077957837,
0.039364215,
-0.0107582547,
-0.0293924883,
-0.0221373495,
0.1025024354,
-0.0162874702,
0.0427013636,
0.0153748579,
0.0542696975,
0.0248211902,
-0.0379701667,
0.0151716648,
0.0242087971,
0.0162608568,
0.0772424117,
-0.0386649407,
0.0195205174,
-0.0346134268,
-0.0109129967,
-0.0009749237,
-0.0298777819,
-0.0027460537,
-0.0291118659,
0.0146905482,
-0.0262465235,
-0.028555749,
-0.0524512716,
0.0253518056,
0.0032345755,
-0.000569438,
-0.0133577306,
-0.0427985005,
0.0372829586,
-0.0236262754,
0.0234997869,
0.0229621641,
-0.0328038633,
0.0500023104,
0.0201211255,
0.0680308118,
0.0172135662,
0.0499475151,
0.017142728,
-0.0378789008,
0.0347411036,
-0.0481489599,
0.0466374271,
-0.0618992783,
-0.0256254673,
-0.0065957028,
0.0176855996,
-0.0170370601,
0.005269574,
0.0353611223,
-0.0441950634,
-0.0304924827,
-0.0363587849,
0.016439354,
-0.0124412309,
-0.0495659597,
0.0316456743,
-0.0370447636,
0.0069828024,
0.0563297942,
-0.0159176011,
-0.016954856,
-0.0186700597,
2.583e-7,
0.0477752909,
0.000321958,
0.0187955238,
0.054084897,
-0.0029317683,
0.0358963981,
-0.0074676196,
0.0456939675,
-0.0371352732,
-0.0331793763,
-0.0316105187,
-0.0101331742,
0.0332418494,
0.0257094689,
-0.0689917654,
-0.0368001871,
-0.0609914772,
0.0091845896,
-0.0628513619,
0.0147575103,
0.0838559642,
0.0773733854,
0.0293121692,
-0.0218420811,
-0.0377984755,
-0.0329691954,
-0.0325958617,
-0.0043740943,
0.0140736392,
0.0286022946,
0.0515566282,
-0.0058817035,
0.0106195956,
0.0106173381,
0.000926697,
-0.044765044,
0.0077437446,
0.0466245487,
0.0167381428,
0.0287607182,
-0.0395325981,
-0.0587006956,
0.0250919815,
-0.0623857342,
0.0509390645,
-0.0601218417,
0.0240537878,
-0.0037941663,
0.001482276,
0.0318620615,
-0.0254394505,
-0.0410257094,
-0.047068812,
-0.0182698052,
0.0449692905,
-0.0001921559,
-0.035441488,
-0.045071438,
-0.0475344472,
0.0042090924,
-0.0232467148,
-0.0326898098,
0.0033893911,
0.0710417405,
0.026468128,
-0.0206070673,
0.0049565746,
2.194220918e-34,
0.00899396,
0.0322721787,
0.0524820797,
-0.0343155563,
0.0521808416,
-0.0004963721,
-0.0423200242,
0.0307140611,
-0.0207421966,
-0.0372992568,
-0.0475757681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07842v1 | Augmented Language Models: a Survey | 2023-02-15T18:25:52 | 2023-02-15T18:25:52 | Grégoire Mialon, Roberto Dessì, Maria Lomeli, Christoforos Nalmpantis, Ram Pasunuru, Roberta Raileanu, Baptiste Rozière, Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Asli Celikyilmaz, Edouard Grave, Yann LeCun, Thomas Scialom | cs.CL | cs.CL | This survey reviews works in which language models (LMs) are augmented with
reasoning skills and the ability to use tools. The former is defined as
decomposing a potentially complex task into simpler subtasks while the latter
consists in calling external modules such as a code interpreter. LMs can
leverage these augmentations separately or in combination via heuristics, or
learn to do so from demonstrations. While adhering to a standard missing tokens
prediction objective, such augmented LMs can use various, possibly
non-parametric external modules to expand their context processing ability,
thus departing from the pure language modeling paradigm. We therefore refer to
them as Augmented Language Models (ALMs). The missing token objective allows
ALMs to learn to reason, use tools, and even act, while still performing
standard natural language tasks and even outperforming most regular LMs on
several benchmarks. In this work, after reviewing current advance in ALMs, we
conclude that this new research direction has the potential to address common
limitations of traditional LMs such as interpretability, consistency, and
scalability issues. | [
0.0549465418,
0.0454127416,
-0.0345050916,
0.029049173,
-0.0164589565,
0.0124104703,
0.0046987482,
-0.0306874234,
0.0282663312,
-0.0298921205,
-0.0151713351,
0.0125760511,
-0.0168209616,
0.0401475579,
0.0610396005,
-0.0378039964,
0.0658912137,
-0.0235744677,
0.0107328575,
0.0173691697,
0.0009331231,
0.0469346829,
-0.0050302031,
0.0599691086,
-0.0087846369,
0.0126923965,
-0.0253029577,
0.0086710369,
0.0044161906,
-0.0065066568,
-0.0047385613,
0.0042429934,
0.0341083966,
0.0322236046,
0.0000020673,
-0.066970095,
-0.0138221355,
-0.0167122204,
-0.0421861224,
-0.0115933036,
0.0139155686,
-0.0054445388,
0.0088853408,
0.0448517017,
-0.059967652,
-0.0398177467,
0.0291254669,
-0.0165658128,
0.040987581,
0.0758588612,
0.0013471722,
0.0152224842,
0.0214183219,
-0.0367653854,
0.0239685923,
-0.0248666946,
0.0114014586,
-0.0004053119,
0.0679025576,
0.0137309162,
-0.0045449473,
0.0364126004,
0.0605125614,
-0.0033136618,
0.0037454863,
0.0264403969,
-0.0469181165,
0.0134862484,
-0.0146766677,
0.0117284097,
-0.0192236826,
-0.0585031956,
0.0049980166,
0.0052935928,
0.0221795775,
-0.0358024091,
-0.0642919913,
0.0030966648,
0.0371447876,
0.0161393452,
0.0497786552,
-0.0408621132,
0.0542494394,
0.0413224287,
-0.0336954296,
0.0804717094,
-0.0015916815,
-0.0336980447,
-0.0622383468,
0.0018117941,
-0.0479748696,
-0.0744448602,
0.0150046591,
0.0785043612,
-0.0402397066,
0.0711178035,
-0.0487833768,
-0.0277057234,
0.023894988,
-0.0080224639,
0.0073300395,
0.0727998689,
-0.0288592856,
0.0629633889,
-0.0689755455,
0.0584451668,
0.0197052099,
0.0497898422,
-0.0333943777,
-0.0269304644,
-0.0489848964,
-0.0445944443,
-0.036673326,
0.0489042848,
-0.0365421996,
-0.0077293231,
-0.0084604537,
0.0642124787,
0.0143945934,
0.0267183948,
0.0052423673,
-0.0111612771,
-0.0268992279,
-0.021589702,
-0.0496551506,
0.0129284626,
-0.0268829539,
0.0414635278,
0.0160391685,
-0.0778791159,
-0.019992495,
0.0127018737,
0.0092630731,
-0.028033128,
0.0240546558,
0.0885791183,
0.012985264,
-0.0413437225,
-0.0358065106,
-0.0059242635,
-0.0154108182,
-0.0499603935,
-0.020455189,
-0.0836467072,
0.0233282801,
0.0146099525,
-0.0234445333,
-0.0177567191,
0.0096169524,
0.0251225885,
-0.0076191179,
0.0727303103,
-0.0338855088,
0.01495534,
0.024814792,
0.004220556,
-0.0177456252,
0.0578171089,
0.0261954889,
0.0134440707,
0.0139059117,
0.008234839,
0.0112948613,
0.0302208308,
0.0175489951,
-0.0179136526,
-0.034137249,
0.0124417804,
-0.0102506187,
0.0053658648,
-0.0096955132,
0.0353512466,
-0.0100509189,
0.0046117483,
0.0132750552,
0.0400268696,
0.0055092373,
-0.0008515696,
0.0850389004,
-0.030224869,
0.0060113557,
-0.0117534297,
-0.0746266767,
0.0142557668,
-0.0435637422,
0.0109764151,
0.0005498005,
0.0111881923,
-0.0164287537,
-0.0757868141,
-0.0057323049,
-0.0286659431,
0.0435322411,
0.0244945101,
0.063081488,
0.0237659104,
-0.0398977213,
0.0075478195,
0.0128288893,
-0.0434684381,
0.0304880012,
-0.0810754672,
0.0166657977,
0.0721935108,
0.0739501864,
-0.0413793065,
-0.0578928217,
0.0000166944,
0.0074132942,
0.0255953111,
0.0252208728,
0.0053612296,
0.0154065099,
-0.0381322727,
-0.0083466107,
-0.0177688487,
0.0160291959,
0.0103284568,
0.0294744056,
0.0112451389,
0.0201054029,
-0.0557494201,
-0.0217951555,
0.0354531296,
-0.0430733301,
-0.0094163744,
-0.0132484725,
0.0109549612,
0.0172437169,
0.0255757254,
0.0340605713,
0.0267441757,
0.052468285,
-0.0324654765,
-0.033011172,
0.0336971134,
-0.0477230512,
-0.0520351343,
0.0448331349,
0.0141944746,
0.0027591069,
0.0338034444,
-0.0163557399,
-0.0693143234,
0.0655385926,
-0.0344939195,
0.0855451971,
-0.0607336462,
0.0422868244,
0.0083594276,
-0.0083724884,
-0.0071035447,
0.0682207868,
-0.0138588892,
0.0197169203,
-0.0093724951,
0.0266876854,
-0.0096098557,
-0.0453388467,
-0.0277635735,
-0.0165525191,
-0.0219588242,
0.0269662533,
0.0070285709,
-0.0045873802,
-0.0250147302,
-0.0236661974,
-0.1074703187,
0.0172352325,
-0.0205325726,
-0.0038347058,
0.0022192027,
0.0282746647,
-0.0105036423,
-0.0367464721,
0.0038471024,
-0.0320863426,
0.0186970551,
0.0028524001,
0.0082474612,
0.0377417319,
-0.0292240158,
-0.0270746239,
-0.0112057207,
-0.0415144563,
0.0210068431,
-0.0184774213,
-0.0063479762,
-0.0299974717,
-0.0037306109,
-0.0463519543,
0.0349279121,
-0.0155175012,
-0.0167538654,
0.0167900454,
-0.0403451622,
0.0093786372,
0.0459024496,
-0.0197619013,
0.0205893368,
0.0253088214,
0.0022946214,
-0.0756373554,
0.0337531306,
-0.0014913708,
-0.0103217475,
-0.0082556522,
-0.016668953,
-0.0040436825,
0.0636945292,
-0.0055695092,
-0.0125330621,
-0.0572052859,
0.029025102,
0.0018541397,
-0.0274527445,
-0.0162371416,
-0.0570549816,
-0.0256137215,
0.0514737628,
-0.0409819707,
-0.0657874271,
0.0983121246,
-0.0537590124,
-0.0250785146,
-0.0733009726,
-0.0354501382,
-0.0478914641,
0.0436861143,
0.022844119,
-0.0016472416,
-0.0251031406,
-0.0542520992,
-0.0191673581,
-0.0007602504,
-0.0400652923,
-0.0537234545,
0.0364699662,
-0.050071843,
0.0062988233,
0.0332705639,
-0.0175845884,
-0.0686302781,
0.024751734,
-0.0544551238,
0.0391924344,
-0.0130895488,
-0.00533034,
-0.041141171,
-0.0169546455,
0.0171268601,
0.0672728568,
0.0193016529,
-0.0046439804,
-0.0450720564,
-0.0440420844,
0.0377457142,
-0.0036836893,
-0.0109404875,
-0.0357025713,
0.0161298066,
-0.0116704395,
0.0710660219,
-0.0505898371,
-0.0314146467,
-0.0001318149,
0.0123459538,
-0.0131921321,
-0.0237283595,
0.0240609366,
0.0379878879,
-0.0948817059,
-0.0079112267,
0.1307151616,
0.0550627336,
0.0004080151,
0.0155835245,
-0.0308995042,
0.0192568824,
0.0464440286,
0.0367546417,
-0.0792519003,
-0.0380456075,
0.0166297648,
0.0379688814,
-0.0085597821,
-0.0118773365,
-0.0184784438,
-0.1094242856,
0.0026507145,
0.0071455394,
-0.0563309751,
-0.0166765787,
-0.0215972066,
0.0169748385,
-0.0025137288,
0.0106040062,
0.0096813664,
0.0188251082,
0.004052294,
0.0116979759,
-0.0095311562,
-0.0135457367,
0.002915594,
-0.0318631865,
0.0615303703,
0.0707918406,
-0.0018119975,
0.0050160242,
-0.0155215692,
0.0550331324,
0.0211879872,
0.0369467437,
-0.0368662104,
-0.0016830973,
-0.0422938466,
-0.0172823742,
-0.0019288355,
0.0409139022,
-0.0328676142,
-0.033874929,
0.0083480375,
0.1147746071,
-0.0228270385,
0.0241139326,
-0.0144550707,
-0.0158595275,
-0.024790911,
0.0704733059,
0.0315273814,
-0.0325796679,
-0.0178760588,
-0.018332988,
-0.0250537936,
-0.0484563783,
0.0204826407,
-0.0324423239,
0.0196494386,
0.0106169758,
-0.0459890962,
-0.0495816208,
0.0566824004,
0.0317510404,
0.0010411522,
0.0331838541,
-0.0241038557,
-0.0272459313,
-0.0448685512,
0.022832403,
-0.0342166647,
0.0321143679,
-0.0247452985,
0.0007057653,
0.0002568675,
-0.0704915151,
-0.0207023919,
-0.0047473377,
-0.0427653752,
-0.0677239522,
-0.010936819,
0.0526131578,
0.0271860212,
0.0684032366,
-0.0672290176,
-0.0489623062,
-0.0104611339,
0.0212205648,
-0.0517670363,
0.0278842337,
0.013825018,
0.0027822067,
0.0116800601,
0.0301463101,
-0.05509625,
0.0055104499,
-0.0048293276,
0.0554749295,
-0.0273401681,
-0.0177296549,
0.0313628428,
-0.0061658779,
0.0276962593,
0.0157894623,
-0.0085770534,
-0.024894394,
0.0295014009,
-0.0073063644,
-0.0251743235,
-0.0292384382,
-0.0034889078,
0.0057234894,
0.0088516353,
0.0191802364,
-0.0239844434,
-0.0251397323,
0.0618398637,
0.0185093693,
0.046499081,
0.0040994613,
0.017522607,
0.0147487847,
0.0106435921,
0.0092318309,
-0.0070992401,
-0.0256310981,
0.0276543908,
-0.0428095795,
0.0511280857,
0.0062182369,
-0.0067001982,
-0.0161689017,
0.0086668944,
-0.0639078319,
-0.0374230854,
0.0102747865,
0.0751093552,
0.0164433513,
-0.0206417684,
0.0192477796,
-0.0302882269,
-0.0009624036,
-0.0159656722,
0.0158364326,
0.0282785632,
-0.05763603,
0.0413486436,
0.0442617945,
-0.0276319627,
0.0097591607,
0.0407553874,
-0.030784227,
0.0614607148,
-0.0185456481,
-0.0041302666,
-0.0392600819,
-0.009691949,
0.0219044611,
0.0584412105,
-0.0394105054,
0.0282282233,
-0.0255029332,
-0.0990746021,
-0.0240537208,
0.0230902415,
-0.0150993234,
-0.0272821002,
-0.0122737661,
0.0626636147,
-0.0034876515,
-0.0197078492,
-0.0244792104,
0.013991612,
0.0140845962,
-0.0308737345,
-0.0198242012,
-6.088803231e-33,
-0.042599868,
-0.0240470134,
0.0235485118,
-0.0376375429,
0.0081165014,
0.0144891627,
-0.0580913872,
-0.0075041573,
-0.0273194946,
-0.0297352877,
0.0055776448,
0.0257532932,
0.0121044917,
0.0261866413,
0.004788578,
0.0143273016,
0.0306539293,
0.0263332948,
-0.0263355374,
-0.0033221927,
0.0318782218,
0.0166724864,
0.0378179289,
-0.0352189764,
0.0206307769,
-0.0258258209,
-0.004548125,
0.054908447,
-0.0161431376,
0.094337292,
0.0059270477,
0.0085401349,
0.0198772587,
-0.015060802,
-0.0354088806,
0.0243408978,
-0.0776406974,
-0.0095387613,
0.0768465772,
0.0044976389,
-0.0504547469,
-0.046938993,
0.0505252965,
-0.031982746,
-0.0024422116,
0.0496801771,
0.0315078311,
-0.0320388563,
0.0085360035,
0.0488822795,
-0.0387442075,
0.0242611058,
-0.0149736386,
-0.022707684,
-0.0042632562,
0.0423424728,
0.0121208448,
0.0255290046,
-0.0384348296,
0.0189147592,
-0.0119070066,
0.014336695,
0.0762280151,
0.0088976482,
-0.0213920176,
0.0336619988,
0.0352642685,
-0.0227729455,
-0.0166827776,
0.0055389516,
0.0683137253,
0.0301701017,
0.0518250167,
-0.0258403644,
0.0158809051,
0.0072701997,
-0.0179184359,
-0.0040303064,
0.0189810023,
0.060140945,
0.0440031774,
0.0535620861,
-0.0471785329,
0.0035487628,
-0.0303037725,
0.0073055951,
-0.0565438084,
-0.0591138415,
0.0520831831,
0.0349060856,
-0.0473974943,
0.0081545273,
0.024164075,
-0.0508389063,
0.0111594982,
0.0168554001,
-0.0043853433,
0.0162010528,
-0.0103732133,
0.0515171476,
-0.0552165918,
-0.0077390727,
0.0617595464,
0.0109694591,
0.006303445,
-0.0064838231,
0.043881692,
0.032637082,
-0.0573161915,
0.0091765309,
-0.0495903641,
0.0280585438,
-0.032223653,
-0.0013979822,
0.0546306185,
0.0360379145,
-0.0252474248,
0.0279210787,
0.0190579072,
-0.0424558073,
-0.0509641841,
-0.0122978911,
-0.0319588967,
0.0081156567,
-0.0567782708,
-0.0032410126,
-0.0170147289,
0.0074266871,
-0.0068719843,
-0.02456351,
0.0035491223,
0.0274875145,
2.769e-7,
0.0401048101,
0.0250167772,
0.0306458417,
-0.0171195325,
0.0079228571,
0.0059614694,
-0.0327638127,
0.0030071156,
0.0316727012,
0.0075204647,
-0.0148179047,
0.0452896804,
0.0370501429,
-0.0165711306,
-0.0598507263,
0.0325615853,
-0.042670738,
0.0043907315,
-0.0752771422,
0.032698229,
0.0474591888,
0.1115850508,
0.0283774603,
-0.0019571562,
-0.0336669199,
-0.057429228,
0.018234726,
0.0112641174,
-0.0325051211,
-0.0099485461,
-0.0125756804,
0.0861572325,
0.0080322418,
0.0187587775,
-0.0188798178,
0.0480070598,
0.0293445271,
0.0577769689,
-0.0139033003,
-0.0194234177,
0.0075685643,
0.0159477182,
-0.0045913961,
-0.0543421172,
0.096126765,
-0.0089301802,
-0.0087697757,
-0.0070915329,
0.0004260676,
0.0272499323,
-0.0360180065,
0.0068322388,
-0.0626856536,
0.0076817768,
0.0221866779,
-0.019181041,
-0.0188625213,
-0.087797232,
-0.0459774174,
-0.003867544,
-0.038747441,
-0.0322541706,
-0.0647764131,
0.0391851515,
-0.0033803543,
-0.0718435794,
-0.0037485654,
3.004156729e-34,
0.0270275809,
-0.0046274322,
0.0148308091,
0.0380029641,
0.0520114377,
-0.002498663,
-0.0312271621,
0.0596842319,
0.0459247418,
-0.069592528,
-0.026535077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07778v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07778v2 | Measuring the Instability of Fine-Tuning | 2023-02-15T16:55:15 | 2023-10-01T10:38:39 | Yupei Du, Dong Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning pre-trained language models on downstream tasks with varying
random seeds has been shown to be unstable, especially on small datasets. Many
previous studies have investigated this instability and proposed methods to
mitigate it. However, most studies only used the standard deviation of
performance scores (SD) as their measure, which is a narrow characterization of
instability. In this paper, we analyze SD and six other measures quantifying
instability at different levels of granularity. Moreover, we propose a
systematic framework to evaluate the validity of these measures. Finally, we
analyze the consistency and difference between different measures by
reassessing existing instability mitigation methods. We hope our results will
inform the development of better measurements of fine-tuning instability. | [
-0.0213699881,
0.0686052591,
-0.0364441723,
0.0143098002,
-0.0043636188,
0.0027458642,
-0.0219399426,
-0.0133216763,
-0.0556114912,
-0.0064175427,
-0.0497460477,
-0.0624235235,
0.0307868104,
0.0293644611,
0.0389517471,
-0.0454703011,
0.0777789801,
-0.0684444904,
0.0202162359,
-0.0056074825,
0.0160631519,
-0.0306553971,
0.0101574315,
0.0539735109,
0.0182388015,
-0.0141518787,
0.0169001836,
0.0032061508,
0.0226738062,
0.0128495935,
0.0097070877,
0.0845219865,
-0.0078268889,
0.0263151024,
0.0000019852,
-0.0533351637,
0.0062024542,
0.0215643328,
-0.0222398415,
0.0378530361,
0.0001323257,
0.0247516464,
-0.04224867,
0.0220293775,
-0.0241109785,
-0.0575558059,
0.0194503386,
0.0064485972,
0.0300260726,
0.0548541546,
0.0141963735,
0.0025348368,
0.0126114264,
-0.0446363948,
-0.0242681764,
-0.0428652726,
0.0038002299,
0.0114838388,
-0.0403720364,
-0.0033561194,
-0.0395547077,
-0.0157874413,
-0.0047278218,
0.0118940612,
-0.0558947809,
0.0089203874,
-0.041909039,
-0.0549195558,
-0.0066120275,
0.0534603707,
-0.0450715013,
0.0080583049,
-0.0104656368,
-0.025105454,
0.0206817612,
0.0061174231,
-0.0201831739,
0.0271084402,
0.0268509537,
0.0003770214,
0.0192311555,
-0.021404162,
0.0388516746,
-0.0219051316,
-0.0254162755,
0.0249411631,
0.0299478155,
-0.0260599889,
-0.0005315248,
-0.0029708124,
-0.0313163921,
-0.04895702,
-0.0475698076,
-0.0090882247,
-0.0591298714,
0.0259535201,
-0.0722939298,
-0.0539590642,
0.0061545456,
-0.0227672011,
0.0663186684,
0.013335974,
-0.0397485867,
-0.0007467654,
-0.0170928426,
0.0362130105,
0.0338755064,
0.0623001382,
0.0016248403,
0.0479947515,
-0.0317243487,
0.0351251848,
-0.0227601007,
0.0026296524,
-0.012494361,
-0.0297266077,
-0.0404796116,
0.0391803458,
0.0010357702,
-0.0262729637,
-0.0308341626,
-0.0252066925,
-0.0187057946,
0.0493662171,
0.0117266923,
0.0444582067,
-0.03318711,
0.0205606874,
0.034794081,
-0.0726385713,
-0.0262677539,
-0.0174096171,
0.0000118779,
0.0048647509,
-0.0090784058,
0.0355777889,
0.0265909638,
-0.0266132038,
-0.0383513868,
-0.0150219826,
-0.0613397025,
-0.0903099999,
-0.0317636915,
-0.0256066751,
-0.0096341483,
0.0162090734,
0.0196874663,
-0.0270271525,
-0.0118042883,
-0.0273001548,
-0.0383006595,
0.0357050151,
-0.0421892889,
0.028078679,
-0.0116075454,
0.0025279021,
0.0143029848,
0.077647537,
0.0230395198,
-0.0193585176,
0.034631189,
-0.0349857956,
-0.0168371405,
0.023176901,
-0.0002668582,
-0.0030797084,
-0.0016795613,
-0.0266558677,
0.0377636328,
-0.0058551189,
-0.0051945671,
0.046518825,
-0.0313584358,
0.0436680242,
0.0862241089,
0.0275841914,
0.0365265012,
0.0199582558,
-0.0003073048,
-0.028726276,
0.0137886712,
0.0276764128,
-0.0654207617,
-0.0088429367,
-0.0496230088,
0.0244149063,
0.0303620473,
0.045956783,
-0.0244454052,
-0.0522953905,
-0.0452828668,
0.0115869399,
-0.0053772973,
0.0187008157,
0.0649135038,
0.0126167852,
-0.0018763088,
0.0175113399,
0.0351777002,
-0.0336492583,
0.0247316696,
-0.0443143174,
0.0024484892,
0.0598334409,
0.0234223753,
-0.0194985103,
-0.0512131453,
0.0015901119,
0.0342826657,
-0.0109873023,
0.0470557995,
0.0030294778,
0.0532446019,
-0.0195200406,
-0.0340506025,
0.0191331133,
0.0252994858,
-0.0111189,
0.0043374365,
0.0159672722,
0.0008796283,
-0.0237964131,
-0.0488991402,
0.0222118907,
-0.0320420936,
0.0278484784,
-0.0028549554,
-0.0308450516,
0.0243672542,
-0.0260261055,
-0.0584807247,
0.0063462839,
0.0311784856,
0.0309178084,
0.0297305062,
0.0078620231,
-0.0247613341,
0.0311053246,
0.0532590002,
0.0374482609,
0.0119756255,
0.0224778242,
-0.0293205548,
-0.0549384952,
0.0508218706,
0.0158862416,
0.0175158661,
-0.0221269969,
0.0419258848,
-0.0616999157,
0.0670732334,
-0.0508492924,
0.0002604859,
0.0035504983,
0.0426492915,
-0.0278353635,
0.0397103131,
0.0088819657,
-0.0231372193,
-0.0399700738,
0.0087503986,
-0.0382594913,
0.028712336,
0.010535961,
-0.0040126392,
-0.0308823753,
-0.0428096205,
-0.048613932,
-0.0078316787,
-0.0403724164,
0.0271418411,
0.0314798541,
-0.0054953629,
-0.0404912345,
-0.0016253188,
0.0353718773,
0.0660481751,
0.013184255,
0.0131107783,
-0.002448278,
0.0090105943,
-0.0239653848,
-0.0616524741,
-0.0202786531,
0.0299476702,
0.0354693681,
-0.0054289796,
0.030056376,
-0.1145006269,
0.0549773127,
-0.0185975712,
0.0258403178,
0.0033751077,
-0.0516313203,
0.039743349,
0.0179563332,
0.042747885,
0.0663775057,
0.0008841212,
0.02240826,
0.0360027216,
-0.0322949961,
-0.0024703485,
-0.0292887893,
-0.0075661303,
-0.0406524092,
-0.0511603616,
0.0000384392,
-0.0142525453,
0.0459882244,
0.0057317778,
-0.0333774127,
-0.0531316139,
0.0165727884,
-0.0678434521,
0.0084292153,
0.0079719489,
0.0028936882,
-0.024804879,
0.048206944,
-0.025191009,
-0.0725889951,
0.0595605746,
-0.0379370712,
0.0278962199,
-0.0055153253,
-0.0069100629,
-0.010717744,
0.0243959166,
-0.0277700555,
-0.0186169781,
0.0361127071,
-0.0130300662,
-0.0628714561,
-0.0065348907,
0.0060557295,
-0.0272073299,
0.0605746023,
-0.0241367631,
0.004504397,
-0.0220538955,
-0.0387705192,
-0.0257564839,
-0.0588935837,
-0.009916774,
0.0155173149,
0.0978092253,
-0.0380347446,
0.0168582182,
-0.001038571,
-0.0204668846,
0.0229271576,
-0.057117302,
-0.0133767892,
-0.0240693949,
-0.0003793836,
0.0424148664,
0.023180915,
0.0806042776,
-0.058181297,
0.0122515811,
-0.021396894,
0.0419263728,
0.0458338633,
-0.0792879537,
-0.0022313262,
0.0101137329,
-0.0146587836,
-0.0082333693,
0.0325844921,
0.0695015118,
-0.0484030545,
-0.0671688169,
0.0940933302,
-0.0014283649,
0.0083143003,
0.0169811137,
-0.001706706,
0.0976249501,
0.0478056744,
0.0124664428,
-0.0314901024,
-0.0198846832,
0.0060493639,
0.0314716138,
0.0480263643,
-0.004078974,
0.0367874578,
-0.0923812762,
0.0323616639,
0.0219602566,
-0.0802353546,
0.0150427455,
-0.0097736083,
0.0311459936,
-0.0247618556,
0.0888479352,
0.0152039221,
-0.0156915579,
0.0091047632,
0.0480013974,
-0.0282727834,
-0.1336205006,
0.0418846756,
-0.052961532,
0.077724196,
0.0840203688,
-0.0516880229,
-0.011481856,
-0.0089256493,
0.0928493813,
-0.0078174556,
0.0025402547,
0.0142330956,
0.0345646553,
0.024033403,
-0.0439793505,
0.0070536141,
0.0092372615,
-0.020898059,
0.0140102142,
-0.0409418195,
0.0261401311,
-0.0156421289,
-0.0341085866,
0.0122991614,
-0.0341366492,
0.0180045608,
0.0299421828,
0.041381862,
-0.0708277449,
-0.0320374407,
-0.0056410166,
0.024334887,
-0.0525796413,
-0.011238954,
0.0210090764,
0.028811032,
0.0092497915,
-0.0388576947,
-0.0302957259,
0.0230448041,
0.0108792009,
-0.0016903167,
0.0272688493,
0.0005742434,
0.0031856121,
-0.0008088913,
0.0482515842,
0.0079236729,
-0.000232024,
-0.0728225708,
-0.010887729,
0.0265572164,
0.0319454856,
-0.0027077235,
0.0126464842,
-0.1387171,
-0.0771341771,
0.0566410497,
0.0755846724,
0.0217431113,
-0.002148849,
-0.0227004718,
-0.0869534835,
0.0223742779,
-0.0080419909,
-0.0087410053,
0.0558239855,
0.0216208864,
-0.0828410238,
-0.0142802438,
0.0345287584,
-0.0402273722,
0.003009994,
0.047583364,
0.0264426321,
0.0163926613,
-0.0472517461,
-0.0265874434,
-0.0097975861,
0.0842793137,
-0.0305593982,
-0.0348743051,
-0.0344120748,
0.0086555239,
0.0027595456,
0.003354561,
-0.0257696565,
-0.0135368761,
0.0224107038,
-0.0159314424,
-0.0139183933,
0.0100275846,
-0.0074575199,
0.0203359891,
-0.0441968478,
0.0035146247,
0.0034591481,
0.0070939967,
0.0418943912,
0.0434578285,
-0.0115947602,
0.0406583324,
-0.02812263,
0.0151324356,
-0.0228795167,
0.0131093841,
0.0170887299,
0.0254085641,
0.0037815506,
0.034819901,
-0.0488716885,
-0.0813059062,
-0.0154267922,
-0.0015414683,
0.036608994,
-0.0125178471,
0.0685407147,
0.0218644533,
0.0228301026,
-0.0601329766,
-0.0027017812,
-0.0064565241,
0.0294901356,
-0.0039179078,
0.0107701551,
-0.0122026065,
0.0230831057,
0.063709937,
0.0045207958,
0.0132164247,
-0.018838143,
0.0236197822,
-0.0214347951,
-0.0014194286,
-0.0217620898,
0.0100677973,
-0.040587645,
-0.0289976094,
-0.051180739,
-0.0592969954,
-0.0132802427,
0.0591182001,
0.0493942797,
0.0268048402,
-0.0020735674,
0.0580065511,
-0.0289932936,
0.0321966559,
-0.0091291415,
-0.0507298745,
-0.0020022504,
0.0069642719,
0.0010467508,
-6.857249969e-33,
-0.0325056091,
0.0092449952,
-0.0037218782,
-0.015785981,
-0.0213476028,
-0.0045397021,
-0.0402385667,
0.0397383124,
-0.0254057888,
-0.0057587931,
-0.0251775552,
0.0203348305,
0.0182246026,
0.0128584839,
0.0236959998,
-0.0202805884,
0.0190973245,
-0.0022551711,
-0.0345844738,
-0.0008524321,
0.0373149253,
0.030401079,
0.0569337793,
-0.035188999,
0.0226170402,
0.0307687521,
-0.0138670811,
-0.0367099717,
-0.0458783545,
0.0551808663,
0.0098742833,
0.0540937372,
0.0116870655,
-0.0406825095,
-0.0737041011,
-0.0061125658,
-0.0489699431,
-0.0272788182,
0.0032496934,
0.0234562047,
-0.0396462902,
0.0290067233,
0.0544446334,
-0.0236795843,
-0.0395102389,
-0.0168055315,
0.0215334371,
-0.0325912349,
-0.029629847,
-0.0170690343,
-0.0473325327,
0.0197272655,
0.0100686457,
-0.0361020528,
-0.0049760942,
-0.0478735305,
-0.0076269871,
-0.0104948832,
0.0014736457,
-0.0352924578,
0.0523168072,
0.0865251198,
0.0355302691,
0.0579750314,
0.0146059059,
0.0669347942,
0.0209280718,
0.0461261459,
0.0624354295,
-0.0460864976,
0.0902170762,
0.0202770215,
0.0447265096,
0.0014810346,
0.0434135459,
-0.0297905486,
-0.0723555684,
0.0046891985,
-0.0394746475,
0.0153958434,
0.0418005288,
0.0204761252,
0.0129264537,
-0.0263144262,
-0.0585077479,
-0.0238273144,
-0.0258565117,
-0.005227413,
0.0319801234,
0.014242474,
-0.0034345535,
0.0119705396,
0.0475671217,
-0.021897573,
-0.0002591203,
0.0017400556,
-0.032159172,
0.0278207809,
-0.017197771,
0.020244889,
-0.0367019735,
-0.0586542152,
0.0210301243,
0.0369919017,
0.0365888104,
-0.0249137301,
0.0194211584,
0.0223249067,
-0.0662474707,
-0.0063885776,
-0.0003735973,
0.0543573685,
0.0077026659,
0.0148563087,
0.0724466369,
-0.0336566456,
0.0089805331,
0.0524221249,
0.028330449,
0.014004278,
-0.0286519341,
0.0381842628,
0.0273556579,
0.0128615582,
0.0282825474,
0.0012189061,
-0.0150297312,
0.0141443256,
0.0041678152,
-0.0397217833,
-0.021991685,
0.0073059946,
2.571e-7,
0.0529704578,
0.0554219373,
0.009365919,
0.0076445355,
0.0266807936,
0.0018318682,
-0.0541775674,
-0.0173621718,
0.0063544009,
0.0119059244,
-0.0293163117,
0.0300838202,
0.0489530228,
0.0271135215,
-0.0265824497,
-0.0175839737,
-0.0823642462,
0.0799384117,
-0.0285437908,
-0.0260932725,
0.0116904248,
0.0871577635,
-0.0017204271,
-0.0141557511,
0.0029944887,
-0.0466932319,
0.0355252512,
-0.0121272532,
0.0086418521,
0.0380273685,
-0.0306292903,
0.0563264377,
-0.0046766074,
0.0138732363,
-0.0258548725,
0.0364563502,
-0.053694956,
0.0106802508,
-0.0217401199,
-0.0077560553,
0.0135568241,
0.0240122285,
-0.0011630778,
-0.0505327508,
0.0701906458,
-0.0958321169,
-0.0051708128,
-0.0255859103,
0.0223368984,
-0.0335367806,
0.068828091,
-0.0357883833,
-0.0127105033,
0.0370891355,
0.0221291464,
0.0068749459,
-0.0464322455,
-0.0820508227,
0.0130404811,
0.0676342919,
-0.0269480292,
-0.0518077128,
-0.0155035155,
-0.0478217676,
0.0197488461,
-0.0239217486,
-0.0072273924,
2.464647526e-34,
0.0435040817,
-0.0169916563,
0.0439907163,
-0.0112009589,
0.0412101336,
-0.0216464326,
-0.0029826602,
0.0088138366,
-0.0105682584,
-0.0432998426,
-0.0245754141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07748v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07748v4 | Whats New? Identifying the Unfolding of New Events in Narratives | 2023-02-15T15:54:01 | 2023-08-08T08:08:12 | Seyed Mahed Mousavi, Shohei Tanaka, Gabriel Roccabruna, Koichiro Yoshino, Satoshi Nakamura, Giuseppe Riccardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Narratives include a rich source of events unfolding over time and context.
Automatic understanding of these events provides a summarised comprehension of
the narrative for further computation (such as reasoning). In this paper, we
study the Information Status (IS) of the events and propose a novel challenging
task: the automatic identification of new events in a narrative. We define an
event as a triplet of subject, predicate, and object. The event is categorized
as new with respect to the discourse context and whether it can be inferred
through commonsense reasoning. We annotated a publicly available corpus of
narratives with the new events at sentence level using human annotators. We
present the annotation protocol and study the quality of the annotation and the
difficulty of the task. We publish the annotated dataset, annotation materials,
and machine learning baseline models for the task of new event extraction for
narrative understanding. | [
0.0005758753,
0.0148636531,
-0.0128555512,
0.0122463088,
-0.036259871,
0.011979931,
-0.0461700521,
0.0049681957,
0.0099811601,
-0.0549511835,
0.0512963161,
0.0247783866,
0.0071261162,
0.0462378599,
-0.0172157064,
-0.0503411964,
0.0499332547,
0.0149618741,
0.0565030687,
0.0512539893,
-0.0217895247,
0.0522504859,
-0.0414796323,
0.030069368,
-0.0311213695,
-0.0446450002,
-0.0424150117,
-0.014533543,
0.0357618481,
-0.0649663731,
-0.0112565793,
0.0344486721,
0.0492508858,
0.0279039349,
0.0000019338,
-0.0729181245,
-0.0028200888,
-0.017291151,
-0.0394754373,
-0.0085531408,
-0.0053125718,
-0.0141531639,
0.0104808826,
-0.0390495658,
-0.0496956334,
-0.0228404012,
-0.0034179138,
0.0730490163,
0.0224094298,
0.0694391578,
-0.0119174821,
-0.0206636824,
-0.0486882031,
0.0221843366,
-0.00192887,
-0.0326647349,
0.0087947026,
0.009021149,
0.0271076951,
-0.0475597009,
-0.0086892722,
-0.0124468636,
-0.0075707035,
-0.0323108062,
-0.0365564227,
0.0657721832,
-0.0404833592,
0.0392829999,
-0.0571508259,
0.0629958585,
0.0615304559,
-0.0285190158,
0.012287139,
0.0048729656,
0.0097299432,
-0.0149021642,
-0.0430995263,
0.0067798374,
-0.0272351056,
0.0187130813,
0.0345325768,
-0.0133631034,
-0.0000353309,
0.0070563215,
0.0611376688,
0.0318172723,
-0.0059116464,
0.0272358358,
-0.0583776273,
0.0008481238,
-0.0153136337,
-0.0722817108,
0.0002378687,
0.0666406825,
0.0002228632,
-0.0079995645,
-0.0575967543,
0.0389782786,
-0.0167428218,
-0.0909679309,
0.0151078869,
-0.0086456398,
-0.0507139675,
0.0808804706,
0.0184302703,
-0.0109217726,
-0.0003101745,
-0.0569978133,
-0.0174311977,
0.0528037027,
-0.0388890766,
0.0236120727,
-0.0307834577,
0.041676525,
-0.041435834,
-0.0102357836,
0.0340489522,
0.0055815992,
0.0518741868,
-0.0170187969,
-0.03777235,
-0.0176609345,
-0.0518726259,
0.0022015956,
-0.0203947034,
0.0234856196,
-0.0649725199,
0.0268197134,
-0.0181760434,
-0.0312158279,
-0.0385265052,
-0.0036317038,
0.0412541255,
0.0074051819,
-0.0295271166,
0.0045100087,
-0.0233420245,
0.001235949,
-0.1025762409,
-0.0592852868,
0.0089885676,
0.0116218952,
-0.0266090333,
-0.0245657843,
0.0031813821,
-0.0343999416,
-0.0049502389,
-0.0102187255,
0.0041562738,
0.0109824883,
-0.0187530108,
0.0003183677,
-0.0569245443,
0.0019974739,
0.0145140393,
-0.0155569259,
0.0138471583,
0.0464828275,
0.0622490942,
-0.0009092072,
0.0667688176,
0.0398798957,
0.0151525196,
-0.0100653768,
-0.0538916253,
0.0173871256,
0.0286348984,
-0.0288796704,
-0.0295112673,
0.0269772746,
0.0036183191,
-0.0177678764,
-0.0406210348,
-0.0239334274,
0.0459061153,
0.0668015182,
-0.0494764857,
-0.014621106,
0.0525734723,
0.0107886028,
0.0025164606,
0.0558318235,
0.0033264435,
-0.0156621952,
0.0119996099,
-0.0372226276,
-0.0484318361,
-0.0134425424,
-0.0018617561,
-0.0305489898,
-0.0019755755,
-0.019198779,
-0.0074257413,
-0.0299976412,
0.009316097,
0.0273057707,
-0.0157240108,
0.0015358537,
0.0344669856,
-0.0596636422,
0.0359802581,
0.0038045081,
0.0612186156,
0.0370275266,
0.0523747541,
-0.0582092404,
-0.055166319,
-0.0524299368,
0.0512818508,
-0.0068901968,
0.0088961329,
-0.0506172739,
0.0435273983,
-0.0158108473,
0.0188689083,
-0.0027552787,
0.0177885219,
0.0086529432,
-0.0098971669,
-0.0292906705,
-0.0453051217,
-0.0206996668,
-0.0204174835,
0.0628252774,
-0.0114324847,
-0.0188879315,
-0.0189471655,
-0.017044453,
-0.0152586801,
0.0250465646,
0.0241683088,
-0.0353257917,
0.0456386544,
-0.0084705036,
-0.0167754963,
0.111918956,
0.0044298344,
-0.0448562987,
0.0414070673,
-0.0585703477,
-0.0446528047,
-0.0463724807,
-0.0154916011,
-0.0410877168,
0.0595110431,
-0.007360294,
0.0097056068,
-0.016759688,
-0.0386679135,
0.0030791808,
-0.0263053626,
-0.0199345853,
0.0967030302,
0.020617649,
-0.0276019387,
-0.02137658,
-0.0570773482,
0.0276786443,
0.0030529997,
0.0030783082,
0.0247765537,
0.0102466065,
-0.0274277739,
0.0632138997,
-0.0349780247,
-0.0161835961,
0.0139290411,
-0.0772646889,
0.0410046689,
-0.0202184319,
0.028864773,
0.0468714349,
-0.002463904,
-0.0374772549,
-0.0099717742,
0.0262779333,
-0.0274615586,
-0.0277543552,
-0.0142310997,
0.0421145745,
0.042454198,
0.0237064864,
-0.0327201784,
0.034657985,
-0.0523765981,
0.0781123564,
0.0792759955,
-0.0232750289,
-0.0699881241,
-0.0350804962,
0.0194691997,
0.0491205789,
-0.0144963479,
0.0019728276,
0.0178655051,
0.0014593127,
0.020056067,
0.0696774498,
-0.0064808237,
0.0897483826,
0.016463222,
-0.0373439454,
-0.0169384181,
0.0160276815,
-0.0317419283,
0.0065959236,
-0.0464926511,
0.0103961676,
0.0161639787,
0.0479203425,
0.0002336796,
-0.0125899287,
-0.0434870645,
-0.0201326367,
-0.0401526988,
-0.0295022354,
0.0196301118,
-0.0575735606,
-0.0408138148,
0.0470835119,
-0.0244751442,
0.0254689939,
0.0487840138,
0.0151148522,
0.0144597255,
-0.0435629822,
-0.0047920616,
-0.0486994684,
0.0840292796,
-0.0207076557,
0.0171979908,
0.0253743194,
-0.0448548421,
-0.0020261535,
0.0000636775,
0.0160570871,
0.0151880216,
0.032720197,
-0.0720148534,
0.0047848858,
0.0236967057,
-0.0056033474,
-0.0315072052,
-0.075013198,
-0.0007422476,
-0.0301413834,
-0.0362968519,
-0.0218600612,
-0.0078847213,
-0.0092807412,
-0.0152359046,
0.0569959767,
0.0153823392,
-0.0127429878,
-0.0415474549,
0.0399475507,
0.0137702366,
0.0163811725,
-0.0206109919,
0.0116944807,
0.0191198438,
0.0582722872,
0.0066427053,
-0.0022260649,
-0.0290010553,
0.0299459267,
0.0100900494,
-0.058598537,
-0.0032098456,
-0.0018842595,
0.0315056555,
-0.0532387048,
0.0007416189,
0.0951080769,
0.036571376,
-0.0034850293,
0.0329326056,
0.0174518768,
-0.0190940592,
0.0468040779,
0.0040338389,
-0.0966433063,
0.0022347239,
-0.0032728582,
-0.0008192207,
-0.0222043768,
-0.1085724607,
-0.0128357168,
-0.0721169338,
0.0399823114,
-0.0145390034,
0.0035813053,
0.0155179147,
-0.0250638165,
0.0229446553,
-0.0102090994,
-0.0416600965,
-0.0056381528,
-0.0067236237,
0.0246474631,
0.0200245883,
-0.0203971546,
-0.0266765524,
-0.0091530755,
-0.0200430658,
0.0276583973,
0.0205431767,
0.0579889864,
-0.0134387258,
0.0508624092,
0.0062596938,
0.004441902,
0.0052900477,
0.0187703073,
0.0516425818,
-0.0037383996,
0.0010803213,
-0.0308328271,
0.0645656213,
0.002929064,
-0.0906963199,
0.0374317802,
0.0504747443,
-0.0057850936,
-0.0126627842,
0.0104637397,
0.0132627627,
0.0316239186,
0.0540690571,
0.0189155899,
0.0077225794,
0.0013593462,
-0.0200437997,
0.0532031357,
-0.0510217734,
-0.008997052,
0.0228885897,
-0.0187736005,
-0.0302675255,
-0.0878631845,
-0.0563554615,
0.0266555957,
0.0287314057,
0.0666244552,
0.035176035,
0.062392097,
-0.0033627583,
-0.0669577867,
0.0382869616,
-0.0313312896,
-0.0336793996,
0.0074199853,
0.0110073453,
0.0108653074,
-0.0088069765,
-0.0187881701,
0.0534234047,
-0.0389452614,
-0.0201867688,
0.006067059,
-0.0412862822,
0.0207204986,
0.0494922511,
-0.034707807,
-0.0044582104,
-0.0254205894,
-0.0196144208,
-0.0149839995,
0.0418475196,
-0.008112656,
0.0325606056,
-0.0122398026,
-0.0038586981,
0.0032548937,
0.0045210915,
-0.0406819917,
0.0076824734,
-0.0715486407,
-0.0188188069,
0.0302433223,
-0.0133138159,
0.0546140447,
-0.0379587263,
-0.0125908861,
-0.0702883899,
-0.0353877582,
0.0025682992,
-0.0060542566,
-0.0161859952,
0.0235234648,
-0.0007121908,
0.0119168302,
-0.0541535877,
0.0377816372,
-0.0223569963,
0.0514609963,
-0.0655200705,
-0.0078727677,
0.0721664205,
0.0027280359,
-0.0480415262,
0.009036636,
0.0073797377,
0.0242185798,
-0.0315747745,
0.0623314567,
-0.0128937494,
0.0102795316,
0.0237610564,
-0.0352336578,
0.0115837008,
-0.0010176206,
-0.0588256046,
0.0534945503,
0.0069328179,
0.0413474329,
0.0511901863,
-0.0366994701,
0.0692645833,
0.0040136697,
0.0116270697,
-0.00160777,
0.031803865,
0.0189915318,
-0.0211766548,
-0.0332989879,
0.009271889,
-0.0422362052,
0.0845851451,
0.0439136401,
-0.0847070292,
0.1025462896,
0.0235269442,
-0.0053963051,
-0.015038481,
-0.0359653533,
-0.008951243,
0.0421057642,
0.030985985,
0.0215976704,
-0.0663689598,
0.0569722466,
0.0457566455,
-0.0003990846,
0.03104637,
-0.0081133489,
-0.0024549684,
0.0252963342,
-0.009286385,
-0.033172749,
-0.0636566803,
0.0042383135,
-0.0055318959,
-0.0028728384,
-0.0181932896,
-5.828808492e-33,
-0.0359340273,
0.0033310037,
-0.0178215541,
0.0750164166,
-0.0468515456,
0.0366983898,
-0.0335988849,
-0.0277636126,
0.0173478685,
0.0549680367,
0.0235728435,
0.0208785161,
0.0106078722,
-0.0379027762,
0.0055637648,
-0.0316916332,
0.0349538624,
0.0159900673,
-0.0487425849,
0.0101500032,
0.0692711025,
0.0026327216,
0.0734686255,
-0.0741267651,
0.0286096521,
-0.0183138419,
-0.0182518791,
0.0280938502,
0.0532152764,
0.0160139296,
-0.0063434178,
0.0087977359,
0.0238249954,
-0.034858577,
-0.0172636099,
0.019732438,
-0.0538818538,
-0.0242403373,
0.0664026812,
0.0320913382,
-0.0036467265,
-0.05037231,
-0.0271753855,
0.0084009115,
-0.0001793526,
0.0098098032,
0.0535926372,
-0.03072902,
0.0143847642,
0.0117512895,
-0.076277867,
0.0287175421,
-0.0537628271,
-0.0381521434,
-0.0066440399,
0.02246028,
0.0259174388,
-0.0664748549,
-0.0458807163,
0.0278833788,
-0.0196971912,
0.013960843,
-0.0464927033,
-0.0106547242,
-0.0429676659,
0.0749959946,
0.0024045066,
0.0027899256,
-0.0407010205,
0.0666451827,
-0.0220391378,
0.0300743952,
-0.0203620978,
0.0545776077,
-0.0315470807,
0.0358011536,
-0.075236924,
0.0501212664,
0.0380547941,
0.015114014,
0.0307798311,
0.0034396653,
-0.0302979797,
-0.0067108376,
-0.0314160399,
-0.0277147107,
0.0186579991,
0.0376693755,
-0.0174781736,
-0.0218013264,
-0.0174989104,
0.0616467446,
0.0089134909,
-0.0149778696,
0.0133497166,
0.0118123749,
-0.021000104,
0.0420167409,
0.0105160056,
0.0282015465,
0.0143350046,
0.0098224785,
0.0440297313,
0.0148145398,
0.0878586993,
-0.0123158786,
0.032411173,
0.0201529954,
-0.0127628027,
-0.0109692086,
0.0090686837,
-0.0072336625,
-0.0259291306,
-0.031290058,
0.0195118673,
0.0455968268,
0.0045028096,
0.023457218,
0.0326502919,
0.027977718,
-0.0028602812,
-0.0356456228,
0.0081630824,
-0.0054932269,
-0.0120654935,
0.0163651202,
0.0138972597,
0.0463152789,
0.0105585074,
-0.0331668444,
0.0089292806,
0.0219891965,
2.556e-7,
0.0254610982,
0.0273964368,
0.0884601325,
-0.0354701914,
-0.0020206186,
0.0282230489,
-0.0128864106,
0.0238743853,
-0.0015387693,
-0.0392001681,
0.0142584555,
0.0189737473,
0.027358016,
0.0263001621,
-0.0849226862,
-0.0609650724,
-0.0652986467,
-0.0328607187,
-0.1022300273,
-0.0172681343,
0.0977274254,
0.004264873,
0.0641636401,
0.0204697456,
-0.0017372763,
-0.0511894859,
-0.0052865841,
-0.0187859405,
-0.0402243063,
0.0356195383,
0.0109375436,
0.0389293134,
-0.0317182429,
-0.0154753579,
-0.0272493102,
0.0151694911,
-0.0085554626,
0.0320138484,
-0.0395877436,
0.0190167855,
-0.0218916181,
0.0150157139,
-0.019404646,
0.0196860302,
0.0632931665,
-0.0229455158,
-0.0448353067,
-0.0269785002,
-0.0148276752,
0.0114177084,
-0.0302681364,
0.0304239765,
0.0075614792,
0.0378125198,
0.0000595796,
-0.0065301564,
-0.0279406551,
-0.0825279653,
-0.0005156936,
0.0416707471,
-0.0222231671,
0.0076738158,
0.0308636855,
-0.0397187844,
-0.0222289078,
-0.0662460923,
0.0398055948,
1.900467864e-34,
-0.0067266552,
0.0264916625,
0.00103927,
0.0552660637,
0.055222448,
-0.0043327361,
-0.023974549,
-0.0025222746,
0.0378081985,
-0.0312027633,
0.0016055029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07679v1 | On graph-based reentrancy-free semantic parsing | 2023-02-15T14:14:09 | 2023-02-15T14:14:09 | Alban Petit, Caio Corro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose a novel graph-based approach for semantic parsing that resolves
two problems observed in the literature: (1) seq2seq models fail on
compositional generalization tasks; (2) previous work using phrase structure
parsers cannot cover all the semantic parses observed in treebanks. We prove
that both MAP inference and latent tag anchoring (required for
weakly-supervised learning) are NP-hard problems. We propose two optimization
algorithms based on constraint smoothing and conditional gradient to
approximately solve these inference problems. Experimentally, our approach
delivers state-of-the-art results on Geoquery, Scan and Clevr, both for i.i.d.
splits and for splits that test for compositional generalization. | [
0.0402560942,
0.0081230476,
0.02162393,
0.0374662951,
-0.0263650026,
0.0296300314,
-0.0335359797,
-0.0423405468,
0.0340301096,
-0.0451812707,
0.0115579329,
0.0263733938,
-0.0158246346,
0.0024715862,
0.008085506,
-0.0647331104,
0.0446844511,
-0.0027361435,
0.0235672444,
0.0276011303,
0.0119266929,
0.0135785704,
0.0049370821,
0.0010702151,
-0.0530209318,
-0.0153980609,
-0.0107958205,
0.0261527989,
-0.0119484635,
-0.0390169807,
-0.0006410419,
-0.006662962,
-0.0154427206,
-0.0083954502,
0.0000018965,
-0.0043206629,
-0.0837085247,
0.0133399647,
0.0125928223,
-0.0401407182,
0.0141534107,
-0.0771352798,
0.0318501778,
0.0051489258,
-0.0266258493,
-0.0516354814,
0.0510782935,
0.0218899269,
0.0966550857,
0.0957016349,
-0.0356355272,
-0.0781181008,
-0.0400507003,
-0.0184632894,
0.0002416361,
-0.054743126,
-0.0073509258,
-0.0009057417,
-0.0287232548,
-0.0162817817,
-0.0503177531,
0.0117709292,
-0.014787999,
-0.0010621498,
0.0263332017,
0.0268979035,
-0.0564505607,
-0.0021674647,
0.0030644289,
0.0656832606,
-0.0215338767,
0.0065390593,
0.0458720624,
-0.0072867335,
-0.0152203823,
0.0060214042,
-0.0354837291,
0.0217660107,
-0.0211075582,
0.0582249016,
0.0278479084,
-0.0409073159,
0.017964894,
-0.0284158755,
-0.0417855009,
0.1319836676,
-0.012453435,
-0.0173249133,
-0.0103829578,
0.0477659255,
-0.0467599668,
-0.0098974537,
-0.00015992,
0.0007013323,
-0.0329018086,
0.0353845768,
-0.0316608176,
-0.0165835172,
-0.0463513024,
0.0260871425,
0.0125793098,
0.032221511,
0.0191930905,
0.0758860931,
-0.0047071613,
0.0162486322,
-0.0092426976,
0.0557104535,
-0.0347455442,
-0.031317614,
-0.037285395,
-0.0170330536,
-0.0661797971,
0.0322257206,
-0.0269754473,
-0.0261700954,
-0.0246709641,
0.0160944425,
0.0196729563,
0.0158361159,
0.0046838261,
0.0091894483,
-0.060670834,
0.0060695461,
0.0223975964,
0.0133039709,
0.002338585,
-0.0104050562,
0.0071028373,
-0.0066071348,
-0.0290208049,
0.0449892357,
0.04530292,
-0.0269104652,
-0.0535261557,
0.0378268398,
0.0184420217,
0.0044919164,
-0.068514742,
-0.0496508107,
-0.0365711786,
-0.0122986725,
0.0365197696,
-0.0469550192,
0.035346359,
0.0137903038,
0.0230516847,
-0.0527176745,
-0.013517499,
-0.0050282707,
-0.0282290559,
0.0421080403,
0.0028312998,
-0.0047012512,
-0.0036814697,
-0.0215315204,
-0.0118325418,
0.0749142617,
0.0246390142,
0.0103527969,
0.0423626639,
0.0320389569,
-0.0609955564,
0.0078831809,
0.0018754582,
-0.0318592526,
0.0078050592,
-0.0291014034,
-0.0101733329,
-0.0047582537,
0.0268162023,
0.0542000532,
-0.0320560001,
-0.0178696159,
-0.0472617224,
0.0379318818,
-0.0429380573,
0.0024696002,
0.0799673945,
0.0306481775,
-0.0565742739,
0.0363859832,
-0.0848199278,
-0.0603558868,
0.0327429026,
0.0216981713,
-0.0443308949,
-0.0188013371,
0.0174133815,
-0.0097363312,
-0.025152294,
-0.018484138,
0.0504342914,
-0.0491640382,
0.0649256706,
0.0077955262,
0.0018286522,
0.0401740037,
0.0040611411,
-0.0322889946,
0.0141456956,
0.0192749631,
0.0073843892,
0.0081325527,
0.0059463014,
-0.0098779052,
-0.039336089,
0.0278008245,
0.0394280553,
0.0220663343,
0.041729182,
-0.0389563963,
0.0204948597,
-0.0429317243,
-0.0500201061,
-0.0184217151,
0.0252916384,
-0.0474031419,
0.0215140861,
-0.0376765877,
0.0413558632,
-0.0458836593,
0.0094383638,
0.035293974,
0.0499843322,
0.004438384,
-0.0305074546,
0.0148356939,
0.016890198,
-0.0009038162,
0.0141720753,
0.0287960898,
0.0241223462,
-0.0277265441,
-0.0038233465,
0.0358238071,
-0.0388878062,
-0.0861027688,
0.0344780348,
-0.0723848045,
-0.0334048979,
-0.0302631147,
-0.0922668427,
-0.0613287613,
0.013160455,
-0.0401808806,
0.059147995,
0.0124680344,
0.006259094,
0.0373693146,
-0.0466131382,
-0.0293904785,
0.0612341054,
0.0037901334,
0.0113924844,
-0.0062592085,
-0.0104563311,
0.007827119,
-0.0300091635,
-0.0254866201,
0.0062065027,
0.0146745844,
-0.0641964078,
0.0114560677,
-0.0043353424,
-0.0638890788,
0.0068563563,
-0.0578859113,
-0.0026778765,
-0.0326147825,
0.078104794,
0.04356822,
0.0345048122,
0.0193911586,
-0.0532748885,
-0.0407407172,
0.0027476645,
0.0069287955,
0.0101475026,
0.0472437851,
-0.0025502797,
-0.003564731,
-0.0005175173,
-0.0395282581,
-0.0647377446,
0.0313348919,
0.0262455419,
-0.0342409648,
0.0079347109,
0.0200753361,
0.0048944568,
0.0307871643,
0.013615761,
0.0233970713,
0.0017754388,
-0.0453657359,
0.0281903148,
0.0519745722,
-0.0402870812,
-0.0022612889,
-0.0289241225,
-0.0251319688,
-0.0212164056,
0.0152752958,
-0.0370359458,
-0.004694385,
-0.0436608046,
-0.0262925103,
0.0063466565,
0.0868522078,
-0.0091282055,
0.0031823278,
-0.0173702296,
-0.0283081401,
-0.062189851,
-0.0237869378,
-0.0082234014,
0.0199121051,
0.0265407525,
-0.004990879,
-0.0657107383,
-0.0246173125,
0.0873879716,
-0.0097732553,
-0.0202849191,
-0.0187139809,
0.0164244585,
-0.0745297819,
0.0537124537,
0.0246783439,
0.0268000085,
0.0163922235,
-0.0794736221,
-0.0254825987,
-0.0397727117,
0.0442653447,
0.0150238564,
0.0137650371,
-0.0294171497,
0.0372689068,
-0.0139959343,
-0.0291696172,
0.0061105122,
-0.0143180769,
-0.015558159,
0.0133907627,
0.0313199759,
0.0116434386,
0.0444910936,
0.0435545743,
-0.0460654385,
0.034380015,
-0.0148655185,
0.0102969613,
-0.0293573756,
0.0310544986,
0.0279690567,
0.0365631431,
-0.0375913009,
0.0142779807,
-0.0148126613,
0.0502047203,
0.0364516564,
-0.0059144478,
0.0037087151,
0.0641101152,
-0.0044974615,
-0.0312187057,
-0.054525815,
-0.0439759977,
0.0277747102,
-0.0747566447,
-0.0570002645,
0.081601873,
0.0622343048,
-0.0080129057,
-0.0106603196,
0.0214150678,
0.0263502765,
0.047849752,
0.0082086632,
-0.0627124384,
-0.0521335155,
0.0084873727,
0.0355202071,
0.0226589665,
-0.0630419552,
0.0223144535,
-0.0935602635,
0.0170633625,
0.0161827933,
-0.0150497956,
0.0004883604,
-0.0243861638,
-0.0365919881,
-0.0503137521,
-0.0592562668,
0.002291631,
-0.0361599959,
0.0290529076,
0.0366272256,
-0.0201765522,
0.0090921335,
-0.0490135141,
-0.0686919838,
-0.027117338,
0.0681014732,
0.0040961471,
0.0010320919,
0.0028258159,
0.0777014494,
-0.0194657929,
-0.0193148274,
-0.0169670433,
-0.0129928803,
-0.0378048308,
-0.0054875305,
0.0117862634,
0.034143582,
-0.0411390364,
0.0114878016,
-0.0080643939,
0.062171068,
-0.00397259,
0.0296616685,
-0.0104062054,
-0.0340865999,
0.0023140041,
0.03837201,
0.015298604,
0.0271006301,
-0.0703125596,
-0.0709736496,
0.0132191926,
-0.047523655,
0.0103346407,
0.0745078623,
-0.0206699986,
0.0041981833,
-0.0557417832,
-0.0639600828,
0.0490035564,
0.0162439328,
-0.0511666387,
-0.0104069877,
0.074041374,
-0.0457101315,
-0.034928523,
0.0157463197,
-0.0405956618,
-0.0017089079,
0.0004694455,
0.0149652595,
0.0331539847,
0.0409358554,
-0.0404984914,
-0.020305803,
-0.0709430799,
-0.0452664979,
0.0211546645,
0.0338945426,
0.0141563443,
0.0615705736,
-0.0687518939,
0.0135550639,
-0.0281428453,
0.0250352472,
-0.0243046302,
0.0107983444,
0.0104896296,
0.0180624966,
0.0073041008,
0.025757065,
-0.0257284809,
0.0053529968,
-0.0089884615,
0.0863661915,
0.0015439179,
0.0340605266,
0.0685036331,
0.0304557756,
0.0495588966,
0.0016127824,
0.0468060598,
-0.0126999179,
0.0162519068,
-0.0068647736,
-0.0386013612,
-0.0350773297,
0.0312351324,
0.0140080908,
-0.004907323,
-0.0097701335,
-0.0118864514,
-0.0200791154,
0.0573661737,
-0.0362594053,
0.0083324695,
0.0533732139,
-0.0666406527,
-0.0073813051,
-0.0013286453,
-0.0101824664,
0.0371691659,
-0.0029100797,
-0.0117377127,
-0.0184849091,
-0.0106989788,
0.0514753945,
0.0060380227,
-0.0512243435,
-0.0272081979,
-0.0266550146,
0.0126359323,
-0.001913488,
0.0099104214,
0.054396335,
-0.0039384309,
0.0583760291,
0.0193548482,
0.0004555094,
0.009922429,
0.0196901038,
0.0477446131,
-0.0500746407,
0.0591094494,
0.0110158678,
-0.02142567,
0.0002108252,
0.0573728196,
0.0602322146,
0.0433735289,
0.0101108961,
-0.0336357355,
-0.0365575254,
-0.0356292576,
0.0215333682,
0.0127687734,
-0.0196427591,
0.0210568067,
-0.0244087614,
-0.0565255433,
0.0054497202,
0.0167416148,
0.0284505654,
0.0079917107,
0.0432045795,
0.0707244575,
0.0197945591,
-0.0698418841,
-0.0310208388,
-0.0027926348,
-0.035567116,
-0.0396905281,
-0.0077498714,
-6.268992923e-33,
-0.0474250689,
-0.027057251,
0.0237417687,
0.0213596579,
-0.0101324059,
0.0021714503,
-0.0404856913,
-0.0124151362,
-0.0056187729,
0.0098841395,
-0.0100456337,
0.034166079,
0.0363410972,
0.0791186839,
0.024427712,
-0.0146639403,
0.0651077107,
-0.0015467951,
-0.0067412462,
0.0074946308,
0.0326933488,
0.0361977033,
0.0355433635,
-0.0161231663,
0.0234734882,
-0.0129292645,
-0.0129832802,
0.0404800884,
0.0241599865,
0.0410473011,
0.0001856926,
-0.0289442074,
0.0294337831,
-0.0105478046,
-0.0272036456,
-0.0081655839,
-0.1156325042,
-0.0169771481,
0.0064336485,
0.0215253066,
-0.0641695857,
-0.0006517228,
0.042238947,
-0.0245562196,
0.0569480062,
0.0039608553,
0.0086678453,
0.0217460338,
-0.0241059512,
-0.0293741524,
-0.0346142128,
0.0553779155,
0.0135530252,
0.0315899476,
0.0333923176,
0.0003883371,
0.0079717441,
0.0472397096,
-0.0027591235,
0.0052895271,
-0.0361701921,
0.0422918424,
0.0160999838,
0.041476991,
0.0161989555,
0.0065659168,
-0.0106758708,
-0.0372686684,
0.0107880579,
0.0311034266,
-0.0055302442,
0.0292199478,
-0.0457642414,
0.0149567565,
0.0376944467,
0.02672166,
-0.0748396441,
-0.0024528722,
0.0089597097,
0.0791416988,
-0.036622081,
0.0399202853,
-0.0223660711,
-0.0427155942,
-0.0169013981,
-0.0427153818,
0.003062105,
-0.0197474658,
0.029404616,
0.021687489,
-0.0308269728,
0.0619550087,
0.026380891,
-0.0183092486,
-0.0070951045,
0.0006589659,
0.0253991503,
0.0169549249,
-0.0419669002,
0.0432100892,
-0.0384407267,
-0.0688848794,
0.0120145539,
-0.0104557257,
0.0317549296,
0.0140153747,
0.0364881344,
0.0296563487,
-0.0085045779,
0.0095936023,
-0.0524005257,
-0.0247593466,
-0.0755930617,
0.0492970161,
0.0577233061,
-0.0081979167,
-0.0125147579,
0.0405088253,
0.0243688915,
0.0613809861,
0.0213338397,
-0.0321122855,
0.0089029763,
0.0476862825,
0.0006941285,
-0.0128407497,
0.0321914069,
-0.004471329,
-0.0073411008,
-0.0459714383,
0.0027570603,
0.0273510404,
2.685e-7,
0.0667331517,
0.0125882952,
0.08070492,
0.0016774905,
-0.0001442796,
-0.0026677586,
-0.0018072132,
0.0202596504,
-0.0540429018,
-0.0107545611,
-0.0097513665,
0.0036968223,
-0.0126631102,
0.0431642272,
-0.1316596121,
0.0661474094,
-0.0421366952,
-0.0243259389,
-0.0302372612,
0.0089753941,
0.0791102126,
0.0791584849,
-0.0135679273,
0.0076589761,
-0.0283358935,
-0.0499433652,
0.0040330105,
0.0286158044,
-0.0149202449,
0.0038855588,
0.0314049497,
0.0215018075,
0.0157868546,
-0.0254007187,
0.0061059808,
0.037868619,
0.0437369756,
0.0593656562,
-0.0191523135,
0.0587124228,
-0.0015823655,
-0.0561280921,
0.0174344294,
-0.0091613401,
0.0496685244,
-0.0678053051,
-0.0130599327,
0.0021249917,
-0.0537914075,
0.0131123113,
-0.052574262,
-0.0067764521,
0.0099232905,
-0.0050117816,
0.0483930968,
-0.0031199262,
-0.0211434476,
-0.0560908914,
-0.01874361,
0.0308879055,
0.0023926243,
-0.0080242408,
0.0127432179,
0.0720701292,
-0.0029359928,
-0.0313110873,
-0.0623693243,
2.566680206e-34,
0.0238909759,
0.0113059282,
-0.0112276841,
0.0474123098,
0.0419675149,
-0.0107697472,
-0.0580607578,
0.0296070222,
-0.0382012948,
-0.0796036571,
-0.0178676546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07636v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07636v2 | DP-BART for Privatized Text Rewriting under Local Differential Privacy | 2023-02-15T13:07:34 | 2023-06-06T14:17:46 | Timour Igamberdiev, Ivan Habernal | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Privatized text rewriting with local differential privacy (LDP) is a recent
approach that enables sharing of sensitive textual documents while formally
guaranteeing privacy protection to individuals. However, existing systems face
several issues, such as formal mathematical flaws, unrealistic privacy
guarantees, privatization of only individual words, as well as a lack of
transparency and reproducibility. In this paper, we propose a new system
'DP-BART' that largely outperforms existing LDP systems. Our approach uses a
novel clipping method, iterative pruning, and further training of internal
representations which drastically reduces the amount of noise required for DP
guarantees. We run experiments on five textual datasets of varying sizes,
rewriting them at different privacy guarantees and evaluating the rewritten
texts on downstream text classification tasks. Finally, we thoroughly discuss
the privatized text rewriting approach and its limitations, including the
problem of the strict text adjacency constraint in the LDP paradigm that leads
to the high noise requirement. | [
0.0097003551,
0.095832549,
-0.0077425484,
0.0433451459,
-0.0683928654,
-0.0335192606,
0.0750519633,
0.0259160511,
0.0236047637,
0.0032758957,
-0.0255504288,
0.0050501744,
-0.0016424677,
0.0259853099,
-0.0012701973,
-0.0158542916,
0.0072076493,
0.01399522,
0.0140523389,
-0.0383180194,
-0.0039233239,
-0.0123995729,
0.0285271779,
0.0106524639,
0.0031054369,
0.0002041476,
0.0140712513,
0.0124551877,
0.0304752178,
-0.0132742161,
0.0349103734,
0.0468115695,
0.0431503132,
0.0733046085,
0.000001962,
-0.0148105258,
-0.0530194119,
0.0649802908,
-0.0293456763,
-0.0283967946,
0.0007321865,
-0.0241726227,
0.0547316037,
-0.0246078297,
-0.0254624225,
0.0133472746,
0.0136918928,
0.0605393127,
0.082372658,
0.1020332649,
-0.0280888006,
-0.0546770059,
-0.0141097754,
-0.0430793501,
0.0168838631,
-0.0207010116,
0.0500190742,
-0.0364238285,
-0.0496242642,
0.0007132179,
0.0067043845,
0.0313954242,
0.005000358,
0.0256717931,
0.0330937915,
0.0131439241,
-0.0057661156,
-0.0112896534,
0.0121926675,
0.0238369144,
0.0122027406,
-0.048714336,
0.0307665411,
0.001639195,
0.0471754298,
0.0123628741,
0.0073954309,
0.0354105607,
-0.0418652445,
0.0077211484,
-0.0249436274,
0.026542468,
0.0065805544,
-0.0144363996,
0.0123461336,
0.0122812474,
0.0114570428,
-0.0372643396,
-0.0565629564,
-0.0027949663,
0.0252860859,
-0.0393446311,
0.1059890017,
0.004069543,
0.0588821173,
-0.0032388691,
-0.1020802855,
-0.0728567094,
0.0079130465,
-0.0469630808,
0.003303013,
-0.0249060448,
0.0459607765,
0.0017547514,
-0.0120559158,
0.0431010984,
0.008545002,
0.0434323438,
-0.0060438928,
0.0560091585,
-0.0067570959,
0.0041013355,
-0.0367533229,
0.0730007216,
-0.0843302831,
0.0150607256,
-0.0316314064,
0.0108299553,
-0.0146463867,
0.0061302036,
0.0104117328,
0.0067773932,
-0.0577630512,
0.0018566307,
0.0381987393,
-0.0731665045,
0.0013937637,
0.0062930104,
-0.0036735176,
0.0173034649,
-0.0199435614,
-0.0328118131,
0.0216751788,
-0.0026127594,
-0.0308846533,
0.0904891267,
0.0014105925,
-0.0185336266,
-0.0099135684,
-0.0490705259,
-0.039320752,
-0.0098975655,
-0.0106888469,
-0.0318944119,
0.0152253639,
-0.0606692247,
-0.0307191741,
-0.0916362554,
0.0086637428,
0.0423954204,
0.0069614006,
0.0597722493,
0.0164973475,
-0.0121680163,
0.0475036465,
0.0435822718,
0.0346714072,
-0.0068715112,
0.0208859313,
0.0479173437,
0.067615822,
0.0211623739,
0.0638553053,
-0.0112866713,
0.0860070586,
0.0470119044,
-0.0486944169,
0.0204720106,
0.008030043,
-0.0315975994,
0.0235575661,
0.0417810269,
-0.0189523157,
-0.1029619798,
0.079161562,
0.0610909574,
0.0312675014,
0.0021463034,
-0.0310277622,
0.0634727255,
-0.0349275246,
0.0093069812,
-0.0315817595,
-0.0040978021,
-0.0370122977,
-0.0391571149,
-0.021936588,
-0.0196868666,
-0.004650584,
0.0151756629,
0.0209923144,
-0.0234034136,
0.040391624,
0.0051031285,
-0.0159810726,
0.0137402182,
0.032682512,
0.0356707312,
-0.0008872747,
-0.0324217454,
-0.0204764213,
-0.0470168777,
0.0174171794,
0.0143882632,
0.0263296328,
-0.035188552,
0.0278296489,
-0.0545515344,
-0.0540935807,
0.0116274329,
-0.0105829313,
0.003727403,
0.0372408703,
-0.023812294,
-0.0538182184,
-0.0403958857,
0.0128629971,
0.0110421963,
0.0227874927,
-0.0023512351,
0.0118478518,
-0.0425963327,
0.004983204,
0.0602006428,
0.0021373725,
-0.0599838756,
0.0436880291,
0.0025706643,
0.0359755531,
0.0118343309,
-0.0039333017,
0.0092243636,
0.0024444191,
0.0115780747,
-0.0265361331,
-0.0475575142,
-0.0210533869,
-0.0601388924,
0.003009472,
-0.0681026205,
0.0131815029,
0.0695879459,
-0.0157997105,
-0.0222010557,
-0.0293882471,
-0.0086815245,
-0.0426286869,
0.0039948327,
-0.0044654775,
-0.017819874,
0.0516399145,
-0.0508729666,
0.0110188304,
-0.0230850521,
-0.0054688309,
-0.0827546492,
-0.0407330878,
0.0534800552,
-0.0136707611,
-0.0078273332,
-0.0414786562,
-0.0218884591,
0.0152761871,
0.0063966918,
0.0312301312,
0.0022000442,
-0.0324348621,
0.0021523929,
-0.008013037,
-0.0048444346,
0.0303839054,
0.0214348342,
0.0006798501,
-0.0175468586,
-0.0408331938,
-0.0482154191,
-0.0559661202,
-0.0729193464,
0.0283003543,
0.0579325743,
0.0206046496,
-0.0160525069,
0.0299170371,
-0.0552932136,
0.039600756,
0.0278314855,
-0.0267902669,
-0.0421859249,
-0.0272466429,
0.0396213681,
-0.0220826752,
0.0110493088,
-0.0142307077,
0.0076932902,
-0.0218866281,
0.0128555037,
0.0312592238,
0.0364175253,
-0.0069377804,
-0.0095506674,
-0.0062119775,
0.0158318207,
-0.0255178865,
-0.0029453028,
-0.0302676558,
0.0403446108,
-0.011497316,
-0.0277618095,
0.0133729642,
-0.0231967978,
0.039419692,
-0.059301421,
-0.0233687758,
0.028890457,
-0.0341536626,
-0.0541841127,
-0.0414437726,
-0.0348896421,
-0.0036198553,
0.0088136187,
-0.0185695253,
-0.0473309681,
0.0763767287,
-0.005014827,
0.0360943303,
-0.0298469607,
-0.0468669832,
-0.0292506367,
0.056534797,
-0.0086883614,
0.0285582151,
0.0259746853,
-0.0561198145,
-0.0262773708,
0.0259656031,
0.0353338569,
-0.0113604059,
0.0263631009,
-0.0229932461,
-0.011540398,
-0.0008009948,
-0.0572385117,
-0.0017172256,
-0.1290725321,
0.0458048657,
-0.0161575451,
0.012774732,
-0.0792239532,
0.0179039035,
-0.0040743151,
0.0434300117,
0.0592722073,
-0.0175900701,
0.009250422,
-0.0041194265,
0.0055829454,
-0.0313738212,
-0.0771466345,
-0.0121068042,
-0.04288866,
-0.0187000781,
0.0554521345,
0.0536092184,
-0.0054422952,
0.0375841931,
-0.0163403265,
-0.0241868626,
-0.0226565208,
-0.0555190817,
-0.0098713869,
0.0545291975,
-0.0409867354,
-0.0021305543,
0.0323576592,
-0.0264510661,
-0.0906524435,
-0.0076546338,
0.0392603949,
0.0053224224,
-0.0104791271,
-0.0149047738,
-0.0942983404,
0.0157886837,
0.0243985634,
0.0285746939,
-0.0081484839,
-0.0525642112,
-0.0377433859,
-0.0248072986,
-0.0000697864,
0.0078286901,
-0.0215562247,
0.0092305457,
-0.0496536568,
-0.0071960497,
0.0128430137,
-0.042530518,
-0.0269589443,
-0.0019588724,
-0.0424360745,
-0.0094486773,
-0.0188898146,
-0.004625415,
-0.0240572579,
-0.0035698628,
-0.0150870187,
0.0137052704,
0.0257658437,
-0.0156411305,
-0.0163917728,
0.0014951752,
0.0191602986,
-0.0225791391,
0.0186961014,
0.0757023469,
-0.0074955374,
0.0063732201,
-0.02234862,
0.0837662369,
0.0169899166,
0.0007618758,
0.0106091788,
0.020174006,
0.005447878,
-0.0254708193,
0.0091840429,
-0.0050796224,
0.0386194363,
0.0185086969,
-0.0035014306,
-0.0173811652,
-0.0135181397,
-0.0127906511,
0.0040098117,
-0.0120616509,
0.049897179,
0.0122324182,
-0.0498103313,
-0.0552866533,
-0.0403423831,
0.0400239006,
-0.01607267,
0.0254883859,
0.0144261811,
-0.004144147,
0.0036992922,
-0.0399776287,
-0.0412867256,
-0.0030625635,
-0.0668736547,
0.0105244527,
0.0245978888,
0.0085691167,
-0.0203763787,
0.0063050087,
-0.0308440253,
0.0217664465,
-0.0630686209,
-0.0581521355,
0.0352893248,
0.0075602541,
0.0160573199,
-0.0009244922,
-0.0236784406,
-0.0840139836,
0.0960915983,
0.067925103,
-0.0401442125,
0.011216471,
0.0559004098,
-0.0215361584,
0.0108832559,
0.0219818819,
-0.0096412199,
0.0055097472,
0.0613891408,
-0.075339146,
-0.0241815224,
0.0013617211,
-0.0139512895,
0.0551525578,
-0.0096007744,
0.0123793455,
0.0362798013,
-0.0580240339,
0.0501592904,
-0.0228474196,
-0.008652484,
-0.0090100542,
0.0434416085,
0.0508134663,
-0.0036003974,
0.0143928695,
0.0204072315,
0.0422880128,
-0.0299976282,
-0.0647322461,
-0.0112464773,
0.0620146766,
0.0218352489,
0.0372633934,
0.0294009298,
-0.0342425629,
0.0546621941,
0.0178899169,
0.0153535912,
-0.0068341885,
-0.0136200441,
0.0232541002,
0.0470345914,
-0.0382502452,
0.018108042,
-0.0554215014,
-0.0181073975,
-0.0349847265,
0.035908673,
-0.0154690621,
0.0849583298,
-0.022071775,
-0.0174158122,
-0.018920375,
0.0137192011,
0.0257155243,
-0.0202494375,
-0.0374882035,
-0.0216763001,
-0.043894954,
-0.0237498675,
0.0603099838,
0.1058119461,
-0.0106513882,
0.0301760491,
0.0062976624,
-0.0155543406,
-0.0667728111,
-0.0287133902,
0.0440478139,
0.0660840347,
0.0075315293,
-0.043730922,
-0.016553361,
-0.0253644045,
0.0266876128,
-0.0246384833,
0.0114906402,
0.0189161859,
0.0069373534,
-0.009495385,
0.007721588,
-0.0501834005,
-0.043491222,
0.0159265175,
0.0406067967,
-0.0068641114,
0.0028675899,
-5.486096787e-33,
0.0093469983,
0.0110242171,
-0.0300498717,
0.0406336263,
-0.0212858412,
0.0239096619,
0.0131367706,
-0.0374931209,
0.0355885327,
0.0264650639,
-0.07062345,
0.038371902,
-0.002346586,
0.0132674985,
-0.0341107138,
-0.0099808387,
0.0419092886,
-0.0275288541,
-0.0141420681,
0.0375867747,
0.0548255108,
0.0479438975,
0.0388253257,
-0.0389049649,
0.0677062348,
-0.0386494137,
-0.0723718405,
0.010708319,
-0.0566489287,
-0.0121889217,
-0.0263068266,
-0.019521486,
0.0317147709,
0.0422090888,
-0.0471030548,
0.0414542668,
-0.0315484107,
0.0024201011,
-0.0441403463,
-0.0147257876,
0.0159577075,
-0.0220545623,
0.0576550253,
-0.007234585,
0.0062644938,
-0.0142944111,
0.0126117831,
-0.0068074884,
-0.0197155699,
-0.0489847325,
0.017162377,
0.0477981269,
-0.0027566904,
0.0060544126,
0.0429085456,
0.0223274156,
-0.0125598442,
-0.0482852459,
-0.0317751095,
-0.008079675,
0.0349278189,
-0.0136062596,
-0.0059331656,
-0.0435253941,
0.0214599986,
0.0245120469,
0.0259514917,
0.0501592793,
0.0016835778,
-0.0413208753,
-0.0134525383,
0.0228549689,
0.0200668518,
0.0503526144,
0.02536311,
-0.0207857527,
-0.0513277613,
0.0260157753,
-0.0454353206,
-0.0170155838,
0.0493868962,
0.056459114,
-0.0530432835,
-0.0253682975,
-0.0301428251,
0.0106355017,
-0.0034741438,
0.0102767237,
-0.030036699,
0.034355972,
-0.0364886373,
0.0202866495,
-0.0006921025,
-0.0589816719,
-0.0107203247,
0.0052531767,
0.0464497395,
0.0026656487,
0.010307733,
-0.0397177152,
-0.0451894663,
0.0144677302,
0.0001294968,
-0.0050375811,
0.0170442183,
0.0027083487,
0.0720118657,
0.015964739,
-0.0644437522,
-0.0100043789,
-0.0195965674,
0.0455056243,
0.0523801744,
0.0845357105,
0.019458767,
-0.0279113427,
0.0079613067,
0.0371932909,
0.0247869361,
0.0449345522,
-0.0188329667,
0.0406490453,
0.0279005896,
0.0062939594,
0.0375153981,
-0.0181823559,
0.0227240622,
0.0043372479,
0.0975014865,
-0.0090667559,
0.0055490849,
-0.0322750472,
2.656e-7,
0.004354286,
-0.0033439398,
0.0431482531,
-0.0422803238,
0.0040296651,
0.0369597636,
0.0393799357,
0.0558061711,
-0.0605442002,
0.0319641605,
0.0082266694,
-0.022671083,
0.0444817133,
0.0262968391,
-0.0843307003,
-0.0245703496,
-0.0561551116,
-0.0053015877,
-0.0344122872,
-0.0091527691,
-0.0121203521,
0.0349854827,
0.0667611659,
-0.0152185922,
0.0167488623,
-0.0380505063,
0.0219806805,
-0.0378176421,
-0.0120079294,
0.0213852543,
0.0236838087,
0.0330379643,
0.030807972,
-0.018005427,
-0.0283435117,
0.0227050297,
-0.0297489911,
0.1222911999,
0.0203765146,
0.0370150581,
0.0209158584,
-0.0112344269,
-0.0472190566,
-0.0371835642,
0.0050494852,
-0.0080302572,
-0.0282069277,
-0.0145699354,
0.0139762089,
-0.0840272009,
0.0877206475,
-0.0133064324,
0.0335295983,
0.0306468289,
-0.0097557604,
0.0469324663,
0.0015951996,
-0.1093709692,
-0.0200177282,
-0.0362696424,
-0.0331540294,
0.0414775759,
0.0180943366,
0.0308100116,
0.0163418129,
-0.04982334,
0.0415140912,
2.581997219e-34,
-0.0098154889,
-0.0111440513,
-0.0440792069,
0.0113925645,
0.0084093222,
-0.0070017711,
0.0471950322,
0.0189523641,
0.0310818758,
-0.0454921536,
-0.025375342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07588v1 | Word class representations spontaneously emerge in a deep neural network trained on next word prediction | 2023-02-15T11:02:50 | 2023-02-15T11:02:50 | Kishore Surendra, Achim Schilling, Paul Stoewer, Andreas Maier, Patrick Krauss | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC | How do humans learn language, and can the first language be learned at all?
These fundamental questions are still hotly debated. In contemporary
linguistics, there are two major schools of thought that give completely
opposite answers. According to Chomsky's theory of universal grammar, language
cannot be learned because children are not exposed to sufficient data in their
linguistic environment. In contrast, usage-based models of language assume a
profound relationship between language structure and language use. In
particular, contextual mental processing and mental representations are assumed
to have the cognitive capacity to capture the complexity of actual language use
at all levels. The prime example is syntax, i.e., the rules by which words are
assembled into larger units such as sentences. Typically, syntactic rules are
expressed as sequences of word classes. However, it remains unclear whether
word classes are innate, as implied by universal grammar, or whether they
emerge during language acquisition, as suggested by usage-based approaches.
Here, we address this issue from a machine learning and natural language
processing perspective. In particular, we trained an artificial deep neural
network on predicting the next word, provided sequences of consecutive words as
input. Subsequently, we analyzed the emerging activation patterns in the hidden
layers of the neural network. Strikingly, we find that the internal
representations of nine-word input sequences cluster according to the word
class of the tenth word to be predicted as output, even though the neural
network did not receive any explicit information about syntactic rules or word
classes during training. This surprising result suggests, that also in the
human brain, abstract representational categories such as word classes may
naturally emerge as a consequence of predictive coding and processing during
language acquisition. | [
-0.002778973,
0.0668046549,
-0.047236491,
0.01323344,
-0.0257901736,
0.026671296,
-0.0339531526,
-0.0042800852,
-0.0122699477,
-0.0370245427,
0.0210228395,
-0.0596556552,
0.0229464006,
0.0197527111,
0.0485488847,
-0.0225880668,
0.057606779,
-0.0373664051,
-0.0000437255,
0.019913232,
-0.0235548839,
-0.0266417544,
-0.00766544,
0.02395132,
-0.0381718203,
-0.0128839444,
-0.0281143971,
-0.0960862264,
-0.0800454766,
-0.0305823516,
0.0323981978,
0.0592856519,
0.0422373004,
0.0825208724,
0.0000017625,
-0.0529472642,
0.0437375344,
-0.0352423601,
-0.0483483449,
-0.0029183952,
-0.0054119597,
-0.0154943839,
0.0014263454,
-0.0448750965,
-0.0517649129,
-0.0171908904,
0.0330725051,
0.0172678232,
-0.0338223018,
0.0191076845,
-0.0032085658,
-0.0755926743,
0.0224334765,
-0.0101898219,
0.0239562131,
0.0182004459,
0.0320807919,
-0.0244323537,
-0.0174857918,
-0.0348231457,
-0.0359433666,
-0.0046956073,
0.0430370755,
0.0380417407,
0.0014398266,
0.0658620372,
0.0008874178,
-0.0340375938,
-0.0094620688,
0.0217530597,
-0.0272447132,
-0.0519600511,
0.0024207775,
0.017332254,
0.0189469475,
-0.0320903435,
-0.0098791057,
0.0590181388,
0.0311027877,
0.049252484,
0.0566502251,
-0.014347137,
0.0113528883,
0.0052610831,
0.0004926551,
0.0625950396,
-0.0161829498,
-0.0207617395,
0.0204378013,
0.0326097347,
0.0001568262,
-0.0640446097,
0.0244511515,
-0.0137036145,
0.0148478169,
0.0296180937,
-0.0095362486,
-0.0059687616,
0.0086204018,
-0.0506296232,
0.0373573527,
0.0178183131,
-0.0124213099,
-0.0002891582,
-0.0243631583,
0.0114127873,
0.0071242554,
0.0092787845,
-0.0339067057,
0.0503512509,
-0.0486288257,
-0.0468825214,
-0.0001758924,
0.0478797704,
0.0214014128,
-0.0158251226,
-0.0274672899,
-0.003351615,
0.0119303977,
-0.0232180767,
-0.052317135,
0.023450695,
-0.0358679555,
0.0537661538,
-0.066961579,
-0.0355603732,
-0.0218122136,
0.0342612192,
-0.0054261829,
-0.0292252917,
0.0089913299,
0.0080689257,
-0.0141889043,
0.0152026368,
-0.0194214713,
0.0434320234,
-0.0383837707,
-0.0459874906,
-0.0378802381,
-0.0389028415,
-0.0248942841,
0.0058390801,
0.0490778238,
-0.0440335609,
-0.040233992,
0.0081350002,
-0.0264585912,
-0.039347697,
0.011122426,
0.021303758,
-0.0240317155,
0.0697906092,
-0.0164604299,
0.0042457427,
0.0145558529,
0.0137302531,
0.0496048331,
0.013449721,
0.0142645566,
0.0004194455,
0.0100594042,
-0.0504088514,
0.013169162,
0.0002720118,
-0.013555916,
-0.0592103191,
-0.0585894845,
-0.0522850789,
-0.0183976162,
0.0470595211,
0.0173954032,
0.0145846503,
-0.0100646643,
-0.0399738848,
0.0177340694,
0.0697413683,
0.0040234132,
0.0602454022,
0.0650881156,
-0.0244007222,
-0.0011899078,
0.0640733019,
-0.0270060617,
-0.0170227382,
-0.0126022473,
-0.0074933344,
-0.0303453766,
-0.0200394429,
-0.0074461377,
-0.03564509,
-0.0016822928,
-0.0050552599,
0.0458150283,
-0.0263944734,
0.0233748481,
0.0465022959,
-0.027139876,
0.0345228463,
0.0461849235,
-0.0076781027,
0.0082837977,
-0.0276294947,
0.0310393702,
0.0198871177,
-0.0162621625,
-0.0162074119,
-0.0029278176,
0.0224693846,
-0.0194543768,
0.0618798956,
0.0169462897,
-0.003684432,
0.0027778135,
-0.0167053621,
0.0155327739,
0.0407624058,
0.0075408625,
0.0320686884,
-0.0690127537,
-0.0413556211,
-0.0152480155,
0.0175818205,
-0.0734211877,
0.0638375878,
-0.0191237256,
-0.0509064794,
-0.0089286538,
0.0110303555,
0.0425854661,
-0.0223757587,
0.0041447552,
0.0427824892,
0.0508813709,
-0.0365629084,
-0.0094175031,
-0.0155171156,
-0.1095658913,
-0.0270440858,
0.013819146,
-0.0220319889,
0.0159995686,
0.0116124321,
0.0239126198,
-0.0218567718,
0.0518978573,
-0.0729569793,
0.0775520727,
-0.0364505351,
0.0150209833,
-0.0170486551,
0.0564634986,
-0.0231512506,
0.0613605715,
-0.0077505335,
0.0272203647,
-0.0132202534,
-0.0286083929,
-0.0065773609,
0.0220970605,
0.0013999755,
0.0081399037,
-0.0281984173,
-0.0174997933,
0.0071084541,
-0.0121008959,
-0.0720571354,
0.0170364752,
-0.0465010814,
-0.0347085185,
0.0228387304,
0.030687822,
-0.0163840447,
-0.0645429716,
0.0195306651,
-0.0288644973,
-0.0250132587,
0.0466025583,
0.0064131808,
0.0367669389,
0.0518601127,
-0.0096099572,
-0.0647026524,
-0.0362487435,
-0.0218391642,
-0.0629576445,
0.0607677363,
0.0012524116,
-0.007359772,
-0.0277288016,
0.002119798,
-0.003120312,
0.0357165299,
0.0031968048,
-0.0720233768,
0.0559745058,
-0.0028378607,
0.0141946254,
0.0411620885,
0.0122177703,
0.0537126437,
0.0472718291,
-0.0010160865,
-0.0125086885,
-0.0384740122,
-0.0502818599,
0.0087159909,
-0.025540242,
0.0150453812,
-0.0318789817,
0.148122862,
0.0457977615,
-0.0167740434,
-0.0019786078,
0.0381243713,
-0.017925771,
-0.009426876,
-0.0142850829,
-0.0673179254,
-0.0676911846,
0.0517091937,
-0.0137440087,
-0.0301587153,
0.0461889096,
0.0123521341,
-0.0191100556,
-0.035576839,
-0.0183628704,
0.0182797499,
0.0512506925,
0.095810242,
-0.0157893989,
0.0249119196,
-0.0442660637,
-0.0709480122,
0.004387965,
-0.0138624702,
-0.0006090144,
0.0107340449,
-0.0488961786,
-0.0229384769,
0.050314527,
-0.001391773,
-0.0781606883,
-0.0109969657,
-0.031895604,
0.0310399011,
-0.0096176881,
0.0297099948,
0.0152787678,
-0.0357089117,
-0.0048919572,
0.0411464274,
0.010683639,
-0.0139339725,
-0.0416585356,
0.0538833812,
-0.0130668599,
0.0030752027,
0.0254312623,
0.008123802,
0.0150839128,
0.0339144245,
-0.005857266,
0.0864318013,
-0.0411564298,
0.0466971546,
0.041907303,
-0.0275531895,
-0.0681800097,
0.0544646308,
-0.0425484329,
-0.0503398888,
-0.0170429181,
0.07391949,
0.0410271138,
-0.0395009592,
0.0720741525,
0.0009601109,
0.0092472797,
0.0402477533,
0.0256184805,
-0.0304158945,
-0.0093457475,
0.012922042,
-0.0374952443,
-0.0326258019,
-0.0323037729,
0.0298352633,
-0.0614304021,
-0.0228601452,
0.0011304216,
-0.0746097714,
0.0176136289,
-0.0140799377,
-0.0075150421,
0.0599558465,
-0.0011869651,
0.0167893525,
-0.0029136736,
0.0086676544,
0.038076207,
-0.049059242,
-0.0084982654,
0.0159842428,
-0.0046037859,
0.0314542055,
0.0648496225,
0.0210217796,
-0.0679781958,
-0.0320552811,
0.0801818296,
-0.0703793168,
0.0047542336,
0.0028588071,
0.0259248912,
0.0421221294,
-0.0015265543,
-0.0340448171,
0.041217871,
-0.0544918329,
-0.0372067392,
-0.0122370292,
0.0971886218,
-0.0030936762,
-0.0747246891,
0.0046941764,
0.0188779384,
-0.0192385353,
0.0454251878,
0.0531849489,
-0.0647249669,
-0.0055117086,
-0.0317605883,
0.0567588732,
0.0049643568,
-0.0525783636,
0.052414313,
0.0034129398,
-0.033073552,
-0.0692599043,
-0.0463792868,
0.0038929377,
-0.0007257217,
0.0324653611,
-0.0268535055,
0.0201813709,
-0.0330722108,
-0.0450625457,
-0.0076511973,
0.0457259789,
-0.0503364988,
-0.0382540375,
-0.0577023923,
-0.0027722719,
-0.0334584303,
-0.0286771748,
-0.0236442387,
0.0152528398,
-0.0490835644,
0.0614441372,
0.0117455209,
0.0105972197,
-0.0045337989,
0.0465930626,
-0.0740930811,
0.0521354899,
0.0373913832,
-0.0273226649,
0.0132972803,
-0.021929672,
-0.0171136931,
0.0085756537,
0.0185388811,
0.0103937704,
0.0387689322,
-0.0095729288,
-0.0142456749,
-0.0382016003,
0.0041590622,
0.051436279,
-0.0066320086,
0.0636504367,
-0.0101155667,
-0.0063618594,
-0.0392650664,
-0.0411663838,
0.0081537385,
-0.0066560572,
0.0109952921,
-0.0112343114,
0.0225322563,
0.0577781275,
-0.0140538728,
-0.0291788261,
-0.0088855177,
0.022942597,
0.010580291,
-0.0072105499,
0.0748932883,
0.0338360779,
0.0026947821,
0.0454875082,
0.0224072021,
0.0377028622,
-0.0626123026,
0.0248281788,
-0.0261838287,
0.0258936621,
0.0069772736,
0.0442383066,
-0.0140456315,
-0.0240835473,
-0.0436081998,
0.019184377,
-0.0027761001,
-0.0074458434,
0.0310235042,
-0.0736620203,
-0.0217621792,
-0.0563530512,
0.026601335,
-0.0134426691,
0.000867845,
-0.0582918078,
-0.0495278947,
0.01102746,
0.034661945,
-0.0309902318,
-0.0206739567,
0.0655720755,
-0.0067818803,
0.0287674572,
0.0142831318,
-0.0059130886,
-0.0157981347,
0.0286014844,
0.0615605935,
0.0599090047,
-0.0146043114,
0.0403381698,
0.004261191,
-0.045262102,
0.0073620337,
0.0277215447,
0.0490605868,
-0.0128577696,
0.0435632057,
0.0493137836,
-0.0217329469,
-0.006763265,
-0.0134768793,
0.0323043019,
-0.0060162125,
-0.0049519017,
0.0095402803,
-5.897386832e-33,
-0.0072208783,
-0.0524882227,
-0.0150665641,
0.0509236977,
-0.0082303872,
-0.0031121778,
-0.0198840071,
0.0443014614,
0.0238186922,
0.0450154543,
0.0008924787,
0.005382502,
-0.0024062928,
0.025963679,
0.0972169042,
-0.015021963,
-0.0094379494,
-0.0668759644,
0.0438700654,
-0.0151312724,
0.0483611412,
0.0381163545,
0.0769477487,
-0.0241235942,
0.0023865532,
0.0175876562,
0.0484115817,
0.0178512111,
-0.0229937062,
0.0289353933,
-0.0605212003,
0.0476670153,
0.0401464775,
-0.0060750572,
-0.0062058675,
0.0264497679,
-0.0140250372,
-0.0618801042,
0.0034427205,
0.0175118707,
-0.0478886627,
-0.0296143871,
0.0833711252,
-0.0494190417,
-0.0201968476,
0.0466770828,
0.0480128601,
0.0057801176,
-0.0227125082,
0.0065137399,
-0.0798433721,
-0.0290921964,
-0.0147045916,
-0.0045396863,
0.0380322859,
-0.0092264125,
-0.0116998181,
-0.035700541,
-0.0625547692,
0.0314829983,
-0.0178544614,
0.0580579303,
0.0129367458,
0.0367315933,
0.0283508319,
0.0671270564,
0.1055626869,
-0.0033678464,
-0.0167745277,
0.0301704351,
0.0728782788,
0.0131347319,
-0.0051963613,
-0.0072621764,
0.0772415847,
-0.0405645594,
-0.0028022374,
-0.0571885593,
0.0538054556,
-0.0011177089,
-0.0130459676,
-0.0202360023,
-0.0012882975,
-0.0395279452,
-0.007882461,
-0.0684981048,
-0.0224909764,
0.0003308187,
0.0111864284,
-0.0199375153,
0.0380794965,
-0.0171947144,
-0.0105024418,
-0.0309778061,
-0.00030589,
-0.0282450598,
-0.0151806045,
-0.0178460386,
0.0360928252,
0.0186299533,
-0.0505129471,
-0.0770948604,
-0.0369149335,
-0.0238049962,
0.0437590033,
0.0560474806,
0.0209612716,
0.0016074216,
0.0059992089,
-0.0196723752,
-0.0091628646,
-0.0579943582,
0.058738336,
-0.0129460217,
0.0342082717,
0.0191825405,
-0.0202340763,
-0.0053009,
0.0407436863,
-0.0169347432,
-0.0317550525,
0.0159394424,
-0.0427662283,
0.0416563973,
-0.0389314294,
-0.0636045858,
-0.0303004645,
0.0306627415,
0.0742283836,
-0.0389493518,
-0.0018764033,
-0.0018953264,
2.61e-7,
0.0132094678,
0.0729383752,
-0.0016765413,
-0.0090849614,
0.0602801889,
0.0204640441,
0.0007891416,
0.0016326513,
-0.01214258,
-0.0345064811,
-0.0100925043,
-0.0070028938,
0.0060291556,
0.0279561616,
-0.031143833,
-0.0175082423,
-0.0115440153,
0.0557891876,
-0.0305432808,
0.0260646567,
0.0374328382,
0.0717709363,
-0.0071724583,
-0.0343959928,
-0.0356271081,
-0.0329935886,
0.0112553379,
-0.0039471895,
0.0362364464,
-0.0121638626,
-0.0159384254,
-0.0134367961,
0.0031721063,
0.0590033978,
0.0105785066,
0.0173859764,
0.0052086185,
-0.0256164782,
-0.0081958855,
0.0179953109,
0.0215517376,
0.0234789755,
-0.0198315121,
-0.0148823904,
0.004417988,
-0.0782722458,
-0.0306950714,
0.0143889356,
-0.0046952558,
-0.00942316,
-0.0012456569,
0.0465981178,
0.0006621913,
-0.0050676791,
0.005398198,
-0.0152999312,
-0.0021559903,
-0.0322767943,
0.0102146361,
0.0433053486,
-0.063990362,
0.0186633412,
-0.0356683061,
-0.0190321263,
0.0444977805,
-0.0107907169,
0.0037512165,
1.976169012e-34,
-0.024170218,
-0.0206392352,
0.0514855869,
-0.0123016052,
0.0302309468,
-0.0374978036,
0.045200672,
0.0501465648,
0.0449624583,
-0.076641582,
-0.0256839357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07492v1 | Envisioning the Next-Gen Document Reader | 2023-02-15T06:43:12 | 2023-02-15T06:43:12 | Catherine Yeh, Nedim Lipka, Franck Dernoncourt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | People read digital documents on a daily basis to share, exchange, and
understand information in electronic settings. However, current document
readers create a static, isolated reading experience, which does not support
users' goals of gaining more knowledge and performing additional tasks through
document interaction. In this work, we present our vision for the next-gen
document reader that strives to enhance user understanding and create a more
connected, trustworthy information experience. We describe 18 NLP-powered
features to add to existing document readers and propose a novel plug-in
marketplace that allows users to further customize their reading experience, as
demonstrated through 3 exploratory UI prototypes available at
https://github.com/catherinesyeh/nextgen-prototypes | [
0.0445748456,
0.0090737119,
-0.0110334419,
0.0291840956,
-0.0178873595,
0.0058098137,
0.0249206182,
0.0373664387,
0.0748268291,
0.0038410448,
-0.0553782918,
0.0550053753,
0.0061023426,
0.0590493456,
-0.0102877663,
-0.0661013946,
0.0318653323,
-0.0277078114,
0.0169371087,
0.0278797094,
0.0575891063,
0.0448224097,
-0.0493986867,
-0.0012163327,
-0.0017146643,
-0.0474024825,
-0.0277244356,
-0.0198499821,
-0.0163293872,
-0.0561055243,
-0.0158711392,
0.0413594395,
-0.0344298854,
0.0453708246,
0.0000020468,
-0.0180378575,
-0.0041912012,
0.0119323069,
-0.0255532153,
-0.007627008,
0.0781559423,
-0.021367617,
0.0291633587,
0.0052700005,
-0.0050153434,
-0.0087367343,
0.0076777018,
0.0710005835,
-0.0079311971,
0.0045301742,
-0.0073076808,
0.0005253307,
0.0191118401,
-0.0023677947,
0.0726670548,
-0.0291673858,
-0.0665355474,
0.0136790723,
0.0569327995,
0.0299990866,
0.0122438883,
0.0328584425,
-0.0251442008,
-0.0295635052,
0.0362754278,
0.0663519949,
0.0199817102,
-0.0455310456,
-0.0769835413,
0.0555459782,
0.0072536976,
0.0089978427,
-0.0163649134,
-0.0282401033,
-0.0107944161,
0.0520677418,
-0.051613424,
-0.0431828573,
-0.0457497761,
-0.0343718044,
-0.0075291037,
0.0323163979,
0.0185526256,
0.0322987325,
0.0375849232,
0.0578778721,
0.0051470897,
-0.0274919067,
0.0323502496,
0.0188686159,
0.0554552898,
0.0007051649,
0.0586049259,
0.0300154444,
0.0480240993,
0.0047851596,
-0.0230111834,
-0.0475050211,
0.0524311773,
-0.0066167102,
0.0324746519,
0.0124728754,
-0.0075198142,
0.0625118241,
-0.0004280582,
-0.024302667,
0.0058265403,
-0.008450225,
0.0060474384,
0.0294594057,
0.0315124504,
-0.0094924476,
-0.0036201081,
0.0156758241,
-0.0996380001,
-0.0732880309,
0.048764471,
0.0356756113,
0.0729966089,
0.0374391936,
-0.0111587998,
0.0103119193,
-0.0437000692,
-0.0434134603,
-0.0141799748,
0.0095711807,
-0.0550839826,
-0.0245541893,
-0.0127604799,
-0.012610334,
0.0238096491,
0.0009855371,
0.0168223456,
-0.0146712363,
-0.047231447,
0.0434145965,
0.0036652549,
-0.0251683816,
-0.0337878056,
-0.0350308195,
0.0047638952,
0.0007983394,
-0.0538221225,
-0.0232447665,
0.0217220504,
0.0591104664,
0.0110415276,
-0.0445290729,
-0.0023482251,
0.020362461,
-0.0205937177,
0.0473455302,
-0.0671387985,
-0.0225086063,
0.0681332424,
0.0439855941,
-0.0374699496,
0.0199387837,
0.0031244722,
0.0221840609,
0.0592147484,
0.0022372438,
0.0042750556,
0.0386711508,
-0.0604664832,
-0.0502412468,
0.0811680257,
-0.038220033,
-0.0522902571,
-0.0047647674,
-0.03217794,
-0.0090747969,
-0.0325398333,
-0.0030591087,
0.055012159,
0.0805080384,
0.0674089268,
0.0227265395,
-0.0631511062,
0.0556407087,
0.027201632,
-0.0099341702,
-0.0153440908,
0.0598794632,
0.0073615541,
0.0439185873,
-0.0357922316,
0.005538126,
0.0334194191,
-0.0257900674,
-0.0019541713,
0.0085043302,
0.0360101536,
-0.0386875346,
0.0178276282,
0.0164108966,
-0.0237846822,
0.0002638428,
0.0076944432,
-0.0578791201,
-0.0180428065,
0.0015318498,
0.0355134122,
0.1136995554,
0.0781629235,
-0.0139063103,
-0.0120447613,
-0.0308867525,
-0.0313391462,
0.0587360151,
0.0481027924,
-0.0128539624,
0.029834507,
-0.0698456541,
-0.0133128939,
-0.0152710667,
-0.0063593467,
0.0216180123,
-0.0138131743,
0.0441696122,
0.0368096381,
-0.0311836377,
-0.0274277776,
0.045284573,
0.0012493137,
-0.0345532447,
-0.0272642486,
0.0319560431,
-0.0192933921,
0.0361160822,
0.0069240746,
-0.0026953337,
0.023914801,
0.0261987671,
0.0334038287,
0.0323072076,
0.0186541118,
0.0426491648,
-0.0009972769,
-0.0208151005,
0.0232501514,
-0.0178834274,
0.0131926769,
-0.0053187804,
-0.0236510541,
0.0004037304,
0.0426642001,
-0.0431662388,
0.0016734774,
0.0012841144,
0.0091745453,
-0.0037322801,
0.0172239374,
0.0004233432,
-0.0207006373,
0.0277360491,
0.0178434234,
-0.0355647244,
0.0095245754,
-0.0230845269,
0.0161261298,
0.0164547097,
-0.0159064885,
0.0319446102,
0.0163196269,
-0.0464012474,
-0.0144763403,
-0.0375054628,
-0.0110442648,
0.0115889888,
0.0602446981,
0.0204482228,
0.0415965915,
-0.0448088534,
-0.0368148871,
-0.002655369,
0.0119400918,
-0.0052988804,
-0.0318528116,
0.0442369729,
0.0058395504,
0.0374858789,
-0.0068604564,
0.0093259849,
-0.0000020732,
0.0345827602,
0.0491501577,
-0.0629440099,
-0.0689472333,
-0.0342308022,
0.0549266338,
-0.0229631606,
0.028574327,
0.049808871,
0.000260134,
0.0002907983,
0.0158570409,
0.0597717725,
-0.013145512,
0.0739446506,
-0.012026309,
-0.0419444703,
-0.0592382737,
0.0329201818,
0.0067614205,
0.0296983421,
0.0103350598,
-0.0005842875,
0.0535187311,
0.0258724298,
-0.0334336869,
0.0235183295,
0.006039029,
0.0106916958,
-0.0084105581,
-0.0440701731,
-0.0312771425,
-0.0341115631,
-0.0160169825,
0.0251066163,
-0.0259679668,
-0.0276991501,
0.0270967893,
-0.0411259085,
-0.0063636079,
-0.0761695579,
0.0058787088,
-0.0024998451,
0.078977108,
-0.0353352427,
0.0085508516,
-0.0074297478,
-0.0728696734,
0.0139086051,
0.0303001367,
0.0294170324,
-0.0052306997,
0.0164318457,
-0.0356439278,
-0.0252418276,
0.0019087041,
0.0065788631,
-0.0032970656,
0.0107191205,
-0.0356586464,
-0.0897431523,
0.0063832887,
-0.0262061357,
-0.0608994812,
0.008808475,
0.0090143317,
0.0555227138,
-0.0221441053,
-0.0216523092,
0.0071820165,
0.0282312147,
0.012791601,
-0.0232565627,
-0.0115967281,
-0.0118550174,
-0.0056876671,
0.0814795867,
-0.0486381128,
-0.0300000273,
0.0221954174,
-0.0098507078,
0.0162949637,
-0.0851821154,
-0.0210289285,
-0.0389326923,
0.001848206,
-0.0893119127,
0.0103720743,
0.0782808214,
0.0642348826,
-0.0675090924,
-0.0451055355,
-0.0390593112,
0.0071343454,
-0.0195452701,
0.0285510235,
-0.0962887853,
-0.0385177955,
0.0125193261,
0.0278680082,
0.0215220414,
-0.0087776873,
-0.0043225526,
-0.0313884765,
-0.0042852079,
0.0009529478,
0.0348644108,
-0.0036411928,
-0.0446813442,
0.0102955271,
0.024191102,
-0.0068375035,
0.0283292718,
-0.0288664233,
-0.011794447,
-0.0345121995,
-0.0011588146,
0.062987268,
-0.0456534177,
0.0209240075,
-0.0240766425,
0.0724419281,
0.040585354,
0.0415155515,
-0.0129234409,
-0.0179748926,
-0.0235584248,
0.0210224781,
-0.0371497236,
0.0792597383,
-0.0222635698,
0.0583659112,
-0.0774565041,
0.0499868505,
0.0170566402,
-0.0347163305,
0.0192854945,
-0.0287252814,
-0.0063450071,
-0.0128838373,
-0.0644099638,
-0.0102934903,
0.016787637,
0.016740635,
0.0008256664,
-0.0379505865,
-0.0419760458,
-0.0637115017,
0.0178742763,
-0.0330952778,
-0.0239174906,
0.0179873463,
0.0057535116,
-0.0414456651,
-0.0764903128,
-0.0616254658,
0.0182809234,
-0.0148760574,
0.0483022891,
-0.0232876278,
0.0015874221,
-0.0159936845,
-0.0378076769,
-0.0114723053,
0.0086590694,
0.0106755337,
-0.0147225894,
0.0139074652,
0.0220581647,
-0.0134488819,
0.0068203337,
0.0511046313,
-0.0564181283,
-0.0277237892,
-0.0393298902,
-0.0103130471,
0.0194790829,
0.0371970311,
-0.0584314726,
-0.0372213535,
0.0432397798,
0.0364053771,
-0.0836172551,
-0.0649000034,
-0.0171277467,
0.0199537612,
-0.0116799874,
-0.0039302837,
-0.0178347621,
-0.0425406359,
-0.0289304089,
-0.0353062078,
0.0003819771,
-0.0533931591,
-0.0026264074,
0.0400940552,
-0.0275036357,
0.0083093541,
0.0789382085,
-0.0475531928,
0.020462703,
-0.0107651893,
0.0091006681,
0.008142692,
0.0291879345,
0.0020438037,
-0.0310497899,
0.0034420211,
0.0419421904,
0.0255075581,
0.0163314678,
-0.0584018826,
0.0522287078,
0.0236881487,
0.0033070038,
-0.0141839907,
-0.0151384315,
-0.0311211701,
0.0399248898,
-0.0283257384,
0.0712589547,
0.0080616558,
0.0717895105,
-0.0041168402,
-0.0772859231,
-0.0107431766,
0.0194748342,
-0.0586465672,
-0.015152513,
-0.0130089428,
0.0424627326,
-0.0286223181,
-0.0219236333,
0.044168774,
-0.0562187918,
-0.0010959954,
0.0243628714,
0.0091151688,
0.0370203815,
-0.0141985752,
-0.0537264943,
0.0254961234,
0.0339660905,
-0.0098005626,
0.0660879835,
-0.0762209147,
-0.0184500627,
0.0069982326,
-0.0237805452,
-0.0601648986,
0.0177985784,
-0.0014320281,
0.0519071445,
-0.0393070057,
0.0012124045,
-0.0516265221,
0.0032755889,
0.0419815928,
-0.0090898192,
0.0174911749,
0.0225747861,
0.0341817327,
0.0405544154,
-0.0192179568,
-0.0613935925,
-0.0225164276,
0.0197316799,
-0.0463246927,
-0.0004797894,
-0.0523103178,
-5.747907665e-33,
0.0240522306,
-0.0514818877,
-0.0289836377,
0.0450458489,
0.0477233343,
-0.0180447903,
0.0008663979,
-0.0106280027,
0.0300296452,
-0.0098718815,
-0.0495389812,
-0.0088097984,
0.0293385237,
0.0150852222,
-0.0195676852,
0.0268759038,
0.0623189844,
0.0275967326,
0.0045524887,
0.0379720181,
0.0558491535,
0.0296788756,
0.0320951417,
-0.0951000974,
0.062306419,
0.0151788527,
-0.0268982947,
-0.0248860382,
0.062947683,
0.0164740849,
-0.0065557132,
0.0140788238,
0.0134616317,
-0.0261269286,
0.0013506112,
0.0920569301,
-0.1130312011,
-0.0116348518,
-0.0094370395,
0.0688023865,
-0.0141459145,
-0.0285246149,
0.0270109065,
-0.0042635649,
0.0255469792,
0.0034635488,
0.0186369196,
-0.0200782288,
-0.0294658821,
-0.0285924394,
-0.0667405352,
0.0584576838,
-0.0201717392,
0.0152068101,
0.0160770658,
0.0258790199,
0.0232831966,
-0.0316688307,
-0.113594301,
0.00225501,
0.0002054749,
0.0155876596,
0.0496110991,
-0.0129848765,
-0.0190669056,
0.0379423574,
-0.0038988458,
-0.040664658,
-0.0073008472,
0.0574893504,
0.0153992027,
0.0046480768,
0.0223950148,
0.029516574,
0.035410706,
-0.0633531958,
0.0080032814,
0.0784047693,
0.0238825884,
0.0436495431,
0.0071236561,
0.0230990313,
-0.0377900749,
0.0420560203,
-0.0037851003,
-0.0424218848,
-0.0355363563,
-0.0816798881,
0.0005133344,
-0.0148652261,
-0.0301779471,
-0.0167702902,
-0.0382621437,
0.0212672688,
-0.0271993745,
0.0073846788,
-0.0068435348,
0.0369352773,
-0.0598333627,
-0.0297694001,
0.0128426841,
0.0039099352,
-0.0405669585,
0.0067395931,
-0.0213228911,
-0.0068719392,
0.0065612975,
-0.0325703174,
-0.0765526891,
-0.0186615866,
0.0259124245,
0.0276188795,
0.0399798527,
0.0086891185,
0.0366549678,
-0.046125669,
-0.0618366562,
0.0434035845,
-0.0127356965,
0.0177095179,
-0.0359675921,
-0.0421364568,
0.014621662,
0.0121550569,
-0.0004013434,
-0.0093115252,
-0.0266589355,
-0.0227286201,
0.045747146,
-0.0378961973,
0.0028553868,
0.023565365,
2.569e-7,
0.0295280777,
0.0371479653,
0.0309526268,
-0.0041821469,
-0.007022114,
0.0114448722,
0.0400421768,
0.0363854952,
-0.0078173894,
-0.0262331534,
-0.0103209568,
0.000428642,
0.0430920124,
0.0370295346,
-0.1261600554,
-0.076320529,
0.0001058686,
0.031851653,
-0.0633833632,
0.0253505465,
0.0606813207,
0.0048967926,
-0.0127065955,
0.0103115123,
0.0527721196,
-0.0731264204,
-0.0089121228,
-0.0034329027,
0.0195015855,
-0.0110628959,
0.0629643649,
-0.015016472,
-0.0152757205,
0.0026934268,
-0.0296793077,
-0.0162389241,
0.0044840975,
0.0414802283,
0.0059399977,
0.0093507795,
0.0142746875,
-0.0188568793,
0.0194066055,
-0.0355399176,
0.0322877504,
0.0118081495,
-0.0304205548,
0.0048633693,
-0.0356930979,
-0.0161883421,
-0.0244471822,
-0.0191097669,
-0.0414994024,
0.0421526544,
-0.0001115768,
-0.0439216942,
-0.0424041227,
-0.0515682958,
-0.0220276881,
-0.006350542,
0.0282944739,
0.0142988972,
-0.0465842113,
-0.0222589243,
-0.0082596131,
-0.0299483649,
-0.0152506232,
1.843645569e-34,
-0.0300766472,
0.006173261,
0.0027655414,
0.0411311276,
0.0703495666,
0.008084056,
0.0340634026,
0.010740093,
0.0333003327,
-0.0373806283,
-0.0097764358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09068v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09068v1 | A Pilot Evaluation of ChatGPT and DALL-E 2 on Decision Making and Spatial Reasoning | 2023-02-15T05:04:49 | 2023-02-15T05:04:49 | Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We conduct a pilot study selectively evaluating the cognitive abilities
(decision making and spatial reasoning) of two recently released generative
transformer models, ChatGPT and DALL-E 2. Input prompts were constructed
following neutral a priori guidelines, rather than adversarial intent. Post hoc
qualitative analysis of the outputs shows that DALL-E 2 is able to generate at
least one correct image for each spatial reasoning prompt, but most images
generated are incorrect (even though the model seems to have a clear
understanding of the objects mentioned in the prompt). Similarly, in evaluating
ChatGPT on the rationality axioms developed under the classical Von
Neumann-Morgenstern utility theorem, we find that, although it demonstrates
some level of rational decision-making, many of its decisions violate at least
one of the axioms even under reasonable constructions of preferences, bets, and
decision-making prompts. ChatGPT's outputs on such problems generally tended to
be unpredictable: even as it made irrational decisions (or employed an
incorrect reasoning process) for some simpler decision-making problems, it was
able to draw correct conclusions for more complex bet structures. We briefly
comment on the nuances and challenges involved in scaling up such a 'cognitive'
evaluation or conducting it with a closed set of answer keys ('ground truth'),
given that these models are inherently generative and open-ended in responding
to prompts. | [
0.0017878186,
0.0824304968,
-0.0226213001,
-0.0196685903,
-0.0741477758,
0.0085499892,
0.0417479277,
0.000275243,
0.0129908947,
0.0045434148,
-0.0331347696,
0.0027040758,
0.0212737005,
0.0223621428,
0.0489156283,
-0.0606886446,
0.0050201393,
-0.0066683409,
-0.0097005982,
-0.0224222653,
-0.0931452885,
-0.0507357083,
-0.0372596942,
0.0329413749,
0.0100055542,
0.0018687252,
-0.0216499362,
-0.0317877308,
0.0399247743,
-0.0198634975,
-0.0327984951,
0.0220108982,
0.0095080063,
0.0414504819,
0.0000024815,
-0.0308892243,
-0.022664696,
0.0083569409,
-0.0048155156,
-0.0321861655,
-0.0023039982,
0.0065106414,
-0.0061001424,
-0.0024422039,
-0.068766579,
-0.0022631828,
0.060266044,
0.0847720131,
-0.0108107431,
0.0576846413,
-0.0110980989,
-0.0501220077,
0.0763490126,
-0.0369463004,
0.002580157,
0.0164774209,
0.0046857744,
0.0049475147,
-0.018047763,
0.0424708426,
-0.0282754581,
-0.0095587084,
0.062417794,
0.0242012534,
-0.0037210479,
0.0591229759,
0.0159517862,
-0.0317854024,
-0.0080756564,
0.0125369737,
-0.0177273434,
0.0151956975,
0.0065826736,
0.0038241243,
0.0317422263,
0.0199729353,
-0.0452977493,
0.0360404737,
-0.0017457285,
0.0262457523,
-0.0454993099,
0.0431608632,
-0.0148274535,
-0.0373006687,
-0.011423042,
0.0325792208,
0.0198611282,
-0.001514233,
-0.0213912446,
0.0378435962,
-0.0447522588,
-0.0538171045,
-0.0162246376,
0.0034563513,
-0.0191126522,
0.0003642355,
0.0202261712,
0.0641696006,
-0.0042383559,
-0.054131262,
0.0228464827,
0.0466114171,
0.0021416945,
0.0114634717,
-0.0319174379,
0.087079756,
-0.0299964752,
0.0868255943,
-0.0302124787,
0.0313867815,
-0.0142146191,
-0.0081751188,
-0.0273777526,
0.0080770077,
-0.0263167545,
-0.0251104161,
-0.052192837,
-0.0186172221,
-0.0352054797,
0.0643839836,
0.0012146987,
0.0701040328,
-0.0127065051,
0.0121267848,
-0.0731300116,
-0.0252689272,
-0.010634386,
0.023496341,
0.0206420347,
-0.0310267601,
-0.003137809,
0.0037477377,
-0.0211668238,
-0.0457743518,
0.002052783,
0.1049252748,
-0.0367768556,
-0.0143422978,
-0.0313237906,
0.0157602914,
-0.0081178714,
-0.059464138,
0.0721796528,
-0.0467674211,
-0.006070016,
-0.0090207132,
-0.016416939,
-0.0217346456,
-0.019867124,
-0.0146003105,
0.0081270691,
0.0824071914,
0.0823571756,
-0.0064376271,
0.0197309554,
0.0349495858,
-0.0330371186,
0.0317084752,
0.0256116334,
0.0855352655,
-0.0030183059,
-0.0233788136,
0.0251791663,
0.000820956,
-0.0109961694,
0.0148001844,
-0.0476542972,
-0.0001885732,
-0.0212217439,
0.0127357431,
0.0029237827,
0.0484545417,
-0.0487199575,
-0.0101484153,
0.0603665374,
0.0340586938,
0.0360858142,
0.0113518098,
0.038712319,
0.0010877866,
-0.0250410009,
0.0254874285,
-0.056902349,
0.0838006884,
-0.0500146821,
-0.011307626,
-0.0247593224,
0.0178753901,
-0.008230634,
-0.0456428416,
0.0291454121,
-0.0190593023,
0.0308297239,
0.008692557,
0.0373649187,
0.029412007,
-0.0387255326,
-0.0451248959,
-0.012003677,
-0.0053669009,
-0.0548147298,
-0.0741892159,
0.0420348831,
-0.0083270026,
0.0480968393,
0.0145431198,
-0.0188510269,
-0.0231305715,
-0.0498667695,
0.0169658531,
0.0817213282,
0.0062968661,
-0.0251180008,
-0.025127653,
-0.034409225,
-0.0240329299,
0.0206370447,
0.0587066486,
0.037200965,
0.0211306456,
-0.0204489473,
-0.0033747926,
0.0910184458,
-0.0006959214,
0.0316200107,
-0.0218783841,
-0.0354381651,
0.012590671,
0.0413973853,
-0.0439602435,
0.008535048,
0.027390359,
-0.0062851696,
0.0236388016,
-0.0432063751,
0.0332371257,
-0.0621600673,
-0.0000561366,
-0.0198449567,
-0.060381081,
-0.0030685996,
0.0043441337,
-0.0279358961,
-0.0003649833,
0.0202125609,
-0.0135671124,
-0.0089649782,
-0.0146850897,
0.0063128565,
0.0048435922,
-0.0091047687,
-0.022381017,
0.0843967795,
-0.0095151458,
-0.0175899025,
-0.014463,
0.0101286685,
0.0403424613,
-0.0566460863,
0.034817256,
-0.0024098859,
-0.0163041204,
-0.0035005289,
0.0003773905,
0.0368896835,
-0.0057254164,
-0.0323691778,
-0.0094421403,
-0.021736078,
0.0008536698,
0.0030499964,
-0.007350713,
-0.0568857677,
-0.0008734048,
0.0235103294,
-0.018573381,
0.0235307999,
0.0232856516,
0.0326294117,
0.0198124722,
-0.048191119,
0.0372563303,
-0.0133281052,
-0.0028654512,
-0.0114887794,
0.0255481936,
0.0302197933,
0.0462301783,
-0.0079164347,
0.0193302128,
-0.0084102107,
0.0259137824,
-0.0356914364,
-0.0413227491,
0.0554574095,
-0.0053790403,
0.0538666956,
0.0660660714,
0.0292698238,
0.0227483828,
0.0241922028,
0.0238500405,
-0.0605648309,
-0.0015255308,
-0.051957719,
0.0072830897,
-0.0002105691,
-0.0588521808,
-0.010767987,
0.0501572937,
0.02382675,
-0.0051878672,
-0.0745430067,
0.068962276,
-0.0008751935,
-0.0501461364,
-0.037009649,
0.0111619979,
0.0146037033,
0.0698252991,
-0.005297835,
-0.0177192595,
0.0618422776,
-0.0239473116,
-0.0033611069,
-0.0051941392,
0.0387694761,
-0.0101391766,
0.0681710839,
0.0479775853,
0.0003768097,
0.0378029682,
0.0135632586,
-0.0731201619,
-0.0587162226,
0.0002101656,
0.0018850247,
0.0216523949,
-0.0406873189,
-0.0438262634,
-0.0236046202,
-0.0374267399,
-0.0634561852,
0.0158285424,
0.0104806637,
0.0060677915,
0.0434696488,
-0.0323975049,
-0.0275672879,
0.0157245006,
0.0555673167,
0.0213904995,
-0.0305614397,
-0.0420043617,
-0.0058000037,
0.0195450261,
0.0502193533,
0.0746581554,
0.0330563858,
-0.0087446617,
-0.0071389177,
0.0706342831,
-0.0712317079,
-0.0034888121,
-0.0353358947,
0.0522826314,
-0.0055452143,
0.0306986738,
0.0082949027,
0.0188268051,
0.0590243749,
0.0079464912,
-0.0220305901,
0.0441384874,
0.0153241884,
0.0263010897,
0.0012678353,
-0.0335390456,
-0.022436671,
0.0017287842,
0.0045514004,
-0.0509376787,
-0.0063317153,
0.0062692459,
0.0079279337,
-0.0305494182,
-0.030413622,
0.0411379673,
-0.0946990997,
0.0766982958,
-0.0157293025,
-0.0060179145,
-0.0119518805,
0.0128950523,
-0.0290942043,
-0.0458796062,
-0.0302346218,
-0.0266812202,
0.0158238858,
0.0274157766,
-0.0124772917,
0.0465497896,
0.0367551669,
0.0308013409,
0.0035137427,
0.0025104489,
0.0227236748,
0.0339984708,
0.0052748807,
-0.1082025766,
-0.0409655832,
0.0462640449,
0.0163338874,
0.0288930666,
0.0075836498,
0.0330058672,
0.0100574279,
-0.0173248164,
0.0226251651,
0.0398020558,
-0.0456470735,
0.0032415821,
0.0373182371,
-0.0299192425,
-0.0483147129,
-0.0215101112,
0.0437031388,
0.0002528774,
0.0562079214,
0.0123499604,
-0.0069504725,
-0.0587086268,
-0.0288662668,
0.0105794137,
-0.068499893,
-0.0633039251,
0.0024071338,
0.0664966628,
-0.033803802,
-0.0478421636,
-0.0066192811,
-0.0248883627,
0.0154981147,
-0.0159309637,
-0.1127531007,
-0.024708759,
0.0133548342,
-0.0098728212,
0.0219935365,
0.0064812792,
-0.0201100186,
-0.0053106975,
-0.0052082906,
0.003417138,
-0.1093785614,
-0.0461652018,
0.0177151524,
0.010595955,
-0.0124548357,
0.0174145959,
0.0895825848,
0.0286800861,
-0.0326054208,
-0.0236904975,
0.0601268709,
0.0239415318,
0.0450601056,
0.0084606009,
0.0082888482,
0.0601808019,
0.0540115871,
-0.0053133038,
-0.0161241386,
0.023437392,
0.0572257116,
0.0294857249,
-0.003058126,
-0.049142208,
-0.0020351077,
0.0161079671,
-0.0249458011,
0.0739728957,
-0.0056067691,
0.056648571,
-0.009460195,
-0.0174549446,
0.0200640298,
0.0276216846,
-0.0304547437,
-0.0451532751,
0.0378701016,
0.0365972444,
-0.0074031744,
-0.0115138832,
-0.0033664794,
-0.0048551257,
0.0034331023,
-0.0052493573,
0.0634716451,
-0.0007646806,
0.0146921584,
0.009640797,
0.0091756741,
0.0030559879,
-0.0183860939,
0.0329328217,
-0.0003863383,
0.0707430393,
0.0194577836,
-0.0122467726,
-0.0117164971,
0.0326886252,
-0.0540531278,
-0.0726973042,
0.0388867594,
0.0765367821,
0.033676181,
0.0251809265,
-0.0297920536,
-0.064388521,
0.0083281277,
0.0074969372,
-0.007102415,
0.0419537611,
-0.0417945832,
0.008480872,
-0.0025137104,
-0.0090200966,
-0.0671485886,
0.0308295935,
-0.0449951328,
0.0269312523,
-0.0540676378,
0.0050936034,
-0.0513890535,
-0.0644081607,
-0.0047360933,
-0.0469148979,
-0.0029780597,
-0.0118924109,
-0.0627604723,
-0.03634426,
-0.0746530071,
0.0580089167,
0.0155936079,
0.0107173147,
0.0325309709,
0.0396430045,
-0.0323931202,
-0.0210129023,
0.0134297442,
0.0477660485,
-0.0141671188,
0.0225678496,
-0.0371667147,
-6.861561829e-33,
-0.0125429658,
-0.0083033489,
0.0529576391,
-0.0437496528,
0.0096330084,
-0.0548593178,
-0.0267102774,
-0.0106550949,
-0.0170960594,
-0.022197606,
-0.0163969789,
-0.0185943879,
-0.0005416811,
0.018811224,
0.0233360585,
-0.0368456282,
0.0339671671,
0.0003604607,
-0.0559006482,
-0.007410157,
0.0168915577,
-0.0492212214,
0.0222145617,
-0.0087639,
-0.0181829762,
0.0386413708,
-0.0259346589,
-0.0140895573,
-0.0802517384,
0.0228334088,
-0.0047630225,
-0.0288793985,
-0.0016560865,
-0.0685919225,
-0.0082494998,
0.0085392464,
-0.0617744327,
-0.0178459976,
-0.0008186791,
0.000175444,
-0.0536263995,
-0.0305642746,
0.004711662,
-0.0053680073,
-0.0236603674,
-0.0261922851,
0.0064218901,
-0.0061499951,
0.0182656199,
0.0262509268,
-0.0413988493,
-0.0120242974,
-0.0292876493,
-0.024987096,
-0.0206939261,
0.0657302663,
0.0105170934,
0.0090866946,
-0.0530653745,
0.0573726743,
0.0507548302,
-0.0539676845,
0.0386043526,
-0.0183989462,
0.0302719679,
0.023712974,
0.0293794274,
-0.0275399908,
-0.0889746323,
-0.0472801775,
-0.0269160438,
0.0798682198,
0.0840059072,
0.030272292,
0.0181901045,
-0.0378197953,
-0.0522282235,
0.045277521,
-0.0090053463,
0.0220151395,
0.0421064682,
0.0066963756,
-0.0087378845,
-0.0026615721,
0.0222770683,
-0.0442885607,
-0.0289677065,
-0.0257613789,
0.0062768147,
0.0049730479,
0.0062939264,
-0.0074578105,
0.0386541449,
-0.0418275222,
0.0437361859,
-0.0098276781,
-0.0161849111,
0.0295256414,
-0.011928766,
0.0075854072,
-0.0411140583,
-0.0076002181,
0.0502260104,
0.049447801,
-0.0037400164,
0.0357847475,
0.020621879,
0.0232062526,
0.0131866634,
-0.0053221281,
-0.0330047794,
0.0508024544,
0.0338038504,
-0.0059538963,
0.0218807552,
0.0215224568,
-0.0331818312,
-0.0774279833,
-0.0588134192,
0.0216563959,
-0.0368081555,
0.0146068297,
-0.0400374755,
0.03865752,
0.0066461745,
0.0339876749,
-0.0537778661,
0.0044411062,
0.0060018064,
-0.0556141958,
-0.027468292,
0.0090444395,
3.265e-7,
-0.0029562344,
0.0135394307,
0.0226133633,
-0.0020417944,
0.03229817,
0.0535365157,
-0.023441704,
0.0013717533,
0.026689738,
0.0216489639,
0.0194773041,
0.0378551446,
0.0160635244,
0.0304598957,
-0.0192083288,
-0.0167690031,
-0.0469705164,
-0.0062992792,
0.0117542427,
0.039389085,
0.0742835179,
0.0118434457,
0.0024742184,
-0.002206404,
0.0447977707,
0.0323892869,
0.0127806952,
-0.0213980842,
0.0331039801,
-0.021567205,
0.037605878,
0.0026885096,
0.0254469607,
-0.0074655511,
0.0222350489,
-0.0555313304,
-0.007353378,
0.0217657387,
0.0313417055,
-0.0717591271,
-0.0391007066,
-0.0381421186,
-0.0070406655,
-0.0854292214,
0.0889058411,
-0.1273807287,
-0.0651173517,
0.0263542905,
-0.0095912572,
0.0308265947,
0.0180488955,
0.0100079123,
-0.0130547881,
-0.0481602214,
0.0125729274,
0.0398155376,
0.0150064072,
-0.0261913799,
0.0084344288,
0.0317719877,
-0.0429224037,
-0.065807566,
-0.0319205299,
0.0279758722,
0.0137842093,
0.0011164742,
-0.0831426904,
2.68471614e-34,
-0.0072265025,
0.0546194687,
0.0156750828,
-0.0983388424,
0.0126894359,
0.0068143811,
0.0331488028,
-0.0201246757,
0.0298386831,
-0.0121736648,
-0.0374008641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07459v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07459v2 | The Capacity for Moral Self-Correction in Large Language Models | 2023-02-15T04:25:40 | 2023-02-18T21:30:27 | Deep Ganguli, Amanda Askell, Nicholas Schiefer, Thomas I. Liao, Kamilė Lukošiūtė, Anna Chen, Anna Goldie, Azalia Mirhoseini, Catherine Olsson, Danny Hernandez, Dawn Drain, Dustin Li, Eli Tran-Johnson, Ethan Perez, Jackson Kernion, Jamie Kerr, Jared Mueller, Joshua Landau, Kamal Ndousse, Karina Nguyen, Liane Lovitt, Michael Sellitto, Nelson Elhage, Noemi Mercado, Nova DasSarma, Oliver Rausch, Robert Lasenby, Robin Larson, Sam Ringer, Sandipan Kundu, Saurav Kadavath, Scott Johnston, Shauna Kravec, Sheer El Showk, Tamera Lanham, Timothy Telleen-Lawton, Tom Henighan, Tristan Hume, Yuntao Bai, Zac Hatfield-Dodds, Ben Mann, Dario Amodei, Nicholas Joseph, Sam McCandlish, Tom Brown, Christopher Olah, Jack Clark, Samuel R. Bowman, Jared Kaplan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We test the hypothesis that language models trained with reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) have the capability to "morally
self-correct" -- to avoid producing harmful outputs -- if instructed to do so.
We find strong evidence in support of this hypothesis across three different
experiments, each of which reveal different facets of moral self-correction. We
find that the capability for moral self-correction emerges at 22B model
parameters, and typically improves with increasing model size and RLHF
training. We believe that at this level of scale, language models obtain two
capabilities that they can use for moral self-correction: (1) they can follow
instructions and (2) they can learn complex normative concepts of harm like
stereotyping, bias, and discrimination. As such, they can follow instructions
to avoid certain kinds of morally harmful outputs. We believe our results are
cause for cautious optimism regarding the ability to train language models to
abide by ethical principles. | [
0.0638208836,
0.0875465646,
-0.0443844013,
0.0058617424,
-0.0450729392,
0.0302449353,
0.0051273992,
0.0014339976,
0.0097766137,
-0.0405162871,
-0.0612910204,
-0.0067290762,
-0.01297177,
-0.0217036437,
0.0340021029,
-0.025329303,
0.0613867864,
-0.0046914704,
0.0449242592,
-0.029913038,
-0.0127214557,
0.015251603,
0.0554171465,
-0.0291577484,
-0.0042779902,
0.0112274485,
0.0413143113,
-0.0366009697,
0.0131586045,
0.0045446628,
0.0329090096,
0.0401242673,
0.0567350127,
0.0378151312,
0.0000016301,
-0.062483009,
0.0363403037,
-0.0032491693,
0.028722072,
0.0106772287,
0.0962287262,
-0.0513033532,
-0.0212862045,
0.0087895049,
-0.0222390871,
0.0210694335,
0.0084206695,
0.065689519,
0.0197123829,
0.0700447932,
0.0202086717,
-0.0156188682,
0.0201619398,
0.003934728,
-0.0211014803,
0.0205811933,
0.0536568798,
0.0284756254,
-0.0417821296,
-0.0055658375,
-0.0283361636,
-0.0062651485,
0.0352118947,
-0.0098245936,
-0.0226816479,
0.0002537037,
0.0151196821,
-0.0357465893,
-0.0197478589,
0.0064097228,
0.0092467312,
-0.0323711373,
0.025995573,
0.0085379705,
0.0333900899,
-0.0240036212,
0.0166648626,
0.0543293282,
0.0075812349,
0.014129593,
0.0235547014,
-0.0248944145,
0.0292635523,
0.0493336767,
0.0605167896,
0.0192763004,
-0.0188661627,
-0.05552423,
-0.0018003328,
0.0162560623,
-0.0160965659,
-0.0135890506,
-0.0274983589,
0.0041857399,
-0.0035352928,
0.0460979603,
-0.0313388631,
0.0500264689,
0.0601024888,
-0.0665855408,
0.0128707318,
0.0339999199,
-0.0049045766,
0.0129711209,
-0.0068149739,
0.0383150876,
-0.0154094575,
0.0769558549,
-0.0149973072,
0.0290376674,
0.0202021115,
-0.0087584183,
0.000628253,
0.0238571391,
0.012944025,
0.0628092811,
-0.0356597155,
-0.0156243397,
-0.0713515133,
-0.002252419,
-0.0462703854,
0.006769829,
-0.0335240103,
-0.0238297656,
-0.0641158447,
-0.0286596976,
-0.0398450308,
-0.0187083222,
-0.0078867981,
-0.0093015917,
0.0198285338,
-0.0477160178,
-0.0323616415,
-0.0019222675,
0.0417869985,
0.1246669665,
0.0021268916,
-0.021976918,
-0.0063775075,
0.0000905277,
-0.0393087491,
-0.073069565,
-0.0118735516,
-0.0183175616,
-0.0117440587,
-0.0238949973,
-0.0234231502,
-0.0620277599,
0.0432470739,
0.0052825934,
-0.0577587485,
0.0522741675,
0.0334801562,
0.0075077154,
0.0290590189,
0.0015318717,
0.0033327641,
0.0663742349,
0.0149059761,
-0.0034702194,
0.0087554483,
-0.0386921503,
0.0005376743,
-0.0210812315,
0.021796016,
0.0143028134,
-0.0504203439,
0.0092129521,
0.0018301082,
0.0318721645,
0.0516576134,
0.0576664284,
-0.0112071913,
-0.0379946232,
0.0479566939,
0.0893298984,
-0.0096261567,
0.0180665124,
0.0165112521,
-0.0239153728,
-0.013702374,
0.0174080525,
-0.0897759423,
0.0209396053,
0.0199223515,
-0.018170502,
-0.0408246852,
0.0151688457,
-0.0110738939,
-0.026105307,
-0.0024143346,
-0.0035118854,
0.0660529137,
0.0060387151,
0.0281804856,
0.0397001095,
-0.0027795956,
-0.0504020005,
0.0773681775,
-0.0280161742,
0.0154923797,
-0.0555434264,
0.090548113,
0.0608292073,
0.0473607443,
0.0036707942,
0.0000792183,
-0.0594655834,
-0.0408987924,
0.0339754447,
0.0749393776,
-0.0164137855,
-0.0237580184,
-0.0238469969,
-0.0078246407,
-0.0181875229,
-0.0014372802,
0.0136961471,
0.0031577456,
-0.0299353711,
-0.0064785639,
0.034637928,
-0.0710257143,
0.039319817,
-0.0026647975,
-0.0099895354,
-0.0346133262,
0.0117827784,
0.0255371649,
-0.0284338705,
-0.0331301764,
-0.0210758038,
-0.0273155384,
0.0210526194,
-0.0259527061,
-0.0136552704,
-0.0791299343,
0.010527906,
0.0037579641,
-0.0222147871,
-0.0157900937,
0.0159834269,
0.0051808027,
0.0333246253,
0.021013299,
-0.0394935608,
0.0188788716,
-0.0316115208,
0.0035499735,
-0.0974152386,
-0.034718737,
-0.0169573482,
0.04299796,
-0.0153258657,
-0.004666293,
-0.045518849,
-0.0161648933,
-0.0106329322,
-0.0196489226,
-0.0144981919,
-0.0042981552,
-0.0298416577,
0.0464835316,
0.050007619,
0.0372758731,
-0.0179530457,
-0.0287991781,
-0.0120039731,
-0.0174919702,
0.0165080298,
-0.0211558938,
-0.0012711068,
-0.0356523953,
0.0040890393,
0.0049704239,
-0.0176765453,
-0.0028570851,
0.0417152457,
0.0414240062,
0.0057447641,
-0.0302073918,
-0.018538801,
-0.0277188402,
-0.0025489221,
-0.0415481329,
-0.0077412128,
0.0233568978,
0.0125876497,
-0.0443022959,
0.0387281813,
-0.058364097,
0.0141371926,
0.0019142065,
-0.081217438,
-0.0065945308,
0.050056234,
0.0182002168,
0.0986070633,
0.0527638346,
0.0288058668,
0.0712150484,
0.0671360269,
-0.0454560481,
0.0092629241,
-0.0008031621,
-0.0346242562,
-0.0323602259,
-0.0466543175,
-0.0297779217,
0.0729259849,
0.0191367269,
-0.0048957649,
-0.0415788405,
0.0365029983,
-0.0584156476,
-0.1201273948,
0.0122525562,
-0.077941671,
-0.0081582181,
0.015964359,
-0.0613735244,
-0.0806880072,
0.0710263178,
0.0737780109,
0.0098075904,
0.007341966,
0.0081732087,
0.0085262759,
0.0467120633,
0.0348957852,
0.045977667,
-0.0000165245,
-0.0245593302,
-0.039716091,
-0.0448270477,
0.0627182201,
-0.0394225977,
0.0416987613,
-0.0259663537,
0.0211955123,
0.0214881301,
-0.0968219414,
-0.0574444272,
-0.0408429652,
-0.0076585142,
-0.0364534743,
-0.0166372117,
0.0117424047,
0.0504437797,
-0.0168066919,
0.0374426991,
-0.0352851227,
-0.0121636624,
-0.002337008,
0.0216995943,
-0.0796921477,
0.0379974581,
0.0005546782,
0.0759490207,
0.0016192124,
0.0542822368,
0.0188296102,
-0.0062900865,
0.031149568,
0.0180437118,
0.0464118049,
0.0118245212,
-0.0001330608,
0.0078053121,
0.040161211,
0.04825335,
-0.0125649339,
-0.0187569391,
0.0564126708,
0.0143630784,
-0.0306823384,
0.0210770406,
-0.010778877,
-0.0356155708,
0.0480729602,
0.0053821332,
-0.0715635717,
0.0230394714,
0.0067877476,
-0.005332042,
-0.0737445727,
-0.0463632531,
0.0308944341,
-0.1051395461,
0.0315642729,
0.0389743857,
-0.0048974338,
-0.0660634562,
-0.0112675736,
-0.020533042,
-0.011500434,
0.0434208661,
0.0231165942,
-0.0182310399,
-0.0678765699,
0.0053257439,
0.0335851684,
0.0274533369,
0.0411480479,
-0.0515580289,
0.1001809016,
0.0753458068,
0.0460577011,
-0.0554306321,
-0.0077934423,
0.0029921203,
0.0435436293,
-0.0068144212,
0.0316792428,
0.0102871992,
-0.0222001858,
-0.0163903181,
-0.0272686705,
0.0278623011,
0.0463580079,
-0.0315982364,
-0.0036386366,
0.0562105216,
0.0298995674,
-0.0821267143,
-0.0051186774,
0.0087306425,
-0.0166780315,
0.0511608683,
-0.01031397,
-0.0382253751,
0.0036843142,
-0.0541425906,
-0.0444503613,
-0.019658044,
-0.0621379092,
-0.0173839908,
-0.0017457395,
-0.0035360411,
-0.0536779799,
-0.0512988605,
-0.0302024297,
-0.0327792279,
0.0564368181,
-0.0835453048,
0.031671714,
0.0163385104,
-0.0038382602,
-0.0219124705,
-0.0425663516,
-0.0203275029,
-0.0233562533,
0.014922413,
0.003114233,
-0.0314252228,
0.0188346691,
-0.0465526469,
0.0162500385,
-0.0427644737,
0.0645444691,
0.0670593679,
0.0066113709,
0.0418104343,
-0.0189105626,
-0.0279843919,
0.0274147112,
0.0464886464,
-0.1033675149,
0.049736511,
0.0527330562,
0.0170427524,
-0.0040603327,
0.025034558,
-0.0147734536,
0.0381571874,
0.0392379723,
-0.0012148845,
-0.0170770995,
0.0124634942,
0.0531942509,
0.0106797069,
-0.0066874609,
-0.0164149385,
0.0194646511,
-0.040364325,
-0.0563092306,
-0.0159861408,
-0.0544543415,
0.0189305153,
-0.0010894061,
0.0522637889,
0.0064229281,
-0.0054395315,
-0.0216029957,
-0.0395625159,
0.0030950005,
-0.0010827463,
-0.0224556215,
0.0106357522,
0.0544230379,
-0.0068950406,
0.0332100615,
-0.0397463627,
0.0344693512,
-0.0147698149,
0.0166777316,
0.0059877606,
0.0605728813,
0.0187642518,
-0.002516255,
-0.0179313123,
-0.0236997548,
-0.0676009655,
-0.0140458522,
-0.008709861,
-0.004849026,
0.0035843819,
0.034450449,
0.0002026565,
-0.0191937815,
-0.0234335829,
-0.0059618107,
0.0040545384,
-0.0151105756,
-0.0181611925,
-0.0043877591,
0.0216542184,
-0.0259309243,
-0.0159995053,
0.0053006844,
-0.0011015686,
0.0692276135,
0.0061941259,
-0.0011018909,
0.0014690673,
-0.0396074057,
0.0348543338,
-0.045244731,
-0.0042520515,
0.0224140212,
-0.0360808261,
-0.0623962544,
-0.0647958368,
0.0382602699,
0.0234972481,
-0.0612756163,
-0.0355070345,
0.0394847803,
-0.0221010093,
0.0201696754,
-0.0265761316,
0.0234970022,
0.0116410712,
0.0252323654,
-0.0506338254,
-4.820397072e-33,
-0.0205043256,
0.0055477861,
-0.0266605094,
-0.0118014421,
0.001532982,
-0.0632679611,
0.0221797805,
0.0165689141,
-0.0363473892,
0.0434216261,
0.0007476707,
0.0236128904,
-0.0154532613,
-0.0216548853,
0.0438268222,
-0.0437175743,
0.0393210649,
-0.0279521719,
-0.0209136419,
-0.0043118107,
-0.027281981,
0.0131390961,
0.0499616079,
-0.0557820052,
0.0291553438,
0.0356664583,
-0.0088354293,
0.0091664447,
-0.0593295842,
0.0262409728,
0.0023910648,
0.0462849401,
0.0041352892,
-0.0209301393,
0.004204981,
0.0359857194,
-0.0256242007,
-0.0009428842,
0.0437418669,
-0.0265742652,
-0.0310302153,
-0.02813958,
0.04181353,
-0.0184742492,
-0.0605254285,
0.0059448015,
0.0158110894,
-0.0016615601,
0.0075479718,
0.0085559422,
-0.0712838918,
-0.0405769981,
-0.0132321734,
-0.0250446778,
-0.0587592833,
0.0135274883,
-0.0230792686,
0.0189704988,
-0.0146962171,
0.0388448052,
0.0156786013,
-0.0233809967,
0.0179402698,
-0.0078402767,
0.030682819,
0.0648208112,
0.0418586023,
0.0447710641,
-0.0009614619,
-0.0275577735,
0.0342653953,
-0.0120723238,
0.0376376286,
0.0609344207,
0.0062432922,
-0.0865063816,
0.0197697803,
-0.0612423085,
0.0314789042,
0.01131735,
0.0031570015,
-0.0095996456,
-0.0332108848,
-0.0233283285,
-0.067906186,
-0.0576488301,
-0.0168323182,
-0.024349777,
0.0167720169,
0.0190732572,
-0.0130464099,
-0.0326063037,
-0.0303002484,
-0.0361749865,
-0.0008917003,
0.0108510554,
-0.0069340891,
-0.0109016169,
-0.005239259,
0.019398313,
-0.0681178048,
-0.0249643363,
-0.0198358092,
-0.0167293362,
0.0293970052,
0.0030585632,
0.0663034096,
0.0470597856,
-0.036873728,
0.0224903151,
-0.0128520355,
0.0393499061,
0.0421889462,
-0.035567604,
0.0223583691,
0.0365556367,
0.0093410304,
-0.0136233727,
0.0448003933,
-0.0372231863,
-0.0575376153,
0.0249408279,
-0.0318311043,
0.0336472653,
-0.0182733666,
-0.0030927768,
-0.0353656039,
0.0753811896,
0.023800103,
-0.0665558875,
-0.0181546416,
0.0087103089,
2.379e-7,
-0.0324214809,
0.026097985,
0.0129700312,
0.018029565,
-0.0116575016,
0.0656856447,
0.0335354097,
0.0704274923,
0.0565624535,
-0.0243994612,
-0.0009110434,
0.0186150968,
0.0232583974,
0.0042788563,
0.0257399194,
0.0103758769,
-0.0828238949,
0.0077308407,
-0.0239697043,
0.0015192779,
-0.0152492551,
0.0715925172,
0.0488876812,
-0.0101438295,
0.0044047781,
-0.0025937152,
0.0443480089,
-0.0697815567,
-0.0193982255,
-0.0001319437,
-0.0407675281,
0.0301659033,
0.0093454225,
0.0061785984,
0.0301960055,
0.0062619648,
-0.028974263,
0.036540661,
-0.0170247667,
0.0006454083,
-0.0288565271,
0.0036835368,
-0.0066616153,
-0.0217042472,
0.039634116,
-0.0483461209,
0.0009556792,
-0.0474808961,
0.0508048199,
-0.0190878008,
0.0191168655,
-0.0323573202,
-0.0416011512,
-0.0067478735,
0.0245287959,
0.0488305241,
0.0379625335,
-0.0557736121,
-0.004023782,
0.0021561226,
0.0158048961,
-0.0578293353,
0.0072450088,
0.0581881925,
-0.0009709048,
-0.0496234484,
0.0327098221,
1.645355514e-34,
0.0211108811,
-0.0378410816,
0.0260557197,
-0.0203838982,
0.0371558443,
0.0517948344,
-0.0171197969,
-0.0102596506,
0.0406890921,
0.0151040554,
-0.0173713174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07452v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07452v1 | How to Train Your DRAGON: Diverse Augmentation Towards Generalizable Dense Retrieval | 2023-02-15T03:53:26 | 2023-02-15T03:53:26 | Sheng-Chieh Lin, Akari Asai, Minghan Li, Barlas Oguz, Jimmy Lin, Yashar Mehdad, Wen-tau Yih, Xilun Chen | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Various techniques have been developed in recent years to improve dense
retrieval (DR), such as unsupervised contrastive learning and pseudo-query
generation. Existing DRs, however, often suffer from effectiveness tradeoffs
between supervised and zero-shot retrieval, which some argue was due to the
limited model capacity. We contradict this hypothesis and show that a
generalizable DR can be trained to achieve high accuracy in both supervised and
zero-shot retrieval without increasing model size. In particular, we
systematically examine the contrastive learning of DRs, under the framework of
Data Augmentation (DA). Our study shows that common DA practices such as query
augmentation with generative models and pseudo-relevance label creation using a
cross-encoder, are often inefficient and sub-optimal. We hence propose a new DA
approach with diverse queries and sources of supervision to progressively train
a generalizable DR. As a result, DRAGON, our dense retriever trained with
diverse augmentation, is the first BERT-base-sized DR to achieve
state-of-the-art effectiveness in both supervised and zero-shot evaluations and
even competes with models using more complex late interaction (ColBERTv2 and
SPLADE++). | [
0.029811848,
0.0649785474,
0.011457948,
0.0233183913,
0.0251456443,
0.0029011099,
0.0110111712,
0.0238234587,
-0.020006096,
-0.0279766172,
-0.0526860505,
-0.0228257105,
-0.0624513999,
0.0439043343,
0.0275381394,
-0.0808379278,
0.0393696167,
0.0326954611,
0.0187307075,
-0.0030944124,
-0.0290198214,
-0.0050237584,
0.0205658805,
0.007575036,
-0.0091618225,
0.0250965916,
-0.0482686646,
0.05861504,
0.0209478494,
-0.0292704944,
0.0193387158,
0.0462514311,
0.0727254599,
0.0426704474,
0.0000018301,
-0.038791351,
-0.0324025489,
0.01149162,
-0.0094360346,
0.0182443038,
0.0177308191,
0.0055573224,
0.0580813624,
-0.0198480338,
-0.0025546981,
-0.0918721259,
0.0289749131,
0.0682991892,
0.037639875,
0.0890206099,
-0.0196651984,
-0.0545540601,
0.0546395667,
-0.0412219837,
0.0451613478,
-0.0290675983,
0.0353579484,
-0.0148856016,
0.0302464347,
0.0415935218,
-0.0036706498,
0.0012144647,
0.0193753969,
0.0090721343,
0.0611964837,
0.025048146,
-0.0517879613,
0.0080681043,
0.0345661193,
0.0637867078,
0.0022089414,
0.0112230917,
-0.0247728825,
0.0083247805,
-0.0186794847,
-0.0271258038,
-0.045630794,
-0.0304602049,
0.0136253694,
-0.0031434384,
-0.0441927761,
0.0157071594,
0.0156898573,
0.0142807569,
-0.0495225228,
-0.0215960797,
0.0327048451,
-0.0452450924,
-0.0052622547,
0.0368318036,
-0.0466789603,
-0.0221103039,
0.0085068932,
0.0164670683,
-0.046146933,
-0.0163250826,
-0.0085883988,
-0.0647199005,
0.0242026038,
0.0103564132,
0.0292590708,
0.0406320691,
-0.0728267431,
0.0531444065,
-0.0011071272,
0.0614669435,
-0.0494605787,
0.0337795541,
-0.0548791997,
-0.0348794013,
-0.0387591645,
-0.0078833578,
-0.0681958944,
0.0581878535,
-0.0308723859,
-0.0111310277,
-0.033502847,
0.0251382682,
0.01086039,
-0.0039800224,
0.0175983142,
0.0685658678,
-0.0898073465,
0.0049659321,
-0.0101476889,
0.0436740145,
-0.049257312,
0.0075615114,
0.0275667906,
-0.0300079957,
-0.0188648738,
0.0145733124,
0.043573752,
-0.0821817294,
0.0179070476,
0.0447879657,
-0.0489985384,
-0.0834127814,
-0.0267584864,
0.0031157772,
-0.0028302642,
-0.0241092928,
-0.0142227467,
-0.04570508,
0.0209309701,
-0.0186061021,
-0.009665967,
-0.0247240253,
-0.0030067018,
-0.0003192489,
-0.0184481032,
0.0339300036,
-0.0493362173,
-0.0192879308,
0.0406856053,
-0.0051731286,
-0.0141216842,
0.0651883259,
-0.01830988,
0.0307316184,
0.0264452156,
0.0167061612,
0.0071132514,
-0.0073393495,
0.027663406,
0.0130148102,
-0.0717060566,
0.032626871,
-0.0402501114,
0.0212401021,
0.030543467,
0.0394290239,
-0.0826698095,
-0.0300324503,
-0.0080690309,
0.0225107949,
0.031868536,
-0.0061081932,
0.025727978,
0.012316131,
-0.0343518555,
0.0138115818,
-0.0245065279,
0.0480264761,
-0.0158963725,
0.0153844319,
0.0590377599,
0.0063648233,
-0.0556586459,
-0.0390765518,
0.0150102666,
0.0294147134,
-0.0274900589,
0.0173879452,
0.0628228635,
-0.0050171167,
-0.0039435276,
0.0152366115,
0.0312702656,
-0.0310370717,
0.0132116079,
-0.0360000841,
-0.0066419747,
0.067852281,
0.0404492542,
-0.0466990955,
-0.0342227034,
0.0180379301,
-0.0157578737,
0.0028674453,
0.0128349056,
-0.0230165124,
0.051333759,
-0.0471801087,
-0.0759431645,
-0.0550716408,
0.0125829298,
0.0186311845,
0.0383037813,
0.019623002,
0.0319689922,
-0.0565881468,
0.0066917441,
0.0156862102,
-0.0095218662,
-0.0694939643,
0.0315997377,
0.0059699146,
-0.0265580788,
0.0197554771,
-0.0378637463,
0.0032992037,
0.0383906029,
-0.0090305107,
-0.0379041173,
-0.0188210215,
-0.0197621714,
-0.027441768,
0.0191236455,
-0.0132918628,
0.0053410376,
0.0094364183,
-0.0444895886,
-0.0454979017,
0.0241889749,
-0.0186772812,
0.071727328,
-0.0503960252,
-0.0097863991,
0.0010546029,
-0.0337379761,
-0.0261472799,
0.0803841352,
-0.0054232329,
0.0131933698,
0.0087892963,
0.0271193534,
0.0210777,
-0.0775702521,
-0.0378158242,
0.0156213539,
-0.0144781843,
0.024997903,
0.03094,
-0.0095803188,
-0.0495615862,
0.0208127573,
-0.0608537644,
0.005859205,
-0.0331365243,
-0.0311139189,
-0.0059895031,
0.0414040051,
0.0035867174,
-0.0289808977,
-0.0163865387,
-0.0486489423,
0.0078481873,
0.0498467088,
0.0266487151,
0.0516402833,
0.0121392235,
-0.0259620827,
-0.0566551909,
0.0453067273,
0.0416080207,
-0.0328327343,
-0.0203445796,
0.0467698723,
-0.0092980098,
-0.0280096009,
0.0300017465,
-0.0055185836,
-0.0051993332,
0.0323928371,
-0.0789666623,
-0.037028823,
0.0461634472,
0.0281356238,
0.0013807507,
-0.0097886845,
-0.0147344796,
-0.0876499489,
0.0545108244,
-0.0394997559,
-0.0231907368,
-0.0003206543,
-0.0032797724,
-0.0174691454,
0.0180279501,
-0.0334085561,
-0.0117172673,
-0.0666684285,
-0.0294360332,
0.035518311,
-0.0367737673,
-0.0539413728,
0.0252835955,
0.0183611941,
0.0322972983,
-0.0423153751,
-0.0443869643,
0.0695753694,
0.0275295265,
-0.0275441762,
0.0081443433,
-0.005950565,
-0.0276799407,
0.0601518191,
-0.0274036061,
0.0146847749,
-0.0102183148,
-0.0511204042,
-0.0101148933,
-0.0208601058,
-0.0004478382,
-0.0296395663,
0.0516225658,
0.0137454122,
0.0333486982,
0.0077258577,
-0.0619489998,
-0.0463111401,
0.0122058941,
-0.0055838642,
0.0340765193,
-0.0121027408,
-0.0602449775,
-0.0552382246,
-0.0170329493,
0.0124074761,
0.0443137139,
-0.0239932388,
-0.0215544701,
0.0126816956,
0.0300354455,
0.0379569158,
0.0160469338,
-0.0395044759,
-0.0182844941,
-0.0188175254,
0.0452938713,
0.006003852,
-0.0744309202,
-0.0188177302,
0.041055277,
0.0404794663,
-0.0106162587,
-0.038511198,
-0.0136709781,
0.0218472239,
-0.0122848386,
-0.0378705896,
0.0535482876,
0.0074330084,
-0.048164919,
-0.0297840573,
-0.0229148772,
0.0308033694,
0.0473983996,
0.0565165542,
-0.0793449283,
-0.0235619918,
-0.0136729814,
0.0635639131,
0.0362059064,
-0.0007275013,
0.0089509971,
-0.1175628975,
0.0552022606,
-0.0161379576,
0.0064452332,
-0.0113946591,
-0.0206451006,
0.0158552788,
-0.0462220088,
-0.0006838862,
0.0201499891,
0.0005111239,
-0.0096888915,
0.0303008463,
0.0846491382,
-0.0500013791,
-0.0179820936,
-0.0222869609,
-0.0302357562,
0.0619213842,
0.0056398371,
0.0220621191,
-0.0593087375,
-0.0102836862,
-0.0454064049,
-0.0008268559,
-0.0251009837,
0.085704051,
-0.0234606601,
-0.0159482956,
0.0021500564,
-0.0128166405,
0.0211993754,
-0.0260682702,
-0.0417908691,
0.0337468386,
-0.0091040162,
0.041248247,
-0.0512539968,
-0.0461608283,
-0.018392073,
0.0487354286,
-0.0217742529,
0.0390757062,
-0.0111111775,
-0.0126329232,
0.0140098035,
-0.0504984073,
0.0159374308,
-0.007961804,
-0.0400164053,
-0.0078118653,
-0.0462188572,
-0.0249510892,
0.0110187037,
0.0636872053,
-0.0489115492,
-0.0171624105,
-0.0699224398,
-0.00853117,
-0.0438556969,
0.0524743758,
0.0058053466,
-0.0263487883,
-0.0508470908,
-0.0487863459,
0.0224515367,
-0.0511815995,
-0.0126950843,
-0.0622030981,
-0.0008893865,
-0.044432167,
-0.0098935189,
0.0450763591,
0.0166456215,
0.074009724,
-0.001277635,
-0.0541833639,
0.0614021532,
0.0730213374,
-0.002497361,
-0.0108464034,
0.0560169369,
-0.0228491705,
-0.0119420923,
0.0193401612,
-0.0737101659,
0.0259747524,
0.011110222,
0.0447914973,
-0.0462583676,
-0.0198184643,
0.0263822135,
0.0044068168,
0.0779047757,
0.0061638174,
0.0454767495,
-0.0367753021,
0.0286097061,
-0.0278552193,
-0.024063902,
-0.0497909002,
-0.0031276378,
0.0363125578,
0.0088142268,
-0.0094741071,
0.0372545086,
-0.0251354706,
0.0548457243,
-0.0911784694,
-0.0267237574,
0.0129773961,
-0.0255714152,
0.012825192,
0.0086957728,
-0.0274707451,
0.0401158966,
0.0081954524,
0.0740840882,
-0.0317343101,
-0.005136827,
0.0285137221,
0.0144137777,
-0.0250412934,
0.0050050728,
-0.0962441117,
-0.0272940807,
-0.0465942994,
0.0177141577,
0.0409784988,
-0.0481315702,
0.0003314856,
0.0267200414,
-0.0182644241,
-0.0130403573,
-0.0266648773,
0.0194826927,
-0.042647738,
-0.0194193702,
0.0508246236,
0.0155140264,
0.0217829347,
0.056488689,
-0.0044516004,
0.0586032309,
-0.042743735,
-0.0142351268,
-0.0009849733,
-0.0115326326,
0.1135498583,
0.0505200624,
-0.0190289598,
-0.00406439,
0.0045089023,
-0.0400265306,
0.0435385257,
-0.0253363997,
-0.0144993011,
0.0136115421,
0.0705082715,
0.0428434014,
0.0267450791,
-0.0391377322,
-0.0115884505,
-0.0334010944,
-0.0029728948,
0.0006157433,
0.0175648667,
-6.62139364e-33,
-0.0122825587,
0.0389156528,
0.0219428167,
-0.1042341143,
-0.0129906386,
0.0174952801,
-0.0131813576,
-0.0177614354,
-0.0330539048,
0.0126984855,
-0.0326710194,
0.0241001621,
0.0050349352,
0.0387368575,
0.0120709846,
-0.0160156339,
0.0687705576,
0.0185991526,
0.0134067573,
0.0164554976,
0.0417072102,
0.0688298866,
0.0487502664,
-0.0379973911,
-0.0198583268,
0.010532802,
0.0101578906,
0.052938614,
0.0373005979,
0.0425334126,
0.0004894218,
0.0257877652,
-0.0019197715,
-0.0064564631,
-0.0096342908,
-0.0489960834,
-0.083186537,
-0.0350848176,
-0.0273187794,
-0.017406093,
-0.0398518033,
0.0100857429,
0.0241700839,
-0.0443352796,
0.0173074901,
-0.020731464,
0.0229145139,
-0.0225753505,
-0.0439187214,
-0.0484172963,
-0.0258737039,
0.0150985923,
0.0040639793,
0.0084819095,
0.0133483605,
0.0401012637,
0.0349090137,
0.0542012416,
-0.0424631871,
0.0159341488,
0.0137105174,
0.0272568595,
-0.0006613943,
0.0385524854,
0.0027748721,
0.0473099388,
0.0324711502,
-0.0000250208,
-0.0184387602,
0.0021427781,
0.0105874557,
0.0660796538,
-0.003052555,
0.0448840968,
0.0587156229,
0.0000238155,
-0.0420064852,
0.0540734306,
-0.0287716128,
0.0461574867,
-0.0096543673,
0.0689265281,
-0.0294811483,
-0.0162667483,
0.0170695633,
-0.014324246,
-0.0360107571,
-0.0232778098,
0.0013023134,
0.0618329644,
-0.0350076482,
0.0062540541,
0.0537577607,
0.0089192018,
0.0062786876,
0.0205653049,
-0.0225210991,
-0.004408285,
0.0086771054,
0.0127597414,
-0.0174557287,
-0.048629906,
0.0840791017,
0.0137735987,
-0.0523863435,
0.0086025093,
0.0329060182,
0.0150634814,
-0.0351168476,
-0.0011241811,
-0.0176199432,
0.0040189372,
-0.0256408341,
0.0238729864,
0.0090662614,
0.0263506304,
0.0025247482,
0.0856724456,
0.0175126158,
0.0330444761,
-0.0354057215,
-0.0353598669,
0.0337531157,
0.0028142887,
0.0184382312,
0.0427674614,
-0.0288626552,
-0.0089256614,
0.0132867703,
-0.0469466224,
-0.017375309,
0.0441741981,
2.638e-7,
0.0366812572,
-0.0037761466,
0.0429835282,
0.016952442,
-0.03540067,
0.0295753274,
-0.0180741772,
0.0327106863,
0.0256803557,
-0.0167737901,
0.0215162132,
0.0483888239,
0.0109834271,
0.0186370052,
-0.0370649435,
-0.0140724536,
-0.0587817319,
-0.019366011,
-0.048122406,
-0.0290030614,
0.0514632948,
0.0923134461,
0.0002957303,
-0.0187630691,
0.0491344035,
-0.0433581658,
0.0757279471,
0.0287209209,
0.0208266284,
-0.0026474923,
0.0317931958,
0.0509120338,
0.0081645073,
-0.0004891221,
-0.0103684869,
0.0427249297,
0.0244460069,
0.0466037467,
-0.0150216939,
-0.0464949943,
0.007195022,
0.0014865698,
0.0122978287,
-0.0131942844,
0.0714390725,
-0.0134116355,
0.0168144163,
0.0302053057,
-0.0753811672,
0.0153735783,
0.0321047939,
-0.0376504511,
-0.0154618155,
-0.000245409,
0.0171155203,
0.0307579488,
-0.0081026405,
-0.1074482277,
0.0135024441,
-0.0014578851,
-0.0327201374,
-0.0048264894,
-0.0216649082,
0.0387157314,
-0.0095013678,
0.0164320767,
-0.0225588083,
2.060023315e-34,
0.0391291678,
0.038666077,
0.0039699762,
-0.022316156,
0.0158412233,
-0.0087423064,
-0.0272963401,
-0.0111647788,
0.0226201657,
-0.0661358014,
-0.0243354198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07388v1 | Adding Instructions during Pretraining: Effective Way of Controlling Toxicity in Language Models | 2023-02-14T23:00:42 | 2023-02-14T23:00:42 | Shrimai Prabhumoye, Mostofa Patwary, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained large language models have become indispensable for solving
various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, safely deploying them
in real world applications is challenging because they generate toxic content.
To address this challenge, we propose two novel pretraining data augmentation
strategies that significantly reduce model toxicity without compromising its
utility. Our two strategies are: (1) MEDA: adds raw toxicity score as meta-data
to the pretraining samples, and (2) INST: adds instructions to those samples
indicating their toxicity. Our results indicate that our best performing
strategy (INST) substantially reduces the toxicity probability up to 61% while
preserving the accuracy on five benchmark NLP tasks as well as improving AUC
scores on four bias detection tasks by 1.3%. We also demonstrate the
generalizability of our techniques by scaling the number of training samples
and the number of model parameters. | [
0.0260796715,
0.0717124119,
-0.0096777184,
0.0030257662,
0.0147503018,
0.0407756716,
0.0011125032,
-0.0199890248,
0.0163215455,
-0.0530459099,
-0.0368059762,
0.0287308544,
-0.032591112,
0.0368425399,
0.0195396729,
-0.019541068,
0.0636343136,
-0.0116465967,
0.0003621364,
0.0131835938,
0.0055412157,
0.02620437,
0.0220691264,
0.0287610255,
-0.0416261032,
-0.0155030712,
0.0272672437,
0.0154001918,
0.0217687972,
-0.0616241023,
0.022464199,
0.0421797372,
-0.0150559666,
0.0314488262,
0.0000019813,
-0.0243029725,
-0.0038806088,
0.0185404103,
-0.0627291501,
-0.0018102629,
0.0764698908,
-0.0049028131,
-0.0063875895,
0.0609490089,
-0.038235303,
-0.0371644348,
0.0620647967,
0.0400006883,
0.0897446945,
0.0738610774,
-0.0210778881,
0.0080622453,
0.0325936377,
0.0070322435,
-0.0000374402,
-0.0144394031,
0.0505151376,
-0.0077096689,
-0.0379465148,
-0.0096218958,
-0.0038903034,
0.0376606509,
0.0137463827,
0.0128770703,
0.0000242608,
0.0127345538,
-0.0177915227,
-0.0548083261,
-0.0217973366,
0.0669622347,
-0.0840195194,
-0.0206839405,
-0.0322164148,
-0.0078348247,
0.0035942921,
-0.0314418599,
-0.0204679277,
0.0284750741,
0.0305908415,
0.0336162187,
-0.0051982156,
0.0087783011,
0.0296736248,
0.0197046846,
-0.0084425109,
0.042499464,
0.0186119638,
-0.03318749,
0.0487675257,
0.0204969905,
-0.038854681,
-0.0172269326,
0.0091333492,
-0.0203589741,
-0.0252072215,
0.0240728743,
-0.0841016695,
-0.0673148409,
0.0278774519,
-0.0890765637,
0.0679740235,
0.0170956049,
-0.0439315997,
0.0504367277,
-0.0224207714,
-0.0334473848,
0.0006441738,
0.0487344861,
-0.0282492861,
0.0196240935,
0.0162797831,
-0.0059048012,
-0.0574296638,
0.0099081052,
-0.0122095076,
-0.0031585214,
-0.0289380495,
0.0188002493,
-0.0414821841,
-0.027191598,
0.0299643613,
0.02992885,
-0.0395823233,
0.0129842125,
0.0126313865,
-0.0087480573,
-0.0174354482,
0.0377489887,
-0.026857689,
-0.0763375163,
-0.0339212604,
0.0356856659,
-0.0182561893,
-0.064397797,
0.0256644338,
0.1082806364,
0.0360268168,
-0.0495859347,
-0.0507708006,
-0.0182525758,
-0.0193317197,
-0.0484033972,
-0.0213415306,
-0.0062387693,
0.0221728124,
-0.0286065433,
0.0040226071,
-0.062334951,
0.0007688851,
0.0198220108,
-0.0662167817,
0.0941858217,
-0.0481347814,
-0.0135416193,
-0.0065312758,
-0.0020334173,
-0.0041558668,
0.0703874305,
0.0346245728,
0.0287270676,
0.0298750158,
-0.0158147234,
0.0164246447,
0.039767243,
0.046855174,
0.0140928151,
-0.021270914,
-0.0007567274,
0.008029432,
-0.0225238372,
0.0171002056,
0.0444391593,
-0.0059795962,
0.0025357527,
0.0689592361,
0.0049704928,
-0.006001676,
0.0176401008,
0.0315389931,
-0.0141155655,
-0.013155791,
-0.0388324298,
-0.0939316824,
-0.0182501581,
-0.0719320327,
-0.022463914,
0.0281787794,
0.0500052311,
-0.01600077,
-0.0486835465,
-0.0108212354,
-0.0138161182,
0.0186018553,
-0.004815198,
0.0235877093,
0.0411584117,
-0.0099952323,
0.0353741571,
0.0526815467,
-0.0426483937,
0.0178589374,
-0.0150255905,
-0.0239907224,
0.0669014826,
0.0508578345,
-0.0474686287,
-0.0178960189,
-0.0447771773,
-0.0062356885,
-0.0085822772,
0.0248766243,
-0.0014123759,
0.0545302853,
-0.0293610804,
-0.0387478024,
0.0163757782,
0.0253308993,
-0.0161225069,
0.0442691259,
0.0198088717,
0.007421074,
-0.0450410396,
-0.0843636394,
0.0706858113,
-0.0000816323,
-0.0803180337,
0.0283316877,
-0.0020037063,
0.0395474099,
0.0070458436,
-0.0463944338,
-0.0005003937,
0.0391858108,
-0.0018518992,
-0.015882317,
-0.0106678559,
-0.0484586395,
-0.039391607,
0.0407430716,
-0.005183531,
-0.0225652177,
0.059427958,
-0.0454822704,
-0.0028442061,
0.0017064628,
-0.0401330814,
0.0327950232,
0.0044110813,
0.0295462161,
-0.009691623,
0.0570602566,
-0.034242548,
0.0411356166,
-0.0037472954,
-0.0507299379,
-0.0147347897,
-0.0455658771,
-0.0088069886,
-0.0082187951,
-0.0739760101,
-0.0228241123,
-0.0001504941,
0.0217427313,
0.0102148401,
0.0175860226,
-0.0378885977,
0.0145038655,
-0.0610080846,
0.0083211781,
-0.031280268,
-0.0040814308,
0.019023871,
0.0090324413,
-0.0255949367,
-0.0281902216,
0.0001728445,
-0.0454519726,
0.0167954117,
0.0415043309,
-0.0074800001,
0.006764262,
0.004769295,
-0.0355304033,
-0.0278174821,
-0.0248205867,
0.0615881011,
-0.0064967615,
-0.0119311828,
-0.0424894914,
0.0403815359,
0.0194348563,
0.034798082,
0.0301414486,
-0.0489380024,
0.001136526,
0.0034241464,
0.0078445906,
0.0840188861,
0.0096819568,
0.0457165577,
0.0795717165,
0.0372316875,
-0.0351397283,
0.001008007,
-0.0315969549,
-0.0259123817,
-0.0113509726,
-0.0147691155,
0.0077187661,
0.0516015142,
-0.0228403565,
-0.0210407134,
-0.0361954272,
0.0325960368,
-0.0340538248,
-0.0466373153,
0.0035664297,
-0.0624920018,
-0.0117436545,
0.0019003635,
-0.0106194932,
-0.059201695,
0.0554832034,
0.0003659919,
0.006564857,
-0.0557540692,
-0.0149417408,
0.0039540264,
0.0171798319,
0.0295663625,
0.0105757741,
0.0226582121,
-0.0108004706,
-0.0010548518,
-0.0199083537,
0.0189532377,
-0.0179173294,
-0.0092111547,
-0.0285559669,
0.0003562174,
0.0045625074,
-0.0441598333,
-0.048759155,
-0.0516272262,
-0.0010870955,
-0.005455405,
0.0229833964,
0.0298178475,
-0.0395394564,
0.0011893325,
-0.000593305,
0.0051546725,
-0.0112957247,
-0.0080691762,
0.0023888876,
0.0022168707,
0.0651933551,
-0.0337312259,
0.0578986965,
0.0048247422,
0.0252246093,
0.074357152,
0.0144062862,
0.0085496483,
-0.0526220836,
0.0286081471,
0.0134535572,
-0.0007163057,
0.0284542292,
0.023126116,
0.0039794683,
-0.0518135875,
-0.0112190554,
0.0841376111,
0.0308018904,
-0.0343443565,
0.0175155587,
0.0441849642,
0.0372363403,
0.0305470321,
-0.0041931029,
-0.0764856786,
-0.028115293,
0.0226539262,
0.0257958472,
-0.0293514319,
-0.0422257259,
0.0035275866,
-0.1089454666,
0.0047657872,
0.014538276,
-0.0231719837,
-0.0156463385,
-0.0426223017,
-0.0145562347,
-0.0719791874,
0.0613190308,
-0.0435035042,
-0.0001170954,
-0.0151100913,
0.0245604273,
-0.0264599416,
-0.0874429047,
0.0127253141,
-0.0420659445,
0.0758977681,
0.0659960881,
-0.0075524938,
-0.0130995875,
0.0428706668,
0.0803045705,
0.0189151969,
-0.0127751986,
-0.010219479,
0.0934579894,
-0.043850977,
-0.0325911418,
0.0014970853,
0.0399084464,
-0.021984674,
-0.0043943101,
-0.0096422117,
0.0791184083,
0.0179490689,
-0.0199382156,
-0.0424119271,
-0.0188219678,
0.0338638499,
0.0798807517,
0.0170258731,
-0.0663104877,
-0.0027205145,
-0.013601521,
-0.0131033072,
-0.0422903225,
-0.0469317436,
0.0329714157,
-0.032223843,
-0.0401126072,
-0.0502431877,
-0.0707102716,
0.0566745065,
0.0125342524,
0.0138156833,
-0.0298231002,
-0.0177581031,
0.0148963947,
-0.0355137847,
0.0878074616,
-0.0283805132,
-0.0046380986,
-0.0521441437,
-0.012142715,
-0.0274714604,
0.0095263487,
-0.0207526423,
0.0166717246,
-0.0599887557,
-0.0835457146,
0.0508952141,
0.1071102023,
0.0141513133,
0.0424179398,
-0.0182999,
-0.0752698407,
0.0863256156,
0.0450888015,
-0.0639209747,
-0.0249502435,
0.0640602186,
-0.048534248,
0.0181822293,
0.0191753432,
-0.0252646208,
0.0385101438,
0.0520484373,
0.0283706002,
-0.0110630263,
0.005396544,
0.0483132377,
0.0364438072,
0.0636297837,
-0.0347282849,
0.0200589579,
-0.0303543545,
0.017469123,
-0.030480044,
-0.0383659229,
-0.0257111825,
0.0464799106,
0.037678048,
0.009211543,
-0.0332118683,
0.0051005492,
-0.0392677225,
0.0094965352,
-0.0161456838,
0.0155309346,
0.014368603,
-0.0042795721,
0.0691434741,
0.0345941782,
-0.0194515251,
0.0266932938,
-0.0039334642,
0.0050888839,
-0.0304812212,
-0.0151020996,
0.0155649288,
0.0305156149,
-0.0002100733,
0.0667953417,
-0.0414092615,
-0.0136246355,
-0.0623180494,
0.0019901092,
0.0204277579,
-0.0557685792,
0.0514699556,
-0.0339056961,
-0.0091911061,
-0.0216177106,
-0.0235518273,
0.0013263769,
-0.0202199761,
-0.0038630632,
0.0003541606,
-0.0399336033,
0.0000485889,
0.0683569089,
0.0199912768,
0.0800240338,
-0.0091028912,
-0.0244866796,
-0.025796717,
-0.0202717986,
0.0328645557,
0.0098696519,
-0.043304868,
0.0144377071,
-0.0230450537,
-0.09223748,
-0.0252037067,
0.0021493083,
0.0102698393,
0.0232299864,
0.0250026286,
0.0120977582,
-0.0154744145,
-0.0034609134,
-0.0066705272,
-0.0155968927,
0.0122324536,
-0.0327942148,
-0.01556662,
-6.312828577e-33,
0.0086569116,
0.0049935789,
-0.0113481423,
-0.0229038335,
-0.0011492629,
-0.0103371497,
-0.0031722253,
0.0054920777,
-0.0341987759,
0.0166315474,
-0.0149104157,
0.0182145387,
0.0114315581,
0.0242095925,
-0.0165919568,
-0.0032160038,
0.0415293686,
-0.0190795306,
-0.0325678997,
0.0117097907,
0.0082953786,
0.0287169367,
0.0384444222,
-0.0808025151,
-0.0091676386,
0.0347412415,
-0.0221719984,
-0.0150728598,
-0.003230514,
0.0627767667,
-0.0159439053,
0.0542816445,
0.0191978104,
-0.006512363,
-0.0127916019,
0.0240925793,
-0.0369352177,
0.0002292095,
-0.0104925772,
0.0182147026,
-0.0239244923,
-0.0087684784,
0.0599115901,
-0.010061482,
-0.0105867246,
0.0003758147,
0.0140510155,
-0.0268735159,
-0.0044411202,
-0.0112654418,
-0.0601220392,
0.0178337879,
-0.0221399982,
-0.0008111986,
0.0271589104,
0.031001512,
0.018955756,
0.0168015156,
-0.0256804395,
-0.0146360369,
0.0230680425,
0.0155362692,
0.0264213122,
-0.0091150571,
0.0021568795,
0.0551210754,
-0.0030466656,
0.0193336643,
0.018309813,
0.0082195876,
0.0254075658,
0.0024471767,
0.0526049584,
0.025313843,
0.0459671654,
-0.0263122618,
-0.0447348654,
0.0136635499,
-0.0174334329,
0.0494100824,
0.0137009053,
-0.0049533243,
-0.0457718186,
-0.0220905021,
-0.0505726524,
-0.0074994559,
-0.039703019,
-0.0332069248,
0.0608990975,
0.0199910756,
-0.0470367074,
0.0104781576,
0.0016021386,
-0.0430941172,
0.0200851765,
0.0128402049,
0.0157841854,
-0.0087277386,
-0.0262869969,
0.0300766807,
-0.0230039284,
-0.0094404891,
0.0362270698,
-0.0347871706,
0.0266540665,
-0.021399511,
0.0692655668,
0.0299964175,
-0.079754822,
0.0154054528,
-0.0181636699,
0.0593051463,
0.0654735044,
0.0502126701,
0.0392913409,
0.027501028,
0.0152068138,
0.0180213582,
0.0619066954,
0.0068535488,
-0.0300088543,
-0.01779324,
0.0298872199,
-0.0030381463,
-0.012826304,
-0.0145518156,
-0.0195817426,
0.0091529181,
0.0494536906,
-0.1151053086,
-0.0065733646,
-0.0204210877,
2.681e-7,
0.0547091477,
0.0588240251,
0.0043463479,
-0.0101722805,
-0.0038183141,
0.0292870961,
0.0094086407,
0.0343070105,
-0.0167783275,
0.0162769202,
0.0039347238,
0.0221135467,
0.0300141517,
0.0386526771,
-0.0399127863,
-0.0121354153,
-0.0787862912,
0.0235556196,
-0.0607785136,
-0.025175903,
0.0558377616,
0.1236908957,
0.008913001,
-0.0240191873,
0.002778803,
-0.0585412867,
0.0186100695,
-0.0273368545,
0.0058468571,
0.0255059171,
0.0166191217,
0.0468197688,
-0.0075855292,
0.0216654371,
-0.044264283,
-0.0121994074,
-0.0229480676,
0.0403622687,
-0.0346115455,
-0.0490121655,
-0.0043069934,
-0.0268799774,
-0.0054610302,
-0.0275649168,
0.0821250603,
-0.0320124775,
-0.0244148429,
-0.0745172724,
-0.032332927,
-0.0162506271,
0.0511126071,
-0.0452795662,
-0.0054732696,
0.0169665217,
0.0421760529,
0.0202327985,
-0.0357248299,
-0.1106375232,
-0.0195070487,
-0.0007723882,
-0.0040259063,
-0.042369362,
-0.0116945766,
0.0101959864,
0.0349838622,
-0.0585479587,
0.0137766218,
2.612484537e-34,
0.0383819118,
-0.0380705595,
0.0576259904,
-0.009035131,
0.0350714289,
0.0062304335,
0.0000611014,
-0.0037624515,
-0.0171843041,
-0.0753605738,
-0.0157214385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07371v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07371v3 | BiasTestGPT: Using ChatGPT for Social Bias Testing of Language Models | 2023-02-14T22:07:57 | 2023-12-06T06:26:52 | Rafal Kocielnik, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Vivian Zhang, Roy Jiang, R. Michael Alvarez, Anima Anandkumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, 68T50, I.2.7; J.5; K.4.1 | Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) harbor inherent social biases that can
result in harmful real-world implications. Such social biases are measured
through the probability values that PLMs output for different social groups and
attributes appearing in a set of test sentences. However, bias testing is
currently cumbersome since the test sentences are generated either from a
limited set of manual templates or need expensive crowd-sourcing. We instead
propose using ChatGPT for the controllable generation of test sentences, given
any arbitrary user-specified combination of social groups and attributes
appearing in the test sentences. When compared to template-based methods, our
approach using ChatGPT for test sentence generation is superior in detecting
social bias, especially in challenging settings such as intersectional biases.
We present an open-source comprehensive bias testing framework (BiasTestGPT),
hosted on HuggingFace, that can be plugged into any open-source PLM for bias
testing. User testing with domain experts from various fields has shown their
interest in being able to test modern AI for social biases. Our tool has
significantly improved their awareness of such biases in PLMs, proving to be
learnable and user-friendly. We thus enable seamless open-ended social bias
testing of PLMs by domain experts through an automatic large-scale generation
of diverse test sentences for any combination of social categories and
attributes. | [
0.0296662115,
0.0599445514,
-0.0401535332,
0.0377756916,
-0.0200286396,
0.0119000813,
0.0274725072,
-0.0089065237,
0.0617221594,
-0.0623204,
-0.0248051845,
-0.0149735091,
0.0059439298,
0.0447555631,
0.021223506,
-0.036945302,
0.0592615977,
0.0448316,
0.0432236157,
-0.0468940251,
0.0373784602,
0.0607418194,
0.0222662985,
0.0497568101,
-0.0450028218,
0.0054649445,
0.0294355769,
-0.0053900164,
0.0188173689,
-0.0069075045,
0.083338283,
0.0898464844,
-0.0173386838,
0.0482691862,
0.0000020823,
-0.0642435998,
0.0021136755,
-0.0229603872,
0.032089293,
0.0048805154,
0.07402426,
0.0266515836,
0.0046260832,
0.055254247,
-0.073720932,
0.0164962374,
0.0297610015,
0.0206057131,
0.0566903688,
0.0521902293,
-0.0119011113,
0.0091153225,
-0.0465962663,
-0.0171946175,
0.0117797693,
-0.0050805337,
0.0333551802,
-0.0246624965,
-0.0253340658,
-0.0370802805,
0.0051501417,
0.012316918,
0.0259499867,
0.0182820093,
0.0175669584,
0.0089559732,
-0.0619891547,
-0.0465001166,
-0.0095406417,
0.0665612891,
-0.0062289257,
-0.0667480901,
0.0098362174,
-0.0147403423,
0.0234914683,
0.0037165065,
-0.001120466,
0.0210209526,
0.0005374431,
0.0135555882,
0.0049721347,
-0.0016948074,
0.0177570954,
0.052356407,
0.0066111581,
0.0537725538,
0.0297953319,
-0.0182163492,
-0.0055932198,
0.045430962,
0.0247641634,
-0.0552162193,
0.0129212923,
-0.0241796114,
-0.0453202017,
0.0118955821,
-0.0768024325,
-0.0012141999,
0.0347658098,
-0.0338895991,
0.0225147754,
0.0243672896,
-0.0279349256,
0.0160841215,
0.0023054837,
-0.0098204827,
0.0157278702,
0.0014967198,
-0.0099860467,
0.005885019,
0.0192697104,
-0.0185223725,
-0.0232949872,
-0.034940552,
-0.0036152324,
0.0210323948,
-0.0351133794,
-0.0132657252,
-0.0664497763,
0.0036691795,
0.0053443168,
0.0144612584,
-0.024785161,
-0.0055206753,
-0.0200360399,
0.0062811808,
-0.0590256564,
0.0195391197,
-0.0395050161,
-0.0998897776,
0.0054036477,
0.0105087925,
0.0035222785,
-0.0233696885,
-0.0021050565,
0.0269800685,
-0.0019034345,
-0.0302377958,
-0.0318021066,
-0.0485508442,
-0.0195437185,
-0.0565803833,
-0.012120557,
-0.0626912117,
0.0371218212,
0.0220921729,
-0.0005250985,
-0.0606684648,
0.0010752884,
0.0286133345,
-0.0463177226,
0.0454505906,
0.0110523868,
0.0035623256,
0.0422089249,
0.0222563278,
0.0059112869,
0.1076307818,
0.010729311,
0.0113466401,
0.0601423159,
-0.0075114495,
0.0295067411,
0.0637117177,
0.0383231901,
0.0160799474,
-0.007138134,
-0.0055281185,
-0.0034599048,
0.0003923844,
0.0416468233,
0.069407016,
0.0203515608,
-0.0352909975,
0.0614563003,
0.0394191407,
-0.0153027456,
0.0295747127,
0.0319676138,
0.0339908861,
-0.0075572943,
0.0061433683,
-0.0770514831,
-0.0067512323,
-0.0501060747,
-0.0418940224,
0.002711009,
0.058489196,
-0.005449967,
-0.0119129289,
-0.0103943227,
0.003506565,
0.0560360737,
-0.0042999224,
0.0146972034,
0.022545062,
-0.0273097567,
0.0463452488,
0.0473792478,
-0.0691855475,
0.0232522413,
-0.0427748561,
0.0360488594,
0.032251358,
0.0282776691,
-0.0432329848,
0.0111822393,
-0.0130822062,
-0.0113181574,
0.0599099919,
0.0948727205,
-0.0062073376,
-0.0257441755,
-0.0404949076,
0.0081954105,
0.014658751,
0.0419277214,
0.0167251192,
0.0876427814,
0.0416375808,
0.0259133838,
-0.044416815,
-0.0492946021,
0.0352380686,
-0.0051852921,
-0.0105449529,
-0.0142832417,
0.0052710664,
0.0115991887,
0.0271215327,
-0.0445862375,
-0.0149286715,
-0.0211081002,
0.0067635193,
-0.0206634551,
0.0457662605,
-0.0607911833,
-0.0192844998,
0.0151697416,
-0.0666404665,
-0.0566035323,
0.0599131323,
-0.0289436784,
0.0071463464,
0.0582760721,
-0.0026025733,
0.0337491073,
-0.0408687219,
-0.0127295684,
-0.0440957919,
0.0434291773,
-0.0257619787,
0.0295423958,
0.0120711559,
-0.0339317359,
-0.0094199479,
-0.0320214555,
0.019625688,
-0.0378359891,
-0.0365319811,
-0.0053807651,
-0.0226012878,
0.0142874224,
0.0210455954,
0.0128841177,
-0.0461539477,
-0.0049534123,
-0.1083006561,
-0.0329236649,
-0.0271138046,
-0.0021633869,
0.0056721452,
0.0080413623,
-0.0445338711,
-0.017928537,
-0.021028338,
-0.0067370925,
0.0307018422,
0.0274367854,
0.0086285016,
-0.0498902202,
0.0155228944,
-0.0617957152,
-0.0039106128,
-0.0577876307,
0.0499311052,
0.0441972278,
0.0095175859,
-0.0186735559,
-0.0185332205,
-0.028363958,
0.0126509126,
0.0242955573,
-0.0459185876,
0.0206637047,
0.020517502,
0.0223385599,
0.0811638162,
0.0429768749,
0.021511808,
0.0398333445,
-0.0047321552,
-0.0473197699,
-0.0216107983,
-0.0048624617,
0.0160580017,
0.0077764411,
-0.0565051287,
-0.0066946764,
0.0572549999,
0.050480146,
-0.01550538,
-0.0695095658,
0.0561076179,
-0.0489354841,
-0.0542540364,
0.0026282475,
-0.0363774374,
-0.0120302131,
0.0073788632,
-0.0360765383,
-0.0546258613,
0.0607290156,
-0.0139581738,
-0.0046249307,
-0.0226900503,
0.0079580788,
-0.0365870558,
0.0519199707,
0.011695304,
0.0226899534,
0.0106291277,
0.0042923344,
-0.0417250432,
-0.0167145412,
0.0187995192,
-0.0314523242,
-0.0079800095,
-0.0536400713,
-0.0051275343,
0.0079449741,
-0.0275302231,
-0.0491030142,
-0.0598536246,
-0.0534220636,
-0.0211505145,
0.0005424158,
-0.0228559226,
0.0462134741,
-0.0182151869,
-0.0158225354,
0.0166548863,
-0.0386653356,
0.0109327435,
0.0126943616,
-0.0008483942,
0.0316691734,
-0.0305501148,
0.0177973676,
-0.0255310722,
-0.0184517186,
0.0228574555,
0.0121676587,
0.0284765922,
-0.036019519,
0.002009454,
0.0187482946,
-0.0183188077,
0.0203939117,
-0.0025486036,
0.0554266423,
-0.0308488943,
0.0264937952,
0.1134633794,
0.0188300703,
-0.0464873537,
0.0211209785,
0.0021210285,
0.0377623364,
0.0317708254,
0.029528534,
-0.1326396912,
-0.0128978984,
-0.003803021,
0.0160057284,
-0.0329655223,
-0.0313363187,
-0.0146536725,
-0.1247232631,
0.0231200662,
0.0000972714,
-0.0321528502,
-0.0045010955,
-0.0154677825,
0.0099345874,
-0.013711703,
0.0275929943,
-0.0164955463,
0.0084252628,
0.0228187609,
-0.0046393829,
-0.0581657887,
-0.0478822254,
0.0425914265,
-0.0544655137,
0.0635064915,
0.0393032692,
0.0350467749,
-0.0273434259,
0.0000959376,
0.0716097653,
0.0055342908,
-0.0214136895,
-0.0452098213,
0.0266819131,
-0.0431561321,
-0.0315989666,
0.0120281931,
0.0542213731,
-0.0070331087,
0.0119728679,
0.0235773157,
0.0277027059,
0.0287125744,
-0.0767783448,
-0.0222214442,
0.0280160122,
0.0270030405,
0.0932015106,
0.0489429608,
-0.0353080072,
-0.0029365963,
-0.051775001,
0.0082186013,
-0.0012650231,
-0.0823383555,
0.0138275335,
0.0031200722,
-0.0375694558,
-0.0495717004,
-0.0536809005,
0.0431506671,
0.0047214609,
0.0085935816,
-0.0755168647,
0.0204669386,
-0.0027074886,
-0.0416347235,
0.055956956,
-0.0422891974,
0.0454420224,
0.0057555628,
-0.0291148517,
-0.005102911,
-0.0346101075,
-0.0215227008,
0.0136322621,
-0.016257884,
-0.0751200393,
0.0737292245,
0.042027697,
0.0197509136,
0.0291966572,
-0.0340974815,
-0.0709282309,
0.0540496632,
0.0530951284,
-0.0259467624,
0.0534970388,
0.0293825921,
-0.0204221178,
0.0058266688,
0.03539804,
-0.0346204191,
0.0392690152,
-0.0012970109,
-0.0119514158,
-0.0069233184,
-0.0418475643,
-0.0076939696,
0.0035581135,
0.0500368439,
-0.0412147976,
0.0182922333,
-0.0612124056,
-0.0367636569,
-0.0261571556,
-0.0623341389,
-0.0095914155,
-0.0298043638,
-0.0141188717,
0.0132560339,
-0.0329028033,
-0.0359218158,
-0.076422438,
0.0334761739,
-0.0284020603,
0.0366070233,
0.0141716087,
0.0531525612,
0.0242073871,
-0.0200335253,
-0.0207355879,
0.0253776051,
-0.0598470382,
0.0343521088,
0.0172901079,
0.0450356528,
0.0173430443,
-0.0127214817,
0.0002276081,
0.0177953597,
-0.0036468559,
-0.0153847141,
-0.02613209,
0.0260699764,
0.0275167525,
-0.0341342688,
0.0429643095,
-0.0201733746,
0.0019387577,
-0.0015741807,
0.0120499041,
0.0044274363,
-0.046300631,
0.0167919304,
-0.0190910231,
-0.0344013385,
0.0166707113,
0.0564697124,
0.0010965214,
0.0570954233,
0.0219559614,
-0.023380056,
-0.0133218747,
-0.0462249629,
0.0359022655,
-0.0200196076,
-0.0219556056,
-0.026253609,
-0.072895743,
-0.0724073872,
-0.0229121204,
0.0439193323,
0.0106783817,
0.0063178502,
0.0353569649,
0.0785000771,
-0.0356600843,
0.0056291516,
-0.004914342,
-0.0054314611,
-0.0307789836,
-0.0157687403,
-0.0248990655,
-6.89761571e-33,
-0.0134560708,
-0.0326311402,
-0.0184181184,
-0.0209345631,
-0.0140134403,
0.0032423381,
-0.0457960144,
0.0306733008,
-0.0063580894,
0.0225330256,
-0.0058482252,
0.0307523087,
0.0224689208,
-0.0086816652,
0.0008691596,
-0.0041768956,
0.0520543531,
-0.0092518516,
-0.0231629331,
0.0062815668,
-0.0258779377,
0.0137949763,
0.0427486077,
-0.0656323135,
0.0307969172,
0.0008242723,
-0.0356680863,
0.0022988557,
-0.0124359801,
-0.0088364184,
-0.0121428166,
0.0694160238,
0.0223448295,
0.0178603735,
0.0205085259,
0.0576640591,
-0.0117769027,
-0.0380789824,
0.0121031683,
0.0160524715,
-0.0084301457,
-0.0023814251,
0.0297482703,
-0.0186919644,
-0.0548105538,
0.0263518225,
0.0489133298,
0.0216409806,
0.0665945411,
0.0248601064,
-0.0738708228,
0.0333260894,
-0.0202305093,
0.0128505956,
-0.0538534336,
0.0109620709,
0.0277669374,
-0.0010794131,
-0.0028713292,
0.0268422086,
-0.0169229247,
-0.0185037404,
0.0571892299,
0.0065228995,
0.0049685016,
0.0677709803,
0.0248702448,
0.0506254695,
-0.0132533321,
-0.0351220928,
0.0739028379,
-0.0206491984,
0.0321329571,
0.107161589,
-0.0016766426,
-0.0274596624,
0.0140638798,
0.0085223773,
0.0851137117,
-0.0199463572,
0.0217505358,
-0.0252621341,
-0.0700667202,
-0.0487244353,
-0.0376197249,
-0.0632702783,
-0.0115937833,
-0.0208165105,
0.0315038487,
0.0080775702,
-0.0498163253,
0.0052105282,
0.0059021069,
-0.0388589017,
-0.0035513723,
0.0023494768,
-0.0446853824,
-0.0422054976,
0.0011643829,
0.0276717618,
-0.0558916777,
-0.0095684137,
0.0088846665,
0.0163264927,
0.0346683599,
0.000063612,
-0.0083917323,
0.0064799297,
-0.0551573671,
0.031928923,
-0.0045706714,
0.0131856203,
-0.0024022581,
-0.0103595946,
0.0282434803,
0.0522271693,
-0.0117164105,
0.0051211957,
0.053081885,
0.0149739394,
-0.0703901425,
-0.0324224792,
-0.0251991432,
0.0357808657,
-0.0468928963,
-0.0214065146,
-0.0310728587,
-0.0018018533,
0.0381568223,
-0.0538194887,
-0.0112907672,
-0.0483746305,
2.7e-7,
0.0144555317,
0.0689999238,
-0.0051267198,
0.049135033,
0.0008135514,
0.0394579768,
0.0487054102,
0.0725111514,
0.0150530357,
0.0237106439,
-0.0114367772,
0.0542841293,
0.0505841449,
0.0412006192,
-0.0591733716,
-0.0026585311,
-0.0899143219,
0.0306607392,
-0.055791527,
-0.0126843387,
-0.0012850591,
0.0512341969,
0.054787349,
0.0073176525,
-0.0208317246,
-0.0362310633,
0.0210899115,
-0.0266716667,
-0.0027814826,
0.0253407881,
0.0232000314,
0.0014212474,
0.0241426453,
0.0219935998,
-0.0061792745,
0.0087896818,
-0.0213229284,
0.0072590844,
0.0024814603,
0.0107307136,
-0.01548714,
-0.0054516532,
-0.0237644147,
-0.0968931764,
0.065183349,
-0.0047020544,
0.0020465921,
-0.0725048333,
-0.0083772913,
-0.0380633958,
0.0439338721,
-0.0365971178,
-0.0420273468,
0.011007986,
0.0247663073,
-0.0125664603,
-0.0154011669,
-0.0701829195,
-0.0419454388,
-0.0341896042,
-0.0217317566,
-0.0444174036,
0.0184554048,
0.0340033509,
-0.0090926457,
-0.0185030438,
0.0531800799,
2.480207673e-34,
0.0381047279,
0.0140225682,
0.0192185529,
-0.0408330336,
0.07035584,
0.0173515566,
-0.0093668709,
-0.0039975215,
0.0338932946,
-0.0281845275,
-0.0042974562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07346v1 | ScatterShot: Interactive In-context Example Curation for Text Transformation | 2023-02-14T21:13:31 | 2023-02-14T21:13:31 | Tongshuang Wu, Hua Shen, Daniel S. Weld, Jeffrey Heer, Marco Tulio Ribeiro | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The in-context learning capabilities of LLMs like GPT-3 allow annotators to
customize an LLM to their specific tasks with a small number of examples.
However, users tend to include only the most obvious patterns when crafting
examples, resulting in underspecified in-context functions that fall short on
unseen cases. Further, it is hard to know when "enough" examples have been
included even for known patterns. In this work, we present ScatterShot, an
interactive system for building high-quality demonstration sets for in-context
learning. ScatterShot iteratively slices unlabeled data into task-specific
patterns, samples informative inputs from underexplored or not-yet-saturated
slices in an active learning manner, and helps users label more efficiently
with the help of an LLM and the current example set. In simulation studies on
two text perturbation scenarios, ScatterShot sampling improves the resulting
few-shot functions by 4-5 percentage points over random sampling, with less
variance as more examples are added. In a user study, ScatterShot greatly helps
users in covering different patterns in the input space and labeling in-context
examples more efficiently, resulting in better in-context learning and less
user effort. | [
0.0056766528,
-0.0293912515,
-0.0013996949,
-0.0018436795,
-0.0329398699,
0.0073296619,
0.0321960114,
0.024203008,
-0.0353349037,
-0.049145896,
-0.0121697178,
0.0335284732,
-0.0288949087,
0.0150087541,
0.033615645,
-0.0761311427,
0.008355015,
-0.0261114798,
-0.0252563562,
0.0460741594,
0.0494957231,
0.0034621833,
-0.0232678689,
0.0262827557,
-0.0463369898,
-0.0242575798,
-0.0083646467,
0.0296923723,
0.0134123359,
-0.0339115188,
0.0137138376,
0.0274282061,
0.0209983047,
0.0225514993,
0.0000021796,
-0.0315820873,
-0.0425892547,
0.0057841144,
-0.0243453048,
0.0128162857,
0.0895524397,
0.0155002382,
-0.0227123536,
0.0187734421,
-0.0499845184,
0.0443195589,
0.0413148142,
0.0479719527,
0.0570264272,
0.0507075302,
-0.0339607373,
0.0248162318,
-0.0398005098,
-0.0161510333,
0.0697843507,
0.0083215376,
0.0016831333,
-0.0212955754,
0.026336221,
0.0225527976,
0.0054445071,
0.0550046526,
0.0307603776,
-0.0301892068,
0.0300862063,
0.0284150001,
-0.0583869368,
-0.0048278472,
-0.0256306976,
0.0802981779,
-0.0342182554,
-0.0231093857,
-0.0111260125,
-0.0444131792,
0.0278212409,
0.0350189433,
-0.0783752576,
-0.0407986566,
-0.0107929716,
0.0165085364,
-0.0394714102,
0.0136401132,
-0.005066392,
-0.0219502263,
-0.008432704,
0.0106375394,
-0.0220595729,
-0.0265822317,
-0.0162465312,
0.0047988398,
-0.0120453164,
-0.0297533777,
0.0406993814,
0.0211688317,
-0.0161786526,
0.0327824764,
-0.0620480701,
-0.0739691108,
0.0158352293,
-0.0336209759,
0.0666410476,
0.0100788744,
-0.02818406,
0.0472113378,
-0.0285243895,
-0.0192052145,
0.0070659835,
0.0402951539,
-0.0339973643,
-0.0000497066,
-0.0655898824,
0.0026075752,
-0.0699972361,
0.0252178609,
-0.0284234285,
-0.010815369,
-0.0248367023,
0.0648535937,
0.0064836396,
0.0054568038,
-0.0059512011,
-0.0000788505,
-0.0710181519,
0.0053859735,
-0.0000547161,
-0.0039807479,
-0.0393099077,
0.0193956792,
0.0103430487,
-0.0468046404,
-0.0227553137,
0.0173150208,
0.0349422432,
-0.0250935033,
-0.0037485585,
0.069181934,
-0.0449875183,
-0.045640368,
-0.0303456429,
-0.019252615,
-0.0086279623,
0.0179325249,
-0.0198882818,
-0.0792149678,
-0.0204746854,
0.0163291246,
-0.024264602,
-0.0411991253,
0.0097165629,
0.0495033972,
-0.0158143025,
0.0842491761,
-0.0338432603,
-0.0084835822,
0.0403162688,
0.0143575873,
-0.0211001057,
0.0640042201,
0.0330760367,
0.0213810354,
0.0557956249,
0.0213359501,
0.0607232414,
0.0638180077,
0.0525490716,
0.0434867702,
-0.0507604815,
0.0081753461,
0.0086837392,
0.0337272994,
0.0118309967,
0.0036144569,
-0.0482170805,
0.0311184488,
0.0726022795,
0.0594510771,
0.0126453238,
0.0179067608,
0.0115084033,
0.0196060594,
0.0067878971,
-0.0028126957,
-0.0303278621,
0.0240557194,
-0.0311731696,
0.0013028515,
-0.0257247426,
0.012528846,
-0.0130762486,
-0.0537418127,
-0.0012304103,
-0.0024285284,
0.0198200382,
-0.0234273188,
0.0421714522,
0.0653116629,
-0.0397104844,
0.0463272147,
-0.000092075,
-0.0709904954,
-0.0363893583,
-0.0045290431,
0.0107282996,
0.0631176829,
0.0495269336,
-0.0858906955,
-0.0124793174,
-0.0229056366,
0.0602415502,
0.0118018631,
0.0234352909,
-0.0298873764,
-0.0080888718,
-0.0404175073,
-0.0353856944,
-0.0076439567,
-0.0147584956,
-0.0232386049,
0.0509536862,
0.0028165623,
0.0049011875,
-0.0626221076,
-0.0284291711,
0.0525642075,
-0.0060664485,
-0.0460222326,
0.022235455,
-0.0109506249,
0.0078154467,
-0.0039365878,
0.0120265195,
-0.0061613596,
0.035595011,
-0.0246001668,
0.0119874049,
0.0197659209,
-0.0193929002,
-0.0587706454,
-0.0041435449,
-0.0412950441,
-0.0229072608,
-0.0465580784,
-0.0743041635,
-0.0211083721,
-0.0586647727,
-0.0279798396,
0.0158991329,
-0.0219332594,
-0.0026661996,
0.0019464818,
-0.0106299119,
-0.0628508627,
0.0611781888,
0.0310072042,
-0.0185140874,
0.0263601094,
0.0206262246,
-0.014577345,
0.007650868,
0.0236445945,
-0.0179521348,
0.013974309,
-0.0208559614,
-0.0105591463,
0.0317709744,
-0.0568916686,
0.0016968315,
-0.0674567297,
-0.0172066502,
-0.0258472934,
0.0174815767,
0.0248054843,
0.0316196643,
-0.033152204,
-0.0472306311,
-0.0337017775,
-0.009821373,
-0.042308066,
0.0100982729,
0.0595744364,
0.040162079,
0.0148682501,
-0.02670555,
0.0268082395,
0.0044721649,
0.0266484972,
0.0318108387,
-0.0294126421,
-0.0546166785,
0.0297653675,
0.0203085057,
-0.0105856908,
0.0102188606,
0.0377160087,
0.0154548567,
-0.0005116923,
0.0538371988,
0.0244135875,
-0.0125971707,
0.0617869906,
-0.0051821857,
0.0013200968,
-0.0514252782,
0.0222077519,
-0.0060162749,
0.0309529882,
-0.0107565345,
-0.0127963722,
0.0450602211,
0.0104649998,
-0.0005312268,
-0.0005456569,
-0.0145498887,
0.0180223975,
0.0120225521,
-0.0109381424,
-0.0672353804,
-0.0067875162,
-0.0345049016,
0.0107306847,
0.0047645895,
-0.0684552789,
0.0614476353,
-0.0086805914,
-0.0094628688,
-0.0555873401,
-0.0485625006,
-0.0295402389,
0.0367457382,
-0.0049547097,
-0.0222040955,
-0.0105266068,
-0.0187066309,
-0.0429625772,
0.0116177155,
0.0182579122,
-0.0141423028,
0.0528550372,
-0.0486437976,
0.0035902911,
-0.0346656851,
-0.0469757244,
-0.0179657899,
-0.0455025025,
0.0164258201,
0.004606328,
0.0035323929,
-0.004802715,
-0.030614933,
0.0017099916,
0.0302463546,
0.1053193286,
-0.0160088409,
-0.0519026592,
-0.0209831782,
0.0200385433,
0.0048150886,
0.0125088869,
-0.0356981605,
-0.02175528,
0.0037196672,
0.0531794727,
0.0408873819,
-0.0509984419,
-0.0050332434,
0.0004995902,
-0.004009028,
-0.0585580207,
-0.013505131,
0.023021102,
0.0569031388,
-0.0532805435,
-0.0334197655,
0.0737394392,
0.053668458,
-0.0845339298,
0.0060414532,
-0.0098591438,
0.0426508673,
0.0401480384,
0.0376838185,
-0.1041387245,
-0.0364837199,
0.0065184706,
0.0315010659,
0.011091521,
-0.0092535242,
-0.0060499348,
-0.086254023,
0.0537947379,
0.0155490758,
-0.0624581277,
0.0265354477,
-0.0223161634,
0.0315973498,
0.0014074569,
-0.0076563088,
-0.0049166032,
-0.0343643762,
0.0130872568,
0.0214786846,
-0.012669717,
-0.0673161149,
-0.030876711,
0.001380389,
-0.0112175625,
0.0249048471,
0.007425284,
0.012375324,
-0.0157245509,
0.0405804515,
0.0155342594,
0.0238388348,
-0.044263497,
0.0770698786,
0.0232334472,
0.0115594575,
0.0004979849,
0.0396040492,
-0.0118611669,
-0.0441189259,
0.0228651594,
0.0603600778,
-0.019756794,
0.049248971,
-0.0368952975,
-0.071125403,
0.074966304,
0.0265998375,
0.0575189069,
-0.0540842414,
-0.0165649876,
-0.0525913611,
-0.0056543406,
-0.0296246316,
-0.0088750944,
0.0085047558,
-0.045170106,
0.0203471798,
-0.0788630992,
0.0001220963,
0.0893670693,
0.0902065262,
0.0048903828,
0.0173988827,
-0.0305819903,
0.0053222287,
-0.0470465645,
-0.0025127006,
-0.0244097654,
0.0208268818,
-0.0114891557,
-0.0192330834,
0.0226767343,
-0.0189695023,
-0.0129424734,
0.0448747389,
-0.0492016487,
-0.0417146832,
0.0016046228,
0.0057651713,
0.0239318069,
0.0563787408,
-0.0070898221,
-0.0451334231,
0.0897278413,
0.0708411634,
0.0015866932,
-0.0284630265,
0.006432245,
0.0169501975,
0.0008935086,
0.0051587974,
-0.0482900925,
0.0216856766,
-0.0262234304,
-0.0137082692,
-0.0749350637,
-0.0136570279,
0.0020392493,
-0.0102821141,
0.0480789617,
0.0018315878,
-0.0382423587,
-0.0112023652,
0.0425581969,
-0.0101528373,
-0.0164186973,
-0.0346815698,
0.0329191908,
-0.0176614318,
-0.0346317925,
-0.0085285744,
0.0557054989,
-0.0198791772,
0.0673891604,
-0.0717051178,
0.0307376496,
-0.0024711979,
0.0104327789,
0.0157860983,
0.0330300927,
0.0129939979,
-0.006282873,
0.0001905644,
0.0424310118,
-0.0095467409,
0.0432003699,
0.0306822956,
0.024293201,
0.0044335853,
0.0364397727,
-0.07777825,
0.0216492042,
-0.0843955353,
0.030881254,
-0.000366091,
0.0015772907,
0.0579269342,
-0.0355171934,
-0.0358027332,
0.0304476507,
0.0190769676,
-0.0039729071,
-0.0179628562,
-0.0059430273,
0.0025657939,
-0.0036288961,
-0.0188067518,
0.0686294138,
0.0063344641,
0.0251740851,
-0.0013392953,
-0.0018195092,
-0.0511495024,
0.0255843699,
0.0655706748,
0.0124710258,
0.0272986926,
-0.0470373183,
-0.0196233802,
-0.0341601111,
0.0344756581,
-0.0189153813,
-0.0388024859,
-0.0258437805,
0.0568479337,
0.0630563349,
0.0012486315,
0.0036427549,
0.0153986719,
0.0071198917,
0.0129414201,
-0.0642895401,
-0.0080119884,
-6.27435832e-33,
-0.0527045168,
-0.0667300448,
0.0180698503,
0.0119565539,
0.0107717477,
-0.0108450195,
0.0017419156,
0.0005394121,
0.0605176166,
-0.0004316508,
-0.0325720683,
0.0068720509,
0.0280019157,
0.0044245431,
-0.0023071687,
-0.0000470839,
0.056855537,
-0.0223700702,
-0.0320906937,
0.0482423864,
0.0155637432,
0.0458637588,
0.0670782998,
-0.1126515865,
0.0126533518,
0.0224363282,
-0.0507782735,
-0.0125515163,
0.0039191465,
0.0418862067,
0.0047316388,
0.0512582026,
0.0019935519,
-0.0268675443,
-0.0369095281,
0.0404726341,
-0.0826458633,
-0.0443008058,
-0.0051644766,
0.0155032612,
-0.0339833274,
-0.0395784788,
0.0584917739,
-0.0263357498,
0.003314022,
0.0417318642,
0.0457261279,
-0.0338499211,
-0.0296070036,
-0.0513851158,
-0.0590884238,
0.0271109808,
-0.008521324,
-0.0027119126,
0.0266504902,
0.0334927067,
0.0133314831,
0.0084147425,
-0.0828250572,
0.0062751193,
0.0239785127,
0.0138967261,
0.0458074734,
0.0169309899,
0.01315419,
0.0473400615,
-0.0397534743,
-0.0039756037,
0.027438404,
-0.0456827246,
0.0334991999,
0.052347552,
0.0354432166,
0.06496346,
0.0748691037,
-0.0066824728,
-0.0264330562,
0.0507297218,
0.0145130428,
-0.0448590405,
0.021191828,
0.0564044453,
-0.0326443575,
-0.0095644435,
-0.0117420983,
-0.004759986,
-0.0214207545,
-0.0481324792,
0.0249949358,
0.0234483164,
-0.023871839,
0.0471852645,
0.0137521317,
0.0221925713,
-0.0510483757,
-0.0271842014,
-0.0287186205,
0.0534797348,
-0.0115974499,
-0.0483377464,
-0.0469919741,
-0.0515802242,
0.0204183664,
0.0275547467,
0.0341673419,
-0.0112365568,
0.0900736377,
0.0446707122,
-0.0771759003,
0.0097110448,
0.0209568683,
0.0309784915,
0.0173835959,
-0.000461666,
0.0035106675,
-0.0134476619,
-0.0218448285,
0.0142464247,
0.0345251635,
-0.0599253327,
-0.0358682983,
-0.0136483964,
-0.0370597579,
0.0022284754,
-0.0341907851,
-0.0121924803,
0.001076959,
0.015227003,
0.0657140538,
-0.0808064565,
-0.0121567203,
0.0350559503,
2.871e-7,
0.067625463,
0.080761753,
0.0188920628,
-0.0260760114,
0.0393585712,
0.0119246198,
-0.0150863314,
0.0160480589,
-0.0000272402,
-0.0156768505,
0.0513652749,
-0.0094156424,
0.0550034866,
0.0702963844,
-0.0951864943,
-0.0347927362,
-0.0431979373,
0.0260590818,
-0.054810036,
0.024272101,
0.0546134934,
0.0717074275,
0.0220630784,
-0.0155378794,
0.0154596344,
-0.0471843369,
0.0594642349,
-0.048343502,
0.0368027799,
0.0048754937,
-0.0080669951,
0.010713188,
-0.0106800972,
0.0108038587,
-0.0230221041,
-0.0112137478,
0.0256195609,
0.043151468,
-0.0109570138,
-0.0272106845,
0.0004353733,
-0.0249884445,
0.0315538831,
-0.0242493544,
0.037187878,
-0.0847362801,
0.0140932575,
0.0212511327,
0.008770681,
-0.031014232,
0.0161724426,
0.0070454376,
-0.0241312385,
0.0189213995,
0.0156494975,
0.0245255306,
-0.0541005023,
-0.0714333355,
-0.0273137894,
-0.007146134,
-0.0230725426,
-0.0093212482,
-0.0756651014,
0.0193273649,
-0.0083355494,
-0.0080543533,
0.0082502514,
3.082503428e-34,
0.0308729,
0.0053277733,
-0.0000702383,
0.0628956035,
0.0000085123,
0.0129662007,
0.0247688349,
0.0189206451,
0.0288718585,
-0.0557786748,
-0.0184306614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07324v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07324v2 | READIN: A Chinese Multi-Task Benchmark with Realistic and Diverse Input Noises | 2023-02-14T20:14:39 | 2023-05-25T01:04:08 | Chenglei Si, Zhengyan Zhang, Yingfa Chen, Xiaozhi Wang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | For many real-world applications, the user-generated inputs usually contain
various noises due to speech recognition errors caused by linguistic
variations1 or typographical errors (typos). Thus, it is crucial to test model
performance on data with realistic input noises to ensure robustness and
fairness. However, little study has been done to construct such benchmarks for
Chinese, where various language-specific input noises happen in the real world.
In order to fill this important gap, we construct READIN: a Chinese multi-task
benchmark with REalistic And Diverse Input Noises. READIN contains four diverse
tasks and requests annotators to re-enter the original test data with two
commonly used Chinese input methods: Pinyin input and speech input. We designed
our annotation pipeline to maximize diversity, for example by instructing the
annotators to use diverse input method editors (IMEs) for keyboard noises and
recruiting speakers from diverse dialectical groups for speech noises. We
experiment with a series of strong pretrained language models as well as robust
training methods, we find that these models often suffer significant
performance drops on READIN even with robustness methods like data
augmentation. As the first large-scale attempt in creating a benchmark with
noises geared towards user-generated inputs, we believe that READIN serves as
an important complement to existing Chinese NLP benchmarks. The source code and
dataset can be obtained from https://github.com/thunlp/READIN. | [
0.0016102901,
0.0479633585,
0.0181841366,
0.0578635186,
0.0142574692,
-0.0066692419,
0.0189696699,
0.0065962221,
0.0054765521,
-0.027874114,
-0.0860224143,
-0.0545235835,
0.0248329043,
-0.0267027635,
0.0409363098,
-0.0376264378,
0.049415946,
-0.016582232,
-0.0183073301,
0.0151648885,
0.0299751833,
-0.0320967175,
0.0031586855,
0.0612109378,
-0.022517411,
-0.0179059114,
0.006158181,
0.0431385934,
0.0203845948,
-0.0082075382,
0.0337627791,
0.0788918287,
-0.0265858434,
0.0752914175,
0.000001904,
-0.0154158333,
-0.0019022216,
0.0071043544,
-0.0462954417,
0.0376482382,
0.022910472,
0.0245087687,
-0.0562697351,
0.0240470078,
-0.0043541179,
-0.0372595452,
0.054574348,
0.0858820602,
0.044021111,
0.0954121053,
-0.0122068217,
0.0244314764,
-0.001536787,
-0.0268094223,
-0.0145966494,
-0.0148428166,
0.0053402395,
-0.0094219446,
-0.0081845894,
-0.0321712531,
0.0017449707,
0.0026820225,
0.0041583572,
0.0137765622,
-0.019155547,
0.0151910139,
-0.0356469937,
-0.0096308766,
-0.0429569967,
0.0911240429,
-0.0498406254,
0.0060183676,
-0.0332267806,
-0.0171094369,
-0.0084032035,
-0.0316542611,
-0.0097790174,
-0.0042742253,
-0.0220888034,
0.0189479664,
0.0105154254,
0.015744701,
0.0541520342,
-0.0066571739,
0.010355209,
0.0124614965,
0.0174802411,
-0.0658484697,
0.0103982789,
0.0137100173,
0.005350084,
-0.0334879868,
0.0163235255,
-0.0001060792,
-0.065574646,
0.0024135089,
-0.033326149,
-0.0656786039,
-0.0060760505,
-0.0706405118,
0.0484451354,
0.0462891832,
-0.0594302937,
0.0255251825,
0.0127614941,
0.0511990525,
-0.0064036977,
0.0007187158,
-0.026202023,
-0.0252235513,
-0.0017501718,
0.0138517534,
-0.0311460085,
0.0284519829,
-0.0133839389,
-0.0093473699,
-0.0209618416,
0.0134435417,
-0.0553566664,
0.0273719281,
0.0579155236,
-0.0213118792,
-0.083459191,
0.0055105668,
0.020594202,
0.0066480227,
-0.020597592,
0.0378148779,
0.0081705106,
-0.0677511841,
-0.0054437602,
0.0174911134,
0.0134787299,
-0.0465890169,
0.0113755092,
0.0578351058,
-0.009826133,
-0.0109159946,
-0.0431505628,
0.0122479573,
-0.0133819617,
-0.031522084,
-0.0377240144,
-0.0264248177,
0.0137527091,
-0.0411319956,
0.041256126,
-0.056713149,
0.0035330786,
-0.002878089,
0.0084683662,
0.0764795989,
-0.0049846196,
-0.027051352,
0.0069339913,
0.0061764917,
-0.0406969376,
0.0778538287,
0.043507535,
-0.0233771689,
0.0482159071,
-0.0158718824,
0.0155153647,
0.0741765723,
-0.0390769206,
0.000766238,
0.0208482351,
-0.0241743643,
0.0079811271,
0.0319481343,
0.0265675392,
0.0609093904,
-0.047033947,
0.0014502445,
0.0645674989,
0.0442618728,
0.0120389005,
-0.0084552672,
0.0005642821,
-0.0208286587,
0.0000951903,
0.0211961158,
-0.051476106,
-0.0047651012,
-0.0243674479,
0.0394166,
0.0599975921,
0.0087839998,
-0.0397371687,
-0.047232151,
-0.042887859,
-0.0170646906,
0.0091279084,
-0.0101586413,
0.0500304997,
0.0014841571,
-0.0256121028,
0.0089814728,
0.0308812521,
-0.072541818,
0.0162085611,
-0.0046733753,
-0.0213698801,
0.0875066519,
0.0213383995,
-0.0306463838,
-0.012752505,
-0.0228613634,
-0.0142147355,
0.0678702742,
0.0527337827,
-0.0203876067,
0.0200587064,
-0.0601764135,
-0.0164235849,
0.0608517379,
0.0188286193,
0.0472780727,
0.0168632437,
0.0062888814,
0.0038906129,
-0.0413418151,
-0.0441178977,
0.0293450952,
-0.0607713126,
-0.0207588226,
0.0212102812,
-0.0028897438,
0.0402612798,
0.0455516577,
-0.0701063424,
0.0077104238,
-0.0019336327,
-0.0307928566,
0.0085984599,
0.0478632934,
-0.0253217295,
-0.0239681993,
0.0656437129,
-0.0319390856,
-0.0413202345,
0.0641893074,
-0.0309429783,
-0.0726636723,
0.0058157463,
0.0249629114,
-0.0027544689,
-0.0856418237,
0.0167684313,
-0.012190666,
0.0288727786,
-0.0136127882,
0.0222039204,
0.0123399366,
0.0251350943,
-0.0209684819,
0.0380559303,
0.0022789519,
-0.0827246234,
-0.0727382898,
0.0210190229,
-0.0130468225,
0.0405298583,
-0.0020296457,
0.0142200561,
-0.0224954914,
0.0018810024,
-0.1084953547,
0.0243058838,
-0.0627965555,
0.007246919,
0.0132388687,
0.0158841703,
-0.0096448576,
-0.032298971,
-0.0276631862,
-0.0114813251,
-0.0269468352,
0.0272980426,
-0.0135634262,
-0.0080321543,
0.0245084167,
-0.0444307104,
0.0022765556,
0.0039657224,
-0.0100355474,
-0.0133017311,
-0.0628041327,
-0.03067757,
0.0016063706,
0.0431967489,
0.034789741,
-0.0015510482,
-0.032081902,
0.0095621794,
0.0110204257,
0.0850422308,
0.0363939516,
-0.02245171,
0.0243441891,
0.024048293,
-0.0069760401,
-0.0224739518,
0.0325893573,
0.036049623,
0.0308595169,
-0.0312690809,
-0.0338728391,
-0.0255969092,
0.0743679479,
-0.0076783011,
-0.0005713762,
-0.0606841817,
-0.0554667041,
-0.0581084229,
-0.031666901,
-0.0236670412,
-0.0104873469,
-0.072872147,
0.0093301563,
-0.0289546661,
-0.0024455686,
0.0481721796,
-0.0665406585,
-0.030500507,
-0.0351296589,
0.0067918533,
0.0099015767,
0.0258048624,
-0.0302400663,
-0.0188208576,
0.0103040766,
-0.0365957282,
-0.0313719995,
0.0406144261,
0.0379875898,
-0.0485973731,
0.0575527996,
-0.01846404,
0.0129866982,
-0.0412540771,
-0.0489559509,
-0.0484992974,
-0.0010981822,
-0.0317423306,
0.00556699,
0.0315456688,
-0.0487370417,
0.0453968048,
0.031434048,
-0.0195618067,
0.0895576477,
-0.0231324229,
0.0310214441,
-0.0063955481,
0.00622406,
0.0200346094,
0.0600223504,
0.0070819962,
-0.0400237888,
0.0342563763,
0.0245088115,
0.0696754977,
0.0007647453,
-0.0270594917,
-0.001072556,
0.0265136324,
-0.0120023536,
-0.0148279592,
0.0203148387,
0.0893169791,
-0.0529806502,
-0.0165923648,
0.1014167964,
-0.0045638285,
-0.0306287035,
0.0036272502,
0.0099310856,
0.0336091742,
0.0117013529,
-0.0101178549,
-0.0749477372,
-0.0388075002,
0.0490911417,
0.0364057794,
0.0076050502,
-0.0046389201,
0.0181482453,
-0.1191377863,
0.0486446731,
0.0125425849,
-0.0272687916,
-0.0208171122,
-0.0393783078,
0.0195834413,
-0.0513490811,
0.0861189514,
-0.0206413288,
0.0315895565,
-0.0113683091,
0.0596231632,
-0.0404486731,
-0.0824610963,
-0.01494502,
-0.0324199498,
0.076662682,
0.0419138074,
-0.0128234308,
-0.0165108182,
0.0156878587,
0.0703879073,
0.0303601269,
-0.0296084471,
0.0008043963,
0.0341590904,
0.0288467947,
-0.0391904078,
0.0073973504,
0.0227471367,
-0.0314213634,
0.0095654437,
0.030686764,
0.0405054204,
-0.002113339,
0.031797912,
0.0116260527,
-0.0135369999,
0.0353650078,
0.0967812762,
0.0365326069,
-0.0530572683,
-0.0242636669,
-0.0493501462,
-0.0251778513,
-0.1043837443,
-0.0224336516,
0.0612406768,
-0.028985858,
-0.0599175654,
-0.0777418166,
-0.0866495967,
-0.0057917289,
0.0179112516,
0.0285184644,
0.0162162092,
0.0295761451,
0.0091528194,
-0.0303767025,
0.0092644552,
0.0069938409,
0.0336728841,
-0.0538825877,
-0.0204786398,
-0.0127935521,
-0.0238311123,
0.000112734,
0.01740315,
-0.101223968,
-0.0634702444,
0.032739073,
0.0146753266,
0.0063055144,
0.0471493676,
-0.041608084,
-0.0233099442,
0.0010718401,
-0.0189268459,
0.0074011101,
-0.0115969563,
0.0727498978,
-0.0519758649,
-0.0092984075,
0.0152324717,
-0.0548259504,
0.0089713614,
0.0123258559,
0.0396559313,
-0.0238685757,
-0.0246999022,
0.0129068922,
0.01732748,
0.0355976485,
-0.0251023471,
-0.0075228992,
-0.0534039661,
0.0204002224,
-0.0114259701,
-0.0147800092,
-0.0347575322,
-0.0334880091,
0.0354658514,
-0.004341641,
-0.0165273231,
0.0612257048,
-0.0036962612,
0.0078486064,
-0.0383100845,
0.0027131394,
0.0149262594,
0.0431798212,
-0.0102342581,
0.0082410937,
-0.0277396105,
0.0427875593,
0.0173950382,
0.0330395624,
-0.0040333774,
0.0021703932,
0.0230013896,
0.0103796702,
0.0192626156,
0.0064501273,
-0.0520355105,
0.0036542716,
-0.0278604086,
0.0071234223,
0.074356325,
-0.0172707718,
0.0662085488,
-0.0392849483,
0.0134757319,
-0.051550474,
-0.0024375503,
0.0169249289,
0.0107275229,
-0.0109995585,
-0.0032006465,
-0.014226649,
-0.0194049645,
0.0917822495,
-0.0029835619,
0.0398246758,
0.0185494088,
0.0496546067,
-0.0605357438,
-0.0148805259,
-0.0107084941,
0.0108119072,
-0.0307374429,
-0.0123699456,
-0.0187960342,
-0.0541757233,
0.0028480308,
0.0072683385,
0.0046110926,
0.0409686752,
-0.0068009789,
0.0210102312,
-0.0296327174,
0.0450808704,
-0.0140422368,
-0.0543034114,
-0.0025106743,
-0.0104513504,
0.0032548963,
-6.379280007e-33,
-0.0168868192,
-0.0093093431,
-0.0131163141,
-0.0447688475,
0.0094488608,
0.0081584165,
-0.0369107239,
0.0160932727,
-0.0329807959,
-0.0113103976,
-0.0454658046,
0.0071467077,
0.0464301743,
0.0401563048,
0.0090604844,
-0.0096564172,
0.0772273019,
-0.0117540779,
-0.00315834,
-0.0223574918,
0.0327503346,
0.0364104174,
0.0676644295,
-0.0567151904,
0.0310600419,
0.0083816024,
-0.0108898859,
-0.0078532491,
0.0135735534,
0.0571563803,
-0.0016497076,
0.0618954599,
0.0141373714,
-0.0287072696,
-0.0547398515,
-0.0194815695,
-0.0989603847,
-0.0231503267,
-0.0332395695,
0.086059995,
-0.0010722704,
0.0139387753,
0.0182668008,
-0.0179596432,
-0.0007850296,
-0.0139541952,
0.0132455695,
-0.0360644758,
-0.0096085779,
-0.0021077413,
-0.0421461575,
0.0427236483,
0.0088879494,
0.0076899785,
0.0452903472,
0.0201231651,
-0.0291276556,
-0.03538635,
-0.0804155469,
-0.0022002105,
0.0211436264,
0.0500939675,
0.0213557035,
0.0344506279,
0.0039373636,
0.0163466316,
0.0389747322,
0.0141340001,
0.0208348129,
-0.0251161475,
0.0415521152,
-0.014406994,
0.0304007623,
0.0745155364,
0.0424481034,
-0.0007898445,
-0.038262628,
0.0319126584,
0.0805937424,
-0.0452614129,
0.0105704153,
0.0265157204,
-0.0603224859,
-0.0148501508,
-0.0096159857,
-0.0080518257,
-0.0305253565,
-0.0130321141,
0.050220497,
0.0117220217,
-0.0011037537,
0.0143983774,
0.0510288402,
-0.0199425574,
-0.0122556901,
0.0185834542,
0.0188869089,
-0.0082514342,
-0.0168637447,
0.029469436,
-0.0181806646,
-0.0633621886,
0.0401180312,
0.0461130515,
0.0104241846,
-0.0166205503,
0.0485508814,
0.0154510001,
-0.0606400631,
0.0030910259,
-0.005591949,
0.0199010968,
0.0209492631,
0.057119403,
0.0483580157,
-0.0270245671,
0.004062416,
0.0416915491,
0.0148742702,
0.0267953072,
-0.0413584933,
-0.0208919402,
-0.0389230624,
-0.0051204301,
-0.0089077801,
0.0226055458,
-0.0171401724,
-0.0080920933,
0.0375053808,
-0.0173838586,
-0.0030563229,
-0.0091033503,
2.521e-7,
0.0126438262,
0.0173234232,
0.0530531518,
0.0336319543,
0.0065646037,
0.0232163388,
-0.0692552477,
0.0227783415,
-0.0355435573,
0.0259430874,
0.0097584724,
-0.0017426438,
0.107055895,
0.0419325605,
-0.0582718849,
-0.0658146888,
-0.0594857037,
0.0422634631,
-0.0102945045,
0.0051898346,
-0.003700451,
0.1023515537,
-0.0216509141,
0.0121128773,
0.0353853218,
-0.033685334,
0.0138707878,
-0.015795242,
-0.0038032893,
0.0353545733,
0.0409118794,
0.0012199352,
0.009556652,
0.0048282086,
-0.0471911505,
0.009942418,
0.0539631471,
0.0374785922,
0.0014172613,
-0.076716654,
-0.03147652,
0.0190237407,
-0.0032977744,
-0.0074556828,
0.0316172205,
0.0403956026,
-0.0073588407,
-0.031364806,
-0.0103020128,
0.0015571974,
0.0157140736,
-0.0221578535,
-0.0073365024,
0.0161852501,
0.0319588222,
-0.0074627963,
-0.0411134809,
-0.0304822903,
-0.0534669012,
-0.0045552165,
-0.0462589227,
-0.0383078791,
-0.0215687212,
-0.0256171338,
0.0101941908,
-0.0460374877,
-0.0138885174,
2.028176142e-34,
0.0343043022,
-0.0138306003,
0.051463306,
0.0502353869,
-0.0147764357,
-0.0089229885,
-0.0151583906,
-0.0249498282,
-0.0091850739,
-0.0059938109,
-0.0468579531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07322v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07322v2 | TRESTLE: Toolkit for Reproducible Execution of Speech, Text and Language Experiments | 2023-02-14T20:07:31 | 2023-03-14T19:35:05 | Changye Li, Weizhe Xu, Trevor Cohen, Martin Michalowski, Serguei Pakhomov | cs.CL | cs.CL | The evidence is growing that machine and deep learning methods can learn the
subtle differences between the language produced by people with various forms
of cognitive impairment such as dementia and cognitively healthy individuals.
Valuable public data repositories such as TalkBank have made it possible for
researchers in the computational community to join forces and learn from each
other to make significant advances in this area. However, due to variability in
approaches and data selection strategies used by various researchers, results
obtained by different groups have been difficult to compare directly. In this
paper, we present TRESTLE (\textbf{T}oolkit for \textbf{R}eproducible
\textbf{E}xecution of \textbf{S}peech \textbf{T}ext and \textbf{L}anguage
\textbf{E}xperiments), an open source platform that focuses on two datasets
from the TalkBank repository with dementia detection as an illustrative domain.
Successfully deployed in the hackallenge (Hackathon/Challenge) of the
International Workshop on Health Intelligence at AAAI 2022, TRESTLE provides a
precise digital blueprint of the data pre-processing and selection strategies
that can be reused via TRESTLE by other researchers seeking comparable results
with their peers and current state-of-the-art (SOTA) approaches. | [
-0.0089260442,
0.1063989401,
-0.0102789914,
0.0285230521,
-0.0377904736,
0.0254426543,
0.0347444005,
0.0194255933,
0.0379258581,
0.0040195528,
-0.0080187973,
0.0243854057,
0.0362654068,
0.0539600141,
0.0108400369,
-0.0326644704,
0.0949707776,
0.0125290984,
0.0483845621,
0.0095736803,
-0.0035114628,
-0.0084437542,
-0.0499350876,
0.01829735,
-0.0159022473,
-0.0101507008,
0.0255104471,
-0.0180315804,
0.0084394272,
-0.0256801229,
0.0048483135,
0.0264383499,
0.0084044877,
0.0581750944,
0.0000023769,
-0.0598057918,
0.0029206187,
-0.0064847763,
-0.0446257219,
-0.0353975073,
-0.0019798721,
0.0201169848,
-0.0060291849,
0.0015288321,
-0.0409063473,
-0.0228034947,
0.0439575538,
-0.0058331592,
0.0349097513,
0.0601542555,
-0.0022469219,
0.0481308885,
0.0540850423,
-0.0164744947,
0.0641453043,
0.0059671798,
0.0182573181,
-0.0221379809,
-0.0294056125,
-0.0558604412,
0.0221841298,
0.0515785813,
0.0004855766,
0.0222527031,
-0.0302498359,
0.0321489759,
-0.0365602896,
-0.0574125722,
-0.027064953,
0.0681855008,
-0.0150116039,
0.0292919558,
0.0142259654,
0.0154347867,
-0.0104454365,
-0.0021528981,
-0.0405255184,
-0.0124760224,
0.0051134522,
0.0024457478,
-0.0270320047,
0.012952012,
0.0244539641,
-0.0311451107,
0.0217670072,
0.0809678659,
-0.0123630529,
-0.0273790229,
0.0337849185,
-0.0019357041,
-0.0223527607,
-0.0192202665,
0.0440636948,
-0.0119338222,
-0.0577937402,
-0.0073896674,
-0.019120859,
-0.0539104231,
0.0582661517,
-0.0140182329,
0.0142230829,
0.0159531105,
-0.0873890743,
0.022726547,
-0.0210136529,
0.0278702527,
-0.0047958489,
0.0113727367,
0.0073218169,
0.0141595257,
-0.0232500434,
0.0183267519,
-0.0266288929,
-0.0001841614,
-0.0380153395,
-0.0172052681,
-0.0725732446,
-0.0439593233,
-0.0144777065,
-0.0126673048,
0.0220255032,
0.0524118952,
-0.0320696831,
0.0525840446,
-0.0160156395,
0.0296486393,
-0.0324641056,
0.0161559191,
-0.0141219655,
-0.090230763,
-0.0169188697,
0.047304783,
-0.0217871517,
-0.0527680442,
0.0325027183,
0.0527696125,
-0.0136643555,
-0.00007961,
-0.0292114466,
-0.0334762782,
-0.0391911156,
-0.034270674,
0.0379811078,
-0.067847304,
0.0435714312,
-0.0010382448,
0.0073014293,
-0.0717032254,
-0.0129200183,
0.0039561191,
-0.0232141502,
0.048037,
-0.0412086919,
-0.0256629959,
0.0573845059,
0.0013119213,
-2.024e-7,
0.0505014062,
0.0180537514,
-0.0274965297,
0.0344542749,
-0.006435052,
0.0068001715,
0.0517913848,
0.0541893542,
-0.0291544851,
0.003641475,
0.0098044612,
0.032216277,
0.0376552641,
0.0535282716,
0.0497250147,
-0.0038426381,
-0.0449910723,
0.0333108716,
0.0755489916,
-0.0086226873,
0.0081050824,
0.0032377541,
-0.0072034793,
0.0093235029,
-0.0362326279,
-0.0203938708,
-0.011015512,
-0.0091852574,
-0.0417035297,
-0.0367268436,
0.0225040354,
-0.0066508083,
-0.0101850471,
0.0212022066,
-0.043441657,
0.0248725917,
-0.0130669186,
0.010599561,
-0.0007630742,
-0.0042115524,
0.0269020535,
0.0320509337,
-0.0522869416,
-0.0494620688,
-0.075851649,
-0.0087696826,
0.018753944,
0.0245441105,
-0.0527540743,
0.0340980962,
-0.0121192513,
0.0026615749,
0.0226929225,
-0.0115636708,
-0.0042558606,
0.0619538613,
-0.0477351621,
-0.0036770443,
0.014539131,
0.005777786,
-0.0103785573,
0.0240210239,
0.0390695892,
-0.0094122682,
-0.0188700166,
0.0224593636,
0.0379206985,
-0.0307261609,
0.0022976613,
0.005088741,
-0.010148664,
0.0556683913,
0.012191724,
-0.0164293777,
0.0077267238,
-0.001593204,
-0.0213038158,
0.0157334078,
0.0271608029,
-0.0554978736,
-0.0475409813,
0.0032967525,
-0.0236537587,
-0.0101208687,
0.0476823561,
-0.0249677226,
-0.0136889182,
0.026310537,
-0.0573279262,
0.0006801309,
-0.0236141458,
0.0051915841,
-0.0339151025,
0.0401333496,
-0.0151860258,
0.0672624558,
-0.0232687667,
-0.0355257802,
0.0331465825,
-0.0371988714,
0.0270426795,
-0.0525125712,
-0.0379343331,
0.0082673775,
-0.042949602,
-0.006104358,
-0.0225739572,
0.0157046374,
-0.0591396801,
0.0414120294,
-0.1212972701,
0.020971911,
-0.0218586288,
0.0265967883,
-0.0041443487,
0.0024593347,
-0.0217414983,
-0.0563712344,
-0.0053877146,
0.0382458232,
0.0242323484,
0.0164885223,
0.0169788841,
-0.0118143428,
-0.0142122125,
-0.0525061041,
-0.0358675048,
-0.0292795766,
0.0494160131,
-0.0104045495,
-0.0868976042,
-0.0022284756,
-0.0091511197,
-0.0093597099,
0.0174692497,
-0.0068736123,
0.0000019388,
-0.0022626151,
0.0121331029,
0.0047541959,
0.0694252551,
-0.024082629,
0.0591434725,
-0.0075110216,
0.0095454818,
-0.0302811451,
0.0011094107,
-0.0193298813,
0.0535476506,
-0.034589231,
-0.0257272758,
0.0296363886,
0.0255631097,
0.0372086465,
0.0424730554,
-0.0053774598,
0.013693179,
-0.0159443468,
-0.0212921966,
-0.028478438,
-0.0349710621,
-0.0444825962,
-0.0134730591,
-0.0238691475,
-0.0849563852,
0.0606909469,
-0.0117772492,
-0.0260582082,
-0.0884241164,
-0.0071990374,
-0.0156145431,
0.0362649895,
-0.0069987741,
0.0071673323,
-0.0206321664,
-0.0525110476,
0.0033994906,
-0.0103345532,
-0.0330371298,
-0.031460654,
0.0344626009,
-0.0420900993,
0.0109040672,
-0.0022990999,
-0.0493053421,
-0.031070929,
0.0087990155,
-0.0366721116,
0.0400937833,
0.0399991833,
-0.0355369262,
-0.0799095407,
-0.0534843951,
0.0332096331,
0.0769900382,
0.0017513512,
0.0168383624,
-0.0063334657,
0.0446888059,
-0.0060369777,
0.0178472344,
0.0211080611,
0.0010103228,
0.0051062591,
0.0492781997,
-0.0149425939,
0.0103458175,
-0.0151352882,
0.0362906978,
0.0056484314,
-0.0353854559,
-0.013007774,
0.0177708734,
0.0668386072,
-0.0284804124,
-0.0233484469,
0.0770859942,
0.0511744246,
-0.0823024362,
0.0047874777,
-0.0188559666,
0.0330482312,
-0.000999523,
-0.009009771,
-0.0779460892,
-0.0706461966,
0.0040216404,
0.063182041,
-0.0244040638,
-0.024831729,
0.0060171881,
-0.0326758474,
0.0639905185,
-0.0147789698,
-0.0734259114,
0.0355852097,
-0.0313691385,
-0.004771146,
-0.0347903036,
0.0495324582,
-0.0075124758,
-0.0153117124,
-0.0238141771,
0.0128028346,
-0.0885781273,
-0.0573158562,
0.0456255861,
-0.027484823,
0.0901302099,
0.0675149336,
0.0330380835,
0.0120971631,
-0.04742397,
0.0247545801,
-0.0416301563,
0.0241648406,
-0.046747338,
0.1230672821,
0.0371874161,
-0.0176330209,
-0.0436681733,
0.0638636798,
-0.0407073721,
-0.0117631787,
0.0166496225,
0.0545112044,
-0.0629125461,
-0.01934129,
-0.0344915949,
-0.0081288014,
0.0617950372,
0.0502657071,
0.0171877425,
-0.0298307762,
-0.0434201099,
0.0080993539,
0.0075418917,
-0.0172835197,
-0.0412474833,
0.01091424,
0.0201073755,
-0.0270408094,
-0.056803491,
-0.0166306384,
0.0625914708,
0.0129259964,
-0.0093292193,
-0.0305836666,
-0.0151418336,
0.0288949404,
-0.0839622319,
0.0647247955,
0.0224756598,
0.0442639776,
-0.0722179636,
-0.0518214181,
0.003962778,
-0.0130913593,
-0.0407209955,
0.0431938805,
-0.054721944,
-0.0243723318,
0.0642864406,
0.0176495854,
0.0285599791,
0.0544942059,
-0.0037364713,
-0.0339434259,
0.079868719,
0.0451500788,
-0.0183858275,
-0.0030181464,
0.0216634143,
-0.0302847307,
-0.0141369579,
0.0135163106,
0.01913465,
0.0355657563,
0.0119825201,
-0.0104878694,
0.0067187203,
0.0288915634,
0.0033323294,
0.0377914533,
0.0344489776,
0.0037094101,
0.0011676929,
-0.0319844447,
0.0121058328,
0.0416030139,
0.0230142679,
-0.0182715096,
-0.0105277244,
0.0026433477,
-0.0114519643,
0.0036600726,
0.0192662794,
-0.0450018086,
-0.0466509536,
-0.0601160116,
0.0511921979,
0.042272836,
0.071719721,
0.019377226,
-0.0020882748,
0.0098477956,
0.0704404712,
-0.0404654965,
0.0456273779,
-0.0013389875,
0.0536368638,
-0.0197241213,
-0.0248741843,
0.0070016971,
0.0137243252,
-0.0234433934,
-0.0347491466,
-0.0357002802,
0.025489673,
-0.0039300122,
0.0108685289,
0.0708437338,
-0.0130037442,
0.0088362871,
-0.0193513166,
-0.0423069559,
-0.0059375814,
0.0118454173,
-0.0115753235,
-0.0157621671,
-0.0314139351,
-0.0111650769,
0.0557657033,
-0.0422540121,
0.0136557221,
0.0078878906,
-0.0214888491,
-0.0365268961,
-0.0811396912,
0.0653072223,
-0.0230803005,
-0.068926625,
-0.0559685789,
0.0207891539,
-0.0257645044,
0.0225806497,
0.0023844014,
0.0143183982,
0.0471313372,
0.0319072902,
0.0275737289,
-0.0090695303,
-0.038806811,
0.0030493329,
0.0092525324,
-0.0689695179,
-0.0414469689,
-0.0029282244,
-6.619900762e-33,
-0.0037621942,
0.0128747951,
0.0016316912,
-0.0028355711,
0.007974267,
0.0368643031,
-0.0434757508,
0.0182501096,
-0.0274435319,
0.047349304,
0.0212298501,
0.0147758657,
0.0388931297,
0.0433443449,
-0.0010346746,
-0.0275619924,
0.0399034955,
-0.0209773723,
-0.0347934365,
0.0409898013,
0.0255158097,
0.0222672988,
0.0642013326,
-0.069135353,
0.0461932309,
0.0360718742,
0.0039558862,
0.0376345664,
-0.0139209647,
0.0345328413,
-0.0482817441,
0.0499808043,
0.0033920845,
-0.0038895181,
-0.0360475816,
0.0489988998,
-0.0729994923,
-0.0133999689,
0.0201298408,
0.0319630243,
-0.0569333062,
0.0321131945,
0.0285392161,
0.0081894221,
-0.021335287,
0.0343134329,
0.0281894021,
-0.0341117904,
0.0029454466,
-0.020196395,
-0.0329320617,
0.0151275489,
-0.0195345487,
0.0170033854,
0.0291849431,
0.0111744218,
-0.0505973548,
-0.0145346355,
-0.0760885701,
0.0157312043,
-0.0148810074,
0.0044282777,
0.0423281305,
-0.0528925471,
-0.0212540217,
0.0883274749,
0.0507357083,
-0.0494382121,
0.0359378718,
0.0094517553,
0.0254556928,
0.0584066659,
0.087990053,
-0.0154007701,
0.0472910218,
-0.0487736389,
-0.0513224229,
-0.011419829,
0.0519360341,
-0.0017498306,
0.0142588094,
-0.0033888726,
-0.0433842503,
-0.0221338272,
-0.0104597714,
0.0258397833,
-0.0324685909,
-0.0244537797,
0.0115157068,
-0.0226122122,
0.0025947578,
0.0100234216,
0.0389895812,
-0.026530683,
0.0113132,
0.0099596521,
0.0248908661,
0.0018981964,
0.0088619646,
0.0078844531,
-0.0247838944,
-0.0491176434,
0.0338743664,
0.0498554781,
0.065099664,
-0.0202836804,
0.0539289415,
0.0106627662,
-0.0364418887,
0.0151128192,
-0.0071474686,
0.0412960388,
-0.0061776387,
0.0375387631,
-0.0075333053,
-0.0027377235,
-0.0030192733,
0.0302792992,
-0.0085344175,
-0.012367717,
-0.0431157388,
-0.0064588366,
0.007552464,
0.029165186,
-0.0335236602,
-0.0116128232,
-0.0279631745,
-0.023179207,
0.0045501268,
-0.0543867387,
0.0211117547,
0.0215450209,
3.018e-7,
0.0335773528,
0.0700465217,
0.0340055153,
-0.0170021318,
0.0501315929,
-0.0165206715,
-0.0222497247,
0.0321703255,
-0.0080851084,
-0.018905405,
-0.0018293479,
0.0081730448,
0.0838024095,
0.0443988256,
-0.0410167724,
-0.0328259096,
-0.0850586668,
-0.010537344,
-0.0701237172,
0.0301005039,
0.0144787664,
0.0559375063,
-0.0285869557,
-0.071674794,
0.0457680188,
0.0091964845,
-0.0076890686,
-0.0300850216,
0.0414927341,
0.0111643439,
0.0193753075,
-0.0077028852,
0.0551717654,
0.0462808982,
-0.0548002571,
-0.0250286851,
-0.0156569406,
0.0489078239,
-0.0275438223,
-0.0340407602,
-0.0002757286,
0.0367898941,
0.0207075477,
-0.0101242047,
0.0596839227,
-0.0284003858,
-0.0497840382,
-0.0200338289,
-0.0072581493,
-0.0314149112,
0.080797717,
-0.0354892835,
0.0444387682,
0.001340138,
0.0240953714,
0.0257015731,
-0.0330482088,
-0.0423792414,
-0.0362402983,
0.0146167474,
-0.0880112797,
-0.0587768927,
-0.0147454888,
-0.0317011923,
-0.0256276336,
-0.0819607452,
0.0233468357,
2.885553023e-34,
0.0146531295,
0.0494017564,
0.0344854034,
-0.004499028,
-0.0047135591,
-0.0221425872,
0.0938996971,
-0.0004947766,
-0.0391070135,
-0.0127896955,
-0.0054963925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07232v1 | A Psycholinguistic Analysis of BERT's Representations of Compounds | 2023-02-14T18:23:15 | 2023-02-14T18:23:15 | Lars Buijtelaar, Sandro Pezzelle | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; J.5 | This work studies the semantic representations learned by BERT for compounds,
that is, expressions such as sunlight or bodyguard. We build on recent studies
that explore semantic information in Transformers at the word level and test
whether BERT aligns with human semantic intuitions when dealing with
expressions (e.g., sunlight) whose overall meaning depends -- to a various
extent -- on the semantics of the constituent words (sun, light). We leverage a
dataset that includes human judgments on two psycholinguistic measures of
compound semantic analysis: lexeme meaning dominance (LMD; quantifying the
weight of each constituent toward the compound meaning) and semantic
transparency (ST; evaluating the extent to which the compound meaning is
recoverable from the constituents' semantics). We show that BERT-based measures
moderately align with human intuitions, especially when using contextualized
representations, and that LMD is overall more predictable than ST. Contrary to
the results reported for 'standard' words, higher, more contextualized layers
are the best at representing compound meaning. These findings shed new light on
the abilities of BERT in dealing with fine-grained semantic phenomena.
Moreover, they can provide insights into how speakers represent compounds. | [
0.0091816997,
0.0089940233,
-0.0450047478,
0.0343070216,
-0.0201776177,
-0.0220457632,
-0.0354341418,
0.0278077889,
-0.0287837647,
-0.0665948018,
-0.0532222129,
-0.0122862514,
0.0127400747,
-0.0263032801,
0.0457273945,
-0.0759352297,
0.0264699738,
0.0099105071,
0.0214480497,
-0.0087377289,
0.011114846,
-0.0032359888,
-0.0247033089,
0.0358443074,
-0.0316981152,
0.0018548662,
0.0259904172,
-0.0041164001,
0.0341544077,
-0.0116297528,
-0.0235856231,
0.0244570468,
0.0132047636,
0.0186174903,
0.0000015283,
-0.0890319273,
0.0044819904,
-0.0028088228,
0.0050535272,
0.005633268,
0.0542191528,
-0.0297115855,
-0.0126758963,
-0.0263340529,
-0.0220217463,
0.0546765514,
0.0830506757,
0.0138343591,
-0.0040086485,
-0.0308200642,
-0.0201461371,
-0.020079108,
0.0158965569,
0.0091604143,
0.0469476171,
0.0132380491,
0.0328713357,
-0.0434904881,
-0.0210567545,
-0.0370669439,
-0.0707857981,
-0.0092200348,
0.0056865816,
0.0367332585,
0.0084693097,
0.0497626401,
-0.0626778603,
-0.0282381326,
0.0164557826,
0.0410654098,
-0.0056974939,
-0.0030136988,
-0.033714924,
0.013860669,
-0.0295815896,
0.0206599329,
0.0097294543,
0.0433641113,
0.0000293273,
0.0275650062,
0.0147621129,
-0.0195744019,
-0.0129769333,
0.041687008,
-0.0324632935,
0.0986235216,
0.045907069,
-0.0420379154,
0.0319454186,
-0.0143867657,
-0.0311931167,
-0.0257058032,
0.0324303657,
-0.0142626977,
0.0319381878,
0.0489443168,
-0.0027524717,
-0.0346924476,
0.0340672098,
-0.0736640245,
0.0164718833,
0.0260605812,
-0.052602876,
0.0323129781,
-0.0546531826,
0.0481560715,
-0.0114215175,
0.0523614027,
-0.054677587,
-0.0102520129,
-0.0391491912,
-0.0198951308,
-0.0668308139,
0.0511115566,
-0.0204750244,
-0.0380365476,
-0.0532180816,
0.0092368834,
-0.0162185766,
-0.0531512164,
-0.0085868193,
0.0286784414,
-0.0434177667,
0.0317089595,
-0.0218782388,
0.0332367346,
-0.0432172157,
0.0385824442,
-0.0351413041,
-0.0485301875,
-0.0035256795,
-0.0091874804,
-0.0028750934,
-0.0344045609,
-0.0093585281,
0.0665918365,
0.0068296255,
-0.0484287515,
-0.0155962007,
-0.0464687608,
-0.0307438448,
-0.0010238937,
0.0136064803,
-0.0306280535,
-0.0055445293,
0.0225414857,
0.0052845147,
-0.0378472246,
0.015546862,
0.005192148,
-0.0222795047,
0.1001442745,
-0.0367349833,
-0.0191273373,
-0.0186572056,
0.0260951146,
-0.0428174287,
0.021146955,
0.0490009934,
0.0086883958,
0.0163262095,
-0.0307929106,
-0.0164626613,
-0.0104194442,
-0.0224121027,
-0.0177215505,
-0.0334829316,
-0.0609340072,
-0.020803418,
0.0482993275,
0.0020928793,
0.0549550503,
-0.0349611118,
-0.0234297104,
0.0638713017,
0.0406192504,
0.0209240559,
0.0324625075,
0.0185890626,
0.0435795449,
0.0445422009,
0.0409621298,
-0.020909356,
-0.0054292236,
-0.0586681217,
0.0033731731,
-0.0268104188,
0.0125981085,
0.0011216693,
0.0125598712,
-0.029999312,
0.013969182,
0.0343672708,
-0.0667775199,
0.0214063283,
0.0209846236,
-0.0498753451,
0.1088204756,
0.0452011228,
-0.0524971746,
0.0217207074,
-0.0462880991,
-0.0303667504,
0.0707865581,
0.0004618678,
-0.0101235164,
-0.0351909138,
0.037657924,
-0.0470638424,
0.0327655412,
-0.0529584885,
0.0055143014,
0.0510017984,
-0.0228119642,
-0.0017662271,
-0.0300331023,
0.0017493668,
0.0003194385,
-0.0486279763,
-0.000224709,
0.0009833124,
-0.0913378671,
0.082701996,
0.0414536223,
0.0161966793,
-0.065842554,
-0.0296801645,
0.0361911915,
0.0085838083,
-0.0065717502,
-0.0166073274,
0.0470157862,
0.0176676307,
-0.0484086424,
0.0021567361,
0.0290452112,
-0.0065458426,
-0.0072708153,
0.0114375921,
-0.0499372445,
-0.0029387411,
0.0324620306,
0.02726724,
-0.0020737934,
0.0140958475,
-0.0861451179,
0.102840066,
-0.0522854477,
-0.0078844083,
-0.0216705073,
0.0522446595,
0.004738451,
0.0696481317,
-0.0026119177,
0.0018012184,
0.0097052921,
0.0291144419,
0.0333870165,
-0.0050292108,
-0.0041284743,
-0.0307122786,
-0.0108685149,
0.0049485909,
0.0177482367,
-0.0305009745,
-0.0673262626,
0.0001370941,
-0.0715249181,
-0.0401539281,
0.0280114356,
0.0243692212,
0.0311808791,
-0.0186070036,
0.0089054145,
0.0217692293,
0.0336163528,
-0.0075514573,
-0.0803844333,
0.0749495775,
0.0069087348,
-0.0144926589,
-0.0643412098,
-0.0081631243,
-0.029824907,
-0.0582417808,
0.0634259135,
-0.02183518,
-0.011562841,
0.001581024,
-0.0656904057,
-0.0452648737,
-0.0028822902,
0.0356512591,
-0.0573061779,
0.0301277582,
0.0166267026,
0.0420040935,
0.0286700893,
0.0523912385,
0.0252580196,
0.0518334657,
-0.052659817,
-0.0359094627,
-0.0155889383,
-0.0144762918,
0.0220129695,
-0.017332755,
-0.0227367785,
0.0043831081,
0.0862861872,
0.0200692359,
0.019416675,
-0.0479050316,
0.0259711742,
-0.0397092067,
-0.0495085046,
-0.0209745336,
-0.0460206717,
-0.0740870833,
0.0242947582,
-0.0000259348,
-0.015049736,
0.0942310467,
-0.0140426382,
-0.0194189064,
-0.0691153854,
0.0367008075,
0.0200201608,
0.030466795,
-0.0304927081,
0.0410372056,
0.0283905901,
-0.0529351719,
-0.0361775048,
-0.027639566,
0.0064287623,
-0.0326715596,
0.014341061,
-0.0340110995,
-0.0170875229,
0.0218108855,
-0.032966122,
-0.0302140117,
-0.0297918525,
-0.0315281525,
0.0407750309,
0.0450008884,
-0.00199953,
0.0073480112,
-0.0171509068,
-0.0102478238,
-0.0335632227,
0.0396203995,
-0.0193918142,
-0.0007829769,
0.0298858061,
-0.0131505048,
-0.0472749099,
0.0634037778,
-0.0212339032,
-0.0353244804,
0.0293007568,
0.0368773229,
-0.0028210043,
-0.0202476792,
0.0501330569,
0.054171633,
-0.0324400291,
-0.0254525747,
0.0001541623,
0.005913835,
-0.0233218241,
0.0136035997,
0.091341652,
0.0379295088,
-0.0031106817,
0.0709205493,
-0.0525363311,
0.0089843851,
0.0037115244,
0.0097228074,
-0.0747509301,
-0.0267048925,
-0.0008908774,
-0.0173752327,
0.0100413542,
-0.0149912229,
0.0002084119,
-0.0663789585,
0.0012129679,
-0.0135012055,
-0.0152373491,
0.0186123997,
-0.0244311001,
0.0358075537,
0.0155469337,
0.0444329828,
0.0069279918,
-0.0356922783,
-0.0175330993,
0.0198620893,
0.0052054026,
-0.0038022688,
0.0407378674,
-0.0162965935,
-0.0248728059,
0.055533994,
0.0569501631,
-0.0495803058,
-0.1149264872,
0.0218214151,
-0.0582634248,
0.0018376451,
0.003853763,
0.0067552417,
-0.0042608003,
-0.0111206304,
-0.0275645424,
-0.0034715189,
0.0158267394,
-0.0725328177,
-0.0655093566,
0.0555282161,
-0.0071241967,
-0.0251003541,
-0.0205073133,
0.0274687801,
-0.0277187582,
0.0680756718,
0.0405790471,
-0.0531120189,
0.0142787062,
0.01962547,
0.0392107517,
0.0203330163,
-0.0251174476,
-0.0092200227,
-0.0485170558,
-0.0241764411,
-0.0556551777,
-0.0400326438,
0.0320933536,
0.0086976839,
0.0124696717,
-0.0040747537,
0.0016036852,
0.0006233414,
-0.0270125736,
0.0397930667,
0.0462986901,
0.0337909907,
-0.0113277696,
-0.0239344127,
0.0086334934,
-0.0225944743,
-0.0439950824,
-0.0037572477,
-0.0001696374,
-0.029146865,
0.0965236723,
-0.0000610929,
0.0279246271,
-0.0129349539,
0.0063125179,
-0.0350403748,
0.0305621941,
0.0416409709,
0.0124738608,
0.0267823804,
0.033121895,
0.0041573709,
0.0267166626,
0.0347511657,
-0.0250995737,
0.0429580547,
-0.0250309315,
0.0696572438,
0.0235334337,
-0.0435076728,
0.0561239421,
0.0049873986,
0.0586075485,
-0.0212658551,
0.0472280234,
0.0013713561,
-0.0040445556,
0.0063752048,
-0.0108474893,
-0.0107052838,
-0.0278556477,
0.0065493993,
0.0281501319,
-0.0438734852,
0.0581262931,
-0.0155358976,
0.0211027637,
0.0134898862,
0.0060374951,
0.0040916828,
-0.0274323486,
-0.0011740864,
0.0356894583,
0.0023567278,
-0.0324005969,
-0.0309898462,
-0.0130406609,
-0.0319424309,
0.0359568149,
0.0236600433,
0.0029346775,
-0.0686210245,
0.0253582783,
-0.0171039347,
-0.0315788276,
0.0043884818,
0.0028327175,
0.0109204659,
-0.022599481,
0.0226592645,
-0.0656629205,
0.0088589434,
-0.0005358213,
-0.0174704194,
-0.0191792678,
-0.009940546,
0.0793912932,
0.0222155359,
0.0085538318,
-0.0512865596,
0.0571084395,
-0.0692097247,
0.0410618223,
-0.0171464123,
-0.0290551372,
-0.0035823055,
0.0035553651,
-0.0078277104,
0.0400154032,
-0.0150814876,
0.0002118782,
-0.1060959622,
-0.0457652248,
0.0472031608,
-0.0189982057,
0.0635949671,
-0.0297959708,
0.0536162294,
0.0603446551,
0.0135610858,
-0.0812581703,
0.0333878659,
0.0208242554,
-0.0028648169,
0.03034373,
-0.0047291163,
-5.379480919e-33,
-0.0182486661,
0.0031629133,
-0.0431460254,
-0.0125187812,
-0.0214451682,
0.0418110937,
-0.0650530905,
0.0018437563,
-0.0248394869,
0.0688428581,
0.0193626769,
-0.0024191621,
0.0227004793,
-0.0071642576,
0.0266326908,
-0.0137418965,
0.00479824,
0.0194610674,
-0.0132742962,
-0.03540162,
0.0268956497,
0.0242436826,
0.0855150297,
-0.0285177529,
0.0008632145,
0.0595218763,
-0.0055061704,
0.0060072802,
-0.0034741166,
0.077173464,
-0.0167547558,
0.0854136199,
0.020366108,
0.0086827222,
-0.0134183588,
0.0656810775,
-0.0389973819,
-0.0482539721,
0.0577441938,
-0.0167536829,
-0.0927051753,
-0.002124531,
0.0505754463,
-0.0185003728,
-0.0572390407,
0.0323068127,
0.0227616858,
-0.003522651,
-0.0111934058,
-0.055489637,
-0.0931688473,
-0.0338223726,
0.01223501,
-0.0296839997,
0.0232536457,
-0.023043327,
-0.0149909556,
0.0251177084,
-0.0295822285,
0.0134038823,
-0.0198353659,
0.0237463899,
0.0126763908,
0.0469399244,
0.0050057513,
0.0651404038,
0.0267855152,
-0.0040689115,
0.0013805333,
-0.0273073707,
0.074377425,
0.0715364516,
0.04143098,
0.0160026923,
0.0551636629,
0.0192638934,
0.0264571812,
-0.0314749926,
0.0014816551,
0.0513922982,
0.0108915931,
0.0251489617,
-0.0106704319,
-0.0118406788,
-0.0322289467,
0.0416650362,
-0.0401992537,
-0.0015140964,
0.0141010527,
-0.0416303724,
-0.0114705134,
0.0353205539,
0.0081253592,
-0.0321477503,
-0.0055613345,
-0.0072966274,
-0.026563704,
0.0182407927,
0.0055745374,
0.0448797196,
-0.0264234208,
-0.0373873152,
0.014249743,
0.0198745392,
0.0044310503,
0.021209849,
0.0337873884,
0.0023616133,
0.0028462678,
-0.0130347321,
-0.046818953,
-0.053702265,
-0.0045579416,
-0.0387806073,
0.0364986248,
0.0531420261,
-0.0163409058,
-0.0160679687,
0.0482904725,
0.010844701,
-0.0187420398,
0.0283575859,
0.0036060279,
0.0423016883,
-0.0267458502,
-0.0166766718,
-0.0208610501,
0.0044786017,
0.0646834299,
-0.0366968997,
-0.0368304215,
-0.0137554761,
2.6e-7,
0.0863190815,
0.0744841248,
0.0271794572,
0.0157850217,
-0.0008671822,
0.0266361125,
0.0002586158,
0.0636887774,
-0.0105222268,
-0.0182083715,
-0.0268303733,
-0.0153967356,
-0.0165796168,
0.0202009771,
-0.0273292661,
0.0073157172,
-0.043567542,
0.0181600135,
-0.0452106073,
0.0298820883,
0.0808808729,
0.0645242929,
0.0137924338,
-0.0389085189,
-0.0151174283,
-0.0010049324,
0.0509380512,
-0.0319186226,
0.0424824655,
0.0109027736,
-0.0114989402,
0.0060455878,
0.0397956707,
0.0669474527,
-0.0403346755,
0.0040229587,
0.0131968474,
-0.0133463554,
-0.0653968006,
-0.0459964685,
0.0139509523,
-0.0551133864,
-0.0167100839,
-0.0276400968,
0.01477833,
-0.0118224872,
-0.0451244041,
0.0292373821,
-0.0539194122,
0.046305228,
-0.002985683,
-0.020785138,
-0.0489557534,
0.005152002,
0.0040881075,
0.0069003776,
-0.0504692122,
-0.0506104007,
-0.0327659883,
0.0115718795,
-0.0167721789,
-0.0280661788,
-0.0080360379,
-0.0077380845,
0.0356947482,
-0.1015705988,
-0.0150299966,
1.730772168e-34,
0.0081762439,
-0.0070223166,
0.0560346842,
0.0332807302,
0.0068622534,
-0.0022099854,
0.0489907637,
0.0036908423,
0.0160662532,
-0.0301186237,
-0.0209928323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07189v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07189v4 | Reveal the Unknown: Out-of-Knowledge-Base Mention Discovery with Entity Linking | 2023-02-14T17:00:06 | 2023-09-01T20:32:05 | Hang Dong, Jiaoyan Chen, Yuan He, Yinan Liu, Ian Horrocks | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Discovering entity mentions that are out of a Knowledge Base (KB) from texts
plays a critical role in KB maintenance, but has not yet been fully explored.
The current methods are mostly limited to the simple threshold-based approach
and feature-based classification, and the datasets for evaluation are
relatively rare. We propose BLINKout, a new BERT-based Entity Linking (EL)
method which can identify mentions that do not have corresponding KB entities
by matching them to a special NIL entity. To better utilize BERT, we propose
new techniques including NIL entity representation and classification, with
synonym enhancement. We also apply KB Pruning and Versioning strategies to
automatically construct out-of-KB datasets from common in-KB EL datasets.
Results on five datasets of clinical notes, biomedical publications, and
Wikipedia articles in various domains show the advantages of BLINKout over
existing methods to identify out-of-KB mentions for the medical ontologies,
UMLS, SNOMED CT, and the general KB, WikiData. | [
0.0561450832,
-0.0281019807,
0.0130095426,
-0.012728814,
-0.0189624857,
0.0453979336,
-0.0243239254,
0.0705722943,
0.0430638418,
-0.0308943782,
0.0066894446,
0.0424736403,
-0.0022985714,
-0.0101422993,
0.0116180191,
-0.0105803376,
0.0293048415,
0.0436057709,
0.001899144,
-0.0057270671,
-0.0248374324,
0.0169546567,
-0.0280577987,
0.0007236961,
-0.0057680737,
0.021210799,
0.0326171629,
0.0060580648,
0.0585293397,
-0.0374393389,
0.0039693005,
0.0245955121,
-0.0504765958,
0.0184731353,
0.0000018083,
-0.0771774054,
-0.0261964314,
0.0387867428,
-0.0389077067,
0.004560458,
-0.0098749502,
-0.0111369221,
-0.0183428731,
-0.0118270572,
0.0223750975,
-0.0291641336,
0.0292197671,
0.0379731879,
0.0297250636,
0.0746794119,
-0.0091022337,
0.0387022495,
0.0217703823,
0.016104633,
0.0338406973,
-0.0166110676,
0.0702334195,
-0.0676630959,
0.0177731924,
-0.028000094,
0.0301862359,
0.0540608019,
-0.0450192988,
0.014404702,
0.0344069228,
0.0435394235,
-0.0584115162,
0.0081716683,
0.0442649499,
0.0517678671,
-0.0135776661,
-0.0090706395,
0.0785198212,
0.0354942419,
-0.0035609072,
0.0468699113,
0.0072132228,
-0.0416681655,
-0.0474571809,
-0.0019180438,
-0.0145829422,
-0.0267436597,
0.0225482807,
-0.0094064614,
-0.0087223854,
-0.0126007227,
0.0155801866,
-0.0213453975,
0.0203197058,
-0.0109842224,
-0.0127489176,
-0.0653511286,
0.0517345928,
0.0190750156,
-0.0042581549,
0.0099064559,
-0.0272596609,
-0.0128968488,
0.0665476099,
-0.0731366053,
-0.0615489073,
-0.0125181545,
-0.035908632,
0.0468204394,
-0.0567512885,
-0.0424958207,
0.0009988151,
-0.0443477593,
0.0141286999,
-0.0160214249,
-0.0587242134,
0.0062458296,
-0.0372074917,
0.0595265664,
-0.0076051657,
-0.005789679,
-0.0425717868,
-0.0274166912,
-0.02833944,
0.0722460896,
-0.0035866695,
-0.0060915775,
0.0088789752,
0.0115971612,
-0.0335681923,
0.0028812964,
0.0038255544,
-0.0386077948,
-0.0818168968,
0.0008275557,
0.0253672656,
-0.0049763578,
0.0307862256,
-0.0197402537,
0.0302016251,
0.0491570197,
0.0534902699,
-0.0385829881,
-0.0260754284,
-0.0318442099,
0.0115440357,
-0.0007956765,
-0.0217599869,
-0.0613213442,
-0.0142127415,
0.0070765186,
-0.0079564126,
-0.0691582561,
0.0297190472,
0.0441546701,
-0.0902912319,
0.0453354903,
-0.1131275743,
-0.0204649363,
0.0076445313,
0.0042721704,
0.0226618517,
0.0192109831,
0.0173232667,
-0.0666012093,
0.0306454897,
0.0266307667,
-0.0226024855,
0.0261704214,
0.0505371019,
-0.0155891748,
0.0365077071,
0.0207452606,
-0.0254689772,
0.0519647859,
-0.0168522969,
0.0577706806,
-0.020340601,
-0.0445902944,
-0.0147590069,
0.0217021815,
-0.0195230134,
0.0461274013,
-0.0033447447,
0.0121236797,
0.0090111112,
-0.0204631425,
-0.0253462121,
0.0109249437,
-0.0165116061,
-0.0124548692,
0.0137937069,
0.0330756046,
-0.015136539,
0.0230600275,
-0.018368151,
0.0091574453,
-0.0132507384,
-0.024881281,
0.0633179545,
0.0058641681,
-0.0303329639,
0.1344738454,
0.0440795161,
-0.0093734907,
0.0011581546,
-0.0271926504,
-0.0534942225,
0.071646221,
0.0758737698,
-0.0334187187,
-0.0633139163,
0.0028159702,
-0.0423382297,
0.0656369254,
-0.0412676856,
-0.0539159179,
0.0009690935,
-0.0101272585,
0.0105480542,
0.0211301893,
0.0211796798,
-0.0200781822,
0.0334862918,
0.057708323,
0.0113767404,
-0.0879211649,
0.0307630841,
0.0189239662,
-0.0272896346,
0.0258857273,
-0.0097518386,
0.0233782195,
-0.0200640373,
0.04524469,
-0.0021606516,
0.0160399005,
0.0295157339,
-0.0204601698,
-0.0148923825,
0.0105256606,
0.066486448,
-0.0630838349,
0.0467385165,
-0.0571504273,
-0.0148815745,
-0.0416308902,
0.0021416531,
-0.0288058948,
-0.0240942463,
-0.0290964562,
0.0936869904,
-0.0162680671,
0.0211758912,
-0.0003090309,
-0.0312670805,
0.0002866681,
0.0723429546,
-0.0345854238,
0.0337084606,
0.0505512506,
-0.0691020414,
0.046003677,
0.0084461197,
-0.07664226,
-0.0007650292,
0.0032342609,
-0.0192824267,
0.0135585358,
-0.0227538869,
-0.0351021439,
-0.0110459076,
-0.0937677324,
0.0191633347,
0.0249439534,
0.0526060872,
0.0401010513,
0.0217284374,
-0.0082528852,
-0.0237112548,
0.0229419451,
-0.0172121543,
-0.0142948478,
0.0026391735,
0.0370175466,
0.0307974648,
-0.0198438112,
0.0167896915,
0.01140837,
-0.0417518914,
0.0271869153,
-0.0150868483,
-0.0881265104,
-0.0519499816,
0.0130457524,
-0.0592426658,
-0.0014885782,
0.0298900772,
0.02042499,
-0.0317182317,
0.0369155593,
0.0041873641,
-0.0171563998,
-0.0225382894,
0.0118945772,
0.0254289173,
-0.0127442526,
-0.0282603074,
0.0188826676,
0.0072766151,
0.0162085649,
0.0077633844,
-0.0245540664,
0.0402582102,
-0.0101101529,
-0.0265890863,
-0.022506699,
-0.035557352,
-0.0151287923,
0.0177934859,
0.0417279601,
-0.0258225407,
0.0255248975,
-0.0034068762,
-0.0024467173,
0.0177645683,
0.0188431498,
0.052272886,
0.0054212152,
0.0517397635,
-0.0599154532,
0.0440128706,
-0.0087387254,
-0.0173880346,
-0.0283091962,
0.0197694842,
0.0574939772,
-0.0465658791,
0.0287290309,
0.0536798313,
-0.0279002506,
-0.000373068,
0.047616221,
0.0080590602,
0.0436703153,
0.0352605917,
0.0101816012,
-0.0254587568,
0.0034924122,
-0.0211266112,
-0.0025871131,
-0.0245401561,
-0.0293361191,
-0.0275091864,
0.0327994265,
-0.0130668608,
0.0496421568,
0.054476209,
-0.0162000023,
0.0128044477,
0.0451149866,
0.0232551619,
-0.0516109839,
0.0180894397,
0.046906095,
-0.0214036331,
0.0740687847,
0.015664747,
0.0051911543,
0.0203329809,
-0.0292665083,
0.0025963876,
-0.1170874387,
-0.0229334012,
-0.0013276783,
-0.0193882212,
-0.0240368582,
-0.0199258011,
0.1140766144,
0.0624848828,
-0.0417180583,
-0.001608963,
0.009631359,
-0.0390684716,
-0.0245178565,
0.0162705518,
-0.0676964298,
-0.0220895167,
-0.0112455906,
-0.010578136,
-0.017429553,
-0.0694189444,
0.0413040332,
-0.0753269121,
0.0000056076,
-0.0223529413,
-0.0066550313,
-0.0493706614,
-0.0492032021,
0.0361917168,
-0.0123527627,
-0.0370109975,
0.0116638998,
0.0105557358,
0.0194871854,
-0.0113552697,
-0.0200095344,
-0.0839787051,
0.0461751111,
-0.0585940965,
0.0615226552,
0.0291789081,
0.0961616263,
-0.0033907825,
0.009595572,
-0.0198106542,
-0.0574146248,
-0.0415646471,
-0.0139648654,
0.0878547728,
-0.0187043864,
0.0115342308,
-0.0482153669,
0.0097068949,
0.0005304927,
-0.0212392528,
0.000160402,
0.0441400073,
-0.0045922962,
0.0007785475,
-0.0261711441,
0.0000459181,
0.0118678315,
0.0559395142,
-0.0214598235,
0.0078437533,
0.0268178117,
0.0074753952,
0.0331878886,
0.0240320787,
0.0531202406,
0.0117756762,
-0.0906674191,
-0.0286544748,
-0.1217267737,
-0.0132006761,
0.0249492414,
0.0033203745,
0.0342902131,
0.0309438091,
0.0553276427,
0.0082595535,
-0.0556711964,
0.0146230329,
0.0112007204,
-0.002382508,
0.0055997684,
-0.0391327441,
0.050604485,
0.0264137443,
-0.0151309678,
-0.0199549142,
0.0096609984,
-0.033572156,
-0.0143215787,
-0.0265196133,
0.0201234668,
0.0377207175,
-0.0283591785,
0.0049736062,
0.0686000362,
0.0759654939,
-0.0131595386,
-0.0027650651,
-0.0122981416,
0.0361765772,
-0.0019593427,
0.0447304323,
-0.0276912451,
-0.0423603207,
-0.0187721979,
0.0346900374,
-0.053186886,
-0.0068386015,
0.0026758674,
0.0099312766,
0.0031148009,
-0.0271740034,
-0.0035939177,
-0.0141539872,
0.0374696068,
0.0230211616,
0.0061302581,
-0.003095523,
0.0065822634,
0.0050728014,
0.0311937593,
-0.0257992074,
0.0611472912,
-0.0386273451,
-0.0049181245,
-0.0372475274,
0.0228145588,
0.0169331208,
0.009545533,
0.0135777276,
-0.0615991242,
-0.0075613181,
-0.0166385155,
0.0221308004,
0.0207452551,
-0.0716096312,
0.0059958533,
0.0339807235,
-0.0187965296,
-0.003027891,
0.0425805859,
-0.0170126725,
0.0416305885,
-0.0423468165,
0.0458584614,
0.0455639884,
0.0174615774,
0.0713365674,
-0.0448573232,
-0.0427006595,
0.0242556222,
-0.0060823802,
-0.036557205,
0.0007979487,
-0.0080926968,
0.0120519036,
-0.0111365449,
0.0033878731,
0.0614026971,
0.006373757,
0.0840789154,
0.0284167659,
-0.0583412871,
-0.0454996005,
-0.0008560692,
-0.0019975461,
0.0154655408,
-0.0198336113,
0.0024435031,
-0.0566961169,
-0.0401234627,
0.0734699667,
-0.0193214826,
-0.0319231674,
0.0081764041,
0.059580896,
0.010962002,
0.079296425,
-0.029013684,
0.0026443312,
-0.0029455428,
-0.0037495121,
-0.0286366213,
0.003908095,
-5.63747695e-33,
-0.0198807474,
-0.0380184278,
0.0004639246,
-0.0167695712,
0.0060144719,
0.0239760727,
-0.0312454794,
-0.0802707896,
-0.024087524,
0.0180056412,
-0.0086915568,
0.0134306131,
0.0107641807,
-0.0133426758,
-0.0099892262,
-0.0066857375,
0.0256633405,
0.0284287427,
-0.0282159746,
0.0235666893,
0.0428995825,
0.0570920594,
0.0901870206,
-0.0350326709,
0.0406119935,
0.0115610231,
0.0074996809,
0.044554837,
0.0567964241,
0.0232024398,
-0.0395616628,
0.0398645401,
-0.0049586715,
0.0033283308,
0.0141614014,
-0.0511253662,
-0.1345905513,
-0.0182229578,
-0.0062229754,
-0.0308400635,
0.0796188489,
0.0004814281,
0.0293101091,
0.0094630057,
-0.0127713308,
0.0101694223,
0.0448820256,
-0.0191855337,
-0.0342271887,
-0.0273624901,
-0.0254451055,
0.0502551645,
0.0224344116,
0.0082469173,
0.0076858741,
-0.0614898689,
-0.0078986576,
-0.0555688702,
-0.0749719292,
-0.0058164741,
0.0454988368,
0.0260751098,
-0.0359770395,
-0.0717010871,
0.018283369,
0.0635523051,
0.0119555341,
-0.0123700565,
0.0020037161,
0.0334032252,
-0.0039350954,
0.0220726244,
-0.0109730875,
0.0424841456,
0.0256162193,
-0.0255273059,
-0.0669509396,
0.0603724346,
0.0007943353,
0.0337726362,
-0.0256671309,
-0.0353741609,
-0.0550364666,
-0.0286488533,
0.0077558649,
-0.00770834,
-0.014575284,
-0.0304363891,
-0.0154354386,
-0.017952431,
-0.0264664702,
0.0453477092,
-0.0453504585,
0.0153643321,
-0.0228189714,
0.0215494223,
0.042758923,
0.0259453412,
0.0024705604,
-0.022394022,
-0.0506840199,
-0.0322152786,
0.0225689076,
-0.0109547637,
0.0210144576,
0.0108791068,
0.0231896825,
-0.0134312054,
-0.0533501133,
0.0112181818,
0.0082182512,
-0.0337627232,
-0.0451811589,
-0.0241007041,
0.0053442656,
0.0141719328,
0.0301012136,
-0.0268151406,
0.0596933067,
0.0085050361,
-0.0320457108,
0.0377455726,
0.0207337886,
-0.0014505856,
-0.0048064198,
0.0105661834,
-0.0081926286,
0.043960683,
-0.0285560768,
-0.0724011585,
-0.0031855246,
-0.0085211638,
2.742e-7,
0.0436678529,
0.0490833521,
0.0145221949,
-0.0217094477,
0.0115468102,
-0.000378766,
0.015257746,
0.0295549016,
-0.0207103323,
-0.0052861525,
0.0094966814,
-0.038669683,
-0.0388156734,
0.0412382036,
-0.1023192927,
-0.0513561666,
-0.0244168323,
-0.0567443855,
-0.0430470109,
-0.0220969319,
-0.0181410071,
-0.0201627221,
0.0046572406,
-0.013610974,
-0.0150449602,
-0.029617656,
0.0126003437,
-0.0382042713,
0.0019141961,
0.0063495706,
0.0363579355,
0.0201051254,
0.0397035517,
0.0711320788,
-0.0216894802,
0.0306682214,
0.0096305832,
0.0197294224,
-0.0198151506,
-0.0047622123,
0.0025016272,
-0.0676598027,
0.0025664391,
-0.0161151476,
0.0529155992,
-0.0002609988,
-0.0013097088,
0.0317102037,
-0.0418471023,
-0.0113080107,
-0.016423149,
-0.0029872388,
-0.0417560041,
0.0364337899,
0.0050696353,
0.0045640543,
-0.0075087277,
-0.0744808912,
0.0062786019,
0.0472053736,
-0.0190074109,
-0.0603527464,
0.0222096704,
-0.0490321741,
-0.0172464978,
-0.0983346328,
0.0330561101,
2.619594901e-34,
-0.0009517284,
0.0155433649,
-0.0204720683,
0.0408293307,
0.0102188019,
-0.0401109233,
0.0045368797,
-0.0014862677,
-0.0058846236,
-0.0334640294,
0.0068033435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07159v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07159v1 | A Friendly Face: Do Text-to-Image Systems Rely on Stereotypes when the Input is Under-Specified? | 2023-02-14T16:11:06 | 2023-02-14T16:11:06 | Kathleen C. Fraser, Svetlana Kiritchenko, Isar Nejadgholi | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | As text-to-image systems continue to grow in popularity with the general
public, questions have arisen about bias and diversity in the generated images.
Here, we investigate properties of images generated in response to prompts
which are visually under-specified, but contain salient social attributes
(e.g., 'a portrait of a threatening person' versus 'a portrait of a friendly
person'). Grounding our work in social cognition theory, we find that in many
cases, images contain similar demographic biases to those reported in the
stereotype literature. However, trends are inconsistent across different models
and further investigation is warranted. | [
0.0441089422,
0.0151257701,
-0.0416782349,
0.0119691249,
0.0260697752,
0.0477218777,
0.0631792918,
-0.0067036212,
0.044723846,
-0.0590802543,
-0.0116112493,
-0.0497170016,
0.0547030754,
0.0169287007,
0.0452349782,
-0.1161849648,
-0.0147668431,
0.0249417443,
0.0042468146,
-0.0299106129,
0.0234088395,
0.0441336408,
0.0315418504,
0.0432082936,
-0.1045241803,
-0.0094548892,
0.0370844305,
0.0311184395,
0.0080343299,
-0.0191736054,
-0.0175541844,
0.0364952944,
0.0003714461,
0.006559771,
0.000001668,
-0.0992635563,
0.0497975871,
-0.0000291987,
0.0101806968,
0.0093785385,
0.0817570835,
-0.0372148193,
0.0071645668,
0.0007564068,
-0.0275300648,
0.011825162,
0.0944620222,
0.0687835068,
0.0308838096,
-0.0117227314,
-0.0020070844,
-0.0191476438,
-0.0603144616,
0.0048977202,
0.0276940726,
0.0508557931,
0.0037113882,
-0.0828627944,
-0.0513101108,
-0.024478225,
-0.0065451427,
0.0047998317,
-0.008677206,
0.0174248572,
0.0145386122,
0.0490484089,
-0.0257194266,
-0.0630224422,
-0.0267612878,
0.0510486253,
0.0160640366,
0.01279944,
-0.025466783,
-0.0170125552,
0.0320965648,
0.0446403846,
0.0191317648,
0.0082126278,
-0.018970076,
-0.0099215694,
-0.104977034,
0.0339613482,
0.0063230167,
-0.0108850729,
0.0088659106,
-0.0263363142,
0.0142107401,
0.0107702333,
-0.022781821,
0.0213276725,
-0.0103479913,
-0.0357303023,
0.0342754461,
0.011971076,
0.0522228964,
-0.0150549682,
-0.0282246508,
-0.0445448197,
0.0105535993,
-0.0574040897,
0.013899168,
0.0122299204,
-0.0436801612,
0.0103570586,
0.0468698889,
0.0371353924,
0.0138684297,
-0.0106375273,
-0.0104721002,
0.020487668,
-0.0112178922,
-0.0488430932,
0.0166063141,
-0.0418553203,
0.04832137,
0.0251353178,
-0.0442850552,
-0.0354169644,
-0.0502387881,
0.0126149654,
-0.0199393481,
0.0598042309,
-0.0475424044,
0.0020097636,
-0.0972078443,
0.0063392492,
-0.0484158471,
-0.0030464362,
-0.0467444547,
-0.0695728585,
0.0220983364,
-0.0171873569,
0.0255365241,
-0.0203072317,
0.0127500836,
0.064617686,
0.0000613638,
-0.0333649032,
-0.0226478986,
0.0081843017,
-0.0349676199,
-0.0310011879,
0.028319668,
-0.0263918545,
0.010802648,
-0.0002578335,
0.0165493265,
-0.0490637012,
-0.0064373189,
0.0306674074,
-0.0352340154,
0.0676270351,
0.0399741232,
0.0119718229,
0.045555383,
0.0258259792,
-0.0709585324,
0.0354064852,
0.0118879778,
0.0329827778,
0.0213899445,
-0.0404433422,
0.0389144942,
0.0388846807,
-0.0069150408,
0.0072237989,
0.0077731824,
0.0240778495,
0.0104513941,
-0.0261536557,
0.0555292033,
0.0125029255,
0.0017088113,
-0.0132472962,
0.0900312662,
0.0874204263,
-0.0340459645,
0.0252859853,
0.0072310679,
0.0111870952,
0.0105217444,
0.020770669,
-0.0754541233,
0.0401373655,
0.0102561675,
-0.0140842302,
-0.0477459766,
0.0990067646,
-0.0474425443,
0.0085152881,
0.0079576038,
-0.0038639032,
0.0399331413,
-0.0222911686,
0.0102936355,
0.044484511,
-0.0146466261,
-0.0120801348,
-0.0018491101,
-0.0127097974,
0.0016441038,
-0.0348514393,
0.008411142,
0.0526648983,
-0.0283804704,
0.0191451926,
0.0647818297,
-0.0470083803,
-0.0207627919,
0.0572725683,
0.0302659851,
0.0327055156,
0.0084327413,
-0.00481355,
0.005721488,
0.004247291,
0.0154788652,
0.0482270829,
0.029795561,
0.0538337678,
0.0098233586,
0.029241899,
-0.0281840712,
0.0133645395,
0.0576616786,
-0.0289856642,
-0.033160083,
0.0598056205,
0.0018527991,
0.0170343034,
-0.0136230299,
-0.0106456,
-0.0215823688,
0.026846962,
0.02883696,
0.0542011634,
-0.0625279173,
0.0115859043,
0.0210837536,
-0.084109202,
-0.081346646,
0.0055831554,
0.0245485939,
0.03258406,
0.0542739853,
-0.0307496265,
0.0121882483,
-0.0083777606,
-0.0089984555,
-0.0101030134,
0.0154105593,
0.0302440748,
0.0462034978,
0.0001087982,
-0.0509909056,
0.008253919,
-0.0336752571,
-0.0209624544,
-0.0196665321,
-0.0223153345,
-0.021426985,
0.0079549178,
-0.0056349183,
-0.0285634715,
0.0031097338,
-0.0597902089,
0.0160687082,
-0.036616262,
-0.0540673472,
0.0139924744,
-0.0578949563,
-0.0134773059,
-0.018925989,
-0.0019530535,
-0.018756846,
-0.0688561276,
0.0010945852,
-0.0250723399,
0.0322792195,
0.0038552007,
-0.0215442106,
0.0024484149,
-0.0062277741,
-0.010681455,
-0.0197914578,
0.0803364068,
0.0493545942,
-0.0118386131,
-0.0222280137,
0.0077427933,
-0.0470923223,
0.0225922428,
0.0078299297,
-0.0213796739,
0.0582762659,
0.0502051786,
0.0462030992,
0.0549207106,
0.0550782792,
0.0083597684,
0.0128259817,
0.0327374488,
-0.0179181639,
-0.0302454326,
-0.0150716361,
0.0242148433,
0.0627544597,
-0.1122674793,
-0.0168899894,
0.0004267731,
0.0158265121,
0.0082432507,
-0.072895363,
0.0766671449,
-0.0018497738,
-0.06464836,
-0.0706330761,
-0.0113686528,
0.014470269,
0.0232736003,
-0.0496161096,
-0.0750921294,
0.0645235032,
0.0043226015,
-0.0135731185,
0.0743738785,
0.0355366915,
0.0215870496,
0.0498189889,
0.0201619286,
0.0394618213,
0.0587460548,
0.0158619564,
-0.0374965593,
-0.0169638377,
0.0261753965,
-0.0227309633,
0.0094587151,
-0.0097937062,
-0.0569526032,
-0.0065624132,
-0.0344689526,
-0.0044253292,
-0.0573326126,
-0.0204028077,
-0.0211639348,
-0.0413320698,
-0.0136663541,
0.0183946919,
0.0080143688,
0.0180364214,
-0.029317135,
-0.0064964467,
-0.0232536122,
0.0107710212,
-0.0187166985,
-0.0013266515,
0.024712285,
0.0191572998,
-0.02320241,
-0.0126215555,
0.0153614031,
-0.0296831299,
-0.0302243549,
-0.0295900926,
0.0348870829,
0.0013590009,
0.0874988958,
-0.0078669023,
0.0065779779,
0.05635757,
0.0401556753,
0.0379175954,
0.0380653366,
-0.0081811631,
-0.0181724206,
0.0087130992,
0.0043550031,
0.0168619379,
0.0299704131,
-0.0186378993,
-0.0211669765,
0.0247000251,
-0.0103764934,
0.0139394095,
-0.0593289249,
-0.0171565823,
-0.0153545849,
-0.0749676004,
0.0591707826,
-0.0043858448,
-0.0315151997,
-0.0028063047,
0.0298285559,
0.0219276063,
0.0358780101,
-0.0080326479,
-0.0060409638,
-0.0146198487,
-0.0032881193,
-0.0123231858,
0.0058143339,
0.0089311115,
0.0087400367,
-0.024806533,
-0.0115157021,
0.0387587212,
0.0311702155,
0.0390867405,
-0.0388276614,
-0.0458961762,
0.0324199907,
0.0510523245,
-0.0156910401,
0.0636845827,
-0.0294372775,
-0.0090194214,
-0.050815355,
0.0233589504,
0.0419068821,
0.0095041441,
0.000411203,
0.0073576979,
0.0406844504,
-0.046287518,
-0.039722465,
-0.0135710845,
-0.0068524298,
0.0295799933,
0.0076535973,
-0.023760885,
-0.0016901636,
-0.0359070227,
0.056853082,
0.0003324044,
-0.0682293847,
0.0418412089,
-0.0279275533,
-0.0902356952,
-0.0225632638,
-0.0315268897,
0.0006665697,
0.0190791544,
0.0145406509,
-0.0879430324,
0.012032344,
0.0063945856,
-0.0160265397,
0.0517856926,
-0.000492569,
0.0082131857,
0.0249721631,
-0.0066721914,
-0.0425485931,
-0.0726562142,
-0.0054083783,
-0.0054527633,
-0.0297720004,
-0.0141814034,
0.0331807323,
0.0478538461,
0.0261156242,
-0.0104010599,
0.0327831879,
-0.051578369,
0.0638149828,
0.0396353789,
0.0745868981,
0.0177654754,
-0.0352240019,
0.0339797959,
-0.0147182317,
-0.0063194688,
-0.0044654915,
0.0232190043,
0.0210044757,
-0.0786165744,
-0.0439286791,
-0.0177847371,
-0.0189011469,
-0.0047614905,
0.0195361711,
-0.0366471782,
0.0036735861,
0.004320872,
-0.0142980972,
-0.0134838857,
-0.008923335,
0.0027303833,
-0.0703843236,
-0.0119816568,
0.024937747,
-0.0160734393,
-0.0346615314,
-0.0450884402,
0.0780483037,
-0.0415552706,
-0.0367889702,
0.0840579718,
0.0235260352,
0.0101978173,
0.0067311833,
0.0141970897,
0.0506100915,
-0.0497746132,
0.0168200713,
0.0234446153,
0.0542542525,
0.0040288898,
-0.0120667806,
-0.0335802734,
-0.0030768081,
-0.0153782014,
-0.0272271205,
-0.0143835107,
0.0188719388,
-0.0151982866,
-0.0280817244,
0.0043597114,
-0.0176171735,
0.0011851803,
0.0169625208,
-0.0082389349,
0.0234294236,
-0.0373576134,
0.0500813983,
-0.032243751,
0.0043273335,
0.0115560181,
0.0286723059,
-0.042837359,
0.0166234598,
-0.0127485506,
-0.077894941,
-0.0076809684,
-0.0031876878,
0.0560989566,
-0.0251216888,
0.022004718,
-0.0074441102,
-0.0836277008,
-0.0474239737,
0.0253051817,
-0.0098054549,
0.0261563323,
0.0045589395,
0.0479810685,
0.0031036239,
-0.0195564032,
-0.025038546,
0.0486060865,
0.0505928956,
-0.0582825057,
0.0176031739,
-0.0187096931,
-5.734011485e-33,
-0.0115794819,
-0.0282328911,
-0.0274120383,
-0.0351366326,
-0.0091755018,
-0.0198415723,
0.0072676567,
0.0065493821,
-0.0074325074,
0.0204976331,
-0.0134015288,
-0.0035837193,
0.0092543261,
-0.0190876462,
-0.0145406267,
0.003999514,
0.0561337471,
-0.0285643041,
-0.0391833708,
-0.0390274711,
0.0187876374,
-0.0173083264,
0.0111296177,
-0.0650350899,
0.0383147709,
-0.0329480432,
-0.0395575166,
-0.0454439111,
0.0309306197,
0.0094387028,
-0.0207461175,
0.0518451445,
0.0408657044,
0.0062678666,
0.0198995396,
0.1185673028,
-0.0266490877,
-0.0182967819,
-0.0271385405,
-0.0012999589,
-0.0128845973,
-0.0138237923,
0.0050284676,
-0.0211741384,
-0.0554562695,
-0.0008833718,
0.0616768785,
-0.0134505341,
0.0789037421,
0.0292272177,
-0.019068012,
-0.0386383571,
-0.0067672823,
0.0021782052,
-0.0332061797,
0.075915277,
0.0203030854,
0.0496635474,
-0.0461529195,
0.0639811382,
-0.0050219735,
-0.0701978207,
0.0621285848,
0.0337455757,
0.0380973481,
0.0311115105,
0.0452962406,
0.0472682752,
-0.0518328063,
-0.0678584501,
0.0226737317,
-0.0146742258,
0.0372151025,
0.1026340425,
0.0243113413,
-0.0776659399,
0.0150249582,
0.0130331814,
0.0229794625,
-0.0136304544,
0.0377319045,
-0.0132691031,
-0.0601616576,
-0.0164091513,
-0.0022779021,
-0.0324103273,
-0.042229034,
-0.0627988428,
0.0196273625,
-0.0344677605,
-0.0102708917,
0.0339676403,
0.0150333857,
0.0005653053,
-0.0481537879,
-0.0541284122,
-0.0077813626,
0.024160333,
0.0079371724,
-0.0272621419,
-0.0178703088,
-0.0042687324,
0.0452405512,
0.0550961457,
0.0253354479,
0.0273829419,
0.0244906601,
-0.0297779161,
-0.0434454344,
-0.0048499485,
0.0102768224,
0.0221326388,
0.0206047501,
-0.0022063649,
0.0290726703,
0.0121598095,
-0.0282955058,
-0.0656111687,
0.0124207307,
-0.0115038352,
-0.0459984876,
-0.0077964296,
-0.0422322191,
0.0161557291,
-0.0339769423,
0.0062948628,
-0.0414584428,
-0.0283501167,
0.0428144448,
-0.0343470164,
-0.0150588378,
-0.0415429957,
2.314e-7,
-0.0312470272,
0.0339470245,
-0.0000720772,
0.0097089848,
0.0662215278,
0.0780131593,
0.0135159669,
0.0484088473,
0.0534201153,
-0.0256943423,
-0.0405143276,
0.0134766409,
-0.0064349608,
0.0253065061,
0.0079719452,
0.0038707114,
-0.0109898932,
0.0263869688,
0.0081925029,
0.0465770885,
0.0587375388,
0.0142623261,
0.0056653582,
-0.0255061816,
-0.0149929123,
-0.0367454886,
0.0298435818,
-0.0517425463,
0.0230685622,
-0.0751915649,
-0.0290918443,
-0.0048063914,
0.0229118764,
0.0521976389,
0.0124818943,
-0.0111482078,
0.0089324703,
-0.0178829599,
-0.0454644896,
0.0281785987,
0.0089896908,
0.0320879631,
-0.0293796398,
-0.0461721607,
0.0450287946,
-0.015619209,
-0.0311097298,
-0.0128209768,
-0.0245059337,
-0.0073429216,
0.0356699042,
-0.0235348195,
-0.0421819091,
-0.0132703558,
0.0441587232,
-0.0072452915,
-0.0108792037,
-0.0524963848,
-0.0248587355,
-0.0368158072,
0.0273452997,
-0.0858637244,
-0.052426029,
0.0650238618,
0.0361320451,
-0.0190696735,
-0.0012217747,
1.437905786e-34,
-0.0135074612,
0.0189532004,
0.0332872197,
-0.0730750784,
0.0289426092,
-0.0133517394,
0.0025244462,
-0.0393620357,
0.0649965182,
-0.0373823829,
-0.0001668905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07139v1 | Modeling Complex Event Scenarios via Simple Entity-focused Questions | 2023-02-14T15:48:56 | 2023-02-14T15:48:56 | Mahnaz Koupaee, Greg Durrett, Nathanael Chambers, Niranjan Balasubramanian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event scenarios are often complex and involve multiple event sequences
connected through different entity participants. Exploring such complex
scenarios requires an ability to branch through different sequences, something
that is difficult to achieve with standard event language modeling. To address
this, we propose a question-guided generation framework that models events in
complex scenarios as answers to questions about participants. At any step in
the generation process, the framework uses the previously generated events as
context, but generates the next event as an answer to one of three questions:
what else a participant did, what else happened to a participant, or what else
happened. The participants and the questions themselves can be sampled or be
provided as input from a user, allowing for controllable exploration. Our
empirical evaluation shows that this question-guided generation provides better
coverage of participants, diverse events within a domain, comparable
perplexities for modeling event sequences, and more effective control for
interactive schema generation. | [
0.0050061806,
0.0365857296,
-0.0260880422,
0.0376079939,
-0.0304270554,
-0.0039090053,
-0.009690932,
-0.0206605494,
0.0125041343,
-0.0062770327,
0.0663108006,
-0.0264838878,
-0.0360298268,
0.0744289607,
-0.0296016764,
-0.0972518027,
0.0278430711,
-0.0092769135,
-0.0210364927,
0.0407940634,
0.0094219344,
0.0113680139,
-0.038236659,
0.0355905667,
-0.0261378828,
-0.0036610188,
-0.1066474244,
0.0141456816,
0.0041393163,
-0.0649483576,
-0.0392864347,
0.046382729,
0.055777438,
-0.0202097706,
0.0000022069,
-0.0399152823,
-0.0378188975,
-0.0019292329,
-0.0093049109,
-0.002313144,
-0.0610976182,
0.0506821685,
0.0198388156,
-0.0178764146,
-0.047612004,
-0.0217970759,
0.0308875367,
0.0299872663,
0.0284891259,
0.0349568501,
-0.0151207,
-0.024326846,
-0.0276996344,
-0.004114192,
0.0243188646,
-0.0279958565,
-0.0366594717,
0.0028474284,
0.0792949498,
-0.0168545954,
0.0292891487,
-0.0203148723,
0.0290089119,
0.0096926335,
0.0183184352,
0.039482493,
0.0237009916,
-0.0100842649,
0.0045886384,
0.0536748767,
0.0537106544,
0.0037614706,
0.0297720972,
-0.0250767302,
0.0242795702,
0.0369049944,
-0.0490662865,
0.0176473781,
-0.0403505825,
-0.0218144879,
0.0099224616,
0.0184292123,
-0.0074411486,
-0.018163614,
-0.0352080166,
0.0088549089,
0.0320177265,
0.0076752771,
-0.1074411124,
-0.0056764367,
-0.0345474444,
-0.0664720982,
0.0154870888,
0.066526629,
-0.102710329,
0.0132060824,
-0.0246580262,
0.0512306578,
0.0159663185,
-0.0249102693,
0.021457538,
0.0410589501,
0.0187795181,
0.0032490098,
0.074798204,
-0.0070544854,
-0.0049825883,
-0.0541462339,
-0.0229006261,
0.0297278799,
-0.0281918384,
0.0133249564,
-0.0471635796,
0.0261762906,
-0.0930324048,
-0.0000858078,
0.0130995438,
0.0543895327,
0.0387177728,
0.0016960327,
-0.0229507741,
0.0319179855,
-0.0661529154,
0.0125316605,
-0.0536368415,
-0.031690672,
-0.1011038497,
-0.0065686968,
0.034878701,
-0.0308110956,
0.0062933243,
-0.009548042,
0.0363149308,
0.0193329323,
-0.0632220656,
0.0656079948,
0.0074865753,
0.012967119,
-0.0735443681,
-0.1153338477,
0.0100348918,
-0.0121651087,
-0.0494169146,
-0.065968506,
0.0308677144,
0.0015040323,
-0.0411200561,
-0.0066268276,
0.0266485419,
0.0446044393,
-0.0005659864,
0.0354726613,
-0.0316855386,
0.0316683352,
0.0278109089,
0.0349819735,
-0.0058733062,
0.0359194353,
0.0409155488,
0.0213300809,
0.0214325283,
0.0248416997,
0.0099792061,
0.0102861105,
0.0101190936,
-0.0196365882,
0.0166978613,
0.0357349254,
-0.0159034114,
0.0250992533,
-0.0204915814,
0.0008653345,
-0.0178776998,
0.0278069228,
0.0117922602,
0.0136330007,
-0.026740076,
0.0117845396,
0.0849429965,
-0.0076746987,
-0.0201776568,
0.073046498,
0.0071370038,
0.0267863721,
0.0358042829,
-0.0244702194,
-0.0236942451,
-0.0207882077,
-0.0263635628,
-0.0176143087,
0.0476082377,
0.0219930671,
0.0273431335,
0.0116071962,
-0.0044123214,
0.0367658325,
-0.0250748806,
0.0714709237,
0.0008921531,
-0.0744190291,
0.0226217657,
-0.006699712,
0.0409728736,
0.0752047226,
0.0720664486,
-0.0433208346,
-0.0608132668,
0.0185204484,
0.035796985,
0.0393645428,
0.0756580606,
-0.0365224369,
0.0068183374,
0.0018959473,
-0.0289783496,
-0.0148711847,
0.0081721088,
0.0177695714,
-0.0044338102,
-0.0228613876,
0.0060535017,
-0.0034984197,
0.0174732562,
0.0243767872,
-0.0541706495,
-0.048721619,
-0.0274701845,
0.0159601159,
-0.0152309211,
0.0386936702,
0.0248020794,
0.0368566029,
0.0397727117,
-0.0255252458,
-0.0365465544,
0.0600881539,
-0.0244501475,
-0.0397120528,
0.0187747739,
-0.0164763685,
-0.0138368318,
-0.0474621132,
-0.0224240609,
-0.0677156821,
0.011302148,
-0.0134809073,
0.0095657101,
-0.0078740548,
0.0181055926,
0.0228840951,
-0.0466439798,
-0.0439441875,
0.0700688735,
0.0178377181,
-0.0148130944,
0.0137570901,
-0.0136837885,
0.0369843245,
-0.0492063351,
0.0171267986,
0.033134345,
-0.0049783243,
-0.0231665894,
0.0484821945,
-0.0178908333,
-0.0562930591,
0.0159357823,
-0.0719814152,
0.0340112112,
-0.035908673,
0.0366807878,
0.0351177901,
0.0628281981,
-0.0181256048,
-0.0033466918,
-0.043712765,
-0.0381551161,
0.0077395779,
-0.0200496186,
0.034423884,
0.0478010476,
0.003470079,
-0.0396907441,
0.0146965683,
-0.0377893448,
0.0453523882,
0.0485801063,
0.0126994615,
-0.0403320752,
-0.0059016049,
-0.0305609088,
0.0108576622,
0.0242631808,
0.0318806395,
0.0612034947,
-0.0348032862,
0.0628576204,
-0.0274433214,
-0.0167151149,
0.0782174766,
-0.0008012102,
-0.082482487,
-0.030898029,
0.0165181365,
-0.0293230247,
0.0186955854,
-0.00341765,
-0.0283476189,
0.0252600834,
0.0372563042,
0.0069696391,
0.0070560467,
-0.0436432101,
-0.0069280062,
-0.0106471889,
0.0365056396,
-0.0118774865,
-0.0632219389,
-0.0148998098,
0.0618861839,
-0.0065364889,
0.0158483144,
0.0562224686,
0.0076115555,
0.0396315493,
-0.0384689048,
0.0098390188,
-0.0483999848,
0.117982313,
-0.0141234072,
0.0263876989,
0.0167265534,
-0.0390120298,
-0.0418103449,
0.0038566266,
0.0291747805,
-0.0280267652,
0.0291461442,
-0.0903705731,
-0.0206295624,
0.0045009125,
-0.0075475732,
-0.0431485437,
-0.0321502797,
0.0362639986,
-0.0148951858,
0.0324958451,
0.0195681658,
-0.0301077235,
-0.0000618183,
-0.0091040265,
0.0310585536,
0.0057325051,
-0.0178227108,
-0.0204322953,
0.0975726396,
0.0460343584,
0.0153563851,
0.0036396047,
-0.039857801,
0.0402288251,
0.0594815277,
0.0339938216,
0.0005552269,
0.0056335102,
0.0083796931,
-0.0064151506,
-0.0637755841,
-0.0083528226,
0.049311243,
0.0662820861,
-0.0605372488,
-0.0123751825,
0.0884317681,
0.0753115118,
0.0057541775,
0.0436777547,
0.0029308149,
0.032566186,
0.0136248805,
0.0286089685,
-0.1043270528,
0.0168510005,
-0.0195404869,
-0.0035426188,
-0.0079096211,
-0.0729575902,
-0.0167152584,
-0.0674139336,
0.0403374173,
-0.0266065076,
-0.045933973,
-0.000726309,
-0.0374308415,
0.0152797224,
0.0470752455,
-0.0213764925,
0.0536528975,
-0.0007363642,
0.011870916,
-0.029228054,
-0.0251065493,
-0.0346121639,
0.0054464415,
-0.0512620807,
0.0414836854,
0.0313400254,
0.0085519487,
0.044060193,
0.0684468523,
-0.0402886905,
-0.0186095349,
0.0266401451,
-0.017802842,
0.0315498337,
0.0292752609,
-0.0096125221,
-0.0341396891,
0.0575544126,
-0.0116544357,
-0.0465040468,
0.036839582,
0.0585320927,
-0.0496809557,
0.000197748,
-0.0262297578,
-0.0174420215,
0.0545512475,
0.0258722696,
0.0591799207,
-0.019017145,
-0.0190983154,
-0.00572275,
0.0213662218,
-0.0784168914,
0.0141312946,
-0.0034625693,
0.0212292057,
-0.0030612743,
-0.0570279583,
-0.0830700919,
0.0381084457,
0.0216057394,
-0.0085289693,
-0.0041503017,
0.0343080312,
-0.027651269,
-0.0571065247,
0.016927151,
-0.0059175855,
0.0054363422,
0.0395983681,
-0.0152197592,
-0.0060587744,
0.0223343987,
0.0095651718,
0.0524755009,
-0.0594860464,
-0.0248477794,
-0.019772185,
-0.0060410234,
0.0140517494,
0.0283843111,
0.0007931496,
-0.0220208112,
-0.0615400299,
-0.0174279287,
-0.0535822883,
-0.0495468304,
-0.0640020967,
0.0409262143,
-0.0167190135,
0.0141792996,
-0.03164557,
0.0303928517,
-0.0575822406,
0.0917318463,
-0.0625255704,
-0.0399831422,
0.0388766713,
-0.008601292,
-0.0002109423,
-0.0277827028,
-0.023562666,
-0.014182711,
0.0035805122,
-0.0837466642,
-0.0099596931,
-0.0212322492,
0.0154423006,
-0.0662738606,
-0.0158535764,
0.0103916777,
-0.019441789,
-0.0585927404,
0.0379433632,
-0.0534138866,
0.0089442879,
0.0275456551,
-0.0224431418,
0.0175281093,
-0.0031680863,
-0.0238391254,
0.0146687143,
0.0039119576,
0.035182178,
-0.0133429868,
0.0450053848,
0.0106372992,
0.0310563985,
-0.0009985374,
-0.0282629691,
-0.0380531922,
-0.0195723828,
0.0166963879,
0.0238372479,
0.0360234454,
0.0246609114,
0.0090286033,
-0.0090386588,
-0.0096598128,
0.0267318748,
0.0189768896,
0.0420225374,
-0.0232495535,
0.0105049815,
0.0358796343,
-0.0183607209,
-0.0130185941,
0.0469715372,
-0.0011734741,
0.0497552343,
-0.0244135298,
-0.0166553725,
-0.0693431422,
-0.0351839289,
0.0366404131,
0.0284606386,
-0.0338051617,
-0.0099615082,
-0.0945693702,
0.0074563283,
0.0075556128,
0.0326977745,
-0.015671527,
-0.0120110298,
0.0464725532,
0.0206569843,
0.0218496136,
-0.0277789198,
-0.0142671643,
0.0451136976,
-0.0518894345,
-0.0467749313,
-0.0281412303,
-5.930763893e-33,
-0.0610835105,
-0.0720166266,
0.0697439089,
0.000698977,
-0.0009877424,
-0.0386580341,
-0.0741707906,
0.0051813642,
0.0152940508,
-0.0004022651,
0.0200847294,
-0.010043012,
0.0116324034,
-0.0043136468,
-0.0095816487,
-0.0428454466,
0.0588711798,
0.0089434842,
-0.0193313584,
0.0601583906,
0.0231432263,
0.0002585937,
-0.0302699581,
-0.0668295696,
0.0235167351,
-0.0276716184,
-0.0052774823,
0.015702663,
0.0583472177,
0.0206614435,
-0.0177237894,
-0.0076056998,
0.0154019156,
-0.0196302477,
-0.0096005592,
-0.005046491,
-0.044918865,
-0.0261850543,
0.0041792258,
-0.0216721967,
-0.0371573009,
-0.0414838605,
0.0021437481,
0.0013673204,
0.0545817912,
0.0017928304,
0.0300140642,
0.0188348759,
0.0041405465,
-0.0267124549,
-0.0608781762,
0.0184166413,
-0.0160396788,
-0.0111659085,
-0.04153312,
0.0296278428,
0.0188571978,
-0.0274825804,
0.017545661,
0.0322342813,
0.009364984,
-0.0143945459,
-0.0024493942,
-0.0194211267,
-0.0215003286,
0.0216408316,
-0.0019053889,
0.0200331993,
-0.0479053929,
0.0779839307,
-0.0190859362,
0.0801620409,
0.0012138141,
0.060903579,
-0.0232430771,
0.0212961938,
-0.0714347512,
0.0807041004,
-0.0141770411,
-0.0279480796,
-0.0260481872,
-0.0024792396,
-0.0243939906,
-0.0027366779,
-0.0377877615,
0.0368936025,
-0.0266613178,
-0.0300224833,
0.0313690118,
-0.0306073539,
-0.0274487287,
0.0115721803,
0.0062277531,
-0.0044016517,
-0.0296217836,
0.0133509338,
-0.0186497141,
-0.0041572815,
-0.0136185363,
0.0449317992,
-0.0095014563,
0.0033473973,
0.040223252,
-0.0116372984,
0.0119219758,
0.0532619804,
-0.0280461032,
0.0413802154,
-0.0208950993,
0.0212934837,
-0.0175674297,
-0.0009440274,
-0.0409252048,
-0.0177474804,
0.0134136798,
-0.0057571894,
-0.0096066259,
0.0090882871,
0.0169215258,
-0.0013457724,
0.0029798115,
-0.0170125663,
0.0005234275,
0.0460106917,
0.0313341692,
0.0057475958,
-0.0367781967,
0.0293341018,
0.0212860871,
-0.0257976819,
-0.0274776928,
0.0116083445,
2.701e-7,
0.0360258445,
-0.0012797585,
0.0319999047,
0.1013327911,
-0.0074837138,
0.0034378376,
0.0344857872,
0.0415243022,
0.008739749,
-0.0147146368,
0.0332691148,
0.0198536739,
0.0040435414,
0.0735070184,
-0.0545447357,
-0.0314658768,
-0.0034759913,
0.0167157538,
-0.0797769055,
-0.003224669,
0.1217754781,
0.0133517263,
0.0160752721,
0.0291198976,
0.0266656447,
-0.004028162,
0.0258899946,
0.0065774731,
-0.0355640315,
0.0436192639,
-0.0437342897,
0.0218246989,
-0.0253898893,
0.0229304824,
-0.0442484654,
-0.0099149076,
-0.0212457944,
0.0174913406,
0.0112522468,
-0.0212020408,
0.0128018344,
-0.0670390427,
0.0136941718,
-0.049790062,
0.0477068089,
-0.0575044975,
0.000620288,
0.0495820157,
-0.0367826037,
0.0086433263,
-0.0467449501,
-0.0001441359,
-0.0181284975,
0.0199880488,
-0.0191551056,
0.0306710117,
0.0009525741,
-0.0237943754,
-0.0218929034,
0.0154294884,
-0.0242363922,
-0.0359105654,
-0.0331530496,
-0.0455747433,
-0.0496415533,
-0.0140086096,
0.0014511339,
2.43295877e-34,
-0.0011227484,
0.0578254759,
-0.0260598864,
0.016086949,
0.0446914434,
-0.0154900355,
-0.0088315457,
0.011160519,
0.0498430245,
-0.0228745751,
-0.0304432679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07124v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07124v1 | Exploiting Summarization Data to Help Text Simplification | 2023-02-14T15:32:04 | 2023-02-14T15:32:04 | Renliang Sun, Zhixian Yang, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | One of the major problems with text simplification is the lack of
high-quality data. The sources of simplification datasets are limited to
Wikipedia and Newsela, restricting further development of this field. In this
paper, we analyzed the similarity between text summarization and text
simplification and exploited summarization data to help simplify. First, we
proposed an alignment algorithm to extract sentence pairs from summarization
datasets. Then, we designed four attributes to characterize the degree of
simplification and proposed a method to filter suitable pairs. We named these
pairs Sum4Simp (S4S). Next, we conducted human evaluations to show that S4S is
high-quality and compared it with a real simplification dataset. Finally, we
conducted experiments to illustrate that the S4S can improve the performance of
several mainstream simplification models, especially in low-resource scenarios. | [
-0.00000772,
-0.0068310462,
-0.0108670583,
0.0085275676,
-0.0395222306,
0.0193027407,
-0.0239940565,
0.0292023309,
-0.0138761541,
-0.0100194225,
0.0212764051,
0.0463069975,
0.0795683339,
-0.0661243349,
0.0083184484,
-0.1003255248,
0.0134925069,
0.0220977571,
0.0012063921,
0.0177675914,
0.0562350526,
0.0076961243,
-0.0023999505,
0.0244901422,
0.0288820509,
0.0027686018,
0.0207841136,
0.0177045707,
0.0493189543,
0.0250278227,
0.0153696872,
0.047366783,
-0.0127490656,
-0.029707104,
0.0000018588,
-0.0317021124,
-0.0345678888,
-0.0127049377,
0.0275476705,
0.0668743625,
0.0760109946,
-0.0583105236,
0.0125820795,
0.0249227099,
-0.0202663969,
-0.0143941185,
0.0184792802,
0.0086804498,
0.0695052296,
0.0669645593,
-0.0382498316,
-0.0459503494,
-0.0366044417,
0.0076718968,
-0.0324414074,
-0.004028081,
0.0239934102,
0.0108298175,
-0.0319562145,
-0.0370127894,
0.0018065193,
0.030053867,
-0.0334466696,
-0.0129876183,
0.0253030639,
0.0186113492,
-0.0716818199,
-0.0011397898,
0.0412512496,
0.0835858881,
-0.0027636059,
-0.0451186076,
0.0294280257,
0.0084636016,
0.0148748588,
0.0462497957,
-0.0750656277,
-0.0328360386,
-0.0088246278,
0.0297171958,
-0.0200941321,
0.0141247604,
-0.0030075833,
0.0066658882,
0.002168101,
-0.0040468816,
0.0319999196,
-0.0060213897,
-0.0426873192,
-0.0257479791,
-0.0064755762,
-0.0731819049,
0.036855612,
0.0481023081,
0.0052970387,
-0.0124274204,
-0.081373468,
-0.0983643904,
0.0197364613,
-0.0402755402,
-0.0320733599,
0.0183287915,
0.0410249941,
0.0323775485,
-0.0444038101,
0.032358095,
0.0420706458,
-0.018858131,
-0.0644649863,
0.0099992249,
0.0033943236,
0.0372509472,
-0.0395947658,
0.0401563644,
-0.0336458758,
-0.0255835522,
-0.0429010279,
0.002089794,
0.0225026291,
-0.0222312529,
-0.015339653,
-0.018263882,
0.0133112753,
-0.0145908277,
0.0008930124,
0.0401695967,
-0.0369309224,
0.0033106995,
-0.0002730077,
-0.0155634619,
-0.0071344441,
0.0081201652,
0.0827517882,
0.0153523991,
-0.0108837048,
-0.0224750601,
-0.0427474231,
-0.0049737887,
-0.0187621657,
-0.0153085375,
0.0572096854,
-0.0097364979,
-0.0329881646,
-0.0759026781,
0.0143982787,
0.0278702769,
-0.0132050049,
-0.0322887339,
0.0071412786,
0.0090701608,
-0.0591662712,
0.0334489085,
-0.0757351816,
0.0519989096,
0.0163889863,
-0.0133677525,
0.0309964903,
0.0438507572,
0.0255487598,
0.0082202805,
0.0700566024,
-0.0168754738,
0.042039264,
0.0114673954,
0.0171904638,
0.0248102751,
0.032230854,
-0.0141361626,
-0.0723216757,
-0.0045917067,
0.0290911142,
0.0658604801,
-0.0408938304,
0.0334634259,
0.0590839759,
0.0512457192,
0.0119075589,
0.0111263227,
0.0087528909,
0.0366937742,
0.06505353,
0.0739885792,
0.0329616889,
-0.0111631081,
-0.0571624525,
0.0570522323,
0.0830893889,
0.0115101002,
-0.0250461288,
-0.0511084683,
0.0150905391,
-0.0069538909,
0.0506374463,
0.0091201309,
0.0059348852,
0.0056524309,
-0.0474741273,
0.0344052725,
0.0005869062,
-0.0700919628,
0.0107548721,
0.0074329004,
-0.0036136946,
0.0501519628,
0.0295441765,
-0.0134423897,
-0.0410222784,
-0.0048331753,
-0.0007039349,
-0.0068481648,
0.0288590193,
-0.0227382444,
0.0006095901,
-0.0785227418,
-0.0037187128,
0.0133115472,
0.0077586807,
-0.0335645974,
0.0355774835,
-0.0388309136,
0.0436571538,
-0.0384680778,
-0.0589194298,
0.0412532315,
0.0187798608,
0.0309826024,
-0.015732931,
0.0203627963,
-0.0105250953,
0.0355660506,
0.0095475335,
0.0238861162,
0.0119126011,
-0.0152939772,
0.0222421642,
0.0174326487,
0.014060637,
-0.0468314663,
0.0508771613,
-0.0839647949,
-0.0271974131,
0.0668641254,
-0.0279991422,
-0.0409258977,
-0.0106824776,
-0.0491777249,
-0.0164914504,
-0.0126839634,
0.072333619,
-0.0125575354,
0.0076011703,
-0.0375206657,
0.0702165142,
0.0457280427,
0.0373860002,
0.0546846911,
-0.0482680574,
0.0248923395,
-0.0253640134,
0.0193620156,
-0.0721982121,
-0.0282441266,
-0.013908877,
0.0662256181,
-0.0038288087,
-0.0342126042,
0.0172082465,
-0.096910052,
-0.0099202255,
0.0079516107,
0.0174209643,
0.0777486637,
0.0316250511,
0.0006134836,
0.0120031768,
-0.0415587015,
-0.029539587,
0.0210736599,
0.007595757,
0.0724093989,
-0.0023829998,
-0.0248630345,
-0.0592533574,
0.0031578615,
0.0046428493,
0.0259865914,
0.0283135958,
-0.0518226847,
-0.0134192854,
0.0571986847,
0.0022209028,
-0.0441855043,
0.0433981828,
-0.0208714325,
-0.0593565255,
-0.0010703061,
0.0472517163,
0.0616555437,
0.0414977521,
-0.0147669781,
-0.0004590799,
0.0049655787,
-0.0193186291,
-0.0106097963,
-0.0180406906,
0.0599915199,
-0.0076807267,
-0.0554570816,
0.0525960512,
0.0146178622,
0.0116837481,
0.0245095864,
-0.0353233926,
0.001151177,
0.0098509686,
0.0248952229,
-0.0561315306,
-0.0166435875,
0.007713872,
0.0449374467,
-0.0281794872,
-0.004042387,
0.0586882159,
-0.0041462905,
0.0240504537,
-0.0673573539,
0.0057873693,
-0.0473430604,
0.0001246625,
-0.0227814149,
0.0402055383,
0.01094383,
0.0006996286,
-0.0271760747,
-0.0201767851,
0.0494115725,
-0.0361235328,
0.0719490349,
-0.061532829,
0.0278031379,
-0.0504057854,
-0.0407048687,
0.0003303136,
-0.03943941,
0.0064992956,
-0.0128396759,
0.0650690645,
-0.0026437745,
-0.0203783233,
0.0195347033,
0.0221535191,
0.0506696515,
-0.0130564729,
-0.0068212547,
0.0014571296,
0.0706036687,
0.0616069473,
-0.0247096997,
0.0234802328,
-0.0254298914,
0.020856794,
0.0103661772,
0.0138768256,
-0.0190354735,
0.0226485468,
-0.0390741155,
-0.010237908,
-0.0804485008,
0.0078944154,
-0.003009771,
0.0217924342,
-0.0307615362,
0.0393436067,
0.1017962992,
0.0137516279,
-0.0076816441,
-0.0159701295,
0.0171216559,
-0.0192604102,
-0.0193914138,
-0.000612019,
-0.0434127674,
-0.0094305081,
0.0128998552,
-0.0014538656,
0.0149372462,
-0.0275747646,
-0.0131931184,
-0.0414578058,
0.0123243146,
0.0093627591,
-0.0985910222,
-0.0774916708,
-0.0365093872,
0.0284247529,
-0.0126856398,
0.0001948733,
0.0404136591,
-0.0328920297,
0.0378174521,
-0.023956852,
-0.0925075188,
-0.044304613,
-0.0792094022,
-0.0258968025,
0.0225687828,
-0.0108498083,
0.059368223,
0.0063549816,
0.0052588182,
0.0342436656,
-0.0163133536,
-0.0361903645,
-0.0176833551,
0.0580995381,
0.0267428532,
0.0150912153,
-0.0313380286,
0.0507585965,
0.0065031233,
0.0183751527,
0.0231431462,
0.0025093253,
0.0456794612,
-0.0079762423,
0.0038428286,
0.0182174053,
-0.0329621062,
0.0478258729,
0.0645591319,
0.0538334176,
-0.0328042209,
-0.0222735293,
-0.0242914651,
-0.0785529092,
-0.0367773101,
-0.0140007576,
-0.0259696431,
-0.0466837771,
-0.0877122208,
-0.0321200415,
0.0350734256,
-0.0101631461,
0.0079653226,
0.0211594887,
0.0027899186,
0.0187421385,
-0.0395248942,
-0.0343328826,
-0.0202239081,
0.0210473351,
-0.0032339506,
-0.0077611268,
-0.0238949452,
0.0096951537,
0.0150519041,
0.0227020271,
-0.0694349334,
-0.0489386432,
-0.0351429358,
0.0287360288,
0.0206035823,
0.0434385054,
-0.0002264987,
-0.0044325595,
0.0171748847,
0.047550898,
-0.0516782962,
0.0519368798,
-0.0001598498,
0.0209868923,
0.0004565049,
0.0180194136,
-0.0405578986,
0.0080457516,
-0.0432767347,
0.0176532622,
-0.0329553187,
-0.029516805,
0.0230412241,
0.0836356729,
0.0010752616,
-0.006334634,
-0.0185968727,
0.0088880518,
-0.0247907434,
-0.0578798465,
-0.0245745983,
-0.0051839575,
0.0276179202,
-0.003360017,
0.0349983275,
-0.0167619921,
0.0807163641,
-0.0054487227,
-0.0359170102,
-0.0187877472,
-0.0143249817,
-0.054231476,
-0.0200862959,
-0.0066478406,
-0.0181576442,
-0.0348661281,
-0.0455908477,
-0.0412928872,
-0.022991607,
-0.009600034,
-0.0503691062,
0.0220871307,
0.0326054581,
-0.0178157501,
0.0493155941,
-0.0415725335,
-0.0079448018,
-0.025361238,
-0.0157104917,
0.0485635214,
-0.0147612849,
0.0943586007,
0.0001131731,
-0.0325764716,
-0.0160558876,
0.0483523831,
0.025839461,
0.009674103,
-0.0389582179,
-0.0089333458,
0.0010413018,
0.0075776228,
0.1083297357,
-0.0649968237,
0.0176803321,
0.0135035347,
-0.036700163,
-0.041524902,
-0.0462666415,
-0.0281245075,
0.0296621621,
-0.0090080425,
-0.0747903138,
-0.0448764935,
-0.0223190077,
0.0035829653,
0.0162024964,
0.0204274468,
-0.0171789248,
0.0167590901,
0.0139532806,
-0.0111441286,
-0.0015745318,
-0.0406775847,
-0.0036800776,
-0.0563814864,
-0.008803675,
-0.0327556729,
-6.029183259e-33,
-0.0097677121,
0.0130144879,
-0.0244680028,
0.0032873696,
-0.0408716761,
0.0156338923,
-0.0800277814,
-0.0089215459,
-0.0155620892,
0.0193406716,
-0.0076687676,
0.0157618746,
0.0106265368,
-0.0194205251,
-0.0270080417,
0.0417757742,
0.0540146679,
0.0080828322,
-0.0570622124,
0.0031459017,
-0.0101597114,
0.0157576501,
0.0180757362,
-0.0629155338,
-0.033234667,
-0.0066178963,
-0.0488250107,
-0.0229548998,
0.0749945119,
0.0142638972,
0.0213739723,
0.0084511517,
0.022258237,
-0.0304788221,
-0.030219622,
0.0224793684,
-0.0647135824,
-0.00613607,
0.0698080286,
-0.0279236026,
-0.0694596246,
-0.0784686506,
0.0644575804,
-0.0180420373,
-0.0057837511,
-0.0233849902,
0.0519798286,
-0.0653526112,
-0.0124451332,
-0.0680952445,
-0.01110496,
0.035850808,
-0.0471969247,
-0.0099438448,
0.0056554587,
0.0376973785,
-0.0166123249,
-0.0098760948,
-0.0003691111,
0.0669287518,
0.0637380704,
0.0607986413,
0.0484603569,
-0.02274682,
0.0212263186,
0.0349057242,
-0.024096882,
-0.0214787982,
-0.0131935338,
0.0177511275,
0.0050579649,
0.0182237159,
0.0402782746,
0.0377538614,
0.0301961731,
0.0034735226,
-0.0298934989,
0.0984871611,
0.016583534,
0.0026161412,
-0.0127691636,
0.0125780441,
-0.0113773504,
-0.0215000082,
-0.0069349506,
0.0388402268,
-0.0174823813,
-0.0153729208,
-0.0354631916,
0.02892798,
-0.0594078861,
0.0043162722,
-0.0017872204,
-0.0256255213,
0.0193655659,
0.0494352765,
-0.0066366326,
0.0246388353,
0.0101046618,
-0.0764606521,
-0.0125422645,
0.0294229276,
0.0275328904,
0.0399247408,
0.009079027,
0.0033568242,
0.0295257103,
-0.0070718103,
-0.0434833989,
0.019458266,
0.019661298,
-0.0152307143,
-0.0243270546,
-0.0472081676,
-0.0052878456,
0.0225542169,
0.0083423387,
0.0031232294,
0.0184888393,
-0.0171382651,
-0.0243694466,
0.0125637632,
0.0368395969,
0.0096105589,
0.0223858505,
-0.0015170198,
-0.0167806409,
0.010638319,
0.0325555578,
-0.012872953,
-0.0301655587,
-0.0050837314,
2.462e-7,
0.0552447215,
0.0290088728,
0.0788522661,
-0.0081203496,
-0.004938974,
0.0096922899,
0.0185180362,
-0.0083155464,
-0.026675893,
0.0201960579,
0.0803719386,
0.0049097361,
0.0338872112,
-0.0060234414,
-0.0794664696,
-0.0125820749,
-0.0279154256,
-0.0808697268,
-0.0250434559,
-0.0219919216,
0.0330886319,
0.0343030058,
-0.0072564296,
0.0242752153,
-0.007606626,
0.0079320222,
0.0097679608,
-0.0597273894,
-0.0086741028,
0.0529759713,
0.0346068293,
-0.0404757895,
-0.0060068169,
0.0016699331,
-0.0269262455,
0.0033505175,
0.0331711695,
0.0622971952,
0.0023161932,
0.0591473207,
-0.0150168911,
-0.0645735338,
0.010847562,
-0.0241000373,
0.0585924797,
-0.029770663,
0.0065572136,
0.0059089987,
-0.0414969735,
0.0437534153,
-0.0287025496,
0.0397350565,
-0.0720452368,
0.0629598349,
0.0210644156,
0.0060784002,
-0.006519543,
-0.0706829727,
-0.0480776206,
0.0005681369,
0.008938835,
-0.0094757881,
-0.0090596853,
0.0222307406,
0.0268016551,
-0.0542578064,
0.0229688436,
2.336475938e-34,
0.0575813763,
0.0039745239,
-0.0281073693,
0.0001580907,
0.0349195562,
-0.0738629028,
-0.0416853242,
0.0214171112,
-0.0044134315,
-0.0517733283,
0.0161053557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07739v1 | Meta-Learning Triplet Network with Adaptive Margins for Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition | 2023-02-14T15:10:26 | 2023-02-14T15:10:26 | Chengcheng Han, Renyu Zhu, Jun Kuang, FengJiao Chen, Xiang Li, Ming Gao, Xuezhi Cao, Wei Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Meta-learning methods have been widely used in few-shot named entity
recognition (NER), especially prototype-based methods. However, the Other(O)
class is difficult to be represented by a prototype vector because there are
generally a large number of samples in the class that have miscellaneous
semantics. To solve the problem, we propose MeTNet, which generates prototype
vectors for entity types only but not O-class. We design an improved triplet
network to map samples and prototype vectors into a low-dimensional space that
is easier to be classified and propose an adaptive margin for each entity type.
The margin plays as a radius and controls a region with adaptive size in the
low-dimensional space. Based on the regions, we propose a new inference
procedure to predict the label of a query instance. We conduct extensive
experiments in both in-domain and cross-domain settings to show the superiority
of MeTNet over other state-of-the-art methods. In particular, we release a
Chinese few-shot NER dataset FEW-COMM extracted from a well-known e-commerce
platform. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first Chinese few-shot NER
dataset. All the datasets and codes are provided at
https://github.com/hccngu/MeTNet. | [
0.0189710576,
0.0026528917,
0.0076289061,
0.0212049782,
0.0251137596,
0.0398371369,
0.053519208,
0.0052328208,
-0.0263966247,
-0.0384311974,
-0.0576366633,
0.0080567906,
-0.0053317682,
0.0186927691,
0.030227663,
-0.0149375824,
0.017820349,
0.0518214926,
-0.010578895,
0.0236661285,
-0.008498352,
0.0084407255,
0.00254095,
0.0129409656,
0.0653853044,
-0.0108269388,
-0.0331085883,
0.022288125,
0.0329381302,
-0.0676436648,
0.0464961603,
0.0301374849,
0.0027149431,
0.0648621693,
0.0000020517,
-0.0426525809,
-0.0490240045,
0.0075835446,
-0.0274551343,
-0.0292396564,
0.0186678153,
0.0010235386,
0.0067377957,
0.0117195295,
-0.016736595,
-0.0678231865,
0.0515272729,
0.0683691204,
-0.0037933607,
0.0623508841,
-0.0039710384,
-0.0373460762,
0.003571037,
-0.0288411006,
0.027221527,
-0.0202828944,
0.0449142568,
-0.0596978851,
-0.0155206397,
0.0005530128,
0.0067753643,
-0.0020804026,
-0.0250165015,
0.0539086051,
-0.0340033695,
0.0537243076,
-0.0564225353,
0.0419121906,
-0.0065856506,
0.0727444664,
-0.0177280381,
0.0017390503,
0.0342709534,
-0.0062956447,
0.0050097588,
-0.0405548997,
-0.022764245,
-0.0386255905,
-0.0366743915,
-0.0308884829,
-0.0502434112,
0.0201640837,
0.0123268664,
-0.0016710222,
-0.0404381827,
0.002957603,
-0.0051139095,
-0.0227607712,
-0.0228753872,
-0.0203046836,
-0.0057353242,
0.015893409,
-0.001839929,
-0.0054144203,
0.0331906416,
0.0285144262,
0.011734427,
-0.0325846374,
-0.0075451029,
-0.0283108782,
0.0252732374,
0.011185063,
0.0132814413,
0.0339551196,
-0.0570250005,
-0.0001108623,
-0.0126794167,
0.0701129586,
0.0055300337,
0.0281043537,
-0.0727612451,
-0.0161144659,
-0.056716308,
0.0600582957,
0.0345516987,
0.0368162915,
-0.0647877753,
-0.0064844824,
0.0186667237,
-0.0011085358,
0.0276377108,
-0.0085558472,
0.0089736125,
-0.0180438925,
-0.0100393854,
0.0245129652,
-0.044209566,
0.0105753625,
-0.0177718084,
-0.0422749259,
-0.0011277235,
-0.0118939877,
0.0222753063,
-0.0559904687,
0.0210805386,
0.0699288696,
0.0519295745,
-0.1026623845,
-0.1119828746,
0.0043963599,
-0.0047283317,
-0.0375278816,
0.0231653061,
-0.014058386,
0.0233644694,
-0.0204460435,
0.0030120476,
0.0024548871,
-0.0155107146,
-0.0053250138,
-0.0197473653,
0.0720298439,
-0.073791109,
-0.0372404866,
-0.0003773722,
-0.0144168437,
0.0164504815,
0.046221301,
0.0552186072,
0.0309653785,
0.0300297905,
0.0048076455,
0.0058302782,
0.0106591061,
0.0413567871,
-0.0578566901,
-0.0286539365,
0.0096695134,
-0.0353986062,
0.0057586352,
-0.0013999373,
-0.0205243286,
-0.0274853352,
-0.0356602296,
0.0145680532,
0.0165840816,
0.0078643383,
0.0172550511,
0.0302137546,
-0.0150731169,
-0.0147227608,
-0.0389996059,
-0.0210973676,
0.0381322168,
-0.0369043685,
-0.0120081352,
-0.0085907755,
0.062127132,
-0.0723457783,
-0.0091279941,
0.0418661721,
0.0012511397,
-0.0775537938,
-0.0001944618,
0.0645443425,
0.0122075491,
-0.0391830914,
0.0248601642,
0.0003963757,
0.0044232695,
-0.0095519591,
-0.0331352763,
0.0117588472,
0.046995312,
0.042917341,
-0.0557248183,
-0.0536386557,
-0.0338239074,
-0.0428014435,
0.0419032276,
0.0257069487,
-0.0217177495,
0.003153244,
-0.0443016626,
-0.0104525713,
0.0358281061,
0.0089195352,
0.0522882752,
0.0114959115,
0.0411393717,
0.0229966324,
-0.1002787724,
0.0649145171,
0.0212331358,
-0.0329364166,
-0.0287984759,
0.031563621,
0.0522099957,
0.0146996584,
0.0439882837,
-0.0123624625,
-0.0203861985,
-0.0005953647,
-0.0093315607,
-0.0360727273,
-0.0153746707,
0.0193170011,
-0.0687769353,
0.0113814836,
-0.0207675956,
0.0039165714,
-0.0231799018,
-0.060058862,
-0.0476401411,
-0.0010041691,
0.0351595804,
0.0391838551,
-0.0447334237,
-0.0030222649,
0.0161736608,
0.0395986699,
-0.037552651,
0.0618999675,
-0.0047136047,
0.0292135645,
0.0296564121,
-0.0282961447,
0.0078180088,
0.0199071541,
-0.0528245308,
0.0364469774,
-0.0278299097,
0.0104555786,
0.0030504442,
0.016703371,
-0.0448016003,
-0.0333588868,
-0.0410978645,
0.0088192765,
-0.0033872954,
0.0672675818,
-0.0036585794,
0.0436033048,
-0.0273939166,
-0.0294100828,
-0.017140124,
0.0464607179,
-0.0810879767,
0.0048435796,
0.0494489595,
0.0208302736,
-0.0382309295,
0.031804394,
-0.0276819877,
-0.0330653526,
0.0598931164,
-0.0134467296,
-0.0567407869,
-0.017250482,
0.0154068368,
-0.0398016013,
0.0065696272,
-0.0080060568,
0.0151094617,
-0.0385399759,
-0.0184565429,
-0.0250153523,
0.0418343022,
0.0036455598,
-0.0261648037,
-0.0163771883,
0.0038088509,
-0.0690058917,
0.0196900498,
-0.0381164029,
0.0186973382,
-0.0037328631,
-0.0049912822,
0.0206545964,
0.0638855845,
-0.0191623755,
-0.011462206,
-0.0596852526,
0.0260050204,
0.0453137457,
-0.020825332,
-0.0254942607,
0.0878744274,
-0.0090085994,
-0.0062928274,
-0.0068273898,
0.0173510779,
0.0666430965,
0.0000848648,
0.0004951053,
0.0196443796,
0.0217413362,
-0.0503018908,
0.0062602456,
-0.0093527893,
0.0169385504,
0.0411575288,
-0.0887803063,
-0.0325534008,
-0.0010698471,
0.0256004278,
-0.0244390257,
0.0146225328,
0.0474989526,
0.0242023114,
-0.0419226289,
-0.0338639542,
-0.0214988962,
0.0119034024,
-0.0223970786,
0.0101985699,
-0.0628792569,
0.0174948182,
-0.0401754826,
0.0513737798,
0.0054268376,
0.0888857245,
-0.029219022,
-0.0327334665,
-0.0207863376,
0.0314995125,
0.0135741541,
0.0121081108,
0.0150889093,
0.0085139293,
0.0380437821,
0.0167245138,
0.0021601545,
0.0094266571,
-0.0013120829,
0.003626975,
0.0100901155,
-0.0618637539,
0.0171234719,
0.0175852273,
-0.0306984782,
-0.0281101856,
0.0036713339,
0.0728129148,
0.0116991522,
-0.0606136248,
-0.0339990444,
0.0340776294,
0.0156079326,
0.0437094793,
0.026061099,
-0.0829927251,
-0.0382884592,
0.0095788511,
0.0255066045,
0.0026532346,
-0.0818120316,
-0.0147956088,
-0.1337596923,
-0.0000424735,
-0.0235418454,
-0.0646983907,
-0.0242515672,
-0.0436145961,
0.0050537875,
-0.0256693736,
0.0079462854,
0.0021844397,
-0.0285194442,
-0.0197298359,
0.0236352123,
0.0493627191,
-0.0497701578,
0.0029086589,
-0.0238340944,
0.0414288417,
0.0091596544,
0.0241588969,
-0.031954132,
0.0284642242,
0.0188741367,
-0.0658036992,
-0.033064682,
-0.0130967833,
0.0973986536,
-0.0652521625,
0.0050240909,
0.0212320108,
-0.0279059969,
-0.0586000085,
-0.0145116206,
0.0193294883,
0.0415045209,
0.0170134287,
-0.0158746019,
-0.0227383412,
-0.0264504962,
-0.0382214822,
0.0506303757,
0.0180717502,
-0.048536364,
-0.0003202581,
0.0190551039,
-0.0295390431,
-0.0244944468,
0.0197612699,
0.0533864759,
-0.0178743768,
-0.0570660308,
-0.0145752644,
-0.0034041782,
0.0295689758,
0.0504615158,
0.0208895039,
-0.001546741,
0.0327145942,
0.0392998755,
-0.0494839102,
-0.0383569188,
-0.0486877561,
0.0055766706,
-0.0595558286,
0.052540686,
0.075316973,
-0.0554975308,
-0.0357001685,
-0.0489253253,
-0.0530452766,
-0.0417244434,
-0.0407533795,
0.0229645148,
0.0061096535,
0.006572831,
-0.0002672391,
-0.013644157,
0.048107855,
0.1049983501,
0.017781673,
-0.0548821762,
0.0300065205,
0.0079103541,
-0.0291558821,
0.0098780189,
-0.0343947746,
0.0304466896,
0.0387964398,
0.0046110926,
-0.0438138023,
0.010699681,
0.0249722246,
0.0032948253,
0.082255356,
-0.0014396755,
-0.0088131595,
-0.0827197507,
0.0486288369,
0.0367954634,
0.0096108047,
-0.0344354287,
-0.0220103636,
0.015487886,
-0.0374875106,
-0.0203856025,
0.0006189223,
-0.0015927062,
0.000592137,
-0.0028087406,
0.0038627509,
-0.0223014522,
0.0613522492,
-0.0109497411,
-0.0321894623,
-0.0132657802,
0.0367182493,
0.0737150908,
0.0397813059,
-0.0565388799,
0.0465772934,
0.0303076934,
0.0058628614,
-0.017021453,
0.0345489308,
-0.0487148203,
0.0614047684,
-0.0630920455,
0.0316082649,
0.0187390372,
0.0311381537,
0.0049639475,
-0.0170625243,
-0.0009317801,
-0.013302898,
0.0308480226,
0.0014093487,
-0.0120560266,
0.0301398356,
0.0217562485,
-0.0268831085,
-0.0294436775,
0.0549979173,
0.0112813581,
0.0367467664,
0.0386762992,
-0.0035915386,
-0.0562290549,
0.006291124,
0.0485095866,
-0.0088479109,
-0.0122787422,
0.004977183,
-0.0738663524,
-0.0270308387,
-0.0008679589,
-0.0295578912,
0.0028797421,
0.0427595191,
0.0183696747,
0.0228438284,
0.0141481273,
-0.0205127485,
-0.0128840376,
-0.0090720309,
-0.0196407195,
-0.0149844708,
0.0219964255,
-6.179945552e-33,
-0.0350658484,
-0.0248740092,
0.0194774065,
-0.0299749747,
-0.000997511,
0.0096923839,
-0.0021660794,
-0.0037177308,
-0.0315707624,
-0.0483593196,
-0.0209468473,
-0.0153198047,
0.035824284,
0.0078817802,
-0.0345579647,
-0.0562585667,
0.0302926041,
0.0056139757,
-0.0071329828,
0.0333811603,
0.0165942982,
0.0644201562,
0.0934931487,
-0.0396862403,
-0.0178457741,
0.0165226068,
-0.0492338203,
0.0200939868,
0.0322727151,
0.0680504292,
-0.0089084227,
0.024516657,
0.0332624316,
-0.020428706,
0.0120882448,
-0.0154544581,
-0.1396283209,
-0.0142190531,
-0.0527171679,
0.0494729206,
0.0360295698,
-0.0143302362,
0.0352235101,
-0.0231741555,
0.0405077115,
-0.0105281118,
0.05238197,
-0.0136360684,
-0.0255150255,
-0.0620990135,
-0.0242254566,
0.0642675534,
0.0100089749,
0.0358954743,
0.0804620013,
0.0284789968,
0.045579046,
0.0094468556,
-0.0411870331,
0.0250016917,
-0.0182591714,
-0.0081984,
0.0052970969,
0.0575554818,
0.0088565154,
0.0371538103,
0.065245606,
0.0376703441,
0.0314999633,
-0.0270993505,
0.0366521105,
0.0061523234,
-0.0146340933,
0.0690406114,
0.0616856739,
-0.0409053192,
-0.0462223366,
0.0156392306,
-0.0121082189,
-0.0258143805,
0.0095206536,
-0.0454596989,
-0.0426674038,
0.0044139083,
0.0004677519,
-0.0634823442,
-0.0814596862,
-0.0010963881,
0.0264378581,
0.0219304729,
-0.0582471713,
0.0249826591,
0.0249487478,
-0.0476368666,
-0.0585432537,
0.0263579395,
0.0158728119,
0.0343437567,
-0.0010929094,
-0.0004967693,
-0.0356129035,
-0.0770822763,
-0.0093427999,
-0.005257118,
0.0045036399,
-0.0045781094,
0.0914042741,
-0.0002171117,
-0.0770936459,
-0.0180664398,
0.0187717043,
-0.000509495,
-0.0137794688,
0.0127533143,
0.000617208,
0.0148995444,
0.0124536185,
-0.0135498,
0.0735405385,
-0.0347563699,
0.013931171,
0.0106478911,
0.0178868119,
0.0686518401,
-0.0052680452,
0.0148725212,
-0.0242845956,
-0.0069585266,
0.0703036413,
-0.0582878515,
-0.0053399494,
0.0287054833,
2.893e-7,
0.0088572139,
0.0221550874,
0.0177858621,
-0.0002327736,
0.0000708969,
0.0406180918,
0.0339971483,
0.0731500685,
-0.0201096255,
0.0120137967,
0.052542299,
-0.0246313401,
0.0233601183,
0.0177502837,
-0.1099506244,
0.0168141685,
0.0062085507,
0.022665184,
-0.0446431004,
0.0488565788,
0.0404206626,
0.0704575479,
0.010478273,
0.0045116795,
-0.0188023672,
-0.0284101423,
0.0286386572,
0.0050195684,
0.0525504202,
0.0556277633,
-0.0173279997,
0.0535477474,
-0.0437460057,
0.017888546,
0.0045895218,
0.0456870943,
0.0171307269,
0.0545839779,
0.0131588178,
0.0151358563,
0.0242431387,
-0.0346142948,
0.0178205315,
0.0008787558,
0.0616527572,
-0.068005234,
-0.0203626007,
0.0234735664,
0.0124112796,
-0.0214528423,
0.0373290777,
-0.0209906697,
-0.0092378529,
0.0272189043,
0.0305766761,
-0.0285166092,
-0.0036273936,
-0.0679603219,
0.0298275128,
0.0030734912,
-0.0122901294,
-0.0265246388,
0.0011195645,
-0.0244436599,
0.0563551299,
-0.0545652919,
0.0143812569,
2.737301145e-34,
0.0067898687,
-0.0203835163,
-0.0148804467,
0.0202946719,
-0.0256529097,
-0.0340605192,
0.0293183383,
-0.0290997718,
0.0221333653,
-0.046238061,
-0.0102155507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07027v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07027v3 | AdapterSoup: Weight Averaging to Improve Generalization of Pretrained Language Models | 2023-02-14T13:09:23 | 2023-03-28T13:37:54 | Alexandra Chronopoulou, Matthew E. Peters, Alexander Fraser, Jesse Dodge | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models (PLMs) are trained on massive corpora, but often
need to specialize to specific domains. A parameter-efficient adaptation method
suggests training an adapter for each domain on the task of language modeling.
This leads to good in-domain scores but can be impractical for domain- or
resource-restricted settings. A solution is to use a related-domain adapter for
the novel domain at test time. In this paper, we introduce AdapterSoup, an
approach that performs weight-space averaging of adapters trained on different
domains. Our approach is embarrassingly parallel: first, we train a set of
domain-specific adapters; then, for each novel domain, we determine which
adapters should be averaged at test time. We present extensive experiments
showing that AdapterSoup consistently improves performance to new domains
without extra training. We also explore weight averaging of adapters trained on
the same domain with different hyper-parameters, and show that it preserves the
performance of a PLM on new domains while obtaining strong in-domain results.
We explore various approaches for choosing which adapters to combine, such as
text clustering and semantic similarity. We find that using clustering leads to
the most competitive results on novel domains. | [
0.0143457996,
0.020574728,
0.0084226541,
0.0116128325,
0.0156844296,
0.0269478019,
0.0459015481,
-0.0022535555,
0.0063243452,
-0.0352202617,
-0.0482415892,
-0.053982988,
-0.0190017633,
0.0206653904,
0.0127050309,
-0.0785303488,
0.0227497816,
0.0007487351,
-0.0369400196,
-0.0044206833,
0.032361567,
0.0229432359,
0.0193076301,
0.0264010839,
0.0261305943,
0.007333911,
0.011846262,
-0.0106987469,
0.0103371134,
-0.0167552568,
0.0264848955,
0.04959815,
0.033925347,
0.0291392449,
0.0000021284,
-0.0558407456,
-0.0703692213,
-0.022096822,
0.0275766067,
0.0317629166,
0.0783576667,
-0.0303054973,
0.0203494281,
0.0394541472,
-0.0403980687,
-0.0779478177,
0.0413373932,
0.037146356,
0.0271687992,
0.0770583972,
-0.0295744576,
-0.0522836559,
-0.0110029271,
-0.0495255142,
-0.0383640751,
-0.0835444182,
0.029178774,
0.0394816957,
-0.005240134,
-0.0377863757,
-0.0206049532,
0.0000856824,
-0.0017366222,
0.0352892838,
-0.0082974583,
0.0131886052,
0.0017079096,
-0.0059937397,
-0.0202594697,
0.0825809389,
-0.0268696044,
-0.0470930189,
-0.0038954245,
-0.0165828057,
-0.0050340197,
0.0352408327,
-0.0199288372,
-0.0083321007,
0.011148883,
0.0191928651,
0.0047669704,
0.0409926139,
0.0318068825,
-0.0002669888,
-0.0825594217,
0.0327476598,
0.0367182493,
0.0097198617,
0.0276656412,
0.035120666,
-0.0352081135,
-0.0175019689,
0.0136301192,
0.0324643478,
-0.0114607178,
0.0141727151,
-0.0820650458,
-0.0714500919,
-0.0056737587,
-0.0286309905,
0.0778764933,
0.0360852964,
-0.0048820465,
0.0431798473,
-0.036544051,
0.0135508887,
0.00072051,
-0.0068488172,
-0.0932675451,
-0.0239707511,
-0.0720065758,
0.018786896,
-0.0585193783,
0.0461246669,
-0.0304242093,
-0.0027532252,
-0.0264944267,
0.0348466933,
0.0036169225,
-0.0636329651,
0.0383213721,
-0.0213879719,
-0.0281668399,
-0.0464149043,
-0.0019234419,
0.0543532819,
-0.0374288782,
0.0515113287,
-0.026222771,
-0.0169251282,
-0.0013521551,
0.0264467299,
0.0057898313,
-0.0288493633,
0.0201718714,
0.0754874721,
-0.0027185343,
-0.0354368277,
-0.0201374814,
0.0240708273,
0.0004776428,
-0.0380699113,
-0.0336387418,
-0.0484828912,
0.0441798978,
0.006232813,
0.0165026989,
-0.0745651349,
-0.0475202017,
-0.0191622302,
-0.0276867915,
0.051856149,
-0.0022561289,
0.0111022824,
0.0358264968,
-0.0163970683,
-0.0001116241,
0.0785832405,
0.0111422036,
-0.02300358,
0.0246265344,
0.0018416449,
-0.0166637488,
0.0435264781,
0.0067671542,
0.0242897477,
0.004095987,
-0.0026502949,
0.0427964367,
-0.0129175931,
0.0472353697,
0.033311706,
-0.0533702374,
0.0038021239,
0.0328561515,
0.0137652373,
0.0435963757,
0.0083275996,
0.0572937317,
-0.0212210733,
0.0039425753,
0.0187850446,
-0.0333186314,
-0.031638857,
-0.0458313115,
0.0126204491,
0.038812682,
0.058278054,
-0.0616158284,
-0.0363093242,
0.0099410284,
-0.0327321403,
0.0476546213,
-0.0105273053,
0.0771575719,
0.0369611345,
-0.0266807713,
0.041927956,
0.0587754175,
-0.0490072742,
0.0376327895,
0.0159522798,
0.0018361291,
0.0166118238,
-0.0134793324,
-0.044244457,
-0.0193123687,
0.0242426042,
0.0707887486,
0.0100934263,
0.0722617358,
-0.0096118497,
0.0314219743,
-0.0681318641,
-0.054005675,
0.0304927249,
0.0195285641,
0.0478923582,
0.0155369258,
0.0040760403,
0.0368941464,
-0.0634736493,
-0.0609988533,
0.0464076772,
-0.0526343584,
-0.0153306574,
0.03327002,
-0.0132206632,
0.0299042985,
0.0056600063,
-0.0278279614,
-0.0128641548,
0.0100523876,
-0.0306911711,
-0.0093982313,
0.0114389975,
-0.0468916111,
-0.0041441973,
0.0491972789,
-0.0430457741,
-0.0024485474,
0.0181857068,
-0.0323693939,
-0.0462277643,
0.0327305719,
0.0247770026,
0.0957236588,
-0.0478123054,
0.0447084568,
-0.0331690647,
0.0157686006,
-0.043209821,
0.0469304174,
0.0486126989,
-0.0115903104,
-0.0282936711,
-0.0071136421,
0.016562786,
0.0046592252,
-0.0363140963,
-0.0600854643,
0.0165474415,
0.0517174564,
0.0325201824,
0.006636057,
-0.0226552617,
-0.0053370916,
-0.0860699564,
0.019258609,
-0.0335823521,
0.0248901695,
0.0489857905,
0.0609541461,
-0.0187479258,
-0.034430936,
0.0066656033,
0.0045325402,
-0.0062430166,
0.0025435355,
0.0141953863,
0.006857614,
0.0363949463,
-0.0400336683,
0.0067991302,
0.0015571709,
0.0572513938,
0.0052038669,
0.006792482,
-0.0583669432,
0.0379555747,
-0.0418666191,
0.0456383042,
-0.0026030031,
-0.0248760991,
-0.0296283737,
-0.0286129434,
0.0231647268,
0.0320789516,
0.0147318859,
-0.0036251035,
0.067479901,
0.0436880775,
-0.0648030266,
-0.0148009043,
-0.0460224971,
0.0003610753,
-0.0504945815,
0.0155106299,
0.0459839404,
0.0791623667,
-0.0167483985,
-0.041889932,
-0.0494513065,
-0.0210608933,
-0.0282196384,
0.0165878795,
0.0049605351,
0.003102974,
0.0094786733,
0.0202670377,
0.0029548858,
-0.0606044903,
0.0770716071,
-0.0260913279,
0.0030106262,
-0.0981059745,
-0.0377131067,
-0.0525440276,
0.0246771891,
0.0054723187,
0.0212686565,
0.0453253612,
-0.0104983924,
-0.0455140918,
0.016158374,
0.0182696898,
0.0056079975,
0.0760589167,
-0.0362856798,
0.0549954586,
0.0136253815,
-0.017067248,
-0.0277114008,
-0.0254465602,
-0.0435700491,
-0.008602608,
-0.0133699132,
0.0000587478,
-0.0865193903,
0.0288923383,
0.0155810285,
0.0526579581,
0.0001178621,
-0.0091820341,
0.0033935967,
0.0025777973,
0.0286173504,
0.013711527,
-0.0055412492,
-0.0413868912,
-0.0016116201,
0.0272237509,
0.0151049318,
-0.0463636592,
-0.0511289202,
0.0148813566,
0.0283665806,
-0.0530621,
0.0119873378,
0.0092638489,
0.038038034,
0.0025678219,
0.0126345307,
0.1346233189,
0.0281843394,
-0.0748908371,
-0.0153556233,
0.0266907141,
0.0473740436,
0.0137199061,
0.0279005151,
-0.0411791205,
-0.0497312136,
-0.0275922175,
-0.0122534251,
0.0385151729,
-0.0041405689,
-0.0003312002,
-0.1188169643,
-0.0620013922,
0.0211486835,
-0.0499969386,
-0.0025803845,
-0.0344525427,
0.0027245721,
-0.0522801615,
0.0361388996,
-0.0232855808,
-0.005856161,
0.0152496751,
0.0193424504,
-0.0194684677,
-0.0361740142,
-0.0101730647,
-0.0680244789,
0.0361659713,
0.0688007027,
-0.014598689,
-0.0186798442,
0.0081555722,
0.0425610729,
-0.0258485265,
-0.0095451437,
-0.0204986352,
0.0269293096,
0.0020747627,
0.0007497018,
0.0364083387,
0.0044330745,
-0.0641870573,
0.0109704239,
0.0476296768,
0.0345196314,
0.0210685339,
-0.0316352323,
-0.0141225765,
-0.0212786123,
-0.0082980422,
0.0538348369,
0.0057182647,
-0.0515276976,
0.0186859984,
-0.0074028745,
-0.0278355405,
-0.0293565933,
-0.0127151366,
0.0042161718,
-0.0451084338,
0.0097066332,
-0.0661061108,
-0.0231460258,
0.0305190925,
0.0672111213,
0.014982624,
-0.0016912228,
0.0052004135,
-0.029518744,
-0.0441527702,
0.0397723243,
-0.0438206196,
-0.0144721735,
-0.0516824238,
-0.0285699032,
0.0610356182,
-0.0382740311,
-0.0385876931,
-0.0156224249,
-0.0282290056,
-0.0638073906,
-0.0100918831,
0.0261459015,
0.0207961798,
0.0630688146,
-0.0358940922,
-0.0555951223,
0.0669857562,
-0.0137034208,
-0.0254572332,
0.0240362268,
0.0235174112,
-0.0646236613,
0.007970307,
0.022231346,
-0.0645275339,
0.0504306555,
0.0488191284,
-0.005537278,
-0.0200433545,
-0.055593092,
-0.0168640241,
-0.0194415543,
0.038239304,
-0.0002007911,
-0.026613934,
-0.0297108311,
0.0032797123,
-0.0019897579,
-0.0001438245,
-0.0412640385,
0.0184742492,
0.0363833383,
0.0192359909,
-0.0091571426,
0.0383974649,
-0.0267418269,
0.0018192101,
-0.006285246,
0.0035625086,
0.0009520226,
0.0319831036,
0.0059236828,
0.0172917638,
0.021889342,
-0.0226598736,
0.013815403,
0.0097599505,
-0.0350307822,
-0.0138188815,
0.0149318157,
0.052536577,
-0.0175634455,
0.0571877845,
-0.0735627711,
0.0108881723,
-0.0487752929,
-0.0011376985,
0.0390132442,
-0.0481089652,
0.0625461116,
0.0185482819,
0.0135035273,
-0.0450192206,
0.0056143207,
0.00303136,
0.0197074078,
0.0102646388,
0.0104810363,
-0.031350296,
0.0495027602,
0.1023384333,
-0.0210396051,
0.0362786464,
0.0250127055,
0.0023398353,
-0.015710704,
0.0134679405,
0.010324263,
0.0343985781,
-0.059038423,
-0.0132450657,
-0.0175986215,
-0.0585121848,
0.040946953,
-0.023939494,
-0.0272620954,
0.0339527763,
0.0527905449,
0.0383615419,
-0.036461547,
0.055005867,
-0.0036742976,
-0.0529042557,
-0.0097052185,
-0.0211828295,
0.0050355657,
-6.470081068e-33,
-0.0198933426,
0.0119976187,
-0.0099089537,
-0.0434824489,
-0.0032402326,
-0.0023509974,
0.0048875352,
-0.0107238553,
-0.0197468642,
-0.0083101615,
0.0087530138,
0.0062996736,
0.0199946146,
0.0256867371,
-0.0108598052,
0.0117180031,
0.0293474812,
0.0342468359,
-0.0226571038,
0.0094951428,
-0.0125699481,
0.0469324663,
0.0584663115,
-0.0418874286,
0.0001790496,
0.0133681521,
0.0104474733,
-0.0098291272,
0.0743967891,
0.0613163412,
-0.0059770849,
0.0392073952,
0.0244297627,
-0.0078899739,
-0.047872521,
-0.0229392517,
-0.0586867779,
-0.0416650586,
0.0354631394,
-0.0033948992,
0.0276914481,
0.0062027974,
0.0466247685,
0.0012075301,
0.0103882439,
-0.0523942746,
0.0675308779,
-0.0286878031,
-0.0261614732,
0.0033951611,
-0.0405738167,
0.0303946752,
0.0070728865,
0.0139717758,
0.0078562424,
0.0073459572,
-0.0073049562,
0.0362966172,
-0.0361599065,
0.0281188283,
-0.0108969845,
0.0290830601,
0.0166381989,
0.0035493847,
-0.004741936,
0.0382396057,
-0.0068813637,
-0.0308304485,
0.0022474036,
0.015219409,
0.0474633574,
-0.0290888306,
0.0195987262,
0.067790769,
0.0148574337,
-0.0396684296,
-0.0768831,
0.0942593738,
-0.0157066341,
-0.0275056828,
0.0058498993,
0.0375643559,
-0.0054527987,
-0.011808088,
-0.0373975001,
-0.0008416661,
-0.0333885029,
-0.0805889592,
-0.0029143598,
0.0170623008,
-0.0405900143,
0.0218492355,
0.0226044729,
-0.0656478852,
-0.0155787943,
-0.0088057369,
0.0032408473,
-0.008878327,
0.0048202528,
0.0220371261,
-0.0139288194,
-0.0590813085,
0.028728243,
0.0074610696,
-0.0002803871,
-0.0261017941,
0.02841896,
0.0010308484,
-0.0690600201,
-0.0017279615,
0.0069737914,
-0.0434688181,
0.0234935749,
0.0967545286,
0.0300150365,
0.0344733186,
-0.0038351384,
0.0394335017,
0.0033107109,
-0.0728885159,
-0.0289459713,
0.0084892632,
0.0252939872,
0.0396391004,
-0.0410133526,
-0.0302320495,
-0.0140681332,
0.0058844765,
0.0706808046,
-0.0351027548,
-0.0331112742,
-0.0229989719,
2.752e-7,
0.0756376833,
-0.0001134015,
0.0137225324,
-0.0496153831,
-0.01492434,
0.0236870311,
-0.0163654685,
0.0485597923,
0.0287972987,
0.0216858387,
0.0072414707,
0.0226044748,
0.0417835452,
0.001840321,
-0.090396516,
-0.0033509445,
-0.0001040857,
-0.0015746969,
-0.0084713288,
0.0132750478,
-0.0030046399,
0.1223880425,
0.0224651769,
-0.0113970377,
-0.0053475359,
-0.065399304,
0.0521181077,
-0.0397019871,
-0.0145201264,
0.047104422,
-0.012248097,
0.0263284948,
-0.0338221453,
0.0308074802,
-0.0327347107,
0.0509808511,
0.0265683085,
0.0402039252,
-0.0072359946,
-0.0046209465,
0.0047400813,
0.0023215122,
-0.0057808654,
-0.0207274575,
0.0592212975,
-0.058074791,
-0.0004574043,
-0.0036351706,
-0.0131463502,
-0.0074398518,
0.002138569,
0.0163560119,
-0.0175746828,
0.0588687137,
0.0383332595,
-0.0004198584,
-0.0375552028,
-0.0848140717,
-0.0231342688,
0.0084861331,
-0.0251899362,
-0.0354691036,
0.0014133564,
-0.0418820083,
0.0533879511,
-0.0698766708,
0.0490625687,
2.477009502e-34,
0.028761318,
-0.0096896375,
0.003458712,
0.0098290183,
0.0159565508,
-0.0400044434,
-0.0184296034,
-0.0061345072,
0.0008856587,
-0.0942967385,
0.0127732977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07729v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07729v3 | Generation of Highlights from Research Papers Using Pointer-Generator Networks and SciBERT Embeddings | 2023-02-14T12:45:14 | 2023-09-17T16:45:44 | Tohida Rehman, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal, Samiran Chattopadhyay, Plaban Kumar Bhowmick, Partha Pratim Das | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Nowadays many research articles are prefaced with research highlights to
summarize the main findings of the paper. Highlights not only help researchers
precisely and quickly identify the contributions of a paper, they also enhance
the discoverability of the article via search engines. We aim to automatically
construct research highlights given certain segments of a research paper. We
use a pointer-generator network with coverage mechanism and a contextual
embedding layer at the input that encodes the input tokens into SciBERT
embeddings. We test our model on a benchmark dataset, CSPubSum, and also
present MixSub, a new multi-disciplinary corpus of papers for automatic
research highlight generation. For both CSPubSum and MixSub, we have observed
that the proposed model achieves the best performance compared to related
variants and other models proposed in the literature. On the CSPubSum dataset,
our model achieves the best performance when the input is only the abstract of
a paper as opposed to other segments of the paper. It produces ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2
and ROUGE-L F1-scores of 38.26, 14.26 and 35.51, respectively, METEOR score of
32.62, and BERTScore F1 of 86.65 which outperform all other baselines. On the
new MixSub dataset, where only the abstract is the input, our proposed model
(when trained on the whole training corpus without distinguishing between the
subject categories) achieves ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2 and ROUGE-L F1-scores of 31.78,
9.76 and 29.3, respectively, METEOR score of 24.00, and BERTScore F1 of 85.25. | [
0.0259316638,
0.0112861618,
0.0141338529,
-0.0145721501,
-0.0010332778,
-0.0426669382,
0.0217878725,
-0.0124262413,
-0.0306711495,
-0.0531066842,
-0.0053905188,
0.0553117245,
-0.044356443,
0.0294734072,
0.0396832041,
-0.0516485646,
0.0272903536,
0.00011193,
0.0077635716,
-0.0064591626,
0.0041275513,
0.0031855446,
0.0064924038,
0.033006411,
0.0099499337,
-0.022321092,
0.009395224,
0.0003676102,
0.054409869,
-0.0445711128,
0.0326819345,
0.0426248312,
0.0238917265,
0.0366527513,
0.000001723,
-0.0518405586,
-0.0168049764,
0.0347547233,
0.0677798912,
0.0005830395,
0.0510739125,
-0.0189564824,
-0.0027026061,
-0.0033393963,
0.0028704612,
0.0308943987,
0.0132192476,
0.080534555,
0.0059734937,
0.0476944596,
-0.0010764961,
-0.0248852745,
0.0544150658,
0.0051237126,
0.0266602356,
0.0185508933,
0.011192224,
-0.0199934542,
0.024617631,
0.0875491425,
0.0187972095,
0.0126689756,
0.0158370174,
-0.067448467,
0.0512720235,
0.0406406373,
-0.0724788755,
0.0353758074,
0.0196825657,
0.0661197752,
-0.0243526939,
-0.0195374265,
0.0476188362,
0.0055904784,
-0.0244225115,
0.008326333,
-0.0721513703,
0.0031514319,
-0.0058002411,
-0.0322080106,
0.0524359159,
0.017749818,
0.0134773199,
0.0177276153,
0.0000662531,
-0.0017295105,
0.0381175838,
-0.046762716,
-0.0022470381,
-0.0212394875,
0.0257988796,
-0.0424110293,
0.0279043019,
0.0309205521,
-0.001715224,
-0.0096687358,
-0.0092080887,
-0.0765205994,
0.0579303466,
-0.0002019649,
0.0233199485,
-0.0144820418,
-0.0309034847,
0.0213512667,
-0.034934856,
-0.0489000231,
-0.0354087055,
-0.010468157,
0.0109413229,
-0.0247693788,
-0.0293237865,
-0.0239999313,
-0.0201879684,
0.0178417806,
0.0228750687,
-0.0483754948,
-0.038658049,
-0.0091668153,
0.0117896358,
0.0214055255,
-0.0059355441,
0.0134002911,
-0.0835262239,
0.0052873637,
0.0463598147,
-0.0085886987,
-0.0590028316,
-0.0188015532,
0.0269064866,
0.0380239002,
-0.0161719956,
0.0429747961,
-0.0017008823,
-0.0189687777,
0.0013480693,
-0.017057959,
0.0333238356,
-0.0480680205,
0.0242111571,
-0.0597712435,
0.0047238157,
-0.0300566666,
0.0409757532,
-0.0821769461,
0.0023384369,
0.0043646791,
-0.0171406511,
-0.0020301989,
0.0161262844,
0.0379531682,
-0.0139599415,
0.0138240447,
-0.0579409823,
-0.0569261685,
0.0144140031,
0.0058385888,
-0.0211149286,
0.0275847036,
0.0282021984,
0.0312285647,
0.0348824896,
-0.0078292908,
0.0133677134,
0.0184617955,
0.0144343572,
-0.0014102939,
0.0188163221,
-0.0335390009,
-0.0437308252,
0.0657371655,
0.0402385704,
0.0334897265,
-0.04628212,
-0.010278387,
-0.0080304556,
0.0653973296,
0.027067693,
0.0778228492,
0.0294430386,
0.0068878927,
0.0355671123,
0.0168109946,
0.0404779017,
0.0204099063,
0.0082913656,
0.0247068238,
0.0334702954,
0.0181656852,
-0.0107784849,
0.0156923123,
0.0124423569,
0.0141104348,
-0.038404692,
-0.0230082721,
0.0792627558,
0.0435676947,
-0.0408398248,
0.0354044959,
0.0320764184,
-0.0255326815,
0.0716916025,
-0.01269673,
0.0327557437,
0.0137396855,
0.0848804489,
-0.0480896086,
-0.0269114394,
-0.0155239524,
-0.0277629904,
0.0697173178,
0.0049173567,
-0.0346886516,
-0.0398764536,
-0.0462809615,
-0.0087785563,
-0.0588570125,
0.0136600938,
0.0180786531,
-0.0112792226,
-0.0087568136,
0.0324295312,
-0.0282718875,
-0.0379408635,
0.0334729813,
-0.0334331393,
0.0258149356,
-0.0252114106,
-0.060365662,
0.0051736091,
0.0409140103,
-0.0334237479,
0.0425795875,
0.0580309331,
-0.0625899062,
0.0081352182,
0.0272032693,
0.0026045907,
-0.0097604627,
0.0141214728,
-0.1166805476,
0.0317016765,
0.0564153083,
-0.0208959226,
-0.041154962,
0.0196921751,
-0.0214828569,
0.0211395007,
-0.0027334902,
-0.0278655607,
0.0133088492,
-0.0032889189,
-0.0135634188,
0.0619008951,
-0.0002903979,
0.074695237,
0.0542951412,
-0.0232549813,
0.0030557609,
-0.0756778792,
-0.0084538218,
-0.0280505959,
0.02803188,
-0.0129738105,
0.0378559865,
-0.0144915869,
-0.0342991799,
-0.0138957109,
-0.0874008909,
0.017282024,
-0.0107421242,
0.0131748999,
0.0469929203,
-0.0073585515,
0.0240514204,
-0.0154787796,
-0.0220744964,
-0.0161653254,
-0.0232885815,
-0.015229472,
0.0503828153,
0.0255801938,
0.0073718284,
-0.0405469202,
-0.0350346081,
-0.029126903,
0.0290649924,
0.0489485115,
-0.0032343455,
-0.064489983,
0.0065541253,
0.030183455,
-0.0161781777,
-0.0197396688,
0.0120337131,
0.0144716203,
-0.0100894468,
0.0080974083,
0.0575728305,
0.0288860686,
0.034277346,
0.0148371458,
-0.0040686238,
-0.0619292632,
-0.0182461757,
-0.0549579784,
0.0363304093,
0.0162732061,
-0.0253427718,
0.070269011,
0.0239548963,
0.0039226059,
0.0067163459,
0.0142885409,
-0.0062090894,
0.0032251477,
-0.0242091566,
0.0226160698,
0.007809672,
-0.005819669,
0.0080817165,
0.037744645,
0.0084227482,
0.0427232422,
-0.016191991,
0.0207041055,
-0.0692506209,
0.0294029079,
-0.0592067726,
-0.0146626523,
-0.0033645718,
0.0013811303,
-0.0039106663,
-0.038534496,
-0.0224769078,
0.0130729377,
-0.0092456685,
-0.0095318081,
0.0019170189,
0.0130629344,
-0.0100363856,
-0.0387841985,
-0.0113495095,
-0.0027527988,
-0.0537913218,
0.0148653537,
0.0727361366,
0.054874979,
-0.0563542023,
-0.0242219269,
0.0161468759,
0.0303438175,
0.0583536513,
-0.0463748164,
-0.0245175548,
-0.0255969986,
0.0593677796,
0.0707097575,
-0.0706688389,
0.0215252936,
0.0262515396,
-0.0174992401,
0.0339213051,
0.0086321896,
0.046617955,
-0.0242250394,
-0.0477204882,
0.0195198506,
-0.1057285815,
-0.0110472282,
-0.0343564972,
0.0504427999,
-0.0391240679,
-0.0252902769,
0.0752914771,
0.0502822399,
-0.0545291379,
-0.0177967735,
-0.0355131775,
0.0008285968,
0.0012668958,
0.025178358,
-0.0664197505,
0.0356289223,
-0.0046652257,
0.0435742363,
0.012780048,
-0.018156888,
0.0175855514,
-0.0623998642,
0.0294045191,
0.0121226823,
-0.0272237211,
-0.0199045483,
-0.0329014026,
0.0030315318,
0.0142993229,
-0.0298277996,
0.0263691489,
-0.0237099528,
-0.0013035145,
0.0324355438,
-0.009479342,
-0.0650287569,
-0.0050691902,
-0.0548712425,
-0.0166504681,
0.0417285338,
0.0338148363,
-0.025458565,
-0.0022144564,
-0.0083401194,
-0.0613809861,
-0.0308247581,
-0.0098751104,
0.0223310031,
-0.0137733882,
0.0122402413,
-0.0156134488,
0.0550009683,
0.0267805718,
0.0067100828,
0.0556146428,
0.0372705571,
0.007253028,
0.006518044,
-0.1187442467,
0.0188980605,
-0.0255244654,
0.0572350919,
0.0138570145,
-0.0281932708,
-0.0126195243,
-0.022168329,
0.0154180154,
-0.0741342381,
-0.0147332819,
-0.0202884115,
-0.0547767729,
-0.0111748576,
-0.0584790967,
-0.0449914485,
0.0153736426,
0.008503912,
0.0121376254,
0.0036909571,
-0.038198147,
-0.0237688888,
-0.0407928675,
0.0309701357,
0.0042850552,
-0.0266990662,
-0.0228945315,
-0.0357757472,
0.1021531373,
-0.0207694508,
-0.0290651042,
-0.0069783628,
0.0370443389,
-0.0246183556,
-0.0212547183,
0.0210448764,
0.0150951855,
0.0362826325,
-0.0397292785,
-0.0825702921,
0.0339354575,
0.0529028997,
0.0403645448,
-0.0308179632,
0.0111027062,
-0.0309567992,
-0.0338823646,
-0.0185125172,
-0.0775761157,
0.0361477174,
-0.0345178582,
0.0336753726,
-0.0303603597,
-0.0091804126,
0.0150049496,
-0.0355968513,
0.0285398364,
-0.0556135103,
0.049259197,
-0.0429948308,
0.010523377,
-0.0262369234,
0.0137621826,
-0.0171373188,
0.0575787276,
-0.0047002719,
-0.0268726908,
-0.0026401496,
0.0448246337,
-0.0319679566,
0.0455828048,
-0.1010006219,
0.0332388729,
0.0076585314,
0.0085865138,
-0.0047295261,
-0.0112149986,
-0.0665837228,
-0.0332000144,
-0.0370474197,
0.0242109578,
-0.0103905927,
0.012766758,
0.0498448573,
-0.0104545252,
0.0242332686,
0.0062777572,
-0.1138308346,
0.0164723508,
-0.0727036372,
-0.0026944606,
0.0662874654,
0.0296221953,
0.0307970848,
-0.0435272641,
-0.0641855299,
-0.0118275592,
0.0560123548,
0.0102592511,
-0.0138065889,
0.0284491964,
0.033461798,
-0.0063271779,
-0.05231997,
0.0568171665,
0.0196308661,
0.0081399223,
0.033828035,
-0.029870512,
-0.0265794843,
0.026510803,
0.0321822576,
0.0434820168,
0.005146198,
-0.0061167264,
-0.0332728475,
0.0050173635,
0.0819176435,
0.0282048658,
0.0106274551,
-0.0033867157,
0.0273173917,
0.0339162163,
-0.0142312115,
-0.0094765704,
-0.031965252,
0.0534290597,
-0.0272710491,
-0.0911990851,
-0.0111757666,
-5.768757261e-33,
-0.014757216,
-0.0462542847,
-0.026393529,
0.0140757272,
-0.0194327272,
0.0276676081,
-0.0703138188,
-0.0534674414,
0.0000688713,
0.0108224619,
-0.0453983657,
-0.008904146,
-0.0029158357,
0.0325107686,
0.0253256746,
0.0238204356,
0.0558247007,
0.0385100171,
-0.0024916949,
0.0666575655,
0.023890717,
0.0322669037,
0.0535329394,
-0.0645067692,
0.0153544508,
-0.0379145406,
0.0040460313,
-0.0334117599,
0.0554573089,
0.0588681474,
-0.0108750006,
0.0066375663,
0.0167425182,
-0.0056727631,
-0.0239001065,
0.0040013385,
-0.0872901529,
-0.0116736759,
-0.0025295685,
-0.0198104661,
-0.0473295934,
-0.0492866263,
0.0358855464,
-0.0473868884,
0.018761985,
0.0015632447,
0.0692523569,
-0.0047860113,
-0.0501824841,
-0.1319452971,
-0.0682643428,
0.0133232065,
-0.0035317473,
0.0183108598,
0.0244354866,
0.0130652618,
0.0331436209,
0.047695186,
-0.0262098182,
0.0252260696,
0.003434082,
0.0492679104,
0.0022456308,
-0.0014695992,
0.0130640585,
0.0311814025,
-0.0215847548,
-0.0014780221,
0.0600165352,
-0.0160404984,
0.0015547931,
-0.0024487539,
0.0618748441,
0.0209723338,
0.0402631722,
0.0309944786,
-0.0432799123,
0.0335687473,
0.0475820825,
0.0005774077,
0.0641205683,
0.0100391116,
0.0263246093,
0.0148278782,
-0.0056840177,
-0.0391389728,
0.0059244712,
-0.0318248384,
-0.0022016428,
0.0190494619,
-0.0374704599,
0.0364685021,
0.0064209718,
-0.0311337356,
-0.0156009514,
0.0423943326,
-0.0046202359,
0.0457206517,
-0.0049919221,
-0.0253808238,
-0.0795480758,
-0.0270276144,
-0.0016117025,
-0.0076563009,
0.0124188755,
0.0198269989,
0.0594213754,
-0.0155994073,
-0.0026010354,
-0.017291218,
-0.0061075273,
-0.0006793099,
-0.0304196626,
0.0195369329,
0.0057497118,
0.0142572736,
-0.000730857,
0.0280362014,
0.0465614982,
0.0654321685,
0.0235824939,
0.0109812701,
0.0157262776,
0.0574136637,
-0.0086082434,
0.0204573888,
-0.0053828163,
0.0562115535,
0.0149250831,
-0.0503742993,
-0.0079464177,
-0.0250612758,
2.582e-7,
0.0542556606,
0.0222265404,
0.0193084888,
0.0220379364,
0.0355004519,
-0.0162702892,
0.0232853238,
0.0508744493,
0.0112719238,
0.0202318542,
-0.0064444831,
-0.0484961122,
-0.0005452371,
0.0139233442,
-0.1290958822,
-0.0273770969,
-0.0448801294,
-0.0185190551,
-0.0383124873,
0.007841194,
0.051224757,
0.0135627445,
-0.0218171608,
0.0279724281,
-0.0177497081,
-0.0212689936,
0.0538394116,
-0.0103161559,
-0.0133119868,
0.0371133164,
0.0407606289,
0.0409861431,
-0.0245483983,
-0.0302884076,
-0.0208004918,
0.0280539971,
0.0041246735,
-0.0074821478,
0.0363694318,
-0.0289333891,
0.0427758098,
-0.0380219147,
0.0480513908,
-0.0456837788,
-0.0059325974,
-0.0572404228,
-0.0171327386,
-0.0651416779,
-0.0503634512,
-0.0002351418,
0.005663272,
-0.0636101961,
-0.0377153382,
0.0275763273,
-0.0259596724,
-0.0022874963,
0.0003133617,
-0.0859003887,
0.0011481975,
0.0667691827,
-0.0334565751,
-0.0439223535,
-0.0120343054,
-0.0236051288,
-0.0047146771,
-0.0823844671,
-0.0012282194,
2.799597524e-34,
0.0819653943,
-0.0248407647,
-0.0279128924,
0.0494720489,
0.0092453379,
-0.0107211247,
0.0092674978,
0.0030256631,
0.0394238159,
-0.015031117,
-0.0493471101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06976v1 | Investigating Multi-source Active Learning for Natural Language Inference | 2023-02-14T11:10:18 | 2023-02-14T11:10:18 | Ard Snijders, Douwe Kiela, Katerina Margatina | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, active learning has been successfully applied to an array of
NLP tasks. However, prior work often assumes that training and test data are
drawn from the same distribution. This is problematic, as in real-life settings
data may stem from several sources of varying relevance and quality. We show
that four popular active learning schemes fail to outperform random selection
when applied to unlabelled pools comprised of multiple data sources on the task
of natural language inference. We reveal that uncertainty-based strategies
perform poorly due to the acquisition of collective outliers, i.e.,
hard-to-learn instances that hamper learning and generalization. When outliers
are removed, strategies are found to recover and outperform random baselines.
In further analysis, we find that collective outliers vary in form between
sources, and show that hard-to-learn data is not always categorically harmful.
Lastly, we leverage dataset cartography to introduce difficulty-stratified
testing and find that different strategies are affected differently by example
learnability and difficulty. | [
0.0172461513,
0.065692015,
-0.0190327633,
-0.0165346116,
-0.0276442189,
0.0544904731,
0.0285380725,
0.0053623822,
0.0177909322,
-0.0567909516,
0.0215216875,
-0.0193530396,
-0.0040325038,
-0.0134044206,
0.0326676257,
-0.0170185808,
0.018590413,
-0.0186729245,
0.0563142188,
-0.0190357845,
-0.0100442804,
0.0238558967,
-0.0136253573,
0.0182331353,
-0.038230408,
0.0663330629,
0.0270148795,
-0.0172865074,
0.001765259,
-0.0292880218,
0.0218717884,
0.0465026237,
0.0184283182,
-0.0010038492,
0.0000015735,
-0.0556564406,
-0.0254738256,
-0.0094499858,
-0.0040097474,
-0.0010708746,
-0.0434853211,
0.0024275947,
0.0639209151,
-0.0154580371,
-0.0261197984,
-0.067603983,
0.0867950991,
0.0033668296,
0.0418602228,
0.0124452254,
-0.0149398008,
0.0002710783,
-0.036867585,
-0.0424704142,
0.0242448673,
-0.0612720549,
0.0410133302,
-0.0267417338,
-0.0236992277,
-0.0112845013,
0.0133345826,
-0.0032578073,
-0.0128608672,
0.0457394794,
-0.0031897165,
0.0322474763,
-0.030322127,
-0.0242077615,
0.0105237029,
0.0789958313,
0.0013347706,
-0.0005459345,
0.0017037437,
-0.0646079108,
0.0102384556,
0.0646640435,
-0.0383591428,
0.0339948982,
-0.0373847149,
0.0467491522,
-0.0241982602,
-0.0220897049,
0.0391098484,
0.0395462625,
-0.0105427913,
-0.0002378625,
-0.0162266549,
-0.0494178273,
0.0596483536,
0.0710419714,
-0.0839134753,
0.0012518485,
-0.0038607377,
-0.0010032484,
-0.0540552773,
0.0336175561,
0.0181367155,
-0.0069071241,
0.0280999523,
-0.0241849553,
0.016256284,
0.0117472522,
-0.0461051129,
0.0864905268,
0.0080390265,
-0.0280408841,
-0.0025704268,
0.0182826128,
-0.0017981955,
-0.0465188399,
-0.0286044888,
0.0193214547,
-0.0089014843,
0.056063816,
0.0074644764,
0.0100196898,
-0.048122827,
-0.0039593093,
-0.038067963,
-0.0244676843,
-0.0124309622,
0.0428737141,
-0.0619540438,
0.0263256337,
-0.0211627036,
-0.0039061103,
-0.023355009,
0.0425217338,
-0.0523551181,
-0.0596805997,
-0.0314630829,
0.0304849781,
0.0207505561,
-0.0247451197,
0.0227626152,
0.0712404922,
0.0112478929,
-0.0555316508,
-0.0257772263,
0.0014895037,
0.0249133091,
-0.0150222825,
0.0193459485,
-0.0412639864,
0.018048659,
0.0082701873,
0.0067511024,
-0.0758085325,
-0.0074913232,
0.0220704246,
-0.0990162492,
0.0505123064,
0.0030074075,
-0.0122365411,
0.0195314307,
-0.0394321121,
-0.0372996815,
0.0993301421,
-0.0357176177,
-0.013296131,
0.0522951186,
0.0280169882,
-0.0001583695,
0.0058268267,
0.0314071737,
0.0183806717,
0.0263031442,
0.0228260718,
-0.0297187623,
-0.0165252946,
-0.0597261749,
0.0144794816,
-0.0330748819,
-0.0034700818,
0.0190237593,
-0.0108493585,
-0.047274109,
-0.0565369688,
0.0307700783,
0.0002231512,
0.0356118567,
-0.0010269112,
-0.0522276387,
-0.0150267333,
-0.0203648247,
-0.0055211619,
-0.0008159488,
0.0400820635,
-0.024132207,
-0.0404003263,
-0.0609986782,
-0.0461618863,
0.0091396132,
0.0524585433,
0.1060071662,
0.0299732517,
-0.0009454517,
0.0129732043,
0.0834052265,
0.007781764,
-0.0374400429,
-0.0058060708,
0.0368397236,
-0.0453990512,
0.0108469436,
-0.0564046055,
-0.0268220622,
-0.0238126218,
0.0585877709,
-0.0044521159,
0.0179546103,
-0.0236325376,
0.0656104237,
-0.0535646379,
-0.0545659624,
0.062797077,
0.0672639608,
0.0064242133,
0.0506876931,
-0.0140760206,
-0.0077681183,
-0.0376471989,
-0.0237742625,
0.059861768,
0.0215758272,
-0.0223493669,
0.0189474244,
-0.0067412057,
0.0373067893,
-0.053940434,
-0.0451860353,
-0.0254331715,
0.0091802999,
0.0003842815,
-0.0391551815,
0.0489352793,
-0.0002847718,
-0.0015148334,
-0.0037717198,
-0.0500029773,
-0.099714011,
-0.009729729,
-0.0684368685,
0.0131102474,
-0.0497053415,
-0.0735904276,
-0.0214878246,
-0.0386980698,
-0.0047099129,
-0.0234410893,
0.0473255217,
-0.058296904,
0.0967250466,
-0.0147800129,
0.0301063303,
0.047146339,
-0.0450061932,
0.0345697552,
-0.0239204522,
-0.0121506937,
-0.0136807365,
-0.0118855862,
-0.031811092,
0.0185049139,
0.0000579743,
-0.0364219546,
0.0302642044,
-0.020549871,
0.0023348678,
-0.0220913086,
-0.0156458244,
0.0069077183,
0.0158159286,
-0.0232068989,
-0.0310218651,
0.0194315761,
-0.0284748878,
-0.0116469013,
0.0508585684,
0.0367476195,
-0.0081776325,
0.0466214344,
-0.0111279003,
-0.0269339755,
-0.0240032133,
0.0767766088,
-0.0100710345,
0.0097893905,
-0.0406166129,
-0.0069307135,
-0.0332585461,
0.0239921901,
0.0133098383,
0.0351308137,
0.0017855917,
-0.0414653867,
-0.0188836921,
0.0338743627,
-0.0098807486,
0.0266189296,
0.0228720531,
-0.0283791218,
-0.0538215004,
0.0243979208,
-0.0419469699,
-0.0227505844,
-0.0017830116,
-0.0426091105,
-0.02585328,
0.0120675918,
0.0208170544,
-0.0226792507,
-0.0231544673,
0.0593359172,
-0.0256089624,
-0.0138568049,
-0.046137087,
0.0367332995,
0.0314025059,
0.0523441471,
-0.0115781957,
-0.0485469401,
0.0895397291,
0.0110815819,
-0.0166689642,
-0.0572326295,
-0.000086606,
-0.0251736548,
0.0154812438,
0.0223391857,
-0.0209921245,
0.010095736,
0.0136253806,
-0.0263068266,
-0.0518501326,
0.0497413687,
0.0175199453,
0.0406613722,
-0.0563899837,
0.0132651366,
0.0133170839,
-0.0425379984,
-0.039635621,
-0.0407440327,
0.0110537307,
-0.0041558696,
0.0144824274,
-0.0045526018,
-0.0076875729,
0.0105897291,
0.0034180644,
0.0139576644,
0.0106452322,
-0.0287927035,
-0.016131226,
0.0103104115,
0.0243516788,
-0.0024077368,
0.0236973166,
-0.034473639,
-0.0597085319,
0.0304428749,
0.0026807259,
0.0137786735,
0.0023389475,
0.0404885784,
0.0391076095,
-0.0164324269,
0.0303843841,
0.0128251603,
0.0370576456,
0.0184574611,
-0.0390343219,
0.0701912194,
0.0379091501,
-0.0219636075,
-0.003745849,
0.026449414,
-0.001876876,
0.0235028528,
0.0064858594,
-0.0238533169,
-0.025668513,
0.0003038085,
0.0442800634,
-0.0269025005,
-0.0595857129,
-0.0055728322,
-0.0977765098,
0.0338220596,
-0.0327719152,
-0.0630937368,
-0.0040944293,
-0.0886223912,
0.0406987555,
-0.066173099,
0.0160130877,
-0.0406812355,
0.0080792429,
0.0262231082,
0.0223027207,
-0.045762945,
-0.0363145657,
-0.0136592686,
-0.032399781,
0.0042349109,
-0.0098243495,
0.0183438715,
-0.0075606336,
0.0174000189,
0.0426766723,
-0.0780163705,
-0.0042068069,
-0.0529241897,
0.0803143606,
0.0514715388,
-0.0347627103,
0.0063844174,
0.0196949616,
-0.0301434211,
0.0016018063,
-0.0095213242,
0.0257030874,
-0.0017284261,
0.0042238692,
0.0008364531,
-0.0149462605,
0.0309321452,
0.0390978456,
-0.0328980871,
-0.0088076591,
-0.025763534,
-0.0022000254,
-0.01062374,
-0.0038494742,
-0.0132908942,
0.0774641037,
-0.0515419915,
-0.0460471362,
-0.0331139043,
-0.051057566,
0.0354028903,
0.1012776718,
0.0300397705,
0.0289999731,
0.0065211053,
0.0115669537,
0.0148888715,
0.0263059456,
0.003577118,
-0.0054630036,
0.0806196854,
-0.0811348185,
0.0127067706,
-0.0109387096,
-0.0361628197,
0.0435191244,
-0.049721133,
-0.0587157682,
0.0281703547,
0.0363537632,
0.0312928036,
0.0561078973,
-0.0248904694,
-0.0011443737,
0.0047935601,
0.0338677242,
-0.016714314,
0.0009844684,
0.0256228298,
-0.0400226973,
0.0307881776,
0.0216061343,
-0.0515756048,
0.0359183662,
0.0784111023,
0.0048080604,
-0.0480603389,
0.0279540326,
0.0217626058,
0.0014699156,
0.1017441303,
-0.0282867029,
-0.044875104,
-0.0071979975,
-0.0137742599,
0.0321513824,
-0.034402173,
-0.0052914689,
0.0238797888,
-0.0023994835,
0.0403239541,
-0.0551307611,
0.0381544828,
0.052629292,
0.0665579289,
-0.0270550754,
-0.0064357729,
0.0761811659,
-0.0023366157,
-0.016739158,
-0.0277719237,
-0.0262560342,
0.055497773,
-0.0185799878,
0.0615500398,
0.0086927162,
0.0154869799,
0.0349306241,
0.0414348803,
-0.0058628675,
-0.0474721603,
-0.0992752016,
-0.0434526689,
-0.0198440738,
0.0305623412,
0.0616974384,
-0.0680354163,
0.053931959,
-0.0049783303,
-0.0110505847,
0.0166357439,
-0.0094726598,
0.0346221961,
0.0040754545,
0.0057555381,
0.0077867424,
-0.0006058754,
0.0462858118,
0.0631670132,
0.0196762718,
0.091230616,
-0.0262393076,
-0.0200335179,
-0.0449982882,
-0.0163589064,
0.0213004556,
0.0164504629,
0.0217719097,
0.0289956443,
-0.000696714,
-0.0633508042,
0.0157747939,
-0.0322429985,
0.0253303964,
0.024080975,
0.0448917486,
0.0929541066,
0.0197296031,
0.020509433,
-0.0092878472,
-0.0088189654,
-0.0017434647,
0.0158719923,
-0.0269887224,
-6.252975343e-33,
0.0117439618,
-0.038070485,
-0.0477217734,
-0.0260541514,
0.048460491,
0.0178542621,
-0.0219381824,
-0.0292214714,
-0.0327264778,
-0.0037364117,
0.0025962139,
-0.0125128729,
0.0230175927,
0.0241535138,
0.0222911276,
-0.0169755388,
0.014612468,
0.0188236721,
-0.0088666081,
-0.0133939693,
0.0646462813,
0.0362935923,
0.0532347746,
-0.0871093422,
0.0327478237,
0.0327675417,
-0.0114875538,
0.0500923954,
0.0006051743,
0.0131422132,
0.024572162,
0.0691663548,
0.0165517889,
-0.0206799451,
0.0044874144,
-0.0565489456,
-0.0821163952,
-0.0417622589,
-0.004038075,
0.0369389318,
0.0203106944,
0.0391645096,
0.0155231729,
-0.0293576773,
0.0416349843,
-0.0047542313,
0.042421829,
-0.0167357437,
-0.0358134247,
-0.0272795781,
-0.0108445911,
0.0393464528,
-0.0508491509,
0.0436422639,
-0.0446467288,
0.0299918931,
-0.0077068661,
0.0028991594,
-0.0269031487,
0.000449108,
-0.0160290208,
-0.0131347571,
-0.0193441045,
-0.0207980257,
0.0110218422,
0.0336434953,
0.0084667597,
-0.0258263815,
-0.0396097973,
-0.0137361297,
0.0043851109,
0.0368785299,
0.0024104097,
0.0655306578,
0.0287696756,
0.0130132567,
-0.1039302647,
0.0144291623,
0.0825359896,
-0.0303518604,
0.0109222475,
-0.0117690442,
-0.0446692929,
-0.0384647027,
-0.000757663,
0.010203951,
-0.0100198453,
-0.0235445891,
0.015147741,
0.0276286062,
-0.0405695438,
0.0574290492,
0.0141016124,
-0.0182403289,
-0.0414696112,
0.0175475851,
0.0046258704,
-0.0349140055,
-0.0037971525,
-0.0203109495,
-0.03049553,
-0.0779998824,
0.0019177984,
0.0159775075,
0.0111283027,
0.0336114131,
0.0642490089,
0.008990434,
-0.0509030372,
0.0047275256,
-0.0040440205,
0.0135137569,
-0.0040479465,
0.0280414652,
0.0343738496,
0.0120735103,
-0.0030734676,
0.0229011327,
0.0456585437,
0.0012611339,
-0.0277132168,
0.0069750268,
-0.0224964824,
-0.0126432395,
-0.0110730752,
-0.0453485884,
0.013527872,
-0.0416851975,
-0.0036549501,
-0.0666061789,
-0.0019390591,
0.0013956911,
2.423e-7,
0.0558082424,
0.0523759834,
-0.0304948669,
0.0243810546,
-0.009330052,
0.0210809018,
-0.0177777149,
-0.0229135361,
0.0282481201,
0.004874486,
-0.0173906032,
0.0283272881,
-0.0020695066,
0.0787857547,
-0.0873125866,
-0.0339566432,
-0.0169003066,
0.0254634172,
-0.0388614871,
0.0102350945,
0.0528534353,
0.0857586563,
0.0378598459,
-0.0041204775,
-0.0215190873,
-0.0850178301,
0.0357911624,
-0.0078535369,
0.0256294589,
0.0014985647,
0.0217156075,
-0.0010630609,
0.0074295341,
0.0656536669,
-0.0080888066,
-0.0156645402,
0.0167680681,
0.0065720757,
-0.0045287157,
-0.0169784706,
-0.0195673034,
0.0089593949,
0.0403406434,
0.0004392207,
0.0878668353,
-0.0678623691,
-0.0408257209,
-0.0046791197,
-0.0090484666,
-0.0122066885,
0.0581700727,
0.0310792234,
0.0090032369,
0.0265438892,
-0.0108589036,
0.032657031,
-0.0503204837,
-0.0905737206,
-0.0107714217,
-0.0385411456,
-0.0498171076,
-0.0530735701,
0.0246413499,
0.0459251739,
0.0109784808,
-0.0377227217,
-0.0075882263,
1.866762974e-34,
0.035747312,
0.0077905329,
0.015331517,
0.0322568119,
0.0224988796,
-0.0273967199,
0.0503866784,
-0.0123050986,
-0.0188690834,
-0.00889262,
0.0113384463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06951v1 | Few-shot learning approaches for classifying low resource domain specific software requirements | 2023-02-14T10:19:23 | 2023-02-14T10:19:23 | Anmol Nayak, Hari Prasad Timmapathini, Vidhya Murali, Atul Anil Gohad | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the advent of strong pre-trained natural language processing models like
BERT, DeBERTa, MiniLM, T5, the data requirement for industries to fine-tune
these models to their niche use cases has drastically reduced (typically to a
few hundred annotated samples for achieving a reasonable performance). However,
the availability of even a few hundred annotated samples may not always be
guaranteed in low resource domains like automotive, which often limits the
usage of such deep learning models in an industrial setting. In this paper we
aim to address the challenge of fine-tuning such pre-trained models with only a
few annotated samples, also known as Few-shot learning. Our experiments focus
on evaluating the performance of a diverse set of algorithms and methodologies
to achieve the task of classifying BOSCH automotive domain textual software
requirements into 3 categories, while utilizing only 15 annotated samples per
category for fine-tuning. We find that while SciBERT and DeBERTa based models
tend to be the most accurate at 15 training samples, their performance
improvement scales minimally as the number of annotated samples is increased to
50 in comparison to Siamese and T5 based models. | [
0.0321253799,
0.0283505283,
-0.0010907737,
0.0198514722,
-0.0287040416,
-0.0033101167,
0.0319646969,
-0.0128226308,
-0.0209733807,
-0.0933366567,
-0.0019111249,
0.0230824202,
0.0074397093,
-0.0096617611,
-0.0147077776,
-0.0186662376,
0.0193657335,
0.0162398927,
-0.0147840371,
0.0148258451,
-0.0161141027,
0.0488491394,
-0.0284526404,
0.0530336797,
0.0204508565,
-0.0370811261,
-0.0006888136,
-0.0068668388,
0.0130723948,
-0.0133901937,
0.0409415364,
0.0374586768,
0.0224005301,
0.02085099,
0.0000020666,
-0.0549220331,
-0.0364496075,
-0.0123781813,
-0.0264337994,
0.013803049,
0.0189087,
-0.0202004369,
0.0175214317,
0.0063994788,
-0.0029918773,
-0.0112173669,
0.0345987864,
0.0647576526,
0.0407358818,
0.0534450077,
-0.0047767693,
-0.0206433628,
-0.030181786,
-0.0213845987,
-0.0000755345,
-0.0426274724,
0.0120893577,
-0.0369163826,
0.0509274863,
0.0122992229,
0.0317476466,
0.0137962634,
0.0163038615,
0.0399052948,
0.0392072424,
0.0426217169,
-0.0842155293,
-0.0036441963,
0.0163271055,
0.0880962238,
-0.0526990779,
-0.0330803804,
-0.0233253185,
-0.053378664,
-0.016623361,
-0.0376510769,
0.0191392675,
-0.0355579779,
0.0103359064,
-0.0122420797,
-0.0081118811,
0.0270910282,
-0.0082553169,
-0.0221091881,
-0.0080236197,
0.0064187106,
-0.031063905,
-0.0277036298,
0.0260231476,
-0.0067645595,
-0.0432075039,
-0.0463270731,
-0.0337839201,
0.0124918409,
0.0014094391,
-0.0108392388,
-0.0343736112,
0.023466384,
0.0266028121,
-0.0265670177,
0.0206857137,
-0.0369176008,
-0.0265846867,
0.0559881106,
-0.0340926312,
0.0046825814,
0.0297504496,
-0.0260770321,
-0.0261822194,
0.0047521405,
-0.0531834811,
-0.006193982,
-0.0558128469,
0.0728043094,
0.0105945934,
-0.0079259584,
-0.0271952227,
-0.0088057006,
0.0089295227,
0.034785334,
-0.0178002566,
0.0479205064,
-0.0240557771,
-0.010108537,
-0.0184997898,
0.0274690855,
-0.0373695157,
0.0337174535,
-0.0398375839,
-0.0260181744,
0.0356707945,
0.0115327705,
0.0002886906,
-0.0174663141,
0.0331536755,
0.0157794151,
0.0413500294,
-0.0374566987,
-0.082542643,
-0.0309892241,
-0.0043102163,
-0.0262462609,
-0.0263784733,
-0.0372797921,
-0.0341718905,
-0.0057795336,
0.0154016586,
-0.000841982,
0.0014376538,
-0.0086952215,
-0.0028380158,
0.0802543163,
-0.0352762267,
-0.0195074528,
0.0127873179,
-0.0064426167,
0.0314467363,
0.0593115054,
0.0302857235,
0.0520724654,
0.0339479931,
0.0066000992,
0.0221947804,
0.031293191,
-0.0178945288,
-0.0313337818,
0.0133297229,
0.0302373488,
-0.0764113143,
-0.0017741349,
0.0059974366,
-0.0506753437,
0.0179281551,
0.019354336,
0.0089423433,
0.0570442751,
0.0702870712,
-0.0165840723,
0.0293048527,
0.0851022899,
-0.0087667685,
-0.0552270114,
0.0173239075,
0.048437845,
-0.0028384789,
-0.0002259234,
-0.0232353341,
-0.0199079178,
-0.05570703,
-0.0303019565,
0.0025365415,
-0.0408031903,
-0.0550424047,
0.001734179,
0.0807216093,
-0.0181140527,
-0.0314046144,
0.0262734201,
0.0264170244,
0.0303782318,
-0.0247990265,
-0.0037489715,
-0.013717277,
0.0774653703,
0.0387528799,
-0.0791912824,
-0.0552121028,
-0.019112438,
-0.0115565108,
0.0195996389,
0.0558359288,
-0.0284692887,
0.0191597696,
-0.011126169,
-0.0360552743,
-0.0560599975,
0.0260697305,
0.0048508104,
-0.0308804438,
0.0106798206,
0.0108903795,
-0.0138239851,
0.0191941019,
0.0304631833,
-0.0040354356,
-0.0640003383,
0.0330659486,
0.0633812249,
0.0122208074,
0.006236231,
-0.0271315854,
-0.002022374,
0.0209772587,
-0.0188997518,
-0.0084476341,
-0.0444189571,
0.0258140489,
-0.0276530981,
0.0058228015,
0.0032878513,
0.0331420712,
0.0273739696,
-0.0458556898,
-0.0057447646,
-0.0188164152,
-0.0207442325,
-0.0045156656,
0.0223511904,
-0.0113684433,
-0.0303478483,
-0.0187980905,
-0.0347549766,
0.0310649313,
0.0589261129,
0.0259847734,
-0.0223825667,
-0.0376214422,
0.0652366355,
0.0046910779,
-0.0524810962,
-0.0185483955,
-0.0379723385,
0.0444130488,
0.0176105984,
0.0318482891,
-0.0022801203,
0.028458681,
-0.0624298565,
0.0133735202,
-0.0026618261,
0.0076236427,
-0.0097624855,
-0.0225377772,
0.0161910597,
-0.0215062387,
-0.0072500864,
-0.0021477141,
-0.0667304844,
-0.0164221376,
0.039678704,
0.018060118,
0.000509333,
-0.0017918,
0.0018169937,
-0.0358337313,
0.0346545167,
0.0047577983,
-0.0179122407,
-0.0607593395,
0.0334266797,
-0.0188725684,
0.0353165455,
0.0010770975,
-0.0207700711,
-0.005777101,
0.0266930927,
-0.0155368885,
0.0133778527,
-0.0183878299,
-0.0138191413,
0.0225481633,
0.0552663021,
-0.0396698378,
0.0181598701,
-0.0083612157,
0.0105969254,
0.0126331821,
-0.0063198418,
0.0153661603,
0.042407304,
-0.0206027832,
0.0069513498,
-0.06289161,
0.0255890507,
-0.0132172527,
0.0052746166,
-0.0247677881,
0.0239039306,
0.0273603667,
0.0499998406,
-0.0103364484,
-0.0013206509,
0.0624178238,
-0.0007529698,
-0.0017778291,
-0.065377526,
-0.0303939991,
-0.0305847991,
0.0580528826,
-0.0209997017,
0.0114318971,
0.0609004088,
0.023285361,
-0.0662588179,
0.0178481862,
-0.0117347632,
0.0026498635,
0.0381238833,
-0.0166665409,
0.0445916355,
-0.0506509952,
-0.0462280847,
-0.0258515794,
-0.0776942149,
-0.0391519628,
0.0350943319,
-0.0122037195,
-0.0051734596,
-0.0368809551,
0.0358701944,
-0.0020149262,
0.1009711176,
0.0447641276,
-0.0307078585,
-0.0215543695,
-0.0122385221,
0.055418916,
-0.0544645824,
-0.0061599761,
0.0181813575,
0.0444535837,
-0.0176877324,
0.034605246,
0.0392488502,
-0.0901995301,
-0.0168597791,
0.0120592322,
-0.0536744446,
-0.0236414056,
0.0126965493,
-0.0025733642,
-0.0402950943,
0.0096520158,
0.0893908069,
0.0187049974,
-0.0131598171,
0.0296066403,
0.0692646801,
-0.0057204305,
0.0596895255,
0.0279957093,
-0.1019991934,
-0.0453885347,
-0.0055864747,
0.0504396074,
-0.0141506484,
0.0044222027,
-0.0283604041,
-0.1358531862,
0.0116286725,
-0.0257879905,
-0.01384647,
-0.0024740493,
-0.0385709926,
-0.017891001,
-0.0309320372,
-0.0024259302,
-0.0371159501,
-0.0109413881,
-0.0269031655,
0.033243496,
-0.0702031329,
-0.0985989794,
0.0776012987,
-0.0027076667,
0.0242378544,
0.0432669334,
0.0014997296,
0.0149177285,
0.005349745,
0.0643660426,
-0.0330240577,
0.014414777,
0.0080749355,
0.0755270347,
-0.0117902346,
-0.0296964347,
0.05554213,
-0.0297781471,
-0.0521366782,
-0.0005772827,
-0.0084215896,
0.0583197027,
-0.0081768567,
0.0031973813,
-0.0234784335,
0.0069924733,
-0.0398023166,
0.0633540303,
0.0011468764,
-0.0684348717,
-0.012550897,
0.0278466437,
-0.020564476,
-0.0559484363,
-0.0287045036,
0.0092974324,
-0.0528371222,
-0.0465067402,
-0.0513152033,
-0.0450346619,
0.0623802952,
0.0209257398,
-0.0029307753,
0.0066956361,
0.0379321091,
0.025244467,
-0.0584517717,
0.0333767496,
0.0160229877,
0.0190741271,
-0.0084800562,
0.0018626055,
0.0446502343,
-0.0088614877,
-0.0588114671,
-0.0562396757,
-0.0579723231,
-0.0088191107,
-0.047991924,
0.0362744592,
0.0113124764,
-0.0053590112,
-0.0417322628,
-0.1031630263,
0.0261590965,
0.1058304831,
-0.0143519193,
-0.0277779084,
0.0335549563,
-0.0045016049,
-0.0374202058,
0.0217734426,
-0.0710541382,
0.0348035842,
0.0038476652,
-0.0184277464,
0.0118795326,
0.0329085849,
0.0193162709,
-0.0106251854,
0.0532543547,
-0.0103215287,
-0.000331161,
-0.0344320647,
0.0467882752,
0.0555335619,
-0.0259185079,
-0.0519090034,
-0.0075301449,
0.0131514762,
-0.0455701984,
-0.0222947784,
-0.0150486268,
0.012535831,
0.0377352796,
-0.0408093445,
0.0124522811,
0.0813014582,
0.0138185304,
-0.0024992649,
0.0038420698,
-0.0258246455,
-0.0127536515,
0.0020762724,
0.0161309931,
-0.0149211735,
0.0080364179,
-0.012120761,
0.0491565391,
-0.0240963604,
0.0188432168,
-0.0021178306,
-0.0411771722,
-0.0559033416,
-0.0088125216,
0.0282512121,
0.0129490038,
0.0097414432,
-0.0102746533,
0.0082256729,
-0.0420361646,
0.0430047885,
-0.0097262654,
0.000058641,
-0.0188585408,
0.0226139389,
-0.0410858132,
0.0269662105,
0.0831428468,
-0.0099105379,
0.0461929068,
0.0174464695,
0.0064333631,
-0.089900434,
0.0082194684,
0.0460693836,
0.0141099999,
-0.0314735472,
0.0171064008,
-0.0619385615,
-0.0309358798,
-0.0015206727,
-0.0418710187,
0.0154335015,
0.0359071307,
0.0376721062,
0.0556982309,
0.0048137857,
-0.0091305897,
-0.0106413849,
-0.0720317587,
-0.0236309562,
0.0117078023,
-0.0052015767,
-5.86269028e-33,
0.003458719,
0.0081426324,
-0.008749079,
-0.0240166727,
0.0339177884,
0.0325752199,
0.0104657207,
-0.0146192322,
-0.0196666531,
-0.0064166035,
0.0303209294,
0.0039876057,
0.0007063444,
-0.0175473206,
0.0582144521,
0.0003935561,
0.0502839461,
-0.0109442482,
-0.0252804942,
0.0436957516,
0.0034664776,
0.0286025703,
0.0466876216,
-0.0350439101,
0.0163464602,
-0.0020659103,
-0.0157868527,
-0.0040761307,
0.0375374556,
0.0725356117,
-0.0302782916,
0.0583185293,
0.0288276114,
-0.0409155898,
-0.0012194463,
0.0211329646,
-0.0335230306,
-0.0339955613,
-0.0256069135,
0.0165632777,
0.0414635763,
-0.0006270389,
0.0469178595,
0.0017336948,
0.0091553377,
0.0139196953,
0.0867373943,
-0.0068484698,
0.000629281,
-0.0763884261,
-0.0644687042,
0.0092755603,
-0.013224164,
-0.0303790662,
0.0321704596,
0.1189088523,
0.0160847753,
0.0446647741,
-0.0252936371,
-0.0198652875,
0.0233077705,
0.0575372316,
0.0701314136,
-0.0217681918,
-0.0201656837,
0.0237853415,
0.0127549404,
0.0110741612,
0.0208521951,
-0.020248685,
0.0341204852,
0.0917842239,
0.0226628557,
0.029543452,
0.0785043612,
0.0288223159,
-0.0646639243,
0.0266946536,
-0.0070915218,
0.0203839466,
0.041558627,
-0.0073736473,
-0.0693923086,
0.0012139886,
0.0096531222,
-0.0021227361,
-0.0449486859,
0.0089764884,
0.0326184221,
0.0594440363,
-0.0368876569,
0.0498426557,
0.0266104285,
-0.0759766623,
-0.0346902274,
-0.002485469,
-0.0377343558,
0.0132687232,
0.0032181554,
0.0081623727,
-0.0582069047,
-0.0459637046,
0.0211795997,
0.0234473664,
0.0641394779,
0.0105235865,
0.0788544416,
0.0169116315,
-0.0737361833,
-0.0001242152,
-0.0298251249,
-0.0108306678,
-0.0309808776,
0.0944804847,
0.0229423735,
0.0119787371,
-0.0028679231,
0.0151810227,
0.0035373743,
-0.0332973041,
0.0157148037,
0.0355635919,
-0.0242141131,
-0.0161190704,
-0.0037947532,
-0.0232002921,
-0.0012846357,
0.045846995,
0.0132921105,
-0.018977683,
-0.0304779336,
-0.029547628,
2.721e-7,
0.013927578,
0.0499284305,
-0.0202636011,
0.0061619966,
-0.0028372046,
0.0610735081,
0.0100914473,
0.0190027915,
-0.0456397906,
0.0049144761,
0.0319317654,
-0.0316854976,
0.042458348,
0.0241831876,
-0.0610720776,
-0.0066977968,
-0.0391829796,
0.0303198975,
-0.0854655951,
-0.0115018496,
0.0639400929,
0.1114869714,
0.0365198627,
-0.0272576883,
0.0032724068,
-0.0411001369,
0.007594924,
-0.0375650376,
0.0393336862,
0.034408547,
0.0137648601,
0.0843798593,
-0.04114566,
0.0257930364,
-0.0260884911,
0.0111414948,
-0.042281922,
0.0388878547,
-0.0300735217,
-0.0446413532,
0.0245260634,
-0.0362813361,
-0.0059556998,
-0.0214950256,
0.0440503396,
-0.0900198221,
-0.001913154,
-0.0048626084,
-0.0125832418,
0.0028220573,
0.0088132862,
-0.0074081491,
0.029329814,
-0.0266221724,
0.0027819106,
-0.076514408,
-0.0498164035,
-0.1010104045,
0.0221285652,
0.0702461377,
-0.0100295767,
-0.0143457679,
-0.0191125609,
-0.0030232305,
0.0682561323,
-0.0456038974,
0.0338707343,
2.410581214e-34,
0.0199904013,
-0.0245830622,
-0.0061985026,
0.0343473032,
-0.0219007395,
-0.00233096,
-0.0291104205,
-0.0391350612,
0.0089529455,
-0.013082887,
-0.0141943255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06871v1 | Learning gain differences between ChatGPT and human tutor generated algebra hints | 2023-02-14T07:20:48 | 2023-02-14T07:20:48 | Zachary A. Pardos, Shreya Bhandari | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, are quickly advancing AI to
the frontiers of practical consumer use and leading industries to re-evaluate
how they allocate resources for content production. Authoring of open
educational resources and hint content within adaptive tutoring systems is
labor intensive. Should LLMs like ChatGPT produce educational content on par
with human-authored content, the implications would be significant for further
scaling of computer tutoring system approaches. In this paper, we conduct the
first learning gain evaluation of ChatGPT by comparing the efficacy of its
hints with hints authored by human tutors with 77 participants across two
algebra topic areas, Elementary Algebra and Intermediate Algebra. We find that
70% of hints produced by ChatGPT passed our manual quality checks and that both
human and ChatGPT conditions produced positive learning gains. However, gains
were only statistically significant for human tutor created hints. Learning
gains from human-created hints were substantially and statistically
significantly higher than ChatGPT hints in both topic areas, though ChatGPT
participants in the Intermediate Algebra experiment were near ceiling and not
even with the control at pre-test. We discuss the limitations of our study and
suggest several future directions for the field. Problem and hint content used
in the experiment is provided for replicability. | [
0.0358011536,
-0.0058739064,
-0.0363669768,
0.0329419188,
-0.0487224236,
-0.0081131067,
0.051527489,
0.0029251562,
0.0454358347,
-0.0341867693,
0.0022320568,
0.0183258355,
-0.0201684907,
-0.0084155789,
0.0103436662,
-0.0439388864,
0.0030042308,
-0.0322224088,
0.0061720111,
0.0274216849,
0.0147065977,
-0.010363997,
-0.0463974103,
0.0564319417,
-0.0253170747,
-0.0514425822,
-0.0135329841,
-0.0581629798,
-0.0199457053,
-0.0124533912,
0.0393917151,
0.0543193966,
0.000096906,
0.0256602466,
0.0000022366,
-0.0496991314,
-0.0041647931,
0.0054086396,
-0.0554323271,
0.0578961,
0.0257979389,
0.0683134869,
-0.0001553652,
0.0119235395,
-0.0653493702,
0.0498934835,
0.0276960656,
-0.0079243025,
0.0482059903,
0.0439474732,
0.0071232421,
0.0345690139,
0.0269536655,
0.0237665456,
0.080500178,
-0.0328923054,
0.0148966042,
0.0410895832,
0.0197170563,
0.016578652,
-0.0351554453,
0.0449496917,
0.0194791723,
-0.0454786122,
0.0040596239,
0.0469676368,
-0.0060224636,
0.0066066417,
0.0056117377,
0.0421358347,
0.0074610538,
-0.0102035534,
-0.0243638288,
-0.0138036842,
0.0589112788,
0.0804137215,
-0.0871559158,
0.0291740689,
-0.02431616,
-0.0141782779,
0.0323700607,
-0.0584526658,
-0.0088823466,
0.0203207359,
0.0766718686,
0.0064798589,
-0.006978726,
-0.0520861894,
-0.0138903903,
0.0346496888,
-0.0210779142,
-0.0338303149,
0.0119254962,
0.0596173145,
0.0124057308,
0.0070091435,
-0.0051655588,
-0.0475095063,
-0.025215311,
-0.0455271155,
0.0518809371,
0.0672011301,
-0.0329516567,
0.0220035836,
-0.028557159,
0.0618475862,
0.0409741737,
0.0176020954,
-0.0433127731,
0.0491195321,
-0.0731330886,
-0.0221969821,
-0.0531755127,
0.0694567338,
0.0170384832,
0.0062264833,
-0.0655971766,
0.0343042836,
-0.0185593478,
0.0221602768,
-0.0048041353,
-0.0253690034,
0.0033392799,
-0.0016964009,
-0.0150961773,
0.0155795151,
-0.0235180613,
0.0229766909,
0.0131625552,
-0.0744898096,
-0.0048572682,
0.0190348197,
-0.0078039179,
0.0110571701,
-0.000148617,
0.0763883218,
-0.0320389867,
-0.0323065296,
-0.0544625372,
-0.0142492149,
0.0303072445,
-0.023536643,
-0.0117244003,
-0.0517412499,
0.0225060619,
0.0278502293,
-0.0097824531,
-0.0315764882,
0.0028745141,
0.0204143114,
0.0283659585,
0.011720187,
-0.0363355726,
0.016580103,
0.0657678545,
0.0055228202,
-0.1224597022,
0.0629036799,
0.046946805,
0.0314387344,
0.0168147366,
-0.047762204,
0.0735720992,
0.0273148995,
0.0212674066,
0.0001958571,
0.0376900509,
-0.0051242253,
0.0223706141,
0.0327370241,
-0.0355045311,
0.0409413092,
-0.0411965959,
0.007631884,
0.0628148764,
0.0795449317,
-0.0091051944,
0.077256076,
0.0332155004,
0.0445810594,
0.0621007048,
0.0187295657,
-0.0606131069,
0.0195274688,
-0.1102690622,
0.0117049534,
-0.0103816791,
-0.0144010512,
0.0044711572,
-0.0699077174,
-0.0332481079,
-0.0003311568,
0.0073146173,
0.009975004,
0.0746423751,
-0.0302113909,
-0.0221788306,
0.0252480991,
0.0479316823,
-0.0126428902,
0.0261103511,
-0.0872758701,
0.0880789831,
0.065011397,
0.0594654754,
-0.0306105558,
-0.0116034718,
-0.011783734,
0.0418385267,
0.0153371412,
0.0250910968,
-0.0130371293,
-0.0392710827,
-0.0261339787,
0.000862354,
-0.0410455875,
0.0002441295,
0.0016169967,
0.0617170371,
0.0052274032,
-0.0006794783,
0.0061866124,
-0.035262052,
0.0018976678,
-0.0679888204,
-0.0413116589,
-0.0313278921,
0.001658742,
-0.0388711244,
0.0118817929,
-0.0073261,
0.024130147,
-0.0027831076,
0.0080164615,
-0.05194683,
-0.0284268446,
-0.0322111994,
-0.0379672311,
0.0284779295,
-0.0375672281,
0.0018412872,
-0.0458707102,
-0.0034892727,
0.0312581062,
0.0698588938,
-0.0676414967,
0.0766078904,
0.004353147,
0.0180464778,
-0.0114808362,
-0.0361258872,
0.0082252938,
0.0504471883,
0.0236845333,
0.0157161336,
0.0235022679,
-0.0380652249,
-0.0010656241,
-0.0050369981,
0.0398301743,
-0.0333005264,
-0.0088744564,
0.0171068627,
-0.0046180915,
0.0252724774,
-0.0546266921,
-0.0151970889,
-0.0343660004,
-0.0223411378,
0.0121891052,
0.0440372154,
-0.0016910173,
-0.0172479227,
-0.0313363336,
-0.0082825404,
-0.0268905535,
-0.0165296979,
-0.0237400699,
0.0123710139,
0.0044612261,
0.0387442783,
-0.0350008309,
-0.0638123453,
-0.0195422564,
-0.0215774551,
0.0207222886,
0.0735133886,
0.0081842067,
-0.0306102075,
0.0405316949,
0.0049263127,
-0.0146959201,
-0.0192164779,
-0.0255022608,
0.0046861726,
-0.0437533185,
0.0462450162,
0.0733565316,
-0.0076807952,
0.0568770804,
-0.0022783109,
-0.0160598978,
-0.0531706922,
0.0070558335,
-0.0233493838,
-0.0420316458,
0.0038401147,
-0.0405536592,
-0.0235386677,
0.041928716,
0.0049277567,
-0.0163249895,
-0.0306237098,
0.0608121827,
-0.0367597863,
0.0025600852,
-0.0673665479,
-0.0289495699,
-0.0088279583,
-0.0024035585,
-0.0003478335,
-0.0705913752,
0.0853507444,
0.0240409169,
-0.0132773919,
-0.0202683453,
-0.007911887,
-0.0405832045,
-0.011691533,
-0.0144970622,
-0.0071668904,
-0.0379964896,
-0.010731061,
-0.0347703323,
-0.0061008874,
0.0562878214,
-0.0553717054,
0.0274014585,
-0.0732547864,
-0.0253730547,
0.00380613,
-0.0178617127,
-0.0569962002,
0.0022814709,
-0.0081356661,
-0.0217177942,
0.0735854879,
-0.022927681,
0.0122861089,
-0.026255317,
0.0346078202,
0.0008214,
-0.0372343622,
-0.0386365689,
0.0139840031,
-0.0036725439,
0.0269881077,
-0.0095564816,
0.0192579646,
-0.0675236285,
0.0567240641,
0.0439486131,
0.0538975932,
-0.0274532624,
0.0188573916,
-0.0000038052,
0.0172012132,
-0.0301874466,
-0.021301046,
0.0558863953,
-0.017091943,
-0.0527845882,
0.0247389749,
0.084366791,
0.027724551,
-0.0438006371,
-0.0091819661,
-0.030792892,
-0.0259171594,
-0.0286412835,
0.0270264745,
-0.117200762,
-0.0057404637,
-0.0217573624,
0.0247237403,
0.0111399069,
-0.0186673757,
-0.0070913807,
-0.0969797745,
0.0086803967,
0.0096447347,
-0.0290596448,
0.0232136231,
-0.0481172949,
-0.0226190649,
-0.031108018,
-0.0087944092,
0.0043270797,
-0.0438014604,
0.038283281,
0.052044265,
-0.047481183,
-0.0302762333,
-0.0213352591,
-0.0085958252,
0.0337748192,
-0.0138432328,
-0.0065530385,
-0.0217029806,
-0.0456709377,
0.0374484919,
0.0621706657,
0.0142144831,
-0.0137116695,
0.0476221181,
-0.0141820684,
0.0194263943,
-0.0457418561,
0.0400074758,
-0.0189141762,
-0.0121792937,
0.0720688254,
0.095596619,
0.0491706878,
-0.015883809,
-0.005959366,
0.0075977771,
0.0118921027,
0.0723854005,
0.0288142692,
-0.0471965261,
0.0253897551,
-0.0531408526,
-0.0040492271,
-0.0123729752,
-0.0538950898,
-0.0094515122,
0.0075986292,
0.0409037992,
-0.0501190722,
-0.0417802967,
0.0535768792,
-0.0095017022,
0.0072243041,
0.0195713844,
0.0171891823,
0.0341605395,
0.0235920101,
0.0143190417,
-0.0111176539,
0.0005647459,
-0.0513279028,
-0.0402510539,
-0.0221018344,
-0.074563615,
-0.0054887342,
-0.0043252795,
-0.0754681453,
-0.0509654693,
0.0205256082,
0.0465053022,
0.0183299333,
0.0077489442,
0.0400236957,
-0.0162972771,
0.0010179668,
0.0223499071,
-0.0108315805,
-0.0079966877,
-0.014034465,
0.044963114,
0.044776123,
-0.0100402301,
-0.0457698032,
-0.030009035,
0.002752807,
0.0184205603,
-0.0018255486,
-0.0149953198,
0.0318783671,
0.0260067899,
-0.0266415589,
-0.0074260836,
0.0151532432,
-0.0127780382,
0.0313381329,
-0.0342455059,
-0.0005261881,
-0.0252194498,
-0.0268988591,
0.0011442298,
-0.0164670311,
0.01830866,
0.0308398213,
-0.0304440074,
0.0427876934,
-0.0294821728,
0.0341737196,
-0.0293074958,
0.0160770603,
0.0401053727,
-0.0030442681,
0.0036590411,
0.0053941002,
-0.0064323358,
0.0358367562,
0.0012208084,
0.110560365,
0.0023855348,
-0.0129943546,
0.0527196042,
-0.0029065143,
0.0061670686,
-0.072247684,
-0.040589828,
0.0836434513,
0.0251236856,
0.0137278549,
0.0103940032,
-0.0694941878,
0.0038725403,
-0.0057465807,
0.0175533351,
-0.0207609311,
-0.041518908,
0.008722594,
0.0088029429,
0.0306510609,
-0.0185947903,
0.0564793013,
0.0054256329,
0.0237005595,
-0.0092810057,
-0.0090782652,
-0.0029244914,
-0.0007037377,
0.0415121466,
0.0105987117,
0.0241573993,
0.0300514046,
-0.0693989992,
-0.0344123915,
-0.0881928429,
0.019924406,
0.010221743,
-0.0154778548,
0.0461944081,
0.0363665894,
-0.0244183838,
-0.0542824194,
-0.0154432878,
0.0573875085,
-0.0565106459,
-0.0291147903,
-0.0035513099,
-6.111314315e-33,
-0.0160853136,
-0.0325010717,
0.0425560176,
0.097494781,
0.0248478241,
-0.0044112671,
-0.0192763526,
0.0571847633,
-0.0009244271,
0.0272441637,
0.0059594284,
-0.001508435,
-0.0097149871,
0.0008760926,
0.0091911322,
-0.0091494294,
-0.0050727325,
-0.021376865,
0.0005887056,
0.0334420428,
-0.0298452638,
-0.0011058705,
0.0723459274,
-0.0676500648,
0.0246310234,
-0.0612001456,
0.0201491248,
-0.019890517,
-0.0186955724,
0.0529190563,
-0.0188800823,
0.049964264,
-0.0004686427,
-0.024486145,
-0.0002674099,
-0.0323273242,
0.011928292,
-0.0576668307,
0.0108298957,
-0.0095474189,
-0.0484827086,
-0.0404239222,
-0.0124639748,
-0.0115012927,
-0.0645519868,
0.0244662017,
0.0424335189,
-0.0007250942,
0.0033042682,
0.035326127,
-0.0425052159,
-0.0009980815,
-0.0546616018,
-0.0384269245,
-0.001866166,
0.0134878093,
0.0084365578,
-0.0638432726,
-0.0142196864,
0.0616730489,
0.0674390048,
0.0195742305,
0.0457441919,
-0.0358930267,
-0.0140890013,
0.0018255697,
0.0612409301,
0.0139103355,
-0.0001779658,
-0.0565581396,
0.0084087001,
0.0098325051,
0.0699726194,
0.0179433506,
0.0311091803,
0.010261056,
-0.0226592347,
0.0332538337,
0.0583309233,
-0.016838396,
0.0099525936,
-0.0215100553,
-0.0838430822,
-0.037682157,
-0.0122124907,
0.0439587794,
-0.0248613115,
-0.0791913643,
0.0259699989,
-0.0128453858,
0.0352383517,
-0.023740273,
-0.001750638,
-0.0368708745,
-0.0157601871,
0.0072273263,
-0.025477441,
0.0343176685,
-0.0055278516,
-0.03537637,
-0.0870846063,
-0.0129415812,
0.0084375814,
-0.0110493461,
0.0238989592,
0.0235807635,
0.0131379217,
0.0394696482,
-0.0166242812,
-0.0110424925,
-0.0429256782,
-0.014175361,
0.0644156635,
-0.0804375857,
0.017079832,
0.0209422205,
-0.0121908169,
0.0621099733,
0.0142886192,
0.0350731686,
-0.0311331302,
-0.0321500972,
-0.0198849235,
-0.0423264392,
-0.0328745842,
0.0116567574,
-0.0103289429,
-0.0093439082,
-0.0088039599,
-0.0546329506,
-0.0191713329,
-0.0386790708,
2.9e-7,
0.0084964484,
0.070580177,
0.003387688,
0.0240255091,
-0.0062159309,
0.0235490352,
-0.0234600976,
-0.04164638,
0.0602985397,
0.0286216754,
-0.0017247638,
0.0338291675,
0.0344866402,
0.0400381833,
-0.0464695729,
-0.0257408842,
-0.0229547769,
-0.0124446424,
-0.0460313335,
0.0356021225,
0.0844595432,
-0.0190620869,
0.039700035,
0.0005800108,
-0.0410158522,
-0.0335781164,
0.0585821569,
-0.0397369042,
-0.0418567918,
0.0375048779,
0.0215272065,
0.0146981524,
0.0183598772,
-0.0008278889,
-0.0152736967,
-0.0039677578,
0.010254724,
0.0122665577,
0.0194895416,
0.0310418736,
0.024993049,
-0.0108940043,
0.0033643504,
-0.0130936019,
0.0110062538,
-0.0269772764,
0.0079689864,
0.0188267566,
-0.0208181366,
-0.0472675934,
0.0041657044,
-0.0445383452,
0.0227374621,
-0.0128616914,
-0.01260914,
-0.0022084564,
0.0125825079,
0.0030199536,
-0.026205685,
0.0335614309,
-0.0300711226,
-0.0519130602,
-0.0457004607,
-0.0030856424,
-0.0150612146,
-0.0208112523,
0.0362969115,
2.392249013e-34,
0.0194594115,
-0.030083362,
0.0519503355,
0.074385576,
0.0295778885,
0.0364037603,
0.0329625644,
0.0065343082,
0.0468568057,
-0.0330480337,
-0.0392450169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06868v1 | SwitchPrompt: Learning Domain-Specific Gated Soft Prompts for Classification in Low-Resource Domains | 2023-02-14T07:14:08 | 2023-02-14T07:14:08 | Koustava Goswami, Lukas Lange, Jun Araki, Heike Adel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompting pre-trained language models leads to promising results across
natural language processing tasks but is less effective when applied in
low-resource domains, due to the domain gap between the pre-training data and
the downstream task. In this work, we bridge this gap with a novel and
lightweight prompting methodology called SwitchPrompt for the adaptation of
language models trained on datasets from the general domain to diverse
low-resource domains. Using domain-specific keywords with a trainable gated
prompt, SwitchPrompt offers domain-oriented prompting, that is, effective
guidance on the target domains for general-domain language models. Our few-shot
experiments on three text classification benchmarks demonstrate the efficacy of
the general-domain pre-trained language models when used with SwitchPrompt.
They often even outperform their domain-specific counterparts trained with
baseline state-of-the-art prompting methods by up to 10.7% performance increase
in accuracy. This result indicates that SwitchPrompt effectively reduces the
need for domain-specific language model pre-training. | [
0.0620823912,
0.0311077852,
0.0143421851,
0.0094815223,
-0.0214389991,
0.0121671874,
0.0628753304,
0.0042137867,
0.0392893329,
-0.1017667875,
-0.0611355454,
-0.0545023903,
-0.027378764,
0.0372386798,
-0.0117890714,
-0.0437210985,
0.0715223625,
-0.0232871734,
0.0216793232,
0.0050816424,
-0.0102115432,
0.0096655777,
-0.009517855,
0.0294488482,
0.0134257376,
-0.0460243151,
0.0009238689,
0.0027697708,
-0.0180822294,
-0.0269853882,
0.0809128806,
0.1010251865,
0.0215105154,
0.0194082204,
0.0000020232,
-0.0913242325,
-0.025328096,
-0.0031131103,
-0.0483223572,
0.0078595737,
0.0415655598,
-0.018477194,
0.0191133395,
0.0102855563,
-0.0375148281,
-0.0635098964,
0.0368177444,
0.0710426718,
0.0453841835,
0.0752130672,
-0.0082015404,
-0.0155449985,
-0.0314177647,
-0.0602590255,
-0.0206857603,
-0.0499861613,
0.0194609985,
-0.0729891881,
0.0124755735,
0.0296020657,
-0.0057601999,
-0.0041422285,
-0.0241581816,
0.0224578232,
0.0045226305,
0.0201136917,
-0.0048538884,
-0.0335295647,
-0.0428704843,
0.0623717345,
-0.0206959974,
-0.022629315,
0.0143262763,
-0.0349261053,
0.0135639748,
0.0320181958,
0.0099169146,
-0.0092601124,
0.0198005028,
-0.0142439632,
0.0113003729,
0.0374404304,
0.0080070635,
0.0109605994,
-0.0208698921,
0.0447748154,
-0.0018093328,
-0.0408352353,
0.0343414955,
0.0300423801,
-0.0058917091,
-0.067557022,
-0.0374889001,
-0.0000437175,
-0.0408277437,
-0.0021004968,
-0.0676093251,
-0.0171878207,
0.0485497825,
0.0011473588,
0.0233739112,
-0.0190884247,
-0.0568408035,
0.051200442,
-0.0060113422,
-0.0109397732,
0.029368965,
-0.0037616526,
-0.0065221973,
0.0295336805,
-0.0224693362,
0.0195662212,
-0.0495379828,
0.0173519477,
-0.0119540412,
-0.0237492733,
-0.0194632374,
0.0154358801,
-0.0065636691,
-0.0206789561,
0.0208749995,
-0.0051348298,
-0.0301088188,
-0.0126369214,
-0.0286730137,
0.0196114033,
-0.0503328815,
0.047464408,
-0.000171599,
-0.0499262027,
-0.019774165,
0.0106791798,
0.0192939434,
-0.0348398089,
0.0294058435,
0.0671037808,
-0.0072786887,
-0.0794470087,
-0.0511786267,
0.0019897686,
0.0034239173,
-0.0377521813,
0.0061140675,
-0.0195154734,
-0.0007553556,
0.008652729,
0.0126285264,
-0.0381720811,
0.0060091363,
0.0100170989,
0.0017242825,
0.114210315,
-0.023708351,
-0.016048396,
0.0185092222,
-0.0051327595,
-0.0146674952,
0.0783617124,
-0.0466513522,
0.0189458784,
0.0568162054,
-0.0030862188,
0.016303584,
0.0012571206,
0.048601035,
0.0162920337,
0.0314117223,
0.0158959404,
0.0253436919,
0.0034535315,
0.0231819153,
0.0069559794,
0.0151249683,
0.0260831509,
0.0247845314,
0.0431980342,
0.0284063872,
-0.0013230591,
0.0489500649,
0.0205118861,
-0.0195292681,
-0.0039828047,
-0.0737017691,
-0.0083763842,
-0.0428944826,
-0.0091320919,
0.0378690772,
0.0225759987,
-0.0273067802,
-0.0308191404,
0.0077810972,
-0.0329350084,
0.0249308161,
0.0264444351,
0.0531070791,
0.0459997766,
-0.0267769005,
0.0311410818,
0.0449453592,
-0.0043430249,
-0.0167443138,
-0.0600270517,
0.0330261216,
0.0027201818,
0.001796638,
-0.0510485433,
-0.001290243,
-0.0385599211,
0.0796254575,
0.0397230983,
0.0872852877,
-0.0186634306,
-0.0080777556,
-0.0305554196,
-0.0460258015,
-0.002100358,
0.0481834598,
0.0018775015,
0.014642518,
0.0291463342,
0.0352728479,
-0.0148657672,
-0.0200271066,
0.029795792,
-0.0093096532,
-0.0524043515,
0.0448647477,
0.026098948,
0.0131802587,
0.0095921475,
-0.0120425886,
-0.0068225898,
0.0081791226,
-0.0036825563,
-0.0123924846,
-0.0635795966,
-0.0247322023,
-0.0161444023,
-0.0123615209,
0.0406533219,
0.0111436257,
0.0061565489,
-0.0318421312,
-0.0306939688,
-0.0129229566,
0.0155843683,
0.036733944,
-0.0543715991,
0.0142036788,
0.0007071037,
0.0244674943,
-0.0623521544,
0.0702833459,
0.0689951107,
0.0449403822,
-0.0105707794,
-0.0040474371,
0.017890716,
0.0087831281,
-0.0356729776,
-0.0220311284,
-0.0349478349,
0.0364926159,
0.0363093987,
0.0486530662,
-0.0399873778,
0.0149863185,
-0.0685987845,
-0.0286039002,
-0.030016195,
0.0002542871,
-0.0271174088,
0.0360203944,
-0.03536148,
-0.0446434692,
-0.0324248783,
-0.0094229821,
-0.0101356469,
0.0393776931,
0.013963161,
0.0043024737,
0.0309696924,
-0.0174308158,
0.0162324347,
0.0154985571,
0.0504924729,
0.0178982969,
-0.0284000207,
-0.0567045286,
0.0396201052,
0.0075251055,
0.0396953523,
0.0200315081,
0.014511236,
-0.0040621082,
-0.0099853268,
0.0343321897,
0.0480012819,
0.0135148345,
-0.0219670534,
0.0294116847,
0.0257119797,
-0.0773120224,
0.008384442,
-0.0386451259,
-0.0315980203,
-0.0093557257,
0.0240884461,
0.0544674024,
0.0728792176,
0.0046595484,
-0.036932867,
-0.0631146878,
0.0235992279,
-0.0140976245,
0.0110789547,
-0.0436912104,
0.0198607314,
0.0083687212,
0.0607462451,
0.0049047698,
-0.0574843027,
0.0717417002,
-0.0233162362,
0.005695791,
-0.0782214701,
-0.0401831083,
-0.0367133729,
0.0343394689,
-0.035964638,
0.0035689361,
0.1119763702,
-0.0295478739,
-0.0367406793,
0.013158787,
-0.0099873692,
-0.0103561487,
0.0630088001,
-0.0044960491,
0.0528838262,
-0.0140981404,
-0.0434797257,
-0.0539266951,
-0.0740661249,
-0.0217543542,
-0.028827047,
-0.0231357235,
-0.0053314888,
-0.022326624,
0.0077092834,
-0.0296977144,
0.0751620457,
-0.0146662481,
-0.0157986935,
0.0140894307,
0.0134650813,
0.0293535329,
0.0249817353,
-0.0371524245,
-0.0248959772,
0.0104691936,
0.0093630441,
0.009568383,
-0.016835345,
-0.0147521477,
-0.0147029422,
0.0747874603,
-0.0361663625,
-0.0222916268,
0.0197103284,
0.0435036123,
-0.0283577703,
-0.0352351405,
0.127797097,
0.0268917214,
-0.1146883145,
-0.0098657776,
-0.0067262254,
0.0075209443,
0.0409535505,
0.0301523563,
-0.0565311126,
-0.0761038437,
0.0110785486,
0.0303412043,
0.0199376326,
0.0041200579,
-0.0118332272,
-0.1056698114,
0.0171837285,
-0.0385019109,
-0.0114457598,
-0.0125148883,
-0.0657413974,
0.0322054513,
0.009180137,
-0.0325607546,
-0.0540711954,
-0.0208767354,
-0.0121202674,
0.0158410892,
0.0241896212,
-0.0946071297,
0.0212008972,
-0.0334632434,
0.0432680324,
0.0846586227,
-0.0154192997,
-0.0042314064,
-0.01575597,
0.051616732,
-0.0076059802,
0.0026205729,
-0.0482372493,
0.0205858666,
-0.0199911389,
-0.0068834322,
0.0170747079,
0.0143528813,
-0.033155553,
-0.0224220958,
0.036853753,
0.0771950111,
-0.0262262821,
-0.0339854769,
-0.0288982689,
-0.0156802777,
0.0651682094,
0.0716368183,
0.0054889368,
-0.0811673403,
0.0061894176,
-0.003618865,
-0.016658878,
-0.0002751568,
-0.0562658273,
-0.0183555428,
-0.0305747073,
-0.0274880938,
-0.0439794585,
-0.0435823165,
0.0179363899,
0.0327378213,
0.0349801369,
0.0068365862,
-0.0114252474,
0.0160236377,
-0.0358407497,
0.0596401095,
-0.0253835376,
0.0215929896,
-0.102669403,
-0.0209015738,
0.0541573092,
-0.0471408367,
-0.0421046726,
0.0062539061,
-0.0297800601,
-0.0416752398,
-0.0208367463,
0.0151327197,
0.0117007531,
0.0185662974,
-0.0305795539,
-0.0514990352,
0.0625639111,
0.0623463988,
-0.0490865558,
-0.0017863134,
0.0575566217,
-0.0434060171,
-0.0112041309,
0.0245048665,
-0.0513497777,
0.0518215746,
0.0271655507,
0.0132974871,
-0.0023019533,
-0.0469052009,
-0.0050815344,
-0.0096384333,
0.1103054434,
-0.0159924366,
-0.0319195725,
-0.0522256754,
0.0103138983,
0.0583333485,
-0.0434283912,
-0.0348327011,
-0.0029886137,
0.023247188,
-0.0304143261,
-0.0075444034,
0.0159932133,
-0.0316111036,
0.0301759448,
-0.0463770777,
0.0030062473,
0.0390393175,
0.0474082418,
0.0253197085,
0.0022951297,
-0.0070558405,
0.0177499615,
0.0220402535,
0.0135387201,
-0.0367102399,
0.053732153,
0.0265989564,
0.0240289997,
0.003792031,
0.0236754883,
-0.0394134745,
-0.0239615142,
-0.0295861941,
0.0111047542,
0.0391081199,
-0.0293986723,
-0.008446889,
-0.0082628494,
0.0007529171,
-0.0165349599,
0.029352231,
0.0253013149,
-0.0163491089,
0.0386351943,
0.0064078583,
-0.0384887494,
0.0182698239,
0.064255856,
-0.0062584919,
0.0244133566,
0.0207841936,
0.0036785982,
-0.0398687012,
-0.0214051455,
0.0429402739,
0.0146425348,
-0.021102082,
0.0375416838,
-0.0348729789,
-0.0497046746,
0.0102035608,
-0.0524975695,
-0.0313496031,
0.0231100842,
0.0436518192,
0.0821222812,
-0.0033189303,
0.0046740253,
-0.0508304313,
-0.0018707117,
0.0265060868,
-0.0377482362,
-0.021395579,
-6.368127504e-33,
-0.0040837713,
0.0163213238,
0.0044382024,
-0.0351316072,
0.0203404389,
0.0168248899,
0.0086761471,
-0.0307005309,
-0.0098987808,
0.0011613257,
-0.0275961384,
0.0041037207,
0.020966351,
0.0394336246,
-0.0033283446,
-0.0269469116,
0.0517542213,
0.0074523361,
-0.034221787,
0.0183514059,
-0.0173102953,
0.0505768768,
0.0318524912,
-0.0738916323,
0.0780995712,
0.0021679988,
-0.0006456882,
-0.0015679523,
0.0179053023,
0.0307476036,
-0.0277232155,
0.0508623905,
0.0244664978,
-0.0598396361,
0.0005590308,
0.0633468777,
-0.0879735276,
-0.0425302535,
0.0159071945,
-0.0121057006,
-0.0026912284,
-0.0098427851,
-0.0370056294,
-0.0039184052,
0.0397384912,
-0.0033536751,
0.0418008156,
-0.0097369803,
-0.0318073295,
-0.0538286977,
-0.0450910442,
0.0145303346,
0.0458868816,
-0.0187733192,
-0.003723372,
0.0653041974,
-0.0135017335,
0.0226896517,
-0.0282986853,
0.0305105727,
0.0457125306,
0.029162515,
0.0025599829,
0.0112903574,
-0.0513186082,
0.042606622,
-0.0149805406,
0.0112920608,
0.0232725181,
0.0118815387,
0.032852795,
0.0089577483,
-0.0199817121,
0.0440238342,
0.0482945368,
-0.0229186341,
-0.0539797805,
0.023194015,
0.0011201182,
-0.041650746,
0.0293924473,
-0.0249217898,
-0.0302742366,
-0.025221467,
-0.0399040729,
0.013780158,
-0.051444944,
-0.0304466989,
0.0287365299,
0.0514939874,
-0.0253532194,
0.0059857988,
0.0121348714,
-0.028724758,
-0.0433435515,
0.0074780285,
0.0577344522,
-0.012435412,
-0.0044491366,
-0.004945423,
-0.033075653,
-0.0366931707,
0.0371636599,
-0.0029975313,
-0.0003692941,
-0.002991036,
0.0349999517,
0.010581838,
-0.0916794017,
0.0007671019,
0.0131997839,
0.0302786268,
-0.010701336,
0.0806360245,
0.0147338537,
0.0232472569,
-0.0088674128,
0.0951945707,
0.0214972161,
-0.0590654984,
-0.0194859672,
-0.0040118531,
-0.0053623724,
0.043989528,
-0.0263685957,
-0.0193210226,
-0.0169491339,
0.0301664881,
0.0314690769,
-0.0499262214,
-0.0034779275,
-0.0066629457,
2.75e-7,
0.0092397463,
0.0229858011,
-0.0559591725,
0.0351208076,
-0.0271388255,
0.054636132,
0.0199628528,
0.0523436628,
0.0002113905,
0.0159844086,
0.0213485304,
0.001733316,
0.0237132534,
-0.0082960175,
-0.1148358509,
-0.0305976085,
-0.0103590507,
0.0155932512,
-0.0403734669,
-0.0046709282,
0.0654651672,
0.1118036658,
0.0087599391,
-0.0300696921,
0.0048466893,
-0.0280252993,
0.0287264697,
-0.0276068673,
-0.0013844453,
0.0238815639,
0.0240428764,
0.0035731527,
0.0038766887,
0.0428620465,
-0.0338009745,
0.0255214591,
-0.0130657339,
0.0513957068,
0.018030405,
-0.0065942234,
-0.0022838151,
0.0108055938,
0.0143699162,
0.0000451878,
0.0904029533,
-0.0780052543,
0.0100981602,
-0.0281898323,
0.001879886,
-0.0286954325,
0.0060867476,
-0.0473554656,
-0.0185529906,
0.0202302318,
0.0125786178,
0.004346671,
-0.0243365765,
-0.0972171426,
0.0019411657,
0.0132359331,
-0.002831158,
0.0036172147,
-0.0312556885,
0.007231181,
0.0391349308,
-0.0617795959,
0.0329612568,
2.586381216e-34,
0.0286273379,
-0.0072210133,
-0.0072559249,
0.0219508484,
-0.0141567485,
-0.0165917203,
-0.0004050134,
-0.0241779834,
0.0335366055,
-0.0496892333,
0.0026453296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06860v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06860v2 | BLIAM: Literature-based Data Synthesis for Synergistic Drug Combination Prediction | 2023-02-14T06:48:52 | 2023-02-16T05:26:25 | Cai Yang, Addie Woicik, Hoifung Poon, Sheng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models pre-trained on scientific literature corpora have
substantially advanced scientific discovery by offering high-quality feature
representations for downstream applications. However, these features are often
not interpretable, and thus can reveal limited insights to domain experts.
Instead of obtaining features from language models, we propose BLIAM, a
literature-based data synthesis approach to directly generate training data
points that are interpretable and model-agnostic to downstream applications.
The key idea of BLIAM is to create prompts using existing training data and
then use these prompts to synthesize new data points. BLIAM performs these two
steps iteratively as new data points will define more informative prompts and
new prompts will in turn synthesize more accurate data points. Notably,
literature-based data augmentation might introduce data leakage since labels of
test data points in downstream applications might have already been mentioned
in the language model corpus. To prevent such leakage, we introduce GDSC-combo,
a large-scale drug combination discovery dataset that was published after the
biomedical language model was trained. We found that BLIAM substantially
outperforms a non-augmented approach and manual prompting in this rigorous data
split setting. BLIAM can be further used to synthesize data points for novel
drugs and cell lines that were not even measured in biomedical experiments. In
addition to the promising prediction performance, the data points synthesized
by BLIAM are interpretable and model-agnostic, enabling in silico augmentation
for in vitro experiments. | [
0.0390258431,
0.0588362291,
-0.0078346357,
-0.001682564,
0.0157947224,
0.0145300357,
0.0533035509,
-0.0021118661,
0.0277291033,
-0.0044391835,
-0.0091973729,
-0.0166520327,
0.0170376282,
0.0898943096,
0.0246554315,
0.0017859237,
0.0412041284,
0.0175625011,
-0.0334710553,
-0.0280173812,
-0.0083965193,
0.0353292786,
0.0266615991,
0.0107351355,
0.0415849462,
-0.0113425888,
0.0297047962,
-0.0239750259,
-0.003585394,
-0.0476920642,
0.0072882185,
0.053223189,
0.012736639,
0.0601856597,
0.0000020052,
-0.0796897337,
-0.0303072203,
0.0474390835,
-0.0328383148,
-0.0413719676,
0.0650687739,
-0.0462873578,
0.0212789681,
-0.0235402305,
-0.0095796539,
-0.0130138882,
0.0484207831,
0.0266626198,
0.0031277232,
0.0235136393,
0.0028159204,
-0.0281408969,
0.0582340434,
-0.0284312125,
0.0606666766,
0.0227333624,
0.0544483215,
-0.0204966608,
0.0717039704,
0.0280372351,
0.0224668812,
0.0332682729,
-0.0167997479,
-0.011860013,
0.0579899661,
0.0358986929,
0.0136473263,
-0.0641480014,
-0.0102048358,
0.0513983928,
-0.0085753547,
-0.0363222063,
-0.0020483437,
-0.0213477369,
-0.0230634101,
0.0444356203,
-0.0248283539,
-0.021181548,
-0.0227899291,
0.0080679348,
0.0320432298,
-0.0231850557,
0.0392176583,
-0.0140252169,
0.0190566387,
0.0572158433,
-0.0056869038,
0.0088199433,
0.0117251473,
0.0153375864,
-0.0123458719,
-0.0274919309,
-0.0101489769,
-0.023781389,
-0.0281963795,
0.0231094789,
0.0006068944,
-0.0492400229,
0.0883048773,
-0.0526594035,
0.013429,
-0.0170458779,
-0.0246601589,
0.0183649678,
-0.0380747877,
-0.019085912,
-0.0216369405,
0.0041162339,
-0.0422855876,
0.0086788107,
-0.039236933,
-0.0095914071,
0.0191949885,
0.0183158778,
-0.0352385379,
0.0001481072,
-0.0590647869,
0.0472749397,
0.0043572481,
-0.0018935419,
0.0276640877,
0.0245381575,
-0.0424064323,
0.0113857398,
-0.0394203067,
-0.0312220789,
0.0340723284,
0.0357137732,
-0.0267739389,
-0.0425783396,
-0.0089505408,
-0.0351584703,
-0.0072533619,
-0.0262586102,
0.0306789093,
0.0835832283,
-0.0194649026,
-0.0205924846,
-0.0084766448,
-0.0596533865,
0.0030923011,
-0.0487489998,
0.0455832444,
-0.0552484728,
0.0788848549,
0.0109290993,
0.0034719391,
-0.0474630855,
-0.0120283104,
-0.0076838825,
-0.0601891689,
0.0864495486,
-0.0720998868,
-0.0462326594,
0.0140251853,
-0.0088078668,
-0.0054232068,
0.0446760058,
-0.0028498566,
0.0034945649,
0.0057573509,
0.0134425769,
-0.0020306481,
-0.0137174167,
0.0110090207,
-0.0188444648,
-0.0005006196,
0.0290119499,
0.0371856019,
0.0366044901,
-0.0344671831,
-0.0341856703,
-0.019663414,
-0.0116453385,
0.0361503214,
0.0448549539,
0.0430438258,
0.0382500663,
0.0205936544,
-0.0309412237,
-0.0070254789,
-0.0210808776,
-0.0212390199,
0.0033311085,
-0.0421498418,
0.0289688576,
0.041168347,
0.0494190603,
0.0044970782,
-0.0229587071,
0.0024016548,
-0.0351682678,
-0.0015373189,
-0.0161232557,
0.0441973396,
-0.0256546922,
-0.0379982032,
0.0321980454,
0.0784287527,
-0.0159851592,
-0.0149834743,
-0.0084777074,
-0.0006598937,
0.0608234666,
0.0673346445,
-0.0526415557,
-0.0023367309,
-0.0175405648,
-0.0348381102,
0.0121911597,
-0.0006933223,
-0.0097481199,
0.0217583645,
0.0088027688,
-0.0210803933,
-0.030382853,
0.0109368516,
0.0070893746,
-0.0169313196,
-0.0112292524,
-0.0178787429,
-0.0310511328,
-0.0306444075,
0.0331360474,
-0.0621924549,
-0.0119745675,
0.0486707687,
-0.0402999595,
0.0241788644,
0.0269197114,
-0.0100742225,
0.028001545,
0.0718648806,
-0.050224442,
-0.0221763197,
-0.0455899909,
0.0243967511,
-0.0624767616,
0.0016742049,
-0.0134131899,
0.0313405618,
-0.0405381992,
-0.0515819527,
-0.0254433434,
0.0221990384,
-0.0082147596,
0.0019657617,
-0.0116382847,
0.0307771787,
0.0010501902,
0.0332347825,
-0.0344159529,
0.0189401098,
-0.0021630395,
-0.0033661474,
0.0124739064,
-0.0266570523,
0.0399205685,
0.0100931497,
0.0114780348,
0.0362762325,
0.0197732598,
0.0046698395,
0.0031723692,
-0.0281294063,
-0.0192086529,
0.0061791292,
-0.0275643431,
0.0093779005,
0.0402449109,
0.0178298429,
-0.0106520597,
-0.009705456,
-0.0000962072,
-0.0267894492,
-0.0184782688,
-0.0320370086,
-0.0150716538,
0.0104536097,
0.0176083948,
0.0429838151,
-0.0270814281,
-0.0346208364,
-0.0506119803,
-0.0446226224,
0.0846518278,
0.0059004291,
-0.0359303504,
-0.0125154257,
-0.0241006576,
-0.0251872428,
0.0318577886,
-0.020522641,
0.0256334841,
0.0062487754,
0.0086519541,
-0.0196218062,
-0.006076654,
-0.0353067964,
-0.0308564026,
0.0829684883,
0.0225726906,
-0.0010493429,
0.0077810572,
-0.047675699,
-0.0098209316,
0.0327424817,
-0.0181567855,
-0.0187277328,
0.0376462489,
-0.0249612052,
-0.0273306165,
-0.0283524934,
0.0149830226,
0.0341963731,
-0.0514744483,
-0.035405729,
-0.0187694076,
-0.0059260824,
0.0351122767,
0.0001052863,
-0.0850240216,
0.1098262891,
-0.047937274,
0.0174231678,
-0.10196767,
0.0119141554,
-0.0097251572,
-0.0485539474,
0.0256397724,
0.0024500557,
0.0238611009,
0.0410183817,
0.0111677097,
0.0223938171,
0.0099935038,
-0.0250127781,
0.0764134675,
-0.0307634659,
0.0328654312,
0.032980524,
-0.0310479477,
-0.0461226963,
0.0117101427,
-0.0113124941,
0.010520515,
0.0603550002,
-0.0328059234,
-0.0263466612,
-0.0065220576,
-0.0085978042,
0.020887142,
0.0022054932,
0.0013582836,
-0.0095452918,
-0.0550889112,
0.0315022208,
-0.0602850281,
0.0152879767,
-0.010114246,
0.0406141318,
0.0049376525,
-0.0163742732,
-0.0046786079,
0.0050995476,
0.0408105217,
0.0049507217,
0.0032623457,
-0.0468302816,
0.0145991836,
-0.00470265,
-0.0495696627,
0.0020482375,
0.0753003657,
0.0294823386,
-0.0652510077,
-0.0046872464,
-0.004440323,
-0.0306726694,
-0.0178841241,
0.0668726116,
-0.0748876408,
-0.0204848889,
-0.0382433422,
0.008546643,
-0.0282666758,
-0.02098676,
-0.0445508361,
-0.0472170971,
0.0324779749,
0.0241259281,
-0.0356200561,
0.0121216178,
-0.1075592414,
-0.0341937952,
-0.0316983089,
-0.0239804313,
0.0023875358,
0.0066294889,
-0.0247686505,
-0.0131796254,
-0.0503341518,
-0.0966114178,
-0.0075963032,
0.0020691701,
0.015398738,
0.0423418544,
0.0097549418,
0.005295658,
0.0088645015,
-0.0288158897,
-0.0290049855,
0.0165844001,
-0.0220052451,
0.1004018113,
0.0353798494,
0.0221038852,
-0.0102391401,
0.0535405427,
-0.0244522914,
-0.0548270494,
-0.0656470582,
0.110431388,
-0.0365002193,
-0.0137855057,
-0.0723587647,
0.019927429,
0.0182168689,
0.0679895803,
-0.0152591076,
-0.0228742566,
-0.0029166278,
-0.0147029562,
-0.0211807732,
-0.0195702035,
0.0126610836,
0.0279492196,
-0.0584878586,
-0.039387349,
-0.0465580262,
-0.0485910773,
0.0582955182,
-0.0220708996,
0.0163965579,
0.0726124197,
-0.0318920687,
-0.0570600629,
-0.0320197083,
0.045181457,
0.0787021518,
0.0332167372,
-0.0273703896,
-0.045629371,
0.0292683113,
-0.0298703089,
-0.0166518223,
0.0484192185,
-0.0413202494,
-0.0961799026,
-0.0148676448,
0.0416675173,
0.0199273378,
0.0164299011,
-0.0068957033,
-0.0516780056,
0.1049975306,
0.0739885047,
0.0157173686,
-0.0429164693,
-0.0226180069,
-0.0150478156,
-0.0208811834,
-0.0191639047,
-0.0192793664,
0.0381813906,
0.0032038433,
-0.0422104001,
-0.0011213253,
0.0088025052,
0.055920478,
0.0137070054,
0.0621696077,
-0.0445905998,
0.0000908278,
-0.0420283824,
0.0102718892,
-0.0035038958,
0.028260326,
-0.0174113307,
0.0004601901,
0.0008380783,
-0.0374748632,
0.0140546253,
0.0109559689,
-0.0681816265,
-0.0103004733,
-0.0400740393,
-0.0022890007,
0.0100587485,
0.0370573923,
0.0773796812,
0.0071026189,
0.0017262304,
0.0083446829,
-0.0645382181,
0.0177490879,
-0.0202986505,
0.0296746716,
-0.0020111189,
0.0402320884,
-0.0367810801,
0.052979175,
-0.0286238343,
-0.0464876927,
-0.0775355771,
0.0146363229,
0.0298596546,
-0.0103396848,
0.0809800103,
-0.0180952735,
-0.0111203035,
-0.0656881332,
0.0208593179,
-0.0098616574,
0.0211825483,
0.0280079339,
0.0110169314,
-0.0482285656,
-0.0832590088,
0.104546763,
0.0114156576,
0.0304294173,
-0.0398657396,
-0.0327323377,
0.0044330084,
-0.0283487588,
0.0245553367,
0.0264462568,
-0.0563022047,
-0.0041683963,
-0.0405587815,
-0.0331920385,
0.0333059169,
0.017461475,
-0.0301600918,
0.0325890891,
0.0049229036,
0.0443313494,
0.0399678797,
-0.0349729992,
-0.0276281368,
-0.0025806492,
0.0094296783,
-0.065471828,
-0.0129796267,
-5.932415829e-33,
0.0506449193,
0.0111090196,
-0.0105442097,
-0.0296534803,
0.0452580191,
0.0089846142,
-0.0543036796,
-0.0166053977,
0.0329864025,
0.06540218,
0.0014897543,
-0.0121425157,
-0.0097701401,
-0.0131096896,
0.0159132015,
0.0049456074,
0.0239155497,
0.0143639222,
0.0103376368,
0.0267171524,
0.0680748075,
0.0703167021,
0.0455505177,
-0.0686669871,
0.0170605518,
0.0208687056,
0.0201540031,
-0.0001524048,
-0.031866312,
0.0774085894,
-0.0088454289,
0.0500599518,
-0.0028452729,
-0.0539677553,
-0.0485773571,
-0.0092255026,
-0.0171870906,
0.0011021754,
0.0328167006,
-0.0256407131,
-0.0356126539,
0.0056071114,
0.0356964096,
-0.006619825,
0.001883946,
-0.0182352196,
0.0407713391,
-0.046892792,
-0.0464523695,
-0.0387940668,
-0.0234665461,
0.0049160467,
0.0192784443,
0.0208626464,
0.0166299511,
0.0386211872,
0.0190607868,
0.0237488914,
-0.0198426414,
0.0471053496,
0.0503696017,
0.011359836,
0.0686234608,
0.0036250323,
0.0186789706,
0.0858906657,
-0.0144245969,
0.0033971614,
0.0360450856,
0.0036326761,
0.004684045,
0.0686350763,
0.0250194371,
0.0301698018,
0.0455526449,
0.0181240141,
-0.0735050291,
0.0471573062,
-0.0260671861,
-0.0219131801,
-0.0021059171,
0.0026497771,
0.0102610886,
-0.0448592491,
-0.0257911459,
0.0335150212,
-0.0321373343,
-0.0399395749,
-0.0051641311,
-0.0330727063,
-0.049011562,
0.0399930179,
0.0176319294,
-0.0380125716,
-0.041282706,
0.0262106694,
0.0030914943,
-0.0091467258,
0.0028376691,
-0.0079962742,
-0.030936731,
-0.0206964761,
0.0529515482,
-0.0388811305,
0.0131693343,
0.0105312737,
0.0332596675,
-0.0278531723,
-0.0074461061,
0.0236772709,
-0.0640303269,
0.0102964072,
0.0500672832,
0.0159537103,
0.0257104319,
0.0546352938,
0.0047686743,
0.0550138727,
0.0231725015,
-0.0129281823,
-0.0329059362,
0.0079212589,
0.0100728599,
0.0369576477,
-0.0493638217,
-0.0117803207,
-0.0188205093,
-0.0091687655,
0.0619634874,
-0.0491648279,
-0.0175198913,
0.0098052351,
2.92e-7,
0.0804288462,
0.0076249861,
-0.0246779919,
-0.0126881283,
0.0348248184,
0.0301444698,
-0.0064064646,
0.0422826931,
-0.0248939618,
-0.0293715056,
0.0407554694,
-0.020456586,
0.0604723804,
0.0166336522,
-0.0348123387,
-0.0298912283,
-0.052574534,
-0.044467736,
-0.0955164731,
-0.0342913643,
0.0112630781,
0.0634410679,
0.035084784,
-0.0299226213,
0.0513632968,
0.0043264451,
-0.0041786386,
-0.0456180237,
-0.0091706673,
0.0769610628,
0.012913119,
-0.0392435677,
0.0045604771,
0.0650703833,
-0.0458515026,
-0.0160276294,
-0.0416411348,
-0.0065736566,
-0.032932885,
0.0098123709,
0.0575149246,
-0.0172252338,
0.0034155692,
-0.0365709849,
0.0146491043,
-0.024113521,
-0.0337243043,
-0.0175485108,
-0.0033493873,
-0.0166887641,
0.0709056854,
-0.011237341,
0.0220802408,
0.0665535554,
-0.0063889809,
0.0214627646,
0.003882484,
-0.0423044711,
-0.0300529525,
0.0854420364,
-0.0670581609,
0.0059111416,
-0.024206847,
-0.0131635871,
0.0324436165,
-0.0703380108,
0.0257116891,
2.824064107e-34,
0.0505108275,
-0.0194859207,
0.0260388274,
0.02829496,
0.044994127,
-0.0324931219,
0.0373641066,
0.0253132433,
-0.0033956422,
-0.0928307772,
0.0042720656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07268v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07268v5 | AI Chat Assistants can Improve Conversations about Divisive Topics | 2023-02-14T06:42:09 | 2023-10-20T23:28:08 | Lisa P. Argyle, Ethan Busby, Joshua Gubler, Chris Bail, Thomas Howe, Christopher Rytting, David Wingate | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | A rapidly increasing amount of human conversation occurs online. But
divisiveness and conflict can fester in text-based interactions on social media
platforms, in messaging apps, and on other digital forums. Such toxicity
increases polarization and, importantly, corrodes the capacity of diverse
societies to develop efficient solutions to complex social problems that impact
everyone. Scholars and civil society groups promote interventions that can make
interpersonal conversations less divisive or more productive in offline
settings, but scaling these efforts to the amount of discourse that occurs
online is extremely challenging. We present results of a large-scale experiment
that demonstrates how online conversations about divisive topics can be
improved with artificial intelligence tools. Specifically, we employ a large
language model to make real-time, evidence-based recommendations intended to
improve participants' perception of feeling understood in conversations. We
find that these interventions improve the reported quality of the conversation,
reduce political divisiveness, and improve the tone, without systematically
changing the content of the conversation or moving people's policy attitudes.
These findings have important implications for future research on social media,
political deliberation, and the growing community of scholars interested in the
place of artificial intelligence within computational social science. | [
0.0866995603,
0.0491508357,
-0.0326351412,
0.0001290822,
-0.0385781191,
-0.0217436813,
0.042757839,
-0.0084982356,
0.0480280928,
-0.0253342427,
0.0384770297,
-0.0018380521,
0.0154047748,
0.0532418191,
-0.0211312976,
-0.0693028346,
-0.0143933771,
0.0144238854,
0.0904977992,
-0.0255443081,
0.0630609021,
0.0023492079,
-0.0150383683,
0.0481474176,
-0.0301181562,
0.003863228,
-0.0095773786,
0.0057069096,
0.0197072811,
0.0079304716,
0.0248899087,
0.0610330477,
-0.0142011335,
0.0223331563,
0.0000020021,
-0.0327637196,
0.0084631136,
-0.0273037106,
-0.0090342909,
-0.0392416418,
0.0874751508,
0.0180462431,
-0.0040614018,
0.040862184,
-0.0729840547,
0.0708705783,
0.0290562492,
0.0046193115,
0.0299446601,
0.0292167161,
-0.0121653546,
-0.0028938113,
0.0045235478,
0.0168230962,
-0.0250008721,
-0.0133815063,
0.0018658873,
-0.0155822504,
-0.0260227695,
0.0023705892,
-0.0004630661,
0.0022752613,
0.0120236464,
-0.0255355649,
0.0196157899,
0.0087266983,
-0.0564134382,
-0.0506081544,
0.0068564881,
0.0873025805,
0.0124322753,
-0.0148532111,
0.0399516188,
-0.0121983644,
0.0175217073,
-0.0096979067,
-0.0693774596,
0.0325700156,
-0.0232062433,
0.0012942124,
0.0145492693,
-0.0041534486,
0.0227729995,
0.0490916744,
0.006629569,
0.0629026666,
-0.0375804268,
-0.0355537385,
-0.0111058261,
0.0214646682,
0.0203429498,
-0.0246216096,
0.0288686361,
0.0023300808,
-0.0542301275,
0.0346301123,
-0.0115587525,
-0.0283492599,
0.0140456753,
-0.0741121694,
0.0167915877,
0.0029624011,
-0.0060844366,
0.0426275767,
0.0840743929,
-0.0387730449,
0.035738185,
0.0120730791,
0.0377641805,
-0.0182852577,
-0.0450474396,
0.0110014267,
-0.0166388433,
0.0067096553,
-0.0270114876,
0.0023318259,
0.0254579019,
-0.0039686947,
-0.0567587614,
-0.0007342341,
-0.0060595796,
-0.0033526465,
-0.0196736883,
0.0005042247,
-0.0354051329,
0.0409384705,
-0.0541663468,
0.0210247785,
-0.0221678149,
-0.0831770003,
0.0199109986,
0.0201792009,
0.014051768,
0.0237903912,
-0.0036831922,
0.0370535627,
-0.0004117231,
-0.0127121191,
0.0124471067,
-0.0140048908,
-0.0245024431,
-0.0209146272,
0.0086105326,
-0.0540884733,
0.0585584678,
0.0085529489,
-0.0097212614,
-0.0190256033,
0.0347232893,
0.0065987492,
-0.0486609861,
0.0513175465,
-0.0343090966,
0.035820093,
0.0791889727,
0.0553441234,
-0.0083822235,
0.0528984368,
-0.005391865,
0.0125818439,
0.0767553076,
0.0170439295,
0.0336682647,
0.0058809617,
0.0024771672,
-0.0106127383,
-0.009102229,
-0.0053069531,
-0.0696106702,
-0.011667449,
-0.0476171784,
0.0527022518,
-0.0025558388,
-0.0283145979,
0.077285476,
0.0849758163,
-0.0601522326,
0.0918209478,
-0.0095979664,
0.0592292361,
-0.0068252538,
0.0007462361,
-0.0243916679,
0.0250527263,
-0.0289146304,
-0.0620365404,
0.0668824166,
0.0306353346,
-0.0270874575,
-0.0587124713,
0.0236183554,
-0.0265537892,
0.0767425299,
0.0153489094,
0.0064452607,
-0.0210435688,
-0.0087462477,
-0.0141482428,
0.0512891263,
-0.0561577976,
-0.0335188657,
-0.0539735183,
0.0442101434,
0.0708979741,
0.0406071059,
-0.0256154817,
-0.0259830728,
-0.0371054597,
0.06027776,
0.0807057098,
0.0672366098,
-0.0148563171,
-0.0170933548,
-0.0403105915,
-0.006172902,
0.0333372839,
-0.0046029938,
0.0181120262,
0.0374913551,
0.008722676,
-0.0179142244,
0.0190668609,
-0.0374594033,
0.0051384652,
-0.0045606084,
0.051512789,
0.0041819327,
0.0328144655,
0.0374197662,
0.0243240967,
-0.0391253047,
-0.0382922664,
-0.0083356351,
0.005166484,
-0.0567140616,
0.01346297,
-0.0197281148,
0.0499415919,
0.0379118547,
-0.0676220506,
-0.0353691019,
0.0364789329,
-0.0059231208,
0.0276602395,
0.085934177,
-0.0159740746,
-0.0019149901,
0.0412889831,
-0.0214144848,
-0.0594844334,
-0.0027472067,
-0.016011253,
0.0146286674,
-0.00921233,
-0.0148244584,
-0.0227246508,
-0.0547669455,
0.0013487968,
0.0246235989,
-0.0074088965,
0.0105630374,
0.0147506865,
0.0183182396,
0.0498400517,
-0.0338927023,
-0.0543390438,
-0.039620921,
-0.0931339636,
-0.0290676188,
-0.0286523644,
-0.0052921176,
0.0252862778,
-0.0049227839,
0.0198795609,
0.0136801777,
-0.0464336053,
-0.0034416209,
0.0003320096,
0.0302260779,
0.0397850275,
-0.0194872525,
-0.0003718372,
-0.0438446887,
0.0128237559,
-0.019910641,
0.0147284064,
0.0371734835,
-0.0332158878,
0.0181071963,
-0.0020624381,
-0.071082972,
0.00482208,
-0.0385828391,
-0.0574797876,
0.0429777019,
0.0366130285,
0.042063497,
0.0810385421,
0.0781379119,
0.0749043971,
0.0211532842,
0.0343389772,
-0.0415629856,
-0.0225244537,
-0.0167376045,
0.0199286863,
-0.0288710054,
-0.0534642898,
-0.0081278142,
0.0370972641,
0.0172342006,
0.0214703362,
-0.0475367606,
0.0535089187,
-0.0335608572,
-0.0388447493,
-0.0283581447,
-0.0229698364,
0.015902061,
0.0339134112,
-0.0378322229,
-0.0235885363,
0.042912174,
0.0324772149,
0.0291542262,
-0.0409723334,
-0.0362443551,
-0.0036319953,
0.0368564762,
-0.0105114775,
0.0174257681,
-0.0342801921,
0.0102220019,
-0.0292483047,
-0.0522917211,
0.0386412144,
-0.0682162717,
0.0150140105,
-0.0665840805,
-0.0126270866,
0.0257232413,
-0.0301208925,
-0.0220819581,
-0.0469221212,
-0.0450140461,
-0.0082028816,
0.058676634,
-0.0182752851,
-0.0045598773,
0.003410531,
0.0487804338,
-0.0206503682,
0.011981505,
-0.0187840853,
0.0176178124,
-0.0230577327,
-0.0052596577,
0.0020352385,
0.0463598855,
-0.013636291,
0.0461434796,
0.0571213365,
-0.0232051741,
-0.0369317532,
-0.0114217307,
-0.0562666915,
-0.0031525923,
0.0151806781,
-0.0008360842,
-0.0008310457,
0.0533524193,
-0.0213182867,
-0.0128145032,
0.0734335631,
0.0472596064,
-0.06006236,
-0.006694952,
-0.0581453852,
-0.0221243799,
0.002961182,
-0.0061047422,
-0.0917142108,
0.0078197606,
0.0008419512,
0.004241854,
-0.0676688477,
-0.0480465889,
0.0184054095,
-0.0896047205,
0.0152577003,
0.0016543373,
0.0161387101,
-0.0161585733,
-0.0159545727,
0.0181489345,
-0.0104567353,
0.0011814187,
-0.0433024913,
0.062069118,
0.0098383427,
-0.0217290614,
-0.0601060502,
0.0029159954,
-0.0080647804,
-0.0315697864,
0.0726358816,
0.0445942022,
0.1079642102,
0.0140386401,
-0.0057096272,
0.0496467501,
0.0421748795,
-0.0263326187,
-0.0125452317,
0.0707567856,
0.006162555,
0.0118977679,
-0.0391769297,
0.0196457896,
0.0071598967,
-0.0275493991,
0.0179228466,
0.0034483927,
-0.0133135999,
-0.0196055137,
-0.0217425954,
0.0565384775,
0.0616597086,
0.0244400054,
0.0597998537,
-0.0548059121,
-0.0237940978,
-0.0602138937,
0.0282493755,
-0.0136470115,
-0.0503974967,
-0.031780459,
0.0054772883,
-0.0113519207,
-0.0396549143,
-0.0426899195,
0.0012175416,
-0.0235987343,
0.0121613843,
-0.0394983664,
0.0534410179,
0.0074800225,
0.0261219442,
0.0092047732,
-0.024015503,
0.018446127,
-0.0148660131,
-0.0407386124,
-0.0337046944,
-0.0187874492,
-0.0040934007,
0.0163328499,
-0.0095161814,
-0.0660470501,
0.0475060083,
0.0243961867,
0.0202197731,
0.0302887764,
-0.0264351778,
-0.0405869968,
-0.0106256343,
0.0472870506,
-0.0110673225,
-0.0217693951,
0.0258291159,
0.0527704507,
0.0383287035,
0.0291212592,
0.0301436521,
0.0250463523,
0.0215600058,
-0.0352163613,
-0.0811619386,
-0.0486000702,
-0.0068380777,
-0.0093083866,
0.0358292907,
0.0468113348,
-0.0436789766,
-0.0162935611,
-0.0147733958,
-0.0230005216,
-0.0240027383,
0.0160191245,
-0.0163457375,
-0.0322602242,
-0.0273699183,
-0.0078050904,
0.0466655865,
-0.0626367778,
0.0115652476,
-0.012929284,
0.0215516184,
-0.0015249441,
0.033030618,
0.0070581208,
-0.0184182432,
0.0062621548,
0.0509780124,
0.0202477835,
0.0249977577,
-0.0085433237,
0.0352512859,
-0.0141020995,
-0.0219083205,
0.0415047891,
0.0027729995,
-0.0263870265,
-0.0918430835,
0.0256313235,
0.0746396035,
0.0129689956,
0.0213733334,
0.0141233951,
0.0087579349,
-0.0133243548,
-0.0057240548,
0.0344715938,
-0.0149079347,
-0.0422647856,
-0.0168320015,
-0.0063813995,
-0.054009188,
0.0214259848,
0.0416187011,
-0.076384455,
0.005806582,
0.0519499034,
-0.0319730714,
-0.0069784769,
-0.0260122567,
0.008032172,
0.0069991695,
0.0062132059,
0.0220554844,
-0.0465645567,
-0.0071355067,
-0.0188771505,
-0.0058448478,
0.0329105593,
-0.0431679562,
-0.0148618361,
0.0455153845,
-0.0252823737,
0.0359478109,
-0.0574032404,
0.0503435396,
-0.0455665737,
-0.0428760834,
-0.0024272893,
-6.214416924e-33,
0.0215782579,
-0.0504716858,
-0.0151457042,
0.0061503025,
0.0016808913,
-0.0054141111,
-0.0218226332,
0.0553902909,
-0.0263019111,
0.0556069501,
-0.0126285395,
0.0672279298,
0.0013972027,
-0.0220700279,
-0.0139542148,
-0.0328163244,
0.0226447973,
-0.0302950442,
-0.010734776,
0.0448685065,
0.021368511,
-0.0169986598,
-0.0381113589,
-0.0741029978,
0.028935317,
0.0035336518,
0.023945123,
0.0130122332,
0.0271221753,
0.0046567959,
-0.0040679132,
0.046679154,
0.0435576513,
-0.01538222,
-0.0012798051,
0.0849690288,
-0.0138715114,
-0.0085260682,
0.0099023767,
-0.031567473,
-0.0349442326,
-0.0199601054,
0.0175465476,
0.0153303742,
-0.038548518,
0.017949013,
0.0318087563,
-0.0186978839,
0.0279957261,
-0.0216558743,
-0.0625796616,
0.0145520652,
-0.0579851903,
-0.0416189916,
-0.0091633601,
0.0367770493,
0.0385148339,
0.0275084767,
-0.074849695,
0.0574359111,
-0.0257057194,
-0.0256691575,
0.0135457832,
-0.0513677672,
-0.0019469034,
0.026995305,
0.017922217,
0.0838330686,
-0.0401567407,
-0.052468542,
-0.0017883849,
0.0103660803,
0.0595473982,
0.0637691468,
-0.002883144,
-0.1075467542,
-0.0656585544,
-0.0080661578,
0.0365669616,
-0.0139707886,
0.0377501175,
0.0001596217,
-0.0515979007,
-0.0164076593,
-0.0142015833,
-0.0937462524,
-0.0322817154,
-0.0383137912,
-0.0285113696,
-0.0036545526,
-0.0233563278,
-0.0347140282,
0.0114275133,
-0.0571073145,
0.0058197435,
0.0164300893,
0.0005031923,
0.0107338307,
0.0165828615,
-0.0133441016,
-0.0557754003,
-0.0079531558,
-0.0309811849,
0.0085212113,
0.033976566,
-0.0040726759,
0.0203525107,
-0.0353487581,
-0.0284765977,
-0.0094276564,
-0.0278209019,
0.0548705906,
-0.0019644736,
0.0438794717,
0.0102936802,
0.0433771797,
0.00363542,
0.0268586241,
0.0326074436,
0.0223353636,
-0.0099713849,
-0.0151192797,
-0.0560274571,
-0.0151960365,
-0.0694776326,
-0.0385878943,
-0.0588878132,
0.0080493623,
0.0086527057,
-0.0067800721,
-0.0296454877,
-0.0820505098,
2.599e-7,
0.0077075195,
0.0944568515,
-0.0047371159,
-0.011478777,
0.0282072127,
0.0381294787,
0.0340719633,
0.036724396,
-0.0193755887,
-0.0440664887,
0.006155543,
0.0453784429,
0.0680464134,
0.0368117318,
-0.0253089517,
-0.0525848754,
-0.0527502298,
-0.0041489634,
-0.0452431403,
0.0257454347,
0.0227346588,
0.0114576081,
0.0377320647,
0.0052760723,
-0.0441203378,
0.036422465,
0.0258330852,
-0.0444670655,
-0.0385776907,
0.0129915699,
0.0357578248,
-0.0354925171,
0.0085262535,
0.0278184656,
0.0038367824,
-0.0163438153,
-0.0225834008,
0.061022535,
0.0066226739,
-0.0146071492,
0.0211108383,
0.0353383832,
0.0158817321,
-0.0260067042,
0.0298271682,
-0.0772498176,
-0.0577216111,
-0.0850679055,
-0.0030839334,
-0.037160892,
0.0529808775,
0.0040881443,
-0.0288375951,
0.0103147998,
-0.0009789487,
0.0062865051,
0.0324789323,
-0.04304602,
-0.0045708418,
0.0070212223,
-0.0326961987,
-0.0671623573,
-0.0004498259,
0.0117078945,
0.0168979056,
0.028132204,
0.0602405295,
1.929171049e-34,
0.0258282833,
0.0105557945,
0.0078399768,
0.0020539558,
0.0654705167,
0.0209790356,
-0.0074185356,
-0.0274466742,
0.0280575622,
-0.0256197918,
0.0203603394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06829v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06829v2 | The Role of Semantic Parsing in Understanding Procedural Text | 2023-02-14T04:59:33 | 2023-05-18T02:41:52 | Hossein Rajaby Faghihi, Parisa Kordjamshidi, Choh Man Teng, James Allen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SC | In this paper, we investigate whether symbolic semantic representations,
extracted from deep semantic parsers, can help reasoning over the states of
involved entities in a procedural text. We consider a deep semantic
parser~(TRIPS) and semantic role labeling as two sources of semantic parsing
knowledge. First, we propose PROPOLIS, a symbolic parsing-based procedural
reasoning framework. Second, we integrate semantic parsing information into
state-of-the-art neural models to conduct procedural reasoning. Our experiments
indicate that explicitly incorporating such semantic knowledge improves
procedural understanding. This paper presents new metrics for evaluating
procedural reasoning tasks that clarify the challenges and identify differences
among neural, symbolic, and integrated models. | [
0.0252941139,
0.0120084491,
-0.0414416678,
0.0204289854,
-0.0194214154,
0.0370743833,
0.0044984738,
-0.0019152731,
-0.0623996742,
-0.018340148,
0.0148816938,
-0.0359881707,
-0.0139268711,
0.0302268565,
-0.0394444317,
-0.0672453642,
0.0491482057,
0.0032468708,
0.0514436625,
0.0460978374,
-0.0076326951,
0.0035342502,
-0.0105684465,
0.0388795324,
-0.0308120605,
-0.0455640405,
-0.0190818682,
-0.0323198214,
0.017476486,
-0.0394283161,
-0.0274668392,
0.0468609333,
0.0417215452,
0.0221649818,
0.0000018655,
-0.0304801855,
-0.0166173186,
-0.0049998038,
-0.0402392074,
-0.0432030708,
0.0015511324,
-0.0426042415,
-0.0037731517,
-0.0231830645,
-0.0347693563,
-0.0178688336,
0.0369562358,
0.0387297645,
0.045885507,
0.0489373803,
0.0048012873,
-0.0118898805,
-0.0056772255,
-0.0026741491,
0.0230125505,
-0.0079096071,
-0.0178679004,
0.0146567337,
-0.0043954602,
-0.0085651902,
-0.0033246966,
0.0265709702,
0.0783958435,
-0.0125088496,
0.0015578644,
0.0453647524,
0.005179008,
0.0172565896,
0.0369386561,
0.0654176623,
0.0091979494,
-0.0104920529,
-0.0001284401,
-0.0082849022,
0.009447475,
0.0210451894,
-0.0348145738,
0.0594454072,
-0.0246380847,
0.0179307666,
0.0317519121,
0.0576776117,
0.0100492071,
0.0081212185,
-0.0176171754,
0.0466344431,
-0.0447637439,
-0.0263531618,
0.009940722,
-0.0066213687,
-0.0037501135,
-0.0334016979,
0.0340642519,
0.0597766116,
-0.0208877809,
0.0287516396,
-0.0100630708,
-0.0033007518,
0.0076361913,
-0.0228520874,
0.0283301696,
0.0523749068,
-0.0334206037,
0.049509801,
-0.0328118391,
0.0235776827,
-0.0080074873,
0.0565480515,
-0.0370830819,
0.0121435933,
-0.0758862719,
-0.0461760722,
-0.0305704102,
0.049909953,
-0.0489655808,
-0.0269190706,
0.0502128229,
0.015465986,
-0.0140184676,
0.0375542454,
0.0055789459,
0.0425158776,
-0.0391943678,
-0.0070033437,
-0.0652864873,
-0.0075847162,
-0.0715965033,
-0.0188313536,
-0.0119095389,
0.0101181883,
-0.0241879337,
-0.0332303829,
0.0191988442,
-0.0121528674,
-0.0445678383,
0.0699646696,
0.0138831642,
0.019123666,
-0.0003227214,
-0.0668227151,
0.0402658619,
-0.0676923841,
0.0175646674,
-0.0380373672,
0.0233473685,
-0.0062700086,
-0.0154811582,
-0.0270271022,
0.014075432,
0.0258242283,
0.0323320068,
0.0484778322,
-0.0165519752,
-0.0170043465,
-0.0271509998,
0.024986038,
0.0099986624,
0.0509937368,
0.0346138477,
0.010166184,
-0.0203721114,
0.0102494536,
-0.0159457531,
-0.0221923366,
-0.0491400026,
-0.0546196923,
0.0134658851,
-0.0099427337,
0.0177088547,
0.0485062078,
0.0126580875,
0.0184397846,
-0.0289229713,
-0.0549272709,
-0.0054799444,
0.0267000441,
-0.0348241888,
-0.0127847604,
0.1073650271,
0.0002992725,
0.0296764988,
0.0135932071,
-0.0947182849,
0.0416226089,
0.0125353076,
-0.0030153147,
-0.1378889829,
-0.0267573446,
0.013737685,
-0.0622066744,
-0.0014366225,
0.0361829475,
-0.0092728157,
-0.0233870558,
0.0366984829,
0.0113451965,
-0.0242677629,
-0.0022184495,
0.0152514447,
-0.0010022946,
0.029472582,
0.0113347564,
0.0261871945,
0.1135829166,
0.021055568,
-0.0681567192,
-0.0372137874,
-0.0181841031,
0.006861825,
0.0299302712,
0.0019506835,
-0.0271568187,
0.0388875417,
-0.0345329493,
-0.0189035237,
-0.0581914186,
0.0245247055,
0.0156831592,
-0.0370265394,
-0.0336252898,
0.0193045978,
-0.0595066324,
-0.0248381216,
0.0544977114,
0.0173970778,
-0.0212063696,
-0.0180832148,
0.0301371869,
-0.0073389034,
0.033344686,
-0.0096432781,
0.021700751,
0.0002805945,
-0.0370265469,
0.0158936866,
0.0365110748,
-0.082026653,
-0.0639973506,
0.0140216853,
-0.0248113759,
-0.0801380128,
0.0032793025,
-0.0293432195,
-0.0348542631,
0.0090758046,
-0.0501709171,
0.0030056557,
-0.0068800226,
-0.0199807081,
0.0409171954,
-0.0225116722,
-0.0411224626,
0.0708440244,
-0.0055408981,
0.0255664159,
0.0494025387,
0.0339523964,
0.0315197073,
-0.032143265,
0.0037383975,
0.0192108061,
-0.0237543173,
-0.0588007607,
-0.0192473959,
0.0145103708,
-0.0514496565,
0.0149367834,
-0.0621945821,
0.0065047629,
-0.013665081,
0.0013140228,
0.0384067856,
-0.0544388443,
0.0176916588,
-0.0220352486,
-0.0373757817,
0.0331227593,
-0.009638126,
-0.0199943334,
0.0547530688,
0.0210319161,
-0.0498655662,
-0.0123320119,
-0.0014192578,
-0.0881263688,
0.029245859,
0.0549552366,
0.006720975,
-0.0340625271,
-0.0196001604,
0.0060531762,
0.0215533786,
0.0060235793,
-0.0148737514,
0.0580165796,
-0.0144278724,
-0.015817482,
0.0602499396,
-0.0328462236,
0.0613826141,
0.0329473205,
-0.0689080879,
-0.0729597211,
0.0244525392,
0.0021422959,
0.0629232079,
-0.0416084826,
-0.0370243751,
-0.007605928,
0.0929974318,
0.0091645876,
0.0270718727,
-0.0482810736,
0.0213114079,
-0.0185102336,
-0.0127310557,
-0.023178257,
-0.0011738284,
0.0035360854,
0.0327700078,
-0.0584474318,
-0.004367094,
0.0933867842,
-0.0106590297,
-0.0156024201,
-0.0373212285,
0.0000449532,
-0.0430796929,
0.1079045758,
0.0477463938,
0.0122634564,
0.0346412323,
-0.0514357463,
-0.0412466601,
0.043780338,
0.0096074957,
0.0159645695,
-0.0072786189,
-0.0532309785,
-0.0097378129,
0.0005049483,
-0.0237005185,
-0.0299364123,
0.0045621521,
-0.0096699987,
0.0571514592,
0.0033188344,
0.0092573455,
0.0038112886,
-0.0059454897,
-0.0172210503,
0.0314345881,
0.01021278,
-0.014831881,
-0.0627607778,
0.0089256391,
0.0090046553,
0.0426460244,
0.0082058897,
-0.0159358103,
0.0496444516,
0.0225106254,
0.0045875763,
-0.0430069789,
-0.0243368428,
0.0453775413,
-0.0059600379,
-0.0584833659,
-0.0118282409,
0.0308724586,
0.0277365427,
-0.1191143468,
-0.0297229271,
0.0860494077,
0.0486736745,
-0.0207074881,
0.0098586064,
-0.0258875396,
-0.0125363469,
0.0190591998,
0.017079005,
-0.0511968099,
-0.0265866928,
0.0339724496,
-0.0408971794,
0.004564146,
-0.0697696954,
0.0208001342,
-0.0834104791,
0.0540893115,
-0.039894592,
-0.0994982496,
-0.0185756553,
0.0045417058,
-0.0010998587,
0.0239644758,
-0.0114522614,
0.0161679927,
-0.0138908271,
0.0033971029,
0.027257245,
-0.033024624,
0.0122303031,
0.0075760437,
-0.0607755184,
0.0363625623,
0.0541353077,
0.0021861824,
-0.0107666142,
0.0064053037,
0.0040686685,
0.0037121172,
0.0287498627,
0.0044073262,
0.0450239256,
-0.0200518053,
-0.0137907723,
-0.0139490282,
0.0196133442,
-0.0559924766,
-0.0356723964,
-0.0148128923,
0.0391409807,
-0.0278478395,
-0.0048248689,
-0.0289578494,
0.0360911004,
-0.0219778009,
0.0471023135,
0.0395557806,
0.0265586078,
-0.0704432651,
-0.0735523328,
0.0323313773,
-0.0965969414,
0.0145883476,
0.0007689805,
0.0226841867,
0.0060136816,
-0.0624219552,
-0.0717424676,
0.0739716291,
0.0146211898,
0.0039121564,
-0.0083935084,
0.0134513555,
-0.0495867841,
-0.0634144396,
0.0401273929,
-0.0213039387,
0.0350643359,
0.0176795963,
-0.0553419366,
-0.0108779566,
-0.008406152,
-0.0341056697,
-0.0292249601,
-0.0478593111,
0.0122608347,
0.0250813924,
0.0520129316,
0.0172787327,
0.0124408724,
-0.0365171991,
0.0107326005,
-0.0016125857,
0.0100532724,
-0.0822878778,
-0.0430935957,
0.0101290867,
-0.0029445982,
0.0116307773,
0.0137145668,
-0.0000258002,
-0.0122306813,
0.007137639,
0.0504331216,
-0.0292931143,
0.0444858521,
0.0517287366,
-0.002991938,
0.0193757024,
0.040470276,
0.0121416254,
-0.0328081362,
0.0054790354,
-0.0292443205,
-0.0490312614,
-0.0321815088,
0.0269721076,
0.0144832218,
0.0197051037,
0.0142699713,
-0.0025858295,
0.0341281779,
0.0196402185,
0.0446734168,
-0.0188801419,
0.0545204207,
-0.0208424982,
-0.0007399739,
0.0093592582,
0.0013572712,
0.0329896882,
-0.024948841,
0.0577684157,
-0.0097302245,
0.0255852323,
0.0489981361,
0.0190167576,
-0.048618976,
-0.0127411382,
-0.0479385927,
-0.0682740137,
0.0165966377,
-0.0435361341,
0.0294369385,
-0.0153071061,
-0.0209503863,
-0.0339288712,
0.0453573838,
0.0554290712,
-0.002010362,
0.0235445295,
-0.0168445092,
0.0352101438,
0.0400530547,
0.0180558246,
-0.0489149727,
0.0606930666,
0.0017340322,
0.0592190027,
-0.0273838155,
0.0086488202,
-0.0280129164,
-0.0255030114,
0.0039316271,
0.0733303577,
-0.0129698338,
-0.0096854623,
-0.0473346896,
-0.0356042832,
-0.0187807716,
0.0251504779,
0.0249319132,
0.003689205,
0.0320890024,
0.0090146195,
0.0091615142,
-0.0571313314,
0.0020106209,
-0.0067405673,
0.0345904455,
-0.0078196498,
-0.051508192,
-5.735356691e-33,
-0.0664750487,
-0.0296464767,
0.0440424643,
0.0401429273,
-0.0332107507,
-0.0063939304,
-0.0674931854,
-0.0056836875,
0.0344047323,
0.0432526134,
0.013999762,
0.0208430793,
0.0165070314,
-0.0061921356,
0.0386501774,
-0.0508358441,
0.0290241875,
0.0091092987,
-0.0074932664,
-0.0295098927,
0.0624567829,
0.0245544631,
0.0513525791,
-0.0384887941,
0.0280906446,
0.0561605468,
-0.0002775714,
0.0352859758,
-0.0545005575,
0.0312990583,
-0.0008299539,
-0.0089986948,
0.0385387614,
-0.0101755224,
-0.0080822725,
0.0267638285,
-0.102634348,
-0.0555738173,
0.0207841862,
0.0274214149,
-0.0526768565,
-0.0753995106,
0.0284684449,
-0.0084836353,
0.0640483871,
-0.0078810295,
0.0445924178,
-0.0146478005,
0.0572963618,
-0.0512260273,
-0.0616480559,
0.0260369275,
-0.0439111292,
0.0180383921,
0.0053319647,
-0.0208119322,
0.0103193857,
-0.0220478475,
-0.0306814238,
-0.0345939882,
-0.0317712948,
0.0091524357,
-0.007487786,
0.0094281258,
-0.014279509,
0.0770652145,
0.0159255844,
0.0019239935,
-0.0832643285,
0.0744414404,
0.025533298,
0.0702949241,
0.0259329788,
-0.0101564424,
0.0568125062,
0.0609547943,
-0.0397067703,
0.0304857381,
0.0148916598,
0.1022234336,
-0.0024199516,
0.000251459,
-0.0179668106,
-0.0069806469,
-0.0437056012,
-0.0048425607,
-0.0302328821,
-0.027521912,
0.020618109,
-0.0219333544,
-0.0107432799,
0.0154523989,
0.011740434,
-0.0490613952,
0.0475422367,
0.0279600918,
0.0050029382,
0.0434342399,
0.0030971861,
0.0167640876,
-0.054919295,
-0.0660737604,
0.0305799842,
-0.0226581097,
0.0428448915,
0.0232217517,
0.0406514518,
0.0036844034,
-0.0072528454,
0.0172018576,
-0.046195507,
-0.0137695316,
0.0007363157,
0.0245979913,
0.0378963389,
0.0092625758,
-0.0409314632,
-0.0023003456,
-0.0053945282,
0.001451339,
-0.0321106501,
0.0446736887,
-0.0128701106,
0.0219392627,
0.007657018,
-0.0268254708,
-0.0440892465,
-0.0042934143,
0.0023420227,
-0.0116901016,
0.0243230294,
0.0358989537,
2.536e-7,
0.064049378,
0.0218114294,
0.0390485339,
0.0469934791,
-0.0036783956,
-0.0084487554,
-0.0098862946,
-0.0058635022,
-0.0034080918,
-0.0535903461,
0.0177618619,
0.03556519,
0.0007681749,
0.0463550799,
-0.0762298331,
-0.0153808389,
0.0054489593,
-0.0594491214,
-0.0260631554,
0.0131270904,
0.05953281,
0.0531600378,
0.0116911037,
0.0105756624,
0.0275109932,
-0.0231390391,
0.0283995755,
-0.0127252676,
0.0666576102,
0.0204566922,
-0.004207537,
-0.0346057229,
0.00135683,
0.0398783833,
0.0306282956,
0.0282520615,
0.0107578039,
0.048835367,
-0.0116316732,
0.0369220562,
-0.0152439391,
-0.0677309036,
0.0136449272,
-0.04144435,
0.0511611179,
-0.0716881528,
-0.0201707985,
0.0805500969,
-0.027134981,
-0.0295362566,
-0.0222514048,
0.0121350503,
-0.0262047518,
0.0294272341,
-0.0003205,
-0.0362792946,
-0.0002955094,
-0.0661407784,
-0.0318585858,
0.018219946,
-0.0185641106,
0.0160987787,
-0.0246928092,
-0.0073124045,
0.0117021874,
-0.0331368409,
-0.028567398,
2.103061561e-34,
0.0152899632,
0.014953156,
0.0158632435,
0.0507168695,
0.0502011999,
0.0013015562,
-0.0313813686,
0.0257834047,
-0.0000622133,
-0.0720438808,
-0.0048501953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06784v1 | The Stable Entropy Hypothesis and Entropy-Aware Decoding: An Analysis and Algorithm for Robust Natural Language Generation | 2023-02-14T02:02:33 | 2023-02-14T02:02:33 | Kushal Arora, Timothy J. O'Donnell, Doina Precup, Jason Weston, Jackie C. K. Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art language generation models can degenerate when applied to
open-ended generation problems such as text completion, story generation, or
dialog modeling. This degeneration usually shows up in the form of incoherence,
lack of vocabulary diversity, and self-repetition or copying from the context.
In this paper, we postulate that ``human-like'' generations usually lie in a
narrow and nearly flat entropy band, and violation of these entropy bounds
correlates with degenerate behavior. Our experiments show that this stable
narrow entropy zone exists across models, tasks, and domains and confirm the
hypothesis that violations of this zone correlate with degeneration. We then
use this insight to propose an entropy-aware decoding algorithm that respects
these entropy bounds resulting in less degenerate, more contextual, and
"human-like" language generation in open-ended text generation settings. | [
0.0178863127,
0.0534420051,
-0.0151235489,
-0.0144531913,
-0.0190687701,
-0.0075109894,
-0.0357707329,
0.0225420147,
-0.0266880374,
-0.0384939462,
0.0091583673,
-0.067762576,
0.0274396539,
0.0053022224,
0.0223990288,
-0.1024955213,
0.0204089582,
-0.0166508947,
-0.0109964311,
-0.0062118662,
-0.0335590616,
-0.0277852826,
0.0195851773,
0.0368120521,
0.0399982519,
-0.0025421961,
-0.0329690464,
0.027501883,
-0.0028283445,
0.0092356987,
-0.0028984146,
0.078073442,
0.0067124711,
0.0113117872,
0.000001863,
-0.0452017225,
0.0171930604,
-0.0247202683,
0.0314227566,
-0.0157763083,
0.0407323539,
-0.0013724478,
-0.0317785703,
0.0136981951,
-0.0126089528,
-0.0168232843,
0.0399897918,
0.0286588613,
0.0378328711,
0.0311162975,
0.0038058357,
-0.0157737806,
0.0315072909,
-0.0234450847,
0.0386631489,
-0.0219784733,
0.0025054133,
-0.0270716213,
0.0125147719,
-0.0382692255,
-0.0049340306,
0.0205656774,
0.0279615745,
0.0172606818,
0.0318868868,
0.0440753698,
0.0586373247,
-0.0263457708,
0.0164869986,
0.0362199657,
-0.0224603973,
-0.0298580416,
0.0005744222,
-0.0177893769,
-0.0018654006,
-0.0395373441,
-0.0089282589,
0.0722409561,
-0.0464400202,
0.024962442,
0.0192389116,
0.0230319761,
0.0048794113,
0.0007170698,
0.0074361572,
0.008188962,
0.0099329092,
-0.0499904566,
-0.0277217496,
0.0475901552,
-0.0290923622,
-0.050521113,
0.0006573465,
0.0324944668,
-0.0142085562,
0.0348500349,
-0.0858504698,
-0.0335073732,
0.0264140964,
-0.0264557414,
-0.0125454972,
0.0129771596,
0.0213783141,
-0.0329458639,
0.0286105741,
0.0120086707,
0.0068583894,
0.0001732902,
-0.0554289259,
0.019766923,
-0.0196345821,
-0.013816189,
-0.0544582531,
0.0392677747,
-0.0115926601,
-0.015490911,
-0.0438740179,
0.0380919352,
0.0055114715,
-0.0023944124,
0.0004831319,
0.0338278003,
-0.0467163809,
-0.004702107,
-0.0003757572,
-0.0209837575,
-0.0369481668,
-0.0140379146,
0.0598146021,
-0.0208315291,
-0.0026333923,
0.0063084112,
-0.0080903424,
-0.0094208205,
-0.0405700207,
0.0469205417,
-0.0282677021,
-0.0085004158,
-0.0833849609,
-0.0545674339,
-0.0270106159,
-0.0503847897,
-0.0134047726,
-0.027330935,
-0.019638421,
0.0112303207,
-0.0266969558,
-0.0648455694,
0.0025501025,
0.0226495638,
-0.0398316197,
0.0120144505,
-0.0777354091,
0.007949803,
0.0567913279,
0.0167038236,
0.0454894491,
0.0835099369,
0.0396215804,
0.0350057855,
0.0072038518,
0.0121999541,
0.0144322766,
0.0138724446,
0.0080101714,
0.0002203615,
-0.0135740517,
-0.0472240597,
-0.0372353718,
0.0499064289,
0.053153377,
0.0769175887,
-0.0318004489,
-0.0017716257,
0.081281282,
0.0270578749,
0.0186484959,
0.0413840301,
0.0477902405,
0.0008270429,
-0.0144109568,
0.0978433192,
-0.0181600489,
0.0085838428,
0.0139878532,
0.0346455052,
0.0497336425,
0.0087970551,
-0.0196029861,
-0.0521471202,
-0.0135336965,
-0.007384595,
-0.0028958353,
-0.04900131,
0.0236078519,
0.0419754945,
-0.0497857034,
0.0297637265,
0.0137107624,
-0.0677701011,
0.05308659,
0.0065842909,
0.0325751938,
0.105270043,
0.0645770058,
0.0143359434,
0.0030017088,
-0.0052102208,
-0.0128587,
0.0566119365,
0.0267708376,
0.017660344,
0.0168911088,
-0.0629645735,
-0.0081425449,
0.0267334431,
0.0182231162,
0.0217755232,
-0.0197493602,
-0.0013302841,
0.020104168,
0.0096285474,
-0.0083484706,
0.0188691132,
-0.0466057956,
0.0033082133,
0.0093293842,
-0.0047327871,
0.0237476546,
-0.0117783155,
-0.0580755845,
0.040960826,
-0.0049156984,
-0.0457099713,
-0.060488265,
0.0457176901,
-0.090825595,
-0.0163842309,
-0.0262915492,
-0.0186959691,
0.0272740424,
-0.0318213291,
0.0347461738,
-0.0289551467,
0.0444957353,
-0.0737646967,
0.0330586918,
-0.0690269545,
0.0273792613,
0.0070622102,
0.0164073929,
-0.0516264923,
0.0879811421,
-0.0270652194,
0.0071042199,
0.0033029614,
0.0051991856,
-0.0042107049,
-0.0503417812,
0.0152282994,
0.0240337215,
-0.0183629505,
0.0203303006,
0.0513352267,
0.0044449978,
-0.004798641,
-0.0359847732,
-0.0068234731,
-0.0019316796,
-0.016314717,
0.00446617,
0.0377211124,
-0.0075555025,
-0.0092466976,
0.0296469163,
-0.0263051298,
0.0491617322,
0.0432550944,
0.007158271,
0.0518102683,
0.0155331446,
-0.0107612275,
-0.0087025007,
0.0128158564,
0.0189059582,
0.0413210504,
0.0071687708,
0.025934346,
-0.0704650283,
0.124748975,
-0.0213809311,
0.0052385749,
0.0156183401,
-0.044884596,
0.021588549,
0.0057788529,
0.087225914,
0.0389120579,
0.0617753789,
0.0284575392,
0.044769913,
0.0139761968,
0.0058640791,
-0.0098100388,
-0.0417757742,
0.0250771772,
-0.0015370302,
-0.051381886,
0.0556419678,
0.0783922896,
0.0500782877,
0.012694275,
-0.0893190652,
-0.0032696815,
-0.0257030688,
-0.058375787,
-0.0169455912,
-0.0251426082,
-0.0349834971,
0.0408811159,
-0.0390772261,
-0.0489468127,
0.0634028763,
0.0031547749,
0.0155416261,
0.0062932642,
-0.0021651324,
-0.0092752567,
0.0369287767,
0.0135497302,
0.0393596962,
0.0807659402,
-0.0371908285,
-0.0653858781,
0.0035532471,
0.0309486054,
-0.0090578971,
0.0478160083,
-0.0390316471,
-0.0267651342,
-0.014907511,
-0.0568131357,
-0.0400749557,
-0.0241117869,
0.0344003625,
-0.0145903025,
0.0649946928,
-0.0195618365,
0.0210255757,
-0.002341582,
0.021266982,
0.0115944408,
-0.0144274533,
-0.0371057838,
-0.0122434832,
0.0435255952,
0.0642251298,
0.0141405668,
0.0256776512,
-0.0715266317,
0.0102985892,
0.0490541756,
0.0106551759,
0.0392260104,
-0.0017371586,
0.0030798013,
0.0422974341,
0.0174063407,
-0.0321682617,
0.0550182685,
0.0467264988,
-0.002283948,
-0.0278604049,
0.0872560441,
0.0048743249,
-0.0190001596,
0.0296845846,
-0.0392379463,
0.1149416566,
-0.0022534141,
-0.0033211415,
-0.063023895,
-0.0081050722,
0.002683409,
0.0674640387,
-0.0309494883,
-0.0495024882,
-0.0171997268,
-0.0749641508,
0.0328864194,
0.0340349562,
-0.0399404615,
-0.0359110236,
0.0225206278,
-0.0354382396,
0.0165845752,
0.019749891,
0.0307666361,
-0.0114166085,
0.0182784311,
0.0311505422,
-0.0355018862,
-0.051322341,
-0.0561108068,
-0.0461628288,
0.0621108636,
0.0526929013,
0.009822228,
0.0271116719,
0.0071835876,
-0.0109348232,
-0.0679476038,
0.0109622618,
-0.0080441898,
0.0327065438,
0.0127413142,
0.0100302426,
-0.0469337739,
0.0154717257,
-0.0244278871,
-0.0173838921,
-0.0252841897,
0.030003611,
-0.0275767278,
-0.0775512159,
-0.0089794192,
0.0282711834,
0.0361207724,
0.084752202,
0.0399825871,
-0.0393136479,
-0.0805461556,
-0.0456384011,
0.0652190074,
-0.0883215144,
0.0098165786,
0.011478425,
-0.0054171504,
-0.0773860738,
-0.1070009992,
-0.0379978083,
-0.0373536944,
0.0391704142,
0.0043371851,
0.0110930055,
0.0188517775,
-0.0389350578,
-0.0165785346,
-0.0672121421,
-0.001267454,
-0.0286774971,
-0.0627884939,
-0.034964595,
-0.021212494,
-0.0692800805,
0.009695421,
0.0651337951,
-0.0587088726,
-0.0819766894,
0.0410886668,
0.0160104949,
0.0273212474,
0.0262831766,
0.013321205,
-0.0638359636,
0.0473447852,
0.0493705124,
-0.0233476833,
0.0485281944,
0.0001077666,
0.0160672236,
0.0013835796,
0.0398485474,
-0.0136602288,
-0.0208706483,
-0.0025000535,
0.0390103944,
0.0128310723,
-0.0697400868,
0.0328324214,
-0.0094434461,
-0.0427597687,
-0.0646288171,
-0.0360438339,
-0.0236689597,
-0.0303731095,
-0.0009093095,
0.0088676233,
-0.0442512371,
-0.0105477385,
0.0304335188,
-0.0072459956,
0.0126800835,
0.0376825146,
-0.0241438709,
0.0519271567,
-0.0126675889,
-0.0401498713,
-0.0315416493,
0.06031546,
0.0329818912,
0.0045838528,
-0.0140249459,
0.0229331125,
-0.0620831773,
0.0309104919,
0.0016894444,
0.0563377179,
0.0160690676,
-0.0059946436,
0.0266230572,
0.0182131436,
-0.0827657655,
0.0126220351,
-0.0223394278,
-0.0131661454,
0.0633860752,
0.0636827871,
0.0622437224,
-0.0607529879,
0.0364685804,
-0.0111579448,
0.0334107541,
0.0039211926,
-0.0599869862,
-0.0147606386,
-0.0003956402,
-0.0332161747,
-0.0320640057,
0.079888612,
0.0285868607,
0.0252063479,
-0.0302392039,
0.0198274571,
-0.0283178091,
-0.0425447784,
0.0129663069,
0.001949554,
-0.0241316352,
0.0058063846,
-0.0588727705,
-0.0354017019,
-0.0067890487,
0.0078768441,
0.0396041535,
-0.0125529664,
0.0494120345,
0.0309393629,
-0.0439534858,
-0.0087677743,
-0.0347490609,
0.0266351253,
-0.0425268598,
0.0156138455,
-0.0284431539,
-6.164523066e-33,
-0.0419678539,
-0.0199238807,
0.0100913029,
-0.0247842893,
-0.0279060584,
-0.0754681379,
-0.0735940039,
0.0365639403,
0.022913035,
0.0074730925,
0.0158206988,
-0.015019699,
0.0047905347,
0.0244896207,
0.0004760724,
-0.0049837562,
0.056728933,
-0.0235786308,
-0.0412506536,
0.0381142534,
0.0701339692,
0.007330732,
0.0043880311,
-0.0180546697,
0.0045780409,
-0.0260796845,
-0.0199262835,
-0.0046550035,
0.0405074991,
-0.0068207295,
-0.0189497061,
0.0386951603,
0.0245920122,
-0.042707812,
-0.0339051373,
0.0023889123,
-0.0155596016,
-0.0193097908,
-0.0149299055,
-0.0039581205,
-0.0326844938,
-0.0575770773,
0.0331050865,
-0.0277970135,
-0.0412800312,
-0.0027818503,
0.0176976956,
0.0029569112,
-0.0346691459,
-0.0653971955,
-0.0669257864,
0.0142277302,
0.0020704756,
-0.0302100144,
-0.0637424886,
0.0280554611,
0.002173299,
-0.0401035845,
-0.0014682298,
0.0511275381,
0.0372899845,
0.0325634219,
0.0336405449,
-0.0086909076,
-0.0219316129,
0.0536046214,
0.0319361687,
0.0382157154,
-0.0437604785,
0.0035618003,
-0.0086649144,
0.0178722553,
-0.0042670653,
0.049814254,
0.0368033126,
-0.045043502,
-0.0072822357,
0.0684394762,
-0.0007981096,
-0.0074356254,
0.0130746895,
-0.0010580275,
-0.025154883,
-0.0310138557,
-0.0124390908,
-0.0239514355,
-0.0008974496,
-0.0312230103,
0.0277082771,
0.0163636226,
0.004317095,
-0.0628051311,
0.0340815857,
-0.0044554733,
0.0363770127,
0.0457368903,
-0.0400141366,
0.0221388005,
0.0014311324,
0.0045093214,
0.0010681449,
-0.0632533506,
0.0655543804,
0.0524240173,
-0.0157764126,
0.0280150063,
-0.0054767402,
0.0148712164,
-0.0367996655,
0.0223594196,
-0.0343450643,
0.0632206798,
0.0224904697,
-0.0398382023,
0.0352005959,
-0.0385607593,
-0.0280574374,
0.02521169,
-0.0008568887,
0.017196022,
-0.0280562304,
0.0549698956,
0.009525382,
0.0334108919,
0.0141279576,
-0.0009372216,
-0.0353877917,
-0.0097914785,
0.0485427678,
-0.0249928366,
-0.016862018,
-0.0077842097,
2.605e-7,
-0.0146000758,
0.0325309299,
0.0423459671,
0.0135159856,
0.0422420315,
0.0318546966,
-0.0122908931,
0.0364330858,
-0.0275485273,
-0.0082093282,
-0.0001888363,
-0.0223813895,
0.051516939,
0.0189717449,
-0.0702947825,
-0.0231207181,
-0.0457357839,
0.0366547257,
-0.0224906132,
-0.0015317529,
0.0801548362,
0.0250767078,
-0.0489298329,
-0.0147422077,
0.0578759462,
-0.0342740379,
0.0632050037,
-0.01089733,
0.0289938338,
0.0184037331,
0.0113902083,
-0.0234246571,
0.0197299849,
-0.0226530489,
-0.0284767151,
-0.0392859615,
-0.0210143924,
0.0272777509,
0.0350196995,
-0.0357431956,
0.0296711586,
0.0013420052,
0.0017071604,
-0.0606516376,
0.009572668,
-0.0240849163,
-0.0269130953,
-0.0016477408,
-0.0011139065,
0.0155643728,
-0.0265657678,
-0.032091897,
-0.009653545,
-0.0117752729,
0.0096628387,
0.0261330549,
0.0065980265,
-0.0326213613,
-0.0425535478,
-0.0130745731,
-0.0717564449,
-0.0214672405,
-0.0596323162,
0.036734093,
0.0343218409,
-0.0658868551,
-0.0031470617,
2.423895065e-34,
0.0248375125,
-0.0227508824,
0.0212254934,
-0.0112145729,
0.0162523687,
-0.002075823,
0.019968234,
0.0304226633,
0.0331295729,
-0.0152586661,
-0.0325930789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06761v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06761v3 | Language Model Analysis for Ontology Subsumption Inference | 2023-02-14T00:21:56 | 2023-05-08T17:21:40 | Yuan He, Jiaoyan Chen, Ernesto Jiménez-Ruiz, Hang Dong, Ian Horrocks | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | Investigating whether pre-trained language models (LMs) can function as
knowledge bases (KBs) has raised wide research interests recently. However,
existing works focus on simple, triple-based, relational KBs, but omit more
sophisticated, logic-based, conceptualised KBs such as OWL ontologies. To
investigate an LM's knowledge of ontologies, we propose OntoLAMA, a set of
inference-based probing tasks and datasets from ontology subsumption axioms
involving both atomic and complex concepts. We conduct extensive experiments on
ontologies of different domains and scales, and our results demonstrate that
LMs encode relatively less background knowledge of Subsumption Inference (SI)
than traditional Natural Language Inference (NLI) but can improve on SI
significantly when a small number of samples are given. We will open-source our
code and datasets. | [
0.0451129787,
0.0732857659,
-0.0099991811,
0.0794430003,
-0.0319908038,
0.0289037116,
0.001910541,
0.02450593,
0.0287970733,
-0.0507645793,
-0.0225047376,
-0.0195667259,
-0.007883315,
0.0269884039,
-0.0242136363,
-0.023712052,
0.0138676912,
0.0053551863,
-0.0301926993,
0.0120815299,
-0.0036911499,
0.033435829,
-0.0288150646,
0.0012629355,
-0.0061443364,
-0.0009663824,
-0.005039548,
-0.0374747217,
-0.0086612357,
-0.0030184269,
-0.0115538696,
0.0413162075,
0.0381992906,
0.0334994979,
0.0000018887,
-0.0685869381,
-0.0045792544,
-0.0174360666,
-0.0253243409,
0.0040407539,
0.0690281242,
-0.000375151,
0.0297467466,
-0.0065174811,
-0.0335679501,
-0.0550780632,
0.0499629155,
0.0470876321,
-0.0052965689,
0.0296284594,
-0.0229645669,
-0.0208298322,
-0.0007797442,
-0.0078942133,
0.0025090675,
-0.0175593477,
0.0354853794,
0.0388938785,
-0.0062603126,
0.0171544738,
0.0470503643,
0.0094125783,
-0.0116221923,
-0.0017065174,
-0.048237212,
0.0032682181,
-0.0069469139,
-0.0448387191,
0.0189542398,
0.0674991682,
0.0276635233,
-0.0200761463,
-0.0354204737,
-0.0390092619,
-0.039601624,
0.0275335591,
0.0333790071,
0.0412261486,
-0.013892022,
0.0070760753,
0.025701724,
0.0245256722,
0.0379360802,
0.0228958316,
-0.0433921069,
0.130674839,
-0.0209807772,
-0.0106255058,
0.010679869,
0.0047394498,
-0.0179714281,
-0.0307423417,
-0.0283053182,
0.0082476037,
0.0088814981,
0.0683530346,
-0.0208393503,
0.0412456915,
0.041198846,
-0.0074319844,
0.0307618044,
0.04932037,
-0.0461509004,
0.0503176711,
-0.0154272113,
0.0292918254,
-0.014404092,
-0.0123240389,
-0.048132319,
-0.0362907201,
-0.050208807,
0.0351519622,
-0.0064003402,
0.0515198745,
0.0200639274,
-0.0097693037,
-0.0759515539,
0.0213440005,
0.0034921016,
0.0024337168,
-0.0445418917,
-0.0130214645,
0.0132756401,
0.0000102305,
-0.054250069,
-0.001946496,
0.0023937649,
0.0608120784,
-0.0282300748,
-0.0538928956,
0.0150087904,
0.0224641562,
0.0060827686,
-0.0210292675,
0.0320970006,
0.0881973282,
0.0620377362,
-0.0336658508,
-0.0480551869,
-0.0632222444,
0.0278458707,
-0.0382668339,
0.0238554236,
-0.0518081039,
0.0434132554,
0.0263534728,
0.0181089714,
-0.0461789481,
-0.0179512389,
-0.0043720594,
-0.062212944,
0.0942193195,
-0.0628022328,
-0.0254511833,
-0.0410818532,
0.0000845285,
-0.0266724937,
0.0718685761,
-0.0139758633,
0.0374089219,
0.0417656638,
-0.0011473515,
-0.0523671843,
0.0129992086,
0.0390323736,
-0.0085796341,
-0.0229045749,
0.0444758497,
-0.030722918,
0.0175249521,
0.0374414138,
0.0144742401,
-0.0053078332,
0.013103852,
0.0181935485,
0.068461962,
-0.0002803089,
-0.0014426747,
0.0524413697,
0.0079941778,
0.0530042164,
0.0073878597,
-0.0477666482,
0.0032774089,
-0.0523681715,
0.0134719592,
0.0133244544,
-0.0134904869,
-0.0238538701,
-0.0526652671,
-0.0631966889,
-0.0375195034,
-0.0287467781,
0.0386328958,
0.0538465269,
0.0247134399,
0.0178843904,
0.0695333183,
0.0678946674,
-0.0615148172,
0.0188631006,
-0.0439514928,
0.042577967,
0.034149684,
0.0232741386,
-0.0774912834,
-0.006712412,
0.0261794664,
-0.0214449521,
0.0444886126,
0.0299085248,
-0.0223266724,
0.0034673302,
-0.0189276058,
-0.0215221569,
-0.0119302347,
0.0381166153,
-0.0073275673,
0.0542277619,
-0.0087025613,
0.0171370301,
-0.078357406,
0.0071112388,
0.017766783,
-0.0303676967,
0.0083341431,
-0.0274101011,
0.0254965536,
0.0351580158,
0.0007569991,
-0.0256648697,
0.0042789057,
0.0433502458,
0.0002802902,
-0.0305901859,
0.0142728686,
0.0100679863,
-0.0364896394,
0.0520896465,
0.029554721,
0.0019505451,
0.0336628444,
-0.0466047749,
0.0053243004,
0.0163193308,
0.0225468632,
0.0785787031,
-0.0780889168,
-0.0241369233,
-0.0162547976,
-0.0128065711,
0.01137939,
0.0482733585,
-0.0293386597,
0.051534269,
-0.0224608555,
-0.0550575033,
0.0317016207,
0.0146148,
-0.0233091023,
-0.0372245573,
-0.0214919131,
0.0254322812,
0.0278822612,
-0.0245176461,
-0.0188725479,
0.0379612334,
-0.0406595208,
-0.0105056595,
0.0224666987,
0.0365046635,
0.0142219942,
0.0186942779,
-0.0079374881,
-0.0162672233,
0.0175142009,
0.0045738881,
-0.0168219451,
0.0162094478,
0.0474801287,
-0.0393084958,
0.0454132855,
-0.0346199572,
-0.0024167481,
-0.0374546312,
0.0640096366,
-0.0094690006,
0.0600599535,
0.0164579861,
0.0066937506,
-0.0896247104,
0.0246057082,
0.001690843,
-0.0227080733,
-0.0173071902,
-0.0315977633,
-0.0427919924,
0.0083639817,
-0.0337305441,
0.0044561406,
0.0870240927,
0.0188046247,
-0.0056154863,
-0.0283510238,
0.0028248564,
-0.0115857786,
-0.0112315034,
-0.005176635,
-0.015559298,
0.1009384245,
-0.0303159114,
-0.0328834169,
-0.0312110577,
0.0257444922,
-0.0392771959,
0.0312878489,
-0.0433024727,
0.0322315209,
0.0277436189,
0.0873893872,
0.0037018084,
-0.0275575686,
0.0981052741,
-0.0211002063,
0.0315318964,
-0.0220648106,
0.0126729654,
-0.0437169187,
0.0797980055,
-0.0002344323,
0.0138074299,
0.0730297118,
0.0088934125,
0.0006716056,
-0.0347458832,
0.0161712952,
-0.01093888,
0.0001924147,
-0.0437702052,
0.0521992631,
0.0016070514,
0.0317905247,
-0.0429150574,
0.0337868966,
-0.0749845952,
0.0504775196,
-0.0201240946,
-0.0352331996,
-0.023646716,
-0.0237916466,
-0.0222213529,
0.0314449333,
0.0653957576,
-0.0079308096,
-0.0133134751,
0.0438157693,
0.0229923893,
-0.016199952,
0.0210011564,
0.0025857831,
-0.01554674,
0.0041541383,
0.0196356867,
-0.018398501,
-0.0220084414,
0.0097238654,
0.0239431374,
-0.0444665812,
0.0163243134,
0.0098421285,
-0.0306000374,
-0.0150547633,
0.0251232944,
0.1031775549,
0.0599488206,
0.0018570932,
0.0265683215,
0.0169042591,
-0.0258548558,
0.02833209,
-0.0154434014,
-0.1109987125,
-0.0473279096,
-0.0203563068,
-0.0363511555,
0.0199908726,
-0.0431457087,
-0.0144031066,
-0.0973764211,
0.0217225291,
-0.0386042111,
-0.0637719706,
0.0209869407,
-0.0316949859,
0.04143079,
-0.0505402535,
-0.019309802,
-0.0055563552,
-0.037041802,
-0.0334403738,
-0.0128150685,
-0.0219627712,
-0.0495451353,
0.0795612484,
-0.0370423496,
0.0148633383,
-0.0124570606,
0.0055922796,
-0.0034235325,
-0.0187437069,
-0.010107561,
-0.0470175222,
-0.0101563195,
0.0025413258,
0.0372414403,
-0.0101728356,
0.0030289614,
-0.0176431853,
-0.0082012769,
-0.0678793639,
-0.0053842315,
-0.0139548406,
0.0685500577,
-0.0205687061,
-0.037921045,
-0.0092735291,
0.0037518013,
-0.0048277252,
0.0826810375,
0.0030117179,
0.017411055,
0.0083284462,
0.0016334971,
-0.058242429,
-0.0066843727,
-0.0055737393,
0.0016656104,
-0.0103386836,
-0.0316985026,
-0.0372383855,
-0.0168360267,
0.0240477696,
-0.0506913252,
-0.0204962306,
-0.0166234039,
0.0351822786,
-0.007825952,
-0.0880533531,
0.05886041,
-0.0627614409,
0.0167351142,
0.0006471383,
-0.0079954611,
0.0757400095,
-0.0251722895,
-0.0222196281,
-0.0033136969,
-0.0673753247,
-0.0575391836,
-0.0063429815,
0.0336071886,
0.0205182303,
0.019883832,
-0.022576509,
-0.0315128155,
0.0708668008,
0.0001174016,
-0.0700948685,
-0.0132927056,
0.0452482216,
-0.0156321749,
0.0057821828,
0.0631866232,
-0.0430429205,
0.0195547994,
0.022948904,
-0.0024429937,
-0.0070125679,
-0.0379558951,
0.0455056541,
-0.0053143906,
0.0122083928,
0.0011463522,
-0.0092029786,
-0.0401413627,
0.0303981174,
-0.0035278855,
-0.0065232082,
-0.009141719,
-0.0139798112,
0.0077644396,
0.0041560386,
-0.0145593174,
-0.0011626409,
-0.0606933981,
0.0264742561,
0.0485588014,
0.023834506,
0.0403216332,
0.0017405089,
0.041583363,
-0.0342331603,
-0.0384016968,
-0.0191001594,
-0.0731864125,
0.01593633,
-0.029676469,
0.0091011515,
0.007249977,
0.0043566632,
-0.0475226156,
0.0286304541,
-0.0021259021,
-0.0629361868,
0.017264301,
0.0415541679,
0.0612652004,
-0.0586281195,
0.0088444203,
-0.0614468679,
0.0107796611,
-0.0112529006,
0.0364678726,
-0.0389623493,
-0.0335060544,
0.05202391,
0.0155401956,
-0.021152785,
0.047133524,
0.0726704299,
0.0248940587,
0.0502086394,
0.0151674971,
-0.0203134008,
-0.0350292139,
-0.0226829685,
0.0098426472,
0.0647683144,
-0.089171432,
0.0574653447,
-0.0328524001,
-0.1258226484,
0.0294437595,
0.0258488618,
-0.0374295674,
0.0194553714,
0.0199431404,
0.0538900793,
0.0332589895,
-0.0253398344,
-0.0287837759,
-0.0374454111,
-0.072663255,
0.0191902891,
-0.0086024953,
-5.946844655e-33,
-0.0149975354,
-0.0183545761,
-0.0016234141,
0.0181495417,
0.0031967282,
-0.0033876938,
-0.010427719,
-0.0013027167,
-0.0645964742,
0.0016044503,
0.0090814987,
0.0195530225,
0.0010644105,
0.008616345,
0.0035985736,
0.0168360583,
0.0008346307,
0.0117449583,
-0.0149177704,
-0.0157209169,
0.0511354841,
-0.0179296937,
0.0655035377,
-0.0126374327,
0.0523900464,
-0.0065104123,
0.0202064347,
0.0248856284,
-0.0429906771,
0.0611517727,
-0.0540314727,
0.0718497634,
0.0253288727,
0.0195721444,
0.0439180285,
-0.0273630898,
-0.0838523209,
-0.0376242921,
0.0389472954,
-0.0149021298,
-0.0244287141,
-0.0057575167,
0.0076648663,
0.0110147344,
0.0155851068,
-0.0238869824,
0.0399796665,
-0.0022742588,
0.0143346936,
-0.0212616771,
-0.0606725141,
0.0178648885,
0.0369412787,
-0.0305215754,
0.0280608479,
0.0195156317,
0.0143998768,
-0.0228415336,
-0.0213727467,
0.044284761,
0.0332751386,
-0.0154354461,
0.0324209146,
-0.0022062485,
-0.0052653709,
0.0321861021,
-0.0327455103,
0.0106860381,
0.0099828159,
0.0167688318,
0.0294563212,
0.03467777,
-0.0164091066,
-0.0010130334,
0.0204276536,
0.0183358975,
-0.0556690171,
0.0110668531,
0.0582376458,
0.0511399135,
0.0109482193,
0.0011681429,
-0.001099685,
-0.0128456177,
-0.0446571335,
0.0274809264,
-0.0608174615,
-0.0586405769,
-0.005379607,
-0.0208544601,
-0.014717727,
-0.0203490723,
-0.0149524193,
-0.0664398745,
-0.0227912962,
-0.0174602251,
0.0029894907,
-0.0178575888,
-0.0173747391,
0.0547619797,
-0.0837936401,
-0.0383430608,
0.0032747234,
-0.0628889203,
-0.0045119603,
0.0317090005,
0.0325113796,
0.0237333607,
-0.0165748317,
0.0051611373,
-0.009834324,
-0.0486212149,
-0.0084638735,
0.016316155,
0.0385345109,
0.0675801411,
-0.0039697145,
-0.0157553386,
0.0163828228,
-0.0149681764,
-0.0373629816,
0.0170416962,
0.0115017593,
0.0471001044,
-0.0175921228,
-0.0451746099,
-0.0620677806,
-0.054058589,
-0.0297075361,
-0.0031046267,
-0.0188613571,
-0.002344891,
2.615e-7,
0.0557200722,
0.0178981032,
0.0081784027,
0.0783197805,
-0.0133839324,
0.0078470604,
-0.0057063312,
0.0194924362,
0.0088673811,
-0.0474555939,
0.0105377296,
0.0069667688,
0.0098459935,
0.0190325715,
-0.0692185014,
0.0037773685,
0.0271591768,
-0.040836636,
-0.0108894156,
-0.0098950323,
0.0247103609,
0.0602971613,
0.0414127447,
-0.0108466586,
-0.0378258415,
-0.0143270968,
0.0659104064,
-0.0171901882,
-0.0225467719,
0.0105252378,
0.0305778403,
0.0749136582,
-0.0163492411,
0.0846335143,
0.0100481836,
0.0275470484,
-0.0163731035,
-0.006454255,
-0.0231371839,
-0.011597367,
-0.038807705,
-0.0714565516,
0.01311142,
-0.0629688948,
0.0855971053,
-0.0617071427,
-0.0204808451,
-0.0267823897,
-0.0015739762,
0.0007663386,
0.005461745,
-0.020126963,
-0.0216201413,
-0.0143374642,
0.0056041093,
0.0104395635,
-0.0223296955,
-0.0501821414,
-0.0139265889,
0.0639151931,
-0.0054930309,
-0.0486734323,
-0.0092441142,
-0.0558586605,
0.0417126603,
-0.0944778472,
0.0249369871,
1.844879265e-34,
0.052967649,
0.0239750557,
-0.023274757,
0.0087511791,
0.0335725956,
-0.0439301617,
0.0249018818,
-0.0079347556,
0.0039055685,
-0.0603314675,
0.0371068493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06729v1 | STREET: A Multi-Task Structured Reasoning and Explanation Benchmark | 2023-02-13T22:34:02 | 2023-02-13T22:34:02 | Danilo Ribeiro, Shen Wang, Xiaofei Ma, Henry Zhu, Rui Dong, Deguang Kong, Juliette Burger, Anjelica Ramos, William Wang, Zhiheng Huang, George Karypis, Bing Xiang, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.6 | We introduce STREET, a unified multi-task and multi-domain natural language
reasoning and explanation benchmark. Unlike most existing question-answering
(QA) datasets, we expect models to not only answer questions, but also produce
step-by-step structured explanations describing how premises in the question
are used to produce intermediate conclusions that can prove the correctness of
a certain answer. We perform extensive evaluation with popular language models
such as few-shot prompting GPT-3 and fine-tuned T5. We find that these models
still lag behind human performance when producing such structured reasoning
steps. We believe this work will provide a way for the community to better
train and test systems on multi-step reasoning and explanations in natural
language. | [
-0.0038412292,
-0.0041992543,
0.0122355605,
0.0458868928,
-0.0073360177,
0.0357406102,
0.0265476704,
-0.031612508,
-0.0116945403,
-0.0371638648,
-0.0135081122,
-0.0325282626,
-0.0193368625,
0.0331018791,
0.0171822421,
-0.0755567104,
0.0481668115,
-0.0537863523,
0.021346882,
0.011464145,
-0.0043908027,
0.0259989612,
-0.0235682018,
0.048387073,
0.0412010252,
-0.0468467586,
-0.0330923125,
0.0004989014,
-0.0068377522,
-0.0255822446,
0.028079642,
0.0417175218,
0.0596308112,
0.0141637707,
0.0000018425,
-0.0181376208,
0.0114509156,
0.0101550873,
-0.0640976354,
0.0049137948,
-0.0598737858,
0.0139696533,
0.0293605775,
0.0239243116,
-0.0331018195,
-0.0112624038,
0.021332927,
0.0705499798,
0.0949601606,
0.0814361423,
0.0142021403,
-0.0602726452,
-0.0270581581,
-0.0250278953,
0.0165707432,
-0.0642231405,
-0.0016138963,
0.0323996171,
0.0463446043,
0.0443188623,
0.0020410118,
-0.0198476668,
0.0570644103,
-0.006342099,
-0.0415210761,
0.0279115904,
-0.0188390836,
0.0005340049,
-0.0056927642,
0.0760025829,
0.0161575079,
-0.0096119465,
-0.0100239227,
0.0070516188,
-0.013311862,
-0.038755212,
-0.052241046,
0.0123677822,
-0.029874919,
-0.007573708,
-0.0103163999,
-0.0115863364,
0.0324162282,
0.0185014829,
0.0055146506,
0.0985731781,
-0.0111789815,
-0.0124474932,
0.0029956223,
0.0129807955,
-0.0461957641,
-0.0645778254,
-0.0226744711,
0.0609102175,
-0.0704645365,
-0.0031882646,
-0.0084105162,
-0.0050563929,
0.0062565608,
0.0117469579,
0.0375710391,
0.0422660857,
-0.0264946483,
0.0759819672,
-0.0187173057,
0.057995528,
-0.0388542749,
0.0145318378,
-0.0267103761,
-0.0302879699,
-0.0672638193,
-0.0188644901,
-0.0132759679,
0.0308997892,
-0.0682089254,
0.0005811286,
-0.0075821937,
0.0207019411,
-0.0097037386,
0.0052317926,
0.0265614241,
0.0292762145,
-0.016700929,
-0.0134983873,
-0.0429102294,
0.0124972509,
-0.1287049651,
0.0407629907,
0.0396900885,
-0.0220941324,
-0.0730419382,
0.009523619,
0.0022093735,
-0.0408539027,
0.0085509084,
0.0350369401,
-0.0184158571,
0.0038179564,
-0.046994146,
-0.0413022377,
-0.000399028,
-0.088376537,
0.0009678137,
-0.033975184,
0.0469792895,
0.0124593871,
-0.0443585925,
0.0098927189,
-0.0030499457,
0.0334125534,
-0.0232011769,
0.0700442791,
-0.0170236174,
-0.0093165999,
-0.0082096905,
0.0314787477,
-0.0427856781,
0.0708127096,
-0.0139747495,
-0.0007752026,
0.0098353485,
-0.023810301,
0.0075830608,
-0.0140457172,
0.0321419127,
0.0004187439,
0.0446421504,
0.0623437166,
-0.0102339992,
0.0365730822,
0.0221815221,
0.0159126129,
-0.0341113023,
-0.017647313,
0.0101475092,
0.0319909081,
0.0005180888,
-0.0305624101,
0.0529942364,
-0.001420098,
0.0114086354,
0.0190434195,
-0.0789633691,
0.0417523049,
-0.0139950905,
0.0111368168,
0.0192906335,
0.0107818041,
-0.0437957086,
-0.0257852878,
-0.0074958294,
0.0342538171,
-0.0089628976,
0.0051585785,
0.0415577516,
0.0264637396,
-0.0472583584,
0.0396130532,
0.011403542,
-0.005691485,
-0.0228678733,
-0.0520656146,
0.0626989529,
0.0531743094,
0.0297778957,
-0.03051221,
-0.0357428938,
-0.0352562033,
0.0704766437,
0.0116745876,
0.0144005427,
-0.0164784305,
0.0570610017,
-0.0265411511,
-0.0230113342,
-0.0707148239,
0.0105190016,
0.0106055085,
0.0370540954,
-0.0151679358,
0.0133126592,
-0.0540317744,
0.0571724474,
0.0254886188,
-0.0078816824,
-0.0179568008,
0.0094535518,
-0.0119558014,
-0.0076049683,
0.0283080433,
0.0109565193,
0.0055205123,
0.0042360253,
-0.0031048898,
-0.0219335984,
0.012297974,
-0.0327522755,
-0.061959248,
0.0012196995,
-0.0097578876,
-0.0414440744,
0.0150371166,
-0.0725540221,
-0.0438614115,
-0.0190342683,
0.004405465,
-0.0304891951,
-0.0351700261,
-0.0183985792,
0.0391075835,
0.0069940388,
-0.0017103364,
0.0986945257,
0.0128448866,
0.0238737147,
0.0165215824,
0.0007252416,
0.010522875,
-0.0346779115,
0.0411488861,
-0.0176912025,
-0.0246875715,
-0.0224959813,
-0.0099043529,
0.013040985,
-0.0660723075,
0.0211454015,
-0.0587800629,
0.0258869864,
-0.0428339764,
0.0359008461,
0.016739063,
0.0109921927,
0.0202866197,
-0.0488510989,
-0.0399484821,
-0.0140100913,
0.0061311806,
0.0274372362,
0.0411724299,
0.0079464307,
0.0009246856,
-0.0312787406,
0.0086055668,
-0.0362407379,
0.03767474,
-0.0121331671,
0.0093530566,
-0.0609980784,
-0.0130257672,
-0.0185418669,
0.030618947,
-0.0041313767,
-0.0050108535,
0.0576557703,
-0.0102702938,
0.0190553535,
0.0810431093,
-0.0269160178,
0.009412365,
0.0225620475,
0.008415645,
-0.0407428518,
0.0510479286,
-0.0163741671,
0.0191822089,
-0.0100122709,
0.0041027479,
-0.0147330454,
0.0684919953,
-0.0084628901,
0.0250254702,
-0.0606479272,
0.0198194813,
0.0223465152,
0.0049048685,
-0.0512586944,
-0.0103860795,
0.0035282956,
0.0522168465,
-0.0511404686,
-0.0080393124,
0.0741966441,
-0.0189074222,
-0.0300839152,
-0.0250733998,
0.0076065594,
-0.0415397286,
0.0746956095,
-0.0126452763,
-0.0040688827,
0.0290103946,
-0.0091074826,
-0.0167202763,
-0.0391919203,
0.0453560315,
0.0044867489,
0.0393899754,
-0.0514312983,
0.0019108903,
-0.0062180781,
-0.0601623356,
-0.0336164199,
-0.0391950235,
-0.0491397046,
0.012709816,
-0.0305732414,
-0.0290023331,
0.0032875983,
-0.0135332737,
0.0126878163,
0.0422375165,
-0.0091803716,
-0.0145541895,
-0.0163060538,
0.0418000594,
0.0403892435,
0.0565540679,
0.0206655469,
-0.0416223295,
0.0450547263,
0.0391984507,
0.0654176623,
0.0012764154,
-0.0410985649,
0.0213667452,
-0.0197523832,
-0.0248642173,
-0.0007229992,
0.0185884349,
0.0662458614,
-0.0653521493,
-0.0071728104,
0.1144734845,
0.0123306802,
0.0079393107,
-0.0007254118,
-0.0464591049,
0.0308868121,
0.0321014114,
0.0297967866,
-0.0989364535,
-0.0694257766,
0.0125347981,
0.012156954,
0.0381523073,
-0.0083365832,
0.0054975995,
-0.1030594483,
0.0370893739,
-0.0390853137,
-0.0227107778,
-0.0158031117,
-0.0511997603,
0.0124072526,
0.0124048293,
-0.0191039424,
0.0018757479,
0.0180966444,
-0.0000668066,
0.017388219,
0.0126451077,
-0.0216467567,
0.0926618576,
-0.0463909507,
0.0260363407,
0.0512132458,
0.0207245518,
0.005310609,
-0.0437831879,
-0.0062998673,
-0.0132628595,
0.017179383,
-0.0036543992,
0.05117663,
-0.0035240459,
-0.0212830063,
-0.037525896,
0.0508197471,
-0.06099803,
-0.0273667462,
0.0104099549,
0.0794082507,
-0.0246369988,
-0.0193251818,
-0.0030380243,
0.018644806,
0.0029387346,
0.0916761011,
0.0204847138,
0.0095796054,
-0.0706936866,
-0.0269082393,
-0.0414981805,
-0.0613858588,
-0.0232966468,
0.0153197059,
0.0307344962,
0.0341761746,
-0.0353130065,
-0.0452761203,
0.0616127886,
0.0489004254,
-0.0357999429,
0.0065451884,
-0.0391373932,
0.0158190355,
-0.0223660953,
0.0472961627,
-0.0069335182,
0.0349223875,
-0.0128733199,
0.0025616558,
-0.0061985236,
-0.0076536117,
-0.0224339366,
-0.0012402056,
-0.0871829316,
-0.0207171906,
-0.0350650735,
0.0428408682,
0.0227296557,
0.0426561423,
-0.0295811426,
-0.0234491769,
-0.0470823608,
-0.0362463035,
-0.0394079871,
-0.0044395542,
0.0561052077,
-0.0280183237,
0.0014541709,
0.0458403267,
-0.0478877649,
0.0201680567,
-0.0077245031,
0.0422458425,
-0.0179239716,
0.0004041277,
0.0179358665,
-0.0306276623,
0.0382864736,
0.0278258212,
-0.0006128151,
-0.0099735055,
0.0213048216,
-0.0297193695,
-0.0182345118,
-0.0217841789,
0.0231333524,
0.0029537708,
-0.0694758445,
0.0000494953,
0.0095732911,
-0.0074847541,
0.0160731934,
-0.0356098376,
-0.0203974936,
0.0561098233,
-0.0127328746,
-0.0038479152,
-0.0170743503,
-0.0259189233,
-0.0152454525,
0.0165735092,
0.0722924322,
-0.0103640882,
0.1034624875,
0.0431673191,
0.0109386509,
0.0011792651,
0.0014208766,
-0.0803568438,
-0.0620037243,
0.0183562785,
-0.0086690942,
0.0215789471,
0.0103481775,
0.0290873926,
0.0135188997,
-0.0192703083,
0.009499169,
0.0404717624,
0.0284442231,
-0.0087508326,
0.0453181714,
0.0373643488,
-0.0113422023,
-0.0037326438,
0.0702271238,
0.014844412,
0.038522508,
0.0390366577,
0.0116028925,
-0.0100320922,
-0.0412873365,
-0.0518124066,
0.0221953429,
0.0243134294,
0.008931919,
-0.038184341,
-0.0509168617,
-0.0283790044,
0.0176325291,
-0.0184292514,
0.0042206007,
0.0258166119,
0.0548437648,
0.0245109648,
-0.0638860688,
-0.0126286959,
-0.0064121522,
-0.0293227341,
-0.0013970278,
-0.0272601191,
-6.210520895e-33,
-0.0311602131,
-0.0305559207,
0.0499343202,
-0.0243248958,
-0.0004762502,
-0.021430498,
-0.0555560105,
-0.0114659751,
-0.0452718064,
0.04580741,
-0.0046867942,
0.0510926172,
0.013748941,
0.0253667496,
-0.0062210527,
-0.0420841649,
0.0243385471,
-0.00588925,
-0.0357173868,
0.0301774759,
0.0531318896,
-0.008474024,
0.0243227743,
-0.0130335027,
0.0322236083,
0.0059237732,
-0.0375393964,
0.0553468466,
-0.0501678996,
0.0483790375,
-0.0099519277,
0.0076103262,
0.0412270017,
-0.0692072287,
0.0186752621,
0.0542210713,
-0.1099327281,
-0.0369877592,
0.0472667366,
-0.0252736006,
-0.1020324677,
-0.0164861623,
-0.013164374,
0.0052028652,
0.057929758,
-0.0395789519,
-0.0011077727,
0.000599398,
0.0150810592,
-0.0235916693,
-0.0407103188,
-0.0003089053,
-0.0434897095,
-0.0607035197,
-0.0028796538,
0.0781566128,
-0.0056594964,
-0.0017334488,
-0.0311099794,
-0.0476885624,
-0.0260284115,
-0.0000433288,
0.0367298014,
0.0066135302,
-0.0311132725,
0.0543639623,
0.0108557763,
0.0176332537,
-0.0681217238,
0.0092193969,
-0.0421380624,
0.081100136,
0.0681887269,
0.015902549,
0.0117110508,
0.0523098223,
-0.0784557462,
0.0233358089,
-0.0029436608,
0.0515046678,
0.009682822,
-0.0113944793,
-0.0322189964,
-0.0207539555,
-0.0565941483,
0.0235400591,
-0.0480364598,
-0.0207953844,
0.0530813262,
-0.0057569728,
-0.0302682705,
-0.0133124385,
0.0114908619,
-0.0316094495,
0.0411905572,
0.0345662534,
-0.02381837,
-0.0127291325,
0.0136223268,
0.0560019054,
-0.0080597168,
0.0055393772,
0.0284584872,
0.0222740192,
0.0172881298,
0.0036300977,
0.0497086495,
-0.0159279369,
-0.0392224714,
-0.0014109431,
-0.057913512,
0.0292932987,
-0.0414031893,
0.0425482653,
0.0312433224,
0.0431707166,
-0.02566793,
0.0465066135,
-0.0041810768,
-0.0189377554,
-0.0173304994,
0.0350900516,
-0.0139253652,
0.0086179907,
0.0138988839,
0.0161718968,
-0.038796708,
-0.0206729788,
-0.0005400205,
-0.0355673879,
-0.0075504463,
0.0592470951,
2.364e-7,
0.0245795585,
0.0294868089,
0.0387955196,
0.0723308399,
0.0121842269,
0.0559186749,
0.0046565556,
0.0076863952,
0.0029646815,
-0.0677537397,
-0.0399748757,
0.0560916886,
0.038063433,
0.0346674845,
-0.0479256473,
0.0009324882,
-0.0455147699,
-0.0318933278,
-0.0394419171,
-0.0411901437,
0.052588962,
0.0630502626,
0.0001001704,
-0.005224057,
0.0265456922,
-0.0297996011,
0.0518123247,
0.0150632234,
0.0092057781,
-0.0102625005,
-0.0122111849,
0.0066818004,
0.0173212383,
0.026784962,
-0.0157382172,
-0.0162017699,
0.0027328604,
0.0725294128,
-0.0011834586,
-0.0342187993,
-0.0597924106,
-0.0486629494,
0.0406621434,
-0.0203637108,
0.1028643847,
-0.0406263024,
-0.0228276737,
-0.0034904168,
-0.0199459605,
-0.023353586,
-0.0103140995,
-0.006460832,
0.004996621,
0.0034671791,
0.0044057961,
-0.0364522934,
0.0151960151,
-0.0829002708,
-0.0322300345,
0.0193461757,
-0.0219577439,
0.0162817352,
-0.0185618345,
-0.0121507077,
0.045564197,
-0.0523675717,
-0.0394719057,
1.775897835e-34,
0.0108161718,
-0.0073534888,
0.0474689417,
0.0483885482,
0.0446427129,
0.0162254199,
-0.0529804565,
-0.0495992862,
0.0425571576,
-0.0686650723,
-0.0159554034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06716v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06716v3 | Machine Learning Model Attribution Challenge | 2023-02-13T22:05:27 | 2023-02-17T15:48:46 | Elizabeth Merkhofer, Deepesh Chaudhari, Hyrum S. Anderson, Keith Manville, Lily Wong, João Gante | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | We present the findings of the Machine Learning Model Attribution Challenge.
Fine-tuned machine learning models may derive from other trained models without
obvious attribution characteristics. In this challenge, participants identify
the publicly-available base models that underlie a set of anonymous, fine-tuned
large language models (LLMs) using only textual output of the models.
Contestants aim to correctly attribute the most fine-tuned models, with ties
broken in the favor of contestants whose solutions use fewer calls to the
fine-tuned models' API. The most successful approaches were manual, as
participants observed similarities between model outputs and developed
attribution heuristics based on public documentation of the base models, though
several teams also submitted automated, statistical solutions. | [
0.043800883,
0.0808738172,
-0.0304475706,
0.0601987503,
-0.0398845375,
0.0136203421,
0.0522673838,
-0.0208078008,
-0.0061933687,
-0.0522609502,
-0.008281921,
0.0317041315,
0.0060215592,
0.0297211986,
0.0584895723,
-0.0071166041,
-0.0105900168,
-0.0154959764,
-0.0060903188,
-0.0269526616,
-0.0203296337,
0.0084194746,
0.0399718508,
0.0489643738,
0.016899934,
-0.009561236,
0.0349409431,
-0.003647435,
0.0116705038,
0.0260108393,
0.0172837097,
0.0517508425,
-0.0060290126,
0.0842316523,
0.0000017385,
-0.0495818779,
-0.0114577487,
0.0322130397,
-0.0620298125,
0.0349028595,
0.0330335498,
0.0232756827,
0.0137012685,
0.0046724966,
-0.0128005994,
0.0212319288,
0.0939049646,
0.0045418246,
0.0459566824,
0.0498798229,
0.0082480609,
-0.0597219318,
0.0093516205,
-0.022993885,
-0.012842061,
-0.0229687151,
0.0166195761,
0.0366815664,
-0.0529727265,
-0.0040964726,
0.031284906,
0.0358504951,
0.0042577549,
0.0061988207,
0.013728681,
0.0138355326,
-0.0303659365,
0.0120872296,
0.0072573526,
0.0774299279,
0.0192470588,
-0.0828716382,
0.035014227,
-0.0043119797,
-0.0130299889,
0.0305274986,
-0.0401918031,
0.043628104,
0.0133443987,
0.006114013,
0.0097784,
-0.0131325154,
0.06111582,
0.0477175377,
0.0072518312,
0.0568875857,
-0.0041604978,
-0.0019632673,
-0.0175513439,
-0.0132161425,
-0.0435974561,
-0.0765030012,
-0.0000657147,
-0.0290547553,
0.0521466099,
0.0110575771,
-0.013671631,
-0.0135427294,
0.0255164914,
-0.0325153619,
0.0860242173,
-0.017736299,
0.0031868885,
0.0522046648,
-0.0354443453,
0.044714205,
-0.0308628604,
0.0350430943,
-0.0184274092,
-0.0059102736,
-0.0847255215,
-0.0086854417,
-0.0085425712,
0.0280833598,
0.000319355,
0.0051458334,
-0.0239666849,
0.0131889051,
-0.05434376,
-0.0147840306,
0.0144203641,
0.0241584443,
0.0004659324,
-0.0056273662,
0.0134570701,
0.0153447445,
-0.0292305853,
0.0224635173,
-0.0055242265,
-0.0721701533,
-0.0077155712,
0.0343973264,
-0.0270302556,
-0.0324185491,
0.0322494879,
0.082956396,
0.0242924187,
0.001829145,
-0.0103372568,
-0.0446553528,
0.0046844017,
-0.0599030666,
-0.0169452336,
-0.0845071152,
0.0014416713,
0.0285771284,
0.0094158929,
-0.0608908534,
-0.0219339598,
-0.0182413179,
-0.0539037399,
0.0486230142,
0.0033806087,
0.0311789662,
0.0518935658,
-0.0153575968,
-0.0304288752,
0.0211303476,
0.0406687595,
0.0452038012,
0.0468159877,
-0.0185853932,
0.0433206633,
0.0302736573,
0.0268596523,
0.0135915214,
-0.0378066637,
0.0257199612,
0.0019255758,
-0.0234513264,
-0.0167581942,
0.0486890301,
-0.0103102401,
-0.0139712337,
0.0799289793,
0.048538141,
-0.0305091999,
0.0464451686,
0.0381354913,
-0.0181778856,
0.034832783,
-0.034752477,
-0.0645535439,
-0.0075168489,
-0.0578421429,
-0.0244612806,
-0.0210932177,
0.0245439373,
-0.0081051774,
-0.0180220511,
-0.0074617271,
-0.0046203663,
-0.0119821671,
0.0399542823,
0.0515426658,
-0.0229942985,
-0.0229041912,
0.0371765494,
-0.0084103784,
-0.050858181,
-0.0218019132,
-0.0654032975,
0.0264199991,
0.0325484648,
0.0335923769,
-0.0095719639,
0.0220191199,
-0.031029202,
0.0277686398,
-0.0165612604,
0.0289439373,
-0.0218814667,
0.0157992095,
-0.0003586971,
-0.0322529674,
-0.028431382,
0.0414047539,
0.0436501056,
0.0103640603,
-0.0161059685,
0.0271814615,
-0.052232258,
-0.0633903071,
0.0345778614,
-0.0361823738,
-0.0166153572,
-0.0052767177,
-0.0040855492,
0.03846737,
0.0177074932,
-0.0404354818,
0.0194887761,
0.0212370418,
-0.0037572593,
0.0017571863,
0.0129793817,
0.0314546116,
0.0485000089,
0.0151909366,
-0.0416143239,
-0.0143529214,
0.06841328,
-0.0407485627,
-0.0133711947,
0.0265230779,
-0.035111174,
-0.0056588547,
-0.0209023729,
0.0290282611,
-0.0563918613,
-0.0059255972,
-0.0219507273,
0.0490563847,
0.0094732214,
0.0300132111,
0.0155543974,
-0.0358409658,
0.0258771628,
-0.0035916721,
-0.026920503,
0.0043261554,
-0.0476917736,
0.0291855466,
0.0333860591,
-0.0329069197,
-0.010091248,
-0.0149297426,
-0.0443677604,
0.0014670654,
0.0052196328,
0.0119385496,
0.0202263799,
-0.0257352833,
-0.0084350109,
-0.006147516,
-0.0196267553,
-0.0731138438,
-0.0079280315,
0.003116695,
0.0104938094,
-0.0204771496,
-0.0219875257,
-0.0484201424,
-0.0302526243,
-0.0269883852,
0.0905809477,
0.0274002291,
0.013639451,
-0.0564924553,
0.0022589427,
-0.0423231944,
0.0087465355,
-0.0196785014,
-0.0412550233,
-0.0026514232,
0.0120650586,
-0.0479780994,
0.1023210734,
-0.0068048597,
-0.0000844033,
0.038029559,
0.0134616802,
-0.0696733668,
-0.0240887813,
-0.0168588497,
-0.0523020849,
-0.0214223266,
-0.0703262836,
0.0040815505,
0.0518834107,
0.0103503512,
-0.0205249917,
-0.0160579272,
0.0679034814,
0.0067168018,
-0.0571087301,
-0.0186115466,
-0.0204675756,
0.0167883262,
0.0397881977,
-0.0248900522,
-0.0988453925,
0.0537699088,
-0.0554580837,
0.021738831,
0.0149497706,
-0.0314429626,
-0.0182738807,
0.0685940236,
-0.0172348451,
0.0239788275,
0.0485877134,
0.000527452,
-0.0268091708,
-0.0232152399,
0.0802633911,
-0.0231319796,
0.0221548118,
-0.0264913999,
0.0169993937,
0.0327395499,
-0.009516404,
-0.0011758569,
-0.0688324347,
-0.0519417226,
0.0321061164,
0.0184771698,
-0.0304788277,
-0.0454889685,
0.0076520429,
0.0388357341,
-0.0153260566,
0.0089440159,
0.0189089403,
-0.0085206022,
0.0095387269,
0.0295421276,
-0.0024372034,
0.0532589592,
-0.0337336175,
-0.0171761774,
0.0046896231,
0.0529867969,
0.040193323,
-0.0447897576,
-0.003443209,
0.0127402982,
-0.0471322313,
-0.0065668286,
0.0157127269,
0.0359629653,
-0.0460413061,
0.0271318052,
0.091011107,
0.0132960957,
-0.0338127539,
-0.0093591288,
-0.0001325501,
0.0158950072,
0.0174685735,
0.0119175408,
-0.0725483596,
-0.0126382224,
0.0254508406,
0.0346628129,
-0.0239414237,
-0.0252873395,
0.0093782507,
-0.0993933529,
0.0247820765,
0.0028795016,
-0.0212056972,
0.0047084554,
-0.0647329837,
-0.0173772313,
-0.0582681224,
-0.0315295421,
-0.0232309792,
0.0123161925,
0.0134313628,
0.0217161439,
-0.0100932335,
-0.0478900298,
0.0649358705,
-0.0553775504,
0.0535830371,
0.0930788741,
0.0237684399,
-0.0306144506,
-0.0107466122,
-0.0070308642,
-0.0126660625,
-0.0048268647,
-0.0023737787,
0.0538594499,
-0.0093403608,
-0.010240606,
-0.010783744,
0.0312348008,
-0.0463152193,
0.0227375813,
0.0074499622,
0.0518709458,
0.0254462473,
-0.0455775745,
-0.0023575139,
-0.0476800464,
-0.0021917298,
0.0954590067,
0.0297040641,
0.009195216,
-0.0513396002,
-0.0378525667,
0.0206788182,
0.0022726567,
-0.0421540141,
0.0216165874,
-0.0109146889,
-0.0713669807,
-0.0614754483,
-0.0063549606,
-0.0105975326,
-0.0018804048,
0.0433804952,
0.0104996897,
0.004355236,
-0.0118636461,
-0.0544104688,
0.03868974,
-0.0489074476,
0.0421648212,
-0.0555380397,
0.0018084887,
0.0342468023,
0.0009688218,
-0.0328520983,
0.0541239642,
-0.0705775097,
-0.0729197562,
-0.0105342697,
0.0660431087,
0.0326008573,
0.0332364403,
-0.0207995549,
-0.0750592947,
0.0418747738,
0.0183919501,
-0.0104161883,
0.0107431803,
0.0356588438,
-0.0601756312,
-0.013210847,
0.0336631164,
-0.0379412808,
0.0255958941,
0.0535288155,
-0.0111970399,
-0.020527726,
-0.0255042389,
0.0078784553,
0.0481259301,
0.0538300388,
-0.016675178,
-0.0576645546,
0.024286421,
-0.0016894146,
0.0014960299,
-0.0214011781,
-0.0407801047,
0.0219186377,
0.0346767455,
0.0071460954,
0.0129959891,
-0.0002845682,
0.0261452645,
0.0528460331,
-0.0486083701,
0.0393662117,
0.0003811985,
0.0440749228,
0.0019178123,
0.0098310281,
0.0108119976,
0.0125682056,
-0.008352533,
0.0437923595,
-0.0107262982,
0.0173094757,
0.0137896826,
0.0199897848,
-0.0032307436,
0.037806835,
-0.070887126,
-0.0588622242,
-0.0451050699,
-0.0024917379,
0.0580963828,
-0.0027271067,
0.0508653745,
0.0068719313,
-0.0095509198,
-0.0453656055,
0.0362888686,
0.0133516695,
-0.0035529968,
-0.0058458983,
0.0091684209,
-0.0521836951,
0.0071908915,
0.0660685971,
0.0464013331,
0.0555699952,
-0.013131042,
-0.0601794794,
0.0059546032,
-0.0382412672,
-0.0006407843,
-0.0271357931,
-0.0030956112,
-0.0110804252,
-0.0373645909,
-0.0936177224,
0.0136609161,
0.0042109415,
0.0294324756,
-0.0104706837,
0.0058460897,
0.0791851059,
-0.0142918481,
-0.0109240981,
-0.0574851073,
0.0089557534,
-0.0285947099,
-0.0249274131,
-0.0322243124,
-5.810649676e-33,
0.0060778637,
-0.0158135798,
-0.032940805,
-0.0261617973,
-0.00614245,
0.0181418117,
-0.0301218592,
-0.0076468689,
-0.0521405451,
0.0086478787,
-0.0061923158,
0.0090336762,
0.012893131,
-0.0167473666,
0.0441885404,
-0.0165413637,
0.01884133,
-0.0022318093,
-0.0375270247,
0.0260219704,
0.0141288079,
-0.0152486078,
0.0592029169,
-0.1048517376,
0.0651907176,
-0.0287872832,
-0.0353974886,
0.0156529173,
-0.016409697,
0.0747749656,
-0.0031684916,
-0.0043714009,
0.0249841139,
-0.0502126217,
0.002209363,
-0.0220777541,
-0.0437318683,
0.0221477877,
0.0345750488,
-0.0347315073,
0.014531265,
-0.053037867,
0.0843967274,
-0.0210447796,
0.0009774081,
-0.0159164984,
0.0688586831,
-0.0238099713,
0.0010961463,
-0.0162283555,
-0.0304955617,
0.0197522826,
-0.0516420119,
-0.0017066415,
0.0374737382,
0.0024952134,
0.003281493,
0.0259733442,
-0.0238113571,
0.003544033,
0.0192189533,
-0.0007548156,
0.1095891446,
0.022298133,
0.0409985147,
0.0364035703,
0.0375854596,
0.0137595898,
-0.0579178445,
-0.0255402159,
0.0070112534,
0.0984916091,
0.0974234194,
0.0746473745,
-0.0116411643,
-0.0109477937,
-0.0543195195,
0.0037446748,
0.0143772904,
-0.0162405521,
0.0187033191,
-0.016603088,
-0.05726799,
-0.0086749718,
-0.0898659602,
-0.0638768226,
-0.0335691236,
-0.0301607121,
0.015803555,
-0.037372876,
-0.0492118895,
0.0097358311,
0.0388727188,
-0.0840246752,
-0.0235130303,
0.003862174,
0.023459265,
0.0356931463,
0.023051599,
0.014749865,
-0.0378829353,
-0.0068583256,
-0.0213448387,
0.0254375637,
0.0623449646,
0.0110415751,
0.0294311754,
0.0194619261,
-0.0315855965,
0.0270936657,
-0.0324212313,
-0.0405328758,
0.0165066756,
0.0054231747,
0.0124459108,
0.0314383917,
0.0099666053,
-0.0028613745,
0.0156652052,
0.0281871222,
-0.0186205842,
0.0429762267,
-0.0089931572,
0.0174688827,
-0.0303617213,
-0.0382279605,
-0.029803412,
0.018075943,
0.0698137283,
0.0287538841,
-0.0165365823,
-0.0211927202,
2.348e-7,
0.0420444198,
0.0204003286,
-0.0031420963,
-0.0122383405,
0.0120318467,
0.0545257106,
-0.0131255426,
0.0150821051,
0.0138022481,
-0.0268969089,
-0.0088676019,
0.0106443195,
0.0858313814,
-0.01449739,
-0.0451252311,
0.0046076779,
-0.0827524289,
0.0140774893,
-0.0403089412,
0.0097495224,
-0.0202204771,
0.0753037259,
0.0624231994,
0.0094372937,
-0.0438140407,
-0.0580429733,
0.0293075927,
-0.0599998273,
0.0149585493,
0.0541619882,
0.0208635181,
-0.0113180038,
0.0069076228,
-0.0121725425,
-0.0116499783,
-0.0249532033,
0.0147408955,
0.0701087043,
0.0127643524,
0.0209806245,
-0.0559413582,
-0.0551469661,
0.0298492834,
-0.0763985068,
0.0377943218,
-0.0244898982,
-0.0520403124,
-0.0316214748,
-0.0412012264,
-0.0395392589,
0.0279531721,
0.001345369,
0.0393688492,
0.0348606296,
-0.0397607796,
-0.0207737014,
0.0038548298,
-0.0444170348,
-0.0398938023,
-0.0417315699,
-0.0312501937,
-0.048331596,
-0.0081362864,
-0.0466200262,
0.033231169,
-0.0547393076,
0.0419819318,
1.919215507e-34,
0.0155929849,
0.0017466889,
0.0076337294,
0.0275497455,
0.0673747286,
0.0007687086,
-0.0105648935,
0.0062015201,
-0.0147569776,
-0.0527584143,
0.0076163919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06706v1 | On the Planning Abilities of Large Language Models (A Critical Investigation with a Proposed Benchmark) | 2023-02-13T21:37:41 | 2023-02-13T21:37:41 | Karthik Valmeekam, Sarath Sreedharan, Matthew Marquez, Alberto Olmo, Subbarao Kambhampati | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Intrigued by the claims of emergent reasoning capabilities in LLMs trained on
general web corpora, in this paper, we set out to investigate their planning
capabilities. We aim to evaluate (1) how good LLMs are by themselves in
generating and validating simple plans in commonsense planning tasks (of the
type that humans are generally quite good at) and (2) how good LLMs are in
being a source of heuristic guidance for other agents--either AI planners or
human planners--in their planning tasks. To investigate these questions in a
systematic rather than anecdotal manner, we start by developing a benchmark
suite based on the kinds of domains employed in the International Planning
Competition. On this benchmark, we evaluate LLMs in three modes: autonomous,
heuristic and human-in-the-loop. Our results show that LLM's ability to
autonomously generate executable plans is quite meager, averaging only about 3%
success rate. The heuristic and human-in-the-loop modes show slightly more
promise. In addition to these results, we also make our benchmark and
evaluation tools available to support investigations by research community. | [
0.0699182227,
0.0210187398,
-0.0180778727,
0.019606173,
-0.0513707362,
-0.0070667276,
-0.0018371627,
0.0080703879,
0.0237153359,
-0.0336803123,
-0.0221689884,
-0.0298612006,
-0.0306609645,
0.0233384743,
-0.0024418551,
-0.0232299231,
-0.0209452398,
-0.0609511882,
-0.009579788,
-0.0105218738,
-0.0250271298,
-0.0199072678,
-0.0245239381,
0.0411637798,
0.0128291771,
0.0376394391,
-0.0340341851,
-0.0103148809,
-0.0229271892,
-0.0577643514,
-0.0203303881,
0.0234152712,
0.0130375689,
0.0079304976,
0.0000020905,
-0.0797394216,
-0.0020741734,
-0.0330291092,
-0.0391625315,
-0.0015932759,
-0.0144782225,
0.0002510989,
-0.0239503626,
0.0135776214,
-0.0722206011,
0.0709043741,
-0.0200724546,
0.0180164669,
0.0144428127,
0.077793926,
0.0082085915,
-0.0344355144,
0.0262174699,
0.010437862,
-0.0009954579,
-0.0627156645,
0.0001467974,
-0.0038185297,
0.0526057109,
0.0051977686,
-0.003384887,
-0.001704635,
0.0220733751,
-0.0147711746,
-0.038876947,
0.0304235872,
-0.0319134742,
-0.0374378115,
-0.0038905807,
0.0539769605,
0.0358620062,
-0.0061404752,
0.0462741069,
0.0001515079,
-0.0121682305,
0.0295875855,
-0.0442913249,
0.0748089105,
0.0011052175,
0.0276599899,
0.0429230928,
-0.0025722852,
0.035495352,
0.0310190786,
-0.0343785137,
0.1191880181,
-0.0209933501,
-0.0423717313,
0.0472681262,
-0.0083108656,
0.0083401222,
-0.0828670785,
0.007303603,
0.0728466809,
-0.0425842255,
0.0329516754,
-0.0046022339,
0.0519395806,
-0.0055855084,
-0.0304080248,
0.0754720718,
0.0508333445,
0.0334813744,
0.0405822061,
-0.0135101629,
0.0837260857,
-0.017433852,
0.0279939789,
-0.0229324456,
0.0337093063,
-0.0873911455,
0.0204050634,
-0.0112521993,
0.0474425554,
-0.0448827595,
-0.0173991583,
-0.0198471211,
0.0605147816,
0.0133422464,
0.0546356775,
0.0253955312,
-0.0061199795,
0.0193439163,
-0.0432386175,
-0.1282964796,
-0.0534519814,
-0.0646454692,
0.0096094804,
-0.0195216183,
-0.0471357927,
0.0213711094,
0.0262502003,
0.0029867329,
-0.0182753522,
0.0027163408,
0.0933506489,
0.006130985,
-0.0088609876,
-0.0785513967,
-0.0618888512,
-0.0028713858,
-0.0672294572,
0.0446930751,
-0.0665099025,
0.011585583,
0.0177327599,
-0.0376910605,
-0.0137345437,
0.0166192669,
0.0066299411,
-0.007596489,
0.040018972,
-0.0042555179,
0.0336547382,
0.0055972757,
0.0115889749,
0.0025358994,
0.0675287917,
0.0474875569,
0.0652142167,
-0.0006360727,
0.0669201091,
0.0175030883,
0.0508845411,
-0.0117965043,
-0.0008479593,
0.0118173966,
0.0135676218,
-0.0264209993,
0.0357546024,
-0.0132788476,
0.0471325144,
-0.0104162861,
-0.0083968621,
0.0446490645,
0.0905768052,
0.0016134398,
0.020200653,
0.0640794486,
0.0004490456,
0.0061224522,
0.0042408397,
-0.0357991122,
0.0034418686,
-0.0534598567,
0.0085506495,
-0.0323074684,
-0.0099779563,
-0.0142267477,
-0.0654724985,
-0.0430668965,
-0.0048994031,
0.0016611376,
-0.0343563296,
0.0320832282,
0.008715394,
-0.0513435043,
0.019426072,
-0.0144711593,
-0.0163897257,
0.0081341472,
-0.064180702,
0.0223598741,
0.0630283505,
0.0544133559,
-0.0193502028,
-0.0418990962,
0.0189450644,
0.0072184321,
0.0556683205,
0.0494190827,
-0.0197563171,
-0.0284854211,
-0.0416184217,
-0.0315090716,
-0.0471646599,
-0.0089309067,
0.0027108318,
0.0349217989,
-0.0041374266,
-0.006372313,
-0.0325933658,
-0.0063246051,
0.0385695994,
-0.0569876879,
-0.0041603073,
-0.0430769287,
0.0024015454,
0.0474537052,
0.0142191285,
-0.023864191,
0.0201415252,
0.0308190864,
-0.0342130922,
-0.0379040278,
-0.0060541374,
-0.0093408125,
0.0122848991,
0.0494982153,
-0.0329457931,
-0.0043485477,
-0.0057460973,
-0.0084449919,
-0.0280508716,
0.0237515606,
-0.0115617886,
0.0145247616,
-0.0263774637,
0.0289205555,
0.0173634216,
-0.0392922387,
-0.0127338404,
0.0857497826,
-0.0180177111,
-0.0254508182,
0.0330926701,
0.0198870245,
0.0150317345,
-0.0276100095,
-0.0083166538,
0.0165284574,
0.0089554284,
-0.0011975857,
0.0268480815,
0.0314205214,
-0.0539437197,
-0.0602946877,
-0.0924400985,
0.0093175303,
-0.0309222396,
0.0167322494,
0.0038710372,
-0.0449736416,
-0.00021985,
0.0137399277,
-0.0259900689,
0.027965799,
-0.0032041308,
0.0096370261,
0.0552336872,
0.0299701449,
-0.0197178628,
-0.0385279097,
0.020374991,
-0.0328077562,
-0.0266444366,
0.0556971692,
-0.0223222319,
-0.0166618582,
0.061466299,
-0.0339563414,
0.0140720019,
-0.0222172774,
-0.0554096289,
0.0169497877,
-0.0292068329,
0.0176354982,
0.0429435149,
0.0038438435,
0.0245590229,
0.063957192,
-0.0134468554,
-0.0606085546,
0.0463733301,
-0.0312366616,
-0.0144012729,
-0.1122506261,
-0.0369468518,
0.0211440343,
0.0689175874,
-0.0175659824,
0.0310533755,
-0.0411081463,
0.0080045024,
0.0166018344,
-0.0237657782,
-0.0145102497,
-0.0022824297,
-0.001917952,
0.1103584543,
0.0027457222,
-0.0347891413,
0.0375748761,
-0.0142771462,
0.001249298,
0.0203696899,
-0.0242785551,
-0.0556101836,
0.0537945591,
-0.0008543201,
0.0214367192,
-0.0051821773,
0.0093332054,
-0.0492676683,
-0.0071971659,
-0.0052194707,
-0.0051499391,
0.0362386703,
-0.0854096338,
0.0176133607,
-0.0025049734,
-0.0701373145,
-0.0386169851,
-0.0262328032,
-0.0511643738,
0.0208001286,
0.0148964608,
-0.0510327891,
-0.0248108953,
-0.0013373713,
0.0148380352,
0.0246006995,
0.0024867859,
-0.0250720903,
-0.010754209,
-0.0138627021,
0.0310894419,
0.0747215599,
0.016058052,
-0.0142818158,
0.0211052187,
0.0268295072,
0.0243750382,
-0.0126175806,
-0.0266106781,
0.0415059365,
0.0024527914,
-0.0234000981,
-0.0188659523,
0.0632587224,
0.0420524217,
-0.0167662967,
-0.0155691998,
0.1130820438,
0.0409613289,
0.0156206172,
0.0078553576,
-0.0383676998,
0.0202358253,
0.0496246256,
0.026157815,
-0.0236586295,
-0.0085518025,
0.008859951,
0.0056844419,
-0.025424296,
-0.0775958598,
-0.0027425084,
-0.1183880419,
0.0442219488,
-0.0154740475,
-0.015149558,
0.0436588675,
-0.0183374602,
-0.0226293411,
-0.0001763484,
-0.0272420309,
-0.0103032505,
0.0145084681,
-0.0037658671,
0.0119065912,
-0.0795659125,
-0.0306888893,
0.0036071681,
-0.0262682196,
0.0670703575,
0.0758956149,
0.0532079488,
-0.0068816552,
-0.0313767307,
0.0299465843,
0.0290925018,
0.0326090679,
-0.0246514976,
-0.0021564099,
0.0225648787,
0.0135851875,
0.0131849525,
0.0186079852,
-0.0652375072,
-0.0240320526,
0.0455670841,
0.0866964981,
-0.0294307433,
-0.0113768457,
-0.0178428516,
0.0093697915,
-0.0356957428,
0.0659014061,
0.0063537238,
-0.0298303925,
-0.0619206801,
-0.0458654426,
-0.0406086706,
-0.0724423975,
-0.0447445177,
0.0020313095,
0.0243143737,
0.0385447927,
-0.092866838,
-0.0581390783,
0.0165105164,
0.0586022213,
0.0224670805,
-0.0149602098,
0.0221501235,
0.0161482356,
-0.0029125393,
-0.0034793902,
-0.0339330658,
-0.0129266912,
-0.075048469,
-0.0106821395,
0.0163233634,
-0.0490383804,
-0.009789302,
0.0062260968,
-0.0610216148,
-0.0615704879,
0.0063239653,
0.0603107661,
0.0229299236,
-0.0176848602,
0.0004929375,
-0.0427789986,
0.0402714349,
-0.0057899132,
-0.0006921875,
0.0211237594,
0.0115570677,
0.071765624,
0.0201538447,
0.0468601845,
-0.0321839191,
0.0279630721,
0.0275387373,
0.0556641929,
-0.0321871117,
-0.0144171547,
0.0205833409,
0.0327560939,
-0.0063691866,
-0.0276041012,
-0.0121777346,
0.0106943408,
0.0028268914,
-0.002485232,
-0.0338111706,
-0.0377834514,
0.0032905403,
0.0369193591,
0.0021326172,
0.0275916979,
0.0460448936,
-0.0197838675,
0.008870895,
0.024149619,
0.0083607323,
0.031537503,
0.0077811428,
0.0287212748,
0.0147556551,
0.0109697226,
0.026778752,
0.0034964075,
0.0319033377,
0.0127254846,
0.0390170142,
-0.0009908869,
-0.0069535514,
-0.0037721391,
-0.0166432485,
-0.063821882,
-0.0833161473,
0.0566978566,
0.0508905873,
0.062937744,
0.0086776838,
-0.0066912211,
-0.0693658367,
0.0233114157,
0.0018133592,
-0.025873594,
-0.0029666931,
-0.015862504,
0.0607199259,
0.0135020083,
-0.0236052815,
-0.0085643679,
0.0460032225,
0.004102747,
0.0571964793,
0.0060350965,
-0.0084662363,
-0.0541829057,
-0.0577753522,
-0.0286809411,
0.0086145578,
-0.0097870622,
0.0023270345,
-0.0596205033,
-0.0393440872,
0.0096825231,
0.0265063234,
0.0098663205,
-0.003166568,
0.0354826488,
0.0463195406,
-0.0002846698,
-0.00059935,
-0.0230695419,
-0.0267348308,
-0.0232915767,
-0.0288374461,
-0.0251721069,
-6.13200375e-33,
-0.0115882149,
-0.0621800683,
0.0745196044,
-0.0541800447,
0.021825945,
-0.0317913406,
-0.0445505045,
0.0264525469,
-0.0211667661,
0.0019137696,
-0.0500851721,
0.0010250555,
0.017405659,
-0.0073748808,
0.0015222144,
-0.0200624652,
0.0114567261,
-0.026991738,
-0.0351124294,
-0.0409818701,
0.0030569362,
-0.0056226579,
-0.0008667961,
-0.0383011065,
-0.0167088937,
0.0018246623,
-0.0164349917,
0.0433130078,
0.004078703,
0.0762545913,
-0.0093993256,
-0.0047018169,
0.0435751192,
0.0147956945,
-0.0104180956,
0.0104216123,
-0.0188823249,
-0.0518349558,
0.0236900765,
-0.0300503634,
-0.030669976,
-0.0222768225,
0.0181843359,
-0.0003929851,
-0.0617387816,
0.0295323171,
0.0179728512,
-0.0028005303,
0.0192187484,
0.01938775,
-0.0405815095,
0.018020859,
-0.0231692847,
0.0082626138,
0.0543340594,
-0.0199104566,
0.0094969859,
-0.0050732326,
-0.0124111706,
0.0466860645,
-0.0198606122,
0.0114369299,
0.0774166286,
-0.0287217628,
-0.0210836362,
0.0724467635,
0.02553376,
0.0405597202,
-0.0261861254,
-0.0193691272,
0.0033102224,
0.0911475718,
-0.0079579949,
0.0285079516,
-0.0187868159,
0.0510179549,
-0.0331992842,
0.0333300307,
0.0040422659,
0.027141558,
0.0416139998,
0.0192546863,
-0.0388616063,
-0.0038588915,
-0.0415553078,
0.0146664688,
-0.0198968779,
-0.0185961034,
0.0393474437,
0.0203960482,
0.0493531562,
-0.0111383488,
-0.0003927589,
-0.0472252518,
-0.0056177354,
0.0322462246,
-0.0222059209,
0.0342586711,
0.0080660889,
0.0207441784,
-0.0808573589,
-0.0431109294,
-0.0319735855,
0.0155260712,
0.0062147882,
0.0243151058,
-0.0390485972,
0.0343976766,
-0.0307181701,
-0.037353646,
-0.0626822785,
-0.0037340771,
0.0164735503,
-0.0307142027,
0.0578539632,
-0.013973006,
-0.0228921659,
0.0012459905,
0.0038250387,
-0.0687044859,
-0.0081950277,
0.0031813178,
0.0053355624,
0.0178885218,
-0.0100536393,
-0.0038469019,
-0.0196826272,
0.0605987944,
0.0057444172,
-0.0272828434,
0.0021036072,
0.0401031747,
2.899e-7,
0.0149803516,
0.0758422613,
-0.0139908036,
0.0307325684,
0.0028670561,
0.0140188308,
-0.045894932,
-0.0246464703,
-0.0572551116,
-0.0238705128,
0.037997745,
0.0534939766,
0.0354399346,
0.0330590867,
-0.0745509937,
0.0191134233,
-0.0206139628,
-0.0330498256,
-0.0662504137,
0.0052802255,
0.056641493,
0.0435488671,
0.016634237,
-0.0167273115,
-0.0093037449,
-0.0747706667,
0.0305101778,
-0.0504473858,
-0.0064087943,
0.0319975019,
-0.0016273728,
0.0244963635,
-0.0164765697,
0.0073057958,
0.0044160457,
0.0384803042,
-0.0270047802,
0.0725329965,
0.0251090527,
-0.0312334634,
-0.0085122632,
-0.0735276639,
0.0209398791,
-0.0244516712,
0.060770344,
-0.0116220247,
-0.0288450066,
0.0120678302,
0.0494197346,
-0.0226017237,
-0.030379774,
-0.0254923236,
0.042662777,
-0.0000386135,
-0.0060929027,
-0.0209996626,
0.0120914606,
-0.0845223963,
0.0274790544,
0.0128027415,
-0.0385527313,
-0.0503788181,
-0.0695239007,
0.0393823572,
0.0118362587,
-0.0267722774,
-0.0065169348,
2.528121466e-34,
-0.0030535969,
0.0092486041,
-0.0005467916,
0.0591112934,
0.055926092,
0.0423798561,
-0.0159661639,
0.0210954901,
-0.0008790016,
-0.0715377927,
-0.0183236245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06692v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06692v2 | Guiding Pretraining in Reinforcement Learning with Large Language Models | 2023-02-13T21:16:03 | 2023-09-15T02:42:40 | Yuqing Du, Olivia Watkins, Zihan Wang, Cédric Colas, Trevor Darrell, Pieter Abbeel, Abhishek Gupta, Jacob Andreas | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning algorithms typically struggle in the absence of a
dense, well-shaped reward function. Intrinsically motivated exploration methods
address this limitation by rewarding agents for visiting novel states or
transitions, but these methods offer limited benefits in large environments
where most discovered novelty is irrelevant for downstream tasks. We describe a
method that uses background knowledge from text corpora to shape exploration.
This method, called ELLM (Exploring with LLMs) rewards an agent for achieving
goals suggested by a language model prompted with a description of the agent's
current state. By leveraging large-scale language model pretraining, ELLM
guides agents toward human-meaningful and plausibly useful behaviors without
requiring a human in the loop. We evaluate ELLM in the Crafter game environment
and the Housekeep robotic simulator, showing that ELLM-trained agents have
better coverage of common-sense behaviors during pretraining and usually match
or improve performance on a range of downstream tasks. Code available at
https://github.com/yuqingd/ellm. | [
0.0067289984,
0.0474799424,
0.0006604334,
-0.0068334038,
-0.0110728759,
0.0172630101,
-0.0579252467,
0.0007308113,
-0.0003147812,
-0.0037835909,
-0.0335423015,
0.0392256714,
-0.0584985763,
0.0428599156,
-0.0046105823,
-0.0261773653,
0.0473592877,
-0.048495803,
0.0246784128,
0.0038251402,
-0.0466306433,
-0.0257732011,
-0.0049691023,
0.0693397298,
0.0325674936,
0.0068445392,
-0.0549475104,
-0.0072383806,
0.0366107039,
-0.075822182,
-0.0067948741,
-0.0003672252,
0.0922617614,
0.0431285203,
0.0000022155,
-0.0638841391,
-0.0293820798,
-0.0370496102,
0.0006405134,
-0.0785431042,
0.047232762,
0.0231237169,
-0.015147482,
-0.0185737554,
-0.048573304,
-0.004829702,
0.0540700033,
0.0489907749,
0.0185902454,
0.0464220345,
0.0111024827,
-0.0022547923,
-0.0330037549,
0.0148815978,
0.0590478666,
-0.0482064374,
0.0204555672,
0.0167816002,
0.0746429414,
-0.0021093921,
-0.0107936608,
-0.029140301,
0.0330860354,
-0.0172966272,
0.0035142966,
0.0731193274,
0.0544968545,
-0.010263213,
-0.0030736672,
0.0258424636,
-0.0309835915,
-0.0131971324,
-0.0035371021,
-0.0011200388,
0.0203135293,
0.0366665758,
-0.0203781668,
0.0474345461,
-0.0194551293,
0.0274713673,
0.0266595967,
-0.00477057,
0.0280076917,
0.0155747635,
-0.0287092645,
0.0952902734,
-0.0270967688,
-0.0374787375,
0.0304439627,
0.033245787,
0.0340060554,
-0.0490537621,
-0.035120558,
0.0426021814,
-0.0677232295,
0.0171182752,
-0.0194417909,
0.0596849658,
-0.0184450205,
0.0050563207,
0.0248542558,
0.0309278667,
-0.0142019866,
0.0515740439,
-0.0145409089,
0.0031940213,
-0.0137943905,
0.0261535589,
-0.0510130115,
0.01917357,
-0.0794358253,
-0.0010237673,
-0.0696391538,
0.0423453674,
-0.0290693939,
-0.0456216261,
0.0113086505,
0.0718849003,
-0.0143391117,
0.0160183813,
-0.0137041323,
0.0127698919,
-0.0225830898,
0.010260189,
-0.0638767406,
-0.0461856574,
-0.0667209476,
0.0436854959,
0.02040671,
0.0137433968,
-0.0112738097,
-0.002489489,
-0.0093338182,
-0.0241934285,
0.0318258666,
0.0633873343,
0.0165556911,
-0.0540538654,
-0.0401620492,
-0.0236049145,
0.0604588538,
-0.0307540428,
0.0039014199,
-0.057518404,
-0.0117553938,
-0.0221591573,
0.0047009597,
-0.0136221386,
-0.0051957765,
0.0074250274,
0.0032422235,
0.0915472135,
0.0030886966,
0.0057655741,
0.0090171881,
-0.0058837598,
-0.010125705,
0.0662854686,
0.0350374505,
0.0511804521,
0.0003930076,
0.027894903,
0.0256916489,
0.0193603411,
-0.0335267596,
0.0073910546,
0.042279087,
-0.018460663,
-0.0067326305,
0.0558364168,
0.0164963715,
-0.0185041912,
-0.0537065826,
0.0536329672,
0.0520482361,
0.0790850148,
0.0033955954,
-0.0193060338,
0.0543770529,
0.0121719958,
-0.0164296962,
-0.0419755168,
-0.0116918003,
0.0349857062,
-0.0203002524,
-0.0064638061,
-0.0201269463,
-0.0034805946,
-0.0136998231,
-0.0278522987,
0.0407979786,
0.0069088023,
0.0818919316,
0.0293193068,
0.0652761683,
0.009202335,
-0.0415391922,
-0.038737122,
0.0311972387,
-0.0183991306,
0.0008995493,
-0.0726867691,
0.053994894,
0.0877501145,
0.0332646929,
-0.0645059943,
-0.0259426236,
-0.0277021974,
0.0029208041,
0.0317920856,
-0.0143000474,
-0.0425488986,
0.0139274001,
0.021283593,
-0.0579132177,
-0.0629498363,
0.00372007,
0.0563271567,
0.0185637586,
-0.00385163,
-0.0575025454,
-0.0513306074,
-0.0313293599,
0.0513582453,
-0.0173039548,
-0.0226677693,
-0.0039060761,
-0.0049481685,
-0.009659851,
-0.0017781256,
-0.0048530092,
-0.0083166016,
0.0505257957,
-0.0203136187,
-0.0295232423,
0.0378517173,
-0.0093139838,
-0.0024329787,
0.0268986449,
-0.0274271462,
-0.0139489984,
0.007043906,
0.0160487853,
-0.0094008837,
0.0003941507,
-0.0240142457,
0.0748506561,
0.0006528022,
0.0273370109,
-0.0240149014,
-0.0317674764,
-0.0555438846,
0.0579382777,
0.0174658559,
-0.0008293898,
-0.0092859343,
0.0104120476,
-0.0165037066,
-0.0429438092,
0.0035578273,
0.0174194258,
0.0186362565,
0.0188459903,
0.0676594153,
0.0417508185,
-0.0415652171,
-0.0094855111,
-0.0396758839,
-0.0313672163,
-0.012169282,
-0.00050338,
0.0162526872,
-0.0311155673,
-0.0206843242,
-0.0248067044,
0.0129692899,
0.0316629596,
0.0128540816,
0.0045237616,
0.0318345577,
0.0514672659,
-0.0100912536,
-0.0284962561,
0.0204996653,
-0.0153157981,
0.0058337077,
0.0504843444,
0.0550082847,
-0.1051628813,
0.0281878151,
-0.0066060242,
0.0268474407,
-0.0462655537,
-0.0333150849,
0.0500002317,
-0.0524759889,
0.0066875382,
0.0609676577,
-0.0091760131,
0.0558289737,
0.1002093032,
-0.0228504762,
-0.0675142631,
0.0253589563,
-0.0270458348,
-0.0254586861,
-0.0630363524,
0.0135974018,
0.0735463426,
0.05871097,
-0.0504415669,
0.0046351533,
-0.0646476895,
0.0513924062,
-0.0264246054,
-0.0579517074,
-0.0338565446,
-0.0015652218,
-0.0260013454,
0.0320546441,
-0.0211744308,
-0.044882033,
0.0959132761,
0.0229622275,
-0.0313888639,
-0.0413183793,
-0.015817944,
-0.0177801996,
0.0602103472,
-0.0080185682,
0.0282628573,
0.0012987378,
-0.0333924778,
-0.0268033147,
0.0044373334,
0.0105213346,
0.0144282924,
0.0452489369,
-0.046294421,
0.0198381804,
0.0269328095,
-0.0520472229,
-0.0489946827,
-0.0197703727,
-0.0222923439,
-0.0063069966,
-0.0141416984,
-0.0412266478,
-0.0352071486,
-0.0312345475,
0.0660095513,
0.0252668802,
0.0258007366,
-0.0385356918,
-0.0258354638,
-0.049794253,
0.0465349071,
0.0091486871,
-0.0021395062,
-0.0605448261,
0.027595453,
0.036699418,
-0.0041986564,
-0.0720026568,
-0.0275279358,
0.0366612375,
0.0327585824,
-0.056059584,
0.0216948576,
0.0410879515,
0.0225459095,
-0.0496250391,
-0.0628305823,
0.0796126202,
0.0276931264,
-0.0178104974,
0.016114302,
-0.0563274175,
0.039131254,
0.029060401,
0.0528140031,
-0.0404302925,
-0.0086534852,
-0.0028383944,
0.0115283635,
0.0032867487,
-0.0388729647,
0.0066332417,
-0.1172463596,
0.0078483932,
-0.0039180089,
-0.0790310428,
-0.0285271835,
-0.0282150432,
-0.0081041679,
-0.0105279302,
-0.054452043,
0.023212444,
-0.0137448311,
-0.0123928469,
0.0054305294,
0.025382977,
-0.0482156985,
0.0229987279,
-0.0523243733,
0.0256200563,
0.0930258706,
0.0173642375,
-0.0325207375,
-0.0095814681,
-0.0240904056,
0.0452177785,
0.0242397133,
-0.0139417555,
0.0000549196,
-0.0158884339,
0.0054988223,
0.0221304484,
0.0354168266,
-0.0008532476,
-0.0522843301,
-0.0015144153,
0.0707184821,
-0.0210530832,
-0.0090676695,
0.0127376402,
-0.0280028936,
0.0549732149,
0.0514083505,
-0.0407249182,
-0.0385580212,
-0.0368336216,
-0.041208405,
-0.0756360441,
-0.0166784227,
-0.0362043418,
-0.0108010573,
-0.0219487268,
0.029930545,
-0.080599077,
-0.0733631775,
0.0491877086,
0.0274814032,
-0.0054719197,
-0.0080024283,
-0.0243195575,
0.043902088,
-0.0290093906,
0.0276527889,
-0.0334372856,
0.0063090273,
-0.0464809537,
-0.027540924,
0.0134890331,
-0.0798438638,
-0.0018451355,
-0.023943644,
-0.0201204307,
-0.0436363481,
0.0032199956,
0.0624345802,
0.0163846631,
0.0514926538,
0.0057929391,
-0.0120358039,
0.0426648743,
-0.005027507,
-0.0082551083,
-0.0010245973,
0.0353600755,
0.0498414859,
0.0321777984,
0.0172653049,
-0.0550561361,
0.0059653614,
-0.0059638242,
0.0425681993,
0.0024510287,
0.0080976188,
0.0445856154,
-0.0357559621,
0.0275924783,
-0.0243168771,
0.0111251036,
-0.0355218239,
0.0024305731,
-0.0022210628,
-0.031781625,
-0.0437308699,
0.0030380529,
0.031225007,
-0.0027463224,
0.0306174736,
0.0329185948,
-0.000269247,
0.0222189315,
-0.0399583876,
0.0178354494,
0.0149051314,
0.0418861285,
0.0474845394,
0.0355291739,
0.0301102679,
-0.0036152548,
-0.0049434188,
0.0644514188,
0.0102468124,
0.0682860613,
0.0323038809,
-0.0118823722,
-0.0446759984,
0.01846122,
-0.0504143722,
-0.0586048923,
0.0310067274,
0.0170404799,
0.0722925067,
-0.0069424058,
0.0457187146,
-0.0629904121,
0.0156785585,
0.0140259834,
-0.030739598,
0.0087908907,
-0.0372313038,
0.0174580738,
0.0368904546,
-0.0083091483,
-0.0049613453,
0.0450812317,
-0.0057760845,
0.1005849168,
-0.0271226242,
0.0040891329,
-0.0372323431,
0.0095731262,
0.050827235,
0.0207285844,
-0.0345345661,
0.0112703722,
-0.0301658586,
0.0004058464,
-0.0416432619,
0.0583636612,
-0.0214368571,
-0.0113005899,
0.0627402216,
0.0329553373,
-0.0139313396,
-0.0167242605,
-0.0470591038,
-0.046119187,
0.0107837673,
0.0077638249,
-0.0412840694,
-5.83053904e-33,
-0.0022784271,
-0.0396983884,
0.0701562762,
-0.0222972706,
-0.0103637157,
-0.0374900624,
-0.0433569886,
-0.0116250152,
0.0223328024,
0.0372934565,
-0.0148502011,
-0.0127752014,
0.0030738036,
-0.0026353039,
0.0426316448,
-0.0202901922,
0.031549193,
0.0313462168,
-0.041774746,
-0.0041150679,
0.0187000129,
0.0173645504,
0.0447829477,
-0.0448602885,
0.0268225595,
0.0298392922,
-0.0130677605,
0.0292863343,
0.0242573749,
0.0190804973,
-0.0027262189,
-0.0324236006,
-0.0085904114,
-0.0329267047,
-0.0364669561,
-0.0013814343,
-0.0409648567,
-0.0604252443,
-0.0170313418,
-0.0139438519,
-0.0402591862,
-0.0227692351,
-0.0062022065,
-0.0128751341,
-0.0243734475,
0.063768737,
0.0238008909,
-0.0171599202,
0.0144966301,
0.0238735527,
-0.0759073496,
-0.0017551181,
0.0048944554,
-0.0285501294,
0.0331723802,
0.0220860653,
-0.0090564564,
0.0087887291,
-0.0014680261,
0.063375406,
0.0231813453,
-0.0198926535,
0.0474469028,
0.0340812057,
0.0514857508,
0.0559389815,
0.0012247573,
0.0109744715,
-0.0231994316,
0.0392083675,
0.0213760585,
0.034919139,
-0.0212634727,
0.0267838966,
0.0114030736,
0.0666603073,
-0.0230227318,
0.0529402569,
-0.0113711553,
0.0654978007,
0.0232263729,
0.0449157692,
-0.0165277198,
-0.0130182654,
-0.0331516415,
0.021907296,
0.0144223785,
-0.0487211049,
0.0262892544,
0.0243008509,
-0.004344502,
-0.0908078328,
0.0069348156,
-0.03739978,
-0.0187373608,
0.0418014787,
-0.0426150449,
-0.0001835634,
-0.0208911542,
-0.0283255335,
-0.0358938798,
-0.0619919635,
0.0105985524,
-0.0214751139,
0.008823134,
0.0298138596,
-0.0360360481,
0.0633143783,
-0.0393163562,
0.0203696564,
-0.0304781776,
-0.0071565025,
0.0253112987,
0.0022141922,
0.0686846897,
-0.029908482,
-0.0143760778,
0.0437324271,
0.0099951932,
-0.0660486668,
-0.0279469602,
0.0057694674,
-0.0251385886,
0.011438095,
-0.0082255369,
0.0054479013,
-0.0698193014,
0.0349629335,
0.011788547,
-0.0625025555,
-0.0013987107,
0.0097537832,
3.003e-7,
-0.0375102013,
0.0477361456,
-0.0115427822,
0.0370195806,
-0.0201338585,
0.0313627832,
-0.0391122065,
0.0134852575,
-0.0226732809,
0.004437834,
0.0465712622,
0.0407642424,
-0.0084447702,
-0.0114660505,
-0.0897384882,
-0.0265810415,
-0.0064220079,
0.0023570668,
-0.0438431874,
-0.0243549533,
0.0095506888,
0.0392539501,
0.0130944587,
0.0179408714,
0.0505526103,
-0.0654283836,
0.0312893875,
-0.0556405671,
0.0285187978,
-0.0080189677,
-0.0380497538,
0.0290202387,
-0.0165254362,
-0.0573503897,
-0.0122223953,
0.0471349433,
-0.0476417616,
0.0388560258,
0.0000148167,
0.0048841811,
-0.0247883257,
0.0056658997,
0.0152086606,
-0.0330256782,
0.0176103543,
-0.0613511093,
-0.0074626198,
-0.0029069057,
0.0267507005,
-0.0406498984,
-0.0325824954,
-0.041804824,
-0.0281806216,
-0.0282524154,
-0.01713714,
0.0352963656,
-0.0191291589,
-0.0782461092,
-0.0103940824,
0.0160757136,
-0.0495231412,
-0.0266521424,
-0.0244348627,
0.0286115315,
-0.018866105,
-0.0446957573,
-0.0034147066,
2.511513476e-34,
-0.0066853189,
-0.0118042054,
-0.0067820782,
0.0292685162,
0.0286297463,
0.0440926142,
-0.0092040934,
0.0007977281,
0.0724053383,
-0.0273318384,
-0.0230024811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06690v1 | Bag of Tricks for In-Distribution Calibration of Pretrained Transformers | 2023-02-13T21:11:52 | 2023-02-13T21:11:52 | Jaeyoung Kim, Dongbin Na, Sungchul Choi, Sungbin Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While pre-trained language models (PLMs) have become a de-facto standard
promoting the accuracy of text classification tasks, recent studies find that
PLMs often predict over-confidently. Although various calibration methods have
been proposed, such as ensemble learning and data augmentation, most of the
methods have been verified in computer vision benchmarks rather than in
PLM-based text classification tasks. In this paper, we present an empirical
study on confidence calibration for PLMs, addressing three categories,
including confidence penalty losses, data augmentations, and ensemble methods.
We find that the ensemble model overfitted to the training set shows sub-par
calibration performance and also observe that PLMs trained with confidence
penalty loss have a trade-off between calibration and accuracy. Building on
these observations, we propose the Calibrated PLM (CALL), a combination of
calibration techniques. The CALL complements the drawbacks that may occur when
utilizing a calibration method individually and boosts both classification and
calibration accuracy. Design choices in CALL's training procedures are
extensively studied, and we provide a detailed analysis of how calibration
techniques affect the calibration performance of PLMs. | [
0.0067096297,
0.0449968912,
0.0185941681,
0.01701512,
0.0252308864,
0.007231907,
0.0036229293,
-0.0212204196,
-0.0430035032,
-0.0573016405,
-0.0854833499,
-0.0384944864,
0.0561002232,
-0.0142831001,
0.002016495,
-0.0087264944,
-0.0049884859,
0.0128339976,
-0.0186807383,
0.0090154316,
0.0138024073,
-0.0081097865,
-0.0081230598,
0.0129759219,
-0.023313202,
-0.0108504975,
0.0335972272,
0.0176001452,
0.0137415566,
-0.0132415779,
0.0538696982,
0.0804310143,
0.0115638701,
0.0575192906,
0.0000019497,
-0.0428816266,
-0.0180656724,
-0.0025599168,
-0.0425665714,
0.0253140572,
0.0396184698,
-0.015581564,
0.0207909271,
0.0439570621,
-0.0194981787,
-0.0219535381,
0.0676012859,
0.0387449153,
0.0069617783,
0.0738962367,
-0.0106404731,
-0.0063929697,
0.0271124523,
-0.0178102255,
-0.0470575802,
-0.0095821023,
0.0234335084,
-0.0046394435,
-0.0713314489,
-0.0198993236,
0.0012754072,
0.0215770286,
0.0108396998,
-0.0009179834,
0.0279129259,
0.0357393138,
-0.0482584834,
-0.0107024359,
-0.0327335671,
0.0249025505,
-0.0134679964,
-0.0478159785,
-0.0585620366,
-0.0323449783,
-0.0377012827,
-0.013821587,
-0.0004989418,
0.0269656405,
0.0286971126,
0.0346650444,
-0.0555487797,
0.0480954684,
0.0480052605,
0.0073695607,
-0.0079410467,
0.060394492,
0.0062778648,
-0.0081340419,
0.0078355689,
0.0654233322,
-0.0045366352,
-0.0179136656,
0.0297677089,
0.0275437273,
-0.0032535468,
0.0203476436,
-0.0617688075,
-0.0653541237,
0.0102581568,
-0.028389696,
0.0646304339,
0.0131248394,
-0.0537828542,
0.0109675564,
-0.0243596416,
0.0560562052,
-0.0110853473,
0.067332156,
-0.0458829254,
0.0044685318,
-0.0066010603,
-0.0053282278,
-0.0292966161,
-0.0259122234,
0.0163021386,
-0.0177153423,
-0.0814183503,
0.0293111894,
0.0343722478,
-0.0124337664,
0.036802981,
0.0215757769,
-0.0470881201,
-0.0247762464,
-0.005661435,
0.0457552709,
0.0435612984,
0.0404643938,
-0.0253872275,
-0.0587719455,
-0.0064636734,
0.0334821381,
-0.0018942978,
-0.001795611,
0.0396200456,
0.0243319441,
-0.0110739572,
-0.0945646688,
0.0075716088,
0.0260157418,
-0.0452727191,
-0.0645297021,
-0.002013511,
-0.0360288434,
-0.0087723173,
0.0449394882,
0.0208261739,
-0.0129975751,
-0.0003649646,
-0.008604601,
0.0099369232,
0.0686198696,
-0.0131109916,
-0.0023387074,
0.0196968634,
-0.0242670607,
0.0118447868,
0.0693882704,
0.0345108621,
0.019694075,
0.0364548042,
-0.0144629441,
0.0760758892,
0.0706217736,
0.0057944455,
-0.0303734038,
-0.0029650331,
-0.0060222945,
-0.0029131472,
-0.0061647929,
0.0222308934,
0.0413488261,
-0.0050561344,
0.0094461842,
0.0929655805,
0.002569312,
0.0219787229,
-0.0164106153,
-0.0341274068,
-0.0412392356,
0.0378143564,
-0.0195452962,
-0.0538820662,
-0.016347535,
-0.0618407093,
-0.0104804076,
-0.0006459219,
0.0249635428,
-0.0252954103,
-0.0356262997,
-0.0151544968,
-0.0139124412,
-0.008078401,
0.0131991068,
0.066589497,
-0.0089627439,
-0.0210523736,
0.0753083006,
0.0035199642,
-0.0319129527,
0.0144462315,
-0.0324714929,
-0.0100915171,
0.0116249397,
0.0204417501,
-0.0288161524,
0.0006732017,
-0.0041929111,
0.0250733849,
0.0147602307,
0.0252431203,
0.0138709191,
0.0236256495,
-0.04210677,
-0.035315875,
0.0085513396,
0.0292369518,
0.0026063472,
0.0250887834,
-0.0067029195,
0.0359521471,
-0.0590940416,
-0.0252686962,
0.0611023717,
0.000409302,
-0.0344721749,
0.0059060305,
0.0046332274,
0.0056404085,
0.0019345023,
-0.0356822051,
0.0047220294,
0.030621957,
0.0118190646,
-0.0098704798,
0.001254081,
-0.0389202274,
-0.0086371759,
0.0530936383,
-0.0230670217,
-0.0047534355,
0.0414510183,
-0.0359945558,
-0.0263118502,
-0.0391165279,
-0.0316101536,
0.0193010662,
-0.0749629363,
0.0424954072,
-0.0568076298,
0.0329976305,
-0.0420644358,
0.0249752831,
0.0107161263,
0.0156627391,
-0.0342644006,
-0.0321999751,
0.0410425887,
0.0153920315,
-0.0700115561,
-0.0245170239,
-0.0055388585,
0.0455914848,
0.0280591454,
-0.0186662339,
-0.0249714516,
-0.0131413033,
-0.0835558325,
0.0056048702,
-0.0630865619,
0.00882864,
0.0113147115,
-0.0219407398,
-0.0149373366,
-0.0310029425,
-0.0149346013,
-0.0188640356,
0.0230463687,
-0.0000365507,
0.0143658426,
-0.0200436655,
0.004521009,
-0.0118345413,
-0.0158662144,
0.0028378698,
0.0772102997,
0.0186348185,
-0.0113235712,
-0.0746859983,
0.0388258472,
0.0018790304,
0.0120037245,
-0.0081701586,
-0.0481825545,
-0.0128070153,
0.0069069006,
0.0008033519,
0.0454563461,
0.0274371486,
-0.0257390905,
0.0498510189,
0.0594389774,
-0.0157115478,
-0.0298685338,
-0.0426375754,
-0.058668267,
-0.0464275852,
0.0086679887,
-0.0054639373,
0.0565121472,
-0.0382254981,
-0.0050927228,
-0.006332037,
-0.0187968798,
-0.0018250787,
0.0112108346,
-0.0096582351,
-0.0193174444,
-0.0047975741,
0.0320574045,
-0.0004752966,
-0.0867124349,
0.0411743447,
-0.0802502856,
-0.01622824,
-0.0321412757,
-0.0220257044,
-0.0043375748,
0.0368798822,
0.0429432727,
-0.0117163109,
0.0270586256,
0.0088479826,
-0.0549390949,
-0.0074733472,
0.0417339243,
-0.0438744873,
0.0445575155,
0.0008445984,
0.0234301016,
-0.0313520133,
-0.0208110809,
-0.0641792789,
-0.0679009482,
-0.0547585078,
-0.0073591084,
0.0282730535,
-0.0226105247,
-0.0618291982,
0.0194985718,
-0.0023842468,
0.0617905483,
-0.018657811,
-0.0019760081,
0.0027360062,
0.0223107524,
0.0160591546,
0.0052793496,
0.0332214609,
-0.0574334525,
-0.0460520089,
0.011140123,
-0.0253391173,
0.0203144327,
-0.0668565333,
-0.0170966238,
0.0452493206,
0.0005253723,
0.0093307495,
0.0116816973,
0.0465162247,
-0.0018676427,
0.0035961114,
0.123227641,
0.0147053916,
-0.0825560093,
-0.0502101481,
0.0235986728,
0.014071851,
0.0297815651,
0.0182872936,
-0.0387412049,
-0.0179888289,
-0.0090578161,
0.0103438012,
0.0022190304,
-0.0035179046,
0.0007854559,
-0.0957271829,
-0.0092063332,
-0.0020278401,
-0.0318666585,
-0.0265815705,
-0.0272420738,
0.0206331182,
-0.0431585982,
0.03490429,
-0.007962157,
-0.0000167276,
-0.0063821576,
0.066920124,
-0.0573527217,
-0.0651765615,
-0.0067224973,
-0.0565417074,
0.0150845367,
0.0779352114,
-0.0122361295,
-0.0347120129,
-0.0057890294,
0.0339733995,
-0.0376173854,
-0.0037918668,
0.0291730389,
0.0874032378,
-0.0119348066,
0.0040355446,
0.0153335817,
-0.0064940834,
-0.0304428861,
0.0018016774,
-0.045448482,
0.0165046547,
-0.0239349958,
-0.0196361542,
-0.0112526417,
-0.0106468759,
-0.0027459157,
0.03797796,
0.0017237213,
-0.0309934523,
-0.0188062955,
-0.0262550227,
0.0423745178,
-0.0430913158,
0.0171320364,
0.0641425475,
0.0060439403,
-0.0594558679,
-0.0243792254,
-0.0113782119,
0.0071645826,
0.0062573506,
0.0178968702,
-0.0522620156,
0.0009566238,
0.011127376,
-0.0490693785,
0.0350068361,
-0.0245858766,
0.0427953973,
-0.061897818,
0.0048723295,
0.0283236131,
-0.0328927077,
-0.0197183918,
0.00218766,
-0.110852994,
-0.0577041693,
0.0239596739,
0.0637899712,
0.0161570497,
0.0273294188,
0.0093820095,
-0.0672748685,
0.0906089544,
0.0734126568,
-0.0015944479,
0.0243316609,
0.0194138978,
-0.0596390329,
-0.0401812457,
-0.0062986603,
-0.0200134013,
0.0474963598,
0.0563974455,
-0.008938388,
-0.0202381033,
-0.0712658092,
0.0049785068,
-0.0280140154,
0.1153680608,
-0.0493223369,
-0.0088144401,
-0.0208915956,
0.0367569141,
0.0024558578,
-0.0180918984,
-0.0053030238,
-0.0467097424,
0.0456285104,
-0.0048655719,
-0.0305093843,
0.0569973402,
-0.0150406398,
0.0509022176,
-0.0138840694,
0.0157937873,
0.0495313741,
-0.0114708273,
0.0322050117,
0.003064954,
-0.0176193956,
-0.0121856174,
0.0324829631,
0.0104931658,
0.0281603206,
0.0322021917,
0.0149963954,
0.0236715246,
-0.0399927497,
0.0152592715,
-0.0804861858,
0.0315534212,
-0.0713834018,
0.0309668444,
0.0404276401,
-0.0409473516,
0.0086725838,
-0.0215529688,
-0.0160101429,
-0.052528169,
0.0187395588,
-0.0015754884,
0.0171169732,
0.0479748361,
-0.0265387706,
-0.0219268538,
0.020058034,
0.0428589247,
-0.0110180993,
0.020489106,
-0.010238247,
-0.0432043001,
-0.009534453,
0.0033588237,
0.0030194304,
-0.0277281646,
-0.0282390118,
-0.0169062521,
0.0029075225,
-0.0565582514,
0.0719350353,
0.0043042204,
0.0171498545,
-0.0168256909,
0.0025762352,
0.0503849722,
-0.0213625543,
0.0023993044,
-0.0142007861,
-0.011133804,
-0.0092212809,
0.0427449085,
-0.0367562547,
-5.896483539e-33,
-0.0280978903,
-0.0215126835,
0.0041801985,
0.0026944228,
-0.0066701891,
0.0358222015,
0.0024370502,
0.030019721,
-0.0025561205,
0.0225481335,
-0.0138801951,
0.0108797457,
0.0421026461,
0.0399665833,
-0.0297737792,
-0.0145537062,
0.0538419969,
-0.0198303275,
-0.0431786478,
-0.0332120657,
0.0024225807,
0.0463387109,
0.1045327485,
-0.057622496,
-0.0138172274,
-0.0134695563,
-0.0372964442,
0.0090959659,
0.0111112026,
0.0348297469,
-0.0098113436,
0.0548914485,
0.0039119385,
0.0077541266,
-0.0008889313,
0.0369367935,
-0.0548711531,
-0.0042528529,
-0.0110411933,
0.0850322619,
0.0136531163,
0.0477681383,
0.0192346964,
-0.0209433679,
-0.0320781171,
-0.0307240225,
0.052170258,
-0.0463647284,
-0.0191112459,
-0.0611551777,
-0.019154584,
0.0145039894,
0.0186242219,
-0.0312358253,
0.0294719525,
0.0340423137,
0.0343992487,
0.0580782443,
-0.0785899758,
0.0012594804,
0.0392926969,
0.0211100373,
0.0504612364,
0.095673658,
-0.0156324022,
0.0399415717,
0.0057150903,
0.0207625069,
-0.042128548,
-0.0271543674,
0.0634601638,
-0.0171617381,
0.0367326438,
0.0554568395,
0.0470339283,
-0.0199284926,
-0.0723141134,
0.0397306606,
-0.0351969041,
-0.0291608367,
0.0631905794,
-0.0012550565,
-0.0158602837,
-0.0200248733,
-0.0375342071,
-0.0274438914,
-0.0117796846,
-0.0032652752,
-0.0086833071,
0.0399769582,
-0.0035324581,
0.0311797503,
0.0275291242,
-0.0492801368,
-0.0478791893,
-0.0079659736,
-0.0006887996,
0.0218667276,
-0.0360023975,
0.0164775401,
-0.0251054373,
-0.0253907833,
0.0215658732,
0.0267064366,
-0.010352483,
-0.0187601019,
0.0903309137,
0.0232852697,
-0.050939098,
0.0118949842,
0.0025597485,
-0.004422754,
0.035006918,
0.0907564536,
0.0194193963,
0.0209854878,
-0.0193768125,
0.0125563834,
-0.0012448252,
0.0150977746,
-0.0075613232,
-0.0231797788,
0.0235633664,
0.030939173,
-0.025313627,
-0.0045275618,
-0.0097622126,
-0.0353400521,
0.0124221267,
-0.0458950736,
0.0119789932,
-0.010236823,
2.474e-7,
0.1223714352,
0.0391149446,
0.0092603154,
-0.0110192196,
0.0076361243,
0.0130930394,
-0.0338483304,
0.0106247421,
0.0223931763,
-0.0383724384,
0.0250413157,
-0.0010747804,
0.0581476763,
0.0159638599,
-0.044928316,
-0.0646592602,
-0.051106479,
0.0328947119,
0.016398957,
-0.0053653233,
0.0320321023,
0.1163359806,
0.0020910127,
-0.0368273668,
-0.0185130276,
-0.0398709774,
0.0877501518,
-0.0405269638,
0.0315767154,
0.0567369536,
0.043533612,
0.0094407462,
-0.0074870274,
0.0544759482,
-0.028403189,
0.029417472,
0.0289094616,
0.0198637601,
-0.016965026,
-0.0047913748,
-0.027231738,
0.0429487005,
0.0198571086,
-0.0523676462,
0.0271455068,
-0.087819472,
-0.0005463217,
-0.0689957291,
-0.0336425826,
-0.0401549563,
0.0767633468,
-0.0007739105,
0.0203316677,
0.0386134498,
0.0194391534,
-0.003880518,
-0.0482154302,
-0.1041376814,
-0.0531310514,
0.0161240101,
-0.0251930524,
-0.0267272834,
0.0000932634,
-0.0339524373,
0.0522408113,
-0.0350207761,
0.0377794541,
2.003803001e-34,
0.0332395136,
-0.0171377845,
-0.0046283808,
0.0003583338,
-0.0008122969,
-0.0106480876,
0.0589450635,
-0.0204468444,
-0.0053605861,
-0.0748742595,
0.0341584198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06675v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06675v4 | Symbolic Discovery of Optimization Algorithms | 2023-02-13T20:27:30 | 2023-05-08T21:49:57 | Xiangning Chen, Chen Liang, Da Huang, Esteban Real, Kaiyuan Wang, Yao Liu, Hieu Pham, Xuanyi Dong, Thang Luong, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Yifeng Lu, Quoc V. Le | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.NE | We present a method to formulate algorithm discovery as program search, and
apply it to discover optimization algorithms for deep neural network training.
We leverage efficient search techniques to explore an infinite and sparse
program space. To bridge the large generalization gap between proxy and target
tasks, we also introduce program selection and simplification strategies. Our
method discovers a simple and effective optimization algorithm, $\textbf{Lion}$
($\textit{Evo$\textbf{L}$ved S$\textbf{i}$gn M$\textbf{o}$me$\textbf{n}$tum}$).
It is more memory-efficient than Adam as it only keeps track of the momentum.
Different from adaptive optimizers, its update has the same magnitude for each
parameter calculated through the sign operation. We compare Lion with widely
used optimizers, such as Adam and Adafactor, for training a variety of models
on different tasks. On image classification, Lion boosts the accuracy of ViT by
up to 2% on ImageNet and saves up to 5x the pre-training compute on JFT. On
vision-language contrastive learning, we achieve 88.3% $\textit{zero-shot}$ and
91.1% $\textit{fine-tuning}$ accuracy on ImageNet, surpassing the previous best
results by 2% and 0.1%, respectively. On diffusion models, Lion outperforms
Adam by achieving a better FID score and reducing the training compute by up to
2.3x. For autoregressive, masked language modeling, and fine-tuning, Lion
exhibits a similar or better performance compared to Adam. Our analysis of Lion
reveals that its performance gain grows with the training batch size. It also
requires a smaller learning rate than Adam due to the larger norm of the update
produced by the sign function. Additionally, we examine the limitations of Lion
and identify scenarios where its improvements are small or not statistically
significant. Lion is also successfully deployed in production systems such as
Google search ads CTR model. | [
0.0024105497,
0.1008563116,
-0.0099114319,
0.0640682951,
-0.0071347258,
-0.0284056738,
0.0002229878,
0.0005188864,
-0.0467919745,
0.0162885357,
-0.0197604988,
-0.0058117914,
0.0042922827,
0.027024338,
0.0333737694,
0.0113820508,
0.0403552763,
0.036725726,
-0.0098654665,
-0.0117523959,
-0.0084008938,
-0.0054653143,
-0.0230633803,
0.0367599055,
-0.0059802351,
0.0441024564,
-0.0321204253,
0.0298922788,
0.0596402735,
-0.0238795653,
0.0074968906,
0.0117051443,
0.0270682517,
0.0548683405,
0.0000026669,
-0.0177683681,
-0.0164344721,
-0.0167586897,
-0.0251882747,
0.0342129208,
0.0394226871,
-0.0253852401,
0.0010373427,
0.0041781189,
-0.0050244401,
-0.0592937693,
0.0948624834,
0.0131530631,
0.0358720906,
0.0724292174,
0.0104117766,
-0.0492857657,
0.0123361405,
-0.0209413525,
-0.0231841058,
-0.0341666564,
-0.0090933517,
-0.0515675619,
-0.0264201518,
-0.0072095715,
-0.0022182162,
0.0390623771,
0.0300037768,
0.0100451121,
0.047009632,
0.0262343679,
-0.0462246947,
-0.0280190185,
0.0094694123,
0.0756271631,
-0.0459818244,
-0.040232569,
-0.0155034354,
-0.0338174626,
-0.0453571677,
-0.018857548,
0.0027791064,
0.0105296569,
0.0440845378,
0.0167877823,
0.0052861497,
-0.0187056772,
0.0714297891,
0.0188204199,
-0.0086039519,
0.0229985788,
-0.0036834297,
0.0436620042,
0.0469203256,
-0.0291490983,
-0.0844717622,
-0.0365802608,
0.0244338643,
0.0140802404,
-0.0138871316,
-0.0075865071,
-0.0204463992,
-0.0780588686,
-0.0427650101,
-0.0158655476,
0.0789932162,
0.0512430817,
0.0210026093,
0.0165728647,
-0.0473824888,
0.0327546634,
-0.0687907264,
-0.0255532879,
-0.0313503779,
0.0067246393,
-0.027964849,
0.0224401001,
-0.0703519136,
0.0434459038,
-0.0172070358,
-0.0229195002,
-0.0522794053,
0.0007338925,
0.0064483057,
-0.0337343663,
-0.0092116073,
0.0421773084,
-0.0104484921,
-0.0003069846,
-0.0089973779,
0.0117120966,
-0.0430388413,
0.00837347,
-0.0084970761,
-0.0085136509,
-0.0239273794,
0.0404771008,
-0.0052840849,
-0.0110244211,
0.0308154132,
0.074633345,
-0.0300000049,
-0.0154587924,
-0.0530569777,
-0.029557148,
0.0148111172,
-0.0290489178,
0.0268705562,
-0.0713194236,
0.0055645145,
-0.0386835039,
0.0137729188,
-0.0458578691,
0.0126615735,
-0.0109799169,
0.0022511645,
0.0602099746,
-0.0370035954,
-0.0407202207,
0.0671039373,
0.020718148,
0.0079993624,
0.07773038,
0.016353216,
0.0410963595,
-0.0106830699,
-0.0130891334,
-0.0302529205,
0.0314359181,
0.0346465893,
0.0079639349,
-0.0189814717,
-0.0531965718,
-0.0146569274,
0.0535338372,
-0.0010004104,
0.0041822302,
-0.0488779023,
-0.0638307258,
0.0142351789,
0.052414801,
0.0391959473,
0.0509300679,
0.043932341,
-0.0177694689,
0.0202502441,
-0.0567705221,
-0.0223181248,
0.0553830825,
-0.0498537868,
-0.0441062786,
-0.0388540514,
-0.0063000857,
-0.04873861,
-0.0401321761,
0.0099005615,
-0.0377604663,
-0.0434622839,
0.032797832,
0.0298054852,
-0.0323306881,
-0.0707189813,
0.0010385419,
-0.0000267318,
0.0081832809,
-0.0123121534,
-0.0518190004,
0.0023380741,
0.0313761383,
0.0319852307,
-0.0372464992,
0.0155801484,
0.0094700884,
0.0094241323,
0.0070976983,
0.0018053183,
-0.0006781056,
0.0407140553,
-0.0608123131,
-0.0255243704,
-0.0232331883,
-0.0073923096,
0.0551579557,
0.0239785034,
0.0463221595,
0.0258449521,
0.0127044506,
-0.0135575663,
0.0292140339,
-0.0236980729,
-0.0400578938,
0.1175167337,
0.0211335849,
0.0324361511,
-0.0002201671,
-0.009439637,
-0.0143553009,
0.0138962995,
-0.0538094901,
-0.058446914,
-0.0029743076,
-0.0407490022,
0.0224799905,
0.0327502787,
-0.0645858794,
0.0539103188,
0.1083893776,
-0.0312318951,
-0.0390233956,
0.0633270591,
-0.0285914242,
0.0304228272,
-0.0032557601,
-0.0099248122,
-0.0163870398,
0.046638418,
0.0094316257,
0.0448066816,
-0.0022834681,
-0.0256866664,
0.0041845776,
0.0338372476,
0.0370498784,
0.0127392123,
-0.0441996306,
-0.0139752086,
-0.0168833509,
0.0212479122,
0.0389846191,
0.0063222339,
0.0293364692,
0.0276473947,
-0.0733958334,
0.0621005036,
-0.0336290188,
-0.0148449438,
0.014508523,
-0.007141694,
0.0290467162,
0.024857264,
0.0066421037,
0.0572345182,
-0.0730750933,
-0.0204324368,
0.0292252004,
0.0513970405,
-0.0473766066,
-0.0430022962,
-0.0500738397,
-0.0060857302,
0.0419431999,
-0.0335558467,
0.0103044985,
0.0103721768,
0.0628608167,
0.0144283706,
0.0437470488,
-0.0314444527,
-0.0605141334,
-0.023898486,
-0.0297828354,
-0.0802737698,
0.1026720926,
0.0092620086,
0.0131886099,
-0.001550598,
0.0705227107,
-0.0437545665,
0.0335620567,
-0.0186093152,
-0.0049924292,
0.0194318108,
-0.0233145393,
0.0069521605,
0.0773416758,
-0.0429241061,
0.0118938563,
-0.0304216556,
-0.0097126858,
0.0250861831,
-0.0449675284,
-0.0291176364,
0.0246940125,
0.0122799641,
0.0008959867,
-0.0007452917,
-0.0228253063,
0.0513503775,
0.0014430123,
-0.0234435648,
-0.0299170073,
-0.0830263272,
-0.026527252,
0.0118242959,
-0.0296561513,
0.02479163,
-0.0071360059,
0.0093810838,
-0.0205993447,
-0.0105155604,
0.0402979925,
0.0041903518,
0.047511898,
0.0067763501,
0.0245995503,
-0.0236825626,
-0.0368722342,
-0.0532237403,
-0.0279567409,
-0.0239524152,
0.0453685559,
0.0168930702,
-0.0541760772,
-0.0202709176,
-0.0204840694,
-0.009409016,
0.0578963757,
-0.0055282419,
-0.0152313532,
-0.0316688791,
0.0010033187,
0.0152025679,
-0.0409054458,
0.0360195376,
-0.0122122038,
0.0301992204,
0.0262206774,
0.0084717479,
-0.0062458208,
-0.1011075079,
0.0006471296,
0.0144128799,
-0.032336019,
-0.02058734,
0.0347903259,
0.0104813306,
-0.0430109613,
0.0071996935,
0.0472763069,
0.0320862532,
-0.0643006414,
0.0021588418,
0.0096174171,
0.0111364201,
0.0445491858,
0.0119273197,
-0.0866832137,
-0.0691362396,
-0.0166338552,
0.0223176125,
-0.0203420836,
-0.0221579634,
0.0005070989,
-0.0797575265,
-0.0036948177,
0.0148094231,
-0.0478135198,
0.0044037118,
-0.0246133972,
-0.0324581005,
-0.0572377704,
-0.0130681032,
-0.0184947792,
0.0295485035,
-0.0211915914,
-0.0018740603,
0.0380618311,
-0.0407965444,
-0.0382011905,
-0.0311650392,
-0.0193563122,
0.036778722,
-0.01634649,
-0.017628286,
-0.0148437293,
0.0714041069,
-0.0260552317,
0.0072328066,
-0.0623097196,
0.0146179022,
0.0014435478,
-0.0436735563,
0.0307734068,
0.0460507721,
-0.0342671871,
-0.0043493914,
0.0182085875,
0.0587070733,
-0.0080007268,
0.0016499365,
-0.0237592403,
-0.0126910713,
0.0219216458,
0.0420876481,
-0.0195916072,
-0.0433647409,
-0.0150034977,
-0.0193779338,
0.0422796793,
-0.0651959851,
-0.0246680658,
-0.0284176059,
0.0454846174,
-0.0473483019,
-0.0355312824,
0.0187334791,
0.0075128791,
0.0427024588,
0.0138036553,
-0.0443827473,
-0.0045714034,
0.0029972999,
-0.0981769636,
0.0131932329,
-0.0093172397,
0.0275593176,
-0.0166421104,
-0.0011232495,
0.0528881513,
-0.0271062516,
0.0052191317,
0.0594088845,
-0.0819501206,
-0.0547827855,
-0.050747674,
0.0536915809,
0.0041976026,
0.0384181328,
0.0050652162,
-0.0444561653,
0.0282818172,
0.0482313856,
0.0440014154,
-0.0061762263,
0.064735949,
-0.032514181,
0.0064064967,
0.0242877994,
-0.0028431145,
0.0231093802,
0.0475950278,
0.0093503706,
-0.0301364027,
0.0301351789,
0.0103947595,
-0.012373602,
0.0268596932,
-0.0279907454,
-0.0174839832,
-0.004774624,
0.0268669855,
0.0405275673,
0.0255912524,
-0.0612414181,
-0.0011308243,
0.0417573564,
0.0276654623,
0.023245519,
0.0447519906,
0.0572488159,
-0.0024417657,
-0.0145514654,
0.057581272,
-0.0045641218,
0.0594802275,
0.0227482915,
0.0218225252,
-0.0053071147,
0.0115018217,
0.0423087887,
0.0529579036,
-0.0515244156,
0.0492634177,
0.0299386811,
0.0130871851,
-0.0619703606,
-0.011901577,
-0.0268330518,
-0.0540654846,
-0.0616625473,
0.0286457967,
0.0778059661,
-0.0139771746,
-0.0506214388,
-0.0397346355,
-0.0257474668,
-0.0229720995,
0.0088967932,
-0.042835582,
-0.0049531194,
0.0262315478,
0.0308634192,
0.0045318804,
-0.0260762647,
0.0478646085,
-0.0080606053,
0.0597422048,
-0.0096684396,
0.0322494842,
-0.0214394275,
-0.0084586414,
0.0457858406,
0.0698846877,
-0.0077116247,
-0.0100812996,
0.0097020604,
-0.0484908186,
-0.004531363,
-0.0217752233,
0.0052648969,
0.0124913733,
0.0860263705,
0.022009518,
0.0055491957,
-0.016986927,
-0.007209104,
-0.0281681791,
-0.0215578042,
-0.0065514734,
-0.0089530526,
-7.042056783e-33,
0.0286399536,
0.004380621,
-0.0078995144,
-0.0042902124,
-0.0005757548,
0.0360050499,
-0.0371632129,
-0.0053422819,
-0.0781002864,
0.0200889371,
0.0101008369,
0.0200682376,
-0.0022704285,
0.0038985277,
-0.0158845019,
0.0200033728,
0.0224878062,
-0.0216798242,
-0.0253591519,
0.0025963828,
-0.0137462476,
0.0250553209,
0.0479414798,
-0.0214579143,
-0.1071782112,
0.026582282,
-0.0025006623,
0.049962528,
-0.0019602231,
0.0255827066,
0.0039837258,
0.0148467589,
-0.0257476196,
-0.0553631745,
0.0070646158,
-0.0367176533,
-0.0556430779,
-0.0312892348,
0.0155059434,
0.0042752489,
-0.0613321029,
-0.0403774977,
0.0500071906,
0.0274902862,
-0.0456417091,
-0.0141475964,
0.0152851148,
-0.0069007706,
0.0033449365,
-0.0444241427,
-0.0303640887,
-0.0085358871,
-0.0420007929,
0.0002373864,
0.0457733423,
-0.0070286845,
-0.0194465518,
0.0241025109,
-0.0461391732,
-0.0142651368,
0.0021782976,
0.0614558682,
0.0615814105,
0.0763835609,
0.0301214214,
0.0394163541,
0.0959173813,
-0.0061771963,
0.0237347279,
0.0113039063,
0.0854716972,
0.0105994642,
0.0542515554,
0.020743113,
0.0441757739,
-0.0195283815,
-0.0978900418,
-0.0329718553,
0.0182153229,
0.0109592648,
0.0056987861,
0.0124887275,
-0.0041623465,
-0.0073219058,
-0.0379828736,
-0.0335744172,
-0.0484045669,
0.0105945459,
0.0170647651,
0.0682961494,
-0.024446588,
0.0094771935,
0.0239724591,
-0.0629988685,
0.049092859,
0.0285881348,
-0.0200658012,
0.0505441986,
0.0351588391,
0.0097374264,
-0.0658912659,
-0.0546506867,
-0.0036002598,
0.0177747197,
0.065581426,
-0.005396523,
0.0144757032,
0.0388765596,
-0.0171507373,
-0.0179257821,
-0.0575228222,
0.0336955599,
0.0134759778,
0.0213172752,
0.0075014769,
-0.0093290769,
-0.0067109973,
0.067565091,
0.0078347446,
0.0122912815,
-0.0331109837,
0.0055144262,
0.0123975305,
0.0317739248,
-0.0350102372,
0.0093568536,
-0.0030663128,
0.0308370274,
0.0308210719,
-0.0955884084,
-0.0494231507,
0.015467287,
3.226e-7,
0.0041235159,
0.0150413895,
-0.0180006102,
0.006610503,
0.0255532768,
0.055442173,
0.0019224817,
-0.0137714827,
-0.0247590225,
-0.0149930632,
0.0410697795,
0.0311809815,
0.053097859,
-0.0349649265,
-0.0720557049,
0.0115847094,
-0.0148695931,
-0.0000305416,
-0.0279169176,
-0.0227723569,
-0.0237094369,
0.1105546355,
0.0372456126,
-0.0338002704,
0.0239629392,
-0.019878298,
0.0228118133,
-0.0091351783,
0.0287933834,
0.0092387609,
-0.0753572881,
0.0297612101,
-0.0413469188,
-0.0374971777,
-0.0507259555,
0.0439377129,
-0.01698808,
0.0495281816,
-0.0176415425,
-0.0346690565,
0.0202763882,
0.028905496,
-0.0196458548,
0.0153749092,
0.0729671344,
-0.0069974097,
-0.0186957456,
-0.0528766774,
-0.0198863056,
-0.0219158642,
0.0089468928,
-0.0569479428,
0.0335028619,
0.0101007828,
-0.0232139509,
-0.0000256887,
-0.035685569,
-0.0553600937,
0.0110856378,
0.0354064405,
-0.0289251655,
0.0022028873,
-0.0672099069,
-0.0061406856,
0.0501901172,
0.0043378384,
-0.0141621707,
2.968789273e-34,
0.0276549738,
-0.0100341393,
0.0340286456,
0.0453084558,
0.0057204012,
0.0037926803,
-0.0711350217,
-0.0050930916,
0.026091326,
0.0016643025,
-0.0388116278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06674v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06674v3 | PK-ICR: Persona-Knowledge Interactive Context Retrieval for Grounded Dialogue | 2023-02-13T20:27:26 | 2023-10-19T15:43:06 | Minsik Oh, Joosung Lee, Jiwei Li, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Identifying relevant persona or knowledge for conversational systems is
critical to grounded dialogue response generation. However, each grounding has
been mostly researched in isolation with more practical multi-context dialogue
tasks introduced in recent works. We define Persona and Knowledge Dual Context
Identification as the task to identify persona and knowledge jointly for a
given dialogue, which could be of elevated importance in complex multi-context
dialogue settings. We develop a novel grounding retrieval method that utilizes
all contexts of dialogue simultaneously. Our method requires less computational
power via utilizing neural QA retrieval models. We further introduce our novel
null-positive rank test which measures ranking performance on semantically
dissimilar samples (i.e. hard negatives) in relation to data augmentation. | [
0.017771272,
0.0114201298,
-0.0257183854,
0.0481463,
0.0019994725,
-0.0173221007,
0.0215968918,
0.0039172536,
0.0191758908,
-0.0040010386,
-0.0633212775,
-0.0378230028,
0.0118530206,
0.0403328426,
0.0402260609,
-0.0138932271,
0.0330663249,
0.0238344446,
0.0023764628,
0.0153813055,
-0.0148811862,
0.0046133581,
-0.0367010459,
0.0563237779,
-0.0281954315,
-0.0245717317,
-0.0293605048,
0.0163690969,
0.0661899745,
-0.0417579487,
0.048210077,
0.0437743552,
0.044994168,
0.0263806041,
0.0000017263,
-0.0018209936,
-0.0102495989,
-0.0283160917,
-0.0306208264,
-0.0361400545,
-0.0385681987,
0.0273342468,
0.0346134491,
0.0133975269,
-0.0505351685,
0.0017776227,
0.0325036757,
0.100545913,
0.0669940263,
0.0524394363,
-0.0132715805,
-0.0251367465,
0.0022556852,
-0.0400461406,
0.0013298439,
-0.0398354381,
0.0029308817,
-0.0060910117,
-0.030628657,
0.0447686873,
0.0276874769,
0.0015138045,
0.028788073,
-0.0208444912,
0.0118030906,
0.0321879983,
-0.0374700278,
0.0312746428,
0.011990116,
0.1300321072,
0.0723777264,
0.0071556359,
0.0130439484,
0.0196442064,
0.0184906144,
-0.062131457,
-0.0508282781,
0.006676706,
0.0005307273,
-0.0136634605,
-0.0594957732,
0.0460420698,
-0.0074819853,
0.0058196941,
-0.0333938189,
0.0761482939,
0.0134727145,
-0.0253933035,
0.0122479778,
-0.0006204445,
-0.018194247,
-0.0235484596,
0.0167929586,
0.0059198514,
-0.0315047726,
0.0023637072,
-0.0001857792,
0.027852077,
0.0142968213,
0.0023655444,
-0.0145961335,
0.0441329703,
-0.0254568923,
0.013532171,
-0.0126083819,
0.0546867512,
-0.0075567975,
-0.0036320137,
-0.0013139318,
-0.0010220193,
-0.0248284061,
-0.0403278433,
-0.022814462,
0.0376050808,
-0.0909480378,
-0.0251179803,
-0.0278263949,
0.0227710772,
-0.0550212376,
-0.0253534913,
-0.0058870008,
0.0683448017,
-0.0506640635,
0.0460959896,
-0.0294127576,
0.0416801088,
-0.0566018932,
0.0276319329,
0.0465633161,
-0.0290455855,
-0.0337162428,
0.0356161781,
0.0351451561,
-0.0232750718,
-0.0323981531,
-0.0034218992,
-0.0406618379,
-0.0405992679,
-0.0056214216,
-0.0507345721,
-0.0433500111,
-0.0514422506,
-0.0088138515,
0.0035487534,
0.0469347946,
-0.0292886198,
-0.0206830278,
-0.0398632102,
0.0292662866,
0.0251770467,
0.0182085838,
0.0548735335,
0.0333411023,
-0.0186431166,
0.0455517285,
0.0282871928,
-0.016413711,
0.036465995,
-0.0236938316,
-0.0177094769,
0.0296307746,
0.0144753139,
-0.018091565,
-0.021355534,
0.0326091424,
-0.0119682159,
0.0057871062,
0.0219015069,
-0.0260669813,
0.009160717,
0.0185216591,
0.0327099524,
-0.0609177314,
-0.0257972702,
0.0243290514,
0.0474622324,
-0.0186837111,
-0.0068977075,
0.04013009,
0.0127516398,
-0.0172297135,
0.011691506,
-0.0242385082,
0.0426096618,
-0.0112649146,
-0.020374937,
0.0275523998,
-0.0075084837,
-0.0394466557,
-0.0173379015,
0.0492360294,
0.0172271617,
0.0228783432,
-0.0147603266,
-0.003045832,
0.0169443171,
-0.0425081253,
0.054148823,
-0.015037423,
-0.0807119682,
-0.0314200446,
-0.0182306617,
0.0240467917,
0.0152101535,
0.0195980966,
-0.0381399058,
-0.0450351574,
-0.0183341987,
-0.0021665758,
0.0333932713,
-0.0198097173,
-0.0298663639,
0.0515680723,
-0.0368031114,
-0.0026792241,
-0.0356652141,
0.0096438872,
0.0508694761,
0.0248713046,
-0.0034994171,
0.0728942528,
0.023186231,
0.0653752759,
0.0074270037,
-0.0545239113,
-0.0010585198,
0.0315054245,
0.0361789502,
0.0283507705,
0.0449963585,
0.0047061271,
0.0028672344,
0.0638311803,
-0.033300858,
-0.026486557,
0.0155659122,
-0.0626484156,
-0.0713463649,
0.0192843657,
-0.0297910441,
-0.0031042092,
0.0228832215,
0.0147937806,
-0.063626349,
0.0449970551,
-0.0169475805,
0.0045350511,
-0.0555664301,
-0.008564827,
0.032569021,
0.0329412557,
-0.0405334197,
0.0778841078,
0.0143987611,
0.0215325542,
0.0710338727,
0.0424306095,
0.0083849626,
-0.0983248502,
-0.0059702354,
-0.0231723748,
-0.0271711405,
-0.005350037,
0.0181258172,
-0.0042466824,
-0.0695687011,
-0.017908629,
-0.1426326632,
0.0116709601,
-0.0257831253,
-0.0201862045,
0.0148713328,
0.0204472709,
-0.0026886384,
-0.0279129818,
-0.0735903531,
-0.0155039821,
0.0363583304,
0.0165285449,
0.0303535759,
0.0521051995,
0.0102368705,
-0.0419726484,
0.013324975,
0.0145849157,
0.0610004626,
-0.0076418626,
-0.0042194971,
-0.0176349375,
0.0167917274,
-0.0706341192,
0.0231202934,
-0.0380754024,
-0.0140107786,
0.0475967191,
0.0050134328,
0.0418605208,
0.069761157,
0.0324168503,
0.0300283954,
-0.0236925632,
-0.0242468975,
-0.0498678423,
0.0427146479,
-0.0084029324,
0.0160298217,
0.0401378162,
0.0030125449,
0.0429756492,
0.0135043534,
0.0336406641,
-0.0034977002,
-0.0499340631,
0.0291558653,
0.0244610887,
-0.0339422375,
-0.030103296,
0.0058369222,
-0.020836642,
0.0591098443,
-0.0374067351,
0.0187324621,
0.0743804798,
-0.0235577356,
-0.0263202786,
0.0101840347,
0.001363934,
-0.0467700809,
0.0260743517,
-0.0418161787,
0.0144583257,
-0.0504233837,
-0.0469745807,
-0.0226823315,
-0.0067079235,
-0.0159609579,
-0.0373570509,
0.0620258823,
-0.0200200379,
0.0229307655,
0.0006164925,
-0.076060079,
-0.0607857257,
-0.0063722478,
0.0322521068,
-0.0094987173,
-0.0159945991,
0.0104263574,
0.0155859375,
0.0145673323,
0.0324666798,
0.0309872832,
-0.0386973955,
0.0167786293,
-0.0244463272,
0.0411577635,
0.0199510381,
0.0497496612,
0.019227678,
-0.0142940553,
0.0499588363,
0.0083019827,
0.0385431051,
-0.0107446918,
0.0126562035,
-0.0168576371,
0.0104369679,
0.0109289791,
-0.0097264228,
-0.0009337529,
0.0383860022,
-0.0110622086,
-0.0564278811,
0.0919299796,
0.0329382122,
-0.044076696,
-0.0182272885,
-0.0483343489,
0.0211772341,
0.0366076678,
0.0249097999,
-0.0517054908,
-0.0099435346,
-0.0265720021,
0.0235549584,
-0.0186152421,
-0.0693766475,
-0.0195744429,
-0.1148250178,
0.0237794686,
-0.0158737078,
-0.0608654246,
-0.0714183599,
0.0075900536,
0.0392897092,
0.0321055315,
0.0437219739,
0.0138002411,
0.0435794033,
0.0005373229,
-0.0108700898,
0.0539500639,
-0.0507371463,
0.005339548,
-0.0172755942,
0.042993702,
0.0361609422,
0.0556369983,
0.0242565144,
-0.035162013,
-0.0193056688,
-0.046831008,
0.0082066255,
0.0040651513,
0.0376759954,
-0.0144932363,
-0.0241128914,
-0.0278750323,
0.0255339127,
-0.0125384657,
-0.017019093,
0.0043152319,
-0.0103895366,
-0.0331373028,
0.0501843281,
0.0218698699,
0.0438110717,
0.0410542861,
0.0576430336,
0.0395890065,
-0.0077573233,
0.0061618793,
-0.0063332482,
0.0769596621,
-0.0578389876,
-0.0038778968,
-0.0125809005,
0.0071202451,
0.0321888886,
-0.1040470451,
-0.0286257565,
0.0241922867,
0.0491728149,
-0.028793931,
-0.0130093908,
-0.0227137432,
-0.023113003,
-0.0277660303,
0.0238884874,
-0.0299331322,
0.0121469544,
-0.0481341742,
-0.0019081184,
0.0517402031,
-0.0527621508,
-0.0242886785,
-0.0185430162,
-0.0308422726,
-0.0432176143,
-0.044314608,
0.0484686159,
0.0173611492,
0.045204211,
0.0070712827,
-0.0035081215,
-0.0070205997,
-0.0003417842,
-0.0348132662,
0.0357547067,
0.0118162595,
0.0580574572,
-0.042104017,
0.0480017439,
-0.052602876,
0.0294576045,
-0.0175125059,
0.0618719421,
-0.0164091215,
-0.0902564228,
0.0136794439,
0.0137386769,
0.0393144339,
0.0507569686,
-0.0148639828,
-0.0343100913,
0.011083195,
-0.0566466227,
-0.0331149064,
-0.0271346793,
-0.0051249149,
-0.004694744,
-0.0116471723,
0.0116386609,
-0.0297648106,
-0.0167291909,
0.0947843269,
-0.0423046164,
-0.0629308373,
0.0249284524,
-0.0152391577,
-0.0230017919,
0.0170620754,
-0.0422075316,
0.0069495779,
0.0051110187,
0.0649990365,
-0.004356897,
0.0885628015,
-0.002049736,
-0.0277786218,
-0.0328711495,
0.0420632213,
-0.0579671077,
0.0275495164,
0.0146254888,
0.0224497337,
0.0015819778,
0.0384546109,
0.0254842564,
0.0462342054,
0.0028051117,
0.0035639938,
0.0131622301,
0.01071674,
-0.0422084481,
0.0249070339,
0.0229962189,
-0.0042512584,
0.033147417,
0.0586784557,
-0.0390615687,
0.0077451221,
-0.0400464796,
-0.0119518796,
-0.0509956367,
-0.0225570146,
0.0101861916,
0.0626413152,
0.0306523927,
0.0067364192,
-0.040030852,
-0.0272865035,
0.0142689552,
-0.002048095,
-0.0344609991,
-0.0003663146,
0.0143577689,
0.0421063676,
0.0085268561,
-0.0180755556,
-0.0261370894,
0.0036431088,
-0.0483952425,
-0.0092567587,
-0.0417361036,
-5.822636412e-33,
-0.0975190252,
-0.0149222752,
0.0119555993,
-0.01787889,
-0.0838856697,
0.029243974,
-0.0551202148,
-0.0118273711,
-0.0000099459,
-0.01765576,
-0.0027291626,
0.0075224438,
-0.0103697609,
0.0335392021,
-0.0446212515,
-0.0186609942,
0.0322829746,
0.0349646993,
-0.015079394,
0.0682898015,
0.0645201355,
0.0167126711,
-0.0058884048,
-0.0583925992,
-0.0014694517,
-0.0041105328,
0.0142320013,
0.0344131365,
0.0016152002,
0.0538039394,
-0.0351933427,
0.0369230546,
0.0261006653,
-0.0247456115,
0.036825031,
0.0584844425,
-0.0579239689,
-0.0415818691,
0.0003598027,
-0.0180686172,
-0.0271247327,
-0.0396902524,
0.0223688427,
-0.0302880127,
0.0319509618,
0.028227821,
-0.0035111893,
0.0090441722,
0.0066381739,
-0.0264360309,
-0.0461682901,
-0.0143049089,
-0.0197970625,
-0.0183752012,
-0.0394495875,
0.0828903392,
0.0210796613,
-0.0093908701,
-0.0789151415,
-0.0028668747,
-0.0615990087,
-0.0373217575,
0.0054256124,
0.0706217661,
-0.0057295822,
0.0650605038,
0.00599061,
0.0227688439,
-0.043696221,
-0.0518769324,
-0.0143507877,
0.0386748724,
0.015122191,
0.0881041288,
-0.0489558615,
-0.0117398566,
-0.0419446751,
0.0394585989,
0.0436525829,
-0.0159395989,
0.0233889371,
-0.0043437467,
-0.0296010878,
-0.0254336838,
-0.0295557268,
-0.0177831799,
-0.0358442999,
-0.0194320474,
0.0561766438,
0.0167367831,
-0.0509878062,
-0.0132897226,
0.0398370214,
-0.0370235667,
0.0263360702,
0.045775149,
-0.0375040136,
0.009969933,
0.0030661509,
0.0097060241,
-0.0153775373,
-0.02042762,
0.0821070746,
-0.0007505667,
0.0158089548,
0.0032124394,
-0.0023456118,
-0.0284255873,
-0.0393955223,
-0.0144636054,
-0.0190286338,
0.0612580292,
-0.0385003909,
0.0611203499,
-0.0020110232,
0.0270466227,
-0.0190240871,
0.0446615852,
0.0458042547,
0.013439415,
-0.0199264772,
-0.0774528831,
0.0101283453,
0.0177476481,
-0.0426717997,
0.0168070961,
0.0253828131,
0.0069651757,
0.0131372456,
-0.0450101681,
-0.0063785887,
-0.0187352318,
2.457e-7,
-0.0335492417,
-0.004756751,
0.0330593735,
-0.0153536834,
0.0131027568,
0.0353826508,
0.0095045688,
0.0303138569,
0.0236292128,
-0.048796773,
-0.0010737072,
0.0217368416,
0.0241905656,
-0.0029941832,
-0.0937203988,
-0.0530494824,
-0.0519806221,
-0.0342525505,
-0.025260333,
-0.0448069163,
0.073802188,
0.0480322391,
-0.0104282862,
0.012563115,
-0.0043343632,
-0.0130903386,
0.067730546,
0.0014065943,
0.0087579535,
-0.017103374,
0.0416434444,
-0.0051356452,
0.0213254802,
0.049693495,
0.0396673419,
0.0730023012,
0.0300223529,
0.040587198,
-0.0026208216,
-0.0597143471,
-0.0117159467,
0.0439211689,
0.0326815285,
-0.053892076,
0.0695773959,
-0.0474664979,
-0.0106577091,
-0.0026662047,
-0.0574762858,
-0.0118782632,
0.0238557067,
-0.0131558608,
-0.032739155,
0.0292623993,
0.0055205543,
0.0031085352,
0.0215403754,
-0.1109232977,
0.0051774988,
-0.0244650766,
-0.0555490479,
-0.0100774458,
-0.0096885581,
-0.0423409268,
-0.0170536228,
-0.0339914635,
0.0278254803,
2.032243995e-34,
-0.0135184489,
0.0093259104,
0.0083916662,
0.0181507245,
0.0627152845,
-0.0166622121,
-0.0242914613,
-0.0018869546,
0.0214394573,
-0.0644818544,
0.0017803451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06605v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06605v2 | UniAdapter: Unified Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning for Cross-modal Modeling | 2023-02-13T18:59:10 | 2023-05-21T17:50:30 | Haoyu Lu, Yuqi Huo, Guoxing Yang, Zhiwu Lu, Wei Zhan, Masayoshi Tomizuka, Mingyu Ding | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large-scale vision-language pre-trained models have shown promising
transferability to various downstream tasks. As the size of these foundation
models and the number of downstream tasks grow, the standard full fine-tuning
paradigm becomes unsustainable due to heavy computational and storage costs.
This paper proposes UniAdapter, which unifies unimodal and multimodal adapters
for parameter-efficient cross-modal adaptation on pre-trained vision-language
models. Specifically, adapters are distributed to different modalities and
their interactions, with the total number of tunable parameters reduced by
partial weight sharing. The unified and knowledge-sharing design enables
powerful cross-modal representations that can benefit various downstream tasks,
requiring only 1.0%-2.0% tunable parameters of the pre-trained model. Extensive
experiments on 6 cross-modal downstream benchmarks (including video-text
retrieval, image-text retrieval, VideoQA, and VQA) show that in most cases,
UniAdapter not only outperforms the state-of-the-arts, but even beats the full
fine-tuning strategy. Particularly, on the MSRVTT retrieval task, UniAdapter
achieves 49.7% recall@1 with 2.2% model parameters, outperforming the latest
competitors by 2.0%. The code and models are available at
https://github.com/RERV/UniAdapter. | [
0.0037470576,
0.0485132225,
-0.0061856913,
0.0277259946,
0.0139626693,
-0.0024820464,
0.0287807342,
-0.0157425553,
0.0057151113,
-0.074519664,
-0.0999568179,
-0.0203103106,
-0.0260233209,
0.044554241,
0.0036241398,
-0.0629302487,
0.0502241701,
-0.0218554065,
-0.0334602408,
-0.0084263766,
0.0152565194,
-0.0052834847,
-0.0156492386,
0.012029347,
0.0016290223,
0.0134525644,
-0.0186039824,
0.0110363029,
0.0064918427,
0.001404892,
0.0157643557,
0.0292773582,
0.0453755371,
0.0095744217,
0.0000021805,
-0.0091064181,
-0.0291964617,
-0.0249550994,
0.0167947076,
-0.0127949072,
0.0765594766,
-0.0405532345,
0.0136616724,
0.0153629137,
-0.0131770223,
-0.0525803827,
0.0806398988,
0.0200255625,
0.0318298526,
0.0665294379,
-0.034171354,
0.0090227937,
0.0271232016,
-0.0142733464,
0.028552169,
-0.0438984483,
0.0137017732,
-0.0017503691,
-0.0250757933,
0.0122841103,
-0.0527251437,
0.0458458848,
-0.0137068974,
0.0035523118,
-0.0208627377,
0.0025600623,
-0.0297318567,
-0.0013794015,
-0.0503672697,
0.0767295882,
-0.0150684444,
-0.013164388,
-0.0178393982,
-0.0119776931,
0.0013930651,
0.0314361565,
-0.0388755798,
-0.0087340754,
0.0027470572,
0.0060052392,
-0.0642405599,
-0.0012432088,
0.0052236719,
0.0031442901,
-0.0184655357,
-0.0064939121,
0.0301371478,
0.0423141867,
0.0299034417,
-0.0114737572,
-0.0067475992,
-0.0188699476,
0.0194199719,
0.0311864335,
-0.0035351508,
-0.0246340036,
-0.063387543,
-0.0618004911,
-0.0312509052,
-0.001736955,
0.0992229208,
0.0414235257,
-0.0733440965,
0.0561436377,
-0.0749882236,
0.0398180261,
-0.0555878691,
0.0622810349,
-0.0356130488,
-0.0445334576,
-0.0560698397,
0.0152079845,
-0.0432947762,
-0.0030367787,
-0.055643443,
-0.0400797352,
0.0022408012,
0.0358341038,
0.0138717154,
-0.0785608068,
0.0231550224,
0.0065140952,
-0.0315850638,
-0.0376444645,
-0.0270496737,
0.0975860283,
0.0206889473,
0.0351946652,
-0.0096955979,
-0.04851228,
0.0029256435,
0.0294604767,
0.0399966724,
-0.0342059098,
0.0310350861,
0.0965648815,
-0.0639156401,
-0.0563951321,
-0.0166299418,
0.0001979826,
-0.0027209963,
-0.0063024857,
0.0580511801,
-0.0178634226,
0.0286540575,
-0.0038954304,
0.0138684427,
-0.0283141378,
-0.0175838377,
-0.009531172,
-0.0205494799,
0.1037915871,
0.0128839631,
0.0082292622,
-0.0084803849,
-0.0147342412,
-0.0120608648,
0.0679620653,
0.0167955309,
0.057135161,
0.0050914939,
-0.0100047756,
0.0000376418,
-0.0006904736,
0.0190708246,
0.0135437641,
-0.0229381975,
-0.0207037069,
0.0391119123,
-0.0003225114,
0.0614013486,
0.0335080922,
-0.020008713,
-0.0284513608,
0.0647164285,
-0.0228184443,
0.0680356398,
0.0161456298,
0.0270805359,
-0.0113293771,
-0.0121516772,
-0.0423191153,
-0.0675998628,
0.0762869418,
-0.0317234658,
-0.0371561199,
0.000685645,
0.0369689912,
-0.0562641919,
-0.0199308284,
0.0473941267,
-0.0052341549,
0.0137699647,
0.0269887876,
0.0551492609,
-0.0108212708,
-0.0483465791,
0.0259109829,
0.0385529734,
-0.0414451882,
0.0202443469,
-0.0331807844,
0.0121763097,
0.0343712308,
-0.0161081981,
-0.0334164314,
-0.007713946,
0.0216213409,
0.0440615267,
0.0043758922,
0.0171598438,
0.006560476,
0.0666732565,
-0.060989134,
-0.0542401187,
-0.0246386733,
0.0039841365,
0.0636487305,
-0.0383134708,
0.0407266803,
0.0147216432,
-0.0249794293,
0.0577616431,
0.0346566178,
0.0174082853,
-0.0142331934,
0.0011304341,
0.0096681025,
0.0036522744,
-0.0516518652,
-0.0209235456,
-0.0108408267,
0.0033632268,
-0.0591312312,
0.029788902,
0.0048709163,
-0.0533226021,
0.0122818854,
0.0252021514,
-0.0249789972,
0.0540235825,
0.050640028,
0.0051171002,
-0.0302766915,
0.0377839692,
0.0173529685,
0.0375212878,
-0.0438527353,
0.0042137085,
0.0043573109,
0.044729691,
0.0090443734,
0.0080594011,
0.0202392749,
-0.0409093015,
0.0033394895,
0.0033235168,
0.0098602455,
0.0047722515,
-0.0173977483,
0.0040110382,
-0.0128785353,
0.0266004745,
-0.0037208386,
0.0019842198,
-0.0087236175,
-0.034909755,
-0.1209764928,
0.0080339536,
-0.033608824,
0.0079055801,
-0.0049315747,
0.0260984097,
-0.012508207,
-0.0510024019,
-0.0112659596,
0.0786186382,
0.0023851786,
0.0398255661,
-0.0181175116,
0.010215505,
0.0353045203,
-0.0195830949,
-0.0081726145,
0.0278370548,
0.0262834691,
-0.0390031822,
-0.0380559899,
-0.0238400046,
0.0255406108,
-0.0066834972,
0.0498263612,
-0.022234844,
-0.0184120201,
-0.0084940726,
-0.0208629221,
0.0241752584,
0.0686218441,
0.0067895297,
-0.009579326,
0.022893846,
-0.0555133298,
-0.0377741605,
0.0136261173,
0.0019172981,
-0.0693590641,
-0.0396376513,
0.0583987162,
-0.0107099032,
0.0441192351,
-0.0447003357,
-0.0050062379,
-0.0653068051,
0.0021888537,
0.0135941524,
-0.0382495299,
-0.044889085,
0.0467753597,
-0.0076055364,
0.028556576,
-0.0172560811,
-0.0393538997,
0.0018090903,
-0.0299940687,
-0.0072325701,
0.0046323049,
0.0140490215,
-0.0185717493,
0.0799488202,
0.010425101,
0.0286331754,
0.0005230124,
-0.0217664409,
-0.071104005,
-0.0250474643,
0.0275347549,
-0.0125511819,
0.0408147164,
-0.0157674327,
0.009732238,
-0.0559389256,
-0.0196584743,
0.0106770815,
-0.0257815812,
-0.0252479631,
0.0134766633,
-0.0341712981,
0.0097511141,
-0.042858962,
0.0187216271,
0.0317554064,
0.0505434275,
-0.0104936082,
-0.0107035041,
-0.0331768245,
0.0209414419,
0.0241039358,
0.0516985841,
-0.0415996127,
-0.0131657096,
-0.0374479145,
0.0470579155,
0.0425549932,
-0.0147882113,
-0.0579109341,
0.0405439325,
0.0411600433,
0.0317636244,
-0.0264828,
0.0088736815,
0.0701217055,
-0.0464498624,
0.0189567003,
0.0324140675,
-0.0262277648,
-0.0680823699,
-0.0451098233,
0.0215595067,
0.011660465,
0.028902391,
0.0374177471,
-0.0597943366,
-0.0842949525,
-0.0171491448,
-0.0028874385,
0.050529819,
-0.00397444,
-0.0101515027,
-0.051598493,
0.0237844773,
0.0080789048,
-0.0240350533,
-0.0357181057,
0.000272674,
0.0133349551,
-0.0439643189,
0.0005969958,
0.0138794323,
-0.0480508246,
-0.0200626664,
0.0202014539,
0.0674269199,
-0.0250206739,
0.0077275103,
-0.0458965935,
0.0014882279,
0.0228422191,
-0.0088493302,
-0.0016956259,
-0.0667574853,
0.0317578763,
-0.0480080545,
0.0088749193,
0.0009967549,
0.0428259075,
-0.0323946476,
-0.0488170311,
0.0236873273,
-0.0058484492,
-0.0331663601,
-0.0210350547,
-0.0325049311,
0.0469702035,
0.0199480541,
0.0063148947,
-0.0217494722,
-0.0434990488,
-0.0187364426,
0.023132205,
-0.0205682125,
-0.0255045053,
-0.0339137539,
0.0100599807,
-0.0284544993,
-0.0220423155,
-0.0449989215,
-0.0036608959,
-0.014428962,
-0.0247369334,
-0.0346897878,
0.0105014984,
0.0192072149,
0.0702932999,
0.0002248476,
-0.0158751644,
-0.0051995353,
0.0201238226,
-0.0640265718,
0.0582703389,
-0.0537569448,
0.0094751921,
-0.0382294729,
-0.0111399628,
0.0409148,
-0.0501217581,
0.0053524426,
0.0127842519,
-0.0505108312,
-0.0482514985,
-0.0232893005,
0.0589915179,
0.0093337605,
0.036658816,
0.0189147461,
-0.0518208444,
0.0551653057,
0.0232372247,
-0.0026856191,
0.0398749746,
0.0375944711,
-0.0269591324,
-0.0183477104,
0.0188066363,
-0.0725508258,
0.0125821596,
0.0381062888,
0.0076531167,
0.0131410928,
-0.0318362005,
0.0124509791,
-0.0208670758,
0.0566654578,
0.0320831053,
0.0183184296,
-0.0497448593,
0.021897234,
0.0133344643,
0.0098571535,
-0.0776680112,
0.0203433763,
0.0288963635,
0.0064035435,
0.0110314637,
0.0142743671,
0.0421280749,
0.0228125136,
-0.0298983213,
0.0153479548,
0.0119574405,
0.0248508938,
-0.0128228124,
0.0274396334,
0.0027368995,
0.0133396462,
0.0256007928,
0.043352291,
-0.0505826883,
0.0548517704,
0.0050085536,
-0.0355723053,
-0.0609145425,
0.0678805113,
-0.0270955879,
-0.0356944166,
-0.0419892594,
0.0240532756,
0.010493217,
-0.0073888903,
0.0235642586,
0.0133327367,
-0.0051677497,
-0.0482138358,
0.0493682437,
-0.0031049328,
0.0301144198,
0.054995317,
0.0141764618,
0.0033822353,
-0.0023415666,
0.0436354689,
-0.0303925462,
0.0429974683,
0.0056704865,
0.0088378908,
-0.013121753,
-0.0094395839,
0.052478049,
-0.0044118711,
-0.0243514329,
-0.0035973149,
0.0263602473,
-0.0308784172,
0.0116888518,
0.0021970465,
-0.0208880398,
0.0106768599,
0.0362932011,
0.0553696863,
0.0224635731,
-0.0123112462,
-0.0191506576,
-0.0317099914,
-0.0009244872,
0.0444631167,
0.038869109,
-6.465769942e-33,
-0.0464318432,
0.0450852364,
0.0396772474,
-0.027036598,
-0.0317155048,
0.0099735027,
-0.0225113034,
0.0482436456,
-0.039351698,
-0.0184621606,
0.030920174,
-0.0201149564,
0.0231530592,
0.0247141235,
-0.0088901101,
-0.0091755874,
0.0326943062,
-0.0085380869,
-0.0125748171,
0.0201383214,
0.0458217785,
0.0418075137,
0.0485600121,
-0.0815918595,
-0.0471222363,
0.0530052558,
-0.0103042014,
-0.0040316964,
0.0311484076,
0.0715971068,
-0.0158220269,
0.0331617817,
0.016929226,
0.018921487,
-0.0217484757,
0.028970249,
-0.0736585259,
-0.0009732577,
0.0038787485,
0.022679003,
-0.061316859,
-0.0228219293,
0.0496111885,
-0.0184285063,
0.0146348551,
-0.0357242115,
0.0244167298,
-0.0230238922,
-0.0208712071,
0.0266825836,
-0.0624482483,
0.0160282254,
0.0334766582,
-0.0515490919,
0.0551548749,
0.0364540964,
0.0460899025,
0.0325449258,
-0.0256137904,
0.0046862322,
-0.061211057,
0.0404521264,
0.0503125414,
0.0464474037,
0.00288709,
0.0534437485,
0.0444070324,
-0.0712024868,
0.0228599217,
-0.0442143567,
0.0562969632,
0.0580279492,
0.0175194815,
0.10179656,
0.0176395215,
-0.0353230685,
-0.0244259443,
-0.0042363219,
-0.0167681444,
0.0511674099,
-0.0054101772,
0.063085489,
0.0167436879,
0.0146085192,
-0.0364600457,
-0.0419665128,
-0.0453615822,
-0.0370522626,
0.0569684878,
0.0424045548,
-0.0159745682,
0.0259131715,
0.1099115387,
-0.0291436277,
0.0218997896,
-0.0039467523,
-0.0148864547,
0.0335486941,
-0.0088320961,
0.0287083536,
-0.0443431996,
-0.0447780862,
0.0571671575,
-0.0429459736,
-0.0051801931,
-0.0044641662,
0.0008348355,
0.0524971224,
-0.0721407831,
-0.0168524887,
-0.0253649931,
-0.0120389387,
0.0108872326,
0.0954613388,
0.02757442,
0.0022108615,
-0.0419258177,
0.0249054953,
-0.011966764,
-0.0213711653,
-0.0497074053,
-0.0721849352,
0.046990972,
0.0319293439,
-0.0085306829,
0.0097688446,
-0.0650665015,
-0.0223635063,
0.0058200588,
-0.0445068032,
-0.0120745106,
0.0521604829,
2.963e-7,
0.0421637781,
0.0037873527,
-0.0145544875,
-0.0670546517,
0.011170458,
0.053210929,
-0.0181234255,
0.0581294335,
0.0101781776,
-0.044791013,
-0.0192177948,
0.0496359654,
0.0307464916,
-0.0104808025,
-0.0048416252,
0.012806071,
0.0172467083,
-0.002716451,
-0.000028172,
-0.0409098454,
0.0322559848,
0.0906825513,
-0.0315547474,
-0.0079236208,
0.0425260067,
-0.0692561343,
0.1012464538,
-0.0351065695,
-0.0211502891,
-0.0156682003,
-0.0182310678,
0.031781137,
-0.0512767434,
-0.0001162634,
0.0165525302,
0.0264608357,
0.029001588,
0.0273539852,
-0.0254670121,
-0.0622284971,
0.0098072989,
0.0384490788,
-0.0235835668,
-0.0300387591,
0.0758505464,
-0.0459808372,
-0.0057559735,
-0.0591928773,
-0.0191065185,
0.0124618988,
0.006244326,
-0.0105660241,
-0.0213247817,
0.0081331022,
0.0304451007,
0.0090058176,
-0.0812272802,
-0.1011631936,
0.0126679521,
-0.0072552613,
-0.0278804041,
-0.0203183126,
-0.0747831091,
-0.036092259,
0.0741717219,
-0.053147044,
-0.011642742,
2.084858847e-34,
-0.0127641829,
-0.0260754284,
0.0248726271,
-0.0289653689,
-0.0156577155,
-0.0149772018,
-0.0158076901,
-0.0006889297,
0.0025108443,
-0.072470516,
-0.0268416349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06600v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06600v2 | Task-Specific Skill Localization in Fine-tuned Language Models | 2023-02-13T18:55:52 | 2023-07-02T01:55:00 | Abhishek Panigrahi, Nikunj Saunshi, Haoyu Zhao, Sanjeev Arora | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models can be fine-tuned to solve diverse NLP tasks,
including in few-shot settings. Thus fine-tuning allows the model to quickly
pick up task-specific ``skills,'' but there has been limited study of where
these newly-learnt skills reside inside the massive model. This paper
introduces the term skill localization for this problem and proposes a
solution. Given the downstream task and a model fine-tuned on that task, a
simple optimization is used to identify a very small subset of parameters
($\sim0.01$% of model parameters) responsible for ($>95$%) of the model's
performance, in the sense that grafting the fine-tuned values for just this
tiny subset onto the pre-trained model gives performance almost as well as the
fine-tuned model. While reminiscent of recent works on parameter-efficient
fine-tuning, the novel aspects here are that: (i) No further re-training is
needed on the subset (unlike, say, with lottery tickets). (ii) Notable
improvements are seen over vanilla fine-tuning with respect to calibration of
predictions in-distribution ($40$-$90$% error reduction) as well as the quality
of predictions out-of-distribution (OOD). In models trained on multiple tasks,
a stronger notion of skill localization is observed, where the sparse regions
corresponding to different tasks are almost disjoint, and their overlap (when
it happens) is a proxy for task similarity. Experiments suggest that
localization via grafting can assist certain forms of continual learning. | [
0.0578391701,
0.0344481692,
-0.0141458074,
0.0177437533,
-0.0125880549,
0.0033293469,
0.0026803683,
-0.0163837168,
-0.0430324785,
-0.0593813881,
-0.0738277435,
-0.0192213487,
0.003745863,
-0.0024809176,
0.0426103994,
-0.0404131599,
0.0143920453,
-0.016183326,
-0.0038991522,
-0.0013089462,
0.004260988,
-0.0014907115,
0.0221706498,
0.077907905,
0.0217851643,
-0.005236988,
0.0169639084,
0.0073447176,
-0.0050946372,
0.0279759783,
0.0377869606,
0.0597749799,
0.0178300682,
-0.0226893537,
0.0000021508,
-0.0139787225,
-0.0204054136,
-0.006226772,
-0.0416908786,
-0.0088372743,
0.0457654782,
-0.0247669369,
0.0102725569,
0.0523405634,
-0.0311037619,
-0.0337740891,
0.0484090559,
0.0049021463,
0.0136580067,
0.079346709,
0.0003769751,
0.0218151156,
0.0132987648,
-0.0480274931,
-0.0046510906,
-0.076302737,
0.0098860636,
0.0179307815,
-0.0182681605,
0.0107762311,
-0.0221002586,
0.0193540249,
-0.00718841,
0.0175563022,
0.0185863655,
0.0144319339,
-0.0148620643,
0.0071962653,
-0.0139788846,
-0.0101216678,
-0.1098972633,
-0.0543674268,
-0.0074549732,
-0.0186204556,
0.0059041078,
0.035519924,
-0.0544319116,
0.0135076568,
0.0316736251,
0.0028072512,
0.0319449231,
-0.024150962,
0.0200025178,
0.0278935935,
-0.0005190679,
0.0318709575,
-0.000278811,
-0.0255993661,
-0.0386734568,
0.0292873569,
-0.0804072022,
-0.0529822186,
0.0135711562,
0.0325528942,
-0.021569157,
0.0100880042,
-0.0605775788,
0.0071156654,
-0.0183886066,
-0.0054054917,
0.0908582956,
0.0372558124,
0.0035419681,
0.0434531905,
-0.0117401015,
0.0263672583,
-0.0003225557,
0.0304389875,
-0.0712463558,
-0.0196474288,
-0.0864288807,
-0.035802912,
-0.0418365709,
0.0017235652,
-0.0200458635,
-0.0282384511,
-0.0174084324,
0.0027826284,
-0.0153066823,
-0.02590058,
0.0201740544,
0.0226059649,
-0.0745060146,
0.0012151271,
0.0069769006,
0.0368945971,
-0.0255653933,
0.0513924547,
0.0081806369,
-0.0182881169,
-0.0341059342,
0.0101238079,
0.0210226849,
-0.0246120039,
0.0221031941,
0.0484554507,
0.0128799733,
-0.0182696506,
-0.0110203112,
-0.0273376852,
-0.0261108726,
-0.0696714967,
-0.0034825632,
-0.0436250269,
0.0053030895,
0.0051528518,
0.0116098113,
-0.0496331416,
-0.0155393071,
0.016341418,
-0.0512410328,
0.0788368136,
0.016877858,
0.0415458456,
-0.0105732465,
-0.0351576917,
-0.0109313568,
0.0680665672,
0.0078300508,
0.0150288884,
0.0241396595,
-0.0128893554,
0.0334299318,
0.0277676582,
0.0185476877,
0.0035219728,
-0.0032665795,
-0.0233794581,
0.0676958635,
-0.0084766522,
0.0444603041,
-0.0318570547,
-0.025947975,
0.0618226826,
0.0732976645,
0.0416645966,
0.0570909716,
0.0038531683,
0.0384775624,
0.0006059114,
-0.0064391997,
0.0100430055,
-0.0959722921,
0.0036854274,
-0.0074719987,
-0.0093861995,
-0.0108189648,
0.0281581972,
-0.0191824492,
-0.0213698484,
-0.021438228,
0.0136294654,
-0.0312501714,
0.0343759134,
0.0563557632,
0.0198198855,
-0.0349614844,
0.0323493928,
0.0331606306,
0.0075870617,
0.0246712342,
-0.0484319218,
-0.0357879587,
0.0480872653,
0.0107244244,
-0.0328966081,
-0.0525318123,
0.0134414313,
0.0222271476,
-0.0167988278,
0.0441152491,
-0.010824576,
0.0082533704,
-0.0261329506,
-0.0386899263,
-0.0417928211,
0.0295084305,
-0.0029084519,
0.0247196835,
0.0026646501,
0.0015980861,
-0.0273532532,
-0.0328025632,
0.0262015183,
-0.0195854343,
-0.0049214489,
-0.0144669628,
0.0120082246,
-0.0109308502,
-0.0063707861,
-0.0134686129,
0.0206593592,
0.0159383062,
-0.0326585136,
0.0227192231,
0.0009479251,
-0.0298434757,
-0.0097004864,
0.039268259,
0.0144109614,
0.0298957899,
0.0427387096,
-0.018749034,
-0.0361002572,
0.0108537618,
-0.0038982877,
0.0316600241,
-0.0040991111,
0.0560963601,
-0.0339571573,
-0.0046473155,
-0.0588551797,
0.0525342263,
0.0168667417,
0.0202432983,
-0.0213754885,
0.0128509561,
-0.0025794634,
-0.0582241602,
-0.0096010324,
-0.0300206579,
-0.0177330337,
0.0423295684,
0.0170029178,
0.0080848113,
-0.0053401035,
-0.0581935681,
-0.0594517067,
0.049436789,
-0.0365824141,
0.0064380681,
0.0495606773,
-0.0211315975,
-0.0015379387,
-0.0218101479,
-0.0263076443,
-0.0214128681,
0.0246574972,
0.009772392,
0.0049464018,
0.0034021495,
0.0068797874,
-0.030286517,
-0.0107474551,
0.0030829301,
0.0122482525,
-0.0068645617,
0.0241985768,
-0.0995743498,
0.0537046157,
0.0138548296,
0.0469614863,
0.0063392306,
-0.0411994345,
-0.0285171773,
0.0001254019,
-0.0019392699,
0.0987616256,
-0.0544744544,
0.0259801745,
0.0447474681,
0.0097671179,
-0.0334449075,
0.0008583843,
-0.0389955863,
-0.0459387079,
-0.0481499918,
0.0269040838,
-0.017384816,
0.0705137327,
0.0084542045,
-0.020964697,
-0.0603952333,
0.0371016189,
-0.0299433917,
-0.0325887576,
-0.0080620181,
0.0158494636,
-0.0077419253,
0.0130212549,
-0.0547748134,
-0.0547811091,
0.0176784974,
-0.0068953177,
0.0266674198,
-0.0433683842,
-0.0514421277,
-0.0090513043,
0.0377896018,
-0.0004076558,
0.0203291904,
0.0003189991,
-0.0367032439,
-0.0812253803,
0.0124783693,
0.02844215,
-0.0151001783,
-0.007351818,
-0.0141030904,
-0.0111660026,
-0.0114584072,
-0.0455912352,
-0.0198489893,
-0.0335246772,
-0.016415067,
0.035003189,
0.0531104356,
-0.0026332012,
-0.0386070758,
0.0343230739,
-0.0223106109,
0.0403387025,
-0.0369903371,
0.0064877779,
-0.0416092575,
0.0082773948,
0.0858266875,
0.05373732,
-0.0158371255,
-0.0401605964,
-0.0434756167,
0.0223875716,
0.0346065462,
0.0201953631,
-0.0205292515,
0.0279388987,
0.0488188006,
-0.0507476889,
-0.0484096259,
0.0065016919,
0.094838798,
-0.0662214085,
-0.0394854546,
0.1101962104,
0.0234891325,
-0.0394847728,
0.013995382,
0.0235658363,
-0.0049511092,
0.0449078567,
0.0330895744,
-0.019361876,
-0.0245287754,
0.0499179326,
0.017729206,
0.0039034777,
0.0027390807,
0.0018277833,
-0.1279384345,
0.0289354939,
0.00726326,
-0.0238334779,
-0.040267244,
0.0038369542,
0.0138888415,
-0.0175015237,
0.0150733758,
-0.010052002,
-0.0129001867,
0.0196196288,
0.0504026935,
0.0189619213,
-0.0875843838,
0.0204306114,
-0.0568977632,
0.076389119,
0.0496261306,
0.0040877583,
0.0203801021,
0.0073127626,
0.0389810167,
0.0156186102,
0.0240640212,
0.0102195507,
0.0589266159,
-0.0298753791,
-0.0115749072,
0.0092536369,
0.0300575495,
-0.0208023172,
-0.0135318805,
-0.0067181452,
0.0650953576,
-0.0034995184,
0.0094378237,
0.0222807825,
-0.0291068703,
0.0050159008,
0.0628844127,
0.0157565065,
-0.0513482615,
-0.0547306724,
-0.010517587,
-0.0038961205,
-0.0169216581,
-0.0310750231,
0.0292060412,
-0.000975536,
-0.0201558489,
-0.0416079313,
-0.0201517958,
0.0638845786,
0.063654691,
0.0267669447,
0.0295456722,
0.0083939591,
-0.0140069127,
-0.0261025503,
0.0299836323,
-0.0610479079,
0.0094952434,
-0.0530809127,
-0.0332102329,
0.0409896486,
-0.0445186757,
-0.0311811529,
-0.0341077745,
-0.1020698547,
-0.0584022216,
-0.0238911565,
0.0494233668,
0.0246144179,
0.0484512746,
-0.0341621377,
-0.0983904526,
0.0424216613,
-0.0030883627,
-0.0667162016,
0.0284435116,
0.0138249248,
-0.038141463,
0.0054431292,
0.03818826,
-0.0244736038,
0.0254712198,
0.0513727926,
0.0285541844,
0.0087710992,
-0.014481755,
0.028656207,
-0.0362058617,
0.0749735162,
0.0142982593,
-0.0229839571,
-0.0475684628,
-0.0103016132,
0.0247351415,
-0.0307323709,
-0.0593851842,
-0.0153103387,
0.0547264032,
0.0246045738,
0.010400244,
-0.0066519016,
0.0299984924,
0.0316348597,
-0.0870245621,
-0.0058767926,
0.0145474477,
-0.0196634308,
0.0069721313,
0.0591093339,
0.0024122735,
0.0171817262,
0.0061878501,
0.0316395313,
-0.0122076999,
-0.0007864665,
0.0260493103,
0.0138134444,
-0.055588983,
0.0316410959,
-0.0703071579,
-0.0775009245,
-0.0371876098,
0.0245700367,
0.0936105773,
-0.0575875528,
0.0369299389,
0.0085985037,
-0.037381459,
-0.0100166043,
0.0094334958,
0.0230405778,
-0.0033855052,
0.0035613724,
0.0124820536,
-0.0249409005,
0.0012188233,
0.0873182639,
0.0336072706,
0.0625404939,
-0.0233053155,
-0.0470944084,
-0.0136479484,
-0.0010179935,
0.0319896117,
0.024696447,
-0.018407343,
0.0591696836,
-0.017245546,
-0.0768626779,
-0.0153670479,
-0.007326649,
-0.0151528548,
-0.0294514429,
0.0255334098,
0.0619896688,
-0.0293844547,
-0.0055406196,
-0.0506579094,
-0.0299636796,
0.0425512008,
0.0061732009,
-0.008357387,
-6.582934403e-33,
-0.0264108311,
-0.0044820872,
0.0159481689,
0.0188013017,
0.0037926252,
0.0166319702,
-0.0087322993,
0.0161964186,
-0.0407965668,
0.0206923764,
-0.0216644742,
-0.0141387945,
0.0177014209,
-0.005451154,
0.0113418819,
-0.010288571,
0.0429525636,
-0.0078110476,
-0.0214680079,
-0.0037697023,
0.013772917,
0.0372443497,
0.099908419,
-0.0415798165,
0.0023626888,
-0.0012506929,
-0.0184025094,
0.0236879848,
0.0175902229,
0.0517376289,
0.0066240602,
0.0364891849,
0.0220893603,
-0.0653123707,
-0.0396306626,
-0.0262138285,
-0.0590664074,
-0.030617794,
0.0193849839,
0.0141616147,
0.0063442029,
-0.0085838782,
0.0730836689,
-0.0019734076,
-0.037252225,
-0.0230963323,
0.0395866074,
-0.0326177515,
-0.0280752443,
0.0020856757,
-0.0784847587,
-0.0000563826,
0.0183534231,
-0.0892936289,
0.0328621678,
-0.0080390163,
0.0012403603,
-0.0168607589,
-0.046034392,
-0.0256179105,
0.0341719091,
0.0879524797,
0.0395064279,
0.0292540658,
-0.0072605028,
0.0225475971,
0.0100267315,
0.0427820198,
0.0294251759,
-0.0346203595,
0.0643367916,
0.0462822728,
0.0152985835,
-0.0070228986,
0.0461692698,
-0.0092433132,
-0.0464375392,
0.0005775348,
0.014818307,
0.0321398228,
0.0539761819,
0.0211981647,
-0.0210940093,
-0.0324240588,
-0.0585889108,
-0.0383568071,
-0.0195818804,
0.0060870084,
0.0495357849,
0.0540594161,
-0.0219640229,
0.0184822008,
0.0358345099,
-0.0722717196,
0.0305577125,
0.0012868734,
-0.0135717066,
0.0226602964,
-0.0112500228,
0.0125859259,
-0.068729274,
-0.0464345329,
-0.0305559449,
-0.0049071508,
0.0002117666,
0.0168955866,
0.036104966,
0.0326244645,
-0.0500810854,
0.0057483288,
-0.0418436266,
0.0153493015,
0.0223984737,
0.0898397788,
0.0720622241,
-0.0002015483,
-0.0092871916,
0.0212644655,
0.0311082378,
-0.017617248,
-0.0110060079,
0.0333853178,
0.0224630088,
-0.0008854725,
-0.0192703418,
-0.0011288511,
-0.0527305603,
-0.0371017084,
0.0022024126,
-0.0130333826,
-0.029126605,
-0.0101213856,
2.813e-7,
0.0546381511,
0.0355784446,
-0.0267125312,
0.0032581142,
0.0143957576,
0.027660884,
-0.0183079801,
0.0152078541,
0.0219272021,
0.0219224803,
-0.0047326498,
0.0435224064,
0.0305230599,
-0.0408049449,
-0.0962873325,
0.0186589379,
-0.0302572884,
0.0532288104,
-0.0177749023,
-0.0201614909,
-0.0438987538,
0.1223159581,
0.0229946002,
-0.0019792842,
-0.0019901455,
-0.0651848912,
0.0472066551,
-0.0225026514,
-0.0082177753,
0.0436756127,
-0.0224000718,
0.0597268417,
-0.0254381243,
0.0264805816,
-0.0124020642,
0.0497302115,
0.0319977403,
0.0649335012,
-0.0311743245,
0.0220391732,
-0.0322532542,
0.0078853844,
-0.0053701783,
-0.0536398776,
0.0725741982,
-0.0958601832,
-0.0500288233,
-0.0511316843,
0.0017180374,
-0.0147888316,
-0.0027908476,
0.0151814232,
-0.0053655622,
0.0157875791,
0.0262477733,
0.0308677312,
-0.0495508127,
-0.0945876688,
-0.0206439551,
0.0418918654,
-0.0213230588,
-0.0442505665,
0.0074561788,
-0.05250597,
0.0325315446,
-0.0774585903,
0.0081501557,
2.944498095e-34,
0.0222542193,
0.0174787194,
0.0542249307,
0.0275130086,
0.0297360271,
0.0161772836,
-0.0052553569,
0.0066893753,
0.0320903249,
-0.051129844,
-0.028234005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06598v1 | Gradient-Based Automated Iterative Recovery for Parameter-Efficient Tuning | 2023-02-13T18:54:58 | 2023-02-13T18:54:58 | Maximilian Mozes, Tolga Bolukbasi, Ann Yuan, Frederick Liu, Nithum Thain, Lucas Dixon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained large language models (LLMs) are able to solve a wide variety of
tasks through transfer learning. Various explainability methods have been
developed to investigate their decision making process. TracIn (Pruthi et al.,
2020) is one such gradient-based method which explains model inferences based
on the influence of training examples. In this paper, we explore the use of
TracIn to improve model performance in the parameter-efficient tuning (PET)
setting. We develop conversational safety classifiers via the prompt-tuning PET
method and show how the unique characteristics of the PET regime enable TracIn
to identify the cause for certain misclassifications by LLMs. We develop a new
methodology for using gradient-based explainability techniques to improve model
performance, G-BAIR: gradient-based automated iterative recovery. We show that
G-BAIR can recover LLM performance on benchmarks after manually corrupting
training labels. This suggests that influence methods like TracIn can be used
to automatically perform data cleaning, and introduces the potential for
interactive debugging and relabeling for PET-based transfer learning methods. | [
-0.0109535698,
0.085820131,
-0.0151418829,
0.0435440727,
0.0235586613,
0.0326921791,
-0.0022342938,
-0.0214301217,
-0.0434756577,
-0.0351317152,
-0.0481866933,
-0.0065118703,
0.0149079822,
0.0123245362,
0.0386984982,
-0.0606385171,
0.0493064225,
-0.0584401563,
-0.0011237027,
0.0122633297,
-0.0085501187,
0.0161547661,
-0.0062240162,
0.0477700308,
0.0053348588,
-0.0186484661,
-0.0036440596,
0.0060154321,
0.0005595912,
0.0192480627,
0.0280953161,
0.023431832,
0.0218515843,
0.0064722602,
0.0000024705,
-0.0189440139,
-0.049317874,
0.0146850729,
-0.0577030741,
0.0350302942,
0.0215499941,
0.0093689105,
-0.0045018876,
0.0591430292,
-0.0019385478,
-0.0079863798,
0.0607140288,
0.0295636691,
0.0638080314,
0.0801701024,
-0.0020887258,
-0.0158161446,
-0.0145129226,
-0.0061458102,
-0.0050273906,
-0.0786187798,
0.0171966348,
-0.0028778885,
-0.0689963847,
-0.0143840946,
0.0006404883,
0.0313033238,
-0.0089721587,
-0.0563695282,
0.0048951772,
-0.0362519547,
0.010382141,
-0.0343899392,
-0.0230140407,
0.0726270825,
-0.0390107706,
-0.0241089184,
0.0113605214,
-0.0299587902,
0.0072002634,
0.0010876431,
-0.0277081616,
-0.0044422247,
0.0393295474,
0.0370233767,
-0.0026609076,
-0.0156160314,
0.0674414858,
-0.0031700588,
-0.0406291597,
0.0534652583,
-0.0093889786,
0.0079347594,
0.002833426,
-0.0063504744,
-0.0240521841,
-0.0364414193,
-0.0057901214,
0.0266519245,
-0.0683749542,
0.034265589,
-0.0262685176,
-0.0318422876,
-0.0119675035,
-0.0106145991,
0.0679668039,
0.0103152404,
0.0121227847,
0.0169255994,
-0.0189160742,
0.0459211096,
0.0001262857,
0.0249421988,
-0.0309162885,
0.0003014551,
-0.0654946491,
-0.0032211768,
-0.045360554,
-0.0072328299,
-0.0165885948,
0.0249836519,
-0.0199133661,
0.0356798731,
-0.0272506289,
-0.0165973902,
0.0061715175,
-0.0184762217,
-0.0326649249,
-0.0073987362,
-0.0103137577,
0.0352989621,
0.0065750629,
0.0087003224,
0.0222620852,
-0.0559344552,
-0.0351109616,
0.0166818425,
0.0039863382,
-0.0289032981,
0.0089942496,
0.051634267,
-0.0401267782,
-0.0232557505,
-0.0462407805,
-0.0354871377,
-0.0175507385,
-0.0610292554,
-0.0156551972,
-0.0056541008,
0.002719305,
-0.0056383931,
0.0082989754,
-0.088003315,
-0.0155621711,
-0.0097686704,
-0.0568348728,
0.0936089605,
-0.0255336259,
0.0288024433,
0.0019602766,
0.0199034195,
-0.0493460856,
0.0444954336,
0.0340886526,
0.0022218132,
0.0438005552,
-0.0633853897,
0.0334117189,
0.0121208988,
0.0582585074,
-0.0063393945,
-0.0038420213,
-0.0260949321,
0.0332926996,
0.013497767,
0.0440951772,
0.0313650668,
-0.0058099004,
0.0204785857,
0.046279937,
0.007563944,
0.0428650826,
0.00554827,
0.0318583325,
0.0138765443,
-0.0099617979,
0.023913607,
-0.0542735271,
-0.0227931999,
-0.0465396866,
-0.0259974077,
0.0242226589,
-0.0013992412,
-0.0413058139,
-0.0487162806,
0.0173314922,
-0.0164425261,
0.0155199766,
0.0211245846,
0.0602718666,
0.0461373664,
-0.0543008409,
0.0620457493,
0.0481995232,
-0.0504051335,
-0.028587712,
-0.0717495382,
0.0393183865,
0.0674262419,
0.0049769515,
-0.0445282981,
0.0055196784,
-0.022070637,
0.0483562313,
-0.0283385627,
0.0263991337,
-0.0118781189,
0.073776722,
-0.0400080085,
-0.0368061848,
-0.0293014962,
0.0413617939,
0.0316064171,
0.0024509905,
-0.0042304578,
0.0230674259,
-0.0353444554,
-0.0810956731,
0.0476733185,
-0.0208350047,
-0.0632427037,
0.0411508754,
0.0076247533,
0.0360481776,
-0.0216352772,
-0.0033225659,
-0.0049090683,
0.0041301944,
-0.0051600938,
0.0464673601,
0.001592626,
-0.0477106199,
-0.017013127,
0.0132931853,
0.0193818361,
-0.0162885115,
0.0375666879,
-0.0615184531,
-0.0607077926,
0.0167097058,
-0.0113722412,
0.0202192832,
-0.0204236954,
0.0323233828,
-0.0558570512,
0.0292554833,
-0.0058901105,
0.0200758353,
0.0544802994,
-0.0309694838,
-0.0027084309,
0.0139713101,
-0.0124557735,
-0.04008108,
-0.0101067554,
0.0166553594,
-0.0110643236,
0.019834999,
0.0029074296,
-0.0001960657,
-0.0030406679,
0.0144818528,
-0.0510313176,
-0.0079045212,
-0.0234912224,
0.0154437162,
-0.0028547777,
-0.0078589227,
0.0038404358,
-0.0132130496,
0.0077356319,
0.0144214574,
-0.0118627371,
0.019165203,
0.0380143896,
0.0059513431,
-0.0454103909,
-0.0352368988,
-0.0031594452,
-0.0052119754,
0.0695343539,
-0.0063150693,
-0.0292485468,
-0.0924580768,
0.0445077643,
0.0161021724,
0.0057638199,
-0.0068644546,
-0.0356452689,
-0.0224644803,
0.025471827,
-0.0043196748,
0.0684527978,
-0.0040478036,
0.0604761429,
0.0361718684,
0.0196671095,
-0.0404443666,
-0.0088192066,
-0.0326733775,
-0.0814232081,
0.0012118035,
-0.0384148806,
0.0143362153,
0.082572408,
-0.0152899437,
-0.009891591,
-0.0502113849,
0.0062473789,
-0.0111097833,
-0.0359598249,
-0.0571362898,
-0.0248942208,
-0.0037322296,
0.0589762367,
0.0085082557,
-0.0793494731,
0.0663119182,
-0.0376094095,
0.0106984423,
-0.0210352559,
-0.0538277142,
0.0142215407,
0.0362597071,
-0.0012817816,
0.006648886,
0.0446298346,
-0.0404962078,
-0.0143105621,
-0.0462049283,
0.06067992,
-0.016452102,
0.0144301448,
-0.0539049953,
-0.0033242898,
0.0166756082,
-0.030704841,
-0.0255339686,
-0.0643881187,
0.0113339499,
0.0090521341,
0.0255658031,
-0.0306713786,
-0.0140759423,
0.0107142087,
-0.0020555779,
0.0076483986,
-0.0125342375,
-0.0102014523,
0.0018951066,
-0.0089235883,
0.0097239567,
0.0061079697,
0.0464103147,
-0.0617092922,
0.0433297083,
0.0259108357,
0.0178853832,
0.0141680818,
-0.0604670681,
0.0160561781,
-0.015164922,
-0.0194116533,
-0.0189336333,
0.0247432049,
0.0613862388,
-0.0828992352,
-0.0332301557,
0.0850099847,
0.0091034975,
-0.0248528086,
0.0090792831,
0.0105393827,
0.0260477215,
-0.0171213113,
0.0305057559,
-0.0395897999,
-0.0330603644,
0.02788838,
0.066986002,
-0.0131910648,
0.0006216029,
0.0063683409,
-0.0759500563,
0.0576265901,
0.0169805046,
-0.0601771064,
-0.031133242,
-0.0591147318,
-0.0155587345,
-0.0183351468,
0.0954977795,
0.0128592355,
-0.0116619663,
0.0011920203,
0.0487414263,
-0.0052307574,
-0.0746358559,
0.018774705,
0.0003301824,
0.0583288372,
0.0500945412,
0.0304779634,
0.0171800796,
-0.0374616645,
0.0657932833,
-0.0091878474,
0.0236721095,
-0.0072713885,
0.0455103219,
0.0215338133,
-0.0313148759,
0.0133892437,
0.0579655915,
-0.0242301077,
-0.0159491859,
-0.0114939213,
0.0548653342,
-0.0087590348,
-0.0342311487,
0.0126698446,
-0.0151970312,
0.0501464829,
0.08285781,
0.0614152662,
-0.0259486791,
-0.0391063206,
-0.0082186237,
-0.0139322234,
-0.020643387,
-0.0164704248,
0.00567867,
-0.0241810922,
-0.0434184,
-0.0311522502,
0.0294686686,
0.0030186458,
0.0510788448,
0.0033670319,
0.0003675867,
-0.017909158,
0.0236036517,
-0.0249031764,
0.0655162111,
-0.0283587538,
0.0050986484,
-0.0667227209,
-0.0193633996,
0.0313969031,
-0.0091715185,
-0.0168924835,
0.0064904909,
-0.0151953297,
-0.0794642866,
-0.0030607602,
0.0637994781,
0.0213320255,
0.0679916441,
-0.0169376265,
-0.0743793771,
0.0276059322,
0.0367492996,
-0.0108633181,
0.0188293513,
0.0640409514,
-0.0202079248,
-0.0121499831,
0.0411481857,
-0.0322578326,
0.0033317378,
0.0323816538,
-0.0153049091,
-0.0292616133,
-0.0378655121,
0.006536921,
0.0197998136,
0.0428082868,
0.0126197254,
-0.0698338449,
-0.0570092648,
0.0290849525,
-0.0120369019,
0.0038179066,
-0.0701544285,
0.0586011335,
0.0202384703,
-0.016409304,
0.0032951694,
-0.0609768294,
-0.0021120752,
-0.0167174134,
-0.0279945061,
0.0298571791,
-0.0101761408,
0.0406538472,
0.0192780979,
0.0228389204,
-0.0122111309,
0.0361362658,
0.0293073803,
0.044503361,
0.0223940127,
0.0438357778,
0.0448177345,
0.0441406853,
-0.035834942,
0.0059064077,
-0.0493243746,
-0.0769414753,
-0.0293546692,
0.0096851056,
0.0435548835,
-0.0085778795,
0.0769730061,
0.0265071355,
-0.023186259,
-0.0012976517,
0.0809101611,
0.0285904631,
0.0088284444,
0.014325358,
-0.004156088,
-0.0310111456,
0.0168912727,
0.0816470906,
0.0420869701,
0.0339222997,
-0.0103796441,
-0.043857865,
-0.0102391252,
-0.0049808654,
0.0202324372,
0.0122385044,
-0.0109476959,
-0.0071169608,
0.0132561922,
-0.0752270669,
-0.043864537,
0.0030541301,
-0.034526825,
0.01083198,
0.0238722041,
0.0873959437,
-0.0216239113,
-0.0123950811,
-0.0519001707,
-0.0255461354,
0.0046150889,
0.0115485927,
0.0062518874,
-7.320578414e-33,
-0.0245441329,
-0.0387830175,
-0.0294957384,
0.0326492749,
0.0076317871,
-0.0058634994,
-0.0468367711,
-0.0105725098,
-0.0113888215,
0.0599207096,
-0.0040478483,
0.0253264438,
0.0180280823,
0.0288305469,
-0.028325377,
-0.0426682644,
0.0502085574,
0.0344711244,
-0.035743162,
0.0619260222,
0.07088162,
0.0430040881,
0.0582744367,
-0.1043724716,
0.0045862752,
0.0349286944,
-0.0314469598,
0.0354081467,
-0.0261708498,
0.0391870923,
0.0300083514,
0.0238550585,
0.0018004054,
-0.0350906812,
-0.0259874035,
0.0305397045,
-0.06406793,
-0.0242866389,
0.0264440402,
0.0103613921,
-0.0182566643,
-0.0519110933,
0.0658702403,
-0.0253185555,
0.0147599913,
-0.0323259346,
0.0218414981,
-0.0272078943,
-0.0172341652,
-0.0367743447,
-0.0466257446,
0.0245167594,
-0.0221904814,
-0.0512638353,
0.0580853485,
0.0171469003,
-0.0177091565,
-0.0126379952,
-0.0222184695,
-0.0370997228,
0.0542686246,
0.0290995594,
0.0573354028,
0.0455325842,
-0.0097188819,
0.0315818042,
0.0152002387,
-0.0006262221,
-0.0007208071,
-0.0278554223,
-0.0010365617,
0.0655125901,
0.0336440466,
0.010717378,
-0.0022688787,
-0.0419787951,
-0.0910104439,
0.0262714066,
-0.0195839964,
0.0125622153,
0.0135760987,
0.0181309544,
-0.0396336503,
-0.0503979512,
-0.0713030621,
-0.0214673411,
-0.0252545699,
-0.0111807007,
0.0298963785,
-0.0103056133,
-0.0686536506,
-0.0200807061,
0.0217231624,
-0.0370509736,
0.0128972745,
0.0021608919,
-0.0083101988,
-0.0286393799,
-0.030259328,
-0.0071661454,
-0.0305637121,
-0.0594279654,
-0.0057976395,
-0.0051911683,
0.0714323148,
-0.009888662,
0.0325581729,
0.0572135225,
-0.027525492,
-0.0082407398,
-0.060535349,
0.0220195539,
-0.0197278578,
0.0510162376,
0.0330015384,
0.024687523,
-0.0155963907,
0.0565536506,
0.0018525056,
0.0488545373,
-0.025360208,
-0.0222574901,
-0.0100512505,
0.0251531564,
-0.0426254831,
-0.0292202868,
-0.0067715482,
0.0103455577,
0.085303843,
-0.0761102065,
-0.0205943957,
-0.0135923214,
3.224e-7,
0.0518924445,
0.0471564643,
-0.0159983803,
-0.0201131105,
0.0168278981,
0.0464003831,
-0.0261614397,
-0.0175243132,
0.012914014,
-0.0215783957,
0.0433088802,
0.0180512834,
0.0765587911,
0.0350839943,
-0.0293191485,
-0.0593167059,
-0.0723059103,
0.0064858701,
-0.0268944278,
-0.0325265527,
0.0199068394,
0.0766586661,
0.0341436528,
-0.0375297293,
0.0238458347,
-0.0228753705,
0.0409103259,
-0.0769855306,
0.01240867,
0.0551001988,
0.080459021,
0.0312682651,
0.0238296017,
0.021299582,
-0.0290949289,
0.0245521329,
-0.0260382574,
0.0781562477,
-0.0152806602,
-0.007355039,
-0.0374264568,
-0.0285120588,
0.0229352675,
-0.0736215636,
0.0615921356,
-0.0482687317,
-0.0408595614,
-0.0375101045,
-0.0069963727,
-0.0561712086,
0.0193000846,
-0.0168365091,
0.0155999241,
0.0348291472,
-0.0041403496,
0.0170733668,
-0.0376571827,
-0.0966691971,
-0.0130011523,
0.0225626472,
-0.0206426457,
-0.0242038015,
-0.0178587101,
-0.0302122738,
0.0411025696,
-0.084002167,
0.0227840561,
3.085100995e-34,
0.0142661361,
-0.0310966503,
0.0265167393,
0.0043825372,
0.0599705316,
0.0263101589,
0.0163518339,
0.0036140352,
0.0203179382,
-0.0391019695,
0.0030391535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06589v1 | Improving Out-of-Distribution Generalization of Neural Rerankers with Contextualized Late Interaction | 2023-02-13T18:42:17 | 2023-02-13T18:42:17 | Xinyu Zhang, Minghan Li, Jimmy Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recent progress in information retrieval finds that embedding query and
document representation into multi-vector yields a robust bi-encoder retriever
on out-of-distribution datasets. In this paper, we explore whether late
interaction, the simplest form of multi-vector, is also helpful to neural
rerankers that only use the [CLS] vector to compute the similarity score.
Although intuitively, the attention mechanism of rerankers at the previous
layers already gathers the token-level information, we find adding late
interaction still brings an extra 5% improvement in average on
out-of-distribution datasets, with little increase in latency and no
degradation in in-domain effectiveness. Through extensive experiments and
analysis, we show that the finding is consistent across different model sizes
and first-stage retrievers of diverse natures and that the improvement is more
prominent on longer queries. | [
0.0186674334,
0.0059853811,
0.0024297908,
0.0390415415,
0.0365403406,
0.0020930716,
-0.0438862815,
0.0019773948,
0.0005259759,
-0.0121972617,
-0.0274090488,
-0.0406101905,
-0.0337654054,
0.0134265497,
-0.0109249102,
-0.0228132196,
0.0113857398,
0.0456852429,
0.0351044536,
-0.0042098793,
-0.0180328861,
-0.0015139322,
0.0437362976,
0.018261157,
0.044541847,
0.0087858671,
-0.0265288744,
0.0431876704,
0.0108348867,
-0.0092731873,
-0.0054448377,
0.0058419653,
0.0713493302,
-0.0023609882,
0.0000018767,
-0.0306274612,
-0.0349863879,
-0.0065628793,
-0.0160171967,
-0.0162626803,
-0.006656168,
-0.0287014749,
0.0548826382,
-0.009583191,
-0.043348901,
-0.0034549048,
-0.0026610291,
0.0304814596,
0.0273841582,
0.0410032719,
-0.0196735375,
-0.0137687838,
0.0332333073,
-0.0496749543,
0.0100215804,
-0.0562168136,
0.0065430058,
-0.0317884386,
0.0169198532,
0.0475589335,
-0.0110916542,
0.0373098925,
0.05639432,
0.0021824921,
0.0660765395,
0.0332357697,
-0.0326960385,
0.0512059703,
0.0083691953,
0.0889117718,
-0.1047290117,
0.0154575603,
-0.0297361575,
0.0071236617,
0.0148543492,
0.0225846469,
-0.0549129248,
-0.0401216298,
-0.0093954811,
0.0251174159,
-0.0144658247,
0.0398900025,
0.0381132886,
-0.0060581001,
-0.0496495105,
0.0490957573,
-0.0088591296,
-0.0317064933,
-0.0151194977,
0.0241012536,
-0.0282191951,
0.0103945946,
0.0534596592,
0.0114600053,
-0.0023227725,
-0.011615159,
-0.0042934516,
-0.0120015983,
-0.0117148142,
-0.0636557564,
-0.0010087535,
0.021129515,
-0.0441418551,
0.0612382032,
-0.0004922564,
0.0388864987,
-0.0124846315,
0.0688722655,
-0.0203316435,
-0.0268381163,
0.0077473428,
-0.0400215909,
-0.0113798389,
0.0624129064,
-0.0209626462,
-0.0209933631,
-0.0194266122,
0.0218238719,
-0.0114010405,
-0.0423891135,
-0.0062452252,
0.0349261314,
-0.0320853665,
0.0050152983,
-0.0490121618,
0.0203062631,
-0.0277267639,
0.0040794443,
0.0061425562,
-0.0241403822,
-0.0239804797,
-0.0102723073,
0.0168367811,
-0.0524927415,
-0.0070730145,
0.0079415515,
-0.0470620207,
-0.0399359204,
0.017629426,
-0.0256699659,
0.0296387747,
-0.0175841916,
0.014090552,
-0.0305110086,
0.0730469525,
0.0098654684,
-0.028943954,
-0.028494345,
-0.0216418672,
0.0316138007,
-0.0503750704,
0.0568589568,
0.0534939058,
-0.0252068806,
0.0176635571,
0.0293979496,
0.0186278224,
0.0322433896,
-0.0182862133,
0.0231756363,
0.0510626659,
0.0281013977,
0.0275015049,
0.0034598147,
0.0513315983,
-0.0307491459,
0.0081519885,
0.0400552712,
-0.0079286648,
0.0347235054,
0.0698771849,
-0.0043597626,
-0.0868015215,
-0.0764498785,
0.0018716585,
0.0215831585,
0.0660830587,
0.0027638527,
-0.0073497957,
0.0022163733,
-0.0547583885,
0.0417533293,
-0.0547150485,
0.082279183,
0.0158008505,
0.0084193256,
0.0476617552,
0.0375948846,
-0.0408730581,
-0.0317707397,
0.0435204059,
0.0220683143,
-0.020523252,
0.0144474655,
0.0484489575,
0.0161966756,
0.0115697114,
0.0246596113,
0.0171138588,
-0.0101616895,
0.0308228191,
-0.0290742293,
-0.0391622745,
0.0519464947,
0.0797115117,
-0.0597647205,
0.0291343816,
0.0125307748,
-0.007463892,
-0.035775777,
0.001143254,
-0.0109309573,
0.0327278599,
-0.0341195837,
-0.0464517288,
-0.0348109417,
-0.0117111905,
0.0347800106,
-0.005697439,
0.0189980064,
0.0403529294,
-0.0537898503,
0.0067276233,
-0.0001855704,
0.0047137709,
0.0067235669,
0.0232775789,
0.0182860885,
-0.0006749463,
0.0253495537,
0.0061653918,
0.0241924655,
0.0661844015,
-0.0222500712,
-0.0365980417,
-0.0297809169,
-0.0590295196,
-0.0522415414,
-0.0011371456,
-0.0266840216,
0.0180695187,
0.0407160446,
-0.0085409107,
-0.0034132248,
0.0224721953,
0.011952281,
0.0500039868,
-0.0555232689,
0.0087467264,
0.0128235389,
0.008668622,
-0.0310626384,
0.0511655323,
-0.0329743847,
0.0232727043,
0.0382013321,
-0.0176277272,
-0.0400873646,
-0.0516763031,
-0.0398880392,
0.0370284691,
0.0047663269,
0.0131195327,
-0.0098668588,
-0.0149819944,
-0.0257076249,
0.0028797558,
-0.0358108543,
-0.0190052632,
-0.026661085,
-0.0153740859,
0.0156887602,
0.0309484806,
0.0356904306,
-0.0280688237,
-0.04265799,
-0.0383063778,
-0.0112349605,
0.0313473083,
0.0384564735,
0.0045865676,
0.0106850453,
-0.0070959949,
-0.0652547702,
0.0084432801,
0.0856445581,
-0.043788027,
-0.0267792139,
-0.0102183288,
-0.0181241035,
-0.0536327921,
0.0265464503,
-0.0598237775,
0.0088818176,
-0.0253385808,
-0.0396206453,
-0.0030311032,
0.0899866968,
0.011153576,
0.0339893326,
0.0405354649,
0.0143804448,
-0.0940227583,
-0.0039406875,
-0.0371777266,
0.0219916366,
0.01504423,
0.0372881778,
-0.0011681084,
-0.012093408,
-0.0317259654,
-0.0156023838,
-0.0089287981,
0.0083519118,
0.0300557707,
-0.0170494337,
-0.0958944932,
0.0019799785,
0.0117574381,
0.0135732433,
-0.030989835,
-0.0158461481,
0.0918208212,
0.0189491529,
-0.0176748,
-0.0221182834,
0.004182267,
-0.0452418663,
0.0355804712,
-0.0122186495,
0.0151085183,
-0.0493192226,
-0.0411153212,
-0.0269564036,
0.0200132728,
0.0004816009,
-0.0393477939,
0.0460194498,
0.0263924599,
0.021896746,
0.004596977,
-0.0935728028,
0.0001422447,
-0.025695309,
0.0587891117,
0.0217491146,
0.0059214393,
0.0026587001,
-0.072691001,
0.0234950278,
0.0017408547,
0.0588018373,
-0.0476593077,
-0.0265781619,
0.0205260869,
0.0966939852,
0.0081264172,
0.0095863342,
-0.0267958846,
-0.0095227519,
-0.0094228713,
0.0524299778,
0.0248375572,
-0.0788677633,
0.017379269,
0.0034243865,
0.0379858389,
-0.0047993185,
-0.0175996535,
-0.016388895,
-0.0079401843,
-0.0097322399,
-0.0397790596,
0.0643067732,
0.0192552861,
-0.0956424773,
-0.0076458636,
-0.0407544002,
0.0101781022,
0.0483398549,
0.0188234318,
-0.0545601957,
0.0036389974,
-0.0134727284,
0.0353182927,
0.0258343779,
-0.0151803736,
0.0184012782,
-0.1057850868,
0.0345398933,
-0.0296944529,
-0.0359538272,
-0.0352622829,
-0.0432733446,
0.0175311398,
-0.0053834124,
0.0009292162,
0.0472463779,
0.0069969925,
-0.020893909,
-0.0256498773,
0.0389173068,
-0.0313699953,
0.0147037124,
-0.05506064,
-0.0069322563,
0.013341628,
0.0117577706,
0.0187894553,
-0.0248139948,
0.0145036485,
-0.0408119559,
0.0022416229,
0.0044078622,
0.0491822772,
-0.048744116,
0.0110856947,
-0.0332153924,
-0.0175624117,
0.0074801063,
0.0325842164,
-0.059995763,
0.0528935827,
-0.0211394355,
-0.0155601343,
-0.0628496334,
-0.0579362549,
-0.0337040611,
0.0279007778,
0.027937673,
0.0097986078,
-0.0148982732,
-0.0191772431,
0.0192942433,
0.0126814488,
-0.0033708171,
0.0084696254,
0.0115576833,
-0.0123912171,
-0.0497558303,
-0.0675918534,
-0.0252559986,
0.0434767716,
-0.0613408163,
0.0087966537,
-0.0083981557,
-0.0313686877,
-0.0460289232,
-0.0121431537,
0.0067210542,
-0.0081854733,
0.0038595453,
0.0419571549,
0.0288815256,
-0.0220301971,
-0.0577917024,
-0.043561019,
0.0184551645,
-0.0415297858,
-0.0277650319,
0.0411674045,
0.017742075,
0.0784119442,
-0.0285056755,
-0.0427212343,
0.0569365732,
0.0482802764,
-0.0401128978,
-0.011774838,
-0.0026386478,
-0.0238550417,
0.0005298348,
0.0356498919,
-0.0683366433,
0.0070404136,
-0.0163218249,
0.0091403304,
-0.012708826,
-0.0256775841,
0.0066795135,
0.0100360811,
0.0741392821,
0.0542796552,
-0.0033468849,
-0.0351295024,
0.0601386242,
-0.0577835739,
-0.0157910381,
-0.0337078981,
0.0278586447,
0.0257477853,
0.0136540933,
-0.0153198931,
0.0113806007,
0.0112071689,
0.0286364332,
-0.0759873763,
-0.0058397269,
0.002479414,
-0.0090650395,
-0.0086562885,
0.0038105412,
-0.0260843076,
0.0153753096,
0.0359643809,
0.0527179874,
-0.0385766253,
-0.0311034191,
0.0562903397,
0.005171631,
-0.0368128642,
0.0526803881,
-0.117833443,
-0.0060185548,
-0.045711156,
-0.0516282171,
0.026366882,
0.0118894633,
0.0269110315,
0.0772904307,
-0.0151595604,
0.005539271,
-0.022220334,
0.0122177033,
-0.0511092283,
0.0311913788,
0.0379455425,
0.0097802877,
0.0259075277,
0.0955780074,
-0.0393063687,
-0.0100527192,
-0.0344553962,
-0.0194302909,
-0.0094537055,
0.0096167289,
0.0317786224,
0.0662209913,
-0.0242263731,
-0.0195876732,
0.0113744987,
-0.0223421846,
0.0244019479,
-0.0190886091,
-0.0155120464,
0.0008888444,
0.0529831387,
0.0932011679,
0.0298677776,
-0.04319188,
-0.0186240748,
-0.0281330645,
-0.0373174697,
-0.0571625903,
-0.0012702638,
-6.63595728e-33,
-0.007415724,
-0.0224446505,
-0.0074400324,
-0.0496504046,
-0.0276383758,
0.0110199274,
-0.0023925221,
-0.0583845191,
-0.0310050715,
0.0025712864,
-0.0297564194,
0.0392403565,
-0.0022755878,
0.0025695194,
0.0244471561,
-0.0245594792,
0.0213955101,
0.0192119628,
-0.0194413643,
0.0156483352,
0.0586429127,
0.0635334402,
0.0337888487,
-0.0484113358,
0.0102109341,
-0.0097543439,
0.0176611375,
0.0361873768,
0.033631511,
0.0725152865,
-0.0027262191,
0.0348082036,
0.0622078739,
-0.0687465891,
0.0084701255,
0.0109113064,
-0.0807296708,
-0.0291212313,
-0.047353372,
-0.0226075165,
-0.0007611125,
0.0168281905,
0.0611050949,
0.0088245729,
0.0101445159,
-0.0612867884,
0.0473966151,
0.0296829473,
-0.0434900858,
-0.0413203202,
-0.006888154,
0.0212749243,
-0.0054766815,
0.0092022894,
0.0181014817,
0.0644854382,
0.0135232182,
0.0740911365,
-0.0815150887,
0.0174369123,
-0.0750192329,
0.0206221137,
-0.0024120542,
-0.0191529337,
-0.0165058821,
0.0495250672,
0.0232246816,
-0.0030440027,
-0.0220197625,
-0.0506173745,
0.0148546202,
0.0106720123,
0.0113906609,
0.0147946114,
0.0580930002,
0.0064395298,
-0.095604822,
0.0402720198,
-0.0046621477,
0.0213766471,
0.001857026,
0.0440201797,
-0.0409476273,
-0.0376136303,
0.0049649198,
-0.0204534791,
-0.0495893843,
-0.0292932615,
0.0234677326,
0.0447947495,
0.0292184986,
0.0130727934,
0.0201968253,
-0.0118495645,
-0.0375394449,
0.0533431284,
0.0143516632,
-0.0162857398,
0.0163613874,
-0.0097479122,
-0.0177825466,
0.0215255618,
0.0161426608,
0.0052157412,
-0.0070185163,
0.0115802707,
0.0411016382,
-0.0049847332,
-0.0389792621,
-0.035488084,
0.0101303384,
-0.0361560285,
-0.0137594994,
0.0471087433,
0.0087886862,
-0.0047785747,
-0.0068230112,
0.0749596506,
0.0473820195,
0.0564976223,
-0.0543788075,
-0.0078955665,
0.0412880108,
-0.0086285686,
0.0130791161,
0.0215188842,
0.0011650384,
0.0313548967,
0.0324896313,
-0.0561079085,
-0.0396583863,
0.0031786375,
2.769e-7,
0.0429927409,
0.0357198901,
0.0217532683,
0.0250186585,
0.003783572,
-0.0160837304,
0.0015863067,
0.0755007491,
0.0212686434,
0.0085472642,
0.0410580672,
-0.0038163012,
-0.010453511,
0.0088483999,
-0.0942457765,
-0.008545598,
-0.0960391611,
-0.0582085736,
-0.0160693228,
-0.0965935066,
0.0155946547,
0.0769050941,
-0.0187195558,
0.0255251732,
-0.0000356484,
-0.0424090475,
0.05363236,
0.0035605126,
0.0240859855,
-0.0401963778,
0.0457091928,
0.0220464729,
0.0204016678,
0.0088440673,
-0.002798829,
0.0724291801,
0.0745918453,
0.0210422799,
-0.0436407626,
-0.064366512,
0.0246208124,
0.0266198739,
0.0050999844,
-0.0866330266,
0.0642192215,
-0.069111295,
-0.0227303207,
0.0498646833,
-0.0463214926,
0.0086653885,
0.0258802045,
0.0232924111,
-0.0023481704,
0.0204364527,
0.0180855915,
0.0184146464,
0.035902068,
-0.1041849107,
-0.0089431908,
0.0236363616,
-0.0293671526,
-0.0154814059,
-0.0271969307,
-0.0376355238,
0.0401958972,
-0.0047825342,
0.0042916094,
2.234102089e-34,
0.0676215068,
0.0324925482,
0.0280594863,
0.0336889438,
0.0230829716,
-0.0214531217,
-0.014117972,
-0.0235114489,
0.0107544754,
-0.0792217329,
-0.03367237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06579v1 | AbLit: A Resource for Analyzing and Generating Abridged Versions of English Literature | 2023-02-13T18:33:26 | 2023-02-13T18:33:26 | Melissa Roemmele, Kyle Shaffer, Katrina Olsen, Yiyi Wang, Steve DeNeefe | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating an abridged version of a text involves shortening it while
maintaining its linguistic qualities. In this paper, we examine this task from
an NLP perspective for the first time. We present a new resource, AbLit, which
is derived from abridged versions of English literature books. The dataset
captures passage-level alignments between the original and abridged texts. We
characterize the linguistic relations of these alignments, and create automated
models to predict these relations as well as to generate abridgements for new
texts. Our findings establish abridgement as a challenging task, motivating
future resources and research. The dataset is available at
github.com/roemmele/AbLit. | [
0.00890176,
0.0313278548,
-0.0338692814,
0.0424141698,
-0.0789202005,
-0.0308327004,
-0.0150210867,
0.0202547926,
-0.0227341782,
-0.0142811006,
0.0372678749,
0.034065254,
0.0469940752,
0.0061879875,
0.0167834535,
-0.0508737825,
0.0388074033,
0.0247159023,
-0.0073599112,
0.0052742525,
0.0649728328,
0.0445051864,
0.0429597385,
0.0380570255,
0.0231287349,
-0.0183992013,
-0.0134421298,
0.0340737253,
0.0332863927,
0.0350752212,
0.013191415,
0.0096344585,
-0.0076924441,
0.0218921769,
0.0000015172,
-0.0450864956,
-0.0604485758,
0.0120489663,
0.017981505,
0.0302804653,
0.0894527957,
-0.0054318123,
0.0045249006,
-0.023278527,
-0.0031420663,
0.0334686525,
0.0430689529,
0.0486121289,
0.0899650231,
0.0830844566,
-0.011627065,
-0.0266763773,
-0.0596484132,
0.0218136702,
-0.0132452156,
-0.0017300079,
0.0046631051,
0.0025055367,
0.0158847217,
0.0166072156,
-0.0170383453,
0.0157303549,
-0.0320069827,
-0.0092465309,
-0.0022795359,
-0.0462223105,
-0.0590206273,
-0.0030257232,
0.0202937927,
0.0245776754,
0.0415987037,
-0.0883251056,
0.0107917441,
0.012282134,
0.0010495133,
0.0027216352,
-0.0698755085,
-0.0254772194,
0.0020532687,
0.0388269387,
-0.0071425494,
-0.0175149608,
0.0084968666,
-0.0083259391,
0.0436534397,
0.0320061482,
0.0537676588,
-0.0251079835,
-0.066924572,
-0.0328953713,
-0.0207476914,
-0.0226640254,
0.0139872767,
-0.0010752698,
0.034127228,
-0.0012365074,
-0.1030789167,
-0.0601816624,
-0.0119046159,
-0.0086458353,
-0.0013347324,
0.0246452186,
0.0197079889,
-0.0086882981,
-0.0034513993,
0.0318449773,
0.0608902089,
-0.0303877071,
-0.0486989357,
0.011152721,
-0.0035875724,
0.0225421861,
-0.0655321702,
0.0193744395,
-0.0335919783,
-0.0118603678,
-0.0547276661,
-0.0438007079,
0.0268465839,
0.0200212598,
-0.0103603397,
0.0172460433,
-0.0356477126,
-0.0350960754,
0.0006278067,
0.0177515093,
-0.0206700563,
0.0001877511,
-0.0306933969,
0.0022207629,
-0.0109762652,
-0.0040415614,
0.0314220339,
-0.0327923372,
0.0097335652,
0.0127457399,
-0.0002247343,
-0.0180784091,
-0.0387831442,
-0.0173959062,
0.0027334276,
-0.0105663417,
-0.0632217005,
-0.0579662696,
0.0468807928,
-0.0286475364,
-0.0010175557,
-0.0713788122,
0.016246479,
0.0293473918,
-0.0375525132,
0.0673437193,
-0.0382293016,
0.0223886296,
-0.0092862556,
-0.0195362158,
0.0257317796,
0.0296645314,
0.0647811145,
0.0052076555,
0.1003800407,
-0.0244710986,
-0.0288279504,
0.0392428227,
-0.0053563658,
0.0078217629,
-0.0057051177,
-0.0436601005,
-0.0318470001,
0.0297731627,
0.016643675,
0.0452095047,
-0.0233392771,
-0.0363444947,
0.0794069916,
0.0544779785,
0.0036169302,
0.0678734779,
0.0453498773,
0.0332755633,
0.0140476692,
0.0705558732,
-0.0119024776,
-0.0422091708,
-0.0229500346,
0.0303674545,
0.0245962683,
0.0241301917,
0.0228323136,
-0.0013413761,
-0.0164931137,
0.0251166318,
0.0431813449,
-0.0434737392,
0.0035007673,
0.0377658419,
-0.038393423,
0.0129904663,
0.0168833528,
-0.0743121281,
0.0579315722,
0.0192995407,
-0.0435871072,
0.0517995656,
0.0978201553,
-0.0559787601,
0.0008460731,
0.0096646948,
-0.021043025,
0.0462672859,
0.0052827178,
-0.0539147854,
-0.0038156877,
-0.0495778248,
0.0406070277,
-0.0530242845,
0.0093043894,
-0.0148573406,
0.0249030907,
-0.0090792449,
0.0066596437,
-0.0692812875,
-0.0895320624,
0.0567209572,
-0.0502665043,
-0.0161553659,
-0.0065267417,
0.0108264266,
-0.0020184582,
0.0094669564,
-0.0063039558,
0.0136828246,
0.0080700926,
-0.0305728149,
-0.0028617599,
0.0357713066,
0.0486259572,
-0.0165280197,
0.0901748911,
-0.0807455257,
0.0378180072,
0.05127142,
-0.0378735065,
-0.0344591849,
0.0253557097,
-0.0139694912,
0.0227146018,
0.0040935627,
0.0487473719,
-0.0137766292,
0.002973215,
-0.0422542505,
0.0057912581,
0.0531315245,
0.0570133775,
0.0194454044,
-0.0820638016,
0.032160338,
0.0019367029,
-0.0207693428,
-0.0239857715,
-0.0136244241,
-0.0322961733,
0.0561559908,
-0.0244119149,
-0.0268898159,
-0.0189343914,
-0.047909651,
0.0445513465,
0.0155462762,
0.034262538,
0.0746977851,
0.0273466911,
-0.0006246708,
0.0285071153,
0.0092643425,
-0.0050724479,
0.0168178659,
0.0018464893,
0.0473542847,
-0.0056843609,
-0.0287235603,
-0.0407733805,
0.0079228468,
0.0046825912,
0.0300379023,
-0.0077363006,
-0.0542443208,
-0.0639323816,
0.012182897,
-0.0053269812,
0.0095325438,
0.0158068966,
-0.0411421694,
-0.0486177355,
0.0221872404,
0.036233332,
0.0180241987,
0.0129776457,
-0.0068982183,
0.0174915604,
-0.0419263802,
-0.0120855989,
-0.0007355812,
-0.025108384,
-0.0258550067,
-0.0455477573,
-0.0962253958,
0.0352284275,
0.0079185497,
0.0007433546,
-0.0137405526,
-0.0517326184,
0.021096129,
-0.0064229062,
-0.021829037,
0.0022538174,
-0.0123737603,
-0.0336997174,
0.0245632958,
-0.025185572,
-0.0194582324,
0.042154979,
-0.0438707955,
0.0158366524,
-0.0765786693,
0.0062320074,
-0.0474477001,
0.0772480294,
0.000643422,
0.0422900841,
0.0329305269,
-0.0173379947,
-0.0660364181,
0.0238768551,
0.0532091446,
-0.0105167385,
0.0342186093,
-0.0654525086,
0.020556571,
-0.0112226782,
-0.0030595714,
-0.0054817214,
-0.0245496742,
0.0239605512,
-0.0120332008,
0.0286812354,
-0.0124212606,
-0.0588782914,
-0.0098901261,
-0.0023272969,
0.0218608417,
0.005001103,
0.0178953111,
-0.0125673264,
0.0372936428,
0.0759748891,
-0.0050035003,
0.0031824051,
-0.0188250132,
0.0260305777,
0.0150178103,
-0.0397391655,
-0.0221847706,
0.0194104724,
-0.0271899775,
0.0075064125,
-0.0937446952,
-0.0032178622,
-0.0024391196,
0.0170328729,
-0.0549804345,
-0.0375199243,
0.0976884738,
0.0215955842,
0.0067502926,
-0.0067000235,
-0.0235703401,
0.0277074985,
0.0094872322,
-0.0016873293,
-0.0846414492,
-0.0097801704,
0.0275878478,
0.0272719562,
0.0227298196,
-0.0296287481,
-0.0344398394,
-0.0547264181,
-0.0098910471,
0.0179922637,
-0.0090446137,
-0.052139502,
-0.0138902972,
0.0171811525,
-0.0194759276,
-0.0217020027,
-0.0029666997,
-0.0271484088,
0.0277275741,
-0.052486036,
-0.036114499,
0.008670751,
-0.0496275313,
-0.0232718494,
0.0331559777,
0.0301066302,
0.0761539936,
-0.001198528,
0.0414069369,
-0.0087694759,
-0.0553187691,
-0.0428170376,
0.0083810193,
0.0665099099,
0.0192209613,
0.0335462876,
0.0218593404,
0.066543214,
0.0166931078,
-0.045246765,
0.0397873558,
0.0018532798,
0.0221700966,
-0.0276997723,
-0.0302904192,
0.0526115447,
0.0023788612,
0.0813298374,
0.0187027492,
-0.0069163796,
-0.0398116149,
-0.0195590984,
-0.0089305146,
-0.0567743368,
-0.0533034094,
0.0101472819,
-0.0886342153,
-0.0004632255,
-0.0981927067,
-0.0171034951,
-0.0139584141,
0.0121716708,
0.0934772044,
0.0311125368,
0.0158165041,
0.0023574121,
-0.0382791273,
-0.0211007893,
-0.0288630333,
0.0020117646,
-0.0046968251,
-0.0027878731,
-0.0157855619,
-0.0246617571,
0.0336409658,
0.0043285578,
-0.0643267781,
-0.0720458925,
0.0279431697,
0.0044249007,
0.0256395675,
0.0532532446,
-0.01657038,
-0.0095303031,
-0.0107755391,
0.0116700241,
-0.021722652,
0.095207341,
0.0004625167,
0.031024497,
-0.0351183526,
0.0659682006,
-0.0112053053,
-0.0110000717,
0.0066743838,
0.042253416,
0.0101120882,
-0.0459084548,
0.0343463011,
0.0484366529,
-0.0235180631,
-0.055347763,
0.0044248938,
-0.0406514816,
-0.0197400134,
-0.0400677882,
-0.060698539,
-0.0130780209,
0.0346843153,
0.0430681705,
0.0146480463,
-0.0230480712,
0.0612872429,
-0.0501167625,
-0.0070452983,
-0.0279181432,
-0.0014852604,
0.032121636,
-0.0144930324,
0.008482581,
0.0216855705,
0.0041733622,
0.0054041101,
-0.0425323993,
0.0632370487,
-0.0000301257,
0.0001512142,
0.0464065038,
0.0121440999,
-0.0409228876,
0.0256247707,
-0.0313053951,
0.0412042737,
-0.0342398621,
-0.0030583069,
0.0200535506,
-0.0198596437,
0.1222189888,
-0.0332565457,
-0.0491080992,
-0.0248590633,
0.0480653793,
0.0413202271,
0.002985921,
-0.0515441373,
-0.0004978873,
-0.0337930843,
0.0544494353,
0.0787466988,
-0.040432252,
0.0509844907,
0.0475441106,
-0.0260272231,
-0.027681835,
-0.0571097769,
0.0030267593,
0.020197697,
0.0206789188,
-0.0401072241,
-0.0597809628,
0.0032299119,
0.0329858027,
0.0010390548,
0.0322806127,
-0.0044134064,
0.0059350231,
0.0174584035,
-0.0123625016,
0.041018717,
-0.0438662916,
0.0458332375,
-0.0111210141,
-0.0521939993,
-0.0455305763,
-4.705606007e-33,
-0.0216391515,
0.01739043,
-0.0174896233,
0.0080677699,
-0.0709259957,
0.0026410595,
-0.0196884405,
-0.0203631893,
0.0185624454,
0.0281156264,
-0.0094900243,
-0.0126671642,
-0.0022199079,
0.006915825,
-0.0102217998,
0.0179772992,
0.0680061877,
0.021156216,
-0.0480108485,
-0.0060647395,
0.0577516817,
0.0063410937,
0.0562639907,
-0.0042939163,
0.0279895738,
-0.0506109707,
-0.052425608,
-0.0116515495,
0.0466916561,
-0.0033561685,
0.0010378126,
0.029421676,
0.0166685358,
-0.0008353354,
-0.0159944519,
0.024321029,
-0.0390465744,
0.0044694385,
0.056394197,
0.0228307545,
-0.0084887045,
-0.0522712618,
0.0204278734,
-0.0188302509,
0.0013488819,
-0.0163467694,
0.0799391046,
-0.0598416217,
-0.0047712293,
-0.0234462693,
-0.087502338,
0.0008933298,
-0.0490938462,
-0.0181583334,
0.0402986184,
0.0430277623,
0.011108581,
-0.0017020499,
-0.0288563203,
0.014275522,
0.0099959383,
0.0862624794,
-0.0168430004,
-0.0454454757,
0.0112317307,
0.0538273193,
-0.018593628,
-0.0094358763,
0.0190805439,
0.0554882027,
0.0093273753,
-0.0022820532,
0.0229147747,
0.0823969096,
0.0264358614,
-0.0006336236,
-0.0038887858,
0.0405739658,
0.015113065,
0.0445324704,
-0.0254569538,
0.0126966368,
0.0101054143,
-0.0127080753,
-0.0463651232,
-0.0502171963,
0.0108921612,
-0.0355150066,
-0.017137913,
0.0009004192,
-0.0478728078,
-0.0094718756,
0.0058261114,
-0.0471205339,
-0.0025173069,
-0.0079201628,
-0.0388291702,
0.0379431881,
-0.0112679601,
0.01840147,
0.0258046277,
0.0058937897,
0.0119223585,
-0.0151534295,
0.0344931781,
-0.0493917279,
0.0428691804,
0.0203504059,
-0.0262565557,
0.0234774798,
-0.0033519822,
-0.0027968683,
-0.0247074813,
0.0250520725,
0.0055479011,
0.0243357755,
0.0130402958,
0.023454465,
0.0524425618,
-0.0046931789,
-0.0116888201,
-0.0046534697,
0.0344628394,
-0.0124222822,
-0.0319448076,
0.021184748,
-0.0036505624,
0.0059803533,
-0.0196977034,
-0.0411244817,
-0.0134436591,
0.0043263254,
2.292e-7,
0.0287648048,
0.0168499891,
0.0872969478,
-0.0304648299,
-0.0151488828,
0.0153109618,
-0.0023952052,
0.0235128962,
-0.0229259618,
-0.0245467108,
0.0309320241,
-0.0534772277,
0.0619098805,
-0.0066852211,
-0.1075517759,
0.001662154,
-0.0271546505,
-0.0202759858,
-0.0537120141,
-0.0062706564,
0.035758689,
0.0368618444,
0.0577779561,
0.0057801381,
-0.0088514015,
0.0007421291,
-0.0064412267,
-0.0478032418,
-0.0567391291,
0.0625738874,
0.0399931483,
-0.0403487198,
0.002639028,
-0.0515192486,
-0.0551065281,
0.0283206757,
0.0122736208,
0.047114756,
-0.0180011205,
0.0180652495,
-0.0204148013,
-0.0378056653,
-0.017456511,
-0.0038248126,
0.0465240255,
0.0461026579,
-0.0009847378,
-0.0158539638,
-0.0544346869,
0.0413274877,
-0.0171629507,
-0.0038179234,
-0.0578597113,
0.0419015922,
0.0313480534,
0.0241658203,
-0.0463788137,
-0.0565260388,
-0.0199425202,
0.0432635844,
-0.0253837705,
0.0003002493,
0.017842453,
0.0297767725,
0.0049533541,
-0.1193730012,
0.0059737558,
2.259760009e-34,
0.043052543,
-0.0271535851,
-0.0006360924,
0.020750355,
0.0236040186,
-0.0551179685,
0.0056980257,
0.0379733182,
-0.0377512686,
-0.0312240683,
-0.0172306113
] |
Subsets and Splits