id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04498v2 | DialogRE^C+: An Extension of DialogRE to Investigate How Much Coreference Helps Relation Extraction in Dialogs | 2023-08-08T18:03:29 | 2023-08-12T06:12:36 | Yiyun Xiong, Mengwei Dai, Fei Li, Hao Fei, Bobo Li, Shengqiong Wu, Donghong Ji, Chong Teng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue relation extraction (DRE) that identifies the relations between
argument pairs in dialogue text, suffers much from the frequent occurrence of
personal pronouns, or entity and speaker coreference. This work introduces a
new benchmark dataset DialogRE^C+, introducing coreference resolution into the
DRE scenario. With the aid of high-quality coreference knowledge, the reasoning
of argument relations is expected to be enhanced. In DialogRE^C+ dataset, we
manually annotate total 5,068 coreference chains over 36,369 argument mentions
based on the existing DialogRE data, where four different coreference chain
types namely speaker chain, person chain, location chain and organization chain
are explicitly marked. We further develop 4 coreference-enhanced graph-based
DRE models, which learn effective coreference representations for improving the
DRE task. We also train a coreference resolution model based on our annotations
and evaluate the effect of automatically extracted coreference chains
demonstrating the practicality of our dataset and its potential to other
domains and tasks. | [
0.055704467,
0.0311861746,
0.0202991404,
0.0553119257,
-0.020084681,
0.0090183588,
-0.0136989234,
-0.0210360028,
0.0600878187,
-0.0470164195,
-0.0240387917,
0.0297914017,
-0.0483739264,
-0.026398506,
-0.0254605673,
-0.0461789481,
0.0374043472,
0.0152881751,
0.0578226522,
0.0249729846,
0.019785786,
0.0320137218,
-0.017162526,
0.0067812353,
-0.038631741,
-0.0583335198,
0.0071806218,
0.0205694195,
0.043869324,
-0.027325172,
0.0412194319,
0.0429790914,
-0.0081668273,
0.0048328955,
0.0000017657,
-0.0413580947,
-0.0220285431,
-0.0039054293,
-0.0708827674,
-0.0008281698,
0.0085450783,
0.0279187467,
0.0169121549,
-0.0174281709,
-0.0280850306,
-0.0411194824,
0.027221268,
0.0875668004,
0.0446510613,
0.0606553778,
-0.0277425162,
-0.007635789,
0.0128811123,
-0.038447246,
-0.0968260765,
-0.065296039,
0.0189790167,
0.046826411,
-0.0168573242,
0.0199384969,
0.0316333435,
-0.0073491107,
0.0222933721,
-0.027725609,
0.0057993326,
0.0140971048,
-0.0782247707,
-0.0087321289,
0.0087137725,
0.1039386988,
0.0494141653,
0.0356488377,
0.041970443,
0.0068562184,
-0.0028382691,
-0.0355898477,
-0.0221695825,
-0.0184976012,
-0.0466321744,
-0.0071867313,
0.0083028097,
0.0168470852,
-0.0146157052,
-0.0061770468,
-0.0122641353,
0.0656724721,
-0.0267394166,
-0.0089853043,
0.0900517032,
0.0211664997,
-0.0334726833,
-0.0411873497,
0.0359829441,
-0.0105709536,
-0.0284524392,
0.0257363599,
-0.0359175876,
0.0747929588,
0.0000337765,
-0.0803321302,
-0.0135252019,
-0.0389520191,
-0.0373600088,
0.0509963408,
-0.0128924698,
0.0372527465,
-0.0439916402,
0.0144350473,
0.0110955741,
-0.0407418162,
-0.0691957697,
0.0319464728,
-0.0694791377,
0.0509585217,
-0.0555707105,
-0.0360276401,
-0.0437183902,
0.0016330614,
0.0031566017,
0.0171472598,
0.0318566523,
0.0146067226,
-0.0093173226,
0.0007408123,
-0.0066514807,
0.0381879769,
-0.0341112353,
0.0054637971,
-0.0231564473,
-0.02945696,
-0.0038374346,
0.0081573362,
0.0501449816,
-0.0654049218,
-0.0291010868,
0.0401777662,
0.0006845318,
-0.0151436515,
0.0198643152,
-0.0535529815,
-0.0288685262,
-0.0561114997,
-0.0454975106,
-0.0358328633,
0.0327873453,
0.0007269445,
-0.0079393527,
-0.0688114762,
0.0598560199,
-0.0057456964,
-0.0313141905,
0.0257849712,
0.0217168499,
-0.0259323996,
0.0427288525,
-0.0007645637,
-0.0115459096,
0.0416092016,
0.0194735751,
0.0240291934,
0.0520264469,
0.0175398048,
-0.0190915428,
0.0107573429,
0.0357558355,
-0.0270103291,
0.0598696396,
0.0309215188,
-0.0761205703,
-0.017661212,
0.0385339223,
0.0565303005,
-0.0236680396,
-0.0526765138,
0.0115647465,
0.0400558673,
-0.0219017509,
-0.0098405862,
-0.0233149938,
0.0368155129,
0.023142634,
0.0449053161,
-0.0709777549,
0.0035799737,
0.0362855233,
-0.0181796011,
0.0254441258,
-0.0332062915,
0.008067687,
-0.0186169874,
-0.011463589,
0.0154357189,
0.0101613551,
-0.0205320027,
0.0473853424,
0.0225454234,
-0.0373631977,
0.0458958186,
0.0423349701,
-0.0526121035,
-0.0543777272,
0.0294425152,
-0.051069662,
-0.0184498653,
0.0154797873,
-0.006201609,
-0.068429552,
-0.0269656908,
0.0574221648,
0.0171406548,
0.0450433828,
-0.043226812,
0.0560875386,
-0.0298175719,
-0.0148582896,
0.0191473868,
-0.0068146857,
0.0030685489,
0.0493379869,
-0.021023104,
0.020566076,
0.0093638189,
-0.0084978314,
-0.0152195198,
0.0171657354,
-0.0015679541,
0.0353632383,
0.0316644982,
0.0394202657,
0.0434288271,
0.0011011186,
-0.0389694422,
0.0260639936,
-0.0038112486,
0.0008117222,
0.0390267819,
-0.0726915747,
-0.0343617387,
0.0179616641,
-0.0377988629,
-0.0425330177,
-0.0516273603,
-0.0268806629,
-0.0503318012,
0.0127974395,
-0.032919582,
0.0224560183,
-0.0154277179,
-0.0100854943,
0.032076247,
0.0021520904,
-0.0137348566,
0.0779356137,
0.0176119823,
-0.0356225222,
0.0300201792,
0.0440175347,
0.0284073912,
-0.0723249018,
0.0220155139,
-0.0228012968,
-0.022845095,
-0.0160767045,
0.038419567,
-0.0111667421,
-0.0674708113,
0.0100510819,
-0.0840677917,
0.0118654687,
0.0011783093,
0.024639437,
-0.0015173019,
-0.0048637306,
0.0099103283,
-0.0286991391,
-0.0056287576,
0.0137586556,
0.0043323352,
-0.0135882851,
0.0288219489,
0.0155474553,
-0.00731134,
-0.0586271137,
-0.0009786146,
-0.0362964757,
0.0339412056,
0.0093945805,
-0.0336232372,
0.0259347297,
0.0013156765,
0.0035565293,
0.0501002856,
-0.0036995467,
-0.0159989018,
-0.0112734968,
0.0024966286,
0.0248518158,
0.0454419889,
-0.0234939884,
0.0724922568,
-0.0458271168,
-0.0767259598,
-0.0555545762,
0.0500264578,
-0.0040465109,
-0.007821166,
-0.0339814648,
0.0059434031,
-0.0019674054,
0.0585440993,
0.0232289843,
0.0384569541,
-0.0142709892,
0.0264227334,
-0.0003233424,
-0.0004736285,
0.0351015478,
-0.0038171038,
-0.0100393426,
0.0292791314,
-0.0638073534,
0.0155198872,
0.0642589629,
-0.0170297511,
-0.0134503208,
-0.0005135342,
-0.0249783918,
-0.0442212,
0.0666173324,
0.000979939,
0.0186140928,
0.086465016,
-0.0776223987,
-0.0065566422,
-0.0185951386,
0.0269538332,
-0.0111923702,
0.0339631438,
-0.0262016151,
0.0235496312,
0.0071740425,
-0.0188258346,
-0.0516935401,
0.031857226,
-0.0425560921,
-0.0083089536,
-0.0040401299,
0.0066178017,
0.0248195156,
0.0128667988,
-0.0087124994,
0.0247254912,
-0.0117656318,
0.0298231952,
-0.0233888011,
0.0745507777,
0.0334918685,
0.0146692442,
-0.0346655175,
0.0113309016,
0.0305328369,
0.0473940857,
0.0017617987,
-0.0257434025,
-0.0211758185,
-0.0108220074,
-0.0317979045,
-0.0374322832,
-0.0150439851,
-0.0464281589,
0.0566030554,
-0.0618086159,
-0.040214058,
0.0926094428,
0.0246671848,
-0.0220519267,
-0.020729186,
-0.0006837416,
-0.0123797636,
0.0247319527,
-0.0007855402,
-0.0355311036,
-0.0326369964,
-0.0298129655,
-0.0164957829,
0.0099059343,
-0.0614543557,
-0.0049807299,
-0.0745711625,
0.0384970531,
-0.0249978844,
-0.0291701015,
-0.034274932,
-0.0269331094,
0.0230496582,
-0.0349108018,
0.0039299298,
-0.0140645709,
-0.0089612203,
-0.0104530444,
0.0242851507,
-0.0143703464,
0.0367308967,
0.052732572,
-0.0172542464,
0.0250620469,
0.0241265632,
0.046835918,
0.051632721,
0.0610157475,
0.0283132046,
-0.0468867011,
-0.0125392284,
-0.0177288689,
0.0471210182,
-0.0093202442,
-0.0128220255,
-0.0073423912,
0.0310975537,
0.0067147021,
-0.0137909809,
0.0353368893,
0.0221460219,
0.0046632797,
0.0215047579,
0.030777121,
0.0376907624,
0.0043482389,
0.0308511946,
0.0434969515,
0.0287868511,
-0.0491682515,
-0.0240529645,
0.023708785,
-0.0605242215,
-0.0033959963,
-0.0063171294,
-0.0237069558,
0.0413975753,
-0.0636204854,
-0.0532896705,
0.0225353483,
0.0219170172,
-0.017618496,
-0.0150276171,
0.0435212851,
0.0289293695,
-0.0392313339,
-0.0022895539,
-0.0532765053,
-0.0250662565,
-0.0563131683,
0.0286628455,
0.0519851111,
0.043109253,
-0.0314842276,
0.0858021602,
-0.0375987254,
-0.0461661518,
-0.0350358412,
0.0187377669,
0.012173811,
0.0714026988,
-0.0250102188,
-0.0065390891,
-0.0404053554,
0.0111430557,
-0.0408008881,
-0.0344779752,
0.0564572997,
0.0196396615,
-0.0105720544,
0.0389874987,
-0.0082014082,
0.0507641062,
-0.0035679189,
0.0332564861,
-0.0552936047,
-0.1073214039,
-0.0058046323,
0.0147755342,
0.0341086425,
0.0494755767,
0.0174248591,
-0.0369478092,
0.057810504,
-0.044693362,
-0.0106509291,
-0.0129846269,
0.0204573944,
-0.0284131486,
-0.0089630354,
0.0075446903,
-0.0482981279,
-0.027228659,
0.0721764639,
0.0188232083,
0.002584069,
0.0558068082,
-0.0050692223,
0.0124607347,
-0.0305944104,
-0.0260413494,
0.0392929763,
0.0621322431,
0.0454593301,
-0.0263138935,
0.047461804,
-0.0127527285,
-0.0323168635,
0.0091058174,
-0.0224861279,
-0.027605122,
0.0253106728,
-0.0419491678,
-0.0064029475,
0.0268376358,
-0.0082879737,
0.0723474622,
-0.0040624347,
-0.0084393164,
0.0057578865,
0.0555444695,
-0.0290967226,
-0.0124303671,
0.0080027161,
0.0158224385,
-0.025489172,
0.0468010604,
0.0176438522,
0.0332487635,
0.0020473269,
0.0313316621,
-0.0231922511,
-0.0788078085,
-0.0476766229,
-0.0377559997,
0.0009915774,
0.0109175416,
0.0416176282,
-0.0273029059,
-0.0311787315,
0.0328513496,
-0.032327354,
-0.0093401736,
0.0199432503,
0.0114208497,
0.0166917909,
0.0210862309,
-0.0391660519,
-0.0398787707,
0.0315449424,
0.011588526,
-0.0407567471,
-0.0195810404,
-5.601742656e-33,
-0.0649141446,
-0.0361825451,
0.0091304844,
0.0216657389,
-0.0179883353,
0.0344622806,
-0.0672609359,
-0.0167761426,
-0.0157248862,
0.0186472721,
-0.0044121123,
-0.0201375037,
0.0214886777,
0.0259223431,
-0.0391511917,
-0.0218293741,
0.0397917554,
0.0291971061,
-0.0059245536,
0.0489797555,
0.0460725836,
0.0330668725,
0.0802663341,
-0.1224772185,
0.0064670267,
0.0095351702,
-0.0008011708,
0.0194885675,
0.0523143485,
0.0648097098,
-0.0203815605,
0.0183802992,
0.0021919108,
-0.0357347801,
0.0154881813,
0.0152410893,
-0.1452010423,
-0.0081101591,
0.0108458214,
0.016135525,
0.0061852122,
-0.0244363956,
0.0071698399,
-0.0091955429,
0.0569591969,
-0.0321188904,
0.0394491069,
0.0005462976,
-0.0091065532,
0.0049527083,
-0.0662604719,
0.0511685051,
-0.0134131806,
-0.0114906374,
0.0160186626,
0.0323539451,
0.0045143543,
-0.0137972273,
-0.0413806252,
-0.0272385459,
-0.0193498824,
-0.0057862215,
-0.0151762376,
-0.0077977576,
-0.0209009498,
0.036540214,
-0.0094703985,
-0.0173390768,
-0.0170954708,
0.012362333,
-0.0263646655,
0.0933846459,
-0.0461643785,
0.0916791931,
-0.0351425521,
0.035498701,
-0.0668867156,
-0.0074996073,
0.056878414,
0.0203923993,
-0.0334043168,
0.0038164561,
-0.0194305684,
-0.0175122842,
0.0112157501,
-0.069636561,
-0.0059224106,
-0.0506532267,
0.020824533,
-0.0374928489,
-0.0321722403,
0.0479759499,
0.0351739302,
-0.0367583856,
-0.0456383377,
0.0409592688,
0.0231078677,
0.0167515092,
-0.0008751891,
0.032602828,
-0.0467633754,
-0.022103535,
0.0109079974,
0.0185225736,
0.0407452062,
-0.0168050919,
0.0486820266,
-0.0563115776,
-0.0507220663,
-0.0191260967,
-0.0266089998,
0.047078304,
-0.0832023099,
0.0496230163,
0.0112396628,
0.0379669219,
-0.0049689235,
0.0659236833,
0.0273617115,
0.0227040704,
-0.0501470044,
-0.0317082815,
0.0257659126,
0.0245911796,
0.0131700551,
-0.0169441123,
0.0284136534,
-0.0132007292,
0.0011427549,
-0.031358812,
0.013670723,
-0.0247420166,
2.342e-7,
0.006217109,
0.0544489287,
0.0946649686,
-0.0256322175,
-0.0101181436,
0.0224980861,
0.0206287224,
0.0305031817,
0.0212692879,
-0.0641398281,
0.0203108154,
0.0220379569,
0.017379282,
0.0551440492,
-0.0760461912,
-0.0204670783,
-0.0878977478,
-0.0572643019,
-0.0349723808,
0.008614176,
0.0241947547,
0.0533085056,
0.0521698929,
-0.0005841185,
-0.0756339058,
0.0230042767,
0.0112533662,
-0.0059941853,
-0.0030307409,
0.0422648638,
-0.0141562223,
0.003878478,
-0.0339304507,
0.0317585245,
-0.0027034248,
0.0496033058,
0.0349030048,
0.0821802989,
0.0144691067,
-0.0318743773,
-0.0192091577,
-0.0235361345,
0.0409549028,
-0.0079910355,
0.0355687588,
-0.0621025711,
-0.000335006,
-0.0529597104,
-0.0467617363,
0.0083356295,
-0.036358472,
0.0313901156,
0.023369642,
0.0487339981,
-0.0016253083,
-0.0134122372,
-0.0080675995,
-0.081490092,
-0.0088945599,
0.0145236924,
0.0250256304,
-0.020859655,
0.0174900126,
-0.0208142232,
-0.0312810875,
0.0107095363,
0.0074282386,
1.666119749e-34,
-0.018482212,
0.0160322394,
-0.0083305594,
0.028215684,
0.0376839228,
-0.0289663617,
-0.0497326329,
0.0073245242,
0.0088682212,
-0.0277541392,
0.0115151908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04430v1 | SILO Language Models: Isolating Legal Risk In a Nonparametric Datastore | 2023-08-08T17:58:15 | 2023-08-08T17:58:15 | Sewon Min, Suchin Gururangan, Eric Wallace, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Noah A. Smith, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The legality of training language models (LMs) on copyrighted or otherwise
restricted data is under intense debate. However, as we show, model performance
significantly degrades if trained only on low-risk text (e.g., out-of-copyright
books or government documents), due to its limited size and domain coverage. We
present SILO, a new language model that manages this risk-performance tradeoff
during inference. SILO is built by (1) training a parametric LM on Open License
Corpus (OLC), a new corpus we curate with 228B tokens of public domain and
permissively licensed text and (2) augmenting it with a more general and easily
modifiable nonparametric datastore (e.g., containing copyrighted books or news)
that is only queried during inference. The datastore allows use of high-risk
data without training on it, supports sentence-level data attribution, and
enables data producers to opt out from the model by removing content from the
store. These capabilities can foster compliance with data-use regulations such
as the fair use doctrine in the United States and the GDPR in the European
Union. Our experiments show that the parametric LM struggles on domains not
covered by OLC. However, access to the datastore greatly improves out of domain
performance, closing 90% of the performance gap with an LM trained on the Pile,
a more diverse corpus with mostly high-risk text. We also analyze which
nonparametric approach works best, where the remaining errors lie, and how
performance scales with datastore size. Our results suggest that it is possible
to build high quality language models while mitigating their legal risk. | [
0.0408236459,
0.098070398,
-0.008180513,
0.0245693382,
-0.0637296513,
0.0174704008,
0.0866303295,
0.0206952915,
0.0256839041,
-0.0558284149,
-0.0464942791,
-0.0002251129,
-0.0327775069,
-0.0019989614,
-0.0046362737,
0.0050426065,
0.0205839071,
-0.0248425324,
0.0278904811,
-0.0435665473,
-0.0022548235,
0.0398885943,
0.0326433405,
0.0110943401,
0.0273219496,
-0.0128996624,
0.0071609383,
0.0223596636,
0.0096306382,
0.0199603327,
0.0211364739,
0.0612045154,
0.0259551723,
0.07090085,
0.0000015318,
-0.0792081431,
-0.0385456085,
0.0221385024,
0.0131480386,
0.0351893082,
0.0987981111,
-0.0177530292,
-0.0216099788,
0.0103633078,
-0.0401238017,
0.0167537257,
0.0107086711,
0.0125701958,
0.037100058,
0.0740892142,
-0.0285132192,
-0.0262210332,
0.0170066636,
-0.069674097,
-0.0178004969,
-0.0309609249,
0.0359823368,
-0.0085534547,
0.0035583142,
0.0147800036,
0.002672974,
0.0621840395,
0.0286291055,
0.0093994997,
-0.0456939191,
0.0107143447,
-0.0324717313,
-0.0100649027,
0.0063655195,
0.0355482548,
-0.0029228721,
-0.0451145582,
0.0420200601,
-0.0103947632,
0.0337601006,
0.0328977481,
-0.0248649102,
0.0934523717,
0.0034935139,
0.0319385678,
0.0096347528,
-0.0059178802,
0.0445353128,
0.0479722805,
0.020491099,
0.0232480559,
0.0105167944,
-0.0536509827,
0.0236685071,
-0.0153385783,
-0.0166970491,
-0.0163179655,
0.0442390218,
-0.0409875624,
0.0356060266,
0.0284479987,
-0.0842683911,
-0.0332515799,
0.0446618758,
-0.074326463,
-0.0273781363,
-0.0144894915,
-0.0322640873,
0.0688662753,
-0.0225939006,
-0.0001608395,
-0.018350089,
0.0446715057,
0.0107738981,
-0.0426986739,
0.0076664742,
0.0000234773,
-0.0073886248,
0.056130819,
-0.0516334102,
-0.0122213718,
-0.0417496003,
0.0046581947,
-0.019470783,
-0.0068505318,
-0.0038379668,
-0.0042601642,
-0.0080471197,
-0.0233513657,
-0.0044988184,
-0.0396183357,
0.0057074572,
0.0625451654,
-0.0164101906,
-0.0545127466,
0.0135749104,
0.0165641885,
0.0063379491,
-0.0530400649,
0.045708973,
0.0779000297,
0.033806704,
-0.021831112,
-0.0362404883,
-0.0552534051,
0.0026800178,
-0.0553163886,
-0.000350832,
-0.0601808541,
0.0173412748,
-0.0012476962,
0.0107162418,
-0.0950920582,
-0.0251790099,
0.0330542289,
-0.0755413696,
0.0236114468,
-0.0014646464,
-0.013785772,
-0.0428675488,
0.0172249675,
0.0110413479,
0.0507309362,
0.022285996,
0.0179278329,
0.061540246,
-0.0023602399,
0.0142013924,
0.0586579889,
0.0342961065,
0.0593726598,
-0.0276065432,
0.0151219238,
-0.0032727264,
-0.0351597965,
0.0354278758,
0.0715393946,
0.0095738601,
-0.0439860336,
0.0649217293,
0.0748661533,
0.0339165218,
0.0179157723,
-0.0187484901,
0.0178807359,
-0.0021342244,
-0.0399555638,
-0.0543929338,
-0.0180357248,
0.0012065768,
-0.0253906976,
-0.0006440529,
0.0322988145,
-0.003896428,
0.0076552583,
-0.0153988721,
-0.0158900749,
0.034779802,
0.0290788319,
0.0401313864,
0.0016748601,
-0.0072834305,
0.0906911716,
0.0026090024,
-0.0543617532,
0.0024291461,
-0.036935702,
0.0085428916,
0.0401893333,
0.0536372587,
-0.0146208974,
0.0704057291,
-0.0636040643,
0.0054982789,
0.0672978759,
0.0047157602,
-0.0023427394,
0.035408143,
-0.0467440337,
-0.035450615,
-0.0167803094,
0.0301869698,
0.0059324582,
0.0105838757,
0.0310306214,
0.048008386,
-0.0569914505,
-0.02650165,
0.0048480784,
-0.0238992926,
-0.0142504992,
-0.0065087411,
-0.0171380807,
0.0183590166,
0.016366858,
-0.0344339497,
-0.0205730479,
0.0204672068,
0.0065460443,
-0.0468284711,
0.0110822609,
0.0004311109,
0.0160238575,
0.0346638635,
-0.0071413703,
0.0493773855,
0.0282969214,
-0.0387740135,
-0.0030630783,
0.0188685264,
0.0061346684,
0.0368590392,
-0.0497799329,
-0.0106602916,
-0.0270673167,
0.0266107842,
-0.021864593,
0.0274271853,
-0.0276345387,
0.0266012307,
0.0072062593,
-0.0397454053,
0.067653358,
-0.0122044496,
-0.039401602,
0.0002133954,
-0.0554891154,
0.0741707832,
0.0220587421,
-0.0013258319,
-0.0013551532,
-0.0062604505,
-0.0095848637,
-0.0011128475,
-0.0331490859,
0.0118187899,
0.0000208318,
-0.0036696859,
-0.0445638821,
-0.0092943013,
-0.0235770009,
-0.0834126398,
-0.0142770605,
0.0210315771,
-0.0068165148,
-0.0168539993,
-0.0096753305,
0.0175455641,
-0.0349066593,
-0.0058149081,
0.0315875262,
-0.0011860233,
0.0193862189,
-0.0081785796,
0.0429025628,
-0.0181129798,
0.0189595167,
-0.0148041705,
0.0083639789,
-0.0223395228,
-0.018193353,
-0.0406406783,
0.0426432192,
-0.0046961047,
-0.0337664969,
0.0429254733,
0.0048269061,
-0.0555954203,
-0.0092947809,
0.0123080201,
-0.0286621153,
-0.036542803,
-0.0144987144,
0.0403158851,
0.001558897,
0.0116159637,
-0.0218117479,
-0.0341171138,
0.0231490787,
-0.022028489,
-0.0151778115,
-0.0178892296,
0.0125628496,
-0.0308772251,
0.0323441476,
0.005820551,
-0.0678600296,
0.0386336371,
-0.0180041436,
0.0501830354,
-0.0318620503,
-0.0115437936,
-0.0365259685,
0.0238401704,
-0.014136605,
0.0300906748,
0.0243493132,
-0.0235455502,
-0.0143152392,
0.024326589,
0.0738414079,
-0.0341787674,
0.0333390273,
-0.018508099,
0.0153495008,
-0.0098744407,
-0.0453416631,
-0.0133978743,
-0.0706564859,
-0.0043042814,
0.0034198656,
0.004316288,
-0.0118416501,
0.003437479,
-0.0201344118,
0.009095449,
0.0532328933,
-0.0031285242,
0.0190985072,
-0.0014076546,
0.0306139346,
0.0372672565,
-0.0367900953,
-0.0013300497,
-0.012687956,
-0.0276384857,
0.0271104965,
0.0374816507,
-0.0052457014,
0.0169181097,
0.0331860706,
0.037437018,
-0.0120682372,
-0.0085065523,
0.0284395218,
0.0232777186,
-0.0345213488,
0.017221814,
0.0853626207,
0.0096443193,
-0.0267328992,
-0.0286637675,
0.0229788516,
0.0172113087,
0.0122117614,
0.0120459907,
-0.128481403,
-0.0075034867,
-0.0038650227,
0.0474993289,
-0.0320459493,
-0.0314573832,
-0.0089491773,
-0.0947501138,
0.05729964,
0.0132647976,
0.0037060643,
-0.0065278872,
-0.0459228866,
-0.0236520339,
-0.0594272912,
-0.0149234813,
-0.0374260284,
-0.0245752875,
-0.0118394801,
0.0234300829,
0.0115770614,
-0.0357308686,
0.0168374572,
-0.057367824,
0.0128980754,
0.0320315436,
-0.0029268519,
-0.0374276154,
-0.0247512665,
0.031317614,
-0.0143495239,
-0.0374534875,
0.005995709,
0.0379847437,
-0.0007896755,
0.0200255159,
-0.0184722915,
0.0569720343,
-0.0096538216,
-0.0483905822,
-0.0002567153,
0.0490307659,
0.0152905835,
-0.0096029919,
-0.0150615992,
-0.0163170788,
0.0074353772,
0.0658644661,
-0.0066720634,
-0.045376379,
-0.0212690327,
-0.0462459177,
-0.0233943835,
-0.0310855415,
0.0030123633,
-0.0054839463,
-0.0282726847,
-0.0508689545,
-0.0203360412,
-0.0062610074,
-0.0615324043,
0.0336191282,
0.0293921791,
0.0206865259,
0.0144423107,
-0.0342992023,
-0.02611617,
0.000084039,
-0.0562890097,
0.0045027803,
-0.025592424,
0.0271072704,
-0.0009848542,
0.0423798673,
-0.0306202676,
-0.0000417561,
-0.0998070985,
-0.0675445944,
0.0381342582,
0.0179680772,
0.0289226379,
0.0162625629,
-0.0320075043,
-0.0730763599,
0.1005334929,
0.0880074948,
-0.0734809786,
0.0106060058,
0.0777194574,
-0.057038825,
-0.0122746872,
0.0458759405,
-0.0651327521,
-0.006487322,
0.0400331281,
-0.0126818158,
-0.0109592509,
0.0028310113,
0.0017932263,
0.0323479474,
0.01700758,
-0.0263803564,
-0.0128456056,
-0.0403202698,
0.0085916873,
0.0078276526,
-0.0210101865,
-0.0113480575,
0.0170236826,
0.0476206914,
-0.0256854091,
-0.0434519015,
0.0751459002,
-0.0094343377,
0.0328314193,
-0.0536599085,
0.0308640823,
0.0464794487,
0.0055279518,
0.0272663981,
-0.0135718025,
-0.002766395,
0.0457177833,
-0.0062999702,
0.0554179586,
-0.0005917543,
0.0373373516,
-0.0036784024,
0.0280122664,
0.0209617354,
0.0199411921,
-0.0600265972,
-0.0278566852,
-0.0172043946,
0.0043895766,
0.0518553704,
-0.0130873667,
0.0443232432,
-0.0513290726,
-0.0221093167,
-0.0176129695,
0.0394422673,
0.0036312591,
-0.0655011907,
0.007482559,
-0.0054392149,
-0.0450093485,
0.0646180212,
0.0652365685,
0.0482389256,
0.0369090326,
-0.0072914832,
-0.0097050751,
-0.0261540059,
-0.0260323398,
0.0011052552,
-0.0047264118,
-0.0317406617,
-0.0180997532,
-0.0655092523,
-0.0741530359,
-0.0104835406,
-0.0000249074,
0.0256446954,
-0.0192570835,
-0.0094062742,
0.0577691868,
-0.0138450023,
-0.0054566725,
-0.0647582337,
0.0058268174,
-0.0053764419,
-0.0552014783,
-0.0307640415,
-5.61798505e-33,
0.0300681684,
0.0128820315,
-0.0311817899,
0.0024297708,
0.0163187496,
0.0033651069,
0.0097083719,
-0.0143482666,
-0.0142027047,
-0.0226561241,
-0.020730935,
0.0202482697,
0.0091703674,
0.0157187898,
0.007866987,
-0.0343887731,
0.0197291169,
-0.0105340537,
-0.0402297303,
0.0168895032,
0.033157222,
0.0218798351,
0.027877409,
-0.078030929,
0.066340588,
-0.0070977439,
-0.0526647978,
-0.0123017933,
-0.0292701647,
0.0551372543,
0.0119776502,
0.0367747657,
0.0094402442,
-0.0776018873,
-0.0043340726,
0.0195346195,
-0.0556306913,
0.0309551172,
0.0147040002,
0.0000693723,
0.0833267421,
-0.0504313186,
0.0605007969,
0.0002995766,
-0.0208828039,
-0.0122410646,
0.0273104012,
-0.0151563287,
-0.0414273329,
-0.0728043392,
0.00822003,
0.0325909816,
-0.0133009031,
0.0304703899,
0.0308778342,
0.0471993573,
0.0063540116,
0.0628791153,
-0.0446354561,
0.0135887377,
0.0181262158,
-0.0108758956,
0.0582228266,
-0.0077444115,
0.0178801231,
0.0436184816,
-0.0223017968,
-0.0250173192,
0.0217249729,
-0.0154923489,
0.053386502,
0.0374904573,
0.0207689144,
0.0822163895,
0.050862778,
-0.0132332193,
-0.054125376,
0.0033390753,
0.0010237078,
-0.0084910654,
0.0137992008,
-0.0059305984,
-0.026192151,
-0.0415641218,
-0.0558711886,
-0.0485179722,
-0.003951163,
-0.015212818,
0.0251982026,
0.0077585564,
-0.0099737579,
0.0018365078,
0.037618503,
-0.0609583221,
-0.0789007768,
0.0307491235,
-0.0218501277,
-0.0069590169,
0.0020965131,
0.0412066691,
-0.0838713422,
-0.014808855,
0.019664688,
-0.0181790441,
0.0219414793,
-0.0127007663,
0.0783247277,
0.0402945019,
-0.0901413709,
0.013144657,
0.0037001343,
0.0313110575,
0.0096741021,
0.0455802381,
0.0206502471,
0.0328970253,
0.0364275575,
0.0187776051,
0.0173600838,
-0.0159109086,
-0.032398738,
0.0054828571,
-0.0100238519,
0.000102592,
-0.006797513,
-0.0221607778,
0.0042260983,
0.0144335739,
0.0575549901,
-0.0686813742,
-0.0053562326,
0.0128067965,
2.413e-7,
0.062418744,
-0.0224855915,
-0.0070970412,
0.0063834465,
-0.0106420089,
0.0664522797,
-0.004247183,
0.0938453078,
-0.0258246232,
0.0165533368,
-0.0384159349,
-0.0203834306,
0.0774831772,
0.0497722141,
-0.1095836908,
-0.0158664882,
-0.0624750815,
0.0271882396,
-0.0638728961,
0.0121366978,
-0.0026464427,
0.0953530744,
0.0479436703,
-0.0383527912,
0.0015847164,
-0.0447709002,
0.0610988922,
-0.0405959785,
-0.0253069308,
-0.0391388126,
0.065284647,
0.0525767952,
0.0034652306,
-0.0037444443,
-0.0212362297,
0.0515270196,
-0.0417636782,
0.0823146701,
0.0597388931,
-0.0298667233,
-0.0107352976,
-0.0829882622,
-0.0252817888,
-0.0342977308,
0.0649230704,
0.0321076959,
-0.0174959917,
-0.0079349866,
-0.0125429314,
-0.0392435826,
-0.0002305666,
-0.0223242082,
-0.0314895771,
-0.0173266958,
0.0149587449,
-0.0180958714,
0.0211388413,
-0.0854850337,
-0.017770132,
-0.0307921767,
-0.0090813972,
-0.0046222424,
-0.0022957965,
0.0243070219,
0.02329126,
-0.0606839061,
0.0620984212,
2.345009981e-34,
0.0493809059,
-0.0374519527,
-0.0166596919,
0.0114503624,
0.0100895269,
-0.0044353842,
0.0410667732,
0.012298245,
-0.0174342711,
-0.047933422,
0.0056560943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04424v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04424v2 | A Bi-directional Multi-hop Inference Model for Joint Dialog Sentiment Classification and Act Recognition | 2023-08-08T17:53:24 | 2023-08-12T06:17:42 | Li Zheng, Fei Li, Yuyang Chai, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | The joint task of Dialog Sentiment Classification (DSC) and Act Recognition
(DAR) aims to predict the sentiment label and act label for each utterance in a
dialog simultaneously. However, current methods encode the dialog context in
only one direction, which limits their ability to thoroughly comprehend the
context. Moreover, these methods overlook the explicit correlations between
sentiment and act labels, which leads to an insufficient ability to capture
rich sentiment and act clues and hinders effective and accurate reasoning. To
address these issues, we propose a Bi-directional Multi-hop Inference Model
(BMIM) that leverages a feature selection network and a bi-directional
multi-hop inference network to iteratively extract and integrate rich sentiment
and act clues in a bi-directional manner. We also employ contrastive learning
and dual learning to explicitly model the correlations of sentiment and act
labels. Our experiments on two widely-used datasets show that BMIM outperforms
state-of-the-art baselines by at least 2.6% on F1 score in DAR and 1.4% on F1
score in DSC. Additionally, Our proposed model not only improves the
performance but also enhances the interpretability of the joint sentiment and
act prediction task. | [
-0.0137599595,
0.0825627372,
-0.0022572698,
0.0414110571,
-0.0298375133,
0.0266861692,
0.0385356061,
-0.0211981721,
0.1016675606,
-0.0651550964,
-0.0564827956,
-0.0299732257,
-0.0547965728,
0.0874860063,
-0.0065671294,
0.0064221271,
0.0550827421,
0.0294321422,
0.0355838723,
-0.0063211555,
0.00704333,
0.0459092744,
-0.0188525412,
0.0295862276,
-0.0067210686,
-0.0468507074,
-0.0032999543,
0.0277094059,
0.0090872264,
-0.0098145325,
0.0680798665,
0.0605719946,
0.0341406986,
0.0031147676,
0.0000019993,
-0.0348935612,
-0.0033742695,
-0.0331843421,
-0.0302514173,
-0.0121041276,
0.0202731136,
0.0209972281,
0.0225144736,
0.0105953757,
-0.023504978,
-0.0263106059,
0.0349050537,
0.1110649556,
0.022615334,
0.0508819632,
-0.0221454371,
-0.0408949368,
-0.0296573341,
-0.0415868536,
-0.0076974826,
-0.0232067704,
0.0135196969,
-0.0017649073,
-0.0618495382,
0.0422326773,
-0.0080431895,
0.0243806597,
0.0100414231,
-0.0228446499,
-0.0319133326,
0.0309247952,
0.0219199229,
-0.0135679459,
0.0089838514,
0.0571570471,
0.0232673138,
0.0011154453,
0.0190947037,
-0.0189536195,
-0.0018598055,
0.0033770129,
-0.0384930633,
-0.0401096866,
0.0021242728,
0.0237707384,
0.0222059973,
0.0140681472,
0.0353908986,
0.0408331491,
-0.0117424065,
0.0127670541,
-0.0542235337,
-0.0164128188,
0.0207336005,
0.0351046398,
0.0196048785,
-0.0125419181,
0.0229940861,
-0.0416044295,
-0.0268549658,
0.0086376993,
0.0159562714,
-0.0059722015,
0.0085677458,
-0.046632465,
-0.0134494994,
0.0075971182,
-0.0635788143,
0.0742891133,
-0.0172631312,
0.002685749,
0.0167744122,
0.0313882269,
-0.0209003948,
-0.0015176912,
-0.0291075148,
-0.0171544664,
0.0098769888,
0.0379688442,
-0.0525684319,
-0.0160585735,
-0.0570196323,
-0.036610771,
-0.0498199463,
-0.0257268772,
0.0355018564,
0.0160104726,
-0.00920456,
-0.0098106153,
-0.0208537169,
0.0821546987,
-0.0322115049,
0.0637602136,
-0.0037129088,
-0.0125031639,
-0.0312569402,
0.0369350687,
0.0018403357,
-0.0041541271,
0.0207675993,
0.0764980689,
-0.0041353484,
-0.012603824,
-0.020876972,
-0.0135969333,
-0.0310392138,
-0.0423000827,
0.0047111465,
-0.0132207246,
0.062567994,
-0.0303990617,
-0.0121968677,
-0.0141103724,
0.0088292761,
-0.012419573,
-0.014276241,
0.0709934309,
0.0397955701,
-0.0647100955,
0.0071711321,
0.0078566289,
-0.0664791837,
0.067077145,
-0.0016771397,
0.0563977063,
0.0314586274,
0.0300568976,
0.0136396391,
0.0005359081,
0.019575309,
-0.039934434,
0.0545482263,
-0.004355669,
-0.0194923095,
0.0048419889,
0.0168764219,
0.0321422741,
-0.0402587317,
-0.0551215559,
0.0408505984,
0.0343224071,
0.0269246195,
0.0104556382,
0.0229848567,
0.0379342288,
-0.0245631561,
-0.0439602807,
-0.0182542484,
0.0430589542,
0.0116067985,
-0.022624623,
0.0449590534,
0.017187573,
-0.0502355471,
-0.0774082243,
0.0188406613,
-0.0340139195,
0.0314259082,
0.0235246606,
0.0559203029,
-0.0010387558,
-0.080218941,
0.0260478221,
0.0392218754,
-0.0368302464,
-0.004923881,
-0.072904326,
0.0231756661,
0.0430665798,
-0.0089460025,
-0.0228144359,
-0.0273940694,
-0.0485515296,
-0.0029699572,
0.0074614212,
0.0459379815,
-0.016937295,
0.022169847,
-0.0678686202,
-0.0103276111,
-0.0122561492,
0.0258502644,
0.0410747044,
-0.0551383123,
0.0033107996,
0.0082362406,
0.0447291806,
0.0008637524,
-0.0224588625,
-0.0204440635,
-0.0117028318,
0.0477826223,
0.0117874211,
0.0780181438,
0.028369518,
0.0115476325,
-0.0083386786,
0.011468485,
-0.0153219206,
-0.0525173433,
0.0210507382,
-0.044866804,
-0.120843716,
-0.0044132536,
-0.0197953396,
-0.0369913206,
0.0354996659,
-0.0676766932,
-0.0293348636,
0.0296049584,
-0.0093567027,
-0.0130803101,
-0.0437623523,
-0.0523614623,
0.0279956572,
0.0135108568,
0.0026908489,
0.0585662536,
-0.0219733883,
-0.0191705134,
-0.0273122247,
0.031256564,
0.0007308632,
0.0114941113,
-0.0132396761,
-0.0168415178,
0.0042993468,
-0.0115988497,
-0.007269918,
0.0237255562,
-0.034263026,
-0.0293097887,
-0.0935582072,
-0.003588934,
0.001221028,
0.0107666431,
-0.0044170641,
-0.0205782149,
0.0049658953,
0.0015569333,
-0.0330708362,
0.0001841648,
-0.0102510992,
-0.0108923828,
0.0179798454,
0.0056215529,
0.0185859781,
-0.0395930186,
0.0022204826,
-0.0389247984,
0.0428774282,
-0.012530393,
-0.0275483709,
0.0005783668,
0.0036276476,
-0.0387058705,
0.0059266482,
-0.0556671135,
-0.038048882,
-0.0232872944,
-0.0243811831,
-0.0305301845,
0.0367326066,
0.0133026838,
0.0599850491,
-0.0170733705,
-0.0073838746,
-0.0425318778,
0.0569555201,
-0.0428397544,
0.0742904171,
-0.0066247182,
-0.0197442044,
-0.0186512992,
0.1016414016,
0.0239697117,
0.0067615472,
-0.0317857489,
-0.0152468206,
0.005920114,
-0.019216964,
0.0083587719,
-0.0122036124,
-0.0086820088,
-0.0066433847,
-0.0143429888,
-0.0290532634,
0.1004392728,
0.0184856914,
-0.0281544495,
-0.0655710846,
-0.0307487156,
-0.0389650613,
0.0816358626,
-0.020119546,
-0.0094049685,
0.0050848257,
-0.0139924092,
-0.0091573261,
-0.0238272194,
0.0237712748,
-0.0547447875,
0.0672333315,
-0.0272535849,
0.0132996012,
0.0143641392,
-0.0463501066,
0.008111963,
-0.0255276822,
-0.0395148359,
-0.0100173065,
0.0121770296,
-0.0059474939,
0.0194776226,
-0.0005711674,
-0.0095103998,
0.016844159,
0.0126493713,
0.0190068036,
0.0067843576,
0.0094623389,
0.0470738634,
0.0040430175,
-0.0001474936,
-0.0160960704,
0.0313529372,
0.0413849093,
-0.021418076,
-0.0126985069,
0.0059706727,
-0.0050268839,
0.0178464856,
0.0418565981,
-0.0134068793,
-0.0391586572,
0.068557255,
-0.0468804128,
0.0121997204,
0.0930910408,
0.0072060744,
-0.0581531413,
-0.0150041291,
-0.0075461818,
-0.0065379073,
-0.0054523968,
-0.0079990961,
-0.0561612956,
-0.0723050311,
-0.0244309828,
-0.00252432,
0.0086049195,
-0.0154338144,
0.0395548642,
-0.0694492608,
0.0381961539,
-0.0058746347,
-0.0216344669,
-0.0709963664,
-0.0218977276,
0.0037743368,
-0.0310765449,
0.0285691787,
-0.039069023,
0.0420921855,
-0.020682577,
0.0058814813,
-0.0133328363,
0.0144182229,
0.0829826593,
-0.0059505459,
0.0372431874,
-0.0080679459,
0.048662167,
0.0151063791,
-0.0153948832,
0.0503551327,
-0.062590383,
-0.0154421329,
-0.0529897474,
0.0606188886,
-0.0348589197,
-0.029734524,
-0.0174825825,
0.038256675,
-0.035649769,
-0.0246060081,
-0.049434159,
0.0562517233,
-0.0108977407,
-0.0413369276,
-0.0199690908,
0.0519779883,
0.0321291313,
0.0800437257,
-0.001570173,
-0.0349644795,
-0.0273483302,
-0.0412315726,
-0.0020732777,
-0.0522120073,
-0.0118710231,
-0.0140548637,
0.0087072188,
-0.0031320362,
-0.0229264889,
-0.0668804199,
-0.0022025453,
-0.0004297868,
-0.0500169247,
0.0260283761,
0.0002617196,
-0.0072094714,
-0.0077056824,
0.030313367,
0.0047809533,
0.0162218977,
0.0506909676,
-0.0419142134,
0.0700409412,
-0.0000042909,
-0.065929994,
0.0342003331,
-0.0340403169,
-0.012147449,
-0.0347140282,
0.0680955425,
0.0107503133,
0.054196123,
-0.0035444326,
0.0255579855,
-0.0200371668,
0.0465971008,
-0.0228438806,
-0.0411820263,
0.0834635571,
0.0842517316,
-0.004775404,
0.0329402834,
-0.0301184449,
0.04687199,
-0.0030920631,
0.023869209,
-0.0610263757,
-0.0611855723,
-0.0301746912,
-0.0450804941,
0.0762735084,
0.0525708757,
-0.0047975495,
-0.0743796453,
0.0114763845,
0.0037028054,
-0.0162175186,
-0.0450554043,
0.0164241139,
0.0219797436,
-0.0266926847,
-0.0466419421,
-0.0047876718,
0.0022778835,
0.014009688,
-0.0092942556,
0.0092105698,
0.0397951677,
0.0264204592,
-0.019646382,
-0.0274693947,
-0.0635771155,
-0.0076370435,
0.0427066013,
-0.0023522798,
0.0166996289,
0.0774009004,
0.0332566388,
0.0105868801,
-0.013768686,
-0.0073776906,
-0.0445418693,
0.0179903191,
-0.0318323374,
-0.0138214417,
0.0094682798,
-0.0378653295,
0.0377270617,
-0.0147133255,
0.0118963337,
0.0004576426,
0.0673419163,
0.0005914829,
-0.0092008449,
0.0440231599,
0.0144279506,
-0.002771588,
-0.0201860815,
0.0429650657,
-0.0721627623,
0.0430753082,
-0.0079420563,
-0.0178052243,
-0.0386380032,
-0.0386318751,
0.0388065837,
-0.0015967255,
-0.0014262717,
0.031729348,
-0.0560906343,
-0.0662690029,
0.0385562181,
-0.0034935141,
0.0191198476,
0.0087013189,
0.0357386433,
0.0607346259,
0.03968044,
0.010582922,
-0.05485617,
-0.006211834,
-0.0082814842,
-0.0045165308,
-0.0277259387,
-6.408110475e-33,
-0.0071894848,
0.0029441945,
-0.019439064,
0.0144508313,
-0.01889221,
0.0086526107,
-0.0590895042,
-0.0150156338,
-0.0348437503,
0.0727234632,
0.0364293046,
0.0184225105,
0.0001200722,
0.0383857712,
0.0134500135,
-0.0464095138,
0.0243034177,
0.0043648318,
0.0260006841,
0.039399866,
0.0356119312,
0.0241225641,
0.0580570623,
-0.1069639623,
0.0247673839,
-0.027881328,
-0.0029648556,
0.0394687094,
-0.0053651538,
0.0502400883,
-0.0072817067,
0.0421016365,
0.0299721975,
-0.0230260864,
0.0190484133,
0.0463423505,
-0.0456781536,
-0.0476520285,
0.0085195163,
-0.022164382,
-0.0220433902,
-0.0181513671,
-0.0161752515,
0.0345726199,
-0.0045062485,
-0.0516823716,
0.0210628398,
0.0036735041,
0.0007781434,
-0.0592844971,
-0.0153021021,
0.0105907945,
-0.0313243121,
-0.0306575913,
-0.0237314217,
0.0694939941,
0.0344740786,
0.0254855491,
-0.0544688925,
-0.0099551193,
-0.0473253578,
-0.0066190525,
0.0085021453,
-0.0009926825,
0.0055960426,
0.1006447896,
0.0123326257,
0.0174278915,
-0.0400735512,
0.0099780336,
-0.0096795233,
0.0220093243,
0.0210992452,
0.0658006296,
0.0137007348,
-0.0212726593,
-0.0825622678,
-0.0001147664,
0.0701802075,
0.0210325625,
0.0300782267,
0.0215694923,
-0.0115591977,
-0.020569073,
0.0054778848,
-0.0495861024,
-0.0216443893,
-0.0234918557,
-0.001814808,
0.0195560195,
0.0001897204,
0.0165952686,
0.0234542377,
-0.0510496423,
-0.0170686971,
0.0186567921,
-0.0242595058,
-0.0229280461,
0.0277055688,
0.0248606633,
-0.0690171346,
-0.0607252121,
0.0076358528,
0.0227611233,
0.0079726418,
0.0240318067,
0.0552290231,
-0.0221543983,
-0.0277906284,
-0.0209033079,
-0.0169929378,
-0.0036951129,
-0.0516414307,
0.0337845124,
0.0044159992,
0.032041911,
-0.01047148,
0.0730044991,
-0.0091779511,
0.0477790572,
-0.0098349685,
-0.0072671273,
-0.0103976885,
0.0144292787,
-0.0347574092,
-0.0287632253,
-0.0127617316,
-0.0339531153,
-0.0049156845,
-0.086503908,
-0.0169342291,
0.007940203,
2.73e-7,
0.0428292714,
0.0408387668,
-0.0145331658,
0.019265322,
0.0297786165,
0.0792424306,
-0.0102009643,
0.0132617429,
0.0428294651,
-0.030731298,
0.0328203589,
0.0256787818,
0.0449826457,
0.0173799656,
-0.1091868505,
-0.0103470609,
-0.0247977357,
-0.0053286543,
-0.0070283422,
0.024336623,
0.118776463,
0.0867885947,
0.0365501978,
-0.0021113809,
0.016016867,
-0.0035965713,
0.0500319377,
-0.0285114087,
-0.0200672559,
0.0113097848,
0.0019030286,
-0.0496196374,
-0.0050313408,
0.0503944345,
-0.038839858,
0.0216080267,
0.0150157036,
0.0834575742,
0.0327495001,
-0.0688451603,
-0.0088817598,
0.0277706124,
0.0311633032,
-0.0001912286,
0.0534916222,
-0.0727978945,
-0.0160865616,
-0.0366283171,
-0.0530082509,
0.014124562,
0.0505725183,
0.0226871576,
-0.0254603252,
0.0326008275,
0.0013971239,
-0.0200826898,
-0.0162789188,
-0.1216823906,
0.0196544658,
0.0166421235,
-0.0714307427,
-0.025959352,
0.0020509523,
-0.0078215972,
0.0589698069,
-0.0295560751,
0.0206878651,
2.265637939e-34,
0.0470227413,
-0.0354996584,
-0.0095245996,
0.0476666652,
0.035427846,
-0.0109808696,
-0.0107342787,
-0.0158525128,
0.0418481901,
-0.0330506749,
-0.0036420026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04398v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04398v1 | Character-level NMT and language similarity | 2023-08-08T17:01:42 | 2023-08-08T17:01:42 | Josef Jon, Ondřej Bojar | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore the effectiveness of character-level neural machine translation
using Transformer architecture for various levels of language similarity and
size of the training dataset on translation between Czech and Croatian, German,
Hungarian, Slovak, and Spanish. We evaluate the models using automatic MT
metrics and show that translation between similar languages benefits from
character-level input segmentation, while for less related languages,
character-level vanilla Transformer-base often lags behind subword-level
segmentation. We confirm previous findings that it is possible to close the gap
by finetuning the already trained subword-level models to character-level. | [
0.0166822355,
0.0643778592,
-0.0129853263,
0.0382116958,
-0.032229159,
0.0221975725,
0.0292669535,
0.0247869343,
-0.0733416453,
0.0133568645,
-0.0371621661,
-0.0793366581,
0.0206485,
-0.0301098805,
0.0663509592,
-0.0463530868,
0.0237635542,
-0.0094183749,
-0.067702882,
0.0019407334,
0.0094822142,
-0.0033418394,
0.0216685962,
0.027855847,
0.0048150877,
0.0117747793,
0.0014816868,
0.0098169707,
0.0321075246,
-0.004399165,
-0.0327146836,
-0.0055809617,
0.0193046816,
0.0887995586,
0.0000018041,
-0.0060548889,
-0.0451091342,
-0.0185433682,
0.0301553439,
-0.0348622203,
0.0775570646,
-0.073669225,
-0.026905993,
0.0204970073,
0.0258614607,
-0.0393723324,
0.065100342,
0.0416474715,
0.0180073362,
0.0620202608,
-0.0351634845,
-0.0547122508,
0.014467434,
-0.0424786508,
-0.0313818343,
-0.0129382769,
-0.0270774849,
-0.0024494296,
-0.0353667662,
0.0051790732,
-0.0066676452,
0.0486187488,
-0.0083657904,
-0.0020532971,
-0.0367648341,
0.0307216123,
-0.0234885979,
-0.0130297318,
0.0125231342,
0.0471847914,
-0.0836297348,
-0.0336683504,
-0.0088978345,
-0.0011489014,
0.0014110567,
0.0015033911,
-0.0324386135,
0.0245823134,
-0.0222318526,
0.0273518842,
0.0143861445,
0.0765751302,
0.0418722443,
-0.0491213128,
-0.0366447531,
-0.0047179931,
0.0530017093,
-0.0467185043,
-0.0020397222,
0.0038750577,
0.0144222043,
-0.0184808746,
0.0435341373,
-0.0076884003,
0.0051223096,
0.0125274239,
-0.0082887867,
-0.0356249213,
-0.0174453892,
-0.0433995724,
0.0272848308,
0.0880111158,
-0.006315114,
-0.0017134,
-0.0383192413,
0.0812402144,
-0.0571936518,
0.0196031649,
-0.078336373,
-0.0755724832,
-0.0665355176,
-0.0105458247,
-0.0476619229,
-0.0238264035,
0.0031411827,
0.0422606729,
-0.0187815577,
0.0207388494,
0.0320868418,
-0.0186514184,
0.0230702646,
-0.0366643406,
-0.0766521096,
-0.0122860149,
0.0086744586,
0.0762230456,
-0.0332241803,
-0.0336520039,
-0.0220816396,
-0.032159552,
0.0004868574,
0.0150276497,
-0.0323081091,
-0.0490875505,
0.0159836523,
0.0850012824,
-0.0337629728,
-0.063158378,
-0.0241006501,
0.0288437996,
-0.0098410929,
-0.0505985394,
0.0362013876,
-0.0588867627,
0.0709453523,
-0.0130156754,
0.0119402995,
0.0000528043,
-0.0313912742,
0.006311228,
-0.0176153872,
0.0781093538,
0.0263463724,
-0.0140377348,
0.0392107591,
-0.0124661401,
0.041477982,
0.0138584757,
0.0355974659,
0.020469252,
0.0058380216,
-0.0107758725,
-0.0389130712,
0.0543981306,
-0.0267402697,
-0.0008037655,
-0.0399682261,
0.0071744015,
-0.0139842741,
0.0492654108,
0.037818443,
0.0678017586,
-0.0290070195,
-0.0338711627,
0.0533521362,
0.0916069746,
0.0762265995,
0.0842525586,
0.0500948168,
0.0042686053,
-0.0309645347,
0.0219043568,
-0.0062847119,
0.0313232653,
0.0248058699,
0.0103225363,
-0.0330478624,
0.0854848698,
-0.0405162238,
0.0001587835,
0.0033474367,
-0.0304486938,
0.0246725902,
-0.0700775459,
0.0246518292,
0.0143877836,
-0.0536744483,
0.0757311285,
-0.0041315155,
-0.079709284,
0.0101956083,
-0.031030966,
-0.0253569968,
0.0357135311,
0.0283748768,
0.0003483656,
-0.015483804,
-0.0018840921,
-0.0195159707,
0.061388243,
0.0311635286,
0.007262114,
0.018236775,
-0.073656179,
0.0225529466,
0.0037226141,
-0.0162268505,
0.0538890995,
-0.0330999009,
0.0299365763,
0.0371120386,
-0.0642360747,
0.0201126803,
0.0282576531,
-0.024471594,
0.0229071751,
-0.0177882258,
0.0091016293,
-0.0084108412,
0.0154633522,
-0.0222608447,
0.0039160284,
0.0034863804,
-0.0512340181,
-0.0202218834,
0.0539984033,
-0.0712302476,
-0.05196568,
0.0123077389,
-0.067099534,
-0.000131939,
0.0296829399,
-0.0233739503,
-0.0340029113,
-0.0008941415,
-0.040831726,
0.0221332479,
-0.0456220433,
0.0527844466,
-0.0209120456,
-0.0078991475,
-0.0212251823,
0.0502279699,
-0.0228160638,
0.0029551089,
0.0177992266,
-0.0471380726,
0.0422745571,
-0.0130918827,
-0.0247618575,
0.0673200265,
0.0242186859,
0.0069838664,
0.0223825406,
-0.0053377841,
0.0233438313,
-0.0331909135,
-0.0407511108,
0.0050313789,
0.0008959837,
0.0394486487,
0.0350135602,
0.0877952352,
0.0221129321,
-0.0072136135,
-0.0484103188,
0.01347325,
0.0075499555,
-0.0069043864,
0.0381660908,
-0.0292961337,
0.0174431317,
-0.0332060307,
-0.0274843201,
-0.0112661161,
0.0489523932,
-0.0035717441,
-0.0463436134,
-0.0838609412,
0.0234707929,
-0.0180062428,
0.0378728025,
-0.0370790698,
-0.0778199509,
0.0214920789,
-0.0060854377,
0.0506104045,
0.0379871838,
0.0017588538,
-0.039573025,
0.0441965722,
0.0112061435,
-0.0174255222,
-0.0150155723,
-0.0064669522,
0.0142509509,
-0.044275254,
-0.0512013063,
0.0269071441,
0.1061246768,
-0.0240346678,
0.0020795362,
-0.0798194706,
-0.0461586304,
-0.0192807335,
0.0225154981,
0.0191887617,
0.0288352519,
-0.0078843022,
-0.0086657209,
-0.0251586474,
-0.0106638111,
0.0653209239,
-0.0634977296,
-0.0260774381,
-0.0395381413,
-0.0134592745,
-0.0283401329,
0.0334206112,
0.016592579,
0.0022374415,
-0.0097933207,
-0.0572050959,
-0.0478192605,
0.0047584088,
-0.0103958212,
0.0071371803,
0.0692391098,
-0.0077495878,
-0.0206928384,
-0.0219272636,
-0.0002772511,
-0.009080641,
-0.0006830515,
-0.0098753572,
0.0172738992,
0.0273601077,
-0.0516795143,
-0.0093540177,
0.0273751188,
0.0073212446,
0.1103595495,
0.0159186479,
-0.0091028353,
-0.0214636773,
0.0373783223,
-0.0317277126,
-0.0034059132,
0.0080508916,
-0.0449427702,
0.0458604097,
0.0178841483,
-0.0058433437,
-0.0439389721,
-0.0348105282,
-0.0250819698,
0.0329393335,
-0.0256862938,
0.0011148578,
-0.0322466083,
0.0552967638,
-0.0303224362,
-0.0300607141,
0.098256588,
0.0204268917,
-0.0247464124,
-0.0019462815,
-0.0114838248,
0.0456127189,
0.0043265005,
0.010340306,
-0.0470574498,
-0.0209401641,
0.0060488195,
0.0460469685,
0.0245661121,
0.0075417371,
0.0008436333,
-0.0745942518,
-0.0270053577,
0.0191785712,
-0.0801048428,
-0.0318609886,
0.0037486376,
-0.0216437541,
-0.0371163674,
0.0322220586,
0.0049440083,
-0.0131574841,
-0.0451395437,
0.0177419093,
-0.0112474291,
-0.033319436,
0.0043166052,
-0.059104342,
-0.0183489919,
0.0215289202,
0.0390493348,
-0.0217791907,
0.0009475109,
-0.0011418327,
-0.0084577529,
0.0391139016,
0.0146368789,
0.0344488993,
0.0242330022,
-0.0200081151,
-0.027557116,
-0.0219980124,
0.0153060928,
0.0155423041,
-0.0236390568,
0.0488608405,
-0.0086728763,
-0.0078943204,
0.0392772481,
-0.0078893397,
-0.0305661522,
0.0374496616,
0.0301609971,
-0.0095190387,
-0.0007142217,
0.0292354692,
0.0231756438,
-0.0420359597,
-0.021274481,
0.0007810481,
-0.0460871235,
-0.0329513177,
-0.0809168294,
-0.0490952954,
-0.0049724709,
0.0014323111,
-0.0013800883,
-0.021849934,
0.0321420282,
-0.0323153548,
-0.0258361045,
0.0159292575,
-0.0363108739,
0.0115821389,
-0.0537126325,
0.0104694683,
0.0259420425,
-0.0367710479,
-0.0000578045,
-0.0220638085,
-0.1128904745,
-0.0587400347,
-0.0154738538,
0.0227039251,
0.0103837233,
0.0618450679,
-0.0130576193,
-0.0201352816,
0.0112772556,
-0.042045746,
-0.0129272295,
-0.0188262016,
0.0289200321,
-0.0434914976,
-0.0043383879,
0.0176488478,
-0.0030456029,
0.0189537778,
0.0005978928,
0.0004871679,
-0.0049579702,
-0.0243624542,
0.0075339559,
-0.022310026,
0.0219590906,
0.0030008031,
0.0451767631,
-0.0453871265,
0.0353581011,
-0.018284468,
0.0307710059,
-0.0222662743,
-0.0407665968,
0.0815643445,
0.0300299246,
-0.0050822361,
-0.00069326,
-0.055033844,
0.0043243505,
0.004091417,
0.0401786119,
-0.0238448586,
0.0678431317,
0.0104424842,
0.0022043118,
0.0074641607,
0.0152068269,
0.0091405809,
0.0226403549,
-0.0567019545,
0.0453185178,
0.0125747351,
-0.0057159206,
0.0010586992,
0.0813377351,
-0.0328255482,
-0.0181427989,
-0.0054793456,
0.0036161861,
0.0486753695,
-0.0409141108,
0.0661497414,
-0.0226923879,
0.0079577006,
0.0189059284,
0.0124984542,
-0.0272180252,
0.0127529185,
0.0157813411,
0.0006217407,
0.0144395093,
-0.0286483113,
0.0249300655,
-0.0357940607,
0.0187064968,
-0.0121200131,
-0.0257954579,
-0.0096355202,
0.0467813537,
-0.0044709998,
-0.0296048895,
-0.0426937677,
-0.0485786349,
-0.0318411663,
-0.0237482116,
0.0273439493,
0.0072383555,
0.0032906418,
0.0163211524,
0.0171434004,
0.052481588,
-0.01848628,
-0.0103360005,
-0.0125823608,
0.0128749311,
0.0613635667,
-0.0320709907,
-0.0256339144,
-5.771642732e-33,
-0.0275840182,
0.0403506644,
-0.0008524084,
-0.0323622748,
-0.0529416129,
-0.0306227058,
-0.0118840542,
-0.042766124,
-0.0301010683,
0.0058707721,
-0.0037073013,
0.0226221457,
0.0257132817,
-0.0219565015,
-0.0003518223,
0.0130532747,
0.0815669298,
0.0096581923,
-0.0172046106,
0.0015887393,
0.015633503,
0.0259865206,
0.1433359385,
-0.0185911134,
-0.0183429569,
-0.0645602793,
0.0480602272,
0.0206764154,
0.0310419854,
0.0187081974,
0.0024470342,
0.0117355268,
0.0386653058,
-0.0527227223,
-0.0273200348,
-0.0233712681,
-0.0749182627,
-0.0371696539,
0.0027564603,
0.0524563566,
0.0362842567,
-0.016670635,
0.0666168481,
-0.0538697727,
0.0087835183,
-0.0271744281,
0.0105197998,
-0.0194513332,
0.0029042219,
0.0141681433,
-0.0776426792,
0.0290291961,
0.0033487137,
-0.0007501412,
0.043469619,
0.0801517963,
0.0014381888,
-0.0027040523,
-0.0479369462,
0.0199198499,
0.0085396916,
0.0511940792,
0.030437028,
0.0017750573,
-0.0198824797,
-0.0078793205,
0.0742590129,
-0.0276336838,
0.0402109735,
0.0425289646,
0.0396995135,
-0.0290767346,
0.088361375,
0.0421417803,
0.0304391347,
-0.0029251855,
-0.0351260453,
0.0342305787,
-0.0206099004,
0.0313304402,
-0.0268667806,
0.0242496729,
-0.0225508623,
-0.0101293251,
0.0088267718,
-0.044948142,
-0.0019881157,
-0.0331109352,
0.010204304,
-0.0304351822,
-0.0020905281,
0.0175947715,
0.0765902176,
-0.0007349104,
0.0343365185,
-0.0164656453,
-0.0103260074,
0.0160901379,
-0.0306680035,
0.0569732077,
-0.0390077084,
-0.0656295046,
0.0007026535,
0.0234145131,
0.0256693289,
-0.0005917201,
0.0215803292,
0.0263601486,
-0.0412512049,
0.0151180364,
-0.0133242598,
-0.0297961831,
-0.0282902773,
0.0933209956,
0.0022676047,
-0.0010650646,
0.0000792295,
0.0262468942,
0.0465723723,
-0.0493181497,
-0.047844179,
0.0232937876,
0.0504197106,
0.0502411425,
-0.0319549181,
0.0525258407,
-0.0457420573,
0.0332625136,
0.0433265641,
-0.0457080156,
-0.0260189772,
0.0153767429,
2.602e-7,
0.0497839451,
0.0356905051,
0.0503516644,
-0.0188834425,
0.0018939846,
0.00064763,
-0.0511371158,
0.0124702631,
0.0030659682,
0.0565193668,
0.0336984769,
-0.0166114699,
0.0579632372,
0.0596038066,
-0.0726705343,
0.026530819,
-0.0649958625,
-0.0147303808,
-0.0324379429,
0.0051049991,
0.0419271737,
0.0911527872,
-0.0131663661,
-0.0062572518,
-0.0089534894,
-0.0321117304,
0.0529066399,
-0.0101587968,
-0.0213053059,
0.0296196658,
0.0546163395,
0.0180891417,
-0.0565975346,
-0.0024367613,
-0.0049958597,
0.0294611026,
0.0478884876,
0.0177618936,
-0.0285786949,
0.0009930773,
0.0647114143,
-0.0373627543,
-0.0457907692,
-0.0508074202,
0.0303697605,
-0.0531215928,
0.0111468676,
0.0110005978,
0.0118920961,
0.0514153428,
0.0331515595,
-0.0128474049,
-0.0298992693,
0.0417418703,
0.0537059531,
0.0062317909,
-0.0162529983,
-0.0182930399,
-0.00936554,
-0.0197309423,
-0.0189576149,
-0.0301451758,
-0.032438837,
-0.0527108125,
0.0070290207,
0.0041313325,
-0.0173810292,
2.074840513e-34,
-0.0073464285,
0.0253021307,
0.0098392246,
-0.0290499348,
0.0053278902,
-0.0256787799,
0.0004965132,
0.0110277338,
-0.0345786139,
-0.0414645337,
-0.0393397324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04386v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04386v1 | Learning Evaluation Models from Large Language Models for Sequence Generation | 2023-08-08T16:41:16 | 2023-08-08T16:41:16 | Chenglong Wang, Hang Zhou, Kaiyan Chang, Tongran Liu, Chunliang Zhang, Quan Du, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models achieve state-of-the-art performance on sequence
generation evaluation, but typically have a large number of parameters. This is
a computational challenge as presented by applying their evaluation capability
at scale. To overcome the challenge, in this paper, we propose \textbf{ECT}, an
\textbf{e}valuation \textbf{c}apability \textbf{t}ransfer method, to transfer
the evaluation capability from LLMs to relatively lightweight language models.
Based on the proposed ECT, we learn various evaluation models from ChatGPT, and
employ them as reward models to improve sequence generation models via
reinforcement learning and reranking approaches. Experimental results on
machine translation, text style transfer, and summarization tasks demonstrate
the effectiveness of our ECT. Notably, applying the learned evaluation models
to sequence generation models results in better generated sequences as
evaluated by commonly used metrics and ChatGPT. | [
0.03454151,
0.0506188646,
0.0130154667,
-0.0033100175,
-0.0438895971,
0.0200849846,
-0.0243522674,
0.0098433578,
-0.0092739519,
-0.0449133515,
-0.0199750923,
-0.0616361424,
0.0139646828,
0.0040266449,
0.0229493976,
-0.0570478477,
0.0137616936,
-0.0238837451,
0.027280435,
0.0113002369,
-0.0118890312,
-0.0366032347,
0.0212557595,
0.0461070314,
0.0516999178,
0.0149136167,
-0.0059963204,
-0.0388187729,
0.0529124215,
-0.0472624861,
-0.009638398,
0.0612278916,
-0.0029144748,
0.0578145497,
0.0000018398,
-0.0444676243,
-0.0576683357,
0.0011339725,
0.0270484947,
0.0443780497,
0.0438211523,
0.0453200266,
-0.0212888699,
0.0349359922,
-0.0360663831,
0.0090610823,
0.0369507335,
0.0124600716,
0.0759770647,
0.0882192329,
0.0067047304,
-0.0349950343,
0.0180441048,
-0.0720859766,
0.0382145084,
-0.0525690205,
-0.0057081594,
0.0373079292,
0.0274351183,
0.0186462868,
0.0037531776,
0.0091148848,
0.0185976848,
-0.0061344351,
0.0208482239,
0.0235923417,
-0.0325780883,
-0.0019066305,
-0.0112826834,
0.0422932953,
-0.0543770678,
-0.0112643829,
0.0331980586,
-0.0072316774,
0.0160791557,
-0.0200754795,
-0.0575100407,
0.0428832769,
0.0078213541,
0.0342741162,
0.0403155535,
0.0325190127,
0.0305329133,
0.0145273004,
-0.0269369856,
0.0382154025,
0.0345898941,
-0.012190897,
-0.0497833602,
0.0146513795,
-0.0457917266,
-0.0568873286,
0.0013677813,
0.0297282636,
-0.0332587808,
0.0206786692,
-0.0581574179,
-0.0285051558,
0.0047632656,
-0.0323560312,
0.0622841381,
0.0179832093,
0.0482426435,
-0.0036245226,
-0.0464838147,
0.0634543598,
0.009614707,
-0.0083975894,
-0.0416888446,
0.0468661897,
-0.0429938883,
0.0017872083,
0.0023953603,
0.0384257138,
-0.0214197002,
-0.0260816719,
-0.0892935023,
0.0088135647,
0.0205731113,
0.0189210549,
0.0289972853,
-0.0073373518,
-0.0378800035,
-0.0010277635,
-0.0183127988,
-0.0140130846,
0.0313267075,
-0.0191822834,
0.037037883,
-0.0235807914,
-0.0065359375,
0.0007099683,
0.0025791493,
-0.0121804122,
0.0061934148,
0.0819688141,
-0.0231214277,
-0.0630910918,
-0.0089044403,
-0.0197595209,
-0.0310836025,
-0.051200863,
-0.0135973841,
-0.0824196339,
-0.0303414036,
-0.0187981464,
-0.0236599911,
-0.0126981344,
0.030195903,
0.000685146,
-0.0231857877,
0.0313886702,
0.0580495149,
-0.0097788312,
0.0048493007,
0.0200341996,
0.0189826582,
0.0182042029,
0.0696528852,
0.0871241242,
0.0190899335,
0.0003027713,
0.004806729,
0.042499274,
0.021493718,
0.0150725115,
-0.0132015077,
-0.0141094057,
0.0058795707,
0.0272072125,
0.0104715256,
0.0691686124,
-0.0345010757,
0.0243512932,
0.0586853996,
0.0015491731,
0.0442863777,
0.0195523873,
0.056657698,
-0.0094339242,
-0.0114954785,
0.0456735715,
0.0161326956,
0.0421408042,
-0.0152722104,
0.0535255261,
0.0979298428,
0.0180753134,
0.0012419864,
-0.0697758645,
-0.0079262629,
-0.0116982721,
-0.006604664,
-0.0325860307,
0.0230787843,
0.0198871475,
-0.0873878598,
0.013170667,
-0.0036178615,
-0.0866046697,
0.0024785674,
-0.052789554,
0.023738306,
0.078191027,
0.0742575452,
-0.0107099749,
-0.0301028695,
0.0014166511,
-0.0604649074,
0.0378701724,
0.0128032779,
-0.0107785063,
-0.0174344815,
-0.0519073159,
-0.0349273048,
-0.0036546097,
0.0173294377,
0.0382812843,
0.0049756081,
-0.0047391625,
0.0538113639,
-0.0261373688,
-0.097841531,
0.0121610835,
-0.0419391282,
-0.0348981917,
0.0463866964,
-0.004623434,
0.0579331182,
0.0024409047,
-0.0192308668,
0.0673558637,
0.0082024215,
-0.0458265468,
-0.0258022659,
0.0000601015,
-0.0618740395,
-0.0598519444,
0.0275734682,
-0.0466527343,
0.0324860215,
0.0072761709,
-0.0375520177,
-0.0631742775,
0.0179909896,
-0.0735277906,
0.0054596597,
-0.0360353291,
0.0491506159,
0.02032529,
0.0131097585,
-0.0570423342,
0.0485853627,
-0.0450341552,
0.0499077737,
0.0335759595,
-0.0011448996,
-0.0329587981,
-0.0400604345,
-0.0109612616,
0.0071758633,
0.0186863374,
0.0110088643,
0.0385477319,
0.0632030666,
-0.0231573451,
-0.0634600967,
-0.048529882,
0.0201831646,
-0.0120594325,
0.0468065739,
0.02806063,
0.0232360363,
0.0200095139,
0.0156822708,
-0.0586242974,
-0.0222513583,
0.0322077759,
-0.0029679898,
0.0507034659,
-0.0078553371,
-0.0389321893,
-0.0368805639,
-0.0236249361,
0.0283400044,
0.0478905924,
-0.0111364061,
0.0260031559,
-0.0536593534,
0.0328221656,
-0.0389483273,
-0.0239181668,
0.0037705335,
-0.028965503,
0.0060225856,
-0.0120861996,
0.0672908351,
0.0156338383,
0.0435474217,
0.0491008349,
0.0209948085,
-0.004887071,
-0.0182985086,
-0.0344369859,
-0.0294167921,
-0.0098215388,
0.0292882584,
-0.0596562251,
0.0273163803,
0.0891470537,
-0.0107893776,
-0.0143316751,
-0.0651888102,
0.0189342946,
-0.0014053977,
-0.0276457295,
-0.0085870065,
0.0107540283,
-0.0241241753,
0.0248284936,
-0.0110992193,
-0.0732848942,
0.0588755943,
-0.0715674683,
0.0217795055,
-0.0628884658,
0.0035911195,
-0.0593164377,
0.0377387367,
0.0391826779,
0.0317104198,
-0.0147118121,
-0.0334663726,
-0.0464514904,
0.0229684897,
0.0267078709,
-0.0636476353,
0.0411066189,
-0.0520231538,
-0.0024618045,
-0.0146588152,
0.0151742268,
-0.0273538567,
0.0236783531,
0.0205741022,
0.0228575394,
0.042803809,
-0.0174136218,
-0.0211014803,
0.0302797202,
0.0403287821,
0.0477637015,
-0.0217883978,
0.0038067489,
0.0000605148,
0.0611999966,
0.0438450649,
-0.0204685107,
0.0180129819,
-0.0167160146,
0.0155901965,
0.0078249015,
0.0296071712,
0.0155085782,
-0.0070219734,
0.0180410929,
0.0324508138,
-0.0491597168,
-0.0238468833,
0.0536863096,
-0.0029767174,
-0.0346535221,
-0.0326653756,
0.1243327931,
0.0470095016,
-0.0128779057,
0.0276751183,
0.0231326446,
0.0541546345,
-0.0085989526,
0.0125269033,
-0.07125251,
0.0024782473,
-0.0087306835,
0.0249579456,
-0.0311886556,
-0.0458764471,
-0.0236915126,
-0.1341216117,
0.0279889069,
0.0222959314,
-0.0525929667,
-0.0096059414,
-0.0091660973,
-0.0009393288,
-0.0097705759,
-0.00135547,
0.0432744324,
-0.0156904384,
0.0434237234,
0.0347478837,
-0.0111134583,
-0.0539336354,
-0.0138233397,
-0.0011341808,
0.0337145478,
0.0824464932,
0.0206284206,
0.0125812804,
-0.0524356104,
-0.0147464424,
0.0070721381,
-0.0156260096,
-0.0144507578,
-0.0091922767,
0.0061647501,
-0.0138916243,
0.0091502871,
0.0430260599,
0.0328886174,
0.0056700497,
-0.0030103805,
0.0340421423,
-0.0039661098,
-0.0271610823,
-0.0064711338,
-0.0051906006,
0.0136584379,
0.0447020717,
0.0474334061,
-0.0460981354,
-0.0304924157,
-0.0238455441,
-0.0100355679,
-0.0942196846,
-0.029510092,
-0.0252616815,
-0.0288595166,
-0.0386663601,
-0.1340818405,
-0.0122391954,
-0.0138103832,
0.0455035567,
-0.0188994706,
0.0034547539,
-0.0044933539,
-0.0164866429,
-0.0622149594,
-0.0325597972,
-0.0054900674,
0.0095293568,
-0.0769174695,
0.0042318306,
0.0195368119,
-0.0485004634,
-0.0413564704,
0.0089454809,
-0.0691504478,
-0.0780792907,
-0.0315001979,
0.0852609575,
0.0208506733,
-0.0068471185,
0.013394773,
-0.0201909058,
0.0520676412,
0.0478440821,
0.0063745598,
-0.0025248437,
0.0424021147,
0.0280666444,
-0.0281638708,
0.025146896,
-0.0145538785,
0.0110601205,
0.0084816273,
0.1012151167,
0.0333017036,
-0.042119246,
0.0155042624,
0.0372447558,
0.0099347522,
-0.0678180456,
-0.0195169486,
0.0010395275,
0.0085383141,
-0.0205244739,
-0.0171414185,
-0.0535087064,
0.0261622127,
0.0194652155,
0.0334854573,
-0.011917552,
-0.0085653793,
-0.0159132387,
0.0190204661,
-0.0114310263,
0.0168124773,
-0.0236723162,
0.0094915824,
0.0175096728,
-0.0222377647,
-0.0133966422,
-0.018456297,
-0.0110299038,
0.0179779455,
-0.0151016582,
0.0284349173,
0.0204594731,
0.0460186936,
0.0038973601,
0.0698597506,
-0.0563304797,
0.0147977741,
-0.0584271587,
0.0542800687,
0.0649967194,
0.0216744803,
0.0786080062,
-0.0168392491,
-0.0032973774,
-0.0144644547,
0.0589736663,
-0.0132215172,
-0.0209852569,
-0.0125962477,
0.0148722148,
-0.0056851376,
-0.004160638,
0.1044454649,
0.0084263124,
0.005289522,
-0.0090003107,
-0.0188223179,
-0.0485438704,
-0.0460343435,
0.002931084,
-0.0343108438,
-0.0038054024,
0.0055148592,
-0.0366687253,
-0.0338822193,
0.0147670219,
0.0364981107,
0.0284006819,
-0.0058999001,
0.0403935425,
0.0541651286,
-0.0298709497,
0.0443066321,
-0.0673904195,
-0.0053800396,
-0.0210512318,
-0.0583190098,
0.0064701824,
-5.680621266e-33,
-0.0318189897,
-0.0444209091,
0.009693848,
-0.0128889112,
-0.0353924632,
0.0115620848,
-0.0537472479,
0.010734153,
0.0661909878,
-0.0347421393,
-0.0155958077,
-0.0407394134,
0.001433157,
0.0518751107,
0.0154919438,
0.0291608851,
0.0328641795,
0.0206195023,
-0.0583887883,
0.0259000733,
0.0052275113,
0.0036610721,
0.0585278682,
0.0108468467,
0.0132121872,
0.0036004391,
-0.0049634399,
-0.0183246005,
0.0132671762,
0.0380160995,
-0.0034075419,
-0.0111697614,
0.0153287472,
-0.0939161107,
-0.0290216375,
-0.0017046308,
-0.021952562,
-0.006310889,
0.0309937056,
-0.0428155139,
-0.0296805445,
-0.0708351135,
0.0260748044,
-0.0249523055,
-0.0324396305,
-0.0007460968,
0.0112066381,
-0.0486080572,
-0.0492436774,
-0.0316190049,
-0.0328495428,
0.040346738,
-0.0016969809,
-0.0116186524,
0.0079741543,
0.0278596822,
-0.0330346301,
0.0153484531,
0.01049776,
0.0448084362,
0.0389660187,
0.0943816528,
0.0662171096,
0.0268143397,
0.005531711,
0.017837869,
-0.0346473381,
-0.0214172062,
-0.011942219,
0.0238457117,
-0.0010487916,
0.0463162176,
0.0331708938,
0.0185059197,
-0.0010851441,
0.0220960341,
-0.0308152046,
0.0741160065,
0.0090413913,
0.0175361559,
0.0293236319,
0.0139609957,
0.0017575142,
-0.004870024,
-0.0421690829,
-0.0366969295,
-0.0117422892,
-0.0312709697,
0.0150672896,
0.0263441652,
-0.039806813,
-0.0295450334,
0.0435374901,
-0.012327441,
-0.0365732126,
0.0191426948,
-0.0300242454,
0.0265034027,
-0.0229457971,
0.006649835,
-0.0512121208,
0.002566057,
0.0364676155,
0.0288822725,
-0.0111157121,
-0.0254264157,
0.0216815602,
0.0273112413,
-0.0473117866,
0.0143018831,
-0.0314564817,
0.0306911133,
-0.0172530506,
0.0260146335,
0.0129258605,
-0.0454774573,
-0.0202738699,
0.0286717564,
-0.0151563818,
-0.0112750689,
0.0003066958,
0.005599713,
0.0198194925,
0.0296486281,
-0.0316384919,
0.0518506356,
-0.032725729,
0.0535659306,
0.0171841644,
-0.013922275,
-0.0419622399,
0.0028031205,
2.617e-7,
0.0073183682,
0.0304132737,
0.0205340609,
0.0241106115,
-0.000548068,
0.0312005449,
-0.0154393436,
0.0401294492,
-0.0099657495,
0.0231210291,
0.0571214594,
-0.0280176494,
0.0525944792,
-0.014020416,
-0.0407725275,
-0.0208466835,
-0.1175729409,
0.0101881288,
-0.0210988633,
-0.0647915378,
0.0247599576,
0.0569676384,
-0.0241296161,
-0.0150251435,
0.0048206304,
-0.0030753275,
0.0513333902,
-0.0141282324,
-0.0200807005,
-0.007778699,
0.0511903651,
0.0114503372,
-0.0118632484,
-0.0562996008,
-0.0289194211,
0.0190680567,
0.0517615527,
0.0616137646,
0.039464891,
0.009393069,
0.028637277,
-0.0013332715,
0.0217798855,
-0.0460875481,
0.030821735,
-0.0225089435,
-0.0316384584,
-0.027699599,
-0.0407611988,
-0.0059888703,
-0.0043705646,
-0.0435115099,
-0.0258104187,
0.0430980213,
0.0079539884,
0.0122811561,
0.01967551,
-0.0243668556,
-0.0288011804,
-0.0018288128,
-0.0157611184,
-0.0347149372,
-0.0579673313,
0.0336177051,
-0.0263121445,
-0.059199743,
-0.0411614068,
2.557005796e-34,
0.04771946,
-0.0485194847,
-0.0006587644,
-0.0106165884,
0.0215819683,
0.0080776596,
-0.021855535,
0.0243790988,
0.0136133842,
-0.0677182153,
-0.0503280088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04346v1 | Unmasking Nationality Bias: A Study of Human Perception of Nationalities in AI-Generated Articles | 2023-08-08T15:46:27 | 2023-08-08T15:46:27 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Sanjana Gautam, Ruchi Panchanadikar, Ting-Hao `Kenneth' Huang, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | We investigate the potential for nationality biases in natural language
processing (NLP) models using human evaluation methods. Biased NLP models can
perpetuate stereotypes and lead to algorithmic discrimination, posing a
significant challenge to the fairness and justice of AI systems. Our study
employs a two-step mixed-methods approach that includes both quantitative and
qualitative analysis to identify and understand the impact of nationality bias
in a text generation model. Through our human-centered quantitative analysis,
we measure the extent of nationality bias in articles generated by AI sources.
We then conduct open-ended interviews with participants, performing qualitative
coding and thematic analysis to understand the implications of these biases on
human readers. Our findings reveal that biased NLP models tend to replicate and
amplify existing societal biases, which can translate to harm if used in a
sociotechnical setting. The qualitative analysis from our interviews offers
insights into the experience readers have when encountering such articles,
highlighting the potential to shift a reader's perception of a country. These
findings emphasize the critical role of public perception in shaping AI's
impact on society and the need to correct biases in AI systems. | [
0.0581557043,
0.1030511558,
-0.0382765755,
-0.0119479876,
-0.0219239835,
0.0376129262,
0.0620786585,
-0.0390509181,
0.040965613,
-0.0555597059,
0.0022389479,
0.0000995578,
0.047417663,
0.0074134944,
-0.0056526032,
-0.0046489681,
-0.0054125856,
0.0416550413,
0.0599099733,
-0.0109467786,
0.0334434621,
0.0499064811,
0.0301338639,
0.0654973015,
-0.0189001951,
-0.0122964252,
0.0594111755,
-0.0145356022,
0.0118914964,
-0.0345416293,
0.0226399079,
0.0490104631,
-0.0202502031,
0.0179943554,
0.0000018288,
-0.0450644158,
0.0159219,
0.0169689562,
0.0390543826,
0.0058145416,
0.0484402776,
0.0058802916,
-0.0216054283,
0.0108546577,
-0.0419877879,
-0.0044234414,
0.0292812157,
0.0042563505,
0.033381708,
0.0432513803,
-0.0130776884,
-0.0177279897,
-0.0191751327,
0.0330820903,
-0.0364223905,
0.0093895653,
0.0255542696,
-0.0324503593,
-0.0432750545,
-0.011720622,
0.0116636734,
0.0114172492,
-0.0014547235,
0.0109968651,
0.0058062617,
0.0101234159,
-0.0508931577,
-0.0505796671,
0.0294945166,
0.0356483199,
0.0710430592,
-0.0108578242,
0.0042085922,
-0.008964058,
-0.0000608169,
0.0035359198,
0.0177208986,
0.0722735599,
-0.0284171198,
0.0067468886,
0.0209621359,
0.004432322,
-0.0125304796,
0.0569325499,
0.0000204749,
0.0723004341,
-0.0248026252,
-0.0265796315,
-0.0101747513,
0.0334092863,
0.0634769872,
-0.0477146395,
0.0364564918,
0.0134576894,
-0.0025040607,
0.0125815291,
-0.0102114975,
-0.0096667996,
0.0166964047,
-0.0880062059,
-0.0155474814,
0.0184998251,
-0.0278181471,
-0.0213134028,
0.0176603105,
0.0229729321,
0.0193341766,
-0.0084208483,
-0.0189020019,
0.0044305427,
-0.0067075691,
-0.0018178179,
0.0180706624,
-0.0112840887,
0.0145144723,
0.0352850296,
-0.0311762672,
-0.0087880827,
-0.0568712652,
0.0448947735,
-0.0290237665,
0.0150431348,
-0.0369985662,
0.005466471,
-0.0407612659,
0.0312869698,
-0.0599586032,
0.0055678538,
-0.0409473069,
-0.0699385777,
0.0354793258,
0.0074888952,
-0.0195272043,
-0.0114846276,
-0.0058048149,
0.033941742,
0.0224066414,
-0.0108510135,
-0.0372063741,
-0.040548455,
0.0110843871,
-0.0369772948,
-0.0209102463,
-0.0440833718,
-0.0101240966,
0.0225407835,
-0.003332254,
-0.0896175131,
0.0151584512,
0.047868032,
-0.0525170788,
0.0230027754,
0.0020704737,
0.013609603,
0.0435790904,
0.0096555008,
-0.0071467976,
0.0587691516,
0.0281642489,
0.0555775575,
0.047473602,
0.0210999791,
0.0430442691,
0.0035441373,
-0.0264703427,
0.0012577065,
-0.0214453042,
0.0043796473,
-0.0886842012,
0.0020760696,
0.0394105017,
0.0393434875,
0.0052117077,
0.0287995096,
0.0532399155,
0.0562277921,
-0.0471481122,
0.0422493257,
0.0335493796,
0.0084174508,
-0.0298025329,
0.0364846364,
-0.0518576056,
-0.0252802521,
-0.0074960715,
-0.0208384953,
-0.0060144807,
0.089591153,
-0.0093556102,
-0.0426617973,
0.0013212435,
0.0244246069,
0.085021995,
0.0046800622,
0.0009814422,
0.0041505755,
0.0091917738,
-0.0167057496,
0.0060124728,
-0.028014088,
0.0100270612,
-0.0520875081,
-0.0074257096,
0.0535650812,
0.0052662049,
0.0092102205,
0.0377361923,
-0.0179287214,
-0.0293354224,
0.0639882907,
0.0264397673,
-0.0119849872,
-0.0491185524,
0.0086578522,
-0.0100761708,
0.0116481464,
0.0078083714,
0.0275666658,
0.0237761084,
0.0608636104,
0.0275337193,
-0.0118546654,
-0.0710058734,
0.0170107838,
-0.0182016417,
-0.0298884474,
-0.032312341,
0.0250945892,
-0.0066956305,
0.0317214094,
-0.0513116792,
0.0139516741,
-0.0171582848,
0.0029733013,
-0.0057419306,
0.0480858721,
-0.0000910785,
0.0347432345,
-0.0157687124,
-0.1041892469,
-0.0354323201,
0.0342044793,
0.0115767019,
0.014507995,
0.0293228664,
0.0131172221,
-0.0267291311,
-0.0076013179,
-0.0167885628,
-0.0505891517,
0.0215728208,
-0.0305420049,
0.0208382029,
-0.0289652161,
-0.0080467537,
0.00870068,
-0.0666466802,
0.0301565137,
0.0064170607,
-0.0418958664,
0.0614147596,
0.0001316598,
0.0078695985,
0.0764647201,
-0.0073389057,
-0.01977784,
0.01866352,
-0.0814622566,
-0.0064629936,
-0.0088796765,
-0.0157798305,
0.0231935605,
0.0009898335,
-0.0343353823,
0.0116938073,
-0.0612010583,
-0.0679916963,
-0.0102267331,
0.0436510816,
-0.0076178983,
-0.0220395941,
0.0313345194,
0.0035771132,
0.0080057215,
-0.033709392,
0.037265081,
0.0582868569,
-0.0077721896,
-0.0586794652,
-0.0064027277,
-0.043597497,
-0.0090285819,
-0.0094673969,
-0.0173300449,
0.0069355331,
0.058647044,
-0.0289239828,
0.045724079,
0.0218662042,
0.0275142603,
0.0499823913,
0.0150495088,
0.0116087068,
-0.0409031473,
0.0222375281,
0.0557862893,
0.0178784598,
-0.1130920053,
0.0141575234,
0.0257826336,
0.0362399705,
0.0026199268,
-0.0184633248,
0.0965560377,
-0.1011382267,
-0.0580052696,
-0.0072856285,
-0.0565827973,
0.0076868888,
0.0833915249,
-0.0076804389,
-0.0427777804,
0.0454703495,
0.012049702,
0.0769332871,
-0.0595137551,
0.0007089708,
-0.0155804195,
0.0115127182,
0.0029929017,
0.0614572242,
0.0198383611,
-0.0020475246,
-0.0403983705,
-0.0332773812,
0.0374072157,
-0.0110710943,
-0.0184420925,
-0.0293150172,
-0.0179568138,
-0.0059380461,
-0.0318286344,
-0.0398095474,
-0.0439365432,
-0.025414275,
-0.0005849632,
0.0710687265,
-0.0276916176,
0.0070252437,
0.0112460218,
0.077580139,
0.004118403,
-0.0245804209,
0.0066989996,
0.0172268562,
0.0133315176,
0.0267837327,
-0.0411168337,
0.0899994522,
0.0208388548,
0.0014833458,
-0.004931794,
0.0125961918,
0.0375491567,
0.0389707424,
-0.0019989312,
0.0187307298,
-0.0291444138,
-0.0400463119,
0.0023207315,
0.0436059907,
-0.0154348649,
-0.0009996663,
0.0689917058,
0.00789678,
-0.0519508496,
0.0088425521,
0.0058707637,
-0.0418993533,
0.0251808316,
0.0365220159,
-0.0786597058,
0.0562278032,
0.0229142234,
0.0069447458,
-0.1100116,
-0.030590849,
-0.0428174026,
-0.099503167,
0.0250561032,
0.0005650267,
-0.0211452879,
-0.0159982741,
-0.0146315247,
-0.0339854881,
0.0081782704,
0.0294191018,
-0.0133288819,
0.0132045504,
0.0276184324,
-0.0162323639,
-0.0679222941,
-0.0206003767,
0.0022004377,
-0.0185972638,
0.036613632,
0.0393035822,
0.0790522322,
-0.0178229399,
-0.0233726595,
-0.0085634934,
-0.009873624,
-0.0093384329,
-0.0254389942,
0.0118545322,
-0.0183800273,
-0.008246148,
-0.0352548584,
0.0043581054,
0.0222261157,
0.0024476298,
0.020545641,
0.0046587521,
0.0112025402,
-0.0306564886,
-0.0260664448,
-0.0207390673,
0.0086358292,
0.0385942608,
0.0062914388,
-0.0528953671,
-0.0191783216,
-0.0429682434,
0.0248698257,
-0.0498765856,
-0.0625857785,
0.05589021,
-0.0155795543,
-0.0794032216,
-0.062037915,
-0.109662801,
-0.0322971605,
-0.0189149361,
0.0476305038,
-0.0342182368,
0.0591357164,
-0.0251833368,
-0.0195482969,
0.0101169953,
-0.0207728241,
0.0146827707,
0.0458649322,
-0.0094563654,
-0.0123752905,
-0.0178112276,
0.0021567526,
0.0192535371,
0.0179096796,
-0.024327971,
0.0531104356,
0.0082885679,
0.0155507848,
0.0355868377,
0.0046548233,
-0.0470123328,
0.0430185832,
0.0116315782,
-0.0101705994,
0.0097400341,
-0.0031835088,
0.0239466019,
0.00073394,
0.0021413388,
-0.0037844724,
0.020853648,
0.0049000052,
-0.0456594452,
-0.0373302922,
0.0062453938,
0.0378006063,
0.0155968787,
0.0214896668,
-0.0624102056,
0.0328083299,
-0.0400860086,
-0.0704029575,
-0.038491182,
-0.0321757682,
-0.0097578401,
-0.0411785208,
0.0051952321,
0.0351358391,
-0.0283210482,
0.0244612321,
-0.0615805164,
0.0080433488,
-0.0372870229,
0.0566860847,
0.0340692587,
0.0814931095,
-0.014930605,
-0.01019138,
-0.0128914453,
0.0418202542,
-0.0304064993,
0.0476697348,
0.0149663743,
0.0287320558,
0.00992491,
0.0065926923,
0.0148639027,
0.0186277162,
-0.0467137806,
-0.0266617984,
-0.0160382874,
-0.0134017412,
0.0329200402,
-0.0432394557,
0.0135296555,
0.0423032865,
0.0123763364,
0.042095881,
-0.0062978263,
0.0252169371,
-0.0369729325,
-0.0264941119,
-0.0120346881,
-0.0520264655,
0.0176516715,
0.0620218143,
-0.013605088,
0.0199833233,
0.0095013855,
-0.0717808902,
0.0049456479,
-0.0390813984,
0.0257491451,
-0.0163040869,
-0.0046141199,
-0.026500782,
-0.0865170062,
-0.0533508994,
-0.0287308246,
-0.0046342653,
0.0422753766,
-0.0440969393,
-0.0150943464,
0.066322498,
-0.0129327849,
-0.0322844312,
-0.0711447224,
-0.0040686461,
-0.084726423,
-0.0169519689,
0.0140647627,
-6.04354229e-33,
0.0036153346,
-0.0622450486,
0.0033593145,
-0.0168129429,
-0.0151380179,
-0.0040729935,
-0.0233781543,
0.0195162445,
-0.0371179096,
0.0361218639,
-0.0199457947,
-0.0157621168,
0.0072640083,
-0.0300712194,
0.0124370391,
0.0220055673,
0.0346308537,
0.0161706526,
-0.0214286633,
0.0161797497,
0.0020058898,
-0.0114058172,
0.0306532662,
-0.07444188,
0.096500501,
-0.0103395553,
-0.0512497388,
-0.0295972116,
0.0439145006,
-0.0072452282,
-0.0085029798,
0.0528970994,
0.0478764959,
-0.0477374718,
-0.0033872481,
0.0562261268,
-0.011564699,
-0.0041825743,
0.0281109381,
0.0598802753,
0.0514285043,
-0.0434433483,
0.041040279,
-0.0291904118,
-0.0605263785,
0.0529178977,
0.0664268509,
-0.0122730955,
0.0376379453,
-0.0340057276,
-0.0662862659,
0.0098918034,
-0.0377870798,
0.0675999746,
-0.0331594273,
0.0812160149,
-0.0033126851,
0.022348756,
-0.063537769,
-0.0077842134,
0.0169617347,
-0.0039976658,
0.0577459782,
-0.0067238882,
0.0029035953,
0.0381332822,
0.0602978505,
0.0409845971,
-0.0672113374,
-0.0166762434,
0.0338991135,
-0.0391367711,
0.0031331806,
0.0985828564,
0.0137023833,
-0.0685812831,
-0.0268345475,
0.018617548,
0.0196638256,
0.0239267275,
0.034296494,
-0.0463060029,
-0.0684904754,
-0.0329228714,
-0.0239574164,
-0.0809329376,
-0.0332140438,
-0.0379529074,
0.0280849226,
-0.0289912988,
-0.0268449243,
0.0058444203,
0.0124316039,
-0.0722259581,
-0.0041462071,
0.0329337902,
-0.0375819728,
-0.0396688022,
0.0132933296,
0.0083876494,
-0.0352744646,
0.0053791991,
-0.0255715102,
0.0539741591,
0.0512879044,
0.017693175,
0.0035507283,
-0.0139548164,
-0.0467018411,
-0.015119073,
-0.0182713531,
0.0248833541,
0.0310933534,
0.0172755588,
0.0103722606,
0.0202460755,
-0.0245191548,
-0.034214437,
0.0623144284,
0.0245979298,
-0.0242357142,
-0.017634159,
-0.0348740667,
0.0434251204,
-0.0542428158,
-0.0299475584,
-0.0157182291,
0.0605324209,
0.0514260828,
-0.0327679627,
-0.0276420824,
-0.0480102152,
2.571e-7,
-0.0047066477,
0.0731285885,
-0.0373999551,
0.0122195696,
0.0063156383,
0.031472642,
0.0305283498,
0.0334596634,
0.005820856,
-0.0030064113,
0.015864443,
0.0006808902,
0.0052758683,
0.0680327117,
-0.0851162672,
0.0398398452,
-0.0528720282,
0.0555745699,
-0.0381024294,
0.0367545336,
0.0348605663,
0.0165370852,
-0.0033025267,
-0.0193808023,
-0.0472703204,
-0.0178556256,
-0.0047708531,
-0.0130626718,
0.0040341928,
-0.0016517759,
0.0206024796,
0.0390929133,
0.0231969394,
0.0023230372,
0.005435132,
0.0089533729,
0.0267978832,
0.0210083649,
0.0048128157,
0.0421752073,
0.0189711638,
-0.0031770128,
0.0094034504,
-0.0869095623,
0.0550190471,
0.0171668157,
-0.0525577292,
-0.0787378773,
-0.0199166108,
-0.0505641364,
0.0599537194,
-0.0085739689,
-0.0327144414,
0.0243490674,
0.0185413845,
0.0099702189,
0.0314075053,
-0.017658826,
-0.018528726,
-0.0282088406,
0.0146334385,
-0.0183995347,
-0.0022360927,
0.0275483821,
-0.0233323332,
-0.0052966136,
0.043532297,
2.04651041e-34,
0.0167270564,
-0.0260967463,
-0.0110786064,
-0.0043829,
0.0675422549,
0.0350877196,
-0.0374812223,
-0.0218781065,
0.0122115081,
0.0070047928,
0.0025412661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04333v1 | Towards an AI to Win Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz | 2023-08-08T15:26:58 | 2023-08-08T15:26:58 | George Boateng, Jonathan Abrefah Mensah, Kevin Takyi Yeboah, William Edor, Andrew Kojo Mensah-Onumah, Naafi Dasana Ibrahim, Nana Sam Yeboah | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SD, eess.AS | Can an AI win Ghana's National Science and Maths Quiz (NSMQ)? That is the
question we seek to answer in the NSMQ AI project, an open-source project that
is building AI to compete live in the NSMQ and win. The NSMQ is an annual live
science and mathematics competition for senior secondary school students in
Ghana in which 3 teams of 2 students compete by answering questions across
biology, chemistry, physics, and math in 5 rounds over 5 progressive stages
until a winning team is crowned for that year. The NSMQ is an exciting live
quiz competition with interesting technical challenges across speech-to-text,
text-to-speech, question-answering, and human-computer interaction. In this
ongoing work that began in January 2023, we give an overview of the project,
describe each of the teams, progress made thus far, and the next steps toward
our planned launch and debut of the AI in October for NSMQ 2023. An AI that
conquers this grand challenge can have real-world impact on education such as
enabling millions of students across Africa to have one-on-one learning support
from this AI. | [
0.0328833312,
0.0755696967,
-0.0432615131,
0.0171374697,
-0.0198669434,
-0.0057419729,
-0.0025275375,
-0.0222320966,
0.0053862855,
0.0039427751,
-0.0028849656,
-0.0607418455,
0.0060388343,
0.045413956,
0.0342336074,
-0.0596728139,
0.0136658559,
-0.0637612939,
0.0050153979,
-0.0099952072,
-0.0343807451,
0.0126801291,
-0.0676559061,
0.0028263561,
0.0017593605,
-0.0157515295,
-0.0435027629,
-0.0537817851,
0.0064491485,
-0.0641463995,
-0.0234406069,
0.0407317355,
-0.0296693351,
0.0333374478,
0.0000021219,
-0.0878945515,
-0.0042447993,
0.0002312655,
-0.0676179826,
0.0091629196,
0.0045384914,
0.0863444507,
-0.0265040994,
0.0296606738,
-0.0994431749,
0.0572570711,
0.061019998,
-0.0722904727,
0.0672997832,
0.0572225153,
0.0148227187,
-0.0044372478,
0.0447055362,
-0.006635068,
0.0356543176,
-0.0721192285,
-0.0002050327,
-0.0104739238,
0.047363881,
-0.0102713313,
-0.0232544132,
0.0489317887,
0.0144911995,
-0.0195577387,
-0.0140438573,
0.008373444,
-0.0450943485,
-0.0453501977,
-0.0221931599,
0.0439845622,
0.0515542738,
0.0262205265,
0.021522956,
0.0049940865,
0.0009298932,
0.0106502147,
-0.0893524289,
0.0199200511,
0.0063428986,
-0.0265894681,
-0.0081591718,
0.0107427295,
-0.0203113835,
0.0437589027,
-0.0137291346,
0.0912188292,
-0.0079781106,
-0.0098021813,
0.004038482,
0.0246518981,
0.0020530126,
-0.0392244458,
0.0339238718,
0.0480710827,
-0.0231164563,
0.0038665673,
0.0159591306,
-0.046098303,
0.0068891044,
-0.0447214507,
0.0490144119,
0.0256416015,
0.0335784145,
0.0552556999,
0.0349942669,
0.054878179,
0.0075541628,
0.0076767066,
-0.0366709232,
0.0081675341,
-0.0350244083,
-0.012967919,
0.0060182679,
0.051013995,
-0.0257620439,
0.0311744679,
-0.0356550477,
-0.0191915575,
-0.0106368493,
0.02730437,
0.003620663,
0.0411123931,
-0.0008829647,
-0.0289232414,
-0.0133426655,
0.0184386279,
-0.0410054438,
0.0065386719,
0.0045464523,
-0.0516175665,
0.0307597667,
0.0037860791,
-0.0109710516,
0.0111981323,
0.0510444418,
0.077816993,
-0.0049546519,
-0.0013003341,
0.0003053048,
-0.0481488071,
0.034671288,
-0.0500396676,
0.0221927445,
-0.0378565155,
0.0327256434,
0.0000389148,
0.0075594019,
-0.0105657075,
0.0188878737,
-0.0045642057,
0.0586914979,
0.0602300502,
0.0185358971,
-0.0241371524,
0.0798462108,
0.0225546509,
0.0107566295,
0.0140902903,
0.0390180685,
-0.0114644375,
0.0213046372,
-0.02324453,
-0.0100695994,
0.0301924646,
0.0218236875,
-0.018157497,
0.0383487418,
0.0119139552,
0.0040324191,
0.07343705,
-0.0630556494,
0.0296751745,
0.0392733552,
0.0048252731,
0.0336297192,
0.1043990254,
-0.0053705154,
0.0131568527,
-0.0211888682,
-0.0266057532,
0.0768430755,
-0.0301186536,
-0.0480488949,
0.0682724342,
-0.0306606479,
0.0018485648,
0.0206524041,
0.0746604726,
-0.0100383013,
-0.0759777054,
-0.0122582894,
0.0161344465,
-0.0203527827,
0.0503873341,
0.0375887528,
-0.0466515981,
0.0110721346,
-0.0498874225,
-0.0270371102,
-0.0432007723,
0.0192665309,
-0.0568759292,
0.0586968921,
-0.0081519522,
0.0430835709,
-0.0277376026,
-0.0580299497,
-0.000010362,
-0.0099288281,
0.0534669086,
0.0064015798,
-0.0303572938,
-0.0056064068,
-0.0139030404,
-0.0257701911,
0.0074078925,
-0.0178057458,
-0.0141214645,
0.0329307765,
0.0679387376,
-0.0108173881,
0.0173124596,
0.0376389585,
0.0199488513,
-0.063070856,
-0.0475907512,
-0.0079977093,
0.0209053028,
0.0412505083,
0.0380716212,
0.0143123381,
0.0308653489,
0.0025640051,
-0.0096257208,
-0.0137889218,
-0.0312954001,
-0.0172527898,
-0.0247551296,
0.0497869141,
-0.0736430734,
0.0025549061,
0.075001359,
-0.0019165175,
-0.0138167506,
0.0307550412,
-0.0233856328,
-0.0315423384,
-0.000369299,
0.0118190246,
0.0031271465,
-0.0379060842,
0.0018201461,
0.0065050889,
0.0302724969,
0.0137673691,
0.0137875006,
-0.0048987702,
0.045483917,
-0.0479756631,
-0.0004454967,
0.0146695338,
-0.0251682382,
-0.0052457107,
-0.0166200045,
-0.0167317297,
-0.0622522645,
0.0000523672,
-0.0436230823,
-0.0044075325,
0.0473469123,
0.0312467366,
0.0057012038,
-0.0052897353,
0.0107832318,
0.0008456227,
-0.0465654247,
-0.0127334185,
0.0273317304,
-0.0397140756,
0.0066708908,
-0.0112470742,
-0.0052429973,
-0.0393927991,
-0.0077265226,
-0.0488976762,
0.060210973,
0.0683513135,
0.0045137773,
-0.0241180379,
-0.0322747827,
-0.0621984601,
0.0140208043,
0.0404330976,
0.0092128115,
0.0333661027,
-0.0295974705,
-0.0318710022,
0.0876942873,
0.0254727937,
-0.0303477626,
0.0165455118,
-0.0205089785,
-0.0269996952,
0.0069075027,
0.0073496155,
0.0405381396,
0.0101190349,
-0.0216304213,
0.0169525538,
0.0627850965,
-0.0073072133,
-0.0001243378,
0.0268961154,
0.0918358639,
-0.0383618996,
-0.032765571,
-0.068855986,
0.0194369741,
-0.0286384132,
0.0102458922,
0.0028842767,
-0.0114450054,
0.10099224,
-0.0234541632,
-0.0044993958,
-0.0664689466,
0.0057573873,
-0.0121006547,
0.0558124669,
-0.0860511959,
0.0109442612,
0.0179306958,
-0.0119704297,
-0.0464523435,
-0.0328810737,
0.0171734877,
-0.0474987589,
-0.0408024266,
-0.0396376774,
-0.0099356053,
0.0006537425,
-0.0746849179,
-0.0129981078,
0.0347981974,
-0.0287071802,
0.019971421,
0.0225389414,
-0.0449574143,
-0.0199143551,
-0.0057124943,
0.0521512516,
0.0068204491,
-0.0138244992,
-0.0094950348,
0.0117382007,
0.0829640925,
0.032737121,
0.0474002175,
0.0114722624,
-0.0371962488,
0.0148635888,
0.0487611182,
0.0724012479,
0.0160172284,
0.0456407592,
0.0120527819,
0.0324778594,
-0.0208261497,
-0.0291498676,
0.0292992871,
0.0161862336,
-0.0492555611,
-0.0200054571,
0.078934595,
0.0274054762,
0.0052168174,
-0.0002367799,
-0.0407166705,
-0.073525168,
-0.0191481095,
0.050085064,
-0.1060884595,
-0.0038802545,
-0.0005898529,
0.0160239749,
-0.0067150225,
-0.0140892258,
-0.025315918,
-0.0691970214,
0.0352284126,
0.04051321,
-0.042317152,
-0.0184334256,
-0.0129861329,
-0.042227298,
-0.0134712737,
-0.0153296599,
0.0126956934,
0.0451979935,
0.0161369666,
0.0207890943,
-0.0188307129,
-0.0028870464,
0.0294212103,
-0.0282310285,
0.0414611101,
0.0732041597,
0.033250019,
-0.0002478905,
-0.0837319568,
-0.0275097899,
-0.0059860861,
-0.0022950468,
-0.015213374,
-0.0210180804,
0.0256397203,
-0.0228874721,
-0.0430750959,
0.0614046827,
-0.0341764204,
0.0199465845,
0.0465469211,
0.111697033,
-0.0315696895,
-0.0102754887,
-0.0440144613,
-0.0186344832,
0.0050196014,
0.0316381268,
0.0049982662,
-0.0502135865,
-0.0288517158,
-0.0337836035,
0.0240692887,
-0.0801823139,
-0.0493047722,
-0.0102458904,
0.0606823079,
0.0095370691,
-0.0413315147,
-0.0318733715,
0.077355139,
0.0244039353,
0.0117360316,
-0.0186841078,
0.0355511308,
0.0372860841,
-0.0158963464,
-0.0018905347,
-0.0336140729,
0.0529397801,
-0.0760866031,
-0.0134709496,
0.0300570335,
-0.0026242794,
-0.0256194342,
0.0059915162,
-0.0523778386,
-0.0464275703,
0.0247749761,
0.0665767938,
0.0197040364,
-0.0452041999,
0.023512153,
-0.0173724182,
0.0261106882,
0.0053540454,
-0.0003810548,
0.0457758158,
-0.0347799808,
0.0124618039,
-0.0157450959,
-0.0290945899,
0.0128628472,
0.0060784933,
-0.016764259,
0.045861531,
-0.0319624767,
-0.0154253729,
0.0142561356,
0.0401742049,
0.0594215728,
0.0249315184,
-0.0505373292,
-0.015580263,
0.0251234807,
0.0338753276,
-0.0184887275,
-0.0240749195,
-0.0517903268,
-0.002205187,
0.012463958,
0.0278977733,
-0.0084473882,
-0.0320502743,
-0.0222481601,
-0.0230727959,
0.0888478085,
0.0735029131,
0.0750007182,
0.0035003377,
-0.0050529339,
0.0135068418,
0.0453887358,
-0.0024712265,
0.0797686726,
0.0107431812,
0.0265115388,
-0.0041278712,
-0.0153099494,
0.0104117254,
0.0064410828,
-0.034194719,
-0.0194490682,
-0.0520330556,
0.0571147464,
0.0375155918,
0.0739533082,
-0.0560953729,
0.0015939251,
0.013309666,
0.0096280267,
-0.030252045,
-0.0196383893,
-0.0082980823,
0.017508354,
0.0216703285,
0.0371234789,
-0.0073505947,
0.0352913886,
0.0034144968,
0.0051190918,
0.0349582694,
0.0175852031,
-0.0260814186,
-0.0279943421,
-0.0103673236,
-0.0016274814,
-0.0264963154,
0.0342256501,
-0.0344703011,
-0.0288634077,
0.0072728139,
0.0159567799,
0.0063355467,
-0.0140907327,
0.046584487,
0.0054930765,
-0.0287466887,
-0.0495454632,
0.0082858847,
0.0454203673,
-0.0817023516,
-0.0579573438,
0.0256134588,
-6.511465081e-33,
-0.0179151352,
-0.0636601299,
0.0210218411,
0.0185923539,
-0.0162499286,
-0.023112908,
-0.0323709063,
0.0285827126,
-0.0399064347,
-0.0192978401,
-0.0466098562,
0.0156437438,
0.0175715275,
0.0266119484,
0.030039683,
0.02565022,
0.0246488918,
-0.0194498505,
-0.0417350344,
-0.0089254882,
0.0066164392,
0.0473971926,
0.0466128886,
-0.0327401571,
0.0514998138,
0.0004250608,
0.0039171227,
0.0004522342,
-0.0317033082,
0.0171927307,
0.009411809,
0.0094968611,
-0.0092103994,
-0.0582633726,
-0.0031385447,
0.0187367424,
-0.0370930955,
-0.0624634176,
-0.020433845,
0.0094938306,
-0.02379792,
-0.055463437,
0.0353520438,
-0.0006425147,
-0.0573605224,
-0.0340630971,
0.0261010006,
-0.0301918089,
0.0251019057,
-0.0096932147,
-0.0040266938,
0.0056226151,
-0.022451587,
-0.0001779148,
-0.013425542,
0.0211998131,
-0.0215833634,
-0.0628735274,
0.0163057037,
0.0817168802,
0.044260323,
0.0589596927,
0.0376934074,
0.0139934756,
-0.0342836007,
0.0157633759,
0.0318702906,
-0.0704802498,
-0.0140616233,
-0.0243010074,
-0.0061605307,
-0.0225214362,
0.1350784153,
0.0531303212,
0.0299804639,
0.0160097629,
-0.0619824082,
0.0685553774,
0.0586518683,
0.0044541014,
-0.0653263777,
-0.0181375388,
-0.0312539712,
0.0076677459,
-0.0363257751,
0.0194983333,
-0.0298053399,
-0.0255077239,
0.04677324,
-0.0781440511,
-0.0290641598,
0.0203882977,
0.0100219054,
-0.0182126798,
0.0094201006,
-0.0029139409,
0.0708104521,
0.0600828081,
-0.0157722495,
-0.009603139,
-0.0408433042,
-0.0118945353,
-0.0246822238,
0.0194645748,
0.0394795015,
0.0095072668,
-0.0700954124,
0.029914299,
-0.0181802809,
-0.0081465878,
0.002647795,
-0.0281645302,
0.0396744125,
-0.0237665176,
-0.013758949,
-0.0220247656,
0.0116819171,
-0.0010620833,
-0.0272258744,
0.0076161758,
-0.0154441679,
-0.0153025473,
-0.0243079495,
0.0175122432,
-0.0508864038,
-0.0261875764,
-0.0813593641,
-0.0118308701,
-0.0365314968,
-0.0285414234,
0.0014516015,
-0.0046864315,
2.897e-7,
-0.006616557,
0.04859275,
0.0205510966,
-0.013866174,
-0.039003443,
0.0076898574,
-0.0322912931,
-0.0203838684,
-0.0165737737,
0.0377296805,
0.0235717259,
-0.0103709735,
0.0263392832,
0.0461673029,
-0.1126119271,
-0.0394089855,
-0.0404976681,
0.0291568972,
-0.0634800792,
0.0214162488,
-0.0143557545,
0.0560204536,
0.0198157411,
-0.026018111,
-0.0235133488,
-0.0436470956,
0.0112350667,
0.0279989932,
0.0182151534,
0.0098036034,
-0.0442157425,
-0.0358301587,
0.0117107155,
0.0038411033,
-0.032828331,
-0.0270541329,
0.0336277448,
0.045004297,
0.0104945544,
0.0073869703,
-0.0069257431,
0.0453263558,
0.0139329508,
-0.0293438546,
0.050298579,
-0.0339262076,
-0.0335292444,
0.0074141631,
-0.0137351332,
-0.0410424285,
-0.0028827919,
-0.0112156561,
0.0087165674,
-0.0462374873,
0.0012482925,
-0.0138996318,
0.0270202328,
-0.0086572934,
-0.0106393732,
-0.0118318759,
-0.0028537961,
-0.0643487498,
-0.0483302586,
-0.005250636,
-0.0298297256,
-0.0341505818,
-0.00686209,
2.393832486e-34,
0.0062637157,
-0.0071141352,
0.0464563034,
0.0314953215,
0.0030117556,
0.0125450389,
0.031234948,
0.0037739587,
0.061001122,
-0.0504213683,
-0.0257119834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04306v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04306v4 | Deep Learning-Based Knowledge Injection for Metaphor Detection: A Comprehensive Review | 2023-08-08T14:51:16 | 2024-01-08T14:32:56 | Cheng Yang, Zheng Li, Zhiyue Liu, Qingbao Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Metaphor as an advanced cognitive modality works by extracting familiar
concepts in the target domain in order to understand vague and abstract
concepts in the source domain. This helps humans to quickly understand and
master new domains and thus adapt to changing environments. With the continuous
development of metaphor research in the natural language community, many
studies using knowledge-assisted models to detect textual metaphors have
emerged in recent years. Compared to not using knowledge, systems that
introduce various kinds of knowledge achieve greater performance gains and
reach SOTA in a recent study. Based on this, the goal of this paper is to
provide a comprehensive review of research advances in the application of deep
learning for knowledge injection in metaphor detection tasks. We will first
systematically summarize and generalize the mainstream knowledge and knowledge
injection principles. Then, the datasets, evaluation metrics, and benchmark
models used in metaphor detection tasks are examined. Finally, we explore the
current issues facing knowledge injection methods and provide an outlook on
future research directions. | [
0.0401819348,
-0.0017167954,
-0.0280179381,
0.0542595983,
-0.0144008351,
0.0284060929,
-0.0373293348,
-0.0203926768,
0.0194151253,
-0.0573199354,
-0.0089074662,
0.0263916273,
0.0019615784,
0.0298625845,
0.0066021923,
-0.0285409763,
0.0389732346,
0.0443541296,
-0.0387416035,
0.013518123,
-0.0811531022,
0.0182203744,
-0.0077362764,
0.0575021207,
-0.0334739164,
-0.0230533723,
0.0091823405,
0.0376646556,
0.0214148648,
-0.0283499248,
-0.0028373164,
-0.0249351151,
0.0533129238,
0.0227018911,
0.0000020401,
-0.0452545062,
0.0210539717,
-0.0205331668,
-0.0054443921,
-0.0175576508,
0.0807088912,
0.0033244286,
0.0281133354,
-0.0096341288,
-0.0120926807,
-0.0106789349,
0.0086406088,
0.0541242547,
0.021317428,
0.0277446322,
-0.0175490454,
-0.0045016999,
-0.0034048194,
0.0146643864,
-0.0124424426,
0.0011589931,
0.0321410149,
-0.0018801296,
0.0019819003,
-0.0215333272,
-0.046390716,
0.0460311845,
0.0395701677,
0.0528487973,
0.0041584866,
0.0309539158,
-0.0180132054,
0.0449328125,
-0.0372919478,
0.0606600009,
0.0014524827,
-0.0033366934,
-0.039580483,
-0.0244071689,
0.0125109246,
0.0615355261,
0.019460734,
-0.0276011471,
0.0234973989,
0.033634644,
0.0089626033,
-0.0065014078,
0.0275964886,
0.0191612635,
-0.0406761207,
-0.0108654248,
0.0031177751,
-0.0084495591,
0.0261813179,
-0.0476197414,
-0.0200437512,
-0.0251986627,
-0.0027433257,
0.0266842544,
0.0357978977,
0.0199122261,
-0.0424043685,
-0.0536487661,
-0.0100405132,
-0.03752416,
0.073319979,
0.0398852602,
-0.0314232446,
0.05692387,
-0.0595105924,
0.0190368388,
-0.0359128937,
0.0669528544,
-0.0315472074,
-0.0499299355,
-0.0621331632,
-0.026581442,
-0.0295135584,
0.0352262296,
-0.0189571101,
-0.0445127077,
-0.0193956457,
0.0164750852,
-0.0143992379,
0.0038611314,
-0.0732514113,
0.0426380858,
-0.023145847,
0.0064275302,
-0.0820123702,
-0.0284490082,
-0.0502808653,
0.0358555913,
-0.0416427664,
-0.0462787822,
0.0047354219,
0.0043175421,
0.0293353293,
-0.029230373,
0.0456777252,
0.0725909472,
0.0025577475,
-0.0297628511,
-0.0338851139,
-0.0447623208,
0.0228008293,
0.0133982953,
-0.0133331129,
-0.0239401944,
0.0137469471,
-0.0382151529,
0.0229138192,
-0.0476421081,
-0.0000879039,
0.0029360491,
-0.0653119534,
0.0696691275,
-0.0464152656,
-0.0241803564,
0.0123691317,
0.0244192518,
-0.0930929631,
0.0376453027,
0.0260522179,
0.0469899662,
0.0203670245,
0.0010800814,
-0.0350400172,
-0.0300760157,
-0.0232904796,
0.0083807101,
-0.0274305046,
-0.0201555025,
-0.0180655029,
0.0637565106,
-0.0049636862,
0.0203783903,
-0.0189171936,
0.0152572459,
0.0374488942,
0.0708482489,
0.0193411969,
0.025739694,
0.0956908911,
0.0151254768,
-0.0030692136,
-0.0043472159,
0.0050521581,
-0.0158002898,
0.0325422175,
-0.0212098788,
-0.0164339207,
0.0507099554,
-0.0056240479,
0.0040541762,
-0.0042254478,
-0.025718566,
-0.0271239076,
-0.0087213945,
0.0308363941,
0.032138329,
-0.0247394126,
0.0107233142,
0.0453649871,
0.01235619,
-0.0108676981,
-0.0102406265,
-0.0180483181,
0.0484649166,
0.0367946811,
-0.0503335632,
0.0025944037,
-0.0171935111,
0.0225162823,
0.0434707217,
-0.0184888933,
0.014897611,
0.0130253499,
-0.016966369,
0.0231713131,
-0.0590370446,
0.0083253561,
0.046960175,
-0.0078267651,
0.0616946258,
0.0063340431,
-0.016767269,
-0.0067696474,
0.0505040511,
-0.0163904484,
-0.0063443216,
0.0048228111,
0.0575814918,
0.0238557067,
-0.0009108124,
-0.0038097934,
-0.0247995425,
0.0245922878,
-0.0657965466,
-0.074800089,
0.0804932564,
-0.053107176,
-0.0006743572,
0.0374429896,
-0.0987476856,
-0.0036837028,
0.031407319,
0.0270072129,
-0.0045426828,
0.0430427641,
-0.0056936028,
0.0738747641,
-0.0265913829,
-0.0409082063,
-0.0308074504,
0.0261255726,
0.0313949697,
0.0639169589,
0.0172759052,
0.0410159156,
0.0152209122,
-0.0058349604,
0.0039056963,
0.1099109948,
-0.0171447396,
-0.0309072062,
-0.0048922142,
-0.0193310622,
-0.0423256718,
-0.0458767712,
-0.0496229194,
0.0036113607,
-0.0660338253,
0.0196294207,
0.0022132543,
-0.04277502,
0.0264543388,
-0.0414221287,
-0.029148424,
-0.0040396485,
-0.0030666012,
0.0163969956,
-0.0567448922,
0.0003136109,
0.037550211,
-0.0313141011,
0.0045414725,
0.0122619625,
0.0511071086,
-0.0590928197,
0.071943745,
0.00218924,
0.0233384594,
0.0465292931,
-0.0000401463,
-0.0259010941,
-0.0161063094,
-0.0405975245,
-0.0388998836,
0.0113871489,
0.0484281443,
0.0611407533,
0.0432182252,
-0.0109361326,
0.0491614677,
0.0515219644,
-0.0216359962,
0.0041066613,
0.0247690082,
0.0245478731,
0.0079249805,
-0.0319346227,
-0.0265904237,
0.0159923788,
0.0556304045,
0.0248355009,
-0.0123187993,
-0.011335589,
0.0412591062,
-0.0060776174,
-0.0501653254,
0.0197019465,
0.0331825726,
-0.0191703681,
-0.0041451263,
-0.0083064921,
0.0352815874,
0.0486787148,
-0.0045608422,
-0.0078199683,
0.0000907288,
-0.0305124354,
-0.0439901836,
0.0271409731,
-0.0239039455,
0.0419038497,
0.0137265995,
0.0180048067,
-0.0028810475,
-0.0282736383,
0.0030585576,
-0.0007992981,
0.0695512667,
0.0020402418,
-0.0425206348,
-0.0001110896,
0.0080436226,
-0.0503329523,
-0.0354535282,
-0.0154123511,
0.0067662722,
0.0058051771,
-0.008101318,
-0.050611522,
-0.0453248769,
-0.0047348775,
0.0014950354,
0.010638129,
-0.0487082154,
-0.058954943,
0.032628268,
0.0504500903,
0.0083955638,
0.0079203099,
0.0428060405,
0.0651420802,
0.0263527539,
-0.0747872591,
-0.0124158282,
-0.0631044507,
0.039344985,
-0.0166470129,
-0.0323510952,
0.043755956,
-0.0075091142,
0.0308339056,
-0.0256622899,
-0.0203843843,
0.0491667688,
0.0343379937,
0.0015409217,
0.0266067851,
0.0054558893,
0.000956044,
0.0600239933,
-0.0323913358,
-0.0809760168,
-0.0652372316,
0.0029879557,
-0.0313475728,
-0.0078235092,
-0.0496736132,
0.0003673418,
-0.0825972781,
0.00621098,
-0.0239405129,
-0.024406841,
-0.0361156911,
0.0137943421,
0.000795729,
0.0375105813,
-0.0049079102,
-0.0782663897,
-0.0224933773,
-0.0165328588,
-0.0026601078,
0.0450212657,
-0.0244729519,
-0.0083433418,
-0.0600336716,
0.0431679487,
-0.074469544,
0.0577606224,
-0.0255991947,
0.0211931076,
-0.0672638714,
-0.020568097,
-0.0147565063,
0.0212530177,
0.0037935574,
-0.0351733342,
-0.0071402462,
0.0074741547,
0.0193128865,
-0.0580298491,
-0.0128321592,
0.0214175973,
0.0908725634,
0.0044388175,
-0.0185980108,
-0.0398946553,
0.0041630529,
-0.0174946245,
0.0710936934,
0.0521016829,
-0.0155007653,
0.0419375338,
-0.0105831996,
-0.0127013,
-0.0194474366,
0.0038278522,
-0.012646406,
-0.039908465,
0.0446601138,
-0.0585825965,
-0.0214751214,
0.0397094414,
0.0144377891,
0.0631367788,
0.020983262,
-0.0582888387,
-0.0221271291,
-0.084126085,
0.0258636735,
-0.0253112596,
0.026916353,
0.0143498965,
-0.0117235268,
0.0543829761,
-0.0393394493,
-0.0272050016,
0.0580012761,
-0.041172076,
-0.0462001525,
-0.0152505916,
-0.0276511591,
-0.0003277563,
0.0419591442,
-0.0153616648,
0.0170942508,
0.0839043558,
0.0670540854,
-0.018830074,
0.0170398168,
0.0031950027,
-0.0074031428,
0.006699407,
0.0308702961,
-0.0048237904,
0.0082673477,
0.0173120536,
-0.022229977,
-0.0083515067,
0.0390872061,
0.0119789457,
-0.0329340249,
0.0035008648,
-0.0058706664,
-0.0932395384,
-0.0313318521,
-0.0164657645,
-0.0072318995,
-0.0391747802,
-0.0119018396,
-0.0102708675,
0.0450900421,
0.0423163213,
-0.0410777293,
-0.0350915827,
0.0500869676,
0.0438882262,
0.0621523783,
-0.0127389366,
0.0680597648,
0.0576805957,
-0.0377651528,
0.0189212915,
-0.0111518409,
-0.0021864485,
-0.0455548763,
0.0146459267,
-0.0166694261,
0.0055411807,
0.0398771465,
-0.0150199188,
-0.0431588814,
0.0315807723,
0.0083393827,
-0.0583221801,
0.0361515097,
0.0380887538,
0.0571490861,
-0.0492824912,
-0.0042346404,
-0.0452065319,
-0.0000212468,
0.0417807885,
0.0052200789,
-0.0406103879,
0.0104376124,
0.0070673628,
0.0179258287,
-0.0132075781,
0.0030442625,
-0.0275004208,
-0.0196389854,
0.0856268406,
0.0316218659,
-0.0365869664,
-0.0161856338,
0.0398398787,
0.0593976863,
0.0389540792,
0.0191473756,
0.05677725,
-0.0560988821,
-0.0740191564,
0.0700724497,
-0.01896956,
-0.0109827379,
0.0324058644,
0.018822331,
0.0363778844,
0.0575671941,
-0.0049546324,
-0.0241980534,
0.0255950168,
-0.040170718,
0.0032993304,
0.0101950616,
-6.126468641e-33,
-0.0289726276,
-0.0062104594,
-0.0153770437,
-0.0215293225,
-0.0258966945,
0.0314626619,
-0.0430754498,
-0.0318246521,
-0.0077796658,
0.0445586443,
0.0147324586,
-0.0082959738,
-0.0105990721,
-0.0184964035,
-0.0076333447,
0.009763442,
-0.0050402288,
0.0188034847,
-0.0264723748,
-0.0293323267,
0.0688842908,
0.0287389047,
0.057082817,
0.0112799555,
-0.0493106358,
0.0463483818,
0.03756091,
-0.0267439503,
0.0278001595,
0.0380311869,
-0.0307069086,
0.0623054616,
0.0139653003,
0.0257500987,
0.023643963,
0.0200360361,
-0.071080178,
-0.0536340699,
0.0224391744,
-0.0097754654,
-0.014708031,
-0.0383694358,
0.0494388752,
0.0033138883,
0.034555465,
-0.0105201397,
0.0850247145,
-0.0156680606,
0.0074525606,
-0.0372956805,
-0.0819747746,
-0.0274981558,
-0.0338350087,
-0.0341900662,
0.0044625411,
0.0049432209,
0.036790695,
0.0681075081,
-0.0818468034,
0.0074514998,
-0.0264216214,
-0.0152428364,
-0.0128351832,
-0.0000404911,
-0.0004025173,
0.0887869224,
-0.0182039905,
-0.0071955374,
-0.0226371456,
0.0433607772,
0.0701830313,
0.0168595184,
0.032487575,
0.0406953879,
0.0792753845,
-0.0316542536,
-0.0065835649,
-0.0019050402,
0.0038449685,
0.018521037,
0.0277059674,
-0.0231781211,
-0.0433033034,
0.0221148711,
-0.0410995297,
-0.0195732657,
-0.0119841211,
-0.0397819281,
0.0189689398,
-0.033541467,
-0.0127940411,
0.0424218476,
-0.0023271728,
-0.0159859881,
0.0133144232,
-0.0276116822,
-0.0110415341,
0.0266818292,
-0.0171656571,
0.0099257911,
-0.0374266878,
-0.0433215834,
0.04285625,
0.0004740953,
0.0537876002,
-0.0044113267,
0.0268619731,
0.0114719206,
-0.0656253472,
-0.0172582511,
-0.0441228151,
-0.0350022726,
-0.017885115,
-0.0222091209,
-0.0111550344,
0.0280485954,
-0.0209665988,
-0.0323213972,
0.0247976966,
-0.0150711564,
-0.0381211042,
0.0350744911,
-0.040859431,
0.0182893034,
-0.0524674989,
-0.012656888,
-0.0520765334,
-0.0547388345,
0.0148295015,
-0.1011452228,
-0.0050142519,
-0.0287368204,
2.76e-7,
0.0062662736,
0.0191301182,
-0.0020341687,
0.0172608197,
-0.0152524319,
0.0335003734,
-0.0196982305,
0.0293233413,
-0.005512469,
-0.0374723375,
0.0138338478,
0.0502010733,
-0.0312697925,
0.0235155225,
-0.1309845001,
0.0521158576,
-0.007535731,
-0.0012164023,
-0.0539773367,
-0.0356465392,
0.047299549,
0.0408825129,
0.0708237588,
-0.0354321636,
0.009158168,
-0.0683085322,
0.0309042688,
-0.054948505,
0.0341669917,
0.0029994503,
0.0450453088,
0.0551614799,
-0.0213284977,
0.0398181304,
0.0231161285,
0.0198848788,
0.0125951786,
-0.0542810149,
-0.0093378248,
-0.0074183298,
-0.0442498215,
-0.0276532285,
-0.0114563471,
-0.0528800003,
0.046043016,
-0.0630222857,
-0.0298192259,
-0.0234948043,
-0.0056948005,
0.0035296732,
0.066166088,
0.0218337607,
-0.0630810708,
-0.005613063,
0.0197776854,
0.0091623841,
0.0169419143,
-0.0834801346,
0.0442759022,
0.0385618955,
-0.0391733311,
0.0203225967,
-0.0215027556,
-0.0310007334,
0.0219508503,
-0.0874731988,
0.0081213405,
2.18922346e-34,
-0.022553701,
0.0011843879,
0.0158187151,
0.0398335904,
0.0576629788,
0.0019348614,
0.0139357457,
-0.0257509388,
-0.0090476098,
-0.035400115,
0.0124286758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04286v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04286v1 | Comparative Analysis of the wav2vec 2.0 Feature Extractor | 2023-08-08T14:29:35 | 2023-08-08T14:29:35 | Peter Vieting, Ralf Schlüter, Hermann Ney | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems typically use handcrafted feature
extraction pipelines. To avoid their inherent information loss and to achieve
more consistent modeling from speech to transcribed text, neural raw waveform
feature extractors (FEs) are an appealing approach. Also the wav2vec 2.0 model,
which has recently gained large popularity, uses a convolutional FE which
operates directly on the speech waveform. However, it is not yet studied
extensively in the literature. In this work, we study its capability to replace
the standard feature extraction methods in a connectionist temporal
classification (CTC) ASR model and compare it to an alternative neural FE. We
show that both are competitive with traditional FEs on the LibriSpeech
benchmark and analyze the effect of the individual components. Furthermore, we
analyze the learned filters and show that the most important information for
the ASR system is obtained by a set of bandpass filters. | [
0.0018223594,
0.0567404889,
0.0172453504,
0.0756411403,
-0.0110451728,
-0.002873156,
0.0390695445,
-0.025732778,
-0.0059391535,
-0.0081751766,
-0.021090081,
-0.088638857,
0.0450571477,
0.0504615158,
-0.033043094,
0.0081427144,
0.0215710439,
-0.0657805651,
0.0473483913,
0.0103869801,
-0.0309337918,
-0.0160283968,
-0.0416831709,
0.0258133654,
0.0068921428,
0.041076716,
-0.0127592627,
-0.0194736179,
0.0106356228,
-0.0208582785,
0.0139135672,
-0.0111117745,
0.0112244161,
0.0163379684,
0.0000019044,
-0.0023469701,
-0.0142473541,
0.002731015,
-0.0300143603,
-0.0008294951,
0.0112157278,
0.0596406907,
-0.0452543534,
0.00942552,
-0.0201595966,
-0.054712832,
0.0258068349,
0.0826518312,
0.0069582956,
0.0556385629,
-0.006852828,
-0.0521599725,
0.0536200367,
-0.0131282574,
-0.0040851017,
-0.012283517,
-0.0172124598,
-0.0516028032,
-0.0106547596,
-0.0637518167,
0.0085370997,
0.0638665035,
0.0242017712,
-0.0268769339,
0.020864768,
0.0301655512,
-0.0736719221,
-0.0374964103,
-0.0228534229,
0.0696561038,
-0.0143647362,
-0.0013019483,
-0.0040407116,
0.021829918,
-0.0348117687,
-0.0033156476,
-0.0129023409,
-0.0177546609,
-0.0075495685,
0.0144345695,
-0.0224625804,
0.0577827506,
0.0119196493,
-0.0334084928,
0.0060252589,
0.0005020577,
-0.0271442849,
-0.0081019588,
0.0481481962,
-0.0367514007,
0.0266634598,
0.0117987525,
0.0282242727,
-0.0120345615,
0.0504314825,
-0.0333637111,
-0.0195346419,
-0.0143433819,
-0.0602244958,
-0.0801711679,
0.0380042717,
0.0355342068,
-0.0612244904,
0.030484939,
-0.0656265914,
0.0456120893,
-0.0552582033,
0.0055455901,
-0.0165978465,
0.0138544338,
-0.0280089509,
-0.0064646807,
-0.0230857059,
0.0772555023,
0.0306503661,
-0.0192930792,
0.0048156055,
-0.0317535587,
-0.0288836099,
-0.0211963169,
0.0014889647,
0.0327800065,
-0.0389902256,
0.0156416558,
0.0120215258,
0.0298741926,
0.063800931,
0.0339373499,
-0.0497928187,
-0.0520245619,
-0.0027960818,
-0.0086718602,
0.0627655759,
-0.0261519644,
0.0262021944,
0.0442582443,
-0.0172379389,
-0.0115496647,
-0.0526762381,
0.0097281458,
0.008166777,
-0.0139912274,
0.0112009505,
-0.0420983657,
0.0230648369,
0.0059035057,
0.0030210153,
-0.0190909915,
0.0175810903,
-0.0604797602,
0.0295479912,
0.0350484289,
0.014801681,
-0.0299368519,
0.1047073603,
-0.023790691,
0.0302478056,
0.0131107252,
0.0675569177,
0.0162792131,
-0.0362508707,
-0.0299303718,
-0.0262922812,
0.0386432298,
-0.0038217825,
-0.0590718426,
-0.0745676085,
0.0162005965,
0.0504554473,
-0.0142373135,
0.0558656231,
0.0371816345,
-0.0289758537,
-0.0024288464,
0.0574235842,
0.0324463695,
0.0726868287,
0.0190329943,
0.0597936995,
-0.0101126777,
0.0662097409,
-0.0136052491,
-0.0124566527,
0.0150222257,
-0.0094151273,
0.0116505781,
-0.0287110917,
0.0062354431,
-0.001751067,
-0.0355653055,
0.0214642044,
-0.0187673271,
0.0299650002,
-0.001026958,
0.0413973853,
-0.0301232468,
-0.0062582288,
0.0365419537,
-0.0147061422,
-0.0238868669,
0.0150891142,
-0.0320763178,
0.0277756024,
0.0231082141,
0.0212280471,
-0.0230748802,
-0.0075143706,
-0.0882121921,
-0.0118265608,
0.0047916002,
0.0588320605,
-0.0175718833,
0.0644733608,
-0.0308451187,
-0.043501392,
-0.0010652194,
-0.0454781763,
0.0412970856,
-0.0434812643,
0.0034279614,
0.0300736763,
0.0064583295,
-0.0398921743,
-0.0164608918,
0.0411704108,
-0.0640183911,
0.0086498614,
0.0185434055,
0.0992370695,
0.0389886089,
-0.0251849573,
-0.0047341445,
0.030004479,
-0.0665995628,
0.0065248199,
0.0453470275,
-0.0532023124,
-0.0291695055,
0.05312768,
0.0142933633,
0.0654939339,
0.0708832741,
-0.0011327206,
-0.0564295128,
0.0100938966,
0.0092342775,
0.0652817786,
0.0015332353,
0.0378927663,
0.0310987625,
0.0240640454,
0.0179413464,
0.0138764977,
0.0030529373,
-0.044403255,
0.00309416,
-0.0302497391,
-0.0175666679,
-0.0395659991,
-0.0439116023,
0.0809824839,
0.0051381905,
-0.0291493721,
0.0021322244,
-0.0042430265,
-0.03282113,
-0.0204412397,
-0.0672915801,
0.0173597075,
-0.0126922727,
0.0376190096,
-0.0402182192,
-0.023207739,
0.0200578496,
-0.0284777042,
-0.0502695888,
-0.02531486,
-0.0733299926,
-0.0334386155,
-0.0395961851,
0.050928995,
-0.0369976908,
-0.0285339504,
-0.0405923799,
0.0186274834,
0.0097516933,
-0.0054803328,
-0.0327060185,
-0.0152761526,
-0.0123209683,
0.0232909657,
0.0492071174,
0.0096753072,
-0.0005281285,
-0.0254607871,
-0.0022969665,
-0.0377399437,
0.0433624312,
0.0786857456,
0.0423386917,
0.0091088265,
0.0254790764,
-0.0487636402,
0.046772901,
-0.0070330617,
0.0460023507,
-0.01176342,
0.0540717877,
-0.0613241121,
0.0173904113,
0.0459969305,
0.0695321858,
-0.0131056421,
-0.0123529248,
-0.0090676621,
-0.0241896547,
-0.0162331387,
-0.0286033936,
-0.0461710058,
-0.0291230511,
-0.0181049891,
-0.0458519273,
0.0060678562,
-0.0546459854,
-0.021878127,
-0.0065411343,
-0.0869266763,
-0.0131174456,
0.0399530753,
0.0096169179,
-0.0184694286,
-0.032769043,
-0.0422725081,
-0.0045275455,
-0.0113372998,
-0.0041402504,
-0.0698286071,
0.0217667781,
0.0126587134,
0.0157725476,
-0.0338985175,
-0.01644128,
-0.0322360955,
-0.0291303173,
0.0071217758,
0.032367833,
-0.0195762254,
-0.0156271141,
0.0267019179,
0.0742967948,
0.0203417614,
0.0652954578,
-0.0377739966,
0.0192893203,
-0.0509348065,
0.1072579175,
0.0442731753,
0.0305591058,
-0.0197690204,
0.0206105579,
0.040438816,
-0.0219101235,
0.0381102264,
0.0163643379,
-0.0622766614,
-0.0068037696,
0.0120971221,
-0.0102615282,
-0.0182141531,
0.0173743665,
0.0295364559,
-0.0934713781,
0.0296165682,
0.0699072406,
0.0071557243,
-0.0405299589,
-0.0327040926,
0.0406788476,
-0.0553051867,
-0.0141400378,
-0.0348128639,
0.0195185691,
-0.0030383561,
0.0454743505,
0.0214930903,
0.0156097831,
0.0391156338,
-0.0073090689,
-0.0594863072,
0.0325962156,
0.0282160565,
-0.032119032,
-0.0060711363,
0.0021423674,
-0.022800995,
-0.0239441004,
0.0346943848,
-0.0031945598,
-0.0217654817,
-0.0049812193,
0.0411447622,
-0.0197227653,
-0.036293637,
0.0253865011,
-0.0057663312,
0.0543333404,
0.0670315474,
0.0009298543,
-0.0264645629,
-0.0204546638,
0.0634878799,
-0.0445976965,
0.0164874941,
-0.0287368912,
0.0510945767,
0.0065700784,
-0.0122935381,
0.0073194876,
0.0295037068,
0.0225530174,
0.0255672634,
-0.0188030154,
0.0013769682,
-0.0293024611,
-0.0129524292,
0.0211931448,
-0.0176453013,
-0.0055939644,
0.029392885,
0.0161332078,
-0.0211554039,
-0.0251870155,
0.013535629,
0.0112172067,
-0.0307922158,
-0.0756527111,
0.0028782482,
0.048927702,
-0.0486177579,
0.0154756242,
-0.0152375074,
0.0193748362,
0.0015137405,
0.0049279216,
0.0174031127,
-0.0019063383,
0.0238079038,
-0.0655382425,
0.0347935334,
0.0242880937,
0.0416484959,
-0.0663500205,
-0.0234598964,
0.0197595842,
-0.0912435427,
-0.0268617421,
0.0070089162,
-0.0743590817,
-0.0350085422,
0.0354144908,
-0.0027532545,
0.0120003121,
0.056672357,
-0.0187625177,
0.0030962168,
0.0511808656,
0.0159176476,
-0.0800380185,
-0.0133484062,
0.0426609926,
-0.0132902926,
-0.0198007766,
0.0179978292,
-0.0389298387,
0.0052924184,
0.0037697472,
0.0058228988,
0.0087109599,
-0.0424596407,
0.0032910251,
0.0175763369,
0.064591527,
0.0376343355,
0.008917707,
-0.0360186063,
0.0439124666,
0.0232585724,
0.0696860105,
-0.0310766306,
0.0238563456,
-0.0151733542,
0.0155403037,
-0.0020716181,
0.0123907467,
0.0198939946,
-0.0262354184,
0.0267891791,
0.0873243809,
-0.0019836456,
-0.0106890984,
0.0196250714,
0.0082992502,
-0.0176822115,
0.0457669497,
0.0556134544,
0.0050575919,
0.0044239243,
0.0095338756,
-0.0310422126,
0.023098167,
-0.0174275171,
0.0441750959,
-0.0575705357,
-0.0388346389,
-0.0249937419,
0.0346782357,
0.0186002236,
-0.0385028757,
0.0394708924,
0.0263757557,
0.0205353219,
-0.0089565851,
-0.0123465275,
0.0105590662,
0.0555901937,
0.0627319813,
-0.0012726606,
-0.0309883188,
0.0167557467,
0.0131367045,
-0.003057763,
0.0231214091,
0.0031651736,
0.0375620201,
-0.0458404161,
-0.000495709,
-0.0190078914,
-0.0192253515,
-0.0453203768,
0.0023252375,
-0.019582523,
-0.0020787157,
0.08410687,
-0.0631843358,
-0.0005223176,
-0.0407150164,
-0.0086871181,
-0.0079649575,
-0.0231547728,
-0.0214605667,
0.0251988694,
-0.0391208939,
0.0277877878,
-0.0048874607,
-0.0517127104,
-6.269192757e-33,
-0.007905554,
0.0220517013,
-0.0038632948,
0.0372792855,
-0.0452110358,
0.0238124933,
0.0034885311,
0.0137612987,
-0.0047218371,
-0.0434407555,
-0.0108906385,
-0.0018429643,
0.0579957999,
-0.0206955839,
0.003574247,
-0.0250302311,
0.0958327875,
-0.0465106703,
0.0076469271,
-0.0059076832,
0.066827707,
0.0413777195,
0.0342010744,
-0.0728007481,
-0.0288004633,
-0.0021874553,
0.0218888894,
-0.0430149734,
0.0486225486,
0.002970116,
0.0032305324,
0.0264250021,
-0.0066913343,
-0.0345278829,
0.0057939528,
0.0032029946,
-0.0790045187,
0.0011047154,
-0.015111181,
0.0153032867,
0.0116707049,
-0.0637425259,
0.0367912129,
0.0594845936,
-0.0495737717,
-0.0447680242,
0.0160917863,
-0.0337996967,
-0.0266024116,
-0.0961933732,
-0.0053527076,
0.0403491743,
-0.0255103055,
-0.0010068066,
0.0723717585,
0.0296467748,
-0.041253563,
-0.0281033814,
-0.1024297103,
-0.0096283751,
0.0097053042,
0.060485892,
0.0069806357,
0.0204381421,
0.0016222065,
0.0305410977,
0.0609519891,
-0.0541400649,
0.0080431504,
0.004347241,
0.010618763,
0.0434019342,
-0.0082249856,
-0.0397074558,
0.0663886294,
-0.0558752716,
-0.0297581069,
-0.0103756255,
0.0331615619,
0.0378828011,
-0.0072798762,
-0.0015689555,
-0.0525893755,
0.0465654992,
-0.0365391113,
-0.0154632088,
-0.0245656502,
-0.0244766437,
0.053106606,
0.0097258762,
0.0463425368,
-0.0308363549,
0.040075615,
-0.009771321,
0.0764630064,
0.0386680923,
-0.0413139835,
0.0121352235,
-0.0035895633,
0.0021995939,
-0.0265406128,
-0.0641570389,
0.0079494184,
0.0188868418,
0.0195116419,
-0.005377105,
-0.0274955593,
0.0942700803,
-0.0328096151,
-0.0218571369,
-0.0152613511,
0.0245838724,
-0.0020480624,
0.0638106465,
0.0452177785,
-0.0172729138,
-0.0003895552,
0.0225080289,
-0.0519877337,
0.0597485825,
0.0078669796,
0.0053676208,
0.0637249798,
0.0528159626,
-0.0066056605,
0.0399286263,
-0.0006675784,
0.0555219688,
0.0079734083,
-0.0086038373,
0.0163674001,
0.0273968447,
2.805e-7,
-0.0522211418,
-0.0323240831,
0.0401097685,
-0.0316466726,
-0.0020431969,
-0.0037706136,
-0.0058837552,
-0.0373608246,
0.0185251534,
0.0628659576,
0.0026294892,
-0.0000987713,
0.0823934004,
0.043849986,
-0.0477719605,
-0.0162514281,
-0.0592557266,
0.0127006378,
-0.0095107295,
-0.0226353332,
0.0433463976,
0.066042468,
-0.0072141234,
-0.0352962203,
0.0023282412,
-0.0305211786,
0.0041694599,
0.0143662291,
-0.0022987034,
-0.0266365372,
0.0248561502,
-0.0397701487,
-0.0447663441,
0.0058361352,
-0.0377779901,
0.0601410158,
-0.006100547,
0.0412352346,
-0.0295589548,
-0.0719041005,
-0.0028913161,
0.0451933816,
-0.0292645358,
0.0401218496,
0.0765179321,
-0.0125144646,
-0.0499772727,
-0.0085645039,
-0.0429027602,
0.0304407533,
-0.0064832736,
-0.0223855451,
0.0537849367,
-0.0140649863,
-0.0318900086,
-0.0393405147,
-0.0532796793,
-0.0661674738,
-0.0031003521,
0.0100525077,
-0.0389931314,
-0.0277632345,
-0.0363944285,
0.0182474088,
0.0684204698,
0.0249708034,
0.0051330435,
1.711828342e-34,
0.0245320257,
-0.0098238001,
0.0069445288,
0.0019379199,
-0.057833273,
-0.0201488826,
-0.0055001723,
-0.0246905759,
-0.0310619157,
-0.0557929017,
-0.0553248227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04275v1 | In-Context Alignment: Chat with Vanilla Language Models Before Fine-Tuning | 2023-08-08T14:17:17 | 2023-08-08T14:17:17 | Xiaochuang Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this note, we explore inference-time alignment through in-context
learning. We consider a vanilla pretrained language model Llama-2 before any
fine-tuning and retrieve an average of 9 demonstration alignment examples when
the model is prompted to follow chat-style instructions. Compared to direct
prompting, the in-context alignment without changing model weights leads to a
7x increase in win-rate w.r.t. the text-davinci-003 model from OpenAI, making
the vanilla language model comparable to strong baselines with alignment
fine-tuning. | [
0.0006777724,
0.0486003757,
0.0075156922,
0.0465272851,
-0.0359065868,
0.0096097765,
-0.0127399564,
-0.0298229456,
0.015080126,
0.0025661793,
-0.0719975531,
-0.040157754,
0.0384630859,
-0.0027203902,
0.0373631679,
-0.0001917817,
0.0460049957,
0.012661811,
0.0099290684,
0.0096888812,
0.0315646119,
-0.010941972,
-0.041175101,
0.0283314902,
-0.0207043067,
-0.0530971214,
-0.0510940179,
0.0241114348,
0.0240877308,
0.0080553023,
0.0131413061,
0.0435571894,
-0.0156047437,
0.03169927,
0.000001613,
-0.060113769,
0.0179323964,
-0.0163193252,
-0.0556505732,
0.0163731519,
0.0230412539,
-0.0078235315,
-0.0298648775,
0.0453305207,
-0.0418411382,
0.0318560936,
0.0815846249,
-0.0022730129,
0.0454687066,
0.1083470583,
-0.017800834,
0.0006871163,
0.0247940589,
-0.0452342294,
-0.0271489266,
-0.0768150911,
-0.0019967293,
-0.0042488878,
-0.0469285101,
-0.0221259259,
-0.0149241118,
0.0434770957,
0.0022670263,
-0.0110035008,
-0.0118731325,
0.0238293987,
-0.0712975636,
-0.0291476734,
-0.0127025079,
0.0998893604,
-0.0192687344,
-0.0280911513,
-0.0304838326,
-0.0110689793,
0.0215332676,
-0.0648333654,
-0.0323590934,
0.0044303564,
0.0112905549,
0.0487400182,
0.0470978431,
-0.0022136187,
0.0378601998,
-0.0237354599,
-0.0125708347,
0.0364372544,
0.0228517987,
-0.0208848678,
-0.0117008826,
-0.0021680656,
-0.0199466385,
-0.0669639111,
-0.0425486155,
0.0358865485,
-0.0695150569,
0.0285841711,
-0.0814393535,
-0.0026749631,
0.007031037,
-0.0556626394,
0.0231228713,
0.1086290926,
-0.0204667412,
0.0326298401,
0.0046682884,
0.0576454736,
-0.0135335056,
0.0340745598,
-0.048939798,
-0.0127552971,
0.0172444098,
0.0094685899,
-0.0181078371,
-0.030043399,
-0.0387074873,
-0.0440115072,
-0.0643157512,
0.0624804236,
0.0283939019,
0.0441234745,
0.0005916137,
-0.0369069651,
-0.0844319761,
-0.0065509276,
0.0033896214,
0.0343977027,
0.0005672492,
0.028451737,
0.0220271479,
-0.0892958045,
-0.0424575172,
0.0266543496,
-0.0003635668,
-0.0234004017,
-0.0220987387,
0.0739612132,
-0.0535835214,
-0.0647602603,
-0.0036808883,
0.0389784463,
-0.0112777017,
-0.0814361721,
-0.0140654324,
-0.0360832773,
0.0458933003,
0.0055366023,
-0.0046259598,
-0.038681075,
0.0044315089,
-0.0054112272,
0.0099752089,
0.0624457076,
0.004001955,
0.0232405905,
0.0209576823,
-0.028480554,
0.0069086356,
0.0851022825,
0.0440374799,
0.0186512321,
0.0095827682,
0.0201142002,
-0.0101222824,
0.0871554166,
0.0479477011,
0.0006379092,
-0.030897595,
0.0170825124,
0.0479734764,
0.069006823,
0.0297855325,
0.0186646767,
0.0017841127,
0.0085123666,
0.0576141551,
0.0528879799,
0.0371223837,
-0.0128774187,
-0.0164513737,
-0.0065418282,
-0.0179368034,
0.0138257956,
-0.0701069236,
0.0370519944,
-0.0287036784,
0.0425232276,
0.0584600866,
0.0439277664,
-0.039196562,
-0.0182408039,
-0.0121245161,
-0.0164277386,
-0.0215997025,
-0.0013455102,
0.0191811882,
0.002163226,
-0.0556039326,
0.0350681804,
0.0485024825,
-0.0344308019,
-0.0449272357,
-0.034466248,
0.0200390685,
0.0352757089,
0.0270917825,
0.0002648035,
-0.0645455793,
0.0260754693,
0.0163812842,
0.063054651,
0.0431535095,
0.0091731288,
0.0391288474,
-0.0473617166,
0.0075215553,
-0.0176467448,
-0.0066734441,
-0.0195344947,
0.0280061122,
-0.0006054159,
-0.0124540422,
-0.0120039657,
-0.0433775075,
0.0510594025,
-0.0257154331,
-0.0138271032,
-0.0558932982,
0.0433426052,
0.044488024,
-0.0321392603,
-0.0029462955,
-0.0160391033,
0.0116031421,
-0.0267828163,
0.065561831,
0.0288893487,
-0.0454836525,
-0.0757102519,
0.0645197928,
0.0046524173,
-0.0511880964,
0.003190347,
-0.0435809195,
-0.0457599238,
-0.0339786373,
0.002002032,
0.0487410538,
-0.0062148762,
0.0429994725,
0.0094181532,
-0.0041995747,
-0.0373440348,
0.0357232764,
0.0123981293,
-0.0056478996,
0.0168102439,
0.0256259684,
-0.0094118379,
-0.0409491546,
-0.0207313038,
0.0040824278,
-0.0073598642,
-0.0097577516,
-0.0316170827,
0.0043449942,
-0.0238780119,
-0.0232034493,
-0.1030770838,
0.037639346,
-0.0352821387,
0.0412309989,
0.0672174767,
0.0305736158,
-0.0214861166,
-0.0150226988,
-0.0663682297,
0.0309586897,
0.0085111512,
0.000054605,
0.0580405071,
-0.0059092119,
-0.0339217819,
-0.1085084826,
0.0256329887,
-0.0014815932,
0.0147074526,
0.0078202533,
-0.0357224792,
-0.0584329069,
0.0447883457,
-0.0442456752,
0.0330958553,
-0.0179326776,
-0.0677642375,
-0.005237082,
0.0187113341,
0.0461847968,
0.1008742899,
0.0016301277,
0.0226820502,
0.0122820213,
0.0176811777,
-0.0375848785,
0.0150023662,
-0.0036701025,
-0.0429885127,
-0.0467220172,
-0.0108465459,
0.0038152367,
0.0610406213,
-0.0158291254,
0.0202080086,
-0.0595433563,
-0.0202511605,
0.0272309538,
0.0090930983,
0.0012907304,
0.0411076769,
-0.0374718532,
0.0546726026,
-0.0681634471,
-0.0836113393,
0.075619787,
-0.0475943908,
-0.0379335918,
-0.0214189366,
-0.0198684428,
-0.0152935199,
0.028937798,
-0.0112154009,
0.0281549022,
-0.0109926146,
-0.0442974418,
-0.0548817031,
-0.0030157184,
0.0132820709,
-0.0272178315,
0.0494401082,
-0.0127265723,
0.0359652191,
-0.0350894816,
-0.0320275202,
-0.0404972807,
-0.0294299982,
-0.0284185745,
-0.0109440815,
-0.0037395505,
-0.0151010305,
-0.0296826363,
0.0141238617,
-0.0154716773,
0.0541846417,
-0.0190419555,
0.0229163337,
-0.0261633359,
0.0181373972,
0.0569340698,
0.0164045971,
-0.0364890769,
-0.0397964679,
0.0405446738,
0.0219231322,
0.0200845581,
0.0007031944,
-0.0352558866,
-0.0475915149,
0.025095908,
0.0069369739,
0.020192381,
0.0227668099,
0.0656980723,
0.0138484649,
-0.0341872685,
0.0847091228,
0.0264901146,
-0.0174083374,
-0.0065321592,
-0.0011858501,
0.0472222269,
0.0167465732,
0.016051406,
-0.103799291,
-0.0508072786,
0.0242047329,
-0.0054821842,
0.0462185033,
0.0348709598,
-0.0086919451,
-0.0894260779,
-0.0120888082,
0.0302478373,
-0.0650796816,
-0.0131942583,
0.0058629974,
0.0281174388,
-0.0285334438,
0.0615571812,
0.0355234444,
0.0141857956,
-0.0273411814,
-0.0025027387,
0.0361269191,
-0.0396228619,
0.0108826999,
-0.0393240526,
0.0796509758,
0.0669896826,
0.0373145267,
0.0167501718,
-0.0403174162,
0.0595977455,
0.0149633968,
-0.0014450861,
0.0378369577,
0.0108207781,
-0.0202913359,
-0.020150546,
0.0046672374,
0.0415988863,
0.003809029,
0.0186435021,
-0.0135231642,
0.0064369212,
-0.0104458956,
0.0510499738,
0.0350179374,
0.0108505413,
0.0280324407,
0.0439551324,
0.0249088481,
-0.0244810097,
-0.0004004776,
-0.019459337,
0.019056337,
0.0151240798,
-0.0049383454,
-0.008219514,
-0.0414729565,
-0.0205792766,
-0.0699479058,
-0.0281092003,
0.0118264304,
0.0564193241,
0.0332668833,
-0.0304607321,
-0.012671574,
-0.0061128046,
-0.0074718986,
0.0515993275,
-0.0265064649,
0.0182272196,
-0.0616138689,
0.0057651727,
0.0248153619,
-0.010927584,
0.0255673211,
0.0343095884,
-0.1057306603,
-0.1081966311,
-0.0218820367,
0.0268698167,
0.0213875603,
0.07577575,
-0.0252138637,
0.0136463316,
-0.0123869479,
0.0188148208,
0.0060836803,
0.0389027633,
0.0052032517,
0.0077925962,
0.0130863879,
0.053143952,
-0.0202513654,
-0.009579123,
0.0092045926,
0.0209443625,
-0.0096811233,
-0.0885473266,
0.0118342638,
0.0072829574,
0.0492853709,
-0.0038257921,
-0.0260982811,
-0.0250881854,
0.0518048182,
-0.006507006,
-0.0097288908,
-0.0091422191,
-0.0428784043,
0.0065602772,
0.0007399708,
0.0239606369,
-0.0084308097,
-0.0294564851,
0.0329006128,
-0.0262441467,
-0.0319481194,
-0.01355357,
0.01850361,
0.0227045994,
0.0252304524,
-0.0279545318,
0.0405418612,
0.0105694495,
0.0495235808,
-0.011699995,
0.0489930585,
0.0404366069,
0.0293360054,
-0.0334626064,
0.0220770929,
-0.0016453209,
-0.018167777,
-0.0163942687,
0.0519344695,
0.078469947,
-0.0028839519,
0.0470200107,
0.0075959363,
0.0046347128,
0.0106486026,
0.0652757138,
-0.0477697998,
-0.0337574743,
0.0434462577,
-0.0171317887,
-0.0189728197,
0.0069261924,
0.0524445213,
-0.025797734,
0.0437266044,
-0.0084254611,
0.0430255756,
-0.0330378786,
-0.0133378552,
0.0358046666,
0.0175586455,
-0.0242256839,
-0.0339363068,
0.0014258001,
-0.0572178587,
-0.0128353583,
0.0419768468,
-0.0254672188,
-0.000377091,
0.0179544706,
0.0618837476,
-0.0135895377,
-0.0172966011,
0.0084158359,
-0.022169834,
0.0134088155,
-0.0166898817,
-0.0317923613,
-6.381389285e-33,
-0.0558053702,
-0.0010253408,
0.0231393855,
0.0173232127,
-0.0388939977,
-0.0208567586,
-0.0443495512,
-0.013608031,
-0.0345159248,
-0.011510185,
-0.0286570564,
0.022223426,
0.0199980345,
0.018792063,
-0.0217275489,
-0.0168749727,
0.0178265609,
-0.0064092726,
-0.0542083569,
-0.0140517782,
0.0222420115,
0.0043884199,
0.035813652,
-0.0168423112,
0.0091438452,
-0.023123987,
-0.0212258901,
0.0272879209,
-0.0173751507,
0.0202151779,
-0.0126600396,
-0.0249342956,
0.00310664,
0.0169079546,
0.0029866556,
0.0400584452,
-0.0459153876,
-0.003278851,
0.0516873561,
0.0275620017,
-0.0234960336,
-0.0325979367,
0.0418295227,
-0.0209616236,
-0.0157819558,
0.0149899898,
0.0134239187,
-0.0179589223,
-0.0232558474,
0.0256163832,
-0.0917328298,
-0.003639966,
-0.0271070059,
-0.0591881126,
-0.0003156713,
0.0037122192,
0.0268070623,
-0.0016211782,
-0.0442484021,
0.0078119165,
0.0080087082,
0.0360704474,
0.0769803002,
0.0427415334,
-0.011157372,
0.0325107537,
-0.0012031101,
-0.0052796612,
0.037179254,
-0.0232443549,
0.0060347915,
-0.0076307827,
-0.0025614805,
0.0436548181,
0.0087999227,
-0.0107132392,
-0.0913777426,
0.0210449938,
0.0416562967,
-0.0265284646,
-0.0152296359,
0.0424866304,
-0.0555807725,
-0.0119794076,
0.0043645101,
-0.0055948817,
-0.0410161763,
-0.0252686571,
0.017799478,
0.0142953629,
0.013926954,
-0.0139500182,
0.0343594849,
0.0036793498,
0.0146922227,
-0.0030035421,
-0.0259594452,
0.021762196,
-0.062312305,
0.0103309341,
-0.0613778047,
-0.0467379764,
0.0178773515,
0.0324436203,
0.0380178541,
0.0101523641,
0.0543051288,
0.0175365023,
-0.065984942,
0.0164050758,
-0.0391622558,
-0.0035173555,
0.00304822,
-0.0019010506,
0.0684754178,
-0.0129693849,
-0.0139930788,
0.0817749649,
-0.0041689784,
-0.0121164331,
-0.0485399924,
-0.0400332659,
-0.0005954788,
-0.0011173042,
-0.0622898825,
0.0139777809,
-0.0074030864,
0.0216888525,
-0.0059288773,
-0.0598219596,
-0.0208197441,
0.0114389062,
2.439e-7,
0.0416820571,
0.0155581497,
0.0631814003,
0.0404853858,
-0.0057291002,
0.0167744514,
-0.0373455435,
0.0322515778,
0.0285005327,
0.0055722566,
0.0220766384,
0.0062125204,
0.0605986863,
-0.0070503904,
-0.0652853772,
0.0018704318,
-0.0861871541,
0.0121946521,
-0.0531139262,
-0.0156822857,
0.018129386,
0.1292893589,
-0.0102556972,
0.022007579,
-0.0007616106,
-0.0206393898,
0.0507951602,
-0.0215207729,
-0.0223316457,
0.0423247665,
0.0187165532,
0.0099435374,
-0.0480061881,
-0.0036147498,
0.0077943387,
0.0410816371,
-0.0301895048,
0.0753320158,
-0.0237978529,
-0.0075236601,
-0.0052847248,
0.0234942473,
-0.0197647884,
-0.0355570242,
0.0366227776,
-0.0712426603,
-0.0331040956,
-0.0472855195,
0.0011343315,
0.0105533637,
0.0052431719,
0.0045869588,
0.024282299,
0.0461135022,
0.0238814652,
-0.0112951389,
-0.0476959683,
-0.0484805591,
-0.0725289732,
-0.0064261062,
-0.0232400466,
-0.0351759233,
-0.0120124444,
-0.0153302439,
0.0308991522,
-0.042167183,
0.0115457596,
1.910777088e-34,
-0.0135461707,
-0.0270339865,
0.0299061928,
0.0926284194,
0.0095804092,
-0.0324579701,
0.027358925,
0.0043674745,
0.0223734826,
-0.0466084369,
-0.0190445632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04255v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04255v2 | CLASSLA-Stanza: The Next Step for Linguistic Processing of South Slavic Languages | 2023-08-08T13:41:41 | 2023-08-11T15:24:37 | Luka Terčon, Nikola Ljubešić | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present CLASSLA-Stanza, a pipeline for automatic linguistic annotation of
the South Slavic languages, which is based on the Stanza natural language
processing pipeline. We describe the main improvements in CLASSLA-Stanza with
respect to Stanza, and give a detailed description of the model training
process for the latest 2.1 release of the pipeline. We also report performance
scores produced by the pipeline for different languages and varieties.
CLASSLA-Stanza exhibits consistently high performance across all the supported
languages and outperforms or expands its parent pipeline Stanza at all the
supported tasks. We also present the pipeline's new functionality enabling
efficient processing of web data and the reasons that led to its
implementation. | [
0.0704782903,
0.0271756388,
-0.0150641035,
0.0254491158,
0.0049814833,
0.0376792997,
-0.0229129381,
-0.0492989793,
-0.0073509091,
-0.0448625609,
0.0165054202,
0.0054043699,
-0.0027621968,
-0.0178611707,
0.0486452691,
-0.0702463984,
0.0611070432,
-0.0316675976,
0.0188620333,
0.0402659401,
0.0189333558,
0.02920454,
-0.0333720595,
0.0162904859,
-0.0216438826,
0.0040255156,
0.0117465416,
-0.0009078407,
-0.0117121954,
-0.0372416675,
-0.0174621269,
0.026536759,
-0.0221018177,
0.0628069192,
0.0000017451,
-0.0639786273,
-0.0194303952,
-0.0168841444,
-0.0049224664,
-0.0108237443,
0.0191990808,
-0.0276300181,
-0.0404819958,
-0.016331654,
-0.0229648817,
0.002734557,
0.0565927364,
0.0079953056,
0.0304440893,
0.080941543,
-0.0093599502,
-0.0490658954,
0.0090121189,
0.0274037737,
-0.0622526817,
-0.0092551522,
0.0115078632,
0.0134345423,
0.0021995881,
-0.0016253524,
0.0055481247,
0.0664529055,
-0.0260220617,
-0.0396377705,
-0.0334236622,
0.0055083586,
-0.0365506746,
-0.0533320308,
0.0058726827,
0.0188599471,
0.0124317827,
-0.0189123861,
0.0333634876,
0.0364277884,
0.0125368219,
-0.0626179054,
-0.0341791064,
0.0386700444,
-0.0246503837,
0.0231841858,
0.0251692478,
0.002070012,
0.0176206809,
0.0080876239,
0.0450113639,
0.1028226167,
0.0067872126,
0.0133193787,
0.0277558323,
0.0336017683,
0.0323902182,
-0.0284340195,
0.0457165688,
0.0159400906,
-0.0203759186,
0.0181062073,
-0.0183916315,
-0.0373769328,
0.051318001,
-0.0235155132,
0.0264017321,
0.0298583414,
0.0006277245,
0.0337589532,
-0.0563432761,
0.0013174004,
0.036174655,
0.0017004901,
-0.0076577622,
-0.0307955742,
-0.030818129,
0.0189531613,
-0.0762805343,
-0.0061683445,
-0.0217723288,
0.0094896201,
-0.0297634732,
0.0332726426,
0.0135004502,
0.0498223193,
-0.0323062763,
-0.0339017212,
0.009042467,
0.0038884871,
-0.0031312965,
0.047083389,
-0.0372656919,
-0.0026068345,
-0.0623003021,
-0.0641954765,
0.0615035966,
0.0219733585,
0.0101007633,
-0.0109433914,
0.0003879633,
0.0166562423,
0.0245291386,
-0.0239354707,
-0.0479487814,
-0.0240572002,
-0.0170561876,
-0.062705934,
-0.021596197,
-0.0771094933,
0.0091590555,
0.01696142,
-0.003618126,
-0.0352201685,
0.0060735326,
0.0169717111,
-0.0172619335,
0.0471524298,
-0.0623354577,
-0.0265275985,
0.0095963618,
-0.0499147214,
0.0305029042,
0.0886560678,
0.0299050733,
0.0172797721,
0.0788192227,
-0.0124996826,
-0.0359204076,
0.0528530255,
-0.028119171,
-0.0295961611,
0.0046430952,
0.0489233844,
-0.00724346,
-0.005792181,
0.0697866902,
0.034714438,
0.0133656543,
-0.0021462094,
0.0239268895,
0.0272577498,
0.0200465564,
0.0526851974,
0.0511873625,
0.0334051549,
0.028124148,
-0.0278021861,
-0.0571933128,
0.0010171072,
0.0088755302,
0.0281200819,
-0.0282661784,
0.0275712535,
0.0218195766,
-0.0326163657,
-0.037065573,
-0.0263839886,
-0.0001621152,
-0.0495623536,
0.0583694912,
-0.0180866383,
-0.005652701,
0.0109542171,
0.053450685,
-0.0299915411,
0.0361739695,
0.0160871949,
0.0199167877,
0.0497502945,
-0.0116485385,
-0.0654234812,
-0.010075313,
-0.0111953579,
-0.0131606255,
0.0654586107,
0.0421117954,
-0.0484769158,
-0.0077047772,
-0.0247005336,
0.0161029063,
0.0076713655,
-0.0121702766,
0.0252721123,
-0.011446448,
0.0033763081,
-0.0015050397,
0.0044277054,
-0.0252251923,
0.0258894879,
0.0487872325,
0.0291174743,
-0.0109165553,
-0.0048606806,
-0.0042638993,
0.0454911999,
-0.0019009884,
0.0368169807,
0.0271574389,
-0.0166920144,
-0.0024275547,
0.033532273,
0.0338650495,
-0.0571790636,
0.0348748043,
-0.0031135993,
-0.0272279102,
-0.0562873818,
0.0022310526,
-0.023522662,
0.0775724202,
-0.0453562513,
0.0109147578,
-0.0167418886,
0.0121712126,
0.0197961982,
0.0246169474,
-0.015257814,
0.0162642989,
0.0177788176,
0.0018443259,
-0.003252815,
-0.0438060947,
0.0212041363,
-0.038937144,
-0.0391338728,
0.0368829183,
-0.0507238768,
-0.0198981203,
0.0017259271,
-0.0249704551,
-0.0482178777,
0.0367058218,
-0.1026594266,
0.0108748795,
-0.0298351161,
0.0587575585,
-0.0125861866,
-0.000935067,
-0.0089201843,
-0.043452125,
-0.021980051,
-0.0061091469,
0.0075805923,
0.016759757,
0.0284388177,
-0.0084683131,
-0.0086036427,
-0.0305900462,
0.0041200621,
-0.0190643724,
-0.0126038399,
0.0021764834,
-0.0878721923,
-0.0565623268,
-0.0295927599,
-0.0338768251,
0.035143923,
0.0191259235,
-0.0590397492,
-0.0175140835,
-0.0006403846,
0.0140376547,
0.0205358658,
-0.0617622025,
-0.0432030223,
0.051829122,
-0.0146826459,
0.005759648,
0.0016499984,
-0.0182037894,
0.0645213649,
-0.0196209848,
-0.0005715951,
0.0060345205,
0.0360028632,
-0.024066275,
0.017833367,
0.0036181198,
-0.0111694578,
-0.0605416335,
0.0082920985,
0.0085685654,
0.0040120031,
-0.0171770006,
0.0576965436,
0.0023954962,
-0.0078414753,
0.0538582578,
-0.0234244987,
-0.0411990993,
-0.06380748,
-0.0039528175,
-0.0462375581,
0.0312427003,
0.0118402727,
0.0000928017,
-0.0478136241,
-0.0728554204,
0.0359234326,
-0.0072157448,
0.0337123349,
0.0083578555,
0.0424539633,
-0.0339287892,
0.0208524857,
-0.0428613909,
-0.0069790073,
-0.0063981423,
-0.0210661553,
-0.0367522053,
0.020755291,
-0.0121232355,
-0.004184735,
0.0142950295,
-0.0132342568,
-0.0368470885,
0.0508806407,
-0.0319060795,
0.0216174666,
-0.0142772812,
0.0317815617,
0.0103650847,
0.0059491745,
0.0129556321,
0.0833869204,
0.0573310219,
0.0377208255,
0.0076087662,
-0.0306743141,
0.0080923671,
-0.0103098825,
0.0317865089,
-0.0485255755,
-0.0424420983,
-0.0176838599,
0.0070680282,
-0.0764518604,
-0.0098184971,
0.0903109163,
0.0251979847,
0.0318693221,
0.0067348569,
-0.0091237295,
0.0186200142,
0.0373729803,
0.026321264,
-0.1054529771,
-0.0166115239,
0.0050709071,
-0.002332268,
-0.016872596,
-0.0279083252,
0.0049762581,
-0.0823899582,
-0.0069006295,
-0.0085744141,
-0.0380259082,
-0.0046278308,
-0.0650247782,
0.0065574702,
-0.0387631916,
-0.0306873508,
0.0128767863,
-0.0336151868,
0.0153030753,
0.0296364725,
-0.0817687511,
-0.0573609248,
-0.029360285,
-0.0419977568,
0.0244665388,
0.0252831876,
0.0352708474,
-0.0382209271,
0.0300035831,
0.0287461951,
-0.0117995292,
-0.0224859957,
-0.0273063406,
0.0648780391,
0.0217603426,
-0.043972671,
-0.0086900797,
0.0033648231,
-0.0080584204,
-0.0231088959,
0.0037509026,
0.0611597262,
0.0018107438,
0.0248326473,
0.0143454839,
0.0170718059,
0.0393631049,
0.0363217331,
-0.009064558,
0.0226920359,
-0.0277883168,
-0.0244119,
-0.0465428419,
-0.0306255575,
-0.0353838503,
0.0332096964,
-0.0350971743,
-0.0515421964,
-0.0997637212,
-0.0906220004,
0.0748482943,
0.0075674886,
0.0099433102,
0.0246335045,
-0.0024366672,
0.0010011661,
-0.0547767431,
0.0350613631,
-0.0041398816,
0.0213859025,
-0.0606842861,
-0.0398283713,
0.0217010714,
-0.0118375067,
-0.0066091139,
0.0392221734,
-0.0465088189,
-0.0511135273,
0.0095049301,
0.0121912993,
0.0162593145,
0.0322100334,
-0.0092024058,
-0.0410797261,
-0.0232324544,
-0.0023944087,
-0.0292348452,
-0.02806082,
0.0383415595,
0.0284198541,
0.0072952667,
0.0501954183,
0.023779463,
-0.00483575,
-0.0278888848,
-0.0124287633,
0.0192968789,
-0.023382185,
-0.0078441203,
-0.0132319927,
0.0429062508,
-0.0162123796,
-0.0280647539,
-0.0337637663,
-0.0154232411,
-0.0231462531,
-0.0189643987,
0.0068118819,
0.0181967057,
-0.0065884832,
0.0060134232,
-0.0439757816,
0.0472396091,
-0.0301900376,
-0.010624378,
-0.0259420667,
0.0380593464,
0.0699229091,
0.0078634964,
-0.0177472979,
0.0183440894,
-0.0198035408,
0.0595843196,
0.0232928582,
0.0264396332,
-0.0341774262,
-0.0263101738,
-0.0253691617,
-0.0343444943,
0.0079827243,
0.0156455785,
-0.0011443567,
0.0464235172,
-0.0014087468,
0.0329370275,
0.0789920762,
-0.0313531868,
0.1312853843,
-0.0309456103,
-0.0195261557,
0.0113009783,
0.0250696447,
-0.0250663664,
-0.0370807052,
0.024619136,
-0.018733358,
-0.0387275442,
-0.0171354562,
-0.0021952707,
-0.0315542705,
0.0341850482,
0.0414213017,
-0.0134508628,
-0.0345284939,
-0.0106778108,
-0.0419294573,
0.0118000135,
-0.0310767069,
-0.0014256689,
-0.0558297895,
-0.0346236788,
-0.0391469784,
-0.0010396361,
-0.0487817414,
0.0001786735,
0.0391830578,
0.0174659975,
0.040525645,
0.0083595831,
-0.062451534,
0.0044416673,
-0.0168463308,
-0.016993355,
-0.017047843,
-5.729229427e-33,
-0.0384193361,
0.0047017764,
0.0131053161,
0.0109644998,
0.0151606705,
-0.0201512463,
0.0119446181,
0.0038442516,
-0.0232515875,
0.020700695,
-0.0019190536,
-0.0324842967,
0.0468728282,
-0.0109584052,
0.0367587507,
0.0061374013,
0.0421254449,
-0.0019919311,
-0.0073766341,
0.0239894036,
0.0901171565,
0.0044173133,
0.126224786,
-0.0711282715,
0.0435605384,
0.0330624878,
-0.0051349322,
0.0183354095,
0.0565625131,
0.0502446778,
-0.0254235752,
0.02803839,
0.0102589084,
-0.0115631241,
-0.0257400963,
0.0219493881,
-0.0918333828,
-0.0260246303,
0.0403797701,
0.0839587003,
-0.0123353554,
-0.0331778526,
0.0353152864,
-0.0477176458,
-0.0037824907,
0.0517319925,
0.0319461748,
-0.0365382284,
0.0151646249,
-0.0551184453,
-0.1149329022,
0.0559708141,
-0.0197238773,
-0.0131456237,
0.0712156296,
0.0126479445,
0.0329819694,
-0.0215932038,
-0.0558172129,
0.0123251034,
-0.0480967276,
0.0786156133,
0.0414931551,
-0.0307789072,
-0.0625628754,
0.0257938243,
0.0184640512,
-0.0623022318,
0.046898596,
0.0727878138,
0.0481333099,
0.0135097504,
0.0479505584,
0.0214942861,
0.0087306481,
-0.0071326727,
-0.0478103906,
-0.0055765156,
0.0854548886,
0.0396541692,
-0.0467133448,
-0.0283627622,
-0.02344287,
-0.0197762512,
0.0029569087,
-0.1065689772,
-0.0142661398,
0.0045829141,
0.0275959168,
-0.0558492355,
-0.0031015039,
0.0641241968,
0.0109215658,
-0.00874718,
-0.0741476566,
0.0288648121,
-0.0042330232,
0.0354651511,
-0.0248770788,
0.027308099,
-0.0256285314,
-0.0192689728,
0.0007251084,
0.0105521781,
0.0079621011,
0.0163145959,
0.0554154515,
0.0268739052,
-0.0584841371,
0.0265681315,
-0.0218878202,
0.0687505081,
-0.0024054104,
0.0801090375,
0.0348935463,
-0.0170657355,
-0.0132038174,
0.0622045025,
0.0582418032,
0.0086876191,
-0.0259805936,
0.0239887144,
0.0021776429,
0.0145194735,
-0.0135367494,
0.0232508462,
-0.0182177126,
0.0193631537,
-0.0012107933,
-0.0192001536,
0.0284228809,
-0.0155941034,
2.527e-7,
0.041649323,
0.0709574819,
0.0204936005,
-0.0418796912,
0.0453564897,
-0.0039894655,
-0.0370544717,
0.0028607475,
0.0045955856,
0.0343953036,
-0.0153681049,
-0.0526674688,
0.0261517279,
0.0650190189,
-0.1177819073,
-0.0129525848,
-0.0329128392,
-0.0209558532,
-0.0712185502,
0.0408381186,
0.0591982305,
0.1168120354,
0.028995648,
-0.0417426452,
-0.0594973601,
-0.0269276053,
0.0108267944,
0.0104091028,
-0.002565227,
0.0447264872,
0.0302984435,
0.0325594805,
0.0061362432,
0.0061362293,
-0.0254439451,
0.0558483191,
-0.0134461867,
0.0343405642,
0.0044233031,
0.011260529,
0.0279408097,
-0.0510604195,
-0.0036399665,
-0.0530278198,
0.0850053728,
-0.0130730653,
-0.0557222255,
0.0016800807,
0.0042477008,
0.031645406,
-0.0114574051,
-0.0160230696,
-0.0429415777,
0.0397740714,
0.0242671818,
-0.0697100461,
-0.0434213616,
-0.0401732177,
-0.0387438498,
-0.0471074544,
0.0055027376,
-0.0280416813,
0.0052318247,
0.0106231607,
-0.0285585634,
-0.0253588185,
-0.0066194679,
2.296921012e-34,
0.0125481598,
0.0231381096,
0.0319015943,
0.0076999413,
-0.0147814471,
0.0205412265,
0.0198941752,
0.0542801395,
-0.0104614142,
-0.0263776761,
-0.0169714782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04248v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04248v1 | Gloss Alignment Using Word Embeddings | 2023-08-08T13:26:53 | 2023-08-08T13:26:53 | Harry Walsh, Ozge Mercanoglu Sincan, Ben Saunders, Richard Bowden | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Capturing and annotating Sign language datasets is a time consuming and
costly process. Current datasets are orders of magnitude too small to
successfully train unconstrained \acf{slt} models. As a result, research has
turned to TV broadcast content as a source of large-scale training data,
consisting of both the sign language interpreter and the associated audio
subtitle. However, lack of sign language annotation limits the usability of
this data and has led to the development of automatic annotation techniques
such as sign spotting. These spottings are aligned to the video rather than the
subtitle, which often results in a misalignment between the subtitle and
spotted signs. In this paper we propose a method for aligning spottings with
their corresponding subtitles using large spoken language models. Using a
single modality means our method is computationally inexpensive and can be
utilized in conjunction with existing alignment techniques. We quantitatively
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on the \acf{mdgs} and \acf{bobsl}
datasets, recovering up to a 33.22 BLEU-1 score in word alignment. | [
-0.0497922599,
0.0233003069,
0.0163313225,
0.0455292016,
0.0044483971,
0.0256934538,
-0.0059157154,
-0.0161246415,
0.041544795,
-0.0336826779,
-0.0158867668,
-0.0409501232,
0.0216930285,
0.0221034009,
0.0275700372,
-0.0630912855,
0.050666187,
-0.0242078751,
0.00436184,
-0.0122285429,
0.0778554678,
0.0308118034,
-0.0539986342,
0.0222781803,
-0.0870143473,
-0.0342908017,
0.0185083169,
0.0158365276,
0.0404811986,
-0.0065343417,
-0.0932844281,
0.0307211187,
0.0637471154,
0.0212520845,
0.0000015853,
-0.0276233479,
0.0121644121,
0.0039125318,
0.0154898604,
0.0275565106,
0.0392133333,
-0.0615698472,
-0.0246931519,
0.058014784,
-0.006591544,
-0.0834311321,
0.0782732368,
-0.0045924042,
0.0135703878,
0.0261699278,
-0.0301135555,
-0.0097336331,
0.0176137835,
-0.0293242987,
-0.0170149542,
-0.0241754819,
0.0049373456,
0.0270078573,
-0.0054626721,
-0.0601092726,
-0.0464986637,
0.1054346561,
-0.0200319886,
-0.0452411883,
-0.0480861068,
0.0118103102,
-0.0414858125,
0.0296565462,
-0.0072918455,
0.0520243198,
-0.0268505029,
0.0199607871,
-0.0216385573,
-0.0200513341,
0.0079435445,
0.0310363714,
-0.0229418427,
0.0044357539,
0.0065355608,
0.0081791533,
-0.0230228864,
0.0090104248,
0.0658125356,
-0.0450428985,
0.0148468781,
0.0211504567,
0.0627923459,
-0.0162056088,
-0.0054443497,
-0.0280552264,
-0.013303522,
0.0053573288,
0.0006273167,
-0.0266871545,
0.0007405449,
0.0295573138,
-0.055670917,
0.0100367684,
-0.0259295851,
0.0044593946,
-0.0043651876,
0.0534898266,
-0.029342128,
0.0439668447,
0.0275662635,
0.0231172889,
-0.0455021895,
0.0497672819,
-0.0627511889,
0.0010824022,
-0.0056986073,
-0.0123554692,
-0.0498302914,
-0.0405959748,
0.0087846136,
-0.0295300055,
-0.024504194,
0.0139194513,
0.0206755437,
0.0112372069,
-0.001565559,
-0.0001598614,
0.0208091326,
-0.0253814086,
0.0376457907,
0.0288052671,
-0.0104590477,
0.0284631085,
-0.0405512527,
-0.0372379422,
-0.0045174058,
0.0458641648,
0.0230017453,
0.0226496942,
-0.0358073078,
0.0441271216,
-0.0081893746,
-0.0326018557,
-0.0156721044,
0.02845807,
-0.0391699374,
-0.0016147792,
-0.0311654955,
-0.0292620119,
0.0478821695,
-0.0051314528,
-0.012764873,
-0.0260148384,
-0.0006578104,
-0.0141378557,
0.01851134,
0.0675679073,
-0.0205586087,
0.0285432879,
0.0136199947,
-0.0240119491,
-0.0062785088,
0.0508564711,
0.0794567093,
-0.0117855743,
0.0406460576,
-0.0227022618,
0.0168252755,
0.1190018505,
-0.0277433563,
0.0305854548,
-0.0263371766,
-0.0391574837,
0.0157361533,
0.0775291249,
0.0147073595,
0.0470048971,
-0.0077777826,
-0.0228456296,
0.0449756235,
0.0882626474,
0.0088356482,
-0.0381064042,
0.0258246921,
0.0398182124,
0.0000460903,
-0.0203086194,
0.0064987419,
-0.0063743014,
-0.0135304797,
0.0108182169,
-0.0295527242,
0.0119850859,
-0.0458853468,
0.021713648,
-0.0483569913,
-0.0255003665,
0.0149306469,
0.0022952366,
0.0304584131,
0.0048071924,
-0.0391347222,
0.0036457076,
0.013099229,
-0.03523314,
0.0275492258,
-0.0052304827,
-0.016545888,
0.0364784561,
0.0376182646,
-0.0047919233,
-0.0349683724,
-0.0097434558,
-0.0115793152,
0.0557827391,
-0.0008555742,
-0.0159150362,
-0.0205342341,
-0.0698748156,
0.0046931459,
0.0580738895,
-0.0177492257,
0.0097968979,
-0.0528361499,
0.0348772742,
-0.0062170844,
-0.023653036,
-0.0150523307,
0.036803063,
-0.0012233676,
-0.0244759433,
-0.0141983051,
0.0106777912,
0.048279196,
0.0257337242,
-0.0295501649,
-0.0003158227,
0.0100736283,
-0.0269742571,
0.0183616988,
0.0861611888,
-0.0166047793,
-0.0381137617,
0.0464928001,
-0.0516536683,
-0.0094491225,
0.017133873,
0.0099156741,
-0.0557723865,
-0.0081833666,
-0.0283261016,
0.0688681006,
-0.0568124987,
0.0378407016,
0.0199895389,
-0.0104005737,
-0.0134101426,
0.0049302927,
-0.0170153044,
-0.0359035395,
-0.0255978182,
-0.0053798622,
0.0259702448,
-0.0530238226,
0.0110134706,
0.0484269969,
0.0153931072,
0.0259954613,
-0.014201005,
-0.0164810624,
-0.0144962901,
0.0055321059,
-0.1102885306,
0.0137783671,
-0.0146521572,
0.0340182446,
0.0078336373,
-0.0029931376,
-0.0277948491,
-0.0188030973,
-0.0392806679,
0.001689037,
0.0310577378,
-0.050739143,
0.0041058753,
-0.0154537093,
-0.0416199975,
-0.0543645881,
0.0020306252,
-0.0224565342,
-0.0005446609,
0.0241258293,
-0.0546109453,
-0.0541596711,
-0.0185869969,
0.0222049076,
0.0264859721,
-0.0020588273,
-0.0309804678,
0.0019180342,
0.0320602283,
-0.0321551599,
-0.0213279109,
0.0191324763,
0.0121645452,
-0.0095758364,
-0.0263667535,
-0.0076297945,
-0.0165055711,
0.011224268,
0.0012950376,
-0.0653806329,
0.0030529974,
-0.022932779,
0.044588618,
0.0412703529,
0.0507702492,
-0.067761369,
-0.0434916727,
-0.0241177231,
-0.0330836661,
-0.0057917992,
-0.0024294422,
-0.0663739964,
-0.0237287581,
-0.0227913745,
-0.0635492802,
0.0210478809,
-0.0776495561,
-0.048160594,
-0.0054983459,
0.0116785476,
-0.0208939705,
0.0426144861,
-0.0321621485,
0.0345195271,
-0.0478121005,
-0.0706715956,
-0.0327029005,
0.0123731568,
0.0292866118,
-0.025748197,
0.0181979127,
-0.0304685552,
0.0309285708,
-0.0120268567,
0.0074195364,
-0.0072782608,
-0.0411548801,
-0.0249155797,
-0.0041477196,
0.0311880596,
-0.0634651408,
-0.065995954,
0.028950626,
-0.0013191738,
0.0327192284,
0.0125692179,
0.0401763767,
-0.0218378324,
0.0195134282,
0.0603626855,
-0.0004397315,
-0.0645450652,
-0.0339099243,
-0.0037837068,
-0.0043049608,
-0.0273229815,
0.0446280055,
-0.0291898064,
-0.0346366428,
0.052716326,
0.001963269,
-0.0108067114,
0.0020913961,
0.0298393201,
0.0096430033,
0.044216577,
0.1138043553,
0.0298559554,
-0.0456776842,
0.006459354,
0.0247315336,
-0.0115693668,
0.0048855199,
-0.0436606258,
-0.122056447,
-0.0656486452,
0.0162786376,
0.0460732207,
0.073698014,
0.0267109238,
-0.0141849779,
-0.056587223,
0.0213509724,
0.0509929135,
-0.044926364,
-0.0112996101,
0.0298005454,
0.0192582328,
-0.0046148719,
0.0437643602,
0.0047575599,
-0.0326729119,
-0.0135541465,
0.0246697608,
-0.0188987609,
-0.0768642575,
0.0057359468,
-0.0360467322,
0.0670665875,
0.022564441,
0.0173593517,
-0.0098599968,
-0.0370485969,
0.0076014819,
-0.0139387241,
-0.0165397041,
0.0104153119,
0.0344388746,
-0.0629624501,
-0.0406460129,
-0.0087138852,
0.0610441938,
-0.047135435,
0.0050381594,
0.0155498851,
0.0567899384,
-0.0030251937,
0.0582992136,
0.0035155376,
-0.0196363721,
0.0076759784,
0.0419077836,
-0.0204252489,
-0.0363340788,
0.0366932377,
0.0182361957,
0.0206119847,
0.0843032524,
-0.0589812584,
0.0214152653,
-0.039312847,
-0.034380991,
-0.0173938703,
-0.0178552102,
0.070659861,
0.0453907959,
0.0315976553,
0.0240558181,
0.0463192388,
-0.0047795619,
-0.0361918062,
0.0524088852,
-0.024600843,
0.0364959128,
-0.0765405148,
-0.0343302563,
-0.0098491339,
-0.010510968,
0.0015838374,
0.0356846675,
-0.0720383972,
-0.0560601577,
0.0093786623,
-0.0097324383,
0.0156095186,
0.0401736014,
-0.0370165557,
-0.0141245956,
-0.0408763736,
0.0093413983,
0.0334442258,
0.0305457599,
-0.0072231772,
-0.0442205667,
-0.0107651791,
0.0167882293,
-0.0148454187,
-0.0020534191,
-0.0382012576,
0.0233378019,
-0.0952311531,
-0.0146325538,
-0.0242039468,
0.0320258401,
0.0193175245,
-0.0561424419,
-0.0348943286,
-0.08457046,
0.0232768729,
-0.0189455543,
0.014438604,
-0.062937364,
-0.0093065789,
0.0447632447,
-0.032800179,
-0.0306573082,
0.0056137135,
-0.0529956929,
-0.0102891754,
-0.0002521419,
0.0384818166,
0.0062424163,
-0.0046584555,
0.0110040195,
0.0223455001,
0.0000315611,
0.063643381,
-0.0100931702,
0.008175876,
0.0168865267,
0.0454298258,
-0.0127701256,
0.0001381664,
0.0216911174,
0.0365715772,
0.0574667901,
-0.0308117978,
-0.017763935,
0.0486936346,
0.0451171584,
-0.0169103611,
0.0537259504,
-0.0136390943,
0.0231005605,
-0.0307800751,
0.039276585,
-0.0567163117,
-0.0239312518,
0.0547258072,
-0.0039929869,
-0.0421088636,
0.017465122,
0.037998531,
-0.036492303,
-0.0060243565,
-0.0279163495,
-0.0198263843,
-0.0399417803,
-0.021308545,
0.0318906866,
-0.0157479979,
-0.0436993428,
0.0254017394,
-0.0794014111,
-0.0366679393,
-0.0017299665,
0.0039993497,
-0.0058036684,
0.0464482568,
0.0222306456,
-0.0215232018,
-0.0365060046,
0.0123029016,
0.0140363201,
-0.0450069942,
-0.0492993295,
-0.0218459908,
-0.0183442552,
-4.874673686e-33,
-0.0638481379,
-0.0308059081,
-0.0042338036,
-0.0021647259,
-0.0677945986,
0.0374624617,
0.0030285346,
0.0274552181,
0.0197718143,
0.0161321871,
0.0258920249,
-0.0019818184,
0.0128050502,
-0.0075940336,
0.0021999564,
-0.0374166593,
0.0216423832,
-0.0190575048,
-0.0232165772,
-0.0026933446,
0.0379145816,
0.0159280393,
0.0734400004,
-0.0927743912,
-0.004083246,
-0.0466938466,
-0.0312943421,
0.0152875884,
0.0151505349,
0.0442146845,
-0.0353078991,
0.0293400362,
-0.0203409828,
0.0718020126,
0.0122316815,
0.0430589542,
0.0015795907,
0.0391395055,
0.0556824543,
0.0831498727,
-0.0194306578,
0.0336006768,
-0.0288401376,
-0.0203503836,
-0.051477991,
0.0404190272,
0.0307755806,
-0.029621603,
0.0062841768,
0.0102303149,
-0.0610482804,
0.0486373939,
-0.0259069111,
-0.0463444218,
0.0558688901,
-0.0466520637,
0.0248232447,
-0.0233234093,
-0.0020595228,
0.0103784846,
-0.0059463214,
0.0354829133,
0.098321341,
0.0017195907,
-0.0006724663,
0.0613875426,
0.0212248676,
-0.1111275256,
0.0515338182,
-0.0577575378,
0.0515107624,
-0.00906152,
-0.0032615955,
0.0490588173,
0.0414503887,
-0.0063966513,
-0.0037199352,
-0.0429165773,
0.0474712737,
0.0439292304,
-0.0278884526,
0.040396478,
-0.0404299721,
0.0084442832,
-0.0515342429,
-0.0147838555,
0.0206776708,
-0.0324298926,
0.0299914815,
-0.0016826655,
0.0185180176,
0.0284642261,
0.0693645924,
0.0224674121,
0.0115229823,
-0.0250175521,
-0.0026011625,
0.0298436843,
-0.0301756859,
0.0564440787,
-0.0316591896,
-0.0215767045,
0.0563298091,
-0.0319523923,
0.0455719493,
-0.0037031523,
0.0127336383,
0.0672071129,
-0.0439840667,
0.0204056706,
-0.006589001,
-0.0183370598,
-0.0317124873,
-0.0216857474,
0.0750743523,
0.0015218029,
-0.0234987568,
0.0744431689,
-0.0008297274,
0.0185419898,
0.0103075802,
-0.023109708,
-0.0226986632,
-0.0129855219,
-0.0332664922,
0.0291945077,
0.0499363095,
-0.057543166,
0.0340219066,
-0.0641499758,
0.0157901701,
0.0223337878,
2.276e-7,
0.0631212518,
0.0453039631,
0.0480818488,
0.0434941165,
0.025609009,
0.0098408815,
-0.0197056364,
0.0142634101,
0.0209384337,
0.0100777913,
0.0346119106,
-0.0295850318,
0.060229864,
0.0207520183,
-0.0584702827,
0.0550786145,
-0.0291600972,
0.0306290761,
-0.034586627,
0.0280998312,
0.0310424399,
0.07573428,
0.0143947387,
0.0129593397,
0.0311737545,
-0.0895243287,
0.0551887341,
-0.038244091,
-0.0343557484,
-0.0075680637,
0.0493575223,
0.002849014,
-0.0240825862,
0.006750592,
0.0194235723,
0.0322453231,
0.0347549394,
0.0223423373,
-0.0594616942,
0.0093493098,
-0.0301926099,
0.0146206142,
-0.0604055896,
0.0290638357,
0.0508651212,
0.0142830694,
-0.0182682835,
-0.0616426468,
-0.0267403759,
0.0160578154,
0.0211177915,
-0.0007362129,
0.0282480251,
0.0269101001,
0.0449300036,
-0.0469648205,
-0.0443085358,
-0.0374264568,
-0.0119227581,
0.0037014114,
-0.0110244378,
0.0032335459,
0.036824666,
-0.0058360794,
0.0079125864,
-0.0752665997,
-0.0255951993,
1.903513359e-34,
0.0469352528,
0.0119960988,
0.0252248291,
0.0483046547,
-0.0093929218,
-0.0145721659,
0.0254362933,
0.0224650986,
0.0090866666,
-0.0315655656,
-0.016598165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04226v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04226v1 | OpinionConv: Conversational Product Search with Grounded Opinions | 2023-08-08T12:45:01 | 2023-08-08T12:45:01 | Vahid Sadiri Javadi, Martin Potthast, Lucie Flek | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | When searching for products, the opinions of others play an important role in
making informed decisions. Subjective experiences about a product can be a
valuable source of information. This is also true in sales conversations, where
a customer and a sales assistant exchange facts and opinions about products.
However, training an AI for such conversations is complicated by the fact that
language models do not possess authentic opinions for their lack of real-world
experience. We address this problem by leveraging product reviews as a rich
source of product opinions to ground conversational AI in true subjective
narratives. With OpinionConv, we develop the first conversational AI for
simulating sales conversations. To validate the generated conversations, we
conduct several user studies showing that the generated opinions are perceived
as realistic. Our assessors also confirm the importance of opinions as an
informative basis for decision-making. | [
0.0509570204,
0.0548111722,
0.0006653151,
0.0236138832,
-0.0400908031,
-0.0341326483,
0.0107916808,
-0.0369804911,
-0.0156260598,
-0.0651346892,
-0.0646439269,
-0.0279971231,
-0.0139652668,
0.0768871084,
-0.0475617312,
0.000519328,
-0.0040834569,
0.0198158361,
0.0368341245,
0.02344485,
0.0385672115,
0.0573408976,
-0.0371798463,
0.0140866935,
-0.037745554,
-0.0229831431,
-0.0275926664,
-0.0242554527,
0.0207500048,
-0.0116775054,
0.0690100789,
0.0326671191,
0.0217932221,
0.0099973064,
0.0000018614,
0.0035379704,
0.019347243,
-0.0379925445,
-0.0145091368,
0.0010325508,
0.0670188889,
0.0425979905,
0.0088273175,
0.0118100531,
-0.0903170183,
0.0186184477,
0.0107652694,
0.0947557762,
0.0654884055,
0.0629284307,
-0.0278425384,
-0.0230675694,
-0.0426626354,
0.0007373621,
0.0047575762,
-0.0256964825,
-0.0188358072,
0.0017327146,
-0.0132939322,
-0.0095110862,
0.0394668281,
0.0011108581,
-0.0057340432,
-0.0618679412,
0.0089116683,
0.0484495759,
-0.0238478649,
0.0177804679,
-0.0190932192,
0.0967844352,
0.0113371927,
-0.0309177432,
-0.0218353271,
-0.0014232423,
0.0002617207,
-0.0588892102,
-0.0247519407,
-0.0038443797,
0.0012811334,
0.0438412838,
-0.0705943108,
0.0677776486,
0.0232477915,
-0.0069359206,
0.0377574116,
0.0595137477,
-0.0244909879,
-0.0461914055,
0.0284485053,
0.0068723336,
0.0154357264,
-0.0216931738,
0.0106258113,
-0.0025425765,
-0.0522278659,
0.0189323332,
-0.0012065002,
0.081374526,
-0.0083936797,
-0.1201659814,
0.0074413749,
-0.0071215527,
-0.0040137237,
0.0397824943,
-0.0149164004,
-0.0032621438,
0.0339075513,
-0.0052278698,
-0.0492205918,
-0.0063375267,
-0.0252609495,
0.0014942271,
-0.0230531916,
0.0426247418,
-0.0633495003,
-0.0595814809,
-0.0081137447,
0.0009368772,
-0.0359442942,
-0.0094814328,
0.0073313392,
0.0745699331,
0.0027593039,
0.0140104266,
-0.0777988806,
-0.0016736632,
-0.035449788,
0.0259083025,
0.0085635595,
-0.0251080971,
0.0396559499,
0.0497148931,
0.0094181402,
-0.0076156012,
-0.0039675366,
0.0125534795,
0.0062435428,
-0.0225151144,
-0.0391311795,
0.0032202676,
-0.0072846944,
-0.0584773719,
-0.0350084864,
-0.0206591915,
0.0346088856,
-0.0345306806,
-0.0099954372,
0.0114342785,
0.0258885175,
0.0260140058,
0.0122512225,
0.0921073407,
-0.0232589412,
-0.0148629546,
0.0064717764,
0.0031187003,
0.0489061326,
0.0262029152,
0.0110244844,
0.0589177571,
0.0412844829,
0.0242317915,
0.0635400638,
-0.0203653723,
-0.0105069727,
-0.0288557354,
0.0009667491,
0.0235322844,
-0.0968156978,
0.0366233364,
0.0073389434,
0.0572504401,
-0.0121005122,
0.0077381516,
0.0799294412,
0.0269341357,
-0.0476401821,
0.0325908437,
0.0366594642,
0.0370647088,
0.0034319605,
-0.0030636014,
0.0015807265,
0.0314462408,
-0.00058201,
-0.0268609971,
-0.0008562453,
-0.0477750078,
-0.0219646096,
-0.0501245521,
0.0275677666,
-0.0303539634,
0.0349812284,
0.0035235062,
-0.0389827304,
-0.0074690045,
-0.0299148001,
0.014935541,
0.0128674479,
-0.0733162314,
-0.0292393472,
-0.0169218592,
0.0501837321,
0.1261604279,
0.0480192117,
0.0278267935,
-0.0269185044,
-0.0052394089,
-0.0105825216,
0.072396718,
0.078837119,
-0.0286535099,
-0.0085062748,
-0.0544873551,
0.0240789633,
-0.0287699886,
0.0107358424,
0.0327187851,
-0.0153724821,
0.0172799844,
0.0234749261,
-0.0267026816,
-0.0128553379,
-0.0070949965,
0.0204439517,
-0.034090776,
0.019210564,
0.0179906357,
0.0045925197,
0.0172922704,
-0.0096735992,
0.0121046836,
0.0373467281,
0.0152564514,
-0.072820805,
0.0584840365,
-0.0171601307,
-0.0126484828,
0.0056509748,
-0.0549450144,
0.0040414101,
0.0098528611,
0.007547236,
-0.0396711901,
-0.0099525824,
-0.0323669091,
0.0660203099,
-0.0323237367,
-0.0113604814,
-0.0058767921,
0.0210574586,
-0.0047140485,
0.0375991873,
0.0198234115,
-0.0285639092,
-0.0205184408,
-0.0326348357,
0.0153974518,
-0.017302772,
0.0067071426,
0.0165329892,
0.0582191348,
0.0203938615,
0.0442816205,
0.0053218892,
-0.0180756729,
0.0069440934,
-0.1446865648,
-0.0109144198,
0.0069764364,
-0.0074159182,
0.0030671798,
-0.0024353461,
0.0183917508,
-0.0149369026,
-0.0977154896,
0.0053786598,
0.0030199678,
-0.0009233851,
0.0552812293,
0.0404073894,
0.0048644668,
-0.0732833445,
0.0202204138,
-0.0046098465,
0.0306302533,
0.0204085968,
0.0192680955,
-0.0493845865,
0.002291762,
-0.0665234476,
0.05456312,
-0.0174815599,
-0.0209624693,
0.0023500128,
-0.0134289321,
0.0187239032,
0.0388480835,
0.0332371257,
0.0166573487,
0.0427260771,
-0.0034454761,
-0.0584027134,
0.007933829,
-0.0376814492,
0.0284603015,
-0.028247362,
0.0072642625,
0.041162841,
0.0182381123,
-0.0125745079,
0.0122273117,
-0.0420935974,
0.0155503787,
0.0202170089,
-0.0312294327,
0.0009980784,
-0.0246415865,
-0.0216512792,
0.05739576,
-0.0200244524,
-0.0260663349,
0.0776701793,
-0.0160832107,
-0.0105565321,
-0.0692576021,
-0.0287391506,
-0.0533029772,
0.0070796413,
-0.030662138,
0.0055189962,
-0.0200749077,
0.0258125886,
0.0079265945,
-0.0156297367,
-0.0032701818,
-0.0228374936,
0.0250493009,
-0.0238267891,
0.0353356227,
0.0518654808,
-0.0397812538,
-0.030203728,
-0.0453902557,
-0.0198969021,
-0.0065080072,
0.074460417,
-0.033032693,
-0.0708229542,
-0.0096278433,
0.0003363699,
0.0277620349,
-0.0040927134,
-0.0315746777,
0.0062486897,
0.0235051475,
0.0998145789,
-0.0133521697,
0.0420227982,
0.0125911981,
0.0537473485,
0.0336551294,
0.0152891055,
0.0040946412,
-0.0420497842,
-0.0619542412,
-0.0058711465,
-0.0019196336,
0.0238987245,
-0.0150100905,
-0.0101826154,
0.0019551641,
-0.01365049,
0.1205182001,
0.0274859034,
-0.054249458,
0.01483751,
0.0104506901,
-0.0062442408,
-0.0053603393,
0.0224226713,
-0.0432108082,
-0.0085624168,
-0.0322117992,
0.0210673381,
0.0188593473,
-0.005171054,
-0.0162305571,
-0.1355153918,
-0.0005296438,
-0.0185268614,
0.0375854224,
-0.0642126277,
0.0005016063,
-0.0131125879,
-0.0238312297,
0.0541060604,
-0.0280200318,
0.0207301471,
0.0186695289,
-0.0062050503,
0.0131461127,
-0.0070228474,
0.0761953518,
-0.0167542286,
0.0366794728,
0.0865144134,
0.0838055983,
0.0241304282,
-0.0386531278,
0.010650537,
0.0282155424,
-0.0162729472,
0.0339277834,
0.064898923,
-0.0382415615,
0.0056181839,
-0.011144503,
-0.003679784,
-0.0399627313,
0.02323067,
-0.0018792571,
-0.0094353436,
-0.0461697318,
-0.0548984781,
-0.0267045815,
0.0529050194,
0.0352909602,
0.0757324025,
-0.0021075483,
-0.0857311115,
-0.0299157705,
-0.0346625634,
0.0081331721,
-0.0200183056,
-0.0481551625,
-0.0253394619,
0.0430771075,
0.0113740982,
-0.0681553036,
-0.0647216588,
-0.0214777254,
0.02171655,
0.0146408454,
-0.071413599,
0.0127713541,
0.0147575149,
0.0180325955,
0.0135789001,
-0.0126397507,
0.0263845697,
-0.0322637893,
0.0200171582,
0.0786161125,
-0.0384365357,
0.0000563221,
0.0102150934,
0.006408202,
-0.0346793458,
-0.0360485949,
0.0499023646,
0.0143306777,
0.0290111452,
-0.0217763819,
-0.0216100086,
-0.0362916365,
0.0444151349,
-0.0588063896,
-0.0158983283,
0.0351985358,
0.0747688785,
0.0248230118,
0.0399560407,
-0.0220884737,
0.0286124181,
-0.030883655,
0.0110275131,
-0.0147963781,
-0.0605625659,
0.0421067365,
-0.0386368074,
0.0316676348,
0.0280981194,
0.0648362115,
-0.0341403633,
0.0364672691,
-0.0398370475,
-0.0239186976,
-0.048612047,
0.0124375932,
-0.0239114873,
0.0140744476,
-0.0289958064,
0.0169382691,
-0.0399036482,
0.0400174968,
-0.0081280125,
0.001583036,
0.0195634142,
-0.0107418457,
-0.0187127478,
-0.0205106139,
-0.018877849,
0.040049348,
-0.012808376,
0.0235097855,
0.0080410903,
0.0237879325,
0.008776756,
-0.074867256,
0.0046770717,
0.0263953973,
-0.0355116315,
-0.0234442726,
-0.0378392227,
0.0441878736,
-0.0172075406,
-0.0154540753,
0.0407144278,
-0.0477060191,
0.0308075454,
-0.0100791687,
-0.0105900327,
-0.0184428077,
-0.0215245225,
-0.013372276,
0.0201170053,
-0.0218111966,
-0.0016699834,
0.0290657394,
-0.0316435322,
0.0459957644,
-0.0301037356,
-0.0288259592,
-0.0552728139,
-0.0023016327,
-0.0069293524,
0.0322632156,
-0.004883437,
0.0136211244,
-0.0526759438,
-0.0175224151,
0.0058902041,
0.0169934798,
0.0249680039,
-0.0077862274,
0.0555937476,
0.0775184855,
-0.0051629459,
0.0388256349,
-0.0367027335,
0.0009543889,
-0.044210393,
0.0048257802,
-0.081656605,
-5.434837152e-33,
0.0236793961,
-0.0434071571,
-0.0118052717,
0.0363102481,
-0.0146633955,
-0.0189197585,
-0.0152898254,
0.0236409791,
0.0178106669,
0.0446462184,
0.0044876235,
0.0522806533,
-0.0015038254,
0.0291403662,
-0.0175564848,
-0.0260712896,
0.0619003363,
-0.0028162147,
-0.0125590805,
0.0598960146,
0.026763238,
0.0177579653,
0.0203622859,
-0.1100244671,
0.0385219827,
-0.0093335165,
-0.0541461036,
0.0507598482,
-0.0207190383,
0.0669372454,
-0.0189573169,
0.0647313073,
0.0038552177,
-0.0116793942,
0.0255658943,
0.0211194884,
-0.0169182364,
0.0140182497,
0.0147131421,
0.0054406296,
-0.0345435292,
0.0234293733,
-0.0144093754,
-0.0184581503,
-0.0002129511,
0.0663961843,
0.0316527598,
-0.0391980857,
0.0231523346,
-0.0407372341,
-0.0587916635,
-0.0166223664,
-0.0115216691,
-0.0514701232,
0.0197371673,
0.0686839595,
0.0042569819,
-0.0061215833,
-0.0100923516,
0.0583916642,
-0.0336764343,
0.013001876,
0.0098003093,
-0.0400917269,
-0.0252793133,
0.0844538286,
0.0261967573,
0.0030780989,
-0.0456009097,
0.0096963951,
-0.022594342,
0.025419049,
0.0261443108,
0.0526991934,
-0.0250055827,
-0.0048986562,
0.0031527819,
0.011387161,
0.0377076827,
-0.0116674872,
0.0226679388,
0.0080239391,
-0.0845322981,
0.0161624048,
-0.0026579357,
-0.0079212971,
-0.0357066579,
-0.0282768235,
0.0184890758,
0.014474649,
-0.0088910041,
-0.0009156613,
-0.0295931976,
-0.0412422195,
-0.0406842194,
0.0302420761,
-0.0301067904,
-0.0232081674,
-0.013707622,
-0.0295874216,
-0.0284564923,
0.0032684617,
0.0107079213,
0.0208475552,
-0.0386724062,
0.0058638798,
0.0221999642,
0.0193802044,
-0.0443372801,
0.0013527093,
-0.0201382153,
0.0308204107,
-0.0087461239,
0.0394661464,
-0.0185636133,
0.0237803422,
-0.0358714983,
0.0444245338,
-0.0319404453,
0.0385851189,
-0.0421687402,
-0.0559114441,
-0.0121949203,
0.0081894863,
-0.0319224074,
-0.0101223085,
-0.0172489099,
-0.0086754607,
-0.0053833202,
-0.0641857386,
-0.0082640843,
0.001486874,
2.494e-7,
-0.0105678849,
0.0441943705,
0.0041319877,
0.0072559142,
0.0272734277,
0.0384144112,
0.0319435224,
0.0231991988,
-0.0092171142,
-0.0837089345,
0.0381253287,
0.0197064113,
0.0333957709,
0.0300697368,
-0.1009293422,
-0.0213895794,
-0.0527589135,
-0.0721190944,
-0.0335648097,
-0.0322481282,
0.0542624183,
0.0896239877,
0.0453604013,
-0.0047338372,
-0.0064179553,
0.0089864573,
0.0317170992,
-0.0342307426,
-0.0016846196,
0.0194500796,
0.0348767117,
-0.0250320751,
-0.0452834703,
-0.0490776375,
-0.0087006222,
0.0222004671,
0.0303712003,
0.0234276876,
0.0239742901,
-0.0845685527,
0.0079392726,
-0.0009709498,
-0.0167033747,
-0.0055803214,
0.0258378852,
-0.040326152,
-0.0115583856,
-0.102383472,
0.0069414,
0.0269705597,
0.0065988386,
-0.0394996777,
-0.0297404993,
-0.0120205283,
-0.0054304842,
-0.0151337907,
0.0089051798,
-0.0434433185,
0.0068249702,
0.0081922254,
-0.0447910316,
-0.0247514825,
-0.003355776,
0.0011412465,
0.0013080443,
-0.0343841575,
0.0479621924,
1.580542842e-34,
0.0649841204,
0.0232353956,
-0.0012457815,
0.0124004576,
0.0502953827,
0.0350710414,
0.0197813753,
-0.029971702,
0.0428307988,
-0.0246236809,
-0.0119037302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04215v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04215v2 | Hybrid Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Real-time Composition Assistance | 2023-08-08T12:27:20 | 2024-02-05T14:55:19 | Menglin Xia, Xuchao Zhang, Camille Couturier, Guoqing Zheng, Saravan Rajmohan, Victor Ruhle | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DC | Retrieval augmentation enhances performance of traditional language models by
incorporating additional context. However, the computational demands for
retrieval augmented large language models (LLMs) pose a challenge when applying
them to real-time tasks, such as composition assistance. To address this
limitation, we propose the Hybrid Retrieval-Augmented Generation (HybridRAG)
framework, a novel approach that efficiently combines a cloud-based LLM with a
smaller, client-side, language model through retrieval augmented memory. This
integration enables the client model to generate effective responses,
benefiting from the LLM's capabilities and contextual information.
Additionally, through an asynchronous memory update mechanism, the client model
can deliver real-time completions swiftly to user inputs without the need to
wait for responses from the cloud. Our experiments on five benchmark datasets
demonstrate that HybridRAG significantly improves utility over client-only
models while maintaining low latency. | [
0.0514556803,
0.0168595519,
-0.0291923564,
-0.0047134208,
-0.0157786347,
-0.015672693,
0.0205332525,
-0.0306304805,
-0.0149574159,
-0.0228320993,
-0.0226033404,
-0.0843264163,
-0.0120208021,
0.0255915783,
0.0044375914,
-0.0085712606,
0.0288829003,
-0.0375048108,
-0.0188060831,
0.0052615493,
-0.0050838627,
0.0064152973,
-0.0149545623,
0.0782833025,
-0.0186146144,
0.0118916715,
-0.0387553796,
0.0232090876,
-0.0320945047,
0.0088978056,
-0.0233683977,
0.0561578088,
0.0255140867,
0.0543704964,
0.0000017718,
-0.0427320972,
-0.021964008,
-0.0108899968,
-0.0160232577,
-0.0414536111,
0.0541044362,
0.0223924853,
-0.0272626765,
0.0308417287,
-0.013644862,
0.0220408887,
0.0513218828,
-0.0198576767,
0.0446351804,
0.0452172607,
-0.0038445853,
-0.017564822,
-0.0090594087,
-0.021316329,
0.0199040379,
0.0117461616,
-0.0025572078,
-0.0309730805,
0.0610185936,
0.0057230098,
0.0111088501,
0.0682751238,
0.0369871259,
-0.0463693738,
0.0580311865,
0.0345063582,
-0.0727928802,
-0.004540496,
0.0055653998,
0.0431123786,
0.0474461205,
-0.0020893288,
0.0121338665,
-0.0056713712,
-0.0165182333,
0.0127670998,
-0.0508284904,
-0.0105611086,
-0.0350621268,
-0.0097851064,
-0.0393323973,
-0.0520666167,
0.0416972227,
-0.001695514,
0.0244282,
0.0468310602,
0.0251936372,
-0.0294303074,
-0.0201487243,
-0.0025855352,
0.0142272115,
-0.0617581569,
0.0423291661,
0.0653018281,
-0.0472748205,
0.0065694931,
-0.0455501005,
-0.0795384124,
0.0136411702,
-0.0016600452,
0.0796837136,
0.0255627893,
0.0016801551,
0.0514839515,
-0.0130342739,
0.0208519567,
0.0012400307,
-0.0504868068,
-0.0393453613,
-0.0128137423,
-0.0302998777,
-0.0480973013,
-0.0705204457,
0.038245827,
-0.0190104954,
-0.0593063459,
-0.029983988,
0.0413024239,
-0.0119030429,
0.0382165536,
0.0386220366,
0.0108527457,
-0.0768637508,
0.0020769788,
0.015824236,
0.0164541807,
0.0127927,
0.0013869072,
0.0485412031,
-0.0429605991,
0.0063204323,
-0.0400927253,
0.0136843044,
-0.000127407,
0.012810709,
0.0256188605,
-0.0161236729,
-0.0383517817,
0.0228587482,
-0.0618326291,
-0.0118348524,
-0.0415175185,
-0.0134127317,
-0.0729767978,
0.0390642099,
0.0136410147,
-0.044114016,
-0.0016897446,
0.0107997982,
0.0475642048,
-0.0056184968,
0.0312453434,
-0.0098480294,
0.0478075482,
0.0274054389,
0.0111769745,
-0.0306489337,
0.0688181818,
0.0426903702,
0.0174008645,
0.0377630591,
0.0152813625,
0.0304468013,
0.0463663824,
0.0087067224,
-0.0134303654,
-0.0325331017,
-0.0096960301,
-0.0373775922,
0.0661145076,
0.0001456138,
0.028280193,
-0.0111736301,
0.0106436331,
0.0683706179,
-0.0081258817,
0.0542737357,
0.0013982762,
0.0454400517,
0.0263255574,
-0.0139182629,
0.01119278,
-0.0127776926,
0.0762087852,
-0.013589574,
0.0425795801,
0.0740825683,
0.042849917,
0.0032518397,
0.0046421103,
-0.0297646224,
-0.0020100249,
-0.0277811419,
0.0221786331,
0.0477670543,
0.0220423173,
-0.0403622836,
0.0539447814,
-0.0218550134,
-0.0838721693,
0.0233866833,
-0.0118752252,
0.0231048986,
0.098298192,
0.1018787101,
-0.0506736636,
-0.0207384117,
0.0139964595,
0.0065280641,
0.0427923873,
0.0312312935,
-0.0213007201,
0.0024510231,
-0.0268320851,
-0.0115776835,
-0.0086507862,
-0.0102871358,
0.0047007082,
0.0306160133,
0.0032654572,
0.0345438197,
-0.0131845139,
0.0018616327,
-0.0090383198,
-0.0060138525,
-0.0210731681,
0.0022148748,
0.0232335497,
-0.014211203,
0.0142756049,
-0.0300414972,
0.035644602,
0.0201013163,
-0.0261294488,
-0.0315563008,
0.0161552038,
-0.0608267561,
-0.0042642695,
0.0178784095,
0.0574440025,
0.0144348424,
-0.0009919968,
-0.0077042114,
-0.0493486114,
0.0213817861,
-0.0350648835,
0.0535075814,
-0.0284048747,
0.0179213565,
-0.0002208386,
-0.0198407192,
0.0081579946,
0.0193507839,
0.0180828106,
0.0221064389,
0.0468078554,
0.0145078041,
0.0045289793,
-0.0324289501,
-0.0348138213,
0.0458064452,
0.0031007212,
0.0087232701,
-0.0039471574,
-0.050862506,
-0.0359256566,
-0.017453026,
-0.0987321809,
0.01520022,
-0.0154880732,
-0.0210215095,
-0.0046112617,
0.0415244475,
-0.0009903169,
-0.01912589,
-0.0125461761,
0.0203114543,
0.0200056937,
0.0632014796,
-0.029512858,
0.0175963603,
-0.0079467343,
-0.0392117277,
-0.0227777176,
0.022212496,
-0.0101896338,
0.0101936543,
-0.0439897738,
-0.0054398719,
0.0060828379,
-0.0694674626,
0.0471505262,
0.0010414817,
-0.0068056593,
0.0203268677,
-0.0499424748,
0.0650933459,
0.0513376258,
-0.0023517373,
-0.0176732559,
0.0847242102,
-0.0363226086,
-0.0389379486,
0.037113931,
-0.0316588134,
-0.042157758,
0.0121963006,
0.0066992296,
-0.0141306855,
0.042569574,
0.0148688024,
-0.0215360615,
-0.0195847936,
-0.0030319318,
-0.0310180001,
0.0100347055,
-0.0447001867,
-0.0370275006,
-0.0599008314,
0.0265470184,
-0.0236736238,
-0.0522027276,
0.0744332299,
-0.0368009247,
-0.0223112479,
-0.0051760837,
-0.0163211301,
-0.0172240939,
0.0723639429,
-0.0064618001,
0.009023143,
-0.0651510656,
-0.0231020655,
-0.0301706307,
0.0744226277,
0.045492053,
-0.0862403512,
-0.0235933773,
-0.0321443975,
0.0190832652,
-0.0090221316,
-0.0482737459,
-0.0118407942,
0.0205131676,
0.0012232157,
0.0167439133,
0.0158943329,
-0.0425752774,
0.0099369921,
0.0080534983,
0.030604424,
0.0819620714,
-0.020417532,
-0.0043314979,
-0.0255237333,
0.0204498526,
0.0415266603,
0.014236154,
-0.0183929335,
-0.0110736853,
0.0060468996,
0.021826202,
0.0799573436,
-0.0421519242,
-0.0122585297,
-0.0241268519,
0.058631558,
0.0098912483,
-0.0179152377,
0.0435239561,
0.0089609548,
-0.0794480368,
-0.0386122465,
0.0736023858,
0.0494829826,
-0.0706342459,
-0.0339867286,
-0.0039785355,
-0.0014262288,
0.0344845615,
0.0323050991,
-0.0625394285,
-0.0094800759,
0.0687398463,
0.0513094813,
0.0086105168,
-0.0165395644,
-0.0339906216,
-0.1046333015,
0.0585224964,
-0.0116400467,
-0.016515011,
0.0014673227,
-0.0207372699,
0.0221817326,
0.0669283792,
-0.0402246416,
0.0388425291,
-0.0028070027,
0.0043611829,
-0.015892528,
-0.015388607,
-0.0199372638,
-0.016369056,
-0.0173034761,
0.0305745397,
0.0629129857,
0.0392415076,
0.037879128,
-0.0384305492,
0.0440435447,
0.0199164748,
0.0153942406,
-0.0043078489,
0.0038446349,
-0.000051684,
0.0082729552,
0.0006536174,
-0.0134951482,
0.0044815536,
-0.016609,
-0.0319165699,
0.0583804995,
-0.0093879914,
0.0204596836,
-0.0410711318,
0.0217335653,
0.0314187743,
0.0410517193,
0.0170525238,
-0.0212950651,
-0.0104087684,
0.0089656077,
-0.0052616228,
-0.0731189549,
0.0287072212,
0.0105666555,
0.0074842647,
0.0239881184,
-0.0443194285,
0.0135031482,
0.0257751234,
0.0274122898,
0.0131896427,
0.0604344495,
-0.0175026264,
-0.0333232805,
-0.0937534273,
-0.0013447271,
-0.0041191173,
0.0424571931,
-0.0322792791,
-0.0358989201,
-0.0026398369,
-0.0596770421,
-0.0081642596,
0.0056046946,
-0.0867677033,
-0.0613254793,
0.0055936445,
0.0236573163,
0.0175234489,
0.0125268567,
-0.0098379077,
-0.0844849497,
0.0229971036,
0.0554394908,
-0.0387144685,
0.0436605401,
-0.0206482429,
-0.0144728832,
-0.0021484273,
0.0224732589,
-0.0924515724,
-0.0184629392,
-0.0024671534,
0.0630606413,
0.0627098233,
-0.0274932049,
-0.0013718558,
0.0103262952,
0.0149746267,
-0.0094573824,
0.0417442545,
-0.0566364042,
0.0343750641,
-0.0232283659,
-0.0067665367,
-0.0416722856,
-0.0098501593,
-0.0076413956,
-0.0227359608,
0.014260374,
0.0064900964,
0.0121912332,
0.0250455029,
-0.0307775233,
-0.0192410313,
-0.0113215251,
-0.0789981857,
0.1014810652,
0.0141379377,
-0.0040052151,
0.0224615261,
0.0103228372,
0.0116437646,
-0.0200226121,
0.0312071238,
0.0204248447,
-0.0068784333,
-0.0210653469,
0.0072361091,
-0.0781309977,
-0.0534428284,
-0.0397040583,
-0.0052324827,
0.0695384294,
-0.0019838826,
0.0415263139,
-0.0241218265,
-0.018311508,
-0.0407208055,
0.020406086,
0.0160535499,
-0.0882931873,
-0.0085264528,
0.0237849299,
0.0176575743,
0.0556289032,
0.0818577111,
-0.0650084242,
0.0155579355,
-0.058168035,
-0.0332751684,
0.0061181779,
-0.002313653,
-0.0143900197,
0.0623125285,
-0.0119211413,
-0.0198146272,
-0.0375821777,
-0.0660716593,
0.0273913518,
0.0141719105,
-0.0406921245,
-0.0445488319,
0.0466222316,
0.0532391705,
0.0224031676,
-0.0230813697,
-0.0396831185,
0.0205647908,
-0.0626219437,
0.0053880261,
0.0087468531,
-5.827527938e-33,
-0.0704222918,
-0.051833,
0.0372571237,
-0.0251554158,
-0.0552593693,
0.0207638629,
-0.0607395172,
-0.0155451158,
0.0509551242,
-0.0416698828,
-0.0266940333,
0.040627107,
0.007399946,
0.0159018375,
0.017378334,
0.0288080573,
0.055154331,
-0.012338452,
-0.0460878164,
0.0395059958,
0.0466464683,
0.0395597927,
-0.010628378,
-0.0486471094,
-0.0067323046,
0.001516428,
0.0357523598,
0.0102970637,
-0.0203473493,
0.0610869378,
0.003418732,
0.0635223761,
0.0025000353,
-0.0253788531,
0.0016575075,
0.0123267667,
-0.032953281,
-0.0036501009,
-0.0045024678,
-0.0170739051,
-0.0459852405,
-0.0078065866,
0.034961205,
0.0109636737,
-0.0168569442,
0.0074861208,
0.0111513268,
-0.001960601,
-0.0692239478,
-0.0999902412,
-0.0559810996,
-0.0128253521,
0.0131351287,
0.0068070833,
0.0449250117,
0.0305694807,
0.0196298473,
0.0120431362,
-0.0426483825,
0.0183537956,
-0.022384122,
0.0587189272,
0.0630856231,
0.0183986016,
0.0001946497,
0.050492961,
0.0177921802,
-0.0054174419,
-0.0391979739,
-0.0176873431,
0.0328659117,
0.0261873435,
0.016779108,
0.0206035748,
0.0263446216,
-0.0124461083,
0.0678151324,
0.0063598012,
-0.0014865188,
0.0078463601,
0.0505700111,
0.032701388,
0.0002262583,
-0.0080142841,
-0.0429247208,
0.0007016038,
-0.0535020605,
-0.0366406105,
0.062458545,
0.0422605276,
0.0269331075,
-0.0251108389,
0.0321723185,
0.015782645,
0.0043736557,
-0.0036168438,
-0.0455717891,
0.0367635675,
-0.0157570485,
0.0166812539,
-0.0189604983,
0.0124986619,
0.03911791,
0.0002952965,
-0.0091955718,
0.0210670922,
0.0069392081,
0.0578564554,
-0.0558530912,
0.0171920601,
-0.0504144169,
0.0323341228,
0.0032594372,
-0.0149534233,
0.0678980276,
-0.0028023147,
-0.0125455819,
0.0606012568,
0.0114218919,
0.0069286753,
-0.037157692,
-0.0710718557,
-0.0140905529,
-0.0148250395,
-0.0155871818,
0.0456479862,
-0.0097102514,
0.0338313766,
0.0248790048,
-0.0325364843,
-0.0259501226,
0.0024985771,
2.66e-7,
0.0238213874,
0.0212078933,
0.0078979554,
0.0229710601,
0.0214084983,
-0.0308430009,
-0.0313135125,
-0.0090700416,
0.0331244878,
0.0653656498,
0.0315062292,
0.0143670393,
0.0807404667,
0.0317407027,
-0.1189714968,
-0.0103614526,
-0.1134587452,
0.0237681121,
-0.0804867223,
-0.041336365,
0.0285948887,
0.018512737,
-0.0175367761,
-0.0264246799,
-0.009851072,
-0.0443230011,
0.0573492758,
0.0022764809,
0.0209716801,
-0.0411480255,
0.0349154808,
0.0280372538,
-0.0169116799,
-0.0254682899,
-0.054747846,
0.0117841102,
0.0255533904,
0.007323477,
-0.0108684683,
-0.018194994,
0.0403206572,
0.0033208728,
0.0146506047,
-0.0263216514,
0.0362795517,
-0.012565772,
0.0396207646,
-0.0371819586,
-0.0139736785,
-0.0470699109,
-0.0326723196,
-0.0159971602,
-0.0184296109,
0.0059014228,
0.003018223,
0.0074393791,
0.0084409248,
-0.0818774179,
-0.0344392173,
0.0056638755,
-0.0448095053,
-0.019890951,
-0.0596029647,
0.0096539818,
-0.0424988531,
-0.0512261465,
-0.0137184532,
2.60462273e-34,
0.0357740112,
0.0091850143,
0.0239617303,
0.0431404598,
0.0284891557,
-0.0055497591,
0.0135145281,
0.0266706832,
-0.0106057869,
-0.085710384,
-0.0704152361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04180v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04180v1 | Studying Socially Unacceptable Discourse Classification (SUD) through different eyes: "Are we on the same page ?" | 2023-08-08T10:42:33 | 2023-08-08T10:42:33 | Bruno Machado Carneiro, Michele Linardi, Julien Longhi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We study Socially Unacceptable Discourse (SUD) characterization and detection
in online text. We first build and present a novel corpus that contains a large
variety of manually annotated texts from different online sources used so far
in state-of-the-art Machine learning (ML) SUD detection solutions. This global
context allows us to test the generalization ability of SUD classifiers that
acquire knowledge around the same SUD categories, but from different contexts.
From this perspective, we can analyze how (possibly) different annotation
modalities influence SUD learning by discussing open challenges and open
research directions. We also provide several data insights which can support
domain experts in the annotation task. | [
0.1037934944,
0.0110375928,
-0.0005509469,
0.0114753311,
0.0029451875,
0.0371572487,
0.0249424707,
0.0215464383,
0.0140003338,
-0.0941562057,
-0.0276627466,
-0.0010642842,
-0.0085827792,
0.0145498561,
-0.0241784863,
-0.0078945272,
0.0071468689,
0.0347629488,
0.0582948625,
-0.0368227549,
0.0501235649,
0.0120643647,
0.015366626,
0.0245614368,
-0.0290804915,
-0.0095600123,
0.0693956614,
-0.0133555848,
0.0147510031,
-0.0117567265,
0.0978327766,
0.0763180032,
0.0313047096,
0.0668879673,
0.0000014645,
-0.0398626626,
0.0178704914,
-0.0043987292,
0.0087268054,
0.0024615042,
0.0367329754,
0.0166387446,
0.004670165,
0.0527100861,
-0.0671805367,
0.0112482309,
0.0418115035,
0.0651208609,
0.0713724494,
0.0613045022,
-0.0105325487,
-0.0029227068,
-0.0455854274,
0.0180273782,
-0.0685024336,
0.0071747531,
0.0539119914,
0.0177450329,
-0.0350598358,
0.0208140854,
0.0040781149,
0.029167641,
-0.0146048376,
-0.0110851591,
0.0455834232,
-0.0321499072,
-0.0568037219,
-0.0469160713,
0.0140386065,
0.0477341153,
0.0541219898,
-0.0474223495,
0.0116079757,
0.0261830185,
-0.0114176096,
0.0088124918,
0.0003900142,
0.0194924697,
-0.0188663024,
0.0281572603,
-0.0006321767,
0.022335574,
0.044445388,
0.0747936442,
0.0645526424,
0.0346481651,
-0.0661994815,
-0.0092362678,
0.0145753277,
0.0071152807,
-0.0496806055,
-0.0163928121,
0.0356749594,
0.0186699759,
-0.0222179964,
0.0264187306,
-0.0262196772,
-0.055569537,
0.0541437678,
-0.0924608409,
0.0366575643,
-0.0159349665,
-0.0013066125,
0.0092181982,
0.0118668769,
-0.0100137712,
-0.001172738,
0.002101714,
0.0175257176,
0.0080568427,
-0.0239246078,
-0.0097427145,
-0.0038738239,
0.0135243703,
-0.0269572642,
0.0021015441,
-0.0159641504,
-0.0077373912,
-0.0632390007,
-0.0026522023,
-0.0074017993,
0.0093789278,
-0.0134210624,
0.038489297,
-0.0207749307,
-0.025179958,
-0.0370693132,
0.035314966,
-0.0542459674,
-0.0327393785,
0.0468191691,
0.0127309784,
0.0014209262,
0.0137758348,
0.009845552,
0.0468720496,
0.0169668179,
-0.0154520879,
-0.0175743308,
-0.0384635292,
-0.044159472,
-0.0155809484,
0.0118301297,
-0.0411498174,
-0.0027261674,
-0.02121583,
-0.0529944077,
-0.0519567803,
0.0442601629,
0.0231142901,
-0.016699601,
0.025981836,
-0.0143153993,
-0.0557296053,
0.0762461796,
0.0337979048,
-0.005094103,
0.0686899498,
0.0093984827,
-0.0223837588,
0.059746176,
0.0110137258,
0.0160704814,
0.0391686261,
0.0365521237,
-0.0308730192,
0.0331592783,
0.025664039,
0.0017426552,
-0.0435761847,
0.0096598435,
0.0471330769,
0.005672886,
-0.075392656,
0.026643008,
0.0664848015,
-0.0668511167,
0.0308710206,
0.0321003608,
0.0403954498,
0.0111950189,
-0.0107886903,
-0.0160151348,
-0.055825606,
-0.0246925168,
-0.069893688,
0.0019188744,
0.0048839026,
-0.0121179363,
-0.0724016279,
-0.0181722902,
-0.0094296215,
0.0843754709,
-0.0564966276,
0.0391093567,
0.0211927835,
-0.0191441327,
-0.0122768627,
0.0620610937,
-0.055512771,
-0.0015302674,
-0.012406663,
0.0292728171,
0.0199762993,
0.0322632492,
-0.0454739071,
0.0208045673,
-0.0772115737,
0.0531333275,
0.0582323112,
0.003819753,
-0.0183890089,
-0.0145681296,
-0.0237189438,
-0.0169241149,
0.0029716676,
-0.0036923429,
-0.00817136,
0.0478676111,
-0.0447516516,
-0.0108603863,
0.0415914282,
-0.0641658455,
0.0169002432,
-0.0124983182,
-0.0310228672,
-0.027154563,
0.0064630811,
0.0575593598,
0.0149876587,
-0.0159476567,
-0.0607335046,
0.0060451967,
-0.0022407416,
-0.033473853,
-0.0021989385,
-0.0337454714,
0.0082926229,
0.015153205,
-0.0379969999,
-0.0391885489,
0.0194706898,
-0.0095508862,
0.0339830816,
0.0321211442,
-0.06172093,
0.004972741,
-0.0380444489,
-0.0548093691,
-0.0764692947,
0.0253960229,
-0.0480684116,
0.0443015769,
-0.0195150133,
0.0065882304,
0.0200973377,
-0.0858061537,
0.0253453646,
0.0059257885,
-0.0411376618,
-0.047813531,
-0.0334606729,
0.0443642512,
0.0395227633,
-0.0174287111,
-0.0143392319,
0.0009785539,
-0.0971670672,
-0.0555514358,
-0.055156514,
0.0241542943,
0.0313564427,
-0.0413091332,
0.0002279259,
0.0070815459,
-0.0073233917,
-0.0440221988,
-0.0082561234,
0.0141591197,
0.0457551144,
-0.0406840257,
0.0096708173,
-0.0259460416,
0.0139931152,
-0.0360674001,
0.0489145815,
0.012318274,
-0.040172819,
-0.0035608653,
-0.0121440701,
-0.066456832,
0.0452664495,
-0.0168043207,
-0.0447673649,
0.0319840647,
0.071417518,
-0.0194648374,
0.0724191293,
0.0674268901,
0.087468192,
0.0064706011,
0.0064876168,
-0.0098007442,
-0.0076367892,
0.0050248178,
0.0501729101,
-0.0613411292,
-0.0210367702,
0.005612372,
0.0518766604,
0.0023936213,
-0.0168897565,
-0.0536918603,
0.0240866896,
-0.0545198508,
-0.0622087047,
-0.0234051924,
-0.0436960571,
-0.0125727728,
-0.0158629194,
-0.0260061976,
-0.0233906917,
0.0513301902,
0.0050330055,
0.0179903377,
-0.0249576624,
-0.0543755256,
0.0114077078,
0.0371132903,
0.005598784,
0.0187921599,
0.0085567757,
-0.0285345651,
-0.0026327982,
-0.0050114924,
0.0415560603,
-0.0280010644,
0.0243595019,
-0.0165765807,
0.0016346636,
0.0297660604,
-0.0560688898,
-0.0308614299,
-0.0440057479,
-0.017321812,
-0.0277489722,
-0.010076548,
0.0063588936,
0.0166637767,
-0.0082805101,
-0.0228278879,
0.0066891341,
0.0133448932,
0.0070922682,
0.0258750413,
-0.0202093944,
-0.0067039961,
0.0244896319,
-0.0008683451,
0.011012841,
-0.0116740717,
0.0802871436,
-0.0492939241,
-0.0166502688,
0.0112370746,
-0.0065420298,
0.0026580978,
0.006304868,
-0.0258868244,
-0.0206000973,
0.0539151132,
-0.0373422839,
-0.0057273121,
0.0820494667,
0.0270067453,
0.0250399653,
-0.0013424976,
-0.009753475,
0.0020116265,
0.0172141846,
-0.0340223908,
-0.0395399034,
0.0154630747,
-0.026596684,
0.0357946195,
-0.0941647887,
-0.0548426211,
0.0034353721,
-0.0232622828,
0.0083472962,
-0.0165768303,
-0.054566294,
0.0206467323,
-0.0085278321,
0.0244004149,
-0.0139910625,
0.0383314602,
-0.0467509478,
0.0173013881,
-0.0062084529,
0.0332000032,
-0.0737546384,
-0.000532263,
0.0255931411,
0.0154119795,
0.0595934466,
-0.0171975326,
0.0756441131,
-0.0125395749,
0.0008327622,
0.0601499043,
-0.0005053796,
-0.0371056534,
-0.0472358018,
0.0524110459,
-0.0006412042,
-0.0380793922,
-0.0202239864,
0.0439487062,
-0.0003495532,
-0.0164925568,
-0.0183947049,
0.0425817072,
0.0347110741,
-0.003037306,
-0.0359190479,
0.0516021848,
0.0402641818,
0.0368077718,
0.0233026613,
-0.0613049567,
-0.0046991426,
-0.0765656903,
0.003522208,
-0.0023007554,
-0.0385685191,
-0.0313668326,
0.0238786899,
-0.0249520577,
-0.0635739788,
-0.0518355109,
-0.0044075293,
-0.0216385815,
0.012400452,
-0.0073412461,
0.0301418249,
0.0186580122,
-0.048197493,
-0.0374965705,
-0.0109170806,
0.0077470485,
-0.0072755483,
-0.0120438095,
-0.0240852907,
-0.0102190832,
-0.0400418118,
-0.0049559665,
0.006604956,
-0.0568522625,
0.060858123,
0.0215285737,
0.0068781008,
0.0058365925,
0.0063426779,
-0.0300380737,
0.0777109787,
0.0775783136,
-0.0052739852,
0.0212444868,
0.0773815289,
0.019639235,
-0.0056815906,
0.0203531757,
0.0175300986,
0.0229673833,
-0.0077024782,
-0.0533248782,
-0.0521416143,
0.0412900522,
-0.0622902811,
-0.0148281157,
0.0319969915,
0.0436656214,
-0.0575594939,
-0.0321500264,
-0.052476082,
-0.0165653583,
-0.0504577048,
-0.0018407354,
0.0043601785,
-0.0042681582,
0.0075602769,
-0.0409267284,
0.0315334573,
-0.0486695953,
0.0893972367,
-0.0253592655,
0.0040175901,
0.0752238408,
0.0604419895,
-0.032479208,
-0.0117751854,
-0.0302181095,
0.0271754265,
0.0131557677,
0.0149343247,
0.0225749891,
0.0173233263,
0.0190687198,
-0.0026758553,
0.0441916771,
-0.0040185908,
-0.0258440375,
0.0290501826,
-0.0383105166,
0.0098744361,
-0.0100523187,
-0.0397288427,
0.048466906,
0.001148403,
-0.023542555,
-0.0199314281,
0.0258874912,
-0.0187621061,
-0.0466858819,
-0.0102625368,
0.005022407,
-0.0459767655,
0.0440252274,
0.0411494076,
-0.0137489922,
0.013319809,
0.0629137456,
-0.0310803223,
-0.0354645662,
-0.0380408093,
0.0233281646,
0.0093811741,
0.0170955695,
0.0281298291,
-0.014974121,
-0.0143621732,
0.0046146745,
-0.0318306871,
0.0091292001,
-0.0290651992,
-0.0156612564,
0.0778652802,
0.0087691098,
0.0115165794,
-0.0332111306,
-0.0445149168,
0.0080023473,
-0.0177120753,
-0.0297028013,
-5.134278675e-33,
-0.0130044501,
-0.067916289,
-0.0244726148,
0.0888844877,
0.0126056438,
0.0226339158,
0.0143273398,
0.0071251178,
0.0004284173,
0.0416429266,
0.0273700673,
0.0304978099,
-0.0126681086,
0.0005082338,
-0.0195763875,
-0.034398824,
0.0456413813,
-0.0359147079,
-0.060264498,
0.0011292748,
0.0823842809,
-0.0018336962,
0.0444807112,
-0.1154198945,
0.0731140301,
0.0091656074,
-0.0296253618,
0.0251127779,
0.0185205936,
0.0506957546,
-0.0142370155,
0.0814876184,
0.023280194,
0.0417409725,
0.0108169708,
0.0871231481,
-0.0367416069,
-0.0078203101,
-0.0028967967,
0.0145448521,
-0.0285709649,
-0.0131517658,
0.048643481,
-0.0204854477,
-0.0469616093,
-0.0436449312,
0.067011632,
-0.0103953676,
0.0312624611,
-0.0394132994,
-0.0529895499,
0.0123983771,
-0.0179145485,
-0.0083617428,
-0.0141807524,
0.0497127809,
0.0362368077,
-0.0217285659,
-0.038701959,
0.0187569801,
-0.026101198,
-0.0187197775,
-0.0109925037,
-0.0383101217,
0.0301233679,
0.0737451091,
-0.0238819215,
0.071953319,
-0.0270479396,
-0.0331548415,
0.0267792977,
0.0084657688,
0.0324942842,
0.0275167003,
-0.0209706314,
-0.0404275432,
-0.0563251823,
-0.0307762399,
0.0397513807,
0.0120069711,
0.0000944556,
-0.0452222116,
-0.0393825881,
-0.046574641,
-0.0274508446,
-0.0643538684,
0.0113818413,
-0.0072916937,
-0.0028939741,
-0.0465642288,
-0.0318477936,
0.0010962273,
-0.0122443149,
-0.039485652,
-0.0286359433,
0.0381801203,
0.0107495394,
-0.0185328107,
0.0503424704,
0.0056305295,
-0.0387128107,
-0.0121691572,
0.0075320979,
-0.0429753289,
0.0405448787,
-0.025374867,
0.0743147731,
0.0348230898,
-0.044314228,
0.0042099925,
0.0188094638,
0.0592204891,
-0.0414142981,
0.0688167885,
0.0097422935,
0.0176511593,
0.0073614246,
0.008574497,
0.0222412031,
0.0495695285,
-0.0375764892,
-0.0253203362,
-0.0460967869,
-0.0117169283,
-0.0128567051,
-0.0332554206,
-0.0058027185,
0.0171003621,
-0.00207582,
-0.0503727384,
0.0369122773,
-0.0525031202,
2.164e-7,
0.0212352425,
0.0758158341,
0.0050574155,
-0.003420271,
0.0491668954,
0.0334079452,
0.0522396378,
0.0467214361,
0.0097861011,
-0.0358338542,
0.0051422124,
0.0254833531,
0.0209514908,
0.0491146445,
-0.016000146,
-0.0611299872,
-0.1040116176,
0.0073375474,
-0.0105535211,
-0.0004284234,
0.0071976925,
0.0408335328,
0.020755535,
-0.0298446268,
-0.0166425612,
-0.0326291136,
0.0483982824,
-0.0669358671,
0.0219587702,
0.0076215696,
0.0463745631,
-0.0163382124,
0.0435830355,
-0.0031595654,
0.0066855019,
0.0233186446,
0.0164041966,
0.0609294064,
0.0200339053,
-0.0032693692,
0.0024853093,
0.0079670455,
0.0089986622,
-0.0029616447,
-0.0089895977,
-0.0384607501,
-0.0246231221,
-0.0423598103,
-0.0097881937,
-0.0253294557,
0.0745056197,
0.006505698,
0.0058177612,
0.007939212,
0.0108184488,
-0.0320083238,
0.030213695,
-0.0463930033,
-0.021542633,
-0.0253286827,
-0.0321274027,
-0.0320496596,
0.0159392562,
-0.0172764231,
-0.0003680429,
0.0135438945,
0.0786890015,
1.583197003e-34,
0.0315536112,
-0.0570337065,
0.004787086,
-0.0258656964,
0.0340637341,
0.036571715,
-0.0272761807,
-0.0016818898,
0.0413966365,
0.0079614958,
0.034881562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04176v1 | On Monotonic Aggregation for Open-domain QA | 2023-08-08T10:23:04 | 2023-08-08T10:23:04 | Sang-eun Han, Yeonseok Jeong, Seung-won Hwang, Kyungjae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Question answering (QA) is a critical task for speech-based retrieval from
knowledge sources, by sifting only the answers without requiring to read
supporting documents. Specifically, open-domain QA aims to answer user
questions on unrestricted knowledge sources. Ideally, adding a source should
not decrease the accuracy, but we find this property (denoted as
"monotonicity") does not hold for current state-of-the-art methods. We identify
the cause, and based on that we propose Judge-Specialist framework. Our
framework consists of (1) specialist retrievers/readers to cover individual
sources, and (2) judge, a dedicated language model to select the final answer.
Our experiments show that our framework not only ensures monotonicity, but also
outperforms state-of-the-art multi-source QA methods on Natural Questions.
Additionally, we show that our models robustly preserve the monotonicity
against noise from speech recognition. We publicly release our code and
setting. | [
0.0354455076,
0.0900520161,
0.0207930952,
0.0176050961,
-0.0293609891,
-0.0291156992,
0.0070371302,
-0.0291866194,
0.0003452587,
-0.0201212075,
-0.0023518391,
-0.0020631459,
-0.0260256585,
0.0280876793,
-0.0150084607,
-0.0362261385,
0.0500714071,
-0.0700003728,
0.0306521375,
-0.0333624929,
0.0222152937,
0.0223209243,
-0.0139387362,
0.0066760536,
0.0196584109,
-0.0109068397,
-0.0095440121,
-0.0319889337,
-0.0003108733,
0.0365112349,
0.0111235669,
0.0405500643,
0.0122002466,
0.007391755,
0.0000018349,
-0.0435078666,
-0.0380505025,
0.0059981989,
-0.0220647845,
-0.0310085509,
-0.0471304543,
0.0145509858,
0.024315862,
0.0392037556,
-0.0394963734,
-0.0076946528,
0.0131086288,
0.0310720243,
0.09192238,
0.0505213514,
0.0102769677,
-0.0182273388,
0.0552370399,
-0.0055944729,
0.0155465528,
-0.0710174739,
0.0255905949,
0.0277018454,
0.0423636399,
0.0078781908,
-0.0079638278,
0.0362139866,
0.0000921959,
-0.0052929749,
0.011391242,
0.0136310356,
-0.0279189087,
0.0154397273,
-0.0051850341,
0.100414589,
0.0314317048,
0.013308567,
0.021156637,
0.0133685153,
0.0165522434,
0.0448277667,
-0.0394018777,
0.02366798,
-0.0251257308,
-0.0106701097,
-0.0419695191,
0.0205674563,
-0.0342635661,
0.0152050685,
-0.024563903,
0.0620388202,
0.0014654254,
-0.0410788693,
0.0292364564,
0.004329355,
-0.0102796406,
-0.0263981167,
0.029005222,
0.0557551645,
-0.0139057105,
0.035863217,
-0.0018286417,
-0.0290770438,
0.0171396658,
-0.0094907042,
-0.0336005837,
0.0237807315,
-0.0451120958,
0.0936910585,
0.0315543152,
0.0246854536,
-0.0155005902,
-0.0051223328,
-0.0661106557,
-0.0648913309,
-0.0064545455,
-0.0100089805,
-0.03849243,
0.0731854364,
-0.061175257,
-0.012387611,
0.015024039,
0.0154035557,
0.0076275808,
-0.006688091,
0.0043615219,
0.0435158908,
-0.0219272953,
-0.0033984317,
-0.0316370763,
0.0660364479,
-0.0723377094,
0.0315743163,
0.006155564,
-0.0567702688,
-0.0416949838,
0.0002618559,
0.013467174,
-0.0056925328,
-0.0093209259,
0.0566990115,
-0.0241635721,
-0.0236780234,
-0.0063299644,
-0.0363961458,
-0.0154740717,
-0.0536126606,
-0.025217751,
-0.0692621171,
0.0639361963,
0.0241025593,
-0.0216793604,
-0.0800562799,
-0.0030428579,
0.0551087297,
-0.0396385007,
0.0435559824,
-0.026597362,
0.019241713,
0.0576406084,
0.0241846777,
-0.0209388807,
0.0761228055,
0.008907483,
-0.0302176625,
0.0631838515,
0.0102382489,
0.0307018254,
0.0116062211,
0.0268529654,
0.0141884284,
0.0327321626,
0.0610515587,
-0.0490062088,
-0.0078722574,
0.0455171131,
0.0645630136,
-0.0185297672,
-0.0484069325,
0.001734818,
0.0790333524,
-0.0175692197,
0.001299699,
-0.0340338722,
0.0400261432,
0.0336880237,
0.0452408157,
-0.0114150904,
0.0270301923,
-0.0282757096,
0.0100271441,
0.0570339113,
0.0033197375,
-0.059994325,
-0.021206066,
0.0072622919,
-0.0007769174,
-0.037267711,
0.0563392229,
0.036209207,
0.0048128166,
-0.0159550644,
0.0445645414,
0.033553727,
-0.0716897696,
0.0023219569,
-0.0114552788,
0.0618866496,
-0.0047283056,
0.0305291861,
-0.0441958047,
-0.002009395,
-0.0089818202,
-0.0022353067,
0.0255241022,
0.0085463738,
-0.0260374472,
0.0219496321,
-0.0460413471,
-0.0270811655,
0.022977801,
-0.0064795245,
0.0383761115,
0.0055044168,
0.0100572053,
0.0188809838,
-0.0281495284,
0.0237999968,
0.0085050594,
-0.0107030952,
-0.018461246,
0.0222230665,
-0.0179588869,
0.0095052663,
0.0442897715,
-0.0176511928,
0.0253973324,
0.0445897207,
-0.0133860251,
-0.0377961099,
0.0106937047,
-0.0324675515,
-0.0126963388,
0.0284814183,
-0.0094545046,
-0.0038545358,
0.0286052097,
-0.0157768037,
-0.0673656166,
0.0151819903,
-0.0352201276,
0.0172223207,
-0.0372701958,
-0.0352908932,
0.0445617624,
-0.0182491168,
-0.0539701022,
0.0603950247,
-0.0025142143,
0.0027945486,
0.0155650033,
0.0028854469,
0.0316413119,
-0.0755802691,
-0.0200345162,
0.0005126917,
-0.0064764689,
0.0598846152,
0.0363089889,
-0.0420510173,
-0.0662169978,
-0.0341693982,
-0.0552673228,
0.0259542484,
-0.0215274673,
0.0316177122,
-0.0096492926,
0.0396507606,
0.0021670915,
-0.037908271,
-0.0735960007,
-0.0354052708,
0.0396282077,
0.0214146506,
0.0098438449,
0.0387602858,
0.0456544608,
-0.0645287931,
-0.0069770305,
0.0036335704,
0.0357340015,
-0.0022943395,
0.033517465,
-0.0505019091,
-0.0045020836,
-0.075889647,
0.0610549115,
-0.0191198643,
0.0161845852,
-0.0085500721,
-0.0428358726,
-0.0090245474,
0.0495750383,
0.0203369968,
-0.0373899266,
0.0177431982,
-0.0034155231,
-0.082678102,
0.0519837849,
-0.0026782434,
-0.0315095633,
0.0046896515,
0.0314990655,
0.0128229447,
0.0306549091,
0.0179199111,
-0.017535679,
-0.0225757323,
0.0429158211,
-0.0029021366,
0.0053438251,
-0.057176467,
-0.0181110054,
-0.0215404481,
0.0427720957,
-0.0028297063,
-0.0090956064,
0.0962199792,
-0.0001771242,
-0.0097529106,
-0.057744015,
-0.0030761466,
-0.0851380676,
0.0241444129,
-0.0541360229,
0.0102629792,
0.0039125793,
-0.0232900139,
-0.0225048494,
-0.016151078,
0.0023644369,
-0.0558727495,
0.0928368941,
-0.0500973724,
0.0422633477,
-0.0151210092,
-0.0741929486,
-0.0652948022,
-0.0049457946,
-0.0263503026,
0.008558657,
-0.0139105748,
-0.0084291762,
-0.0603641681,
-0.0155630494,
0.0445366539,
0.0236634631,
-0.0157734044,
0.0005303638,
-0.0054674917,
0.0791376755,
0.0501254201,
0.0513261706,
0.0036146005,
0.0043825111,
-0.0035064444,
0.0705958381,
0.0663822889,
-0.0078312363,
0.0285374857,
-0.0186823998,
0.0330755152,
-0.0381062552,
0.0134275053,
-0.006925649,
0.0249441639,
-0.0209830441,
0.0066874074,
0.0967706218,
0.0519300252,
-0.023391258,
-0.0463942252,
-0.038775593,
0.0417834446,
0.0110958181,
0.0430416316,
-0.0835203305,
-0.0286819935,
-0.0326913707,
0.092333369,
0.0211508926,
-0.0346915461,
-0.0277344342,
-0.1037395671,
0.0058612241,
0.0013866839,
-0.0483041219,
-0.0076209102,
-0.0508187599,
0.0311522912,
-0.0539509766,
-0.0105525572,
0.052156385,
-0.020165788,
0.0115609802,
0.0036554015,
0.0030472022,
0.0182008054,
0.0253824964,
-0.0284296814,
0.0057838461,
0.0440903492,
0.0201833211,
0.0105965436,
-0.0058611552,
-0.0151565578,
-0.0815840662,
-0.0223791134,
0.0002074323,
0.0639029294,
-0.0049883896,
-0.0099823726,
-0.0216747541,
0.0349779762,
-0.0213986002,
0.0129872793,
0.0522185229,
0.033423584,
0.0275353827,
0.0058161686,
-0.0535439029,
0.0155496243,
0.0029777961,
0.0843003467,
-0.0187452398,
-0.0239014179,
-0.0198412873,
-0.0394351669,
-0.0091097085,
-0.0233426392,
-0.046679385,
0.0125935385,
0.0390268788,
-0.0053308289,
-0.0827980638,
-0.0528838411,
0.0045615039,
0.0315361395,
-0.0299224518,
0.0249447674,
0.0242280513,
0.0401552953,
-0.0149728386,
0.0346498601,
-0.0337732956,
-0.0061412873,
-0.0434035659,
-0.0020913607,
0.0589668602,
-0.0363000184,
-0.0401626341,
0.015037192,
-0.0410661995,
-0.0578933246,
-0.0273688026,
0.0209614243,
0.0226515792,
0.0207340736,
-0.0343942568,
-0.0390376076,
0.0222135149,
0.0058236956,
-0.0655717179,
0.0225977916,
0.0432484634,
-0.0222688392,
-0.0357528254,
0.0227757208,
-0.0827364698,
0.0298951715,
-0.0463473834,
0.031044336,
-0.0459210239,
-0.0488876589,
0.0285292882,
0.0076938737,
0.0231040306,
0.067886278,
0.0357657149,
-0.0136020789,
0.0309709087,
0.0087579926,
-0.0239274595,
-0.0272780973,
0.0261087883,
-0.0235287063,
-0.0762385651,
0.0009920305,
0.0320395418,
-0.0237565748,
0.0518727079,
-0.023399137,
-0.0036909296,
0.0589943267,
-0.0208927486,
0.0132682854,
-0.0355599895,
-0.0340137519,
0.0180050805,
-0.0033834383,
0.060333401,
0.0088903885,
0.0419346951,
0.0019799829,
-0.0130607504,
0.0501619838,
-0.0211412013,
-0.1154457629,
-0.0721014291,
-0.0025403639,
0.0195452981,
0.0035734726,
0.0123238452,
0.0430100113,
0.0269595459,
0.0067551481,
-0.02905811,
-0.0352354534,
-0.0011804203,
0.012437677,
0.0206627417,
0.0486483239,
0.0107244411,
0.047526557,
0.076604329,
-0.023423031,
0.0248422734,
-0.0336061157,
0.0225806888,
-0.0311958324,
-0.0555057302,
-0.044838503,
0.0536433049,
-0.0126431361,
-0.0119459582,
-0.0387255326,
-0.0253382046,
0.0124469986,
0.0047179209,
0.0024784564,
-0.0064913277,
0.0523361452,
0.0584216006,
-0.0190478694,
-0.0358754285,
-0.0318372063,
0.0039388281,
-0.077244401,
-0.0275532696,
0.0118496837,
-6.224684133e-33,
-0.0399565734,
-0.0191451553,
0.0132975457,
-0.0083378712,
0.0065240595,
-0.0005287811,
-0.0125134215,
0.0162497275,
-0.0734609589,
-0.0402934775,
-0.0236181412,
0.0095406175,
0.0073426664,
0.0272487625,
-0.0081148865,
-0.0111580733,
0.0163302682,
-0.0028814911,
-0.0145451585,
0.0255188923,
0.0531164706,
0.0191092063,
0.0193393491,
-0.0811457634,
0.0157600846,
-0.0267972443,
0.0034774272,
0.0324811637,
-0.0005000673,
0.0588221401,
0.0056458949,
0.0519636758,
0.0084084673,
-0.0011671199,
0.0072055198,
0.0221981984,
-0.1094047129,
-0.0307313707,
0.0270551853,
-0.0221601967,
-0.0350387096,
-0.0043852222,
0.0243981164,
-0.0228733607,
0.0532043539,
-0.0246564187,
0.0380187556,
-0.0133855687,
-0.0220204443,
-0.0130816344,
0.0042235465,
0.0309661515,
-0.0185542293,
-0.0102046849,
-0.0198792983,
0.066908136,
0.0232785512,
-0.0269685425,
-0.0062786858,
0.0293176677,
0.0310767423,
0.0232722331,
0.0203962997,
-0.004048239,
-0.0363040976,
0.0246864017,
-0.0050272024,
-0.0550519601,
-0.0027304504,
-0.0806190223,
-0.0274137314,
0.0301168803,
0.029108312,
0.0354128964,
0.0096617388,
0.0237261113,
-0.0481237471,
0.0320515148,
0.0163641404,
0.0415211581,
-0.016260216,
0.001944299,
-0.0407079831,
0.0041952729,
-0.0553130247,
0.0354404673,
-0.0447704569,
-0.0213023946,
0.0516172014,
0.0261844937,
-0.0195856858,
-0.0082213376,
0.0199362095,
-0.0340985395,
0.0064136651,
0.0929010063,
-0.0308701489,
-0.0013620995,
-0.0253174677,
0.0407852456,
-0.0627082363,
0.0365597457,
0.0185985845,
-0.0035612786,
-0.0310181193,
0.0332254767,
-0.016476145,
-0.01645853,
-0.0738338456,
0.0099835824,
0.0118824374,
0.0496848188,
-0.0368104912,
0.0141143091,
0.0162175763,
0.0325474814,
0.0014221217,
0.0642181337,
-0.0140753547,
0.0098431781,
-0.0629477054,
-0.0208937302,
0.017962588,
-0.0148925213,
-0.0150509542,
0.0111902235,
0.0226940364,
0.0186325461,
-0.000054186,
-0.0256915633,
0.0079919202,
0.0274630617,
2.524e-7,
0.0306551382,
-0.0090466049,
0.0362027325,
0.0414238796,
0.0007828504,
0.013721968,
0.0059734443,
0.031804055,
0.0304391775,
-0.0156616159,
-0.0400331318,
0.0323196426,
0.0221005436,
0.0605956316,
-0.1118840799,
-0.0491160788,
-0.055341199,
-0.0340291485,
-0.0384057872,
-0.0383161046,
0.0380400941,
0.0825111344,
-0.0204686187,
0.0035625079,
-0.0359859578,
-0.0543272868,
0.0615901351,
0.0405016169,
0.0004966173,
0.0266203098,
0.0473405048,
0.0090366798,
-0.0019047349,
-0.0035185514,
0.00805018,
0.0474689454,
0.0449393466,
0.0788494125,
0.0068744188,
-0.0744425058,
-0.0165345501,
-0.0046738395,
0.0175414011,
0.0074060815,
0.0771827176,
-0.0170239955,
0.0180576332,
-0.0095720543,
-0.0416929834,
-0.018138323,
-0.0036029017,
-0.0079222582,
-0.0269747954,
-0.0003901745,
0.0030732788,
-0.0268990621,
0.0199664403,
-0.0784670189,
-0.0104772318,
0.0083801681,
-0.0222381987,
-0.0446601808,
0.00191941,
-0.0432785638,
-0.005187402,
-0.0702517405,
0.0223525874,
1.725439051e-34,
0.0502442159,
0.0089168549,
-0.0070538516,
0.0295545459,
0.0067106155,
-0.0124228243,
-0.028245816,
-0.0223645717,
0.0328721739,
-0.0796588436,
-0.0069170864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04138v1 | Large Language Model Prompt Chaining for Long Legal Document Classification | 2023-08-08T08:57:01 | 2023-08-08T08:57:01 | Dietrich Trautmann | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompting is used to guide or steer a language model in generating an
appropriate response that is consistent with the desired outcome. Chaining is a
strategy used to decompose complex tasks into smaller, manageable components.
In this study, we utilize prompt chaining for extensive legal document
classification tasks, which present difficulties due to their intricate
domain-specific language and considerable length. Our approach begins with the
creation of a concise summary of the original document, followed by a semantic
search for related exemplar texts and their corresponding annotations from a
training corpus. Finally, we prompt for a label - based on the task - to
assign, by leveraging the in-context learning from the few-shot prompt. We
demonstrate that through prompt chaining, we can not only enhance the
performance over zero-shot, but also surpass the micro-F1 score achieved by
larger models, such as ChatGPT zero-shot, using smaller models. | [
0.058677692,
-0.0008033213,
0.0191934202,
0.0194256026,
-0.0661745444,
0.0319757573,
0.0588769242,
0.0375600792,
0.0108528147,
-0.1116117463,
-0.0356965028,
-0.0163645614,
-0.045878619,
0.0013121563,
-0.0244264305,
-0.0463031456,
0.0328870714,
-0.0137360925,
0.0332499593,
0.0030018801,
0.0096964752,
0.012089164,
0.0145862121,
0.0119009353,
-0.0281936452,
-0.0240423549,
-0.0164685752,
0.0037078862,
-0.0065406319,
-0.0068232678,
0.0062883748,
0.0796625763,
0.0287301317,
0.0496914499,
0.0000016489,
-0.0843302831,
-0.0015820754,
0.0075309812,
-0.0653968602,
0.0024569023,
0.0445687026,
-0.0222150292,
-0.015248077,
0.0067015504,
0.0103358449,
-0.0304803755,
-0.0124384947,
0.0518831536,
0.0080318786,
0.0862668008,
-0.0082494253,
-0.0329328254,
0.029590033,
-0.0716877878,
0.0314752981,
-0.0470865108,
0.0213877577,
-0.0176359545,
0.056617301,
0.056222409,
-0.0048125582,
0.0110304672,
0.041357547,
-0.0498500131,
0.0007492892,
-0.0041991523,
-0.0251130667,
0.0058736904,
-0.003982727,
0.0419287197,
0.0190266166,
-0.0097609535,
-0.0045473911,
-0.0237143785,
0.0484415181,
0.0244698692,
-0.0338820443,
0.0809035972,
-0.0195841864,
-0.0326947793,
0.0298196375,
0.0285140686,
-0.0090153562,
0.0115942135,
-0.0016217275,
0.0313465334,
0.0088905152,
-0.0417589918,
0.0271384288,
-0.0029845436,
0.0008966672,
-0.067980431,
0.0027876189,
0.0369098559,
-0.016879553,
0.0131725874,
-0.0507871211,
-0.0197049286,
0.0809748396,
-0.0359056219,
-0.0006467492,
-0.0126713132,
-0.0347290561,
0.1072622314,
-0.0487300307,
0.0181300566,
0.0247517601,
-0.0072995508,
-0.0243837368,
-0.0261642281,
-0.0608790331,
-0.0017388316,
-0.0580437817,
0.0431734473,
-0.0634368435,
-0.0056039863,
-0.0107271578,
0.022319898,
-0.003027156,
0.0392026715,
-0.000350612,
-0.045792371,
-0.0086821634,
-0.0354019552,
-0.0275983624,
-0.0377579667,
-0.0262576584,
0.0314541757,
0.0046518459,
-0.0115247462,
0.0057872212,
0.0081878081,
-0.002808287,
-0.0248355512,
0.0173354615,
0.0578671284,
-0.0121353632,
-0.0639811978,
-0.0138284843,
-0.0310061686,
-0.0342222229,
-0.0590003841,
-0.039244242,
-0.0468125641,
0.000234326,
-0.0145641901,
-0.0240845662,
0.0016976553,
-0.004718422,
0.0342995599,
0.0058666798,
0.0819887444,
0.022595292,
-0.0319626555,
0.0153110698,
0.0304492414,
0.0168754868,
0.0372218192,
-0.0259410832,
0.0374431871,
0.0342986137,
0.0081454804,
0.0413935073,
0.0375315398,
0.0113940015,
0.0267682951,
0.0082635088,
0.0176990498,
0.0608527623,
0.021225296,
0.0076800045,
0.018714333,
-0.0113545638,
-0.0110358167,
0.0077156555,
0.0524725132,
0.0004797513,
0.0022291087,
0.0336917862,
0.0109816454,
-0.0083087338,
-0.019528335,
-0.0634121075,
0.0238663331,
-0.0158833265,
0.0016832183,
-0.0236073453,
-0.0151667632,
-0.0481338724,
-0.0428991728,
-0.0052611493,
-0.016502535,
-0.0406729765,
0.0124986125,
0.0444170907,
0.035903167,
-0.0358976163,
0.0136877187,
0.009049749,
-0.0168842189,
-0.0254412759,
-0.0409514531,
0.0319705978,
0.0210660528,
0.0305205043,
-0.0530609749,
-0.0169474985,
-0.0519193634,
0.0462486595,
0.0498253815,
0.0259920657,
-0.0374000445,
-0.0158388019,
-0.0293991491,
-0.0528579168,
0.0113751376,
0.0215369333,
0.0167752858,
-0.0167947076,
-0.0014029039,
0.0539781563,
-0.0311867576,
0.0100709032,
0.0375481583,
-0.0174903069,
-0.08340507,
0.0404303558,
0.0180002656,
0.0287872422,
0.0109931557,
0.0087064495,
-0.0100596426,
0.0164455809,
-0.0145526603,
-0.0011784921,
-0.0320739038,
0.0076445215,
-0.0446356125,
0.0188201591,
0.0210866779,
-0.0291503668,
-0.0296296217,
-0.0540411547,
-0.0384571999,
-0.0807946175,
0.0107376268,
-0.0179984681,
-0.060253121,
-0.0042983587,
0.0153067634,
-0.0146266399,
-0.0619835779,
0.0367439613,
0.0353065506,
0.0006359888,
0.006861229,
0.0129990391,
0.0559071042,
-0.0387320966,
-0.0250280462,
-0.0019102605,
-0.0344252326,
0.0054533393,
0.0320258886,
0.031614162,
-0.0405827761,
-0.0368553959,
-0.1000597775,
0.0077091898,
-0.0352355503,
0.0175505746,
-0.0116930855,
-0.0153301014,
-0.0169710573,
-0.0469994992,
-0.0556964166,
-0.0181542318,
0.0087136822,
0.0142309545,
0.0185133889,
-0.0043213246,
-0.0388632305,
-0.0023960224,
-0.0195937958,
-0.0088216346,
0.0507629178,
0.035887599,
-0.0337468274,
-0.0338181295,
0.051051423,
0.0217123423,
-0.0117910746,
-0.0194156207,
0.0261808932,
-0.0099783707,
-0.0082030902,
-0.0041930219,
0.0401251838,
0.0185589828,
0.01861462,
0.014778438,
0.0273903199,
-0.0680214018,
0.0019844351,
-0.0039090188,
-0.0290855486,
-0.0138056856,
0.01971687,
0.0271597039,
0.0368746556,
-0.0304659344,
-0.0029600554,
-0.0423921533,
-0.013144739,
0.010796153,
0.0029596263,
-0.0601192489,
-0.0181473009,
-0.0059206588,
0.0377175324,
0.0107210381,
-0.0668364167,
0.0526799224,
-0.0068335934,
0.0430125296,
-0.0457172282,
0.0065473937,
-0.0362245478,
0.1076586097,
0.0044724504,
-0.0035815632,
0.0277742539,
-0.0409534052,
-0.0094984425,
-0.0044992263,
0.0435499288,
-0.0108143659,
0.0643041283,
-0.0016700884,
0.0518643707,
-0.060769029,
-0.0528565757,
-0.0287071038,
-0.0747638047,
0.005776355,
0.0518555045,
-0.040810667,
0.0298759528,
-0.0205072276,
-0.0029531259,
-0.0030827909,
0.0639978945,
-0.0127855157,
-0.0123195648,
-0.0212935917,
0.0503728651,
0.0160967801,
-0.0360565037,
-0.034608487,
-0.0203412715,
0.0449655168,
0.0118469214,
0.0145471739,
0.0285638291,
0.0267559867,
-0.0088762548,
0.0079911947,
-0.0691810176,
-0.032523036,
0.0328295939,
-0.0040555997,
-0.0600900464,
0.0045737647,
0.0989820585,
0.0342823416,
-0.0690692365,
-0.032759171,
0.0098865898,
0.0251387507,
0.0382096358,
0.0544086844,
-0.0945727304,
-0.0129474746,
0.0104238903,
-0.0110994074,
-0.0115692215,
-0.0018777194,
-0.0163304657,
-0.12146651,
0.0873804837,
-0.0055237818,
-0.0353255756,
-0.0091349417,
-0.0433309115,
0.0181935243,
0.019434303,
-0.0054243146,
0.0042284462,
-0.0235721059,
-0.0315486789,
0.0156290159,
0.0100881532,
-0.0058299266,
0.0497944951,
-0.0377296172,
0.0489598252,
0.0213326383,
0.010788098,
-0.0008822616,
-0.0031164531,
0.0619250871,
-0.0355458073,
-0.0084977075,
-0.0007612634,
0.0530713983,
-0.002485967,
0.0334100761,
-0.008868048,
0.0426556244,
-0.0120599102,
-0.0450772196,
0.0548339412,
0.0684053749,
-0.0348923579,
0.0296203885,
-0.0249211751,
-0.023401564,
0.0103917355,
0.0625933632,
0.0158321317,
-0.0462183543,
-0.0171808582,
-0.0299375746,
-0.0367084593,
-0.021704169,
0.0087388353,
0.0017252732,
-0.0484568514,
-0.0009248263,
-0.0412518941,
-0.0344817601,
0.0167308599,
0.0683596879,
0.0131350355,
0.0329280011,
-0.028324591,
-0.0039184331,
-0.0254926756,
0.0364594012,
-0.0296103638,
0.0117435148,
-0.0545483753,
0.0357389562,
0.0482351258,
-0.0204721373,
-0.0258787759,
-0.0046363217,
-0.0342946425,
-0.010816358,
-0.0108302906,
0.0004087549,
0.0144020617,
0.0247645974,
-0.0492485762,
-0.0672028512,
0.0467514209,
0.0764787942,
-0.0170372948,
-0.0140655264,
0.0508810021,
-0.0017704717,
-0.0412500016,
0.0131543847,
-0.0545561612,
0.0435928516,
0.0590311103,
-0.0053870436,
-0.0170417167,
-0.0260421429,
0.0297917817,
0.0470935926,
0.0474862866,
-0.0227076076,
-0.0164058357,
-0.0302432254,
0.0285552908,
-0.0056130383,
-0.0403084084,
-0.0188782252,
-0.0010071557,
0.0301760957,
-0.0238018539,
-0.0157000478,
0.0545125566,
-0.0038813879,
0.043328166,
-0.0382968783,
0.009031076,
0.0129427481,
0.0086689349,
0.0077847624,
-0.0072700954,
-0.0067229611,
0.0139086498,
0.0276970845,
0.0258577727,
-0.0280484539,
0.0678106695,
0.041049581,
0.0151438331,
-0.0128054451,
0.0147050684,
-0.0409084372,
-0.010137816,
-0.0149861099,
0.0446125641,
0.0562145002,
-0.0368441343,
-0.0086471355,
-0.0359595492,
-0.0258125626,
-0.0158183817,
0.0325899161,
0.0089234505,
-0.0342034921,
0.0482934974,
0.0408713035,
-0.0050225006,
0.0571136139,
0.0296012051,
0.0028701618,
0.0014784974,
0.0297960136,
0.0139762517,
-0.0475596935,
-0.0086066686,
0.0069334791,
-0.0023890482,
-0.0226461533,
-0.0045873947,
-0.0651183128,
-0.0196364801,
0.0025137849,
-0.0053557409,
-0.0401563719,
0.0510296412,
0.0516095161,
0.0630144775,
0.0021290656,
-0.0264894683,
-0.0562442318,
0.0203215312,
0.035201747,
-0.0509518236,
0.0118158571,
-5.063230327e-33,
-0.0298999548,
-0.0331724994,
0.0254889838,
0.0328927487,
-0.0003532275,
-0.0062772357,
-0.0063021206,
-0.0282066464,
0.0122816712,
0.0310249142,
-0.0387471318,
-0.0008920665,
0.0194599219,
0.0262750275,
0.0246261451,
-0.0163368955,
0.026123317,
-0.0060511557,
-0.0107374843,
0.0380239151,
0.0276213512,
0.0096302535,
-0.018397091,
-0.0723283291,
0.0631750375,
0.0336901248,
-0.0258629341,
-0.0019599192,
-0.0431124978,
0.0857020319,
-0.0014501081,
0.0246592686,
0.045349665,
-0.0698077753,
-0.0006744479,
0.0745064616,
-0.1189390868,
0.0125582451,
-0.0176707841,
-0.0114918174,
0.0109862899,
-0.0469414257,
-0.0155733489,
-0.0238444731,
-0.0066774297,
-0.0357911587,
0.0441748463,
-0.0319181606,
-0.0647309646,
-0.0873280168,
-0.0798991993,
0.0388500281,
0.00729803,
-0.0119353076,
0.0583797395,
0.0313670151,
0.0022383728,
0.052012451,
-0.0255057942,
-0.0208080281,
-0.0150982756,
0.0212510508,
0.0071742306,
-0.0148855066,
-0.0310138762,
0.0405364148,
-0.009786102,
0.0231969096,
-0.0302054435,
-0.0130463401,
0.0139017142,
0.0341501348,
0.0455508381,
0.0609894879,
0.0646232516,
-0.0026990597,
-0.072993882,
-0.0119339377,
0.0234229267,
0.0068232343,
-0.0016248452,
-0.0211064499,
-0.0308577511,
-0.0131152263,
-0.0527907535,
-0.0319420695,
-0.0132853212,
0.0165626053,
0.0343055688,
0.0256564934,
0.048949495,
-0.0468802117,
0.0470952019,
-0.0364318602,
-0.0222034343,
0.0304711722,
0.0040264418,
0.0383018143,
-0.0040434669,
0.0225832425,
-0.0438924544,
-0.0342741869,
0.0176927932,
-0.0165456478,
-0.0131184189,
-0.0194799583,
0.0909082219,
-0.0258932747,
-0.0772293434,
0.0023345188,
0.0120808799,
0.0376826525,
0.0363727063,
0.0466054268,
0.0088583566,
0.0149589423,
0.0299790539,
0.084049724,
0.0209160112,
-0.0702205747,
0.0100268451,
-0.0026533257,
-0.0303355251,
-0.0147424033,
-0.0017635091,
0.0139237298,
0.0091372877,
0.0494668484,
0.0604315586,
-0.0252196342,
0.0386656746,
0.0535060652,
2.369e-7,
0.0609509349,
0.0349292979,
-0.0054366891,
-0.0032818501,
0.005383377,
0.0355352946,
0.0206733216,
0.0270762295,
0.0095667429,
-0.0138809131,
0.0122093949,
-0.024337884,
0.0815963894,
0.0179649945,
-0.1140801087,
-0.0152041074,
-0.0613645799,
-0.0184590481,
-0.0480518714,
0.0387610197,
0.0420048721,
0.1083026007,
0.0112519693,
-0.0246186182,
0.0078717945,
-0.0415895358,
0.0460077785,
-0.0341034047,
-0.0226445962,
0.0037320696,
0.055837024,
-0.0581789427,
-0.0019068416,
0.067938745,
-0.0170580428,
0.0428957678,
-0.0216150992,
0.0771498904,
0.0284350328,
0.045468118,
-0.0223906338,
-0.0110154366,
0.0227070898,
-0.0256450437,
0.0730968192,
-0.0510541536,
0.0030852151,
-0.0240120292,
-0.0196969919,
-0.0378285684,
0.0224441104,
0.0076482543,
-0.002224121,
0.0103742369,
0.0469314791,
-0.0153180128,
0.0105722854,
-0.1092083454,
0.0008975038,
0.0333844647,
-0.0261036493,
0.0112799713,
-0.0031562059,
0.0006455426,
0.0608524457,
-0.080580093,
0.0049971696,
2.234616827e-34,
0.0360719077,
-0.0372079834,
-0.0010064429,
0.0143336505,
-0.0175287835,
0.0160983056,
-0.0178386159,
0.030018324,
0.0250034519,
-0.091307506,
0.0145783741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04124v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04124v1 | Social Media, Topic Modeling and Sentiment Analysis in Municipal Decision Support | 2023-08-08T08:27:57 | 2023-08-08T08:27:57 | Miloš Švaňa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Many cities around the world are aspiring to become. However, smart
initiatives often give little weight to the opinions of average citizens.
Social media are one of the most important sources of citizen opinions. This
paper presents a prototype of a framework for processing social media posts
with municipal decision-making in mind. The framework consists of a sequence of
three steps: (1) determining the sentiment polarity of each social media post
(2) identifying prevalent topics and mapping these topics to individual posts,
and (3) aggregating these two pieces of information into a fuzzy number
representing the overall sentiment expressed towards each topic. Optionally,
the fuzzy number can be reduced into a tuple of two real numbers indicating the
"amount" of positive and negative opinion expressed towards each topic.
The framework is demonstrated on tweets published from Ostrava, Czechia over
a period of about two months. This application illustrates how fuzzy numbers
represent sentiment in a richer way and capture the diversity of opinions
expressed on social media. | [
0.0067430544,
0.0477461256,
-0.0236154478,
-0.0015090372,
-0.030306844,
-0.0031269197,
-0.0576792732,
-0.0325362459,
-0.0276423525,
-0.0566624366,
0.0621717274,
0.0050048232,
-0.018417228,
0.0610835738,
-0.0534772798,
-0.0399449877,
-0.0009358941,
0.0353266783,
0.0603061654,
0.0188820492,
0.071475096,
0.0315228365,
-0.0113339815,
0.0205619708,
-0.0223787893,
0.0692489147,
-0.0087805223,
-0.0279044174,
0.0194517802,
-0.0165746659,
0.0115771918,
0.0065819151,
-0.0171338823,
-0.0162148178,
0.0000019493,
-0.0061376346,
-0.042984046,
-0.0257036742,
0.0865217745,
-0.0385415442,
0.104772456,
-0.0291314907,
-0.0166223552,
0.0239048768,
-0.0342432708,
0.0230730828,
0.0342167951,
0.0346420221,
0.0734934211,
0.0068812305,
-0.0293182731,
-0.0364484377,
-0.032334052,
0.0369729884,
-0.0072642793,
0.035733439,
-0.0271643586,
-0.046133209,
0.0093449196,
-0.0093897618,
0.0449807234,
-0.0093467953,
-0.0377455242,
0.0016915256,
-0.0187809039,
0.0118302274,
0.0115261991,
-0.0130907986,
-0.0024470671,
0.0169790443,
0.0038297824,
-0.0125050591,
0.0386953168,
-0.0097834105,
0.003298674,
0.0218002703,
-0.0435276181,
-0.0203655325,
0.0063474188,
0.0790490732,
-0.0234932862,
0.035152968,
-0.0125036724,
0.058897756,
-0.0309670176,
0.0845705867,
-0.0416374281,
-0.0313135423,
-0.007556661,
0.0498449579,
0.0102233179,
-0.0187835582,
0.0431969538,
0.0283278655,
0.0090655312,
0.0174331442,
0.0146222794,
-0.0003510606,
0.0497873761,
-0.1077126339,
-0.0196010564,
-0.0053463345,
0.0088664936,
0.046016302,
0.0753868297,
-0.0683634952,
0.0045331754,
0.0021608614,
-0.0104090022,
-0.0144907124,
-0.0510611571,
0.04150315,
-0.0034341284,
0.0057148309,
0.0111969346,
0.0158342123,
-0.0186183602,
0.0515356399,
-0.0219209418,
0.0065411879,
-0.0210193135,
0.0284892078,
0.044253137,
-0.0012005535,
-0.0748909712,
0.0340360031,
-0.0357107669,
0.0404708907,
-0.0442376547,
0.078479968,
0.0552404039,
-0.0160677154,
0.0720482171,
0.0187052842,
-0.0255011898,
-0.0017486387,
0.0128850862,
0.0343582667,
-0.0468248501,
-0.0099153686,
0.0104968743,
-0.0247131623,
-0.0095681138,
-0.0603544116,
-0.0284162536,
0.0219817515,
-0.0215015933,
0.0277091563,
0.0053617214,
0.0261369515,
-0.0458879136,
-0.0065732002,
-0.1017084494,
0.0100784302,
0.0554926135,
-0.007675624,
0.0570940562,
0.051086653,
-0.0118449219,
0.0601960272,
0.065440625,
-0.0011058415,
0.034306176,
-0.0209207051,
0.0453575253,
0.005123931,
0.0034143578,
0.0261670239,
-0.1123420075,
-0.0709207058,
-0.031062521,
0.0366300531,
0.0274397843,
0.0131889451,
0.0579232462,
0.0214435682,
-0.0145535776,
-0.0176020768,
-0.0257224608,
0.081338495,
-0.0185167547,
-0.0377403833,
0.0006892587,
0.0310792644,
-0.0295642465,
0.0143584628,
0.0034932999,
0.01269852,
-0.0289654713,
-0.0243615825,
0.0193198659,
-0.0212215129,
0.0747518614,
-0.0413913168,
0.0265689082,
-0.0610801615,
0.0019041288,
0.0110581489,
0.0123837488,
-0.0307827499,
0.0142834866,
-0.0159904845,
0.0411855169,
0.0518185236,
-0.0396573581,
-0.0410696603,
0.020347856,
-0.0416032374,
-0.00986489,
-0.0207513608,
0.0681288019,
0.0088389032,
-0.0583520494,
-0.0069443299,
0.0048315399,
0.0516647659,
0.039415326,
-0.0297917258,
-0.0279537663,
0.069119893,
0.0029863059,
0.0272837915,
0.0233802758,
-0.0206868034,
0.1169992164,
0.0380988307,
-0.0374691673,
0.0269523002,
0.0375240631,
0.0475696996,
-0.0051707076,
0.0077698384,
0.0368860364,
0.0424307771,
-0.0809247792,
-0.0354056619,
0.0127857281,
0.0197518002,
0.0232261326,
-0.0160429012,
-0.0287057161,
-0.0218952913,
-0.032834392,
0.0103902854,
0.0692064613,
-0.0371531621,
-0.0496968254,
-0.0239837337,
-0.0043991162,
-0.0330314934,
-0.0140761537,
-0.0029828504,
0.0335073359,
-0.0206651781,
-0.0121718282,
-0.0447868779,
-0.0655321553,
0.0167535581,
-0.0079882843,
0.000813664,
-0.02580305,
0.0058128936,
0.0683369637,
0.0034269029,
-0.0133330673,
-0.0112782577,
-0.0332729071,
-0.0782696605,
-0.0111608543,
-0.023947021,
0.005054059,
0.0264682863,
-0.0181698557,
-0.0102125695,
0.0283605084,
-0.0103019224,
0.0130779715,
0.0185237359,
0.0023108276,
0.0174880642,
-0.0065870616,
0.0597519092,
-0.0128834164,
-0.004488775,
-0.0347459354,
-0.0095899925,
0.0022197459,
-0.0559924729,
0.0148356389,
0.0125247259,
-0.0610803179,
-0.0128071355,
-0.0012847463,
-0.0160085484,
0.0242858231,
-0.0193882529,
0.0194926169,
-0.0552695803,
0.0487213992,
0.0259435531,
0.0172317773,
-0.0034277656,
-0.015815407,
-0.0207385905,
-0.0713536814,
0.0684467033,
0.0017286072,
-0.0141898599,
0.0355165042,
-0.0157184135,
-0.0088344328,
0.0265852138,
-0.0171676725,
0.0517432168,
-0.0419867188,
0.0324031226,
-0.0509675406,
0.0165275987,
0.0389627442,
0.0690043718,
0.033308588,
-0.0264867824,
0.014684448,
0.028982589,
0.040919967,
-0.0442400314,
-0.0604296923,
-0.0417723805,
0.0290926099,
0.0021941124,
0.0054273792,
-0.033420708,
0.0518319309,
0.0396996327,
-0.0555629842,
-0.008465264,
-0.0513429865,
0.0333781615,
0.0249794032,
-0.00437199,
-0.0077077174,
-0.0238995496,
0.0310022421,
-0.0542355925,
-0.043423444,
-0.0203844048,
0.019114133,
0.0204081815,
-0.0057878518,
0.0203766767,
0.0148044797,
-0.0056150714,
0.0035619449,
-0.0321493149,
0.0097891064,
-0.0082910275,
0.0028397846,
-0.0058221365,
0.0169838648,
0.0252666473,
-0.0578579567,
0.0075894333,
0.0290238038,
-0.0395848639,
-0.0253624581,
-0.0129667735,
-0.0029668568,
-0.019703852,
0.0178276729,
-0.0401263386,
0.0315852277,
0.0040293629,
0.0456476808,
0.0619058758,
0.04794126,
-0.0184014142,
0.0059262803,
-0.0086740516,
-0.0393406637,
0.0004533523,
0.0144537156,
-0.031734243,
0.0133695761,
-0.0039252392,
0.0061910627,
-0.0597086027,
-0.0235036593,
0.0073589273,
-0.058276929,
0.0228901152,
-0.0045981104,
-0.0100569148,
-0.0154705578,
-0.0482648388,
0.0244788025,
-0.01988234,
-0.0582840741,
-0.0495495014,
0.0069741048,
0.0142473131,
0.0059930766,
-0.0437362045,
-0.0167157333,
-0.0342648029,
-0.0146470601,
0.0298865419,
-0.022760652,
0.0832455307,
-0.0189152136,
0.014262734,
-0.0038173979,
-0.0020575433,
-0.0022850982,
-0.0360568985,
0.0383765064,
-0.0040242868,
-0.0145599935,
-0.0477775708,
-0.0063199913,
-0.0360211134,
-0.0041447482,
0.0184419304,
0.0526736826,
-0.0349177681,
-0.0212367214,
-0.0530537628,
0.0621950179,
0.0448102392,
0.0059090401,
-0.0170761701,
-0.0011713363,
-0.0050849621,
-0.0116738575,
0.0091013508,
0.0102127828,
-0.043333374,
-0.050181549,
0.0124725215,
-0.0353517272,
-0.0132409148,
-0.0372235775,
-0.0005351059,
0.0326810218,
-0.049980808,
-0.0230725911,
0.1120739281,
-0.0273487158,
-0.0302583203,
-0.010564452,
0.0451406576,
0.0539751649,
-0.001395463,
-0.0512251221,
0.0266960952,
0.0645699278,
-0.0411379747,
-0.0141179925,
-0.0055824858,
-0.0460390151,
0.0354829729,
0.0118154781,
0.0223259702,
-0.0652517676,
-0.0211985763,
-0.029730618,
0.0405965224,
0.0649009794,
-0.0625212267,
-0.06264285,
0.0153383464,
0.0879465118,
0.0310857929,
0.0068277176,
0.004050381,
0.0437189713,
-0.0075042588,
-0.0425987318,
-0.0936270505,
0.0283361636,
-0.0276393164,
-0.0175469872,
0.0516474769,
0.0493335649,
-0.0193146672,
-0.0089357365,
-0.0453592613,
0.0023643577,
-0.0193261858,
-0.0125859911,
-0.0212635659,
-0.0138345174,
0.034340214,
-0.0647061765,
-0.0010954622,
0.0265883934,
0.0241269805,
0.0006718404,
0.0198292006,
0.0038559784,
0.0570964999,
-0.0304666888,
-0.0042290036,
-0.001160086,
0.0018718183,
0.0013351873,
-0.0207879934,
-0.0032062661,
0.0099768154,
-0.0242130179,
0.011265533,
0.003855505,
0.0261935443,
-0.0147969062,
-0.0075116456,
-0.0336521231,
0.0590511821,
-0.0052116551,
0.0262327865,
0.0142614357,
-0.0098313699,
0.0097260494,
-0.0014055003,
0.004256397,
0.0068172631,
0.0123058641,
0.0051132478,
-0.0000066112,
-0.0556674898,
-0.0220830068,
0.0083588064,
-0.0675482526,
-0.0486594699,
0.0026328349,
-0.0572845824,
0.006040012,
0.0279674195,
0.0031631673,
0.0380797647,
0.00857554,
-0.0008601559,
-0.0631531104,
-0.0032789563,
0.0239147786,
-0.0332995281,
0.0179242622,
0.004551833,
0.0289157424,
0.020935569,
-0.0004818855,
0.0998941064,
-0.0503350273,
0.0065889331,
-0.0606363378,
-0.0178336371,
-0.0246992409,
-6.494674614e-33,
-0.000126179,
-0.038806688,
-0.0069875806,
0.0067595071,
0.009304774,
-0.0598284118,
0.0218433533,
0.0297809895,
0.0104141682,
0.0056649209,
0.0141194379,
0.0141977575,
0.0145661496,
-0.0162914898,
-0.0075166407,
-0.0221448038,
0.0154042291,
-0.0220159441,
-0.0018135296,
0.0262187645,
0.0418863706,
-0.0186223295,
0.0086815888,
-0.1215056479,
0.0090500917,
0.0065154764,
-0.0306828152,
0.0018872194,
0.0838660076,
0.0015989598,
-0.0037864982,
0.0629569963,
0.0443446524,
-0.0245236438,
-0.024309786,
0.0907308534,
0.0213315114,
-0.0555346943,
-0.0181607418,
-0.0104732793,
0.0424213335,
0.0061502522,
-0.0002811482,
0.0111262789,
-0.0351965651,
0.0537721552,
0.0239055566,
0.0012504448,
0.0345529355,
-0.0452285036,
-0.065282397,
0.0681028143,
-0.0485969745,
0.0288867801,
-0.0038157925,
-0.0174534712,
0.0152045097,
0.0516167767,
-0.015898779,
0.0186626725,
-0.0281100851,
-0.010310947,
0.001316076,
-0.0875981823,
-0.0138642788,
0.0361013897,
-0.0037616822,
0.0031688802,
-0.0431957692,
0.0121484865,
0.0085344296,
0.0479898602,
0.0492469594,
0.0556685738,
0.0218690373,
-0.0672257692,
-0.0514732562,
0.037215516,
0.0496055447,
-0.0164554082,
0.0451861694,
0.0032011769,
-0.0220141467,
-0.0050824173,
0.0395569988,
-0.0566477515,
-0.0383228399,
-0.0051028626,
-0.0301657245,
0.0180333816,
-0.0321051367,
0.0601086579,
0.0060155094,
-0.0324248523,
-0.0338492319,
0.0027720849,
-0.0477848016,
0.0356581546,
0.0148594594,
0.0398508944,
-0.0677857995,
-0.0426717699,
-0.0149270222,
0.0825222284,
-0.0073172585,
0.0233589541,
-0.0183565766,
0.0167489536,
-0.0485665202,
0.0031188466,
0.0253651608,
0.0110630793,
-0.0427567922,
-0.0170369949,
-0.0038774465,
-0.0189810321,
0.0145656718,
-0.0043316977,
0.0142620783,
0.0351481326,
0.0172614958,
-0.0210271589,
-0.0454037897,
-0.002073386,
0.0111743901,
-0.0371141396,
0.0047934721,
-0.0264001079,
-0.0010876115,
0.0056302245,
-0.0058021792,
-0.0256059133,
2.712e-7,
0.0339126997,
0.0849890411,
-0.071072273,
-0.0178954285,
0.0365440473,
0.0593837537,
-0.0247254521,
0.0217640996,
-0.0094892466,
0.0216300134,
0.0263997465,
0.0056345984,
-0.0097923847,
0.0846455917,
-0.0434762649,
0.0025428769,
-0.0492983684,
-0.0256351642,
-0.0436456688,
0.0569275022,
0.0448303074,
0.071637772,
0.069601953,
-0.0086738998,
-0.0170597937,
-0.0274631921,
0.0150880571,
-0.0404702984,
-0.0297631472,
0.0182501245,
0.0307462867,
-0.0305886082,
0.0134547232,
-0.0380870923,
0.0017504898,
-0.0036906444,
0.0155425072,
0.0239123758,
0.0220646486,
0.0040093455,
0.035429921,
-0.0771069229,
0.0113617592,
-0.0429573432,
0.0209473837,
-0.0946690515,
-0.0492313877,
-0.083041586,
-0.0347139165,
-0.005562318,
0.0683211982,
-0.0063085761,
-0.0681181252,
0.0170488413,
-0.0115062175,
0.0028318625,
-0.033638414,
-0.0377391428,
0.0557669438,
-0.0200122651,
-0.0019113497,
-0.0832759961,
-0.0064490344,
0.0623307079,
0.0601973161,
0.0322516151,
0.0427890569,
1.66431059e-34,
0.0364172086,
-0.0057239104,
-0.0462861769,
-0.045467101,
0.0300274286,
0.0178363789,
-0.065724507,
-0.0102537172,
-0.0066036079,
0.0058185919,
0.0386298299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04114v1 | Collective Human Opinions in Semantic Textual Similarity | 2023-08-08T08:00:52 | 2023-08-08T08:00:52 | Yuxia Wang, Shimin Tao, Ning Xie, Hao Yang, Timothy Baldwin, Karin Verspoor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the subjective nature of semantic textual similarity (STS) and
pervasive disagreements in STS annotation, existing benchmarks have used
averaged human ratings as the gold standard. Averaging masks the true
distribution of human opinions on examples of low agreement, and prevents
models from capturing the semantic vagueness that the individual ratings
represent. In this work, we introduce USTS, the first Uncertainty-aware STS
dataset with ~15,000 Chinese sentence pairs and 150,000 labels, to study
collective human opinions in STS. Analysis reveals that neither a scalar nor a
single Gaussian fits a set of observed judgements adequately. We further show
that current STS models cannot capture the variance caused by human
disagreement on individual instances, but rather reflect the predictive
confidence over the aggregate dataset. | [
0.0604816787,
0.0500750467,
0.0024006232,
0.0308987312,
-0.024316255,
0.0165631771,
-0.0188229214,
-0.0293934923,
-0.0199679919,
-0.0626426265,
-0.0634007528,
-0.0470182337,
0.0435506999,
-0.0248087887,
0.0110701397,
-0.0528399758,
-0.0070299027,
0.0446349345,
0.0289189108,
-0.0141433906,
0.0814759061,
-0.0083638448,
0.0255835932,
0.0236445814,
-0.027444439,
0.014888525,
0.0327271372,
-0.0019647044,
0.0732975975,
-0.0218791794,
0.027113108,
0.0437734835,
-0.0185902026,
0.0258483998,
0.0000015355,
0.0006005959,
0.0108571509,
-0.026007833,
0.0528269149,
0.0478939041,
0.0423239134,
0.0667845532,
0.0099311238,
-0.0122239878,
-0.0311236177,
0.0106964605,
0.0368254744,
0.0244165845,
0.0670756102,
0.0122963348,
-0.0070074718,
-0.0219835285,
-0.0373971462,
0.0009975182,
0.0222642906,
-0.0674474388,
-0.0096743265,
0.0340494923,
-0.0204440281,
0.0244948119,
0.0165186878,
-0.0018158931,
-0.0137296077,
0.0282480512,
-0.0197378322,
0.0214133803,
-0.0674819648,
-0.005101745,
0.0318210572,
0.0733130723,
0.0486228652,
-0.065837875,
-0.0232308824,
0.003500483,
0.0062723327,
0.0433459021,
-0.0021512161,
0.0277311504,
-0.034010727,
0.0638537109,
-0.0272973813,
0.0536214337,
0.0086538,
0.022806339,
0.0334668159,
0.0483751446,
-0.0092101051,
-0.0226219911,
-0.0158818625,
0.0360196456,
-0.0893355012,
0.0046812678,
-0.0012342223,
-0.0302444622,
-0.0332515426,
0.0066689756,
-0.0539033115,
-0.0277909487,
0.0347689129,
-0.0655144975,
0.0055907308,
0.0178738516,
0.0073840548,
0.0498019084,
-0.0074707489,
-0.0031629328,
0.008992156,
0.0151801873,
-0.025689045,
-0.0529440381,
-0.0823588967,
0.0385368727,
0.0091321534,
0.0427897088,
0.0000070844,
-0.0210518595,
-0.0468739159,
0.0011741633,
-0.0632426441,
-0.0038293535,
-0.0076815756,
0.0280213282,
0.024123719,
-0.01880382,
-0.0434263162,
0.0029717511,
-0.0246014986,
0.0361586772,
-0.0058706016,
-0.0387248471,
0.0236994587,
0.0246181544,
0.0160007533,
0.0019651768,
-0.0207755603,
-0.0138110826,
-0.0104765082,
0.0110169388,
-0.0144370049,
-0.0162971504,
-0.0314572006,
-0.0186884329,
-0.0472871512,
-0.0706427544,
-0.0061085941,
0.0012640466,
0.0084281042,
-0.0099415882,
0.0191989336,
0.0498032905,
-0.0460690223,
0.075347431,
0.0172506776,
-0.0132862013,
0.0090028662,
0.0037475708,
-0.0023304813,
0.0082552787,
-0.0005976101,
-0.0014005838,
0.0494695306,
0.0711016208,
-0.0206910782,
-0.0282180756,
0.0046412689,
-0.0138596315,
0.0121263377,
0.0018226701,
-0.023932036,
0.0082621435,
-0.0187140107,
0.0925591365,
-0.0253861528,
-0.0433870405,
0.0633132011,
0.0732351542,
-0.0861263648,
0.0111500761,
-0.002779159,
0.0489749163,
0.0139472913,
0.0112067331,
-0.0247845091,
0.0352992862,
-0.0525379926,
0.0087706419,
0.0559099801,
0.0087184934,
-0.0393884741,
-0.0507354587,
-0.0653593987,
-0.0210677348,
0.0182566606,
-0.0240217708,
-0.0161330774,
-0.0221131761,
0.0215871576,
0.0310241394,
0.0266672578,
-0.0650355145,
-0.0308876801,
0.0079088137,
0.0234619696,
0.0411781706,
0.0072073899,
0.00222581,
-0.0128945038,
0.0043628067,
0.0007152118,
0.009368984,
0.0505852103,
-0.010343276,
-0.021501366,
-0.0485326014,
-0.0165628046,
0.0326355956,
0.0346019305,
0.0113881677,
0.0185792372,
-0.0055941194,
0.0212808531,
-0.0435561612,
-0.0561070032,
0.0067768623,
0.024975419,
0.0391284637,
-0.0018115952,
-0.0067017809,
0.0721961334,
0.0124366228,
-0.036928378,
0.0180134717,
0.0165629424,
0.0048671542,
-0.0948476568,
0.0266646389,
-0.0297571197,
-0.0194938239,
0.0405821465,
-0.0872529596,
-0.0573381409,
0.0174231194,
-0.0650734827,
-0.0303805973,
-0.0059971334,
-0.0412308089,
-0.0538669191,
-0.0570563972,
-0.003347734,
-0.0136653986,
-0.0048421416,
-0.0436997935,
0.0335177705,
-0.0100469803,
0.0310936961,
-0.010262317,
0.0093170013,
0.0481801629,
0.0122248344,
-0.0672853515,
-0.0305716209,
0.0454343706,
0.0225442052,
0.076507993,
0.0049882424,
-0.0037619493,
-0.0155756501,
-0.0865378901,
-0.0063227005,
-0.0144526167,
0.0028357906,
0.0387802348,
-0.0376283377,
0.0252667721,
-0.0021112771,
-0.0481659174,
0.018335063,
-0.045422323,
0.0133980317,
0.0562745966,
-0.0282938574,
0.0417214036,
-0.0655941293,
0.0075242333,
-0.0106930919,
0.024481155,
0.0371641926,
-0.0291720722,
-0.0386623666,
0.0490499847,
-0.0846693739,
-0.0134586776,
0.0160911027,
-0.0219176169,
0.0105667207,
0.0156697072,
0.0218564942,
0.0203229189,
0.0189132616,
-0.0092456993,
0.060726963,
0.0300126355,
-0.0453275628,
-0.0213955808,
-0.0241923053,
-0.0111144707,
0.0025460781,
-0.0533121824,
0.0237974077,
0.0449604765,
0.0352014825,
-0.0271986127,
-0.0521540381,
0.0043081506,
-0.019111326,
0.0189246852,
-0.0328418165,
-0.010899445,
-0.0167152584,
0.0182975419,
-0.0274722595,
-0.0084868232,
0.1082906872,
0.0013465816,
0.0192963034,
-0.059383288,
0.0077527603,
-0.0486785173,
0.0085875336,
-0.0118622081,
-0.0141276885,
-0.0308851171,
0.0506372564,
-0.0345531814,
0.0085486555,
0.0674496368,
-0.0185178388,
0.0078265378,
-0.025071254,
0.0093255946,
0.0034566054,
-0.0275250431,
0.0159200523,
-0.0395929329,
-0.0590718724,
0.0007418183,
0.0629685,
-0.0068844599,
0.000222147,
-0.0192856025,
-0.0171272475,
-0.0007847119,
0.0026270668,
-0.0248636268,
-0.0107655469,
0.0310295746,
0.0279733874,
-0.0081731165,
0.0281158723,
-0.0326001011,
-0.0195100848,
0.0963749141,
0.0019358883,
-0.0083865803,
-0.0190671608,
-0.0524653271,
0.0041690753,
0.0282022581,
-0.0296527334,
-0.0030398674,
0.073616147,
0.0133845545,
0.0111385155,
0.1118646637,
0.0424625613,
-0.0350750573,
-0.0325357914,
-0.0082761431,
0.0468945578,
0.0251871701,
-0.0488939136,
-0.0565693192,
-0.0524778403,
-0.0213662628,
-0.0087954411,
0.0086747091,
-0.0266055427,
0.0209563673,
-0.0641624629,
-0.0033454744,
-0.0130515164,
-0.0173308831,
0.0157267321,
-0.0359388515,
0.0559656881,
-0.0271825176,
0.007976695,
-0.0340559483,
0.0202830974,
0.0515659526,
-0.0039627631,
-0.036360722,
-0.0096577164,
0.054944519,
-0.0748896673,
0.0617293157,
0.0304622222,
0.0717565343,
0.021910632,
-0.0540348291,
0.0144779235,
-0.0650547519,
-0.0345967039,
0.0039092489,
0.0494034179,
-0.0104401633,
0.010913345,
-0.0512227453,
0.0419507213,
-0.042831149,
-0.0019284942,
-0.0141111994,
0.019383667,
-0.0118133184,
-0.0060827085,
-0.0439300835,
0.0358297341,
-0.0351990499,
0.1028750017,
-0.0019157538,
-0.0235335454,
-0.0154205635,
-0.0043046321,
0.0076785572,
-0.0262213778,
-0.0366427191,
0.0189810209,
0.0096402969,
0.0014530803,
-0.0996952727,
-0.0402956456,
-0.0363097377,
-0.0311938375,
-0.0278083514,
-0.0258421898,
0.0644886643,
-0.0144653469,
-0.012985562,
0.014932909,
-0.0039246548,
0.0132699916,
-0.0014298726,
0.0086299563,
0.0455474555,
0.0318437964,
-0.0251006931,
0.0350231901,
-0.0848168731,
-0.0693419874,
-0.0157551542,
0.007549684,
0.0095040072,
-0.000470677,
-0.0117623908,
-0.0190992523,
0.036941722,
0.0472457297,
0.0141208293,
0.0257117972,
0.0094661973,
0.0790642947,
0.028349055,
0.0449826308,
-0.0115012145,
0.0368077196,
0.0323722661,
-0.014370976,
-0.0353312194,
-0.0748270825,
0.0304725673,
0.0168259609,
0.027585309,
0.0015251834,
0.0342411846,
-0.0125325667,
-0.0126004266,
-0.0209357422,
-0.0265732184,
-0.0249275342,
-0.0047439183,
0.0196729414,
-0.0471257344,
-0.0623066686,
0.0676957369,
0.0317963846,
0.0724097788,
-0.0139800552,
-0.0314788073,
0.0201260764,
0.027459396,
-0.0417163558,
-0.0288412813,
-0.0173813645,
-0.0324172303,
-0.0390020758,
-0.0074058385,
0.0368896835,
0.0297105443,
0.0426795147,
-0.0114580495,
0.0169586632,
0.0325992629,
-0.0906357393,
-0.0476226695,
-0.0118268169,
-0.0128016276,
0.0106724668,
-0.0013414543,
0.067806825,
-0.0390501395,
-0.0049609975,
-0.0226766933,
0.0187774654,
-0.0177827477,
0.0315315947,
0.0299244542,
-0.0009588678,
-0.0126232728,
0.0394749753,
0.0912007242,
-0.0577856302,
-0.0055030501,
0.0019780977,
-0.0988352671,
-0.0155158937,
0.0063233944,
-0.0115649942,
0.0292294119,
0.0096691074,
0.0165801775,
-0.0433803946,
-0.02199216,
0.0401364937,
0.0378115885,
0.0218427833,
0.0160088595,
0.0277449787,
0.0557920039,
-0.0235153325,
0.0335154608,
-0.0320656337,
-0.0461089835,
0.0004222289,
-0.0015536333,
-0.0836989731,
-6.161978856e-33,
0.008613023,
-0.0225517899,
-0.0656759366,
0.0288520176,
0.0273359418,
-0.0018872824,
-0.0217703022,
0.0271778423,
-0.0210917778,
0.0805365816,
0.0422042236,
0.0383304171,
0.0119046224,
0.0412913747,
0.029755827,
-0.0265435427,
0.0328850076,
-0.0016636623,
-0.0080520343,
-0.0109789735,
0.0788124427,
-0.0500294417,
0.0136006903,
-0.0894855708,
0.0636560842,
0.007334603,
-0.0111408038,
-0.0076274942,
0.0309710242,
0.0255344175,
0.0058652055,
0.0626946092,
0.0138976239,
0.0163926817,
-0.0306784417,
-0.0053590313,
-0.0476462469,
-0.0380366966,
0.0064885044,
-0.0295363236,
-0.024864044,
0.0256201867,
0.0280495733,
-0.0219215844,
-0.0279004835,
0.0051290346,
0.0768985599,
-0.0107055018,
0.0089129824,
-0.0482382476,
0.0004333369,
0.038863685,
-0.0102893719,
0.0017609412,
-0.0103785973,
0.0135657396,
-0.028605124,
0.0452309065,
-0.0746549591,
0.0212729946,
-0.0854234174,
0.0074475831,
-0.0038827418,
-0.060514763,
0.0274565332,
0.079467915,
0.0049433326,
0.0109039014,
-0.0354573578,
-0.0192405116,
-0.0346637107,
0.0182512142,
0.0366826318,
0.0885119587,
0.0100508463,
-0.0033178676,
-0.0305002294,
0.0577790849,
0.0073533622,
0.0206977949,
0.0393705778,
0.0384254567,
-0.0712982044,
-0.0211749095,
-0.0069291247,
-0.0162016191,
-0.025862366,
0.0100827916,
-0.0106845349,
-0.0167190917,
0.007710611,
0.014245064,
-0.0047360985,
-0.0387346596,
-0.0252971556,
0.009565861,
-0.0112518175,
0.0125420885,
0.0287967287,
0.0053636506,
-0.0420361497,
0.014477903,
-0.0179296602,
0.030968735,
-0.0045418516,
0.0033263974,
0.0819592997,
-0.0170565359,
-0.0721205324,
-0.0018707451,
-0.0206905678,
-0.0635771826,
-0.0552732907,
-0.0553143881,
0.0086653531,
0.0175277274,
0.0014742817,
0.051168561,
-0.0000855602,
0.0431327559,
-0.0224311408,
-0.0358962305,
-0.0143720144,
-0.0047935862,
0.0006684485,
-0.0082512796,
-0.0207746513,
-0.0621820875,
-0.0137127675,
-0.010286822,
-0.0162786096,
0.0099701891,
2.334e-7,
0.048923485,
0.0272891093,
0.0127294725,
-0.02261387,
0.0268567614,
0.065346092,
0.0119301388,
0.0262062103,
0.0041116639,
-0.0323049463,
0.0278228,
0.012468013,
0.0298653878,
0.0466107763,
-0.0391639769,
-0.0041264468,
-0.0790407211,
-0.0623632967,
0.0329179317,
0.0069388449,
0.1008709446,
0.069307588,
0.0413059741,
0.0176248476,
-0.0017166411,
-0.0129026724,
0.0768387765,
-0.0229548253,
-0.0239910372,
0.0393393748,
0.0475441888,
-0.0336671956,
0.0006212751,
0.0245349128,
-0.0005229664,
-0.0065631447,
0.0428283922,
0.004790816,
0.0071673305,
-0.0249916706,
-0.0361215733,
-0.0214528982,
0.0167492554,
-0.0240828991,
0.0448209494,
-0.0423485488,
-0.0388787277,
-0.0019806125,
-0.0109761003,
0.0245114844,
0.069481492,
0.0443390794,
-0.043726299,
0.0192226805,
0.002032896,
0.0345589556,
-0.0248001702,
-0.0486394279,
-0.0421626307,
0.0028424633,
-0.0536750294,
-0.0543502793,
0.0213016625,
0.0165728573,
0.0256412495,
-0.0508625284,
0.0043695704,
1.592857753e-34,
0.078300409,
-0.0075584715,
-0.0059510968,
-0.0050554196,
0.0360635854,
-0.0044900379,
-0.0213013049,
-0.0109841181,
0.0272013359,
-0.0060643777,
0.0134663358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04109v1 | I-WAS: a Data Augmentation Method with GPT-2 for Simile Detection | 2023-08-08T07:47:10 | 2023-08-08T07:47:10 | Yongzhu Chang, Rongsheng Zhang, Jiashu Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Simile detection is a valuable task for many natural language processing
(NLP)-based applications, particularly in the field of literature. However,
existing research on simile detection often relies on corpora that are limited
in size and do not adequately represent the full range of simile forms. To
address this issue, we propose a simile data augmentation method based on
\textbf{W}ord replacement And Sentence completion using the GPT-2 language
model. Our iterative process called I-WAS, is designed to improve the quality
of the augmented sentences. To better evaluate the performance of our method in
real-world applications, we have compiled a corpus containing a more diverse
set of simile forms for experimentation. Our experimental results demonstrate
the effectiveness of our proposed data augmentation method for simile
detection. | [
0.0683425218,
0.1171228066,
-0.010464441,
0.0256421976,
-0.0632782876,
0.0191864744,
-0.0224100612,
0.0364291593,
0.0403910838,
-0.0393036269,
0.0356865562,
-0.0075469431,
0.019576598,
-0.0277214069,
0.0464247093,
-0.067416124,
0.0599860735,
0.0350887775,
0.0261789579,
-0.0203518365,
0.0118006086,
0.0306911916,
0.0326027945,
0.0468251146,
0.020508185,
-0.0110937115,
0.018429447,
0.052494444,
0.0335688442,
-0.0208364241,
0.0061718361,
-0.0090038702,
0.0080411658,
-0.0094336178,
0.0000018566,
-0.0430834033,
-0.0047683362,
-0.0162873026,
0.0191107094,
0.0262762383,
0.0822150335,
-0.0096020177,
-0.004699775,
0.0392198861,
-0.0012142505,
-0.0297814384,
0.0206177402,
0.0509507582,
0.0232067499,
0.0660649613,
-0.0286890902,
-0.0314670727,
0.0504969805,
0.0067151971,
0.0088181198,
0.0018625767,
0.0258302465,
0.0104747573,
0.0551955961,
0.0106703369,
-0.0079991566,
0.0293880124,
-0.0350640342,
0.0774771348,
0.0032248739,
0.0223068837,
-0.0782690197,
0.0699474961,
-0.0436637215,
-0.0014463882,
-0.027811002,
-0.0250215922,
0.0005114098,
0.0109588485,
-0.0051553985,
0.0016041393,
-0.0607383177,
-0.0353094265,
-0.0021780629,
0.0521818995,
0.0336321108,
-0.0031668309,
-0.0119692301,
0.0168390945,
-0.010227846,
0.0581107624,
0.0430812165,
-0.0520514697,
-0.0363494381,
-0.0181349926,
-0.0795771182,
-0.0191608854,
0.002551378,
-0.0136352219,
0.0322930366,
0.0107129049,
-0.0601860248,
-0.057945691,
0.0286465064,
-0.0528881587,
0.0806625709,
0.0493518412,
0.0620887578,
0.0258909073,
-0.0288830101,
0.0264173895,
-0.0147270495,
-0.0154447658,
-0.0726299286,
-0.020242203,
-0.0231967345,
0.022045115,
-0.0718920529,
0.0317807049,
-0.0206706766,
-0.063071385,
0.0014491227,
-0.00836269,
0.0243041683,
-0.0128162876,
-0.0252018254,
0.0245783348,
-0.025143683,
-0.0072097951,
-0.0381895341,
0.0257991236,
-0.0253283549,
0.0264072567,
-0.0428074636,
-0.0266863164,
-0.0270238928,
0.0106901526,
0.082207799,
-0.054728698,
0.0284386799,
0.0452886894,
-0.0036160939,
-0.0759399235,
-0.0362451375,
0.0080472445,
-0.0066301301,
-0.0350000709,
-0.0560685955,
-0.0604987815,
0.0258236621,
-0.0174478926,
0.0304881874,
-0.0467275083,
0.0368921943,
0.0494658053,
-0.0491879322,
0.0576426014,
-0.0569274873,
-0.0118662221,
-0.0687846243,
-0.0309293214,
-0.0092746783,
0.0191067047,
0.0273139812,
-0.008237889,
0.0409053825,
0.0364145041,
-0.0238148216,
0.0242417753,
-0.0291171353,
0.0281243734,
-0.0185258146,
0.0104062287,
0.0152722821,
0.0504011437,
0.0337585621,
0.0634361655,
-0.0326014832,
0.0139833437,
0.0678414255,
0.1010069549,
0.0212342832,
0.048841849,
0.0164545532,
0.0454190671,
0.0074197743,
0.0521909557,
-0.0147758797,
-0.0249763224,
-0.0390122831,
0.013063998,
-0.0215303525,
0.0658326373,
0.0132736778,
-0.0056157163,
-0.0360544324,
0.002574418,
0.0123534463,
-0.0223099384,
-0.0113155376,
0.0291292835,
-0.032819055,
-0.0449185707,
0.0195111912,
-0.0701654926,
-0.017417293,
0.0432170965,
0.0037717018,
0.0740562007,
0.102791734,
0.0041844081,
-0.0135323098,
-0.0066928915,
-0.0378298908,
-0.0065648952,
-0.0100674033,
0.0250758454,
0.0054276069,
-0.053037826,
0.0196364745,
-0.0276355334,
0.027516827,
0.0223435462,
0.0004704513,
0.0376747623,
-0.0006226495,
-0.0209621042,
-0.0518584549,
0.0291618314,
-0.0650040135,
-0.040022932,
-0.0026312449,
-0.0067552659,
0.0088862982,
-0.0006630588,
0.0103774089,
-0.0049873716,
0.0032021196,
-0.0466577038,
-0.0466309786,
0.0853478685,
-0.0253893919,
-0.0660290793,
0.0525127165,
-0.0809238702,
-0.0095180618,
0.0565158986,
0.0173676405,
-0.044061888,
0.0201603808,
-0.0785401687,
0.0461062826,
-0.0420548581,
0.0210002623,
0.0014008171,
0.0292525142,
-0.0305142347,
0.0527683161,
0.003844382,
0.025298696,
-0.0037475384,
0.0332362466,
0.0556085408,
0.0064260433,
-0.0234206058,
-0.0080283042,
0.0151936077,
0.0067127976,
-0.0140383746,
-0.0675693825,
-0.0330804922,
-0.0277374331,
-0.0667581037,
0.0348347761,
0.0195611343,
0.0150028225,
0.0194691662,
0.0195753742,
-0.0455319881,
0.0045328792,
-0.0245426204,
0.0133041302,
0.0118313516,
-0.0241716336,
0.0278490204,
-0.0160924941,
-0.0177149866,
-0.0595564693,
0.0280432813,
-0.0441807024,
0.0226413887,
0.0102053648,
0.0384768024,
-0.0251813773,
-0.0078503201,
0.007639525,
0.0281847138,
0.0062991767,
-0.0168115124,
-0.011789212,
-0.0216667727,
0.1171839833,
0.0272462461,
0.0126757193,
-0.0403555147,
0.0257521961,
-0.0102836797,
-0.028484622,
0.0143785253,
0.0102186222,
0.0009782471,
-0.0254991483,
-0.0492691211,
0.0369556546,
0.0286390986,
0.0162474941,
-0.0180158485,
-0.0346239582,
0.0470302179,
0.0327194892,
0.017621737,
-0.004745963,
-0.0259117316,
-0.037431065,
-0.0138987349,
-0.0126746856,
0.0003191772,
0.0398384221,
-0.0546214506,
-0.0085439933,
-0.0898752362,
-0.0361952856,
-0.0255164467,
0.0672381967,
0.0133015327,
0.0264107678,
-0.0051793437,
-0.0157679822,
-0.0076050092,
0.0106847463,
0.0237158891,
-0.0241137706,
0.0114955725,
-0.0099817608,
-0.0051101632,
0.0076448801,
0.0062646735,
-0.0248560794,
-0.0405800827,
-0.0231967121,
-0.0301652495,
0.0262012985,
-0.0369858295,
-0.0433200747,
-0.0150606437,
-0.0550391376,
0.0662967041,
-0.0238375738,
-0.0253209919,
-0.0628452152,
0.0156515948,
0.0442730151,
-0.0186802335,
-0.0168215986,
0.0169472303,
-0.0016225878,
0.0310628563,
0.0477932133,
-0.0152438423,
-0.0340187363,
0.0143808741,
0.0232510976,
-0.058965981,
-0.0023944101,
-0.0286906119,
0.0478413329,
-0.0211730283,
-0.03731139,
0.0962649435,
0.0259237252,
-0.0370071083,
0.0048059602,
0.0072642998,
0.0495189354,
0.0347286277,
0.0090878839,
-0.0733580515,
-0.0276645217,
0.0121439211,
-0.0045796144,
-0.0144252591,
-0.0386892371,
-0.0302716605,
-0.1114688888,
0.0403074659,
0.0300543774,
0.0096827215,
-0.0476432033,
0.0341492072,
-0.0058720522,
0.0013012466,
-0.0193497837,
0.0191123616,
-0.0525109917,
0.0206484329,
-0.0234929603,
0.01425514,
-0.0225998629,
-0.0267855953,
-0.0688672289,
0.0189551637,
-0.0029554302,
0.053195741,
-0.0053256587,
-0.0516227745,
-0.0560229309,
-0.0518850908,
-0.0229677334,
0.0275956355,
0.0298318323,
-0.0405189916,
-0.0059123323,
-0.0418790989,
0.0488555506,
-0.0087563582,
-0.0140732918,
0.0310098622,
0.059239544,
0.0023219902,
0.0156556834,
-0.043958921,
-0.0106925461,
-0.0194328912,
0.0734436065,
0.0022971658,
-0.0487367623,
0.0079515288,
0.0010109367,
0.0050552147,
-0.046790164,
0.0012489927,
-0.0248321071,
-0.0260696858,
0.0446333289,
-0.0716198906,
-0.0320377871,
0.0062469137,
0.0343578234,
0.0025683776,
0.0346999168,
-0.0281110257,
-0.0050173653,
-0.0360478163,
0.0143678663,
-0.0215130318,
0.0237857159,
0.0307174586,
0.0074407756,
0.0027019521,
-0.0266494099,
-0.0142699303,
0.0205927007,
-0.0811341107,
-0.0402943343,
-0.0230936874,
0.0166609082,
0.0192305688,
0.0488450043,
-0.0264661815,
0.0027175536,
-0.0350629799,
0.0248932093,
0.0261483304,
0.0418519787,
0.0305736288,
-0.0214812905,
0.0318431109,
0.0372376852,
0.0430198424,
-0.0000638134,
-0.0207492355,
0.0597961284,
0.0263014995,
0.0043703448,
0.0797806755,
0.0281569064,
0.0086627547,
-0.0357071012,
0.0172557198,
-0.0185311232,
-0.0071941786,
-0.0241233222,
-0.0091783945,
-0.0543847568,
0.0000786527,
0.0684717819,
0.0248074308,
-0.0497742258,
-0.0807468668,
-0.044640746,
-0.0176443718,
-0.0644652992,
-0.0119749298,
-0.0073073232,
-0.0180557165,
-0.0059365747,
-0.0000280335,
-0.0157683007,
-0.0075135585,
-0.0449747294,
0.0236007515,
0.0135586709,
-0.0116816098,
0.0259717684,
-0.0479751416,
-0.0350594521,
0.0390347578,
-0.0470742024,
-0.0152399,
-0.0277423058,
0.0157912821,
0.0300397892,
-0.0534119383,
0.0765899643,
-0.0575932972,
0.0002132349,
0.010881626,
-0.0088971211,
-0.0205127113,
0.0090859737,
-0.0205939412,
0.0283336211,
-0.0114433104,
-0.003946933,
0.0372569859,
-0.0397456139,
0.052516982,
-0.0017512894,
-0.0337886363,
-0.0289096255,
-0.0435287021,
0.0446081609,
0.1021340564,
-0.0053374604,
0.0017655537,
-0.025140116,
-0.0581431873,
-0.0157232955,
0.0174090043,
0.0247342624,
-0.0188114364,
0.0110200671,
0.011024544,
-0.006531945,
0.0218319725,
-0.0178678464,
0.0128977923,
-0.020053532,
-0.0165255219,
-0.0132204313,
-5.799730435e-33,
-0.0161066186,
0.0359713584,
-0.0334026366,
0.0303931646,
-0.0403404012,
-0.0290720277,
-0.0200527105,
0.000574801,
-0.0001861514,
0.0185800437,
-0.0151920561,
-0.0091668982,
-0.0094021866,
0.0180413965,
0.0087128226,
0.0524506159,
0.0254027862,
0.0422098748,
-0.0129835131,
-0.0445205532,
0.0055680508,
0.0322345532,
0.0688196048,
-0.0338021629,
-0.019893324,
-0.0537147708,
-0.0343105346,
-0.0274269488,
0.0285057668,
0.0246724859,
-0.010647242,
0.0666104928,
0.0021690889,
0.061526563,
-0.029160196,
-0.015389964,
-0.068660982,
-0.0152216433,
0.0614926517,
-0.0115712192,
-0.0254207272,
-0.014158478,
0.0385717079,
-0.0404531956,
-0.0172640793,
0.0186933074,
0.050143104,
-0.0416520052,
-0.0031793667,
0.0378163531,
-0.0516121201,
0.0104357945,
0.023616109,
0.0028367259,
-0.0152415214,
0.0419469513,
0.0112637449,
0.0440016761,
-0.0003819023,
-0.0075711394,
0.0260084867,
0.0126372203,
-0.0600657351,
-0.0446592718,
0.0075722099,
0.0646481216,
-0.0156428702,
-0.0194139518,
0.0219682269,
0.0233056229,
0.0081787165,
-0.002061971,
0.0571815372,
0.0626212135,
0.0853207558,
-0.0298010744,
0.0093062455,
0.0481640324,
0.0559423342,
0.0133193834,
0.024127027,
0.0258096196,
-0.0122370766,
0.0057738945,
-0.0178915039,
-0.0367929153,
0.0007150424,
-0.0583601184,
0.0161983185,
0.0201276913,
-0.0366882719,
0.0338647328,
-0.0002630263,
-0.0363536403,
-0.0068201455,
-0.0045217131,
-0.0340816155,
0.0275679715,
0.0045581297,
0.0354309119,
-0.009923392,
-0.0149914436,
0.0192350857,
0.0489950217,
0.0095954267,
-0.0025412703,
0.0371307507,
0.0239645373,
-0.1068538651,
0.0158071574,
-0.0489140339,
-0.0294683184,
-0.0519408882,
-0.0254347418,
0.0191982444,
-0.0000658464,
0.0216876324,
0.0334990211,
0.027271349,
-0.0159780588,
-0.0739267245,
-0.0312809311,
-0.0182332024,
-0.0081205759,
0.0019383024,
0.0085618058,
-0.0302881692,
-0.0411513522,
-0.0113014914,
-0.0662291124,
0.0177301727,
-0.0160007495,
2.727e-7,
0.0127728218,
0.0358175859,
0.0390565917,
-0.0100240679,
0.0049315398,
-0.0088225128,
-0.0039408361,
0.06960278,
-0.0063657211,
0.0424752235,
0.049094297,
-0.0079214601,
-0.005597169,
-0.045605544,
-0.1065840051,
0.0518612973,
-0.0713888481,
-0.0230702013,
-0.069509767,
-0.0339199789,
0.0652134195,
0.0571408942,
0.0583268069,
-0.0034670453,
0.0274362471,
-0.0322995596,
0.0389491506,
-0.0356525779,
-0.0314354859,
-0.0082847439,
0.0109094111,
0.0471275039,
-0.0004838548,
0.0051770587,
-0.0030106141,
0.0555962436,
0.0267591383,
0.0183585752,
-0.0273920856,
0.045955494,
-0.0068748388,
-0.029455753,
-0.0133848209,
-0.0644978136,
0.0773349404,
-0.0014258112,
0.0049980734,
-0.037083488,
-0.0625156313,
0.0128025087,
0.0375989676,
0.0201725978,
-0.0714101419,
0.02513423,
0.0360676534,
0.0280952044,
-0.0129486015,
-0.0517905019,
0.0040507382,
0.0432508327,
-0.023967132,
-0.006941366,
-0.0177772995,
0.0006212778,
0.0130562242,
-0.0706183091,
-0.0125042275,
2.322136285e-34,
0.0374694653,
0.00252764,
0.0347330607,
0.037951842,
0.0425238088,
0.0057711378,
0.014951692,
0.0330334008,
0.0166690797,
-0.0660636947,
-0.0218851175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04076v1 | DataTales: Investigating the use of Large Language Models for Authoring Data-Driven Articles | 2023-08-08T06:21:58 | 2023-08-08T06:21:58 | Nicole Sultanum, Arjun Srinivasan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Authoring data-driven articles is a complex process requiring authors to not
only analyze data for insights but also craft a cohesive narrative that
effectively communicates the insights. Text generation capabilities of
contemporary large language models (LLMs) present an opportunity to assist the
authoring of data-driven articles and expedite the writing process. In this
work, we investigate the feasibility and perceived value of leveraging LLMs to
support authors of data-driven articles. We designed a prototype system,
DataTales, that leverages a LLM to generate textual narratives accompanying a
given chart. Using DataTales as a design probe, we conducted a qualitative
study with 11 professionals to evaluate the concept, from which we distilled
affordances and opportunities to further integrate LLMs as valuable data-driven
article authoring assistants. | [
0.0174656324,
0.0680373684,
-0.0205816608,
-0.0023998206,
-0.032871224,
-0.0028571754,
0.0384471044,
-0.0316150039,
0.0024218594,
-0.0171391685,
0.0131321754,
0.0389133655,
-0.0008069623,
0.0791010112,
-0.0042896597,
-0.0135541661,
-0.0209139828,
-0.0026520316,
0.0357171856,
0.0216938872,
0.0231712069,
0.0515088513,
-0.0130560873,
0.0415579416,
-0.0062452359,
-0.0412923396,
-0.0156136211,
0.0110281585,
0.011064156,
-0.0684945732,
-0.0231982395,
0.0467589237,
0.0489551537,
0.0438918397,
0.0000020172,
-0.026259549,
0.0117284926,
0.0179126356,
-0.0194357242,
-0.0235973038,
0.0630141422,
-0.0084426068,
0.0083037456,
-0.0224451497,
-0.012911588,
-0.0303125028,
0.0432014503,
0.0010729172,
0.0412349366,
0.0214324389,
-0.0199301895,
-0.058509171,
0.0096955579,
0.0137196984,
-0.0056529799,
0.0860488489,
-0.040230751,
0.0415637456,
0.0829339996,
0.0105146831,
0.0276683699,
0.0492793806,
0.0204142295,
-0.0444934033,
0.0335686877,
0.0415394083,
0.0241192188,
-0.0475428328,
0.0170786772,
0.0494013131,
0.0908279344,
-0.0268650576,
-0.00252087,
-0.0256470144,
-0.010142033,
0.0593085289,
-0.104187049,
0.0138985338,
-0.005920724,
-0.0056240698,
0.0007821875,
-0.0196468737,
0.0040102112,
0.0173360594,
0.0067344368,
0.0023762337,
-0.0039887279,
0.0074222018,
-0.018714495,
0.007036414,
0.0398615561,
-0.0748004392,
0.0018091995,
0.0680455193,
0.0004242686,
0.0040695169,
-0.0009801254,
-0.035986986,
0.0199189838,
-0.0307436399,
0.0506249331,
-0.0176533852,
0.0085733049,
-0.0127766281,
0.0443419628,
-0.0106437886,
0.0150124878,
-0.0327141173,
0.0099235382,
0.0459774844,
-0.0097143333,
-0.0452109352,
-0.0250531007,
-0.0125525715,
-0.0149311479,
-0.0275554936,
0.0100029204,
0.0255653579,
0.0224117078,
0.0575814322,
-0.0043433965,
0.0217585508,
-0.0474407561,
0.0194650721,
-0.0060511995,
0.0241694115,
-0.002858452,
0.0212471616,
0.0203361306,
-0.007603833,
0.0274369642,
0.0291567501,
0.0244597159,
-0.007412361,
-0.0106306393,
0.0672416836,
0.0144030312,
0.0164510421,
-0.0397322886,
-0.0711076409,
0.0077347592,
-0.0203270167,
0.0030491755,
-0.0874084458,
0.0287752599,
0.0651092827,
-0.0070561511,
-0.0471984185,
0.0200617798,
0.047020521,
-0.0193043966,
0.0061161346,
-0.0873763263,
0.0031084353,
0.0044110678,
-0.0015545775,
0.0375344753,
0.0575624071,
0.0915734023,
0.0396121666,
0.0383138321,
-0.0149502559,
0.0462342426,
0.0170708373,
-0.0188762471,
0.0308719799,
-0.0509058833,
0.0232151505,
-0.0673157796,
0.0408714712,
-0.0305437595,
0.0175944921,
-0.0290766601,
0.0843048319,
0.1255586594,
0.0678455234,
0.0585424863,
0.0269610658,
0.0449670814,
0.0031929833,
0.0137193231,
-0.0196952689,
0.0180464946,
0.0400915109,
0.068082571,
0.0287304949,
-0.0475603007,
0.0236268714,
-0.0006254563,
-0.036526151,
-0.0090785241,
0.0106508508,
0.0024856657,
0.0118408902,
0.0147279575,
0.0089798728,
0.0085983723,
-0.0095979935,
0.0068749171,
-0.0975515395,
0.0430768579,
0.0178302918,
0.0359430946,
0.0964113623,
0.0724025965,
-0.0115117235,
-0.0119891288,
-0.0455943756,
0.0304865781,
0.0597474016,
0.0176740047,
-0.0073651425,
-0.0537661538,
-0.0154243121,
-0.0128994258,
-0.0603549145,
-0.0163279418,
-0.0233077742,
-0.028627079,
0.0197414197,
0.0004889567,
-0.0382905267,
-0.0707199499,
0.0160992555,
-0.079099156,
-0.0256419573,
-0.0214777961,
-0.0071805222,
-0.0354314558,
0.0593880229,
-0.0414711721,
0.0472446792,
0.0126402769,
0.0001561911,
-0.0126649225,
0.0648106039,
0.027878372,
0.0106172841,
0.0082693957,
-0.0550365448,
0.0134044727,
-0.0429491363,
0.003056078,
-0.0203701183,
0.0053234696,
-0.0514002778,
0.013956096,
0.0159508195,
-0.0252493285,
0.0059366883,
-0.0054740813,
-0.0149602629,
0.0183403976,
-0.0018514579,
0.0234794468,
-0.0055460106,
0.001904928,
0.0083568413,
0.002775389,
0.0376348794,
0.0649719685,
0.0349087864,
0.0090889437,
0.0319998786,
-0.0340456218,
-0.0381533802,
-0.0215093382,
-0.0553578362,
-0.0153166745,
0.0046859086,
0.0050179185,
0.038969446,
-0.0091359196,
-0.0417317301,
0.0082704574,
-0.0497309342,
-0.0271011833,
0.0105569614,
-0.0026981744,
0.0492263436,
0.014438279,
0.0135933068,
-0.0217392836,
0.0250724573,
-0.0108017046,
0.0556576326,
0.0945287123,
0.0025690272,
-0.0350677483,
-0.0019467373,
-0.0448494814,
-0.060550455,
0.0173606444,
0.0093630757,
0.0383316427,
0.0066854688,
0.0553115122,
-0.000807262,
-0.0305917095,
0.0668762922,
0.0447059199,
-0.1038607135,
-0.005972791,
-0.0189421661,
-0.0220440906,
0.0501820482,
0.0153047116,
-0.0542109646,
0.0275080092,
0.0346777216,
0.0216317661,
0.0097668031,
0.0129694929,
0.0562567301,
-0.0201108344,
0.0371250473,
0.0123637682,
-0.0205703285,
0.0070195091,
0.0545161217,
-0.0050780834,
-0.0331880637,
0.0175143573,
-0.0332386307,
-0.0021108165,
-0.0220970716,
-0.0463745594,
-0.0517206043,
0.0540697239,
-0.0112621784,
0.0029291362,
-0.0308143925,
0.0072133373,
-0.0324760005,
0.0147240274,
0.0163706299,
-0.0247323401,
0.0056109345,
-0.0482807532,
-0.0300734844,
-0.0253585242,
0.0227768216,
0.0137728304,
-0.0049045663,
-0.0459279455,
0.0009755486,
0.0564873852,
-0.0451096632,
-0.0318493396,
-0.0312905274,
0.0736332461,
0.0424091443,
-0.0084901918,
-0.014292418,
-0.0289637242,
0.0145081151,
0.0242648218,
-0.0396185145,
-0.0006038777,
-0.0372262001,
0.0591099337,
0.0349308662,
-0.0518096946,
0.0130406907,
-0.0265306719,
-0.0246131644,
-0.0034878813,
-0.0169367194,
-0.0462240018,
0.0012280298,
0.0323341638,
-0.0383896567,
0.0064436328,
0.0678093061,
0.0263310615,
-0.0391868651,
0.0049700015,
-0.0166006889,
0.0156537686,
0.0147646284,
0.0302765928,
-0.1169011146,
0.0247239172,
0.0109842308,
0.0405653343,
-0.0284321494,
-0.0292435251,
-0.0358769372,
-0.059198875,
0.0589126647,
0.0027769019,
0.0003594042,
0.0299252495,
-0.0682769716,
-0.0084295068,
0.0329039805,
-0.0307308957,
0.002885415,
-0.0162116885,
0.02473999,
-0.0095093939,
-0.0767384395,
-0.0424210727,
-0.050440032,
0.004006532,
0.0032691422,
0.0343615338,
0.0781449899,
-0.0213335492,
0.0167784821,
-0.0744871497,
0.0475861393,
-0.011308575,
-0.0039177174,
0.028793484,
0.0044966182,
0.0014242072,
-0.0558633506,
0.0566395335,
-0.0051915972,
-0.0402248688,
0.014427918,
0.0372434594,
-0.027095722,
0.0035977273,
-0.0480491444,
0.0133439237,
0.0255619772,
0.0200638995,
0.0705708414,
-0.0498907641,
-0.033023145,
-0.0252110641,
0.0180687904,
-0.0486928932,
-0.0172827132,
-0.0002973194,
-0.0318696164,
-0.0043302872,
-0.0493861213,
-0.0777109861,
0.0402115546,
-0.0031631798,
0.042904336,
0.0195984133,
0.0074818619,
-0.04790489,
-0.0666570812,
-0.0072394568,
-0.0120777972,
0.038052626,
-0.0108460095,
-0.0180274863,
-0.0050015328,
-0.0321403407,
0.0301388931,
0.0310610384,
-0.0728056431,
-0.0255576652,
0.00214455,
-0.0107227629,
0.0256606713,
-0.0268764757,
0.0314605869,
-0.056126371,
0.0306313671,
0.0804945976,
-0.0392719917,
-0.0250036158,
-0.0407474376,
0.0814706907,
0.0093005523,
-0.0383258387,
-0.0197287239,
0.0136125935,
0.0044925348,
0.0110888388,
-0.0062695448,
0.0257177446,
0.0092924591,
0.0251162145,
-0.0179666765,
-0.0455955826,
0.0071299486,
-0.0547657646,
-0.0139862513,
-0.0934297889,
-0.0484575331,
-0.0345883146,
0.0049889358,
-0.015809942,
-0.0163346343,
0.002178831,
0.0096063064,
-0.0326035246,
-0.0091520101,
-0.1081790477,
0.0822475702,
0.015512336,
-0.0195015036,
0.0225706939,
-0.0139202494,
-0.0397895984,
-0.0152097261,
-0.0406362489,
0.0243790038,
0.0282019451,
0.0292580519,
0.0106914518,
-0.0268457606,
0.023848569,
0.0142594855,
-0.0543061458,
-0.051584363,
-0.0021744187,
-0.0024200343,
0.0160563737,
0.0004341104,
0.0390942879,
-0.0342544205,
-0.0027842878,
0.0124107031,
0.0416083299,
0.0184795596,
0.0007842963,
-0.0185077656,
-0.0033256696,
-0.0391767882,
-0.0573934726,
0.0671489388,
-0.0004070084,
0.0052058259,
-0.0139941713,
-0.0392452143,
-0.0310758073,
-0.0280589424,
0.0576207899,
-0.0358062759,
0.0118930303,
-0.0138779664,
-0.0818843693,
-0.0660702363,
-0.0032316942,
-0.0093680704,
-0.024022704,
-0.0621453598,
-0.0257313587,
0.009636526,
0.0201182347,
-0.0171981324,
-0.0474846847,
0.0597399734,
-0.0362694561,
-0.0347461812,
-0.0005067234,
-5.50640235e-33,
-0.0035776303,
-0.0690671057,
0.0258532446,
0.0004854899,
-0.0167418811,
0.0172868092,
-0.0298674833,
-0.0085027246,
0.0399202742,
0.0303119868,
-0.0134439971,
-0.0198193435,
-0.0090253996,
0.0237915069,
-0.0021129481,
0.0211251508,
0.0593461879,
0.0005549684,
-0.043040175,
0.0338112526,
0.0197996106,
-0.004268392,
0.0012846293,
-0.0765480474,
0.0832848251,
-0.0634600446,
-0.0117570795,
-0.0156407636,
0.0399587266,
0.0210401155,
0.0053975959,
0.0068046437,
0.0198187381,
-0.0017543015,
-0.0369473547,
0.0549186766,
-0.0323728137,
-0.0207624901,
0.0271096807,
0.0234754346,
-0.0094651645,
-0.00872753,
0.0538063422,
-0.0229395051,
-0.0006373277,
0.0183895361,
0.0422925949,
-0.0362345614,
-0.0184284505,
-0.0455718786,
-0.0469803959,
0.0220547523,
-0.0184909366,
0.0215759296,
0.0000525409,
0.0466257334,
0.0075950739,
0.0057995147,
-0.0585300513,
0.0401674323,
0.0352723859,
-0.0132376375,
0.0397369377,
0.0125252884,
0.0204346981,
0.0692474768,
0.0115107317,
0.032186877,
-0.0565809794,
0.0936162993,
-0.009571665,
0.0409724675,
0.0567002371,
0.0261214264,
-0.0331822,
-0.0078998832,
-0.0378865115,
0.0386530347,
-0.0455349162,
-0.0190601591,
0.026565183,
0.003834154,
-0.0254190397,
-0.0479128361,
-0.0352132618,
-0.0070791668,
-0.0253803171,
-0.0457089432,
-0.0138723664,
-0.0308569483,
-0.0388728008,
0.0282618403,
-0.0271341652,
-0.0005203697,
-0.0625194386,
0.0092798313,
-0.0303589646,
0.0485046282,
-0.0006904904,
-0.0369868763,
-0.0257012956,
0.0288423412,
-0.011020367,
0.0325663239,
0.0453779101,
0.0308579616,
0.0298636779,
0.0383850448,
-0.0567034259,
-0.0156614892,
-0.0072157863,
0.0142429061,
0.0301703084,
-0.0396740809,
0.0262468439,
-0.0275656674,
0.0014229857,
0.0211026203,
0.0406962745,
0.0122427261,
-0.0025145805,
-0.0329320319,
-0.0334306881,
0.0079300012,
-0.0015765505,
-0.0112716425,
-0.0035992123,
0.0020472326,
0.0660179034,
-0.03819374,
-0.0100139631,
-0.0555257276,
2.602e-7,
0.0489652939,
0.0307278261,
0.0019463698,
0.0208945274,
0.0233195852,
-0.0118050715,
0.0057658562,
-0.0135923,
-0.005413231,
0.0117199998,
0.0202394351,
0.0142129567,
0.0383861698,
0.0954612345,
-0.0467964113,
0.0058425753,
-0.0486942679,
-0.0228350982,
-0.0862769037,
0.0167809818,
0.0831034184,
-0.061401058,
0.0115224775,
-0.0118236924,
-0.0215125829,
-0.0547412969,
0.0272708442,
-0.0447337553,
0.0139011992,
0.0347848758,
0.0045627998,
0.0251839925,
0.0059192162,
-0.0237420946,
-0.0268695038,
0.0010379602,
-0.0072195195,
0.0087916506,
0.0198974162,
0.0650912002,
0.0592452288,
-0.0437844917,
0.0103383847,
-0.0701899752,
0.0352441445,
-0.0578840189,
-0.0657788068,
-0.0331904218,
-0.0041954843,
-0.0504131876,
0.0149084525,
-0.043636132,
-0.0223742705,
0.0212967899,
-0.0168354958,
-0.0045705321,
0.013802018,
0.0187672041,
-0.0394311696,
0.0565610155,
-0.0160627924,
-0.0194932502,
-0.0370611921,
-0.0039437525,
-0.0510655269,
-0.0456420109,
0.0395851098,
2.381223013e-34,
0.0212907195,
0.0024337426,
-0.0206183549,
0.0224286653,
0.0813353807,
0.0016946148,
0.0456232429,
0.0099829072,
0.0389259905,
-0.0264067873,
-0.0238827132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04052v1 | The Five-Dollar Model: Generating Game Maps and Sprites from Sentence Embeddings | 2023-08-08T05:16:51 | 2023-08-08T05:16:51 | Timothy Merino, Roman Negri, Dipika Rajesh, M Charity, Julian Togelius | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | The five-dollar model is a lightweight text-to-image generative architecture
that generates low dimensional images from an encoded text prompt. This model
can successfully generate accurate and aesthetically pleasing content in low
dimensional domains, with limited amounts of training data. Despite the small
size of both the model and datasets, the generated images are still able to
maintain the encoded semantic meaning of the textual prompt. We apply this
model to three small datasets: pixel art video game maps, video game sprite
images, and down-scaled emoji images and apply novel augmentation strategies to
improve the performance of our model on these limited datasets. We evaluate our
models performance using cosine similarity score between text-image pairs
generated by the CLIP VIT-B/32 model. | [
0.0298760496,
0.0578299798,
-0.0161026698,
0.0702810138,
0.0247102287,
0.0173594318,
0.0133907804,
-0.0125446022,
-0.0069231763,
-0.0009601539,
-0.0203494299,
0.0028563363,
0.0009806274,
0.0525746979,
0.0206779577,
-0.1023986861,
-0.0172612537,
-0.0086108316,
-0.011477042,
-0.0165234357,
0.00598846,
0.0047946419,
0.0070986571,
0.0389766544,
-0.0599438511,
-0.0217247568,
-0.0301261973,
0.0421150327,
0.0162175726,
-0.0643359721,
-0.0234129224,
0.0059405481,
0.0262449123,
0.004500859,
0.0000021276,
0.010656747,
0.0270277821,
-0.0165525749,
0.0560188293,
0.0374023728,
0.0369481705,
-0.0231834929,
-0.012130335,
-0.0041780644,
-0.0110295471,
0.0135328816,
0.1071215868,
0.0564415194,
0.120039694,
0.0362030454,
-0.0142829642,
-0.0691565946,
-0.0262649748,
-0.0267304815,
0.031756442,
0.0122224269,
-0.0226398725,
0.0079840627,
0.0062787244,
0.054437682,
-0.0204342958,
0.0166493468,
0.0309232846,
0.0217146017,
0.0065787565,
0.066394873,
0.0584594645,
0.0202149656,
-0.0070754769,
0.0424854755,
-0.058252085,
0.0176737756,
0.0080862893,
0.0031463727,
0.0088401232,
-0.0041348529,
-0.0523836799,
-0.0115342494,
0.0239584222,
0.0336478017,
-0.0732193515,
0.0290256385,
0.021378858,
-0.0209980737,
0.0082587292,
-0.0327092074,
0.0189417657,
-0.0348528475,
-0.0954638869,
0.0411605686,
-0.058620628,
-0.0180361066,
-0.0066665327,
0.0106556518,
0.0140696848,
0.0228969846,
-0.0695840195,
-0.0269984212,
0.002242001,
-0.0309854373,
0.0562067851,
0.0016782379,
-0.0355396532,
0.0494656935,
-0.0248649418,
0.0192458127,
0.0202424638,
0.0234646816,
-0.0447253808,
0.0080376472,
-0.0166239552,
-0.0184490159,
-0.061679583,
0.022934895,
-0.052396182,
-0.0319232345,
-0.0484517142,
0.0058303881,
0.0005653366,
0.0398158208,
-0.0040359697,
0.0574191622,
-0.0310856104,
0.0246607978,
-0.0218131933,
-0.0146141686,
-0.0357227325,
0.016751159,
0.0249926616,
-0.0163337328,
-0.0242467001,
-0.0274723135,
0.0666810721,
0.0001046812,
0.0010594582,
0.0449262783,
-0.0049034427,
-0.0326427035,
-0.0206291266,
-0.0116034634,
-0.0511184484,
-0.0032597512,
0.0193110909,
-0.0608636364,
0.0256864168,
-0.0545804724,
0.029435223,
0.0026010536,
0.0044522863,
0.0208976865,
-0.0234632883,
0.0704960525,
0.004041614,
0.0144749777,
0.0088742338,
-0.0003146533,
0.0153465364,
0.0168321226,
0.05602929,
0.0875044912,
0.0135516813,
-0.0352134258,
-0.0119291525,
0.0429000892,
0.0136297029,
0.0168348756,
-0.0213794187,
-0.0318220258,
-0.0277189165,
0.0703900531,
0.0147992829,
0.0466740429,
-0.0401274338,
-0.0346990675,
0.1150740907,
0.0705754533,
0.0200357679,
-0.0028114384,
0.0560881793,
0.0371858738,
-0.0065762331,
-0.0290088933,
0.003610862,
0.0423641987,
0.0344358794,
0.0205283761,
0.016766239,
0.0369954705,
-0.0472978987,
-0.027659893,
0.0379198492,
-0.0585648529,
0.031544026,
-0.0173819773,
0.0298914295,
-0.0000889455,
-0.051876992,
0.0041037193,
-0.0231426097,
-0.0797290727,
0.0146307535,
0.003835835,
0.0512684323,
0.0713301897,
0.0300069135,
0.0323280357,
0.0135097178,
-0.0119205127,
0.0042812284,
0.0751709789,
0.0020401797,
0.0056650667,
0.0291404352,
-0.0387161411,
-0.0379264429,
-0.0722627267,
0.0006302132,
0.0230942946,
-0.0163100362,
0.0456871986,
0.0236255731,
-0.0208769683,
0.005874909,
0.0172254033,
0.0223509893,
-0.0409063622,
-0.0043649641,
0.0356256478,
-0.02174519,
0.0099233063,
-0.0488066599,
0.0246271212,
0.0287169032,
-0.0501220152,
0.0076233805,
0.0303606484,
-0.0416483767,
-0.0406092741,
0.0333042704,
-0.0825767145,
0.027304383,
0.0221198816,
-0.039711494,
-0.0201484486,
0.006946438,
-0.0443620719,
0.0270172898,
-0.027601881,
-0.0121678803,
0.0081601162,
0.0353242271,
-0.0066949897,
0.0374679565,
-0.0460658669,
-0.0234039761,
-0.0192234926,
0.0169328526,
0.0034487802,
-0.0091138473,
-0.0193579793,
-0.0252486411,
-0.0041512204,
-0.0111794136,
0.0120710107,
0.0092592435,
-0.0425443985,
-0.0296217166,
-0.0610066839,
-0.0431711376,
0.0285084434,
-0.0405442528,
0.0049456717,
0.0065160957,
-0.0078479638,
-0.0106429756,
-0.0476481132,
0.0149560915,
0.0222131163,
0.0308173373,
0.0454917997,
-0.0169172026,
0.0337871537,
-0.0213317834,
0.003409588,
0.0249192156,
0.0187822673,
0.0008461032,
-0.0129898917,
-0.0323297977,
0.0397190526,
-0.0213183146,
0.0066766394,
0.0115273716,
-0.0763927102,
0.0224693958,
-0.0077651017,
0.0398708358,
0.0386889204,
0.0253658704,
0.0024888061,
0.0226343889,
-0.0327665582,
-0.0289418269,
0.0073119318,
-0.0059768017,
-0.0003187275,
0.0031348222,
-0.0301358383,
0.0286765192,
0.0425616316,
0.0125244996,
0.0493864268,
-0.0940339118,
0.0342459045,
0.0103184804,
-0.0373142138,
-0.0180100333,
0.0200558808,
0.0147811547,
-0.0194395781,
-0.0710208043,
-0.0286549311,
0.015271116,
-0.0764508769,
-0.0277935881,
0.0103965253,
0.0354676507,
0.0101274913,
0.0544803329,
0.0306424107,
0.0444534607,
0.0047286833,
0.0140359374,
0.011453825,
0.0241034292,
0.0163138397,
-0.0192371141,
0.002438891,
-0.0064956266,
-0.0225093216,
0.0000094428,
-0.0585972331,
-0.0168370679,
-0.041916959,
-0.0114198793,
-0.0556078888,
-0.0053416067,
-0.0356222168,
-0.0202981457,
-0.0030627223,
0.010702461,
0.0252387188,
-0.010125475,
-0.0287544616,
-0.0127255768,
0.0607769378,
0.1012394279,
0.0332900286,
-0.01950166,
-0.0349218398,
0.0343512483,
0.0283082481,
-0.0341372825,
-0.0042366711,
-0.0489337631,
0.0162518546,
0.0108666997,
0.0248422213,
-0.0103947911,
0.0529619604,
0.0526248179,
-0.0368888713,
-0.0435593054,
0.0669305697,
0.017098451,
0.0220647156,
0.0173138194,
0.0163017698,
0.0275010727,
0.007407798,
-0.0169445276,
-0.0832111314,
-0.0289841406,
-0.0119850012,
-0.025688231,
0.0054281848,
-0.0128578544,
-0.0087242201,
-0.1282889694,
0.0609477721,
0.0116432775,
-0.0004716871,
-0.0111314692,
-0.0051917508,
0.0106082046,
0.039464917,
-0.036600247,
-0.0532560721,
0.0126201324,
0.0092232767,
0.0324006155,
0.0272861142,
-0.0335035846,
-0.0273690857,
-0.0222820006,
0.0457560681,
0.0681577846,
0.0536798313,
0.0048495973,
-0.0778734908,
-0.0387539603,
0.0641246811,
0.0073045376,
0.0028442787,
0.0768998563,
0.0128579363,
-0.0154121844,
0.0148983477,
0.0210742559,
0.0065969243,
0.0023824507,
0.0117759798,
0.0370611735,
0.0106199197,
-0.002089818,
-0.0688456297,
0.0086904047,
0.0106693571,
0.0526089966,
0.0427092463,
-0.0462516211,
-0.0131059745,
-0.0108574266,
0.0417354032,
-0.096386902,
-0.0206227209,
-0.0178888459,
0.037719544,
-0.0315842964,
-0.0677883551,
-0.0755278841,
0.0005604067,
0.025996564,
-0.0131201744,
-0.0231219325,
-0.0227662027,
0.0046141441,
-0.0106886653,
0.0179046504,
-0.0500676632,
-0.0017863875,
-0.0338073559,
0.0037399803,
-0.011680942,
-0.0745231733,
-0.001494062,
0.0100457054,
-0.0876232088,
-0.0024328649,
-0.0099743903,
0.1012958959,
-0.0031269328,
0.0036739861,
-0.0241746232,
-0.0443164706,
0.0737346038,
0.0568149574,
-0.0201681796,
-0.02401614,
-0.0016685305,
0.0184103921,
0.0296923518,
-0.0141005628,
-0.0520237684,
0.0495297797,
0.0122870784,
0.0314396583,
-0.0081058973,
-0.0065700943,
0.0222702287,
-0.0049131494,
0.0503006652,
-0.0651755482,
0.0144199617,
0.0082381479,
0.0069589121,
-0.0404898077,
-0.0024713494,
-0.0422651358,
-0.0189377535,
0.0187086761,
0.0274465568,
-0.0045487667,
-0.03891702,
0.0459053107,
0.0256872177,
-0.0391180143,
-0.0267476086,
0.0554101244,
0.0034408751,
-0.0169376303,
0.0067409347,
0.0142937191,
0.0443963185,
-0.0701813847,
0.018191291,
0.0026453526,
-0.0060965479,
0.0064170305,
-0.043979153,
-0.0339139514,
0.0655761212,
-0.0068463702,
-0.0204894152,
-0.0383269526,
0.0453847833,
0.0675508082,
-0.0026926349,
0.0401463546,
-0.0007432702,
0.0012507933,
-0.0149105489,
-0.0189792272,
0.0304661747,
-0.0898297727,
0.0234010331,
-0.0032213647,
0.0122813731,
-0.0555382408,
0.0209536888,
-0.0212089866,
0.0387955569,
0.0032397457,
-0.0370917991,
-0.0234615598,
0.0293318201,
0.0098932702,
0.034893278,
-0.0275929403,
0.0369913802,
-0.0218258426,
-0.0293059032,
0.0223800037,
0.0686141476,
0.0139102452,
0.0294977445,
0.0160361547,
0.0149678979,
-0.0165780578,
0.0117942365,
0.0021114904,
0.0174926966,
-0.0469372869,
-0.0686003044,
-0.0157994181,
-5.821921932e-33,
-0.033090733,
-0.0161779057,
0.027769411,
-0.0205311328,
-0.0023011754,
0.008106458,
-0.05772027,
0.0153199965,
0.008479869,
-0.0028238741,
-0.0126277925,
-0.0478344113,
-0.0070724939,
0.0701676831,
0.0090908203,
0.0107788257,
0.0663134754,
0.0237257853,
-0.0368335247,
0.0190994963,
0.013205084,
0.0149951233,
0.0413728878,
-0.0596804805,
-0.0370299742,
-0.0135365836,
-0.0327003635,
-0.0213301536,
0.0650536269,
0.0575821809,
-0.0194679238,
0.0196660329,
0.0102000339,
-0.0225140899,
-0.0184748061,
0.0135855228,
-0.0663105249,
-0.0232450757,
-0.0085694278,
0.0073097879,
-0.0360246599,
-0.04743791,
0.019678453,
-0.0199362803,
0.0068247756,
-0.0421515815,
0.0587869063,
-0.016781399,
0.0064172726,
0.000871512,
-0.0797451735,
-0.0137710217,
-0.0282076746,
-0.0632434711,
0.0486355014,
0.0824816972,
0.0356876403,
0.0664078593,
-0.043307595,
0.0674783215,
0.0089778695,
-0.0117413029,
0.0383856483,
0.0365033448,
0.0178878065,
0.0754184574,
-0.0121418834,
-0.0216958504,
-0.0952532738,
0.0189146847,
0.0407103039,
0.0363867432,
0.0537067056,
0.0705848038,
0.0530687347,
-0.0421155654,
-0.0267872922,
0.0634122938,
0.0212199632,
0.0219633132,
0.0294771157,
0.0391573422,
-0.0344695598,
0.0195364989,
-0.0269456767,
-0.0374830477,
-0.0258243643,
-0.074774541,
0.0528477207,
0.0089831082,
-0.0167440344,
-0.0062613781,
0.039028272,
-0.0279063843,
-0.0228210911,
-0.0239480771,
-0.0217197668,
0.0257973988,
-0.0319069922,
-0.0209035985,
0.0019675808,
0.000015923,
0.0795037076,
-0.0061657787,
-0.0043192301,
0.0419164263,
0.0302842837,
0.0205363724,
-0.0221313648,
-0.006351734,
-0.0320216902,
0.0044828993,
-0.0146987988,
-0.0131147485,
0.0081031881,
-0.0286533218,
-0.0563845634,
-0.001763146,
-0.0236641355,
0.0246121995,
-0.0135503747,
-0.0446038991,
-0.032752607,
-0.0231032968,
-0.0046627978,
-0.0026009576,
-0.055622004,
0.0045776591,
0.0014664498,
-0.0622013621,
-0.0477713607,
-0.015827382,
2.854e-7,
-0.0261707567,
0.0082904343,
-0.0250368845,
0.0054180282,
-0.006670652,
0.0560502,
-0.0243951287,
0.0060527469,
-0.0093249585,
-0.0308037139,
0.0383826606,
0.0326557755,
0.0486341454,
-0.0091598043,
-0.0483587608,
0.0436771885,
-0.0878744423,
0.0255044531,
-0.0082264747,
0.0382887162,
0.0630306378,
0.0674570054,
0.0425459072,
-0.0267196968,
0.0617470033,
0.0034161285,
0.0512456894,
-0.0522154011,
-0.0006264722,
-0.0388294458,
-0.0060536792,
0.0062173572,
-0.004121107,
-0.0510830097,
-0.0223060641,
0.0175587628,
0.0634513497,
0.0115413889,
-0.0253341794,
0.0488193817,
-0.0218055248,
0.0080356235,
-0.0135630248,
-0.062087968,
0.0430681333,
-0.0295031797,
-0.0274659935,
-0.0516509824,
-0.0339079127,
0.0301174447,
0.0339866877,
-0.0569318645,
-0.0457366556,
-0.0650461838,
0.0579307564,
-0.0232641324,
0.0162374564,
-0.0319607444,
-0.0273274016,
-0.0143993134,
-0.0266373418,
0.010514169,
-0.105191052,
0.0271863099,
0.0023451033,
-0.0246783756,
-0.0097747622,
2.32337285e-34,
-0.0411327481,
-0.0207787864,
0.0108124539,
-0.0322646014,
0.0369877331,
0.0036842334,
0.0319613479,
-0.006562877,
0.0070545045,
-0.0497701801,
-0.0039604432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04041v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04041v1 | InfeRE: Step-by-Step Regex Generation via Chain of Inference | 2023-08-08T04:37:41 | 2023-08-08T04:37:41 | Shuai Zhang, Xiaodong Gu, Yuting Chen, Beijun Shen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Automatically generating regular expressions (abbrev. regexes) from natural
language description (NL2RE) has been an emerging research area. Prior studies
treat regex as a linear sequence of tokens and generate the final expressions
autoregressively in a single pass. They did not take into account the
step-by-step internal text-matching processes behind the final results. This
significantly hinders the efficacy and interpretability of regex generation by
neural language models. In this paper, we propose a new paradigm called InfeRE,
which decomposes the generation of regexes into chains of step-by-step
inference. To enhance the robustness, we introduce a self-consistency decoding
mechanism that ensembles multiple outputs sampled from different models. We
evaluate InfeRE on two publicly available datasets, NL-RX-Turk and KB13, and
compare the results with state-of-the-art approaches and the popular tree-based
generation approach TRANX. Experimental results show that InfeRE substantially
outperforms previous baselines, yielding 16.3% and 14.7% improvement in DFA@5
accuracy on two datasets, respectively. Particularly, InfeRE outperforms the
popular tree-based generation approach by 18.1% and 11.3% on both datasets,
respectively, in terms of DFA@5 accuracy. | [
0.0520871356,
0.1324436069,
-0.0085206935,
0.0384204127,
-0.0410646461,
-0.0008607257,
0.0276876763,
0.0097665684,
-0.0302025061,
-0.077476643,
0.0036746629,
-0.0511897765,
0.004471289,
0.0866385847,
0.0382427014,
-0.0246633422,
0.0190186538,
-0.0223314632,
-0.0233853702,
0.0027481869,
0.0050590509,
0.0422305018,
0.0070881289,
0.0774609149,
-0.0394781008,
0.0132881179,
0.0014591244,
0.0031987361,
-0.0285458975,
-0.0398894772,
0.0246684086,
0.0751236603,
0.0113061834,
0.029711986,
0.000002143,
-0.057988517,
-0.0301738083,
0.0054142755,
-0.024213301,
0.0204168744,
0.022063002,
0.0013571336,
0.0132380109,
0.0290950704,
-0.0015525635,
-0.0427387804,
0.061694365,
0.0398547575,
0.0539764203,
0.0633233041,
-0.006106779,
-0.0635589808,
0.002792425,
-0.0327795483,
-0.0224000737,
-0.022587359,
0.0250179786,
-0.0351881534,
-0.0201387852,
-0.007033139,
-0.0103118746,
-0.0122898752,
0.0104202703,
-0.0136319147,
-0.018316932,
0.0089900149,
-0.0000257182,
-0.0423939601,
-0.0232880041,
0.0815940723,
-0.033878088,
-0.0308110528,
0.0260490961,
0.0027644229,
-0.0186012909,
-0.0025103951,
-0.0033452811,
0.0709111392,
-0.0328574069,
0.0245773736,
0.0179381482,
0.0309035238,
0.0423656516,
0.0105076153,
-0.0321153365,
0.0498716049,
0.0298941918,
-0.0086595016,
-0.0341521688,
-0.0126558114,
-0.0110399257,
-0.0632777363,
0.0237647612,
0.0061890767,
0.0116374632,
0.0247202292,
-0.0574373752,
-0.0147108203,
0.0108251041,
0.0356203951,
0.0286777169,
0.0621748231,
-0.0522460863,
0.0037617369,
-0.0909073502,
0.0369077884,
0.0023371347,
-0.0278504156,
-0.0278159659,
-0.0117184417,
-0.0184406191,
-0.001100804,
-0.0169223584,
0.0295224227,
-0.0481038839,
-0.0187898669,
-0.0513902344,
0.0045052906,
0.0047509931,
-0.0061933459,
0.0193055905,
0.03913109,
-0.0350960754,
-0.0096159801,
-0.0164151415,
-0.0138008641,
-0.028171001,
-0.0116984462,
0.0219251588,
-0.0460695326,
-0.0293265246,
0.0324640572,
0.019141281,
-0.0044917413,
-0.0023328254,
0.0576115921,
-0.0002768313,
-0.0151526481,
-0.0305433441,
-0.0597692765,
-0.0226771086,
-0.0600217097,
0.0318682343,
-0.0572417043,
0.0526174493,
-0.0064394563,
-0.016874332,
-0.0771986172,
0.0309775956,
0.0217992309,
0.0018256814,
0.0473457687,
-0.0459454134,
-0.0009024148,
0.0105374027,
0.0008751455,
-0.0037217694,
0.0467143096,
0.0450487547,
0.0419706739,
0.0121292342,
-0.0128472392,
0.0699483752,
0.0463198237,
0.0144144157,
-0.0571717955,
-0.0286878068,
-0.0103984056,
-0.0310222395,
0.0215255097,
0.062712498,
0.0585581176,
-0.0422524847,
0.0017151678,
0.0129544465,
0.080932498,
0.026091041,
0.0405691378,
0.0860399157,
-0.0163279511,
0.0262878612,
0.0034857204,
-0.046066463,
0.0057833968,
-0.0044582784,
0.0362607576,
0.0073692626,
0.0548642203,
-0.0179402679,
-0.051347848,
-0.0464859903,
-0.0357098877,
0.0043927114,
-0.0321552306,
0.0467055663,
0.0199073199,
-0.0488629788,
0.0184972305,
0.0180709641,
-0.058119446,
0.003246736,
-0.0553255901,
0.0180176888,
0.0388699248,
0.0760652348,
0.044708211,
-0.0061010369,
0.0007497721,
-0.0281374734,
0.0467290021,
0.0181749351,
-0.0158789288,
0.0296203922,
-0.0743238106,
-0.0483373813,
-0.0309887733,
0.0293238424,
0.0219724104,
0.0144615499,
-0.0498873144,
0.0459611341,
-0.0128094656,
-0.0288177095,
0.0932153389,
-0.0154266432,
-0.0186455082,
0.0781543255,
0.0184946172,
0.0621292666,
0.0052120406,
-0.0136061748,
0.0265044197,
0.0201323926,
-0.0265787654,
-0.0098672407,
0.0395535231,
-0.0837458894,
-0.0653641224,
0.0219154954,
0.0085844025,
-0.0142330555,
0.0317872241,
-0.0278603695,
-0.0558943599,
0.0551328547,
-0.0399960279,
0.0138665671,
-0.0539266244,
0.013490363,
0.0268388614,
0.0373649001,
-0.0050126468,
0.0619678572,
0.0117497575,
-0.035279315,
-0.0143459504,
-0.0046297484,
0.0335272923,
-0.0182685871,
-0.0165911838,
-0.0317858756,
-0.0303563066,
-0.0337802731,
0.024748154,
0.0326622277,
-0.015723493,
0.0155859059,
-0.0021305389,
-0.0354633294,
-0.0300828908,
0.0352434665,
0.0540514812,
0.0236099754,
-0.0221803021,
-0.0268740579,
-0.0160518419,
-0.0089120213,
0.0446265116,
-0.0307714101,
0.057908088,
-0.0043499204,
-0.0686102957,
-0.0391195081,
-0.0110379886,
-0.0408899076,
0.0600426756,
0.021673087,
-0.039423421,
-0.0557281077,
-0.0245989915,
-0.002326262,
0.0357711315,
0.0098267626,
-0.022733137,
0.0045523592,
-0.0129611893,
0.0413267352,
0.0206562337,
0.0203983299,
0.0158023331,
0.0816579536,
0.0072350278,
-0.0268649701,
-0.0092629977,
-0.0438972563,
0.0137053151,
0.0034144688,
-0.0395780094,
0.0191418119,
0.0605317615,
0.0684691891,
-0.0056415414,
-0.0188283268,
0.0087507749,
0.0546876527,
-0.0097280946,
-0.0110602863,
-0.0710180476,
-0.0180976875,
0.0533425622,
-0.0303258356,
-0.0352290757,
0.086826466,
-0.069695577,
-0.0063173105,
-0.0665211976,
0.0119229583,
-0.0547115132,
0.0876898468,
0.0250339992,
0.0315752514,
0.0514399111,
-0.03751022,
0.0385498926,
-0.0172203742,
-0.0025771495,
-0.0144987497,
0.0162312705,
-0.0662100688,
0.01493748,
0.0097914329,
-0.0042619337,
-0.0684455633,
-0.0261787735,
-0.0272297598,
0.0047269096,
0.0152074937,
-0.0209324062,
-0.0195949767,
0.0309076924,
0.001871348,
0.0549072102,
-0.0183059685,
-0.0081142122,
-0.001245555,
0.0343415923,
0.0280866735,
0.024640318,
0.0064706262,
-0.0165039059,
0.0272106528,
0.0261990298,
0.0187587235,
0.0543308221,
-0.0535869859,
0.0056183031,
0.0166230965,
-0.0260297284,
0.0427771211,
0.0450726897,
0.000030888,
-0.0720086172,
-0.0396859236,
0.1147812232,
0.0245433096,
-0.0231149774,
0.0462334678,
0.0035630071,
0.0384304225,
0.0167426318,
0.0073774732,
-0.0767741203,
-0.0552915074,
0.0210808553,
0.0552635118,
-0.0087722419,
-0.0034908557,
-0.0161754508,
-0.1083560288,
0.0567461886,
-0.000243439,
-0.037356317,
-0.0095357159,
-0.0500753298,
0.011174188,
-0.018650867,
-0.0052753636,
0.033041168,
0.0245504007,
0.0095693795,
-0.008701615,
-0.0922704563,
-0.089158237,
0.026308421,
-0.0460745282,
0.0358190872,
0.0970804989,
0.0079572629,
0.024177026,
-0.0134451594,
0.0444275253,
-0.0242386125,
0.0115573499,
-0.013270081,
0.0769591331,
-0.0114604654,
-0.0145845953,
0.0046408297,
0.0581508949,
-0.07769721,
0.0030831548,
-0.0086331414,
0.0237829182,
0.0007809685,
-0.0412579514,
-0.0150874667,
-0.0204987507,
0.01342774,
0.0776640922,
0.040773686,
-0.027616404,
-0.0482777469,
-0.0315900445,
0.0138412435,
-0.0867135227,
-0.0003325124,
-0.0090179872,
0.0100895837,
-0.0128101017,
-0.0666048676,
-0.0366155021,
0.0167605411,
0.0355417617,
-0.0209175851,
0.0036035236,
0.0147655103,
0.0071479725,
-0.0288951229,
0.033771012,
0.0063681658,
-0.0217367522,
0.0136218015,
0.0059315893,
-0.0086259339,
-0.0362539738,
-0.0154823428,
0.0724660605,
-0.0546523444,
-0.0185708068,
-0.0078821974,
0.0379087999,
0.0199714899,
0.0360815078,
-0.0181405898,
-0.0167252384,
0.0006265014,
0.0114503885,
-0.0235172529,
-0.0256374367,
-0.0070920265,
-0.0077987579,
-0.0260539837,
0.0138612613,
-0.0354669727,
0.0319996029,
-0.0137950182,
0.0530669391,
0.0371544696,
-0.0162895788,
0.0756038949,
0.0468944013,
-0.0097496845,
-0.0696077123,
0.0515505746,
-0.0369132869,
0.0051563941,
-0.0333140977,
-0.0151242968,
-0.0389952958,
0.0724349841,
0.0025334344,
0.0006496088,
0.0163349956,
-0.0419301689,
-0.0117074903,
0.027941972,
-0.0152183995,
-0.0177067742,
0.0344816521,
0.0588265397,
-0.0222830195,
-0.0384633206,
0.0015429006,
0.0052142581,
-0.0205906127,
0.0042222855,
-0.0477473103,
0.0117966998,
0.0094858343,
0.0016173499,
-0.0614599288,
0.0187205691,
-0.0379392318,
0.0188956559,
-0.0697531328,
-0.0021369145,
0.0604376271,
0.0256151035,
0.0430000424,
-0.0506582186,
0.0163060408,
0.0012260231,
0.0192685779,
-0.0261117835,
-0.0115866642,
0.0042061368,
-0.0050216834,
-0.0507920086,
-0.0245170016,
0.0572949052,
0.0237737782,
0.0727594197,
-0.0007464525,
-0.0153151797,
-0.0626679733,
-0.010603507,
-0.0332166664,
0.0307204667,
-0.0494839102,
-0.0042744828,
-0.0256167501,
-0.0534172729,
0.0360688865,
0.0092366971,
0.0207438953,
0.0290354621,
0.0488122664,
0.051849734,
0.0032960097,
-0.0036717642,
-0.0327458568,
0.0175566133,
-0.0060886336,
-0.0170229636,
-0.0539046302,
-6.789651697e-33,
-0.001449245,
-0.0418080017,
0.0063104345,
-0.0518717058,
-0.0009336846,
-0.025846038,
-0.0799800977,
-0.0366817862,
-0.0035497777,
-0.0161414668,
-0.0049615428,
-0.0453642085,
0.0080458298,
0.0444015078,
0.0236949958,
0.0209832359,
0.0252901055,
-0.031312108,
-0.045701053,
0.0070462129,
0.0419486836,
0.0427670926,
0.0440634303,
-0.0530036725,
-0.0088394824,
0.0007257064,
-0.0416588224,
-0.0171049405,
-0.0345984921,
0.0765938237,
-0.0556065328,
0.0537027642,
0.0201807059,
0.006271766,
-0.0406408049,
-0.0016969912,
-0.0913337991,
0.0040012258,
-0.0139000146,
-0.0201447997,
-0.0310114548,
0.005977483,
0.0677662566,
-0.034871161,
-0.032350447,
0.0335610732,
0.0080997255,
-0.0180355944,
0.0392551795,
-0.0319560282,
-0.0709166378,
0.0182993654,
-0.0004874011,
-0.0296268091,
0.0159560814,
0.0515886135,
-0.0002467705,
0.0085667651,
-0.0447002575,
0.0213872064,
-0.0113906795,
0.045495905,
0.0724413991,
-0.0018736639,
0.0024767448,
0.0562161431,
0.0244908575,
-0.0169501044,
-0.0600904077,
-0.0189583395,
0.0154404128,
0.0274974052,
0.0188677274,
0.0232271738,
0.0500043705,
0.0059881136,
-0.0958172306,
0.0338482782,
0.0465789288,
0.0458200686,
-0.0042507644,
-0.0329046287,
-0.0240314808,
-0.0139592513,
-0.02443978,
-0.0414788723,
-0.0151613727,
-0.0160072893,
0.0437673628,
0.0276848003,
-0.032616239,
0.0020908858,
0.0042942432,
-0.0317586623,
0.0079463264,
0.0205436889,
-0.0068153706,
-0.0099377949,
0.0064200107,
0.0103688808,
-0.038077075,
-0.0239665173,
0.027565321,
0.0210979134,
-0.0007133384,
-0.0104294587,
-0.0122751947,
0.035873048,
-0.0466780402,
0.0135884425,
-0.0368446372,
0.0337537639,
0.0032071262,
0.022045387,
0.0306332875,
0.0032220487,
-0.0172568485,
-0.0019172161,
0.0061251801,
0.0055122841,
-0.0056993496,
0.0373625234,
0.025036443,
0.0432420261,
-0.0051437416,
0.0094260033,
-0.0242674146,
0.0096193217,
0.0540208817,
-0.0158537347,
0.0145804156,
0.0225746017,
2.831e-7,
0.0392055176,
0.0257027242,
0.0803855062,
-0.0114406943,
0.0106970733,
0.0057214531,
0.0032063096,
-0.0015989995,
-0.0099459859,
-0.0218692943,
-0.015667595,
-0.0247859638,
0.0428663455,
0.001599197,
-0.0406274423,
0.0270380992,
-0.0778277069,
-0.0124034239,
-0.032128986,
-0.0117438715,
0.0291568413,
0.0676933601,
-0.0198261738,
-0.0250466261,
-0.0184933636,
-0.0208896603,
0.0276637226,
0.0366777852,
-0.0040545454,
0.0409956314,
0.0379016809,
-0.0045405338,
0.018692093,
0.0104358112,
-0.0112759769,
0.0785879716,
-0.0309313573,
0.0445352346,
-0.0123926355,
-0.003444928,
-0.0021144876,
0.0328456834,
0.012928335,
-0.0389817543,
0.0373801962,
-0.0377523787,
-0.0106681548,
-0.04297968,
-0.0102117443,
0.0244691987,
-0.0076810056,
-0.0411732569,
0.0018099854,
0.0215917472,
0.0207733512,
-0.0190737322,
-0.0137378499,
-0.0854548439,
-0.0103882188,
-0.0269157644,
-0.0658388361,
0.0162183419,
-0.0339112766,
0.0262204502,
0.0626776516,
-0.0410650633,
-0.0295120049,
2.962144286e-34,
-0.0002831914,
-0.0311833434,
-0.0047603301,
0.0471066311,
0.0257500745,
-0.0054276325,
-0.0144459056,
0.0390345529,
-0.023981696,
-0.0662746653,
-0.0594491735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04037v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04037v1 | A Comparative Study on TF-IDF feature Weighting Method and its Analysis using Unstructured Dataset | 2023-08-08T04:27:34 | 2023-08-08T04:27:34 | Mamata Das, Selvakumar K., P. J. A. Alphonse | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text Classification is the process of categorizing text into the relevant
categories and its algorithms are at the core of many Natural Language
Processing (NLP). Term Frequency-Inverse Document Frequency (TF-IDF) and NLP
are the most highly used information retrieval methods in text classification.
We have investigated and analyzed the feature weighting method for text
classification on unstructured data. The proposed model considered two features
N-Grams and TF-IDF on the IMDB movie reviews and Amazon Alexa reviews dataset
for sentiment analysis. Then we have used the state-of-the-art classifier to
validate the method i.e., Support Vector Machine (SVM), Logistic Regression,
Multinomial Naive Bayes (Multinomial NB), Random Forest, Decision Tree, and
k-nearest neighbors (KNN). From those two feature extractions, a significant
increase in feature extraction with TF-IDF features rather than based on
N-Gram. TF-IDF got the maximum accuracy (93.81%), precision (94.20%), recall
(93.81%), and F1-score (91.99%) value in Random Forest classifier. | [
0.0687218606,
0.0069647697,
-0.0050928672,
-0.0102009783,
-0.0553244054,
-0.0037173571,
-0.0043970076,
0.0404881798,
0.0109367743,
-0.0864973664,
0.0112098558,
-0.0574034974,
0.0128006507,
0.0183554832,
-0.0844135731,
0.0012989813,
-0.0179419536,
-0.0021807624,
0.0716823637,
0.0128356135,
0.0062662661,
0.0189886298,
0.0040611387,
0.0023129114,
-0.0273752715,
0.0183497891,
0.0402862988,
-0.0113162035,
0.0063168239,
-0.0297125503,
0.007183494,
0.0619913489,
-0.0258406494,
0.0113010146,
0.0000019476,
-0.0584257506,
-0.0290595777,
0.0111047607,
0.056892328,
-0.0519788526,
0.0986426398,
0.0220804662,
0.0070075435,
0.0490917601,
-0.025147073,
-0.0236952156,
0.0226391312,
0.1266725361,
0.0005432896,
0.0704421774,
-0.0138802556,
-0.0762662292,
0.0039777546,
0.0441804416,
0.0141308,
0.0165326316,
0.0019874484,
0.0050376207,
-0.012232217,
-0.010056884,
-0.0234730858,
-0.0384950973,
-0.0398299247,
0.0037280095,
0.047292307,
-0.0184410196,
-0.0466026962,
-0.0011258054,
0.0068578282,
0.0217002686,
0.0430597849,
-0.0370747447,
-0.0182531849,
0.0112582166,
-0.0431990325,
0.0402979776,
-0.0414013378,
0.0244003907,
-0.0056436178,
0.0302155595,
-0.0154863531,
0.0494145975,
-0.0162602048,
0.0072847707,
0.0388389565,
0.0307502933,
-0.0150305955,
-0.0413083881,
0.040828228,
-0.0154902879,
-0.0148070715,
-0.0192988478,
0.0237293206,
-0.0003356512,
0.0279838741,
0.0114616966,
0.0078374557,
-0.0810643882,
0.0566673018,
-0.1133001521,
-0.0113541633,
0.0090134954,
-0.0189382564,
0.0247766152,
0.0043416917,
0.0020489483,
0.0816322789,
-0.011480242,
-0.0102792727,
0.0204896107,
-0.1106385887,
0.0042349608,
0.0217739251,
0.0857233331,
0.0452767387,
-0.0353121087,
-0.0323408507,
-0.0177752152,
-0.0179268811,
-0.0238136221,
0.0362378173,
0.0390026942,
0.0572041497,
0.0597806573,
-0.0162778273,
0.0044649853,
-0.0094812848,
0.0279962216,
-0.0698671937,
0.0266746245,
0.0459693708,
0.0230942369,
0.0470160246,
0.0029212644,
0.0503585227,
0.0039735408,
0.029710412,
-0.0551817417,
-0.0499882773,
-0.0059259203,
-0.0013511161,
-0.0425259024,
-0.0328034274,
-0.0476006791,
-0.0136086056,
0.0347764269,
-0.0156507995,
0.0497088879,
-0.0032974379,
0.0427630693,
-0.0522208586,
0.0118048079,
-0.0276995488,
-0.0008012669,
0.05579919,
-0.0174074452,
0.0407302491,
0.0186799094,
-0.0105145406,
0.0238767006,
0.0354328826,
-0.0037004957,
-0.0005041774,
-0.0461112298,
-0.0611700639,
-0.0073522725,
-0.0478078835,
0.011984759,
-0.0705398992,
-0.0163929537,
-0.0244746469,
0.0071286545,
0.0129544968,
0.0058211712,
0.0139658283,
0.0230697412,
0.0076092295,
0.0405150913,
-0.0453787781,
0.0685266405,
0.0416183509,
0.0062262486,
0.0375775844,
0.0082611348,
-0.0714391321,
-0.0047963215,
-0.0157293752,
-0.0347836949,
-0.0153197628,
-0.0355001539,
-0.0415461361,
-0.0208379198,
0.0668787286,
-0.0162016004,
0.0821148455,
0.014320422,
-0.0195659194,
-0.0001777361,
0.0543015599,
-0.0454556532,
-0.0588142909,
-0.0000262718,
0.013012642,
0.0543513782,
0.0091640111,
-0.0442379266,
-0.0090465313,
0.000427703,
-0.0080665313,
-0.0306109525,
0.0097212708,
-0.0011722906,
-0.0483118929,
-0.0359366871,
-0.0241714809,
0.0297767967,
0.0121782981,
-0.0046315724,
-0.0428104475,
0.087933749,
0.0163176171,
-0.0152451443,
-0.0702997372,
0.0141110877,
0.0730164573,
0.0059686461,
0.0582481846,
-0.0250826869,
0.0385328382,
0.058434613,
-0.0398739204,
-0.0274099223,
0.0419948697,
0.0317316353,
-0.067366831,
-0.0408171751,
0.0042108181,
0.0186014827,
0.0032453283,
-0.014825644,
0.053047426,
0.0619029142,
0.0023963116,
-0.0208859909,
0.0219625924,
-0.0005742564,
0.037880905,
-0.0225793738,
0.0193183944,
-0.0869100168,
-0.0175494682,
-0.0519223101,
0.0558562726,
0.026647009,
0.0603652745,
-0.09417703,
-0.0892348215,
0.0399618745,
0.001578467,
-0.0035357126,
0.0309803411,
-0.0199090112,
0.0430827588,
0.0393492356,
0.0009596913,
-0.0008287511,
-0.0128123872,
-0.1500289738,
0.0024748377,
-0.0041116104,
0.0154025275,
-0.029076457,
-0.0164830983,
0.0029788304,
-0.0060203183,
-0.0381965972,
-0.003737147,
-0.0125193698,
-0.0212585591,
-0.0149547122,
-0.001338054,
0.0272605028,
0.0015157708,
-0.0026726346,
-0.0378147811,
0.0386316366,
0.0220488347,
-0.0474426039,
0.0234035924,
0.0525061674,
-0.0339415856,
-0.0226054657,
0.0331306383,
0.0070058741,
-0.0003425913,
0.0021323666,
-0.0473743007,
-0.0365095958,
0.049531281,
-0.0070025465,
0.0327661708,
0.0417455994,
-0.0290131643,
0.0052019018,
-0.0283417981,
0.0497947112,
0.0066994759,
0.0040568742,
0.0183778573,
0.0103028184,
0.0239174459,
0.0048879129,
-0.0141874505,
-0.0024064349,
-0.0220991094,
0.0314747281,
-0.0145798409,
-0.0052771652,
0.0040765544,
0.0057717059,
0.0481268503,
-0.0114059392,
0.0143033611,
-0.0243702848,
0.0264279302,
-0.1015550718,
-0.0219203811,
-0.0239998251,
0.0264198557,
-0.0030506784,
0.0381708927,
0.0019226687,
-0.0016929001,
0.0388584659,
-0.0013129435,
0.0218472425,
-0.0266638249,
0.0087490501,
0.0267939679,
-0.006399713,
0.0136354649,
0.0282070991,
0.0028945471,
-0.0383512117,
-0.032251969,
-0.0306976046,
-0.0080741625,
-0.0397081859,
0.0315913036,
0.0316724703,
-0.0121802492,
-0.0033248072,
-0.0279850662,
-0.0345893838,
0.0521025248,
0.0282844082,
0.0532127582,
-0.033619903,
0.0004529893,
0.0552080572,
-0.0039773602,
0.0423892029,
0.0161957499,
-0.0225873888,
-0.0260264743,
-0.0223472398,
0.0129651818,
-0.0480778366,
0.0010703637,
-0.0286917295,
-0.0244083703,
-0.0091505731,
0.043306645,
0.1069675982,
0.0587498248,
-0.0644419342,
0.0060103913,
-0.0099122729,
-0.0331996083,
0.011986508,
0.0154247554,
0.0019850084,
-0.0183367543,
-0.0041595087,
0.0173307937,
-0.0414605513,
-0.046619527,
0.0438371412,
-0.0699977279,
0.021162929,
-0.0368858501,
0.0010893714,
-0.0087059485,
-0.0519627072,
-0.0329279266,
-0.0102231558,
-0.0458751731,
-0.0438558199,
-0.0184036884,
0.0193681959,
0.0187136084,
-0.0498285405,
-0.0107210865,
0.0711813569,
0.0116151385,
0.0026488819,
0.0290972777,
0.0264081378,
-0.0780536234,
-0.0068618492,
-0.0268345568,
0.004272521,
0.0141549064,
-0.0508528389,
0.0716594085,
-0.001015664,
0.0079016406,
-0.0123528792,
-0.0542088225,
-0.029486265,
0.0067611993,
0.0016313087,
0.0431467965,
-0.0379791036,
-0.0401151627,
-0.0361303277,
-0.004809415,
-0.0079210997,
0.0381676182,
-0.0714714304,
-0.0512732938,
0.0005861252,
0.0170781966,
0.0083523011,
0.0050357799,
-0.0271780826,
0.0033977197,
-0.0061018369,
-0.0507374294,
-0.0563686267,
-0.0218942631,
0.010826149,
0.0422360152,
-0.0208072308,
0.0528362878,
-0.0253275875,
0.0223640036,
-0.0323876739,
-0.0219123643,
0.0540798642,
-0.0129786711,
-0.0052056834,
-0.0327046886,
0.0421935581,
-0.0177721009,
-0.0353013612,
-0.055904638,
0.0335738137,
0.0021094452,
-0.0071509928,
-0.0032793183,
0.0051827626,
-0.0182830524,
-0.005427144,
-0.0398088321,
0.0573708601,
0.0274536759,
-0.0737925395,
-0.0184727069,
-0.0013350982,
-0.0376789942,
-0.0053898729,
0.0173225813,
-0.0444472656,
0.0204630792,
-0.0001830264,
-0.0080634514,
0.0027866161,
-0.0346693918,
0.0049717627,
0.0303182453,
0.0765600577,
0.0164361373,
0.0075317635,
0.0055788774,
0.0093950527,
0.0125619601,
-0.0083647715,
-0.02667672,
0.0163299236,
0.0089241164,
0.0159334596,
-0.0446802936,
0.0331412852,
0.0020346178,
-0.0294458512,
0.0560490079,
0.0587314442,
0.0098154182,
0.0368175134,
-0.0145284403,
0.0107471114,
-0.015563854,
-0.0636689812,
0.042321749,
-0.0224788208,
0.0324398652,
0.0190494228,
-0.0087847142,
0.0078452481,
-0.0323419794,
0.0293067861,
-0.0172833744,
0.0041487296,
-0.0459203981,
0.0091446117,
0.0024346791,
-0.0692116544,
-0.010216102,
-0.0196474828,
0.0317550302,
-0.0232892372,
0.0027111063,
0.0153360525,
0.0299328845,
-0.0003175164,
0.0067046047,
-0.0412862487,
0.0640693158,
0.0519571379,
0.0362279452,
-0.0426718295,
0.0362718925,
-0.0833745971,
-0.0082413424,
0.0324711092,
0.0524209514,
0.0253274236,
-0.0198197756,
0.0093046641,
-0.0217614006,
-0.0024539402,
0.0786519572,
-0.078977868,
0.0331318416,
-0.0290651917,
0.0420909673,
0.0658413991,
0.0117264763,
0.0541888289,
-0.0637957901,
-0.0539100692,
-0.0463476181,
0.0161896665,
-0.0133939618,
-6.164581841e-33,
0.022683451,
-0.0301404055,
-0.0316804275,
0.0816132352,
0.0319871642,
-0.0183857605,
0.0231102481,
0.0159423482,
0.0113934623,
0.0321397185,
0.0009221986,
-0.0015889871,
0.0028574455,
0.0019504239,
0.0446081012,
-0.0007708476,
-0.0082893809,
-0.0073912684,
0.0334405415,
0.003688057,
0.0317857713,
0.0485247709,
0.0824804828,
-0.1074296832,
0.0060453927,
-0.0154866688,
-0.0171833523,
-0.0268451162,
0.0312886238,
0.0022530104,
0.0154084777,
0.0790163353,
0.0182918347,
-0.0580415986,
0.0223865788,
-0.0336991437,
-0.0016379635,
-0.0302825477,
-0.0126057621,
0.0422743,
0.0217800867,
0.0259071458,
0.0363052823,
-0.0035212564,
-0.0642268881,
-0.0020961731,
0.0751755312,
-0.0085662901,
-0.0266242716,
-0.0845005065,
-0.0550827198,
0.0435047448,
0.0040067602,
0.0144500108,
0.0057710116,
0.0451099016,
-0.0081376443,
0.0244582705,
-0.0653974861,
-0.0168974232,
-0.0112835327,
0.013256452,
-0.033100877,
-0.0154776201,
-0.0172802545,
0.0419258103,
0.0047098324,
-0.0398685299,
0.0137588978,
0.0307507236,
-0.0014025458,
0.0023344608,
0.0051506613,
0.0280889533,
0.084662661,
-0.0734742954,
-0.029071264,
0.0414035805,
-0.0027461587,
0.0184672419,
0.0080585396,
0.001625277,
-0.051028993,
-0.0003299873,
0.0319666192,
-0.0105922166,
-0.0269857198,
-0.0753305852,
-0.0127327442,
0.0022385935,
-0.0213145334,
-0.0065385168,
-0.0428674743,
-0.0533594526,
-0.0177421086,
0.0235979259,
-0.0373396277,
0.0590319708,
0.0083147073,
-0.019021295,
-0.0303800423,
-0.0021417721,
-0.0159123447,
0.0007417311,
0.0125336209,
-0.0182675123,
0.0450713784,
0.0339713097,
-0.0507087484,
-0.0104281651,
0.0660872757,
-0.0262483712,
-0.0020964483,
0.0879070759,
-0.0563783757,
-0.0126601616,
-0.0075717093,
0.0373813249,
-0.0044395765,
0.0260640457,
-0.0470185541,
-0.0373326689,
0.0016784922,
-0.054521922,
-0.0064988742,
-0.0482258052,
0.0168876741,
-0.0349085592,
-0.0012957192,
-0.0162395313,
0.0048919227,
-0.0052180537,
2.803e-7,
0.052462481,
0.0365288965,
-0.0459553525,
-0.0625859275,
-0.02010208,
0.0779865608,
-0.0020700917,
0.0261962526,
0.0310509875,
0.0077918316,
0.0239491817,
-0.0107408473,
-0.0364963301,
0.0447607078,
-0.1130807921,
-0.0123818656,
-0.05322586,
-0.0015026042,
0.0175915714,
0.0365661718,
0.031164648,
0.0841365829,
0.0149743054,
-0.034889549,
-0.014934537,
-0.0421516895,
0.0134052904,
-0.0050850534,
-0.0058367481,
0.0046331389,
0.0048767757,
-0.0074419738,
-0.0125530092,
0.0141252289,
-0.0226186868,
0.0229725447,
0.0246202573,
0.009115316,
-0.0525671281,
0.0160053745,
0.0135073997,
0.0297052767,
0.0261306204,
0.0151663432,
0.0653876588,
0.0500231721,
-0.0458637625,
-0.0552893616,
0.0344064794,
0.0060918359,
0.0516832247,
0.0095117493,
-0.0168892555,
0.0118134264,
-0.0067847129,
-0.0290432014,
-0.0200178325,
-0.0484899953,
0.023015786,
0.0504666418,
0.0136453127,
-0.0084085567,
0.0055498597,
0.0377881266,
0.0457811244,
0.0143903438,
0.0558030941,
2.278078894e-34,
0.044408273,
0.0243155491,
-0.0226951707,
-0.0237899087,
-0.0206582714,
0.0047527929,
0.0105913142,
-0.0016699248,
-0.0213581063,
-0.0358451083,
0.0248770397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04028v1 | Top K Relevant Passage Retrieval for Biomedical Question Answering | 2023-08-08T04:06:11 | 2023-08-08T04:06:11 | Shashank Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Question answering is a task that answers factoid questions using a large
collection of documents. It aims to provide precise answers in response to the
user's questions in natural language. Question answering relies on efficient
passage retrieval to select candidate contexts, where traditional sparse vector
space models, such as TF-IDF or BM25, are the de facto method. On the web,
there is no single article that could provide all the possible answers
available on the internet to the question of the problem asked by the user. The
existing Dense Passage Retrieval model has been trained on Wikipedia dump from
Dec. 20, 2018, as the source documents for answering questions. Question
answering (QA) has made big strides with several open-domain and machine
comprehension systems built using large-scale annotated datasets. However, in
the clinical domain, this problem remains relatively unexplored. According to
multiple surveys, Biomedical Questions cannot be answered correctly from
Wikipedia Articles. In this work, we work on the existing DPR framework for the
biomedical domain and retrieve answers from the Pubmed articles which is a
reliable source to answer medical questions. When evaluated on a BioASQ QA
dataset, our fine-tuned dense retriever results in a 0.81 F1 score. | [
0.0731805414,
0.0383387357,
-0.0001201428,
-0.0145780733,
-0.004444228,
0.031270951,
-0.0176136978,
0.0609081648,
-0.0011395648,
-0.0238429904,
0.0071030161,
-0.0690896809,
-0.0110593252,
0.0332145207,
0.0040612724,
-0.023294853,
0.0190559737,
0.0312114805,
0.0425428562,
0.0003114816,
-0.011366725,
0.01185806,
-0.0332927294,
0.0105449371,
0.0526057258,
0.0024417939,
0.0230365656,
-0.0010223401,
0.0597061664,
-0.0508494824,
0.0595253557,
0.0236356389,
0.0153357182,
-0.0248410031,
0.0000016856,
-0.0319369659,
-0.0388916321,
0.0337077826,
-0.0474929363,
-0.0122584514,
-0.0115088895,
-0.0251854695,
0.0569543056,
-0.0115077272,
-0.0258269161,
-0.0468063168,
0.0287069958,
0.0764755085,
0.0638008267,
0.0708507225,
0.0087686395,
-0.0247282516,
0.0559120625,
0.0010844998,
0.0514122359,
-0.0597557984,
0.0633548349,
-0.0146732507,
0.032876201,
0.0388995148,
0.0193494074,
0.0158253405,
-0.0291742086,
0.0416166745,
0.0486723036,
0.0315461047,
-0.0302670468,
0.0067825373,
0.0301826112,
0.0896091536,
0.048421938,
-0.0197581518,
0.0402276069,
0.0274108332,
-0.0567698255,
0.01434833,
-0.0459498912,
-0.0217340384,
-0.0404440127,
-0.0085732145,
-0.0144343749,
-0.0076193917,
0.0053264382,
0.0196054522,
-0.0231065378,
-0.011279542,
0.0280937292,
-0.0365952775,
0.0122113219,
-0.0074703987,
-0.0344697423,
-0.0112780044,
0.0515099205,
0.0510279387,
-0.0444816798,
-0.0041593821,
0.0228244383,
-0.0336389318,
0.0870978907,
-0.0592009425,
-0.0095216325,
0.0126426592,
-0.0010985935,
0.031484969,
-0.0166041702,
-0.0022639707,
-0.047168754,
0.0351708122,
-0.0384736657,
-0.0081195394,
-0.0366109647,
-0.0120767327,
-0.0166907888,
0.0610376,
-0.0097904829,
-0.0063975793,
-0.0405358002,
-0.0164839458,
0.0318439901,
-0.0191087965,
-0.0114528649,
0.0509698726,
-0.0590910278,
0.0141735934,
-0.0194931384,
0.028481489,
-0.0292607564,
0.0091871945,
-0.0307181701,
-0.0265200734,
-0.010843684,
-0.0327727497,
0.0297772568,
-0.0444005616,
0.0310048014,
-0.0005710503,
-0.011659489,
-0.0370163061,
0.0146128712,
-0.013948069,
-0.0016297061,
-0.0429822803,
-0.0340834782,
-0.0654903948,
0.0270092301,
0.0601201765,
-0.0212476682,
-0.0285054706,
0.0328735821,
0.055767633,
-0.072719641,
0.0324507728,
-0.0096725766,
-0.0190331582,
0.0263848603,
0.0345153734,
0.0325683579,
0.0265024602,
-0.0042020716,
-0.0502154045,
0.0168420542,
0.0150048761,
-0.0224003587,
-0.043000605,
0.0370022431,
-0.0317770354,
0.0131289102,
0.0739757419,
0.0042890571,
0.0491375104,
-0.009714962,
0.0577626228,
0.0040694899,
-0.06336651,
-0.0066770529,
0.066082947,
0.0079940781,
-0.0023435124,
-0.0070841676,
0.0032581061,
0.0164990202,
0.0041671139,
0.0045296084,
0.000712785,
-0.0019616659,
0.0217928216,
0.0276748631,
0.0221758876,
-0.0069491267,
0.0099610956,
-0.0136750406,
0.034756083,
-0.0403970294,
0.0389795676,
0.0597119518,
-0.0156177422,
-0.0380996652,
0.0855623484,
0.0426652804,
-0.0224768296,
0.0025821137,
-0.0120783243,
-0.0012730705,
0.0132495007,
0.0586504377,
-0.0605869554,
-0.0431737378,
-0.0155870849,
0.0171584878,
0.012654704,
0.001756518,
-0.0396528505,
0.0205521174,
-0.0347699933,
0.0128459735,
0.0126214679,
0.0016483605,
-0.0308838133,
0.0181259755,
0.0353046097,
-0.0049358043,
-0.0776672587,
0.0101932362,
0.0382581763,
-0.0361217931,
-0.002411274,
-0.0181594044,
-0.019017512,
0.0118764555,
0.0411210768,
-0.0360946059,
0.0280068778,
0.0644766167,
-0.0508572236,
-0.025705846,
-0.0641088411,
-0.0258327406,
-0.0214343648,
0.0276261065,
-0.0145998299,
-0.0194331948,
0.0247380398,
-0.0386470519,
-0.01627969,
-0.0334506109,
-0.0459664166,
-0.0277681351,
-0.0030875874,
-0.0238960665,
0.0200715624,
-0.0105632087,
-0.0694696531,
0.0468386374,
-0.0095097637,
0.0765090436,
0.0320985913,
-0.0360085703,
0.0188793186,
-0.043314334,
-0.0207114816,
0.0306106471,
-0.0329959542,
0.0061423406,
0.0298587661,
-0.0188922044,
-0.0555851571,
0.0118843662,
-0.0806510672,
0.0299107209,
0.0009374031,
0.0079368697,
0.0116929971,
0.0257586502,
-0.0020777362,
-0.0341479369,
-0.0635819733,
-0.0125749884,
0.0411536768,
0.0279386546,
0.0474685803,
0.0702155903,
0.017347917,
-0.0429722294,
-0.0361848213,
-0.0280457158,
0.0330182463,
-0.0318314396,
-0.0115130702,
0.016212536,
0.0208358224,
-0.035853494,
0.0063754404,
-0.009511875,
0.0064680125,
0.0118469493,
-0.0347200409,
-0.0092676217,
0.0678375289,
0.0300211664,
0.0038230356,
-0.0154834399,
0.0098581901,
-0.0443222784,
0.0361670032,
-0.0579966418,
-0.005495701,
-0.0132654803,
-0.0265799128,
0.0193620361,
0.027338516,
0.0365831517,
-0.0188905783,
-0.0158122946,
-0.0159281548,
0.0014464995,
0.021639144,
-0.0572125576,
0.0338695385,
-0.0251578353,
0.0536712408,
-0.0094943447,
0.0093729198,
0.1045254767,
0.0095774205,
0.002533301,
-0.0568517782,
-0.004248016,
-0.0509746298,
0.0068165851,
-0.0106206546,
0.0254016984,
-0.0059673334,
-0.0186655261,
-0.0142955948,
0.0074354368,
-0.0094732298,
-0.0785875991,
0.0629540905,
0.0109325889,
0.0395798571,
-0.027504392,
-0.0531450808,
-0.0543203801,
-0.007817057,
-0.00528961,
0.0098087303,
-0.0421106964,
0.0064734723,
-0.0329594128,
0.0143020814,
0.0072895717,
0.0169103667,
-0.0073920116,
-0.006890595,
-0.0169547107,
0.0824622065,
0.0812079608,
0.0084932111,
0.0017379891,
-0.0015581487,
0.00461639,
0.0879582837,
0.0135186724,
0.0014655901,
0.0384918973,
0.0019106881,
0.0317917243,
-0.0773563832,
0.0246962719,
0.0049036057,
0.0342752114,
-0.058570344,
-0.0404434949,
0.0647992119,
0.0380553752,
-0.0421305411,
-0.009589917,
-0.020194808,
-0.0057552941,
0.0072204894,
0.0409405977,
-0.0743250474,
-0.007973589,
-0.0297589097,
0.0496964827,
-0.0014325766,
-0.0513372272,
0.0243539978,
-0.0448906943,
0.0075977668,
-0.0188043546,
-0.0222224835,
-0.0511256829,
-0.0777892843,
0.009425791,
0.0052436492,
-0.0264640786,
0.0330775008,
-0.0069468552,
0.0082228342,
0.035773471,
0.0133044804,
-0.0659617633,
0.0478276834,
-0.0355602615,
0.0152695626,
0.0152375354,
0.0202353895,
0.0000039899,
0.0172714461,
-0.0438562222,
-0.0942391232,
-0.0271462873,
-0.0084643448,
0.0885165259,
-0.0101838633,
-0.0125791123,
-0.0706651658,
0.0300478358,
-0.025597766,
-0.0164028537,
-0.0251449421,
0.0597184859,
-0.0154879224,
-0.0107856337,
-0.0699588656,
0.0105462158,
-0.0090261148,
0.0428396836,
-0.0119208191,
0.0235774647,
-0.0543245673,
0.0142793451,
0.0342445299,
-0.0530779958,
-0.0448770709,
-0.001804894,
-0.0055185994,
0.0454262383,
-0.0655487552,
-0.0083316294,
0.0335917883,
0.003056311,
-0.0240104459,
0.0475753695,
-0.0060551385,
0.0007036807,
-0.0880210102,
0.0377226435,
0.0143758394,
0.0069286623,
-0.0474138036,
-0.0462034531,
0.0658748522,
-0.0075133988,
-0.0208562519,
0.0101178819,
-0.0227554366,
-0.0233191326,
-0.0161768105,
0.0399391092,
0.0129320817,
-0.0116262753,
-0.0037397612,
-0.00684404,
0.0926255807,
0.0401833765,
-0.0702536032,
-0.0167313926,
-0.0163885579,
-0.0157849137,
-0.0357755385,
0.0151883103,
-0.0536891483,
0.0082756011,
-0.0038395922,
0.0666535795,
0.014578159,
-0.0513619147,
0.0295228455,
0.0297340639,
0.0226748269,
0.028056208,
-0.008710009,
-0.0325242132,
0.0305440016,
0.0069481437,
0.0176238865,
0.0054720929,
0.0122568402,
0.0437912568,
-0.0326942429,
-0.0145711834,
0.0216685347,
-0.0311056953,
0.0413930789,
-0.0546376444,
0.0152509557,
0.0527206473,
-0.027481392,
0.049251955,
-0.0122919539,
-0.0294764806,
-0.0341803692,
-0.0065084784,
0.0621399507,
-0.0109513942,
0.0419843271,
0.0016586819,
0.0007649449,
-0.0048391144,
0.0199588314,
-0.0972415954,
-0.0108769787,
-0.0289528538,
-0.0044582817,
0.0226665568,
-0.0173271839,
0.0335774496,
0.0191338453,
-0.0312825665,
-0.0431765541,
-0.0071874103,
-0.0110078119,
0.0284262951,
0.0644772798,
0.0373539366,
0.0018768103,
0.0431507044,
0.0657594949,
0.0274965074,
0.0513948724,
0.0240287092,
-0.0656717271,
-0.0216182601,
-0.0241251308,
-0.0172425937,
0.0389295667,
-0.0367815271,
-0.0040421593,
-0.0310812034,
-0.0279226899,
0.0557071194,
-0.0398589894,
-0.0289675258,
-0.0271285363,
0.0179274119,
0.0460049212,
0.0639259741,
-0.0451255776,
-0.0645434707,
0.0735129938,
-0.0719862208,
-0.0213865116,
-0.0193791352,
-5.911511866e-33,
0.0058708764,
-0.0067525101,
-0.0169744715,
-0.0228133164,
-0.0268241707,
0.0284451917,
-0.0545638651,
-0.0179158803,
-0.0320566148,
0.0182097033,
-0.0275724363,
-0.0089703584,
-0.0053011351,
0.03972321,
-0.0247493479,
-0.033507172,
0.009641435,
-0.0034537194,
-0.0254591648,
0.0307296962,
0.0145703768,
0.0810726881,
0.0267272852,
-0.0368720815,
0.0099849841,
-0.0487881601,
0.0499189049,
0.0237421095,
0.0187974721,
0.0638804659,
-0.0487929396,
0.0428103395,
0.0511811897,
-0.0216850359,
0.0179088153,
0.0133722108,
-0.1137227789,
0.0070543587,
-0.0107234307,
-0.0204454139,
-0.0282161199,
-0.002790605,
0.0211420134,
-0.0386889391,
0.0414999053,
-0.0380556844,
0.0440877564,
-0.026687324,
-0.0429739878,
-0.0603954978,
-0.013150109,
0.0230260342,
-0.0279156677,
0.0069537973,
-0.0200032499,
0.0274218284,
-0.0084759686,
0.0525638871,
-0.0222435705,
-0.0124834469,
-0.0039128927,
0.0488337725,
-0.0423983932,
-0.0341893993,
-0.0159809608,
0.0544714183,
-0.0094757304,
-0.0566317029,
-0.0173843447,
-0.0011836538,
-0.0461008847,
0.0074874032,
0.0187769029,
0.0434842035,
0.0227475818,
0.0046995687,
-0.1021659821,
0.0652847737,
-0.0246726628,
0.0705350935,
0.0380278416,
-0.0142852189,
-0.0229550395,
0.0086312313,
-0.0120942416,
0.0147729702,
-0.0325502604,
-0.0259699356,
0.0370834135,
-0.0165390782,
-0.0304637086,
0.0137600172,
0.0342430212,
-0.0421410426,
0.0172708035,
0.0372224301,
0.0142932814,
0.0070140022,
-0.000340234,
0.0104676615,
-0.0428789631,
0.0129711665,
0.0280782375,
-0.0447724238,
-0.0005175311,
-0.0102887964,
-0.0067328499,
-0.0355197899,
-0.03484473,
-0.007998419,
0.0088497698,
0.0069199433,
-0.0434106216,
0.1088809073,
-0.0131105399,
0.0435984023,
0.0106906481,
0.0791118667,
-0.0038355053,
0.0465077274,
-0.041077368,
-0.0350521095,
0.0119882282,
0.0025585799,
-0.0245747976,
0.0107153254,
-0.020959571,
0.0816513225,
-0.0294593349,
-0.0348644406,
0.0033897145,
0.0172338802,
2.482e-7,
0.0942002535,
0.0154177621,
0.0410030857,
0.0078408346,
0.0009738033,
0.0065216115,
0.0111600114,
0.0316343419,
0.0319670998,
-0.0352181382,
0.0207169466,
0.0419802815,
0.0017049143,
0.0271496791,
-0.079766497,
-0.0361327641,
-0.0575116016,
-0.0334637128,
-0.0307794418,
-0.0383687094,
0.048187986,
0.0644094497,
-0.0601106584,
-0.0278502218,
0.0045971116,
-0.0196977295,
0.0426470786,
0.0006577221,
0.0043319189,
0.0585121475,
0.028103644,
-0.0010647395,
0.0339556225,
0.0185480658,
-0.0099411737,
0.0226003043,
0.0165023897,
0.0777864978,
0.0047603641,
-0.0415764935,
-0.0058628595,
0.0039973636,
0.0720076412,
-0.0451430045,
0.0777125806,
-0.0183214396,
-0.0667045638,
0.0042220368,
-0.0246540718,
-0.0361935273,
0.0478185937,
-0.0145018967,
-0.0349319167,
0.0491341166,
0.0152696827,
0.0102722896,
0.0078955563,
-0.0926209837,
0.0076332879,
0.0457627252,
-0.0470285825,
-0.0123910923,
0.0275705885,
-0.0149891675,
-0.0245977938,
-0.0508218743,
0.006816261,
2.185096602e-34,
0.0181725714,
0.021657154,
-0.0179331433,
0.0287757646,
0.0272057112,
-0.0162783042,
0.0012634977,
-0.0106264865,
-0.00282475,
-0.0963785052,
-0.006717646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.04014v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04014v2 | Continual Pre-Training of Large Language Models: How to (re)warm your model? | 2023-08-08T03:18:18 | 2023-09-06T23:13:07 | Kshitij Gupta, Benjamin Thérien, Adam Ibrahim, Mats L. Richter, Quentin Anthony, Eugene Belilovsky, Irina Rish, Timothée Lesort | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are routinely pre-trained on billions of tokens,
only to restart the process over again once new data becomes available. A much
cheaper and more efficient solution would be to enable the continual
pre-training of these models, i.e. updating pre-trained models with new data
instead of re-training them from scratch. However, the distribution shift
induced by novel data typically results in degraded performance on past data.
Taking a step towards efficient continual pre-training, in this work, we
examine the effect of different warm-up strategies. Our hypothesis is that the
learning rate must be re-increased to improve compute efficiency when training
on a new dataset. We study the warmup phase of models pre-trained on the Pile
(upstream data, 300B tokens) as we continue to pre-train on SlimPajama
(downstream data, 297B tokens), following a linear warmup and cosine decay
schedule. We conduct all experiments on the Pythia 410M language model
architecture and evaluate performance through validation perplexity. We
experiment with different pre-training checkpoints, various maximum learning
rates, and various warmup lengths. Our results show that while rewarming models
first increases the loss on upstream and downstream data, in the longer run it
improves the downstream performance, outperforming models trained from
scratch$\unicode{x2013}$even for a large downstream dataset. | [
-0.013230172,
0.0909830928,
-0.0028277365,
0.0140193617,
-0.0084185721,
0.0212595277,
-0.0228626058,
0.0305719599,
-0.0430000387,
-0.0394822434,
-0.0507427081,
-0.0656529665,
-0.0108968196,
0.0194795169,
-0.002809647,
-0.0274885222,
0.053822998,
-0.0320199393,
-0.0141910156,
-0.0374844149,
-0.0173726268,
-0.0085019851,
-0.0079998951,
-0.0061791982,
-0.004149328,
-0.000601278,
-0.0343810394,
0.0057646576,
-0.0242859013,
-0.0802492052,
0.027935857,
0.0677859411,
0.0324197002,
0.0392741337,
0.0000021806,
-0.0381778553,
0.0127185779,
-0.0035548098,
-0.0777855217,
0.0694274977,
0.0595347248,
0.0069294809,
-0.0072010714,
0.0276175346,
-0.0320181884,
-0.0626300052,
0.0344313756,
0.0155285541,
0.0469491594,
0.0696121082,
-0.0080112992,
-0.0243561249,
0.0074504861,
-0.0251750797,
-0.0315413028,
-0.0611789711,
0.0212372653,
-0.0244363677,
-0.0242663398,
-0.0246681459,
-0.0223559663,
0.0221294537,
0.0370733552,
0.0195848998,
-0.0059502809,
0.0539833456,
-0.0083893789,
-0.0244266819,
-0.0229176432,
0.0306552611,
-0.0631417781,
-0.0418510698,
-0.0001578146,
-0.0167221222,
-0.0502500422,
-0.0381513424,
-0.0246402174,
0.0101007316,
0.0329418033,
0.0146250185,
0.0157129485,
-0.022003362,
0.077804558,
0.0208096579,
-0.0578001998,
0.0484392308,
0.0349083468,
-0.0146029573,
0.0083727567,
0.0288929492,
0.011438258,
-0.0608092211,
-0.0011129725,
0.0574898161,
-0.0297410712,
0.012876343,
-0.0450682901,
-0.0134635605,
0.0118779158,
-0.0223235209,
0.0582588054,
0.0359014198,
-0.0284790657,
0.0394794904,
-0.0112019461,
-0.0217632502,
-0.0228707772,
0.0298039913,
-0.0193064231,
0.0223465394,
-0.0044835284,
-0.0053648683,
-0.0405874886,
0.0034824447,
0.0250621643,
-0.0038809569,
-0.039719671,
0.016300505,
0.0047387341,
-0.033201471,
0.0184396841,
-0.0387180187,
-0.0227963123,
0.0082456423,
-0.0166820064,
0.0120257363,
-0.0258705132,
0.0338341407,
0.0002544351,
-0.0814159065,
-0.0302523728,
0.002760014,
0.0042361715,
0.0038093661,
0.0412008911,
0.0399997942,
0.000161191,
-0.0471259318,
-0.0681723729,
-0.0015306724,
0.0145092774,
-0.0809715837,
-0.011494875,
-0.0244669039,
0.0081567671,
0.0094596846,
0.0089793773,
0.0023216014,
-0.0236029215,
0.0079386607,
-0.0234435052,
0.0447403155,
-0.0021447334,
0.0362173095,
0.0052485969,
0.0077610109,
0.0161583852,
0.1069311351,
0.0221974365,
-0.0142974695,
0.0440167971,
-0.0309051126,
-0.0129524963,
0.0571312085,
0.0615511127,
0.0536120087,
-0.0222808309,
0.0093789743,
0.0173160173,
0.0046337415,
0.0323847868,
0.0035298101,
-0.0509353243,
0.0254945084,
0.0167858414,
0.0243098009,
0.0098850382,
0.0396153927,
0.0300639607,
-0.0276293885,
0.0132309226,
-0.0015034616,
-0.0456141233,
-0.0106426813,
0.0153746996,
-0.0156737119,
0.0320382789,
0.0428969562,
-0.0612200797,
-0.0205910318,
-0.0110891853,
-0.027989015,
-0.0141622731,
0.0171253234,
0.0525049865,
-0.011146971,
-0.025206374,
0.0536083058,
0.0720247999,
-0.056985274,
0.0265931413,
-0.0648115873,
0.0061881505,
0.060504552,
0.0039545135,
-0.0322477631,
-0.034663856,
0.0342350528,
0.0144976694,
-0.0294134375,
0.0439341068,
0.0113594308,
0.0500361584,
-0.043571271,
-0.0301814806,
0.0026805098,
0.0191956609,
0.0320536867,
0.0303360168,
0.0554220192,
0.0160639938,
0.0060736495,
-0.0244049951,
0.0454380177,
-0.0800044984,
0.0012777311,
-0.0000455281,
-0.0001499119,
0.038999632,
-0.0263439529,
-0.0189039558,
-0.0107334135,
0.0505643748,
-0.0204582065,
0.0077956333,
0.0258996338,
-0.0645651519,
0.0115535129,
0.049289912,
0.0741620213,
0.031840235,
0.0182777382,
-0.0420536473,
-0.0393458083,
0.0536501035,
0.0271082111,
0.0762834325,
-0.0368479677,
0.0519810133,
-0.0483582616,
0.0432206094,
-0.0106627066,
0.0294435583,
0.0100765396,
0.0242726281,
-0.0226169191,
-0.0034923118,
0.0363822766,
-0.0247364994,
-0.0157826189,
0.0099124461,
-0.0129036335,
0.0213662796,
0.0269715842,
-0.0128156105,
-0.0319723599,
0.0096378103,
-0.1027240083,
-0.0010756574,
-0.0440410264,
0.0378419422,
0.0236590561,
0.0017841693,
-0.0285296217,
-0.0181414429,
-0.0188456494,
-0.0060292333,
-0.0010807939,
0.0438320599,
0.0085594608,
0.0017461951,
-0.0128338188,
-0.0194041133,
-0.0484950393,
0.0398275666,
0.0786237344,
0.0081011765,
-0.0128443372,
-0.0640373752,
0.017504612,
-0.0215836428,
0.0186306182,
0.0017864873,
-0.0553233325,
-0.0164765231,
0.0062411847,
0.0525411405,
0.0389536917,
0.018146906,
0.0180279426,
0.0366523229,
-0.0159308799,
-0.023430448,
-0.007729162,
-0.0318440236,
-0.0448613651,
-0.0441790521,
-0.0038362222,
-0.0206015538,
0.0653620586,
-0.06163048,
-0.0179533344,
-0.0219278391,
-0.0066843061,
-0.0259662569,
-0.0193385687,
-0.0191808883,
0.0007909522,
-0.0161870867,
0.0445063263,
0.0087377205,
-0.0531567112,
0.0293571576,
-0.0252362881,
-0.004368579,
-0.0555404201,
-0.0138777765,
-0.0299151689,
0.0286857653,
0.0007020754,
0.0070341597,
-0.0596530996,
-0.0219922438,
-0.0364747643,
-0.0153157813,
0.0013313956,
-0.0217563659,
-0.0043565319,
0.0006255819,
0.0406130776,
-0.0149083771,
-0.034111172,
-0.0477571003,
-0.0514977202,
-0.0236309078,
-0.0225273613,
0.0250974037,
-0.0302924085,
0.0000267169,
0.0070800874,
-0.0011939885,
0.0523589849,
-0.0131337214,
0.0215633865,
-0.0002243442,
-0.0012158054,
-0.0028455216,
0.0039379373,
0.002567979,
-0.0576819852,
0.0136741633,
0.0177023206,
0.0887423083,
-0.0225813035,
-0.0471574701,
0.0096446965,
0.0346880853,
-0.0076735788,
-0.0232523438,
0.019111326,
0.0273829401,
-0.0569296665,
-0.0256136563,
0.070753552,
-0.0073233945,
-0.0737709627,
0.0128922928,
0.0183600299,
0.0716700628,
0.0170563385,
0.024386365,
-0.0619118027,
-0.0222953949,
0.0376211815,
0.0250889771,
0.0022847648,
-0.0092260269,
-0.0089510633,
-0.0913119465,
0.0083814869,
-0.0088117197,
-0.0389397852,
0.0446276218,
-0.0660903528,
-0.0247992482,
-0.0090834275,
0.0412221551,
0.0332427733,
-0.0119866263,
0.0069454508,
0.0392347798,
0.0083968127,
-0.0528483503,
0.0150402077,
-0.0583752394,
0.0240017436,
0.037048649,
-0.016645031,
-0.0163482036,
-0.0289222393,
0.0985891968,
-0.0172145218,
-0.0158224721,
0.0018257969,
0.0354740471,
0.0364638008,
-0.0311070904,
0.039278727,
-0.0036559803,
-0.0271290764,
0.0079521872,
0.000039614,
0.0550181828,
0.0096287346,
-0.031455718,
0.0090298457,
-0.00823294,
0.0040082163,
0.0461061932,
0.0167173333,
-0.0333724841,
-0.0319343135,
0.0325887278,
0.0044438601,
-0.0186975021,
-0.0013816716,
0.0349061638,
-0.0567787923,
-0.0343400612,
-0.0368281975,
0.0288658291,
-0.0104486691,
0.0869753882,
0.0187620632,
0.022704443,
-0.0075451443,
0.0156388804,
-0.0728470013,
0.0435753129,
-0.0437368043,
0.0221994612,
-0.1076725274,
-0.0372006819,
0.019903332,
0.0259135738,
-0.0278480109,
-0.0153022679,
-0.121339947,
-0.0663426816,
0.0520552322,
0.0264805388,
0.0298790261,
0.0485349968,
0.011570042,
-0.0433330461,
0.0627159178,
0.0359876938,
-0.094514668,
0.0496386737,
0.0159328878,
-0.0566417649,
0.0042162803,
0.0150134005,
-0.0223171506,
0.0309028681,
0.0363512188,
-0.0004897208,
0.0329475068,
0.0005392323,
-0.0239996351,
0.0449219123,
0.0433409661,
0.0009333711,
-0.018994756,
-0.010244105,
0.0479227901,
0.023545213,
0.0068472219,
-0.0298529863,
0.0003642098,
0.0098258918,
0.0145447273,
-0.0317387581,
0.0251596607,
0.032921683,
0.031577982,
0.0042552343,
-0.0020547698,
0.001501766,
0.0384163633,
0.0669690818,
0.0059973877,
-0.0055947881,
0.0102607459,
-0.0021641455,
0.0216474589,
-0.0517763495,
-0.0235914588,
0.0236936044,
0.0221438631,
-0.065800108,
0.0277310964,
-0.0654990152,
-0.0729305223,
-0.0238833129,
-0.0033644231,
0.0561062768,
-0.0205914099,
0.0295670703,
-0.0245359838,
0.0003232262,
-0.0198977701,
0.0040556015,
-0.0261064451,
-0.041031681,
0.0070073046,
-0.003037361,
-0.0328603163,
0.0416005626,
0.0755349845,
0.0109050842,
0.0693029463,
0.0234617759,
0.032877028,
0.0033204223,
0.0045394185,
0.0189253055,
0.0169124976,
-0.0171022788,
0.005484303,
-0.0005432426,
-0.0760217905,
-0.0061731613,
-0.019263193,
0.0191349685,
-0.0072032055,
0.0291372705,
0.0549802296,
-0.0144655723,
0.0252300687,
-0.0047057141,
0.040195927,
0.0205156393,
-0.0055554844,
0.0374352522,
-7.338841923e-33,
0.0258677229,
0.0298726391,
0.0428966917,
-0.0194659512,
-0.0540068373,
0.0383847728,
-0.0278221704,
-0.0192390438,
-0.016250452,
0.0042053834,
-0.0415548198,
0.023927955,
0.0285108648,
0.0331299528,
-0.0194302518,
-0.0445606038,
0.0522223972,
-0.0292003211,
-0.0242810082,
0.0599149987,
0.0243577659,
0.0411044843,
0.0484523699,
-0.0037436481,
-0.0497144796,
0.0019788723,
-0.0051398543,
0.0251010638,
-0.0203618109,
0.0194398221,
-0.0302470606,
0.0151495039,
0.0090932911,
-0.0302689597,
-0.0136271836,
-0.0136337047,
-0.0534694456,
-0.0041209389,
-0.0246256869,
0.0490324609,
-0.0438021459,
0.0041762912,
0.013872847,
0.0073495121,
-0.0488713644,
0.0346071757,
-0.0137689011,
-0.0164908692,
-0.0607797541,
0.0002886415,
-0.0338694267,
0.0324284919,
0.0047787367,
-0.0016015755,
0.0351807401,
-0.0267105531,
-0.0001211926,
0.0248301849,
-0.0412511677,
-0.0040092496,
0.0445334837,
0.0745352507,
0.0187828224,
0.038174741,
0.0181580838,
0.0453055799,
0.0437782407,
0.0110812709,
0.0068083005,
0.0190771837,
0.0897409841,
-0.0013922382,
0.0040452452,
-0.0310528167,
0.0995764211,
-0.0551068895,
-0.0936588868,
-0.0249897819,
0.0173996873,
0.0243613888,
0.0327547789,
-0.0005722576,
0.0185150132,
-0.0510607138,
-0.0687042996,
-0.0126972562,
-0.0463304743,
0.0013243866,
-0.0112582669,
0.043598827,
-0.0129281422,
-0.0080670575,
0.022304019,
-0.0292051788,
-0.0473495461,
0.0276071485,
-0.0185666364,
-0.0002821217,
0.0008056023,
0.0552506335,
-0.0337473415,
-0.0721322447,
-0.0243982188,
-0.0027690649,
0.0162515957,
-0.0173541084,
0.016786743,
0.0565868765,
-0.0795122907,
-0.0025986624,
-0.0291049723,
0.0197116509,
0.060153529,
0.0239381902,
0.0379361436,
0.0106800627,
0.0063262945,
0.0780323595,
0.039626468,
-0.008660404,
-0.0293053202,
0.0084991446,
0.049561888,
0.0460738875,
-0.0115151908,
-0.0069110356,
-0.065192163,
-0.007150847,
0.0237310287,
-0.0926815718,
-0.0185550284,
-0.0085003525,
2.911e-7,
0.0144864311,
0.0576342568,
0.0180967078,
-0.0177320577,
0.0109117515,
-0.0043933424,
-0.0735780969,
-0.0095218038,
-0.012429907,
0.0382083803,
-0.0140946982,
0.0049488908,
0.0389570929,
0.0240299758,
-0.0600879975,
-0.0145222582,
-0.0888929069,
0.0212452114,
-0.0585493334,
-0.0338388011,
-0.0242654383,
0.0997856036,
0.0247722138,
-0.0414407924,
0.0313308649,
-0.0436032452,
0.0584098846,
-0.0106462026,
0.0305576771,
0.0225315839,
0.0233450178,
0.0350114629,
0.0183820575,
-0.002538885,
-0.0352762081,
0.020585902,
-0.045488134,
0.0086904727,
0.00275177,
0.0058078589,
0.0281361081,
0.0250781253,
-0.011601802,
-0.0470881686,
0.0653255731,
-0.0433146544,
-0.0312271584,
-0.0802275687,
-0.0056702108,
-0.0499668047,
0.0402292535,
-0.0100872908,
-0.0054006502,
0.0736611634,
0.0278186724,
-0.001172453,
-0.0454345681,
-0.1135429144,
-0.0026044401,
-0.0017261362,
-0.0204704646,
-0.0426359177,
-0.0707456768,
0.0089058802,
0.0509005822,
-0.0304952599,
0.0377867408,
2.768033664e-34,
0.0710171983,
-0.0486464128,
0.0032443479,
0.0472078584,
0.0226597395,
-0.0312192254,
0.0780291483,
0.0073559387,
-0.0209040828,
-0.0631486848,
-0.0077957739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03983v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03983v1 | SimplyRetrieve: A Private and Lightweight Retrieval-Centric Generative AI Tool | 2023-08-08T02:00:43 | 2023-08-08T02:00:43 | Youyang Ng, Daisuke Miyashita, Yasuto Hoshi, Yasuhiro Morioka, Osamu Torii, Tomoya Kodama, Jun Deguchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Model (LLM) based Generative AI systems have seen significant
progress in recent years. Integrating a knowledge retrieval architecture allows
for seamless integration of private data into publicly available Generative AI
systems using pre-trained LLM without requiring additional model fine-tuning.
Moreover, Retrieval-Centric Generation (RCG) approach, a promising future
research direction that explicitly separates roles of LLMs and retrievers in
context interpretation and knowledge memorization, potentially leads to more
efficient implementation. SimplyRetrieve is an open-source tool with the goal
of providing a localized, lightweight, and user-friendly interface to these
sophisticated advancements to the machine learning community. SimplyRetrieve
features a GUI and API based RCG platform, assisted by a Private Knowledge Base
Constructor and a Retrieval Tuning Module. By leveraging these capabilities,
users can explore the potential of RCG for improving generative AI performance
while maintaining privacy standards. The tool is available at
https://github.com/RCGAI/SimplyRetrieve with an MIT license. | [
0.0361335054,
0.0935564712,
-0.0281258263,
0.0552178249,
-0.0669078082,
-0.0317741483,
0.0400408767,
0.0005255424,
0.0286731385,
0.0105893584,
-0.0618910678,
-0.0120335864,
-0.0365557894,
0.0575787313,
-0.0070375022,
0.0001337126,
0.0174936876,
-0.0013064977,
0.0323815346,
-0.0317715704,
-0.039986603,
0.024352869,
0.0185539518,
0.0506189317,
-0.0016748742,
-0.0289718509,
-0.0138651868,
-0.001384414,
0.0049491795,
-0.0163019001,
0.0175592899,
0.0681096986,
0.0350693725,
0.0855099261,
0.0000024936,
-0.0501402505,
-0.0552922897,
0.024896197,
-0.0110058719,
-0.005712017,
0.0446704626,
-0.0019017818,
0.0185749996,
0.0186795071,
-0.0819324479,
0.0083493618,
0.0308489166,
0.0108993119,
0.0427628122,
0.0573416948,
0.003532598,
-0.0371367149,
-0.0008386315,
-0.0489651822,
0.0193494037,
-0.0559548177,
0.0173016284,
-0.0134930117,
-0.0244677402,
0.0524767786,
0.0026802458,
0.0367828272,
0.025523467,
0.021964822,
0.0296870992,
0.045780953,
-0.0292476341,
-0.0581374764,
-0.0208896622,
0.0305094998,
0.0597559251,
-0.0435337834,
0.0476631001,
0.0146692656,
0.0226343889,
0.0133630894,
-0.0407729633,
0.0856602788,
-0.0046012797,
0.0104470439,
0.0210143365,
-0.0036102245,
0.0006706759,
-0.0146276625,
0.0128378123,
0.033757735,
0.0261937156,
-0.0042617735,
-0.0455416515,
-0.0330812894,
0.0043416577,
-0.0533495285,
0.0456252135,
0.0351164863,
0.0698571429,
0.015931474,
-0.038085077,
-0.0476562157,
0.0487841219,
-0.0041165138,
0.0105229532,
-0.0008706478,
-0.0027231053,
0.0184118189,
-0.0207841191,
0.0354288146,
0.0077703674,
0.0260014385,
-0.0018323888,
-0.002446905,
-0.0290261339,
-0.0216926299,
-0.0681843683,
0.0475247875,
-0.0645121783,
-0.0239796974,
-0.0498822071,
0.0444767587,
-0.0372303724,
0.011797321,
0.0233810935,
0.042601373,
-0.0327727757,
-0.0071304389,
0.0164629072,
-0.048261214,
-0.0004069409,
-0.015427921,
0.037080206,
-0.0739602447,
-0.0163781121,
-0.0336543731,
0.017691154,
0.0053690565,
-0.0193370059,
0.0340959392,
0.018481683,
-0.0463575944,
-0.0085456865,
-0.0731664672,
0.0228288472,
-0.0538995489,
0.0017535071,
-0.0458388217,
0.0284891799,
-0.0153295211,
-0.0178591385,
-0.0912512764,
0.0202780236,
0.0216793548,
-0.0117667662,
0.018125115,
0.005611896,
0.0000618319,
0.0199917015,
0.0562000014,
0.0172113962,
0.0313810892,
0.0180875286,
0.0499621779,
0.0586133413,
-0.0003252104,
0.0467976443,
-0.0134809865,
0.0637774467,
-0.0286340751,
-0.0251678545,
0.0206662528,
-0.0297260694,
-0.0402269326,
-0.007469466,
0.0463194698,
-0.0122343954,
-0.0278747585,
0.0406918004,
0.0743176714,
0.0477170795,
0.0556036271,
0.0018423619,
0.0508772582,
-0.0245743301,
-0.0438659489,
-0.0159552023,
0.024615787,
-0.0813497007,
-0.0057588131,
-0.0185754877,
0.0363687687,
0.0092684859,
0.0004520164,
0.0081325043,
-0.0381114893,
0.019300621,
0.0118685141,
0.0646100491,
0.0197773967,
-0.01713714,
0.0221252758,
0.0135558862,
-0.099807784,
-0.0255019199,
-0.0727464706,
0.058476653,
0.0763131529,
0.0592356771,
0.0017273792,
0.0163984746,
0.018251026,
-0.055468075,
0.0004006823,
-0.0027898096,
0.0150185078,
0.0242215525,
-0.0403798446,
-0.029319426,
-0.0142335491,
0.0392410941,
0.0468483977,
0.0174682271,
0.007589478,
0.0458376631,
-0.0095020393,
0.0448252745,
0.0179671422,
-0.0262606908,
-0.0466290973,
0.0023224498,
0.0153137408,
0.0323177427,
0.0225562826,
-0.0095140785,
0.0233801156,
0.0541972443,
0.0010828278,
-0.0036459859,
0.0108764917,
-0.0125313448,
-0.0000244012,
-0.0344025828,
-0.0019261714,
0.0511668064,
0.0260621272,
-0.0187759325,
-0.0224711169,
0.0243776347,
0.0144411363,
0.0730683506,
-0.0881942064,
-0.0150708444,
-0.0080986377,
0.0189553555,
-0.0414905287,
0.049262464,
-0.0155746629,
-0.0413480103,
-0.0268195029,
0.0215567052,
-0.0092886817,
-0.048858393,
0.0163847953,
-0.0209567137,
-0.0192030724,
0.0097292233,
0.0267572999,
0.0142915789,
-0.0212112702,
-0.0334633663,
-0.0599129125,
0.0177427325,
-0.0283171069,
-0.0130587462,
0.0088781826,
0.0093217399,
-0.0353557132,
-0.0058227899,
-0.027234789,
0.0419449508,
0.0170686357,
0.0077117993,
-0.0279031005,
0.0277176499,
-0.0155221652,
-0.0080410317,
-0.011907083,
0.0349067189,
0.0375980772,
-0.0113057913,
0.0284418203,
-0.0251980145,
0.0669365674,
-0.0305494051,
0.0389705114,
-0.0119560044,
-0.0325130597,
0.0096565876,
-0.048555214,
-0.0107170744,
0.0564964451,
0.0226958133,
0.0292895697,
0.0449322537,
-0.0269938819,
-0.0632693395,
0.0095050391,
-0.045232553,
-0.069172062,
0.0207441151,
0.0003616137,
0.0189511441,
0.0270964988,
0.0201144256,
-0.0342614427,
-0.0492577776,
0.0532142185,
0.0083763869,
-0.0580444746,
-0.0265592933,
0.0054040821,
0.0075921365,
0.0514238365,
-0.0169233941,
-0.0815664381,
0.0525657795,
-0.0378978103,
0.0089875693,
0.0091184275,
-0.0349973179,
-0.0219067521,
0.1014555097,
-0.0063241399,
0.0567552038,
0.0298725795,
-0.0153393997,
-0.0139795821,
0.0345967822,
0.0196513832,
-0.0746185482,
-0.0037851855,
-0.0106207253,
-0.0253110249,
0.0051836343,
-0.0375158004,
-0.0771945864,
0.0006517505,
0.0155024035,
0.0046366164,
0.0234726351,
-0.0265577268,
0.0013625802,
-0.0071199164,
0.0232289638,
0.0225060452,
0.0056950622,
-0.0039740563,
0.002871902,
0.0075621996,
0.018975284,
-0.0411060415,
-0.023212675,
-0.0022249564,
-0.0273755547,
0.0699218735,
0.0157258771,
-0.0190401655,
0.0235815123,
-0.0273267757,
0.0331320949,
-0.0033435009,
-0.0011582903,
0.0321759433,
0.0145967854,
-0.0650919154,
-0.0328668877,
0.0788008198,
0.0184203442,
-0.0540156662,
-0.0241222102,
-0.0056671756,
0.0306203477,
0.0126771741,
0.0430734307,
-0.0990060866,
0.0219030064,
0.021809414,
0.0601490624,
-0.0222592093,
-0.0332727432,
-0.029646609,
-0.1021123305,
0.0618237816,
0.0066641471,
-0.0259327926,
-0.0143314153,
-0.0439769924,
-0.0107153971,
0.0027286469,
-0.0390007794,
0.0280130133,
-0.0076126279,
0.0124139283,
-0.0258325916,
0.0050833393,
-0.025011586,
0.0028903056,
-0.027626982,
0.0484455526,
0.0557642877,
0.0101802582,
0.0214931872,
-0.0426390916,
-0.0386470817,
0.0162702203,
0.0296820588,
-0.0253521781,
0.0008200568,
0.0079449769,
0.002764602,
-0.0265103187,
0.0340807252,
-0.0102518611,
-0.0313272104,
0.0109921861,
0.0193250105,
-0.0317658186,
-0.0024199367,
-0.037760511,
-0.0109800883,
0.0223276131,
0.0809720531,
0.0146423569,
-0.0045955763,
-0.0061344095,
-0.0166440792,
0.0618922003,
-0.0547120534,
-0.0131771583,
0.0101859067,
0.0197326429,
-0.0469251834,
-0.0768773109,
-0.0102669597,
-0.0304564871,
0.0243086275,
0.0140183233,
-0.0042913356,
0.0115926415,
-0.0045187511,
-0.0744083524,
0.0012237668,
-0.0740393847,
-0.0428919941,
-0.0348176062,
-0.0558734983,
0.0373420455,
-0.0487095006,
-0.0384513363,
0.0334545337,
-0.0382174589,
-0.045156274,
0.027754968,
0.0778527707,
0.0191134531,
0.0108993249,
-0.0056945998,
-0.0253646113,
0.0958372727,
0.0610635318,
-0.0660043284,
0.04947301,
0.0136707798,
0.0091753881,
0.0041193166,
0.0223051421,
-0.0523550585,
0.0175186824,
0.0235556122,
0.0128900586,
-0.0049998579,
-0.0615385547,
-0.0043390305,
0.0261343364,
0.0522975177,
-0.0031205935,
0.0233798455,
-0.0597919337,
0.0123971775,
-0.0455578454,
0.0201651491,
-0.0582537018,
0.0008159636,
0.0291009266,
-0.0405283757,
0.0380317792,
-0.0166012626,
0.0133932121,
0.0583309568,
-0.0657399148,
0.0244416445,
0.0184671879,
0.0145232193,
0.0223825462,
0.0252525583,
-0.0263993405,
0.0370592512,
-0.0475249551,
0.0474476628,
-0.0228610858,
0.0565686449,
-0.0245151035,
-0.033974234,
-0.0206782259,
0.0395191088,
-0.0486639291,
-0.0416027494,
-0.018354157,
0.0605313517,
0.043876823,
0.0464585945,
0.029881293,
-0.0509824082,
0.0075949887,
-0.034083236,
0.0184446778,
-0.0008810284,
-0.0829137638,
-0.0279772859,
0.0063546896,
-0.0031524482,
0.0139018828,
0.0729955882,
0.0020674001,
0.0301977582,
-0.0335962251,
-0.0130765894,
-0.0584400482,
-0.0373131447,
0.021633314,
0.022607768,
-0.0166010279,
-0.0038289696,
-0.0368965641,
-0.083232753,
-0.0000060934,
0.0207601227,
-0.0056065926,
0.0101845097,
0.038594041,
0.0496359952,
-0.0263664667,
-0.0684234053,
-0.0637841746,
0.0305368975,
-0.0529559627,
-0.0269908458,
-0.0193563811,
-7.066792123e-33,
-0.0275667552,
-0.0211136229,
0.0053264662,
-0.0177148413,
0.0280716307,
0.0225860123,
-0.0314191319,
-0.0127335126,
0.0317056663,
-0.0401052609,
-0.0310847349,
-0.0089659886,
0.0114024449,
0.0308300275,
-0.0178845394,
0.0374244638,
0.0355906561,
-0.0074445717,
0.0013255683,
0.0536564067,
0.0594172925,
0.0767138675,
-0.0068158507,
-0.1108774766,
0.008666995,
-0.0440165065,
-0.0373934694,
0.0041834959,
-0.052172143,
0.0485436879,
-0.0181511845,
-0.0047811368,
-0.0066477805,
0.0200235005,
-0.0052230069,
0.0114539023,
-0.0590364411,
-0.0058537833,
-0.0254132841,
-0.0184785593,
-0.0231365208,
-0.0787217766,
0.0594696999,
-0.0464650467,
-0.006702031,
0.0210980717,
0.0024466908,
-0.0192962084,
-0.0251351818,
-0.0724821687,
-0.0212585758,
-0.0224899705,
-0.0065559917,
0.0000198938,
0.0470352471,
-0.0120632425,
0.0193884745,
0.0008859436,
-0.048224967,
0.027888855,
0.0079656262,
-0.0295485277,
0.0586778,
0.0263972152,
0.0658528581,
0.0227394681,
0.0538204312,
-0.0203641504,
-0.027820278,
-0.021824168,
0.0207821112,
0.0749680921,
-0.0068373391,
0.0601292998,
0.0096192956,
-0.0418885015,
-0.0415217318,
0.0185570996,
-0.0309060235,
0.0053432658,
0.0810590386,
0.0258126482,
-0.0436065271,
0.029800415,
-0.0242989082,
-0.0156061267,
-0.049931407,
-0.0157327279,
0.0337634087,
0.0448425338,
-0.0491761416,
-0.0492701717,
0.0272171795,
-0.0496026427,
0.0096972883,
0.0556073897,
0.0353012346,
-0.027764421,
-0.0315122679,
0.0122653283,
-0.0206540246,
-0.0241611376,
0.0296371002,
-0.0392893851,
-0.0054685627,
0.0135605251,
0.0207084306,
0.0196532607,
-0.0437666848,
-0.0057447325,
-0.0457621738,
0.045921769,
0.0398332477,
-0.0226236507,
0.0185261164,
-0.000459567,
-0.0043060435,
0.01919703,
0.0446325652,
0.0519835241,
-0.0370200314,
0.0093564009,
0.0026857972,
-0.0109698074,
-0.0071420264,
0.0065505188,
0.013453817,
0.0539799407,
0.0964397341,
0.0073078796,
0.0028847835,
-0.0047550369,
3.215e-7,
0.0068067955,
0.032088358,
0.0025014237,
0.0013403746,
0.0051707053,
0.0238076001,
0.0106150582,
0.0394035988,
0.0084003368,
0.0217281319,
-0.0169668309,
0.0617150217,
0.0475847013,
0.0246667862,
-0.0587429628,
0.0091765551,
-0.0082283309,
-0.0082136979,
-0.0336437635,
0.0189446565,
0.0506694913,
0.0467340462,
0.0233296994,
-0.0008581694,
0.012594373,
-0.033967305,
0.0548641384,
-0.0529621728,
0.0025482825,
0.0005153958,
0.0179450065,
0.0914706066,
0.0027739196,
-0.0458503962,
-0.0172857847,
0.003375273,
-0.0668762922,
0.0808772221,
-0.0027180242,
-0.0531657599,
0.0439253896,
-0.0252784472,
-0.0192641858,
-0.0568922311,
0.0248766448,
-0.0380829759,
-0.0018691042,
-0.0130901979,
0.0025862474,
-0.0522805341,
-0.0055050529,
-0.0269970316,
0.0090956884,
0.0049486398,
-0.0170782935,
-0.0209268555,
0.0087654004,
-0.0828899741,
-0.026245134,
-0.0514767058,
-0.0463836566,
-0.0060326145,
-0.0271328799,
-0.0068843253,
-0.0245845225,
0.0045510014,
0.070819959,
3.083852721e-34,
-0.0073842132,
-0.0170374718,
-0.0371062011,
0.0219436623,
0.0366707966,
-0.0059990971,
0.026076274,
0.022994861,
-0.0141980685,
-0.0654826984,
-0.0377768166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03958v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03958v2 | Simple synthetic data reduces sycophancy in large language models | 2023-08-07T23:48:36 | 2024-02-15T01:03:13 | Jerry Wei, Da Huang, Yifeng Lu, Denny Zhou, Quoc V. Le | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sycophancy is an undesirable behavior where models tailor their responses to
follow a human user's view even when that view is not objectively correct
(e.g., adapting liberal views once a user reveals that they are liberal). In
this paper, we study the prevalence of sycophancy in language models and
propose a simple synthetic-data intervention to reduce this behavior.
First, on a set of three sycophancy tasks (Perez et al., 2022) where models
are asked for an opinion on statements with no correct answers (e.g.,
politics), we observe that both model scaling and instruction tuning
significantly increase sycophancy for PaLM models up to 540B parameters.
Second, we extend sycophancy evaluations to simple addition statements that are
objectively incorrect, finding that despite knowing that these statements are
wrong, language models will still agree with them if the user does as well.
To reduce sycophancy, we present a straightforward synthetic-data
intervention that takes public NLP tasks and encourages models to be robust to
user opinions on these tasks. Adding these data in a lightweight finetuning
step can significantly reduce sycophantic behavior on held-out prompts. Code
for generating synthetic data for intervention can be found at
https://github.com/google/sycophancy-intervention. | [
0.0513212383,
0.0637823269,
-0.016400326,
0.0120667061,
-0.0160400961,
0.0349366963,
0.0069935801,
-0.0109502114,
0.0072303773,
-0.0673075691,
-0.0281763487,
-0.0400191918,
-0.0160498694,
0.0010480209,
0.0153670721,
-0.0609680936,
0.0966946781,
-0.004871726,
0.0323947482,
-0.0575798601,
0.0002847667,
0.0045465413,
-0.0088979146,
0.0084020449,
0.0165315755,
-0.0402958617,
0.0104499087,
-0.0045176269,
0.0004944662,
-0.0179919414,
0.0147845261,
0.0781492665,
-0.0422895923,
0.0516212843,
0.000001933,
-0.0326028317,
0.0216539949,
-0.0147170546,
-0.0108934352,
0.0431599766,
0.1003069133,
0.000620149,
-0.0038024432,
0.0531612188,
-0.0480394512,
-0.0071182139,
0.0328596495,
0.0423663817,
0.0388754494,
0.0383607596,
0.0014262805,
0.0272927172,
-0.0164005179,
-0.024342021,
-0.0072272429,
0.023339754,
0.0204327889,
-0.0613194443,
-0.003789559,
-0.0040885834,
-0.0018900261,
0.038446717,
0.0282403082,
-0.005162525,
-0.0377088711,
0.0055213263,
-0.0407300256,
-0.0219070036,
-0.0085908929,
0.0487167649,
0.0232909173,
-0.0307883937,
0.0031514654,
-0.0194126256,
0.0348256752,
0.0490951501,
-0.0249482933,
-0.0139455618,
0.014665815,
-0.0065107001,
0.0649938509,
-0.0253016539,
0.0301403292,
0.0038812039,
-0.0125673451,
0.0602198169,
0.006349822,
-0.0392137356,
0.0232814476,
0.0149557237,
-0.0350060239,
-0.056951452,
0.0010906302,
0.0142949782,
-0.061212644,
0.0194138717,
-0.0302388053,
-0.0081852395,
0.046390567,
-0.0986449793,
0.029101545,
0.0381557681,
0.0012517975,
0.0469422378,
-0.0223692097,
0.0065891901,
-0.0528227575,
0.0954751968,
-0.0222747773,
-0.008383587,
0.0249084719,
-0.0170915853,
0.0055219322,
0.0022955562,
-0.0440214202,
-0.007443558,
0.0045137042,
0.0246945582,
-0.0417805873,
0.0035187397,
0.0108983712,
0.040169064,
0.0086970376,
-0.0133325057,
-0.0606787093,
0.0464130752,
-0.0405337363,
0.0359846018,
0.0027624338,
-0.0485378131,
-0.0112395976,
-0.0038720346,
-0.0041771755,
-0.0004116767,
0.0266946983,
0.026969824,
0.0055746473,
0.0137157878,
-0.0124361655,
-0.0155669022,
-0.0405168198,
-0.0654701963,
0.0091019282,
-0.0635925606,
0.0106217079,
0.0322930776,
0.0055747661,
-0.0006388129,
0.0043951254,
0.0159450416,
-0.0251272712,
0.0550016835,
-0.0245947465,
0.014514396,
0.0099545317,
0.0041034147,
0.0201393403,
0.1013005078,
0.0141711505,
-0.0155172152,
0.0244921129,
-0.02486296,
0.0189853087,
0.0218098965,
0.0064753769,
0.0163313989,
-0.0212666318,
0.0198642407,
0.0087214494,
-0.0028680123,
0.0462918654,
0.0867674351,
-0.0086429268,
-0.0573617965,
0.0665657446,
0.0289452523,
-0.0273666997,
0.0080335699,
0.0115418667,
-0.0340903103,
-0.0070548984,
0.0549535155,
-0.0771234408,
0.0331702083,
-0.0186754577,
0.0024993545,
-0.008476113,
0.0170383975,
-0.0304994602,
-0.0410015099,
-0.0357072987,
0.0143108852,
0.0636886954,
0.0459631793,
0.0137567483,
0.0185126215,
-0.002768314,
0.0570301488,
0.0505563058,
-0.0514136702,
-0.0072729117,
-0.0473718271,
0.0105569568,
0.0553346612,
0.0350264609,
-0.0080196969,
0.0013162356,
-0.0306697655,
0.005555233,
0.0780239478,
0.1093154848,
-0.0360378884,
-0.0373621881,
-0.0229091775,
-0.0007682628,
0.0097966418,
0.0474029072,
-0.0034717384,
0.0166742094,
-0.001148603,
-0.0051259822,
0.0347668342,
-0.0334709994,
0.027935205,
-0.0664943233,
-0.0507576838,
-0.0215764437,
-0.0096230162,
0.0432400703,
0.0016172708,
0.0059758658,
0.0103166876,
0.023970494,
0.0138464738,
-0.0076407422,
0.0038877414,
-0.0775253251,
-0.0145338252,
0.0166070573,
-0.0010264694,
-0.0052795825,
0.0764684007,
0.0097480407,
-0.025112642,
0.0269941892,
-0.0620141476,
0.0397455357,
-0.0505005866,
0.0174687505,
-0.0747719705,
0.0121253263,
-0.0406139307,
-0.0000739149,
-0.0166698396,
0.035092704,
0.0342160426,
-0.0117979897,
-0.0265149809,
-0.0289589968,
-0.0227867998,
0.019759139,
0.0251449365,
0.0138182892,
0.0362382233,
-0.036440488,
-0.0287089683,
-0.0518977717,
-0.0922244266,
-0.0303152911,
-0.0338169336,
0.0035840103,
0.0483649708,
-0.0038493436,
0.0008894515,
-0.0054030581,
-0.0172831919,
0.0148050478,
0.0061937477,
0.0606169477,
0.0153625337,
-0.0041381624,
-0.0228532888,
-0.0482396074,
-0.0204027612,
-0.0361732841,
0.0220291167,
0.0069430303,
0.049812641,
-0.0347475596,
0.0169263855,
-0.0366517864,
0.025350688,
-0.0092261946,
-0.0407769494,
0.0203647185,
0.0189319272,
0.018493427,
0.0794888586,
0.0252710152,
0.0322013758,
0.0705489591,
0.0155756129,
-0.0605136752,
0.0003947382,
-0.0430526771,
0.0060060262,
-0.0497124195,
-0.0413172282,
-0.0096669318,
0.1159026697,
0.0139623871,
-0.0048440895,
-0.0439200066,
-0.0052533885,
-0.0395062268,
-0.067011103,
0.0195927583,
-0.0054533416,
-0.0496940725,
0.0048206486,
-0.0210783966,
-0.0312600993,
0.0933109969,
0.0177483167,
0.0132133402,
-0.0545296408,
-0.0146417953,
-0.0149791883,
0.0544480234,
-0.0097944411,
0.0079958141,
0.0020690821,
-0.0050120177,
-0.0871162564,
-0.0358391069,
0.0228161756,
-0.0611415915,
0.0359035693,
-0.0125606861,
-0.0096165007,
-0.0063567567,
-0.0549911894,
-0.0495182686,
-0.0668468103,
-0.0420013107,
0.0007540903,
0.0513012484,
-0.0333854705,
0.007588916,
-0.0569094308,
0.0409444906,
0.0363502838,
-0.0189915635,
-0.0118533121,
-0.0057970388,
-0.0167503525,
0.0841830969,
0.0092459265,
0.0812810436,
-0.0521081313,
0.0278368983,
0.0577478223,
0.0232382249,
0.0428068601,
0.0014356241,
-0.0296414923,
0.0642521232,
-0.0144231785,
-0.0305578746,
0.0110548027,
0.0372067392,
-0.0486173406,
-0.0109834662,
0.1069536731,
0.0383025892,
-0.0459017493,
0.0142037412,
-0.0485478975,
0.0246172398,
0.0671539754,
-0.0008013248,
-0.0440616459,
-0.0031593908,
0.028296886,
-0.0212633722,
-0.0414740629,
-0.026860008,
-0.0227200892,
-0.0923783705,
-0.0068860091,
-0.0074931281,
-0.004984857,
0.0038035573,
-0.0499870144,
0.028219983,
-0.0250329953,
0.0522057377,
0.0177365541,
-0.0271528028,
0.0098866038,
0.0130940583,
-0.0054219598,
-0.0054021911,
0.0320593901,
-0.0130024301,
0.0668684244,
0.0281591807,
0.0228761528,
-0.011831196,
-0.055794809,
0.0673118904,
-0.0025653953,
-0.0311936419,
-0.0117389485,
0.0322516896,
0.0026508137,
-0.0070379293,
-0.0370838232,
0.0301486943,
-0.0276934914,
0.0083016763,
-0.0083358353,
0.049144309,
-0.0012657078,
-0.0584268793,
-0.032404419,
0.0252274144,
0.0129645234,
0.0712556243,
0.0538019538,
-0.0720386058,
-0.0152721033,
-0.0354624465,
-0.0296781082,
0.0021822429,
-0.0355374031,
0.0054729879,
0.0629608333,
-0.0089698834,
-0.0569521412,
-0.0798772946,
0.0016415158,
0.0160774086,
0.0070417146,
-0.0187183544,
0.0353996977,
-0.0455886982,
-0.0196512546,
0.0027453536,
-0.0232181568,
0.0355744287,
-0.0409937911,
0.0210099947,
0.00111633,
0.0282089822,
-0.0161814094,
-0.013958944,
-0.0539633408,
-0.0771048516,
0.083279334,
0.0149131846,
0.0297821704,
0.0044237822,
-0.0251541212,
-0.0821950883,
0.0491384491,
0.0585389435,
-0.0424892679,
0.0421151258,
0.0310560912,
-0.0221710186,
0.0181813147,
0.0406803004,
0.0062466967,
0.0013196078,
0.0621742122,
0.0071780095,
-0.0562285259,
-0.0352284722,
0.0201112404,
0.020942051,
0.0589838214,
0.0011485872,
-0.0385358036,
-0.0211632457,
-0.007583715,
-0.0394347087,
-0.0041142069,
0.0050228462,
-0.012404657,
-0.0101446714,
-0.0200002436,
-0.0235361811,
-0.0103486553,
-0.0190164298,
0.0164900701,
0.0022884572,
-0.0020002541,
0.0046129576,
-0.0069695222,
0.0077326307,
0.0093588289,
-0.0537935831,
0.023551153,
-0.0185409021,
0.0272436775,
0.0292913783,
0.0434566252,
0.028978169,
-0.0263210963,
-0.0053883772,
0.0148952231,
-0.0547696501,
-0.0428029448,
-0.0089944303,
0.0217354037,
0.010454772,
-0.0005063922,
0.0258061737,
0.0013815915,
-0.0246425923,
-0.0334328488,
-0.0035846313,
-0.0018548612,
-0.0316650234,
0.0350452103,
0.0355369188,
-0.020348683,
-0.0328453928,
0.0417418741,
-0.0244083945,
0.0536979474,
0.0117959669,
0.0050123842,
-0.0213219468,
-0.0448891968,
-0.0067507992,
0.0176955517,
-0.0634922534,
0.0148323309,
-0.1001635864,
-0.066744186,
0.0078039509,
0.0445312448,
0.0101824086,
-0.0331678763,
0.0137862759,
0.0432047658,
-0.0382347666,
-0.0003777733,
-0.041159302,
0.0029562565,
-0.0032730717,
-0.0089733182,
-0.0179604366,
-6.625090569e-33,
-0.0149999559,
-0.0243337117,
0.0199168548,
-0.0170776062,
0.0142367082,
-0.0069951043,
-0.0268621426,
0.0583180338,
-0.0422056727,
0.051987879,
-0.0200344473,
0.0489203185,
0.0115978699,
-0.00996261,
0.0203381348,
-0.0327315964,
0.0554396212,
0.001714911,
-0.0397381783,
-0.0067394176,
0.0563943051,
-0.0295583121,
0.0512848869,
-0.0559023172,
0.0367792994,
0.0240353104,
-0.0078155603,
-0.0240608864,
-0.06885539,
0.0155631537,
-0.0235280693,
0.0609085262,
0.0206569619,
-0.0235207044,
-0.0213988721,
0.0618979894,
-0.0080451025,
-0.0483416319,
0.0445316993,
0.0001497086,
-0.038050089,
-0.0136397984,
0.0184804294,
-0.0144861406,
-0.0516588651,
-0.0253569856,
0.0068055699,
-0.0215269793,
0.0185809545,
0.0212878156,
-0.0456611514,
0.0024508953,
0.0306963343,
-0.017757114,
-0.0455220938,
0.078899838,
-0.0011256605,
-0.0073556984,
-0.0464327,
0.0362792797,
0.0178828835,
0.0321881995,
0.0416835211,
0.023823522,
0.0016719933,
0.0604912192,
0.0455293097,
0.040903613,
0.0000044718,
0.0011449665,
0.0477433279,
0.0010822864,
0.0725560486,
0.0901056826,
0.0536233634,
-0.0573964678,
0.0042743157,
-0.0124680335,
0.0281374734,
-0.0047388161,
0.0362810269,
-0.0154601596,
-0.0258622523,
-0.0265281871,
-0.0805906057,
0.00077399,
-0.0474929065,
-0.0092366477,
-0.0094991233,
0.0224253889,
-0.0155524537,
0.0289564561,
0.0182354506,
-0.0371107571,
-0.026858788,
0.001494438,
-0.0144790718,
0.0049502212,
0.0231097788,
0.0148568163,
-0.0352261215,
0.0024656272,
-0.0107598305,
0.0410180949,
0.0131427543,
0.0129286209,
0.0325044207,
0.0136506539,
-0.0947901979,
0.0069271848,
-0.0215088781,
0.0321402214,
0.0118188821,
-0.0563970543,
0.0402521901,
0.00973133,
-0.00624834,
0.0015223487,
0.0043510944,
-0.0119370073,
-0.0459296666,
0.0308251902,
-0.023535287,
0.0443873666,
-0.0176524948,
-0.0265243463,
-0.0467378162,
0.0365182459,
0.0147505533,
-0.0635942444,
-0.0203277711,
-0.017369993,
2.648e-7,
0.0204816498,
0.0541592315,
-0.038142968,
0.0135255381,
0.0208329745,
0.0481974818,
0.0447256453,
0.0359771289,
-0.0095758541,
-0.0587333143,
-0.0304522365,
0.0195335895,
0.0363151766,
0.0295183472,
-0.0659352541,
0.0020169129,
-0.088838011,
0.0504237376,
-0.0248061046,
0.0198937859,
0.0040023457,
0.0714559108,
0.0495758094,
-0.003673051,
-0.0035900876,
0.0012415359,
0.0694832876,
-0.0417497978,
-0.0034355659,
0.0070947334,
0.0262305271,
-0.0229381081,
0.0439038537,
0.0155299855,
-0.0132243745,
0.0060112812,
-0.0371914729,
0.0563991442,
-0.0001958456,
-0.0246252473,
-0.0078235473,
-0.0439200923,
-0.0231178496,
-0.0768104941,
0.0646285564,
-0.0705600828,
-0.0182152279,
-0.0587164834,
-0.0219322816,
0.0033351649,
0.0589896142,
-0.0244704131,
-0.0211062543,
0.0031642343,
0.0117524257,
0.0031512147,
0.0075208172,
-0.0523798466,
-0.0387001596,
-0.0071801334,
-0.0272880066,
-0.0745266899,
-0.0042898548,
0.0148020489,
0.0291473828,
-0.0750023276,
0.0200086609,
2.589995172e-34,
0.0569535904,
0.0077028349,
0.0380635113,
-0.0253989175,
0.014447269,
-0.017922584,
0.019464694,
-0.0027742465,
0.0594749525,
-0.052261021,
-0.0289010704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03929v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03929v4 | Fact-Checking Generative AI: Ontology-Driven Biological Graphs for Disease-Gene Link Verification | 2023-08-07T22:13:30 | 2024-04-08T14:47:37 | Ahmed Abdeen Hamed, Byung Suk Lee, Alessandro Crimi, Magdalena M. Misiak | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2 | Since the launch of various generative AI tools, scientists have been
striving to evaluate their capabilities and contents, in the hope of
establishing trust in their generative abilities. Regulations and guidelines
are emerging to verify generated contents and identify novel uses. we aspire to
demonstrate how ChatGPT claims are checked computationally using the rigor of
network models. We aim to achieve fact-checking of the knowledge embedded in
biological graphs that were contrived from ChatGPT contents at the aggregate
level. We adopted a biological networks approach that enables the systematic
interrogation of ChatGPT's linked entities. We designed an ontology-driven
fact-checking algorithm that compares biological graphs constructed from
approximately 200,000 PubMed abstracts with counterparts constructed from a
dataset generated using the ChatGPT-3.5 Turbo model. In 10-samples of 250
randomly selected records a ChatGPT dataset of 1000 "simulated" articles , the
fact-checking link accuracy ranged from 70% to 86%. This study demonstrated
high accuracy of aggregate disease-gene links relationships found in
ChatGPT-generated texts. | [
0.0053345999,
0.0411889479,
-0.00650245,
0.00600293,
-0.0313238315,
-0.0024058868,
0.0213100314,
0.0264745839,
0.0812297016,
0.0154294008,
0.0251132138,
0.0062252707,
0.0213747881,
0.0608075596,
-0.0068176845,
0.0348535813,
0.0373504199,
0.0497814268,
0.0284910239,
-0.0117834201,
-0.0234663617,
0.0464634448,
-0.0191301145,
0.0133469831,
-0.0245124437,
-0.0276461598,
0.0404626504,
-0.0098816082,
0.0725829229,
-0.0489635728,
-0.0139112147,
0.011173957,
-0.0450632647,
0.0507575311,
0.0000018228,
-0.0415078998,
-0.0222175345,
0.0616924092,
-0.0432961024,
-0.0101876911,
0.0298108831,
0.0262295827,
0.0075437571,
0.0081892805,
-0.0072524361,
-0.0419015698,
0.0509886742,
0.0454859249,
0.02396507,
0.0594378933,
-0.0172646567,
-0.0117271999,
0.1010610536,
-0.0000617141,
0.0499015562,
-0.0183591302,
0.0671581924,
0.0624209009,
0.0284473002,
-0.0089578982,
0.0486601964,
0.0402973257,
-0.0114564542,
-0.0203424003,
0.0085254861,
0.0385535993,
0.0084676817,
-0.0173339657,
0.0382296778,
0.0319341272,
0.0399278365,
-0.0562463962,
0.0584340617,
-0.005554867,
-0.0052478886,
0.0773077607,
-0.0095777903,
-0.001558285,
-0.0651784912,
-0.000137402,
0.0337305963,
-0.0151349613,
0.0490691066,
-0.0172039829,
0.0157599971,
0.0384457223,
-0.0245897062,
-0.0238508303,
-0.0070695584,
-0.0088034645,
0.0280216374,
-0.0626444966,
0.0092627071,
0.0149166426,
-0.0330115631,
0.0035427748,
0.0334368385,
-0.0021749954,
0.0617908835,
-0.0319407098,
-0.040651001,
-0.0266723931,
-0.0042380397,
0.0057697902,
0.009972305,
-0.032175567,
-0.0485980771,
0.0302471332,
0.0159470476,
-0.0155256474,
-0.0757129118,
-0.0076284478,
-0.0052093142,
0.0114323478,
0.0044786483,
0.0185896065,
-0.0798948184,
-0.0065479651,
-0.0403463133,
0.0311460476,
0.0441880524,
0.0190149155,
0.0115152271,
0.0241646711,
-0.0523964912,
-0.0240811277,
0.0121885194,
0.0226205252,
-0.0226882603,
-0.041169066,
0.0043633836,
-0.0267561916,
0.0476220995,
0.0015469238,
-0.005748569,
0.058305718,
0.0270681549,
-0.0065251351,
-0.0039226534,
-0.0674137473,
-0.031736359,
-0.0720178932,
0.0141793052,
-0.0591842569,
0.048430644,
0.0073910691,
-0.0088262418,
-0.0252806786,
-0.0154657187,
0.0125727775,
-0.0863574669,
0.0173017848,
-0.0797216818,
-0.0217868276,
0.0133002261,
0.0141367279,
-0.0073595685,
-0.0296088401,
0.0259037428,
-0.0127565004,
0.0445531905,
0.0340831839,
0.0019607556,
-0.0350229405,
0.046844881,
-0.0491478555,
0.0915579423,
-0.0112831993,
-0.0115597658,
0.0310783107,
-0.0520424582,
0.0492997803,
-0.024993889,
-0.0225679316,
0.033980839,
0.0176608618,
0.0495426878,
0.0290041845,
0.0318837464,
-0.0095626023,
0.0269818865,
-0.0080190618,
-0.0146944411,
0.0311967991,
-0.0216165408,
0.0307767931,
0.0118565671,
0.0287648141,
0.0368981101,
-0.0305241011,
-0.0371737853,
0.0288634449,
-0.0201966129,
-0.0535298176,
-0.0010235007,
-0.007858105,
-0.005939771,
-0.0199342687,
0.0359797962,
-0.0170057639,
-0.0097007444,
-0.028640883,
0.0056328271,
0.0522122569,
0.0833721682,
-0.0207540188,
-0.043573942,
-0.0051266872,
-0.0362197198,
0.0365546122,
0.0032639278,
-0.0533068292,
-0.0534144044,
0.0157772973,
0.0318342634,
0.0083932085,
0.0349971876,
-0.0020654493,
0.0065965676,
0.0248548631,
-0.0271795858,
-0.0445347466,
-0.0224726833,
-0.0047495132,
-0.0336237401,
0.0307818949,
-0.0123988045,
-0.0306411274,
0.0484045856,
0.05177892,
-0.0329128429,
0.0299770888,
0.0307518542,
0.0060481997,
-0.0614462048,
0.0280959178,
0.0434352346,
-0.0213439669,
0.0133368373,
-0.0467600189,
-0.0374925509,
-0.0072413939,
-0.0345068164,
-0.0253870003,
-0.0057954928,
-0.00894849,
0.0034679212,
-0.0296783764,
-0.0372674242,
0.0092818672,
-0.0012441912,
0.0366708711,
0.0502779558,
-0.0206177123,
-0.0243714321,
-0.0041488083,
-0.0388730206,
0.0465383492,
-0.0367451124,
0.0417545922,
-0.0121282469,
0.0189702176,
-0.0014155154,
0.0189258251,
-0.0298377611,
-0.0014149992,
0.0392932445,
-0.0506910235,
0.0217506178,
0.043102026,
0.0603836887,
-0.0069362014,
-0.050294023,
0.0079106959,
0.0155310761,
-0.0235361196,
0.0375694036,
0.0295632072,
-0.0129986973,
0.0587405562,
-0.0091388999,
-0.0385346413,
-0.045534905,
0.0036661867,
-0.0712959915,
0.0724066496,
0.0686139017,
-0.0235504154,
0.0188969877,
-0.0243230537,
-0.0832870901,
0.011294785,
0.0163736604,
0.0134188142,
0.0198286418,
0.0341039561,
0.0066709607,
-0.0059723863,
-0.0275969841,
-0.0044403109,
0.0524749756,
0.0110087981,
0.0157369822,
0.0020924588,
-0.0506672263,
0.032352861,
0.0075267465,
-0.0556340292,
0.0217500906,
0.0173275676,
0.0324139744,
-0.0165674686,
-0.028037928,
0.0494157076,
0.0051632719,
0.023187343,
0.0202468205,
-0.0148268621,
0.0147807384,
0.0353639126,
-0.0091594048,
-0.0151986666,
0.0929129496,
-0.0297851041,
0.0551837198,
-0.024839187,
0.0108852498,
0.0150889577,
0.0236224271,
0.041844178,
0.0289393533,
0.0536464192,
0.053317178,
0.0088233184,
0.0216350704,
0.0623599924,
-0.0196626894,
-0.0088471267,
-0.0404760242,
0.0553583875,
0.0604584403,
-0.0088088857,
-0.0289786719,
0.0736286417,
-0.025180839,
0.0136660887,
0.0371359289,
-0.0577901602,
-0.0431090146,
-0.0113900071,
0.0202619582,
0.0126108387,
0.0111726755,
-0.0195939746,
0.005970106,
0.0318606757,
0.0377434455,
-0.0463689379,
0.0319057368,
0.032242585,
0.0016270828,
0.0315628573,
-0.0632367134,
0.0104453806,
-0.0064958534,
-0.0251277033,
-0.0720810369,
-0.038536977,
0.0166377183,
-0.0043208832,
-0.0357922949,
-0.0217510555,
-0.0136095732,
0.0356211327,
0.038823396,
-0.006241098,
0.025294153,
0.0330251791,
-0.056128975,
-0.0259873103,
0.0478398167,
-0.1264028549,
0.0112825539,
-0.0463654511,
-0.0344953425,
-0.0524018109,
-0.0828386322,
-0.0109843249,
-0.0380016379,
0.0699837282,
-0.0003318908,
-0.0268051252,
-0.0270006489,
-0.089759618,
-0.0121591641,
-0.0576828606,
-0.0460090041,
-0.0259802304,
0.0419188142,
0.009007128,
-0.0120310877,
-0.0147946216,
-0.0544236638,
0.0220711641,
-0.015495819,
0.0745933875,
-0.007655886,
0.0471466109,
0.0133005548,
-0.0230274666,
0.0030785019,
0.046564728,
-0.012928457,
-0.0166444127,
0.0827583075,
0.0122122066,
0.0188305248,
-0.0921700224,
0.0143561196,
0.0058046551,
-0.0425190553,
-0.0203250796,
0.103435874,
-0.0009681497,
-0.0689325929,
-0.0403255485,
0.0076850252,
-0.0192743912,
0.045873642,
-0.0162460916,
0.0472354591,
-0.0158374812,
-0.0134747913,
0.0122574624,
-0.0404593572,
-0.0399298705,
0.0480907112,
-0.0501866676,
-0.016288979,
-0.068483077,
0.0026484334,
-0.018119067,
-0.0271494165,
-0.0309962928,
-0.0174111668,
0.0562009774,
-0.0392258018,
-0.0631662533,
-0.0033152639,
-0.0108636944,
0.0152147114,
0.0343817957,
-0.0314499959,
0.0672353432,
-0.0099532455,
-0.015054008,
0.0551015176,
-0.0146905174,
-0.0439697988,
-0.0555451103,
-0.0045895078,
0.0214073081,
0.0071625747,
-0.0230990686,
0.0210593548,
0.039125137,
0.0820164904,
-0.0536874011,
-0.0254066102,
-0.0439847708,
-0.0174460299,
-0.015098813,
-0.012241859,
-0.0384018943,
0.0358952582,
-0.0049908343,
0.0179200359,
-0.0243327916,
0.0085601136,
0.0601669699,
0.057546027,
0.028876299,
0.0024759762,
-0.0173745453,
-0.0559693128,
0.0148027837,
-0.0330323614,
-0.0136908749,
0.0168350153,
-0.0017704127,
-0.0265547484,
0.0127660604,
-0.0147104682,
-0.0113158962,
-0.0535601154,
0.0125763677,
-0.0526221395,
-0.0271806587,
0.0023232179,
-0.0030628443,
0.0212176051,
-0.0473864004,
0.004876365,
-0.0234777592,
-0.0383942761,
0.0068715522,
-0.0120963752,
-0.0099245878,
0.025811879,
-0.0204028338,
-0.0354791991,
-0.0242879521,
-0.0515196025,
0.0321169235,
-0.0279554967,
0.0316403471,
0.0416418575,
0.057343401,
0.0303976685,
-0.0657305047,
-0.017279679,
-0.0215177424,
-0.0058605713,
-0.0043467567,
-0.0034757389,
-0.0028259964,
0.0018747506,
-0.0309279356,
-0.0352724828,
0.0532501787,
0.0445631668,
0.0677264184,
-0.019338714,
-0.083466202,
-0.0293763988,
-0.0804449692,
-0.0442745425,
-0.0176857412,
-0.0265129823,
-0.0324271396,
-0.062365409,
-0.0682755485,
0.0100105722,
0.0852752477,
0.0320971906,
0.0270282105,
-0.0183413923,
0.0029254216,
0.0559763461,
-0.064112857,
0.0035618858,
0.0182020832,
-0.0749073252,
-0.0420169868,
0.0189507082,
-6.058085359e-33,
0.0014349576,
-0.0873406455,
0.0402604602,
0.058627855,
0.0116734533,
0.0285969879,
-0.0728358254,
-0.0364693515,
0.0090631898,
0.0922434032,
0.0268386751,
0.0300968047,
-0.0141562074,
-0.0238195881,
-0.0293874424,
0.0178269502,
0.0412683301,
-0.0076482436,
0.0032016509,
0.0082769813,
0.0174861904,
-0.0122783286,
-0.006282269,
-0.0795404091,
0.032286223,
-0.0108627686,
-0.0083943708,
0.0230384022,
-0.0645195171,
0.062072888,
0.0069739823,
0.0400009118,
0.0296422746,
-0.0084612612,
0.0383536294,
-0.0611660555,
-0.0805227384,
-0.0000420829,
0.0207652133,
-0.063123472,
-0.0373170041,
-0.0024505358,
0.0196592007,
0.0184599422,
-0.0300658289,
-0.0195917487,
0.0339365192,
-0.010394535,
-0.0350998938,
-0.0646393001,
-0.0277441666,
0.0270562228,
0.0128879035,
0.0303814951,
-0.0313336961,
-0.0392443277,
-0.0090915803,
-0.009880241,
-0.0265658628,
0.0286887903,
0.0250235908,
-0.0305637158,
0.0389112681,
-0.0555494204,
0.0180640761,
0.0441438518,
0.0069564781,
0.0121368254,
-0.0411711,
0.054284662,
-0.0451560989,
0.0479330681,
0.023143474,
0.0532605164,
-0.0125942426,
0.0102484161,
-0.1168173552,
0.0631095544,
-0.0226878934,
0.008393975,
-0.0219166391,
0.0032313839,
0.0113340179,
-0.0101106288,
-0.0017096808,
0.0103428736,
-0.0356362723,
-0.0258057583,
-0.0308706686,
-0.0485319793,
-0.0110150147,
0.0375191718,
-0.0206847098,
-0.04258807,
0.0057771201,
0.0224747341,
0.0160667859,
-0.0158789959,
-0.0207294468,
0.0107909646,
-0.0447957553,
0.0149027277,
0.0243259426,
0.0141960178,
0.0365358666,
0.0142444046,
0.0481298119,
-0.0207843222,
-0.0316022933,
0.0144171007,
-0.0131200887,
0.0120892497,
-0.0019271031,
-0.0445830226,
0.0060683512,
0.0163297039,
0.011369193,
0.0183649771,
0.0548065193,
0.0679896399,
-0.0176895186,
0.0750721768,
-0.0406921357,
-0.0101957899,
-0.0364140794,
0.0016423796,
-0.0246221162,
0.0087930718,
-0.0081082396,
-0.0725502148,
-0.0007961791,
0.021533832,
2.732e-7,
0.0392128825,
0.0636708885,
0.0183112025,
0.0335262567,
0.0501386337,
-0.0181685593,
-0.0003125606,
-0.0161039699,
-0.0499190539,
-0.0379710309,
0.0319290608,
0.0120008131,
-0.0158461798,
0.0631286576,
-0.0151933329,
0.0109373871,
-0.0458640493,
-0.0463106781,
-0.0258554853,
0.0067217927,
0.0175597351,
-0.0171487704,
0.0025738759,
0.0099002877,
0.0342926793,
-0.0040382901,
0.0137714688,
0.0466004871,
-0.0226231609,
0.0363705605,
0.014171266,
-0.0283157509,
0.0293629207,
0.0553124025,
-0.0286431611,
-0.026760323,
-0.0316159278,
0.0157813914,
-0.0043410407,
0.0321697332,
0.0336063467,
-0.0665658787,
0.0576477908,
-0.0199325755,
0.0103090256,
-0.0212837197,
-0.0353557989,
-0.0001181317,
-0.0018274842,
-0.001448037,
0.0141396131,
0.0010643074,
0.0023709757,
0.0195974596,
-0.0295611303,
0.0522481054,
0.0127650136,
-0.0345481113,
0.0132153751,
0.0562453642,
-0.0171763878,
-0.0495166034,
0.0501052178,
-0.0176061261,
0.0315172821,
-0.050048776,
0.0165562406,
2.047417745e-34,
0.0398960263,
0.019039236,
-0.0195347276,
-0.0536712334,
0.0754263327,
-0.0125429137,
-0.00439263,
-0.0151125723,
-0.0162793454,
-0.0487939082,
-0.0162937436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03917v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03917v1 | Universal Automatic Phonetic Transcription into the International Phonetic Alphabet | 2023-08-07T21:29:51 | 2023-08-07T21:29:51 | Chihiro Taguchi, Yusuke Sakai, Parisa Haghani, David Chiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper presents a state-of-the-art model for transcribing speech in any
language into the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA). Transcription of
spoken languages into IPA is an essential yet time-consuming process in
language documentation, and even partially automating this process has the
potential to drastically speed up the documentation of endangered languages.
Like the previous best speech-to-IPA model (Wav2Vec2Phoneme), our model is
based on wav2vec 2.0 and is fine-tuned to predict IPA from audio input. We use
training data from seven languages from CommonVoice 11.0, transcribed into IPA
semi-automatically. Although this training dataset is much smaller than
Wav2Vec2Phoneme's, its higher quality lets our model achieve comparable or
better results. Furthermore, we show that the quality of our universal
speech-to-IPA models is close to that of human annotators. | [
-0.0034034278,
0.0493609048,
0.0140304267,
-0.0128933787,
-0.0112376045,
0.0066086203,
0.004484586,
-0.0199773684,
-0.0310468469,
-0.0019750402,
-0.0149094108,
-0.0152114537,
0.0754060149,
-0.0404831432,
0.0293198545,
-0.0500987209,
0.0137717109,
-0.0827743635,
0.0393916406,
-0.0301199835,
0.0030952415,
0.0268628988,
-0.0513088554,
0.0477871783,
-0.0656515062,
-0.0070161191,
0.0013463673,
0.0311824419,
0.0148473149,
-0.0268396121,
-0.0105228843,
0.0124647887,
-0.007356253,
0.0131008262,
0.000001673,
-0.0390254594,
-0.0000338184,
0.0332611166,
-0.0408616886,
0.0465778038,
-0.028996503,
-0.006550807,
-0.0395259932,
0.0495613627,
0.0081345905,
-0.0459684692,
0.098898463,
0.0006764301,
0.0111985337,
0.0294356849,
-0.0177013408,
-0.0703985393,
0.0445102789,
-0.0202895999,
-0.0015316304,
-0.0328096822,
0.0124003673,
0.0005219106,
-0.0321543925,
-0.0676626116,
0.0105936145,
0.0542770103,
-0.0408256203,
-0.0335142612,
-0.0182114504,
0.0031662313,
-0.0504622571,
-0.0764521584,
0.0083214883,
0.0560845621,
-0.007556411,
-0.0252117235,
-0.0097156772,
0.0525804237,
-0.0241947435,
-0.0541099831,
-0.0249588601,
-0.0154821463,
0.0003278049,
0.0006607742,
0.0682419986,
0.0572318733,
0.0198175106,
-0.0567191951,
0.0271620024,
-0.0002620782,
0.0387433879,
-0.0261410177,
0.0060772621,
0.00532855,
0.0077862516,
0.0177271646,
0.0647672117,
0.0083009815,
0.021751808,
-0.0090657696,
0.0336797647,
-0.037322402,
-0.005512794,
-0.0155617446,
0.0594348423,
0.0505895503,
-0.0583189763,
0.0303624254,
-0.0263218023,
0.0302481689,
-0.001874904,
-0.0000544646,
-0.0095789051,
-0.0518902503,
-0.0211605374,
0.0055109696,
-0.0284129716,
-0.0280266926,
0.0351891033,
0.0259568337,
-0.0223427396,
-0.0208497345,
-0.0204486363,
0.0315544456,
0.0556456372,
-0.0260828491,
-0.0539055914,
-0.0020779974,
0.0511955097,
0.0487943143,
-0.0187183972,
0.033261694,
-0.0695704147,
-0.0693966523,
0.0099009285,
0.0367904529,
0.0331437327,
0.0315505117,
0.0083797267,
0.0622162856,
-0.0144520504,
-0.012494876,
-0.0045099542,
0.0125573417,
-0.0411690548,
-0.0428700075,
-0.0492581613,
-0.0551477037,
0.0516546369,
-0.0081932861,
0.0174634717,
-0.031496305,
-0.0137004359,
-0.032080438,
0.0338025838,
0.0812430754,
-0.0032116941,
0.0528389402,
0.0679130182,
-0.0288775768,
-0.0078134872,
0.007548301,
0.0805525631,
-0.0175438337,
0.0240545534,
-0.0437167175,
0.0117973499,
0.1042067036,
0.0017138083,
0.0090520894,
0.0085560782,
-0.0118812034,
-0.0000741057,
0.0179324914,
0.0452355631,
0.0816187188,
0.0189857557,
-0.0111878533,
0.0477006249,
0.0727668554,
0.0678560138,
0.0036338388,
0.0544820353,
0.0052247262,
0.0195758641,
-0.0418808088,
-0.0078435503,
0.0152749727,
0.0290402062,
0.0397045314,
0.0138779953,
0.0093713589,
-0.0311493073,
-0.0015066097,
-0.0145537509,
-0.0375440679,
-0.0171326026,
-0.0138391703,
0.0343399085,
0.0041226293,
-0.0403246582,
0.0402046815,
0.0163429771,
-0.0349182449,
0.010407906,
-0.0094127636,
0.0626016334,
0.0578779206,
0.0339743271,
-0.0287246555,
0.0324218757,
-0.0649528429,
-0.0247528274,
0.0610587075,
0.0564282872,
-0.0432625152,
0.0309014693,
-0.0513040796,
0.0050287517,
0.083143048,
0.0084576011,
0.0508526005,
0.0060391822,
0.0196961705,
0.0146102495,
-0.0672102869,
-0.0438021049,
0.0133543182,
-0.0565242879,
-0.033820603,
0.0028762929,
0.0198721495,
0.0438531786,
0.052598983,
-0.006214058,
0.0236511827,
0.038366165,
-0.0335465334,
0.0607799217,
0.0437566303,
-0.0166663304,
-0.0024957992,
0.073950924,
-0.0718391836,
0.0064057228,
0.0265655052,
0.039789658,
-0.065434292,
-0.0165374354,
-0.0230638701,
0.0603625923,
-0.0276922118,
0.0414936617,
0.0113253826,
0.0091501242,
0.0373525545,
-0.041115351,
0.0247424878,
-0.0439990498,
0.0269303117,
-0.0228802972,
0.0046727136,
-0.0363111869,
-0.011506591,
0.0369251631,
-0.0147228567,
0.0113374153,
-0.0034579928,
0.0025043765,
0.01193095,
0.0001527587,
-0.1159251109,
-0.0125841284,
-0.0138175189,
0.0081523871,
-0.0249738283,
0.0249964651,
0.0141204894,
-0.0305515118,
-0.0409537964,
-0.0470458157,
-0.0465956889,
-0.0072798817,
-0.0412614234,
-0.0192943793,
-0.0037919385,
-0.0662725866,
-0.0030746956,
0.0113131935,
-0.0108815115,
-0.0160181075,
-0.0610851385,
-0.0565065406,
-0.0117221521,
0.0119424583,
0.0136956628,
0.0144832944,
-0.0164810456,
-0.0067241071,
-0.0053705145,
0.020228954,
-0.0172741972,
-0.0139209218,
-0.0217164196,
0.0197895225,
0.0197853651,
-0.0666568875,
-0.0053288164,
0.0066731321,
0.0358410701,
-0.0085591031,
-0.0384050719,
-0.0661341846,
0.0541000441,
0.0253699142,
0.0500190035,
-0.0835255682,
-0.0692600831,
-0.0212816279,
-0.032880187,
0.0007062057,
-0.0305362828,
-0.0606653094,
0.0019014613,
-0.0125836823,
-0.0264177453,
0.0482071303,
-0.0972890854,
-0.0483424738,
-0.0205167439,
-0.0227509383,
-0.033686161,
0.0495265685,
-0.0451387241,
-0.0126661053,
-0.0298576448,
-0.0346570499,
-0.0088935802,
0.0549006425,
0.0160790589,
-0.0483455434,
0.0068387729,
-0.0140879415,
0.0198974181,
-0.0083477907,
-0.0363897942,
-0.0127717862,
0.0178263988,
-0.065037109,
0.0343792588,
0.0074797519,
-0.0483935475,
0.0437877364,
0.0631381571,
0.0072424547,
0.0776547343,
-0.0034732537,
0.0194007568,
-0.005067375,
0.0406213067,
-0.0045285271,
-0.0044777929,
-0.0368739441,
-0.0206987653,
0.0553268567,
-0.0560788736,
0.0209567342,
0.0717218593,
0.0076515321,
-0.0073193163,
0.0418710597,
0.0234622527,
-0.0191497095,
-0.0017774086,
0.0157328174,
0.0091159437,
0.0274351761,
0.1042080745,
-0.0042076646,
-0.017606426,
-0.0058470829,
-0.0258800574,
0.0257609487,
-0.0160567202,
0.0181067288,
-0.0604027919,
-0.0305883959,
0.0376978405,
0.0910401866,
0.0458018593,
0.0229904167,
0.0093854237,
-0.0519461557,
0.0044088187,
0.045614358,
-0.0275623612,
-0.0225036927,
-0.0215039738,
-0.0311619248,
-0.0648625642,
0.0104158819,
0.0113751385,
0.0150560355,
-0.0291937944,
0.0370182991,
-0.0771746635,
-0.029389916,
0.0430512168,
-0.0238891505,
0.0769172758,
0.0826595724,
0.0369705185,
-0.019231936,
-0.0292171948,
0.0137189673,
-0.0160936918,
-0.0165927317,
-0.0048299143,
0.0255532768,
0.0062674,
-0.0338998884,
0.0095586618,
0.0360917486,
-0.015536597,
0.0241993088,
0.0122893555,
0.0360220708,
0.0242292192,
-0.0055053676,
0.034346167,
0.0276418515,
-0.001803229,
0.0725030601,
0.0271956194,
-0.0604324602,
0.0048754048,
-0.0229840931,
0.0311715063,
-0.0884283185,
-0.0254860464,
0.0352001823,
0.0155487359,
-0.1097947508,
-0.0729587972,
-0.0138888406,
0.0105836568,
0.034476541,
0.0612820871,
0.0037433754,
-0.0016591367,
0.0264993887,
-0.0410363227,
0.0060010995,
-0.0051111393,
0.0441991948,
-0.0553808101,
-0.0351307206,
0.043385312,
-0.0157888103,
0.0055737821,
0.0542236008,
-0.0138451112,
-0.0612094365,
0.0635722578,
0.0489872955,
0.0256590564,
0.062830627,
-0.044931639,
-0.0378185846,
0.0356872566,
-0.0097942892,
-0.0226491056,
-0.0137306061,
0.0162887368,
-0.0079775481,
-0.0124530038,
0.0181062445,
-0.0384058952,
0.0055723703,
-0.0438360684,
0.0254372526,
-0.0409319364,
-0.0782103166,
-0.0010805498,
0.0278875623,
0.0045807059,
-0.0348565988,
-0.0250232629,
-0.0377437323,
-0.009026343,
0.0243923292,
0.0422980972,
-0.0266216695,
0.0121737607,
0.0449783131,
0.0186546501,
-0.0156463124,
0.0190677606,
-0.0035290415,
-0.0197056141,
0.0090143364,
0.027140487,
0.0266832635,
0.0560030192,
0.0161769819,
0.0096708583,
-0.0458594188,
0.103709735,
-0.0259998366,
0.0249320474,
-0.0154864341,
-0.019625118,
-0.0409677178,
0.0306115802,
0.0502347313,
0.0119854668,
0.0259251893,
-0.0339205079,
-0.0220825598,
0.0425877348,
0.0657567531,
0.0214409027,
0.1040934026,
-0.0220776536,
0.025809031,
-0.0260527208,
-0.0075741881,
-0.0621917024,
0.0035260522,
0.0072783628,
0.0016692573,
-0.0016653271,
0.0214934889,
0.0242607631,
0.0008792603,
0.0358604454,
-0.0438977368,
0.0327698253,
-0.0397232361,
-0.0041107736,
0.0001073146,
0.0083182473,
-0.0483971499,
-0.027756637,
-0.0379207507,
-0.0590011477,
0.0139864665,
-0.005937859,
-0.0250330213,
-0.0244824905,
-0.0120135024,
-0.0186919551,
-0.0396204628,
0.0239372756,
-0.0146908555,
-0.0435664319,
0.0024272206,
-0.0413151719,
-0.0203211531,
-5.491466225e-33,
-0.0316080488,
0.0084875962,
-0.0170626491,
0.0237704366,
-0.0196633078,
-0.0183986183,
-0.0324744955,
-0.0019573364,
-0.0303569157,
-0.0126704024,
-0.0122726308,
-0.0019466527,
0.0375050791,
-0.0202294383,
-0.0058639864,
0.0225967951,
0.0554498844,
-0.0184286349,
-0.0163097139,
-0.0034810018,
0.028996557,
0.0349822529,
0.0297074951,
-0.0806981325,
0.0181459319,
-0.006082329,
-0.0085417414,
-0.0074247709,
0.0239818208,
0.0263860282,
-0.010313578,
0.0271582417,
-0.0219738074,
0.000582885,
-0.0011016841,
0.0297269318,
-0.1014878973,
0.0366288535,
0.0122155845,
0.0813444778,
0.005956084,
-0.0144274272,
0.0114376256,
-0.0045373025,
-0.0097009093,
0.0041225771,
0.032289058,
-0.0419781208,
-0.0124008255,
-0.0505110286,
-0.0388046131,
0.0294852238,
-0.0314180553,
-0.0451995134,
0.0806096941,
0.0732279196,
0.0003844518,
-0.0481105335,
-0.0853838772,
0.0435051657,
-0.0195015576,
0.0424002036,
0.0484270342,
-0.0093632685,
-0.0413681939,
-0.0150732873,
0.0579090677,
-0.0652899817,
0.0445481725,
-0.0234526638,
0.0254779048,
0.0017534138,
0.0362241529,
-0.0076812953,
-0.0037075109,
-0.0310409032,
0.012291492,
0.016471887,
0.0229424257,
-0.0105398567,
-0.0105701238,
0.024117332,
-0.0213054884,
0.0139167849,
-0.0241015665,
-0.050997708,
0.0065130922,
-0.0004412212,
0.0518208183,
-0.0235728286,
-0.0168415476,
0.0076111378,
0.0626766533,
0.0085018063,
0.000528237,
0.0033030028,
-0.0149268257,
0.0217345878,
-0.0537825823,
0.0258509014,
-0.0421134569,
-0.0315358937,
0.0424029678,
0.0149728237,
0.0526974872,
0.003167307,
0.0075388299,
0.0603366084,
-0.0440259911,
-0.0217095632,
-0.0007681374,
0.0160359628,
-0.0041640806,
0.0323342867,
0.0093936836,
-0.0038716721,
0.0211199168,
-0.0166078601,
0.0133657679,
0.0212401692,
0.0159928296,
-0.0344841741,
0.0127534168,
0.0149397356,
-0.0555264987,
0.0087019317,
0.0202312246,
0.0098627033,
-0.003093821,
0.0035727071,
0.0007882196,
0.0162767414,
2.334e-7,
0.0260046627,
0.0110270232,
0.0665405914,
-0.029560402,
0.0350272767,
0.0143775092,
-0.0225941725,
-0.008941533,
-0.0018906172,
0.0056135128,
0.0354864821,
-0.0245702695,
0.1292645633,
0.0049158833,
-0.0949292034,
-0.0575136431,
-0.0448191129,
0.047514759,
-0.0416843593,
-0.0007194176,
-0.008087324,
0.0705529824,
-0.0199474357,
-0.0455962047,
-0.0165988132,
-0.0076480568,
0.0229657963,
-0.0252315812,
0.0188578479,
-0.0329411812,
0.0399992913,
-0.0173111446,
-0.0269722119,
0.0030967428,
-0.0565636083,
0.0205737855,
0.0499588624,
0.0524526723,
-0.0241970904,
-0.005795205,
0.0016741231,
0.018164942,
-0.0564456917,
-0.039868556,
0.0191897489,
0.0334682614,
0.0187927615,
0.01727161,
-0.0369255729,
0.0428069048,
-0.0133083556,
-0.015821673,
-0.0021751095,
0.024992507,
0.0189144854,
-0.0343864374,
-0.0287377872,
-0.0108455671,
-0.0383137092,
-0.0069850967,
-0.0166661255,
-0.0172527563,
-0.0086282035,
0.0157745145,
-0.0177425686,
-0.0204264224,
0.0127977971,
1.67020023e-34,
0.0192195456,
-0.0506203622,
0.0413979627,
0.0128632942,
-0.0207799189,
-0.0232651047,
0.0436185636,
0.0141568771,
-0.0162162296,
-0.0088643143,
-0.0762594044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03905v1 | Intelligent Assistant Language Understanding On Device | 2023-08-07T20:43:42 | 2023-08-07T20:43:42 | Cecilia Aas, Hisham Abdelsalam, Irina Belousova, Shruti Bhargava, Jianpeng Cheng, Robert Daland, Joris Driesen, Federico Flego, Tristan Guigue, Anders Johannsen, Partha Lal, Jiarui Lu, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Nathan Perkins, Dhivya Piraviperumal, Stephen Pulman, Diarmuid Ó Séaghdha, David Q. Sun, John Torr, Marco Del Vecchio, Jay Wacker, Jason D. Williams, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | It has recently become feasible to run personal digital assistants on phones
and other personal devices. In this paper we describe a design for a natural
language understanding system that runs on device. In comparison to a
server-based assistant, this system is more private, more reliable, faster,
more expressive, and more accurate. We describe what led to key choices about
architecture and technologies. For example, some approaches in the dialog
systems literature are difficult to maintain over time in a deployment setting.
We hope that sharing learnings from our practical experiences may help inform
future work in the research community. | [
0.0725318119,
0.0050552199,
-0.0267797858,
0.0437460579,
-0.0417871028,
-0.0383934975,
0.1026684865,
-0.050552249,
0.0527714863,
-0.0560480915,
-0.0115657337,
-0.0165090747,
-0.013969739,
0.0286364369,
-0.0347347334,
-0.0283743218,
0.0589454174,
-0.0460399911,
0.0367797017,
-0.0108128591,
0.0197461881,
0.0172710177,
-0.0377403088,
0.0350662433,
-0.00359565,
-0.0481552593,
-0.0318811871,
-0.0105195306,
-0.0305327438,
-0.0319021493,
-0.0427592173,
0.0159421526,
-0.0106566697,
0.0305980165,
0.0000018571,
-0.0294571742,
-0.0140904011,
0.0237099472,
-0.0694562122,
-0.0164804589,
0.0282146595,
0.0329636745,
0.0081663188,
0.0290610734,
-0.0457487814,
-0.0242685918,
-0.0009555811,
0.0046726894,
0.0590868257,
0.0240713824,
-0.0015913576,
0.0033906978,
-0.025603503,
0.0127215208,
-0.0294164494,
-0.0954297781,
-0.0410431772,
-0.0317525603,
0.020999549,
-0.0070636091,
0.0131003475,
0.0204782654,
0.0146253593,
0.0083563952,
-0.0163028948,
0.0028186569,
-0.024281757,
-0.0413558036,
-0.0393007062,
0.0636149421,
0.0419146605,
0.0082228379,
0.0327525176,
0.0333699882,
-0.0099680945,
-0.0334882513,
-0.0104018049,
-0.0072992211,
-0.0687636659,
-0.0433983691,
-0.0023292124,
-0.0214922912,
-0.0224243868,
-0.0031892688,
-0.0321042575,
0.0512117669,
-0.0042755273,
-0.0192151312,
-0.0312034562,
-0.007098827,
0.0247346926,
-0.0695433989,
0.0924918205,
0.0342931636,
-0.0467305146,
0.0315268748,
-0.0476325601,
-0.0148703335,
-0.0164018273,
-0.00945934,
-0.0001178602,
0.0182716846,
0.0049514971,
0.047903493,
0.0702896565,
0.0207608119,
0.0264332965,
0.000857366,
-0.0050517153,
-0.0218115617,
-0.045372162,
0.0186355244,
-0.0656915456,
0.0521201715,
-0.0444271415,
-0.0353400931,
-0.0264339577,
0.0027558568,
0.0346794277,
0.0241168514,
-0.0009812575,
0.0363672674,
-0.0274833236,
-0.0132009145,
0.0043648412,
0.0195826516,
-0.0590570979,
0.0501643121,
-0.0180804692,
-0.0818112418,
0.0283767264,
-0.0276776329,
0.0272820182,
0.0403103158,
-0.0391059928,
0.0267210156,
-0.0136191435,
-0.0514774434,
-0.0135093704,
-0.0303625893,
-0.0012728883,
-0.0562441051,
-0.0506642871,
-0.0254951641,
0.0440243632,
0.0104723237,
0.0218750946,
-0.0195256565,
0.0432156846,
0.0210499875,
0.015339206,
0.0548697226,
-0.0298701953,
0.0076246238,
0.0620166324,
0.0293334648,
-0.0344406441,
0.0488765351,
0.0455071405,
-0.0145944469,
0.0522526987,
-0.0032247235,
-0.0175261851,
-0.005360547,
-0.0033182716,
-0.0637877807,
0.022664167,
0.0355913602,
-0.066028662,
0.0077666608,
-0.0524126515,
0.0356190838,
0.0057254736,
-0.0030995738,
0.0635411292,
0.102974914,
0.000854893,
0.039890781,
-0.0351625644,
0.0373030975,
0.0001260175,
-0.0371110365,
-0.0445685461,
-0.0168122593,
0.007822792,
-0.0023247134,
-0.0172446016,
0.0000604725,
-0.0039332313,
-0.0540148504,
-0.0015270938,
-0.0273683816,
-0.0368532203,
0.0302907862,
0.0102018807,
-0.0108661409,
0.0453249291,
0.0087905452,
-0.0314581916,
-0.034651611,
-0.0301798768,
-0.033857502,
0.0795071051,
0.1074712723,
0.0379834399,
0.0047362302,
-0.040358305,
-0.0026317937,
-0.0078203958,
0.0012739252,
0.0041708914,
-0.0065016137,
0.0630762056,
-0.026689209,
-0.0024329999,
0.0318198763,
0.009693332,
0.0188419353,
-0.0427005291,
0.019941004,
0.00012941,
-0.0077390107,
0.0123755531,
-0.0291269328,
0.0511344187,
-0.0422816761,
0.0334761366,
0.0414585732,
0.0462069064,
0.0411075838,
0.0108592398,
-0.0288116969,
0.0158589724,
-0.0183552802,
0.0390518829,
0.0479996912,
0.0007971743,
0.0018728952,
0.0216028467,
-0.0132049676,
0.0048902282,
0.0132038668,
0.0107237222,
-0.0594677404,
0.048128929,
-0.0818167925,
0.0470705256,
0.0008121939,
0.0437400751,
0.0129614221,
0.0015787204,
0.0162906833,
0.0199618228,
0.029136667,
-0.0303595047,
-0.0050715897,
0.0008150357,
0.0320112444,
-0.0366736166,
-0.007524339,
-0.0222830623,
0.0083531113,
0.0137882335,
-0.0193619654,
-0.0191037897,
-0.0755327716,
0.0002758392,
-0.0964505076,
0.0321292058,
-0.0182244554,
0.0016417489,
0.0188194644,
0.0611330904,
0.0132970568,
-0.0864554718,
-0.0007944169,
0.0339528844,
0.0300457459,
0.002686521,
0.0104488125,
0.0030443331,
-0.0330578461,
-0.0408501439,
0.0313925222,
-0.0087442379,
0.0007000929,
0.0056984895,
0.0331353024,
-0.0657602474,
-0.0483689345,
-0.0637538284,
0.0508209579,
0.0101473061,
-0.0251147579,
0.0502451733,
-0.0034953058,
-0.0051120888,
0.0726972595,
0.0221781377,
0.0048630959,
0.0018963615,
-0.0193487201,
-0.0701458901,
0.0157099739,
0.0278880242,
-0.0061610527,
-0.003937189,
-0.002828958,
-0.0193450693,
0.0487118959,
0.0159391947,
0.0452142209,
-0.0076353326,
0.0385553017,
-0.018952297,
-0.0165802836,
0.0132107791,
0.0287520494,
-0.0241905358,
0.0883920267,
-0.01299066,
-0.0251592919,
0.0717204884,
-0.0024494801,
-0.0062182439,
-0.0751958862,
-0.0418236032,
-0.0352332331,
0.074157849,
-0.0509032346,
0.010704604,
0.0311697405,
-0.0500060357,
0.0000125467,
0.0016834751,
0.024072744,
-0.0752382204,
0.0362377986,
-0.0699461624,
-0.0062514152,
0.0254902337,
-0.0537971407,
-0.0304530468,
-0.0354919434,
-0.0877649188,
-0.0502221622,
0.0183317382,
-0.0040812679,
-0.0490661263,
0.0320244953,
0.0043411474,
0.0324510038,
0.0077125258,
-0.0053724209,
-0.027552899,
0.0036743744,
0.0373807773,
0.0209784321,
-0.0309564564,
0.0490429699,
0.0744124278,
0.0314602368,
0.0699444413,
-0.0447242968,
-0.0302990619,
-0.0150839202,
0.0388257466,
-0.0098058581,
-0.0327657424,
0.039413996,
0.0606851056,
-0.0837850571,
-0.0354262516,
0.1259332746,
0.0319272764,
-0.042125877,
-0.0215271134,
-0.0208739974,
-0.0243672766,
0.0129942233,
0.0364161693,
-0.0661477745,
-0.0618153587,
-0.0092449188,
0.0459904484,
0.0308146477,
0.0050882283,
-0.0267664175,
-0.0610078797,
0.0006193198,
0.0077587119,
-0.0015653851,
-0.0053333798,
0.0163653381,
0.0025572572,
0.0011639475,
0.0042576231,
-0.005895399,
0.0181962438,
-0.0136760343,
-0.0332504399,
-0.0601402111,
0.022066405,
0.0521458201,
-0.0478057265,
0.0434486717,
0.0542853847,
0.0189521965,
0.0686718002,
-0.0283984654,
-0.0387883037,
0.0110840984,
0.0247232039,
-0.0293845199,
-0.0070067989,
0.011945975,
-0.0128502659,
-0.0325968526,
0.0322222635,
-0.0144290393,
0.010294212,
0.071534358,
0.0352825373,
-0.0197450574,
0.022488229,
-0.0143088987,
0.0191134103,
0.0275393557,
0.0347899571,
0.0064841192,
-0.0326806121,
-0.0530447029,
-0.0112892557,
0.0007985656,
-0.0183495171,
0.0280238017,
0.0026324934,
0.0023697547,
-0.010874317,
-0.0350171961,
-0.031577006,
0.0372667313,
0.0166230481,
0.0581751317,
0.005141743,
0.054455068,
0.0386991613,
-0.0207052231,
-0.0013708655,
-0.0224217642,
0.004889817,
-0.0444632322,
-0.0305917021,
0.0524868704,
-0.046119649,
-0.0046529463,
0.0229950827,
-0.0185608063,
-0.0455967672,
0.0281353313,
0.0405574962,
0.0250366274,
0.0532773845,
-0.0598289408,
-0.0248508248,
-0.0330555849,
-0.0132402526,
-0.0864131525,
-0.01596676,
0.0136898113,
0.0305617116,
0.0050386465,
0.0398161747,
-0.0584437586,
0.0163034983,
-0.0717949048,
-0.0110226963,
-0.1085389853,
-0.0956579745,
0.027531011,
0.0423143394,
0.0454180874,
0.0280551538,
-0.0000943907,
-0.0098514305,
0.0849682093,
0.0100537827,
-0.0001597548,
-0.0239905044,
-0.0365410708,
-0.0287736505,
-0.0294813048,
0.0109472219,
-0.0117414976,
-0.0510146618,
-0.0024229514,
0.0053198338,
0.0560117625,
0.027919583,
0.0089307195,
-0.0119496956,
-0.0139827151,
-0.018563671,
0.0428050682,
0.0242138822,
0.0636404455,
-0.0136893606,
0.0939168483,
-0.044162292,
-0.0440411232,
-0.0045818365,
0.0433750935,
-0.0506070182,
-0.0500252545,
0.0540632345,
0.0762275159,
-0.0141126411,
-0.0069627659,
-0.0004065504,
-0.0000992015,
0.0408444516,
0.0017258503,
0.0472782254,
-0.0082407724,
-0.0456187651,
0.0305412374,
0.0162279084,
0.0136872046,
-0.0132265817,
0.0253508072,
-0.0250069369,
0.009325128,
0.0115900161,
-0.0082312236,
-0.0935746059,
-0.013079484,
-0.0360247418,
0.0511258207,
-0.0174588971,
0.0157269761,
-0.0551774614,
-0.0235889126,
-0.0016233716,
-0.0023784116,
0.0213842094,
-0.0394612551,
0.026377812,
0.0363130234,
0.0116453562,
-0.0437715203,
-0.0350143015,
0.0061042109,
-0.0684084445,
0.0034321167,
-0.0186323989,
-5.070077214e-33,
-0.0519252941,
0.0033972447,
0.0160958823,
-0.0037357444,
0.04146415,
-0.0122065423,
-0.0225623529,
0.018886799,
-0.019336177,
-0.0366543643,
-0.0563203841,
0.0261094794,
0.0228863172,
0.0111374119,
-0.0154284695,
-0.0082076285,
0.0477832481,
-0.0396776013,
0.01008905,
0.0148157813,
0.0418086052,
0.0311658345,
0.0051091202,
-0.0760214999,
-0.005926766,
-0.0112155126,
0.0200810339,
-0.0011852466,
-0.0255672354,
0.0145622147,
-0.0031125813,
-0.0186571665,
-0.0022534374,
0.0068444316,
0.0048415782,
0.0476427898,
-0.067611441,
-0.046332702,
0.0239563696,
0.0607512332,
-0.0110566337,
0.0030887811,
0.0015373984,
-0.0076748747,
-0.0088424953,
0.0340921395,
0.0253125876,
-0.0004910115,
-0.0276592337,
0.0237946082,
-0.0134907998,
0.0118138473,
-0.0257262383,
-0.0567849129,
0.0091993613,
-0.0014447729,
-0.0331175886,
-0.0459910668,
-0.0487830527,
0.0119801406,
-0.01981139,
-0.0169055779,
0.0359685719,
-0.0047999835,
-0.0184423234,
0.020341713,
0.0643437877,
-0.0234100297,
-0.0249549709,
-0.0180634614,
-0.0464581847,
0.0357516594,
0.0177964177,
0.0236552972,
0.0260398071,
-0.0051046829,
-0.015946174,
0.0051216744,
0.0755769014,
0.0420094468,
-0.0007966626,
0.035613928,
-0.051920794,
0.0281289723,
-0.0604215078,
0.0068523386,
-0.0559695847,
-0.0157525353,
0.0628517792,
0.0055658342,
-0.0548728704,
-0.0350552611,
0.0047072815,
-0.0164505262,
0.0032919743,
-0.0119361449,
0.0753928348,
-0.0117157297,
-0.0011246424,
0.0224632584,
-0.0323886089,
0.0383213051,
-0.0101736318,
0.0437125154,
0.0468832329,
0.015244036,
-0.0216080789,
0.0036588197,
-0.0427575521,
-0.0049974052,
-0.0361207314,
0.0555468015,
-0.0477148443,
-0.0000683495,
0.0461702049,
-0.0109472135,
-0.0592128113,
0.0841109529,
-0.0285702292,
0.0022742334,
-0.039078325,
-0.0341017395,
0.0383819267,
-0.001452539,
-0.0423633792,
-0.0142592667,
-0.0150235882,
0.0053150575,
0.0094462121,
-0.0021675322,
0.0286441259,
0.0092490036,
2.503e-7,
-0.0306965001,
0.0130573418,
0.0084797647,
0.0268234089,
0.0225363467,
0.0530321077,
0.0285734963,
0.0225327425,
-0.020998016,
0.0041375826,
-0.0366599336,
0.0212571584,
0.0541016795,
0.0407620817,
-0.0586103275,
-0.030127123,
-0.0074468516,
0.0652355999,
-0.0694401488,
0.0347813591,
0.0506125577,
0.0867737979,
0.006113058,
-0.0112830764,
0.0057678772,
-0.0431586094,
0.0075809071,
0.0035393951,
0.0333532915,
-0.0087898616,
0.0639128983,
0.0149612837,
-0.0188634153,
0.0331251472,
-0.0092385262,
0.0177084282,
-0.051716052,
0.0635965317,
-0.0185738467,
-0.0032431029,
-0.0047747092,
-0.0264544841,
-0.0154996635,
-0.016027417,
0.0665670708,
-0.0001309864,
-0.0339964069,
-0.0263853669,
0.0058380091,
-0.0331259146,
-0.0359226093,
0.0192225501,
0.019211797,
0.0040894123,
-0.0264269337,
-0.0549532287,
0.0105486363,
-0.0675737187,
-0.0011807577,
-0.0247581936,
0.0114020696,
0.0099562677,
-0.0653724819,
0.0053709559,
0.013217438,
-0.0291550327,
0.0242216922,
1.257419075e-34,
-0.0214410331,
-0.0238406789,
0.0024451951,
0.0890301317,
0.0254492667,
-0.0042323871,
0.0422429144,
0.0122732157,
0.0796275213,
-0.0299780481,
0.00180662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03891v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03891v1 | A Cross-Domain Evaluation of Approaches for Causal Knowledge Extraction | 2023-08-07T19:50:59 | 2023-08-07T19:50:59 | Anik Saha, Oktie Hassanzadeh, Alex Gittens, Jian Ni, Kavitha Srinivas, Bulent Yener | cs.CL | cs.CL | Causal knowledge extraction is the task of extracting relevant causes and
effects from text by detecting the causal relation. Although this task is
important for language understanding and knowledge discovery, recent works in
this domain have largely focused on binary classification of a text segment as
causal or non-causal. In this regard, we perform a thorough analysis of three
sequence tagging models for causal knowledge extraction and compare it with a
span based approach to causality extraction. Our experiments show that
embeddings from pre-trained language models (e.g. BERT) provide a significant
performance boost on this task compared to previous state-of-the-art models
with complex architectures. We observe that span based models perform better
than simple sequence tagging models based on BERT across all 4 data sets from
diverse domains with different types of cause-effect phrases. | [
-0.0039890381,
0.0453327037,
-0.0399643295,
0.0212713592,
-0.0123315789,
0.0200483762,
0.0210403241,
0.0027395999,
0.0422988981,
-0.0467052422,
0.0513213277,
0.0137881031,
-0.0499667414,
0.0330250636,
0.0507754162,
-0.0341248773,
0.042505119,
0.0160938893,
0.0696120262,
0.0232564677,
-0.0026807266,
-0.0313543789,
-0.0136094224,
0.0293159913,
-0.0326913148,
0.0183529705,
0.0060207695,
-0.0441311784,
0.0332987607,
-0.0335013047,
0.0112543665,
0.0394745842,
0.024095891,
0.0145014906,
0.0000016842,
-0.0069501605,
-0.0342660882,
0.0079578869,
0.0129827214,
0.0062759495,
-0.0695001855,
0.018282311,
0.0218409151,
-0.0068544266,
-0.0506583527,
-0.0532137677,
0.0022567743,
0.0923603103,
0.0085171321,
0.0796812102,
-0.0227607265,
-0.0780164674,
0.049574852,
-0.0203964673,
0.0278838594,
-0.0320824608,
0.069323808,
-0.0007752003,
0.0157810859,
-0.0203091465,
-0.03255108,
0.0032390875,
0.0114782462,
-0.0052428548,
0.0435600691,
0.032267753,
-0.0175237916,
-0.0112135746,
0.0157454368,
0.1109391749,
0.0329530239,
-0.0009085122,
0.0602879785,
0.0055224909,
0.0275925957,
0.059840221,
-0.0079724994,
0.0232568644,
0.00078558,
0.0154751511,
0.010922933,
-0.006576559,
0.0614587478,
0.0051260055,
-0.0629930198,
0.0584126152,
0.0198213849,
-0.0635167733,
-0.0021318595,
0.0300928485,
-0.0061600809,
-0.0443319529,
0.0108151836,
0.008194061,
-0.0012373831,
0.0534346253,
0.0009043353,
-0.0269455463,
-0.0130611081,
-0.0432466008,
-0.0049004639,
-0.0021985746,
-0.0275314078,
0.0468846262,
-0.0733845383,
0.03404174,
-0.0374500602,
0.0393897705,
-0.0001541946,
0.0217381064,
-0.060351681,
-0.01165374,
-0.0059745885,
0.0341711752,
-0.0196299311,
-0.002940645,
-0.0318709686,
0.0149229346,
0.0017454115,
0.0072458507,
-0.0407759659,
-0.0131581826,
0.0262830574,
0.0280630849,
0.0108159315,
0.0053765657,
-0.0616781451,
0.049200628,
-0.0011970606,
-0.0305426512,
-0.0224888008,
0.0048250793,
0.0289704874,
-0.046387732,
-0.0057651452,
0.0682037845,
0.0336250663,
-0.0678566024,
-0.0556223392,
-0.0492382832,
-0.020744333,
-0.0229475107,
0.0166523941,
-0.0108165611,
0.0104314731,
0.013220313,
-0.0242350753,
-0.0043356116,
0.0238888469,
-0.0292737186,
-0.0831258297,
0.040274892,
-0.0132870916,
-0.0100127859,
-0.0056725601,
0.0012227629,
0.0539817922,
0.0487005822,
0.0481579304,
0.0190157909,
0.0559187122,
-0.0260010269,
-0.0235410333,
0.0186921488,
0.0659388751,
-0.0140779549,
-0.003515291,
-0.015174767,
0.0578691103,
-0.017247837,
-0.0147266937,
-0.0146672232,
-0.0457924381,
0.0346716307,
0.0277391747,
0.011559695,
-0.0019654429,
0.0195980184,
0.0452556722,
-0.0450194553,
0.0115784369,
0.0260831099,
-0.0047323513,
-0.0201162864,
-0.0200230144,
0.0017503661,
0.0477135703,
-0.0212223288,
-0.0046408912,
-0.0074162097,
-0.0304684676,
-0.0014914839,
-0.0104135834,
0.0078325188,
0.0841861442,
0.0219551623,
-0.0517636724,
0.0347863175,
0.0422245674,
-0.0599050075,
0.024434058,
0.0213176124,
0.016763676,
0.0357431769,
0.0548000224,
-0.0790885463,
-0.0302251484,
-0.0100950925,
0.0265430287,
-0.0196021982,
0.0331642739,
-0.037245702,
0.0156218754,
-0.0225643218,
-0.0521401651,
0.0159522258,
0.0183753408,
0.0209284406,
0.0102010714,
-0.0155523624,
-0.0137370052,
-0.0021647566,
-0.0060271728,
0.0653382912,
-0.0523792878,
-0.0301831309,
0.0021191165,
0.0274738669,
0.0563055649,
0.0292711928,
-0.0541478992,
0.0074365698,
0.0268780664,
-0.0845454708,
-0.0852329955,
0.049401883,
-0.0219087526,
-0.044703871,
0.0245149788,
-0.0435566306,
-0.0141973952,
0.0008228929,
-0.0532325841,
-0.0569984056,
0.0534794405,
-0.0202724598,
0.0268081073,
-0.0137431603,
-0.0096922955,
0.0041038264,
-0.005752706,
-0.050833717,
0.0841168836,
0.0141855441,
0.0222150981,
-0.029457882,
-0.0031901011,
0.021526482,
0.0024294241,
-0.040429011,
0.0036466897,
-0.0068749436,
-0.0470249392,
0.0456497185,
-0.0659172684,
-0.026224399,
0.0017716538,
-0.0541749187,
0.0121203018,
-0.0043042847,
0.0270900577,
-0.0065586022,
0.0106104519,
-0.0008657954,
-0.0132876085,
-0.0231923237,
-0.0215643346,
-0.0298148934,
0.0124020958,
0.0555476919,
0.0231808275,
-0.004441448,
-0.0494562872,
0.007672247,
-0.07677304,
0.0587298237,
0.0463816077,
-0.0227161963,
-0.0193527937,
-0.0289675463,
0.0084298048,
0.0235429853,
-0.0137165068,
-0.0399336256,
-0.0278637633,
-0.0401875526,
0.0349127948,
0.0334212668,
0.0005750215,
0.033768896,
0.0048965192,
-0.0248180181,
-0.0274254791,
0.0187878665,
-0.0624742098,
0.0734216943,
-0.0257180426,
-0.0172293819,
0.0019305288,
0.1041122526,
0.0162867606,
-0.0132528311,
-0.0650428236,
-0.0445407256,
-0.0002117333,
-0.0033948475,
-0.0212005768,
-0.0313751511,
-0.0164645221,
0.0344890617,
-0.0378717072,
-0.0517748371,
0.0377803743,
0.0004649089,
0.0116784284,
-0.0045064972,
0.0207850486,
-0.0440642647,
0.0330647528,
0.0186426211,
-0.0000955905,
0.0193878561,
-0.0383767039,
0.0085489359,
-0.0099386135,
0.0429440439,
0.0040917881,
-0.0069698375,
-0.057805527,
0.0480346829,
0.005605604,
-0.0206485894,
-0.0484534502,
-0.0607512668,
0.0208141282,
0.0122077717,
0.018202506,
-0.0112349978,
-0.0290263072,
0.005746075,
0.0282501783,
0.0277705621,
-0.022795178,
0.0278028399,
-0.015144987,
0.0398806408,
0.034492366,
-0.0792592168,
0.0083333962,
-0.0159382243,
0.0113571547,
-0.0048316652,
-0.0138985431,
-0.007759111,
-0.0552355237,
0.0262352768,
-0.0031767299,
-0.076066196,
-0.0126804914,
-0.0015512648,
-0.0000207116,
-0.0319316648,
0.0000759965,
0.1022441462,
0.0258084312,
0.0038715252,
0.0022299897,
0.0403347947,
-0.0383004732,
0.015311989,
-0.0046570711,
-0.0761963725,
-0.0194013789,
-0.0015850255,
-0.0269641038,
0.0207898784,
-0.0550187081,
0.0320162699,
-0.0778532401,
-0.0002304715,
-0.0184080582,
-0.0085589094,
0.0001507761,
-0.0584649034,
-0.0066358116,
0.001753045,
-0.0683060363,
-0.0301497094,
0.0076145958,
0.0271234643,
0.0457081981,
-0.0202151071,
-0.0588536859,
-0.0152985621,
-0.0232691839,
0.0371745639,
0.0865579247,
0.0246583186,
-0.0433611348,
-0.0023887886,
0.01242398,
-0.0209993944,
-0.0184107404,
-0.0073112082,
0.0749842227,
0.0005003298,
-0.0170407109,
-0.0105489437,
0.0258006603,
-0.026660474,
-0.0174932629,
0.0196242165,
0.0910833254,
-0.0013741156,
-0.0011532014,
-0.0067044888,
-0.0135068335,
-0.015550172,
0.0660564899,
0.0259473901,
0.0008817882,
-0.0428447537,
0.0145578114,
-0.0145868985,
-0.0753678232,
-0.0159785841,
-0.0314573459,
-0.0191522688,
-0.0439660698,
-0.0835376531,
-0.0527952164,
0.0363255031,
0.0251888223,
0.0326638222,
0.0015115145,
0.0368625857,
0.0031617805,
-0.0352446549,
0.0114251869,
0.0057661394,
0.0258433651,
-0.0123595148,
-0.022475373,
0.0030942485,
-0.0034959491,
-0.0236578397,
-0.0120073156,
0.002770412,
-0.068505913,
-0.0055010277,
0.0327824987,
0.0096720336,
0.0460158177,
-0.0397505648,
-0.0264919903,
0.0250361431,
0.0044072401,
-0.0322559066,
-0.0383163206,
0.0447564572,
-0.0172453169,
0.008768931,
0.0298335291,
-0.0477184989,
0.0269449335,
0.0247142352,
0.0593917109,
-0.0434748977,
0.0335175842,
0.0024346013,
0.0015799516,
0.0899932534,
-0.0187348574,
-0.0462731123,
-0.0528000258,
0.0161742102,
-0.0746965259,
0.0000526777,
-0.0103582079,
0.0359271467,
-0.0004537416,
0.0180605762,
-0.01869791,
0.0040039276,
-0.0301738773,
0.0240804031,
-0.0213278029,
0.0742769316,
-0.006624802,
0.060398329,
-0.009900609,
0.0134924306,
0.0110460883,
-0.0208150521,
0.0379272252,
0.0152573623,
-0.0363407917,
0.0289405994,
0.0403403305,
0.0232777391,
0.02370001,
-0.0179466903,
-0.0816936344,
0.0608734228,
0.0440979712,
-0.0129085826,
0.0676064715,
-0.0380964242,
0.0407957695,
0.011495986,
-0.0098424032,
0.0273683555,
0.0331807397,
0.0086935349,
0.0174264163,
0.0396953896,
0.010543515,
-0.0628134459,
-0.0212235153,
0.0711997449,
0.0177146085,
0.0795123354,
-0.0118978918,
-0.0357188769,
-0.0258345883,
-0.0513770133,
0.0470579453,
0.0178883653,
-0.0557154678,
0.0156762004,
-0.0707306489,
-0.0126032643,
0.0006583104,
-0.0381735116,
0.0030703349,
0.010779636,
0.0278315302,
0.0220716111,
0.0119120302,
-0.0112327896,
-0.0462893322,
0.0447478145,
-0.0450296849,
-0.028327357,
-0.0033351439,
-5.709053168e-33,
-0.0139862951,
-0.0106725348,
0.0210238472,
0.0084390854,
-0.0085262163,
0.0297130328,
-0.0667425022,
-0.0243646838,
-0.0249333736,
0.0506991185,
0.0175579507,
0.0036314018,
0.0167170577,
0.0133978203,
0.0093286689,
-0.0147995669,
0.0322333947,
0.0209009144,
0.0129042948,
0.0147281885,
0.0578141883,
0.0758716166,
0.0483409427,
-0.0610975884,
0.0357864052,
-0.0056526465,
0.027082419,
-0.0354334638,
0.0405693501,
0.0232822895,
-0.0115140257,
-0.0083125895,
0.0235810913,
-0.0600654744,
0.0153338062,
0.0470964126,
-0.1125149876,
-0.0368917324,
0.045058798,
0.0144852512,
-0.0285947453,
-0.0457650721,
-0.0090496698,
-0.007716767,
0.0344766825,
0.0102744885,
0.0706882253,
-0.0165287461,
-0.0329217389,
-0.0685997456,
-0.090886049,
0.045916561,
-0.0387731493,
0.0253638998,
0.0386031419,
0.0330797918,
0.0236322321,
0.0580552295,
0.0189484619,
0.0092845839,
0.0065073334,
0.0070203291,
-0.0099512991,
0.0122824628,
0.0166791379,
0.0721323416,
-0.0249798968,
-0.0362694934,
-0.0240105353,
0.0172944497,
-0.0177540574,
0.0485172682,
0.0515381508,
0.0073558539,
0.0000841037,
0.0008292198,
-0.1172300875,
0.0072143325,
0.0439690314,
-0.0237787198,
-0.0062290751,
-0.0181372259,
-0.0273194239,
0.0138423312,
-0.0174585376,
-0.0260063261,
-0.0103148585,
-0.0122704329,
0.0234391782,
0.0116233323,
0.0167607833,
0.0184339806,
0.0161191672,
-0.0436876565,
0.0061583021,
0.0185654759,
-0.013802967,
-0.0251308307,
0.0033581937,
-0.0064304979,
-0.0777703002,
-0.0355433486,
0.0161696058,
0.0061260625,
0.0328798778,
0.0068276995,
0.0704085901,
-0.0472645015,
-0.0306636412,
-0.0143714715,
-0.0427991413,
-0.0300725307,
-0.0053769751,
0.0437919199,
0.0313076824,
0.058927048,
-0.0046981922,
0.0407831743,
0.0400049537,
0.0640835613,
0.0094880797,
-0.0247430243,
-0.0086418511,
0.0071447338,
-0.0192371774,
-0.0351963453,
-0.0101168258,
0.0788114741,
-0.0212647542,
-0.0721174106,
-0.0077764788,
-0.0084339166,
2.375e-7,
0.0603425577,
0.0440817699,
0.0566165894,
-0.012947849,
0.0193834361,
0.0203134008,
-0.0066950885,
0.0229926035,
-0.0293003395,
0.0496156327,
0.0174079649,
-0.0116110072,
0.0495922156,
0.0123844203,
-0.0656513572,
-0.017940864,
-0.0246752668,
-0.0385334753,
-0.0320430323,
-0.0028038786,
0.0795766711,
0.055395484,
0.0324924178,
0.0309845656,
-0.0110260546,
-0.0379900783,
0.0355313495,
-0.0065627228,
0.0027353696,
0.0098249884,
-0.0268031545,
0.0030749952,
-0.0521442406,
0.0608307943,
-0.0587875992,
0.0426434875,
-0.0188189764,
0.0397381224,
0.0035729401,
-0.0065911897,
-0.0399924777,
-0.0571725219,
0.0250597242,
-0.006562009,
0.0751346573,
-0.030163331,
-0.0488442183,
0.0583296642,
-0.0771258995,
0.0058835149,
0.0068021663,
0.0242832489,
0.0074448278,
0.0238071494,
-0.0055064545,
-0.0070718913,
-0.0063779526,
-0.1105972156,
0.0029796425,
0.0180730391,
-0.0210514292,
-0.0269689094,
-0.0180064924,
0.0062131458,
0.0396030843,
-0.0626592189,
0.0005286608,
2.289819833e-34,
0.0033302426,
0.0014228005,
-0.0158452205,
-0.0056790709,
0.0370087847,
-0.0303165168,
-0.0877704099,
0.0110846078,
0.0359493606,
-0.0945307612,
0.0176554043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03883v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03883v1 | Generative Benchmark Creation for Table Union Search | 2023-08-07T19:26:09 | 2023-08-07T19:26:09 | Koyena Pal, Aamod Khatiwada, Roee Shraga, Renée J. Miller | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.LG | Data management has traditionally relied on synthetic data generators to
generate structured benchmarks, like the TPC suite, where we can control
important parameters like data size and its distribution precisely. These
benchmarks were central to the success and adoption of database management
systems. But more and more, data management problems are of a semantic nature.
An important example is finding tables that can be unioned. While any two
tables with the same cardinality can be unioned, table union search is the
problem of finding tables whose union is semantically coherent. Semantic
problems cannot be benchmarked using synthetic data. Our current methods for
creating benchmarks involve the manual curation and labeling of real data.
These methods are not robust or scalable and perhaps more importantly, it is
not clear how robust the created benchmarks are. We propose to use generative
AI models to create structured data benchmarks for table union search. We
present a novel method for using generative models to create tables with
specified properties. Using this method, we create a new benchmark containing
pairs of tables that are both unionable and non-unionable but related. We
thoroughly evaluate recent existing table union search methods over existing
benchmarks and our new benchmark. We also present and evaluate a new table
search methods based on recent large language models over all benchmarks. We
show that the new benchmark is more challenging for all methods than
hand-curated benchmarks, specifically, the top-performing method achieves a
Mean Average Precision of around 60%, over 30% less than its performance on
existing manually created benchmarks. We examine why this is the case and show
that the new benchmark permits more detailed analysis of methods, including a
study of both false positives and false negatives that were not possible with
existing benchmarks. | [
-0.0173673052,
0.0993625,
-0.0277068056,
-0.0074808314,
-0.0440415181,
0.0069813547,
0.0064868131,
0.0376319289,
-0.0023768977,
-0.0016023355,
0.0358127318,
-0.018409865,
-0.0143069364,
0.035612002,
-0.0126962839,
0.0110083623,
0.0596552193,
0.0375857018,
-0.0862663612,
0.0355465449,
-0.0432139933,
-0.0108832391,
-0.0088105705,
-0.0303915124,
-0.0399534553,
0.0319575407,
-0.0380931422,
-0.0009495887,
-0.0298231859,
0.0173272155,
-0.027211817,
0.0738933608,
-0.0112870336,
0.057214696,
0.0000021811,
-0.024327632,
-0.0652097687,
0.0127083417,
0.0041075246,
0.0141582638,
0.0443999358,
-0.0250646304,
-0.0212864038,
0.0362035297,
-0.027471656,
-0.031632971,
0.0330095403,
0.0161970221,
0.0209011398,
0.0415809564,
-0.0132234944,
-0.0478946529,
0.0079440335,
-0.0041094348,
0.0264975913,
-0.0252798572,
-0.0038368723,
0.0197986122,
0.0395363271,
-0.0739527792,
-0.0063089463,
0.0101776123,
0.0176637433,
-0.0495971888,
-0.0182163808,
0.0169117432,
-0.0879943147,
0.0325177163,
0.0110640367,
0.0286235735,
-0.000660548,
-0.0432358831,
0.0492585152,
-0.0023506964,
-0.0273581054,
0.0182365254,
-0.0026180127,
0.0358482972,
-0.0243315361,
0.0129691912,
-0.0095326416,
0.0084836772,
0.0305155795,
-0.0236178786,
-0.0604226738,
0.01091321,
0.0218531284,
-0.0167710744,
0.0118782874,
-0.0350636393,
0.0261708666,
-0.0557128936,
-0.0253599845,
-0.0005868193,
-0.0553611293,
0.013903656,
-0.0194974635,
-0.0477136932,
0.0309902672,
-0.0152959311,
-0.0082299719,
0.0451233909,
-0.0000896894,
0.0161768254,
-0.0124574173,
0.0199655406,
-0.0545460731,
0.0230977591,
-0.0426181033,
-0.0305735823,
-0.04035981,
0.0046721552,
-0.041380249,
0.008307538,
-0.0789502189,
-0.0205900166,
-0.0137250181,
0.0054875072,
-0.0409094617,
0.0523319282,
-0.0051375739,
0.0175148211,
-0.0029775186,
0.0104743801,
-0.0483805574,
-0.0879748687,
-0.0540044792,
-0.0301429834,
-0.0028443942,
-0.0821468607,
0.0067278524,
-0.0193738565,
0.0016611958,
0.00745819,
0.052854646,
0.053892497,
-0.0229376629,
0.0114643481,
-0.0385650173,
-0.0290306173,
0.0166025665,
-0.0182399284,
0.0042649163,
-0.0259390045,
0.1091459021,
-0.0205518026,
-0.0325041898,
-0.0430564098,
-0.0006428908,
0.0428170785,
0.0114652403,
0.0314768627,
-0.015103179,
0.0624790639,
0.0201578178,
-0.0161820296,
0.0092282612,
0.0624893084,
0.0109856818,
0.0269207209,
0.0056451727,
-0.0249363761,
-0.0180215333,
0.0105041424,
0.0366231464,
-0.009735845,
-0.0236992985,
0.0372338183,
0.0096904663,
0.0516452529,
-0.0599093325,
0.0590774268,
-0.0158128962,
0.0033430227,
-0.0098285833,
0.0150204683,
0.0046308306,
0.0820376799,
-0.0014377248,
-0.0254494976,
0.0068447785,
-0.0062117432,
0.0100069968,
-0.0030857851,
-0.0122387884,
0.0083515886,
0.0680774525,
-0.0219589323,
-0.0090988772,
-0.0396906026,
-0.0032604106,
-0.0026210118,
0.0138978846,
-0.0195883531,
0.0255432948,
0.0289706197,
-0.0511873476,
-0.0069435886,
-0.0058076796,
-0.0667288825,
-0.0403034575,
-0.0178206153,
-0.0114849601,
0.0464217179,
0.0568561293,
-0.067519635,
-0.0014018206,
0.0265031457,
-0.0148199312,
0.0164455809,
0.0583614111,
-0.0435964726,
-0.0247235987,
-0.0369137824,
-0.0313234851,
0.0563386716,
0.0014316335,
0.0123955933,
0.039466273,
0.0013090713,
0.0136270495,
-0.0534152389,
-0.0519319884,
0.0210948456,
0.0072978502,
0.0249892492,
0.0326069146,
-0.0002915974,
0.0337728187,
0.0324507579,
-0.034358222,
0.0202990547,
0.0637886301,
-0.011238981,
-0.0559078567,
0.0038394127,
0.0129240956,
0.0622772723,
0.0052560759,
-0.0476115458,
-0.0641520545,
0.0013723079,
-0.0445657074,
-0.0540201478,
-0.0196420159,
-0.0313468277,
-0.0129414536,
-0.0166619364,
0.0704381689,
-0.0323866084,
-0.0287762024,
0.0081605976,
0.1173519194,
-0.0103830919,
-0.0092458827,
0.009966502,
-0.0483764149,
0.0721926242,
-0.0387504883,
0.0422829427,
0.0093368497,
-0.0215500481,
0.0315894783,
0.0233101994,
-0.0205391552,
-0.071290642,
0.0022823943,
-0.084446609,
0.0710780323,
0.0080334451,
0.0118076531,
0.0125236884,
0.0160046387,
-0.0091003692,
0.0099287946,
-0.0406504534,
-0.0395801887,
0.0243742373,
-0.002435135,
0.0268887766,
0.0119107766,
-0.022884652,
-0.0481727421,
-0.0383110084,
-0.0780201778,
0.0029671956,
-0.0180882476,
-0.0314429924,
0.0434188135,
0.0326472782,
0.0141116101,
0.0604256876,
0.0177193545,
0.012750946,
0.0184253789,
-0.0381314903,
0.0232389513,
0.0224944316,
0.005138041,
-0.0013710819,
0.0454120226,
0.0088800602,
-0.0231477879,
0.0434839316,
0.0211271066,
0.0213310663,
0.0691291094,
-0.0670389012,
0.0535394773,
0.0054328013,
-0.0091736084,
0.0156301446,
-0.0442706421,
-0.0059495764,
0.0193969551,
0.0107970582,
-0.0441658981,
0.0357235409,
0.0286812652,
0.0552246906,
-0.0409600995,
-0.0050284066,
-0.0118699344,
-0.0114163291,
0.0366029069,
-0.0381942093,
0.0159413144,
-0.074400261,
0.0797938779,
0.0318268277,
0.0153626679,
-0.0713610426,
0.0059963251,
-0.0233438592,
0.0163193196,
0.0311343428,
-0.0377083421,
0.0824166313,
-0.0451503769,
0.031105876,
0.0255766828,
-0.0275251176,
-0.0436769128,
-0.0181437861,
-0.0074307369,
-0.0032319673,
0.0749689266,
-0.0257192608,
-0.0426102765,
-0.0249983929,
-0.0011107103,
0.0793085992,
0.0498557836,
-0.0044657723,
-0.0079370541,
-0.0156970043,
-0.0097026955,
-0.0326139964,
-0.019257227,
-0.0170946531,
0.0142687252,
0.0367687419,
0.0371887758,
-0.0027223362,
-0.0278600343,
-0.006530378,
-0.0145369256,
-0.0360978469,
-0.006328465,
0.0364058204,
-0.0856242329,
-0.0339332819,
0.0101099927,
0.0509543754,
0.0308044199,
0.0201089028,
-0.0233520996,
0.0155610461,
0.007811619,
0.0187418424,
0.0250708573,
-0.0817535222,
0.0000404602,
-0.0271450337,
-0.0446754657,
-0.0134298718,
-0.0637941882,
-0.0349438488,
-0.1286859363,
0.0155225089,
-0.0124860955,
-0.0781208798,
-0.0276581086,
-0.0384274386,
-0.0155238099,
-0.0074282377,
-0.0313820802,
0.0368853994,
-0.0134144854,
-0.0228682719,
-0.009651822,
-0.0164383687,
-0.0688744858,
-0.013643438,
-0.0655969828,
0.0306017846,
0.0466626175,
0.0509379096,
0.0001625339,
0.0014546879,
0.0144785121,
0.0370458402,
-0.0028181556,
-0.0349512212,
0.0763214305,
0.0445401445,
0.0144081907,
0.0092737116,
-0.0295134038,
-0.0130697377,
-0.000834808,
0.0265424177,
0.0563474372,
-0.0095376456,
-0.0049089692,
-0.0203016903,
-0.0050125392,
-0.0048068943,
0.0679421499,
0.0173285045,
0.0252807811,
-0.0345427096,
-0.0211046431,
-0.0022377155,
-0.0412583314,
0.017560605,
0.0794779062,
-0.0293043572,
-0.0344646424,
-0.0368029028,
0.0175865088,
0.0234315805,
0.0225509033,
0.0023768821,
0.0164942071,
-0.0363802351,
-0.0267030727,
-0.0588442534,
-0.0385400094,
-0.0494780764,
0.0140364505,
-0.0491876565,
-0.0279985983,
0.0208461862,
0.0033694177,
-0.0105088102,
0.0310039483,
-0.0274668094,
-0.0407434367,
-0.0001862973,
0.0132972635,
0.0187529977,
-0.0049630911,
0.0030410604,
-0.030621523,
-0.0347075537,
0.0584057607,
-0.0243360642,
-0.0526683405,
-0.0402936451,
-0.0741337538,
-0.0192627069,
-0.0060924632,
-0.0322725251,
0.0141885513,
-0.0582392886,
-0.0113999117,
-0.0197156984,
0.059565302,
0.0866121724,
0.0656506866,
-0.037452545,
0.0318341404,
-0.0024895028,
-0.0086835939,
0.0656593814,
-0.0924296081,
-0.0450899042,
0.0409950316,
-0.000231521,
0.0110583641,
0.0246045161,
0.010245786,
0.028448144,
0.0173002109,
0.0144190406,
-0.006046507,
-0.0105317747,
0.0115767736,
-0.0099119535,
0.0428490378,
-0.0223684572,
0.0042066635,
-0.0095981508,
0.0270109046,
0.0931592882,
-0.0178941581,
-0.0163862482,
0.0499075465,
-0.0034427072,
-0.0577643886,
0.0215694625,
-0.0194107667,
-0.0262320004,
0.0202673655,
-0.0040325532,
0.0560421757,
-0.0183241144,
-0.0221697427,
-0.0194044709,
-0.0246046558,
0.0097035505,
-0.0404554531,
0.0433001705,
-0.0138722351,
-0.0255939141,
0.0120919654,
-0.0148275206,
-0.0162245259,
0.0454497859,
0.0193053428,
0.0458665229,
-0.0056905393,
0.023430625,
-0.0645617545,
0.003716995,
0.0116571216,
-0.0111926235,
0.0054935855,
-0.0404971652,
-0.0540818088,
0.0031537637,
0.0239831582,
0.0879103914,
0.0078466134,
-0.0184290614,
0.0315293446,
0.0532446839,
0.0740316063,
0.0350324325,
-0.0210789647,
-0.0200599208,
-0.0514407568,
-0.0206956696,
-0.0095894104,
-5.742673041e-33,
-0.0159293693,
-0.0167279337,
0.0042765536,
-0.0272362176,
0.0269447844,
-0.0210124608,
-0.0417985581,
-0.0110172583,
0.0097580831,
-0.0107612247,
-0.0470119566,
0.0635096133,
0.0159890484,
-0.0301168151,
0.0226524845,
-0.0307266433,
0.0502368584,
-0.0057803323,
-0.0220445897,
-0.0138005968,
-0.0080374833,
-0.0210431237,
-0.0622348152,
-0.0458855331,
-0.0510287732,
-0.0313056856,
-0.0121798506,
-0.0019189804,
-0.0286551621,
0.0320997536,
0.0207013935,
0.015645843,
0.0017719489,
-0.0185061935,
-0.0088484865,
-0.0305068903,
-0.0735196024,
-0.04749576,
0.0065387692,
0.0022238055,
-0.0140617518,
-0.0234206785,
0.0107899047,
0.0115457857,
-0.029152276,
0.000450357,
0.006092574,
-0.0166548155,
-0.0405683853,
-0.0679089576,
-0.0042422637,
0.0110962633,
0.0148658985,
0.0164935347,
0.0663191378,
-0.0050570318,
0.0308797024,
-0.0127014574,
-0.0126075158,
0.062919125,
0.048162546,
0.003445578,
0.0448873527,
-0.0240848865,
0.0393015295,
0.0261989664,
0.0281527173,
0.058407966,
0.0171993263,
0.0184850227,
-0.0282847974,
0.0771670118,
-0.0018881875,
0.0346636549,
0.0389346518,
0.0073242048,
-0.0301560909,
0.110067524,
0.0239572134,
-0.0531318337,
-0.0297484472,
0.0153470589,
-0.0531577207,
-0.0245818682,
-0.0394163318,
0.0226761866,
-0.0394129455,
0.0194446668,
0.0431383662,
0.0211025532,
-0.0029738515,
-0.0349819474,
-0.0312899314,
-0.0071171504,
0.0137558896,
0.0582572892,
-0.0071240081,
-0.0111905383,
0.0079375757,
0.0027843216,
-0.0013093565,
-0.0579773486,
0.0237465501,
0.019705778,
0.0429061539,
0.0388297141,
-0.0045144409,
0.023856312,
-0.0675390735,
0.0356019884,
-0.0124912411,
0.0427998528,
-0.0274276622,
-0.0773730353,
0.0187503621,
0.0488485545,
0.0404452085,
0.0234760027,
0.061724823,
0.0180459768,
-0.007555692,
0.0460707843,
-0.0284363646,
0.0047259238,
0.070396781,
0.0285882875,
-0.0563009381,
-0.0137365051,
0.1075574681,
-0.0214495901,
-0.0155903623,
0.0282584354,
2.721e-7,
0.0317590646,
0.0152274342,
0.0775163844,
0.0716513768,
0.0023851749,
0.0071206698,
0.0014859978,
-0.0349675938,
-0.0513267852,
-0.0133188944,
0.0381820872,
-0.0251192451,
0.0572535321,
0.0538967289,
-0.0126593756,
0.0134145757,
-0.0252220035,
-0.0295461137,
-0.069444865,
-0.0179129448,
0.0223024487,
0.0710891783,
-0.0444314629,
-0.007909962,
-0.0069328356,
-0.0240788683,
0.0061398791,
-0.0457048006,
0.0209015794,
0.0500987321,
0.0284716133,
0.009473701,
-0.02109579,
0.0421165153,
-0.0305187944,
0.0437316336,
-0.0105064772,
0.0213560481,
0.0140003217,
0.0676910356,
0.0236331988,
-0.0918119326,
-0.0173568185,
0.0181439575,
0.0436529703,
-0.0429091826,
0.0288838819,
0.080471307,
0.0025743986,
0.0261046719,
0.0005171836,
0.0414452925,
-0.0051099341,
0.0087652402,
-0.0182313323,
0.0155471545,
0.0154000819,
-0.0381251946,
-0.0019697594,
0.037565425,
-0.0377002582,
0.0389471948,
0.005309585,
0.0032265661,
-0.0244395155,
-0.0247146264,
-0.0469431318,
2.532332353e-34,
0.0549569987,
0.0146359764,
0.0419126824,
-0.0187740196,
0.0679914653,
-0.0224440675,
-0.0327127837,
0.0364886262,
-0.0261093471,
-0.0340300165,
-0.00190086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03869v1 | Semantic Equivalence of e-Commerce Queries | 2023-08-07T18:40:13 | 2023-08-07T18:40:13 | Aritra Mandal, Daniel Tunkelang, Zhe Wu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Search query variation poses a challenge in e-commerce search, as equivalent
search intents can be expressed through different queries with surface-level
differences. This paper introduces a framework to recognize and leverage query
equivalence to enhance searcher and business outcomes. The proposed approach
addresses three key problems: mapping queries to vector representations of
search intent, identifying nearest neighbor queries expressing equivalent or
similar intent, and optimizing for user or business objectives. The framework
utilizes both surface similarity and behavioral similarity to determine query
equivalence. Surface similarity involves canonicalizing queries based on word
inflection, word order, compounding, and noise words. Behavioral similarity
leverages historical search behavior to generate vector representations of
query intent. An offline process is used to train a sentence similarity model,
while an online nearest neighbor approach supports processing of unseen
queries. Experimental evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed
approach, outperforming popular sentence transformer models and achieving a
Pearson correlation of 0.85 for query similarity. The results highlight the
potential of leveraging historical behavior data and training models to
recognize and utilize query equivalence in e-commerce search, leading to
improved user experiences and business outcomes. Further advancements and
benchmark datasets are encouraged to facilitate the development of solutions
for this critical problem in the e-commerce domain. | [
0.0836303756,
0.044629097,
-0.0303042773,
0.0127391322,
-0.030358443,
-0.0112354355,
0.010386603,
0.0400784723,
-0.0162703805,
-0.0440299064,
-0.0644854382,
-0.012210899,
-0.0297685247,
0.0124218306,
0.0102605876,
-0.0345780067,
0.0184456762,
0.0338096097,
-0.0589121692,
0.0481074676,
0.0821220651,
0.0342537872,
0.0242545307,
0.0278073084,
0.0425275043,
0.0124370549,
-0.0081319232,
0.0425399281,
0.0045258999,
-0.0185906198,
0.0590136014,
0.0260798801,
0.0283868518,
0.0106780119,
0.0000015107,
-0.0706296042,
-0.058117643,
-0.0429614149,
-0.0056863306,
0.0059501017,
0.0567004085,
0.0351643637,
0.0608203337,
0.0283133723,
-0.0189281851,
0.0261116363,
0.0293248948,
0.0558097512,
0.0362918824,
0.023294514,
-0.0071539632,
-0.0237174127,
-0.0346568786,
0.0241389684,
0.024864072,
-0.0260881986,
0.0110422121,
-0.0224418771,
-0.0069706351,
0.0113345543,
0.0218411721,
-0.0044818688,
-0.0597499758,
0.0101249469,
0.014518044,
0.0221165437,
0.0104442406,
0.025215568,
-0.0099905422,
0.0460303761,
-0.0497007445,
-0.0476206653,
0.0111498795,
-0.0010958707,
-0.0270495061,
0.0359346904,
-0.031463854,
-0.0119998865,
-0.0205308273,
0.0019543532,
-0.0148919858,
0.0542641506,
-0.0033485885,
0.0281126704,
-0.0205175858,
0.0455610156,
0.0146165062,
-0.0658839345,
-0.0353530347,
-0.0357746743,
0.0126652839,
-0.0026018962,
0.0269402936,
-0.003617987,
-0.0387383327,
0.0180508178,
-0.0347308964,
-0.0097836079,
0.0338429175,
-0.0797664002,
0.0388040431,
0.0101634897,
0.0274557322,
0.0268523637,
-0.0258529466,
0.0651648939,
0.0230378509,
-0.0006871955,
-0.0989750251,
0.0048201089,
-0.0748280287,
-0.0185737107,
-0.041706346,
0.0319260806,
-0.0046290215,
-0.0378603376,
-0.0245498791,
0.0223265067,
0.0341870673,
-0.0518042892,
0.0164664891,
0.027615184,
-0.0411905721,
-0.0066636889,
-0.0573724546,
-0.0051575685,
-0.047040619,
0.029246293,
-0.0167638827,
-0.0477937236,
0.0145237101,
0.0351430401,
0.0499212481,
-0.0404070616,
0.0257647913,
-0.0499396436,
-0.0142665347,
-0.0136648929,
-0.0557280108,
-0.0620487109,
0.0255437288,
0.0212869197,
-0.0468228534,
-0.0323449448,
0.0475151464,
-0.0118778152,
-0.0197209269,
0.0114205424,
-0.023286894,
0.0500214808,
-0.0015575367,
0.0882760435,
0.0341942236,
0.003580712,
0.0367015861,
-0.0179227907,
0.0789741278,
0.0052616438,
-0.0318105109,
0.0135076316,
0.0602523685,
0.02520057,
0.0076345732,
0.0008233073,
-0.023205772,
-0.0219464228,
-0.0222790129,
0.0565280467,
-0.0025112857,
0.0353502408,
0.0154968221,
0.0571385995,
-0.0423350893,
-0.0084419874,
0.0350915343,
0.0521002933,
0.0207741819,
-0.0183019806,
0.022232173,
0.0557332002,
-0.0484913141,
-0.0142105445,
-0.0102925375,
-0.0258169398,
0.0074546039,
0.0072955289,
0.0166472103,
-0.0084036468,
-0.0510386191,
-0.0036144883,
0.0047472632,
0.005064832,
0.0064736758,
-0.0039507379,
-0.0178145468,
0.0321152173,
-0.0306552183,
0.0434087142,
-0.0202287305,
-0.0433197841,
0.0099644922,
-0.0495315902,
-0.0118179498,
0.1055739298,
0.055926308,
-0.0130746141,
-0.0267523639,
-0.0284586269,
-0.0295646843,
0.0311818346,
0.0192039479,
-0.0232665241,
-0.0110016074,
-0.0577098057,
-0.0250683408,
0.029724421,
-0.0133019472,
-0.0238137841,
0.0319561698,
0.0031160901,
0.0577332638,
-0.0900561213,
0.0066237426,
0.0503298938,
0.0094387028,
-0.021324819,
0.0235509202,
0.0204853304,
0.020379683,
-0.001751074,
0.0150668565,
0.0139073338,
-0.0151797384,
-0.0177221689,
-0.0542753637,
0.0207214989,
0.0017620798,
0.0151167465,
0.0117984647,
-0.0503987446,
0.0463646203,
0.0308476854,
-0.0154264718,
-0.0037225874,
-0.0540457554,
-0.0367270894,
0.0588579401,
-0.0509034693,
0.0399637483,
-0.0363286361,
-0.0018410248,
-0.0731181279,
0.0327473991,
0.0207939111,
0.0360803492,
-0.0042940048,
-0.019215595,
0.0050855777,
-0.0100604035,
-0.0156628974,
-0.0232545938,
-0.0138834668,
0.0185457543,
0.0358210392,
0.0219782684,
-0.0327752903,
0.0253247675,
-0.0716110989,
-0.0045748334,
0.0130749494,
0.0396360718,
0.0604013018,
0.066576317,
0.001007654,
-0.0086565595,
-0.0193613097,
-0.0115794865,
-0.0145340189,
0.0293958411,
0.0495694242,
-0.0001392967,
-0.0551481247,
-0.0339835063,
-0.0209307447,
0.0058868574,
0.0133857587,
-0.0061437185,
-0.0263759475,
-0.0739045069,
0.0362500548,
-0.0224322621,
-0.0003525464,
-0.0033958617,
-0.010543799,
-0.0201050509,
-0.0199844986,
0.0273604747,
0.0289719328,
0.0617093146,
-0.0615414679,
0.0243779961,
0.0076374584,
-0.1035617962,
-0.0295887701,
-0.044737611,
-0.0048273341,
-0.0153256059,
-0.0428514779,
0.0844259784,
-0.0158647522,
0.0028973762,
0.0136647867,
-0.0166341811,
-0.0236940328,
-0.0030155,
-0.0361125693,
-0.0781190544,
-0.0045080036,
-0.0099508315,
0.0180335976,
0.0210461412,
-0.0295145735,
0.0793989897,
0.0059210761,
0.0235238839,
-0.0691683888,
-0.0174519327,
-0.0224729385,
0.0382109992,
-0.0306111369,
0.0397825465,
0.0014076608,
-0.0550272129,
-0.042221617,
0.0292054154,
0.0745244548,
-0.0220084824,
0.0444771312,
-0.0058406638,
0.0281971488,
0.0407959744,
-0.0290476177,
-0.0423689224,
-0.0749480352,
0.0128277354,
-0.0374299921,
0.0342058651,
-0.0149719147,
-0.0438279882,
0.0763259381,
-0.023954425,
0.0147653939,
0.0113025801,
-0.063196674,
0.0116781481,
0.0264084153,
0.0550101362,
0.017828932,
-0.0305489637,
0.0341879837,
-0.0109479213,
0.0056250859,
0.0575261191,
-0.0752767101,
0.0169037152,
-0.0234678276,
0.0266657397,
-0.0757014602,
0.0166731048,
0.0437253676,
-0.0505349077,
0.0308599304,
-0.020600507,
0.0754653141,
0.0684826449,
-0.0283724461,
-0.0222067256,
-0.0151179871,
0.012341097,
0.0302973259,
0.0339652151,
-0.0138149047,
-0.0108651025,
0.0028323324,
0.0393407457,
-0.006391712,
0.0056298124,
0.0112993466,
-0.0974737108,
-0.0041515185,
-0.0426210426,
0.0103620812,
-0.0228760429,
-0.0529637299,
0.0240069758,
-0.0151590053,
0.0268546883,
0.0324524492,
-0.0441921018,
-0.0064347,
0.0093800435,
0.0239182264,
-0.0378384292,
0.0006452746,
-0.0485168546,
-0.0183691196,
0.0439051762,
0.0039423364,
0.0187098552,
-0.0178426374,
-0.0114107383,
-0.0639331564,
0.0234946646,
-0.0003737457,
0.0160399601,
-0.0073616328,
0.0430419482,
-0.0284963492,
-0.0199629422,
-0.0197858885,
0.0109845717,
0.0067141154,
0.0104854461,
-0.0198018309,
-0.0054965871,
-0.0318313204,
-0.0248501468,
-0.0137898577,
0.0791000649,
0.0159525685,
0.0263769533,
-0.0227668434,
0.010011713,
0.0167174041,
0.025338266,
-0.0301215034,
-0.0019143533,
-0.0297293961,
0.004863834,
-0.064043276,
-0.0190568734,
-0.0277897492,
0.0031558636,
0.0248766392,
0.0044802655,
0.029179519,
0.0046559838,
-0.0406338871,
-0.0222793184,
-0.0434143804,
0.0491249897,
-0.002496223,
0.0501878969,
0.0545179732,
-0.0092249531,
-0.0370604545,
-0.0341642946,
-0.0449730493,
-0.0193443876,
-0.0282822233,
-0.0202453714,
0.009160595,
0.0375453122,
-0.0307056624,
-0.0068173483,
-0.0141093209,
0.0602518879,
-0.0064854207,
-0.0285854582,
0.0093770688,
0.0113162389,
0.003547508,
0.0324280448,
-0.039187368,
-0.0045485222,
-0.014509568,
0.0506882891,
-0.0345668048,
-0.0934426039,
0.0869439021,
0.0306919217,
0.0303733349,
0.0108286962,
-0.0011533765,
-0.0386571959,
0.0227676313,
0.0163873173,
-0.0398328453,
0.007020677,
-0.0280452799,
0.0059521752,
0.0169796962,
-0.0178445056,
0.0739093348,
-0.0689312965,
0.0077791172,
-0.0384259894,
-0.0163661893,
-0.0146702323,
0.0333495289,
-0.0079863472,
-0.0196206067,
-0.0268692542,
0.016813321,
0.0387468487,
0.0335439779,
-0.0477172248,
0.0030778891,
0.0243438222,
-0.0084963152,
-0.040263731,
0.0659804866,
-0.0456413217,
-0.0284157023,
-0.0632519126,
-0.0652953908,
0.0099643962,
-0.0394906923,
0.0124957887,
-0.0149118453,
0.0185371414,
0.0143582458,
-0.0088252574,
-0.0093402509,
0.0017024693,
0.0397165008,
0.018489318,
0.0042537767,
-0.0108574005,
0.0500929393,
-0.065643549,
0.0406345651,
-0.0376922004,
-0.0630538091,
-0.0340677314,
-0.0237176158,
0.029073013,
0.0417514145,
-0.0209175032,
-0.0747024342,
0.0073490073,
0.0113293044,
0.0156266298,
-0.0256062727,
0.0312348753,
0.0102518443,
0.1091165096,
0.0832157135,
0.0012804269,
-0.0079953363,
0.002022075,
0.0094755189,
-0.0061101052,
-0.0229547676,
-0.103216432,
-5.677226659e-33,
0.052593898,
0.0017148082,
-0.0151335616,
-0.0269028973,
-0.0328175314,
-0.0177982897,
0.0076197623,
-0.0395188294,
-0.0119399112,
-0.0386833213,
-0.0173946749,
0.04847458,
0.0367824249,
-0.0199808739,
0.0227804631,
-0.0582081825,
0.0430692956,
0.0001105412,
-0.0235310961,
0.0237834156,
0.0111605562,
0.0115810847,
0.0329675265,
-0.0635607466,
0.0059365314,
-0.0370270237,
-0.0346249975,
0.0495606735,
0.0436428078,
0.0795179084,
0.0053684949,
0.0226003658,
0.0425054729,
-0.0370977968,
0.0256050061,
-0.0197804533,
-0.0220857728,
-0.0093678162,
0.0331892073,
-0.0007386325,
0.0171632301,
0.0239442345,
0.0536153801,
-0.0313260593,
-0.0177232027,
0.0495972261,
0.0449556932,
0.0066034202,
0.0086512193,
-0.0489524417,
-0.0585822016,
-0.0075779357,
0.002977198,
0.0044230493,
0.0158687681,
0.096446678,
-0.028156735,
0.0208786745,
-0.0074843788,
0.082492426,
-0.0452866182,
0.0469802357,
0.0677828491,
0.0361618251,
-0.0136012491,
0.0387641378,
0.024009563,
-0.0294031408,
0.0386094712,
0.0023486686,
0.0245634895,
0.0175942443,
0.0076620118,
0.0752941966,
0.0332633853,
0.0168202315,
0.0265763085,
0.0593186654,
0.019756956,
0.0114371441,
0.0090099238,
0.034766078,
-0.054927893,
-0.0422507599,
0.0025405963,
0.033120852,
-0.0847536549,
0.0042616175,
0.0777452886,
0.0237460006,
-0.0197536964,
-0.0154854013,
-0.0013992463,
-0.0212760195,
-0.0497577563,
-0.0101054534,
0.0390356407,
-0.0109139821,
0.0149203455,
-0.0157721154,
-0.0014940161,
-0.0410183184,
-0.0102361459,
-0.007972586,
-0.0154876988,
-0.0150733199,
-0.0121628027,
-0.0129763354,
-0.0184450205,
0.0030105093,
0.039844878,
-0.0693045482,
-0.0727864727,
-0.0450186282,
0.0106577622,
0.049474515,
-0.0100069726,
0.0255851559,
0.0605550632,
-0.0251468644,
-0.037675824,
-0.0650136545,
0.0258969013,
0.0427086428,
-0.0007992277,
0.0243959446,
-0.0526120551,
-0.0044128373,
-0.0024635675,
-0.0437097326,
-0.0160875469,
0.0544215962,
2.432e-7,
0.0468829125,
0.0336410254,
-0.0064592226,
0.0350712501,
-0.0343811736,
0.0267419573,
0.0526320525,
0.0232166238,
0.0189876482,
0.0239203423,
0.09301126,
-0.0454190709,
0.0074587977,
-0.0115647595,
-0.0567127131,
-0.0286833197,
-0.0512122773,
-0.0466665477,
-0.0479220673,
0.0037227236,
0.0846180543,
0.0620499812,
-0.0020785823,
-0.0120298201,
-0.0274779666,
-0.0388840176,
-0.0355998538,
-0.0241269451,
0.013291481,
0.0291872844,
0.0143435923,
-0.0185965337,
0.0186409876,
0.0130767636,
-0.0179165006,
0.0202937983,
0.0411992334,
-0.0000255456,
-0.0050166678,
-0.015129392,
-0.0425771028,
-0.0434566513,
0.001090566,
-0.0903875157,
0.0545833521,
-0.0112884762,
0.0478657708,
0.0163105708,
-0.0165338498,
0.0120694106,
-0.0012676428,
-0.0369306505,
-0.0642666668,
0.0109883044,
0.0521832742,
0.0442412756,
-0.0346995816,
-0.042807851,
0.0173161831,
-0.0174895432,
-0.0384102315,
-0.0194205791,
-0.0477203876,
0.0553902574,
0.0039289226,
-0.0005175226,
0.0126343584,
2.098409863e-34,
0.0075842943,
0.0591245517,
0.0270168446,
-0.0004209468,
0.0016813835,
0.0360839777,
0.0162261073,
0.0228748377,
0.0146972565,
-0.1132139266,
-0.0182815567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03866v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03866v1 | Trusting Language Models in Education | 2023-08-07T18:27:54 | 2023-08-07T18:27:54 | Jogi Suda Neto, Li Deng, Thejaswi Raya, Reza Shahbazi, Nick Liu, Adhitya Venkatesh, Miral Shah, Neeru Khosla, Rodrigo Capobianco Guido | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language Models are being widely used in Education. Even though modern deep
learning models achieve very good performance on question-answering tasks,
sometimes they make errors. To avoid misleading students by showing wrong
answers, it is important to calibrate the confidence - that is, the prediction
probability - of these models. In our work, we propose to use an XGBoost on top
of BERT to output the corrected probabilities, using features based on the
attention mechanism. Our hypothesis is that the level of uncertainty contained
in the flow of attention is related to the quality of the model's response
itself. | [
0.0323047191,
0.0368632339,
-0.0183533542,
0.0221333634,
-0.0019642403,
-0.0173966978,
-0.028046228,
-0.0414224006,
-0.0082506482,
-0.0601854995,
-0.01723364,
-0.082357876,
0.0009781101,
0.0204425324,
0.032530766,
-0.0781520903,
0.0354397669,
-0.0123014664,
0.0220549833,
0.0121573601,
-0.0196963288,
-0.0069649704,
-0.0094813686,
0.0704307407,
-0.0215759017,
-0.0349029228,
-0.0217774864,
0.0078203836,
0.018573327,
0.021423975,
0.0463829786,
0.0806159377,
-0.0405867733,
0.0603504069,
0.0000020008,
-0.0482699238,
-0.0054829228,
-0.0339382552,
-0.017448172,
0.0376182012,
-0.0350040197,
0.044427,
-0.0287444163,
0.0371587574,
-0.0307293572,
0.0531870946,
0.0934502408,
0.0208456423,
0.0468910635,
0.0548125468,
0.0106378011,
0.0254204273,
0.0290021934,
-0.017354833,
0.0435844809,
-0.045802854,
0.0023134456,
-0.0146671534,
-0.023266416,
0.0174598321,
-0.0492522046,
0.0337488018,
0.0239303522,
-0.031672392,
0.0101005388,
0.0254177582,
-0.0378920361,
-0.0197065566,
-0.028775027,
0.0528105237,
-0.0477497131,
-0.0342289284,
-0.0466809124,
-0.0058630216,
0.0385509245,
0.03538334,
-0.0346349813,
0.023261087,
-0.0069843745,
0.0173606239,
-0.0127565023,
-0.0404827446,
0.0110934824,
0.0007627693,
-0.0117044998,
0.0553052537,
0.0058313655,
-0.0413557105,
-0.008437979,
0.0157282501,
-0.0126382997,
-0.0845131278,
0.0185941197,
0.040123567,
0.0210682973,
0.0351543576,
-0.056237191,
-0.0426977724,
0.0056122835,
-0.0544193164,
0.0125753498,
0.030315293,
-0.0568296053,
0.023581123,
0.0007491879,
0.0904597566,
-0.0078185396,
0.0281256344,
0.0034224861,
0.0220056958,
-0.0143174771,
-0.0081445649,
-0.0329657383,
0.0015892279,
0.0011952376,
-0.0157722738,
-0.0642012954,
0.021634521,
-0.0364915021,
0.0294252671,
-0.0033097214,
0.044470042,
-0.0216053147,
-0.0092143426,
-0.0413784645,
0.0649727583,
-0.0105979424,
-0.0165782366,
-0.008609809,
-0.0771284997,
-0.013714049,
0.0150568206,
-0.0156339947,
-0.002730598,
-0.0279971734,
0.0385218002,
-0.0010791044,
-0.0155442171,
-0.0102433506,
-0.0374069847,
-0.0415779091,
-0.0292780157,
0.0202817656,
-0.0529113673,
-0.0543101542,
0.0129568204,
0.0127000837,
-0.0014110993,
0.0318039805,
0.0080055902,
-0.0178500786,
0.0222257245,
0.01638964,
0.0062901578,
-0.0145224072,
0.0054482236,
-0.0053049275,
0.0437069833,
0.0518077463,
0.0373534709,
0.0311874915,
-0.0319967829,
0.0302382465,
-0.00140806,
0.0177864674,
-0.0135328919,
0.0032194429,
-0.0167409983,
-0.0053619454,
0.0189702567,
0.0195835978,
0.0520691685,
0.0109503139,
-0.0189471804,
0.0840797052,
0.043948371,
-0.0382516086,
0.0293533746,
-0.013698387,
-0.0010378826,
0.0358193517,
0.0617101751,
-0.0770614818,
0.0273774229,
-0.0114709279,
0.0118937343,
0.0402833074,
-0.0045878389,
0.0188508071,
-0.0529694296,
-0.0541465506,
-0.0087766331,
-0.0218427721,
0.0245519523,
0.063445121,
-0.0369264558,
-0.0430106297,
0.0829675943,
-0.0007843912,
-0.0206595026,
0.0083793076,
-0.091303587,
0.0462706238,
0.0340100639,
-0.0023914922,
-0.0201031193,
-0.0162245706,
-0.012993183,
0.0116968369,
0.0423788913,
0.0821746737,
0.0161511954,
-0.0044381102,
-0.0062329206,
-0.0354675725,
-0.0468613207,
0.0165683255,
0.0141759813,
0.0118240016,
0.0420388281,
-0.0001123728,
-0.0497299768,
-0.0408945493,
0.0354214385,
0.0030218048,
-0.0302950442,
-0.0219605789,
0.0099363495,
0.0122256074,
0.0115187503,
-0.0077489042,
0.0449560545,
0.019337425,
0.0356302671,
0.0050510233,
-0.0147082154,
-0.0113089867,
0.0163206439,
0.0640983433,
-0.0533342846,
-0.0211461484,
0.0403405726,
-0.0105990367,
-0.035878107,
0.0276631378,
-0.0815893859,
0.0567106903,
0.0038759669,
0.0319666676,
-0.0426904559,
0.0163092241,
-0.0307220668,
0.032806877,
-0.0080992719,
0.0487419516,
0.0025846709,
0.0203013271,
0.0178548396,
-0.0432610959,
-0.0087815402,
-0.0235036165,
-0.0121646896,
-0.0011928024,
0.0219545532,
-0.0218904726,
-0.064830102,
0.004667968,
-0.0533595458,
-0.0143839093,
-0.0220986791,
0.030075537,
0.0222542454,
-0.036741823,
0.0019291105,
-0.0194226429,
-0.0302808862,
-0.0018150394,
-0.0371397175,
0.0144356387,
-0.009439989,
-0.0537937544,
0.0093036462,
-0.0552546494,
-0.0227969922,
-0.0385267586,
0.0402134061,
0.0514115281,
-0.0274575576,
-0.0661913753,
0.0156102758,
-0.0112902876,
0.0457812846,
0.0381370336,
-0.0576121323,
0.0411829576,
-0.0094149904,
-0.0159592815,
0.1044693887,
0.0343094952,
0.0182423759,
0.0745672211,
0.0052720467,
-0.0624479279,
0.0249712989,
-0.0295817014,
-0.0510410927,
-0.0088868383,
-0.0543048829,
-0.004846999,
0.0551684387,
0.0499224328,
-0.0317179598,
-0.0586124174,
0.0189969689,
0.011354629,
-0.0161565039,
-0.0088957911,
0.0030975521,
-0.0087348204,
0.0458707549,
-0.0075494903,
-0.0775000528,
0.1240184978,
-0.0076333415,
0.0226810556,
-0.0323295631,
0.0624768026,
0.0321224034,
-0.0019465114,
-0.0003165415,
0.0324614793,
0.0229204576,
-0.0356774032,
-0.0457040332,
0.0064567057,
0.0060694241,
-0.0528135113,
0.0038018874,
-0.0273682941,
-0.0243874453,
0.0072571402,
0.0043785218,
-0.0862130672,
-0.0116387149,
-0.0403626598,
0.0119121466,
0.0005762437,
-0.0451731943,
-0.0838962048,
0.0087805428,
0.0333851166,
-0.0102932937,
-0.0521711148,
-0.0164923817,
0.0049172807,
0.0483214892,
0.0430426933,
0.0267253779,
0.0447043777,
-0.048986312,
-0.0111977831,
0.0674552247,
0.0271739792,
0.0680932179,
-0.0142766079,
-0.0397082977,
0.0265143383,
-0.0156215439,
-0.0029763139,
0.0218599495,
0.0377581492,
-0.0746597499,
-0.0369419008,
0.1074513942,
0.0313571393,
0.0060359179,
-0.0116447099,
-0.0535939448,
0.0150558604,
0.0065758959,
0.0014412453,
-0.0562663153,
-0.0394819863,
-0.0015668037,
0.0426527411,
0.0261525847,
-0.0077537796,
0.0320684873,
-0.0992673337,
0.0142764188,
-0.0008864825,
-0.0260222889,
-0.0563624017,
-0.0701296702,
0.0290558767,
0.007372261,
0.0177445058,
-0.0015391348,
0.0203137267,
0.0178968851,
0.0417426489,
0.006181662,
-0.0298937261,
0.0107027683,
-0.0290539376,
0.0034544666,
0.087071456,
0.0121522844,
-0.0285201427,
-0.0657031909,
-0.0143929357,
-0.012897131,
-0.0369946137,
0.0318900235,
0.0624302477,
-0.0318815038,
-0.0167893004,
-0.0080898684,
0.0163885765,
-0.0243627131,
0.015780583,
-0.0102610048,
0.0774996132,
-0.0170839094,
-0.0411584266,
-0.0599771217,
-0.0090415813,
0.0108031621,
0.0657197013,
0.0375310704,
-0.0441327356,
-0.0215622485,
-0.0601324104,
0.0275346395,
-0.0254513547,
0.0030380532,
0.0704291016,
0.0129151801,
-0.0398582555,
-0.0442341827,
-0.0499478057,
0.0303484332,
-0.0068054283,
0.0248565506,
-0.0508451015,
0.0383397825,
0.0119490623,
-0.0447943509,
0.0894337371,
0.0098714242,
0.0329367183,
-0.0861168876,
-0.015549059,
0.0061645727,
0.0125746531,
-0.0012273425,
0.0259092022,
-0.0582527407,
-0.0671191365,
0.0154134873,
0.0502238683,
0.0218320116,
-0.0105574308,
-0.0174376797,
-0.0450477377,
0.0135664493,
-0.0105951754,
0.0331972837,
0.0045395908,
0.0228842702,
-0.0116239414,
-0.0156630687,
0.0154487211,
-0.0348494872,
-0.0269950889,
0.0233145766,
0.0335050076,
-0.0227128174,
-0.0706828684,
0.0221378691,
0.0030681544,
0.0820490345,
-0.0164938532,
-0.0103654871,
-0.0215179808,
0.0191833358,
0.020686198,
0.0168434829,
-0.0318956636,
-0.0048006326,
0.032535214,
-0.0326990336,
0.0341054164,
-0.0166984461,
-0.0353180394,
-0.0326091386,
-0.0358676314,
0.031369362,
0.0225757807,
-0.0001533397,
0.0356713496,
-0.0156569183,
-0.0262839887,
-0.0156908277,
0.0040834458,
0.0442346446,
0.0502962098,
0.0358352251,
0.0187564865,
-0.0314854346,
0.0269164462,
-0.0317111015,
-0.0740645006,
-0.0643144324,
-0.0621605664,
0.0122871026,
0.0289787725,
-0.0131273791,
0.007274698,
-0.0249626525,
-0.0111250319,
-0.027844036,
0.0126331784,
0.013292376,
-0.000016038,
0.0382217616,
-0.0059890426,
0.0251352116,
-0.0100551955,
0.0496025793,
0.0110773072,
0.0364549085,
-0.0230897404,
-0.0458381101,
-0.0048939059,
-0.0033846758,
0.0435686409,
0.027154861,
0.0125247855,
0.038864281,
-0.0104510337,
-0.0847833529,
0.0169202741,
0.0432045907,
0.0051636938,
-0.0236047283,
0.0458510295,
0.0557035096,
-0.00110166,
0.0053775101,
-0.0303417649,
0.0497225076,
-0.010234274,
0.0090084486,
-0.0553589128,
-6.102496638e-33,
-0.010128784,
-0.0636797994,
-0.0540049076,
-0.0180471297,
0.0083827991,
0.0004230297,
-0.0536203124,
0.0250448193,
-0.0513774492,
0.0246209931,
-0.0016772901,
0.0480987281,
0.0168268569,
0.0410354547,
0.0211640876,
-0.0186570995,
0.0083619198,
-0.0023312792,
-0.0125887869,
-0.0012293194,
0.0403320231,
0.0175002236,
0.1236315891,
-0.0520893894,
0.0629236624,
0.0208993331,
0.0103582349,
0.0161780547,
-0.0392051041,
0.0550657921,
-0.0173961166,
0.0748462677,
-0.0110839345,
-0.0206821617,
-0.0066020177,
0.0306786802,
-0.0027029624,
-0.0567551069,
0.0036044552,
0.030607406,
-0.0567770712,
-0.0006550663,
0.0740740225,
0.0145062739,
-0.0052351872,
-0.0288952328,
0.0408655554,
-0.0363283642,
-0.0290608648,
0.016343208,
-0.0543181486,
0.0038745047,
-0.034898188,
-0.0320321545,
0.0154768461,
0.0679071695,
0.0063963616,
-0.0173240565,
-0.0034193597,
0.0327668972,
0.0800019801,
0.0454322547,
0.0903019086,
0.0364088044,
0.0090796668,
0.0535230488,
0.0384665504,
0.0012291231,
-0.0021951667,
-0.0378099456,
0.0383734517,
0.0080341613,
0.0829400346,
0.0057077068,
0.0044389521,
0.0328401253,
-0.0879241154,
0.0153740114,
0.0101726158,
0.0528033227,
0.0343438014,
-0.0165605005,
-0.0622082539,
-0.0012332456,
-0.0308683142,
-0.0217472501,
-0.0308126044,
-0.0020738172,
0.0142498212,
-0.0406253226,
0.0027605845,
-0.0022370545,
0.0027596052,
-0.0294710714,
-0.0083153332,
0.0113375019,
0.0184897911,
0.0004576713,
-0.0166961253,
0.0509680025,
-0.0200043712,
0.0312846154,
-0.0200053398,
0.0016024137,
-0.0040506315,
0.0435148515,
-0.0064614597,
-0.0194476005,
-0.035920132,
0.0134015065,
-0.0459680632,
-0.0349457003,
0.0076566292,
0.0246711913,
0.0463904291,
-0.0332408957,
-0.0010518947,
0.0340740867,
-0.0059712292,
0.0213679597,
-0.0245462488,
0.0018037293,
-0.0019439769,
0.0083217006,
-0.0463492908,
-0.0402597152,
-0.0475435741,
0.0400464311,
-0.0212969277,
-0.0745271668,
-0.0199139882,
0.0114436829,
2.661e-7,
0.0422225781,
0.0233019032,
-0.0041814977,
0.0118926326,
-0.0064370232,
0.0479901843,
-0.0070393062,
0.0159282293,
0.0730684176,
-0.0410470888,
-0.035129305,
-0.0213647075,
0.0499785654,
0.0252489056,
-0.06875588,
-0.0522441491,
-0.0380496867,
0.0486697964,
0.0167200658,
0.028569486,
0.0398163646,
0.1057143807,
0.0143830804,
0.0000444009,
0.0027870699,
-0.014526139,
0.0141050117,
0.0097640092,
0.0203309432,
0.0142237041,
0.0570963658,
-0.0113864047,
0.0088785188,
0.0269619823,
-0.0265388303,
0.0063947937,
-0.0256580077,
0.0269084908,
-0.0492500514,
-0.0411751419,
-0.028373668,
-0.0237226598,
0.0306465626,
-0.0829459056,
0.028019214,
-0.0324086845,
-0.0014745508,
-0.0077922116,
-0.0050187618,
-0.0312674344,
0.0338524841,
-0.0361080542,
-0.0276046451,
-0.0294895917,
-0.0142497402,
-0.0058587147,
0.0023709,
-0.039809905,
-0.0340977609,
-0.0058606691,
-0.0387138873,
-0.060567908,
-0.0145354969,
-0.0225615483,
0.0146527309,
-0.0505592078,
0.0115109775,
1.932599956e-34,
0.0433679707,
0.0058233584,
0.019714877,
0.0356023498,
0.0154989669,
-0.0186684877,
0.0270456392,
-0.0279470067,
0.0606654994,
-0.0452403426,
-0.0441792347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03864v1 | Storyfier: Exploring Vocabulary Learning Support with Text Generation Models | 2023-08-07T18:25:00 | 2023-08-07T18:25:00 | Zhenhui Peng, Xingbo Wang, Qiushi Han, Junkai Zhu, Xiaojuan Ma, Huamin Qu | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Vocabulary learning support tools have widely exploited existing materials,
e.g., stories or video clips, as contexts to help users memorize each target
word. However, these tools could not provide a coherent context for any target
words of learners' interests, and they seldom help practice word usage. In this
paper, we work with teachers and students to iteratively develop Storyfier,
which leverages text generation models to enable learners to read a generated
story that covers any target words, conduct a story cloze test, and use these
words to write a new story with adaptive AI assistance. Our within-subjects
study (N=28) shows that learners generally favor the generated stories for
connecting target words and writing assistance for easing their learning
workload. However, in the read-cloze-write learning sessions, participants
using Storyfier perform worse in recalling and using target words than learning
with a baseline tool without our AI features. We discuss insights into
supporting learning tasks with generative models. | [
0.0213142782,
-0.0091019869,
-0.0250430088,
-0.0295395665,
-0.0561729856,
-0.0314767621,
0.0451231226,
0.0059991223,
0.0067613111,
-0.0359878242,
-0.0073524071,
-0.0465355702,
0.0274051428,
0.0841479003,
0.0023210358,
-0.0710320473,
0.0281999353,
0.0103716478,
0.0252581201,
0.0248783194,
-0.0148446104,
0.0244858153,
-0.0459792167,
0.0465895869,
-0.0181392953,
-0.0178221911,
-0.0048392662,
-0.0370841734,
-0.0056766975,
-0.0485245064,
0.030303549,
0.0293581374,
0.0428328812,
-0.0276019238,
0.000001883,
-0.0389266983,
-0.0067000813,
-0.0242958367,
-0.0117073366,
-0.0036567484,
0.0510612391,
0.0632524192,
0.009606163,
0.0207383558,
-0.0148045141,
0.0330134965,
0.0522404052,
-0.0042933449,
-0.0278728306,
0.0302273389,
-0.0149398819,
0.0016807443,
0.0119929044,
-0.0098884273,
0.0975283682,
0.0097512035,
-0.0395920314,
0.0005440501,
0.0823216289,
-0.0362204798,
-0.03222939,
0.0442502275,
0.0144960554,
0.0013476743,
0.0694518313,
0.0520536974,
0.0689515248,
-0.0394548513,
0.000400527,
0.0460181236,
0.0291203596,
-0.0125786941,
-0.0018161626,
-0.0011439164,
0.019118974,
0.093864277,
-0.068850562,
0.0633187592,
-0.0106788818,
-0.0051125777,
0.0225050412,
-0.0167952552,
0.0116804317,
0.0205060076,
0.039332591,
-0.0244645495,
0.0182237402,
-0.0044967518,
-0.0337039754,
0.0292102937,
0.0083402153,
-0.0404931381,
0.0478085168,
0.0586885139,
-0.0401366241,
0.0507478938,
-0.0672003925,
-0.0207476299,
0.0151562653,
-0.0095654437,
0.0559690185,
0.0389922634,
0.0337065533,
-0.0144938175,
-0.0212243572,
0.0137778549,
0.0714513287,
-0.0330840908,
-0.0255512502,
0.0360429063,
-0.0272392351,
-0.0287102871,
-0.0308574364,
0.037916746,
-0.0355870463,
-0.058814887,
-0.0408525579,
0.0045198719,
0.0358572192,
0.013780904,
-0.0472307168,
0.0319688618,
-0.014065031,
0.0255647022,
-0.0241735112,
0.0010567193,
-0.0641690269,
0.021341715,
0.0495615229,
-0.0098928893,
-0.0110630458,
-0.0345498584,
0.0132961059,
-0.0117727658,
0.0341250077,
0.016574787,
-0.043737743,
-0.0588398352,
-0.0474551469,
-0.0408434309,
0.0038201734,
-0.0349298939,
-0.0211244766,
-0.0653972402,
0.0102103138,
0.0048887166,
0.0147562576,
-0.0641132221,
0.0114541538,
0.035840299,
-0.0050557461,
0.0103602028,
0.0072626313,
0.0175977685,
0.0620829426,
0.0418060943,
0.0513852909,
0.0124896821,
0.0788159668,
0.0043537188,
0.0304489248,
-0.0272269044,
0.0474523716,
0.0039941301,
0.0009974346,
-0.0299742706,
-0.0338864848,
-0.0645688027,
0.0111087076,
0.0528153665,
-0.0147604579,
0.0182683002,
-0.00374648,
0.0426091589,
0.0604556389,
0.1095943972,
0.0243256167,
0.0328534544,
0.032179527,
0.0119367568,
0.0035614953,
0.0391861461,
-0.0019639842,
0.0334265865,
-0.0066313697,
0.0235058013,
0.0049594822,
0.0332451202,
-0.0224905834,
-0.0613727197,
-0.018988369,
-0.0182652827,
0.0155847203,
-0.0054081054,
0.0340479463,
0.0205678903,
-0.0473748036,
-0.0053048884,
0.03071847,
-0.1169828549,
0.0533924289,
-0.0384700224,
0.0602830388,
0.1145677865,
0.082618922,
-0.011702003,
-0.0379158072,
0.0227953363,
-0.0326072946,
0.0283320826,
0.0094263749,
-0.0039439285,
-0.0106474357,
-0.0384070948,
-0.0089329276,
-0.0420828275,
0.003276479,
-0.0126787443,
0.039361082,
0.019663699,
0.0150269028,
0.0059587979,
-0.0723664314,
0.035093762,
-0.0966244712,
-0.0482959934,
-0.008728575,
-0.0227765143,
-0.0321306512,
0.0118664876,
-0.023154648,
0.0163502749,
0.0291002039,
0.001667819,
-0.0242566802,
0.025832491,
-0.0883251131,
-0.0121526094,
-0.0065648691,
-0.0269134659,
0.0625219494,
-0.0324128866,
0.0487639382,
-0.0420698151,
0.0288335383,
-0.0399262458,
0.0382840894,
0.0057923701,
0.0292155389,
-0.0157308187,
-0.0206801314,
-0.0058252993,
0.0316873416,
0.0067119733,
0.0198787116,
-0.0575995669,
0.0621341392,
-0.0449066199,
-0.0201833807,
0.019200081,
0.0295767486,
-0.0091105681,
-0.0006666761,
0.0187933911,
-0.0157154519,
-0.0665005371,
-0.0007946683,
-0.0421441272,
-0.0048760055,
0.0327526852,
-0.0314077362,
0.0275903661,
0.0186616145,
-0.0355105735,
0.0366970561,
-0.032742843,
0.0336259343,
0.0133524863,
-0.0099564092,
-0.0035040227,
-0.008883629,
0.009978706,
-0.0764413252,
-0.0000626935,
-0.0285638552,
0.0214183405,
0.0947500467,
-0.0262167603,
-0.0183427241,
0.0643450096,
0.0027401191,
-0.0233611669,
-0.0035529237,
0.0155675709,
0.0354634412,
-0.0332196839,
0.0817492604,
0.0610241704,
0.0218614638,
0.0594466925,
0.0460602902,
-0.0371451378,
-0.0443464927,
0.0163603723,
-0.008841482,
0.0017032977,
0.0238310955,
-0.0822178498,
0.0201982949,
0.0439006723,
0.0477422103,
0.0206562653,
-0.0350401886,
0.0177531224,
-0.0270341784,
0.0140342433,
-0.0262546595,
-0.0411345996,
-0.0236775409,
-0.0124282911,
-0.0058431639,
-0.0407703705,
0.0704175383,
-0.0123164812,
0.0074993395,
-0.063175194,
-0.007692805,
-0.000196915,
0.0458911173,
-0.0080528082,
0.0347855054,
0.0148342056,
0.0040175277,
-0.0238309409,
0.0033629718,
0.0343040377,
-0.0356788114,
0.0191620868,
-0.0685689449,
-0.0458072014,
0.0243069809,
0.0170314107,
-0.0464639552,
0.006377189,
0.023999678,
-0.0489925817,
0.0437275283,
-0.0470336564,
-0.0632563829,
-0.0208939426,
0.0381867029,
0.055787988,
-0.0139219845,
-0.0030642729,
0.0103698252,
0.0287336912,
0.0536274724,
-0.0144299641,
-0.0388989411,
-0.0525398999,
0.0475183465,
0.0472800471,
0.0320177861,
-0.0349133871,
0.0506122448,
0.0135607449,
0.0321338885,
-0.0495884567,
-0.0011388181,
0.0263453834,
0.057933975,
-0.0682926029,
-0.0316692181,
0.0787016228,
0.0533180013,
-0.0319180377,
0.0027722707,
-0.0155951558,
0.0446258038,
0.0055942284,
0.0140819009,
-0.0466572978,
-0.010498194,
-0.0066422406,
0.0493003055,
-0.0209484473,
-0.0276114512,
-0.0396181382,
-0.0914046317,
0.01098279,
0.0223193634,
-0.0414165109,
0.0483315699,
-0.0409920216,
-0.0303573236,
0.0501299985,
0.0099468725,
-0.0067093312,
-0.0381609239,
0.0430273451,
-0.0004066051,
0.0111743109,
-0.0469397604,
-0.0110391891,
-0.0128362915,
0.062950857,
0.0610273182,
0.0024144477,
-0.0154824769,
-0.0079818899,
-0.0030255164,
0.0172294769,
0.0312332232,
-0.0299309082,
0.0419227704,
0.0014006434,
0.0379895978,
-0.0013310402,
0.0738017187,
0.0000778841,
-0.0664788485,
0.0510648489,
0.0235277396,
0.0168753937,
-0.0300260056,
-0.0267047137,
0.0285512395,
0.0305817835,
0.0676162466,
0.0500798561,
-0.0616672784,
0.0072430973,
-0.0069190999,
0.0200754963,
-0.0658841878,
-0.0401758663,
-0.0261406098,
-0.0339476652,
0.029883774,
-0.0946928561,
-0.0605819449,
0.0829446763,
0.044989869,
0.0319703184,
0.0253089257,
-0.039216198,
-0.003107782,
-0.054844249,
-0.0003261548,
0.0283692442,
-0.0033724487,
-0.0697205663,
-0.0625510514,
-0.0256797988,
-0.0517935306,
0.0288076885,
0.0710655749,
-0.0111032985,
-0.0399893634,
0.0116349366,
0.0245066229,
0.0244057234,
0.0054035997,
0.0561986752,
-0.0136557855,
0.0358390994,
0.0111321937,
-0.05692764,
0.0207934994,
-0.0497837216,
-0.0161865614,
0.0043739127,
-0.0443170629,
-0.0004559905,
-0.0171400104,
-0.0218335725,
0.0455521792,
-0.002848634,
-0.0173236299,
0.0297093336,
-0.0113952346,
-0.0101458458,
-0.0599239357,
-0.0064927991,
-0.0612597801,
-0.0271750744,
-0.012787058,
-0.0012352358,
-0.0149929989,
0.0039668293,
0.0199185573,
0.0024068137,
0.0144873057,
-0.0196892451,
-0.0703859851,
-0.0060842345,
-0.0484979637,
0.0115205841,
-0.0079925172,
0.0043712771,
0.0225183908,
0.0159645304,
-0.0100431796,
0.0243652072,
-0.0415447876,
0.0557975285,
-0.0027382371,
0.0639654621,
-0.0240086447,
-0.0182931684,
0.0186893158,
-0.0135509362,
-0.0340025909,
0.0051028491,
-0.0413150154,
0.0469490401,
0.0043287356,
-0.039353095,
-0.0084092291,
-0.0408133157,
0.0276617929,
-0.0046825693,
-0.0077549201,
-0.0218381621,
-0.0437515192,
-0.0382524543,
0.0013285953,
0.0293758791,
-0.0524790511,
0.0667642504,
-0.0057355352,
0.0522225983,
0.0073551335,
-0.0027843621,
-0.0352831036,
-0.0297285561,
0.0288329981,
0.0527625792,
-0.0044133738,
-0.0186546277,
-0.0627101734,
-0.017911315,
0.0020742619,
-0.0013824791,
0.0133651085,
-0.0409914926,
0.0214683786,
0.02465453,
-0.0572983623,
0.0067049521,
-0.0486331172,
0.0735738724,
-0.0512925088,
-0.0437485389,
-0.0114320582,
-5.584769253e-33,
-0.0458687954,
-0.0831397921,
0.0446553752,
0.0633669272,
0.0050099003,
-0.0092914812,
-0.0567826927,
0.0498187095,
0.0360121503,
-0.0158149693,
0.0036518904,
0.0007275205,
-0.0058430447,
0.0180023555,
-0.0091493381,
0.0544560812,
0.0479767174,
0.0019168282,
-0.0380493961,
0.0370150544,
0.0524886772,
0.0177041236,
0.0381716192,
-0.0266074389,
0.0286921337,
-0.0371264219,
0.0118186874,
-0.0338396244,
0.0027120048,
0.0081318291,
-0.0316318423,
0.0162046682,
-0.0060382215,
-0.0121353166,
-0.0199309122,
0.0337589756,
-0.0364392512,
-0.0425413512,
0.0155628966,
-0.0362819768,
-0.0377125777,
-0.0595809817,
0.0352890342,
-0.026118556,
-0.0168376826,
0.0211175941,
0.0640061647,
0.0070197382,
-0.0181675628,
0.0039423918,
-0.0787921026,
-0.0089585949,
-0.0107520232,
-0.0540451035,
-0.0492697991,
0.0349685363,
0.0500776134,
-0.0291801244,
-0.0273437556,
0.0805352032,
0.045980271,
0.0441535413,
0.0621338263,
0.009835992,
-0.0449299663,
0.0690178722,
0.0049638492,
-0.0263609532,
-0.0359681249,
0.0256330259,
0.0214413777,
0.0115411151,
0.0625056922,
0.055840455,
0.0511500426,
-0.0504225232,
-0.0065432107,
0.0984530672,
0.022134982,
-0.0043509221,
0.019859191,
-0.015035064,
-0.0116446689,
-0.0198737197,
-0.0368617922,
0.018593641,
-0.020466391,
-0.0251968019,
0.0176245179,
-0.0002586796,
0.0024522666,
-0.025778804,
-0.0283303354,
0.0201708376,
0.0077043576,
0.0241549667,
-0.0313870683,
0.0109792985,
-0.0093219839,
-0.0176324099,
-0.0392584503,
-0.0079873297,
0.0126387617,
0.0459894761,
0.0101273675,
0.0377093852,
-0.0091792028,
0.030397607,
-0.0213505756,
0.0091246907,
-0.0345452279,
0.0141409189,
0.0294901654,
-0.073501803,
0.0099206865,
-0.0007345328,
-0.043998111,
0.006296379,
0.0128589775,
-0.0336000845,
-0.0378629975,
-0.0483253486,
-0.024514569,
-0.004133909,
0.0005772101,
-0.0094215497,
-0.0218359958,
0.0262569357,
0.0529240035,
-0.0361691788,
0.018461002,
-0.0100355335,
2.579e-7,
0.010655012,
0.0235594865,
0.0009846023,
-0.0227826741,
-0.0229772739,
0.0108300541,
0.0028791218,
-0.011762213,
-0.0128172925,
0.038727764,
0.0016705241,
0.0152011337,
-0.0034141452,
0.0424707942,
-0.0397142246,
-0.0178760737,
-0.0227811411,
0.0378510915,
-0.0397162065,
0.016055664,
0.0624194145,
-0.0219065454,
0.0245668497,
-0.048314441,
0.0024130102,
-0.068172574,
0.0406354181,
-0.0407420918,
-0.0225740299,
0.0308080856,
-0.0324028693,
0.0325160511,
-0.0041883443,
-0.0345653743,
-0.0558967032,
-0.0093258647,
-0.019974241,
0.019177543,
0.0131762568,
-0.0155704916,
0.0209629629,
0.0242714882,
-0.0206489544,
-0.0409313738,
-0.0031901544,
0.0037865029,
0.0307455119,
0.0365847684,
0.0196502693,
0.018749984,
0.0049606524,
-0.0403623059,
-0.0027664509,
-0.0047023701,
-0.0250647869,
0.0188071616,
-0.0140770543,
-0.0470993817,
-0.0274854787,
0.0143663539,
-0.0261983611,
0.0197403599,
-0.069609113,
-0.0459218584,
-0.0693289265,
-0.0233866498,
-0.0001129051,
1.93120222e-34,
-0.0272161532,
-0.0086997403,
0.0079611558,
0.0346094929,
0.0187878665,
0.0182923451,
0.0294818264,
0.046308957,
0.0173551813,
-0.017085515,
-0.0541885234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.07326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.07326v1 | AI Text-to-Behavior: A Study In Steerability | 2023-08-07T18:14:24 | 2023-08-07T18:14:24 | David Noever, Sam Hyams | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The research explores the steerability of Large Language Models (LLMs),
particularly OpenAI's ChatGPT iterations. By employing a behavioral psychology
framework called OCEAN (Openness, Conscientiousness, Extroversion,
Agreeableness, Neuroticism), we quantitatively gauged the model's
responsiveness to tailored prompts. When asked to generate text mimicking an
extroverted personality, OCEAN scored the language alignment to that behavioral
trait. In our analysis, while "openness" presented linguistic ambiguity,
"conscientiousness" and "neuroticism" were distinctly evoked in the OCEAN
framework, with "extroversion" and "agreeableness" showcasing a notable overlap
yet distinct separation from other traits. Our findings underscore GPT's
versatility and ability to discern and adapt to nuanced instructions.
Furthermore, historical figure simulations highlighted the LLM's capacity to
internalize and project instructible personas, precisely replicating their
philosophies and dialogic styles. However, the rapid advancements in LLM
capabilities and the opaque nature of some training techniques make metric
proposals degrade rapidly. Our research emphasizes a quantitative role to
describe steerability in LLMs, presenting both its promise and areas for
further refinement in aligning its progress to human intentions. | [
0.0600542463,
0.0447800569,
-0.0553956553,
0.0111474097,
-0.0491065234,
0.0084371502,
-0.0325652286,
-0.0075337049,
-0.0147903869,
-0.008586973,
-0.0632619932,
-0.0108297197,
-0.002796731,
0.0480332971,
0.0132694915,
-0.0425662883,
0.0394607894,
0.0040584826,
0.0227351338,
0.0142185213,
-0.0174563155,
0.0303947274,
0.0022896375,
0.0500989407,
0.0183441024,
-0.0153231071,
-0.0320358686,
-0.0281127617,
0.0056754868,
-0.0030050264,
0.0148064569,
0.0169461556,
0.0263610147,
0.0237405282,
0.0000022183,
-0.0535490364,
0.0067859236,
-0.0003386206,
0.0332931578,
-0.0006929068,
0.0815241709,
0.0121673923,
-0.001024104,
0.0177375823,
-0.0646033064,
0.0295214448,
0.0508215725,
0.0591742955,
0.0693594366,
0.0710544884,
0.0030369945,
-0.0154494373,
0.0271868464,
0.0216458701,
0.0010607286,
0.0189610422,
-0.014349319,
-0.04557864,
-0.0167459361,
0.026235301,
-0.0165870599,
0.0373423845,
0.0236132424,
-0.008678983,
-0.0034210824,
0.0149220927,
-0.0271471888,
-0.0495025478,
-0.0175906718,
0.0511083156,
0.0459679551,
-0.0098375082,
0.0013583689,
-0.0186738539,
0.0048141885,
-0.0097462675,
0.0036399725,
0.0302970987,
0.0200792067,
0.0035033133,
-0.0051549803,
-0.0011320182,
-0.0060182619,
0.0095016854,
-0.0215066001,
0.0657890514,
-0.0235601515,
-0.0204502288,
0.0291923732,
0.0031135636,
0.0323767401,
-0.0596472248,
-0.0073264753,
0.0502139106,
-0.0195502564,
0.0462839156,
-0.0358621143,
-0.0043261647,
0.015887389,
-0.0463430099,
0.0421776213,
0.0478331819,
-0.0162448213,
-0.0047032959,
0.0410409831,
0.0436229333,
0.0047088908,
0.0541199557,
-0.0409612432,
0.0055519482,
-0.0547543541,
-0.0273118094,
-0.0186116118,
-0.0147664743,
0.0355202518,
-0.0548414104,
-0.0278315861,
0.02332942,
-0.0234829821,
-0.0178843271,
0.001686174,
-0.0064355629,
-0.0252062306,
0.0204708111,
-0.0670421124,
0.0097152162,
-0.0362644084,
0.0162251312,
0.0177232251,
-0.0020926881,
0.0225270782,
0.0320451558,
-0.0443838201,
-0.018291492,
0.0179664548,
0.0622849949,
-0.0243164655,
-0.0359874405,
-0.0525180772,
-0.0005915008,
-0.0250819288,
-0.0925985873,
0.0300939828,
-0.0129457107,
0.0208852347,
0.0116510987,
-0.0346310176,
-0.0593590811,
-0.0111339325,
0.0144768683,
-0.0130681591,
0.0421084538,
0.0079710744,
0.0300984215,
0.044856362,
0.0008936683,
-0.0004835227,
0.0545152985,
0.0574947782,
0.0172867998,
0.0188998133,
-0.0003678053,
0.0170519296,
0.0175018292,
0.0197960753,
0.0262766741,
-0.0077377483,
-0.0028549281,
0.0010027817,
0.0311913136,
0.0652465299,
0.0650019273,
0.0012761073,
-0.0105102276,
0.0814536437,
0.0656843185,
0.0141257541,
0.0309450533,
0.0454918407,
0.0310074724,
0.0229137689,
0.006246848,
-0.0331478603,
0.0427135453,
0.0134134926,
0.0127355969,
-0.0152512221,
0.0079960581,
-0.0120842885,
-0.0600640364,
-0.0012400141,
-0.0189514104,
0.0610220432,
-0.0254125781,
-0.0133307865,
-0.000269969,
-0.0180943515,
-0.0430193953,
0.015500254,
-0.0798009187,
-0.0240456071,
-0.0774117932,
0.0334162936,
0.0606702827,
-0.0008699822,
0.0004825235,
-0.00077979,
0.0039784126,
-0.0258332659,
0.0834230259,
0.0593592227,
-0.0014796325,
-0.0031655545,
-0.0373125859,
0.031149568,
-0.0234961975,
-0.0082329065,
0.0109350448,
0.0114138424,
0.0467720367,
-0.0270235687,
0.0146320984,
-0.0307601709,
0.0529999211,
-0.0652931258,
-0.0217279661,
-0.0173855368,
0.0115012536,
0.044429075,
-0.0075570634,
-0.007307136,
0.0004744296,
-0.0067310263,
0.0204966106,
-0.0335963033,
0.0471862704,
-0.0159461796,
0.060746219,
-0.0045687039,
-0.0207347982,
-0.0104732076,
-0.0131388772,
0.0062979604,
-0.0129006281,
0.0013126148,
-0.034919925,
0.0424140431,
-0.0240844805,
0.0216443483,
-0.0322765186,
-0.000613197,
-0.0092812339,
0.0223778933,
-0.0159019232,
-0.033880353,
0.0145583721,
0.003533338,
0.0203273278,
-0.026199853,
-0.0233084355,
0.0130002219,
0.0160856359,
0.0347895622,
0.0185037795,
0.0173697937,
-0.0681683123,
-0.0826572925,
-0.0657358617,
-0.0207435135,
0.0129564051,
-0.0049908622,
0.0146387322,
-0.0517116487,
-0.0208487567,
0.0392993204,
-0.0438000113,
0.0234646928,
-0.0019000528,
0.0111245653,
0.0613126494,
0.0095783276,
-0.0285295565,
-0.0378321558,
0.0276939385,
-0.0167352892,
-0.0006554184,
-0.0113706328,
0.050390549,
-0.0741841644,
0.0486176312,
-0.0697051138,
-0.0066961711,
-0.0437770411,
-0.0752599463,
0.0630824417,
0.0353712887,
0.0266733654,
0.0901047364,
0.0576279126,
0.0584117435,
0.0423752852,
0.0190311614,
-0.0403595269,
0.0130145457,
-0.02458065,
-0.039255932,
-0.0022358855,
-0.0601862632,
0.0209164917,
0.0343123451,
0.0001246294,
0.0322297961,
-0.0740987659,
0.0372885577,
-0.0027201097,
-0.0549236089,
0.0325754769,
0.0069097686,
-0.0299253091,
0.0450917967,
0.0195038393,
-0.0640327185,
0.0688817427,
-0.0119773811,
-0.0007025306,
-0.0381874628,
-0.0338399895,
-0.0173265859,
0.0835284367,
-0.0280459803,
0.0188092384,
0.0778482333,
0.004587281,
-0.0539386831,
-0.03641022,
-0.0089159776,
-0.0156886149,
0.0760340691,
-0.018142961,
-0.0185983256,
0.0509340875,
-0.0023983219,
-0.0258624647,
-0.0208424162,
-0.0089637395,
-0.0036111197,
0.0611450598,
-0.0367695428,
-0.0566526018,
-0.0234120861,
0.0474016666,
-0.0041397572,
-0.0254701506,
-0.0278364606,
-0.0081446273,
-0.074774906,
0.0620171539,
0.0414348766,
0.0077833319,
-0.0505703762,
-0.0078524854,
0.0171211138,
-0.0659871548,
-0.0190983117,
-0.0220437441,
-0.0213657655,
-0.007659548,
-0.0007169513,
-0.0198769737,
0.0370232835,
0.0718126222,
-0.0065021878,
-0.029096134,
0.0857775062,
0.0232307389,
-0.0301605724,
0.0092838109,
-0.010164558,
0.0681776553,
0.0219004378,
0.0443387628,
-0.0206824355,
0.0061928327,
-0.0254802909,
0.0387206003,
-0.0466154069,
-0.0074298447,
-0.0310787633,
-0.0871990398,
0.0259084553,
-0.0029418152,
-0.0689423084,
0.0080173491,
-0.0060446225,
-0.0054849312,
0.0067191469,
0.0368976891,
-0.0142237442,
0.0077537689,
-0.0206827689,
-0.017394118,
-0.0210406762,
0.0051588356,
0.0351529121,
-0.0381231122,
0.0695874915,
0.0311922543,
0.0500677377,
0.00581558,
-0.0529196337,
-0.0375175923,
0.0105754007,
0.0327603742,
0.0207322184,
0.0543675348,
-0.0364007913,
0.0267293416,
-0.0502974875,
0.0022628792,
-0.0024052444,
0.0014828817,
0.0210816469,
0.0561072193,
-0.0302654188,
-0.0370267779,
-0.0431724861,
0.035715051,
0.0429231822,
0.067028746,
0.010804994,
-0.0961529315,
-0.0265741162,
-0.0081197945,
0.0140535273,
0.018686058,
-0.0704946443,
-0.0119737163,
-0.0133130318,
-0.0295986217,
-0.0652973279,
-0.0813022628,
-0.0343231298,
0.0317579657,
0.0228104386,
-0.0568721965,
0.0172339138,
-0.0046470524,
0.0039333263,
0.0044760727,
0.0100391032,
0.0266908202,
-0.069544673,
-0.031930387,
0.0299381856,
-0.0634486079,
0.0133038564,
0.0334454104,
-0.0018926791,
-0.0663120002,
0.0278593767,
0.0561836809,
0.0341588706,
-0.0106255924,
0.0369632877,
-0.0070002945,
-0.011154185,
0.0354023091,
-0.0069687595,
0.0667942539,
0.0136845214,
0.065553613,
-0.0019383148,
0.0186529197,
-0.0019100629,
0.0218623243,
-0.0188513398,
-0.0107271755,
-0.008725496,
-0.0825318322,
0.0105302678,
0.0182984564,
0.0074801734,
-0.0180402678,
-0.0165219605,
-0.0232791565,
-0.0391630828,
-0.0347686559,
-0.0137079824,
-0.0277196467,
-0.0627285987,
0.0159250647,
0.0228671748,
-0.0050853137,
0.0020956374,
-0.0324066505,
0.0126819927,
-0.0094124842,
-0.0080414498,
0.0121715469,
0.0663389042,
-0.0550365336,
0.0164077412,
-0.0386143029,
0.021130722,
-0.0335509256,
0.0504257232,
0.0200863946,
0.1078676805,
0.0328368954,
-0.004266805,
-0.0025394161,
0.0657798201,
-0.061352957,
-0.0433355682,
0.0230631419,
0.0267729051,
-0.0197454132,
0.0126752052,
0.0580981709,
-0.0713744983,
0.0202673618,
0.001495118,
0.0469744392,
0.0006664356,
-0.0480421446,
0.0142391985,
-0.0091093574,
-0.0161187034,
-0.0481028184,
0.0061431858,
-0.0425350741,
0.0165653042,
-0.019402571,
0.0034567942,
-0.0260582827,
-0.0194004215,
0.0330484658,
0.010289629,
-0.0020916506,
-0.0040959725,
-0.0625016838,
-0.0545565486,
0.0275719948,
0.0158691425,
0.0025856493,
-0.075172022,
0.0241238941,
0.0597120486,
-0.0141606908,
-0.0290492196,
-0.0307446625,
0.0032942893,
-0.0573105291,
0.0117103597,
-0.0415679254,
-6.013452573e-33,
-0.0525172167,
-0.0217810366,
0.0405184031,
0.0224763639,
-0.0640912503,
-0.0457239076,
-0.0327226706,
0.0471903458,
-0.057731539,
-0.0081773279,
-0.0248202886,
0.0146973431,
-0.0060047274,
-0.0374812782,
0.0087099988,
0.0097288731,
0.0017214998,
-0.0309630111,
-0.0605619736,
-0.0020283896,
0.0318694301,
-0.0221619979,
0.0300975647,
-0.1084849313,
0.0316663831,
-0.0172504131,
-0.0317879617,
-0.0078105046,
-0.016506562,
0.0299086273,
-0.0091872038,
0.0225357674,
0.0087948889,
0.0064990171,
0.0042049517,
0.0077584032,
0.0161880814,
-0.0472330227,
0.0220387019,
0.0010898074,
-0.0423710942,
-0.033647079,
0.0227733571,
-0.037110053,
-0.0594616719,
-0.0203457475,
0.0297005568,
0.0046680016,
0.026766032,
0.0718819499,
-0.0833988935,
-0.0238308571,
-0.0055728108,
-0.0550926961,
-0.0259281211,
0.0256314259,
-0.0284892842,
-0.0051226914,
-0.0768600479,
0.0381081253,
-0.0149164349,
-0.0172375347,
0.0581239015,
0.0296689719,
0.0159168299,
0.052997753,
0.0435350165,
0.0620211996,
-0.050056275,
-0.0396934152,
0.0720220208,
0.0326245725,
0.0202772263,
0.0413591862,
-0.0297755208,
-0.0675999597,
0.0371750519,
0.0140338419,
0.0595075823,
-0.0328911282,
0.0296483394,
0.0139208753,
-0.0470564105,
-0.0367278904,
-0.005135268,
-0.0114449104,
-0.0130197788,
-0.0490969159,
0.0296005029,
-0.0283240844,
0.0141299618,
-0.0458963066,
0.0311647784,
-0.0246549472,
0.0206165109,
0.0182361547,
-0.08274699,
0.057851322,
-0.0043403981,
0.0084250942,
-0.0765189677,
-0.0308609605,
-0.0057573649,
0.0419538766,
0.0321479402,
0.0416960195,
0.0027037307,
0.0504579954,
-0.0409809873,
-0.0165053774,
0.015281505,
0.031314712,
0.0001689585,
-0.0036406785,
-0.0092199091,
0.0042173369,
-0.0118979812,
0.0421509705,
0.0009155881,
-0.0038139124,
-0.0715280697,
-0.0321278609,
0.016878143,
-0.0017343647,
-0.0358887315,
0.0178990625,
-0.034694422,
0.0402569324,
-0.001844422,
-0.0670923218,
-0.0095364675,
0.0339111052,
2.988e-7,
-0.0026874447,
0.0423165299,
-0.0184673239,
0.0666353032,
0.0146742575,
0.0493529439,
-0.0320867226,
0.0131562753,
0.0364082493,
-0.0448730625,
0.0227558408,
0.0171540994,
0.0360926911,
0.0063460912,
-0.041961804,
0.018968489,
-0.0404564254,
0.0159500316,
-0.0475898348,
0.0382900275,
0.0650382489,
0.054913532,
0.0091816466,
-0.0001511548,
-0.0000793261,
0.0179205108,
0.0528596565,
-0.0324300192,
0.0342313983,
0.0152295372,
-0.0135511318,
-0.0130588207,
-0.0105323764,
0.0249910913,
0.006378924,
0.0117638875,
-0.0158890225,
0.0925312713,
-0.0158732049,
-0.0299794395,
0.0320411325,
0.0154593708,
-0.0384529717,
-0.0858338252,
0.0116648972,
-0.0680715293,
-0.0500402041,
-0.0242548659,
0.0230652262,
-0.0163895767,
0.0351829082,
-0.0151434699,
-0.0086643817,
0.0246009361,
0.0043228613,
-0.0117745474,
0.0076192408,
-0.0343522578,
0.0138834901,
-0.054925967,
-0.0245916247,
-0.0525303707,
-0.0566570275,
0.0456632301,
0.0333101936,
-0.0569660477,
0.0223116595,
2.42144719e-34,
-0.0140910558,
-0.0085719638,
0.0299425218,
-0.0120771853,
0.0676683336,
0.0270675216,
0.0772196203,
0.0373551436,
0.0315677486,
-0.0677206144,
-0.0180177428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03853v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03853v3 | CORAL: Expert-Curated medical Oncology Reports to Advance Language Model Inference | 2023-08-07T18:03:10 | 2024-01-11T16:45:56 | Madhumita Sushil, Vanessa E. Kennedy, Divneet Mandair, Brenda Y. Miao, Travis Zack, Atul J. Butte | cs.CL | cs.CL | Both medical care and observational studies in oncology require a thorough
understanding of a patient's disease progression and treatment history, often
elaborately documented in clinical notes. Despite their vital role, no current
oncology information representation and annotation schema fully encapsulates
the diversity of information recorded within these notes. Although large
language models (LLMs) have recently exhibited impressive performance on
various medical natural language processing tasks, due to the current lack of
comprehensively annotated oncology datasets, an extensive evaluation of LLMs in
extracting and reasoning with the complex rhetoric in oncology notes remains
understudied. We developed a detailed schema for annotating textual oncology
information, encompassing patient characteristics, tumor characteristics,
tests, treatments, and temporality. Using a corpus of 40 de-identified breast
and pancreatic cancer progress notes at University of California, San
Francisco, we applied this schema to assess the zero-shot abilities of three
recent LLMs (GPT-4, GPT-3.5-turbo, and FLAN-UL2) to extract detailed
oncological history from two narrative sections of clinical progress notes. Our
team annotated 9028 entities, 9986 modifiers, and 5312 relationships. The GPT-4
model exhibited overall best performance, with an average BLEU score of 0.73,
an average ROUGE score of 0.72, an exact-match F1-score of 0.51, and an average
accuracy of 68% on complex tasks (expert manual evaluation on subset). Notably,
it was proficient in tumor characteristic and medication extraction, and
demonstrated superior performance in relational inference like adverse event
detection. However, further improvements are needed before using it to reliably
extract important facts from cancer progress notes needed for clinical
research, complex population management, and documenting quality patient care. | [
0.0699742958,
0.0828381404,
0.0058843251,
-0.0141894119,
-0.0349342935,
0.0305565316,
-0.0197242349,
-0.0039664642,
-0.0050641904,
-0.029633984,
0.0004942011,
-0.0530287363,
-0.0230865199,
0.011529129,
-0.0164483432,
-0.0455340706,
0.0092486683,
0.0098814126,
0.0541478433,
0.0420090593,
-0.0005994808,
0.0480167493,
-0.0223130994,
0.035708379,
-0.0073152641,
0.0056733657,
0.0639322624,
-0.0181955714,
-0.0017790813,
-0.0886867344,
-0.0077632205,
0.0063648731,
-0.0347447731,
0.0206231866,
0.000001918,
-0.0796954706,
-0.0201407336,
0.020706173,
-0.0193758998,
-0.0191308204,
0.0561484471,
-0.0696122423,
0.0037378469,
-0.0040382594,
-0.0208396204,
-0.0432050452,
-0.011920331,
0.0577869304,
0.0146274576,
0.0958646312,
-0.0242734067,
-0.0238597207,
0.0459260456,
-0.0079593975,
0.0031972362,
-0.0213929098,
0.0449944809,
0.022410959,
0.0288111642,
-0.0220779125,
0.0540384836,
0.0660167262,
-0.0231544264,
0.0094186179,
-0.0056463862,
0.0565515943,
-0.0039574257,
-0.0043348991,
0.0225880686,
0.0505274534,
0.0077812583,
0.0047580097,
0.0527378432,
-0.0073577291,
-0.0105443811,
0.023731349,
-0.0210286621,
0.0176162105,
-0.0575206205,
0.0013107167,
0.0170842931,
-0.0072934274,
0.0130382581,
0.0125766397,
-0.0017916472,
0.0169701874,
-0.0051090424,
0.0079641994,
-0.0014985728,
0.0046124593,
-0.0069559123,
-0.0349295847,
0.0590295345,
0.0233840775,
-0.0237038918,
0.0517174564,
-0.0061136689,
-0.0300072711,
0.0783063397,
-0.0867080763,
-0.0232705809,
-0.001417856,
-0.0256335922,
0.0478210524,
0.0069909035,
-0.0210242346,
-0.0244514477,
0.0203330573,
-0.0163717549,
-0.0243394505,
-0.0355977006,
-0.0104812384,
-0.0012879086,
0.0312988609,
0.011982034,
0.0100845164,
-0.050476741,
-0.0140841138,
0.0125936223,
0.0277780145,
0.0439398587,
0.0115803517,
-0.0308038089,
0.0062546195,
-0.0146708768,
0.0043282686,
0.001147977,
0.0022513338,
-0.0200956576,
-0.0524359234,
0.0293451939,
-0.0073806895,
0.0158613343,
-0.0492976792,
-0.0022717149,
0.0594562553,
0.0369016752,
-0.0205457043,
0.0129784103,
-0.0408255868,
-0.0239283741,
-0.050166104,
-0.0089577595,
-0.05896331,
0.0286496524,
0.0242740698,
-0.0071228575,
-0.0622178651,
0.0174338724,
-0.0047490713,
-0.0725181922,
0.0471456014,
-0.0344060175,
-0.0156667084,
0.0360573679,
0.029822411,
0.0052126176,
0.023845667,
0.0413409546,
-0.0327438489,
-0.0089014051,
0.0028602607,
-0.0092848269,
0.0077541717,
0.0174911059,
-0.0575144403,
0.0054255519,
0.0289166179,
-0.0215410646,
0.0677159056,
-0.0205463301,
0.0748338327,
-0.0065324986,
-0.0362290926,
0.0270878319,
0.0502985083,
0.0169539899,
0.0509810112,
0.0268609338,
-0.0147262588,
0.0164471902,
-0.0194053333,
-0.0446460284,
-0.0038711259,
-0.0077343252,
0.0115408786,
-0.0219015405,
-0.0035825446,
0.0071761981,
-0.0477156267,
-0.0526224896,
0.0109045049,
-0.0313530043,
-0.0285266358,
0.0477331243,
-0.0320184305,
-0.034244705,
0.0026592123,
0.0707512125,
-0.0089782719,
-0.011949501,
-0.0123344921,
-0.0229217745,
0.0914448351,
0.0528863966,
-0.0546566285,
-0.0702668577,
-0.0172228739,
-0.0105990181,
0.0113408342,
-0.0041019022,
-0.0079161432,
-0.0128550697,
0.0135570727,
0.0179566666,
0.0275325831,
0.0146844862,
-0.0263357535,
0.0005207576,
0.017207453,
-0.0226113722,
-0.0102156773,
-0.0285931509,
0.0639713109,
-0.0269570332,
-0.0455274209,
-0.0362692699,
-0.0260680038,
0.0271579381,
0.0140194939,
-0.0181174241,
0.0310893804,
0.0180397313,
-0.0402280688,
-0.0450504124,
0.0388426296,
-0.0283068158,
-0.0232059378,
0.02854608,
-0.0179687925,
-0.0211257637,
-0.0502505936,
-0.0316162035,
0.0101289293,
-0.0176885594,
-0.009987969,
0.0104845837,
0.0097441729,
0.0031295235,
0.0645078197,
-0.0025250919,
-0.0134641128,
0.0571659803,
-0.0390218757,
-0.0241095051,
0.0025143195,
-0.0700003728,
-0.0078426572,
-0.0177486725,
-0.028723035,
0.0229208004,
0.0284781698,
-0.0189476088,
-0.0225975625,
-0.0211735498,
-0.0247881431,
-0.0032054172,
-0.1303192079,
0.0117455786,
-0.0059413589,
0.0429204851,
0.0319376998,
0.0172328409,
-0.0140632298,
-0.0162797999,
-0.059265811,
-0.0497308485,
0.010595195,
0.0209208429,
0.0504506901,
0.0589531101,
0.0085615814,
-0.0634568334,
-0.0042389664,
-0.0663091019,
0.0351977274,
0.0332826339,
-0.0613961592,
0.00771316,
0.0095519545,
-0.0352720432,
0.0139057813,
0.0075121778,
0.0019210009,
0.0115214754,
-0.0435746536,
-0.0311467834,
0.0572072417,
0.0096577564,
0.0497202985,
0.0220316313,
-0.0154045401,
-0.0263056085,
0.0073726363,
-0.0387215167,
-0.0147524578,
-0.0145547977,
-0.038380079,
-0.0187039208,
0.067993395,
0.0068983631,
0.0039964584,
-0.0380558223,
-0.0381890722,
-0.0148638552,
0.0377086289,
0.0022840358,
0.0360870846,
-0.0158454254,
-0.0182548631,
-0.0123047456,
-0.0000839724,
0.1207765639,
-0.0193831269,
0.0454862453,
-0.0575067811,
-0.0073537496,
-0.0218741335,
0.0612640083,
-0.0000012418,
-0.0145068131,
0.0316419713,
0.0011021269,
0.023400059,
-0.0124895154,
0.0255222227,
-0.0425342992,
0.0649624467,
-0.0363174863,
0.0645810887,
0.0127466144,
0.0026556689,
-0.0274965297,
-0.0465486571,
-0.0468866043,
0.0178707186,
0.0018470039,
-0.0013207601,
-0.0466570966,
0.019829914,
-0.0253711678,
0.0963718966,
0.0190936774,
-0.0174083821,
-0.0067091584,
-0.0005584633,
0.0483344384,
0.0027657899,
-0.0194692183,
-0.0060267542,
0.031341482,
0.0578182712,
-0.013121658,
0.0060645854,
0.0161466524,
-0.0100456569,
-0.0150442095,
-0.0509091765,
-0.002970434,
0.0139526734,
0.0229478236,
-0.0826370195,
-0.0198068731,
0.1201801896,
0.0234697815,
-0.0338877067,
0.0285852738,
0.0405671522,
-0.0262979604,
-0.0265634824,
0.0280582253,
-0.0777254999,
-0.0144635672,
-0.0324080996,
-0.0211827587,
-0.0224525444,
-0.0604282655,
0.0034288375,
-0.0284762885,
-0.0040553161,
-0.0159006231,
-0.0373403989,
0.0182756297,
-0.0379710495,
-0.001716397,
-0.0337478481,
-0.0299277324,
-0.0067335349,
0.0014458986,
-0.0219451506,
0.012724597,
-0.0726951659,
-0.0953189731,
0.01561091,
-0.0353887565,
0.0368915536,
0.018122362,
0.0446351096,
-0.0181163847,
0.0311558116,
-0.0104925921,
0.0200577844,
0.005019072,
0.0173043106,
0.0859730616,
-0.0181490779,
0.0129703861,
-0.0460378937,
0.024494037,
-0.0093379468,
-0.014656987,
-0.0026573341,
0.0784481987,
-0.0479144007,
-0.0119368378,
-0.0269074924,
0.0195161439,
0.01839903,
0.0416931435,
-0.021009123,
0.0210914835,
-0.0348350294,
0.0045960746,
0.0395174772,
0.0082812319,
-0.0091489144,
0.033077918,
-0.0371341556,
-0.0167752896,
-0.0660387725,
-0.0582932234,
0.0469951108,
-0.0422294214,
0.0176504496,
0.0596633479,
0.0080290306,
-0.0147080971,
-0.0569285005,
0.0855707005,
0.0185958669,
0.0035183514,
-0.0158418007,
-0.077395156,
0.0470975973,
0.0024319063,
0.0048077651,
0.0266771242,
-0.0404421017,
-0.0085583366,
-0.0357155278,
-0.0018162098,
0.0186444893,
0.0121764643,
-0.0063230703,
-0.0507009961,
0.0217956286,
0.0162006132,
-0.061039865,
-0.0402226597,
-0.0275667943,
0.010382764,
0.0177249201,
0.0182848051,
-0.0004563106,
0.0253868569,
-0.0114011727,
0.0480843857,
-0.0275990181,
-0.0026771326,
0.0345862582,
0.0242962241,
0.0530565009,
-0.004187258,
-0.0242780261,
-0.0337155089,
0.0067354124,
-0.0668977946,
0.0023738432,
-0.0137903066,
-0.0041341656,
0.0054555209,
0.0038483338,
-0.052448269,
0.0162170716,
-0.0562370867,
-0.0094447555,
-0.0694811046,
0.0456174612,
0.0336687639,
-0.0173067413,
0.0365472138,
-0.0402233079,
-0.0132139567,
-0.0207757317,
-0.0113219786,
0.006647334,
-0.0162033793,
0.005618351,
0.0129651735,
0.0272358097,
-0.0042485036,
0.0168099701,
-0.0625530034,
-0.007270033,
-0.0355023406,
0.0186678041,
0.0483845435,
-0.0286582913,
0.0761991814,
-0.0528655499,
0.0125439018,
-0.0199998785,
0.0357146449,
-0.0265861712,
0.0481099449,
0.0480085425,
0.025041068,
-0.0068746288,
-0.0256117862,
0.0505688637,
0.0380176753,
0.0634119436,
-0.0036017275,
-0.0237727966,
-0.0413622744,
-0.0368770882,
-0.003872694,
0.0104466546,
-0.0570352264,
0.0063716276,
-0.0822151452,
-0.0142244631,
0.0732474476,
-0.0205036271,
-0.0575531125,
-0.030145349,
0.0234271288,
0.0357294865,
0.0235765334,
-0.0530876443,
-0.0626910925,
0.0452635996,
0.0116553688,
-0.0252631996,
0.0082679978,
-5.990041501e-33,
-0.0012462788,
-0.0289576482,
0.0241135284,
-0.0083352206,
-0.0004459466,
0.0352128521,
-0.0505187623,
-0.0256397147,
0.0113629643,
0.043776758,
-0.0203238744,
0.0223944467,
0.002892504,
0.0279351696,
-0.012743867,
-0.0248956587,
0.0405486897,
-0.0009826324,
-0.0267892387,
0.0074717375,
0.0085236616,
0.0890967026,
0.0381630734,
-0.1164492369,
0.0564006269,
0.0226444565,
0.0357382409,
-0.013128032,
-0.0225764755,
0.0514324605,
-0.0560363457,
0.0337785445,
0.0429960452,
0.007584922,
0.0009766556,
-0.0442682654,
-0.0914772004,
-0.0114923883,
0.0353560038,
-0.0111325383,
-0.0219279882,
-0.0121695194,
0.0698184147,
-0.0055128094,
0.0007546665,
-0.0134504158,
0.0431150794,
-0.0269667599,
-0.0130642308,
-0.03056865,
-0.0460840501,
0.0817288756,
0.0228683613,
0.0273530595,
0.0231723376,
-0.0339524485,
-0.0373006761,
0.0490283668,
-0.0022831715,
-0.0276346523,
-0.0025625818,
0.0387185104,
-0.0040669809,
-0.0453279279,
-0.0197258033,
0.0762899518,
0.0032773376,
0.0090595111,
-0.0462798811,
0.0401913971,
-0.0416438915,
0.0353122391,
-0.0071159271,
0.0145181604,
0.0011062094,
-0.0017648265,
-0.0939091668,
0.0109646255,
-0.0301463902,
0.0206341781,
0.0307942014,
-0.0217570197,
-0.0400189981,
0.0168451797,
-0.022741355,
0.0046965028,
0.004973758,
-0.0096325139,
-0.0075583276,
-0.0138229141,
0.0098128757,
0.0512015671,
-0.015906645,
0.0080257943,
-0.028672656,
-0.0023281346,
0.0563521124,
0.0158342607,
-0.0422315598,
0.0162112564,
-0.0468072295,
-0.0269174557,
0.0148882624,
-0.0368439108,
0.0389837176,
0.0063375277,
0.0540681519,
-0.0385914929,
-0.03482382,
-0.0348661877,
-0.0082245721,
0.00029478,
-0.0305095036,
0.036079593,
0.0370227247,
0.0479403548,
0.0169628244,
0.0821201056,
0.0282508712,
0.0093309311,
-0.0079243472,
-0.037738096,
0.0217159539,
-0.0126161175,
-0.0453308746,
0.0086600976,
0.0012331954,
0.0131852916,
0.0213169456,
-0.0589955226,
0.0163416769,
0.0236229897,
2.755e-7,
0.1489624083,
0.0626231655,
0.035511069,
-0.0465243235,
0.0383070111,
-0.0245090313,
-0.0069932966,
-0.0014254567,
0.004641504,
-0.0203139726,
0.034853816,
0.0333176255,
0.0352353342,
0.04342537,
-0.0425245166,
-0.0432139114,
-0.0832265764,
-0.0678818002,
-0.0448447764,
0.0042513171,
0.0923133567,
0.0604949482,
-0.0131912278,
-0.0171425194,
0.0038644015,
0.0084087551,
0.0291729216,
-0.0612779818,
-0.0122450283,
0.0453577265,
0.0132026002,
0.0092498586,
0.0157504529,
0.0726427287,
0.0082303844,
0.0060182121,
0.0019242455,
0.1061793268,
-0.0519978441,
0.0158400722,
0.0351887234,
-0.0353122763,
0.0162830818,
-0.0132358316,
0.0590085983,
-0.0190622788,
-0.0573345982,
-0.00957138,
0.0006937603,
-0.0010513695,
0.0346536711,
-0.0057076351,
-0.0500903577,
0.0410746709,
0.0188686531,
0.0131159155,
-0.0493479297,
-0.0766545236,
-0.0079697575,
0.0582658313,
-0.0374328047,
-0.0235872008,
0.0304569509,
-0.038173575,
0.0061264401,
-0.0473246612,
0.0392903462,
2.282100371e-34,
0.0293571819,
0.0334755778,
-0.0043441863,
0.0438553989,
0.0447385572,
0.0158178881,
0.0183442589,
0.0040112869,
-0.0024600935,
-0.073006466,
0.0049777105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03742v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03742v2 | Training BERT Models to Carry Over a Coding System Developed on One Corpus to Another | 2023-08-07T17:46:49 | 2024-03-26T16:03:57 | Dalma Galambos, Pál Zsámboki | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes how we train BERT models to carry over a coding system
developed on the paragraphs of a Hungarian literary journal to another. The aim
of the coding system is to track trends in the perception of literary
translation around the political transformation in 1989 in Hungary. To evaluate
not only task performance but also the consistence of the annotation, moreover,
to get better predictions from an ensemble, we use 10-fold crossvalidation.
Extensive hyperparameter tuning is used to obtain the best possible results and
fair comparisons. To handle label imbalance, we use loss functions and metrics
robust to it. Evaluation of the effect of domain shift is carried out by
sampling a test set from the target domain. We establish the sample size by
estimating the bootstrapped confidence interval via simulations. This way, we
show that our models can carry over one annotation system to the target domain.
Comparisons are drawn to provide insights such as learning multilabel
correlations and confidence penalty improve resistance to domain shift, and
domain adaptation on OCR-ed text on another domain improves performance almost
to the same extent as that on the corpus under study. See our code at
https://codeberg.org/zsamboki/bert-annotator-ensemble. | [
0.0239986442,
0.033411473,
0.0230918508,
-0.0054738931,
-0.0132879466,
0.0198960323,
0.0221708342,
-0.0073444769,
-0.0257315747,
-0.0792071372,
-0.0337158777,
0.0015282525,
-0.0023467573,
-0.0472662076,
-0.0022104187,
-0.0348414145,
0.0208392646,
-0.0071976194,
-0.0028194673,
-0.0150541067,
0.0130779333,
-0.0154331028,
-0.0104514966,
0.0345695354,
0.0090607377,
0.0002988473,
0.0209598299,
0.0561549366,
0.054358352,
-0.0093336608,
0.0159779675,
0.0284559857,
0.0320629142,
0.0654323176,
0.0000015886,
-0.0617756695,
-0.063762702,
0.0214453693,
0.0453470759,
0.0007330201,
0.030417908,
-0.0300503634,
-0.0329752378,
0.0077357274,
0.014069234,
-0.0258964337,
0.0506843962,
0.0364343263,
0.0570678376,
0.0850166753,
-0.0184781495,
-0.0321339592,
-0.0001075527,
-0.0102352016,
-0.035575442,
-0.0563185588,
0.0481655225,
-0.0010079151,
-0.0342969522,
-0.0050936621,
-0.0222037137,
0.0176256057,
-0.0476497225,
-0.0179651864,
-0.0043118806,
-0.0092104105,
-0.0932642445,
-0.0090161981,
0.0053315973,
0.0086710453,
0.0203779899,
-0.0241533108,
0.0036984351,
0.0435813367,
0.0144353518,
0.049759876,
-0.0201842301,
-0.0202500932,
-0.0182638038,
0.0153959692,
0.0170698632,
0.0124883233,
0.0140221333,
-0.0028487153,
-0.0267514382,
0.0350481421,
0.035177175,
-0.0278537255,
0.0268147308,
0.0262127463,
-0.0353682637,
-0.0221816115,
0.0594887696,
0.0032372207,
0.0196275171,
0.006910102,
-0.0466859303,
-0.0668685287,
-0.0151902111,
-0.0623920597,
0.0034809601,
0.0491834544,
-0.0385795124,
0.0378383957,
-0.0157710798,
0.0522373281,
-0.0108395703,
0.0316081122,
-0.0303860027,
-0.0535432957,
-0.0811457261,
0.0372386985,
-0.0812402144,
0.0086412681,
0.0332440399,
0.0106706424,
-0.05666757,
-0.00825564,
0.0403977595,
0.0056036143,
0.0003755242,
-0.0326876827,
-0.040617682,
0.0017594685,
0.0048178574,
0.0873858184,
-0.0152021134,
0.0006819826,
-0.0154305482,
-0.0083579365,
0.0042501516,
0.0265278388,
-0.0242171548,
-0.0528527424,
0.0129837403,
0.0419549756,
-0.0010894754,
-0.0147334561,
-0.0459062159,
0.0410577506,
-0.0446383208,
-0.0248154905,
0.0372189768,
-0.040793702,
-0.0172941089,
0.0211959202,
0.0430698991,
-0.0428491533,
0.0058640041,
0.000683179,
-0.0375723019,
0.0578009337,
-0.0068601212,
-0.0211398061,
0.0503374226,
-0.025351828,
-0.0307624061,
0.0899730548,
0.0770753995,
0.0013391959,
0.0407219827,
0.0056657684,
0.003949774,
0.0534784161,
-0.0196873322,
0.0308399182,
-0.0235320274,
-0.0125241466,
0.0188343283,
0.0371961556,
0.0090199113,
0.0351069383,
-0.0226736795,
-0.0043292968,
0.0660111979,
0.018407084,
0.0391250625,
0.0307933073,
0.0185778141,
-0.0361266546,
0.0164379571,
0.0188548118,
0.0166761987,
-0.01944541,
0.0027021496,
-0.0002945142,
0.0149787748,
0.0065936628,
-0.0161206909,
0.0139807975,
-0.0112966551,
-0.0174460411,
-0.0071395589,
-0.0662097856,
0.1038271338,
0.0106669506,
-0.0477335192,
0.0326444171,
-0.0032431758,
-0.0532385781,
0.0242057629,
-0.0121042179,
-0.0164940469,
0.0228736941,
0.0542083345,
-0.0517831706,
-0.0102118617,
-0.0385732763,
0.0325190388,
0.0409310609,
0.0441259965,
-0.0192968175,
-0.0053646727,
-0.04392948,
-0.0287114028,
0.0143561242,
0.0196766816,
0.0435198024,
-0.0231826212,
0.0194574054,
-0.012314559,
-0.0653917268,
-0.02066187,
0.0371770076,
-0.026354257,
0.0028960593,
-0.0095396684,
0.0076507856,
0.0184919685,
0.0057126484,
-0.0422273204,
0.0003108267,
-0.0046383967,
-0.0502659306,
-0.0324195325,
0.014160255,
-0.0022592682,
-0.0393780023,
0.0223319456,
-0.0830579847,
0.031511087,
0.0122635271,
-0.0291710664,
-0.037502382,
0.0234470479,
-0.030573776,
0.0290635936,
-0.0321960971,
0.0455954596,
-0.0427972861,
-0.0081825685,
-0.0398116484,
0.0273167007,
0.0304326434,
0.0077322377,
0.0032721164,
-0.0312146693,
0.0582449436,
0.0174241718,
-0.0330113582,
-0.00579726,
0.0064981319,
0.0130118141,
0.0460322611,
-0.0141336014,
-0.0178921446,
-0.0372913107,
-0.0825562254,
0.0258218236,
-0.0333526991,
0.0524139218,
0.0225792266,
0.0069683362,
-0.0106798559,
-0.0166361723,
-0.013064445,
-0.0318666436,
-0.0581869781,
0.0177114084,
0.0280501544,
0.0024227484,
-0.0102755576,
-0.0086013079,
0.0191999674,
-0.0386624262,
0.0745583102,
0.0114848521,
-0.0478735268,
-0.0617973283,
0.0074028927,
-0.015829809,
0.0270712934,
0.0059137172,
-0.0335307196,
-0.0000459166,
0.0333661102,
0.0299103241,
0.0390544459,
0.0192416813,
0.03236112,
0.0322428681,
-0.0179602075,
-0.0286678765,
0.0183745772,
-0.0055576442,
-0.0000476839,
-0.0394807458,
-0.0173226036,
0.0072428025,
0.0503867008,
-0.0369870216,
-0.023232311,
-0.0634464324,
-0.0554169118,
-0.0361923315,
-0.0024025356,
0.0030240533,
-0.0050115883,
-0.0039466661,
0.0475871041,
0.0097982334,
0.0117242765,
0.0564047657,
-0.0249326043,
0.0179467835,
-0.0700889453,
0.0194580853,
-0.028280111,
0.0237023607,
-0.021893803,
0.0058354889,
0.0521860048,
-0.0281454194,
-0.0391774811,
-0.0120024318,
0.047655303,
-0.037407212,
0.0021438967,
-0.0545565858,
0.0260268543,
-0.026965905,
-0.0081273727,
-0.015069508,
-0.0372411124,
0.0024509733,
0.0285241939,
-0.0136060454,
-0.0388512686,
-0.0488054566,
0.0372477286,
-0.008652918,
0.0839639232,
-0.0148049612,
-0.0116393836,
0.0116231088,
0.0629466698,
-0.0112640029,
-0.0361632071,
-0.0316921473,
-0.0530970693,
-0.0030138816,
-0.0061242525,
-0.012950236,
0.0069918763,
-0.0515632145,
-0.0098172398,
0.0538547672,
-0.0661085695,
-0.0301716924,
-0.0539686047,
0.0530585162,
-0.0255642142,
-0.0384869315,
0.112146087,
0.0302211735,
-0.0552375354,
-0.0321132094,
-0.0252055451,
0.0399877243,
0.023123065,
0.0272748787,
-0.0726596192,
-0.0181296878,
0.0158355217,
0.0426284336,
-0.0119153829,
-0.0304253567,
-0.0073661911,
-0.1074941978,
-0.0086449226,
-0.0003206013,
-0.0367721803,
-0.0157247484,
-0.0441354811,
0.0064711883,
-0.0284639336,
-0.0144006209,
-0.0270644128,
0.0252963454,
0.0073978663,
0.0488327593,
-0.0263612308,
-0.0497380085,
-0.0113757458,
-0.0410676971,
0.0526246391,
0.0764404535,
0.0714022443,
-0.0290031619,
-0.0232983753,
-4.805e-7,
-0.0135562792,
-0.032192152,
-0.0061818613,
0.0888880938,
-0.0104707358,
-0.0208705738,
0.0388756096,
-0.0064949826,
-0.0092901792,
0.0012643086,
0.0210431386,
0.0165115874,
-0.0152879488,
0.0025310756,
0.0098131215,
0.0152073083,
0.0110118976,
0.0603783429,
0.0066123665,
-0.0498795249,
0.0156094041,
-0.02422929,
-0.0108315703,
-0.0668453053,
0.0264328122,
0.0344540365,
-0.0756251439,
-0.0671778619,
-0.0915018842,
-0.0088422783,
0.0194884557,
0.0635109991,
0.0439491011,
-0.0056079929,
0.000006697,
0.0298973545,
-0.0262355078,
0.0067596557,
-0.0199934393,
-0.0062532206,
-0.0271473695,
0.002961332,
0.0535296053,
-0.0184869803,
-0.0025101507,
-0.0068434272,
-0.0436292142,
-0.0511755161,
0.0122525962,
0.0155636845,
0.0255999211,
0.056310676,
-0.0294838399,
-0.010957907,
0.0266695842,
0.0372386687,
0.0090823732,
-0.010107629,
0.0417568684,
0.0018749803,
-0.0272205267,
0.0197793972,
-0.0256813634,
0.0314046033,
-0.0151271299,
0.0079907365,
-0.0048227967,
-0.0426179841,
0.0154163735,
-0.0153554827,
0.0659552738,
-0.0423693769,
-0.0418000109,
-0.0124578904,
0.0177587997,
-0.0069970647,
-0.0020365673,
-0.0179238319,
-0.0170259103,
0.0539893694,
-0.0357539281,
-0.0320503786,
0.0758207217,
-0.0131959561,
0.0127579169,
-0.0541878082,
0.0388879776,
-0.0156775787,
0.103221409,
-0.020544285,
-0.0025281284,
-0.0145393116,
-0.0176096279,
0.0383641124,
0.029999448,
-0.0157913528,
0.0384244993,
0.0239770431,
0.0174270943,
0.0699690804,
0.0119819129,
-0.079449743,
0.068522267,
-0.0460186228,
0.0287275165,
0.0543909408,
-0.0102141462,
0.1140243113,
-0.0059846309,
-0.0195556749,
-0.0154407257,
0.0134827727,
0.0127976798,
0.0285894498,
0.0063106925,
-0.0105626397,
0.0065940372,
0.0409419909,
0.052762039,
0.0095649026,
0.0287477784,
0.0076657836,
-0.0555308983,
-0.0283025187,
-0.0040026708,
0.030689979,
-0.0391902812,
-0.0077885892,
-0.030366797,
-0.0175493434,
-0.02550596,
0.067531392,
-0.0155259995,
0.0087965308,
0.0158449598,
0.017054541,
0.041185122,
-0.0377980135,
0.0378266573,
-0.0555270538,
0.0002005475,
0.0155252106,
-0.0148778604,
-0.0104966741,
-5.651352191e-33,
-0.055330947,
0.0228567217,
-0.013441084,
-0.0137223536,
-0.0491861925,
-0.0261811484,
-0.0337928198,
-0.0281225909,
-0.0029227806,
0.0267123282,
0.0041561569,
0.01967852,
0.0324974917,
0.0092956237,
-0.0017630111,
-0.0167045835,
0.0561300293,
0.0007139004,
-0.0557748489,
-0.007953437,
0.0587394014,
0.0379538462,
0.1203151569,
-0.0731451064,
0.0200969353,
0.0046653585,
-0.0351128764,
-0.0099349162,
0.0663813055,
0.0273631737,
0.0173996966,
0.0102571454,
0.0086344955,
-0.0581037067,
0.0232626703,
0.0245258864,
-0.0692530423,
-0.0144003043,
0.0013296935,
0.0600565895,
0.0267690998,
-0.0360638462,
0.0322872847,
0.0128586413,
0.0126131037,
0.0116422623,
0.060309086,
-0.0656438395,
-0.0147522828,
-0.063151598,
-0.0683586672,
0.0298072994,
-0.030369902,
-0.0538713001,
0.0082104541,
0.092071116,
0.0356626362,
0.0281898547,
-0.0280334391,
-0.0085608149,
-0.0149058281,
0.039122995,
0.0274587274,
0.0105138477,
-0.0237951744,
0.0438110195,
-0.0396114662,
0.003170795,
0.0250201337,
-0.0214661006,
0.0510830656,
-0.0312200598,
0.0242760144,
0.0666858628,
0.0187212955,
0.000274529,
-0.1061635092,
0.063827239,
0.0061581009,
-0.006563744,
0.0123180114,
0.0130188158,
0.0038527716,
-0.0002665685,
-0.0315102451,
-0.0285434648,
-0.0031366074,
0.0088650817,
-0.0040678526,
-0.0218296386,
-0.0326652862,
0.0467551909,
0.0454804525,
-0.0354290977,
-0.0331337899,
-0.030228829,
-0.0416022427,
0.0385239907,
-0.0356950909,
0.0335557833,
-0.0042175376,
-0.0513971448,
0.0323018692,
0.0547150373,
0.0260589421,
-0.0190896112,
0.0928010419,
0.0254685041,
-0.0663775057,
-0.025806509,
-0.0187300891,
-0.0170055795,
-0.0230866969,
0.103989087,
-0.0071389256,
0.0050555859,
0.0125591867,
0.0197757874,
0.0414128788,
0.0043333652,
-0.0022143354,
0.0187242366,
0.0293470081,
0.0076472578,
-0.0255598258,
-0.0192917865,
0.0216731001,
0.0397190265,
-0.0120030232,
-0.0496988446,
-0.0236460622,
-0.0061864639,
2.538e-7,
0.0848982409,
0.0577664785,
0.0328221992,
-0.0533955134,
0.0091497442,
0.0222924277,
-0.0644210503,
0.0712708905,
0.0177755039,
-0.0171918962,
0.029159179,
-0.0316971056,
0.0551784523,
0.0411328524,
-0.1157276258,
-0.0725491047,
-0.0172228478,
0.0313760266,
-0.0385337435,
0.0338654108,
0.058680851,
0.061847765,
0.0206394531,
-0.0155723039,
0.0016270184,
-0.0091122035,
0.0909171924,
-0.0124831861,
-0.0113133043,
0.0363954715,
0.0072801737,
0.0158814676,
-0.0316423178,
0.0519950576,
-0.0339211486,
0.0162174348,
0.0366684459,
0.0259400103,
-0.0111011928,
-0.0210216418,
0.0179546513,
-0.0010058242,
0.0120301154,
0.0036053294,
0.0260991249,
-0.0395192504,
-0.0301812775,
-0.020204505,
-0.0296652541,
0.0183551088,
0.0687997937,
-0.0162468012,
-0.0284631979,
0.013328108,
0.0234947279,
0.0214031972,
-0.0257834345,
-0.0344499908,
-0.0016232528,
-0.0038692867,
-0.0224748757,
-0.0486598089,
-0.0035647647,
-0.0099646226,
-0.0307170879,
-0.0889314562,
0.0472316928,
2.128272011e-34,
0.0632868409,
-0.0338827483,
-0.0511204861,
0.014807594,
0.0098030455,
-0.0320593715,
-0.0052621337,
-0.0243817791,
-0.014437479,
-0.035128206,
0.0122990226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03688v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03688v2 | AgentBench: Evaluating LLMs as Agents | 2023-08-07T16:08:11 | 2023-10-25T07:41:24 | Xiao Liu, Hao Yu, Hanchen Zhang, Yifan Xu, Xuanyu Lei, Hanyu Lai, Yu Gu, Hangliang Ding, Kaiwen Men, Kejuan Yang, Shudan Zhang, Xiang Deng, Aohan Zeng, Zhengxiao Du, Chenhui Zhang, Sheng Shen, Tianjun Zhang, Yu Su, Huan Sun, Minlie Huang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly smart and autonomous,
targeting real-world pragmatic missions beyond traditional NLP tasks. As a
result, there has been an urgent need to evaluate LLMs as agents on challenging
tasks in interactive environments. We present AgentBench, a multi-dimensional
evolving benchmark that currently consists of 8 distinct environments to assess
LLM-as-Agent's reasoning and decision-making abilities in a multi-turn
open-ended generation setting. Our extensive test over 27 API-based and
open-sourced (OSS) LLMs shows that, while top commercial LLMs present a strong
ability of acting as agents in complex environments, there is a significant
disparity in performance between them and OSS competitors. We identify the
typical reasons of failures in environments and LLMs, showing that poor
long-term reasoning, decision-making, and instruction following abilities are
the main obstacles for developing usable LLM agents. Training on code and high
quality multi-turn alignment data could improve agent performance. Datasets,
environments, and an integrated evaluation package for AgentBench are released
at \url{https://github.com/THUDM/AgentBench}. | [
-0.0017042861,
0.0424803086,
-0.022073295,
0.03336595,
-0.046904467,
0.008847964,
0.0009264091,
-0.0218315274,
0.0180666465,
-0.0182992183,
-0.0052459762,
-0.0071876636,
-0.0231982525,
0.0356353484,
0.0214117393,
-0.0067527019,
0.0564944297,
-0.0448426306,
0.009901654,
0.0075139585,
-0.0297027081,
0.0113969939,
-0.0505617,
0.055710569,
0.0039988956,
-0.0353895985,
-0.0341982767,
-0.000102749,
0.0270082466,
-0.0347413719,
-0.0171808023,
0.0136206737,
0.0606304817,
0.0570896752,
0.0000018799,
-0.0808815211,
-0.0054522003,
-0.0052349032,
-0.0462847017,
-0.0157757308,
0.0298708621,
0.0083180722,
-0.0407464169,
0.0068231057,
-0.0778789073,
-0.0047932547,
0.0463208854,
-0.0128323697,
0.0793337822,
0.0955170318,
0.0187457129,
-0.0064783785,
0.0078515681,
0.0067320541,
-0.0103784427,
-0.0329347849,
-0.0084244292,
0.0052199578,
0.034516748,
-0.0363670439,
-0.002434416,
0.0186035745,
0.032916598,
-0.0220790207,
-0.0264888629,
0.0465186387,
-0.0601316057,
-0.0442697331,
-0.0233071074,
0.0698279068,
0.0047082822,
0.0005036757,
-0.0030802975,
-0.0048788418,
-0.0110035846,
-0.0255038105,
-0.032599315,
0.0467928983,
0.0050660199,
0.0272116847,
-0.0005722964,
-0.0246964861,
0.026795039,
0.0078794323,
-0.03360717,
0.116056174,
0.0024497628,
0.0042540492,
-0.0218518861,
-0.0097331265,
0.004651376,
-0.0611760132,
-0.0284804646,
0.0700602159,
-0.0739777386,
0.0364217684,
-0.0499144271,
0.0224317517,
0.0205281936,
-0.0257405248,
0.0296892002,
0.0403778963,
-0.0081967078,
0.0340477005,
-0.0183259528,
0.0733023137,
0.014422955,
0.0426241048,
-0.0156627279,
0.0135560194,
-0.0450899564,
-0.0050109387,
-0.0057379468,
0.0253887083,
-0.022688685,
-0.0400675274,
-0.016528802,
0.0634458512,
-0.0249351338,
0.0625002086,
-0.014969592,
0.0103097344,
-0.0028129558,
-0.0121886041,
-0.0490860566,
0.0149395289,
-0.0166628864,
0.0061509972,
0.0375738516,
-0.0734098777,
0.0098799821,
0.0264182072,
-0.0203835256,
0.0045742821,
-0.0000187389,
0.1346689016,
0.0164986495,
-0.0248318743,
-0.0509111173,
-0.0303497985,
0.0241609197,
-0.0944167748,
-0.0017424156,
-0.0708236098,
0.0402845852,
0.0109624788,
-0.0368758664,
-0.0468729101,
0.0294688791,
-0.0043250206,
0.0122002419,
0.0512452945,
-0.0037508425,
0.0359428637,
0.0200573578,
0.0093512237,
-0.0208874382,
0.0964507163,
0.0572372191,
0.0228053816,
0.0430917181,
0.0115768295,
0.0123132756,
0.0569723807,
-0.0438069887,
0.0213426612,
0.0194454696,
0.0302828792,
-0.0156020653,
0.0801283419,
0.0164316073,
0.0349233784,
-0.0157691371,
-0.0087251095,
0.0730780363,
0.0225373711,
0.0127949119,
-0.0210907757,
0.0636288077,
0.0278615169,
-0.0011381007,
-0.0079022767,
-0.0524588302,
0.0525693297,
-0.005697811,
0.0278914552,
-0.008530139,
0.0670548826,
-0.0121404668,
-0.036958918,
-0.0172303189,
0.0009445734,
-0.0035909512,
-0.0097311921,
0.0356107727,
-0.004013387,
-0.0617768653,
0.0273038223,
0.023516776,
-0.0570094585,
-0.0104357731,
-0.0700181946,
0.0458734222,
0.0816467181,
0.0750478432,
-0.0305702128,
-0.073664479,
-0.006221279,
-0.009211245,
0.078845188,
0.0508688018,
-0.0330441296,
0.0029773996,
-0.0383830853,
-0.024915969,
-0.0173959266,
0.0004909877,
0.0467376746,
0.0294224285,
-0.0009489689,
-0.0048871343,
-0.0382819064,
-0.0237037092,
0.0537965819,
-0.0471835211,
-0.0405726321,
-0.0360895544,
0.0065020751,
0.0348649994,
0.0075581265,
-0.0248141605,
0.0101114577,
0.0420095511,
-0.0081071928,
-0.0020662653,
0.0313657522,
-0.0173208751,
-0.0174492914,
0.0655151829,
-0.0223867167,
-0.0230099391,
0.0295315757,
-0.0379114375,
-0.0327649117,
0.0240243711,
-0.0414373763,
0.0393228531,
-0.0167150889,
0.0434256122,
-0.0192002263,
0.0099252602,
-0.0251427647,
0.0421654843,
-0.0086013144,
-0.024633009,
0.034837313,
0.0432625413,
-0.0028930833,
-0.0279236306,
0.0108914291,
0.0233230256,
0.0134397708,
-0.0017697043,
0.009687447,
0.0286632292,
-0.0511717536,
-0.0256025344,
-0.0551286042,
0.0105874389,
-0.0147941392,
0.0304433685,
0.0188799314,
-0.0245562214,
-0.0102200415,
0.0341042913,
-0.0290010758,
0.0410077982,
0.0302661713,
0.0168600846,
0.0148858326,
-0.0022372759,
-0.0588908307,
-0.0404770859,
0.0266747102,
-0.0186156295,
0.0111117726,
-0.0016038324,
0.0323581547,
-0.078959547,
0.0003015324,
-0.0510652587,
0.0275375228,
-0.0168027822,
-0.0413012952,
0.0449631847,
-0.0272999331,
0.0195589792,
0.0453043692,
-0.0121754194,
0.0266811643,
0.0722173676,
-0.0309149772,
-0.0708393082,
0.0134343449,
-0.0145313228,
0.0034179201,
-0.054897029,
-0.0179654267,
-0.0199083388,
0.0432833172,
-0.0126826409,
0.017781673,
-0.0364824533,
0.0283654183,
-0.0030705347,
-0.031538561,
0.0110117588,
0.0202711597,
-0.0300508328,
0.0331688486,
-0.0216528997,
-0.0558983758,
0.0832181722,
-0.0517419092,
-0.0240844693,
-0.0177121945,
-0.0300182682,
-0.0573043078,
0.0765708312,
0.0035868352,
0.0082129464,
-0.0176156722,
0.0080842171,
-0.0489249006,
0.013971718,
-0.0105133113,
-0.0270731952,
0.0668430179,
-0.0863134861,
0.0079738414,
-0.0054988209,
-0.0220660884,
-0.0459981859,
0.006526453,
-0.0323433056,
0.017483741,
0.0005682482,
-0.0416483097,
-0.049784001,
0.0118086506,
0.0392830931,
0.0327347405,
-0.0110902833,
-0.0167395677,
-0.0490312763,
-0.0146360742,
0.0548100173,
0.0459831432,
0.0580515936,
-0.0358052105,
0.0503549837,
0.0305100735,
0.0295925476,
-0.0279871188,
-0.0554732606,
0.0038407191,
0.0257654954,
-0.0330954492,
0.0194024574,
0.0434543006,
0.0407034047,
-0.0794122592,
-0.0180357341,
0.1015283093,
0.0169645716,
-0.0259749629,
0.024419805,
-0.0457060374,
0.0304681994,
0.0465765186,
0.0423086435,
-0.0563627072,
-0.029779071,
0.0061164168,
0.0264180154,
-0.0137439584,
-0.0401475541,
-0.0142616965,
-0.1266221702,
0.0659052655,
0.010860946,
-0.0420974232,
-0.0057755671,
-0.038019523,
0.0111728841,
-0.0025585305,
0.0269457866,
0.0440631211,
-0.0073955981,
-0.0232363399,
-0.0143929273,
-0.0238987673,
-0.0243300479,
0.022390658,
-0.0524181463,
0.0834254101,
0.0968822315,
0.0194673892,
0.0102942344,
-0.0454306416,
0.0086689312,
0.0327784792,
0.0277379286,
0.0048540505,
0.0176161844,
-0.0022601031,
-0.0087995697,
0.0012073553,
0.0175192915,
-0.0751556531,
-0.0010770116,
0.0025714149,
0.0825881213,
-0.0361728035,
-0.0050862217,
-0.0265814979,
0.0146437231,
0.0084857522,
0.0491248816,
0.0000620663,
-0.0143734198,
-0.0805973262,
-0.0294513851,
-0.0371303186,
-0.0535750426,
-0.0174633972,
0.0316159986,
-0.0174225867,
-0.0348350145,
-0.0587449893,
-0.0439132862,
0.039224185,
0.0198806897,
0.008065653,
-0.0174286589,
0.0146645773,
0.0017639954,
-0.0233053509,
-0.0047258437,
-0.027309509,
0.0384601764,
-0.0494867936,
-0.0329279304,
0.0303766336,
-0.053417068,
0.0157184806,
0.0185950287,
-0.0638697296,
-0.0864182189,
0.0229455307,
0.0602043644,
0.033466056,
0.0458731763,
-0.0062651956,
-0.013004371,
0.0220006742,
0.034841802,
-0.0544261448,
0.0376176797,
-0.0098242015,
0.034147203,
0.0057443944,
0.0319899693,
-0.0594036244,
-0.0098235914,
-0.0183856525,
0.0520219579,
-0.0245199092,
-0.0269372053,
0.0035100647,
0.0024637533,
-0.0215806924,
-0.0334058143,
-0.013397349,
-0.0205403883,
0.0187116321,
-0.0349547528,
-0.0060380506,
-0.0406545177,
-0.0172088183,
-0.0155541375,
0.0030606133,
0.0534230657,
0.0320278518,
-0.0126782637,
0.0431960896,
0.0061802575,
0.0274423435,
0.0066880742,
0.0007359638,
0.0408794396,
-0.0007189221,
-0.0100546284,
0.0169098582,
-0.0461543165,
0.0327989943,
0.0099150073,
0.073833853,
0.0128294909,
-0.0053902455,
-0.0011235402,
0.0349313766,
-0.0515689813,
-0.0725289434,
0.0167371202,
0.03625549,
0.0756866038,
0.0252386685,
0.068733193,
-0.0503698848,
0.0165461414,
-0.0051960824,
-0.0023498463,
0.0030424688,
-0.0525818504,
0.011873208,
0.0443647318,
-0.0145349996,
0.0013464717,
0.0717223436,
-0.0015888601,
0.070880495,
-0.0299055092,
0.0216325242,
-0.0458288416,
-0.0570501052,
-0.0005505755,
-0.0189305674,
-0.0186301768,
-0.0168882292,
-0.0583958402,
-0.0406878777,
-0.0169170257,
0.0749041289,
-0.0112620257,
-0.0426126607,
0.0210896656,
0.049184788,
0.0011088619,
-0.024611868,
-0.0492984802,
-0.0189187098,
-0.0558748208,
-0.0089105088,
-0.010198121,
-5.827214963e-33,
-0.0399106964,
-0.0243145376,
0.1025554016,
-0.0032724857,
-0.0486929007,
-0.0256718844,
-0.058266934,
0.0049780449,
-0.0040902472,
-0.0010010079,
0.0086215474,
0.0016596502,
0.0055243606,
0.0034445634,
0.0177307762,
-0.0148496274,
0.0175927598,
0.0019608091,
-0.029155124,
0.0038764596,
0.02747567,
0.0027064967,
0.0041879695,
-0.0591654666,
-0.0080175586,
-0.0010378079,
-0.0114290165,
0.0300401095,
-0.0468102098,
0.0642310604,
0.0069414731,
0.0092309499,
0.0119842263,
-0.0127152884,
-0.0243206024,
-0.0106422305,
-0.007392549,
-0.0029246586,
-0.0008661213,
0.0293532796,
-0.0423887931,
-0.0443270728,
0.027335858,
-0.0007546124,
-0.0305662584,
0.0122293187,
0.0277989544,
-0.037924625,
-0.005426642,
0.0046062195,
-0.0808587372,
0.0270504039,
-0.0141013777,
-0.0316591412,
-0.0093987714,
0.0232653562,
-0.0019828265,
0.0095500657,
-0.0517775416,
0.0281895604,
-0.0045849825,
-0.0082857283,
0.1142806336,
0.0083820662,
0.019075783,
0.0661477149,
0.025297327,
-0.0085142748,
-0.0252375454,
0.0126164798,
0.0176200774,
0.0853204653,
0.0211066082,
0.0424735472,
-0.0551059023,
-0.0005640096,
-0.0272345133,
0.0395946093,
0.037074592,
0.0290053617,
0.034935452,
0.0282309595,
-0.0201369002,
0.0199074056,
-0.0204692744,
0.0150997583,
-0.020520376,
-0.0410040915,
0.0275767371,
0.0056238105,
-0.0000923077,
-0.0529446937,
0.0353156626,
-0.0423186757,
0.0065746,
-0.0037930666,
-0.0623326413,
0.0325912572,
-0.0182207152,
0.034718506,
-0.0406423323,
-0.0482945479,
0.0073959762,
-0.001458957,
0.038134262,
0.0057833851,
-0.0170674808,
0.0561379902,
-0.0267904997,
0.0216135196,
-0.0637371317,
0.030913081,
0.0162613057,
-0.0135141984,
0.0209804308,
-0.0392981134,
-0.0186173264,
0.0420416556,
-0.0019411033,
-0.0139732761,
-0.0005041863,
-0.0094206864,
-0.0011459118,
0.0030611234,
-0.0544893928,
0.0110316761,
-0.0653530434,
0.0372500382,
0.0046997275,
-0.0415522419,
-0.0084029092,
0.0361751355,
2.686e-7,
0.0097994339,
0.0548158921,
0.0310836509,
0.036166247,
0.0251821671,
0.0341241956,
-0.0537576787,
0.0126614049,
-0.0184222814,
-0.0171964187,
0.0053973356,
0.0286317263,
0.0472915284,
0.0344853029,
-0.0675452948,
0.0191495791,
-0.0276726782,
-0.0043723057,
-0.0744117796,
-0.0012967635,
0.0544070043,
0.0599270537,
0.0024446433,
-0.0104517667,
0.0195143092,
-0.0365717858,
0.018392818,
-0.0137837362,
0.0073822741,
0.0349890999,
-0.0295719784,
0.0063296501,
-0.0166502595,
-0.0050344872,
0.0080303978,
0.009479613,
-0.0436419733,
0.0841599703,
0.0132241612,
-0.0651820228,
0.0250416901,
-0.018802058,
-0.0013221545,
-0.035768453,
0.0632804483,
-0.0350836292,
-0.035722699,
-0.0248608422,
-0.0316095874,
-0.0058259503,
-0.0478332452,
-0.0311569795,
-0.0052773021,
0.0221679267,
-0.0028733821,
-0.0482758768,
-0.0119145298,
-0.069184266,
-0.0164822731,
-0.0220590252,
-0.0541132763,
-0.0560836792,
-0.0415840447,
0.0221829116,
0.0025263696,
-0.0451675802,
-0.0289338659,
2.560430571e-34,
0.0086878268,
-0.0001422954,
0.0048125796,
0.0297300834,
0.0423353091,
0.0046530925,
-0.0094533972,
0.0285546351,
0.0047046412,
-0.0470112488,
-0.0203695707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03660v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03660v1 | Detecting Spells in Fantasy Literature with a Transformer Based Artificial Intelligence | 2023-08-07T15:20:20 | 2023-08-07T15:20:20 | Marcel Moravek, Alexander Zender, Andreas Müller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformer architectures and models have made significant progress in
language-based tasks. In this area, is BERT one of the most widely used and
freely available transformer architecture. In our work, we use BERT for
context-based phrase recognition of magic spells in the Harry Potter novel
series. Spells are a common part of active magic in fantasy novels. Typically,
spells are used in a specific context to achieve a supernatural effect. A
series of investigations were conducted to see if a Transformer architecture
could recognize such phrases based on their context in the Harry Potter saga.
For our studies a pre-trained BERT model was used and fine-tuned utilising
different datasets and training methods to identify the searched context. By
considering different approaches for sequence classification as well as token
classification, it is shown that the context of spells can be recognised.
According to our investigations, the examined sequence length for fine-tuning
and validation of the model plays a significant role in context recognition.
Based on this, we have investigated whether spells have overarching properties
that allow a transfer of the neural network models to other fantasy universes
as well. The application of our model showed promising results and is worth to
be deepened in subsequent studies. | [
0.0357902348,
0.022762632,
-0.0297387019,
0.0806781724,
-0.0374705642,
0.0007815818,
0.0032946982,
-0.0001746469,
-0.0117569063,
-0.0728576109,
-0.0093342792,
0.0250614844,
0.0404846668,
-0.0032420994,
0.0132715832,
-0.0411678664,
0.041719649,
-0.0150697622,
-0.0243049283,
0.0324618109,
-0.0117478082,
0.0226201359,
-0.0090721501,
0.0500692464,
-0.0277095344,
-0.038429182,
-0.009945658,
-0.0179712363,
0.0430387743,
-0.033129625,
0.0049671186,
-0.0211238135,
0.0015002065,
0.0649650916,
0.0000019768,
-0.0378422402,
0.0003873405,
-0.0276223198,
0.0269026086,
0.0016942046,
0.0098168096,
0.0494196862,
0.0102492161,
-0.0257674344,
-0.0242222063,
0.040888235,
0.0721941441,
0.0533008501,
0.0321162045,
0.061642386,
-0.007462658,
-0.09203545,
0.0177482646,
0.0246116091,
0.0512146354,
-0.0394913927,
0.0224825703,
-0.0620438382,
0.0428068638,
0.0103490818,
-0.0258837901,
0.0267454945,
-0.011889236,
0.0063551059,
0.0026293057,
0.0118624792,
-0.0550214648,
0.0021184997,
-0.0430029519,
0.0294179115,
0.0108586596,
-0.0471669734,
-0.0113404738,
0.0123959295,
0.0107052652,
0.0882935748,
0.0039591845,
-0.0027118463,
-0.0179812852,
-0.0253386311,
0.0081113847,
0.0223807823,
0.0398203358,
0.0038662043,
-0.0633295625,
0.0722078383,
0.0167964492,
-0.0477823131,
-0.0304337144,
-0.0386818871,
0.0156672876,
-0.0296017434,
0.0420700423,
0.031580288,
0.050685335,
0.0009680013,
-0.0371618532,
-0.0663288981,
0.006625941,
-0.036740765,
0.0001274497,
0.0316028297,
-0.0311980117,
0.0336374789,
-0.0058925883,
0.0524938032,
0.0426999927,
0.0062131654,
-0.0211460534,
-0.0085481629,
-0.0602416359,
-0.0025089534,
-0.0705832615,
0.031314373,
-0.05022645,
-0.0394928046,
-0.0846805498,
-0.038448628,
0.0073213181,
0.0036982922,
-0.0060301684,
0.023753345,
0.022309782,
0.0137050059,
-0.0253693219,
-0.0059736348,
-0.0111476695,
-0.0003913841,
-0.0283709168,
-0.004487549,
-0.0028316551,
0.0074881855,
0.0514243282,
-0.0438445844,
0.0355974399,
0.0611157045,
0.0445216969,
-0.0602593347,
-0.0363129824,
-0.0095664309,
-0.0271971095,
0.001624512,
0.0100886831,
-0.0049713356,
-0.0011539935,
-0.0286285728,
0.0573213138,
0.0468018726,
0.026984321,
0.0197670795,
-0.0209778696,
0.086140804,
-0.0356468372,
-0.0126752285,
0.0395315029,
0.0062271082,
0.0054015671,
-0.0267902147,
0.0524157323,
0.0554471277,
0.0488704033,
-0.0654569715,
0.0758636221,
0.0276784822,
-0.0348119549,
-0.0633879155,
-0.0409990624,
-0.0310538467,
-0.01235078,
0.001492362,
-0.0743490756,
0.0247265194,
-0.0219480172,
-0.0118342079,
0.0481095947,
0.1214593425,
0.0322763696,
0.0857213959,
0.0649146363,
-0.0133260088,
0.0176932532,
0.0143762641,
-0.0283994805,
-0.0190732162,
-0.0059860684,
0.0031245826,
-0.0585304871,
0.0167023372,
0.0378520377,
-0.0083847847,
-0.0566651188,
-0.0066859345,
-0.0110715302,
-0.0436901189,
0.0422449932,
0.0203873403,
-0.0509903543,
0.0468948521,
0.0004601643,
-0.0576525219,
-0.0067839278,
-0.0293749478,
0.0312012974,
0.1103558168,
0.0587990656,
-0.0665355399,
0.0331206731,
-0.0129661858,
-0.0132296141,
0.0267743114,
-0.0538742803,
-0.0126055256,
0.0422218442,
-0.0537064262,
0.0111933053,
-0.0153830592,
0.0144626359,
0.031356439,
-0.0592129827,
-0.0120853111,
0.0105559276,
-0.0230877791,
-0.0059754462,
0.0519371964,
-0.0520868711,
-0.0575114004,
-0.0245366059,
0.0296351388,
0.0127523271,
-0.0083810166,
-0.0424419679,
-0.0098740691,
0.0202466659,
-0.0394355543,
-0.0088403784,
0.0109385019,
-0.0432421304,
0.0284683295,
0.0601006225,
-0.0749809369,
0.0277892686,
0.0097886454,
0.0198438466,
-0.0159856547,
0.0409210213,
-0.0639469251,
0.0458029695,
-0.0091880094,
0.0489686392,
-0.0231084954,
0.0088635487,
-0.0418646969,
0.0496480465,
0.0072543155,
0.0109006669,
-0.048848208,
-0.0049871681,
0.0233916584,
0.0128351413,
-0.0315572545,
-0.0386372916,
0.0021068722,
-0.0068479232,
0.0293138735,
-0.0163560584,
0.0105796913,
-0.0455292389,
-0.0860098004,
-0.008559389,
0.0314695202,
0.0135340411,
0.0096813617,
-0.0033338529,
-0.0186121967,
0.0187733881,
-0.0250227265,
0.0117242401,
-0.0413839631,
-0.0309786294,
0.0420712009,
0.0022993654,
-0.053820435,
-0.010777276,
-0.000416854,
-0.0305849072,
0.0942908302,
0.0350207277,
-0.0103593227,
-0.0190639235,
-0.0594296269,
0.0010336597,
0.0112986919,
-0.0021835794,
-0.0855643973,
-0.0028784594,
-0.0145104621,
0.0038404802,
-0.0041771499,
0.0113630872,
-0.0338689797,
0.0186684467,
-0.0539615713,
-0.0028721623,
-0.0003036699,
0.0127753727,
0.0134892156,
0.0310112815,
-0.0107573299,
0.0836941972,
0.0796514302,
-0.0249047428,
-0.0107931541,
-0.0222590547,
0.0207730681,
0.046037253,
-0.0072456887,
-0.0350405052,
-0.0655011982,
-0.0304204244,
0.000363139,
0.004099804,
-0.0258862879,
0.0350278616,
-0.0510600545,
0.0006962261,
-0.09243837,
0.0101655107,
-0.0228182394,
0.0068701692,
0.0059751556,
0.0236881506,
-0.0003047143,
-0.0363409817,
0.0268825796,
-0.0024207018,
0.0178790931,
-0.02684878,
0.0399334952,
-0.035583809,
-0.0147661818,
0.008132414,
0.0287554488,
-0.0440572277,
0.0127195586,
-0.0221953243,
-0.0450436436,
0.0342918448,
-0.0185465906,
-0.0323672779,
0.0387268998,
-0.012518161,
0.0632586554,
0.0260904208,
-0.042140007,
-0.0072246082,
0.0001756467,
0.0026812174,
-0.0468625501,
0.0246010982,
-0.0130401608,
0.0098194052,
-0.0041561211,
-0.0252964906,
-0.0580643117,
-0.0641439706,
0.0111598643,
0.0371552892,
-0.0781496614,
-0.0088703847,
0.0307906289,
-0.0460832082,
-0.0821930617,
0.0061219856,
0.0805326477,
0.0458505712,
0.0004311485,
0.0225298461,
-0.0203690305,
-0.0736942813,
0.0023809606,
0.0035791497,
-0.1092652157,
-0.0053135203,
0.004387192,
0.0256222356,
0.030942725,
-0.018658042,
0.0199881904,
-0.049227763,
0.0117183886,
0.0003373447,
0.0008361374,
-0.0601527877,
0.0286351591,
-0.0104452418,
0.0022633951,
0.0122285746,
-0.0215734057,
-0.0494642481,
-0.0272052288,
-0.031896431,
0.0230508801,
0.0040489011,
-0.0115534244,
-0.0185471829,
-0.0490121655,
0.0760184303,
0.0712452233,
-0.0385038219,
-0.0726042539,
0.0016994118,
0.0072588087,
0.0086032329,
-0.0036600539,
0.0265536904,
0.0308422986,
0.0083999941,
-0.0224981569,
-0.0151484646,
-0.0248960163,
-0.0829675868,
0.0727019161,
0.0616917163,
-0.002831965,
-0.0337015763,
-0.0293515269,
0.020401774,
0.0212532803,
0.0379564017,
0.0027432684,
-0.0167084336,
-0.0370904356,
-0.0050490894,
0.0271880366,
-0.0123668881,
-0.0724218339,
-0.0136908079,
-0.0182969365,
0.0056940778,
-0.1060320139,
0.0387195349,
-0.0031651331,
0.0566674992,
0.0876906365,
0.0011150312,
0.0380161516,
0.0204883497,
0.0046198205,
0.0076421052,
0.0081664687,
-0.0179737117,
-0.0571189858,
0.0129166665,
0.0209626593,
-0.0367612652,
0.0029777042,
0.0290575735,
-0.0159603152,
-0.0015767901,
0.0273642521,
0.0403663218,
0.0192273911,
-0.0205943659,
-0.0017507011,
-0.0277615413,
0.0339043587,
0.0248384662,
-0.0596036725,
-0.0128689259,
-0.007288056,
0.0058255401,
-0.0284150317,
-0.0159713328,
-0.0061691753,
0.0350600295,
-0.0026704525,
-0.0080320602,
-0.0373138599,
-0.0028022812,
0.0083880583,
-0.0075862198,
0.0608697906,
-0.0508210696,
-0.0198716186,
0.0091079837,
0.0117536196,
-0.0295727067,
-0.0327165276,
0.0117434477,
0.0065971692,
0.0177879017,
0.0149046434,
-0.002510896,
-0.0103183175,
0.0004022416,
0.0114786411,
-0.0528786294,
0.0570775494,
0.0013769489,
0.0195530318,
-0.0095662447,
0.0161343366,
0.0116125122,
-0.0151195461,
-0.018015597,
0.0584128946,
-0.0024896234,
0.0515429229,
0.0211934224,
0.0226198696,
-0.0200479086,
0.01644109,
-0.0326239318,
0.0534153357,
0.0197287239,
-0.0109468056,
0.0296408702,
-0.0413871631,
0.0040969048,
-0.0127091324,
-0.0113779688,
0.0125696864,
0.0555475168,
0.0144058429,
0.052458372,
-0.0304173175,
0.0218853559,
-0.044103425,
-0.0148976613,
0.0073225722,
-0.0371051915,
0.0330807045,
0.0495956093,
-0.0936401859,
-0.0405052789,
-0.0211925749,
0.009924436,
0.0181757063,
-0.0104184961,
0.0382473283,
-0.0644355938,
-0.002866945,
0.0280658547,
-0.0042170892,
0.0412881635,
-0.0208177771,
0.0347322673,
0.0423650965,
0.0057808869,
-0.0042815413,
-0.0010836833,
0.022220552,
0.0355820842,
-0.0367750004,
-0.0578332394,
-5.113255693e-33,
-0.0314660743,
-0.0093625868,
0.0073668747,
0.0264128502,
-0.0038949093,
-0.0130423419,
0.0041686632,
-0.0172109399,
0.0203164928,
0.0303993318,
0.0138998851,
-0.0168185681,
0.0078006922,
0.0015710042,
0.0135653606,
-0.0030226761,
0.0193372834,
0.0317492373,
-0.007337804,
-0.0124429027,
0.0615195334,
0.0335907936,
0.0799151585,
-0.1000248715,
-0.0462396517,
-0.012640099,
0.010444439,
-0.0235667676,
0.038853813,
0.032900501,
-0.047365848,
-0.026063554,
0.0025723916,
0.0038811723,
0.0098277451,
0.0407714061,
-0.0725655556,
-0.0398736894,
0.0336363986,
0.0189554989,
0.0731730238,
-0.0578281842,
0.0380006693,
-0.0079390751,
-0.0203352142,
0.0081282072,
0.0821347758,
-0.0135765681,
-0.0057543088,
-0.0906082392,
-0.1009196118,
0.0201370586,
-0.0263983887,
-0.0091207493,
0.0318516195,
0.0356441401,
0.0039240625,
0.0443637036,
-0.0843166709,
0.0014209219,
0.0400180034,
-0.0003695736,
-0.0193952173,
0.0490515493,
-0.0205210671,
0.0663057119,
0.0262109786,
-0.0384097062,
-0.0476841629,
0.07022167,
0.033524096,
0.0123605309,
0.0858035907,
0.0358318761,
0.0688844323,
0.0349210352,
-0.0545945056,
-0.001156559,
0.0093506565,
0.0234560911,
0.0478333868,
-0.0049718479,
-0.0265302137,
-0.0132344924,
0.0243162531,
0.0255418252,
-0.0180996731,
0.0296355635,
-0.0194125585,
-0.0430244803,
0.0127932755,
0.0138327247,
-0.013527642,
-0.0651141405,
-0.0262038969,
0.0257333778,
-0.0038890289,
-0.0008934662,
-0.0100642871,
0.0186983738,
-0.0098253796,
-0.0355582088,
0.05378519,
0.0143470811,
0.0494395569,
0.025838973,
0.0122672301,
0.0391239412,
-0.0661560893,
-0.0064336448,
0.0159518849,
0.0135072954,
0.0169111658,
0.0542364344,
0.0409134813,
-0.031180013,
0.0018989214,
0.0008406857,
-0.0087852124,
-0.0117961941,
0.0311843809,
-0.0079369647,
0.0006145198,
0.0052386164,
-0.0289245676,
-0.0007499703,
-0.0215815529,
0.0178873166,
0.0468570739,
-0.0847364143,
-0.0236952249,
0.0036416908,
2.796e-7,
0.0265713073,
0.0184525568,
0.032997977,
0.0161622297,
-0.0019564633,
0.025187403,
-0.0229147002,
-0.0034879274,
-0.0122550717,
-0.0082862861,
0.006578878,
-0.05963948,
0.024200758,
0.010665698,
-0.0898048356,
-0.0432542413,
-0.0502361841,
0.0145840282,
-0.0246388875,
0.0298211053,
0.0201779772,
0.071029149,
0.0613739826,
-0.0319994725,
0.016827248,
-0.015388879,
-0.0036539317,
-0.0315438583,
0.0319910496,
0.0602061152,
0.0088406019,
0.0223684963,
-0.0014558255,
0.017719375,
-0.009610842,
0.0877609625,
-0.0074590961,
-0.0046921456,
-0.0433847383,
0.0485232845,
0.0338671021,
-0.0238742437,
0.01824167,
-0.0502967387,
0.0434075184,
0.0071126074,
-0.0140959593,
0.0388438478,
-0.04131658,
0.0041059796,
-0.0183662623,
-0.029453503,
-0.0178736337,
0.053775467,
0.0226703174,
-0.0000299005,
0.0106517999,
-0.1004964486,
0.0304443389,
0.0051974789,
-0.035889674,
-0.0058739609,
-0.0385896452,
-0.0385310091,
-0.0137023404,
-0.0366542526,
-0.0057495325,
2.49347928e-34,
-0.0070673353,
-0.0470335633,
-0.0319230184,
0.0191494972,
0.0436604843,
-0.0146460477,
0.050842531,
0.024407357,
0.015655797,
-0.0314703323,
0.0144275287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03656v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03656v4 | Emotionally Numb or Empathetic? Evaluating How LLMs Feel Using EmotionBench | 2023-08-07T15:18:30 | 2024-04-24T06:20:49 | Jen-tse Huang, Man Ho Lam, Eric John Li, Shujie Ren, Wenxuan Wang, Wenxiang Jiao, Zhaopeng Tu, Michael R. Lyu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating Large Language Models' (LLMs) anthropomorphic capabilities has
become increasingly important in contemporary discourse. Utilizing the emotion
appraisal theory from psychology, we propose to evaluate the empathy ability of
LLMs, i.e., how their feelings change when presented with specific situations.
After a careful and comprehensive survey, we collect a dataset containing over
400 situations that have proven effective in eliciting the eight emotions
central to our study. Categorizing the situations into 36 factors, we conduct a
human evaluation involving more than 1,200 subjects worldwide. With the human
evaluation results as references, our evaluation includes five LLMs, covering
both commercial and open-source models, including variations in model sizes,
featuring the latest iterations, such as GPT-4 and LLaMA-2. We find that,
despite several misalignments, LLMs can generally respond appropriately to
certain situations. Nevertheless, they fall short in alignment with the
emotional behaviors of human beings and cannot establish connections between
similar situations. Our collected dataset of situations, the human evaluation
results, and the code of our testing framework, dubbed EmotionBench, is made
openly accessible via https://github.com/CUHK-ARISE/EmotionBench. We aspire to
contribute to the advancement of LLMs regarding better alignment with the
emotional behaviors of human beings, thereby enhancing their utility and
applicability as intelligent assistants. | [
0.041383367,
0.0330306515,
-0.0309728142,
0.0254275184,
-0.0322523974,
0.0312187802,
-0.0063937912,
-0.0252847988,
0.0361179896,
-0.0236649159,
-0.06457901,
-0.0159434397,
-0.0334538929,
-0.0198725816,
0.0121033108,
-0.0898254365,
0.0239036661,
0.0324794836,
0.0593779013,
-0.0194122959,
-0.0001053841,
0.0447854251,
-0.0283724722,
0.0479377471,
-0.0221303403,
-0.0264401101,
-0.0162765179,
0.0209519025,
0.0454773381,
-0.0345694721,
0.0296030082,
0.0241953693,
0.0085350936,
-0.0181208383,
0.0000022512,
-0.045008719,
0.0323295221,
-0.020857377,
0.0232405774,
-0.0215504635,
0.1022034958,
-0.0235719271,
-0.0126638087,
0.0205954853,
-0.0505585186,
-0.0275959317,
0.021341091,
0.0247827377,
0.0634555146,
0.0580845661,
-0.0372179709,
0.005826822,
-0.0167931318,
-0.0014535263,
-0.0126882456,
-0.0416074097,
0.0102996528,
0.0055799186,
0.0301876031,
-0.080529049,
-0.0169611741,
0.0252798423,
0.0129516469,
0.0133674191,
0.0212369151,
0.0226880442,
-0.0121692531,
-0.060372591,
-0.0281809382,
0.0811189786,
0.0052019265,
0.0350231975,
-0.0089613823,
-0.0053721592,
0.0199776236,
-0.0068061007,
-0.030949913,
0.0209508725,
0.0012147821,
0.0144089581,
0.0000172198,
0.0409368128,
-0.003242234,
0.0452149659,
0.0113322968,
0.0553392358,
-0.0125725828,
-0.0224903636,
0.038906619,
-0.0069854823,
-0.0249034017,
-0.0219012164,
0.0134170633,
0.0241548307,
-0.0279694814,
0.0222339127,
-0.053231582,
0.0166860428,
0.0121338293,
-0.045871675,
0.0272146147,
0.0548503734,
-0.035168618,
0.0174121,
0.017213745,
0.0476575717,
0.0335383266,
-0.0018917884,
-0.0277691241,
0.0103553711,
-0.0310769044,
0.0100068385,
0.002959355,
0.0120815905,
-0.0308565684,
-0.0250898451,
-0.0371059664,
0.023655992,
-0.0369750001,
0.0052222642,
-0.0337121151,
0.0073808096,
-0.0045607346,
-0.0026958359,
-0.0300649945,
0.0113188606,
-0.0586188734,
0.035820201,
-0.0045255343,
-0.0740996599,
0.0255665854,
0.0178960208,
-0.016467575,
-0.017336987,
0.026851546,
0.055292774,
0.0137449121,
-0.0392204635,
-0.015870193,
0.0151390508,
0.0014017179,
-0.0652531758,
-0.0124145877,
-0.0102235954,
0.0504843406,
-0.0045249411,
0.0145686017,
-0.0269993674,
0.0115224645,
0.0050759511,
-0.028085595,
0.0685745999,
-0.0178558063,
0.0380129553,
0.0148008903,
0.0241445545,
0.0220565032,
0.0456038862,
0.0039552948,
0.0288135856,
0.0407848395,
-0.0186052117,
0.0365362428,
0.0005069873,
-0.0386906676,
-0.0021801868,
0.0072399741,
-0.0088581834,
-0.0445434488,
0.0665194988,
0.0641955435,
0.0482739583,
-0.0045228908,
-0.0330286771,
0.0526094623,
0.0856924802,
-0.0454331823,
0.0638757274,
0.0066608647,
0.0261130929,
0.0413362347,
-0.0056252615,
-0.0775204077,
0.0377258807,
-0.0234464202,
-0.0138417156,
-0.0244120471,
0.0222999509,
-0.0337918065,
-0.0241411664,
-0.0180061832,
-0.0164462905,
0.0156954173,
-0.0020787783,
-0.0064937035,
-0.0307595562,
-0.0313120484,
-0.0159026273,
0.0046796864,
-0.0931128189,
-0.026232494,
-0.0436624587,
0.000763391,
0.100409545,
0.0283608269,
-0.0442796163,
-0.0458652563,
0.0058064065,
-0.0179399978,
0.0393128023,
0.0239232574,
-0.004988533,
0.0231393352,
-0.0472910106,
0.024412157,
-0.0057772081,
0.0184239876,
0.0019600403,
-0.0407198481,
0.0318287276,
-0.0112477895,
-0.045027487,
0.0080543486,
0.0402568616,
-0.0667162687,
0.0019453567,
-0.0259775016,
0.0086824009,
0.014227231,
0.0237030834,
0.0029845228,
-0.0188513882,
0.0409033075,
-0.0238416437,
-0.0053208945,
0.0666533262,
-0.0290390439,
0.0021390498,
0.0481514372,
-0.052250959,
-0.0109723127,
0.0593005717,
-0.006448308,
-0.0253449641,
0.0215328857,
-0.0254660714,
0.0282996166,
-0.0501282774,
0.0432922728,
-0.0399016775,
0.0492295362,
0.0246132519,
0.0102467611,
-0.0224948302,
-0.0000932208,
-0.0013828685,
0.0000419319,
-0.0231775828,
-0.0443017818,
-0.0519965142,
0.0116200503,
0.0038192293,
-0.0001521952,
-0.0187614318,
-0.0047080163,
-0.0868605822,
-0.0551609956,
-0.1137978658,
-0.0264981184,
0.0075382404,
0.0161883309,
0.0087353699,
-0.0163256619,
-0.0537667945,
0.0108976113,
-0.035498973,
0.0192660782,
0.0191275328,
0.004513626,
0.019896891,
-0.0348159373,
-0.0036081998,
-0.0911871046,
0.0275483504,
-0.0178750604,
-0.0185777079,
-0.0189689025,
-0.0090355985,
-0.0231750142,
0.0391151905,
-0.0539040975,
0.014265446,
-0.0233927071,
-0.0966814235,
0.0275254883,
0.0097486638,
0.0339729227,
0.0681057572,
0.0150578972,
0.0816931501,
0.0310120285,
0.0064804684,
-0.0555968508,
0.0330028981,
-0.0021893687,
0.0197329968,
-0.048147995,
-0.073700659,
-0.0246435087,
0.0400672555,
0.008388211,
0.0438980199,
-0.0502187423,
0.0118944803,
0.0050137453,
-0.0589802675,
0.0120441942,
-0.0148272729,
-0.0260124039,
0.0122317104,
0.0163995214,
-0.0387706608,
0.0692861378,
0.0144396564,
-0.0324273966,
-0.0240739938,
-0.0102133406,
-0.0139978509,
0.0855435133,
-0.0561704971,
-0.004339295,
-0.0051394179,
0.0132595571,
-0.0281333961,
-0.0352871418,
-0.0404304005,
-0.0503352247,
0.0170503296,
-0.0247308146,
-0.0359665714,
0.0334837846,
-0.0332571156,
-0.0220098011,
-0.0479759425,
-0.0691123903,
0.0160122532,
0.0084209507,
-0.0276710968,
-0.0195468869,
-0.0113962339,
0.0306377895,
-0.025740305,
-0.0120608918,
-0.0112952106,
-0.012193718,
-0.0268332101,
0.0620866157,
0.0336973704,
0.0440439805,
-0.012458873,
0.0794521272,
0.0521450564,
0.0617769733,
0.0190935899,
-0.0131903216,
0.0277123936,
0.0209611673,
0.0324118957,
-0.0065044654,
-0.0226738993,
0.0400096364,
-0.0023332443,
0.0227994788,
0.1443732083,
0.0150418896,
-0.0671149194,
0.0379861444,
-0.0703458115,
-0.0055871182,
0.0245317519,
0.0058636745,
-0.0569502003,
-0.0188083928,
0.0158625413,
0.0483797267,
-0.024740465,
-0.0417531841,
0.0371740349,
-0.1091028005,
0.030674113,
-0.0096456958,
0.0098403674,
-0.0297870301,
-0.001185577,
0.059447661,
0.0059653004,
0.0368440859,
-0.0202473439,
0.0073118065,
-0.0283745527,
0.0029623355,
-0.0244995803,
-0.0297091156,
0.0510386713,
-0.0185632277,
0.09192013,
0.0253483225,
0.0975738317,
-0.0121589741,
-0.0253178142,
-0.0073919585,
0.0222661644,
-0.003675699,
-0.001788597,
0.0034886564,
-0.031946037,
-0.0062996852,
-0.0215713587,
0.0421023667,
-0.0367477201,
0.031346526,
0.0019029189,
0.0761663318,
-0.0565007143,
-0.0338069648,
-0.0335822664,
0.0260326788,
0.0237600394,
0.074790746,
0.0423998833,
-0.0616660938,
-0.0196049921,
0.0332216583,
0.0237059835,
0.0255490653,
-0.0302498732,
0.0142119452,
-0.0043838653,
-0.0279331431,
-0.0502630249,
-0.0875642896,
0.0156944394,
-0.0079781935,
-0.008300079,
-0.0463215634,
0.0037721712,
-0.0008569894,
-0.0122582903,
0.0242942348,
0.0278960783,
0.0632181764,
-0.0266805645,
0.021017611,
0.0501228385,
-0.0259303562,
0.0172318034,
-0.0045760525,
0.0244729836,
-0.0593553074,
0.0545260087,
0.04099942,
0.0181632321,
0.0024413294,
-0.0101717738,
-0.0680021718,
-0.013546342,
0.0427131616,
-0.0497641638,
0.0595519207,
0.0327686071,
0.0497453474,
-0.0151448399,
0.0492897183,
-0.0221971106,
0.0584466867,
-0.0244586524,
0.0223382954,
0.0021498527,
-0.0943386704,
-0.0120401615,
0.0370777696,
0.0166737903,
-0.0014149534,
-0.0215425603,
-0.0101022581,
-0.0290129557,
-0.02356961,
-0.0055939592,
-0.0496068001,
-0.0183214843,
0.0121790972,
0.0385406055,
-0.0168632325,
-0.0891492888,
-0.0529510267,
-0.0011845067,
-0.0184961502,
0.0317877866,
-0.0065344726,
0.0084626451,
-0.0324915275,
0.0340915583,
-0.0230115186,
-0.0044554635,
-0.0402629711,
0.0049235583,
0.0077666137,
0.0610253252,
0.0061074072,
-0.0362191573,
-0.0126013458,
0.0613106787,
-0.0072569181,
-0.0144693833,
-0.0015801635,
0.0325086638,
0.034448579,
-0.0001866279,
0.0825165883,
-0.058330778,
0.0346532576,
-0.0105789416,
-0.0022766152,
-0.0172085166,
-0.0236245543,
0.0243268348,
0.0137775466,
-0.0256732889,
-0.0003764834,
0.0083426153,
-0.0537230521,
0.0670420751,
-0.008457276,
-0.003030272,
-0.0434878059,
-0.0187393725,
0.0356366113,
-0.0364414006,
-0.0244580433,
0.0120274816,
-0.0872160122,
-0.0666038767,
0.0290232468,
-0.0122015029,
-0.0252953172,
-0.076607585,
0.019829262,
0.0389442481,
-0.0081154453,
0.0308145247,
-0.0211076066,
0.0273141563,
-0.0763382316,
-0.0100412713,
-0.0200681519,
-6.396603855e-33,
-0.0171423294,
-0.0147756292,
-0.0396401696,
-0.0180021301,
-0.0577976704,
-0.0032952994,
-0.0385702625,
0.0266778599,
-0.0255090632,
0.040061973,
-0.0302542392,
0.030964775,
0.012011786,
-0.0263745189,
0.0062328028,
0.0057737906,
0.0006357739,
-0.0054717641,
-0.0065063923,
0.0175873656,
0.0080519048,
0.0364965759,
0.027228415,
-0.099534452,
0.0421862081,
-0.019931091,
-0.0642845854,
0.0102296239,
0.0188924167,
0.0415200517,
-0.0348463729,
0.0724200755,
0.020172758,
0.0359996669,
0.0053340127,
0.0370269269,
-0.0136214569,
-0.0114180939,
0.0285677854,
-0.002505244,
-0.0367263965,
-0.044868011,
0.0269534923,
0.0142213469,
-0.051904209,
0.0071416413,
0.0062794564,
-0.0304072611,
0.033400327,
0.0059880516,
-0.0509327836,
-0.0000246904,
-0.0278784335,
-0.0481832139,
0.0106781311,
0.054701969,
-0.0348006152,
0.0031830305,
-0.028458301,
0.012674422,
-0.0401429497,
-0.0259797089,
0.0486197695,
-0.0403395183,
0.0304368995,
0.0985881463,
0.0263273008,
0.0179592595,
-0.0175812133,
0.0336679146,
0.0432701409,
0.0509825498,
0.0408591926,
0.0432198867,
-0.049711898,
-0.0419335999,
0.0593985282,
0.0343389437,
0.0649373904,
0.0502209403,
0.0519244224,
0.0190661587,
-0.0396026932,
0.0095969364,
-0.01119617,
-0.0364104547,
-0.0112818806,
-0.0240383744,
0.0316143781,
-0.0317111239,
0.0015270557,
-0.0381816924,
-0.0160467755,
-0.0323069133,
0.0325997137,
-0.0102518992,
-0.0469940417,
0.0688745379,
0.0105456244,
0.0360932574,
-0.0074082967,
-0.0327993333,
0.0095542595,
0.0342860632,
0.0753037557,
-0.009326716,
-0.0397698618,
0.0303824134,
-0.0339659303,
-0.0110837221,
-0.0140655385,
0.0384179763,
-0.0080097122,
-0.0044218381,
-0.034952689,
0.0000182481,
-0.0285953954,
-0.0172582045,
0.0092304116,
0.0249389112,
-0.0463292412,
-0.0260300599,
-0.0252880789,
0.0253039356,
-0.0511888638,
0.0056938562,
-0.0256444458,
-0.0247746911,
0.0218031965,
-0.0104963658,
-0.0160566662,
-0.0150904972,
2.988e-7,
-0.0154474359,
0.0423398986,
0.0124077778,
-0.0243410598,
0.0010301261,
0.0479678251,
-0.0379429571,
0.067654267,
0.0434961393,
-0.0201302394,
0.0443514548,
-0.0010879389,
0.0946951732,
0.0135025755,
-0.0822114125,
0.035384357,
-0.0482880063,
0.0063465871,
-0.0242527258,
0.0243273042,
0.0488286652,
0.0452673696,
0.0262151659,
-0.0135289161,
-0.0038203644,
0.0142573025,
0.004212366,
-0.0654533207,
-0.0047346465,
0.012832704,
0.0017504891,
-0.0016170433,
0.008460965,
-0.0058132745,
0.0284902491,
0.0174425803,
0.0233029984,
0.0853326917,
-0.0096917106,
-0.0552310459,
0.026012728,
0.0168949775,
-0.0089646876,
-0.0388640761,
0.0269720666,
-0.0539618507,
-0.0242216308,
-0.006612449,
0.0005752018,
-0.0078285234,
0.0428629629,
-0.0285930317,
-0.0485465527,
0.0326253213,
0.0126884868,
-0.0471068174,
-0.0371597856,
-0.0546796806,
0.017055219,
-0.0216909163,
-0.0402606614,
-0.0525436625,
-0.0254719201,
0.0361259356,
0.0078473436,
-0.0529787987,
0.0042366087,
2.014363395e-34,
0.019526884,
0.0211838875,
0.0039616674,
0.0665245578,
0.0453306064,
0.0234292205,
-0.0062719118,
0.0187441725,
0.0296822954,
-0.0677119121,
0.0096113877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03638v1 | KITLM: Domain-Specific Knowledge InTegration into Language Models for Question Answering | 2023-08-07T14:42:49 | 2023-08-07T14:42:49 | Ankush Agarwal, Sakharam Gawade, Amar Prakash Azad, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance in a
wide range of natural language tasks. However, as these models continue to grow
in size, they face significant challenges in terms of computational costs.
Additionally, LLMs often lack efficient domain-specific understanding, which is
particularly crucial in specialized fields such as aviation and healthcare. To
boost the domain-specific understanding, we propose, KITLM, a novel knowledge
base integration approach into language model through relevant information
infusion. By integrating pertinent knowledge, not only the performance of the
language model is greatly enhanced, but the model size requirement is also
significantly reduced while achieving comparable performance. Our proposed
knowledge-infused model surpasses the performance of both GPT-3.5-turbo and the
state-of-the-art knowledge infusion method, SKILL, achieving over 1.5 times
improvement in exact match scores on the MetaQA. KITLM showed a similar
performance boost in the aviation domain with AeroQA. The drastic performance
improvement of KITLM over the existing methods can be attributed to the
infusion of relevant knowledge while mitigating noise. In addition, we release
two curated datasets to accelerate knowledge infusion research in specialized
fields: a) AeroQA, a new benchmark dataset designed for multi-hop
question-answering within the aviation domain, and b) Aviation Corpus, a
dataset constructed from unstructured text extracted from the National
Transportation Safety Board reports. Our research contributes to advancing the
field of domain-specific language understanding and showcases the potential of
knowledge infusion techniques in improving the performance of language models
on question-answering. | [
0.0297533236,
0.0296531133,
0.0005333462,
0.0419231579,
-0.0251546912,
0.0152918743,
-0.0296218526,
-0.0331406146,
-0.0262868088,
-0.0689660683,
-0.032718759,
-0.013527655,
-0.0133831361,
0.0507524908,
0.0343553573,
-0.0043669962,
0.0688616037,
-0.0305133108,
-0.0063969339,
0.0106898211,
0.0167996157,
0.0290367231,
-0.0220753271,
0.0112455208,
0.0063410914,
-0.0194983147,
0.0021173526,
0.0187912174,
0.0475294925,
0.0094924904,
0.0197873991,
0.0454840846,
0.0796340778,
0.0203821156,
0.0000019836,
-0.0323466398,
0.0225562528,
-0.000411778,
-0.0657614246,
-0.0047960901,
-0.001703036,
-0.0034486395,
0.0249514673,
0.0376790166,
-0.0500425808,
0.0044491268,
0.0064316951,
0.0470286496,
0.108864516,
0.0671110824,
-0.0000458788,
-0.0119109238,
0.0292623155,
0.0017814578,
-0.008872238,
-0.0352695063,
0.0378371626,
0.0492338985,
0.0392133631,
-0.001244596,
-0.020498829,
0.0589495674,
0.0303704403,
0.0161980856,
0.0435541235,
0.0402204283,
-0.0535648465,
0.0408989117,
-0.0177144315,
0.0573301986,
-0.0144218924,
-0.0248778239,
-0.01957855,
0.032006532,
0.0180107336,
0.0254177358,
-0.039762456,
-0.0542410053,
-0.0139225191,
-0.0174989831,
0.0220189933,
0.004294611,
0.0319468044,
0.0187671762,
-0.0025405188,
0.0689040646,
0.0126277693,
-0.0482186116,
0.0164710656,
0.018257292,
-0.0415453576,
-0.0440238863,
-0.0269983783,
0.0451704971,
-0.0116985273,
0.0393037312,
-0.0252280887,
0.0166037381,
0.0198287312,
-0.0585010648,
0.0002257077,
0.0127404751,
0.005024523,
0.0940513313,
-0.0324440412,
0.0099757947,
-0.0064973799,
-0.0249392204,
-0.0683463365,
-0.065444462,
-0.0749926493,
-0.0478415079,
-0.0417062305,
0.0292644836,
-0.0329284631,
-0.0284050871,
-0.0218851175,
0.0131196249,
-0.0046464717,
-0.0165596977,
0.0296380799,
0.0196072534,
-0.0161293931,
-0.0128694754,
-0.0279194005,
0.0281673204,
-0.0176758766,
0.042703189,
-0.003346836,
-0.0509192199,
-0.0289851595,
0.0049380292,
-0.0049557732,
-0.0316581242,
-0.0223346371,
0.0580386668,
-0.0297126677,
-0.0208744891,
-0.0128111439,
-0.0542127639,
-0.0007755326,
-0.0701581314,
-0.0249328837,
-0.0736749098,
0.0215394553,
-0.0092635155,
-0.0115700243,
-0.0624217391,
-0.0065669888,
0.00892122,
-0.0291213561,
0.078707628,
-0.0484082438,
0.0057702465,
0.0352443904,
0.0355464667,
-0.0024430538,
0.0640653893,
-0.0092136785,
-0.0373353995,
0.0212703701,
0.0043192841,
0.0063808998,
0.016518062,
0.0496492833,
0.0204372518,
0.0019975018,
0.0681592971,
-0.0112229269,
0.0297596585,
0.0259003304,
-0.0231782161,
-0.0394455232,
0.0202603545,
0.0284754261,
0.0226052031,
0.0341175608,
-0.002774301,
0.0218343493,
0.0176929608,
0.0223667827,
-0.0517014228,
-0.0281920247,
0.0277015679,
-0.0309251714,
0.0127206985,
0.0331318751,
0.061113216,
-0.0340271033,
-0.0345602259,
-0.0096979504,
0.0055575161,
-0.0158351921,
0.0538919531,
0.0168676078,
0.0033632072,
0.0050314534,
0.0636656433,
0.0341455415,
0.0168314613,
0.024900211,
-0.0140771754,
-0.019215554,
0.0723129809,
0.0279551316,
-0.0125438888,
-0.0439455062,
-0.0396300219,
0.0382610001,
0.0293051396,
0.0005005152,
-0.0348652191,
0.0111607499,
-0.0300363135,
-0.0373835601,
0.0164270513,
0.0076889759,
0.0051557831,
0.0567895211,
0.0290540699,
0.012714115,
-0.0637723953,
0.0196193494,
0.001329776,
-0.0519364439,
-0.0235407744,
-0.0172710363,
-0.0125754857,
0.0197814573,
0.0351032205,
-0.015513462,
0.0050192317,
0.0326200575,
-0.0357454196,
-0.0532577857,
0.0104149394,
-0.0385883674,
-0.0433853976,
0.0462967679,
-0.00088467,
-0.0365245901,
0.0418280661,
-0.0321901701,
-0.0587313995,
-0.0179821234,
-0.016398171,
0.042630326,
-0.0440352187,
-0.0400140099,
0.0351531915,
0.0022582607,
-0.0589227527,
0.0796200112,
-0.0040961141,
-0.0066051446,
-0.0165911,
0.0057542217,
0.0176607911,
0.0047343601,
-0.0128649781,
0.005299387,
-0.0023240414,
0.0424454994,
0.001250682,
-0.0284466837,
-0.0858085826,
0.0310653187,
-0.0926600322,
0.0095136892,
-0.0054307641,
0.0099834045,
0.0386835709,
0.0423873626,
-0.0279354006,
-0.0121787442,
-0.0594302081,
-0.0342898853,
0.0213768538,
0.0198274851,
0.0275512002,
0.0260559171,
0.0139759425,
-0.0320331678,
-0.0134807182,
-0.0099906158,
0.0240151621,
0.0019743063,
0.0026156674,
-0.0684623048,
0.0245624967,
-0.0696733296,
0.0246666186,
-0.0072056209,
-0.0322302282,
-0.0061056311,
-0.0057107699,
0.0167737808,
0.0266598146,
-0.0027521823,
-0.0572835691,
0.0174272135,
-0.016631864,
-0.0665171817,
0.0309291594,
-0.0108896671,
0.0128441453,
-0.0102246841,
0.0299067404,
0.0363243446,
0.0631691515,
-0.0002128755,
-0.0215469096,
-0.0423723087,
0.0321767144,
-0.0161653813,
-0.0244900808,
-0.0614845417,
-0.0014865781,
-0.0054221312,
0.0422379486,
-0.0236747451,
-0.0123551833,
0.0886811242,
-0.0162282325,
-0.0030674408,
-0.0779407024,
-0.0065008528,
-0.0328316242,
0.0123731,
-0.0268118624,
0.0179380458,
-0.000838918,
0.0190058909,
-0.0147822741,
-0.0142578091,
-0.021244254,
-0.0232844148,
0.0663308576,
-0.0432982519,
0.0417517908,
0.0073228418,
-0.0422974043,
-0.0509165116,
-0.0394884571,
-0.0462448448,
0.0059725824,
-0.0279793367,
-0.0309952497,
-0.0225408971,
0.0097721247,
0.0457469411,
0.0105160205,
-0.0180751644,
-0.0232312363,
-0.004358972,
0.0698718801,
0.1130954921,
0.0326115489,
0.027303366,
0.0179688521,
0.024789989,
0.0605971813,
0.0378460437,
-0.0014692481,
0.0072350851,
-0.0025886411,
0.0073499004,
-0.0519498326,
0.0040616691,
0.0063380604,
0.0271536242,
-0.0282751229,
-0.0103855748,
0.1289294362,
0.0305122267,
-0.0180148128,
-0.0076904893,
-0.0115431957,
0.0266429987,
0.0239978395,
0.0537720509,
-0.0670901239,
-0.0611704551,
-0.0237070248,
-0.0132749379,
0.0430296734,
-0.0315669365,
0.0119113522,
-0.085127987,
0.0150173288,
-0.0134075284,
-0.0447473191,
-0.0757739991,
-0.0343374126,
0.0162548311,
-0.0065109138,
0.0021413206,
0.0028433816,
-0.005516537,
-0.0009900531,
0.0396681651,
0.0025964535,
-0.0844603851,
0.0385580547,
-0.0396023393,
0.0428719819,
0.0335043557,
-0.0006810456,
-0.0111402655,
0.0001675462,
0.0122093428,
-0.019310791,
-0.0140871452,
-0.0123968683,
0.0529158078,
-0.0338540748,
0.0034544994,
-0.0266832262,
0.0228481442,
-0.1066993177,
-0.0006301772,
0.0233200211,
0.0952184796,
0.0052583264,
0.0132864248,
-0.0394079499,
-0.0182520151,
-0.0110519808,
0.0825307146,
-0.010337715,
-0.0306595266,
-0.0028135958,
-0.0131126354,
-0.0243071448,
-0.0267183743,
-0.0520001166,
0.0314845741,
0.0389694311,
0.0005748243,
-0.0817239955,
-0.0522680804,
0.0487202927,
0.0204757731,
-0.028100986,
0.0791720673,
-0.0229995456,
0.0108259534,
-0.0611450374,
0.0392586999,
-0.0690782219,
0.0237339195,
-0.0248959083,
0.001429782,
0.040270187,
-0.0062433844,
-0.0511568747,
0.027716212,
-0.075521335,
-0.0293391328,
0.0141180996,
-0.0020488875,
0.0254130401,
0.0551028326,
-0.0406517833,
0.001179836,
0.0578041077,
-0.0242955778,
-0.0674576014,
0.009485824,
-0.0122034634,
-0.0427879766,
-0.0021127448,
0.0371245556,
-0.0456042923,
-0.0246060826,
0.0009673206,
0.0200567096,
-0.0437954254,
-0.0285508148,
0.0274540335,
-0.0252207089,
0.0018293345,
0.0306359027,
0.0098932879,
-0.0155970203,
0.0284031536,
0.0069409958,
-0.0316265784,
-0.0449116454,
-0.0163774826,
0.0287981443,
-0.0192891993,
0.0060179722,
0.0007331442,
-0.001894233,
0.0294480287,
-0.0237380359,
-0.0239205062,
0.0472357124,
-0.0092202015,
0.0310001336,
-0.0142794326,
-0.017323168,
-0.0233242325,
-0.0096551953,
0.0245257039,
-0.0274930466,
0.0116697317,
0.0170159806,
-0.0196524858,
-0.0046152314,
0.0348401368,
-0.0757160038,
-0.0431564488,
-0.0059944051,
0.0084485942,
0.0689150766,
-0.0052320319,
0.0436315723,
-0.0057706172,
-0.0059828851,
-0.0089024082,
-0.014335867,
0.0041103624,
0.0284336843,
0.0915018246,
0.0580515936,
0.0003853135,
0.0097209578,
0.1098243371,
0.0170570873,
0.0769865736,
-0.0071403547,
0.0023436227,
-0.0441410802,
-0.0113726016,
0.0265643187,
0.0354610942,
-0.0277792402,
0.0543485582,
-0.0624353625,
-0.0844925195,
0.0062130988,
-0.0055094874,
-0.0415819176,
-0.0237573832,
0.057129994,
0.0444470644,
0.0311949104,
-0.0520838909,
-0.0144554349,
-0.0082224226,
-0.0263756737,
-0.0326132886,
0.0127415946,
-6.58249947e-33,
-0.0329584517,
0.0135746021,
0.0200360361,
-0.0150486799,
-0.0140390778,
-0.0006181079,
-0.0029251631,
-0.0324308686,
-0.0370386392,
-0.0056621521,
0.0012776417,
0.0461434498,
-0.0032660882,
0.0236474089,
0.0042523947,
-0.0381384082,
0.0095125781,
0.0176583566,
0.0120470291,
0.0162077621,
0.0079208622,
0.0284371898,
0.02172474,
-0.0128218373,
0.0165546667,
-0.0242920928,
-0.0057999473,
0.0383685715,
-0.0099635683,
0.0786190033,
-0.0198453534,
0.0568941869,
0.0453796275,
-0.0649295226,
-0.0032257719,
0.0190276541,
-0.0978516415,
-0.0305889975,
0.0633780435,
-0.0167853683,
-0.0070927162,
-0.0288566686,
0.017584173,
0.0179283004,
0.0687291846,
-0.0591226555,
0.0427876413,
-0.030221289,
-0.0081830844,
-0.0301397964,
-0.0791537389,
0.0316792987,
0.0000841593,
-0.0304471403,
0.0066137379,
0.0495789275,
-0.0073865387,
0.0056744949,
-0.0277310014,
-0.0057686339,
0.0149852103,
0.0788282081,
0.0465973616,
0.0238567144,
-0.0225812271,
0.0354324989,
-0.0351410173,
-0.0244724993,
-0.011421985,
0.0153236436,
-0.0051852423,
0.0010376535,
0.0252259281,
0.0727133676,
0.0129318843,
0.032471668,
-0.0738400072,
0.0467229821,
-0.0252875946,
0.0550990738,
0.0051026964,
-0.0021946374,
-0.0331162512,
-0.0099031301,
-0.0344588794,
0.0525963455,
-0.0248602703,
-0.0338805504,
0.0284915213,
0.0024754356,
0.0052915029,
0.0114085944,
0.0189899765,
-0.0422804914,
0.0335083045,
0.0523085557,
0.0030093794,
0.0089501999,
0.0077401837,
0.0443236232,
-0.0750629082,
0.0492386445,
0.0133941146,
0.0198171865,
-0.0143956942,
0.0030697132,
0.014134651,
0.0114786476,
-0.0494811311,
0.0052665505,
-0.046198003,
0.0160314683,
-0.0204304662,
0.0335225575,
0.0195352919,
0.0593343005,
-0.0120560974,
-0.0012489817,
0.0236094631,
-0.033468388,
-0.0203392282,
-0.0134564983,
-0.0275044534,
0.0061406959,
-0.0401173793,
0.0168574434,
-0.0390996821,
-0.0109067541,
-0.0059170723,
-0.0660922378,
-0.0122378515,
0.0139204944,
2.666e-7,
0.0572439097,
0.0132576572,
0.0182155576,
0.0144960145,
0.0262830742,
0.0145447915,
-0.0150452964,
0.031629961,
0.043167945,
-0.018645864,
-0.0018120768,
0.0528412685,
0.0207137596,
0.0242594015,
-0.1096033454,
-0.0334122628,
-0.0323228315,
0.0032963536,
-0.0366181619,
-0.0165030472,
0.0710825399,
0.0950578377,
-0.0014951263,
-0.021484809,
-0.0340951905,
-0.043075487,
0.0496563017,
-0.0215775128,
-0.0512630381,
0.0149598643,
0.004458921,
0.0630271211,
-0.0094385343,
0.0567003563,
-0.0165103413,
0.0319004543,
0.026684735,
0.0578141622,
-0.0231616609,
-0.0033876586,
-0.0310250632,
-0.0295507032,
0.0146154109,
-0.0608136803,
0.0891468301,
-0.0487067774,
-0.0141900759,
-0.0158108305,
-0.0616888441,
-0.0031306553,
0.0082119731,
0.0081433281,
-0.0536495,
0.01232835,
0.0214044526,
0.0131242005,
0.0010696299,
-0.0900679678,
-0.0214252938,
0.0508484617,
-0.048701968,
-0.0182735808,
-0.0175469499,
-0.036999587,
0.0416698642,
-0.0472354442,
0.0039352253,
2.1981889e-34,
0.001374997,
0.0420700014,
0.0272165015,
0.0512418039,
0.0316551477,
-0.0251313709,
-0.0349840969,
-0.0211775042,
0.0163227711,
-0.0948798433,
0.0135957077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03629v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03629v2 | MedMine: Examining Pre-trained Language Models on Medication Mining | 2023-08-07T14:36:03 | 2023-08-08T15:38:21 | Haifa Alrdahi, Lifeng Han, Hendrik Šuvalov, Goran Nenadic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Automatic medication mining from clinical and biomedical text has become a
popular topic due to its real impact on healthcare applications and the recent
development of powerful language models (LMs). However, fully-automatic
extraction models still face obstacles to be overcome such that they can be
deployed directly into clinical practice for better impacts. Such obstacles
include their imbalanced performances on different entity types and clinical
events. In this work, we examine current state-of-the-art pre-trained language
models (PLMs) on such tasks, via fine-tuning including the monolingual model
Med7 and multilingual large language model (LLM) XLM-RoBERTa. We compare their
advantages and drawbacks using historical medication mining shared task data
sets from n2c2-2018 challenges. We report the findings we get from these
fine-tuning experiments such that they can facilitate future research on
addressing them, for instance, how to combine their outputs, merge such models,
or improve their overall accuracy by ensemble learning and data augmentation.
MedMine is part of the M3 Initiative \url{https://github.com/HECTA-UoM/M3} | [
0.0430680513,
0.0259414501,
0.0078985151,
0.0209989622,
0.0150465751,
0.0224877596,
-0.0130599504,
0.0053515052,
0.027697701,
-0.0091095865,
-0.0290132295,
-0.0402369089,
-0.0296168439,
0.0187351461,
0.0077108815,
-0.0034344178,
0.0110361399,
0.0157319419,
-0.0060123657,
0.0222244207,
-0.0030240847,
0.0061402856,
-0.0229012519,
0.0351371877,
0.0357410945,
0.0081450399,
0.0558831394,
-0.0091245435,
0.0215150733,
-0.0638902783,
0.0081470525,
0.0320341066,
-0.0235986337,
0.031715367,
0.0000017573,
-0.0636715814,
-0.0380964838,
0.0272534247,
-0.0519246683,
-0.0359598584,
0.0386449732,
-0.0395325683,
-0.0058532292,
0.0151236169,
-0.0369904861,
-0.046055425,
0.0056002401,
0.0421886407,
0.0024156587,
0.0585590787,
-0.0125618428,
0.0384045206,
0.0209129564,
-0.0531593487,
0.0024914951,
-0.0471842811,
0.0635038242,
-0.0158768315,
0.028575886,
-0.0141671812,
0.0378240794,
0.0132306889,
-0.0407360978,
0.0061023985,
-0.0012456777,
0.0346512571,
-0.0543798581,
-0.0284165889,
0.0047665215,
0.0869672745,
-0.0467186309,
0.0253198724,
0.0276834927,
-0.0133758243,
-0.0248071551,
-0.0232888926,
-0.0179054309,
0.0127567798,
-0.0416540913,
0.0450469479,
0.013227812,
-0.0120831951,
0.0416796543,
0.0106988782,
-0.0332299657,
0.037622828,
0.0016004712,
0.0030334201,
0.0778474286,
0.01106242,
-0.0380240232,
0.0014016591,
0.0566770732,
0.031466458,
-0.0208931677,
0.0314160548,
-0.000199711,
-0.0459390841,
0.0828641132,
-0.0724107921,
0.0421242788,
0.0019663624,
-0.0317788981,
0.07202667,
-0.011300467,
-0.0268983133,
0.0164103545,
0.0343021527,
-0.0399807952,
0.0027658255,
-0.0158181284,
0.0081323925,
-0.0193396397,
0.0171704795,
-0.0121588418,
0.0130441161,
-0.0587943755,
-0.0196589157,
-0.0039921659,
0.0061616059,
0.0333451182,
0.0231665671,
-0.027636366,
-0.0287235286,
0.0296997,
0.0373347513,
0.0147462189,
0.0356744081,
-0.024236666,
-0.0748769268,
0.0123065459,
0.0093288608,
0.0025449747,
-0.0449112244,
0.0481176078,
0.0406040698,
0.0200483613,
-0.0646364018,
-0.0292353686,
-0.0216061398,
-0.0155089665,
-0.0453475378,
0.0276297797,
-0.0427466072,
0.0751303285,
-0.0125290072,
0.0201707557,
-0.0427919291,
0.0242716782,
-0.0203686114,
-0.0709616467,
0.0684661716,
-0.0386356041,
-0.0338042565,
0.0079365755,
0.0224683881,
-0.0022676862,
0.0381764695,
0.0297693256,
-0.0006400133,
0.0402042605,
-0.0194165315,
0.0266986638,
0.0524030253,
0.0055771964,
-0.0460399687,
0.030011801,
0.0337117426,
0.009734178,
0.0250823591,
-0.0106333941,
0.0449139103,
0.0107543226,
-0.0151396329,
0.0219705906,
0.0302636083,
0.0405421406,
-0.01008627,
0.0054453695,
-0.0570351966,
0.025811702,
-0.0569873154,
-0.0000849303,
-0.0508352704,
-0.0058755861,
-0.0042294129,
0.0018100033,
0.0405592248,
-0.0172965452,
-0.0372361951,
-0.0272212978,
-0.0278654192,
-0.0339644402,
-0.0009311237,
0.0606334135,
-0.0326851793,
-0.0511928797,
0.0606855154,
0.0666334555,
-0.0513450019,
0.0129831629,
-0.0356243849,
-0.0170513615,
0.0374423824,
0.0244427249,
-0.0723655149,
-0.0091546103,
-0.0098169651,
0.0002873148,
-0.0102792047,
0.006695305,
-0.0150416913,
0.0602214746,
-0.0533399023,
0.0016477467,
0.0419013016,
0.0167562626,
-0.0212868173,
-0.0042051217,
0.0241490193,
-0.0267934669,
-0.0457370244,
-0.0321763866,
0.0551611893,
-0.039495144,
-0.040499676,
0.0234699268,
-0.0077822939,
0.006330559,
0.011649156,
-0.0192985311,
0.0237373896,
0.0782583579,
-0.0465734638,
-0.0210523363,
-0.0024852175,
0.0296510905,
-0.064188078,
0.0347170383,
0.0053313216,
0.0336650722,
-0.0466802418,
-0.0454546213,
-0.0007481619,
-0.0141173797,
0.0060994416,
0.0371835679,
0.0006711836,
0.0473530404,
0.0223440807,
0.0307493061,
-0.0527719073,
0.0081919739,
-0.0159885157,
0.0028360977,
-0.0129767517,
-0.0727623478,
-0.0023859974,
-0.0016543891,
-0.0143859694,
0.061111439,
0.0031924942,
0.0294868685,
-0.0295791123,
-0.0163547974,
-0.0197980236,
-0.0395784043,
-0.0659421161,
0.0278711002,
-0.001272606,
0.0280863624,
0.010066756,
0.0319360122,
-0.0158563759,
-0.04125496,
0.0124752717,
-0.0484874956,
-0.0003145052,
0.0003531334,
0.0184141621,
0.0561313257,
0.0259620771,
-0.056395065,
-0.015943706,
-0.0285100248,
0.0462828092,
-0.0341621228,
-0.0164862256,
-0.0018687024,
-0.0077005769,
-0.0206006989,
-0.001610223,
-0.0264515951,
0.0152331144,
-0.0155299362,
-0.0136227785,
0.0130321961,
0.0402997881,
-0.0086235311,
0.0476667434,
0.0487767532,
0.0017534326,
0.0277215447,
0.0126140825,
-0.0431552492,
-0.0143854981,
0.0238466244,
-0.0281419177,
0.0061368183,
0.0825528204,
-0.0132856602,
0.008283319,
0.0027378199,
-0.0637968108,
-0.0207867119,
0.0359579735,
-0.0262372289,
0.0227094796,
-0.0353059061,
0.0011935628,
-0.0096667362,
-0.0637409985,
0.0618508011,
-0.036535766,
0.0141462274,
-0.0910480917,
-0.0396969989,
-0.0478293113,
-0.0233848598,
0.0224022176,
0.0084104761,
-0.0099255759,
0.0022473631,
0.0365309753,
-0.0175010748,
0.0117621413,
-0.0614103861,
0.0697737262,
-0.0101809036,
0.0396617427,
-0.002089326,
-0.029204512,
-0.0285670385,
-0.0253449623,
-0.0382818356,
0.0030485501,
0.0137038995,
0.021281505,
-0.0654639676,
0.0429750048,
-0.0358617418,
0.0548140071,
0.0335359797,
-0.0024518077,
0.015471248,
-0.0087341163,
0.0466320403,
-0.0447392873,
0.0120796654,
-0.0334845297,
0.0465648733,
0.0549310409,
0.024543535,
0.0026689409,
0.018506242,
0.0120060761,
0.0244573336,
-0.0332514718,
0.0110780867,
0.0259516165,
0.0284420587,
-0.0293659363,
0.0147316046,
0.0948862731,
0.032013692,
-0.0698310286,
0.0331282802,
0.0048314794,
-0.0452277549,
-0.0173131134,
0.0170932245,
-0.032718122,
-0.0358650088,
-0.0137973782,
0.028711414,
0.0001574647,
-0.0447451472,
-0.014176772,
-0.0633901358,
-0.0015677614,
0.0154829789,
-0.0507472306,
0.0146449823,
-0.0455385782,
-0.0085534081,
-0.0507091768,
-0.011179124,
-0.0233989935,
-0.0362129882,
-0.0106791938,
0.0227662493,
-0.0617491081,
-0.0781596676,
0.0086819539,
-0.0583238937,
0.0173178297,
0.050876677,
0.0066137514,
-0.0210090112,
0.0115635619,
0.0255046412,
-0.0256909281,
-0.0242932532,
-0.0058382885,
0.0939772725,
-0.0088042989,
-0.0100103896,
-0.0273956079,
0.0241950192,
-0.0694955438,
-0.05070908,
-0.0294086896,
0.0654283538,
-0.0312507339,
-0.0358781517,
-0.0306949466,
0.0215706825,
0.0412448198,
0.0480505787,
-0.0097464258,
0.0091069499,
0.013636292,
0.013624724,
0.0374170169,
-0.0194057003,
0.0025651527,
0.0380575918,
-0.0303310789,
0.0023520219,
-0.0475038998,
-0.0420260578,
0.0816662461,
-0.0150557049,
-0.0060738563,
0.0328207538,
0.0127465082,
0.0094788121,
-0.0447150581,
0.0644073635,
0.0444585793,
0.0334502868,
-0.0742571652,
-0.0529347323,
0.0215826649,
0.0181372799,
-0.0155046973,
0.0095746955,
-0.0671352893,
-0.0424167514,
0.0092042582,
0.0339216553,
0.0163550638,
0.0022287054,
-0.0062783505,
-0.0128710391,
0.0428430401,
0.0503475964,
0.0031022865,
-0.0630732775,
-0.0140519114,
-0.048688747,
-0.0244746357,
0.0146373184,
-0.0201365482,
0.0436626002,
0.0185144376,
0.0402324349,
0.0232122447,
-0.0349876098,
0.009472739,
0.0063464423,
0.0495425276,
-0.0201047901,
-0.0312692001,
-0.0551775321,
0.016908953,
0.0037728271,
0.0316605382,
-0.0237985458,
-0.0030213024,
0.023647273,
-0.0332359709,
-0.0338151455,
0.0526572801,
-0.0518888049,
-0.0270793047,
-0.0100649111,
0.0496262535,
-0.0183981787,
0.0049252301,
0.0713754892,
-0.019822279,
0.0280441605,
0.0429694094,
0.0096292701,
0.0389502384,
-0.0189202521,
0.041020669,
-0.0220539663,
0.0337529555,
-0.0122539382,
0.0752595216,
-0.0299741123,
-0.0245434288,
-0.0431970209,
0.0210970379,
0.0822984427,
-0.0552018546,
0.0662686899,
-0.0136185251,
-0.0057108589,
-0.0505049825,
0.0103072543,
-0.012802247,
0.0467697196,
0.0480431132,
0.0196095314,
-0.0609503277,
-0.0028293936,
0.1086579338,
-0.0107362457,
0.0637562275,
0.035645213,
-0.0259376466,
-0.0204921309,
-0.0095502017,
0.0085340543,
0.0103629781,
-0.0867386609,
0.0025714154,
-0.0437589064,
-0.0399909504,
0.0194936544,
-0.0246610567,
-0.0568352155,
0.0133265294,
0.002900034,
0.0673591867,
0.0210852791,
-0.0139755914,
-0.0355073884,
0.0287737306,
-0.0096596079,
-0.0110974815,
0.0394321159,
-5.435711794e-33,
0.0108508682,
-0.0036130168,
-0.008678603,
-0.0140404254,
0.0381716788,
0.028448185,
-0.0186805613,
-0.0106996242,
-0.0118008712,
0.0408729836,
-0.0243837275,
0.0043912893,
0.0176270325,
0.0117413457,
-0.0175836403,
0.0044107377,
0.0060654366,
0.0340267159,
-0.0310644303,
0.009619562,
-0.005317295,
0.1066684946,
0.078733854,
-0.0385374911,
0.0245879795,
0.0097971838,
0.0394433141,
0.012329733,
0.0101484945,
0.0883779153,
-0.0558821075,
0.0425346568,
0.0274388865,
-0.0310949646,
-0.003545712,
-0.0312576964,
-0.0667736679,
-0.0035660816,
-0.0146516627,
-0.006900073,
-0.0038202538,
-0.0140460338,
0.0291490294,
-0.0069870525,
-0.0339624174,
0.0101522431,
0.0345886163,
-0.0273604393,
-0.0112354904,
-0.0293733627,
-0.042636618,
0.0511395149,
0.0081914244,
-0.0074087419,
-0.0012930111,
-0.0244812164,
-0.0096041942,
0.0754026994,
-0.0493701547,
-0.0011502667,
-0.0004923524,
0.0331736021,
0.009391888,
0.0000250474,
-0.0306211039,
0.0804815069,
0.0039142519,
0.0242991932,
-0.0024473488,
0.0083407518,
-0.0299212392,
0.0536139682,
0.0175115429,
0.0061222701,
0.0450278856,
-0.0051978002,
-0.1018860266,
0.0543575697,
-0.031375967,
0.0175220221,
0.0009915535,
-0.0196329281,
-0.0335600376,
-0.0142294308,
-0.0013194553,
0.0012845426,
-0.0198725276,
-0.0148547525,
0.0025307431,
0.0147880232,
-0.0020589067,
0.050084278,
-0.0001376649,
-0.0378205031,
-0.0472678021,
-0.0222438741,
0.0195454061,
-0.0140990652,
-0.0188180823,
0.0169384349,
-0.0465131067,
-0.0225431882,
0.016795259,
-0.0585051924,
0.0140881501,
0.0098262373,
0.0349457227,
-0.0279734991,
-0.0552051812,
-0.0025127425,
-0.0096867755,
-0.0058750706,
0.0230497345,
0.0790701509,
0.0082668215,
0.0435508117,
-0.0004495391,
0.0662555993,
0.0274491888,
-0.0151807265,
-0.0253357161,
-0.0343688615,
0.0424330644,
0.0126754744,
-0.0136783812,
-0.000438548,
-0.0366086401,
0.0325767472,
0.0722158998,
-0.0533795543,
-0.0031325037,
-0.0548183396,
2.539e-7,
0.1268029958,
0.0214583427,
-0.0123173902,
-0.0656129271,
0.0006548493,
0.0175036341,
-0.0550202355,
0.0090999529,
-0.0370923579,
0.0264490973,
0.0299616158,
0.0069337673,
0.0605632365,
0.0444553085,
-0.0186921079,
-0.0417867377,
-0.0620904341,
-0.062339209,
-0.0610923059,
-0.046920076,
-0.0151165696,
0.1151422709,
-0.0046125562,
-0.0353377871,
-0.0114954337,
-0.0649437308,
0.0319698304,
-0.0583964102,
-0.0141587248,
0.0650471523,
0.0263415314,
0.0008486893,
-0.027020935,
0.0173413549,
-0.0373894684,
0.0109609058,
0.0083034644,
0.1003287882,
-0.0615565889,
0.0185487196,
0.0167728867,
-0.0153049976,
0.0128253233,
-0.0133186411,
0.0503447689,
-0.0099951802,
-0.0461192951,
-0.0360190868,
0.0026210467,
-0.0223781206,
0.0863979384,
-0.018246593,
-0.0054495861,
0.0627957359,
0.0325134583,
0.0276493933,
-0.0520758703,
-0.0857531801,
-0.0312885717,
0.0549460016,
-0.0327464305,
-0.0346392728,
0.0395055376,
-0.026765842,
-0.0194378477,
-0.0781684592,
0.0428804047,
2.323956005e-34,
0.0216371436,
0.0122421179,
0.0007222443,
0.0214965455,
0.0425550938,
-0.0274768509,
-0.0091296406,
0.0039886907,
-0.0470630638,
-0.0873720869,
0.0151472744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03601v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03601v1 | Negative Lexical Constraints in Neural Machine Translation | 2023-08-07T14:04:15 | 2023-08-07T14:04:15 | Josef Jon, Dušan Variš, Michal Novák, João Paulo Aires, Ondřej Bojar | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper explores negative lexical constraining in English to Czech neural
machine translation. Negative lexical constraining is used to prohibit certain
words or expressions in the translation produced by the neural translation
model. We compared various methods based on modifying either the decoding
process or the training data. The comparison was performed on two tasks:
paraphrasing and feedback-based translation refinement. We also studied to
which extent these methods "evade" the constraints presented to the model
(usually in the dictionary form) by generating a different surface form of a
given constraint.We propose a way to mitigate the issue through training with
stemmed negative constraints to counter the model's ability to induce a variety
of the surface forms of a word that can result in bypassing the constraint. We
demonstrate that our method improves the constraining, although the problem
still persists in many cases. | [
0.0394903161,
0.047659751,
0.0066912188,
0.0560276322,
-0.0114325443,
-0.0113276178,
-0.0439142063,
-0.0148382001,
-0.0534206964,
-0.0119172111,
-0.0294436235,
-0.0181197226,
0.0262420923,
-0.0060592806,
0.0499860607,
-0.0376715697,
0.0515054762,
0.0041306838,
-0.0404475443,
-0.0119272312,
0.0200150181,
-0.0048086392,
-0.0015886455,
0.0125784921,
-0.0052429945,
0.0235454645,
0.0295561962,
0.0552886501,
-0.0257822778,
-0.0152349705,
-0.0002627139,
0.0004735339,
0.002821143,
0.0282791108,
0.0000018296,
-0.0476708673,
-0.0444196276,
-0.0192803424,
0.0140613792,
0.0075229891,
0.1001045927,
-0.1197980046,
-0.0016482393,
0.0046958486,
-0.0352077968,
-0.0070942696,
0.0681855083,
0.0147105837,
0.0846492574,
0.0557166152,
-0.0194919631,
-0.0252248216,
-0.0073497309,
-0.0397449397,
-0.0446677841,
-0.0405422151,
-0.0066306,
-0.0324499495,
-0.0264045801,
-0.0116121527,
-0.0275980942,
0.0570612065,
0.0123327486,
-0.0056572771,
-0.0034769764,
-0.0038188663,
-0.0188820399,
-0.0599943437,
-0.0204803795,
0.0717359707,
0.0156625081,
-0.0232399609,
-0.0206111968,
-0.0061076554,
-0.0021652728,
0.0048546926,
-0.0269521531,
0.0444526561,
0.0156587195,
0.0104391556,
-0.0026237175,
0.0262872595,
0.0116469925,
-0.0007073933,
-0.0059889858,
0.0063734646,
0.0363683403,
-0.0546110719,
0.0234213639,
0.0125144972,
0.0142109068,
0.0472385101,
0.0555427596,
-0.0024624448,
0.0098338481,
0.009027455,
-0.0148820411,
-0.0401066355,
0.0096864412,
-0.0857421085,
0.0158174913,
0.0544754378,
0.0417017154,
-0.0054730643,
-0.0140173528,
0.0479521416,
-0.0467222519,
0.031750299,
-0.0850701854,
-0.0018062098,
-0.0420808271,
0.0054174145,
-0.088773787,
0.0110661453,
-0.0428865775,
-0.0041373246,
-0.0175831262,
-0.004517247,
-0.0112944245,
-0.0041486141,
-0.0123810256,
0.0180478469,
-0.0545943975,
0.0134366853,
-0.0110155633,
0.0327094831,
-0.0276336744,
-0.0138076432,
-0.0424666069,
0.0159632396,
-0.0296533313,
0.005761222,
-0.0124998381,
-0.0478561819,
-0.0177232567,
0.051927425,
-0.0112331957,
0.0332489349,
-0.0012627695,
-0.0302996673,
-0.0257237609,
-0.025886016,
0.0209381673,
-0.0099564549,
-0.0032929715,
-0.0286196545,
0.0077714566,
-0.0977233648,
0.0105428314,
0.0020260715,
-0.0342320241,
0.0851565748,
0.0053669135,
-0.0200514905,
0.0146525782,
0.001844877,
0.0109764012,
0.0300040971,
0.0186090656,
-0.0080407076,
0.0078303218,
0.0189927537,
0.007032197,
0.0442905091,
0.0572114177,
-0.0099070864,
-0.0904369354,
0.0039698309,
0.01678521,
0.0363612287,
0.0557173453,
0.0659945384,
-0.0382636748,
-0.0191531647,
0.0776943415,
0.0175271053,
-0.0214635432,
0.0574137792,
0.0325003155,
-0.0102578141,
-0.0184561778,
0.0116613423,
-0.0510035045,
-0.0269166362,
-0.0176429078,
0.0316414572,
-0.0207587909,
-0.0037728804,
0.0029916193,
-0.0369345993,
-0.0004825777,
-0.010115318,
0.0848428905,
-0.0790542811,
0.0080645625,
0.0441560261,
-0.0580277331,
0.0601437613,
-0.0160235018,
-0.060404744,
0.0170677956,
0.0159163028,
-0.0430396162,
0.0407872051,
0.05267822,
-0.0073837512,
-0.0535718426,
-0.0108747967,
-0.0513878688,
0.0867436454,
0.0931537524,
0.0052958657,
0.0350868814,
-0.040524289,
-0.0009134217,
0.0164435506,
0.0061275163,
-0.0091452524,
-0.0061315964,
0.0259293765,
0.0440209657,
0.0017708619,
-0.0686635226,
0.045418866,
-0.0039745891,
-0.0562472083,
0.0121776005,
0.02176838,
0.0118387258,
0.0247363206,
0.0221417155,
0.0329290181,
0.0328698307,
-0.0633529499,
-0.0291353278,
0.0161932465,
-0.0821725652,
-0.0526183695,
0.014829387,
-0.0509730838,
0.0484897867,
0.0543615632,
0.0026780847,
-0.0462197736,
0.0722356215,
-0.0335378125,
0.049916137,
-0.0222034119,
0.0281348918,
0.0208461229,
0.0235917605,
-0.0430439003,
0.0079046609,
-0.0289391465,
-0.0103435302,
0.0318869539,
-0.033319734,
0.0036972701,
-0.0218367018,
-0.0365615375,
0.0357697755,
0.0272622295,
0.025152823,
0.0287224222,
0.0287247263,
-0.0113676852,
0.0043114582,
-0.0234738793,
0.0210654754,
0.0107284645,
0.0292653833,
0.0384773128,
0.0088563208,
0.0185478888,
-0.0441709384,
-0.0008239475,
0.0037855203,
-0.0051287515,
-0.0070737735,
0.0232891943,
0.037546359,
0.0107953781,
-0.0247607306,
-0.0151624,
-0.001417277,
0.0060796244,
-0.0137356035,
-0.036043562,
-0.047191795,
0.0535419285,
-0.0347223058,
0.0497267507,
0.0044314098,
-0.0890640989,
-0.0110568181,
-0.0251527391,
0.0074419514,
0.0474850163,
-0.0531459861,
-0.0511808321,
0.0241795257,
0.0100991456,
-0.0330073126,
-0.0012043898,
-0.0435421802,
-0.0134385759,
0.004756798,
-0.0075868764,
0.0007453404,
0.0478274077,
0.0101972083,
-0.0039949398,
-0.0779795945,
0.0396317728,
-0.0614043511,
-0.0229557063,
0.0018936524,
-0.00877399,
-0.0160417669,
0.0008709939,
-0.0364398621,
-0.0348675251,
0.0638383478,
-0.0313050374,
-0.0238900259,
-0.0124947289,
0.0265922435,
-0.0333922319,
0.0470811538,
-0.010275485,
0.0084479041,
0.0393434092,
-0.008130678,
-0.041394785,
-0.0512455776,
0.0424147993,
-0.0078439461,
0.0252304152,
-0.0561883599,
-0.0076577291,
-0.043174006,
-0.0268313643,
-0.0209532492,
-0.0630521774,
0.0394012034,
0.0061402121,
0.0325470157,
-0.0115965093,
0.0278886706,
0.0086912382,
-0.0268887896,
0.0754435435,
-0.0360310823,
0.007743943,
-0.05082139,
-0.0083868178,
0.0065386845,
0.0254439767,
0.0018085294,
-0.0319912657,
0.0046172012,
-0.0268011466,
-0.019229928,
-0.0076431045,
0.0103089865,
0.0121827396,
0.055898115,
0.0058003911,
-0.0276018661,
-0.0227762852,
0.0206766929,
-0.0602888912,
-0.0547978729,
0.1082319543,
0.0238225311,
-0.0472320765,
0.0095540453,
-0.0232517757,
0.0478411354,
0.0334907994,
0.023473911,
-0.0172319673,
-0.0150799397,
-0.0063498439,
0.0802840069,
0.0289936606,
0.0078804297,
-0.0455625728,
-0.1169285625,
-0.0453889035,
0.0594623163,
-0.0571136996,
-0.0484898388,
0.0306023601,
-0.048527915,
-0.0500175282,
0.0318124369,
-0.0018166504,
-0.0047996254,
-0.0026888894,
0.0033761822,
0.0278496761,
-0.0312115606,
-0.0433766246,
-0.0523236543,
0.0268227775,
0.0575035252,
0.0173315853,
-0.0127503546,
-0.0025160038,
0.02588051,
-0.0079565886,
0.0059597399,
-0.0237205531,
0.0010483846,
0.0500461981,
-0.0087879151,
0.0187082142,
-0.0109234275,
-0.0400688946,
0.0058052004,
-0.0029676955,
0.0569096766,
0.0080915606,
0.0162398592,
0.0173174459,
0.0032583233,
0.0218331926,
0.0740154758,
0.0056603584,
-0.0125681367,
0.0029943876,
0.0073497966,
-0.014272063,
-0.0765929446,
-0.0293674301,
0.0005538945,
-0.0315245502,
-0.0197128225,
-0.1251678318,
-0.0715266243,
-0.0344137475,
0.0493309051,
0.044296246,
0.0339053981,
0.0309248343,
-0.02966596,
-0.0274436641,
0.0346248895,
-0.0163550731,
0.0070670107,
-0.0259567499,
0.0097731864,
0.0308176167,
-0.0316534005,
0.0169655252,
0.0409513824,
-0.0402578712,
-0.064591296,
-0.0289242398,
0.0630664304,
0.0288577136,
0.0866176337,
-0.05057339,
-0.0539549142,
-0.0048251944,
0.0064603263,
-0.0174156129,
0.0062610162,
0.0564868525,
-0.0150851803,
0.0010886394,
0.03237582,
-0.0029426112,
0.004237128,
0.0137279443,
0.04111588,
-0.023954222,
-0.039015267,
0.0481867082,
0.0012274734,
0.0199341904,
-0.0162220374,
-0.0106363241,
-0.0186326392,
0.0171846356,
-0.0246130936,
-0.01326223,
-0.0255098157,
0.0096902596,
0.0590963326,
-0.0307790861,
-0.0084842127,
-0.0059480402,
-0.0245625209,
-0.0003680645,
-0.0209871251,
-0.0374629311,
0.0214666314,
0.031545639,
-0.0144542577,
0.0453561544,
-0.0034690914,
0.0550830625,
-0.0352163278,
0.0050753616,
-0.0506840162,
0.0339429043,
-0.0036200664,
0.0113091823,
-0.0451499373,
0.0164680015,
-0.0216275807,
0.0631259084,
-0.0084373066,
-0.0118491007,
0.0302198734,
0.0006271016,
0.1081571952,
0.0127289351,
-0.0191160552,
0.0089958468,
0.0202737525,
0.0227873102,
-0.0060732844,
0.0110850986,
-0.0061055389,
0.0259552486,
-0.0176590569,
0.0388964638,
0.0369654857,
0.0199637674,
-0.0247752052,
-0.0123838577,
-0.0307999179,
-0.0191686265,
0.0050210147,
-0.0093278578,
-0.0201944858,
0.0159606729,
-0.054016076,
-0.0564083457,
0.0084368419,
0.0241328739,
0.004582386,
0.0012844509,
0.0282328781,
0.0147571936,
-0.0528467111,
-0.0477552377,
-0.0350953043,
0.0472748019,
0.014086619,
-0.015653234,
-0.0641510561,
-5.765966931e-33,
-0.0486402586,
0.0086781345,
0.0172207728,
-0.0460160412,
-0.0753281042,
-0.0145744849,
-0.0181159452,
-0.0366983376,
0.0158096962,
0.0068794005,
0.0037740294,
0.000053948,
0.0226455536,
-0.0090622809,
0.0109063536,
-0.0073185409,
0.0462160967,
0.0304475799,
-0.0112408996,
0.0199222863,
0.0384741612,
0.030879302,
0.0811681747,
-0.0505524315,
0.0317601636,
-0.0504270308,
-0.0107017485,
0.0376747176,
0.0397939943,
0.0164364614,
-0.0276445784,
-0.0112705035,
0.013160238,
-0.0715813637,
-0.0416979194,
-0.0169661604,
-0.0779846758,
-0.0360294171,
0.0529291816,
0.0413168594,
-0.0026745738,
-0.0640076622,
0.1076767594,
-0.0350370295,
-0.0317733847,
0.0854538009,
-0.0122625455,
-0.0275829174,
-0.0240644254,
-0.0035479623,
-0.1129325479,
-0.0027239546,
0.0175745916,
-0.0466292575,
0.0258263666,
0.0460413098,
-0.0240791421,
-0.0346728787,
-0.036860168,
-0.0060023558,
-0.0044084531,
0.068312265,
0.0464520939,
0.031422317,
-0.0204719231,
-0.0177544151,
-0.022137234,
-0.0420762077,
0.0146676358,
0.0013701116,
0.0458491705,
-0.0059685754,
0.0692494586,
0.0739271492,
0.0424032472,
-0.0355440229,
-0.0347109027,
0.0020481737,
-0.0548116975,
0.0335434638,
0.0123684965,
-0.0124045713,
-0.0254089627,
-0.0228734352,
-0.0332792252,
-0.0579619631,
-0.0116633521,
0.0339234062,
0.0473447554,
0.0343113132,
-0.0374394916,
0.0308124665,
0.044271417,
-0.0260152202,
0.0394739062,
0.0214589704,
0.0027025877,
-0.0105066178,
-0.014684719,
0.0260286313,
-0.0251296237,
-0.0340452865,
0.0011127578,
0.0510373823,
0.0253427345,
-0.0087166624,
0.0416834988,
0.0326566696,
-0.0203592815,
0.0056763603,
-0.0549022332,
0.0158571154,
0.0008311559,
0.026626518,
0.0435912162,
-0.0028148831,
-0.0147832334,
0.0232433416,
0.0653920248,
-0.011987594,
-0.0147874365,
-0.0035802992,
0.077822946,
0.0493184328,
-0.0381074175,
0.019912025,
0.0258035697,
0.0228584148,
0.0316574946,
-0.0635320246,
-0.0132374736,
-0.0082165645,
2.581e-7,
0.0418879054,
0.0617623627,
0.0177305192,
0.0284811333,
0.016472213,
0.0238748398,
-0.0383143201,
0.0264003389,
-0.0479638912,
0.0434380695,
0.0371471047,
0.0093152002,
0.0318720974,
0.0251653511,
-0.0633022636,
-0.0144661106,
-0.0287608169,
0.0441448502,
-0.02581474,
0.0044238651,
0.0933881104,
0.0977241397,
-0.0041649737,
-0.0050985683,
-0.0459460877,
-0.070185788,
0.0644418225,
0.0118602319,
-0.0101338318,
-0.0167655833,
0.0161607936,
0.0230021104,
-0.0467058048,
0.0115289744,
-0.0017378518,
0.0138252154,
0.0225405116,
0.0801371783,
-0.0342362709,
-0.0278971698,
-0.0034705184,
-0.0479833372,
-0.0182789676,
-0.003540803,
0.0407702513,
-0.0274051074,
0.0259898622,
0.0170997493,
0.0215172209,
0.0693617836,
0.0317259841,
-0.0526959822,
-0.0265510771,
-0.0017551603,
0.037390735,
0.0227819458,
-0.0418093652,
-0.0452816933,
-0.044082161,
-0.0304081459,
0.0295529198,
0.0102741122,
-0.003018176,
0.0164941605,
-0.0350531228,
-0.0264539458,
-0.0098604765,
2.063652424e-34,
0.0253547318,
-0.0243255328,
0.0207605138,
-0.027426241,
0.0123559041,
0.008247558,
-0.0134487106,
0.0265983399,
0.0078358911,
-0.0193680208,
-0.0168715231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03582v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03582v2 | WIKITIDE: A Wikipedia-Based Timestamped Definition Pairs Dataset | 2023-08-07T13:38:54 | 2023-08-18T12:31:52 | Hsuvas Borkakoty, Luis Espinosa-Anke | cs.CL | cs.CL | A fundamental challenge in the current NLP context, dominated by language
models, comes from the inflexibility of current architectures to 'learn' new
information. While model-centric solutions like continual learning or
parameter-efficient fine tuning are available, the question still remains of
how to reliably identify changes in language or in the world. In this paper, we
propose WikiTiDe, a dataset derived from pairs of timestamped definitions
extracted from Wikipedia. We argue that such resource can be helpful for
accelerating diachronic NLP, specifically, for training models able to scan
knowledge resources for core updates concerning a concept, an event, or a named
entity. Our proposed end-to-end method is fully automatic, and leverages a
bootstrapping algorithm for gradually creating a high-quality dataset. Our
results suggest that bootstrapping the seed version of WikiTiDe leads to better
fine-tuned models. We also leverage fine-tuned models in a number of downstream
tasks, showing promising results with respect to competitive baselines. | [
0.0370223857,
0.082918331,
-0.0094079785,
0.004515917,
-0.0497792475,
0.0101737473,
-0.0461810976,
0.0524747781,
-0.0010147282,
-0.0738221258,
0.0563374683,
-0.0253918376,
-0.0254268497,
0.0210758839,
-0.005665285,
-0.0242597423,
0.0722123012,
0.0006991202,
-0.0519688167,
0.0058270772,
-0.0058008498,
-0.000914222,
-0.0408469327,
-0.0117285689,
-0.0279493071,
-0.040226046,
-0.0525626279,
-0.0288258567,
0.0227699429,
-0.0421862975,
0.0296565797,
0.0561245978,
0.0343186632,
0.0317848958,
0.0000019554,
-0.051071953,
0.005132556,
-0.0259982422,
-0.0634580031,
0.0408036076,
0.0084454091,
-0.0209283177,
0.0021324391,
-0.0509196222,
-0.0650433227,
-0.0506359078,
0.0136040663,
0.0248112381,
0.0665727854,
0.0831666812,
0.004445611,
-0.0176675655,
0.0568955652,
-0.0291395728,
0.0082041733,
-0.0321717747,
0.0319082141,
-0.008662913,
-0.0308390912,
-0.0015611597,
-0.0083881803,
0.0120131113,
-0.0157981012,
-0.02022296,
0.0543092117,
0.0374759324,
-0.0368246287,
-0.0009062773,
-0.0313223824,
0.0544914342,
0.0504026376,
-0.0109849852,
0.004685712,
0.0120851444,
-0.0155800376,
0.0280878544,
-0.0126842167,
-0.0503193587,
0.0084631583,
0.0146156838,
0.0424762741,
-0.0319807306,
0.0257190187,
0.0579389371,
0.0066579515,
0.0518459342,
0.0163268093,
-0.0239082966,
-0.0204941314,
-0.0020557102,
-0.0061364127,
-0.0523490347,
-0.0465912633,
0.0608028658,
0.0046804519,
0.0144306822,
-0.0332413465,
0.0447073728,
0.0223041475,
-0.0616520457,
-0.0441647656,
0.0068806438,
0.0064737406,
0.073325865,
0.0068937042,
-0.0151780061,
-0.0000908673,
-0.0443086699,
0.0085836351,
0.0241202079,
-0.0967929289,
0.0260575153,
-0.0160155911,
0.0073837959,
-0.0275562685,
-0.0069745146,
-0.0230117925,
0.0257315692,
0.013763993,
0.0126842083,
0.0102835782,
-0.0155405011,
-0.0341748111,
0.049039375,
-0.0644444078,
-0.0029026645,
-0.0621941127,
-0.006968285,
-0.0113407709,
-0.0486056097,
-0.0171862748,
-0.0290131643,
0.0225245841,
-0.0235850457,
0.004974538,
0.0411820374,
0.0162580274,
-0.0210554227,
-0.0607795045,
-0.0385394953,
-0.0199076142,
0.0039771898,
-0.0444724448,
-0.0656869784,
0.0274358112,
0.0023246885,
0.0054383543,
-0.0443459973,
0.009843328,
0.0038529576,
-0.042239733,
0.0882727578,
-0.0699556917,
0.0220416244,
0.0014388761,
-0.0255129617,
0.0186978783,
0.1028378904,
0.0332431272,
-0.0448846631,
0.0713745281,
0.0381927229,
-0.0748526379,
0.0189545285,
0.0380133986,
0.049234163,
-0.0074013439,
0.0245715808,
0.0216288213,
0.048163645,
-0.0043939888,
-0.0220882166,
-0.0171475951,
-0.0120491004,
0.0298748426,
0.0045836312,
0.0059114248,
0.0098536424,
0.0447185673,
-0.0382247195,
-0.0009388631,
-0.0190632176,
-0.0219254252,
-0.0411264934,
-0.0124921435,
-0.0229217,
-0.0237833299,
-0.0077097877,
-0.0205038451,
-0.006370306,
0.0039336942,
-0.0025274407,
-0.0163655672,
-0.0036793773,
0.0442665517,
0.0188790783,
0.0160682574,
0.103187561,
0.0624067225,
0.0028434738,
0.0278711598,
0.006856848,
-0.0100282738,
0.0783574879,
0.0564643554,
-0.0496653356,
-0.0396686457,
-0.0360325687,
0.04521982,
0.0068201255,
0.0499321111,
-0.0793989822,
0.0130991461,
-0.0019515597,
-0.0137026431,
-0.0242964923,
0.0134378402,
-0.0188157111,
0.0719391555,
0.0533022694,
-0.0054729101,
-0.0515408739,
-0.0293512046,
0.0382354334,
-0.0272393748,
-0.0358237028,
-0.0263598673,
0.0108397482,
-0.023090193,
0.029684091,
-0.0073583275,
-0.0186019149,
0.0362480097,
-0.046591457,
-0.0020934639,
0.0030750027,
0.0094036283,
-0.0340106711,
0.0844766423,
0.0418334492,
-0.0113734398,
0.0135010313,
-0.035062246,
-0.0236203559,
0.015038426,
0.0144637413,
0.0332535766,
-0.0145635856,
-0.0044107609,
-0.0196276344,
0.0294293389,
-0.0356849767,
0.0908673704,
-0.0179744046,
0.0103701912,
0.0204545017,
0.0272024423,
0.0119749792,
0.0104323681,
-0.0427254029,
0.0597078949,
0.0122719398,
-0.006535931,
0.0277576223,
-0.005544473,
-0.0745034069,
0.0182229429,
-0.0392374732,
-0.0112544745,
-0.0292228982,
0.030692989,
0.0354248025,
0.0014621571,
0.0180564355,
-0.0039164349,
0.0287366677,
0.0102698198,
-0.0211126897,
0.0307066776,
0.0522307381,
0.0565172508,
0.0255669076,
-0.0229907334,
-0.0450150892,
-0.0342691913,
0.0526885651,
-0.0005260983,
-0.0244113822,
-0.0376192443,
0.0170024578,
-0.0461252742,
0.0358056091,
-0.0067011383,
0.0235525668,
-0.0035762577,
-0.0234317929,
0.0413550772,
0.0279313847,
0.02632243,
0.0523178838,
0.0097058723,
-0.0510439165,
-0.0554785319,
0.0199494567,
-0.037517,
0.0084454715,
-0.0459094122,
0.0063238214,
0.0152117237,
0.0364494361,
-0.03430897,
-0.0195166431,
-0.0503684022,
0.0400200002,
-0.043411728,
-0.0001718245,
-0.0237951353,
-0.0037537583,
-0.0348514616,
0.0363238417,
-0.0324489921,
-0.0207408499,
0.0659750998,
0.0376837701,
0.0271909591,
0.0108647877,
-0.0068698362,
-0.0198478345,
0.0689861327,
-0.0331392922,
0.0043454836,
0.017788535,
-0.0102073047,
-0.0200123508,
-0.0103170089,
0.0459417254,
-0.0405844115,
0.0676054209,
-0.0348955542,
0.0444925837,
-0.0070323907,
-0.0072826683,
-0.0361602306,
-0.0182207413,
-0.0124349603,
0.0003472806,
-0.0463541895,
-0.0048327418,
-0.0002069611,
0.0232067481,
-0.0324704386,
0.0144524211,
0.0074101808,
-0.0341251083,
-0.0020404302,
0.0322223529,
0.0466335267,
-0.0044824006,
-0.0095393714,
0.0211099479,
0.0535088293,
0.0156447645,
0.0652942881,
-0.0013172724,
-0.0418506153,
0.021123277,
0.0017005767,
-0.0662038773,
-0.0035607354,
-0.020750327,
-0.004155294,
-0.0217247754,
-0.0357681923,
0.0961616337,
0.0317933336,
-0.0539838597,
0.0091086607,
0.0253112987,
-0.0199713856,
0.0395159312,
-0.0083753513,
-0.0620321408,
-0.0299231578,
-0.0195930116,
0.0381572619,
0.0118914759,
-0.0876922309,
-0.0106522972,
-0.0700369477,
-0.0372580364,
0.001072792,
-0.0105375936,
0.040477179,
-0.0554871485,
0.0300254412,
-0.0348996706,
-0.0358044133,
0.0008086464,
0.0049513164,
0.0082192533,
0.0058349106,
-0.0374918245,
-0.072457388,
0.0585310757,
-0.0005102456,
0.0339249931,
0.0108207325,
0.0505149812,
0.0149524659,
-0.0011796908,
0.0300122667,
-0.0784028172,
0.0039187018,
-0.0281038098,
0.0715115219,
-0.0234228298,
-0.0188170094,
0.0361287408,
-0.0014497009,
-0.0185336582,
-0.0150469886,
-0.0054117818,
0.0826084986,
0.0028347685,
0.0020640849,
0.0002822832,
-0.0465013869,
0.0501490645,
0.0183228534,
-0.0103731854,
0.0076764673,
0.0072086761,
0.0240516327,
-0.0037945621,
-0.045529753,
-0.0464458764,
-0.0349911675,
-0.0235638972,
-0.006415111,
-0.0920698717,
-0.0397862829,
-0.018245751,
0.0233982,
0.0216789041,
0.0262881443,
0.0054033324,
0.0065544937,
-0.101578787,
0.0250721183,
-0.0059587271,
-0.0063375006,
-0.0226455666,
-0.0387773812,
0.0543774143,
0.0506947525,
-0.003035638,
0.0668970272,
-0.0773901567,
-0.078273125,
0.0242756959,
-0.0061112242,
0.0160404742,
0.0715110973,
-0.0425892062,
-0.0090217059,
0.0376250222,
0.057594534,
-0.011649861,
-0.0137753747,
-0.0009787941,
0.0081729982,
-0.0107489685,
0.0701049492,
-0.0557037629,
0.0013403025,
-0.0066098273,
0.0614657067,
-0.0423455648,
-0.0042248308,
0.0170991272,
-0.0009847777,
0.0417043306,
-0.0161761642,
-0.0367635116,
-0.0069986335,
-0.0225640628,
0.0148665132,
-0.0267220028,
0.0129041085,
0.0117309522,
-0.019409772,
-0.0288286451,
-0.0263075195,
0.0834482834,
0.003462974,
0.0189510435,
-0.0570248365,
-0.0423364155,
0.0529442765,
0.0390784331,
0.0242815893,
0.0143504385,
0.0026137575,
-0.0291242432,
-0.0172124971,
-0.0058885883,
-0.0479355417,
-0.0044174199,
0.029396493,
0.004874486,
-0.0009520702,
-0.0105232019,
-0.0679512173,
-0.0095780231,
0.0050836266,
-0.0281562489,
0.0835627988,
-0.0164375026,
0.0830242559,
-0.0162983797,
-0.0412920564,
-0.0202039145,
0.0081879199,
0.0340660252,
0.003314842,
0.0100832032,
0.0472009331,
-0.0043340763,
0.066239357,
0.0400978699,
-0.0458633229,
0.1051409915,
0.0257795788,
-0.0174466074,
-0.0176554583,
-0.0224415306,
-0.0581289232,
0.0011358628,
-0.0184956919,
0.0239150357,
-0.0498815961,
-0.0214246977,
0.0331055932,
-0.0304044597,
0.0044817524,
0.0499561466,
0.0235398933,
0.0517079793,
0.0598637201,
0.0038395198,
-0.0404543951,
0.0581893958,
-0.0352050588,
-0.0103567094,
-0.0267829709,
-6.173536904e-33,
-0.0092498455,
0.0153608089,
-0.0032890013,
0.0302545503,
-0.0638393015,
0.0382804461,
-0.0104152635,
-0.0247980412,
-0.0584464446,
-0.0031404146,
-0.0015410825,
0.0455534086,
-0.0053068916,
-0.0593366362,
0.0190705787,
-0.0280127805,
0.0347860232,
-0.0047803442,
-0.0315787271,
0.0186833292,
0.0647850558,
0.0226195529,
0.0975837633,
-0.015955016,
0.0523345023,
0.0175736919,
0.0199046843,
0.0309972111,
0.041159939,
0.027013015,
-0.0174796171,
0.0881436765,
0.0181372538,
-0.0388881154,
-0.0098072337,
-0.0520641059,
-0.1203114167,
-0.0378316529,
-0.0243404247,
0.0090237074,
0.001709282,
-0.00041183,
0.0164409894,
0.0259218905,
-0.0061752521,
0.0230445247,
0.0426952653,
-0.0349310748,
-0.0502251349,
-0.0126294382,
-0.0280970111,
0.0387123041,
-0.0262755975,
-0.0114052286,
-0.0057555623,
0.011442814,
0.0603642762,
-0.0358750783,
-0.066286087,
0.0424251594,
0.0173190199,
0.0478043146,
-0.0021795561,
-0.0424106121,
-0.0011233868,
0.0584627353,
-0.0166715123,
0.0218366515,
0.0519679897,
0.0046474487,
0.010742222,
0.0241161957,
-0.0302439202,
0.052532196,
0.0363545418,
-0.0413138047,
-0.0459800474,
0.0048888484,
0.0595048741,
0.0559298992,
-0.0111468481,
-0.0220755246,
-0.0208059307,
0.0082850149,
-0.0253046788,
0.0213769395,
-0.0337734073,
-0.0059524402,
0.0041852486,
0.0378329232,
-0.0182423703,
0.0404703692,
-0.0281454716,
-0.0405186564,
-0.0387402438,
0.0330577865,
-0.0255387742,
0.0171985161,
0.0189526081,
-0.0052875266,
-0.0080168936,
-0.0235963315,
-0.0033282468,
0.0210409947,
0.0353791527,
-0.0356694348,
-0.0018900504,
0.0254513398,
-0.0293708853,
-0.0033454972,
-0.0118163163,
0.0101039959,
-0.0411250107,
-0.0496036187,
0.0281749312,
-0.004354754,
-0.0092789186,
0.0354834422,
0.0765480325,
0.0037263397,
-0.0038148437,
-0.0435990244,
0.0453773476,
0.0387886353,
-0.0005334972,
-0.0133258486,
0.0011862445,
0.0490564406,
-0.0110183349,
-0.0182999279,
-0.0216613654,
-0.0033667574,
2.74e-7,
0.0284243897,
0.0544025674,
0.0486332737,
0.0371221155,
0.0201552156,
-0.0261931568,
-0.0296075232,
0.0160139967,
-0.0575595908,
-0.0166163202,
-0.0144293625,
0.0191756729,
0.0094521828,
0.0286015477,
-0.0237593558,
-0.0428713933,
-0.0413776077,
0.0334372856,
-0.0995867103,
-0.0262439735,
0.0376703814,
0.0290679764,
0.0454424769,
-0.0154339494,
-0.0142576471,
-0.0272400361,
0.0608054027,
-0.0159681775,
-0.0065206764,
0.0169696435,
0.0261658169,
0.0603286028,
-0.0222171079,
0.0307882316,
-0.0676958784,
0.0201309696,
-0.0450995713,
0.0021327077,
-0.0168237276,
0.017859716,
-0.0258737784,
-0.0333460979,
0.0002854984,
-0.0168568082,
0.0991068706,
-0.0113342619,
-0.0081236018,
-0.0381418131,
-0.0370360948,
0.0139555456,
0.0156471096,
-0.0130181555,
-0.0343057066,
0.0229431745,
-0.0274235085,
0.0530643389,
-0.0239638984,
-0.0990370512,
-0.0046730135,
0.0413262472,
0.0037820835,
-0.0573001094,
-0.0178756192,
-0.0466230698,
-0.0068527288,
-0.0301098749,
0.0330804586,
2.027137483e-34,
0.0076689431,
0.0528601259,
-0.004660367,
0.0472303554,
0.0041555562,
-0.0328645036,
-0.0131939193,
-0.0548652671,
0.0199457537,
-0.0317767672,
-0.0191440899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03581v1 | Towards Controllable Natural Language Inference through Lexical Inference Types | 2023-08-07T13:37:05 | 2023-08-07T13:37:05 | Yingji Zhang, Danilo S. Carvalho, Ian Pratt-Hartmann, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Explainable natural language inference aims to provide a mechanism to produce
explanatory (abductive) inference chains which ground claims to their
supporting premises. A recent corpus called EntailmentBank strives to advance
this task by explaining the answer to a question using an entailment tree
\cite{dalvi2021explaining}. They employ the T5 model to directly generate the
tree, which can explain how the answer is inferred. However, it lacks the
ability to explain and control the generation of intermediate steps, which is
crucial for the multi-hop inference process. % One recent corpus,
EntailmentBank, aims to push this task forward by explaining an answer to a
question according to an entailment tree \cite{dalvi2021explaining}. They
employ T5 to generate the tree directly, which can explain how the answer is
inferred but cannot explain how the intermediate is generated, which is
essential to the multi-hop inference process. In this work, we focus on
proposing a controlled natural language inference architecture for
multi-premise explanatory inference. To improve control and enable explanatory
analysis over the generation, we define lexical inference types based on
Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) graph and modify the architecture of T5
to learn a latent sentence representation (T5 bottleneck) conditioned on said
type information. We also deliver a dataset of approximately 5000 annotated
explanatory inference steps, with well-grounded lexical-symbolic operations.
Experimental results indicate that the inference typing induced at the T5
bottleneck can help T5 to generate a conclusion under explicit control. | [
0.0287582334,
0.0166970752,
-0.000278251,
0.0650433898,
-0.0336077772,
0.0323203802,
-0.0086841527,
-0.0528390557,
0.0331979915,
-0.0299927071,
0.020563025,
0.0417331792,
-0.0283375289,
0.0490476117,
0.032058727,
-0.0425671004,
0.039650362,
-0.0089290487,
0.0318562947,
0.007460407,
0.0180659927,
0.0492037758,
0.0002579274,
0.0337937325,
0.0017336676,
-0.0121250739,
-0.022221718,
-0.0094598634,
0.0143244555,
-0.0179811753,
0.0082504936,
0.0116068991,
0.0543764718,
0.011526091,
0.0000019915,
-0.034498699,
-0.0185121372,
0.0006991616,
-0.0606406666,
-0.0240607355,
0.0090314755,
0.0005102257,
0.0431887172,
-0.0036827284,
0.0084599303,
-0.0132340165,
0.0362359397,
0.0731344074,
0.0490035601,
0.0497556515,
-0.0119360769,
-0.0705245063,
-0.0434357226,
0.0003404709,
-0.0215852298,
-0.0392307974,
-0.0045312969,
0.0335810855,
0.0306260772,
0.0112193543,
-0.0249048993,
-0.0204958152,
0.0351420641,
-0.0112991752,
-0.027288571,
0.0193001162,
0.0109538771,
-0.0350902975,
0.0218871646,
0.0597724803,
0.0385995172,
-0.0564538725,
0.0197775345,
-0.0239832252,
0.0140970191,
0.0529509783,
-0.0071533234,
0.0453299321,
-0.0548467748,
0.0073469072,
0.0736625791,
0.0228748508,
0.0367164426,
0.0282413624,
-0.017603647,
0.082153663,
0.0131307468,
-0.0047273743,
0.0115397945,
0.0175978541,
-0.0469691828,
-0.0654271096,
-0.0010455633,
0.0107024051,
-0.0323627219,
0.0249732397,
-0.0042588497,
-0.0218082648,
-0.001351517,
-0.0264825542,
-0.0094383806,
0.0317552127,
-0.0271631125,
0.0420397893,
-0.0330192558,
0.0087373871,
-0.0710109323,
-0.0224265214,
-0.0195180792,
-0.0528217778,
-0.0073692417,
0.0061620031,
-0.0305275526,
0.0298777651,
-0.0391495526,
-0.0106273275,
-0.0257654935,
0.0245660879,
-0.0224460997,
-0.0104066413,
-0.0251462962,
0.0272879619,
-0.029286772,
-0.0211193655,
-0.03570145,
0.0190539788,
-0.0863697752,
0.0291764662,
0.0044477768,
-0.0341121592,
-0.035292659,
0.0330000557,
0.049000781,
-0.0090953531,
0.0125396103,
0.04923575,
0.0273712892,
0.0125858486,
-0.046525199,
-0.0634019226,
-0.0050677559,
-0.0476936847,
0.0076463586,
-0.0591069721,
-0.0060891449,
0.0317660794,
-0.0189401694,
0.0003211201,
0.0073538576,
0.0309480485,
-0.0188694652,
0.0629940778,
-0.0269530471,
-0.0440871194,
-0.007010954,
-0.0252264999,
-0.0700685307,
0.044328507,
0.0192877706,
0.0434059165,
0.0284466799,
0.0256832112,
0.0171229355,
-0.0321784616,
0.0395623408,
-0.0134221613,
0.0505139604,
0.0038457178,
-0.0715025142,
0.0160683375,
0.0107391905,
0.012738823,
-0.0281366706,
-0.0056542861,
0.0155944368,
0.044207897,
-0.0177929066,
-0.010972538,
0.0804577693,
-0.0229000431,
-0.0127320047,
0.0198007207,
-0.0518542305,
0.0316491053,
-0.0368337184,
-0.0034541893,
-0.0060712742,
0.0058021978,
-0.0029508553,
-0.055404231,
-0.0197542682,
-0.0012391858,
-0.0053199898,
0.0013315409,
0.0547783673,
0.0407639593,
0.0014738815,
0.0394313559,
0.0386070013,
-0.0389020853,
-0.0209746119,
-0.04481785,
0.060869839,
0.0018028793,
0.0311110914,
-0.0198005345,
-0.0120624974,
-0.0173779614,
0.0033157372,
0.0709193423,
0.0169417951,
-0.0232481975,
0.0022063476,
-0.0192537159,
-0.0336934552,
-0.0453119501,
0.0290228669,
0.0136841796,
-0.0014806021,
-0.0118019078,
0.0121837277,
-0.0591293015,
0.0023622336,
0.0280386433,
-0.0204137266,
-0.0150731141,
-0.0065913806,
0.0108253276,
0.0388256945,
0.0203318074,
0.0116187492,
0.0088327304,
0.004570792,
-0.0076750391,
-0.0671557412,
0.0788589939,
-0.0442370474,
-0.0707559139,
-0.0172069054,
-0.0742775127,
-0.0175719671,
0.0047026416,
-0.0615040399,
-0.0658695996,
0.0687694252,
-0.0460427999,
0.0412023067,
-0.0489334762,
-0.041311428,
0.0176058859,
-0.0185778886,
0.0213935133,
0.1311133951,
0.0119778058,
0.0199083891,
-0.0057648793,
0.0103694126,
0.0152221983,
0.017621221,
0.0309599601,
-0.0177120063,
0.0027753133,
-0.0331982635,
0.0586557947,
-0.0213473346,
-0.0396094359,
0.0379096568,
-0.0475554653,
0.0174126048,
-0.0389867462,
0.0318297073,
0.0308480617,
0.0359807909,
0.0292677172,
-0.0233779289,
-0.0150603065,
-0.0133953169,
0.0037116031,
0.0104156658,
0.0451974161,
-0.0402580015,
0.0053460924,
-0.020960629,
0.01253503,
-0.0443168283,
0.0849580988,
0.0145752588,
-0.0324347503,
-0.0399813801,
-0.0160738286,
-0.0285172369,
0.0320886411,
-0.0303985979,
0.0080118738,
0.0174428839,
-0.0064702868,
-0.015092833,
0.0578505583,
-0.0147962403,
0.0312902853,
0.0120448936,
0.0282599255,
-0.0198520198,
0.0280869007,
-0.0321587846,
0.0212542713,
0.0069010593,
-0.0263952091,
-0.0084866229,
0.0608163849,
0.0152433673,
-0.0109977648,
-0.0489886701,
0.0188784394,
-0.002553174,
0.0098588951,
-0.0008528541,
-0.0289535653,
-0.0017675502,
0.0370958783,
-0.0347356573,
-0.0283308029,
0.0784149319,
0.0138450097,
-0.0090451008,
-0.0382765159,
-0.0426284261,
-0.053505756,
0.0769905001,
0.0439869463,
-0.0000091287,
0.0440516844,
-0.024396779,
-0.0017526889,
-0.006164589,
0.0704588294,
0.0287607778,
0.0407590717,
-0.0500025786,
0.0221337527,
-0.002434396,
-0.0283870045,
-0.0270138346,
-0.0233093388,
-0.0448903404,
0.0094240019,
0.001724734,
-0.0178655777,
0.0227119606,
-0.0281547979,
0.0445655584,
0.0547454394,
-0.0178442691,
0.0007554166,
-0.0526774004,
0.0401778296,
0.0508329123,
0.025626231,
0.0532461703,
-0.0167349,
0.0265006926,
0.0532657318,
-0.0277485978,
-0.0014411682,
-0.0501877293,
0.0169244166,
-0.0203730743,
-0.0394781753,
-0.0219318941,
-0.0047310558,
0.0524096265,
-0.0560319684,
-0.0054512494,
0.0826798603,
0.003764994,
-0.0027695368,
0.0214202125,
-0.0220040306,
0.0344158746,
0.0304361843,
-0.0026725391,
-0.1096080914,
-0.0515322872,
-0.0013006132,
-0.0073630726,
-0.0112643568,
-0.0308300424,
-0.001007324,
-0.0887382478,
0.0316335075,
-0.0248812698,
-0.0438130088,
-0.0300423931,
-0.0631040186,
0.0251454581,
-0.0103315134,
-0.0516748466,
0.0120351119,
0.0183545891,
0.0202422738,
0.0233253855,
-0.0102412608,
-0.0014132777,
0.0357093886,
-0.0474678464,
-0.0138287656,
-0.0050167162,
0.0319639407,
0.007630798,
0.0070291986,
-0.011333405,
-0.0666070431,
-0.0115996571,
-0.0242571216,
0.0453825146,
0.0147469928,
0.0132291336,
-0.0293556489,
0.082740441,
-0.0373700745,
-0.0059496709,
-0.0087843016,
0.1091285795,
-0.0256942529,
-0.036552228,
-0.0257981922,
0.0052082594,
0.0088999635,
0.0768921822,
0.0268680658,
0.0116150863,
-0.0665326491,
-0.0314600766,
-0.0132787181,
-0.0512324944,
0.0023294438,
-0.001257675,
-0.0195012335,
-0.0255814027,
-0.0494388007,
-0.0308383461,
-0.013459566,
0.026145082,
-0.0317076184,
-0.0051149679,
0.0220145211,
-0.0206235535,
-0.0368837528,
0.0288971532,
-0.0031144021,
0.0148860458,
0.0634644479,
0.0052989679,
0.0412573554,
0.0029823515,
-0.04380963,
0.0580167919,
-0.0061464589,
-0.049399849,
-0.0455450118,
0.0047351741,
0.0235817861,
0.0709176585,
-0.0197309349,
0.0047336649,
0.0227546729,
-0.0186119843,
-0.0047371145,
-0.0158491042,
0.0514599606,
0.035210602,
0.0082028667,
0.0538321882,
-0.0586794838,
0.0521989502,
0.0054191365,
0.0310396664,
-0.0173143428,
-0.0216381792,
0.0283932518,
0.0004501987,
0.0148714213,
0.0191591401,
-0.0096998522,
-0.0368479602,
-0.0028084456,
-0.0537627228,
-0.0552874617,
-0.0383853279,
0.0559925698,
-0.0390352495,
0.0017881661,
-0.0314283818,
-0.0339590721,
0.0136266155,
0.0252617542,
-0.0045486777,
-0.0043365317,
0.0592667535,
0.0160688572,
-0.0286349729,
-0.0239550136,
-0.0506313816,
-0.0350698046,
-0.0224026777,
0.0472816043,
-0.0310121328,
0.0691383556,
0.0547880679,
-0.0040618149,
-0.0510190874,
-0.0303783938,
-0.0860434473,
0.0090723308,
-0.0009425072,
0.010878874,
0.0349188186,
-0.0177638493,
0.0432043932,
-0.0198341887,
-0.0220095161,
0.039199926,
0.0751506239,
0.0184911508,
-0.0709291846,
0.0414119363,
0.001513914,
-0.0256871767,
0.0176380966,
0.0211739466,
-0.0129125183,
0.0566136613,
0.0183238871,
-0.0258019026,
-0.0389726534,
-0.0480282158,
-0.0410884097,
0.002700981,
0.0384982117,
0.0134356143,
-0.0558000728,
-0.0812465847,
-0.0079362383,
0.0296836551,
0.0183836035,
-0.0097112441,
0.0293623526,
0.0415422767,
0.0524806939,
-0.1255141348,
-0.0228417926,
0.0437930971,
-0.0249633603,
0.0039012006,
-0.0609197654,
-6.252908487e-33,
-0.0187957957,
-0.0382989459,
0.0082058748,
-0.0052686837,
-0.0072699198,
0.0074176365,
-0.0729010552,
-0.0471727587,
-0.0336202011,
0.057937488,
0.0111448392,
0.036703147,
0.0038481064,
0.0247220397,
0.0037554984,
-0.0054687224,
0.0075451359,
0.0154255368,
-0.0252129342,
0.0446629897,
0.08569175,
-0.0297898762,
0.051968161,
-0.0255441274,
0.0241387337,
-0.0105222547,
0.0149583388,
0.0335555971,
-0.0482677408,
0.0240046252,
0.0136863058,
0.020550549,
0.0298329908,
-0.020423023,
0.0200682618,
0.0487768836,
-0.0976346508,
-0.0639391243,
0.0564637929,
-0.0200304706,
-0.0901866108,
-0.03534187,
0.0404493883,
0.0073841321,
0.0206405818,
-0.0133323045,
0.0484105609,
0.0056853443,
0.0215523951,
-0.052628614,
-0.0561390296,
0.02833944,
-0.006818979,
-0.0026868393,
-0.0482865311,
0.0765366107,
-0.0031100907,
0.000243583,
-0.0080897696,
-0.0329871848,
-0.0293587074,
-0.0060912287,
0.0217310842,
-0.0117477598,
-0.0153211178,
0.0451110117,
-0.0339152291,
-0.0328268111,
-0.0743530467,
0.0242751967,
-0.02587438,
0.0787141174,
0.0672184974,
0.0250824019,
0.0406238139,
0.0631426647,
-0.0827179104,
-0.0159482192,
0.0554881766,
0.0686391219,
0.0119492784,
-0.0043136594,
-0.0344264619,
-0.0343410671,
-0.0405408405,
-0.0305835567,
-0.031920094,
-0.0079358881,
0.0046556811,
-0.014447012,
-0.0164279249,
0.0246405266,
-0.0105082057,
-0.0427123867,
0.0219588894,
0.0395136438,
-0.0063060224,
0.0050108545,
0.0289576184,
0.049871102,
-0.0369556583,
0.0040110028,
-0.0070013837,
0.0162762795,
0.0319903307,
-0.0043374537,
0.0298652407,
0.0017793843,
-0.0002783877,
-0.0002539514,
-0.0505387112,
-0.0233476162,
-0.0752437934,
-0.0164948255,
0.0540163405,
0.0627522245,
-0.0043271999,
-0.0035939214,
0.0214658771,
0.0249883253,
-0.0152058303,
0.0007132613,
-0.0096705686,
0.0184461866,
-0.023337746,
-0.0181702692,
-0.0214140918,
0.023270553,
0.0187770259,
-0.0919176862,
-0.0099504488,
0.0401439182,
2.698e-7,
0.0193081666,
0.0258164275,
0.0372666977,
0.0490998141,
0.0381412059,
0.0340741985,
0.0572564416,
0.0261128508,
0.0155917276,
-0.0748343691,
-0.0138856033,
0.0089409947,
0.016206637,
0.0531268492,
-0.0614503436,
0.0237995498,
-0.0581006594,
-0.0016642787,
-0.0186556168,
0.0000410883,
0.0996295661,
0.0625472441,
0.0353081152,
0.0024052968,
0.0058855475,
-0.0201106593,
0.0361914635,
0.029194368,
-0.0005639463,
-0.0236824993,
0.0328027904,
0.0084367795,
0.0208577719,
0.0225750525,
0.0144774728,
0.035101559,
-0.0347398743,
0.0242069978,
-0.0156347007,
0.0018878505,
-0.0397544391,
-0.0591529459,
0.0349357203,
-0.0128379799,
0.0845841989,
-0.0587711744,
-0.0167959891,
-0.0320026875,
-0.0526248217,
-0.0096594412,
-0.0309402272,
0.0139622502,
-0.0257040132,
0.015839491,
0.0268736687,
-0.0256159604,
-0.0125297206,
-0.0831247121,
-0.0242015421,
0.0332798474,
-0.0336968563,
0.0056818789,
0.0039683632,
0.0106620118,
0.0283863433,
-0.0717683285,
-0.0127791651,
2.530321156e-34,
-0.005503152,
-0.0167269986,
0.012141523,
0.008617091,
0.0650309995,
-0.0122374306,
-0.0293708276,
0.011101515,
0.0639833361,
-0.0611945949,
-0.0430828482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03565v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03565v2 | Topological Interpretations of GPT-3 | 2023-08-07T13:16:42 | 2023-08-08T12:12:55 | Tianyi Sun, Bradley Nelson | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.CO | This is an experiential study of investigating a consistent method for
deriving the correlation between sentence vector and semantic meaning of a
sentence. We first used three state-of-the-art word/sentence embedding methods
including GPT-3, Word2Vec, and Sentence-BERT, to embed plain text sentence
strings into high dimensional spaces. Then we compute the pairwise distance
between any possible combination of two sentence vectors in an embedding space
and map them into a matrix. Based on each distance matrix, we compute the
correlation of distances of a sentence vector with respect to the other
sentence vectors in an embedding space. Then we compute the correlation of each
pair of the distance matrices. We observed correlations of the same sentence in
different embedding spaces and correlations of different sentences in the same
embedding space. These observations are consistent with our hypothesis and take
us to the next stage. | [
0.0397888049,
0.0444777869,
-0.0352845788,
0.0452517606,
-0.0803769007,
0.0267928801,
-0.0291326884,
0.0329091959,
0.0084065022,
-0.0094003649,
-0.0028801558,
0.0075504095,
0.0442846417,
0.0124926362,
0.0251456145,
-0.0598432943,
0.0396533981,
0.0355921835,
-0.0081824614,
0.0024206201,
0.009454838,
0.0031599964,
0.0077384417,
0.0661696717,
-0.0329188071,
-0.0046817148,
-0.0236629974,
-0.010579749,
0.0457175113,
-0.0080612702,
-0.0104516111,
-0.0074229357,
0.0454179756,
0.0495982878,
0.0000016577,
-0.0272029713,
-0.0325006656,
-0.0029367411,
0.0473910272,
0.0287988316,
-0.0133253327,
-0.05500843,
0.0256130584,
-0.0237672534,
-0.0364183374,
0.0220681112,
0.0389255099,
0.0761914551,
0.0094970874,
0.0204725116,
-0.0326106511,
-0.0548507534,
0.0081306268,
-0.0083942879,
0.0490177944,
-0.0153976651,
0.0259297881,
0.0333374254,
-0.0089633493,
0.0136361653,
-0.0647691041,
0.0314706825,
0.004689937,
0.0664662868,
0.0241983123,
0.0639950261,
-0.068241559,
0.0029274307,
0.0042344104,
0.0373636521,
0.0054517784,
0.0171668772,
0.01457801,
0.0194562692,
-0.0043849065,
0.0414688364,
-0.0420164168,
-0.0260147005,
0.0117468871,
0.0335973911,
-0.0076956907,
0.0110541368,
-0.0214779433,
-0.0235641189,
-0.0218837876,
0.0836895704,
0.0414629243,
-0.0600910373,
-0.020731926,
0.0254694,
-0.0358635187,
0.0275807325,
0.0083375024,
-0.0235538501,
0.07014139,
0.0131513532,
0.0170900226,
-0.0409518369,
0.0339079276,
-0.0604474284,
0.0427251235,
0.0469789356,
0.0056201299,
0.0353156924,
-0.0407638885,
0.0466825217,
-0.0387668349,
0.0498045422,
-0.038183853,
-0.0034798067,
-0.0370274447,
-0.0259512197,
-0.0444279648,
0.0472682938,
-0.0292219557,
-0.0823915079,
-0.0333775841,
0.0499972589,
0.0344677232,
-0.0338387862,
-0.0380947478,
0.0171310585,
-0.0193814244,
0.0183621086,
-0.0096447384,
-0.0214273408,
-0.0511013977,
0.0107067851,
-0.1166339293,
-0.006828967,
-0.0307647064,
0.0190010052,
0.0360574909,
-0.0503051393,
-0.0090761529,
0.0322821327,
0.0323334746,
-0.0716397315,
0.0434914418,
-0.0141481245,
-0.0403238498,
-0.0367975794,
0.0083621405,
-0.0266940147,
0.0134173539,
0.0304548293,
-0.0134386281,
-0.004367019,
-0.0127293486,
-0.0049181851,
-0.0742516741,
0.029818574,
0.0095911408,
-0.0083391899,
0.0096960329,
0.0038162768,
0.0555411875,
-0.0166682005,
0.0435153767,
0.0393789709,
0.0281054024,
0.0094682397,
-0.0108184284,
-0.0216920264,
0.0024971869,
-0.010559367,
-0.012646703,
0.0386006907,
0.0655830726,
0.0659953952,
-0.0308494922,
0.0564063899,
-0.0379558429,
-0.012106129,
0.0426949151,
0.1205599159,
0.0143743828,
0.0172539223,
0.0104727773,
0.016006859,
0.0129837673,
0.0231703576,
-0.0187154654,
0.0021708643,
-0.0136267347,
0.0067680785,
0.0294242315,
0.0212454945,
0.0112658357,
-0.0139753409,
-0.0037138658,
-0.028662771,
0.0414174348,
-0.0796179473,
0.0250102412,
-0.0579230376,
-0.0381663926,
0.0243135989,
-0.0097457096,
-0.0504225269,
-0.0317869335,
0.0327902772,
-0.0040306766,
0.0532036014,
0.0087195281,
-0.0211596563,
0.0057583754,
-0.0032917287,
0.0117129022,
0.0229571685,
-0.0117508816,
0.0205106772,
-0.0061838389,
-0.033943776,
-0.0404409803,
-0.0241728108,
0.005321315,
0.0026696911,
0.0037792102,
0.0189372059,
0.0064457208,
-0.0534359477,
0.0541156642,
0.0287279803,
0.028303884,
0.0314204022,
-0.0122464541,
0.0309072286,
0.0153787546,
0.0229849853,
-0.0061908965,
0.0094587179,
0.0416435786,
-0.0442830138,
-0.0215356946,
0.0165007692,
-0.0414520018,
-0.0405158959,
0.0093531786,
-0.0833817422,
-0.0192303788,
0.0523099862,
-0.0287885163,
-0.0216102917,
0.018111689,
-0.0981357023,
0.0424297787,
-0.047588218,
-0.0470063202,
-0.0310350228,
0.0483038351,
-0.0270789955,
0.0641049445,
0.0051689534,
0.006254469,
-0.0244473983,
0.0128732966,
0.0680242032,
0.0111209368,
-0.0342118964,
-0.0197232757,
0.02913725,
-0.0085087297,
0.0199622456,
0.016090842,
-0.0336571522,
-0.0466181301,
-0.0886098146,
0.0052365819,
-0.0001628721,
0.0197120495,
0.0303047132,
-0.0078256177,
-0.0088473223,
0.0083738724,
-0.0195695832,
0.0150546124,
-0.0243644435,
0.0119438702,
0.0860901251,
-0.0454853401,
-0.0539155379,
-0.007052151,
-0.0135774594,
-0.0591714606,
0.0534273684,
0.0128941601,
-0.0342216119,
0.0040209102,
-0.0259153843,
-0.0522281602,
-0.0286201313,
0.0092604496,
-0.0364387855,
0.0142057817,
0.0100247879,
0.0943557844,
0.0182319619,
0.0184538886,
0.0782402679,
0.0319105163,
0.0100919725,
-0.0026688646,
-0.0105989501,
-0.0671062618,
0.0364071876,
-0.0402928591,
-0.0174543671,
-0.0119967703,
-0.0000985906,
0.0512435138,
-0.0099181775,
-0.0945880339,
0.0205383096,
-0.0105262548,
0.0440065339,
-0.051449433,
-0.009287185,
-0.0375676453,
0.0145474002,
0.0114485845,
-0.022307314,
0.0583777204,
-0.0055024177,
0.0037491797,
-0.0686819404,
-0.0059415386,
-0.0346507132,
0.0897407308,
-0.0055226954,
0.0315004028,
-0.0146196596,
-0.0138272354,
0.0056173839,
-0.0129607357,
-0.0048296005,
-0.0096578142,
-0.0038792845,
-0.0098405872,
0.0090996847,
0.0042960998,
-0.0355141498,
0.0298351757,
-0.0471656397,
-0.0060771313,
-0.0169939995,
-0.0076137241,
-0.027399607,
0.020656798,
-0.0019616631,
0.0179751217,
-0.0079987412,
-0.0253129601,
-0.0316775478,
-0.0420094281,
0.0620766059,
0.0424691401,
0.0203089081,
-0.0217644554,
0.0093789743,
-0.061187543,
0.0188763905,
-0.0524714626,
0.0348497182,
-0.0060086749,
0.0328432173,
-0.0084339567,
-0.000624039,
-0.0416599847,
-0.0098964265,
0.0062247659,
-0.0015642968,
-0.0261633042,
0.0872437954,
0.0420077369,
0.0144834481,
0.0274058376,
-0.0156117268,
0.0205721855,
0.0007785441,
-0.0115631297,
-0.0600903817,
-0.0018553729,
-0.0231137965,
-0.0263444819,
0.0080544064,
-0.011403189,
0.0023791713,
-0.0520362183,
0.0202511791,
-0.0246031564,
-0.0225516185,
-0.0697214305,
-0.0461377278,
0.0066876891,
0.0256250631,
-0.0410886779,
-0.0387009978,
0.0064270278,
0.0284040384,
-0.0020044877,
-0.0335524864,
-0.0257487912,
0.0298352521,
0.0095259137,
0.0016708643,
0.0454406589,
0.0917456821,
-0.0408334173,
-0.095929116,
-0.0280674621,
-0.0080900285,
0.0155385882,
0.0170895904,
0.027630521,
0.0085351234,
-0.0041486663,
-0.0510535017,
0.0164769664,
-0.0320641287,
-0.0018858078,
-0.0218982827,
0.0923446342,
-0.0236760676,
-0.0336864963,
-0.0454150811,
0.0200584289,
-0.0190516859,
0.0838209987,
0.0211188272,
-0.0189331416,
-0.0548723042,
0.0191887412,
0.0430307426,
0.0227491204,
-0.047407195,
-0.0211673137,
0.0236591119,
-0.001667815,
-0.0276869722,
-0.0530070849,
0.0328597352,
0.0203459691,
0.0068687224,
0.0544984601,
-0.0406732149,
-0.0103491703,
-0.0612335578,
0.0077989022,
0.015288624,
0.0317604616,
0.0678367615,
0.0346750244,
0.0150066186,
0.023834385,
-0.0645886734,
-0.0315608159,
-0.0495555103,
-0.0378486738,
0.0148987137,
0.0019263607,
0.0127042197,
0.0263458453,
0.017018944,
0.0272282027,
0.0258761924,
0.0172708109,
0.0054724715,
0.0562122241,
0.049300462,
0.0353359394,
0.0008212716,
0.0179795176,
-0.005999824,
-0.016679991,
-0.0051094899,
0.0346746407,
0.0022529571,
-0.0016949769,
-0.0053670336,
-0.0027414656,
0.0780557841,
0.0110873859,
-0.0260157268,
0.0098360823,
-0.0014401624,
-0.0435940661,
0.0149675077,
-0.023512762,
-0.01719689,
0.0482680649,
0.0107428022,
-0.0577357225,
0.0019682599,
0.0058232378,
-0.0002927397,
0.0044409581,
-0.0052039172,
0.009421791,
-0.0005539896,
0.0062878635,
0.0015580093,
-0.0264328886,
-0.0015399681,
-0.0485518612,
-0.0147160105,
-0.0340069905,
-0.0097919861,
0.0343632586,
-0.0069737723,
-0.0046088151,
0.0620783083,
-0.0761866122,
0.0200631041,
0.0130642047,
0.035577178,
0.0044265948,
0.0165429283,
0.0454667211,
-0.0749846324,
-0.0144523112,
0.0329018533,
0.0374120884,
-0.0017895447,
-0.0186818335,
0.0153936474,
-0.0060392595,
-0.0264783222,
-0.0043090298,
0.0127248643,
-0.0126196276,
0.0422517844,
-0.0039862646,
-0.0366792753,
-0.0294951517,
0.02309791,
0.037235681,
0.036800772,
-0.0007801653,
0.0322729275,
-0.0591727644,
-0.0245438907,
0.0609926321,
0.0254733264,
0.002863771,
-0.0073711392,
0.0479142629,
0.0416045412,
-0.0055481493,
-0.031906765,
-0.0132406112,
-0.00523917,
-0.0466529056,
-0.0726802349,
-0.03434477,
-5.840556823e-33,
0.0122430734,
-0.0358872302,
-0.0387080349,
0.0076765548,
-0.0568588078,
0.0040056892,
-0.0311268996,
-0.0317772292,
-0.0080982381,
0.0305301789,
0.0047731963,
0.015829403,
0.0004115425,
0.0188828744,
-0.0220700689,
0.0025800429,
0.0035210932,
-0.0133546935,
-0.0081928372,
0.0166312568,
0.0408063531,
0.0574554279,
0.0328651257,
-0.0820460469,
0.0286056027,
-0.0157067701,
0.0219803248,
-0.0209792815,
0.0166367311,
0.0248534549,
-0.068166241,
0.0238842759,
0.0250578336,
-0.0083113061,
0.0127935791,
0.0358871557,
-0.061961662,
-0.0642899647,
0.0378955789,
-0.0138244312,
-0.0544874743,
-0.0127719007,
0.0040098866,
-0.0120459655,
-0.0507913195,
-0.011056751,
0.0674223453,
0.0094132042,
-0.0349844731,
-0.0094474973,
-0.0570934527,
-0.0050062365,
-0.0479904115,
0.0131329419,
0.0452530719,
-0.0253633149,
0.0365716256,
0.0246962737,
-0.0172326118,
0.0000170283,
-0.0492453203,
0.0049922313,
-0.0327130258,
-0.0349316485,
0.0328394063,
0.0595466569,
-0.016509898,
-0.052042719,
-0.0289975535,
-0.007378113,
0.0230201166,
0.0224672128,
0.0220650472,
0.0242747851,
0.0179179143,
0.0050845258,
-0.0927507281,
0.0129046133,
-0.0123618562,
-0.0199930668,
0.0641215816,
-0.002457883,
-0.0249215625,
0.0017450739,
0.0090123853,
-0.0366224945,
-0.0178852845,
-0.025869593,
0.0342735611,
-0.0322514959,
0.0050424915,
0.0208345558,
-0.0035570585,
-0.0359136574,
-0.0369727798,
0.0299655795,
-0.0367624164,
0.0122159543,
0.0200652648,
0.0506088138,
0.0051685618,
-0.035045024,
-0.029904332,
0.062012516,
0.0651996955,
-0.0177006461,
0.0325094983,
0.0037135782,
-0.0244617909,
-0.0029093195,
0.005599949,
-0.0955504179,
-0.0467239283,
-0.044859726,
0.0118459268,
0.0336194634,
0.0065623005,
0.0130879013,
0.0242387298,
0.0423578247,
-0.0225317478,
-0.0432599671,
-0.0149352709,
0.0164904911,
-0.0189384129,
0.0022305578,
-0.001875573,
0.0173742604,
0.0438303724,
-0.0495104156,
-0.014661097,
0.0094903363,
2.671e-7,
0.0704557076,
0.0775516629,
0.0607263781,
-0.0122511173,
-0.0024272006,
0.0012253481,
0.0139957974,
0.0649799034,
-0.0387791321,
0.0193054229,
0.0568038598,
0.0274784528,
-0.0038205031,
-0.0230747256,
-0.0650147796,
0.0831481889,
-0.1051837429,
-0.0420868807,
-0.0719299763,
0.0845257863,
0.1300317645,
0.0555812269,
0.0293386281,
0.0101761185,
-0.0236587618,
0.0055262931,
0.0280810501,
-0.0272932667,
0.0431839898,
-0.0274486784,
0.0167281907,
-0.0500829518,
0.0142808016,
0.0057156002,
0.0480367951,
0.0171597246,
0.0403889082,
0.0383381508,
-0.018897377,
0.0019949095,
-0.0354381837,
-0.0285872333,
-0.0202877298,
-0.054452356,
0.0794066787,
-0.0616808087,
-0.0502486899,
0.0205802917,
0.0239425395,
0.0013063821,
0.0821278021,
0.0329787657,
-0.0476598702,
-0.0325931758,
0.0293819588,
-0.016648639,
0.0264188033,
-0.087665163,
0.0218753461,
0.0363534652,
-0.0370458066,
-0.0143630384,
-0.0414287262,
0.0211053584,
0.0779832378,
-0.0329342484,
-0.0312411822,
2.228082732e-34,
0.0072057322,
-0.0088948775,
0.0510658138,
-0.0335384533,
0.0254099499,
-0.0190225113,
0.070223853,
-0.0188020095,
0.0154846087,
-0.1020694077,
-0.0179370847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03558v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03558v1 | Mondrian: Prompt Abstraction Attack Against Large Language Models for Cheaper API Pricing | 2023-08-07T13:10:35 | 2023-08-07T13:10:35 | Wai Man Si, Michael Backes, Yang Zhang | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | The Machine Learning as a Service (MLaaS) market is rapidly expanding and
becoming more mature. For example, OpenAI's ChatGPT is an advanced large
language model (LLM) that generates responses for various queries with
associated fees. Although these models can deliver satisfactory performance,
they are far from perfect. Researchers have long studied the vulnerabilities
and limitations of LLMs, such as adversarial attacks and model toxicity.
Inevitably, commercial ML models are also not exempt from such issues, which
can be problematic as MLaaS continues to grow. In this paper, we discover a new
attack strategy against LLM APIs, namely the prompt abstraction attack.
Specifically, we propose Mondrian, a simple and straightforward method that
abstracts sentences, which can lower the cost of using LLM APIs. In this
approach, the adversary first creates a pseudo API (with a lower established
price) to serve as the proxy of the target API (with a higher established
price). Next, the pseudo API leverages Mondrian to modify the user query,
obtain the abstracted response from the target API, and forward it back to the
end user. Our results show that Mondrian successfully reduces user queries'
token length ranging from 13% to 23% across various tasks, including text
classification, generation, and question answering. Meanwhile, these abstracted
queries do not significantly affect the utility of task-specific and general
language models like ChatGPT. Mondrian also reduces instruction prompts' token
length by at least 11% without compromising output quality. As a result, the
prompt abstraction attack enables the adversary to profit without bearing the
cost of API development and deployment. | [
0.031293314,
0.0912858546,
-0.0100648915,
0.0621292926,
-0.0435582772,
-0.0129891615,
0.0557198413,
-0.0022348643,
0.0240602046,
-0.0457436405,
0.0013305454,
0.0248492025,
-0.0045279912,
0.0585476793,
0.0524527952,
-0.0344855413,
0.0273941942,
-0.0244294275,
0.039993953,
-0.0226059612,
-0.0205224194,
-0.0087809013,
0.0066359523,
0.0370861962,
0.0357038267,
-0.0465686359,
-0.0353345498,
-0.0255324971,
-0.0203195252,
-0.001230111,
-0.0102358023,
-0.0093937162,
-0.0168901403,
0.0643301755,
0.0000020178,
-0.056236241,
-0.0200869907,
0.0500883199,
-0.0706126094,
0.0270470586,
0.0053281868,
0.0139149306,
0.0316732116,
0.0451462083,
-0.0363161117,
0.0087301591,
0.0380975455,
0.0616665408,
0.0930285379,
0.0965553001,
-0.0051379097,
-0.0073373155,
0.0330570638,
-0.019589927,
-0.0271036606,
-0.0591573231,
0.0037534849,
-0.0727025047,
-0.0382206477,
0.0306660887,
0.0072343876,
0.0182868298,
0.0203027483,
0.0138995405,
-0.0401446037,
0.0317098461,
-0.0445283316,
-0.0149754453,
-0.0279959142,
0.0393954813,
-0.0263079256,
0.001796101,
0.0204202272,
0.0092227645,
0.0219248757,
-0.022914337,
-0.0338460766,
0.0383619778,
0.0253155623,
-0.0048869252,
0.0080329645,
-0.0148985498,
0.0441440754,
0.035967648,
-0.024741251,
0.02338144,
0.0139474906,
-0.0184377655,
-0.0045147366,
-0.0475339778,
-0.001257285,
-0.0546169505,
-0.0201046932,
0.0297873653,
-0.0383125618,
-0.0023242345,
-0.0716916323,
-0.0721900687,
0.003759935,
-0.0223453157,
0.021292679,
0.0174067281,
-0.0041571837,
0.0282808766,
0.0056249625,
0.0148355588,
-0.023894215,
0.0475335605,
0.0133732036,
0.0093456488,
0.024928188,
-0.0221157968,
-0.0327354223,
0.0708588883,
-0.034532588,
-0.0113160275,
-0.0338458344,
0.0519789867,
-0.014783293,
0.0415821113,
-0.0509039126,
0.0389694534,
-0.0080191409,
-0.0069853426,
-0.0063670161,
-0.0128418598,
-0.009452573,
-0.0018767046,
0.0436188839,
-0.0814316422,
-0.0342185721,
0.025174845,
-0.0261724833,
0.0140600987,
0.0074039763,
0.1180218384,
0.0177368559,
-0.0271847155,
-0.0280099213,
-0.0891709477,
0.0327574089,
-0.0348763838,
-0.0267602578,
-0.0583100431,
0.0086489981,
0.0049112774,
-0.0388572589,
-0.0208159275,
-0.0115761235,
0.0207593925,
-0.058108218,
0.0686482787,
-0.0042485408,
-0.002792866,
0.0249271523,
0.0191077515,
-0.0473854765,
0.0533468649,
0.0090858405,
0.0355281755,
0.0777772442,
0.0214879531,
0.0277321581,
0.028349299,
0.0209550597,
-0.0031629715,
0.0218552705,
0.0373861827,
-0.0095561612,
0.0069920826,
-0.0238587782,
0.0520337783,
-0.0008998861,
-0.0603999123,
0.0815048441,
0.0642288998,
-0.075439848,
-0.0055426862,
0.0411385782,
0.0190718062,
0.0167955775,
-0.0119313225,
-0.0457520485,
-0.0285787098,
-0.0642952323,
0.0037042066,
0.0307969395,
0.0067914655,
-0.0409432761,
-0.0333467834,
0.0217577294,
-0.0465089045,
-0.0489653572,
0.0443935879,
0.0225405116,
0.0117603652,
-0.0152673386,
0.0521315448,
0.0009782272,
-0.0412841626,
-0.0183126144,
-0.0925005451,
0.0194201712,
-0.0028675215,
0.0727590397,
-0.0318764672,
0.0176180322,
-0.0221958105,
-0.0001287125,
0.0427047759,
0.0478423089,
0.0099719251,
0.0320507027,
-0.0308655091,
0.0167390145,
-0.0157851391,
0.0234852619,
-0.0245481078,
0.0449623391,
0.0074956012,
0.007433217,
-0.0395636149,
-0.0352801234,
0.0276409779,
0.0101712188,
-0.0790208876,
0.0256624147,
0.0407080837,
0.0398302898,
0.0068336716,
0.015708467,
0.0370148532,
0.0395122692,
0.0003553287,
0.0018719092,
-0.0288390163,
0.0000116895,
0.0308760796,
-0.0013264322,
0.0065539829,
-0.0273886863,
0.0743264258,
-0.0584458336,
-0.0007069575,
0.0105615212,
-0.0116317021,
0.0426758565,
-0.0110826865,
-0.0018941447,
0.0126618193,
0.0313905366,
-0.0163006,
0.0262412988,
-0.0028818217,
0.0124516701,
-0.0103475871,
0.0220165588,
0.0040816944,
-0.0289338697,
-0.0361772068,
0.0209468994,
-0.0419187546,
0.0160729829,
-0.0033539261,
-0.0153560834,
-0.0086907689,
0.0279151406,
-0.0659228414,
-0.0002281853,
-0.0241135936,
0.0282212719,
0.013261361,
0.0450988524,
-0.0152773075,
-0.0250355694,
-0.023654893,
-0.0081813931,
-0.0024024548,
0.0475020185,
0.0359469354,
0.0016890079,
-0.0263042115,
-0.0000953334,
0.0050220597,
-0.0045582005,
0.0795363933,
-0.0196910854,
0.0032653033,
-0.0196896456,
0.0055857874,
-0.0154208411,
0.0380585976,
-0.0192222893,
-0.0168828722,
0.0146795521,
0.0002826742,
-0.0243542306,
0.088614352,
0.0244600382,
0.052451808,
0.0290043075,
0.0361396223,
-0.0531611145,
-0.0044248477,
-0.0075977156,
-0.0519361086,
-0.0194105878,
-0.0121405479,
0.0724883676,
0.0517476462,
0.0039391425,
-0.0286492556,
-0.0291993823,
0.0437731966,
0.0217032172,
-0.020442836,
-0.0343457162,
0.0290347748,
-0.0359080434,
0.0074320342,
0.0198970195,
-0.0990503803,
0.0684250444,
-0.0243522637,
0.0159968939,
-0.0551898256,
-0.0379466079,
-0.001779958,
0.0619542673,
-0.0182803944,
0.0338747203,
0.016611807,
-0.0345342644,
-0.0648846179,
0.0067354525,
0.0325694643,
-0.0420016944,
0.045785673,
-0.0321941487,
-0.0106380982,
-0.0152636683,
-0.0357735604,
-0.0478696786,
-0.0550560988,
-0.03080591,
0.0169391409,
-0.0321523845,
-0.0349477567,
-0.0047335187,
-0.0333714522,
0.0114452969,
0.0338185094,
-0.0267051179,
-0.0108600501,
-0.0271174982,
0.0005692548,
0.0454359092,
-0.0067418525,
-0.0131188557,
-0.0173629634,
0.0632318184,
0.0804884434,
0.0460728221,
-0.0115673635,
-0.0217019226,
-0.0276227295,
0.0209346451,
-0.0471176952,
0.0216036532,
0.0411869586,
0.004031376,
-0.0353915878,
-0.0312146991,
0.0454393551,
0.0236045606,
-0.0492951274,
0.0116375461,
0.0076998076,
0.0500823036,
0.0030651297,
0.0336853825,
-0.097397238,
-0.0216747541,
0.0479323193,
0.083313413,
-0.0365128592,
-0.0282287095,
-0.0438114442,
-0.1295519471,
0.0347209014,
-0.0125773242,
-0.0610237196,
-0.0101572052,
-0.0464859419,
-0.0335969217,
0.0343373977,
0.0312995613,
-0.0152167017,
0.0059533832,
0.0112941582,
0.0023621565,
-0.0171576906,
-0.0296639316,
-0.0148114171,
-0.0496727452,
0.0167790577,
0.0512558669,
0.004733244,
-0.0064805872,
0.0077491277,
0.0536598004,
0.0159180071,
-0.0410839431,
0.0057413881,
0.0593129508,
-0.0046110102,
-0.0257300902,
0.0201267432,
0.0585676767,
-0.0184144415,
0.0017117092,
0.0224669725,
0.0405441374,
-0.0193227828,
0.0017511715,
-0.0161756873,
-0.0311248079,
0.0234154146,
0.0795358717,
0.0248457268,
-0.0456002429,
-0.0395079888,
-0.0475266241,
-0.0389740989,
-0.0062693278,
-0.0090077706,
-0.0007723371,
-0.024313163,
-0.0545550101,
-0.0695836544,
-0.0076038064,
0.0000452997,
0.028747702,
0.0060679493,
0.0116282301,
0.0027245844,
0.0309606474,
-0.048280172,
0.0079352353,
-0.0508397743,
0.0150992926,
-0.0582978204,
-0.0012646883,
0.0165480915,
-0.017455386,
-0.0244710539,
-0.0032414363,
-0.0577871762,
-0.0896554589,
-0.0059908037,
0.0853299424,
0.0282741077,
0.0272848271,
-0.023838345,
-0.0493901558,
0.0573410876,
0.1087244824,
-0.0247821864,
0.0151518015,
0.0512816161,
-0.0025991541,
0.0174568575,
0.0490750931,
-0.0806682035,
-0.0391774364,
0.0248044413,
-0.0151623376,
-0.0003617273,
0.0191969387,
0.0155497529,
0.0736196786,
0.0462689176,
-0.0114452709,
0.0101142982,
0.0088534616,
0.04345835,
-0.0275358129,
-0.0196927879,
-0.0256442465,
0.0089827348,
-0.0173781179,
0.0145249153,
0.0131779891,
0.0258698799,
0.0320037641,
0.0015501358,
0.0046627615,
-0.0022524318,
-0.0305151939,
0.0202937163,
0.0807007924,
-0.0126344441,
-0.0162769333,
0.0032135798,
-0.00688612,
0.0346304066,
-0.0149976034,
0.0254402403,
0.0322262645,
0.0096406089,
-0.0067095701,
0.0307344496,
-0.0633066744,
-0.1358005255,
0.0452350192,
0.0424522869,
-0.0223526638,
-0.0104049416,
-0.0258898232,
-0.0312484298,
-0.0089411223,
-0.0105791437,
-0.0043933988,
0.0190422665,
-0.0465976782,
0.0315222591,
-0.0030754204,
-0.0068999277,
0.0383181833,
0.0965297222,
-0.0266895518,
0.0610251911,
-0.0157166012,
-0.0280030463,
-0.0326671675,
-0.0256789867,
0.0415966548,
0.0070961295,
-0.0222205129,
-0.0489252806,
-0.0241901577,
-0.0712274015,
-0.0429345183,
-0.0078858826,
0.0215939451,
0.0149452165,
0.0074690157,
0.0751601234,
0.0204383191,
0.0108543076,
-0.0922904983,
0.0558744371,
-0.0518373773,
-0.0739150122,
0.0407028794,
-6.101534936e-33,
0.0291468874,
-0.0318054333,
-0.0190355014,
0.0339402109,
0.0162627995,
0.0291707292,
-0.0237158127,
0.0060806721,
-0.0210059192,
-0.0126284296,
-0.0228449721,
0.009274411,
0.022012746,
0.0580628216,
-0.0248533841,
-0.0385189876,
-0.0001047005,
-0.0387455225,
-0.0285474192,
0.0266676769,
0.0501552708,
-0.014579894,
-0.0155078191,
-0.0419901386,
0.0339262709,
-0.0309686735,
-0.0137799522,
0.0199141297,
-0.0353367627,
0.0440901332,
0.0043137451,
0.0454703309,
0.0063349567,
0.0204251371,
0.0132600721,
0.0332196616,
-0.0343857445,
-0.018382756,
-0.0127678541,
0.0100093447,
-0.0436846092,
-0.050553266,
0.0475533903,
-0.0111544216,
0.007221634,
0.0119613828,
-0.0018361084,
-0.0104965437,
-0.0264213867,
-0.0323826149,
-0.0056350981,
-0.0089180488,
-0.0125989038,
0.0068076425,
0.016372975,
0.0246842653,
0.0194868948,
0.0269147959,
-0.0316981934,
0.0076170065,
0.016629044,
-0.0005159922,
0.0340360552,
0.0269981325,
0.000597561,
0.0425743423,
0.0412081294,
-0.0251111109,
-0.0110496506,
0.025390191,
-0.0084591657,
0.0381098278,
0.0391302519,
0.0022040147,
0.0311329812,
-0.0269021466,
-0.0447715186,
0.0164792128,
0.0230902247,
0.0223760251,
0.035106454,
-0.0282347575,
-0.052221477,
-0.0098591074,
-0.0302841011,
-0.0525264964,
-0.0398828872,
0.0020280427,
0.0377050266,
0.0305333044,
-0.0186066795,
-0.016120011,
0.0103958789,
-0.0652791262,
-0.003291151,
-0.017245682,
-0.0021791097,
-0.009804219,
-0.0034987824,
-0.0136367483,
-0.0113754524,
0.0155517031,
-0.0383603685,
-0.0647360981,
0.0348877385,
0.0086248172,
0.030072106,
0.0116207646,
-0.068852827,
0.0014729449,
-0.0196252838,
0.0392139181,
0.0324831009,
0.0411824472,
0.0253993999,
-0.0214942507,
0.0087863086,
0.0150935762,
-0.0065791584,
0.0143963601,
-0.0529219434,
0.036338076,
-0.0052317246,
-0.0052734166,
-0.018158868,
0.0079376912,
-0.0130426427,
0.0671383291,
0.0392370261,
-0.0568927377,
-0.0190165415,
-0.0368110389,
2.886e-7,
-0.0157834832,
0.0064301332,
0.0014801885,
0.044217933,
0.0037566251,
0.0880166143,
0.0270160623,
0.0523975268,
-0.0292826444,
-0.0205833502,
-0.0477332994,
-0.0212671366,
0.0520885736,
0.0121642286,
-0.1221509054,
0.0162430964,
-0.0697652698,
-0.0102169458,
-0.0787541792,
-0.0141550694,
0.048986543,
0.0808409899,
0.0165431257,
-0.021088209,
0.0091144657,
-0.0416175164,
0.004359764,
-0.003930673,
0.0004023275,
0.005618657,
0.0436837636,
0.0474121012,
0.0342299677,
-0.0035349019,
-0.0645340458,
0.0050586057,
-0.0210606027,
0.0623286068,
0.0217097048,
-0.0242588297,
-0.020635061,
-0.0557586588,
0.0180403572,
-0.0199981369,
0.071868293,
0.0156126637,
-0.0325046033,
-0.0640909448,
-0.0039194063,
-0.0492200404,
0.0113120126,
-0.0226589032,
0.0004013175,
0.025003735,
-0.0114219617,
-0.047245197,
0.0463766381,
-0.0823139101,
-0.0187644307,
-0.0361709185,
-0.0120965512,
-0.0177070964,
-0.0167470463,
0.0334985517,
0.0168812219,
-0.0252590124,
-0.0069490494,
2.886456914e-34,
0.0044491752,
-0.0468048751,
0.0227016434,
0.0593508892,
0.0128300898,
-0.0091527365,
0.0264267586,
0.0152956657,
0.0131457038,
-0.0409839712,
-0.0348249078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03549v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03549v3 | Zhongjing: Enhancing the Chinese Medical Capabilities of Large Language Model through Expert Feedback and Real-world Multi-turn Dialogue | 2023-08-07T12:56:13 | 2023-12-28T15:20:24 | Songhua Yang, Hanjie Zhao, Senbin Zhu, Guangyu Zhou, Hongfei Xu, Yuxiang Jia, Hongying Zan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable
breakthroughs in understanding and responding to user intents. However, their
performance lag behind general use cases in some expertise domains, such as
Chinese medicine. Existing efforts to incorporate Chinese medicine into LLMs
rely on Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) with single-turn and distilled dialogue
data. These models lack the ability for doctor-like proactive inquiry and
multi-turn comprehension and cannot align responses with experts' intentions.
In this work, we introduce Zhongjing, the first Chinese medical LLaMA-based LLM
that implements an entire training pipeline from continuous pre-training, SFT,
to Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF). Additionally, we
construct a Chinese multi-turn medical dialogue dataset of 70,000 authentic
doctor-patient dialogues, CMtMedQA, which significantly enhances the model's
capability for complex dialogue and proactive inquiry initiation. We also
define a refined annotation rule and evaluation criteria given the unique
characteristics of the biomedical domain. Extensive experimental results show
that Zhongjing outperforms baselines in various capacities and matches the
performance of ChatGPT in some abilities, despite the 100x parameters. Ablation
studies also demonstrate the contributions of each component: pre-training
enhances medical knowledge, and RLHF further improves instruction-following
ability and safety. Our code, datasets, and models are available at
https://github.com/SupritYoung/Zhongjing. | [
0.0922195911,
0.0210927203,
0.0014250253,
0.0083849002,
0.0271278024,
0.0188416671,
-0.0141884694,
0.0071868137,
0.0128358491,
-0.0057525039,
-0.076347746,
-0.0542344674,
-0.0093512852,
0.0316261463,
0.0194259398,
-0.0567545928,
0.0423614755,
0.0062751514,
0.0615484901,
-0.0003630789,
0.0254951566,
-0.0039760675,
-0.0536863096,
0.0609615333,
0.0201082975,
0.000244974,
0.0098378044,
0.0039487858,
0.0364399999,
-0.0772449896,
0.0191222765,
0.0510441177,
0.0071108132,
0.0007346369,
0.0000020216,
-0.0505285449,
-0.0028777327,
-0.0041472511,
-0.0497358032,
-0.0188909397,
0.028674975,
-0.0241051689,
-0.0112460908,
0.0269162375,
-0.0531096607,
-0.0076685911,
0.0245387126,
0.0914671868,
0.0804162174,
0.0899488777,
-0.0010509691,
0.006531293,
0.0302146636,
-0.032230597,
0.0253154468,
-0.0680782646,
0.0189468302,
0.0320806094,
0.0238972176,
-0.001768806,
-0.020006137,
0.0317897983,
0.0138820959,
-0.0097247213,
-0.0107104247,
0.0446035974,
-0.0021423716,
-0.0027469704,
-0.0259270426,
0.1074167415,
0.0078464923,
0.0206880458,
0.0026441796,
0.0024707774,
0.0049240524,
-0.0295868162,
-0.0642870292,
-0.0095518474,
-0.0008099416,
0.0036909704,
-0.0073120459,
-0.0262235701,
0.0329755433,
0.0147774313,
-0.0096412441,
-0.0091716861,
-0.0162761565,
-0.0210621264,
0.0049383831,
-0.0136093628,
0.016570719,
-0.029114794,
0.016991511,
0.0538707562,
-0.1003122181,
0.021341024,
-0.0038055135,
0.0330663882,
0.0734911785,
-0.033988826,
0.0053021419,
0.0357309207,
-0.0205139015,
0.0407643579,
0.0171205644,
0.0036163325,
-0.0273110829,
0.0413377509,
-0.0435434543,
0.0075948164,
-0.060161531,
-0.0106201386,
-0.023431031,
0.0149959894,
-0.0026075728,
-0.0161832273,
-0.0851304978,
0.005097094,
-0.0014549394,
0.0383567102,
-0.0011623384,
0.0231163837,
-0.0434325486,
-0.00021976,
-0.0423478782,
0.0475334041,
-0.0140922619,
0.0310365763,
-0.0164298154,
-0.0285918117,
-0.0198982693,
0.0132795228,
-0.0206878409,
-0.0082423966,
0.0205571037,
0.0605751649,
-0.0246281568,
-0.0068547213,
0.0094823465,
-0.0217457004,
-0.0167542659,
-0.0261721853,
0.0296813287,
-0.0366292894,
0.0322086997,
-0.0157550797,
0.0387259871,
-0.02391815,
0.0303732045,
0.0033523447,
-0.0345532708,
0.064629674,
-0.0274957046,
0.0197666846,
0.0262808688,
0.0301977675,
-0.0107722525,
0.0466873087,
0.0444332659,
-0.0418198556,
0.0138428612,
-0.0224392954,
0.0186405294,
0.000947097,
0.0292142816,
-0.0184163004,
0.0280637722,
0.0151084494,
-0.007891695,
0.0878712088,
-0.0125806071,
0.0608901978,
-0.0469346344,
0.0023432383,
0.0349462181,
0.054772716,
-0.015864579,
-0.0124736307,
0.00916126,
-0.0110277515,
0.0173363313,
0.0006253194,
-0.0547554828,
0.0257504955,
0.0013643531,
-0.0115086334,
0.0033508616,
-0.0132963592,
-0.0430444255,
-0.0497147851,
-0.007914478,
-0.0043855249,
-0.0018876765,
0.0190950986,
0.0335255191,
-0.0024120132,
-0.016728878,
0.0413465947,
0.0490571335,
-0.0250270814,
-0.0286411345,
-0.0711414218,
-0.0016552875,
0.096762009,
0.0465239845,
-0.0392227955,
-0.0637715459,
-0.0338634849,
-0.0096508022,
0.0277597923,
0.0466044731,
-0.0349233262,
0.0119069749,
-0.0569587611,
-0.0188804455,
0.0207542609,
-0.0039407178,
-0.0135051496,
0.0045368792,
0.0111328764,
-0.0218467899,
-0.0056636557,
-0.0242812745,
0.0355744846,
-0.0773078054,
-0.0074650617,
-0.0018254453,
0.0007305856,
0.0388451219,
0.0154940151,
-0.0218401588,
0.0177312419,
0.0269526299,
-0.0179174338,
-0.0188713223,
0.0142884366,
-0.060064964,
-0.0577903949,
0.0422628932,
-0.0169747677,
-0.0265009217,
-0.023569189,
-0.0513936058,
-0.0398514308,
-0.0616128631,
-0.0172621254,
0.0306429472,
-0.0306753796,
0.0203372128,
0.0299644265,
0.0041634412,
-0.039719291,
0.0017065787,
-0.019252399,
0.0001539644,
0.0385459885,
0.0038469075,
-0.0083902031,
-0.0443640351,
-0.0245160088,
0.0187440123,
0.0148790125,
0.0107935462,
-0.0205599479,
0.0605705976,
-0.0482011586,
-0.0513150096,
-0.1090386212,
-0.0060183457,
-0.0095489621,
-0.0217952542,
0.0228362177,
0.0125149498,
-0.0100924,
-0.0313686728,
-0.0570397153,
-0.0050049569,
0.0170863066,
-0.0042701033,
0.0347456038,
0.0419708714,
0.0017562523,
-0.0290630627,
0.0182991885,
-0.0202332176,
-0.0272656139,
-0.0028036986,
-0.0029901157,
-0.0091129104,
-0.0472530611,
-0.0236543212,
0.005589914,
-0.0422656015,
-0.0623883121,
0.0288508534,
-0.0051315455,
0.0152214011,
0.0490331985,
0.0031455914,
0.0247159321,
0.0330226012,
0.0085405558,
-0.0386799239,
0.0452965386,
-0.0223738197,
-0.0488040708,
-0.0378094353,
-0.0160912164,
-0.0080146231,
0.0783345029,
0.0147229349,
0.0259569753,
-0.0601858534,
-0.0541424714,
0.0033642154,
-0.0052277944,
-0.0135255111,
0.0332141966,
-0.04750292,
0.0260664131,
-0.0071135741,
-0.02121385,
0.1107219309,
0.0069828653,
-0.0075078537,
-0.0592326336,
-0.0175565537,
-0.0311812814,
0.001465995,
-0.0338210315,
0.0102913836,
-0.0005073232,
-0.0230551548,
-0.0165577698,
0.0277639758,
-0.0112978183,
-0.0635169223,
0.0383620113,
-0.0233788788,
0.002997135,
-0.0041453461,
-0.0358491205,
-0.0526134521,
-0.0101345237,
-0.0352369994,
-0.0056147007,
0.0230034702,
-0.0029461747,
-0.0242754053,
0.011915287,
0.0098336516,
0.0806355998,
0.0036639981,
-0.0021387883,
-0.016751403,
-0.0074389675,
0.026369568,
0.0206244085,
-0.0071200249,
-0.0355252624,
0.0797387809,
0.068556197,
0.0130954245,
-0.0134411296,
0.0378449559,
-0.0021757816,
0.0069143372,
-0.0069860187,
0.0075821984,
0.0407683849,
0.047483962,
-0.059361551,
-0.01506285,
0.1244297698,
0.0301039703,
-0.0595135912,
0.0100280931,
-0.0247338004,
-0.0004369017,
0.0120721115,
0.0173427016,
-0.1055514812,
-0.0398014113,
-0.0200343784,
0.0480120406,
0.0103027644,
0.0030059654,
0.026490977,
-0.0831682086,
0.0332578644,
0.0020024383,
-0.045700442,
-0.0295061078,
-0.0133676883,
0.0122232996,
-0.0015192862,
0.0281185638,
0.0002955704,
0.0055423551,
-0.0391487218,
0.0076105944,
-0.031694673,
-0.0745543614,
0.0482655168,
0.0029811868,
0.0725568086,
0.0728545114,
0.0445908457,
0.0122789256,
0.0056811534,
-0.0056493394,
0.0346934088,
0.0051308512,
-0.0196983516,
0.0792497694,
-0.0079266578,
0.0028036702,
-0.0125075923,
0.0680186749,
-0.0208078716,
-0.0204463322,
0.0337734073,
0.0466268063,
-0.05710195,
-0.0031434076,
-0.0307711065,
0.0552265793,
0.0379686467,
0.0642790347,
0.0012308878,
-0.0234014653,
-0.0166681763,
-0.009403144,
-0.0170628391,
-0.0061646015,
-0.043893978,
0.0303380061,
-0.0237039812,
0.0195773393,
-0.0773906782,
-0.0218466092,
0.0380258001,
-0.0203789342,
0.0040000784,
0.0182502158,
0.0253754891,
0.0237135179,
-0.0007332025,
0.0302881449,
0.0032024533,
0.0139431357,
-0.0928505585,
-0.0559254624,
0.0873180851,
-0.0401014499,
0.00873145,
0.0159101896,
-0.0353306308,
-0.0262294523,
-0.0194897633,
0.060211733,
0.009117377,
0.06627509,
-0.0160318315,
-0.014537828,
0.0192742255,
0.0035748372,
-0.04870997,
-0.0235125404,
0.0335634649,
0.048975978,
-0.0165702365,
0.0225585457,
-0.0119223138,
0.0241235998,
0.0089375461,
0.0480168723,
-0.048243966,
-0.0505600162,
0.0165546555,
0.0069629424,
0.0497635864,
-0.0098105399,
0.0121385772,
-0.04118523,
0.062200699,
-0.0190542266,
-0.0111773303,
-0.0397929177,
-0.0162386484,
0.0211877264,
-0.0524677709,
0.0035047729,
-0.0176770333,
-0.042796731,
-0.0232163612,
-0.0398810618,
0.0202082358,
0.0175604802,
-0.0148745691,
0.0175416339,
-0.0117040891,
-0.004272528,
0.0297772139,
0.0219713598,
0.0264876634,
0.0187625661,
0.1165074706,
0.0160509925,
0.0013742121,
0.0102676321,
0.0344228819,
-0.065367125,
-0.0690698475,
-0.0186285879,
0.0549517088,
0.0515129529,
0.0274122767,
0.0259120166,
-0.0266669765,
0.0071821637,
-0.0069900402,
0.0358447209,
-0.0499584824,
0.0158315487,
0.0694195703,
0.0120916851,
0.0061284713,
-0.0030757864,
0.0861441866,
-0.0084341047,
0.0509942546,
0.0091840904,
-0.0192984883,
-0.0650176033,
-0.0361594036,
0.039454814,
0.0100802463,
-0.0521217249,
0.0443887226,
-0.0360813253,
-0.0296230409,
-0.0155960834,
-0.0093515702,
-0.0551694818,
-0.0218658,
0.0524766296,
0.0278198309,
-0.012567237,
-0.0165380239,
-0.0332681015,
0.0204665437,
0.004831946,
-0.016949961,
0.0171469878,
-6.282840246e-33,
-0.0136764981,
-0.0173799358,
0.0439538397,
-0.0286685247,
-0.025824327,
-0.0026344426,
-0.0452852026,
0.0196127817,
-0.0488778763,
0.0258315001,
-0.0370394178,
0.0195749532,
0.0108627276,
0.0365083329,
0.0045253383,
-0.0289502405,
0.0333066843,
0.0064195464,
-0.0087415362,
0.0529055148,
-0.0162236392,
0.037596833,
0.0462227762,
-0.0852419659,
0.0163615216,
0.0093749044,
0.004136221,
0.0389394686,
-0.0688758492,
0.0738823339,
-0.0317111947,
0.0171498377,
0.0289444942,
-0.0319842473,
-0.0118971793,
-0.011638944,
-0.0846340284,
-0.0085598603,
-0.0120559605,
-0.0121501014,
-0.0597905517,
-0.0153439632,
0.0196754131,
-0.027329728,
0.010821104,
-0.0049213991,
0.0218677744,
-0.0363841318,
-0.0116510373,
-0.0204023067,
-0.0289838947,
0.0281111803,
-0.0234478358,
-0.0454116128,
-0.0608603247,
0.0122941267,
-0.0415856726,
0.0333639607,
-0.0253780186,
0.0036123986,
0.0441302992,
0.0271494109,
0.0000654517,
0.0048482637,
0.0008449823,
0.028351279,
0.0052663703,
-0.0060845683,
-0.0064507616,
-0.0173406582,
-0.0264780968,
0.0316299163,
0.0256820396,
0.0525059514,
-0.0150550632,
-0.0098425224,
-0.0832848102,
0.0155743733,
-0.0246381648,
0.0688203052,
0.0134931076,
-0.0051541748,
-0.0444865674,
-0.0165283922,
-0.0255609378,
0.0228211861,
0.0008080994,
-0.0246774089,
0.0307146683,
0.0268280469,
-0.0136237554,
-0.0201529041,
0.0227539986,
-0.024636345,
0.0243591275,
0.0116169741,
0.0044568763,
0.0028764899,
-0.042000398,
-0.0053617582,
-0.0783026814,
-0.026427757,
0.0302047897,
-0.0545867234,
0.0220019072,
0.0270290188,
0.0175056588,
-0.0112351542,
-0.043983195,
0.0031987845,
0.027384283,
0.0037998597,
0.0169900563,
0.0437638685,
0.0093754316,
-0.0001605715,
-0.020550143,
0.0925412253,
-0.007417006,
-0.0189854912,
-0.0664570779,
-0.072784394,
-0.0052799266,
0.0016493255,
-0.0811083168,
0.0367335789,
-0.0362921357,
0.0218187384,
0.0122693684,
-0.0602929033,
-0.0199839827,
0.0085390974,
2.773e-7,
0.0553946048,
0.0427474044,
0.0172785036,
0.0125847226,
0.0210334416,
0.0197744332,
-0.0348284766,
0.0135388533,
0.0173215903,
-0.0098409588,
0.0684910044,
0.0498429686,
0.0421808623,
0.0117570162,
-0.0856494755,
-0.0333080217,
-0.0872108266,
-0.0171771552,
-0.0223840456,
-0.0356315747,
0.0309080407,
0.096687004,
-0.0347817652,
-0.0156588908,
0.0253609549,
-0.0020292515,
0.0500916205,
-0.035425853,
-0.0049032574,
0.0741659179,
0.0306020565,
0.0031733403,
-0.007495983,
0.0157548636,
-0.0155687509,
0.0139959389,
0.0000742465,
0.1337456703,
-0.0422650725,
-0.0294197761,
0.0283393748,
0.0319012217,
0.0357111543,
-0.0389094204,
0.0428059213,
-0.0543214083,
-0.0364830643,
0.0008107039,
0.0251914803,
-0.0453969352,
0.0747914612,
-0.0519268773,
-0.0267986059,
0.0290192105,
0.0293251649,
0.0393593907,
-0.0213157814,
-0.0661063492,
-0.0304291304,
0.0111634145,
-0.0422283858,
-0.0564062856,
0.0272494741,
-0.0546970181,
-0.0392126516,
-0.0506536849,
0.0013998427,
2.123517917e-34,
0.0282391571,
-0.0186198298,
0.0189335179,
0.0640306026,
0.0242163576,
0.0010561937,
0.0155962035,
0.0263637453,
0.0566628724,
-0.0644581616,
-0.0268349927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03531v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03531v1 | Measuring Variety, Balance, and Disparity: An Analysis of Media Coverage of the 2021 German Federal Election | 2023-08-07T12:30:00 | 2023-08-07T12:30:00 | Michael Färber, Jannik Schwade, Adam Jatowt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Determining and measuring diversity in news articles is important for a
number of reasons, including preventing filter bubbles and fueling public
discourse, especially before elections. So far, the identification and analysis
of diversity have been illuminated in a variety of ways, such as measuring the
overlap of words or topics between news articles related to US elections.
However, the question of how diversity in news articles can be measured
holistically, i.e., with respect to (1) variety, (2) balance, and (3)
disparity, considering individuals, parties, and topics, has not been
addressed. In this paper, we present a framework for determining diversity in
news articles according to these dimensions. Furthermore, we create and provide
a dataset of Google Top Stories, encompassing more than 26,000 unique headlines
from more than 900 news outlets collected within two weeks before and after the
2021 German federal election. While we observe high diversity for more general
search terms (e.g., "election"), a range of search terms ("education,"
"Europe," "climate protection," "government") resulted in news articles with
high diversity in two out of three dimensions. This reflects a more subjective,
dedicated discussion on rather future-oriented topics. | [
0.0141340895,
0.0520786792,
-0.0205565579,
-0.0123699876,
-0.0035352926,
-0.0155578889,
-0.0040388885,
-0.046630837,
0.0156165855,
-0.0426896587,
0.0438559614,
-0.0447322391,
-0.001821772,
0.0626432523,
-0.0286418255,
-0.116063796,
0.0361670032,
0.0362223797,
0.0273941197,
-0.0337985195,
0.0028399786,
0.0056841276,
0.0134950522,
0.0433925241,
0.0074372143,
0.0148924943,
-0.0061959415,
0.0060874745,
0.0586188585,
-0.0196393374,
0.0157306194,
-0.0001739793,
0.0155894179,
0.0201553181,
0.0000015931,
-0.0336872004,
-0.0297429282,
-0.000206118,
0.0503012463,
-0.0498532653,
0.0503166914,
0.0094207469,
-0.0226783007,
0.014228466,
-0.0110164359,
0.0131985089,
0.0246429127,
0.0035935824,
0.0128605394,
0.026810145,
0.0040127891,
-0.0146601489,
-0.0366176181,
-0.0135171637,
-0.0030114632,
-0.0002890874,
0.0014414917,
-0.0718314946,
-0.042978432,
0.0112881809,
-0.0368734673,
-0.0078143198,
0.0123045286,
0.0423353724,
-0.0199020598,
0.0341978185,
-0.003839809,
-0.0446613468,
0.004791229,
0.0096529676,
0.0312654413,
-0.0068507041,
0.01587696,
-0.0175225437,
0.0180604029,
0.0803064778,
-0.03452136,
0.0467331931,
-0.0283868369,
0.0067679747,
0.0273525827,
0.0223910566,
-0.0147158606,
0.0664560422,
-0.0140590025,
0.0986768231,
0.0286990963,
0.0059274305,
0.0059777326,
0.0057053692,
0.0433146171,
-0.0195094608,
0.0095507465,
-0.020216221,
0.0109045664,
0.0065099224,
0.0007732415,
-0.0488655493,
0.0307603683,
-0.071172066,
-0.0640567243,
-0.0113474019,
-0.0033882754,
0.0679587349,
0.1085606813,
-0.0505768172,
0.0293185413,
-0.0092541547,
-0.0040825219,
-0.0126057444,
-0.0096858237,
0.0416965894,
0.0325830132,
-0.0243853461,
-0.0131652327,
-0.0059931078,
0.0145575153,
0.0143161789,
-0.0272964519,
-0.0183815155,
-0.0478755422,
0.0178091582,
-0.0116417129,
-0.0121994233,
-0.0613913536,
0.0619309358,
-0.0779962391,
0.0059866207,
-0.0302362535,
0.019450698,
0.0221136995,
0.0196334645,
0.0096818646,
-0.0326946341,
0.0138353389,
-0.0062685013,
0.005991423,
0.0068220613,
0.0425270349,
0.014562455,
-0.0043699197,
-0.0210664235,
0.0534772091,
-0.0704929531,
0.0033665681,
-0.0059564984,
0.0518882088,
-0.0050888397,
-0.009203692,
0.0073815528,
-0.0330932923,
0.0059201764,
-0.0096068894,
0.007540565,
0.0668894574,
0.0138888946,
-0.0021271037,
0.1090265214,
-0.0315554217,
0.0266053174,
0.0447975323,
-0.0015975959,
-0.0016211942,
-0.0019696692,
-0.0284308549,
0.0621494539,
-0.0090888496,
-0.0006389896,
-0.0254079252,
-0.0588677414,
0.0209334921,
-0.0202967823,
0.0052775913,
-0.0108556664,
0.0425136015,
0.0472798459,
-0.0215372071,
0.0199596826,
-0.0223313924,
-0.0144819394,
-0.0002325125,
0.0455862507,
0.0163600408,
0.0065293768,
0.0124495858,
-0.0127741722,
0.0362451263,
0.0646027774,
-0.0278172344,
-0.0020188754,
0.0095963478,
0.0535028353,
0.0760245398,
-0.0187325086,
0.0256163254,
-0.0417308994,
0.0006087309,
0.0700111538,
0.0063918186,
-0.0235303082,
0.007108327,
0.0056333444,
0.0453853384,
-0.0012940365,
-0.0089047933,
-0.0101572424,
-0.0068259249,
-0.0207853243,
0.0398496799,
0.0281790551,
0.0682869554,
0.0277872384,
-0.0318444408,
-0.0208274517,
-0.0336047895,
-0.0062357783,
0.0515172072,
0.0730535835,
0.0215247106,
0.0632782131,
-0.0423440635,
-0.0053264191,
0.0126699982,
-0.0093650613,
0.0063644852,
0.0570853725,
0.0161599573,
0.0063918135,
-0.0072498955,
0.0381073207,
-0.0107815405,
-0.0203703176,
0.0264298897,
0.0031069827,
-0.0235145204,
-0.0129713314,
0.0273097884,
0.0791668072,
-0.0179997403,
-0.1266873032,
-0.0129017951,
0.0316498429,
-0.0073995972,
0.0040699053,
0.0679487213,
0.0143409986,
-0.0509541519,
0.0157119241,
-0.0242340844,
-0.0394685157,
-0.0146212932,
-0.0314704888,
0.0788707808,
-0.013282299,
0.0413386375,
-0.0424434952,
-0.0252217073,
0.0112776076,
-0.0069484976,
-0.0240031946,
0.023588419,
-0.0032463328,
0.0484282412,
0.0228812527,
-0.0446722284,
-0.0362230837,
-0.0182079691,
-0.0458074026,
0.0158236697,
-0.0488259494,
0.0188789703,
0.0380275287,
0.0027088223,
-0.0120682186,
0.0204105843,
0.0198775232,
-0.0533787161,
-0.0350497067,
-0.0141611136,
-0.0148805492,
0.0037584023,
0.0164123792,
0.0263596661,
-0.0106044225,
-0.030387396,
0.0522253066,
0.0150307463,
0.0188951455,
0.030337736,
-0.012161376,
-0.0607511103,
-0.0046785292,
-0.0358107835,
0.0079807732,
-0.0054256571,
0.0343697406,
0.0128787551,
0.025246406,
0.0702339485,
0.0379209816,
0.0362646207,
0.0297253951,
-0.0361027122,
0.0082955603,
-0.0359863378,
0.0656638369,
-0.001147117,
-0.0356922634,
0.0626074076,
0.0161293373,
0.0038849977,
0.0186180752,
-0.0262733512,
0.0527259596,
-0.0588013269,
-0.0174135938,
-0.0459931493,
-0.0205208324,
0.0074973921,
0.0323798805,
0.0102552427,
-0.004130682,
-0.0195595901,
0.0457941256,
0.1152656004,
-0.045453798,
-0.0406389162,
-0.0297557153,
0.0414748751,
-0.0529324785,
0.0188936666,
-0.0087088309,
0.0283221081,
-0.0589318313,
-0.0370149314,
0.052892454,
-0.0413441956,
0.1073702946,
-0.0215226077,
-0.0201094281,
-0.0238100309,
-0.029286053,
-0.0254970975,
-0.0671144351,
0.014763915,
-0.0153015759,
0.0657823831,
-0.0083004329,
-0.0868629292,
-0.0033583846,
0.0247906726,
-0.0182537585,
-0.0057490626,
0.0001604453,
0.0508965999,
0.0418673232,
0.0099562425,
-0.0046797274,
0.0373845696,
-0.0140182097,
-0.0330888554,
0.0008395264,
0.0182751659,
0.0374626704,
0.0214164481,
-0.0233989805,
-0.0067976168,
-0.031075418,
-0.0239534155,
-0.0436371043,
0.0384752005,
-0.0117394822,
0.0287704021,
0.0336145572,
0.0107338885,
-0.0308860466,
-0.02397242,
-0.0234013647,
-0.0107404971,
0.0302018095,
0.0125976531,
-0.0553434528,
0.0831274316,
0.0105227046,
-0.0212847311,
-0.0487011969,
0.0065994109,
-0.0553071424,
-0.0311689842,
-0.0062989611,
0.0146743488,
-0.0330126509,
-0.0154621573,
-0.0359622613,
0.0135720894,
-0.0277703237,
-0.0466998518,
-0.0335131921,
0.018602984,
0.0179440174,
-0.0106128473,
-0.0559325591,
-0.0569800809,
0.0003447435,
-0.012383543,
-0.0230616406,
-0.0112376781,
0.024843052,
-0.0563979186,
0.0086658457,
-0.0112046422,
-0.0044676955,
-0.0392920785,
-0.0079569193,
0.0440566093,
-0.0423899367,
-0.0065937312,
-0.0225228537,
0.0106471386,
0.0666120201,
-0.0133787431,
0.0039532236,
-0.002462442,
-0.0049427887,
-0.0389096402,
-0.0324245356,
-0.0112948958,
0.0556024872,
0.0385505296,
0.0127315549,
-0.0004708675,
0.0459003784,
-0.0733467117,
0.0549122244,
-0.034780506,
-0.0009018276,
0.0253700353,
-0.0313152261,
-0.0379143022,
0.053923659,
-0.0215448644,
-0.038024202,
0.0355470292,
0.0078153228,
0.0158979874,
0.0331671722,
-0.0059176027,
-0.0280963853,
0.0066294693,
0.0400847159,
0.0127181644,
0.0268014576,
-0.067382805,
-0.0447829403,
0.0223049559,
-0.0602907427,
0.0108843837,
-0.0533467755,
-0.0232761689,
0.0437230431,
-0.0556898862,
0.0153334606,
0.0000885566,
-0.0069883065,
-0.010046564,
0.0670441911,
0.0740483105,
0.0200694799,
-0.0349888429,
0.0063106241,
-0.0106151672,
0.0094326856,
0.0094892494,
-0.0170455202,
0.0159322806,
0.0308585223,
-0.0593769997,
-0.0140028456,
0.0063754995,
-0.0296238214,
-0.0304933097,
0.0301859844,
-0.0080758473,
-0.0201236811,
-0.0369976647,
-0.0607515574,
0.0273303427,
-0.0315735787,
0.0177452993,
-0.0341296829,
0.0001589503,
-0.0344979428,
-0.0373149514,
0.07363832,
0.0061723082,
0.0598592907,
-0.1071429551,
0.0308020096,
-0.0151372403,
-0.0036152378,
-0.0129376771,
-0.0042756996,
-0.0066371085,
0.0121568376,
-0.0112413848,
0.0147714056,
0.0016554471,
-0.0103743356,
0.0208443664,
-0.0011962125,
0.047209952,
-0.0217650328,
-0.0806838498,
-0.0341107622,
-0.0244305581,
0.044114247,
0.0127863372,
0.0087647727,
-0.0215335004,
0.0148733137,
-0.0170057304,
-0.0204734523,
-0.022084387,
-0.0058224923,
0.0094732372,
0.0316953845,
0.0110735772,
-0.0178642534,
-0.0193022713,
0.0414320342,
-0.0098498277,
0.0122550391,
0.0309145469,
-0.0341690555,
-0.0057197982,
-0.0106867095,
0.0411731154,
0.025021214,
-0.0284187123,
-0.0317892805,
-0.0778178498,
0.0140651381,
0.0521284565,
-0.0096773775,
0.0349464677,
0.0279361755,
-0.0076267351,
0.0714531466,
-0.0037777326,
0.064017348,
-0.0104475264,
0.0369469002,
-0.0731099769,
-0.0527270027,
0.0306095351,
-6.145587689e-33,
-0.0107775331,
-0.0390411131,
-0.0296412744,
-0.1231594607,
-0.0236255825,
0.0489288643,
0.0074297553,
0.0099830339,
-0.0548125841,
0.0478652976,
0.0212185346,
0.0322284549,
0.0133783575,
-0.007678675,
0.040072415,
-0.0269665681,
0.0229684841,
0.0089454288,
-0.0381686352,
0.0049987324,
-0.0098185539,
-0.0047526453,
0.0280982964,
-0.0152705321,
0.0161174405,
0.0231811237,
-0.0133886291,
-0.0782888234,
0.0654256791,
0.0214151926,
0.0113714356,
0.0437154211,
0.0570735522,
-0.0940288007,
-0.0091538383,
0.0654223338,
-0.0215766858,
-0.0899898857,
0.0271180719,
-0.0053119217,
0.0155961886,
-0.0080458643,
-0.0003824951,
0.0309112165,
-0.0374505147,
-0.0315518863,
0.0705743581,
0.0266130865,
0.0121326549,
-0.0308107343,
0.0135100912,
0.0279287715,
-0.0415282436,
0.0513631292,
-0.0630599037,
0.0353290252,
0.0606553108,
0.0737441778,
-0.0494715385,
0.0515757538,
-0.0239258297,
-0.0019784432,
0.0078673614,
-0.0316083692,
-0.005965706,
0.0688694865,
-0.0142063936,
0.0577378497,
-0.0659444854,
-0.0522231162,
0.0283048023,
-0.005056743,
-0.0055744359,
0.0643637404,
0.0461740345,
-0.037578579,
-0.0648525506,
0.0315688103,
0.0156551115,
-0.0345885158,
0.0148379784,
-0.017713109,
-0.029563589,
0.0154079562,
0.0049713082,
-0.0469577536,
-0.0221805945,
-0.0117053511,
0.0036237263,
0.0438900217,
-0.0321270302,
0.0232679155,
0.030380616,
-0.0521498919,
-0.0155953187,
0.0256274547,
-0.0370636322,
-0.0232749786,
0.0133336354,
0.0099736033,
-0.026297221,
-0.0276043136,
-0.0173631329,
0.0842313617,
0.0026724255,
-0.0358950011,
-0.0250035804,
0.0037805219,
-0.0507547073,
-0.019542437,
0.0062064757,
-0.0225298516,
0.0107530784,
0.0253119245,
0.0097229825,
0.0369545817,
0.0331074856,
-0.0088147381,
0.0418347493,
-0.001230441,
0.0266535934,
-0.0509811491,
-0.0689132288,
0.0353316925,
-0.0039490089,
-0.0359588489,
-0.0228594486,
-0.0368126817,
0.0458988138,
-0.0027904003,
-0.0294781309,
-0.0448890254,
2.434e-7,
0.0421172269,
0.0205387454,
-0.0554421879,
0.0442121811,
0.0156374499,
0.0284234565,
0.0076623154,
0.0735717341,
-0.0860242024,
-0.0579906106,
-0.0278257169,
0.0011442043,
-0.0041293828,
0.0482765026,
-0.0300061405,
0.0114801032,
-0.0746699572,
0.0564296432,
-0.0598955043,
0.0296578258,
0.0115064392,
0.0528829172,
0.0306066126,
0.0082523543,
-0.0384883024,
0.0397463627,
0.0230378415,
-0.0281539634,
-0.0573107712,
0.019496737,
0.0301287416,
-0.0098542469,
0.0119533893,
0.029870579,
-0.0067067281,
-0.0083980262,
0.0024482948,
-0.0241683945,
0.0127959875,
0.0262421407,
0.0013952276,
-0.0159722548,
-0.0051005161,
-0.0679693446,
0.0487338975,
-0.0015443715,
-0.0168636553,
-0.1432763487,
-0.0561271645,
0.0204697829,
0.1132015511,
0.00457288,
-0.0366604067,
0.0092792725,
-0.0299616475,
0.0040453286,
0.0162164457,
-0.0095732864,
-0.0137878414,
0.0039512399,
-0.0344539061,
-0.0551874898,
-0.0156692732,
0.0126536805,
0.0280985199,
-0.0018159351,
0.037055362,
1.585197869e-34,
0.0543031469,
0.0267613661,
-0.0510130189,
-0.0504206643,
0.0190611612,
-0.0313172415,
-0.0409795754,
-0.0438219085,
-0.0247652233,
0.0083606048,
0.0197736491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03519v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03519v1 | Vocab-Expander: A System for Creating Domain-Specific Vocabularies Based on Word Embeddings | 2023-08-07T12:13:25 | 2023-08-07T12:13:25 | Michael Färber, Nicholas Popovic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we propose Vocab-Expander at https://vocab-expander.com, an
online tool that enables end-users (e.g., technology scouts) to create and
expand a vocabulary of their domain of interest. It utilizes an ensemble of
state-of-the-art word embedding techniques based on web text and ConceptNet, a
common-sense knowledge base, to suggest related terms for already given terms.
The system has an easy-to-use interface that allows users to quickly confirm or
reject term suggestions. Vocab-Expander offers a variety of potential use
cases, such as improving concept-based information retrieval in technology and
innovation management, enhancing communication and collaboration within
organizations or interdisciplinary projects, and creating vocabularies for
specific courses in education. | [
0.0429599658,
-0.0424992666,
-0.0152784064,
0.0086298697,
0.0047861789,
-0.0387959965,
0.0017359887,
0.0322962105,
-0.0149355829,
-0.0311449599,
-0.014674386,
-0.0131189441,
0.0103263129,
0.0620897822,
0.0396820344,
-0.0271625891,
0.0388048328,
0.0219866894,
-0.0533131659,
0.0363438539,
0.0142295379,
0.0204391181,
-0.0074563809,
0.0509653091,
0.0165003054,
0.0157381948,
0.0105225407,
-0.0474092774,
-0.0094553633,
-0.0221314766,
0.0322886482,
0.0305864718,
0.0370725319,
-0.0027552214,
0.0000021179,
-0.0536225438,
-0.0404533483,
-0.0228535105,
0.0039361683,
0.0135744028,
0.058072377,
0.041689612,
0.0265014023,
0.0283071548,
-0.0332308672,
-0.012375568,
0.0387707204,
-0.0129370885,
-0.003405903,
-0.0093981717,
0.0078610983,
-0.0263301991,
-0.004456508,
-0.0160884708,
-0.0044292537,
-0.0182733722,
-0.0021545938,
0.0053691659,
0.0601540059,
0.0247840639,
-0.0246260278,
-0.0016954412,
-0.0724916086,
-0.0228074752,
0.1226831675,
0.0179269239,
0.0034889898,
-0.0258458313,
0.0250468981,
0.0647768304,
0.0565640256,
0.0012118786,
-0.0047665993,
0.0124459872,
0.0053744265,
0.0981450677,
-0.0416509435,
-0.0098913582,
-0.0088044861,
-0.0336581022,
0.0030100837,
0.0078419847,
0.0158901513,
0.0259465836,
0.0021463844,
0.0491563417,
0.0288131386,
-0.0322936922,
0.0040281685,
0.0057227118,
0.0121509042,
-0.0224259142,
0.0248818602,
0.0046507469,
-0.0115737421,
0.0382471979,
-0.0209050868,
-0.0373833142,
0.0252056252,
-0.0517698303,
-0.0073703323,
-0.0018729251,
0.0299047828,
0.0575200692,
-0.0094931144,
-0.0229653046,
-0.0008218031,
-0.0172123071,
-0.0407893695,
-0.0063244631,
-0.0964425877,
0.0014588438,
-0.0241860393,
0.0285397284,
0.0288265292,
-0.0410802662,
-0.0039613866,
0.0452859364,
-0.0395779051,
0.014424975,
0.0112857036,
0.0226441771,
0.0064891619,
-0.031483613,
-0.0434875749,
-0.0155074801,
-0.0644026175,
0.0192536339,
-0.0055296803,
0.0011979023,
0.0023782819,
-0.026200844,
0.0426587127,
0.0226237997,
-0.0117092645,
0.0144886561,
0.0327590108,
-0.0527078621,
-0.0232078321,
-0.0499521047,
0.0090990756,
0.0575166047,
-0.0009229506,
-0.0703149289,
-0.0076328437,
0.0032615294,
-0.0078639975,
-0.0023885109,
0.0193011779,
0.0593106039,
-0.0585864671,
0.0803931281,
-0.0977467895,
-0.0262563881,
0.0719873086,
0.037356548,
0.0142193381,
0.0121883266,
-0.0008623941,
0.0187012795,
0.0773882121,
0.0121461339,
-0.0257767737,
-0.0439009033,
0.0002779039,
-0.0379128791,
-0.0305860601,
0.0111109195,
-0.0303816237,
0.0514067225,
-0.0325318426,
-0.0139394486,
-0.0475198664,
0.0497840643,
0.0107593387,
0.0944945663,
0.061418429,
0.0270519312,
0.0123337032,
0.0265697129,
-0.0400487371,
-0.0591427982,
0.0081719914,
0.0177423917,
-0.0264077876,
-0.0158521589,
0.0346519575,
0.0021653604,
-0.0169240907,
-0.022838017,
-0.0117220879,
-0.0053633978,
0.0433038957,
-0.0479362383,
0.0577818342,
-0.0009957178,
-0.0088229915,
0.0158150308,
0.0375354178,
-0.0394424871,
0.0196492318,
-0.00970966,
0.0204171222,
0.1162126139,
0.1016704291,
-0.0444934145,
-0.0828010067,
-0.0038800361,
-0.0072738775,
0.0304207951,
0.0480513312,
-0.0437990539,
-0.0853462294,
-0.048683539,
-0.0376065373,
-0.0052047078,
0.0162650477,
-0.0106130233,
0.0212483425,
0.0452152081,
0.0314713307,
-0.0672713816,
0.0436797626,
0.0382871702,
-0.0194159914,
0.0130905919,
0.0032672931,
0.0067486484,
-0.0411932543,
0.0592071414,
-0.0082372688,
0.0214953981,
0.0250798464,
-0.033362817,
-0.0790818557,
-0.0495764837,
-0.0024339515,
0.0508918464,
0.04116074,
-0.0634924993,
0.0494359471,
-0.0219626874,
0.0125856549,
-0.0127032874,
0.0461340174,
-0.0082393382,
0.0502154306,
-0.0283963941,
0.0003056224,
-0.0439610183,
0.0174846146,
-0.0228677094,
0.0421814471,
0.0269703884,
0.0386533886,
-0.0553816669,
0.0247822329,
0.0019051052,
0.0581457652,
-0.0320949964,
0.0140936626,
0.0132103758,
0.0401607975,
0.0300638936,
-0.0210335404,
-0.0359811522,
0.0430050418,
-0.0735306293,
0.0022378224,
0.0201419853,
0.0078817364,
-0.0028032754,
0.0030562074,
0.0256496426,
0.012751569,
0.0057569882,
0.0677016079,
-0.0389748998,
-0.0150365876,
0.0135008637,
0.0018283982,
-0.0309511274,
-0.0269309077,
-0.0136536825,
0.0150004672,
0.0301747546,
0.0332058258,
-0.0372196995,
-0.0451226011,
0.0623164549,
-0.0494791381,
-0.0029498229,
-0.0004157891,
-0.0080161607,
-0.0245658364,
-0.0260587335,
-0.0120182484,
-0.0248823203,
0.0267868638,
0.0044571417,
0.0651732683,
-0.0037600086,
-0.0155831771,
-0.0250810031,
-0.0021165775,
0.0272130258,
0.0098933382,
0.022308616,
0.004627353,
-0.0181653015,
0.0042010103,
-0.0061703227,
-0.0312914476,
0.0148749901,
-0.0439755656,
0.0316740647,
-0.0668947995,
-0.0327864699,
-0.0070425319,
0.0291862357,
0.0330688469,
0.0028026004,
0.0535868257,
0.0259197094,
0.0178193804,
-0.0535913818,
-0.0534205735,
-0.0117140012,
0.0219569076,
-0.0425541587,
0.0392614193,
0.0396450087,
-0.0192735586,
-0.03350145,
0.0360956751,
0.0537426248,
-0.0670393035,
0.031554874,
-0.0159778446,
0.0035643703,
0.0116049238,
0.0087218396,
-0.0502958037,
0.0361969732,
-0.0060448293,
0.0084634935,
0.0722234994,
-0.0299578402,
0.0056991503,
0.0053243684,
0.0170620084,
0.0057667028,
0.0611819811,
-0.0449512191,
0.0171650723,
0.0213008616,
0.0241947621,
-0.0174223911,
-0.0042133387,
0.0428130813,
-0.0105160028,
0.0358166471,
-0.0313098095,
-0.0977512598,
-0.0047450601,
-0.029865928,
0.0371485688,
-0.0849127173,
-0.011809648,
-0.0204321425,
-0.0382526815,
-0.0057306523,
-0.0015881124,
0.0727782622,
0.0761749893,
-0.0400404297,
-0.0091212709,
-0.0124467965,
-0.0107208723,
0.0430873111,
0.0272542778,
-0.0627392232,
0.0090772221,
-0.0004674857,
0.0254288372,
0.0289143622,
-0.0332257785,
-0.0217737872,
-0.0902459249,
0.0080186483,
-0.01246709,
0.036890585,
-0.0019892924,
-0.0517831556,
-0.0005307937,
0.0354008451,
-0.0547462516,
-0.0103349052,
-0.018811455,
0.0139282569,
0.0054428387,
-0.0577692129,
-0.0361548364,
0.038709458,
-0.0244069621,
0.01056989,
0.0782316998,
0.0317967348,
-0.0356346332,
-0.0284343194,
-0.0253685694,
-0.0431471616,
-0.0369940288,
-0.0091376975,
0.051252231,
-0.02545272,
0.011348404,
0.0108583756,
-0.0085422629,
-0.0428931639,
-0.0124062784,
0.0210235473,
0.0734060109,
0.0071768472,
0.0420947187,
-0.0655438825,
-0.0173840038,
0.0087695178,
0.0392323621,
0.0030929013,
-0.0496885553,
0.0701084286,
0.000238158,
0.00013158,
0.0220887866,
-0.0474882573,
-0.0173087232,
-0.0211289246,
-0.0363232568,
-0.0929823294,
-0.0100744655,
0.0626023561,
0.0160349254,
0.0302483048,
0.0252022501,
0.0132655632,
0.0328205712,
-0.0862133875,
-0.0239031855,
0.0448270068,
0.0196044073,
-0.0474213064,
-0.0080731977,
0.0444647484,
-0.0092499275,
-0.0250382517,
0.0237194076,
0.0189290661,
-0.0261981543,
-0.0355783887,
-0.0377918966,
0.0076096747,
-0.0204613023,
-0.0377445519,
-0.040546909,
0.0955824852,
0.0133238444,
-0.0135690346,
-0.016324956,
-0.0006668382,
0.0075302366,
0.0029562616,
0.0385142751,
-0.051085081,
0.0031564918,
-0.0589725189,
0.0204358902,
0.0057303188,
-0.0381376296,
0.0306051336,
-0.0383233391,
0.0304628797,
-0.0284795295,
0.0218195189,
-0.0554235727,
-0.014474568,
0.0337031968,
-0.0244626533,
-0.020482257,
0.0142604467,
-0.0043561975,
-0.0712374449,
0.0156703312,
0.0178586692,
-0.0122687863,
-0.0020879868,
0.0437196977,
0.0324518383,
0.0038188908,
0.0265263971,
0.0137136308,
0.0233341176,
-0.0136299832,
-0.0634646937,
-0.0545717701,
-0.0050307852,
-0.0878682062,
0.0337894075,
-0.0120704351,
-0.0278647523,
-0.0230932813,
0.0400899313,
-0.0140148764,
-0.0677776337,
-0.0326562934,
0.0620984808,
0.001508918,
0.0141894966,
-0.0275361333,
-0.0582679957,
-0.0301510952,
-0.0086657247,
0.0049068327,
-0.0610411391,
-0.0034158044,
0.027582068,
0.0383129939,
-0.0070413947,
-0.0068248855,
0.0619370453,
-0.0248869322,
0.016653493,
-0.0266865175,
-0.0471159928,
-0.028813675,
0.0039159684,
0.0285885297,
0.0802800283,
-0.0371707417,
0.0167638492,
-0.085080713,
-0.0309531819,
0.0158905089,
0.0050463984,
-0.0279305615,
0.0467217118,
0.0666105673,
0.086598441,
0.0094424346,
0.0158415809,
-0.0126956133,
0.0254236087,
-0.0641091093,
-0.039682515,
0.0030139424,
-6.035907821e-33,
-0.019827202,
-0.0406471677,
0.021225052,
0.0184771996,
0.0062181307,
0.0073537244,
0.0254174061,
0.0443204269,
-0.0324879102,
0.0344119146,
-0.0077188229,
0.0070080836,
-0.0063784299,
-0.0311560631,
0.0098149879,
0.0255430508,
0.0268254001,
0.0295290668,
0.0245088171,
0.0207899921,
0.0457291119,
0.04914831,
0.0659594014,
-0.0666804463,
0.0115178432,
-0.0117353546,
0.0007702261,
-0.0282033663,
0.0784949437,
0.0472841933,
-0.017707739,
0.0512476973,
0.0086588692,
-0.0229722299,
0.020664297,
0.0128147509,
-0.034314014,
-0.0389311276,
-0.0059635057,
-0.0251089223,
0.0021456734,
-0.0074957311,
0.0109817209,
-0.0061307182,
0.0180217996,
0.0429163054,
0.0631551892,
-0.00348224,
-0.0511026122,
0.0127207441,
-0.0535000823,
0.0228084624,
0.0138442256,
-0.0026667418,
0.010431272,
0.0013784331,
0.036791373,
-0.0202021077,
-0.0573649257,
0.0701585338,
-0.0043567861,
0.0364933684,
0.0644984692,
-0.0028518229,
-0.0432200357,
0.0627859086,
-0.0504584871,
-0.0504337139,
0.0379795283,
-0.0320327133,
-0.0066861059,
0.0742625669,
0.0027152384,
0.0526691563,
0.0368416719,
-0.0579258166,
0.0052418876,
-0.0020836086,
-0.0203716811,
0.0280092694,
-0.0049776258,
0.0171391461,
-0.0499684736,
-0.0264440775,
0.0029929373,
0.036526449,
-0.0501705632,
-0.0790914968,
0.044869978,
0.0162855238,
-0.0148354732,
0.0093409382,
-0.0411578529,
-0.0367347375,
-0.0087158196,
0.0207869373,
0.0053645852,
-0.0330214053,
-0.0227208622,
-0.0144788893,
-0.0358838141,
-0.0426190458,
-0.0293972101,
-0.001978524,
-0.0239457954,
-0.0065888357,
-0.0219049659,
-0.0183875952,
-0.037666589,
0.0013530552,
0.0041076872,
-0.0852614269,
-0.0318332538,
-0.0404127538,
0.0332552083,
0.0407779701,
-0.0103439773,
0.0179876294,
0.0596085452,
-0.0156867802,
-0.0025744112,
-0.0799229071,
0.0061957063,
-0.0032013324,
-0.0022879578,
0.0000967354,
-0.0179598499,
0.0338905714,
0.0534582175,
-0.0337365381,
-0.0205290169,
-0.0312017445,
2.864e-7,
0.0486079752,
0.0750679225,
-0.0512600541,
-0.0228792951,
-0.0030474016,
0.0067035104,
0.0250800028,
0.0513838604,
-0.0493551679,
-0.0254907683,
0.0018960253,
0.0019850344,
-0.0307536814,
0.039932929,
-0.0617760941,
-0.0626577958,
0.0444330722,
-0.013515221,
-0.0399176739,
-0.0279050637,
0.1011569351,
0.0447704978,
0.0619599931,
0.0020116742,
-0.0469346158,
-0.0469459295,
0.0034907463,
-0.0160090532,
0.0069803162,
0.0280294586,
0.0105319712,
0.0432257429,
-0.030677991,
0.0002945427,
-0.066270873,
0.0048631127,
0.0196345765,
-0.0225017704,
-0.0055252952,
0.0436085686,
-0.0175900199,
-0.0588072017,
0.0174681693,
-0.0227221306,
0.0158581659,
0.004171594,
0.0188784674,
0.0173513982,
-0.0135933366,
0.0531716309,
-0.0053196591,
-0.0288142134,
0.0059319516,
-0.0268920399,
-0.0190514959,
0.0166175701,
-0.0319545493,
-0.111857146,
0.0578946285,
0.0351449773,
-0.0222845189,
-0.0359517373,
-0.0172348674,
-0.0184938088,
0.0312681198,
0.0371629,
0.046282988,
2.381341022e-34,
-0.0027963277,
0.0137992594,
-0.0062691211,
0.0151975155,
0.0244344547,
-0.0087916292,
0.019279113,
0.0232488532,
0.0255752169,
-0.0370849483,
-0.0076802555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03449v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03449v2 | Accurate Retraining-free Pruning for Pretrained Encoder-based Language Models | 2023-08-07T10:11:42 | 2024-03-15T04:51:19 | Seungcheol Park, Hojun Choi, U Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | Given a pretrained encoder-based language model, how can we accurately
compress it without retraining? Retraining-free structured pruning algorithms
are crucial in pretrained language model compression due to their significantly
reduced pruning cost and capability to prune large language models. However,
existing retraining-free algorithms encounter severe accuracy degradation, as
they fail to handle pruning errors, especially at high compression rates. In
this paper, we propose K-prune (Knowledge-preserving pruning), an accurate
retraining-free structured pruning algorithm for pretrained encoder-based
language models. K-prune focuses on preserving the useful knowledge of the
pretrained model to minimize pruning errors through a carefully designed
iterative pruning process composed of knowledge measurement,
knowledge-preserving mask search, and knowledge-preserving weight-tuning. As a
result, K-prune shows significant accuracy improvements up to 58.02%p higher F1
score compared to existing retraining-free pruning algorithms under a high
compression rate of 80% on the SQuAD benchmark without any retraining process. | [
-0.0105665009,
0.052786015,
-0.0049037198,
0.0300893039,
0.0005877035,
0.0233712085,
-0.0112558249,
0.0884714052,
-0.0708178207,
0.0048063397,
-0.0227118954,
-0.0206088256,
0.0182955693,
-0.0033715346,
0.0009907165,
-0.0197625123,
0.0247478355,
-0.0223690979,
0.0208983794,
-0.015198797,
0.0176045503,
0.0076556015,
0.0104184859,
0.0339581929,
-0.0132006044,
-0.0127759799,
-0.0114603899,
0.0050666551,
-0.0281588379,
0.0077817282,
0.0168128442,
0.0520209707,
0.0233301651,
0.0029334438,
0.0000021197,
-0.0150344493,
-0.0170635525,
-0.0270669553,
-0.0768523589,
0.0640089884,
0.0480931401,
-0.0539592691,
0.0056447494,
0.0298059639,
0.0032397413,
-0.0399344787,
0.049645368,
-0.0009281641,
0.0498363711,
0.088951759,
0.0030936627,
-0.0464921147,
-0.0395188704,
-0.0403313376,
-0.0646215528,
-0.0172161106,
0.0272956956,
-0.0123235341,
-0.0660500824,
-0.0368738733,
-0.0346341915,
0.0144902999,
0.015772976,
0.0232859813,
-0.021520555,
0.0067634145,
-0.0333199725,
-0.0298850499,
0.0312556326,
0.0218386874,
-0.0809382871,
-0.0728779435,
-0.0023884594,
-0.0010251709,
-0.0397695191,
-0.027721554,
-0.0305955261,
0.0089188963,
0.0197432861,
0.0262801405,
-0.0267602354,
-0.0110731358,
0.0325669944,
-0.0370418988,
-0.0170172434,
0.0524879694,
0.0331860669,
-0.0264516287,
-0.0126826167,
-0.0048046075,
0.012792604,
-0.0618811026,
0.0150922257,
0.0228585545,
0.0244564749,
0.0106547866,
-0.0722271875,
-0.0461229049,
-0.0123943556,
-0.0330771133,
-0.0023010434,
0.0379415229,
0.0584396422,
0.0106863091,
-0.0097737107,
0.050429441,
0.0718301386,
0.0078384448,
-0.0409605801,
-0.0095722117,
-0.010370736,
-0.0165594164,
-0.0781052932,
0.0203599762,
-0.0383449607,
-0.0022827929,
-0.0421552882,
-0.0120627033,
0.0159232765,
-0.0159073342,
0.030135816,
-0.0397055298,
-0.0241484903,
0.0024310888,
0.0150556946,
0.0142936418,
-0.0025068317,
-0.0086227469,
-0.0387481749,
-0.0393170826,
-0.0214794464,
0.0131632257,
0.0090487413,
-0.0196420681,
0.0189613383,
-0.0015150997,
-0.0085109053,
-0.0313967988,
-0.0185955614,
0.0033764432,
0.0109516103,
-0.0386378728,
-0.0088180965,
-0.0519762374,
0.0441315137,
-0.050560575,
0.0107715176,
-0.0942892581,
-0.0251737759,
0.0140153421,
-0.0423590019,
0.0342530571,
-0.0248082206,
0.0542544611,
0.0066254539,
0.0006032623,
0.0433913879,
0.0925598294,
0.0299525633,
-0.013584624,
0.0283304267,
-0.0644627735,
-0.0129408874,
0.0564249419,
0.0477098823,
0.0062090689,
-0.0449188948,
-0.029951226,
0.0185097996,
-0.0235922653,
0.0568605065,
0.0587699413,
-0.0694406778,
-0.0472647697,
0.0284970161,
-0.0014504141,
0.0702098459,
0.0658959523,
0.0325988047,
0.0131381089,
0.0221405104,
-0.0062828828,
-0.0057066819,
-0.0175852831,
-0.0536410771,
-0.0052522705,
-0.0169630088,
0.0467417911,
-0.0568504557,
-0.0129250893,
-0.0321344621,
-0.0389422812,
0.0290934164,
-0.0041149538,
0.0451331325,
0.0073822229,
-0.0374500826,
0.0928553268,
0.0166661702,
-0.0910799429,
0.0002005585,
-0.0231811777,
-0.0213606805,
0.0402753204,
0.0483356714,
-0.0011379195,
-0.0278883055,
0.0398280956,
-0.015071203,
-0.0248487107,
0.0409334488,
-0.0350281671,
0.0490356274,
-0.0794230476,
-0.0081076901,
0.0082445666,
0.0099062901,
-0.007581546,
0.0183716435,
0.0377269797,
0.0241693258,
-0.0320675038,
-0.0112473583,
0.0455309115,
-0.0188522711,
0.0050036111,
-0.0069127847,
0.001868414,
0.0239045043,
-0.0100249052,
-0.029213246,
-0.0042797406,
0.0668987259,
-0.0396566801,
0.0321443938,
-0.028269086,
-0.0403250121,
-0.106380716,
0.0594572462,
0.0045781345,
0.0316825397,
0.090042159,
-0.0363424718,
-0.034838412,
-0.0056133238,
-0.0272257272,
0.068820335,
-0.0536952205,
0.0649618581,
-0.040458627,
0.0249181278,
0.0201114658,
0.0369811058,
-0.0033489114,
0.0032746205,
0.0178275947,
-0.052259732,
0.009249825,
-0.0464717485,
-0.0575524196,
0.0368161388,
-0.0294403303,
0.0086465348,
0.0233796351,
0.0270248521,
0.0112132821,
-0.0010062534,
-0.0951771885,
0.0000718082,
-0.0300311092,
0.0210394915,
0.0097699193,
0.0244543813,
-0.010865964,
-0.0258438606,
0.0004666208,
-0.0061940737,
0.0012605488,
0.0262417458,
-0.0200106818,
-0.027254805,
-0.0349887684,
0.023409687,
-0.0437878035,
0.0433358401,
0.0702866763,
-0.0573507883,
-0.0394586734,
-0.0556587018,
0.0849816874,
-0.0548566505,
0.0315803587,
0.0086293686,
-0.0466083176,
-0.0140513806,
0.0185425617,
-0.0110316994,
0.0305385496,
-0.0012627918,
0.0331216902,
0.07808768,
0.0134385908,
-0.0297709648,
-0.002583232,
-0.0184293296,
-0.0371427871,
-0.0271606501,
-0.0244249515,
0.0083398912,
0.0899943933,
-0.0095151709,
0.0048730657,
-0.09866824,
-0.0408501662,
-0.0180541519,
-0.0281173158,
-0.0632868558,
-0.0493818149,
-0.0045532668,
0.0270998925,
-0.0144058708,
-0.014072109,
0.0272093359,
-0.062103305,
-0.0300008859,
-0.0313873552,
-0.0032279657,
-0.0024803821,
0.0369148441,
0.0329635553,
0.0489578396,
0.0256350189,
0.0054935305,
-0.0277582295,
0.0303293187,
0.0078963209,
-0.044295039,
-0.0181418117,
-0.0328565575,
0.0381489955,
0.0046737376,
-0.0144325448,
-0.0221504029,
-0.027479995,
-0.0108242007,
0.0272920467,
0.0284647308,
-0.010169073,
0.0116924401,
0.0836658627,
-0.0036608244,
0.0611293316,
0.0416158997,
0.0362365916,
0.0122645162,
0.0062083066,
0.0439491794,
-0.0125083681,
0.0264536981,
-0.0491964296,
0.0212531257,
0.0381575562,
0.0475557856,
0.0262438487,
-0.0245913956,
-0.0033686338,
0.0233725552,
-0.0213050563,
-0.0127653517,
0.0106151691,
0.0556891039,
-0.0388033427,
0.0001332144,
0.1032990441,
0.0252533592,
-0.0417216979,
0.0303283725,
0.0342073254,
0.0592128411,
0.0073348056,
0.0292358436,
-0.0481302068,
-0.0198086295,
0.0306253247,
-0.0030855848,
0.0135282706,
-0.0104701631,
-0.0039701257,
-0.1311184615,
0.0033936072,
0.0255616941,
-0.035369847,
-0.0155746844,
-0.0367444046,
0.0011925035,
-0.0263070408,
-0.0087605016,
0.0414956361,
-0.0027923246,
-0.0010941286,
0.0240731444,
-0.0731460527,
-0.0692161396,
0.0081484476,
0.0110052796,
0.0417019539,
0.0294510219,
0.0242352467,
0.0203386098,
-0.0288131069,
0.0353139341,
-0.0016224707,
-0.0166708957,
-0.0314467996,
0.0476555265,
-0.0008246208,
0.0045448681,
0.0513965786,
-0.0154665839,
-0.0415879376,
0.0034602017,
0.0015735278,
0.0423054695,
0.0011996577,
-0.0412601866,
0.01746778,
-0.0247871447,
-0.0277823433,
0.0601976067,
0.0419427119,
0.0036209263,
-0.008980101,
-0.0197203588,
0.0200717989,
-0.0328246914,
-0.0085063726,
0.0340325572,
-0.0185795277,
-0.0311380401,
-0.0403155163,
0.0064078029,
0.042344559,
0.0255829785,
-0.0215547252,
-0.0099213123,
0.0038023365,
0.0246704277,
-0.0741693377,
-0.0185649488,
-0.0464908183,
-0.0085673928,
-0.0465121754,
0.0029973364,
-0.0127039533,
0.038178049,
-0.0206305608,
-0.0205439925,
-0.0727831051,
-0.0308362208,
-0.0301922224,
0.0658451021,
0.0244175401,
0.0653063431,
-0.012767911,
-0.0287469476,
0.0367235616,
-0.0169830136,
-0.0534784235,
0.0830577388,
0.0214968286,
-0.1025120094,
-0.0003946938,
0.0515366718,
-0.0376023576,
0.022030279,
-0.0028717141,
0.0320095159,
-0.0074661709,
-0.0257165674,
0.0161515102,
0.0575886108,
0.0032584893,
-0.01214178,
-0.0289173238,
-0.003367539,
0.039988596,
-0.0079615992,
0.0165905543,
-0.0578722097,
0.0319943354,
0.0124872504,
0.0613493398,
0.0165883917,
0.0193717536,
0.0179689769,
-0.0193280838,
0.0021369231,
0.0048335865,
0.0182081573,
0.0320302472,
0.076784797,
0.0103364112,
-0.0051826546,
-0.0161081273,
0.0052023018,
-0.0025819354,
-0.046476528,
-0.0192355607,
0.0189018771,
0.0425383821,
-0.0488536768,
0.0385571979,
0.0224069878,
-0.0504618585,
-0.0621277802,
0.0078302277,
0.0377335884,
-0.0199392661,
0.0387841053,
-0.0113664996,
0.0075972942,
-0.0387344137,
0.0039669564,
-0.0009994856,
-0.0251233485,
0.0079983808,
-0.0036617699,
-0.0405822657,
0.0084726671,
0.0954447165,
0.012490401,
0.0745772719,
-0.025879791,
-0.0262202173,
-0.0380071439,
-0.0131938858,
-0.0254497156,
0.0330281481,
-0.0279272217,
-0.0034859711,
-0.0316334702,
-0.0695345625,
0.0027588201,
-0.0092356568,
0.0080211144,
0.0220357906,
0.0686904266,
0.045864854,
-0.0107739549,
0.025993064,
-0.0088902889,
-0.0561397262,
-0.0086645009,
-0.0271509197,
0.0300486926,
-6.122275432e-33,
-0.0278811846,
0.0537197925,
0.0109402314,
-0.0362590514,
-0.0552487709,
0.0242980737,
-0.0463315137,
-0.0440671742,
-0.0113554941,
0.0005732785,
-0.0098401913,
-0.0001149036,
0.0010340185,
0.0112193581,
-0.033541128,
0.0243164692,
0.0731987208,
-0.0238383841,
-0.0490337424,
0.0243517626,
0.011248189,
0.0460453294,
0.0624103062,
0.0008001282,
-0.0759403929,
0.0204455536,
-0.0142504266,
0.029836243,
0.0145901721,
0.0447331071,
-0.0266170427,
0.0298162382,
0.0090351142,
-0.0415763967,
-0.0241611563,
-0.0077125519,
-0.0507929623,
-0.0225613862,
0.0003696236,
0.0218830314,
-0.0152294086,
-0.0107020196,
0.0436576344,
0.0208546892,
-0.0214029998,
0.0125454729,
0.0048875776,
-0.0343807265,
-0.0328769423,
-0.0179466866,
-0.0161707271,
0.0214491487,
-0.0041311458,
-0.0583856329,
0.0673321038,
0.0310468152,
-0.0181184374,
-0.0031747604,
-0.0539604723,
0.0187396724,
0.0504714586,
0.0838084221,
0.0444932505,
0.0089688199,
0.0409613252,
0.0429714061,
-0.0037213024,
-0.0088622924,
-0.0008426246,
0.0576591901,
0.0820827112,
0.0210261978,
0.0286574252,
0.015441387,
0.0430997238,
-0.0547115579,
-0.0826608017,
0.0049171676,
-0.0049234973,
0.0423453636,
-0.0067080813,
0.060045708,
-0.0097677996,
-0.0537829436,
-0.03510819,
-0.0201637968,
-0.0122366855,
-0.0362669528,
0.0290028062,
0.0378949679,
-0.0498400629,
-0.0027205059,
0.0293155406,
-0.0439154059,
0.0294250045,
0.0336777605,
-0.0188113526,
0.0187044851,
0.0136591783,
0.0449871384,
-0.0606107749,
-0.006819197,
0.0310279597,
-0.050435517,
0.0169306789,
-0.0288171601,
0.020897435,
0.0710194781,
-0.0442053676,
-0.0041857306,
-0.0139464838,
-0.0046574664,
0.0190947689,
0.0462457873,
0.0299663972,
0.0399252698,
0.0170284472,
0.0085445149,
0.0308548901,
-0.0490361415,
-0.0421486497,
0.0039678696,
0.0553657897,
0.0322703049,
-0.0199292134,
-0.016035296,
-0.0251761265,
-0.0044840332,
0.0618611164,
-0.030256262,
-0.0269689504,
0.0201718844,
2.642e-7,
0.036752142,
-0.0034990727,
0.0097430637,
-0.0482727177,
0.0242432505,
0.0119297029,
-0.0211384259,
-0.0166965313,
-0.0127844159,
0.0018932953,
0.0498224311,
0.0353229083,
0.0687854812,
-0.009292447,
-0.0885422155,
0.0064489692,
-0.0467916317,
-0.0401274152,
-0.0181588493,
-0.0352080725,
-0.0419905148,
0.0963751897,
0.0312462561,
-0.0310809091,
-0.0369240865,
-0.011218477,
0.0256825835,
-0.0061906283,
0.0118285595,
0.0048707831,
-0.0042698635,
0.009147427,
-0.0175773427,
0.0291205831,
-0.0229321979,
0.0256189536,
0.0261982251,
0.0889321566,
-0.0414594635,
0.0192547757,
0.0350983329,
0.032981161,
-0.0659454241,
-0.0327110104,
0.0748711675,
0.0236246418,
0.0128713893,
-0.0160662048,
-0.0046895202,
0.0014219672,
-0.018478537,
-0.0036470525,
-0.0067829601,
0.044666145,
0.0508000813,
0.0191639774,
-0.021921698,
-0.0726433024,
-0.0109815793,
-0.0046311445,
-0.0432084575,
-0.0264956262,
-0.0247001797,
-0.019179171,
0.0190614201,
-0.0312161278,
0.0185251664,
2.447567501e-34,
0.0074070296,
-0.010242667,
-0.0029991921,
0.0281172823,
0.0271735825,
-0.0538095832,
0.0077261222,
0.0299531054,
-0.0559664518,
-0.0584912673,
-0.016920289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03429v1 | RCMHA: Relative Convolutional Multi-Head Attention for Natural Language Modelling | 2023-08-07T09:24:24 | 2023-08-07T09:24:24 | Herman Sugiharto, Aradea, Husni Mubarok | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The Attention module finds common usage in language modeling, presenting
distinct challenges within the broader scope of Natural Language Processing.
Multi-Head Attention (MHA) employs an absolute positional encoding, which
imposes limitations on token length and entails substantial memory consumption
during the processing of embedded inputs. The current remedy proposed by
researchers involves the utilization of relative positional encoding, similar
to the approach adopted in Transformer-XL or Relative Multi-Head Attention
(RMHA), albeit the employed architecture consumes considerable memory
resources. To address these challenges, this study endeavors to refine MHA,
leveraging relative positional encoding in conjunction with the Depth-Wise
Convolutional Layer architecture, which promises heightened accuracy coupled
with minimized memory usage. The proposed RCMHA framework entails the
modification of two integral components: firstly, the application of the
Depth-Wise Convolutional Layer to the input embedding, encompassing Query, Key,
and Value parameters; secondly, the incorporation of Relative Positional
Encoding into the attention scoring phase, harmoniously integrated with Scaled
Dot-Product Attention. Empirical experiments underscore the advantages of
RCMHA, wherein it exhibits superior accuracy, boasting a score of 0.572 in
comparison to alternative attention modules such as MHA, Multi-DConv-Head
Attention (MDHA), and RMHA. Concerning memory utilization, RMHA emerges as the
most frugal, demonstrating an average consumption of 2.98 GB, surpassing RMHA
which necessitates 3.5 GB. | [
0.0559753217,
-0.0023061431,
-0.0157948788,
0.0341587774,
-0.0090364004,
-0.0148117216,
-0.0197178647,
-0.0375383645,
-0.0006573555,
-0.0494765379,
-0.0206455477,
-0.0515888408,
-0.016000405,
0.0261205714,
0.0340371989,
-0.0503004082,
0.0707943141,
0.0072931945,
0.0071311272,
0.0325419568,
0.0197029803,
-0.0176691003,
0.0559641197,
0.0488398634,
-0.0253925901,
-0.0177765321,
-0.030474497,
-0.0042007831,
0.0302478168,
-0.0129193505,
-0.0038469399,
0.0591583885,
0.0286026467,
0.0278244782,
0.0000022077,
-0.0118572023,
-0.0005737469,
0.0017544418,
-0.0040151551,
0.0291071888,
0.0195549317,
-0.0033495149,
0.0022923399,
0.0093584219,
0.0134444283,
-0.0050000539,
0.0509527959,
0.0605632588,
0.0476980917,
0.0680042505,
-0.0144557999,
-0.0484844185,
0.0158320833,
-0.0437920652,
0.0275471471,
-0.0330668725,
0.0145229194,
-0.0049625435,
-0.0044546579,
0.0452060662,
-0.0508442521,
0.0578954741,
0.047267884,
-0.0041166381,
0.0309066344,
0.0534911528,
-0.0421196856,
-0.0233387575,
-0.0031030984,
0.0969199389,
-0.0665400997,
-0.0192709304,
-0.0196285788,
0.003175451,
-0.0137944706,
-0.0592417717,
-0.0454675034,
0.0328991786,
-0.0031259684,
0.0051750438,
0.009150858,
0.0266291425,
0.0268291179,
0.0174510013,
-0.0251695812,
0.0238541923,
-0.0000270101,
-0.0413026847,
-0.0081600053,
-0.0164944399,
-0.0380386449,
-0.0299467146,
0.0245380923,
0.0348703861,
-0.0155801307,
0.0256843027,
-0.0576874875,
-0.0447700955,
0.0397418775,
-0.1392251402,
0.0300962664,
0.0567784123,
-0.0411325321,
0.0473174006,
0.0051641935,
0.0714750811,
-0.0331504568,
0.0069966423,
-0.0242904034,
-0.0068650837,
0.0008623205,
-0.0088174054,
-0.0556981526,
0.0325542614,
-0.0509880781,
-0.0629233867,
0.0033681714,
0.0261913259,
0.0045055235,
-0.0291231833,
0.0288515892,
0.0589323379,
-0.0544423498,
0.006861418,
0.026991833,
0.048743315,
-0.049047444,
-0.019609211,
-0.0033693728,
-0.037486136,
-0.0449149385,
0.0489936173,
0.0054058707,
-0.0353183597,
-0.0145711098,
0.0445129201,
-0.0091702761,
-0.0515899658,
0.0200143661,
0.0124080908,
-0.0198094416,
-0.0564145334,
0.0065661361,
-0.0278178453,
0.0392376706,
-0.0226586089,
-0.0098668505,
0.0119226286,
0.0182449892,
0.0538696572,
-0.0325419083,
0.0433971919,
0.0663160458,
-0.0035400407,
0.0248054489,
0.0220997054,
0.0257413425,
0.0687382072,
0.05191857,
0.0478487313,
-0.0084352242,
-0.0390854366,
-0.0384234898,
-0.0218350105,
0.029375568,
-0.0178951491,
-0.046511855,
0.0435892604,
-0.0223858077,
0.038605582,
0.0645689368,
0.0513661206,
-0.0043668025,
-0.0371883698,
0.0548495539,
0.0208962932,
0.000745663,
0.03980821,
0.0456649847,
0.0289826561,
-0.0183056295,
-0.0182970334,
-0.0901809782,
0.0905501619,
0.0008015275,
0.003394349,
0.0346518457,
-0.0001225328,
-0.0173572116,
-0.0178621076,
-0.0106919259,
0.0160250813,
-0.0183915049,
-0.0038951288,
0.0135868415,
-0.038130261,
-0.0597523637,
0.0748593956,
0.0068213372,
-0.0360632464,
0.0013199458,
-0.0230136868,
-0.0034018578,
0.0470932163,
0.0062278584,
-0.0320707485,
-0.0326461308,
-0.0092806118,
0.0306038093,
0.0499235541,
0.0446672589,
0.0344311781,
0.0116333654,
-0.0485815071,
0.0295455996,
-0.0202415101,
-0.0084091276,
0.0384149253,
0.0210439134,
0.0121948291,
0.0127469059,
0.0028417304,
0.0111374464,
0.027601514,
0.0412590764,
-0.0082244752,
-0.021662062,
0.0080695515,
0.0355296955,
0.0081537329,
0.0052153459,
0.0423185341,
0.0516995043,
-0.0261681769,
0.0068897721,
-0.0172856729,
-0.0341540165,
-0.0143408962,
0.0205111708,
-0.0207233541,
0.0037436895,
0.0347229838,
-0.0313850157,
-0.0371098891,
0.0361656919,
-0.0732947141,
0.0506659634,
-0.0380068347,
0.0060052914,
-0.0038226254,
0.0569234304,
-0.0388327725,
0.089676246,
-0.0308436044,
0.0138689121,
0.0276295971,
-0.0285978876,
-0.0041322536,
-0.0443997495,
-0.0107034305,
-0.0013578291,
-0.0191167649,
0.0298745446,
-0.0144714331,
-0.0220945161,
-0.030322209,
-0.0218512248,
-0.0553279519,
0.0087998789,
-0.0269775204,
0.008064623,
0.0196699891,
0.0226094089,
0.0178423636,
-0.017302461,
-0.0222966094,
-0.0246509053,
-0.0099674622,
0.0068485439,
0.0066897478,
-0.0087119499,
0.0212171283,
-0.0566918999,
-0.0203491133,
0.001591131,
0.0437043384,
-0.0138182864,
-0.0494216569,
-0.0173702016,
-0.0212708469,
0.001461966,
0.003002655,
-0.0001714294,
-0.0646113083,
-0.0315711051,
0.0218492262,
0.0399169289,
0.0784751326,
0.0132021923,
0.028654987,
0.0531216785,
-0.0131822508,
-0.0362556204,
0.0594140962,
-0.0118310563,
0.0304664504,
-0.0060754879,
-0.0121709006,
-0.0028426209,
0.0736658275,
0.0020606888,
0.0181578193,
-0.0619758107,
-0.0020258124,
0.0152507713,
-0.054930523,
-0.0178880319,
0.0148079656,
-0.0515536889,
0.002929606,
-0.0662421808,
-0.0361547247,
0.06668026,
-0.0315080769,
-0.0318411924,
-0.0491204374,
0.0221632328,
-0.0422356464,
0.0278637465,
-0.0060960688,
0.0275645647,
-0.0371312648,
-0.0437379777,
-0.0343463197,
0.0307121295,
-0.0226249211,
-0.0242472608,
0.0657458231,
0.0263789184,
-0.0056961714,
-0.0343379527,
0.0091380635,
-0.0352637991,
-0.0336606167,
0.0038597856,
0.0321395658,
0.0078711817,
-0.00238539,
-0.061361175,
0.0554854497,
0.0438648053,
0.0150615275,
-0.0016676447,
0.0266831126,
-0.0065448573,
0.027278956,
0.0403902084,
0.064334996,
-0.0043834005,
0.0257124044,
0.0182469133,
0.0644183308,
0.0153006539,
0.013481495,
-0.0180004872,
-0.0107842237,
0.0127651822,
-0.0203262009,
-0.0289225448,
0.0070702164,
0.0307460148,
-0.0981079862,
-0.0208747908,
0.0701274723,
0.025574781,
-0.0481795855,
0.0205815956,
0.0014234023,
0.0190161485,
0.0299324039,
0.0537421405,
-0.002616782,
-0.0281056911,
0.0181809124,
-0.0022226071,
0.015961051,
-0.0016836539,
-0.0201124623,
-0.0856833085,
0.0333390795,
-0.0252327956,
-0.0753429085,
-0.0460931435,
-0.0282571204,
0.0108647039,
0.033432208,
0.006668828,
0.012107756,
-0.0041875434,
-0.0237952173,
0.0150678921,
-0.0163570885,
-0.0092755742,
0.0274060089,
-0.0308184754,
0.0129871732,
0.051123593,
0.037335027,
0.010455193,
-0.0422934555,
-0.0227512307,
-0.0354273766,
0.0017968318,
-0.0022278044,
0.0350217074,
-0.0469929948,
-0.0173424203,
-0.0361415781,
-0.0122317448,
-0.0396337174,
-0.0101619624,
-0.0452257581,
0.1205907166,
-0.0195527375,
0.0141093088,
-0.0801826194,
0.0174906906,
-0.0120893121,
0.0613242015,
0.0653882027,
-0.0348509066,
-0.0558645464,
0.0035828108,
0.0115095247,
-0.0431724004,
-0.0034193557,
0.0280959271,
0.0056507359,
-0.0627247021,
-0.0375758074,
-0.0492033474,
0.0111119002,
0.029149577,
0.0036107453,
-0.0172886606,
0.0015862365,
-0.0060024844,
-0.0661575869,
0.024497658,
-0.0032311496,
0.0316687301,
-0.0317990631,
0.0203260761,
0.026538562,
-0.0160653852,
-0.0171333961,
0.0251825582,
-0.0635213628,
-0.0269106999,
0.0038606257,
0.0506583601,
0.0123138111,
0.010277695,
-0.0428923331,
-0.0597615838,
-0.0205625184,
-0.0158892907,
-0.0401107334,
0.0307944156,
0.0183105841,
-0.0185731407,
0.0097894957,
0.0442515053,
-0.0376068987,
0.0165110435,
0.0023830528,
0.0534971952,
-0.0077536553,
-0.0466020219,
0.0008267632,
-0.0354082659,
0.0620143525,
0.0353277661,
0.0446159244,
-0.0070200223,
0.0343260653,
-0.0025547883,
-0.0040764329,
-0.0421678685,
-0.0247187056,
0.0165079869,
0.0006261664,
-0.0159997903,
0.0200360436,
0.0160811096,
-0.0129876453,
0.0105612399,
0.0617734753,
-0.0020810009,
-0.0244596023,
-0.0104299979,
0.049616307,
-0.0468242131,
-0.03469285,
-0.0084788939,
0.0308227129,
-0.0281172749,
0.0348678268,
0.0046020201,
-0.0294530354,
-0.0453444384,
0.0256434307,
-0.0557041019,
0.0014247674,
-0.0187596343,
-0.0016706603,
0.0316233151,
-0.0419080146,
0.0322898589,
0.0292645004,
-0.0009728406,
-0.0145579549,
0.0251757167,
-0.0076321969,
-0.0595793687,
0.0440272763,
0.0270291101,
-0.0199830364,
-0.0154278418,
0.0465396233,
-0.0016636427,
-0.0030047656,
-0.013806086,
-0.0252729859,
-0.0258719791,
-0.018753117,
0.0244005248,
0.0328953415,
-0.0243203305,
0.0277588237,
-0.062548697,
-0.0621264726,
0.0138765937,
-0.0503321588,
-0.0211119857,
-0.0331201442,
0.0149221057,
0.0149385035,
0.0260150302,
-0.0371235013,
-0.0308203753,
0.0100915581,
-0.0257391017,
-0.0187580343,
-0.0025703649,
-6.635814751e-33,
-0.0251138769,
-0.0225069802,
-0.0091773029,
-0.0530991293,
-0.07207001,
0.0364806876,
-0.050275106,
-0.0156702586,
-0.0334739424,
-0.0156191876,
-0.0260005202,
0.0187146198,
0.0122529771,
0.0138216903,
0.0186339505,
-0.0232463442,
0.0163261369,
0.0051675718,
-0.0018941947,
0.0359500535,
0.0318414383,
0.0419427976,
0.0767307058,
0.0212695133,
-0.006184279,
0.0142252352,
0.0052451314,
0.0150356507,
-0.0314142779,
0.0566052571,
-0.0409840718,
0.040316686,
0.0298542511,
-0.041053582,
-0.0146175763,
0.0617123693,
-0.0754080564,
-0.0330215953,
0.0196178015,
0.006637509,
-0.0047175926,
-0.0154817719,
0.0629442111,
0.0294264443,
0.0710981488,
-0.0443873666,
0.0244573578,
-0.0034893327,
-0.0944017321,
-0.0048913029,
-0.0753813088,
0.0256214738,
0.001364202,
0.0174967311,
0.0146857165,
0.0523371436,
0.0030799177,
0.0432065092,
-0.0646172464,
-0.0218370128,
-0.0298593491,
0.0410284288,
0.0504999682,
0.0291069392,
-0.0014093887,
0.0369133316,
0.0533175804,
-0.0234642476,
-0.059867382,
0.0058104503,
0.0315760374,
0.0198195241,
0.0352251045,
0.0037994878,
0.0418008417,
0.0118136592,
-0.0536830463,
-0.046745494,
-0.0235937182,
0.1078550965,
0.0407214947,
0.0249197055,
-0.0556797162,
-0.0050426843,
-0.0014955736,
0.0081998613,
-0.0545373261,
-0.0535041168,
0.0426347293,
0.0155800236,
-0.0452617817,
0.0255337246,
0.0489616506,
-0.0253797807,
0.0625196025,
0.0084239887,
0.02344325,
0.0491193421,
0.0186607596,
0.0319027938,
-0.0390237235,
-0.0024385815,
0.0047864243,
-0.0241135806,
-0.0089744227,
-0.0048186709,
0.0190411173,
0.0334160402,
-0.0539040193,
-0.0279781502,
-0.0303188022,
-0.0158673748,
-0.0228350312,
0.0827545151,
0.0203616917,
-0.0115596876,
-0.0085546486,
0.0433688276,
0.0134856878,
0.0126137007,
-0.0175443999,
-0.0032007648,
0.0185977351,
0.032000415,
-0.0321269706,
0.0037338831,
-0.0570968948,
0.0309879016,
0.0354926549,
-0.0759377927,
-0.0195639171,
0.0550923161,
3.011e-7,
0.0573013797,
0.0415219478,
0.0188429933,
-0.0113613559,
-0.0035828983,
0.0046111266,
0.0217643268,
0.0681653991,
-0.0094189262,
0.0081755659,
0.0040520546,
0.0015792249,
0.0089757461,
0.0021106959,
-0.1049594954,
-0.0329847708,
-0.0685680583,
0.0150221223,
-0.0275282133,
-0.0023679086,
0.0335745215,
0.1447981745,
-0.0006659871,
0.0231126398,
0.009860348,
0.0074539813,
0.0379118361,
-0.0013099847,
-0.002955779,
0.0004688259,
0.015687922,
0.0045086821,
-0.0408195294,
-0.0088596372,
-0.0161129944,
0.010491496,
0.0421655215,
0.102508761,
-0.0481934063,
-0.0639096946,
-0.0069029168,
-0.0089091407,
-0.0113941906,
-0.0921046585,
0.0517971478,
-0.0519947521,
-0.0380604044,
-0.0247171707,
0.0024644784,
0.0297171157,
-0.0062427488,
-0.0060178037,
0.020968942,
0.0044205347,
-0.0010015961,
-0.0502180681,
-0.0248567984,
-0.1104539037,
-0.0452091619,
-0.0385591611,
-0.0457732193,
0.0065198503,
-0.0836904421,
-0.0376528911,
0.0857264474,
-0.0035573505,
-0.0353157371,
2.700828218e-34,
0.0474747904,
-0.0323682725,
0.0094487201,
0.0067836014,
-0.0131439324,
-0.0161147881,
0.0149416076,
-0.0038450104,
0.0114411665,
-0.0886222869,
-0.0500688218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03423v1 | Boosting Chinese ASR Error Correction with Dynamic Error Scaling Mechanism | 2023-08-07T09:19:59 | 2023-08-07T09:19:59 | Jiaxin Fan, Yong Zhang, Hanzhang Li, Jianzong Wang, Zhitao Li, Sheng Ouyang, Ning Cheng, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chinese Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) error correction presents
significant challenges due to the Chinese language's unique features, including
a large character set and borderless, morpheme-based structure. Current
mainstream models often struggle with effectively utilizing word-level features
and phonetic information. This paper introduces a novel approach that
incorporates a dynamic error scaling mechanism to detect and correct
phonetically erroneous text generated by ASR output. This mechanism operates by
dynamically fusing word-level features and phonetic information, thereby
enriching the model with additional semantic data. Furthermore, our method
implements unique error reduction and amplification strategies to address the
issues of matching wrong words caused by incorrect characters. Experimental
results indicate substantial improvements in ASR error correction,
demonstrating the effectiveness of our proposed method and yielding promising
results on established datasets. | [
-0.0005376185,
0.039045047,
0.0237029511,
-0.0068879146,
0.0183053091,
0.0086272499,
0.0053618094,
0.0164125394,
-0.0282034352,
-0.0137159927,
-0.0268726721,
-0.0551145785,
0.1068452373,
0.0104200505,
0.0080393087,
-0.0404747725,
0.0359294675,
-0.0310753919,
-0.0109766489,
-0.0146754002,
0.0338060521,
0.0187729783,
-0.0034879032,
0.0410366617,
-0.0141815757,
0.0279589761,
0.0015512842,
0.0734913796,
0.0333318934,
-0.0255164914,
-0.0107609201,
-0.0032031527,
-0.024367556,
0.0446232744,
0.0000017127,
-0.0390598439,
-0.0454836711,
0.0024433606,
-0.0186131094,
0.0148850204,
0.0485559367,
-0.0194126572,
-0.0794822946,
0.0900574178,
0.0431192294,
-0.0576287806,
0.0995590016,
0.054685168,
-0.0181536246,
0.0385257751,
-0.002675537,
-0.0314590335,
0.0071349726,
-0.0036765249,
-0.051829543,
-0.0094038183,
0.0433211178,
0.0093548344,
-0.0699824095,
-0.0442755334,
-0.0545540452,
0.0068667182,
-0.0436225273,
-0.0123420516,
-0.0207088888,
-0.0151128247,
0.0059612826,
-0.0158579331,
-0.0318095535,
0.0301534384,
-0.048123844,
-0.0371647999,
-0.0077236746,
-0.0254365038,
-0.04790847,
-0.0035145343,
0.0174548961,
0.0072092745,
-0.043547675,
0.0162791554,
0.0028846774,
-0.0072230427,
0.0437708311,
0.0111031141,
-0.0419374146,
-0.002556904,
0.0174186788,
-0.0563985184,
-0.0469606332,
-0.0475570522,
0.032692004,
0.0047578015,
0.0568203814,
0.0121963443,
-0.0045535802,
0.015945226,
0.0024887864,
-0.0285016559,
0.0112404991,
-0.0438190252,
0.0068759397,
0.0364684314,
-0.0385915786,
-0.0249629207,
-0.0117905457,
0.0701168105,
0.0280246362,
0.0025018353,
-0.0244211257,
-0.0282103531,
0.0038507404,
-0.0062039546,
-0.0543458462,
0.0321520567,
0.0066125547,
-0.0037629167,
-0.0595945045,
-0.0025874684,
-0.0119605204,
0.0247771107,
0.0208780672,
-0.0246185511,
-0.0640939251,
-0.0310274661,
0.0204760805,
0.0353095718,
0.0247581843,
0.033565402,
-0.0267691463,
-0.018782068,
0.0043397713,
0.0125517203,
0.0506385528,
0.0320374593,
0.0188482907,
0.0801935196,
0.017892465,
-0.0376591608,
-0.0393167026,
0.0198323503,
-0.0430505089,
0.0230478402,
-0.0487180799,
-0.0291655175,
-0.0179771185,
-0.0465303585,
0.0266595855,
0.0128282392,
0.0291544013,
-0.0124882786,
-0.0063073821,
0.061501205,
-0.0301068686,
0.0269319676,
0.0108040553,
-0.0111463303,
0.0280252136,
0.0381018482,
0.0593040697,
-0.0482752658,
0.0375561416,
0.0221546162,
-0.0188102629,
0.0190112796,
-0.0225001425,
-0.0083472673,
-0.0425535887,
-0.0616733246,
0.0009557474,
0.0094733695,
0.0338821113,
0.0649186671,
-0.02817614,
0.043917045,
0.0189151838,
0.0375044942,
0.0305427443,
0.0275430121,
-0.0302971527,
-0.0141886659,
-0.018628912,
0.0051598498,
-0.0071594021,
-0.0436875373,
-0.0407619178,
0.049394995,
0.0561456941,
0.0647966489,
-0.0327785015,
-0.0570907593,
-0.0532583259,
-0.0116240801,
0.0057013915,
-0.0013669382,
0.0502366163,
0.0249753967,
-0.0076876623,
0.0185424276,
0.0097617768,
-0.0521847121,
0.0317167342,
-0.0378557295,
-0.0161786657,
0.082953535,
0.093184039,
-0.0399209969,
-0.0107201263,
0.016063178,
-0.0541677065,
0.0639370233,
-0.0032830641,
-0.0004359906,
0.0025456664,
-0.0881997421,
0.009862029,
0.108380273,
0.0037453095,
0.0176838264,
-0.0003777917,
0.0317511261,
0.0149519881,
-0.0022103079,
-0.0513428152,
-0.0067813857,
-0.0080393841,
-0.0132467346,
0.0241481178,
0.008512455,
0.0318728201,
0.0395628214,
-0.0574000813,
0.0008985942,
-0.0085371835,
0.0002249628,
-0.0474739969,
0.0364701971,
-0.0404118784,
-0.0359690301,
0.0773938596,
-0.0091754775,
0.0139671303,
-0.014323053,
-0.0152310282,
-0.0886156633,
-0.005444414,
0.0017025177,
0.0201340802,
-0.1013543606,
0.0913331285,
-0.0116851563,
0.0410814062,
-0.0014499829,
0.0022963141,
0.010214611,
0.0225537252,
0.0036144115,
0.0225211345,
-0.0335322618,
-0.0526806861,
-0.0255430844,
0.0395307727,
-0.0000983097,
0.0468946695,
0.0163161494,
-0.0183113348,
0.027954543,
-0.0122815464,
-0.024591865,
-0.0250484161,
-0.0249096509,
0.0097889705,
0.0226665437,
0.0467247404,
0.0104839224,
-0.0342229456,
-0.0075858058,
-0.0177606381,
0.0097947977,
-0.0546378754,
0.0105849504,
-0.0406686403,
-0.0414688885,
-0.0172194988,
0.0216589551,
-0.0112014087,
-0.0373824611,
0.0053474531,
-0.0486531854,
-0.1005212814,
0.0102166319,
-0.0026354345,
0.0378326923,
0.0220330134,
-0.0463477224,
-0.0366340242,
-0.0018881353,
0.0173325818,
-0.0126489196,
0.0033527238,
-0.0170842651,
0.014863275,
-0.0295870285,
-0.0164638665,
-0.0135966372,
0.0140133305,
0.016235264,
0.0238838363,
-0.0212331861,
-0.0733071342,
0.0436353981,
0.0387580693,
0.0233559534,
-0.039941024,
-0.0672668293,
-0.0120518943,
0.0133308396,
0.0059648207,
-0.0526245236,
-0.03922683,
-0.0062214662,
-0.0424144976,
-0.0219130497,
0.0561617725,
-0.0732491761,
-0.0157119222,
-0.0446181335,
0.0111594368,
-0.0305889659,
-0.0186200086,
-0.0266671367,
0.0256222486,
0.0068897312,
-0.0807086602,
-0.0018031399,
0.0005676679,
0.024832109,
-0.0674764737,
0.0567658171,
-0.035135556,
0.0137141384,
-0.0026215226,
0.0036595191,
-0.0051962878,
0.0178062022,
-0.0013823764,
0.0251916274,
-0.0175428912,
-0.0681483448,
0.0162556339,
0.035948839,
-0.0070303129,
0.05806344,
0.0222160649,
0.020735221,
-0.023573814,
-0.0001125951,
-0.0214615297,
0.0424288027,
0.0081503447,
-0.0159821436,
0.0601674542,
0.013073815,
0.0642874166,
0.0081814909,
0.0105845015,
-0.038203463,
0.0405447111,
-0.0114147998,
0.018370118,
-0.0073194834,
0.0276111849,
-0.0419250689,
-0.0136986207,
0.0960720852,
0.0173566826,
0.0097560734,
-0.0108804172,
-0.0075917626,
0.0233740322,
-0.0060906983,
-0.0373883657,
-0.0676246285,
-0.008140265,
0.0709645376,
0.0583634563,
0.0032798678,
0.0516705848,
0.0151257701,
-0.1218772307,
0.0321330689,
0.0781860948,
0.0043379646,
-0.0629875958,
-0.0209142026,
0.0282926299,
-0.0088435672,
0.0671832934,
0.0390621163,
-0.0227495916,
-0.0610808991,
0.039154876,
-0.0581606925,
-0.0982576758,
-0.0145728467,
-0.0268976875,
0.0697263554,
0.0766845718,
-0.0007698769,
-0.0104034748,
0.0196825098,
0.0327548161,
0.0000739824,
-0.0000988788,
0.0084637133,
0.0299161617,
0.0118932743,
-0.0068556084,
0.0100593902,
0.0127800051,
-0.0026623348,
-0.008201994,
-0.0153572811,
-0.0064985608,
-0.005967984,
0.0498043261,
0.0362051353,
0.000960947,
-0.0322606936,
0.0402382612,
0.005897773,
-0.0115989875,
-0.0300213341,
-0.0213335957,
0.0090964204,
-0.0198944937,
-0.0003140349,
0.0568627119,
-0.0355968177,
-0.0465172715,
-0.0830920786,
-0.0389673412,
-0.0411902629,
-0.0159484427,
0.0182553716,
-0.01421664,
-0.0079951445,
0.0506234318,
-0.018598685,
-0.0628113821,
0.0050089159,
0.0402010232,
-0.0636336729,
0.050567966,
-0.007841995,
-0.041043207,
0.0168293901,
-0.0057566315,
-0.0291022137,
-0.0510430038,
0.0515378602,
-0.0545993745,
0.0094217407,
0.0272642076,
-0.0688502863,
-0.0337084346,
0.0643312633,
0.0386532433,
0.0255479254,
0.0098275822,
0.0371746682,
-0.0247207545,
-0.0230087172,
0.0162619222,
-0.0559464395,
0.0210102741,
-0.0467657447,
0.0484218523,
-0.0231774915,
-0.0370857939,
0.0244805925,
0.0505155511,
0.0200241487,
-0.0374649391,
0.0206741672,
-0.0622849278,
0.0575553961,
0.0203455631,
0.0026903991,
-0.000579034,
0.035775464,
0.0240489766,
-0.0272591375,
-0.0086809518,
-0.0158969592,
-0.0371719077,
-0.0881687924,
0.0073251096,
0.0190585349,
-0.0071861343,
0.0582608506,
-0.0095743472,
0.0016546204,
-0.0083379829,
0.0450410843,
0.0452113599,
0.0146523863,
-0.0136702619,
0.0018789786,
-0.0123589197,
0.0176521447,
-0.0251077432,
-0.0040059797,
-0.0313869342,
-0.0129404161,
-0.0537915193,
0.0265746471,
0.0717676654,
0.0208995715,
0.0594856702,
-0.0297454428,
0.018820636,
-0.0500684008,
-0.0153683145,
-0.0065123569,
0.0081823934,
-0.0183452759,
0.0071494458,
-0.0099166241,
-0.0087401224,
0.0499335565,
-0.0121760974,
0.0467523299,
-0.0386502929,
-0.0061066314,
-0.0004710988,
-0.0268002059,
-0.0031495478,
-0.0256167576,
-0.0663725361,
-0.0383521169,
-0.0329136252,
-0.0819534734,
0.040464472,
0.0362897255,
0.0495810919,
-0.0100902645,
-0.0315799564,
-0.0185758509,
-0.016947601,
0.0426365919,
-0.0054806527,
-0.047019884,
0.0311817769,
0.0343707837,
0.037732631,
-5.527600922e-33,
-0.0283373892,
0.0114511186,
-0.0468240976,
-0.0203321427,
0.0016313358,
0.0193723254,
0.0143860467,
0.0049951919,
0.0199925713,
-0.0053709713,
-0.0057515977,
0.0348926,
0.0386593379,
-0.0012568617,
0.011554121,
0.015495603,
0.0742537528,
-0.0024468498,
0.0138238445,
-0.0268415846,
0.0750128701,
0.0406383276,
0.0210576467,
-0.0601294413,
-0.0021588907,
0.0446390696,
-0.050620988,
0.0181214307,
0.0256445501,
0.0553975813,
0.0419323593,
0.0682219639,
-0.0031662544,
0.0284279473,
-0.0509726517,
-0.0122049581,
-0.1455293149,
-0.002961495,
-0.0379994251,
0.0692617893,
0.0194508787,
0.0292354133,
0.0438284837,
-0.0090790847,
-0.0030840593,
-0.0193955991,
0.0148682753,
-0.0770626664,
-0.0053587356,
-0.0161586273,
0.0047689877,
0.0643643215,
0.0370572321,
0.0315093845,
0.0510936379,
-0.0148991616,
-0.0202382151,
-0.0062557203,
-0.056942407,
0.0127536235,
0.055882223,
0.0396860205,
-0.0031589696,
0.0621176511,
-0.0361449271,
-0.0058463961,
0.0569737665,
-0.0589952692,
0.0271608215,
-0.0330175646,
0.0351738445,
-0.0444039851,
0.0044106152,
0.0583484434,
0.0474081188,
-0.0560109802,
-0.0169321299,
-0.0035192156,
0.0298194755,
0.0120918881,
0.0068826317,
0.0174370352,
-0.0605709702,
-0.0102519123,
-0.0280005243,
0.0079547456,
-0.0469708294,
-0.0206218008,
0.0246762726,
0.0562526323,
-0.0390246436,
0.0303803515,
0.0057691252,
-0.0209509283,
-0.0022432299,
-0.00912946,
0.0162373763,
-0.016658267,
-0.0394492671,
0.017698111,
-0.0453401171,
-0.064779222,
0.0137433903,
0.0343766026,
-0.0293610189,
-0.014220723,
-0.0073638991,
0.0761601031,
-0.0763116851,
0.0390653126,
0.0213212296,
-0.0197590832,
0.0172911193,
0.0021137691,
0.0295895692,
-0.018085815,
0.0121798944,
-0.0042529134,
0.0257632826,
0.0516010486,
-0.0103659285,
0.0018439712,
-0.0293833707,
0.037115708,
-0.0257681683,
0.0179759283,
0.0234235134,
-0.0570856296,
0.0205284562,
-0.0168216601,
-0.0166416541,
0.0042419499,
2.515e-7,
-0.0009417335,
-0.0016045978,
0.0879906714,
0.0194248147,
-0.0082339849,
-0.0165421534,
-0.0310567543,
0.0177693535,
-0.0133647546,
0.0555141009,
0.0715449005,
-0.012521754,
0.0817669407,
0.0272136088,
-0.0266266447,
-0.0312806927,
-0.0319734029,
0.012204635,
0.0312199276,
-0.0070165806,
0.0002057876,
0.0704185516,
-0.0351357199,
-0.0225521848,
0.011798691,
-0.0411860235,
0.0312816761,
0.0482970402,
0.0303995889,
0.0212532897,
0.0024024241,
0.0136785936,
-0.0142371738,
0.0185312331,
-0.0290087759,
0.0459890515,
0.0181232914,
-0.0045641507,
-0.060190089,
-0.0200843159,
-0.0172017626,
0.0330701768,
-0.0204894394,
-0.0170959141,
0.0065550534,
0.0492124148,
0.0314342789,
-0.0162857231,
-0.016911624,
0.0290212519,
0.0025242565,
-0.0144972596,
-0.0316912383,
0.0457460247,
0.0264020916,
0.0424910448,
-0.0316482335,
-0.0665231049,
-0.0184267685,
0.011318245,
-0.018534679,
-0.0012205968,
0.0288682226,
-0.0047656079,
-0.0063912426,
-0.0421958305,
-0.0057301396,
2.08739741e-34,
0.0342071354,
-0.0481111482,
-0.0267428439,
0.0094421934,
0.0017299721,
-0.0209146161,
0.0083517684,
0.0148305511,
-0.0271382295,
-0.0279959477,
-0.0675487444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03422v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03422v1 | Prompt Guided Copy Mechanism for Conversational Question Answering | 2023-08-07T09:15:03 | 2023-08-07T09:15:03 | Yong Zhang, Zhitao Li, Jianzong Wang, Yiming Gao, Ning Cheng, Fengying Yu, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Conversational Question Answering (CQA) is a challenging task that aims to
generate natural answers for conversational flow questions. In this paper, we
propose a pluggable approach for extractive methods that introduces a novel
prompt-guided copy mechanism to improve the fluency and appropriateness of the
extracted answers. Our approach uses prompts to link questions to answers and
employs attention to guide the copy mechanism to verify the naturalness of
extracted answers, making necessary edits to ensure that the answers are fluent
and appropriate. The three prompts, including a question-rationale relationship
prompt, a question description prompt, and a conversation history prompt,
enhance the copy mechanism's performance. Our experiments demonstrate that this
approach effectively promotes the generation of natural answers and achieves
good results in the CoQA challenge. | [
0.0338494368,
0.05690521,
-0.0221352447,
0.0128895845,
-0.0585337915,
-0.0028526501,
0.0119261602,
-0.009084533,
-0.0293554869,
-0.0022866647,
-0.0336933173,
0.0177149083,
-0.0178736392,
0.0514832847,
0.0063868873,
-0.0621682219,
0.0136489505,
-0.0274102315,
0.004372037,
0.0190865509,
0.0076045119,
-0.0242654141,
0.0012538688,
0.0053959289,
0.0175872445,
-0.0297216102,
-0.0593246594,
-0.0125289187,
0.0036853114,
-0.0057361973,
0.0146542881,
0.068537876,
0.0009445341,
-0.0067855963,
0.0000019265,
-0.0564725883,
-0.0134724295,
-0.0026207899,
-0.052296605,
-0.0431875214,
-0.008784038,
0.0748072341,
0.0271763429,
0.0167581066,
-0.0442442,
0.030899683,
0.0199073125,
0.0430443212,
0.0908780694,
0.0445382111,
-0.0046449131,
-0.019146936,
-0.0163214225,
0.0130389407,
0.0417755209,
-0.0464267842,
-0.0057121902,
0.0570281222,
0.0603369549,
0.0212750882,
0.0015502496,
0.0348284952,
0.0334606841,
-0.0517655462,
0.0201372057,
0.0410262421,
-0.0286355112,
-0.0269529708,
-0.008668134,
0.1274994165,
0.0207980946,
-0.0039237156,
-0.0022071006,
0.0002644967,
0.0567730181,
0.0225560796,
-0.0677105933,
0.0035135713,
-0.026701754,
-0.0393452309,
-0.0403647125,
0.0354531631,
-0.0227066875,
-0.006521163,
0.0278517995,
-0.0163661726,
0.0171479378,
-0.0062182401,
-0.0018251009,
0.0150326686,
0.0172644202,
-0.0698151365,
0.0299581029,
0.0851997659,
-0.021370545,
-0.0095857307,
-0.0117466887,
0.010505259,
0.0001108392,
-0.0011596634,
-0.0012621292,
0.021570731,
-0.0330335349,
0.045211412,
-0.0192199536,
0.0497879386,
0.0020762158,
0.0277160723,
-0.0618954226,
0.0085311523,
-0.0429252759,
-0.0142044341,
-0.059968207,
0.069970049,
-0.0625707582,
0.0029209023,
0.0134700695,
0.0112791471,
0.0056558312,
0.0039521661,
-0.0226018522,
0.0445018224,
-0.0246544238,
0.0043604001,
-0.0155969122,
0.005468295,
-0.0705590099,
0.0124374898,
0.0480375811,
-0.0621086806,
-0.0427368321,
0.0260773953,
0.0438625179,
-0.0139133576,
-0.0083490657,
0.0323749259,
-0.0461224839,
-0.0368981734,
0.015990708,
-0.0270783268,
-0.0143999085,
-0.0317371711,
-0.0203771815,
-0.0419315659,
0.0837526992,
-0.0071709859,
-0.0704052523,
0.0026514127,
0.0184139758,
0.0197052583,
-0.0263327044,
0.0375806652,
-0.0155359674,
0.0177709498,
0.0312360376,
0.0182225369,
-0.0300484039,
0.0203574505,
0.0312578231,
0.0340061001,
0.0628354996,
-0.003668373,
0.0418713093,
-0.0090843104,
0.0190367792,
-0.0143198641,
0.0391635261,
0.0576081313,
0.0244206134,
0.0034898221,
0.0512830913,
0.0324797258,
-0.0217950232,
0.0146496212,
0.060134571,
0.0327842385,
0.0072419536,
0.0114038372,
0.0343230963,
0.0080976486,
0.0400814116,
0.0619531274,
-0.0483620912,
0.0441578552,
-0.0101195211,
0.0142415091,
0.0117004216,
0.0279352516,
-0.0228436571,
-0.0348164439,
0.0502289459,
0.0095898602,
-0.0240327064,
0.039052669,
-0.0210314542,
0.0293571074,
-0.0193289667,
0.0158604868,
-0.0185543187,
-0.0423661582,
0.0190992448,
-0.0246080272,
0.0549833886,
0.050727766,
0.0169954393,
-0.0059168674,
-0.0521015562,
-0.0221206117,
0.0270436741,
0.0158588961,
0.0409177803,
-0.0316553004,
0.0409229025,
-0.0161434375,
-0.0106550045,
-0.0223068316,
-0.0279735345,
-0.0073025636,
0.0411144234,
0.0396829508,
0.0131030697,
0.0106583126,
-0.0126016373,
0.0418887697,
-0.0027010278,
-0.0457779542,
0.0243142955,
-0.0073119127,
-0.0184576288,
0.0265165213,
0.0034440239,
0.0294086412,
0.0107066883,
-0.0336426049,
-0.0351638831,
0.0811806098,
-0.0899792686,
-0.0384815186,
-0.0020152309,
-0.0018264693,
-0.0423404723,
-0.0124242529,
-0.030859407,
-0.0391948558,
-0.0186091121,
-0.033059001,
0.00117533,
-0.063770391,
-0.005861491,
0.0385426506,
0.0067066518,
-0.0449341275,
0.0720817819,
0.0278873798,
-0.0188418869,
0.0585125498,
0.0294002518,
-0.0324964821,
-0.0434929766,
0.0533182882,
0.0125446115,
-0.0178613979,
-0.0125338724,
0.0294063073,
0.0227688309,
-0.0733257458,
-0.0278685279,
-0.0380253606,
0.0233885944,
-0.0327602178,
0.0292649195,
0.0436821282,
0.0288930535,
-0.0220191963,
-0.0270434525,
-0.0754153207,
-0.0038132225,
0.0145976655,
0.0128328614,
0.0541018918,
0.0266061258,
0.0251597203,
-0.0538932271,
0.0191540401,
0.0138705336,
0.0329531655,
0.0134839378,
-0.0167049859,
-0.0643239319,
0.0083680069,
-0.0311514754,
0.0089791026,
0.0277379788,
-0.0000661382,
-0.013712273,
-0.0147512956,
0.0208978932,
0.0641234741,
0.0324649662,
-0.0313614346,
0.0062202453,
-0.0242603775,
-0.0407333635,
0.0436907075,
-0.0235464964,
-0.0168521628,
0.0533819608,
-0.0207168944,
0.0476608686,
0.0174055528,
-0.004514649,
0.0285697412,
-0.0142953536,
0.0382857472,
0.0379439853,
0.0038268114,
-0.0563897826,
-0.0070578214,
-0.0339873768,
0.0148837883,
-0.0444496796,
-0.0101731308,
0.0580632463,
-0.0046113222,
-0.0429992564,
-0.0582465678,
0.0010233464,
-0.0373283476,
0.071666643,
-0.031531021,
0.0193132516,
0.0275649894,
-0.0611524507,
-0.0511897244,
-0.0332519449,
0.0455303341,
-0.0334949493,
0.0088693826,
-0.0639616325,
0.0059332186,
-0.0144976638,
-0.0608009957,
-0.084375374,
-0.0654401705,
0.0093459422,
0.0250630993,
-0.008677124,
-0.0000673222,
0.0157572385,
0.0190819278,
0.0393110476,
0.0476614498,
-0.0407915935,
-0.0067546358,
-0.0283640157,
0.1158276424,
0.0971170366,
0.087587662,
0.0185523126,
-0.0037946254,
0.0645934865,
0.0644171089,
-0.0090824487,
0.0199717935,
0.0101961233,
-0.0072465488,
0.0116887074,
-0.0643488541,
0.0209107809,
0.0041158986,
0.0831928328,
-0.0556052476,
-0.0612592883,
0.0764182732,
0.043790549,
-0.042672243,
-0.0084981397,
-0.0238213073,
0.0390638672,
0.0059194472,
0.0635628104,
-0.0796765909,
-0.0389741547,
-0.0040682373,
0.0169181451,
0.0099193603,
-0.0394085161,
0.0009599764,
-0.1211168468,
0.0226966199,
-0.0339183547,
-0.0876041278,
-0.0523992404,
-0.028148042,
0.0269141626,
0.0450430997,
0.0024145814,
0.0229906123,
-0.0196437035,
0.014524092,
0.0127770165,
-0.035679061,
-0.010624351,
0.0400189161,
-0.022926569,
0.0008348426,
0.0860740319,
0.0166268777,
0.0060079214,
-0.028049076,
0.027568128,
-0.0680835918,
0.008008739,
0.0244992543,
0.0357760452,
-0.0020165408,
0.0067054643,
-0.0248821639,
0.0671380684,
0.0118547296,
-0.0325561613,
0.0572440624,
0.0243862271,
-0.0224929247,
-0.0416951627,
0.0048662405,
0.0502174236,
0.0293153916,
0.0799659267,
0.0458682254,
-0.0180102065,
-0.0415833443,
0.0009137556,
0.0053772619,
-0.0663569421,
-0.0041898401,
-0.0025279641,
0.0264132749,
0.0333034471,
-0.1033002511,
-0.0570730455,
0.0357484855,
0.0336691774,
-0.0069283238,
-0.0256286506,
-0.0176535007,
0.0372903533,
-0.0165149234,
0.0208783001,
-0.0382894129,
-0.0035148775,
-0.0052897786,
-0.0094636222,
-0.01026583,
-0.0121294735,
-0.0194843616,
0.0247311778,
-0.0377360657,
-0.0222599618,
-0.0049517066,
0.0540553741,
0.0213761125,
0.0222150236,
-0.015703775,
0.0323698856,
-0.0290089399,
0.0019295651,
-0.0349073112,
-0.028897237,
0.0025718503,
0.0177228209,
-0.0051242183,
0.0257185344,
-0.0382460095,
-0.0322920568,
-0.0351495296,
0.0665440336,
-0.0340104848,
-0.0746413246,
0.0416874029,
-0.0157732964,
-0.007769668,
0.0430120416,
0.0243677069,
-0.0218455866,
0.0353279933,
0.0161745772,
-0.0162249822,
-0.0431155339,
0.0296345502,
-0.0445132181,
-0.0323764458,
0.0394067019,
-0.0213923678,
-0.0367345437,
0.0117966412,
-0.0441732965,
-0.025791375,
0.0208843667,
0.0101777073,
-0.0045781122,
-0.031937249,
-0.0365653522,
0.0136875138,
0.0330519453,
0.0948546901,
-0.0152031314,
0.0859627426,
0.0356501862,
-0.0371269137,
-0.0006888707,
0.038556885,
-0.0888346732,
-0.0332920924,
-0.0156663284,
0.0110665821,
0.0309376772,
-0.0158677939,
-0.0146328686,
0.0186487082,
-0.0063415039,
0.015305452,
0.0127944155,
0.025282681,
-0.0373930708,
0.0442376547,
0.017519718,
0.003307197,
-0.0103905397,
0.0244484115,
-0.0771541744,
0.004571327,
0.004314085,
-0.0019128756,
-0.0391334184,
-0.0331633091,
-0.0048249019,
0.0125591233,
-0.0126796123,
-0.0300774761,
-0.0552676804,
-0.0293001328,
0.0240851101,
-0.003137548,
-0.0083822105,
-0.0055563264,
0.0641578287,
0.0371154547,
0.019211553,
-0.0823836699,
-0.0386764482,
0.0778921098,
-0.0269339252,
-0.0132513866,
-0.0304151811,
-6.275936421e-33,
-0.0356483981,
-0.0334829316,
0.0152118569,
0.014827501,
-0.0382724814,
-0.0020791255,
-0.0877668187,
-0.007064268,
-0.0275268294,
-0.000138909,
-0.0200124048,
-0.0037002708,
0.0038134134,
-0.0013920047,
-0.0244246516,
-0.0498152189,
0.0328172222,
0.0134926271,
-0.0503995158,
0.0507108867,
0.032080669,
0.0146865724,
0.016273411,
-0.0160334092,
0.0340464972,
-0.0309257843,
0.0169323608,
0.0450195223,
0.0235998631,
0.0211801715,
0.0079435939,
0.005837264,
0.0159963034,
-0.0499479584,
0.0115683777,
0.065624699,
-0.0787526295,
-0.0641724765,
0.0140458709,
-0.0438057967,
-0.0756064057,
-0.0373452976,
-0.0091101294,
-0.0174158663,
0.0696773976,
-0.0011323094,
0.0169969406,
0.0063270396,
-0.0037075812,
-0.0136358477,
-0.0503046811,
-0.0061611896,
-0.0139401779,
-0.0350837,
-0.0285873748,
0.0808475092,
0.001766416,
-0.0358004794,
-0.0184992719,
-0.0015550489,
0.0147922365,
0.0319256186,
0.026551215,
0.0150645161,
-0.0112132635,
0.0484401807,
-0.0084707169,
-0.0289878156,
-0.0465126447,
0.0313777402,
-0.0292211417,
0.0496419631,
0.0468833148,
0.0238663815,
-0.0204153657,
0.0356835648,
-0.0157698486,
0.0633624345,
0.0274849851,
0.0423451476,
-0.0326000229,
-0.0372258238,
0.0015648878,
-0.00357284,
-0.0342566334,
0.0312221926,
-0.0210507866,
-0.0216909871,
0.0354186483,
0.0008810555,
-0.0288307909,
0.0030796216,
0.016315816,
0.0197933093,
0.0075493869,
0.0023060879,
-0.0301301554,
0.0122487051,
0.0069624707,
0.0109290956,
-0.048261553,
0.0219313037,
0.0188942682,
0.0035810892,
0.0254866686,
0.0219948329,
-0.0052623716,
0.0190549791,
-0.0466995463,
0.0121882614,
-0.0407110862,
0.0553233251,
-0.036116045,
-0.0194316115,
0.0098823635,
0.0250274651,
-0.0341087878,
0.0254309401,
0.0047289529,
0.0048914016,
-0.0575635992,
0.0172390621,
0.0363579765,
0.0241082925,
-0.0124036847,
0.0142541435,
-0.0258944258,
0.0818987861,
-0.0239392631,
-0.0262872241,
-0.0102659678,
0.0052192849,
2.584e-7,
0.0123865288,
-0.0192073938,
0.0547207333,
0.0206258185,
0.0018009417,
0.0043887617,
0.0215363316,
-0.0065028276,
0.0336306542,
-0.0490025468,
-0.0034793634,
0.0406775475,
0.0347918347,
0.0112082697,
-0.1046000496,
-0.0408506021,
-0.058230184,
-0.0283750296,
-0.0166296791,
-0.045777943,
0.0855236426,
0.0193032939,
-0.0420595706,
0.0086528519,
-0.0282111261,
-0.0213514175,
0.0054891095,
0.0191254951,
-0.0047589787,
0.0221520215,
0.0084215347,
-0.0556284934,
-0.0087904464,
0.0062651164,
-0.02250682,
-0.0060640033,
0.0201113448,
0.0554824807,
-0.0021860241,
-0.0689224973,
-0.0755603686,
-0.0188285708,
0.0512361042,
-0.0448606312,
0.0772982687,
-0.0439208299,
-0.002566606,
-0.0576726794,
-0.0575894155,
0.0016047127,
-0.0226099435,
0.0174897667,
-0.0303727016,
0.0440967344,
-0.0085650561,
0.0318325385,
-0.0149020869,
-0.0341448858,
-0.0057089305,
-0.01242973,
0.0040966137,
-0.0417213142,
-0.0435908325,
-0.0269045979,
-0.0263138488,
-0.0340168029,
0.0119574005,
1.997499413e-34,
-0.0032198308,
0.034219671,
0.0396839865,
0.0550815091,
0.0435613915,
-0.0228240117,
0.0199257676,
0.0067927092,
0.0462440178,
-0.0576524623,
-0.0065625496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03421v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03421v3 | RecycleGPT: An Autoregressive Language Model with Recyclable Module | 2023-08-07T09:14:33 | 2024-05-23T08:07:07 | Yufan Jiang, Qiaozhi He, Xiaomin Zhuang, Zhihua Wu, Kunpeng Wang, Wenlai Zhao, Guangwen Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing large language models have to run K times to generate a sequence of
K tokens. In this paper, we present RecycleGPT, a generative language model
with fast decoding speed by recycling pre-generated model states without
running the whole model in multiple steps. Our approach relies on the
observation that adjacent tokens in a sequence usually have strong correlations
and the next token in a sequence can be reasonably guessed or inferred based on
the preceding ones. Experiments and analysis demonstrate the effectiveness of
our approach in lowering inference latency, achieving up to 1.4x speedup while
preserving high performance. | [
-0.0034375826,
0.1175486818,
-0.0068207602,
0.0124076251,
-0.0281079914,
0.022965664,
-0.0044307001,
0.0184225999,
-0.0025084196,
0.0023188035,
0.0445777886,
-0.0006705615,
0.0115995053,
0.085749507,
-0.0001988241,
-0.010926391,
0.0381826982,
-0.0631336793,
0.0321719199,
-0.0293801278,
-0.0155837191,
0.0081760893,
-0.0139201488,
0.0551937632,
-0.015663702,
-0.0294922572,
-0.0362733305,
-0.0051451046,
-0.027595209,
-0.0155556407,
-0.0179345105,
0.0643814728,
0.0014225907,
0.0528237931,
0.0000019855,
0.0155786583,
-0.0228096973,
-0.0157037172,
-0.0486312881,
0.0315792188,
0.0388678014,
-0.0119470339,
-0.0247228257,
0.0351374149,
-0.0157762561,
-0.074917227,
0.0363319069,
0.0070994766,
0.0250786599,
0.0483015999,
-0.0032195356,
-0.0207277108,
0.0093058767,
-0.0541220978,
-0.0186846014,
-0.0500952825,
0.0078345425,
0.0195877943,
0.0012325388,
-0.0082089407,
-0.0436735041,
0.057863526,
0.0343110934,
0.0120581714,
-0.0272070505,
0.0326453596,
0.0052235005,
0.0052027768,
-0.0166889932,
0.0361190587,
-0.0607174076,
-0.0689000264,
0.0174869001,
-0.0000195268,
-0.0334469713,
-0.0152245536,
-0.0229435917,
0.0220790599,
-0.0222010147,
0.0352484807,
0.0497332662,
0.0003755927,
0.0450615995,
-0.019248575,
-0.0564432479,
0.0675591305,
0.0484244972,
0.0288544353,
-0.0753697902,
0.0122648608,
0.0230224263,
-0.0667896643,
0.0013859528,
0.0022041053,
-0.0117904861,
0.008620169,
-0.0470228009,
-0.0263095926,
-0.0189594217,
0.0255460516,
0.0100419847,
0.0411364324,
0.0153776482,
0.0284591727,
-0.0260875896,
0.0286136921,
-0.0252152048,
-0.0531884804,
-0.0365659893,
-0.017962642,
0.0037132292,
-0.0264377892,
-0.0517406277,
0.0282858405,
-0.0173323806,
-0.0338761918,
-0.01040872,
0.0160549823,
0.02824012,
-0.0447964035,
0.0232167281,
-0.0231812298,
-0.038531702,
-0.0268546827,
0.023155624,
0.0221662931,
-0.0252513755,
-0.0065245382,
-0.0106119886,
-0.0792585462,
-0.0231354348,
-0.0041281362,
0.0327496566,
-0.0021652433,
-0.0364525877,
0.0421962254,
0.0014843383,
-0.0343732834,
-0.0095786005,
-0.0369633548,
0.0100174071,
-0.0447631404,
-0.0097453808,
-0.0627530366,
0.0396467857,
0.029564552,
0.0042818272,
-0.0366791189,
-0.0097716348,
0.0065486026,
-0.0183852911,
0.035234645,
-0.0023530324,
0.0182388909,
-0.0205198526,
0.0061295223,
0.0548256487,
0.0679094419,
0.0321515948,
0.0542793572,
-0.0019108998,
0.001082785,
0.0214238223,
0.0528077148,
0.0246343166,
-0.012045484,
-0.0130754067,
-0.0409088358,
0.0075058211,
-0.004928302,
0.0635785311,
0.0301982071,
-0.0320137255,
-0.0045592817,
0.0220559947,
0.0484823547,
0.0322257802,
0.0238635466,
0.0526530109,
0.0218826849,
-0.0185894612,
-0.0136582172,
-0.0035726093,
0.0308557991,
0.0159031805,
0.0091796033,
0.0454405844,
0.0692604408,
-0.0205377489,
-0.0007551537,
0.0044745831,
-0.0403231345,
0.0455111861,
0.0119422525,
0.0641577989,
0.0066374228,
-0.0586092472,
0.0267363805,
0.0160652492,
-0.0622882172,
-0.0220825803,
-0.0675802007,
0.0496756919,
0.0713718534,
0.0622823983,
0.0532731712,
0.0119216982,
0.0078326929,
-0.0112936804,
0.0201196019,
-0.0175116025,
-0.0069895098,
0.0369612947,
-0.0439450815,
-0.0389680266,
0.0672121197,
0.0238726791,
0.0827965885,
0.02498216,
0.0236301236,
0.0384015106,
-0.0189475678,
0.0217350964,
-0.0113482121,
-0.0358621702,
-0.0121294251,
0.0139651988,
-0.0015003412,
0.0384841859,
-0.0131874746,
0.0077892272,
0.0363632925,
0.039836403,
-0.0558703542,
0.0015758054,
0.0485621542,
-0.0672942773,
-0.0562821589,
-0.0149674946,
-0.0096863238,
0.0121630216,
0.0224420391,
-0.0366112106,
-0.0696523339,
0.0636229441,
-0.0387497656,
0.083324708,
-0.0359916352,
0.0006507225,
0.038187284,
0.0227300506,
0.031571202,
0.0432539359,
-0.0316219181,
0.0006459883,
0.015742179,
0.0210480299,
0.0190680493,
-0.0196551234,
-0.0179586429,
0.0085494975,
-0.0357561074,
0.0000043306,
0.0301838405,
-0.0138373142,
0.0206532441,
-0.0275014192,
-0.0608078167,
-0.0221768096,
-0.0314287581,
0.0026607511,
-0.0151834777,
0.0314622112,
0.0037640296,
-0.0279286522,
-0.0235368647,
-0.004435943,
0.0230465867,
0.0272287074,
-0.0259411819,
-0.03234981,
-0.053918656,
-0.0025459079,
-0.0406304635,
0.0117461355,
0.0474068895,
-0.0304058548,
-0.0159005597,
-0.0581522025,
-0.0008047771,
0.0016198537,
0.0358760878,
-0.0141364923,
-0.0533453301,
0.0079487581,
-0.0268241949,
0.1002953276,
0.0287375897,
0.0074666883,
0.0140895378,
-0.0095507838,
-0.0370160863,
-0.0324391387,
-0.0145396246,
-0.0262966361,
-0.0002060839,
0.0028438722,
-0.0484781042,
-0.0270036459,
0.1091223359,
0.019173326,
-0.0192810632,
-0.0867863894,
-0.0073487679,
-0.0008223105,
-0.0328844972,
-0.0320230275,
0.0059423144,
-0.0027725911,
0.0345791876,
-0.0265676733,
-0.0532878898,
0.0313944779,
-0.0430917256,
0.0082037142,
0.0195410699,
0.0153023964,
-0.0178215541,
0.0754900575,
0.0421451516,
0.0037204362,
-0.0100440327,
-0.0563982204,
-0.0009160999,
0.0491702519,
0.0145320129,
-0.0552062429,
0.0225520302,
-0.0349444449,
0.0356582738,
0.0026912929,
-0.0377856605,
-0.0352406949,
0.0160443969,
-0.0228242427,
-0.0125066191,
0.0420543849,
-0.0215177424,
-0.0197718535,
0.0361627452,
-0.0068112421,
0.0553206503,
-0.0099977711,
0.0362841524,
-0.0072584935,
0.0304194465,
0.0437719524,
-0.0452939942,
-0.0273265038,
-0.0241535772,
-0.0176553652,
0.0630377159,
0.0375404842,
0.049914442,
-0.0517279766,
0.008051076,
0.0453744903,
0.0141742555,
-0.0185100213,
0.0339062847,
0.0115265409,
-0.0646882728,
-0.0367437638,
0.0887527317,
0.0007494439,
-0.02656921,
-0.0047254888,
0.0190493967,
0.0677251592,
-0.0051734946,
0.0010090846,
-0.0551684387,
-0.0347641595,
0.0319311321,
-0.0016749782,
0.0160711836,
-0.0162784029,
0.0006290838,
-0.0932180285,
0.0303790569,
0.0052570347,
-0.0436581299,
-0.0369256102,
-0.0282914396,
-0.047607787,
-0.0037213142,
-0.0076626842,
0.0696516037,
-0.0064909365,
0.0302977916,
0.0344623551,
-0.0667198598,
-0.0341333374,
0.0090865642,
-0.0002932517,
0.0611996278,
0.0830147192,
0.0091988305,
0.0351762697,
-0.0375327431,
-0.0070670564,
-0.0420270301,
-0.020049464,
-0.0117851291,
-0.0118038468,
-0.0122671127,
-0.0167134274,
0.0119054709,
0.0238258839,
-0.0427203439,
-0.0059642857,
-0.037485294,
0.0491657592,
0.0075289053,
-0.0190621875,
-0.027976824,
-0.038068112,
0.0105702383,
0.0764123201,
0.0410550646,
-0.0277157649,
-0.0503166765,
-0.038565401,
0.0259019863,
-0.0621979982,
-0.013280238,
-0.043613635,
0.0471138023,
-0.0456882119,
-0.0517960116,
0.0023611044,
0.0407574065,
0.0255972035,
-0.0294792242,
0.0714799985,
-0.0181577355,
-0.0282747503,
-0.072922647,
-0.0244343337,
-0.0327870958,
-0.003131906,
-0.0758771822,
-0.0050315075,
0.0169856325,
-0.0035347808,
-0.048574362,
0.0597363189,
-0.1249362454,
-0.0534385704,
0.033605691,
0.0459829122,
0.0268807244,
0.0354606584,
-0.0101894746,
-0.0196231417,
0.0108062048,
0.0232378505,
-0.021413181,
0.0080245724,
-0.0018116124,
0.0250262301,
0.0047862837,
0.0388270915,
-0.035100311,
0.0263526551,
-0.0244909991,
0.0494485013,
-0.0239055455,
-0.0288646799,
0.0010997357,
-0.0039828331,
0.0398576371,
-0.0154567342,
0.0193470586,
-0.0081324158,
0.0052537038,
-0.0310909227,
0.0258185267,
-0.0592758954,
0.0870999768,
0.0346526876,
-0.0165134873,
-0.0120861558,
-0.0281320233,
0.0177638531,
0.0361049548,
0.0146860136,
-0.0247309972,
-0.0327064879,
0.0062697981,
0.0765008926,
-0.0366818421,
-0.0056221094,
0.0032109641,
0.0091381753,
-0.005770999,
-0.0498091355,
0.0003661806,
0.025180079,
0.0133402292,
-0.0296318028,
0.0146403862,
-0.0252283905,
-0.0318155698,
-0.0145709598,
0.0393687189,
0.0394000337,
0.0196324568,
0.0582613945,
-0.0383696482,
0.0066926512,
-0.0344340764,
0.07391949,
0.0215064976,
-0.0353340767,
0.0417793542,
0.0269766953,
-0.0432890542,
-0.0173438974,
0.0825851038,
0.0487345196,
0.0091430135,
-0.0023454591,
0.0123290159,
-0.024107974,
-0.0263732057,
-0.0445628054,
-0.0208477713,
-0.030190764,
0.0394065641,
-0.0237838328,
-0.0673422366,
-0.010057196,
0.0201680604,
0.0188449621,
-0.0112600103,
0.0213763714,
0.0631666407,
0.0085896356,
-0.0223798901,
-0.0497615524,
0.0127462763,
0.0213537961,
-0.0619440377,
0.0134491948,
-6.810537293e-33,
-0.0134385359,
-0.0037223711,
0.0063363295,
-0.0477810912,
-0.0155609949,
-0.0019137337,
-0.0449003316,
-0.0026269821,
0.0255552176,
0.0076467358,
-0.0104188221,
0.0298815183,
0.0173106454,
0.0437168814,
0.0035452852,
0.0423757769,
0.0663353056,
-0.0106321098,
0.0003787445,
0.0538145117,
0.0466205701,
0.0520833619,
0.0092277015,
0.0024839931,
-0.0532956906,
-0.0570446216,
0.0238218028,
-0.0195859335,
0.0216568913,
0.0254103206,
-0.0356952846,
-0.0058838804,
0.0206784867,
-0.0372905731,
-0.0341079533,
0.0126660299,
-0.0894165114,
-0.0046342318,
0.0135647347,
-0.0052989805,
-0.0404280424,
-0.0194465667,
-0.0114828106,
-0.0104855243,
0.0030515688,
0.0208828244,
-0.0077595161,
-0.0209927149,
-0.0792765021,
-0.0136427386,
-0.0400134735,
0.0320732221,
0.0094320215,
0.0076188971,
0.0531205386,
0.014274966,
-0.0150124766,
0.0049728709,
-0.0296285227,
0.0094742747,
0.0174105801,
0.105628103,
0.0399370752,
0.0229492486,
0.0473937839,
0.0134584252,
0.0277815685,
-0.0359949842,
-0.0595545806,
0.0292199329,
0.0502549633,
-0.0063523129,
0.0103371469,
-0.0079464149,
0.0790383145,
-0.0476810224,
-0.039077241,
-0.0118473563,
0.037197113,
0.0531053767,
0.0432699881,
0.0126398653,
-0.0418636389,
-0.041869618,
-0.0433609709,
-0.0379216187,
-0.0230607558,
-0.03827025,
0.0298769288,
0.0535607003,
-0.0306948889,
-0.0478726737,
0.0763428062,
-0.0114474921,
-0.0526211858,
0.0431583337,
0.0020805574,
-0.016609503,
-0.0230753198,
0.0592768565,
-0.025464084,
-0.0188253094,
0.0059244344,
-0.0083726663,
0.007660619,
-0.0166612491,
-0.0251342226,
0.0269538052,
-0.0879272446,
-0.018015366,
-0.0633081719,
0.0348211899,
-0.0252693053,
-0.0006507346,
0.0631753802,
0.0011968298,
0.0269562006,
0.0368627794,
-0.0026966573,
0.0099466704,
-0.0088297017,
-0.0082854573,
0.0141960103,
0.0265243221,
-0.0188750457,
0.0032752715,
-0.0738774464,
0.0280468147,
0.0636519641,
-0.0282156318,
-0.0227647908,
0.0711504593,
2.637e-7,
0.0098717753,
0.0145046059,
0.0707621872,
0.0205858033,
0.0502765998,
-0.0035049692,
-0.0023684162,
0.0143765463,
0.0168077946,
0.0337535962,
-0.0154000213,
0.0298763961,
0.0790417343,
-0.0163383894,
-0.0799478516,
0.0668164045,
-0.0633119717,
-0.0034185268,
-0.0476817451,
-0.0662750825,
-0.0202659536,
0.0926003903,
-0.0037509981,
0.0060490668,
0.0367651805,
0.0117253885,
0.0371607952,
-0.0068078754,
0.0018198154,
-0.0011710854,
0.0190946721,
0.0205082949,
0.012427303,
-0.0376086533,
-0.0145063577,
-0.0209732559,
-0.0095587382,
0.055300951,
-0.0040195691,
-0.0299939681,
0.0404100865,
-0.0258256029,
-0.014200639,
-0.0036209242,
0.0567749292,
-0.0395551175,
0.0039413623,
-0.052369263,
-0.0361643732,
0.0353670046,
-0.0366418399,
0.0146969659,
-0.0195242539,
0.0430986471,
0.026892921,
-0.0173840206,
0.0182628073,
-0.0719006583,
-0.0102056889,
-0.0380280428,
-0.0667264685,
-0.0160916001,
-0.0535045341,
0.0086767701,
0.0277607236,
-0.0094661936,
-0.0150674433,
2.582709862e-34,
0.0635003075,
-0.034035001,
-0.0098201502,
0.0561974086,
0.019910736,
-0.0434018411,
-0.0222461745,
0.0545059815,
-0.0184746198,
-0.0833768398,
-0.059372548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03415v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03415v2 | End-to-End Evaluation for Low-Latency Simultaneous Speech Translation | 2023-08-07T09:06:20 | 2023-10-23T11:47:04 | Christian Huber, Tu Anh Dinh, Carlos Mullov, Ngoc Quan Pham, Thai Binh Nguyen, Fabian Retkowski, Stefan Constantin, Enes Yavuz Ugan, Danni Liu, Zhaolin Li, Sai Koneru, Jan Niehues, Alexander Waibel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The challenge of low-latency speech translation has recently draw significant
interest in the research community as shown by several publications and shared
tasks. Therefore, it is essential to evaluate these different approaches in
realistic scenarios. However, currently only specific aspects of the systems
are evaluated and often it is not possible to compare different approaches.
In this work, we propose the first framework to perform and evaluate the
various aspects of low-latency speech translation under realistic conditions.
The evaluation is carried out in an end-to-end fashion. This includes the
segmentation of the audio as well as the run-time of the different components.
Secondly, we compare different approaches to low-latency speech translation
using this framework. We evaluate models with the option to revise the output
as well as methods with fixed output. Furthermore, we directly compare
state-of-the-art cascaded as well as end-to-end systems. Finally, the framework
allows to automatically evaluate the translation quality as well as latency and
also provides a web interface to show the low-latency model outputs to the
user. | [
-0.004730294,
0.0233560167,
0.0078027877,
-0.0211924072,
-0.0521607101,
-0.0177408289,
0.0630290657,
-0.0112988325,
-0.0741971135,
0.0056333807,
-0.0454621725,
-0.0437396988,
0.0657642856,
0.0226868484,
0.022572238,
-0.0826905519,
-0.0018916059,
-0.031727232,
-0.0375926197,
0.0197422095,
-0.0117933918,
-0.0180202518,
-0.0195409115,
0.0321639478,
-0.0054087178,
-0.0026524889,
-0.0030115028,
0.0532361083,
0.0525723509,
-0.0017070047,
-0.0253741127,
0.0049158232,
0.0107366089,
0.0638542846,
0.0000019368,
-0.0094389822,
-0.0248905458,
0.0615551099,
-0.0059253131,
0.0095129898,
0.052104082,
0.0200703274,
-0.0622398444,
0.0400129594,
0.0004296252,
-0.0103046866,
0.0414926037,
-0.0184358414,
0.0579496436,
0.0274248309,
-0.0262143705,
-0.0453467108,
-0.0192373507,
-0.033255022,
-0.0343221091,
-0.0183166321,
-0.0423367172,
-0.0108571583,
-0.0163397938,
-0.0249236599,
-0.0032758622,
0.0775345042,
0.0074576377,
-0.0427997634,
-0.0018537346,
-0.0205736887,
-0.0321797915,
-0.0285114106,
-0.0638348833,
0.0419613011,
-0.0346924961,
0.0079651559,
0.0067951223,
0.0168081652,
-0.0397321992,
-0.0861810073,
-0.0474143401,
0.0176746827,
0.0026654159,
-0.0359928422,
-0.0417712703,
0.0767597854,
0.0275994092,
-0.0537405424,
-0.0401799753,
-0.0190579332,
0.0385231748,
-0.0099708792,
-0.0198003743,
0.0212824289,
-0.0303039048,
-0.0157602914,
0.0651016384,
-0.0118262721,
-0.0135546438,
-0.0144228339,
-0.0512609668,
-0.0690296516,
-0.0346529484,
-0.028275745,
0.0242692549,
0.0753815994,
-0.0434401408,
0.013051169,
-0.0415589623,
0.0271137506,
-0.0207796786,
-0.0329035111,
-0.0237525608,
-0.0007141883,
0.0118497089,
0.0274335854,
-0.0334594734,
-0.0084218225,
-0.0625250936,
-0.0238254443,
-0.0220853854,
-0.0244989209,
-0.0300422497,
0.0188375581,
0.0578387566,
-0.0212249849,
-0.0685418844,
-0.0406243689,
0.0364659727,
0.0637922361,
-0.0142380595,
0.0354478806,
0.0217083655,
-0.0583038405,
-0.0022753752,
0.0472833216,
0.0133237718,
0.0097037498,
-0.0323429853,
0.049362544,
-0.0018071226,
-0.008143154,
-0.0058919596,
-0.0040993919,
0.0045461054,
-0.0320713595,
-0.0284604058,
-0.0720941573,
0.0233866833,
0.0039504012,
0.0402547792,
0.0424096808,
-0.011745018,
-0.0165121686,
0.0383548811,
0.056857571,
0.0028483435,
0.0423823185,
0.0479217544,
0.0396610759,
0.0002822017,
0.0500050895,
0.0732445344,
0.0020821914,
0.0077228947,
-0.0111125316,
-0.0617076866,
0.0911781192,
0.0170016736,
0.0404208153,
-0.0212803502,
-0.0069968398,
-0.0121565228,
0.0421356335,
0.0004044363,
0.0427439995,
-0.019471677,
0.0221750475,
0.0862205848,
0.0215846412,
0.0422912203,
-0.0225233901,
0.0873697624,
0.0059823659,
-0.0015169794,
-0.0222477298,
0.0105605703,
0.0164727103,
0.021093756,
-0.0036737532,
0.0752349719,
0.0733646527,
-0.0005034441,
0.0141657451,
0.0157820154,
-0.0249293763,
-0.0118969623,
-0.0101322588,
0.0472389422,
0.0114256488,
-0.0584754609,
0.0409261063,
-0.0542134717,
-0.0717679113,
0.0154739385,
-0.0367415324,
-0.0786661655,
0.0255412962,
0.030208569,
0.026595952,
0.0260719229,
-0.0374973863,
-0.0144085139,
0.0397025123,
0.0184465107,
0.0342226401,
0.0305630453,
-0.0164346602,
-0.0091478666,
0.091256626,
0.012232733,
0.0338657573,
0.0102007464,
0.0364240333,
0.0352032147,
0.0222158637,
0.0319020525,
-0.01406918,
0.0088956608,
0.0646391213,
0.0074940198,
0.020150641,
0.0347341113,
0.0318253525,
-0.0108605474,
0.0129912496,
-0.0069892551,
-0.0202317052,
0.02951934,
0.0420160666,
-0.0174197257,
-0.0152523899,
0.000755895,
-0.034457434,
0.0395494774,
0.0483923592,
0.0078768954,
-0.085301578,
0.0030995351,
0.0023313938,
-0.0033227145,
0.0008884062,
0.0759488493,
0.0278539211,
-0.0364921577,
-0.0073050391,
-0.036618758,
-0.0001886377,
0.0357806981,
0.0351746492,
0.0313576795,
0.0049860375,
-0.0727160275,
-0.0138960611,
0.0536904112,
-0.0086978972,
0.0144839622,
-0.0207894985,
-0.0034738763,
-0.0117657827,
-0.0363484584,
-0.0627628714,
0.0204876065,
-0.017594032,
0.033893764,
0.0271343701,
0.0180124454,
0.0343555845,
-0.019358566,
-0.0165158845,
0.0387820415,
0.0262230281,
-0.0257567391,
-0.0862130895,
0.0003822991,
-0.0437765494,
-0.0227695741,
0.0124174319,
0.0614748299,
0.0304490495,
0.0039680391,
-0.0328199379,
-0.0532415919,
-0.0203687157,
0.0105527965,
0.0056588533,
0.0334731638,
-0.0617069006,
0.0088824229,
0.0368285328,
0.0166618489,
-0.0098226583,
-0.0143988207,
-0.0148987258,
0.00346295,
-0.0299057569,
-0.0213973764,
-0.0033352738,
0.033242885,
0.0251991786,
-0.0095164254,
0.000080033,
-0.0307729188,
0.0379094817,
0.0441187583,
0.0138795292,
-0.0494023599,
-0.0153226815,
-0.0410358571,
-0.0200510845,
-0.0046983561,
-0.0313300379,
-0.0084562544,
0.0080695124,
-0.0172064863,
-0.0461702794,
-0.007982105,
-0.0851499215,
-0.0640565306,
0.000892063,
-0.0341508389,
-0.0166376308,
0.0116668381,
-0.020121377,
-0.0059766821,
-0.0807299167,
-0.0395846479,
-0.0442281403,
0.0475636274,
0.0107493997,
-0.0579658784,
0.0084280558,
-0.0272062737,
-0.0134644583,
-0.0272096116,
0.0001948493,
0.0273777992,
0.0288179144,
-0.0187869407,
0.0176808368,
0.0448705517,
-0.0434586257,
-0.0417354852,
0.091862537,
0.0000541063,
0.0876945853,
-0.0115871662,
0.0013246323,
-0.0174932647,
0.0461387783,
-0.0197708271,
0.0196564794,
0.0191307273,
-0.0243247859,
0.0255417507,
-0.0040024561,
0.073591657,
-0.010689741,
-0.0719905049,
-0.0242813304,
0.0378196985,
0.0155447097,
-0.0499144644,
0.0107072163,
0.0402793735,
-0.0646844879,
0.0158110578,
0.0755584538,
-0.0344654173,
-0.0388730653,
-0.0073405746,
0.02324179,
0.0148868049,
-0.0005009755,
-0.0334322304,
-0.0403921567,
-0.0004888197,
0.0366578065,
0.0749573931,
0.0333988108,
0.0453191549,
-0.010296749,
-0.0313264653,
0.0565805994,
0.0510091409,
-0.0308577586,
-0.0374347158,
0.0074927984,
-0.0427676067,
0.0037063858,
0.0503955185,
-0.0100111002,
0.0134004932,
-0.0183767248,
-0.0042521455,
-0.0168613382,
-0.0192529391,
0.0070135104,
-0.0131895021,
0.089318566,
0.0383543372,
0.0083211223,
0.0292652082,
-0.0096218577,
0.0343913436,
-0.0433198176,
-0.0267730579,
0.0281479694,
-0.0361298621,
0.0211224258,
-0.0275405385,
0.0171790104,
-0.0035425776,
0.0345482267,
0.0497426838,
-0.013889838,
0.0070949798,
-0.0345914215,
0.055707138,
0.0213434212,
0.0375976823,
0.0361108519,
0.0532595702,
0.0050755767,
-0.0403757058,
-0.0001196427,
0.0298836753,
-0.019188771,
-0.0470474288,
-0.0283068661,
-0.0165625401,
-0.0129066398,
-0.0459598936,
-0.0601940267,
0.0186285712,
0.0000912973,
0.0485663973,
0.0013013417,
0.0073559824,
0.0039160242,
0.0198372323,
-0.0109135015,
-0.0111549357,
-0.0019808712,
0.0358145498,
-0.0826189071,
0.0295908041,
0.0011808034,
-0.0334394239,
-0.0087354742,
0.0229012463,
-0.0930506662,
-0.026678592,
0.01162575,
-0.0010185053,
0.0235797521,
0.032798849,
-0.0496304333,
-0.0176164526,
0.0175964776,
-0.0334727839,
-0.0176852271,
0.0310105141,
0.0270069782,
-0.0011152466,
-0.0217511579,
0.0356716514,
-0.03231249,
0.0319175571,
-0.0360744074,
0.0242592003,
0.0338203907,
-0.086328581,
-0.0170144718,
0.0412013419,
0.0507476255,
-0.0009778226,
0.0065238373,
0.0235774498,
0.0714511871,
-0.047649961,
0.033394035,
-0.0647295713,
-0.0256070457,
0.019323837,
-0.0114468224,
0.0100650787,
0.0166107938,
0.0125770494,
-0.0472266302,
0.0093893716,
0.0232830737,
-0.0238294397,
-0.0292644836,
0.0103646414,
0.0082828477,
0.0149588827,
-0.021973623,
0.014776377,
-0.0172014646,
-0.0421383679,
0.024593398,
-0.0115034906,
0.0133420099,
0.0462728105,
0.0384146497,
-0.0114830397,
0.0060963924,
-0.0218212232,
-0.0151203293,
0.034630131,
0.0298548751,
0.1388740987,
-0.0075071147,
0.0303159524,
-0.049269069,
0.0750496536,
-0.007172063,
-0.0068685045,
-0.0251233336,
-0.0257194452,
0.0136465067,
0.0478682928,
-0.0058715064,
-0.022974899,
-0.0093850615,
-0.0400622599,
-0.0010204922,
0.0087278094,
-0.0424244106,
-0.0602641217,
-0.0393145606,
-0.0254286285,
-0.0449522585,
-0.0033926012,
-0.0349618867,
-0.0328304805,
0.0036004637,
0.0174324419,
-0.025249254,
0.0058187158,
0.0389600545,
-0.0054526562,
0.0171056539,
-0.0070590936,
-0.054677207,
0.0104583651,
0.0056127217,
0.0320036933,
-5.999694147e-33,
-0.0628406927,
-0.0264534764,
0.0288083237,
-0.049862504,
-0.0494919717,
0.0021587957,
-0.0270612184,
0.0006890991,
0.0044268304,
-0.0066971425,
0.0208482482,
0.021212291,
0.0419501588,
-0.0179953221,
-0.0365799628,
0.0605315864,
0.1066700742,
-0.0372124054,
-0.0476295352,
0.0068041091,
0.0491631813,
0.0025752145,
-0.0043914621,
-0.0181722809,
-0.0177333541,
0.0123936087,
-0.0386150964,
0.0014454584,
-0.0145639265,
-0.0019091753,
0.055859413,
-0.000842747,
-0.0340641476,
-0.0578363277,
-0.0211518221,
0.0010828648,
-0.0619572997,
0.0344100483,
-0.0181760155,
0.0627381802,
0.0202607065,
0.0069866949,
0.0028050451,
0.0080076344,
0.000104084,
-0.0316485651,
-0.0370804481,
-0.0533869267,
-0.038510371,
-0.0482777394,
-0.0295146219,
0.0273074862,
-0.016150279,
-0.0251394156,
0.0591080487,
0.0814700425,
-0.0583138429,
-0.0387537926,
-0.0806712359,
0.0245982651,
0.0061183088,
0.0292776171,
0.0643659532,
0.0077011473,
-0.017346302,
-0.0198987927,
0.0334645584,
-0.0322527178,
0.0446035266,
0.0109918267,
0.0459940061,
-0.0066607418,
0.0747687966,
-0.0419798866,
-0.0031403888,
0.0103805596,
-0.0240248963,
0.0240502544,
-0.0188388508,
0.0018642008,
0.0040972829,
0.0308389328,
-0.0346041471,
0.038194973,
-0.064428024,
-0.0234271344,
-0.0101509076,
-0.029901458,
0.0361445434,
0.0323145427,
-0.0092861047,
-0.0404397137,
0.0980952829,
0.0194162577,
0.034681987,
-0.0355928093,
-0.0183571465,
0.0388513654,
-0.0535280742,
0.0196805689,
0.0105503574,
-0.0090464009,
0.0546067171,
0.0279829893,
0.0129097831,
-0.0599672869,
-0.0291789845,
0.0684909597,
-0.0441914909,
0.0130186444,
0.004362491,
0.0260473937,
0.0038009677,
0.0197406281,
0.0412773602,
-0.0688048154,
-0.002729415,
0.0605443642,
-0.044269219,
-0.0181903522,
0.0424812809,
0.0009703399,
0.0364754722,
0.050930839,
-0.0815825909,
0.0713186413,
-0.0259852521,
0.004350442,
0.0521802641,
0.0064469678,
-0.049333021,
-0.0041767582,
2.726e-7,
-0.0229449943,
0.0136009874,
0.0108457115,
0.0107893096,
0.0384261012,
-0.0006667955,
-0.0272310413,
-0.0106090354,
-0.0054773786,
0.0256455578,
-0.0076531465,
-0.0181235038,
0.1421212256,
0.00278973,
-0.0451233014,
-0.0274176188,
-0.0566444881,
0.0247683767,
0.000911014,
0.0011376615,
0.044150278,
0.0300435349,
-0.0413147956,
-0.0054640532,
0.0160031803,
0.0212578289,
0.0290913079,
0.0135018313,
-0.0235614982,
-0.0469827577,
0.0569004416,
-0.014009323,
-0.0617042258,
0.0133424411,
-0.046593558,
-0.0143239088,
0.0662969574,
0.0756212249,
0.0040922794,
-0.0346932225,
0.0154744564,
0.0210382566,
-0.0145269576,
0.0001809843,
0.0490395613,
-0.009109579,
-0.0046737306,
-0.0091828937,
-0.0463970713,
0.0078740818,
-0.020536609,
-0.0139907915,
0.0289905965,
-0.0104037346,
0.006402696,
0.0296841376,
0.0059813806,
0.0102212057,
-0.0082847504,
0.0257793684,
-0.0223899186,
-0.0872155949,
-0.0408654548,
0.0086446367,
-0.0062318994,
0.017025359,
-0.0540764667,
1.994124688e-34,
0.0207511857,
-0.0509393848,
0.0207819026,
-0.0063390862,
-0.0048853606,
-0.0519469753,
-0.0058781574,
0.0047177128,
-0.0627539009,
-0.01625406,
-0.0541096926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03365v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03365v2 | Improving Few-shot and Zero-shot Entity Linking with Coarse-to-Fine Lexicon-based Retriever | 2023-08-07T07:39:43 | 2023-08-13T07:02:16 | Shijue Huang, Bingbing Wang, Libo Qin, Qin Zhao, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few-shot and zero-shot entity linking focus on the tail and emerging
entities, which are more challenging but closer to real-world scenarios. The
mainstream method is the ''retrieve and rerank'' two-stage framework. In this
paper, we propose a coarse-to-fine lexicon-based retriever to retrieve entity
candidates in an effective manner, which operates in two layers. The first
layer retrieves coarse-grained candidates by leveraging entity names, while the
second layer narrows down the search to fine-grained candidates within the
coarse-grained ones. In addition, this second layer utilizes entity
descriptions to effectively disambiguate tail or new entities that share names
with existing popular entities. Experimental results indicate that our approach
can obtain superior performance without requiring extensive finetuning in the
retrieval stage. Notably, our approach ranks the 1st in NLPCC 2023 Shared Task
6 on Chinese Few-shot and Zero-shot Entity Linking. | [
0.0471501984,
-0.0001722762,
-0.003104049,
0.0095998636,
0.0370585881,
0.0019684925,
-0.0357499532,
0.0365396589,
0.0020963245,
-0.0376165397,
-0.0091416407,
0.0203158036,
-0.005985185,
-0.031973999,
0.0368341617,
-0.0243602451,
0.017530892,
0.0533745624,
-0.0211870652,
0.0152533371,
-0.0013255817,
0.0293757897,
0.0170703996,
-0.002231373,
0.0170323644,
0.0194336399,
0.0116105368,
0.0516919121,
0.0502869375,
-0.0616861731,
-0.0108320722,
-0.0005585072,
-0.0234781373,
0.0424332246,
0.0000018855,
-0.0629337132,
-0.0750896111,
0.0326648317,
-0.0308415387,
-0.0153726889,
0.0007076031,
-0.0186475497,
-0.0064847157,
-0.0316846631,
0.0008289891,
-0.0419637784,
0.019067049,
0.0565567948,
0.015545141,
0.0604612678,
0.0023493359,
-0.0807244703,
0.004464481,
-0.0253244303,
0.0032615415,
-0.0755986646,
0.0195139535,
-0.0286604818,
0.0292733125,
0.0312519409,
-0.0105414363,
0.0328540802,
-0.0180209782,
0.0397895426,
-0.0126153799,
0.0516646281,
-0.0422313735,
0.0140883448,
0.0233715493,
0.1052086651,
-0.0165935867,
-0.019889785,
0.0443972684,
0.0196997523,
-0.0005670263,
-0.0070549245,
-0.0535704121,
-0.0136615485,
-0.0015754779,
0.0025817635,
-0.019061029,
-0.0059968545,
0.0303384326,
0.0043559386,
-0.0192730203,
-0.0118115824,
-0.0002454936,
-0.0019284,
-0.0284359232,
0.0099541759,
0.0035510554,
-0.0264192112,
0.0092042526,
0.0077827596,
-0.0316290669,
0.0328214951,
-0.0062496876,
0.0186453667,
0.0126981549,
-0.0207944941,
-0.0115453722,
0.0030739529,
0.0128767611,
0.0377556756,
-0.0626863092,
-0.059413787,
-0.0003960997,
-0.0430179611,
0.0306282099,
-0.0544506386,
-0.0582165271,
-0.0005566289,
-0.0467072576,
0.0632209331,
-0.0135358432,
0.0088745169,
-0.0266108364,
-0.054560367,
-0.0073114922,
0.0487664565,
-0.0110726347,
-0.0063722637,
-0.0185531117,
-0.0210787803,
-0.0402409099,
0.0305730179,
-0.0558737516,
-0.0224832855,
0.0090024434,
0.0022687505,
-0.0287483539,
-0.0261733085,
0.027359359,
-0.0537440181,
0.0064778524,
0.0204500705,
0.032282088,
-0.0286913589,
-0.0609235838,
-0.0319205783,
0.020305898,
-0.0480011776,
-0.0395912342,
-0.039748352,
0.0111491391,
0.0104874345,
0.0131164547,
-0.0419590436,
0.0253920835,
0.0085702045,
-0.0824249983,
0.0631836206,
-0.0409205072,
-0.044248689,
0.0075611435,
0.0251474734,
0.072374925,
0.0433579236,
0.000405241,
0.0195267722,
0.0666634664,
0.0383446887,
-0.0226321798,
0.0040088668,
0.0414613523,
-0.0388333797,
-0.0011228069,
0.0065219603,
-0.0357238501,
0.0081290826,
0.003547919,
0.0308516435,
-0.0497324169,
-0.0332626291,
0.0026354303,
0.0225473978,
0.0484017842,
-0.0223205164,
0.0239728671,
0.024775032,
-0.042257525,
-0.0070937481,
-0.0385337062,
0.0395037681,
-0.0291069131,
-0.0015515232,
0.0466012806,
0.0393900536,
-0.0252124444,
0.0035956912,
0.0123416232,
0.0084086554,
-0.0342432447,
0.0434544906,
0.0381820835,
0.014513717,
-0.0151399635,
0.0802208185,
0.0360265039,
-0.0140455449,
-0.0062269499,
0.0121857729,
-0.0406933427,
0.0586767197,
0.0519100614,
0.0189967472,
-0.0476229414,
0.022239022,
-0.0195370968,
0.0121779293,
0.0167429447,
-0.04638502,
0.0194555148,
-0.0173291061,
-0.0114873676,
0.0582717583,
-0.0005003628,
-0.0040286453,
0.0581437238,
0.0738083646,
0.0466842316,
-0.0436979607,
0.0092086652,
0.0018145895,
-0.0267045107,
-0.0119908415,
0.0253091138,
0.0203971881,
-0.0530958995,
0.0652452633,
-0.0163901225,
-0.0059386468,
0.0334061272,
0.0113076391,
-0.0109360348,
-0.0228311419,
0.0301249754,
-0.0457033403,
0.0380505957,
-0.0202870984,
0.0082952119,
-0.0272771493,
-0.0024082321,
-0.048587732,
-0.0045720707,
0.0421262011,
0.007299256,
-0.0318141431,
0.0389417112,
-0.010254981,
0.0220947862,
-0.0492368601,
0.0803921074,
0.052065216,
0.0292875282,
0.0091932621,
0.0023745087,
0.0087961098,
-0.0444716066,
-0.0594942831,
0.005839888,
-0.0071100476,
0.0040594102,
0.0395630337,
-0.014643969,
-0.0514484197,
-0.0110059474,
-0.019319864,
0.0655139983,
0.0115952101,
0.0031020686,
-0.0281308591,
0.0206980687,
-0.0192717128,
-0.000286076,
0.0072149239,
0.0236226451,
-0.0228434335,
0.003281909,
0.0115427459,
0.0175309889,
-0.0242161378,
-0.0364215523,
-0.0114391213,
-0.0002803136,
0.0072337422,
-0.0196199212,
-0.0522427447,
-0.0190504529,
0.0212794393,
-0.0558124669,
-0.0075732921,
0.0075973584,
0.016461838,
-0.0287638865,
0.0306424592,
-0.0162395593,
0.0233277101,
-0.0309058838,
0.0190634448,
-0.0248706117,
-0.0287485681,
-0.0602804869,
0.0147877205,
0.0107521685,
0.0271121915,
0.0184140857,
0.0070896493,
0.0067594112,
0.0161940139,
-0.0363391936,
-0.0207035094,
-0.0143838283,
0.0011087905,
0.0265308898,
0.0232365485,
0.0018675029,
0.0529891029,
0.0084694596,
-0.001451942,
-0.0205953456,
0.039165169,
0.019632183,
-0.00923994,
0.025345739,
0.017781565,
0.0018849825,
-0.0252131112,
0.0293127056,
-0.0132073378,
0.0020258531,
0.039957948,
-0.043663498,
-0.0186579488,
0.0479798019,
0.0382540636,
-0.0298736524,
0.0260868706,
0.0408742391,
0.0484044626,
-0.0318371356,
-0.03253901,
0.0077449507,
-0.0012970039,
-0.0183991678,
0.0398544557,
-0.0030158842,
-0.0173403006,
-0.0082681756,
0.0427656695,
0.0327971503,
-0.0023310753,
0.0159389712,
-0.0545680113,
0.0220759362,
0.0168413911,
0.0590809882,
-0.0160389207,
0.0439158753,
0.0382982641,
0.0489498861,
0.0418733768,
0.0534710549,
-0.0250449236,
0.0569411553,
-0.027472388,
0.0425013117,
-0.0827971175,
-0.0332544632,
0.0127390204,
0.0251479056,
-0.0454620421,
0.0081576686,
0.0966963992,
0.0497221462,
0.0006281842,
-0.0120920986,
0.058810465,
-0.0212052464,
0.040675018,
0.0240275934,
-0.1042573079,
-0.027637437,
0.0142204287,
0.0054385387,
0.0103064282,
-0.0810047761,
0.0088280309,
-0.1562990993,
0.0377614126,
-0.0240873918,
-0.0034849648,
-0.018300062,
-0.0762531757,
0.0214136839,
-0.0182610303,
-0.0197834838,
0.0218355451,
-0.0092490297,
0.0102472743,
-0.0257182661,
0.0456178896,
-0.0328953639,
0.0537117384,
-0.0904446244,
0.0482314639,
0.033652477,
0.0640132576,
0.0175124481,
0.0466365404,
-0.0366888084,
-0.0885005519,
-0.0418057926,
-0.0083139986,
0.0641452298,
-0.0444654375,
-0.0048320885,
0.0152068576,
-0.0340972431,
0.0118867205,
0.0112063689,
-0.0430430137,
0.0117801316,
0.0451366901,
0.0123733338,
-0.0229504723,
-0.0186320655,
-0.0109728361,
0.0713294521,
-0.0025907161,
-0.0004863733,
0.0178863332,
-0.0132946009,
-0.0002535618,
-0.0269143246,
-0.0474119261,
0.0208992623,
-0.0796116143,
-0.0155633623,
-0.0665358305,
-0.0513059646,
0.0459959731,
0.0703243911,
-0.0169402212,
0.0787413269,
0.0048436956,
0.0025131244,
-0.0683974996,
-0.0288485754,
-0.0366019793,
0.0092640556,
-0.0295920763,
0.0038021416,
0.0726925656,
-0.0159507897,
-0.0190174319,
0.0071118986,
-0.0443077981,
-0.0424808264,
-0.0448599942,
-0.0111199711,
0.0104298266,
0.030870039,
-0.0391443036,
-0.0492101312,
0.0241202507,
0.0628958419,
-0.0150058083,
-0.0272255316,
-0.0205944218,
0.0099805258,
-0.0154053373,
0.0502661243,
-0.0862353966,
0.0245037861,
0.0181834027,
0.0646348372,
-0.0413481109,
-0.0415519737,
0.0085028419,
0.0380760469,
0.0371698514,
-0.0128693646,
0.00719113,
-0.0230236202,
0.0315426849,
-0.0109777525,
-0.0356011204,
0.0040586661,
-0.0145630185,
0.0167129729,
0.0010970626,
-0.0264846738,
0.0529944822,
0.026404988,
0.0478956327,
-0.1065825149,
-0.023886364,
-0.0349551737,
-0.0275934432,
-0.0068765553,
-0.0303550269,
0.0027265688,
0.0183455236,
0.0513820946,
0.0658256933,
-0.059088584,
-0.0275146738,
0.0264289938,
-0.0016796588,
-0.0263881776,
0.0203622133,
-0.0224018097,
0.0227489974,
-0.0063071689,
0.0323088691,
0.0767473206,
-0.0078643998,
0.0521855466,
0.0279567689,
-0.0197460465,
0.0056773867,
-0.0063519408,
-0.0050720219,
-0.0394604653,
-0.0094873449,
0.0206430573,
-0.0170623716,
0.04550438,
0.0575583652,
-0.0163394026,
0.0370575935,
0.0141350506,
0.0124842767,
-0.0126019074,
0.0040346589,
0.0280314572,
-0.0164566059,
0.0062829521,
0.0121342698,
-0.0555286072,
-0.0390201882,
0.0497619472,
-0.0522635877,
-0.0239275284,
0.0050219512,
0.0205556322,
0.0413366556,
0.0515673198,
-0.0204459336,
-0.0166245438,
-0.069672823,
-0.0014379533,
-0.0351006612,
0.0154463891,
-6.415129646e-33,
-0.0607157722,
-0.004987081,
0.0151203834,
-0.0467915423,
-0.010851468,
-0.0048603537,
-0.0100013316,
-0.0374115966,
-0.0819824412,
-0.0162101034,
-0.0161886197,
0.026168935,
0.0177934058,
0.0142825637,
-0.0153607093,
-0.0106335459,
0.0396657139,
0.0397431515,
-0.0215829443,
0.0074865497,
0.0495599508,
0.0532948487,
0.0581364632,
-0.0390539058,
0.0201909393,
0.0210513901,
-0.0002433381,
0.0145467641,
0.071287483,
0.0659733191,
0.0355966203,
0.0203139205,
0.0113684209,
-0.05967189,
-0.0051671676,
-0.0709227622,
-0.1510877907,
-0.0150369704,
-0.0255591311,
-0.0160428341,
0.0582337677,
0.0047746846,
0.0405625738,
-0.0007111617,
0.0482878909,
-0.0078925351,
0.0232634954,
-0.0164015107,
-0.0436646529,
-0.0808870569,
-0.0388890654,
0.0517182089,
0.0039117043,
0.0128814355,
0.0374190882,
-0.0515420362,
0.0082088551,
0.0227218177,
-0.0791094527,
-0.0228813607,
0.0103188995,
0.0426155254,
0.0086401235,
-0.0236457717,
0.0219253879,
0.0562898964,
0.0351373143,
0.0167599488,
-0.0153430682,
0.0002858917,
0.0071994807,
0.0148740485,
-0.0535077602,
0.0761819109,
0.0479408167,
-0.0488780513,
-0.0778293386,
0.0513660945,
0.0183847994,
0.0125278551,
-0.0230546799,
0.0229262169,
-0.0516899042,
-0.0400204659,
-0.015668273,
0.0043430142,
-0.0392683409,
-0.0146453157,
0.0149463732,
0.0330265686,
-0.0480787866,
0.0701755509,
0.0105098812,
-0.0296393223,
-0.0614071377,
0.0104402723,
0.0220615845,
-0.0102231046,
-0.0062769451,
0.0024412081,
-0.05630311,
-0.0171489492,
0.0508529246,
-0.0178873036,
-0.0306963101,
0.0080695366,
0.0365862697,
-0.0127638374,
-0.0609240867,
0.0024200184,
0.0201766323,
-0.0095121525,
-0.041418314,
-0.0258015543,
0.0051971595,
0.029657403,
0.0101086767,
-0.0088551901,
0.1059345007,
-0.0346915573,
-0.0047061411,
0.0493397228,
0.006963809,
-0.0109794624,
0.0023481655,
0.0552251227,
0.0025881662,
0.0186842736,
0.0246410612,
-0.0519382842,
-0.0320519246,
-0.0137986103,
2.752e-7,
0.000042052,
0.0023836738,
-0.0052082329,
0.055466909,
-0.0392349511,
-0.0028336579,
0.0518521182,
0.0437478609,
-0.0246646255,
-0.0091942428,
0.0009179918,
-0.0016437828,
0.0134640569,
0.0215901919,
-0.0957524031,
0.0176905692,
-0.0159736034,
-0.0104887709,
-0.0287027601,
-0.0485193133,
0.0126042953,
0.0529948324,
0.0041642459,
0.0283779278,
-0.0129637532,
-0.0461579785,
0.0326651484,
0.0099680144,
0.0053791837,
0.0343877785,
-0.0056768139,
0.0450979732,
-0.0235770922,
-0.01000557,
-0.0198780447,
0.0803194195,
0.0314874016,
0.0095546721,
-0.0261592232,
-0.0143614942,
-0.0068172929,
-0.0903235003,
0.0152240619,
0.0167991742,
0.0741830766,
-0.0324828438,
-0.010195314,
0.0528774336,
-0.0340225436,
0.0325412117,
-0.038107723,
0.0049977689,
-0.0293221194,
0.0250047445,
0.0180978123,
0.025804108,
-0.0011084877,
-0.1126544178,
0.0113248816,
0.0257386975,
0.0351788402,
-0.0274879858,
0.0379641652,
-0.0820511654,
-0.0187425613,
-0.0310136061,
-0.0184231587,
2.350571539e-34,
-0.0262005441,
0.0135286795,
-0.0298720002,
0.0449226201,
0.0707362592,
-0.0365789495,
-0.0693856403,
0.0008233398,
0.0051587531,
-0.0386495329,
-0.0146459369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03360v1 | Coupling Symbolic Reasoning with Language Modeling for Efficient Longitudinal Understanding of Unstructured Electronic Medical Records | 2023-08-07T07:29:49 | 2023-08-07T07:29:49 | Shivani Shekhar, Simran Tiwari, T. C. Rensink, Ramy Eskander, Wael Salloum | cs.CL | cs.CL | The application of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in healthcare has been
revolutionary, especially with the recent advancements in transformer-based
Large Language Models (LLMs). However, the task of understanding unstructured
electronic medical records remains a challenge given the nature of the records
(e.g., disorganization, inconsistency, and redundancy) and the inability of
LLMs to derive reasoning paradigms that allow for comprehensive understanding
of medical variables. In this work, we examine the power of coupling symbolic
reasoning with language modeling toward improved understanding of unstructured
clinical texts. We show that such a combination improves the extraction of
several medical variables from unstructured records. In addition, we show that
the state-of-the-art commercially-free LLMs enjoy retrieval capabilities
comparable to those provided by their commercial counterparts. Finally, we
elaborate on the need for LLM steering through the application of symbolic
reasoning as the exclusive use of LLMs results in the lowest performance. | [
0.0327084325,
0.0670029894,
-0.0214993805,
-0.0130931521,
-0.0550867617,
0.0572216213,
0.0028417991,
0.058516182,
0.0176408831,
-0.013370771,
0.0594940707,
-0.0461578481,
0.0071133021,
0.0356108658,
-0.0443917997,
-0.0346997529,
0.008687757,
-0.0042128875,
0.0590080842,
0.018095931,
-0.0422608294,
0.0021096754,
-0.0171653982,
0.0058244155,
-0.0019866633,
-0.007641424,
0.0172110666,
-0.0028426223,
0.0140636014,
-0.0323949829,
-0.0754402578,
-0.001375483,
0.0057495735,
-0.0231348351,
0.0000020131,
-0.0598244667,
-0.0565398112,
0.0297746491,
-0.0501795597,
-0.0749342144,
0.0156845301,
-0.0683233365,
-0.0129996967,
0.0118212709,
-0.0262328163,
-0.0365363508,
0.0163096394,
0.0546701625,
0.0313667022,
0.0595602021,
-0.0324870199,
-0.004304213,
0.0038125401,
0.0113804014,
0.0315699838,
-0.0037353705,
0.0497522801,
0.0233502295,
0.0430482887,
-0.0426215529,
0.0130669726,
0.0398449898,
0.0051548169,
0.0250992142,
-0.0367624089,
0.0332940146,
-0.0257471483,
0.0157893673,
0.0118602002,
0.0174833108,
0.0100170774,
-0.0093779219,
0.0639052391,
0.0212700851,
-0.0291615799,
0.0233507752,
-0.0482629687,
0.0354114138,
-0.0526495613,
-0.01316028,
0.0371864662,
-0.0033595127,
0.0243504941,
-0.0085991966,
-0.1097625569,
0.0365941934,
0.0006921899,
-0.0398211628,
0.0190861914,
-0.0435133651,
-0.0303032994,
-0.0197799876,
0.0499588102,
0.0917859897,
-0.0004754438,
0.0326380543,
-0.0011279938,
-0.0569199026,
0.0411555432,
-0.060605105,
0.0044216979,
0.0169369336,
0.0303723011,
0.0697704256,
-0.0006878641,
0.0232848357,
-0.0382921435,
0.0617613606,
-0.0548369773,
-0.0135872969,
-0.0546254516,
-0.0315659419,
-0.0386809744,
0.0447551906,
0.0073017282,
0.0087478086,
-0.027255334,
-0.0023185413,
0.0081846388,
0.0073431991,
0.0323186815,
0.0038911568,
-0.0077810185,
-0.0317895971,
-0.0133445421,
0.0035161411,
0.0108646909,
-0.0177711844,
-0.0426896475,
-0.0258185603,
0.033711195,
0.0127552245,
0.0387929156,
-0.0251441523,
0.0307531394,
0.0839202851,
0.0328313932,
-0.0006980246,
-0.0404440202,
-0.0427590646,
-0.0066072256,
-0.0377992168,
0.0233958811,
-0.0418393984,
0.0361965001,
0.0563534684,
-0.0258875787,
-0.0563873164,
0.0190919172,
0.0072164251,
-0.0375749916,
0.0398995318,
-0.0255704615,
-0.0064708516,
0.0048189838,
0.0086543662,
0.0028939764,
-0.0038200363,
0.0496143922,
-0.0386383124,
-0.013899981,
-0.0240547135,
0.0149233509,
0.0243789628,
-0.004006356,
-0.0623885989,
-0.050541997,
0.026450133,
0.0270707905,
0.0384074226,
-0.0573592521,
0.0746951848,
0.0261715148,
-0.014872822,
0.0161713734,
0.0619559065,
0.0515688285,
0.0142823923,
0.0069817528,
-0.0474238247,
0.0252068769,
-0.0419810265,
-0.0014943848,
0.002422852,
0.0233336538,
0.0016250812,
-0.0923125744,
0.027497286,
-0.0005889508,
-0.0566524155,
-0.0771219581,
-0.0153067587,
0.0107675269,
-0.0011696251,
0.0716592446,
-0.0053680567,
-0.0187722631,
0.0811685771,
0.0322190523,
-0.0260530598,
-0.0237519722,
-0.0203082412,
-0.0011692066,
0.0731275007,
0.0577488355,
-0.0546373874,
-0.0101057794,
-0.0346263871,
-0.0100287991,
-0.0195324924,
-0.0223840419,
-0.0139067601,
-0.0146882236,
-0.0409509689,
0.0161396675,
0.0837475061,
0.0014702518,
-0.0077364845,
-0.0376821645,
0.008267412,
-0.0078236423,
-0.0463996306,
-0.0047512003,
0.0316485688,
-0.0827639401,
-0.0241791457,
-0.0010098484,
0.0266780276,
0.0368613787,
0.0235252324,
-0.0053357151,
0.034072686,
0.0391191207,
-0.0705169067,
-0.0524873026,
0.0357712284,
-0.0349441282,
0.0123586841,
0.0157483425,
-0.0183637608,
-0.0110228471,
-0.0317865647,
-0.0120248059,
-0.0065332088,
-0.0082988758,
-0.042549137,
0.0451536477,
0.0178320389,
0.0253825467,
0.0422437042,
-0.045776207,
-0.0517774783,
0.0484380387,
-0.0186070912,
0.0048809368,
0.0362897478,
-0.0595813952,
0.0168719776,
-0.0050607682,
0.0275817271,
0.0381057449,
-0.0083313603,
-0.0124023948,
-0.0305199381,
-0.0271860212,
-0.0009327497,
-0.0435072184,
-0.0674932152,
-0.0185629576,
0.0022663036,
0.0215011649,
0.0276136808,
0.0261033587,
-0.0014008132,
0.0020849751,
-0.021893261,
-0.0137002207,
0.0335304514,
-0.0096494816,
0.0469961129,
0.0430857018,
-0.0145901544,
-0.0026366948,
-0.0137529569,
-0.0891777799,
0.0391280502,
0.0186699592,
-0.0136705982,
-0.006329699,
-0.007960829,
-0.0222396273,
0.0101753408,
-0.0411797389,
-0.0015768353,
0.0005496313,
-0.0685635805,
0.0118629364,
0.0675951615,
-0.012225138,
0.0306942463,
0.0078346021,
-0.0405650213,
-0.011548222,
0.0086094709,
-0.0376111008,
0.0164358392,
-0.0183694344,
-0.0589858554,
0.0075534498,
0.0732232034,
0.0226536635,
-0.006591876,
-0.01840185,
-0.0002701542,
-0.0359229334,
0.0644306913,
-0.0365781412,
0.0111988811,
-0.003348503,
0.044718273,
0.0058884989,
-0.0067242547,
0.0930883586,
-0.014446117,
0.0549436323,
-0.0737743974,
-0.0270422921,
-0.080029726,
0.0397748165,
-0.0100853629,
0.0228212737,
0.0187014993,
-0.0278540682,
0.0017502004,
0.0029361588,
-0.0039860131,
-0.0659381971,
0.0886331871,
-0.0370870046,
0.040455848,
0.0322698429,
-0.0157255456,
-0.0158958416,
0.0025351092,
-0.0078857495,
-0.0144966207,
-0.0058190227,
0.0080795558,
-0.0651488677,
0.0467591211,
0.0081377244,
0.0580406636,
0.0224490203,
-0.010235711,
-0.0143120978,
0.0022513666,
0.0162592959,
-0.0302616265,
0.0085247541,
-0.022550527,
0.0160034522,
0.0508937761,
0.0080133304,
0.0045865355,
0.0019894035,
0.016454652,
-0.012228475,
-0.0512100607,
0.004606599,
0.0353746936,
-0.0566903539,
-0.0766422376,
-0.003736808,
0.096404478,
0.0531790257,
-0.0223346408,
0.0091944812,
-0.0259577148,
-0.0821554661,
-0.0117687704,
0.0324185453,
-0.0733076707,
-0.0002012003,
0.005570285,
-0.0076076551,
-0.0057750349,
-0.053413067,
0.0196733996,
-0.0145939467,
0.021647606,
0.0074120793,
-0.0414881557,
-0.0273022912,
-0.0444187373,
-0.0183784869,
-0.028960336,
-0.0409455337,
0.0197657216,
-0.0376199521,
-0.0250371341,
-0.0063922754,
-0.0522721224,
-0.0475747511,
0.0226119179,
0.0064256736,
0.0079497211,
0.0295130275,
0.0469860658,
-0.0440362878,
-0.0425927565,
-0.0019729051,
0.0163238645,
0.0151295755,
-0.0424127989,
0.0395904444,
0.0469142795,
-0.0028005962,
-0.0617696419,
0.0297347326,
-0.0433830544,
-0.0366700254,
-0.0272400323,
0.0828012675,
-0.057677675,
-0.0116265379,
-0.0272372458,
-0.0110713635,
0.0036566413,
0.0316327699,
-0.040003404,
0.0054529784,
-0.0478958711,
0.0138280941,
0.0324150249,
0.036713995,
-0.0162866879,
0.0360604525,
-0.0197775811,
-0.0256102439,
-0.0437452793,
0.0095043136,
0.039060574,
0.0280878153,
0.0376221389,
0.0121887848,
0.0640292987,
-0.013996671,
-0.0891092867,
0.035710074,
0.0149988905,
0.0211306643,
-0.0255505722,
-0.0062306887,
0.0091409702,
-0.0217244085,
-0.0323383249,
-0.0416425765,
-0.021687936,
0.0131062996,
0.0227902867,
0.0269054864,
0.0291407835,
-0.0110998517,
0.0023692311,
0.0114238439,
-0.0011825466,
0.0285222959,
-0.0194892827,
-0.0555863492,
-0.0175977182,
0.0173907652,
-0.0022263785,
0.0036893669,
-0.0120129874,
0.0158842541,
-0.0073076948,
0.0216485113,
-0.0485473908,
0.0341528878,
0.0277326144,
0.0475741439,
0.0095364526,
0.0432773158,
-0.0459435508,
-0.0095445598,
0.0529819392,
-0.0512938946,
-0.0022821012,
-0.0085310554,
0.0073459614,
0.0076236413,
0.0180540234,
-0.0212648455,
-0.0327771604,
-0.0376341753,
-0.0537182279,
-0.0129851596,
0.0571593717,
-0.0002614607,
-0.0059288265,
0.0474045649,
-0.0509087741,
0.0234497618,
0.0009648722,
0.0208866615,
0.0569142066,
-0.0246236064,
0.0710191876,
0.0004620101,
0.0231030677,
-0.0519843288,
-0.0032734524,
-0.0266897082,
-0.0471542031,
0.0408868007,
-0.0312815383,
0.0236738976,
-0.0082789389,
-0.0002424987,
-0.0453075059,
0.019450061,
0.0077133756,
0.0044215042,
0.0221961718,
0.0310111754,
0.0259785317,
0.0370253511,
0.0016481945,
-0.0240527894,
0.0616087206,
-0.0179004967,
0.04059669,
-0.0152744409,
-0.0432889648,
-0.0323892124,
-0.0092515778,
0.0328675583,
-0.0259401444,
-0.0573444776,
-0.0077559366,
-0.0879513174,
-0.0180462524,
0.0577357113,
0.0111999363,
-0.0153053505,
-0.0177080557,
0.0179192964,
0.0398465768,
0.0066528204,
-0.0324253477,
-0.0330636576,
0.0386173055,
-0.020421112,
-0.0238042716,
0.0221303441,
-5.691064799e-33,
0.0165889934,
-0.0326061919,
0.0346922725,
-0.0080683241,
0.0107369833,
0.0094786528,
-0.0374141634,
-0.033202596,
0.0240970943,
0.0055793244,
-0.0430442728,
0.0120482305,
0.0180660505,
0.0351866521,
0.0088574821,
-0.0297352411,
-0.0043411725,
0.0492647849,
-0.0109714502,
-0.0194034204,
0.0201015603,
0.0449513942,
0.0233482774,
-0.0805460364,
0.0016519872,
0.0148109756,
0.0398818068,
0.0203040466,
-0.016030116,
0.0495824516,
0.0062499535,
-0.0270903762,
0.0335015692,
-0.02055154,
0.0121932188,
0.0060980925,
-0.103088066,
-0.0044786553,
0.0147361299,
0.0040538269,
0.0006373581,
-0.0473275185,
0.0503503792,
-0.0226988234,
0.007116951,
-0.0222140066,
0.0250945482,
-0.0440550335,
0.0008896133,
-0.0849312991,
-0.0246736743,
0.0617180504,
-0.0052073537,
0.034797363,
-0.0035213197,
-0.019733334,
-0.0520468131,
0.0512118116,
-0.0211629197,
-0.0045313127,
0.0380465537,
0.0026066948,
-0.004320845,
-0.0544844791,
-0.0014032361,
0.048280593,
0.0079530533,
-0.0085698823,
-0.0625272542,
0.043263685,
-0.0373173654,
0.0350996442,
0.0456216633,
-0.0057033724,
0.0478154533,
-0.0081724552,
-0.1141923815,
0.0387220941,
-0.0480583832,
0.0773574337,
0.0309345294,
-0.0244158115,
-0.0506049469,
0.0015575137,
-0.0159802232,
0.0271769315,
-0.0268529747,
-0.0261640381,
0.0015116045,
-0.0173306894,
-0.0218725596,
0.0179984551,
0.0279539041,
-0.0358651243,
-0.012791154,
-0.0026459715,
0.0916633457,
0.0113995643,
-0.0591828823,
0.0018580853,
-0.032125663,
-0.0367647633,
0.0261960477,
-0.0034674173,
0.068461284,
0.0384959392,
0.0154912407,
0.0030651942,
-0.0583705269,
-0.0219711643,
0.0185717065,
-0.0194305144,
-0.0162303485,
-0.017289564,
0.0474503413,
0.0537165403,
0.0269584805,
0.0373445824,
0.0001975601,
-0.0121164573,
-0.0357499532,
0.0192930996,
0.0047093243,
-0.014345617,
-0.0011075407,
-0.0294448324,
-0.038208846,
0.0339426361,
0.0402357429,
-0.0514417514,
0.0185154602,
0.0337701589,
2.817e-7,
0.0787306726,
0.0824013427,
0.0397199281,
0.0037251336,
0.0334116705,
-0.0132728368,
-0.0058489698,
-0.0563514009,
-0.0019128644,
-0.0114745656,
0.0681952089,
0.017765196,
0.026017474,
0.0528492481,
-0.045349136,
0.0150562171,
-0.051404763,
-0.084735401,
-0.040998593,
0.0163991973,
0.0841083676,
0.0600301772,
-0.0399698541,
-0.0351118073,
0.0177053977,
-0.0085372524,
0.0191902518,
-0.0252734777,
0.0224254355,
0.0343051478,
0.0128864609,
-0.0427909046,
0.0311750565,
0.0516137406,
0.0121603366,
0.0059337509,
-0.0144616645,
0.1145214513,
-0.0361741371,
0.0469769873,
0.0211811326,
-0.0392515063,
0.0020337221,
-0.0141189909,
0.0873648822,
-0.0617278852,
-0.0518890768,
0.0141168842,
-0.028515365,
-0.0139545389,
0.0141485874,
0.0208388232,
-0.0033974035,
0.0631693602,
0.0207170956,
-0.0022664529,
0.0024347042,
-0.0709570721,
-0.0003351884,
0.0445115827,
-0.0106029008,
0.0043971301,
0.0548734441,
0.0003589204,
0.0343503579,
-0.061912749,
0.0031967303,
2.735989734e-34,
0.0323171504,
0.0118520446,
-0.0180505943,
0.0361615308,
0.045962818,
-0.0068889284,
-0.0104807187,
0.0443424731,
-0.0142608406,
-0.1120794341,
0.0092610251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03349v1 | SciGraphQA: A Large-Scale Synthetic Multi-Turn Question-Answering Dataset for Scientific Graphs | 2023-08-07T07:03:49 | 2023-08-07T07:03:49 | Shengzhi Li, Nima Tajbakhsh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | In this work, we present SciGraphQA, a synthetic multi-turn question-answer
dataset related to academic graphs. SciGraphQA is 13 times larger than
ChartVQA, the previously largest chart-visual question-answering dataset. It is
also the largest open-sourced chart VQA dataset with non-synthetic charts. To
build our dataset, we selected 290,000 Computer Science or Machine Learning
ArXiv papers published between 2010 and 2020, and then used Palm-2 to generate
295K samples of open-vocabulary multi-turn question-answering dialogues about
the graphs. As context, we provided the text-only Palm-2 with paper title,
abstract, paragraph mentioning the graph, and rich text contextual data from
the graph itself, obtaining dialogues with an average 2.23 question-answer
turns for each graph. We asked GPT-4 to assess the matching quality of our
question-answer turns given the paper's context, obtaining an average rating of
8.7/10 on our 3K test set. We evaluated the 0-shot capability of the most
popular MLLM models such as LLaVa, mPLUGowl, BLIP-2, and openFlamingo's on our
dataset, finding LLaVA-13B being the most performant with a CIDEr score of
0.08. We further enriched the question prompts for LLAVA by including the
serialized data tables extracted from the graphs using the DePlot model,
boosting LLaVA's 0-shot CIDEr to 0.15. To verify the validity of our dataset,
we also fine-tuned LLaVa using our dataset, reaching a substantially higher
CIDEr score of 0.26. We anticipate further accuracy improvement by including
segmentation mask tokens and leveraging larger LLM backbones coupled with
emergent prompting techniques. Our code and data are open-sourced. | [
0.0166599322,
0.0130869839,
0.0185524113,
0.0362675339,
-0.0234662574,
-0.002682307,
0.0097105466,
0.0018659536,
0.0445898734,
0.0039883303,
-0.0247591045,
0.0256875306,
-0.0294357333,
0.055643782,
0.0048089013,
-0.0432505794,
0.0093239145,
-0.0046671531,
0.0518625192,
-0.0144399526,
0.0013128394,
0.0195595082,
-0.0257984698,
0.0253258161,
0.0032080039,
-0.0574071221,
-0.00392449,
0.0082989121,
0.0400183983,
-0.0522281751,
-0.0198880471,
0.0607477427,
0.0144986864,
0.0426373258,
0.0000019231,
-0.0586043745,
-0.0073516974,
0.0172535498,
-0.0554244183,
-0.0128792105,
0.0246857665,
-0.0285409987,
0.0595820993,
0.0005023878,
-0.0532349534,
-0.0029128822,
0.0443235934,
0.0330733471,
0.0790327415,
0.0448222384,
-0.0016420292,
-0.0284559876,
0.0272986963,
0.0118760448,
0.0289425887,
-0.0344812013,
0.0081499675,
0.0445252396,
0.0529673472,
0.0363910049,
-0.0367049091,
0.0444157682,
0.0211373121,
-0.0259649418,
0.0396079756,
0.0435355753,
-0.0387152694,
0.017245682,
0.0144810705,
0.1536346674,
0.0209819488,
-0.0204159748,
0.000568598,
-0.0218104962,
0.0245941039,
0.0590153039,
-0.0895400345,
-0.0398716815,
-0.0067164092,
-0.0474768318,
0.0028358605,
-0.0098064849,
0.0140411267,
-0.0305258576,
-0.0154485703,
0.0385759696,
-0.0026176574,
-0.0330208242,
0.0221157838,
-0.0064796223,
-0.0170701761,
-0.0269789547,
-0.0309986454,
0.0468774773,
-0.0226020478,
0.0100264465,
-0.0181608219,
-0.0007328233,
0.0075484454,
0.0132048028,
0.0387029871,
-0.0167339612,
0.0043322528,
0.059494134,
0.0216623805,
0.0073287832,
-0.0332599729,
0.0349730477,
-0.0290730111,
-0.035142038,
-0.0071224812,
-0.01242413,
-0.0303985253,
0.0056625358,
-0.0268426612,
-0.0445629768,
-0.0014887719,
0.0332376286,
0.0124770096,
0.0183161125,
0.0306204557,
0.046653036,
-0.0097505413,
0.0097801723,
-0.0232417081,
0.0695016459,
-0.0318469964,
-0.0039893501,
0.0033789522,
-0.0455891006,
-0.0168530438,
0.0293830615,
0.0429253019,
-0.0379661061,
0.0108224731,
0.075662747,
0.0399192162,
-0.0110347038,
0.0439630188,
-0.041655235,
-0.0144035025,
-0.0491637252,
0.0172000732,
-0.0603177845,
0.0465533696,
0.0228549801,
-0.0169024393,
-0.0079774885,
0.0172734819,
0.0355232581,
-0.0295969956,
0.074481748,
-0.0292751323,
-0.0192570072,
0.0390742645,
-0.0134230191,
-0.0224094912,
0.0345777832,
0.0280483719,
-0.033194907,
0.0599846616,
-0.0601228662,
0.038314119,
0.0130616659,
0.0495482013,
-0.0067698606,
0.0447643846,
0.0550810173,
-0.0383923911,
0.0367334485,
0.0000398036,
0.0302099213,
-0.0276622772,
-0.0779340491,
0.001360688,
0.0429482833,
0.0133721381,
-0.0191835314,
0.0116102872,
0.0054762196,
0.0336615816,
0.0005997797,
-0.0129945902,
0.0639468804,
0.030328447,
0.0305084232,
0.0270991344,
-0.0277984627,
-0.0131628644,
-0.0190710407,
-0.0165222567,
0.0329311378,
-0.0074709947,
0.0040846062,
0.0492557622,
0.0182472095,
-0.0468775854,
-0.0031806719,
0.003496954,
-0.0319749489,
-0.0338636786,
-0.0038272149,
0.0463623293,
0.0103628533,
0.0583206974,
-0.0134881977,
-0.0564374216,
-0.0261953995,
0.003787803,
0.0298433285,
0.0574111082,
-0.0414728895,
-0.0151127428,
-0.0297109038,
-0.0196088348,
-0.040526621,
-0.0288789496,
0.006478285,
0.0132975094,
-0.0013292952,
-0.0332172848,
-0.0673179328,
-0.0301320832,
0.0020462202,
-0.0222266894,
-0.039592728,
0.0159439668,
-0.0236570779,
0.0491181687,
0.0250701718,
-0.0233379696,
0.0435962006,
0.0646411926,
0.0015481935,
0.0155417062,
0.0145428525,
-0.0258703064,
-0.0863819197,
0.0321950279,
-0.0835060924,
-0.0393343903,
0.0113507872,
-0.0470026731,
-0.0453884825,
-0.0055617271,
-0.0477279536,
-0.0126717938,
0.0078147016,
-0.0509113967,
0.0193220284,
0.0237076711,
-0.041542381,
0.0166240074,
-0.0021070139,
0.0701877475,
0.025262177,
0.0229596552,
0.0316110477,
-0.0680982023,
0.0228047948,
0.012909485,
0.0214683898,
-0.0093682436,
-0.0035188342,
-0.007148643,
-0.0728627369,
0.0222725887,
-0.0824251473,
0.0023594999,
-0.0083908439,
0.0023604999,
0.0426654182,
-0.0065315985,
-0.0113672996,
-0.0437091477,
-0.0662214458,
-0.003275296,
0.016108742,
-0.0099392254,
0.0695400983,
-0.0020428067,
0.0250431169,
-0.0321453735,
-0.014878395,
-0.0406814069,
0.053826455,
0.0487101711,
0.0275761038,
0.0022257764,
-0.020114677,
-0.0260858312,
-0.001296621,
-0.0231910534,
0.0302670784,
0.0319003426,
-0.0118199959,
0.0167924762,
0.0675560981,
-0.0052255592,
0.0079910643,
-0.007021416,
-0.0047457376,
-0.0467921719,
0.0142204231,
-0.0463610478,
0.0156421009,
-0.0162346605,
-0.0293961223,
0.0178865697,
0.0314227268,
0.0115517089,
0.0032663115,
-0.0188962389,
-0.0007616535,
0.03427561,
0.0120555321,
-0.0186577309,
0.0273140799,
0.0032791402,
0.0283500683,
0.0128905419,
-0.0209471099,
0.0675884187,
-0.0231343061,
-0.0322641209,
-0.0582223721,
-0.0100864572,
-0.0603429116,
0.0198275894,
0.0177948922,
0.0007070216,
-0.0181566812,
0.000281065,
-0.0540932044,
0.0121347327,
0.0096062087,
-0.0350233577,
-0.0058096312,
-0.0299114827,
0.0019499785,
-0.0127713177,
-0.0023701636,
-0.0167780053,
-0.0203180797,
-0.0206221677,
0.0143717248,
0.0203712564,
-0.0650888458,
-0.0105947489,
-0.0110177882,
0.006739873,
0.0012908982,
-0.0387504362,
-0.0068470538,
-0.0191807654,
0.0830523223,
0.0908810347,
0.0115022259,
0.0247919671,
-0.0176071413,
0.068455793,
0.0709982216,
0.0011748391,
0.006122245,
0.0074902419,
-0.0235734992,
-0.0132422326,
-0.0317002907,
0.0030954892,
-0.0172664784,
0.0539289974,
-0.0286099091,
-0.0113279261,
0.0768937841,
0.0302034486,
-0.0304427054,
-0.0255792588,
-0.0264064614,
0.0395701416,
0.0215470232,
0.0299836695,
-0.1307281405,
-0.0051820148,
-0.0461142026,
0.0387667753,
0.0166185722,
-0.0372143574,
-0.0075755864,
-0.0986153707,
0.0653081536,
-0.0150567871,
-0.0468205325,
-0.0048913322,
-0.0624277592,
-0.0093614776,
-0.0194785725,
-0.0187220629,
-0.0083014267,
-0.007349133,
0.0159642268,
0.0169067401,
-0.0182156544,
0.0255865827,
0.0212469622,
0.0220916755,
-0.0284226555,
-0.0236806963,
0.0485669859,
-0.005731713,
-0.0158773363,
0.0074138315,
-0.0206288341,
-0.0243571941,
-0.0200827513,
0.0813691616,
-0.0061970516,
-0.0168140773,
-0.0381093733,
0.0701424703,
-0.0332102887,
-0.0239570681,
0.0335250646,
0.0702397302,
-0.0292166397,
-0.0248039383,
-0.0788450614,
0.0295279641,
-0.0419473201,
0.0611857511,
0.0560091361,
-0.014048459,
-0.0650907308,
-0.0512397811,
0.0270750523,
-0.0521230511,
-0.0340869464,
-0.0100431433,
0.0069798264,
0.0300590359,
-0.0597017221,
-0.0319686085,
0.0439631455,
0.0151554355,
-0.0294787902,
-0.0098196436,
0.0039318134,
-0.027559923,
-0.057940755,
0.0101376371,
-0.0205367543,
0.0208433922,
-0.0304688029,
-0.0224163979,
0.0455486402,
0.0190585218,
-0.0508659519,
0.0121194338,
-0.0421794318,
-0.0393297412,
-0.0296444185,
0.0211925302,
0.0153136468,
0.0395457,
-0.0176385902,
-0.0004163029,
0.0718176961,
0.0527301431,
0.0026841399,
-0.0421870723,
0.0104221683,
0.0288930647,
-0.021563191,
-0.0156504624,
-0.0303952489,
-0.0097356737,
-0.0104951467,
0.0203671437,
-0.064704515,
-0.0682042316,
-0.0100276889,
0.0395755582,
0.0186670125,
0.035366822,
-0.0066774669,
-0.0067827241,
0.009382572,
-0.0209484454,
-0.0245830771,
-0.0163424127,
-0.0045949873,
0.001830913,
-0.041193407,
0.0074751703,
-0.0286411066,
-0.0429732352,
0.0218831021,
-0.0692834407,
0.0164325703,
0.063609764,
-0.0080645699,
0.0318125896,
-0.0133219743,
-0.0316471122,
-0.0233831666,
0.0063823368,
0.0557735749,
0.0384360813,
0.0664340258,
0.0309415963,
-0.0182088241,
0.0227603521,
0.0206040591,
-0.14058806,
-0.0581168458,
-0.0130636664,
0.0294224769,
0.0202905405,
0.0311107188,
0.0200093854,
0.0056487159,
-0.0214189552,
-0.0142603554,
0.0396363921,
0.0115998471,
0.0008671638,
0.1035320535,
0.0325496048,
-0.0112208482,
-0.0157069843,
0.0660318136,
0.0249548852,
0.0280881356,
0.0115958927,
-0.0071805143,
-0.0510295592,
-0.027412666,
-0.0312697701,
0.0180165954,
0.0337195806,
0.0174701139,
-0.0666740015,
-0.0754674971,
0.0377293415,
0.0179896131,
-0.0155427242,
0.0011959847,
0.0445101634,
0.0036844048,
0.0295454729,
-0.0293217618,
-0.0459108725,
0.0943134129,
-0.0379364155,
-0.0627281368,
-0.022700768,
-5.962245101e-33,
-0.0055808974,
-0.0720726326,
0.02308576,
0.0288423132,
0.003476281,
-0.0052501839,
-0.0376249552,
-0.0151198339,
-0.0410113968,
0.0341246761,
-0.0031847402,
0.0171455685,
-0.0086410707,
0.0242075864,
-0.0269817319,
-0.0619252883,
-0.0068703489,
-0.0160173737,
-0.0162731819,
0.0668100789,
0.0476316214,
0.0122467037,
0.0331083648,
-0.0876564831,
0.0423232801,
-0.0220527165,
0.036556758,
-0.0012889699,
-0.0441606827,
0.080410935,
-0.0221410617,
0.0322555602,
0.0183768962,
-0.0190612916,
-0.0040028361,
0.0223088898,
-0.0699963942,
-0.0477791354,
0.0005506715,
0.0165591612,
-0.0618047826,
-0.0092603136,
0.03842761,
-0.0023313044,
0.0259927046,
-0.0601860881,
0.066968672,
-0.0093435813,
-0.0344799422,
-0.0127438642,
0.0061751669,
0.0177281499,
-0.0529242642,
-0.016354017,
-0.033064574,
0.0978124663,
0.0207439642,
0.071802333,
-0.0461246669,
0.0568192713,
-0.0275594629,
-0.0398115329,
0.0194491185,
-0.0024858678,
0.0511952713,
0.031186549,
0.0135308206,
-0.0326082483,
-0.000531877,
0.0159399621,
-0.0214966685,
0.0746210143,
0.0796618313,
0.030348327,
0.0183561984,
0.031828288,
-0.0643205121,
0.0422758795,
-0.0249307211,
0.0176010448,
-0.0259112101,
-0.0265202783,
0.0029009252,
-0.0199195351,
-0.0316263884,
-0.0181430858,
-0.0196044575,
-0.0004328646,
0.0138681773,
-0.0605184659,
-0.0115763219,
0.0300821122,
0.0247145202,
-0.0546736494,
-0.0397663191,
0.0466591641,
-0.0013455679,
0.0432831272,
0.0275141038,
0.0025682875,
-0.0588008314,
0.0222501978,
0.0214083586,
-0.0061386437,
0.0184973516,
0.024622269,
0.0254019983,
-0.025998421,
-0.0510013029,
-0.0190323796,
-0.0326477475,
-0.0145572312,
-0.0339441672,
0.018662557,
0.0084392764,
0.0279262587,
-0.0273705106,
0.0592813231,
0.003492523,
0.0572632104,
-0.026398195,
-0.0064916699,
-0.0271012057,
0.0293546319,
-0.0273200274,
-0.007372295,
-0.0051778685,
0.0302784909,
-0.0057028844,
-0.0570440777,
-0.0013632568,
0.012531844,
2.561e-7,
0.0873996019,
0.026469212,
0.0471850075,
0.0276351608,
0.0304896086,
0.0146005424,
-0.0100372732,
0.0086814519,
0.0178211257,
0.0109524438,
-0.0029377409,
0.00127525,
0.0066352333,
0.0491193756,
-0.1025324762,
-0.0290324911,
-0.0785170719,
-0.0353013873,
-0.0485519692,
0.0242287982,
0.0650042221,
0.0393709056,
-0.0179124232,
-0.0057157045,
0.0025322405,
-0.0032255899,
0.0546731763,
-0.0155783687,
0.0120033063,
0.0209587943,
0.0007943406,
-0.0076420573,
0.0324249938,
0.0090107881,
-0.0093800994,
0.0051435572,
0.0165613703,
0.0277581736,
0.0283982269,
-0.048919864,
0.0298600439,
-0.015234462,
0.0441135876,
-0.0442718752,
0.0650249049,
-0.0357967839,
-0.0690385327,
-0.021672871,
-0.0635137409,
-0.0128335319,
0.0608463474,
-0.0351176746,
-0.0073416955,
0.018878499,
0.0096745314,
-0.0089728255,
0.0387517735,
-0.0237731077,
-0.0166154858,
0.0058886101,
-0.0178030897,
-0.0558623299,
0.0092084147,
-0.0230147298,
0.0038008962,
0.0141005712,
-0.0175083093,
2.51238752e-34,
0.0502587333,
-0.0108511243,
0.016975658,
0.0335583724,
0.0287960786,
-0.0489469506,
0.0361376852,
-0.0073519652,
0.048918087,
-0.1020282656,
-0.0152666662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03311v1 | CrossTalk: Intelligent Substrates for Language-Oriented Interaction in Video-Based Communication and Collaboration | 2023-08-07T05:40:01 | 2023-08-07T05:40:01 | Haijun Xia, Tony Wang, Aditya Gunturu, Peiling Jiang, William Duan, Xiaoshuo Yao | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite the advances and ubiquity of digital communication media such as
videoconferencing and virtual reality, they remain oblivious to the rich
intentions expressed by users. Beyond transmitting audio, videos, and messages,
we envision digital communication media as proactive facilitators that can
provide unobtrusive assistance to enhance communication and collaboration.
Informed by the results of a formative study, we propose three key design
concepts to explore the systematic integration of intelligence into
communication and collaboration, including the panel substrate, language-based
intent recognition, and lightweight interaction techniques. We developed
CrossTalk, a videoconferencing system that instantiates these concepts, which
was found to enable a more fluid and flexible communication and collaboration
experience. | [
0.0835122392,
-0.0089159785,
-0.0290983133,
0.030562114,
-0.0143808573,
-0.010483359,
0.058408197,
0.0391869843,
0.0200471953,
-0.038024351,
-0.0409147777,
-0.0178609304,
0.0280453097,
0.0373006761,
0.0357888527,
-0.0606823228,
0.0308663379,
-0.0086251535,
0.0529140681,
0.0412346497,
0.0616491698,
0.0161732528,
-0.0463049561,
0.0377281047,
-0.0839380324,
-0.0155555354,
-0.0538735017,
0.0107904142,
-0.0168800689,
0.0270235818,
-0.0204403419,
0.0339244008,
0.0071328217,
0.0408252291,
0.0000019395,
-0.0409798771,
0.0345615,
-0.0363630801,
-0.0346346013,
-0.0108690104,
0.0218715705,
0.0087570567,
-0.0037300633,
0.0022586819,
-0.0338184498,
0.0168315321,
0.0725619793,
0.0015182846,
0.0206814818,
-0.0259508882,
-0.0369383469,
0.0330108739,
-0.0111766644,
0.0243431143,
0.0248088371,
-0.0045981645,
-0.0400425345,
0.0112331975,
0.0412836708,
0.0078641577,
0.0031141967,
0.0273877718,
-0.0216513127,
-0.0616459213,
0.0008640319,
0.0220940001,
-0.018047737,
-0.1007069647,
-0.0216904134,
0.0483258888,
0.0408688113,
0.0559738688,
-0.0114414087,
0.0089045847,
0.0256453771,
0.0541040562,
-0.0095856311,
-0.03764439,
-0.0169980265,
-0.0682746992,
-0.0337203033,
0.0257490817,
-0.0152027002,
0.00054394,
0.0314431675,
0.0175220594,
0.0180801991,
0.0187373552,
-0.0019748423,
-0.0021346433,
0.07779672,
-0.0523277782,
0.0120785581,
0.0328363664,
-0.0459490046,
0.0120407697,
0.0086708106,
-0.0121062752,
-0.0215684101,
-0.0368487909,
-0.019931145,
0.0317172036,
-0.0100053493,
0.0190156586,
0.0557238832,
-0.0019933078,
0.0053041792,
-0.0467575677,
0.009909356,
0.0064116092,
-0.0113911377,
-0.0406475551,
-0.0661534593,
0.0313971452,
-0.0793925449,
-0.0496428832,
0.0041028704,
0.0688468143,
-0.0216167402,
0.0157479681,
-0.0375728905,
0.0071116118,
0.0031646783,
0.0110648638,
-0.0240469109,
0.0448721461,
-0.0411229916,
0.033874847,
0.0043068202,
-0.1029822081,
0.0263272636,
0.028307965,
0.0008145053,
-0.0039250068,
-0.0202559363,
0.0870901272,
-0.0205406472,
-0.0319003351,
0.0254734624,
-0.0498284064,
-0.0009527999,
0.0094606848,
0.0037588743,
-0.0181550588,
0.0340362489,
0.0331516899,
-0.0319437459,
-0.01745704,
0.0356687307,
0.005427456,
-0.015321197,
0.0558614135,
-0.0571652986,
0.0276324525,
0.0916440561,
0.0387225635,
-0.0119324476,
0.0404253118,
0.0137253171,
0.0202782992,
0.0460667759,
0.0159606393,
0.0184054635,
0.0207928699,
-0.0600991696,
-0.0177553724,
-0.0023551495,
-0.0128398687,
0.0122195603,
-0.0000509092,
-0.0610103644,
0.0183198564,
-0.0331656709,
0.0177339539,
0.0585994311,
0.0560417697,
-0.0239982083,
0.0186077952,
0.0266030617,
0.042562671,
-0.0201809686,
-0.0005713999,
0.0279882159,
0.0725915879,
0.0066966158,
-0.014699433,
0.0043770811,
-0.0040302482,
-0.0536530316,
-0.0481341705,
-0.0053855651,
-0.00546879,
0.0488010198,
0.0123038702,
0.0126294782,
0.0019125676,
0.007599494,
0.0490792766,
-0.0368353091,
-0.0716711134,
0.0047845631,
-0.0238553211,
0.0118761007,
0.099130556,
-0.0012570632,
0.0107627669,
-0.0531239286,
-0.0005241977,
0.0489941053,
0.0264691561,
0.0659649894,
-0.0002698072,
0.0108883232,
-0.0043453514,
-0.0033564374,
0.0050751655,
-0.0211393218,
0.0476089008,
-0.0433699898,
0.0302133113,
-0.0134405605,
0.0445844494,
0.0375814214,
-0.00713812,
0.0412971266,
0.0197358727,
-0.0470733903,
0.042188175,
0.0148235671,
0.0505814254,
0.0063977535,
-0.0172624849,
0.0248896461,
-0.0059134061,
-0.0074669756,
0.0914473087,
0.0154622402,
0.045620773,
0.0189315658,
-0.060110271,
0.0161067788,
-0.0267541762,
0.0483384803,
0.0001189433,
0.1064995751,
-0.023903206,
0.0538605899,
-0.0368972458,
0.0111917807,
-0.0188595839,
-0.0011072175,
0.0447011627,
-0.0056302003,
0.0112417201,
-0.0096362997,
0.0170219913,
0.0351311006,
0.0522797182,
-0.0209668167,
0.036766082,
0.0466711,
-0.0241542011,
-0.0016601044,
0.0051400852,
0.025018299,
-0.0290229358,
-0.031337861,
-0.0969981998,
-0.0476328544,
-0.0201239083,
-0.0309931263,
0.0075312559,
0.0392895378,
-0.0059399572,
-0.0412371643,
-0.0114287008,
0.0370870568,
0.0040036687,
-0.0037321143,
0.0070851082,
-0.001299147,
-0.0134192687,
-0.0019388879,
0.0094341487,
0.0199724231,
0.0198340751,
0.0391518138,
-0.0637027249,
-0.0385900512,
-0.0327666625,
-0.0434736125,
-0.0097594364,
-0.0217274129,
-0.0433811098,
0.0604184419,
0.0146487514,
-0.025862053,
-0.0104060639,
0.0139269466,
0.0287169795,
0.0189991593,
-0.0580926836,
-0.0117698917,
0.0193946697,
0.0110312514,
0.0327239856,
-0.0028040095,
0.0040581124,
0.0086473711,
-0.0128611708,
-0.0236788262,
0.0592855811,
-0.0418012552,
0.0099055003,
0.0079552745,
-0.0433100685,
-0.004313976,
-0.0642517954,
-0.026133962,
0.0479395464,
0.0107304025,
-0.0231511127,
0.0189918354,
-0.0253181811,
-0.0703134015,
0.017997412,
-0.014193004,
-0.0083712367,
0.0422341786,
-0.0923774689,
0.0208948143,
-0.0270171389,
-0.0573759712,
-0.009063012,
0.0086001186,
0.0053798715,
-0.034124814,
-0.0282851402,
-0.088647604,
-0.0244303495,
0.0135607561,
0.022382468,
-0.0007459343,
0.0250798892,
-0.0473196991,
-0.0220677089,
0.0360018164,
0.0044104122,
-0.0192716531,
0.0509200022,
0.0240482707,
0.0028407325,
0.0286839213,
-0.0074250172,
-0.0104389125,
-0.007588068,
0.0009606844,
0.0256699696,
-0.064293392,
0.015196071,
0.0455644913,
0.0244836025,
-0.0642492324,
-0.0690130815,
0.0210417043,
0.0392591842,
0.0903725028,
0.0349038057,
-0.0607119314,
0.0147545747,
0.0869698972,
0.0091707362,
0.018065162,
0.0725693554,
0.0073050959,
-0.0993813202,
-0.0196921099,
-0.0497900099,
-0.010517518,
0.0180893578,
0.0093835471,
-0.0662955865,
-0.0200210307,
-0.010917333,
-0.0354842618,
0.0107040079,
0.0046385466,
-0.0151130352,
-0.0397741906,
0.0211734436,
0.0048448117,
-0.0605866387,
-0.0089474237,
0.0197837036,
0.043726854,
0.039061252,
0.0194789395,
-0.0301196743,
-0.0084302388,
-0.0208951626,
0.0083842985,
-0.0741410255,
-0.0067840028,
-0.0113632753,
-0.0047503081,
0.0526616275,
0.0353278331,
0.0544986501,
0.0270028636,
-0.07537321,
-0.0303943269,
-0.0378167778,
0.0382594131,
-0.056925334,
0.0378135927,
0.0002764775,
0.0048803403,
-0.0127066681,
-0.0013306576,
0.0151764983,
0.0016085283,
0.0197782181,
0.029186774,
-0.0564224757,
0.0321036205,
-0.0047227936,
0.0385043956,
0.0521246903,
0.0244474709,
-0.0000195072,
-0.0536778159,
-0.008986013,
-0.0215178747,
0.0059005478,
0.0276670251,
-0.0529041961,
-0.0375848487,
0.0062592323,
-0.0535542071,
-0.0273795482,
-0.0540801957,
0.0682844818,
0.0114845373,
0.0210440867,
0.0309614558,
-0.0282729305,
0.0499550626,
-0.0059133465,
-0.0214512274,
0.0367539637,
0.0140727293,
-0.0180671234,
-0.0336228535,
-0.0432737693,
-0.0806264654,
0.0575226396,
0.0275850743,
0.0436545834,
-0.0522151031,
-0.0380015261,
0.0170072168,
0.0241931882,
0.0490456447,
-0.01193438,
-0.0151643418,
-0.0313034207,
-0.0077822912,
-0.0312350951,
-0.0249103587,
0.0190600771,
0.0077248933,
-0.0055433088,
0.0110280421,
-0.0245272387,
-0.0143508986,
0.0001426323,
0.0079754656,
-0.0978118256,
-0.1257847399,
0.0048895855,
0.0168692209,
-0.0009934248,
-0.0539779291,
-0.0119137717,
0.013793868,
-0.0042670155,
-0.0318498649,
0.0388031043,
-0.061943274,
-0.0071724486,
-0.0511937551,
0.0005903731,
0.0489794649,
0.0387017988,
-0.0297066569,
-0.027154481,
-0.0271654557,
0.0298364814,
-0.0630446374,
0.0026251376,
-0.0258442983,
0.0359598324,
0.0496327654,
0.0275136549,
0.0020665638,
0.0199119207,
-0.0000447863,
0.1129109785,
-0.0063755028,
-0.0654955581,
0.031077005,
0.0633134544,
-0.0064019933,
-0.0346862487,
0.061062295,
0.1046749055,
0.0182866994,
-0.0069233389,
-0.025468152,
-0.0301816314,
0.0202971194,
0.0012446317,
0.0541030318,
-0.0035117471,
-0.0651468635,
-0.0090565439,
0.0052732131,
-0.0279303398,
-0.0186662953,
-0.002195318,
-0.0785493478,
-0.0319377147,
-0.0199811477,
-0.0301671587,
-0.0419247486,
0.0063533485,
0.0353125297,
0.030520685,
-0.0355935283,
0.0091430685,
-0.0850458071,
-0.0522534773,
-0.0467965677,
-0.0261563472,
0.0248628091,
-0.0434789881,
0.0392696336,
0.062100362,
0.0157472603,
-0.0181846786,
-0.0238307957,
-0.033816997,
-0.0511904918,
0.0336285494,
-0.0690508783,
-5.214618204e-33,
-0.0126170674,
-0.0451676175,
0.0353431404,
0.0782839134,
-0.0260289796,
0.0008352091,
-0.0146841276,
0.0446518436,
-0.0281942561,
-0.0324556157,
0.0124500832,
0.0104631986,
-0.0072960183,
-0.0496235415,
0.0006360419,
0.0246019401,
0.0402981564,
-0.0128499828,
0.0064008343,
0.0154153006,
0.0163627919,
-0.0034928476,
-0.0060463315,
-0.1314892918,
0.0017422272,
0.0177685041,
-0.0080455039,
-0.0058323718,
0.0444383994,
-0.023997521,
-0.0182960574,
0.0167924222,
0.0051400014,
-0.0123741543,
0.0156942606,
0.0892706662,
-0.0194518305,
-0.0517702214,
0.0303665362,
0.0479617827,
-0.0382126682,
-0.0170081835,
-0.0372187383,
-0.0023373812,
-0.0527421013,
0.0141447345,
0.0213139579,
0.0160854086,
-0.031368617,
0.0349243693,
-0.0576796494,
-0.01375408,
-0.0190609694,
-0.0323792249,
0.013597101,
0.0198895149,
0.0101015996,
-0.0847953558,
-0.0449884571,
0.0597665645,
-0.0713189095,
-0.0403413996,
0.0662918091,
0.0110359639,
0.035302192,
0.0241684821,
0.0191654861,
-0.0110709248,
0.0014866426,
0.0047237775,
0.0137140602,
0.0492285714,
0.0193797369,
0.0174486879,
-0.0411134548,
-0.0735127255,
0.0076867533,
0.0182791334,
0.0196878724,
-0.0033202739,
-0.0152363405,
0.0201657992,
-0.0379293188,
0.0309654679,
0.0134176631,
0.0450240448,
-0.0180410054,
-0.079635255,
0.0218237191,
-0.0085231531,
0.0243312567,
-0.0201341324,
0.0280805118,
0.0035331524,
0.0354403108,
0.0123560987,
0.010695464,
0.0214550216,
0.0255850255,
-0.0317559987,
0.0222375765,
0.0032034717,
-0.0069325706,
0.0270354878,
0.0349581465,
0.0113941897,
-0.0143659217,
0.0399706177,
0.0220980719,
-0.0298708044,
-0.0006216262,
0.0557030998,
0.0293780845,
-0.0286871288,
0.0288287941,
0.0035038628,
-0.0554679744,
-0.0146225002,
-0.0115899164,
-0.0097059049,
-0.0314814039,
-0.0538187586,
-0.0438683853,
-0.0106033692,
-0.0865097791,
-0.0290281158,
-0.0286713894,
-0.0231949333,
0.0193636734,
-0.0233008843,
-0.0428167433,
-0.0072604278,
2.846e-7,
-0.0568272695,
0.0150287468,
-0.0454941466,
0.0217953958,
0.0235825703,
0.0226786193,
0.042818971,
0.0186725259,
0.0269142538,
0.0042271977,
0.048600547,
0.0375789367,
0.0370237827,
-0.0083507849,
-0.0786670819,
-0.0216120798,
0.0294650849,
-0.0276306476,
-0.0180174392,
0.0741160661,
0.0719901621,
-0.0036323655,
0.0028378139,
-0.0008468645,
-0.0096988734,
-0.0207308326,
-0.0053802035,
-0.0504253618,
0.0049587502,
-0.0223376174,
0.0321862772,
-0.0163407419,
-0.0389467403,
0.059007749,
-0.0202544797,
-0.0254346561,
-0.0137903569,
0.0198843405,
-0.0459424779,
-0.0062691984,
-0.0131639838,
0.0185815301,
-0.0040984889,
0.0050405888,
0.0019300398,
0.0118678808,
0.0025256451,
0.0289602149,
-0.0162692517,
-0.0187840499,
-0.0196727756,
-0.0028986011,
0.0066460688,
0.0210677944,
-0.0368043408,
-0.0229460318,
0.0043775728,
-0.0026197438,
0.0716378391,
0.0090103121,
-0.0031385468,
-0.0335962586,
-0.0353598557,
-0.0069900295,
-0.0008273217,
0.0213177241,
-0.0094401399,
1.559166753e-34,
-0.0442905538,
-0.0014903898,
0.0017145666,
0.0464640893,
0.0494636074,
0.0354671367,
0.0186926294,
0.0627253577,
0.050891228,
0.0010943135,
0.002831501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03303v1 | LoRA-FA: Memory-efficient Low-rank Adaptation for Large Language Models Fine-tuning | 2023-08-07T05:12:27 | 2023-08-07T05:12:27 | Longteng Zhang, Lin Zhang, Shaohuai Shi, Xiaowen Chu, Bo Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The low-rank adaptation (LoRA) method can largely reduce the amount of
trainable parameters for fine-tuning large language models (LLMs), however, it
still requires expensive activation memory to update low-rank weights. Reducing
the number of LoRA layers or using activation recomputation could harm the
fine-tuning performance or increase the computational overhead. In this work,
we present LoRA-FA, a memory-efficient fine-tuning method that reduces the
activation memory without performance degradation and expensive recomputation.
LoRA-FA chooses to freeze the projection-down weight of $A$ and update the
projection-up weight of $B$ in each LoRA layer. It ensures the change of model
weight reside in a low-rank space during LLMs fine-tuning, while eliminating
the requirement to store full-rank input activations. We conduct extensive
experiments across multiple model types (RoBERTa, T5, LLaMA) and model scales.
Our results show that LoRA-FA can always achieve close fine-tuning accuracy
across different tasks compared to full parameter fine-tuning and LoRA.
Furthermore, LoRA-FA can reduce the overall memory cost by up to 1.4$\times$
compared to LoRA. | [
0.0382962897,
0.0628248528,
-0.0137621956,
0.0498357564,
0.0367989168,
0.0309183504,
-0.0095321294,
-0.0196940769,
-0.0192924161,
-0.0217614956,
-0.0883666202,
-0.015986817,
0.0225058533,
0.0050107124,
0.0303737633,
-0.0347859636,
0.0275806785,
-0.0416631773,
-0.0073046489,
-0.0055282377,
-0.0002942519,
0.0283699222,
-0.0042114654,
0.0122112092,
0.0758737326,
-0.002404097,
-0.0139001198,
0.0180906709,
0.0256350134,
0.0021513512,
0.0163176749,
0.0631444901,
0.0158733856,
0.0478774942,
0.000001908,
-0.0381523371,
-0.0096835652,
-0.022902634,
-0.0208356045,
0.0501065105,
0.0358631164,
0.00004815,
-0.0232732333,
0.0304864626,
-0.010003387,
-0.0237524696,
0.0577475689,
0.0134371147,
0.0107038962,
0.0839501396,
-0.0171685871,
-0.0313250795,
-0.000612355,
-0.0701369941,
-0.038309861,
-0.0819435269,
0.0314713456,
-0.027526034,
-0.0486437641,
-0.0137528991,
-0.0269981995,
0.0112103904,
-0.0095833382,
-0.0086423764,
-0.033042714,
0.0117502902,
-0.0581989586,
-0.0072430912,
0.0039597265,
0.0809679925,
-0.0727622658,
-0.0218129475,
0.0305909067,
-0.0130319465,
0.0004770188,
-0.0731311813,
-0.0235415958,
-0.007474063,
0.036218524,
0.0306314267,
-0.0054925508,
-0.0452556834,
0.0475847088,
0.01423069,
-0.0464606285,
-0.0023981403,
0.0366155021,
-0.0048533753,
-0.0177110936,
-0.0133198202,
-0.0280098468,
-0.0196927469,
0.0004391788,
0.0036656191,
-0.0319558084,
-0.0020191018,
-0.085150294,
-0.0519858375,
0.0054393783,
-0.0335900821,
0.0851585492,
0.0480701774,
-0.0135213342,
0.0500417836,
-0.0645557269,
0.0567597002,
-0.0239758566,
0.0273505822,
-0.0363812745,
0.0077828118,
0.0021465223,
0.0386514366,
-0.0291900728,
0.0110149123,
-0.0510569401,
-0.0128731793,
-0.0550385751,
0.021914199,
0.0057729767,
-0.0111824637,
-0.0194127578,
-0.0057929959,
-0.0289458781,
-0.0197598208,
0.0074935397,
0.0842648968,
0.0117546124,
0.0277652312,
-0.0280283913,
-0.0454742499,
-0.0332488492,
0.0069194296,
0.0571325161,
-0.0185173787,
0.0441314653,
0.0148777002,
-0.0265752431,
-0.0603154637,
-0.0412954614,
0.0484932922,
0.0014043967,
-0.0824094564,
0.010744662,
-0.0250716265,
0.0304864086,
-0.0175297242,
0.0200760495,
-0.0272778459,
0.0091473497,
0.0131985489,
-0.0583454147,
0.0718162954,
0.0188059285,
-0.0186944157,
0.0090564517,
-0.0003105303,
0.0016341131,
0.0601580404,
0.0347247235,
0.0378089026,
-0.0079276552,
-0.0168242753,
-0.0462526865,
0.0453706831,
0.0236806851,
0.014460356,
-0.0219528396,
-0.0121837724,
0.0200807899,
0.0056240871,
0.0568580255,
0.0192725137,
-0.0132590942,
-0.0145003442,
0.0580501221,
0.0149364425,
0.0480489098,
0.0515620038,
-0.0058097718,
-0.0455558226,
0.0027076623,
-0.0339796729,
-0.0591231324,
0.0646067858,
-0.0584637485,
-0.0176524743,
0.0135037182,
0.0632962212,
-0.0349642485,
-0.0132624423,
-0.0168677717,
0.0048489054,
0.0052655209,
0.0117375366,
0.0305631869,
0.0055076908,
-0.0228984114,
0.0601441674,
0.0381695405,
-0.0376804955,
-0.0257001687,
-0.0621400699,
0.017780615,
0.0436126143,
0.0108207641,
-0.0130594233,
-0.0259382576,
0.0132609885,
0.0490735397,
0.0185553767,
0.0430946574,
0.0252623614,
0.0226121042,
-0.0795363188,
0.0206576958,
0.0059520723,
0.0099267801,
0.0175333619,
0.0053667314,
0.036543794,
0.0206486527,
-0.0085174376,
-0.0204996746,
0.0233711489,
-0.0142804161,
-0.0162306894,
0.0211203303,
-0.0038350064,
0.0166637488,
-0.0294576306,
0.0137701817,
-0.0162375215,
0.0352166258,
-0.0204691514,
0.0369906276,
-0.0386641026,
-0.0274180304,
0.0022384077,
0.030789528,
0.0487081856,
0.0413910821,
0.0529036708,
-0.0369538292,
-0.0443100855,
0.0396826006,
-0.0171236582,
0.0115572643,
-0.0273797642,
0.0470370874,
-0.0254214611,
0.0709538981,
-0.0319654085,
0.0205839612,
0.005897752,
0.0017601515,
0.0535266027,
0.0354165323,
0.0048809214,
-0.0167601649,
-0.0603736192,
0.0525568314,
0.0072497232,
0.0348958932,
-0.0200080089,
0.0195153579,
-0.02323265,
-0.0581884496,
-0.0757091492,
0.0230194796,
-0.032770142,
0.0333663672,
0.0384297818,
0.0387583114,
0.0073225456,
-0.0406232998,
-0.0133798737,
0.0476827845,
-0.0403194241,
0.0305068828,
-0.0225784853,
0.0028508822,
-0.0041182199,
-0.0512429513,
-0.0244533326,
0.0408476479,
0.0424776562,
-0.0252192449,
-0.0210618898,
-0.0538070798,
0.0039489865,
-0.0348935649,
0.0469936095,
-0.0201913752,
-0.0746653229,
-0.0385780707,
-0.014451324,
0.0367306769,
0.0607344247,
-0.0135228662,
-0.0024855207,
0.0932608694,
0.0198478308,
-0.0191066545,
0.0169633422,
0.0096718837,
-0.0573336929,
-0.0521545522,
-0.0002265715,
-0.0354386158,
0.0486138128,
-0.0283607822,
0.010834638,
-0.0465885997,
0.0033935236,
0.0041605388,
-0.0141365714,
-0.0088223713,
0.0246379934,
-0.04111173,
-0.020126434,
-0.0289798118,
-0.0158473272,
0.0247128326,
-0.0428907648,
-0.0235721245,
-0.0483293012,
-0.0233969688,
-0.0413401984,
0.0162172988,
0.0090253819,
0.0269899052,
-0.0319577754,
-0.0182025582,
-0.0255060662,
-0.0035347738,
0.0056075053,
-0.0276413001,
0.0416537225,
-0.0474633127,
0.0348506793,
-0.0627902523,
-0.0578586981,
0.0160250217,
-0.0137474667,
-0.0291723311,
0.0129434029,
-0.0051099695,
-0.0523267873,
-0.0190004203,
0.0079210456,
0.0240455028,
0.0872891545,
-0.0290105529,
0.0177623201,
-0.0378688388,
0.0292930901,
0.0662508458,
0.0861821622,
0.024338007,
0.0117000397,
0.0028320528,
0.0044181114,
0.0179492533,
0.0102301026,
-0.0446432978,
0.0332904272,
0.0473702848,
0.0341362618,
-0.0137464702,
0.0051757568,
0.037520472,
-0.0394186229,
-0.0226679277,
0.0708185136,
0.0027146647,
-0.0700452104,
-0.0088508176,
-0.0195157826,
0.0773403943,
0.0269670729,
0.036501959,
-0.0353083536,
-0.0345449559,
0.0134187518,
0.0256687775,
0.0125323748,
0.0037671346,
0.004191739,
-0.0991281345,
0.018744722,
0.018111974,
-0.0287835132,
-0.0347059146,
-0.0102292923,
0.0229551718,
0.0123311905,
0.0438067503,
0.0167833287,
-0.0192517824,
-0.0451156534,
0.0401242301,
0.0123893619,
-0.0490256548,
0.0150276693,
-0.0139862038,
0.0415749289,
0.0321226157,
0.0185536798,
0.0079306848,
-0.0409011841,
0.0420267843,
-0.0324906893,
-0.0137928538,
-0.0117928954,
0.0271734037,
0.0363841094,
-0.061965216,
0.0229914729,
0.0265447311,
0.0006469493,
-0.0171848349,
-0.0312995464,
0.0398936681,
0.0067432574,
-0.0058072619,
0.0300071016,
-0.0271470938,
-0.0410740413,
0.0332536288,
0.0378379226,
-0.0436220355,
0.000727244,
0.0089807799,
-0.0264985673,
-0.0432510301,
-0.0080385385,
0.0037605732,
-0.0315478593,
0.0029558097,
-0.0273378156,
0.0107917981,
0.0410335176,
0.0285652522,
-0.0295964442,
0.0050658137,
-0.0034885837,
0.0196594466,
-0.036147099,
0.0274566952,
-0.0546210445,
-0.0145949246,
-0.0292564481,
-0.0077906782,
0.0689254329,
0.0030594592,
0.0037674408,
-0.0003643408,
-0.0973303318,
-0.0563919581,
0.0182578135,
0.0416882224,
0.0176886804,
0.0263584983,
0.006049844,
-0.0847556889,
0.0461986251,
0.0192558784,
0.0085744802,
0.098630093,
0.0228861161,
-0.0526413359,
-0.0193706863,
0.0498127565,
-0.0759833232,
-0.0158852004,
0.0477888435,
0.043700818,
-0.0042732526,
-0.046401199,
-0.0207206123,
0.0207553133,
0.0218214076,
0.0302741416,
-0.0280203447,
-0.0209268015,
0.0702364743,
-0.0117164534,
0.0145865222,
-0.0290577225,
-0.024564188,
0.0247227475,
0.006033672,
-0.0296914354,
-0.0254530441,
0.0573066697,
-0.0024213623,
-0.0280589424,
0.0069459039,
0.0101988055,
-0.0024385306,
0.0573598556,
0.0239126422,
-0.0392857864,
0.0315682292,
0.0524151474,
0.0139396973,
-0.045444835,
-0.0065030842,
0.0113860592,
-0.0303725246,
-0.099327229,
0.0567378551,
-0.0156822708,
-0.0664661005,
-0.0395429097,
0.0131194238,
0.0671047643,
0.013593711,
0.0923579261,
0.0364600606,
-0.0320778191,
0.0018335318,
-0.0199306794,
-0.0091927396,
-0.002995718,
0.0195266455,
0.0034271316,
-0.0008728082,
0.0256995354,
0.0609994233,
0.0330485851,
0.0594823435,
-0.0203101896,
0.0241477136,
-0.0039464384,
-0.0297761206,
-0.0182948746,
0.0213976819,
-0.0080406442,
-0.0181908105,
0.0201233253,
-0.0577557981,
0.0081241028,
-0.0285018515,
0.0008584993,
-0.0522092357,
-0.001058889,
0.0347312205,
0.0086217541,
0.0046385941,
-0.002802318,
-0.0419707745,
0.0204721335,
-0.0178656727,
0.0142023405,
-6.62391581e-33,
-0.0417772494,
0.0325241685,
0.0260384455,
0.0043209638,
-0.0154740326,
-0.0109640947,
-0.0292178057,
0.0051560476,
-0.029207686,
-0.0187397208,
-0.0252819434,
0.0076984381,
0.0184103437,
0.0091636525,
0.0022521229,
0.0043529742,
0.0595555156,
-0.003905294,
-0.0250105187,
0.0364404991,
0.0117817279,
0.0223909058,
0.0382559486,
0.0036843207,
-0.0574537814,
0.0168700963,
-0.0500128381,
0.0015109336,
-0.0436921045,
0.0422802903,
-0.0386028811,
0.0506405346,
0.0180511456,
-0.011659489,
-0.0241973344,
0.0265266206,
-0.0964757651,
-0.0274386518,
0.0270124972,
0.0058032265,
-0.0075703566,
-0.0195399635,
0.0690839142,
0.0370453931,
-0.0056597949,
0.0088733733,
-0.0082595591,
-0.0408734754,
-0.029200064,
0.0051293168,
-0.0466700681,
0.0055366047,
0.009088872,
-0.0025461717,
0.0375262313,
-0.0052114287,
-0.0127282832,
0.0302713383,
-0.084941186,
-0.0389538147,
0.0152888093,
0.0970294029,
0.0304974373,
0.0484382585,
-0.028133167,
0.0252023246,
0.0092148324,
0.0150369862,
0.0475648865,
-0.023164466,
0.0729846805,
0.0108569888,
0.0471731611,
0.0187869426,
0.0283326451,
-0.0344256423,
-0.0730097592,
-0.0355936959,
0.0206196662,
0.0301371124,
0.0333324149,
0.0442818664,
0.0010864716,
-0.0189371742,
-0.0511769392,
-0.0035485693,
-0.0800464824,
0.0017082493,
0.0241796114,
0.0584201366,
-0.0201070346,
0.0076065417,
0.0270860493,
-0.0256645754,
0.0120099289,
-0.007851785,
-0.0010790027,
0.0224248637,
0.0080847312,
0.0218635444,
-0.0264754575,
-0.0456437729,
0.0201329906,
-0.0175136197,
0.0071208212,
-0.0152278924,
0.0365143344,
0.0303565096,
-0.0840692744,
-0.0115119424,
-0.0292842258,
0.0162570868,
0.0002162686,
0.0758573264,
-0.0220132191,
-0.02613643,
0.0124957282,
0.0421705395,
0.0285914056,
0.019807836,
0.0016900143,
-0.0264584236,
0.0440178066,
0.0299684368,
-0.0524240695,
0.0060727573,
-0.0317709595,
0.0562550984,
0.0277777612,
-0.0677304491,
-0.0189401247,
0.0212570708,
2.748e-7,
-0.0000805746,
0.0442496501,
-0.0376531407,
-0.0409269184,
0.0282360967,
0.0181888901,
-0.0103959031,
0.0374267325,
0.044502262,
0.0243862141,
0.0050152186,
-0.0015971018,
0.0333668776,
-0.0171500184,
-0.0647246763,
-0.0016765899,
-0.0786718354,
0.0326605178,
-0.0528781228,
-0.0636072159,
-0.0162084959,
0.1196004972,
0.0224885773,
-0.0257610753,
-0.0045085624,
-0.0198702831,
0.0504014902,
-0.0058866898,
0.0031088046,
-0.0009508737,
0.052801948,
0.0357970223,
-0.050352376,
-0.0223536398,
-0.0124424817,
0.0551436245,
-0.0192882437,
0.0658658221,
-0.0360916369,
-0.0090477718,
0.056861572,
0.0321954377,
-0.0102968654,
-0.046282772,
0.0697249994,
-0.0606673434,
-0.012734415,
-0.0253506955,
0.0125703961,
-0.0306113251,
0.0008965637,
-0.0341663882,
-0.0066565527,
0.0138929738,
0.026101945,
-0.0116469832,
-0.0542434677,
-0.1328630447,
-0.0007052755,
0.0202660374,
-0.0283162296,
-0.0229918659,
-0.0587648526,
-0.0500619784,
0.0208724011,
-0.0680793375,
0.038246613,
2.363971027e-34,
0.0254749879,
-0.0314301327,
0.0171979405,
0.0121431574,
0.0280344449,
-0.000715355,
0.0112835979,
0.0257505793,
-0.0120987156,
-0.1340854317,
-0.0187402237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03296v1 | Studying Large Language Model Generalization with Influence Functions | 2023-08-07T04:47:42 | 2023-08-07T04:47:42 | Roger Grosse, Juhan Bae, Cem Anil, Nelson Elhage, Alex Tamkin, Amirhossein Tajdini, Benoit Steiner, Dustin Li, Esin Durmus, Ethan Perez, Evan Hubinger, Kamilė Lukošiūtė, Karina Nguyen, Nicholas Joseph, Sam McCandlish, Jared Kaplan, Samuel R. Bowman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | When trying to gain better visibility into a machine learning model in order
to understand and mitigate the associated risks, a potentially valuable source
of evidence is: which training examples most contribute to a given behavior?
Influence functions aim to answer a counterfactual: how would the model's
parameters (and hence its outputs) change if a given sequence were added to the
training set? While influence functions have produced insights for small
models, they are difficult to scale to large language models (LLMs) due to the
difficulty of computing an inverse-Hessian-vector product (IHVP). We use the
Eigenvalue-corrected Kronecker-Factored Approximate Curvature (EK-FAC)
approximation to scale influence functions up to LLMs with up to 52 billion
parameters. In our experiments, EK-FAC achieves similar accuracy to traditional
influence function estimators despite the IHVP computation being orders of
magnitude faster. We investigate two algorithmic techniques to reduce the cost
of computing gradients of candidate training sequences: TF-IDF filtering and
query batching. We use influence functions to investigate the generalization
patterns of LLMs, including the sparsity of the influence patterns, increasing
abstraction with scale, math and programming abilities, cross-lingual
generalization, and role-playing behavior. Despite many apparently
sophisticated forms of generalization, we identify a surprising limitation:
influences decay to near-zero when the order of key phrases is flipped.
Overall, influence functions give us a powerful new tool for studying the
generalization properties of LLMs. | [
0.0425156951,
0.0708110854,
-0.0296819843,
0.0463505313,
-0.0166145135,
0.0168476589,
-0.0223607291,
0.0289826412,
-0.0656139106,
-0.0190591961,
-0.002512557,
-0.0889822766,
0.0038606867,
0.0329893269,
0.0534968674,
-0.0842432007,
0.0201347601,
-0.0707492083,
0.0062715779,
-0.0582107343,
-0.0170636661,
0.0197684653,
0.0182237849,
0.0656438097,
0.0081130443,
0.0013146116,
0.0020939461,
-0.0183670819,
0.0141376536,
0.0262528118,
-0.0000416215,
0.0253375582,
0.0435533524,
0.0286678951,
0.0000024128,
-0.0385122225,
-0.0141973719,
-0.0081326226,
0.0093300752,
0.0466974005,
0.0526555665,
-0.0023620122,
0.0171618611,
-0.0150346318,
-0.0278480258,
-0.0180261061,
0.033231467,
0.01923557,
0.0265608914,
0.0524621643,
-0.0011585882,
-0.0535455979,
0.0056692162,
-0.0253435932,
0.0586901978,
-0.0524217226,
0.0487582758,
-0.0287303496,
-0.0167003572,
-0.0024584306,
-0.0298830625,
0.0270616002,
-0.0217803828,
0.0039844303,
0.0285544507,
0.0341082066,
0.0179830566,
-0.0102648279,
0.0321142338,
0.0642066002,
-0.0117442412,
-0.0547870733,
0.0244340822,
-0.0175965969,
0.0199433267,
0.0974723026,
-0.0450358726,
-0.0114001343,
0.0319878608,
-0.0084650842,
0.040321786,
-0.0463043675,
0.0583901852,
0.0343388692,
-0.0520819947,
0.0700181797,
0.0285161175,
-0.0516438708,
0.0057019494,
-0.0204084441,
-0.0171846934,
-0.0395497046,
-0.0138236526,
-0.0062567824,
-0.0134033822,
0.0252159927,
-0.0114396513,
-0.0333980732,
0.005914839,
-0.0691706836,
0.0733064115,
0.0194819272,
0.0489983745,
0.0401511379,
-0.0318438783,
0.0313940421,
-0.0404592715,
0.0274200235,
-0.050710313,
0.0146317771,
-0.0521277115,
-0.0277724899,
-0.0067012836,
0.0202948619,
0.0056754439,
-0.003721776,
-0.021375481,
0.0419160761,
0.0004850141,
-0.0079913437,
0.0101890303,
0.0237649307,
0.031423904,
-0.0228004549,
-0.0034044245,
-0.0177249033,
-0.0336710624,
-0.0005246159,
-0.0357834883,
-0.0086672427,
0.0155131258,
-0.0319469012,
0.0220893063,
-0.0307882652,
0.041716665,
0.0354061536,
0.0010778451,
-0.0531194359,
0.0124410437,
-0.0047949101,
-0.0238531493,
-0.035512045,
-0.0022918724,
-0.0685072541,
0.0175903961,
0.0259546004,
-0.0085206693,
-0.0234077778,
-0.0125957839,
-0.0273102149,
-0.0865710527,
0.0464968309,
0.0355070941,
0.0312945098,
0.0504540913,
-0.0245039966,
-0.0003463629,
0.0897284374,
-0.0095619401,
-0.026272269,
0.043494653,
-0.0172762685,
-0.0332826413,
0.0657911822,
0.0268795379,
0.0322416089,
-0.0194692556,
-0.0030168088,
0.0160527732,
0.0263334289,
0.0152590694,
0.0216292161,
-0.0438596979,
-0.0416258983,
0.0471770167,
0.0543799661,
-0.0236755237,
0.0367934369,
0.0427330211,
0.0160308983,
-0.0002682348,
0.0005790016,
-0.0277821273,
-0.0361359119,
0.0187888872,
-0.0092214849,
-0.0013413718,
0.0088571915,
-0.0283755362,
-0.0283843428,
0.0054089986,
0.0026467817,
0.0162693318,
0.0113327596,
0.0718676001,
0.001736559,
-0.018083645,
0.0523295924,
0.0469241813,
-0.0580578558,
0.00607325,
-0.0311804097,
0.0307899658,
0.0342449509,
0.0308459643,
-0.0533431917,
-0.0423097536,
0.0146767423,
-0.0116167907,
-0.032438416,
0.0347928107,
-0.0256288256,
-0.0046701636,
-0.0301683694,
0.010331952,
0.0289876685,
0.0304373708,
0.0375893414,
-0.0127941174,
-0.0046633421,
0.0068205055,
-0.043649517,
-0.0608017929,
0.0247001108,
-0.0000530494,
-0.0521727502,
0.0270949416,
0.0055762795,
0.0429993756,
0.016916845,
-0.0104846442,
-0.015046183,
0.0289093293,
-0.0468462594,
-0.0282757543,
-0.0168630593,
-0.010887159,
0.0225095656,
0.0493364073,
-0.02791919,
-0.0010393225,
0.0021132063,
-0.021233378,
-0.0366966315,
0.0447214283,
-0.0138244163,
0.1087029427,
-0.0141906179,
0.0171691906,
-0.0450190827,
0.0096325362,
-0.0242805313,
0.0333751589,
-0.0337710828,
0.020338282,
-0.0430613197,
-0.0167431589,
-0.0379034542,
-0.0200583953,
-0.0326674506,
0.0284386873,
-0.0111462558,
-0.000561026,
0.0429548062,
-0.0404602364,
0.0158860348,
-0.0036568809,
-0.063824743,
-0.0420251004,
-0.0344764963,
0.0208942629,
0.0223059449,
0.0068555027,
-0.0089378571,
0.0285243932,
-0.0092618456,
-0.0369473174,
-0.0176972169,
0.0345439203,
-0.0066538323,
0.0062423479,
-0.0543467626,
-0.0216189157,
-0.0554696992,
-0.0329664089,
0.0991081968,
-0.0240822341,
-0.0012235274,
-0.0354524218,
-0.0048711882,
-0.0549839213,
0.0023731883,
-0.0529645793,
-0.0165893324,
0.0116804019,
-0.0402646102,
0.0161139257,
0.0773077309,
0.0304379109,
-0.0181247406,
0.0457714424,
0.0166487563,
-0.0493904948,
-0.0273129288,
-0.0545950979,
-0.0236314163,
-0.0712870881,
-0.0431851521,
0.0195057057,
0.0756744295,
-0.0271899439,
-0.0250702035,
-0.0564477332,
-0.0136707267,
-0.0244800635,
-0.0557189919,
-0.0532355271,
-0.0164708085,
-0.0343826711,
0.022966655,
0.0125356689,
-0.0344999209,
0.0568980686,
-0.0046116048,
-0.0068610781,
0.0177385975,
-0.0224952437,
-0.0105659096,
0.0292475577,
0.040617764,
0.0417821258,
-0.010761817,
-0.0179538615,
-0.0078989305,
-0.0139011089,
0.0566464514,
-0.0276382547,
0.0585216135,
-0.0255405083,
0.0124113765,
0.042775929,
-0.0500089936,
-0.0126776267,
-0.0297550969,
0.0094580855,
-0.0236077532,
0.0686886832,
-0.0630685762,
0.0018445081,
0.0080652107,
0.0358707048,
0.0017089015,
-0.0222335849,
-0.0072579528,
-0.0078802286,
-0.0099732429,
0.0498312265,
-0.0226491336,
-0.0034307418,
-0.0533560514,
0.0030046268,
0.039750237,
0.0331255011,
-0.0394372419,
-0.0178954173,
0.0248700399,
0.0553606711,
-0.0400878899,
-0.0456444174,
0.0155814337,
0.0006293334,
-0.0434282757,
-0.0079272715,
0.0729471818,
0.0313475914,
-0.0753727853,
0.0220017526,
0.0324876495,
0.0605460182,
0.0051212125,
0.0305692591,
-0.0612344444,
0.0212113652,
0.0211981554,
0.0147013133,
-0.030040659,
-0.0543129705,
0.0379539169,
-0.1016806215,
0.0123026147,
0.0159571543,
-0.0227924306,
-0.0051952605,
-0.0608964562,
-0.0078533711,
-0.0496201478,
-0.0125904363,
0.0050812997,
-0.0204287209,
0.0024402861,
0.0197834,
-0.0129639106,
-0.0644576102,
0.0087164054,
0.0018107775,
0.0050283917,
0.0328860767,
0.0113555985,
-0.0340345427,
-0.0207287725,
0.0086041028,
0.0416374058,
-0.0071458202,
-0.0314929411,
0.034911029,
-0.0195602681,
-0.0044599222,
0.0068561775,
0.0328911133,
-0.009636879,
0.0271799359,
-0.0196761787,
0.0908790827,
0.0035202564,
-0.0390193872,
0.0226017181,
-0.0677697062,
-0.0018132075,
0.0669126138,
0.0119395209,
-0.0707538873,
0.020545993,
-0.0196255744,
-0.0107226148,
0.0276706126,
-0.0707023963,
-0.0663262382,
0.0158302579,
0.0054980773,
-0.0507973805,
0.0443791933,
-0.0023547481,
0.0312743932,
-0.000830248,
0.0075956406,
0.0184656829,
-0.0148101412,
-0.0170576163,
0.0017805723,
-0.0025843673,
-0.0024871181,
-0.0412561446,
-0.0137412325,
0.0161581133,
-0.027871415,
-0.0526885688,
0.0054739364,
-0.0358875245,
-0.115631789,
0.0368746594,
0.0478269681,
0.0161576495,
0.0461561605,
0.0184935331,
-0.0722192675,
0.0914053097,
0.0200852118,
-0.0064194119,
0.0244262889,
0.0322383046,
-0.0511352383,
0.0109239044,
0.0425659753,
-0.0399249345,
-0.0064777099,
0.0156100839,
0.0005831456,
-0.0736602992,
-0.0265187621,
0.0074934289,
0.0435774736,
0.0501070842,
-0.0194702931,
-0.0353968069,
-0.0368879437,
0.0058768368,
-0.0057563786,
-0.0032056186,
-0.0196937118,
0.0186668877,
0.038625516,
0.012770609,
-0.0177633092,
-0.0044610328,
0.0029120105,
-0.0166128017,
-0.0477446094,
0.0346135832,
-0.0182202738,
0.0428455956,
0.0727540255,
0.0258351304,
0.0121177239,
0.0226353593,
-0.0069762766,
0.0113650849,
-0.0072022816,
-0.0079615954,
0.0212943796,
0.0264032315,
-0.0369443595,
0.0242790002,
-0.0949372798,
-0.0831225589,
-0.0103950687,
0.0104130404,
0.0547748245,
-0.0387716964,
0.0517811403,
-0.0215097927,
-0.0266136378,
-0.0024565388,
-0.0091967946,
0.0169072542,
-0.0025104182,
0.021772312,
0.0356138125,
-0.0267496575,
0.0493072756,
0.0686852336,
0.0102666188,
0.0295856353,
-0.0054759942,
-0.027583234,
-0.0078965984,
-0.0046514459,
0.0243804995,
0.0596678704,
-0.0442087017,
-0.0058545694,
-0.0432949997,
-0.0642189234,
-0.0201400425,
-0.0209099539,
-0.0267047212,
-0.0096350294,
0.0515282117,
0.0816776752,
-0.005053801,
-0.0015050712,
-0.0555245429,
-0.033224877,
-0.0421725884,
-0.0304660741,
0.0014781425,
-7.500376153e-33,
0.0302503537,
0.0337794945,
-0.0498962738,
0.0411689766,
0.0024997371,
0.0131584303,
0.0280329417,
0.0135488687,
-0.0198040474,
0.0241363924,
-0.0279533807,
0.0013298297,
-0.0099328002,
0.001462089,
0.0385307409,
-0.0134714432,
0.0500110909,
0.0265255962,
-0.0002714862,
0.0425943322,
0.0573589727,
0.0521779694,
0.0932023376,
-0.0900393873,
0.0380966291,
-0.0114097446,
-0.0003713263,
0.0155890575,
-0.0116868569,
0.0229310375,
-0.003042253,
0.032983087,
-0.0079036644,
-0.079504393,
-0.0144297713,
-0.0496483222,
-0.0421976633,
-0.0000218795,
0.0409010425,
-0.0098604849,
0.0133388201,
-0.0323652364,
0.0531092174,
0.0158888102,
-0.0251680445,
-0.0140333464,
0.0445745029,
0.0146487467,
-0.0445544571,
-0.0003425099,
-0.0319785401,
0.0233286247,
-0.0295629706,
0.0325610787,
0.0495737232,
0.0189147778,
-0.0079468172,
0.0379688889,
-0.0448405072,
0.0421659574,
0.0036399283,
0.0435845032,
0.0319097638,
0.0397828743,
0.0333184451,
0.03105128,
0.0328523926,
-0.0074067647,
-0.0238702632,
-0.0172197074,
0.0324885622,
0.0569515899,
-0.0122163957,
0.0244502202,
0.071643047,
-0.0419006124,
-0.055353146,
-0.0198926721,
0.0060821618,
0.0252758358,
0.0234229024,
0.006045721,
-0.0469055325,
-0.023235973,
-0.0540460534,
-0.0497335903,
-0.0095737185,
-0.0185488462,
-0.013490458,
0.0018912475,
-0.0363583937,
0.015302835,
0.0054315883,
-0.0384912603,
0.0026120881,
0.0095441425,
-0.0094058206,
0.0136241009,
0.0135032618,
-0.0025470902,
-0.0565237738,
-0.0404255018,
-0.0450394563,
-0.0624653697,
0.0195509493,
-0.0021023245,
0.0108349603,
0.0249012895,
-0.0492612943,
-0.0180837456,
0.0062475232,
-0.0405068323,
0.0084563391,
0.0424782634,
0.0699972659,
0.0061085373,
0.0126217259,
0.039241299,
0.0453911088,
0.0475524701,
-0.0116382139,
-0.0221159626,
-0.0337982662,
0.0248666108,
-0.0208842177,
-0.0311453696,
-0.0315156206,
0.0107934736,
0.0903136805,
-0.0602935292,
-0.029337205,
-0.0109688174,
3.32e-7,
0.0302090105,
0.0993448421,
-0.0505208932,
0.0425543971,
-0.0068807234,
0.0416017808,
0.0254750326,
0.0157508366,
0.0280194059,
-0.0226924475,
0.0561935566,
0.0322071277,
0.0397610106,
0.0186595432,
-0.0760333985,
-0.0202538315,
-0.1089757234,
0.0242769774,
-0.0379823558,
-0.0044524432,
-0.0188283175,
0.1054168567,
0.0481908247,
-0.017017033,
0.0318390615,
-0.0479413271,
0.079765372,
-0.0588755608,
0.0051597576,
0.0466171652,
0.0249092337,
-0.0025052479,
-0.0016855119,
0.0299475733,
-0.0291539021,
0.0424043052,
-0.0095907329,
0.0242718235,
0.0028407213,
0.0227428935,
0.0041639875,
-0.0239554085,
-0.0041311863,
-0.114534013,
0.089523077,
0.0198670216,
-0.0105029074,
-0.0369215272,
-0.0010372358,
-0.0092723081,
0.0592881553,
-0.0300939269,
0.0206272211,
0.0324685574,
0.0105756586,
-0.0109192673,
0.0181308202,
-0.0766300485,
0.0128668575,
0.0370043032,
-0.0249009691,
-0.0300338101,
-0.0210417286,
0.005621939,
0.0131503735,
-0.0051709223,
0.0162421279,
3.323352807e-34,
0.0413234979,
0.0132161779,
0.0170308687,
-0.0054780906,
0.0247520283,
-0.0217474531,
-0.0034782065,
0.0195437223,
0.0195577517,
-0.100077264,
-0.0105086751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03293v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03293v1 | Dialogue Systems Can Generate Appropriate Responses without the Use of Question Marks? -- Investigation of the Effects of Question Marks on Dialogue Systems | 2023-08-07T04:42:36 | 2023-08-07T04:42:36 | Tomoya Mizumoto, Takato Yamazaki, Katsumasa Yoshikawa, Masaya Ohagi, Toshiki Kawamoto, Toshinori Sato | cs.CL | cs.CL | When individuals engage in spoken discourse, various phenomena can be
observed that differ from those that are apparent in text-based conversation.
While written communication commonly uses a question mark to denote a query, in
spoken discourse, queries are frequently indicated by a rising intonation at
the end of a sentence. However, numerous speech recognition engines do not
append a question mark to recognized queries, presenting a challenge when
creating a spoken dialogue system. Specifically, the absence of a question mark
at the end of a sentence can impede the generation of appropriate responses to
queries in spoken dialogue systems. Hence, we investigate the impact of
question marks on dialogue systems, with the results showing that they have a
significant impact. Moreover, we analyze specific examples in an effort to
determine which types of utterances have the impact on dialogue systems. | [
0.0754133984,
0.0039792187,
-0.0332787856,
-0.0020376237,
-0.020048039,
0.001684909,
0.024970144,
0.0370164178,
0.0197803304,
-0.0117835067,
0.0011504758,
-0.0051872483,
0.0190388467,
0.0013478869,
0.0094681215,
-0.0465098545,
0.0602423474,
-0.0455843993,
-0.0067699994,
-0.0098870751,
0.0338534378,
-0.0051726294,
-0.030211756,
0.0426495261,
-0.0215294026,
0.005509661,
-0.072344467,
0.0420984216,
-0.0406679995,
-0.0143231954,
-0.0235198475,
0.03413276,
-0.0386383049,
0.0393916182,
0.0000014431,
-0.0543322116,
0.0100652296,
-0.0269937236,
-0.0687498674,
0.0074380175,
-0.014197439,
0.0662264749,
0.0131470636,
0.0607371405,
-0.02139025,
-0.011751215,
0.0574684963,
0.0586174428,
0.009821238,
0.0438708626,
-0.0075524976,
0.0091647487,
0.0101235313,
0.0193868782,
-0.0056403833,
-0.0250500832,
0.026091883,
-0.0052177054,
0.0246209055,
-0.0355607942,
0.0175562967,
0.0413930416,
-0.00541959,
-0.0336572751,
-0.051162973,
-0.0007225819,
-0.0580286942,
-0.0556151755,
-0.0505377203,
0.0480170324,
0.0411387421,
0.0027824899,
-0.0016251813,
0.0122968238,
0.0420530327,
0.0179580413,
-0.0405475385,
-0.0275316425,
-0.0249768384,
-0.0234337319,
-0.0408914983,
0.0468376093,
-0.0661081672,
-0.0184838809,
-0.0441562161,
0.0447352231,
0.0240656417,
-0.0319325998,
-0.0229648575,
-0.058356002,
-0.0046392074,
-0.0643622726,
0.0304425582,
0.0080957385,
-0.0415245853,
0.0125827398,
-0.0188224129,
-0.0157997515,
0.0223647766,
-0.0052642925,
-0.0235282537,
0.021329755,
-0.0262594409,
0.0273914747,
0.0345725268,
0.0553023741,
0.0082643973,
-0.0305203404,
-0.0275426973,
0.0104080001,
0.0001942936,
-0.0324618109,
-0.0757938251,
0.0396323912,
-0.0362026766,
-0.0047891797,
0.0083008278,
0.0386236869,
0.0556230247,
-0.0100101437,
-0.0230769664,
0.0312751122,
-0.0068378332,
0.0240505859,
-0.0289067198,
0.008149663,
-0.0470397957,
0.0363375954,
0.0153551688,
-0.0751768276,
0.0145234894,
0.026885245,
0.0686848611,
0.0073166876,
0.0077408892,
0.0262632202,
-0.0034657368,
-0.0144269476,
-0.0075958571,
-0.0108316382,
-0.0106766131,
-0.0511335768,
-0.0498978719,
-0.0056063696,
0.0082109412,
0.0301871561,
-0.031464804,
0.0459032506,
0.0216154344,
0.0299174357,
-0.0261818413,
0.0334133133,
-0.0245571565,
0.0309781693,
0.0644739494,
-0.0218537692,
0.0171420965,
0.014292133,
0.0434646979,
-0.0537479073,
0.0652001873,
-0.0335602164,
0.026842773,
0.0295668878,
-0.0138924168,
0.0012879107,
-0.0269344356,
0.0473214053,
-0.021505706,
0.0060974662,
-0.0336989611,
0.0763415098,
-0.0311845634,
0.0037895003,
0.0541944988,
0.1002285033,
-0.0282864887,
-0.053449899,
-0.01663878,
0.0117793633,
0.0172962975,
0.048509106,
0.0021636379,
-0.0452452414,
-0.0149053447,
0.0170657486,
0.057124611,
-0.0325610526,
-0.0230102055,
-0.0491004251,
-0.000594326,
0.0242259987,
-0.0054627061,
0.0200985782,
-0.0153535949,
0.0100722872,
-0.0429533646,
-0.0256376453,
-0.040569257,
-0.0601944104,
-0.0243974011,
-0.0318715572,
0.0375675224,
0.0424137637,
0.0319412909,
0.0148440469,
-0.0315260664,
-0.0297945775,
-0.0095072212,
0.0390933752,
0.0203136168,
-0.0153024653,
0.0145191327,
-0.0099693341,
0.0375453457,
0.0707787797,
-0.0175966248,
0.0374827832,
-0.0596491545,
0.006134884,
-0.0169269089,
-0.005611469,
0.0490929075,
-0.0253178272,
0.0528826788,
-0.0326689221,
0.0055511137,
-0.0076322756,
0.0034267155,
0.028577745,
-0.0266764276,
0.0095020095,
0.0325930044,
0.0135387117,
-0.0062681078,
0.06503883,
-0.0313528702,
-0.0206946507,
0.0027391089,
-0.0038544373,
-0.0146721527,
0.0040503461,
0.0540020242,
-0.0845124498,
0.0080214795,
-0.0478201918,
0.0338636748,
-0.0327995867,
0.0318096317,
0.010686839,
0.009111858,
-0.0654300973,
-0.0331516787,
0.0298366938,
0.0289364923,
0.0037159228,
0.010378723,
0.0350954309,
-0.0422975346,
-0.0433595106,
0.0943074003,
-0.0519334003,
0.01481744,
0.0161001682,
-0.0306068696,
-0.055093471,
0.033044897,
-0.1092466712,
0.0334248841,
-0.0017109399,
0.0191027522,
0.0136548895,
0.0390327722,
-0.0458057597,
-0.0326598957,
-0.0302272439,
-0.0336851142,
0.0281678773,
0.0110996915,
0.0315927938,
0.0326670781,
-0.0325578488,
-0.0426942036,
0.0002656251,
0.0028755434,
0.0201105624,
0.0008145864,
-0.0399192609,
-0.0230408851,
0.0145141929,
0.0098993201,
0.0308232456,
0.0087887105,
-0.0557392985,
0.0504324846,
0.0056424933,
0.026976293,
0.030455485,
0.0520286039,
-0.002263248,
-0.0307920258,
-0.0390395075,
-0.0686263368,
0.034831401,
-0.0228811894,
0.0208998676,
-0.0109594325,
0.006194884,
0.0237753652,
0.0285588838,
0.060960792,
0.0441755652,
-0.0176961143,
0.0404100493,
-0.0082207369,
-0.043372646,
-0.0529761836,
-0.0305968747,
-0.0636747256,
0.0808890015,
0.0264754854,
-0.0074684438,
0.0259146765,
-0.0422352813,
-0.0625195801,
-0.0230871979,
-0.0034579965,
0.0017177626,
0.0080782417,
-0.0621025413,
-0.0127155865,
0.0926745534,
-0.129841432,
-0.0279624984,
-0.0128569342,
-0.0040390673,
-0.0265798662,
0.0176210888,
0.0008374192,
-0.0449422561,
-0.0053344718,
-0.0020201823,
-0.0509464294,
-0.0120212138,
0.0031423157,
0.0053893537,
0.0314862318,
-0.0371963605,
0.0302048065,
0.0353524797,
0.0046015014,
0.0400542542,
-0.044595629,
0.0091248294,
-0.0438391045,
0.0409895591,
0.0180562846,
0.0795430019,
-0.0110894525,
0.0412646048,
0.0697271526,
0.0249887165,
0.0689335316,
0.0194373187,
0.0233877059,
0.0058330474,
0.0498116054,
-0.0230731498,
-0.0430727899,
0.0231454261,
0.0554441698,
-0.0133192064,
-0.0043094782,
0.0793816522,
0.0254206918,
0.0199538842,
-0.029539112,
-0.0305976588,
0.0307471529,
0.0451578684,
0.0136047043,
-0.0926485583,
0.0033281324,
0.0216718726,
0.0277200844,
-0.047343716,
0.0077087856,
0.0013109696,
-0.1049526259,
0.0584807061,
-0.0163473804,
-0.0405575484,
0.0194043778,
0.0033641164,
0.0214331429,
0.0420215838,
0.0279948842,
0.0463975444,
0.0054013198,
-0.0032108421,
0.0482868031,
-0.036756441,
0.0184861962,
-0.0362547785,
-0.015208167,
0.0117069408,
0.0695279986,
0.0401977934,
0.0121282628,
-0.0051402552,
0.0095434738,
-0.0435373038,
0.0182153396,
-0.0312352907,
0.019768605,
0.0147373267,
-0.0077865794,
-0.0342624038,
0.0119300568,
-0.0213526785,
0.0524489433,
0.0675375611,
0.0073673478,
-0.0536494404,
0.0262176376,
-0.0172829069,
0.0281104371,
0.0001284746,
0.0220045969,
0.0514063388,
-0.0496238396,
-0.0495343879,
-0.0190480426,
0.0117915133,
-0.0650995374,
0.0150222788,
-0.0008226295,
0.0203031264,
-0.0243872311,
-0.0768337622,
-0.0601094402,
0.0142180165,
0.0209688768,
-0.0091988165,
0.0222437419,
0.0029588139,
0.0406214818,
0.0003041074,
-0.0685223714,
0.0380360484,
-0.0162382182,
-0.0521803908,
0.0229722112,
0.0087107215,
-0.0445242971,
-0.020599423,
-0.0481204726,
-0.0227407478,
-0.0662122592,
-0.0045289914,
0.0096371761,
0.0284160338,
0.0174445603,
-0.0084222006,
-0.0236424822,
-0.0698744729,
0.0193210412,
0.027166035,
-0.0139718708,
0.0385472178,
0.0050327992,
-0.0207276493,
0.0133076003,
-0.0038042152,
-0.0010374141,
-0.0605542175,
-0.0072752582,
-0.0997910723,
-0.1015544534,
0.0092306696,
0.0493034609,
0.0523589291,
0.0410198458,
-0.03386949,
-0.0017993919,
0.0672268569,
-0.0074596093,
-0.01563913,
-0.0396711081,
-0.0218447242,
-0.0501535945,
0.0148184206,
-0.0111381756,
-0.0501651615,
-0.087817654,
0.0398637354,
0.0231345538,
0.019563999,
0.0273814555,
0.0462501533,
0.0153182717,
-0.0181873776,
-0.0041467929,
0.0714989081,
0.0442840271,
0.0559236482,
0.0171874445,
0.0521505177,
-0.0280694477,
-0.0183954779,
0.0326991268,
0.007697124,
-0.0775717869,
-0.0283164196,
0.041793596,
0.0195453055,
-0.0043621114,
0.005217832,
0.0136721097,
0.0478496514,
0.0402761176,
-0.0114155356,
0.0287015215,
0.0067717228,
-0.0027885525,
0.0464615151,
0.0281419661,
-0.0286411904,
0.0291750263,
0.0043821717,
-0.0371339135,
0.006264667,
0.0073636808,
0.0205411464,
-0.0551263765,
-0.0267081466,
0.0303458087,
0.027505694,
-0.0055609401,
0.0144040212,
-0.0199835766,
-0.0084753186,
0.0411759615,
0.0055749328,
0.0422417074,
-0.0494014546,
0.0371833816,
0.0164967384,
0.0212843847,
-0.0322192609,
-0.022021614,
0.0029415605,
-0.069815971,
-0.0150663108,
-0.0351102613,
-5.260859948e-33,
-0.0359754153,
-0.0416951217,
0.0057048504,
0.0043338286,
-0.0195418056,
-0.0307225231,
-0.0254077725,
0.0267138705,
-0.032034371,
-0.0341439061,
-0.0614450946,
-0.008542412,
0.0058416924,
-0.019831093,
0.0165381134,
-0.0849423185,
0.0514275655,
-0.0020035338,
-0.0154503221,
0.0042826072,
0.0481420085,
0.0139590902,
-0.0025117926,
-0.0241759364,
0.0037599893,
-0.0467827767,
-0.0234499499,
-0.0125714131,
-0.0018022866,
0.0301535968,
0.0062324055,
0.04187176,
-0.0008025896,
0.0052327001,
-0.0004801232,
0.0764718056,
-0.02311817,
-0.0331301764,
0.0311904885,
0.0579506382,
-0.0194522869,
-0.0040955772,
0.0192512218,
-0.0158132687,
-0.0045748311,
0.0473346785,
0.0112100029,
0.0059429165,
0.0016146282,
0.0029889843,
-0.0083853919,
0.010006167,
-0.0320034586,
-0.0398929939,
-0.0312199071,
0.1080253348,
0.0233086329,
-0.0537133254,
0.008419469,
0.0460087135,
0.0343387835,
0.0004159903,
-0.0021610607,
0.0333267674,
-0.0032218255,
0.0051770476,
0.0769992098,
-0.0086403368,
0.0723356158,
-0.0210019164,
0.0242512971,
0.0435558334,
0.0227656215,
0.0575784743,
0.0133825699,
0.0106744254,
0.0145566324,
-0.0088843945,
0.0046868785,
-0.0069174832,
-0.0419831127,
0.0169565864,
-0.0447884724,
-0.0030019318,
-0.0423377305,
0.0278733037,
-0.0275572017,
-0.0161208641,
0.0607219972,
-0.04560614,
0.0151273385,
-0.0059107691,
0.0597884357,
-0.0050066677,
0.022993207,
-0.0301750768,
-0.0136420177,
0.0166722704,
-0.0082452158,
0.014880646,
-0.0113017829,
0.0259159729,
0.0465324037,
-0.0317911282,
0.0105346609,
0.0209785346,
-0.0404515527,
-0.0142668141,
-0.0659349859,
-0.0237538256,
0.052739393,
0.0808817521,
-0.0478173308,
0.0036816029,
-0.0028546969,
-0.0006829072,
-0.0018525199,
0.0321067609,
-0.0376817547,
-0.0278264824,
-0.1097222865,
-0.0431037396,
-0.0323157758,
0.0155743333,
-0.0708913431,
-0.0067763929,
0.0013256569,
0.0124116717,
-0.0171937477,
-0.0380377807,
-0.0130293304,
0.0051807552,
2.249e-7,
0.0145832589,
0.0351011567,
0.0840251818,
0.0249110367,
0.0202426501,
0.0319516025,
0.0094689978,
0.0086064758,
0.070715256,
0.0310619362,
0.0149069754,
-0.0732121766,
0.0399463065,
-0.0129147191,
-0.1300617307,
-0.0710720792,
-0.0432478711,
-0.0139736915,
-0.0348697007,
0.0367451347,
0.067490533,
-0.005228783,
-0.0326928385,
0.0142868962,
-0.0196392536,
-0.0201008767,
-0.0196154248,
0.0049547493,
-0.0062962878,
0.0254098866,
-0.0065408479,
-0.020811772,
0.0217096284,
0.0783177465,
0.0038751021,
0.0238499492,
0.0159454811,
0.0210367981,
0.0021569803,
-0.0725937784,
-0.0133761242,
0.0339022279,
-0.0231744964,
-0.0315162539,
0.0633338764,
0.034189254,
0.0182590205,
-0.0182785075,
-0.0019114325,
-0.0570517033,
-0.0044934009,
-0.0225294326,
0.0078483541,
-0.0108984308,
0.020695243,
-0.0275297239,
0.0366487876,
-0.0069879317,
0.0158791672,
-0.005964132,
-0.0354477577,
-0.0606953539,
-0.0132657718,
-0.0182490926,
0.0096244942,
-0.0178827457,
-0.0352578461,
1.310256398e-34,
0.025374582,
-0.0093199657,
0.0526421666,
0.0733629614,
0.0076555745,
-0.0027509744,
-0.0002344056,
0.0254979543,
0.0599564575,
-0.0459454581,
-0.0356310606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03291v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03291v3 | SynJax: Structured Probability Distributions for JAX | 2023-08-07T04:20:38 | 2023-10-15T23:51:32 | Miloš Stanojević, Laurent Sartran | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The development of deep learning software libraries enabled significant
progress in the field by allowing users to focus on modeling, while letting the
library to take care of the tedious and time-consuming task of optimizing
execution for modern hardware accelerators. However, this has benefited only
particular types of deep learning models, such as Transformers, whose
primitives map easily to the vectorized computation. The models that explicitly
account for structured objects, such as trees and segmentations, did not
benefit equally because they require custom algorithms that are difficult to
implement in a vectorized form.
SynJax directly addresses this problem by providing an efficient vectorized
implementation of inference algorithms for structured distributions covering
alignment, tagging, segmentation, constituency trees and spanning trees. This
is done by exploiting the connection between algorithms for automatic
differentiation and probabilistic inference. With SynJax we can build
large-scale differentiable models that explicitly model structure in the data.
The code is available at https://github.com/google-deepmind/synjax | [
-0.0002880446,
0.0805730671,
0.0078731328,
0.0178842358,
-0.02064953,
0.0034228037,
0.005394625,
-0.020896174,
-0.0443988889,
0.0014090134,
0.0121639604,
-0.0423687324,
0.0247349702,
0.0529330112,
-0.0058745001,
-0.1007191092,
-0.0079470864,
-0.0024304178,
0.0019743841,
-0.0048431843,
-0.0103508821,
0.00279849,
0.0100305928,
0.0326905847,
-0.0754294395,
-0.0263153911,
-0.0351970941,
0.0537586249,
0.0268009733,
-0.0059854873,
0.0227597654,
0.0572898798,
0.006382416,
0.0366164036,
0.0000020892,
0.0217737947,
-0.012622756,
0.0190111808,
0.0042041531,
-0.0068006269,
-0.0053939987,
-0.0131235179,
-0.034165591,
-0.0337080769,
-0.0130624371,
-0.0557382852,
0.1093661711,
0.0128425108,
0.0341646932,
0.0485000201,
-0.0155510288,
-0.1017609239,
0.0485239141,
-0.037944071,
0.0579835512,
0.0031563619,
0.0196687393,
-0.0085389428,
-0.054855831,
-0.0296614692,
-0.0055471496,
0.0067244116,
0.0648201853,
-0.0390535034,
0.0140151232,
0.0520360358,
-0.0519561321,
-0.0220490079,
-0.0065033911,
0.0539022982,
-0.0358816087,
-0.0166379884,
0.0299683809,
-0.0325308293,
-0.0232203305,
-0.0204602182,
-0.0347619802,
0.0476558022,
-0.014886898,
0.0007972659,
0.0089376569,
0.0295949634,
0.0205120742,
-0.0306111854,
-0.0060875285,
0.0838047639,
0.0469908156,
0.0487663411,
-0.0503715351,
0.0038055161,
-0.0069234227,
-0.0478300862,
-0.0156783201,
0.0052330904,
0.0075449292,
0.000285397,
-0.0423545875,
-0.0896635428,
-0.0087957662,
-0.0493460968,
0.0543528199,
0.0164943747,
-0.0303198006,
0.043667037,
-0.0209018476,
0.0128178559,
-0.0961079448,
0.0601846501,
-0.0030365887,
-0.0017574837,
-0.0203906503,
-0.0198394638,
0.0087244157,
0.0022018496,
-0.0290048942,
-0.0336576179,
-0.0442387201,
0.0476559252,
-0.003640946,
-0.0299609005,
0.0197961554,
0.0273242854,
-0.0623529665,
0.0111333588,
-0.0202669613,
0.0257914104,
-0.0488641635,
-0.0200558696,
0.0210077707,
-0.0101203863,
-0.0056994129,
0.0577021912,
-0.0128923822,
-0.0431881361,
-0.0067004589,
0.032625068,
-0.0147821009,
-0.0204831865,
-0.0177875385,
0.0159437824,
-0.0302687045,
-0.0432475656,
0.0884587765,
-0.0910350457,
0.0134355491,
-0.0133009804,
0.0024480312,
-0.0051860032,
0.0153097203,
-0.01947443,
-0.0204262752,
0.0406451523,
0.0319485441,
-0.0008424509,
0.0185363665,
-0.0240112823,
0.0286322869,
0.042841386,
0.0170815345,
0.0306960549,
0.0065327692,
0.0093638115,
0.0021368337,
0.0302767605,
-0.0375266895,
-0.026422007,
-0.0290185902,
-0.0267788768,
-0.0098252166,
0.0080674672,
0.0489923395,
0.001857676,
-0.0064041796,
-0.041466061,
0.0110688983,
0.0213868432,
0.0185323935,
-0.0017727157,
0.0267982446,
-0.0487225279,
0.0162256416,
-0.0169213675,
-0.0380122364,
0.0437465683,
0.0419899635,
0.0432743244,
-0.0491161942,
0.0563361757,
-0.0303488448,
-0.0051646964,
0.0067705042,
-0.0087211682,
-0.0004500592,
-0.0589360707,
0.0864965022,
0.0052718944,
0.0157894269,
0.0597980656,
0.0226510167,
-0.0187558942,
-0.0350627229,
-0.0351202525,
0.0057063038,
0.0009314083,
0.0212332606,
-0.0399449877,
-0.0180275645,
0.0548911653,
-0.0259517208,
0.0321427695,
0.0024715564,
-0.0061995848,
0.0278023612,
0.0057291575,
-0.0248941667,
0.0288271662,
0.0335043147,
0.0375264771,
0.0333640948,
-0.0362742022,
0.0335579589,
-0.0679489151,
0.0403134972,
0.0324072316,
0.0343008824,
-0.0095317485,
0.0587137304,
0.0065021133,
0.0561892167,
0.0443540774,
-0.0170370229,
-0.0115111889,
0.0680152252,
-0.0171949528,
0.0458747074,
0.0098093925,
-0.0017585378,
-0.0078320485,
0.0507215597,
-0.0028074309,
-0.039207302,
0.0564514287,
-0.0561218038,
-0.0471751243,
0.0146733923,
-0.0171772316,
0.0030555928,
-0.0323273353,
0.028800305,
0.0092137232,
0.030721901,
-0.0293698963,
0.0591843128,
0.0247930214,
-0.0242244322,
0.0118751395,
-0.0295500644,
-0.0207047593,
-0.0252658166,
-0.0156039409,
-0.0091092214,
-0.0211787168,
-0.0195491835,
0.0011186289,
-0.0039567542,
-0.0062062442,
0.0020106114,
0.0157728381,
0.0159795973,
-0.038378071,
0.066956535,
0.0063889786,
0.0398169272,
-0.0130947437,
-0.029461123,
-0.0492673442,
0.0452955067,
-0.0191335957,
-0.0041152034,
0.0243488289,
-0.0162827447,
-0.0347470678,
-0.0264840815,
-0.0876107812,
-0.0278053042,
0.0180431623,
0.0140518462,
-0.0767402425,
-0.0185913816,
-0.0056495741,
-0.0481840968,
0.0361061767,
-0.0120713999,
-0.0169718415,
-0.0144588947,
-0.0647815317,
0.0269682817,
0.0719584227,
-0.0163066685,
-0.0145674702,
-0.0233608484,
-0.0132328104,
0.0225088187,
-0.0117728338,
-0.0579348505,
0.0175939854,
-0.0425952673,
-0.0111972271,
-0.0215984564,
0.0578328855,
-0.0292843021,
-0.0163085293,
-0.0261627957,
-0.0611901172,
0.0264047664,
-0.0153047675,
0.0256235301,
0.0202043336,
-0.015601391,
0.0251977481,
-0.0086636189,
-0.0615428984,
0.082524471,
-0.0217195135,
-0.0012365287,
-0.0054221516,
-0.0260426998,
-0.0634670705,
0.0780430436,
0.0875698254,
0.0049520419,
0.0111042289,
-0.0398283713,
-0.0451507904,
0.0694454983,
0.018107282,
0.006375365,
-0.0039563528,
-0.0263081398,
0.0240362268,
-0.0323505364,
-0.0100014899,
-0.021323625,
-0.0149112679,
-0.0002218748,
0.0091775209,
0.0401094817,
-0.0411704704,
-0.0426261798,
0.0372917764,
-0.013030149,
0.0413299091,
-0.0400281511,
0.0114041688,
-0.0378375575,
0.0733374134,
0.0302942395,
-0.0205012318,
0.0156736635,
-0.0454725586,
-0.0472689569,
0.0292571634,
0.0291709099,
0.0396544002,
-0.0717978626,
-0.0014453639,
0.0070926966,
-0.0054915613,
-0.0065709776,
0.0187367182,
0.0291065276,
-0.0531077124,
-0.000650809,
0.0368623808,
0.0091188587,
-0.0428281128,
-0.0347783677,
0.0055105658,
0.064282611,
0.0089278053,
0.0423863269,
-0.1043262258,
-0.0204792321,
0.0305852816,
-0.0020484417,
0.0481068902,
-0.0155728171,
0.0691383854,
-0.0542039499,
0.0368887857,
-0.006393434,
-0.0429905914,
-0.0667419508,
-0.0301714521,
0.0095624849,
-0.0320373178,
-0.0312697329,
0.0086057633,
0.0109727662,
0.0054016337,
0.018931346,
-0.0237848815,
0.003500486,
0.006376713,
-0.0617103875,
0.0154917296,
0.1132919788,
0.0037460215,
-0.0100600449,
-0.0318786539,
0.0328036286,
-0.0293495785,
-0.0370659865,
0.0270407367,
0.0422633775,
0.0045770961,
-0.0130042592,
-0.0150039392,
0.0284771416,
-0.0236315429,
0.0087565491,
-0.0296908468,
0.053281229,
0.0007125264,
-0.0057940814,
-0.0736313537,
-0.0495760851,
0.0017527684,
-0.0029991437,
-0.0118720587,
0.0144845545,
-0.0674339905,
-0.0538964234,
0.0496069565,
0.0094785774,
0.0215257742,
0.024643451,
-0.042525351,
-0.1332917958,
-0.0466868803,
0.0281045213,
0.0179388653,
0.0349909402,
-0.0238666218,
-0.0680699125,
-0.0090989424,
-0.0343056321,
-0.0730421245,
0.0415145308,
0.0258935131,
0.0350058265,
-0.0104136858,
-0.0313444249,
0.0066369455,
0.026720101,
-0.0269359443,
0.0262160674,
-0.1028865203,
-0.062004678,
-0.0154417893,
0.0832286105,
0.0231973194,
0.0032905659,
-0.0261187721,
0.0307961572,
0.0138834128,
0.0722500831,
0.0044942847,
0.0168598127,
0.0217208974,
-0.063415654,
-0.0205506273,
0.0009067704,
-0.0471362658,
0.0269145872,
-0.0305315331,
0.0238870531,
-0.030228775,
-0.0665098354,
-0.0285861176,
-0.0017791929,
0.0587480068,
0.011790866,
-0.0301042423,
-0.0276481118,
0.0331419967,
0.0022613835,
-0.0180997867,
-0.0172136724,
0.0082226694,
0.0043565622,
0.0212427024,
0.0171132814,
0.0672106296,
0.0534973294,
0.0543697663,
-0.0193031952,
-0.0307445582,
0.0519779883,
-0.0028226404,
-0.0021724573,
-0.0103755072,
0.0399239063,
-0.0305232555,
0.0048374739,
0.0288955476,
0.0175916441,
-0.0110617131,
0.015768962,
0.010298837,
-0.0470319726,
-0.0365806408,
-0.0522959344,
-0.0112404302,
-0.0540710874,
0.0144480467,
0.0114100277,
0.0076209716,
0.0419366062,
-0.0345306508,
-0.0247469563,
-0.0181989409,
0.032734476,
0.0193157606,
-0.0020798871,
0.0536018796,
-0.0004442173,
-0.0081736324,
-0.0548386537,
0.0795477182,
0.0528543144,
0.0118727582,
-0.0189190526,
-0.0016406247,
-0.0249631032,
-0.0059081907,
0.0040674661,
0.0244656429,
-0.0042581423,
-0.056472782,
-0.0275756214,
-0.0633306205,
0.0230071601,
0.0443681031,
0.040473111,
0.0121368868,
0.0235088989,
0.0428072736,
0.0053550624,
-0.0622439049,
-0.0295289941,
-0.0008529412,
-0.021568194,
-0.0130325612,
-0.007025999,
-6.022600858e-33,
-0.0177315027,
-0.0066895923,
-0.019555876,
0.0462309718,
-0.0414543003,
0.0062144776,
-0.041469682,
-0.0116301859,
0.0156696439,
0.0294161942,
0.0099106804,
0.0277499519,
0.0270852353,
0.0438875854,
0.0028972414,
-0.0373217128,
0.0021364396,
-0.0213686805,
0.0140313813,
0.0055626412,
0.0104314052,
0.0227651633,
0.0444074646,
-0.027833024,
-0.0055567925,
0.0253276657,
0.0004780097,
-0.0018027633,
-0.0163171794,
0.0370576158,
0.0011861286,
-0.0078136669,
-0.0125116967,
-0.0383846387,
-0.0062149456,
0.0402310342,
-0.0772949979,
0.0302816834,
-0.0280546416,
0.0303751007,
-0.0799714476,
-0.0143892681,
0.0216426793,
0.0372917168,
0.0542005412,
-0.0612397641,
0.0649863034,
-0.0599275306,
-0.0088496404,
-0.0788184851,
-0.016981462,
0.0419646353,
-0.0031550208,
0.0009661319,
0.0612041578,
-0.0183725189,
0.0394267328,
0.0286177564,
-0.0225415416,
0.0250779614,
-0.0035889784,
0.0338765718,
0.0711085126,
0.0601117909,
0.0234586019,
0.0283241346,
0.0523598082,
-0.0372964107,
-0.0393864438,
-0.0061762342,
-0.02782497,
0.037777096,
-0.0083669387,
0.023850102,
0.0442345776,
0.0481049083,
-0.1017148048,
0.0394647755,
0.0053313426,
0.0168244895,
-0.0113704307,
0.0463124998,
-0.0023436781,
0.0083249109,
0.0206755009,
-0.0640889257,
-0.0170509908,
-0.0071441713,
-0.0305190627,
-0.0028302111,
-0.0355040766,
0.0672795475,
0.0278546494,
-0.0221936312,
-0.0093071666,
0.0266709048,
-0.0204789545,
0.0637646019,
-0.0193302892,
-0.0099515505,
-0.0008407915,
-0.0284578577,
-0.0123892939,
-0.0067168707,
0.0237050336,
0.0114218788,
0.0431127883,
0.0194323324,
-0.0321817622,
-0.0066768252,
-0.0135227488,
-0.0085015511,
-0.032016594,
0.0738860518,
0.0491044186,
-0.0137931267,
0.0105399415,
0.0614246726,
0.0321440212,
0.0513053238,
-0.0100159533,
0.0233398918,
-0.0034193222,
0.0238066986,
-0.0189755894,
0.0101742987,
-0.0428592823,
-0.0148357926,
0.0295011532,
-0.0563286506,
-0.0041771801,
0.0353303887,
2.699e-7,
0.0945149064,
0.0260118488,
0.0572617501,
0.0140859624,
0.030689897,
0.0446141884,
0.0183299072,
0.0126519445,
0.0093772532,
-0.0528243668,
0.0119063659,
-0.0048363055,
0.0396560654,
0.0023606315,
-0.0906385034,
0.0454196706,
-0.0719869584,
0.0055882009,
-0.034958832,
-0.0517819561,
-0.0022466285,
0.1249087676,
0.0094992211,
-0.0334325992,
0.0480099022,
0.0315214209,
0.0237564705,
0.0175788086,
0.0084966868,
-0.0012673073,
-0.0099941017,
-0.0677628964,
0.0027485951,
0.0412614495,
-0.0249914192,
0.0071073752,
0.0357222743,
0.0646102354,
-0.0137938242,
0.0103319706,
0.0158046745,
0.0043620137,
0.0352074355,
-0.0281185154,
0.0339153111,
-0.0376831554,
-0.0203580279,
-0.0051684291,
-0.0583736897,
0.0392024256,
-0.0055335597,
0.0188776404,
0.0069922432,
0.0357899256,
0.0098195272,
-0.0639971942,
0.0033066007,
-0.0381341837,
-0.0223994385,
-0.0021543824,
-0.0594722368,
-0.0308693182,
-0.0120086009,
0.0023786833,
0.0436581597,
-0.0361539684,
-0.0418355018,
2.850839894e-34,
0.0139399832,
0.024480259,
-0.0374468826,
0.0727034807,
-0.009046183,
-0.0159309115,
-0.0109622795,
0.0056889402,
-0.0180686843,
-0.0291430987,
-0.0446126908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03281v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03281v1 | Towards General Text Embeddings with Multi-stage Contrastive Learning | 2023-08-07T03:52:59 | 2023-08-07T03:52:59 | Zehan Li, Xin Zhang, Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Pengjun Xie, Meishan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present GTE, a general-purpose text embedding model trained with
multi-stage contrastive learning. In line with recent advancements in unifying
various NLP tasks into a single format, we train a unified text embedding model
by employing contrastive learning over a diverse mixture of datasets from
multiple sources. By significantly increasing the number of training data
during both unsupervised pre-training and supervised fine-tuning stages, we
achieve substantial performance gains over existing embedding models. Notably,
even with a relatively modest parameter count of 110M, GTE$_\text{base}$
outperforms the black-box embedding API provided by OpenAI and even surpasses
10x larger text embedding models on the massive text embedding benchmark.
Furthermore, without additional fine-tuning on each programming language
individually, our model outperforms previous best code retrievers of similar
size by treating code as text. In summary, our model achieves impressive
results by effectively harnessing multi-stage contrastive learning, offering a
powerful and efficient text embedding model with broad applicability across
various NLP and code-related tasks. | [
-0.0234911963,
0.0508555956,
0.0109177995,
0.0564883463,
-0.0023485369,
0.0342954844,
-0.0198709965,
0.0117332879,
0.0358205251,
-0.0228257068,
-0.0021871191,
0.0136082368,
-0.0041087437,
0.0403508246,
0.087740615,
-0.0454497822,
-0.008587311,
0.0069876062,
0.0078749973,
0.02044034,
0.0243949033,
0.0368632488,
0.0321617126,
0.0507706665,
-0.0095738359,
-0.059602689,
-0.0008399658,
-0.0027328504,
0.0443649627,
-0.0504663847,
0.0329832695,
-0.0067144088,
0.0518996604,
-0.0100890836,
0.0000019056,
0.0366376005,
-0.0142874233,
-0.0052820798,
0.0107019348,
0.0146070244,
0.0815449432,
-0.0557903238,
0.0042394698,
0.0390654393,
-0.0473117568,
-0.0472148024,
0.0496376567,
0.0296197347,
0.0388927832,
0.0782895982,
-0.0123391449,
-0.0579946972,
0.0318974666,
-0.0415606424,
-0.0411565416,
0.0013271348,
-0.0032200841,
0.0016502532,
-0.0029296877,
0.0794908106,
-0.009170007,
0.0215787571,
0.0387426056,
0.0285384301,
0.0106160715,
0.0547306091,
-0.0166860875,
0.0386285596,
-0.0067626154,
0.1221153438,
-0.0368572548,
-0.0183182899,
-0.0078698685,
-0.0439978056,
-0.003450552,
-0.0567821376,
-0.0112704122,
-0.00526499,
0.0223141313,
0.0505943298,
0.0279789884,
0.0224780552,
0.0383827947,
-0.0065050726,
-0.0219604149,
-0.0341696702,
0.0015848194,
-0.038229119,
-0.0212855767,
-0.0100339251,
-0.0155442674,
0.0015956095,
0.0015304632,
0.0061796634,
0.0085071055,
0.0016973523,
-0.0346004069,
-0.0703916326,
0.0213406868,
-0.0422295965,
0.0249971133,
0.0481670834,
-0.0619359873,
0.042070847,
-0.0526910909,
0.0245039314,
-0.0462994054,
-0.0021247317,
-0.0151647273,
-0.0331713594,
-0.0287827943,
0.0152900033,
-0.0201834179,
0.0354526229,
-0.0425444171,
-0.0398348086,
0.0324659981,
0.0461632907,
0.0036348384,
0.0587726682,
0.0066619813,
0.0182339028,
-0.0205725599,
-0.0012040947,
0.0490065329,
-0.0081197545,
-0.0516424067,
-0.0144902887,
-0.0133932289,
-0.0361952893,
-0.0310137086,
0.0359778851,
0.0101257013,
-0.0411842167,
0.0128184622,
0.0501722172,
-0.0021012132,
-0.0462075174,
-0.0588876419,
0.0278940033,
-0.0124547901,
0.0091746654,
-0.0341367051,
-0.0759726316,
0.0084534809,
-0.0013336085,
-0.0125910435,
-0.0570838489,
0.0001920239,
0.0375646241,
-0.0321117938,
0.0762680769,
-0.0442288667,
-0.0659649074,
0.0090749413,
0.0241536424,
-0.0383871831,
0.0458331071,
0.0314180963,
-0.0056594643,
0.0190869104,
-0.0129203135,
0.0182249174,
0.0125398999,
0.0201109219,
0.0082090897,
0.0004231033,
0.0456979722,
0.0264578387,
0.0101372926,
0.0647598729,
0.0428129919,
-0.0020037303,
-0.0361092836,
0.0046205614,
0.0337031148,
0.0275528356,
0.0576805808,
0.0587644838,
0.0650534704,
-0.0407746434,
-0.000239327,
-0.0099919168,
0.0451628901,
0.0241360683,
0.0290719327,
0.0659258887,
0.0234434493,
-0.0295606479,
-0.0295168702,
0.0065398519,
-0.041142974,
0.0019831292,
-0.0268367212,
0.0350465439,
0.0057320455,
-0.0793917999,
-0.0026285346,
0.064587988,
-0.0394837484,
-0.0213395078,
-0.0066416641,
-0.0030006901,
0.05837515,
0.0387233905,
-0.0651068091,
0.016871918,
-0.0381222516,
0.0254042689,
0.0180607252,
0.0084043462,
-0.0001068691,
0.0555890761,
-0.074386172,
-0.0375917517,
-0.0819126293,
-0.0007004277,
0.0395179875,
0.0138008352,
0.0155332256,
0.0377022102,
0.0172605049,
-0.0293635949,
0.039029669,
-0.0429397188,
-0.0257082433,
-0.0001637649,
0.0110732745,
-0.0062019513,
0.0020425536,
-0.0536257066,
0.0097279642,
0.0286958124,
-0.0404755399,
-0.0170449261,
-0.0603504851,
-0.0387424305,
-0.0791631192,
0.015477607,
-0.0520597398,
0.0096097151,
0.070228152,
-0.0699039623,
-0.0002703248,
0.0305475928,
-0.0137671782,
0.0510874391,
-0.000196515,
-0.0357476696,
0.0048948405,
0.0103777843,
-0.0081666298,
0.0465379618,
-0.005332117,
0.0136688603,
0.0138060246,
0.0504829325,
0.0257629473,
-0.0056481529,
-0.0504810549,
-0.0206065886,
0.0049132453,
0.0484503992,
-0.0139276404,
0.0045922194,
-0.0310776103,
-0.0181395579,
-0.0795506611,
0.0206202772,
-0.0144268833,
-0.0116052264,
0.0226560086,
0.0003411094,
0.0104739647,
-0.0359266885,
-0.0496070273,
-0.0386894941,
-0.0626076236,
0.0022116229,
0.0401917882,
-0.0050504529,
0.0134822121,
-0.0529091656,
-0.0001200607,
-0.0199841838,
0.0846796781,
-0.0426334403,
0.0023063815,
-0.0161823984,
0.0623570532,
-0.0012942353,
0.0104841897,
-0.0257019494,
-0.0376625396,
-0.00468254,
-0.0212250743,
0.0254548341,
0.0601219982,
0.0069376267,
0.0013981267,
0.013769187,
0.0084056575,
-0.0585298538,
0.0318634138,
0.0078350939,
0.0223840661,
0.0094804475,
-0.0086511383,
0.0006482812,
0.0690844655,
0.0229521915,
0.0153498929,
-0.0577777624,
-0.0093960743,
0.0018083,
0.0356832631,
0.0053731767,
0.0220345836,
-0.0240887236,
-0.0077911341,
-0.0365928784,
-0.0595546328,
0.0781337246,
-0.0280510113,
-0.0338481478,
-0.0273781512,
-0.0455629639,
-0.0404644199,
0.0214816704,
-0.0195615459,
0.015142438,
0.0185884517,
-0.015749488,
-0.0349517837,
-0.0071426216,
-0.024052592,
-0.0197093077,
0.0399686694,
0.0112852678,
-0.0068674316,
-0.0187273063,
-0.0830905885,
-0.015040623,
-0.0420674458,
-0.0177719854,
0.0173590519,
0.0513159409,
-0.0043098135,
-0.0075546615,
-0.0401136652,
0.0078663975,
0.0636242926,
0.0198655725,
-0.0534073077,
-0.0494856797,
0.0263918359,
0.0181090776,
-0.0304463506,
-0.018109398,
0.0150423236,
0.0150645552,
0.0339002386,
0.0230012834,
0.0173211414,
-0.0717097446,
-0.0224794131,
0.0052007502,
0.0059442413,
-0.034100119,
0.0117731085,
-0.0001055692,
-0.0276959185,
-0.0176157728,
0.0872024968,
0.0298037622,
-0.0661175177,
-0.0159791037,
-0.0036036619,
0.0216624197,
0.0297181681,
0.0037319451,
-0.0807866752,
-0.037181817,
-0.0398955345,
0.016721813,
0.064058356,
0.0132874502,
-0.0077830106,
-0.0841041356,
-0.0156673118,
0.0242517665,
0.0037627225,
-0.0629625469,
-0.0272480957,
-0.0230375379,
-0.0337760188,
-0.0153197078,
-0.0095789861,
-0.0077296803,
-0.0028788229,
-0.0007731906,
-0.0159442853,
-0.021771539,
0.0175809562,
-0.0590880997,
0.0125111053,
0.0504048206,
0.0380890071,
0.0127552142,
-0.0346859321,
-0.0106329275,
-0.0574381165,
-0.0275057126,
-0.0023826784,
0.0933672637,
-0.0423429459,
-0.0172737632,
0.0097192079,
-0.0077115907,
-0.0488108248,
0.0001078326,
0.0220568199,
0.0770981461,
0.0205290783,
0.0039566271,
-0.044062756,
-0.0120731769,
0.0062803184,
0.0476707667,
0.0544274561,
-0.0629894137,
-0.0245673023,
-0.0596194863,
0.0268037766,
-0.0577225909,
-0.0112989089,
-0.0278605316,
0.0304030739,
0.0456793681,
-0.0568884201,
-0.0368707217,
0.0026073507,
0.0308944359,
-0.0134844286,
-0.0019412606,
-0.0251531098,
-0.039035283,
-0.0565095991,
0.0117768422,
-0.0189583693,
0.0036428217,
-0.022376433,
-0.0123732127,
0.0518505536,
-0.010275986,
-0.0450617895,
-0.0203883592,
-0.0577272959,
-0.0354831852,
-0.0784607157,
0.0328797996,
-0.006118305,
0.0358408503,
-0.0239866115,
-0.020501256,
0.0295497794,
-0.0046967524,
-0.0368902758,
-0.0107845347,
0.0574858002,
0.0229153801,
0.0245826598,
0.0259397421,
-0.04899434,
-0.0167891122,
0.0106413476,
-0.0143729663,
-0.0211577639,
0.0096114706,
-0.0160930753,
-0.0567121468,
0.0481552742,
0.0325377323,
0.0055911127,
-0.0403883941,
0.0014102838,
0.0138726383,
-0.0213271268,
-0.0552545562,
0.0677109808,
0.0406683944,
0.0011405089,
-0.0104527958,
0.0348247327,
0.0219513625,
0.0303161573,
-0.0252717901,
0.0347156264,
0.0520249419,
0.0235933624,
0.0265348759,
0.0109535186,
-0.0304606371,
0.0048600724,
-0.0265177321,
0.0200229809,
-0.0196692701,
0.0293594357,
0.0240490753,
-0.0184563678,
0.0070976247,
0.027933348,
-0.0386000723,
-0.0198151581,
-0.0081139756,
-0.0521442033,
0.061380025,
0.0074091321,
0.0246090572,
0.0237680972,
0.0017416684,
-0.0061534964,
0.0603534691,
-0.0171099603,
-0.0435162634,
0.0156720337,
0.0202964135,
-0.0456787087,
-0.0037739177,
0.0674729645,
-0.004975826,
0.0195688494,
0.0061501483,
0.0008603608,
-0.0396600291,
0.0145260338,
0.041482009,
0.0743770301,
-0.006349294,
0.0018412904,
-0.0035186773,
-0.0626480207,
0.010849027,
0.003461428,
-0.0331014059,
0.0168325994,
0.0338998809,
0.0655428991,
0.005090897,
-0.0110487733,
-0.0292131342,
-0.0062423134,
0.0175703019,
-0.0693574399,
-0.0538958646,
-5.753784402e-33,
0.0042073163,
-0.0110188434,
-0.0128492396,
-0.0235388149,
0.0097256042,
0.0356748328,
-0.0475892611,
-0.0161489174,
-0.0495126918,
-0.0239401478,
0.0205049422,
0.0379244462,
-0.0174582545,
0.0301734656,
0.0144118816,
-0.003912908,
0.0148108434,
0.0191904977,
-0.0175591968,
0.055208683,
0.0056744735,
0.0479063615,
0.0261968262,
-0.053210862,
0.0111792358,
0.0118700452,
0.0195753369,
-0.0147363916,
0.0596610643,
0.0621654503,
-0.0440123528,
0.0294681694,
0.0142587023,
-0.0271100234,
-0.0360831544,
0.0200719535,
-0.0579674132,
-0.0146923726,
-0.0209085997,
-0.025139844,
-0.0308616422,
-0.0367220864,
0.0305294506,
-0.0222025737,
0.0288076084,
-0.0351765491,
0.0622193553,
0.0100388713,
-0.0010359107,
-0.0055875904,
-0.049208317,
0.0498176254,
-0.0194445793,
0.0034378774,
0.0331486575,
0.0346369594,
0.0597790778,
0.0919630453,
-0.0684630573,
-0.0350119472,
-0.0358562768,
0.0129432986,
0.0144409193,
0.0037927404,
-0.0060087102,
0.0446662977,
-0.0073617683,
-0.0084910113,
-0.0132939657,
-0.0277162995,
0.0236088187,
0.033552397,
0.0702047721,
0.0418851785,
0.0209587831,
0.0023068506,
-0.0383698605,
0.0091599077,
-0.0074905683,
-0.0267589949,
0.0148505056,
0.0717054829,
-0.0538445637,
-0.011675084,
-0.002032073,
-0.0429864526,
-0.0328782797,
-0.0451741852,
0.0313339569,
0.0239973459,
-0.0073404429,
0.0045977621,
0.0206005219,
-0.054927025,
0.0056889993,
0.0678497702,
-0.0424320996,
0.0168376155,
0.0032761861,
0.009550035,
-0.0667959154,
-0.0175757315,
0.0364642367,
-0.0092786923,
0.0337890536,
0.0000167187,
0.0616791882,
-0.003184367,
-0.0908162668,
-0.0084890472,
-0.0212994069,
-0.0402910821,
0.0184266772,
0.0487703122,
0.0300232433,
0.0096643018,
0.0160503369,
0.0449629724,
0.0235034134,
-0.0050089327,
-0.0509361811,
-0.0152240815,
-0.0223663915,
0.0119052045,
-0.017293293,
-0.0153458389,
-0.0380671658,
0.0458581001,
0.0326748528,
-0.0529667325,
-0.0452354811,
0.0035944101,
2.377e-7,
0.0455734953,
0.0050806017,
0.01442088,
0.0407823436,
-0.0068712193,
0.0621070676,
-0.0074057281,
0.0572705194,
-0.0261464175,
0.0124383951,
-0.0113796769,
0.0134612378,
0.0666625425,
0.0197392832,
-0.0945723578,
0.0282883421,
-0.0656320676,
-0.0000130997,
-0.0485345088,
-0.0154114477,
0.0765167624,
0.1415615231,
0.0170751456,
0.0314505398,
0.015752783,
-0.0469022132,
0.0744615868,
-0.0061481758,
0.0432417579,
-0.0141832,
-0.066115208,
0.0628879964,
-0.0516197011,
-0.0402920581,
-0.0248029977,
0.0551084019,
0.0131578995,
0.0778633803,
0.0289271139,
-0.0075304629,
0.0294188838,
-0.0197586585,
-0.0091413511,
-0.052324973,
0.0635336414,
-0.0460182689,
0.0128262546,
-0.0116740279,
-0.0114029208,
0.0025901156,
0.0575611144,
0.0026378073,
-0.024933761,
0.0166829396,
0.0044262172,
-0.0337033197,
-0.0153754884,
-0.1095038429,
-0.0303786527,
0.0447031632,
-0.0074217725,
-0.0009472175,
-0.0428451598,
0.00874242,
0.0590129048,
-0.028341651,
0.0667888522,
2.178053508e-34,
0.0286507774,
-0.0424179807,
-0.0058286567,
0.0289931968,
0.0391903855,
-0.018243365,
-0.0089544365,
-0.0603171885,
0.023680428,
-0.0321844146,
-0.0097089931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03279v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03279v2 | UniversalNER: Targeted Distillation from Large Language Models for Open Named Entity Recognition | 2023-08-07T03:39:52 | 2024-01-19T02:26:38 | Wenxuan Zhou, Sheng Zhang, Yu Gu, Muhao Chen, Hoifung Poon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable generalizability,
such as understanding arbitrary entities and relations. Instruction tuning has
proven effective for distilling LLMs into more cost-efficient models such as
Alpaca and Vicuna. Yet such student models still trail the original LLMs by
large margins in downstream applications. In this paper, we explore targeted
distillation with mission-focused instruction tuning to train student models
that can excel in a broad application class such as open information
extraction. Using named entity recognition (NER) for case study, we show how
ChatGPT can be distilled into much smaller UniversalNER models for open NER.
For evaluation, we assemble the largest NER benchmark to date, comprising 43
datasets across 9 diverse domains such as biomedicine, programming, social
media, law, finance. Without using any direct supervision, UniversalNER attains
remarkable NER accuracy across tens of thousands of entity types, outperforming
general instruction-tuned models such as Alpaca and Vicuna by over 30 absolute
F1 points in average. With a tiny fraction of parameters, UniversalNER not only
acquires ChatGPT's capability in recognizing arbitrary entity types, but also
outperforms its NER accuracy by 7-9 absolute F1 points in average. Remarkably,
UniversalNER even outperforms by a large margin state-of-the-art multi-task
instruction-tuned systems such as InstructUIE, which uses supervised NER
examples. We also conduct thorough ablation studies to assess the impact of
various components in our distillation approach. We release the distillation
recipe, data, and UniversalNER models to facilitate future research on targeted
distillation. | [
0.0391555019,
0.0881165192,
0.0345416851,
0.0348001048,
0.0055654561,
0.0685750172,
-0.0033033846,
0.0169454552,
0.0125623746,
-0.0424274355,
-0.0419556163,
-0.0201504789,
-0.0415932275,
0.0176324788,
0.0092659872,
-0.0245072916,
0.0318874717,
-0.0303752944,
-0.0011104026,
0.0223599803,
-0.0395650305,
0.0220595095,
-0.0057093399,
0.0167509038,
0.0517038517,
-0.0017400875,
-0.009584046,
0.0260209851,
0.0421326198,
-0.0362905525,
0.0275197979,
0.0528503582,
0.0168788768,
0.0495497137,
0.0000022583,
-0.0620185919,
-0.0620358698,
0.0256603844,
-0.0638608634,
0.0167620592,
0.0455684178,
-0.0040612943,
-0.0017774462,
0.0167723466,
0.0015150891,
-0.0459214672,
0.0360017754,
0.0379235744,
0.0382275395,
0.0774574652,
0.0058854609,
-0.0599388294,
0.0617814735,
-0.0255890787,
-0.0051487405,
-0.0451223105,
0.0486968905,
-0.0184966531,
-0.0140497731,
0.0154855065,
0.0035245281,
0.0114782667,
0.0066414853,
0.0320271999,
0.0289780777,
0.0462736934,
-0.0656843185,
-0.0191612523,
0.000417735,
0.0946033522,
-0.0331862681,
0.0031271577,
0.0418092236,
0.003106907,
-0.0368479602,
-0.0381410681,
-0.0431432761,
0.01697555,
-0.0274370182,
0.0208929628,
0.0299989562,
-0.0087716682,
0.0235590339,
0.0094063701,
-0.0093644811,
0.000461173,
0.0239354726,
-0.0391045809,
0.0646042153,
0.0159287713,
-0.0382969007,
-0.0526340306,
0.0326984264,
0.026233647,
0.0251807999,
0.0125133395,
-0.0327322818,
-0.0041705603,
0.0083770659,
-0.0377131701,
0.0293473229,
0.0215154085,
-0.0103250267,
0.0497408547,
-0.0462196395,
0.0317262895,
-0.0187623128,
0.0359980315,
0.0203700885,
-0.0176275186,
-0.0781847611,
0.0260623656,
-0.0261676442,
0.033555828,
-0.0568130314,
0.003659331,
-0.0199178588,
0.0129601648,
0.0060050916,
0.0124995979,
0.0389065892,
-0.0063091037,
-0.0105659589,
-0.0028628507,
-0.0172625873,
0.0360340513,
-0.0021455633,
-0.0296605136,
-0.0210875422,
-0.0806362256,
-0.0207218006,
-0.0288108699,
0.0233021639,
-0.0380824916,
0.0521263182,
0.0803552195,
0.0100989211,
-0.0989107266,
-0.0411306247,
-0.0065006786,
0.0173189361,
-0.0860322416,
0.004371684,
-0.0314796306,
0.0341534913,
0.0243993141,
0.0088668363,
-0.0661004335,
0.0300141219,
0.0003770067,
-0.0488007888,
0.0719716549,
-0.0229190979,
-0.0300447103,
-0.0072426456,
0.0160762873,
0.0279445853,
0.061677292,
0.0235015862,
0.0264036264,
0.0102648651,
0.0016341424,
-0.0031517108,
0.0314462595,
0.0249632653,
-0.000304363,
0.0317609273,
0.03937288,
0.0272553582,
0.0074188444,
0.0433469713,
0.0619192496,
-0.0163987521,
-0.0079086265,
0.0335304029,
0.0084583033,
0.0306154694,
0.0234134179,
0.0302657392,
0.0172991138,
0.0166204683,
-0.0230710339,
-0.0456220545,
0.001128961,
-0.0022877371,
0.0178750679,
0.0274468232,
0.0866981149,
-0.0354398638,
-0.0095918346,
-0.0062440401,
0.0025524297,
-0.0345769599,
0.0197654143,
0.0472721122,
0.0036961383,
-0.0782315806,
0.090923883,
0.0921662748,
-0.0317974947,
0.0143298861,
-0.0436232165,
0.0095654232,
0.0464440808,
0.0491833948,
-0.0435049795,
-0.0142729003,
-0.0601107255,
-0.0220561251,
0.0291379336,
0.0215643905,
-0.0240603406,
0.0488599315,
-0.0538936891,
-0.012782624,
-0.0050220294,
0.0313471034,
0.0332876816,
0.0413463749,
0.0392187014,
0.0222180821,
-0.0411421619,
-0.0434102416,
0.0528245009,
-0.0435638465,
-0.0877011493,
-0.0158666801,
0.0206791162,
0.0161197316,
0.0288579706,
-0.0244913995,
-0.0380869992,
0.0122638131,
-0.0254007727,
-0.0059053404,
-0.0645369813,
-0.0015898953,
-0.0344175771,
-0.0004599177,
-0.0203660838,
-0.0352244154,
0.0155694382,
-0.0533700436,
-0.0301360264,
-0.0311797597,
0.0334833898,
0.0327088945,
-0.0275707208,
0.0346948989,
0.009537138,
0.0133167701,
-0.0213690642,
0.0447581708,
-0.0273082871,
-0.000776677,
0.0252558496,
-0.0401357897,
-0.0111192958,
-0.0238373037,
-0.0435301587,
0.0139579158,
-0.0125043001,
0.0049134805,
-0.0159562789,
0.0332656428,
-0.0581248254,
-0.0717607737,
-0.0838096291,
0.0337007083,
-0.0414729975,
0.0613290332,
0.0225615259,
0.0507305413,
-0.0281796884,
-0.0085117025,
0.0169956312,
-0.034751825,
-0.0449221544,
-0.0001099377,
0.0238335282,
0.0095642935,
-0.0346452333,
-0.0260372609,
-0.0041106469,
-0.0266953222,
0.040670421,
-0.0034278142,
-0.0130213266,
-0.040594019,
0.0570360981,
-0.0153325619,
0.0237151831,
0.0095659448,
0.0195270292,
-0.0018247061,
0.0261715744,
-0.0023890997,
0.0944525078,
-0.0237085354,
0.0418725535,
-0.0067215473,
-0.0091131292,
-0.0416369624,
0.0468459539,
-0.0236076172,
-0.0197274946,
-0.014689439,
-0.0152431456,
0.0149937123,
0.0837804228,
-0.0471794903,
0.0048295492,
-0.0306791868,
0.0143003669,
-0.004632236,
-0.0080584092,
-0.0360546745,
0.0468407311,
-0.009957632,
-0.0225791093,
-0.0276799984,
-0.0243645795,
0.058503557,
-0.0440096967,
-0.0130289467,
-0.0326778032,
-0.0116437441,
-0.0786272213,
0.027534971,
0.0075333538,
-0.0001694671,
0.0513936579,
-0.0480349772,
-0.0149026271,
0.0433120951,
-0.0170981567,
-0.0318867676,
0.0493139364,
-0.0203090813,
0.0164127033,
-0.022133749,
-0.0458438322,
-0.0416025445,
-0.0270082243,
-0.0294637699,
0.029488761,
0.0180145372,
-0.0090369647,
-0.0384429507,
0.0152787091,
-0.0042968877,
0.0333664715,
0.0073467861,
-0.0117606092,
-0.0512159541,
0.0144947032,
0.0438928753,
-0.0250867102,
0.0044872281,
-0.0388388298,
0.0007466454,
0.0146608334,
0.0132601345,
-0.0213661268,
0.0054938425,
0.0190016478,
0.0078782514,
-0.0608185455,
0.0203672945,
-0.0160674024,
0.0622194707,
-0.028223455,
-0.0050498657,
0.1012610421,
0.0042250557,
-0.0071435473,
-0.0196284316,
0.0303106699,
0.0552060306,
0.0140781179,
0.0258244369,
-0.0968614891,
-0.0539622568,
0.0008079248,
0.008737511,
0.0243268162,
-0.0637854859,
-0.0173713583,
-0.0846804827,
0.0047746268,
-0.0131684747,
-0.0510848574,
0.0003377522,
-0.0375146531,
0.0167443343,
-0.0868360773,
0.012413295,
-0.0075762854,
-0.052431576,
0.0220991094,
0.0161442943,
0.0319014341,
-0.0549804717,
0.0327937715,
-0.0410009846,
0.0331563503,
0.0289908461,
0.011702613,
0.0167230964,
-0.0288655479,
0.0169953648,
-0.0339278951,
-0.0165356882,
-0.0135868248,
0.0651691183,
-0.0316512473,
-0.0039466494,
-0.0101435464,
0.0159612764,
-0.0465837382,
0.0036119909,
0.0157575589,
0.0652673393,
0.0238444768,
-0.0075487215,
0.0001164021,
-0.0694797263,
0.0265342444,
0.0768717006,
0.0247729439,
-0.0325206183,
-0.0495205484,
0.002511495,
-0.0296023898,
-0.0294666272,
-0.0235276483,
0.0019818342,
-0.053093724,
-0.0509781316,
0.0056133224,
-0.0205649752,
0.0385758132,
0.0295576025,
0.0005868364,
-0.0198440682,
0.0377155468,
0.0327856392,
-0.0516380407,
0.0555237196,
-0.042283833,
-0.0084171798,
-0.0655430853,
-0.0388691165,
0.0115311984,
0.0100525422,
-0.0625245348,
0.0224358942,
-0.1200097352,
-0.0683432594,
0.004723683,
0.0146895563,
0.0190343689,
0.021513721,
0.0007102688,
-0.026004266,
0.0481084101,
0.0463376231,
-0.0247084275,
0.0042191609,
0.0304490682,
0.0106065478,
-0.0017728431,
0.043468222,
-0.0252577718,
0.0245682374,
0.0405892432,
0.026428761,
-0.0252531618,
-0.0192399081,
0.000704307,
0.0272905231,
0.0443453044,
0.0165024549,
-0.0303685702,
-0.062176127,
0.0210927036,
0.0414201617,
0.0297280047,
-0.0324285254,
-0.0103415996,
0.0387815535,
-0.0041196649,
-0.0179221109,
0.0437811129,
-0.0042982674,
0.0271462183,
-0.0769941807,
0.00377294,
0.0041581015,
0.0485135987,
0.0496212803,
-0.0435487367,
-0.0060566249,
0.0567774139,
0.0479036607,
0.0385807529,
-0.0297791362,
0.0305203889,
-0.0105459085,
0.046489872,
-0.0043406878,
0.017078571,
-0.0464359485,
-0.0121838683,
-0.0495328344,
0.0728048012,
0.0422613882,
0.0258277785,
0.0461170748,
-0.0039426461,
-0.0179991107,
-0.0001508588,
0.0112307761,
-0.015655363,
0.003173349,
0.018540971,
0.0231002718,
-0.0265222229,
-0.0179538224,
0.0653793067,
-0.0002839206,
0.0663311109,
0.0072335778,
0.010257503,
-0.0454734676,
-0.0171846338,
0.0122915478,
-0.0169991776,
-0.0005254187,
0.0215230584,
-0.0272228271,
-0.0387506522,
0.0042587188,
-0.0306998286,
-0.0258642752,
0.0022379125,
0.0235985108,
0.0105835516,
-0.0030305937,
-0.0616037436,
-0.0208007712,
-0.0062886747,
0.0000223697,
-0.0621777624,
0.0140435379,
-7.216042436e-33,
-0.0251898598,
0.0370688997,
0.0238873791,
-0.006407137,
-0.0255749524,
0.0272296853,
-0.0155360559,
-0.0165370815,
-0.0171805359,
-0.0321039259,
-0.012467524,
0.0016858542,
0.0315997563,
0.0269562956,
-0.0194908697,
-0.0499481745,
0.0755740106,
0.0290486794,
-0.0200344194,
0.0440268815,
0.0320776999,
0.0711662322,
0.0709532127,
-0.0955911055,
0.0181628782,
-0.0148601253,
0.0065763136,
-0.0114245135,
0.0543281771,
0.0445567481,
-0.0474043377,
0.0216252375,
-0.0012509427,
-0.0638557523,
0.0016423244,
0.0026715123,
-0.1506126821,
0.0099399118,
-0.0238287486,
0.0035096754,
-0.0265268274,
-0.0429463461,
0.0387188867,
-0.0039264704,
0.0132052004,
-0.0236196723,
0.0092967516,
0.0016758268,
0.0181082003,
-0.003697583,
-0.0644435808,
0.0396182016,
-0.007088399,
0.0052735717,
0.0255842172,
-0.0293804612,
0.0100546703,
0.0198892076,
-0.058647912,
-0.0250016917,
0.0610365681,
0.0042230245,
0.0445355847,
0.0185308047,
-0.012633672,
0.0412798524,
-0.0080736708,
-0.0081925774,
-0.0306929089,
-0.0291960202,
0.0094453897,
0.0814825818,
-0.0303351358,
0.0209040157,
0.0565427504,
-0.0202406552,
-0.0904767066,
0.0125675015,
0.004022317,
0.0136235273,
-0.0144058736,
0.0027180884,
-0.0411591195,
0.0156392138,
-0.0140115852,
-0.0380913168,
-0.0443498977,
-0.0005793564,
0.0386130251,
0.0171881653,
-0.0581609979,
0.0041294014,
0.0261402745,
-0.0453586243,
-0.0225093272,
0.0288954154,
0.0158144124,
0.0009883405,
-0.0115346992,
-0.0162318554,
-0.1001481861,
-0.056961339,
0.0264855511,
-0.0112840291,
0.0295055043,
-0.0103652999,
0.045441553,
-0.0056451759,
-0.0716553703,
-0.0072846157,
-0.0298113599,
0.049251806,
0.0075451215,
0.0495961569,
0.020050548,
0.007179121,
-0.000128859,
0.0345931612,
0.0583895706,
0.0073650228,
-0.0373720638,
0.0043808888,
0.0366152525,
0.0169415753,
-0.0006529088,
0.0105399992,
0.0165138151,
-0.0063623991,
-0.0164784659,
-0.0747457966,
-0.0076537468,
0.0115682567,
2.973e-7,
0.0194565207,
0.0283741932,
0.0104178311,
0.0019014844,
-0.0155234989,
0.0199157465,
0.0279948823,
0.0411566868,
-0.0178974047,
-0.0338398777,
-0.0201246664,
0.013949086,
0.0398432575,
0.0303411204,
-0.0948871672,
-0.0186502524,
-0.0334603935,
-0.0256955791,
-0.0766093433,
-0.021828698,
0.0163182411,
0.0925466642,
0.0058282474,
-0.0169311818,
-0.016437361,
-0.0046476242,
0.050465133,
0.0092939092,
0.0108982511,
0.0609045029,
0.0070769368,
0.0463430211,
-0.0123980846,
0.0091332579,
-0.0053039007,
0.0427187122,
0.0100463927,
0.0889879391,
0.0105269151,
-0.002364089,
0.0143494559,
-0.0352914445,
0.0002508392,
-0.0540851653,
0.0952441618,
-0.0368764699,
-0.0122722862,
-0.0098764235,
0.0029563061,
-0.0337667018,
0.0428111888,
0.0020159131,
0.0256401971,
0.0514426492,
-0.0010394222,
-0.0493961573,
-0.0326303504,
-0.0750034302,
0.0353931189,
0.0014307817,
-0.00389532,
-0.0319888033,
-0.0091042016,
-0.0117416354,
0.0211710799,
-0.0479069538,
0.0234609563,
2.983662261e-34,
0.0023736709,
0.0116588371,
-0.0010458712,
0.0166208204,
0.0228057802,
-0.0033935204,
-0.0653457046,
-0.0046571181,
-0.0321711376,
-0.0827261358,
0.0151755093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03277v1 | From Ambiguity to Explicitness: NLP-Assisted 5G Specification Abstraction for Formal Analysis | 2023-08-07T03:37:31 | 2023-08-07T03:37:31 | Shiyu Yuan, Jingda Yang, Sudhanshu Arya, Carlo Lipizzi, Ying Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Formal method-based analysis of the 5G Wireless Communication Protocol is
crucial for identifying logical vulnerabilities and facilitating an
all-encompassing security assessment, especially in the design phase. Natural
Language Processing (NLP) assisted techniques and most of the tools are not
widely adopted by the industry and research community. Traditional formal
verification through a mathematics approach heavily relied on manual logical
abstraction prone to being time-consuming, and error-prone. The reason that the
NLP-assisted method did not apply in industrial research may be due to the
ambiguity in the natural language of the protocol designs nature is
controversial to the explicitness of formal verification. To address the
challenge of adopting the formal methods in protocol designs, targeting (3GPP)
protocols that are written in natural language, in this study, we propose a
hybrid approach to streamline the analysis of protocols. We introduce a
two-step pipeline that first uses NLP tools to construct data and then uses
constructed data to extract identifiers and formal properties by using the NLP
model. The identifiers and formal properties are further used for formal
analysis. We implemented three models that take different dependencies between
identifiers and formal properties as criteria. Our results of the optimal model
reach valid accuracy of 39% for identifier extraction and 42% for formal
properties predictions. Our work is proof of concept for an efficient procedure
in performing formal analysis for largescale complicate specification and
protocol analysis, especially for 5G and nextG communications. | [
0.031005498,
0.0710607022,
0.0249356534,
0.014978935,
-0.0468019247,
-0.0519827828,
0.0263279174,
-0.0649674907,
-0.0301257931,
-0.0797462687,
0.0639240816,
0.0675963685,
0.004568785,
0.0642780811,
0.0522077717,
0.0048024892,
0.0520195477,
-0.0202211309,
0.0149154207,
0.0329163596,
0.0058423476,
0.0170439556,
0.0326689668,
-0.002869287,
0.0010164502,
-0.030562073,
-0.0360521041,
0.0128262304,
-0.0056061996,
-0.078755334,
-0.0147056766,
0.0370968729,
-0.0370527282,
-0.0138481427,
0.0000022839,
-0.0147880642,
-0.0735141262,
0.0578055717,
-0.0277613513,
0.0538765043,
-0.039362058,
-0.0071030506,
-0.0073568868,
0.021096712,
0.0008317234,
-0.00267705,
0.0221530702,
0.1092018932,
0.0912304446,
0.0832590312,
-0.0232804175,
-0.0596384965,
0.0186450556,
0.026552869,
-0.0350908525,
-0.0230515748,
0.028880557,
0.0053277817,
0.0436685719,
0.0649291724,
0.0767658353,
-0.0082161911,
0.0437285826,
-0.0011617192,
-0.007499455,
0.0042979326,
-0.0012638464,
0.0103423772,
-0.0705274493,
0.0023601074,
0.068479836,
-0.0315062292,
0.0470439903,
-0.0046544252,
-0.0307354182,
-0.0341325998,
0.0090939747,
-0.0542704426,
-0.0229835361,
-0.0185364075,
0.0273735318,
0.0303791426,
0.0209945384,
-0.0249348674,
-0.0102976989,
0.0970233455,
0.0234100278,
-0.0227446537,
-0.0156682152,
-0.044869341,
0.0122422362,
-0.0506558307,
0.0317494832,
0.0067312103,
0.0227848105,
-0.0101311635,
-0.0198717061,
-0.0133505054,
0.019322088,
-0.0421252996,
-0.010960551,
0.0045519341,
0.0344839692,
-0.0095518911,
0.0213740133,
-0.0214807726,
-0.0201036222,
-0.0195143018,
-0.0312830135,
0.0326371118,
-0.0368057191,
-0.0599802732,
-0.0084999641,
0.0555710681,
-0.0112122139,
0.0173616372,
-0.0269070622,
-0.0320283845,
-0.0673768446,
0.0297758821,
-0.0411832072,
-0.0302050021,
0.0070409877,
0.0211731251,
0.0104369214,
-0.0377942026,
-0.0459536053,
-0.0198041666,
-0.0230329894,
-0.0639439225,
0.0237564817,
0.0253728293,
-0.0205393005,
0.0294691306,
-0.0283412188,
0.094648689,
0.0107110823,
-0.0076044803,
0.0134841837,
-0.1081627756,
0.0257245414,
-0.0343010984,
0.0120180454,
-0.0743504167,
-0.048136875,
-0.0068316888,
-0.0175533202,
0.0142314592,
-0.0306973085,
-0.0203251243,
0.0095550912,
0.0505805761,
-0.0398042686,
0.0001633585,
0.0139477421,
-0.0064338124,
0.0045408034,
0.0069470764,
0.0070992527,
-0.0274608601,
-0.0003088175,
-0.0293328837,
-0.0075839176,
0.0153033417,
-0.0029779002,
-0.0631903559,
-0.0128775025,
-0.0048064785,
-0.0060694716,
-0.0298396312,
-0.0498210825,
0.0395860448,
0.0226914976,
-0.0039638393,
-0.0224138051,
0.0388844237,
0.0401300974,
-0.0081419768,
-0.0181222931,
0.1024089977,
0.0473364182,
-0.0378574841,
-0.0235862006,
0.015705416,
-0.072871536,
-0.0199043695,
-0.0142276278,
0.0272050258,
0.0042838803,
-0.0396196246,
-0.0639464855,
-0.0043013473,
0.0388922133,
-0.030221533,
-0.0022942259,
-0.0097835204,
0.0298322104,
0.0210115016,
0.0122751053,
-0.0032609084,
-0.0478865504,
-0.0316126943,
0.0081574088,
0.014591326,
0.0019379887,
-0.0214940477,
-0.0180566013,
-0.0134539036,
-0.0021254614,
0.0553700104,
0.0162753072,
-0.0062749088,
-0.0194622315,
0.00373082,
0.0055465214,
0.0132052787,
0.0405684896,
-0.0140848914,
-0.0135567551,
-0.0202954337,
0.0090376269,
0.0132294353,
-0.0565352403,
0.0337708481,
0.047600124,
-0.0306733269,
0.0460205153,
0.0401421227,
0.0223298147,
0.0522725694,
0.0100695686,
0.0501500741,
-0.0149462083,
0.0051342389,
0.0262419246,
-0.0196028631,
-0.0031725806,
0.062323615,
0.0035256047,
-0.0364690535,
-0.0306089018,
0.0210828912,
-0.0251586586,
-0.0200634673,
0.0823666751,
-0.0111244954,
-0.043493513,
-0.0059041209,
-0.0087604104,
0.0308423527,
-0.012299533,
-0.0297316387,
-0.01049829,
0.0450455993,
-0.040503785,
-0.027108958,
-0.0156759471,
0.075179942,
0.0003281884,
-0.0292199329,
0.0089769457,
-0.0437530242,
0.030336516,
0.025136847,
0.0470650084,
-0.0013127454,
0.004486769,
-0.0128304595,
0.0034227008,
-0.0034571732,
0.08689899,
0.0305619817,
0.0216827169,
-0.0239104424,
-0.0285664834,
-0.0003267085,
-0.0189046599,
-0.0251528006,
-0.0344061852,
0.0309717581,
0.0217273571,
-0.0642637759,
-0.011579209,
-0.0167123675,
-0.05692311,
0.0724808797,
0.0205705594,
-0.0311436728,
-0.0240105372,
0.0131782982,
-0.0193522759,
-0.016789563,
-0.0085158674,
-0.0284942109,
0.0737267211,
0.0294020325,
-0.055735983,
-0.0461316444,
-0.00330179,
0.0386648662,
0.0303163342,
-0.0373989232,
-0.0319626071,
-0.0114424378,
0.0083987126,
0.034353245,
-0.0030550424,
0.0085629113,
0.0437505282,
0.0635189712,
-0.015050536,
0.0291528348,
-0.021741515,
0.0039936835,
0.0157173369,
0.0168793909,
-0.0064245467,
-0.017373452,
0.0194803439,
0.0545608476,
0.0369567424,
0.0035334229,
0.0812294856,
-0.0233661532,
0.0130700665,
-0.1059474275,
-0.0276589375,
-0.0123218261,
0.0538348965,
-0.0456055403,
0.031731721,
0.078668803,
-0.0259828996,
-0.0081049893,
-0.0604630336,
0.0594861433,
-0.0098767783,
-0.0086617144,
-0.0522027463,
0.0291320756,
-0.0003430575,
-0.0006417044,
-0.0256533083,
-0.0035312038,
-0.0334544703,
0.013965454,
-0.0807963982,
0.0028016351,
0.0070814276,
0.033266928,
-0.0071032769,
-0.0278654508,
0.0289189182,
-0.0002728547,
-0.0315065645,
-0.0153741073,
0.001701612,
-0.053808894,
-0.0157482922,
0.0513005778,
0.0019889213,
-0.0033410194,
-0.007009726,
0.0984686613,
-0.0739522874,
-0.0055387849,
-0.0392712913,
-0.0726171061,
0.0221858453,
0.0684892982,
0.032542631,
-0.0165854413,
0.0047748992,
0.0506214723,
0.0153785674,
0.0282846615,
0.0453114063,
-0.0045492044,
-0.0313672908,
-0.0134733114,
0.0793247074,
-0.0816831216,
-0.0053199185,
-0.0033597357,
0.004635537,
-0.0206744596,
0.0040724389,
-0.0368639417,
-0.0540570393,
0.0174367987,
0.0292033739,
-0.0177588761,
-0.0201477204,
-0.0565704927,
-0.0053941244,
0.024415547,
0.0391996987,
-0.015817197,
-0.0069589657,
-0.0028007485,
0.0096355462,
-0.1236598119,
-0.1052924022,
0.0377709791,
-0.008022123,
0.022553945,
0.0126136206,
0.0060160304,
-0.0354932845,
-0.0005754894,
0.0523923934,
0.0186278131,
-0.0180953238,
-0.0006706683,
-0.0026075805,
0.0137174698,
-0.0018058626,
-0.0380123854,
0.0261521637,
-0.0154337659,
-0.0212148875,
-0.0189643428,
0.0331873521,
-0.0296453945,
-0.013599406,
-0.0035782279,
0.0154364258,
0.0562060848,
0.0107605811,
-0.0172787756,
0.0170943122,
-0.0624184757,
-0.0535057001,
-0.0002431627,
-0.0391522534,
-0.0246823523,
0.0406911857,
0.0229916014,
-0.105508469,
-0.0472634919,
0.0140346847,
0.0117312372,
0.0005370317,
0.0193460975,
0.0106834816,
0.0911926925,
0.01531184,
-0.0560035631,
0.0032803814,
0.0077932812,
0.0352724567,
0.0166071933,
0.0140206488,
-0.0193437897,
0.0489839874,
-0.0299670305,
0.0572554767,
-0.0493248813,
-0.0574215241,
-0.0309887622,
0.0073219347,
0.0215482116,
-0.0374371856,
-0.0707464591,
-0.0182272233,
-0.0300888326,
0.0630706847,
-0.0568548441,
-0.0317597277,
0.029090574,
-0.0256236773,
-0.0010826426,
-0.0223523211,
-0.0180594455,
0.0152805233,
0.0014659544,
0.0398607999,
-0.0197820589,
0.0258754268,
0.031512741,
0.1032648906,
0.0008012835,
0.0065677753,
-0.0097497888,
0.0141947456,
-0.0299780779,
-0.0282592941,
-0.0410474725,
0.0028814448,
0.0240166858,
-0.0772174001,
0.0181568656,
0.020964196,
-0.0485602096,
0.0069134259,
0.0186826158,
0.0288247913,
0.0401716046,
-0.0027511874,
-0.0037985665,
0.0298443865,
-0.0120250676,
-0.0132999076,
0.0088560143,
0.0122574829,
0.0044242209,
0.0171913635,
-0.0366696604,
0.0410555899,
0.0311834887,
-0.0855000764,
0.0084493915,
0.0348595455,
-0.04011143,
0.0478383191,
0.0142495586,
0.0019297021,
0.0547811352,
-0.0185777713,
-0.0328238755,
0.0381474458,
-0.0190746859,
0.0364830345,
-0.0413989797,
-0.0226306096,
0.0448111929,
0.0271479376,
-0.0091165593,
-0.0306128617,
-0.0084727444,
0.0178972427,
0.018745238,
-0.0210970379,
-0.0327331051,
-0.0633366108,
-0.0160302725,
0.0024398167,
0.0176830143,
-0.081303142,
0.0031454402,
-0.0421681032,
-0.0414295681,
-0.004630954,
-0.0119212894,
0.0571318008,
0.0165621024,
0.0317296423,
0.0692481324,
0.0371681489,
-0.0063241259,
-0.0109148296,
-0.077277936,
-0.0036071315,
-0.0468465164,
0.0049712039,
-6.486284523e-33,
0.0192690827,
-0.0228672083,
0.016645737,
0.0361654274,
0.0243538413,
0.0022986948,
-0.0506663807,
-0.0158560686,
0.0541939326,
-0.0156097226,
0.0164337326,
0.0060486007,
0.0405738987,
0.0141895674,
-0.0144638186,
-0.020582037,
0.0454220511,
-0.0141895059,
-0.027277166,
-0.0365021713,
0.0270650815,
-0.0401596427,
0.0506213717,
-0.0503311567,
0.0628614128,
0.005624597,
-0.0282041691,
-0.035207469,
-0.0348489583,
0.0506684706,
-0.0203484092,
-0.0214534737,
0.0165261663,
0.0162241142,
-0.025399426,
0.0267181657,
-0.0271110889,
-0.0199416187,
0.016496025,
0.0209863596,
-0.0126010571,
-0.0424834788,
0.0436692089,
0.0018349688,
-0.051090233,
0.0449231677,
0.0257800408,
0.0379873812,
-0.0019897944,
-0.0143883452,
-0.0057376474,
0.0402662307,
-0.0480303504,
0.0467052869,
0.0117823239,
-0.0674049705,
-0.0574143194,
-0.0793509856,
-0.0143202217,
-0.0126767121,
0.0151204122,
0.0231793653,
0.0308803394,
-0.0181914903,
0.0071388832,
0.0185282156,
-0.0498148203,
-0.0212170966,
-0.0069550509,
-0.0018903788,
0.0113153532,
0.0323911607,
-0.0100476239,
-0.0270042475,
0.0707635209,
0.0184903312,
-0.0713356882,
0.0349465199,
-0.0154347923,
0.0721483231,
-0.0030873434,
-0.019019274,
-0.0472666286,
-0.0167076793,
0.0136424238,
-0.0205150694,
-0.0006294647,
-0.0279662143,
-0.0144448513,
-0.0200191643,
-0.038621068,
0.0510103963,
0.001133224,
-0.0397179313,
-0.0166603476,
-0.0427711941,
0.0175868571,
-0.0052498854,
-0.0273118839,
0.0184653681,
0.0086325789,
-0.0000958934,
-0.0113648865,
-0.0455083139,
0.046973642,
0.0045687398,
-0.0173887108,
0.0263232496,
-0.0513392352,
0.0063724499,
0.0006822673,
0.0031661894,
-0.0312778875,
0.0316668153,
0.0306894574,
-0.0107421465,
0.0065078093,
0.0071071028,
-0.0225510541,
-0.0228976142,
0.0249593947,
0.0957486257,
0.0334236734,
0.0134791881,
0.0132529512,
-0.0055701756,
-0.0534018837,
-0.0301040076,
0.0435171239,
0.0593759157,
-0.0007343906,
0.0036970868,
3.25e-7,
-0.0025846788,
0.0130616305,
0.0815848932,
0.0938356742,
-0.0190780275,
0.0491150208,
0.0274971481,
0.0304699522,
-0.0257953033,
-0.0365034752,
-0.0283558425,
-0.0116833141,
0.0601654351,
0.0066504851,
-0.0438497961,
0.0292009935,
-0.0329704918,
-0.0029576076,
-0.0537963212,
-0.0035578485,
0.0812435076,
-0.0082826475,
0.025178574,
0.0390773304,
-0.0496254303,
-0.0227341838,
-0.0125431288,
0.0052039381,
-0.0077485754,
0.0485326275,
0.0666303262,
-0.0155284498,
0.0455920361,
0.0415525027,
-0.0091859056,
-0.0051016556,
-0.0112188151,
0.0500368737,
0.0257626437,
0.0472167172,
-0.0807157978,
-0.0644355863,
-0.0027311312,
0.0133648813,
-0.0060776328,
-0.0249846671,
-0.1073456556,
0.0085671442,
-0.0473593771,
-0.0456508435,
-0.0252052564,
0.0202274565,
0.0102266138,
-0.0063776192,
0.0014147519,
-0.0161098354,
0.0060826926,
-0.0372132882,
0.0021873885,
0.0100553622,
0.0198426936,
0.0218302477,
0.0268618278,
0.0458107404,
0.1028221026,
0.000800116,
0.0418238305,
2.849800316e-34,
0.0058206716,
0.0089581618,
-0.0129907364,
0.0302049872,
0.0117160277,
0.0292730425,
-0.0179390237,
0.0196603704,
-0.002656457,
-0.0387548953,
0.0087363748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03275v1 | Adapter-based Selective Knowledge Distillation for Federated Multi-domain Meeting Summarization | 2023-08-07T03:34:01 | 2023-08-07T03:34:01 | Xiachong Feng, Xiaocheng Feng, Xiyuan Du, Min-Yen Kan, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Meeting summarization has emerged as a promising technique for providing
users with condensed summaries. However, existing work has focused on training
models on centralized data, neglecting real-world scenarios where meeting data
are infeasible to collect centrally, due to their sensitive nature. This gap
motivates us to explore federated learning for meeting summarization. Two
critical challenges impede progress. First, state-of-the-art summarizers are
based on parameter-heavy pre-trained models. Exchanging such a model's
parameters across clients imposes large bandwidth costs. Second, as real-world
meeting data belong to various domains and are distributed across clients, they
are instances of non-identically and independently distributed (non-IID). IID
assumptions do not hold, which changes which forms of learning algorithms best
apply. To address this, we propose Adapter-based Federated Selective Knowledge
Distillation (AdaFedSelecKD) for training performant client models.
Specifically, we develop an adapter-based summarization model where two
adapters cooperatively facilitate learning using fewer parameters to reduce
communication costs. Then, we devise a selective knowledge distillation
strategy, assisting clients in robustly handling domain-focused modelling on
their own data, while leveraging global parameters based on non-IID data.
Extensive experiments on the QMSum benchmark demonstrate AdaFedSelecKD can
achieve comparable performance with powerful centralized training methods, and
shows its generalizability and robustness. | [
0.0136206616,
0.0153376833,
0.0205144249,
0.0218555965,
-0.0000644883,
-0.0044562537,
0.0393730067,
-0.0166101046,
0.0129409293,
-0.0377090871,
-0.0543657541,
-0.0538362227,
0.0106310993,
0.0301112533,
-0.0509328246,
-0.1017360315,
0.0264931079,
-0.0097223539,
-0.0385698862,
-0.0101088416,
0.000073097,
-0.0094000539,
0.0031688295,
0.0360892043,
-0.0005673841,
-0.0283455458,
-0.0167819671,
-0.0038762519,
0.0005693492,
0.0245496687,
0.0182848517,
0.0372940749,
0.0348036662,
-0.0042833146,
0.000002251,
-0.0112958588,
-0.0422868431,
-0.0158773642,
-0.014237782,
0.0297729075,
0.0003420583,
-0.005344281,
0.0493485704,
0.0025693909,
-0.0377137549,
0.0030436907,
0.0031071326,
0.0773116425,
0.0525401942,
0.0392876454,
-0.0225817505,
-0.0366798192,
-0.0190534461,
-0.0415087901,
-0.0735369995,
-0.0767659396,
0.0006497918,
0.0212423466,
-0.0479058623,
-0.0491400287,
-0.0145837162,
0.0369483419,
-0.0097788274,
0.0127385855,
0.0074998592,
0.0009848349,
-0.0582094416,
-0.020187337,
-0.0253765564,
0.0800630152,
0.0547660589,
0.0434695892,
0.0285305362,
-0.0001248188,
0.0144041125,
0.0387963951,
-0.05969432,
-0.0238037687,
-0.0111660389,
0.0253803711,
-0.0742517561,
0.0743935108,
-0.0002616775,
-0.0048145098,
-0.0275732931,
0.0363170952,
-0.0460248701,
0.0056542596,
-0.042793002,
0.0133249322,
-0.0262386445,
-0.0531745553,
0.0489330441,
0.0178048238,
0.0101322262,
-0.0154759269,
-0.0467490777,
-0.0622525923,
-0.0213448387,
-0.0012754332,
0.0724994689,
-0.001728725,
0.0317794383,
0.0448707938,
0.004699586,
-0.006695481,
0.0329371691,
0.0176501274,
-0.0431515165,
-0.0093055442,
-0.0521524101,
0.0119101368,
-0.013993768,
0.0779029354,
-0.085209921,
-0.029915804,
-0.0195846017,
0.0317338705,
-0.0158179775,
-0.0061385264,
0.0182922632,
0.0214532558,
-0.03521166,
-0.0144457584,
-0.0239875726,
0.0593338385,
-0.0301503111,
-0.0127532287,
0.0224047638,
-0.0025304654,
0.0159692187,
0.0115965717,
0.0305686705,
0.0303983875,
-0.07755211,
0.0651591346,
-0.0319457352,
-0.0315050855,
-0.0099418918,
-0.0585144162,
-0.0084563699,
-0.0412442163,
0.0141851762,
-0.0334422365,
0.0549736954,
0.0171701424,
-0.0092834076,
-0.0842053965,
-0.0212198459,
-0.0437159389,
-0.0385860577,
0.039914351,
-0.0044127041,
0.0245165993,
0.0397856571,
0.0217010733,
-0.0308343917,
0.0852314606,
0.0190588962,
0.0458449163,
0.0425738059,
0.0406396799,
-0.0121145174,
0.0059118671,
0.0279818829,
0.0161763728,
0.0258316379,
-0.0200591255,
-0.0227171015,
-0.0310071688,
-0.0018969623,
0.0349275656,
-0.0471905619,
0.0236089341,
0.0632576346,
0.0119519113,
0.0554150827,
-0.0077574211,
-0.0081634894,
0.0335034914,
-0.0026341446,
0.0930401459,
-0.0199147407,
0.0285048727,
-0.0013922866,
0.0172307957,
0.0868261904,
0.0606789179,
-0.0561520904,
-0.0865416452,
0.0417462289,
-0.0392249599,
-0.0068513304,
0.003435157,
0.0189585146,
0.0254373159,
-0.0325510614,
0.0680698901,
0.0320662186,
-0.0485685542,
0.0104450202,
-0.0147663802,
-0.008458009,
0.0364953876,
0.0225599259,
-0.043068219,
-0.0156869497,
-0.0285531022,
0.0552297793,
0.0125824083,
0.0640984923,
-0.0198568031,
0.0258370545,
-0.0466299169,
-0.1004201844,
0.032496091,
0.0209077857,
-0.0044138739,
-0.0062082694,
0.0106563587,
0.035498336,
-0.0140073542,
-0.0305061731,
-0.003160903,
0.0126012294,
-0.0160669405,
-0.0111572603,
0.0262183696,
0.0259063747,
0.026351722,
-0.0067430669,
-0.0223439187,
0.0194002967,
-0.0073811454,
-0.0203851536,
0.0155176623,
-0.0741178021,
-0.0446265154,
0.0173329972,
-0.020008469,
0.0271757524,
0.0000489634,
-0.0470848829,
-0.0567705519,
0.0119964387,
0.0186547246,
0.0361878611,
-0.0144762183,
0.0223676134,
0.0215501375,
0.009155578,
0.0200878792,
0.0299146287,
-0.0342784896,
-0.06060756,
0.0087502627,
-0.0779181421,
0.0039334828,
0.0062536127,
0.0239124876,
-0.0136865182,
0.010125936,
0.0283060502,
0.0236437898,
-0.0215857588,
-0.010489326,
0.0253583305,
-0.0621559285,
-0.0072852643,
-0.0253353659,
-0.0056044641,
0.0130560761,
0.0848794505,
0.0163773857,
-0.0160455443,
-0.0226651542,
-0.001804063,
-0.0045498372,
0.020218512,
-0.0174660776,
0.0509368777,
0.0293472204,
-0.007891803,
-0.0019626447,
0.0296672266,
0.0421488658,
-0.0130449282,
-0.0579554737,
-0.0353140198,
-0.0304524954,
-0.0556151345,
0.0052628145,
-0.0026585746,
0.0302828848,
-0.0180844907,
0.02856691,
0.0179392509,
-0.0009224933,
0.0197382998,
0.0282378998,
0.0131040281,
0.0133103142,
-0.0686255097,
0.0039007692,
-0.0474929586,
0.0478105545,
-0.0169933103,
0.0134408316,
0.0631978214,
0.0428725816,
-0.0149622047,
0.0079425452,
-0.0392302051,
0.0338223316,
0.0021781332,
-0.0405380055,
-0.067445308,
-0.0048439871,
-0.0080960616,
0.0348889902,
-0.0028365059,
-0.026866924,
0.0431881882,
-0.0048647374,
0.0311085358,
-0.0226457082,
-0.0345360711,
-0.0274077319,
0.0168571305,
-0.0288964268,
0.0511982478,
0.0080862232,
-0.0186630804,
-0.0332599021,
-0.0286741145,
0.0148012843,
-0.0266510081,
0.0876292661,
-0.0457130484,
0.0057968083,
-0.0095236273,
-0.0592778437,
-0.0122951772,
-0.0069924202,
-0.0129559189,
0.0097343903,
-0.019571621,
0.017086545,
-0.0966311619,
0.0610953607,
-0.0076708016,
0.0601555593,
-0.0281699058,
-0.0071239425,
-0.0169387069,
0.0442082435,
0.034426067,
0.0170315392,
-0.0140551552,
-0.0424625911,
0.0281972401,
0.0516116805,
0.0778758898,
-0.0647289529,
0.0279905815,
-0.0338577889,
-0.0115603898,
-0.0435964353,
0.0020387091,
-0.0220191125,
0.0766515359,
-0.0016358487,
0.0532058775,
0.0903016552,
0.0019341413,
-0.0509354696,
-0.0256044902,
-0.0124720708,
0.0334875956,
-0.0206987187,
0.0152498214,
-0.0799868554,
-0.0488995053,
0.0010252635,
0.0641040951,
0.048970446,
-0.0453000888,
-0.0248767547,
-0.043043267,
0.0220195148,
0.0268226303,
-0.0300379861,
-0.0314458199,
-0.0050590839,
0.0101916678,
-0.0004291282,
0.0248714723,
-0.0141962701,
-0.0182057228,
-0.0303343944,
0.0312310718,
-0.080853872,
-0.0515123159,
-0.064503774,
-0.0147910444,
0.0040634852,
0.0200408809,
0.0343361422,
0.0440535434,
0.0055322303,
-0.0277907178,
-0.0060701668,
0.0358344913,
-0.0201288834,
0.078161791,
-0.0262800734,
0.016167948,
0.0262458436,
0.0248195957,
0.0066778916,
0.0007699049,
0.0197285749,
0.0317863114,
-0.0171813685,
-0.0173112862,
-0.0197177157,
0.015971899,
0.0092599392,
0.0670211166,
0.0148893166,
-0.0117489593,
-0.0211402681,
0.0177024528,
-0.0067193573,
-0.0135820471,
0.0190734267,
-0.0219029896,
-0.0454000793,
0.0090904925,
-0.0836745277,
-0.0201094393,
0.0449050702,
0.0045464728,
-0.0025786969,
0.0317330621,
0.0150898853,
0.0378890857,
-0.0381502621,
-0.0161809269,
-0.0607977286,
-0.0137520405,
-0.0375634357,
-0.0303326696,
0.0350032188,
-0.0230263025,
-0.0139642889,
0.0376399569,
-0.006182008,
-0.063904658,
0.0037461352,
0.0521740355,
0.029061567,
0.1020424962,
0.0190007892,
-0.0004050953,
0.0753727481,
0.0370021127,
0.0068780151,
0.0165474229,
0.032851167,
-0.0167055335,
-0.0330413841,
0.0370220654,
-0.064012289,
0.0291408822,
-0.0212547183,
0.0033646354,
-0.0324612446,
-0.0738643482,
-0.032865759,
0.0247545633,
0.0179477911,
0.0180176087,
-0.0121333227,
-0.0146581121,
0.0179249197,
0.0067252428,
-0.0030156656,
-0.0499348268,
0.0090344017,
-0.0526852459,
0.0092700934,
0.0220812541,
0.0512508899,
0.0067807855,
-0.0018939477,
-0.0511660464,
-0.0200173147,
-0.0143606775,
-0.0850588083,
0.0129716778,
0.0015583271,
-0.0121319164,
0.0131202312,
0.0393919721,
0.0160712283,
-0.0410819203,
0.0353803486,
0.0030921951,
0.050263688,
-0.0260051936,
0.0673748702,
-0.0806511492,
-0.0530719124,
-0.0504295267,
0.0509011671,
0.0051033217,
-0.0156011516,
0.0493861549,
-0.0276319329,
0.0444961637,
-0.0611028671,
0.0271089096,
0.0140533447,
0.0135065336,
-0.0214218348,
0.00606072,
0.0064138612,
0.063581042,
0.1287356913,
-0.0681242123,
0.0105608637,
-0.0309419781,
-0.012844177,
-0.0771257877,
-0.0535514429,
0.0287781656,
0.050176207,
0.0022916107,
-0.0401840471,
-0.0405802466,
-0.0187700577,
0.0541775189,
-0.0714186803,
-0.0253027454,
-0.050313551,
0.0618143454,
-0.0017486234,
0.0060726586,
-0.0045259646,
-0.0528299883,
-0.0515994318,
-0.0335183963,
0.0328406766,
0.0412226766,
-6.572972089e-33,
-0.0467778854,
0.0132047264,
-0.0216336753,
0.0404186435,
-0.0300019439,
0.0093918443,
0.0013595034,
-0.0217738878,
0.0234584939,
-0.0179001,
-0.0135528045,
0.0227420107,
0.0382519476,
0.0537553951,
-0.03676394,
0.0103312284,
0.0946561098,
-0.0309590884,
-0.0345109217,
0.0599836893,
0.0503279865,
0.0515715703,
-0.0033007138,
-0.0739296824,
-0.0148047432,
-0.0023980113,
0.0203002635,
-0.0339775942,
0.0852519795,
-0.0020394058,
-0.0090701208,
0.0377858281,
0.0113377487,
-0.015893504,
-0.0489465445,
-0.0044403528,
-0.0848523751,
-0.0059849191,
0.0106062395,
-0.0112714954,
-0.0101039642,
-0.0002314737,
0.0370803624,
0.0018406057,
0.0248436667,
-0.0544073433,
0.0277155209,
-0.0139350118,
-0.0470072292,
-0.0213902742,
-0.0046954076,
0.0091443844,
-0.0167152639,
-0.0330964029,
0.0371885523,
0.0394499637,
0.030720925,
-0.0411765017,
-0.0688663572,
0.0461982153,
0.026883522,
-0.0031936578,
0.0605613105,
0.0103446022,
-0.0046501239,
0.0722506791,
0.0145117929,
0.0091167586,
0.0024249847,
0.0053076544,
-0.0175286904,
0.0686302334,
-0.0428901725,
0.0199209899,
0.0017356462,
-0.026891375,
0.0020161669,
0.0757491365,
0.0101460544,
-0.0391321629,
0.0267437287,
0.0117413513,
0.0127536757,
-0.0218298286,
-0.0127952397,
0.0456540547,
0.01352756,
-0.0374227948,
0.0011852359,
0.0328935869,
-0.0698728785,
0.0302681085,
0.0279857162,
-0.0506025329,
0.0085982028,
0.0109251868,
0.0425768122,
0.0088566989,
0.0024067422,
-0.0457697324,
-0.0429502763,
-0.0118971616,
0.0094932532,
0.0102702826,
-0.0153162098,
0.0134272557,
0.0340375453,
0.0281292163,
-0.0089620342,
0.013347703,
0.0124278646,
0.0106021492,
-0.015442295,
0.0449843295,
0.029675277,
0.0108310441,
-0.0397898033,
0.0104171783,
-0.0302178059,
-0.0040002954,
-0.000686553,
-0.0286663733,
0.0269607101,
0.0475665443,
-0.0319484062,
-0.0113334041,
-0.0382840745,
-0.0350757018,
0.0682379901,
-0.0150211575,
-0.0161688942,
-0.0322815292,
2.895e-7,
0.019678764,
0.0155125372,
0.0134695601,
-0.0493083782,
0.0211264044,
0.0244781189,
0.014411536,
0.0361398533,
0.031618949,
0.0088971211,
0.0317688324,
0.032344237,
0.0529745221,
0.0127060944,
-0.1008627191,
-0.0097703561,
-0.0429863781,
-0.023345748,
-0.0147647662,
-0.0300903264,
-0.023447156,
0.0297745448,
-0.0085837152,
-0.0181099363,
0.0189545229,
-0.0305008478,
0.0469751284,
-0.0275890846,
-0.0030616985,
0.0210720599,
0.0183855779,
0.0106693702,
-0.0256214477,
0.022994766,
-0.0326601714,
0.0150051601,
0.039615076,
0.0515325256,
0.0158818569,
0.0054706493,
0.0067298189,
0.0074477205,
0.0077954642,
0.0583315343,
0.0745052993,
-0.0892344788,
0.0025348754,
0.0292294975,
-0.0089886133,
-0.0138681261,
-0.0119410278,
0.0409910865,
0.0011288981,
0.0428406261,
-0.0146529442,
0.0115200765,
-0.0076115988,
-0.0634548664,
0.0285749827,
0.0000230446,
-0.0043164436,
-0.0846608505,
-0.0429735184,
-0.0531441793,
-0.0011628083,
-0.0639681965,
-0.0248160437,
2.552340093e-34,
0.0442206524,
0.0209268071,
-0.0225562807,
0.0303468127,
0.0004137023,
-0.0548356324,
-0.0122558046,
-0.0029428105,
0.0063026012,
-0.0419871919,
0.0159667358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03269v1 | Simple Rule Injection for ComplEx Embeddings | 2023-08-07T03:19:59 | 2023-08-07T03:19:59 | Haodi Ma, Anthony Colas, Yuejie Wang, Ali Sadeghian, Daisy Zhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent works in neural knowledge graph inference attempt to combine logic
rules with knowledge graph embeddings to benefit from prior knowledge. However,
they usually cannot avoid rule grounding, and injecting a diverse set of rules
has still not been thoroughly explored. In this work, we propose InjEx, a
mechanism to inject multiple types of rules through simple constraints, which
capture definite Horn rules. To start, we theoretically prove that InjEx can
inject such rules. Next, to demonstrate that InjEx infuses interpretable prior
knowledge into the embedding space, we evaluate InjEx on both the knowledge
graph completion (KGC) and few-shot knowledge graph completion (FKGC) settings.
Our experimental results reveal that InjEx outperforms both baseline KGC models
as well as specialized few-shot models while maintaining its scalability and
efficiency. | [
0.0370953009,
0.0177633297,
-0.014568409,
0.0656770393,
-0.0014634944,
-0.007345113,
-0.0484840646,
-0.0005616444,
0.0627672523,
0.0142582832,
0.0309402365,
0.0412313268,
-0.0268558823,
0.0167766549,
0.0384253114,
0.0057137646,
0.0192298032,
0.0154994503,
0.0194359347,
-0.0083848732,
-0.0128659345,
-0.0076487735,
-0.0046337289,
0.0137834614,
-0.0379705727,
0.015847493,
0.0047510448,
0.0024472468,
-0.0062105879,
0.0234154984,
-0.0037660219,
0.0150682656,
0.0040356824,
-0.0211401545,
0.0000019032,
0.0032474657,
0.0271765105,
-0.0023126351,
-0.0336027034,
-0.0100185964,
-0.0103092398,
-0.0499313921,
0.038985759,
-0.0405555815,
-0.0391387604,
-0.0505095534,
0.0577385724,
0.0640767664,
0.0334697738,
0.0497489423,
-0.0147837522,
-0.0281466544,
0.0325129963,
-0.0420589373,
0.0083273733,
-0.0427526794,
0.0249291379,
0.0115524828,
-0.0196258314,
-0.0280587878,
-0.0207763296,
0.0085218204,
0.0453956835,
0.0159357898,
0.0448463559,
0.0490733124,
-0.0153181823,
0.002034772,
0.0347532295,
0.0919806361,
-0.0247950684,
0.0022191943,
-0.0260142684,
0.0016139963,
0.0201948974,
-0.0170427766,
-0.0331305228,
-0.0430311114,
0.0015310323,
-0.0054737167,
0.0079361042,
-0.0059302519,
0.0663345978,
-0.032608863,
-0.0164391436,
0.0469858535,
0.0078423237,
-0.0297842566,
-0.0029929872,
0.0156362597,
-0.0226970501,
0.0012101405,
-0.0320656188,
0.0128034865,
0.0047121323,
0.0111873299,
-0.0123438034,
0.0604355596,
-0.0003748132,
-0.0157997385,
0.0196066443,
0.0431022458,
0.0053794701,
0.0773207843,
-0.0743837357,
-0.0116361137,
-0.0125915473,
0.0251783989,
-0.0473027527,
-0.0499416627,
-0.0373164602,
-0.0120440153,
-0.0033719139,
0.0429079197,
-0.0213274248,
-0.0436652005,
-0.0269883201,
0.0157424901,
-0.0551545247,
0.0479021519,
0.0041478528,
0.0045917979,
0.0105411522,
-0.02256798,
0.0205172449,
-0.0035816189,
-0.0806471258,
0.043306563,
-0.0250420533,
0.0204950403,
-0.0563450456,
-0.0205155201,
-0.007338292,
0.0007759742,
-0.0024210939,
0.0855785161,
0.0259095337,
0.0084631564,
-0.0289150123,
-0.0686860532,
-0.0003881017,
-0.0240693055,
0.0307661369,
-0.0340592451,
0.0631686151,
0.0024868152,
-0.021489948,
-0.0292787533,
-0.0011582987,
-0.0192025378,
-0.0720649883,
0.0572037213,
-0.0025704484,
-0.0367035754,
-0.0515095703,
0.0028956959,
-0.0797479525,
0.0640852898,
-0.0119648119,
0.0136513263,
-0.0049598515,
-0.0010974626,
-0.0142405648,
0.0157577638,
0.0627770126,
-0.0032166303,
0.0157159101,
0.014209602,
0.0150687909,
0.0298403129,
0.0054245871,
-0.0020499423,
-0.0539562739,
-0.0242852587,
0.0151772536,
0.0140906945,
0.049335368,
-0.0218383651,
0.0535883531,
-0.0418743975,
0.0024576809,
0.0065389359,
-0.0889852419,
-0.0032304518,
-0.039983362,
0.0073537994,
-0.0287647303,
0.0375501551,
0.0016145243,
-0.0412612893,
0.0273180716,
-0.0119940229,
-0.0027046036,
0.0073927394,
0.0585321225,
0.0227845144,
0.0152524039,
0.031545192,
0.0772018731,
0.0064436086,
0.011644288,
0.0347388797,
0.0163584724,
0.0437227674,
0.061560832,
-0.0270751845,
-0.0211940687,
0.0146108652,
0.0063405861,
-0.0100519704,
0.0310961679,
-0.0337546393,
0.0441856831,
-0.0489424802,
-0.0478568561,
-0.0063466863,
0.0402475931,
-0.0073292549,
0.0489687249,
-0.0241270419,
0.0193472896,
-0.0818105862,
0.0518295281,
0.0084565934,
-0.01770138,
-0.0146535616,
0.0020915784,
0.0207781848,
0.0280132852,
0.0064426041,
0.0091228914,
0.0088060796,
0.0357944593,
-0.0251878276,
-0.0563175604,
0.0070587499,
-0.026786916,
-0.0674158037,
0.0513480641,
-0.0507222451,
-0.0184978284,
-0.0373408347,
-0.0313515551,
-0.0188719612,
0.0172090884,
0.0073094466,
0.090077281,
-0.0296884645,
-0.0474271439,
0.0254095849,
-0.0200387873,
0.0050003869,
0.0752836913,
-0.0117049711,
-0.0271654353,
0.0253469311,
-0.0919043124,
0.0016880619,
0.0354080014,
0.0017489409,
-0.0232905969,
-0.0169069543,
-0.0046194182,
-0.0253244918,
-0.0259689055,
-0.0392689481,
-0.0139489751,
-0.0396848693,
0.0237367488,
0.0423786119,
-0.0259302743,
-0.03608853,
-0.0275490694,
0.0405257046,
-0.0271626487,
-0.0054690698,
0.0210670251,
-0.054385297,
0.0218161959,
0.0230014361,
-0.0160650723,
-0.023066083,
0.0183682945,
-0.0339623503,
-0.0457364246,
0.073675558,
-0.0080115255,
0.0651322007,
0.0145094795,
-0.016397804,
-0.0396613553,
0.0158597585,
-0.0317950137,
0.0043507963,
-0.00808849,
-0.0198418442,
-0.0035982195,
0.0552942306,
-0.0583030619,
-0.001645971,
0.0285336897,
0.0041296463,
-0.0261259489,
-0.0061951554,
-0.0433036797,
0.0355614312,
-0.0501707345,
0.044970952,
-0.0397181325,
-0.0035161164,
0.0081178965,
-0.0289107356,
-0.0888796225,
0.0478861555,
-0.00318778,
-0.0226611551,
-0.0151819233,
0.0033087684,
0.0271118339,
-0.0107469372,
-0.0402485058,
0.0011126328,
0.0912155211,
0.0181913674,
0.0004048838,
0.0283241887,
0.006868179,
-0.0376823246,
0.0212146081,
0.0182022881,
0.0114204856,
0.0394365229,
0.013599596,
-0.0419948362,
0.0046304557,
0.0422397703,
-0.0010513123,
0.0311960969,
0.0267433543,
-0.0255590994,
0.002063479,
-0.0327415504,
-0.0303901732,
-0.0291887149,
-0.0095252357,
0.0321566314,
-0.0114984708,
-0.0304755773,
0.0194868445,
-0.0196645129,
0.0044832956,
-0.01355311,
0.0025673721,
-0.0138778808,
-0.0519886427,
0.0293976013,
0.0369079225,
-0.0354596563,
0.0094181523,
0.0240475964,
0.0177897029,
0.043597132,
0.0113167232,
0.0079532098,
-0.0099307764,
0.0414787941,
-0.0168497544,
-0.0040803268,
-0.0117317215,
0.0149232578,
0.0127374008,
-0.0289647114,
0.0550384261,
0.0636421666,
-0.0137582505,
0.0136303175,
0.0195455048,
-0.0077990587,
0.010863116,
0.0354722142,
0.0060616503,
-0.0873021856,
-0.0265227035,
0.0170981213,
-0.0057279943,
0.0659005716,
-0.0521707013,
0.005923131,
-0.0986753628,
0.0029427917,
0.0408727005,
0.0010544169,
-0.042211853,
-0.0160415489,
0.0157280993,
-0.0259231329,
-0.040388193,
-0.0162903611,
0.0198975168,
0.0075406493,
-0.0288935732,
0.0008175534,
-0.0348071419,
0.0378733128,
-0.0614234507,
0.0702908635,
-0.0413635373,
0.0069145784,
-0.0021547175,
0.005065016,
-0.0365614519,
0.0222278386,
-0.0490528047,
0.0017388237,
0.0387596227,
-0.0022581327,
-0.0250754151,
-0.014002094,
0.0256767869,
-0.0505237505,
-0.0015059296,
0.003708659,
0.1307561547,
0.0388071276,
-0.0549962595,
-0.0236762986,
-0.0116010746,
-0.032074064,
0.0696164891,
0.0281266719,
0.010185645,
-0.0000910483,
-0.0294656195,
0.0037937362,
-0.0199767686,
-0.0128004756,
-0.0000559142,
0.0178752933,
-0.0063875611,
-0.043954514,
-0.0509513803,
0.0552001968,
0.0147267878,
0.0166191701,
0.0256027225,
0.0284455661,
-0.0378163941,
-0.014917207,
0.0067697866,
-0.0410323851,
-0.0100299465,
0.0416738652,
0.0375924259,
-0.0113463765,
-0.0140154501,
-0.0371813104,
-0.0111981593,
-0.0011895698,
-0.0587086044,
-0.0269907117,
0.052311644,
0.0084486883,
0.0862338096,
-0.0597252995,
0.031959001,
0.0584240817,
0.012593478,
-0.0165477116,
0.0033917534,
0.0803676322,
-0.0682462677,
0.040435385,
0.049931597,
-0.0561804101,
0.0091231279,
0.0150827048,
0.0388777442,
-0.0556825027,
-0.0039250068,
0.0058847931,
-0.0104263499,
0.0027725468,
0.0334543809,
-0.0189006049,
-0.030630257,
0.0123627307,
-0.0461668745,
-0.0080320742,
-0.0600060485,
-0.0287200399,
0.0307324957,
0.0236657057,
0.0264909361,
-0.0582429431,
0.0580723137,
0.0513504595,
-0.0009670567,
-0.0912058353,
0.0750438049,
-0.0412610024,
0.0430624038,
-0.0141908797,
-0.0274856482,
0.0506558232,
-0.0554249287,
-0.0154557014,
-0.0701957196,
-0.0167792737,
0.0504411459,
-0.038259618,
-0.0506706797,
-0.0200390033,
-0.0257914271,
-0.0029432331,
0.0035805192,
0.0178193524,
0.0848958269,
-0.0071007125,
0.0017062924,
0.0009292974,
-0.0212383792,
0.0189389028,
0.0355953313,
-0.0314810015,
-0.0253041424,
0.0395410955,
0.0313952081,
-0.0109781632,
-0.003808775,
0.04198597,
0.0266239103,
0.0939667597,
-0.0507404096,
0.0034621884,
-0.0327691622,
-0.0272908136,
0.0589300282,
0.0502404347,
-0.0181558765,
0.0615271144,
-0.0500490777,
-0.0856995359,
-0.0087664304,
-0.006464079,
-0.0694868118,
0.0134370998,
-0.021315597,
0.0274082515,
0.045639541,
-0.0877860337,
-0.0035568441,
-0.0196499955,
-0.0124587798,
-0.0208289791,
0.0233810898,
-6.472947805e-33,
-0.0191817433,
0.0064052199,
0.0285590142,
0.0058944249,
-0.0228902269,
-0.0163252018,
-0.0118316161,
-0.0501644164,
-0.0354262367,
0.049467206,
-0.0047065835,
0.0099143619,
-0.015543865,
-0.0074237953,
0.0218899716,
-0.0112826834,
0.0168064963,
0.0391704664,
0.0279210899,
-0.0005588625,
0.0131691191,
0.0256114919,
0.0358874388,
-0.0456086099,
0.0043486697,
0.017096173,
0.0194985773,
0.0535283983,
-0.0236439444,
0.0513059683,
-0.0141206952,
0.0247832164,
0.0305050183,
-0.0186039712,
-0.0025233661,
-0.0057264189,
-0.1117065847,
-0.0586421192,
0.0134594226,
-0.0192013234,
-0.0113408761,
-0.0185048413,
0.0462789237,
-0.012713748,
0.0821529329,
-0.0836520046,
0.0069308258,
-0.0271885078,
-0.0302508362,
0.0050027734,
-0.0612944514,
-0.0070946151,
0.0225302111,
-0.0120528424,
0.0047922423,
0.0062100086,
0.0487595573,
-0.0480899066,
-0.0747953579,
-0.01938756,
-0.047561314,
-0.0238076877,
-0.014047211,
-0.026809711,
-0.0106864423,
0.0234628431,
0.022544248,
-0.0211593751,
-0.0505806431,
0.0079447012,
0.000972188,
0.0600234754,
0.0158670861,
0.0201393012,
0.0165503323,
0.0067495038,
-0.0814566091,
-0.029026866,
0.0285406671,
0.0623068698,
-0.0101218866,
0.0060657277,
-0.068276383,
-0.0138048427,
-0.0460878946,
0.0005471419,
-0.0264340993,
-0.0220939554,
0.0078799548,
0.0271496847,
0.0050167283,
-0.0141654527,
0.0004446878,
-0.0669546947,
0.0455580167,
0.061720036,
0.0340848789,
0.0000984446,
-0.0031841574,
0.0290535819,
-0.0428303853,
-0.0230357591,
0.05108542,
-0.0559803285,
0.003843707,
0.0386567488,
0.0853002369,
0.0088785812,
-0.0085097477,
-0.031175606,
-0.0310586821,
-0.0548619032,
0.0295163002,
-0.0166366193,
0.0542688519,
0.0735947341,
-0.0110972384,
-0.0354199819,
0.0596064366,
0.0592910461,
-0.0039887107,
0.0189284626,
0.0457787216,
0.0183519088,
0.014953508,
-0.0131536638,
-0.030367123,
-0.0091658765,
0.0086190188,
-0.0242002476,
-0.014171822,
-0.0115532707,
2.722e-7,
0.032804545,
-0.0081469445,
-0.0123853805,
0.0934739262,
0.0004185613,
0.0440626927,
-0.0099731702,
0.0165097415,
-0.0080574201,
-0.0062586218,
0.043505989,
0.0424572118,
-0.0083807483,
0.0407742374,
-0.0876209885,
-0.0491048247,
-0.0032414449,
-0.0373472907,
0.0042028017,
-0.0243824981,
0.0553008318,
0.0756499544,
0.0863380209,
0.0014860528,
0.0033749007,
-0.0765247568,
0.0673291609,
0.0149825225,
-0.0085801361,
-0.0240444429,
0.0592323095,
0.0215681437,
0.0205881242,
0.0776636675,
0.0064027742,
0.0481882133,
0.0112748984,
0.0306751132,
-0.0152681628,
0.0262374151,
-0.0482619852,
-0.0504700802,
0.0099254511,
-0.0235405434,
0.099623926,
-0.0635843799,
-0.012219999,
-0.0143509423,
-0.0571703501,
-0.0352853388,
0.0057606832,
0.035360612,
-0.0012167692,
-0.0467419587,
0.0345719196,
0.0218463112,
0.0191783812,
-0.0473504551,
0.0062786597,
0.0490854047,
-0.0235534068,
-0.0379310846,
0.0313855559,
-0.0499336421,
0.0357485041,
-0.0606390461,
0.0121866167,
2.619658956e-34,
0.0203362126,
-0.0298996959,
0.0624356829,
0.0205254909,
0.0262962691,
-0.0427073799,
-0.0236029699,
-0.0394610129,
0.0380062498,
-0.0779094622,
-0.0048829443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03266v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03266v4 | SeACo-Paraformer: A Non-Autoregressive ASR System with Flexible and Effective Hotword Customization Ability | 2023-08-07T03:12:27 | 2023-12-25T08:44:15 | Xian Shi, Yexin Yang, Zerui Li, Yanni Chen, Zhifu Gao, Shiliang Zhang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Hotword customization is one of the concerned issues remained in ASR field -
it is of value to enable users of ASR systems to customize names of entities,
persons and other phrases to obtain better experience. The past few years have
seen effective modeling strategies for ASR contextualization developed, but
they still exhibit space for improvement about training stability and the
invisible activation process. In this paper we propose Semantic-Augmented
Contextual-Paraformer (SeACo-Paraformer) a novel NAR based ASR system with
flexible and effective hotword customization ability. It possesses the
advantages of AED-based model's accuracy, NAR model's efficiency, and explicit
customization capacity of superior performance. Through extensive experiments
with 50,000 hours of industrial big data, our proposed model outperforms strong
baselines in customization. Besides, we explore an efficient way to filter
large-scale incoming hotwords for further improvement. The industrial models
compared, source codes and two hotword test sets are all open source. | [
0.0374103151,
-0.0098941568,
0.0075194882,
0.0170973856,
0.0098438663,
0.0023051263,
0.0246910863,
-0.0321300514,
-0.058320649,
-0.0462357476,
-0.0083716828,
-0.0086978916,
-0.0328134671,
0.0444601364,
-0.0027000664,
-0.0089668296,
0.0429785214,
-0.0057413266,
0.0021983846,
0.023292955,
0.0325028561,
0.019151805,
-0.0010966345,
0.0453797914,
0.010598179,
0.0309052132,
0.0036656286,
-0.0076791784,
0.0203454532,
-0.0183073431,
0.0209159479,
0.0385939106,
0.0180606171,
0.0482049361,
0.000001969,
-0.0726953745,
-0.0572608374,
0.0171826407,
-0.0277332868,
-0.0085195862,
0.0549523979,
-0.0295796227,
-0.0198089834,
0.0235743802,
-0.0212376993,
0.0174601655,
0.0431762971,
0.0602578521,
0.0301574878,
0.0120674968,
-0.0191595983,
-0.070209913,
-0.0129737919,
-0.0236846097,
-0.0055073206,
-0.0418398902,
0.0142052742,
-0.0482158661,
-0.0356555507,
0.0217006691,
-0.0243886206,
0.0417764299,
0.0030791576,
0.0306266733,
0.0516421273,
0.0122058047,
-0.0175608248,
-0.011080524,
-0.0048553115,
0.0654821023,
-0.0022843431,
-0.0241910201,
0.027326012,
-0.0138862683,
-0.0296876226,
-0.0065481756,
-0.0216400176,
-0.0092727225,
-0.0068961321,
0.0076535568,
0.0180805773,
0.0289662704,
0.0093832714,
0.0215168167,
-0.0191027876,
0.0394868813,
-0.0052121202,
-0.0306982584,
-0.0168328136,
-0.0505629182,
0.0198023338,
-0.050774347,
0.0578778982,
0.0059254901,
-0.0337564461,
0.0312396809,
-0.0569014661,
0.003162703,
0.048076652,
-0.1155769154,
0.0191899948,
0.0011588654,
-0.0061004069,
0.0163010769,
-0.0267362464,
0.000492546,
0.0248389598,
-0.0106193945,
0.0012226397,
-0.0227072723,
-0.0425795838,
0.0057054679,
-0.0598101839,
0.0415348373,
-0.0335468128,
-0.0543263555,
-0.0658229068,
0.0261615142,
0.0071992464,
-0.0097289002,
0.0229610614,
0.0207973514,
-0.0272550955,
-0.001433367,
-0.0284518991,
0.0005945908,
-0.0059680981,
-0.0136025539,
-0.0039972533,
-0.0144523326,
0.0405565239,
-0.0095743686,
0.0576674528,
-0.026868837,
-0.0042935004,
0.0213407315,
-0.0096137505,
-0.0434293896,
-0.0494784862,
-0.0353517048,
0.0067807254,
-0.0014849211,
-0.0553913787,
-0.0265785865,
0.0103312396,
-0.0082581295,
-0.0021475113,
-0.0366521925,
0.0260597952,
0.0085104778,
0.0045301127,
0.1330689937,
-0.0414947905,
-0.0371103249,
0.0112233059,
-0.0189806614,
0.0475104265,
0.0581264161,
0.0568068847,
0.0340944827,
0.0421688668,
-0.0116690444,
-0.0008521195,
0.0006725284,
-0.0416046008,
-0.0436863974,
-0.0567603558,
-0.0091951722,
-0.0229108315,
0.0326876417,
0.0137044154,
0.0254631024,
0.0167785455,
0.004338556,
0.0264309905,
-0.0047312928,
0.0368482471,
0.0263596307,
0.0483281687,
0.0226937886,
-0.0549051985,
-0.0451687574,
-0.0101380115,
-0.0084398789,
-0.0360440835,
0.0174785741,
-0.016456306,
0.0059504188,
-0.012506742,
-0.0388039872,
0.0288611073,
-0.0124786934,
0.0173106659,
0.0261573121,
0.0557079799,
0.0182277393,
-0.0630807579,
0.0422942005,
0.022036409,
-0.0415097997,
0.0268865842,
-0.0346751623,
-0.0243976284,
0.0779695585,
0.0801435858,
-0.0169189293,
-0.0453286804,
-0.037180718,
-0.0049227187,
0.0558195077,
0.004258906,
0.0000954708,
-0.0036434876,
-0.0805709437,
-0.0538953058,
0.0419744775,
-0.0042893738,
0.0290430486,
-0.0125928735,
0.0102108717,
0.0584965274,
0.026376335,
-0.0402342826,
0.0118802497,
-0.0188702531,
-0.0505763218,
0.0146841127,
0.0121632135,
0.0083999848,
0.0416753814,
-0.010250181,
-0.0168716703,
0.0365125313,
-0.0213534273,
-0.0463152342,
0.0171176195,
-0.0726419687,
0.0051107677,
0.0025681821,
-0.0070922389,
0.0469612107,
0.0010403236,
-0.020281082,
-0.0774143636,
-0.0243589636,
-0.0199556258,
0.0788556933,
-0.0379708372,
0.0696710572,
-0.0002554804,
0.0448041894,
-0.019116709,
0.041071333,
0.0212346893,
0.0005630362,
-0.0455080606,
0.0514412895,
-0.0071245455,
-0.0746354312,
-0.0219274834,
-0.0075421054,
-0.010775594,
-0.0185738485,
0.0452369638,
-0.0083117709,
-0.034767136,
-0.0042777178,
-0.0626945496,
-0.0097363368,
-0.0219520293,
-0.0132324528,
-0.0182248466,
0.072152622,
-0.0091074463,
-0.023756884,
0.0015792408,
-0.036418464,
-0.0378617793,
0.0157658868,
0.0118018854,
0.0249371491,
-0.0623688772,
-0.0210857447,
-0.0019552936,
-0.007243616,
0.0162418559,
0.0513880886,
-0.0695643947,
-0.0497996919,
0.0279559251,
-0.0150024919,
0.0347315818,
-0.0027742258,
0.0047745341,
-0.0140309986,
0.0049959244,
0.0242429301,
0.0328119844,
0.0108484393,
0.0327341072,
-0.0307493415,
-0.013596328,
-0.0423791744,
0.0105217593,
-0.0476566181,
0.0053728749,
0.0187383555,
0.0040124161,
0.0383846536,
0.0355112925,
0.008422575,
0.0278212018,
-0.0311842002,
-0.012240787,
-0.0003013369,
-0.0588560887,
-0.0535283051,
0.0163394213,
-0.0623049252,
0.0131276594,
-0.007223608,
0.0091907298,
0.0282747038,
-0.0229351651,
-0.0075642816,
-0.0348610729,
-0.0472783968,
-0.0569601357,
-0.0074799657,
-0.0088898409,
0.0296749733,
0.0136466352,
-0.0694386959,
0.0304740984,
0.0108681824,
-0.0149204414,
-0.0438878238,
0.0406932496,
-0.0208072271,
0.0112482198,
0.0294542871,
-0.0051119518,
-0.0334211104,
-0.0055640512,
-0.0267986152,
0.048799172,
0.0296427328,
-0.0230753701,
0.0011001979,
0.0720973611,
0.0081850933,
0.0537690856,
0.0102466159,
-0.0105360448,
-0.0487906039,
-0.0059327944,
0.0989648476,
-0.0167503264,
-0.0120833283,
0.0651413426,
0.0165099297,
-0.002432005,
0.0663286746,
-0.042690102,
-0.036194209,
0.0013390768,
0.0107395435,
-0.0779855773,
0.0046199891,
-0.0145358033,
-0.0144213159,
-0.0153890913,
0.0224812422,
0.1093107387,
0.0462422967,
-0.0389777757,
0.0122797135,
0.0439299084,
-0.0148147354,
0.0396563075,
-0.0166401099,
-0.0750305802,
-0.0460140072,
0.0260216016,
0.0180668533,
-0.0019540081,
-0.0427074246,
-0.0160642192,
-0.0902592167,
0.0213517305,
-0.024213966,
-0.0644966513,
-0.0102961808,
-0.0451345742,
0.0197483469,
-0.0317881256,
0.0579685085,
0.0046775709,
-0.0184354018,
-0.0241706334,
0.0349498168,
-0.0264190231,
-0.0799135864,
-0.0112243863,
-0.0362921096,
0.0599303022,
0.0646688938,
0.0351287946,
-0.0076129017,
-0.0317568108,
0.0044277003,
-0.005003788,
0.0239063576,
-0.0457032621,
0.0045628967,
-0.0251770318,
-0.007644563,
-0.0354483165,
0.0032538809,
0.0007441774,
0.009552299,
-0.001847692,
0.0254539736,
-0.0089060972,
0.026217958,
-0.0081221806,
-0.0229127649,
0.0076033706,
0.0554592423,
0.0000526493,
-0.0293669868,
-0.0249939971,
-0.0003183395,
0.0245445203,
-0.0277937949,
-0.0338833928,
-0.0338167213,
-0.0821502581,
-0.0489152521,
-0.0389303938,
-0.0411396623,
0.050847128,
0.0414195284,
0.0071766768,
0.0842788368,
-0.0288544055,
-0.0050567477,
-0.0544310771,
-0.0163804479,
-0.0427601226,
0.0216664728,
-0.0732170269,
-0.0367232449,
0.0859348625,
-0.0064156912,
-0.0236901175,
0.0463386066,
0.0135292895,
-0.0477676652,
0.0461007506,
0.0090916706,
0.017499866,
0.0205195136,
-0.0330969468,
-0.1084400713,
0.0749503002,
0.0277096126,
-0.0162660889,
-0.0034410751,
0.0029462294,
0.0776094124,
-0.0006262669,
-0.0015211356,
-0.0421133451,
0.0238193776,
-0.0418301299,
0.0568973795,
-0.0254287515,
-0.0197769105,
0.0117860185,
0.0296173301,
0.0287399795,
-0.0358716398,
-0.0166337825,
-0.0259932056,
0.0474181101,
-0.0265948661,
0.0140611073,
-0.0134410867,
0.0321029797,
0.0029772117,
-0.008493457,
0.0018328688,
0.0386632904,
-0.0576501042,
-0.0108084008,
-0.0474328808,
0.0439364538,
0.0079789469,
0.0262316056,
0.0414807573,
0.0397956446,
-0.0075518307,
0.0317261107,
0.0815942436,
0.0260166749,
-0.0114043737,
0.0309842732,
-0.0151770236,
0.0053470796,
-0.0541407168,
0.063519679,
-0.033471752,
0.0306421462,
-0.040098004,
0.0789669007,
0.008833454,
0.0253493786,
0.0339132957,
0.0257827751,
0.0062711532,
0.0149036162,
0.0584474877,
0.0078428434,
-0.0189688727,
0.0436012,
0.0214187,
-0.0338278748,
0.03590234,
0.0470125116,
0.017899381,
0.0483536683,
-0.0214469098,
-0.0250783544,
-0.0697857589,
0.0226233862,
0.0277299918,
0.0184700489,
-0.0361969098,
0.0053624334,
-0.0180629473,
-0.0643350333,
0.0159166232,
-0.0330848768,
0.0118427007,
-0.0021711877,
0.0371230729,
0.0158112869,
-0.0066523449,
-0.0464508682,
-0.0073658437,
-0.0272231679,
-0.01731118,
-0.0324286111,
-0.0218733717,
-6.513684562e-33,
-0.0188495237,
0.021966232,
0.01538816,
-0.011193064,
-0.0009285843,
0.0190304089,
0.0090578878,
-0.0223924797,
0.0325763673,
-0.050110817,
-0.025536783,
0.0003068887,
0.0546000227,
0.0186185613,
-0.013473697,
-0.0252100229,
0.0821457356,
0.0407267399,
0.0331191085,
0.0141542703,
0.0238269046,
0.0562526882,
0.0607179739,
-0.0831797719,
0.0209620167,
0.022454625,
-0.0274876468,
0.0245587677,
0.0436672494,
0.0768381953,
-0.015078174,
0.0615541711,
0.0087674484,
-0.038035281,
-0.0080271354,
0.0275339037,
-0.0879498124,
-0.0081605343,
0.0053529544,
0.054681886,
0.0129854819,
-0.0397029184,
0.0649361759,
-0.0271337349,
-0.0293005407,
0.0792150497,
0.0436632633,
-0.0055055623,
-0.0423334315,
-0.0398180634,
-0.0386270434,
0.0262122396,
0.0119476113,
0.026149502,
0.0415722765,
-0.0097254831,
0.0226788465,
-0.0028165372,
-0.0844697505,
-0.023211712,
0.0652982667,
0.0080767525,
0.0638068616,
0.0748215988,
0.0086112004,
-0.0039165583,
0.0354916565,
-0.0131892245,
0.0194460172,
-0.0080673471,
0.0106687909,
0.0698134452,
-0.0035873943,
0.0406108983,
0.0427995995,
-0.0198607054,
0.0235056039,
0.0248886105,
-0.002318609,
0.0249051135,
0.0182337724,
0.0146828247,
-0.079765141,
-0.0024908881,
-0.0347531997,
0.0075312182,
-0.0472964905,
-0.0411168113,
0.0686424673,
0.049339693,
-0.0429859646,
0.0731762126,
-0.0045965463,
-0.0144982226,
-0.0086042834,
0.0031061319,
0.04205231,
0.0216963906,
-0.0045218319,
-0.0307064094,
-0.0384451263,
-0.0090913847,
0.0239587817,
-0.0062936791,
-0.0134541877,
-0.0396249853,
0.0071564522,
0.0356718674,
-0.063441366,
0.0072708167,
0.0125481701,
0.0157829672,
0.00081173,
-0.0430316739,
0.0012994501,
-0.0270317569,
-0.0611478724,
0.0376845598,
0.0751439556,
0.0081948098,
0.0124602038,
-0.0451243296,
-0.007621096,
0.0377942175,
-0.0343714245,
0.0137961637,
0.0044014864,
0.016568128,
0.0785176158,
-0.037714906,
-0.028554501,
-0.0074228109,
2.711e-7,
-0.0058688032,
0.0300883483,
0.0119228913,
-0.0143556967,
-0.0367018171,
0.0246684887,
0.0700277686,
0.0236924496,
-0.0061137178,
0.0578927137,
-0.006267841,
-0.0153634502,
-0.0108927535,
-0.0052334806,
-0.0953499153,
-0.0495241396,
-0.0693551376,
0.0550468713,
-0.0505519286,
0.0276800916,
0.0641495287,
0.0850691423,
0.0251107179,
-0.0414280184,
-0.0209294446,
-0.0385798179,
0.0078360606,
-0.0348834358,
0.0047088531,
0.0257928185,
-0.0018616788,
0.0171921402,
-0.0273957364,
-0.0055612451,
-0.0210008658,
0.018180104,
0.0134173166,
0.0190945324,
-0.0562035777,
-0.0162326582,
0.0203894898,
-0.0101603502,
0.0149563607,
-0.0406718962,
0.0936264992,
-0.0185423438,
-0.0092224516,
-0.0097788004,
-0.0486666337,
0.0191790648,
-0.0099925986,
-0.0201932769,
-0.043208614,
-0.0084764762,
0.0160363652,
0.0154877705,
-0.0653237179,
-0.1108510643,
0.0128576206,
-0.0113254683,
0.0034625574,
0.0188699774,
-0.0299587548,
-0.0317042246,
-0.0149277588,
-0.0320576206,
0.0248938166,
2.418539449e-34,
0.0219463538,
0.0420454256,
-0.0142652858,
0.044040028,
0.05244454,
-0.0025774199,
0.0029038866,
0.0550568849,
0.0059099142,
-0.0902069435,
-0.0321531519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03253v2 | PaniniQA: Enhancing Patient Education Through Interactive Question Answering | 2023-08-07T02:18:23 | 2023-08-21T02:41:29 | Pengshan Cai, Zonghai Yao, Fei Liu, Dakuo Wang, Meghan Reilly, Huixue Zhou, Lingxi Li, Yi Cao, Alok Kapoor, Adarsha Bajracharya, Dan Berlowitz, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Patient portal allows discharged patients to access their personalized
discharge instructions in electronic health records (EHRs). However, many
patients have difficulty understanding or memorizing their discharge
instructions. In this paper, we present PaniniQA, a patient-centric interactive
question answering system designed to help patients understand their discharge
instructions. PaniniQA first identifies important clinical content from
patients' discharge instructions and then formulates patient-specific
educational questions. In addition, PaniniQA is also equipped with answer
verification functionality to provide timely feedback to correct patients'
misunderstandings. Our comprehensive automatic and human evaluation results
demonstrate our PaniniQA is capable of improving patients' mastery of their
medical instructions through effective interactions | [
0.0751946867,
0.0008230217,
-0.0269990247,
-0.0482481346,
-0.0155346273,
0.0384395011,
0.0039189816,
0.0015153207,
0.0291538332,
0.0160420202,
0.003786365,
-0.029484557,
0.014690768,
0.0084445383,
0.005554283,
-0.0419130996,
0.0092057409,
0.0279224608,
0.0381916538,
-0.0031102244,
0.0068968809,
-0.0058736284,
-0.0778195783,
0.0361106582,
0.0361834094,
-0.0190917905,
-0.0125554623,
0.0087295724,
0.0123708164,
-0.0986057371,
0.008246501,
0.0247081313,
-0.045483999,
-0.0444044769,
0.0000020403,
-0.0567264035,
0.005960457,
0.0230471957,
-0.1281934083,
-0.0385250598,
-0.0217114948,
-0.0235553496,
0.0323927328,
0.0128123974,
-0.0045063123,
-0.0392790623,
0.0422277711,
0.0573099442,
0.0771084726,
0.0172932781,
-0.0152556458,
0.0291732065,
-0.0215870328,
0.0009040884,
0.0648900419,
-0.0354090184,
0.0001083275,
0.0317389406,
0.0641225204,
-0.0650800392,
0.0184442122,
0.0281649232,
-0.0024479295,
0.0329394713,
0.0250841193,
0.0457584076,
0.0209963284,
-0.0065026642,
-0.0024965534,
0.0567166544,
0.073661305,
0.0008296506,
0.0174662061,
-0.0059223548,
0.0136962878,
0.0291694906,
-0.0680340528,
-0.0328739919,
-0.0578554198,
-0.057778243,
-0.0398576371,
0.0067218696,
-0.0006707302,
-0.0096534519,
0.0029632114,
-0.0254794881,
0.0230949298,
-0.0284649469,
-0.0095109101,
-0.0042621396,
0.0449024662,
-0.0505644754,
0.0849811062,
0.0759614184,
-0.0328025967,
-0.0172178317,
0.0041079018,
-0.0421692766,
0.0882511884,
-0.0245659202,
0.005705718,
0.0214714371,
0.0165602472,
0.0443661287,
0.0173452441,
0.0320371985,
0.0172024202,
-0.0138333933,
-0.0347238779,
-0.0082326392,
-0.0495301969,
-0.0533855259,
-0.0384411812,
0.0349220596,
0.0199526679,
0.012333109,
-0.0639538467,
-0.0142787565,
0.0273794997,
0.0625790581,
0.0283053964,
0.0334140137,
-0.0281427726,
0.0078004198,
-0.0296026636,
0.0079905866,
-0.0734108314,
-0.0114053944,
-0.0016970328,
-0.0383884348,
0.0180987231,
-0.0117051909,
0.021407539,
0.0277879704,
0.0223215185,
0.0576111972,
-0.0207680613,
0.0013390337,
-0.0145213315,
-0.0457297303,
-0.0072312048,
0.0044095302,
0.0139837842,
-0.0441279262,
0.0403142907,
0.0161461402,
-0.0344160534,
-0.0144711733,
0.036434073,
0.0437479503,
-0.0249204785,
0.0471307337,
-0.0642776042,
0.0204129685,
0.0688165799,
0.0340122692,
0.0032757977,
-0.0180434659,
0.0216998644,
0.0050070775,
0.0146442894,
-0.0233326741,
0.0591356009,
-0.0079021286,
0.0172093678,
-0.073384732,
0.0633448884,
0.0518314205,
-0.0097349146,
0.0580068193,
-0.0649506599,
0.0666847676,
0.0026642855,
0.0396138094,
0.0131440451,
0.0774420947,
-0.0086936625,
-0.0316107944,
-0.0211838726,
-0.0228841864,
0.0250334404,
-0.008469658,
-0.0023338245,
0.044746127,
0.0759990439,
0.0115939798,
-0.0027089212,
-0.0149768498,
-0.0438088253,
-0.0597121418,
-0.0328263193,
-0.0019320176,
-0.0224332139,
0.0321871005,
0.026956277,
0.0055377171,
-0.0243802536,
0.0695019066,
0.0460066721,
-0.0501963384,
-0.0057898723,
-0.0509237759,
0.0450371653,
0.1195201874,
0.0426404811,
0.0020747308,
-0.0586179979,
-0.043570593,
-0.0067915963,
-0.0069339625,
0.0114605157,
-0.033045508,
-0.0150338346,
-0.0448948443,
-0.0192488767,
0.0543300584,
-0.0141289169,
-0.0130275069,
0.0017499716,
0.0184523799,
-0.0338937864,
-0.0510973223,
-0.0284807328,
0.0424360521,
-0.0346260481,
-0.0290139876,
-0.0197577849,
0.027363766,
-0.0124191148,
0.0503145643,
0.0129352072,
0.0291198473,
0.0446864739,
-0.0198951904,
-0.0040064496,
0.0017382546,
-0.0302822217,
-0.0088822609,
0.0094857868,
-0.0323530957,
-0.0102164,
-0.0512329042,
-0.0082864566,
-0.0242075156,
-0.0553063639,
-0.0789416134,
0.0150024332,
-0.0221198518,
-0.0159508344,
0.0723429695,
-0.0402548388,
-0.0453267805,
0.0191307887,
-0.0106085418,
0.0060005859,
-0.0083094826,
-0.0202854034,
0.0009080262,
-0.0286203586,
0.0283316821,
0.0065974882,
-0.0397508889,
0.0000832506,
-0.0259958319,
0.0147806546,
-0.0404706486,
0.0272580739,
-0.1258690655,
-0.0304578021,
0.0033284663,
0.0098225055,
0.0360166505,
0.0477475896,
-0.0166986734,
-0.0683809146,
-0.0367306247,
-0.0085883746,
0.0300328266,
-0.0072792359,
0.0283335298,
0.0457227044,
0.0268771425,
-0.0096375849,
-0.0119225001,
-0.0251888912,
0.0184344165,
0.0214363784,
-0.0165682007,
-0.0084184259,
-0.0876516253,
-0.0312266294,
-0.0394340456,
0.022022184,
-0.0304809846,
0.0183980018,
-0.000689004,
0.0091516767,
0.0337685682,
0.0264217556,
-0.0044891238,
-0.008288838,
-0.0105546461,
-0.0367221162,
0.0226885024,
-0.0043678116,
-0.0131900599,
0.0374346711,
-0.0656257197,
0.0063703903,
0.0278751869,
0.0362161361,
0.0228111651,
-0.0077417581,
-0.0063338303,
-0.0170088671,
0.0421960726,
-0.0862845406,
0.0306863319,
-0.0500058681,
0.0328249373,
0.0062089036,
0.0002734549,
0.0766589642,
0.0072845076,
0.0185741521,
-0.0847687945,
-0.016292844,
-0.0301410984,
0.0209241658,
-0.0733205825,
0.0259467587,
0.0525093712,
-0.0461920761,
-0.0004649865,
-0.0232501887,
-0.0144953933,
-0.0534250401,
0.030115582,
-0.0101578627,
0.0131479306,
0.0161624048,
-0.0253658146,
-0.057772778,
0.0005480935,
-0.0339063443,
-0.01560318,
-0.038902849,
-0.007549216,
-0.0348353274,
-0.007584373,
0.0316401944,
0.0236426815,
0.0287769251,
-0.0218815561,
0.0184171684,
0.0200010706,
0.0493927449,
0.0260824542,
0.0059905839,
-0.033041779,
0.0181743894,
0.0843981579,
-0.0001869148,
0.0085534332,
0.0625114366,
-0.0280505978,
0.0121975299,
-0.0597992502,
0.0022851806,
0.014541721,
0.0318143591,
-0.0419773199,
-0.0009552527,
0.0729941204,
0.0490748324,
-0.0385218747,
0.0231859218,
-0.0410051718,
-0.0372393318,
-0.0019710073,
0.033986222,
-0.0766275376,
-0.0276394449,
0.0046874639,
0.0862631425,
0.0178859122,
0.0176556259,
0.003504937,
-0.0093716215,
0.0211834703,
-0.0290129129,
-0.015538482,
-0.031983681,
0.0060375775,
0.0157773774,
0.0252271201,
-0.013828693,
0.0201260578,
-0.0133707048,
0.0082698846,
0.0144506227,
-0.0458527245,
-0.0100384476,
0.0389820337,
-0.0037046042,
0.0227256157,
0.0787223727,
0.0224431716,
0.008644552,
-0.0414289162,
-0.0391603038,
-0.0491168424,
0.0047152876,
0.0007950444,
0.0635092035,
0.0191405099,
0.0022106788,
-0.0673684552,
0.0580707006,
-0.0203016736,
-0.0243059844,
0.0446764193,
0.0223906077,
-0.0454721786,
-0.0122061661,
-0.0358787477,
0.0356281362,
0.0226919707,
0.0374954455,
0.0214852151,
-0.0264442153,
-0.0342119858,
-0.0049771215,
0.0370954163,
-0.0117126172,
0.0164345335,
0.0035705795,
-0.0083871549,
-0.0204767864,
-0.069879353,
-0.0479179882,
0.0744745508,
0.0103661073,
0.0141820125,
-0.0159799214,
0.0192858316,
0.0499100797,
-0.047283873,
-0.0075911512,
0.0100017171,
-0.0038311242,
-0.0755839497,
-0.0611605234,
0.0130986348,
-0.0060057677,
-0.0193474926,
-0.0159766562,
0.0143197151,
0.0360272862,
0.0329691656,
0.0389027745,
0.0158113781,
-0.0509467311,
0.0066961912,
-0.0008951475,
0.0248560589,
0.0224096682,
-0.0300711244,
-0.0284021236,
-0.0339838453,
0.033050485,
-0.0168747343,
-0.0209005475,
-0.0353283323,
-0.0010460349,
-0.0230486989,
0.0185029004,
-0.0285098515,
-0.0035392758,
0.0352857374,
0.0354817323,
-0.0159609411,
0.0007013567,
-0.0374274962,
-0.01366637,
0.0585716292,
0.0248960145,
-0.0156105878,
-0.0035100377,
-0.0213237591,
-0.0168296751,
-0.0254569016,
0.0201889127,
0.0154935196,
-0.0294749346,
-0.0308909975,
-0.0520086139,
-0.0034511113,
0.0297051612,
0.0258590207,
-0.0087134549,
-0.031674955,
-0.0052358815,
0.0018652296,
0.020111572,
0.0443419963,
0.0043660458,
0.0911593735,
-0.0293866601,
-0.0160865076,
0.007537927,
0.0489675961,
-0.0302956402,
-0.0781540275,
0.0190555211,
0.0446801856,
0.0325897262,
0.0497614518,
-0.0550609492,
0.0116061075,
0.0009865212,
0.0013129354,
-0.0054656141,
-0.0181391761,
0.0165118854,
0.0385656655,
0.0310340282,
0.0146076269,
-0.0383162573,
0.0534390956,
-0.044671122,
0.0451251343,
-0.0293287691,
-0.0245344713,
-0.0554484539,
0.0010571657,
0.0072017005,
0.0180600621,
-0.050754115,
-0.0154905133,
-0.0457234979,
-0.0116738547,
0.0227508228,
0.0348066576,
-0.0253937989,
-0.0185256861,
0.0974738151,
0.0117234821,
0.0206742585,
-0.0604874119,
-0.0222612508,
0.0810961872,
-0.0454787351,
0.0194203481,
-0.0311909094,
-5.75114909e-33,
-0.0213493742,
-0.0469887853,
0.014481633,
-0.0137571413,
0.0239175428,
-0.0270032808,
-0.0492990091,
0.0071334951,
-0.005628081,
0.0114335604,
0.0029201072,
0.0155801633,
0.0093480619,
0.0375799946,
0.0038883865,
-0.0682041645,
0.0555041283,
0.0123543423,
-0.0353910998,
0.0564168245,
0.0016603313,
0.059358228,
0.0199788846,
-0.0272006262,
0.023716934,
-0.0212997552,
0.0199137758,
-0.0003314239,
-0.0366637148,
0.0625746474,
-0.0188351497,
0.0158272162,
0.0385944657,
0.0360326096,
0.0033904084,
0.0668875799,
-0.1107098162,
-0.0437709577,
-0.0167972799,
-0.0245380346,
-0.072941795,
-0.0341892056,
0.056398578,
-0.0158274267,
-0.0129060065,
0.0015217623,
0.0384749696,
0.0064267041,
0.0212157946,
-0.0247165989,
0.0014717048,
0.0034066592,
-0.0155503368,
-0.0125051811,
-0.0682717264,
0.0447816439,
-0.0209950972,
-0.0269362051,
-0.0553970337,
0.0016283215,
0.0270624366,
0.0255330075,
0.0167008508,
-0.0150753772,
-0.0263881255,
0.0155824739,
0.0278463997,
-0.0364691764,
-0.0319077857,
0.0373983122,
-0.0613370948,
-0.0194016937,
0.073769249,
-0.0061695813,
0.024885593,
-0.006880125,
-0.0653999969,
0.0620784983,
-0.0439300537,
0.0901174843,
0.0088343946,
-0.0226572733,
-0.0546012037,
0.0110388538,
-0.0190136898,
0.0463207327,
-0.0288428199,
-0.0323875956,
0.0408121012,
-0.0000961667,
-0.0272771847,
-0.0386638343,
-0.0478253737,
0.013096733,
0.0562031828,
-0.0147245759,
0.0730475932,
-0.0028698286,
-0.0028127581,
-0.0451078899,
-0.0410818681,
0.0617820024,
0.0033822777,
-0.0150213968,
0.0256290995,
0.0484049059,
-0.0087430561,
-0.0486394428,
-0.0353474841,
0.0138540426,
0.0393303446,
0.0453685038,
-0.0207987148,
-0.0104776779,
0.0353184417,
0.0367821492,
-0.009250802,
0.0737676099,
-0.0218218435,
-0.0229114629,
-0.0769688711,
-0.0451410562,
0.0205738991,
0.0103311613,
-0.041083131,
0.0218070783,
-0.0730443969,
0.0644108281,
-0.0284298901,
-0.0101424372,
0.0389668606,
0.0342059992,
2.717e-7,
0.0547840483,
0.0213186331,
0.0503225885,
-0.0013434171,
0.0025501254,
-0.0038343931,
-0.0051079551,
-0.032022059,
0.0046243593,
-0.0299656186,
0.0394105576,
0.0074119419,
0.007917027,
0.032335151,
-0.0545144305,
-0.0510870107,
-0.0311172102,
-0.0103998194,
-0.0401051752,
0.0022366024,
0.0940479115,
-0.0026207548,
-0.0590629876,
-0.0129789812,
-0.0005115651,
0.0330763906,
0.0241153724,
0.0056172102,
0.0175610911,
0.0167438127,
0.017348554,
-0.0170573983,
0.0136239305,
0.0326850004,
-0.0123572582,
-0.058175385,
0.011422921,
0.0610343888,
-0.0317111909,
-0.0267347395,
-0.0334923603,
-0.01633735,
0.029312985,
-0.0205453523,
0.0495595783,
-0.0382834598,
-0.0253383238,
0.0271706749,
-0.0410166085,
-0.0087380763,
0.0483671986,
0.0124346586,
-0.0605662093,
0.005670669,
0.013894178,
0.0359229334,
-0.0089662438,
-0.0259701926,
0.0157890804,
0.0244025812,
-0.0193385612,
-0.0096991612,
0.0257297419,
-0.0476549268,
-0.0674115941,
-0.0438465849,
-0.0174369793,
1.975570933e-34,
-0.021360958,
0.0160173345,
0.0021225766,
0.0268115401,
0.0226588622,
-0.0011396727,
0.0501856357,
0.0240162369,
0.0591154248,
-0.0513807125,
-0.0153077189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03235v1 | Analysis of the Evolution of Advanced Transformer-Based Language Models: Experiments on Opinion Mining | 2023-08-07T01:10:50 | 2023-08-07T01:10:50 | Nour Eddine Zekaoui, Siham Yousfi, Maryem Rhanoui, Mounia Mikram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Opinion mining, also known as sentiment analysis, is a subfield of natural
language processing (NLP) that focuses on identifying and extracting subjective
information in textual material. This can include determining the overall
sentiment of a piece of text (e.g., positive or negative), as well as
identifying specific emotions or opinions expressed in the text, that involves
the use of advanced machine and deep learning techniques. Recently,
transformer-based language models make this task of human emotion analysis
intuitive, thanks to the attention mechanism and parallel computation. These
advantages make such models very powerful on linguistic tasks, unlike recurrent
neural networks that spend a lot of time on sequential processing, making them
prone to fail when it comes to processing long text. The scope of our paper
aims to study the behaviour of the cutting-edge Transformer-based language
models on opinion mining and provide a high-level comparison between them to
highlight their key particularities. Additionally, our comparative study shows
leads and paves the way for production engineers regarding the approach to
focus on and is useful for researchers as it provides guidelines for future
research subjects. | [
0.0380099639,
0.057969626,
-0.0103672612,
0.0512806214,
-0.055509571,
0.0057595819,
-0.000583998,
-0.0346065573,
-0.0181423537,
-0.0277574006,
-0.0228951089,
-0.0515104942,
-0.017311858,
0.0254657511,
-0.0462690517,
-0.0083494559,
0.0061014532,
0.0523094349,
0.0220463146,
0.0049724719,
-0.0088852812,
0.0157643221,
0.0209877491,
0.0269547664,
0.0077187791,
-0.0046942434,
0.0162038822,
-0.0345893838,
0.0084890192,
0.0115392292,
0.0096061109,
0.0093044331,
-0.0217349045,
0.0461296886,
0.0000020093,
-0.0026014219,
-0.0165252201,
-0.0039740652,
0.0408335775,
-0.0059581124,
0.0859759152,
-0.0235406831,
-0.0310296658,
0.0294762049,
-0.0454599261,
-0.0402875543,
0.0376389697,
0.0955438018,
0.0673404336,
0.0636062846,
-0.0294207595,
-0.0214197841,
0.0160420183,
-0.0220367294,
-0.0336377434,
-0.012181866,
0.0247887913,
-0.0519135669,
-0.0225744043,
-0.0160370078,
-0.0205808822,
0.0206414387,
0.0269887354,
-0.0032462364,
-0.0418908335,
0.0033969001,
-0.0123113152,
-0.0059426362,
-0.0249659177,
0.0245767068,
-0.0466760769,
-0.013507762,
-0.0216879193,
-0.0094232531,
-0.0022372468,
-0.0088827182,
-0.0236758981,
0.045705568,
0.0025686091,
0.0414583348,
0.0062901857,
0.0316683799,
0.0136728929,
0.0151509512,
-0.0370657817,
0.080269888,
-0.0239570886,
-0.0465233587,
0.0379675925,
0.0332768187,
-0.0118365418,
0.0094410144,
0.0419507474,
0.0176310223,
0.0437942743,
0.0095705604,
0.0031760293,
-0.0301291943,
-0.0179340132,
-0.1087922007,
0.0155879622,
0.0230549946,
-0.0347387455,
0.0329802632,
-0.0292569287,
0.0435746238,
-0.0272236746,
-0.0134531045,
-0.008324692,
-0.0066553177,
-0.039374236,
0.0049277903,
-0.0048254034,
0.0350794978,
-0.0389825255,
-0.0189744681,
-0.0521733277,
0.0197484829,
-0.0168573223,
-0.0120695634,
0.0415335447,
0.034836486,
0.020570254,
0.0081052631,
-0.0440620221,
0.065001525,
0.0122734085,
0.021677237,
-0.0206202231,
-0.0392307229,
0.0202469323,
0.029319739,
0.0145590715,
-0.0076832753,
0.0140623134,
0.0354367271,
0.0022603027,
-0.0369450115,
-0.0409415364,
0.0105263898,
-0.0326689444,
-0.0295314547,
0.0107637886,
-0.0611078329,
0.0240846947,
0.0035309638,
0.0048686741,
-0.0183626097,
0.0164971258,
0.0162703358,
-0.029707307,
0.0229751375,
-0.0118927956,
-0.0076256581,
0.0024140624,
-0.0044447798,
0.0350233763,
0.0459199622,
0.0337886065,
0.0784686506,
0.0272087324,
-0.0225359593,
0.0438158251,
0.0057907808,
-0.0541934669,
-0.0538829677,
-0.0146187292,
-0.0444377512,
-0.0770821869,
-0.0178228505,
-0.0108558908,
0.0906236395,
0.0115419747,
-0.0309341103,
0.0676283613,
-0.0162154194,
0.0082761887,
0.0916162059,
0.0274161454,
0.0128195882,
0.0054542786,
-0.0053138202,
-0.0130784111,
0.0250855573,
0.0211079307,
-0.017111117,
-0.0311342347,
0.0273870956,
-0.0221160892,
-0.0769596696,
0.0126278987,
-0.0196183585,
0.0339306854,
-0.0205616634,
0.0608062185,
0.023754105,
-0.0846520513,
0.0364394672,
0.0262800343,
-0.077020742,
-0.028207384,
-0.0323079228,
-0.0087715844,
0.0499283783,
0.0067431806,
-0.0054160422,
-0.0092560472,
-0.0437417813,
-0.0187486988,
0.0319607593,
0.0357825682,
0.0256330241,
-0.02235936,
-0.0449094027,
0.0305425301,
0.0130105242,
0.0066901944,
-0.0092092277,
-0.041975908,
0.0322577395,
0.0022969749,
0.0086022373,
-0.0376506001,
0.0147403646,
0.015039674,
0.0143673951,
0.0277108159,
0.0183737557,
0.0054356246,
0.0323256738,
-0.017212037,
0.005256495,
0.0531611815,
-0.0371920802,
-0.0875433609,
0.0525375605,
-0.0030187943,
-0.0008837882,
0.0055200439,
-0.0551390871,
0.0325130932,
0.0687495917,
-0.0117732361,
-0.0172004923,
0.0262993388,
-0.0507775471,
0.0513166338,
-0.0073475265,
0.0484831482,
-0.0536049157,
0.0238150917,
-0.0126364203,
0.0554071516,
-0.0429776311,
0.0019159107,
-0.046616707,
-0.0338492356,
-0.0026764756,
0.0014506134,
-0.0856001154,
0.0266923662,
0.0028436834,
0.0206690934,
0.0305520948,
-0.0204320382,
0.0100129582,
-0.0597327128,
-0.0760726333,
-0.0068844017,
-0.0110774413,
0.0264125671,
-0.0082097165,
0.0090069417,
0.0038308017,
0.0621199124,
-0.0114913695,
0.027374316,
-0.0080670146,
0.0124709541,
0.0470424145,
0.0068251383,
0.003393088,
-0.0506713092,
-0.0262424238,
-0.0278036259,
0.0426722392,
0.0302172191,
0.0089554256,
-0.0526417159,
0.0324454904,
-0.0044985148,
0.0257807784,
-0.013384887,
-0.074276939,
-0.0011404336,
-0.0210067332,
0.0237193629,
0.0535515137,
0.0459711626,
0.0820918083,
0.0202603098,
0.0268907547,
-0.0127449762,
0.0234506596,
-0.0973203182,
0.0171686597,
-0.0393108763,
0.0047453875,
0.0252834409,
0.099681057,
-0.0179322679,
-0.0112919658,
-0.0311515965,
0.0006048928,
-0.0061754584,
0.0098660355,
0.0711919665,
0.0062755751,
0.0094503053,
0.021399444,
0.0044873082,
-0.0080214487,
0.0454177596,
-0.0067284848,
-0.0135217095,
-0.0880931094,
-0.0384922959,
-0.042457331,
0.0304994956,
0.0115973307,
0.0210431628,
-0.0287857037,
0.0110787675,
0.0092702201,
0.0026880512,
-0.0491950475,
-0.0286228564,
0.0419648997,
0.0153528964,
-0.0202867631,
0.0373674855,
-0.0312564671,
-0.01219365,
-0.0369879343,
-0.0518285893,
-0.0049099573,
0.0626842231,
-0.0415473692,
-0.0397960469,
0.0160733629,
-0.0091835409,
-0.013044198,
0.0157898981,
-0.0304835737,
0.010825919,
0.0146508431,
0.0427896865,
-0.0381409824,
0.058609996,
0.0260393806,
0.0133251892,
0.0704999641,
0.0208724439,
0.0123578282,
-0.0618754365,
-0.0481751598,
0.0291057341,
-0.0317346454,
-0.0057347799,
-0.0360792428,
-0.0125359725,
-0.0625147596,
0.0135679794,
0.1128377691,
0.0284716934,
-0.0590392314,
0.0195790809,
0.0306905638,
-0.0387823097,
0.0148595851,
0.0007443428,
-0.0489991531,
-0.0031527297,
-0.0298358873,
0.006017881,
-0.0088885268,
-0.0152762253,
0.019115584,
-0.1133255288,
0.0188706089,
-0.0453897081,
-0.0143684251,
-0.0502584875,
-0.0216952395,
0.000990374,
-0.0322662778,
-0.0007358306,
-0.0305861849,
0.0055989479,
-0.0175293721,
0.0258223861,
-0.0409467742,
-0.0237726774,
0.0158012025,
-0.0379275456,
-0.0019273271,
0.0325874873,
0.0759065747,
-0.0587961972,
-0.0711678416,
0.0205373298,
-0.0090409014,
0.0088924849,
-0.0165161975,
0.0376079753,
-0.0257471483,
-0.0534820147,
-0.0124778952,
-0.0146877393,
-0.04594386,
0.0357936658,
-0.051543802,
0.0626205727,
-0.0162119009,
-0.0859589353,
-0.0127728302,
0.0368592814,
0.0150859756,
0.0513874851,
-0.0031355519,
-0.0973278433,
-0.0424291193,
-0.0213625357,
0.0263473094,
-0.0438767858,
-0.0698438287,
-0.0070005869,
0.0598117225,
-0.0579181463,
-0.068158783,
-0.0175372995,
-0.002735242,
0.0200663842,
0.0006787894,
-0.0378186479,
0.0519399941,
-0.0070807333,
-0.0567442216,
0.008264089,
0.0391736329,
0.0103703719,
-0.0464012325,
-0.0127723133,
0.0839469805,
-0.0109417168,
-0.0377851687,
-0.0142895123,
-0.0560079813,
-0.0297627915,
0.0416049473,
0.0413361117,
0.0153502757,
-0.0219321474,
-0.0042680586,
-0.028008651,
-0.0139880497,
0.0544235073,
-0.0320569612,
-0.0019987989,
0.047543399,
0.0140871508,
-0.0009200187,
0.0073707402,
0.0029662976,
0.0429290794,
0.0115194898,
-0.0098023154,
-0.0238330085,
-0.0686636865,
0.0063234642,
-0.0351531804,
0.0750292465,
0.0553355552,
-0.0040882952,
-0.0093370769,
0.0057111289,
0.0190844089,
-0.0108948844,
-0.0552387945,
-0.0343218967,
0.0157475732,
0.0316640995,
-0.0519341379,
0.0262988899,
0.0142116994,
-0.005395391,
-0.0145201935,
0.0887312219,
0.0311402697,
0.0188004356,
-0.0054789553,
0.0414297655,
-0.0145308021,
-0.0430679135,
0.0300408676,
0.0276021212,
0.0105062621,
0.0433506556,
0.0051682102,
-0.00878694,
-0.0185208544,
0.0439528935,
-0.0682394952,
-0.0080360267,
-0.0170029961,
-0.0177522711,
0.0018554099,
-0.0549061708,
0.0412077457,
-0.0279835816,
0.0143768881,
-0.0196127817,
0.0056366683,
-0.0294815376,
-0.0060901078,
0.0043336516,
-0.0027814361,
-0.03307252,
-0.006613296,
0.0403390452,
-0.0526061766,
0.0384847745,
0.0506517515,
-0.0164443627,
-0.0367982313,
-0.0132058468,
0.0470860898,
-0.0245389305,
0.02097762,
0.0101493746,
-0.0533856414,
-0.0260504559,
0.0618867055,
-0.0242306981,
0.0384182557,
-0.0542324819,
0.0150735443,
0.0772503242,
0.0149079598,
0.0466285013,
-0.0592871346,
0.0123637142,
-0.0350879058,
-0.0055305017,
-0.0311475135,
-6.049843307e-33,
0.0239957254,
-0.0063797883,
-0.0427144207,
0.0729225799,
-0.0262386054,
-0.0174771417,
-0.0162486415,
0.0116226487,
-0.0329789482,
0.0501654744,
-0.0150495041,
0.0396483354,
0.0040178481,
0.0330941193,
0.0160670429,
-0.0104274461,
0.0567731783,
0.0048447708,
0.0090281656,
0.0135972472,
0.0426365323,
0.0400098301,
0.070230335,
-0.0799748972,
0.0177835859,
0.0030234556,
-0.0097396346,
-0.0040679644,
0.0264318883,
0.0759185627,
0.0083676847,
0.0633022785,
0.0233949907,
-0.0834159926,
0.0107323378,
0.0386536606,
-0.0353641547,
0.01506087,
-0.0277317278,
0.0344838463,
-0.0038398572,
-0.0162121505,
0.0616284199,
0.0335434601,
-0.0242924616,
-0.0051582344,
0.0290726963,
-0.020121621,
0.0205831528,
-0.0961433649,
-0.0401387587,
-0.0010570864,
-0.0115331775,
-0.0061877775,
0.0488958247,
0.0244240202,
0.0019663589,
0.0546612479,
-0.094337672,
0.0281953998,
-0.0067112409,
0.0213283189,
0.0040888181,
-0.0433619097,
-0.0137918619,
0.0654352754,
0.0240677502,
0.0010537505,
-0.0252250563,
0.0469442196,
0.0241575316,
0.0437445082,
0.0598254278,
0.01440957,
0.0204313006,
-0.0345004462,
-0.0282372069,
0.0139908483,
0.0438149497,
0.0276017245,
0.0887887105,
-0.0034220233,
-0.0470119007,
-0.0139024798,
0.0238154102,
-0.0288257729,
-0.0309393443,
-0.0141556868,
-0.0114209093,
-0.0050227647,
-0.0433730856,
0.0371388756,
-0.0057068607,
-0.0941550434,
0.0057918495,
0.038464468,
-0.0457703024,
0.0481691994,
-0.004601582,
0.018639911,
-0.0375026651,
-0.0151066929,
-0.0337376371,
0.0420174561,
0.0015163022,
0.0054718363,
0.0092338799,
0.0449467599,
-0.0835826769,
-0.0164852925,
-0.0184068829,
0.0182304326,
0.0009958727,
0.0749273151,
-0.0262715742,
0.0150512233,
-0.0383005142,
0.0356381536,
-0.0034323114,
0.0501208492,
-0.0188069101,
0.0147404773,
0.0153450901,
0.0000252719,
-0.0368616097,
-0.0566033758,
-0.0044206991,
0.0264158789,
0.0002482578,
-0.0694327727,
-0.0165736284,
-0.0140304305,
2.673e-7,
0.0461392887,
0.0533327237,
0.0090121021,
-0.0298648756,
0.0301062483,
0.0401149318,
0.0347616635,
0.003734492,
0.0238504913,
0.0077199978,
0.0105127431,
0.0190915968,
0.0043838201,
0.008239463,
-0.0892389119,
-0.0217951667,
-0.0531532094,
0.004679875,
0.0114262253,
0.0153502794,
0.06725014,
0.1158196628,
0.0192128774,
-0.0134160481,
-0.0367808044,
-0.0006452501,
0.0350505188,
-0.0509902798,
0.0230403841,
0.0407511815,
0.0137444958,
0.002622427,
-0.0409906618,
-0.0376941077,
0.0109092221,
0.0347699113,
0.0177963879,
0.0363124497,
0.0185062736,
-0.028421944,
0.0408513211,
0.0088481829,
-0.0142543279,
-0.0274782386,
0.0625634566,
-0.0915163383,
-0.0528681539,
-0.060350351,
0.0039423686,
0.0204964653,
0.011209311,
-0.0197659377,
0.0081210304,
0.0006076198,
0.0047830339,
-0.0254380088,
-0.0340166017,
-0.0767945424,
0.0001091459,
0.0026066408,
-0.0304307267,
-0.0181668065,
-0.0178893916,
0.0049073282,
0.0295254104,
0.003319188,
0.0256702602,
2.039777491e-34,
0.048723489,
0.0296449196,
-0.0283324607,
0.0280600619,
0.0259548463,
0.0148744872,
-0.0041574547,
-0.0109375939,
-0.0146012949,
-0.0570672639,
-0.0068231006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03234v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03234v2 | Automated Distractor and Feedback Generation for Math Multiple-choice Questions via In-context Learning | 2023-08-07T01:03:04 | 2024-01-11T18:59:58 | Hunter McNichols, Wanyong Feng, Jaewook Lee, Alexander Scarlatos, Digory Smith, Simon Woodhead, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multiple-choice questions (MCQs) are ubiquitous in almost all levels of
education since they are easy to administer, grade, and are a reliable form of
assessment. An important aspect of MCQs is the distractors, i.e., incorrect
options that are designed to target specific misconceptions or insufficient
knowledge among students. To date, the task of crafting high-quality
distractors has largely remained a labor-intensive process for teachers and
learning content designers, which has limited scalability. In this work, we
explore the task of automated distractor and corresponding feedback message
generation in math MCQs using large language models. We establish a formulation
of these two tasks and propose a simple, in-context learning-based solution.
Moreover, we propose generative AI-based metrics for evaluating the quality of
the feedback messages. We conduct extensive experiments on these tasks using a
real-world MCQ dataset. Our findings suggest that there is a lot of room for
improvement in automated distractor and feedback generation; based on these
findings, we outline several directions for future work. | [
-0.0006160513,
-0.003988395,
-0.0280117486,
0.033859808,
-0.020028742,
0.0214823708,
0.035331022,
-0.0271616355,
0.0388783142,
-0.0459113903,
0.0121546155,
-0.0172354486,
-0.0488413684,
-0.0191060081,
0.0319278911,
-0.0584245212,
-0.004306396,
-0.0533954091,
0.0231513213,
0.0236503948,
-0.0038782926,
-0.0232555848,
-0.0289937817,
0.0141111109,
-0.0254157539,
-0.0922009945,
-0.0231238753,
-0.0210669879,
0.0142692253,
-0.0378074124,
0.0251422375,
0.0674334243,
-0.0328209624,
0.01290025,
0.0000022365,
-0.0642747357,
-0.0088200439,
-0.0090216845,
-0.0311041959,
0.0178392772,
0.0078043472,
0.0574740395,
0.0104542654,
0.0163946431,
-0.0469302833,
0.0276376735,
0.0327992924,
-0.0032670447,
0.0925857946,
0.0458545797,
0.0056419689,
0.0263178293,
0.0117026484,
0.0021578055,
0.0724145621,
-0.0211168136,
0.0035980826,
0.0409580916,
-0.0257388484,
0.0394622572,
-0.0572430342,
0.0201265588,
0.0409497097,
-0.0294877067,
0.0022257287,
-0.019347081,
-0.0039774617,
0.000600935,
-0.0131638655,
0.0843668506,
-0.0210278779,
-0.014452111,
-0.0138863912,
-0.0380997434,
0.0381611772,
0.0443372317,
-0.0731820241,
0.0097180642,
-0.0418342389,
-0.0383593068,
0.0020335359,
-0.0374202356,
-0.0205915011,
0.0121671082,
-0.0202757679,
-0.0328081064,
0.0349829085,
-0.0571618676,
-0.0267726835,
0.0200257618,
-0.0486419797,
-0.0632973015,
0.0369933322,
0.0329312272,
-0.0534343496,
0.0112162894,
-0.0396870375,
-0.0991485044,
0.0038561216,
-0.0322363153,
0.0220011007,
0.0293080341,
-0.0153303975,
0.0087434547,
0.0168385953,
0.0934603512,
-0.0098171402,
0.0306808706,
-0.0287953336,
0.0329412632,
-0.0295623969,
0.0015453761,
-0.0079309912,
0.0387842283,
0.0217542835,
0.0147523182,
-0.0345968157,
0.0286218133,
-0.0585814714,
0.0766052008,
-0.0072365887,
-0.0216746423,
-0.0163681507,
-0.001781558,
-0.030255571,
0.0251580086,
-0.028297985,
-0.0181499962,
0.0206230227,
-0.018670097,
-0.0218903571,
0.0783047453,
0.0042146202,
-0.0115047386,
0.0074889343,
0.0808251873,
-0.0039080633,
0.0008073454,
0.0181462448,
-0.0284137763,
0.0070805126,
-0.0285982229,
-0.0082623204,
-0.0486770906,
-0.0153839188,
0.0270768385,
-0.0279773418,
-0.0313194655,
0.0222821943,
0.0516697802,
0.0706843436,
0.0154202636,
0.0284403525,
-0.024720775,
0.0574086271,
-0.0150547195,
-0.0235462673,
0.0480597205,
0.0454256125,
0.0223293528,
0.0762011558,
-0.0462954566,
0.0588953234,
0.0300345737,
0.0101246033,
0.010483305,
0.0077872165,
0.0113616027,
0.0354738794,
0.0270082876,
-0.0357578695,
0.0543309972,
-0.0014128413,
0.0320141688,
0.0438943356,
0.0220792647,
0.0032571161,
0.0227229614,
0.0345402099,
0.0167018268,
0.0075618969,
0.0462135151,
-0.045899421,
0.028094003,
-0.0418601893,
0.017000204,
0.0393941067,
0.0136771491,
-0.0086060846,
-0.1106258631,
-0.006929554,
0.0153828058,
-0.0214478895,
0.0593123734,
0.0748216659,
0.010089742,
-0.0504183359,
0.0324866958,
-0.0024417415,
-0.0482949428,
0.0112209199,
-0.0487698913,
0.0863869861,
0.023922516,
0.0520378426,
-0.0761450231,
-0.0538488925,
-0.0195168294,
0.0172727015,
0.0419350937,
0.0452467911,
-0.0491829254,
-0.0437341481,
-0.0557496995,
-0.0195551608,
-0.0190306474,
0.0079268767,
-0.0244786087,
0.030479366,
-0.0022674908,
0.0218299478,
-0.0169410203,
-0.0576622523,
0.0372137763,
-0.0052792118,
-0.0810114443,
0.0061797658,
0.0087418752,
0.0018892557,
0.0187778808,
0.0204831343,
0.0213354453,
0.0196534507,
-0.0199491326,
0.0180455204,
-0.0340106487,
-0.0678454638,
-0.0411461592,
0.0660899505,
-0.0221237279,
-0.0154357478,
0.0008988957,
-0.0514756851,
-0.0072112526,
0.0308396723,
-0.0400666781,
-0.0003346383,
0.0125817908,
0.0299921595,
-0.0018852397,
-0.0545938462,
-0.0296593532,
0.0861497968,
0.029983893,
0.0410302989,
0.0327400528,
0.053765934,
0.0264340229,
0.0091751898,
0.0285672396,
-0.0311119091,
-0.0224602968,
0.0317785814,
0.0088214278,
0.0316661857,
-0.0778841302,
-0.0108933253,
-0.0182650499,
0.0037609984,
-0.017671423,
0.0249718223,
0.0308189895,
-0.0114695709,
0.0004953771,
-0.0214107912,
-0.0562835597,
0.0003285396,
-0.0169716142,
-0.0159541722,
0.0157032125,
-0.013069056,
0.0075937798,
-0.0548963472,
-0.0166269615,
-0.0332969576,
0.0371934958,
0.0533718243,
0.0334362015,
-0.0364528671,
0.0434108935,
0.0026025868,
0.0008458187,
0.02675163,
0.0418780483,
0.0369323418,
-0.0490874164,
0.0787108392,
0.0547683053,
0.0066636954,
0.0628948212,
0.0154286204,
-0.0081844758,
-0.0807712153,
0.028918881,
-0.0255560912,
-0.0309927631,
0.0200280938,
-0.0287770797,
0.0274280962,
0.0561169237,
0.0335761793,
-0.0493456572,
-0.0365929604,
0.0451430567,
-0.0476869084,
-0.0094722817,
-0.0586649887,
0.0035767471,
-0.0169478692,
0.0403387956,
0.001969968,
-0.0381372124,
0.0782508999,
0.010440642,
0.008321912,
-0.0698458552,
0.0183123834,
-0.0359886661,
-0.0099313259,
-0.0099714715,
-0.0083567575,
0.0171665847,
-0.0035337766,
-0.0470466465,
0.0024134174,
0.0419414826,
-0.0502084978,
0.0469849855,
-0.0808443576,
-0.0390291177,
0.0358473882,
-0.0205713324,
-0.05913423,
0.0089069512,
0.0264618304,
-0.022637412,
0.0050320113,
-0.008059429,
-0.0070996988,
-0.0344801284,
0.0424473174,
0.0224519279,
-0.0435012057,
-0.037441548,
0.000611674,
0.0590062961,
0.0483380146,
0.0182129219,
0.0247791875,
-0.0793475434,
0.0089181839,
0.0473521501,
0.0535821542,
0.0010374372,
0.0265468433,
-0.0106237084,
0.0261722989,
-0.0385031514,
0.037726447,
0.0371876955,
0.0535501055,
-0.0575533733,
-0.0534959286,
0.0875227004,
0.0507375039,
-0.045814123,
-0.0102510899,
-0.0561597161,
-0.0079955896,
0.0238100234,
-0.005610921,
-0.0558033176,
-0.0264849234,
-0.017806327,
0.0318851359,
0.0042156442,
0.007919278,
0.0300585087,
-0.1242180541,
0.0352446921,
0.0082279602,
-0.0165364146,
-0.0183078628,
-0.0250478704,
-0.0013830165,
-0.0056664641,
-0.012804863,
-0.0034176488,
0.0281453598,
0.0228807721,
0.0443144888,
0.0072850897,
-0.0342999808,
-0.0376451686,
-0.0113469306,
-0.0333775543,
0.0145455627,
-0.0120348493,
-0.0174562708,
-0.0647942349,
0.0281053539,
-0.0354087949,
-0.0443892479,
0.0047523146,
0.0205926932,
-0.008830877,
-0.0117718512,
-0.0590128787,
0.059324719,
-0.0331508629,
-0.0286350623,
0.1106031165,
0.0684800372,
0.0048100254,
-0.0060262508,
-0.015498857,
-0.0037949434,
0.0300822575,
0.0432765931,
0.0472530946,
-0.0954032093,
0.0252927057,
-0.0721362308,
0.0451615378,
-0.0653446391,
-0.0082306582,
-0.0122922314,
0.0172551423,
0.0054345741,
-0.032100305,
-0.0386016443,
0.063538529,
0.008427415,
0.0214268658,
-0.0342158377,
0.025461318,
-0.0073115425,
-0.0153416116,
0.0044612712,
0.0061599743,
0.0036950079,
-0.0216370262,
-0.0159343295,
-0.0335072987,
-0.0001276534,
-0.0214837436,
0.0477893353,
-0.1049696133,
-0.0369006395,
-0.0208082478,
0.0642275587,
0.0100106625,
-0.0168487821,
-0.0072845756,
0.0085329963,
-0.0052120583,
-0.0180932004,
-0.0133429384,
-0.0076663294,
-0.0151570514,
0.0028687818,
-0.0070857345,
-0.0126273641,
-0.0278044995,
-0.0041488623,
0.0281897206,
0.0379059613,
-0.055913642,
-0.000724998,
0.0483272932,
0.0074403146,
-0.0274600871,
-0.0140517643,
-0.0092583131,
-0.0255551133,
0.0364157259,
-0.0209602825,
-0.0563334152,
-0.0017048233,
0.0043551661,
0.0156048983,
-0.0472139977,
0.0209976584,
-0.0143485721,
-0.0239552092,
0.0369602889,
-0.0237513762,
0.0649093539,
-0.0041779354,
0.0364296325,
0.0462244339,
-0.0168617014,
-0.017434122,
-0.012432361,
0.0269966405,
0.0511388183,
0.0162446722,
0.0975183696,
0.0176435057,
-0.0128015364,
0.0547671169,
-0.0081477482,
0.0036448492,
-0.0360591412,
-0.0439359136,
0.0522036739,
0.0066433968,
0.0201527774,
0.0011907261,
0.0088591911,
-0.0193748865,
-0.0174855981,
0.0413631126,
0.032095518,
-0.0176026523,
-0.0020449753,
0.0284751598,
0.0535671599,
-0.0447568558,
0.0467591994,
-0.0411827751,
-0.0115035931,
0.0047747251,
-0.0028442948,
-0.0680857599,
0.0238959305,
-0.0107541839,
0.0308036972,
0.0221739523,
0.0357082859,
-0.0760738999,
-0.0619723573,
0.0139935799,
0.0331855863,
0.0203849636,
-0.0118048713,
0.0274693035,
0.0602937602,
-0.028809255,
-0.0020193001,
0.0052097877,
0.0749206468,
-0.0826409757,
-0.0368847512,
-0.0555233285,
-5.577011357e-33,
-0.0440386087,
-0.0746988729,
0.0189054161,
0.0093751578,
0.0294399448,
-0.0350926183,
-0.0429898277,
0.0308513567,
0.0111625781,
0.001129661,
0.0230786894,
0.0101811001,
-0.0212770458,
0.0653663725,
0.0174340196,
-0.0282675549,
0.0165382233,
-0.0104308855,
-0.0310180057,
0.033908613,
0.011622455,
-0.0328230411,
0.0365026295,
-0.0445651785,
0.0358167961,
-0.0571337231,
0.0058763959,
0.0007196383,
-0.0628617555,
0.057197284,
-0.024813259,
0.0807094052,
0.0135480333,
-0.0461085401,
-0.0066353674,
0.0333411098,
-0.0130494619,
-0.0749062449,
-0.0176314972,
-0.0042298282,
-0.0564938411,
-0.0613360628,
0.0223820433,
0.0156098418,
-0.0284286905,
-0.0205092318,
0.067929022,
-0.0024744635,
-0.0097760549,
-0.0040821955,
-0.0797008798,
0.0172375161,
-0.0657936633,
-0.0160406027,
-0.0147299496,
0.0868542865,
0.0047754887,
0.0166594964,
-0.03398389,
0.0496735536,
0.0572731085,
0.0094769737,
0.0460784845,
0.0111723663,
-0.011687994,
0.0250379518,
0.0154904248,
0.0033151028,
0.0149577176,
-0.0247959681,
0.0005995004,
0.0145556405,
0.0978860483,
0.0509689488,
0.0181055591,
0.0070355628,
-0.0505374372,
0.0293277632,
-0.0382663012,
0.0209379941,
0.0178256668,
-0.0406306349,
-0.0446261726,
0.0078292424,
-0.0495480932,
-0.019049285,
-0.0532327741,
0.0002067828,
0.0599750355,
-0.0344557352,
-0.0187751707,
0.0070091286,
-0.0146420961,
0.0037413843,
0.0041632275,
-0.0194488131,
-0.0145963253,
0.0436829999,
-0.0143295489,
-0.008237374,
-0.0196599923,
0.0106203966,
-0.0027008564,
-0.0022643884,
0.0238597952,
0.0242441073,
0.0081960522,
-0.0100807594,
-0.0457604788,
0.0015274468,
-0.0435349159,
0.0113766743,
0.0372399017,
-0.0043727676,
-0.0016122003,
0.0229180269,
-0.0292125605,
0.0364265293,
0.0138104586,
-0.0226907507,
-0.0145018203,
-0.0309971105,
-0.0091118412,
0.0004526001,
-0.0328203402,
-0.0453639776,
-0.0064786137,
0.0033038761,
0.0382878706,
-0.0669755191,
0.0032791195,
-0.0289408863,
2.644e-7,
0.0394214131,
0.061873097,
0.0048710392,
0.0178126842,
-0.0020043761,
0.0528636426,
-0.0001018694,
-0.0257204901,
0.0524700992,
-0.0086394334,
-0.0212447047,
0.0290642884,
0.000658755,
0.0101539949,
-0.0580831766,
0.0075421259,
0.0207538195,
-0.0035105888,
-0.0339086577,
0.0571237244,
0.1058438346,
0.0249519311,
0.0144411493,
0.0042462177,
-0.0177762751,
-0.0001251788,
0.0103932777,
-0.0052696709,
-0.0185554922,
0.0240557864,
0.0047812425,
-0.0290244687,
0.0082590142,
0.0275585372,
-0.0102607282,
-0.0433907658,
0.0368770249,
0.0308913887,
0.0263855997,
-0.0074407305,
-0.0308367852,
0.0265396629,
0.0275392514,
-0.041995924,
0.0136301676,
-0.0344745889,
0.0000659159,
-0.0033047658,
-0.0341560431,
-0.0305829197,
0.0001904865,
-0.0133653246,
-0.0084197996,
-0.04300607,
0.005118941,
0.0257876907,
0.0186022557,
0.006183207,
-0.019805165,
0.0455063209,
-0.009060692,
-0.0397634581,
-0.0535910986,
-0.0391286165,
0.0086508747,
-0.0045706499,
0.0089845145,
2.360726249e-34,
0.0473551676,
0.0058131604,
0.0652901977,
0.0261916891,
0.0113513237,
-0.0220032968,
-0.0043510357,
0.0212578978,
0.0577692837,
-0.0727480501,
-0.0085326377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03228v1 | Why Linguistics Will Thrive in the 21st Century: A Reply to Piantadosi (2023) | 2023-08-06T23:41:14 | 2023-08-06T23:41:14 | Jordan Kodner, Sarah Payne, Jeffrey Heinz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present a critical assessment of Piantadosi's (2023) claim that "Modern
language models refute Chomsky's approach to language," focusing on four main
points. First, despite the impressive performance and utility of large language
models (LLMs), humans achieve their capacity for language after exposure to
several orders of magnitude less data. The fact that young children become
competent, fluent speakers of their native languages with relatively little
exposure to them is the central mystery of language learning to which Chomsky
initially drew attention, and LLMs currently show little promise of solving
this mystery. Second, what can the artificial reveal about the natural? Put
simply, the implications of LLMs for our understanding of the cognitive
structures and mechanisms underlying language and its acquisition are like the
implications of airplanes for understanding how birds fly. Third, LLMs cannot
constitute scientific theories of language for several reasons, not least of
which is that scientific theories must provide interpretable explanations, not
just predictions. This leads to our final point: to even determine whether the
linguistic and cognitive capabilities of LLMs rival those of humans requires
explicating what humans' capacities actually are. In other words, it requires a
separate theory of language and cognition; generative linguistics provides
precisely such a theory. As such, we conclude that generative linguistics as a
scientific discipline will remain indispensable throughout the 21st century and
beyond. | [
0.0086720157,
0.0860969648,
-0.0576903783,
-0.0053891591,
-0.050969325,
0.0196436811,
-0.0089500155,
0.0155865112,
-0.0088868598,
-0.0230710357,
0.0035377999,
-0.0529043823,
0.0014995242,
-0.0069752592,
0.0842873603,
-0.0596324243,
0.0457706824,
-0.0501526669,
0.0149049908,
-0.0174311604,
-0.0477904938,
-0.0096504958,
-0.0285044685,
0.0065581012,
-0.0147504136,
-0.0169362184,
-0.0037499748,
-0.0464186817,
-0.036309965,
0.0049662017,
-0.0323259868,
0.0332792737,
0.0190463252,
0.0579409897,
0.0000021059,
-0.0592652075,
0.0762332156,
-0.0187166054,
-0.0535217971,
-0.0118871536,
0.0503507592,
-0.013647913,
-0.0398070589,
-0.0306663308,
-0.0665415525,
-0.0348305106,
0.0267697293,
-0.0337601639,
-0.0696203411,
0.0617870502,
0.0038302746,
-0.0595497601,
0.0684533194,
-0.0123784328,
0.0399215557,
0.0097126998,
0.0124181435,
-0.0164283328,
0.0304409172,
0.0031558143,
-0.0635300875,
0.0564117096,
0.0450108908,
-0.0095641762,
-0.0049592862,
0.0476609059,
0.0116592851,
-0.0603546277,
0.0149184735,
-0.0018287225,
0.0405193307,
-0.0399514139,
0.0121419774,
0.0116998572,
0.0019582575,
0.0274695605,
-0.0626609921,
0.0712706223,
0.0196650978,
0.0379494913,
0.0686035678,
-0.0555528067,
0.0467912182,
0.037455909,
0.0213763677,
0.0778358802,
-0.0010868403,
-0.0126595413,
-0.0056831827,
0.0422840081,
0.026371792,
-0.0451699272,
-0.0419667587,
0.0037602342,
-0.0127133057,
0.0293597504,
-0.0135731157,
0.0058903699,
0.0227272306,
-0.0254353844,
0.0164773744,
-0.0046443515,
-0.0234954506,
0.0160366017,
0.0007761151,
0.0189412739,
-0.0130554521,
0.0449923128,
-0.052948188,
0.0150203183,
-0.0524299182,
-0.0559249036,
-0.0064973575,
0.0092111919,
-0.0278697684,
0.0183049608,
0.0053834021,
-0.0004622097,
0.0188342407,
-0.0303185508,
-0.0293867327,
-0.0043281275,
-0.0540073477,
-0.0044608535,
-0.0485391468,
-0.001255276,
-0.0096438527,
0.0382757448,
0.0043517798,
-0.0734197572,
-0.0099375192,
0.0328133553,
-0.0249590352,
0.0136904726,
-0.0094312541,
0.0365682133,
0.0148872444,
-0.0401648581,
-0.0130796032,
0.0036367795,
-0.046620179,
-0.0708507001,
0.0419257991,
-0.0332538262,
0.0041826996,
0.0129777072,
-0.002484363,
-0.0751046985,
-0.0334480256,
-0.0076724258,
-0.0302197151,
0.0149478754,
0.0001952297,
0.0465094335,
0.0131865712,
0.0030335404,
0.0524965897,
0.0446417741,
0.035956271,
-0.0473633111,
0.0067257131,
-0.0328067206,
0.0028951499,
0.0120936558,
-0.0169689786,
-0.0077626379,
-0.0198375434,
-0.0358211398,
-0.0168778002,
0.0159705076,
0.0680399463,
0.0577947646,
-0.0001413514,
-0.0077159153,
0.0763313919,
0.0709596872,
-0.0218899325,
0.0547831841,
0.0992018357,
-0.0077133565,
0.0327801928,
0.0402610824,
-0.0025948775,
0.0062400289,
-0.0288414918,
0.0096963951,
-0.01318096,
0.0109653277,
-0.0168692805,
-0.0324590765,
0.0010561321,
-0.0080940593,
0.0131964395,
0.0217868332,
0.0627180934,
0.0173049327,
0.005225468,
-0.0170886703,
0.0442381538,
-0.0245881248,
0.0429198779,
-0.0589633733,
0.0528072789,
0.0131072756,
0.000044329,
0.0148359817,
0.0201277751,
0.0306228995,
-0.0027779483,
0.0969422311,
0.0260998681,
-0.0005619508,
-0.0184582416,
0.0076712789,
0.0347262397,
-0.0225287229,
0.02736778,
-0.0142577905,
-0.0602348708,
0.0017470046,
-0.0307314657,
-0.0110839307,
-0.0215712506,
0.04234685,
-0.075078167,
-0.0135183334,
-0.0505221821,
-0.0159540754,
0.0281515475,
0.0213021282,
0.0010718469,
0.0371293016,
0.0365277752,
-0.0187314674,
0.0215755552,
0.021911772,
-0.0679150596,
-0.0120026655,
0.016692834,
-0.0544372946,
0.0013677931,
-0.0102010369,
0.0132428622,
-0.0368345156,
0.091415979,
-0.0461878031,
0.0619187467,
-0.0109777553,
0.0323279612,
-0.0205900595,
0.0234853551,
-0.008492332,
0.0662005469,
0.0184109081,
0.0186946411,
-0.0210088715,
0.0199073162,
0.0226812791,
-0.0620614365,
-0.0176739097,
0.0386232026,
0.005246534,
-0.0101890489,
-0.0060147354,
-0.007645064,
-0.0680563748,
0.0124246832,
-0.0429341234,
-0.0214995183,
0.0326156393,
0.0233470611,
0.0089020273,
-0.0495568216,
-0.0104263537,
0.0145652955,
-0.0119137233,
0.0090773338,
0.0323153324,
-0.009722407,
-0.0025118953,
-0.0241128355,
-0.0366345383,
-0.0238406025,
-0.0008607219,
-0.0237415414,
0.014004508,
0.0352721699,
-0.0083863838,
-0.0325558446,
0.0143341068,
-0.0469275601,
-0.0107463477,
-0.0082527967,
-0.024988208,
0.0378219076,
0.0086923577,
0.0420669019,
0.0497833118,
-0.0102442028,
0.0448127463,
0.026422929,
-0.0021255778,
-0.028732067,
-0.0261645503,
-0.0416485481,
-0.0320865884,
-0.0485873669,
-0.0188430864,
-0.0235091839,
0.104014501,
0.0418648459,
-0.0321950279,
-0.0241107792,
0.072003819,
-0.0377557389,
-0.0258187037,
-0.0024608884,
-0.0362036936,
-0.0550453924,
0.0360419862,
-0.045529753,
-0.0820024908,
0.0455000065,
0.0057084691,
-0.0207319576,
-0.0231548045,
-0.0072407015,
0.03707885,
0.0673291534,
0.0433439128,
-0.0060662446,
0.0685485005,
-0.0047160541,
-0.0834125951,
0.0284752231,
0.0132143265,
-0.0226262808,
0.0134269409,
-0.102316387,
0.0106760832,
0.0234090947,
-0.0157429557,
-0.0225179046,
0.0196864847,
-0.0237122234,
0.0614882857,
0.0217521507,
0.0165554043,
-0.0280572157,
-0.052849669,
0.0466195233,
-0.0010715461,
0.0199552849,
0.0009943771,
-0.0190344732,
-0.0038330853,
0.0157738682,
0.0088446904,
0.0158616249,
-0.0286835115,
0.0032891457,
0.0502739958,
-0.0156906601,
0.0589609891,
0.001236394,
0.0545640215,
0.0279873628,
0.0061235726,
-0.0753971487,
0.0158997662,
0.0143635962,
-0.0366746113,
-0.0210872162,
0.0778261498,
0.0140117388,
-0.004974016,
0.0486734174,
-0.0021538015,
-0.0161121767,
0.0265923496,
0.0056704539,
-0.0623333678,
0.0380223468,
0.0085595809,
0.0140903173,
-0.0360006876,
-0.0271517336,
-0.0120172566,
-0.1026447788,
0.0347608142,
0.0329832137,
-0.0445041023,
0.0301824808,
-0.0246775132,
-0.0202174932,
0.0472513959,
0.0248595588,
0.0338590033,
-0.011082801,
0.016131293,
0.0323869027,
-0.0119544938,
-0.0892945975,
-0.0098504676,
-0.0072818329,
0.0658971965,
0.0250570811,
0.0399135053,
-0.0474849604,
-0.0553669445,
0.0389077812,
-0.0004520255,
-0.0057935468,
-0.005308209,
0.0078702802,
0.0586349554,
-0.0165069439,
-0.0710387677,
0.0322513618,
-0.0161002576,
-0.0379964933,
-0.003485817,
0.1000790745,
-0.0050943196,
-0.0685294569,
0.0040250337,
0.0086642355,
-0.0487601347,
0.065482527,
0.0437931828,
-0.0326934196,
-0.0036938137,
-0.0340538546,
-0.0035949734,
0.0051747509,
-0.0986238569,
0.0674392805,
0.0280875899,
-0.0535587966,
-0.0765138939,
-0.0349808484,
0.0172227137,
0.0154000819,
0.0030548726,
-0.0002590583,
-0.0172656961,
-0.0592262186,
0.0002588841,
0.0377808288,
-0.0155016249,
-0.0465646759,
-0.0813138708,
-0.0831203535,
0.0395477265,
-0.048751343,
-0.0133338599,
-0.0212702602,
-0.0210343022,
-0.0822441578,
0.0142960874,
0.0468191728,
0.0269412678,
-0.0061484845,
0.0234525166,
-0.0726371184,
0.0355509557,
0.0423038788,
-0.0090627382,
0.0751913115,
-0.0349360146,
-0.0288580824,
0.0227834061,
0.0176397488,
0.0210983269,
0.022534715,
0.0041163894,
0.0185887869,
-0.0127403596,
0.0074889599,
0.0349176824,
0.0154211968,
0.0732637942,
-0.0460568368,
-0.003358613,
-0.0340520293,
-0.0618872978,
0.0009155311,
0.0158178248,
-0.0124899391,
-0.0314462781,
0.0435176268,
0.0692765266,
-0.0037437922,
-0.0197418798,
-0.0313169286,
0.0469841361,
-0.0031539761,
0.0360614583,
-0.0100738732,
0.0290947296,
-0.0022347784,
0.0336459912,
0.0310404431,
0.0184808467,
-0.0767194107,
0.0399364568,
-0.0098860478,
0.0200722832,
-0.0031402688,
-0.0035610499,
0.013383464,
-0.044852417,
-0.0278960895,
-0.0424300022,
0.0098794121,
0.0423057154,
0.0502497517,
-0.0168127026,
0.0470963717,
-0.0498259403,
0.0161999613,
-0.0296133105,
0.0064055771,
0.0018638123,
-0.0668418333,
0.0236418005,
0.0068745776,
-0.0314382464,
-0.0139271421,
0.0460933596,
0.0019265756,
0.0469209291,
-0.026421681,
0.031197438,
-0.0086973412,
-0.0474648774,
-0.0228226669,
-0.0262577478,
0.0022848069,
0.0543305464,
-0.0532577783,
-0.0731442273,
-0.0439319722,
0.0400466435,
0.0122856749,
-0.0551970564,
0.0297897905,
0.0177504923,
-0.0305061266,
-0.0332975164,
-0.0279864594,
0.0439712852,
0.0085641276,
0.0052933837,
-0.002066934,
-6.440804647e-33,
-0.0347507186,
-0.029850252,
0.0345346741,
-0.0024106067,
-0.0211769119,
-0.0403542332,
-0.0377372615,
0.0370439626,
-0.0237755217,
0.0183390081,
0.008719488,
-0.0267972425,
-0.0005469693,
0.0465297401,
0.0435202606,
0.0171409938,
-0.0075597055,
-0.0490891561,
0.0334560126,
-0.0152643863,
0.0040232427,
-0.013766842,
0.0832821801,
-0.0380326584,
0.0612379536,
-0.01463868,
0.0293239951,
0.0100850612,
-0.0365477912,
0.0261557214,
-0.0193131529,
0.0407450125,
0.0427478068,
-0.0369455107,
-0.0060995999,
-0.014283739,
-0.0415835902,
-0.027739726,
0.0804739967,
0.0120193344,
-0.0319019854,
-0.0476104952,
0.0404231735,
-0.0062053292,
-0.0529632457,
0.0228215922,
0.0110446112,
-0.0529386885,
-0.0210535675,
-0.0055259666,
-0.0812487453,
-0.0128362058,
-0.0039338483,
0.026112318,
0.0233140327,
-0.0076510957,
-0.0549510941,
-0.0371115394,
-0.0021788664,
0.046482265,
0.0042532249,
0.0451664403,
0.0816756412,
0.0140015949,
0.0508456156,
0.0357590839,
0.0931183174,
-0.0177436508,
0.0123230666,
0.0201478954,
0.0736507624,
0.0038743166,
-0.005784119,
0.0600096174,
0.0196822342,
-0.0195105821,
-0.051769916,
-0.0460006036,
0.0331297703,
0.0033756795,
0.0026404033,
0.0042451643,
-0.0071001798,
-0.0341922864,
-0.0194781274,
-0.0350459814,
0.0055855992,
-0.0243870784,
-0.0036972654,
-0.0142798154,
0.0084455051,
-0.0356601179,
-0.0057760202,
-0.029214628,
-0.0067619164,
-0.0291737299,
-0.0182077177,
0.0306482129,
0.0065230839,
0.0138209369,
-0.0546695329,
-0.0564126372,
-0.012344419,
0.0441263169,
0.0274106115,
0.0456800126,
-0.0040345141,
0.0219194982,
0.0047455835,
-0.0037187231,
-0.0351483412,
-0.0215794537,
0.0475888439,
-0.0342202447,
0.0626575053,
0.0191431753,
-0.0175737869,
-0.0087282881,
0.0314392522,
-0.0137451747,
-0.015431894,
0.0300393868,
-0.0481442511,
0.031618908,
-0.032776136,
0.0073170383,
-0.00581457,
0.0215060432,
0.0705790967,
-0.0305824187,
-0.0073125092,
-0.0187008642,
2.888e-7,
0.041670464,
0.0550595671,
-0.0003566072,
-0.0015050903,
0.0508852303,
-0.0241206251,
-0.036590904,
-0.0282702241,
0.0134993326,
0.0066530136,
-0.0334897228,
0.043726787,
0.0495948009,
0.0129834432,
-0.0738881528,
0.0434140041,
-0.0317733809,
0.0052741999,
-0.0559645221,
0.0436517484,
0.0046641738,
0.0452594161,
0.0128369434,
-0.0189157669,
-0.0182522517,
-0.0256987792,
0.0460469574,
-0.0318648517,
0.0253335387,
-0.0058641206,
-0.0008480356,
0.0360602811,
0.0112101454,
0.0303160194,
-0.0057939477,
0.0246807765,
-0.0286673419,
0.0263877157,
0.0101844445,
0.0000919198,
0.0409124382,
-0.0122795394,
-0.0005680919,
-0.0486129075,
0.0448617488,
-0.0584209971,
-0.0374592468,
0.0312555209,
-0.0172830373,
0.0269256085,
-0.0380337052,
-0.0095001766,
-0.0099016838,
-0.0144805256,
0.0173367318,
-0.0421854928,
0.0119468383,
-0.0411498584,
0.0242505688,
0.0564039983,
-0.0568922497,
-0.0802235976,
-0.0148995118,
0.0205638185,
0.0133854374,
-0.001967048,
-0.0108527048,
1.832518781e-34,
-0.0040013907,
0.0330843963,
0.0500909016,
-0.0317563191,
-0.0087658279,
-0.0027247509,
0.0323771276,
0.0275313277,
0.0511936024,
-0.0468614288,
-0.020320449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03226v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03226v1 | Investigation of Self-supervised Pre-trained Models for Classification of Voice Quality from Speech and Neck Surface Accelerometer Signals | 2023-08-06T23:16:54 | 2023-08-06T23:16:54 | Sudarsana Reddy Kadiri, Farhad Javanmardi, Paavo Alku | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD | Prior studies in the automatic classification of voice quality have mainly
studied the use of the acoustic speech signal as input. Recently, a few studies
have been carried out by jointly using both speech and neck surface
accelerometer (NSA) signals as inputs, and by extracting MFCCs and glottal
source features. This study examines simultaneously-recorded speech and NSA
signals in the classification of voice quality (breathy, modal, and pressed)
using features derived from three self-supervised pre-trained models
(wav2vec2-BASE, wav2vec2-LARGE, and HuBERT) and using a SVM as well as CNNs as
classifiers. Furthermore, the effectiveness of the pre-trained models is
compared in feature extraction between glottal source waveforms and raw signal
waveforms for both speech and NSA inputs. Using two signal processing methods
(quasi-closed phase (QCP) glottal inverse filtering and zero frequency
filtering (ZFF)), glottal source waveforms are estimated from both speech and
NSA signals. The study has three main goals: (1) to study whether features
derived from pre-trained models improve classification accuracy compared to
conventional features (spectrogram, mel-spectrogram, MFCCs, i-vector, and
x-vector), (2) to investigate which of the two modalities (speech vs. NSA) is
more effective in the classification task with pre-trained model-based
features, and (3) to evaluate whether the deep learning-based CNN classifier
can enhance the classification accuracy in comparison to the SVM classifier.
The results revealed that the use of the NSA input showed better classification
performance compared to the speech signal. Between the features, the
pre-trained model-based features showed better classification accuracies, both
for speech and NSA inputs compared to the conventional features. It was also
found that the HuBERT features performed better than the wav2vec2-BASE and
wav2vec2-LARGE features. | [
0.0177317671,
0.0573417582,
0.006875331,
-0.0186854694,
0.0474420749,
-0.0166718736,
0.0530626029,
-0.0028992458,
-0.0177324899,
0.0191116259,
-0.0558968559,
-0.0117666945,
0.0498449393,
0.0026510637,
0.0202475227,
0.0080933841,
-0.0106548173,
-0.0110205105,
0.0630748272,
-0.0292404946,
0.0062877745,
-0.0212479457,
-0.06126846,
0.0330098458,
-0.0331310444,
0.0020273845,
-0.0048347581,
-0.0069989194,
-0.0013801343,
-0.0258562732,
0.008526098,
-0.0184327867,
-0.0144060589,
0.0345141068,
0.0000019158,
-0.0067262775,
0.0130816717,
0.0233798753,
-0.0677344799,
-0.0005163696,
0.0077067446,
0.1002176106,
-0.0325268693,
0.0066213571,
-0.0543190613,
-0.0468117855,
0.0336712003,
-0.0263608117,
0.0372872949,
0.0283093676,
-0.0289566293,
0.0054670479,
-0.0129369339,
-0.0063716504,
-0.0186307114,
-0.0018218193,
-0.0053084097,
-0.0067523043,
-0.0309451818,
-0.0298947971,
0.0303759649,
0.0518641062,
-0.0213351604,
0.018279409,
0.0661573708,
-0.0086770076,
-0.054215461,
-0.0432523116,
-0.0115779722,
0.0481701531,
0.0197366942,
0.0135256462,
-0.0233455226,
0.0171008948,
0.002871115,
0.0000297035,
-0.0052923202,
0.0075517343,
0.0345877483,
-0.0062738881,
-0.0408798009,
0.0420078151,
-0.007014656,
-0.0468110517,
0.0000842874,
-0.0167846959,
-0.0200747382,
-0.0103474278,
0.0731769651,
-0.0067237127,
0.0188732911,
0.0203450471,
0.028931288,
0.0069668037,
-0.0021822446,
-0.0268312767,
0.0021462727,
-0.0698317736,
0.0185951889,
-0.0078401016,
0.0060953111,
-0.0261659212,
-0.0963442847,
-0.0206139907,
-0.0285661276,
0.0285809934,
-0.0132429078,
-0.0001559867,
-0.0284785163,
0.0041453615,
-0.0196173936,
0.0125726024,
0.0165698975,
0.0215222891,
0.0401898585,
0.0346666388,
-0.0325209983,
-0.0346184857,
-0.0416233391,
-0.0186785813,
-0.0067891856,
0.0390606411,
-0.0061059608,
0.0630591661,
-0.0131067038,
0.0040536807,
0.04781463,
0.0792087689,
-0.0345478095,
-0.0423449799,
0.0156462472,
-0.0053151241,
0.057019718,
0.0259864293,
0.0818040818,
0.0055622119,
0.0217225589,
0.0516820438,
-0.0375987217,
-0.0156678855,
-0.0249374341,
-0.0037543799,
-0.0343707278,
-0.0617887601,
0.0098815616,
-0.0086471941,
0.0046238233,
0.0145471878,
-0.0186378751,
-0.0401214436,
0.0514942743,
-0.0313954689,
-0.0122721354,
0.0229502451,
0.1107276082,
-0.0302482322,
0.0300751664,
-0.019858053,
0.0330112427,
-0.0135161364,
0.0071049575,
-0.0465843491,
-0.0276786275,
0.0374637432,
0.0172271952,
-0.0265443027,
-0.0289529487,
-0.0305604544,
-0.0273099914,
0.0238873214,
0.0041760313,
0.0130843166,
0.027780816,
-0.0009346003,
0.0573248379,
0.0629054233,
0.0495870411,
0.0231576897,
-0.0048192046,
0.0049649477,
0.0239040274,
-0.0459100641,
-0.0110546397,
-0.0345625952,
-0.0163768642,
-0.0194339678,
-0.0193023738,
0.0246818867,
-0.0260905456,
-0.0685461834,
-0.0102773774,
-0.0368678682,
-0.0037336501,
0.0241539702,
0.0520322807,
-0.0204307586,
0.0221753065,
-0.0315844938,
-0.0134306839,
-0.036209628,
-0.0144886542,
-0.0569566451,
0.0303174723,
-0.0467554703,
-0.0486046597,
-0.0320304893,
-0.0091426335,
-0.0695582405,
-0.0649957135,
-0.0578230843,
-0.0057853414,
-0.0151506839,
0.0412665755,
-0.0216868818,
-0.0401732475,
0.014752781,
-0.0178918187,
-0.0170510728,
-0.0456331931,
0.026218893,
0.0268249661,
0.0128456261,
-0.0324678086,
-0.0181215387,
0.0271864552,
-0.0497846492,
0.0301961042,
0.0201556571,
0.0966830924,
0.0143108862,
-0.0000244135,
0.0007045105,
0.0253537726,
-0.0166252516,
-0.0521229431,
0.0112584839,
-0.0230220668,
0.015359208,
0.0583597571,
0.0017004737,
0.0417333432,
0.0288793929,
0.0071324306,
-0.0863016844,
0.0039468724,
-0.0048864745,
0.0180341601,
-0.0642828718,
-0.022424845,
0.0331902988,
-0.0160166938,
0.020453345,
-0.0332922526,
0.0585963987,
-0.0570856184,
0.0311857685,
-0.0117351655,
0.0496545583,
-0.0337245725,
-0.076438494,
0.0221549366,
-0.0939731449,
0.0212891772,
0.0119423969,
-0.0348536931,
-0.032354977,
0.0127932457,
-0.0977268741,
0.0368373394,
0.0259836558,
-0.0229132734,
-0.0404419936,
-0.0053247078,
0.0194827318,
-0.0098649003,
-0.0595047399,
-0.0174705535,
-0.0096657062,
-0.0252989195,
-0.0349093117,
0.0022059812,
0.0403569639,
-0.0029176017,
-0.0029973853,
-0.011331588,
-0.0114183752,
-0.0294337384,
-0.0112126805,
0.0424221344,
-0.0167451911,
0.0325775556,
0.033785753,
0.0332970172,
-0.0458238572,
-0.0126288198,
0.0007150511,
0.0068448153,
0.0395329073,
0.0225772131,
-0.0168547146,
0.0308650043,
0.0483148023,
-0.0064254566,
0.0123506533,
-0.0037043982,
0.031387426,
-0.0294105653,
0.0498162396,
-0.0461600982,
0.0137131121,
0.0778422728,
0.0283181276,
0.0130231986,
0.0419000685,
-0.0137257604,
-0.0112978173,
-0.0126094632,
-0.0037863678,
0.0129104117,
0.0254863817,
0.0351501592,
-0.0337320529,
0.0002504528,
-0.0457461923,
-0.0579625145,
-0.0092974035,
-0.09699779,
0.016674675,
0.0059249587,
-0.0576228909,
0.0128291789,
-0.0127367359,
0.0002011487,
0.0223915614,
-0.0181660503,
0.0208447557,
-0.0592999198,
-0.012650026,
-0.0255289543,
-0.0184378773,
-0.0171560626,
0.0326344967,
-0.0594680272,
0.0089977952,
-0.037276797,
0.0001134935,
-0.0019224691,
-0.0047644335,
0.0699916333,
0.0721397474,
-0.0211184714,
0.0345081128,
0.0179618802,
0.033154726,
-0.0012550022,
0.0196546149,
-0.009985486,
0.0845803916,
-0.0496580228,
0.0434642434,
0.0287664626,
-0.0139521351,
-0.0117497016,
0.0316749401,
-0.0573285073,
-0.0273421984,
-0.0159252249,
0.0018321539,
-0.0252536982,
0.0157565363,
-0.0056350385,
-0.0529287718,
0.0369200818,
0.0486468635,
0.0124440622,
-0.0263370126,
-0.0083083268,
0.0432204641,
-0.0387076586,
-0.0228214245,
-0.0317943692,
0.025492264,
0.0131310076,
0.0412973836,
0.0377455503,
0.0015746632,
0.0720117614,
-0.0061721569,
-0.0216701478,
0.0545082167,
0.0283570681,
-0.016735075,
0.045548562,
-0.0377235003,
0.0019514379,
-0.0599079579,
0.0227611475,
-0.0350675136,
0.0169389974,
-0.0077105742,
0.0631758645,
-0.1272572577,
-0.0225955155,
0.0008020385,
-0.0319463871,
0.0395869426,
0.0352998637,
0.0003160287,
-0.0346655995,
-0.0653678849,
-0.0130995987,
-0.0254955404,
0.0024413997,
-0.0434526168,
0.0445646159,
0.0565167516,
-0.00268862,
0.0223028567,
0.0817956701,
-0.0054159397,
0.0228115935,
0.020482786,
0.0184413865,
-0.0380819477,
0.0080732433,
-0.0371921323,
0.0273076892,
0.0288340244,
0.0185631551,
-0.0060961731,
-0.0509528518,
-0.0164015237,
0.0395804383,
0.0533035621,
0.0389330462,
-0.0287893414,
0.055952061,
0.0517143868,
-0.0745713934,
-0.0109687801,
0.0121255657,
-0.0243247524,
0.0403247848,
0.0300539751,
0.0481336378,
0.0486842729,
0.0242259018,
-0.0028598919,
0.0230096262,
0.0509597361,
0.061121311,
-0.0283544213,
-0.0281408373,
0.0567437597,
-0.0395736657,
-0.0362569131,
-0.0183637924,
0.0193625167,
-0.0123965219,
0.0183375683,
-0.0021281024,
0.0040095216,
0.034014646,
-0.0548326001,
-0.0291957259,
0.0307428539,
-0.0494249277,
-0.0622578934,
0.0100340014,
0.109332338,
-0.030009117,
-0.0104105296,
0.0028208503,
-0.026697157,
0.0470138676,
-0.0485987626,
-0.0402295105,
-0.0025365846,
-0.1142693833,
0.0321615897,
0.0303278174,
0.0663852915,
0.0401452817,
0.0438379347,
-0.0395147167,
0.0363326408,
0.0567613095,
0.0371362939,
-0.0356602408,
-0.0219896175,
0.021252865,
0.0082273921,
-0.0211218316,
-0.0253545325,
-0.0901511535,
-0.0118920254,
0.0207754094,
0.0948302373,
-0.005389208,
0.0308811385,
-0.0189536382,
0.0199434031,
-0.0182986632,
0.0211554077,
0.0340430215,
-0.0213247743,
0.0179229081,
-0.0082274452,
0.0124004455,
-0.0387928635,
0.0154535323,
0.0383621342,
-0.0185117405,
-0.0078481752,
0.000013728,
-0.0708967671,
-0.0214814488,
-0.042078279,
-0.0073557165,
0.0556997806,
0.0065646176,
-0.0163248107,
-0.013310831,
-0.0395157449,
0.0605997816,
0.0569918342,
-0.0266224463,
-0.034107767,
-0.0081412774,
0.0126127014,
0.0379845612,
-0.0004257142,
-0.0262165982,
-0.0022768565,
-0.0143218152,
-0.0228325967,
0.0292071085,
0.0080220914,
-0.0312720537,
-0.0196632612,
0.0131984018,
-0.0187548008,
0.0483310223,
-0.0149715859,
0.0242058244,
-0.0161495656,
0.0018427455,
-0.0088967187,
-0.0600195862,
-0.0137236174,
0.0211390518,
-0.0677683204,
0.0167982802,
-0.0203136858,
0.0005267942,
-5.260567176e-33,
0.0076811081,
0.0393680707,
-0.0124636069,
0.0391755104,
-0.0257448908,
0.0203178115,
0.0240017194,
0.0218062699,
0.0058689783,
0.0206921119,
0.0040478013,
-0.026466785,
0.0418009497,
-0.0196555275,
-0.0022434674,
-0.0059357933,
0.0859791785,
-0.0052624261,
0.0551767498,
0.0074886633,
0.0362075157,
0.0233397819,
0.0432877988,
-0.1165825054,
-0.0503007621,
0.0355952457,
-0.0050409413,
-0.0702269822,
0.0140253697,
0.002573069,
0.001654973,
0.0499604903,
-0.0193374008,
-0.027650075,
0.0243546814,
0.0004990767,
-0.020588683,
0.006128951,
-0.0151411397,
0.0078776991,
0.0300048199,
0.0057041398,
0.0338561386,
0.0088236164,
-0.0088621769,
-0.0357787125,
0.0682612583,
-0.0433127806,
0.010798974,
-0.0651991218,
0.0418116488,
0.0023267849,
0.0117130224,
-0.0386815742,
0.0564883985,
0.0328316391,
-0.0535707474,
-0.021883402,
-0.0394727439,
0.0184407756,
0.0279115606,
0.0153099848,
-0.0158409066,
0.0256199185,
0.0120619815,
0.0039474843,
0.0645045638,
-0.0577794053,
-0.0160972103,
0.0041183853,
0.0137032233,
0.1002682298,
0.0237918422,
-0.0208691284,
0.0467764288,
-0.1039223075,
-0.0464442112,
0.0306879953,
-0.0148463659,
-0.0191832129,
-0.0918812752,
0.0329805352,
0.0172249116,
-0.0218847785,
-0.0488040745,
-0.0257317759,
-0.0089486474,
0.0114011616,
0.0240161791,
-0.0506141968,
0.0183293149,
0.0101913577,
0.0220219847,
-0.0284085404,
0.056996122,
-0.0194650013,
0.0182275344,
-0.0445330106,
0.0404882617,
-0.0396694243,
-0.028415123,
-0.0137011036,
0.0682036877,
0.0396514051,
0.0442408174,
-0.0526951849,
-0.0384836644,
0.0752958804,
-0.0298285782,
-0.0034591712,
0.0313951261,
0.0072251325,
0.0158921611,
0.0401689298,
0.0141119193,
0.0067257662,
0.0018258287,
0.0684008747,
-0.0464828052,
0.031532459,
-0.0458445996,
-0.0403212868,
0.0298891477,
0.0175559446,
-0.0315828025,
-0.0006359356,
0.0197204147,
-0.0047248318,
0.0305339284,
-0.0179290287,
0.0196534041,
-0.0104317237,
2.728e-7,
-0.0263985675,
-0.047475908,
0.0275133308,
-0.0610818826,
0.0254278164,
0.0415516235,
-0.0322683081,
-0.0460077673,
0.0143606123,
-0.011050567,
0.0293855146,
-0.02269415,
0.0687138885,
0.0520956106,
0.0163095389,
-0.0392013974,
-0.0569633432,
0.0222125947,
-0.0040192674,
0.0649848357,
0.0256932005,
0.0281700585,
-0.0371171273,
-0.1263323426,
0.043053925,
-0.0118878884,
0.0112750297,
0.0043825302,
0.0264604222,
-0.0161968153,
0.0515007228,
0.0177156311,
0.0333156548,
0.0275576543,
-0.0282073598,
0.051525224,
0.0062747374,
0.0327905305,
-0.0376682766,
-0.0451304801,
0.0318725184,
0.0762827396,
-0.0018675952,
0.0517124236,
0.0704988986,
0.0007803311,
-0.0070953602,
-0.0716780201,
-0.0463814102,
0.0030672173,
0.0578413643,
-0.0371456072,
0.0539366528,
-0.037969999,
-0.0128719863,
-0.0078119179,
-0.0310137235,
-0.0068711131,
-0.0360231809,
0.0240610093,
-0.0560173318,
-0.0081459545,
0.0070279227,
-0.0107075311,
0.0046575847,
0.0074343425,
0.005885134,
1.685703784e-34,
-0.0328961574,
-0.0123442998,
-0.0111790868,
-0.0260765273,
-0.0441528633,
-0.0217000712,
0.0368236825,
0.0287384,
-0.0197622646,
-0.0020543772,
-0.0418407843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03212v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03212v2 | Average-Hard Attention Transformers are Constant-Depth Uniform Threshold Circuits | 2023-08-06T21:23:22 | 2023-08-21T18:54:56 | Lena Strobl | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CC, cs.LG | Transformers have emerged as a widely used neural network model for various
natural language processing tasks. Previous research explored their
relationship with constant-depth threshold circuits, making two assumptions:
average-hard attention and logarithmic precision for internal computations
relative to input length. Merrill et al. (2022) prove that average-hard
attention transformers recognize languages that fall within the complexity
class TC0, denoting the set of languages that can be recognized by
constant-depth polynomial-size threshold circuits. Likewise, Merrill and
Sabharwal (2023) show that log-precision transformers recognize languages
within the class of uniform TC0. This shows that both transformer models can be
simulated by constant-depth threshold circuits, with the latter being more
robust due to generating a uniform circuit family. Our paper shows that the
first result can be extended to yield uniform circuits as well. | [
0.0031313098,
-0.0029762331,
-0.0105311815,
0.0407769531,
-0.0393191166,
-0.0246558879,
0.0212353189,
-0.0365762897,
-0.0097765801,
-0.0412166864,
-0.0031088882,
-0.0219908431,
0.0010952435,
0.0305380374,
0.0113943582,
-0.0010529452,
0.0546020307,
-0.0117200883,
-0.0520823114,
-0.0295067132,
-0.0311704222,
-0.0448617451,
-0.0026338627,
0.0331178159,
0.0067787706,
0.0016623386,
-0.0093354089,
-0.0625896379,
-0.0144182062,
0.0175692495,
-0.0167506095,
0.0599816889,
-0.0270371363,
0.0290677566,
0.0000017695,
0.0020463667,
0.0296289101,
-0.0223026257,
-0.0479307622,
-0.0245066322,
-0.0305190384,
-0.0052187806,
-0.0237577651,
-0.009624335,
-0.0006913614,
-0.0189839005,
0.0969923139,
0.0424540713,
-0.0002865559,
0.0375926346,
-0.0071966653,
-0.064816162,
0.0616475865,
-0.0224757586,
-0.0195790138,
-0.018168401,
-0.0035492729,
-0.0428843424,
0.008007668,
-0.0489518866,
-0.0528841093,
0.0039255167,
0.0414084233,
0.0212673768,
0.0313691646,
0.028556928,
-0.0416394733,
-0.0124598285,
-0.0252247602,
0.0256974734,
-0.0664449632,
-0.0236044675,
-0.0305886306,
0.0228840802,
0.0063225203,
-0.061267186,
-0.0168509036,
0.0206650384,
-0.0211329646,
0.0259808172,
-0.0115368376,
0.0129583301,
0.0168704893,
-0.0422247164,
-0.0365161449,
0.0514956489,
-0.0033763824,
-0.0067861639,
-0.004820955,
-0.0045486484,
-0.0203707758,
-0.0155923972,
0.0514731295,
0.0450293273,
0.0108955037,
-0.0083248047,
-0.0294415504,
-0.0053889961,
-0.0228898451,
-0.0533770137,
0.0209970698,
0.0241894405,
-0.0136077907,
0.0093606636,
-0.0323007219,
0.0741186738,
-0.0274321064,
0.0547053665,
0.0175508335,
0.0133869722,
0.0347916931,
0.009171498,
-0.0513010472,
0.0460300036,
0.0238818284,
-0.0108316159,
-0.0327962786,
0.0116960267,
-0.0186527111,
-0.0195250567,
-0.0014191924,
-0.0101528801,
-0.0593553856,
0.0006033904,
0.0187784918,
0.0630570874,
0.0059155556,
-0.0036267864,
0.0089953262,
-0.0642359704,
-0.0263509545,
-0.0028203938,
0.0501813889,
0.0039489875,
0.0002779104,
0.0695714727,
0.0159735773,
-0.0704227313,
-0.0521990135,
0.0199597105,
-0.0198809169,
0.0081253015,
0.0118039865,
-0.0594710223,
0.0007075603,
0.0200495869,
0.0128883105,
-0.006550218,
0.0156066269,
0.0572013669,
0.008497077,
0.0440880433,
0.0515040755,
-0.0337024964,
-0.0043771593,
-0.033881437,
0.0194198322,
0.0383774377,
0.0507849716,
0.0108168768,
-0.0006092785,
-0.0359111167,
0.0161903594,
0.0098381974,
-0.0153109999,
-0.0457770675,
-0.0073001124,
-0.0577433743,
-0.0463110395,
-0.0031374351,
0.0212794729,
0.0753357187,
-0.0146822706,
-0.0326013975,
0.0413035639,
0.0317185298,
0.0400353819,
0.0917531252,
0.0279757157,
-0.0205578357,
-0.0230381098,
0.0591286309,
-0.0470840633,
0.0540877245,
-0.0022350166,
0.0015668005,
0.0064769052,
-0.002905919,
-0.0284467563,
-0.0525383614,
-0.0089659942,
0.014710282,
0.018135516,
-0.0522963442,
0.050924167,
0.0303001869,
-0.0647810921,
0.0791755691,
-0.0122428155,
-0.01482201,
0.0094387885,
-0.0507503562,
-0.0158311334,
-0.0236816593,
0.0092544677,
-0.0219768062,
0.0626962408,
-0.008457643,
-0.0426103435,
0.0317768231,
0.0396025553,
0.0274982136,
-0.0081445128,
-0.0106421495,
-0.0025967355,
-0.0162016191,
0.0267175734,
0.0195855573,
-0.0184390862,
0.001422692,
-0.0100525357,
0.006014281,
-0.0142457867,
-0.0068555237,
0.0355884843,
-0.0126326596,
0.0275938008,
0.0228513554,
0.0238818377,
-0.0104122646,
-0.0161163546,
0.0441438183,
0.0120955249,
-0.0662143528,
-0.017090328,
0.0110152923,
-0.0361655392,
0.0163675454,
0.0090060122,
-0.0768457055,
0.016052762,
0.0793979242,
0.0145649584,
-0.0237542223,
0.0504158176,
-0.0726667717,
0.0582271889,
-0.0184451696,
0.0014217675,
0.0064447755,
0.0423564203,
-0.0209675226,
0.0550631769,
-0.0093726413,
0.0537215024,
-0.0007465927,
-0.0539306328,
-0.0380485803,
-0.0131719243,
-0.0720627382,
-0.0080984756,
-0.0511278212,
0.0228485223,
0.0150949657,
-0.0613046102,
0.009533505,
-0.040768031,
-0.0201947652,
-0.0259794462,
-0.0195871145,
0.0197947323,
-0.0118595734,
0.0052120993,
0.0571051538,
0.0214139521,
-0.0222865082,
0.0359260291,
0.0032587256,
0.0392487161,
0.0439165235,
-0.0209594667,
-0.036215093,
-0.0293870568,
-0.0662930459,
-0.0001148142,
0.0453156009,
0.0206871089,
-0.0338609181,
-0.0527716763,
0.0291348044,
0.0552446097,
0.0596034266,
0.0002872213,
-0.043007791,
0.0069748112,
0.0066405311,
0.0462562479,
0.0964025781,
0.030753158,
0.0171111058,
0.0160663389,
0.0008201309,
0.0388838425,
0.0440959521,
-0.0240216125,
-0.0164310634,
-0.0131669641,
0.0076350826,
0.0168481283,
0.1144314632,
-0.0075891349,
-0.033338517,
-0.0444904156,
-0.0549267195,
-0.0093439966,
0.0105664907,
0.0184912272,
-0.0085335085,
-0.0442253388,
0.0334032774,
-0.0138378851,
-0.0418800004,
0.027749775,
0.0082933679,
0.0096278889,
-0.033537291,
-0.0070419479,
-0.0145331994,
0.0265517458,
0.0766957775,
0.0148881264,
-0.0156356972,
-0.0471163243,
-0.0273869056,
0.0364315063,
-0.0085307583,
-0.0270143151,
0.0868371874,
0.0160634965,
-0.0102673033,
-0.0465186499,
-0.0178451743,
-0.0281758308,
0.0118639553,
-0.0352848731,
0.0294646565,
0.0549593866,
-0.0252945963,
-0.0721528977,
0.0788943842,
0.0221692286,
0.0774409324,
-0.0039403834,
-0.0189161934,
-0.0319786146,
0.0219606273,
-0.0164453052,
0.0610073507,
0.0856641755,
-0.0130596897,
0.0201206692,
0.0387567095,
0.0129027106,
0.058701586,
-0.0161651019,
-0.0314063244,
0.0428348146,
-0.0187651496,
0.0091761872,
0.0152206244,
-0.0181794632,
-0.0140480557,
-0.0450782925,
0.0681733191,
0.0051408643,
-0.0511718914,
0.0231272653,
-0.0298759304,
-0.0020136023,
0.0323041938,
0.0027886913,
-0.07158833,
-0.0018653481,
-0.0014283773,
-0.0132334121,
-0.0234305356,
-0.0103944335,
-0.0060398178,
-0.0720955655,
0.0050576609,
0.0161043555,
-0.0119181313,
-0.0498846173,
-0.0053104586,
0.0226839725,
-0.0283419043,
0.0169868749,
0.0048112418,
-0.0022322275,
-0.0480511934,
0.0007245782,
-0.0039742137,
-0.0220764875,
0.0231523924,
-0.012247595,
-0.0049301079,
-0.0053473697,
-0.017804224,
-0.0569470562,
-0.0273424238,
0.0645339265,
0.0023744088,
0.0053629125,
0.0281003658,
-0.0202059504,
0.0411395654,
-0.045338884,
-0.0054794918,
-0.0101464456,
-0.0169148464,
0.0162820965,
-0.0572368279,
0.0663319081,
-0.0146161625,
-0.0672307312,
-0.0023457343,
0.0134900017,
-0.0482864976,
0.0256868321,
0.0538624078,
-0.0497429222,
-0.0661803484,
-0.0331877954,
0.026443515,
-0.0635476336,
-0.0646479502,
0.0559849702,
0.0239074696,
-0.1013695523,
0.0030863017,
0.0241381917,
-0.0243040472,
0.0198285971,
0.0125436792,
-0.096284613,
0.0600361414,
0.0027942846,
-0.0067791454,
0.0020201197,
-0.0290577412,
0.0026530246,
-0.1085942313,
0.0347563997,
0.0212818924,
-0.0431209803,
-0.0372219011,
0.0202864576,
-0.0840540454,
-0.0458612628,
0.0604338944,
-0.0052900412,
0.0203206465,
-0.0409881994,
-0.0028118859,
-0.0248010326,
0.0153688071,
0.0211856999,
-0.0264066756,
0.0384750627,
0.0408315137,
-0.0534942858,
-0.0052155298,
0.0435798727,
0.0128562972,
0.0441147685,
0.0013345104,
0.0306402203,
-0.0196107086,
-0.0324312225,
0.0544664897,
-0.0164534599,
0.0465805568,
0.0908817872,
0.0674540848,
-0.0212232415,
0.0385522582,
0.0386069119,
0.0252400637,
-0.0386269502,
-0.0416757464,
-0.0141531983,
0.0156420246,
-0.0016442743,
-0.0470233224,
0.0266251303,
-0.0058034249,
-0.0067813676,
0.0266769901,
0.0110191582,
-0.0008345529,
-0.0073957597,
-0.0093182065,
-0.0625302568,
0.000867266,
0.015191569,
0.0384360217,
0.0253366623,
0.0189723298,
-0.0006194212,
0.0138386078,
-0.0717069358,
-0.0053323298,
-0.0523376577,
-0.0071589705,
0.0074097132,
-0.004886739,
0.0531886183,
-0.0035241104,
-0.0327723287,
-0.0385653339,
-0.0056862645,
-0.0270848311,
-0.0225655828,
0.0209930651,
-0.0161494631,
0.0420465358,
0.0313936807,
0.0208195746,
-0.0567231476,
0.0214739125,
-0.0535846129,
-0.0023145878,
0.0046077711,
0.0213254839,
-0.0323773175,
-0.0031708486,
-0.0629964173,
0.0365013257,
0.0181360934,
-0.007141924,
-0.0377533622,
-0.0552440882,
0.0393607877,
-0.0066330954,
0.0561347455,
-0.0481590331,
-0.0050183651,
0.0179459639,
0.0148307793,
-0.0206266548,
0.0313120261,
0.034548223,
0.0460283123,
0.0121418554,
-0.0525867492,
-5.642000767e-33,
-0.0264664888,
-0.0084089357,
-0.0104003018,
0.0478336699,
0.0036629769,
0.0589502156,
-0.0280786548,
0.0294913985,
-0.0531914532,
-0.009008023,
-0.021461077,
0.0093440078,
0.0158885401,
0.021427922,
0.0038214142,
-0.0336902626,
0.0412496328,
-0.0120697068,
0.0211519524,
0.0048344289,
0.030543549,
-0.0260092597,
0.0934545398,
0.0048023118,
-0.0169985909,
0.0312436093,
-0.0045886412,
-0.0011216108,
-0.0250787288,
0.0361827388,
-0.0073158643,
0.082689479,
0.0437500477,
-0.0439715423,
-0.0085983109,
0.0433771461,
-0.0866607502,
0.0003978609,
-0.0221839231,
0.0374935418,
-0.0034355444,
-0.0360001698,
0.0911051482,
-0.0045210719,
-0.0103695188,
-0.0612988919,
0.0123322206,
-0.028227888,
-0.0123808309,
-0.0201859288,
0.0056027076,
0.0232663602,
0.0107131675,
-0.0067266296,
-0.0167052746,
0.0441799201,
-0.0315176174,
-0.0078807352,
-0.0657647476,
0.0402579419,
0.0414722264,
0.0547581948,
0.0087933568,
-0.0073681613,
0.0143150929,
0.0074503198,
0.0777621046,
0.0298812147,
-0.0065485993,
-0.0277692266,
0.0230261497,
0.0092919907,
0.0439308286,
-0.0024393741,
0.0961185172,
-0.0237069745,
-0.0578045025,
-0.0476251058,
-0.001356512,
0.0810782462,
0.0581895895,
-0.018305501,
-0.0640681684,
-0.02627155,
0.0058541647,
0.0176741835,
-0.0593445599,
0.0210058037,
-0.0114533547,
-0.0102186222,
0.0149832712,
-0.0034935926,
0.0180350486,
-0.0342672728,
0.0439812429,
0.0059804241,
0.0653298348,
0.042846974,
-0.0145324348,
0.0168884285,
-0.0182225853,
0.0007827388,
-0.0550166517,
-0.0053177457,
-0.0167230424,
0.0198350679,
0.0006068262,
0.055166401,
-0.0495389812,
-0.0504013337,
-0.0387152284,
0.0072534122,
0.0169202872,
0.1105864048,
0.0441350155,
-0.0056246612,
-0.0132888993,
0.0119920289,
-0.0302768871,
-0.0301553532,
-0.0039263885,
0.106260255,
-0.0001152563,
0.0532536916,
-0.0058655436,
-0.0537701063,
-0.0721305683,
0.0454676338,
0.0361968912,
-0.0463860333,
-0.0266362522,
0.0071741091,
2.664e-7,
0.0164485686,
-0.02398674,
0.0302318912,
0.0004305299,
0.06012116,
-0.0149409659,
0.0613390319,
0.0473967381,
0.0109054223,
-0.0034401878,
-0.0080626672,
0.0068360725,
-0.0259542242,
0.0203660131,
-0.0735326931,
-0.0252136979,
-0.0377761722,
0.0486327186,
0.0256301165,
0.0197345391,
0.0172009021,
0.0730135888,
-0.0360489264,
0.0231706463,
-0.0183877517,
-0.0576369241,
0.0077830604,
0.0037125996,
0.0649753287,
-0.0077176578,
0.0308483336,
-0.0048040417,
-0.0020121525,
0.0536837503,
0.0192525666,
0.0457754247,
-0.0147740683,
0.0264701266,
0.002265414,
-0.0174356159,
0.0363634825,
-0.0333638154,
-0.0375622138,
-0.0301972758,
0.0156093473,
-0.0941237286,
-0.0425010212,
-0.029087618,
0.0100660566,
-0.0047220318,
0.0065911454,
0.0075463089,
-0.0180152711,
-0.0306886993,
0.0160459634,
-0.0227128826,
0.0054543559,
-0.0209162664,
0.0275050327,
0.0099799158,
-0.0627770945,
-0.0080067543,
-0.0432377644,
-0.0637983829,
0.0449917316,
0.0070875911,
-0.0240153521,
2.259332285e-34,
0.0503819995,
-0.0148984985,
0.0255072899,
0.027592374,
0.0295904744,
-0.0307059251,
0.0400175229,
-0.0401364118,
0.0341435112,
-0.0577722713,
-0.0730325878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03188v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03188v2 | Automatically Correcting Large Language Models: Surveying the landscape of diverse self-correction strategies | 2023-08-06T18:38:52 | 2023-08-30T03:47:34 | Liangming Pan, Michael Saxon, Wenda Xu, Deepak Nathani, Xinyi Wang, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance across
a wide array of NLP tasks. However, their efficacy is undermined by undesired
and inconsistent behaviors, including hallucination, unfaithful reasoning, and
toxic content. A promising approach to rectify these flaws is self-correction,
where the LLM itself is prompted or guided to fix problems in its own output.
Techniques leveraging automated feedback -- either produced by the LLM itself
or some external system -- are of particular interest as they are a promising
way to make LLM-based solutions more practical and deployable with minimal
human feedback. This paper presents a comprehensive review of this emerging
class of techniques. We analyze and taxonomize a wide array of recent work
utilizing these strategies, including training-time, generation-time, and
post-hoc correction. We also summarize the major applications of this strategy
and conclude by discussing future directions and challenges. | [
0.0459444784,
0.0558888167,
-0.0415812433,
0.0318232737,
-0.064026773,
-0.0035518752,
-0.0258127563,
-0.0028805807,
0.033635769,
-0.0881240144,
-0.0138745178,
-0.012554069,
0.0026055323,
0.0024168135,
0.0363149233,
-0.0225108732,
0.0494221896,
-0.0465829745,
-0.0218029581,
-0.012258702,
-0.0053283386,
0.0312093981,
-0.004744024,
0.0385244153,
-0.0168904401,
-0.0369647853,
0.0118534798,
0.0171868987,
-0.0363755263,
-0.0211394671,
0.001364853,
0.0637566373,
-0.010425169,
0.0460395366,
0.0000020207,
-0.0588138402,
-0.0093889702,
-0.0108617861,
0.0012129395,
0.0335390754,
0.043196667,
-0.0276741441,
-0.0396093093,
0.0308241621,
-0.0218495224,
-0.0005998718,
0.0429025665,
0.0410522707,
0.0786105171,
0.0633247644,
0.007315537,
-0.0047067325,
0.0137220146,
0.0247406065,
0.005301462,
0.0022488877,
0.0535819605,
0.0328899175,
0.0000063165,
-0.0021491174,
-0.0042968215,
0.044073943,
-0.0072094742,
-0.0490589999,
0.0073526464,
-0.0044632936,
-0.0386159942,
-0.0328138582,
-0.0320149474,
0.0263028275,
-0.0242816284,
-0.0634721592,
-0.0051400703,
-0.0064140232,
-0.0060987268,
0.0047084889,
-0.0273921881,
0.0516836867,
0.0242858846,
0.0280371513,
0.0189484414,
-0.0350987837,
0.0380017944,
0.0078135421,
-0.0322195664,
0.0749306381,
0.0317272879,
-0.0413106605,
-0.0336382501,
0.0140716117,
-0.0014487819,
-0.0815491527,
0.0168545302,
0.0538779236,
-0.0424924344,
0.033837568,
-0.0493078865,
-0.0211203173,
0.0480634533,
-0.0720754564,
0.0346620791,
0.0225726049,
-0.0361539237,
0.0373845585,
-0.0286813043,
0.0271891132,
-0.0010756617,
0.0328738317,
-0.0115040764,
0.0149223888,
-0.0182386469,
-0.0271569062,
-0.0474247821,
0.0261503942,
0.0065694815,
-0.0090894643,
-0.0499592088,
0.0298639052,
-0.0348673388,
0.046418041,
0.0142205423,
0.012060537,
-0.017880002,
-0.0364636406,
-0.0253450628,
0.0299256202,
0.0098731844,
-0.0156187844,
-0.0117591489,
-0.0451119319,
-0.0043106624,
0.015179188,
-0.0294742007,
0.0022083363,
-0.0023465017,
0.0800441504,
0.0174020641,
-0.0159221217,
-0.0457081944,
-0.0289970078,
-0.0462922864,
-0.0455262028,
-0.0473624468,
-0.0833400041,
-0.01986886,
0.0034163964,
-0.002975239,
-0.051967185,
0.0438250005,
0.0224068817,
-0.0388748161,
0.0997322947,
-0.0420880206,
0.0478065982,
0.0391494744,
-0.0132589713,
0.0296412632,
0.0810290202,
0.0495611876,
0.0055178613,
0.0407829247,
-0.0068446626,
0.0559246466,
0.0463873744,
-0.0105548548,
-0.0002415898,
-0.0641579032,
-0.0156872515,
0.0167201739,
0.0446238667,
0.0043708086,
0.078820318,
0.0147307385,
0.0222629681,
0.0464930311,
0.0322955996,
0.0197504275,
0.0295544993,
0.0437882356,
-0.0148196099,
0.0035623033,
0.0325682126,
-0.0714769065,
0.004931123,
-0.0517159887,
0.0017964467,
0.0322248042,
0.0487800762,
0.001772398,
-0.0571434461,
-0.0653554201,
0.0064057349,
0.0086605763,
-0.0000053491,
0.0624855049,
0.0675383955,
-0.0252306666,
0.0413426198,
0.0540461466,
-0.0177658144,
0.0142548494,
-0.0664869472,
0.0186963435,
0.1072958708,
0.0810563043,
-0.0223160181,
-0.013028414,
-0.0079517383,
-0.0013396057,
0.0648401901,
0.0288188215,
-0.0041612275,
-0.072288692,
-0.0332585946,
0.0191290919,
-0.0005130395,
0.0355112366,
0.0043730154,
0.024389673,
-0.0301515404,
0.0037453903,
-0.0093021952,
-0.0559581853,
0.051107049,
-0.0169085432,
-0.0328940414,
0.0147253964,
-0.0063761398,
-0.0017297561,
0.0070898957,
-0.0248535033,
0.0234755613,
0.0170542598,
-0.0099368617,
-0.0594252981,
0.0078524603,
-0.0398091488,
-0.0188574288,
0.0671867281,
0.0165870078,
-0.0317663662,
-0.0021457572,
-0.0158194862,
-0.030820692,
0.0340757445,
-0.0498656929,
0.0322777256,
-0.0565612465,
0.078518413,
-0.0036409586,
-0.0034531481,
-0.0431280397,
0.0257668365,
0.0115982732,
0.0016235649,
0.0104172882,
0.0195983518,
-0.0093652904,
-0.0113012707,
-0.0139341941,
0.0154856229,
-0.0023426272,
0.0181298573,
0.0194754712,
-0.0012373206,
-0.0167480931,
-0.0350967608,
-0.048894491,
-0.0039207372,
-0.0328099318,
-0.0060480526,
0.0292159915,
-0.0041971155,
-0.0144081693,
-0.0211024191,
-0.0115378331,
-0.0030268428,
0.0601905994,
0.0160787869,
0.0353999026,
-0.0234299209,
-0.0291245282,
-0.0407770574,
0.0090405624,
-0.041696053,
0.020658629,
0.0018538079,
-0.022692509,
-0.115467675,
0.0527326055,
-0.0364198945,
0.0476923734,
0.0220944565,
-0.0484511554,
0.0081612589,
-0.0248961207,
0.0591866262,
0.0340553895,
0.0188673194,
0.0189865381,
0.0922424942,
-0.008190617,
-0.0534340031,
-0.0070490874,
-0.0157322511,
-0.0537399948,
-0.0094118826,
-0.0411214642,
-0.0066368044,
0.0492904447,
0.0141229834,
-0.0062222816,
-0.0523904003,
0.0276797637,
-0.0435688943,
-0.0301419981,
0.0026410122,
-0.0626905784,
-0.0157973412,
0.0373269357,
-0.0064282659,
-0.0604850501,
0.0811109245,
-0.0294599626,
0.0212536361,
-0.0237567071,
0.0002845397,
-0.0323736668,
0.0629098266,
0.0160154961,
0.0322305337,
0.0187587123,
-0.0393905789,
-0.0189418774,
-0.0366501622,
0.0061939415,
-0.0411884189,
0.0649872869,
-0.0713602751,
0.0166786686,
0.0315224826,
-0.0397358797,
-0.0543404296,
-0.0239318553,
-0.0234709717,
-0.0267771967,
-0.0127758933,
-0.002977313,
-0.0099502522,
0.0230818316,
0.005838233,
-0.0039853505,
-0.015984321,
-0.0266131777,
-0.0036667087,
-0.0154014695,
0.0468705781,
0.0126610957,
0.0348940082,
0.006193703,
0.0255178381,
0.056813743,
0.0217992179,
0.0284950323,
-0.0318256356,
0.0044004065,
0.0183127541,
-0.0405213907,
0.0121762725,
0.0037992375,
0.0457084738,
-0.0684560239,
-0.0329942033,
0.121180959,
0.0562441275,
-0.0359478481,
0.0117368856,
-0.033872623,
-0.0090637105,
0.0188851114,
0.025670452,
-0.0792208686,
-0.0060669966,
0.0333043523,
0.0102250623,
-0.0239220187,
-0.0066577834,
-0.0019076454,
-0.150377214,
0.044660069,
0.0438583978,
0.0097921398,
-0.0419770032,
-0.0268506724,
0.0118402783,
0.0049453974,
0.0374356396,
0.0315227881,
-0.0178143959,
-0.0388007686,
0.0064442023,
-0.0522606075,
-0.0451090932,
0.0050013885,
-0.0396742672,
0.0974694192,
0.0940880328,
0.0033837608,
0.0219896492,
-0.0206184573,
0.0599849783,
-0.0085673491,
0.0164936129,
-0.0075475094,
0.0196352173,
-0.0090972437,
-0.0151746534,
0.0029418762,
0.0181471258,
-0.0161196571,
-0.0225006677,
-0.0039279256,
0.0773863122,
-0.0251776855,
-0.011754238,
-0.0227529593,
0.0319226757,
0.0113472082,
0.0616684817,
0.025014801,
-0.0305169132,
-0.0357203707,
-0.0439816229,
-0.0061931703,
-0.0171601474,
-0.0586338528,
0.020004211,
0.011980148,
0.0078588268,
-0.064357549,
-0.0403712653,
0.0463847928,
0.001820836,
0.0489277095,
-0.014090417,
-0.0118234241,
-0.0007631031,
0.0113899484,
0.0048829475,
-0.0370616987,
0.0046609025,
-0.0376249962,
-0.0166201517,
0.014383846,
-0.0113957375,
0.031724494,
0.0221069902,
-0.0538938381,
-0.0803286806,
0.0335449837,
0.0651182979,
0.0218935367,
0.0472468249,
-0.0461150073,
-0.0797644183,
0.0314067043,
0.0692768469,
-0.0509245023,
0.0069220602,
-0.0065544154,
0.0208097622,
0.0028050835,
0.0449177288,
-0.0259742811,
0.0282095298,
0.0078906901,
0.0645954683,
-0.0057223262,
-0.0466211475,
0.063263759,
0.0182738528,
0.0117812539,
-0.0278484616,
0.0244991649,
-0.0188387278,
0.0040380848,
-0.0631745011,
-0.055751171,
-0.0051270057,
0.0512747988,
0.0070249317,
-0.0373608805,
-0.0092168525,
-0.0352636948,
-0.0734564662,
0.0237159021,
-0.022614602,
-0.0186820515,
-0.0048352852,
-0.01891605,
0.0482829362,
0.0109787416,
-0.0076013119,
0.0320913754,
0.0164167192,
0.0354579836,
-0.0063509326,
0.0356573202,
0.0119868731,
-0.0072283433,
-0.0608375333,
0.0133698992,
-0.0266606603,
-0.0591857769,
-0.033182919,
0.0484642796,
0.0735197812,
0.0192035213,
0.0662192702,
-0.0459565297,
-0.0358142555,
0.0043699448,
0.0044799019,
0.0256293919,
-0.0216198526,
-0.017490942,
0.0161967482,
-0.0375350304,
-0.0150660984,
0.0189334042,
-0.0280668009,
0.0537661389,
0.0203324594,
-0.018960325,
-0.0295847207,
-0.0414119214,
-0.0397299118,
-0.0283323247,
-0.0522784926,
-0.0249368288,
-0.0536087863,
-0.0901836306,
-0.0102577955,
0.0442208312,
-0.0004679767,
-0.0185831077,
-0.0000313105,
0.0785199255,
0.0178494137,
-0.0052777608,
-0.0319544226,
0.00681995,
0.0147433933,
-0.0198911447,
-0.0121747879,
-6.194595885e-33,
-0.0370906666,
-0.0474976227,
0.0173976142,
-0.0360786393,
-0.0009263063,
-0.056656383,
-0.0297470465,
0.0227662679,
0.03986663,
0.0176292509,
-0.0231000725,
0.000240925,
0.0105028991,
-0.0035449094,
0.0568414442,
0.0253273211,
0.0764185041,
-0.0053724549,
-0.0351170003,
-0.0054467199,
0.021964049,
0.0180897079,
0.0332082845,
-0.0686681569,
0.0281575322,
0.0253211372,
-0.0520500913,
0.0419561863,
-0.0138129639,
0.0560844876,
-0.0147218499,
0.0499818809,
0.0068964316,
-0.0027528501,
-0.0334450081,
0.0064410768,
-0.0472741611,
-0.0085744355,
0.0053385454,
0.0193644203,
-0.0240669679,
-0.0143418936,
0.0751587972,
-0.0389929563,
-0.0346902795,
0.032141149,
0.0326321088,
-0.0367398821,
-0.004657398,
0.0231950041,
-0.0769975632,
0.0124793109,
0.0047179018,
-0.0264012162,
-0.0024792051,
0.0224484783,
-0.0074805557,
0.0094957957,
-0.0622949116,
0.0250262115,
0.0466203913,
0.0357988216,
0.0661061406,
-0.0074862018,
0.0086118123,
0.0453774258,
0.0112251062,
0.0374926627,
-0.0459850617,
-0.0242167674,
0.0229776036,
0.0017842343,
0.0484968759,
0.0273644328,
0.0126428008,
-0.030254405,
-0.0135394223,
-0.0055119605,
-0.0303985737,
0.043343693,
0.0314759538,
0.0088696172,
-0.0405959748,
-0.015054456,
-0.0283424277,
0.0121112093,
-0.0321674757,
-0.0622092374,
0.0217224117,
0.0257992167,
-0.0365582965,
0.0028964293,
-0.0126599474,
-0.0494026877,
-0.0496319495,
-0.0210616421,
-0.0095816487,
0.0097436449,
-0.0261652917,
0.0272892565,
-0.0118228011,
-0.0018197903,
-0.0054934956,
-0.0006232722,
0.0035035186,
0.0241287686,
-0.0004318336,
0.0374522358,
-0.088984102,
0.036976371,
-0.0360651761,
0.0238127764,
0.0031887048,
-0.0252238046,
0.0270566307,
0.0164894555,
-0.0112323686,
0.016659569,
0.0410881154,
-0.0143505428,
-0.0234452374,
0.0220959987,
-0.0022579206,
0.0120127201,
-0.0293020494,
-0.0041638748,
-0.042591773,
0.033430405,
0.0375946946,
-0.050988473,
0.0084782522,
-0.011871323,
2.776e-7,
0.02409067,
0.0834461078,
0.0160193443,
0.0244996212,
0.01163592,
0.0048319274,
-0.0128791695,
-0.0041492605,
0.0412250236,
-0.0175938904,
-0.0042982767,
0.023911735,
0.0455071293,
0.0283300839,
-0.0611596182,
0.0110515309,
-0.0544929877,
0.0121683218,
-0.0710845217,
-0.0422851741,
0.0288477354,
0.0828467533,
0.031159522,
-0.0196612384,
-0.0125300465,
-0.0542220436,
0.0478365049,
-0.0084650163,
-0.0390545614,
0.040060591,
0.0237766821,
0.0408431441,
0.0060042874,
-0.0008041376,
-0.0139197903,
-0.0194782056,
-0.0380495898,
0.0242756754,
-0.0156565364,
-0.0056821951,
-0.0296693929,
-0.0134562999,
0.0112731112,
-0.0643285289,
0.0464502834,
-0.0560465008,
-0.0046140035,
-0.0446396396,
0.0077754282,
-0.0313936882,
0.0311278999,
-0.042059999,
-0.0319985747,
0.0504707694,
0.0242886152,
0.0633023605,
-0.0162072517,
-0.0914628208,
-0.0216090772,
-0.0042282641,
-0.0289708991,
-0.0050557666,
0.008826131,
0.017794989,
-0.0085437438,
-0.073683247,
0.0194463842,
2.696969061e-34,
0.040019989,
-0.0063088583,
0.0258461926,
0.0295635276,
0.0296106003,
0.0262359306,
0.0187983103,
0.0344947651,
-0.0004637915,
-0.0608990863,
-0.0270380285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03151v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03151v1 | Food-500 Cap: A Fine-Grained Food Caption Benchmark for Evaluating Vision-Language Models | 2023-08-06T15:56:31 | 2023-08-06T15:56:31 | Zheng Ma, Mianzhi Pan, Wenhan Wu, Kanzhi Cheng, Jianbing Zhang, Shujian Huang, Jiajun Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision-language models (VLMs) have shown impressive performance in
substantial downstream multi-modal tasks. However, only comparing the
fine-tuned performance on downstream tasks leads to the poor interpretability
of VLMs, which is adverse to their future improvement. Several prior works have
identified this issue and used various probing methods under a zero-shot
setting to detect VLMs' limitations, but they all examine VLMs using general
datasets instead of specialized ones. In practical applications, VLMs are
usually applied to specific scenarios, such as e-commerce and news fields, so
the generalization of VLMs in specific domains should be given more attention.
In this paper, we comprehensively investigate the capabilities of popular VLMs
in a specific field, the food domain. To this end, we build a food caption
dataset, Food-500 Cap, which contains 24,700 food images with 494 categories.
Each image is accompanied by a detailed caption, including fine-grained
attributes of food, such as the ingredient, shape, and color. We also provide a
culinary culture taxonomy that classifies each food category based on its
geographic origin in order to better analyze the performance differences of VLM
in different regions. Experiments on our proposed datasets demonstrate that
popular VLMs underperform in the food domain compared with their performance in
the general domain. Furthermore, our research reveals severe bias in VLMs'
ability to handle food items from different geographic regions. We adopt
diverse probing methods and evaluate nine VLMs belonging to different
architectures to verify the aforementioned observations. We hope that our study
will bring researchers' attention to VLM's limitations when applying them to
the domain of food or culinary cultures, and spur further investigations to
address this issue. | [
0.0401030406,
0.0897842571,
-0.0147078643,
0.0417808183,
-0.0180461574,
0.0399285741,
0.008941195,
0.0270843469,
0.0115519045,
-0.0907652155,
-0.026575122,
-0.0323972292,
0.0073948996,
0.0730615109,
-0.002264312,
-0.0486152209,
0.0201813951,
-0.0040156548,
-0.0002945032,
0.0424572527,
-0.0092709325,
-0.0037778981,
0.0291920584,
0.026407849,
-0.0244558994,
0.0055222195,
0.0083224801,
0.0282078143,
-0.0024393988,
-0.0301203728,
-0.0067679263,
0.0467787907,
0.0263875853,
-0.0193557981,
0.0000018735,
-0.0062698037,
0.0256667994,
0.0047296518,
0.0264896248,
0.0315342583,
0.0503702052,
-0.0473401584,
0.0025063884,
-0.0337002948,
-0.01253442,
-0.0332683772,
0.0816473663,
0.0672451034,
-0.0249299686,
0.0250740424,
-0.009714948,
-0.0952917561,
-0.024064118,
0.0053319745,
-0.0017065144,
-0.0142469648,
0.0363356099,
0.0139720058,
-0.0213504639,
0.0065525747,
-0.038925007,
0.0462188609,
0.0186267681,
0.0218623988,
-0.066339314,
0.0586159751,
-0.0362370647,
-0.0590416119,
0.0099575575,
0.0755640715,
-0.0257935673,
0.0092670172,
-0.0201802459,
0.0009847466,
-0.0351962484,
-0.0343511105,
-0.0288597345,
0.0006396765,
0.008391073,
0.0373213738,
-0.039573472,
0.0164013132,
0.0247804057,
0.0275795497,
0.0096348915,
0.0294778179,
0.0044228169,
0.0156908799,
-0.046109546,
0.0053111562,
-0.0525785051,
-0.0467183292,
-0.0013473463,
-0.004377929,
0.0220416579,
0.02669104,
-0.017937867,
0.0314881839,
0.0163382906,
-0.0046641333,
0.0257348623,
0.0107700713,
-0.0824046135,
0.0519971848,
-0.0271235388,
0.0523448065,
-0.011809919,
0.0428680144,
-0.0591263287,
-0.0147115374,
-0.0638677329,
0.0108533707,
0.0146430423,
-0.0184517652,
-0.0528607443,
-0.0551391356,
-0.0265306067,
-0.0219613463,
-0.0084657511,
-0.0010840941,
-0.0175039656,
0.0395207442,
-0.0228562299,
0.0094101401,
-0.0529513694,
0.0563229993,
-0.0134326387,
-0.0071409815,
-0.0255958531,
-0.036354173,
0.015786333,
0.0118151344,
0.0074996329,
0.0133449621,
-0.0043519284,
0.0533884875,
-0.0150070824,
-0.0534189157,
-0.0350271501,
-0.0353102908,
-0.0694390163,
-0.0553119071,
0.0157740768,
-0.0743276998,
0.0081397062,
0.000437153,
0.0406902805,
-0.011319994,
0.0127430996,
0.0418492556,
-0.0411971286,
0.1029258445,
0.03449893,
0.0049674036,
-0.0144327227,
0.0188143831,
0.0173393153,
0.0734303892,
-0.0088143963,
0.0520112328,
0.0357265323,
0.0053480449,
0.024693625,
0.0109824101,
-0.0417387076,
0.0257741995,
-0.0843217522,
0.0154157365,
-0.0074393144,
0.012899898,
0.0205562245,
0.045209799,
-0.0031542927,
-0.0130767981,
0.1184471324,
0.0589326285,
0.0044904035,
0.0239344556,
0.0306243282,
-0.000538373,
-0.0024217803,
0.0000629033,
-0.0295749567,
0.0275155138,
-0.0343718305,
-0.0035942413,
-0.0400945954,
0.0310301892,
-0.0415279418,
-0.0488798879,
-0.0268427171,
-0.032661438,
0.0500781275,
0.0036978971,
0.0755207464,
-0.0187593065,
-0.0146562364,
-0.0182072651,
0.0030894899,
-0.0342048742,
-0.0040014493,
-0.0383967794,
0.0386439189,
0.0617402419,
0.0306532048,
0.0042632408,
0.000077607,
0.0320196562,
0.0523529276,
0.0418636687,
0.0303282719,
0.0035928374,
0.0062726135,
-0.0356195047,
-0.0708452389,
-0.0176440459,
0.0226534959,
-0.0099696768,
-0.0000988837,
0.0135260439,
0.0381091647,
-0.0148262931,
-0.0232856087,
0.0151404943,
0.0638144985,
0.0099481372,
-0.0119846705,
0.0086348262,
-0.0327149406,
0.0163875595,
0.0109604383,
0.0212391913,
-0.0084529659,
-0.039362371,
0.0086001437,
0.0559200794,
-0.0092361951,
-0.0052984161,
0.0066863727,
-0.061065875,
0.0001423655,
-0.0021024067,
-0.0262659099,
-0.033745084,
0.0277644619,
-0.0175514705,
-0.0092982482,
-0.0359298848,
0.0006309706,
-0.0279845558,
0.0452940241,
-0.0115685444,
0.0638244599,
-0.019651508,
0.0049806815,
-0.0211454965,
-0.0304100104,
0.0066734035,
0.0135568446,
-0.0149765192,
-0.0094313575,
0.0208365433,
0.0451550111,
0.0178899057,
0.0371853374,
-0.0442812964,
-0.0140039297,
-0.0950291529,
-0.0217698105,
-0.0248791259,
-0.0166688971,
-0.0134917265,
-0.0028625298,
0.0024850243,
-0.0272190385,
-0.0210590735,
0.0338488147,
-0.0543109961,
0.0350635499,
0.0014696262,
0.0051039928,
-0.0049206,
-0.0082396055,
-0.0034849434,
0.025326794,
0.0672352836,
0.0003610759,
-0.0306974798,
-0.0253177453,
-0.0623633116,
-0.0250042882,
0.0119187431,
0.0020442258,
-0.0264139585,
-0.0200173967,
0.0094250795,
-0.0332958438,
0.0573029257,
-0.0199866537,
0.0115979416,
0.0190853719,
-0.0325959437,
-0.0399190821,
-0.022812767,
-0.0133541655,
-0.0011504851,
-0.0197257418,
-0.0606563725,
-0.0134452553,
0.0513027236,
-0.0139941964,
0.0334600024,
-0.04266949,
0.0680157095,
-0.0420546606,
-0.0613628849,
-0.0624357313,
0.0470308922,
0.012533756,
0.0697291344,
-0.0269596539,
-0.0587334186,
0.032455232,
-0.047252018,
0.0092772683,
0.013558452,
-0.0078125428,
-0.0508786589,
0.072636947,
0.0368722603,
0.0400982946,
0.0452373102,
-0.0086041978,
-0.0238182545,
0.022116432,
-0.024447348,
-0.0464394316,
0.1119858325,
-0.0570357852,
-0.032521084,
-0.0185725503,
-0.0122686392,
-0.0298769344,
-0.0087641142,
-0.0364340022,
0.029952582,
-0.0112470156,
0.0062964628,
-0.0753536075,
0.0859356523,
-0.0067853862,
0.0049484572,
0.009883252,
-0.0245411415,
0.0032093448,
0.0214733165,
0.0506608188,
0.0172581319,
-0.0417195484,
0.0007661608,
-0.0167103242,
0.0261705052,
-0.0139170028,
-0.0004992152,
-0.04142664,
0.0705132782,
0.0372810178,
0.0378851928,
-0.032289613,
0.0132124657,
0.0419017673,
-0.0294940099,
-0.0134832282,
0.0853007138,
0.0246621463,
-0.0723048076,
0.0027133264,
0.0548737273,
-0.0180785693,
0.038998168,
0.0266959686,
-0.0753896385,
-0.0353003368,
-0.0330475755,
-0.0158967711,
-0.0303350743,
0.0163377859,
-0.0536621436,
-0.0908450782,
0.0627265945,
-0.0043044114,
-0.0488146693,
-0.076248616,
-0.002679019,
0.0023148195,
-0.0203821212,
0.0385403633,
-0.045855172,
-0.0261365362,
-0.0049156817,
0.0158298537,
0.002691227,
-0.0489409268,
0.0344216451,
-0.0760156885,
0.0193807203,
0.0755214989,
0.0273352787,
-0.0005558261,
-0.0560092852,
-0.0122208148,
-0.0296433438,
0.03143958,
-0.0064070392,
0.0434789583,
-0.0082981028,
-0.0420721285,
0.021140527,
-0.0239390545,
-0.0326318331,
-0.0168377273,
-0.0157448463,
0.0235217717,
0.0286025163,
-0.0222717319,
-0.0405179895,
-0.0360884815,
-0.0129043227,
0.0380115956,
0.0408363342,
-0.0337850377,
-0.0347172432,
-0.0278420448,
-0.0833073705,
-0.0212763175,
-0.0227380786,
0.0697929263,
-0.0357856899,
-0.0457392074,
-0.0560006984,
-0.0131550301,
0.0052983765,
0.0255669858,
0.0108716637,
0.0198754128,
-0.0103412839,
0.0296045467,
-0.0579317845,
0.0526733845,
-0.037682984,
0.0061679701,
-0.027918363,
-0.0027394528,
0.0620737448,
-0.0520763397,
-0.0082995128,
0.0168311652,
-0.0950933173,
-0.0116527388,
-0.0316013992,
0.0506401174,
0.013387586,
0.0308932271,
-0.0053914678,
-0.0838261098,
0.0205106735,
0.0469998568,
0.0198305696,
0.0068226536,
-0.0106036374,
-0.0370855965,
0.020964751,
0.0225989558,
-0.0510299318,
0.0552464426,
0.0183091145,
0.0338485576,
-0.0001928261,
-0.0334865637,
0.0177893844,
-0.0347193629,
0.0495364256,
-0.0139558399,
-0.0054076863,
-0.0038166624,
0.0010126238,
0.0054289205,
-0.0288924295,
-0.0530452989,
-0.0289456155,
0.0409720577,
0.0233950913,
-0.0176292807,
0.0022237583,
-0.0253497362,
0.0144765796,
-0.0595634282,
0.0093723703,
0.0392539203,
-0.0325445272,
-0.0250490569,
0.0194608532,
-0.0100409649,
0.0231163129,
-0.0394065157,
0.0162419286,
-0.0223264974,
0.0681742951,
-0.0196179617,
-0.0026703817,
-0.0566883422,
0.0760148168,
0.0028185733,
0.0060703387,
0.0039488496,
0.0176793579,
0.0562667102,
-0.0771086439,
0.0493419208,
-0.0097252904,
0.0079477243,
-0.0312405098,
0.0615737624,
0.0037370387,
-0.0221002065,
0.0671973899,
0.0246359333,
0.0010847459,
0.0103861829,
0.0746783763,
0.0037206255,
0.0108055379,
0.0216859654,
-0.0203748196,
-0.0056176973,
0.0180990715,
0.0327650532,
-0.022513302,
-0.0328408964,
0.005055014,
-0.0461902805,
-0.0463633761,
0.0140191438,
-0.0183006525,
0.0344355293,
0.0298074689,
0.0234586503,
0.0735328496,
0.0319153406,
-0.0151795344,
-0.0315052569,
-0.0429066792,
-0.0358306654,
0.0068136747,
0.0192509834,
-6.176715147e-33,
-0.0079968553,
-0.0533802807,
0.0227015391,
0.0069292015,
0.017345544,
0.0428153686,
-0.0207630713,
-0.0067665786,
0.0074719726,
0.0048838002,
0.0396320261,
-0.0252282377,
0.0219202787,
0.0234823357,
0.0172909945,
-0.0369069465,
0.0174124073,
0.0259105731,
-0.002219111,
-0.0328792073,
-0.0190872438,
0.0010943711,
0.0459850095,
-0.0432339683,
0.008536703,
0.0131306332,
0.0035416966,
-0.0292342082,
0.044481732,
0.1064800173,
-0.0532429665,
0.064485155,
0.040952567,
-0.0099135712,
-0.0412126519,
0.0059862868,
-0.0452779867,
0.0180476811,
0.0093941744,
0.0486889817,
-0.0410871468,
0.0105983522,
0.0365698934,
-0.0076731392,
0.0078027849,
0.0288806017,
0.0584941134,
-0.0450804196,
-0.024291005,
0.0076231826,
-0.0435586199,
0.0423047617,
0.0263679828,
-0.0066930847,
0.0886595547,
0.0375147238,
0.0284672212,
0.0471936092,
-0.0056883642,
0.040262308,
0.0279845726,
-0.0049176416,
0.1135686487,
0.0593798533,
0.0013344563,
0.0594024099,
0.0257465169,
-0.007219289,
-0.0039592236,
-0.0287221614,
0.0437383167,
0.0858941302,
0.0320257209,
0.040961463,
0.0406679958,
0.0233337544,
0.0004031725,
0.017900303,
-0.0587664954,
-0.0009158759,
0.0114474045,
0.0346980244,
-0.0085507343,
0.0141619639,
-0.0433739237,
-0.022546446,
-0.0659395978,
-0.0215767529,
0.0444745645,
0.0303144362,
-0.0319138728,
0.0256507657,
0.0399657935,
-0.0064861802,
0.0032384838,
-0.0486581661,
0.0053891744,
0.0319781303,
-0.0116134882,
-0.0025961495,
-0.0692618042,
-0.0717201009,
0.0272264723,
0.0111278677,
-0.0052941795,
-0.0164699983,
0.0215619616,
0.0112593155,
-0.0155777633,
-0.0134515148,
-0.0269146301,
-0.0549153164,
-0.0070061493,
0.0370621905,
0.0542427376,
0.0020787877,
-0.0642885864,
0.033430025,
0.0086645093,
-0.0144272326,
-0.0198908113,
-0.0157437976,
0.030974187,
-0.0021621713,
-0.0242759865,
-0.0108635174,
-0.0326646045,
-0.0376617275,
0.020177789,
-0.0308217723,
-0.0098156091,
0.0467115045,
2.547e-7,
0.0548128821,
0.0473828763,
-0.0057202387,
0.013989768,
0.0059720636,
0.0390977748,
-0.003362657,
0.0288844276,
-0.0266854875,
-0.0220143292,
0.0141904466,
0.0046665445,
0.0213170443,
0.0216534957,
-0.0238327552,
0.0364300199,
-0.0185971223,
0.0363478474,
-0.0498865172,
-0.01003638,
0.0199022274,
0.0822831094,
-0.0143036395,
-0.0197774954,
0.0273956303,
-0.0517329462,
0.0765971318,
-0.0766963512,
0.0024243607,
-0.029853655,
-0.0080529116,
0.067465201,
0.0092737013,
0.0064997673,
-0.0134588797,
-0.0358262658,
0.0650593266,
0.030306397,
-0.0298215747,
-0.0147412196,
-0.0186531451,
0.0306068398,
-0.0174402781,
-0.0780993104,
0.0888795778,
-0.0748688877,
-0.0069978964,
-0.0035718384,
0.0297920909,
0.0260613337,
0.0207987987,
-0.0144135775,
0.0190871544,
0.0191394668,
0.0238377824,
-0.0294342432,
-0.0323405527,
-0.0699185431,
-0.0160496458,
-0.0445410982,
-0.0122548826,
-0.0182154421,
-0.0483200625,
-0.0264590178,
-0.0192780662,
-0.0089370683,
-0.0652080998,
2.199716813e-34,
0.0326256268,
-0.0052350615,
0.0035402887,
-0.0147078987,
0.0064730654,
-0.0037300314,
-0.0502767563,
-0.0005792662,
-0.0237170141,
-0.0685280114,
0.0041071442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03131v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03131v4 | Towards Multiple References Era -- Addressing Data Leakage and Limited Reference Diversity in NLG Evaluation | 2023-08-06T14:49:26 | 2023-08-10T02:08:04 | Xianfeng Zeng, Yijin Liu, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | N-gram matching-based evaluation metrics, such as BLEU and chrF, are widely
utilized across a range of natural language generation (NLG) tasks. However,
recent studies have revealed a weak correlation between these matching-based
metrics and human evaluations, especially when compared with neural-based
metrics like BLEURT. In this paper, we conjecture that the performance
bottleneck in matching-based metrics may be caused by the limited diversity of
references. To address this issue, we propose to utilize \textit{multiple
references} to enhance the consistency between these metrics and human
evaluations. Within the WMT Metrics benchmarks, we observe that the
multi-references F200spBLEU surpasses the conventional single-reference one by
an accuracy improvement of 7.2\%. Remarkably, it also exceeds the neural-based
BERTscore by an accuracy enhancement of 3.9\%. Moreover, we observe that the
data leakage issue in large language models (LLMs) can be mitigated to a large
extent by our multi-reference metric. We release the code and data at
\url{https://github.com/SefaZeng/LLM-Ref} | [
0.0233916808,
0.0682572946,
0.0127255172,
0.0136480099,
-0.0467350408,
-0.0435147919,
0.0384023003,
-0.0083119543,
-0.0179762207,
-0.048883941,
-0.0578447953,
-0.0608582757,
0.0454238839,
-0.0019957621,
0.0481345952,
0.0001413203,
0.022262821,
-0.0129170381,
-0.0084453775,
-0.0029213491,
-0.019014338,
0.0304594692,
-0.0003560177,
0.0640689582,
-0.0269524734,
0.0217413139,
0.0383432694,
0.0131513812,
0.0190436654,
-0.0420497097,
-0.0081065958,
0.0473255552,
-0.0436101146,
0.0344248898,
0.0000020045,
-0.0715800151,
-0.0209110137,
0.0308774691,
0.0056976494,
0.0599050932,
0.0368991271,
0.0028794522,
0.0173621904,
0.0234268121,
-0.0182345826,
-0.0011054659,
0.044109866,
0.0320897922,
0.0873654634,
0.0433371887,
0.0118890079,
0.0050283084,
0.0148024717,
-0.0540609434,
0.0173615776,
-0.0577071644,
-0.0047367741,
-0.014042859,
0.0093273288,
-0.030282801,
0.01115348,
0.0371167213,
-0.0164203141,
0.0144778574,
0.0169609226,
0.0423752964,
-0.0506789126,
-0.0024396474,
0.0206831321,
0.0735456795,
-0.023653686,
-0.0015478822,
0.0060502235,
0.0152370641,
-0.0108258445,
-0.0009649281,
-0.021627903,
0.0413079523,
-0.030684175,
0.0285280664,
-0.0018449754,
-0.0093515599,
0.0432210974,
0.0259603746,
0.0316148512,
0.032242123,
0.0487212539,
-0.0106071355,
0.0170052499,
0.0326720215,
-0.0055910046,
-0.0440470763,
0.0216584336,
0.0039168797,
-0.0328736156,
0.026625216,
-0.0891376138,
-0.0150007838,
0.0485390685,
-0.041714076,
0.0658214614,
0.0304307733,
-0.0155029027,
-0.016501788,
-0.0347258151,
0.06978558,
-0.0269843321,
-0.0386280119,
-0.046063412,
-0.0166604873,
-0.0348173082,
0.0073352791,
-0.023586981,
0.0402846858,
-0.0249297004,
-0.0374215879,
-0.0701161698,
-0.0133189755,
-0.0148416823,
-0.027587777,
0.0009876845,
0.0136654759,
-0.0542245544,
0.0507922731,
-0.0103142699,
0.0135910632,
0.0011257259,
-0.0123621784,
0.0032367574,
-0.0676539987,
-0.0190546121,
0.0104819201,
-0.0009634387,
-0.0401573516,
-0.0026955465,
0.0702973455,
-0.0129804583,
-0.0066226926,
-0.0254662018,
-0.0656403452,
-0.0438133851,
-0.0702228993,
0.0235739034,
-0.0722446069,
0.0435879715,
-0.0082569439,
-0.021755781,
-0.0665402114,
0.0298066549,
0.0512171611,
-0.059478417,
0.0326662362,
-0.0140191242,
-0.0146919144,
0.0213675145,
0.0189175252,
0.0334062614,
0.0430256911,
0.0327485427,
-0.0011984145,
0.0367368981,
0.0006879871,
0.0011572842,
0.0442947969,
0.0253640506,
0.0108632464,
0.0088163717,
-0.0461716503,
0.0063441419,
0.0436169356,
0.0591769293,
0.0810727179,
-0.0384954028,
-0.0071071284,
0.0666008368,
-0.0116192764,
-0.0038187671,
0.0133954808,
0.058718618,
0.0207472239,
-0.0007609549,
0.0167125855,
-0.0131696025,
0.0285520796,
-0.0164017566,
0.0343694985,
0.1017564982,
0.0519188084,
-0.0009514269,
-0.0032452387,
-0.0231831744,
0.0026230686,
-0.0407740325,
-0.0418514758,
0.0019494616,
0.0234761126,
-0.0502319373,
0.1285901964,
0.0273440294,
-0.0777268559,
0.0325542949,
-0.0296046678,
0.0163107459,
0.0258701481,
0.0793343857,
0.0514616929,
-0.0486392193,
0.0055322926,
-0.0257238317,
0.0733412132,
0.0316988118,
0.0171983354,
0.02811612,
-0.0630415007,
-0.0178864263,
-0.0302064717,
0.0027501718,
0.0444335602,
-0.0123564787,
-0.0005575385,
0.0564513989,
-0.046168562,
-0.0352981165,
0.0435546525,
0.0004620078,
0.0078098904,
0.019868616,
-0.0129163293,
0.0310197845,
-0.0043543391,
-0.044723548,
0.0457327776,
0.0020612425,
-0.025319837,
0.0343056992,
0.0099620195,
-0.0460277461,
-0.0084439833,
0.0474458747,
-0.0554025881,
0.0362044089,
0.0161910597,
-0.0229527224,
-0.0464695506,
0.0274722651,
-0.0378977358,
-0.002773752,
-0.0162383746,
0.0258833468,
0.0440128371,
0.0365030058,
-0.020642776,
0.0438844152,
-0.0210922137,
0.0198331308,
0.0290082246,
0.0236511119,
0.0458317883,
-0.034547735,
-0.0357923657,
0.0075752055,
-0.0033485536,
0.0185605884,
0.0321355648,
0.0370315351,
-0.0326038785,
-0.0584955737,
-0.0320499763,
0.0213022307,
0.0039368453,
0.0320410877,
0.0258081481,
0.0086148381,
-0.0028668214,
-0.0077803517,
-0.018921202,
-0.0114962822,
0.0298313927,
0.0172596555,
0.031004563,
0.0191929191,
-0.0076392698,
-0.0404994003,
-0.0019937807,
0.0085496185,
0.0492336042,
0.0177167393,
-0.0057269419,
-0.0687927157,
0.0113750147,
-0.0594699942,
-0.0143653424,
0.0210640766,
-0.0408393256,
0.0216784161,
0.0266373232,
0.0478116274,
-0.0159589481,
0.002011528,
-0.0128627736,
0.0838066489,
-0.0040853843,
-0.0430972278,
0.0035599254,
-0.001976517,
-0.013995165,
-0.0011373344,
-0.0415686555,
0.0215470586,
0.0262968056,
0.0286877919,
-0.0172325112,
-0.0241095535,
0.0392672345,
-0.0043326449,
-0.0295351036,
-0.0111884829,
-0.0374455936,
-0.0107656624,
-0.0022475568,
-0.0201696157,
-0.0484705605,
0.0275230072,
-0.1028783619,
0.0013614189,
-0.039917063,
0.0189304166,
-0.0443194509,
0.0217508227,
0.005770463,
0.0125290947,
0.0217171982,
0.0064167259,
-0.046803955,
0.0315451734,
0.0069957408,
-0.0229185894,
0.0584993362,
-0.0796090439,
0.0096285855,
-0.0252642743,
-0.0414001383,
-0.0633038804,
-0.032396473,
-0.0058748811,
0.0178305265,
0.0268197823,
-0.0016850483,
-0.0656973794,
-0.0041209823,
0.0159171317,
0.0219621509,
-0.0097412495,
-0.0119466316,
-0.000310913,
0.0543517694,
0.0588163845,
0.0126773594,
0.0174004994,
-0.0018476262,
-0.0604147911,
0.0435296446,
0.0421681553,
0.0446269177,
-0.0229825284,
-0.0130003039,
0.0176236052,
-0.0102759656,
-0.0427006371,
0.0086382218,
0.0419541039,
-0.0600271672,
-0.0504860915,
0.1188943535,
0.0157317799,
-0.0204785503,
0.0037553213,
-0.0126254139,
0.0737374201,
0.002148587,
0.0137184458,
-0.0492819138,
-0.0254496634,
-0.0055968026,
0.048634816,
0.0067442334,
-0.0278985016,
-0.0444414616,
-0.1668924838,
0.0004114241,
0.0370217562,
-0.019127477,
0.0160213038,
-0.0235775523,
-0.0295371134,
-0.0214466564,
0.0046751141,
0.0089823026,
0.0185483545,
0.0352873579,
0.0286235046,
-0.0222586822,
-0.0538329519,
-0.0038343328,
-0.0527800806,
0.056720987,
0.0617457144,
0.0558519699,
0.0108700162,
-0.0247212406,
0.0259100292,
-0.0495400541,
0.0157170687,
-0.0290921424,
0.051632531,
-0.0043999515,
-0.0108868852,
-0.002947784,
0.0140504139,
-0.0226391517,
0.0109293722,
0.0075374069,
0.0325132012,
0.0129833044,
-0.021892922,
-0.0171910878,
0.0401259363,
0.0170971192,
0.070427455,
0.0287565626,
-0.0326670967,
-0.0104429685,
-0.0177147482,
0.0146107273,
-0.090266943,
0.0064025712,
0.040736489,
-0.0498423949,
-0.0229480807,
-0.1025899351,
-0.0390261598,
-0.0258097667,
0.049460832,
0.0043121455,
0.0017338993,
-0.0107517391,
0.0077021853,
-0.0017548961,
0.024120206,
-0.0066810022,
0.0008806815,
-0.0437503047,
-0.0059854388,
0.0277497824,
-0.0272109862,
-0.0197185036,
0.0800874308,
-0.0506182835,
-0.0514823273,
-0.0210551824,
0.0633400083,
0.0247384496,
0.0219286978,
-0.0014545479,
-0.0316543393,
-0.0125139123,
0.0571680441,
-0.0148755657,
0.0461049229,
-0.001725389,
-0.033645764,
-0.02346492,
0.0270326231,
-0.0615202077,
0.000886885,
0.0158487465,
0.0819310695,
0.0385161601,
-0.0430305824,
0.0247475207,
0.048702728,
0.0187978353,
-0.0935290456,
0.0830064565,
-0.0196717232,
-0.0273559131,
0.0167935882,
-0.017236419,
-0.0497095585,
0.0160698146,
0.0237483252,
0.0171874184,
-0.002609235,
-0.0202930123,
0.0022618666,
0.0588777401,
-0.0018934204,
-0.0355601572,
0.0368771106,
0.0287969317,
-0.0200147498,
-0.0121247387,
-0.033173196,
-0.011610386,
-0.0204728395,
0.014804936,
-0.0467183888,
0.0306116361,
0.0145711601,
0.0056325654,
0.0074463105,
0.0316005982,
-0.0283369124,
0.0562844463,
-0.0512535609,
-0.0142665477,
0.066025421,
0.029703103,
0.1113684997,
-0.0294827912,
0.0090073552,
-0.0329742096,
0.040391583,
-0.0163390525,
-0.0152358515,
0.0185322855,
-0.0217389558,
-0.0188632868,
0.0079087503,
0.0963400975,
0.0408892669,
0.0487688407,
-0.0166649148,
-0.0112635866,
-0.0256864112,
-0.0471606217,
-0.0803337917,
0.0083189327,
0.0011346826,
-0.0108894138,
-0.0437887534,
-0.0642006919,
0.0648836643,
0.0114748888,
0.0280810613,
-0.0042359619,
0.0407152139,
0.0371884368,
-0.0171666611,
0.0186326075,
-0.0260675643,
-0.0231489576,
-0.0346135162,
0.0041526947,
-0.0405211598,
-6.500279518e-33,
-0.0512315519,
-0.0293750148,
0.0197392106,
-0.0605758391,
-0.0364684388,
-0.0016882789,
-0.0572081767,
-0.0090812156,
-0.0031222438,
-0.0251771733,
0.0055359839,
-0.0509960689,
0.0147738494,
0.016683301,
0.0147213684,
-0.005712016,
0.0581211746,
0.0147985993,
-0.0555645004,
0.0234189332,
0.0506489202,
0.028048683,
0.0658015832,
-0.0492305644,
-0.0181524362,
-0.0126395933,
-0.0314368419,
-0.0131918024,
0.0150217256,
0.0522255637,
-0.0342161059,
0.0505804159,
0.0139134955,
0.0046029282,
-0.0328667127,
-0.025995383,
-0.0648958012,
-0.0376126952,
0.0253732223,
-0.0118323304,
0.0021236471,
-0.0342560709,
0.0496109463,
-0.0050662481,
-0.0211229958,
-0.0027980702,
0.0178353265,
-0.0344151892,
-0.063722074,
-0.0357382111,
-0.0347182527,
0.0130935665,
-0.0065281275,
0.0088675255,
-0.0195774995,
0.0497923829,
-0.0380604602,
-0.0401781574,
-0.0597520806,
0.009217808,
-0.0066455668,
0.0398810729,
0.0896677077,
0.0014745456,
-0.0089807948,
0.0555169508,
0.0242939349,
-0.0236326996,
-0.0015799757,
-0.0439868309,
0.0128690759,
0.0384636745,
0.0524195023,
0.0715724155,
0.034086477,
-0.0127378274,
-0.0673927292,
0.0418345146,
0.0178419761,
0.02243191,
0.0251756031,
-0.0150569659,
-0.0089837546,
-0.0076642353,
-0.0459950194,
-0.0208193585,
-0.0393163525,
-0.0244807005,
0.0625720471,
0.015596508,
-0.0135071957,
0.0168748442,
0.0351236835,
0.0013930094,
-0.0023698094,
0.0457159504,
-0.024078263,
-0.0045933649,
-0.0253537819,
-0.0097443135,
-0.0463018902,
-0.0366892107,
0.0215454269,
0.0383943878,
0.0179884974,
-0.0011263561,
0.024385225,
0.004313237,
-0.0470956005,
0.0163482837,
-0.0662246943,
0.0419617742,
0.0088065332,
-0.0307403021,
0.0309922975,
-0.0501872562,
-0.0166954435,
0.0247430615,
0.0113579128,
0.0246932637,
0.0150403073,
0.0002073662,
0.0355376191,
0.0119733028,
-0.0304707605,
0.0193011444,
0.0085011693,
0.0079154363,
0.0438504703,
-0.0352485888,
-0.0342904963,
-0.0004014544,
2.732e-7,
0.0156444795,
0.0184789263,
0.0177025124,
-0.0033422844,
-0.0222035814,
0.0007657604,
-0.0360152125,
0.0387244523,
-0.0247949958,
0.0380634591,
-0.0232865922,
-0.0458539613,
0.0782088041,
0.0278566014,
-0.0641800091,
-0.0382328741,
-0.0828515068,
0.0122323921,
-0.0398352593,
-0.0409728959,
-0.0394404642,
0.059249185,
-0.0141568426,
-0.0262384936,
-0.0248656161,
-0.0766523853,
0.0558669232,
-0.0188113451,
-0.0129790492,
0.0193524286,
0.0661638305,
0.0264917426,
-0.0199510511,
0.0083668502,
-0.0350063443,
0.0238329601,
0.0485428832,
0.0199024044,
0.0424369425,
-0.0600266904,
0.0259110201,
-0.0122001246,
-0.006643238,
-0.0054808198,
0.0219141953,
-0.0009040316,
-0.0307618547,
-0.0258410797,
-0.0386637487,
0.0014497825,
0.0046580848,
-0.0396559983,
-0.0189948045,
0.0130470376,
-0.0026022648,
0.000042992,
-0.0365986153,
-0.0300527401,
-0.0333608203,
0.0283796825,
-0.0287405849,
-0.0338496715,
-0.0176529791,
-0.0046489011,
0.0300706867,
-0.0619982332,
0.0145424595,
2.192938894e-34,
0.0265606996,
-0.0580145195,
0.0176101197,
-0.007297196,
0.0379336178,
-0.005546602,
-0.031797953,
0.0115197524,
-0.01222937,
-0.0638215393,
-0.0273644291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03122v1 | "Kurosawa": A Script Writer's Assistant | 2023-08-06T14:09:02 | 2023-08-06T14:09:02 | Prerak Gandhi, Vishal Pramanik, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Storytelling is the lifeline of the entertainment industry -- movies, TV
shows, and stand-up comedies, all need stories. A good and gripping script is
the lifeline of storytelling and demands creativity and resource investment.
Good scriptwriters are rare to find and often work under severe time pressure.
Consequently, entertainment media are actively looking for automation. In this
paper, we present an AI-based script-writing workbench called KUROSAWA which
addresses the tasks of plot generation and script generation. Plot generation
aims to generate a coherent and creative plot (600-800 words) given a prompt
(15-40 words). Script generation, on the other hand, generates a scene (200-500
words) in a screenplay format from a brief description (15-40 words). Kurosawa
needs data to train. We use a 4-act structure of storytelling to annotate the
plot dataset manually. We create a dataset of 1000 manually annotated plots and
their corresponding prompts/storylines and a gold-standard dataset of 1000
scenes with four main elements -- scene headings, action lines, dialogues, and
character names -- tagged individually. We fine-tune GPT-3 with the above
datasets to generate plots and scenes. These plots and scenes are first
evaluated and then used by the scriptwriters of a large and famous media
platform ErosNow. We release the annotated datasets and the models trained on
these datasets as a working benchmark for automatic movie plot and script
generation. | [
0.0294926483,
0.0034325121,
0.0028792673,
-0.0033670943,
-0.019286301,
-0.0094772913,
0.0102073327,
0.0264517684,
0.0113652283,
-0.0199788045,
-0.0197805706,
0.0103099002,
-0.004365609,
0.1062269583,
-0.0254011415,
-0.0552478768,
-0.0472323969,
-0.0016158874,
0.0544331782,
0.0393744409,
-0.0033752134,
0.0599421859,
-0.0163751896,
0.0306285433,
-0.0553790443,
-0.0122824088,
0.0071305325,
0.0204734504,
0.0549944751,
-0.0304175504,
0.0054986579,
0.0218912829,
0.0348807164,
0.0193217117,
0.0000016706,
-0.0657747611,
0.0189867914,
-0.026525991,
0.0138353053,
0.0178710762,
0.0029251699,
-0.0082402462,
0.0103772003,
-0.0313534364,
-0.0149442162,
0.0284304209,
0.0557771586,
0.0403617062,
0.0808867514,
0.0682265162,
-0.0427595973,
-0.065430373,
-0.0382747762,
-0.0220515355,
0.0242042039,
-0.0085646734,
-0.030387165,
0.0106739746,
0.0517200492,
-0.0481745005,
-0.0215842761,
-0.0045641544,
0.0050067627,
-0.0148968482,
0.0081297169,
0.0740844458,
-0.044431489,
0.0039960505,
0.0046131099,
0.0667778328,
-0.0030937123,
0.0048987297,
-0.0169984214,
-0.050610289,
0.0121519575,
0.0038774437,
-0.0560168847,
0.033019837,
-0.0295219328,
-0.009375276,
-0.0052241217,
0.0054699574,
0.0113065559,
-0.050819058,
0.0702140033,
-0.000978409,
0.0395160466,
0.0049416553,
-0.06141866,
-0.0145182423,
-0.0039094589,
-0.0947422832,
0.0249467678,
0.0378202908,
0.0443739146,
-0.0071956078,
-0.045692347,
-0.0051197112,
-0.0449160002,
-0.0101345852,
0.0755512714,
0.0307413507,
0.0067336275,
0.03629338,
0.0108683389,
0.0389441624,
0.0337044075,
-0.0274360497,
0.0337469503,
0.0728937164,
-0.0638850182,
0.0188471582,
-0.0685601905,
-0.0038776307,
-0.0444050431,
-0.0075028855,
-0.017216472,
0.015188369,
0.0043177377,
0.0389258824,
0.0046858704,
0.0330061205,
-0.0424116291,
-0.0255714785,
-0.0567052774,
0.0207607485,
-0.0330872275,
-0.0094736153,
0.0239704885,
0.0218051802,
-0.0145644331,
-0.0185718033,
0.0438108407,
0.0048517128,
0.0412492454,
0.0553686395,
-0.014804394,
0.0008725963,
-0.046205394,
-0.0283036064,
-0.0083433613,
-0.0441350825,
-0.0615575612,
-0.044132296,
0.08980643,
-0.0193798132,
-0.0049941363,
-0.0376374833,
0.0158709418,
-0.0009690505,
0.0159408338,
0.0114295939,
-0.0028358928,
0.019739354,
0.0312579833,
0.0223814957,
-0.0404934734,
-0.0072993785,
0.0796986595,
0.0845038742,
0.0301180985,
0.0033973441,
0.0595636927,
0.0143869091,
-0.0358525068,
0.0355434418,
-0.0099096429,
0.0148554081,
-0.0043285838,
0.0654892772,
-0.0162881818,
0.0349708833,
-0.0134881381,
0.0127370078,
0.047187496,
0.0398615263,
0.0081044482,
0.0230511557,
0.1160208955,
-0.0057298043,
0.001766875,
-0.00702648,
-0.0087960334,
0.0536385477,
0.0395972133,
0.016691478,
-0.0434487052,
-0.0197313745,
-0.033122804,
-0.0057578986,
0.0055798679,
-0.0120938495,
-0.0551478043,
-0.0530091003,
0.0031613195,
0.0124246208,
-0.0985909849,
-0.0410954058,
-0.0194996186,
-0.1098598391,
0.0543468781,
0.0159836523,
0.0457061715,
0.1029221937,
0.0250555091,
-0.0250172541,
-0.049270235,
-0.027377408,
0.0123139303,
0.0167262182,
-0.0000964632,
-0.0667400062,
0.0518955737,
-0.0510491617,
0.02710706,
-0.0337095708,
-0.0017593352,
0.0729135647,
-0.0342067555,
0.0063153435,
-0.0187406465,
0.0008625493,
-0.0402628519,
0.0355606601,
-0.0703256354,
-0.0366843082,
-0.023322301,
-0.0173038989,
0.0132113481,
-0.0175507385,
-0.0588689819,
-0.0299980287,
0.0178578887,
-0.0112498095,
-0.0082032355,
0.0555454828,
-0.003721114,
-0.0085910019,
-0.0205154214,
-0.0604568347,
-0.0168624334,
-0.0054716165,
-0.0171512756,
-0.0688529834,
-0.0188921355,
-0.0191740021,
-0.0251541287,
-0.0247078612,
0.0031066565,
0.0076189856,
-0.0006660593,
-0.0137983216,
0.0359438024,
0.0129107032,
-0.0020694158,
0.0083242273,
0.0268689431,
0.0520636141,
-0.0292215329,
0.022831209,
-0.0182832014,
0.0372484066,
-0.0212125257,
0.0350571945,
0.0062886761,
-0.0158699993,
-0.0395004265,
-0.0670968369,
0.0141516114,
0.0098542245,
-0.0302274954,
0.0269986782,
0.0065799956,
-0.0620155297,
-0.0142997578,
-0.0375511572,
0.0248932187,
0.0302416924,
-0.0599178076,
0.0124451322,
0.0517883338,
-0.0036773097,
-0.0091331825,
0.0198464561,
-0.0109618157,
0.0245541111,
0.0887364373,
0.012445624,
-0.0125335753,
0.0528651439,
-0.0001766302,
-0.0114884665,
-0.0355940983,
-0.0154373981,
-0.0015930459,
-0.0118309045,
0.0064340313,
0.0289017893,
-0.0018652327,
0.0015551872,
0.084507376,
-0.0375285558,
0.0296501741,
0.0152262887,
0.0116996281,
0.0280984342,
-0.0312955081,
-0.0362171158,
0.0062073101,
0.0333471112,
0.0629876852,
0.0347475074,
-0.0689116791,
0.0214852262,
0.0458050221,
0.0283172894,
0.0454524644,
-0.0255110674,
-0.0337288678,
0.0801941156,
0.0118736997,
-0.0252870303,
0.0546431653,
-0.0537526645,
-0.0331361331,
0.0001060447,
0.011396016,
-0.0298016779,
0.062789768,
0.0052295993,
0.0509105362,
-0.0220743306,
-0.0010458354,
-0.0424897857,
-0.0093396576,
0.056734737,
-0.0048976666,
0.0063781808,
-0.0123026688,
-0.0063513541,
-0.0223559868,
0.0011240838,
-0.0322840326,
-0.0007784787,
-0.0331315212,
-0.0347770639,
0.0249147452,
-0.0636948124,
0.0000349628,
0.0301812738,
-0.0209624059,
0.0848421007,
-0.0163770579,
-0.0447224528,
-0.0257576182,
0.0236338172,
0.0530187897,
-0.0544885434,
-0.0759162828,
-0.0079417042,
0.068950817,
-0.0036519694,
-0.0416635536,
0.0282894038,
-0.0231237449,
0.0342200659,
-0.0054261107,
-0.0218902919,
0.025696354,
-0.0189382825,
0.0602801256,
-0.0525448583,
-0.0149376774,
0.1134548262,
0.0181227233,
-0.0302189905,
-0.0102254599,
0.0072006243,
0.0173329897,
0.0511447527,
0.0192871951,
-0.0307826623,
0.01045065,
0.0009388346,
0.0384956412,
0.0011551834,
-0.0486932807,
-0.0434192233,
-0.0844758973,
0.1140001267,
0.0148924086,
-0.0253944937,
-0.0031674653,
-0.0121359294,
0.0145759573,
-0.010657358,
-0.0233910475,
0.0072500044,
-0.0183446873,
0.0092467191,
-0.0440299325,
-0.008394842,
-0.0215268936,
0.0306908656,
-0.0313577913,
0.0483088978,
0.0196007248,
0.0574406721,
-0.022943886,
0.0291460492,
-0.0157533102,
0.0234471299,
0.0125849387,
0.0169711746,
0.0507834181,
-0.0275297295,
-0.0243658852,
-0.022001626,
0.0753168166,
0.0007587137,
-0.0465618595,
0.0359370299,
0.021811856,
-0.0394197255,
-0.0308411345,
-0.0203299373,
0.0486590005,
0.0017678333,
0.0350460634,
0.0324522629,
-0.0498761423,
-0.0205518156,
-0.0183497611,
0.030063156,
-0.0894569457,
0.0249477364,
-0.0002456752,
-0.0540309325,
-0.0132840872,
-0.0524795242,
-0.0380932018,
0.0497005507,
0.0911819488,
0.0409507565,
-0.0386420079,
-0.0543017834,
-0.0044565392,
-0.0611837097,
-0.0351113863,
0.0122437868,
-0.0170898605,
-0.0117346402,
-0.0283560883,
0.0205980483,
-0.030306343,
-0.0136149572,
0.0221131649,
-0.0695989281,
-0.0603836998,
-0.0300982669,
0.0404646732,
0.0220566541,
0.0401992239,
0.0257982351,
-0.0207152627,
0.0219484381,
0.0067867092,
-0.0123667661,
0.0229361933,
-0.0147941671,
0.0409297869,
-0.0262262542,
-0.0099460911,
-0.0412750989,
0.0194064081,
-0.0187526029,
0.0328904651,
-0.023457123,
0.0024217356,
0.0037924966,
0.0275342129,
-0.0486112982,
-0.0922230184,
-0.0123184398,
-0.0779865459,
-0.0528564043,
-0.0252909362,
-0.0093304552,
-0.0348304696,
0.0233429596,
0.0476517044,
-0.0092470944,
-0.0322856978,
-0.0059382264,
-0.0644384995,
-0.0133640878,
-0.0492457449,
-0.0163168218,
0.0401769243,
-0.0124539249,
0.055513259,
0.0115691237,
-0.0216664299,
0.0333443582,
-0.0535801277,
0.039083194,
-0.0036197589,
0.0431682095,
0.0317791328,
0.0096263085,
0.0296117645,
0.043919839,
-0.0110000446,
-0.0321132392,
-0.0139029417,
0.0172424875,
0.0563586578,
-0.0376522094,
0.023032343,
-0.0369739681,
0.0184872448,
-0.0081045814,
0.031410601,
0.0013435283,
-0.0436113663,
-0.0345271602,
0.0124138203,
-0.0106016239,
0.0510575287,
0.0694462731,
-0.0023216638,
0.0431004576,
0.0455759577,
-0.0263758358,
-0.0368185528,
0.0060998509,
0.0189330503,
0.0241443608,
0.0211280771,
0.0029704159,
-0.0280552879,
-0.0483177342,
0.0374913886,
-0.0044583012,
0.0100744572,
-0.0088790134,
0.0484117419,
0.0266625285,
0.0101386923,
0.0484471321,
-0.0220419709,
0.0129129989,
-0.0429261215,
-0.0154312868,
-0.0253435913,
-4.655684599e-33,
-0.0353375748,
-0.031613782,
-0.0026043956,
0.0550424866,
-0.0480670631,
-0.0194677282,
-0.0287518743,
-0.0233825222,
0.0277762152,
0.0478007719,
0.018491203,
0.0123258503,
-0.0132305222,
0.0045740069,
0.009838569,
-0.0299990829,
0.0409964174,
0.0222449414,
-0.088285923,
0.0509496965,
0.0535298362,
0.046092499,
0.0233338196,
-0.0417404622,
-0.0567029379,
-0.0848820657,
-0.0326847397,
-0.0018923739,
0.0460167155,
0.0027027288,
0.0085080154,
0.0366840512,
0.0230794325,
0.0054328805,
0.0160604622,
-0.0057897214,
-0.0059072264,
-0.0353409983,
0.0025408827,
-0.0023776353,
0.0024435199,
-0.0342165306,
-0.0180685949,
-0.0458190478,
0.0204655975,
-0.044797603,
0.0660957173,
-0.0097071696,
0.0341254994,
-0.0123681268,
-0.0715732947,
-0.0046012215,
-0.0504521504,
-0.0551922731,
-0.0050710165,
0.0122740939,
0.0410349295,
-0.0177715886,
-0.0420668423,
0.0078982301,
-0.0427694768,
0.0399043895,
0.0133364983,
-0.0016913252,
-0.0394406989,
0.0650630891,
0.0030963426,
0.0059296372,
-0.0363896787,
0.0512985028,
-0.0423143841,
0.0439215973,
-0.0078250598,
0.0180378854,
-0.008667754,
-0.040025793,
-0.0448341072,
0.0706284344,
-0.0144087914,
0.0042362921,
0.0434886925,
0.0212929454,
0.0044362345,
-0.0201439578,
-0.0083604595,
-0.0807901844,
-0.0136240413,
-0.0407330394,
0.0239195451,
-0.0183054097,
0.024279099,
0.0048828251,
0.0323186293,
-0.013228992,
0.0688885078,
0.0334392041,
-0.0979754329,
0.0653543025,
0.0063250042,
0.0331817232,
0.0206851549,
-0.0103028556,
0.042536594,
0.0436036363,
0.0816315711,
0.0176675934,
0.0173886288,
0.0816717297,
-0.025735395,
-0.0021086487,
-0.0268041752,
0.0228694119,
-0.008121226,
-0.0182870217,
-0.0286695492,
0.008605497,
-0.0195385814,
0.0084301289,
-0.0091456668,
-0.0031280837,
-0.0093960306,
-0.0167507026,
-0.0240991898,
-0.0045642937,
-0.0474239029,
0.0421753377,
0.0152276019,
-0.0219700821,
0.0328334458,
-0.0300707836,
-0.0086791525,
-0.0068354844,
2.406e-7,
-0.0071542785,
-0.0140551534,
0.0454614162,
0.0409811288,
-0.0051425882,
0.0398348458,
-0.0413780361,
0.0321205966,
0.027628107,
-0.0292505305,
0.0421612449,
-0.0020130998,
0.0093861371,
0.0317825526,
-0.0619792007,
-0.0261653736,
-0.0444998257,
-0.0426766239,
-0.0731881559,
-0.0090231756,
0.0462393127,
-0.0093718795,
0.0526063256,
-0.0254070275,
0.0238546301,
-0.0461393483,
0.0729384571,
-0.0285796616,
-0.0099043669,
0.0285588037,
-0.0167169441,
0.0069420175,
-0.0389270447,
0.0014280147,
-0.0188363101,
-0.0003867397,
0.0204502847,
0.067572996,
-0.063620843,
0.033171013,
0.0465762764,
0.0130386213,
-0.0085358303,
-0.0402457379,
0.0394105613,
0.0169123821,
-0.0374464616,
-0.003628683,
-0.0056184074,
0.007074737,
-0.0355421118,
-0.0331797525,
-0.0073812413,
0.0137481662,
0.0372611098,
0.0288117509,
-0.0015046974,
-0.0391119756,
-0.0050470978,
0.0470774733,
-0.0290044844,
-0.0101803029,
-0.0028758983,
-0.0120357722,
0.0285808425,
-0.0449890494,
-0.0005330538,
2.064604987e-34,
0.0023475606,
0.0034545958,
0.0056513916,
-0.0151422173,
0.0485273674,
0.0077621276,
0.029222142,
0.0105350008,
0.0208679512,
-0.0265789796,
-0.0376820862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03117v1 | PromptSum: Parameter-Efficient Controllable Abstractive Summarization | 2023-08-06T13:54:14 | 2023-08-06T13:54:14 | Mathieu Ravaut, Hailin Chen, Ruochen Zhao, Chengwei Qin, Shafiq Joty, Nancy Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt tuning (PT), a parameter-efficient technique that only tunes the
additional prompt embeddings while keeping the backbone pre-trained language
model (PLM) frozen, has shown promising results in language understanding
tasks, especially in low-resource scenarios. However, effective prompt design
methods suitable for generation tasks such as summarization are still lacking.
At the same time, summarization guided through instructions (discrete prompts)
can achieve a desirable double objective of high quality and controllability in
summary generation. Towards a goal of strong summarization performance under
the triple conditions of parameter-efficiency, data-efficiency, and
controllability, we introduce PromptSum, a method combining PT with a
multi-task objective and discrete entity prompts for abstractive summarization.
Our model achieves competitive ROUGE results on popular abstractive
summarization benchmarks coupled with a strong level of controllability through
entities, all while only tuning several orders of magnitude less parameters. | [
0.0347310156,
0.0347817875,
0.0297433324,
-0.0050526788,
0.0194931738,
0.024956556,
-0.0022252148,
-0.0537819862,
-0.0322298594,
-0.0248212013,
-0.0090536941,
-0.0286973827,
0.005953345,
0.0235747509,
0.0259525366,
-0.093002677,
0.0609857962,
-0.0309990421,
-0.0027890683,
-0.0038197516,
0.0112026054,
0.0054356777,
0.0161660872,
0.0281742662,
0.0265544504,
-0.0073441872,
-0.03259084,
0.0162892789,
0.032307867,
-0.0190826412,
-0.00074415,
0.0427554138,
0.0289912038,
0.0014710722,
0.0000021101,
-0.0474617705,
-0.0559783801,
-0.0149503006,
-0.0322380513,
0.03030934,
0.014798467,
-0.0148851797,
0.0336929075,
0.0231588166,
0.0090941396,
-0.0065069273,
0.0247843135,
0.0565238409,
0.0928632244,
0.0794766024,
-0.003601315,
-0.0036752287,
-0.0072097089,
-0.0397705026,
-0.029959511,
-0.0132113174,
-0.0235216841,
-0.0202142671,
0.0092218956,
0.0069605475,
0.0032023268,
0.0414238498,
0.0343882591,
0.0008600287,
-0.0113671711,
0.0402956679,
-0.0037729687,
-0.0273404028,
-0.0186582617,
0.0832298845,
-0.0287225358,
-0.0048755486,
0.0313058235,
-0.0192795526,
-0.0027875141,
-0.0406424664,
-0.0396894999,
0.0561136603,
-0.0023371666,
0.0123884371,
0.014124536,
0.0389169678,
-0.0038372022,
0.016288938,
-0.0555334389,
0.0094038863,
0.0127244703,
0.0028620269,
-0.0166158229,
0.005315992,
-0.0913637504,
-0.0586564094,
-0.0014849404,
0.0583930202,
-0.0869323686,
-0.0070370855,
-0.0639879555,
-0.047953777,
0.008561857,
0.015092276,
0.0518707819,
0.0389925949,
0.0009615902,
0.0359167904,
-0.0121335061,
0.0538078807,
0.0248276982,
0.0285634212,
-0.0603717752,
0.0100150416,
-0.0010398284,
0.0148425009,
-0.0738810748,
0.0515192673,
-0.0504159816,
-0.0177743547,
-0.0209979694,
0.0534502119,
0.0446295701,
-0.0065067173,
-0.0037680273,
-0.0143043995,
-0.0285150055,
-0.0054717492,
0.0178689454,
-0.0241125692,
-0.0700150803,
-0.0379314683,
0.0401807986,
-0.0150197754,
-0.0358547755,
0.0250772666,
0.0107223364,
0.0022254824,
-0.0101521462,
0.0145026287,
-0.04409118,
-0.0415364504,
-0.0033266307,
-0.0522868708,
0.0028850629,
-0.0523485728,
-0.0549741909,
-0.0420845971,
0.0391713344,
-0.0041598217,
-0.0233631842,
-0.0188301615,
-0.0063017858,
0.006142363,
-0.0250533912,
0.0181161854,
-0.0249492209,
0.0129937027,
0.0036546327,
0.013923632,
-0.0115829371,
0.0398373641,
0.0173195936,
0.0461654738,
0.0194710307,
0.0359365791,
-0.030864032,
0.0115197049,
0.0365308858,
0.000643616,
0.0469777398,
0.0136380307,
0.0087071154,
-0.0124748722,
0.0475178212,
0.0811164156,
-0.0337257423,
0.0389197469,
0.0351630859,
0.0171726458,
-0.0051268856,
0.0027462412,
0.0960899964,
0.0457242094,
0.0010212389,
0.0437731743,
-0.0413544737,
0.0171325766,
-0.0317868926,
0.0563573837,
0.0887927935,
0.0212520137,
-0.0611077212,
-0.0482423007,
0.0337714218,
-0.013082887,
-0.0281227361,
0.0242069326,
-0.0075804298,
0.0211049207,
-0.0926679671,
0.0488062501,
0.0134806074,
-0.070917666,
0.012817285,
-0.0196909662,
0.0536008254,
0.0381264128,
0.0215035956,
-0.0256906301,
-0.0377925634,
-0.0028022463,
0.0416097865,
0.0474816673,
0.0385013968,
-0.0252642632,
0.022871308,
-0.0346366614,
-0.0257203691,
-0.0366862454,
-0.0032639131,
0.0303527825,
-0.005793415,
-0.0206345953,
0.0537979901,
0.0104294447,
-0.0452773087,
0.029585721,
-0.0384377912,
-0.0284048039,
-0.0007363591,
0.0164010357,
0.0044275811,
0.0414269902,
-0.0078958068,
0.0253336374,
-0.0061889221,
-0.0391755551,
0.0261636022,
0.0059589799,
-0.0637550429,
-0.0802117959,
-0.0161550045,
-0.0003875577,
0.0047740587,
0.0037599124,
-0.0358997732,
-0.0852031112,
-0.0190710798,
-0.0494805537,
0.0219468679,
-0.0485848486,
0.0164890494,
0.0195889268,
0.0027993543,
-0.0331520885,
0.0526252128,
-0.0151208015,
0.0012030349,
0.0987988934,
0.031522274,
0.0020806242,
-0.0541863963,
-0.0394307859,
-0.0133526688,
0.0231829919,
0.0076494585,
0.0610541515,
0.0418405905,
-0.0165884066,
-0.0206109043,
-0.0865621343,
0.0192274917,
-0.0437737517,
0.0012047355,
0.040888276,
0.0249539465,
-0.0133352289,
-0.0184361245,
-0.0542848334,
-0.0212381855,
0.0210595801,
0.0116280299,
0.0204662289,
0.0478964262,
-0.015322228,
-0.0412663408,
-0.0052980343,
0.0230595712,
0.0454031862,
0.0159731656,
-0.0190332159,
-0.0413866043,
0.0385918058,
-0.0255158097,
-0.0067300419,
0.0107419631,
0.0265722852,
-0.0029294046,
-0.0098303296,
0.0876159295,
0.0072981133,
0.0141146183,
0.0252031069,
0.0254667066,
-0.000209063,
-0.0283614285,
0.0165622756,
-0.0393451303,
0.0018852107,
0.0397881679,
-0.0133493813,
0.04483518,
0.0747075975,
0.0167216677,
-0.0074678608,
-0.0612208359,
0.0022468623,
-0.0029376696,
-0.0157117546,
-0.0632486641,
-0.0204212349,
-0.0075049559,
0.0318096541,
-0.0480026156,
-0.0237084813,
0.0704324841,
-0.0289702397,
0.0042677037,
-0.0483643785,
0.0000103719,
-0.0350141414,
0.0223226994,
0.023099605,
0.0489514209,
0.0207151584,
-0.0387093574,
-0.0725047365,
-0.0143617047,
0.0095446771,
-0.0046114423,
0.0510244034,
-0.0295204278,
-0.010653262,
-0.0348792411,
-0.0079056546,
-0.033733882,
-0.0663585588,
0.0073980209,
0.0481158718,
0.0424054787,
0.0062905382,
-0.0192239992,
0.0119507769,
0.0263005178,
0.0708064139,
-0.0321984217,
0.0054961247,
-0.0426137261,
0.0278749485,
0.0489874519,
0.0243154261,
0.0381769463,
-0.0845496207,
0.0858957469,
0.0049910834,
0.0280640665,
-0.0353915095,
0.0067647141,
0.004315841,
0.0068485332,
-0.0687814355,
-0.0118892752,
0.0262973383,
0.0919723138,
-0.0189647563,
-0.0222151466,
0.1381909698,
0.0110030249,
-0.0335102938,
0.0095540993,
0.0351357162,
0.0618611202,
-0.003864743,
0.034019921,
-0.0339771882,
-0.0049047521,
0.0003646793,
0.032791812,
0.026140023,
-0.037367098,
-0.0404235199,
-0.0658544973,
0.0131328516,
0.0021754093,
-0.065756999,
-0.002532193,
-0.0073096328,
-0.0106917135,
0.0138252322,
0.0446670651,
0.0523563735,
-0.0253521893,
0.030695606,
0.0269033834,
-0.0365872011,
0.0102695646,
-0.004584,
-0.0336498991,
-0.0039615841,
0.0483714677,
0.0175839514,
0.016534755,
0.035236489,
0.0360757709,
-0.054321181,
-0.0009963714,
-0.0035256781,
0.0345975645,
-0.0189782009,
-0.0166727267,
-0.0040857578,
0.0315959975,
0.0234321672,
-0.0055657057,
-0.0076921456,
0.0112440502,
-0.0090384958,
0.0110502001,
-0.0248595513,
0.024334155,
0.0132558402,
0.0844499543,
0.0806958899,
-0.0380286723,
-0.0301513094,
-0.0124029219,
-0.0291197915,
-0.1006826013,
0.0034957353,
-0.0252928045,
-0.0315736011,
-0.0062682596,
-0.075927332,
-0.0484427698,
0.0436388999,
0.0300524868,
-0.0108061871,
-0.0153537281,
-0.0224580429,
-0.0156894587,
-0.0317297131,
0.012670665,
-0.002656359,
-0.0080395853,
-0.0876689628,
-0.0552044362,
0.0282219183,
-0.0423708744,
-0.0186789464,
0.01806546,
-0.0439905785,
-0.055106584,
-0.0217324328,
0.0502742045,
0.0138745243,
0.0678706542,
-0.0009636366,
-0.0107500898,
0.096156396,
0.0081225354,
-0.0178592633,
0.0272007454,
0.0387897305,
0.0611038618,
-0.0219150484,
0.0359381847,
-0.0622494444,
0.0438017584,
0.0205936003,
0.0449772067,
-0.011023852,
-0.0554719679,
0.020601416,
0.0435705893,
0.0099744117,
-0.0390151963,
-0.0015676256,
-0.0484091863,
-0.0142592127,
-0.0183955021,
-0.0150752505,
-0.0698029846,
0.0473777391,
-0.0285550877,
-0.0128648803,
0.0053425399,
0.065237917,
0.0027348252,
0.0256980229,
-0.0310909562,
0.0012107895,
-0.0698532835,
-0.0081283581,
-0.0112976246,
0.0039100968,
-0.0522535294,
0.0030382208,
-0.0384606235,
0.0043014418,
-0.0094637033,
0.0510336794,
0.0298597347,
0.0217824746,
-0.0066137318,
0.065355055,
-0.0490631536,
-0.0326452702,
-0.0357411876,
0.0027207308,
0.0284629129,
-0.006319636,
0.0541039817,
0.005650532,
0.0088197412,
-0.0380257368,
0.0550469309,
0.0237023272,
-0.0407026857,
0.007919183,
0.0222630426,
0.012087943,
-0.0097565847,
0.0688292533,
-0.0219006389,
-0.0080728279,
0.0313071348,
0.0422209539,
-0.0584286153,
-0.0163595937,
-0.0056480854,
0.009935583,
-0.0365350395,
0.0014252549,
-0.0309808217,
-0.0211128257,
0.0147629948,
0.0267890785,
-0.0258845277,
0.0191530231,
0.0621526055,
-0.0006896519,
-0.0118507519,
-0.0095533244,
-0.0384510607,
-0.017762132,
-0.0116512952,
0.0019315631,
0.0092300866,
-6.342556094e-33,
-0.079975374,
0.01884133,
0.0085671684,
-0.0205321815,
-0.0341399536,
0.0323342569,
-0.0851907432,
0.0013583046,
0.0120695606,
-0.0260672066,
-0.0105377967,
-0.0169271473,
0.0066381427,
0.0442118719,
-0.0409932993,
-0.0030996203,
0.065718025,
-0.0015999046,
-0.0501511022,
0.0712527782,
0.0227050986,
0.0409055166,
0.007216807,
0.00057955,
0.0208937749,
-0.0261893217,
-0.0232580416,
0.0134391747,
0.0259865802,
0.0271445084,
-0.0222281497,
0.0115261646,
0.0039427951,
-0.0412721522,
-0.0872423351,
0.0449439026,
-0.0831892267,
-0.0521076135,
0.0305571146,
-0.0217611399,
-0.0905424058,
-0.0516340807,
-0.0090572694,
-0.0335537307,
0.0375897475,
-0.0336319692,
0.0149372006,
-0.0225925725,
-0.0240711551,
-0.067230083,
-0.0197860189,
0.0059664347,
-0.0181667563,
-0.0400654227,
0.0278875418,
0.04261709,
-0.0092867808,
-0.0207951926,
-0.0020826727,
0.0157510545,
0.057982143,
0.0203711856,
0.0151361581,
0.0442711562,
-0.0033013918,
0.0469859987,
0.0078208251,
0.0070292139,
-0.0272754766,
0.0536670499,
-0.0015628353,
0.0147167584,
-0.0022697221,
0.0059804842,
0.0107310778,
0.039908722,
-0.0413590781,
0.0691117719,
0.0013036117,
-0.0044546099,
0.0314777754,
-0.0317895226,
0.0016521644,
-0.0359843671,
-0.0398367606,
-0.001910424,
-0.0257247761,
-0.0220059343,
0.0263976231,
0.0314788111,
-0.0558366217,
-0.0334799327,
0.0474029146,
-0.0201973692,
0.028190352,
0.0075292517,
-0.0215381179,
-0.0036854427,
-0.0053173383,
0.0180078987,
-0.0531760342,
-0.0167960394,
0.0405999571,
-0.024343444,
-0.0211155321,
0.0236339141,
0.0442923643,
0.0291726533,
-0.0376003981,
0.014865906,
-0.0107292533,
0.0454594977,
-0.039961651,
0.0270452145,
-0.0085695703,
-0.0003279674,
-0.0064168838,
0.0654360801,
-0.0208536517,
-0.040282283,
-0.0180937406,
0.0424703658,
0.022605652,
0.0744258314,
-0.0280263405,
0.0158227216,
-0.0167417452,
0.0204596203,
0.032776203,
-0.0486888625,
-0.0211245213,
0.0053210501,
2.614e-7,
0.0295891892,
0.0101996921,
0.0612655133,
0.0370684601,
-0.0245448947,
-0.0106225014,
0.0132070547,
0.0377441794,
-0.0027812757,
-0.0155662736,
0.0455506556,
0.0445127413,
0.0087525919,
-0.0121623203,
-0.0997760296,
0.017941311,
-0.0667619333,
0.0210155584,
-0.0517703556,
-0.0117139639,
0.0688077509,
0.0634939075,
-0.0397790559,
0.020121187,
-0.0086785229,
0.02578713,
0.0371529311,
-0.0199530292,
-0.0231157392,
0.0363946445,
0.0448750108,
0.0214233045,
-0.0201902837,
-0.0016177153,
-0.0024513127,
0.0089201797,
0.0254140198,
0.0605972223,
0.051370427,
-0.0350334719,
0.0290543325,
-0.0241448153,
0.018913405,
-0.0111377621,
0.0653893352,
-0.0634047762,
-0.0045177299,
0.001307406,
-0.0362684727,
-0.0015560829,
-0.031339433,
-0.0135199297,
-0.0426658839,
0.0424329415,
0.0211093836,
-0.0160783436,
0.0228760317,
-0.0727179274,
-0.0432949215,
0.0045606848,
-0.0094242021,
-0.0326640792,
-0.0315087736,
-0.0137164695,
0.0047988086,
-0.0917035565,
-0.0262802821,
2.886797164e-34,
0.0682197064,
-0.0267446898,
-0.0050907214,
-0.0045353374,
0.0148815969,
-0.030214794,
0.0110419625,
-0.0210041311,
0.0585410111,
-0.0789480358,
-0.0428244397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03103v1 | Improving Domain-Specific Retrieval by NLI Fine-Tuning | 2023-08-06T12:40:58 | 2023-08-06T12:40:58 | Roman Dušek, Aleksander Wawer, Christopher Galias, Lidia Wojciechowska | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | The aim of this article is to investigate the fine-tuning potential of
natural language inference (NLI) data to improve information retrieval and
ranking. We demonstrate this for both English and Polish languages, using data
from one of the largest Polish e-commerce sites and selected open-domain
datasets. We employ both monolingual and multilingual sentence encoders
fine-tuned by a supervised method utilizing contrastive loss and NLI data. Our
results point to the fact that NLI fine-tuning increases the performance of the
models in both tasks and both languages, with the potential to improve mono-
and multilingual models. Finally, we investigate uniformity and alignment of
the embeddings to explain the effect of NLI-based fine-tuning for an
out-of-domain use-case. | [
0.0363789201,
0.0400394313,
-0.0311221071,
0.0668241605,
-0.020480698,
0.0309999119,
0.0207911823,
-0.0132391965,
0.0045601823,
-0.0474430136,
-0.0391757041,
-0.0008327441,
0.0041859718,
0.0094925258,
0.0342362151,
-0.0317101963,
0.0108640566,
-0.0049866205,
-0.0265868343,
-0.0182815231,
0.0269175041,
0.0149103301,
0.0052771848,
0.0210808665,
0.0752194896,
0.015941212,
0.0277854949,
-0.0002224049,
0.0103352293,
-0.0132110063,
0.072035566,
0.0076896632,
0.0476952866,
-0.0177746229,
0.0000017669,
-0.05849066,
-0.0028536581,
-0.0201100353,
0.0001300394,
-0.0081299646,
0.0363387205,
-0.0376861207,
0.0475550145,
0.0264612511,
-0.0259990375,
-0.0105410069,
0.0417665131,
0.0495780595,
-0.0029442555,
0.0832728297,
0.0025188385,
-0.0763032138,
-0.0083977133,
-0.0351456329,
-0.0897451043,
-0.0171181411,
0.0204739533,
-0.0249684285,
-0.0264846087,
0.0482492112,
0.011945934,
0.0073403744,
-0.0038571209,
0.0255912654,
-0.0007325275,
-0.0005262297,
-0.0288116559,
0.0035539798,
0.01001871,
0.0611339323,
-0.0176340528,
0.0055872248,
-0.0207028557,
0.0069477428,
0.0060256817,
0.0103835622,
-0.0449639186,
0.0346199349,
0.0054278863,
0.0255888533,
0.0405217484,
0.0470685735,
0.0167556107,
0.0007738643,
-0.0126053309,
0.0607703812,
0.0384610407,
-0.0361805782,
0.0377075225,
0.0193882007,
-0.044240877,
0.0120549751,
0.0325447321,
-0.0217645206,
-0.0130309137,
-0.0066466131,
-0.004229119,
-0.0067278314,
0.0135108875,
-0.0599920899,
-0.0045429692,
0.0452574007,
-0.0219256636,
0.0540916249,
-0.0160072856,
0.0370816737,
-0.0012942995,
-0.00780018,
-0.0560247786,
-0.0571896024,
-0.0203143992,
-0.0294718295,
-0.0322620161,
0.0266244709,
-0.0600241423,
-0.0007142054,
-0.0561070666,
-0.0050151297,
0.0053103627,
-0.0315388031,
0.0163682308,
0.0083770072,
-0.0485456139,
0.0174244959,
-0.0507470071,
0.0748613179,
-0.0602203272,
0.0185173471,
-0.0189166851,
-0.0364341214,
0.007646116,
0.0317419767,
0.0236983486,
-0.0569454469,
0.0343181938,
0.0725707337,
0.025455704,
-0.0313864835,
-0.0392982997,
-0.0088232709,
-0.0112390015,
-0.0443531834,
0.0214916449,
-0.0418699458,
0.0190551337,
0.0500305519,
-0.021619292,
-0.072517544,
0.0042891749,
0.0205246992,
-0.0520852916,
0.0583450422,
0.0008106869,
-0.035878595,
-0.0158254672,
-0.0281431526,
0.0268583093,
0.0726033673,
-0.0222433247,
0.0017150829,
0.0613220036,
0.0265452825,
-0.0152030056,
0.0135943089,
0.0082497913,
-0.0035637598,
0.0082256924,
0.0429713242,
-0.0230379906,
0.0077075134,
0.0570237264,
0.0036073031,
-0.0349919572,
0.0044246754,
0.0121119656,
0.0126230763,
0.0627417639,
0.0038557346,
0.0283202771,
-0.0203528255,
-0.0498329252,
0.0320502818,
0.0051729162,
0.0070839729,
0.0003952525,
0.0110014547,
0.061580617,
0.0470717251,
-0.0327464491,
-0.0369739868,
0.0034835793,
-0.0257006995,
0.0359193236,
-0.0271302164,
0.0796004981,
-0.0116092088,
-0.0315689966,
0.0205595642,
0.0673755854,
-0.0327870958,
-0.0197134018,
0.0078537185,
-0.0347663946,
0.0692210793,
0.0271397997,
-0.0326703824,
0.0157925468,
0.0095553119,
-0.009309792,
0.0412983373,
0.0314242728,
-0.006863676,
0.0368669927,
-0.05314558,
-0.0457603745,
-0.0607842132,
0.012566627,
0.0214446466,
-0.0010605473,
0.0469705649,
0.0457750484,
-0.0634808987,
-0.0132166622,
0.0053447564,
-0.0235953163,
-0.0163978282,
0.0072039962,
0.0489256196,
-0.0416793264,
0.0068832999,
0.0044498867,
-0.0027819856,
0.0122053931,
-0.0515780933,
-0.0282569006,
-0.026089197,
0.0005274921,
-0.0677655786,
0.0237247515,
-0.0789738595,
0.0002146329,
0.0379774421,
-0.0424868055,
-0.0010799633,
0.025107462,
-0.0169963911,
-0.008190426,
-0.0279579218,
-0.0147124361,
-0.0172806215,
0.0252550654,
-0.0544936024,
0.0628949106,
0.0062223268,
0.0727442205,
0.0253305286,
-0.0218868703,
0.0477765873,
-0.0194645561,
-0.039757099,
0.0209969245,
-0.0210706033,
0.0297542904,
0.0736542717,
-0.000333089,
-0.0186171178,
0.0403962284,
-0.069479458,
0.0356055163,
-0.0318174884,
0.0262291487,
0.0021452296,
0.0273441654,
0.0106552551,
-0.0213619359,
-0.0334105864,
-0.0576645546,
0.0025212897,
0.0496877134,
0.0427251831,
0.0144023439,
0.0137955146,
-0.0322177187,
-0.0214102641,
0.0113554122,
0.0465525612,
-0.0344537273,
-0.0304611493,
-0.0911260396,
0.0767876431,
-0.051674135,
0.0048516188,
-0.031491477,
-0.0393401496,
-0.017388083,
0.0197751746,
0.0417482667,
0.0601106957,
-0.0248451214,
-0.0073415777,
0.0332382582,
-0.0006884057,
-0.0375910327,
0.0088328142,
-0.0394007154,
0.003873466,
-0.0182962473,
0.0072968244,
0.0217820592,
0.026561955,
-0.013646421,
-0.0089773433,
-0.0412822813,
0.0026703526,
-0.0217582546,
0.0265096072,
-0.0403681099,
0.024505306,
0.0247256234,
0.0660631731,
0.0067356839,
-0.0169285499,
0.0754076019,
0.0171881448,
0.026744172,
-0.0621537231,
-0.0461066142,
-0.0713369474,
0.0321839228,
0.0002487509,
0.031024266,
0.0098793861,
-0.0284769814,
-0.0522999987,
0.0205437206,
0.0460075587,
-0.0261636376,
0.0348942615,
0.0245386846,
-0.0144383814,
-0.0320958979,
-0.0897907242,
-0.0156400837,
-0.0461556725,
-0.0168061331,
-0.0112338485,
0.0441755429,
-0.0081798574,
-0.0437208563,
0.0034641372,
0.0065728477,
0.014322863,
-0.0361723974,
-0.0077972822,
0.0007693159,
0.0391646475,
0.0703462213,
-0.0081796777,
-0.0069793896,
-0.0294199176,
-0.0365332812,
-0.00338746,
-0.0482489169,
-0.0201650169,
-0.0107430341,
-0.0377432145,
0.0486345105,
-0.0414902009,
-0.0186647791,
0.0027606941,
0.0224488229,
-0.0100383181,
-0.037394084,
0.0955923572,
-0.0018826157,
-0.01130528,
-0.0169807691,
-0.0135850795,
0.0223139208,
0.0249807704,
0.0178413279,
-0.0592808612,
-0.0628164411,
0.0008410834,
0.0251870546,
0.0043490632,
0.0267882608,
0.008985376,
-0.1536670923,
-0.0043314192,
-0.0165688824,
-0.0241771061,
-0.1038203165,
-0.0615639575,
0.0079020644,
-0.0269227978,
0.036566332,
0.003791448,
-0.0089785503,
0.0233903024,
0.0133394254,
-0.0221312437,
-0.0943815559,
-0.022803992,
-0.0521367043,
-0.000861585,
0.037836194,
0.0218134765,
-0.0093448656,
-0.0164989009,
0.0121180331,
-0.0523410961,
0.0086517129,
-0.0197455864,
0.1023084372,
-0.0063870056,
0.0092826225,
-0.0278784316,
0.0074755871,
-0.0283168908,
0.0228934642,
-0.0279163755,
0.0225376319,
0.013945641,
0.0115529606,
-0.0122262146,
-0.0325181969,
-0.0089975093,
0.0663098469,
0.0113789141,
-0.0238426737,
0.0022475943,
-0.075105533,
-0.0122864023,
-0.0197383314,
-0.048800528,
0.0314684398,
0.0167672876,
-0.0110856183,
-0.051999256,
-0.0731347874,
0.0223116782,
-0.0012643442,
-0.0038360595,
0.0083468221,
-0.0341808833,
-0.0138356239,
-0.0552605391,
0.0219155923,
-0.0405366495,
0.0153767215,
-0.0060848189,
0.0580694005,
0.0565768182,
-0.0164647643,
-0.0363016613,
-0.0266649611,
-0.0324038118,
-0.0709932223,
-0.0414338596,
0.0321445949,
0.0085710911,
0.0390838571,
-0.0219578389,
-0.0379900523,
0.025881473,
0.0739744306,
-0.0313959494,
-0.0294495337,
0.0368442424,
-0.0040135547,
0.0068744766,
0.04129906,
-0.0710481182,
-0.0055273278,
-0.0002930434,
0.0346808285,
0.0495072566,
-0.068657361,
0.0406703018,
0.008329317,
0.084858194,
0.0048761545,
-0.0085138455,
-0.0487335399,
0.0294697545,
-0.0047069509,
-0.0364573821,
-0.0056386609,
-0.0020616096,
0.0146335484,
0.0350221023,
-0.0236358158,
0.0364250056,
0.0057663606,
-0.0134891113,
-0.0607994497,
-0.002976387,
0.048599422,
0.0254644081,
-0.0131762708,
0.0246568322,
-0.0285410415,
0.0059734103,
0.0215383954,
0.0498544909,
-0.0552632436,
-0.0043638349,
0.040837463,
0.0079950402,
-0.01686229,
0.0200845413,
-0.0315370113,
-0.0062853876,
-0.0143990796,
-0.0652090758,
0.0735939294,
-0.0559423454,
0.0299425647,
0.0102197053,
-0.0207301546,
0.0154557712,
0.0321901031,
0.0044651907,
0.0077446597,
0.0224840306,
-0.0010789976,
-0.0496361628,
0.0104798768,
0.0677373782,
0.0076254569,
0.0148001239,
-0.0236836076,
-0.0287663192,
-0.0142618427,
-0.0065583116,
0.0019722129,
0.0175068881,
-0.0162578281,
-0.0010755819,
-0.017535869,
-0.055558648,
-0.01853537,
-0.003007442,
-0.0190576147,
-0.0128895482,
0.0466200784,
0.0519323722,
0.0122191785,
-0.007373238,
-0.0236429293,
0.0010557745,
-0.0136184525,
-0.0107308421,
-0.0597854629,
-6.131985016e-33,
-0.0028217402,
-0.0141697386,
-0.0193085633,
0.0004248043,
0.0150402877,
-0.0170242749,
-0.0005912971,
-0.0216514319,
-0.0584141165,
0.0037677391,
0.0146515518,
0.0193871818,
0.0094116917,
0.0196898114,
0.0020954588,
-0.0417201519,
0.0383747034,
0.0401586406,
-0.0183563754,
-0.0190146044,
0.0419911705,
0.0466296114,
0.0995762944,
-0.0641210079,
0.0203356165,
-0.0109827137,
0.0111813899,
0.0324174501,
0.0645551011,
0.0668207109,
0.0040243273,
0.0753285438,
0.0330006517,
-0.0834584758,
0.0213697981,
0.0017127532,
-0.0439579897,
-0.037754599,
0.0160308983,
0.0126401447,
-0.0217293035,
-0.0218783412,
0.0532142632,
0.0004668229,
0.012653959,
0.0145410085,
0.0704930723,
-0.0194036253,
0.0105094295,
-0.0343217403,
-0.0596860088,
0.0115101021,
-0.0153487232,
0.0070014494,
0.0186188277,
0.0867844969,
0.0165766515,
0.0594891161,
-0.0329238251,
0.031995289,
-0.004763288,
0.0595404655,
0.0139703443,
-0.0167883672,
-0.023351077,
0.0505483784,
-0.0204113498,
0.01164978,
0.0187162813,
-0.0317732841,
0.0241560042,
0.0242642928,
0.047596503,
0.0885756388,
0.0339695103,
0.0017048067,
-0.0992906094,
0.0466066115,
-0.0116755432,
0.0199314412,
-0.0046514403,
0.0301538669,
-0.0670457929,
-0.0510368831,
-0.0126894694,
-0.0131827146,
-0.0451402031,
-0.020413043,
0.0273764562,
0.0022089919,
-0.0191372726,
0.0069434848,
0.0273774955,
-0.0526992157,
-0.0568162948,
0.0373367034,
-0.0323320515,
-0.0133521268,
0.0061609023,
0.0248637926,
-0.0282894466,
-0.0340883955,
-0.0274662822,
0.0115016485,
-0.0047048777,
-0.0004842699,
0.0540826246,
-0.0176427606,
-0.0603197999,
0.01754307,
-0.0247052219,
-0.04269455,
-0.0290628355,
0.0416249298,
0.0208772942,
0.0530610569,
-0.0220579617,
0.0763749331,
0.0825455114,
-0.012541201,
-0.0644155219,
-0.0593603775,
0.0615053475,
0.0008383872,
-0.0133574419,
0.0040494073,
-0.0212127846,
0.0579532124,
-0.0091707753,
-0.04757566,
-0.0270253364,
0.0124685634,
2.62e-7,
0.0675956905,
0.0377099216,
-0.0239535216,
0.0466141291,
-0.0078078741,
0.0511244275,
0.0168668013,
0.0304895155,
0.0282297544,
0.0023572259,
0.0145457331,
-0.0032549652,
0.0246076416,
-0.0079250941,
-0.1021455973,
0.0418352298,
-0.0113068605,
-0.0243746862,
-0.026395807,
0.0004635819,
0.0374451727,
0.1286157221,
0.0108797895,
0.0291302297,
-0.0380317494,
-0.0516694635,
0.0719914287,
0.0006227765,
-0.0281086676,
-0.0140828872,
-0.0162567701,
0.0770742074,
-0.0138421925,
-0.0071691922,
-0.01011007,
0.0630246103,
0.0421865806,
0.0190885812,
0.00193255,
-0.0167472977,
0.005831012,
-0.0290165842,
-0.0356954969,
-0.0198011566,
0.0563122034,
-0.0743027478,
-0.0242017824,
-0.0024416693,
-0.0217506159,
0.0263763703,
0.0399914384,
-0.0190722812,
-0.0420080908,
0.0056720166,
0.0061886013,
0.0119400173,
-0.0151952002,
-0.0554450452,
0.0024044069,
0.0276682973,
-0.0076977951,
-0.0257254634,
-0.0020210082,
0.0053494116,
0.0445781834,
-0.0257185642,
0.0340206772,
2.21313903e-34,
0.0595279038,
0.0058335494,
-0.0102797598,
0.0044939434,
0.0343746729,
-0.0355756506,
-0.0284599774,
-0.0216472298,
0.0279868916,
-0.0630526766,
-0.0101909572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03099v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03099v2 | LARCH: Large Language Model-based Automatic Readme Creation with Heuristics | 2023-08-06T12:28:24 | 2023-08-22T09:48:20 | Yuta Koreeda, Terufumi Morishita, Osamu Imaichi, Yasuhiro Sogawa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | Writing a readme is a crucial aspect of software development as it plays a
vital role in managing and reusing program code. Though it is a pain point for
many developers, automatically creating one remains a challenge even with the
recent advancements in large language models (LLMs), because it requires
generating an abstract description from thousands of lines of code. In this
demo paper, we show that LLMs are capable of generating a coherent and
factually correct readmes if we can identify a code fragment that is
representative of the repository. Building upon this finding, we developed
LARCH (LLM-based Automatic Readme Creation with Heuristics) which leverages
representative code identification with heuristics and weak supervision.
Through human and automated evaluations, we illustrate that LARCH can generate
coherent and factually correct readmes in the majority of cases, outperforming
a baseline that does not rely on representative code identification. We have
made LARCH open-source and provided a cross-platform Visual Studio Code
interface and command-line interface, accessible at
https://github.com/hitachi-nlp/larch. A demo video showcasing LARCH's
capabilities is available at https://youtu.be/ZUKkh5ED-O4. | [
0.0053540049,
0.0541281998,
-0.045918908,
0.0368389934,
-0.0118348226,
-0.0311957113,
-0.0227830354,
0.0079184501,
0.0283143707,
-0.0363733657,
-0.0212130602,
0.0252845492,
0.0068502226,
0.0266802087,
0.0322661251,
-0.0179586876,
0.014340939,
-0.0253315773,
-0.0100453077,
0.0216479544,
-0.0050525023,
0.0329522155,
0.0394470766,
0.0210324787,
0.031359151,
-0.0286495816,
0.0078936359,
0.0398643427,
0.0006174808,
0.0030725065,
0.0059648613,
0.0110653788,
-0.022828836,
0.0571574196,
0.0000022031,
-0.0347297192,
-0.0600628071,
-0.0111062648,
0.0091956565,
0.0232459251,
0.0066504679,
-0.0225883462,
-0.0083136829,
-0.0017806273,
0.0155700091,
-0.0041879811,
0.0189500023,
-0.0120020602,
0.0651581734,
0.0509681553,
0.0054822941,
-0.0002096843,
-0.0156871732,
0.0162251126,
0.0599434525,
0.0108720157,
-0.0410817601,
0.0549129881,
0.0263090022,
0.0656105801,
0.0392810889,
0.0372517332,
0.0044948473,
0.0080687311,
0.0326665193,
0.0387067571,
-0.0100620454,
0.0041353991,
0.0131346919,
0.0481654331,
-0.0325364806,
-0.0395176411,
0.0791269913,
-0.0421681255,
-0.0413125642,
-0.0030626077,
-0.0272539891,
0.0680541396,
0.0020875616,
0.0164322816,
0.0072208294,
-0.0207180493,
0.0352849886,
-0.017575996,
-0.0222826283,
0.017456023,
0.0048962436,
0.0169204194,
-0.0152135147,
-0.0474326313,
-0.0103927758,
-0.0623561963,
-0.0111144949,
0.0429683104,
0.0261160005,
0.0091483351,
-0.026001038,
-0.0324562006,
0.0555320233,
-0.0278434996,
-0.0031250634,
0.0199533813,
-0.0464032441,
-0.0035479756,
-0.0535862558,
0.0798106194,
0.0063728578,
-0.0496309288,
-0.0305631589,
-0.0019175109,
-0.0482479297,
-0.0326526128,
-0.0395680889,
0.036365103,
0.0059543108,
0.0019227429,
0.0064747878,
0.063024573,
0.0202558041,
0.0807885602,
-0.0270541571,
-0.0586589538,
-0.0296665356,
0.0083327042,
0.0554447472,
-0.0399026088,
-0.0006621453,
-0.0383237936,
-0.0515445955,
0.0000819727,
0.0012866076,
0.0636155382,
-0.0538309254,
0.0040085916,
0.0025174452,
0.0584056936,
0.0449024066,
0.0254197307,
-0.0554373972,
-0.0694493502,
0.0057874289,
0.014250177,
-0.0208563469,
-0.1009670272,
-0.0373013318,
0.0173263047,
0.0029709467,
-0.0786748305,
-0.0176504385,
-0.0205808897,
0.006564307,
0.0080286823,
-0.0769759193,
0.0364243127,
0.0528973006,
0.0293792561,
-0.0190307889,
0.0204188414,
0.0313267745,
0.0594526306,
0.0548687689,
-0.0360249765,
0.0473697856,
0.0434819236,
-0.0223574247,
0.0072639561,
0.0256722718,
0.0083953002,
0.0285779554,
-0.0292023383,
0.0157983359,
0.0295730047,
-0.0051900283,
0.0101001235,
0.033339411,
0.0720846429,
0.0336253196,
-0.0027371128,
0.0375377722,
0.0817032158,
-0.0034158828,
-0.0439686812,
0.0024331424,
0.0176939089,
-0.001847839,
0.0174760949,
-0.0489596911,
-0.0061576744,
0.0017248121,
-0.0130475564,
-0.0325277857,
-0.0281204116,
-0.0739347711,
-0.0180717781,
0.0081582451,
0.0008891223,
0.0123064844,
0.074333176,
0.0249225348,
-0.0287654679,
-0.0202164706,
-0.0089634433,
0.0716571584,
0.0535560027,
0.0781331584,
-0.0560057275,
-0.0280163176,
0.004494471,
-0.0111556416,
0.0255434625,
0.0310171954,
-0.0297960322,
-0.0287667997,
-0.0464968905,
-0.0051051588,
-0.068885453,
-0.0162606761,
0.0351268351,
0.0121965492,
-0.0424928144,
0.0373963192,
-0.0296351165,
-0.0603598282,
0.0250744391,
-0.0419952571,
-0.0303854737,
0.0226119142,
-0.0286552757,
0.0104537411,
0.0004863666,
-0.0393226594,
0.0109146554,
0.0580734089,
0.0046785958,
-0.0261517465,
-0.022345189,
0.0126408758,
0.0172009468,
0.0328304656,
-0.0136986561,
-0.025451038,
-0.0018293933,
-0.0108130965,
-0.0209029987,
0.0265395213,
-0.0292423498,
0.0370418131,
0.0124384593,
0.0300297923,
-0.0260484256,
-0.0404353999,
-0.0278810207,
0.0338731147,
0.0266946424,
0.0043040942,
0.014858447,
0.0538739748,
0.0193474237,
0.0229348559,
-0.0588480681,
0.0232248586,
-0.0228466541,
-0.0002556909,
-0.0185219161,
0.0565251969,
-0.0020515218,
-0.0351709463,
-0.0627016202,
0.0275706053,
0.0037351926,
0.0402865037,
0.0263132043,
0.0065054921,
-0.0140069816,
-0.009097416,
-0.0171194877,
-0.0138609922,
-0.0296811815,
-0.0304028615,
0.0546325445,
-0.0304165725,
-0.03499211,
-0.0267289337,
0.0141870752,
-0.0271316487,
0.0312298089,
0.0030467315,
-0.0037381861,
-0.1250887513,
0.0847151801,
0.0032633545,
0.0075006173,
-0.0269516502,
-0.0154515924,
-0.003677557,
-0.0410369709,
0.068973951,
0.0123287309,
-0.0254634023,
-0.0099792015,
0.0714392141,
0.0190082844,
-0.0730331466,
-0.0225162134,
0.0384197235,
-0.0023108996,
0.0262684543,
-0.0727617219,
0.0541549623,
0.0245990157,
-0.0082818372,
0.0065648882,
0.0320021361,
-0.0319132619,
-0.0250121597,
0.0331321508,
0.0101473751,
-0.0546397269,
0.0090068625,
0.016637573,
-0.0051183808,
-0.099016957,
0.0373761319,
-0.1036284342,
-0.0080198152,
-0.047466211,
-0.03577061,
-0.057972949,
0.1060625315,
-0.0089701163,
0.0190206729,
0.0169588905,
-0.0201089736,
0.0018997727,
-0.0067827869,
-0.0079824682,
0.0168457571,
0.0632433295,
-0.0655755326,
0.0271479618,
-0.0102497991,
0.0217322558,
-0.0078437263,
-0.0196528658,
-0.0093335509,
-0.0188612062,
0.0415696837,
-0.0258771628,
0.0210892018,
0.059533976,
0.0390507728,
0.0559062473,
0.0838742331,
-0.0289126243,
-0.0214525443,
-0.0107860109,
-0.0181254577,
-0.0618595853,
-0.0005920911,
-0.0303967446,
0.0047792117,
0.0465800986,
0.0401539989,
0.0262214597,
-0.0801691487,
-0.0478198454,
0.0266044587,
-0.0362117402,
-0.0419611074,
0.0205629114,
0.0403570868,
-0.0076276665,
-0.0045780977,
0.0977749527,
0.0309272707,
-0.085200578,
0.0114760408,
0.0160443187,
0.0514835864,
0.0396592245,
0.021660408,
-0.0725004971,
-0.029576309,
0.0042132824,
0.0332715325,
0.0144638671,
0.019421,
0.0004865411,
-0.0248759482,
-0.0086133415,
0.0257742163,
-0.0321713425,
0.0041311458,
0.0064057517,
-0.0226943288,
0.0177167039,
-0.0757998824,
0.0144825876,
-0.0032771321,
0.0179063529,
-0.0418282971,
-0.064971514,
0.0180043895,
0.000475559,
-0.0450588763,
0.0384286717,
0.0954347923,
0.0016762583,
0.034259513,
0.0350931734,
0.0479138941,
-0.036825534,
-0.0100449836,
-0.0397669487,
0.0456877202,
-0.0007225119,
-0.0026158593,
0.0273448136,
0.0299768317,
-0.0587828644,
-0.0383024849,
0.0421003401,
0.0383990593,
-0.0454041101,
-0.024848599,
-0.0147899054,
-0.0151161794,
0.0081894575,
0.0546726063,
0.0593420826,
0.0112508424,
0.0095214983,
-0.040819753,
0.0121474303,
-0.0126102082,
-0.0260392204,
-0.0454484671,
-0.0467031673,
0.0086353244,
-0.0771672502,
0.0027997659,
-0.005720214,
0.0190821923,
0.0656565651,
-0.0284584425,
0.0083926665,
-0.037346486,
-0.0450469218,
0.0191790834,
-0.0322252251,
0.0009482533,
-0.0458506979,
-0.0625799522,
0.0494495742,
-0.014694469,
-0.0071156146,
0.0174057167,
-0.0594705604,
-0.0204357766,
-0.0526309125,
0.0413350128,
0.0251427982,
0.0105803404,
-0.0287432317,
-0.0366802067,
0.0099794772,
-0.0157913901,
-0.0243439656,
0.0260124523,
-0.0144759286,
0.0113492217,
-0.008497918,
-0.0123375962,
-0.0840100721,
0.0170458239,
0.0111059034,
-0.0366689526,
-0.0103804078,
-0.0188588016,
0.0307801962,
0.0392364487,
-0.0248598251,
0.0257630162,
0.0495183393,
-0.0095268656,
-0.0047585322,
-0.0010799693,
-0.0437293388,
-0.0186054558,
0.0785565674,
0.0041203084,
-0.0486199632,
0.0176452864,
0.0337351784,
-0.0606205836,
0.064810805,
-0.0362789407,
0.0427749753,
-0.0241971444,
0.0288641602,
0.0281332154,
-0.0160167646,
-0.0086783282,
0.0175703391,
-0.0504548512,
0.01952805,
-0.0091205155,
0.0201361608,
0.0257730223,
-0.0033257282,
-0.0048273713,
0.0070128567,
-0.0115320273,
-0.0593662076,
0.0061856816,
-0.0139364256,
0.036798425,
0.0288325548,
0.0836657062,
-0.017340973,
0.0064404551,
-0.0303626228,
0.055060491,
0.0021001869,
-0.0278085936,
-0.0309027582,
0.0145649929,
-0.0417833813,
-0.0673365295,
0.0913472995,
-0.0357851088,
0.0031261013,
-0.0228399392,
-0.0244227834,
-0.0404835828,
0.0021541098,
0.0578331649,
-0.0494915992,
-0.0610461868,
-0.0582169853,
-0.050229311,
-0.0201110188,
0.0341663472,
0.0308124647,
0.0114884647,
0.0324500613,
-0.0003962484,
0.0872448906,
0.0309207588,
-0.0416195653,
-0.0131527008,
0.0229231045,
-0.0368182883,
-0.0321877748,
-0.037428394,
-5.255626426e-33,
-0.0034804924,
-0.0402396917,
-0.0254808292,
0.0318778753,
0.0240083933,
0.026523022,
-0.0584383346,
-0.0301700346,
0.0541929714,
-0.0601277314,
0.0602254272,
0.0031906879,
-0.016042579,
-0.051104337,
0.0536258481,
0.0635378659,
0.0424252115,
0.0711998791,
-0.0606337078,
0.0405196697,
-0.0079579428,
0.0099696489,
-0.0187499579,
-0.0310484953,
-0.0051688161,
-0.029604923,
0.059491016,
-0.0034188123,
0.0275252759,
0.0500050597,
-0.0020064863,
-0.020821996,
-0.0043621408,
0.0272838101,
-0.0378447287,
-0.0267612189,
-0.0034628289,
-0.0269044787,
0.0016128555,
-0.0221083891,
0.0441299267,
-0.0850251988,
0.0568452179,
-0.0310870726,
-0.0132053737,
0.035898868,
0.0457890369,
0.026054576,
0.0158234611,
-0.0399051644,
-0.0315388963,
0.0626181215,
-0.0201176442,
0.0348092914,
0.0148370881,
0.0276878979,
0.0447250903,
0.0672399402,
-0.0165411811,
-0.0124438908,
0.0071028369,
0.0429606251,
0.0756414458,
-0.0234457757,
-0.0010160069,
0.0209008437,
0.0055329921,
0.0303634945,
0.0007266275,
0.0240871124,
0.0072955801,
0.0067237271,
0.0162866637,
-0.0016238623,
-0.0059184986,
0.0126463221,
0.0132841766,
0.0428639352,
-0.0431106426,
0.0289074536,
0.0185701046,
0.0463703014,
-0.0374679938,
0.0137075046,
-0.0087389369,
0.0046654651,
-0.0223712698,
-0.0493229404,
0.0333182998,
-0.0150571642,
-0.0430074334,
0.0037978557,
-0.0061339941,
-0.024688635,
0.0104033388,
0.004201476,
-0.0695782155,
0.0191922691,
-0.0246781521,
0.0041229022,
-0.0009154796,
-0.0419710577,
0.0230179001,
-0.0243722107,
0.0748582557,
0.0379750915,
0.0125968484,
0.0225729141,
-0.035666056,
0.0145549718,
-0.0342942961,
-0.0380790494,
-0.0617628694,
0.0087419888,
-0.014162316,
-0.0150268916,
0.0166393928,
-0.0010644564,
0.0173637848,
-0.0273255054,
-0.0466621704,
0.0027909994,
-0.0226517841,
0.0187552255,
-0.0292130746,
0.0030797382,
-0.019039588,
0.0655528754,
0.0494803302,
-0.0133252107,
-0.0384301059,
0.0018573806,
2.866e-7,
0.0019186658,
0.0461929627,
0.0120776175,
0.0162025895,
-0.0011986939,
0.0240078215,
-0.0680091903,
0.0075242184,
-0.0373501331,
-0.0083843209,
-0.0339805037,
0.0186986923,
0.0526410416,
0.0480759256,
-0.0680600256,
0.003854997,
-0.0041273828,
0.0018872145,
-0.0849210471,
0.0180485044,
0.0612700358,
0.0370038077,
0.0023978772,
0.0145360595,
0.0086140269,
-0.0376379862,
-0.0136829698,
-0.0316943936,
0.0241894443,
0.0768476948,
0.0139608942,
-0.0220995359,
-0.0382535867,
-0.0415789932,
-0.0154688414,
-0.0478672609,
-0.0194998048,
0.0451049954,
0.0219224915,
0.0254437793,
0.0150133809,
-0.0466779023,
0.0051903767,
-0.0449223258,
0.0114054596,
0.0219733957,
0.0046867258,
-0.015876621,
-0.0474423096,
-0.0164445378,
-0.0439881012,
-0.0023451147,
0.0344208367,
0.0255021434,
-0.0377910882,
-0.0595541373,
-0.0256387386,
-0.0585329607,
-0.0421346612,
0.0242438186,
-0.0358259417,
-0.0184035022,
-0.0478655025,
0.0008658934,
0.0179140493,
-0.0429304577,
0.0564640798,
2.763659539e-34,
0.0132498359,
-0.0465334654,
-0.0392198749,
0.053165473,
0.033039704,
-0.004025084,
-0.0116281724,
0.031453874,
-0.0371853709,
0.016517166,
-0.0242996234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03098v1 | System-Initiated Transitions from Chit-Chat to Task-Oriented Dialogues with Transition Info Extractor and Transition Sentence Generator | 2023-08-06T12:25:22 | 2023-08-06T12:25:22 | Ye Liu, Stefan Ultes, Wolfgang Minker, Wolfgang Maier | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we study dialogue scenarios that start from chit-chat but
eventually switch to task-related services, and investigate how a unified
dialogue model, which can engage in both chit-chat and task-oriented dialogues,
takes the initiative during the dialogue mode transition from chit-chat to
task-oriented in a coherent and cooperative manner. We firstly build a
{transition info extractor} (TIE) that keeps track of the preceding chit-chat
interaction and detects the potential user intention to switch to a
task-oriented service. Meanwhile, in the unified model, a {transition sentence
generator} (TSG) is extended through efficient Adapter tuning and transition
prompt learning. When the TIE successfully finds task-related information from
the preceding chit-chat, such as a transition domain, then the TSG is activated
automatically in the unified model to initiate this transition by generating a
transition sentence under the guidance of transition information extracted by
TIE. The experimental results show promising performance regarding the
proactive transitions. We achieve an additional large improvement on TIE model
by utilizing Conditional Random Fields (CRF). The TSG can flexibly generate
transition sentences while maintaining the unified capabilities of normal
chit-chat and task-oriented response generation. | [
0.0691131726,
-0.0073029674,
-0.0084974058,
-0.0058249529,
-0.0444643982,
-0.0026844791,
0.0157713238,
-0.0202139337,
0.0266701635,
-0.0391262695,
-0.0041871523,
-0.0318965092,
-0.0183142405,
0.057548251,
-0.0309832953,
-0.0578186698,
0.0438541882,
-0.0200301707,
0.0200030152,
0.0347572751,
0.017027026,
-0.0137658343,
-0.0072139958,
0.0522425026,
-0.015111099,
-0.0122530386,
-0.0564673468,
0.0167457964,
-0.0018173255,
-0.0259339027,
0.0251951795,
0.0406364724,
-0.0120184263,
-0.0088919969,
0.0000020142,
-0.0603131652,
-0.0291712303,
-0.0155924736,
-0.0254681204,
-0.0604710318,
0.0274344757,
0.0462734997,
-0.0194928925,
0.0361384526,
-0.0468773283,
0.0445657074,
0.0557874665,
0.0882121548,
0.0576751083,
0.0562122837,
-0.0302079823,
-0.004059819,
-0.0097128581,
-0.0132592041,
-0.0155312605,
-0.0763025284,
-0.010018656,
-0.0063130823,
0.0268780608,
-0.008009648,
-0.0073950901,
0.0138544608,
0.0232499,
-0.029819604,
0.0061255381,
0.0289143175,
-0.0294065718,
-0.0338659734,
-0.0718702599,
0.0724124387,
-0.0223603509,
0.0151210222,
0.0472987816,
0.0024466822,
0.0315586254,
0.0019606119,
-0.0486910827,
-0.0306540802,
-0.0418268591,
-0.0099994997,
0.0175133925,
0.0331577137,
-0.0257371217,
-0.0172636937,
-0.0441563092,
0.0227829944,
0.02265778,
-0.0340493694,
-0.0081454692,
-0.0231369548,
0.0372145474,
-0.0377551988,
0.0382369049,
0.0341919027,
-0.0913536027,
0.0247857105,
-0.0404242016,
-0.0103776883,
-0.0131475516,
-0.0123549392,
0.0047563463,
0.035308551,
-0.0191005096,
0.0106517896,
0.0144390408,
0.0033598889,
0.0080450978,
-0.0378487296,
-0.0529530235,
0.0080025978,
-0.0562548526,
-0.0209330283,
-0.0796078965,
0.0368688405,
-0.0730344132,
-0.0577325411,
-0.0110267205,
0.0824186504,
0.0310343821,
-0.0141824139,
0.0345866419,
0.019876305,
-0.0526282825,
0.005644768,
-0.0224401895,
0.0242118724,
-0.0167240277,
-0.0077845776,
0.0578883216,
-0.0507186577,
0.0035788298,
0.0056092902,
0.0351522267,
-0.0104336599,
-0.0563032031,
0.0773763731,
-0.0405305885,
-0.0151696028,
0.013848423,
-0.0367180742,
-0.0300272685,
-0.0557693951,
0.0275264718,
-0.0083216261,
0.015481255,
0.0285905153,
-0.0019318096,
0.0455294102,
0.0212402977,
0.012133033,
-0.0192952063,
0.0445934497,
-0.0291209854,
0.0158474073,
0.0209800508,
0.0089525515,
-0.0048484984,
0.0757854432,
0.0184272397,
0.0241326746,
0.0442567021,
-0.0022582735,
0.0221489184,
0.0471250005,
-0.0275319126,
-0.0397179946,
0.0600946993,
0.023291558,
0.0356382728,
-0.019610526,
-0.0095840339,
0.0352497883,
-0.0217145439,
0.0160991624,
0.0527309887,
0.0522880554,
0.0144944517,
0.0215131436,
0.0321231782,
0.0612375624,
-0.0328406692,
0.0458277427,
-0.005631302,
0.0211235899,
-0.0397036709,
0.008208354,
0.0327952206,
0.0501548015,
-0.0354459472,
-0.02917137,
0.0309895612,
-0.0271187164,
0.0040773349,
-0.0266930368,
0.0281667393,
0.0416477099,
-0.0522369742,
0.0318827555,
0.0264423341,
-0.039425984,
-0.0375459455,
-0.0668792203,
-0.0022044869,
0.0947638378,
0.0316157006,
-0.0257511027,
-0.0390494913,
0.003754887,
0.0075339763,
0.0532031655,
0.0474481173,
-0.0156915244,
0.0140642328,
-0.0231579859,
-0.0162120443,
0.0426789299,
-0.0049425131,
0.0085643064,
-0.0271219444,
0.0077620228,
0.0041203937,
0.0178771466,
0.0090680942,
-0.0023158218,
0.0111421552,
0.0249543786,
0.0322084613,
0.0136626875,
0.0253018755,
0.0048770304,
0.0059190369,
-0.0030859143,
-0.0056200484,
0.0029699353,
-0.0217690039,
0.1085612252,
-0.0663973764,
-0.0573306046,
-0.0006561697,
0.0303770136,
-0.0097368453,
-0.0149906082,
-0.0065078223,
-0.0682475194,
0.0203021038,
-0.0063052629,
0.0391289145,
-0.0151529955,
0.0289158393,
0.0466489308,
0.0021769807,
-0.0055082147,
0.0320263095,
0.0187451746,
-0.0157290734,
0.0331296884,
-0.0103045795,
0.0098661166,
-0.0383479632,
0.0310269911,
0.0260179099,
-0.0622947738,
-0.0157084521,
0.0191567801,
0.0102164168,
-0.0515656434,
-0.047661975,
-0.1120242551,
-0.0040973634,
-0.0220740046,
-0.0015773968,
0.0210089665,
0.0642559081,
-0.0145594198,
-0.0049209339,
-0.0289811864,
0.0552118756,
0.0694609135,
0.0035299892,
0.0253527444,
0.0016830965,
-0.0342094414,
-0.054727219,
0.0422759429,
-0.0054601342,
0.0377060436,
0.0036656496,
-0.0436653718,
-0.0552812628,
0.003813009,
0.0382409543,
0.028648274,
-0.0288504045,
-0.022227833,
0.0488346405,
-0.0245661903,
0.06941659,
0.04085242,
0.053258393,
0.0428174511,
-0.0525495969,
-0.068853125,
-0.0461287685,
0.0452684499,
-0.0404839218,
0.0274441075,
-0.0410079025,
-0.010135158,
0.0718689561,
0.0656697825,
-0.0040973672,
0.0486298017,
-0.0463963896,
-0.0268825777,
0.0103765605,
-0.060101077,
0.0060211187,
0.0208450276,
-0.0617536604,
0.0137760015,
-0.0151451388,
-0.0335567072,
0.0390283354,
0.0001294215,
-0.0162883643,
-0.0767838582,
-0.002824038,
0.0143262353,
0.0519625917,
-0.0300268326,
0.0083437897,
0.084306486,
-0.0526637658,
-0.0160805844,
-0.0166544821,
-0.0092130657,
-0.0321542956,
-0.0235886797,
-0.0609052777,
0.010933823,
0.0014637951,
-0.0386148095,
-0.0485376231,
-0.0538995825,
-0.0121915424,
0.0217772201,
0.0043851743,
-0.0386091135,
-0.0049143331,
0.0420308858,
-0.0375139602,
0.0365117863,
-0.0446668714,
-0.0081941877,
-0.0210998245,
0.0577140898,
0.0690824538,
0.0159739051,
-0.0566363186,
-0.0202446096,
0.068702884,
0.0268847495,
0.0485732555,
-0.0227450095,
0.0023618257,
-0.05087322,
0.0005940375,
-0.0469018444,
-0.0293296445,
0.0346054882,
0.0592943504,
-0.0123942774,
-0.029616842,
0.1225115731,
0.0176167879,
-0.0102458438,
-0.002977107,
-0.0183977205,
-0.0112651717,
-0.0077058217,
0.0128003014,
-0.069441475,
-0.0289690252,
-0.0000797419,
0.0191545058,
0.0096670296,
-0.0160348229,
0.0017742694,
-0.0806455761,
0.0323160775,
-0.0117833363,
-0.0363945365,
-0.0046009244,
0.0098893642,
0.0129354689,
0.0430283546,
0.0095724044,
-0.0201271996,
-0.0116649373,
0.0071557811,
0.0065026493,
-0.0228112172,
-0.004570384,
-0.0191190783,
-0.0062190248,
0.0995348617,
0.0778950974,
0.028444102,
0.0308666546,
0.0482136793,
0.0210275222,
0.0312949382,
0.0198638514,
-0.0197215267,
0.0263713747,
0.0052331625,
0.0136607531,
-0.025841238,
-0.0006789634,
-0.0000042007,
-0.0189382099,
0.0305846781,
0.0241405349,
-0.0522601604,
-0.025142448,
-0.0050791199,
0.0231526718,
0.0822618678,
0.0376247279,
0.0034723305,
-0.0642236695,
-0.047082454,
0.0067155254,
-0.0010077074,
-0.0590094626,
0.0097853551,
-0.0423473604,
0.0047951299,
-0.0402820855,
-0.0789445564,
-0.0530058257,
0.0038460963,
0.0383809395,
-0.0018981646,
0.0292794053,
0.0086497404,
0.0470603332,
0.0058173132,
-0.0423035473,
-0.0340766646,
0.005620454,
-0.0431479886,
-0.0188780539,
0.0148083391,
-0.0682073757,
0.0035917903,
0.0060869139,
-0.0197924934,
-0.054633081,
-0.0244688317,
0.0552704744,
0.0250187404,
0.021770753,
-0.0331086107,
0.0078147864,
-0.0320275873,
0.0492768288,
-0.0329577141,
-0.0051627918,
0.0442277156,
0.0461194739,
-0.0197143629,
0.007412368,
-0.0346694961,
-0.0054393755,
-0.0358812138,
0.0548632778,
-0.0373960026,
-0.1008016542,
-0.0042720498,
0.0062224171,
0.0363010094,
0.0034842205,
-0.0022074641,
-0.0095596155,
0.0261423718,
-0.0171809401,
-0.0054586339,
-0.0456170104,
0.0060230778,
-0.0342242941,
0.018375637,
0.04554566,
-0.0031546706,
-0.0489064567,
0.0421127006,
-0.0343341418,
-0.0125951041,
0.0151508506,
0.0333632827,
-0.0044760099,
-0.0192895718,
0.0005957366,
-0.0084198266,
0.0700567365,
0.0358138271,
-0.011143622,
0.1030073315,
-0.000823991,
-0.0410667248,
0.0165529605,
0.062785767,
-0.0579640493,
0.0019986341,
-0.0228359587,
0.0542051271,
0.0143972253,
0.0242189262,
0.0541945472,
-0.0149516612,
0.0332751684,
-0.0242677741,
0.0565098338,
0.0378022119,
-0.0468912944,
0.0197055284,
-0.0015834073,
-0.0250514783,
-0.0155194346,
0.045630753,
-0.0381318294,
0.0210097283,
0.005790825,
-0.0367867872,
-0.0652620718,
-0.0224219821,
-0.0110317646,
0.0035359135,
-0.0069143698,
0.0086409235,
-0.0448328927,
0.0041098087,
0.0155943213,
0.0055130678,
0.0112556675,
-0.0209354777,
0.048475638,
0.056959074,
-0.0064864806,
-0.0240520891,
-0.0411852747,
-0.0041891532,
0.0105391406,
0.0022634263,
-0.0679111034,
-6.076101647e-33,
-0.0304386914,
-0.0056489636,
0.026260253,
0.0277222171,
-0.055128362,
-0.0359741151,
-0.0545219928,
0.006030886,
0.014895048,
-0.0149164712,
-0.0429467708,
0.0056183706,
0.0333950929,
0.0112335896,
-0.0283494536,
-0.0124728885,
0.0681873709,
-0.0167782996,
-0.0207511745,
0.0498113222,
0.0282344036,
0.0331077315,
0.0050138542,
-0.0927919,
0.0025258216,
-0.0134892343,
-0.0009168364,
-0.0019069163,
0.0414811559,
0.0031273284,
-0.0160956718,
0.016130317,
0.020367682,
-0.013886461,
-0.0185975563,
0.0739518404,
-0.0717844442,
-0.0002588984,
0.0251600202,
0.0024836748,
-0.021078445,
-0.0080961995,
-0.0203292742,
-0.01352017,
0.009858246,
0.0293279737,
0.02491243,
-0.0016057077,
0.0191880241,
-0.0207625479,
-0.1093941927,
0.002595956,
0.0062891538,
-0.0619926415,
-0.0262385178,
0.070058614,
-0.0018906074,
-0.0992836282,
0.0364002958,
0.0360242948,
-0.0061405487,
0.0042073922,
0.0151625955,
0.061898049,
0.0095359283,
0.025845509,
0.0093516009,
0.0422685929,
0.0179030634,
-0.0133289099,
-0.026654819,
0.0517848991,
-0.0228554457,
0.0097786346,
-0.0290379226,
-0.0346936025,
-0.0248709526,
0.025241496,
0.1241639778,
-0.0040189722,
0.0146300485,
0.0239556897,
-0.0264225174,
0.000339755,
0.002241635,
0.0248088874,
0.0083097536,
-0.0520221628,
0.0524676591,
0.0338040181,
-0.0100766877,
-0.0318898447,
0.0481105186,
-0.0176327769,
0.0306060519,
-0.0029817966,
-0.0081443302,
0.0199143551,
-0.0258780774,
-0.021142358,
-0.0514676906,
-0.0517876223,
0.0540925004,
0.0199851599,
-0.0008944282,
0.0319973528,
-0.0375383124,
0.0321360789,
-0.0424338058,
-0.0070508104,
-0.0131344227,
0.0443318076,
-0.0193207804,
0.0452282615,
0.0213383064,
-0.0160916634,
-0.0616813973,
0.0340657644,
-0.0279821604,
-0.0141608762,
-0.0798331872,
-0.0202974007,
0.0054997765,
-0.0009639924,
-0.0245599542,
0.0140134348,
-0.0531146638,
0.0164057966,
-0.0189450122,
-0.0119586503,
-0.0052893884,
0.0322129428,
2.884e-7,
-0.0228833798,
-0.0027709864,
0.0197480526,
0.0198662691,
-0.0016371352,
0.0231560618,
0.0309996177,
0.032410264,
0.0634892285,
-0.001545108,
0.0206222329,
0.0016788405,
0.0326014422,
-0.0006685443,
-0.1273336112,
-0.0839388594,
-0.033081606,
-0.0193132255,
-0.002927891,
-0.0013154475,
0.0686001405,
0.0263480339,
-0.0089669926,
0.0196081661,
0.0017549945,
-0.0123063913,
0.0119868824,
-0.0246718135,
-0.0027684059,
0.0094749685,
-0.0125556272,
-0.0234393701,
-0.0129463198,
0.0170084815,
0.0029757977,
0.0252843499,
-0.0028817246,
0.0350659974,
0.0025270344,
-0.0438669324,
-0.0031633354,
-0.0149637861,
0.0188525505,
-0.0005410478,
0.0684391931,
-0.0756585971,
0.0051056449,
-0.0198445749,
-0.0197620578,
0.008090266,
-0.0619536601,
-0.0132935969,
-0.0366920121,
0.0274179559,
-0.0011104557,
0.0378524102,
0.0256516822,
-0.0647672117,
0.0153649524,
-0.0161296073,
-0.0442096069,
-0.07448484,
-0.0683132336,
-0.0198848844,
-0.0193701703,
-0.029732462,
0.0102934809,
2.517039676e-34,
0.0337933116,
0.0042304574,
0.0192871038,
0.0577536598,
0.0211683363,
0.0174725614,
0.0202079955,
0.0309484862,
0.0734132826,
-0.0564263314,
-0.0312272534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03051v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03051v2 | TARJAMAT: Evaluation of Bard and ChatGPT on Machine Translation of Ten Arabic Varieties | 2023-08-06T08:29:16 | 2023-10-23T23:26:55 | Karima Kadaoui, Samar M. Magdy, Abdul Waheed, Md Tawkat Islam Khondaker, Ahmed Oumar El-Shangiti, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the purported multilingual proficiency of instruction-finetuned large
language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and Bard, the linguistic inclusivity of
these models remains insufficiently explored. Considering this constraint, we
present a thorough assessment of Bard and ChatGPT (encompassing both GPT-3.5
and GPT-4) regarding their machine translation proficiencies across ten
varieties of Arabic. Our evaluation covers diverse Arabic varieties such as
Classical Arabic (CA), Modern Standard Arabic (MSA), and several country-level
dialectal variants. Our analysis indicates that LLMs may encounter challenges
with dialects for which minimal public datasets exist, but on average are
better translators of dialects than existing commercial systems. On CA and MSA,
instruction-tuned LLMs, however, trail behind commercial systems such as Google
Translate. Finally, we undertake a human-centric study to scrutinize the
efficacy of the relatively recent model, Bard, in following human instructions
during translation tasks. Our analysis reveals a circumscribed capability of
Bard in aligning with human instructions in translation contexts. Collectively,
our findings underscore that prevailing LLMs remain far from inclusive, with
only limited ability to cater for the linguistic and cultural intricacies of
diverse communities. | [
0.0315694101,
0.0199066959,
-0.0228600297,
0.0120165218,
-0.0638018474,
0.0309147779,
0.0591951907,
-0.0178647321,
-0.0336997062,
-0.0322477408,
-0.0368333757,
-0.0839697793,
0.0650751293,
-0.011908236,
0.0620186962,
-0.0415789559,
0.010283934,
-0.0663989484,
-0.0173502695,
-0.015000823,
0.0323843732,
0.0328400806,
0.0035898231,
0.0474898592,
0.0010965763,
-0.0148867331,
-0.0193069987,
0.0482947193,
0.0330833159,
0.0236722138,
-0.010042293,
0.0683214888,
-0.0000769083,
0.0509753041,
0.0000022041,
-0.0555264689,
-0.0111397058,
-0.0069713057,
-0.0249985065,
0.0500377864,
0.0326202214,
-0.0419936366,
-0.0324314348,
0.020089766,
-0.0008411894,
0.0108719626,
0.0652757734,
-0.0024099504,
0.0382707901,
0.0316101871,
-0.0050604986,
-0.0424134806,
0.0074404739,
-0.0418610908,
-0.0061609671,
-0.0418635719,
-0.0232467074,
-0.0054481891,
-0.0069082575,
0.0286077838,
-0.0410093553,
0.0388165116,
-0.0021149372,
-0.010791556,
-0.0358154513,
-0.0134013584,
-0.0630065203,
-0.0574244596,
0.0221361835,
0.0468788631,
0.0055552018,
-0.0099749798,
-0.0297582187,
0.0347717218,
0.0009467859,
0.0056312522,
-0.0323437154,
0.0558426119,
-0.0264625084,
-0.0112740612,
0.0101388106,
0.0130779566,
-0.0071982425,
-0.0145435203,
-0.0494288281,
0.0073248302,
0.0406797044,
-0.0338821337,
0.0179173872,
0.0349833481,
-0.0278808046,
0.0024922704,
0.0325805508,
-0.0263173748,
-0.0267745275,
-0.0021657231,
-0.0081924023,
0.0091717299,
0.0363826714,
-0.024018066,
0.0497610532,
0.0979012027,
-0.037127059,
0.0361455642,
-0.0095511805,
0.0333784632,
0.0017492947,
0.0356527753,
-0.0700405836,
0.0013545487,
-0.0426164493,
0.0282303579,
-0.0384986848,
-0.0097317547,
-0.0781939626,
0.0200706478,
-0.0349208601,
0.0049575348,
-0.0077264509,
0.0117394365,
0.0118554262,
-0.047479704,
-0.0677443966,
-0.0530585684,
-0.0098583931,
0.0134682059,
-0.0044327527,
-0.0078884643,
-0.0424132794,
-0.1049814597,
-0.0001517895,
0.0133339921,
-0.0248619486,
-0.0070617548,
-0.0252755489,
0.0293735657,
-0.0220879298,
-0.0525269993,
-0.0389942937,
0.0265880767,
-0.0473940708,
-0.0475389771,
-0.0341894925,
-0.0466153137,
0.0782598555,
0.0196586736,
0.0001542005,
0.0093615195,
-0.021271931,
0.018892603,
0.0148518598,
0.04034549,
0.0759554729,
0.0466205366,
0.0782832652,
0.0041991058,
-0.0272455569,
0.0692655593,
0.0242626648,
-0.0031700551,
-0.008657001,
-0.0016656274,
-0.027761234,
0.061062526,
-0.0008601249,
0.0464961641,
-0.0331499428,
-0.0231682919,
0.0296194907,
0.0598309226,
0.0054181544,
0.0763427913,
-0.0255943108,
0.0015362217,
0.0894702598,
0.0255848058,
-0.0297339354,
0.049047552,
0.0415464379,
0.0623955391,
0.0343340151,
-0.007272501,
-0.0249368511,
-0.0069374321,
0.0083619151,
-0.0142694181,
0.0547192805,
0.1004144475,
-0.006917173,
-0.0152949169,
0.0036770012,
-0.0152928848,
0.0316801369,
-0.013785826,
0.0856901258,
-0.0502983928,
-0.0388292894,
0.0283353236,
0.0163766816,
-0.0037256137,
0.0034151229,
-0.0413319506,
-0.0453885421,
0.0496707745,
0.0090899784,
0.0293526221,
-0.0060770828,
-0.0090722963,
0.0368944257,
0.0380752906,
0.0769449919,
0.0194337163,
0.0107765505,
-0.0429259501,
-0.0218841787,
0.022722302,
0.0141956694,
0.027266657,
0.0140660945,
0.0580924489,
0.0054300963,
-0.0166085195,
-0.0300451498,
0.0195480455,
-0.0464740545,
0.0269275047,
-0.0146903265,
-0.0018642663,
-0.001841819,
0.0241462104,
-0.0212490782,
0.0065632574,
-0.0140470741,
-0.0431127399,
-0.021098908,
0.0342212655,
-0.04781444,
-0.0038176386,
0.029658597,
-0.0154158687,
0.0064886515,
-0.0082121184,
-0.0059885033,
-0.0592501424,
0.046029631,
-0.0355849639,
0.0391361974,
-0.014115029,
0.050578896,
-0.0020478393,
-0.0128897224,
-0.0431276672,
0.0197062753,
-0.0121249454,
-0.0414362215,
0.0036803801,
-0.0220441166,
0.03368783,
-0.0235908963,
-0.0072932411,
0.0312153529,
0.023136517,
0.0278805383,
0.0494899787,
0.0203548633,
-0.0152220009,
-0.0713042319,
-0.1003269255,
-0.0043885056,
-0.0145670678,
0.0410238728,
-0.0047733258,
0.033276815,
-0.0159683954,
0.0152183231,
-0.0211869888,
-0.0407521352,
-0.0030802207,
0.0328807123,
-0.0049900976,
-0.0239660237,
0.01330633,
-0.0223553088,
-0.0077610379,
0.0390772671,
0.0291828439,
0.033250846,
-0.0312819555,
0.0204500444,
-0.0289033502,
-0.0124282762,
-0.0047987089,
0.0029834225,
-0.042906601,
0.0253303517,
-0.0211109463,
0.0493592322,
0.023870863,
-0.007410768,
-0.0013822917,
-0.0091831721,
-0.0064974143,
-0.0626481771,
0.0100407256,
-0.004453029,
-0.0863706321,
-0.0496614762,
-0.0912614837,
-0.0406151824,
0.018197611,
0.0196901113,
-0.0010013561,
-0.0898836479,
-0.0036642533,
-0.0375764072,
0.0170497522,
-0.0004177549,
0.0429911874,
0.0188034382,
0.0734317154,
-0.0621273741,
-0.0654092506,
0.0174337775,
-0.030736478,
-0.0137496563,
0.0207326114,
0.0357416384,
-0.0545874834,
0.0170102976,
-0.0301383603,
0.0294244532,
-0.0602902137,
-0.0204609092,
-0.0389162078,
0.0272318441,
0.0357665345,
-0.0269646682,
0.0182780232,
-0.0982600078,
0.0054846136,
-0.0316373035,
-0.0083889756,
0.0171002876,
0.0101203425,
-0.0253301412,
-0.0086965086,
0.0970273837,
-0.0153935682,
-0.0279651042,
0.033429753,
0.0313171856,
0.0298260301,
-0.0270620398,
0.0072788587,
-0.0024241416,
-0.0589435734,
0.0030242261,
0.0258420743,
0.0177000817,
-0.0390086807,
0.0280539524,
0.0264272206,
-0.0628163368,
-0.0199940763,
-0.0367128588,
-0.0131748263,
0.040500626,
-0.0041914126,
-0.0694167539,
-0.035889674,
0.038127102,
-0.0225702841,
0.0321104936,
0.1051930189,
0.0113980947,
-0.0458637364,
-0.0033644394,
-0.0506187417,
0.0307736844,
-0.0108951852,
-0.0124894734,
-0.1029277369,
-0.0087664109,
0.0283010788,
0.0497317016,
0.0376794972,
0.0324096493,
0.0121272597,
-0.0998294204,
0.0077576851,
0.0259189103,
-0.0159255862,
-0.030531507,
0.0100319069,
-0.0214971993,
-0.0383559056,
0.0020183926,
-0.0351340659,
-0.0010964482,
0.0354530364,
0.055859033,
-0.0057808305,
-0.0665687174,
0.0343354344,
-0.0510287173,
0.0308117177,
0.0305367783,
0.0157793313,
-0.0194600094,
-0.0276710987,
0.0227733403,
-0.0112723159,
-0.0297594555,
0.0075732828,
0.0151041048,
0.004318973,
0.0026004084,
-0.012244273,
-0.01599494,
-0.0360437594,
0.0276162326,
0.0200127736,
0.0155595578,
-0.0248058401,
0.0274551027,
0.0175444912,
-0.0104672154,
-0.0324883275,
0.0605866201,
-0.0313987546,
-0.0548559129,
-0.0394890495,
-0.0084906574,
-0.027201442,
-0.059163101,
-0.0209860168,
0.0191710461,
-0.0038078777,
-0.0387797579,
-0.0611960776,
-0.0479002334,
0.0322663188,
0.0285702404,
0.0204020739,
0.0100530973,
0.0273959953,
0.0086391075,
0.0223949142,
0.0155084785,
-0.0246800594,
0.0215382352,
-0.0840792581,
-0.0466343127,
0.0198130552,
-0.07380189,
0.0307164583,
-0.0099680312,
-0.0546055809,
-0.0545680039,
0.0383284315,
0.0035832338,
0.0227337256,
0.0093845781,
-0.0072109117,
-0.0239179209,
0.020129133,
-0.0324505679,
0.0108156484,
0.0565133467,
0.0173658784,
0.0052904994,
-0.0330637395,
0.0520039722,
0.0183637906,
0.0151265254,
-0.0220481455,
0.0301567931,
0.0015687713,
-0.0781969205,
0.0274302121,
-0.0140254004,
-0.0179513991,
-0.063819997,
-0.0085689826,
-0.0272477288,
-0.0203875676,
0.0021371536,
0.029350901,
-0.061435096,
-0.0393574908,
0.0515684187,
0.0191559698,
0.0307617821,
-0.0282835159,
-0.0145982029,
-0.0372074023,
-0.0071897423,
-0.0037527704,
-0.0497109629,
0.0333815292,
0.0200319774,
0.0336032398,
0.0072182533,
-0.0086077536,
-0.0641759858,
0.0284819938,
-0.0261110254,
0.0583531782,
-0.0158497803,
0.0308222733,
0.0480248258,
0.0546138324,
0.0216196254,
-0.0316391364,
0.0044736294,
0.0530981645,
0.0667342469,
-0.0022945416,
0.0818358585,
0.0150156226,
-0.0015625788,
-0.0228387695,
0.0414521396,
0.0106078088,
-0.0098782191,
-0.0109586762,
-0.0180049427,
-0.0090525495,
0.0447613858,
0.0731441081,
0.0221248511,
0.0057165874,
-0.0122049144,
-0.0075951847,
0.0177528113,
-0.052628655,
0.0117273843,
-0.0331059806,
-0.0322085023,
0.0185323749,
-0.08629971,
-0.0476270914,
-0.0096977148,
0.0301296879,
0.0042085983,
-0.0250488594,
0.0110367229,
0.0895760134,
-0.0395555608,
-0.016160341,
-0.0717607066,
0.0094161602,
-0.0242365208,
-0.0060830805,
-0.0125505766,
-6.888450528e-33,
-0.0207125712,
0.0015295203,
0.0333952233,
-0.0400214978,
-0.0102317827,
-0.0258369204,
-0.0097448779,
0.0038030583,
0.002489239,
0.0201961547,
-0.0213417038,
-0.0057678926,
0.0147451079,
-0.0103095938,
0.0811384469,
-0.0123089971,
0.0307578333,
-0.0120386761,
-0.0175919142,
0.0566573888,
0.0078923553,
-0.0057932558,
0.0708715618,
-0.0398486592,
0.047521878,
-0.0471316166,
-0.0307320021,
0.0072605913,
-0.0372320525,
0.0518531203,
-0.0077973194,
0.0243371427,
0.0128824813,
-0.0162741859,
0.0068905861,
-0.0164555721,
-0.0306784306,
0.0372458287,
0.021607941,
0.0516308323,
0.0110590244,
-0.0278626867,
-0.0109371124,
-0.0144077623,
-0.0602981225,
0.0163247641,
-0.0143110771,
-0.0361063071,
-0.0097283954,
0.0015215395,
-0.0657369196,
0.041226957,
-0.0199758392,
-0.0256174989,
0.0006526692,
0.069713369,
-0.02102888,
0.0192471184,
-0.0255001411,
0.0185234435,
0.0186211187,
0.0098192673,
0.0785911381,
0.0006733137,
-0.0588482432,
-0.0058093821,
0.0216205921,
0.0086679831,
0.0626170114,
-0.0111649726,
0.0373799242,
-0.0364936218,
0.0084890258,
0.0603935122,
0.0094373738,
-0.0130762709,
-0.0272475984,
0.0354697853,
-0.0114503847,
0.031543307,
0.0211421512,
-0.0105894664,
-0.0517744012,
-0.0388611741,
-0.0109408591,
-0.0276046302,
0.0110245319,
0.005350424,
0.0211066511,
-0.0087234555,
-0.0080913194,
0.0293277185,
0.0665394366,
0.0155656664,
0.041744221,
-0.0267301146,
-0.0419040695,
-0.0094084889,
-0.0315143093,
0.0658183247,
-0.0598126389,
-0.0569047928,
0.0080367336,
0.050825946,
-0.0082846079,
-0.0026337965,
0.0135244951,
0.0368123837,
-0.0561975017,
0.0234142654,
-0.0400064029,
0.0164170396,
-0.0247698519,
0.0244463161,
0.0268136952,
-0.0216626842,
0.0057117771,
0.0443681516,
0.0350352079,
-0.0136492215,
-0.0404616296,
-0.0370856039,
-0.0263687689,
-0.0257588923,
-0.0054060142,
0.0593878776,
-0.0262630451,
-0.0466011539,
0.0312170815,
-0.0227381196,
-0.0265213847,
-0.0201000478,
3.106e-7,
0.041238334,
0.0637965128,
-0.0058238106,
-0.0054872516,
0.0241651461,
0.023318883,
-0.0031899214,
0.0227848534,
0.0384248383,
0.0486794114,
0.0257643312,
0.0520208478,
0.0813377351,
-0.0110292565,
-0.0481742024,
-0.0611230917,
-0.0345865041,
0.0633882508,
-0.0641106442,
0.0159526486,
0.0611018278,
0.0996523499,
-0.0580301248,
0.0108053507,
-0.0437734053,
-0.0445706323,
0.089505814,
-0.0339653976,
-0.0387887508,
0.0286321267,
0.0545602739,
-0.0213330053,
-0.0160462037,
0.0106239486,
-0.0076491907,
0.01085399,
0.0472510979,
0.1313598603,
0.0022008554,
0.0193506312,
0.0096226996,
-0.0211803634,
-0.0216600783,
-0.0413572527,
0.0510400757,
-0.0017184394,
-0.0147997076,
0.0087252622,
-0.0193718672,
0.0119565036,
0.034504734,
-0.0468883365,
0.0073903096,
0.0097867278,
0.0589696504,
-0.0334670097,
-0.0130410288,
-0.0135082295,
0.0045245956,
-0.0118238982,
-0.0183170009,
-0.0515674353,
0.0045768144,
0.0185745992,
-0.023266308,
0.0034876748,
-0.0054294528,
2.537676949e-34,
0.0597685203,
0.0004966229,
0.0373697728,
-0.0329303816,
0.0542062558,
0.0023449839,
-0.0255488753,
0.0223780889,
-0.0205708109,
-0.021544138,
-0.0242777523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03043v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03043v2 | 3D-EX : A Unified Dataset of Definitions and Dictionary Examples | 2023-08-06T07:59:12 | 2023-08-11T12:07:52 | Fatemah Almeman, Hadi Sheikhi, Luis Espinosa-Anke | cs.CL | cs.CL | Definitions are a fundamental building block in lexicography, linguistics and
computational semantics. In NLP, they have been used for retrofitting word
embeddings or augmenting contextual representations in language models.
However, lexical resources containing definitions exhibit a wide range of
properties, which has implications in the behaviour of models trained and
evaluated on them. In this paper, we introduce 3D- EX , a dataset that aims to
fill this gap by combining well-known English resources into one centralized
knowledge repository in the form of <term, definition, example> triples. 3D- EX
is a unified evaluation framework with carefully pre-computed
train/validation/test splits to prevent memorization. We report experimental
results that suggest that this dataset could be effectively leveraged in
downstream NLP tasks. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/F-Almeman/3D-EX . | [
0.0043311315,
0.0268748309,
0.0132733388,
0.0660247579,
-0.0238898695,
0.0011016413,
-0.0145312548,
0.0084576504,
-0.0680584013,
-0.0725885555,
-0.0199239794,
-0.0298602972,
-0.0113941813,
0.0504094474,
0.0420565978,
-0.0210604407,
0.0599794053,
0.0310158283,
-0.0349047892,
0.0152837802,
0.0275907461,
0.002546689,
0.0285631698,
0.0118484711,
-0.0604189374,
-0.0248383023,
0.0017618306,
-0.0155624989,
-0.011241843,
-0.0688246265,
0.0433616564,
0.0503816679,
0.0404164568,
0.013831907,
0.000001882,
-0.0541932583,
-0.0208655857,
-0.0139579112,
-0.0179375485,
-0.0202903915,
0.0405183509,
-0.019939471,
0.0453090556,
-0.0390620716,
-0.0716501176,
0.0021095742,
0.0438616835,
0.0332335532,
0.0660063773,
0.0489405319,
-0.0050164424,
-0.0672971308,
-0.0107328584,
-0.004370105,
0.0557296053,
-0.0030053749,
0.0120271156,
0.0422039814,
-0.0255649146,
0.0063560237,
-0.0321616307,
-0.0000824955,
0.0229209848,
0.0459391475,
0.0135964174,
0.0041397586,
-0.0606188476,
-0.0283964556,
-0.0271876827,
0.1074605882,
0.0667616874,
-0.007325314,
-0.0564016588,
-0.0035521765,
-0.0149427159,
0.0015444475,
-0.0093947174,
-0.0000417654,
-0.0099609932,
-0.013840653,
0.0136270262,
0.0165534876,
0.0332374461,
0.0276021212,
-0.0126894526,
0.0313689969,
0.0014912848,
-0.0391266085,
0.0224237237,
-0.0046618278,
-0.0349459164,
0.0052065891,
-0.0443883501,
-0.0206926838,
0.0247749854,
0.0420709364,
-0.0353534371,
-0.0285799839,
0.0405093357,
-0.0489451736,
0.0259918142,
-0.0006731539,
-0.0139834145,
0.0502786636,
-0.0067517837,
-0.004424212,
0.0219647624,
0.0463364162,
-0.0108697917,
0.0191935953,
-0.0539501011,
0.0256007276,
-0.0528473221,
0.0269420668,
0.0072352951,
-0.0202180315,
-0.0382574834,
0.0143901045,
-0.03706792,
0.0112910476,
0.0082311137,
0.0436685197,
-0.0292584151,
0.0438069999,
-0.0239476562,
-0.0361092463,
-0.0579251722,
-0.0064655202,
-0.0215229411,
-0.0565139167,
-0.0218185559,
-0.0259114765,
-0.0082510877,
-0.0361570157,
0.032010451,
0.0463518612,
0.0507847145,
-0.0887958333,
0.0234490465,
-0.0380621888,
-0.0296673961,
-0.0241545774,
-0.0212901793,
-0.0632487684,
0.0176508687,
-0.0091262618,
-0.0026729966,
-0.0755570605,
-0.0028325703,
0.0113101089,
0.0033223829,
0.12246795,
-0.0702630058,
-0.0466089249,
-0.0141455159,
0.0321461596,
0.0058220387,
0.0703847706,
0.0213550888,
-0.0183567703,
0.0839625522,
0.0111444527,
-0.0113444664,
0.0266838185,
0.033598803,
0.0264341943,
-0.0944283232,
0.0173293687,
0.0053432132,
0.0781573579,
-0.0223590136,
0.0058774333,
-0.0345503986,
-0.0351570547,
0.0121988384,
0.0493502244,
0.0133941406,
-0.0051215217,
0.0500888899,
-0.0254998095,
0.0203713402,
-0.015509394,
-0.0265361108,
-0.0508290306,
0.0188171156,
0.0236635357,
-0.004628669,
0.0151052112,
-0.010697294,
-0.0245097578,
-0.0422208905,
0.0000757695,
-0.003838894,
-0.0170995668,
0.0291305184,
0.0249394532,
-0.0053025801,
0.0897324309,
0.0386973582,
-0.0454522744,
-0.0062058531,
-0.0159481615,
0.0219862927,
0.0417979509,
0.074324362,
-0.041711513,
-0.049331367,
0.0111423414,
0.0156230237,
0.0171253067,
0.0589304194,
-0.039918039,
0.0239283685,
-0.0470200107,
-0.0170383155,
-0.0324494503,
0.020603979,
-0.0102731716,
0.0813633129,
0.006427424,
0.002705612,
-0.0503887683,
-0.0360720605,
0.0452393889,
-0.0119985025,
-0.0522488914,
-0.0097348625,
0.0056410469,
0.0278948434,
0.0335044079,
-0.0237023756,
-0.0157688819,
0.0487492383,
-0.020502938,
0.0332608148,
0.0116508193,
-0.0450393036,
-0.0362797193,
0.0461228229,
-0.0089830142,
-0.0062715053,
0.0489927419,
-0.0408558883,
-0.0190397277,
-0.028361043,
-0.0057982146,
0.0547237322,
-0.0472847633,
-0.0239723641,
0.0224247128,
0.0535240918,
-0.0133799035,
0.0799240768,
-0.0354092605,
0.0404126644,
-0.0390436091,
0.0362795629,
-0.0121304849,
0.0362846181,
-0.0402794592,
-0.0091130091,
-0.0011914667,
0.0354412496,
0.0169654973,
0.032376308,
-0.0696514621,
0.0363979787,
-0.0276808795,
0.0158793684,
-0.0222249329,
0.0299999248,
0.0220607053,
0.0130251162,
0.0045835548,
-0.0059472034,
-0.0120839467,
0.0294213668,
0.003498039,
0.0114023332,
0.0514360182,
0.0219308417,
-0.0302803144,
-0.0038517101,
-0.0284872763,
-0.0154486569,
0.0602717623,
-0.0250181947,
0.0060600885,
0.053102579,
0.0014720699,
-0.0426834337,
0.0418963283,
0.007011856,
-0.0048119775,
0.0184197519,
-0.0279739425,
-0.0071472158,
-0.0102126561,
-0.0061925296,
0.0438598134,
0.0180986114,
-0.0033736583,
-0.0337698795,
-0.0076755062,
-0.022627566,
-0.0069300807,
0.0006580348,
0.00310608,
-0.0091851167,
0.0334168039,
0.0066969255,
-0.0083381962,
-0.0084203798,
0.0444159545,
-0.0032545521,
-0.0373600572,
-0.0610078797,
0.0202093814,
-0.0670099929,
0.0360590443,
-0.0236554835,
-0.0287776925,
0.0631616265,
-0.0398970582,
0.0059271897,
-0.017649984,
0.008982975,
-0.0302410573,
0.0989662483,
-0.0376866981,
0.0107811736,
-0.0059882519,
0.0172359217,
-0.0010158212,
-0.0280435141,
0.0351626091,
-0.042868264,
0.0541703776,
-0.0391789302,
0.0174616296,
-0.0012658153,
0.0040238011,
-0.0243153851,
-0.0261380374,
-0.0171177126,
0.0220405515,
-0.0282357708,
-0.0016315028,
0.0103061153,
0.006505542,
-0.0034613346,
0.0407960936,
0.0093531115,
-0.02548288,
-0.0217454061,
0.0179291144,
0.0176985618,
0.0463691801,
-0.0063687633,
0.0034133443,
0.0245603807,
0.0295615923,
0.023300387,
0.0236949008,
-0.0460769683,
0.0428254902,
0.0236028042,
-0.0295829922,
0.0043275948,
-0.0025036121,
-0.0119990576,
-0.0572623461,
-0.0379728377,
0.0834525079,
0.0384007208,
-0.0704909116,
0.0127049917,
-0.0025254753,
0.0044652214,
0.0460330099,
-0.0407107845,
-0.1393755525,
-0.0591264293,
-0.0276283287,
0.0007388394,
0.0428724177,
-0.0177079421,
-0.0203889087,
-0.0831690282,
0.0107140988,
-0.0233988352,
-0.0213587414,
0.0005021313,
-0.0407574773,
0.0077090063,
-0.0443006977,
0.0071009952,
-0.0442419164,
-0.0221035834,
0.0010405544,
-0.0189360529,
0.0391673855,
-0.0809899345,
0.1017884985,
-0.0345428064,
-0.005577168,
0.0204181112,
0.024908267,
-0.0419077612,
-0.0551585332,
0.0209377687,
-0.0453663841,
-0.0418505669,
-0.0004323437,
0.0364535637,
-0.0511344299,
0.0054758922,
0.0308058634,
-0.0118703162,
-0.0489592925,
-0.033076074,
-0.0190322064,
0.0689675361,
-0.0224071685,
0.0218710098,
-0.0147631224,
0.0081593692,
0.0207456574,
0.0825599059,
0.0126206465,
0.0028157982,
0.0025074105,
0.0193529502,
0.0298474226,
-0.034352269,
-0.0558207221,
0.0239604954,
-0.0581816658,
-0.0039475486,
-0.0527047478,
-0.0594761185,
0.0380521677,
0.0593908355,
0.0334290564,
0.0245888326,
-0.0725363046,
0.0191100836,
-0.0878245533,
0.052490335,
0.0211153422,
-0.0085684778,
0.0017776213,
-0.0114255268,
0.0287456848,
0.0153059764,
-0.0334798098,
0.0675994679,
-0.0066754953,
-0.0090599461,
0.0341982059,
0.0362888873,
0.0133637106,
0.0411951505,
-0.0133701107,
0.005116005,
0.0498275347,
0.0239328537,
0.000543872,
-0.0169190429,
0.0341517404,
0.0028732538,
-0.0167003274,
0.0274539124,
-0.0319729112,
0.0275156423,
-0.0282703713,
0.0122636175,
-0.0232109819,
-0.0420670733,
0.0257932637,
-0.0092431149,
0.0505424626,
-0.043661464,
-0.0130485147,
-0.0093608862,
0.0068176785,
-0.0098100454,
-0.035503801,
-0.0363332927,
0.0065997299,
0.0046474999,
-0.0572199337,
-0.0201743394,
0.0389403887,
-0.0010837184,
0.0185674634,
-0.0273367334,
0.022074718,
0.0819639787,
-0.0179879274,
-0.0167447422,
0.0049494114,
-0.0176694039,
0.0044630873,
-0.0794070736,
-0.0038549025,
-0.0559101738,
0.0473817103,
0.0184848998,
0.0042271931,
-0.0062012747,
0.055982206,
-0.0256174151,
0.0039402526,
-0.0404923856,
-0.024749266,
0.0404801443,
-0.0175807774,
0.0356602371,
-0.0269030202,
-0.0146086868,
-0.0026682045,
0.0097565074,
-0.0379707627,
-0.0269606076,
0.0309097972,
0.0370484293,
-0.0042793937,
-0.0151483519,
0.0315013565,
-0.0095062433,
0.0720138922,
0.036187917,
0.0017711392,
-0.0299704578,
0.0040798858,
0.0092921006,
0.0282406583,
0.0223622248,
0.0199518204,
-0.0729081109,
-0.0843620673,
0.0066266772,
0.0360876508,
0.0118834227,
0.0591380745,
0.052447781,
0.0789480656,
0.0187548716,
-0.0085612023,
-0.0098695057,
0.0078696739,
-0.055853609,
-0.0400947705,
-0.0225842223,
-5.744452079e-33,
-0.0102871945,
-0.0138456803,
0.0122433919,
-0.0394055173,
-0.0406387486,
0.0302102584,
-0.0038185338,
-0.0444470309,
-0.0203853063,
0.0108107273,
-0.0116865896,
0.0461489223,
0.0051753204,
0.0124673247,
-0.0048091128,
-0.0037726951,
-0.0025602269,
-0.0216637161,
-0.0238583144,
0.0083158398,
0.0564522743,
0.0155645665,
0.1215727255,
-0.0098603228,
0.0487220995,
0.0073470557,
-0.0179471001,
-0.002046485,
0.0017328971,
0.0526258089,
-0.0468939096,
0.0459121056,
0.026350813,
-0.0399495773,
0.0047518746,
-0.0068377666,
-0.0872982591,
-0.039210964,
0.0268943477,
-0.0032455926,
-0.0628921539,
0.0156345665,
0.0337517634,
-0.0060901218,
-0.0115087051,
0.0254677422,
0.0279489458,
0.0035157904,
-0.0627293736,
-0.0174237061,
-0.0361487083,
0.0479454026,
0.0057177907,
-0.0128514888,
0.0455496348,
-0.0341762267,
0.0338086039,
-0.052559346,
-0.049767483,
-0.0040592756,
-0.0215823855,
0.033290647,
0.0181058403,
0.0039409418,
-0.0149704944,
0.0898798928,
-0.026502477,
-0.0270077232,
0.0225474648,
-0.0417181551,
0.0349545889,
0.0705224201,
-0.0194041226,
0.0972810611,
0.0600649156,
-0.007019246,
-0.0022169086,
0.0139648886,
-0.0308374427,
0.0652932301,
-0.0036298574,
-0.0526634268,
-0.0268641021,
0.0016411432,
-0.0427669808,
0.0254071392,
-0.0378848165,
-0.0168170985,
0.0454503857,
-0.0262630079,
0.0014595493,
0.0144673623,
-0.0078123803,
-0.0390996523,
-0.001790531,
0.0605895333,
-0.012077691,
-0.0040011494,
0.0028626546,
0.0076399613,
0.0009938508,
-0.0423160046,
-0.0385305621,
0.0262515787,
0.0367373452,
-0.0150980689,
0.0409994721,
0.0404713117,
-0.0042790412,
0.008284742,
-0.0292997397,
-0.0014322499,
-0.0445924662,
0.0047953944,
0.052876208,
0.0424297638,
-0.0150766512,
0.0008660287,
0.0574497059,
-0.021048503,
-0.0335603282,
-0.043019902,
-0.0066290176,
0.0537242517,
-0.0141837224,
-0.0003974092,
-0.0370935015,
-0.0209432505,
0.0622678995,
-0.0182194747,
0.0137259802,
0.0075623197,
2.567e-7,
0.0571408235,
0.0544883274,
0.0069645373,
0.060214825,
-0.0262879934,
0.0152441449,
-0.0090972576,
0.0510753542,
-0.0941999108,
-0.0377675742,
0.0086307833,
0.016825635,
-0.010845623,
0.0312204044,
-0.0755399466,
0.0048558372,
-0.0628415421,
0.0565976575,
-0.0273708235,
0.0083709517,
0.0809882656,
0.1000374258,
0.0220800675,
-0.037292473,
-0.0815365314,
-0.0139816189,
0.031255208,
-0.0405454338,
0.0090397745,
0.03118545,
0.031310834,
0.0373176299,
0.0191452429,
0.0029651106,
-0.0293934681,
0.0185392518,
-0.0032372165,
0.0391356051,
-0.0099842027,
-0.0222837217,
-0.0343505181,
-0.0385093205,
-0.0028277091,
-0.0270383302,
0.0582053959,
0.0103095183,
0.0025530057,
-0.0485852957,
-0.0334778391,
0.0281482656,
0.033747647,
-0.0256200619,
-0.000861792,
0.0133460378,
0.0007352681,
-0.0091759795,
-0.0361803696,
-0.1048145145,
-0.0136881191,
0.0599556603,
-0.0079841027,
-0.0168835595,
0.0024493749,
-0.0349243507,
0.0060116793,
-0.0515846759,
-0.0086801397,
2.128003393e-34,
0.0207860954,
0.005988738,
0.0254931469,
0.0351011194,
0.0090256231,
-0.0477636084,
0.0721435472,
-0.0295166131,
-0.007321483,
-0.0344559364,
0.0054442398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03024v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03024v1 | Towards Scene-Text to Scene-Text Translation | 2023-08-06T05:23:25 | 2023-08-06T05:23:25 | Onkar Susladkar, Prajwal Gatti, Anand Mishra | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | In this work, we study the task of ``visually" translating scene text from a
source language (e.g., English) to a target language (e.g., Chinese). Visual
translation involves not just the recognition and translation of scene text but
also the generation of the translated image that preserves visual features of
the text, such as font, size, and background. There are several challenges
associated with this task, such as interpolating font to unseen characters and
preserving text size and the background. To address these, we introduce VTNet,
a novel conditional diffusion-based method. To train the VTNet, we create a
synthetic cross-lingual dataset of 600K samples of scene text images in six
popular languages, including English, Hindi, Tamil, Chinese, Bengali, and
German. We evaluate the performance of VTnet through extensive experiments and
comparisons to related methods. Our model also surpasses the previous
state-of-the-art results on the conventional scene-text editing benchmarks.
Further, we present rigorous qualitative studies to understand the strengths
and shortcomings of our model. Results show that our approach generalizes well
to unseen words and fonts. We firmly believe our work can benefit real-world
applications, such as text translation using a phone camera and translating
educational materials. Code and data will be made publicly available. | [
0.0180372708,
0.0226966906,
0.0205111057,
0.0696993545,
-0.0314523615,
0.000297909,
0.0226344559,
0.0348233581,
-0.0038643242,
0.011548955,
-0.0267508235,
-0.0303244274,
0.047429651,
-0.0111989183,
0.0049393466,
-0.0909494981,
-0.0273338277,
-0.0149308201,
-0.0490326062,
0.0069002998,
0.0439098515,
0.023339903,
0.0025045609,
-0.0227100868,
-0.0287453402,
-0.0138720665,
0.007487596,
0.0780458525,
0.083733514,
-0.0035275659,
-0.0214535352,
0.0230074432,
0.0466096513,
0.0287345462,
0.0000018345,
0.0050006364,
0.0040362244,
0.0074509257,
0.0714764223,
0.0093327565,
0.0949086919,
-0.0468914732,
-0.042041596,
0.0011003581,
-0.008478201,
-0.0046919575,
0.1082158685,
0.0621562004,
0.0233584549,
0.0582231469,
-0.0519926511,
-0.061013788,
-0.0288517941,
-0.03791143,
0.0444682986,
-0.0088335183,
0.0090541691,
0.0540465377,
-0.0353949778,
0.0042370958,
-0.0497012138,
0.0599654578,
0.0157474987,
-0.0359251313,
0.0035913221,
0.0444831923,
0.00230038,
0.0012073581,
-0.0019372546,
0.0949083194,
-0.0710188299,
-0.0093792398,
-0.0263882745,
-0.0177282542,
-0.0338606089,
0.0083168633,
-0.0501229018,
-0.0130978469,
-0.0332519524,
0.0204934478,
-0.0451692194,
0.0265052486,
0.0340231992,
-0.0186471436,
-0.0054214578,
-0.0396727212,
0.0511149094,
0.0001885348,
-0.0681438819,
0.009673113,
-0.0220293645,
-0.0281035174,
0.1144819185,
-0.0007137319,
0.0579515733,
0.0091672642,
-0.0364935696,
-0.0623627305,
-0.0391312204,
-0.0333844349,
0.0234183092,
0.0422780924,
-0.0316436402,
0.0444530286,
-0.0733722597,
0.0479012281,
-0.0389074869,
0.0151380897,
-0.0548695102,
0.0033225182,
-0.0161764584,
0.006771754,
-0.0386068523,
-0.0546464771,
-0.0585658737,
-0.0002170197,
-0.0207524654,
-0.0262813959,
0.0406597145,
0.0038299423,
0.0547338538,
-0.0190857593,
-0.0758047104,
-0.0470504686,
0.0087356567,
0.0174595453,
-0.0105063468,
0.0308204982,
-0.0198400952,
0.0050335866,
-0.0262144171,
0.0145628676,
0.077304408,
-0.0048292312,
-0.0142700914,
0.0696958303,
-0.0749590993,
-0.0109111369,
-0.0307372492,
0.027172273,
-0.0226476938,
-0.0364247225,
-0.0182668678,
-0.0704458654,
0.0296470113,
-0.0466480553,
-0.0036355297,
-0.0096301725,
0.0043446426,
0.0211032666,
-0.0108303642,
0.0903227031,
-0.0073931199,
0.0001454421,
0.0466013774,
0.0119223399,
0.0041139433,
0.0373379029,
0.0371324196,
0.0848676041,
0.0236472618,
0.0327827148,
0.0101286406,
0.0768984333,
-0.0109355291,
0.0210245363,
-0.0491113439,
-0.0227635875,
0.0336653516,
0.0222487953,
-0.0134576401,
0.0558844618,
-0.0439421609,
0.0283297207,
0.0880635604,
0.0290946774,
-0.0029520688,
0.0264408905,
0.0395586118,
0.0373405032,
-0.0218135994,
0.0014738146,
0.0038223492,
0.0361602269,
0.0279126037,
0.0084889485,
-0.0149912573,
0.021706216,
-0.0451709069,
-0.0425445661,
0.0182761215,
-0.0140857939,
0.0275497623,
-0.0233018324,
0.0616710857,
0.0548137799,
-0.0893563032,
0.004264174,
-0.0011996441,
-0.0551943667,
0.0183216967,
-0.0099663595,
0.0140100494,
0.1061216518,
0.0372339562,
-0.0044511175,
0.0394093096,
0.0285647251,
0.0259523746,
0.0497859158,
0.0202726014,
0.0080054151,
0.0459931344,
-0.0873048976,
-0.011160112,
0.0293965396,
-0.0134309633,
0.0596899316,
-0.0134761687,
0.0655353442,
0.0229727216,
-0.0151555762,
-0.053159602,
0.0536358058,
-0.020811107,
-0.0341215543,
0.0226729438,
0.0031734926,
-0.0373743922,
-0.0009609719,
-0.0404478498,
-0.0222136751,
-0.0173815899,
-0.0512677096,
-0.0024703541,
0.0354686454,
-0.0098403124,
-0.0631581545,
-0.0182403568,
-0.0750536397,
-0.0001811775,
0.0121002123,
-0.0375997871,
-0.0343572982,
-0.008239368,
0.0298631657,
-0.0030329458,
-0.0332068466,
-0.0003630931,
-0.0170857832,
0.0286444742,
-0.0343747884,
0.0352256596,
0.0274967086,
-0.0110563328,
0.0039115273,
0.0284895841,
-0.003454064,
-0.0062956382,
0.0084872888,
-0.0202565659,
0.0251578931,
0.0325694829,
0.0164996572,
0.0415257104,
-0.0234882198,
-0.0282876175,
-0.0992358252,
-0.0077551068,
-0.0387764238,
0.0023987947,
0.0316267051,
0.0304672867,
-0.000045393,
-0.0389627926,
-0.0251070708,
0.0435983762,
-0.0217888877,
-0.0434179194,
0.021943748,
-0.0000617052,
0.0254724119,
-0.0458181873,
0.0074456488,
0.0329160355,
0.0194728933,
0.0442026518,
-0.0733501911,
-0.0540253185,
0.0370509252,
0.0194891896,
0.0019325437,
-0.0182644706,
-0.035485778,
-0.0317904055,
-0.0372482352,
0.0588580742,
0.0603746064,
-0.0060083438,
-0.0465630963,
-0.000579397,
-0.0404372923,
-0.0194612592,
-0.0024027089,
0.0085975481,
-0.0163313448,
-0.0206948314,
-0.0466307811,
-0.040698465,
0.033195436,
-0.0021058174,
0.0321371146,
-0.0763271824,
-0.0467932001,
-0.0513004698,
-0.0153360618,
-0.0344993249,
0.055761911,
-0.0058208313,
0.0170181636,
-0.0606405027,
-0.0290221255,
0.0298585668,
-0.0413306095,
-0.0332380012,
-0.0393281244,
0.0051364391,
-0.014187308,
0.029883761,
-0.0007601948,
0.0449983142,
-0.0185652059,
-0.0087745404,
-0.0396611467,
-0.0241095107,
0.0203413516,
-0.0176889747,
0.0172667243,
-0.0599391311,
0.0180525761,
-0.0365163684,
-0.0005826357,
-0.00303235,
-0.0299528241,
-0.0019283665,
-0.0468988158,
-0.0333436802,
-0.0372023098,
-0.0007380294,
0.0475702807,
-0.010413806,
0.0825436935,
-0.0044370303,
-0.0214004219,
-0.0123014282,
0.0517080314,
0.0024557987,
-0.0294917468,
-0.0421251021,
-0.0483296216,
0.0365293548,
0.0061260457,
0.0210115798,
-0.020501541,
-0.0302545168,
0.0138731049,
-0.0093064336,
0.0561302043,
0.03258048,
-0.0124230804,
0.076164633,
-0.0339302868,
-0.0122565413,
0.0570109151,
0.0101212058,
-0.035714861,
-0.056799937,
-0.0130070485,
0.0274292007,
-0.0018170777,
0.0172100458,
-0.0654036775,
-0.0322514474,
0.003167158,
-0.0226030797,
0.0454409644,
0.0050581573,
-0.042218063,
-0.0371698029,
0.0263075083,
0.0514104925,
-0.0159644168,
-0.0273562968,
0.0054854732,
0.0151853887,
-0.0086256824,
-0.0211081188,
-0.01491745,
0.0055226674,
-0.0451487899,
-0.0086706867,
0.0688071176,
-0.0129157864,
-0.0234037824,
-0.0212433431,
-0.045619227,
0.0543475635,
0.0453690179,
-0.0130387107,
-0.0356347188,
0.0533546843,
0.0087600974,
-0.0075089829,
-0.0075380928,
0.0720026419,
0.022804562,
-0.0237777978,
0.0230513364,
0.0356037468,
-0.0300661903,
-0.024224015,
0.0512104481,
-0.0117263654,
0.0513109043,
-0.0183672048,
0.0095745055,
-0.008112086,
0.0265630707,
0.0078810314,
0.0091756471,
-0.0634437948,
-0.017438326,
-0.0452248193,
-0.0038484575,
-0.0553690381,
-0.0559749901,
0.0022470683,
-0.0482924767,
-0.0581908077,
-0.0657391027,
-0.0197667405,
0.0143528534,
0.0580113083,
0.0378942415,
-0.0017089503,
-0.004802906,
0.0409385413,
-0.0421974063,
-0.0148697114,
-0.0528442375,
0.0510941185,
-0.0078058471,
0.0299951658,
0.008454279,
-0.0527292788,
0.0059693474,
-0.0280290525,
-0.0712095872,
-0.0301279053,
-0.0364447162,
0.0366872996,
0.0100215496,
0.0457159206,
-0.0441958494,
-0.038358625,
0.0690403879,
0.0112637104,
0.0507605672,
-0.0214814693,
-0.0101153934,
-0.0262494329,
-0.0022101093,
0.0341802351,
-0.0265947375,
0.0469763279,
0.0049088448,
0.0089907702,
-0.013944325,
0.0226591192,
0.0117851309,
-0.0285007134,
-0.0171833169,
-0.0354013294,
0.0458564386,
-0.0767651424,
0.0194429234,
-0.0020270499,
-0.0109642409,
-0.0695126578,
-0.0220980737,
0.0536578931,
0.0262456071,
-0.005760584,
-0.0054322099,
0.0307877325,
-0.0119418912,
0.0082093365,
-0.0176305026,
0.0051096086,
0.08093936,
0.0504931286,
0.0259308219,
0.0036810583,
0.0211371407,
-0.0147898346,
0.0405368321,
0.0083232168,
0.0541830622,
0.0249163713,
-0.0268047899,
0.0055480837,
0.0307067093,
0.007848531,
-0.0182327516,
-0.057768859,
0.0460060947,
0.0604622923,
-0.0156338848,
0.0845426321,
-0.028757507,
-0.0043243016,
-0.0194362588,
0.0199667402,
0.0041440018,
-0.0194908008,
0.0049589542,
-0.0206705499,
0.0287859906,
0.007381157,
0.0479047224,
-0.0237784702,
0.0044308505,
0.001594239,
-0.020043049,
-0.0316591114,
-0.0075277346,
-0.0104145706,
-0.0590544119,
0.0190511253,
-0.0026817238,
-0.0117220953,
-0.0371308438,
-0.0141322631,
0.0354016945,
-0.0100015793,
0.026399212,
0.0124955801,
0.0283535756,
0.0032250804,
0.0437086187,
-0.0021584427,
-0.0118222358,
-0.0275041852,
-0.0086848708,
-0.010129544,
-4.843548433e-33,
-0.033179421,
-0.0256652199,
-0.000465962,
-0.0211938825,
-0.0424188301,
-0.0045191227,
-0.0509765632,
0.0075814533,
0.0030246761,
0.0427333601,
0.0022032475,
0.0206443965,
0.0441318452,
0.0337268412,
-0.029104203,
0.0183956865,
0.0538037606,
-0.0137375863,
-0.0095949601,
0.026723031,
0.0155406808,
0.0279697962,
0.0550401658,
-0.0509003215,
-0.0047883331,
-0.0416142084,
-0.0204306524,
0.0176523849,
0.0335756689,
-0.0063180523,
0.0017874553,
-0.0076393043,
-0.0006175044,
-0.0020172549,
-0.0193510447,
0.0560888946,
-0.0720610321,
0.0102304174,
-0.0585933104,
0.0825445801,
-0.0796592608,
-0.0223102067,
0.037350826,
-0.0388604291,
0.0108179944,
-0.0138049209,
0.0508798175,
-0.0614528544,
0.0120411897,
-0.0101904506,
-0.049523361,
0.0308968797,
-0.0258503146,
-0.0251261946,
0.0636583716,
0.0527947135,
0.0222803969,
0.011181728,
-0.0587611124,
0.0053975563,
-0.0106388563,
0.0386471339,
0.0622461438,
0.0483891703,
0.0020445285,
0.0086242585,
0.040979322,
-0.0042246468,
0.039706286,
-0.0267908853,
0.033824265,
0.0101950895,
0.0407994166,
0.0327391624,
0.0318160467,
-0.03212706,
-0.0505661666,
0.0287486091,
-0.0694658011,
-0.0029634272,
0.0257659685,
0.0334255695,
0.020270342,
0.0095668631,
-0.026129147,
-0.0538717322,
-0.0268306378,
-0.0257167891,
0.0206468869,
0.0260286219,
-0.0264267251,
-0.0264761727,
0.0799298659,
-0.0309284534,
-0.0088943271,
-0.0091402261,
-0.0629498139,
0.0393828712,
-0.0149026876,
0.0355201922,
-0.0576795787,
-0.0488917306,
0.0213722736,
0.0638805255,
-0.0078979656,
-0.0138082094,
0.0255126655,
0.017825434,
-0.0225557499,
-0.0067773582,
-0.0383668616,
-0.009760513,
0.0152376182,
0.0818432868,
-0.0122562116,
-0.0161214899,
-0.0316149779,
0.0132422959,
0.0103217792,
-0.0182601437,
0.0125327511,
0.0240372717,
0.0081560761,
0.0150865884,
-0.0493330322,
0.0215641744,
-0.0426929891,
0.0147126429,
0.0511359349,
-0.0460215434,
-0.0275809877,
0.0545482747,
2.347e-7,
0.0138062118,
0.0174184032,
0.0344043002,
-0.0175806489,
0.0106359748,
0.0466332324,
-0.0637919456,
0.0237559564,
0.0071521644,
-0.0128654083,
0.0503349975,
0.0401077792,
0.0650258511,
-0.0234532095,
-0.0620806068,
-0.0005231477,
0.0045340629,
0.0027363824,
-0.0269827824,
0.0017591624,
0.0461022258,
0.0489097387,
-0.0101347752,
-0.0065890555,
0.0264494363,
-0.0232630391,
0.0992639735,
-0.0216871593,
0.0095418589,
-0.0028861931,
-0.0260318667,
0.005830375,
-0.0928575844,
-0.0029119628,
-0.0052873059,
-0.0197052024,
0.0792070851,
0.0381840281,
-0.0412552282,
0.0389071777,
-0.0149998087,
0.0253944788,
-0.017314449,
-0.0232274253,
0.0530037731,
-0.0112619232,
0.0126533546,
0.0050616455,
-0.0134631349,
0.0199611485,
0.0270685218,
-0.0012975116,
-0.0486867651,
0.0380959213,
0.0606831647,
0.0183858275,
-0.0534192212,
-0.0378981307,
-0.0374484472,
-0.0374887958,
-0.0063717593,
-0.0269497391,
-0.0782494918,
0.0271078981,
-0.0122859664,
0.0144162364,
0.0045722146,
1.593365144e-34,
0.0189896598,
-0.0218580086,
-0.0158878528,
-0.0367899276,
0.0287771877,
-0.0056183874,
0.0123212319,
-0.0056868559,
-0.0099204108,
-0.0376571193,
-0.033908695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02976v1 | Spanish Pre-trained BERT Model and Evaluation Data | 2023-08-06T00:16:04 | 2023-08-06T00:16:04 | José Cañete, Gabriel Chaperon, Rodrigo Fuentes, Jou-Hui Ho, Hojin Kang, Jorge Pérez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The Spanish language is one of the top 5 spoken languages in the world.
Nevertheless, finding resources to train or evaluate Spanish language models is
not an easy task. In this paper we help bridge this gap by presenting a
BERT-based language model pre-trained exclusively on Spanish data. As a second
contribution, we also compiled several tasks specifically for the Spanish
language in a single repository much in the spirit of the GLUE benchmark. By
fine-tuning our pre-trained Spanish model, we obtain better results compared to
other BERT-based models pre-trained on multilingual corpora for most of the
tasks, even achieving a new state-of-the-art on some of them. We have publicly
released our model, the pre-training data, and the compilation of the Spanish
benchmarks. | [
-0.0106730033,
0.082999818,
-0.0001687266,
0.0410891473,
-0.004322262,
0.0012242994,
-0.004999571,
-0.0270860419,
-0.0064159138,
-0.0120707257,
-0.1007027477,
-0.0020910229,
-0.0146038672,
-0.0277375244,
0.0355336778,
-0.0460710861,
0.0371742584,
-0.0147945574,
-0.0049082204,
-0.0331891589,
0.0317747518,
-0.0019930117,
-0.0209016744,
0.0235414784,
-0.0328985453,
0.016907325,
0.0190594234,
0.0030139824,
0.0132218162,
0.0134593258,
0.060048189,
0.0708885714,
-0.0259963516,
0.0443008132,
0.0000016523,
-0.0662093237,
-0.0357795022,
-0.0125907566,
0.0233502556,
0.0411746167,
-0.026514573,
-0.0153828813,
-0.0277233999,
0.0297016352,
-0.0377614871,
-0.0265575517,
0.0417639911,
-0.0184464417,
0.048735667,
0.0441955626,
-0.0264083892,
-0.0323271044,
0.0040542358,
-0.050412003,
-0.0293029025,
-0.0201793071,
0.0214560274,
-0.0092742071,
0.0057032546,
-0.0501371548,
0.0063900636,
0.0175387319,
0.0162882004,
0.0092573045,
-0.0425685681,
-0.0064063841,
-0.0918592438,
-0.021908829,
-0.0016319511,
0.0732585713,
-0.0771739259,
-0.0410301089,
0.0063636494,
0.0159882996,
-0.032453537,
-0.0130840028,
-0.015771294,
-0.017726386,
0.0345046706,
0.0210798029,
0.0381834954,
0.0090698432,
0.048765216,
0.0273940507,
-0.0553812757,
0.02857293,
0.0641319975,
-0.0346771069,
0.027165845,
0.0206088889,
-0.0080677858,
-0.042011153,
0.0449452698,
0.0234745014,
0.004898706,
0.0094109792,
-0.028454667,
-0.0499768481,
0.0258328617,
-0.0822973624,
0.0167814717,
0.0392978638,
-0.0375806168,
0.0279225744,
-0.0163761955,
0.0374531187,
-0.0045227851,
0.0714079887,
-0.0304370709,
-0.0290874131,
-0.0228078496,
0.0172261223,
-0.0788473859,
0.0177651085,
-0.0003237773,
0.0065916767,
-0.0024670779,
0.0101453438,
0.0309429374,
-0.016391227,
0.0339350849,
-0.0246563964,
-0.0307414588,
-0.0150676062,
0.0262237638,
0.0243840571,
-0.0658139735,
-0.0095372275,
-0.0195944719,
-0.0783152729,
0.0024696339,
0.014102581,
0.0008986928,
-0.0371463671,
0.0608650073,
0.0202709194,
0.0042754491,
-0.0544337109,
-0.0201316029,
0.0278939977,
-0.0222278181,
-0.0872794539,
-0.006726366,
-0.0804637,
0.0474153832,
0.0013314682,
0.0323482379,
0.0082841432,
-0.0176480636,
-0.0189281534,
0.0213278793,
0.0696034133,
-0.042321194,
-0.0167951081,
0.0153617905,
-0.0042559942,
0.0113604348,
0.0645452365,
0.0267301984,
0.0168405212,
0.0312110502,
-0.0053438046,
-0.0119085396,
0.1058018878,
0.0239859391,
0.0060648839,
-0.0024478282,
0.0219352841,
-0.0102851605,
0.0300563853,
0.0215271376,
0.0370089188,
-0.0193270613,
0.0202404466,
0.0203815997,
0.0515936986,
0.0136028938,
0.0388591364,
0.0512432083,
-0.002153147,
0.0639060885,
-0.0121369734,
-0.0177626908,
-0.0476461872,
-0.0041924007,
0.0314179771,
-0.004230645,
0.0220366269,
-0.0653479546,
-0.0051971418,
0.0110773249,
-0.0334023014,
-0.0271934215,
-0.0172897037,
0.0427792408,
0.0312377028,
-0.0305402428,
0.0783999935,
0.0031163809,
-0.0551871434,
0.0241599195,
-0.0261128284,
0.0066925525,
0.0267796367,
0.0640313998,
-0.0467963032,
-0.0855182558,
0.0387813896,
-0.0091456054,
0.0260109566,
0.0288127773,
-0.0091822241,
0.0488842204,
-0.0692210123,
0.0044566225,
0.0173262171,
0.0051718378,
0.0479302891,
0.0043293498,
0.0010220362,
-0.0188363232,
-0.0654764995,
-0.0083800266,
0.0181802772,
-0.0259603951,
-0.0162897538,
-0.0074140364,
0.0197889619,
0.0207158867,
0.0383157954,
-0.0435421951,
-0.0146628814,
0.0624104291,
-0.0166812539,
0.040829353,
0.0234844945,
-0.0467774719,
-0.0638659298,
0.0335931852,
-0.0128502911,
-0.0357223861,
0.0373234004,
-0.0243364666,
-0.0281045437,
-0.0034691468,
-0.0111622643,
0.0817980617,
-0.0560126118,
0.0646376461,
-0.0303700063,
0.0063981107,
-0.0031088432,
0.0357309282,
-0.0406797118,
0.0695921183,
0.0036841687,
0.0047123237,
0.0522529967,
-0.0461726002,
-0.0641594604,
0.0198570285,
-0.0111110499,
0.0292991903,
0.0140275601,
0.0426287279,
0.0043616462,
-0.010245692,
-0.086442098,
0.0175360478,
-0.0484414436,
0.0468970425,
0.0293464996,
0.0210459847,
-0.0346254706,
-0.0448523872,
-0.0055171736,
-0.0476067886,
0.0102918437,
-0.0045467671,
0.0010969193,
0.0248514451,
0.0162761565,
-0.069917284,
-0.0058177901,
0.0007274218,
0.0267806705,
-0.0201070551,
-0.0435177013,
-0.0220021699,
-0.028162308,
-0.0365290269,
0.0610408895,
0.0309836753,
-0.0934742987,
0.0069615883,
-0.0112599535,
0.0913691595,
0.0248789582,
-0.0317306109,
0.0237969141,
-0.0002196102,
-0.0234202128,
-0.0302158184,
0.0103308111,
-0.0067252489,
0.0047263578,
-0.0514963977,
-0.0232905224,
0.0414427407,
0.0836429521,
-0.0336251967,
-0.0110889059,
-0.0429825634,
-0.0378488526,
0.0041979384,
-0.0159791224,
-0.0050674453,
0.0168066993,
-0.0142028145,
0.0082004499,
-0.0334838517,
-0.0328725204,
0.0531118214,
-0.0743797272,
-0.0132941483,
-0.0543502159,
0.0208009873,
-0.025230201,
0.008385662,
0.0314954817,
0.0211039204,
-0.0400151648,
-0.0255702008,
-0.0000067782,
0.0077449684,
-0.0117311832,
-0.0311670061,
0.0247924645,
-0.0322682522,
0.0153262522,
0.0173331164,
-0.0476542152,
-0.0281097703,
-0.0056626708,
-0.0315158889,
0.0173463766,
0.009937604,
-0.0076916823,
-0.02593017,
-0.016922975,
-0.0062706326,
0.0714789778,
0.0186821204,
0.0200062525,
-0.0081268605,
0.0428393558,
-0.0234326627,
-0.0200942662,
-0.0024956248,
-0.0612687394,
-0.0342613086,
-0.0284376517,
0.0481652245,
-0.0156775974,
-0.0522465892,
0.0105083566,
0.0423644371,
-0.0330532417,
-0.0229027998,
-0.0276757237,
0.0248981919,
0.0050954996,
0.0022856009,
0.094917506,
0.0443502441,
0.000040461,
-0.0171704106,
-0.0084055383,
0.0310015921,
0.0057243071,
0.0301583745,
-0.0574249998,
-0.019042775,
0.0071425587,
-0.0111824935,
0.0581356399,
-0.0191958621,
-0.0135218482,
-0.1314243078,
-0.0238106046,
-0.0248770416,
-0.0074507515,
-0.0291249231,
-0.0293309428,
-0.0189646836,
-0.0634274185,
0.0050893459,
-0.0247327965,
0.0196591709,
-0.003258907,
0.0427008979,
-0.0186186042,
-0.0458790921,
0.0323855765,
-0.0692508966,
0.0157749765,
0.0725999177,
0.0215084106,
-0.027068492,
-0.0394900106,
0.024500981,
-0.017497709,
-0.0370184071,
-0.0006965352,
0.0191492271,
-0.001379443,
-0.045734968,
-0.0089186262,
-0.0184891075,
-0.0200423636,
0.0188481268,
-0.0151684741,
0.0523389131,
0.0011202286,
0.0303426329,
0.0129218027,
-0.0184638537,
-0.0051233466,
0.0447758958,
0.0243350081,
-0.0612486452,
0.0088776434,
0.0118747791,
-0.002401296,
-0.0777057856,
0.0176849253,
0.017995989,
-0.0733602047,
-0.0288352221,
-0.0629238263,
-0.0476054214,
0.0411288999,
0.0263793226,
0.0356559567,
-0.033906851,
0.0059851417,
-0.0182792768,
-0.0174815413,
0.0658105984,
0.0252982378,
0.0294976607,
-0.0936868638,
-0.0407469496,
0.0087120729,
0.0085009728,
-0.0276062023,
-0.0119506046,
-0.0528518111,
-0.037489932,
-0.0025943075,
0.1066604257,
0.0220508259,
0.0358537659,
-0.0824124217,
-0.0582520813,
0.0147572076,
0.0217552483,
-0.0280914679,
-0.0428208746,
0.0570402332,
-0.0287583452,
0.0011703375,
0.0349115282,
-0.0174665563,
0.020930022,
-0.0034626531,
0.0486949608,
-0.0159999672,
-0.0212623402,
0.0041962056,
0.000297542,
0.0678208768,
-0.0450453572,
0.027347479,
-0.0488714874,
0.0022250591,
-0.0045023812,
0.0255885534,
-0.0095872423,
0.0115374839,
0.0431987718,
0.0056571071,
-0.0260116234,
0.0461498648,
-0.0247488078,
0.0115582384,
-0.0326890387,
0.0350602902,
0.0269698519,
0.0108989794,
0.0210035946,
0.0266460441,
0.0174362119,
0.0257882793,
-0.0150867198,
0.015690593,
-0.0574237742,
0.0102255866,
-0.0005149899,
0.020065302,
0.0156096462,
0.0592312962,
0.0359842107,
-0.0263230931,
-0.0424993746,
0.0408929288,
0.0702617988,
-0.0443445258,
0.0481897704,
0.0078446288,
-0.01216467,
-0.0221558772,
0.005704022,
0.0089380182,
-0.0143421562,
0.0188766271,
-0.0170153268,
0.005623213,
-0.0234413743,
0.0746752843,
-0.0006318869,
0.0586388372,
0.0169576574,
0.0269654095,
-0.0320870616,
-0.0044388562,
0.0469883531,
-0.0387560017,
-0.0683504567,
-0.0160463694,
-0.0051895333,
-0.0651670396,
0.0207623802,
0.0027172591,
0.0036212837,
0.0401292294,
0.045440387,
0.0845029876,
-0.017716039,
-0.0029294286,
-0.0047038398,
-0.016743131,
-0.0092131216,
-0.0283264033,
0.0130438106,
-5.277884412e-33,
0.0046455022,
0.0239764024,
0.0010916577,
-0.0183351114,
0.0316819847,
0.0077281566,
-0.0478444695,
-0.0282325279,
-0.0157179162,
0.0041327048,
-0.0019433142,
-0.0031576031,
0.0362401046,
0.0182084385,
-0.0176026914,
0.0241138898,
0.0343969092,
0.0097446786,
-0.0088648945,
-0.0411593989,
-0.0333357714,
0.068351239,
0.1151056737,
-0.0134910727,
-0.009751617,
-0.018575022,
-0.0092798471,
0.0393826626,
0.0636967048,
0.051365599,
-0.0253118798,
0.0189724751,
-0.0024648411,
-0.0042248978,
-0.0361687727,
0.0173629951,
-0.0738664046,
-0.0477244221,
0.0326043256,
0.0552626103,
-0.0216520652,
0.005038586,
-0.0072579188,
-0.025575988,
-0.0110970801,
0.0684210658,
0.0267992802,
-0.0142041296,
0.0049875313,
0.0021846283,
-0.0678008273,
0.032010857,
0.0111353407,
-0.048849985,
0.040840324,
0.0429506376,
-0.006460866,
-0.015141381,
-0.0216907207,
0.0085209552,
0.0364704877,
0.0257509202,
0.0521533303,
0.016706666,
0.0056112069,
0.0343417414,
0.0005991794,
-0.0121135181,
0.0313914493,
0.02369483,
0.0648950562,
0.0395000912,
0.0432842039,
0.0254570153,
0.0192002635,
0.0025229957,
-0.0590111725,
0.0529412553,
0.02111963,
-0.0224671699,
-0.0182401948,
-0.0010366902,
-0.0037497566,
0.0284347814,
-0.0200649127,
-0.031468723,
-0.0074379058,
-0.0190079473,
0.018437244,
-0.0076713995,
-0.009248171,
0.0328217447,
0.0291537233,
-0.0084974086,
-0.0249849148,
0.018400453,
-0.0161962416,
-0.0040114885,
-0.0133869154,
0.0937754065,
-0.0898028463,
-0.0228601135,
0.0170269702,
0.0377939343,
-0.0035211118,
-0.0060697766,
0.0651772395,
0.0373515487,
-0.0410202406,
0.0234589167,
-0.0448126793,
0.0245774593,
-0.003617611,
0.0723039135,
0.0304013845,
0.0231706258,
0.002668241,
0.0573775508,
0.0273989812,
0.0139058419,
-0.0054202201,
0.005673043,
0.0116340676,
0.0458948947,
-0.0111112036,
-0.0167436991,
-0.0544221886,
0.0002498662,
-0.0325726308,
-0.0396401137,
-0.0080329059,
-0.0399578176,
2.269e-7,
0.0758769959,
0.0132695884,
0.0567714684,
0.0361075364,
-0.010365067,
-0.0137274098,
-0.0423943885,
0.0517295301,
-0.0140207456,
0.0371756405,
-0.0102472296,
-0.0116313146,
0.0443591774,
0.0101721454,
-0.0671488345,
-0.0451006219,
-0.0551093854,
0.0093494337,
-0.0691483542,
-0.01435911,
-0.0041800602,
0.1037846953,
-0.0101892529,
-0.0101398239,
-0.0057786582,
-0.0465004034,
0.0690863207,
-0.0109714353,
-0.0373566188,
0.059527766,
0.0084831342,
0.0463904031,
-0.015153748,
-0.0203855596,
-0.037620943,
0.0276173949,
0.014140835,
0.0472192056,
-0.0148234209,
-0.0058577782,
0.0650472566,
-0.0684353188,
-0.0368377492,
-0.0346435979,
0.030982051,
-0.0362594426,
-0.0018320845,
0.0622216612,
-0.0268135536,
0.0233887713,
0.0260351095,
-0.0527046472,
-0.0583609119,
0.0358767956,
0.0637007058,
-0.0550274029,
-0.0340269245,
-0.0654010996,
-0.039342694,
0.0290077534,
-0.0239184648,
-0.0065098242,
-0.0277551394,
-0.034376815,
-0.0003975322,
-0.0821680278,
0.0475470982,
1.661280363e-34,
0.0152773159,
-0.0191471763,
0.0048903166,
-0.0018523433,
0.0364766382,
-0.0315356739,
-0.0055731228,
-0.0182532966,
-0.0106919538,
-0.0068977308,
-0.0015193812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.07078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.07078v1 | Auditing and Robustifying COVID-19 Misinformation Datasets via Anticontent Sampling | 2023-08-05T22:38:05 | 2023-08-05T22:38:05 | Clay H. Yoo, Ashiqur R. KhudaBukhsh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | This paper makes two key contributions. First, it argues that highly
specialized rare content classifiers trained on small data typically have
limited exposure to the richness and topical diversity of the negative class
(dubbed anticontent) as observed in the wild. As a result, these classifiers'
strong performance observed on the test set may not translate into real-world
settings. In the context of COVID-19 misinformation detection, we conduct an
in-the-wild audit of multiple datasets and demonstrate that models trained with
several prominently cited recent datasets are vulnerable to anticontent when
evaluated in the wild. Second, we present a novel active learning pipeline that
requires zero manual annotation and iteratively augments the training data with
challenging anticontent, robustifying these classifiers. | [
-0.0045927991,
0.012969628,
-0.0300125033,
-0.0101250801,
-0.0282674059,
0.0039360328,
-0.0278555769,
-0.007388656,
0.0158870518,
-0.0152744595,
-0.0016464181,
-0.0220210087,
-0.0009718477,
0.0734662488,
0.0111750793,
-0.0205792189,
0.0793085545,
0.0310058147,
0.0699692145,
-0.0161140822,
-0.0291635264,
0.0035197663,
0.0098669138,
0.0306172129,
-0.0104867909,
0.005729069,
0.0304807909,
-0.0120603368,
0.0612389073,
-0.094932884,
0.0512964092,
-0.0196955353,
0.0326974019,
0.0589718185,
0.0000017781,
-0.015949674,
-0.0283800829,
0.0090016508,
-0.0217425786,
-0.0035949748,
0.0240793563,
-0.0535355546,
0.0400908291,
0.0283740815,
-0.0281954594,
0.0045294226,
0.0345187709,
0.0372705869,
0.0737370104,
0.0578109138,
-0.0084057366,
0.0339922383,
0.0407633521,
-0.0113225626,
0.0016360007,
-0.008016943,
0.061690554,
-0.019548988,
0.0018084842,
0.031905368,
0.0291339085,
0.0349248536,
-0.0078729996,
0.0198947899,
-0.0152290286,
0.0412868522,
-0.0400769226,
-0.0472040586,
-0.0142252054,
0.0376172513,
-0.0159364436,
-0.0443509892,
0.0315060616,
-0.0508089848,
0.0187396854,
0.0173857622,
-0.0180065855,
-0.033389654,
-0.0271861218,
0.041306559,
-0.0100600971,
-0.0168025587,
0.0726327226,
0.016452888,
0.0533286445,
0.0064602136,
-0.0272808317,
-0.047297921,
0.0257067271,
0.0117041292,
-0.0172414985,
-0.0349768251,
0.0492184684,
-0.0041906773,
-0.0025067169,
-0.0109587191,
-0.0310255121,
-0.0363853835,
0.0659801885,
-0.0868081152,
-0.0437119417,
-0.0391622297,
-0.0214565843,
0.0373734757,
0.0314489678,
-0.0545239411,
-0.0085216211,
0.0511417761,
0.0326961726,
0.016649235,
-0.0044692652,
0.008841889,
-0.0105806543,
0.0475243144,
0.0112214023,
0.0578854419,
-0.0443070009,
-0.0405863114,
-0.056372717,
0.0312621631,
-0.048999466,
0.0200530849,
-0.0392981358,
0.0339853093,
0.0114893354,
0.0172405057,
-0.0018729854,
0.0390974618,
-0.0217456855,
-0.0243646596,
-0.0028165684,
0.0221836828,
0.0020484875,
0.0175375082,
0.0001385566,
0.0036174383,
0.029657675,
-0.0135794459,
0.002687708,
-0.0321733318,
-0.057484407,
-0.0248247888,
0.0148946606,
-0.042562414,
-0.043494273,
-0.0114888316,
0.0180426575,
-0.0534184054,
-0.0252541136,
-0.0195397157,
-0.0840964243,
0.0304193702,
-0.0027664823,
-0.0215606522,
0.0432770327,
0.0194896869,
0.0054678326,
0.0494191721,
-0.0163516179,
0.078078419,
0.0553457513,
0.028426202,
0.0150776664,
-0.0041255285,
0.1075382307,
0.0490880385,
0.0399100445,
0.0149171976,
-0.001350977,
-0.0225423314,
-0.0317984819,
0.0081358217,
0.0016346737,
-0.0429996997,
0.0465502106,
-0.0488317497,
-0.0796275288,
-0.0557202771,
0.0225132927,
0.0718370825,
-0.0061636548,
0.0049477462,
-0.0485301577,
0.0119770803,
-0.0494100899,
-0.0308887865,
-0.0054723388,
0.0014536842,
-0.013745754,
-0.0168974493,
-0.0231552962,
-0.0149651244,
-0.0074091032,
-0.0038898345,
0.0266875979,
-0.0063208691,
-0.0341953747,
-0.0189691149,
0.0671638027,
0.0240257941,
0.0161437001,
-0.0585927293,
0.0408871695,
-0.0077120932,
0.0239343327,
-0.0415138789,
-0.0633805469,
-0.0451542102,
0.0231011808,
-0.0256856624,
0.0444634743,
-0.0115557127,
-0.0101409163,
0.0233484767,
-0.0198077764,
-0.0390447527,
0.0527139455,
0.0096031325,
0.0052855574,
0.0391956866,
-0.0131042516,
-0.0194948986,
-0.049295675,
0.0250109825,
-0.0207300112,
-0.0044705933,
0.0103092771,
0.0336719304,
0.0590390526,
-0.015101823,
0.0001347847,
-0.0063776178,
0.0651397929,
-0.0170706827,
-0.0316494368,
-0.0493631437,
0.0247541964,
-0.0028014276,
-0.0026787876,
-0.0473671332,
-0.0375835858,
0.0588034801,
-0.0381443053,
0.0516643003,
0.0036899166,
0.0132230949,
0.0020562459,
-0.016488729,
-0.0077144322,
-0.0257029794,
0.04258091,
0.03556991,
0.0677510649,
-0.0584675558,
-0.018594183,
0.0119500402,
-0.0863930434,
-0.0050065811,
-0.0145668602,
0.0107357102,
-0.0535724983,
-0.0214006752,
-0.0148069561,
0.0023957517,
-0.0221046805,
0.0035463613,
0.0135345338,
0.0070528896,
-0.0256744158,
-0.0340375416,
0.0039469055,
0.0213285852,
-0.0182001721,
-0.0101040937,
-0.0082636531,
-0.0208541062,
-0.0131484037,
0.0156033812,
0.0205913894,
0.0080996016,
0.0004692685,
0.0013912666,
-0.0085376976,
0.0021135407,
-0.027107032,
0.0073192068,
0.0196638815,
-0.0429509208,
0.0093509816,
-0.0406541489,
-0.0363288596,
-0.0183178317,
-0.0270583145,
-0.0234428328,
0.0098473718,
0.0056458465,
-0.0873838812,
0.0148574319,
0.0123593174,
0.0368381217,
0.0401119068,
0.0737726614,
0.012043939,
0.0328475721,
-0.0388112962,
0.0117966477,
-0.0287275501,
-0.0240964834,
0.0201624222,
0.030449247,
0.030621687,
-0.0006292601,
-0.038199611,
0.0148589928,
-0.0191682726,
-0.0487518646,
-0.0010626054,
-0.0259032995,
0.0002006239,
0.0198988914,
-0.0319927856,
-0.050871335,
0.0627857596,
0.0220075045,
0.0412192345,
-0.0218439642,
-0.0143539878,
0.0189783033,
-0.0114923865,
-0.0015942559,
-0.0063507366,
0.0256171953,
0.0315353684,
0.0306450818,
-0.058157634,
0.0268895626,
-0.0305548571,
-0.0239615459,
-0.017370455,
0.0007090296,
0.0282422435,
-0.0596081056,
-0.0826812088,
-0.0791039988,
-0.0156397242,
0.0004729188,
0.004931543,
0.0096216686,
-0.0749281049,
-0.033446122,
-0.0162583124,
0.0466397181,
0.0064121773,
-0.0105536552,
0.0324484743,
0.0006738381,
0.028873492,
-0.0552613474,
0.0675906688,
-0.0606596209,
0.0012219237,
0.0489419438,
-0.0380556621,
0.0118031092,
0.0153931193,
0.0112632178,
-0.0044560777,
-0.0209827013,
-0.0175579656,
0.0214222725,
0.0224956926,
-0.0364583023,
0.0065151127,
0.0558500923,
0.0102610709,
0.0007777272,
0.0317211039,
0.0005788293,
-0.0003605339,
0.0028401671,
-0.003853302,
-0.0303652585,
0.0081401942,
-0.0010559884,
0.0390301161,
-0.05774289,
-0.0599858761,
-0.0072813006,
-0.0290965848,
0.0434901603,
0.0018075105,
-0.008402219,
-0.055035837,
-0.0742333978,
0.0066963648,
-0.0344899967,
-0.0171449296,
-0.0476097018,
0.0282368548,
0.00162968,
-0.0297259912,
-0.0432399102,
-0.0529741347,
0.0197693314,
-0.0058231875,
0.0082155503,
0.0210988056,
0.0608540475,
-0.0200417321,
-0.0139308209,
0.037696436,
0.0066027697,
-0.0230631251,
-0.0189452916,
0.1227957457,
-0.0147051765,
-0.0177718643,
-0.0349848941,
0.0545715913,
-0.001214285,
-0.0285036508,
0.0114440527,
0.082591705,
-0.0410678051,
-0.0487273224,
-0.0426234715,
0.0425542854,
0.0847180635,
0.0512250476,
-0.0079916799,
0.0057202722,
0.0327312797,
0.0298950244,
0.0478048362,
-0.0063428655,
0.0044602575,
0.0595493615,
-0.0150088789,
-0.0566533096,
-0.03537938,
-0.0287156831,
0.0173773933,
0.0406508446,
-0.0265438091,
-0.038469281,
-0.0096501727,
-0.0095666777,
-0.022167135,
-0.0202067923,
0.0057706526,
0.0276699513,
0.0005462782,
-0.0727489367,
-0.0096078422,
0.000968447,
-0.0327859819,
0.0421759449,
-0.0489549898,
-0.0497841537,
0.0384612754,
0.0183987785,
0.0205837823,
0.0693498701,
-0.0227900613,
0.0262427516,
0.1062158868,
0.0796084851,
-0.0507286265,
-0.0419440605,
0.0420523547,
-0.0617968217,
-0.0028576902,
0.0334499292,
-0.0235687234,
0.0199938789,
0.0410807282,
-0.0292668827,
-0.0501912571,
0.0180065483,
0.0238262098,
-0.0004641081,
0.0839968771,
-0.0290430896,
-0.0156752504,
-0.0128631871,
-0.0082783382,
0.0214717723,
-0.0072341636,
0.0313718133,
0.0026528211,
0.008153216,
-0.0191071257,
-0.0385721363,
0.1094875783,
-0.0217972212,
0.0449201204,
-0.0817769691,
-0.0074018426,
0.0156540796,
0.0570018515,
0.0261452328,
-0.0494475514,
-0.0110920649,
0.0340537839,
0.0321771912,
0.0251935367,
0.0020877135,
-0.0258367416,
-0.0116706602,
0.0562747866,
0.0002094408,
-0.0354734436,
-0.0598582365,
0.0183967091,
-0.0694702193,
0.0623061806,
0.0270843972,
-0.0014717724,
0.0048379037,
-0.0365783237,
-0.0504556671,
-0.0245989226,
0.0143110473,
-0.0180623122,
-0.0198995266,
-0.0078656347,
-0.0179989226,
-0.0314994268,
0.0435583852,
0.0532519259,
-0.020633528,
0.077175647,
0.0208060816,
-0.0519545525,
-0.0454244986,
0.0035603498,
0.0442341752,
0.0512107499,
-0.0098657152,
0.026180001,
-0.0521603674,
-0.0402476229,
0.0632587597,
-0.0398904495,
-0.0149760833,
0.0169896036,
-0.0331666321,
0.0290067531,
-0.0033725323,
-0.0237428118,
-0.0280610118,
0.0252386145,
0.0193518586,
-0.0009979912,
-0.0177613534,
-6.187941853e-33,
0.0308204629,
-0.0113625219,
-0.0427057073,
-0.0027337763,
0.0363194197,
0.0589583814,
0.0247130655,
-0.0738883391,
0.0104983179,
0.0553657822,
-0.003195365,
0.0016017106,
-0.0130488174,
0.0059905071,
-0.0253322255,
-0.0277290754,
0.0892178938,
-0.015126504,
-0.0282612164,
0.0488529354,
0.0374054462,
0.0372848436,
0.0385096222,
-0.1042582467,
0.0425375886,
0.0136998612,
-0.0085049774,
-0.0082711056,
-0.019866351,
0.039207276,
0.0115362927,
0.0200515892,
0.0314582624,
-0.0180342197,
-0.0015021376,
-0.0313029923,
-0.0562187284,
-0.0372466333,
-0.000927692,
-0.0183823742,
0.0045013851,
-0.0265495423,
0.0654894933,
0.0233224891,
0.0123620331,
0.0041179955,
0.0204710867,
-0.0228987727,
-0.0076744291,
-0.0386448242,
-0.023309676,
0.0283994898,
-0.0349811167,
0.0339303911,
-0.0729993284,
0.0608794242,
-0.0090872804,
0.0679704919,
-0.0300345886,
0.0190050863,
0.0269028284,
-0.0023269255,
0.035653729,
-0.0405469351,
-0.0068485881,
0.0682438686,
0.0135570848,
0.0213871263,
-0.0345551148,
0.0238655172,
-0.0045523131,
0.025358133,
-0.0065396852,
0.1071199104,
0.0055077071,
-0.0610550232,
-0.0905106664,
0.0490663499,
-0.0255730208,
0.0111753596,
0.0088611711,
-0.03404174,
-0.0346954465,
0.0210092682,
-0.0050538331,
-0.0178872608,
0.0143029345,
0.0194113739,
-0.0139161088,
0.0336308628,
-0.0620574802,
0.0887504593,
-0.0275509432,
-0.0058701788,
-0.0112766381,
0.0046677557,
0.0273796711,
-0.0362386592,
0.0069673769,
0.0066873496,
-0.0558193699,
-0.0020445327,
0.034723226,
0.0000337125,
0.0194433741,
-0.0162104871,
0.0734340698,
0.0298005715,
-0.0552183613,
0.0085932938,
0.0177327264,
0.0621623024,
0.0000350615,
0.0353873447,
0.0470301844,
-0.0029756951,
0.0192873627,
0.0122928573,
-0.0240186919,
0.0203122329,
0.0177236348,
-0.0134535469,
-0.0543103702,
0.0303952247,
-0.0465506166,
-0.0383571126,
-0.0013903377,
-0.0203613117,
0.0140635101,
-0.1133603975,
0.0028109143,
-0.0431694686,
2.585e-7,
0.0343768112,
0.0248843469,
-0.0110935196,
-0.0512168258,
0.0157309007,
0.0284088589,
-0.0328362361,
0.0260261502,
-0.03506409,
-0.0498023964,
0.0245478321,
0.0233991165,
-0.0418268181,
0.0420860946,
-0.0195924398,
0.0275155045,
-0.0713125914,
0.0274457596,
-0.0419052728,
0.0027785692,
0.0091666942,
0.0895183533,
0.0369837917,
-0.0229301676,
0.0244840942,
-0.0202525295,
0.0336201489,
0.0165596399,
-0.031397406,
0.0058583342,
0.0323178023,
0.0156623833,
0.0056197545,
0.0567002483,
-0.0576038435,
-0.0232412759,
-0.0493902899,
0.0384111144,
0.0104221273,
0.0135356039,
-0.0252411067,
-0.030373212,
0.0035826156,
-0.0055731023,
0.0641429275,
-0.0612836182,
-0.0370479077,
-0.0431496985,
-0.0575691648,
0.0196936782,
0.0524863154,
0.0089747617,
-0.0103687569,
0.0325050168,
-0.0445758775,
0.0265337024,
-0.0216745418,
-0.0237614457,
0.0392979681,
0.0107719572,
-0.0452580005,
-0.0470440127,
0.025825344,
0.0046055987,
0.0174889453,
-0.027024094,
0.0612799674,
2.057624801e-34,
0.0797470361,
-0.0306091476,
-0.0563392602,
-0.0640734285,
-0.0185983181,
-0.0180509612,
0.0194248259,
-0.0181059074,
0.0110184876,
0.0372773446,
0.0225177146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02962v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02962v2 | Science and engineering for what? A large-scale analysis of students' projects in science fairs | 2023-08-05T22:19:03 | 2023-10-14T02:31:04 | Adelmo Eloy, Thomas Palmeira Ferraz, Fellip Silva Alves, Roseli de Deus Lopes | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, physics.ed-ph, stat.AP | Science and Engineering fairs offer K-12 students opportunities to engage
with authentic STEM practices. Particularly, students are given the chance to
experience authentic and open inquiry processes, by defining which themes,
questions and approaches will guide their scientific endeavors. In this study,
we analyzed data from over 5,000 projects presented at a nationwide science
fair in Brazil over the past 20 years using topic modeling to identify the main
topics that have driven students' inquiry and design. Our analysis identified a
broad range of topics being explored, with significant variations over time,
region, and school setting. We argue those results and proposed methodology can
not only support further research in the context of science fairs, but also
inform instruction and design of contexts-specific resources to support
students in open inquiry experiences in different settings. | [
-0.0024142549,
0.0011164349,
-0.0329282396,
-0.0093777599,
-0.0156783238,
-0.0384568758,
0.0317656808,
-0.0498940162,
-0.0438968875,
0.0133394608,
0.0030818721,
0.0259500016,
-0.0020468158,
0.0467576571,
-0.0404780358,
-0.0319962092,
0.0223526303,
-0.0266884007,
-0.0060206568,
0.0343471393,
-0.0075821294,
-0.0087013906,
-0.0369869322,
0.0349348783,
0.0425720923,
-0.0320642963,
-0.0126903597,
0.0044106073,
0.0201850589,
-0.0658911318,
0.0334415026,
0.0263065808,
0.0379509479,
0.0003108948,
0.0000021806,
-0.0182185993,
-0.050024163,
-0.0055478192,
0.0043252772,
0.0745624453,
0.0837777555,
0.1060083658,
-0.0034794968,
0.0339583978,
-0.0161276795,
0.0075094881,
0.0289659575,
-0.0046545123,
-0.0149144791,
-0.0576584823,
0.0156376176,
-0.0275525004,
-0.0147545272,
-0.0275928658,
0.0511232615,
0.0612273775,
0.0174214132,
0.0096940994,
0.0799992085,
0.0654030219,
0.0007738816,
0.0282797888,
-0.0010230208,
-0.014910779,
0.0728381723,
0.0070879282,
-0.0150687955,
-0.0085036848,
0.0181818083,
0.0354251415,
0.0396886691,
0.0095873419,
0.015136241,
-0.0194947533,
-0.0227358919,
0.0614218861,
-0.0899890885,
0.0256645493,
0.0101797711,
-0.0064444882,
0.0418544821,
0.0113283619,
-0.0264456663,
0.0396906324,
0.0537948161,
0.0552350655,
0.0023364662,
0.0068396577,
-0.0773098245,
0.0147824967,
0.0677894801,
-0.0255170949,
0.0073885312,
-0.011292926,
0.0437644571,
-0.0087176999,
0.074289985,
-0.0015243136,
0.0181484949,
0.0001292059,
-0.0451393612,
0.0175944064,
0.0433287434,
0.015235954,
0.0576349199,
-0.0130008683,
-0.0064475103,
0.0098426379,
0.0068536401,
-0.0042100237,
-0.0553344004,
-0.0126784034,
0.0027784831,
-0.0019369338,
-0.0222655497,
0.0152397612,
0.0417560339,
0.0031319752,
-0.0080006709,
-0.0223205928,
-0.0458827615,
0.0340814069,
0.009020458,
-0.0036707583,
-0.019105332,
0.0846804976,
-0.0285163596,
0.0611304045,
-0.0094143329,
0.0372237153,
-0.0322403163,
0.0133614382,
-0.0036529053,
0.0297237821,
-0.0186825115,
-0.0084544299,
-0.0149636241,
-0.0217912793,
-0.0367479846,
-0.0598589368,
0.0620890372,
0.0169305746,
0.0458107665,
-0.0349365696,
-0.0402799025,
0.0222465135,
0.0233269949,
-0.0014158868,
0.0275896471,
0.0235363357,
-0.001948392,
-0.0230713338,
0.0035454975,
-0.0239255875,
0.0391029306,
0.0644679293,
0.0048966007,
-0.0130927069,
-0.0290849023,
0.0324998274,
-0.0172964595,
-0.0245059524,
0.0341422334,
-0.0142643442,
-0.0237093549,
0.0028772724,
0.0268414225,
-0.0016952733,
0.0065927533,
0.0384244025,
-0.0500278324,
-0.0233510118,
-0.0133761922,
0.1312146336,
-0.0028036113,
0.0523698218,
-0.032417994,
0.0034090711,
-0.0554109365,
-0.0100579942,
0.0291867331,
-0.0812551826,
0.014593442,
0.0299364794,
0.0526763797,
-0.0216789041,
-0.008886829,
0.034913294,
-0.0232460555,
-0.0190154538,
-0.0362427346,
0.0479707569,
0.0189330913,
0.0086094672,
0.0204637125,
-0.012524154,
0.0425670035,
-0.0218463559,
-0.0174873061,
-0.0335240848,
0.001632059,
0.011883351,
0.1015802473,
0.0123302937,
0.0170641337,
-0.0352896899,
-0.0346894898,
-0.0173165295,
0.0241856016,
0.0285121351,
0.0460234173,
-0.046162039,
-0.0271978881,
0.0279341694,
-0.0146521954,
-0.0565862432,
0.0288139526,
0.0125032309,
-0.0539437644,
0.016230816,
-0.0089136725,
-0.0512721166,
0.0307624675,
0.0381954052,
-0.055546999,
0.0031330551,
0.0080428887,
-0.0484962128,
0.0011162983,
0.0298596881,
0.0386826321,
0.02026462,
0.038098976,
-0.0179695971,
0.0143388174,
-0.0073979287,
0.0433492213,
0.0388614722,
-0.0060782684,
-0.1071217209,
-0.0148740765,
-0.0254471544,
0.0408334844,
0.0315172449,
0.0831601992,
0.0378709398,
-0.0056621223,
0.0237624515,
0.0238401555,
-0.0566141792,
-0.030095458,
-0.0160420984,
-0.020413015,
0.0361131728,
0.0390131921,
0.041676037,
-0.0575667657,
0.066635333,
-0.0132516809,
0.011322977,
0.0193115659,
0.0166818164,
0.0181998219,
0.0042861546,
-0.0602163151,
-0.0506302863,
-0.0008356054,
0.0060925055,
-0.001580642,
-0.0036530399,
-0.0176090375,
0.0412374735,
-0.0193935223,
-0.0107897539,
0.0282279439,
0.0424270965,
-0.0283417515,
-0.0014503113,
-0.0431292318,
0.0185148418,
0.0020982402,
0.0120995836,
-0.0314953402,
0.0306750257,
-0.0484759547,
0.075605005,
0.0908514485,
0.0637551174,
-0.0281678177,
0.0136790611,
-0.0243512243,
-0.0178173333,
0.0056987833,
0.0226610322,
0.0241714139,
-0.0102051869,
0.0768607259,
-0.008139696,
-0.0042834468,
0.007832217,
0.0373168401,
-0.0644489229,
-0.0164690688,
-0.0116437012,
0.0080982056,
0.0708387792,
0.0178877711,
-0.0167731941,
0.0543824695,
-0.0005649613,
-0.0194176976,
0.0120787984,
0.0154967774,
0.067343384,
-0.0259729624,
0.0178818647,
-0.0514306612,
-0.0039514001,
0.0141988145,
0.0359816253,
0.0318471603,
0.0131005365,
0.0302580781,
0.01793487,
0.0151502993,
-0.0752409697,
-0.0075711692,
0.0086095557,
0.0112107331,
-0.0923678577,
0.0126285302,
0.0437582918,
0.0279404111,
-0.0263180565,
0.0673741996,
-0.0184753593,
-0.0282605588,
-0.0582784042,
-0.0755049288,
-0.0645948872,
0.0180224758,
-0.0076589645,
-0.0368366726,
0.003225073,
0.003859235,
0.0117338914,
0.0116902078,
-0.0146844937,
-0.0391569175,
0.0030114905,
0.0867594704,
-0.0176349226,
-0.022047177,
0.000142779,
-0.0058166636,
0.0354998186,
0.0096063046,
-0.051721748,
-0.0148052359,
-0.0473493226,
-0.0138085037,
-0.0038928364,
0.0404649042,
-0.0136215547,
-0.0160876624,
0.0045508631,
0.0165455732,
0.0245690402,
-0.0137463296,
-0.0143490126,
0.0489004105,
-0.007618729,
0.013098184,
-0.0165333468,
0.0037128639,
0.0240560081,
0.0031274466,
-0.0220504683,
-0.009630423,
0.0052703712,
0.0118696718,
-0.0389714167,
0.0348941982,
-0.049319502,
0.0310669728,
-0.0327139571,
-0.0093154451,
-0.0568460934,
0.0021918491,
0.0347320288,
-0.0229499787,
-0.0346216895,
-0.0369104072,
-0.0240732674,
0.0276923813,
0.007932663,
-0.0316629298,
0.008612927,
0.0288875028,
0.0194958728,
0.0303289313,
0.0257721078,
-0.0815239027,
0.0141039975,
0.0287495982,
-0.0085247755,
-0.0422706679,
-0.032758262,
0.0013562861,
-0.0280666314,
-0.0155163258,
-0.0121663809,
-0.0124342674,
0.0008412937,
-0.0596402325,
0.0182897989,
0.0131935896,
-0.0077363034,
0.026796937,
-0.0529447161,
-0.0276059862,
0.0405844562,
0.1034978777,
-0.025345685,
-0.0086945547,
-0.0810931772,
-0.0660639033,
0.0083226059,
-0.0109781083,
0.0082572084,
-0.0257879104,
0.0505764484,
-0.0598910116,
-0.012156209,
0.0256701652,
-0.0032051674,
-0.0631519482,
-0.014633731,
0.0193987545,
0.0431315899,
0.0232502017,
0.042109441,
-0.0313900486,
-0.0112701505,
0.00195342,
0.0226989463,
-0.0173707195,
-0.042170044,
0.0927327275,
0.0013127337,
-0.0023607726,
-0.0030884144,
-0.0632668063,
-0.0202251673,
-0.04478205,
-0.0389520675,
-0.0113397771,
-0.064132385,
-0.0382959321,
-0.0022750124,
-0.0282674097,
0.0094579086,
-0.0265140161,
-0.0120143564,
-0.0380917341,
-0.0150713716,
0.0279508065,
-0.0170909856,
-0.0043500201,
-0.061891418,
0.0188539773,
-0.00169329,
-0.0834842995,
0.0396455117,
0.0151927266,
0.0016230674,
-0.0024846788,
-0.0709565654,
-0.066467762,
-0.0128063429,
0.0393540561,
0.1364361346,
0.02395414,
-0.039146781,
-0.0511312187,
-0.0516306795,
0.0547939837,
-0.0240252037,
0.0209153052,
-0.0161553752,
-0.0247826371,
-0.0388940684,
-0.0053374968,
0.0074878926,
-0.0030177403,
0.0668811128,
-0.0537337847,
0.0763690844,
-0.0100072213,
0.0204034485,
-0.0001181394,
0.0246654954,
0.0054717604,
-0.01797924,
-0.0364473797,
0.0439445116,
0.002555555,
0.0191147011,
0.0251493566,
0.0132072866,
0.0253886245,
0.0155567219,
-0.0235048383,
-0.043217808,
-0.0441647805,
0.0752383545,
-0.0516910665,
0.063811563,
-0.0264530461,
-0.0356908999,
0.0078186849,
-0.0300883558,
0.0223260783,
-0.0252798218,
-0.0217667799,
0.0646872669,
0.0274949726,
0.0295558274,
-0.0574039742,
-0.0048787729,
0.0043744892,
-0.0212308001,
-0.0236126278,
0.051478222,
-0.0154227735,
0.0708517283,
0.05955844,
-0.0017255491,
-0.0066068093,
0.0200262871,
-0.0792938843,
0.0312115364,
0.0163448527,
-0.015407485,
0.0126376739,
-0.0311863832,
0.0362167917,
0.0395479798,
-0.0465480275,
-0.0448168404,
0.0396947414,
0.0258906521,
-0.0403905995,
-0.0749964863,
-0.0257858485,
-6.932457363e-33,
0.0218533128,
-0.0522436909,
0.0266301986,
-0.030218618,
-0.0117137525,
0.0155159449,
-0.0484002791,
0.0183182042,
-0.0123803066,
-0.0220947806,
0.0029768676,
-0.0110797277,
-0.0231995732,
-0.0328411311,
0.0565772541,
-0.0132771758,
0.0503894314,
0.0250377338,
-0.0426647477,
-0.0020383508,
-0.0084766755,
-0.0334001221,
0.0213551056,
-0.0786390752,
0.0093788337,
-0.016488377,
0.011380096,
-0.0203520469,
0.0281337779,
-0.032294631,
-0.0081656966,
0.0307725538,
-0.0101098232,
-0.0799262598,
-0.012215809,
-0.0003396512,
0.0230217222,
-0.050352823,
-0.0104970941,
-0.0312786847,
0.001620813,
-0.0590959564,
-0.0288420897,
0.0390142016,
-0.0223606508,
-0.0113049289,
0.0545168407,
0.0348334499,
0.0496661104,
0.0135653447,
0.0197582152,
-0.0115778642,
-0.0458092242,
-0.0093348604,
0.0327226147,
0.005184391,
0.0159769859,
0.0599612109,
0.0780470669,
0.1348487437,
-0.0228429902,
0.0052931514,
0.0172988735,
-0.0262671188,
-0.0148367872,
0.0149100423,
-0.0530649088,
0.0209970083,
-0.0694345534,
-0.0329303667,
0.0324018598,
0.0222709645,
0.0801156983,
0.0579026714,
0.0192727074,
0.021398114,
-0.0392142609,
0.0133264698,
0.0057055131,
-0.0395502113,
-0.0385324992,
-0.0038004515,
0.0334673189,
-0.0311022624,
-0.0269984026,
-0.0050411052,
0.0148658277,
0.0496633239,
-0.003584971,
-0.0327629223,
-0.0565468967,
-0.0075601847,
0.0074052252,
0.0169548411,
0.0140526658,
0.052548591,
-0.0174496267,
0.0215843674,
0.0032845321,
0.0098199686,
-0.1142645478,
0.0352814943,
-0.0240679961,
0.0279476214,
0.0127676977,
0.0210426506,
-0.1152112111,
-0.0117993196,
0.0182851199,
-0.003174071,
0.0108819604,
-0.0786238909,
0.0115534887,
-0.0394669548,
-0.0238288045,
0.0237541441,
0.0101279262,
-0.03823255,
0.0286681652,
0.0694320127,
0.0042394665,
-0.0521343909,
-0.048562713,
0.003386921,
0.0404623747,
-0.0257418845,
-0.0438505895,
-0.0497200005,
0.0074714082,
-0.0413432159,
-0.0229003374,
-0.0227110721,
2.989e-7,
-0.0233257972,
0.0489246473,
-0.0207893364,
0.0467913784,
-0.0109104654,
-0.000553133,
-0.0411203168,
-0.0079388479,
0.0429828651,
0.005312671,
-0.0090336306,
-0.0143392077,
-0.0145866787,
0.0431083217,
-0.0448007397,
-0.0317396708,
0.0073962822,
0.0401563421,
-0.0671945438,
0.0255633909,
0.0316781178,
-0.0350122303,
0.0226305202,
0.0323122479,
-0.0302891247,
0.0232006274,
-0.007824162,
0.0020269768,
0.0526607595,
0.0313186049,
-0.0493435003,
0.0325590409,
0.0118199056,
0.0207789391,
0.0135123283,
-0.0544024371,
0.0102710063,
-0.046094358,
0.0393312313,
0.0077120457,
0.0205381401,
0.0303135291,
0.0041005905,
-0.0470712483,
-0.0187119246,
-0.0371683128,
0.0438966192,
0.0540784411,
0.018000206,
0.0230814554,
-0.0129951639,
-0.0007316423,
-0.0023045391,
-0.0332708247,
-0.047951594,
0.0015037272,
-0.0072717704,
0.0172913577,
-0.0198072568,
-0.0568975918,
-0.0280011427,
-0.0626998395,
-0.0247127581,
-0.0138910292,
0.0151163461,
0.0159261096,
-0.0033573848,
2.119400014e-34,
0.02623621,
-0.0704673082,
-0.0331231691,
-0.0229688454,
-0.0196414124,
0.0048618582,
0.0142026069,
-0.0189302824,
0.0002023701,
0.0244308263,
-0.0149386944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02951v1 | Multi-Source (Pre-)Training for Cross-Domain Measurement, Unit and Context Extraction | 2023-08-05T20:33:39 | 2023-08-05T20:33:39 | Yueling Li, Sebastian Martschat, Simone Paolo Ponzetto | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a cross-domain approach for automated measurement and context
extraction based on pre-trained language models. We construct a multi-source,
multi-domain corpus and train an end-to-end extraction pipeline. We then apply
multi-source task-adaptive pre-training and fine-tuning to benchmark the
cross-domain generalization capability of our model. Further, we conceptualize
and apply a task-specific error analysis and derive insights for future work.
Our results suggest that multi-source training leads to the best overall
results, while single-source training yields the best results for the
respective individual domain. While our setup is successful at extracting
quantity values and units, more research is needed to improve the extraction of
contextual entities. We make the cross-domain corpus used in this work
available online. | [
-0.0325395986,
0.035126619,
0.0019561644,
0.0447242446,
-0.0100051239,
0.0122384224,
0.0455470383,
-0.0312323291,
-0.0504998043,
-0.0569503531,
-0.0584247671,
-0.0764594525,
-0.0328990035,
0.0271628238,
0.0261721443,
-0.004163282,
0.0138889095,
-0.0066154702,
-0.0087061878,
0.0491614267,
-0.0072823144,
0.0085453121,
-0.0225528311,
0.0036326833,
-0.0323511399,
0.0062357509,
0.02047351,
-0.0449774079,
0.0253352262,
-0.0595069416,
0.0331667177,
0.0137365861,
0.0433962755,
-0.0151787885,
0.000002183,
-0.0479805171,
-0.0759050623,
0.0187495667,
-0.0222045295,
-0.0286709778,
0.0336698145,
-0.0537822768,
0.0058976486,
0.0081831869,
-0.0453378037,
-0.0386271663,
0.0273943245,
0.0048379824,
0.0064146966,
0.0874959454,
-0.0257205497,
-0.0180671848,
-0.0219933596,
-0.0478857644,
-0.0103913257,
-0.0523834489,
0.0325593315,
0.0507473275,
0.0038649472,
0.0331733413,
-0.0133790979,
0.0191906691,
0.0094256317,
0.0448965803,
-0.0235576928,
-0.0010061745,
0.0031497676,
0.0203590095,
-0.0209283624,
0.0945506617,
0.0243125744,
0.0180089213,
0.052137997,
-0.027275702,
-0.0324066877,
-0.0216925703,
-0.0204934143,
-0.0082712453,
0.0172017384,
-0.0021779784,
-0.0653687045,
0.023350006,
0.0052108527,
-0.012225817,
-0.0430726856,
0.0299178902,
-0.0100196013,
-0.0273971967,
0.0023157846,
0.0357408337,
-0.0200640224,
-0.0264819581,
0.0129208909,
-0.0148115484,
0.0194461979,
0.0400617421,
-0.0335742906,
-0.0859161019,
-0.0215087626,
-0.0291367173,
-0.0157182515,
0.0179330613,
-0.0603648722,
0.0535024144,
0.0015640352,
0.0580635592,
-0.012304523,
0.0068298057,
-0.0572290942,
0.0043635508,
-0.0305506345,
0.0200676415,
-0.0008085984,
0.0234461278,
-0.045062881,
-0.0053931908,
-0.0566301383,
0.0079035312,
-0.0036910595,
-0.015214988,
0.0312178209,
-0.0159100462,
-0.0264271405,
-0.0150396274,
0.0063786474,
0.0434207991,
-0.0404327661,
0.0442246012,
-0.0175182503,
-0.0598421618,
-0.0335343033,
0.0131337782,
0.0249736831,
-0.044161018,
0.0237502325,
0.0922679603,
0.0167888645,
-0.0463441759,
-0.042500142,
-0.0403430536,
-0.0052435216,
-0.0294063371,
0.0116151469,
-0.0283371434,
0.0768404752,
0.0174591206,
-0.0024052102,
-0.0668005869,
-0.0016047416,
-0.036820665,
-0.0083576972,
0.0651552379,
0.0223896615,
-0.0127805602,
-0.0061667087,
-0.0226464886,
0.0227625817,
0.1205976605,
0.0416322015,
-0.0163000636,
0.0465263277,
-0.0058111055,
-0.0603038259,
0.0639463961,
0.0257623512,
-0.0254770406,
-0.0322264172,
-0.0045367316,
0.024787901,
-0.0127906399,
0.0352000371,
-0.0183640849,
-0.0197800007,
0.0274998341,
0.0175988115,
0.031471882,
0.0414199382,
-0.0324465334,
0.083447963,
-0.0170215461,
0.0038288531,
-0.0082495669,
-0.0237070583,
-0.0366677269,
0.0289473757,
0.0275665373,
0.01098572,
0.0326256454,
-0.0230800509,
-0.0350509025,
-0.0005118511,
-0.0485454723,
-0.0346877426,
0.0217945781,
0.1360733807,
-0.0033509827,
-0.0248312242,
0.0477601886,
0.0290731266,
-0.0515573919,
0.045293469,
0.0342079066,
-0.0072502927,
0.0055095241,
0.0070905839,
-0.0694609359,
0.0163003746,
-0.0057741832,
0.0392540619,
-0.0182620492,
0.0407919362,
-0.0162395481,
0.0700738654,
-0.0436631404,
-0.0484389663,
-0.0237460826,
0.0072321524,
0.0115997586,
0.0071388553,
0.0200113952,
0.0421125181,
-0.0663352609,
0.055620566,
0.0420894511,
-0.0444693454,
-0.072057344,
0.0091950195,
0.0088919057,
0.0123244915,
0.0415429994,
-0.0286346748,
0.0241132304,
0.0089709703,
-0.0305780619,
-0.0032948472,
0.0383918285,
-0.0140281105,
0.0152380913,
0.0364120901,
0.0132818688,
0.0133650079,
-0.0462967493,
-0.0250370074,
-0.0173561182,
0.004997611,
0.0478427149,
0.0502275862,
-0.0245190915,
-0.0185809266,
0.0225698538,
0.0141068837,
-0.0367047712,
0.0606060065,
0.0272123087,
-0.0030287819,
-0.0221755523,
0.0049339747,
0.0148258135,
0.0152534666,
0.0008891848,
-0.0609314926,
-0.0172432587,
0.0285485927,
0.021658374,
-0.0131031079,
-0.0458376296,
0.0023990886,
-0.0620531067,
0.0341552719,
-0.012366253,
0.0706727132,
0.0438643768,
0.0532478727,
-0.0305618551,
-0.021715384,
-0.0014496612,
-0.0434494279,
-0.0103311082,
0.0166093055,
0.0130886436,
0.0434670113,
0.0547589846,
-0.0373194665,
-0.0079982392,
-0.0543791987,
0.0465731695,
-0.0072996411,
0.0138377026,
-0.0341418274,
0.0941509977,
0.0068784044,
0.051804617,
0.0090906043,
-0.007178029,
-0.0041232039,
-0.0497510806,
0.0461616814,
0.056593392,
-0.0351334848,
0.0579206012,
0.0195016041,
-0.0520125106,
-0.0800218135,
0.0071732504,
-0.0258502327,
0.0016263805,
0.0027431259,
0.0411924459,
0.0251444448,
0.0733602047,
0.0109045738,
0.00446781,
-0.0067004212,
0.0270282496,
-0.051109504,
-0.0465005748,
-0.0438010283,
0.0611978509,
-0.0127460388,
0.0406787321,
0.0288937893,
0.0108510097,
0.0315048359,
-0.0227523595,
-0.0033751989,
-0.0510663465,
-0.0067550289,
-0.0438174047,
0.0305510908,
-0.0219065603,
-0.0038373533,
0.0124125648,
-0.0110387914,
-0.0043814247,
0.0167605244,
0.029788062,
-0.0064189686,
0.0304175597,
-0.0648017079,
0.0235257111,
-0.0169361047,
-0.0359817781,
-0.0265613925,
-0.0124109183,
-0.0114724385,
-0.0025626994,
-0.0107551357,
-0.006634417,
-0.0279368516,
0.0195150096,
0.0182289165,
0.0417319462,
-0.0172814373,
-0.0045562228,
-0.0137815513,
0.0580516048,
0.0283516329,
-0.0099821528,
-0.0174267124,
-0.0291457158,
-0.0169507191,
0.0432322808,
0.0472841822,
-0.0025551473,
-0.0399469882,
0.0155284004,
-0.0132384608,
-0.001514199,
0.0230210945,
0.0257013161,
0.0680681393,
-0.0436244719,
-0.0172555633,
0.1027364358,
0.0118175447,
-0.007691442,
-0.0322919413,
0.0256148651,
-0.0543249995,
0.0104309535,
0.0134442355,
-0.087127775,
-0.0273730457,
-0.0265496802,
-0.0025031685,
0.0206594002,
-0.0426374525,
-0.0286182631,
-0.1221461967,
-0.0431005992,
0.0072285375,
-0.0635162368,
-0.0271596853,
-0.0434834324,
0.0472170822,
-0.0469239466,
-0.0141749587,
-0.0421325862,
-0.0060426495,
0.0166093074,
0.0358360037,
-0.0040443619,
-0.0900398269,
0.001135568,
-0.0507909693,
0.0079843262,
0.0522723682,
-0.0115887383,
-0.0278064236,
0.0028325107,
0.0376227647,
-0.0361302122,
0.0035870599,
0.0099423742,
0.0399922431,
-0.0118726827,
-0.0386835635,
0.0209922958,
0.0313818567,
-0.033181373,
-0.0239551496,
0.011602086,
0.0501128845,
0.0300365258,
0.0579319708,
-0.0094717909,
-0.0170662552,
0.0644312352,
0.0577935539,
-0.0092465011,
-0.0441210531,
0.0028838639,
-0.0208298061,
-0.0159127638,
-0.0634228885,
-0.0231753923,
-0.0180486832,
-0.0507938936,
-0.0082124909,
-0.0305394791,
-0.0428448021,
0.0628988221,
0.0514670946,
0.022627648,
-0.0450026616,
0.03804655,
0.0359198563,
-0.0363649167,
0.0435236581,
-0.0275809038,
0.0443345867,
-0.0278221481,
0.0134483064,
0.0504532233,
0.0039593922,
-0.0334953815,
0.0552069657,
-0.0875629857,
-0.0491337553,
0.0010237179,
0.0460057184,
0.0142990258,
0.0087244362,
-0.0175250843,
0.0146360565,
-0.0174016505,
-0.0200661905,
-0.0914440602,
0.0142419655,
0.0390410833,
0.0008895739,
-0.0052506994,
-0.0106606046,
-0.0511065088,
0.0536272936,
0.0119579267,
0.0458679833,
-0.0387801081,
-0.0268095881,
0.0109646982,
-0.0168731809,
0.072867237,
0.0362661555,
0.0269535892,
-0.0320467129,
-0.0233106948,
-0.0445470251,
0.0119499611,
-0.0446971692,
0.0116170719,
-0.0046868105,
-0.0046512634,
-0.0341126919,
0.029501278,
0.0122286286,
0.0157546401,
-0.0344103575,
0.0370957814,
0.0182384085,
0.0382946134,
-0.0017415085,
-0.0052685891,
0.0130545851,
-0.023845572,
0.0192213207,
0.0331188589,
-0.0329374932,
0.024357982,
-0.0124146184,
-0.0067769033,
-0.0164473169,
0.0402765051,
-0.0209993012,
0.0460104905,
-0.0296072979,
0.0076394062,
-0.003574999,
-0.0338691361,
0.030300932,
0.0177498441,
0.0042026155,
-0.0163195711,
0.0361738168,
-0.0084705083,
0.0819950849,
0.0316546299,
0.0141894417,
-0.0020624341,
-0.0094249947,
0.0746489093,
-0.0072761988,
0.0620344691,
0.0031287563,
0.0134485923,
-0.0401279591,
0.014990503,
-0.0347476266,
0.0118691484,
-0.0213252623,
-0.0173084885,
-0.0572902597,
-0.0504215471,
-0.0076244902,
0.0124304341,
-0.0308067966,
0.0447209962,
0.0141913248,
0.0652646795,
-0.0343161151,
0.0324920081,
-0.0115369996,
-0.0134300934,
-0.0128303822,
0.0014932971,
0.0028974758,
-5.888757969e-33,
-0.037146695,
-0.0158069041,
0.0233808532,
-0.018713193,
-0.0112063056,
0.0240197927,
0.0168841332,
-0.0015947275,
-0.0099131763,
-0.0273392461,
-0.0042448803,
-0.0095809763,
0.0408783555,
-0.0253411513,
0.0410181656,
0.0018122768,
0.0411966331,
-0.02928501,
0.0026469249,
-0.0301913992,
0.0583182015,
0.0603947788,
0.1049311906,
-0.1283155829,
0.0546131097,
0.0500380918,
0.0013072279,
0.0113435388,
0.0897648707,
0.0535155013,
0.0027598396,
0.024503991,
-0.00030537,
-0.0866809711,
-0.0379089154,
0.0535923503,
-0.1103419662,
-0.0810716227,
0.0245618392,
0.0104606571,
0.0180112235,
-0.0115554612,
-0.0005775965,
-0.0120731229,
0.0277266167,
-0.0302808881,
0.0355038792,
-0.0213683657,
0.0158265606,
-0.0623780452,
-0.0403008498,
0.0222650636,
-0.005051564,
0.0185257178,
0.0861002877,
0.0471266061,
0.0147887366,
0.0002431374,
-0.0382005237,
0.0261848792,
-0.0188362952,
0.0200679712,
0.0288522299,
0.0224150717,
0.0008352422,
0.0220751334,
0.0029980876,
-0.0397706516,
0.0186131056,
-0.0609156005,
0.0303448625,
0.0264217816,
-0.0075094188,
0.051647421,
-0.0033788381,
-0.0338290222,
-0.1025065184,
0.0404604785,
0.0189378411,
-0.0213805381,
-0.038323693,
-0.022698123,
-0.0333227664,
0.01660062,
-0.0005264428,
-0.0155333811,
-0.0148290526,
-0.0414250605,
0.0361919627,
-0.001522318,
-0.0016518247,
0.0420863144,
0.0349355116,
-0.0414060056,
0.0062399847,
0.005673259,
0.0176839102,
-0.0043023704,
-0.0061125713,
-0.016841637,
-0.0457780436,
-0.027738167,
-0.0065650637,
0.0563638099,
0.0322735272,
-0.0232955273,
-0.0035576643,
0.005583596,
-0.0469874516,
-0.0162588228,
-0.0311076958,
-0.0002495542,
0.0158507023,
0.0626429915,
0.0022953521,
0.0163342915,
-0.0297605004,
0.0533994511,
0.0208930168,
-0.0538303889,
-0.0204625838,
0.0173375104,
0.0311823152,
0.040183872,
-0.0313799046,
-0.0612197965,
-0.0180767775,
0.0235318113,
0.0909630135,
-0.0095219612,
-0.0078008706,
-0.0092201754,
2.712e-7,
0.0640277714,
-0.0058257673,
0.0313472785,
-0.0073802564,
-0.0053118314,
0.0204530209,
-0.0272314157,
0.0297037121,
0.0013404095,
0.0104380138,
0.0118621783,
-0.0299640018,
0.0169557296,
0.0345400572,
-0.0604862422,
-0.0368088782,
0.009976388,
-0.0146233803,
-0.0144818015,
0.0251905397,
0.0104769273,
0.0592656285,
0.0184490718,
0.0390166715,
-0.045610901,
-0.0412198082,
0.0520080477,
-0.0459316112,
-0.0047047907,
0.0367897823,
-0.0287476555,
0.022399595,
-0.0242206212,
0.015073467,
-0.0458510108,
0.0543804802,
0.0423370004,
0.0745003,
0.0349893384,
-0.0161070861,
-0.0028388838,
-0.0151355555,
-0.0132887205,
0.0033834076,
0.054005418,
-0.0766199455,
-0.0170803647,
-0.0598189943,
0.007011991,
0.0102799088,
-0.0297574326,
0.0155838747,
0.0212781448,
0.0048326203,
0.0250871666,
0.0086972797,
-0.0420702659,
-0.0644293576,
-0.0361139067,
0.0420448333,
0.0032500084,
-0.0355329104,
0.0181361493,
-0.0380830243,
0.0177728031,
-0.0435907431,
-0.0001348615,
2.345804129e-34,
0.0045599258,
0.0015440373,
0.0075814864,
0.0341946632,
0.0078984816,
-0.0371781886,
-0.0765323862,
-0.0035897149,
-0.0075906012,
-0.0553545989,
0.0137153752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02926v1 | Towards Consistency Filtering-Free Unsupervised Learning for Dense Retrieval | 2023-08-05T17:33:51 | 2023-08-05T17:33:51 | Haoxiang Shi, Sumio Fujita, Tetsuya Sakai | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NI | Domain transfer is a prevalent challenge in modern neural Information
Retrieval (IR). To overcome this problem, previous research has utilized
domain-specific manual annotations and synthetic data produced by consistency
filtering to finetune a general ranker and produce a domain-specific ranker.
However, training such consistency filters are computationally expensive, which
significantly reduces the model efficiency. In addition, consistency filtering
often struggles to identify retrieval intentions and recognize query and corpus
distributions in a target domain. In this study, we evaluate a more efficient
solution: replacing the consistency filter with either direct pseudo-labeling,
pseudo-relevance feedback, or unsupervised keyword generation methods for
achieving consistent filtering-free unsupervised dense retrieval. Our extensive
experimental evaluations demonstrate that, on average, TextRank-based pseudo
relevance feedback outperforms other methods. Furthermore, we analyzed the
training and inference efficiency of the proposed paradigm. The results
indicate that filtering-free unsupervised learning can continuously improve
training and inference efficiency while maintaining retrieval performance. In
some cases, it can even improve performance based on particular datasets. | [
0.056106884,
0.031533774,
0.0326725505,
-0.0010214157,
0.0060962355,
-0.021321116,
0.0000731272,
0.0292743407,
0.0381959453,
-0.0337910503,
-0.0528200194,
-0.0180973634,
-0.0676509589,
0.0440910459,
-0.0182862543,
-0.0119005926,
0.0602707528,
0.0334130563,
0.0092703132,
0.0182979517,
-0.0143399537,
-0.008811689,
0.0210068431,
-0.0170943849,
0.0162626244,
0.0238635987,
0.0005213289,
0.0256659724,
-0.0111058652,
0.0014538112,
0.0174053703,
0.0150526688,
0.0507729687,
0.0026633556,
0.0000018495,
-0.063722901,
-0.0691316426,
-0.011584105,
-0.0002604044,
0.011843442,
0.0115369102,
-0.00356949,
0.0487791225,
-0.015528976,
-0.0399665125,
-0.0010109143,
0.0173696298,
0.0558384992,
0.0508633852,
0.0596723743,
-0.0251228344,
-0.012465274,
0.0008580331,
-0.0531934276,
-0.0165831465,
-0.0742291808,
0.0350636914,
-0.0106989667,
-0.0147061851,
0.062869288,
-0.0065694712,
0.043073684,
-0.0282969512,
-0.0172013398,
0.0831578523,
-0.0093145799,
-0.0495404564,
-0.0427285619,
0.0395474508,
0.0650535524,
0.0172055364,
-0.037544325,
0.0293983184,
-0.0040515671,
-0.0264937896,
0.0325919166,
-0.0186869577,
0.0116065964,
0.0014599971,
0.0114313094,
-0.0389155075,
0.0397255085,
0.0304566007,
0.0144554395,
-0.0552410223,
0.0616598204,
-0.0037531243,
-0.0350284427,
0.0246355031,
0.0199542008,
-0.0700647905,
-0.0141333332,
0.0315996185,
-0.007196282,
-0.0121374046,
0.0071805483,
-0.0175663903,
0.0069430559,
0.0006941786,
-0.0528786741,
-0.0154369958,
0.0160355475,
-0.0315659828,
0.0331057496,
0.0035464934,
0.0185690299,
-0.0266719759,
0.0462354198,
-0.0422412008,
-0.0150977476,
-0.041502919,
-0.0012668018,
0.0042725396,
0.083535254,
-0.0320401601,
-0.0133300722,
-0.0192299336,
0.0034642764,
-0.0010055768,
-0.0365560986,
0.010801971,
0.0362330861,
-0.0723697171,
0.0078138271,
-0.0467741936,
0.0410113074,
0.005901054,
0.0030635826,
-0.0052613406,
0.0085313106,
0.0081523573,
0.0374243371,
0.034861099,
-0.0616922155,
0.0274671726,
0.0166807249,
-0.051195018,
-0.0236473531,
-0.0199368224,
-0.0267369449,
0.0247249547,
-0.0485162176,
0.0243601222,
-0.0017350117,
0.0042234235,
-0.0238402225,
-0.0103612468,
-0.1101476029,
0.0202596299,
0.0299269017,
-0.0368618816,
0.0703746378,
-0.0249122512,
-0.0250243526,
0.0269120485,
0.0452264622,
0.0101361582,
0.0179555863,
-0.0187228639,
0.0357125811,
0.0646979362,
0.0275506843,
-0.0163795557,
-0.0398066565,
0.0602951013,
-0.0112056611,
-0.0490288585,
0.0239799377,
-0.0572115779,
-0.0064228075,
0.012946398,
0.0340902805,
-0.0206015874,
-0.0004847131,
-0.023828499,
-0.0197225567,
0.0740459114,
-0.0108307581,
0.0143714091,
0.041576542,
-0.0193531048,
0.0325027071,
-0.0269225109,
0.0295952335,
0.0063702562,
-0.0015103603,
0.0628816634,
-0.037267644,
-0.0362182632,
-0.0450326465,
0.0199517608,
0.0575166941,
-0.0357604586,
0.0064577893,
0.0717569664,
0.0308048241,
0.0149089135,
0.0282315407,
0.0273114443,
-0.0220042728,
0.0191926546,
-0.0349015035,
0.0102165248,
0.0409283862,
0.0297680385,
-0.0481496751,
0.0317476876,
-0.0084519414,
0.0463872217,
0.0304830708,
-0.0099529391,
-0.0242534615,
0.0249175411,
-0.0540894233,
-0.0641687736,
0.0120457197,
0.0178975798,
-0.0133854626,
0.0169175956,
0.0372255631,
0.0693681315,
-0.0868405253,
-0.006236807,
0.0192674976,
-0.0105725415,
-0.0708560944,
0.0420815423,
0.0042391978,
0.0154070118,
0.0078228405,
-0.030497618,
-0.0030757084,
0.0540970303,
-0.0056253509,
0.0032387553,
-0.0667026863,
-0.0722119734,
0.0258939173,
0.017941311,
0.0079714619,
0.0424493365,
0.0725566298,
0.0106253419,
-0.0341644995,
-0.0164418519,
0.0197179783,
0.0151341138,
-0.0653250217,
-0.0106890788,
-0.0122773964,
0.0004607314,
-0.0638153926,
0.0477159992,
0.0498311855,
0.0321866535,
0.0146024153,
-0.0126990257,
0.0271568522,
-0.0355807878,
-0.0121845184,
0.0376628824,
-0.0322351567,
0.0158189181,
0.0491342284,
0.0221598335,
-0.0385765247,
0.057150051,
-0.0205555689,
0.0028784764,
-0.0238178857,
-0.0226536468,
-0.0072083762,
0.0289946515,
0.0307526812,
-0.020174915,
-0.0131213143,
-0.014148674,
-0.0209479425,
0.0019536661,
-0.0000870052,
0.0368734486,
0.041173663,
-0.0526294783,
-0.0409458131,
0.0198451206,
0.0177097805,
-0.0207673833,
-0.0817829967,
-0.0288579483,
0.037974935,
-0.0506691262,
0.0569682792,
-0.0085829142,
0.0301381443,
-0.005927159,
-0.0481926948,
-0.0330558084,
0.0368398987,
0.037554469,
-0.0157060325,
0.0267864112,
-0.005797145,
-0.1131871492,
0.0253055487,
-0.0481569618,
-0.002447072,
0.0502059422,
0.0010914153,
0.0221115295,
0.0022692508,
-0.0173195191,
-0.0284488015,
-0.0506675206,
-0.0092670219,
0.0067231697,
-0.0226658303,
-0.0656079873,
0.0538044162,
0.005697058,
0.0370978415,
0.0071700644,
-0.038941782,
0.0321954936,
0.0105548473,
0.004632357,
-0.0482241213,
-0.0363384411,
-0.0094493311,
0.0371363349,
-0.0442391261,
0.0242688525,
0.004900936,
0.0055452134,
-0.0175456218,
-0.0025284728,
0.0234646499,
-0.0447646938,
0.0288599692,
-0.0120397219,
0.0701772645,
0.0125436438,
-0.0212390739,
-0.064500466,
-0.0646879524,
0.018693896,
-0.0047760569,
-0.025866583,
-0.0182813499,
-0.0293369181,
0.0182575919,
0.0018845327,
0.056904722,
0.005132128,
-0.0494300239,
0.0302944686,
0.0233785845,
0.0522003733,
-0.0027552699,
-0.0161007084,
0.0329191498,
-0.0130302403,
0.0481387228,
0.0182755515,
-0.0123041281,
0.0137194796,
0.0043041343,
0.06582883,
0.0030367167,
-0.0113473302,
0.0032386666,
0.0202413425,
0.0522479936,
-0.0554462671,
0.0636682287,
0.0274618864,
-0.0575423054,
-0.0217442401,
-0.0247540977,
0.0195919573,
0.0347764343,
0.0517871566,
-0.0184329748,
-0.0277996417,
0.0101921204,
0.0878542289,
0.0241338443,
-0.0197655596,
-0.0295873024,
-0.0683007911,
0.0264561977,
-0.0168075021,
0.0094092889,
-0.0191799346,
-0.0425809175,
0.0183482692,
-0.0167624038,
-0.0181013662,
0.0048212917,
-0.0150825875,
-0.0344201736,
0.0321541019,
0.0345892943,
-0.0855927542,
-0.0001008126,
-0.0364430323,
0.0115127815,
0.051192034,
0.0013047796,
0.0215327572,
-0.0503904894,
0.031238623,
-0.0210553929,
-0.0212402269,
-0.0427939855,
0.0381579064,
-0.0657391697,
-0.0231185984,
-0.0240284186,
-0.0173256435,
-0.0054342337,
-0.00710133,
-0.0245381631,
0.0179588441,
-0.0164066721,
0.0028077669,
-0.0293558091,
-0.0282022692,
-0.0114715016,
0.0519014224,
-0.0503957719,
0.0077982252,
0.0427915044,
0.0272964556,
0.0201492868,
0.0013143884,
-0.0633262247,
-0.0092708739,
-0.0631514117,
0.0236215927,
-0.0586395301,
-0.0217634831,
-0.0307951123,
0.0496092737,
-0.0114308177,
0.0278271493,
-0.0100504803,
-0.0423303284,
-0.0478342921,
0.0198467504,
-0.0608326979,
-0.0027194405,
-0.0342080444,
-0.0094598867,
0.0231238808,
-0.043320965,
-0.0273616482,
-0.0125032393,
0.0242046993,
-0.0322987214,
-0.0122113759,
0.0048062536,
0.0137807075,
0.066838555,
-0.0098903598,
-0.0033548267,
0.0129640074,
0.08489912,
-0.0369936377,
0.0047524604,
0.0441345759,
-0.0489110053,
-0.0185819156,
0.0225179382,
-0.064483352,
0.0310926493,
0.0253258366,
0.0506918617,
-0.0148430523,
-0.0289758258,
0.0340951718,
0.02282786,
0.0852860361,
0.0231529959,
0.0200228319,
-0.0520294867,
0.0031988572,
0.0083875842,
-0.0263972115,
-0.0682422817,
0.0245416723,
0.0572090112,
-0.0049026427,
-0.0226603933,
0.0729343668,
-0.0517655872,
0.0387752429,
-0.0373103023,
-0.0522096418,
-0.0489630364,
-0.0041988818,
-0.0238045026,
0.0182792228,
-0.0324295461,
0.0199884474,
0.0536524095,
0.0686835051,
-0.0583777539,
-0.0034849436,
0.0387825891,
0.0032306842,
-0.015625637,
0.0084935185,
-0.0734416768,
0.0333502404,
-0.0741198957,
-0.0308068134,
0.0465099029,
-0.0509439446,
0.0307820402,
0.0049209599,
-0.0061175348,
-0.0301023908,
-0.0131053943,
0.033115536,
0.0361516327,
-0.0019696741,
0.0195588395,
0.002314351,
0.0558909103,
0.0670025349,
0.045660086,
-0.0112183467,
-0.0443233848,
-0.0250973981,
-0.0440472886,
0.0039103734,
0.0383297056,
0.1113674492,
-0.0119004473,
-0.0283337627,
0.0238796417,
-0.0208824966,
0.0306748357,
-0.0542471223,
-0.0228752512,
-0.0118565159,
0.0444513783,
0.0760408789,
-0.0043729353,
-0.010965514,
-0.0263998508,
-0.0643280074,
0.0238917731,
0.0209196806,
-0.0175660159,
-7.039561796e-33,
0.0009448988,
-0.002359878,
-0.0122388145,
-0.0410643555,
-0.0305406172,
-0.0184684098,
-0.0153655643,
-0.0591939725,
-0.0255796164,
-0.0015885325,
-0.0148874968,
0.0473428629,
0.0229059272,
0.0050304802,
-0.0124004642,
-0.0014701687,
0.0631255656,
0.0471671298,
-0.0218766425,
-0.0010722216,
0.0433270186,
0.0727262869,
0.0189194214,
-0.1287859082,
0.0240181778,
-0.0016548662,
0.0088321213,
0.0345520489,
0.0240915641,
0.037555363,
-0.0167061612,
0.0512707867,
0.0195341762,
-0.0481134243,
0.0269180313,
-0.0198996644,
-0.0842309445,
-0.0488126762,
-0.0011597693,
-0.0444149412,
-0.0232418031,
0.0202140547,
0.0340280831,
-0.0212311763,
0.0046865572,
-0.0082515683,
0.0336608775,
0.0005748894,
-0.0456874035,
-0.0456219018,
-0.0220467187,
0.0288442783,
0.0315642506,
0.0078441966,
0.0190163758,
0.0491898209,
0.0086868731,
0.0428853445,
-0.07282231,
0.0089810826,
-0.0677122772,
0.0517537147,
0.0317174979,
0.0184273757,
-0.0335714407,
0.0381610468,
0.0031166645,
-0.0217906702,
-0.0011927974,
-0.0561284758,
0.023018878,
0.0361277424,
0.0075476025,
0.0525989793,
0.0457240008,
-0.0209124256,
-0.065174289,
0.0444222465,
-0.0972927064,
0.0231891423,
-0.0077833305,
0.0490076207,
-0.0533776619,
-0.0486077294,
-0.001439989,
0.017961191,
-0.0543890595,
-0.0040641357,
0.0517921597,
0.0699179918,
-0.0575272776,
0.0646819249,
0.035521917,
-0.0145230414,
-0.0173520464,
-0.0258671101,
0.0030680909,
-0.0159527808,
0.0037127486,
-0.0124005796,
-0.0569103435,
-0.0287294779,
0.0400375724,
0.0075989915,
-0.0372408926,
0.0081515657,
-0.0043938672,
0.0114726564,
-0.0197532773,
-0.0191446207,
-0.0021641795,
-0.0233210232,
-0.0274238642,
0.0208291113,
0.0006936697,
0.0383246429,
-0.0130228652,
0.1048206761,
0.0362465829,
0.0189864933,
0.0031971717,
0.0020456377,
0.0382513218,
0.0250012297,
0.0134517634,
0.0239246413,
-0.0205798522,
0.0532662459,
0.0148392851,
-0.0712850243,
0.000404365,
0.0196684264,
2.758e-7,
0.0152586661,
0.0101715615,
0.0016669048,
-0.0250311643,
-0.0508992113,
0.0257783867,
0.0155012654,
0.0292017534,
0.0134536121,
-0.0446194038,
0.00862893,
0.0223231129,
0.0229009744,
-0.0065621776,
-0.0658525601,
-0.0567780584,
-0.0359095261,
-0.0264958702,
-0.0072716302,
-0.0347005799,
0.0825338885,
0.0554366857,
0.0015269367,
-0.0266712755,
0.0229289494,
-0.030580245,
0.0364984237,
0.0088508036,
0.0368958227,
-0.0107360585,
0.0398723371,
0.0270003378,
0.0034072383,
0.019697316,
-0.0347363912,
0.0140664894,
0.0694577768,
0.0554851741,
-0.0148265483,
-0.0081450455,
-0.0113748079,
0.0260335505,
0.0388899632,
-0.0058939853,
0.0752189681,
-0.0544433966,
0.0181886666,
0.0564579591,
-0.0178516917,
0.0205332171,
0.0101715503,
0.01031911,
-0.0162723362,
-0.0285442993,
0.0112877302,
0.0707534105,
-0.053976126,
-0.0783710405,
0.0303630792,
-0.0684243366,
-0.030429624,
0.0001771946,
-0.0385854729,
0.0020006897,
0.0135510508,
-0.0030177012,
0.0044684731,
1.938934999e-34,
0.0071750986,
0.036846105,
0.0359560996,
-0.0598274842,
-0.0212397166,
-0.0049386546,
-0.0275649708,
-0.0035892422,
-0.001713275,
-0.0708210915,
-0.0013197103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02903v1 | LaDA: Latent Dialogue Action For Zero-shot Cross-lingual Neural Network Language Modeling | 2023-08-05T15:51:45 | 2023-08-05T15:51:45 | Zhanyu Ma, Jian Ye, Shuang Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual adaptation has proven effective in spoken language
understanding (SLU) systems with limited resources. Existing methods are
frequently unsatisfactory for intent detection and slot filling, particularly
for distant languages that differ significantly from the source language in
scripts, morphology, and syntax. Latent Dialogue Action (LaDA) layer is
proposed to optimize decoding strategy in order to address the aforementioned
issues. The model consists of an additional layer of latent dialogue action. It
enables our model to improve a system's capability of handling conversations
with complex multilingual intent and slot values of distant languages. To the
best of our knowledge, this is the first exhaustive investigation of the use of
latent variables for optimizing cross-lingual SLU policy during the decode
stage. LaDA obtains state-of-the-art results on public datasets for both
zero-shot and few-shot adaptation. | [
0.0177216623,
0.0365278758,
0.0068310355,
0.0720822886,
0.0075656921,
0.0171725992,
0.0170318298,
-0.0307292603,
-0.018425297,
-0.0245675612,
-0.0542016923,
-0.0484704226,
-0.0086242706,
0.0310125183,
0.0031566974,
0.0005046742,
0.0406129323,
-0.0483478233,
0.0356180258,
-0.0071260063,
-0.015937075,
0.0240222737,
-0.0560508966,
0.0203071702,
0.0282805003,
-0.0401198864,
-0.0471231118,
0.0001019883,
0.0107739475,
0.0097961016,
-0.0170513485,
0.0283494927,
0.0217227768,
0.0558137707,
0.00000196,
-0.0308580082,
0.0085167931,
-0.0355225019,
-0.0673534051,
0.0196945686,
0.0050955638,
-0.0488078184,
-0.0146818189,
0.0012468449,
-0.0188704431,
-0.049185019,
0.0660035461,
0.0255940109,
0.0370905325,
0.0792392716,
-0.0082138479,
-0.0296225678,
0.0096199317,
-0.0261898916,
0.0148136439,
-0.0670102686,
0.0049696672,
0.0289725587,
-0.0075117555,
-0.0076304786,
-0.0629968867,
0.0459290892,
0.0011865896,
-0.0356786177,
-0.0354310386,
0.0125027755,
-0.0140045108,
-0.042492073,
-0.0181683265,
0.0925744548,
0.0048571336,
-0.0163546763,
-0.0214858036,
-0.0449870415,
-0.0417482294,
-0.0384227782,
-0.0517359935,
0.0180604644,
0.0411685519,
0.0092020687,
0.0548485443,
0.0138957538,
0.020700708,
0.0022079051,
-0.0340230837,
0.0407198556,
0.0120916106,
-0.0036773756,
-0.0365310423,
-0.0193883497,
0.0529253408,
-0.0600863248,
0.0025206967,
0.0524280854,
-0.0510052405,
0.0382364132,
-0.0037677565,
-0.0119733233,
-0.0075723277,
-0.0462788045,
0.0208063293,
0.0825598985,
-0.0287737846,
0.0696561858,
0.0022875343,
0.0600286648,
-0.0167791583,
-0.0116563318,
-0.0441957191,
-0.0163872559,
-0.0228734221,
0.0099476408,
-0.0261596553,
0.0053463904,
-0.0410892069,
-0.0207172427,
-0.0175267961,
0.0297952965,
0.0286661815,
0.0022553988,
0.044999592,
-0.0118861496,
-0.0361620523,
-0.0084945764,
-0.00759013,
0.101460211,
-0.0108713992,
0.0049941191,
-0.0357943885,
-0.0440356173,
-0.0463364534,
0.0357185565,
0.0177301448,
-0.0173614882,
-0.0215682127,
0.0595990382,
-0.0326569416,
-0.0155297006,
-0.0231102426,
0.0184069462,
-0.022973666,
-0.0495110676,
0.0019126373,
-0.0239207745,
0.0638056174,
-0.0154835219,
0.0048003173,
-0.0136640808,
-0.0207770951,
-0.0196762979,
-0.032092724,
0.0629766509,
0.0059608137,
0.008340166,
0.0132591575,
-0.0262435637,
0.036437396,
0.0800719485,
0.023779083,
0.0025906097,
0.0143513419,
-0.0075264764,
-0.0218281094,
0.049294848,
0.0217455104,
0.009443678,
0.0075911116,
0.0274701864,
-0.0003671169,
0.0092038438,
0.0567304157,
0.0021527444,
-0.0717501566,
-0.0196806043,
0.0116438447,
0.027903365,
0.0378158428,
-0.0006323004,
0.0780091956,
0.0662422627,
-0.0455825888,
-0.0090941973,
-0.0120921321,
0.050377097,
0.0118514365,
0.0043201912,
0.003676974,
0.0014920442,
-0.0572410449,
-0.0121631036,
0.0186071806,
-0.0068146577,
0.0200920273,
-0.0065121795,
0.0461430103,
-0.001289216,
-0.0420881063,
0.0842513293,
0.0265779682,
-0.0231696106,
0.01718463,
-0.0234428514,
0.0252673198,
0.0453892834,
0.0201888923,
-0.0029682906,
-0.0992726386,
-0.0294693839,
0.0043795113,
0.0260128397,
0.0340340994,
-0.0351232029,
0.0754666254,
-0.0880338922,
-0.0061421753,
-0.0227995105,
0.006692437,
0.0872828141,
-0.0743715614,
0.0107278023,
-0.0006203285,
0.009630735,
0.0385395736,
0.0016089072,
-0.0629874915,
-0.0408337675,
0.0358665437,
0.0134976907,
0.0532843657,
0.0589725636,
-0.0024379699,
-0.0334186666,
0.0065365122,
-0.0045572054,
0.0343619734,
0.0461715199,
-0.0562308505,
-0.0683490559,
0.0217599012,
0.0106086545,
-0.0128964316,
-0.0100100702,
-0.0230930336,
-0.0776698515,
0.0777991861,
-0.0129065616,
0.0125193167,
-0.083611995,
-0.0014517712,
0.0056912913,
0.036337629,
-0.0012033813,
0.0160838701,
0.0225523189,
-0.0207297094,
0.1000992134,
0.0073749698,
0.0618586838,
-0.057326097,
-0.0110678887,
0.0487350374,
-0.0153366467,
0.0030819739,
-0.0086900303,
0.0509270765,
0.0075302566,
-0.002687206,
-0.0761317313,
0.003399045,
-0.0320774317,
0.0226790104,
0.0184542816,
0.059962932,
-0.0132405944,
-0.0390499532,
-0.0318788774,
0.0260622501,
0.0294158291,
-0.0141903656,
0.0053994777,
0.0361365825,
-0.0098688127,
-0.0219050106,
0.0237684827,
0.0133690247,
0.0384756029,
-0.0428102277,
-0.0178824849,
-0.0440551862,
0.0127430512,
-0.0097318459,
0.0274075642,
-0.0289831422,
-0.0560580082,
-0.013019233,
0.0011998556,
-0.0346543975,
0.0367704928,
-0.0409946032,
0.010638711,
0.0351412334,
-0.030345913,
-0.0752139837,
0.0338926315,
0.005020686,
-0.0126218339,
-0.057843443,
-0.0104133999,
-0.0040062764,
0.0924755335,
0.0013171117,
0.0129594803,
-0.1059627458,
-0.0127864163,
0.0048993682,
-0.062924996,
0.0165742859,
0.001441812,
-0.0277989451,
0.0351690613,
-0.0165475942,
0.0179279801,
0.0596267879,
-0.0547316149,
-0.0494570285,
-0.0773231089,
-0.0128473612,
-0.0405068211,
0.025993593,
-0.0291279219,
0.0202866625,
-0.009007398,
-0.0714886114,
-0.0247646794,
-0.0127697233,
0.0234893877,
0.0065728044,
0.006547248,
-0.0283943918,
0.0067116036,
-0.0443613343,
-0.0153326606,
-0.0248954911,
-0.0296696108,
-0.0197170433,
0.0170237403,
-0.0049393089,
-0.0008088799,
-0.0102601033,
0.0279445797,
0.0166275855,
0.0456029065,
-0.0056323623,
0.0493870787,
-0.0479137637,
0.0374134071,
0.0257345159,
0.02236945,
-0.0349561572,
0.0138671566,
0.0799848735,
-0.0054612076,
0.0013851733,
-0.0088842297,
-0.0171833877,
0.0364300981,
0.0664298981,
0.0236385074,
-0.0252881292,
-0.0088527724,
0.0632132217,
-0.0163085721,
-0.0044233594,
0.0877174959,
0.0090739354,
-0.0719645619,
-0.0199871622,
-0.0612401254,
0.0042265235,
-0.0032875896,
0.0589811653,
-0.0850686505,
-0.0307736136,
-0.0102074295,
-0.0103102867,
0.0109762233,
0.0051466222,
-0.0309250522,
-0.1028761193,
0.0349034369,
0.0078657167,
-0.0742738023,
-0.0148257073,
-0.0155216446,
-0.0051010139,
-0.0435188636,
0.0439168811,
0.0014746567,
0.0238058679,
-0.020473104,
0.0259391498,
0.0284321643,
-0.0608862452,
0.0013596701,
-0.0032364246,
0.1022926494,
0.0103067458,
0.0497638211,
0.0089936564,
0.0149483215,
0.0143052284,
-0.0495853834,
-0.0058294106,
-0.0120063201,
0.0187528599,
-0.0053592394,
-0.0255214255,
0.0539825372,
0.0086693466,
-0.0280185733,
0.0014391403,
-0.0151011804,
0.0467577502,
-0.0160937402,
0.0208251532,
0.0120329494,
0.0367497876,
0.0346498899,
0.0428451113,
0.0318898335,
-0.030301258,
-0.0360848382,
-0.0257337,
-0.0256707557,
-0.0574056059,
0.0220219865,
-0.0018087702,
0.0110547477,
-0.0404534079,
-0.0240155533,
-0.0828424245,
0.0234848186,
0.0042670523,
0.0096760085,
0.0021144219,
0.0037176695,
0.0155768506,
0.0030862675,
-0.0055428348,
0.0000409685,
0.002254586,
-0.0231017135,
-0.0028891482,
0.0556704141,
-0.0642790869,
-0.0034801925,
-0.017059112,
-0.0601956882,
-0.0665233806,
-0.0265967883,
0.0140898237,
0.0174983796,
0.0999972001,
-0.0533356667,
-0.0675001219,
0.0273925811,
-0.0317655653,
-0.0144061968,
0.0142074311,
0.0503240786,
0.0523498952,
-0.0156268198,
0.0467692539,
-0.0458362252,
0.0023814505,
-0.0009978599,
0.0583062023,
-0.0970801264,
-0.0550557822,
-0.0057654805,
-0.0051493482,
-0.0049496237,
0.0082322992,
-0.0129829301,
-0.0580341294,
0.0510460287,
-0.0309641268,
0.0338507444,
-0.0375784487,
-0.0178488921,
0.0323006436,
-0.0428735614,
-0.0119874692,
-0.0161615554,
-0.0599597245,
0.0073670782,
-0.0130019709,
0.0352899581,
0.0717383623,
0.0027658041,
-0.0070892819,
-0.0001537465,
-0.0303400904,
0.0260966439,
0.0168507341,
0.0249443613,
-0.044656761,
0.0823007375,
-0.0099527659,
-0.023483742,
0.018732423,
0.0303788763,
-0.046167504,
-0.0227603149,
0.0107982662,
0.0052867853,
0.0404096246,
-0.024215607,
0.0673604533,
0.0054559358,
0.0148012834,
0.0111156506,
0.049543649,
-0.0085789599,
-0.0325197056,
0.0510619655,
0.0092843818,
-0.0057427343,
0.0220750347,
0.04674422,
0.0297185797,
0.0247146767,
-0.010119752,
0.0512625128,
-0.0298997741,
-0.0278811939,
0.0288311075,
0.0267833006,
-0.0580226444,
0.0147903077,
-0.0292534158,
-0.0504459962,
-0.0266002007,
0.008870475,
-0.0015953643,
-0.0117314318,
-0.0123669654,
0.0490766764,
-0.0108795762,
0.0181286447,
-0.0339468345,
-0.0219689216,
-0.009269882,
-0.0082467888,
-0.037236657,
-6.240224903e-33,
-0.0366900116,
0.0445751175,
0.0410359576,
-0.0004568962,
-0.0330295637,
-0.0055851513,
-0.0505631492,
-0.0114772292,
-0.0330021791,
0.0028543135,
-0.0058687632,
0.0271121878,
0.0251369216,
0.0304796454,
-0.0053911544,
-0.0278822184,
0.0416820087,
-0.0338035114,
-0.0004338604,
0.022072468,
0.0242485888,
0.0239857677,
0.0428108908,
-0.041677855,
0.012900589,
0.0161654893,
0.0102163814,
0.0475766324,
0.0411984995,
0.0693244189,
-0.0236014724,
0.0127897067,
0.0244352184,
-0.0351092927,
-0.0053058481,
0.0026800067,
-0.0716197938,
-0.03426864,
0.0530640297,
0.0578864701,
-0.001654115,
-0.0325866751,
-0.034726847,
-0.0072583375,
0.0022958433,
0.0036298861,
-0.0037520865,
-0.0058554765,
-0.0181597956,
-0.0069357087,
-0.0452462099,
0.0236353762,
-0.0339807346,
-0.0351104029,
0.0728102773,
0.0943593532,
-0.0164673533,
0.0166574381,
-0.0635118112,
0.0279333778,
-0.065225862,
0.0018516907,
0.0908984765,
0.0198136158,
-0.0263798609,
0.0313808098,
0.0368841812,
-0.0352261066,
-0.0124647543,
-0.0180046111,
0.0183365699,
-0.0129511356,
-0.0186965261,
0.0464098826,
-0.001401064,
0.0114221936,
-0.056406673,
-0.0170170702,
0.034657523,
0.0336779393,
0.0203205068,
0.0298957769,
0.0000697926,
-0.0194040705,
-0.0400975533,
-0.0366935469,
-0.0462847911,
-0.043109782,
0.0174931902,
-0.0097655561,
-0.0263610203,
-0.0299668908,
0.10006129,
-0.035775587,
0.033932358,
0.03212329,
0.0136242146,
-0.0029245422,
-0.0046151821,
0.0593343973,
-0.0579444133,
-0.0183148347,
0.0167088043,
0.0020042302,
0.0215160605,
0.0081981588,
-0.0037035726,
0.0058254725,
-0.0090178093,
-0.0088172881,
-0.0316243097,
0.0069471365,
-0.043477606,
0.1010440364,
0.0132798031,
0.0020034176,
-0.0186601914,
0.0420424342,
0.0121260965,
-0.0014559125,
0.0121080615,
-0.0259799417,
0.0128868734,
0.0215401612,
-0.0692692772,
0.01450436,
0.0136815412,
0.0211564917,
0.0123539492,
-0.0494072698,
-0.0002807691,
0.0586750582,
2.663e-7,
-0.0075215241,
0.0259096734,
0.0112720262,
0.0091183325,
0.0407284759,
0.0319285169,
-0.0336206816,
0.0238844883,
0.0300145,
-0.0050295726,
0.0184831657,
0.0146341501,
0.0397658572,
0.0049465797,
-0.0992062762,
-0.0153190009,
-0.0011314536,
-0.0147495931,
-0.0289001912,
0.0179937147,
0.0279999524,
0.1032492816,
-0.0409543142,
0.0139557971,
0.0144237475,
-0.0193925463,
0.0205051173,
-0.0193609875,
-0.0527293719,
0.0104591707,
0.0052172351,
-0.0104710991,
-0.0230801422,
0.0102973757,
-0.0197635144,
0.0552454218,
0.0007280192,
0.0741754025,
-0.0088523813,
-0.0743512288,
-0.0122328736,
-0.0118557783,
-0.0178708714,
-0.0376874842,
0.0721759424,
-0.0285887308,
-0.0490902923,
0.0122568095,
-0.027298335,
0.0369263962,
0.0101112016,
-0.0195668843,
0.0008836758,
0.02319571,
0.0498317517,
-0.033742141,
-0.0120694535,
-0.053377375,
0.0025971185,
-0.0296730492,
-0.0240071565,
-0.0015525398,
0.018603161,
-0.0622604527,
0.0576332249,
-0.0102505079,
0.0090333316,
2.005739812e-34,
0.0566741936,
-0.0175961144,
0.0136124445,
0.0234751441,
0.0040765428,
-0.0095704701,
-0.0035825281,
0.0309902113,
0.0391066819,
-0.0832630992,
-0.0289841425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03800v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03800v1 | Textual Data Mining for Financial Fraud Detection: A Deep Learning Approach | 2023-08-05T15:33:10 | 2023-08-05T15:33:10 | Qiuru Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this report, I present a deep learning approach to conduct a natural
language processing (hereafter NLP) binary classification task for analyzing
financial-fraud texts. First, I searched for regulatory announcements and
enforcement bulletins from HKEX news to define fraudulent companies and to
extract their MD&A reports before I organized the sentences from the reports
with labels and reporting time. My methodology involved different kinds of
neural network models, including Multilayer Perceptrons with Embedding layers,
vanilla Recurrent Neural Network (RNN), Long-Short Term Memory (LSTM), and
Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU) for the text classification task. By utilizing this
diverse set of models, I aim to perform a comprehensive comparison of their
accuracy in detecting financial fraud. My results bring significant
implications for financial fraud detection as this work contributes to the
growing body of research at the intersection of deep learning, NLP, and
finance, providing valuable insights for industry practitioners, regulators,
and researchers in the pursuit of more robust and effective fraud detection
methodologies. | [
0.019925002,
0.0450842194,
-0.0126669183,
0.0557250381,
-0.0456446148,
0.0047606751,
0.0410564132,
0.0252293311,
0.0251708943,
-0.0420077927,
-0.0303517748,
-0.0345627964,
0.0311169568,
0.0713449419,
0.0057180719,
0.0014433137,
0.044065401,
0.0066478499,
0.0697920248,
0.0265475772,
0.0133899534,
0.0038468037,
0.0100154867,
0.0097945714,
-0.0061847614,
-0.0076828431,
0.0286658704,
-0.0377416871,
0.011516911,
-0.0358000919,
0.0302585214,
0.0014992326,
0.0363500491,
0.104241319,
0.0000020176,
-0.0463949665,
-0.022146875,
-0.0282638911,
-0.0212894175,
0.0573538207,
0.0161778387,
-0.0519582815,
0.0124323452,
0.0111642266,
-0.0676082969,
-0.0526644178,
0.0256990828,
0.1066600233,
0.0433945954,
0.0523435883,
-0.0128681362,
-0.0323076472,
0.0180130471,
-0.0286464207,
-0.0277012084,
-0.0248647034,
0.0336868763,
-0.0106584355,
-0.0289095156,
-0.0196326841,
-0.0320569836,
0.0331466906,
0.0226230193,
-0.0244208686,
0.0120817022,
0.001392104,
-0.010042049,
0.0202406496,
-0.0419564694,
0.0352276564,
-0.0652953908,
0.0050978377,
-0.0048302487,
-0.0260404982,
0.003166938,
-0.0307093021,
-0.0009781717,
0.0846106783,
-0.0286765862,
0.0015300568,
-0.0044400315,
0.0055246791,
0.0474791415,
0.0152493557,
-0.0247982368,
-0.0012004474,
-0.0156389549,
-0.0656868592,
0.0333429947,
-0.0213134959,
0.0168260168,
-0.0491116196,
0.0336366855,
0.0278052147,
0.0118430816,
0.0160078518,
-0.0084446501,
-0.0405649394,
0.0158085283,
-0.0609084517,
0.0148343723,
-0.0095364088,
-0.024276061,
0.0321470946,
-0.0337990336,
0.0488592759,
0.0066937977,
0.0111914445,
0.000620155,
0.0156784654,
-0.0126017425,
-0.0111913197,
0.0293020364,
0.081925869,
-0.0313549861,
-0.0035858259,
-0.0958141088,
-0.0025306365,
-0.0306383185,
0.0253243353,
-0.0146083124,
0.0353630744,
0.0172659587,
0.0280167963,
-0.0628414303,
-0.026064707,
-0.008780607,
0.0313037075,
-0.0110882027,
0.0169659555,
-0.0008633955,
0.0530713424,
-0.0002657897,
-0.0049295416,
0.0148760183,
0.0390120111,
0.0274772756,
-0.0576841831,
-0.0864397958,
-0.0252575502,
-0.0294236913,
0.0009212353,
-0.021390833,
-0.0135144182,
-0.0096838446,
-0.0884320736,
-0.0281268377,
0.0280422419,
-0.0124250771,
0.0028803323,
-0.0098726135,
0.0406182073,
-0.0016645476,
-0.0367541574,
-0.001814808,
-0.0349327028,
0.0207280498,
-0.0093871942,
0.030537555,
0.0493829399,
0.03138173,
-0.0052002803,
0.0374164805,
0.0231993049,
0.004573429,
-0.0682759285,
0.0161624216,
-0.0207164399,
-0.0351393782,
0.0288618673,
0.0196280144,
-0.0003745325,
-0.0154088615,
-0.0114643695,
0.0629728287,
0.0426107012,
0.0310504436,
0.0430020206,
0.0161863063,
0.0269035175,
-0.0180473663,
-0.0126945646,
0.0056318743,
-0.030152142,
-0.0394267924,
-0.0076934267,
-0.0646765381,
0.007719669,
-0.0169762485,
-0.0528388768,
-0.0202040579,
-0.0243286192,
-0.0265343785,
-0.0184140634,
0.0411274694,
-0.002074104,
-0.0719413757,
0.0090658776,
-0.0041847797,
0.0291592441,
-0.0207299553,
-0.0461163186,
0.0579927303,
0.0743960217,
0.0214042701,
-0.0281553809,
0.0522748604,
-0.0669681057,
-0.0180586763,
0.0324059799,
-0.0116934311,
0.0093207182,
0.0042576189,
-0.044200778,
0.0125857713,
-0.0045930431,
-0.0229496099,
0.0398523249,
-0.064597562,
0.022572862,
0.0284571517,
0.0054859701,
-0.0333190151,
0.0496415421,
-0.0029159063,
-0.0648961887,
0.0680995211,
0.0314057544,
-0.0084479386,
-0.0044842409,
0.0216759797,
-0.0153346639,
0.0340158232,
-0.03041308,
-0.0730966255,
-0.0212091487,
-0.0173725374,
-0.0150766326,
-0.0062472206,
-0.0485253446,
0.0132948766,
0.0432894155,
-0.0363142416,
-0.0315328501,
0.0319615789,
-0.003911328,
-0.0302819721,
-0.0813961327,
-0.0328480676,
-0.0031269088,
0.029338181,
0.0058129923,
0.1011825502,
-0.015181764,
0.0145180924,
-0.0193826649,
-0.0266547538,
0.0545127615,
0.0077633685,
0.0108275488,
-0.0312603936,
-0.0612927303,
0.0009977331,
0.0396645144,
0.0148276277,
0.0340813436,
-0.0002100007,
-0.0287063252,
0.0025064289,
-0.0331081413,
0.001672604,
-0.0150083415,
-0.0012817816,
0.0048054,
-0.0158062801,
-0.0522242934,
-0.0438969694,
0.0286092162,
-0.0175777487,
0.0745973811,
-0.0029282016,
-0.0322749503,
-0.0174930505,
-0.0197057668,
-0.0311681684,
0.0427330807,
0.0215674527,
-0.0500137918,
-0.0413215831,
-0.0253919605,
0.0117907086,
0.0179797523,
-0.0110006779,
0.0309751946,
0.0040579597,
0.0238238461,
-0.0132897869,
0.0516863465,
0.020326063,
0.0687781274,
-0.0120891547,
0.0434399918,
-0.0038574981,
0.0316103362,
-0.0058188029,
0.0489395447,
0.0019564652,
0.0007027359,
0.0532873534,
0.020954404,
0.0032089823,
0.005878407,
0.0073681385,
-0.0087923203,
0.0252880752,
-0.0021652505,
-0.0124922637,
-0.0444144309,
0.0049163392,
0.0418433212,
0.0121445926,
-0.0108218873,
0.0518645309,
0.0133069595,
0.0092791477,
-0.0454891995,
-0.0524720177,
-0.0584556572,
0.0392337628,
-0.014188502,
-0.0102480361,
0.0048936158,
-0.0384968035,
0.0483070426,
0.001927507,
0.047865849,
0.0290823579,
0.030195808,
-0.0380871333,
0.0246676188,
-0.0022216002,
-0.0060437354,
-0.0507992357,
-0.068992734,
0.0250101388,
-0.0256988555,
0.0045733368,
0.0079087336,
-0.0867213756,
0.0037914452,
-0.0540695339,
0.014795009,
-0.0156292003,
-0.0102729425,
-0.0143995536,
0.0396447331,
0.0170548838,
-0.0226749294,
0.0647678971,
-0.0233552679,
0.036324773,
0.0155249014,
-0.0293023568,
0.0352427252,
-0.0363022387,
0.0043778913,
-0.0217435528,
-0.0255218316,
0.0213310719,
0.0159452148,
-0.0701777562,
-0.0705453902,
-0.028989248,
0.0991706252,
0.0227511078,
0.0312511437,
0.0207566209,
0.0560931824,
-0.0021670589,
-0.0211697668,
0.0049658129,
-0.0875271037,
-0.0049264915,
-0.0417132601,
-0.0183526911,
0.0025235463,
-0.075809814,
-0.0060334029,
-0.0844181255,
0.0451184064,
0.0002198387,
-0.0098841274,
-0.0755889565,
-0.0089255329,
-0.0596502647,
-0.0311124623,
0.0533835031,
-0.0343406014,
-0.0039714919,
-0.0378507711,
-0.0102443537,
-0.1232459396,
0.0021582539,
-0.010548329,
-0.0343132913,
-0.0308687612,
0.0598197542,
0.0339350179,
-0.0315596014,
-0.017014917,
-0.0365256071,
0.0162320957,
-0.0118161868,
0.0291639846,
0.0625223964,
-0.015539851,
-0.0157314148,
0.0032230441,
0.0493771732,
-0.084440425,
0.0455096923,
-0.0095783081,
0.037034709,
-0.0309357829,
-0.0827790275,
0.0189102739,
0.0077262912,
0.0434282199,
0.0491448008,
-0.0258785877,
-0.0153375641,
-0.0497966111,
-0.008798115,
-0.0167019237,
-0.0566247143,
0.0404013991,
0.0280240718,
0.0516359694,
-0.0197957698,
-0.0702876002,
-0.0734767467,
0.0049024378,
-0.0380052961,
0.0129171163,
0.0212438274,
0.042645514,
-0.0252085999,
-0.0361674577,
-0.00017734,
-0.031296175,
0.0375472717,
-0.0104905432,
0.0624258965,
-0.0171063654,
0.037708085,
-0.0341093466,
0.0335677527,
-0.0923805982,
0.0068676462,
-0.0070394543,
-0.0428746901,
0.0018490425,
0.004756764,
-0.0332014486,
0.0277435649,
0.0323513597,
0.0448803641,
-0.0336912647,
-0.0516510718,
0.0243453942,
-0.0310864057,
0.0008283639,
-0.0044796974,
-0.0052714366,
0.0463011563,
-0.0363159329,
-0.037224602,
-0.0229063164,
0.0366448574,
0.0058151796,
-0.0097574648,
0.0352899618,
0.0404021703,
-0.0402872637,
-0.0526688024,
-0.0256457403,
0.0198676847,
-0.0019685167,
-0.0100119067,
0.0003038211,
0.0773973241,
-0.0143155893,
-0.0366335027,
0.0320271254,
0.0259528197,
-0.0251088124,
-0.0378727131,
0.0125928614,
0.0079719992,
0.0534873828,
-0.0545844585,
-0.0059261373,
0.0082314322,
0.0349425301,
0.0446929447,
0.0389696322,
0.0087624704,
-0.0220542978,
0.0247431826,
0.0426260605,
-0.0120281177,
-0.0323947147,
-0.0188401565,
0.0284821447,
-0.01213306,
0.0162577704,
0.0428582653,
-0.0334843956,
-0.050417982,
-0.043661356,
0.0542867593,
0.0115849134,
0.0265888944,
0.0059517319,
-0.0246208683,
0.0030566859,
-0.0062689176,
-0.0672770962,
0.0079963692,
0.0834650695,
0.0580056719,
0.0238931291,
-0.0042335279,
-0.0082101664,
-0.0446866117,
-0.0242536124,
0.0629196614,
0.0347793028,
-0.0085384101,
-0.0201994125,
-0.0352186188,
-0.0189196747,
0.0525733456,
-0.0081657702,
0.0313233808,
-0.004126457,
0.0094432719,
0.0599244349,
0.0362034552,
0.0600123554,
0.0310555175,
0.0265663564,
0.0306483768,
-0.0281623788,
-0.0958282948,
-5.309781818e-33,
0.0205647834,
-0.0679371133,
0.015269299,
0.0150280902,
0.0352260061,
-0.002261301,
-0.0157053359,
-0.0518017597,
-0.007315503,
0.0260668918,
0.0104213003,
0.0686268359,
0.0115562901,
0.0270863865,
0.0031834799,
-0.0470248796,
0.0424631909,
-0.0130050462,
0.0208043884,
-0.0160473641,
0.0175993908,
0.0865118653,
0.0439226963,
-0.0488737151,
0.0358549878,
0.0000115933,
-0.024028318,
0.0048526097,
-0.0256501306,
0.0471431576,
-0.0228189975,
0.0707608983,
0.0250299275,
-0.049883686,
0.0178048089,
0.0263080411,
-0.008550222,
-0.0487400889,
-0.0220181216,
0.0338688456,
-0.0263017677,
-0.0076118247,
0.0647864491,
0.0015650528,
-0.0174519867,
0.0101352409,
0.0311441608,
0.0020591011,
-0.0133878021,
-0.0664677471,
-0.0622861423,
0.015706474,
-0.0164803714,
0.0428429618,
0.0199563839,
0.0303042848,
0.0056922357,
0.0159675218,
-0.0700297654,
-0.0238728113,
-0.0085971337,
-0.0081930347,
-0.0043372563,
-0.0044969409,
-0.0580523051,
0.0673932061,
-0.0031209975,
0.005996488,
-0.0283414293,
0.0399891101,
0.0434891097,
0.0290366895,
0.0510844365,
0.0209426228,
0.0551932007,
-0.0701391771,
-0.1091943234,
0.0199363381,
0.0247415956,
0.0056114472,
0.0264466852,
-0.0155586787,
-0.0248058289,
-0.0079412032,
0.0007801674,
0.0280320607,
-0.0201872028,
0.0318704471,
0.0276644025,
0.0122443177,
0.025337996,
0.0242074393,
-0.0216516722,
-0.0603791475,
-0.0305822585,
-0.0060647433,
0.0420567617,
0.0014217683,
0.0088822041,
0.0148177147,
-0.04468707,
-0.0134521136,
0.0097405249,
-0.0148851108,
0.0118992645,
-0.0393147729,
0.0734838843,
0.0173133686,
-0.0299038216,
0.0109857861,
0.0374536663,
-0.0019644874,
0.0036763682,
0.0731917247,
-0.0335559808,
0.0101782503,
0.0059689367,
0.0058395229,
-0.0286531188,
0.0222646706,
-0.0125598768,
-0.0184952132,
0.0002941691,
0.0003883262,
-0.0172900353,
-0.0540717281,
-0.0241532233,
0.024678275,
0.0326910056,
-0.0796304122,
0.0044906014,
0.0423017256,
2.587e-7,
0.0039607729,
0.0381612256,
0.012690736,
-0.0099793971,
0.0263779834,
0.02149578,
0.0208981466,
0.0406370386,
-0.0260060262,
-0.0606328808,
0.0377421305,
-0.0235103294,
0.0457683951,
-0.0209608059,
-0.0970937833,
-0.0429046527,
-0.041918084,
-0.0010177476,
-0.0715951174,
0.0104429396,
-0.003849227,
0.0813705772,
0.0111553865,
-0.0679393783,
0.0562983118,
-0.0570296198,
0.031831447,
0.00943074,
-0.0079681091,
0.0156126767,
0.08431153,
0.0060452339,
-0.0171731822,
0.0157228839,
0.0036137179,
0.0708700642,
-0.0064052874,
-0.0063607371,
-0.0286667943,
0.0015058268,
-0.036872033,
-0.0000324407,
0.0341361202,
0.020085955,
0.0208266787,
-0.0231743734,
-0.0139068477,
-0.0354706757,
0.0114931688,
-0.0060932836,
0.0509149954,
0.0043687876,
-0.0160002727,
0.0245823115,
0.0004189664,
-0.0210887715,
0.0520232692,
-0.0288492255,
0.0351860635,
0.0462194756,
-0.0559550561,
0.0790293813,
-0.0339653268,
0.0072655911,
0.066865243,
-0.0497237556,
0.0175763946,
2.22669923e-34,
0.0278825816,
-0.0637313277,
-0.0177921392,
0.0311190747,
0.0626298264,
0.0242688786,
-0.022594668,
0.0238607414,
0.0005925903,
-0.0606660172,
-0.0068056728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02870v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02870v1 | ApproBiVT: Lead ASR Models to Generalize Better Using Approximated Bias-Variance Tradeoff Guided Early Stopping and Checkpoint Averaging | 2023-08-05T12:50:54 | 2023-08-05T12:50:54 | Fangyuan Wang, Ming Hao, Yuhai Shi, Bo Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | The conventional recipe for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) models is to
1) train multiple checkpoints on a training set while relying on a validation
set to prevent overfitting using early stopping and 2) average several last
checkpoints or that of the lowest validation losses to obtain the final model.
In this paper, we rethink and update the early stopping and checkpoint
averaging from the perspective of the bias-variance tradeoff. Theoretically,
the bias and variance represent the fitness and variability of a model and the
tradeoff of them determines the overall generalization error. But, it's
impractical to evaluate them precisely. As an alternative, we take the training
loss and validation loss as proxies of bias and variance and guide the early
stopping and checkpoint averaging using their tradeoff, namely an Approximated
Bias-Variance Tradeoff (ApproBiVT). When evaluating with advanced ASR models,
our recipe provides 2.5%-3.7% and 3.1%-4.6% CER reduction on the AISHELL-1 and
AISHELL-2, respectively. | [
-0.0382424444,
0.0493472628,
0.0214568526,
-0.0355858579,
0.0025289084,
0.0252211615,
0.0305394549,
-0.0148633607,
0.0008175559,
0.0074839499,
-0.0191472173,
-0.0106174173,
0.0339277536,
-0.014489362,
0.0081335222,
-0.0600267872,
0.0335563309,
-0.0528714731,
0.0648334622,
-0.0477671362,
0.0354517847,
0.0025586965,
-0.0300180931,
0.0574681498,
0.0015036447,
0.0577359758,
0.0110943774,
0.0019743943,
0.0488954857,
-0.0283015184,
-0.0132326344,
0.01260316,
0.0363802761,
0.0199141204,
0.0000019649,
-0.053454075,
-0.0113923606,
0.0171737112,
-0.0908585861,
0.0157041308,
0.0402387008,
0.0691837892,
-0.0082906336,
0.0571225919,
0.0283976588,
-0.0467410274,
0.0504093543,
0.0176876411,
0.0387592055,
0.033531338,
0.0015153199,
-0.036256481,
0.0129020764,
-0.0412066355,
-0.0313023292,
-0.0780546442,
-0.0105845835,
-0.0177196432,
-0.0189433396,
-0.0694900304,
0.0010902958,
0.0375060365,
-0.0058615934,
0.0190877747,
-0.0229582228,
0.0105798068,
-0.0289530139,
-0.033921998,
-0.0296476875,
-0.0060900496,
-0.0184104536,
-0.0280132722,
0.0029259238,
-0.0095827188,
-0.0209211372,
-0.0053447247,
-0.0386798307,
0.0157634802,
-0.0387696251,
0.013712489,
-0.0008764428,
0.0117335068,
0.0310925134,
-0.0121166287,
-0.0450686738,
-0.0233927853,
-0.0034517038,
-0.0211586542,
0.0752260163,
-0.0238984954,
-0.0368077978,
-0.0016202998,
0.044746127,
-0.0083224205,
-0.034813948,
-0.0084497221,
-0.0117636696,
0.0224139933,
-0.0150720244,
0.0016488069,
0.0358699113,
0.043484766,
-0.0337761454,
0.0319570005,
-0.0382446498,
0.0403334014,
0.0310802944,
-0.0128411576,
-0.0344646461,
0.021340223,
-0.0485815555,
0.0128907086,
-0.0407073274,
0.0224208124,
0.0216527488,
-0.0159430746,
-0.0512391962,
0.0060764616,
-0.006362129,
0.0036838222,
0.030720396,
-0.0152186491,
-0.0179687869,
0.0125661213,
0.0259379894,
-0.0004013673,
-0.00920997,
0.0221634582,
-0.0036100573,
-0.0802774504,
-0.0120045291,
-0.0197997633,
0.0484291613,
0.0086354138,
0.0423983075,
0.0627163798,
-0.00543204,
-0.0396826342,
-0.0601661913,
0.0694025978,
-0.0010505657,
-0.0483499393,
-0.0253191032,
-0.0148608927,
0.0469943546,
-0.0235801917,
0.0289680716,
-0.0157032758,
-0.0177520365,
-0.0441457219,
0.0366690196,
0.0342577286,
0.0174287371,
0.0137538575,
0.0902132839,
-0.0269687641,
-0.0125477938,
0.0949785635,
0.0394597165,
-0.0191870406,
-0.0025470695,
-0.0378002599,
-0.037981499,
0.0421983302,
0.0092405975,
-0.0236281343,
0.033039052,
-0.0251190234,
0.0320274644,
0.0022028764,
0.0134786796,
0.0494091921,
-0.0631851256,
0.0115317376,
0.0462267138,
0.0278201941,
0.0465201773,
-0.0072971759,
0.0110474192,
0.0096931607,
0.0175807588,
-0.0208262503,
-0.0107558444,
-0.0261303037,
-0.0461332053,
0.0121977162,
0.037749391,
0.0471870415,
-0.0477249026,
-0.0415099375,
-0.0153984483,
0.0090485094,
-0.0116670579,
0.0389961079,
0.0612260848,
-0.0197689738,
-0.0430876203,
0.0318940915,
0.0084147677,
-0.0106649073,
0.0189745221,
-0.0685839355,
-0.0059844335,
-0.0403557085,
-0.0012381347,
-0.0276768543,
-0.0266419202,
-0.0204272103,
0.0194261242,
-0.0037005355,
0.0515369773,
0.0010552158,
0.0672366396,
-0.0789050534,
-0.0557626262,
0.0574935563,
-0.0090107042,
0.0486589409,
0.0057924753,
0.0468109623,
0.0260819029,
-0.0307385419,
-0.0547830164,
0.0072966646,
0.0094374502,
-0.0304625928,
0.0050031422,
0.0294736195,
0.0585333668,
0.0043804203,
-0.0404365323,
-0.0071095233,
0.023485139,
-0.0105942953,
0.0005013123,
0.0310268886,
-0.0284051877,
-0.0010309091,
0.0422578156,
-0.0336826891,
0.0485570356,
0.0166885033,
-0.0077210348,
-0.084590897,
-0.0150538469,
-0.0380949453,
0.0152702024,
-0.007761199,
0.0726758167,
0.0021401304,
0.0204014983,
-0.0282819271,
-0.0209943913,
0.0074733966,
0.0016412147,
0.0280172862,
-0.0312620066,
0.0123803653,
-0.0933632553,
-0.0657133386,
0.0410282277,
-0.0195520613,
0.008466539,
0.0563725419,
0.0094692698,
-0.0018156725,
-0.0033059001,
-0.1035343856,
-0.0253858622,
-0.0094450368,
0.038816493,
-0.0282986034,
-0.0015786684,
-0.0122642461,
0.016821878,
0.0245844033,
-0.0374929681,
-0.0095988121,
-0.014992795,
-0.0551926903,
-0.0041759536,
-0.0638859794,
-0.0285806414,
-0.0178077091,
0.014389636,
0.0192435049,
-0.009043674,
-0.0407766104,
-0.059240412,
-0.0224097408,
0.0194473956,
0.0250165015,
-0.0288019869,
-0.0008084389,
0.0386369601,
0.004473343,
0.0048563476,
0.056026727,
0.0182760172,
-0.0186664462,
-0.0179745927,
0.0107094506,
-0.0596928969,
0.0304767434,
0.017658554,
0.0077273319,
0.0062150192,
-0.0439320058,
-0.0059392196,
0.0154174147,
0.0344016254,
0.0516408496,
-0.0622695759,
-0.0219379142,
0.0038885074,
-0.0184370056,
-0.0265523065,
-0.0179160703,
-0.0083495509,
0.0044975611,
-0.0257480927,
-0.0300773624,
0.0228731986,
-0.0635005534,
-0.0243194755,
-0.0385564044,
-0.0141337067,
-0.0272045322,
0.0189265255,
-0.0168562382,
-0.005469684,
-0.0105343107,
-0.0301516708,
-0.0293799024,
0.0038893118,
0.0139318723,
-0.0342241116,
0.0243544802,
-0.0128213568,
0.0288843885,
-0.0080549996,
-0.0093141729,
0.0118070813,
0.0582578033,
-0.0487423018,
0.0226478875,
-0.0235407669,
0.0054518022,
-0.0211622454,
0.0175505914,
0.0059465826,
0.0846682414,
0.000291368,
0.0117226811,
-0.0036023846,
0.037691839,
0.0161036868,
-0.0077049248,
-0.0015369868,
-0.0234267935,
0.071593605,
-0.0142575307,
0.0997877568,
0.0378493667,
-0.0565288775,
-0.0013107104,
0.0551061332,
-0.0272526145,
-0.0152975777,
0.0204693209,
0.0320970118,
-0.0291839745,
0.0378186107,
0.0659923926,
-0.034050338,
-0.004518528,
-0.0108089997,
0.0195473339,
0.0630269796,
-0.0057045063,
-0.0291565955,
-0.007321672,
-0.0114119546,
0.0500940122,
0.0283493232,
-0.0093545392,
0.020613553,
-0.0028502024,
-0.0719323084,
0.0117273675,
0.0301491451,
-0.0457573049,
0.0352628976,
-0.0428645201,
-0.0108244643,
-0.0796714649,
0.044667244,
0.0333185531,
-0.0166868772,
-0.0294111501,
0.0733551309,
-0.0524716228,
-0.084815003,
0.0181498509,
-0.0500833243,
0.0693142414,
0.0695897415,
-0.009659986,
0.0071869488,
0.0025075783,
0.0567120053,
-0.0279539507,
0.0365337878,
-0.0279042777,
0.013014039,
0.0078962957,
-0.01147989,
0.0223514643,
0.0376121029,
0.0365259089,
0.0274752807,
0.0415916257,
0.0405182168,
-0.0203447044,
-0.0505492277,
0.0085096825,
-0.0115207396,
-0.0043144086,
0.0256881975,
0.0180020258,
-0.0282049421,
-0.0188916586,
0.0189000573,
0.0517469049,
-0.0270721596,
0.0224397499,
0.0128967296,
0.0007528455,
-0.0680094361,
-0.0144082475,
0.0197083764,
0.0009634274,
0.1094718874,
0.0078710625,
-0.0133007038,
-0.0794686377,
0.0600250252,
-0.0296216011,
0.0156796668,
0.0081891464,
0.0223435294,
-0.0855893642,
0.0145828519,
-0.0092316475,
-0.0670181364,
-0.0509940796,
0.005129273,
-0.0772899985,
-0.0712919235,
0.0241708253,
0.0262237191,
0.0222901888,
0.0389850736,
-0.0002452121,
-0.0935718417,
0.1157382131,
-0.0178263597,
0.0266628135,
0.0223965831,
0.073080048,
-0.0081652515,
-0.0391153917,
-0.0123241795,
-0.0366329849,
0.0287944917,
-0.0221507624,
0.0323715322,
0.0010808348,
-0.0187331829,
-0.0180387553,
0.0299915448,
0.0318664499,
-0.0220434312,
-0.0092107384,
-0.0326636247,
0.0441063307,
0.0734468549,
0.0548738092,
-0.0188764315,
0.0090431776,
0.0166708734,
0.0112799453,
0.0042675021,
0.0308511406,
0.0010897603,
-0.0465942249,
-0.0115056364,
0.0430366024,
0.0259682406,
0.0744653493,
-0.014464573,
-0.025450455,
-0.040272072,
0.05364272,
0.0236777533,
-0.0084447367,
-0.0208940785,
0.026888676,
0.0055134245,
0.0465177,
0.0337243713,
0.0237187706,
-0.0560490564,
-0.0610609911,
-0.0733586028,
0.0330636464,
0.0088731283,
0.0118745705,
0.0507952981,
0.0117417397,
0.0138481306,
-0.0395869464,
-0.0174612924,
-0.0241543893,
0.0088025965,
0.0166296847,
0.0387571566,
0.0126072727,
0.0154479071,
0.031298399,
-0.0090701645,
0.0713244304,
-0.065842092,
0.0225790702,
-0.0519352853,
-0.047963623,
-0.0292332228,
0.0007419753,
-0.0202286672,
-0.0295316875,
0.0241337772,
-0.0203701872,
0.0295530763,
0.0082643302,
0.070932284,
-0.0298892129,
0.0209395681,
0.0098834531,
-0.0505489707,
0.0133345341,
0.0281129852,
-0.0764833316,
0.0164158158,
0.0137554221,
-0.0141977947,
-6.540668769e-33,
-0.0100381682,
0.0571908951,
0.0140095577,
-0.0353415348,
-0.038868852,
0.0074698818,
0.0150214657,
-0.0003262934,
-0.0129261762,
-0.0321833715,
-0.001627087,
-0.0482069515,
0.04309218,
-0.0250497404,
-0.0233899262,
0.0022096669,
0.0897265971,
0.0139897382,
-0.0298956148,
-0.0329098552,
-0.0113261426,
0.0314608365,
0.0544168875,
0.022111889,
-0.0439643636,
0.0490102693,
-0.0525705926,
-0.0458727479,
0.0098149497,
0.0135505935,
0.0177115444,
0.0070444741,
-0.012286935,
-0.0232207626,
-0.0111402674,
-0.0368906669,
-0.0439333208,
-0.0032329035,
0.019377619,
0.0451960489,
0.0369096734,
-0.0006727845,
0.026426727,
-0.008238174,
-0.0828559846,
-0.020055186,
0.0124020074,
-0.0139044598,
-0.0440516137,
0.0012134226,
0.0184081458,
0.0421207696,
-0.0170400795,
-0.0047959089,
0.0358831808,
0.0551323071,
-0.0262948014,
-0.0054642954,
-0.0141517427,
0.026027238,
0.052884534,
0.0129757775,
0.0354290046,
0.0282758456,
0.0168632735,
0.0096792644,
0.0892132744,
-0.0608335771,
0.0087622134,
-0.0638702437,
0.0444437973,
0.013356491,
0.0030536039,
0.0185927842,
0.0131757809,
-0.0336856022,
-0.0361641347,
0.011723117,
0.0315386094,
0.0686308071,
0.0081941215,
0.0380861461,
-0.0480003729,
-0.0205198769,
-0.0778089836,
-0.0811785236,
-0.0314835422,
-0.0063516903,
0.0554992743,
0.0481963269,
-0.0171686988,
-0.016682921,
0.0503451042,
0.0352147892,
0.0603275001,
0.015654793,
0.0115709389,
0.007905703,
0.0011620249,
-0.0118737575,
-0.0530816428,
-0.0594102852,
0.024468502,
0.037595693,
0.030241929,
-0.0499583967,
-0.0328113101,
0.0722470209,
-0.0315148197,
-0.0113083199,
-0.0142159443,
0.0146501921,
0.0159909595,
0.0060644555,
0.0745479614,
-0.0253083315,
0.0124101853,
0.0682391971,
-0.042622108,
0.0182921626,
-0.0332274139,
0.0371305197,
0.040527422,
0.0557347611,
-0.0056528398,
0.0156650096,
0.0338220038,
-0.0333765671,
-0.0213039406,
-0.0211442076,
-0.0359660089,
0.0259950645,
2.815e-7,
-0.0631791353,
-0.0176390279,
0.036876142,
-0.0132973837,
-0.0187862683,
-0.0098621547,
-0.0205708109,
-0.0468330979,
0.0107894903,
0.0474922769,
0.031427566,
0.0012202114,
0.0581728667,
0.0153029216,
-0.0450657792,
-0.0894167572,
-0.0860076696,
0.0889065415,
0.0125539871,
0.0133289183,
-0.0105901677,
0.0542646125,
-0.007855528,
-0.0521060899,
0.012541024,
0.0188206602,
0.0205193385,
-0.012984653,
0.0347520746,
0.0101996846,
0.0089249518,
-0.0318717584,
-0.0054461826,
0.0206221342,
-0.0006452845,
0.048040539,
0.0104456032,
0.0066942587,
-0.015616104,
-0.0292932242,
0.0280204266,
0.0885282755,
-0.0144160269,
-0.0343226604,
0.0824461356,
-0.016975794,
-0.0188691895,
-0.073406063,
-0.064776428,
-0.0467629321,
0.0149568487,
-0.0222391523,
0.002569556,
0.0194875915,
-0.0238808282,
0.001646223,
-0.0265747346,
-0.0601718053,
0.0387215763,
0.0201030076,
-0.0519572236,
-0.0320740789,
-0.0468165427,
0.0065481709,
0.0024294392,
-0.0210350789,
-0.0109179243,
1.972484572e-34,
0.0630208105,
-0.0540733077,
0.0436772108,
-0.0099894721,
-0.0056941016,
-0.0362477601,
-0.0082583176,
-0.0001960065,
-0.0101992805,
-0.0357840434,
-0.0554208532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02773v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02773v1 | EduChat: A Large-Scale Language Model-based Chatbot System for Intelligent Education | 2023-08-05T02:55:35 | 2023-08-05T02:55:35 | Yuhao Dan, Zhikai Lei, Yiyang Gu, Yong Li, Jianghao Yin, Jiaju Lin, Linhao Ye, Zhiyan Tie, Yougen Zhou, Yilei Wang, Aimin Zhou, Ze Zhou, Qin Chen, Jie Zhou, Liang He, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | EduChat (https://www.educhat.top/) is a large-scale language model
(LLM)-based chatbot system in the education domain. Its goal is to support
personalized, fair, and compassionate intelligent education, serving teachers,
students, and parents. Guided by theories from psychology and education, it
further strengthens educational functions such as open question answering,
essay assessment, Socratic teaching, and emotional support based on the
existing basic LLMs. Particularly, we learn domain-specific knowledge by
pre-training on the educational corpus and stimulate various skills with tool
use by fine-tuning on designed system prompts and instructions. Currently,
EduChat is available online as an open-source project, with its code, data, and
model parameters available on platforms (e.g., GitHub
https://github.com/icalk-nlp/EduChat, Hugging Face
https://huggingface.co/ecnu-icalk ). We also prepare a demonstration of its
capabilities online (https://vimeo.com/851004454). This initiative aims to
promote research and applications of LLMs for intelligent education. | [
0.0841719061,
-0.024418233,
-0.0360975862,
0.0331303999,
-0.031057911,
0.0136082573,
0.0019257055,
-0.0161391161,
0.0684696063,
-0.0664749369,
-0.019978473,
0.0151377004,
-0.0598009974,
0.0256530177,
0.0032636696,
-0.0894222707,
0.0316124111,
-0.0021195821,
0.0170287341,
-0.0156291071,
0.0368433781,
0.0255320258,
-0.0442683473,
0.0525934882,
-0.0069398037,
-0.0221266188,
-0.0258540772,
0.0065783113,
-0.016903108,
-0.0012760916,
0.0488688461,
0.0512241945,
0.003278703,
0.0141275674,
0.0000022431,
-0.048800651,
-0.0235932097,
-0.0522065945,
-0.0124048945,
-0.0205084831,
0.0607724488,
0.0406693332,
-0.0349979699,
0.0254103262,
-0.0531918518,
0.0177524853,
0.0447509177,
0.0190492887,
0.0913378894,
0.0679233596,
0.0245368332,
-0.0109533034,
0.0289282445,
0.0308298953,
0.0092396541,
-0.0108984355,
0.0153944101,
0.0259077698,
0.0436002873,
0.0246691052,
-0.0301824976,
0.0357869826,
0.0107953846,
-0.0601184294,
0.0204943996,
-0.0037268293,
-0.0198102482,
-0.0588459261,
-0.0171269123,
0.0749792233,
0.028297605,
-0.0206581652,
0.0032139858,
0.0175920334,
0.0245218221,
0.019670669,
-0.0796002597,
0.0262657385,
0.0208094008,
0.0173463244,
0.0053298119,
-0.0393513814,
-0.0498561971,
0.0372279882,
0.0180961117,
0.01833608,
-0.0096809706,
-0.0205233507,
-0.0258994233,
0.0273423344,
-0.0206092671,
-0.0684543625,
0.0287672654,
0.0800299495,
0.009637679,
0.037021935,
-0.0189955477,
-0.0243474375,
0.00809428,
-0.0099371616,
-0.0486463383,
0.0627865046,
0.0084296865,
0.0374518745,
0.0346767493,
0.0619079918,
0.0425396115,
0.0588555224,
-0.0198833589,
0.0024232713,
-0.0462456793,
-0.0111189317,
-0.0397171862,
0.0412384793,
-0.0010679046,
0.0090510566,
-0.0638147891,
0.0507055335,
0.0026598822,
0.0092414273,
-0.0160295498,
-0.0064044823,
0.0030705945,
0.0092552323,
-0.0520624667,
0.0390863754,
-0.0223213471,
-0.0169805884,
0.0046452656,
-0.0496938899,
0.005420384,
0.023455698,
-0.0255974829,
0.0027405971,
0.0167984758,
0.0657561794,
0.0085665472,
-0.0404462777,
-0.0106143178,
-0.0351761952,
-0.0013381731,
-0.0380181707,
0.0045566708,
-0.0963363722,
0.0038939891,
0.0132422345,
0.004276061,
-0.0323347673,
0.009513556,
0.0295994673,
-0.0004591179,
0.018254213,
-0.0306562055,
0.0022895434,
0.0585724711,
0.0309269577,
0.013003001,
0.0615117885,
0.0284388233,
-0.0056184689,
0.0472718924,
-0.0192044061,
0.0022682936,
0.039365463,
-0.0037084825,
-0.0199909341,
0.025203377,
0.0042786123,
-0.0015639866,
0.0282287784,
-0.0240362417,
0.0324601009,
-0.012074477,
0.0002167216,
0.0324556008,
0.0802060217,
-0.0336587913,
0.0231148545,
0.0030696441,
0.0551483743,
0.0691914186,
0.0040346049,
-0.0412372686,
0.021213809,
-0.0302212872,
-0.0344594829,
0.0052538333,
0.0016285593,
-0.0113033839,
-0.0780778453,
-0.0156907924,
-0.0278297756,
0.0069574774,
0.0261238813,
0.0566546433,
-0.0193886962,
0.0083786901,
0.0192621239,
0.0637235865,
-0.0364683568,
0.0074262433,
-0.0779632106,
0.0559967607,
0.0867221653,
0.0591394454,
-0.0784243345,
-0.046280846,
-0.007321313,
0.0195067972,
0.0501571484,
0.0281112697,
-0.0197203383,
-0.0549751259,
-0.0311542768,
-0.0272004288,
-0.0073600714,
-0.0176637862,
-0.0143179018,
0.0069801589,
0.0117390333,
-0.0309041534,
0.0193693899,
-0.0145729603,
0.0316314399,
-0.0365193486,
-0.0231730416,
-0.0649618059,
0.0032218962,
0.0030530465,
0.0374977887,
0.0092917997,
-0.0072614509,
0.0301069785,
0.008831297,
-0.0362353362,
-0.0150605962,
-0.0409138054,
-0.0122761903,
0.0879202783,
-0.0431866087,
-0.0215549022,
0.0384584703,
-0.011477259,
-0.0159420967,
0.0291317869,
-0.0380448513,
0.045816008,
-0.0178514924,
0.0297260061,
-0.0576518103,
-0.0207082536,
-0.0646551475,
0.0262181628,
0.0428901091,
-0.0033633553,
0.0251597203,
0.0281041898,
-0.0028498061,
-0.0139942886,
-0.0243509877,
0.0226097666,
0.0042325021,
0.0218299702,
0.0217757188,
0.0457815304,
-0.0860142335,
-0.0409625843,
-0.1018785536,
0.0087298499,
0.0176782943,
-0.009050454,
0.0088910777,
-0.0060678045,
-0.0302726701,
-0.0183982644,
-0.0454076305,
0.0283458792,
0.021986695,
-0.0006633108,
0.0221539773,
-0.0233943053,
-0.0287654176,
-0.0648996159,
-0.0020249388,
-0.0318710394,
-0.0056372238,
0.0642834008,
-0.0155037045,
-0.044096522,
0.059425883,
-0.0415523611,
0.0343282819,
0.0138144428,
-0.0636160746,
0.0283774529,
-0.0251079854,
0.0457331873,
0.0852123201,
0.0316937976,
0.0458652712,
0.0263509527,
-0.0053793821,
-0.1004356742,
0.0189717673,
-0.0104311816,
-0.0117050409,
-0.0416491963,
-0.0161657184,
-0.0460877642,
0.047416918,
0.0239141975,
-0.0230357684,
-0.0570974611,
0.0635187104,
-0.0150471944,
0.0044098068,
-0.0302304793,
0.0025673409,
-0.0072081885,
0.0034551956,
0.0157968886,
-0.0256839842,
0.0852227658,
0.0007632523,
-0.0025102571,
-0.0620872863,
-0.0195635799,
-0.0276864711,
0.0446587428,
-0.0296761487,
0.0176517703,
-0.0015245909,
-0.0141675975,
-0.0466534793,
0.0149508109,
0.0182169545,
-0.0742628351,
-0.0031977547,
-0.0463777073,
-0.031020239,
0.0075465809,
-0.0201341212,
-0.0603130534,
-0.020748673,
-0.0513399802,
-0.0015691069,
-0.0074667404,
0.0071670124,
-0.0310749672,
-0.0281297229,
0.0344512016,
-0.009414169,
-0.0259098094,
-0.018917026,
-0.0140738906,
-0.0344583876,
0.039941337,
0.0151632018,
0.0118363397,
-0.0237926561,
0.085895963,
0.077408731,
0.0106102778,
0.0024919806,
0.0364703909,
-0.0048311432,
0.0563274696,
-0.0145319616,
-0.0219309591,
-0.0194698013,
0.0653660446,
-0.0592622049,
0.0059785387,
0.1424846649,
0.026490042,
-0.057673879,
-0.0119019961,
-0.0627920926,
0.0089028087,
0.0178305134,
0.0555622242,
-0.0683544278,
-0.0398522951,
-0.0243063644,
0.0453012586,
-0.0145025263,
-0.0349059291,
0.0080863088,
-0.0735021904,
0.0094189411,
0.0110729262,
-0.0057420153,
-0.0236863121,
-0.0288647544,
-0.0140164057,
0.0078611569,
-0.0173143744,
0.0040831002,
-0.0158970878,
0.0037622999,
0.0267339479,
-0.0082680965,
-0.0010999542,
0.0361523516,
-0.026306117,
0.070500128,
0.027874073,
0.0454367474,
0.0032974533,
-0.0086388746,
0.0114741763,
0.0338490643,
-0.034278553,
-0.0155965295,
0.0150730768,
-0.0367414579,
-0.00310629,
-0.0618110411,
0.0461164415,
-0.0077121458,
0.0154293664,
0.0531675294,
0.0846088603,
-0.0169184618,
0.0265166573,
-0.0447079502,
0.0251551699,
-0.0065151546,
0.0535173938,
0.0165216196,
-0.0811891928,
-0.0203673448,
-0.0562328212,
-0.0326304473,
0.0107594291,
-0.0762433633,
0.01166216,
-0.0390303656,
0.0164611153,
-0.0755931884,
-0.0419707559,
0.0514953285,
0.009264118,
0.0144920638,
-0.0120070903,
0.03384896,
0.0234779809,
-0.0139021212,
0.0130766453,
-0.0467413478,
0.0093293712,
-0.0901102275,
-0.061655961,
0.0106187798,
-0.0635383427,
-0.0041573178,
0.0041237618,
-0.032270804,
-0.0717272162,
0.0005818584,
0.0167027246,
0.0171132572,
0.0242301505,
-0.0037817582,
-0.046536129,
0.0136105493,
-0.0018723918,
-0.022723902,
0.0115579041,
0.0070503722,
0.0294112675,
0.0145462006,
0.0081571732,
-0.0413942672,
0.0310200378,
0.0233105924,
0.0146903517,
-0.0254478343,
-0.0619518682,
0.0328083225,
0.0457025468,
0.0147404177,
0.0027096858,
-0.0574412793,
-0.0324028172,
0.0071150153,
-0.0319678113,
-0.0121568851,
-0.0469432026,
-0.000178382,
-0.0061668339,
-0.0438054837,
0.0272924434,
-0.0282707773,
-0.0350982621,
0.0127926497,
-0.0022666079,
0.0506857634,
-0.0251660608,
0.0106389793,
0.0101247085,
0.0138785075,
-0.0171035286,
0.0045807636,
0.0018558371,
0.0473259687,
0.0028015575,
0.0988256335,
-0.0029223757,
-0.035475418,
0.0443014875,
0.0257421061,
-0.0344346315,
-0.0429973677,
0.0044037574,
0.0705108717,
0.0394601673,
0.0306401271,
0.0304957386,
-0.0513034575,
0.0218039453,
-0.0247075949,
0.0241354611,
0.0016227934,
-0.0237156618,
0.0224746391,
0.0033207168,
0.0145940911,
0.0129851634,
0.0238084942,
-0.0201263539,
0.0442069136,
-0.0026412969,
-0.0027293465,
-0.0253033936,
0.002330496,
0.0518210307,
0.0063795019,
0.0040717875,
0.0263326056,
-0.0220318977,
-0.0228300467,
-0.025330456,
0.0376762338,
-0.0326301903,
-0.0293820612,
0.0436464958,
0.0529877059,
-0.0362035148,
0.0086297309,
-0.0625238195,
0.0488992222,
-0.0317663662,
-0.0473859087,
0.0063657644,
-6.132685904e-33,
-0.0494459867,
-0.0388831832,
0.0255267769,
0.0758296028,
-0.0309456363,
-0.0172277931,
-0.0163603164,
0.0444306508,
-0.0208819807,
-0.0039500012,
-0.0051756841,
0.0246792994,
-0.0022472492,
-0.0042612408,
0.0142647969,
-0.0111849438,
0.0019229647,
-0.0193734225,
-0.0065514776,
0.0271853209,
0.0319234282,
0.024371421,
0.0582500473,
-0.0494137853,
0.0348500274,
-0.0372850448,
0.0244496595,
0.0187837481,
-0.0131354667,
0.0562238693,
-0.0150467549,
0.0570463613,
0.0079209441,
-0.0104819871,
-0.0180122573,
0.0346733145,
-0.0479560122,
-0.0553119294,
0.0169430207,
0.0251243971,
-0.0284110922,
-0.0441472605,
0.0311467405,
-0.0250677057,
-0.0218062196,
0.0084928609,
0.0570914298,
-0.014234554,
0.0410938784,
0.0370125808,
-0.0540384836,
0.0090241143,
-0.0434287451,
-0.068752192,
-0.0290180165,
0.0513559878,
0.0114123961,
0.0115856323,
-0.0086536529,
0.0590815358,
-0.0020344623,
0.0078126751,
0.044005692,
-0.0330830179,
0.0085970685,
0.0835455209,
0.0344112851,
-0.0139348079,
-0.0032487458,
0.004035674,
0.0382006913,
0.0178444367,
0.0729101673,
0.0263064392,
-0.0582002923,
-0.0250042751,
-0.0692271665,
0.0358913578,
0.0944192857,
-0.0082933214,
-0.0027139147,
-0.0107837198,
-0.0438972712,
0.0147198299,
-0.0233746488,
0.0394534804,
-0.0008523709,
-0.0370853804,
0.0112361079,
-0.0335249007,
-0.0263616908,
-0.0808067769,
-0.0056977756,
-0.0616469942,
0.0045272596,
-0.0088605676,
-0.0050999359,
0.0274018887,
-0.0297138169,
0.0206974261,
-0.0032209672,
-0.0172450654,
0.016459465,
-0.0574152172,
0.0137002384,
0.0267820321,
-0.0200860258,
0.0238147601,
-0.0040168092,
-0.0071864082,
-0.0311524607,
0.0310608651,
0.0152069451,
-0.0268899556,
-0.0202234667,
0.0198296066,
-0.0079828119,
0.0524239652,
0.0249462314,
-0.014483084,
-0.0446500257,
-0.03642774,
0.0187187232,
-0.00166599,
-0.0589004494,
-0.0054600853,
-0.0691450983,
0.0240304526,
-0.0396258645,
-0.0607600473,
0.0075140991,
-0.007660809,
2.852e-7,
0.0184644889,
0.064784281,
0.0104096774,
0.0001321504,
0.0164121985,
0.0349771678,
-0.0118177831,
0.0173198003,
0.0430929512,
0.0129945679,
-0.0138357673,
0.0412394777,
0.0419738926,
-0.0037027355,
-0.1188769117,
-0.0444562696,
0.0068950718,
-0.0285432916,
-0.0383600295,
0.0503726378,
0.0931443423,
0.0493724123,
0.0415992402,
0.0064675407,
-0.0355755277,
-0.0119915921,
0.0077687819,
-0.015548842,
-0.0183558911,
0.036577832,
0.0086422563,
0.0013165661,
0.0304817297,
0.0003008299,
0.0272414014,
0.0135721033,
-0.0035241332,
0.0824140757,
0.0051664147,
-0.0123858331,
0.0535705462,
-0.0168391541,
-0.0259787124,
-0.0488426425,
0.0694575012,
-0.0189115051,
-0.0085759191,
-0.0060571125,
-0.0058580982,
-0.0677580088,
0.0180316791,
-0.0393630378,
-0.0309355892,
-0.0017837487,
-0.0112865493,
-0.0471553802,
0.0298081338,
-0.0281777214,
0.0069444738,
-0.0363012888,
-0.0446014479,
-0.0707609355,
-0.0159180574,
-0.0158383492,
-0.0001875115,
-0.0284024626,
0.0212944038,
2.273530282e-34,
0.0052294023,
-0.0005550671,
0.0205032304,
0.032208059,
0.031883046,
0.0238242652,
0.008678114,
0.0150364693,
0.0467214882,
-0.0523766987,
-0.0315684341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02746v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02746v1 | Meta-Tsallis-Entropy Minimization: A New Self-Training Approach for Domain Adaptation on Text Classification | 2023-08-04T23:50:58 | 2023-08-04T23:50:58 | Menglong Lu, Zhen Huang, Zhiliang Tian, Yunxiang Zhao, Xuanyu Fei, Dongsheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text classification is a fundamental task for natural language processing,
and adapting text classification models across domains has broad applications.
Self-training generates pseudo-examples from the model's predictions and
iteratively trains on the pseudo-examples, i.e., minimizes the loss on the
source domain and the Gibbs entropy on the target domain. However, Gibbs
entropy is sensitive to prediction errors, and thus, self-training tends to
fail when the domain shift is large. In this paper, we propose Meta-Tsallis
Entropy minimization (MTEM), which applies a meta-learning algorithm to
optimize the instance adaptive Tsallis entropy on the target domain. To reduce
the computation cost of MTEM, we propose an approximation technique to
approximate the Second-order derivation involved in the meta-learning. To
efficiently generate pseudo labels, we propose an annealing sampling mechanism
for exploring the model's prediction probability. Theoretically, we prove the
convergence of the meta-learning algorithm in MTEM and analyze the
effectiveness of MTEM in achieving domain adaptation. Experimentally, MTEM
improves the adaptation performance of BERT with an average of 4 percent on the
benchmark dataset. | [
0.0312482063,
-0.0464153588,
-0.0182027109,
0.0002384823,
-0.0107152816,
0.0292310454,
0.0118900966,
-0.0035324446,
-0.0402740128,
-0.0505397879,
-0.0662222728,
0.0168841332,
-0.026536772,
-0.0195414219,
-0.0105141122,
-0.0414309725,
0.0292697232,
0.0002414926,
-0.0181313716,
-0.0256295186,
-0.0128572704,
-0.0163433477,
-0.0126869185,
-0.0255673546,
0.049324438,
-0.0044052429,
0.0024929028,
0.0113691194,
0.0438298173,
-0.0157800671,
0.0075265383,
0.0206561424,
0.0090852547,
0.0380477346,
0.0000019501,
-0.0594314896,
-0.0360491909,
0.0051998692,
0.0196664371,
-0.0085563622,
0.0622648373,
-0.0032978456,
-0.0148038007,
0.0385867618,
-0.0374609455,
-0.0644813254,
0.06773296,
0.0404886603,
0.0420902148,
0.0638355315,
-0.0217450485,
-0.0346611291,
-0.0309211537,
-0.0286181234,
0.006201419,
-0.0565041304,
0.0417242311,
-0.0593005344,
-0.045015879,
-0.0320920907,
0.0107658198,
0.0205195677,
-0.0136351539,
0.0260174759,
-0.0010856049,
0.0193109009,
0.013725738,
0.052696716,
-0.0227056034,
0.0298215356,
0.0196324121,
-0.0488720089,
-0.0095675904,
-0.0121297874,
0.0259474255,
0.0519763418,
0.0087545281,
-0.0481657423,
-0.0029095276,
0.0067105056,
-0.0363677964,
0.0166387912,
0.0138828466,
0.0087020099,
-0.0453411452,
0.0208142716,
-0.011680224,
-0.0586349331,
0.0223850645,
0.0005775306,
-0.0291319024,
0.0355933756,
0.0255281273,
0.0049426476,
0.0208897851,
0.0035793385,
-0.0444360375,
-0.0564739257,
-0.0322800055,
-0.0784228221,
0.0381054766,
0.009232494,
0.0182420146,
0.0145175103,
-0.0044544549,
-0.0335301012,
0.0199003629,
0.0349356271,
-0.0479786657,
0.0089912759,
-0.1023792252,
0.0231646188,
-0.0960525572,
0.0598450303,
0.0341031179,
0.0437834598,
-0.0328684747,
0.0252992343,
0.0268797353,
-0.0493033044,
0.0367797576,
-0.0299035106,
-0.0311133973,
-0.0338362977,
0.0039810478,
0.0175904147,
-0.0204853639,
0.0183898993,
-0.0216688253,
0.0324649848,
-0.0008413372,
-0.0099169891,
0.0150132384,
-0.0425476842,
0.0153856985,
0.0788363144,
0.0060669803,
-0.0574666187,
-0.0722241178,
0.0852096751,
-0.0237720963,
-0.0063264049,
0.0220768079,
-0.0015624188,
-0.0065187272,
-0.0236124694,
0.0022343956,
-0.0341426171,
-0.0372337252,
-0.035151992,
-0.0020377475,
0.0600383356,
-0.0584370829,
-0.0134636229,
0.0699679777,
-0.0138106002,
-0.0050248071,
0.0861343518,
0.0646806285,
-0.003466872,
0.0030269711,
-0.0174816046,
0.0025983122,
0.0135660581,
0.0282975882,
0.0178996567,
-0.0117100887,
-0.008264645,
-0.011282647,
0.0118489303,
0.0295947101,
-0.0226766746,
0.0048344885,
-0.0197112374,
0.0361515842,
-0.0097458269,
0.0191159733,
0.0340022705,
0.0046578264,
-0.0144281257,
0.026783172,
0.0076843086,
-0.0160438381,
0.0139248185,
-0.0391370356,
-0.0150237763,
0.00303412,
-0.0135729024,
-0.0553103164,
-0.0410160199,
0.0203760937,
0.0129751442,
-0.0445120819,
-0.0314714499,
0.0687548369,
0.0304460377,
0.005287163,
0.0401613079,
0.0356180966,
-0.0148289353,
0.0086769555,
-0.0220946055,
-0.0350533687,
0.0524713211,
0.0132479612,
-0.1021512672,
-0.0236090645,
-0.0221475214,
0.0250222385,
0.0450966842,
0.0271045994,
-0.0011177063,
0.01012717,
-0.0460869223,
0.0125056235,
0.039252501,
0.0132767251,
0.0323020183,
-0.045012176,
0.0115687978,
0.0113322269,
-0.1042697579,
0.0116996719,
0.0373610519,
-0.0582932532,
-0.0448493361,
0.0602491423,
0.0279101096,
0.0183712933,
0.00269734,
-0.0574508794,
-0.0096006626,
-0.0016225997,
-0.0382037945,
-0.0309164524,
0.0118993986,
0.0031236915,
-0.0445030741,
0.0385552794,
-0.0318711102,
0.0029404296,
0.0185623728,
-0.059175726,
-0.0350225493,
0.0294388421,
-0.0087364418,
0.0379830971,
-0.0654248968,
0.0138707003,
-0.020250855,
0.0200311542,
-0.0451934524,
0.0246789455,
0.0234187767,
-0.0124132307,
-0.0505499691,
-0.0488365181,
0.0022217724,
0.0102215083,
-0.0005142625,
0.0097978311,
-0.0263016373,
0.0418602005,
0.0176125877,
0.0114559829,
-0.0122810202,
-0.0066699656,
-0.0295469146,
-0.0043561207,
-0.0312825143,
0.064965032,
0.0243740566,
0.0249823444,
-0.0231720917,
-0.0134966327,
0.0045455778,
0.0165207423,
-0.07300964,
-0.0053949216,
0.0357361436,
0.0115821371,
0.0371732898,
0.0103681693,
-0.0114764692,
0.0019988664,
0.0598350801,
-0.0374623165,
0.0281658769,
-0.0495370515,
0.0272734631,
0.0113379061,
0.0281359497,
0.0315145031,
-0.0238948092,
-0.0852797851,
-0.0172169413,
-0.0154597657,
0.0015019887,
0.0527005009,
-0.0414541587,
0.0516771972,
0.0747691244,
-0.0375047699,
0.0156155257,
-0.0341322832,
0.018459579,
-0.0291290134,
-0.0340188928,
0.0293611716,
0.063356936,
-0.0244538747,
-0.0078234458,
-0.0521434098,
-0.0039025487,
0.017329108,
-0.0578227863,
-0.0116941864,
0.072524175,
-0.0168415401,
-0.0242207944,
-0.0135663981,
-0.0103203012,
0.0784220397,
0.0121397413,
0.0197357461,
-0.0942431986,
-0.0234622918,
-0.0104402425,
-0.0015917215,
-0.0062292651,
0.0295316,
0.0957302228,
-0.0050107832,
-0.0350461379,
-0.0530896075,
0.0732956231,
0.0068722446,
-0.0102837337,
0.0098078046,
0.0260129664,
0.0011747843,
-0.028774742,
0.0065943734,
-0.0325337611,
0.006892758,
-0.053513322,
-0.0790777504,
0.012992274,
-0.0671469048,
-0.0064132963,
0.0066629634,
0.0688630864,
0.0060898247,
-0.0423088484,
0.0068208673,
0.0508095324,
0.0292486865,
0.0123341093,
-0.0282994453,
0.0011024973,
0.0557733774,
0.0107403509,
0.0605370998,
0.0292855687,
-0.0375758521,
-0.0258092061,
0.0288696215,
-0.0482021533,
0.0108724851,
0.0076776338,
-0.0193311702,
0.0236864798,
-0.0298068933,
0.0836510211,
0.0430955812,
-0.0384504013,
-0.0225821082,
-0.030226633,
0.006666515,
-0.0078055989,
0.0310898889,
-0.0121414913,
-0.0301515162,
-0.0021766156,
0.0352916457,
-0.0031539178,
-0.0075080018,
0.0025783074,
-0.0648845136,
-0.0094465362,
0.0019391443,
-0.0699066669,
-0.0031643133,
-0.0354421251,
0.0088541266,
-0.0146550946,
-0.0152612329,
-0.0219092928,
-0.0241503492,
-0.0062650442,
0.0817672983,
-0.0131162321,
-0.0530722216,
-0.0094341869,
-0.0119569851,
0.0317514353,
0.0729319602,
0.0248892717,
-0.0426316075,
0.0004977896,
0.0721791089,
0.0014882211,
-0.0221835412,
-0.021690404,
0.0801802799,
-0.0280212592,
0.0314495191,
0.0383179225,
-0.0088632647,
-0.0508424751,
0.0045968639,
0.0622898564,
0.0507864803,
0.0193172097,
-0.0210364275,
-0.0122216754,
-0.0089013437,
-0.0094863903,
0.0218107626,
0.0022606673,
-0.0853289291,
0.0028284998,
0.0011281066,
-0.0037297006,
-0.0581681319,
0.0265375879,
0.0290261526,
-0.0242484417,
-0.076888673,
-0.0564136095,
0.0098535689,
-0.0268388111,
0.0715040714,
0.0124525707,
-0.0100507615,
0.0125637231,
0.0387601517,
-0.058009427,
-0.0504434854,
-0.0384712517,
-0.0284351222,
-0.0473212004,
0.0137554025,
0.0894547999,
-0.049427975,
0.0007949774,
-0.0274223685,
0.0026124832,
-0.048950579,
0.0022369076,
0.043471422,
0.0096883466,
0.0253405105,
0.0042767073,
-0.0410094671,
0.0888310224,
0.1064647064,
-0.0017021208,
0.0080640372,
0.0733258128,
-0.0294605382,
-0.0189952627,
0.0226058047,
-0.0248603411,
0.0314574093,
0.0354160517,
-0.0236591827,
0.0000814175,
-0.0105286883,
0.0190035217,
0.0089312252,
0.0602005012,
-0.0073148431,
-0.042988956,
-0.0104362462,
0.0365456752,
0.03605498,
0.0156019405,
-0.0136753479,
0.0132134613,
0.0250647739,
-0.009352589,
-0.0242794249,
0.0472156927,
-0.0145353423,
-0.0162749998,
0.0159314666,
0.0281025395,
-0.0238028895,
0.1118455902,
-0.0185700227,
0.0037460332,
0.0130442688,
-0.0674885884,
0.1000833064,
0.0186658818,
-0.0086021246,
0.0135319438,
0.0378016643,
0.0172069259,
-0.0234871879,
0.0337490588,
-0.0817975327,
0.0550927147,
-0.0761828497,
0.0066179154,
0.0492528528,
0.0417434275,
0.0075260573,
0.0036769451,
0.0021890514,
-0.0196181592,
0.0091346391,
0.0095642982,
0.0459283032,
-0.0071442919,
-0.0197302401,
-0.0114730112,
0.0007809983,
0.0465642177,
0.0406048074,
0.0476433076,
0.039565973,
-0.0067528286,
-0.0462113433,
-0.0081724143,
-0.0596025325,
0.0061327359,
-0.0095885899,
0.015943693,
-0.0482602231,
-0.0399995781,
0.0489401966,
-0.02901184,
0.029916143,
-0.0035398817,
0.0395643674,
0.0410947315,
-0.0012009272,
0.0260528456,
-0.0088067437,
-0.0035620902,
0.0365806371,
0.0141886612,
0.0217379797,
-5.758443033e-33,
-0.0391728468,
0.0326257162,
0.0059060878,
0.0073081385,
0.0090515977,
-0.0675830543,
0.0005328045,
-0.0131176282,
-0.0129118869,
-0.0075814957,
-0.0181463528,
-0.0031342979,
0.0202687085,
0.0239043124,
-0.0216579027,
-0.0216510389,
0.0415201671,
-0.0378794186,
-0.037447881,
-0.0205468573,
0.0034099026,
0.0487119108,
0.054813832,
-0.0503859073,
-0.0243597049,
0.0406625085,
-0.01684919,
-0.004877978,
0.0528299697,
-0.000304099,
0.0038446228,
0.0650534108,
0.0151400995,
-0.0475550443,
-0.0001604415,
-0.0037429775,
-0.0980092213,
-0.0816677287,
-0.0075436938,
0.0208308138,
0.0161361322,
-0.0323606767,
0.0065967776,
0.0427192263,
-0.0171829574,
-0.0328442305,
0.0354374945,
-0.0540290587,
-0.0339749679,
-0.0342088714,
-0.0212757718,
0.0377560146,
0.0048264624,
-0.0056286207,
0.0512563996,
0.0230364017,
0.0146450065,
-0.0223287605,
-0.0290104449,
0.026472114,
0.0165467132,
0.0123429596,
-0.0139615238,
0.0244960617,
-0.0088771926,
0.0080906339,
0.0524939448,
0.0155447116,
0.0521188118,
-0.0270452742,
0.0312197525,
-0.0219275877,
-0.0401595645,
0.0645319745,
0.0446710996,
-0.0700239167,
-0.0581507348,
0.0731595457,
-0.0234678891,
-0.0374097079,
0.0142095778,
-0.0114252549,
-0.0364758335,
0.0116178179,
-0.0342202298,
0.0006608535,
-0.019537257,
-0.0287317336,
-0.0074537657,
-0.0025639057,
-0.042751994,
0.0237862058,
-0.0055594253,
-0.0395209193,
-0.0006429126,
-0.0172832794,
-0.0164739322,
0.0218815599,
-0.0039856839,
0.0084804427,
0.0100800283,
-0.0612003654,
-0.0008932877,
0.0537169799,
0.0102196187,
-0.0197302308,
0.06018373,
-0.007450812,
-0.0733892992,
-0.000691861,
0.0134300468,
0.0016545457,
0.0254768971,
0.0053414158,
-0.0444442295,
0.0145082967,
0.0143759158,
0.0327046774,
0.0218886733,
-0.0676179603,
-0.0176979061,
0.1005249619,
-0.0034158682,
0.0415942632,
0.0047002696,
-0.0040029008,
-0.0048845308,
-0.0155200018,
0.0319791324,
-0.0661010221,
-0.0276516154,
-0.0427687019,
2.683e-7,
0.0338819921,
0.063195549,
0.0014635876,
-0.047710482,
-0.0035408677,
0.0698506758,
-0.0302504711,
0.0705755353,
0.0359653085,
0.0212672483,
0.0617280118,
-0.0117409145,
0.0057019629,
0.0114246616,
-0.0715939999,
-0.0150398137,
0.0001378884,
0.0636010095,
0.0292488467,
0.0371089689,
0.0096263736,
0.072201699,
0.0326189958,
-0.0283381511,
-0.001612104,
-0.0384366773,
0.0596670806,
-0.025009485,
0.0538479723,
0.0374291874,
-0.0618802086,
0.0109064365,
-0.0455776788,
0.0127153099,
-0.0361341313,
0.0298505966,
-0.016446352,
0.0103693614,
-0.0045844754,
-0.0011351756,
0.0252233781,
0.0136322957,
0.0339697376,
0.0440743454,
0.0306984205,
-0.0721478313,
-0.0341015384,
0.0109740281,
-0.0178635977,
0.0036848155,
0.0070158518,
-0.013318154,
-0.0023994953,
0.0120212231,
0.0085764136,
0.0159413256,
-0.0259780306,
-0.0719530582,
0.0219883118,
0.0236897096,
-0.0094160186,
-0.0124158273,
-0.0249151569,
0.0369946472,
0.0842803717,
-0.1164142713,
0.0557400845,
1.880769839e-34,
0.0172096267,
-0.0198683962,
-0.0212852061,
0.0061461702,
-0.0390112735,
-0.0297348015,
-0.0007221422,
-0.0097803529,
0.0263823923,
-0.0134493811,
0.0269459989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02727v1 | How Good Are SOTA Fake News Detectors | 2023-08-04T22:14:19 | 2023-08-04T22:14:19 | Matthew Iceland | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic fake news detection with machine learning can prevent the
dissemination of false statements before they gain many views. Several datasets
labeling statements as legitimate or false have been created since the 2016
United States presidential election for the prospect of training machine
learning models. We evaluate the robustness of both traditional and deep
state-of-the-art models to gauge how well they may perform in the real world.
We find that traditional models tend to generalize better to data outside the
distribution it was trained on compared to more recently-developed large
language models, though the best model to use may depend on the specific task
at hand. | [
0.0473393165,
0.0641196072,
0.0044109719,
0.0365276113,
-0.0296668448,
0.0221011806,
-0.0008989621,
-0.0157483406,
0.0195717625,
-0.0252291895,
0.0021063578,
-0.0369475707,
-0.0120237656,
0.0956437811,
-0.0056482446,
-0.0179998651,
0.0772566497,
0.0232831538,
0.0703722388,
-0.0385594219,
0.0292943269,
0.0223424118,
-0.0168672465,
0.0161397755,
-0.0612441599,
0.0068296241,
0.0261319727,
-0.0036967555,
0.0364562199,
-0.0024333328,
0.0013867383,
0.0373473987,
0.0391322263,
0.1050967127,
0.0000016023,
0.0099289501,
-0.015304843,
0.0043983976,
-0.0554059371,
0.0208259076,
0.0539386831,
-0.0980621725,
-0.0200824533,
0.0307114534,
-0.0229583085,
-0.0379297398,
0.0279306341,
0.0448395386,
0.0830540806,
0.1048484668,
-0.0063008852,
-0.0154226078,
0.0559941679,
-0.0273734517,
-0.038460236,
-0.0463480242,
0.0528945625,
-0.0096736094,
-0.0572380386,
0.0334846377,
0.0255859885,
0.0015761161,
0.0429722592,
-0.0070181927,
-0.0538742691,
0.0257939845,
-0.0527557172,
-0.0233074166,
-0.0089765005,
0.0489193089,
-0.0379239582,
-0.0721999109,
0.0223877151,
-0.0174108688,
-0.0074066324,
0.0368997976,
0.0147696109,
0.0182940606,
-0.0278055128,
0.0107108755,
0.0375598334,
-0.0097700655,
0.04937727,
0.0536212288,
0.0126995118,
0.0594369136,
-0.0358661339,
-0.0353778265,
0.0298697632,
-0.0063734511,
-0.0239550211,
-0.0221871864,
0.02173746,
-0.0295344088,
-0.0286203083,
0.0071810777,
-0.0895735845,
0.0026463976,
0.0200377945,
-0.0748853907,
-0.0098605398,
-0.0091378409,
-0.026911132,
0.0685774088,
-0.0195060484,
-0.0051105139,
-0.0220624097,
0.0384750776,
0.0246189181,
-0.0315385759,
-0.0129994629,
0.010431462,
0.0142856454,
0.0320790559,
-0.0456960239,
0.0048227604,
-0.0357798636,
-0.0226080529,
-0.0196021199,
0.0446901582,
-0.0356974378,
-0.0194366165,
-0.025541069,
-0.0168281998,
-0.0162798353,
0.0333809331,
0.000808061,
0.0517726801,
-0.0043086722,
-0.0726649985,
0.0119025344,
0.022787068,
-0.0047967695,
0.0163251013,
0.0195667837,
-0.011629126,
-0.0108037787,
0.0046755746,
-0.038849771,
-0.02075742,
-0.0209416375,
-0.0432919934,
0.0279722735,
-0.0663511455,
0.01860171,
-0.044889804,
0.0046536266,
-0.0094956001,
-0.0089595867,
0.0392896384,
-0.0062762387,
0.0472750552,
0.0242470019,
0.0200270675,
0.0671570525,
0.007571951,
0.0217928104,
0.0890812278,
-0.0092830667,
0.0984569192,
0.0551597141,
0.0034999638,
0.0226432439,
0.0173269697,
0.0571682267,
0.0425989218,
0.0174546614,
0.007058749,
-0.0330382884,
-0.0005595924,
-0.0021790504,
0.0242248531,
0.0033697367,
-0.0393296704,
0.0836869255,
-0.019809356,
-0.0152467228,
0.0113905007,
0.0574439429,
0.02378387,
0.0164270476,
0.0014068052,
-0.0428402685,
0.0014647042,
-0.0400382616,
-0.025291739,
-0.0059363768,
0.0497327633,
-0.0222239755,
-0.028917158,
-0.0094439369,
0.009121079,
-0.0300018303,
0.01025216,
0.0000249157,
-0.0085783247,
-0.0242335685,
0.0251846239,
0.0161682889,
-0.0039354339,
-0.0011985018,
-0.0658622608,
0.0274999849,
0.0004273771,
0.0086822473,
-0.0100912852,
0.0320779271,
-0.0446369089,
0.0399285816,
0.0417146422,
0.0764159039,
-0.0005916252,
-0.0148821697,
0.014361022,
0.0239412356,
-0.0176106375,
0.0435431562,
0.0277489722,
0.0305546075,
0.0428476371,
0.0087861018,
-0.0184952579,
-0.0483829826,
0.0172009412,
-0.0044163945,
-0.0066511286,
0.0118431766,
0.0348543003,
0.0290683843,
0.021088643,
-0.024184389,
-0.0355773047,
0.0451815128,
0.0056954972,
-0.0280887391,
-0.0553631671,
-0.0247235894,
-0.0147243896,
-0.0126571395,
-0.0402984805,
-0.0276978724,
0.091502592,
-0.0435102507,
0.0232663732,
0.0109337112,
-0.0265036058,
-0.047836218,
-0.0366284959,
-0.0346771702,
-0.0257662944,
0.0268021803,
0.0421868637,
0.0840552524,
-0.0401317552,
-0.0042057498,
-0.0122799724,
0.0025822569,
0.018660916,
-0.0118655516,
-0.0252619665,
-0.01637513,
-0.0155949118,
0.0102800867,
0.0209551211,
-0.0175778475,
-0.0060341028,
-0.008910358,
-0.0578658655,
-0.0126262307,
-0.0419826582,
-0.0016319278,
0.0464428924,
-0.0239740834,
-0.0089401631,
0.0281477962,
-0.0375410691,
-0.026907634,
0.0199787747,
0.0000186002,
-0.012108501,
-0.0248961933,
0.0168585032,
-0.0151943248,
0.0031534224,
-0.0337949917,
0.0216015149,
0.001575299,
-0.0709962472,
-0.0100666219,
-0.0153859742,
-0.0463401265,
0.0271657966,
-0.0457732677,
-0.0265886448,
-0.0069836578,
0.0184682738,
-0.0278443303,
0.0859670639,
0.0344586447,
0.0653696358,
0.0232381001,
0.0797048807,
0.0014589927,
-0.0184669718,
-0.028748434,
0.0249230228,
-0.0281294398,
-0.0397151522,
0.0235871542,
0.0483873561,
0.0183030851,
0.0091320081,
0.0011472858,
0.0340388082,
-0.0140147153,
-0.0374753773,
0.0423366241,
-0.0067761922,
0.016538186,
0.0107326386,
-0.0359574519,
-0.021823179,
0.0767163187,
-0.0076258993,
0.0349545293,
-0.0127696926,
-0.0533040948,
-0.0190279726,
0.017282594,
-0.0047401921,
-0.0114821708,
0.0024245,
0.02069222,
0.0164868757,
-0.0245492402,
0.0538309216,
-0.0465174392,
0.0024242939,
-0.046254456,
0.041178219,
0.0090630287,
-0.0257535577,
-0.0607012957,
-0.1013492122,
-0.0132687883,
-0.011091047,
-0.0217526052,
-0.0172997396,
-0.0649453998,
-0.0371804647,
0.0317489654,
0.0675581843,
0.0012714898,
0.0221456494,
-0.0020799099,
0.0307692792,
0.0380360074,
-0.0174136292,
0.0469949134,
-0.0068326588,
-0.0175619964,
0.0353261679,
-0.0346922055,
0.038457606,
-0.0342389569,
-0.0436890125,
-0.0005989801,
0.0044538341,
0.0067315008,
-0.0134339426,
-0.0153569449,
-0.0389123261,
0.0041168006,
0.0713512525,
0.0214592069,
0.0018093148,
0.0040942892,
0.0644578561,
-0.0053914292,
0.0115643144,
-0.0346957296,
-0.1017365754,
-0.0070717088,
-0.0057121604,
-0.0134910783,
-0.0421661474,
-0.0148757324,
-0.0082268892,
-0.0972270519,
0.0097527681,
-0.0319636948,
-0.0278199445,
-0.0480832756,
-0.0551111959,
-0.0016326858,
-0.0235941727,
0.0064540319,
-0.0372759625,
0.0542634949,
-0.0413936488,
0.0057025468,
-0.0194932763,
-0.0904690176,
0.0161236972,
-0.0174918063,
0.0396497324,
0.0327686258,
0.0501178689,
-0.015425548,
-0.0549645908,
0.0187403057,
0.0216449313,
-0.0571924597,
-0.0134147676,
0.0666636303,
-0.0488682054,
-0.0081470814,
0.0049456791,
0.0434552468,
-0.0041703554,
0.0212208293,
-0.0071625849,
0.0216962863,
0.0207306258,
-0.0891862437,
-0.0146121802,
0.0161116812,
0.0297911204,
0.056112878,
0.0078106294,
0.0013343834,
-0.0038414691,
-0.0252815299,
0.0165361147,
-0.0126084238,
-0.0494525135,
0.0383474268,
-0.0037354764,
-0.03960374,
-0.0522422642,
-0.018740423,
-0.0323209167,
0.01172606,
-0.0331665203,
-0.0348480642,
0.0370570086,
-0.0082276594,
-0.0227327347,
0.0012150338,
-0.0371057466,
0.0300865099,
-0.0149794323,
-0.0132817384,
0.0224498007,
0.0198318642,
-0.0268912129,
0.0367507748,
-0.0931007713,
-0.0403671674,
0.0216049571,
0.0075509991,
0.0194896609,
0.0315248445,
-0.0253230147,
-0.0304445997,
0.0511388145,
0.0594345257,
-0.0400866047,
-0.0053483504,
0.0331083164,
-0.0130366208,
0.0441516377,
0.0171305425,
0.0034797804,
0.0529631227,
0.0194573458,
-0.0622133426,
-0.0439850464,
0.0240045302,
0.0190589353,
0.018098224,
0.045028206,
0.0425303765,
-0.0310795493,
-0.0293305106,
-0.030105833,
-0.0066747479,
-0.0248761214,
0.0095599666,
0.0352951139,
0.0352473147,
0.0275418907,
-0.0099239601,
0.0129528511,
-0.0195060372,
0.0390157402,
-0.0315433033,
-0.041626785,
-0.0115787163,
0.0584464222,
-0.0090452665,
-0.0172436349,
-0.0605905131,
0.0184186772,
0.0323613025,
0.0309614353,
-0.0085891662,
-0.0162284523,
0.0135543421,
-0.0147710629,
0.0370305404,
-0.0444912761,
-0.0467600152,
-0.0230205115,
-0.0575030819,
0.0688632801,
0.0312239341,
-0.0110726906,
-0.0092633953,
-0.0326635092,
-0.0324090794,
0.0001933018,
-0.0081322631,
0.0015342376,
-0.0332135595,
0.0028914227,
0.0148967505,
-0.0319674723,
0.0196329057,
0.0587222092,
0.0452275015,
0.0418494157,
0.0367739648,
-0.0548848249,
-0.0418932438,
-0.0097458279,
-0.0284177344,
0.019421,
0.004736566,
-0.0084374947,
-0.0560489744,
-0.0375326239,
0.037949685,
-0.0029746157,
0.0373705961,
0.0400283746,
-0.0324581265,
0.0962929875,
0.0029745693,
0.0245527476,
-0.0292017199,
0.0036213454,
0.0145604461,
-0.0491948798,
-0.0033426576,
-5.878101011e-33,
0.017615106,
0.0016365953,
-0.0219667405,
-0.044638183,
0.0062614419,
0.0637613386,
0.0185829718,
-0.0342794284,
-0.0581340641,
0.0416243151,
0.0363611504,
0.0541714653,
-0.0077312719,
0.0335021913,
-0.0871518925,
-0.0394228697,
0.0270626545,
-0.0203851573,
-0.0422262214,
0.003872572,
0.0424678065,
-0.0346544571,
0.0330791138,
-0.0613250583,
0.0200358368,
-0.0062651956,
-0.0271915086,
-0.0044654584,
-0.0590658188,
0.0382316746,
-0.0179874413,
0.0421655476,
0.0541291796,
-0.0335381441,
0.0335998684,
0.0574401319,
-0.034002807,
0.0002972293,
0.0196956173,
-0.0095970053,
-0.0184397716,
0.0178475082,
0.0475312918,
0.0178415608,
-0.0092970207,
-0.0079197558,
0.0063705849,
-0.0198992305,
0.0142267253,
-0.0296486076,
-0.0240733381,
0.0061806021,
0.0044821533,
0.0243386514,
-0.0263598561,
0.0501795597,
0.0248240139,
0.0374721214,
-0.0888376608,
0.0269215889,
-0.0254604314,
0.0109684654,
0.0385208093,
-0.0691913515,
-0.0316701643,
0.0418010168,
0.0270259269,
0.0490505919,
-0.0581002831,
0.0001640541,
0.0245993193,
0.0133839939,
0.0775665715,
0.1208214685,
0.0469076522,
-0.0758476257,
-0.111963965,
-0.0115780132,
0.0277066417,
-0.0488043688,
0.0115857394,
-0.0351838917,
-0.0341124646,
0.0079361955,
-0.0429938063,
-0.0138962129,
-0.0309590511,
0.0155951688,
-0.0055639343,
0.0410897024,
-0.0374467075,
0.0623598509,
0.0023892946,
-0.043470677,
0.0056828712,
0.0444070324,
-0.0216687806,
0.0038237916,
0.0149383135,
0.0548941977,
-0.0826621801,
-0.032139875,
0.0148773119,
0.0076860921,
0.0075754556,
-0.0397902131,
0.0595488362,
0.0306326058,
-0.0444919877,
0.0354092382,
-0.0163336378,
0.0635050163,
-0.0152333509,
0.021920301,
0.0524048731,
-0.0189193599,
0.0018393402,
0.0045430558,
-0.0284942593,
-0.0095700491,
-0.0034575963,
0.0182737317,
-0.0296747852,
0.0401714519,
-0.0283451378,
-0.006751569,
-0.0458357483,
-0.0086717932,
-0.0235642232,
-0.0842651874,
0.0217060149,
-0.0171304215,
2.421e-7,
-0.0336395279,
0.0280896481,
0.0193183888,
0.0244167726,
0.020652933,
0.0506525636,
0.0510385595,
0.0506177433,
-0.0480785295,
-0.1024194658,
-0.0250850525,
0.0235687923,
0.0238703508,
0.0197244603,
-0.0572379194,
0.0102742659,
-0.0694969147,
-0.0104732634,
-0.0384209901,
-0.0216071866,
-0.0142352274,
0.0922777429,
0.0551161878,
-0.0297778323,
0.0220855474,
-0.0215909835,
0.0468185954,
0.0527450368,
-0.0340487324,
0.0014260048,
0.0464229137,
-0.000103353,
-0.0147397006,
0.0528634079,
-0.0442342348,
0.0049818517,
0.0058844634,
0.0281767193,
0.0204308983,
-0.0080249552,
-0.0252813864,
-0.0321421139,
0.0102001596,
-0.0372362025,
0.0704668984,
-0.0345215239,
-0.0237070695,
-0.0640846938,
-0.0507899225,
0.0035372919,
0.0369221829,
-0.0086790007,
0.0158735439,
0.0340459161,
-0.0196873229,
-0.0054840394,
0.010080697,
-0.0011327757,
0.0198699012,
-0.0088075483,
-0.0430943035,
-0.0232215561,
-0.0055770488,
-0.022383064,
0.0595491566,
-0.027331017,
0.0313721001,
1.772277335e-34,
0.0292127039,
0.0006120468,
-0.0017495936,
-0.0497419313,
0.0221574809,
0.0311091729,
-0.0198517852,
-0.0469356067,
0.0214480571,
0.0185289942,
0.0050288672
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.